id sid tid token lemma pos 40436 1 1 PLATO PLATO NNP 40436 1 2 , , , 40436 1 3 AND and CC 40436 1 4 THE the DT 40436 1 5 OTHER other JJ 40436 1 6 COMPANIONS companion NNS 40436 1 7 OF of IN 40436 1 8 SOKRATES sokrate NNS 40436 1 9 . . . 40436 2 1 PLATO PLATO NNP 40436 2 2 , , , 40436 2 3 AND and CC 40436 2 4 THE the DT 40436 2 5 OTHER other JJ 40436 2 6 COMPANIONS companion NNS 40436 2 7 OF of IN 40436 2 8 SOKRATES sokrate NNS 40436 2 9 . . . 40436 3 1 BY by IN 40436 3 2 GEORGE GEORGE NNP 40436 3 3 GROTE GROTE NNP 40436 3 4 , , , 40436 3 5 AUTHOR AUTHOR NNP 40436 3 6 OF of IN 40436 3 7 THE the DT 40436 3 8 ' ' `` 40436 3 9 HISTORY HISTORY NNP 40436 3 10 OF of IN 40436 3 11 GREECE GREECE NNP 40436 3 12 ' ' '' 40436 3 13 . . . 40436 4 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4 2 A a DT 40436 4 3 NEW NEW NNP 40436 4 4 EDITION EDITION NNP 40436 4 5 . . . 40436 4 6 _ _ NNP 40436 4 7 IN in IN 40436 4 8 FOUR four CD 40436 4 9 VOLUMES volume NNS 40436 4 10 . . . 40436 5 1 VOL VOL NNP 40436 5 2 . . . 40436 6 1 II ii CD 40436 6 2 . . . 40436 7 1 LONDON LONDON NNP 40436 7 2 : : : 40436 7 3 JOHN JOHN NNP 40436 7 4 MURRAY MURRAY NNP 40436 7 5 , , , 40436 7 6 ALBEMARLE ALBEMARLE NNP 40436 7 7 STREET STREET NNP 40436 7 8 . . . 40436 8 1 1888 1888 CD 40436 8 2 . . . 40436 9 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9 2 The the DT 40436 9 3 right right NN 40436 9 4 of of IN 40436 9 5 Translation translation NN 40436 9 6 is be VBZ 40436 9 7 reserved reserve VBN 40436 9 8 . . . 40436 9 9 _ _ NNP 40436 9 10 CONTENTS CONTENTS NNP 40436 9 11 . . . 40436 10 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 10 2 XII XII NNP 40436 10 3 . . . 40436 11 1 ALKIBIADES ALKIBIADES NNP 40436 11 2 I. I. NNP 40436 12 1 AND and CC 40436 12 2 II II NNP 40436 12 3 . . . 40436 13 1 Situation situation NN 40436 13 2 supposed suppose VBN 40436 13 3 in in IN 40436 13 4 the the DT 40436 13 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 13 6 . . . 40436 14 1 Persons person NNS 40436 14 2 -- -- : 40436 14 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 14 4 and and CC 40436 14 5 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 14 6 1 1 CD 40436 14 7 Exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 14 8 hopes hope NNS 40436 14 9 and and CC 40436 14 10 political political JJ 40436 14 11 ambition ambition NN 40436 14 12 of of IN 40436 14 13 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 14 14 2 2 CD 40436 14 15 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 14 16 put put VBN 40436 14 17 by by IN 40436 14 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 14 19 , , , 40436 14 20 in in IN 40436 14 21 reference reference NN 40436 14 22 to to IN 40436 14 23 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 14 24 in in IN 40436 14 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 14 26 intended intended JJ 40436 14 27 function function NN 40436 14 28 as as IN 40436 14 29 adviser adviser NN 40436 14 30 of of IN 40436 14 31 the the DT 40436 14 32 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 14 33 . . . 40436 15 1 What what WP 40436 15 2 does do VBZ 40436 15 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 15 4 intend intend VB 40436 15 5 to to TO 40436 15 6 advise advise VB 40436 15 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 15 8 upon upon IN 40436 15 9 ? ? . 40436 16 1 What what WP 40436 16 2 has have VBZ 40436 16 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 16 4 learnt learn VBN 40436 16 5 , , , 40436 16 6 and and CC 40436 16 7 what what WP 40436 16 8 does do VBZ 40436 16 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 16 10 know know VB 40436 16 11 ? ? . 40436 17 1 _ _ NNP 40436 17 2 ib ib UH 40436 17 3 . . . 40436 17 4 _ _ NNP 40436 17 5 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 17 6 intends intend VBZ 40436 17 7 to to TO 40436 17 8 advise advise VB 40436 17 9 the the DT 40436 17 10 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 17 11 on on IN 40436 17 12 questions question NNS 40436 17 13 of of IN 40436 17 14 war war NN 40436 17 15 and and CC 40436 17 16 peace peace NN 40436 17 17 . . . 40436 18 1 Questions question NNS 40436 18 2 of of IN 40436 18 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 18 4 thereupon thereupon RB 40436 18 5 . . . 40436 19 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 19 2 must must MD 40436 19 3 fight fight VB 40436 19 4 those those DT 40436 19 5 whom whom WP 40436 19 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 19 7 is be VBZ 40436 19 8 better well JJR 40436 19 9 to to TO 40436 19 10 fight fight VB 40436 19 11 -- -- : 40436 19 12 to to IN 40436 19 13 what what WDT 40436 19 14 standard standard NN 40436 19 15 does do VBZ 40436 19 16 better well RBR 40436 19 17 refer refer VB 40436 19 18 ? ? . 40436 20 1 To to IN 40436 20 2 just just RB 40436 20 3 and and CC 40436 20 4 unjust unjust VB 40436 20 5 3 3 CD 40436 20 6 How how WRB 40436 20 7 , , , 40436 20 8 or or CC 40436 20 9 from from IN 40436 20 10 whom whom WP 40436 20 11 , , , 40436 20 12 has have VBZ 40436 20 13 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 20 14 learnt learn VBN 40436 20 15 to to IN 40436 20 16 discern discern VB 40436 20 17 or or CC 40436 20 18 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 20 19 Just just RB 40436 20 20 and and CC 40436 20 21 Unjust unjust JJ 40436 20 22 ? ? . 40436 21 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 21 2 never never RB 40436 21 3 learnt learn VBD 40436 21 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 21 5 from from IN 40436 21 6 any any DT 40436 21 7 one one NN 40436 21 8 ; ; : 40436 21 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 21 10 always always RB 40436 21 11 knew know VBD 40436 21 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 21 13 , , , 40436 21 14 even even RB 40436 21 15 as as IN 40436 21 16 a a DT 40436 21 17 boy boy NN 40436 21 18 4 4 CD 40436 21 19 Answer Answer NNP 40436 21 20 amended amend VBN 40436 21 21 . . . 40436 22 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 22 2 learnt learn VBD 40436 22 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 22 4 from from IN 40436 22 5 the the DT 40436 22 6 multitude multitude NN 40436 22 7 , , , 40436 22 8 as as IN 40436 22 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 22 10 learnt learn VBD 40436 22 11 to to TO 40436 22 12 speak speak VB 40436 22 13 Greek.--The Greek.--The NNP 40436 22 14 multitude multitude NN 40436 22 15 can can MD 40436 22 16 not not RB 40436 22 17 teach teach VB 40436 22 18 just just RB 40436 22 19 and and CC 40436 22 20 unjust unjust JJ 40436 22 21 , , , 40436 22 22 for for IN 40436 22 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 22 24 are be VBP 40436 22 25 at at IN 40436 22 26 variance variance NN 40436 22 27 among among IN 40436 22 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 22 29 about about IN 40436 22 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 22 31 . . . 40436 23 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 23 2 is be VBZ 40436 23 3 going go VBG 40436 23 4 to to TO 40436 23 5 advise advise VB 40436 23 6 the the DT 40436 23 7 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 23 8 about about IN 40436 23 9 what what WP 40436 23 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 23 11 does do VBZ 40436 23 12 not not RB 40436 23 13 know know VB 40436 23 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 23 15 5 5 CD 40436 23 16 Answer Answer NNP 40436 23 17 farther farther RB 40436 23 18 amended amend VBN 40436 23 19 . . . 40436 24 1 The the DT 40436 24 2 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 24 3 do do VBP 40436 24 4 not not RB 40436 24 5 generally generally RB 40436 24 6 debate debate VB 40436 24 7 about about IN 40436 24 8 just just RB 40436 24 9 or or CC 40436 24 10 unjust unjust JJ 40436 24 11 -- -- : 40436 24 12 which which WDT 40436 24 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 24 14 consider consider VBP 40436 24 15 plain plain JJ 40436 24 16 to to IN 40436 24 17 every every DT 40436 24 18 one one CD 40436 24 19 -- -- : 40436 24 20 but but CC 40436 24 21 about about IN 40436 24 22 expedient expedient NN 40436 24 23 and and CC 40436 24 24 inexpedient inexpedient JJ 40436 24 25 , , , 40436 24 26 which which WDT 40436 24 27 are be VBP 40436 24 28 not not RB 40436 24 29 coincident coincident JJ 40436 24 30 with with IN 40436 24 31 just just JJ 40436 24 32 and and CC 40436 24 33 unjust unjust JJ 40436 24 34 . . . 40436 25 1 But but CC 40436 25 2 neither neither DT 40436 25 3 does do VBZ 40436 25 4 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 25 5 know know VB 40436 25 6 the the DT 40436 25 7 expedient expedient NN 40436 25 8 . . . 40436 26 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 26 2 asks ask VBZ 40436 26 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 26 4 to to TO 40436 26 5 explain explain VB 40436 26 6 . . . 40436 27 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 27 2 declines decline VBZ 40436 27 3 : : : 40436 27 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 27 5 can can MD 40436 27 6 do do VB 40436 27 7 nothing nothing NN 40436 27 8 but but IN 40436 27 9 question question VB 40436 27 10 6 6 CD 40436 27 11 Comment comment NN 40436 27 12 on on IN 40436 27 13 the the DT 40436 27 14 preceding precede VBG 40436 27 15 -- -- : 40436 27 16 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 27 17 method method NN 40436 27 18 -- -- : 40436 27 19 the the DT 40436 27 20 respondent respondent NN 40436 27 21 makes make VBZ 40436 27 22 the the DT 40436 27 23 discoveries discovery NNS 40436 27 24 for for IN 40436 27 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 27 26 _ _ NNP 40436 27 27 ib ib UH 40436 27 28 . . . 40436 27 29 _ _ NNP 40436 27 30 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 27 31 is be VBZ 40436 27 32 brought bring VBN 40436 27 33 to to TO 40436 27 34 admit admit VB 40436 27 35 that that IN 40436 27 36 whatever whatever WDT 40436 27 37 is be VBZ 40436 27 38 just just RB 40436 27 39 , , , 40436 27 40 is be VBZ 40436 27 41 good good JJ 40436 27 42 , , , 40436 27 43 honourable honourable JJ 40436 27 44 , , , 40436 27 45 expedient expedient NN 40436 27 46 : : : 40436 27 47 and and CC 40436 27 48 that that IN 40436 27 49 whoever whoever WP 40436 27 50 acts act VBZ 40436 27 51 honourably honourably RB 40436 27 52 , , , 40436 27 53 both both DT 40436 27 54 does do VBZ 40436 27 55 well well RB 40436 27 56 , , , 40436 27 57 and and CC 40436 27 58 procures procure NNS 40436 27 59 for for IN 40436 27 60 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 27 61 happiness happiness NN 40436 27 62 thereby thereby RB 40436 27 63 . . . 40436 28 1 Equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 28 2 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 28 3 of of IN 40436 28 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 28 5 7 7 CD 40436 28 6 Humiliation Humiliation NNP 40436 28 7 of of IN 40436 28 8 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 28 9 . . . 40436 29 1 Other other JJ 40436 29 2 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 29 3 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 29 4 are be VBP 40436 29 5 equally equally RB 40436 29 6 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 29 7 . . . 40436 30 1 But but CC 40436 30 2 the the DT 40436 30 3 real real JJ 40436 30 4 opponents opponent NNS 40436 30 5 , , , 40436 30 6 against against IN 40436 30 7 whom whom WP 40436 30 8 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 30 9 is be VBZ 40436 30 10 to to TO 40436 30 11 measure measure VB 40436 30 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 30 13 , , , 40436 30 14 are be VBP 40436 30 15 , , , 40436 30 16 the the DT 40436 30 17 kings king NNS 40436 30 18 of of IN 40436 30 19 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 30 20 and and CC 40436 30 21 Persia Persia NNP 40436 30 22 . . . 40436 31 1 Eulogistic eulogistic JJ 40436 31 2 description description NN 40436 31 3 of of IN 40436 31 4 those those DT 40436 31 5 kings king NNS 40436 31 6 . . . 40436 32 1 To to TO 40436 32 2 match match VB 40436 32 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 32 4 , , , 40436 32 5 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 32 6 must must MD 40436 32 7 make make VB 40436 32 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 32 9 as as RB 40436 32 10 good good JJ 40436 32 11 as as IN 40436 32 12 possible possible JJ 40436 32 13 8 8 CD 40436 32 14 But but CC 40436 32 15 good good JJ 40436 32 16 -- -- : 40436 32 17 for for IN 40436 32 18 what what WDT 40436 32 19 end end NN 40436 32 20 , , , 40436 32 21 and and CC 40436 32 22 under under IN 40436 32 23 what what WDT 40436 32 24 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 32 25 ? ? . 40436 33 1 Abundant abundant JJ 40436 33 2 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 33 3 examples example NNS 40436 33 4 9 9 CD 40436 33 5 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 33 6 , , , 40436 33 7 puzzled puzzle VBD 40436 33 8 and and CC 40436 33 9 humiliated humiliate VBD 40436 33 10 , , , 40436 33 11 confesses confess VBZ 40436 33 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 33 13 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 33 14 . . . 40436 34 1 Encouragement encouragement NN 40436 34 2 given give VBN 40436 34 3 by by IN 40436 34 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 34 5 . . . 40436 35 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 35 2 is be VBZ 40436 35 3 an an DT 40436 35 4 advantage advantage NN 40436 35 5 to to TO 40436 35 6 make make VB 40436 35 7 such such JJ 40436 35 8 discovery discovery NN 40436 35 9 in in IN 40436 35 10 youth youth NN 40436 35 11 10 10 CD 40436 35 12 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 35 13 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 35 14 -- -- : 40436 35 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 35 16 actual actual JJ 40436 35 17 effect effect NN 40436 35 18 -- -- : 40436 35 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 35 20 anticipated anticipated JJ 40436 35 21 effect effect NN 40436 35 22 -- -- : 40436 35 23 applicable applicable JJ 40436 35 24 to to IN 40436 35 25 the the DT 40436 35 26 season season NN 40436 35 27 of of IN 40436 35 28 youth youth NN 40436 35 29 11 11 CD 40436 35 30 Know know VBP 40436 35 31 Thyself thyself PRP 40436 35 32 -- -- : 40436 35 33 Delphian delphian JJ 40436 35 34 maxim maxim NN 40436 35 35 -- -- : 40436 35 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 35 37 urgent urgent JJ 40436 35 38 importance importance NN 40436 35 39 -- -- : 40436 35 40 What what WP 40436 35 41 is be VBZ 40436 35 42 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 35 43 ? ? . 40436 36 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 36 2 mind mind NN 40436 36 3 is be VBZ 40436 36 4 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 36 5 _ _ NNP 40436 36 6 ib ib UH 40436 36 7 . . . 40436 36 8 _ _ NNP 40436 36 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 36 10 can can MD 40436 36 11 not not RB 40436 36 12 know know VB 40436 36 13 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 36 14 , , , 40436 36 15 except except IN 40436 36 16 by by IN 40436 36 17 looking look VBG 40436 36 18 into into IN 40436 36 19 another another DT 40436 36 20 mind mind NN 40436 36 21 . . . 40436 37 1 Self self NN 40436 37 2 - - HYPH 40436 37 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 37 4 is be VBZ 40436 37 5 temperance temperance NN 40436 37 6 . . . 40436 38 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 38 2 and and CC 40436 38 3 Justice Justice NNP 40436 38 4 are be VBP 40436 38 5 the the DT 40436 38 6 conditions condition NNS 40436 38 7 both both DT 40436 38 8 of of IN 40436 38 9 happiness happiness NN 40436 38 10 and and CC 40436 38 11 of of IN 40436 38 12 freedom freedom NN 40436 38 13 11 11 CD 40436 38 14 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 38 15 feels feel VBZ 40436 38 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 38 17 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 38 18 to to TO 40436 38 19 be be VB 40436 38 20 free free JJ 40436 38 21 , , , 40436 38 22 and and CC 40436 38 23 declares declare VBZ 40436 38 24 that that IN 40436 38 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 38 26 will will MD 40436 38 27 never never RB 40436 38 28 quit quit VB 40436 38 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 38 30 12 12 CD 40436 38 31 Second Second NNP 40436 38 32 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 38 33 -- -- : 40436 38 34 situation situation NN 40436 38 35 supposed suppose VBN 40436 38 36 _ _ NNP 40436 38 37 ib ib UH 40436 38 38 . . . 40436 38 39 _ _ NNP 40436 38 40 Danger Danger NNP 40436 38 41 of of IN 40436 38 42 mistake mistake NN 40436 38 43 in in IN 40436 38 44 praying pray VBG 40436 38 45 to to IN 40436 38 46 the the DT 40436 38 47 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 38 48 for for IN 40436 38 49 gifts gift NNS 40436 38 50 which which WDT 40436 38 51 may may MD 40436 38 52 prove prove VB 40436 38 53 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 38 54 . . . 40436 39 1 Most Most JJS 40436 39 2 men man NNS 40436 39 3 are be VBP 40436 39 4 unwise unwise JJ 40436 39 5 . . . 40436 40 1 Unwise Unwise NNP 40436 40 2 is be VBZ 40436 40 3 the the DT 40436 40 4 generic generic JJ 40436 40 5 word word NN 40436 40 6 : : : 40436 40 7 madmen madmen NNP 40436 40 8 , , , 40436 40 9 a a DT 40436 40 10 particular particular JJ 40436 40 11 variety variety NN 40436 40 12 under under IN 40436 40 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 40 14 _ _ NNP 40436 40 15 ib ib UH 40436 40 16 . . . 40436 40 17 _ _ NNP 40436 40 18 Relation Relation NNP 40436 40 19 between between IN 40436 40 20 a a DT 40436 40 21 generic generic JJ 40436 40 22 term term NN 40436 40 23 , , , 40436 40 24 and and CC 40436 40 25 the the DT 40436 40 26 specific specific JJ 40436 40 27 terms term NNS 40436 40 28 comprehended comprehend VBD 40436 40 29 under under IN 40436 40 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 40 31 , , , 40436 40 32 was be VBD 40436 40 33 not not RB 40436 40 34 then then RB 40436 40 35 familiar familiar JJ 40436 40 36 13 13 CD 40436 40 37 Frequent frequent JJ 40436 40 38 cases case NNS 40436 40 39 , , , 40436 40 40 in in IN 40436 40 41 which which WDT 40436 40 42 men man NNS 40436 40 43 pray pray VBP 40436 40 44 for for IN 40436 40 45 supposed suppose VBN 40436 40 46 benefits benefit NNS 40436 40 47 , , , 40436 40 48 and and CC 40436 40 49 find find VB 40436 40 50 that that IN 40436 40 51 when when WRB 40436 40 52 obtained obtain VBN 40436 40 53 , , , 40436 40 54 they -PRON- PRP 40436 40 55 are be VBP 40436 40 56 misfortunes misfortune NNS 40436 40 57 . . . 40436 41 1 Every every DT 40436 41 2 one one CD 40436 41 3 fancies fancy VBZ 40436 41 4 that that WDT 40436 41 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 41 6 knows know VBZ 40436 41 7 what what WP 40436 41 8 is be VBZ 40436 41 9 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 41 10 : : : 40436 41 11 mischiefs mischiefs NNP 40436 41 12 of of IN 40436 41 13 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 41 14 14 14 CD 40436 41 15 Mistake Mistake NNP 40436 41 16 in in IN 40436 41 17 predications predication NNS 40436 41 18 about about IN 40436 41 19 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 41 20 generally generally RB 40436 41 21 . . . 40436 42 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 42 2 must must MD 40436 42 3 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 42 4 . . . 40436 43 1 Ignorance ignorance NN 40436 43 2 of of IN 40436 43 3 _ _ NNP 40436 43 4 what what WP 40436 43 5 ? ? . 40436 43 6 _ _ NNP 40436 43 7 Ignorance Ignorance NNP 40436 43 8 of of IN 40436 43 9 good good NN 40436 43 10 , , , 40436 43 11 is be VBZ 40436 43 12 always always RB 40436 43 13 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 43 14 : : : 40436 43 15 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 43 16 of of IN 40436 43 17 other other JJ 40436 43 18 things thing NNS 40436 43 19 , , , 40436 43 20 not not RB 40436 43 21 always always RB 40436 43 22 _ _ NNP 40436 43 23 ib ib UH 40436 43 24 . . . 40436 43 25 _ _ NNP 40436 43 26 Wise wise JJ 40436 43 27 public public JJ 40436 43 28 counsellors counsellor NNS 40436 43 29 are be VBP 40436 43 30 few few JJ 40436 43 31 . . . 40436 44 1 Upon upon IN 40436 44 2 what what WDT 40436 44 3 ground ground NN 40436 44 4 do do VBP 40436 44 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 44 6 call call VB 40436 44 7 these these DT 40436 44 8 few few JJ 40436 44 9 wise wise JJ 40436 44 10 ? ? . 40436 45 1 Not not RB 40436 45 2 because because IN 40436 45 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 45 4 possess possess VBP 40436 45 5 merely merely RB 40436 45 6 special special JJ 40436 45 7 arts art NNS 40436 45 8 or or CC 40436 45 9 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 45 10 , , , 40436 45 11 but but CC 40436 45 12 because because IN 40436 45 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 45 14 know know VBP 40436 45 15 besides besides RB 40436 45 16 , , , 40436 45 17 upon upon IN 40436 45 18 what what WP 40436 45 19 occasions occasion NNS 40436 45 20 and and CC 40436 45 21 under under IN 40436 45 22 what what WP 40436 45 23 limits limit VBZ 40436 45 24 each each DT 40436 45 25 of of IN 40436 45 26 these these DT 40436 45 27 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 45 28 ought ought MD 40436 45 29 to to TO 40436 45 30 be be VB 40436 45 31 used use VBN 40436 45 32 15 15 CD 40436 45 33 Special special JJ 40436 45 34 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 45 35 , , , 40436 45 36 without without IN 40436 45 37 the the DT 40436 45 38 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 45 39 of of IN 40436 45 40 the the DT 40436 45 41 good good JJ 40436 45 42 or or CC 40436 45 43 profitable profitable JJ 40436 45 44 , , , 40436 45 45 are be VBP 40436 45 46 oftener oftener RB 40436 45 47 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 45 48 than than IN 40436 45 49 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 45 50 16 16 CD 40436 45 51 It -PRON- PRP 40436 45 52 is be VBZ 40436 45 53 unsafe unsafe JJ 40436 45 54 for for IN 40436 45 55 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 45 56 to to TO 40436 45 57 proceed proceed VB 40436 45 58 with with IN 40436 45 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 45 60 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 45 61 , , , 40436 45 62 until until IN 40436 45 63 he -PRON- PRP 40436 45 64 has have VBZ 40436 45 65 learnt learn VBN 40436 45 66 what what WP 40436 45 67 is be VBZ 40436 45 68 the the DT 40436 45 69 proper proper JJ 40436 45 70 language language NN 40436 45 71 to to TO 40436 45 72 address address NN 40436 45 73 to to IN 40436 45 74 the the DT 40436 45 75 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 45 76 . . . 40436 46 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 46 2 renounces renounce VBZ 40436 46 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 46 4 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 46 5 , , , 40436 46 6 and and CC 40436 46 7 throws throw VBZ 40436 46 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 46 9 upon upon IN 40436 46 10 the the DT 40436 46 11 counsel counsel NN 40436 46 12 of of IN 40436 46 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 46 14 _ _ NNP 40436 46 15 ib ib UH 40436 46 16 . . . 40436 46 17 _ _ NNP 40436 46 18 Different different JJ 40436 46 19 critical critical JJ 40436 46 20 opinions opinion NNS 40436 46 21 respecting respect VBG 40436 46 22 these these DT 40436 46 23 two two CD 40436 46 24 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 46 25 17 17 CD 40436 46 26 Grounds Grounds NNPS 40436 46 27 for for IN 40436 46 28 disallowing disallow VBG 40436 46 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 46 30 -- -- : 40436 46 31 less less RBR 40436 46 32 strong strong JJ 40436 46 33 against against IN 40436 46 34 the the DT 40436 46 35 Second Second NNP 40436 46 36 than than IN 40436 46 37 against against IN 40436 46 38 the the DT 40436 46 39 First First NNP 40436 46 40 18 18 CD 40436 46 41 The the DT 40436 46 42 supposed suppose VBN 40436 46 43 grounds ground NNS 40436 46 44 for for IN 40436 46 45 disallowance disallowance NN 40436 46 46 are be VBP 40436 46 47 in in IN 40436 46 48 reality reality NN 40436 46 49 only only RB 40436 46 50 marks mark NNS 40436 46 51 of of IN 40436 46 52 inferiority inferiority NN 40436 46 53 _ _ NNP 40436 46 54 ib ib NNP 40436 46 55 . . . 40436 46 56 _ _ NNP 40436 46 57 The the DT 40436 46 58 two two CD 40436 46 59 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 46 60 may may MD 40436 46 61 probably probably RB 40436 46 62 be be VB 40436 46 63 among among IN 40436 46 64 Plato Plato NNP 40436 46 65 's 's POS 40436 46 66 earlier early JJR 40436 46 67 compositions composition NNS 40436 46 68 20 20 CD 40436 46 69 Analogy analogy NN 40436 46 70 with with IN 40436 46 71 various various JJ 40436 46 72 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 46 73 in in IN 40436 46 74 the the DT 40436 46 75 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 46 76 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 46 77 -- -- : 40436 46 78 Purpose purpose NN 40436 46 79 of of IN 40436 46 80 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 46 81 to to TO 40436 46 82 humble humble VB 40436 46 83 presumptuous presumptuous JJ 40436 46 84 young young JJ 40436 46 85 men man NNS 40436 46 86 21 21 CD 40436 46 87 Fitness fitness NN 40436 46 88 of of IN 40436 46 89 the the DT 40436 46 90 name name NN 40436 46 91 and and CC 40436 46 92 character character NN 40436 46 93 of of IN 40436 46 94 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 46 95 for for IN 40436 46 96 idealising idealise VBG 40436 46 97 this this DT 40436 46 98 feature feature NN 40436 46 99 in in IN 40436 46 100 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 46 101 _ _ NNP 40436 46 102 ib ib NN 40436 46 103 . . . 40436 46 104 _ _ NNP 40436 46 105 Plato Plato NNP 40436 46 106 's 's POS 40436 46 107 manner manner NN 40436 46 108 of of IN 40436 46 109 replying reply VBG 40436 46 110 to to IN 40436 46 111 the the DT 40436 46 112 accusers accuser NNS 40436 46 113 of of IN 40436 46 114 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 46 115 . . . 40436 47 1 Magical magical JJ 40436 47 2 influence influence NN 40436 47 3 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 47 4 to to IN 40436 47 5 the the DT 40436 47 6 conversation conversation NN 40436 47 7 of of IN 40436 47 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 47 9 22 22 CD 40436 47 10 The the DT 40436 47 11 purpose purpose NN 40436 47 12 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 47 13 by by IN 40436 47 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 47 15 in in IN 40436 47 16 the the DT 40436 47 17 Apology Apology NNP 40436 47 18 is be VBZ 40436 47 19 followed follow VBN 40436 47 20 out out RP 40436 47 21 in in IN 40436 47 22 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 47 23 I. i. NN 40436 48 1 Warfare warfare VB 40436 48 2 against against IN 40436 48 3 the the DT 40436 48 4 false false JJ 40436 48 5 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 48 6 of of IN 40436 48 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 48 8 24 24 CD 40436 48 9 Difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 48 10 multiplied multiply VBN 40436 48 11 for for IN 40436 48 12 the the DT 40436 48 13 purpose purpose NN 40436 48 14 of of IN 40436 48 15 bringing bring VBG 40436 48 16 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 48 17 to to IN 40436 48 18 a a DT 40436 48 19 conviction conviction NN 40436 48 20 of of IN 40436 48 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 48 22 own own JJ 40436 48 23 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 48 24 25 25 CD 40436 48 25 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 48 26 furnishes furnish VBZ 40436 48 27 no no DT 40436 48 28 means means NN 40436 48 29 of of IN 40436 48 30 solving solve VBG 40436 48 31 these these DT 40436 48 32 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 48 33 . . . 40436 49 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 49 2 exhorts exhort VBZ 40436 49 3 to to IN 40436 49 4 Justice Justice NNP 40436 49 5 and and CC 40436 49 6 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 49 7 -- -- : 40436 49 8 but but CC 40436 49 9 these these DT 40436 49 10 are be VBP 40436 49 11 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 49 12 Incognita Incognita NNP 40436 49 13 26 26 CD 40436 49 14 Prolixity Prolixity NNP 40436 49 15 of of IN 40436 49 16 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 49 17 I.--Extreme i.--extreme NN 40436 49 18 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 49 19 of of IN 40436 49 20 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 49 21 examples example NNS 40436 49 22 -- -- : 40436 49 23 How how WRB 40436 49 24 explained explain VBN 40436 49 25 _ _ NNP 40436 49 26 ib ib UH 40436 49 27 . . . 40436 49 28 _ _ NNP 40436 49 29 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 49 30 II II NNP 40436 49 31 . . . 40436 50 1 leaves leave VBZ 40436 50 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 50 3 problem problem NN 40436 50 4 avowedly avowedly RB 40436 50 5 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 50 6 27 27 CD 40436 50 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 50 8 commends commend VBZ 40436 50 9 the the DT 40436 50 10 practice practice NN 40436 50 11 of of IN 40436 50 12 praying pray VBG 40436 50 13 to to IN 40436 50 14 the the DT 40436 50 15 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 50 16 for for IN 40436 50 17 favours favour NNS 40436 50 18 undefined undefined JJ 40436 50 19 -- -- : 40436 50 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 50 21 views view NNS 40436 50 22 about about IN 40436 50 23 the the DT 40436 50 24 semi semi JJ 40436 50 25 - - JJ 40436 50 26 regular regular JJ 40436 50 27 , , , 40436 50 28 semi semi JJ 40436 50 29 - - JJ 40436 50 30 irregular irregular JJ 40436 50 31 agency agency NN 40436 50 32 of of IN 40436 50 33 the the DT 40436 50 34 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 50 35 -- -- : 40436 50 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 50 37 prays pray VBZ 40436 50 38 to to IN 40436 50 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 50 40 for for IN 40436 50 41 premonitory premonitory JJ 40436 50 42 warnings warning NNS 40436 50 43 28 28 CD 40436 50 44 Comparison Comparison NNP 40436 50 45 of of IN 40436 50 46 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 50 47 II II NNP 40436 50 48 . . . 40436 51 1 with with IN 40436 51 2 the the DT 40436 51 3 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 51 4 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 51 5 , , , 40436 51 6 especially especially RB 40436 51 7 the the DT 40436 51 8 conversation conversation NN 40436 51 9 of of IN 40436 51 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 51 11 with with IN 40436 51 12 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 51 13 . . . 40436 52 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 52 2 not not RB 40436 52 3 always always RB 40436 52 4 consistent consistent JJ 40436 52 5 with with IN 40436 52 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 52 7 29 29 CD 40436 52 8 Remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 52 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 52 10 of of IN 40436 52 11 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 52 12 II.--that II.--that NNP 40436 52 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 52 14 is be VBZ 40436 52 15 not not RB 40436 52 16 always always RB 40436 52 17 Good good JJ 40436 52 18 . . . 40436 53 1 The the DT 40436 53 2 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 53 3 of of IN 40436 53 4 Good good JJ 40436 53 5 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 53 6 is be VBZ 40436 53 7 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 53 8 : : : 40436 53 9 without without IN 40436 53 10 that that DT 40436 53 11 , , , 40436 53 12 the the DT 40436 53 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 53 14 of of IN 40436 53 15 other other JJ 40436 53 16 things thing NNS 40436 53 17 is be VBZ 40436 53 18 more more RBR 40436 53 19 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 53 20 than than IN 40436 53 21 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 53 22 _ _ NNP 40436 53 23 ib ib UH 40436 53 24 . . . 40436 53 25 _ _ NNP 40436 53 26 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 53 27 of of IN 40436 53 28 Good good JJ 40436 53 29 -- -- : 40436 53 30 appears appear VBZ 40436 53 31 postulated postulate VBN 40436 53 32 and and CC 40436 53 33 divined divine VBN 40436 53 34 , , , 40436 53 35 in in IN 40436 53 36 many many JJ 40436 53 37 of of IN 40436 53 38 the the DT 40436 53 39 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 53 40 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 53 41 , , , 40436 53 42 under under IN 40436 53 43 different different JJ 40436 53 44 titles title NNS 40436 53 45 31 31 CD 40436 53 46 The the DT 40436 53 47 Good good JJ 40436 53 48 -- -- : 40436 53 49 the the DT 40436 53 50 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 53 51 -- -- : 40436 53 52 what what WP 40436 53 53 is be VBZ 40436 53 54 it?--How it?--how ADD 40436 53 55 are be VBP 40436 53 56 we -PRON- PRP 40436 53 57 to to TO 40436 53 58 know know VB 40436 53 59 it -PRON- PRP 40436 53 60 ? ? . 40436 54 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 54 2 leaves leave VBZ 40436 54 3 this this DT 40436 54 4 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 54 5 _ _ NNP 40436 54 6 ib ib UH 40436 54 7 . . . 40436 54 8 _ _ NNP 40436 54 9 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 54 10 XIII XIII NNP 40436 54 11 . . . 40436 55 1 HIPPIAS HIPPIAS NNP 40436 55 2 MAJOR MAJOR NNP 40436 55 3 -- -- : 40436 55 4 HIPPIAS HIPPIAS NNP 40436 55 5 MINOR MINOR NNP 40436 55 6 . . . 40436 56 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 56 2 Major major JJ 40436 56 3 -- -- : 40436 56 4 situation situation NN 40436 56 5 supposed suppose VBN 40436 56 6 -- -- : 40436 56 7 character character NN 40436 56 8 of of IN 40436 56 9 the the DT 40436 56 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 56 11 . . . 40436 57 1 Sarcasm sarcasm JJ 40436 57 2 and and CC 40436 57 3 mockery mockery NN 40436 57 4 against against IN 40436 57 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 57 6 33 33 CD 40436 57 7 Real real JJ 40436 57 8 debate debate NN 40436 57 9 between between IN 40436 57 10 the the DT 40436 57 11 historical historical JJ 40436 57 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 57 13 and and CC 40436 57 14 Hippias Hippias NNPS 40436 57 15 in in IN 40436 57 16 the the DT 40436 57 17 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 57 18 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 57 19 -- -- : 40436 57 20 subject subject JJ 40436 57 21 of of IN 40436 57 22 that that DT 40436 57 23 debate debate NN 40436 57 24 34 34 CD 40436 57 25 Opening opening NN 40436 57 26 of of IN 40436 57 27 the the DT 40436 57 28 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 57 29 Major**--Hippias Major**--Hippias NNP 40436 57 30 describes describe VBZ 40436 57 31 the the DT 40436 57 32 successful successful JJ 40436 57 33 circuit circuit NN 40436 57 34 which which WDT 40436 57 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 57 36 had have VBD 40436 57 37 made make VBN 40436 57 38 through through IN 40436 57 39 Greece Greece NNP 40436 57 40 , , , 40436 57 41 and and CC 40436 57 42 the the DT 40436 57 43 renown renown NN 40436 57 44 as as RB 40436 57 45 well well RB 40436 57 46 as as IN 40436 57 47 the the DT 40436 57 48 gain gain NN 40436 57 49 acquired acquire VBN 40436 57 50 by by IN 40436 57 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 57 52 lectures lecture NNS 40436 57 53 35 35 CD 40436 57 54 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 57 55 had have VBD 40436 57 56 met meet VBN 40436 57 57 with with IN 40436 57 58 no no DT 40436 57 59 success success NN 40436 57 60 at at IN 40436 57 61 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 57 62 . . . 40436 58 1 Why why WRB 40436 58 2 the the DT 40436 58 3 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 58 4 did do VBD 40436 58 5 not not RB 40436 58 6 admit admit VB 40436 58 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 58 8 instructions instruction NNS 40436 58 9 -- -- : 40436 58 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 58 11 law law NN 40436 58 12 forbids forbid NNS 40436 58 13 _ _ NNP 40436 58 14 ib ib NNP 40436 58 15 . . . 40436 58 16 _ _ NNP 40436 58 17 Question Question NNP 40436 58 18 , , , 40436 58 19 What what WP 40436 58 20 is be VBZ 40436 58 21 law law NN 40436 58 22 ? ? . 40436 59 1 The the DT 40436 59 2 law law NN 40436 59 3 - - HYPH 40436 59 4 makers maker NNS 40436 59 5 always always RB 40436 59 6 aim aim VBP 40436 59 7 at at IN 40436 59 8 the the DT 40436 59 9 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 59 10 , , , 40436 59 11 but but CC 40436 59 12 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 59 13 fail fail VB 40436 59 14 to to TO 40436 59 15 attain attain VB 40436 59 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 59 17 . . . 40436 60 1 When when WRB 40436 60 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 60 3 fail fail VBP 40436 60 4 , , , 40436 60 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 60 6 fail fail VBP 40436 60 7 to to TO 40436 60 8 attain attain VB 40436 60 9 law law NN 40436 60 10 . . . 40436 61 1 The the DT 40436 61 2 lawful lawful JJ 40436 61 3 is be VBZ 40436 61 4 the the DT 40436 61 5 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 61 6 : : : 40436 61 7 the the DT 40436 61 8 Unprofitable Unprofitable NNP 40436 61 9 is be VBZ 40436 61 10 also also RB 40436 61 11 unlawful unlawful JJ 40436 61 12 36 36 CD 40436 61 13 Comparison comparison NN 40436 61 14 of of IN 40436 61 15 the the DT 40436 61 16 argument argument NN 40436 61 17 of of IN 40436 61 18 the the DT 40436 61 19 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 61 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 61 21 with with IN 40436 61 22 that that DT 40436 61 23 of of IN 40436 61 24 the the DT 40436 61 25 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 61 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 61 27 37 37 CD 40436 61 28 The the DT 40436 61 29 Just just JJ 40436 61 30 or or CC 40436 61 31 Good good JJ 40436 61 32 is be VBZ 40436 61 33 the the DT 40436 61 34 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 61 35 or or CC 40436 61 36 profitable profitable JJ 40436 61 37 . . . 40436 62 1 This this DT 40436 62 2 is be VBZ 40436 62 3 the the DT 40436 62 4 only only JJ 40436 62 5 explanation explanation NN 40436 62 6 which which WDT 40436 62 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 62 8 ever ever RB 40436 62 9 gives give VBZ 40436 62 10 and and CC 40436 62 11 to to IN 40436 62 12 this this DT 40436 62 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 62 14 does do VBZ 40436 62 15 not not RB 40436 62 16 always always RB 40436 62 17 adhere adhere VB 40436 62 18 38 38 CD 40436 62 19 Lectures lecture NNS 40436 62 20 of of IN 40436 62 21 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 62 22 at at IN 40436 62 23 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 62 24 not not RB 40436 62 25 upon upon IN 40436 62 26 geometry geometry NN 40436 62 27 , , , 40436 62 28 or or CC 40436 62 29 astronomy astronomy NNP 40436 62 30 , , , 40436 62 31 & & CC 40436 62 32 c. c. NNP 40436 62 33 , , , 40436 62 34 but but CC 40436 62 35 upon upon IN 40436 62 36 the the DT 40436 62 37 question question NN 40436 62 38 -- -- : 40436 62 39 What what WDT 40436 62 40 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 62 41 are be VBP 40436 62 42 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 62 43 , , , 40436 62 44 fine fine JJ 40436 62 45 , , , 40436 62 46 and and CC 40436 62 47 honourable honourable JJ 40436 62 48 for for IN 40436 62 49 youth youth NN 40436 62 50 ? ? . 40436 63 1 39 39 CD 40436 63 2 Question question NN 40436 63 3 put put VBN 40436 63 4 by by IN 40436 63 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 63 6 , , , 40436 63 7 in in IN 40436 63 8 the the DT 40436 63 9 name name NN 40436 63 10 of of IN 40436 63 11 a a DT 40436 63 12 friend friend NN 40436 63 13 in in IN 40436 63 14 the the DT 40436 63 15 background background NN 40436 63 16 , , , 40436 63 17 who who WP 40436 63 18 has have VBZ 40436 63 19 just just RB 40436 63 20 been be VBN 40436 63 21 puzzling puzzle VBG 40436 63 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 63 23 with with IN 40436 63 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 63 25 -- -- : 40436 63 26 What what WP 40436 63 27 is be VBZ 40436 63 28 the the DT 40436 63 29 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 63 30 ? ? . 40436 64 1 _ _ NNP 40436 64 2 ib ib UH 40436 64 3 . . . 40436 64 4 _ _ NNP 40436 64 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 64 6 thinks think VBZ 40436 64 7 the the DT 40436 64 8 question question NN 40436 64 9 easy easy JJ 40436 64 10 to to TO 40436 64 11 answer answer VB 40436 64 12 40 40 CD 40436 64 13 Justice Justice NNP 40436 64 14 , , , 40436 64 15 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 40436 64 16 , , , 40436 64 17 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 64 18 must must MD 40436 64 19 each each DT 40436 64 20 be be VB 40436 64 21 something something NN 40436 64 22 . . . 40436 65 1 What what WP 40436 65 2 is be VBZ 40436 65 3 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 65 4 , , , 40436 65 5 or or CC 40436 65 6 the the DT 40436 65 7 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 65 8 ? ? . 40436 66 1 _ _ NNP 40436 66 2 ib ib UH 40436 66 3 . . . 40436 66 4 _ _ NNP 40436 66 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 66 6 does do VBZ 40436 66 7 not not RB 40436 66 8 understand understand VB 40436 66 9 the the DT 40436 66 10 question question NN 40436 66 11 . . . 40436 67 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 67 2 answers answer VBZ 40436 67 3 by by IN 40436 67 4 indicating indicate VBG 40436 67 5 one one CD 40436 67 6 particularly particularly RB 40436 67 7 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 67 8 object object NN 40436 67 9 _ _ NNP 40436 67 10 ib ib UH 40436 67 11 . . . 40436 67 12 _ _ NNP 40436 67 13 Cross Cross NNP 40436 67 14 - - HYPH 40436 67 15 questioning questioning NN 40436 67 16 by by IN 40436 67 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 67 18 -- -- : 40436 67 19 Other other JJ 40436 67 20 things thing NNS 40436 67 21 also also RB 40436 67 22 are be VBP 40436 67 23 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 67 24 ; ; : 40436 67 25 but but CC 40436 67 26 each each DT 40436 67 27 thing thing NN 40436 67 28 is be VBZ 40436 67 29 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 67 30 only only RB 40436 67 31 by by IN 40436 67 32 comparison comparison NN 40436 67 33 , , , 40436 67 34 or or CC 40436 67 35 under under IN 40436 67 36 some some DT 40436 67 37 particular particular JJ 40436 67 38 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 67 39 -- -- : 40436 67 40 it -PRON- PRP 40436 67 41 is be VBZ 40436 67 42 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 67 43 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 67 44 , , , 40436 67 45 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 67 46 not not RB 40436 67 47 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 67 48 41 41 CD 40436 67 49 Second second JJ 40436 67 50 answer answer NN 40436 67 51 of of IN 40436 67 52 Hippias-- hippias-- NN 40436 67 53 _ _ NNP 40436 67 54 Gold Gold NNP 40436 67 55 _ _ NNP 40436 67 56 , , , 40436 67 57 is be VBZ 40436 67 58 that that IN 40436 67 59 by by IN 40436 67 60 the the DT 40436 67 61 presence presence NN 40436 67 62 of of IN 40436 67 63 which which WDT 40436 67 64 all all DT 40436 67 65 things thing NNS 40436 67 66 become become VBP 40436 67 67 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 67 68 -- -- : 40436 67 69 scrutiny scrutiny NN 40436 67 70 applied apply VBN 40436 67 71 to to IN 40436 67 72 the the DT 40436 67 73 answer answer NN 40436 67 74 . . . 40436 68 1 Complaint complaint NN 40436 68 2 by by IN 40436 68 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 68 4 about about IN 40436 68 5 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 68 6 analogies analogy NNS 40436 68 7 _ _ NNP 40436 68 8 ib ib UH 40436 68 9 . . . 40436 68 10 _ _ NNP 40436 68 11 Third third JJ 40436 68 12 answer answer NN 40436 68 13 of of IN 40436 68 14 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 68 15 -- -- : 40436 68 16 questions question NNS 40436 68 17 upon upon IN 40436 68 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 68 19 -- -- : 40436 68 20 proof proof NN 40436 68 21 given give VBN 40436 68 22 that that IN 40436 68 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 68 24 fails fail VBZ 40436 68 25 of of IN 40436 68 26 universal universal JJ 40436 68 27 application application NN 40436 68 28 42 42 CD 40436 68 29 Farther Farther NNP 40436 68 30 answers answer NNS 40436 68 31 , , , 40436 68 32 suggested suggest VBN 40436 68 33 by by IN 40436 68 34 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 68 35 himself--1 himself--1 NNP 40436 68 36 . . . 40436 69 1 The the DT 40436 69 2 Suitable suitable JJ 40436 69 3 or or CC 40436 69 4 Becoming become VBG 40436 69 5 -- -- : 40436 69 6 objections objection NNS 40436 69 7 thereunto thereunto NNS 40436 69 8 -- -- : 40436 69 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 69 10 is be VBZ 40436 69 11 rejected reject VBN 40436 69 12 43 43 CD 40436 69 13 2 2 CD 40436 69 14 . . . 40436 70 1 The the DT 40436 70 2 useful useful JJ 40436 70 3 or or CC 40436 70 4 profitable profitable JJ 40436 70 5 -- -- : 40436 70 6 objections objection NNS 40436 70 7 -- -- : 40436 70 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 70 9 will will MD 40436 70 10 not not RB 40436 70 11 hold hold VB 40436 70 12 44 44 CD 40436 70 13 3 3 CD 40436 70 14 . . . 40436 71 1 The the DT 40436 71 2 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 71 3 is be VBZ 40436 71 4 a a DT 40436 71 5 variety variety NN 40436 71 6 of of IN 40436 71 7 the the DT 40436 71 8 Pleasurable Pleasurable NNP 40436 71 9 -- -- : 40436 71 10 that that IN 40436 71 11 which which WDT 40436 71 12 is be VBZ 40436 71 13 received receive VBN 40436 71 14 through through IN 40436 71 15 the the DT 40436 71 16 eye eye NN 40436 71 17 and and CC 40436 71 18 the the DT 40436 71 19 ear ear NN 40436 71 20 45 45 CD 40436 71 21 Objections objection NNS 40436 71 22 to to IN 40436 71 23 this this DT 40436 71 24 last last JJ 40436 71 25 -- -- : 40436 71 26 What what WDT 40436 71 27 property property NN 40436 71 28 is be VBZ 40436 71 29 there there RB 40436 71 30 common common JJ 40436 71 31 to to IN 40436 71 32 both both DT 40436 71 33 sight sight NN 40436 71 34 and and CC 40436 71 35 hearing hearing NN 40436 71 36 , , , 40436 71 37 which which WDT 40436 71 38 confers confer VBZ 40436 71 39 upon upon IN 40436 71 40 the the DT 40436 71 41 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 71 42 of of IN 40436 71 43 these these DT 40436 71 44 two two CD 40436 71 45 senses sense NNS 40436 71 46 the the DT 40436 71 47 exclusive exclusive JJ 40436 71 48 privilege privilege NN 40436 71 49 of of IN 40436 71 50 being be VBG 40436 71 51 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 71 52 ? ? . 40436 72 1 _ _ NNP 40436 72 2 ib ib UH 40436 72 3 . . . 40436 72 4 _ _ NNP 40436 72 5 Answer Answer NNP 40436 72 6 -- -- . 40436 72 7 There there EX 40436 72 8 is be VBZ 40436 72 9 , , , 40436 72 10 belonging belong VBG 40436 72 11 to to IN 40436 72 12 each each DT 40436 72 13 and and CC 40436 72 14 to to IN 40436 72 15 both both DT 40436 72 16 in in IN 40436 72 17 common common JJ 40436 72 18 , , , 40436 72 19 the the DT 40436 72 20 property property NN 40436 72 21 of of IN 40436 72 22 being be VBG 40436 72 23 innocuous innocuous JJ 40436 72 24 and and CC 40436 72 25 profitable profitable JJ 40436 72 26 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 72 27 -- -- : 40436 72 28 upon upon IN 40436 72 29 this this DT 40436 72 30 ground ground NN 40436 72 31 they -PRON- PRP 40436 72 32 are be VBP 40436 72 33 called call VBN 40436 72 34 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 72 35 46 46 CD 40436 72 36 This this DT 40436 72 37 will will MD 40436 72 38 not not RB 40436 72 39 hold hold VB 40436 72 40 -- -- : 40436 72 41 the the DT 40436 72 42 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 72 43 is be VBZ 40436 72 44 the the DT 40436 72 45 cause cause NN 40436 72 46 of of IN 40436 72 47 Good Good NNP 40436 72 48 , , , 40436 72 49 and and CC 40436 72 50 is be VBZ 40436 72 51 therefore therefore RB 40436 72 52 different different JJ 40436 72 53 from from IN 40436 72 54 Good Good NNP 40436 72 55 -- -- : 40436 72 56 to to TO 40436 72 57 say say VB 40436 72 58 that that IN 40436 72 59 the the DT 40436 72 60 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 72 61 is be VBZ 40436 72 62 the the DT 40436 72 63 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 72 64 , , , 40436 72 65 is be VBZ 40436 72 66 to to TO 40436 72 67 say say VB 40436 72 68 that that IN 40436 72 69 it -PRON- PRP 40436 72 70 is be VBZ 40436 72 71 different different JJ 40436 72 72 from from IN 40436 72 73 Good Good NNP 40436 72 74 but but CC 40436 72 75 this this DT 40436 72 76 has have VBZ 40436 72 77 been be VBN 40436 72 78 already already RB 40436 72 79 declared declare VBN 40436 72 80 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 72 81 _ _ NNP 40436 72 82 ib ib NN 40436 72 83 . . . 40436 72 84 _ _ NNP 40436 72 85 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 72 86 upon upon IN 40436 72 87 the the DT 40436 72 88 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 72 89 -- -- : 40436 72 90 the the DT 40436 72 91 explanations explanation NNS 40436 72 92 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 72 93 to to IN 40436 72 94 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 72 95 are be VBP 40436 72 96 special special JJ 40436 72 97 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 72 98 examples example NNS 40436 72 99 : : : 40436 72 100 those those DT 40436 72 101 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 72 102 to to IN 40436 72 103 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 72 104 are be VBP 40436 72 105 attempts attempt NNS 40436 72 106 to to TO 40436 72 107 assign assign VB 40436 72 108 some some DT 40436 72 109 general general JJ 40436 72 110 concept concept NN 40436 72 111 47 47 CD 40436 72 112 Analogy analogy NN 40436 72 113 between between IN 40436 72 114 the the DT 40436 72 115 explanations explanation NNS 40436 72 116 here here RB 40436 72 117 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 72 118 to to IN 40436 72 119 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 72 120 , , , 40436 72 121 and and CC 40436 72 122 those those DT 40436 72 123 given give VBN 40436 72 124 by by IN 40436 72 125 the the DT 40436 72 126 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 72 127 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 72 128 in in IN 40436 72 129 the the DT 40436 72 130 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 72 131 49 49 CD 40436 72 132 Concluding Concluding NNP 40436 72 133 thrust thrust VBD 40436 72 134 exchanged exchange VBD 40436 72 135 between between IN 40436 72 136 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 72 137 and and CC 40436 72 138 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 72 139 51 51 CD 40436 72 140 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 72 141 against against IN 40436 72 142 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 72 143 52 52 CD 40436 72 144 Men Men NNPS 40436 72 145 who who WP 40436 72 146 dealt deal VBD 40436 72 147 with with IN 40436 72 148 real real JJ 40436 72 149 life life NN 40436 72 150 , , , 40436 72 151 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 72 152 with with IN 40436 72 153 the the DT 40436 72 154 speculative speculative JJ 40436 72 155 and and CC 40436 72 156 analytical analytical JJ 40436 72 157 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 72 158 _ _ NNP 40436 72 159 ib ib NN 40436 72 160 . . . 40436 72 161 _ _ NNP 40436 72 162 Concrete Concrete NNP 40436 72 163 Aggregates Aggregates NNP 40436 72 164 -- -- : 40436 72 165 abstract abstract JJ 40436 72 166 or or CC 40436 72 167 logical logical JJ 40436 72 168 Aggregates Aggregates NNPS 40436 72 169 . . . 40436 73 1 Distinct distinct JJ 40436 73 2 aptitudes aptitude NNS 40436 73 3 required require VBN 40436 73 4 by by IN 40436 73 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 73 6 for for IN 40436 73 7 the the DT 40436 73 8 Dialectician dialectician JJ 40436 73 9 53 53 CD 40436 73 10 Antithesis Antithesis NNP 40436 73 11 of of IN 40436 73 12 Absolute Absolute NNP 40436 73 13 and and CC 40436 73 14 Relative Relative NNP 40436 73 15 , , , 40436 73 16 here here RB 40436 73 17 brought bring VBD 40436 73 18 into into IN 40436 73 19 debate debate NN 40436 73 20 by by IN 40436 73 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 73 22 , , , 40436 73 23 in in IN 40436 73 24 regard regard NN 40436 73 25 to to IN 40436 73 26 the the DT 40436 73 27 Idea Idea NNP 40436 73 28 of of IN 40436 73 29 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 73 30 54 54 CD 40436 73 31 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 73 32 Minor minor JJ 40436 73 33 -- -- : 40436 73 34 characters character NNS 40436 73 35 and and CC 40436 73 36 situation situation NN 40436 73 37 supposed suppose VBD 40436 73 38 55 55 CD 40436 73 39 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 73 40 has have VBZ 40436 73 41 just just RB 40436 73 42 delivered deliver VBN 40436 73 43 a a DT 40436 73 44 lecture lecture NN 40436 73 45 , , , 40436 73 46 in in IN 40436 73 47 which which WDT 40436 73 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 73 49 extols extol VBZ 40436 73 50 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 73 51 as as RB 40436 73 52 better well JJR 40436 73 53 than than IN 40436 73 54 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 73 55 -- -- : 40436 73 56 the the DT 40436 73 57 veracious veracious JJ 40436 73 58 and and CC 40436 73 59 straightforward straightforward JJ 40436 73 60 hero hero NN 40436 73 61 better well RBR 40436 73 62 than than IN 40436 73 63 the the DT 40436 73 64 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 73 65 and and CC 40436 73 66 crafty crafty JJ 40436 73 67 56 56 CD 40436 73 68 This this DT 40436 73 69 is be VBZ 40436 73 70 contested contest VBN 40436 73 71 by by IN 40436 73 72 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 73 73 . . . 40436 74 1 The the DT 40436 74 2 veracious veracious JJ 40436 74 3 man man NN 40436 74 4 and and CC 40436 74 5 the the DT 40436 74 6 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 74 7 man man NN 40436 74 8 are be VBP 40436 74 9 one one CD 40436 74 10 and and CC 40436 74 11 the the DT 40436 74 12 same same JJ 40436 74 13 -- -- : 40436 74 14 the the DT 40436 74 15 only only JJ 40436 74 16 man man NN 40436 74 17 who who WP 40436 74 18 can can MD 40436 74 19 answer answer VB 40436 74 20 truly truly RB 40436 74 21 if if IN 40436 74 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 74 23 chooses choose VBZ 40436 74 24 , , , 40436 74 25 is be VBZ 40436 74 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 74 27 who who WP 40436 74 28 can can MD 40436 74 29 also also RB 40436 74 30 answer answer VB 40436 74 31 falsely falsely RB 40436 74 32 if if IN 40436 74 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 74 34 chooses choose VBZ 40436 74 35 , , , 40436 74 36 _ _ NNP 40436 74 37 i. i. NNP 40436 75 1 e. e. NNP 40436 75 2 _ _ NNP 40436 75 3 the the DT 40436 75 4 knowing know VBG 40436 75 5 man man NN 40436 75 6 -- -- : 40436 75 7 the the DT 40436 75 8 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 75 9 man man NN 40436 75 10 can can MD 40436 75 11 not not RB 40436 75 12 make make VB 40436 75 13 sure sure JJ 40436 75 14 of of IN 40436 75 15 doing do VBG 40436 75 16 either either CC 40436 75 17 the the DT 40436 75 18 one one CD 40436 75 19 or or CC 40436 75 20 the the DT 40436 75 21 other other JJ 40436 75 22 57 57 CD 40436 75 23 Analogy analogy NN 40436 75 24 of of IN 40436 75 25 special special JJ 40436 75 26 arts art NNS 40436 75 27 -- -- : 40436 75 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 75 29 is be VBZ 40436 75 30 only only RB 40436 75 31 the the DT 40436 75 32 arithmetician arithmetician NN 40436 75 33 who who WP 40436 75 34 can can MD 40436 75 35 speak speak VB 40436 75 36 falsely falsely RB 40436 75 37 on on IN 40436 75 38 a a DT 40436 75 39 question question NN 40436 75 40 of of IN 40436 75 41 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 75 42 when when WRB 40436 75 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 75 44 chooses choose VBZ 40436 75 45 _ _ NNP 40436 75 46 ib ib NNP 40436 75 47 . . . 40436 75 48 _ _ NNP 40436 75 49 View View NNP 40436 75 50 of of IN 40436 75 51 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 75 52 respecting respect VBG 40436 75 53 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 75 54 in in IN 40436 75 55 the the DT 40436 75 56 Iliad Iliad NNP 40436 75 57 . . . 40436 76 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 76 2 thinks think VBZ 40436 76 3 that that IN 40436 76 4 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 76 5 speaks speak VBZ 40436 76 6 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 76 7 cleverly cleverly RB 40436 76 8 . . . 40436 77 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 77 2 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 77 3 that that IN 40436 77 4 if if IN 40436 77 5 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 77 6 ever ever RB 40436 77 7 speaks speak VBZ 40436 77 8 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 77 9 , , , 40436 77 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 77 11 is be VBZ 40436 77 12 with with IN 40436 77 13 an an DT 40436 77 14 innocent innocent JJ 40436 77 15 purpose purpose NN 40436 77 16 , , , 40436 77 17 whereas whereas IN 40436 77 18 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 77 19 does do VBZ 40436 77 20 the the DT 40436 77 21 like like VB 40436 77 22 with with IN 40436 77 23 fraudulent fraudulent JJ 40436 77 24 purpose purpose NN 40436 77 25 58 58 CD 40436 77 26 Issue issue NN 40436 77 27 here here RB 40436 77 28 taken take VBN 40436 77 29 -- -- : 40436 77 30 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 77 31 contends contend VBZ 40436 77 32 that that IN 40436 77 33 those those DT 40436 77 34 who who WP 40436 77 35 hurt hurt VBP 40436 77 36 , , , 40436 77 37 or or CC 40436 77 38 cheat cheat VB 40436 77 39 , , , 40436 77 40 or or CC 40436 77 41 lie lie NN 40436 77 42 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 77 43 , , , 40436 77 44 are be VBP 40436 77 45 better well JJR 40436 77 46 than than IN 40436 77 47 those those DT 40436 77 48 who who WP 40436 77 49 do do VBP 40436 77 50 the the DT 40436 77 51 like like UH 40436 77 52 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 77 53 -- -- : 40436 77 54 he -PRON- PRP 40436 77 55 entreats entreat VBZ 40436 77 56 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 77 57 to to TO 40436 77 58 enlighten enlighten VB 40436 77 59 him -PRON- PRP 40436 77 60 and and CC 40436 77 61 answer answer VB 40436 77 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 77 63 questions question NNS 40436 77 64 _ _ IN 40436 77 65 ib ib UH 40436 77 66 . . . 40436 77 67 _ _ NNP 40436 77 68 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 77 69 of of IN 40436 77 70 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 77 71 -- -- : 40436 77 72 multiplied multiply VBN 40436 77 73 analogies analogy NNS 40436 77 74 of of IN 40436 77 75 the the DT 40436 77 76 special special JJ 40436 77 77 arts art NNS 40436 77 78 . . . 40436 78 1 The the DT 40436 78 2 unskilful unskilful JJ 40436 78 3 artist artist NN 40436 78 4 , , , 40436 78 5 who who WP 40436 78 6 runs run VBZ 40436 78 7 , , , 40436 78 8 wrestles wrestle NNS 40436 78 9 , , , 40436 78 10 or or CC 40436 78 11 sings sing VBZ 40436 78 12 badly badly RB 40436 78 13 , , , 40436 78 14 whether whether IN 40436 78 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 78 16 will will MD 40436 78 17 or or CC 40436 78 18 not not RB 40436 78 19 , , , 40436 78 20 is be VBZ 40436 78 21 worse bad JJR 40436 78 22 than than IN 40436 78 23 the the DT 40436 78 24 skilful skilful JJ 40436 78 25 , , , 40436 78 26 who who WP 40436 78 27 can can MD 40436 78 28 sing sing VB 40436 78 29 well well RB 40436 78 30 when when WRB 40436 78 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 78 32 chooses choose VBZ 40436 78 33 , , , 40436 78 34 but but CC 40436 78 35 can can MD 40436 78 36 also also RB 40436 78 37 sing sing VB 40436 78 38 badly badly RB 40436 78 39 when when WRB 40436 78 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 78 41 chooses choose VBZ 40436 78 42 59 59 CD 40436 78 43 It -PRON- PRP 40436 78 44 is be VBZ 40436 78 45 better well JJR 40436 78 46 to to TO 40436 78 47 have have VB 40436 78 48 the the DT 40436 78 49 mind mind NN 40436 78 50 of of IN 40436 78 51 a a DT 40436 78 52 bowman bowman NN 40436 78 53 who who WP 40436 78 54 misses miss VBZ 40436 78 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 78 56 mark mark NN 40436 78 57 only only RB 40436 78 58 by by IN 40436 78 59 design design NN 40436 78 60 , , , 40436 78 61 than than IN 40436 78 62 that that DT 40436 78 63 of of IN 40436 78 64 one one NN 40436 78 65 who who WP 40436 78 66 misses miss VBZ 40436 78 67 even even RB 40436 78 68 when when WRB 40436 78 69 he -PRON- PRP 40436 78 70 intends intend VBZ 40436 78 71 to to TO 40436 78 72 hit hit VB 40436 78 73 60 60 CD 40436 78 74 Dissent Dissent NNP 40436 78 75 and and CC 40436 78 76 repugnance repugnance NN 40436 78 77 of of IN 40436 78 78 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 78 79 _ _ NNP 40436 78 80 ib ib UH 40436 78 81 . . . 40436 78 82 _ _ NNP 40436 78 83 Conclusion Conclusion NNP 40436 78 84 -- -- : 40436 78 85 That that IN 40436 78 86 none none NN 40436 78 87 but but CC 40436 78 88 the the DT 40436 78 89 good good JJ 40436 78 90 man man NN 40436 78 91 can can MD 40436 78 92 do do VB 40436 78 93 evil evil NN 40436 78 94 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 78 95 : : : 40436 78 96 the the DT 40436 78 97 bad bad JJ 40436 78 98 man man NN 40436 78 99 does do VBZ 40436 78 100 evil evil NN 40436 78 101 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 78 102 . . . 40436 79 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 79 2 can can MD 40436 79 3 not not RB 40436 79 4 resist resist VB 40436 79 5 the the DT 40436 79 6 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 79 7 , , , 40436 79 8 but but CC 40436 79 9 will will MD 40436 79 10 not not RB 40436 79 11 accept accept VB 40436 79 12 the the DT 40436 79 13 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 79 14 -- -- : 40436 79 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 79 16 confesses confess VBZ 40436 79 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 79 18 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 79 19 61 61 CD 40436 79 20 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 79 21 on on IN 40436 79 22 the the DT 40436 79 23 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 79 24 . . . 40436 80 1 If if IN 40436 80 2 the the DT 40436 80 3 parts part NNS 40436 80 4 had have VBD 40436 80 5 been be VBN 40436 80 6 inverted invert VBN 40436 80 7 , , , 40436 80 8 the the DT 40436 80 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 80 10 would would MD 40436 80 11 have have VB 40436 80 12 been be VBN 40436 80 13 cited cite VBN 40436 80 14 by by IN 40436 80 15 critics critic NNS 40436 80 16 as as IN 40436 80 17 a a DT 40436 80 18 specimen speciman NNS 40436 80 19 of of IN 40436 80 20 the the DT 40436 80 21 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 80 22 and and CC 40436 80 23 corruption corruption NN 40436 80 24 of of IN 40436 80 25 the the DT 40436 80 26 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 80 27 62 62 CD 40436 80 28 Polemical polemical JJ 40436 80 29 purpose purpose NN 40436 80 30 of of IN 40436 80 31 the the DT 40436 80 32 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 80 33 -- -- : 40436 80 34 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 80 35 humiliated humiliate VBN 40436 80 36 by by IN 40436 80 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 80 38 63 63 CD 40436 80 39 Philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 80 40 purpose purpose NN 40436 80 41 of of IN 40436 80 42 the the DT 40436 80 43 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 80 44 -- -- : 40436 80 45 theory theory NN 40436 80 46 of of IN 40436 80 47 the the DT 40436 80 48 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 80 49 of of IN 40436 80 50 Search Search NNP 40436 80 51 generally generally RB 40436 80 52 , , , 40436 80 53 and and CC 40436 80 54 of of IN 40436 80 55 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 40436 80 56 as as IN 40436 80 57 understood understand VBN 40436 80 58 by by IN 40436 80 59 Plato Plato NNP 40436 80 60 _ _ NNP 40436 80 61 ib ib NN 40436 80 62 . . . 40436 80 63 _ _ NNP 40436 80 64 The the DT 40436 80 65 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 80 66 is be VBZ 40436 80 67 an an DT 40436 80 68 exemplification exemplification NN 40436 80 69 of of IN 40436 80 70 this this DT 40436 80 71 theory theory NN 40436 80 72 -- -- : 40436 80 73 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 80 74 sets set VBZ 40436 80 75 forth forth RB 40436 80 76 a a DT 40436 80 77 case case NN 40436 80 78 of of IN 40436 80 79 confusion confusion NN 40436 80 80 , , , 40436 80 81 and and CC 40436 80 82 avows avow VBZ 40436 80 83 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 80 84 inability inability NN 40436 80 85 to to TO 40436 80 86 clear clear VB 40436 80 87 it -PRON- PRP 40436 80 88 up up RP 40436 80 89 . . . 40436 81 1 Confusion confusion NN 40436 81 2 shown show VBN 40436 81 3 up up RP 40436 81 4 in in IN 40436 81 5 the the DT 40436 81 6 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 81 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 81 8 -- -- : 40436 81 9 Error error NN 40436 81 10 in in IN 40436 81 11 the the DT 40436 81 12 Greater Greater NNP 40436 81 13 64 64 CD 40436 81 14 The the DT 40436 81 15 thesis thesis NN 40436 81 16 maintained maintain VBN 40436 81 17 here here RB 40436 81 18 by by IN 40436 81 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 81 20 , , , 40436 81 21 is be VBZ 40436 81 22 also also RB 40436 81 23 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 81 24 by by IN 40436 81 25 the the DT 40436 81 26 historical historical JJ 40436 81 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 81 28 in in IN 40436 81 29 the the DT 40436 81 30 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 81 31 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 81 32 66 66 CD 40436 81 33 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 81 34 combats combat VBZ 40436 81 35 the the DT 40436 81 36 thesis thesis NN 40436 81 37 . . . 40436 82 1 Arguments argument NNS 40436 82 2 against against IN 40436 82 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 82 4 67 67 CD 40436 82 5 Mistake Mistake NNP 40436 82 6 of of IN 40436 82 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 82 8 and and CC 40436 82 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 82 10 in in IN 40436 82 11 dwelling dwell VBG 40436 82 12 too too RB 40436 82 13 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 82 14 on on IN 40436 82 15 the the DT 40436 82 16 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 82 17 conditions condition NNS 40436 82 18 of of IN 40436 82 19 human human JJ 40436 82 20 conduct conduct NN 40436 82 21 _ _ NNP 40436 82 22 ib ib UH 40436 82 23 . . . 40436 82 24 _ _ NNP 40436 82 25 They -PRON- PRP 40436 82 26 rely rely VBP 40436 82 27 too too RB 40436 82 28 much much RB 40436 82 29 on on IN 40436 82 30 the the DT 40436 82 31 analogy analogy NN 40436 82 32 of of IN 40436 82 33 the the DT 40436 82 34 special special JJ 40436 82 35 arts art NNS 40436 82 36 -- -- : 40436 82 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 82 38 take take VBP 40436 82 39 no no DT 40436 82 40 note note NN 40436 82 41 of of IN 40436 82 42 the the DT 40436 82 43 tacit tacit JJ 40436 82 44 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 82 45 underlying underlie VBG 40436 82 46 the the DT 40436 82 47 epithets epithet NNS 40436 82 48 of of IN 40436 82 49 praise praise NN 40436 82 50 and and CC 40436 82 51 blame blame VBP 40436 82 52 68 68 CD 40436 82 53 Value value NN 40436 82 54 of of IN 40436 82 55 a a DT 40436 82 56 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 82 57 of of IN 40436 82 58 Search Search NNP 40436 82 59 , , , 40436 82 60 that that IN 40436 82 61 it -PRON- PRP 40436 82 62 shall shall MD 40436 82 63 be be VB 40436 82 64 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 82 65 , , , 40436 82 66 and and CC 40436 82 67 that that IN 40436 82 68 it -PRON- PRP 40436 82 69 shall shall MD 40436 82 70 bring bring VB 40436 82 71 before before RB 40436 82 72 us -PRON- PRP 40436 82 73 different different JJ 40436 82 74 aspects aspect NNS 40436 82 75 of of IN 40436 82 76 the the DT 40436 82 77 question question NN 40436 82 78 under under IN 40436 82 79 review review NN 40436 82 80 69 69 CD 40436 82 81 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 82 82 between between IN 40436 82 83 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 82 84 and and CC 40436 82 85 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 82 86 70 70 CD 40436 82 87 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 82 88 XIV XIV NNP 40436 82 89 . . . 40436 83 1 HIPPARCHUS HIPPARCHUS NNP 40436 83 2 -- -- : 40436 83 3 MINOS MINOS NNP 40436 83 4 . . . 40436 84 1 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 84 2 -- -- : 40436 84 3 Question question NN 40436 84 4 -- -- : 40436 84 5 What what WP 40436 84 6 is be VBZ 40436 84 7 the the DT 40436 84 8 definition definition NN 40436 84 9 of of IN 40436 84 10 Lover Lover NNP 40436 84 11 of of IN 40436 84 12 Gain Gain NNP 40436 84 13 ? ? . 40436 85 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 85 2 is be VBZ 40436 85 3 one one CD 40436 85 4 who who WP 40436 85 5 thinks think VBZ 40436 85 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 85 7 right right JJ 40436 85 8 to to TO 40436 85 9 gain gain VB 40436 85 10 from from IN 40436 85 11 things thing NNS 40436 85 12 worth worth JJ 40436 85 13 nothing nothing NN 40436 85 14 . . . 40436 86 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 86 2 cross cross NN 40436 86 3 - - NNS 40436 86 4 examines examine NNS 40436 86 5 upon upon IN 40436 86 6 this this DT 40436 86 7 explanation explanation NN 40436 86 8 . . . 40436 87 1 No no DT 40436 87 2 man man NN 40436 87 3 expects expect VBZ 40436 87 4 to to TO 40436 87 5 gain gain VB 40436 87 6 from from IN 40436 87 7 things thing NNS 40436 87 8 which which WDT 40436 87 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 87 10 knows know VBZ 40436 87 11 to to TO 40436 87 12 be be VB 40436 87 13 worth worth JJ 40436 87 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 87 15 : : : 40436 87 16 in in IN 40436 87 17 this this DT 40436 87 18 sense sense NN 40436 87 19 , , , 40436 87 20 no no DT 40436 87 21 man man NN 40436 87 22 is be VBZ 40436 87 23 a a DT 40436 87 24 lover lover NN 40436 87 25 of of IN 40436 87 26 gain gain NN 40436 87 27 71 71 CD 40436 87 28 Gain Gain NNP 40436 87 29 is be VBZ 40436 87 30 good good JJ 40436 87 31 . . . 40436 88 1 Every every DT 40436 88 2 man man NN 40436 88 3 loves love VBZ 40436 88 4 good good JJ 40436 88 5 : : : 40436 88 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 88 7 all all DT 40436 88 8 men man NNS 40436 88 9 are be VBP 40436 88 10 lovers lover NNS 40436 88 11 of of IN 40436 88 12 gain gain JJ 40436 88 13 72 72 CD 40436 88 14 Apparent apparent JJ 40436 88 15 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 88 16 . . . 40436 89 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 89 2 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 89 3 the the DT 40436 89 4 companion companion NN 40436 89 5 of of IN 40436 89 6 trying try VBG 40436 89 7 to to TO 40436 89 8 deceive deceive VB 40436 89 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 89 10 -- -- : 40436 89 11 accusation accusation NN 40436 89 12 is be VBZ 40436 89 13 retorted retort VBN 40436 89 14 upon upon IN 40436 89 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 89 16 73 73 CD 40436 89 17 Precept Precept NNP 40436 89 18 inscribed inscribe VBN 40436 89 19 formerly formerly RB 40436 89 20 by by IN 40436 89 21 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 89 22 the the DT 40436 89 23 Peisistratid Peisistratid NNPS 40436 89 24 -- -- : 40436 89 25 never never RB 40436 89 26 deceive deceive VBP 40436 89 27 a a DT 40436 89 28 friend friend NN 40436 89 29 . . . 40436 90 1 Eulogy eulogy NN 40436 90 2 of of IN 40436 90 3 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 90 4 by by IN 40436 90 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 90 6 _ _ NNP 40436 90 7 ib ib NN 40436 90 8 . . . 40436 90 9 _ _ NNP 40436 90 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 90 11 allows allow VBZ 40436 90 12 the the DT 40436 90 13 companion companion NN 40436 90 14 to to TO 40436 90 15 retract retract VB 40436 90 16 some some DT 40436 90 17 of of IN 40436 90 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 90 19 answers answer NNS 40436 90 20 . . . 40436 91 1 The the DT 40436 91 2 companion companion NN 40436 91 3 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 91 4 that that IN 40436 91 5 some some DT 40436 91 6 gain gain NN 40436 91 7 is be VBZ 40436 91 8 good good JJ 40436 91 9 , , , 40436 91 10 other other JJ 40436 91 11 gain gain NN 40436 91 12 is be VBZ 40436 91 13 evil evil JJ 40436 91 14 74 74 CD 40436 91 15 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 91 16 by by IN 40436 91 17 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 91 18 -- -- : 40436 91 19 bad bad JJ 40436 91 20 gain gain NN 40436 91 21 is be VBZ 40436 91 22 _ _ NNP 40436 91 23 gain gain NN 40436 91 24 _ _ NNP 40436 91 25 , , , 40436 91 26 as as RB 40436 91 27 much much RB 40436 91 28 as as IN 40436 91 29 good good JJ 40436 91 30 gain gain NN 40436 91 31 . . . 40436 92 1 What what WP 40436 92 2 is be VBZ 40436 92 3 the the DT 40436 92 4 common common JJ 40436 92 5 property property NN 40436 92 6 , , , 40436 92 7 in in IN 40436 92 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 92 9 of of IN 40436 92 10 which which WDT 40436 92 11 both both DT 40436 92 12 are be VBP 40436 92 13 called call VBN 40436 92 14 Gain gain NN 40436 92 15 ? ? . 40436 93 1 Every every DT 40436 93 2 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 93 3 , , , 40436 93 4 made make VBN 40436 93 5 with with IN 40436 93 6 no no DT 40436 93 7 outlay outlay NN 40436 93 8 , , , 40436 93 9 or or CC 40436 93 10 with with IN 40436 93 11 a a DT 40436 93 12 smaller small JJR 40436 93 13 outlay outlay NN 40436 93 14 , , , 40436 93 15 is be VBZ 40436 93 16 gain gain NN 40436 93 17 . . . 40436 94 1 Objections objection NNS 40436 94 2 -- -- : 40436 94 3 the the DT 40436 94 4 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 94 5 may may MD 40436 94 6 be be VB 40436 94 7 evil evil JJ 40436 94 8 -- -- : 40436 94 9 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 94 10 confessed confess VBD 40436 94 11 _ _ NNP 40436 94 12 ib ib NN 40436 94 13 . . . 40436 94 14 _ _ NNP 40436 94 15 It -PRON- PRP 40436 94 16 is be VBZ 40436 94 17 essential essential JJ 40436 94 18 to to TO 40436 94 19 gain gain VB 40436 94 20 , , , 40436 94 21 that that IN 40436 94 22 the the DT 40436 94 23 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 94 24 made make VBN 40436 94 25 shall shall MD 40436 94 26 be be VB 40436 94 27 greater great JJR 40436 94 28 not not RB 40436 94 29 merely merely RB 40436 94 30 in in IN 40436 94 31 quantity quantity NN 40436 94 32 , , , 40436 94 33 but but CC 40436 94 34 also also RB 40436 94 35 in in IN 40436 94 36 value value NN 40436 94 37 , , , 40436 94 38 than than IN 40436 94 39 the the DT 40436 94 40 outlay outlay NN 40436 94 41 . . . 40436 95 1 The the DT 40436 95 2 valuable valuable JJ 40436 95 3 is be VBZ 40436 95 4 the the DT 40436 95 5 profitable profitable JJ 40436 95 6 -- -- : 40436 95 7 the the DT 40436 95 8 profitable profitable JJ 40436 95 9 is be VBZ 40436 95 10 the the DT 40436 95 11 good good JJ 40436 95 12 . . . 40436 96 1 Conclusion conclusion NN 40436 96 2 comes come VBZ 40436 96 3 back back RB 40436 96 4 . . . 40436 97 1 That that IN 40436 97 2 Gain Gain NNP 40436 97 3 is be VBZ 40436 97 4 Good good JJ 40436 97 5 75 75 CD 40436 97 6 Recapitulation recapitulation NN 40436 97 7 . . . 40436 98 1 The the DT 40436 98 2 debate debate NN 40436 98 3 has have VBZ 40436 98 4 shown show VBN 40436 98 5 that that IN 40436 98 6 all all DT 40436 98 7 gain gain NN 40436 98 8 is be VBZ 40436 98 9 good good JJ 40436 98 10 , , , 40436 98 11 and and CC 40436 98 12 that that IN 40436 98 13 there there EX 40436 98 14 is be VBZ 40436 98 15 no no DT 40436 98 16 evil evil JJ 40436 98 17 gain gain NN 40436 98 18 -- -- : 40436 98 19 all all DT 40436 98 20 men man NNS 40436 98 21 are be VBP 40436 98 22 lovers lover NNS 40436 98 23 of of IN 40436 98 24 gain gain NN 40436 98 25 -- -- : 40436 98 26 no no DT 40436 98 27 man man NN 40436 98 28 ought ought MD 40436 98 29 to to TO 40436 98 30 be be VB 40436 98 31 reproached reproach VBN 40436 98 32 for for IN 40436 98 33 being be VBG 40436 98 34 so so RB 40436 98 35 the the DT 40436 98 36 companion companion NN 40436 98 37 is be VBZ 40436 98 38 compelled compel VBN 40436 98 39 to to TO 40436 98 40 admit admit VB 40436 98 41 this this DT 40436 98 42 , , , 40436 98 43 though though IN 40436 98 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 98 45 declares declare VBZ 40436 98 46 that that IN 40436 98 47 he -PRON- PRP 40436 98 48 is be VBZ 40436 98 49 not not RB 40436 98 50 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 98 51 _ _ NNP 40436 98 52 ib ib UH 40436 98 53 . . . 40436 98 54 _ _ NNP 40436 98 55 Minos Minos NNP 40436 98 56 . . . 40436 99 1 Question question NN 40436 99 2 put put VBN 40436 99 3 by by IN 40436 99 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 99 5 to to IN 40436 99 6 the the DT 40436 99 7 companion companion NN 40436 99 8 . . . 40436 100 1 What what WP 40436 100 2 is be VBZ 40436 100 3 Law Law NNP 40436 100 4 , , , 40436 100 5 or or CC 40436 100 6 The the DT 40436 100 7 Law Law NNP 40436 100 8 ? ? . 40436 101 1 All all DT 40436 101 2 law law NN 40436 101 3 is be VBZ 40436 101 4 the the DT 40436 101 5 same same JJ 40436 101 6 , , , 40436 101 7 _ _ NNP 40436 101 8 quatenus quatenus NN 40436 101 9 _ _ NNP 40436 101 10 law law NN 40436 101 11 : : : 40436 101 12 what what WP 40436 101 13 is be VBZ 40436 101 14 the the DT 40436 101 15 common common JJ 40436 101 16 constituent constituent NN 40436 101 17 attribute attribute NN 40436 101 18 ? ? . 40436 102 1 76 76 CD 40436 102 2 Answer Answer NNP 40436 102 3 -- -- : 40436 102 4 Law Law NNP 40436 102 5 is be VBZ 40436 102 6 , , , 40436 102 7 1 1 CD 40436 102 8 . . . 40436 103 1 The the DT 40436 103 2 consecrated consecrated JJ 40436 103 3 and and CC 40436 103 4 binding bind VBG 40436 103 5 customs custom NNS 40436 103 6 . . . 40436 104 1 2 2 LS 40436 104 2 . . . 40436 105 1 The the DT 40436 105 2 decree decree NN 40436 105 3 of of IN 40436 105 4 the the DT 40436 105 5 city city NN 40436 105 6 . . . 40436 106 1 3 3 LS 40436 106 2 . . . 40436 107 1 Social social JJ 40436 107 2 or or CC 40436 107 3 civic civic JJ 40436 107 4 opinion opinion NN 40436 107 5 _ _ NNP 40436 107 6 ib ib UH 40436 107 7 . . . 40436 107 8 _ _ NNP 40436 107 9 Cross Cross NNP 40436 107 10 - - NN 40436 107 11 examination examination NN 40436 107 12 by by IN 40436 107 13 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 107 14 -- -- : 40436 107 15 just just RB 40436 107 16 and and CC 40436 107 17 lawfully lawfully RB 40436 107 18 - - HYPH 40436 107 19 behaving behave VBG 40436 107 20 men man NNS 40436 107 21 are be VBP 40436 107 22 so so RB 40436 107 23 through through IN 40436 107 24 law law NN 40436 107 25 ; ; : 40436 107 26 unjust unjust JJ 40436 107 27 and and CC 40436 107 28 lawless lawless JJ 40436 107 29 men man NNS 40436 107 30 are be VBP 40436 107 31 so so RB 40436 107 32 through through IN 40436 107 33 the the DT 40436 107 34 absence absence NN 40436 107 35 of of IN 40436 107 36 law law NN 40436 107 37 . . . 40436 108 1 Law Law NNP 40436 108 2 is be VBZ 40436 108 3 highly highly RB 40436 108 4 honourable honourable JJ 40436 108 5 and and CC 40436 108 6 useful useful JJ 40436 108 7 : : : 40436 108 8 lawlessness lawlessness NN 40436 108 9 is be VBZ 40436 108 10 ruinous ruinous JJ 40436 108 11 . . . 40436 109 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 109 2 , , , 40436 109 3 bad bad JJ 40436 109 4 decrees decree NNS 40436 109 5 of of IN 40436 109 6 the the DT 40436 109 7 city city NN 40436 109 8 -- -- : 40436 109 9 or or CC 40436 109 10 bad bad JJ 40436 109 11 social social JJ 40436 109 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 109 13 -- -- : 40436 109 14 cannot cannot NNP 40436 109 15 be be VB 40436 109 16 law law NN 40436 109 17 77 77 CD 40436 109 18 Suggestion suggestion NN 40436 109 19 by by IN 40436 109 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 109 21 -- -- : 40436 109 22 Law Law NNP 40436 109 23 is be VBZ 40436 109 24 the the DT 40436 109 25 _ _ NNP 40436 109 26 good good JJ 40436 109 27 _ _ NNP 40436 109 28 opinion opinion NN 40436 109 29 of of IN 40436 109 30 the the DT 40436 109 31 city city NN 40436 109 32 -- -- : 40436 109 33 but but CC 40436 109 34 good good JJ 40436 109 35 opinion opinion NN 40436 109 36 is be VBZ 40436 109 37 true true JJ 40436 109 38 opinion opinion NN 40436 109 39 , , , 40436 109 40 or or CC 40436 109 41 the the DT 40436 109 42 finding finding NN 40436 109 43 out out IN 40436 109 44 of of IN 40436 109 45 reality reality NN 40436 109 46 . . . 40436 110 1 Law law NN 40436 110 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 110 3 wishes wish VBZ 40436 110 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 110 5 tends tend VBZ 40436 110 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 110 7 to to TO 40436 110 8 be be VB 40436 110 9 the the DT 40436 110 10 finding finding NN 40436 110 11 out out IN 40436 110 12 of of IN 40436 110 13 reality reality NN 40436 110 14 , , , 40436 110 15 though though IN 40436 110 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 110 17 does do VBZ 40436 110 18 not not RB 40436 110 19 always always RB 40436 110 20 succeed succeed VB 40436 110 21 in in IN 40436 110 22 doing do VBG 40436 110 23 so so RB 40436 110 24 77 77 CD 40436 110 25 Objection objection NN 40436 110 26 taken take VBN 40436 110 27 by by IN 40436 110 28 the the DT 40436 110 29 Companion Companion NNP 40436 110 30 -- -- : 40436 110 31 That that IN 40436 110 32 there there EX 40436 110 33 is be VBZ 40436 110 34 great great JJ 40436 110 35 discordance discordance NN 40436 110 36 of of IN 40436 110 37 laws law NNS 40436 110 38 in in IN 40436 110 39 different different JJ 40436 110 40 places place NNS 40436 110 41 -- -- : 40436 110 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 110 43 specifies specify VBZ 40436 110 44 several several JJ 40436 110 45 cases case NNS 40436 110 46 of of IN 40436 110 47 such such JJ 40436 110 48 discordance discordance NN 40436 110 49 at at IN 40436 110 50 some some DT 40436 110 51 length length NN 40436 110 52 . . . 40436 111 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 111 2 reproves reprove VBZ 40436 111 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 111 4 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 111 5 , , , 40436 111 6 and and CC 40436 111 7 requests request VBZ 40436 111 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 111 9 to to TO 40436 111 10 confine confine VB 40436 111 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 111 12 to to TO 40436 111 13 question question VB 40436 111 14 or or CC 40436 111 15 answer answer VB 40436 111 16 78 78 CD 40436 111 17 Farther farther JJ 40436 111 18 questions question NNS 40436 111 19 by by IN 40436 111 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 111 21 -- -- : 40436 111 22 Things thing NNS 40436 111 23 heavy heavy JJ 40436 111 24 and and CC 40436 111 25 light light JJ 40436 111 26 , , , 40436 111 27 just just RB 40436 111 28 and and CC 40436 111 29 unjust unjust JJ 40436 111 30 , , , 40436 111 31 honourable honourable JJ 40436 111 32 and and CC 40436 111 33 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 111 34 , , , 40436 111 35 & & CC 40436 111 36 c. c. NNP 40436 111 37 , , , 40436 111 38 are be VBP 40436 111 39 so so RB 40436 111 40 , , , 40436 111 41 and and CC 40436 111 42 are be VBP 40436 111 43 accounted account VBN 40436 111 44 so so RB 40436 111 45 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 111 46 . . . 40436 112 1 Real real JJ 40436 112 2 things thing NNS 40436 112 3 are be VBP 40436 112 4 always always RB 40436 112 5 accounted account VBN 40436 112 6 real real JJ 40436 112 7 . . . 40436 113 1 Whoever whoever WP 40436 113 2 fails fail VBZ 40436 113 3 in in IN 40436 113 4 attaining attain VBG 40436 113 5 the the DT 40436 113 6 real real JJ 40436 113 7 , , , 40436 113 8 fails fail VBZ 40436 113 9 in in IN 40436 113 10 attaining attain VBG 40436 113 11 the the DT 40436 113 12 lawful lawful JJ 40436 113 13 _ _ NNP 40436 113 14 ib ib UH 40436 113 15 . . . 40436 113 16 _ _ NNP 40436 113 17 There there EX 40436 113 18 are be VBP 40436 113 19 laws law NNS 40436 113 20 of of IN 40436 113 21 health health NN 40436 113 22 and and CC 40436 113 23 of of IN 40436 113 24 cure cure NN 40436 113 25 , , , 40436 113 26 composed compose VBN 40436 113 27 by by IN 40436 113 28 the the DT 40436 113 29 few few JJ 40436 113 30 physicians physician NNS 40436 113 31 wise wise JJ 40436 113 32 upon upon IN 40436 113 33 those those DT 40436 113 34 subjects subject NNS 40436 113 35 , , , 40436 113 36 and and CC 40436 113 37 unanimously unanimously RB 40436 113 38 declared declare VBD 40436 113 39 by by IN 40436 113 40 them -PRON- PRP 40436 113 41 . . . 40436 114 1 So so RB 40436 114 2 also also RB 40436 114 3 there there EX 40436 114 4 are be VBP 40436 114 5 laws law NNS 40436 114 6 of of IN 40436 114 7 farming farming NN 40436 114 8 , , , 40436 114 9 gardening gardening NN 40436 114 10 , , , 40436 114 11 cookery cookery NN 40436 114 12 , , , 40436 114 13 declared declare VBN 40436 114 14 by by IN 40436 114 15 the the DT 40436 114 16 few few JJ 40436 114 17 wise wise JJ 40436 114 18 in in IN 40436 114 19 those those DT 40436 114 20 respective respective JJ 40436 114 21 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 114 22 . . . 40436 115 1 In in IN 40436 115 2 like like JJ 40436 115 3 manner manner NN 40436 115 4 , , , 40436 115 5 the the DT 40436 115 6 laws law NNS 40436 115 7 of of IN 40436 115 8 a a DT 40436 115 9 city city NN 40436 115 10 are be VBP 40436 115 11 the the DT 40436 115 12 judgments judgment NNS 40436 115 13 declared declare VBN 40436 115 14 by by IN 40436 115 15 the the DT 40436 115 16 few few JJ 40436 115 17 wise wise JJ 40436 115 18 men man NNS 40436 115 19 who who WP 40436 115 20 know know VBP 40436 115 21 how how WRB 40436 115 22 to to TO 40436 115 23 rule rule VB 40436 115 24 79 79 CD 40436 115 25 That that DT 40436 115 26 which which WDT 40436 115 27 is be VBZ 40436 115 28 right right JJ 40436 115 29 is be VBZ 40436 115 30 the the DT 40436 115 31 regal regal JJ 40436 115 32 law law NN 40436 115 33 , , , 40436 115 34 the the DT 40436 115 35 only only JJ 40436 115 36 true true JJ 40436 115 37 and and CC 40436 115 38 real real JJ 40436 115 39 law law NN 40436 115 40 -- -- : 40436 115 41 that that IN 40436 115 42 which which WDT 40436 115 43 is be VBZ 40436 115 44 not not RB 40436 115 45 right right JJ 40436 115 46 , , , 40436 115 47 is be VBZ 40436 115 48 not not RB 40436 115 49 law law NN 40436 115 50 , , , 40436 115 51 but but CC 40436 115 52 only only RB 40436 115 53 seems seem VBZ 40436 115 54 to to TO 40436 115 55 be be VB 40436 115 56 law law NN 40436 115 57 in in IN 40436 115 58 the the DT 40436 115 59 eyes eye NNS 40436 115 60 of of IN 40436 115 61 the the DT 40436 115 62 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 115 63 80 80 CD 40436 115 64 Minos Minos NNP 40436 115 65 , , , 40436 115 66 King King NNP 40436 115 67 of of IN 40436 115 68 Krete Krete NNP 40436 115 69 -- -- : 40436 115 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 115 71 laws law NNS 40436 115 72 were be VBD 40436 115 73 divine divine JJ 40436 115 74 and and CC 40436 115 75 excellent excellent JJ 40436 115 76 , , , 40436 115 77 and and CC 40436 115 78 have have VBP 40436 115 79 remained remain VBN 40436 115 80 unchanged unchanged JJ 40436 115 81 from from IN 40436 115 82 time time NN 40436 115 83 immemorial immemorial JJ 40436 115 84 _ _ NNP 40436 115 85 ib ib UH 40436 115 86 . . . 40436 115 87 _ _ NNP 40436 115 88 Question Question NNP 40436 115 89 about about IN 40436 115 90 the the DT 40436 115 91 character character NN 40436 115 92 of of IN 40436 115 93 Minos Minos NNP 40436 115 94 -- -- : 40436 115 95 Homer Homer NNP 40436 115 96 and and CC 40436 115 97 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 40436 115 98 declare declare VBP 40436 115 99 him -PRON- PRP 40436 115 100 to to TO 40436 115 101 have have VB 40436 115 102 been be VBN 40436 115 103 admirable admirable JJ 40436 115 104 , , , 40436 115 105 the the DT 40436 115 106 Attic attic JJ 40436 115 107 tragedians tragedians NNPS 40436 115 108 defame defame VBP 40436 115 109 him -PRON- PRP 40436 115 110 as as IN 40436 115 111 a a DT 40436 115 112 tyrant tyrant NN 40436 115 113 , , , 40436 115 114 because because IN 40436 115 115 he -PRON- PRP 40436 115 116 was be VBD 40436 115 117 an an DT 40436 115 118 enemy enemy NN 40436 115 119 of of IN 40436 115 120 Athens Athens NNP 40436 115 121 81 81 CD 40436 115 122 That that IN 40436 115 123 Minos Minos NNP 40436 115 124 was be VBD 40436 115 125 really really RB 40436 115 126 admirable admirable JJ 40436 115 127 -- -- : 40436 115 128 and and CC 40436 115 129 that that IN 40436 115 130 he -PRON- PRP 40436 115 131 has have VBZ 40436 115 132 found find VBN 40436 115 133 out out RP 40436 115 134 truth truth NN 40436 115 135 and and CC 40436 115 136 reality reality NN 40436 115 137 respecting respect VBG 40436 115 138 the the DT 40436 115 139 administration administration NN 40436 115 140 of of IN 40436 115 141 the the DT 40436 115 142 city city NN 40436 115 143 -- -- : 40436 115 144 we -PRON- PRP 40436 115 145 may may MD 40436 115 146 be be VB 40436 115 147 sure sure JJ 40436 115 148 from from IN 40436 115 149 the the DT 40436 115 150 fact fact NN 40436 115 151 that that IN 40436 115 152 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 115 153 laws law NNS 40436 115 154 have have VBP 40436 115 155 remained remain VBN 40436 115 156 so so RB 40436 115 157 long long RB 40436 115 158 unaltered unaltered JJ 40436 115 159 _ _ NNP 40436 115 160 ib ib UH 40436 115 161 . . . 40436 115 162 _ _ NNP 40436 115 163 The the DT 40436 115 164 question question NN 40436 115 165 is be VBZ 40436 115 166 made make VBN 40436 115 167 more more JJR 40436 115 168 determinate determinate NN 40436 115 169 -- -- : 40436 115 170 What what WP 40436 115 171 is be VBZ 40436 115 172 it -PRON- PRP 40436 115 173 that that WDT 40436 115 174 the the DT 40436 115 175 good good JJ 40436 115 176 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 115 177 prescribes prescribe NNS 40436 115 178 and and CC 40436 115 179 measures measure NNS 40436 115 180 out out RP 40436 115 181 for for IN 40436 115 182 the the DT 40436 115 183 health health NN 40436 115 184 of of IN 40436 115 185 the the DT 40436 115 186 mind mind NN 40436 115 187 , , , 40436 115 188 as as IN 40436 115 189 the the DT 40436 115 190 physician physician NN 40436 115 191 measures measure VBZ 40436 115 192 out out RP 40436 115 193 food food NN 40436 115 194 and and CC 40436 115 195 exercise exercise NN 40436 115 196 for for IN 40436 115 197 the the DT 40436 115 198 body body NN 40436 115 199 ? ? . 40436 116 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 116 2 can can MD 40436 116 3 not not RB 40436 116 4 tell tell VB 40436 116 5 . . . 40436 117 1 Close close JJ 40436 117 2 81 81 CD 40436 117 3 The the DT 40436 117 4 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 117 5 and and CC 40436 117 6 Minos Minos NNP 40436 117 7 are be VBP 40436 117 8 analogous analogous JJ 40436 117 9 to to IN 40436 117 10 each each DT 40436 117 11 other other JJ 40436 117 12 , , , 40436 117 13 and and CC 40436 117 14 both both DT 40436 117 15 of of IN 40436 117 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 117 17 inferior inferior JJ 40436 117 18 works work NNS 40436 117 19 of of IN 40436 117 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 117 21 , , , 40436 117 22 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 117 23 unfinished unfinished JJ 40436 117 24 82 82 CD 40436 117 25 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNPS 40436 117 26 -- -- : 40436 117 27 double double JJ 40436 117 28 meaning meaning NN 40436 117 29 of of IN 40436 117 30 [ [ -LRB- 40436 117 31 Greek Greek NNP 40436 117 32 : : : 40436 117 33 philokerdê\s philokerdê\s ADD 40436 117 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 117 35 and and CC 40436 117 36 [ [ -LRB- 40436 117 37 Greek Greek NNP 40436 117 38 : : : 40436 117 39 ke ke NNP 40436 117 40 / / SYM 40436 117 41 rdos rdos NNP 40436 117 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 117 43 _ _ NNP 40436 117 44 ib ib UH 40436 117 45 . . . 40436 117 46 _ _ NNP 40436 117 47 State State NNP 40436 117 48 or or CC 40436 117 49 mind mind NN 40436 117 50 of of IN 40436 117 51 the the DT 40436 117 52 agent agent NN 40436 117 53 , , , 40436 117 54 as as IN 40436 117 55 to to IN 40436 117 56 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 117 57 , , , 40436 117 58 frequent frequent JJ 40436 117 59 inquiry inquiry NN 40436 117 60 in in IN 40436 117 61 Plato Plato NNP 40436 117 62 . . . 40436 118 1 No no DT 40436 118 2 tenable tenable JJ 40436 118 3 definition definition NN 40436 118 4 found find VBD 40436 118 5 83 83 CD 40436 118 6 Admitting admit VBG 40436 118 7 that that IN 40436 118 8 there there EX 40436 118 9 is be VBZ 40436 118 10 bad bad JJ 40436 118 11 gain gain NN 40436 118 12 , , , 40436 118 13 as as RB 40436 118 14 well well RB 40436 118 15 as as IN 40436 118 16 good good JJ 40436 118 17 gain gain NN 40436 118 18 , , , 40436 118 19 what what WP 40436 118 20 is be VBZ 40436 118 21 the the DT 40436 118 22 meaning meaning NN 40436 118 23 of of IN 40436 118 24 the the DT 40436 118 25 word word NN 40436 118 26 _ _ NNP 40436 118 27 gain gain NN 40436 118 28 _ _ NNP 40436 118 29 * * NFP 40436 118 30 * * NFP 40436 118 31 ? ? . 40436 119 1 None none NN 40436 119 2 is be VBZ 40436 119 3 found find VBN 40436 119 4 _ _ NNP 40436 119 5 ib ib UH 40436 119 6 . . . 40436 119 7 _ _ NNP 40436 119 8 Purpose Purpose NNP 40436 119 9 of of IN 40436 119 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 119 11 in in IN 40436 119 12 the the DT 40436 119 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 119 14 -- -- : 40436 119 15 to to TO 40436 119 16 lay lay VB 40436 119 17 bare bare JJ 40436 119 18 the the DT 40436 119 19 confusion confusion NN 40436 119 20 , , , 40436 119 21 and and CC 40436 119 22 to to TO 40436 119 23 force force VB 40436 119 24 the the DT 40436 119 25 mind mind NN 40436 119 26 of of IN 40436 119 27 the the DT 40436 119 28 respondent respondent NN 40436 119 29 into into IN 40436 119 30 efforts effort NNS 40436 119 31 for for IN 40436 119 32 clearing clear VBG 40436 119 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 119 34 up up RP 40436 119 35 84 84 CD 40436 119 36 Historical historical JJ 40436 119 37 narrative narrative NN 40436 119 38 and and CC 40436 119 39 comments comment NNS 40436 119 40 given give VBN 40436 119 41 in in IN 40436 119 42 the the DT 40436 119 43 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 119 44 respecting respect VBG 40436 119 45 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 119 46 -- -- : 40436 119 47 afford afford VB 40436 119 48 no no DT 40436 119 49 ground ground NN 40436 119 50 for for IN 40436 119 51 declaring declare VBG 40436 119 52 the the DT 40436 119 53 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 119 54 to to TO 40436 119 55 be be VB 40436 119 56 spurious spurious JJ 40436 119 57 _ _ NNP 40436 119 58 ib ib UH 40436 119 59 . . . 40436 119 60 _ _ NNP 40436 119 61 Minos Minos NNP 40436 119 62 . . . 40436 120 1 Question question NN 40436 120 2 -- -- : 40436 120 3 What what WP 40436 120 4 is be VBZ 40436 120 5 the the DT 40436 120 6 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 120 7 property property NN 40436 120 8 connoted connote VBN 40436 120 9 by by IN 40436 120 10 the the DT 40436 120 11 word word NN 40436 120 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 120 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 120 14 : : : 40436 120 15 No no UH 40436 120 16 / / SYM 40436 120 17 mos mos NN 40436 120 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 120 19 or or CC 40436 120 20 law law NN 40436 120 21 ? ? . 40436 121 1 86 86 CD 40436 121 2 This this DT 40436 121 3 question question NN 40436 121 4 was be VBD 40436 121 5 discussed discuss VBN 40436 121 6 by by IN 40436 121 7 the the DT 40436 121 8 historical historical JJ 40436 121 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 121 10 , , , 40436 121 11 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 121 12 of of IN 40436 121 13 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 121 14 _ _ NNP 40436 121 15 ib ib UH 40436 121 16 . . . 40436 121 17 _ _ NNP 40436 121 18 Definitions definition NNS 40436 121 19 of of IN 40436 121 20 law law NN 40436 121 21 -- -- : 40436 121 22 suggested suggest VBN 40436 121 23 and and CC 40436 121 24 refuted refute VBN 40436 121 25 . . . 40436 122 1 Law Law NNP 40436 122 2 includes include VBZ 40436 122 3 , , , 40436 122 4 as as IN 40436 122 5 a a DT 40436 122 6 portion portion NN 40436 122 7 of of IN 40436 122 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 122 9 meaning meaning NN 40436 122 10 , , , 40436 122 11 justice justice NN 40436 122 12 , , , 40436 122 13 goodness goodness NN 40436 122 14 , , , 40436 122 15 usefulness usefulness NNP 40436 122 16 , , , 40436 122 17 & & CC 40436 122 18 c. c. NNP 40436 122 19 Bad bad JJ 40436 122 20 decrees decree NNS 40436 122 21 are be VBP 40436 122 22 not not RB 40436 122 23 laws law NNS 40436 122 24 86 86 CD 40436 122 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 122 26 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 122 27 that that DT 40436 122 28 law law NN 40436 122 29 is be VBZ 40436 122 30 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 122 31 the the DT 40436 122 32 same same JJ 40436 122 33 -- -- : 40436 122 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 122 35 is be VBZ 40436 122 36 the the DT 40436 122 37 declared declared JJ 40436 122 38 judgment judgment NN 40436 122 39 and and CC 40436 122 40 command command NN 40436 122 41 of of IN 40436 122 42 the the DT 40436 122 43 Wise wise JJ 40436 122 44 man man NN 40436 122 45 upon upon IN 40436 122 46 the the DT 40436 122 47 subject subject NN 40436 122 48 to to IN 40436 122 49 which which WDT 40436 122 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 122 51 refers refer VBZ 40436 122 52 -- -- : 40436 122 53 it -PRON- PRP 40436 122 54 is be VBZ 40436 122 55 truth truth NN 40436 122 56 and and CC 40436 122 57 reality reality NN 40436 122 58 , , , 40436 122 59 found find VBD 40436 122 60 out out RP 40436 122 61 and and CC 40436 122 62 certified certify VBN 40436 122 63 by by IN 40436 122 64 him -PRON- PRP 40436 122 65 87 87 CD 40436 122 66 Reasoning reasoning NN 40436 122 67 of of IN 40436 122 68 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 122 69 in in IN 40436 122 70 the the DT 40436 122 71 Minos Minos NNP 40436 122 72 is be VBZ 40436 122 73 unsound unsound JJ 40436 122 74 , , , 40436 122 75 but but CC 40436 122 76 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 122 77 . . . 40436 123 1 The the DT 40436 123 2 Good good JJ 40436 123 3 , , , 40436 123 4 True true JJ 40436 123 5 , , , 40436 123 6 and and CC 40436 123 7 Real real JJ 40436 123 8 , , , 40436 123 9 coalesce coalesce NN 40436 123 10 in in IN 40436 123 11 the the DT 40436 123 12 mind mind NN 40436 123 13 of of IN 40436 123 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 123 15 -- -- : 40436 123 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 123 17 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 40436 123 18 nothing nothing NN 40436 123 19 to to TO 40436 123 20 be be VB 40436 123 21 Law Law NNP 40436 123 22 , , , 40436 123 23 except except IN 40436 123 24 what what WP 40436 123 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 123 26 thinks think VBZ 40436 123 27 ought ought MD 40436 123 28 to to TO 40436 123 29 _ _ NNP 40436 123 30 be be VB 40436 123 31 _ _ NNP 40436 123 32 Law Law NNP 40436 123 33 88 88 CD 40436 123 34 Plato Plato NNP 40436 123 35 worships worship VBZ 40436 123 36 the the DT 40436 123 37 Ideal Ideal NNP 40436 123 38 of of IN 40436 123 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 123 40 own own JJ 40436 123 41 mind mind NN 40436 123 42 -- -- : 40436 123 43 the the DT 40436 123 44 work work NN 40436 123 45 of of IN 40436 123 46 systematic systematic JJ 40436 123 47 constructive constructive JJ 40436 123 48 theory theory NN 40436 123 49 by by IN 40436 123 50 the the DT 40436 123 51 Wise Wise NNP 40436 123 52 Man Man NNP 40436 123 53 89 89 CD 40436 123 54 Different different JJ 40436 123 55 applications application NNS 40436 123 56 of of IN 40436 123 57 this this DT 40436 123 58 general general JJ 40436 123 59 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 123 60 view view NN 40436 123 61 , , , 40436 123 62 in in IN 40436 123 63 the the DT 40436 123 64 Minos Minos NNP 40436 123 65 , , , 40436 123 66 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 123 67 , , , 40436 123 68 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 123 69 , , , 40436 123 70 & & CC 40436 123 71 c. c. NNP 40436 123 72 _ _ NNP 40436 123 73 Natural Natural NNP 40436 123 74 _ _ NNP 40436 123 75 Rectitude Rectitude NNP 40436 123 76 of of IN 40436 123 77 Law Law NNP 40436 123 78 , , , 40436 123 79 Government Government NNP 40436 123 80 , , , 40436 123 81 Names Names NNP 40436 123 82 , , , 40436 123 83 & & CC 40436 123 84 c c NNP 40436 123 85 _ _ NNP 40436 123 86 ib ib UH 40436 123 87 . . . 40436 123 88 _ _ NNP 40436 123 89 Eulogy Eulogy NNP 40436 123 90 on on IN 40436 123 91 Minos Minos NNP 40436 123 92 , , , 40436 123 93 as as IN 40436 123 94 having have VBG 40436 123 95 established establish VBN 40436 123 96 laws law NNS 40436 123 97 on on IN 40436 123 98 this this DT 40436 123 99 divine divine JJ 40436 123 100 type type NN 40436 123 101 or or CC 40436 123 102 natural natural JJ 40436 123 103 rectitude rectitude NN 40436 123 104 90 90 CD 40436 123 105 The the DT 40436 123 106 Minos Minos NNP 40436 123 107 was be VBD 40436 123 108 arranged arrange VBN 40436 123 109 by by IN 40436 123 110 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40436 123 111 at at IN 40436 123 112 first first RB 40436 123 113 in in IN 40436 123 114 a a DT 40436 123 115 Trilogy trilogy NN 40436 123 116 along along IN 40436 123 117 with with IN 40436 123 118 the the DT 40436 123 119 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 123 120 91 91 CD 40436 123 121 Explanations Explanations NNPS 40436 123 122 of of IN 40436 123 123 the the DT 40436 123 124 word word NN 40436 123 125 Law law NN 40436 123 126 -- -- : 40436 123 127 confusion confusion NN 40436 123 128 in in IN 40436 123 129 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 123 130 meaning meaning NN 40436 123 131 _ _ NNP 40436 123 132 ib ib UH 40436 123 133 . . . 40436 123 134 _ _ NNP 40436 123 135 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 123 136 XV XV NNP 40436 123 137 . . . 40436 124 1 THEAGES THEAGES NNP 40436 124 2 . . . 40436 125 1 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 125 2 -- -- : 40436 125 3 has have VBZ 40436 125 4 been be VBN 40436 125 5 declared declare VBN 40436 125 6 spurious spurious JJ 40436 125 7 by by IN 40436 125 8 some some DT 40436 125 9 modern modern JJ 40436 125 10 critics critic NNS 40436 125 11 -- -- : 40436 125 12 grounds ground NNS 40436 125 13 for for IN 40436 125 14 such such JJ 40436 125 15 opinion opinion NN 40436 125 16 not not RB 40436 125 17 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 125 18 98 98 CD 40436 125 19 Persons Persons NNPS 40436 125 20 of of IN 40436 125 21 the the DT 40436 125 22 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 125 23 -- -- : 40436 125 24 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 125 25 , , , 40436 125 26 with with IN 40436 125 27 Demodokus Demodokus NNP 40436 125 28 and and CC 40436 125 29 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 125 30 , , , 40436 125 31 father father NN 40436 125 32 and and CC 40436 125 33 son son NN 40436 125 34 . . . 40436 126 1 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 126 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 126 3 the the DT 40436 126 4 son son NN 40436 126 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 126 6 , , , 40436 126 7 eager eager JJ 40436 126 8 to to TO 40436 126 9 acquire acquire VB 40436 126 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 126 11 , , , 40436 126 12 desires desire NNS 40436 126 13 to to TO 40436 126 14 be be VB 40436 126 15 placed place VBN 40436 126 16 under under IN 40436 126 17 the the DT 40436 126 18 teaching teaching NN 40436 126 19 of of IN 40436 126 20 a a DT 40436 126 21 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 126 22 99 99 CD 40436 126 23 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 126 24 questions question NNS 40436 126 25 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 126 26 , , , 40436 126 27 inviting invite VBG 40436 126 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 126 29 to to TO 40436 126 30 specify specify VB 40436 126 31 what what WP 40436 126 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 126 33 wants want VBZ 40436 126 34 _ _ NNP 40436 126 35 ib ib UH 40436 126 36 . . . 40436 126 37 _ _ NNP 40436 126 38 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 126 39 desires desire NNS 40436 126 40 to to TO 40436 126 41 acquire acquire VB 40436 126 42 that that DT 40436 126 43 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 126 44 by by IN 40436 126 45 which which WDT 40436 126 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 126 47 can can MD 40436 126 48 govern govern VB 40436 126 49 freemen freeman NNS 40436 126 50 with with IN 40436 126 51 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 126 52 own own JJ 40436 126 53 consent consent NN 40436 126 54 100 100 CD 40436 126 55 Incompetence incompetence NN 40436 126 56 of of IN 40436 126 57 the the DT 40436 126 58 best good JJS 40436 126 59 practical practical JJ 40436 126 60 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 126 61 to to TO 40436 126 62 teach teach VB 40436 126 63 any any DT 40436 126 64 one one NN 40436 126 65 else else RB 40436 126 66 . . . 40436 127 1 Theagês theagês JJ 40436 127 2 requests request NNS 40436 127 3 that that IN 40436 127 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 127 5 will will MD 40436 127 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 127 7 teach teach VB 40436 127 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 127 9 _ _ NNP 40436 127 10 ib ib UH 40436 127 11 . . . 40436 127 12 _ _ NNP 40436 127 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 127 14 declares declare VBZ 40436 127 15 that that IN 40436 127 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 127 17 is be VBZ 40436 127 18 not not RB 40436 127 19 competent competent JJ 40436 127 20 to to TO 40436 127 21 teach teach VB 40436 127 22 -- -- : 40436 127 23 that that IN 40436 127 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 127 25 knows know VBZ 40436 127 26 nothing nothing NN 40436 127 27 except except IN 40436 127 28 about about IN 40436 127 29 matters matter NNS 40436 127 30 of of IN 40436 127 31 love love NN 40436 127 32 . . . 40436 128 1 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 128 2 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 128 3 that that IN 40436 128 4 many many JJ 40436 128 5 of of IN 40436 128 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 128 7 young young JJ 40436 128 8 friends friend NNS 40436 128 9 have have VBP 40436 128 10 profited profit VBN 40436 128 11 largely largely RB 40436 128 12 by by IN 40436 128 13 the the DT 40436 128 14 conversation conversation NN 40436 128 15 of of IN 40436 128 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 128 17 101 101 CD 40436 128 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 128 19 explains explain VBZ 40436 128 20 how how WRB 40436 128 21 this this DT 40436 128 22 has have VBZ 40436 128 23 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 128 24 happened happen VBN 40436 128 25 -- -- : 40436 128 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 128 27 recites recite VBZ 40436 128 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 128 29 experience experience NN 40436 128 30 of of IN 40436 128 31 the the DT 40436 128 32 divine divine JJ 40436 128 33 sign sign NN 40436 128 34 or or CC 40436 128 35 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 128 36 _ _ NNP 40436 128 37 ib ib UH 40436 128 38 . . . 40436 128 39 _ _ NNP 40436 128 40 The the DT 40436 128 41 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 128 42 is be VBZ 40436 128 43 favourable favourable JJ 40436 128 44 to to IN 40436 128 45 some some DT 40436 128 46 persons person NNS 40436 128 47 , , , 40436 128 48 adverse adverse RB 40436 128 49 to to IN 40436 128 50 others other NNS 40436 128 51 . . . 40436 129 1 Upon upon IN 40436 129 2 this this DT 40436 129 3 circumstance circumstance NN 40436 129 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 129 5 depends depend VBZ 40436 129 6 how how WRB 40436 129 7 far far RB 40436 129 8 any any DT 40436 129 9 companion companion NN 40436 129 10 profits profit NNS 40436 129 11 by by IN 40436 129 12 the the DT 40436 129 13 society society NN 40436 129 14 of of IN 40436 129 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 129 16 . . . 40436 130 1 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 130 2 has have VBZ 40436 130 3 not not RB 40436 130 4 learnt learn VBN 40436 130 5 anything anything NN 40436 130 6 from from IN 40436 130 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 130 8 , , , 40436 130 9 yet yet RB 40436 130 10 has have VBZ 40436 130 11 improved improve VBN 40436 130 12 much much RB 40436 130 13 by by IN 40436 130 14 being be VBG 40436 130 15 near near JJ 40436 130 16 to to IN 40436 130 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 130 18 102 102 CD 40436 130 19 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 130 20 expresses express VBZ 40436 130 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 130 22 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 130 23 to to TO 40436 130 24 be be VB 40436 130 25 received receive VBN 40436 130 26 as as IN 40436 130 27 the the DT 40436 130 28 companion companion NN 40436 130 29 of of IN 40436 130 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 130 31 103 103 CD 40436 130 32 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 130 33 on on IN 40436 130 34 the the DT 40436 130 35 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 130 36 -- -- : 40436 130 37 analogy analogy NN 40436 130 38 with with IN 40436 130 39 the the DT 40436 130 40 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 130 41 104 104 CD 40436 130 42 Chief chief JJ 40436 130 43 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 130 44 of of IN 40436 130 45 the the DT 40436 130 46 Theagês theagês JJ 40436 130 47 -- -- : 40436 130 48 stress stress NN 40436 130 49 laid lay VBN 40436 130 50 upon upon IN 40436 130 51 the the DT 40436 130 52 divine divine JJ 40436 130 53 sign sign NN 40436 130 54 or or CC 40436 130 55 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 130 56 _ _ NNP 40436 130 57 ib ib UH 40436 130 58 . . . 40436 130 59 _ _ NNP 40436 130 60 Plato Plato NNP 40436 130 61 employs employ VBZ 40436 130 62 this this DT 40436 130 63 divine divine JJ 40436 130 64 sign sign NN 40436 130 65 here here RB 40436 130 66 to to TO 40436 130 67 render render VB 40436 130 68 some some DT 40436 130 69 explanation explanation NN 40436 130 70 of of IN 40436 130 71 the the DT 40436 130 72 singularity singularity NN 40436 130 73 and and CC 40436 130 74 eccentricity eccentricity NN 40436 130 75 of of IN 40436 130 76 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 130 77 , , , 40436 130 78 and and CC 40436 130 79 of of IN 40436 130 80 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 130 81 unequal unequal JJ 40436 130 82 influence influence NN 40436 130 83 upon upon IN 40436 130 84 different different JJ 40436 130 85 companions companion NNS 40436 130 86 _ _ IN 40436 130 87 ib ib NN 40436 130 88 . . . 40436 130 89 _ _ NNP 40436 130 90 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 130 91 , , , 40436 130 92 while while IN 40436 130 93 continually continually RB 40436 130 94 finding find VBG 40436 130 95 fault fault NN 40436 130 96 with with IN 40436 130 97 other other JJ 40436 130 98 teachers teacher NNS 40436 130 99 , , , 40436 130 100 refused refuse VBD 40436 130 101 to to TO 40436 130 102 teach teach VB 40436 130 103 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 130 104 -- -- : 40436 130 105 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 130 106 of of IN 40436 130 107 finding find VBG 40436 130 108 an an DT 40436 130 109 excuse excuse NN 40436 130 110 for for IN 40436 130 111 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 130 112 refusal refusal NN 40436 130 113 . . . 40436 131 1 The the DT 40436 131 2 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 131 3 furnishes furnish VBZ 40436 131 4 an an DT 40436 131 5 excuse excuse NN 40436 131 6 106 106 CD 40436 131 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 131 8 does do VBZ 40436 131 9 not not RB 40436 131 10 always always RB 40436 131 11 , , , 40436 131 12 nor nor CC 40436 131 13 in in IN 40436 131 14 other other JJ 40436 131 15 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 131 16 , , , 40436 131 17 allude allude VB 40436 131 18 to to IN 40436 131 19 the the DT 40436 131 20 divine divine JJ 40436 131 21 sign sign NN 40436 131 22 in in IN 40436 131 23 the the DT 40436 131 24 same same JJ 40436 131 25 way way NN 40436 131 26 . . . 40436 132 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 132 2 character character NN 40436 132 3 and and CC 40436 132 4 working work VBG 40436 132 5 essentially essentially RB 40436 132 6 impenetrable impenetrable JJ 40436 132 7 . . . 40436 133 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 133 2 a a DT 40436 133 3 privileged privileged JJ 40436 133 4 person person NN 40436 133 5 _ _ NNP 40436 133 6 ib ib NN 40436 133 7 . . . 40436 133 8 _ _ NNP 40436 133 9 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 133 10 XVI XVI NNP 40436 133 11 . . . 40436 134 1 ERASTÆ ERASTÆ NNP 40436 134 2 OR or CC 40436 134 3 ANTERASTÆ ANTERASTÆ NNP 40436 134 4 -- -- : 40436 134 5 RIVALES rivale NNS 40436 134 6 . . . 40436 135 1 Erastæ erastæ JJ 40436 135 2 -- -- : 40436 135 3 subject subject NN 40436 135 4 and and CC 40436 135 5 persons person NNS 40436 135 6 of of IN 40436 135 7 the the DT 40436 135 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 135 9 -- -- : 40436 135 10 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 135 11 introduction introduction NN 40436 135 12 -- -- : 40436 135 13 interesting interesting JJ 40436 135 14 youths youth NNS 40436 135 15 in in IN 40436 135 16 the the DT 40436 135 17 palæstra palæstra NN 40436 135 18 111 111 CD 40436 135 19 Two two CD 40436 135 20 rival rival JJ 40436 135 21 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 135 22 -- -- : 40436 135 23 one one CD 40436 135 24 of of IN 40436 135 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 135 26 literary literary JJ 40436 135 27 , , , 40436 135 28 devoted devote VBN 40436 135 29 to to IN 40436 135 30 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 135 31 -- -- : 40436 135 32 the the DT 40436 135 33 other other JJ 40436 135 34 gymnastic gymnastic NN 40436 135 35 , , , 40436 135 36 hating hate VBG 40436 135 37 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 135 38 _ _ NNP 40436 135 39 ib ib UH 40436 135 40 . . . 40436 135 41 _ _ NNP 40436 135 42 Question Question NNP 40436 135 43 put put VBN 40436 135 44 by by IN 40436 135 45 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 135 46 -- -- : 40436 135 47 What what WP 40436 135 48 is be VBZ 40436 135 49 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 135 50 ? ? . 40436 136 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 136 2 is be VBZ 40436 136 3 the the DT 40436 136 4 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 136 5 accumulation accumulation NN 40436 136 6 of of IN 40436 136 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 136 8 , , , 40436 136 9 so so IN 40436 136 10 as as IN 40436 136 11 to to TO 40436 136 12 make make VB 40436 136 13 the the DT 40436 136 14 largest large JJS 40436 136 15 sum sum NN 40436 136 16 total total NN 40436 136 17 112 112 CD 40436 136 18 In in IN 40436 136 19 the the DT 40436 136 20 case case NN 40436 136 21 of of IN 40436 136 22 the the DT 40436 136 23 body body NN 40436 136 24 , , , 40436 136 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 136 26 is be VBZ 40436 136 27 not not RB 40436 136 28 the the DT 40436 136 29 maximum maximum NN 40436 136 30 of of IN 40436 136 31 exercise exercise NN 40436 136 32 which which WDT 40436 136 33 does do VBZ 40436 136 34 good good NN 40436 136 35 , , , 40436 136 36 but but CC 40436 136 37 the the DT 40436 136 38 proper proper JJ 40436 136 39 , , , 40436 136 40 measured measure VBN 40436 136 41 quantity quantity NN 40436 136 42 . . . 40436 137 1 For for IN 40436 137 2 the the DT 40436 137 3 mind mind NN 40436 137 4 also also RB 40436 137 5 , , , 40436 137 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 137 7 is be VBZ 40436 137 8 not not RB 40436 137 9 the the DT 40436 137 10 maximum maximum NN 40436 137 11 of of IN 40436 137 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 137 13 , , , 40436 137 14 but but CC 40436 137 15 the the DT 40436 137 16 measured measured JJ 40436 137 17 quantity quantity NN 40436 137 18 which which WDT 40436 137 19 is be VBZ 40436 137 20 good good JJ 40436 137 21 . . . 40436 138 1 Who who WP 40436 138 2 is be VBZ 40436 138 3 the the DT 40436 138 4 judge judge NN 40436 138 5 to to TO 40436 138 6 determine determine VB 40436 138 7 this this DT 40436 138 8 measure measure NN 40436 138 9 ? ? . 40436 139 1 _ _ NNP 40436 139 2 ib ib UH 40436 139 3 . . . 40436 139 4 _ _ NNP 40436 139 5 No no DT 40436 139 6 answer answer NN 40436 139 7 given give VBN 40436 139 8 . . . 40436 140 1 What what WP 40436 140 2 is be VBZ 40436 140 3 the the DT 40436 140 4 best good JJS 40436 140 5 conjecture conjecture NN 40436 140 6 ? ? . 40436 141 1 Answer answer NN 40436 141 2 of of IN 40436 141 3 the the DT 40436 141 4 literary literary JJ 40436 141 5 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 141 6 . . . 40436 142 1 A a DT 40436 142 2 man man NN 40436 142 3 must must MD 40436 142 4 learn learn VB 40436 142 5 that that IN 40436 142 6 which which WDT 40436 142 7 will will MD 40436 142 8 yield yield VB 40436 142 9 to to IN 40436 142 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 142 11 the the DT 40436 142 12 greatest great JJS 40436 142 13 reputation reputation NN 40436 142 14 as as IN 40436 142 15 a a DT 40436 142 16 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 142 17 -- -- : 40436 142 18 as as RB 40436 142 19 much much RB 40436 142 20 as as IN 40436 142 21 will will MD 40436 142 22 enable enable VB 40436 142 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 142 24 to to TO 40436 142 25 talk talk VB 40436 142 26 like like IN 40436 142 27 an an DT 40436 142 28 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 142 29 critic critic NN 40436 142 30 , , , 40436 142 31 though though IN 40436 142 32 not not RB 40436 142 33 to to TO 40436 142 34 practise practise VB 40436 142 35 113 113 CD 40436 142 36 The the DT 40436 142 37 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 142 38 is be VBZ 40436 142 39 one one CD 40436 142 40 who who WP 40436 142 41 is be VBZ 40436 142 42 second second RB 40436 142 43 - - HYPH 40436 142 44 best good JJS 40436 142 45 in in IN 40436 142 46 several several JJ 40436 142 47 different different JJ 40436 142 48 arts art NNS 40436 142 49 -- -- : 40436 142 50 a a DT 40436 142 51 Pentathlus pentathlus NN 40436 142 52 -- -- : 40436 142 53 who who WP 40436 142 54 talks talk VBZ 40436 142 55 well well RB 40436 142 56 upon upon IN 40436 142 57 each each DT 40436 142 58 _ _ NNP 40436 142 59 ib ib UH 40436 142 60 . . . 40436 142 61 _ _ NNP 40436 142 62 On on IN 40436 142 63 what what WDT 40436 142 64 occasions occasion NNS 40436 142 65 can can MD 40436 142 66 such such JJ 40436 142 67 second second RB 40436 142 68 - - HYPH 40436 142 69 best good JJS 40436 142 70 men man NNS 40436 142 71 be be VB 40436 142 72 useful useful JJ 40436 142 73 ? ? . 40436 143 1 There there EX 40436 143 2 are be VBP 40436 143 3 always always RB 40436 143 4 regular regular JJ 40436 143 5 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 143 6 at at IN 40436 143 7 hand hand NN 40436 143 8 , , , 40436 143 9 and and CC 40436 143 10 no no DT 40436 143 11 one one NN 40436 143 12 will will MD 40436 143 13 call call VB 40436 143 14 in in IN 40436 143 15 the the DT 40436 143 16 second second RB 40436 143 17 - - HYPH 40436 143 18 best good JJS 40436 143 19 man man NN 40436 143 20 when when WRB 40436 143 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 143 22 can can MD 40436 143 23 have have VB 40436 143 24 the the DT 40436 143 25 regular regular JJ 40436 143 26 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 143 27 114 114 CD 40436 143 28 Philosophy philosophy NN 40436 143 29 can can MD 40436 143 30 not not RB 40436 143 31 consist consist VB 40436 143 32 in in IN 40436 143 33 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 143 34 of of IN 40436 143 35 learned learn VBN 40436 143 36 acquirements acquirement NNS 40436 143 37 _ _ NNP 40436 143 38 ib ib NN 40436 143 39 . . . 40436 143 40 _ _ NNP 40436 143 41 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 143 42 changes change VBZ 40436 143 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 143 44 course course NN 40436 143 45 of of IN 40436 143 46 examination examination NN 40436 143 47 -- -- : 40436 143 48 questions question NNS 40436 143 49 put put VBP 40436 143 50 to to TO 40436 143 51 show show VB 40436 143 52 that that IN 40436 143 53 there there EX 40436 143 54 is be VBZ 40436 143 55 one one CD 40436 143 56 special special JJ 40436 143 57 art art NN 40436 143 58 , , , 40436 143 59 regal regal JJ 40436 143 60 and and CC 40436 143 61 political political JJ 40436 143 62 , , , 40436 143 63 of of IN 40436 143 64 administering administer VBG 40436 143 65 and and CC 40436 143 66 discriminating discriminate VBG 40436 143 67 the the DT 40436 143 68 bad bad JJ 40436 143 69 from from IN 40436 143 70 the the DT 40436 143 71 good good JJ 40436 143 72 115 115 CD 40436 143 73 In in IN 40436 143 74 this this DT 40436 143 75 art art NN 40436 143 76 the the DT 40436 143 77 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 143 78 must must MD 40436 143 79 not not RB 40436 143 80 only only RB 40436 143 81 be be VB 40436 143 82 second second RB 40436 143 83 - - HYPH 40436 143 84 best good JJS 40436 143 85 , , , 40436 143 86 competent competent JJ 40436 143 87 to to TO 40436 143 88 talk talk VB 40436 143 89 -- -- : 40436 143 90 but but CC 40436 143 91 he -PRON- PRP 40436 143 92 must must MD 40436 143 93 be be VB 40436 143 94 a a DT 40436 143 95 fully fully RB 40436 143 96 qualified qualified JJ 40436 143 97 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 143 98 , , , 40436 143 99 competent competent JJ 40436 143 100 to to TO 40436 143 101 act act VB 40436 143 102 _ _ NNP 40436 143 103 ib ib UH 40436 143 104 . . . 40436 143 105 _ _ NNP 40436 143 106 Close Close NNP 40436 143 107 of of IN 40436 143 108 the the DT 40436 143 109 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 143 110 -- -- : 40436 143 111 humiliation humiliation NN 40436 143 112 of of IN 40436 143 113 the the DT 40436 143 114 literary literary JJ 40436 143 115 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 143 116 116 116 CD 40436 143 117 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 143 118 -- -- : 40436 143 119 animated animate VBN 40436 143 120 manner manner NN 40436 143 121 of of IN 40436 143 122 the the DT 40436 143 123 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 143 124 _ _ NNP 40436 143 125 ib ib UH 40436 143 126 . . . 40436 143 127 _ _ NNP 40436 143 128 Definition definition NN 40436 143 129 of of IN 40436 143 130 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 143 131 -- -- : 40436 143 132 here here RB 40436 143 133 sought seek VBN 40436 143 134 for for IN 40436 143 135 the the DT 40436 143 136 first first JJ 40436 143 137 time time NN 40436 143 138 -- -- : 40436 143 139 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 143 140 conception conception NN 40436 143 141 of of IN 40436 143 142 measure measure NN 40436 143 143 -- -- : 40436 143 144 referee referee NN 40436 143 145 not not RB 40436 143 146 discovered discover VBD 40436 143 147 117 117 CD 40436 143 148 View View NNP 40436 143 149 taken take VBN 40436 143 150 of of IN 40436 143 151 the the DT 40436 143 152 second second RB 40436 143 153 - - HYPH 40436 143 154 best good JJS 40436 143 155 critical critical JJ 40436 143 156 talking talking NN 40436 143 157 man man NN 40436 143 158 , , , 40436 143 159 as as IN 40436 143 160 compared compare VBN 40436 143 161 with with IN 40436 143 162 the the DT 40436 143 163 special special JJ 40436 143 164 proficient proficient NN 40436 143 165 and and CC 40436 143 166 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 143 167 118 118 CD 40436 143 168 Plato Plato NNP 40436 143 169 's 's POS 40436 143 170 view view NN 40436 143 171 -- -- : 40436 143 172 that that IN 40436 143 173 the the DT 40436 143 174 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 143 175 has have VBZ 40436 143 176 a a DT 40436 143 177 province province NN 40436 143 178 special special JJ 40436 143 179 to to IN 40436 143 180 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 143 181 , , , 40436 143 182 distinct distinct JJ 40436 143 183 from from IN 40436 143 184 other other JJ 40436 143 185 specialties specialty NNS 40436 143 186 -- -- : 40436 143 187 dimly dimly RB 40436 143 188 indicated indicate VBN 40436 143 189 -- -- : 40436 143 190 regal regal JJ 40436 143 191 or or CC 40436 143 192 political political JJ 40436 143 193 art art NN 40436 143 194 119 119 CD 40436 143 195 Philosopher Philosopher NNP 40436 143 196 -- -- : 40436 143 197 the the DT 40436 143 198 supreme supreme NNP 40436 143 199 artist artist NNP 40436 143 200 controlling control VBG 40436 143 201 other other JJ 40436 143 202 artists artist NNS 40436 143 203 120 120 CD 40436 143 204 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 143 205 XVII XVII NNP 40436 143 206 . . . 40436 144 1 ION ION NNP 40436 144 2 . . . 40436 145 1 Ion ion VB 40436 145 2 . . . 40436 146 1 Persons person NNS 40436 146 2 of of IN 40436 146 3 the the DT 40436 146 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 146 5 . . . 40436 147 1 Difference difference NN 40436 147 2 of of IN 40436 147 3 opinion opinion NN 40436 147 4 among among IN 40436 147 5 modern modern JJ 40436 147 6 critics critic NNS 40436 147 7 as as IN 40436 147 8 to to IN 40436 147 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 147 10 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 147 11 124 124 CD 40436 147 12 Rhapsodes Rhapsodes NNPS 40436 147 13 as as IN 40436 147 14 a a DT 40436 147 15 class class NN 40436 147 16 in in IN 40436 147 17 Greece Greece NNP 40436 147 18 . . . 40436 148 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 148 2 competed compete VBD 40436 148 3 for for IN 40436 148 4 prizes prize NNS 40436 148 5 at at IN 40436 148 6 the the DT 40436 148 7 festivals festival NNS 40436 148 8 . . . 40436 149 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 149 2 has have VBZ 40436 149 3 been be VBN 40436 149 4 triumphant triumphant JJ 40436 149 5 124 124 CD 40436 149 6 Functions function NNS 40436 149 7 of of IN 40436 149 8 the the DT 40436 149 9 Rhapsodes Rhapsodes NNPS 40436 149 10 . . . 40436 150 1 Recitation recitation NN 40436 150 2 -- -- : 40436 150 3 exposition exposition NN 40436 150 4 of of IN 40436 150 5 the the DT 40436 150 6 poets poet NNS 40436 150 7 -- -- : 40436 150 8 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 40436 150 9 exposition exposition NN 40436 150 10 of of IN 40436 150 11 the the DT 40436 150 12 poets poet NNS 40436 150 13 was be VBD 40436 150 14 then then RB 40436 150 15 frequent frequent JJ 40436 150 16 125 125 CD 40436 150 17 The the DT 40436 150 18 popularity popularity NN 40436 150 19 of of IN 40436 150 20 the the DT 40436 150 21 Rhapsodes Rhapsodes NNPS 40436 150 22 was be VBD 40436 150 23 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 150 24 derived derive VBN 40436 150 25 from from IN 40436 150 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 150 27 recitation recitation NN 40436 150 28 -- -- : 40436 150 29 powerful powerful JJ 40436 150 30 effect effect NN 40436 150 31 which which WDT 40436 150 32 they -PRON- PRP 40436 150 33 produced produce VBD 40436 150 34 _ _ NNP 40436 150 35 ib ib UH 40436 150 36 . . . 40436 150 37 _ _ NNP 40436 150 38 Ion Ion NNP 40436 150 39 both both CC 40436 150 40 reciter reciter NN 40436 150 41 and and CC 40436 150 42 expositor expositor NN 40436 150 43 -- -- : 40436 150 44 Homer Homer NNP 40436 150 45 was be VBD 40436 150 46 considered consider VBN 40436 150 47 more more JJR 40436 150 48 as as IN 40436 150 49 an an DT 40436 150 50 instructor instructor NN 40436 150 51 than than IN 40436 150 52 as as IN 40436 150 53 a a DT 40436 150 54 poet poet NN 40436 150 55 126 126 CD 40436 150 56 Plato Plato NNP 40436 150 57 disregards disregard NNS 40436 150 58 and and CC 40436 150 59 disapproves disapprove VBZ 40436 150 60 the the DT 40436 150 61 poetic poetic JJ 40436 150 62 or or CC 40436 150 63 emotional emotional JJ 40436 150 64 working working NN 40436 150 65 _ _ NNP 40436 150 66 ib ib UH 40436 150 67 . . . 40436 150 68 _ _ NNP 40436 150 69 Ion Ion NNP 40436 150 70 devoted devote VBD 40436 150 71 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 150 72 to to IN 40436 150 73 Homer Homer NNP 40436 150 74 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 150 75 . . . 40436 151 1 Questions question NNS 40436 151 2 of of IN 40436 151 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 151 4 to to IN 40436 151 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 151 6 -- -- : 40436 151 7 How how WRB 40436 151 8 happens happen VBZ 40436 151 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 151 10 that that IN 40436 151 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 151 12 can can MD 40436 151 13 not not RB 40436 151 14 talk talk VB 40436 151 15 equally equally RB 40436 151 16 upon upon IN 40436 151 17 other other JJ 40436 151 18 poets poet NNS 40436 151 19 ? ? . 40436 152 1 The the DT 40436 152 2 poetic poetic JJ 40436 152 3 art art NN 40436 152 4 is be VBZ 40436 152 5 one one CD 40436 152 6 127 127 CD 40436 152 7 Explanation explanation NN 40436 152 8 given give VBN 40436 152 9 by by IN 40436 152 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 152 11 -- -- : 40436 152 12 both both CC 40436 152 13 the the DT 40436 152 14 Rhapsode Rhapsode NNP 40436 152 15 and and CC 40436 152 16 the the DT 40436 152 17 Poet Poet NNP 40436 152 18 work work NN 40436 152 19 , , , 40436 152 20 not not RB 40436 152 21 by by IN 40436 152 22 art art NN 40436 152 23 and and CC 40436 152 24 system system NN 40436 152 25 , , , 40436 152 26 but but CC 40436 152 27 by by IN 40436 152 28 divine divine JJ 40436 152 29 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 152 30 -- -- : 40436 152 31 fine fine JJ 40436 152 32 poets poet NNS 40436 152 33 are be VBP 40436 152 34 bereft bereft JJ 40436 152 35 of of IN 40436 152 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 152 37 reason reason NN 40436 152 38 , , , 40436 152 39 and and CC 40436 152 40 possessed possess VBN 40436 152 41 by by IN 40436 152 42 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 152 43 from from IN 40436 152 44 some some DT 40436 152 45 God God NNP 40436 152 46 _ _ NNP 40436 152 47 ib ib UH 40436 152 48 . . . 40436 152 49 _ _ NNP 40436 152 50 Analogy Analogy NNP 40436 152 51 of of IN 40436 152 52 the the DT 40436 152 53 Magnet Magnet NNP 40436 152 54 , , , 40436 152 55 which which WDT 40436 152 56 holds hold VBZ 40436 152 57 up up RP 40436 152 58 by by IN 40436 152 59 attraction attraction NN 40436 152 60 successive successive JJ 40436 152 61 stages stage NNS 40436 152 62 of of IN 40436 152 63 iron iron NN 40436 152 64 rings ring NNS 40436 152 65 . . . 40436 153 1 The the DT 40436 153 2 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 153 3 first first RB 40436 153 4 inspire inspire VBP 40436 153 5 Homer Homer NNP 40436 153 6 , , , 40436 153 7 then then RB 40436 153 8 act act VB 40436 153 9 through through IN 40436 153 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 153 11 and and CC 40436 153 12 through through IN 40436 153 13 Ion Ion NNP 40436 153 14 upon upon IN 40436 153 15 the the DT 40436 153 16 auditors auditor NNS 40436 153 17 128 128 CD 40436 153 18 This this DT 40436 153 19 comparison comparison NN 40436 153 20 forms form VBZ 40436 153 21 the the DT 40436 153 22 central central JJ 40436 153 23 point point NN 40436 153 24 of of IN 40436 153 25 the the DT 40436 153 26 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 153 27 . . . 40436 154 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 154 2 is be VBZ 40436 154 3 an an DT 40436 154 4 expansion expansion NN 40436 154 5 of of IN 40436 154 6 a a DT 40436 154 7 judgment judgment NN 40436 154 8 delivered deliver VBN 40436 154 9 by by IN 40436 154 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 154 11 in in IN 40436 154 12 the the DT 40436 154 13 Apology apology NN 40436 154 14 129 129 CD 40436 154 15 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 154 16 Antithesis Antithesis NNP 40436 154 17 : : : 40436 154 18 systematic systematic JJ 40436 154 19 procedure procedure NN 40436 154 20 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 154 21 from from IN 40436 154 22 unsystematic unsystematic JJ 40436 154 23 : : : 40436 154 24 which which WDT 40436 154 25 latter latter NNP 40436 154 26 was be VBD 40436 154 27 either either CC 40436 154 28 blind blind JJ 40436 154 29 routine routine JJ 40436 154 30 , , , 40436 154 31 or or CC 40436 154 32 madness madness NN 40436 154 33 inspired inspire VBN 40436 154 34 by by IN 40436 154 35 the the DT 40436 154 36 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 154 37 . . . 40436 155 1 Varieties variety NNS 40436 155 2 of of IN 40436 155 3 madness madness NN 40436 155 4 , , , 40436 155 5 good good JJ 40436 155 6 and and CC 40436 155 7 bad bad JJ 40436 155 8 129 129 CD 40436 155 9 Special special JJ 40436 155 10 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 155 11 from from IN 40436 155 12 the the DT 40436 155 13 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 155 14 was be VBD 40436 155 15 a a DT 40436 155 16 familiar familiar JJ 40436 155 17 fact fact NN 40436 155 18 in in IN 40436 155 19 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 155 20 life life NN 40436 155 21 -- -- : 40436 155 22 privileged privileged JJ 40436 155 23 communications communication NNS 40436 155 24 from from IN 40436 155 25 the the DT 40436 155 26 Gods god NNS 40436 155 27 to to IN 40436 155 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 155 29 -- -- : 40436 155 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 155 31 firm firm JJ 40436 155 32 belief belief NN 40436 155 33 in in IN 40436 155 34 them -PRON- PRP 40436 155 35 130 130 CD 40436 155 36 Condition condition NN 40436 155 37 of of IN 40436 155 38 the the DT 40436 155 39 inspired inspire VBN 40436 155 40 person person NN 40436 155 41 -- -- : 40436 155 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 155 43 reason reason NN 40436 155 44 is be VBZ 40436 155 45 for for IN 40436 155 46 the the DT 40436 155 47 time time NN 40436 155 48 withdrawn withdraw VBN 40436 155 49 131 131 CD 40436 155 50 Ion Ion NNP 40436 155 51 does do VBZ 40436 155 52 not not RB 40436 155 53 admit admit VB 40436 155 54 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 155 55 to to TO 40436 155 56 be be VB 40436 155 57 inspired inspire VBN 40436 155 58 and and CC 40436 155 59 out out IN 40436 155 60 of of IN 40436 155 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 155 62 mind mind NN 40436 155 63 132 132 CD 40436 155 64 Homer Homer NNP 40436 155 65 talks talk NNS 40436 155 66 upon upon IN 40436 155 67 all all DT 40436 155 68 subjects subject NNS 40436 155 69 -- -- : 40436 155 70 Is be VBZ 40436 155 71 Ion Ion VBN 40436 155 72 competent competent JJ 40436 155 73 to to TO 40436 155 74 explain explain VB 40436 155 75 what what WP 40436 155 76 Homer Homer NNP 40436 155 77 says say VBZ 40436 155 78 upon upon IN 40436 155 79 all all DT 40436 155 80 of of IN 40436 155 81 them -PRON- PRP 40436 155 82 ? ? . 40436 156 1 Rhapsodic rhapsodic JJ 40436 156 2 art art NN 40436 156 3 . . . 40436 157 1 What what WP 40436 157 2 is be VBZ 40436 157 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 157 4 province province NN 40436 157 5 ? ? . 40436 158 1 _ _ NNP 40436 158 2 ib ib UH 40436 158 3 . . . 40436 158 4 _ _ NNP 40436 158 5 The the DT 40436 158 6 Rhapsode Rhapsode NNP 40436 158 7 does do VBZ 40436 158 8 not not RB 40436 158 9 know know VB 40436 158 10 special special JJ 40436 158 11 matters matter NNS 40436 158 12 , , , 40436 158 13 such such JJ 40436 158 14 as as IN 40436 158 15 the the DT 40436 158 16 craft craft NN 40436 158 17 of of IN 40436 158 18 the the DT 40436 158 19 pilot pilot NN 40436 158 20 , , , 40436 158 21 physician physician NN 40436 158 22 , , , 40436 158 23 farmer farmer NN 40436 158 24 , , , 40436 158 25 & & CC 40436 158 26 c. c. NNP 40436 158 27 , , , 40436 158 28 but but CC 40436 158 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 158 30 knows know VBZ 40436 158 31 the the DT 40436 158 32 business business NN 40436 158 33 of of IN 40436 158 34 the the DT 40436 158 35 general general NN 40436 158 36 , , , 40436 158 37 and and CC 40436 158 38 is be VBZ 40436 158 39 competent competent JJ 40436 158 40 to to TO 40436 158 41 command command NN 40436 158 42 soldiers soldier NNS 40436 158 43 , , , 40436 158 44 having have VBG 40436 158 45 learnt learn VBN 40436 158 46 it -PRON- PRP 40436 158 47 from from IN 40436 158 48 Homer Homer NNP 40436 158 49 133 133 CD 40436 158 50 Conclusion Conclusion NNP 40436 158 51 . . . 40436 159 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 159 2 expounds expound NNS 40436 159 3 Homer Homer NNP 40436 159 4 , , , 40436 159 5 not not RB 40436 159 6 with with IN 40436 159 7 any any DT 40436 159 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 159 9 of of IN 40436 159 10 what what WP 40436 159 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 159 12 says say VBZ 40436 159 13 , , , 40436 159 14 but but CC 40436 159 15 by by IN 40436 159 16 divine divine JJ 40436 159 17 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 159 18 134 134 CD 40436 159 19 The the DT 40436 159 20 generals general NNS 40436 159 21 in in IN 40436 159 22 Greece Greece NNP 40436 159 23 usually usually RB 40436 159 24 possessed possess VBD 40436 159 25 no no DT 40436 159 26 professional professional JJ 40436 159 27 experience experience NN 40436 159 28 -- -- : 40436 159 29 Homer Homer NNP 40436 159 30 and and CC 40436 159 31 the the DT 40436 159 32 poets poet NNS 40436 159 33 were be VBD 40436 159 34 talked talk VBN 40436 159 35 of of IN 40436 159 36 as as IN 40436 159 37 the the DT 40436 159 38 great great JJ 40436 159 39 teachers teacher NNS 40436 159 40 -- -- : 40436 159 41 Plato Plato NNP 40436 159 42 's 's POS 40436 159 43 view view NN 40436 159 44 of of IN 40436 159 45 the the DT 40436 159 46 poet poet NN 40436 159 47 , , , 40436 159 48 as as IN 40436 159 49 pretending pretend VBG 40436 159 50 to to TO 40436 159 51 know know VB 40436 159 52 everything everything NN 40436 159 53 , , , 40436 159 54 but but CC 40436 159 55 really really RB 40436 159 56 knowing know VBG 40436 159 57 nothing nothing NN 40436 159 58 _ _ NNP 40436 159 59 ib ib UH 40436 159 60 . . . 40436 159 61 _ _ NNP 40436 159 62 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 40436 159 63 , , , 40436 159 64 opposed oppose VBN 40436 159 65 to to TO 40436 159 66 divine divine JJ 40436 159 67 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 159 68 without without IN 40436 159 69 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 159 70 136 136 CD 40436 159 71 Illustration Illustration NNP 40436 159 72 of of IN 40436 159 73 Plato Plato NNP 40436 159 74 's 's POS 40436 159 75 opinion opinion NN 40436 159 76 respecting respect VBG 40436 159 77 the the DT 40436 159 78 uselessness uselessness NN 40436 159 79 of of IN 40436 159 80 written write VBN 40436 159 81 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 159 82 treatises treatise NNS 40436 159 83 _ _ NNP 40436 159 84 ib ib UH 40436 159 85 . . . 40436 159 86 _ _ NNP 40436 159 87 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 159 88 XVIII XVIII NNP 40436 159 89 . . . 40436 160 1 LACHES LACHES NNP 40436 160 2 . . . 40436 161 1 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 161 2 . . . 40436 162 1 Subject subject JJ 40436 162 2 and and CC 40436 162 3 persons person NNS 40436 162 4 of of IN 40436 162 5 the the DT 40436 162 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 162 7 -- -- : 40436 162 8 whether whether IN 40436 162 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 162 10 is be VBZ 40436 162 11 useful useful JJ 40436 162 12 that that IN 40436 162 13 two two CD 40436 162 14 young young JJ 40436 162 15 men man NNS 40436 162 16 should should MD 40436 162 17 receive receive VB 40436 162 18 lessons lesson NNS 40436 162 19 from from IN 40436 162 20 a a DT 40436 162 21 master master NN 40436 162 22 of of IN 40436 162 23 arms arm NNS 40436 162 24 . . . 40436 163 1 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 163 2 and and CC 40436 163 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 163 4 differ differ VBP 40436 163 5 in in IN 40436 163 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 163 7 138 138 CD 40436 163 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 163 9 is be VBZ 40436 163 10 invited invite VBN 40436 163 11 to to TO 40436 163 12 declare declare VB 40436 163 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 163 14 opinion opinion NN 40436 163 15 -- -- : 40436 163 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 163 17 replies reply VBZ 40436 163 18 that that IN 40436 163 19 the the DT 40436 163 20 point point NN 40436 163 21 can can MD 40436 163 22 not not RB 40436 163 23 be be VB 40436 163 24 decided decide VBN 40436 163 25 without without IN 40436 163 26 a a DT 40436 163 27 competent competent JJ 40436 163 28 professional professional JJ 40436 163 29 judge judge NN 40436 163 30 139 139 CD 40436 163 31 Those those DT 40436 163 32 who who WP 40436 163 33 deliver deliver VBP 40436 163 34 an an DT 40436 163 35 opinion opinion NN 40436 163 36 must must MD 40436 163 37 begin begin VB 40436 163 38 by by IN 40436 163 39 proving prove VBG 40436 163 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 163 41 competence competence NN 40436 163 42 to to TO 40436 163 43 judge judge VB 40436 163 44 -- -- : 40436 163 45 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 163 46 avows avow VBZ 40436 163 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 163 48 own own JJ 40436 163 49 incompetence incompetence NN 40436 163 50 140 140 CD 40436 163 51 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 163 52 and and CC 40436 163 53 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 163 54 submit submit VBP 40436 163 55 to to TO 40436 163 56 be be VB 40436 163 57 cross cros VBN 40436 163 58 - - VBN 40436 163 59 examined examine VBN 40436 163 60 by by IN 40436 163 61 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 163 62 141 141 CD 40436 163 63 Both both DT 40436 163 64 of of IN 40436 163 65 them -PRON- PRP 40436 163 66 give give VBP 40436 163 67 opinions opinion NNS 40436 163 68 offhand offhand JJ 40436 163 69 , , , 40436 163 70 according accord VBG 40436 163 71 to to IN 40436 163 72 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 163 73 feelings feeling NNS 40436 163 74 on on IN 40436 163 75 the the DT 40436 163 76 special special JJ 40436 163 77 case case NN 40436 163 78 -- -- : 40436 163 79 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 163 80 requires require VBZ 40436 163 81 that that IN 40436 163 82 the the DT 40436 163 83 question question NN 40436 163 84 shall shall MD 40436 163 85 be be VB 40436 163 86 generalised generalise VBN 40436 163 87 , , , 40436 163 88 and and CC 40436 163 89 examined examine VBD 40436 163 90 as as IN 40436 163 91 a a DT 40436 163 92 branch branch NN 40436 163 93 of of IN 40436 163 94 education education NN 40436 163 95 141 141 CD 40436 163 96 Appeal appeal NN 40436 163 97 of of IN 40436 163 98 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 163 99 to to IN 40436 163 100 the the DT 40436 163 101 judgment judgment NN 40436 163 102 of of IN 40436 163 103 the the DT 40436 163 104 One one CD 40436 163 105 Wise Wise NNP 40436 163 106 Man Man NNP 40436 163 107 -- -- : 40436 163 108 this this DT 40436 163 109 man man NN 40436 163 110 is be VBZ 40436 163 111 never never RB 40436 163 112 seen see VBN 40436 163 113 or or CC 40436 163 114 identified identify VBN 40436 163 115 142 142 CD 40436 163 116 We -PRON- PRP 40436 163 117 must must MD 40436 163 118 know know VB 40436 163 119 what what WP 40436 163 120 virtue virtue NN 40436 163 121 is be VBZ 40436 163 122 , , , 40436 163 123 before before IN 40436 163 124 we -PRON- PRP 40436 163 125 give give VBP 40436 163 126 an an DT 40436 163 127 opinion opinion NN 40436 163 128 on on IN 40436 163 129 education education NN 40436 163 130 -- -- : 40436 163 131 virtue virtue NN 40436 163 132 , , , 40436 163 133 as as IN 40436 163 134 a a DT 40436 163 135 whole whole NN 40436 163 136 , , , 40436 163 137 is be VBZ 40436 163 138 too too RB 40436 163 139 large large JJ 40436 163 140 a a DT 40436 163 141 question question NN 40436 163 142 -- -- : 40436 163 143 we -PRON- PRP 40436 163 144 will will MD 40436 163 145 enquire enquire VB 40436 163 146 about about IN 40436 163 147 one one CD 40436 163 148 branch branch NN 40436 163 149 of of IN 40436 163 150 virtue virtue NN 40436 163 151 -- -- : 40436 163 152 courage courage NN 40436 163 153 _ _ NNP 40436 163 154 ib ib UH 40436 163 155 . . . 40436 163 156 _ _ NNP 40436 163 157 Question Question NNP 40436 163 158 -- -- : 40436 163 159 what what WP 40436 163 160 is be VBZ 40436 163 161 courage courage NN 40436 163 162 ? ? . 40436 164 1 Laches laches NN 40436 164 2 answers answer NNS 40436 164 3 by by IN 40436 164 4 citing cite VBG 40436 164 5 one one CD 40436 164 6 particularly particularly RB 40436 164 7 manifest manif JJS 40436 164 8 case case NN 40436 164 9 of of IN 40436 164 10 courage courage NN 40436 164 11 -- -- : 40436 164 12 mistake mistake NN 40436 164 13 of of IN 40436 164 14 not not RB 40436 164 15 giving give VBG 40436 164 16 a a DT 40436 164 17 general general JJ 40436 164 18 explanation explanation NN 40436 164 19 143 143 CD 40436 164 20 Second second JJ 40436 164 21 answer answer NN 40436 164 22 . . . 40436 165 1 Courage courage NN 40436 165 2 is be VBZ 40436 165 3 a a DT 40436 165 4 sort sort NN 40436 165 5 of of IN 40436 165 6 endurance endurance NN 40436 165 7 of of IN 40436 165 8 the the DT 40436 165 9 mind mind NN 40436 165 10 -- -- : 40436 165 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 165 12 points point VBZ 40436 165 13 out out RP 40436 165 14 that that IN 40436 165 15 the the DT 40436 165 16 answer answer NN 40436 165 17 is be VBZ 40436 165 18 vague vague JJ 40436 165 19 and and CC 40436 165 20 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 165 21 -- -- : 40436 165 22 endurance endurance NN 40436 165 23 is be VBZ 40436 165 24 not not RB 40436 165 25 always always RB 40436 165 26 courage courage NN 40436 165 27 : : : 40436 165 28 even even RB 40436 165 29 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 165 30 endurance endurance NN 40436 165 31 is be VBZ 40436 165 32 not not RB 40436 165 33 always always RB 40436 165 34 courage courage VB 40436 165 35 _ _ NNP 40436 165 36 ib ib UH 40436 165 37 . . . 40436 165 38 _ _ NNP 40436 165 39 Confusion Confusion NNP 40436 165 40 . . . 40436 166 1 New new JJ 40436 166 2 answer answer NN 40436 166 3 given give VBN 40436 166 4 by by IN 40436 166 5 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 166 6 . . . 40436 167 1 Courage courage NN 40436 167 2 is be VBZ 40436 167 3 a a DT 40436 167 4 sort sort NN 40436 167 5 of of IN 40436 167 6 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 167 7 -- -- : 40436 167 8 the the DT 40436 167 9 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 167 10 of of IN 40436 167 11 things thing NNS 40436 167 12 terrible terrible JJ 40436 167 13 and and CC 40436 167 14 not not RB 40436 167 15 terrible terrible JJ 40436 167 16 . . . 40436 168 1 Objections objection NNS 40436 168 2 of of IN 40436 168 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 168 4 144 144 CD 40436 168 5 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 168 6 of of IN 40436 168 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 168 8 to to IN 40436 168 9 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 168 10 . . . 40436 169 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 169 2 is be VBZ 40436 169 3 only only RB 40436 169 4 future future JJ 40436 169 5 events event NNS 40436 169 6 , , , 40436 169 7 not not RB 40436 169 8 past past JJ 40436 169 9 or or CC 40436 169 10 present present JJ 40436 169 11 , , , 40436 169 12 which which WDT 40436 169 13 are be VBP 40436 169 14 terrible terrible JJ 40436 169 15 ; ; : 40436 169 16 but but CC 40436 169 17 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 169 18 of of IN 40436 169 19 future future JJ 40436 169 20 events event NNS 40436 169 21 can can MD 40436 169 22 not not RB 40436 169 23 be be VB 40436 169 24 had have VBN 40436 169 25 without without IN 40436 169 26 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 169 27 of of IN 40436 169 28 past past NN 40436 169 29 or or CC 40436 169 30 present present JJ 40436 169 31 145 145 CD 40436 169 32 Courage courage NN 40436 169 33 therefore therefore RB 40436 169 34 must must MD 40436 169 35 be be VB 40436 169 36 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 169 37 of of IN 40436 169 38 good good JJ 40436 169 39 and and CC 40436 169 40 evil evil NN 40436 169 41 generally generally RB 40436 169 42 . . . 40436 170 1 But but CC 40436 170 2 this this DT 40436 170 3 definition definition NN 40436 170 4 would would MD 40436 170 5 include include VB 40436 170 6 the the DT 40436 170 7 whole whole NN 40436 170 8 of of IN 40436 170 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 170 10 , , , 40436 170 11 and and CC 40436 170 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 170 13 declared declare VBD 40436 170 14 that that DT 40436 170 15 courage courage NN 40436 170 16 was be VBD 40436 170 17 only only RB 40436 170 18 a a DT 40436 170 19 part part NN 40436 170 20 thereof thereof RB 40436 170 21 -- -- : 40436 170 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 170 23 will will MD 40436 170 24 not not RB 40436 170 25 hold hold VB 40436 170 26 therefore therefore RB 40436 170 27 as as IN 40436 170 28 a a DT 40436 170 29 definition definition NN 40436 170 30 of of IN 40436 170 31 courage courage NN 40436 170 32 146 146 CD 40436 170 33 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 170 34 . . . 40436 171 1 Warfare warfare NN 40436 171 2 of of IN 40436 171 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 171 4 against against IN 40436 171 5 the the DT 40436 171 6 false false JJ 40436 171 7 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 171 8 of of IN 40436 171 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 171 10 . . . 40436 172 1 Brave brave JJ 40436 172 2 generals general NNS 40436 172 3 deliver deliver VBP 40436 172 4 opinions opinion NNS 40436 172 5 confidently confidently RB 40436 172 6 about about IN 40436 172 7 courage courage NN 40436 172 8 without without IN 40436 172 9 knowing know VBG 40436 172 10 what what WP 40436 172 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 172 12 is be VBZ 40436 172 13 _ _ NNP 40436 172 14 ib ib UH 40436 172 15 . . . 40436 172 16 _ _ NNP 40436 172 17 No no DT 40436 172 18 solution solution NN 40436 172 19 given give VBN 40436 172 20 by by IN 40436 172 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 172 22 -- -- : 40436 172 23 apparent apparent JJ 40436 172 24 tendency tendency NN 40436 172 25 of of IN 40436 172 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 172 27 mind mind NN 40436 172 28 , , , 40436 172 29 in in IN 40436 172 30 looking look VBG 40436 172 31 for for IN 40436 172 32 a a DT 40436 172 33 solution solution NN 40436 172 34 . . . 40436 173 1 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 173 2 -- -- : 40436 173 3 cannot cannot NN 40436 173 4 be be VB 40436 173 5 understood understand VBN 40436 173 6 without without IN 40436 173 7 reference reference NN 40436 173 8 to to IN 40436 173 9 some some DT 40436 173 10 object object NN 40436 173 11 or or CC 40436 173 12 end end VB 40436 173 13 147 147 CD 40436 173 14 Object object NN 40436 173 15 -- -- : 40436 173 16 is be VBZ 40436 173 17 supplied supply VBN 40436 173 18 in in IN 40436 173 19 the the DT 40436 173 20 answer answer NN 40436 173 21 of of IN 40436 173 22 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 173 23 . . . 40436 174 1 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 174 2 -- -- : 40436 174 3 of of IN 40436 174 4 things thing NNS 40436 174 5 terrible terrible JJ 40436 174 6 and and CC 40436 174 7 not not RB 40436 174 8 terrible terrible JJ 40436 174 9 . . . 40436 175 1 Such such JJ 40436 175 2 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 175 3 is be VBZ 40436 175 4 not not RB 40436 175 5 possessed possess VBN 40436 175 6 by by IN 40436 175 7 professional professional JJ 40436 175 8 artists artist NNS 40436 175 9 148 148 CD 40436 175 10 Postulate Postulate NNP 40436 175 11 of of IN 40436 175 12 a a DT 40436 175 13 Science Science NNP 40436 175 14 of of IN 40436 175 15 Ends Ends NNPS 40436 175 16 , , , 40436 175 17 or or CC 40436 175 18 Teleology teleology NN 40436 175 19 , , , 40436 175 20 dimly dimly RB 40436 175 21 indicated indicate VBN 40436 175 22 by by IN 40436 175 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 175 24 . . . 40436 176 1 The the DT 40436 176 2 Unknown unknown JJ 40436 176 3 Wise Wise NNP 40436 176 4 Man Man NNP 40436 176 5 -- -- : 40436 176 6 correlates correlate VBZ 40436 176 7 with with IN 40436 176 8 the the DT 40436 176 9 undiscovered undiscovered JJ 40436 176 10 Science Science NNP 40436 176 11 of of IN 40436 176 12 Ends Ends NNPS 40436 176 13 _ _ NNP 40436 176 14 ib ib UH 40436 176 15 . . . 40436 176 16 _ _ NNP 40436 176 17 Perfect perfect JJ 40436 176 18 condition condition NN 40436 176 19 of of IN 40436 176 20 the the DT 40436 176 21 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 176 22 -- -- : 40436 176 23 is be VBZ 40436 176 24 the the DT 40436 176 25 one one CD 40436 176 26 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 176 27 condition condition NN 40436 176 28 of of IN 40436 176 29 virtue virtue NN 40436 176 30 149 149 CD 40436 176 31 Dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 176 32 contrast contrast NN 40436 176 33 between between IN 40436 176 34 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 176 35 and and CC 40436 176 36 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 176 37 , , , 40436 176 38 as as IN 40436 176 39 cross cross NN 40436 176 40 - - NNS 40436 176 41 examiners examiner VBZ 40436 176 42 150 150 CD 40436 176 43 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 176 44 XIX xix NN 40436 176 45 . . . 40436 177 1 CHARMIDES charmide NNS 40436 177 2 . . . 40436 178 1 Scene scene NN 40436 178 2 and and CC 40436 178 3 personages personage NNS 40436 178 4 of of IN 40436 178 5 the the DT 40436 178 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 178 7 . . . 40436 179 1 Crowded crowd VBN 40436 179 2 palæstra palæstra NNP 40436 179 3 . . . 40436 180 1 Emotions emotion NNS 40436 180 2 of of IN 40436 180 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 180 4 153 153 CD 40436 180 5 Question Question NNP 40436 180 6 , , , 40436 180 7 What what WP 40436 180 8 is be VBZ 40436 180 9 Temperance temperance NN 40436 180 10 ? ? . 40436 181 1 addressed address VBN 40436 181 2 by by IN 40436 181 3 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 181 4 to to IN 40436 181 5 the the DT 40436 181 6 temperate temperate NN 40436 181 7 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 181 8 . . . 40436 182 1 Answer answer VB 40436 182 2 , , , 40436 182 3 It -PRON- PRP 40436 182 4 is be VBZ 40436 182 5 a a DT 40436 182 6 kind kind NN 40436 182 7 of of IN 40436 182 8 sedateness sedateness NN 40436 182 9 or or CC 40436 182 10 slowness slowness VB 40436 182 11 154 154 CD 40436 182 12 But but CC 40436 182 13 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 182 14 is be VBZ 40436 182 15 a a DT 40436 182 16 fine fine JJ 40436 182 17 or or CC 40436 182 18 honourable honourable JJ 40436 182 19 thing thing NN 40436 182 20 , , , 40436 182 21 and and CC 40436 182 22 slowness slowness NN 40436 182 23 is be VBZ 40436 182 24 , , , 40436 182 25 in in IN 40436 182 26 many many JJ 40436 182 27 or or CC 40436 182 28 most most JJS 40436 182 29 cases case NNS 40436 182 30 , , , 40436 182 31 not not RB 40436 182 32 fine fine JJ 40436 182 33 or or CC 40436 182 34 honourable honourable JJ 40436 182 35 , , , 40436 182 36 but but CC 40436 182 37 the the DT 40436 182 38 contrary contrary NN 40436 182 39 . . . 40436 183 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 183 2 can can MD 40436 183 3 not not RB 40436 183 4 be be VB 40436 183 5 slowness slowness JJ 40436 183 6 _ _ NNP 40436 183 7 ib ib UH 40436 183 8 . . . 40436 183 9 _ _ NNP 40436 183 10 Second second JJ 40436 183 11 answer answer NN 40436 183 12 . . . 40436 184 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 184 2 is be VBZ 40436 184 3 a a DT 40436 184 4 variety variety NN 40436 184 5 of of IN 40436 184 6 the the DT 40436 184 7 feeling feeling NN 40436 184 8 of of IN 40436 184 9 shame shame NN 40436 184 10 . . . 40436 185 1 Refuted refute VBN 40436 185 2 by by IN 40436 185 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 185 4 _ _ NNP 40436 185 5 ib ib NN 40436 185 6 . . . 40436 185 7 _ _ NNP 40436 185 8 Third Third NNP 40436 185 9 answer answer NN 40436 185 10 . . . 40436 186 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 186 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 186 3 in in IN 40436 186 4 doing do VBG 40436 186 5 one one PRP 40436 186 6 's 's POS 40436 186 7 own own JJ 40436 186 8 business business NN 40436 186 9 . . . 40436 187 1 Defended defend VBN 40436 187 2 by by IN 40436 187 3 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 187 4 . . . 40436 188 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 188 2 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 188 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 188 4 a a DT 40436 188 5 riddle riddle NN 40436 188 6 , , , 40436 188 7 and and CC 40436 188 8 refutes refute VBZ 40436 188 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 188 10 . . . 40436 189 1 Distinction distinction NN 40436 189 2 between between IN 40436 189 3 making make VBG 40436 189 4 and and CC 40436 189 5 doing do VBG 40436 189 6 155 155 CD 40436 189 7 Fourth fourth JJ 40436 189 8 answer answer NN 40436 189 9 , , , 40436 189 10 by by IN 40436 189 11 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 189 12 . . . 40436 190 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 190 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 190 3 in in IN 40436 190 4 self self NN 40436 190 5 - - HYPH 40436 190 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 190 7 . . . 40436 191 1 _ _ NNP 40436 191 2 ib ib UH 40436 191 3 . . . 40436 191 4 _ _ NNP 40436 191 5 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 191 6 of of IN 40436 191 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 191 8 thereupon thereupon RB 40436 191 9 . . . 40436 192 1 What what WDT 40436 192 2 good good NN 40436 192 3 does do VBZ 40436 192 4 self self NN 40436 192 5 - - HYPH 40436 192 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 192 7 procure procure NN 40436 192 8 for for IN 40436 192 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 192 10 ? ? . 40436 193 1 What what WP 40436 193 2 is be VBZ 40436 193 3 the the DT 40436 193 4 object object NN 40436 193 5 known know VBN 40436 193 6 , , , 40436 193 7 in in IN 40436 193 8 this this DT 40436 193 9 case case NN 40436 193 10 ? ? . 40436 194 1 Answer answer NN 40436 194 2 : : : 40436 194 3 There there EX 40436 194 4 is be VBZ 40436 194 5 no no DT 40436 194 6 object object NN 40436 194 7 of of IN 40436 194 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 194 9 , , , 40436 194 10 distinct distinct JJ 40436 194 11 from from IN 40436 194 12 the the DT 40436 194 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 194 14 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 194 15 156 156 CD 40436 194 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 194 17 doubts doubt VBZ 40436 194 18 the the DT 40436 194 19 possibility possibility NN 40436 194 20 of of IN 40436 194 21 any any DT 40436 194 22 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 194 23 , , , 40436 194 24 without without IN 40436 194 25 a a DT 40436 194 26 given give VBN 40436 194 27 _ _ NNP 40436 194 28 cognitum cognitum NN 40436 194 29 _ _ NNP 40436 194 30 as as IN 40436 194 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 194 32 object object NN 40436 194 33 . . . 40436 195 1 Analogies analogy NNS 40436 195 2 to to TO 40436 195 3 prove prove VB 40436 195 4 that that DT 40436 195 5 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 195 6 of of IN 40436 195 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 195 8 is be VBZ 40436 195 9 impossible impossible JJ 40436 195 10 156 156 CD 40436 195 11 All all DT 40436 195 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 195 13 must must MD 40436 195 14 be be VB 40436 195 15 relative relative JJ 40436 195 16 to to IN 40436 195 17 some some DT 40436 195 18 object object NN 40436 195 19 157 157 CD 40436 195 20 All all DT 40436 195 21 properties property NNS 40436 195 22 are be VBP 40436 195 23 relative relative JJ 40436 195 24 -- -- : 40436 195 25 every every DT 40436 195 26 thing thing NN 40436 195 27 in in IN 40436 195 28 nature nature NN 40436 195 29 has have VBZ 40436 195 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 195 31 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 195 32 property property NN 40436 195 33 with with IN 40436 195 34 reference reference NN 40436 195 35 to to IN 40436 195 36 something something NN 40436 195 37 else else RB 40436 195 38 _ _ NNP 40436 195 39 ib ib UH 40436 195 40 . . . 40436 195 41 _ _ NNP 40436 195 42 Even even RB 40436 195 43 if if IN 40436 195 44 cognition cognition NN 40436 195 45 of of IN 40436 195 46 cognition cognition NN 40436 195 47 were be VBD 40436 195 48 possible possible JJ 40436 195 49 , , , 40436 195 50 cognition cognition NN 40436 195 51 of of IN 40436 195 52 non non JJ 40436 195 53 - - NN 40436 195 54 cognition cognition NN 40436 195 55 would would MD 40436 195 56 be be VB 40436 195 57 impossible impossible JJ 40436 195 58 . . . 40436 196 1 A a DT 40436 196 2 man man NN 40436 196 3 may may MD 40436 196 4 know know VB 40436 196 5 what what WP 40436 196 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 196 7 knows know VBZ 40436 196 8 , , , 40436 196 9 but but CC 40436 196 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 196 11 can can MD 40436 196 12 not not RB 40436 196 13 know know VB 40436 196 14 what what WP 40436 196 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 196 16 is be VBZ 40436 196 17 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 196 18 of of IN 40436 196 19 . . . 40436 197 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 197 2 knows know VBZ 40436 197 3 the the DT 40436 197 4 fact fact NN 40436 197 5 _ _ IN 40436 197 6 that that IN 40436 197 7 _ _ NNP 40436 197 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 197 9 knows know VBZ 40436 197 10 : : : 40436 197 11 but but CC 40436 197 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 197 13 does do VBZ 40436 197 14 not not RB 40436 197 15 know know VB 40436 197 16 how how WRB 40436 197 17 much much JJ 40436 197 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 197 19 knows know VBZ 40436 197 20 , , , 40436 197 21 and and CC 40436 197 22 how how WRB 40436 197 23 much much JJ 40436 197 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 197 25 does do VBZ 40436 197 26 not not RB 40436 197 27 know know VB 40436 197 28 158 158 CD 40436 197 29 Temperance temperance NN 40436 197 30 , , , 40436 197 31 therefore therefore RB 40436 197 32 , , , 40436 197 33 as as IN 40436 197 34 thus thus RB 40436 197 35 defined define VBN 40436 197 36 , , , 40436 197 37 would would MD 40436 197 38 be be VB 40436 197 39 of of IN 40436 197 40 little little JJ 40436 197 41 or or CC 40436 197 42 no no DT 40436 197 43 value value NN 40436 197 44 159 159 CD 40436 197 45 But but CC 40436 197 46 even even RB 40436 197 47 granting grant VBG 40436 197 48 the the DT 40436 197 49 possibility possibility NN 40436 197 50 of of IN 40436 197 51 that that DT 40436 197 52 which which WDT 40436 197 53 has have VBZ 40436 197 54 just just RB 40436 197 55 been be VBN 40436 197 56 denied deny VBN 40436 197 57 , , , 40436 197 58 still still RB 40436 197 59 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 197 60 would would MD 40436 197 61 be be VB 40436 197 62 of of IN 40436 197 63 little little JJ 40436 197 64 value value NN 40436 197 65 . . . 40436 198 1 Suppose suppose VB 40436 198 2 that that IN 40436 198 3 all all DT 40436 198 4 separate separate JJ 40436 198 5 work work NN 40436 198 6 were be VBD 40436 198 7 well well RB 40436 198 8 performed perform VBN 40436 198 9 , , , 40436 198 10 by by IN 40436 198 11 special special JJ 40436 198 12 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 198 13 , , , 40436 198 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 198 15 should should MD 40436 198 16 not not RB 40436 198 17 attain attain VB 40436 198 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 198 19 end end NN 40436 198 20 -- -- : 40436 198 21 Happiness Happiness NNP 40436 198 22 _ _ NNP 40436 198 23 ib ib UH 40436 198 24 . . . 40436 198 25 _ _ NNP 40436 198 26 Which which WDT 40436 198 27 of of IN 40436 198 28 the the DT 40436 198 29 varieties variety NNS 40436 198 30 of of IN 40436 198 31 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 198 32 contributes contribute VBZ 40436 198 33 most most RBS 40436 198 34 to to IN 40436 198 35 well well RB 40436 198 36 - - HYPH 40436 198 37 doing doing NN 40436 198 38 or or CC 40436 198 39 happiness happiness NN 40436 198 40 ? ? . 40436 199 1 That that IN 40436 199 2 by by IN 40436 199 3 which which WDT 40436 199 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 199 5 know know VBP 40436 199 6 good good JJ 40436 199 7 and and CC 40436 199 8 evil evil JJ 40436 199 9 160 160 CD 40436 199 10 Without without IN 40436 199 11 the the DT 40436 199 12 science science NN 40436 199 13 of of IN 40436 199 14 good good NN 40436 199 15 and and CC 40436 199 16 evil evil NN 40436 199 17 , , , 40436 199 18 the the DT 40436 199 19 other other JJ 40436 199 20 special special JJ 40436 199 21 science science NN 40436 199 22 will will MD 40436 199 23 be be VB 40436 199 24 of of IN 40436 199 25 little little JJ 40436 199 26 or or CC 40436 199 27 of of IN 40436 199 28 no no DT 40436 199 29 service service NN 40436 199 30 . . . 40436 200 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 200 2 is be VBZ 40436 200 3 not not RB 40436 200 4 the the DT 40436 200 5 science science NN 40436 200 6 of of IN 40436 200 7 good good NN 40436 200 8 and and CC 40436 200 9 evil evil NN 40436 200 10 , , , 40436 200 11 and and CC 40436 200 12 is be VBZ 40436 200 13 of of IN 40436 200 14 little little JJ 40436 200 15 service service NN 40436 200 16 161 161 CD 40436 200 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 200 18 confesses confess VBZ 40436 200 19 to to IN 40436 200 20 entire entire JJ 40436 200 21 failure failure NN 40436 200 22 in in IN 40436 200 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 200 24 research research NN 40436 200 25 . . . 40436 201 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 201 2 can can MD 40436 201 3 not not RB 40436 201 4 find find VB 40436 201 5 out out RP 40436 201 6 what what WP 40436 201 7 temperance temperance NN 40436 201 8 is be VBZ 40436 201 9 : : : 40436 201 10 although although IN 40436 201 11 several several JJ 40436 201 12 concessions concession NNS 40436 201 13 have have VBP 40436 201 14 been be VBN 40436 201 15 made make VBN 40436 201 16 which which WDT 40436 201 17 can can MD 40436 201 18 not not RB 40436 201 19 be be VB 40436 201 20 justified justify VBN 40436 201 21 _ _ NNP 40436 201 22 ib ib NN 40436 201 23 . . . 40436 201 24 _ _ NNP 40436 201 25 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 201 26 is be VBZ 40436 201 27 and and CC 40436 201 28 must must MD 40436 201 29 be be VB 40436 201 30 a a DT 40436 201 31 good good JJ 40436 201 32 thing thing NN 40436 201 33 : : : 40436 201 34 but but CC 40436 201 35 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 201 36 can can MD 40436 201 37 not not RB 40436 201 38 tell tell VB 40436 201 39 whether whether IN 40436 201 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 201 41 is be VBZ 40436 201 42 temperate temperate NN 40436 201 43 or or CC 40436 201 44 not not RB 40436 201 45 ; ; : 40436 201 46 since since IN 40436 201 47 what what WDT 40436 201 48 temperance temperance NN 40436 201 49 is be VBZ 40436 201 50 remains remain VBZ 40436 201 51 unknown unknown JJ 40436 201 52 162 162 CD 40436 201 53 Expressions expression NNS 40436 201 54 both both CC 40436 201 55 from from IN 40436 201 56 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 201 57 and and CC 40436 201 58 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 201 59 of of IN 40436 201 60 praise praise NN 40436 201 61 and and CC 40436 201 62 devotion devotion NN 40436 201 63 to to IN 40436 201 64 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 201 65 , , , 40436 201 66 at at IN 40436 201 67 the the DT 40436 201 68 close close NN 40436 201 69 of of IN 40436 201 70 the the DT 40436 201 71 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 201 72 . . . 40436 202 1 Dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 202 2 ornament ornament NN 40436 202 3 throughout throughout IN 40436 202 4 _ _ NNP 40436 202 5 ib ib UH 40436 202 6 . . . 40436 202 7 _ _ NNP 40436 202 8 The the DT 40436 202 9 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 202 10 is be VBZ 40436 202 11 an an DT 40436 202 12 excellent excellent JJ 40436 202 13 specimen speciman NNS 40436 202 14 of of IN 40436 202 15 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 202 16 of of IN 40436 202 17 Search Search NNP 40436 202 18 . . . 40436 203 1 Abundance abundance NN 40436 203 2 of of IN 40436 203 3 guesses guess NNS 40436 203 4 and and CC 40436 203 5 tentatives tentative NNS 40436 203 6 , , , 40436 203 7 all all DT 40436 203 8 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 203 9 disallowed disallow VBD 40436 203 10 163 163 CD 40436 203 11 Trial Trial NNP 40436 203 12 and and CC 40436 203 13 Error Error NNP 40436 203 14 , , , 40436 203 15 the the DT 40436 203 16 natural natural JJ 40436 203 17 process process NN 40436 203 18 of of IN 40436 203 19 the the DT 40436 203 20 human human JJ 40436 203 21 mind mind NN 40436 203 22 . . . 40436 204 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 204 2 stands stand VBZ 40436 204 3 alone alone RB 40436 204 4 in in IN 40436 204 5 bringing bring VBG 40436 204 6 to to TO 40436 204 7 view view VB 40436 204 8 and and CC 40436 204 9 dramatising dramatise VBG 40436 204 10 this this DT 40436 204 11 part part NN 40436 204 12 of of IN 40436 204 13 the the DT 40436 204 14 mental mental JJ 40436 204 15 process process NN 40436 204 16 . . . 40436 205 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 205 2 accepts accept VBZ 40436 205 3 for for IN 40436 205 4 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 205 5 the the DT 40436 205 6 condition condition NN 40436 205 7 of of IN 40436 205 8 conscious conscious JJ 40436 205 9 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 205 10 164 164 CD 40436 205 11 Familiar familiar JJ 40436 205 12 words word NNS 40436 205 13 -- -- : 40436 205 14 constantly constantly RB 40436 205 15 used use VBN 40436 205 16 , , , 40436 205 17 with with IN 40436 205 18 much much RB 40436 205 19 earnest earnest JJ 40436 205 20 feeling feeling NN 40436 205 21 , , , 40436 205 22 but but CC 40436 205 23 never never RB 40436 205 24 understood understand VBD 40436 205 25 nor nor CC 40436 205 26 defined define VBN 40436 205 27 -- -- : 40436 205 28 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 205 29 phenomenon phenomenon NN 40436 205 30 in in IN 40436 205 31 human human JJ 40436 205 32 society society NN 40436 205 33 165 165 CD 40436 205 34 Different different JJ 40436 205 35 ethical ethical JJ 40436 205 36 points point NNS 40436 205 37 of of IN 40436 205 38 view view NN 40436 205 39 in in IN 40436 205 40 different different JJ 40436 205 41 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 205 42 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 205 43 167 167 CD 40436 205 44 Self self NN 40436 205 45 - - HYPH 40436 205 46 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 205 47 is be VBZ 40436 205 48 here here RB 40436 205 49 declared declare VBN 40436 205 50 to to TO 40436 205 51 be be VB 40436 205 52 impossible impossible JJ 40436 205 53 _ _ NNP 40436 205 54 ib ib UH 40436 205 55 . . . 40436 205 56 _ _ NNP 40436 205 57 In in IN 40436 205 58 other other JJ 40436 205 59 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 205 60 , , , 40436 205 61 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 205 62 declares declare VBZ 40436 205 63 self self NN 40436 205 64 - - HYPH 40436 205 65 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 205 66 to to TO 40436 205 67 be be VB 40436 205 68 essential essential JJ 40436 205 69 and and CC 40436 205 70 inestimable inestimable JJ 40436 205 71 . . . 40436 206 1 Necessity necessity NN 40436 206 2 for for IN 40436 206 3 the the DT 40436 206 4 student student NN 40436 206 5 to to TO 40436 206 6 have have VB 40436 206 7 presented present VBN 40436 206 8 to to IN 40436 206 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 206 10 dissentient dissentient JJ 40436 206 11 points point NNS 40436 206 12 of of IN 40436 206 13 view view NN 40436 206 14 _ _ NNP 40436 206 15 ib ib UH 40436 206 16 . . . 40436 206 17 _ _ NNP 40436 206 18 Courage Courage NNP 40436 206 19 and and CC 40436 206 20 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 206 21 are be VBP 40436 206 22 shown show VBN 40436 206 23 to to TO 40436 206 24 have have VB 40436 206 25 no no DT 40436 206 26 distinct distinct JJ 40436 206 27 meaning meaning NN 40436 206 28 , , , 40436 206 29 except except IN 40436 206 30 as as IN 40436 206 31 founded found VBN 40436 206 32 on on IN 40436 206 33 the the DT 40436 206 34 general general JJ 40436 206 35 cognizance cognizance NN 40436 206 36 of of IN 40436 206 37 good good JJ 40436 206 38 and and CC 40436 206 39 evil evil JJ 40436 206 40 168 168 CD 40436 206 41 Distinction Distinction NNP 40436 206 42 made make VBN 40436 206 43 between between IN 40436 206 44 the the DT 40436 206 45 special special JJ 40436 206 46 sciences science NNS 40436 206 47 and and CC 40436 206 48 the the DT 40436 206 49 science science NN 40436 206 50 of of IN 40436 206 51 Good Good NNP 40436 206 52 and and CC 40436 206 53 Evil Evil NNP 40436 206 54 . . . 40436 207 1 Without without IN 40436 207 2 this this DT 40436 207 3 last last JJ 40436 207 4 , , , 40436 207 5 the the DT 40436 207 6 special special JJ 40436 207 7 sciences science NNS 40436 207 8 are be VBP 40436 207 9 of of IN 40436 207 10 no no DT 40436 207 11 use use NN 40436 207 12 _ _ NNP 40436 207 13 ib ib UH 40436 207 14 . . . 40436 207 15 _ _ NNP 40436 207 16 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 40436 207 17 , , , 40436 207 18 always always RB 40436 207 19 relative relative JJ 40436 207 20 to to IN 40436 207 21 some some DT 40436 207 22 object object NN 40436 207 23 known know VBN 40436 207 24 . . . 40436 208 1 Postulate postulate NN 40436 208 2 or or CC 40436 208 3 divination divination NN 40436 208 4 of of IN 40436 208 5 a a DT 40436 208 6 Science Science NNP 40436 208 7 of of IN 40436 208 8 Teleology Teleology NNP 40436 208 9 169 169 CD 40436 208 10 Courage Courage NNP 40436 208 11 and and CC 40436 208 12 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 208 13 , , , 40436 208 14 handled handle VBD 40436 208 15 both both CC 40436 208 16 by by IN 40436 208 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 208 18 and and CC 40436 208 19 by by IN 40436 208 20 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 208 21 . . . 40436 209 1 Comparison comparison NN 40436 209 2 between between IN 40436 209 3 the the DT 40436 209 4 two two CD 40436 209 5 170 170 CD 40436 209 6 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 209 7 XX XX NNP 40436 209 8 . . . 40436 210 1 LYSIS LYSIS NNP 40436 210 2 . . . 40436 211 1 Analogy analogy NN 40436 211 2 between between IN 40436 211 3 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 211 4 and and CC 40436 211 5 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 211 6 . . . 40436 212 1 Richness richness NN 40436 212 2 of of IN 40436 212 3 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 212 4 incident incident NN 40436 212 5 in in IN 40436 212 6 both both DT 40436 212 7 . . . 40436 213 1 Youthful youthful JJ 40436 213 2 beauty beauty NN 40436 213 3 172 172 CD 40436 213 4 Scenery Scenery NNP 40436 213 5 and and CC 40436 213 6 personages personage NNS 40436 213 7 of of IN 40436 213 8 the the DT 40436 213 9 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 213 10 _ _ NNP 40436 213 11 ib ib UH 40436 213 12 . . . 40436 213 13 _ _ NNP 40436 213 14 Origin Origin NNP 40436 213 15 of of IN 40436 213 16 the the DT 40436 213 17 conversation conversation NN 40436 213 18 . . . 40436 214 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 214 2 promises promise NNS 40436 214 3 to to TO 40436 214 4 give give VB 40436 214 5 an an DT 40436 214 6 example example NN 40436 214 7 of of IN 40436 214 8 the the DT 40436 214 9 proper proper JJ 40436 214 10 way way NN 40436 214 11 of of IN 40436 214 12 talking talk VBG 40436 214 13 to to IN 40436 214 14 a a DT 40436 214 15 youth youth NN 40436 214 16 , , , 40436 214 17 for for IN 40436 214 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 214 19 benefit benefit NN 40436 214 20 173 173 CD 40436 214 21 Conversation conversation NN 40436 214 22 of of IN 40436 214 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 214 24 with with IN 40436 214 25 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 214 26 _ _ NNP 40436 214 27 ib ib UH 40436 214 28 . . . 40436 214 29 _ _ NNP 40436 214 30 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 214 31 is be VBZ 40436 214 32 humiliated humiliate VBN 40436 214 33 . . . 40436 215 1 Distress Distress NNP 40436 215 2 of of IN 40436 215 3 Hippothalês Hippothalês NNP 40436 215 4 177 177 CD 40436 215 5 Lysis lysis NN 40436 215 6 entreats entreat NNS 40436 215 7 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 215 8 to to TO 40436 215 9 talk talk VB 40436 215 10 in in IN 40436 215 11 the the DT 40436 215 12 like like JJ 40436 215 13 strain strain NN 40436 215 14 to to IN 40436 215 15 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 215 16 _ _ NNP 40436 215 17 ib ib UH 40436 215 18 . . . 40436 215 19 _ _ NNP 40436 215 20 Value Value NNP 40436 215 21 of of IN 40436 215 22 the the DT 40436 215 23 first first JJ 40436 215 24 conversation conversation NN 40436 215 25 between between IN 40436 215 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 215 27 and and CC 40436 215 28 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 215 29 , , , 40436 215 30 as as IN 40436 215 31 an an DT 40436 215 32 illustration illustration NN 40436 215 33 of of IN 40436 215 34 the the DT 40436 215 35 Platonico Platonico NNP 40436 215 36 - - HYPH 40436 215 37 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 215 38 manner manner NN 40436 215 39 177 177 CD 40436 215 40 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 215 41 begins begin VBZ 40436 215 42 to to TO 40436 215 43 examine examine VB 40436 215 44 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 215 45 respecting respecting NN 40436 215 46 friendship friendship NN 40436 215 47 . . . 40436 216 1 Who who WP 40436 216 2 is be VBZ 40436 216 3 to to TO 40436 216 4 be be VB 40436 216 5 called call VBN 40436 216 6 a a DT 40436 216 7 friend friend NN 40436 216 8 ? ? . 40436 217 1 Halt halt VB 40436 217 2 in in IN 40436 217 3 the the DT 40436 217 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 217 5 178 178 CD 40436 217 6 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 217 7 addressed address VBN 40436 217 8 to to IN 40436 217 9 Lysis lysis NN 40436 217 10 . . . 40436 218 1 Appeal appeal VB 40436 218 2 to to IN 40436 218 3 the the DT 40436 218 4 maxims maxim NNS 40436 218 5 of of IN 40436 218 6 the the DT 40436 218 7 poets poet NNS 40436 218 8 . . . 40436 219 1 Like like UH 40436 219 2 is be VBZ 40436 219 3 the the DT 40436 219 4 friend friend NN 40436 219 5 of of IN 40436 219 6 like like UH 40436 219 7 . . . 40436 220 1 Canvassed canvass VBN 40436 220 2 and and CC 40436 220 3 rejected reject VBN 40436 220 4 _ _ NNP 40436 220 5 ib ib UH 40436 220 6 . . . 40436 220 7 _ _ NNP 40436 220 8 Other other JJ 40436 220 9 poets poet NNS 40436 220 10 declare declare VBP 40436 220 11 that that IN 40436 220 12 likeness likeness NN 40436 220 13 is be VBZ 40436 220 14 a a DT 40436 220 15 cause cause NN 40436 220 16 of of IN 40436 220 17 aversion aversion NN 40436 220 18 ; ; , 40436 220 19 unlikeness unlikeness NN 40436 220 20 , , , 40436 220 21 of of IN 40436 220 22 friendship friendship NN 40436 220 23 . . . 40436 221 1 Reasons Reasons NNP 40436 221 2 _ _ NNP 40436 221 3 pro pro JJ 40436 221 4 _ _ NNP 40436 221 5 and and CC 40436 221 6 _ _ NNP 40436 221 7 con con XX 40436 221 8 _ _ NNP 40436 221 9 . . . 40436 222 1 Rejected reject VBN 40436 222 2 179 179 CD 40436 222 3 Confusion Confusion NNP 40436 222 4 of of IN 40436 222 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 222 6 . . . 40436 223 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 223 2 suggests suggest VBZ 40436 223 3 , , , 40436 223 4 That that IN 40436 223 5 the the DT 40436 223 6 Indifferent Indifferent NNP 40436 223 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 223 8 neither neither CC 40436 223 9 good good JJ 40436 223 10 nor nor CC 40436 223 11 evil evil JJ 40436 223 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 223 13 is be VBZ 40436 223 14 friend friend NN 40436 223 15 to to IN 40436 223 16 the the DT 40436 223 17 Good Good NNP 40436 223 18 180 180 CD 40436 223 19 Suggestion Suggestion NNP 40436 223 20 canvassed canvass VBN 40436 223 21 . . . 40436 224 1 If if IN 40436 224 2 the the DT 40436 224 3 Indifferent Indifferent NNP 40436 224 4 is be VBZ 40436 224 5 friend friend NN 40436 224 6 to to IN 40436 224 7 the the DT 40436 224 8 Good Good NNP 40436 224 9 , , , 40436 224 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 224 11 is be VBZ 40436 224 12 determined determined JJ 40436 224 13 to to TO 40436 224 14 become become VB 40436 224 15 so so RB 40436 224 16 by by IN 40436 224 17 the the DT 40436 224 18 contact contact NN 40436 224 19 of of IN 40436 224 20 felt feel VBN 40436 224 21 evil evil JJ 40436 224 22 , , , 40436 224 23 from from IN 40436 224 24 which which WDT 40436 224 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 224 26 is be VBZ 40436 224 27 anxious anxious JJ 40436 224 28 to to TO 40436 224 29 escape escape VB 40436 224 30 180 180 CD 40436 224 31 Principle principle NN 40436 224 32 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 224 33 by by IN 40436 224 34 the the DT 40436 224 35 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 224 36 . . . 40436 225 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 225 2 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 225 3 condition condition NN 40436 225 4 -- -- : 40436 225 5 not not RB 40436 225 6 wise wise JJ 40436 225 7 , , , 40436 225 8 yet yet CC 40436 225 9 painfully painfully RB 40436 225 10 feeling feel VBG 40436 225 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 225 12 own own JJ 40436 225 13 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 225 14 181 181 CD 40436 225 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 225 16 dissatisfied dissatisfy VBN 40436 225 17 . . . 40436 226 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 226 2 originates originate VBZ 40436 226 3 a a DT 40436 226 4 new new JJ 40436 226 5 suggestion suggestion NN 40436 226 6 . . . 40436 227 1 The the DT 40436 227 2 Primum Primum NNP 40436 227 3 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 227 4 , , , 40436 227 5 or or CC 40436 227 6 object object VBP 40436 227 7 originally originally RB 40436 227 8 dear dear JJ 40436 227 9 to to IN 40436 227 10 us -PRON- PRP 40436 227 11 , , , 40436 227 12 _ _ NNP 40436 227 13 per per FW 40436 227 14 se se FW 40436 227 15 _ _ NNP 40436 227 16 : : : 40436 227 17 by by IN 40436 227 18 relation relation NN 40436 227 19 or or CC 40436 227 20 resemblance resemblance NN 40436 227 21 to to TO 40436 227 22 which which WDT 40436 227 23 other other JJ 40436 227 24 objects object NNS 40436 227 25 become become VBP 40436 227 26 dear dear JJ 40436 227 27 _ _ NNP 40436 227 28 ib ib UH 40436 227 29 . . . 40436 227 30 _ _ NNP 40436 227 31 The the DT 40436 227 32 cause cause NN 40436 227 33 of of IN 40436 227 34 love love NN 40436 227 35 is be VBZ 40436 227 36 desire desire NN 40436 227 37 . . . 40436 228 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 228 2 desire desire VBP 40436 228 3 that that DT 40436 228 4 which which WDT 40436 228 5 is be VBZ 40436 228 6 akin akin JJ 40436 228 7 to to IN 40436 228 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 228 9 or or CC 40436 228 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 228 11 own own JJ 40436 228 12 182 182 CD 40436 228 13 Good good JJ 40436 228 14 is be VBZ 40436 228 15 of of IN 40436 228 16 a a DT 40436 228 17 nature nature NN 40436 228 18 akin akin JJ 40436 228 19 to to IN 40436 228 20 every every DT 40436 228 21 one one CD 40436 228 22 , , , 40436 228 23 evil evil NN 40436 228 24 is be VBZ 40436 228 25 alien alien JJ 40436 228 26 to to IN 40436 228 27 every every DT 40436 228 28 one one CD 40436 228 29 . . . 40436 229 1 Inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 229 2 with with IN 40436 229 3 what what WP 40436 229 4 has have VBZ 40436 229 5 been be VBN 40436 229 6 previously previously RB 40436 229 7 laid lay VBN 40436 229 8 down down RP 40436 229 9 183 183 CD 40436 229 10 Failure failure NN 40436 229 11 of of IN 40436 229 12 the the DT 40436 229 13 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 229 14 . . . 40436 230 1 Close close NN 40436 230 2 of of IN 40436 230 3 the the DT 40436 230 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 230 5 184 184 CD 40436 230 6 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 230 7 . . . 40436 231 1 No no DT 40436 231 2 positive positive JJ 40436 231 3 result result NN 40436 231 4 . . . 40436 232 1 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 232 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 232 3 in in IN 40436 232 4 analysing analyse VBG 40436 232 5 the the DT 40436 232 6 familiar familiar JJ 40436 232 7 words word NNS 40436 232 8 -- -- : 40436 232 9 to to TO 40436 232 10 expose expose VB 40436 232 11 the the DT 40436 232 12 false false JJ 40436 232 13 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 232 14 of of IN 40436 232 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 232 16 _ _ NNP 40436 232 17 ib ib UH 40436 232 18 . . . 40436 232 19 _ _ NNP 40436 232 20 Subject Subject NNP 40436 232 21 of of IN 40436 232 22 Lysis lysis NN 40436 232 23 . . . 40436 233 1 Suited suit VBN 40436 233 2 for for IN 40436 233 3 a a DT 40436 233 4 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 233 5 of of IN 40436 233 6 Search Search NNP 40436 233 7 . . . 40436 234 1 Manner Manner NNP 40436 234 2 of of IN 40436 234 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 234 4 , , , 40436 234 5 multiplying multiply VBG 40436 234 6 defective defective JJ 40436 234 7 explanations explanation NNS 40436 234 8 , , , 40436 234 9 and and CC 40436 234 10 showing show VBG 40436 234 11 reasons reason NNS 40436 234 12 why why WRB 40436 234 13 each each DT 40436 234 14 is be VBZ 40436 234 15 defective defective JJ 40436 234 16 185 185 CD 40436 234 17 The the DT 40436 234 18 process process NN 40436 234 19 of of IN 40436 234 20 trial trial NN 40436 234 21 and and CC 40436 234 22 error error NN 40436 234 23 is be VBZ 40436 234 24 better well RBR 40436 234 25 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 234 26 by by IN 40436 234 27 a a DT 40436 234 28 search search NN 40436 234 29 without without IN 40436 234 30 result result NN 40436 234 31 than than IN 40436 234 32 with with IN 40436 234 33 result result NN 40436 234 34 . . . 40436 235 1 Usefulness usefulness NN 40436 235 2 of of IN 40436 235 3 the the DT 40436 235 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 235 5 for for IN 40436 235 6 self self NN 40436 235 7 - - HYPH 40436 235 8 working work VBG 40436 235 9 minds mind NNS 40436 235 10 186 186 CD 40436 235 11 Subject subject NN 40436 235 12 of of IN 40436 235 13 friendship friendship NN 40436 235 14 , , , 40436 235 15 handled handle VBD 40436 235 16 both both CC 40436 235 17 by by IN 40436 235 18 the the DT 40436 235 19 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 235 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 235 21 , , , 40436 235 22 and and CC 40436 235 23 by by IN 40436 235 24 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 235 25 _ _ NNP 40436 235 26 ib ib UH 40436 235 27 . . . 40436 235 28 _ _ NNP 40436 235 29 Debate debate NN 40436 235 30 in in IN 40436 235 31 the the DT 40436 235 32 Lysis lysis NN 40436 235 33 partly partly RB 40436 235 34 verbal verbal JJ 40436 235 35 , , , 40436 235 36 partly partly RB 40436 235 37 real real JJ 40436 235 38 . . . 40436 236 1 Assumptions assumption NNS 40436 236 2 made make VBN 40436 236 3 by by IN 40436 236 4 the the DT 40436 236 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 236 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 236 7 , , , 40436 236 8 questionable questionable JJ 40436 236 9 , , , 40436 236 10 such such JJ 40436 236 11 as as IN 40436 236 12 the the DT 40436 236 13 real real JJ 40436 236 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 236 15 would would MD 40436 236 16 have have VB 40436 236 17 found find VBN 40436 236 18 reason reason NN 40436 236 19 for for IN 40436 236 20 challenging challenge VBG 40436 236 21 188 188 CD 40436 236 22 Peculiar Peculiar NNP 40436 236 23 theory theory NN 40436 236 24 about about IN 40436 236 25 friendship friendship NN 40436 236 26 broached broach VBN 40436 236 27 by by IN 40436 236 28 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 236 29 . . . 40436 237 1 Persons person NNS 40436 237 2 neither neither CC 40436 237 3 good good JJ 40436 237 4 nor nor CC 40436 237 5 evil evil JJ 40436 237 6 by by IN 40436 237 7 nature nature NN 40436 237 8 , , , 40436 237 9 yet yet CC 40436 237 10 having have VBG 40436 237 11 a a DT 40436 237 12 superficial superficial JJ 40436 237 13 tinge tinge NN 40436 237 14 of of IN 40436 237 15 evil evil NN 40436 237 16 , , , 40436 237 17 and and CC 40436 237 18 desiring desire VBG 40436 237 19 good good JJ 40436 237 20 to to TO 40436 237 21 escape escape VB 40436 237 22 from from IN 40436 237 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 237 24 189 189 CD 40436 237 25 This this DT 40436 237 26 general general JJ 40436 237 27 theory theory NN 40436 237 28 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 237 29 by by IN 40436 237 30 the the DT 40436 237 31 case case NN 40436 237 32 of of IN 40436 237 33 the the DT 40436 237 34 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 237 35 or or CC 40436 237 36 lover lover NN 40436 237 37 of of IN 40436 237 38 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 237 39 . . . 40436 238 1 Painful painful JJ 40436 238 2 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 238 3 of of IN 40436 238 4 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 238 5 the the DT 40436 238 6 attribute attribute NN 40436 238 7 of of IN 40436 238 8 the the DT 40436 238 9 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 238 10 . . . 40436 239 1 Value value NN 40436 239 2 set set VBN 40436 239 3 by by IN 40436 239 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 239 5 and and CC 40436 239 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 239 7 upon upon IN 40436 239 8 this this DT 40436 239 9 attribute attribute NN 40436 239 10 190 190 CD 40436 239 11 Another another DT 40436 239 12 theory theory NN 40436 239 13 of of IN 40436 239 14 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 239 15 . . . 40436 240 1 The the DT 40436 240 2 Primum Primum NNP 40436 240 3 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 240 4 , , , 40436 240 5 or or CC 40436 240 6 original original JJ 40436 240 7 and and CC 40436 240 8 primary primary JJ 40436 240 9 object object NN 40436 240 10 of of IN 40436 240 11 Love Love NNP 40436 240 12 . . . 40436 241 1 Particular particular JJ 40436 241 2 objects object NNS 40436 241 3 are be VBP 40436 241 4 loved love VBN 40436 241 5 through through IN 40436 241 6 association association NN 40436 241 7 with with IN 40436 241 8 this this DT 40436 241 9 . . . 40436 242 1 The the DT 40436 242 2 object object NN 40436 242 3 is be VBZ 40436 242 4 Good good JJ 40436 242 5 191 191 CD 40436 242 6 Statement statement NN 40436 242 7 by by IN 40436 242 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 242 9 of of IN 40436 242 10 the the DT 40436 242 11 general general JJ 40436 242 12 law law NN 40436 242 13 of of IN 40436 242 14 mental mental NNP 40436 242 15 association association NNP 40436 242 16 _ _ NNP 40436 242 17 ib ib NNP 40436 242 18 . . . 40436 242 19 _ _ NNP 40436 242 20 Theory Theory NNP 40436 242 21 of of IN 40436 242 22 the the DT 40436 242 23 Primum Primum NNP 40436 242 24 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 242 25 , , , 40436 242 26 here here RB 40436 242 27 introduced introduce VBN 40436 242 28 by by IN 40436 242 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 242 30 , , , 40436 242 31 with with IN 40436 242 32 numerous numerous JJ 40436 242 33 derivative derivative JJ 40436 242 34 objects object NNS 40436 242 35 of of IN 40436 242 36 love love NN 40436 242 37 . . . 40436 243 1 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 243 2 Idea Idea NNP 40436 243 3 . . . 40436 244 1 Generic generic JJ 40436 244 2 communion communion NN 40436 244 3 of of IN 40436 244 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 244 5 , , , 40436 244 6 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 244 7 by by IN 40436 244 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 244 9 from from IN 40436 244 10 the the DT 40436 244 11 feebler feebler NN 40436 244 12 analogical analogical JJ 40436 244 13 communion communion NN 40436 244 14 192 192 CD 40436 244 15 Primum Primum NNP 40436 244 16 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 244 17 of of IN 40436 244 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 244 19 , , , 40436 244 20 compared compare VBN 40436 244 21 with with IN 40436 244 22 the the DT 40436 244 23 Prima Prima NNP 40436 244 24 Amicitia Amicitia NNP 40436 244 25 of of IN 40436 244 26 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 244 27 . . . 40436 245 1 Each each DT 40436 245 2 of of IN 40436 245 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 245 4 is be VBZ 40436 245 5 head head NN 40436 245 6 of of IN 40436 245 7 an an DT 40436 245 8 analogical analogical JJ 40436 245 9 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 245 10 , , , 40436 245 11 not not RB 40436 245 12 member member NN 40436 245 13 of of IN 40436 245 14 a a DT 40436 245 15 generic generic JJ 40436 245 16 family family NN 40436 245 17 194 194 CD 40436 245 18 The the DT 40436 245 19 Good good JJ 40436 245 20 and and CC 40436 245 21 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 245 22 , , , 40436 245 23 considered consider VBN 40436 245 24 as as IN 40436 245 25 objects object NNS 40436 245 26 of of IN 40436 245 27 attachment attachment NN 40436 245 28 _ _ NNP 40436 245 29 ib ib UH 40436 245 30 . . . 40436 245 31 _ _ NNP 40436 245 32 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 245 33 XXI XXI NNP 40436 245 34 . . . 40436 246 1 EUTHYDEMUS EUTHYDEMUS NNP 40436 246 2 . . . 40436 247 1 Dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 247 2 and and CC 40436 247 3 comic comic JJ 40436 247 4 exuberance exuberance NN 40436 247 5 of of IN 40436 247 6 the the DT 40436 247 7 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 247 8 . . . 40436 248 1 Judgments judgment NNS 40436 248 2 of of IN 40436 248 3 various various JJ 40436 248 4 critics critic NNS 40436 248 5 195 195 CD 40436 248 6 Scenery Scenery NNP 40436 248 7 and and CC 40436 248 8 personages personage NNS 40436 248 9 _ _ NNP 40436 248 10 ib ib UH 40436 248 11 . . . 40436 248 12 _ _ NNP 40436 248 13 The the DT 40436 248 14 two two CD 40436 248 15 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 248 16 , , , 40436 248 17 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 248 18 and and CC 40436 248 19 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 248 20 : : : 40436 248 21 manner manner NN 40436 248 22 in in IN 40436 248 23 which which WDT 40436 248 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 248 25 are be VBP 40436 248 26 here here RB 40436 248 27 presented present VBN 40436 248 28 196 196 CD 40436 248 29 Conversation conversation NN 40436 248 30 carried carry VBN 40436 248 31 on on RP 40436 248 32 with with IN 40436 248 33 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 248 34 , , , 40436 248 35 first first RB 40436 248 36 by by IN 40436 248 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 248 38 , , , 40436 248 39 next next RB 40436 248 40 by by IN 40436 248 41 the the DT 40436 248 42 two two CD 40436 248 43 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 248 44 _ _ NNP 40436 248 45 ib ib UH 40436 248 46 . . . 40436 248 47 _ _ NNP 40436 248 48 Contrast Contrast NNP 40436 248 49 between between IN 40436 248 50 the the DT 40436 248 51 two two CD 40436 248 52 different different JJ 40436 248 53 modes mode NNS 40436 248 54 of of IN 40436 248 55 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 248 56 197 197 CD 40436 248 57 Wherein wherein WRB 40436 248 58 this this DT 40436 248 59 contrast contrast NN 40436 248 60 does do VBZ 40436 248 61 not not RB 40436 248 62 consist consist VB 40436 248 63 198 198 CD 40436 248 64 Wherein wherein WRB 40436 248 65 it -PRON- PRP 40436 248 66 does do VBZ 40436 248 67 consist consist VB 40436 248 68 199 199 CD 40436 248 69 Abuse abuse NN 40436 248 70 of of IN 40436 248 71 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 248 72 by by IN 40436 248 73 the the DT 40436 248 74 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 248 75 -- -- : 40436 248 76 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 248 77 bidding bidding NN 40436 248 78 for for IN 40436 248 79 the the DT 40436 248 80 applause applause NN 40436 248 81 of of IN 40436 248 82 the the DT 40436 248 83 by by NN 40436 248 84 - - HYPH 40436 248 85 standers stander NNS 40436 248 86 _ _ NNP 40436 248 87 ibid ibid NN 40436 248 88 . . . 40436 248 89 _ _ NNP 40436 248 90 Comparison Comparison NNP 40436 248 91 of of IN 40436 248 92 the the DT 40436 248 93 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 248 94 with with IN 40436 248 95 the the DT 40436 248 96 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 248 97 200 200 CD 40436 248 98 Necessity Necessity NNP 40436 248 99 of of IN 40436 248 100 settling settle VBG 40436 248 101 accounts account NNS 40436 248 102 with with IN 40436 248 103 the the DT 40436 248 104 negative negative JJ 40436 248 105 , , , 40436 248 106 before before IN 40436 248 107 we -PRON- PRP 40436 248 108 venture venture VBP 40436 248 109 upon upon IN 40436 248 110 the the DT 40436 248 111 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 248 112 , , , 40436 248 113 is be VBZ 40436 248 114 common common JJ 40436 248 115 to to IN 40436 248 116 both both DT 40436 248 117 : : : 40436 248 118 in in IN 40436 248 119 the the DT 40436 248 120 one one NN 40436 248 121 the the DT 40436 248 122 process process NN 40436 248 123 is be VBZ 40436 248 124 solitary solitary JJ 40436 248 125 and and CC 40436 248 126 serious serious JJ 40436 248 127 ; ; : 40436 248 128 in in IN 40436 248 129 the the DT 40436 248 130 other other JJ 40436 248 131 , , , 40436 248 132 it -PRON- PRP 40436 248 133 is be VBZ 40436 248 134 vulgarised vulgarise VBN 40436 248 135 and and CC 40436 248 136 ludicrous ludicrous JJ 40436 248 137 201 201 CD 40436 248 138 Opinion Opinion NNP 40436 248 139 of of IN 40436 248 140 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 248 141 and and CC 40436 248 142 other other JJ 40436 248 143 critics critic NNS 40436 248 144 about about IN 40436 248 145 the the DT 40436 248 146 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 248 147 , , , 40436 248 148 that that IN 40436 248 149 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 248 150 and and CC 40436 248 151 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 248 152 represent represent VBP 40436 248 153 the the DT 40436 248 154 way way NN 40436 248 155 in in IN 40436 248 156 which which WDT 40436 248 157 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 248 158 and and CC 40436 248 159 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 248 160 talked talk VBD 40436 248 161 to to IN 40436 248 162 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 248 163 auditors auditor NNS 40436 248 164 202 202 CD 40436 248 165 That that DT 40436 248 166 opinion opinion NN 40436 248 167 is be VBZ 40436 248 168 unfounded unfounded JJ 40436 248 169 . . . 40436 249 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 249 2 was be VBD 40436 249 3 much much RB 40436 249 4 more more RBR 40436 249 5 Eristic eristic JJ 40436 249 6 than than IN 40436 249 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 249 8 , , , 40436 249 9 who who WP 40436 249 10 generally generally RB 40436 249 11 manifested manifest VBD 40436 249 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 249 13 by by IN 40436 249 14 continuous continuous JJ 40436 249 15 speech speech NN 40436 249 16 or or CC 40436 249 17 lecture lecture NN 40436 249 18 _ _ NNP 40436 249 19 ib ib UH 40436 249 20 . . . 40436 249 21 _ _ NNP 40436 249 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 249 23 in in IN 40436 249 24 the the DT 40436 249 25 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 249 26 is be VBZ 40436 249 27 drawn draw VBN 40436 249 28 suitably suitably RB 40436 249 29 to to IN 40436 249 30 the the DT 40436 249 31 purpose purpose NN 40436 249 32 of of IN 40436 249 33 that that DT 40436 249 34 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 249 35 203 203 CD 40436 249 36 The the DT 40436 249 37 two two CD 40436 249 38 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 249 39 in in IN 40436 249 40 the the DT 40436 249 41 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 249 42 are be VBP 40436 249 43 not not RB 40436 249 44 to to TO 40436 249 45 be be VB 40436 249 46 taken take VBN 40436 249 47 as as IN 40436 249 48 real real JJ 40436 249 49 persons person NNS 40436 249 50 , , , 40436 249 51 or or CC 40436 249 52 representatives representative NNS 40436 249 53 of of IN 40436 249 54 real real JJ 40436 249 55 persons person NNS 40436 249 56 204 204 CD 40436 249 57 Colloquy Colloquy NNS 40436 249 58 of of IN 40436 249 59 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 249 60 with with IN 40436 249 61 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 249 62 -- -- : 40436 249 63 possession possession NN 40436 249 64 of of IN 40436 249 65 good good JJ 40436 249 66 things thing NNS 40436 249 67 is be VBZ 40436 249 68 useless useless JJ 40436 249 69 , , , 40436 249 70 unless unless IN 40436 249 71 we -PRON- PRP 40436 249 72 also also RB 40436 249 73 have have VBP 40436 249 74 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 249 75 how how WRB 40436 249 76 to to TO 40436 249 77 use use VB 40436 249 78 them -PRON- PRP 40436 249 79 _ _ IN 40436 249 80 ib ib UH 40436 249 81 . . . 40436 249 82 _ _ NNP 40436 249 83 But but CC 40436 249 84 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 249 85 -- -- : 40436 249 86 of of IN 40436 249 87 what what WP 40436 249 88 ? ? . 40436 250 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 250 2 must must MD 40436 250 3 be be VB 40436 250 4 such such JJ 40436 250 5 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 250 6 , , , 40436 250 7 or or CC 40436 250 8 such such PDT 40436 250 9 an an DT 40436 250 10 art art NN 40436 250 11 , , , 40436 250 12 as as IN 40436 250 13 will will MD 40436 250 14 include include VB 40436 250 15 both both CC 40436 250 16 the the DT 40436 250 17 making making NN 40436 250 18 of of IN 40436 250 19 what what WP 40436 250 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 250 21 want want VBP 40436 250 22 , , , 40436 250 23 and and CC 40436 250 24 the the DT 40436 250 25 right right JJ 40436 250 26 use use NN 40436 250 27 of of IN 40436 250 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 250 29 when when WRB 40436 250 30 made make VBN 40436 250 31 205 205 CD 40436 250 32 Where where WRB 40436 250 33 is be VBZ 40436 250 34 such such PDT 40436 250 35 an an DT 40436 250 36 art art NN 40436 250 37 to to TO 40436 250 38 be be VB 40436 250 39 found find VBN 40436 250 40 ? ? . 40436 251 1 The the DT 40436 251 2 regal regal JJ 40436 251 3 or or CC 40436 251 4 political political JJ 40436 251 5 art art NN 40436 251 6 looks look VBZ 40436 251 7 like like IN 40436 251 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 251 9 ; ; : 40436 251 10 but but CC 40436 251 11 what what WP 40436 251 12 does do VBZ 40436 251 13 this this DT 40436 251 14 art art NN 40436 251 15 do do VB 40436 251 16 for for IN 40436 251 17 us -PRON- PRP 40436 251 18 ? ? . 40436 252 1 No no DT 40436 252 2 answer answer NN 40436 252 3 can can MD 40436 252 4 be be VB 40436 252 5 found find VBN 40436 252 6 . . . 40436 253 1 Ends end NNS 40436 253 2 in in IN 40436 253 3 puzzle puzzle NN 40436 253 4 206 206 CD 40436 253 5 Review Review NNP 40436 253 6 of of IN 40436 253 7 the the DT 40436 253 8 cross cross NN 40436 253 9 - - NN 40436 253 10 examination examination NN 40436 253 11 just just RB 40436 253 12 pursued pursue VBN 40436 253 13 by by IN 40436 253 14 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 253 15 . . . 40436 254 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 254 2 is be VBZ 40436 254 3 very very RB 40436 254 4 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 254 5 -- -- : 40436 254 6 puts put VBZ 40436 254 7 the the DT 40436 254 8 mind mind NN 40436 254 9 upon upon IN 40436 254 10 what what WP 40436 254 11 to to TO 40436 254 12 look look VB 40436 254 13 for for IN 40436 254 14 207 207 CD 40436 254 15 Comparison Comparison NNP 40436 254 16 with with IN 40436 254 17 other other JJ 40436 254 18 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 254 19 -- -- : 40436 254 20 Republic Republic NNP 40436 254 21 , , , 40436 254 22 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 254 23 , , , 40436 254 24 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 254 25 . . . 40436 255 1 The the DT 40436 255 2 only only JJ 40436 255 3 distinct distinct JJ 40436 255 4 answer answer NN 40436 255 5 is be VBZ 40436 255 6 found find VBN 40436 255 7 in in IN 40436 255 8 the the DT 40436 255 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 255 10 208 208 CD 40436 255 11 The the DT 40436 255 12 talk talk NN 40436 255 13 of of IN 40436 255 14 the the DT 40436 255 15 two two CD 40436 255 16 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 255 17 , , , 40436 255 18 though though IN 40436 255 19 ironically ironically RB 40436 255 20 admired admire VBN 40436 255 21 while while IN 40436 255 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 255 23 is be VBZ 40436 255 24 going go VBG 40436 255 25 on on RP 40436 255 26 , , , 40436 255 27 is be VBZ 40436 255 28 shown show VBN 40436 255 29 at at IN 40436 255 30 the the DT 40436 255 31 end end NN 40436 255 32 to to TO 40436 255 33 produce produce VB 40436 255 34 no no DT 40436 255 35 real real JJ 40436 255 36 admiration admiration NN 40436 255 37 , , , 40436 255 38 but but CC 40436 255 39 the the DT 40436 255 40 contrary contrary JJ 40436 255 41 _ _ NNP 40436 255 42 ib ib UH 40436 255 43 . . . 40436 255 44 _ _ NNP 40436 255 45 Mistaken Mistaken NNP 40436 255 46 representations representation NNS 40436 255 47 about about IN 40436 255 48 the the DT 40436 255 49 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 255 50 -- -- : 40436 255 51 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 255 52 's 's POS 40436 255 53 definition definition NN 40436 255 54 -- -- : 40436 255 55 no no DT 40436 255 56 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 40436 255 57 line line NN 40436 255 58 can can MD 40436 255 59 be be VB 40436 255 60 drawn draw VBN 40436 255 61 between between IN 40436 255 62 the the DT 40436 255 63 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 255 64 and and CC 40436 255 65 the the DT 40436 255 66 Dialectician dialectician JJ 40436 255 67 210 210 CD 40436 255 68 Philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 255 69 purpose purpose NN 40436 255 70 of of IN 40436 255 71 the the DT 40436 255 72 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 255 73 -- -- : 40436 255 74 exposure exposure NN 40436 255 75 of of IN 40436 255 76 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 255 77 , , , 40436 255 78 in in IN 40436 255 79 Plato Plato NNP 40436 255 80 's 's POS 40436 255 81 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 255 82 manner manner NN 40436 255 83 , , , 40436 255 84 by by IN 40436 255 85 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 255 86 of of IN 40436 255 87 particular particular JJ 40436 255 88 examples example VBZ 40436 255 89 211 211 CD 40436 255 90 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 255 91 ( ( -LRB- 40436 255 92 Soph Soph NNP 40436 255 93 . . . 40436 256 1 Elench elench NN 40436 256 2 . . . 40436 256 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 257 1 attempts attempt VBZ 40436 257 2 a a DT 40436 257 3 classification classification NN 40436 257 4 of of IN 40436 257 5 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 257 6 : : : 40436 257 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 257 8 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 257 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 257 10 without without IN 40436 257 11 classification classification NN 40436 257 12 212 212 CD 40436 257 13 Fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 257 14 of of IN 40436 257 15 equivocation equivocation NN 40436 257 16 propounded propound VBN 40436 257 17 by by IN 40436 257 18 the the DT 40436 257 19 two two CD 40436 257 20 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 257 21 in in IN 40436 257 22 the the DT 40436 257 23 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 257 24 _ _ NNP 40436 257 25 ib ib UH 40436 257 26 . . . 40436 257 27 _ _ NNP 40436 257 28 Fallacies--_à Fallacies--_à NNP 40436 257 29 dicto dicto NNP 40436 257 30 secundum secundum NN 40436 257 31 quid quid NN 40436 257 32 , , , 40436 257 33 ad ad NN 40436 257 34 dictum dictum NN 40436 257 35 simpliciter_--in simpliciter_--in NNP 40436 257 36 the the DT 40436 257 37 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 257 38 213 213 CD 40436 257 39 Obstinacy Obstinacy NNP 40436 257 40 shown show VBN 40436 257 41 by by IN 40436 257 42 the the DT 40436 257 43 two two CD 40436 257 44 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 257 45 in in IN 40436 257 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 257 47 replies reply NNS 40436 257 48 -- -- : 40436 257 49 determination determination NN 40436 257 50 not not RB 40436 257 51 to to TO 40436 257 52 contradict contradict VB 40436 257 53 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 257 54 214 214 CD 40436 257 55 Farther farther RB 40436 257 56 verbal verbal JJ 40436 257 57 equivocations equivocation NNS 40436 257 58 _ _ NNP 40436 257 59 ib ib NN 40436 257 60 . . . 40436 257 61 _ _ NNP 40436 257 62 Fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 257 63 involving involve VBG 40436 257 64 deeper deep JJR 40436 257 65 logical logical JJ 40436 257 66 principles principle NNS 40436 257 67 -- -- : 40436 257 68 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 257 69 is be VBZ 40436 257 70 impossible.--To impossible.--to NN 40436 257 71 speak speak VBP 40436 257 72 falsely falsely RB 40436 257 73 is be VBZ 40436 257 74 impossible impossible JJ 40436 257 75 215 215 CD 40436 257 76 Plato Plato NNP 40436 257 77 's 's POS 40436 257 78 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 257 79 is be VBZ 40436 257 80 the the DT 40436 257 81 earliest early JJS 40436 257 82 known known JJ 40436 257 83 attempt attempt NN 40436 257 84 to to TO 40436 257 85 set set VB 40436 257 86 out out RP 40436 257 87 and and CC 40436 257 88 expose expose VB 40436 257 89 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 257 90 -- -- : 40436 257 91 the the DT 40436 257 92 only only JJ 40436 257 93 way way NN 40436 257 94 of of IN 40436 257 95 exposing expose VBG 40436 257 96 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 257 97 is be VBZ 40436 257 98 to to TO 40436 257 99 exemplify exemplify VB 40436 257 100 the the DT 40436 257 101 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 257 102 by by IN 40436 257 103 particular particular JJ 40436 257 104 cases case NNS 40436 257 105 , , , 40436 257 106 in in IN 40436 257 107 which which WDT 40436 257 108 the the DT 40436 257 109 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 257 110 proved prove VBD 40436 257 111 is be VBZ 40436 257 112 known know VBN 40436 257 113 _ _ NNP 40436 257 114 aliunde aliunde NNP 40436 257 115 _ _ NNP 40436 257 116 to to TO 40436 257 117 be be VB 40436 257 118 false false JJ 40436 257 119 and and CC 40436 257 120 absurd absurd JJ 40436 257 121 216 216 CD 40436 257 122 Mistake Mistake NNP 40436 257 123 of of IN 40436 257 124 supposing suppose VBG 40436 257 125 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 257 126 to to TO 40436 257 127 have have VB 40436 257 128 been be VBN 40436 257 129 invented invent VBN 40436 257 130 and and CC 40436 257 131 propagated propagate VBN 40436 257 132 by by IN 40436 257 133 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 257 134 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 257 135 -- -- : 40436 257 136 they -PRON- PRP 40436 257 137 are be VBP 40436 257 138 inherent inherent JJ 40436 257 139 inadvertencies inadvertency NNS 40436 257 140 and and CC 40436 257 141 liabilities liability NNS 40436 257 142 to to TO 40436 257 143 error error VB 40436 257 144 , , , 40436 257 145 in in IN 40436 257 146 the the DT 40436 257 147 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 257 148 process process NN 40436 257 149 of of IN 40436 257 150 thinking think VBG 40436 257 151 . . . 40436 258 1 Formal formal JJ 40436 258 2 debate debate NN 40436 258 3 affords afford VBZ 40436 258 4 the the DT 40436 258 5 best good JJS 40436 258 6 means mean NNS 40436 258 7 of of IN 40436 258 8 correcting correct VBG 40436 258 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 258 10 217 217 CD 40436 258 11 Wide wide JJ 40436 258 12 - - HYPH 40436 258 13 spread spread VBN 40436 258 14 prevalence prevalence NN 40436 258 15 of of IN 40436 258 16 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 258 17 belief belief NN 40436 258 18 , , , 40436 258 19 misguided misguide VBN 40436 258 20 by by IN 40436 258 21 one one CD 40436 258 22 or or CC 40436 258 23 other other JJ 40436 258 24 of of IN 40436 258 25 these these DT 40436 258 26 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 258 27 , , , 40436 258 28 attested attest VBN 40436 258 29 by by IN 40436 258 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 258 31 , , , 40436 258 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 258 33 , , , 40436 258 34 Bacon Bacon NNP 40436 258 35 , , , 40436 258 36 & & CC 40436 258 37 c c NNP 40436 258 38 . . . 40436 258 39 ,--complete ,--complete , 40436 258 40 enumeration enumeration NN 40436 258 41 of of IN 40436 258 42 heads head NNS 40436 258 43 of of IN 40436 258 44 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 258 45 by by IN 40436 258 46 Mill Mill NNP 40436 258 47 218 218 CD 40436 258 48 Value value NN 40436 258 49 of of IN 40436 258 50 formal formal JJ 40436 258 51 debate debate NN 40436 258 52 as as IN 40436 258 53 a a DT 40436 258 54 means means NN 40436 258 55 for for IN 40436 258 56 testing testing NN 40436 258 57 and and CC 40436 258 58 confuting confute VBG 40436 258 59 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 258 60 221 221 CD 40436 258 61 Without without IN 40436 258 62 the the DT 40436 258 63 habit habit NN 40436 258 64 of of IN 40436 258 65 formal formal JJ 40436 258 66 debate debate NN 40436 258 67 , , , 40436 258 68 Plato Plato NNP 40436 258 69 could could MD 40436 258 70 not not RB 40436 258 71 have have VB 40436 258 72 composed compose VBN 40436 258 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 258 74 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 258 75 , , , 40436 258 76 nor nor CC 40436 258 77 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 258 78 the the DT 40436 258 79 treatise treatise NN 40436 258 80 De De NNP 40436 258 81 Sophisticis Sophisticis NNP 40436 258 82 Elenchis Elenchis NNP 40436 258 83 _ _ NNP 40436 258 84 ib ib UH 40436 258 85 . . . 40436 258 86 _ _ NNP 40436 258 87 Probable probable JJ 40436 258 88 popularity popularity NN 40436 258 89 of of IN 40436 258 90 the the DT 40436 258 91 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 258 92 at at IN 40436 258 93 Athens Athens NNP 40436 258 94 -- -- : 40436 258 95 welcomed welcome VBN 40436 258 96 by by IN 40436 258 97 all all PDT 40436 258 98 the the DT 40436 258 99 enemies enemy NNS 40436 258 100 of of IN 40436 258 101 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 258 102 222 222 CD 40436 258 103 Epilogue Epilogue NNP 40436 258 104 of of IN 40436 258 105 Plato Plato NNP 40436 258 106 to to IN 40436 258 107 the the DT 40436 258 108 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 258 109 , , , 40436 258 110 trying try VBG 40436 258 111 to to TO 40436 258 112 obviate obviate VB 40436 258 113 this this DT 40436 258 114 inference inference NN 40436 258 115 by by IN 40436 258 116 opponents opponent NNS 40436 258 117 -- -- : 40436 258 118 Conversation conversation NN 40436 258 119 between between IN 40436 258 120 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 258 121 and and CC 40436 258 122 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 258 123 223 223 CD 40436 258 124 Altered Altered NNP 40436 258 125 tone tone NN 40436 258 126 in in IN 40436 258 127 speaking speak VBG 40436 258 128 of of IN 40436 258 129 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 258 130 -- -- : 40436 258 131 Disparagement Disparagement NNP 40436 258 132 of of IN 40436 258 133 persons person NNS 40436 258 134 half half JJ 40436 258 135 - - HYPH 40436 258 136 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 258 137 , , , 40436 258 138 half half NN 40436 258 139 - - HYPH 40436 258 140 politicians politician NNS 40436 258 141 224 224 CD 40436 258 142 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 258 143 asks ask VBZ 40436 258 144 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 258 145 for for IN 40436 258 146 advice advice NN 40436 258 147 about about IN 40436 258 148 the the DT 40436 258 149 education education NN 40436 258 150 of of IN 40436 258 151 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 258 152 sons son NNS 40436 258 153 -- -- : 40436 258 154 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 258 155 can can MD 40436 258 156 not not RB 40436 258 157 recommend recommend VB 40436 258 158 a a DT 40436 258 159 teacher teacher NN 40436 258 160 -- -- : 40436 258 161 tells tell VBZ 40436 258 162 him -PRON- PRP 40436 258 163 to to TO 40436 258 164 search search VB 40436 258 165 for for IN 40436 258 166 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 258 167 225 225 CD 40436 258 168 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 258 169 is be VBZ 40436 258 170 here here RB 40436 258 171 cited cite VBN 40436 258 172 as as IN 40436 258 173 representative representative NN 40436 258 174 of of IN 40436 258 175 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 258 176 and and CC 40436 258 177 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 258 178 226 226 CD 40436 258 179 Who who WP 40436 258 180 is be VBZ 40436 258 181 the the DT 40436 258 182 person person NN 40436 258 183 here here RB 40436 258 184 intended intend VBN 40436 258 185 by by IN 40436 258 186 Plato Plato NNP 40436 258 187 , , , 40436 258 188 half half JJ 40436 258 189 - - HYPH 40436 258 190 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 258 191 , , , 40436 258 192 half half JJ 40436 258 193 - - HYPH 40436 258 194 politician politician NN 40436 258 195 ? ? . 40436 259 1 Is be VBZ 40436 259 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 259 3 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 259 4 ? ? . 40436 260 1 227 227 CD 40436 260 2 Variable variable JJ 40436 260 3 feeling feeling NN 40436 260 4 at at IN 40436 260 5 different different JJ 40436 260 6 times time NNS 40436 260 7 , , , 40436 260 8 between between IN 40436 260 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 260 10 and and CC 40436 260 11 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 260 12 228 228 CD 40436 260 13 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 260 14 XXII XXII NNS 40436 260 15 . . . 40436 261 1 MENON MENON NNP 40436 261 2 . . . 40436 262 1 Persons person NNS 40436 262 2 of of IN 40436 262 3 the the DT 40436 262 4 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 262 5 232 232 CD 40436 262 6 Question Question NNP 40436 262 7 put put VBN 40436 262 8 by by IN 40436 262 9 Menon Menon NNP 40436 262 10 -- -- : 40436 262 11 Is be VBZ 40436 262 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 262 13 teachable teachable NN 40436 262 14 ? ? . 40436 263 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 263 2 confesses confess VBZ 40436 263 3 that that IN 40436 263 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 263 5 does do VBZ 40436 263 6 not not RB 40436 263 7 know know VB 40436 263 8 what what WP 40436 263 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 263 10 is be VBZ 40436 263 11 . . . 40436 264 1 Surprise Surprise NNP 40436 264 2 of of IN 40436 264 3 Menon Menon NNP 40436 264 4 _ _ NNP 40436 264 5 ib ib UH 40436 264 6 . . . 40436 264 7 _ _ NNP 40436 264 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 264 9 stands stand VBZ 40436 264 10 alone alone RB 40436 264 11 in in IN 40436 264 12 this this DT 40436 264 13 confession confession NN 40436 264 14 . . . 40436 265 1 Unpopularity unpopularity NN 40436 265 2 entailed entail VBN 40436 265 3 by by IN 40436 265 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 265 5 233 233 CD 40436 265 6 Answer Answer NNP 40436 265 7 of of IN 40436 265 8 Menon Menon NNP 40436 265 9 -- -- : 40436 265 10 plurality plurality NN 40436 265 11 of of IN 40436 265 12 virtues virtue NNS 40436 265 13 , , , 40436 265 14 one one CD 40436 265 15 belonging belong VBG 40436 265 16 to to IN 40436 265 17 each each DT 40436 265 18 different different JJ 40436 265 19 class class NN 40436 265 20 and and CC 40436 265 21 condition condition NN 40436 265 22 . . . 40436 266 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 266 2 enquires enquire VBZ 40436 266 3 for for IN 40436 266 4 the the DT 40436 266 5 property property NN 40436 266 6 common common JJ 40436 266 7 to to IN 40436 266 8 all all DT 40436 266 9 of of IN 40436 266 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 266 11 _ _ NNP 40436 266 12 ib ib UH 40436 266 13 . . . 40436 266 14 _ _ NNP 40436 266 15 Analogous analogous JJ 40436 266 16 cases case NNS 40436 266 17 cited cite VBD 40436 266 18 -- -- : 40436 266 19 definitions definition NNS 40436 266 20 of of IN 40436 266 21 figure figure NN 40436 266 22 and and CC 40436 266 23 colour colour NN 40436 266 24 235 235 CD 40436 266 25 Importance importance NN 40436 266 26 at at IN 40436 266 27 that that DT 40436 266 28 time time NN 40436 266 29 of of IN 40436 266 30 bringing bring VBG 40436 266 31 into into IN 40436 266 32 conscious conscious JJ 40436 266 33 view view NN 40436 266 34 , , , 40436 266 35 logical logical JJ 40436 266 36 subordination subordination NN 40436 266 37 and and CC 40436 266 38 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 266 39 -- -- : 40436 266 40 Neither neither CC 40436 266 41 logic logic NN 40436 266 42 nor nor CC 40436 266 43 grammar grammar NN 40436 266 44 had have VBD 40436 266 45 then then RB 40436 266 46 been be VBN 40436 266 47 cast cast VBN 40436 266 48 into into IN 40436 266 49 system system NN 40436 266 50 _ _ NNP 40436 266 51 ib ib UH 40436 266 52 . . . 40436 266 53 _ _ NNP 40436 266 54 Definition Definition NNP 40436 266 55 of of IN 40436 266 56 virtue virtue NN 40436 266 57 given give VBN 40436 266 58 by by IN 40436 266 59 Menon Menon NNP 40436 266 60 : : : 40436 266 61 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 266 62 pulls pull VBZ 40436 266 63 it -PRON- PRP 40436 266 64 to to IN 40436 266 65 pieces piece NNS 40436 266 66 236 236 CD 40436 266 67 Menon Menon NNP 40436 266 68 complains complain VBZ 40436 266 69 that that IN 40436 266 70 the the DT 40436 266 71 conversation conversation NN 40436 266 72 of of IN 40436 266 73 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 266 74 confounds confound VBZ 40436 266 75 him -PRON- PRP 40436 266 76 like like IN 40436 266 77 an an DT 40436 266 78 electric electric JJ 40436 266 79 shock shock NN 40436 266 80 -- -- : 40436 266 81 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 266 82 replies reply VBZ 40436 266 83 that that IN 40436 266 84 he -PRON- PRP 40436 266 85 is be VBZ 40436 266 86 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 266 87 in in IN 40436 266 88 the the DT 40436 266 89 same same JJ 40436 266 90 state state NN 40436 266 91 of of IN 40436 266 92 confusion confusion NN 40436 266 93 and and CC 40436 266 94 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 266 95 . . . 40436 267 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 267 2 urges urge VBZ 40436 267 3 continuance continuance NN 40436 267 4 of of IN 40436 267 5 search search NN 40436 267 6 by by IN 40436 267 7 both both DT 40436 267 8 237 237 CD 40436 267 9 But but CC 40436 267 10 how how WRB 40436 267 11 is be VBZ 40436 267 12 the the DT 40436 267 13 process process NN 40436 267 14 of of IN 40436 267 15 search search NN 40436 267 16 available available JJ 40436 267 17 to to IN 40436 267 18 any any DT 40436 267 19 purpose purpose NN 40436 267 20 ? ? . 40436 268 1 No no DT 40436 268 2 man man NN 40436 268 3 searches search VBZ 40436 268 4 for for IN 40436 268 5 what what WP 40436 268 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 268 7 already already RB 40436 268 8 knows know VBZ 40436 268 9 : : : 40436 268 10 and and CC 40436 268 11 for for IN 40436 268 12 what what WP 40436 268 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 268 14 does do VBZ 40436 268 15 not not RB 40436 268 16 know know VB 40436 268 17 , , , 40436 268 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 268 19 is be VBZ 40436 268 20 useless useless JJ 40436 268 21 to to TO 40436 268 22 search search VB 40436 268 23 , , , 40436 268 24 for for IN 40436 268 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 268 26 can can MD 40436 268 27 not not RB 40436 268 28 tell tell VB 40436 268 29 when when WRB 40436 268 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 268 31 has have VBZ 40436 268 32 found find VBN 40436 268 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 268 34 _ _ NNP 40436 268 35 ib ib UH 40436 268 36 . . . 40436 268 37 _ _ NNP 40436 268 38 Theory Theory NNP 40436 268 39 of of IN 40436 268 40 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 268 41 propounded propound VBN 40436 268 42 by by IN 40436 268 43 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 268 44 -- -- : 40436 268 45 anterior anterior NN 40436 268 46 immortality immortality NN 40436 268 47 of of IN 40436 268 48 the the DT 40436 268 49 soul soul NN 40436 268 50 -- -- : 40436 268 51 what what WP 40436 268 52 is be VBZ 40436 268 53 called call VBN 40436 268 54 teaching teaching NN 40436 268 55 is be VBZ 40436 268 56 the the DT 40436 268 57 revival revival NN 40436 268 58 and and CC 40436 268 59 recognition recognition NN 40436 268 60 of of IN 40436 268 61 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 268 62 acquired acquire VBN 40436 268 63 in in IN 40436 268 64 a a DT 40436 268 65 former former JJ 40436 268 66 life life NN 40436 268 67 , , , 40436 268 68 but but CC 40436 268 69 forgotten forget VBN 40436 268 70 _ _ NNP 40436 268 71 ib ib UH 40436 268 72 . . . 40436 268 73 _ _ NNP 40436 268 74 Illustration Illustration NNP 40436 268 75 of of IN 40436 268 76 this this DT 40436 268 77 theory theory NN 40436 268 78 -- -- : 40436 268 79 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 268 80 may may MD 40436 268 81 be be VB 40436 268 82 revived revive VBN 40436 268 83 by by IN 40436 268 84 skilful skilful JJ 40436 268 85 questions question NNS 40436 268 86 in in IN 40436 268 87 the the DT 40436 268 88 mind mind NN 40436 268 89 of of IN 40436 268 90 a a DT 40436 268 91 man man NN 40436 268 92 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 268 93 untaught untaught JJ 40436 268 94 . . . 40436 269 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 269 2 questions question NNS 40436 269 3 the the DT 40436 269 4 slave slave NN 40436 269 5 of of IN 40436 269 6 Menon Menon NNP 40436 269 7 238 238 CD 40436 269 8 Enquiry Enquiry NNP 40436 269 9 taken take VBN 40436 269 10 up up RP 40436 269 11 -- -- : 40436 269 12 Whether whether IN 40436 269 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 269 14 is be VBZ 40436 269 15 teachable teachable JJ 40436 269 16 ? ? . 40436 270 1 without without IN 40436 270 2 determining determine VBG 40436 270 3 what what WDT 40436 270 4 virtue virtue NN 40436 270 5 is be VBZ 40436 270 6 239 239 CD 40436 270 7 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 270 8 is be VBZ 40436 270 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 270 10 -- -- : 40436 270 11 no no DT 40436 270 12 possessions possession NNS 40436 270 13 , , , 40436 270 14 no no DT 40436 270 15 attributes attribute NNS 40436 270 16 , , , 40436 270 17 either either DT 40436 270 18 of of IN 40436 270 19 mind mind NN 40436 270 20 or or CC 40436 270 21 body body NN 40436 270 22 , , , 40436 270 23 are be VBP 40436 270 24 good good JJ 40436 270 25 or or CC 40436 270 26 profitable profitable JJ 40436 270 27 , , , 40436 270 28 except except IN 40436 270 29 under under IN 40436 270 30 the the DT 40436 270 31 guidance guidance NN 40436 270 32 of of IN 40436 270 33 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 270 34 _ _ NNP 40436 270 35 ib ib NNP 40436 270 36 . . . 40436 270 37 _ _ NNP 40436 270 38 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 270 39 , , , 40436 270 40 as as IN 40436 270 41 being be VBG 40436 270 42 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 270 43 , , , 40436 270 44 must must MD 40436 270 45 be be VB 40436 270 46 teachable teachable JJ 40436 270 47 . . . 40436 271 1 Yet yet CC 40436 271 2 there there EX 40436 271 3 are be VBP 40436 271 4 opposing oppose VBG 40436 271 5 reasons reason NNS 40436 271 6 , , , 40436 271 7 showing show VBG 40436 271 8 that that IN 40436 271 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 271 10 can can MD 40436 271 11 not not RB 40436 271 12 be be VB 40436 271 13 teachable teachable JJ 40436 271 14 . . . 40436 272 1 No no DT 40436 272 2 teachers teacher NNS 40436 272 3 of of IN 40436 272 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 272 5 can can MD 40436 272 6 be be VB 40436 272 7 found find VBN 40436 272 8 239 239 CD 40436 272 9 Conversation conversation NN 40436 272 10 of of IN 40436 272 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 272 12 with with IN 40436 272 13 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 272 14 , , , 40436 272 15 who who WP 40436 272 16 detests detest VBZ 40436 272 17 the the DT 40436 272 18 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 272 19 , , , 40436 272 20 and and CC 40436 272 21 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 272 22 that that IN 40436 272 23 any any DT 40436 272 24 one one CD 40436 272 25 of of IN 40436 272 26 the the DT 40436 272 27 leading lead VBG 40436 272 28 politicians politician NNS 40436 272 29 can can MD 40436 272 30 teach teach VB 40436 272 31 virtue virtue NN 40436 272 32 240 240 CD 40436 272 33 Confused confused JJ 40436 272 34 state state NN 40436 272 35 of of IN 40436 272 36 the the DT 40436 272 37 discussion discussion NN 40436 272 38 . . . 40436 273 1 No no DT 40436 273 2 way way NN 40436 273 3 of of IN 40436 273 4 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 273 5 virtue virtue NN 40436 273 6 is be VBZ 40436 273 7 shown show VBN 40436 273 8 _ _ NNP 40436 273 9 ib ib NN 40436 273 10 . . . 40436 273 11 _ _ NNP 40436 273 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 273 13 modifies modify VBZ 40436 273 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 273 15 premisses premiss NNS 40436 273 16 -- -- : 40436 273 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 273 18 is be VBZ 40436 273 19 not not RB 40436 273 20 the the DT 40436 273 21 only only JJ 40436 273 22 thing thing NN 40436 273 23 which which WDT 40436 273 24 guides guide VBZ 40436 273 25 to to IN 40436 273 26 good good JJ 40436 273 27 results result NNS 40436 273 28 -- -- : 40436 273 29 right right JJ 40436 273 30 opinion opinion NN 40436 273 31 will will MD 40436 273 32 do do VB 40436 273 33 the the DT 40436 273 34 same same JJ 40436 273 35 _ _ NNP 40436 273 36 ib ib UH 40436 273 37 . . . 40436 273 38 _ _ NNP 40436 273 39 Right right JJ 40436 273 40 opinion opinion NN 40436 273 41 can can MD 40436 273 42 not not RB 40436 273 43 be be VB 40436 273 44 relied rely VBN 40436 273 45 on on RP 40436 273 46 for for IN 40436 273 47 staying stay VBG 40436 273 48 in in IN 40436 273 49 the the DT 40436 273 50 mind mind NN 40436 273 51 , , , 40436 273 52 and and CC 40436 273 53 can can MD 40436 273 54 never never RB 40436 273 55 give give VB 40436 273 56 rational rational JJ 40436 273 57 explanations explanation NNS 40436 273 58 , , , 40436 273 59 nor nor CC 40436 273 60 teach teach VB 40436 273 61 others other NNS 40436 273 62 -- -- : 40436 273 63 good good JJ 40436 273 64 practical practical JJ 40436 273 65 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 273 66 receive receive VBP 40436 273 67 right right JJ 40436 273 68 opinion opinion NN 40436 273 69 by by IN 40436 273 70 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 273 71 from from IN 40436 273 72 the the DT 40436 273 73 Gods Gods NNP 40436 273 74 241 241 CD 40436 273 75 All all PDT 40436 273 76 the the DT 40436 273 77 real real JJ 40436 273 78 virtue virtue NN 40436 273 79 that that IN 40436 273 80 there there EX 40436 273 81 is be VBZ 40436 273 82 , , , 40436 273 83 is be VBZ 40436 273 84 communicated communicate VBN 40436 273 85 by by IN 40436 273 86 special special JJ 40436 273 87 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 273 88 from from IN 40436 273 89 the the DT 40436 273 90 Gods Gods NNP 40436 273 91 242 242 CD 40436 273 92 But but CC 40436 273 93 what what WDT 40436 273 94 virtue virtue NN 40436 273 95 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 273 96 is be VBZ 40436 273 97 , , , 40436 273 98 remains remain VBZ 40436 273 99 unknown unknown JJ 40436 273 100 _ _ NNP 40436 273 101 ib ib UH 40436 273 102 . . . 40436 273 103 _ _ NNP 40436 273 104 Remarks Remarks NNP 40436 273 105 on on IN 40436 273 106 the the DT 40436 273 107 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 273 108 . . . 40436 274 1 Proper proper JJ 40436 274 2 order order NN 40436 274 3 for for IN 40436 274 4 examining examine VBG 40436 274 5 the the DT 40436 274 6 different different JJ 40436 274 7 topics topic NNS 40436 274 8 , , , 40436 274 9 is be VBZ 40436 274 10 pointed point VBN 40436 274 11 out out RP 40436 274 12 by by IN 40436 274 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 274 14 _ _ NNP 40436 274 15 ib ib NN 40436 274 16 . . . 40436 274 17 _ _ NNP 40436 274 18 Mischief Mischief NNP 40436 274 19 of of IN 40436 274 20 debating debate VBG 40436 274 21 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 274 22 and and CC 40436 274 23 secondary secondary JJ 40436 274 24 questions question NNS 40436 274 25 when when WRB 40436 274 26 the the DT 40436 274 27 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 274 28 notions notion NNS 40436 274 29 and and CC 40436 274 30 word word NN 40436 274 31 are be VBP 40436 274 32 unsettled unsettled JJ 40436 274 33 _ _ NNP 40436 274 34 ib ib UH 40436 274 35 . . . 40436 274 36 _ _ NNP 40436 274 37 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 40436 274 38 of of IN 40436 274 39 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 274 40 in in IN 40436 274 41 the the DT 40436 274 42 Menon Menon NNP 40436 274 43 -- -- : 40436 274 44 desire desire NN 40436 274 45 of of IN 40436 274 46 good good NN 40436 274 47 alleged allege VBN 40436 274 48 to to TO 40436 274 49 be be VB 40436 274 50 universally universally RB 40436 274 51 felt feel VBN 40436 274 52 -- -- : 40436 274 53 in in IN 40436 274 54 what what WDT 40436 274 55 sense sense NN 40436 274 56 this this DT 40436 274 57 is be VBZ 40436 274 58 true true JJ 40436 274 59 243 243 CD 40436 274 60 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 274 61 requires require VBZ 40436 274 62 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 274 63 as as IN 40436 274 64 the the DT 40436 274 65 principal principal JJ 40436 274 66 condition condition NN 40436 274 67 of of IN 40436 274 68 virtue virtue NN 40436 274 69 , , , 40436 274 70 but but CC 40436 274 71 does do VBZ 40436 274 72 not not RB 40436 274 73 determine determine VB 40436 274 74 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 274 75 , , , 40436 274 76 of of IN 40436 274 77 what what WP 40436 274 78 ? ? . 40436 275 1 244 244 CD 40436 275 2 Subject subject NN 40436 275 3 of of IN 40436 275 4 Menon Menon NNP 40436 275 5 ; ; : 40436 275 6 same same JJ 40436 275 7 as as IN 40436 275 8 that that DT 40436 275 9 of of IN 40436 275 10 the the DT 40436 275 11 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 275 12 -- -- : 40436 275 13 diversity diversity NN 40436 275 14 of of IN 40436 275 15 handling handling NN 40436 275 16 -- -- : 40436 275 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 275 18 is be VBZ 40436 275 19 not not RB 40436 275 20 anxious anxious JJ 40436 275 21 to to TO 40436 275 22 settle settle VB 40436 275 23 a a DT 40436 275 24 question question NN 40436 275 25 and and CC 40436 275 26 get get VB 40436 275 27 rid rid VBN 40436 275 28 of of IN 40436 275 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 275 30 245 245 CD 40436 275 31 Anxiety Anxiety NNP 40436 275 32 of of IN 40436 275 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 275 34 to to TO 40436 275 35 keep keep VB 40436 275 36 up up RP 40436 275 37 and and CC 40436 275 38 enforce enforce VB 40436 275 39 the the DT 40436 275 40 spirit spirit NN 40436 275 41 of of IN 40436 275 42 research research NN 40436 275 43 246 246 CD 40436 275 44 Great great JJ 40436 275 45 question question NN 40436 275 46 discussed discuss VBN 40436 275 47 among among IN 40436 275 48 the the DT 40436 275 49 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 275 50 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 275 51 -- -- : 40436 275 52 criterion criterion NN 40436 275 53 of of IN 40436 275 54 truth truth NN 40436 275 55 -- -- . 40436 275 56 Wherein wherein WRB 40436 275 57 consists consist VBZ 40436 275 58 the the DT 40436 275 59 process process NN 40436 275 60 of of IN 40436 275 61 verification verification NN 40436 275 62 ? ? . 40436 276 1 _ _ NNP 40436 276 2 ib ib UH 40436 276 3 . . . 40436 276 4 _ _ NNP 40436 276 5 None none NN 40436 276 6 of of IN 40436 276 7 the the DT 40436 276 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 276 9 were be VBD 40436 276 10 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 276 11 with with IN 40436 276 12 the the DT 40436 276 13 answer answer NN 40436 276 14 here here RB 40436 276 15 made make VBN 40436 276 16 by by IN 40436 276 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 276 18 -- -- : 40436 276 19 that that IN 40436 276 20 verification verification NN 40436 276 21 consists consist VBZ 40436 276 22 in in IN 40436 276 23 appeal appeal NN 40436 276 24 to to IN 40436 276 25 pre pre JJ 40436 276 26 - - JJ 40436 276 27 natal natal JJ 40436 276 28 experience experience NN 40436 276 29 247 247 CD 40436 276 30 Plato Plato NNP 40436 276 31 's 's POS 40436 276 32 view view NN 40436 276 33 of of IN 40436 276 34 the the DT 40436 276 35 immortality immortality NN 40436 276 36 of of IN 40436 276 37 the the DT 40436 276 38 soul soul NN 40436 276 39 -- -- : 40436 276 40 difference difference NN 40436 276 41 between between IN 40436 276 42 the the DT 40436 276 43 Menon Menon NNP 40436 276 44 , , , 40436 276 45 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 276 46 , , , 40436 276 47 and and CC 40436 276 48 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 276 49 249 249 CD 40436 276 50 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 40436 276 51 of of IN 40436 276 52 Plato Plato NNP 40436 276 53 , , , 40436 276 54 that that DT 40436 276 55 new new JJ 40436 276 56 truth truth NN 40436 276 57 may may MD 40436 276 58 be be VB 40436 276 59 elicited elicit VBN 40436 276 60 by by IN 40436 276 61 skilful skilful JJ 40436 276 62 examination examination NN 40436 276 63 out out IN 40436 276 64 of of IN 40436 276 65 the the DT 40436 276 66 unlettered unlettered JJ 40436 276 67 mind mind NN 40436 276 68 -- -- : 40436 276 69 how how WRB 40436 276 70 far far RB 40436 276 71 correct correct JJ 40436 276 72 ? ? . 40436 277 1 _ _ NNP 40436 277 2 ib ib UH 40436 277 3 . . . 40436 277 4 _ _ NNP 40436 277 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 277 6 's 's POS 40436 277 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 277 8 about about IN 40436 277 9 _ _ NNP 40436 277 10 à à NNP 40436 277 11 priori priori VBP 40436 277 12 _ _ NNP 40436 277 13 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 277 14 -- -- : 40436 277 15 different different JJ 40436 277 16 from from IN 40436 277 17 the the DT 40436 277 18 modern modern JJ 40436 277 19 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 277 20 251 251 CD 40436 277 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 277 22 's 's POS 40436 277 23 theory theory NN 40436 277 24 about about IN 40436 277 25 pre pre JJ 40436 277 26 - - JJ 40436 277 27 natal natal JJ 40436 277 28 experience experience NN 40436 277 29 . . . 40436 278 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 278 2 took take VBD 40436 278 3 no no DT 40436 278 4 pains pain NNS 40436 278 5 to to TO 40436 278 6 ascertain ascertain VB 40436 278 7 and and CC 40436 278 8 measure measure VB 40436 278 9 the the DT 40436 278 10 extent extent NN 40436 278 11 of of IN 40436 278 12 post post JJ 40436 278 13 - - JJ 40436 278 14 natal natal JJ 40436 278 15 experience experience NN 40436 278 16 252 252 CD 40436 278 17 Little little JJ 40436 278 18 or or CC 40436 278 19 nothing nothing NN 40436 278 20 is be VBZ 40436 278 21 said say VBN 40436 278 22 in in IN 40436 278 23 the the DT 40436 278 24 Menon Menon NNP 40436 278 25 about about IN 40436 278 26 the the DT 40436 278 27 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 278 28 Ideas Ideas NNPS 40436 278 29 or or CC 40436 278 30 Forms Forms NNPS 40436 278 31 253 253 CD 40436 278 32 What what WP 40436 278 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 278 34 meant mean VBD 40436 278 35 by by IN 40436 278 36 Causal Causal NNP 40436 278 37 Reasoning Reasoning NNP 40436 278 38 -- -- : 40436 278 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 278 40 distinction distinction NN 40436 278 41 between between IN 40436 278 42 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 278 43 and and CC 40436 278 44 right right JJ 40436 278 45 opinion opinion NN 40436 278 46 _ _ NNP 40436 278 47 ib ib UH 40436 278 48 . . . 40436 278 49 _ _ NNP 40436 278 50 This this DT 40436 278 51 distinction distinction NN 40436 278 52 compared compare VBN 40436 278 53 with with IN 40436 278 54 modern modern JJ 40436 278 55 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 278 56 views view NNS 40436 278 57 254 254 CD 40436 278 58 Manifestation Manifestation NNP 40436 278 59 of of IN 40436 278 60 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 278 61 -- -- : 40436 278 62 intense intense JJ 40436 278 63 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 278 64 to to IN 40436 278 65 the the DT 40436 278 66 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 278 67 and and CC 40436 278 68 to to TO 40436 278 69 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 278 70 generally generally RB 40436 278 71 255 255 CD 40436 278 72 The the DT 40436 278 73 enemy enemy NN 40436 278 74 of of IN 40436 278 75 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 278 76 is be VBZ 40436 278 77 also also RB 40436 278 78 the the DT 40436 278 79 enemy enemy NN 40436 278 80 of of IN 40436 278 81 the the DT 40436 278 82 sophists sophist NNS 40436 278 83 -- -- : 40436 278 84 practical practical JJ 40436 278 85 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 278 86 256 256 CD 40436 278 87 The the DT 40436 278 88 Menon Menon NNP 40436 278 89 brings bring VBZ 40436 278 90 forward forward RB 40436 278 91 the the DT 40436 278 92 point point NN 40436 278 93 of of IN 40436 278 94 analogy analogy NN 40436 278 95 between between IN 40436 278 96 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 278 97 and and CC 40436 278 98 the the DT 40436 278 99 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 278 100 , , , 40436 278 101 in in IN 40436 278 102 which which WDT 40436 278 103 both both DT 40436 278 104 were be VBD 40436 278 105 disliked dislike VBN 40436 278 106 by by IN 40436 278 107 the the DT 40436 278 108 practical practical JJ 40436 278 109 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 278 110 257 257 CD 40436 278 111 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 278 112 XXIII xxiii NN 40436 278 113 . . . 40436 279 1 PROTAGORAS PROTAGORAS NNP 40436 279 2 . . . 40436 280 1 Scenic scenic JJ 40436 280 2 arrangement arrangement NN 40436 280 3 and and CC 40436 280 4 personages personage NNS 40436 280 5 of of IN 40436 280 6 the the DT 40436 280 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 280 8 259 259 CD 40436 280 9 Introduction introduction NN 40436 280 10 . . . 40436 281 1 Eagerness eagerness NN 40436 281 2 of of IN 40436 281 3 the the DT 40436 281 4 youthful youthful JJ 40436 281 5 Hippokrates hippokrate NNS 40436 281 6 to to TO 40436 281 7 become become VB 40436 281 8 acquainted acquaint VBN 40436 281 9 with with IN 40436 281 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 281 11 260 260 CD 40436 281 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 281 13 questions question NNS 40436 281 14 Hippokrates hippokrate NNS 40436 281 15 as as IN 40436 281 16 to to IN 40436 281 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 281 18 purpose purpose NN 40436 281 19 and and CC 40436 281 20 expectations expectation NNS 40436 281 21 from from IN 40436 281 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 281 23 _ _ NNP 40436 281 24 ib ib UH 40436 281 25 . . . 40436 281 26 _ _ NNP 40436 281 27 Danger Danger NNP 40436 281 28 of of IN 40436 281 29 going go VBG 40436 281 30 to to TO 40436 281 31 imbibe imbibe VB 40436 281 32 the the DT 40436 281 33 instruction instruction NN 40436 281 34 of of IN 40436 281 35 a a DT 40436 281 36 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 281 37 without without IN 40436 281 38 knowing know VBG 40436 281 39 beforehand beforehand RB 40436 281 40 what what WP 40436 281 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 281 42 is be VBZ 40436 281 43 about about JJ 40436 281 44 to to TO 40436 281 45 teach teach VB 40436 281 46 262 262 CD 40436 281 47 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 281 48 on on IN 40436 281 49 the the DT 40436 281 50 Introduction introduction NN 40436 281 51 . . . 40436 282 1 False false JJ 40436 282 2 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 282 3 of of IN 40436 282 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 282 5 brought bring VBN 40436 282 6 to to IN 40436 282 7 light light NN 40436 282 8 263 263 CD 40436 282 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 282 10 and and CC 40436 282 11 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 282 12 go go VBP 40436 282 13 to to IN 40436 282 14 the the DT 40436 282 15 house house NN 40436 282 16 of of IN 40436 282 17 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 282 18 . . . 40436 283 1 Company company NN 40436 283 2 therein therein RB 40436 283 3 . . . 40436 284 1 Respect respect NN 40436 284 2 shown show VBN 40436 284 3 to to IN 40436 284 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 284 5 264 264 CD 40436 284 6 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 284 7 of of IN 40436 284 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 284 9 to to IN 40436 284 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 284 11 . . . 40436 285 1 Answer answer NN 40436 285 2 of of IN 40436 285 3 the the DT 40436 285 4 latter latter JJ 40436 285 5 , , , 40436 285 6 declaring declare VBG 40436 285 7 the the DT 40436 285 8 antiquity antiquity NN 40436 285 9 of of IN 40436 285 10 the the DT 40436 285 11 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 285 12 profession profession NN 40436 285 13 , , , 40436 285 14 and and CC 40436 285 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 285 16 own own JJ 40436 285 17 openness openness NN 40436 285 18 in in IN 40436 285 19 avowing avow VBG 40436 285 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 285 21 a a DT 40436 285 22 sophist sophist JJ 40436 285 23 _ _ NNP 40436 285 24 ib ib UH 40436 285 25 . . . 40436 285 26 _ _ NNP 40436 285 27 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 285 28 prefers prefer VBZ 40436 285 29 to to TO 40436 285 30 converse converse VB 40436 285 31 in in IN 40436 285 32 presence presence NN 40436 285 33 of of IN 40436 285 34 the the DT 40436 285 35 assembled assemble VBN 40436 285 36 company company NN 40436 285 37 266 266 CD 40436 285 38 Answers Answers NNPS 40436 285 39 of of IN 40436 285 40 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 285 41 . . . 40436 286 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 286 2 intends intend VBZ 40436 286 3 to to TO 40436 286 4 train train VB 40436 286 5 young young JJ 40436 286 6 men man NNS 40436 286 7 as as IN 40436 286 8 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 286 9 citizens citizen NNS 40436 286 10 _ _ IN 40436 286 11 ib ib NN 40436 286 12 . . . 40436 286 13 _ _ NNP 40436 286 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 286 15 doubts doubt VBZ 40436 286 16 whether whether IN 40436 286 17 virtue virtue NN 40436 286 18 is be VBZ 40436 286 19 teachable teachable JJ 40436 286 20 . . . 40436 287 1 Reasons reason NNS 40436 287 2 for for IN 40436 287 3 such such JJ 40436 287 4 doubt doubt NN 40436 287 5 . . . 40436 288 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 288 2 is be VBZ 40436 288 3 asked ask VBN 40436 288 4 to to TO 40436 288 5 explain explain VB 40436 288 6 whether whether IN 40436 288 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 288 8 is be VBZ 40436 288 9 or or CC 40436 288 10 not not RB 40436 288 11 . . . 40436 289 1 _ _ NNP 40436 289 2 ib ib UH 40436 289 3 . . . 40436 289 4 _ _ NNP 40436 289 5 Explanation Explanation NNP 40436 289 6 of of IN 40436 289 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 289 8 . . . 40436 290 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 290 2 begins begin VBZ 40436 290 3 with with IN 40436 290 4 a a DT 40436 290 5 mythe mythe NN 40436 290 6 267 267 CD 40436 290 7 Mythe Mythe NNP 40436 290 8 . . . 40436 291 1 First first JJ 40436 291 2 fabrication fabrication NN 40436 291 3 of of IN 40436 291 4 men man NNS 40436 291 5 by by IN 40436 291 6 the the DT 40436 291 7 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 291 8 . . . 40436 292 1 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 292 2 and and CC 40436 292 3 Epimetheus Epimetheus NNP 40436 292 4 . . . 40436 293 1 Bad bad JJ 40436 293 2 distribution distribution NN 40436 293 3 of of IN 40436 293 4 endowments endowment NNS 40436 293 5 to to TO 40436 293 6 man man VB 40436 293 7 by by IN 40436 293 8 the the DT 40436 293 9 latter latter JJ 40436 293 10 . . . 40436 294 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 294 2 is be VBZ 40436 294 3 partly partly RB 40436 294 4 amended amend VBN 40436 294 5 by by IN 40436 294 6 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 294 7 267 267 CD 40436 294 8 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 294 9 gave give VBD 40436 294 10 to to IN 40436 294 11 mankind mankind NN 40436 294 12 skill skill NN 40436 294 13 for for IN 40436 294 14 the the DT 40436 294 15 supply supply NN 40436 294 16 of of IN 40436 294 17 individual individual NN 40436 294 18 wants want VBZ 40436 294 19 , , , 40436 294 20 but but CC 40436 294 21 could could MD 40436 294 22 not not RB 40436 294 23 give give VB 40436 294 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 294 25 the the DT 40436 294 26 social social JJ 40436 294 27 art art NN 40436 294 28 -- -- : 40436 294 29 Mankind mankind NN 40436 294 30 are be VBP 40436 294 31 on on IN 40436 294 32 the the DT 40436 294 33 point point NN 40436 294 34 of of IN 40436 294 35 perishing perish VBG 40436 294 36 , , , 40436 294 37 when when WRB 40436 294 38 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 294 39 sends send VBZ 40436 294 40 to to IN 40436 294 41 them -PRON- PRP 40436 294 42 the the DT 40436 294 43 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 294 44 essential essential JJ 40436 294 45 for for IN 40436 294 46 society society NN 40436 294 47 268 268 CD 40436 294 48 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 294 49 follows follow VBZ 40436 294 50 up up RP 40436 294 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 294 52 mythe mythe NN 40436 294 53 by by IN 40436 294 54 a a DT 40436 294 55 discourse discourse NN 40436 294 56 . . . 40436 295 1 Justice justice NN 40436 295 2 and and CC 40436 295 3 the the DT 40436 295 4 sense sense NN 40436 295 5 of of IN 40436 295 6 shame shame NN 40436 295 7 are be VBP 40436 295 8 not not RB 40436 295 9 professional professional JJ 40436 295 10 attributes attribute NNS 40436 295 11 , , , 40436 295 12 but but CC 40436 295 13 are be VBP 40436 295 14 possessed possess VBN 40436 295 15 by by IN 40436 295 16 all all DT 40436 295 17 citizens citizen NNS 40436 295 18 and and CC 40436 295 19 taught teach VBN 40436 295 20 by by IN 40436 295 21 all all RB 40436 295 22 to to IN 40436 295 23 all all DT 40436 295 24 269 269 CD 40436 295 25 Constant constant JJ 40436 295 26 teaching teaching NN 40436 295 27 of of IN 40436 295 28 virtue virtue NN 40436 295 29 . . . 40436 296 1 Theory theory NN 40436 296 2 of of IN 40436 296 3 punishment punishment NN 40436 296 4 270 270 CD 40436 296 5 Why why WRB 40436 296 6 eminent eminent JJ 40436 296 7 men man NNS 40436 296 8 can can MD 40436 296 9 not not RB 40436 296 10 make make VB 40436 296 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 296 12 sons son NNS 40436 296 13 eminent eminent VB 40436 296 14 271 271 CD 40436 296 15 Teaching teaching NN 40436 296 16 by by IN 40436 296 17 parents parent NNS 40436 296 18 , , , 40436 296 19 schoolmaster schoolmaster NN 40436 296 20 , , , 40436 296 21 harpist harpist NN 40436 296 22 , , , 40436 296 23 laws law NNS 40436 296 24 , , , 40436 296 25 dikastery dikastery NN 40436 296 26 , , , 40436 296 27 & & CC 40436 296 28 c. c. NNP 40436 296 29 _ _ NNP 40436 296 30 ib ib UH 40436 296 31 . . . 40436 296 32 _ _ NNP 40436 296 33 All all DT 40436 296 34 learn learn VB 40436 296 35 virtue virtue NN 40436 296 36 from from IN 40436 296 37 the the DT 40436 296 38 same same JJ 40436 296 39 teaching teaching NN 40436 296 40 by by RB 40436 296 41 all all DT 40436 296 42 . . . 40436 297 1 Whether whether IN 40436 297 2 a a DT 40436 297 3 learner learner NN 40436 297 4 shall shall MD 40436 297 5 acquire acquire VB 40436 297 6 more more RBR 40436 297 7 or or CC 40436 297 8 less less JJR 40436 297 9 of of IN 40436 297 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 297 11 , , , 40436 297 12 depends depend VBZ 40436 297 13 upon upon IN 40436 297 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 297 15 own own JJ 40436 297 16 individual individual JJ 40436 297 17 aptitude aptitude NN 40436 297 18 272 272 CD 40436 297 19 Analogy Analogy NNP 40436 297 20 of of IN 40436 297 21 learning learn VBG 40436 297 22 vernacular vernacular JJ 40436 297 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 297 24 . . . 40436 298 1 No no DT 40436 298 2 special special JJ 40436 298 3 teacher teacher NN 40436 298 4 thereof thereof RB 40436 298 5 . . . 40436 299 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 299 2 teaches teach VBZ 40436 299 3 virtue virtue VBP 40436 299 4 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 299 5 better well JJR 40436 299 6 than than IN 40436 299 7 others other NNS 40436 299 8 273 273 CD 40436 299 9 The the DT 40436 299 10 sons son NNS 40436 299 11 of of IN 40436 299 12 great great JJ 40436 299 13 artists artist NNS 40436 299 14 do do VBP 40436 299 15 not not RB 40436 299 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 299 17 become become VB 40436 299 18 great great JJ 40436 299 19 artists artist NNS 40436 299 20 274 274 CD 40436 299 21 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 299 22 upon upon IN 40436 299 23 the the DT 40436 299 24 mythe mythe NN 40436 299 25 and and CC 40436 299 26 discourse discourse NN 40436 299 27 . . . 40436 300 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 300 2 explain explain VBP 40436 300 3 the the DT 40436 300 4 manner manner NN 40436 300 5 in in IN 40436 300 6 which which WDT 40436 300 7 the the DT 40436 300 8 established established JJ 40436 300 9 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 300 10 of of IN 40436 300 11 a a DT 40436 300 12 community community NN 40436 300 13 propagates propagate VBZ 40436 300 14 and and CC 40436 300 15 perpetuates perpetuate VBZ 40436 300 16 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 300 17 274 274 CD 40436 300 18 Antithesis Antithesis NNP 40436 300 19 of of IN 40436 300 20 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 300 21 and and CC 40436 300 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 300 23 . . . 40436 301 1 Whether whether IN 40436 301 2 virtue virtue NN 40436 301 3 is be VBZ 40436 301 4 to to TO 40436 301 5 be be VB 40436 301 6 assimilated assimilate VBN 40436 301 7 to to IN 40436 301 8 a a DT 40436 301 9 special special JJ 40436 301 10 art art NN 40436 301 11 275 275 CD 40436 301 12 Procedure Procedure NNP 40436 301 13 of of IN 40436 301 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 301 15 in in IN 40436 301 16 regard regard NN 40436 301 17 to to IN 40436 301 18 the the DT 40436 301 19 discourse discourse NN 40436 301 20 of of IN 40436 301 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 301 22 -- -- : 40436 301 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 301 24 compliments compliment VBZ 40436 301 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 301 26 as as IN 40436 301 27 an an DT 40436 301 28 exposition exposition NN 40436 301 29 , , , 40436 301 30 and and CC 40436 301 31 analyses analyse VBZ 40436 301 32 some some DT 40436 301 33 of of IN 40436 301 34 the the DT 40436 301 35 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 301 36 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 301 37 276 276 CD 40436 301 38 One one CD 40436 301 39 purpose purpose NN 40436 301 40 of of IN 40436 301 41 the the DT 40436 301 42 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 301 43 . . . 40436 302 1 To to TO 40436 302 2 contrast contrast VB 40436 302 3 continuous continuous JJ 40436 302 4 discourse discourse NN 40436 302 5 with with IN 40436 302 6 short short JJ 40436 302 7 cross cross NN 40436 302 8 - - JJ 40436 302 9 examining examine VBG 40436 302 10 question question NN 40436 302 11 and and CC 40436 302 12 answer answer NN 40436 302 13 277 277 CD 40436 302 14 Questions question NNS 40436 302 15 by by IN 40436 302 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 302 17 -- -- : 40436 302 18 Whether whether IN 40436 302 19 virtue virtue NN 40436 302 20 is be VBZ 40436 302 21 one one CD 40436 302 22 and and CC 40436 302 23 indivisible indivisible JJ 40436 302 24 , , , 40436 302 25 or or CC 40436 302 26 composed compose VBN 40436 302 27 of of IN 40436 302 28 different different JJ 40436 302 29 parts part NNS 40436 302 30 ? ? . 40436 303 1 Whether whether IN 40436 303 2 the the DT 40436 303 3 parts part NNS 40436 303 4 are be VBP 40436 303 5 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 40436 303 6 or or CC 40436 303 7 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ 40436 303 8 ? ? . 40436 304 1 _ _ NNP 40436 304 2 ib ib UH 40436 304 3 . . . 40436 304 4 _ _ NNP 40436 304 5 Whether whether IN 40436 304 6 justice justice NN 40436 304 7 is be VBZ 40436 304 8 just just RB 40436 304 9 , , , 40436 304 10 and and CC 40436 304 11 holiness holiness NN 40436 304 12 holy holy JJ 40436 304 13 ? ? . 40436 305 1 How how WRB 40436 305 2 far far JJ 40436 305 3 justice justice NN 40436 305 4 is be VBZ 40436 305 5 like like IN 40436 305 6 to to IN 40436 305 7 holiness holiness NN 40436 305 8 ? ? . 40436 306 1 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 306 2 protests protest NNS 40436 306 3 against against IN 40436 306 4 an an DT 40436 306 5 answer answer NN 40436 306 6 , , , 40436 306 7 " " `` 40436 306 8 If if IN 40436 306 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 306 10 please please VBP 40436 306 11 " " `` 40436 306 12 278 278 CD 40436 306 13 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 306 14 and and CC 40436 306 15 moderation moderation NN 40436 306 16 are be VBP 40436 306 17 identical identical JJ 40436 306 18 , , , 40436 306 19 because because IN 40436 306 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 306 21 have have VBP 40436 306 22 the the DT 40436 306 23 same same JJ 40436 306 24 contrary contrary JJ 40436 306 25 279 279 CD 40436 306 26 Insufficient insufficient JJ 40436 306 27 reasons reason NNS 40436 306 28 given give VBN 40436 306 29 by by IN 40436 306 30 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 306 31 . . . 40436 307 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 307 2 seldom seldom RB 40436 307 3 cares care VBZ 40436 307 4 to to TO 40436 307 5 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 307 6 different different JJ 40436 307 7 meanings meaning NNS 40436 307 8 of of IN 40436 307 9 the the DT 40436 307 10 same same JJ 40436 307 11 term term NN 40436 307 12 _ _ NNP 40436 307 13 ib ib UH 40436 307 14 . . . 40436 307 15 _ _ NNP 40436 307 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 307 17 is be VBZ 40436 307 18 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 307 19 , , , 40436 307 20 and and CC 40436 307 21 becomes become VBZ 40436 307 22 irritated irritated JJ 40436 307 23 280 280 CD 40436 307 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 307 25 presses press VBZ 40436 307 26 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 307 27 farther farther RB 40436 307 28 . . . 40436 308 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 308 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 308 3 is be VBZ 40436 308 4 , , , 40436 308 5 to to TO 40436 308 6 test test VB 40436 308 7 opinions opinion NNS 40436 308 8 and and CC 40436 308 9 not not RB 40436 308 10 persons person NNS 40436 308 11 . . . 40436 309 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 309 2 answers answer VBZ 40436 309 3 with with IN 40436 309 4 angry angry JJ 40436 309 5 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 309 6 _ _ NNP 40436 309 7 ib ib UH 40436 309 8 . . . 40436 309 9 _ _ NNP 40436 309 10 Remonstrance remonstrance NN 40436 309 11 of of IN 40436 309 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 309 13 against against IN 40436 309 14 long long JJ 40436 309 15 answers answer NNS 40436 309 16 as as IN 40436 309 17 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 309 18 with with IN 40436 309 19 the the DT 40436 309 20 laws law NNS 40436 309 21 of of IN 40436 309 22 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 309 23 . . . 40436 310 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 310 2 persists persist VBZ 40436 310 3 . . . 40436 311 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 311 2 rises rise VBZ 40436 311 3 to to TO 40436 311 4 depart depart VB 40436 311 5 281 281 CD 40436 311 6 Interference Interference NNP 40436 311 7 of of IN 40436 311 8 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 311 9 to to TO 40436 311 10 get get VB 40436 311 11 the the DT 40436 311 12 debate debate NN 40436 311 13 continued continue VBN 40436 311 14 . . . 40436 312 1 Promiscuous promiscuous JJ 40436 312 2 conversation conversation NN 40436 312 3 . . . 40436 313 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 313 2 declares declare VBZ 40436 313 3 that that IN 40436 313 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 313 5 ought ought MD 40436 313 6 to to TO 40436 313 7 acknowledge acknowledge VB 40436 313 8 superiority superiority NN 40436 313 9 of of IN 40436 313 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 313 11 in in IN 40436 313 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 313 13 282 282 CD 40436 313 14 Claim claim NN 40436 313 15 of of IN 40436 313 16 a a DT 40436 313 17 special special JJ 40436 313 18 _ _ NNP 40436 313 19 locus locus NN 40436 313 20 standi standi NN 40436 313 21 _ _ NNP 40436 313 22 and and CC 40436 313 23 professorship professorship NN 40436 313 24 for for IN 40436 313 25 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 313 26 , , , 40436 313 27 apart apart RB 40436 313 28 from from IN 40436 313 29 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 313 30 _ _ NNP 40436 313 31 ib ib UH 40436 313 32 . . . 40436 313 33 _ _ NNP 40436 313 34 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 313 35 is be VBZ 40436 313 36 prevailed prevail VBN 40436 313 37 upon upon IN 40436 313 38 to to TO 40436 313 39 continue continue VB 40436 313 40 , , , 40436 313 41 and and CC 40436 313 42 invites invite VBZ 40436 313 43 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 313 44 to to TO 40436 313 45 question question VB 40436 313 46 him -PRON- PRP 40436 313 47 _ _ NNP 40436 313 48 ib ib UH 40436 313 49 . . . 40436 313 50 _ _ NNP 40436 313 51 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 313 52 extols extol VBZ 40436 313 53 the the DT 40436 313 54 importance importance NN 40436 313 55 of of IN 40436 313 56 knowing know VBG 40436 313 57 the the DT 40436 313 58 works work NNS 40436 313 59 of of IN 40436 313 60 the the DT 40436 313 61 poets poet NNS 40436 313 62 , , , 40436 313 63 and and CC 40436 313 64 questions question NNS 40436 313 65 about about IN 40436 313 66 parts part NNS 40436 313 67 of of IN 40436 313 68 a a DT 40436 313 69 song song NN 40436 313 70 of of IN 40436 313 71 Simonides simonide NNS 40436 313 72 . . . 40436 314 1 Dissenting dissent VBG 40436 314 2 opinions opinion NNS 40436 314 3 about about IN 40436 314 4 the the DT 40436 314 5 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 314 6 of of IN 40436 314 7 the the DT 40436 314 8 song song NN 40436 314 9 283 283 CD 40436 314 10 Long long JJ 40436 314 11 speech speech NN 40436 314 12 of of IN 40436 314 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 314 14 , , , 40436 314 15 expounding expound VBG 40436 314 16 the the DT 40436 314 17 purpose purpose NN 40436 314 18 of of IN 40436 314 19 the the DT 40436 314 20 song song NN 40436 314 21 , , , 40436 314 22 and and CC 40436 314 23 laying lay VBG 40436 314 24 down down RP 40436 314 25 an an DT 40436 314 26 ironical ironical JJ 40436 314 27 theory theory NN 40436 314 28 about about IN 40436 314 29 the the DT 40436 314 30 numerous numerous JJ 40436 314 31 concealed conceal VBN 40436 314 32 sophists sophist NNS 40436 314 33 at at IN 40436 314 34 Krete Krete NNP 40436 314 35 and and CC 40436 314 36 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 314 37 , , , 40436 314 38 masters master NNS 40436 314 39 of of IN 40436 314 40 short short JJ 40436 314 41 speech speech NN 40436 314 42 283 283 CD 40436 314 43 Character Character NNP 40436 314 44 of of IN 40436 314 45 this this DT 40436 314 46 speech speech NN 40436 314 47 -- -- : 40436 314 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 314 49 connection connection NN 40436 314 50 with with IN 40436 314 51 the the DT 40436 314 52 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 314 53 , , , 40436 314 54 and and CC 40436 314 55 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 314 56 general general JJ 40436 314 57 purpose purpose NN 40436 314 58 . . . 40436 315 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 315 2 inferior inferior JJ 40436 315 3 to to IN 40436 315 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 315 5 in in IN 40436 315 6 continuous continuous JJ 40436 315 7 speech speech NN 40436 315 8 284 284 CD 40436 315 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 315 10 depreciates depreciate VBZ 40436 315 11 the the DT 40436 315 12 value value NN 40436 315 13 of of IN 40436 315 14 debates debate NNS 40436 315 15 on on IN 40436 315 16 the the DT 40436 315 17 poets poet NNS 40436 315 18 . . . 40436 316 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 316 2 meaning meaning NN 40436 316 3 is be VBZ 40436 316 4 always always RB 40436 316 5 disputed dispute VBN 40436 316 6 , , , 40436 316 7 and and CC 40436 316 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 316 9 can can MD 40436 316 10 never never RB 40436 316 11 ask ask VB 40436 316 12 from from IN 40436 316 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 316 14 what what WP 40436 316 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 316 16 is be VBZ 40436 316 17 . . . 40436 317 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 317 2 consents consent VBZ 40436 317 3 reluctantly reluctantly RB 40436 317 4 to to TO 40436 317 5 resume resume VB 40436 317 6 the the DT 40436 317 7 task task NN 40436 317 8 of of IN 40436 317 9 answering answer VBG 40436 317 10 285 285 CD 40436 317 11 Purpose Purpose NNP 40436 317 12 of of IN 40436 317 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 317 14 to to TO 40436 317 15 sift sift VB 40436 317 16 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 317 17 which which WDT 40436 317 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 317 19 really really RB 40436 317 20 feels feel VBZ 40436 317 21 in in IN 40436 317 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 317 23 own own JJ 40436 317 24 mind mind NN 40436 317 25 . . . 40436 318 1 Importance importance NN 40436 318 2 of of IN 40436 318 3 a a DT 40436 318 4 colloquial colloquial JJ 40436 318 5 companion companion NN 40436 318 6 for for IN 40436 318 7 this this DT 40436 318 8 purpose purpose NN 40436 318 9 287 287 CD 40436 318 10 The the DT 40436 318 11 interrupted interrupted JJ 40436 318 12 debate debate NN 40436 318 13 is be VBZ 40436 318 14 resumed resume VBN 40436 318 15 . . . 40436 319 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 319 2 says say VBZ 40436 319 3 that that IN 40436 319 4 courage courage NN 40436 319 5 differs differ VBZ 40436 319 6 materially materially RB 40436 319 7 from from IN 40436 319 8 the the DT 40436 319 9 other other JJ 40436 319 10 branches branch NNS 40436 319 11 of of IN 40436 319 12 virtue virtue JJ 40436 319 13 288 288 CD 40436 319 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 319 15 argues argue VBZ 40436 319 16 to to TO 40436 319 17 prove prove VB 40436 319 18 that that DT 40436 319 19 courage courage NN 40436 319 20 consists consist VBZ 40436 319 21 in in IN 40436 319 22 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 319 23 or or CC 40436 319 24 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 319 25 . . . 40436 320 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 320 2 does do VBZ 40436 320 3 not not RB 40436 320 4 admit admit VB 40436 320 5 this this DT 40436 320 6 . . . 40436 321 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 321 2 changes change VBZ 40436 321 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 321 4 attack attack NN 40436 321 5 _ _ NNP 40436 321 6 ib ib UH 40436 321 7 . . . 40436 321 8 _ _ NNP 40436 321 9 Identity Identity NNP 40436 321 10 of of IN 40436 321 11 the the DT 40436 321 12 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 321 13 with with IN 40436 321 14 the the DT 40436 321 15 good good JJ 40436 321 16 -- -- : 40436 321 17 of of IN 40436 321 18 the the DT 40436 321 19 painful painful JJ 40436 321 20 with with IN 40436 321 21 the the DT 40436 321 22 evil evil NN 40436 321 23 . . . 40436 322 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 322 2 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 322 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 322 4 . . . 40436 323 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 323 2 denies deny VBZ 40436 323 3 . . . 40436 324 1 Debate debate NN 40436 324 2 289 289 CD 40436 324 3 Enquiry enquiry NN 40436 324 4 about about IN 40436 324 5 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 324 6 . . . 40436 325 1 Is be VBZ 40436 325 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 325 3 the the DT 40436 325 4 dominant dominant JJ 40436 325 5 agency agency NN 40436 325 6 in in IN 40436 325 7 the the DT 40436 325 8 mind mind NN 40436 325 9 ? ? . 40436 326 1 Or or CC 40436 326 2 is be VBZ 40436 326 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 326 4 overcome overcome VBN 40436 326 5 frequently frequently RB 40436 326 6 by by IN 40436 326 7 other other JJ 40436 326 8 agencies agency NNS 40436 326 9 , , , 40436 326 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 326 11 or or CC 40436 326 12 pain pain NN 40436 326 13 ? ? . 40436 327 1 Both both DT 40436 327 2 agree agree VBP 40436 327 3 that that IN 40436 327 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 327 5 is be VBZ 40436 327 6 dominant dominant JJ 40436 327 7 290 290 CD 40436 327 8 Mistake Mistake NNP 40436 327 9 of of IN 40436 327 10 supposing suppose VBG 40436 327 11 that that IN 40436 327 12 men man NNS 40436 327 13 act act VBP 40436 327 14 contrary contrary RB 40436 327 15 to to IN 40436 327 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 327 17 . . . 40436 328 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 328 2 never never RB 40436 328 3 call call VBP 40436 328 4 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 328 5 evils evil NNS 40436 328 6 , , , 40436 328 7 except except IN 40436 328 8 when when WRB 40436 328 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 328 10 entail entail VBP 40436 328 11 a a DT 40436 328 12 preponderance preponderance NN 40436 328 13 of of IN 40436 328 14 pain pain NN 40436 328 15 , , , 40436 328 16 or or CC 40436 328 17 a a DT 40436 328 18 disappointment disappointment NN 40436 328 19 of of IN 40436 328 20 greater great JJR 40436 328 21 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 328 22 291 291 CD 40436 328 23 Pleasure pleasure NN 40436 328 24 is be VBZ 40436 328 25 the the DT 40436 328 26 only only JJ 40436 328 27 good good JJ 40436 328 28 -- -- : 40436 328 29 pain pain VB 40436 328 30 the the DT 40436 328 31 only only JJ 40436 328 32 evil evil NN 40436 328 33 . . . 40436 329 1 No no DT 40436 329 2 man man NN 40436 329 3 does do VBZ 40436 329 4 evil evil NN 40436 329 5 voluntarily voluntarily RB 40436 329 6 , , , 40436 329 7 knowing know VBG 40436 329 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 329 9 to to TO 40436 329 10 be be VB 40436 329 11 evil evil JJ 40436 329 12 . . . 40436 330 1 Difference difference NN 40436 330 2 between between IN 40436 330 3 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 330 4 present present JJ 40436 330 5 and and CC 40436 330 6 future future JJ 40436 330 7 -- -- : 40436 330 8 resolves resolve VBZ 40436 330 9 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 330 10 into into IN 40436 330 11 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 330 12 and and CC 40436 330 13 pain pain VB 40436 330 14 292 292 CD 40436 330 15 Necessary necessary JJ 40436 330 16 resort resort NN 40436 330 17 to to IN 40436 330 18 the the DT 40436 330 19 measuring measure VBG 40436 330 20 art art NN 40436 330 21 for for IN 40436 330 22 choosing choose VBG 40436 330 23 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 330 24 rightly rightly RB 40436 330 25 -- -- : 40436 330 26 all all PDT 40436 330 27 the the DT 40436 330 28 security security NN 40436 330 29 of of IN 40436 330 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 330 31 lives life NNS 40436 330 32 depend depend VBP 40436 330 33 upon upon IN 40436 330 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 330 35 293 293 CD 40436 330 36 To to TO 40436 330 37 do do VB 40436 330 38 wrong wrong NN 40436 330 39 , , , 40436 330 40 overcome overcome VBN 40436 330 41 by by IN 40436 330 42 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 330 43 , , , 40436 330 44 is be VBZ 40436 330 45 only only RB 40436 330 46 a a DT 40436 330 47 bad bad JJ 40436 330 48 phrase phrase NN 40436 330 49 for for IN 40436 330 50 describing describe VBG 40436 330 51 what what WP 40436 330 52 is be VBZ 40436 330 53 really really RB 40436 330 54 a a DT 40436 330 55 case case NN 40436 330 56 of of IN 40436 330 57 grave grave JJ 40436 330 58 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 330 59 294 294 CD 40436 330 60 Reasoning Reasoning NNP 40436 330 61 of of IN 40436 330 62 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 330 63 assented assent VBD 40436 330 64 to to IN 40436 330 65 by by RB 40436 330 66 all all DT 40436 330 67 . . . 40436 331 1 Actions action NNS 40436 331 2 which which WDT 40436 331 3 conduct conduct VBP 40436 331 4 to to IN 40436 331 5 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 331 6 or or CC 40436 331 7 freedom freedom NN 40436 331 8 from from IN 40436 331 9 pain pain NN 40436 331 10 , , , 40436 331 11 are be VBP 40436 331 12 honourable honourable JJ 40436 331 13 295 295 CD 40436 331 14 Explanation Explanation NNP 40436 331 15 of of IN 40436 331 16 courage courage NN 40436 331 17 . . . 40436 332 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 332 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 332 3 in in IN 40436 332 4 a a DT 40436 332 5 wise wise JJ 40436 332 6 estimate estimate NN 40436 332 7 of of IN 40436 332 8 things thing NNS 40436 332 9 terrible terrible JJ 40436 332 10 and and CC 40436 332 11 not not RB 40436 332 12 terrible terrible JJ 40436 332 13 _ _ NNP 40436 332 14 ib ib UH 40436 332 15 . . . 40436 332 16 _ _ NNP 40436 332 17 Reluctance Reluctance NNP 40436 332 18 of of IN 40436 332 19 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 332 20 to to TO 40436 332 21 continue continue VB 40436 332 22 answering answer VBG 40436 332 23 . . . 40436 333 1 Close close NN 40436 333 2 of of IN 40436 333 3 the the DT 40436 333 4 discussion discussion NN 40436 333 5 . . . 40436 334 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 334 2 declares declare VBZ 40436 334 3 that that IN 40436 334 4 the the DT 40436 334 5 subject subject NN 40436 334 6 is be VBZ 40436 334 7 still still RB 40436 334 8 in in IN 40436 334 9 confusion confusion NN 40436 334 10 , , , 40436 334 11 and and CC 40436 334 12 that that IN 40436 334 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 334 14 wishes wish VBZ 40436 334 15 to to TO 40436 334 16 debate debate VB 40436 334 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 334 18 again again RB 40436 334 19 with with IN 40436 334 20 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 334 21 . . . 40436 335 1 Amicable amicable JJ 40436 335 2 reply reply NN 40436 335 3 of of IN 40436 335 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 335 5 297 297 CD 40436 335 6 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 335 7 on on IN 40436 335 8 the the DT 40436 335 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 335 10 . . . 40436 336 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 336 2 closes close VBZ 40436 336 3 without without IN 40436 336 4 the the DT 40436 336 5 least least JJS 40436 336 6 allusion allusion NN 40436 336 7 to to IN 40436 336 8 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNP 40436 336 9 298 298 CD 40436 336 10 Two two CD 40436 336 11 distinct distinct JJ 40436 336 12 aspects aspect NNS 40436 336 13 of of IN 40436 336 14 ethics ethic NNS 40436 336 15 and and CC 40436 336 16 politics politic NNS 40436 336 17 exhibited exhibit VBD 40436 336 18 : : : 40436 336 19 one one CD 40436 336 20 under under IN 40436 336 21 the the DT 40436 336 22 name name NN 40436 336 23 of of IN 40436 336 24 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 336 25 ; ; : 40436 336 26 the the DT 40436 336 27 other other JJ 40436 336 28 , , , 40436 336 29 under under IN 40436 336 30 that that DT 40436 336 31 of of IN 40436 336 32 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 336 33 299 299 CD 40436 336 34 Order order NN 40436 336 35 of of IN 40436 336 36 ethical ethical JJ 40436 336 37 problems problem NNS 40436 336 38 , , , 40436 336 39 as as IN 40436 336 40 conceived conceive VBN 40436 336 41 by by IN 40436 336 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 336 43 _ _ NNP 40436 336 44 ib ib NN 40436 336 45 . . . 40436 336 46 _ _ NNP 40436 336 47 Difference Difference NNP 40436 336 48 of of IN 40436 336 49 method method NN 40436 336 50 between between IN 40436 336 51 him -PRON- PRP 40436 336 52 and and CC 40436 336 53 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 336 54 flows flow VBZ 40436 336 55 from from IN 40436 336 56 this this DT 40436 336 57 difference difference NN 40436 336 58 of of IN 40436 336 59 order order NN 40436 336 60 . . . 40436 337 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 337 2 assumes assume VBZ 40436 337 3 what what WP 40436 337 4 virtue virtue NN 40436 337 5 is be VBZ 40436 337 6 , , , 40436 337 7 without without IN 40436 337 8 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 337 9 300 300 CD 40436 337 10 Method Method NNP 40436 337 11 of of IN 40436 337 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 337 13 . . . 40436 338 1 Continuous continuous JJ 40436 338 2 lectures lecture NNS 40436 338 3 addressed address VBD 40436 338 4 to to IN 40436 338 5 established establish VBN 40436 338 6 public public JJ 40436 338 7 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 338 8 with with IN 40436 338 9 which which WDT 40436 338 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 338 11 is be VBZ 40436 338 12 in in IN 40436 338 13 harmony harmony NN 40436 338 14 301 301 CD 40436 338 15 Method Method NNP 40436 338 16 of of IN 40436 338 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 338 18 . . . 40436 339 1 Dwells dwell NNS 40436 339 2 upon upon IN 40436 339 3 that that DT 40436 339 4 part part NN 40436 339 5 of of IN 40436 339 6 the the DT 40436 339 7 problem problem NN 40436 339 8 which which WDT 40436 339 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 339 10 had have VBD 40436 339 11 left leave VBN 40436 339 12 out out RP 40436 339 13 _ _ NNP 40436 339 14 ib ib UH 40436 339 15 . . . 40436 339 16 _ _ NNP 40436 339 17 Antithesis Antithesis NNP 40436 339 18 between between IN 40436 339 19 the the DT 40436 339 20 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 339 21 lecturer lecturer NN 40436 339 22 and and CC 40436 339 23 the the DT 40436 339 24 analytical analytical JJ 40436 339 25 cross cross JJ 40436 339 26 - - NN 40436 339 27 examiner examiner NN 40436 339 28 303 303 CD 40436 339 29 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 339 30 not not RB 40436 339 31 intended intend VBD 40436 339 32 to to TO 40436 339 33 be be VB 40436 339 34 always always RB 40436 339 35 in in IN 40436 339 36 the the DT 40436 339 37 wrong wrong NN 40436 339 38 , , , 40436 339 39 though though IN 40436 339 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 339 41 is be VBZ 40436 339 42 described describe VBN 40436 339 43 as as IN 40436 339 44 brought bring VBN 40436 339 45 to to IN 40436 339 46 a a DT 40436 339 47 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 339 48 _ _ NNP 40436 339 49 ib ib UH 40436 339 50 . . . 40436 339 51 _ _ NNP 40436 339 52 Affirmation Affirmation NNP 40436 339 53 of of IN 40436 339 54 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 339 55 about about IN 40436 339 56 courage courage NN 40436 339 57 is be VBZ 40436 339 58 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 339 59 by by IN 40436 339 60 Plato Plato NNP 40436 339 61 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 339 62 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 339 63 _ _ NNP 40436 339 64 ib ib UH 40436 339 65 . . . 40436 339 66 _ _ NNP 40436 339 67 The the DT 40436 339 68 harsh harsh JJ 40436 339 69 epithets epithet NNS 40436 339 70 applied apply VBN 40436 339 71 by by IN 40436 339 72 critics critic NNS 40436 339 73 to to IN 40436 339 74 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 339 75 are be VBP 40436 339 76 not not RB 40436 339 77 borne bear VBN 40436 339 78 out out RP 40436 339 79 by by IN 40436 339 80 the the DT 40436 339 81 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 339 82 . . . 40436 340 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 340 2 stands stand VBZ 40436 340 3 on on IN 40436 340 4 the the DT 40436 340 5 same same JJ 40436 340 6 ground ground NN 40436 340 7 as as IN 40436 340 8 the the DT 40436 340 9 common common JJ 40436 340 10 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 340 11 304 304 CD 40436 340 12 Aversion aversion NN 40436 340 13 of of IN 40436 340 14 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 340 15 for for IN 40436 340 16 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 340 17 . . . 40436 341 1 Interlude interlude NN 40436 341 2 about about IN 40436 341 3 the the DT 40436 341 4 song song NN 40436 341 5 of of IN 40436 341 6 Simonides Simonides NNP 40436 341 7 305 305 CD 40436 341 8 Ethical ethical JJ 40436 341 9 view view NN 40436 341 10 given give VBN 40436 341 11 by by IN 40436 341 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 341 13 worked work VBD 40436 341 14 out out RP 40436 341 15 at at IN 40436 341 16 length length NN 40436 341 17 clearly clearly RB 40436 341 18 . . . 40436 342 1 Good good JJ 40436 342 2 and and CC 40436 342 3 evil evil NN 40436 342 4 consist consist VBP 40436 342 5 in in IN 40436 342 6 right right NN 40436 342 7 or or CC 40436 342 8 wrong wrong JJ 40436 342 9 calculation calculation NN 40436 342 10 of of IN 40436 342 11 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 342 12 and and CC 40436 342 13 pains pain NNS 40436 342 14 of of IN 40436 342 15 the the DT 40436 342 16 agent agent NN 40436 342 17 _ _ NNP 40436 342 18 ib ib UH 40436 342 19 . . . 40436 342 20 _ _ NNP 40436 342 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 342 22 is be VBZ 40436 342 23 at at IN 40436 342 24 first first RB 40436 342 25 opposed oppose VBN 40436 342 26 to to IN 40436 342 27 this this DT 40436 342 28 theory theory NN 40436 342 29 306 306 CD 40436 342 30 Reasoning reasoning NN 40436 342 31 of of IN 40436 342 32 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 342 33 307 307 CD 40436 342 34 Application application NN 40436 342 35 of of IN 40436 342 36 that that DT 40436 342 37 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 342 38 to to IN 40436 342 39 the the DT 40436 342 40 case case NN 40436 342 41 of of IN 40436 342 42 courage courage NN 40436 342 43 _ _ NNP 40436 342 44 ib ib UH 40436 342 45 . . . 40436 342 46 _ _ NNP 40436 342 47 The the DT 40436 342 48 theory theory NN 40436 342 49 which which WDT 40436 342 50 Plato Plato NNP 40436 342 51 here here RB 40436 342 52 lays lay VBZ 40436 342 53 down down RB 40436 342 54 is be VBZ 40436 342 55 more more RBR 40436 342 56 distinct distinct JJ 40436 342 57 and and CC 40436 342 58 specific specific JJ 40436 342 59 than than IN 40436 342 60 any any DT 40436 342 61 theory theory NN 40436 342 62 laid lay VBN 40436 342 63 down down RP 40436 342 64 in in IN 40436 342 65 other other JJ 40436 342 66 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 342 67 308 308 CD 40436 342 68 Remarks Remarks NNPS 40436 342 69 on on IN 40436 342 70 the the DT 40436 342 71 theory theory NN 40436 342 72 here here RB 40436 342 73 laid lay VBN 40436 342 74 down down RP 40436 342 75 by by IN 40436 342 76 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 342 77 . . . 40436 343 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 343 2 is be VBZ 40436 343 3 too too RB 40436 343 4 narrow narrow JJ 40436 343 5 , , , 40436 343 6 and and CC 40436 343 7 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 343 8 prudential prudential JJ 40436 343 9 309 309 CD 40436 343 10 Comparison comparison NN 40436 343 11 with with IN 40436 343 12 the the DT 40436 343 13 Republic Republic NNP 40436 343 14 310 310 CD 40436 343 15 The the DT 40436 343 16 discourse discourse NN 40436 343 17 of of IN 40436 343 18 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 343 19 brings bring VBZ 40436 343 20 out out RP 40436 343 21 an an DT 40436 343 22 important important JJ 40436 343 23 part part NN 40436 343 24 of of IN 40436 343 25 the the DT 40436 343 26 whole whole JJ 40436 343 27 case case NN 40436 343 28 , , , 40436 343 29 which which WDT 40436 343 30 is be VBZ 40436 343 31 omitted omit VBN 40436 343 32 in in IN 40436 343 33 the the DT 40436 343 34 analysis analysis NN 40436 343 35 by by IN 40436 343 36 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 343 37 311 311 CD 40436 343 38 The the DT 40436 343 39 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 343 40 End End NNP 40436 343 41 , , , 40436 343 42 as as IN 40436 343 43 implied imply VBN 40436 343 44 in in IN 40436 343 45 the the DT 40436 343 46 discourse discourse NN 40436 343 47 of of IN 40436 343 48 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 343 49 , , , 40436 343 50 involves involve VBZ 40436 343 51 a a DT 40436 343 52 direct direct JJ 40436 343 53 regard regard NN 40436 343 54 to to IN 40436 343 55 the the DT 40436 343 56 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 343 57 and and CC 40436 343 58 pains pain NNS 40436 343 59 of of IN 40436 343 60 other other JJ 40436 343 61 persons person NNS 40436 343 62 besides besides IN 40436 343 63 the the DT 40436 343 64 agent agent NN 40436 343 65 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 343 66 312 312 CD 40436 343 67 Plato Plato NNP 40436 343 68 's 's POS 40436 343 69 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 343 70 in in IN 40436 343 71 the the DT 40436 343 72 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 343 73 is be VBZ 40436 343 74 not not RB 40436 343 75 clear clear JJ 40436 343 76 or or CC 40436 343 77 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 343 78 , , , 40436 343 79 especially especially RB 40436 343 80 about about IN 40436 343 81 courage courage NN 40436 343 82 313 313 CD 40436 343 83 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 40436 343 84 of of IN 40436 343 85 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 343 86 and and CC 40436 343 87 other other JJ 40436 343 88 critics critic NNS 40436 343 89 is be VBZ 40436 343 90 not not RB 40436 343 91 correct correct JJ 40436 343 92 . . . 40436 344 1 That that IN 40436 344 2 the the DT 40436 344 3 analysis analysis NN 40436 344 4 here here RB 40436 344 5 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 344 6 to to IN 40436 344 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 344 8 is be VBZ 40436 344 9 not not RB 40436 344 10 intended intend VBN 40436 344 11 by by IN 40436 344 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 344 13 as as IN 40436 344 14 serious serious JJ 40436 344 15 , , , 40436 344 16 but but CC 40436 344 17 as as IN 40436 344 18 a a DT 40436 344 19 mockery mockery NN 40436 344 20 of of IN 40436 344 21 the the DT 40436 344 22 sophists sophist NNS 40436 344 23 314 314 CD 40436 344 24 Grounds Grounds NNPS 40436 344 25 of of IN 40436 344 26 that that DT 40436 344 27 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 344 28 . . . 40436 345 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 345 2 insufficiency insufficiency NN 40436 345 3 315 315 CD 40436 345 4 Subject Subject NNP 40436 345 5 is be VBZ 40436 345 6 professedly professedly RB 40436 345 7 still still RB 40436 345 8 left leave VBN 40436 345 9 unsettled unsettle VBN 40436 345 10 at at IN 40436 345 11 the the DT 40436 345 12 close close NN 40436 345 13 of of IN 40436 345 14 the the DT 40436 345 15 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 345 16 316 316 CD 40436 345 17 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 345 18 XXIV XXIV NNP 40436 345 19 . . . 40436 346 1 GORGIAS GORGIAS NNP 40436 346 2 . . . 40436 347 1 Persons person NNS 40436 347 2 who who WP 40436 347 3 debate debate VBP 40436 347 4 in in IN 40436 347 5 the the DT 40436 347 6 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 347 7 . . . 40436 348 1 Celebrity celebrity NN 40436 348 2 of of IN 40436 348 3 the the DT 40436 348 4 historical historical JJ 40436 348 5 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 348 6 317 317 CD 40436 348 7 Introductory introductory JJ 40436 348 8 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 348 9 of of IN 40436 348 10 the the DT 40436 348 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 348 12 . . . 40436 349 1 Polus polus JJ 40436 349 2 and and CC 40436 349 3 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 349 4 318 318 CD 40436 349 5 Purpose Purpose NNP 40436 349 6 of of IN 40436 349 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 349 8 in in IN 40436 349 9 questioning questioning NN 40436 349 10 . . . 40436 350 1 Conditions condition NNS 40436 350 2 of of IN 40436 350 3 a a DT 40436 350 4 good good JJ 40436 350 5 definition definition NN 40436 350 6 _ _ NNP 40436 350 7 ib ib NN 40436 350 8 . . . 40436 350 9 _ _ NNP 40436 350 10 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 350 11 about about IN 40436 350 12 the the DT 40436 350 13 definition definition NN 40436 350 14 of of IN 40436 350 15 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 350 16 . . . 40436 351 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 351 2 is be VBZ 40436 351 3 the the DT 40436 351 4 artisan artisan NNP 40436 351 5 of of IN 40436 351 6 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 351 7 319 319 CD 40436 351 8 The the DT 40436 351 9 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 351 10 produces produce VBZ 40436 351 11 belief belief NN 40436 351 12 without without IN 40436 351 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 351 14 . . . 40436 352 1 Upon upon IN 40436 352 2 what what WP 40436 352 3 matters matter NNS 40436 352 4 is be VBZ 40436 352 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 352 6 competent competent JJ 40436 352 7 to to TO 40436 352 8 advise advise VB 40436 352 9 ? ? . 40436 353 1 319 319 CD 40436 353 2 The the DT 40436 353 3 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 353 4 can can MD 40436 353 5 persuade persuade VB 40436 353 6 the the DT 40436 353 7 people people NNS 40436 353 8 upon upon IN 40436 353 9 any any DT 40436 353 10 matter matter NN 40436 353 11 , , , 40436 353 12 even even RB 40436 353 13 against against IN 40436 353 14 the the DT 40436 353 15 opinion opinion NN 40436 353 16 of of IN 40436 353 17 the the DT 40436 353 18 special special JJ 40436 353 19 expert expert NN 40436 353 20 . . . 40436 354 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 354 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 354 3 to to TO 40436 354 4 know know VB 40436 354 5 , , , 40436 354 6 among among IN 40436 354 7 the the DT 40436 354 8 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 354 9 320 320 CD 40436 354 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 354 11 is be VBZ 40436 354 12 now now RB 40436 354 13 made make VBN 40436 354 14 to to TO 40436 354 15 contradict contradict VB 40436 354 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 354 17 . . . 40436 355 1 Polus polus NN 40436 355 2 takes take VBZ 40436 355 3 up up RP 40436 355 4 the the DT 40436 355 5 debate debate NN 40436 355 6 with with IN 40436 355 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 355 8 321 321 CD 40436 355 9 Polemical polemical JJ 40436 355 10 tone tone NN 40436 355 11 of of IN 40436 355 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 355 13 . . . 40436 356 1 At at IN 40436 356 2 the the DT 40436 356 3 instance instance NN 40436 356 4 of of IN 40436 356 5 Polus Polus NNP 40436 356 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 356 7 gives give VBZ 40436 356 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 356 9 own own JJ 40436 356 10 definition definition NN 40436 356 11 of of IN 40436 356 12 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 356 13 . . . 40436 357 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 357 2 is be VBZ 40436 357 3 no no DT 40436 357 4 art art NN 40436 357 5 , , , 40436 357 6 but but CC 40436 357 7 an an DT 40436 357 8 empirical empirical JJ 40436 357 9 knack knack NN 40436 357 10 of of IN 40436 357 11 catering catering NN 40436 357 12 for for IN 40436 357 13 the the DT 40436 357 14 immediate immediate JJ 40436 357 15 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 357 16 of of IN 40436 357 17 hearers hearer NNS 40436 357 18 , , , 40436 357 19 analogous analogous JJ 40436 357 20 to to IN 40436 357 21 cookery cookery NN 40436 357 22 . . . 40436 358 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 358 2 is be VBZ 40436 358 3 a a DT 40436 358 4 branch branch NN 40436 358 5 under under IN 40436 358 6 the the DT 40436 358 7 general general JJ 40436 358 8 head head NN 40436 358 9 flattery flattery RB 40436 358 10 _ _ NNP 40436 358 11 ib ib UH 40436 358 12 . . . 40436 358 13 _ _ NNP 40436 358 14 Distinction Distinction NNP 40436 358 15 between between IN 40436 358 16 the the DT 40436 358 17 true true JJ 40436 358 18 arts art NNS 40436 358 19 which which WDT 40436 358 20 aim aim VBP 40436 358 21 at at IN 40436 358 22 the the DT 40436 358 23 good good NN 40436 358 24 of of IN 40436 358 25 the the DT 40436 358 26 body body NN 40436 358 27 and and CC 40436 358 28 mind mind NN 40436 358 29 -- -- : 40436 358 30 and and CC 40436 358 31 the the DT 40436 358 32 counterfeit counterfeit JJ 40436 358 33 arts art NNS 40436 358 34 , , , 40436 358 35 which which WDT 40436 358 36 pretend pretend VBP 40436 358 37 to to IN 40436 358 38 the the DT 40436 358 39 same same JJ 40436 358 40 , , , 40436 358 41 but but CC 40436 358 42 in in IN 40436 358 43 reality reality NN 40436 358 44 aim aim NN 40436 358 45 at at IN 40436 358 46 immediate immediate JJ 40436 358 47 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 358 48 322 322 CD 40436 358 49 Questions Questions NNPS 40436 358 50 of of IN 40436 358 51 Polus Polus NNP 40436 358 52 . . . 40436 359 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 359 2 denies deny VBZ 40436 359 3 that that IN 40436 359 4 the the DT 40436 359 5 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 359 6 have have VBP 40436 359 7 any any DT 40436 359 8 real real JJ 40436 359 9 power power NN 40436 359 10 , , , 40436 359 11 because because IN 40436 359 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 359 13 do do VBP 40436 359 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 359 15 which which WDT 40436 359 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 359 17 really really RB 40436 359 18 wish wish VBP 40436 359 19 323 323 CD 40436 359 20 All all DT 40436 359 21 men man NNS 40436 359 22 wish wish VBP 40436 359 23 for for IN 40436 359 24 what what WP 40436 359 25 is be VBZ 40436 359 26 good good JJ 40436 359 27 for for IN 40436 359 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 359 29 . . . 40436 360 1 Despots despot NNS 40436 360 2 and and CC 40436 360 3 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 360 4 , , , 40436 360 5 when when WRB 40436 360 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 360 7 kill kill VBP 40436 360 8 any any DT 40436 360 9 one one NN 40436 360 10 , , , 40436 360 11 do do VB 40436 360 12 so so RB 40436 360 13 because because IN 40436 360 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 360 15 think think VBP 40436 360 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 360 17 good good JJ 40436 360 18 for for IN 40436 360 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 360 20 . . . 40436 361 1 If if IN 40436 361 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 361 3 be be VB 40436 361 4 really really RB 40436 361 5 not not RB 40436 361 6 good good JJ 40436 361 7 , , , 40436 361 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 361 9 do do VBP 40436 361 10 not not RB 40436 361 11 do do VB 40436 361 12 what what WP 40436 361 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 361 14 will will MD 40436 361 15 , , , 40436 361 16 and and CC 40436 361 17 therefore therefore RB 40436 361 18 have have VB 40436 361 19 no no DT 40436 361 20 real real JJ 40436 361 21 power power NN 40436 361 22 324 324 CD 40436 361 23 Comparison Comparison NNP 40436 361 24 of of IN 40436 361 25 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 361 26 , , , 40436 361 27 usurping usurping NN 40436 361 28 despot despot NN 40436 361 29 of of IN 40436 361 30 Macedonia Macedonia NNP 40436 361 31 -- -- : 40436 361 32 Polus polus JJ 40436 361 33 affirms affirm NNS 40436 361 34 that that IN 40436 361 35 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 361 36 is be VBZ 40436 361 37 happy happy JJ 40436 361 38 , , , 40436 361 39 and and CC 40436 361 40 that that IN 40436 361 41 every every DT 40436 361 42 one one NN 40436 361 43 thinks think VBZ 40436 361 44 so so RB 40436 361 45 -- -- : 40436 361 46 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 361 47 admits admit VBZ 40436 361 48 that that IN 40436 361 49 every every DT 40436 361 50 one one NN 40436 361 51 thinks think VBZ 40436 361 52 so so RB 40436 361 53 , , , 40436 361 54 but but CC 40436 361 55 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 361 56 denies deny VBZ 40436 361 57 it -PRON- PRP 40436 361 58 325 325 CD 40436 361 59 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 361 60 maintains--1 maintains--1 NNP 40436 361 61 . . . 40436 362 1 That that IN 40436 362 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 362 3 is be VBZ 40436 362 4 a a DT 40436 362 5 greater great JJR 40436 362 6 evil evil NN 40436 362 7 to to TO 40436 362 8 do do VB 40436 362 9 wrong wrong NN 40436 362 10 , , , 40436 362 11 than than IN 40436 362 12 to to TO 40436 362 13 suffer suffer VB 40436 362 14 wrong wrong JJ 40436 362 15 . . . 40436 363 1 2 2 LS 40436 363 2 . . . 40436 364 1 That that IN 40436 364 2 if if IN 40436 364 3 a a DT 40436 364 4 man man NN 40436 364 5 has have VBZ 40436 364 6 done do VBN 40436 364 7 wrong wrong NN 40436 364 8 , , , 40436 364 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 364 10 is be VBZ 40436 364 11 better well JJR 40436 364 12 for for IN 40436 364 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 364 14 to to TO 40436 364 15 be be VB 40436 364 16 punished punish VBN 40436 364 17 than than IN 40436 364 18 to to TO 40436 364 19 remain remain VB 40436 364 20 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 364 21 326 326 CD 40436 364 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 364 23 offers offer VBZ 40436 364 24 proof proof NN 40436 364 25 -- -- : 40436 364 26 Definition Definition NNP 40436 364 27 of of IN 40436 364 28 Pulchrum Pulchrum NNP 40436 364 29 and and CC 40436 364 30 Turpe Turpe NNP 40436 364 31 -- -- : 40436 364 32 Proof Proof NNP 40436 364 33 of of IN 40436 364 34 the the DT 40436 364 35 first first JJ 40436 364 36 point point NN 40436 364 37 327 327 CD 40436 364 38 Proof proof NN 40436 364 39 of of IN 40436 364 40 the the DT 40436 364 41 second second JJ 40436 364 42 point point NN 40436 364 43 _ _ NNP 40436 364 44 ib ib UH 40436 364 45 . . . 40436 364 46 _ _ NNP 40436 364 47 The the DT 40436 364 48 criminal criminal JJ 40436 364 49 labours labour VBZ 40436 364 50 under under IN 40436 364 51 a a DT 40436 364 52 mental mental JJ 40436 364 53 distemper distemper NN 40436 364 54 , , , 40436 364 55 which which WDT 40436 364 56 though though IN 40436 364 57 not not RB 40436 364 58 painful painful JJ 40436 364 59 , , , 40436 364 60 is be VBZ 40436 364 61 a a DT 40436 364 62 capital capital NN 40436 364 63 evil evil NN 40436 364 64 . . . 40436 365 1 Punishment punishment NN 40436 365 2 is be VBZ 40436 365 3 the the DT 40436 365 4 only only JJ 40436 365 5 cure cure NN 40436 365 6 for for IN 40436 365 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 365 8 . . . 40436 366 1 To to TO 40436 366 2 be be VB 40436 366 3 punished punish VBN 40436 366 4 is be VBZ 40436 366 5 best good JJS 40436 366 6 for for IN 40436 366 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 366 8 328 328 CD 40436 366 9 Misery misery NN 40436 366 10 of of IN 40436 366 11 the the DT 40436 366 12 Despot Despot NNP 40436 366 13 who who WP 40436 366 14 is be VBZ 40436 366 15 never never RB 40436 366 16 punished punish VBN 40436 366 17 . . . 40436 367 1 If if IN 40436 367 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 367 3 friend friend NN 40436 367 4 has have VBZ 40436 367 5 done do VBN 40436 367 6 wrong wrong NN 40436 367 7 , , , 40436 367 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 367 9 ought ought MD 40436 367 10 to to TO 40436 367 11 get get VB 40436 367 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 367 13 punished punish VBN 40436 367 14 : : : 40436 367 15 if if IN 40436 367 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 367 17 enemy enemy NN 40436 367 18 , , , 40436 367 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 367 20 ought ought MD 40436 367 21 to to TO 40436 367 22 keep keep VB 40436 367 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 367 24 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 367 25 329 329 CD 40436 367 26 Argument Argument NNP 40436 367 27 of of IN 40436 367 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 367 29 paradoxical paradoxical JJ 40436 367 30 -- -- : 40436 367 31 Doubt Doubt NNP 40436 367 32 expressed express VBN 40436 367 33 by by IN 40436 367 34 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 367 35 whether whether IN 40436 367 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 367 37 means mean VBZ 40436 367 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 367 39 seriously seriously RB 40436 367 40 330 330 CD 40436 367 41 Principle principle NN 40436 367 42 laid lay VBD 40436 367 43 down down RP 40436 367 44 by by IN 40436 367 45 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 367 46 -- -- : 40436 367 47 That that IN 40436 367 48 every every DT 40436 367 49 one one CD 40436 367 50 acts act VBZ 40436 367 51 with with IN 40436 367 52 a a DT 40436 367 53 view view NN 40436 367 54 to to IN 40436 367 55 the the DT 40436 367 56 attainment attainment NN 40436 367 57 of of IN 40436 367 58 happiness happiness NN 40436 367 59 and and CC 40436 367 60 avoidance avoidance NN 40436 367 61 of of IN 40436 367 62 misery misery NN 40436 367 63 _ _ NNP 40436 367 64 ib ib UH 40436 367 65 . . . 40436 367 66 _ _ NNP 40436 367 67 Peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 367 68 view view NN 40436 367 69 taken take VBN 40436 367 70 by by IN 40436 367 71 Plato Plato NNP 40436 367 72 of of IN 40436 367 73 Good good JJ 40436 367 74 -- -- : 40436 367 75 Evil evil JJ 40436 367 76 -- -- : 40436 367 77 Happiness happiness NN 40436 367 78 331 331 CD 40436 367 79 Contrast contrast NN 40436 367 80 of of IN 40436 367 81 the the DT 40436 367 82 usual usual JJ 40436 367 83 meaning meaning NN 40436 367 84 of of IN 40436 367 85 these these DT 40436 367 86 words word NNS 40436 367 87 , , , 40436 367 88 with with IN 40436 367 89 the the DT 40436 367 90 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 367 91 meaning meaning NN 40436 367 92 _ _ NNP 40436 367 93 ib ib UH 40436 367 94 . . . 40436 367 95 _ _ NNP 40436 367 96 Examination Examination NNP 40436 367 97 of of IN 40436 367 98 the the DT 40436 367 99 proof proof NN 40436 367 100 given give VBN 40436 367 101 by by IN 40436 367 102 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 367 103 -- -- : 40436 367 104 Inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 367 105 between between IN 40436 367 106 the the DT 40436 367 107 general general JJ 40436 367 108 answer answer NN 40436 367 109 of of IN 40436 367 110 Polus Polus NNP 40436 367 111 and and CC 40436 367 112 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 367 113 previous previous JJ 40436 367 114 declarations declaration NNS 40436 367 115 -- -- : 40436 367 116 Law Law NNP 40436 367 117 and and CC 40436 367 118 Nature Nature NNP 40436 367 119 332 332 CD 40436 367 120 The the DT 40436 367 121 definition definition NN 40436 367 122 of of IN 40436 367 123 Pulchrum Pulchrum NNP 40436 367 124 and and CC 40436 367 125 Turpe Turpe NNP 40436 367 126 , , , 40436 367 127 given give VBN 40436 367 128 by by IN 40436 367 129 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 367 130 , , , 40436 367 131 will will MD 40436 367 132 not not RB 40436 367 133 hold hold VB 40436 367 134 334 334 CD 40436 367 135 Worse bad JJR 40436 367 136 or or CC 40436 367 137 better well JJR 40436 367 138 -- -- : 40436 367 139 for for IN 40436 367 140 whom whom WP 40436 367 141 ? ? . 40436 368 1 The the DT 40436 368 2 argument argument NN 40436 368 3 of of IN 40436 368 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 368 5 does do VBZ 40436 368 6 not not RB 40436 368 7 specify specify VB 40436 368 8 . . . 40436 369 1 If if IN 40436 369 2 understood understand VBN 40436 369 3 in in IN 40436 369 4 the the DT 40436 369 5 sense sense NN 40436 369 6 necessary necessary JJ 40436 369 7 for for IN 40436 369 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 369 9 inference inference NN 40436 369 10 , , , 40436 369 11 the the DT 40436 369 12 definition definition NN 40436 369 13 would would MD 40436 369 14 be be VB 40436 369 15 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 369 16 _ _ NNP 40436 369 17 ib ib UH 40436 369 18 . . . 40436 369 19 _ _ NNP 40436 369 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 369 21 applies apply VBZ 40436 369 22 to to IN 40436 369 23 every every DT 40436 369 24 one one CD 40436 369 25 a a DT 40436 369 26 standard standard NN 40436 369 27 of of IN 40436 369 28 happiness happiness NN 40436 369 29 and and CC 40436 369 30 misery misery NN 40436 369 31 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 369 32 to to IN 40436 369 33 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 369 34 . . . 40436 370 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 370 2 view view NN 40436 370 3 about about IN 40436 370 4 the the DT 40436 370 5 conduct conduct NN 40436 370 6 of of IN 40436 370 7 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 370 8 is be VBZ 40436 370 9 just just RB 40436 370 10 , , , 40436 370 11 but but CC 40436 370 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 370 13 does do VBZ 40436 370 14 not not RB 40436 370 15 give give VB 40436 370 16 the the DT 40436 370 17 true true JJ 40436 370 18 reasons reason NNS 40436 370 19 for for IN 40436 370 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 370 21 335 335 CD 40436 370 22 If if IN 40436 370 23 the the DT 40436 370 24 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 370 25 of of IN 40436 370 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 370 27 were be VBD 40436 370 28 true true JJ 40436 370 29 , , , 40436 370 30 the the DT 40436 370 31 point point NN 40436 370 32 of of IN 40436 370 33 view view NN 40436 370 34 in in IN 40436 370 35 which which WDT 40436 370 36 punishment punishment NN 40436 370 37 is be VBZ 40436 370 38 considered consider VBN 40436 370 39 would would MD 40436 370 40 be be VB 40436 370 41 reversed reverse VBN 40436 370 42 336 336 CD 40436 370 43 Plato Plato NNP 40436 370 44 pushes push VBZ 40436 370 45 too too RB 40436 370 46 far far RB 40436 370 47 the the DT 40436 370 48 analogy analogy NN 40436 370 49 between between IN 40436 370 50 mental mental JJ 40436 370 51 distemper distemper NN 40436 370 52 and and CC 40436 370 53 bodily bodily JJ 40436 370 54 distemper distemper NN 40436 370 55 -- -- : 40436 370 56 Material material NN 40436 370 57 difference difference NN 40436 370 58 between between IN 40436 370 59 the the DT 40436 370 60 two two CD 40436 370 61 -- -- : 40436 370 62 Distemper Distemper NNP 40436 370 63 must must MD 40436 370 64 be be VB 40436 370 65 felt feel VBN 40436 370 66 by by IN 40436 370 67 the the DT 40436 370 68 distempered distemper VBN 40436 370 69 persons person NNS 40436 370 70 337 337 CD 40436 370 71 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 370 72 begins begin VBZ 40436 370 73 to to TO 40436 370 74 argue argue VB 40436 370 75 against against IN 40436 370 76 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 370 77 -- -- : 40436 370 78 he -PRON- PRP 40436 370 79 takes take VBZ 40436 370 80 a a DT 40436 370 81 distinction distinction NN 40436 370 82 between between IN 40436 370 83 Just just RB 40436 370 84 by by IN 40436 370 85 Law Law NNP 40436 370 86 and and CC 40436 370 87 Just just RB 40436 370 88 by by IN 40436 370 89 nature nature NN 40436 370 90 -- -- : 40436 370 91 Reply Reply NNP 40436 370 92 of of IN 40436 370 93 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 370 94 , , , 40436 370 95 that that IN 40436 370 96 there there EX 40436 370 97 is be VBZ 40436 370 98 no no DT 40436 370 99 variance variance NN 40436 370 100 between between IN 40436 370 101 the the DT 40436 370 102 two two CD 40436 370 103 , , , 40436 370 104 properly properly RB 40436 370 105 understood understand VBD 40436 370 106 338 338 CD 40436 370 107 What what WP 40436 370 108 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 370 109 says say VBZ 40436 370 110 is be VBZ 40436 370 111 not not RB 40436 370 112 to to TO 40436 370 113 be be VB 40436 370 114 taken take VBN 40436 370 115 as as IN 40436 370 116 a a DT 40436 370 117 sample sample NN 40436 370 118 of of IN 40436 370 119 the the DT 40436 370 120 teachings teaching NNS 40436 370 121 of of IN 40436 370 122 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 370 123 sophists sophist NNS 40436 370 124 . . . 40436 371 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 371 2 -- -- : 40436 371 3 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 371 4 and and CC 40436 371 5 politician politician NN 40436 371 6 339 339 CD 40436 371 7 Uncertainty Uncertainty NNP 40436 371 8 of of IN 40436 371 9 referring refer VBG 40436 371 10 to to IN 40436 371 11 Nature Nature NNP 40436 371 12 as as IN 40436 371 13 an an DT 40436 371 14 authority authority NN 40436 371 15 . . . 40436 372 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 372 2 may may MD 40436 372 3 be be VB 40436 372 4 pleaded plead VBN 40436 372 5 in in IN 40436 372 6 favour favour NN 40436 372 7 of of IN 40436 372 8 opposite opposite JJ 40436 372 9 theories theory NNS 40436 372 10 . . . 40436 373 1 The the DT 40436 373 2 theory theory NN 40436 373 3 of of IN 40436 373 4 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 373 5 is be VBZ 40436 373 6 made make VBN 40436 373 7 to to TO 40436 373 8 appear appear VB 40436 373 9 repulsive repulsive JJ 40436 373 10 by by IN 40436 373 11 the the DT 40436 373 12 language language NN 40436 373 13 in in IN 40436 373 14 which which WDT 40436 373 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 373 16 expresses express VBZ 40436 373 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 373 18 340 340 CD 40436 373 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 373 20 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 373 21 that that IN 40436 373 22 self self NN 40436 373 23 - - HYPH 40436 373 24 command command NN 40436 373 25 and and CC 40436 373 26 moderation moderation NN 40436 373 27 is be VBZ 40436 373 28 requisite requisite JJ 40436 373 29 for for IN 40436 373 30 the the DT 40436 373 31 strong strong JJ 40436 373 32 man man NN 40436 373 33 as as RB 40436 373 34 well well RB 40436 373 35 as as IN 40436 373 36 for for IN 40436 373 37 others other NNS 40436 373 38 . . . 40436 374 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 374 2 defends defend VBZ 40436 374 3 the the DT 40436 374 4 negative negative JJ 40436 374 5 343 343 CD 40436 374 6 Whether whether IN 40436 374 7 the the DT 40436 374 8 largest large JJS 40436 374 9 measure measure NN 40436 374 10 of of IN 40436 374 11 desires desire NNS 40436 374 12 is be VBZ 40436 374 13 good good JJ 40436 374 14 for for IN 40436 374 15 a a DT 40436 374 16 man man NN 40436 374 17 , , , 40436 374 18 provided provide VBN 40436 374 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 374 20 has have VBZ 40436 374 21 the the DT 40436 374 22 means mean NNS 40436 374 23 of of IN 40436 374 24 satisfying satisfy VBG 40436 374 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 374 26 ? ? . 40436 375 1 Whether whether IN 40436 375 2 all all DT 40436 375 3 varieties variety NNS 40436 375 4 of of IN 40436 375 5 desire desire NN 40436 375 6 are be VBP 40436 375 7 good good JJ 40436 375 8 ? ? . 40436 376 1 Whether whether IN 40436 376 2 the the DT 40436 376 3 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 376 4 and and CC 40436 376 5 the the DT 40436 376 6 good good JJ 40436 376 7 are be VBP 40436 376 8 identical identical JJ 40436 376 9 ? ? . 40436 377 1 344 344 CD 40436 377 2 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 377 3 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 377 4 that that DT 40436 377 5 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 377 6 and and CC 40436 377 7 good good JJ 40436 377 8 are be VBP 40436 377 9 identical identical JJ 40436 377 10 . . . 40436 378 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 378 2 refutes refute VBZ 40436 378 3 him -PRON- PRP 40436 378 4 . . . 40436 379 1 Some some DT 40436 379 2 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 379 3 are be VBP 40436 379 4 good good JJ 40436 379 5 , , , 40436 379 6 others other NNS 40436 379 7 bad bad JJ 40436 379 8 . . . 40436 380 1 A a DT 40436 380 2 scientific scientific JJ 40436 380 3 adviser adviser NN 40436 380 4 is be VBZ 40436 380 5 required require VBN 40436 380 6 to to TO 40436 380 7 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 380 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 380 9 345 345 CD 40436 380 10 Contradiction contradiction NN 40436 380 11 between between IN 40436 380 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 380 13 in in IN 40436 380 14 the the DT 40436 380 15 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 380 16 , , , 40436 380 17 and and CC 40436 380 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 380 19 in in IN 40436 380 20 the the DT 40436 380 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 380 22 _ _ NNP 40436 380 23 ib ib IN 40436 380 24 . . . 40436 380 25 _ _ NNP 40436 380 26 Views Views NNPS 40436 380 27 of of IN 40436 380 28 critics critic NNS 40436 380 29 about about IN 40436 380 30 this this DT 40436 380 31 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 380 32 346 346 CD 40436 380 33 Comparison comparison NN 40436 380 34 and and CC 40436 380 35 appreciation appreciation NN 40436 380 36 of of IN 40436 380 37 the the DT 40436 380 38 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 380 39 of of IN 40436 380 40 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 380 41 in in IN 40436 380 42 both both DT 40436 380 43 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 380 44 _ _ NNP 40436 380 45 ib ib NN 40436 380 46 . . . 40436 380 47 _ _ NNP 40436 380 48 Distinct distinct JJ 40436 380 49 statement statement NN 40436 380 50 in in IN 40436 380 51 the the DT 40436 380 52 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 380 53 . . . 40436 381 1 What what WP 40436 381 2 are be VBP 40436 381 3 good good JJ 40436 381 4 and and CC 40436 381 5 evil evil JJ 40436 381 6 , , , 40436 381 7 and and CC 40436 381 8 upon upon IN 40436 381 9 what what WP 40436 381 10 principles principle NNS 40436 381 11 the the DT 40436 381 12 scientific scientific JJ 40436 381 13 adviser adviser NN 40436 381 14 is be VBZ 40436 381 15 to to TO 40436 381 16 proceed proceed VB 40436 381 17 in in IN 40436 381 18 discriminating discriminate VBG 40436 381 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 381 20 . . . 40436 382 1 No no DT 40436 382 2 such such JJ 40436 382 3 distinct distinct JJ 40436 382 4 statement statement NN 40436 382 5 in in IN 40436 382 6 the the DT 40436 382 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 382 8 347 347 CD 40436 382 9 Modern modern JJ 40436 382 10 ethical ethical JJ 40436 382 11 theories theory NNS 40436 382 12 . . . 40436 383 1 Intuition intuition NN 40436 383 2 . . . 40436 384 1 Moral moral JJ 40436 384 2 sense sense NN 40436 384 3 -- -- : 40436 384 4 not not RB 40436 384 5 recognised recognise VBN 40436 384 6 by by IN 40436 384 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 384 8 in in IN 40436 384 9 either either DT 40436 384 10 of of IN 40436 384 11 the the DT 40436 384 12 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 384 13 348 348 CD 40436 384 14 In in IN 40436 384 15 both both DT 40436 384 16 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 384 17 the the DT 40436 384 18 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 384 19 of of IN 40436 384 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 384 21 is be VBZ 40436 384 22 self self NN 40436 384 23 - - HYPH 40436 384 24 regarding regard VBG 40436 384 25 as as IN 40436 384 26 respects respect VBZ 40436 384 27 the the DT 40436 384 28 agent agent NN 40436 384 29 : : : 40436 384 30 not not RB 40436 384 31 considering consider VBG 40436 384 32 the the DT 40436 384 33 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 384 34 and and CC 40436 384 35 pains pain NNS 40436 384 36 of of IN 40436 384 37 other other JJ 40436 384 38 persons person NNS 40436 384 39 , , , 40436 384 40 so so RB 40436 384 41 far far RB 40436 384 42 as as IN 40436 384 43 affected affect VBN 40436 384 44 by by IN 40436 384 45 the the DT 40436 384 46 agent agent NN 40436 384 47 349 349 CD 40436 384 48 Points Points NNPS 40436 384 49 wherein wherein WRB 40436 384 50 the the DT 40436 384 51 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 384 52 of of IN 40436 384 53 the the DT 40436 384 54 two two CD 40436 384 55 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 384 56 is be VBZ 40436 384 57 in in IN 40436 384 58 substance substance NN 40436 384 59 the the DT 40436 384 60 same same JJ 40436 384 61 , , , 40436 384 62 but but CC 40436 384 63 differing differ VBG 40436 384 64 in in IN 40436 384 65 classification classification NN 40436 384 66 _ _ NNP 40436 384 67 ib ib UH 40436 384 68 . . . 40436 384 69 _ _ NNP 40436 384 70 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 384 71 , , , 40436 384 72 whom whom WP 40436 384 73 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 384 74 refutes refute VBZ 40436 384 75 in in IN 40436 384 76 the the DT 40436 384 77 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 384 78 , , , 40436 384 79 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 384 80 a a DT 40436 384 81 different different JJ 40436 384 82 argument argument NN 40436 384 83 from from IN 40436 384 84 that that DT 40436 384 85 which which WDT 40436 384 86 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 384 87 combats combat VBZ 40436 384 88 in in IN 40436 384 89 the the DT 40436 384 90 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 384 91 350 350 CD 40436 384 92 The the DT 40436 384 93 refutation refutation NN 40436 384 94 of of IN 40436 384 95 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 384 96 by by IN 40436 384 97 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 384 98 in in IN 40436 384 99 the the DT 40436 384 100 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 384 101 , , , 40436 384 102 is be VBZ 40436 384 103 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 40436 384 104 -- -- : 40436 384 105 it -PRON- PRP 40436 384 106 is be VBZ 40436 384 107 only only RB 40436 384 108 so so RB 40436 384 109 far far RB 40436 384 110 successful successful JJ 40436 384 111 as as IN 40436 384 112 he -PRON- PRP 40436 384 113 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 384 114 unintentionally unintentionally RB 40436 384 115 the the DT 40436 384 116 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 384 117 of of IN 40436 384 118 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 384 119 in in IN 40436 384 120 the the DT 40436 384 121 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 384 122 351 351 CD 40436 384 123 Permanent permanent JJ 40436 384 124 elements element NNS 40436 384 125 -- -- : 40436 384 126 and and CC 40436 384 127 transient transient JJ 40436 384 128 elements element NNS 40436 384 129 -- -- : 40436 384 130 of of IN 40436 384 131 human human JJ 40436 384 132 agency agency NN 40436 384 133 -- -- : 40436 384 134 how how WRB 40436 384 135 each each DT 40436 384 136 of of IN 40436 384 137 them -PRON- PRP 40436 384 138 is be VBZ 40436 384 139 appreciated appreciate VBN 40436 384 140 in in IN 40436 384 141 the the DT 40436 384 142 two two CD 40436 384 143 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 384 144 353 353 CD 40436 384 145 In in IN 40436 384 146 the the DT 40436 384 147 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 384 148 _ _ NNP 40436 384 149 ib ib UH 40436 384 150 . . . 40436 384 151 _ _ NNP 40436 384 152 In in IN 40436 384 153 the the DT 40436 384 154 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 384 155 354 354 CD 40436 384 156 Character Character NNP 40436 384 157 of of IN 40436 384 158 the the DT 40436 384 159 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 384 160 generally generally RB 40436 384 161 -- -- : 40436 384 162 discrediting discredit VBG 40436 384 163 all all PDT 40436 384 164 the the DT 40436 384 165 actualities actuality NNS 40436 384 166 of of IN 40436 384 167 life life NN 40436 384 168 355 355 CD 40436 384 169 Argument Argument NNP 40436 384 170 of of IN 40436 384 171 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 384 172 resumed resume VBD 40436 384 173 -- -- : 40436 384 174 multifarious multifarious JJ 40436 384 175 arts art NNS 40436 384 176 of of IN 40436 384 177 flattery flattery NN 40436 384 178 , , , 40436 384 179 aiming aim VBG 40436 384 180 at at IN 40436 384 181 immediate immediate JJ 40436 384 182 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 384 183 357 357 CD 40436 384 184 The the DT 40436 384 185 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 384 186 aim aim VBP 40436 384 187 at at IN 40436 384 188 only only RB 40436 384 189 flattering flatter VBG 40436 384 190 the the DT 40436 384 191 public public NN 40436 384 192 -- -- : 40436 384 193 even even RB 40436 384 194 the the DT 40436 384 195 best good JJS 40436 384 196 past past JJ 40436 384 197 Rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 384 198 have have VBP 40436 384 199 done do VBN 40436 384 200 nothing nothing NN 40436 384 201 else else RB 40436 384 202 -- -- : 40436 384 203 citation citation NN 40436 384 204 of of IN 40436 384 205 the the DT 40436 384 206 four four CD 40436 384 207 great great JJ 40436 384 208 Rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 384 209 by by IN 40436 384 210 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 384 211 357 357 CD 40436 384 212 Necessity necessity NN 40436 384 213 for for IN 40436 384 214 temperance temperance NN 40436 384 215 , , , 40436 384 216 regulation regulation NN 40436 384 217 , , , 40436 384 218 order order NN 40436 384 219 . . . 40436 385 1 This this DT 40436 385 2 is be VBZ 40436 385 3 the the DT 40436 385 4 condition condition NN 40436 385 5 of of IN 40436 385 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 385 7 and and CC 40436 385 8 happiness happiness NN 40436 385 9 358 358 CD 40436 385 10 Impossible impossible JJ 40436 385 11 to to TO 40436 385 12 succeed succeed VB 40436 385 13 in in IN 40436 385 14 public public JJ 40436 385 15 life life NN 40436 385 16 , , , 40436 385 17 unless unless IN 40436 385 18 a a DT 40436 385 19 man man NN 40436 385 20 be be VB 40436 385 21 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 385 22 akin akin JJ 40436 385 23 to to IN 40436 385 24 and and CC 40436 385 25 in in IN 40436 385 26 harmony harmony NN 40436 385 27 with with IN 40436 385 28 the the DT 40436 385 29 ruling rule VBG 40436 385 30 force force NN 40436 385 31 359 359 CD 40436 385 32 Danger danger NN 40436 385 33 of of IN 40436 385 34 one one CD 40436 385 35 who who WP 40436 385 36 dissents dissent VBZ 40436 385 37 from from IN 40436 385 38 the the DT 40436 385 39 public public NN 40436 385 40 , , , 40436 385 41 either either CC 40436 385 42 for for IN 40436 385 43 better well JJR 40436 385 44 or or CC 40436 385 45 for for IN 40436 385 46 worse bad JJR 40436 385 47 _ _ NNP 40436 385 48 ib ib UH 40436 385 49 . . . 40436 385 50 _ _ NNP 40436 385 51 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 385 52 resolves resolve VBZ 40436 385 53 upon upon IN 40436 385 54 a a DT 40436 385 55 scheme scheme NN 40436 385 56 of of IN 40436 385 57 life life NN 40436 385 58 for for IN 40436 385 59 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 385 60 -- -- : 40436 385 61 to to TO 40436 385 62 study study VB 40436 385 63 permanent permanent JJ 40436 385 64 good good NN 40436 385 65 , , , 40436 385 66 and and CC 40436 385 67 not not RB 40436 385 68 immediate immediate JJ 40436 385 69 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 385 70 360 360 CD 40436 385 71 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 385 72 announces announce VBZ 40436 385 73 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 385 74 as as IN 40436 385 75 almost almost RB 40436 385 76 the the DT 40436 385 77 only only JJ 40436 385 78 man man NN 40436 385 79 at at IN 40436 385 80 Athens Athens NNP 40436 385 81 , , , 40436 385 82 who who WP 40436 385 83 follows follow VBZ 40436 385 84 out out RP 40436 385 85 the the DT 40436 385 86 true true JJ 40436 385 87 political political JJ 40436 385 88 art art NN 40436 385 89 . . . 40436 386 1 Danger danger NN 40436 386 2 of of IN 40436 386 3 doing do VBG 40436 386 4 this this DT 40436 386 5 361 361 CD 40436 386 6 Mythe Mythe NNP 40436 386 7 respecting respect VBG 40436 386 8 Hades Hades NNP 40436 386 9 , , , 40436 386 10 and and CC 40436 386 11 the the DT 40436 386 12 treatment treatment NN 40436 386 13 of of IN 40436 386 14 deceased deceased JJ 40436 386 15 persons person NNS 40436 386 16 therein therein RB 40436 386 17 , , , 40436 386 18 according accord VBG 40436 386 19 to to IN 40436 386 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 386 21 merits merit NNS 40436 386 22 during during IN 40436 386 23 life life NN 40436 386 24 -- -- : 40436 386 25 the the DT 40436 386 26 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 386 27 who who WP 40436 386 28 stood stand VBD 40436 386 29 aloof aloof JJ 40436 386 30 from from IN 40436 386 31 public public JJ 40436 386 32 affairs affair NNS 40436 386 33 , , , 40436 386 34 will will MD 40436 386 35 then then RB 40436 386 36 be be VB 40436 386 37 rewarded reward VBN 40436 386 38 _ _ NNP 40436 386 39 ib ib NN 40436 386 40 . . . 40436 386 41 _ _ NNP 40436 386 42 Peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 386 43 ethical ethical JJ 40436 386 44 views view NNS 40436 386 45 of of IN 40436 386 46 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 386 47 -- -- : 40436 386 48 Rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 386 49 or or CC 40436 386 50 dogmatical dogmatical JJ 40436 386 51 character character NN 40436 386 52 of of IN 40436 386 53 the the DT 40436 386 54 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 386 55 362 362 CD 40436 386 56 He -PRON- PRP 40436 386 57 merges merge VBZ 40436 386 58 politics politic NNS 40436 386 59 in in IN 40436 386 60 Ethics Ethics NNP 40436 386 61 -- -- : 40436 386 62 he -PRON- PRP 40436 386 63 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 386 64 the the DT 40436 386 65 rulers ruler NNS 40436 386 66 as as IN 40436 386 67 spiritual spiritual JJ 40436 386 68 teachers teacher NNS 40436 386 69 and and CC 40436 386 70 trainers trainer NNS 40436 386 71 of of IN 40436 386 72 the the DT 40436 386 73 community community NN 40436 386 74 _ _ NNP 40436 386 75 i -PRON- PRP 40436 386 76 d d NNP 40436 386 77 . . . 40436 386 78 _ _ NNP 40436 386 79 _ _ NNP 40436 386 80 Idéal Idéal NNP 40436 386 81 _ _ NNP 40436 386 82 of of IN 40436 386 83 Plato Plato NNP 40436 386 84 -- -- : 40436 386 85 a a DT 40436 386 86 despotic despotic JJ 40436 386 87 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 386 88 or or CC 40436 386 89 man man NN 40436 386 90 - - HYPH 40436 386 91 trainer trainer NN 40436 386 92 , , , 40436 386 93 on on IN 40436 386 94 scientific scientific JJ 40436 386 95 principles principle NNS 40436 386 96 , , , 40436 386 97 fashioning fashion VBG 40436 386 98 all all DT 40436 386 99 characters character NNS 40436 386 100 pursuant pursuant JJ 40436 386 101 to to IN 40436 386 102 certain certain JJ 40436 386 103 types type NNS 40436 386 104 of of IN 40436 386 105 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 386 106 own own JJ 40436 386 107 363 363 CD 40436 386 108 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 386 109 analogy analogy NN 40436 386 110 between between IN 40436 386 111 mental mental JJ 40436 386 112 goodness goodness NN 40436 386 113 and and CC 40436 386 114 bodily bodily JJ 40436 386 115 health health NN 40436 386 116 -- -- : 40436 386 117 incomplete incomplete JJ 40436 386 118 analogy analogy NN 40436 386 119 -- -- : 40436 386 120 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 386 121 of of IN 40436 386 122 difference difference NN 40436 386 123 _ _ NNP 40436 386 124 ib ib NN 40436 386 125 . . . 40436 386 126 _ _ NNP 40436 386 127 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 386 128 in in IN 40436 386 129 the the DT 40436 386 130 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 386 131 speaks speak VBZ 40436 386 132 like like IN 40436 386 133 a a DT 40436 386 134 dissenter dissenter NN 40436 386 135 among among IN 40436 386 136 a a DT 40436 386 137 community community NN 40436 386 138 of of IN 40436 386 139 fixed fix VBN 40436 386 140 opinions opinion NNS 40436 386 141 and and CC 40436 386 142 habits habit NNS 40436 386 143 . . . 40436 387 1 Impossible impossible JJ 40436 387 2 that that IN 40436 387 3 a a DT 40436 387 4 dissenter dissenter NN 40436 387 5 , , , 40436 387 6 on on IN 40436 387 7 important important JJ 40436 387 8 points point NNS 40436 387 9 , , , 40436 387 10 should should MD 40436 387 11 acquire acquire VB 40436 387 12 any any DT 40436 387 13 public public JJ 40436 387 14 influence influence NN 40436 387 15 364 364 CD 40436 387 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 387 17 feels feel VBZ 40436 387 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 387 19 own own JJ 40436 387 20 isolation isolation NN 40436 387 21 from from IN 40436 387 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 387 23 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 387 24 . . . 40436 388 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 388 2 is be VBZ 40436 388 3 thrown throw VBN 40436 388 4 upon upon IN 40436 388 5 individual individual JJ 40436 388 6 speculation speculation NN 40436 388 7 and and CC 40436 388 8 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 388 9 365 365 CD 40436 388 10 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 388 11 between between IN 40436 388 12 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 388 13 and and CC 40436 388 14 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 388 15 _ _ NNP 40436 388 16 ib ib UH 40436 388 17 . . . 40436 388 18 _ _ NNP 40436 388 19 Position Position NNP 40436 388 20 of of IN 40436 388 21 one one CD 40436 388 22 who who WP 40436 388 23 dissents dissent VBZ 40436 388 24 , , , 40436 388 25 upon upon IN 40436 388 26 material material JJ 40436 388 27 points point NNS 40436 388 28 , , , 40436 388 29 from from IN 40436 388 30 the the DT 40436 388 31 fixed fix VBN 40436 388 32 opinions opinion NNS 40436 388 33 and and CC 40436 388 34 creed creed NN 40436 388 35 of of IN 40436 388 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 388 37 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 388 38 366 366 CD 40436 388 39 Probable probable JJ 40436 388 40 feelings feeling NNS 40436 388 41 of of IN 40436 388 42 Plato Plato NNP 40436 388 43 on on IN 40436 388 44 this this DT 40436 388 45 subject subject NN 40436 388 46 -- -- : 40436 388 47 Claim claim NN 40436 388 48 put put VBN 40436 388 49 forward forward RB 40436 388 50 in in IN 40436 388 51 the the DT 40436 388 52 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 388 53 of of IN 40436 388 54 an an DT 40436 388 55 independent independent JJ 40436 388 56 _ _ NNP 40436 388 57 locus locus NN 40436 388 58 standi standi NN 40436 388 59 _ _ NNP 40436 388 60 for for IN 40436 388 61 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 388 62 , , , 40436 388 63 but but CC 40436 388 64 without without IN 40436 388 65 the the DT 40436 388 66 indiscriminate indiscriminate NNP 40436 388 67 cross cross NN 40436 388 68 - - NN 40436 388 69 examination examination NN 40436 388 70 pursued pursue VBN 40436 388 71 by by IN 40436 388 72 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 388 73 367 367 CD 40436 388 74 Importance importance NN 40436 388 75 of of IN 40436 388 76 maintaining maintain VBG 40436 388 77 the the DT 40436 388 78 utmost utmost JJ 40436 388 79 liberty liberty NN 40436 388 80 of of IN 40436 388 81 discussion discussion NN 40436 388 82 . . . 40436 389 1 Tendency tendency NN 40436 389 2 of of IN 40436 389 3 all all DT 40436 389 4 ruling rule VBG 40436 389 5 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 40436 389 6 towards towards IN 40436 389 7 intolerance intolerance NN 40436 389 8 368 368 CD 40436 389 9 Issue issue NN 40436 389 10 between between IN 40436 389 11 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 389 12 and and CC 40436 389 13 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 389 14 -- -- : 40436 389 15 not not RB 40436 389 16 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 40436 389 17 handled handle VBN 40436 389 18 by by IN 40436 389 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 389 20 . . . 40436 390 1 Injustice Injustice NNP 40436 390 2 done do VBN 40436 390 3 to to TO 40436 390 4 rhetoric rhetoric VB 40436 390 5 . . . 40436 391 1 Ignoble ignoble JJ 40436 391 2 manner manner NN 40436 391 3 in in IN 40436 391 4 which which WDT 40436 391 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 391 6 is be VBZ 40436 391 7 presented present VBN 40436 391 8 by by IN 40436 391 9 Polus Polus NNP 40436 391 10 and and CC 40436 391 11 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 391 12 369 369 CD 40436 391 13 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 391 14 would would MD 40436 391 15 have have VB 40436 391 16 accepted accept VBN 40436 391 17 the the DT 40436 391 18 defence defence NN 40436 391 19 of of IN 40436 391 20 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 391 21 , , , 40436 391 22 as as IN 40436 391 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 391 24 has have VBZ 40436 391 25 put put VBN 40436 391 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 391 27 into into IN 40436 391 28 the the DT 40436 391 29 mouth mouth NN 40436 391 30 of of IN 40436 391 31 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 391 32 370 370 CD 40436 391 33 The the DT 40436 391 34 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 391 35 people people NNS 40436 391 36 recognise recognise VBP 40436 391 37 a a DT 40436 391 38 distinction distinction NN 40436 391 39 between between IN 40436 391 40 the the DT 40436 391 41 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 391 42 and and CC 40436 391 43 the the DT 40436 391 44 good good JJ 40436 391 45 : : : 40436 391 46 but but CC 40436 391 47 not not RB 40436 391 48 the the DT 40436 391 49 same same JJ 40436 391 50 as as IN 40436 391 51 that that DT 40436 391 52 which which WDT 40436 391 53 Plato Plato NNP 40436 391 54 conceived conceive VBD 40436 391 55 371 371 CD 40436 391 56 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 391 57 was be VBD 40436 391 58 employed employ VBN 40436 391 59 at at IN 40436 391 60 Athens Athens NNP 40436 391 61 in in IN 40436 391 62 appealing appeal VBG 40436 391 63 to to IN 40436 391 64 all all PDT 40436 391 65 the the DT 40436 391 66 various various JJ 40436 391 67 established established JJ 40436 391 68 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 391 69 and and CC 40436 391 70 opinions opinion NNS 40436 391 71 . . . 40436 392 1 Erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 392 2 inferences inference NNS 40436 392 3 raised raise VBN 40436 392 4 by by IN 40436 392 5 the the DT 40436 392 6 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 392 7 of of IN 40436 392 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 392 9 373 373 CD 40436 392 10 The the DT 40436 392 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 392 12 Idéal Idéal NNP 40436 392 13 exacts exact NNS 40436 392 14 , , , 40436 392 15 as as IN 40436 392 16 good good JJ 40436 392 17 , , , 40436 392 18 some some DT 40436 392 19 order order NN 40436 392 20 , , , 40436 392 21 system system NN 40436 392 22 , , , 40436 392 23 discipline discipline NN 40436 392 24 . . . 40436 393 1 But but CC 40436 393 2 order order NN 40436 393 3 may may MD 40436 393 4 be be VB 40436 393 5 directed direct VBN 40436 393 6 to to IN 40436 393 7 bad bad JJ 40436 393 8 ends end NNS 40436 393 9 as as RB 40436 393 10 well well RB 40436 393 11 as as IN 40436 393 12 to to IN 40436 393 13 good good NN 40436 393 14 . . . 40436 394 1 Divergent divergent JJ 40436 394 2 ideas idea NNS 40436 394 3 about about IN 40436 394 4 virtue virtue NN 40436 394 5 374 374 CD 40436 394 6 How how WRB 40436 394 7 to to TO 40436 394 8 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 394 9 the the DT 40436 394 10 right right JJ 40436 394 11 order order NN 40436 394 12 from from IN 40436 394 13 the the DT 40436 394 14 wrong wrong NN 40436 394 15 . . . 40436 395 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 395 2 does do VBZ 40436 395 3 not not RB 40436 395 4 advise advise VB 40436 395 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 395 6 375 375 CD 40436 395 7 The the DT 40436 395 8 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 395 9 upholds uphold VBZ 40436 395 10 the the DT 40436 395 11 independence independence NN 40436 395 12 and and CC 40436 395 13 dignity dignity NN 40436 395 14 of of IN 40436 395 15 the the DT 40436 395 16 dissenting dissent VBG 40436 395 17 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 395 18 _ _ NNP 40436 395 19 ib ib UH 40436 395 20 . . . 40436 395 21 _ _ NNP 40436 395 22 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 395 23 XXV XXV NNP 40436 395 24 . . . 40436 396 1 PHÆDON PHÆDON NNP 40436 396 2 . . . 40436 397 1 The the DT 40436 397 2 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 397 3 is be VBZ 40436 397 4 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 397 5 and and CC 40436 397 6 expository expository JJ 40436 397 7 377 377 CD 40436 397 8 Situation situation NN 40436 397 9 and and CC 40436 397 10 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 397 11 assumed assume VBN 40436 397 12 in in IN 40436 397 13 the the DT 40436 397 14 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 397 15 . . . 40436 398 1 Pathetic pathetic JJ 40436 398 2 interest interest NN 40436 398 3 which which WDT 40436 398 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 398 5 inspire inspire VBP 40436 398 6 _ _ NNP 40436 398 7 ib ib UH 40436 398 8 . . . 40436 398 9 _ _ NNP 40436 398 10 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 398 11 and and CC 40436 398 12 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 398 13 , , , 40436 398 14 the the DT 40436 398 15 two two CD 40436 398 16 collocutors collocutor NNS 40436 398 17 with with IN 40436 398 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 398 19 . . . 40436 399 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 399 2 feelings feeling NNS 40436 399 3 and and CC 40436 399 4 those those DT 40436 399 5 of of IN 40436 399 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 399 7 378 378 CD 40436 399 8 Emphasis emphasis NN 40436 399 9 of of IN 40436 399 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 399 11 in in IN 40436 399 12 insisting insist VBG 40436 399 13 on on IN 40436 399 14 freedom freedom NN 40436 399 15 of of IN 40436 399 16 debate debate NN 40436 399 17 , , , 40436 399 18 active active JJ 40436 399 19 exercise exercise NN 40436 399 20 of of IN 40436 399 21 reason reason NN 40436 399 22 , , , 40436 399 23 and and CC 40436 399 24 independent independent JJ 40436 399 25 judgment judgment NN 40436 399 26 for for IN 40436 399 27 each each DT 40436 399 28 reasoner reasoner NN 40436 399 29 379 379 CD 40436 399 30 Anxiety Anxiety NNP 40436 399 31 of of IN 40436 399 32 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 399 33 that that IN 40436 399 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 399 35 friends friend NNS 40436 399 36 shall shall MD 40436 399 37 be be VB 40436 399 38 on on IN 40436 399 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 399 40 guard guard NN 40436 399 41 against against IN 40436 399 42 being be VBG 40436 399 43 influenced influence VBN 40436 399 44 by by IN 40436 399 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 399 46 authority authority NN 40436 399 47 -- -- : 40436 399 48 that that IN 40436 399 49 they -PRON- PRP 40436 399 50 shall shall MD 40436 399 51 follow follow VB 40436 399 52 only only RB 40436 399 53 the the DT 40436 399 54 convictions conviction NNS 40436 399 55 of of IN 40436 399 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 399 57 own own JJ 40436 399 58 reason reason NN 40436 399 59 380 380 CD 40436 399 60 Remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 399 61 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 399 62 of of IN 40436 399 63 earnest earnest JJ 40436 399 64 interest interest NN 40436 399 65 for for IN 40436 399 66 reasoned reason VBN 40436 399 67 truth truth NN 40436 399 68 and and CC 40436 399 69 the the DT 40436 399 70 liberty liberty NN 40436 399 71 of of IN 40436 399 72 individual individual JJ 40436 399 73 dissent dissent NN 40436 399 74 381 381 CD 40436 399 75 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 399 76 and and CC 40436 399 77 Symposion symposion NN 40436 399 78 -- -- : 40436 399 79 points point NNS 40436 399 80 of of IN 40436 399 81 analogy analogy NN 40436 399 82 and and CC 40436 399 83 contrast contrast NN 40436 399 84 382 382 CD 40436 399 85 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 399 86 -- -- : 40436 399 87 compared compare VBN 40436 399 88 with with IN 40436 399 89 Republic Republic NNP 40436 399 90 and and CC 40436 399 91 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 399 92 . . . 40436 400 1 No no DT 40436 400 2 recognition recognition NN 40436 400 3 of of IN 40436 400 4 the the DT 40436 400 5 triple triple JJ 40436 400 6 or or CC 40436 400 7 lower low JJR 40436 400 8 souls soul NNS 40436 400 9 . . . 40436 401 1 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 401 2 between between IN 40436 401 3 soul soul NN 40436 401 4 and and CC 40436 401 5 body body NN 40436 401 6 383 383 CD 40436 401 7 Different different JJ 40436 401 8 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 401 9 of of IN 40436 401 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 401 11 about about IN 40436 401 12 the the DT 40436 401 13 soul soul NN 40436 401 14 . . . 40436 402 1 Whether whether IN 40436 402 2 all all PDT 40436 402 3 the the DT 40436 402 4 three three CD 40436 402 5 souls soul NNS 40436 402 6 are be VBP 40436 402 7 immortal immortal JJ 40436 402 8 , , , 40436 402 9 or or CC 40436 402 10 the the DT 40436 402 11 rational rational JJ 40436 402 12 soul soul NN 40436 402 13 alone alone RB 40436 402 14 385 385 CD 40436 402 15 The the DT 40436 402 16 life life NN 40436 402 17 and and CC 40436 402 18 character character NN 40436 402 19 of of IN 40436 402 20 a a DT 40436 402 21 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 402 22 is be VBZ 40436 402 23 a a DT 40436 402 24 constant constant JJ 40436 402 25 struggle struggle NN 40436 402 26 to to TO 40436 402 27 emancipate emancipate VB 40436 402 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 402 29 soul soul NN 40436 402 30 from from IN 40436 402 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 402 32 body body NN 40436 402 33 . . . 40436 403 1 Death death NN 40436 403 2 alone alone RB 40436 403 3 enables enable VBZ 40436 403 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 403 5 to to TO 40436 403 6 do do VB 40436 403 7 this this DT 40436 403 8 completely completely RB 40436 403 9 386 386 CD 40436 403 10 Souls soul NNS 40436 403 11 of of IN 40436 403 12 the the DT 40436 403 13 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 403 14 or or CC 40436 403 15 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 40436 403 16 men man NNS 40436 403 17 pass pass VBP 40436 403 18 after after IN 40436 403 19 death death NN 40436 403 20 into into IN 40436 403 21 the the DT 40436 403 22 bodies body NNS 40436 403 23 of of IN 40436 403 24 different different JJ 40436 403 25 animals animal NNS 40436 403 26 . . . 40436 404 1 The the DT 40436 404 2 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 404 3 alone alone RB 40436 404 4 is be VBZ 40436 404 5 relieved relieve VBN 40436 404 6 from from IN 40436 404 7 all all DT 40436 404 8 communion communion NN 40436 404 9 with with IN 40436 404 10 body body NN 40436 404 11 387 387 CD 40436 404 12 Special special JJ 40436 404 13 privilege privilege NN 40436 404 14 claimed claim VBD 40436 404 15 for for IN 40436 404 16 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 404 17 in in IN 40436 404 18 the the DT 40436 404 19 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 404 20 apart apart RB 40436 404 21 from from IN 40436 404 22 the the DT 40436 404 23 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 404 24 men man NNS 40436 404 25 who who WP 40436 404 26 are be VBP 40436 404 27 not not RB 40436 404 28 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 404 29 388 388 CD 40436 404 30 Simmias Simmias NNPS 40436 404 31 and and CC 40436 404 32 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 404 33 do do VBP 40436 404 34 not not RB 40436 404 35 admit admit VB 40436 404 36 readily readily RB 40436 404 37 the the DT 40436 404 38 immortality immortality NN 40436 404 39 of of IN 40436 404 40 the the DT 40436 404 41 soul soul NN 40436 404 42 , , , 40436 404 43 but but CC 40436 404 44 are be VBP 40436 404 45 unwilling unwilling JJ 40436 404 46 to to TO 40436 404 47 trouble trouble NN 40436 404 48 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 404 49 by by IN 40436 404 50 asking ask VBG 40436 404 51 for for IN 40436 404 52 proof proof NN 40436 404 53 . . . 40436 405 1 Unabated unabated JJ 40436 405 2 interest interest NN 40436 405 3 of of IN 40436 405 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 405 5 in in IN 40436 405 6 rational rational JJ 40436 405 7 debate debate NN 40436 405 8 390 390 CD 40436 405 9 Simmias Simmias NNPS 40436 405 10 and and CC 40436 405 11 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 405 12 believe believe VBP 40436 405 13 fully fully RB 40436 405 14 in in IN 40436 405 15 the the DT 40436 405 16 pre pre NN 40436 405 17 - - NN 40436 405 18 existence existence NN 40436 405 19 of of IN 40436 405 20 the the DT 40436 405 21 soul soul NN 40436 405 22 , , , 40436 405 23 but but CC 40436 405 24 not not RB 40436 405 25 in in IN 40436 405 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 405 27 post post NN 40436 405 28 - - NN 40436 405 29 existence existence NN 40436 405 30 . . . 40436 406 1 Doctrine doctrine NN 40436 406 2 -- -- : 40436 406 3 That that IN 40436 406 4 the the DT 40436 406 5 soul soul NN 40436 406 6 is be VBZ 40436 406 7 a a DT 40436 406 8 sort sort NN 40436 406 9 of of IN 40436 406 10 harmony harmony NN 40436 406 11 -- -- : 40436 406 12 refuted refute VBN 40436 406 13 by by IN 40436 406 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 406 15 _ _ NNP 40436 406 16 ib ib NN 40436 406 17 . . . 40436 406 18 _ _ NNP 40436 406 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 406 20 unfolds unfold VBZ 40436 406 21 the the DT 40436 406 22 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 406 23 changes change NNS 40436 406 24 or or CC 40436 406 25 wanderings wandering NNS 40436 406 26 through through IN 40436 406 27 which which WDT 40436 406 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 406 29 mind mind NN 40436 406 30 had have VBD 40436 406 31 passed pass VBN 40436 406 32 391 391 CD 40436 406 33 First first JJ 40436 406 34 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 406 35 of of IN 40436 406 36 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 406 37 as as IN 40436 406 38 to to TO 40436 406 39 cause cause VB 40436 406 40 . . . 40436 407 1 Reasons reason NNS 40436 407 2 why why WRB 40436 407 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 407 4 rejected reject VBD 40436 407 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 407 6 _ _ IN 40436 407 7 ib ib UH 40436 407 8 . . . 40436 407 9 _ _ NNP 40436 407 10 Second Second NNP 40436 407 11 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 407 12 . . . 40436 408 1 Hopes hope NNS 40436 408 2 raised raise VBN 40436 408 3 by by IN 40436 408 4 the the DT 40436 408 5 treatise treatise NN 40436 408 6 of of IN 40436 408 7 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 408 8 393 393 CD 40436 408 9 Disappointment Disappointment NNP 40436 408 10 because because IN 40436 408 11 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 408 12 did do VBD 40436 408 13 not not RB 40436 408 14 follow follow VB 40436 408 15 out out RP 40436 408 16 the the DT 40436 408 17 optimistic optimistic JJ 40436 408 18 principle principle NN 40436 408 19 into into IN 40436 408 20 detail detail NN 40436 408 21 . . . 40436 409 1 Distinction distinction NN 40436 409 2 between between IN 40436 409 3 causes cause VBZ 40436 409 4 efficient efficient JJ 40436 409 5 and and CC 40436 409 6 causes cause VBZ 40436 409 7 co co JJ 40436 409 8 - - JJ 40436 409 9 efficient efficient JJ 40436 409 10 394 394 CD 40436 409 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 409 12 could could MD 40436 409 13 neither neither CC 40436 409 14 trace trace VB 40436 409 15 out out IN 40436 409 16 the the DT 40436 409 17 optimistic optimistic JJ 40436 409 18 principle principle NN 40436 409 19 for for IN 40436 409 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 409 21 , , , 40436 409 22 nor nor CC 40436 409 23 find find VB 40436 409 24 any any DT 40436 409 25 teacher teacher NN 40436 409 26 thereof thereof RB 40436 409 27 . . . 40436 410 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 410 2 renounced renounce VBD 40436 410 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 410 4 , , , 40436 410 5 and and CC 40436 410 6 embraced embrace VBD 40436 410 7 a a DT 40436 410 8 third third JJ 40436 410 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 410 10 about about IN 40436 410 11 cause cause NN 40436 410 12 395 395 CD 40436 410 13 He -PRON- PRP 40436 410 14 now now RB 40436 410 15 assumes assume VBZ 40436 410 16 the the DT 40436 410 17 separate separate JJ 40436 410 18 existence existence NN 40436 410 19 of of IN 40436 410 20 ideas idea NNS 40436 410 21 . . . 40436 411 1 These these DT 40436 411 2 ideas idea NNS 40436 411 3 are be VBP 40436 411 4 the the DT 40436 411 5 causes cause NNS 40436 411 6 why why WRB 40436 411 7 particular particular JJ 40436 411 8 objects object NNS 40436 411 9 manifest manifest VBP 40436 411 10 certain certain JJ 40436 411 11 attributes attribute VBZ 40436 411 12 396 396 CD 40436 411 13 Procedure Procedure NNP 40436 411 14 of of IN 40436 411 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 411 16 if if IN 40436 411 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 411 18 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 411 19 were be VBD 40436 411 20 impugned impugn VBN 40436 411 21 . . . 40436 412 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 412 2 insists insist VBZ 40436 412 3 upon upon IN 40436 412 4 keeping keep VBG 40436 412 5 apart apart RB 40436 412 6 the the DT 40436 412 7 discussion discussion NN 40436 412 8 of of IN 40436 412 9 the the DT 40436 412 10 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 412 11 and and CC 40436 412 12 the the DT 40436 412 13 discussion discussion NN 40436 412 14 of of IN 40436 412 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 412 16 consequences consequence NNS 40436 412 17 397 397 CD 40436 412 18 Exposition exposition NN 40436 412 19 of of IN 40436 412 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 412 21 welcomed welcome VBN 40436 412 22 by by IN 40436 412 23 the the DT 40436 412 24 hearers hearer NNS 40436 412 25 . . . 40436 413 1 Remarks remark NNS 40436 413 2 upon upon IN 40436 413 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 413 4 398 398 CD 40436 413 5 The the DT 40436 413 6 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 413 7 changes change NNS 40436 413 8 in in IN 40436 413 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 413 10 all all DT 40436 413 11 turned turn VBD 40436 413 12 upon upon RP 40436 413 13 different different JJ 40436 413 14 views view NNS 40436 413 15 as as IN 40436 413 16 to to IN 40436 413 17 a a DT 40436 413 18 true true JJ 40436 413 19 cause cause NN 40436 413 20 _ _ NNP 40436 413 21 ib ib UH 40436 413 22 . . . 40436 413 23 _ _ NNP 40436 413 24 . . . 40436 414 1 Problems problem NNS 40436 414 2 and and CC 40436 414 3 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 414 4 of of IN 40436 414 5 which which WDT 40436 414 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 414 7 first first RB 40436 414 8 sought seek VBD 40436 414 9 solution solution NN 40436 414 10 399 399 CD 40436 414 11 Expectations expectation NNS 40436 414 12 entertained entertain VBN 40436 414 13 by by IN 40436 414 14 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 414 15 from from IN 40436 414 16 the the DT 40436 414 17 treatise treatise NN 40436 414 18 of of IN 40436 414 19 Anaxagoras anaxagora NNS 40436 414 20 . . . 40436 415 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 415 2 disappointment disappointment NN 40436 415 3 . . . 40436 416 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 416 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 416 3 between between IN 40436 416 4 causes cause NNS 40436 416 5 and and CC 40436 416 6 co co NNS 40436 416 7 - - NNS 40436 416 8 efficients efficient NNS 40436 416 9 400 400 CD 40436 416 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 416 11 imputes impute NNS 40436 416 12 to to IN 40436 416 13 Anaxagoras anaxagora NNS 40436 416 14 the the DT 40436 416 15 mistake mistake NN 40436 416 16 of of IN 40436 416 17 substituting substitute VBG 40436 416 18 physical physical JJ 40436 416 19 agencies agency NNS 40436 416 20 in in IN 40436 416 21 place place NN 40436 416 22 of of IN 40436 416 23 mental mental NN 40436 416 24 . . . 40436 417 1 This this DT 40436 417 2 is be VBZ 40436 417 3 the the DT 40436 417 4 same same JJ 40436 417 5 which which WDT 40436 417 6 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40436 417 7 and and CC 40436 417 8 others other NNS 40436 417 9 imputed impute VBD 40436 417 10 to to IN 40436 417 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 417 12 401 401 CD 40436 417 13 The the DT 40436 417 14 supposed suppose VBN 40436 417 15 theory theory NN 40436 417 16 of of IN 40436 417 17 Anaxagoras anaxagora NNS 40436 417 18 can can MD 40436 417 19 not not RB 40436 417 20 be be VB 40436 417 21 carried carry VBN 40436 417 22 out out RP 40436 417 23 , , , 40436 417 24 either either CC 40436 417 25 by by IN 40436 417 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 417 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 417 28 or or CC 40436 417 29 any any DT 40436 417 30 one one NN 40436 417 31 else else RB 40436 417 32 . . . 40436 418 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 418 2 turns turn VBZ 40436 418 3 to to IN 40436 418 4 general general JJ 40436 418 5 words word NNS 40436 418 6 , , , 40436 418 7 and and CC 40436 418 8 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 418 9 the the DT 40436 418 10 theory theory NN 40436 418 11 of of IN 40436 418 12 ideas idea NNS 40436 418 13 403 403 CD 40436 418 14 Vague Vague NNP 40436 418 15 and and CC 40436 418 16 dissentient dissentient JJ 40436 418 17 meanings meaning NNS 40436 418 18 attached attach VBN 40436 418 19 to to IN 40436 418 20 the the DT 40436 418 21 word word NN 40436 418 22 Cause Cause NNP 40436 418 23 . . . 40436 419 1 That that DT 40436 419 2 is be VBZ 40436 419 3 a a DT 40436 419 4 cause cause NN 40436 419 5 , , , 40436 419 6 to to IN 40436 419 7 each each DT 40436 419 8 man man NN 40436 419 9 , , , 40436 419 10 which which WDT 40436 419 11 gives give VBZ 40436 419 12 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 419 13 to to IN 40436 419 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 419 15 inquisitive inquisitive JJ 40436 419 16 feelings feeling NNS 40436 419 17 404 404 CD 40436 419 18 Dissension dissension NN 40436 419 19 and and CC 40436 419 20 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 419 21 on on IN 40436 419 22 the the DT 40436 419 23 question.--What question.--what CD 40436 419 24 is be VBZ 40436 419 25 a a DT 40436 419 26 cause cause NN 40436 419 27 ? ? . 40436 420 1 revealed reveal VBN 40436 420 2 by by IN 40436 420 3 the the DT 40436 420 4 picture picture NN 40436 420 5 of of IN 40436 420 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 420 7 -- -- : 40436 420 8 no no DT 40436 420 9 intuition intuition NN 40436 420 10 to to TO 40436 420 11 guide guide VB 40436 420 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 420 13 407 407 CD 40436 420 14 Different different JJ 40436 420 15 notions notion NNS 40436 420 16 of of IN 40436 420 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 420 18 and and CC 40436 420 19 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 420 20 about about IN 40436 420 21 causation causation NN 40436 420 22 , , , 40436 420 23 causes cause VBZ 40436 420 24 regular regular JJ 40436 420 25 and and CC 40436 420 26 irregular irregular JJ 40436 420 27 . . . 40436 421 1 Inductive inductive JJ 40436 421 2 theory theory NN 40436 421 3 of of IN 40436 421 4 causation causation NN 40436 421 5 , , , 40436 421 6 elaborated elaborate VBN 40436 421 7 in in IN 40436 421 8 modern modern JJ 40436 421 9 times time NNS 40436 421 10 _ _ NNP 40436 421 11 ib ib UH 40436 421 12 . . . 40436 421 13 _ _ NNP 40436 421 14 Last last JJ 40436 421 15 transition transition NN 40436 421 16 of of IN 40436 421 17 the the DT 40436 421 18 mind mind NN 40436 421 19 of of IN 40436 421 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 421 21 from from IN 40436 421 22 things thing NNS 40436 421 23 to to IN 40436 421 24 words word NNS 40436 421 25 -- -- : 40436 421 26 to to IN 40436 421 27 the the DT 40436 421 28 adoption adoption NN 40436 421 29 of of IN 40436 421 30 the the DT 40436 421 31 theory theory NN 40436 421 32 of of IN 40436 421 33 ideas idea NNS 40436 421 34 . . . 40436 422 1 Great great JJ 40436 422 2 multitude multitude NN 40436 422 3 of of IN 40436 422 4 ideas idea NNS 40436 422 5 assumed assume VBN 40436 422 6 , , , 40436 422 7 each each DT 40436 422 8 fitting fit VBG 40436 422 9 a a DT 40436 422 10 certain certain JJ 40436 422 11 number number NN 40436 422 12 of of IN 40436 422 13 particulars particular NNS 40436 422 14 410 410 CD 40436 422 15 Ultimate ultimate JJ 40436 422 16 appeal appeal NN 40436 422 17 to to IN 40436 422 18 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 422 19 of of IN 40436 422 20 extreme extreme JJ 40436 422 21 generality generality NN 40436 422 22 411 411 CD 40436 422 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 422 24 's 's POS 40436 422 25 demonstration demonstration NN 40436 422 26 of of IN 40436 422 27 the the DT 40436 422 28 immortality immortality NN 40436 422 29 of of IN 40436 422 30 the the DT 40436 422 31 soul soul NN 40436 422 32 rests rest NNS 40436 422 33 upon upon IN 40436 422 34 the the DT 40436 422 35 assumption assumption NN 40436 422 36 of of IN 40436 422 37 the the DT 40436 422 38 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 422 39 ideas idea NNS 40436 422 40 . . . 40436 423 1 Reasoning reason VBG 40436 423 2 to to TO 40436 423 3 prove prove VB 40436 423 4 this this DT 40436 423 5 412 412 CD 40436 423 6 The the DT 40436 423 7 soul soul NN 40436 423 8 always always RB 40436 423 9 brings bring VBZ 40436 423 10 life life NN 40436 423 11 , , , 40436 423 12 and and CC 40436 423 13 is be VBZ 40436 423 14 essentially essentially RB 40436 423 15 living live VBG 40436 423 16 . . . 40436 424 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 424 2 can can MD 40436 424 3 not not RB 40436 424 4 receive receive VB 40436 424 5 death death NN 40436 424 6 : : : 40436 424 7 in in IN 40436 424 8 other other JJ 40436 424 9 words word NNS 40436 424 10 , , , 40436 424 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 424 12 is be VBZ 40436 424 13 immortal immortal JJ 40436 424 14 413 413 CD 40436 424 15 The the DT 40436 424 16 proof proof NN 40436 424 17 of of IN 40436 424 18 immortality immortality NN 40436 424 19 includes include VBZ 40436 424 20 pre pre JJ 40436 424 21 - - NN 40436 424 22 existence existence NN 40436 424 23 as as RB 40436 424 24 well well RB 40436 424 25 as as IN 40436 424 26 post post JJ 40436 424 27 - - JJ 40436 424 28 existence existence NN 40436 424 29 -- -- : 40436 424 30 animals animal NNS 40436 424 31 as as RB 40436 424 32 well well RB 40436 424 33 as as IN 40436 424 34 man man NN 40436 424 35 -- -- : 40436 424 36 also also RB 40436 424 37 the the DT 40436 424 38 metempsychosis metempsychosis NN 40436 424 39 or or CC 40436 424 40 translation translation NN 40436 424 41 of of IN 40436 424 42 the the DT 40436 424 43 soul soul NN 40436 424 44 from from IN 40436 424 45 one one CD 40436 424 46 body body NN 40436 424 47 to to IN 40436 424 48 another another DT 40436 424 49 414 414 CD 40436 424 50 After after IN 40436 424 51 finishing finish VBG 40436 424 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 424 53 proof proof NN 40436 424 54 that that IN 40436 424 55 the the DT 40436 424 56 soul soul NN 40436 424 57 is be VBZ 40436 424 58 immortal immortal JJ 40436 424 59 , , , 40436 424 60 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 424 61 enters enter VBZ 40436 424 62 into into IN 40436 424 63 a a DT 40436 424 64 description description NN 40436 424 65 , , , 40436 424 66 what what WP 40436 424 67 will will MD 40436 424 68 become become VB 40436 424 69 of of IN 40436 424 70 it -PRON- PRP 40436 424 71 after after IN 40436 424 72 the the DT 40436 424 73 death death NN 40436 424 74 of of IN 40436 424 75 the the DT 40436 424 76 body body NN 40436 424 77 . . . 40436 425 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 425 2 describes describe VBZ 40436 425 3 a a DT 40436 425 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 425 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 425 6 : : : 40436 425 7 Nekui Nekui NNP 40436 425 8 / / SYM 40436 425 9 a a NN 40436 425 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 425 11 415 415 CD 40436 425 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 425 13 expects expect VBZ 40436 425 14 that that IN 40436 425 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 425 16 soul soul NN 40436 425 17 is be VBZ 40436 425 18 going go VBG 40436 425 19 to to IN 40436 425 20 the the DT 40436 425 21 islands island NNS 40436 425 22 of of IN 40436 425 23 the the DT 40436 425 24 blest blest NN 40436 425 25 . . . 40436 426 1 Reply reply NN 40436 426 2 to to IN 40436 426 3 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 426 4 about about IN 40436 426 5 burying bury VBG 40436 426 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 426 7 body body NN 40436 426 8 416 416 CD 40436 426 9 Preparations preparation NNS 40436 426 10 for for IN 40436 426 11 administering administer VBG 40436 426 12 the the DT 40436 426 13 hemlock hemlock NN 40436 426 14 . . . 40436 427 1 Sympathy Sympathy NNP 40436 427 2 of of IN 40436 427 3 the the DT 40436 427 4 gaoler gaoler NN 40436 427 5 . . . 40436 428 1 Equanimity equanimity NN 40436 428 2 of of IN 40436 428 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 428 4 _ _ NNP 40436 428 5 ib ib NN 40436 428 6 . . . 40436 428 7 _ _ NNP 40436 428 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 428 9 swallows swallow VBZ 40436 428 10 the the DT 40436 428 11 poison poison NN 40436 428 12 . . . 40436 429 1 Conversation conversation NN 40436 429 2 with with IN 40436 429 3 the the DT 40436 429 4 gaoler gaoler NN 40436 429 5 417 417 CD 40436 429 6 Ungovernable ungovernable JJ 40436 429 7 sorrow sorrow NN 40436 429 8 of of IN 40436 429 9 the the DT 40436 429 10 friends friend NNS 40436 429 11 present present JJ 40436 429 12 . . . 40436 430 1 Self self NN 40436 430 2 - - HYPH 40436 430 3 command command NN 40436 430 4 of of IN 40436 430 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 430 6 . . . 40436 431 1 Last last JJ 40436 431 2 words word NNS 40436 431 3 to to IN 40436 431 4 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 431 5 , , , 40436 431 6 and and CC 40436 431 7 death death NN 40436 431 8 _ _ NNP 40436 431 9 ib ib UH 40436 431 10 . . . 40436 431 11 _ _ NNP 40436 431 12 Extreme Extreme NNP 40436 431 13 pathos pathos NNP 40436 431 14 , , , 40436 431 15 and and CC 40436 431 16 probable probable JJ 40436 431 17 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 40436 431 18 of of IN 40436 431 19 these these DT 40436 431 20 personal personal JJ 40436 431 21 details detail NNS 40436 431 22 419 419 CD 40436 431 23 Contrast contrast NN 40436 431 24 between between IN 40436 431 25 the the DT 40436 431 26 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 431 27 Apology Apology NNP 40436 431 28 and and CC 40436 431 29 the the DT 40436 431 30 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 431 31 _ _ NNP 40436 431 32 ib ib UH 40436 431 33 . . . 40436 431 34 _ _ NNP 40436 431 35 . . . 40436 432 1 Abundant abundant JJ 40436 432 2 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 40436 432 3 and and CC 40436 432 4 poetical poetical JJ 40436 432 5 invention invention NN 40436 432 6 of of IN 40436 432 7 the the DT 40436 432 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 432 9 compared compare VBN 40436 432 10 with with IN 40436 432 11 the the DT 40436 432 12 profession profession NN 40436 432 13 of of IN 40436 432 14 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 432 15 which which WDT 40436 432 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 432 17 read read VBP 40436 432 18 in in IN 40436 432 19 the the DT 40436 432 20 Apology Apology NNP 40436 432 21 421 421 CD 40436 432 22 Total total JJ 40436 432 23 renunciation renunciation NN 40436 432 24 and and CC 40436 432 25 discredit discredit NN 40436 432 26 of of IN 40436 432 27 the the DT 40436 432 28 body body NN 40436 432 29 in in IN 40436 432 30 the the DT 40436 432 31 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 432 32 . . . 40436 433 1 Different different JJ 40436 433 2 feeling feeling NN 40436 433 3 about about IN 40436 433 4 the the DT 40436 433 5 body body NN 40436 433 6 in in IN 40436 433 7 other other JJ 40436 433 8 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 433 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 433 10 422 422 CD 40436 433 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 433 12 's 's POS 40436 433 13 argument argument NN 40436 433 14 does do VBZ 40436 433 15 not not RB 40436 433 16 prove prove VB 40436 433 17 the the DT 40436 433 18 immortality immortality NN 40436 433 19 of of IN 40436 433 20 the the DT 40436 433 21 soul soul NN 40436 433 22 . . . 40436 434 1 Even even RB 40436 434 2 if if IN 40436 434 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 434 4 did do VBD 40436 434 5 prove prove VB 40436 434 6 that that DT 40436 434 7 , , , 40436 434 8 yet yet CC 40436 434 9 the the DT 40436 434 10 mode mode NN 40436 434 11 of of IN 40436 434 12 pre pre NN 40436 434 13 - - NN 40436 434 14 existence existence NN 40436 434 15 and and CC 40436 434 16 the the DT 40436 434 17 mode mode NN 40436 434 18 of of IN 40436 434 19 post post JJ 40436 434 20 - - NN 40436 434 21 existence existence NN 40436 434 22 , , , 40436 434 23 of of IN 40436 434 24 the the DT 40436 434 25 soul soul NN 40436 434 26 , , , 40436 434 27 would would MD 40436 434 28 be be VB 40436 434 29 quite quite RB 40436 434 30 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 434 31 423 423 CD 40436 434 32 The the DT 40436 434 33 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 434 34 will will MD 40436 434 35 enjoy enjoy VB 40436 434 36 an an DT 40436 434 37 existence existence NN 40436 434 38 of of IN 40436 434 39 pure pure JJ 40436 434 40 soul soul NN 40436 434 41 unattached unattache VBD 40436 434 42 to to IN 40436 434 43 any any DT 40436 434 44 body body NN 40436 434 45 425 425 CD 40436 434 46 Plato Plato NNP 40436 434 47 's 's POS 40436 434 48 demonstration demonstration NN 40436 434 49 of of IN 40436 434 50 the the DT 40436 434 51 immortality immortality NN 40436 434 52 of of IN 40436 434 53 the the DT 40436 434 54 soul soul NN 40436 434 55 did do VBD 40436 434 56 not not RB 40436 434 57 appear appear VB 40436 434 58 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 434 59 to to IN 40436 434 60 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 434 61 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 434 62 . . . 40436 435 1 The the DT 40436 435 2 question question NN 40436 435 3 remained remain VBD 40436 435 4 debated debated JJ 40436 435 5 and and CC 40436 435 6 problematical problematical JJ 40436 435 7 426 426 CD 40436 435 8 PLATO PLATO NNS 40436 435 9 . . . 40436 436 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 436 2 XII XII NNP 40436 436 3 ALKIBIADES alkibiades NN 40436 436 4 I. i. NN 40436 437 1 AND and CC 40436 437 2 II II NNP 40436 437 3 . . . 40436 438 1 ALKIBIADES ALKIBIADES NNP 40436 438 2 I.--ON i.--on XX 40436 438 3 THE the DT 40436 438 4 NATURE NATURE NNP 40436 438 5 OF of IN 40436 438 6 MAN MAN NNP 40436 438 7 . . . 40436 439 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 439 2 Side side NN 40436 439 3 - - HYPH 40436 439 4 note note NN 40436 439 5 : : : 40436 439 6 Situation situation NN 40436 439 7 supposed suppose VBN 40436 439 8 in in IN 40436 439 9 the the DT 40436 439 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 439 11 . . . 40436 440 1 Persons person NNS 40436 440 2 -- -- : 40436 440 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 440 4 and and CC 40436 440 5 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 440 6 . . . 40436 440 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 441 1 This this DT 40436 441 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 441 3 is be VBZ 40436 441 4 carried carry VBN 40436 441 5 on on RP 40436 441 6 between between IN 40436 441 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 441 8 and and CC 40436 441 9 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 441 10 . . . 40436 442 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 442 2 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 442 3 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 442 4 as as IN 40436 442 5 about about RB 40436 442 6 twenty twenty CD 40436 442 7 years year NNS 40436 442 8 of of IN 40436 442 9 age age NN 40436 442 10 , , , 40436 442 11 having have VBG 40436 442 12 just just RB 40436 442 13 passed pass VBN 40436 442 14 through through IN 40436 442 15 the the DT 40436 442 16 period period NN 40436 442 17 of of IN 40436 442 18 youth youth NN 40436 442 19 , , , 40436 442 20 and and CC 40436 442 21 about about IN 40436 442 22 to to TO 40436 442 23 enter enter VB 40436 442 24 on on IN 40436 442 25 the the DT 40436 442 26 privileges privilege NNS 40436 442 27 and and CC 40436 442 28 duties duty NNS 40436 442 29 of of IN 40436 442 30 a a DT 40436 442 31 citizen citizen NN 40436 442 32 . . . 40436 443 1 The the DT 40436 443 2 real real JJ 40436 443 3 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 443 4 and and CC 40436 443 5 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 443 6 of of IN 40436 443 7 the the DT 40436 443 8 historical historical JJ 40436 443 9 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 443 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 443 11 magnificent magnificent JJ 40436 443 12 personal personal JJ 40436 443 13 beauty beauty NN 40436 443 14 , , , 40436 443 15 stature stature NN 40436 443 16 , , , 40436 443 17 and and CC 40436 443 18 strength strength NN 40436 443 19 , , , 40436 443 20 high high JJ 40436 443 21 family family NN 40436 443 22 and and CC 40436 443 23 connections connection NNS 40436 443 24 , , , 40436 443 25 great great JJ 40436 443 26 wealth wealth NN 40436 443 27 already already RB 40436 443 28 possessed possess VBN 40436 443 29 , , , 40436 443 30 since since IN 40436 443 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 443 32 father father NN 40436 443 33 had have VBD 40436 443 34 died die VBN 40436 443 35 when when WRB 40436 443 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 443 37 was be VBD 40436 443 38 a a DT 40436 443 39 child,--a child,--a NNP 40436 443 40 full full JJ 40436 443 41 measure measure NN 40436 443 42 of of IN 40436 443 43 education education NN 40436 443 44 and and CC 40436 443 45 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 443 46 -- -- : 40436 443 47 together together RB 40436 443 48 with with IN 40436 443 49 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 443 50 ambition ambition NN 40436 443 51 and and CC 40436 443 52 insolence insolence NN 40436 443 53 , , , 40436 443 54 derived derive VBN 40436 443 55 from from IN 40436 443 56 such such JJ 40436 443 57 accumulated accumulate VBN 40436 443 58 advantages advantage NNS 40436 443 59 ) ) -RRB- 40436 443 60 are be VBP 40436 443 61 brought bring VBN 40436 443 62 to to TO 40436 443 63 view view VB 40436 443 64 in in IN 40436 443 65 the the DT 40436 443 66 opening opening NN 40436 443 67 address address NN 40436 443 68 of of IN 40436 443 69 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 443 70 . . . 40436 444 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 444 2 , , , 40436 444 3 during during IN 40436 444 4 the the DT 40436 444 5 years year NNS 40436 444 6 of of IN 40436 444 7 youth youth NN 40436 444 8 which which WDT 40436 444 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 444 10 had have VBD 40436 444 11 just just RB 40436 444 12 passed pass VBN 40436 444 13 , , , 40436 444 14 had have VBD 40436 444 15 been be VBN 40436 444 16 surrounded surround VBN 40436 444 17 by by IN 40436 444 18 admirers admirer NNS 40436 444 19 who who WP 40436 444 20 tried try VBD 40436 444 21 to to TO 40436 444 22 render render VB 40436 444 23 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 444 24 acceptable acceptable JJ 40436 444 25 to to IN 40436 444 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 444 27 , , , 40436 444 28 but but CC 40436 444 29 whom whom WP 40436 444 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 444 31 repelled repel VBD 40436 444 32 with with IN 40436 444 33 indifference indifference NN 40436 444 34 , , , 40436 444 35 and and CC 40436 444 36 even even RB 40436 444 37 with with IN 40436 444 38 scorn scorn JJ 40436 444 39 . . . 40436 445 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 445 2 had have VBD 40436 445 3 been be VBN 40436 445 4 among among IN 40436 445 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 445 6 , , , 40436 445 7 constantly constantly RB 40436 445 8 present present JJ 40436 445 9 and and CC 40436 445 10 near near JJ 40436 445 11 to to IN 40436 445 12 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 445 13 , , , 40436 445 14 but but CC 40436 445 15 without without IN 40436 445 16 ever ever RB 40436 445 17 addressing address VBG 40436 445 18 a a DT 40436 445 19 word word NN 40436 445 20 to to IN 40436 445 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 445 22 . . . 40436 446 1 The the DT 40436 446 2 youthful youthful JJ 40436 446 3 beauty beauty NN 40436 446 4 being be VBG 40436 446 5 now now RB 40436 446 6 exchanged exchange VBN 40436 446 7 for for IN 40436 446 8 manhood manhood NN 40436 446 9 , , , 40436 446 10 all all PDT 40436 446 11 these these DT 40436 446 12 admirers admirer NNS 40436 446 13 had have VBD 40436 446 14 retired retire VBN 40436 446 15 , , , 40436 446 16 and and CC 40436 446 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 446 18 alone alone RB 40436 446 19 remains remain VBZ 40436 446 20 . . . 40436 447 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 447 2 attachment attachment NN 40436 447 3 is be VBZ 40436 447 4 to to IN 40436 447 5 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 447 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 447 7 : : : 40436 447 8 to to TO 40436 447 9 promise promise VB 40436 447 10 of of IN 40436 447 11 mind mind NN 40436 447 12 rather rather RB 40436 447 13 than than IN 40436 447 14 to to IN 40436 447 15 attractions attraction NNS 40436 447 16 of of IN 40436 447 17 person person NN 40436 447 18 . . . 40436 448 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 448 2 has have VBZ 40436 448 3 been be VBN 40436 448 4 always always RB 40436 448 5 hitherto hitherto RB 40436 448 6 restrained restrained JJ 40436 448 7 , , , 40436 448 8 by by IN 40436 448 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 448 10 divine divine JJ 40436 448 11 sign sign NN 40436 448 12 or or CC 40436 448 13 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 448 14 , , , 40436 448 15 from from IN 40436 448 16 speaking speak VBG 40436 448 17 to to IN 40436 448 18 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 448 19 . . . 40436 449 1 But but CC 40436 449 2 this this DT 40436 449 3 prohibition prohibition NN 40436 449 4 has have VBZ 40436 449 5 now now RB 40436 449 6 been be VBN 40436 449 7 removed remove VBN 40436 449 8 ; ; : 40436 449 9 and and CC 40436 449 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 449 11 accosts accost VBZ 40436 449 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 449 13 for for IN 40436 449 14 the the DT 40436 449 15 first first JJ 40436 449 16 time time NN 40436 449 17 , , , 40436 449 18 in in IN 40436 449 19 the the DT 40436 449 20 full full JJ 40436 449 21 belief belief NN 40436 449 22 that that IN 40436 449 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 449 24 shall shall MD 40436 449 25 be be VB 40436 449 26 able able JJ 40436 449 27 to to TO 40436 449 28 give give VB 40436 449 29 improving improve VBG 40436 449 30 counsel counsel NN 40436 449 31 , , , 40436 449 32 essential essential JJ 40436 449 33 to to IN 40436 449 34 the the DT 40436 449 35 success success NN 40436 449 36 of of IN 40436 449 37 that that DT 40436 449 38 political political JJ 40436 449 39 career career NN 40436 449 40 upon upon IN 40436 449 41 which which WDT 40436 449 42 the the DT 40436 449 43 youth youth NN 40436 449 44 is be VBZ 40436 449 45 about about JJ 40436 449 46 to to TO 40436 449 47 enter enter VB 40436 449 48 . . . 40436 450 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 450 2 1 1 CD 40436 450 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 450 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 450 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 450 6 1 1 CD 40436 450 7 : : : 40436 450 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 450 9 , , , 40436 450 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 450 11 . . . 40436 451 1 i. i. NNP 40436 452 1 103 103 CD 40436 452 2 , , , 40436 452 3 104 104 CD 40436 452 4 , , , 40436 452 5 105 105 CD 40436 452 6 . . . 40436 453 1 Perikles Perikles NNP 40436 453 2 is be VBZ 40436 453 3 supposed suppose VBN 40436 453 4 to to TO 40436 453 5 be be VB 40436 453 6 still still RB 40436 453 7 alive alive JJ 40436 453 8 and and CC 40436 453 9 political political JJ 40436 453 10 leader leader NN 40436 453 11 of of IN 40436 453 12 Athens--104 Athens--104 NNP 40436 453 13 B. B. NNP 40436 453 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 453 15 have have VBP 40436 453 16 briefly briefly RB 40436 453 17 sketched sketch VBN 40436 453 18 the the DT 40436 453 19 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 453 20 situation situation NN 40436 453 21 to to IN 40436 453 22 which which WDT 40436 453 23 this this DT 40436 453 24 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 453 25 is be VBZ 40436 453 26 made make VBN 40436 453 27 to to TO 40436 453 28 apply apply VB 40436 453 29 . . . 40436 454 1 The the DT 40436 454 2 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 454 3 of of IN 40436 454 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 454 5 belong belong VBP 40436 454 6 to to IN 40436 454 7 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 454 8 manners manner NNS 40436 454 9 of of IN 40436 454 10 the the DT 40436 454 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 454 12 age age NN 40436 454 13 . . . 40436 455 1 Some some DT 40436 455 2 of of IN 40436 455 3 the the DT 40436 455 4 critics critic NNS 40436 455 5 , , , 40436 455 6 considering consider VBG 40436 455 7 that that IN 40436 455 8 the the DT 40436 455 9 relation relation NN 40436 455 10 supposed suppose VBN 40436 455 11 between between IN 40436 455 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 455 13 and and CC 40436 455 14 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 455 15 is be VBZ 40436 455 16 absurd absurd JJ 40436 455 17 and and CC 40436 455 18 unnatural unnatural JJ 40436 455 19 , , , 40436 455 20 allege allege VBP 40436 455 21 this this DT 40436 455 22 among among IN 40436 455 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 455 24 reasons reason NNS 40436 455 25 for for IN 40436 455 26 denying deny VBG 40436 455 27 the the DT 40436 455 28 authenticity authenticity NN 40436 455 29 of of IN 40436 455 30 the the DT 40436 455 31 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 455 32 . . . 40436 456 1 But but CC 40436 456 2 if if IN 40436 456 3 any any DT 40436 456 4 one one NN 40436 456 5 reads read VBZ 40436 456 6 the the DT 40436 456 7 concluding conclude VBG 40436 456 8 part part NN 40436 456 9 of of IN 40436 456 10 the the DT 40436 456 11 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 456 12 -- -- : 40436 456 13 the the DT 40436 456 14 authenticity authenticity NN 40436 456 15 of of IN 40436 456 16 which which WDT 40436 456 17 has have VBZ 40436 456 18 never never RB 40436 456 19 yet yet RB 40436 456 20 been be VBN 40436 456 21 denied deny VBN 40436 456 22 by by IN 40436 456 23 any any DT 40436 456 24 critic critic NN 40436 456 25 -- -- : 40436 456 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 456 27 will will MD 40436 456 28 find find VB 40436 456 29 something something NN 40436 456 30 a a DT 40436 456 31 great great JJ 40436 456 32 deal deal NN 40436 456 33 more more RBR 40436 456 34 abnormal abnormal JJ 40436 456 35 in in IN 40436 456 36 what what WP 40436 456 37 is be VBZ 40436 456 38 there there RB 40436 456 39 recounted recount VBN 40436 456 40 about about IN 40436 456 41 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 456 42 and and CC 40436 456 43 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 456 44 . . . 40436 457 1 In in IN 40436 457 2 a a DT 40436 457 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 457 4 composed compose VBN 40436 457 5 by by IN 40436 457 6 Æschines Æschines NNPS 40436 457 7 Socraticus Socraticus NNP 40436 457 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 457 9 cited cite VBN 40436 457 10 by by IN 40436 457 11 the the DT 40436 457 12 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 457 13 Aristeides--[Greek Aristeides--[Greek NNP 40436 457 14 : : : 40436 457 15 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 457 16 R(êtorikê R(êtorikê NNP 40436 457 17 = = NFP 40436 457 18 s s NN 40436 457 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 457 20 , , , 40436 457 21 Or or CC 40436 457 22 . . . 40436 458 1 xlv xlv NNP 40436 458 2 . . . 40436 459 1 p. p. NN 40436 459 2 23 23 CD 40436 459 3 - - SYM 40436 459 4 24 24 CD 40436 459 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 459 6 , , , 40436 459 7 expressions expression NNS 40436 459 8 of of IN 40436 459 9 intense intense JJ 40436 459 10 love love NN 40436 459 11 for for IN 40436 459 12 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 459 13 are be VBP 40436 459 14 put put VBN 40436 459 15 into into IN 40436 459 16 the the DT 40436 459 17 mouth mouth NN 40436 459 18 of of IN 40436 459 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 459 20 . . . 40436 460 1 Æschines æschine NNS 40436 460 2 was be VBD 40436 460 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 460 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 460 5 : : : 40436 460 6 gnê gnê NN 40436 460 7 / / SYM 40436 460 8 sios sio NNS 40436 460 9 e(tai e(tai JJ 40436 460 10 = = SYM 40436 460 11 ros ros NNP 40436 460 12 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 460 13 / / SYM 40436 460 14 tous tous JJ 40436 460 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 460 16 , , , 40436 460 17 not not RB 40436 460 18 less less JJR 40436 460 19 than than IN 40436 460 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 460 21 . . . 40436 461 1 The the DT 40436 461 2 different different JJ 40436 461 3 companions companion NNS 40436 461 4 of of IN 40436 461 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 461 6 thus thus RB 40436 461 7 agreed agree VBD 40436 461 8 in in IN 40436 461 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 461 10 picture picture NN 40436 461 11 of of IN 40436 461 12 the the DT 40436 461 13 relation relation NN 40436 461 14 between between IN 40436 461 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 461 16 and and CC 40436 461 17 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 461 18 . . . 40436 461 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 462 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 462 2 Side side NN 40436 462 3 - - HYPH 40436 462 4 note note NN 40436 462 5 : : : 40436 462 6 Exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 462 7 hopes hope NNS 40436 462 8 and and CC 40436 462 9 political political JJ 40436 462 10 ambition ambition NN 40436 462 11 of of IN 40436 462 12 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 462 13 . . . 40436 462 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 463 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 463 2 are be VBP 40436 463 3 about about JJ 40436 463 4 to to TO 40436 463 5 enter enter VB 40436 463 6 on on IN 40436 463 7 public public JJ 40436 463 8 life life NN 40436 463 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 463 10 says say VBZ 40436 463 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 463 12 to to IN 40436 463 13 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 463 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 463 15 with with IN 40436 463 16 the the DT 40436 463 17 most most RBS 40436 463 18 inordinate inordinate JJ 40436 463 19 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 463 20 for for IN 40436 463 21 glory glory NN 40436 463 22 and and CC 40436 463 23 aggrandisement aggrandisement NN 40436 463 24 . . . 40436 464 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 464 2 not not RB 40436 464 3 only only RB 40436 464 4 thirst thirst NN 40436 464 5 for for IN 40436 464 6 the the DT 40436 464 7 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 464 8 of of IN 40436 464 9 ascendancy ascendancy NN 40436 464 10 such such JJ 40436 464 11 as as IN 40436 464 12 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 464 13 possesses possesse NNS 40436 464 14 at at IN 40436 464 15 Athens Athens NNP 40436 464 16 , , , 40436 464 17 but but CC 40436 464 18 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 464 19 ambition ambition NN 40436 464 20 will will MD 40436 464 21 not not RB 40436 464 22 be be VB 40436 464 23 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 464 24 unless unless IN 40436 464 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 464 26 fill fill VBP 40436 464 27 Asia Asia NNP 40436 464 28 with with IN 40436 464 29 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 464 30 renown renown NN 40436 464 31 , , , 40436 464 32 and and CC 40436 464 33 put put VBD 40436 464 34 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 464 35 upon upon IN 40436 464 36 a a DT 40436 464 37 level level NN 40436 464 38 with with IN 40436 464 39 Cyrus Cyrus NNP 40436 464 40 and and CC 40436 464 41 Xerxes Xerxes NNP 40436 464 42 . . . 40436 465 1 Now now RB 40436 465 2 such such JJ 40436 465 3 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 465 4 can can MD 40436 465 5 not not RB 40436 465 6 be be VB 40436 465 7 gratified gratify VBN 40436 465 8 except except IN 40436 465 9 through through IN 40436 465 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 465 11 assistance assistance NN 40436 465 12 . . . 40436 466 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 466 2 do do VBP 40436 466 3 not not RB 40436 466 4 deal deal VB 40436 466 5 in in IN 40436 466 6 long long JJ 40436 466 7 discourses discourse NNS 40436 466 8 such such JJ 40436 466 9 as as IN 40436 466 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 466 11 have have VBP 40436 466 12 been be VBN 40436 466 13 accustomed accustom VBN 40436 466 14 to to TO 40436 466 15 hear hear VB 40436 466 16 from from IN 40436 466 17 others other NNS 40436 466 18 : : : 40436 466 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 466 20 shall shall MD 40436 466 21 put put VB 40436 466 22 to to IN 40436 466 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 466 24 only only RB 40436 466 25 some some DT 40436 466 26 short short JJ 40436 466 27 interrogatories interrogatory NNS 40436 466 28 , , , 40436 466 29 requiring require VBG 40436 466 30 nothing nothing NN 40436 466 31 more more JJR 40436 466 32 than than IN 40436 466 33 answers answer NNS 40436 466 34 to to IN 40436 466 35 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 466 36 questions question NNS 40436 466 37 . . . 40436 467 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 467 2 2 2 CD 40436 467 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 467 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 467 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 467 6 2 2 CD 40436 467 7 : : : 40436 467 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 467 9 , , , 40436 467 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 467 11 . . . 40436 468 1 i. i. NNP 40436 469 1 106 106 CD 40436 469 2 B. B. NNP 40436 470 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 470 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 470 3 : : : 40436 470 4 A)=ra A)=ra NNP 40436 470 5 e)rôtta=|s e)rôtta=|s NNP 40436 470 6 ei)/ ei)/ NN 40436 470 7 tina tina NN 40436 470 8 e)/chô e)/chô NNP 40436 470 9 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 470 10 = = SYM 40436 470 11 n n CC 40436 470 12 lo lo NNP 40436 470 13 / / SYM 40436 470 14 gon gon NNP 40436 470 15 makro makro NNP 40436 470 16 / / SYM 40436 470 17 n n JJ 40436 470 18 , , , 40436 470 19 oi(/ous oi(/ous JJ 40436 470 20 dê\ dê\ NN 40436 470 21 a)kou a)kou NNP 40436 470 22 / / SYM 40436 470 23 ein ein NNP 40436 470 24 ei)/thisai ei)/thisai NNS 40436 470 25 ? ? . 40436 471 1 ou ou NNP 40436 471 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 471 3 ga ga NNP 40436 471 4 / / SYM 40436 471 5 r r NNP 40436 471 6 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 471 7 toiou toiou NNP 40436 471 8 = = NFP 40436 471 9 ton ton NN 40436 471 10 to\ to\ NN 40436 471 11 e)mo e)mo NNP 40436 471 12 / / SYM 40436 471 13 n n NN 40436 471 14 . . . 40436 471 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 472 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 472 2 give give VBP 40436 472 3 here here RB 40436 472 4 , , , 40436 472 5 as as RB 40436 472 6 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 472 7 , , , 40436 472 8 not not RB 40436 472 9 an an DT 40436 472 10 exact exact JJ 40436 472 11 translation translation NN 40436 472 12 , , , 40436 472 13 but but CC 40436 472 14 an an DT 40436 472 15 abstract abstract NN 40436 472 16 . . . 40436 472 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 473 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 473 2 Side side NN 40436 473 3 - - HYPH 40436 473 4 note note NN 40436 473 5 : : : 40436 473 6 Questions question NNS 40436 473 7 put put VBN 40436 473 8 by by IN 40436 473 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 473 10 , , , 40436 473 11 in in IN 40436 473 12 reference reference NN 40436 473 13 to to IN 40436 473 14 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 473 15 in in IN 40436 473 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 473 17 intended intended JJ 40436 473 18 function function NN 40436 473 19 as as IN 40436 473 20 adviser adviser NN 40436 473 21 of of IN 40436 473 22 the the DT 40436 473 23 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 473 24 . . . 40436 474 1 What what WP 40436 474 2 does do VBZ 40436 474 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 474 4 intend intend VB 40436 474 5 to to TO 40436 474 6 advise advise VB 40436 474 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 474 8 upon upon IN 40436 474 9 ? ? . 40436 475 1 What what WP 40436 475 2 has have VBZ 40436 475 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 475 4 learnt learn VBN 40436 475 5 , , , 40436 475 6 and and CC 40436 475 7 what what WP 40436 475 8 does do VBZ 40436 475 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 475 10 know know VB 40436 475 11 ? ? . 40436 475 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 476 1 _ _ NNP 40436 476 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 476 3 are be VBP 40436 476 4 about about JJ 40436 476 5 to to TO 40436 476 6 step step VB 40436 476 7 forward forward RB 40436 476 8 as as IN 40436 476 9 adviser adviser NN 40436 476 10 of of IN 40436 476 11 the the DT 40436 476 12 public public NNP 40436 476 13 assembly assembly NN 40436 476 14 . . . 40436 477 1 Upon upon IN 40436 477 2 what what WDT 40436 477 3 points point NNS 40436 477 4 do do VBP 40436 477 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 477 6 intend intend VB 40436 477 7 to to TO 40436 477 8 advise advise VB 40436 477 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 477 10 ? ? . 40436 478 1 Upon upon IN 40436 478 2 points point NNS 40436 478 3 which which WDT 40436 478 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 478 5 know know VBP 40436 478 6 better well RBR 40436 478 7 than than IN 40436 478 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 478 9 ? ? . 40436 479 1 _ _ NNP 40436 479 2 Alk._--Of Alk._--Of NNP 40436 479 3 course course NN 40436 479 4 . . . 40436 480 1 _ _ NNP 40436 480 2 Sokr._--All Sokr._--All NNP 40436 480 3 that that WDT 40436 480 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 480 5 know know VBP 40436 480 6 , , , 40436 480 7 has have VBZ 40436 480 8 been be VBN 40436 480 9 either either CC 40436 480 10 learnt learn VBN 40436 480 11 from from IN 40436 480 12 others other NNS 40436 480 13 or or CC 40436 480 14 found find VBN 40436 480 15 out out RP 40436 480 16 by by IN 40436 480 17 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 480 18 . . . 40436 481 1 _ _ NNP 40436 481 2 Alk._--Certainly alk._--certainly ADD 40436 481 3 . . . 40436 482 1 _ _ NNP 40436 482 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 482 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 482 4 would would MD 40436 482 5 neither neither RB 40436 482 6 have have VB 40436 482 7 learnt learn VBN 40436 482 8 any any DT 40436 482 9 thing thing NN 40436 482 10 , , , 40436 482 11 nor nor CC 40436 482 12 found find VBD 40436 482 13 out out RP 40436 482 14 any any DT 40436 482 15 thing thing NN 40436 482 16 , , , 40436 482 17 without without IN 40436 482 18 the the DT 40436 482 19 desire desire NN 40436 482 20 to to TO 40436 482 21 learn learn VB 40436 482 22 or or CC 40436 482 23 find find VB 40436 482 24 out out RP 40436 482 25 : : : 40436 482 26 and and CC 40436 482 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 482 28 would would MD 40436 482 29 have have VB 40436 482 30 felt feel VBN 40436 482 31 no no DT 40436 482 32 such such JJ 40436 482 33 desire desire NN 40436 482 34 , , , 40436 482 35 in in IN 40436 482 36 respect respect NN 40436 482 37 to to IN 40436 482 38 that that DT 40436 482 39 which which WDT 40436 482 40 you -PRON- PRP 40436 482 41 believed believe VBD 40436 482 42 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 482 43 to to TO 40436 482 44 know know VB 40436 482 45 already already RB 40436 482 46 . . . 40436 483 1 That that DT 40436 483 2 which which WDT 40436 483 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 483 4 now now RB 40436 483 5 know know VBP 40436 483 6 , , , 40436 483 7 therefore therefore RB 40436 483 8 , , , 40436 483 9 there there EX 40436 483 10 was be VBD 40436 483 11 a a DT 40436 483 12 time time NN 40436 483 13 when when WRB 40436 483 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 483 15 believed believe VBD 40436 483 16 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 483 17 not not RB 40436 483 18 to to TO 40436 483 19 know know VB 40436 483 20 ? ? . 40436 484 1 _ _ NNP 40436 484 2 Alk._--Necessarily Alk._--Necessarily NNP 40436 484 3 so so RB 40436 484 4 . . . 40436 485 1 _ _ NNP 40436 485 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 485 3 all all DT 40436 485 4 that that WDT 40436 485 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 485 6 have have VBP 40436 485 7 learnt learn VBN 40436 485 8 , , , 40436 485 9 as as IN 40436 485 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 485 11 am be VBP 40436 485 12 well well RB 40436 485 13 aware aware JJ 40436 485 14 , , , 40436 485 15 consists consist VBZ 40436 485 16 of of IN 40436 485 17 three three CD 40436 485 18 things thing NNS 40436 485 19 -- -- : 40436 485 20 letters letter NNS 40436 485 21 , , , 40436 485 22 the the DT 40436 485 23 harp harp NN 40436 485 24 , , , 40436 485 25 gymnastics gymnastic NNS 40436 485 26 . . . 40436 486 1 Do do VBP 40436 486 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 486 3 intend intend VB 40436 486 4 to to TO 40436 486 5 advise advise VB 40436 486 6 the the DT 40436 486 7 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 486 8 when when WRB 40436 486 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 486 10 are be VBP 40436 486 11 debating debate VBG 40436 486 12 about about IN 40436 486 13 letters letter NNS 40436 486 14 , , , 40436 486 15 or or CC 40436 486 16 about about IN 40436 486 17 harp harp NN 40436 486 18 - - HYPH 40436 486 19 playing play VBG 40436 486 20 , , , 40436 486 21 or or CC 40436 486 22 about about IN 40436 486 23 gymnastics gymnastic NNS 40436 486 24 ? ? . 40436 487 1 _ _ NNP 40436 487 2 Alk._--Neither Alk._--Neither , 40436 487 3 of of IN 40436 487 4 the the DT 40436 487 5 three three CD 40436 487 6 . . . 40436 488 1 _ _ NNP 40436 488 2 Sokr._--Upon Sokr._--Upon NNP 40436 488 3 what what WP 40436 488 4 occasions occasion NNS 40436 488 5 , , , 40436 488 6 then then RB 40436 488 7 , , , 40436 488 8 do do VBP 40436 488 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 488 10 propose propose VB 40436 488 11 to to TO 40436 488 12 give give VB 40436 488 13 advice advice NN 40436 488 14 ? ? . 40436 489 1 Surely surely RB 40436 489 2 , , , 40436 489 3 not not RB 40436 489 4 when when WRB 40436 489 5 the the DT 40436 489 6 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 489 7 are be VBP 40436 489 8 debating debate VBG 40436 489 9 about about IN 40436 489 10 architecture architecture NN 40436 489 11 , , , 40436 489 12 or or CC 40436 489 13 prophetic prophetic JJ 40436 489 14 warnings warning NNS 40436 489 15 , , , 40436 489 16 or or CC 40436 489 17 the the DT 40436 489 18 public public JJ 40436 489 19 health health NN 40436 489 20 : : : 40436 489 21 for for IN 40436 489 22 to to TO 40436 489 23 deliver deliver VB 40436 489 24 opinions opinion NNS 40436 489 25 on on IN 40436 489 26 each each DT 40436 489 27 of of IN 40436 489 28 these these DT 40436 489 29 matters matter NNS 40436 489 30 , , , 40436 489 31 belongs belong VBZ 40436 489 32 not not RB 40436 489 33 to to IN 40436 489 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 489 35 but but CC 40436 489 36 to to IN 40436 489 37 professional professional JJ 40436 489 38 men man NNS 40436 489 39 -- -- : 40436 489 40 architects architect NNS 40436 489 41 , , , 40436 489 42 prophets prophet NNS 40436 489 43 , , , 40436 489 44 physicians physician NNS 40436 489 45 ; ; : 40436 489 46 whether whether IN 40436 489 47 they -PRON- PRP 40436 489 48 be be VBP 40436 489 49 poor poor JJ 40436 489 50 or or CC 40436 489 51 rich rich JJ 40436 489 52 , , , 40436 489 53 high high RB 40436 489 54 - - HYPH 40436 489 55 born bear VBN 40436 489 56 or or CC 40436 489 57 low low RB 40436 489 58 - - HYPH 40436 489 59 born bear VBN 40436 489 60 ? ? . 40436 490 1 If if IN 40436 490 2 not not RB 40436 490 3 _ _ NNP 40436 490 4 then then RB 40436 490 5 _ _ NNP 40436 490 6 , , , 40436 490 7 upon upon IN 40436 490 8 what what WP 40436 490 9 other other JJ 40436 490 10 occasions occasion NNS 40436 490 11 will will MD 40436 490 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 490 13 tender tender VB 40436 490 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 490 15 counsel counsel NN 40436 490 16 ? ? . 40436 491 1 _ _ NNP 40436 491 2 Alk._--When Alk._--When NNP 40436 491 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 491 4 are be VBP 40436 491 5 debating debate VBG 40436 491 6 about about IN 40436 491 7 affairs affair NNS 40436 491 8 of of IN 40436 491 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 491 10 own own JJ 40436 491 11 . . . 40436 492 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 492 2 Side side NN 40436 492 3 - - HYPH 40436 492 4 note note NN 40436 492 5 : : : 40436 492 6 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 492 7 intends intend VBZ 40436 492 8 to to TO 40436 492 9 advise advise VB 40436 492 10 the the DT 40436 492 11 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 492 12 on on IN 40436 492 13 questions question NNS 40436 492 14 of of IN 40436 492 15 war war NN 40436 492 16 and and CC 40436 492 17 peace peace NN 40436 492 18 . . . 40436 493 1 Questions question NNS 40436 493 2 of of IN 40436 493 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 493 4 thereupon thereupon RB 40436 493 5 . . . 40436 494 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 494 2 must must MD 40436 494 3 fight fight VB 40436 494 4 those those DT 40436 494 5 whom whom WP 40436 494 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 494 7 is be VBZ 40436 494 8 better well JJR 40436 494 9 to to TO 40436 494 10 fight fight VB 40436 494 11 -- -- : 40436 494 12 to to IN 40436 494 13 what what WDT 40436 494 14 standard standard NN 40436 494 15 does do VBZ 40436 494 16 better well RBR 40436 494 17 refer refer VB 40436 494 18 ? ? . 40436 495 1 To to IN 40436 495 2 just just RB 40436 495 3 and and CC 40436 495 4 unjust unjust JJ 40436 495 5 . . . 40436 495 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 496 1 _ _ NNP 40436 496 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 496 3 about about IN 40436 496 4 what what WP 40436 496 5 affairs affair NNS 40436 496 6 of of IN 40436 496 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 496 8 own own JJ 40436 496 9 ? ? . 40436 497 1 Not not RB 40436 497 2 about about IN 40436 497 3 affairs affair NNS 40436 497 4 of of IN 40436 497 5 shipbuilding shipbuilding NN 40436 497 6 : : : 40436 497 7 for for IN 40436 497 8 of of IN 40436 497 9 that that DT 40436 497 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 497 11 know know VBP 40436 497 12 nothing nothing NN 40436 497 13 . . . 40436 498 1 _ _ NNP 40436 498 2 Alk._--When Alk._--When NNP 40436 498 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 498 4 are be VBP 40436 498 5 discussing discuss VBG 40436 498 6 war war NN 40436 498 7 and and CC 40436 498 8 peace peace NN 40436 498 9 , , , 40436 498 10 or or CC 40436 498 11 any any DT 40436 498 12 other other JJ 40436 498 13 business business NN 40436 498 14 concerning concern VBG 40436 498 15 the the DT 40436 498 16 city city NN 40436 498 17 . . . 40436 499 1 _ _ NNP 40436 499 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 499 3 mean mean NN 40436 499 4 when when WRB 40436 499 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 499 6 are be VBP 40436 499 7 discussing discuss VBG 40436 499 8 the the DT 40436 499 9 question question NN 40436 499 10 with with IN 40436 499 11 whom whom WP 40436 499 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 499 13 shall shall MD 40436 499 14 make make VB 40436 499 15 war war NN 40436 499 16 or or CC 40436 499 17 peace peace NN 40436 499 18 , , , 40436 499 19 and and CC 40436 499 20 in in IN 40436 499 21 what what WDT 40436 499 22 manner manner NN 40436 499 23 ? ? . 40436 500 1 But but CC 40436 500 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 500 3 is be VBZ 40436 500 4 certain certain JJ 40436 500 5 that that IN 40436 500 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 500 7 must must MD 40436 500 8 fight fight VB 40436 500 9 those those DT 40436 500 10 whom whom WP 40436 500 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 500 12 is be VBZ 40436 500 13 best good JJS 40436 500 14 to to TO 40436 500 15 fight fight VB 40436 500 16 -- -- : 40436 500 17 also also RB 40436 500 18 _ _ NNP 40436 500 19 when when WRB 40436 500 20 _ _ NNP 40436 500 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 500 22 is be VBZ 40436 500 23 best good JJS 40436 500 24 -- -- : 40436 500 25 and and CC 40436 500 26 _ _ NNP 40436 500 27 as as RB 40436 500 28 long long RB 40436 500 29 as as IN 40436 500 30 _ _ NNP 40436 500 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 500 32 is be VBZ 40436 500 33 best good JJS 40436 500 34 . . . 40436 501 1 _ _ NNP 40436 501 2 Alk._--Certainly alk._--certainly ADD 40436 501 3 . . . 40436 502 1 _ _ NNP 40436 502 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 502 3 , , , 40436 502 4 if if IN 40436 502 5 the the DT 40436 502 6 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 502 7 wished wish VBD 40436 502 8 to to TO 40436 502 9 know know VB 40436 502 10 whom whom WP 40436 502 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 502 12 was be VBD 40436 502 13 best good JJS 40436 502 14 to to TO 40436 502 15 wrestle wrestle VB 40436 502 16 with with IN 40436 502 17 , , , 40436 502 18 and and CC 40436 502 19 when when WRB 40436 502 20 or or CC 40436 502 21 how how WRB 40436 502 22 long long RB 40436 502 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 502 24 was be VBD 40436 502 25 best good JJS 40436 502 26 which which WDT 40436 502 27 of of IN 40436 502 28 the the DT 40436 502 29 two two CD 40436 502 30 would would MD 40436 502 31 be be VB 40436 502 32 most most RBS 40436 502 33 competent competent JJ 40436 502 34 to to TO 40436 502 35 advise advise VB 40436 502 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 502 37 , , , 40436 502 38 you -PRON- PRP 40436 502 39 or or CC 40436 502 40 the the DT 40436 502 41 professional professional JJ 40436 502 42 trainer trainer NN 40436 502 43 ? ? . 40436 503 1 _ _ NNP 40436 503 2 Alk._--The Alk._--The NNP 40436 503 3 trainer trainer NN 40436 503 4 , , , 40436 503 5 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 503 6 . . . 40436 504 1 _ _ NNP 40436 504 2 Sokr._--So Sokr._--So NNP 40436 504 3 , , , 40436 504 4 too too RB 40436 504 5 , , , 40436 504 6 about about IN 40436 504 7 playing play VBG 40436 504 8 the the DT 40436 504 9 harp harp NN 40436 504 10 or or CC 40436 504 11 singing singing NN 40436 504 12 . . . 40436 505 1 But but CC 40436 505 2 when when WRB 40436 505 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 505 4 talk talk VBP 40436 505 5 about about IN 40436 505 6 _ _ NNP 40436 505 7 better well RBR 40436 505 8 _ _ NNP 40436 505 9 , , , 40436 505 10 in in IN 40436 505 11 wrestling wrestling NN 40436 505 12 or or CC 40436 505 13 singing singing NN 40436 505 14 , , , 40436 505 15 what what WDT 40436 505 16 standard standard NN 40436 505 17 do do VBP 40436 505 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 505 19 refer refer VB 40436 505 20 to to IN 40436 505 21 ? ? . 40436 506 1 Is be VBZ 40436 506 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 506 3 not not RB 40436 506 4 to to IN 40436 506 5 the the DT 40436 506 6 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 506 7 or or CC 40436 506 8 musical musical JJ 40436 506 9 art art NN 40436 506 10 ? ? . 40436 507 1 _ _ NNP 40436 507 2 Alk._--Yes Alk._--Yes NNP 40436 507 3 . . . 40436 508 1 _ _ NNP 40436 508 2 Sokr._--Answer Sokr._--Answer NNP 40436 508 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 508 4 in in IN 40436 508 5 like like IN 40436 508 6 manner manner NN 40436 508 7 about about IN 40436 508 8 war war NN 40436 508 9 or or CC 40436 508 10 peace peace NN 40436 508 11 , , , 40436 508 12 the the DT 40436 508 13 subjects subject NNS 40436 508 14 on on IN 40436 508 15 which which WDT 40436 508 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 508 17 are be VBP 40436 508 18 going go VBG 40436 508 19 to to TO 40436 508 20 advise advise VB 40436 508 21 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 508 22 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 508 23 , , , 40436 508 24 whom whom WP 40436 508 25 , , , 40436 508 26 and and CC 40436 508 27 at at IN 40436 508 28 what what WDT 40436 508 29 periods period NNS 40436 508 30 , , , 40436 508 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 508 32 is be VBZ 40436 508 33 _ _ NNP 40436 508 34 better well JJR 40436 508 35 _ _ NNP 40436 508 36 to to TO 40436 508 37 fight fight VB 40436 508 38 , , , 40436 508 39 and and CC 40436 508 40 _ _ NNP 40436 508 41 better well RBR 40436 508 42 _ _ NNP 40436 508 43 not not RB 40436 508 44 to to TO 40436 508 45 fight fight VB 40436 508 46 ? ? . 40436 509 1 What what WP 40436 509 2 in in IN 40436 509 3 this this DT 40436 509 4 last last JJ 40436 509 5 case case NN 40436 509 6 do do VBP 40436 509 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 509 8 mean mean VB 40436 509 9 by by IN 40436 509 10 _ _ NNP 40436 509 11 better well RBR 40436 509 12 _ _ NNP 40436 509 13 ? ? . 40436 510 1 To to IN 40436 510 2 what what WDT 40436 510 3 standard standard NN 40436 510 4 , , , 40436 510 5 or or CC 40436 510 6 to to IN 40436 510 7 what what WDT 40436 510 8 end end NN 40436 510 9 , , , 40436 510 10 do do VBP 40436 510 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 510 12 refer refer VB 40436 510 13 ? ? . 40436 511 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 511 2 3 3 CD 40436 511 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 511 4 _ _ NNP 40436 511 5 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 511 6 can can MD 40436 511 7 not not RB 40436 511 8 say say VB 40436 511 9 . . . 40436 512 1 _ _ NNP 40436 512 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 512 3 is be VBZ 40436 512 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 512 5 not not RB 40436 512 6 a a DT 40436 512 7 disgrace disgrace NN 40436 512 8 , , , 40436 512 9 since since IN 40436 512 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 512 11 profess profess VBP 40436 512 12 to to TO 40436 512 13 advise advise VB 40436 512 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 512 15 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 512 16 when when WRB 40436 512 17 and and CC 40436 512 18 against against IN 40436 512 19 whom whom WP 40436 512 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 512 21 is be VBZ 40436 512 22 better well JJR 40436 512 23 for for IN 40436 512 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 512 25 to to IN 40436 512 26 war,--not war,--not NNP 40436 512 27 to to TO 40436 512 28 be be VB 40436 512 29 able able JJ 40436 512 30 to to TO 40436 512 31 say say VB 40436 512 32 to to IN 40436 512 33 what what WDT 40436 512 34 end end VB 40436 512 35 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 512 36 _ _ NNP 40436 512 37 better well RBR 40436 512 38 _ _ NNP 40436 512 39 refers refer VBZ 40436 512 40 ? ? . 40436 513 1 Do do VBP 40436 513 2 not not RB 40436 513 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 513 4 know know VB 40436 513 5 what what WP 40436 513 6 are be VBP 40436 513 7 the the DT 40436 513 8 usual usual JJ 40436 513 9 grounds ground NNS 40436 513 10 and and CC 40436 513 11 complaints complaint NNS 40436 513 12 urged urge VBD 40436 513 13 when when WRB 40436 513 14 war war NN 40436 513 15 is be VBZ 40436 513 16 undertaken undertake VBN 40436 513 17 ? ? . 40436 514 1 _ _ NNP 40436 514 2 Alk._--Yes Alk._--Yes NNP 40436 514 3 : : : 40436 514 4 complaints complaint NNS 40436 514 5 of of IN 40436 514 6 having have VBG 40436 514 7 been be VBN 40436 514 8 cheated cheat VBN 40436 514 9 , , , 40436 514 10 or or CC 40436 514 11 robbed rob VBN 40436 514 12 , , , 40436 514 13 or or CC 40436 514 14 injured injure VBN 40436 514 15 . . . 40436 515 1 _ _ NNP 40436 515 2 Sokr._--Under Sokr._--Under NNP 40436 515 3 what what WDT 40436 515 4 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 515 5 ? ? . 40436 516 1 _ _ NNP 40436 516 2 Alk._--You Alk._--You NNP 40436 516 3 mean mean VBP 40436 516 4 , , , 40436 516 5 whether whether IN 40436 516 6 justly justly RB 40436 516 7 or or CC 40436 516 8 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 516 9 ? ? . 40436 517 1 That that DT 40436 517 2 makes make VBZ 40436 517 3 all all PDT 40436 517 4 the the DT 40436 517 5 difference difference NN 40436 517 6 . . . 40436 518 1 _ _ NNP 40436 518 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 518 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 518 4 mean mean VBP 40436 518 5 to to TO 40436 518 6 advise advise VB 40436 518 7 the the DT 40436 518 8 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 518 9 to to TO 40436 518 10 fight fight VB 40436 518 11 those those DT 40436 518 12 who who WP 40436 518 13 behave behave VBP 40436 518 14 justly justly RB 40436 518 15 , , , 40436 518 16 or or CC 40436 518 17 those those DT 40436 518 18 who who WP 40436 518 19 behave behave VBP 40436 518 20 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 518 21 ? ? . 40436 519 1 _ _ NNP 40436 519 2 Alk._--The Alk._--The NNP 40436 519 3 question question NN 40436 519 4 is be VBZ 40436 519 5 monstrous monstrous JJ 40436 519 6 . . . 40436 520 1 Certainly certainly RB 40436 520 2 not not RB 40436 520 3 those those DT 40436 520 4 who who WP 40436 520 5 behave behave VBP 40436 520 6 justly justly RB 40436 520 7 . . . 40436 521 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 521 2 would would MD 40436 521 3 be be VB 40436 521 4 neither neither CC 40436 521 5 lawful lawful JJ 40436 521 6 nor nor CC 40436 521 7 honourable honourable JJ 40436 521 8 . . . 40436 522 1 _ _ NNP 40436 522 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 522 3 when when WRB 40436 522 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 522 5 spoke speak VBD 40436 522 6 about about IN 40436 522 7 _ _ NNP 40436 522 8 better well RBR 40436 522 9 _ _ NNP 40436 522 10 , , , 40436 522 11 in in IN 40436 522 12 reference reference NN 40436 522 13 to to IN 40436 522 14 war war NN 40436 522 15 or or CC 40436 522 16 peace peace NN 40436 522 17 , , , 40436 522 18 what what WP 40436 522 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 522 20 meant mean VBD 40436 522 21 was be VBD 40436 522 22 _ _ NNP 40436 522 23 juster_--you juster_--you NNP 40436 522 24 had have VBD 40436 522 25 in in IN 40436 522 26 view view NN 40436 522 27 justice justice NN 40436 522 28 and and CC 40436 522 29 injustice injustice NN 40436 522 30 ? ? . 40436 523 1 _ _ NNP 40436 523 2 Alk._--It Alk._--It NNP 40436 523 3 seems seem VBZ 40436 523 4 so so RB 40436 523 5 . . . 40436 524 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 524 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 524 3 3 3 CD 40436 524 4 : : : 40436 524 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 524 6 , , , 40436 524 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 524 8 . . . 40436 525 1 i. i. NNP 40436 526 1 108 108 CD 40436 526 2 E--109 e--109 SYM 40436 526 3 A. a. NN 40436 527 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 527 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 527 3 : : : 40436 527 4 i)/thi i)/thi NN 40436 527 5 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 527 6 , , , 40436 527 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 527 8 to\ to\ NNP 40436 527 9 en en FW 40436 527 10 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 527 11 polemei polemei NN 40436 527 12 = = SYM 40436 527 13 n n CC 40436 527 14 be be VB 40436 527 15 / / SYM 40436 527 16 ltion ltion NN 40436 527 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 527 18 to\ to\ NNP 40436 527 19 en en FW 40436 527 20 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 527 21 ei)rê ei)rê NNP 40436 527 22 / / SYM 40436 527 23 nên nên NNP 40436 527 24 a)/gein a)/gein NNP 40436 527 25 , , , 40436 527 26 tou tou NNP 40436 527 27 = = SYM 40436 527 28 to to TO 40436 527 29 to\ to\ NN 40436 527 30 be be VB 40436 527 31 / / SYM 40436 527 32 ltion ltion NN 40436 527 33 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 527 34 o)noma o)noma NNP 40436 527 35 / / SYM 40436 527 36 zeis zeis NNP 40436 527 37 ? ? . 40436 528 1 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 528 2 e)kei= e)kei= NN 40436 528 3 e)ph e)ph NNP 40436 528 4 ' ' '' 40436 528 5 e)ka e)ka NNP 40436 528 6 / / SYM 40436 528 7 stô| stô| NN 40436 528 8 e)/leges e)/lege VBZ 40436 528 9 to\ to\ NNP 40436 528 10 a)/meinon a)/meinon NNP 40436 528 11 , , , 40436 528 12 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 528 13 mousikô mousikô NNP 40436 528 14 / / SYM 40436 528 15 teron teron NNP 40436 528 16 , , , 40436 528 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 528 18 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 528 19 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 528 20 e(terô| e(terô| NNP 40436 528 21 , , , 40436 528 22 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 528 23 gumnastikô gumnastikô NN 40436 528 24 / / SYM 40436 528 25 teron teron NNP 40436 528 26 ; ; : 40436 528 27 peirô= peirô= NNP 40436 528 28 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 528 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 528 30 e)ntau e)ntau NNP 40436 528 31 = = SYM 40436 528 32 tha tha NNP 40436 528 33 le le NNP 40436 528 34 / / SYM 40436 528 35 gein gein NNP 40436 528 36 to\ to\ NN 40436 528 37 be be VB 40436 528 38 / / SYM 40436 528 39 ltion ltion NN 40436 528 40 . . . 40436 529 1 . . . 40436 530 1 . . . 40436 531 1 . . . 40436 532 1 . . . 40436 533 1 pro\s pro\s NN 40436 533 2 ti/ ti/ NN 40436 533 3 teinei teinei NN 40436 533 4 to\ to\ NN 40436 533 5 e)n e)n NNP 40436 533 6 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 533 7 ei)rê ei)rê NNP 40436 533 8 / / SYM 40436 533 9 nên nên NNP 40436 533 10 te te NNP 40436 533 11 a)/gein a)/gein NNP 40436 533 12 a)/meinon a)/meinon NNP 40436 533 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 533 14 to\ to\ NNP 40436 533 15 e)n e)n NNP 40436 533 16 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 533 17 polemei polemei NN 40436 533 18 = = SYM 40436 533 19 n n CC 40436 533 20 oi(=s oi(=s NN 40436 533 21 dei= dei= NNP 40436 533 22 ? ? . 40436 533 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 534 1 _ _ NNP 40436 534 2 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 534 3 . . . 40436 534 4 _ _ NNP 40436 534 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 534 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 534 7 : : : 40436 534 8 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNS 40436 534 9 skopô skopô VB 40436 534 10 = = NNS 40436 534 11 n n CC 40436 534 12 ou ou NNP 40436 534 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 534 14 du du NNP 40436 534 15 / / SYM 40436 534 16 namai namai NNP 40436 534 17 e)nnoê e)nnoê , 40436 534 18 = = SYM 40436 534 19 sai sai NNP 40436 534 20 . . . 40436 534 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 534 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 535 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 535 2 Side side NN 40436 535 3 - - HYPH 40436 535 4 note note NN 40436 535 5 : : : 40436 535 6 How how WRB 40436 535 7 , , , 40436 535 8 or or CC 40436 535 9 from from IN 40436 535 10 whom whom WP 40436 535 11 , , , 40436 535 12 has have VBZ 40436 535 13 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 535 14 learnt learn VBN 40436 535 15 to to IN 40436 535 16 discern discern VB 40436 535 17 or or CC 40436 535 18 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 535 19 Just just RB 40436 535 20 and and CC 40436 535 21 Unjust unjust JJ 40436 535 22 ? ? . 40436 536 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 536 2 never never RB 40436 536 3 learnt learn VBD 40436 536 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 536 5 from from IN 40436 536 6 any any DT 40436 536 7 one one NN 40436 536 8 ; ; : 40436 536 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 536 10 always always RB 40436 536 11 knew know VBD 40436 536 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 536 13 , , , 40436 536 14 even even RB 40436 536 15 as as IN 40436 536 16 a a DT 40436 536 17 boy boy NN 40436 536 18 . . . 40436 536 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 537 1 _ _ NNP 40436 537 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 537 3 is be VBZ 40436 537 4 this this DT 40436 537 5 ? ? . 40436 538 1 How how WRB 40436 538 2 do do VBP 40436 538 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 538 4 know know VB 40436 538 5 , , , 40436 538 6 or or CC 40436 538 7 where where WRB 40436 538 8 have have VBP 40436 538 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 538 10 learnt learn VBN 40436 538 11 , , , 40436 538 12 to to TO 40436 538 13 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 538 14 just just RB 40436 538 15 from from IN 40436 538 16 unjust unjust JJ 40436 538 17 ? ? . 40436 539 1 Have have VBP 40436 539 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 539 3 frequented frequent VBN 40436 539 4 some some DT 40436 539 5 master master NN 40436 539 6 , , , 40436 539 7 without without IN 40436 539 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 539 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 539 10 , , , 40436 539 11 to to TO 40436 539 12 teach teach VB 40436 539 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 539 14 this this DT 40436 539 15 ? ? . 40436 540 1 If if IN 40436 540 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 540 3 have have VBP 40436 540 4 , , , 40436 540 5 pray pray VB 40436 540 6 introduce introduce VB 40436 540 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 540 8 to to IN 40436 540 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 540 10 , , , 40436 540 11 that that IN 40436 540 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 540 13 also also RB 40436 540 14 may may MD 40436 540 15 learn learn VB 40436 540 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 540 17 from from IN 40436 540 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 540 19 . . . 40436 541 1 _ _ NNP 40436 541 2 Alk._--You Alk._--You NNP 40436 541 3 are be VBP 40436 541 4 jesting jest VBG 40436 541 5 . . . 40436 542 1 _ _ NNP 40436 542 2 Sokr._--Not Sokr._--Not NNP 40436 542 3 at at RB 40436 542 4 all all RB 40436 542 5 : : : 40436 542 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 542 7 love love VBP 40436 542 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 542 9 too too RB 40436 542 10 well well RB 40436 542 11 to to IN 40436 542 12 jest jest NNP 40436 542 13 . . . 40436 543 1 _ _ NNP 40436 543 2 Alk._--But Alk._--But NNP 40436 543 3 what what WP 40436 543 4 if if IN 40436 543 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 543 6 had have VBD 40436 543 7 no no DT 40436 543 8 master master NN 40436 543 9 ? ? . 40436 544 1 Can can MD 40436 544 2 not not RB 40436 544 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 544 4 know know VBP 40436 544 5 about about IN 40436 544 6 justice justice NN 40436 544 7 and and CC 40436 544 8 injustice injustice NN 40436 544 9 , , , 40436 544 10 without without IN 40436 544 11 a a DT 40436 544 12 master master NN 40436 544 13 ? ? . 40436 545 1 _ _ NNP 40436 545 2 Sokr._--Certainly Sokr._--Certainly NNP 40436 545 3 : : : 40436 545 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 545 5 might may MD 40436 545 6 find find VB 40436 545 7 out out RP 40436 545 8 for for IN 40436 545 9 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 545 10 , , , 40436 545 11 if if IN 40436 545 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 545 13 made make VBD 40436 545 14 search search NN 40436 545 15 and and CC 40436 545 16 investigated investigate VBN 40436 545 17 . . . 40436 546 1 But but CC 40436 546 2 this this DT 40436 546 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 546 4 would would MD 40436 546 5 not not RB 40436 546 6 do do VB 40436 546 7 , , , 40436 546 8 unless unless IN 40436 546 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 546 10 were be VBD 40436 546 11 under under IN 40436 546 12 the the DT 40436 546 13 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 546 14 that that WDT 40436 546 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 546 16 did do VBD 40436 546 17 not not RB 40436 546 18 already already RB 40436 546 19 know know VB 40436 546 20 . . . 40436 547 1 _ _ NNP 40436 547 2 Alk._--Was Alk._--Was NNP 40436 547 3 there there RB 40436 547 4 not not RB 40436 547 5 a a DT 40436 547 6 time time NN 40436 547 7 when when WRB 40436 547 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 547 9 really really RB 40436 547 10 believed believe VBD 40436 547 11 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 547 12 not not RB 40436 547 13 to to TO 40436 547 14 know know VB 40436 547 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 547 16 ? ? . 40436 548 1 _ _ NNP 40436 548 2 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 548 3 there there EX 40436 548 4 may may MD 40436 548 5 have have VB 40436 548 6 been be VBN 40436 548 7 : : : 40436 548 8 tell tell VB 40436 548 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 548 10 _ _ NNP 40436 548 11 when when WRB 40436 548 12 _ _ NNP 40436 548 13 that that DT 40436 548 14 time time NN 40436 548 15 was be VBD 40436 548 16 . . . 40436 549 1 Was be VBD 40436 549 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 549 3 last last JJ 40436 549 4 year year NN 40436 549 5 ? ? . 40436 550 1 _ _ NNP 40436 550 2 Alk._--No Alk._--No NNP 40436 550 3 : : : 40436 550 4 last last JJ 40436 550 5 year year NN 40436 550 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 550 7 thought think VBD 40436 550 8 that that IN 40436 550 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 550 10 knew know VBD 40436 550 11 . . . 40436 551 1 _ _ NNP 40436 551 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 551 3 , , , 40436 551 4 then then RB 40436 551 5 two two CD 40436 551 6 years year NNS 40436 551 7 , , , 40436 551 8 three three CD 40436 551 9 years year NNS 40436 551 10 , , , 40436 551 11 & & CC 40436 551 12 c. c. NNP 40436 551 13 , , , 40436 551 14 ago ago RB 40436 551 15 ? ? . 40436 552 1 _ _ NNP 40436 552 2 Alk._--No Alk._--No NNP 40436 552 3 : : : 40436 552 4 the the DT 40436 552 5 case case NN 40436 552 6 was be VBD 40436 552 7 the the DT 40436 552 8 same same JJ 40436 552 9 then then RB 40436 552 10 , , , 40436 552 11 also also RB 40436 552 12 , , , 40436 552 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 552 14 thought think VBD 40436 552 15 that that IN 40436 552 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 552 17 knew know VBD 40436 552 18 . . . 40436 553 1 _ _ NNP 40436 553 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 553 3 before before IN 40436 553 4 that that DT 40436 553 5 , , , 40436 553 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 553 7 were be VBD 40436 553 8 a a DT 40436 553 9 mere mere JJ 40436 553 10 boy boy NN 40436 553 11 ; ; : 40436 553 12 and and CC 40436 553 13 during during IN 40436 553 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 553 15 boyhood boyhood NN 40436 553 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 553 17 certainly certainly RB 40436 553 18 believed believe VBD 40436 553 19 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 553 20 to to TO 40436 553 21 know know VB 40436 553 22 what what WP 40436 553 23 was be VBD 40436 553 24 just just RB 40436 553 25 and and CC 40436 553 26 unjust unjust JJ 40436 553 27 ; ; : 40436 553 28 for for IN 40436 553 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 553 30 well well RB 40436 553 31 recollect recollect JJ 40436 553 32 hearing hear VBG 40436 553 33 you -PRON- PRP 40436 553 34 then then RB 40436 553 35 complain complain VB 40436 553 36 confidently confidently RB 40436 553 37 of of IN 40436 553 38 other other JJ 40436 553 39 boys boy NNS 40436 553 40 , , , 40436 553 41 for for IN 40436 553 42 acting act VBG 40436 553 43 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 553 44 towards towards IN 40436 553 45 you -PRON- PRP 40436 553 46 . . . 40436 554 1 _ _ NNP 40436 554 2 Alk._--Certainly alk._--certainly RB 40436 554 3 : : : 40436 554 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 554 5 was be VBD 40436 554 6 not not RB 40436 554 7 then then RB 40436 554 8 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 554 9 on on IN 40436 554 10 the the DT 40436 554 11 point point NN 40436 554 12 : : : 40436 554 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 554 14 knew know VBD 40436 554 15 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 554 16 that that IN 40436 554 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 554 18 were be VBD 40436 554 19 acting act VBG 40436 554 20 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 554 21 towards towards IN 40436 554 22 me -PRON- PRP 40436 554 23 . . . 40436 555 1 _ _ NNP 40436 555 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 555 3 knew know VBD 40436 555 4 , , , 40436 555 5 then then RB 40436 555 6 , , , 40436 555 7 even even RB 40436 555 8 in in IN 40436 555 9 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 555 10 boyhood boyhood NN 40436 555 11 , , , 40436 555 12 what what WP 40436 555 13 was be VBD 40436 555 14 just just RB 40436 555 15 and and CC 40436 555 16 what what WP 40436 555 17 was be VBD 40436 555 18 unjust unjust JJ 40436 555 19 ? ? . 40436 556 1 _ _ NNP 40436 556 2 Alk._--Certainly alk._--certainly RB 40436 556 3 : : : 40436 556 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 556 5 knew know VBD 40436 556 6 even even RB 40436 556 7 then then RB 40436 556 8 . . . 40436 557 1 _ _ NNP 40436 557 2 Sokr._--At Sokr._--At NNP 40436 557 3 what what WP 40436 557 4 moment moment NN 40436 557 5 did do VBD 40436 557 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 557 7 first first RB 40436 557 8 find find VB 40436 557 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 557 10 out out RP 40436 557 11 ? ? . 40436 558 1 Not not RB 40436 558 2 when when WRB 40436 558 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 558 4 already already RB 40436 558 5 believed believe VBD 40436 558 6 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 558 7 to to TO 40436 558 8 know know VB 40436 558 9 : : : 40436 558 10 and and CC 40436 558 11 what what WDT 40436 558 12 time time NN 40436 558 13 was be VBD 40436 558 14 there there RB 40436 558 15 when when WRB 40436 558 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 558 17 did do VBD 40436 558 18 not not RB 40436 558 19 believe believe VB 40436 558 20 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 558 21 to to TO 40436 558 22 know know VB 40436 558 23 ? ? . 40436 559 1 _ _ NNP 40436 559 2 Alk._--Upon alk._--upon RB 40436 559 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 559 4 word word NN 40436 559 5 , , , 40436 559 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 559 7 can can MD 40436 559 8 not not RB 40436 559 9 say say VB 40436 559 10 . . . 40436 560 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 560 2 Side side NN 40436 560 3 - - HYPH 40436 560 4 note note NN 40436 560 5 : : : 40436 560 6 Answer Answer NNP 40436 560 7 amended amend VBD 40436 560 8 . . . 40436 561 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 561 2 learnt learn VBD 40436 561 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 561 4 from from IN 40436 561 5 the the DT 40436 561 6 multitude multitude NN 40436 561 7 , , , 40436 561 8 as as IN 40436 561 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 561 10 learnt learn VBD 40436 561 11 to to TO 40436 561 12 speak speak VB 40436 561 13 Greek.--The Greek.--The NNP 40436 561 14 multitude multitude NN 40436 561 15 can can MD 40436 561 16 not not RB 40436 561 17 teach teach VB 40436 561 18 just just RB 40436 561 19 and and CC 40436 561 20 unjust unjust JJ 40436 561 21 , , , 40436 561 22 for for IN 40436 561 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 561 24 are be VBP 40436 561 25 at at IN 40436 561 26 variance variance NN 40436 561 27 among among IN 40436 561 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 561 29 about about IN 40436 561 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 561 31 . . . 40436 562 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 562 2 is be VBZ 40436 562 3 going go VBG 40436 562 4 to to TO 40436 562 5 advise advise VB 40436 562 6 the the DT 40436 562 7 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 562 8 about about IN 40436 562 9 what what WP 40436 562 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 562 11 does do VBZ 40436 562 12 not not RB 40436 562 13 know know VB 40436 562 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 562 15 . . . 40436 562 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 563 1 _ _ NNP 40436 563 2 Sokr._--Since Sokr._--Since NNP 40436 563 3 , , , 40436 563 4 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 563 5 , , , 40436 563 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 563 7 neither neither CC 40436 563 8 found find VBD 40436 563 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 563 10 out out RP 40436 563 11 for for IN 40436 563 12 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 563 13 , , , 40436 563 14 nor nor CC 40436 563 15 learnt learn VBD 40436 563 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 563 17 from from IN 40436 563 18 others other NNS 40436 563 19 , , , 40436 563 20 how how WRB 40436 563 21 come come VB 40436 563 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 563 23 to to TO 40436 563 24 know know VB 40436 563 25 justice justice NN 40436 563 26 or or CC 40436 563 27 injustice injustice NN 40436 563 28 at at RB 40436 563 29 all all RB 40436 563 30 , , , 40436 563 31 or or CC 40436 563 32 from from IN 40436 563 33 what what WDT 40436 563 34 quarter quarter NN 40436 563 35 ? ? . 40436 564 1 _ _ NNP 40436 564 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 564 3 was be VBD 40436 564 4 mistaken mistake VBN 40436 564 5 in in IN 40436 564 6 saying say VBG 40436 564 7 that that IN 40436 564 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 564 9 had have VBD 40436 564 10 not not RB 40436 564 11 learnt learn VBN 40436 564 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 564 13 . . . 40436 565 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 565 2 learnt learn VBD 40436 565 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 565 4 , , , 40436 565 5 as as IN 40436 565 6 others other NNS 40436 565 7 do do VBP 40436 565 8 , , , 40436 565 9 from from IN 40436 565 10 the the DT 40436 565 11 multitude multitude NN 40436 565 12 . . . 40436 566 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 566 2 4 4 CD 40436 566 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 566 4 _ _ NNP 40436 566 5 Sokr._--Your Sokr._--Your NNP 40436 566 6 teachers teacher NNS 40436 566 7 are be VBP 40436 566 8 none none NN 40436 566 9 of of IN 40436 566 10 the the DT 40436 566 11 best good JJS 40436 566 12 : : : 40436 566 13 no no DT 40436 566 14 one one NN 40436 566 15 can can MD 40436 566 16 learn learn VB 40436 566 17 from from IN 40436 566 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 566 19 even even RB 40436 566 20 such such JJ 40436 566 21 small small JJ 40436 566 22 matters matter NNS 40436 566 23 as as IN 40436 566 24 playing play VBG 40436 566 25 at at IN 40436 566 26 draughts draught NNS 40436 566 27 : : : 40436 566 28 much much RB 40436 566 29 less less JJR 40436 566 30 , , , 40436 566 31 what what WP 40436 566 32 is be VBZ 40436 566 33 just just RB 40436 566 34 and and CC 40436 566 35 unjust unjust JJ 40436 566 36 . . . 40436 567 1 _ _ NNP 40436 567 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 567 3 learnt learn VBZ 40436 567 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 567 5 from from IN 40436 567 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 567 7 as as IN 40436 567 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 567 9 learnt learn VBD 40436 567 10 to to TO 40436 567 11 speak speak VB 40436 567 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 567 13 , , , 40436 567 14 in in IN 40436 567 15 which which WDT 40436 567 16 , , , 40436 567 17 too too RB 40436 567 18 , , , 40436 567 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 567 20 never never RB 40436 567 21 had have VBD 40436 567 22 any any DT 40436 567 23 special special JJ 40436 567 24 teacher teacher NN 40436 567 25 . . . 40436 568 1 _ _ NNP 40436 568 2 Sokr._--Of Sokr._--Of NNP 40436 568 3 that that IN 40436 568 4 the the DT 40436 568 5 multitude multitude NNP 40436 568 6 are be VBP 40436 568 7 competent competent JJ 40436 568 8 teachers teacher NNS 40436 568 9 , , , 40436 568 10 for for IN 40436 568 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 568 12 are be VBP 40436 568 13 all all DT 40436 568 14 of of IN 40436 568 15 one one CD 40436 568 16 mind mind NN 40436 568 17 . . . 40436 569 1 Ask ask VB 40436 569 2 which which WDT 40436 569 3 is be VBZ 40436 569 4 a a DT 40436 569 5 tree tree NN 40436 569 6 or or CC 40436 569 7 a a DT 40436 569 8 stone,--a stone,--a NNP 40436 569 9 horse horse NN 40436 569 10 or or CC 40436 569 11 a a DT 40436 569 12 man,--you man,--you NNPS 40436 569 13 get get VBP 40436 569 14 the the DT 40436 569 15 same same JJ 40436 569 16 answer answer NN 40436 569 17 from from IN 40436 569 18 every every DT 40436 569 19 one one CD 40436 569 20 . . . 40436 570 1 But but CC 40436 570 2 when when WRB 40436 570 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 570 4 ask ask VBP 40436 570 5 not not RB 40436 570 6 simply simply RB 40436 570 7 which which WDT 40436 570 8 are be VBP 40436 570 9 _ _ NNP 40436 570 10 horses horse NNS 40436 570 11 _ _ NNP 40436 570 12 , , , 40436 570 13 but but CC 40436 570 14 also also RB 40436 570 15 which which WDT 40436 570 16 horses horse NNS 40436 570 17 are be VBP 40436 570 18 fit fit JJ 40436 570 19 to to TO 40436 570 20 run run VB 40436 570 21 well well RB 40436 570 22 in in IN 40436 570 23 a a DT 40436 570 24 race race NN 40436 570 25 -- -- : 40436 570 26 when when WRB 40436 570 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 570 28 ask ask VBP 40436 570 29 not not RB 40436 570 30 merely merely RB 40436 570 31 about about IN 40436 570 32 which which WDT 40436 570 33 are be VBP 40436 570 34 _ _ NNP 40436 570 35 men man NNS 40436 570 36 _ _ NNP 40436 570 37 , , , 40436 570 38 but but CC 40436 570 39 which which WDT 40436 570 40 men man NNS 40436 570 41 are be VBP 40436 570 42 healthy healthy JJ 40436 570 43 or or CC 40436 570 44 unhealthy unhealthy JJ 40436 570 45 -- -- : 40436 570 46 are be VBP 40436 570 47 the the DT 40436 570 48 multitude multitude NN 40436 570 49 all all DT 40436 570 50 of of IN 40436 570 51 one one CD 40436 570 52 mind mind NN 40436 570 53 , , , 40436 570 54 or or CC 40436 570 55 all all DT 40436 570 56 competent competent JJ 40436 570 57 to to TO 40436 570 58 answer answer VB 40436 570 59 ? ? . 40436 571 1 _ _ NNP 40436 571 2 Alk._--Assuredly alk._--assuredly RB 40436 571 3 not not RB 40436 571 4 . . . 40436 572 1 _ _ NNP 40436 572 2 Sokr._--When Sokr._--When NNP 40436 572 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 572 4 see see VBP 40436 572 5 the the DT 40436 572 6 multitude multitude NN 40436 572 7 differing differ VBG 40436 572 8 among among IN 40436 572 9 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 572 10 , , , 40436 572 11 that that DT 40436 572 12 is be VBZ 40436 572 13 a a DT 40436 572 14 clear clear JJ 40436 572 15 proof proof NN 40436 572 16 that that IN 40436 572 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 572 18 are be VBP 40436 572 19 not not RB 40436 572 20 competent competent JJ 40436 572 21 to to TO 40436 572 22 teach teach VB 40436 572 23 others other NNS 40436 572 24 . . . 40436 573 1 _ _ NNP 40436 573 2 Alk._--It Alk._--It NNP 40436 573 3 is be VBZ 40436 573 4 so so RB 40436 573 5 . . . 40436 574 1 _ _ NNP 40436 574 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 574 3 , , , 40436 574 4 about about IN 40436 574 5 the the DT 40436 574 6 question question NN 40436 574 7 , , , 40436 574 8 What what WP 40436 574 9 is be VBZ 40436 574 10 just just RB 40436 574 11 and and CC 40436 574 12 unjust unjust JJ 40436 574 13 -- -- : 40436 574 14 are be VBP 40436 574 15 the the DT 40436 574 16 multitude multitude NN 40436 574 17 all all DT 40436 574 18 of of IN 40436 574 19 one one CD 40436 574 20 mind mind NN 40436 574 21 , , , 40436 574 22 or or CC 40436 574 23 do do VBP 40436 574 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 574 25 differ differ VB 40436 574 26 among among IN 40436 574 27 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 574 28 ? ? . 40436 575 1 _ _ NNP 40436 575 2 Alk._--They Alk._--They NNP 40436 575 3 differ differ VBP 40436 575 4 prodigiously prodigiously RB 40436 575 5 : : : 40436 575 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 575 7 not not RB 40436 575 8 only only RB 40436 575 9 dispute dispute VBP 40436 575 10 , , , 40436 575 11 but but CC 40436 575 12 quarrel quarrel NN 40436 575 13 and and CC 40436 575 14 destroy destroy VB 40436 575 15 each each DT 40436 575 16 other other JJ 40436 575 17 , , , 40436 575 18 respecting respect VBG 40436 575 19 justice justice NN 40436 575 20 and and CC 40436 575 21 injustice injustice NN 40436 575 22 , , , 40436 575 23 far far RB 40436 575 24 more more JJR 40436 575 25 than than IN 40436 575 26 about about IN 40436 575 27 health health NN 40436 575 28 and and CC 40436 575 29 sickness sickness NN 40436 575 30 . . . 40436 576 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 576 2 5 5 CD 40436 576 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 576 4 _ _ NNP 40436 576 5 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 576 6 . . . 40436 576 7 _ _ NNP 40436 576 8 How how WRB 40436 576 9 , , , 40436 576 10 then then RB 40436 576 11 , , , 40436 576 12 can can MD 40436 576 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 576 14 say say VB 40436 576 15 that that IN 40436 576 16 the the DT 40436 576 17 multitude multitude NNP 40436 576 18 know know VB 40436 576 19 what what WP 40436 576 20 is be VBZ 40436 576 21 just just RB 40436 576 22 and and CC 40436 576 23 unjust unjust JJ 40436 576 24 , , , 40436 576 25 when when WRB 40436 576 26 they -PRON- PRP 40436 576 27 thus thus RB 40436 576 28 fiercely fiercely RB 40436 576 29 dispute dispute VBP 40436 576 30 about about IN 40436 576 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 576 32 among among IN 40436 576 33 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 576 34 ? ? . 40436 577 1 _ _ NNP 40436 577 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 577 3 now now RB 40436 577 4 perceive perceive VBP 40436 577 5 that that IN 40436 577 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 577 7 can can MD 40436 577 8 not not RB 40436 577 9 say say VB 40436 577 10 so so RB 40436 577 11 . . . 40436 578 1 _ _ NNP 40436 578 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 578 3 can can MD 40436 578 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 578 5 say say VB 40436 578 6 , , , 40436 578 7 therefore therefore RB 40436 578 8 , , , 40436 578 9 that that IN 40436 578 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 578 11 are be VBP 40436 578 12 fit fit JJ 40436 578 13 to to TO 40436 578 14 teach teach VB 40436 578 15 others other NNS 40436 578 16 : : : 40436 578 17 and and CC 40436 578 18 how how WRB 40436 578 19 can can MD 40436 578 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 578 21 pretend pretend VB 40436 578 22 to to TO 40436 578 23 know know VB 40436 578 24 , , , 40436 578 25 who who WP 40436 578 26 have have VBP 40436 578 27 learnt learn VBN 40436 578 28 from from IN 40436 578 29 no no DT 40436 578 30 other other JJ 40436 578 31 teachers teacher NNS 40436 578 32 ? ? . 40436 579 1 _ _ NNP 40436 579 2 Alk._--From alk._--from IN 40436 579 3 what what WP 40436 579 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 579 5 say say VBP 40436 579 6 , , , 40436 579 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 579 8 is be VBZ 40436 579 9 impossible impossible JJ 40436 579 10 . . . 40436 580 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 580 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 580 3 4 4 CD 40436 580 4 : : : 40436 580 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 580 6 , , , 40436 580 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 580 8 . . . 40436 581 1 i. i. NNP 40436 582 1 110 110 CD 40436 582 2 D D NNP 40436 582 3 - - HYPH 40436 582 4 E. e. NN 40436 582 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 582 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 582 7 : : : 40436 582 8 e)/mathon e)/mathon NN 40436 582 9 , , , 40436 582 10 oi)=mai oi)=mai NNP 40436 582 11 , , , 40436 582 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 582 13 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 582 14 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 582 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 582 16 oi oi NNP 40436 582 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 582 18 a)/lloi a)/lloi NNP 40436 582 19 . . . 40436 583 1 . . . 40436 584 1 . . . 40436 585 1 . . . 40436 586 1 para\ para\ NNP 40436 586 2 tô tô NNP 40436 586 3 = = SYM 40436 586 4 n n IN 40436 586 5 pollô pollô NN 40436 586 6 = = SYM 40436 586 7 n n NN 40436 586 8 . . . 40436 586 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 586 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 587 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 587 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 587 3 5 5 CD 40436 587 4 : : : 40436 587 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 587 6 , , , 40436 587 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 587 8 . . . 40436 588 1 i. i. NNP 40436 589 1 112 112 CD 40436 589 2 A. a. NN 40436 590 1 _ _ NNP 40436 590 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 590 3 . . . 40436 590 4 _ _ NNP 40436 590 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 590 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 590 7 : : : 40436 590 8 Ti/ Ti/ NNP 40436 590 9 de\ de\ NNP 40436 590 10 dê\ dê\ NN 40436 590 11 ? ? . 40436 591 1 nu nu NNP 40436 591 2 = = SYM 40436 591 3 n n NNP 40436 591 4 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 591 5 tô tô IN 40436 591 6 = = NFP 40436 591 7 n n CC 40436 591 8 dikai dikai NNP 40436 591 9 / / SYM 40436 591 10 ôn ôn NNP 40436 591 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 591 12 a)di a)di NNP 40436 591 13 / / SYM 40436 591 14 kôn kôn NNP 40436 591 15 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 591 16 / / SYM 40436 591 17 pôn pôn NNP 40436 591 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 591 19 pragma pragma NNP 40436 591 20 / / SYM 40436 591 21 tôn tôn NNP 40436 591 22 , , , 40436 591 23 oi oi NNP 40436 591 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 591 25 polloi\ polloi\ NNP 40436 591 26 dokou dokou NNP 40436 591 27 = = SYM 40436 591 28 si/ si/ XX 40436 591 29 soi soi NN 40436 591 30 o(mologei o(mologei CD 40436 591 31 = = NFP 40436 591 32 n n NNP 40436 591 33 au)toi\ au)toi\ NNP 40436 591 34 e(autoi e(autoi NNP 40436 591 35 = = SYM 40436 591 36 s s NNP 40436 591 37 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 591 38 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 591 39 / / SYM 40436 591 40 lois lois JJ 40436 591 41 ? ? . 40436 591 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 592 1 _ _ NNP 40436 592 2 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 592 3 . . . 40436 592 4 _ _ NNP 40436 592 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 592 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 592 7 : : : 40436 592 8 Ê(/kista ê(/kista NN 40436 592 9 , , , 40436 592 10 nê\ nê\ NNP 40436 592 11 Di/ Di/ NNP 40436 592 12 ' ' POS 40436 592 13 , , , 40436 592 14 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 592 15 Sô Sô NNP 40436 592 16 / / SYM 40436 592 17 krates krate NNS 40436 592 18 . . . 40436 592 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 593 1 _ _ NNP 40436 593 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 593 3 . . . 40436 593 4 _ _ NNP 40436 593 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 593 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 593 7 : : : 40436 593 8 Ti/ Ti/ NNP 40436 593 9 de/ de/ NNP 40436 593 10 ? ? . 40436 594 1 ma ma NNP 40436 594 2 / / SYM 40436 594 3 lista lista NNP 40436 594 4 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 594 5 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 594 6 = = SYM 40436 594 7 n n CC 40436 594 8 diaphe diaphe NNP 40436 594 9 / / SYM 40436 594 10 resthai resthai NNP 40436 594 11 ? ? . 40436 594 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 595 1 _ _ NNP 40436 595 2 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 595 3 . . . 40436 595 4 _ _ NNP 40436 595 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 595 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 595 7 : : : 40436 595 8 polu/ polu/ NNP 40436 595 9 ge ge NNP 40436 595 10 . . . 40436 595 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 595 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 596 1 _ _ NNP 40436 596 2 Sokr._--No Sokr._--No NNP 40436 596 3 : : : 40436 596 4 not not RB 40436 596 5 from from IN 40436 596 6 what what WP 40436 596 7 _ _ NNP 40436 596 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 596 9 _ _ NNP 40436 596 10 say say VBP 40436 596 11 , , , 40436 596 12 but but CC 40436 596 13 from from IN 40436 596 14 what what WP 40436 596 15 _ _ NNP 40436 596 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 596 17 _ _ NNP 40436 596 18 say say VB 40436 596 19 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 596 20 . . . 40436 597 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 597 2 merely merely RB 40436 597 3 ask ask VBP 40436 597 4 questions question NNS 40436 597 5 : : : 40436 597 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 597 7 is be VBZ 40436 597 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 597 9 who who WP 40436 597 10 give give VBP 40436 597 11 all all PDT 40436 597 12 the the DT 40436 597 13 answers answer NNS 40436 597 14 . . . 40436 598 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 598 2 6 6 CD 40436 598 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 598 4 And and CC 40436 598 5 what what WP 40436 598 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 598 7 have have VBP 40436 598 8 said say VBD 40436 598 9 amounts amount NNS 40436 598 10 to to IN 40436 598 11 this this DT 40436 598 12 -- -- : 40436 598 13 that that IN 40436 598 14 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 598 15 knows know VBZ 40436 598 16 nothing nothing NN 40436 598 17 about about IN 40436 598 18 what what WP 40436 598 19 is be VBZ 40436 598 20 just just RB 40436 598 21 and and CC 40436 598 22 unjust unjust JJ 40436 598 23 , , , 40436 598 24 but but CC 40436 598 25 believes believe VBZ 40436 598 26 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 598 27 to to TO 40436 598 28 know know VB 40436 598 29 , , , 40436 598 30 and and CC 40436 598 31 is be VBZ 40436 598 32 going go VBG 40436 598 33 to to TO 40436 598 34 advise advise VB 40436 598 35 the the DT 40436 598 36 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 598 37 about about IN 40436 598 38 what what WP 40436 598 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 598 40 does do VBZ 40436 598 41 not not RB 40436 598 42 know know VB 40436 598 43 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 598 44 ? ? . 40436 599 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 599 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 599 3 6 6 CD 40436 599 4 : : : 40436 599 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 599 6 , , , 40436 599 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 599 8 . . . 40436 600 1 i. i. NNP 40436 601 1 112 112 CD 40436 601 2 - - SYM 40436 601 3 113 113 CD 40436 601 4 . . . 40436 601 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 602 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 602 2 Side side NN 40436 602 3 - - HYPH 40436 602 4 note note NN 40436 602 5 : : : 40436 602 6 Answer answer VB 40436 602 7 farther farther RB 40436 602 8 amended amend VBN 40436 602 9 . . . 40436 603 1 The the DT 40436 603 2 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 603 3 do do VBP 40436 603 4 not not RB 40436 603 5 generally generally RB 40436 603 6 debate debate VB 40436 603 7 about about IN 40436 603 8 just just RB 40436 603 9 or or CC 40436 603 10 unjust unjust JJ 40436 603 11 -- -- : 40436 603 12 which which WDT 40436 603 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 603 14 consider consider VBP 40436 603 15 plain plain JJ 40436 603 16 to to IN 40436 603 17 every every DT 40436 603 18 one one CD 40436 603 19 -- -- : 40436 603 20 but but CC 40436 603 21 about about IN 40436 603 22 expedient expedient NN 40436 603 23 and and CC 40436 603 24 inexpedient inexpedient JJ 40436 603 25 , , , 40436 603 26 which which WDT 40436 603 27 are be VBP 40436 603 28 not not RB 40436 603 29 coincident coincident JJ 40436 603 30 with with IN 40436 603 31 just just JJ 40436 603 32 and and CC 40436 603 33 unjust unjust JJ 40436 603 34 . . . 40436 604 1 But but CC 40436 604 2 neither neither DT 40436 604 3 does do VBZ 40436 604 4 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 604 5 know know VB 40436 604 6 the the DT 40436 604 7 expedient expedient NN 40436 604 8 . . . 40436 605 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 605 2 asks ask VBZ 40436 605 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 605 4 to to TO 40436 605 5 explain explain VB 40436 605 6 . . . 40436 606 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 606 2 declines decline VBZ 40436 606 3 : : : 40436 606 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 606 5 can can MD 40436 606 6 do do VB 40436 606 7 nothing nothing NN 40436 606 8 but but IN 40436 606 9 question question NN 40436 606 10 . . . 40436 606 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 607 1 _ _ NNP 40436 607 2 Alk._--But Alk._--But NNP 40436 607 3 , , , 40436 607 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 607 5 , , , 40436 607 6 the the DT 40436 607 7 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 607 8 do do VBP 40436 607 9 not not RB 40436 607 10 often often RB 40436 607 11 debate debate VB 40436 607 12 about about IN 40436 607 13 what what WP 40436 607 14 is be VBZ 40436 607 15 just just RB 40436 607 16 and and CC 40436 607 17 unjust unjust JJ 40436 607 18 . . . 40436 608 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 608 2 think think VBP 40436 608 3 that that IN 40436 608 4 question question NN 40436 608 5 self self NN 40436 608 6 - - HYPH 40436 608 7 evident evident JJ 40436 608 8 ; ; : 40436 608 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 608 10 debate debate VBP 40436 608 11 generally generally RB 40436 608 12 about about IN 40436 608 13 what what WP 40436 608 14 is be VBZ 40436 608 15 expedient expedient JJ 40436 608 16 or or CC 40436 608 17 not not RB 40436 608 18 expedient expedient JJ 40436 608 19 . . . 40436 609 1 Justice justice NN 40436 609 2 and and CC 40436 609 3 expediency expediency NN 40436 609 4 do do VBP 40436 609 5 not not RB 40436 609 6 do do VB 40436 609 7 not not RB 40436 609 8 always always RB 40436 609 9 coincide coincide VB 40436 609 10 . . . 40436 610 1 Many many JJ 40436 610 2 persons person NNS 40436 610 3 commit commit VBP 40436 610 4 great great JJ 40436 610 5 crimes crime NNS 40436 610 6 , , , 40436 610 7 and and CC 40436 610 8 are be VBP 40436 610 9 great great JJ 40436 610 10 gainers gainer NNS 40436 610 11 by by IN 40436 610 12 doing do VBG 40436 610 13 so so RB 40436 610 14 : : : 40436 610 15 others other NNS 40436 610 16 again again RB 40436 610 17 behave behave VBP 40436 610 18 justly justly RB 40436 610 19 , , , 40436 610 20 and and CC 40436 610 21 suffer suffer VB 40436 610 22 from from IN 40436 610 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 610 24 . . . 40436 611 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 611 2 7 7 CD 40436 611 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 611 4 _ _ NNP 40436 611 5 Sokr_--Do Sokr_--Do NNP 40436 611 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 611 7 then then RB 40436 611 8 profess profess VBP 40436 611 9 to to TO 40436 611 10 know know VB 40436 611 11 what what WP 40436 611 12 is be VBZ 40436 611 13 expedient expedient NN 40436 611 14 or or CC 40436 611 15 inexpedient inexpedient JJ 40436 611 16 ? ? . 40436 612 1 From from IN 40436 612 2 whom whom WP 40436 612 3 have have VBP 40436 612 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 612 5 learnt learn VBN 40436 612 6 -- -- : 40436 612 7 or or CC 40436 612 8 when when WRB 40436 612 9 did do VBD 40436 612 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 612 11 find find VB 40436 612 12 out out RP 40436 612 13 for for IN 40436 612 14 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 612 15 ? ? . 40436 613 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 613 2 might may MD 40436 613 3 ask ask VB 40436 613 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 613 5 the the DT 40436 613 6 same same JJ 40436 613 7 round round NN 40436 613 8 of of IN 40436 613 9 questions question NNS 40436 613 10 , , , 40436 613 11 and and CC 40436 613 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 613 13 would would MD 40436 613 14 be be VB 40436 613 15 compelled compel VBN 40436 613 16 to to TO 40436 613 17 answer answer VB 40436 613 18 in in IN 40436 613 19 the the DT 40436 613 20 same same JJ 40436 613 21 manner manner NN 40436 613 22 . . . 40436 614 1 But but CC 40436 614 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 614 3 will will MD 40436 614 4 pass pass VB 40436 614 5 to to IN 40436 614 6 a a DT 40436 614 7 different different JJ 40436 614 8 point point NN 40436 614 9 . . . 40436 615 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 615 2 say say VBP 40436 615 3 that that DT 40436 615 4 justice justice NN 40436 615 5 and and CC 40436 615 6 expediency expediency NN 40436 615 7 are be VBP 40436 615 8 not not RB 40436 615 9 coincident coincident JJ 40436 615 10 . . . 40436 616 1 Persuade Persuade NNP 40436 616 2 _ _ NNP 40436 616 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 616 4 _ _ NNP 40436 616 5 of of IN 40436 616 6 this this DT 40436 616 7 , , , 40436 616 8 by by IN 40436 616 9 interrogating interrogate VBG 40436 616 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 616 11 as as IN 40436 616 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 616 13 interrogated interrogate VBD 40436 616 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 616 15 . . . 40436 617 1 _ _ NNP 40436 617 2 Alk._--That alk._--that DT 40436 617 3 is be VBZ 40436 617 4 beyond beyond IN 40436 617 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 617 6 power power NN 40436 617 7 . . . 40436 618 1 _ _ NNP 40436 618 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 618 3 when when WRB 40436 618 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 618 5 rise rise VBP 40436 618 6 to to TO 40436 618 7 address address VB 40436 618 8 the the DT 40436 618 9 assembly assembly NN 40436 618 10 , , , 40436 618 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 618 12 will will MD 40436 618 13 have have VB 40436 618 14 to to TO 40436 618 15 persuade persuade VB 40436 618 16 _ _ NNP 40436 618 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 618 18 _ _ NNP 40436 618 19 . . . 40436 619 1 If if IN 40436 619 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 619 3 can can MD 40436 619 4 persuade persuade VB 40436 619 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 619 6 , , , 40436 619 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 619 8 can can MD 40436 619 9 persuade persuade VB 40436 619 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 619 11 . . . 40436 620 1 Assume Assume NNP 40436 620 2 _ _ NNP 40436 620 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 620 4 _ _ NNP 40436 620 5 to to TO 40436 620 6 be be VB 40436 620 7 the the DT 40436 620 8 assembly assembly NN 40436 620 9 , , , 40436 620 10 and and CC 40436 620 11 practise practise VB 40436 620 12 upon upon IN 40436 620 13 me -PRON- PRP 40436 620 14 . . . 40436 621 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 621 2 8 8 CD 40436 621 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 621 4 _ _ NNP 40436 621 5 Alk._--You Alk._--You NNP 40436 621 6 are be VBP 40436 621 7 too too RB 40436 621 8 hard hard JJ 40436 621 9 upon upon IN 40436 621 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 621 11 , , , 40436 621 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 621 13 . . . 40436 622 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 622 2 is be VBZ 40436 622 3 for for IN 40436 622 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 622 5 to to TO 40436 622 6 speak speak VB 40436 622 7 and and CC 40436 622 8 prove prove VB 40436 622 9 the the DT 40436 622 10 point point NN 40436 622 11 . . . 40436 623 1 _ _ NNP 40436 623 2 Sokr_--No Sokr_--No NNP 40436 623 3 : : : 40436 623 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 623 5 can can MD 40436 623 6 only only RB 40436 623 7 question question VB 40436 623 8 : : : 40436 623 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 623 10 must must MD 40436 623 11 answer answer VB 40436 623 12 . . . 40436 624 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 624 2 will will MD 40436 624 3 be be VB 40436 624 4 most most RBS 40436 624 5 surely surely RB 40436 624 6 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 624 7 when when WRB 40436 624 8 the the DT 40436 624 9 point point NN 40436 624 10 is be VBZ 40436 624 11 determined determine VBN 40436 624 12 by by IN 40436 624 13 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 624 14 own own JJ 40436 624 15 answers answer NNS 40436 624 16 . . . 40436 625 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 625 2 9 9 CD 40436 625 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 625 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 625 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 625 6 7 7 CD 40436 625 7 : : : 40436 625 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 625 9 , , , 40436 625 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 625 11 . . . 40436 626 1 i. i. NNP 40436 627 1 113 113 CD 40436 627 2 D. D. NNP 40436 627 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 627 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 627 5 : : : 40436 627 6 Oi)=mai Oi)=mai NNP 40436 627 7 me\n me\n NNP 40436 627 8 o)liga o)liga , 40436 627 9 / / SYM 40436 627 10 kis kis NNP 40436 627 11 A)thênai A)thênai NNP 40436 627 12 / / SYM 40436 627 13 ous ous NNP 40436 627 14 bouleu bouleu NNP 40436 627 15 / / SYM 40436 627 16 esthai esthai NNP 40436 627 17 po po NNP 40436 627 18 / / SYM 40436 627 19 tera tera NN 40436 627 20 dikaio dikaio NN 40436 627 21 / / SYM 40436 627 22 tera tera NNP 40436 627 23 ê)\ ê)\ CD 40436 627 24 a)dikôtera a)dikôtera NNS 40436 627 25 ; ; , 40436 627 26 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 627 27 me\n me\n NNP 40436 627 28 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 627 29 toiau toiau NN 40436 627 30 = = SYM 40436 627 31 ta ta NNP 40436 627 32 ê(gou ê(gou NNP 40436 627 33 = = SYM 40436 627 34 ntai ntai NNP 40436 627 35 dê dê NNP 40436 627 36 = = SYM 40436 627 37 la la NNP 40436 627 38 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 627 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 627 40 , , , 40436 627 41 & & CC 40436 627 42 c. c. NNP 40436 627 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 627 44 [ [ -LRB- 40436 627 45 Footnote footnote NN 40436 627 46 8 8 CD 40436 627 47 : : : 40436 627 48 Plato Plato NNP 40436 627 49 , , , 40436 627 50 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 627 51 . . . 40436 628 1 i. i. NNP 40436 629 1 114 114 CD 40436 629 2 B B NNP 40436 629 3 - - HYPH 40436 629 4 C. C. NNP 40436 630 1 This this DT 40436 630 2 same same JJ 40436 630 3 argument argument NN 40436 630 4 is be VBZ 40436 630 5 addressed address VBN 40436 630 6 by by IN 40436 630 7 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 630 8 to to IN 40436 630 9 Glaukon Glaukon NNP 40436 630 10 , , , 40436 630 11 in in IN 40436 630 12 Xenoph Xenoph NNP 40436 630 13 . . . 40436 631 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 631 2 . . . 40436 632 1 iii iii NNP 40436 632 2 . . . 40436 633 1 6 6 CD 40436 633 2 , , , 40436 633 3 14 14 CD 40436 633 4 - - SYM 40436 633 5 15 15 CD 40436 633 6 . . . 40436 633 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 634 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 634 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 634 3 9 9 CD 40436 634 4 : : : 40436 634 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 634 6 , , , 40436 634 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 634 8 . . . 40436 635 1 i. i. NNP 40436 636 1 114 114 CD 40436 636 2 E. E. NNP 40436 636 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 636 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 636 5 : : : 40436 636 6 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 636 7 = = SYM 40436 636 8 n n CC 40436 636 9 ei ei NNP 40436 636 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 636 11 le le NNP 40436 636 12 / / SYM 40436 636 13 geis geis NNP 40436 636 14 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 636 15 tau tau NNP 40436 636 16 = = SYM 40436 636 17 th th NNP 40436 636 18 ' ' '' 40436 636 19 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 636 20 e)/chei e)/chei NNP 40436 636 21 , , , 40436 636 22 ma ma NNP 40436 636 23 / / SYM 40436 636 24 list list NNP 40436 636 25 ' ' `` 40436 636 26 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 636 27 ei)/ês ei)/ês NNP 40436 636 28 pepeisme pepeisme NNP 40436 636 29 / / SYM 40436 636 30 nos nos NNP 40436 636 31 ? ? . 40436 636 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 636 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 637 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 637 2 Side side NN 40436 637 3 - - HYPH 40436 637 4 note note NN 40436 637 5 : : : 40436 637 6 Comment comment NN 40436 637 7 on on IN 40436 637 8 the the DT 40436 637 9 preceding precede VBG 40436 637 10 -- -- : 40436 637 11 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 637 12 method method NN 40436 637 13 -- -- : 40436 637 14 the the DT 40436 637 15 respondent respondent NN 40436 637 16 makes make VBZ 40436 637 17 the the DT 40436 637 18 discoveries discovery NNS 40436 637 19 for for IN 40436 637 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 637 21 . . . 40436 637 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 638 1 Such such JJ 40436 638 2 is be VBZ 40436 638 3 the the DT 40436 638 4 commencing commencing NN 40436 638 5 portion portion NN 40436 638 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 638 7 abbreviated abbreviate VBN 40436 638 8 or or CC 40436 638 9 abstracted abstract VBN 40436 638 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 638 11 of of IN 40436 638 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 638 13 's 's POS 40436 638 14 First First NNP 40436 638 15 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 638 16 . . . 40436 639 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 639 2 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 639 3 a a DT 40436 639 4 very very RB 40436 639 5 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 639 6 specimen speciman NNS 40436 639 7 of of IN 40436 639 8 the the DT 40436 639 9 Sokratico Sokratico NNP 40436 639 10 - - HYPH 40436 639 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 639 12 method method NN 40436 639 13 : : : 40436 639 14 both both DT 40436 639 15 in in IN 40436 639 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 639 17 negative negative JJ 40436 639 18 and and CC 40436 639 19 positive positive JJ 40436 639 20 aspect aspect NN 40436 639 21 . . . 40436 640 1 By by IN 40436 640 2 the the DT 40436 640 3 negative negative JJ 40436 640 4 , , , 40436 640 5 false false JJ 40436 640 6 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 640 7 of of IN 40436 640 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 640 9 is be VBZ 40436 640 10 exposed expose VBN 40436 640 11 . . . 40436 641 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 641 2 believes believe VBZ 40436 641 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 641 4 competent competent JJ 40436 641 5 to to TO 40436 641 6 advise advise VB 40436 641 7 about about IN 40436 641 8 just just JJ 40436 641 9 and and CC 40436 641 10 unjust unjust JJ 40436 641 11 , , , 40436 641 12 which which WDT 40436 641 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 641 14 has have VBZ 40436 641 15 neither neither CC 40436 641 16 learnt learn VBN 40436 641 17 from from IN 40436 641 18 any any DT 40436 641 19 teacher teacher NN 40436 641 20 nor nor CC 40436 641 21 investigated investigate VBN 40436 641 22 for for IN 40436 641 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 641 24 -- -- : 40436 641 25 which which WDT 40436 641 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 641 27 has have VBZ 40436 641 28 picked pick VBN 40436 641 29 up up RP 40436 641 30 from from IN 40436 641 31 the the DT 40436 641 32 multitude multitude NN 40436 641 33 , , , 40436 641 34 and and CC 40436 641 35 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 641 36 to to TO 40436 641 37 be be VB 40436 641 38 clear clear JJ 40436 641 39 to to IN 40436 641 40 every every DT 40436 641 41 one one CD 40436 641 42 , , , 40436 641 43 but but CC 40436 641 44 about about IN 40436 641 45 which which WDT 40436 641 46 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 641 47 there there EX 40436 641 48 is be VBZ 40436 641 49 so so RB 40436 641 50 much much JJ 40436 641 51 difference difference NN 40436 641 52 of of IN 40436 641 53 appreciation appreciation NN 40436 641 54 among among IN 40436 641 55 the the DT 40436 641 56 multitude multitude NN 40436 641 57 , , , 40436 641 58 that that DT 40436 641 59 fierce fierce JJ 40436 641 60 and and CC 40436 641 61 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 641 62 quarrels quarrel NNS 40436 641 63 are be VBP 40436 641 64 going go VBG 40436 641 65 on on RP 40436 641 66 . . . 40436 642 1 On on IN 40436 642 2 the the DT 40436 642 3 positive positive JJ 40436 642 4 side side NN 40436 642 5 , , , 40436 642 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 642 7 restricts restrict VBZ 40436 642 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 642 9 to to IN 40436 642 10 the the DT 40436 642 11 function function NN 40436 642 12 of of IN 40436 642 13 questioning question VBG 40436 642 14 : : : 40436 642 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 642 16 neither neither CC 40436 642 17 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 642 18 nor nor CC 40436 642 19 denies deny VBZ 40436 642 20 any any DT 40436 642 21 thing thing NN 40436 642 22 . . . 40436 643 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 643 2 is be VBZ 40436 643 3 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 643 4 who who WP 40436 643 5 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 643 6 or or CC 40436 643 7 denies deny VBZ 40436 643 8 every every DT 40436 643 9 thing thing NN 40436 643 10 , , , 40436 643 11 and and CC 40436 643 12 who who WP 40436 643 13 makes make VBZ 40436 643 14 all all PDT 40436 643 15 the the DT 40436 643 16 discoveries discovery NNS 40436 643 17 for for IN 40436 643 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 643 19 out out IN 40436 643 20 of of IN 40436 643 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 643 22 own own JJ 40436 643 23 mind mind NN 40436 643 24 , , , 40436 643 25 instigated instigate VBN 40436 643 26 indeed indeed RB 40436 643 27 , , , 40436 643 28 but but CC 40436 643 29 not not RB 40436 643 30 taught teach VBN 40436 643 31 , , , 40436 643 32 by by IN 40436 643 33 the the DT 40436 643 34 questions question NNS 40436 643 35 of of IN 40436 643 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 643 37 companion companion NN 40436 643 38 . . . 40436 644 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 644 2 Side side NN 40436 644 3 - - HYPH 40436 644 4 note note NN 40436 644 5 : : : 40436 644 6 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 644 7 is be VBZ 40436 644 8 brought bring VBN 40436 644 9 to to TO 40436 644 10 admit admit VB 40436 644 11 that that IN 40436 644 12 whatever whatever WDT 40436 644 13 is be VBZ 40436 644 14 just just RB 40436 644 15 , , , 40436 644 16 is be VBZ 40436 644 17 good good JJ 40436 644 18 , , , 40436 644 19 honourable honourable JJ 40436 644 20 , , , 40436 644 21 expedient expedient NN 40436 644 22 : : : 40436 644 23 and and CC 40436 644 24 that that IN 40436 644 25 whoever whoever WP 40436 644 26 acts act VBZ 40436 644 27 honourably honourably RB 40436 644 28 , , , 40436 644 29 both both DT 40436 644 30 does do VBZ 40436 644 31 well well RB 40436 644 32 , , , 40436 644 33 and and CC 40436 644 34 procures procure NNS 40436 644 35 for for IN 40436 644 36 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 644 37 happiness happiness NN 40436 644 38 thereby thereby RB 40436 644 39 . . . 40436 645 1 Equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 645 2 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 645 3 of of IN 40436 645 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 645 5 . . . 40436 645 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 646 1 By by IN 40436 646 2 a a DT 40436 646 3 farther farther JJ 40436 646 4 series series NN 40436 646 5 of of IN 40436 646 6 questions question NNS 40436 646 7 , , , 40436 646 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 646 9 next next JJ 40436 646 10 brings bring VBZ 40436 646 11 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 646 12 to to IN 40436 646 13 the the DT 40436 646 14 admission admission NN 40436 646 15 that that IN 40436 646 16 what what WP 40436 646 17 is be VBZ 40436 646 18 just just RB 40436 646 19 , , , 40436 646 20 is be VBZ 40436 646 21 also also RB 40436 646 22 honourable honourable JJ 40436 646 23 , , , 40436 646 24 good good JJ 40436 646 25 , , , 40436 646 26 expedient expedient NN 40436 646 27 -- -- : 40436 646 28 what what WP 40436 646 29 is be VBZ 40436 646 30 unjust unjust JJ 40436 646 31 , , , 40436 646 32 is be VBZ 40436 646 33 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 646 34 , , , 40436 646 35 evil evil JJ 40436 646 36 , , , 40436 646 37 inexpedient inexpedient JJ 40436 646 38 : : : 40436 646 39 and and CC 40436 646 40 that that IN 40436 646 41 whoever whoever WP 40436 646 42 acts act VBZ 40436 646 43 justly justly RB 40436 646 44 , , , 40436 646 45 and and CC 40436 646 46 honourably honourably RB 40436 646 47 , , , 40436 646 48 thereby thereby RB 40436 646 49 acquires acquire VBZ 40436 646 50 happiness happiness NN 40436 646 51 . . . 40436 647 1 Admitting admit VBG 40436 647 2 , , , 40436 647 3 first first RB 40436 647 4 , , , 40436 647 5 that that IN 40436 647 6 an an DT 40436 647 7 act act NN 40436 647 8 which which WDT 40436 647 9 is be VBZ 40436 647 10 good good JJ 40436 647 11 , , , 40436 647 12 honourable honourable JJ 40436 647 13 , , , 40436 647 14 just just RB 40436 647 15 , , , 40436 647 16 expedient expedient NN 40436 647 17 , , , 40436 647 18 & & CC 40436 647 19 c. c. NNP 40436 647 20 , , , 40436 647 21 considered consider VBN 40436 647 22 in in IN 40436 647 23 one one CD 40436 647 24 aspect aspect NN 40436 647 25 or or CC 40436 647 26 in in IN 40436 647 27 reference reference NN 40436 647 28 to to IN 40436 647 29 some some DT 40436 647 30 of of IN 40436 647 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 647 32 conditions condition NNS 40436 647 33 -- -- : 40436 647 34 may may MD 40436 647 35 be be VB 40436 647 36 at at IN 40436 647 37 the the DT 40436 647 38 same same JJ 40436 647 39 time time NN 40436 647 40 bad bad JJ 40436 647 41 , , , 40436 647 42 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 647 43 , , , 40436 647 44 unjust unjust JJ 40436 647 45 , , , 40436 647 46 considered consider VBN 40436 647 47 in in IN 40436 647 48 another another DT 40436 647 49 aspect aspect NN 40436 647 50 or or CC 40436 647 51 in in IN 40436 647 52 reference reference NN 40436 647 53 to to IN 40436 647 54 other other JJ 40436 647 55 conditions condition NNS 40436 647 56 ; ; : 40436 647 57 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 647 58 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 647 59 brings bring VBZ 40436 647 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 647 61 respondent respondent NN 40436 647 62 to to TO 40436 647 63 admit admit VB 40436 647 64 , , , 40436 647 65 that that IN 40436 647 66 every every DT 40436 647 67 act act NN 40436 647 68 , , , 40436 647 69 _ _ NNP 40436 647 70 in in IN 40436 647 71 so so RB 40436 647 72 far far RB 40436 647 73 as as IN 40436 647 74 it -PRON- PRP 40436 647 75 is be VBZ 40436 647 76 just just RB 40436 647 77 and and CC 40436 647 78 honourable honourable JJ 40436 647 79 _ _ NNP 40436 647 80 , , , 40436 647 81 is be VBZ 40436 647 82 also also RB 40436 647 83 good good JJ 40436 647 84 and and CC 40436 647 85 expedient expedient JJ 40436 647 86 . . . 40436 648 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 648 2 10 10 CD 40436 648 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 648 4 And and CC 40436 648 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 648 6 contends contend VBZ 40436 648 7 farther far RBR 40436 648 8 , , , 40436 648 9 that that IN 40436 648 10 whoever whoever WP 40436 648 11 acts act VBZ 40436 648 12 honourably honourably RB 40436 648 13 , , , 40436 648 14 does do VBZ 40436 648 15 well well RB 40436 648 16 : : : 40436 648 17 now now RB 40436 648 18 every every DT 40436 648 19 man man NN 40436 648 20 who who WP 40436 648 21 does do VBZ 40436 648 22 well well RB 40436 648 23 , , , 40436 648 24 becomes become VBZ 40436 648 25 happy happy JJ 40436 648 26 , , , 40436 648 27 or or CC 40436 648 28 secures secure VBZ 40436 648 29 good good JJ 40436 648 30 things thing NNS 40436 648 31 thereby thereby RB 40436 648 32 : : : 40436 648 33 therefore therefore RB 40436 648 34 the the DT 40436 648 35 just just RB 40436 648 36 , , , 40436 648 37 the the DT 40436 648 38 honourable honourable JJ 40436 648 39 , , , 40436 648 40 and and CC 40436 648 41 the the DT 40436 648 42 good good JJ 40436 648 43 or or CC 40436 648 44 expedient expedient NN 40436 648 45 , , , 40436 648 46 coincide coincide VB 40436 648 47 . . . 40436 649 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 649 2 11 11 CD 40436 649 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 649 4 The the DT 40436 649 5 argument argument NN 40436 649 6 , , , 40436 649 7 whereby whereby WRB 40436 649 8 this this DT 40436 649 9 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 649 10 is be VBZ 40436 649 11 here here RB 40436 649 12 established establish VBN 40436 649 13 , , , 40436 649 14 is be VBZ 40436 649 15 pointed point VBN 40436 649 16 out out RP 40436 649 17 by by IN 40436 649 18 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 649 19 , , , 40436 649 20 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 649 21 , , , 40436 649 22 and and CC 40436 649 23 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 649 24 , , , 40436 649 25 as as IN 40436 649 26 not not RB 40436 649 27 merely merely RB 40436 649 28 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 40436 649 29 , , , 40436 649 30 but but CC 40436 649 31 as as IN 40436 649 32 mere mere JJ 40436 649 33 verbal verbal JJ 40436 649 34 equivocation equivocation NN 40436 649 35 and and CC 40436 649 36 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 649 37 -- -- : 40436 649 38 the the DT 40436 649 39 like like IN 40436 649 40 of of IN 40436 649 41 which which WDT 40436 649 42 , , , 40436 649 43 however however RB 40436 649 44 , , , 40436 649 45 we -PRON- PRP 40436 649 46 find find VBP 40436 649 47 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 649 48 in in IN 40436 649 49 Plato Plato NNP 40436 649 50 . . . 40436 650 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 650 2 12 12 CD 40436 650 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 650 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 650 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 650 6 10 10 CD 40436 650 7 : : : 40436 650 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 650 9 , , , 40436 650 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 650 11 . . . 40436 651 1 i. i. NNP 40436 652 1 115 115 CD 40436 652 2 B--116 B--116 NNS 40436 652 3 A. a. NN 40436 653 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 653 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 653 3 : : : 40436 653 4 Ou)kou ou)kou ADD 40436 653 5 = = SYM 40436 653 6 n n CC 40436 653 7 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 653 8 toiau toiau NNP 40436 653 9 / / SYM 40436 653 10 tên tên NNP 40436 653 11 boêthei boêthei NNP 40436 653 12 / / , 40436 653 13 an an DT 40436 653 14 kalê\n kalê\n -LRB- 40436 653 15 me\n me\n NNP 40436 653 16 le le NNP 40436 653 17 / / SYM 40436 653 18 geis geis NN 40436 653 19 kata\ kata\ . 40436 653 20 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 653 21 e)pichei e)pichei NNP 40436 653 22 / / , 40436 653 23 rêsin rêsin NNP 40436 653 24 tou= tou= NNP 40436 653 25 sô sô NNP 40436 653 26 = = SYM 40436 653 27 sai sai FW 40436 653 28 ou(=s ou(=s UH 40436 653 29 e)/dei e)/dei NNP 40436 653 30 ; ; : 40436 653 31 tou tou NNP 40436 653 32 = = SYM 40436 653 33 to to IN 40436 653 34 d d NN 40436 653 35 ' ' POS 40436 653 36 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 653 37 a)ndri a)ndri , 40436 653 38 / / SYM 40436 653 39 a a DT 40436 653 40 ; ; : 40436 653 41 . . . 40436 654 1 . . . 40436 655 1 . . . 40436 656 1 . . . 40436 657 1 kakê\n kakê\n NNP 40436 657 2 de/ de/ NNP 40436 657 3 ge ge NNP 40436 657 4 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 657 5 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 657 6 thana thana NNP 40436 657 7 / / SYM 40436 657 8 tous tous JJ 40436 657 9 te te NNP 40436 657 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 657 11 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 657 12 e(/lkê e(/lkê NNP 40436 657 13 . . . 40436 658 1 . . . 40436 659 1 . . . 40436 660 1 . . . 40436 661 1 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 661 2 = = SYM 40436 661 3 n n CC 40436 661 4 ô(=de ô(=de NNP 40436 661 5 di di NNP 40436 661 6 / / SYM 40436 661 7 kaion kaion NNP 40436 661 8 prosagoreu prosagoreu NN 40436 661 9 / / SYM 40436 661 10 ein ein NNP 40436 661 11 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 661 12 / / SYM 40436 661 13 stên stên NNP 40436 661 14 tô tô NNP 40436 661 15 = = NFP 40436 661 16 n n NNP 40436 661 17 pra pra NNP 40436 661 18 / / SYM 40436 661 19 xeôn xeôn NNP 40436 661 20 ; ; : 40436 661 21 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 661 22 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 661 23 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 661 24 a)perga a)perga NNP 40436 661 25 / / SYM 40436 661 26 zetai zetai NNP 40436 661 27 kakê\n kakê\n NNP 40436 661 28 kalei kalei NNP 40436 661 29 = = SYM 40436 661 30 s s NNP 40436 661 31 , , , 40436 661 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 661 33 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 661 34 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 661 35 a)gathê\n a)gathê\n NNP 40436 661 36 klête klête NNP 40436 661 37 / / SYM 40436 661 38 on on RB 40436 661 39 . . . 40436 662 1 A)r A)r NNP 40436 662 2 ' ' '' 40436 662 3 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 662 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 662 5 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 662 6 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 662 7 kalo kalo NNP 40436 662 8 / / SYM 40436 662 9 n,--ê)=| n,--ê)=| NNP 40436 662 10 de\ de\ NNP 40436 662 11 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 662 12 ai)schro ai)schro NNP 40436 662 13 / / SYM 40436 662 14 n n JJ 40436 662 15 ? ? . 40436 663 1 Nai/. nai/. LS 40436 663 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 664 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 664 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 664 3 , , , 40436 664 4 Republic Republic NNP 40436 664 5 , , , 40436 664 6 v. v. CC 40436 664 7 p. p. NN 40436 664 8 479 479 CD 40436 664 9 , , , 40436 664 10 where where WRB 40436 664 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 664 12 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 664 13 that that IN 40436 664 14 in in IN 40436 664 15 every every DT 40436 664 16 particular particular JJ 40436 664 17 case case NN 40436 664 18 , , , 40436 664 19 what what WP 40436 664 20 is be VBZ 40436 664 21 just just RB 40436 664 22 , , , 40436 664 23 honourable honourable JJ 40436 664 24 , , , 40436 664 25 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 664 26 , , , 40436 664 27 & & CC 40436 664 28 c. c. NNP 40436 664 29 , , , 40436 664 30 is be VBZ 40436 664 31 also also RB 40436 664 32 unjust unjust JJ 40436 664 33 , , , 40436 664 34 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 664 35 , , , 40436 664 36 vicious vicious JJ 40436 664 37 , , , 40436 664 38 & & CC 40436 664 39 c. c. NNP 40436 664 40 Nothing Nothing NNP 40436 664 41 remains remain VBZ 40436 664 42 unchanged unchanged JJ 40436 664 43 , , , 40436 664 44 nor nor CC 40436 664 45 excludes exclude VBZ 40436 664 46 the the DT 40436 664 47 contrary contrary NN 40436 664 48 , , , 40436 664 49 except except IN 40436 664 50 the the DT 40436 664 51 pure pure JJ 40436 664 52 , , , 40436 664 53 self self NN 40436 664 54 - - HYPH 40436 664 55 existent existent NN 40436 664 56 , , , 40436 664 57 Idea Idea NNP 40436 664 58 or or CC 40436 664 59 general general JJ 40436 664 60 Concept.--[Greek concept.--[greek NN 40436 664 61 : : : 40436 664 62 au)to\-dikaiosu au)to\-dikaiosu NNP 40436 664 63 / / SYM 40436 664 64 nê nê NNP 40436 664 65 ] ] -RRB- 40436 664 66 , , , 40436 664 67 & & CC 40436 664 68 c. c. NNP 40436 664 69 ] ] -RRB- 40436 664 70 [ [ -LRB- 40436 664 71 Footnote footnote NN 40436 664 72 11 11 CD 40436 664 73 : : : 40436 664 74 Plato Plato NNP 40436 664 75 , , , 40436 664 76 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 664 77 . . . 40436 665 1 i. i. NNP 40436 666 1 116 116 CD 40436 666 2 E. E. NNP 40436 666 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 666 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 666 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 666 6 12 12 CD 40436 666 7 : : : 40436 666 8 The the DT 40436 666 9 words word NNS 40436 666 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 666 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 666 12 : : : 40436 666 13 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 666 14 pra pra NNP 40436 666 15 / / SYM 40436 666 16 ttein ttein NN 40436 666 17 -- -- : 40436 666 18 eu)pragi eu)pragi . 40436 666 19 / / SYM 40436 666 20 a a LS 40436 666 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 666 22 have have VB 40436 666 23 a a DT 40436 666 24 double double JJ 40436 666 25 sense sense NN 40436 666 26 , , , 40436 666 27 like like IN 40436 666 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 666 29 " " `` 40436 666 30 doing do VBG 40436 666 31 well well RB 40436 666 32 " " '' 40436 666 33 . . . 40436 667 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 667 2 , , , 40436 667 3 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 667 4 . . . 40436 668 1 p. p. NN 40436 668 2 175 175 CD 40436 668 3 ; ; : 40436 668 4 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 668 5 , , , 40436 668 6 Einl Einl NNP 40436 668 7 . . . 40436 669 1 p. p. NN 40436 669 2 149 149 CD 40436 669 3 . . . 40436 670 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 670 2 have have VBP 40436 670 3 , , , 40436 670 4 p. p. NN 40436 670 5 116 116 CD 40436 670 6 B b NN 40436 670 7 , , , 40436 670 8 the the DT 40436 670 9 equivocation equivocation NN 40436 670 10 between between IN 40436 670 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 670 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 670 13 : : : 40436 670 14 kalô kalô NNP 40436 670 15 = = SYM 40436 670 16 s s NNP 40436 670 17 pra pra NNP 40436 670 18 / / SYM 40436 670 19 ttein ttein NN 40436 670 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 670 21 and and CC 40436 670 22 [ [ -LRB- 40436 670 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 670 24 : : : 40436 670 25 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 670 26 pra pra NNP 40436 670 27 / / SYM 40436 670 28 ttein ttein NNP 40436 670 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 670 30 , , , 40436 670 31 also also RB 40436 670 32 with with IN 40436 670 33 [ [ -LRB- 40436 670 34 Greek Greek NNP 40436 670 35 : : : 40436 670 36 kakô kakô NNP 40436 670 37 = = SYM 40436 670 38 s s NNP 40436 670 39 pra pra NNP 40436 670 40 / / SYM 40436 670 41 ttein ttein NNP 40436 670 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 670 43 , , , 40436 670 44 p. p. NN 40436 670 45 134 134 CD 40436 670 46 A a NN 40436 670 47 , , , 40436 670 48 135 135 CD 40436 670 49 A a NN 40436 670 50 ; ; : 40436 670 51 compare compare VB 40436 670 52 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 670 53 ad ad NN 40436 670 54 Platon Platon NNP 40436 670 55 . . . 40436 671 1 Charmid Charmid NNP 40436 671 2 . . . 40436 672 1 p. p. NN 40436 672 2 172 172 CD 40436 672 3 A a NN 40436 672 4 , , , 40436 672 5 p. p. NN 40436 672 6 174 174 CD 40436 672 7 B b NN 40436 672 8 ; ; : 40436 672 9 also also RB 40436 672 10 Platon Platon NNP 40436 672 11 . . . 40436 673 1 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 673 2 , , , 40436 673 3 p. p. NN 40436 673 4 507 507 CD 40436 673 5 C C NNP 40436 673 6 , , , 40436 673 7 where where WRB 40436 673 8 similar similar JJ 40436 673 9 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 673 10 meanings meaning NNS 40436 673 11 occur occur VBP 40436 673 12 . . . 40436 673 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 674 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 674 2 Side side NN 40436 674 3 - - HYPH 40436 674 4 note note NN 40436 674 5 : : : 40436 674 6 Humiliation humiliation NN 40436 674 7 of of IN 40436 674 8 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 674 9 . . . 40436 675 1 Other other JJ 40436 675 2 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 675 3 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 675 4 are be VBP 40436 675 5 equally equally RB 40436 675 6 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 675 7 . . . 40436 676 1 But but CC 40436 676 2 the the DT 40436 676 3 real real JJ 40436 676 4 opponents opponent NNS 40436 676 5 , , , 40436 676 6 against against IN 40436 676 7 whom whom WP 40436 676 8 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 676 9 is be VBZ 40436 676 10 to to TO 40436 676 11 measure measure VB 40436 676 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 676 13 , , , 40436 676 14 are be VBP 40436 676 15 , , , 40436 676 16 the the DT 40436 676 17 kings king NNS 40436 676 18 of of IN 40436 676 19 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 676 20 and and CC 40436 676 21 Persia Persia NNP 40436 676 22 . . . 40436 677 1 Eulogistic eulogistic JJ 40436 677 2 description description NN 40436 677 3 of of IN 40436 677 4 those those DT 40436 677 5 kings king NNS 40436 677 6 . . . 40436 678 1 To to TO 40436 678 2 match match VB 40436 678 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 678 4 , , , 40436 678 5 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 678 6 must must MD 40436 678 7 make make VB 40436 678 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 678 9 as as RB 40436 678 10 good good JJ 40436 678 11 as as IN 40436 678 12 possible possible JJ 40436 678 13 . . . 40436 678 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 679 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 679 2 is be VBZ 40436 679 3 thus thus RB 40436 679 4 reduced reduce VBN 40436 679 5 to to IN 40436 679 6 a a DT 40436 679 7 state state NN 40436 679 8 of of IN 40436 679 9 humiliating humiliating JJ 40436 679 10 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 679 11 , , , 40436 679 12 and and CC 40436 679 13 stands stand VBZ 40436 679 14 convicted convict VBN 40436 679 15 , , , 40436 679 16 by by IN 40436 679 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 679 18 own own JJ 40436 679 19 contradictions contradiction NNS 40436 679 20 and and CC 40436 679 21 confession confession NN 40436 679 22 , , , 40436 679 23 of of IN 40436 679 24 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 679 25 in in IN 40436 679 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 679 27 worst bad JJS 40436 679 28 form form NN 40436 679 29 : : : 40436 679 30 that that RB 40436 679 31 is is RB 40436 679 32 , , , 40436 679 33 of of IN 40436 679 34 being be VBG 40436 679 35 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 679 36 , , , 40436 679 37 and and CC 40436 679 38 yet yet RB 40436 679 39 believing believe VBG 40436 679 40 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 679 41 to to TO 40436 679 42 know know VB 40436 679 43 . . . 40436 680 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 680 2 13 13 CD 40436 680 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 680 4 But but CC 40436 680 5 other other JJ 40436 680 6 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 680 7 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 680 8 are be VBP 40436 680 9 no no RB 40436 680 10 wiser wise JJR 40436 680 11 . . . 40436 681 1 Even even RB 40436 681 2 Perikles Perikles NNP 40436 681 3 is be VBZ 40436 681 4 proved prove VBN 40436 681 5 to to TO 40436 681 6 be be VB 40436 681 7 equally equally RB 40436 681 8 deficient deficient JJ 40436 681 9 -- -- : 40436 681 10 by by IN 40436 681 11 the the DT 40436 681 12 fact fact NN 40436 681 13 that that IN 40436 681 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 681 15 has have VBZ 40436 681 16 never never RB 40436 681 17 been be VBN 40436 681 18 able able JJ 40436 681 19 to to TO 40436 681 20 teach teach VB 40436 681 21 or or CC 40436 681 22 improve improve VB 40436 681 23 any any DT 40436 681 24 one one NN 40436 681 25 else else RB 40436 681 26 , , , 40436 681 27 not not RB 40436 681 28 even even RB 40436 681 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 681 30 own own JJ 40436 681 31 sons son NNS 40436 681 32 and and CC 40436 681 33 those those DT 40436 681 34 whom whom WP 40436 681 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 681 36 loved love VBD 40436 681 37 best well RBS 40436 681 38 . . . 40436 682 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 682 2 14 14 CD 40436 682 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 682 4 " " `` 40436 682 5 At at IN 40436 682 6 any any DT 40436 682 7 rate rate NN 40436 682 8 " " '' 40436 682 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 682 10 contends contend VBZ 40436 682 11 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 682 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 682 13 " " `` 40436 682 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 682 15 am be VBP 40436 682 16 as as RB 40436 682 17 good good JJ 40436 682 18 as as IN 40436 682 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 682 20 competitors competitor NNS 40436 682 21 , , , 40436 682 22 and and CC 40436 682 23 can can MD 40436 682 24 hold hold VB 40436 682 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 682 26 ground ground NN 40436 682 27 against against IN 40436 682 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 682 29 . . . 40436 682 30 " " '' 40436 683 1 But but CC 40436 683 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 683 3 reminds remind VBZ 40436 683 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 683 5 that that IN 40436 683 6 the the DT 40436 683 7 real real JJ 40436 683 8 competitors competitor NNS 40436 683 9 with with IN 40436 683 10 whom whom WP 40436 683 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 683 12 ought ought MD 40436 683 13 to to TO 40436 683 14 compare compare VB 40436 683 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 683 16 , , , 40436 683 17 are be VBP 40436 683 18 foreigners foreigner NNS 40436 683 19 , , , 40436 683 20 liable liable JJ 40436 683 21 to to TO 40436 683 22 become become VB 40436 683 23 the the DT 40436 683 24 enemies enemy NNS 40436 683 25 of of IN 40436 683 26 Athens Athens NNP 40436 683 27 , , , 40436 683 28 and and CC 40436 683 29 against against IN 40436 683 30 whom whom WP 40436 683 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 683 32 , , , 40436 683 33 if if IN 40436 683 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 683 35 pretends pretend VBZ 40436 683 36 to to TO 40436 683 37 lead lead VB 40436 683 38 Athens Athens NNP 40436 683 39 , , , 40436 683 40 must must MD 40436 683 41 be be VB 40436 683 42 able able JJ 40436 683 43 to to TO 40436 683 44 contend contend VB 40436 683 45 . . . 40436 684 1 In in IN 40436 684 2 an an DT 40436 684 3 harangue harangue NN 40436 684 4 of of IN 40436 684 5 unusual unusual JJ 40436 684 6 length length NN 40436 684 7 , , , 40436 684 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 684 9 shows show VBZ 40436 684 10 that that IN 40436 684 11 the the DT 40436 684 12 kings king NNS 40436 684 13 of of IN 40436 684 14 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 684 15 and and CC 40436 684 16 Persia Persia NNP 40436 684 17 are be VBP 40436 684 18 of of IN 40436 684 19 nobler nobler NN 40436 684 20 breed breed NN 40436 684 21 , , , 40436 684 22 as as RB 40436 684 23 well well RB 40436 684 24 as as IN 40436 684 25 more more RBR 40436 684 26 highly highly RB 40436 684 27 and and CC 40436 684 28 carefully carefully RB 40436 684 29 trained train VBN 40436 684 30 , , , 40436 684 31 than than IN 40436 684 32 the the DT 40436 684 33 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 684 34 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 684 35 . . . 40436 685 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 685 2 15 15 CD 40436 685 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 685 4 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 685 5 must must MD 40436 685 6 be be VB 40436 685 7 rescued rescue VBN 40436 685 8 from from IN 40436 685 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 685 10 present present JJ 40436 685 11 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 685 12 , , , 40436 685 13 and and CC 40436 685 14 exalted exalted JJ 40436 685 15 , , , 40436 685 16 so so IN 40436 685 17 as as IN 40436 685 18 to to TO 40436 685 19 be be VB 40436 685 20 capable capable JJ 40436 685 21 of of IN 40436 685 22 competing compete VBG 40436 685 23 with with IN 40436 685 24 these these DT 40436 685 25 kings king NNS 40436 685 26 : : : 40436 685 27 which which WDT 40436 685 28 object object NN 40436 685 29 can can MD 40436 685 30 not not RB 40436 685 31 be be VB 40436 685 32 attained attain VBN 40436 685 33 except except IN 40436 685 34 through through IN 40436 685 35 the the DT 40436 685 36 auxiliary auxiliary JJ 40436 685 37 interposition interposition NN 40436 685 38 of of IN 40436 685 39 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 685 40 . . . 40436 686 1 Not not RB 40436 686 2 that that IN 40436 686 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 686 4 professes profess VBZ 40436 686 5 to to TO 40436 686 6 be be VB 40436 686 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 686 8 already already RB 40436 686 9 on on IN 40436 686 10 this this DT 40436 686 11 elevation elevation NN 40436 686 12 , , , 40436 686 13 and and CC 40436 686 14 to to TO 40436 686 15 stand stand VB 40436 686 16 in in IN 40436 686 17 need need NN 40436 686 18 of of IN 40436 686 19 no no DT 40436 686 20 farther farther JJ 40436 686 21 improvement improvement NN 40436 686 22 . . . 40436 687 1 But but CC 40436 687 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 687 3 can can MD 40436 687 4 , , , 40436 687 5 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 687 6 , , , 40436 687 7 help help VB 40436 687 8 others other NNS 40436 687 9 to to TO 40436 687 10 attain attain VB 40436 687 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 687 12 for for IN 40436 687 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 687 14 , , , 40436 687 15 through through IN 40436 687 16 the the DT 40436 687 17 discipline discipline NN 40436 687 18 and and CC 40436 687 19 stimulus stimulus NN 40436 687 20 of of IN 40436 687 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 687 22 interrogatories interrogatory NNS 40436 687 23 . . . 40436 688 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 688 2 16 16 CD 40436 688 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 688 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 688 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 688 6 13 13 CD 40436 688 7 : : : 40436 688 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 688 9 , , , 40436 688 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 688 11 . . . 40436 689 1 i. i. NNP 40436 689 2 p. p. NNP 40436 690 1 118 118 CD 40436 690 2 . . . 40436 690 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 691 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 691 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 691 3 14 14 CD 40436 691 4 : : : 40436 691 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 691 6 , , , 40436 691 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 691 8 . . . 40436 692 1 i. i. NNP 40436 692 2 p. p. NNP 40436 693 1 118 118 CD 40436 693 2 - - SYM 40436 693 3 119 119 CD 40436 693 4 . . . 40436 693 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 694 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 694 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 694 3 15 15 CD 40436 694 4 : : : 40436 694 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 694 6 , , , 40436 694 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 694 8 . . . 40436 695 1 i. i. NNP 40436 695 2 p. p. NNP 40436 696 1 120 120 CD 40436 696 2 - - SYM 40436 696 3 124 124 CD 40436 696 4 . . . 40436 696 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 697 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 697 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 697 3 16 16 CD 40436 697 4 : : : 40436 697 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 697 6 , , , 40436 697 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 697 8 . . . 40436 698 1 i. i. NNP 40436 698 2 p. p. NNP 40436 699 1 124 124 CD 40436 699 2 . . . 40436 699 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 700 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 700 2 Side side NN 40436 700 3 - - HYPH 40436 700 4 note note NN 40436 700 5 : : : 40436 700 6 But but CC 40436 700 7 good good JJ 40436 700 8 -- -- : 40436 700 9 for for IN 40436 700 10 what what WDT 40436 700 11 end end NN 40436 700 12 , , , 40436 700 13 and and CC 40436 700 14 under under IN 40436 700 15 what what WDT 40436 700 16 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 700 17 ? ? . 40436 701 1 Abundant abundant JJ 40436 701 2 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 701 3 examples example NNS 40436 701 4 . . . 40436 701 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 702 1 The the DT 40436 702 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 702 3 then then RB 40436 702 4 continues continue VBZ 40436 702 5 . . . 40436 703 1 _ _ NNP 40436 703 2 Sokr._--We Sokr._--We NNP 40436 703 3 wish wish VBP 40436 703 4 to to TO 40436 703 5 become become VB 40436 703 6 as as RB 40436 703 7 good good JJ 40436 703 8 as as IN 40436 703 9 possible possible JJ 40436 703 10 . . . 40436 704 1 But but CC 40436 704 2 in in IN 40436 704 3 what what WP 40436 704 4 sort sort NN 40436 704 5 of of IN 40436 704 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 704 7 ? ? . 40436 705 1 _ _ NNP 40436 705 2 Alk._--In Alk._--In NNP 40436 705 3 that that DT 40436 705 4 virtue virtue NN 40436 705 5 which which WDT 40436 705 6 belongs belong VBZ 40436 705 7 to to IN 40436 705 8 good good JJ 40436 705 9 men man NNS 40436 705 10 . . . 40436 706 1 _ _ NNP 40436 706 2 Sokr._--Yes Sokr._--Yes NNP 40436 706 3 , , , 40436 706 4 but but CC 40436 706 5 _ _ NNP 40436 706 6 good good JJ 40436 706 7 _ _ NNP 40436 706 8 , , , 40436 706 9 in in IN 40436 706 10 what what WP 40436 706 11 matters matter NNS 40436 706 12 ? ? . 40436 707 1 _ _ NNP 40436 707 2 Alk._--Evidently alk._--evidently RB 40436 707 3 , , , 40436 707 4 to to IN 40436 707 5 men man NNS 40436 707 6 who who WP 40436 707 7 are be VBP 40436 707 8 good good JJ 40436 707 9 in in IN 40436 707 10 transacting transact VBG 40436 707 11 business business NN 40436 707 12 . . . 40436 708 1 _ _ NNP 40436 708 2 Sokr._--Ay Sokr._--Ay NNS 40436 708 3 , , , 40436 708 4 but but CC 40436 708 5 what what WP 40436 708 6 kind kind NN 40436 708 7 of of IN 40436 708 8 business business NN 40436 708 9 ? ? . 40436 709 1 business business NN 40436 709 2 relating relate VBG 40436 709 3 to to IN 40436 709 4 horses horse NNS 40436 709 5 , , , 40436 709 6 or or CC 40436 709 7 to to IN 40436 709 8 navigation navigation NN 40436 709 9 ? ? . 40436 710 1 If if IN 40436 710 2 that that DT 40436 710 3 be be VB 40436 710 4 meant mean VBN 40436 710 5 , , , 40436 710 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 710 7 must must MD 40436 710 8 go go VB 40436 710 9 and and CC 40436 710 10 consult consult VB 40436 710 11 horse horse NN 40436 710 12 - - HYPH 40436 710 13 trainers trainer NNS 40436 710 14 or or CC 40436 710 15 mariners mariner NNS 40436 710 16 ? ? . 40436 711 1 _ _ NNP 40436 711 2 Alk._--No Alk._--No NNP 40436 711 3 , , , 40436 711 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 711 5 mean mean VBP 40436 711 6 such such JJ 40436 711 7 business business NN 40436 711 8 as as IN 40436 711 9 is be VBZ 40436 711 10 transacted transact VBN 40436 711 11 by by IN 40436 711 12 the the DT 40436 711 13 most most RBS 40436 711 14 esteemed esteemed JJ 40436 711 15 leaders leader NNS 40436 711 16 in in IN 40436 711 17 Athens Athens NNP 40436 711 18 . . . 40436 712 1 _ _ NNP 40436 712 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 712 3 mean mean VBP 40436 712 4 the the DT 40436 712 5 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 712 6 men man NNS 40436 712 7 . . . 40436 713 1 Every every DT 40436 713 2 man man NN 40436 713 3 is be VBZ 40436 713 4 good good JJ 40436 713 5 , , , 40436 713 6 in in IN 40436 713 7 reference reference NN 40436 713 8 to to IN 40436 713 9 that that DT 40436 713 10 which which WDT 40436 713 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 713 12 understands understand VBZ 40436 713 13 : : : 40436 713 14 every every DT 40436 713 15 man man NN 40436 713 16 is be VBZ 40436 713 17 bad bad JJ 40436 713 18 , , , 40436 713 19 in in IN 40436 713 20 reference reference NN 40436 713 21 to to IN 40436 713 22 that that DT 40436 713 23 which which WDT 40436 713 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 713 25 does do VBZ 40436 713 26 not not RB 40436 713 27 understand understand VB 40436 713 28 . . . 40436 714 1 _ _ NNP 40436 714 2 Alk._--Of Alk._--Of NNP 40436 714 3 course course NN 40436 714 4 . . . 40436 715 1 _ _ NNP 40436 715 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 715 3 cobbler cobbler NN 40436 715 4 understands understand VBZ 40436 715 5 shoemaking shoemaking NN 40436 715 6 , , , 40436 715 7 and and CC 40436 715 8 is be VBZ 40436 715 9 therefore therefore RB 40436 715 10 good good JJ 40436 715 11 at at IN 40436 715 12 _ _ NNP 40436 715 13 that that IN 40436 715 14 _ _ NNP 40436 715 15 : : : 40436 715 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 715 17 does do VBZ 40436 715 18 not not RB 40436 715 19 understand understand VB 40436 715 20 weaving weaving NN 40436 715 21 , , , 40436 715 22 and and CC 40436 715 23 is be VBZ 40436 715 24 therefore therefore RB 40436 715 25 bad bad JJ 40436 715 26 at at IN 40436 715 27 that that DT 40436 715 28 . . . 40436 716 1 The the DT 40436 716 2 same same JJ 40436 716 3 man man NN 40436 716 4 thus thus RB 40436 716 5 , , , 40436 716 6 in in IN 40436 716 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 716 8 view view NN 40436 716 9 , , , 40436 716 10 will will MD 40436 716 11 be be VB 40436 716 12 both both CC 40436 716 13 good good JJ 40436 716 14 and and CC 40436 716 15 bad bad JJ 40436 716 16 ? ? . 40436 717 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 717 2 17 17 CD 40436 717 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 717 4 _ _ NNP 40436 717 5 Alk._--No Alk._--No NNP 40436 717 6 : : : 40436 717 7 that that DT 40436 717 8 can can MD 40436 717 9 not not RB 40436 717 10 be be VB 40436 717 11 . . . 40436 718 1 _ _ NNP 40436 718 2 Sokr._--Whom Sokr._--Whom NNP 40436 718 3 then then RB 40436 718 4 do do VBP 40436 718 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 718 6 mean mean VB 40436 718 7 , , , 40436 718 8 when when WRB 40436 718 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 718 10 talk talk VBP 40436 718 11 of of IN 40436 718 12 _ _ NNP 40436 718 13 the the DT 40436 718 14 good good JJ 40436 718 15 _ _ NN 40436 718 16 ? ? . 40436 719 1 _ _ NNP 40436 719 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 719 3 mean mean VBP 40436 719 4 those those DT 40436 719 5 who who WP 40436 719 6 are be VBP 40436 719 7 competent competent JJ 40436 719 8 to to TO 40436 719 9 command command VB 40436 719 10 in in IN 40436 719 11 the the DT 40436 719 12 city city NN 40436 719 13 . . . 40436 720 1 _ _ NNP 40436 720 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 720 3 to to TO 40436 720 4 command command VB 40436 720 5 whom whom WP 40436 720 6 or or CC 40436 720 7 what what WP 40436 720 8 -- -- : 40436 720 9 horses horse NNS 40436 720 10 or or CC 40436 720 11 men man NNS 40436 720 12 ? ? . 40436 721 1 _ _ NNP 40436 721 2 Alk._--To Alk._--To NNP 40436 721 3 command command NN 40436 721 4 men man NNS 40436 721 5 . . . 40436 722 1 _ _ NNP 40436 722 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 722 3 what what WP 40436 722 4 men man NNS 40436 722 5 , , , 40436 722 6 and and CC 40436 722 7 under under IN 40436 722 8 what what WDT 40436 722 9 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 722 10 ? ? . 40436 723 1 sick sick JJ 40436 723 2 men man NNS 40436 723 3 , , , 40436 723 4 or or CC 40436 723 5 men man NNS 40436 723 6 on on IN 40436 723 7 shipboard shipboard NN 40436 723 8 , , , 40436 723 9 or or CC 40436 723 10 labourers labourer NNS 40436 723 11 engaged engage VBD 40436 723 12 in in IN 40436 723 13 harvesting harvesting NN 40436 723 14 , , , 40436 723 15 or or CC 40436 723 16 in in IN 40436 723 17 what what WP 40436 723 18 occupations occupation NNS 40436 723 19 ? ? . 40436 724 1 _ _ NNP 40436 724 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 724 3 mean mean NN 40436 724 4 , , , 40436 724 5 men man NNS 40436 724 6 living live VBG 40436 724 7 in in IN 40436 724 8 social social JJ 40436 724 9 and and CC 40436 724 10 commercial commercial JJ 40436 724 11 relation relation NN 40436 724 12 with with IN 40436 724 13 each each DT 40436 724 14 other other JJ 40436 724 15 , , , 40436 724 16 as as IN 40436 724 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 724 18 live live VBP 40436 724 19 here here RB 40436 724 20 ; ; : 40436 724 21 men man NNS 40436 724 22 who who WP 40436 724 23 live live VBP 40436 724 24 in in IN 40436 724 25 common common JJ 40436 724 26 possession possession NN 40436 724 27 of of IN 40436 724 28 the the DT 40436 724 29 same same JJ 40436 724 30 laws law NNS 40436 724 31 and and CC 40436 724 32 government government NN 40436 724 33 . . . 40436 725 1 _ _ NNP 40436 725 2 Sokr._--When Sokr._--When NNP 40436 725 3 men man NNS 40436 725 4 are be VBP 40436 725 5 in in IN 40436 725 6 communion communion NN 40436 725 7 of of IN 40436 725 8 a a DT 40436 725 9 sea sea NN 40436 725 10 voyage voyage NN 40436 725 11 and and CC 40436 725 12 of of IN 40436 725 13 the the DT 40436 725 14 same same JJ 40436 725 15 ship ship NN 40436 725 16 , , , 40436 725 17 how how WRB 40436 725 18 do do VBP 40436 725 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 725 20 name name VB 40436 725 21 the the DT 40436 725 22 art art NN 40436 725 23 of of IN 40436 725 24 commanding command VBG 40436 725 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 725 26 , , , 40436 725 27 and and CC 40436 725 28 to to IN 40436 725 29 what what WDT 40436 725 30 purpose purpose NN 40436 725 31 does do VBZ 40436 725 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 725 33 tend tend VB 40436 725 34 ? ? . 40436 726 1 _ _ NNP 40436 726 2 Alk._--It Alk._--It NNP 40436 726 3 is be VBZ 40436 726 4 the the DT 40436 726 5 art art NN 40436 726 6 of of IN 40436 726 7 the the DT 40436 726 8 pilot pilot NN 40436 726 9 ; ; : 40436 726 10 and and CC 40436 726 11 the the DT 40436 726 12 purpose purpose NN 40436 726 13 towards towards IN 40436 726 14 which which WDT 40436 726 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 726 16 tends tend VBZ 40436 726 17 , , , 40436 726 18 is be VBZ 40436 726 19 , , , 40436 726 20 bringing bring VBG 40436 726 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 726 22 safely safely RB 40436 726 23 through through IN 40436 726 24 the the DT 40436 726 25 dangers danger NNS 40436 726 26 of of IN 40436 726 27 the the DT 40436 726 28 sea sea NN 40436 726 29 . . . 40436 727 1 _ _ NNP 40436 727 2 Sokr._--When Sokr._--When NNP 40436 727 3 men man NNS 40436 727 4 are be VBP 40436 727 5 in in IN 40436 727 6 social social JJ 40436 727 7 and and CC 40436 727 8 political political JJ 40436 727 9 communion communion NN 40436 727 10 , , , 40436 727 11 to to IN 40436 727 12 what what WDT 40436 727 13 purpose purpose NN 40436 727 14 does do VBZ 40436 727 15 the the DT 40436 727 16 art art NN 40436 727 17 of of IN 40436 727 18 commanding command VBG 40436 727 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 727 20 tend tend VB 40436 727 21 ? ? . 40436 728 1 _ _ NNP 40436 728 2 Alk._--Towards Alk._--Towards , 40436 728 3 the the DT 40436 728 4 better well JJR 40436 728 5 preservation preservation NN 40436 728 6 and and CC 40436 728 7 administration administration NN 40436 728 8 of of IN 40436 728 9 the the DT 40436 728 10 city city NN 40436 728 11 . . . 40436 729 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 729 2 18 18 CD 40436 729 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 729 4 _ _ NNP 40436 729 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 729 6 what what WP 40436 729 7 do do VBP 40436 729 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 729 9 mean mean VB 40436 729 10 by by IN 40436 729 11 _ _ NNP 40436 729 12 better well RBR 40436 729 13 _ _ NNP 40436 729 14 ? ? . 40436 730 1 What what WP 40436 730 2 is be VBZ 40436 730 3 that that DT 40436 730 4 , , , 40436 730 5 the the DT 40436 730 6 presence presence NN 40436 730 7 or or CC 40436 730 8 absence absence NN 40436 730 9 of of IN 40436 730 10 which which WDT 40436 730 11 makes make VBZ 40436 730 12 _ _ NNP 40436 730 13 better well JJR 40436 730 14 _ _ NNP 40436 730 15 or or CC 40436 730 16 _ _ NNP 40436 730 17 worse bad JJR 40436 730 18 _ _ NNP 40436 730 19 ? ? . 40436 731 1 If if IN 40436 731 2 in in IN 40436 731 3 regard regard NN 40436 731 4 to to IN 40436 731 5 the the DT 40436 731 6 management management NN 40436 731 7 of of IN 40436 731 8 the the DT 40436 731 9 body body NN 40436 731 10 , , , 40436 731 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 731 12 put put VBP 40436 731 13 to to IN 40436 731 14 me -PRON- PRP 40436 731 15 the the DT 40436 731 16 same same JJ 40436 731 17 question question NN 40436 731 18 , , , 40436 731 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 731 20 should should MD 40436 731 21 reply reply VB 40436 731 22 , , , 40436 731 23 that that IN 40436 731 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 731 25 is be VBZ 40436 731 26 the the DT 40436 731 27 presence presence NN 40436 731 28 of of IN 40436 731 29 health health NN 40436 731 30 , , , 40436 731 31 and and CC 40436 731 32 the the DT 40436 731 33 absence absence NN 40436 731 34 of of IN 40436 731 35 disease disease NN 40436 731 36 . . . 40436 732 1 What what WDT 40436 732 2 reply reply NN 40436 732 3 will will MD 40436 732 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 732 5 make make VB 40436 732 6 , , , 40436 732 7 in in IN 40436 732 8 the the DT 40436 732 9 case case NN 40436 732 10 of of IN 40436 732 11 the the DT 40436 732 12 city city NN 40436 732 13 ? ? . 40436 733 1 _ _ NNP 40436 733 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 733 3 should should MD 40436 733 4 say say VB 40436 733 5 , , , 40436 733 6 when when WRB 40436 733 7 friendship friendship NN 40436 733 8 and and CC 40436 733 9 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 733 10 among among IN 40436 733 11 the the DT 40436 733 12 citizens citizen NNS 40436 733 13 are be VBP 40436 733 14 present present JJ 40436 733 15 , , , 40436 733 16 and and CC 40436 733 17 when when WRB 40436 733 18 discord discord NN 40436 733 19 and and CC 40436 733 20 antipathy antipathy NNP 40436 733 21 are be VBP 40436 733 22 absent absent JJ 40436 733 23 . . . 40436 734 1 _ _ NNP 40436 734 2 Sokr._--This Sokr._--This NNP 40436 734 3 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 734 4 , , , 40436 734 5 of of IN 40436 734 6 what what WP 40436 734 7 nature nature NN 40436 734 8 is be VBZ 40436 734 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 734 10 ? ? . 40436 735 1 Respecting respect VBG 40436 735 2 what what WDT 40436 735 3 subject subject NN 40436 735 4 ? ? . 40436 736 1 What what WP 40436 736 2 is be VBZ 40436 736 3 the the DT 40436 736 4 art art NN 40436 736 5 or or CC 40436 736 6 science science NN 40436 736 7 for for IN 40436 736 8 realising realise VBG 40436 736 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 736 10 ? ? . 40436 737 1 If if IN 40436 737 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 737 3 ask ask VBP 40436 737 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 737 5 what what WP 40436 737 6 brings bring VBZ 40436 737 7 about about IN 40436 737 8 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 737 9 respecting respect VBG 40436 737 10 numbers number NNS 40436 737 11 and and CC 40436 737 12 measures measure NNS 40436 737 13 , , , 40436 737 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 737 15 will will MD 40436 737 16 say say VB 40436 737 17 the the DT 40436 737 18 arithmetical arithmetical JJ 40436 737 19 and and CC 40436 737 20 the the DT 40436 737 21 metrêtic metrêtic JJ 40436 737 22 art art NN 40436 737 23 . . . 40436 738 1 _ _ NNP 40436 738 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 738 3 mean mean VBP 40436 738 4 that that IN 40436 738 5 friendship friendship NN 40436 738 6 and and CC 40436 738 7 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 738 8 which which WDT 40436 738 9 prevails prevail VBZ 40436 738 10 between between IN 40436 738 11 near near IN 40436 738 12 relatives relative NNS 40436 738 13 , , , 40436 738 14 father father NN 40436 738 15 and and CC 40436 738 16 son son NN 40436 738 17 , , , 40436 738 18 husband husband NN 40436 738 19 and and CC 40436 738 20 wife wife NN 40436 738 21 . . . 40436 739 1 _ _ NNP 40436 739 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 739 3 how how WRB 40436 739 4 can can MD 40436 739 5 there there EX 40436 739 6 be be VB 40436 739 7 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 739 8 between between IN 40436 739 9 any any DT 40436 739 10 two two CD 40436 739 11 persons person NNS 40436 739 12 , , , 40436 739 13 respecting respect VBG 40436 739 14 subjects subject NNS 40436 739 15 which which WDT 40436 739 16 one one CD 40436 739 17 of of IN 40436 739 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 739 19 knows know VBZ 40436 739 20 , , , 40436 739 21 and and CC 40436 739 22 the the DT 40436 739 23 other other JJ 40436 739 24 does do VBZ 40436 739 25 not not RB 40436 739 26 know know VB 40436 739 27 ? ? . 40436 740 1 For for IN 40436 740 2 example example NN 40436 740 3 , , , 40436 740 4 about about IN 40436 740 5 spinning spinning NN 40436 740 6 and and CC 40436 740 7 weaving weaving NN 40436 740 8 , , , 40436 740 9 which which WDT 40436 740 10 the the DT 40436 740 11 husband husband NN 40436 740 12 does do VBZ 40436 740 13 not not RB 40436 740 14 know know VB 40436 740 15 , , , 40436 740 16 or or CC 40436 740 17 about about IN 40436 740 18 military military JJ 40436 740 19 duties duty NNS 40436 740 20 , , , 40436 740 21 which which WDT 40436 740 22 the the DT 40436 740 23 wife wife NN 40436 740 24 does do VBZ 40436 740 25 not not RB 40436 740 26 know know VB 40436 740 27 , , , 40436 740 28 how how WRB 40436 740 29 can can MD 40436 740 30 there there EX 40436 740 31 be be VB 40436 740 32 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 740 33 between between IN 40436 740 34 the the DT 40436 740 35 two two CD 40436 740 36 ? ? . 40436 741 1 _ _ NNP 40436 741 2 Alk._--No Alk._--No NNP 40436 741 3 : : : 40436 741 4 there there EX 40436 741 5 can can MD 40436 741 6 not not RB 40436 741 7 be be VB 40436 741 8 . . . 40436 742 1 _ _ NNP 40436 742 2 Sokr._--Nor Sokr._--Nor NNP 40436 742 3 friendship friendship NN 40436 742 4 , , , 40436 742 5 if if IN 40436 742 6 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 742 7 and and CC 40436 742 8 friendship friendship NN 40436 742 9 go go VB 40436 742 10 together together RB 40436 742 11 ? ? . 40436 743 1 _ _ NNP 40436 743 2 Alk._--Apparently alk._--apparently RB 40436 743 3 there there EX 40436 743 4 can can MD 40436 743 5 not not RB 40436 743 6 . . . 40436 744 1 _ _ NNP 40436 744 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 744 3 when when WRB 40436 744 4 men man NNS 40436 744 5 and and CC 40436 744 6 women woman NNS 40436 744 7 each each DT 40436 744 8 perform perform VBP 40436 744 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 744 10 own own JJ 40436 744 11 special special JJ 40436 744 12 duties duty NNS 40436 744 13 , , , 40436 744 14 there there EX 40436 744 15 can can MD 40436 744 16 be be VB 40436 744 17 no no DT 40436 744 18 friendship friendship NN 40436 744 19 between between IN 40436 744 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 744 21 . . . 40436 745 1 Nor nor CC 40436 745 2 can can MD 40436 745 3 a a DT 40436 745 4 city city NN 40436 745 5 be be VB 40436 745 6 well well RB 40436 745 7 administered administer VBN 40436 745 8 , , , 40436 745 9 when when WRB 40436 745 10 each each DT 40436 745 11 citizen citizen NN 40436 745 12 performs perform VBZ 40436 745 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 745 14 own own JJ 40436 745 15 special special JJ 40436 745 16 duties duty NNS 40436 745 17 ? ? . 40436 746 1 or or CC 40436 746 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 746 3 which which WDT 40436 746 4 is be VBZ 40436 746 5 the the DT 40436 746 6 same same JJ 40436 746 7 thing thing NN 40436 746 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 746 9 when when WRB 40436 746 10 each each DT 40436 746 11 citizen citizen NN 40436 746 12 acts act VBZ 40436 746 13 justly justly RB 40436 746 14 ? ? . 40436 747 1 _ _ NNP 40436 747 2 Alk._--Not Alk._--Not NNP 40436 747 3 so so RB 40436 747 4 : : : 40436 747 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 747 6 think think VBP 40436 747 7 there there EX 40436 747 8 may may MD 40436 747 9 be be VB 40436 747 10 friendship friendship NN 40436 747 11 , , , 40436 747 12 when when WRB 40436 747 13 each each DT 40436 747 14 person person NN 40436 747 15 performs perform VBZ 40436 747 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 747 17 or or CC 40436 747 18 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 747 19 own own JJ 40436 747 20 business business NN 40436 747 21 . . . 40436 748 1 _ _ NNP 40436 748 2 Sokr._--Just Sokr._--Just NNP 40436 748 3 now now RB 40436 748 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 748 5 said say VBD 40436 748 6 the the DT 40436 748 7 reverse reverse NN 40436 748 8 . . . 40436 749 1 What what WP 40436 749 2 is be VBZ 40436 749 3 this this DT 40436 749 4 friendship friendship NN 40436 749 5 or or CC 40436 749 6 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 749 7 which which WDT 40436 749 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 749 9 must must MD 40436 749 10 understand understand VB 40436 749 11 and and CC 40436 749 12 realise realise VB 40436 749 13 , , , 40436 749 14 in in IN 40436 749 15 order order NN 40436 749 16 to to TO 40436 749 17 become become VB 40436 749 18 good good JJ 40436 749 19 men man NNS 40436 749 20 ? ? . 40436 750 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 750 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 750 3 17 17 CD 40436 750 4 : : : 40436 750 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 750 6 , , , 40436 750 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 750 8 . . . 40436 751 1 i. i. NNP 40436 751 2 p. p. NN 40436 751 3 125 125 CD 40436 751 4 B. B. NNP 40436 752 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 752 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 752 3 : : : 40436 752 4 O o NN 40436 752 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 752 6 au)to\s au)to\s NNP 40436 752 7 a)/ra a)/ra FW 40436 752 8 tou tou NNP 40436 752 9 / / SYM 40436 752 10 tô| tô| NNP 40436 752 11 ge ge NNP 40436 752 12 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 752 13 lo lo NNP 40436 752 14 / / SYM 40436 752 15 gô| gô| NNP 40436 752 16 kako kako NNP 40436 752 17 / / SYM 40436 752 18 s s NNP 40436 752 19 te te NNP 40436 752 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 752 21 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 752 22 / / SYM 40436 752 23 s s NNP 40436 752 24 . . . 40436 752 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 753 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 753 2 slides slide NNS 40436 753 3 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 753 4 here here RB 40436 753 5 , , , 40436 753 6 as as IN 40436 753 7 in in IN 40436 753 8 other other JJ 40436 753 9 parts part NNS 40436 753 10 of of IN 40436 753 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 753 12 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 753 13 , , , 40436 753 14 _ _ NNP 40436 753 15 à à NNP 40436 753 16 dicto dicto NNP 40436 753 17 secundum secundum NN 40436 753 18 quid quid NN 40436 753 19 , , , 40436 753 20 ad ad NN 40436 753 21 dictum dictum NN 40436 753 22 simpliciter simplicit JJR 40436 753 23 _ _ NNP 40436 753 24 . . . 40436 753 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 754 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 754 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 754 3 18 18 CD 40436 754 4 : : : 40436 754 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 754 6 , , , 40436 754 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 754 8 . . . 40436 755 1 i. i. NNP 40436 755 2 p. p. NN 40436 755 3 126 126 CD 40436 755 4 A. a. NN 40436 756 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 756 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 756 3 : : : 40436 756 4 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 756 5 de/ de/ NNP 40436 756 6 ? ? . 40436 757 1 ê)\n ê)\n NNP 40436 757 2 su\ su\ NNP 40436 757 3 kalei kalei NNP 40436 757 4 = = NFP 40436 757 5 s s NNP 40436 757 6 eu)bouli eu)bouli NNP 40436 757 7 / / , 40436 757 8 an an DT 40436 757 9 , , , 40436 757 10 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 757 11 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 757 12 e)stin e)stin , 40436 757 13 ? ? . 40436 757 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 758 1 _ _ NNP 40436 758 2 Alk Alk NNP 40436 758 3 . . . 40436 758 4 _ _ NNP 40436 758 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 758 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 758 7 : : : 40436 758 8 Ei)s Ei)s NNP 40436 758 9 to\ to\ NN 40436 758 10 a)/meinon a)/meinon . 40436 758 11 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 758 12 po po NNP 40436 758 13 / / SYM 40436 758 14 lin lin NNP 40436 758 15 dioikei dioikei NNP 40436 758 16 = = SYM 40436 758 17 n n CC 40436 758 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 758 19 sô sô NNP 40436 758 20 / / SYM 40436 758 21 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 758 22 . . . 40436 758 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 759 1 _ _ NNP 40436 759 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 759 3 . . . 40436 759 4 _ _ NNP 40436 759 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 759 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 759 7 : : : 40436 759 8 A)meinon A)meinon NNP 40436 759 9 de\ de\ NNP 40436 759 10 dioikei dioikei VBZ 40436 759 11 = = SYM 40436 759 12 tai tai NNP 40436 759 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 759 14 sô sô NNP 40436 759 15 / / SYM 40436 759 16 zetai zetai NNP 40436 759 17 ti ti NNP 40436 759 18 / / SYM 40436 759 19 nos nos NNP 40436 759 20 paragignome paragignome NNP 40436 759 21 / / SYM 40436 759 22 nou nou NN 40436 759 23 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 759 24 a)pogignomenou a)pogignomenou , 40436 759 25 ? ? . 40436 759 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 759 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 760 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 760 2 Side side NN 40436 760 3 - - HYPH 40436 760 4 note note NN 40436 760 5 : : : 40436 760 6 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 760 7 , , , 40436 760 8 puzzled puzzle VBD 40436 760 9 and and CC 40436 760 10 humiliated humiliate VBD 40436 760 11 , , , 40436 760 12 confesses confess VBZ 40436 760 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 760 14 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 760 15 . . . 40436 761 1 Encouragement encouragement NN 40436 761 2 given give VBN 40436 761 3 by by IN 40436 761 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 761 5 . . . 40436 762 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 762 2 is be VBZ 40436 762 3 an an DT 40436 762 4 advantage advantage NN 40436 762 5 to to TO 40436 762 6 make make VB 40436 762 7 such such JJ 40436 762 8 discovery discovery NN 40436 762 9 in in IN 40436 762 10 youth youth NN 40436 762 11 . . . 40436 762 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 763 1 _ _ NNP 40436 763 2 Alk._--In Alk._--In NNP 40436 763 3 truth truth NN 40436 763 4 , , , 40436 763 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 763 6 am be VBP 40436 763 7 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 763 8 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 763 9 to to TO 40436 763 10 say say VB 40436 763 11 . . . 40436 764 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 764 2 find find VBP 40436 764 3 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 764 4 in in IN 40436 764 5 a a DT 40436 764 6 state state NN 40436 764 7 of of IN 40436 764 8 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 764 9 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 764 10 , , , 40436 764 11 of of IN 40436 764 12 which which WDT 40436 764 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 764 14 had have VBD 40436 764 15 no no DT 40436 764 16 previous previous JJ 40436 764 17 suspicion suspicion NN 40436 764 18 . . . 40436 765 1 _ _ NNP 40436 765 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 765 3 not not RB 40436 765 4 be be VB 40436 765 5 discouraged discourage VBN 40436 765 6 . . . 40436 766 1 If if IN 40436 766 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 766 3 had have VBD 40436 766 4 made make VBN 40436 766 5 this this DT 40436 766 6 discovery discovery NN 40436 766 7 when when WRB 40436 766 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 766 9 were be VBD 40436 766 10 fifty fifty CD 40436 766 11 years year NNS 40436 766 12 old old JJ 40436 766 13 , , , 40436 766 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 766 15 would would MD 40436 766 16 have have VB 40436 766 17 been be VBN 40436 766 18 too too RB 40436 766 19 late late JJ 40436 766 20 for for IN 40436 766 21 taking take VBG 40436 766 22 care care NN 40436 766 23 of of IN 40436 766 24 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 766 25 and and CC 40436 766 26 applying apply VBG 40436 766 27 a a DT 40436 766 28 remedy remedy NN 40436 766 29 : : : 40436 766 30 but but CC 40436 766 31 at at IN 40436 766 32 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 766 33 age age NN 40436 766 34 , , , 40436 766 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 766 36 is be VBZ 40436 766 37 the the DT 40436 766 38 right right JJ 40436 766 39 time time NN 40436 766 40 for for IN 40436 766 41 making make VBG 40436 766 42 the the DT 40436 766 43 discovery discovery NN 40436 766 44 . . . 40436 767 1 _ _ NNP 40436 767 2 Alk._--What alk._--what DT 40436 767 3 am be VBP 40436 767 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 767 5 to to TO 40436 767 6 do do VB 40436 767 7 , , , 40436 767 8 now now RB 40436 767 9 that that IN 40436 767 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 767 11 have have VBP 40436 767 12 made make VBN 40436 767 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 767 14 ? ? . 40436 768 1 _ _ NNP 40436 768 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 768 3 must must MD 40436 768 4 answer answer VB 40436 768 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 768 6 questions question NNS 40436 768 7 . . . 40436 769 1 If if IN 40436 769 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 769 3 auguries augury NNS 40436 769 4 are be VBP 40436 769 5 just just RB 40436 769 6 , , , 40436 769 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 769 8 shall shall MD 40436 769 9 soon soon RB 40436 769 10 be be VB 40436 769 11 both both DT 40436 769 12 of of IN 40436 769 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 769 14 better well RBR 40436 769 15 for for IN 40436 769 16 the the DT 40436 769 17 process process NN 40436 769 18 . . . 40436 770 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 770 2 19 19 CD 40436 770 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 770 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 770 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 770 6 19 19 CD 40436 770 7 : : : 40436 770 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 770 9 , , , 40436 770 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 770 11 . . . 40436 771 1 i. i. NNP 40436 772 1 127 127 CD 40436 772 2 D D NNP 40436 772 3 - - HYPH 40436 772 4 E. E. NNP 40436 772 5 _ _ NNP 40436 772 6 Alk Alk NNP 40436 772 7 . . . 40436 772 8 _ _ NNP 40436 772 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 772 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 772 11 : : : 40436 772 12 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 772 13 ma\ ma\ RB 40436 772 14 tou\s tou\s NN 40436 772 15 theou theou NNP 40436 772 16 / / SYM 40436 772 17 s s NNPS 40436 772 18 , , , 40436 772 19 ou)d ou)d JJ 40436 772 20 ' ' '' 40436 772 21 au)to\s au)to\s VBP 40436 772 22 oi)=da oi)=da NNP 40436 772 23 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 772 24 ti ti PRP 40436 772 25 le le NNP 40436 772 26 / / SYM 40436 772 27 gô gô UH 40436 772 28 , , , 40436 772 29 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 772 30 / / SYM 40436 772 31 ô ô NNP 40436 772 32 de\ de\ NNP 40436 772 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 772 34 pa pa NNP 40436 772 35 / / SYM 40436 772 36 lai lai NNP 40436 772 37 lelêthe lelêthe NNP 40436 772 38 / / SYM 40436 772 39 nai nai NNP 40436 772 40 e)mauto\n e)mauto\n NNP 40436 772 41 ai)/schist ai)/schist NNP 40436 772 42 ' ' POS 40436 772 43 e)/chôn e)/chôn NNP 40436 772 44 . . . 40436 772 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 773 1 _ _ NNP 40436 773 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 773 3 . . . 40436 773 4 _ _ NNP 40436 773 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 773 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 773 7 : : : 40436 773 8 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 773 9 chrê\ chrê\ NNP 40436 773 10 thar)r(ei thar)r(ei NNP 40436 773 11 = = SYM 40436 773 12 n n XX 40436 773 13 ; ; : 40436 773 14 ei ei LS 40436 773 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 773 16 me\n me\n NNP 40436 773 17 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 773 18 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 773 19 ê)=|sthou ê)=|sthou NNP 40436 773 20 peponthô\s peponthô\s CD 40436 773 21 pentêkontae pentêkontae NN 40436 773 22 / / SYM 40436 773 23 tês tês NNP 40436 773 24 , , , 40436 773 25 chalepo\n chalepo\n . 40436 773 26 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 773 27 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 773 28 soi soi NNP 40436 773 29 e)pimelêthê e)pimelêthê NNS 40436 773 30 = = SYM 40436 773 31 nai nai NNP 40436 773 32 sautou= sautou= JJ 40436 773 33 ; ; : 40436 773 34 nu nu NNP 40436 773 35 = = SYM 40436 773 36 n n NNP 40436 773 37 de\ de\ NNP 40436 773 38 ê)\n ê)\n NNP 40436 773 39 e)/cheis e)/cheis NNP 40436 773 40 ê(liki ê(liki NNP 40436 773 41 / / , 40436 773 42 an an DT 40436 773 43 , , , 40436 773 44 au)/tê au)/tê CD 40436 773 45 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 773 46 / / SYM 40436 773 47 n n NNP 40436 773 48 , , , 40436 773 49 e)n e)n NNP 40436 773 50 ê(=| ê(=| NN 40436 773 51 dei= dei= NNP 40436 773 52 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 773 53 ai)sthe ai)sthe DT 40436 773 54 / / SYM 40436 773 55 sthai sthai NNP 40436 773 56 . . . 40436 773 57 ] ] -RRB- 40436 774 1 _ _ NNP 40436 774 2 Alk Alk NNP 40436 774 3 . . . 40436 774 4 _ _ NNP 40436 774 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 774 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 774 7 : : : 40436 774 8 Ti/ Ti/ NNP 40436 774 9 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 774 10 to\n to\n NNP 40436 774 11 ai(stho ai(stho NNP 40436 774 12 / / SYM 40436 774 13 menon menon NNP 40436 774 14 chrê\ chrê\ NNP 40436 774 15 poiei poiei NNP 40436 774 16 = = SYM 40436 774 17 n n XX 40436 774 18 ? ? . 40436 774 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 775 1 _ _ NNP 40436 775 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 775 3 . . . 40436 775 4 _ _ NNP 40436 775 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 775 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 775 7 : : : 40436 775 8 _ _ NNP 40436 775 9 A)pokri A)pokri NNP 40436 775 10 / / SYM 40436 775 11 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 775 12 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 775 13 e)rôtô e)rôtô NNP 40436 775 14 / / SYM 40436 775 15 mena mena NNP 40436 775 16 _ _ NNP 40436 775 17 , , , 40436 775 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 775 19 e)a\n e)a\n -RRB- 40436 775 20 tou tou NNP 40436 775 21 = = SYM 40436 775 22 to to IN 40436 775 23 poiê=|s poiê=|s NNP 40436 775 24 , , , 40436 775 25 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 775 26 theo\s theo\s ADD 40436 775 27 e)the e)the NNP 40436 775 28 / / SYM 40436 775 29 lê| lê| NNP 40436 775 30 , , , 40436 775 31 ei)/ ei)/ NNP 40436 775 32 ti ti NNP 40436 775 33 dei= dei= NNP 40436 775 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 775 35 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 775 36 e)mê=| e)mê=| NNS 40436 775 37 mantei mantei NN 40436 775 38 / / SYM 40436 775 39 a| a| NN 40436 775 40 pisteu pisteu NN 40436 775 41 / / SYM 40436 775 42 ein ein NN 40436 775 43 , , , 40436 775 44 su/ su/ NNP 40436 775 45 te te NNP 40436 775 46 ka)gô\ ka)gô\ NNP 40436 775 47 beltio beltio NNP 40436 775 48 / / SYM 40436 775 49 nôs nôs NNP 40436 775 50 schê schê NNP 40436 775 51 / / SYM 40436 775 52 somen soman NNS 40436 775 53 . . . 40436 775 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 775 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 776 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 776 2 Side side NN 40436 776 3 - - HYPH 40436 776 4 note note NN 40436 776 5 : : : 40436 776 6 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 776 7 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 776 8 -- -- : 40436 776 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 776 10 actual actual JJ 40436 776 11 effect effect NN 40436 776 12 -- -- : 40436 776 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 776 14 anticipated anticipated JJ 40436 776 15 effect effect NN 40436 776 16 -- -- : 40436 776 17 applicable applicable JJ 40436 776 18 to to IN 40436 776 19 the the DT 40436 776 20 season season NN 40436 776 21 of of IN 40436 776 22 youth youth NN 40436 776 23 . . . 40436 776 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 777 1 Here here RB 40436 777 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 777 3 have have VBP 40436 777 4 again again RB 40436 777 5 , , , 40436 777 6 brought bring VBN 40436 777 7 into into IN 40436 777 8 prominent prominent JJ 40436 777 9 relief relief NN 40436 777 10 , , , 40436 777 11 the the DT 40436 777 12 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 777 13 method method NN 40436 777 14 of of IN 40436 777 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 777 16 , , , 40436 777 17 under under IN 40436 777 18 two two CD 40436 777 19 distinct distinct JJ 40436 777 20 aspects aspect NNS 40436 777 21 : : : 40436 777 22 1 1 CD 40436 777 23 . . . 40436 778 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 778 2 actual actual JJ 40436 778 3 effects effect NNS 40436 778 4 , , , 40436 778 5 in in IN 40436 778 6 exposing expose VBG 40436 778 7 the the DT 40436 778 8 false false JJ 40436 778 9 supposition supposition NN 40436 778 10 of of IN 40436 778 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 778 12 , , , 40436 778 13 in in IN 40436 778 14 forcing force VBG 40436 778 15 upon upon IN 40436 778 16 the the DT 40436 778 17 respondent respondent NN 40436 778 18 the the DT 40436 778 19 humiliating humiliating JJ 40436 778 20 conviction conviction NN 40436 778 21 , , , 40436 778 22 that that IN 40436 778 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 778 24 does do VBZ 40436 778 25 not not RB 40436 778 26 know know VB 40436 778 27 familiar familiar JJ 40436 778 28 topics topic NNS 40436 778 29 which which WDT 40436 778 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 778 31 supposed suppose VBD 40436 778 32 to to TO 40436 778 33 be be VB 40436 778 34 clear clear JJ 40436 778 35 both both DT 40436 778 36 to to IN 40436 778 37 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 778 38 and and CC 40436 778 39 to to IN 40436 778 40 others other NNS 40436 778 41 . . . 40436 779 1 2 2 LS 40436 779 2 . . . 40436 780 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 780 2 anticipated anticipated JJ 40436 780 3 effects effect NNS 40436 780 4 , , , 40436 780 5 if if IN 40436 780 6 continued continue VBN 40436 780 7 , , , 40436 780 8 in in IN 40436 780 9 remedying remedy VBG 40436 780 10 such such JJ 40436 780 11 defect defect NN 40436 780 12 : : : 40436 780 13 and and CC 40436 780 14 in in IN 40436 780 15 generating generate VBG 40436 780 16 out out IN 40436 780 17 of of IN 40436 780 18 the the DT 40436 780 19 mind mind NN 40436 780 20 of of IN 40436 780 21 the the DT 40436 780 22 respondent respondent NN 40436 780 23 , , , 40436 780 24 real real JJ 40436 780 25 and and CC 40436 780 26 living living NN 40436 780 27 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 780 28 . . . 40436 781 1 Lastly lastly RB 40436 781 2 , , , 40436 781 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 781 4 is be VBZ 40436 781 5 plainly plainly RB 40436 781 6 intimated intimate VBN 40436 781 7 that that IN 40436 781 8 this this DT 40436 781 9 shock shock NN 40436 781 10 of of IN 40436 781 11 humiliation humiliation NN 40436 781 12 and and CC 40436 781 13 mistrust mistrust NN 40436 781 14 , , , 40436 781 15 painful painful JJ 40436 781 16 but but CC 40436 781 17 inevitable inevitable JJ 40436 781 18 , , , 40436 781 19 must must MD 40436 781 20 be be VB 40436 781 21 undergone undergo VBN 40436 781 22 in in IN 40436 781 23 youth youth NN 40436 781 24 . . . 40436 782 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 782 2 Side side NN 40436 782 3 - - HYPH 40436 782 4 note note NN 40436 782 5 : : : 40436 782 6 Know know VB 40436 782 7 Thyself thyself PRP 40436 782 8 -- -- : 40436 782 9 Delphian delphian JJ 40436 782 10 maxim maxim NN 40436 782 11 -- -- : 40436 782 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 782 13 urgent urgent JJ 40436 782 14 importance importance NN 40436 782 15 -- -- : 40436 782 16 What what WP 40436 782 17 is be VBZ 40436 782 18 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 782 19 ? ? . 40436 783 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 783 2 mind mind NN 40436 783 3 is be VBZ 40436 783 4 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 783 5 . . . 40436 783 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 784 1 The the DT 40436 784 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 784 3 continues continue VBZ 40436 784 4 , , , 40436 784 5 in in IN 40436 784 6 short short JJ 40436 784 7 questions question NNS 40436 784 8 and and CC 40436 784 9 answers answer NNS 40436 784 10 , , , 40436 784 11 of of IN 40436 784 12 which which WDT 40436 784 13 the the DT 40436 784 14 following follow VBG 40436 784 15 is be VBZ 40436 784 16 an an DT 40436 784 17 abstract abstract NN 40436 784 18 . . . 40436 785 1 _ _ NNP 40436 785 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 785 3 is be VBZ 40436 785 4 meant mean VBN 40436 785 5 by by IN 40436 785 6 a a DT 40436 785 7 man man NN 40436 785 8 _ _ NNP 40436 785 9 taking take VBG 40436 785 10 care care NN 40436 785 11 of of IN 40436 785 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 785 13 _ _ NNP 40436 785 14 ? ? . 40436 786 1 Before before IN 40436 786 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 786 3 can can MD 40436 786 4 take take VB 40436 786 5 care care NN 40436 786 6 of of IN 40436 786 7 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 786 8 , , , 40436 786 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 786 10 must must MD 40436 786 11 know know VB 40436 786 12 what what WP 40436 786 13 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 786 14 is be VBZ 40436 786 15 : : : 40436 786 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 786 17 must must MD 40436 786 18 _ _ NNP 40436 786 19 know know VB 40436 786 20 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 786 21 _ _ NNP 40436 786 22 , , , 40436 786 23 according accord VBG 40436 786 24 to to IN 40436 786 25 the the DT 40436 786 26 Delphian delphian JJ 40436 786 27 motto motto NN 40436 786 28 . . . 40436 787 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 787 2 can can MD 40436 787 3 not not RB 40436 787 4 make make VB 40436 787 5 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 787 6 better well JJR 40436 787 7 , , , 40436 787 8 without without IN 40436 787 9 knowing know VBG 40436 787 10 what what WP 40436 787 11 _ _ NNP 40436 787 12 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 787 13 _ _ NNP 40436 787 14 is be VBZ 40436 787 15 . . . 40436 788 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 788 2 20 20 CD 40436 788 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 788 4 That that DT 40436 788 5 which which WDT 40436 788 6 belongs belong VBZ 40436 788 7 to to IN 40436 788 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 788 9 is be VBZ 40436 788 10 not not RB 40436 788 11 _ _ IN 40436 788 12 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 788 13 _ _ NN 40436 788 14 : : : 40436 788 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 788 16 body body NN 40436 788 17 is be VBZ 40436 788 18 not not RB 40436 788 19 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 788 20 , , , 40436 788 21 but but CC 40436 788 22 an an DT 40436 788 23 instrument instrument NN 40436 788 24 governed govern VBN 40436 788 25 by by IN 40436 788 26 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 788 27 . . . 40436 789 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 789 2 21 21 LS 40436 789 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 789 4 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 789 5 mind mind NN 40436 789 6 or or CC 40436 789 7 soul soul NN 40436 789 8 only only RB 40436 789 9 , , , 40436 789 10 is be VBZ 40436 789 11 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 789 12 . . . 40436 790 1 To to TO 40436 790 2 take take VB 40436 790 3 care care NN 40436 790 4 of of IN 40436 790 5 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 790 6 is be VBZ 40436 790 7 , , , 40436 790 8 to to TO 40436 790 9 take take VB 40436 790 10 care care NN 40436 790 11 of of IN 40436 790 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 790 13 mind mind NN 40436 790 14 . . . 40436 791 1 At at IN 40436 791 2 any any DT 40436 791 3 rate rate NN 40436 791 4 , , , 40436 791 5 if if IN 40436 791 6 this this DT 40436 791 7 be be VB 40436 791 8 not not RB 40436 791 9 strictly strictly RB 40436 791 10 true,[22 true,[22 NNP 40436 791 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 791 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 791 13 mind mind NN 40436 791 14 is be VBZ 40436 791 15 the the DT 40436 791 16 most most RBS 40436 791 17 important important JJ 40436 791 18 and and CC 40436 791 19 dominant dominant JJ 40436 791 20 element element NN 40436 791 21 within within IN 40436 791 22 me -PRON- PRP 40436 791 23 . . . 40436 792 1 The the DT 40436 792 2 physician physician NN 40436 792 3 who who WP 40436 792 4 knows know VBZ 40436 792 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 792 6 own own JJ 40436 792 7 body body NN 40436 792 8 , , , 40436 792 9 does do VBZ 40436 792 10 not not RB 40436 792 11 for for IN 40436 792 12 that that DT 40436 792 13 reason reason NN 40436 792 14 know know VBP 40436 792 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 792 16 : : : 40436 792 17 much much RB 40436 792 18 less less JJR 40436 792 19 do do VB 40436 792 20 the the DT 40436 792 21 husbandman husbandman NN 40436 792 22 or or CC 40436 792 23 the the DT 40436 792 24 tradesman tradesman NN 40436 792 25 , , , 40436 792 26 who who WP 40436 792 27 know know VBP 40436 792 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 792 29 own own JJ 40436 792 30 properties property NNS 40436 792 31 or or CC 40436 792 32 crafts craft NNS 40436 792 33 , , , 40436 792 34 know know VB 40436 792 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 792 36 , , , 40436 792 37 or or CC 40436 792 38 perform perform VB 40436 792 39 what what WP 40436 792 40 is be VBZ 40436 792 41 truly truly RB 40436 792 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 792 43 own own JJ 40436 792 44 business business NN 40436 792 45 . . . 40436 793 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 793 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 793 3 20 20 CD 40436 793 4 : : : 40436 793 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 793 6 , , , 40436 793 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 793 8 . . . 40436 794 1 i. i. NNP 40436 795 1 129 129 CD 40436 795 2 B. B. NNP 40436 796 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 796 2 Greek greek NN 40436 796 3 : : : 40436 796 4 ti ti NN 40436 796 5 / / SYM 40436 796 6 n n CC 40436 796 7 ' ' CC 40436 796 8 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 796 9 tro tro NN 40436 796 10 / / SYM 40436 796 11 pon pon NNP 40436 796 12 eu(rethei eu(rethei NNP 40436 796 13 / / SYM 40436 796 14 ê ê NNP 40436 796 15 _ _ NNP 40436 796 16 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 796 17 to\ to\ NN 40436 796 18 au)to/ au)to/ NNP 40436 796 19 _ _ NNP 40436 796 20 ? ? . 40436 796 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 796 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 797 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 797 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 797 3 21 21 CD 40436 797 4 : : : 40436 797 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 797 6 , , , 40436 797 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 797 8 . . . 40436 798 1 i. i. NNP 40436 799 1 128 128 CD 40436 799 2 - - SYM 40436 799 3 130 130 CD 40436 799 4 . . . 40436 800 1 All all DT 40436 800 2 this this DT 40436 800 3 is be VBZ 40436 800 4 greatly greatly RB 40436 800 5 expanded expand VBN 40436 800 6 in in IN 40436 800 7 the the DT 40436 800 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 800 9 -- -- : 40436 800 10 p p NN 40436 800 11 . . . 40436 800 12 128 128 CD 40436 800 13 D d NN 40436 800 14 : : : 40436 800 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 800 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 800 17 : : : 40436 800 18 Ou)k Ou)k NNP 40436 800 19 a)/ra a)/ra UH 40436 800 20 o)/tan o)/tan NNP 40436 800 21 tô tô NNP 40436 800 22 = = SYM 40436 800 23 n n CC 40436 800 24 sautou= sautou= JJ 40436 800 25 e)pimelê=| e)pimelê=| ADD 40436 800 26 , , , 40436 800 27 sautou= sautou= JJ 40436 800 28 e)pime e)pime , 40436 800 29 / / SYM 40436 800 30 lei lei NN 40436 800 31 ? ? . 40436 800 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 801 1 This this DT 40436 801 2 same same JJ 40436 801 3 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 801 4 is be VBZ 40436 801 5 employed employ VBN 40436 801 6 by by IN 40436 801 7 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 801 8 , , , 40436 801 9 De De NNP 40436 801 10 Permutatione Permutatione NNP 40436 801 11 , , , 40436 801 12 sect sect NN 40436 801 13 . . . 40436 802 1 309 309 CD 40436 802 2 , , , 40436 802 3 p. p. NN 40436 802 4 492 492 CD 40436 802 5 , , , 40436 802 6 Bekker Bekker NNP 40436 802 7 . . . 40436 803 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 803 2 recommends recommend VBZ 40436 803 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 803 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 803 5 : : : 40436 803 6 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 803 7 pro pro JJ 40436 803 8 / / SYM 40436 803 9 teron teron JJ 40436 803 10 ê)\ ê)\ NFP 40436 803 11 tô tô FW 40436 803 12 = = NFP 40436 803 13 n n CC 40436 803 14 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 803 15 poiei poiei NN 40436 803 16 = = SYM 40436 803 17 sthai sthai NNP 40436 803 18 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 803 19 e)pime e)pime NNP 40436 803 20 / / SYM 40436 803 21 leian leian NNP 40436 803 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 803 23 . . . 40436 803 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 804 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 804 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 804 3 22 22 CD 40436 804 4 : : : 40436 804 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 804 6 considers consider VBZ 40436 804 7 this this DT 40436 804 8 point point NN 40436 804 9 to to TO 40436 804 10 be be VB 40436 804 11 not not RB 40436 804 12 clearly clearly RB 40436 804 13 made make VBN 40436 804 14 out out RP 40436 804 15 . . . 40436 805 1 Alkib alkib UH 40436 805 2 . . . 40436 806 1 i. i. NNP 40436 807 1 130 130 CD 40436 807 2 . . . 40436 807 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 808 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 808 2 Side side NN 40436 808 3 - - HYPH 40436 808 4 note note NN 40436 808 5 : : : 40436 808 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 808 7 can can MD 40436 808 8 not not RB 40436 808 9 know know VB 40436 808 10 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 808 11 , , , 40436 808 12 except except IN 40436 808 13 by by IN 40436 808 14 looking look VBG 40436 808 15 into into IN 40436 808 16 another another DT 40436 808 17 mind mind NN 40436 808 18 . . . 40436 809 1 Self self NN 40436 809 2 - - HYPH 40436 809 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 809 4 is be VBZ 40436 809 5 temperance temperance NN 40436 809 6 . . . 40436 810 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 810 2 and and CC 40436 810 3 Justice Justice NNP 40436 810 4 are be VBP 40436 810 5 the the DT 40436 810 6 conditions condition NNS 40436 810 7 both both DT 40436 810 8 of of IN 40436 810 9 happiness happiness NN 40436 810 10 and and CC 40436 810 11 of of IN 40436 810 12 freedom freedom NN 40436 810 13 . . . 40436 810 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 811 1 Since since IN 40436 811 2 temperance temperance NN 40436 811 3 consists consist VBZ 40436 811 4 in in IN 40436 811 5 self self NN 40436 811 6 - - HYPH 40436 811 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 811 8 , , , 40436 811 9 neither neither DT 40436 811 10 of of IN 40436 811 11 these these DT 40436 811 12 professional professional JJ 40436 811 13 men man NNS 40436 811 14 , , , 40436 811 15 as as IN 40436 811 16 such such JJ 40436 811 17 , , , 40436 811 18 is be VBZ 40436 811 19 temperate temperate NN 40436 811 20 : : : 40436 811 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 811 22 professions profession NNS 40436 811 23 are be VBP 40436 811 24 of of IN 40436 811 25 a a DT 40436 811 26 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 811 27 cast cast NN 40436 811 28 , , , 40436 811 29 and and CC 40436 811 30 do do VBP 40436 811 31 not not RB 40436 811 32 belong belong VB 40436 811 33 to to IN 40436 811 34 the the DT 40436 811 35 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 811 36 life life NN 40436 811 37 . . . 40436 812 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 812 2 23 23 CD 40436 812 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 812 4 How how WRB 40436 812 5 are be VBP 40436 812 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 812 7 to to TO 40436 812 8 know know VB 40436 812 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 812 10 own own JJ 40436 812 11 minds mind NNS 40436 812 12 ? ? . 40436 813 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 813 2 know know VBP 40436 813 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 813 4 by by IN 40436 813 5 looking look VBG 40436 813 6 into into IN 40436 813 7 another another DT 40436 813 8 mind mind NN 40436 813 9 , , , 40436 813 10 and and CC 40436 813 11 into into IN 40436 813 12 the the DT 40436 813 13 most most RBS 40436 813 14 rational rational JJ 40436 813 15 and and CC 40436 813 16 divine divine JJ 40436 813 17 portion portion NN 40436 813 18 thereof thereof RB 40436 813 19 : : : 40436 813 20 just just RB 40436 813 21 as as IN 40436 813 22 the the DT 40436 813 23 eye eye NN 40436 813 24 can can MD 40436 813 25 only only RB 40436 813 26 know know VB 40436 813 27 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 813 28 by by IN 40436 813 29 looking look VBG 40436 813 30 into into IN 40436 813 31 another another DT 40436 813 32 eye eye NN 40436 813 33 , , , 40436 813 34 and and CC 40436 813 35 seeing see VBG 40436 813 36 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 813 37 therein therein RB 40436 813 38 reflected reflect VBN 40436 813 39 . . . 40436 814 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 814 2 24 24 CD 40436 814 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 814 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 814 5 is be VBZ 40436 814 6 only only RB 40436 814 7 in in IN 40436 814 8 this this DT 40436 814 9 way way NN 40436 814 10 that that WDT 40436 814 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 814 12 can can MD 40436 814 13 come come VB 40436 814 14 to to TO 40436 814 15 know know VB 40436 814 16 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 814 17 , , , 40436 814 18 or or CC 40436 814 19 become become VB 40436 814 20 temperate temperate NN 40436 814 21 : : : 40436 814 22 and and CC 40436 814 23 if if IN 40436 814 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 814 25 do do VBP 40436 814 26 not not RB 40436 814 27 know know VB 40436 814 28 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 814 29 , , , 40436 814 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 814 31 can can MD 40436 814 32 not not RB 40436 814 33 even even RB 40436 814 34 know know VB 40436 814 35 what what WP 40436 814 36 belongs belong VBZ 40436 814 37 to to IN 40436 814 38 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 814 39 , , , 40436 814 40 or or CC 40436 814 41 what what WP 40436 814 42 belongs belong VBZ 40436 814 43 to to IN 40436 814 44 others other NNS 40436 814 45 : : : 40436 814 46 all all PDT 40436 814 47 these these DT 40436 814 48 are be VBP 40436 814 49 branches branch NNS 40436 814 50 of of IN 40436 814 51 one one CD 40436 814 52 and and CC 40436 814 53 the the DT 40436 814 54 same same JJ 40436 814 55 cognition cognition NN 40436 814 56 . . . 40436 815 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 815 2 can can MD 40436 815 3 have have VB 40436 815 4 no no DT 40436 815 5 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 815 6 of of IN 40436 815 7 affairs affair NNS 40436 815 8 , , , 40436 815 9 either either CC 40436 815 10 public public JJ 40436 815 11 or or CC 40436 815 12 private private JJ 40436 815 13 : : : 40436 815 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 815 15 shall shall MD 40436 815 16 go go VB 40436 815 17 wrong wrong JJ 40436 815 18 , , , 40436 815 19 and and CC 40436 815 20 shall shall MD 40436 815 21 be be VB 40436 815 22 unable unable JJ 40436 815 23 to to TO 40436 815 24 secure secure VB 40436 815 25 happiness happiness NN 40436 815 26 either either CC 40436 815 27 for for IN 40436 815 28 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 815 29 or or CC 40436 815 30 for for IN 40436 815 31 others other NNS 40436 815 32 . . . 40436 816 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 816 2 is be VBZ 40436 816 3 not not RB 40436 816 4 wealth wealth NN 40436 816 5 or or CC 40436 816 6 power power NN 40436 816 7 which which WDT 40436 816 8 are be VBP 40436 816 9 the the DT 40436 816 10 conditions condition NNS 40436 816 11 of of IN 40436 816 12 happiness happiness NN 40436 816 13 , , , 40436 816 14 but but CC 40436 816 15 justice justice NN 40436 816 16 and and CC 40436 816 17 temperance temperance NN 40436 816 18 . . . 40436 817 1 Both both DT 40436 817 2 for for IN 40436 817 3 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 817 4 individually individually RB 40436 817 5 , , , 40436 817 6 and and CC 40436 817 7 for for IN 40436 817 8 the the DT 40436 817 9 public public NN 40436 817 10 collectively collectively RB 40436 817 11 , , , 40436 817 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 817 13 ought ought MD 40436 817 14 to to TO 40436 817 15 aim aim VB 40436 817 16 at at IN 40436 817 17 justice justice NN 40436 817 18 and and CC 40436 817 19 temperance temperance NN 40436 817 20 , , , 40436 817 21 not not RB 40436 817 22 at at IN 40436 817 23 wealth wealth NN 40436 817 24 and and CC 40436 817 25 power power NN 40436 817 26 . . . 40436 818 1 The the DT 40436 818 2 evil evil JJ 40436 818 3 and and CC 40436 818 4 unjust unjust JJ 40436 818 5 man man NN 40436 818 6 ought ought MD 40436 818 7 to to TO 40436 818 8 have have VB 40436 818 9 no no DT 40436 818 10 power power NN 40436 818 11 , , , 40436 818 12 but but CC 40436 818 13 to to TO 40436 818 14 be be VB 40436 818 15 the the DT 40436 818 16 slave slave NN 40436 818 17 of of IN 40436 818 18 those those DT 40436 818 19 who who WP 40436 818 20 are be VBP 40436 818 21 better well JJR 40436 818 22 than than IN 40436 818 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 818 24 . . . 40436 819 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 819 2 25 25 CD 40436 819 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 819 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 819 5 is be VBZ 40436 819 6 fit fit JJ 40436 819 7 for for IN 40436 819 8 nothing nothing NN 40436 819 9 but but IN 40436 819 10 to to TO 40436 819 11 be be VB 40436 819 12 a a DT 40436 819 13 slave slave NN 40436 819 14 : : : 40436 819 15 none none NN 40436 819 16 deserve deserve VB 40436 819 17 freedom freedom NN 40436 819 18 except except IN 40436 819 19 the the DT 40436 819 20 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 819 21 . . . 40436 820 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 820 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 820 3 23 23 CD 40436 820 4 : : : 40436 820 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 820 6 , , , 40436 820 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 820 8 . . . 40436 821 1 i. i. NNP 40436 822 1 131 131 CD 40436 822 2 B. B. NNP 40436 822 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 823 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 823 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 823 3 24 24 CD 40436 823 4 : : : 40436 823 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 823 6 , , , 40436 823 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 823 8 . . . 40436 824 1 i. i. NNP 40436 825 1 133 133 LS 40436 825 2 . . . 40436 825 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 826 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 826 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 826 3 25 25 CD 40436 826 4 : : : 40436 826 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 826 6 , , , 40436 826 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 826 8 . . . 40436 827 1 i. i. NNP 40436 828 1 134 134 CD 40436 828 2 - - SYM 40436 828 3 135 135 CD 40436 828 4 B B NNP 40436 828 5 - - HYPH 40436 828 6 C. C. NNP 40436 828 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 828 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 828 9 : : : 40436 828 10 Pri\n Pri\n NNPS 40436 828 11 de/ de/ NNP 40436 828 12 ge ge NNP 40436 828 13 a)retê\n a)retê\n NNP 40436 828 14 e)/chein e)/chein NNP 40436 828 15 , , , 40436 828 16 to\ to\ NN 40436 828 17 a)/rchesthai a)/rchesthai NNP 40436 828 18 a)/meinon a)/meinon NNP 40436 828 19 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 828 20 tou= tou= NNP 40436 828 21 belti belti NN 40436 828 22 / / SYM 40436 828 23 onos onos NN 40436 828 24 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 828 25 to\ to\ NN 40436 828 26 a)/rchein a)/rchein NNP 40436 828 27 a)ndri\ a)ndri\ NNP 40436 828 28 , , , 40436 828 29 ou ou NNP 40436 828 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 828 31 mo mo NNP 40436 828 32 / / SYM 40436 828 33 non non NNP 40436 828 34 paidi/ paidi/ NNS 40436 828 35 . . . 40436 829 1 . . . 40436 830 1 . . . 40436 831 1 . . . 40436 832 1 Pre Pre NNP 40436 832 2 / / SYM 40436 832 3 pei pei NNP 40436 832 4 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 832 5 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 832 6 kakô=| kakô=| NNP 40436 832 7 douleu douleu NNP 40436 832 8 / / SYM 40436 832 9 ein ein NNP 40436 832 10 ; ; : 40436 832 11 a)/meinon a)/meinon NNP 40436 832 12 ga ga NNP 40436 832 13 / / SYM 40436 832 14 r r NNP 40436 832 15 . . . 40436 832 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 832 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 833 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 833 2 Side side NN 40436 833 3 - - HYPH 40436 833 4 note note NN 40436 833 5 : : : 40436 833 6 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 833 7 feels feel VBZ 40436 833 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 833 9 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 833 10 to to TO 40436 833 11 be be VB 40436 833 12 free free JJ 40436 833 13 , , , 40436 833 14 and and CC 40436 833 15 declares declare VBZ 40436 833 16 that that IN 40436 833 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 833 18 will will MD 40436 833 19 never never RB 40436 833 20 quit quit VB 40436 833 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 833 22 . . . 40436 833 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 834 1 _ _ NNP 40436 834 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 834 3 do do VBP 40436 834 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 834 5 feel feel VB 40436 834 6 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 834 7 own own JJ 40436 834 8 condition condition NN 40436 834 9 now now RB 40436 834 10 , , , 40436 834 11 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 834 12 . . . 40436 835 1 Are be VBP 40436 835 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 835 3 worthy worthy JJ 40436 835 4 of of IN 40436 835 5 freedom freedom NN 40436 835 6 ? ? . 40436 836 1 _ _ NNP 40436 836 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 836 3 feel feel VBP 40436 836 4 but but CC 40436 836 5 too too RB 40436 836 6 keenly keenly RB 40436 836 7 that that IN 40436 836 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 836 9 am be VBP 40436 836 10 not not RB 40436 836 11 . . . 40436 837 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 837 2 can can MD 40436 837 3 not not RB 40436 837 4 emerge emerge VB 40436 837 5 from from IN 40436 837 6 this this DT 40436 837 7 degradation degradation NN 40436 837 8 except except IN 40436 837 9 by by IN 40436 837 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 837 11 society society NN 40436 837 12 and and CC 40436 837 13 help help NN 40436 837 14 . . . 40436 838 1 From from IN 40436 838 2 this this DT 40436 838 3 time time NN 40436 838 4 forward forward RB 40436 838 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 838 6 shall shall MD 40436 838 7 never never RB 40436 838 8 leave leave VB 40436 838 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 838 10 . . . 40436 839 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 839 2 26 26 CD 40436 839 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 839 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 839 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 839 6 26 26 CD 40436 839 7 : : : 40436 839 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 839 9 , , , 40436 839 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 839 11 . . . 40436 840 1 i. i. NNP 40436 841 1 135 135 CD 40436 841 2 . . . 40436 841 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 842 1 ALKIBIADES ALKIBIADES NNP 40436 842 2 II II NNP 40436 842 3 . . . 40436 843 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 843 2 Side side NN 40436 843 3 - - HYPH 40436 843 4 note note NN 40436 843 5 : : : 40436 843 6 Second Second NNP 40436 843 7 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 843 8 -- -- : 40436 843 9 situation situation NN 40436 843 10 supposed suppose VBN 40436 843 11 . . . 40436 843 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 844 1 The the DT 40436 844 2 other other JJ 40436 844 3 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 844 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 844 5 , , , 40436 844 6 termed term VBD 40436 844 7 the the DT 40436 844 8 Second Second NNP 40436 844 9 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 844 10 , , , 40436 844 11 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 844 12 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 844 13 as as IN 40436 844 14 about about IN 40436 844 15 to to TO 40436 844 16 offer offer VB 40436 844 17 prayer prayer NN 40436 844 18 and and CC 40436 844 19 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 844 20 to to IN 40436 844 21 the the DT 40436 844 22 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 844 23 . . . 40436 845 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 845 2 Side side NN 40436 845 3 - - HYPH 40436 845 4 note note NN 40436 845 5 : : : 40436 845 6 Danger danger NN 40436 845 7 of of IN 40436 845 8 mistake mistake NN 40436 845 9 in in IN 40436 845 10 praying pray VBG 40436 845 11 to to IN 40436 845 12 the the DT 40436 845 13 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 845 14 for for IN 40436 845 15 gifts gift NNS 40436 845 16 which which WDT 40436 845 17 may may MD 40436 845 18 prove prove VB 40436 845 19 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 845 20 . . . 40436 846 1 Most Most JJS 40436 846 2 men man NNS 40436 846 3 are be VBP 40436 846 4 unwise unwise JJ 40436 846 5 . . . 40436 847 1 Unwise Unwise NNP 40436 847 2 is be VBZ 40436 847 3 the the DT 40436 847 4 generic generic JJ 40436 847 5 word word NN 40436 847 6 : : : 40436 847 7 madmen madmen NNP 40436 847 8 , , , 40436 847 9 a a DT 40436 847 10 particular particular JJ 40436 847 11 variety variety NN 40436 847 12 under under IN 40436 847 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 847 14 . . . 40436 847 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 848 1 _ _ NNP 40436 848 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 848 3 seem seem VBP 40436 848 4 absorbed absorb VBN 40436 848 5 in in IN 40436 848 6 thought thought NN 40436 848 7 , , , 40436 848 8 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 848 9 , , , 40436 848 10 and and CC 40436 848 11 not not RB 40436 848 12 unreasonably unreasonably RB 40436 848 13 . . . 40436 849 1 In in IN 40436 849 2 supplicating supplicate VBG 40436 849 3 the the DT 40436 849 4 Gods god NNS 40436 849 5 , , , 40436 849 6 caution caution NN 40436 849 7 is be VBZ 40436 849 8 required require VBN 40436 849 9 not not RB 40436 849 10 to to TO 40436 849 11 pray pray VB 40436 849 12 for for IN 40436 849 13 gifts gift NNS 40436 849 14 which which WDT 40436 849 15 are be VBP 40436 849 16 really really RB 40436 849 17 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 849 18 . . . 40436 850 1 The the DT 40436 850 2 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 850 3 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 850 4 grant grant VBP 40436 850 5 men man NNS 40436 850 6 's 's POS 40436 850 7 prayers prayer NNS 40436 850 8 , , , 40436 850 9 even even RB 40436 850 10 when when WRB 40436 850 11 ruinously ruinously RB 40436 850 12 destructive destructive JJ 40436 850 13 ; ; : 40436 850 14 as as IN 40436 850 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 850 16 granted grant VBD 40436 850 17 the the DT 40436 850 18 prayers prayer NNS 40436 850 19 of of IN 40436 850 20 Oedipus Oedipus NNP 40436 850 21 , , , 40436 850 22 to to IN 40436 850 23 the the DT 40436 850 24 destruction destruction NN 40436 850 25 of of IN 40436 850 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 850 27 own own JJ 40436 850 28 sons son NNS 40436 850 29 . . . 40436 851 1 _ _ NNP 40436 851 2 Alk._--Oedipus Alk._--Oedipus NNP 40436 851 3 was be VBD 40436 851 4 mad mad JJ 40436 851 5 : : : 40436 851 6 what what WP 40436 851 7 man man NN 40436 851 8 in in IN 40436 851 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 851 10 senses sense NNS 40436 851 11 would would MD 40436 851 12 put put VB 40436 851 13 up up RP 40436 851 14 such such PDT 40436 851 15 a a DT 40436 851 16 prayer prayer NN 40436 851 17 ? ? . 40436 852 1 _ _ NNP 40436 852 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 852 3 think think VBP 40436 852 4 that that IN 40436 852 5 madness madness NN 40436 852 6 is be VBZ 40436 852 7 the the DT 40436 852 8 opposite opposite NN 40436 852 9 of of IN 40436 852 10 good good JJ 40436 852 11 sense sense NN 40436 852 12 or or CC 40436 852 13 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 852 14 . . . 40436 853 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 853 2 recognise recognise VBP 40436 853 3 men man NNS 40436 853 4 wise wise JJ 40436 853 5 and and CC 40436 853 6 unwise unwise JJ 40436 853 7 : : : 40436 853 8 and and CC 40436 853 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 853 10 farther farther RB 40436 853 11 admit admit VBP 40436 853 12 that that IN 40436 853 13 every every DT 40436 853 14 man man NN 40436 853 15 must must MD 40436 853 16 be be VB 40436 853 17 one one CD 40436 853 18 or or CC 40436 853 19 other other JJ 40436 853 20 of of IN 40436 853 21 the the DT 40436 853 22 two,--just two,--just NNP 40436 853 23 as as IN 40436 853 24 every every DT 40436 853 25 man man NN 40436 853 26 must must MD 40436 853 27 be be VB 40436 853 28 either either CC 40436 853 29 healthy healthy JJ 40436 853 30 or or CC 40436 853 31 sick sick JJ 40436 853 32 : : : 40436 853 33 there there EX 40436 853 34 is be VBZ 40436 853 35 no no DT 40436 853 36 third third JJ 40436 853 37 alternative alternative NN 40436 853 38 possible possible JJ 40436 853 39 ? ? . 40436 854 1 _ _ NNP 40436 854 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 854 3 think think VBP 40436 854 4 so so RB 40436 854 5 . . . 40436 855 1 _ _ NNP 40436 855 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 855 3 each each DT 40436 855 4 thing thing NN 40436 855 5 can can MD 40436 855 6 have have VB 40436 855 7 but but CC 40436 855 8 one one CD 40436 855 9 opposite:[27 opposite:[27 NN 40436 855 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 855 11 to to TO 40436 855 12 be be VB 40436 855 13 unwise unwise JJ 40436 855 14 , , , 40436 855 15 and and CC 40436 855 16 to to TO 40436 855 17 be be VB 40436 855 18 mad mad JJ 40436 855 19 , , , 40436 855 20 are be VBP 40436 855 21 therefore therefore RB 40436 855 22 identical identical JJ 40436 855 23 ? ? . 40436 856 1 _ _ NNP 40436 856 2 Alk._--They Alk._--They NNP 40436 856 3 are be VBP 40436 856 4 . . . 40436 857 1 _ _ NNP 40436 857 2 Sokr._--Wise Sokr._--Wise NNP 40436 857 3 men man NNS 40436 857 4 are be VBP 40436 857 5 only only RB 40436 857 6 few few JJ 40436 857 7 , , , 40436 857 8 the the DT 40436 857 9 majority majority NN 40436 857 10 of of IN 40436 857 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 857 12 citizens citizen NNS 40436 857 13 are be VBP 40436 857 14 unwise unwise JJ 40436 857 15 : : : 40436 857 16 but but CC 40436 857 17 do do VBP 40436 857 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 857 19 really really RB 40436 857 20 think think VB 40436 857 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 857 22 mad mad JJ 40436 857 23 ? ? . 40436 858 1 How how WRB 40436 858 2 could could MD 40436 858 3 any any DT 40436 858 4 of of IN 40436 858 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 858 6 live live VBP 40436 858 7 safely safely RB 40436 858 8 in in IN 40436 858 9 the the DT 40436 858 10 society society NN 40436 858 11 of of IN 40436 858 12 so so RB 40436 858 13 many many JJ 40436 858 14 mad mad JJ 40436 858 15 - - HYPH 40436 858 16 men man NNS 40436 858 17 ? ? . 40436 859 1 _ _ NNP 40436 859 2 Alk._--No Alk._--No NNP 40436 859 3 : : : 40436 859 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 859 5 can can MD 40436 859 6 not not RB 40436 859 7 be be VB 40436 859 8 so so RB 40436 859 9 : : : 40436 859 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 859 11 was be VBD 40436 859 12 mistaken mistaken JJ 40436 859 13 . . . 40436 860 1 _ _ NNP 40436 860 2 Sokr._--Here Sokr._--Here NNP 40436 860 3 is be VBZ 40436 860 4 the the DT 40436 860 5 illustration illustration NN 40436 860 6 of of IN 40436 860 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 860 8 mistake mistake NN 40436 860 9 . . . 40436 861 1 All all DT 40436 861 2 men man NNS 40436 861 3 who who WP 40436 861 4 have have VBP 40436 861 5 gout gout NN 40436 861 6 , , , 40436 861 7 or or CC 40436 861 8 fever fever NN 40436 861 9 , , , 40436 861 10 or or CC 40436 861 11 ophthalmia ophthalmia NN 40436 861 12 are be VBP 40436 861 13 sick sick JJ 40436 861 14 ; ; : 40436 861 15 but but CC 40436 861 16 all all DT 40436 861 17 sick sick JJ 40436 861 18 men man NNS 40436 861 19 have have VBP 40436 861 20 not not RB 40436 861 21 gout gout VB 40436 861 22 , , , 40436 861 23 or or CC 40436 861 24 fever fever NN 40436 861 25 , , , 40436 861 26 or or CC 40436 861 27 ophthalmia ophthalmia NN 40436 861 28 . . . 40436 862 1 So so RB 40436 862 2 , , , 40436 862 3 too too RB 40436 862 4 , , , 40436 862 5 all all DT 40436 862 6 carpenters carpenter NNS 40436 862 7 , , , 40436 862 8 or or CC 40436 862 9 shoemakers shoemaker NNS 40436 862 10 , , , 40436 862 11 or or CC 40436 862 12 sculptors sculptor NNS 40436 862 13 , , , 40436 862 14 are be VBP 40436 862 15 craftsmen craftsman NNS 40436 862 16 ; ; : 40436 862 17 but but CC 40436 862 18 all all DT 40436 862 19 craftsmen craftsman NNS 40436 862 20 are be VBP 40436 862 21 not not RB 40436 862 22 carpenters carpenter NNS 40436 862 23 , , , 40436 862 24 or or CC 40436 862 25 shoemakers shoemaker NNS 40436 862 26 , , , 40436 862 27 or or CC 40436 862 28 sculptors sculptor NNS 40436 862 29 . . . 40436 863 1 In in IN 40436 863 2 like like JJ 40436 863 3 manner manner NN 40436 863 4 , , , 40436 863 5 all all DT 40436 863 6 mad mad JJ 40436 863 7 men man NNS 40436 863 8 are be VBP 40436 863 9 unwise unwise JJ 40436 863 10 ; ; : 40436 863 11 but but CC 40436 863 12 all all DT 40436 863 13 unwise unwise JJ 40436 863 14 men man NNS 40436 863 15 are be VBP 40436 863 16 not not RB 40436 863 17 mad mad JJ 40436 863 18 . . . 40436 864 1 _ _ NNP 40436 864 2 Unwise Unwise NNP 40436 864 3 _ _ NNP 40436 864 4 comprises comprise VBZ 40436 864 5 many many JJ 40436 864 6 varieties variety NNS 40436 864 7 and and CC 40436 864 8 gradations gradation NNS 40436 864 9 of of IN 40436 864 10 which which WDT 40436 864 11 the the DT 40436 864 12 extreme extreme NN 40436 864 13 is be VBZ 40436 864 14 , , , 40436 864 15 being be VBG 40436 864 16 mad mad JJ 40436 864 17 : : : 40436 864 18 but but CC 40436 864 19 these these DT 40436 864 20 varieties variety NNS 40436 864 21 are be VBP 40436 864 22 different different JJ 40436 864 23 among among IN 40436 864 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 864 25 , , , 40436 864 26 as as IN 40436 864 27 one one CD 40436 864 28 disease disease NN 40436 864 29 differs differ VBZ 40436 864 30 from from IN 40436 864 31 another another DT 40436 864 32 , , , 40436 864 33 though though RB 40436 864 34 all all DT 40436 864 35 agree agree VBP 40436 864 36 in in IN 40436 864 37 being be VBG 40436 864 38 disease disease NN 40436 864 39 and and CC 40436 864 40 one one CD 40436 864 41 art art NN 40436 864 42 differs differ VBZ 40436 864 43 from from IN 40436 864 44 another another DT 40436 864 45 , , , 40436 864 46 though though RB 40436 864 47 all all DT 40436 864 48 agree agree VBP 40436 864 49 in in IN 40436 864 50 being be VBG 40436 864 51 art art NN 40436 864 52 . . . 40436 865 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 865 2 28 28 CD 40436 865 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 865 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 865 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 865 6 27 27 CD 40436 865 7 : : : 40436 865 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 865 9 , , , 40436 865 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 865 11 . . . 40436 866 1 ii ii LS 40436 866 2 . . . 40436 867 1 p. p. NN 40436 867 2 139 139 CD 40436 867 3 B. B. NNP 40436 868 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 868 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 868 3 : : : 40436 868 4 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 868 5 mê\n mê\n NNP 40436 868 6 du du NNP 40436 868 7 / / SYM 40436 868 8 o o NNP 40436 868 9 ge ge NNP 40436 868 10 u(penanti u(penanti NNP 40436 868 11 / / SYM 40436 868 12 a a DT 40436 868 13 e(ni\ e(ni\ NNP 40436 868 14 pra pra NNP 40436 868 15 / / SYM 40436 868 16 gmati gmati NNP 40436 868 17 pô pô NNP 40436 868 18 = = SYM 40436 868 19 s s NN 40436 868 20 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 868 21 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 868 22 ? ? . 40436 868 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 869 1 That that IN 40436 869 2 each each DT 40436 869 3 thing thing NN 40436 869 4 has have VBZ 40436 869 5 one one CD 40436 869 6 opposite opposite NN 40436 869 7 , , , 40436 869 8 and and CC 40436 869 9 no no RB 40436 869 10 more more JJR 40436 869 11 , , , 40436 869 12 is be VBZ 40436 869 13 asserted assert VBN 40436 869 14 in in IN 40436 869 15 the the DT 40436 869 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 869 17 also also RB 40436 869 18 , , , 40436 869 19 p. p. NN 40436 870 1 192 192 CD 40436 870 2 - - SYM 40436 870 3 193 193 CD 40436 870 4 . . . 40436 870 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 871 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 871 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 871 3 28 28 CD 40436 871 4 : : : 40436 871 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 871 6 , , , 40436 871 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 871 8 . . . 40436 872 1 ii ii LS 40436 872 2 . . . 40436 873 1 p. p. NN 40436 873 2 139 139 CD 40436 873 3 - - SYM 40436 873 4 140 140 CD 40436 873 5 A A NNP 40436 873 6 - - HYPH 40436 873 7 B. b. NN 40436 874 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 874 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 874 3 : : : 40436 874 4 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 874 5 ga\r ga\r VB 40436 874 6 oi oi PRP 40436 874 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 874 8 pure pure JJ 40436 874 9 / / SYM 40436 874 10 ttontes ttonte VBZ 40436 874 11 pa pa NNP 40436 874 12 / / SYM 40436 874 13 ntes ntes NNP 40436 874 14 nosou nosou NNP 40436 874 15 = = SYM 40436 874 16 sin sin NN 40436 874 17 , , , 40436 874 18 ou ou NNP 40436 874 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 874 20 me -PRON- PRP 40436 874 21 / / SYM 40436 874 22 nntoioi nntoioi NNP 40436 874 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 874 24 nosou nosou NNP 40436 874 25 = = SYM 40436 874 26 ntes ntes NNP 40436 874 27 pa pa NNP 40436 874 28 / / SYM 40436 874 29 ntes ntes NNP 40436 874 30 pure pure JJ 40436 874 31 / / SYM 40436 874 32 ttousin ttousin NN 40436 874 33 ou)de\ ou)de\ JJ 40436 874 34 podagrô podagrô NN 40436 874 35 = = SYM 40436 874 36 sin sin NN 40436 874 37 ou)de/ ou)de/ NNP 40436 874 38 ge ge NNP 40436 874 39 o)phthalmiô o)phthalmiô NFP 40436 874 40 = = SYM 40436 874 41 sin sin NN 40436 874 42 ; ; : 40436 874 43 a)lla\ a)lla\ `` 40436 874 44 no no DT 40436 874 45 / / SYM 40436 874 46 sos sos NNP 40436 874 47 me\n me\n NNP 40436 874 48 pa pa NNP 40436 874 49 = = SYM 40436 874 50 n n CC 40436 874 51 to\ to\ NN 40436 874 52 toiou toiou NNP 40436 874 53 = = NNS 40436 874 54 to to IN 40436 874 55 / / SYM 40436 874 56 n n NNP 40436 874 57 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 874 58 , , , 40436 874 59 diaphe diaphe NNP 40436 874 60 / / SYM 40436 874 61 rein rein NNP 40436 874 62 de/ de/ NNP 40436 874 63 phasin phasin NNP 40436 874 64 ou(\s ou(\s NNP 40436 874 65 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 874 66 kalou kalou NNP 40436 874 67 = = SYM 40436 874 68 men man NNS 40436 874 69 i)atros i)atros . 40436 874 70 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 874 71 a)pergasi a)pergasi NNP 40436 874 72 / / SYM 40436 874 73 an an DT 40436 874 74 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 874 75 = = SYM 40436 874 76 n n CC 40436 874 77 ; ; : 40436 874 78 ou ou NNP 40436 874 79 ) ) -RRB- 40436 874 80 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 874 81 pa pa NNP 40436 874 82 = = SYM 40436 874 83 sai sai NNP 40436 874 84 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 874 85 o(/moiai o(/moiai NNP 40436 874 86 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 874 87 o(moi o(moi NNP 40436 874 88 / / SYM 40436 874 89 ôs ôs NNP 40436 874 90 diapra diapra NNP 40436 874 91 / / SYM 40436 874 92 ttontai ttontai NNP 40436 874 93 , , , 40436 874 94 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 874 95 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 874 96 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 874 97 au)tê au)tê NNP 40436 874 98 = = SYM 40436 874 99 s s POS 40436 874 100 du du NN 40436 874 101 / / SYM 40436 874 102 namin namin NNP 40436 874 103 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 874 104 / / SYM 40436 874 105 stê stê NNP 40436 874 106 . . . 40436 874 107 ] ] -RRB- 40436 874 108 ] ] -RRB- 40436 875 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 875 2 Side side NN 40436 875 3 - - HYPH 40436 875 4 note note NN 40436 875 5 : : : 40436 875 6 Relation relation NN 40436 875 7 between between IN 40436 875 8 a a DT 40436 875 9 generic generic JJ 40436 875 10 term term NN 40436 875 11 , , , 40436 875 12 and and CC 40436 875 13 the the DT 40436 875 14 specific specific JJ 40436 875 15 terms term NNS 40436 875 16 comprehended comprehend VBD 40436 875 17 under under IN 40436 875 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 875 19 , , , 40436 875 20 was be VBD 40436 875 21 not not RB 40436 875 22 then then RB 40436 875 23 familiar familiar JJ 40436 875 24 . . . 40436 875 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 876 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 876 2 We -PRON- PRP 40436 876 3 may may MD 40436 876 4 remark remark VB 40436 876 5 that that IN 40436 876 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 876 7 here here RB 40436 876 8 , , , 40436 876 9 as as IN 40436 876 10 in in IN 40436 876 11 the the DT 40436 876 12 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 876 13 , , , 40436 876 14 brings bring VBZ 40436 876 15 under under IN 40436 876 16 especial especial JJ 40436 876 17 notice notice NN 40436 876 18 one one CD 40436 876 19 of of IN 40436 876 20 the the DT 40436 876 21 most most RBS 40436 876 22 important important JJ 40436 876 23 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 876 24 in in IN 40436 876 25 formal formal JJ 40436 876 26 logic logic NN 40436 876 27 -- -- : 40436 876 28 that that IN 40436 876 29 between between IN 40436 876 30 a a DT 40436 876 31 generic generic NN 40436 876 32 between between IN 40436 876 33 a a DT 40436 876 34 term term NN 40436 876 35 and and CC 40436 876 36 the the DT 40436 876 37 various various JJ 40436 876 38 specific specific JJ 40436 876 39 terms term NNS 40436 876 40 comprehended comprehend VBN 40436 876 41 under under IN 40436 876 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 876 43 . . . 40436 877 1 Possessing possess VBG 40436 877 2 as as IN 40436 877 3 yet yet RB 40436 877 4 no no DT 40436 877 5 technical technical JJ 40436 877 6 language language NN 40436 877 7 for for IN 40436 877 8 characterising characterise VBG 40436 877 9 this this DT 40436 877 10 distinction distinction NN 40436 877 11 , , , 40436 877 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 877 13 makes make VBZ 40436 877 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 877 15 understood understand VBN 40436 877 16 by by IN 40436 877 17 an an DT 40436 877 18 induction induction NN 40436 877 19 of of IN 40436 877 20 several several JJ 40436 877 21 separate separate JJ 40436 877 22 but but CC 40436 877 23 analogous analogous JJ 40436 877 24 cases case NNS 40436 877 25 . . . 40436 878 1 Because because IN 40436 878 2 the the DT 40436 878 3 distinction distinction NN 40436 878 4 is be VBZ 40436 878 5 familiar familiar JJ 40436 878 6 now now RB 40436 878 7 to to IN 40436 878 8 instructed instruct VBN 40436 878 9 men man NNS 40436 878 10 , , , 40436 878 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 878 12 must must MD 40436 878 13 not not RB 40436 878 14 suppose suppose VB 40436 878 15 that that IN 40436 878 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 878 17 was be VBD 40436 878 18 familiar familiar JJ 40436 878 19 then then RB 40436 878 20 . . . 40436 878 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 879 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 879 2 Side side NN 40436 879 3 - - HYPH 40436 879 4 note note NN 40436 879 5 : : : 40436 879 6 Frequent frequent JJ 40436 879 7 cases case NNS 40436 879 8 , , , 40436 879 9 in in IN 40436 879 10 which which WDT 40436 879 11 men man NNS 40436 879 12 pray pray VBP 40436 879 13 for for IN 40436 879 14 supposed suppose VBN 40436 879 15 benefits benefit NNS 40436 879 16 , , , 40436 879 17 and and CC 40436 879 18 find find VB 40436 879 19 that that IN 40436 879 20 when when WRB 40436 879 21 obtained obtain VBN 40436 879 22 , , , 40436 879 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 879 24 are be VBP 40436 879 25 misfortunes misfortune NNS 40436 879 26 . . . 40436 880 1 Every every DT 40436 880 2 one one CD 40436 880 3 fancies fancy VBZ 40436 880 4 that that WDT 40436 880 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 880 6 knows know VBZ 40436 880 7 what what WP 40436 880 8 is be VBZ 40436 880 9 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 880 10 : : : 40436 880 11 mischiefs mischiefs NNP 40436 880 12 of of IN 40436 880 13 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 880 14 . . . 40436 880 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 881 1 _ _ NNP 40436 881 2 Sokr._--Whom Sokr._--Whom NNP 40436 881 3 do do VBP 40436 881 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 881 5 call call VB 40436 881 6 wise wise JJ 40436 881 7 and and CC 40436 881 8 unwise unwise JJ 40436 881 9 ? ? . 40436 882 1 Is be VBZ 40436 882 2 not not RB 40436 882 3 the the DT 40436 882 4 wise wise JJ 40436 882 5 man man NN 40436 882 6 , , , 40436 882 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 882 8 who who WP 40436 882 9 knows know VBZ 40436 882 10 what what WP 40436 882 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 882 12 is be VBZ 40436 882 13 proper proper JJ 40436 882 14 to to TO 40436 882 15 say say VB 40436 882 16 and and CC 40436 882 17 do do VB 40436 882 18 -- -- : 40436 882 19 and and CC 40436 882 20 the the DT 40436 882 21 unwise unwise JJ 40436 882 22 man man NN 40436 882 23 , , , 40436 882 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 882 25 who who WP 40436 882 26 does do VBZ 40436 882 27 not not RB 40436 882 28 know know VB 40436 882 29 ? ? . 40436 883 1 _ _ NNP 40436 883 2 Alk._--Yes Alk._--Yes NNP 40436 883 3 . . . 40436 884 1 _ _ NNP 40436 884 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 884 3 unwise unwise JJ 40436 884 4 man man NN 40436 884 5 will will MD 40436 884 6 thus thus RB 40436 884 7 often often RB 40436 884 8 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 884 9 say say VB 40436 884 10 or or CC 40436 884 11 do do VBP 40436 884 12 what what WP 40436 884 13 ought ought MD 40436 884 14 not not RB 40436 884 15 to to TO 40436 884 16 be be VB 40436 884 17 said say VBN 40436 884 18 or or CC 40436 884 19 done do VBN 40436 884 20 ? ? . 40436 885 1 Though though IN 40436 885 2 not not RB 40436 885 3 mad mad JJ 40436 885 4 like like IN 40436 885 5 Oedipus Oedipus NNP 40436 885 6 , , , 40436 885 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 885 8 will will MD 40436 885 9 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 885 10 pray pray VB 40436 885 11 to to IN 40436 885 12 the the DT 40436 885 13 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 885 14 for for IN 40436 885 15 gifts gift NNS 40436 885 16 , , , 40436 885 17 which which WDT 40436 885 18 will will MD 40436 885 19 be be VB 40436 885 20 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 885 21 to to IN 40436 885 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 885 23 if if IN 40436 885 24 obtained obtain VBN 40436 885 25 . . . 40436 886 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 886 2 , , , 40436 886 3 for for IN 40436 886 4 example example NN 40436 886 5 , , , 40436 886 6 would would MD 40436 886 7 be be VB 40436 886 8 overjoyed overjoyed JJ 40436 886 9 if if IN 40436 886 10 the the DT 40436 886 11 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 886 12 were be VBD 40436 886 13 to to TO 40436 886 14 promise promise VB 40436 886 15 that that IN 40436 886 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 886 17 should should MD 40436 886 18 become become VB 40436 886 19 despot despot NN 40436 886 20 not not RB 40436 886 21 only only RB 40436 886 22 over over IN 40436 886 23 Athens Athens NNP 40436 886 24 , , , 40436 886 25 but but CC 40436 886 26 also also RB 40436 886 27 over over IN 40436 886 28 Greece Greece NNP 40436 886 29 . . . 40436 887 1 _ _ NNP 40436 887 2 Alk._--Doubtless Alk._--Doubtless NNP 40436 887 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 887 4 should should MD 40436 887 5 : : : 40436 887 6 and and CC 40436 887 7 every every DT 40436 887 8 one one NN 40436 887 9 else else RB 40436 887 10 would would MD 40436 887 11 feel feel VB 40436 887 12 as as IN 40436 887 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 887 14 do do VBP 40436 887 15 . . . 40436 888 1 _ _ NNP 40436 888 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 888 3 what what WP 40436 888 4 if if IN 40436 888 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 888 6 were be VBD 40436 888 7 to to TO 40436 888 8 purchase purchase VB 40436 888 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 888 10 with with IN 40436 888 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 888 12 life life NN 40436 888 13 , , , 40436 888 14 or or CC 40436 888 15 to to TO 40436 888 16 damage damage VB 40436 888 17 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 888 18 by by IN 40436 888 19 the the DT 40436 888 20 employment employment NN 40436 888 21 of of IN 40436 888 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 888 23 ? ? . 40436 889 1 _ _ NNP 40436 889 2 Alk._--Not Alk._--Not NNP 40436 889 3 on on IN 40436 889 4 those those DT 40436 889 5 conditions condition NNS 40436 889 6 . . . 40436 890 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 890 2 29 29 CD 40436 890 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 890 4 _ _ NNP 40436 890 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 890 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 890 7 are be VBP 40436 890 8 aware aware JJ 40436 890 9 that that IN 40436 890 10 many many JJ 40436 890 11 ambitious ambitious JJ 40436 890 12 aspirants aspirant NNS 40436 890 13 , , , 40436 890 14 both both DT 40436 890 15 at at IN 40436 890 16 Athens Athens NNP 40436 890 17 and and CC 40436 890 18 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 890 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 890 20 among among IN 40436 890 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 890 22 , , , 40436 890 23 the the DT 40436 890 24 man man NN 40436 890 25 who who WP 40436 890 26 just just RB 40436 890 27 now now RB 40436 890 28 killed kill VBD 40436 890 29 the the DT 40436 890 30 Macedonian macedonian JJ 40436 890 31 King King NNP 40436 890 32 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 890 33 , , , 40436 890 34 and and CC 40436 890 35 usurped usurp VBD 40436 890 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 890 37 throne throne NN 40436 890 38 ) ) -RRB- 40436 890 39 , , , 40436 890 40 have have VBP 40436 890 41 acquired acquire VBN 40436 890 42 power power NN 40436 890 43 and and CC 40436 890 44 aggrandisement aggrandisement NN 40436 890 45 , , , 40436 890 46 so so IN 40436 890 47 as as IN 40436 890 48 to to TO 40436 890 49 be be VB 40436 890 50 envied envy VBN 40436 890 51 by by IN 40436 890 52 every every DT 40436 890 53 one one NN 40436 890 54 : : : 40436 890 55 yet yet RB 40436 890 56 have have VBP 40436 890 57 presently presently RB 40436 890 58 found find VBN 40436 890 59 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 890 60 brought bring VBN 40436 890 61 to to IN 40436 890 62 ruin ruin NN 40436 890 63 and and CC 40436 890 64 death death NN 40436 890 65 by by IN 40436 890 66 the the DT 40436 890 67 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 890 68 . . . 40436 891 1 So so RB 40436 891 2 , , , 40436 891 3 also also RB 40436 891 4 , , , 40436 891 5 many many JJ 40436 891 6 persons person NNS 40436 891 7 pray pray VBP 40436 891 8 that that IN 40436 891 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 891 10 may may MD 40436 891 11 become become VB 40436 891 12 fathers father NNS 40436 891 13 ; ; : 40436 891 14 but but CC 40436 891 15 discover discover VBP 40436 891 16 presently presently RB 40436 891 17 that that IN 40436 891 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 891 19 children child NNS 40436 891 20 are be VBP 40436 891 21 the the DT 40436 891 22 source source NN 40436 891 23 of of IN 40436 891 24 so so RB 40436 891 25 much much JJ 40436 891 26 grief grief NN 40436 891 27 to to IN 40436 891 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 891 29 , , , 40436 891 30 that that IN 40436 891 31 they -PRON- PRP 40436 891 32 wish wish VBP 40436 891 33 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 891 34 again again RB 40436 891 35 childless childless JJ 40436 891 36 . . . 40436 892 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 892 2 , , , 40436 892 3 though though IN 40436 892 4 such such JJ 40436 892 5 reverses reverse NNS 40436 892 6 are be VBP 40436 892 7 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 892 8 happening happen VBG 40436 892 9 , , , 40436 892 10 every every DT 40436 892 11 one one NN 40436 892 12 is be VBZ 40436 892 13 still still RB 40436 892 14 not not RB 40436 892 15 only only RB 40436 892 16 eager eager JJ 40436 892 17 to to TO 40436 892 18 obtain obtain VB 40436 892 19 these these DT 40436 892 20 supposed suppose VBN 40436 892 21 benefits benefit NNS 40436 892 22 , , , 40436 892 23 but but CC 40436 892 24 importunate importunate VB 40436 892 25 with with IN 40436 892 26 the the DT 40436 892 27 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 892 28 in in IN 40436 892 29 asking ask VBG 40436 892 30 for for IN 40436 892 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 892 32 . . . 40436 893 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 893 2 see see VBP 40436 893 3 that that IN 40436 893 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 893 5 is be VBZ 40436 893 6 not not RB 40436 893 7 safe safe JJ 40436 893 8 even even RB 40436 893 9 to to TO 40436 893 10 accept accept VB 40436 893 11 without without IN 40436 893 12 reflection reflection NN 40436 893 13 boons boon NNS 40436 893 14 offered offer VBN 40436 893 15 to to IN 40436 893 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 893 17 , , , 40436 893 18 much much RB 40436 893 19 less less JJR 40436 893 20 to to TO 40436 893 21 pray pray VB 40436 893 22 for for IN 40436 893 23 boons boon NNS 40436 893 24 to to TO 40436 893 25 be be VB 40436 893 26 conferred confer VBN 40436 893 27 . . . 40436 894 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 894 2 30 30 CD 40436 894 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 894 4 _ _ NNP 40436 894 5 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 894 6 see see VBP 40436 894 7 now now RB 40436 894 8 how how WRB 40436 894 9 much much JJ 40436 894 10 mischief mischief JJ 40436 894 11 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 894 12 produces produce VBZ 40436 894 13 . . . 40436 895 1 Every every DT 40436 895 2 one one NN 40436 895 3 thinks think VBZ 40436 895 4 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 895 5 competent competent JJ 40436 895 6 to to TO 40436 895 7 pray pray VB 40436 895 8 for for IN 40436 895 9 what what WP 40436 895 10 is be VBZ 40436 895 11 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 895 12 to to IN 40436 895 13 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 895 14 ; ; : 40436 895 15 but but CC 40436 895 16 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 895 17 makes make VBZ 40436 895 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 895 19 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 895 20 imprecate imprecate JJ 40436 895 21 mischief mischief NN 40436 895 22 on on IN 40436 895 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 895 24 own own JJ 40436 895 25 head head NN 40436 895 26 . . . 40436 896 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 896 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 896 3 29 29 CD 40436 896 4 : : : 40436 896 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 896 6 , , , 40436 896 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 896 8 . . . 40436 897 1 ii ii LS 40436 897 2 . . . 40436 898 1 p. p. NN 40436 899 1 141 141 CD 40436 899 2 . . . 40436 899 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 900 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 900 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 900 3 30 30 CD 40436 900 4 : : : 40436 900 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 900 6 , , , 40436 900 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 900 8 . . . 40436 901 1 ii ii LS 40436 901 2 . . . 40436 902 1 p. p. NN 40436 903 1 141 141 CD 40436 903 2 - - SYM 40436 903 3 142 142 CD 40436 903 4 . . . 40436 903 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 904 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 904 2 Side side NN 40436 904 3 - - HYPH 40436 904 4 note note NN 40436 904 5 : : : 40436 904 6 Mistake mistake NN 40436 904 7 in in IN 40436 904 8 predications predication NNS 40436 904 9 about about IN 40436 904 10 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 904 11 generally generally RB 40436 904 12 . . . 40436 905 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 905 2 must must MD 40436 905 3 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 905 4 . . . 40436 906 1 Ignorance ignorance NN 40436 906 2 of of IN 40436 906 3 _ _ NNP 40436 906 4 what what WP 40436 906 5 ? ? . 40436 906 6 _ _ NNP 40436 906 7 Ignorance Ignorance NNP 40436 906 8 of of IN 40436 906 9 good good NN 40436 906 10 , , , 40436 906 11 is be VBZ 40436 906 12 always always RB 40436 906 13 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 906 14 : : : 40436 906 15 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 906 16 of of IN 40436 906 17 other other JJ 40436 906 18 things thing NNS 40436 906 19 , , , 40436 906 20 not not RB 40436 906 21 always always RB 40436 906 22 . . . 40436 906 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 907 1 _ _ NNP 40436 907 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 907 3 ought ought MD 40436 907 4 not not RB 40436 907 5 to to TO 40436 907 6 denounce denounce VB 40436 907 7 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 907 8 in in IN 40436 907 9 this this DT 40436 907 10 unqualified unqualified JJ 40436 907 11 manner manner NN 40436 907 12 . . . 40436 908 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 908 2 must must MD 40436 908 3 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 908 4 and and CC 40436 908 5 specify specify VB 40436 908 6 . . . 40436 909 1 Ignorance ignorance NN 40436 909 2 of of IN 40436 909 3 what what WP 40436 909 4 ? ? . 40436 910 1 and and CC 40436 910 2 under under IN 40436 910 3 what what WDT 40436 910 4 modifications modification NNS 40436 910 5 of of IN 40436 910 6 persons person NNS 40436 910 7 and and CC 40436 910 8 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 910 9 ? ? . 40436 911 1 _ _ NNP 40436 911 2 Alk._--How Alk._--How NNP 40436 911 3 ? ? . 40436 912 1 Are be VBP 40436 912 2 there there EX 40436 912 3 _ _ NNP 40436 912 4 any any DT 40436 912 5 _ _ NNP 40436 912 6 matters matter NNS 40436 912 7 or or CC 40436 912 8 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 912 9 in in IN 40436 912 10 which which WDT 40436 912 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 912 12 is be VBZ 40436 912 13 better well JJR 40436 912 14 for for IN 40436 912 15 a a DT 40436 912 16 man man NN 40436 912 17 to to TO 40436 912 18 be be VB 40436 912 19 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 912 20 , , , 40436 912 21 than than IN 40436 912 22 to to TO 40436 912 23 know know VB 40436 912 24 ? ? . 40436 913 1 _ _ NNP 40436 913 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 913 3 will will MD 40436 913 4 see see VB 40436 913 5 that that IN 40436 913 6 there there EX 40436 913 7 are be VBP 40436 913 8 such such JJ 40436 913 9 . . . 40436 914 1 Ignorance ignorance NN 40436 914 2 of of IN 40436 914 3 good good JJ 40436 914 4 , , , 40436 914 5 or or CC 40436 914 6 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 914 7 of of IN 40436 914 8 what what WP 40436 914 9 is be VBZ 40436 914 10 best good JJS 40436 914 11 , , , 40436 914 12 is be VBZ 40436 914 13 always always RB 40436 914 14 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 914 15 : : : 40436 914 16 moreover moreover RB 40436 914 17 , , , 40436 914 18 assuming assume VBG 40436 914 19 that that IN 40436 914 20 a a DT 40436 914 21 man man NN 40436 914 22 knows know VBZ 40436 914 23 what what WP 40436 914 24 is be VBZ 40436 914 25 best good JJS 40436 914 26 , , , 40436 914 27 then then RB 40436 914 28 all all DT 40436 914 29 other other JJ 40436 914 30 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 914 31 will will MD 40436 914 32 be be VB 40436 914 33 profitable profitable JJ 40436 914 34 to to IN 40436 914 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 914 36 . . . 40436 915 1 In in IN 40436 915 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 915 3 special special JJ 40436 915 4 case case NN 40436 915 5 , , , 40436 915 6 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 915 7 on on IN 40436 915 8 any any DT 40436 915 9 subject subject NN 40436 915 10 can can MD 40436 915 11 not not RB 40436 915 12 be be VB 40436 915 13 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 915 14 than than IN 40436 915 15 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 915 16 . . . 40436 916 1 But but CC 40436 916 2 if if IN 40436 916 3 a a DT 40436 916 4 man man NN 40436 916 5 be be VB 40436 916 6 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 916 7 things thing NNS 40436 916 8 of of IN 40436 916 9 good good JJ 40436 916 10 , , , 40436 916 11 or or CC 40436 916 12 of of IN 40436 916 13 what what WP 40436 916 14 is be VBZ 40436 916 15 best good JJS 40436 916 16 , , , 40436 916 17 in in IN 40436 916 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 916 19 case case NN 40436 916 20 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 916 21 on on IN 40436 916 22 other other JJ 40436 916 23 subjects subject NNS 40436 916 24 will will MD 40436 916 25 be be VB 40436 916 26 more more RBR 40436 916 27 often often RB 40436 916 28 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 916 29 than than IN 40436 916 30 profitable profitable JJ 40436 916 31 . . . 40436 917 1 To to IN 40436 917 2 a a DT 40436 917 3 man man NN 40436 917 4 like like IN 40436 917 5 Orestes Orestes NNP 40436 917 6 , , , 40436 917 7 so so RB 40436 917 8 misguided misguided JJ 40436 917 9 on on IN 40436 917 10 the the DT 40436 917 11 question question NN 40436 917 12 , , , 40436 917 13 " " `` 40436 917 14 What what WP 40436 917 15 is be VBZ 40436 917 16 good good JJ 40436 917 17 ? ? . 40436 917 18 " " '' 40436 918 1 as as IN 40436 918 2 to to TO 40436 918 3 resolve resolve VB 40436 918 4 to to TO 40436 918 5 kill kill VB 40436 918 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 918 7 mother mother NN 40436 918 8 , , , 40436 918 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 918 10 would would MD 40436 918 11 be be VB 40436 918 12 a a DT 40436 918 13 real real JJ 40436 918 14 benefit benefit NN 40436 918 15 , , , 40436 918 16 if if IN 40436 918 17 for for IN 40436 918 18 the the DT 40436 918 19 time time NN 40436 918 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 918 21 did do VBD 40436 918 22 not not RB 40436 918 23 know know VB 40436 918 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 918 25 mother mother NN 40436 918 26 . . . 40436 919 1 Ignorance ignorance NN 40436 919 2 on on IN 40436 919 3 that that DT 40436 919 4 point point NN 40436 919 5 , , , 40436 919 6 in in IN 40436 919 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 919 8 state state NN 40436 919 9 of of IN 40436 919 10 mind mind NN 40436 919 11 , , , 40436 919 12 would would MD 40436 919 13 be be VB 40436 919 14 better well JJR 40436 919 15 for for IN 40436 919 16 him -PRON- PRP 40436 919 17 than than IN 40436 919 18 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 919 19 . . . 40436 920 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 920 2 31 31 CD 40436 920 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 920 4 _ _ NNP 40436 920 5 Alk._--It Alk._--It NNP 40436 920 6 appears appear VBZ 40436 920 7 so so RB 40436 920 8 . . . 40436 921 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 921 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 921 3 31 31 CD 40436 921 4 : : : 40436 921 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 921 6 , , , 40436 921 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 921 8 . . . 40436 922 1 ii ii LS 40436 922 2 . . . 40436 923 1 p. p. NN 40436 924 1 144 144 CD 40436 924 2 . . . 40436 924 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 925 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 925 2 Side side NN 40436 925 3 - - HYPH 40436 925 4 note note NN 40436 925 5 : : : 40436 925 6 Wise wise JJ 40436 925 7 public public JJ 40436 925 8 counsellors counsellor NNS 40436 925 9 are be VBP 40436 925 10 few few JJ 40436 925 11 . . . 40436 926 1 Upon upon IN 40436 926 2 what what WDT 40436 926 3 ground ground NN 40436 926 4 do do VBP 40436 926 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 926 6 call call VB 40436 926 7 these these DT 40436 926 8 few few JJ 40436 926 9 wise wise JJ 40436 926 10 ? ? . 40436 927 1 Not not RB 40436 927 2 because because IN 40436 927 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 927 4 possess possess VBP 40436 927 5 merely merely RB 40436 927 6 special special JJ 40436 927 7 arts art NNS 40436 927 8 or or CC 40436 927 9 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 927 10 , , , 40436 927 11 but but CC 40436 927 12 because because IN 40436 927 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 927 14 know know VBP 40436 927 15 besides besides RB 40436 927 16 , , , 40436 927 17 upon upon IN 40436 927 18 what what WP 40436 927 19 occasions occasion NNS 40436 927 20 and and CC 40436 927 21 under under IN 40436 927 22 what what WP 40436 927 23 limits limit VBZ 40436 927 24 each each DT 40436 927 25 of of IN 40436 927 26 these these DT 40436 927 27 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 927 28 ought ought MD 40436 927 29 to to TO 40436 927 30 be be VB 40436 927 31 used use VBN 40436 927 32 . . . 40436 927 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 928 1 _ _ NNP 40436 928 2 Sokr._--Follow Sokr._--Follow NNP 40436 928 3 the the DT 40436 928 4 argument argument NN 40436 928 5 farther farther RB 40436 928 6 . . . 40436 929 1 When when WRB 40436 929 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 929 3 come come VBP 40436 929 4 forward forward RB 40436 929 5 to to TO 40436 929 6 say say VB 40436 929 7 or or CC 40436 929 8 do do VB 40436 929 9 any any DT 40436 929 10 thing thing NN 40436 929 11 , , , 40436 929 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 929 13 either either CC 40436 929 14 know know VBP 40436 929 15 what what WP 40436 929 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 929 17 are be VBP 40436 929 18 about about JJ 40436 929 19 to to TO 40436 929 20 say say VB 40436 929 21 and and CC 40436 929 22 do do VB 40436 929 23 , , , 40436 929 24 or or CC 40436 929 25 at at IN 40436 929 26 least least JJS 40436 929 27 believe believe VB 40436 929 28 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 929 29 to to TO 40436 929 30 know know VB 40436 929 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 929 32 . . . 40436 930 1 Every every DT 40436 930 2 statesman statesman NN 40436 930 3 who who WP 40436 930 4 gives give VBZ 40436 930 5 counsel counsel NN 40436 930 6 to to IN 40436 930 7 the the DT 40436 930 8 public public NN 40436 930 9 , , , 40436 930 10 does do VBZ 40436 930 11 so so RB 40436 930 12 in in IN 40436 930 13 the the DT 40436 930 14 faith faith NN 40436 930 15 of of IN 40436 930 16 such such JJ 40436 930 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 930 18 . . . 40436 931 1 Most Most JJS 40436 931 2 citizens citizen NNS 40436 931 3 are be VBP 40436 931 4 unwise unwise JJ 40436 931 5 , , , 40436 931 6 and and CC 40436 931 7 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 931 8 of of IN 40436 931 9 good good JJ 40436 931 10 as as RB 40436 931 11 well well RB 40436 931 12 as as IN 40436 931 13 of of IN 40436 931 14 other other JJ 40436 931 15 things thing NNS 40436 931 16 . . . 40436 932 1 The the DT 40436 932 2 wise wise JJ 40436 932 3 are be VBP 40436 932 4 but but CC 40436 932 5 few few JJ 40436 932 6 , , , 40436 932 7 and and CC 40436 932 8 by by IN 40436 932 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 932 10 advice advice NN 40436 932 11 the the DT 40436 932 12 city city NN 40436 932 13 is be VBZ 40436 932 14 conducted conduct VBN 40436 932 15 . . . 40436 933 1 Now now RB 40436 933 2 upon upon IN 40436 933 3 what what WP 40436 933 4 ground ground NN 40436 933 5 do do VBP 40436 933 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 933 7 call call VB 40436 933 8 these these DT 40436 933 9 few few JJ 40436 933 10 , , , 40436 933 11 wise wise JJ 40436 933 12 and and CC 40436 933 13 useful useful JJ 40436 933 14 public public JJ 40436 933 15 counsellors counsellor NNS 40436 933 16 ? ? . 40436 934 1 If if IN 40436 934 2 a a DT 40436 934 3 statesman statesman NN 40436 934 4 knows know VBZ 40436 934 5 war war NN 40436 934 6 , , , 40436 934 7 but but CC 40436 934 8 does do VBZ 40436 934 9 not not RB 40436 934 10 know know VB 40436 934 11 whether whether IN 40436 934 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 934 13 is be VBZ 40436 934 14 best good JJS 40436 934 15 to to TO 40436 934 16 go go VB 40436 934 17 to to IN 40436 934 18 war war NN 40436 934 19 , , , 40436 934 20 or or CC 40436 934 21 at at IN 40436 934 22 what what WDT 40436 934 23 juncture juncture NN 40436 934 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 934 25 is be VBZ 40436 934 26 best good JJS 40436 934 27 -- -- : 40436 934 28 should should MD 40436 934 29 we -PRON- PRP 40436 934 30 call call VB 40436 934 31 him -PRON- PRP 40436 934 32 wise wise JJ 40436 934 33 ? ? . 40436 935 1 If if IN 40436 935 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 935 3 knows know VBZ 40436 935 4 how how WRB 40436 935 5 to to TO 40436 935 6 kill kill VB 40436 935 7 men man NNS 40436 935 8 , , , 40436 935 9 or or CC 40436 935 10 dispossess dispossess VB 40436 935 11 them -PRON- PRP 40436 935 12 , , , 40436 935 13 or or CC 40436 935 14 drive drive VB 40436 935 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 935 16 into into IN 40436 935 17 exile,--but exile,--but NNP 40436 935 18 does do VBZ 40436 935 19 not not RB 40436 935 20 know know VB 40436 935 21 upon upon IN 40436 935 22 whom whom WP 40436 935 23 , , , 40436 935 24 or or CC 40436 935 25 on on IN 40436 935 26 what what WDT 40436 935 27 occasions occasion NNS 40436 935 28 , , , 40436 935 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 935 30 is be VBZ 40436 935 31 good good JJ 40436 935 32 to to TO 40436 935 33 inflict inflict VB 40436 935 34 this this DT 40436 935 35 treatment treatment NN 40436 935 36 -- -- : 40436 935 37 is be VBZ 40436 935 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 935 39 a a DT 40436 935 40 useful useful JJ 40436 935 41 counsellor counsellor NN 40436 935 42 ? ? . 40436 936 1 If if IN 40436 936 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 936 3 can can MD 40436 936 4 ride ride VB 40436 936 5 , , , 40436 936 6 or or CC 40436 936 7 shoot shoot VB 40436 936 8 , , , 40436 936 9 or or CC 40436 936 10 wrestle wrestle NN 40436 936 11 , , , 40436 936 12 well,--we well,--we WDT 40436 936 13 give give VB 40436 936 14 him -PRON- PRP 40436 936 15 an an DT 40436 936 16 epithet epithet NN 40436 936 17 derived derive VBN 40436 936 18 from from IN 40436 936 19 this this DT 40436 936 20 special special JJ 40436 936 21 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 936 22 : : : 40436 936 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 936 24 do do VBP 40436 936 25 not not RB 40436 936 26 call call VB 40436 936 27 him -PRON- PRP 40436 936 28 wise wise JJ 40436 936 29 . . . 40436 937 1 What what WP 40436 937 2 would would MD 40436 937 3 be be VB 40436 937 4 the the DT 40436 937 5 condition condition NN 40436 937 6 of of IN 40436 937 7 a a DT 40436 937 8 community community NN 40436 937 9 composed compose VBN 40436 937 10 of of IN 40436 937 11 bowmen bowman NNS 40436 937 12 , , , 40436 937 13 horsemen horseman NNS 40436 937 14 , , , 40436 937 15 wrestlers wrestler NNS 40436 937 16 , , , 40436 937 17 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 937 18 , , , 40436 937 19 & & CC 40436 937 20 c. c. NNP 40436 937 21 , , , 40436 937 22 accomplished accomplished JJ 40436 937 23 and and CC 40436 937 24 excellent excellent JJ 40436 937 25 each each DT 40436 937 26 in in IN 40436 937 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 937 28 own own JJ 40436 937 29 particular particular JJ 40436 937 30 craft craft NN 40436 937 31 , , , 40436 937 32 yet yet CC 40436 937 33 none none NN 40436 937 34 of of IN 40436 937 35 them -PRON- PRP 40436 937 36 knowing know VBG 40436 937 37 what what WP 40436 937 38 is be VBZ 40436 937 39 good good JJ 40436 937 40 , , , 40436 937 41 nor nor CC 40436 937 42 when when WRB 40436 937 43 , , , 40436 937 44 nor nor CC 40436 937 45 on on IN 40436 937 46 what what WDT 40436 937 47 occasions occasion NNS 40436 937 48 , , , 40436 937 49 it -PRON- PRP 40436 937 50 is be VBZ 40436 937 51 good good JJ 40436 937 52 to to TO 40436 937 53 employ employ VB 40436 937 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 937 55 craft craft NN 40436 937 56 ? ? . 40436 938 1 When when WRB 40436 938 2 each each DT 40436 938 3 man man NN 40436 938 4 pushes push VBZ 40436 938 5 forward forward RB 40436 938 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 938 7 own own JJ 40436 938 8 art art NN 40436 938 9 and and CC 40436 938 10 speciality speciality NN 40436 938 11 , , , 40436 938 12 without without IN 40436 938 13 any any DT 40436 938 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 938 15 whether whether IN 40436 938 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 938 17 is be VBZ 40436 938 18 good good JJ 40436 938 19 on on IN 40436 938 20 the the DT 40436 938 21 whole whole NN 40436 938 22 either either CC 40436 938 23 for for IN 40436 938 24 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 938 25 or or CC 40436 938 26 for for IN 40436 938 27 the the DT 40436 938 28 city city NN 40436 938 29 , , , 40436 938 30 will will MD 40436 938 31 not not RB 40436 938 32 affairs affair NNS 40436 938 33 thus thus RB 40436 938 34 conducted conduct VBN 40436 938 35 be be VBP 40436 938 36 reckless reckless JJ 40436 938 37 and and CC 40436 938 38 disastrous disastrous JJ 40436 938 39 ? ? . 40436 939 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 939 2 32 32 CD 40436 939 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 939 4 _ _ NNP 40436 939 5 Alk._--They alk._--they NN 40436 939 6 will will MD 40436 939 7 be be VB 40436 939 8 very very RB 40436 939 9 bad bad JJ 40436 939 10 indeed indeed RB 40436 939 11 . . . 40436 940 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 940 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 940 3 32 32 CD 40436 940 4 : : : 40436 940 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 940 6 , , , 40436 940 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 940 8 . . . 40436 941 1 ii ii LS 40436 941 2 . . . 40436 942 1 p. p. NN 40436 943 1 145 145 CD 40436 943 2 . . . 40436 943 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 944 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 944 2 Side side NN 40436 944 3 - - HYPH 40436 944 4 note note NN 40436 944 5 : : : 40436 944 6 Special special JJ 40436 944 7 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 944 8 , , , 40436 944 9 without without IN 40436 944 10 the the DT 40436 944 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 944 12 of of IN 40436 944 13 the the DT 40436 944 14 good good JJ 40436 944 15 or or CC 40436 944 16 profitable profitable JJ 40436 944 17 , , , 40436 944 18 are be VBP 40436 944 19 oftener oftener RB 40436 944 20 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 944 21 than than IN 40436 944 22 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 944 23 . . . 40436 944 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 945 1 _ _ NNP 40436 945 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 945 3 , , , 40436 945 4 then then RB 40436 945 5 , , , 40436 945 6 a a DT 40436 945 7 man man NN 40436 945 8 has have VBZ 40436 945 9 no no DT 40436 945 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 945 11 of of IN 40436 945 12 good good NN 40436 945 13 or or CC 40436 945 14 of of IN 40436 945 15 the the DT 40436 945 16 better well JJR 40436 945 17 -- -- : 40436 945 18 if if IN 40436 945 19 upon upon IN 40436 945 20 this this DT 40436 945 21 cardinal cardinal JJ 40436 945 22 point point NN 40436 945 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 945 24 obeys obey VBZ 40436 945 25 fancy fancy JJ 40436 945 26 without without IN 40436 945 27 reason reason NN 40436 945 28 -- -- : 40436 945 29 the the DT 40436 945 30 possession possession NN 40436 945 31 of of IN 40436 945 32 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 945 33 upon upon IN 40436 945 34 special special JJ 40436 945 35 subjects subject NNS 40436 945 36 will will MD 40436 945 37 be be VB 40436 945 38 oftener oftener RB 40436 945 39 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 945 40 than than IN 40436 945 41 profitable profitable JJ 40436 945 42 to to IN 40436 945 43 him -PRON- PRP 40436 945 44 ; ; : 40436 945 45 because because IN 40436 945 46 it -PRON- PRP 40436 945 47 will will MD 40436 945 48 make make VB 40436 945 49 him -PRON- PRP 40436 945 50 more more RBR 40436 945 51 forward forward RB 40436 945 52 in in IN 40436 945 53 action action NN 40436 945 54 , , , 40436 945 55 without without IN 40436 945 56 any any DT 40436 945 57 good good JJ 40436 945 58 result result NN 40436 945 59 . . . 40436 946 1 Possessing possess VBG 40436 946 2 many many JJ 40436 946 3 arts art NNS 40436 946 4 and and CC 40436 946 5 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 946 6 , , , 40436 946 7 and and CC 40436 946 8 prosecuting prosecute VBG 40436 946 9 one one CD 40436 946 10 after after IN 40436 946 11 another another DT 40436 946 12 , , , 40436 946 13 but but CC 40436 946 14 without without IN 40436 946 15 the the DT 40436 946 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 946 17 of of IN 40436 946 18 good,--he good,--he NNP 40436 946 19 will will MD 40436 946 20 only only RB 40436 946 21 fall fall VB 40436 946 22 into into IN 40436 946 23 greater great JJR 40436 946 24 trouble trouble NN 40436 946 25 , , , 40436 946 26 like like IN 40436 946 27 a a DT 40436 946 28 ship ship NN 40436 946 29 sailing sailing NN 40436 946 30 without without IN 40436 946 31 a a DT 40436 946 32 pilot pilot NN 40436 946 33 . . . 40436 947 1 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 947 2 of of IN 40436 947 3 good good JJ 40436 947 4 is be VBZ 40436 947 5 , , , 40436 947 6 in in IN 40436 947 7 other other JJ 40436 947 8 words word NNS 40436 947 9 , , , 40436 947 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 947 11 of of IN 40436 947 12 what what WP 40436 947 13 is be VBZ 40436 947 14 useful useful JJ 40436 947 15 and and CC 40436 947 16 profitable profitable JJ 40436 947 17 . . . 40436 948 1 In in IN 40436 948 2 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 948 3 with with IN 40436 948 4 this this DT 40436 948 5 , , , 40436 948 6 all all DT 40436 948 7 other other JJ 40436 948 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 948 9 is be VBZ 40436 948 10 valuable valuable JJ 40436 948 11 , , , 40436 948 12 and and CC 40436 948 13 goes go VBZ 40436 948 14 to to TO 40436 948 15 increase increase VB 40436 948 16 a a DT 40436 948 17 man man NN 40436 948 18 's 's POS 40436 948 19 competence competence NN 40436 948 20 as as IN 40436 948 21 a a DT 40436 948 22 counsellor counsellor NN 40436 948 23 : : : 40436 948 24 apart apart RB 40436 948 25 from from IN 40436 948 26 this this DT 40436 948 27 , , , 40436 948 28 all all DT 40436 948 29 other other JJ 40436 948 30 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 948 31 will will MD 40436 948 32 not not RB 40436 948 33 render render VB 40436 948 34 a a DT 40436 948 35 man man NN 40436 948 36 competent competent JJ 40436 948 37 as as IN 40436 948 38 a a DT 40436 948 39 counsellor counsellor NN 40436 948 40 , , , 40436 948 41 but but CC 40436 948 42 will will MD 40436 948 43 be be VB 40436 948 44 more more RBR 40436 948 45 frequently frequently RB 40436 948 46 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 948 47 than than IN 40436 948 48 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 948 49 . . . 40436 949 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 949 2 33 33 CD 40436 949 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 949 4 Towards towards IN 40436 949 5 right right JJ 40436 949 6 living living NN 40436 949 7 , , , 40436 949 8 what what WP 40436 949 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 949 10 need need VBP 40436 949 11 is be VBZ 40436 949 12 , , , 40436 949 13 the the DT 40436 949 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 949 15 of of IN 40436 949 16 good good NN 40436 949 17 : : : 40436 949 18 just just RB 40436 949 19 as as IN 40436 949 20 the the DT 40436 949 21 sick sick JJ 40436 949 22 stand stand NN 40436 949 23 in in IN 40436 949 24 need need NN 40436 949 25 of of IN 40436 949 26 a a DT 40436 949 27 physician physician NN 40436 949 28 , , , 40436 949 29 and and CC 40436 949 30 the the DT 40436 949 31 ship ship NN 40436 949 32 's 's POS 40436 949 33 crew crew NN 40436 949 34 of of IN 40436 949 35 a a DT 40436 949 36 pilot pilot NN 40436 949 37 . . . 40436 950 1 _ _ NNP 40436 950 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 950 3 admit admit VBP 40436 950 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 950 5 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 950 6 . . . 40436 951 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 951 2 opinion opinion NN 40436 951 3 is be VBZ 40436 951 4 changed change VBN 40436 951 5 . . . 40436 952 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 952 2 no no RB 40436 952 3 longer longer RB 40436 952 4 believe believe VBP 40436 952 5 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 952 6 competent competent JJ 40436 952 7 to to TO 40436 952 8 determine determine VB 40436 952 9 what what WP 40436 952 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 952 11 ought ought MD 40436 952 12 to to TO 40436 952 13 accept accept VB 40436 952 14 from from IN 40436 952 15 the the DT 40436 952 16 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 952 17 , , , 40436 952 18 or or CC 40436 952 19 what what WP 40436 952 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 952 21 ought ought MD 40436 952 22 to to TO 40436 952 23 pray pray VB 40436 952 24 for for IN 40436 952 25 . . . 40436 953 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 953 2 incur incur VBP 40436 953 3 serious serious JJ 40436 953 4 danger danger NN 40436 953 5 of of IN 40436 953 6 erring err VBG 40436 953 7 , , , 40436 953 8 and and CC 40436 953 9 of of IN 40436 953 10 asking ask VBG 40436 953 11 for for IN 40436 953 12 mischiefs mischief NNS 40436 953 13 , , , 40436 953 14 under under IN 40436 953 15 the the DT 40436 953 16 belief belief NN 40436 953 17 that that IN 40436 953 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 953 19 are be VBP 40436 953 20 benefits benefit NNS 40436 953 21 . . . 40436 954 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 954 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 954 3 33 33 CD 40436 954 4 : : : 40436 954 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 954 6 , , , 40436 954 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 954 8 . . . 40436 955 1 ii ii LS 40436 955 2 . . . 40436 956 1 145 145 CD 40436 956 2 C c NN 40436 956 3 : : : 40436 956 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 956 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 956 6 : : : 40436 956 7 O(/stis o(/stis ADD 40436 956 8 a)/ra a)/ra UH 40436 956 9 ti ti XX 40436 956 10 tô tô NNP 40436 956 11 = = SYM 40436 956 12 n n CC 40436 956 13 toiou toiou NNP 40436 956 14 / / SYM 40436 956 15 tôn tôn NNP 40436 956 16 oi)=den oi)=den CD 40436 956 17 , , , 40436 956 18 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 956 19 me\n me\n NNP 40436 956 20 pare pare NNP 40436 956 21 / / SYM 40436 956 22 pêtai pêtai NNP 40436 956 23 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 956 24 ê ê NNP 40436 956 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 956 26 _ _ NNP 40436 956 27 tou= tou= NNP 40436 956 28 belti belti NN 40436 956 29 / / SYM 40436 956 30 stou stou NNP 40436 956 31 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 956 32 / / SYM 40436 956 33 mê mê NN 40436 956 34 -- -- : 40436 956 35 au(/tê au(/tê CD 40436 956 36 d d NN 40436 956 37 ' ' POS 40436 956 38 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 956 39 ê ê NNP 40436 956 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 956 41 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 956 42 dê dê NNP 40436 956 43 / / SYM 40436 956 44 pou pou CC 40436 956 45 ê(/per ê(/per NNP 40436 956 46 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 956 47 ê ê NNP 40436 956 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 956 49 tou= tou= NNP 40436 956 50 ô)pheli ô)pheli NNS 40436 956 51 / / SYM 40436 956 52 mou_--phro mou_--phro NN 40436 956 53 / / SYM 40436 956 54 nimo nimo NNP 40436 956 55 / / SYM 40436 956 56 n n NNP 40436 956 57 ge ge NNP 40436 956 58 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 956 59 phê phê NNP 40436 956 60 / / SYM 40436 956 61 somen soman NNS 40436 956 62 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 956 63 a)pochrô a)pochrô NNP 40436 956 64 = = SYM 40436 956 65 nta nta NNP 40436 956 66 xu xu NNP 40436 956 67 / / SYM 40436 956 68 mboulou mboulou NNP 40436 956 69 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 956 70 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 956 71 po po NNP 40436 956 72 / / SYM 40436 956 73 lei lei NNP 40436 956 74 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 956 75 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 956 76 au(tô=| au(tô=| IN 40436 956 77 ; ; : 40436 956 78 to\n to\n NNP 40436 956 79 de\ de\ NNP 40436 956 80 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 956 81 toiou toiou NNP 40436 956 82 = = SYM 40436 956 83 ton ton NN 40436 956 84 , , , 40436 956 85 ta)nanti ta)nanti NNP 40436 956 86 / / SYM 40436 956 87 a a DT 40436 956 88 tou tou NNP 40436 956 89 / / SYM 40436 956 90 tôn tôn NNP 40436 956 91 . . . 40436 956 92 ] ] -RRB- 40436 957 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 957 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 957 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 957 4 : : : 40436 957 5 Touou Touou NNP 40436 957 6 = = SYM 40436 957 7 ton ton NN 40436 957 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 957 9 is be VBZ 40436 957 10 Schneider Schneider NNP 40436 957 11 's 's POS 40436 957 12 emendation emendation NN 40436 957 13 for for IN 40436 957 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 957 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 957 16 : : : 40436 957 17 poiou poiou NNP 40436 957 18 = = SYM 40436 957 19 nta nta NNP 40436 957 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 957 21 . . . 40436 957 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 958 1 Ibid ibid RB 40436 958 2 . . . 40436 959 1 146 146 CD 40436 959 2 C c NN 40436 959 3 : : : 40436 959 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 959 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 959 6 : : : 40436 959 7 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 959 8 = = SYM 40436 959 9 n n CC 40436 959 10 phame\n phame\n NNP 40436 959 11 pa pa NNP 40436 959 12 / / SYM 40436 959 13 lin lin NNP 40436 959 14 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 959 15 pollou\s pollou\s CC 40436 959 16 diêmartêke diêmartêke NNP 40436 959 17 / / SYM 40436 959 18 nai nai NNP 40436 959 19 tou= tou= NNP 40436 959 20 belti belti NN 40436 959 21 / / SYM 40436 959 22 stou stou NN 40436 959 23 , , , 40436 959 24 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 959 25 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 959 26 polla/ polla/ NNP 40436 959 27 ge ge NNP 40436 959 28 , , , 40436 959 29 oi)=mai oi)=mai CD 40436 959 30 , , , 40436 959 31 a)/neu a)/neu RB 40436 959 32 nou= nou= NNP 40436 959 33 do do VB 40436 959 34 / / SYM 40436 959 35 xê| xê| NNP 40436 959 36 pepisteuko pepisteuko NN 40436 959 37 / / SYM 40436 959 38 tas tas NN 40436 959 39 ? ? . 40436 959 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 960 1 Ibid ibid RB 40436 960 2 . . . 40436 961 1 146 146 CD 40436 961 2 E E NNS 40436 961 3 : : : 40436 961 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 961 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 961 6 : : : 40436 961 7 O(ra=|s O(ra=|s NNP 40436 961 8 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 961 9 , , , 40436 961 10 o(/te o(/te NNP 40436 961 11 g g NNP 40436 961 12 ' ' '' 40436 961 13 e)/phên e)/phên NN 40436 961 14 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 961 15 / / SYM 40436 961 16 ein ein NNP 40436 961 17 to/ to/ CD 40436 961 18 ge ge NNP 40436 961 19 tô tô NNP 40436 961 20 = = SYM 40436 961 21 n n NN 40436 961 22 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 961 23 e)pistêmô e)pistêmô NNP 40436 961 24 = = SYM 40436 961 25 n n NNP 40436 961 26 ktê ktê NNP 40436 961 27 = = SYM 40436 961 28 ma ma NNP 40436 961 29 , , , 40436 961 30 e)a e)a NNP 40436 961 31 / / SYM 40436 961 32 n n NN 40436 961 33 tis tis NN 40436 961 34 a)/neu a)/neu NN 40436 961 35 tê tê NN 40436 961 36 = = SYM 40436 961 37 s s NNP 40436 961 38 tou= tou= NNP 40436 961 39 belti belti NN 40436 961 40 / / SYM 40436 961 41 stou stou NNP 40436 961 42 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 961 43 / / SYM 40436 961 44 mês mês NNP 40436 961 45 kektême kektême NNP 40436 961 46 / / SYM 40436 961 47 nos nos NNP 40436 961 48 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 961 49 , , , 40436 961 50 o)liga o)liga CD 40436 961 51 / / SYM 40436 961 52 kis kis NNP 40436 961 53 me\n me\n NNP 40436 961 54 ô)phelei ô)phelei NNP 40436 961 55 = = SYM 40436 961 56 n n CC 40436 961 57 bla bla NNP 40436 961 58 / / SYM 40436 961 59 ptein ptein NNP 40436 961 60 de\ de\ NNP 40436 961 61 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 961 62 plei plei NNP 40436 961 63 / / SYM 40436 961 64 ô ô NN 40436 961 65 ton ton NN 40436 961 66 e)/chont e)/chont NN 40436 961 67 ' ' `` 40436 961 68 au)to/. au)to/. NN 40436 961 69 ] ] -RRB- 40436 962 1 Ibid ibid RB 40436 962 2 . . . 40436 963 1 147 147 CD 40436 963 2 A a NN 40436 963 3 : : : 40436 963 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 963 5 Greek greek NN 40436 963 6 : : : 40436 963 7 O o NN 40436 963 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 963 9 de\ de\ NNP 40436 963 10 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 963 11 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 963 12 kaloume kaloume NNP 40436 963 13 / / SYM 40436 963 14 nên nên NNP 40436 963 15 poluma poluma NNP 40436 963 16 / / SYM 40436 963 17 theia theia NNP 40436 963 18 / / SYM 40436 963 19 n n NNP 40436 963 20 te te NNP 40436 963 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 963 22 polutechni polutechni NNP 40436 963 23 / / , 40436 963 24 an an DT 40436 963 25 kektême kektême NN 40436 963 26 / / SYM 40436 963 27 nos nos NNP 40436 963 28 , , , 40436 963 29 o)rphano\s o)rphano\s NNP 40436 963 30 de\ de\ NNP 40436 963 31 ô)\n ô)\n NNP 40436 963 32 tau tau NNP 40436 963 33 / / SYM 40436 963 34 tês tês NNP 40436 963 35 tê tê NNP 40436 963 36 = = SYM 40436 963 37 s s NNP 40436 963 38 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 963 39 / / SYM 40436 963 40 mês mês NNPS 40436 963 41 , , , 40436 963 42 a)go a)go NNP 40436 963 43 / / SYM 40436 963 44 menos menos NNP 40436 963 45 de\ de\ NNP 40436 963 46 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 963 47 mia mia NN 40436 963 48 = = SYM 40436 963 49 s s NNP 40436 963 50 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 963 51 / / SYM 40436 963 52 stês stês NN 40436 963 53 tô tô NNS 40436 963 54 = = NFP 40436 963 55 n n NN 40436 963 56 a)/llôn a)/llôn UH 40436 963 57 , , , 40436 963 58 a)=r a)=r UH 40436 963 59 ' ' `` 40436 963 60 ou)chi\ ou)chi\ NNP 40436 963 61 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 963 62 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 963 63 dikai dikai NNP 40436 963 64 / / SYM 40436 963 65 ôs ôs NNP 40436 963 66 pollô=| pollô=| FW 40436 963 67 cheimô cheimô NNP 40436 963 68 = = SYM 40436 963 69 ni ni NNP 40436 963 70 chrê chrê NNP 40436 963 71 / / SYM 40436 963 72 setai setai NNP 40436 963 73 , , , 40436 963 74 a(/t a(/t NNP 40436 963 75 ' ' '' 40436 963 76 , , , 40436 963 77 oi)=mai oi)=mai NNP 40436 963 78 , , , 40436 963 79 a)/neu a)/neu NNP 40436 963 80 kubernê kubernê NNP 40436 963 81 / / SYM 40436 963 82 tou tou NNP 40436 963 83 diatelô diatelô NNP 40436 963 84 = = SYM 40436 963 85 n n CC 40436 963 86 e)n e)n NNP 40436 963 87 pela pela NNP 40436 963 88 / / SYM 40436 963 89 gei gei NN 40436 963 90 ] ] -RRB- 40436 963 91 , , , 40436 963 92 & & CC 40436 963 93 c. c. NNP 40436 963 94 ] ] -RRB- 40436 963 95 [ [ -LRB- 40436 963 96 Side side NN 40436 963 97 - - HYPH 40436 963 98 note note NN 40436 963 99 : : : 40436 963 100 It -PRON- PRP 40436 963 101 is be VBZ 40436 963 102 unsafe unsafe JJ 40436 963 103 for for IN 40436 963 104 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 963 105 to to TO 40436 963 106 proceed proceed VB 40436 963 107 with with IN 40436 963 108 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 963 109 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 963 110 , , , 40436 963 111 until until IN 40436 963 112 he -PRON- PRP 40436 963 113 has have VBZ 40436 963 114 learnt learn VBN 40436 963 115 what what WP 40436 963 116 is be VBZ 40436 963 117 the the DT 40436 963 118 proper proper JJ 40436 963 119 language language NN 40436 963 120 to to TO 40436 963 121 address address NN 40436 963 122 to to IN 40436 963 123 the the DT 40436 963 124 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 963 125 . . . 40436 964 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 964 2 renounces renounce VBZ 40436 964 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 964 4 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 964 5 , , , 40436 964 6 and and CC 40436 964 7 throws throw VBZ 40436 964 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 964 9 upon upon IN 40436 964 10 the the DT 40436 964 11 counsel counsel NN 40436 964 12 of of IN 40436 964 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 964 14 . . . 40436 964 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 965 1 _ _ NNP 40436 965 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 965 3 Lacedæmonians Lacedæmonians NNP 40436 965 4 , , , 40436 965 5 when when WRB 40436 965 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 965 7 offer offer VBP 40436 965 8 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 965 9 , , , 40436 965 10 pray pray VBP 40436 965 11 simply simply RB 40436 965 12 that that IN 40436 965 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 965 14 may may MD 40436 965 15 obtain obtain VB 40436 965 16 what what WP 40436 965 17 is be VBZ 40436 965 18 honourable honourable JJ 40436 965 19 and and CC 40436 965 20 good good JJ 40436 965 21 , , , 40436 965 22 without without IN 40436 965 23 farther farther JJ 40436 965 24 specification specification NN 40436 965 25 . . . 40436 966 1 This this DT 40436 966 2 language language NN 40436 966 3 is be VBZ 40436 966 4 acceptable acceptable JJ 40436 966 5 to to IN 40436 966 6 the the DT 40436 966 7 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 966 8 , , , 40436 966 9 more more RBR 40436 966 10 acceptable acceptable JJ 40436 966 11 than than IN 40436 966 12 the the DT 40436 966 13 costly costly JJ 40436 966 14 festivals festival NNS 40436 966 15 of of IN 40436 966 16 Athens Athens NNP 40436 966 17 . . . 40436 967 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 967 2 has have VBZ 40436 967 3 procured procure VBN 40436 967 4 for for IN 40436 967 5 the the DT 40436 967 6 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 967 7 more more RBR 40436 967 8 continued continue VBN 40436 967 9 prosperity prosperity NN 40436 967 10 than than IN 40436 967 11 the the DT 40436 967 12 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 967 13 have have VBP 40436 967 14 enjoyed enjoy VBN 40436 967 15 . . . 40436 968 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 968 2 34 34 CD 40436 968 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 968 4 The the DT 40436 968 5 Gods Gods NNP 40436 968 6 honour honour NN 40436 968 7 wise wise JJ 40436 968 8 and and CC 40436 968 9 just just JJ 40436 968 10 men man NNS 40436 968 11 , , , 40436 968 12 that that RB 40436 968 13 is is RB 40436 968 14 , , , 40436 968 15 men man NNS 40436 968 16 who who WP 40436 968 17 know know VBP 40436 968 18 what what WP 40436 968 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 968 20 ought ought MD 40436 968 21 to to TO 40436 968 22 say say VB 40436 968 23 and and CC 40436 968 24 do do VB 40436 968 25 both both DT 40436 968 26 towards towards IN 40436 968 27 Gods god NNS 40436 968 28 and and CC 40436 968 29 towards towards IN 40436 968 30 men man NNS 40436 968 31 -- -- : 40436 968 32 more more RBR 40436 968 33 than than IN 40436 968 34 numerous numerous JJ 40436 968 35 and and CC 40436 968 36 splendid splendid JJ 40436 968 37 offerings offering NNS 40436 968 38 . . . 40436 969 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 969 2 35 35 CD 40436 969 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 969 4 You -PRON- PRP 40436 969 5 see see VBP 40436 969 6 , , , 40436 969 7 therefore therefore RB 40436 969 8 , , , 40436 969 9 that that IN 40436 969 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 969 11 is be VBZ 40436 969 12 not not RB 40436 969 13 safe safe JJ 40436 969 14 for for IN 40436 969 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 969 16 to to TO 40436 969 17 proceed proceed VB 40436 969 18 with with IN 40436 969 19 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 969 20 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 969 21 , , , 40436 969 22 until until IN 40436 969 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 969 24 have have VBP 40436 969 25 learnt learn VBN 40436 969 26 what what WP 40436 969 27 is be VBZ 40436 969 28 the the DT 40436 969 29 proper proper JJ 40436 969 30 language language NN 40436 969 31 to to TO 40436 969 32 be be VB 40436 969 33 used use VBN 40436 969 34 , , , 40436 969 35 and and CC 40436 969 36 what what WP 40436 969 37 are be VBP 40436 969 38 the the DT 40436 969 39 really really RB 40436 969 40 good good JJ 40436 969 41 gifts gift NNS 40436 969 42 to to TO 40436 969 43 be be VB 40436 969 44 prayed pray VBN 40436 969 45 for for IN 40436 969 46 . . . 40436 970 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 40436 970 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 970 3 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 970 4 will will MD 40436 970 5 not not RB 40436 970 6 prove prove VB 40436 970 7 acceptable acceptable JJ 40436 970 8 , , , 40436 970 9 and and CC 40436 970 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 970 11 may may MD 40436 970 12 even even RB 40436 970 13 bring bring VB 40436 970 14 upon upon RP 40436 970 15 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 970 16 positive positive JJ 40436 970 17 mischief mischief NN 40436 970 18 . . . 40436 971 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 971 2 36 36 CD 40436 971 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 971 4 _ _ NNP 40436 971 5 Alk._--When alk._--when RB 40436 971 6 shall shall MD 40436 971 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 971 8 be be VB 40436 971 9 able able JJ 40436 971 10 to to TO 40436 971 11 learn learn VB 40436 971 12 this this DT 40436 971 13 , , , 40436 971 14 and and CC 40436 971 15 who who WP 40436 971 16 is be VBZ 40436 971 17 there there RB 40436 971 18 to to TO 40436 971 19 teach teach VB 40436 971 20 me -PRON- PRP 40436 971 21 ? ? . 40436 972 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 972 2 shall shall MD 40436 972 3 be be VB 40436 972 4 delighted delight VBN 40436 972 5 to to TO 40436 972 6 meet meet VB 40436 972 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 972 8 . . . 40436 973 1 _ _ NNP 40436 973 2 Sokr._--There Sokr._--There NNP 40436 973 3 is be VBZ 40436 973 4 a a DT 40436 973 5 person person NN 40436 973 6 at at IN 40436 973 7 hand hand NN 40436 973 8 most most RBS 40436 973 9 anxious anxious JJ 40436 973 10 for for IN 40436 973 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 973 12 improvement improvement NN 40436 973 13 . . . 40436 974 1 What what WP 40436 974 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 974 3 must must MD 40436 974 4 do do VB 40436 974 5 is be VBZ 40436 974 6 , , , 40436 974 7 first first RB 40436 974 8 to to TO 40436 974 9 disperse disperse VB 40436 974 10 the the DT 40436 974 11 darkness darkness NN 40436 974 12 from from IN 40436 974 13 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 974 14 mind mind NN 40436 974 15 , , , 40436 974 16 next next RB 40436 974 17 , , , 40436 974 18 to to TO 40436 974 19 impart impart VB 40436 974 20 that that IN 40436 974 21 which which WDT 40436 974 22 will will MD 40436 974 23 teach teach VB 40436 974 24 you -PRON- PRP 40436 974 25 to to TO 40436 974 26 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 974 27 evil evil NN 40436 974 28 from from IN 40436 974 29 good good JJ 40436 974 30 , , , 40436 974 31 which which WDT 40436 974 32 at at IN 40436 974 33 present present NN 40436 974 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 974 35 are be VBP 40436 974 36 unable unable JJ 40436 974 37 to to TO 40436 974 38 do do VB 40436 974 39 . . . 40436 975 1 _ _ NNP 40436 975 2 Alk._--I Alk._--I NNP 40436 975 3 shall shall MD 40436 975 4 shrink shrink VB 40436 975 5 from from IN 40436 975 6 no no DT 40436 975 7 labour labour NN 40436 975 8 to to TO 40436 975 9 accomplish accomplish VB 40436 975 10 this this DT 40436 975 11 object object NN 40436 975 12 . . . 40436 976 1 Until until IN 40436 976 2 then then RB 40436 976 3 , , , 40436 976 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 976 5 postpone postpone VBP 40436 976 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 976 7 intended intended JJ 40436 976 8 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 976 9 : : : 40436 976 10 and and CC 40436 976 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 976 12 tender tender VBP 40436 976 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 976 14 sacrificial sacrificial JJ 40436 976 15 wreath wreath NN 40436 976 16 to to IN 40436 976 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 976 18 , , , 40436 976 19 in in IN 40436 976 20 gratitude gratitude NN 40436 976 21 for for IN 40436 976 22 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 976 23 counsel counsel NN 40436 976 24 . . . 40436 977 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 977 2 37 37 CD 40436 977 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 977 4 _ _ NNP 40436 977 5 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 977 6 accept accept VBP 40436 977 7 the the DT 40436 977 8 wreath wreath NN 40436 977 9 as as IN 40436 977 10 a a DT 40436 977 11 welcome welcome JJ 40436 977 12 augury augury NN 40436 977 13 of of IN 40436 977 14 future future JJ 40436 977 15 friendship friendship NN 40436 977 16 and and CC 40436 977 17 conversation conversation NN 40436 977 18 between between IN 40436 977 19 us -PRON- PRP 40436 977 20 , , , 40436 977 21 to to TO 40436 977 22 help help VB 40436 977 23 us -PRON- PRP 40436 977 24 out out IN 40436 977 25 of of IN 40436 977 26 the the DT 40436 977 27 present present JJ 40436 977 28 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 977 29 . . . 40436 978 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 978 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 978 3 34 34 CD 40436 978 4 : : : 40436 978 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 978 6 , , , 40436 978 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 978 8 . . . 40436 979 1 ii ii LS 40436 979 2 . . . 40436 980 1 p. p. NN 40436 981 1 148 148 CD 40436 981 2 . . . 40436 981 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 982 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 982 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 982 3 35 35 CD 40436 982 4 : : : 40436 982 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 982 6 , , , 40436 982 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 982 8 . . . 40436 983 1 ii ii LS 40436 983 2 . . . 40436 984 1 p. p. NN 40436 985 1 150 150 CD 40436 985 2 . . . 40436 985 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 986 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 986 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 986 3 36 36 CD 40436 986 4 : : : 40436 986 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 986 6 , , , 40436 986 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 986 8 . . . 40436 987 1 ii ii LS 40436 987 2 . . . 40436 988 1 p. p. NN 40436 989 1 150 150 CD 40436 989 2 . . . 40436 989 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 990 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 990 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 990 3 37 37 CD 40436 990 4 : : : 40436 990 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 990 6 , , , 40436 990 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 990 8 . . . 40436 991 1 ii ii LS 40436 991 2 . . . 40436 992 1 p. p. NN 40436 993 1 151 151 CD 40436 993 2 . . . 40436 993 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 994 1 * * NFP 40436 994 2 * * NFP 40436 994 3 * * NFP 40436 994 4 * * NFP 40436 994 5 * * NFP 40436 994 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 994 7 Side side NN 40436 994 8 - - HYPH 40436 994 9 note note NN 40436 994 10 : : : 40436 994 11 Different different JJ 40436 994 12 critical critical JJ 40436 994 13 opinions opinion NNS 40436 994 14 respecting respect VBG 40436 994 15 these these DT 40436 994 16 two two CD 40436 994 17 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 994 18 . . . 40436 994 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 995 1 The the DT 40436 995 2 two two CD 40436 995 3 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 995 4 , , , 40436 995 5 called call VBD 40436 995 6 First First NNP 40436 995 7 and and CC 40436 995 8 Second Second NNP 40436 995 9 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 995 10 , , , 40436 995 11 of of IN 40436 995 12 which which WDT 40436 995 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 995 14 have have VBP 40436 995 15 just just RB 40436 995 16 given give VBN 40436 995 17 some some DT 40436 995 18 account account NN 40436 995 19 , , , 40436 995 20 resemble resemble VB 40436 995 21 each each DT 40436 995 22 other other JJ 40436 995 23 more more JJR 40436 995 24 than than IN 40436 995 25 most most JJS 40436 995 26 of of IN 40436 995 27 the the DT 40436 995 28 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 995 29 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 995 30 , , , 40436 995 31 not not RB 40436 995 32 merely merely RB 40436 995 33 in in IN 40436 995 34 the the DT 40436 995 35 personages personage NNS 40436 995 36 introduced introduce VBD 40436 995 37 , , , 40436 995 38 but but CC 40436 995 39 in in IN 40436 995 40 general general JJ 40436 995 41 spirit spirit NN 40436 995 42 , , , 40436 995 43 in in IN 40436 995 44 subject subject NN 40436 995 45 , , , 40436 995 46 and and CC 40436 995 47 even even RB 40436 995 48 in in IN 40436 995 49 illustrations illustration NNS 40436 995 50 . . . 40436 996 1 The the DT 40436 996 2 First First NNP 40436 996 3 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 996 4 was be VBD 40436 996 5 recognised recognise VBN 40436 996 6 as as IN 40436 996 7 authentic authentic JJ 40436 996 8 by by IN 40436 996 9 all all DT 40436 996 10 critics critic NNS 40436 996 11 without without IN 40436 996 12 exception exception NN 40436 996 13 , , , 40436 996 14 until until IN 40436 996 15 the the DT 40436 996 16 days day NNS 40436 996 17 of of IN 40436 996 18 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 996 19 . . . 40436 997 1 Nay nay UH 40436 997 2 , , , 40436 997 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 997 4 was be VBD 40436 997 5 not not RB 40436 997 6 only only RB 40436 997 7 recognised recognise VBN 40436 997 8 , , , 40436 997 9 but but CC 40436 997 10 extolled extoll VBD 40436 997 11 as as IN 40436 997 12 one one CD 40436 997 13 of of IN 40436 997 14 the the DT 40436 997 15 most most RBS 40436 997 16 valuable valuable JJ 40436 997 17 and and CC 40436 997 18 important important JJ 40436 997 19 of of IN 40436 997 20 all all PDT 40436 997 21 the the DT 40436 997 22 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 997 23 compositions composition NNS 40436 997 24 ; ; , 40436 997 25 proper proper JJ 40436 997 26 to to TO 40436 997 27 be be VB 40436 997 28 studied study VBN 40436 997 29 first first RB 40436 997 30 , , , 40436 997 31 as as IN 40436 997 32 a a DT 40436 997 33 key key NN 40436 997 34 to to IN 40436 997 35 all all PDT 40436 997 36 the the DT 40436 997 37 rest rest NN 40436 997 38 . . . 40436 998 1 Such such JJ 40436 998 2 was be VBD 40436 998 3 the the DT 40436 998 4 view view NN 40436 998 5 of of IN 40436 998 6 Jamblichus Jamblichus NNP 40436 998 7 and and CC 40436 998 8 Proklus Proklus NNP 40436 998 9 , , , 40436 998 10 transmitted transmit VBN 40436 998 11 to to IN 40436 998 12 modern modern JJ 40436 998 13 times time NNS 40436 998 14 ; ; : 40436 998 15 until until IN 40436 998 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 998 17 received receive VBD 40436 998 18 a a DT 40436 998 19 harsh harsh JJ 40436 998 20 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 998 21 from from IN 40436 998 22 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 998 23 , , , 40436 998 24 who who WP 40436 998 25 declared declare VBD 40436 998 26 the the DT 40436 998 27 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 998 28 to to TO 40436 998 29 be be VB 40436 998 30 both both CC 40436 998 31 worthless worthless JJ 40436 998 32 and and CC 40436 998 33 spurious spurious JJ 40436 998 34 . . . 40436 999 1 The the DT 40436 999 2 Second Second NNP 40436 999 3 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 999 4 was be VBD 40436 999 5 also also RB 40436 999 6 admitted admit VBN 40436 999 7 both both DT 40436 999 8 by by IN 40436 999 9 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 999 10 , , , 40436 999 11 and and CC 40436 999 12 by by IN 40436 999 13 the the DT 40436 999 14 general general JJ 40436 999 15 body body NN 40436 999 16 of of IN 40436 999 17 critics critic NNS 40436 999 18 in in IN 40436 999 19 ancient ancient JJ 40436 999 20 times time NNS 40436 999 21 : : : 40436 999 22 but but CC 40436 999 23 there there EX 40436 999 24 were be VBD 40436 999 25 some some DT 40436 999 26 persons person NNS 40436 999 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 999 28 as as IN 40436 999 29 we -PRON- PRP 40436 999 30 learn learn VBP 40436 999 31 from from IN 40436 999 32 Athenæus)[38 Athenæus)[38 NNP 40436 999 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 999 34 who who WP 40436 999 35 considered consider VBD 40436 999 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 999 37 to to TO 40436 999 38 be be VB 40436 999 39 a a DT 40436 999 40 work work NN 40436 999 41 of of IN 40436 999 42 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 999 43 ; ; : 40436 999 44 perceiving perceiving NN 40436 999 45 probably probably RB 40436 999 46 ( ( -LRB- 40436 999 47 what what WP 40436 999 48 is be VBZ 40436 999 49 the the DT 40436 999 50 fact fact NN 40436 999 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 999 52 that that IN 40436 999 53 it -PRON- PRP 40436 999 54 bears bear VBZ 40436 999 55 much much JJ 40436 999 56 analogy analogy NN 40436 999 57 to to IN 40436 999 58 several several JJ 40436 999 59 conversations conversation NNS 40436 999 60 which which WDT 40436 999 61 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 999 62 has have VBZ 40436 999 63 set set VBN 40436 999 64 down down RP 40436 999 65 . . . 40436 1000 1 But but CC 40436 1000 2 those those DT 40436 1000 3 who who WP 40436 1000 4 held hold VBD 40436 1000 5 this this DT 40436 1000 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 1000 7 are be VBP 40436 1000 8 not not RB 40436 1000 9 to to TO 40436 1000 10 be be VB 40436 1000 11 considered consider VBN 40436 1000 12 as as IN 40436 1000 13 of of IN 40436 1000 14 one one CD 40436 1000 15 mind mind NN 40436 1000 16 with with IN 40436 1000 17 critics critic NNS 40436 1000 18 who who WP 40436 1000 19 reject reject VBP 40436 1000 20 the the DT 40436 1000 21 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1000 22 as as IN 40436 1000 23 a a DT 40436 1000 24 forgery forgery NN 40436 1000 25 or or CC 40436 1000 26 imitation imitation NN 40436 1000 27 of of IN 40436 1000 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1000 29 . . . 40436 1001 1 Compositions composition NNS 40436 1001 2 emanating emanate VBG 40436 1001 3 from from IN 40436 1001 4 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1001 5 are be VBP 40436 1001 6 just just RB 40436 1001 7 as as RB 40436 1001 8 much much RB 40436 1001 9 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1001 10 , , , 40436 1001 11 probably probably RB 40436 1001 12 even even RB 40436 1001 13 more more RBR 40436 1001 14 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1001 15 , , , 40436 1001 16 than than IN 40436 1001 17 the the DT 40436 1001 18 most most RBS 40436 1001 19 unquestioned unquestioned JJ 40436 1001 20 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1001 21 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1001 22 , , , 40436 1001 23 besides besides IN 40436 1001 24 that that IN 40436 1001 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1001 26 must must MD 40436 1001 27 of of IN 40436 1001 28 necessity necessity NN 40436 1001 29 be be VB 40436 1001 30 contemporary contemporary JJ 40436 1001 31 also also RB 40436 1001 32 . . . 40436 1002 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1002 2 has have VBZ 40436 1002 3 gone go VBN 40436 1002 4 much much RB 40436 1002 5 farther farther RB 40436 1002 6 : : : 40436 1002 7 declaring declare VBG 40436 1002 8 the the DT 40436 1002 9 Second second JJ 40436 1002 10 as as RB 40436 1002 11 well well RB 40436 1002 12 as as IN 40436 1002 13 the the DT 40436 1002 14 First first JJ 40436 1002 15 to to TO 40436 1002 16 be be VB 40436 1002 17 an an DT 40436 1002 18 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 1002 19 imitation imitation NN 40436 1002 20 of of IN 40436 1002 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1002 22 . . . 40436 1003 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1003 2 39 39 CD 40436 1003 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1003 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1003 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1003 6 38 38 CD 40436 1003 7 : : : 40436 1003 8 Athenæus Athenæus NNP 40436 1003 9 , , , 40436 1003 10 xi xi NNP 40436 1003 11 . . . 40436 1004 1 p. p. NN 40436 1005 1 506 506 CD 40436 1005 2 . . . 40436 1005 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1006 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1006 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1006 3 39 39 CD 40436 1006 4 : : : 40436 1006 5 See see VB 40436 1006 6 the the DT 40436 1006 7 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 1006 8 of of IN 40436 1006 9 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1006 10 to to IN 40436 1006 11 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1006 12 . . . 40436 1007 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1007 2 part part NNP 40436 1007 3 ii ii NNP 40436 1007 4 . . . 40436 1008 1 vol vol NNP 40436 1008 2 . . . 40436 1009 1 iii iii NNP 40436 1009 2 . . . 40436 1010 1 p. p. NN 40436 1010 2 293 293 CD 40436 1010 3 seq seq NN 40436 1010 4 . . . 40436 1011 1 Einleitung einleitung JJ 40436 1011 2 to to IN 40436 1011 3 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1011 4 . . . 40436 1012 1 ii ii LS 40436 1012 2 . . . 40436 1013 1 part part NNP 40436 1013 2 i. i. NNP 40436 1013 3 vol vol NNP 40436 1013 4 . . . 40436 1014 1 ii ii LS 40436 1014 2 . . . 40436 1015 1 p. p. NN 40436 1015 2 365 365 CD 40436 1015 3 seq seq NN 40436 1015 4 . . . 40436 1016 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1016 2 notes note NNS 40436 1016 3 on on IN 40436 1016 4 the the DT 40436 1016 5 two two CD 40436 1016 6 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1016 7 contain contain VBP 40436 1016 8 various various JJ 40436 1016 9 additional additional JJ 40436 1016 10 reasons reason NNS 40436 1016 11 , , , 40436 1016 12 besides besides IN 40436 1016 13 what what WP 40436 1016 14 is be VBZ 40436 1016 15 urged urge VBN 40436 1016 16 in in IN 40436 1016 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1016 18 Introduction introduction NN 40436 1016 19 . . . 40436 1016 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1017 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1017 2 Side side NN 40436 1017 3 - - HYPH 40436 1017 4 note note NN 40436 1017 5 : : : 40436 1017 6 Grounds ground NNS 40436 1017 7 for for IN 40436 1017 8 disallowing disallow VBG 40436 1017 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1017 10 -- -- : 40436 1017 11 less less RBR 40436 1017 12 strong strong JJ 40436 1017 13 against against IN 40436 1017 14 the the DT 40436 1017 15 Second Second NNP 40436 1017 16 than than IN 40436 1017 17 against against IN 40436 1017 18 the the DT 40436 1017 19 First First NNP 40436 1017 20 . . . 40436 1017 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1018 1 Here here RB 40436 1018 2 Ast Ast NNP 40436 1018 3 agrees agree VBZ 40436 1018 4 with with IN 40436 1018 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1018 6 fully fully RB 40436 1018 7 , , , 40436 1018 8 including include VBG 40436 1018 9 both both CC 40436 1018 10 the the DT 40436 1018 11 First first JJ 40436 1018 12 and and CC 40436 1018 13 Second Second NNP 40436 1018 14 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1018 15 in in IN 40436 1018 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1018 17 large large JJ 40436 1018 18 list list NN 40436 1018 19 of of IN 40436 1018 20 the the DT 40436 1018 21 spurious spurious JJ 40436 1018 22 . . . 40436 1019 1 Most Most JJS 40436 1019 2 of of IN 40436 1019 3 the the DT 40436 1019 4 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 1019 5 critics critic NNS 40436 1019 6 go go VBP 40436 1019 7 with with IN 40436 1019 8 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1019 9 only only RB 40436 1019 10 half half JJ 40436 1019 11 - - HYPH 40436 1019 12 way way NN 40436 1019 13 : : : 40436 1019 14 Socher Socher NNP 40436 1019 15 , , , 40436 1019 16 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 1019 17 , , , 40436 1019 18 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1019 19 , , , 40436 1019 20 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1019 21 , , , 40436 1019 22 Susemihl Susemihl NNP 40436 1019 23 , , , 40436 1019 24 recognise recognise VB 40436 1019 25 the the DT 40436 1019 26 First First NNP 40436 1019 27 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1019 28 , , , 40436 1019 29 but but CC 40436 1019 30 disallow disallow VB 40436 1019 31 the the DT 40436 1019 32 Second second JJ 40436 1019 33 . . . 40436 1020 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1020 2 40 40 CD 40436 1020 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1020 4 In in IN 40436 1020 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1020 6 judgment judgment NN 40436 1020 7 , , , 40436 1020 8 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1020 9 and and CC 40436 1020 10 Ast Ast NNP 40436 1020 11 are be VBP 40436 1020 12 more more RBR 40436 1020 13 consistently consistently RB 40436 1020 14 right right JJ 40436 1020 15 , , , 40436 1020 16 or or CC 40436 1020 17 more more RBR 40436 1020 18 consistently consistently RB 40436 1020 19 wrong wrong JJ 40436 1020 20 , , , 40436 1020 21 in in IN 40436 1020 22 rejecting reject VBG 40436 1020 23 both both DT 40436 1020 24 , , , 40436 1020 25 than than IN 40436 1020 26 the the DT 40436 1020 27 other other JJ 40436 1020 28 critics critic NNS 40436 1020 29 who who WP 40436 1020 30 find find VBP 40436 1020 31 or or CC 40436 1020 32 make make VBP 40436 1020 33 so so RB 40436 1020 34 capital capital NN 40436 1020 35 a a DT 40436 1020 36 distinction distinction NN 40436 1020 37 between between IN 40436 1020 38 the the DT 40436 1020 39 two two CD 40436 1020 40 . . . 40436 1021 1 The the DT 40436 1021 2 similarity similarity NN 40436 1021 3 of of IN 40436 1021 4 tone tone NN 40436 1021 5 and and CC 40436 1021 6 topics topic NNS 40436 1021 7 between between IN 40436 1021 8 the the DT 40436 1021 9 two two CD 40436 1021 10 is be VBZ 40436 1021 11 obvious obvious JJ 40436 1021 12 , , , 40436 1021 13 and and CC 40436 1021 14 is be VBZ 40436 1021 15 indeed indeed RB 40436 1021 16 admitted admit VBN 40436 1021 17 by by IN 40436 1021 18 all all DT 40436 1021 19 . . . 40436 1022 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 1022 2 , , , 40436 1022 3 if if IN 40436 1022 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1022 5 were be VBD 40436 1022 6 compelled compel VBN 40436 1022 7 to to TO 40436 1022 8 make make VB 40436 1022 9 a a DT 40436 1022 10 choice choice NN 40436 1022 11 , , , 40436 1022 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1022 13 should should MD 40436 1022 14 say say VB 40436 1022 15 that that IN 40436 1022 16 the the DT 40436 1022 17 grounds ground NNS 40436 1022 18 for for IN 40436 1022 19 suspicion suspicion NN 40436 1022 20 are be VBP 40436 1022 21 rather rather RB 40436 1022 22 less less RBR 40436 1022 23 strong strong JJ 40436 1022 24 against against IN 40436 1022 25 the the DT 40436 1022 26 Second Second NNP 40436 1022 27 than than IN 40436 1022 28 against against IN 40436 1022 29 the the DT 40436 1022 30 First first JJ 40436 1022 31 ; ; : 40436 1022 32 and and CC 40436 1022 33 that that IN 40436 1022 34 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1022 35 , , , 40436 1022 36 reasoning reason VBG 40436 1022 37 upon upon IN 40436 1022 38 the the DT 40436 1022 39 objections objection NNS 40436 1022 40 admitted admit VBN 40436 1022 41 by by IN 40436 1022 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1022 43 opponents opponent NNS 40436 1022 44 as as IN 40436 1022 45 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 1022 46 against against IN 40436 1022 47 the the DT 40436 1022 48 Second Second NNP 40436 1022 49 , , , 40436 1022 50 would would MD 40436 1022 51 have have VB 40436 1022 52 no no DT 40436 1022 53 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 1022 54 in in IN 40436 1022 55 showing show VBG 40436 1022 56 that that IN 40436 1022 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1022 58 own own JJ 40436 1022 59 objections objection NNS 40436 1022 60 against against IN 40436 1022 61 the the DT 40436 1022 62 First First NNP 40436 1022 63 were be VBD 40436 1022 64 still still RB 40436 1022 65 more more RBR 40436 1022 66 forcible forcible JJ 40436 1022 67 . . . 40436 1023 1 The the DT 40436 1023 2 long long JJ 40436 1023 3 speech speech NN 40436 1023 4 assigned assign VBN 40436 1023 5 in in IN 40436 1023 6 the the DT 40436 1023 7 First First NNP 40436 1023 8 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1023 9 to to IN 40436 1023 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1023 11 , , , 40436 1023 12 about about IN 40436 1023 13 the the DT 40436 1023 14 privileges privilege NNS 40436 1023 15 of of IN 40436 1023 16 the the DT 40436 1023 17 Spartan Spartan NNP 40436 1023 18 and and CC 40436 1023 19 Persian Persian NNP 40436 1023 20 kings,[41 kings,[41 NNP 40436 1023 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1023 22 including include VBG 40436 1023 23 the the DT 40436 1023 24 mention mention NN 40436 1023 25 of of IN 40436 1023 26 Zoroaster Zoroaster NNP 40436 1023 27 , , , 40436 1023 28 son son NN 40436 1023 29 of of IN 40436 1023 30 Oromazes Oromazes NNP 40436 1023 31 , , , 40436 1023 32 and and CC 40436 1023 33 the the DT 40436 1023 34 Magian magian JJ 40436 1023 35 religion religion NN 40436 1023 36 , , , 40436 1023 37 appears appear VBZ 40436 1023 38 to to IN 40436 1023 39 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1023 40 more more RBR 40436 1023 41 unusual unusual JJ 40436 1023 42 with with IN 40436 1023 43 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1023 44 than than IN 40436 1023 45 anything anything NN 40436 1023 46 which which WDT 40436 1023 47 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1023 48 find find VBP 40436 1023 49 in in IN 40436 1023 50 the the DT 40436 1023 51 Second Second NNP 40436 1023 52 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1023 53 . . . 40436 1024 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1024 2 is be VBZ 40436 1024 3 more more JJR 40436 1024 4 Xenophontic[42 xenophontic[42 ADD 40436 1024 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1024 6 than than IN 40436 1024 7 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1024 8 . . . 40436 1025 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1025 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1025 3 40 40 CD 40436 1025 4 : : : 40436 1025 5 Socher Socher NNP 40436 1025 6 , , , 40436 1025 7 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 1025 8 Platon Platon NNP 40436 1025 9 's 's POS 40436 1025 10 Schriften Schriften NNP 40436 1025 11 , , , 40436 1025 12 p. p. NN 40436 1025 13 112 112 CD 40436 1025 14 . . . 40436 1026 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1026 2 , , , 40436 1026 3 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 1026 4 . . . 40436 1027 1 to to IN 40436 1027 2 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1027 3 . . . 40436 1028 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1028 2 and and CC 40436 1028 3 ii ii NNP 40436 1028 4 . . . 40436 1029 1 vol vol NNP 40436 1029 2 . . . 40436 1030 1 v. v. NNP 40436 1030 2 pp pp NNP 40436 1030 3 . . . 40436 1031 1 171 171 CD 40436 1031 2 - - SYM 40436 1031 3 304 304 CD 40436 1031 4 . . . 40436 1032 1 K. K. NNP 40436 1032 2 F. F. NNP 40436 1032 3 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 1032 4 , , , 40436 1032 5 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 1032 6 . . . 40436 1033 1 und und JJ 40436 1033 2 Syst Syst NNP 40436 1033 3 . . . 40436 1034 1 der der NNP 40436 1034 2 Platon Platon NNP 40436 1034 3 . . . 40436 1035 1 Philos Philos NNP 40436 1035 2 . . . 40436 1036 1 p. p. NN 40436 1036 2 420 420 CD 40436 1036 3 - - SYM 40436 1036 4 439 439 CD 40436 1036 5 . . . 40436 1037 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1037 2 , , , 40436 1037 3 Einleitungen Einleitungen NNP 40436 1037 4 to to TO 40436 1037 5 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1037 6 . . . 40436 1038 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1038 2 and and CC 40436 1038 3 ii ii NNP 40436 1038 4 . . . 40436 1039 1 in in IN 40436 1039 2 Hieronymus Hieronymus NNP 40436 1039 3 Müller Müller NNP 40436 1039 4 's 's POS 40436 1039 5 Uebersetzung Uebersetzung NNP 40436 1039 6 des des FW 40436 1039 7 Platon Platon NNP 40436 1039 8 's 's POS 40436 1039 9 Werke Werke NNP 40436 1039 10 , , , 40436 1039 11 vol vol NNP 40436 1039 12 . . . 40436 1040 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1040 2 pp pp NNP 40436 1040 3 . . . 40436 1041 1 135 135 CD 40436 1041 2 - - SYM 40436 1041 3 509 509 CD 40436 1041 4 . . . 40436 1041 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1042 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1042 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1042 3 41 41 CD 40436 1042 4 : : : 40436 1042 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1042 6 , , , 40436 1042 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1042 8 . . . 40436 1043 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1043 2 p. p. NNP 40436 1043 3 121 121 CD 40436 1043 4 - - SYM 40436 1043 5 124 124 CD 40436 1043 6 . . . 40436 1044 1 Whoever whoever WP 40436 1044 2 reads read VBZ 40436 1044 3 the the DT 40436 1044 4 objections objection NNS 40436 1044 5 in in IN 40436 1044 6 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1044 7 's 's POS 40436 1044 8 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 1044 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1044 10 p. p. NN 40436 1044 11 148 148 CD 40436 1044 12 - - SYM 40436 1044 13 150 150 CD 40436 1044 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1044 15 against against IN 40436 1044 16 the the DT 40436 1044 17 First First NNP 40436 1044 18 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1044 19 , , , 40436 1044 20 will will MD 40436 1044 21 see see VB 40436 1044 22 that that IN 40436 1044 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1044 24 are be VBP 40436 1044 25 quite quite RB 40436 1044 26 as as RB 40436 1044 27 forcible forcible JJ 40436 1044 28 as as IN 40436 1044 29 what what WP 40436 1044 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1044 31 urges urge VBZ 40436 1044 32 against against IN 40436 1044 33 the the DT 40436 1044 34 Second second JJ 40436 1044 35 ; ; : 40436 1044 36 only only RB 40436 1044 37 , , , 40436 1044 38 that that IN 40436 1044 39 in in IN 40436 1044 40 the the DT 40436 1044 41 case case NN 40436 1044 42 of of IN 40436 1044 43 the the DT 40436 1044 44 First first JJ 40436 1044 45 , , , 40436 1044 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1044 47 gives give VBZ 40436 1044 48 these these DT 40436 1044 49 objections objection NNS 40436 1044 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1044 51 legitimate legitimate JJ 40436 1044 52 bearing bearing NN 40436 1044 53 , , , 40436 1044 54 allowing allow VBG 40436 1044 55 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1044 56 to to TO 40436 1044 57 tell tell VB 40436 1044 58 against against IN 40436 1044 59 the the DT 40436 1044 60 merit merit NN 40436 1044 61 of of IN 40436 1044 62 the the DT 40436 1044 63 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1044 64 , , , 40436 1044 65 but but CC 40436 1044 66 not not RB 40436 1044 67 against against IN 40436 1044 68 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1044 69 authenticity authenticity NN 40436 1044 70 . . . 40436 1044 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1045 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1045 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1045 3 42 42 CD 40436 1045 4 : : : 40436 1045 5 See see VB 40436 1045 6 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1045 7 . . . 40436 1046 1 Oekonom Oekonom NNP 40436 1046 2 . . . 40436 1047 1 c. c. NNP 40436 1047 2 4 4 CD 40436 1047 3 ; ; : 40436 1047 4 Cyropæd Cyropæd NNP 40436 1047 5 . . . 40436 1048 1 vii vii NN 40436 1048 2 . . . 40436 1049 1 5 5 CD 40436 1049 2 , , , 40436 1049 3 58 58 CD 40436 1049 4 - - SYM 40436 1049 5 64 64 CD 40436 1049 6 , , , 40436 1049 7 viii viii JJ 40436 1049 8 . . . 40436 1050 1 1 1 CD 40436 1050 2 , , , 40436 1050 3 5 5 CD 40436 1050 4 - - SYM 40436 1050 5 8 8 CD 40436 1050 6 - - SYM 40436 1050 7 45 45 CD 40436 1050 8 ; ; : 40436 1050 9 Laced lace VBN 40436 1050 10 . . . 40436 1051 1 Repub Repub NNP 40436 1051 2 . . . 40436 1052 1 c. c. NNP 40436 1053 1 15 15 CD 40436 1053 2 . . . 40436 1053 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1054 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1054 2 Side side NN 40436 1054 3 - - HYPH 40436 1054 4 note note NN 40436 1054 5 : : : 40436 1054 6 The the DT 40436 1054 7 supposed suppose VBN 40436 1054 8 grounds ground NNS 40436 1054 9 for for IN 40436 1054 10 disallowance disallowance NN 40436 1054 11 are be VBP 40436 1054 12 in in IN 40436 1054 13 reality reality NN 40436 1054 14 only only RB 40436 1054 15 marks mark NNS 40436 1054 16 of of IN 40436 1054 17 inferiority inferiority NN 40436 1054 18 . . . 40436 1054 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1055 1 But but CC 40436 1055 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1055 3 must must MD 40436 1055 4 here here RB 40436 1055 5 repeat repeat VB 40436 1055 6 , , , 40436 1055 7 that that IN 40436 1055 8 because because IN 40436 1055 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1055 10 find find VBP 40436 1055 11 , , , 40436 1055 12 in in IN 40436 1055 13 this this DT 40436 1055 14 or or CC 40436 1055 15 any any DT 40436 1055 16 other other JJ 40436 1055 17 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1055 18 , , , 40436 1055 19 some some DT 40436 1055 20 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 40436 1055 21 not not RB 40436 1055 22 usual usual JJ 40436 1055 23 with with IN 40436 1055 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1055 25 , , , 40436 1055 26 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1055 27 do do VBP 40436 1055 28 not not RB 40436 1055 29 feel feel VB 40436 1055 30 warranted warrant VBN 40436 1055 31 thereby thereby RB 40436 1055 32 in in IN 40436 1055 33 declaring declare VBG 40436 1055 34 the the DT 40436 1055 35 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1055 36 spurious spurious JJ 40436 1055 37 . . . 40436 1056 1 In in IN 40436 1056 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1056 3 judgment judgment NN 40436 1056 4 , , , 40436 1056 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1056 6 must must MD 40436 1056 7 look look VB 40436 1056 8 for for IN 40436 1056 9 a a DT 40436 1056 10 large large JJ 40436 1056 11 measure measure NN 40436 1056 12 of of IN 40436 1056 13 diversity diversity NN 40436 1056 14 in in IN 40436 1056 15 the the DT 40436 1056 16 various various JJ 40436 1056 17 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1056 18 ; ; : 40436 1056 19 and and CC 40436 1056 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1056 21 think think VBP 40436 1056 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1056 23 an an DT 40436 1056 24 injudicious injudicious JJ 40436 1056 25 novelty novelty NN 40436 1056 26 , , , 40436 1056 27 introduced introduce VBN 40436 1056 28 by by IN 40436 1056 29 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1056 30 , , , 40436 1056 31 to to TO 40436 1056 32 set set VB 40436 1056 33 up up RP 40436 1056 34 a a DT 40436 1056 35 canonical canonical JJ 40436 1056 36 type type NN 40436 1056 37 of of IN 40436 1056 38 Platonism Platonism NNP 40436 1056 39 , , , 40436 1056 40 all all DT 40436 1056 41 deviations deviation NNS 40436 1056 42 from from IN 40436 1056 43 which which WDT 40436 1056 44 are be VBP 40436 1056 45 to to TO 40436 1056 46 be be VB 40436 1056 47 rejected reject VBN 40436 1056 48 as as IN 40436 1056 49 forgeries forgery NNS 40436 1056 50 . . . 40436 1057 1 Both both DT 40436 1057 2 the the DT 40436 1057 3 First first JJ 40436 1057 4 and and CC 40436 1057 5 the the DT 40436 1057 6 Second Second NNP 40436 1057 7 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1057 8 appear appear VB 40436 1057 9 to to IN 40436 1057 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1057 11 genuine genuine JJ 40436 1057 12 , , , 40436 1057 13 even even RB 40436 1057 14 upon upon IN 40436 1057 15 the the DT 40436 1057 16 showing showing NN 40436 1057 17 of of IN 40436 1057 18 those those DT 40436 1057 19 very very JJ 40436 1057 20 critics critic NNS 40436 1057 21 who who WP 40436 1057 22 disallow disallow VBP 40436 1057 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1057 24 . . . 40436 1058 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1058 2 , , , 40436 1058 3 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1058 4 , , , 40436 1058 5 and and CC 40436 1058 6 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1058 7 , , , 40436 1058 8 all all DT 40436 1058 9 admit admit VBP 40436 1058 10 that that IN 40436 1058 11 there there EX 40436 1058 12 is be VBZ 40436 1058 13 in in IN 40436 1058 14 both both PDT 40436 1058 15 the the DT 40436 1058 16 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1058 17 a a DT 40436 1058 18 considerable considerable JJ 40436 1058 19 proportion proportion NN 40436 1058 20 of of IN 40436 1058 21 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1058 22 and and CC 40436 1058 23 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1058 24 ideas idea NNS 40436 1058 25 : : : 40436 1058 26 but but CC 40436 1058 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1058 28 maintain maintain VBP 40436 1058 29 that that IN 40436 1058 30 there there EX 40436 1058 31 are be VBP 40436 1058 32 also also RB 40436 1058 33 other other JJ 40436 1058 34 ideas idea NNS 40436 1058 35 which which WDT 40436 1058 36 are be VBP 40436 1058 37 not not RB 40436 1058 38 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1058 39 or or CC 40436 1058 40 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1058 41 , , , 40436 1058 42 and and CC 40436 1058 43 that that IN 40436 1058 44 the the DT 40436 1058 45 texture texture NN 40436 1058 46 , , , 40436 1058 47 style style NN 40436 1058 48 , , , 40436 1058 49 and and CC 40436 1058 50 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 1058 51 of of IN 40436 1058 52 the the DT 40436 1058 53 Second Second NNP 40436 1058 54 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1058 55 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1058 56 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1058 57 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 1058 58 this this DT 40436 1058 59 about about IN 40436 1058 60 the the DT 40436 1058 61 First first JJ 40436 1058 62 also also RB 40436 1058 63 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1058 64 are be VBP 40436 1058 65 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 1058 66 of of IN 40436 1058 67 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1058 68 . . . 40436 1059 1 But but CC 40436 1059 2 if if IN 40436 1059 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1059 4 grant grant VBP 40436 1059 5 these these DT 40436 1059 6 premisses premiss NNS 40436 1059 7 , , , 40436 1059 8 the the DT 40436 1059 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 1059 10 inference inference NN 40436 1059 11 would would MD 40436 1059 12 be be VB 40436 1059 13 , , , 40436 1059 14 not not RB 40436 1059 15 to to TO 40436 1059 16 disallow disallow VB 40436 1059 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1059 18 altogether altogether RB 40436 1059 19 , , , 40436 1059 20 but but CC 40436 1059 21 to to TO 40436 1059 22 admit admit VB 40436 1059 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1059 24 as as IN 40436 1059 25 a a DT 40436 1059 26 work work NN 40436 1059 27 by by IN 40436 1059 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1059 29 , , , 40436 1059 30 of of IN 40436 1059 31 inferior inferior JJ 40436 1059 32 merit merit NN 40436 1059 33 ; ; : 40436 1059 34 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 1059 35 of of IN 40436 1059 36 earlier early JJR 40436 1059 37 days day NNS 40436 1059 38 , , , 40436 1059 39 before before IN 40436 1059 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1059 41 powers power NNS 40436 1059 42 of of IN 40436 1059 43 composition composition NN 40436 1059 44 had have VBD 40436 1059 45 attained attain VBN 40436 1059 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1059 47 maturity maturity NN 40436 1059 48 . . . 40436 1060 1 To to TO 40436 1060 2 presume presume VB 40436 1060 3 that that IN 40436 1060 4 because because IN 40436 1060 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1060 6 composed compose VBD 40436 1060 7 many many JJ 40436 1060 8 excellent excellent JJ 40436 1060 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1060 10 , , , 40436 1060 11 therefore therefore RB 40436 1060 12 all all DT 40436 1060 13 that that WDT 40436 1060 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1060 15 composed compose VBD 40436 1060 16 must must MD 40436 1060 17 have have VB 40436 1060 18 been be VBN 40436 1060 19 excellent excellent JJ 40436 1060 20 , , , 40436 1060 21 is be VBZ 40436 1060 22 a a DT 40436 1060 23 pretension pretension NN 40436 1060 24 formally formally RB 40436 1060 25 disclaimed disclaim VBN 40436 1060 26 by by IN 40436 1060 27 many many JJ 40436 1060 28 critics critic NNS 40436 1060 29 , , , 40436 1060 30 and and CC 40436 1060 31 asserted assert VBN 40436 1060 32 by by IN 40436 1060 33 none none NN 40436 1060 34 . . . 40436 1061 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1061 2 42 42 CD 40436 1061 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1061 4 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1061 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1061 6 allows allow VBZ 40436 1061 7 that that IN 40436 1061 8 the the DT 40436 1061 9 Second Second NNP 40436 1061 10 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1061 11 , , , 40436 1061 12 though though IN 40436 1061 13 not not RB 40436 1061 14 composed compose VBN 40436 1061 15 by by IN 40436 1061 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1061 17 , , , 40436 1061 18 is be VBZ 40436 1061 19 the the DT 40436 1061 20 work work NN 40436 1061 21 of of IN 40436 1061 22 some some DT 40436 1061 23 other other JJ 40436 1061 24 author author NN 40436 1061 25 contemporary contemporary NN 40436 1061 26 , , , 40436 1061 27 an an DT 40436 1061 28 untrained untrained JJ 40436 1061 29 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1061 30 disciple disciple NN 40436 1061 31 attempting attempt VBG 40436 1061 32 to to TO 40436 1061 33 imitate imitate VB 40436 1061 34 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1061 35 . . . 40436 1062 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1062 2 44 44 CD 40436 1062 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1062 4 But but CC 40436 1062 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1062 6 do do VBP 40436 1062 7 not not RB 40436 1062 8 know know VB 40436 1062 9 that that IN 40436 1062 10 there there EX 40436 1062 11 were be VBD 40436 1062 12 any any DT 40436 1062 13 contemporaries contemporary NNS 40436 1062 14 who who WP 40436 1062 15 tried try VBD 40436 1062 16 to to TO 40436 1062 17 imitate imitate VB 40436 1062 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1062 19 : : : 40436 1062 20 though though IN 40436 1062 21 Theopompus Theopompus NNP 40436 1062 22 accused accuse VBD 40436 1062 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1062 24 of of IN 40436 1062 25 imitating imitate VBG 40436 1062 26 others other NNS 40436 1062 27 , , , 40436 1062 28 and and CC 40436 1062 29 called call VBD 40436 1062 30 most most JJS 40436 1062 31 of of IN 40436 1062 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1062 33 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1062 34 useless useless RB 40436 1062 35 as as RB 40436 1062 36 well well RB 40436 1062 37 as as IN 40436 1062 38 false false JJ 40436 1062 39 : : : 40436 1062 40 while while IN 40436 1062 41 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1062 42 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1062 43 , , , 40436 1062 44 in in IN 40436 1062 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1062 46 inferior inferior JJ 40436 1062 47 works work NNS 40436 1062 48 , , , 40436 1062 49 will will MD 40436 1062 50 naturally naturally RB 40436 1062 51 appear appear VB 40436 1062 52 like like IN 40436 1062 53 an an DT 40436 1062 54 imitator imitator NN 40436 1062 55 of of IN 40436 1062 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1062 57 better well JJR 40436 1062 58 self self NN 40436 1062 59 . . . 40436 1063 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1063 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1063 3 43 43 CD 40436 1063 4 : : : 40436 1063 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1063 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1063 7 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 1063 8 . . . 40436 1064 1 ad ad NN 40436 1064 2 Alcib Alcib NNP 40436 1064 3 . . . 40436 1065 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1065 2 p. p. NN 40436 1065 3 186 186 CD 40436 1065 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1065 5 makes make VBZ 40436 1065 6 this this DT 40436 1065 7 general general JJ 40436 1065 8 statement statement NN 40436 1065 9 very very RB 40436 1065 10 justly justly RB 40436 1065 11 , , , 40436 1065 12 but but CC 40436 1065 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1065 14 as as RB 40436 1065 15 well well RB 40436 1065 16 as as IN 40436 1065 17 other other JJ 40436 1065 18 critics critic NNS 40436 1065 19 are be VBP 40436 1065 20 apt apt JJ 40436 1065 21 to to TO 40436 1065 22 forget forget VB 40436 1065 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1065 24 in in IN 40436 1065 25 particular particular JJ 40436 1065 26 cases case NNS 40436 1065 27 . . . 40436 1065 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1066 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1066 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1066 3 44 44 CD 40436 1066 4 : : : 40436 1066 5 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1066 6 , , , 40436 1066 7 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 1066 8 , , , 40436 1066 9 p. p. NN 40436 1066 10 516 516 CD 40436 1066 11 - - SYM 40436 1066 12 519 519 CD 40436 1066 13 . . . 40436 1067 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1067 2 and and CC 40436 1067 3 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 1067 4 indeed indeed RB 40436 1067 5 assign assign VBP 40436 1067 6 the the DT 40436 1067 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1067 8 to to IN 40436 1067 9 a a DT 40436 1067 10 later later JJ 40436 1067 11 period period NN 40436 1067 12 . . . 40436 1068 1 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 1068 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1068 3 ad ad NN 40436 1068 4 Lysin Lysin NNP 40436 1068 5 , , , 40436 1068 6 p. p. NN 40436 1068 7 211 211 CD 40436 1068 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1068 9 thinks think VBZ 40436 1068 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1068 11 the the DT 40436 1068 12 work work NN 40436 1068 13 " " '' 40436 1068 14 antiqui antiqui NNP 40436 1068 15 auctoris auctoris NNP 40436 1068 16 , , , 40436 1068 17 sed se VBD 40436 1068 18 non non AFX 40436 1068 19 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 1068 20 " " '' 40436 1068 21 . . . 40436 1069 1 Steinhart steinhart NN 40436 1069 2 and and CC 40436 1069 3 others other NNS 40436 1069 4 who who WP 40436 1069 5 disallow disallow VBP 40436 1069 6 the the DT 40436 1069 7 authenticity authenticity NN 40436 1069 8 of of IN 40436 1069 9 the the DT 40436 1069 10 Second Second NNP 40436 1069 11 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1069 12 insist insist VBP 40436 1069 13 much much JJ 40436 1069 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1069 15 p. p. NN 40436 1069 16 518 518 CD 40436 1069 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1069 18 upon upon IN 40436 1069 19 the the DT 40436 1069 20 enormity enormity NN 40436 1069 21 of of IN 40436 1069 22 the the DT 40436 1069 23 chronological chronological JJ 40436 1069 24 blunder blunder NN 40436 1069 25 , , , 40436 1069 26 whereby whereby WRB 40436 1069 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1069 28 and and CC 40436 1069 29 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1069 30 are be VBP 40436 1069 31 introduced introduce VBN 40436 1069 32 as as IN 40436 1069 33 talking talk VBG 40436 1069 34 about about IN 40436 1069 35 the the DT 40436 1069 36 death death NN 40436 1069 37 of of IN 40436 1069 38 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 1069 39 king king NN 40436 1069 40 of of IN 40436 1069 41 Macedonia Macedonia NNP 40436 1069 42 , , , 40436 1069 43 who who WP 40436 1069 44 was be VBD 40436 1069 45 killed kill VBN 40436 1069 46 in in IN 40436 1069 47 399 399 CD 40436 1069 48 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1069 49 , , , 40436 1069 50 in in IN 40436 1069 51 the the DT 40436 1069 52 same same JJ 40436 1069 53 year year NN 40436 1069 54 as as IN 40436 1069 55 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1069 56 , , , 40436 1069 57 and and CC 40436 1069 58 four four CD 40436 1069 59 years year NNS 40436 1069 60 after after IN 40436 1069 61 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1069 62 . . . 40436 1070 1 Such such PDT 40436 1070 2 an an DT 40436 1070 3 anachronism anachronism NN 40436 1070 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1070 5 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1070 6 urges urge VBZ 40436 1070 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1070 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1070 9 could could MD 40436 1070 10 never never RB 40436 1070 11 allow allow VB 40436 1070 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1070 13 to to TO 40436 1070 14 commit commit VB 40436 1070 15 . . . 40436 1071 1 But but CC 40436 1071 2 when when WRB 40436 1071 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1071 4 read read VBP 40436 1071 5 the the DT 40436 1071 6 Symposion symposion NN 40436 1071 7 , , , 40436 1071 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1071 9 find find VBP 40436 1071 10 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40436 1071 11 in in IN 40436 1071 12 a a DT 40436 1071 13 company company NN 40436 1071 14 of of IN 40436 1071 15 which which WDT 40436 1071 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1071 17 , , , 40436 1071 18 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1071 19 , , , 40436 1071 20 and and CC 40436 1071 21 Agathon Agathon NNP 40436 1071 22 form form NN 40436 1071 23 a a DT 40436 1071 24 part part NN 40436 1071 25 , , , 40436 1071 26 alluding allude VBG 40436 1071 27 to to IN 40436 1071 28 the the DT 40436 1071 29 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1071 30 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1071 31 : : : 40436 1071 32 dioi dioi NN 40436 1071 33 / / SYM 40436 1071 34 kisis kisis NN 40436 1071 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1071 36 of of IN 40436 1071 37 Mantineia Mantineia NNP 40436 1071 38 , , , 40436 1071 39 which which WDT 40436 1071 40 took take VBD 40436 1071 41 place place NN 40436 1071 42 in in IN 40436 1071 43 386 386 CD 40436 1071 44 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1072 1 No no DT 40436 1072 2 one one NN 40436 1072 3 has have VBZ 40436 1072 4 ever ever RB 40436 1072 5 made make VBN 40436 1072 6 this this DT 40436 1072 7 glaring glaring JJ 40436 1072 8 anachronism anachronism NN 40436 1072 9 a a DT 40436 1072 10 ground ground NN 40436 1072 11 for for IN 40436 1072 12 disallowing disallow VBG 40436 1072 13 the the DT 40436 1072 14 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 1072 15 . . . 40436 1073 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1073 2 says say VBZ 40436 1073 3 that that IN 40436 1073 4 the the DT 40436 1073 5 style style NN 40436 1073 6 of of IN 40436 1073 7 the the DT 40436 1073 8 Second Second NNP 40436 1073 9 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1073 10 copies copy NNS 40436 1073 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1073 12 too too RB 40436 1073 13 closely closely RB 40436 1073 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1073 15 die die VBP 40436 1073 16 ängstlich ängstlich NNP 40436 1073 17 platonisirende platonisirende NNP 40436 1073 18 Sprache Sprache NNP 40436 1073 19 des des NNP 40436 1073 20 Dialogs Dialogs NNP 40436 1073 21 , , , 40436 1073 22 p. p. NN 40436 1073 23 515 515 CD 40436 1073 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1073 25 , , , 40436 1073 26 yet yet CC 40436 1073 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1073 28 agrees agree VBZ 40436 1073 29 with with IN 40436 1073 30 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1073 31 that that IN 40436 1073 32 in in IN 40436 1073 33 several several JJ 40436 1073 34 places place NNS 40436 1073 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1073 36 departs depart VBZ 40436 1073 37 too too RB 40436 1073 38 widely widely RB 40436 1073 39 from from IN 40436 1073 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1073 41 . . . 40436 1073 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1074 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1074 2 Side side NN 40436 1074 3 - - HYPH 40436 1074 4 note note NN 40436 1074 5 : : : 40436 1074 6 The the DT 40436 1074 7 two two CD 40436 1074 8 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1074 9 may may MD 40436 1074 10 probably probably RB 40436 1074 11 be be VB 40436 1074 12 among among IN 40436 1074 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1074 14 's 's POS 40436 1074 15 earlier early JJR 40436 1074 16 compositions composition NNS 40436 1074 17 . . . 40436 1074 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1075 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1075 2 agree agree VBP 40436 1075 3 with with IN 40436 1075 4 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1075 5 and and CC 40436 1075 6 the the DT 40436 1075 7 other other JJ 40436 1075 8 recent recent JJ 40436 1075 9 critics critic NNS 40436 1075 10 in in IN 40436 1075 11 considering consider VBG 40436 1075 12 the the DT 40436 1075 13 First first JJ 40436 1075 14 and and CC 40436 1075 15 Second Second NNP 40436 1075 16 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1075 17 to to TO 40436 1075 18 be be VB 40436 1075 19 inferior inferior JJ 40436 1075 20 in in IN 40436 1075 21 merit merit NN 40436 1075 22 to to IN 40436 1075 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1075 24 's 's POS 40436 1075 25 best good JJS 40436 1075 26 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1075 27 ; ; : 40436 1075 28 and and CC 40436 1075 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1075 30 contend contend VBP 40436 1075 31 that that IN 40436 1075 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1075 33 own own JJ 40436 1075 34 premisses premiss NNS 40436 1075 35 justify justify VBP 40436 1075 36 no no RB 40436 1075 37 more more JJR 40436 1075 38 . . . 40436 1076 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 1076 2 may may MD 40436 1076 3 probably probably RB 40436 1076 4 be be VB 40436 1076 5 among among IN 40436 1076 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1076 7 earlier early JJR 40436 1076 8 productions production NNS 40436 1076 9 , , , 40436 1076 10 though though IN 40436 1076 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1076 12 do do VBP 40436 1076 13 not not RB 40436 1076 14 believe believe VB 40436 1076 15 that that IN 40436 1076 16 the the DT 40436 1076 17 First First NNP 40436 1076 18 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1076 19 was be VBD 40436 1076 20 composed compose VBN 40436 1076 21 during during IN 40436 1076 22 the the DT 40436 1076 23 lifetime lifetime NN 40436 1076 24 of of IN 40436 1076 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1076 26 , , , 40436 1076 27 as as IN 40436 1076 28 Socher Socher NNP 40436 1076 29 , , , 40436 1076 30 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1076 31 , , , 40436 1076 32 and and CC 40436 1076 33 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1076 34 endeavour endeavour VBP 40436 1076 35 to to TO 40436 1076 36 show show VB 40436 1076 37 . . . 40436 1077 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1077 2 45 45 CD 40436 1077 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1077 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1077 5 have have VBP 40436 1077 6 already already RB 40436 1077 7 given give VBN 40436 1077 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1077 9 reasons reason NNS 40436 1077 10 , , , 40436 1077 11 in in IN 40436 1077 12 a a DT 40436 1077 13 previous previous JJ 40436 1077 14 chapter chapter NN 40436 1077 15 , , , 40436 1077 16 for for IN 40436 1077 17 believing believe VBG 40436 1077 18 that that IN 40436 1077 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1077 20 composed compose VBD 40436 1077 21 no no DT 40436 1077 22 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1077 23 at at RB 40436 1077 24 all all RB 40436 1077 25 during during IN 40436 1077 26 the the DT 40436 1077 27 lifetime lifetime NN 40436 1077 28 of of IN 40436 1077 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1077 30 ; ; : 40436 1077 31 still still RB 40436 1077 32 less less JJR 40436 1077 33 in in IN 40436 1077 34 that that DT 40436 1077 35 of of IN 40436 1077 36 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1077 37 , , , 40436 1077 38 who who WP 40436 1077 39 died die VBD 40436 1077 40 four four CD 40436 1077 41 years year NNS 40436 1077 42 earlier early RBR 40436 1077 43 . . . 40436 1078 1 There there EX 40436 1078 2 is be VBZ 40436 1078 3 certainly certainly RB 40436 1078 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 1078 5 in in IN 40436 1078 6 either either DT 40436 1078 7 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1078 8 I. I. NNP 40436 1078 9 or or CC 40436 1078 10 II II NNP 40436 1078 11 . . . 40436 1079 1 to to TO 40436 1079 2 shake shake VB 40436 1079 3 this this DT 40436 1079 4 belief belief NN 40436 1079 5 . . . 40436 1080 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1080 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1080 3 45 45 CD 40436 1080 4 : : : 40436 1080 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1080 6 refers refer VBZ 40436 1080 7 the the DT 40436 1080 8 composition composition NN 40436 1080 9 of of IN 40436 1080 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1080 11 . . . 40436 1081 1 i. i. NN 40436 1081 2 to to IN 40436 1081 3 a a DT 40436 1081 4 time time NN 40436 1081 5 not not RB 40436 1081 6 long long RB 40436 1081 7 before before IN 40436 1081 8 the the DT 40436 1081 9 accusation accusation NN 40436 1081 10 of of IN 40436 1081 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1081 12 , , , 40436 1081 13 when when WRB 40436 1081 14 the the DT 40436 1081 15 enemies enemy NNS 40436 1081 16 of of IN 40436 1081 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1081 18 were be VBD 40436 1081 19 calumniating calumniate VBG 40436 1081 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1081 21 in in IN 40436 1081 22 consequence consequence NN 40436 1081 23 of of IN 40436 1081 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1081 25 past past JJ 40436 1081 26 intimacy intimacy NN 40436 1081 27 with with IN 40436 1081 28 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1081 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1081 30 who who WP 40436 1081 31 had have VBD 40436 1081 32 before before IN 40436 1081 33 that that DT 40436 1081 34 time time NN 40436 1081 35 been be VBN 40436 1081 36 killed kill VBN 40436 1081 37 in in IN 40436 1081 38 404 404 CD 40436 1081 39 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1081 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1082 1 and and CC 40436 1082 2 when when WRB 40436 1082 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1082 4 was be VBD 40436 1082 5 anxious anxious JJ 40436 1082 6 to to TO 40436 1082 7 defend defend VB 40436 1082 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1082 9 master master NN 40436 1082 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1082 11 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 1082 12 . . . 40436 1083 1 p. p. NN 40436 1083 2 186 186 CD 40436 1083 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1083 4 . . . 40436 1084 1 Socher Socher NNP 40436 1084 2 and and CC 40436 1084 3 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1084 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1084 5 p. p. NN 40436 1084 6 210 210 CD 40436 1084 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1084 8 remark remark VB 40436 1084 9 that that IN 40436 1084 10 such such JJ 40436 1084 11 writings writing NNS 40436 1084 12 would would MD 40436 1084 13 do do VB 40436 1084 14 little little JJ 40436 1084 15 good good NN 40436 1084 16 to to IN 40436 1084 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1084 18 under under IN 40436 1084 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1084 20 accusation accusation NN 40436 1084 21 . . . 40436 1085 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 1085 2 place place VBP 40436 1085 3 the the DT 40436 1085 4 composition composition NN 40436 1085 5 of of IN 40436 1085 6 the the DT 40436 1085 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1085 8 earlier early RBR 40436 1085 9 , , , 40436 1085 10 in in IN 40436 1085 11 406 406 CD 40436 1085 12 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1086 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1086 2 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1086 3 , , , 40436 1086 4 p. p. NN 40436 1086 5 151 151 CD 40436 1086 6 - - SYM 40436 1086 7 152 152 CD 40436 1086 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1086 9 , , , 40436 1086 10 and and CC 40436 1086 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1086 12 consider consider VBP 40436 1086 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1086 14 the the DT 40436 1086 15 first first JJ 40436 1086 16 exercise exercise NN 40436 1086 17 of of IN 40436 1086 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1086 19 in in IN 40436 1086 20 the the DT 40436 1086 21 strict strict JJ 40436 1086 22 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 1086 23 method method NN 40436 1086 24 . . . 40436 1087 1 Both both DT 40436 1087 2 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1087 3 and and CC 40436 1087 4 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 1087 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1087 6 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 1087 7 . . . 40436 1088 1 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1088 2 . . . 40436 1089 1 Phil Phil NNP 40436 1089 2 . . . 40436 1090 1 p. p. NN 40436 1090 2 440 440 CD 40436 1090 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1090 4 think think VBP 40436 1090 5 that that IN 40436 1090 6 the the DT 40436 1090 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1090 8 has have VBZ 40436 1090 9 not not RB 40436 1090 10 only only RB 40436 1090 11 a a DT 40436 1090 12 speculative speculative NN 40436 1090 13 but but CC 40436 1090 14 a a DT 40436 1090 15 political political JJ 40436 1090 16 purpose purpose NN 40436 1090 17 ; ; : 40436 1090 18 to to TO 40436 1090 19 warn warn VB 40436 1090 20 and and CC 40436 1090 21 amend amend VB 40436 1090 22 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1090 23 , , , 40436 1090 24 and and CC 40436 1090 25 to to TO 40436 1090 26 prevent prevent VB 40436 1090 27 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1090 28 from from IN 40436 1090 29 surrendering surrender VBG 40436 1090 30 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1090 31 blindly blindly RB 40436 1090 32 to to IN 40436 1090 33 the the DT 40436 1090 34 democracy democracy NN 40436 1090 35 . . . 40436 1091 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1091 2 can can MD 40436 1091 3 not not RB 40436 1091 4 admit admit VB 40436 1091 5 the the DT 40436 1091 6 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 1091 7 that that WDT 40436 1091 8 the the DT 40436 1091 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1091 10 was be VBD 40436 1091 11 written write VBN 40436 1091 12 in in IN 40436 1091 13 406 406 CD 40436 1091 14 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1092 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1092 2 when when WRB 40436 1092 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1092 4 was be VBD 40436 1092 5 twenty twenty CD 40436 1092 6 - - HYPH 40436 1092 7 one one CD 40436 1092 8 years year NNS 40436 1092 9 of of IN 40436 1092 10 age age NN 40436 1092 11 , , , 40436 1092 12 at at IN 40436 1092 13 most most RBS 40436 1092 14 twenty twenty CD 40436 1092 15 - - HYPH 40436 1092 16 two two CD 40436 1092 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1092 18 , , , 40436 1092 19 nor nor CC 40436 1092 20 that that IN 40436 1092 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1092 22 had have VBD 40436 1092 23 any any DT 40436 1092 24 intended intended JJ 40436 1092 25 bearing bearing NN 40436 1092 26 upon upon IN 40436 1092 27 the the DT 40436 1092 28 real real JJ 40436 1092 29 historical historical JJ 40436 1092 30 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1092 31 , , , 40436 1092 32 who who WP 40436 1092 33 left leave VBD 40436 1092 34 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1092 35 in in IN 40436 1092 36 415 415 CD 40436 1092 37 B.C. B.C. NNS 40436 1093 1 at at IN 40436 1093 2 the the DT 40436 1093 3 head head NN 40436 1093 4 of of IN 40436 1093 5 the the DT 40436 1093 6 armament armament NN 40436 1093 7 against against IN 40436 1093 8 Syracuse Syracuse NNP 40436 1093 9 , , , 40436 1093 10 was be VBD 40436 1093 11 banished banish VBN 40436 1093 12 three three CD 40436 1093 13 months month NNS 40436 1093 14 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 1093 15 , , , 40436 1093 16 and and CC 40436 1093 17 never never RB 40436 1093 18 came come VBD 40436 1093 19 back back RB 40436 1093 20 to to IN 40436 1093 21 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1093 22 until until IN 40436 1093 23 May May NNP 40436 1093 24 407 407 CD 40436 1093 25 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1094 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1094 2 Xenoph Xenoph NNP 40436 1094 3 . . . 40436 1095 1 Hellen Hellen NNP 40436 1095 2 . . . 40436 1096 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1097 1 4 4 CD 40436 1097 2 , , , 40436 1097 3 13 13 CD 40436 1097 4 ; ; : 40436 1097 5 i. i. NNP 40436 1098 1 5 5 CD 40436 1098 2 , , , 40436 1098 3 17 17 CD 40436 1098 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1098 5 . . . 40436 1099 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1099 2 then then RB 40436 1099 3 enjoyed enjoy VBD 40436 1099 4 four four CD 40436 1099 5 months month NNS 40436 1099 6 of of IN 40436 1099 7 great great JJ 40436 1099 8 ascendancy ascendancy NN 40436 1099 9 at at IN 40436 1099 10 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1099 11 , , , 40436 1099 12 left leave VBD 40436 1099 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1099 14 at at IN 40436 1099 15 the the DT 40436 1099 16 head head NN 40436 1099 17 of of IN 40436 1099 18 the the DT 40436 1099 19 fleet fleet NN 40436 1099 20 to to IN 40436 1099 21 Asia Asia NNP 40436 1099 22 in in IN 40436 1099 23 Oct. October NNP 40436 1099 24 407 407 CD 40436 1099 25 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1099 26 , , , 40436 1099 27 remained remain VBD 40436 1099 28 in in IN 40436 1099 29 command command NN 40436 1099 30 of of IN 40436 1099 31 the the DT 40436 1099 32 fleet fleet NN 40436 1099 33 for for IN 40436 1099 34 about about RB 40436 1099 35 three three CD 40436 1099 36 months month NNS 40436 1099 37 or or CC 40436 1099 38 so so RB 40436 1099 39 , , , 40436 1099 40 then then RB 40436 1099 41 fell fall VBD 40436 1099 42 into into IN 40436 1099 43 disgrace disgrace NN 40436 1099 44 and and CC 40436 1099 45 retired retire VBN 40436 1099 46 to to IN 40436 1099 47 Chersonese Chersonese NNP 40436 1099 48 , , , 40436 1099 49 never never RB 40436 1099 50 revisiting revisit VBG 40436 1099 51 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1099 52 . . . 40436 1100 1 In in IN 40436 1100 2 406 406 CD 40436 1100 3 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1101 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1101 2 was be VBD 40436 1101 3 again again RB 40436 1101 4 in in IN 40436 1101 5 banishment banishment NN 40436 1101 6 , , , 40436 1101 7 out out IN 40436 1101 8 of of IN 40436 1101 9 the the DT 40436 1101 10 reach reach NN 40436 1101 11 of of IN 40436 1101 12 all all DT 40436 1101 13 such such JJ 40436 1101 14 warnings warning NNS 40436 1101 15 as as IN 40436 1101 16 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 1101 17 and and CC 40436 1101 18 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1101 19 suppose suppose VBP 40436 1101 20 that that IN 40436 1101 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1101 22 intended intend VBD 40436 1101 23 to to TO 40436 1101 24 address address VB 40436 1101 25 to to IN 40436 1101 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1101 27 in in IN 40436 1101 28 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1101 29 . . . 40436 1102 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1102 2 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1102 3 says say VBZ 40436 1102 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1102 5 p. p. NN 40436 1102 6 152 152 CD 40436 1102 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1102 8 , , , 40436 1102 9 " " `` 40436 1102 10 In in IN 40436 1102 11 dieser dieser NN 40436 1102 12 Zeit Zeit NNP 40436 1102 13 also also RB 40436 1102 14 , , , 40436 1102 15 _ _ NNP 40436 1102 16 wenige wenige NNP 40436 1102 17 Jahre Jahre NNP 40436 1102 18 nach nach NN 40436 1102 19 seiner seiner NN 40436 1102 20 triumphirenden triumphirenden VBD 40436 1102 21 Rückkehr Rückkehr NNP 40436 1102 22 _ _ NNP 40436 1102 23 , , , 40436 1102 24 wo wo NNP 40436 1102 25 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1102 26 , , , 40436 1102 27 " " '' 40436 1102 28 & & CC 40436 1102 29 c. c. NNP 40436 1102 30 Now now RB 40436 1102 31 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1102 32 left leave VBD 40436 1102 33 the the DT 40436 1102 34 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 1102 35 service service NN 40436 1102 36 , , , 40436 1102 37 irrevocably irrevocably RB 40436 1102 38 , , , 40436 1102 39 within within IN 40436 1102 40 less less JJR 40436 1102 41 _ _ NNP 40436 1102 42 than than IN 40436 1102 43 one one CD 40436 1102 44 year year NN 40436 1102 45 _ _ NNP 40436 1102 46 after after IN 40436 1102 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1102 48 triumphant triumphant NN 40436 1102 49 return return NN 40436 1102 50 . . . 40436 1103 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1103 2 has have VBZ 40436 1103 3 not not RB 40436 1103 4 realised realise VBN 40436 1103 5 in in IN 40436 1103 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1103 7 mind mind NN 40436 1103 8 the the DT 40436 1103 9 historical historical JJ 40436 1103 10 and and CC 40436 1103 11 chronological chronological JJ 40436 1103 12 conditions condition NNS 40436 1103 13 of of IN 40436 1103 14 the the DT 40436 1103 15 period period NN 40436 1103 16 . . . 40436 1103 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1104 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1104 2 Side side NN 40436 1104 3 - - HYPH 40436 1104 4 note note NN 40436 1104 5 : : : 40436 1104 6 Analogy analogy NN 40436 1104 7 with with IN 40436 1104 8 various various JJ 40436 1104 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1104 10 in in IN 40436 1104 11 the the DT 40436 1104 12 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1104 13 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1104 14 -- -- : 40436 1104 15 Purpose purpose NN 40436 1104 16 of of IN 40436 1104 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1104 18 to to TO 40436 1104 19 humble humble VB 40436 1104 20 presumptuous presumptuous JJ 40436 1104 21 young young JJ 40436 1104 22 men man NNS 40436 1104 23 . . . 40436 1104 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1105 1 If if IN 40436 1105 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1105 3 compare compare VBP 40436 1105 4 various various JJ 40436 1105 5 colloquies colloquy NNS 40436 1105 6 of of IN 40436 1105 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1105 8 in in IN 40436 1105 9 the the DT 40436 1105 10 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1105 11 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1105 12 , , , 40436 1105 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1105 14 shall shall MD 40436 1105 15 find find VB 40436 1105 16 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1105 17 I. I. NNP 40436 1105 18 and and CC 40436 1105 19 II II NNP 40436 1105 20 . . . 40436 1106 1 very very RB 40436 1106 2 analogous analogous JJ 40436 1106 3 to to IN 40436 1106 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1106 5 both both DT 40436 1106 6 in in IN 40436 1106 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 1106 8 and and CC 40436 1106 9 spirit spirit NN 40436 1106 10 . . . 40436 1107 1 In in IN 40436 1107 2 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1107 3 I. I. NNP 40436 1107 4 the the DT 40436 1107 5 situation situation NN 40436 1107 6 conceived conceive VBN 40436 1107 7 is be VBZ 40436 1107 8 the the DT 40436 1107 9 same same JJ 40436 1107 10 as as IN 40436 1107 11 that that DT 40436 1107 12 of of IN 40436 1107 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1107 14 and and CC 40436 1107 15 Glaukon Glaukon NNP 40436 1107 16 , , , 40436 1107 17 in in IN 40436 1107 18 the the DT 40436 1107 19 third third JJ 40436 1107 20 book book NN 40436 1107 21 of of IN 40436 1107 22 the the DT 40436 1107 23 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1107 24 . . . 40436 1108 1 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1108 2 recounts recount VBZ 40436 1108 3 how how WRB 40436 1108 4 the the DT 40436 1108 5 presumptuous presumptuous JJ 40436 1108 6 Glaukon Glaukon NNP 40436 1108 7 , , , 40436 1108 8 hardly hardly RB 40436 1108 9 twenty twenty CD 40436 1108 10 years year NNS 40436 1108 11 of of IN 40436 1108 12 age age NN 40436 1108 13 , , , 40436 1108 14 fancied fancy VBD 40436 1108 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1108 16 already already RB 40436 1108 17 fit fit JJ 40436 1108 18 to to TO 40436 1108 19 play play VB 40436 1108 20 a a DT 40436 1108 21 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 1108 22 part part NN 40436 1108 23 in in IN 40436 1108 24 public public JJ 40436 1108 25 affairs affair NNS 40436 1108 26 , , , 40436 1108 27 and and CC 40436 1108 28 tried try VBD 40436 1108 29 to to TO 40436 1108 30 force force VB 40436 1108 31 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1108 32 , , , 40436 1108 33 in in IN 40436 1108 34 spite spite NN 40436 1108 35 of of IN 40436 1108 36 rebuffs rebuff NNS 40436 1108 37 and and CC 40436 1108 38 humiliations humiliation NNS 40436 1108 39 , , , 40436 1108 40 upon upon IN 40436 1108 41 the the DT 40436 1108 42 notice notice NN 40436 1108 43 of of IN 40436 1108 44 the the DT 40436 1108 45 assembly assembly NN 40436 1108 46 . . . 40436 1109 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1109 2 46 46 CD 40436 1109 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1109 4 No no DT 40436 1109 5 remonstrances remonstrance NNS 40436 1109 6 of of IN 40436 1109 7 friends friend NNS 40436 1109 8 could could MD 40436 1109 9 deter deter VB 40436 1109 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1109 11 , , , 40436 1109 12 nor nor CC 40436 1109 13 could could MD 40436 1109 14 anything anything NN 40436 1109 15 , , , 40436 1109 16 except except IN 40436 1109 17 the the DT 40436 1109 18 ingenious ingenious JJ 40436 1109 19 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 1109 20 of of IN 40436 1109 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1109 22 , , , 40436 1109 23 convince convince VB 40436 1109 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1109 25 of of IN 40436 1109 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1109 27 own own JJ 40436 1109 28 impertinent impertinent JJ 40436 1109 29 forwardness forwardness NN 40436 1109 30 and and CC 40436 1109 31 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 40436 1109 32 self self NN 40436 1109 33 - - HYPH 40436 1109 34 estimation estimation NN 40436 1109 35 . . . 40436 1110 1 Probably probably RB 40436 1110 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1110 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1110 4 Glaukon Glaukon NNP 40436 1110 5 's 's POS 40436 1110 6 elder eld JJR 40436 1110 7 brother brother NN 40436 1110 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1110 9 had have VBD 40436 1110 10 heard hear VBN 40436 1110 11 of of IN 40436 1110 12 this this DT 40436 1110 13 conversation conversation NN 40436 1110 14 , , , 40436 1110 15 but but CC 40436 1110 16 whether whether IN 40436 1110 17 the the DT 40436 1110 18 fact fact NN 40436 1110 19 be be VB 40436 1110 20 so so RB 40436 1110 21 or or CC 40436 1110 22 not not RB 40436 1110 23 , , , 40436 1110 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1110 25 see see VBP 40436 1110 26 the the DT 40436 1110 27 same same JJ 40436 1110 28 situation situation NN 40436 1110 29 idealised idealise VBN 40436 1110 30 by by IN 40436 1110 31 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1110 32 in in IN 40436 1110 33 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1110 34 I. I. NNP 40436 1110 35 , , , 40436 1110 36 and and CC 40436 1110 37 worked work VBD 40436 1110 38 out out RP 40436 1110 39 in in IN 40436 1110 40 a a DT 40436 1110 41 way way NN 40436 1110 42 of of IN 40436 1110 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1110 44 own own JJ 40436 1110 45 . . . 40436 1111 1 Again again RB 40436 1111 2 , , , 40436 1111 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1111 4 find find VBP 40436 1111 5 in in IN 40436 1111 6 the the DT 40436 1111 7 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1111 8 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1111 9 another another DT 40436 1111 10 colloquy colloquy NN 40436 1111 11 , , , 40436 1111 12 wherein wherein WRB 40436 1111 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1111 14 cross cross NN 40436 1111 15 - - NNS 40436 1111 16 questions question NNS 40436 1111 17 , , , 40436 1111 18 perplexes perplexe NNS 40436 1111 19 , , , 40436 1111 20 and and CC 40436 1111 21 humiliates humiliate NNS 40436 1111 22 , , , 40436 1111 23 the the DT 40436 1111 24 studious studious JJ 40436 1111 25 youth youth NN 40436 1111 26 Euthydemus,[47 euthydemus,[47 RB 40436 1111 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1111 28 whom whom WP 40436 1111 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1111 30 regards regard VBZ 40436 1111 31 as as IN 40436 1111 32 over over RB 40436 1111 33 - - HYPH 40436 1111 34 confident confident JJ 40436 1111 35 in in IN 40436 1111 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1111 37 persuasions persuasion NNS 40436 1111 38 and and CC 40436 1111 39 too too RB 40436 1111 40 well well RB 40436 1111 41 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 1111 42 with with IN 40436 1111 43 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1111 44 . . . 40436 1112 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1112 2 was be VBD 40436 1112 3 among among IN 40436 1112 4 the the DT 40436 1112 5 specialties specialty NNS 40436 1112 6 of of IN 40436 1112 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1112 8 to to TO 40436 1112 9 humiliate humiliate VB 40436 1112 10 confident confident JJ 40436 1112 11 young young JJ 40436 1112 12 men man NNS 40436 1112 13 , , , 40436 1112 14 with with IN 40436 1112 15 a a DT 40436 1112 16 view view NN 40436 1112 17 to to IN 40436 1112 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1112 19 future future JJ 40436 1112 20 improvement improvement NN 40436 1112 21 . . . 40436 1113 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1113 2 made make VBD 40436 1113 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1113 4 conversation conversation NN 40436 1113 5 " " `` 40436 1113 6 an an DT 40436 1113 7 instrument instrument NN 40436 1113 8 of of IN 40436 1113 9 chastisement chastisement NN 40436 1113 10 , , , 40436 1113 11 " " '' 40436 1113 12 in in IN 40436 1113 13 the the DT 40436 1113 14 language language NN 40436 1113 15 of of IN 40436 1113 16 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1113 17 : : : 40436 1113 18 or or CC 40436 1113 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1113 20 to to TO 40436 1113 21 use use VB 40436 1113 22 a a DT 40436 1113 23 phrase phrase NN 40436 1113 24 of of IN 40436 1113 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1113 26 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1113 27 in in IN 40436 1113 28 the the DT 40436 1113 29 Lysis lysis NN 40436 1113 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1113 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1113 32 conceived conceive VBD 40436 1113 33 . . . 40436 1114 1 " " `` 40436 1114 2 that that IN 40436 1114 3 the the DT 40436 1114 4 proper proper JJ 40436 1114 5 way way NN 40436 1114 6 of of IN 40436 1114 7 talking talk VBG 40436 1114 8 to to IN 40436 1114 9 youth youth NN 40436 1114 10 whom whom WP 40436 1114 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1114 12 love love VBP 40436 1114 13 , , , 40436 1114 14 was be VBD 40436 1114 15 , , , 40436 1114 16 not not RB 40436 1114 17 to to TO 40436 1114 18 exalt exalt VB 40436 1114 19 and and CC 40436 1114 20 puff puff VB 40436 1114 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1114 22 up up RP 40436 1114 23 , , , 40436 1114 24 but but CC 40436 1114 25 to to TO 40436 1114 26 subdue subdue VB 40436 1114 27 and and CC 40436 1114 28 humiliate humiliate VB 40436 1114 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1114 30 " " '' 40436 1114 31 . . . 40436 1115 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1115 2 48 48 CD 40436 1115 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1115 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1115 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1115 6 46 46 CD 40436 1115 7 : : : 40436 1115 8 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1115 9 . . . 40436 1116 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 1116 2 . . . 40436 1117 1 iii iii NNP 40436 1117 2 . . . 40436 1118 1 6 6 LS 40436 1118 2 . . . 40436 1118 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1119 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1119 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1119 3 47 47 CD 40436 1119 4 : : : 40436 1119 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1119 6 . . . 40436 1120 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1120 2 . . . 40436 1121 1 iv iv XX 40436 1121 2 . . . 40436 1122 1 2 2 LS 40436 1122 2 . . . 40436 1122 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1123 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1123 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1123 3 48 48 CD 40436 1123 4 : : : 40436 1123 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1123 6 . . . 40436 1124 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1124 2 . . . 40436 1125 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1126 1 4 4 CD 40436 1126 2 , , , 40436 1126 3 1 1 CD 40436 1126 4 . . . 40436 1127 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1127 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1127 3 : : : 40436 1127 4 skepsa skepsa NNP 40436 1127 5 / / SYM 40436 1127 6 menoi menoi NNP 40436 1127 7 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 1127 8 mo mo NN 40436 1127 9 / / SYM 40436 1127 10 non non JJ 40436 1127 11 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 1127 12 e)kei e)kei NNPS 40436 1127 13 = = NFP 40436 1127 14 nos nos NNP 40436 1127 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1127 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1127 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1127 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1127 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1127 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1127 21 : : : 40436 1127 22 _ _ NNP 40436 1127 23 kolastêri kolastêri NNP 40436 1127 24 / / SYM 40436 1127 25 ou ou NNP 40436 1127 26 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 1127 27 _ _ NNP 40436 1127 28 tou tou NNP 40436 1127 29 / / SYM 40436 1127 30 s s NNP 40436 1127 31 pa pa NNP 40436 1127 32 / / SYM 40436 1127 33 nt nt RB 40436 1127 34 ' ' '' 40436 1127 35 oi)ome oi)ome NNP 40436 1127 36 / / SYM 40436 1127 37 nous nous JJ 40436 1127 38 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 1127 39 / / SYM 40436 1127 40 nai nai NNP 40436 1127 41 e)rôtô e)rôtô NNP 40436 1127 42 = = SYM 40436 1127 43 n n NNP 40436 1127 44 ê)/legchen ê)/legchen NNP 40436 1127 45 , , , 40436 1127 46 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 1127 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1127 48 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 1127 49 le le NNP 40436 1127 50 / / SYM 40436 1127 51 gôn gôn NNP 40436 1127 52 sunême sunême NNP 40436 1127 53 / / SYM 40436 1127 54 reue reue NNP 40436 1127 55 toi toi NNP 40436 1127 56 = = SYM 40436 1127 57 s s NNP 40436 1127 58 sundiatri sundiatri NNP 40436 1127 59 / / SYM 40436 1127 60 bousin bousin NNP 40436 1127 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1127 62 , , , 40436 1127 63 & & CC 40436 1127 64 c. c. NNP 40436 1127 65 So so RB 40436 1127 66 in in IN 40436 1127 67 the the DT 40436 1127 68 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1127 69 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 1127 70 , , , 40436 1127 71 the the DT 40436 1127 72 youthful youthful JJ 40436 1127 73 Lysis lysis NN 40436 1127 74 says say VBZ 40436 1127 75 to to IN 40436 1127 76 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1127 77 " " `` 40436 1127 78 Talk talk NN 40436 1127 79 to to IN 40436 1127 80 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 1127 81 , , , 40436 1127 82 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1127 83 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1127 84 : : : 40436 1127 85 i(/n i(/n NNP 40436 1127 86 ' ' '' 40436 1127 87 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 1127 88 kola kola NNP 40436 1127 89 / / SYM 40436 1127 90 sê|s sê|s NNP 40436 1127 91 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1127 92 " " `` 40436 1127 93 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1127 94 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1127 95 . . . 40436 1128 1 Lysis lysis NN 40436 1128 2 , , , 40436 1128 3 211 211 CD 40436 1128 4 B b NN 40436 1128 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1128 6 . . . 40436 1129 1 And and CC 40436 1129 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1129 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1129 4 says say VBZ 40436 1129 5 , , , 40436 1129 6 a a DT 40436 1129 7 few few JJ 40436 1129 8 lines line NNS 40436 1129 9 before before IN 40436 1129 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1129 11 210 210 CD 40436 1129 12 E E NNS 40436 1129 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1129 14 , , , 40436 1129 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1129 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1129 17 : : : 40436 1129 18 Ou(/tô Ou(/tô NFP 40436 1129 19 chrê\ chrê\ NNP 40436 1129 20 toi toi NNP 40436 1129 21 = = SYM 40436 1129 22 s s NNP 40436 1129 23 paidikoi paidikoi NNP 40436 1129 24 = = SYM 40436 1129 25 s s NNP 40436 1129 26 diale diale NNP 40436 1129 27 / / SYM 40436 1129 28 gesthai gesthai NNP 40436 1129 29 , , , 40436 1129 30 tapeinou tapeinou NNP 40436 1129 31 = = SYM 40436 1129 32 nta nta NNP 40436 1129 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1129 34 suste suste NNP 40436 1129 35 / / SYM 40436 1129 36 llonta llonta NNP 40436 1129 37 , , , 40436 1129 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1129 39 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 1129 40 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 1129 41 su\ su\ NNP 40436 1129 42 chaunou chaunou NNP 40436 1129 43 = = SYM 40436 1129 44 nta nta NNP 40436 1129 45 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1129 46 diathru diathru NNP 40436 1129 47 / / SYM 40436 1129 48 ptonta ptonta NNP 40436 1129 49 . . . 40436 1129 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1129 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1130 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1130 2 Side side NN 40436 1130 3 - - HYPH 40436 1130 4 note note NN 40436 1130 5 : : : 40436 1130 6 Fitness fitness NN 40436 1130 7 of of IN 40436 1130 8 the the DT 40436 1130 9 name name NN 40436 1130 10 and and CC 40436 1130 11 character character NN 40436 1130 12 of of IN 40436 1130 13 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1130 14 for for IN 40436 1130 15 idealising idealise VBG 40436 1130 16 this this DT 40436 1130 17 feature feature NN 40436 1130 18 in in IN 40436 1130 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1130 20 . . . 40436 1130 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1131 1 If if IN 40436 1131 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1131 3 wished wish VBD 40436 1131 4 to to TO 40436 1131 5 idealise idealise VB 40436 1131 6 this this DT 40436 1131 7 feature feature NN 40436 1131 8 in in IN 40436 1131 9 the the DT 40436 1131 10 character character NN 40436 1131 11 of of IN 40436 1131 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1131 13 , , , 40436 1131 14 no no DT 40436 1131 15 name name NN 40436 1131 16 could could MD 40436 1131 17 be be VB 40436 1131 18 more more RBR 40436 1131 19 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1131 20 to to IN 40436 1131 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1131 22 purpose purpose NN 40436 1131 23 than than IN 40436 1131 24 that that DT 40436 1131 25 of of IN 40436 1131 26 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1131 27 : : : 40436 1131 28 who who WP 40436 1131 29 , , , 40436 1131 30 having have VBG 40436 1131 31 possessed possess VBN 40436 1131 32 as as IN 40436 1131 33 a a DT 40436 1131 34 youth youth NN 40436 1131 35 the the DT 40436 1131 36 greatest great JJS 40436 1131 37 personal personal JJ 40436 1131 38 beauty beauty NN 40436 1131 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1131 40 to to TO 40436 1131 41 which which WDT 40436 1131 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1131 43 was be VBD 40436 1131 44 exquisitely exquisitely RB 40436 1131 45 sensible sensible JJ 40436 1131 46 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1131 47 had have VBD 40436 1131 48 become become VBN 40436 1131 49 in in IN 40436 1131 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1131 51 mature mature JJ 40436 1131 52 life life NN 40436 1131 53 distinguished distinguish VBD 40436 1131 54 not not RB 40436 1131 55 less less JJR 40436 1131 56 for for IN 40436 1131 57 unprincipled unprincipled JJ 40436 1131 58 ambition ambition NN 40436 1131 59 and and CC 40436 1131 60 insolence insolence NN 40436 1131 61 , , , 40436 1131 62 than than IN 40436 1131 63 for for IN 40436 1131 64 energy energy NN 40436 1131 65 and and CC 40436 1131 66 ability ability NN 40436 1131 67 . . . 40436 1132 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1132 2 know know VBP 40436 1132 3 the the DT 40436 1132 4 real real JJ 40436 1132 5 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1132 6 both both CC 40436 1132 7 from from IN 40436 1132 8 Thucydides Thucydides NNP 40436 1132 9 and and CC 40436 1132 10 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1132 11 , , , 40436 1132 12 and and CC 40436 1132 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1132 14 also also RB 40436 1132 15 know know VBP 40436 1132 16 that that IN 40436 1132 17 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1132 18 had have VBD 40436 1132 19 in in IN 40436 1132 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1132 21 youth youth NN 40436 1132 22 so so RB 40436 1132 23 far far RB 40436 1132 24 frequented frequent VBD 40436 1132 25 the the DT 40436 1132 26 society society NN 40436 1132 27 of of IN 40436 1132 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1132 29 as as IN 40436 1132 30 to to TO 40436 1132 31 catch catch VB 40436 1132 32 some some DT 40436 1132 33 of of IN 40436 1132 34 that that DT 40436 1132 35 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 1132 36 ingenuity ingenuity NN 40436 1132 37 , , , 40436 1132 38 which which WDT 40436 1132 39 the the DT 40436 1132 40 latter latter JJ 40436 1132 41 was be VBD 40436 1132 42 expected expect VBN 40436 1132 43 and and CC 40436 1132 44 believed believe VBN 40436 1132 45 to to IN 40436 1132 46 impart impart NN 40436 1132 47 . . . 40436 1133 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1133 2 49 49 CD 40436 1133 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1133 4 The the DT 40436 1133 5 contrast contrast NN 40436 1133 6 , , , 40436 1133 7 as as RB 40436 1133 8 well well RB 40436 1133 9 as as IN 40436 1133 10 the the DT 40436 1133 11 companionship companionship NN 40436 1133 12 , , , 40436 1133 13 between between IN 40436 1133 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1133 15 and and CC 40436 1133 16 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1133 17 was be VBD 40436 1133 18 eminently eminently RB 40436 1133 19 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 1133 20 to to IN 40436 1133 21 the the DT 40436 1133 22 writers writer NNS 40436 1133 23 of of IN 40436 1133 24 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1133 25 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1133 26 , , , 40436 1133 27 and and CC 40436 1133 28 nearly nearly RB 40436 1133 29 all all DT 40436 1133 30 of of IN 40436 1133 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1133 32 made make VBD 40436 1133 33 use use NN 40436 1133 34 of of IN 40436 1133 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1133 36 , , , 40436 1133 37 composing compose VBG 40436 1133 38 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1133 39 in in IN 40436 1133 40 which which WDT 40436 1133 41 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1133 42 was be VBD 40436 1133 43 the the DT 40436 1133 44 principal principal JJ 40436 1133 45 name name NN 40436 1133 46 and and CC 40436 1133 47 figure figure NN 40436 1133 48 . . . 40436 1134 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1134 2 50 50 CD 40436 1134 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1134 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1134 5 would would MD 40436 1134 6 be be VB 40436 1134 7 surprising surprising JJ 40436 1134 8 indeed indeed RB 40436 1134 9 if if IN 40436 1134 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1134 11 had have VBD 40436 1134 12 never never RB 40436 1134 13 done do VBN 40436 1134 14 the the DT 40436 1134 15 same same JJ 40436 1134 16 : : : 40436 1134 17 which which WDT 40436 1134 18 is be VBZ 40436 1134 19 what what WP 40436 1134 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1134 21 must must MD 40436 1134 22 suppose suppose VB 40436 1134 23 , , , 40436 1134 24 if if IN 40436 1134 25 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1134 26 adopt adopt VBP 40436 1134 27 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1134 28 's 's POS 40436 1134 29 view view NN 40436 1134 30 , , , 40436 1134 31 that that IN 40436 1134 32 both both CC 40436 1134 33 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1134 34 I. I. NNP 40436 1134 35 and and CC 40436 1134 36 II II NNP 40436 1134 37 . . . 40436 1135 1 are be VBP 40436 1135 2 spurious spurious JJ 40436 1135 3 . . . 40436 1136 1 In in IN 40436 1136 2 the the DT 40436 1136 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 1136 4 as as RB 40436 1136 5 well well RB 40436 1136 6 as as IN 40436 1136 7 in in IN 40436 1136 8 the the DT 40436 1136 9 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 1136 10 , , , 40436 1136 11 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1136 12 figures figure NNS 40436 1136 13 ; ; : 40436 1136 14 but but CC 40436 1136 15 in in IN 40436 1136 16 neither neither DT 40436 1136 17 of of IN 40436 1136 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1136 19 is be VBZ 40436 1136 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1136 21 the the DT 40436 1136 22 principal principal JJ 40436 1136 23 person person NN 40436 1136 24 , , , 40436 1136 25 or or CC 40436 1136 26 titular titular JJ 40436 1136 27 hero hero NN 40436 1136 28 , , , 40436 1136 29 of of IN 40436 1136 30 the the DT 40436 1136 31 piece piece NN 40436 1136 32 . . . 40436 1137 1 In in IN 40436 1137 2 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1137 3 I. I. NNP 40436 1137 4 and and CC 40436 1137 5 II II NNP 40436 1137 6 . . NNP 40436 1137 7 , , , 40436 1137 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1137 9 is be VBZ 40436 1137 10 introduced introduce VBN 40436 1137 11 as as IN 40436 1137 12 the the DT 40436 1137 13 solitary solitary JJ 40436 1137 14 respondent respondent NN 40436 1137 15 to to IN 40436 1137 16 the the DT 40436 1137 17 questions question NNS 40436 1137 18 of of IN 40436 1137 19 Sokrates--[Greek sokrates--[greek NN 40436 1137 20 : : : 40436 1137 21 kolastêri kolastêri NNP 40436 1137 22 / / SYM 40436 1137 23 ou ou NNP 40436 1137 24 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 1137 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1137 26 : : : 40436 1137 27 to to TO 40436 1137 28 receive receive VB 40436 1137 29 from from IN 40436 1137 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1137 31 a a DT 40436 1137 32 lesson lesson NN 40436 1137 33 of of IN 40436 1137 34 humiliation humiliation NN 40436 1137 35 such such JJ 40436 1137 36 as as IN 40436 1137 37 the the DT 40436 1137 38 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1137 39 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1137 40 administers administer NNS 40436 1137 41 to to IN 40436 1137 42 Glaukon Glaukon NNP 40436 1137 43 and and CC 40436 1137 44 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 1137 45 , , , 40436 1137 46 taking take VBG 40436 1137 47 care care NN 40436 1137 48 to to TO 40436 1137 49 address address VB 40436 1137 50 the the DT 40436 1137 51 latter latter JJ 40436 1137 52 when when WRB 40436 1137 53 alone alone JJ 40436 1137 54 . . . 40436 1138 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1138 2 51 51 CD 40436 1138 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1138 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1138 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1138 6 49 49 CD 40436 1138 7 : : : 40436 1138 8 The the DT 40436 1138 9 sensibility sensibility NN 40436 1138 10 of of IN 40436 1138 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1138 12 to to IN 40436 1138 13 youthful youthful JJ 40436 1138 14 beauty beauty NN 40436 1138 15 is be VBZ 40436 1138 16 as as RB 40436 1138 17 strongly strongly RB 40436 1138 18 declared declare VBN 40436 1138 19 in in IN 40436 1138 20 the the DT 40436 1138 21 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1138 22 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1138 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1138 24 i. i. NNP 40436 1139 1 3 3 CD 40436 1139 2 , , , 40436 1139 3 8 8 CD 40436 1139 4 - - SYM 40436 1139 5 14 14 CD 40436 1139 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1139 7 , , , 40436 1139 8 as as IN 40436 1139 9 in in IN 40436 1139 10 the the DT 40436 1139 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1139 12 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 1139 13 , , , 40436 1139 14 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 1139 15 , , , 40436 1139 16 or or CC 40436 1139 17 Symposion symposion NN 40436 1139 18 . . . 40436 1140 1 The the DT 40436 1140 2 conversation conversation NN 40436 1140 3 reported report VBN 40436 1140 4 by by IN 40436 1140 5 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1140 6 between between IN 40436 1140 7 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1140 8 , , , 40436 1140 9 when when WRB 40436 1140 10 not not RB 40436 1140 11 yet yet RB 40436 1140 12 twenty twenty CD 40436 1140 13 years year NNS 40436 1140 14 of of IN 40436 1140 15 age age NN 40436 1140 16 , , , 40436 1140 17 and and CC 40436 1140 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1140 19 guardian guardian JJ 40436 1140 20 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 1140 21 , , , 40436 1140 22 the the DT 40436 1140 23 first first JJ 40436 1140 24 man man NN 40436 1140 25 in in IN 40436 1140 26 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1140 27 -- -- : 40436 1140 28 wherein wherein WRB 40436 1140 29 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1140 30 puzzles puzzle NNS 40436 1140 31 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 1140 32 by by IN 40436 1140 33 a a DT 40436 1140 34 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1140 35 cross cross NN 40436 1140 36 - - NN 40436 1140 37 examination examination NN 40436 1140 38 -- -- : 40436 1140 39 is be VBZ 40436 1140 40 likely likely JJ 40436 1140 41 enough enough RB 40436 1140 42 to to TO 40436 1140 43 be be VB 40436 1140 44 real real JJ 40436 1140 45 , , , 40436 1140 46 and and CC 40436 1140 47 was be VBD 40436 1140 48 probably probably RB 40436 1140 49 the the DT 40436 1140 50 fruit fruit NN 40436 1140 51 of of IN 40436 1140 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1140 53 sustained sustained JJ 40436 1140 54 society society NN 40436 1140 55 with with IN 40436 1140 56 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1140 57 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1140 58 Xen Xen NNP 40436 1140 59 . . . 40436 1141 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 1141 2 . . . 40436 1142 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1143 1 2 2 CD 40436 1143 2 , , , 40436 1143 3 40 40 CD 40436 1143 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1143 5 . . . 40436 1143 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1144 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1144 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1144 3 50 50 CD 40436 1144 4 : : : 40436 1144 5 Stallbaum stallbaum JJ 40436 1144 6 observes observe VBZ 40436 1144 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1144 8 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 1144 9 . . . 40436 1145 1 ad ad NN 40436 1145 2 Alcib Alcib NNP 40436 1145 3 . . . 40436 1146 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1146 2 p. p. NNP 40436 1146 3 215 215 CD 40436 1146 4 , , , 40436 1146 5 2nd 2nd JJ 40436 1146 6 ed ed NN 40436 1146 7 . . . 40436 1147 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1147 2 , , , 40436 1147 3 " " `` 40436 1147 4 Ceterum Ceterum NNP 40436 1147 5 etiam etiam NN 40436 1147 6 Æschines Æschines NNPS 40436 1147 7 , , , 40436 1147 8 Euclides Euclides NNP 40436 1147 9 , , , 40436 1147 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 1147 11 , , , 40436 1147 12 et et NNP 40436 1147 13 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNP 40436 1147 14 , , , 40436 1147 15 dialogos dialogo NNS 40436 1147 16 _ _ NNP 40436 1147 17 Alcibiadis Alcibiadis NNP 40436 1147 18 _ _ NNP 40436 1147 19 nomine nomine NNP 40436 1147 20 inscriptos inscriptos NNP 40436 1147 21 composuisse composuisse NNP 40436 1147 22 narrantur narrantur NNP 40436 1147 23 " " '' 40436 1147 24 . . . 40436 1148 1 Respecting respect VBG 40436 1148 2 the the DT 40436 1148 3 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1148 4 composed compose VBN 40436 1148 5 by by IN 40436 1148 6 Æschines æschine NNS 40436 1148 7 , , , 40436 1148 8 see see VB 40436 1148 9 the the DT 40436 1148 10 first first JJ 40436 1148 11 note note NN 40436 1148 12 to to IN 40436 1148 13 this this DT 40436 1148 14 chapter chapter NN 40436 1148 15 . . . 40436 1148 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1149 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1149 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1149 3 51 51 CD 40436 1149 4 : : : 40436 1149 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1149 6 . . . 40436 1150 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1150 2 . . . 40436 1151 1 iv iv XX 40436 1151 2 . . . 40436 1152 1 2 2 CD 40436 1152 2 , , , 40436 1152 3 8 8 CD 40436 1152 4 . . . 40436 1152 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1153 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1153 2 Side side NN 40436 1153 3 - - HYPH 40436 1153 4 note note NN 40436 1153 5 : : : 40436 1153 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1153 7 's 's POS 40436 1153 8 manner manner NN 40436 1153 9 of of IN 40436 1153 10 replying reply VBG 40436 1153 11 to to IN 40436 1153 12 the the DT 40436 1153 13 accusers accuser NNS 40436 1153 14 of of IN 40436 1153 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1153 16 . . . 40436 1154 1 Magical magical JJ 40436 1154 2 influence influence NN 40436 1154 3 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 1154 4 to to IN 40436 1154 5 the the DT 40436 1154 6 conversation conversation NN 40436 1154 7 of of IN 40436 1154 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1154 9 . . . 40436 1154 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1155 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1155 2 conceive conceive VBP 40436 1155 3 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1155 4 I. I. NNP 40436 1155 5 and and CC 40436 1155 6 II II NNP 40436 1155 7 . . . 40436 1156 1 as as IN 40436 1156 2 composed compose VBN 40436 1156 3 by by IN 40436 1156 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1156 5 among among IN 40436 1156 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1156 7 earlier early JJR 40436 1156 8 writings writing NNS 40436 1156 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1156 10 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 1156 11 between between IN 40436 1156 12 399 399 CD 40436 1156 13 - - SYM 40436 1156 14 390 390 CD 40436 1156 15 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1157 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1157 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1157 3 52 52 CD 40436 1157 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1157 5 giving give VBG 40436 1157 6 an an DT 40436 1157 7 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 1157 8 picture picture NN 40436 1157 9 of of IN 40436 1157 10 the the DT 40436 1157 11 way way NN 40436 1157 12 in in IN 40436 1157 13 which which WDT 40436 1157 14 " " `` 40436 1157 15 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1157 16 handled handle VBD 40436 1157 17 every every DT 40436 1157 18 respondent respondent NN 40436 1157 19 just just RB 40436 1157 20 as as IN 40436 1157 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1157 22 chose choose VBD 40436 1157 23 " " `` 40436 1157 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1157 25 to to TO 40436 1157 26 use use VB 40436 1157 27 the the DT 40436 1157 28 literal literal JJ 40436 1157 29 phrase phrase NN 40436 1157 30 of of IN 40436 1157 31 Xenophon[53 Xenophon[53 NNP 40436 1157 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1157 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1157 34 : : : 40436 1157 35 taming tame VBG 40436 1157 36 even even RB 40436 1157 37 that that DT 40436 1157 38 most most RBS 40436 1157 39 overbearing overbearing JJ 40436 1157 40 youth youth NN 40436 1157 41 , , , 40436 1157 42 whom whom WP 40436 1157 43 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40436 1157 44 characterises characterise VBZ 40436 1157 45 as as IN 40436 1157 46 the the DT 40436 1157 47 lion lion NN 40436 1157 48 's 's POS 40436 1157 49 whelp whelp NN 40436 1157 50 . . . 40436 1158 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1158 2 54 54 CD 40436 1158 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1158 4 In in IN 40436 1158 5 selecting select VBG 40436 1158 6 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1158 7 as as IN 40436 1158 8 the the DT 40436 1158 9 sufferer sufferer NN 40436 1158 10 under under IN 40436 1158 11 such such PDT 40436 1158 12 a a DT 40436 1158 13 chastising chastising NN 40436 1158 14 process process NN 40436 1158 15 , , , 40436 1158 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1158 17 rebuts rebut NNS 40436 1158 18 in in IN 40436 1158 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1158 20 own own JJ 40436 1158 21 ideal ideal JJ 40436 1158 22 style style NN 40436 1158 23 that that WDT 40436 1158 24 charge charge NN 40436 1158 25 which which WDT 40436 1158 26 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1158 27 answers answer VBZ 40436 1158 28 with with IN 40436 1158 29 prosaic prosaic JJ 40436 1158 30 directness directness NN 40436 1158 31 -- -- : 40436 1158 32 the the DT 40436 1158 33 charge charge NN 40436 1158 34 made make VBN 40436 1158 35 against against IN 40436 1158 36 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1158 37 by by IN 40436 1158 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1158 39 enemies enemy NNS 40436 1158 40 , , , 40436 1158 41 that that IN 40436 1158 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1158 43 taught teach VBD 40436 1158 44 political political JJ 40436 1158 45 craft craft NN 40436 1158 46 without without IN 40436 1158 47 teaching teach VBG 40436 1158 48 ethical ethical JJ 40436 1158 49 sobriety sobriety NN 40436 1158 50 ; ; : 40436 1158 51 and and CC 40436 1158 52 that that IN 40436 1158 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1158 54 had have VBD 40436 1158 55 encouraged encourage VBN 40436 1158 56 by by IN 40436 1158 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1158 58 training training NN 40436 1158 59 the the DT 40436 1158 60 lawless lawless JJ 40436 1158 61 propensities propensity NNS 40436 1158 62 of of IN 40436 1158 63 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1158 64 . . . 40436 1159 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1159 2 55 55 CD 40436 1159 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1159 4 When when WRB 40436 1159 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1159 6 , , , 40436 1159 7 and and CC 40436 1159 8 others other NNS 40436 1159 9 who who WP 40436 1159 10 disallow disallow VBP 40436 1159 11 the the DT 40436 1159 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1159 13 , , , 40436 1159 14 argue argue VBP 40436 1159 15 that that IN 40436 1159 16 the the DT 40436 1159 17 inordinate inordinate JJ 40436 1159 18 insolence insolence NN 40436 1159 19 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 1159 20 to to IN 40436 1159 21 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1159 22 , , , 40436 1159 23 and and CC 40436 1159 24 the the DT 40436 1159 25 submissive submissive JJ 40436 1159 26 deference deference NN 40436 1159 27 towards towards IN 40436 1159 28 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1159 29 also also RB 40436 1159 30 ascribed ascribe VBD 40436 1159 31 to to IN 40436 1159 32 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1159 33 , , , 40436 1159 34 are be VBP 40436 1159 35 incongruous incongruous JJ 40436 1159 36 and and CC 40436 1159 37 incompatible incompatible JJ 40436 1159 38 attributes,--I attributes,--i NN 40436 1159 39 reply reply NN 40436 1159 40 that that IN 40436 1159 41 such such PDT 40436 1159 42 a a DT 40436 1159 43 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 1159 44 is be VBZ 40436 1159 45 very very RB 40436 1159 46 improbable improbable JJ 40436 1159 47 in in IN 40436 1159 48 any any DT 40436 1159 49 real real JJ 40436 1159 50 character character NN 40436 1159 51 . . . 40436 1160 1 But but CC 40436 1160 2 this this DT 40436 1160 3 does do VBZ 40436 1160 4 not not RB 40436 1160 5 hinder hinder VB 40436 1160 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1160 7 from from IN 40436 1160 8 combining combine VBG 40436 1160 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1160 10 in in IN 40436 1160 11 one one CD 40436 1160 12 and and CC 40436 1160 13 the the DT 40436 1160 14 same same JJ 40436 1160 15 ideal ideal JJ 40436 1160 16 character character NN 40436 1160 17 , , , 40436 1160 18 as as IN 40436 1160 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1160 20 shall shall MD 40436 1160 21 farther farther RB 40436 1160 22 see see VB 40436 1160 23 when when WRB 40436 1160 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1160 25 come come VBP 40436 1160 26 to to IN 40436 1160 27 the the DT 40436 1160 28 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 1160 29 of of IN 40436 1160 30 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1160 31 in in IN 40436 1160 32 the the DT 40436 1160 33 Symposion symposion NN 40436 1160 34 : : : 40436 1160 35 in in IN 40436 1160 36 which which WDT 40436 1160 37 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1160 38 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1160 39 find find VBP 40436 1160 40 a a DT 40436 1160 41 combination combination NN 40436 1160 42 of of IN 40436 1160 43 the the DT 40436 1160 44 same same JJ 40436 1160 45 elements element NNS 40436 1160 46 , , , 40436 1160 47 still still RB 40436 1160 48 more more RBR 40436 1160 49 extravagant extravagant JJ 40436 1160 50 and and CC 40436 1160 51 high high JJ 40436 1160 52 - - HYPH 40436 1160 53 coloured coloured JJ 40436 1160 54 . . . 40436 1161 1 Both both DT 40436 1161 2 here here RB 40436 1161 3 and and CC 40436 1161 4 there there RB 40436 1161 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1161 6 are be VBP 40436 1161 7 made make VBN 40436 1161 8 to to TO 40436 1161 9 see see VB 40436 1161 10 that that IN 40436 1161 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1161 12 , , , 40436 1161 13 far far RB 40436 1161 14 from from IN 40436 1161 15 encouraging encourage VBG 40436 1161 16 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1161 17 , , , 40436 1161 18 is be VBZ 40436 1161 19 the the DT 40436 1161 20 only only JJ 40436 1161 21 person person NN 40436 1161 22 who who WP 40436 1161 23 ever ever RB 40436 1161 24 succeeded succeed VBD 40436 1161 25 in in IN 40436 1161 26 humbling humble VBG 40436 1161 27 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1161 28 . . . 40436 1162 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1162 2 attributes attribute VBZ 40436 1162 3 to to IN 40436 1162 4 the the DT 40436 1162 5 personality personality NN 40436 1162 6 and and CC 40436 1162 7 conversation conversation NN 40436 1162 8 of of IN 40436 1162 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1162 10 an an DT 40436 1162 11 influence influence NN 40436 1162 12 magical magical JJ 40436 1162 13 and and CC 40436 1162 14 almost almost RB 40436 1162 15 superhuman superhuman NN 40436 1162 16 : : : 40436 1162 17 which which WDT 40436 1162 18 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 1162 19 and and CC 40436 1162 20 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40436 1162 21 , , , 40436 1162 22 proceeding proceed VBG 40436 1162 23 probably probably RB 40436 1162 24 upon upon IN 40436 1162 25 the the DT 40436 1162 26 evidence evidence NN 40436 1162 27 of of IN 40436 1162 28 the the DT 40436 1162 29 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1162 30 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1162 31 , , , 40436 1162 32 describe describe VBP 40436 1162 33 as as IN 40436 1162 34 if if IN 40436 1162 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1162 36 were be VBD 40436 1162 37 historical historical JJ 40436 1162 38 fact fact NN 40436 1162 39 . . . 40436 1163 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 1163 2 represent represent VBP 40436 1163 3 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1163 4 as as IN 40436 1163 5 shedding shed VBG 40436 1163 6 tears tear NNS 40436 1163 7 of of IN 40436 1163 8 sorrow sorrow NN 40436 1163 9 and and CC 40436 1163 10 shame shame NN 40436 1163 11 , , , 40436 1163 12 and and CC 40436 1163 13 entreating entreat VBG 40436 1163 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1163 15 to to TO 40436 1163 16 rescue rescue VB 40436 1163 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1163 18 from from IN 40436 1163 19 a a DT 40436 1163 20 sense sense NN 40436 1163 21 of of IN 40436 1163 22 degradation degradation NN 40436 1163 23 insupportably insupportably RB 40436 1163 24 painful painful JJ 40436 1163 25 . . . 40436 1164 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1164 2 56 56 CD 40436 1164 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1164 4 Now now RB 40436 1164 5 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1164 6 mentions mention VBZ 40436 1164 7 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 1164 8 and and CC 40436 1164 9 other other JJ 40436 1164 10 young young JJ 40436 1164 11 men man NNS 40436 1164 12 as as IN 40436 1164 13 having have VBG 40436 1164 14 really really RB 40436 1164 15 experienced experience VBN 40436 1164 16 these these DT 40436 1164 17 profound profound JJ 40436 1164 18 and and CC 40436 1164 19 distressing distressing JJ 40436 1164 20 emotions emotion NNS 40436 1164 21 . . . 40436 1165 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1165 2 56 56 CD 40436 1165 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1165 4 But but CC 40436 1165 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1165 6 does do VBZ 40436 1165 7 not not RB 40436 1165 8 at at RB 40436 1165 9 all all RB 40436 1165 10 certify certify VB 40436 1165 11 the the DT 40436 1165 12 same same JJ 40436 1165 13 about about IN 40436 1165 14 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1165 15 , , , 40436 1165 16 whose whose WP$ 40436 1165 17 historical historical JJ 40436 1165 18 career career NN 40436 1165 19 is be VBZ 40436 1165 20 altogether altogether RB 40436 1165 21 adverse adverse JJ 40436 1165 22 to to IN 40436 1165 23 the the DT 40436 1165 24 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 1165 25 . . . 40436 1166 1 The the DT 40436 1166 2 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1166 3 picture picture NN 40436 1166 4 is be VBZ 40436 1166 5 an an DT 40436 1166 6 _ _ NNP 40436 1166 7 idéal idéal NN 40436 1166 8 _ _ NNP 40436 1166 9 , , , 40436 1166 10 drawn draw VBN 40436 1166 11 from from IN 40436 1166 12 what what WP 40436 1166 13 may may MD 40436 1166 14 have have VB 40436 1166 15 been be VBN 40436 1166 16 actually actually RB 40436 1166 17 true true JJ 40436 1166 18 about about IN 40436 1166 19 other other JJ 40436 1166 20 interlocutors interlocutor NNS 40436 1166 21 of of IN 40436 1166 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1166 23 , , , 40436 1166 24 and and CC 40436 1166 25 calculated calculate VBN 40436 1166 26 to to TO 40436 1166 27 reply reply VB 40436 1166 28 to to IN 40436 1166 29 Melêtus Melêtus NNP 40436 1166 30 and and CC 40436 1166 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1166 32 allies ally NNS 40436 1166 33 . . . 40436 1167 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1167 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1167 3 52 52 CD 40436 1167 4 : : : 40436 1167 5 The the DT 40436 1167 6 date date NN 40436 1167 7 which which WDT 40436 1167 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1167 9 here here RB 40436 1167 10 suppose suppose VBP 40436 1167 11 for for IN 40436 1167 12 the the DT 40436 1167 13 composition composition NN 40436 1167 14 of of IN 40436 1167 15 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1167 16 . . . 40436 1168 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1169 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1169 2 _ _ NNP 40436 1169 3 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 1169 4 _ _ NNP 40436 1169 5 after after IN 40436 1169 6 the the DT 40436 1169 7 death death NN 40436 1169 8 of of IN 40436 1169 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1169 10 , , , 40436 1169 11 but but CC 40436 1169 12 early early RB 40436 1169 13 in in IN 40436 1169 14 the the DT 40436 1169 15 literary literary JJ 40436 1169 16 career career NN 40436 1169 17 of of IN 40436 1169 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1169 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1169 20 , , , 40436 1169 21 is be VBZ 40436 1169 22 farther far RBR 40436 1169 23 sustained sustain VBN 40436 1169 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1169 25 against against IN 40436 1169 26 those those DT 40436 1169 27 critics critic NNS 40436 1169 28 who who WP 40436 1169 29 place place VBP 40436 1169 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1169 31 in in IN 40436 1169 32 406 406 CD 40436 1169 33 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1170 1 or or CC 40436 1170 2 402 402 CD 40436 1170 3 B.C. B.C. NNS 40436 1171 1 before before IN 40436 1171 2 the the DT 40436 1171 3 death death NN 40436 1171 4 of of IN 40436 1171 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1171 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1171 7 by by IN 40436 1171 8 the the DT 40436 1171 9 long long JJ 40436 1171 10 discourse discourse NN 40436 1171 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1171 12 p. p. NN 40436 1171 13 121 121 CD 40436 1171 14 - - SYM 40436 1171 15 124 124 CD 40436 1171 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1171 17 of of IN 40436 1171 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1171 19 about about IN 40436 1171 20 the the DT 40436 1171 21 Persian persian JJ 40436 1171 22 and and CC 40436 1171 23 Spartan spartan JJ 40436 1171 24 kings king NNS 40436 1171 25 . . . 40436 1172 1 In in IN 40436 1172 2 reference reference NN 40436 1172 3 to to IN 40436 1172 4 the the DT 40436 1172 5 Persian persian JJ 40436 1172 6 monarchy monarchy NN 40436 1172 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1172 8 says say VBZ 40436 1172 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1172 10 p. p. NN 40436 1172 11 123 123 CD 40436 1172 12 B b NN 40436 1172 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1172 14 , , , 40436 1172 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1172 16 Greek greek NN 40436 1172 17 : : : 40436 1172 18 e)pei/ e)pei/ NN 40436 1172 19 pot pot NN 40436 1172 20 ' ' '' 40436 1172 21 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 1172 22 ê(/kousa ê(/kousa NNP 40436 1172 23 a)ndro\s a)ndro\s NNP 40436 1172 24 a)xiopi a)xiopi NNPS 40436 1172 25 / / SYM 40436 1172 26 stou stou NNP 40436 1172 27 tô tô NNP 40436 1172 28 = = NFP 40436 1172 29 n n CC 40436 1172 30 a)nabebêko a)nabebêko NNP 40436 1172 31 / / SYM 40436 1172 32 tôn tôn NNP 40436 1172 33 para\ para\ NNP 40436 1172 34 basile basile NNP 40436 1172 35 / / , 40436 1172 36 a a DT 40436 1172 37 , , , 40436 1172 38 o(\s o(\s NNP 40436 1172 39 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 1172 40 parelthei parelthei NNP 40436 1172 41 = = SYM 40436 1172 42 n n NNP 40436 1172 43 chô chô NNP 40436 1172 44 / / SYM 40436 1172 45 ran run VBD 40436 1172 46 pa pa NNP 40436 1172 47 / / SYM 40436 1172 48 nu nu NNP 40436 1172 49 pollê\n pollê\n '' 40436 1172 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1172 51 a)gathê a)gathê NNPS 40436 1172 52 / / SYM 40436 1172 53 n n CD 40436 1172 54 -- -- : 40436 1172 55 ê(\n ê(\n NNP 40436 1172 56 kalei kalei NNP 40436 1172 57 = = SYM 40436 1172 58 n n NNP 40436 1172 59 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 1172 60 e)pichôri e)pichôri NNPS 40436 1172 61 / / SYM 40436 1172 62 ous ous JJ 40436 1172 63 zô zô NNP 40436 1172 64 / / SYM 40436 1172 65 nên nên NNP 40436 1172 66 tê tê NNP 40436 1172 67 = = SYM 40436 1172 68 s s NNP 40436 1172 69 basile basile NN 40436 1172 70 / / SYM 40436 1172 71 ôs ôs NNP 40436 1172 72 gunaiko gunaiko NNP 40436 1172 73 / / SYM 40436 1172 74 s s NNP 40436 1172 75 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1172 76 , , , 40436 1172 77 & & CC 40436 1172 78 c. c. NNP 40436 1172 79 Olympiodorus Olympiodorus NNP 40436 1172 80 and and CC 40436 1172 81 the the DT 40436 1172 82 Scholiast Scholiast NNP 40436 1172 83 both both DT 40436 1172 84 suppose suppose VBP 40436 1172 85 that that IN 40436 1172 86 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1172 87 here here RB 40436 1172 88 refers refer VBZ 40436 1172 89 to to IN 40436 1172 90 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1172 91 and and CC 40436 1172 92 the the DT 40436 1172 93 Anabasis Anabasis NNP 40436 1172 94 , , , 40436 1172 95 in in IN 40436 1172 96 which which WDT 40436 1172 97 a a DT 40436 1172 98 statement statement NN 40436 1172 99 very very RB 40436 1172 100 like like IN 40436 1172 101 this this DT 40436 1172 102 is be VBZ 40436 1172 103 found find VBN 40436 1172 104 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1172 105 i. i. NNP 40436 1173 1 4 4 CD 40436 1173 2 , , , 40436 1173 3 9 9 CD 40436 1173 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1173 5 . . . 40436 1174 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1174 2 is be VBZ 40436 1174 3 plain plain JJ 40436 1174 4 , , , 40436 1174 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 1174 6 , , , 40436 1174 7 that that IN 40436 1174 8 _ _ NNP 40436 1174 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1174 10 _ _ NNP 40436 1174 11 did do VBD 40436 1174 12 not not RB 40436 1174 13 consider consider VB 40436 1174 14 the the DT 40436 1174 15 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1174 16 to to TO 40436 1174 17 have have VB 40436 1174 18 been be VBN 40436 1174 19 composed compose VBN 40436 1174 20 before before IN 40436 1174 21 the the DT 40436 1174 22 death death NN 40436 1174 23 of of IN 40436 1174 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1174 25 . . . 40436 1175 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1175 2 think think VBP 40436 1175 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1175 4 very very RB 40436 1175 5 probable probable JJ 40436 1175 6 that that IN 40436 1175 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1175 8 had have VBD 40436 1175 9 in in IN 40436 1175 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1175 11 mind mind NN 40436 1175 12 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1175 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1175 14 either either CC 40436 1175 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1175 16 Anabasis Anabasis NNP 40436 1175 17 , , , 40436 1175 18 or or CC 40436 1175 19 personal personal JJ 40436 1175 20 communications communication NNS 40436 1175 21 with with IN 40436 1175 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1175 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1175 24 ; ; : 40436 1175 25 but but CC 40436 1175 26 at at IN 40436 1175 27 any any DT 40436 1175 28 rate rate NN 40436 1175 29 visits visit NNS 40436 1175 30 of of IN 40436 1175 31 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 1175 32 to to IN 40436 1175 33 the the DT 40436 1175 34 Persian persian JJ 40436 1175 35 court court NN 40436 1175 36 became become VBD 40436 1175 37 very very RB 40436 1175 38 numerous numerous JJ 40436 1175 39 between between IN 40436 1175 40 399 399 CD 40436 1175 41 - - SYM 40436 1175 42 390 390 CD 40436 1175 43 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1175 44 , , , 40436 1175 45 whereas whereas IN 40436 1175 46 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1175 47 can can MD 40436 1175 48 hardly hardly RB 40436 1175 49 have have VB 40436 1175 50 seen see VBN 40436 1175 51 any any DT 40436 1175 52 such such JJ 40436 1175 53 visitors visitor NNS 40436 1175 54 at at IN 40436 1175 55 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1175 56 in in IN 40436 1175 57 406 406 CD 40436 1175 58 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1176 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1176 2 before before IN 40436 1176 3 the the DT 40436 1176 4 close close NN 40436 1176 5 of of IN 40436 1176 6 the the DT 40436 1176 7 war war NN 40436 1176 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1176 9 , , , 40436 1176 10 nor nor CC 40436 1176 11 probably probably RB 40436 1176 12 in in IN 40436 1176 13 402 402 CD 40436 1176 14 B.C. B.C. NNS 40436 1176 15 , , , 40436 1176 16 when when WRB 40436 1176 17 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1176 18 , , , 40436 1176 19 though though IN 40436 1176 20 relieved relieve VBN 40436 1176 21 from from IN 40436 1176 22 the the DT 40436 1176 23 oligarchy oligarchy NN 40436 1176 24 , , , 40436 1176 25 was be VBD 40436 1176 26 still still RB 40436 1176 27 in in IN 40436 1176 28 a a DT 40436 1176 29 state state NN 40436 1176 30 of of IN 40436 1176 31 great great JJ 40436 1176 32 public public JJ 40436 1176 33 prostration prostration NN 40436 1176 34 . . . 40436 1177 1 Between between IN 40436 1177 2 399 399 CD 40436 1177 3 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1178 1 and and CC 40436 1178 2 the the DT 40436 1178 3 peace peace NN 40436 1178 4 of of IN 40436 1178 5 Antalkidas Antalkidas NNP 40436 1178 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1178 7 387 387 CD 40436 1178 8 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1179 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1179 2 , , , 40436 1179 3 visitors visitor NNS 40436 1179 4 from from IN 40436 1179 5 Greece Greece NNP 40436 1179 6 to to IN 40436 1179 7 the the DT 40436 1179 8 interior interior NN 40436 1179 9 of of IN 40436 1179 10 Persia Persia NNP 40436 1179 11 became become VBD 40436 1179 12 more more RBR 40436 1179 13 and and CC 40436 1179 14 more more RBR 40436 1179 15 frequent frequent JJ 40436 1179 16 , , , 40436 1179 17 the the DT 40436 1179 18 Persian persian JJ 40436 1179 19 kings king NNS 40436 1179 20 interfering interfere VBG 40436 1179 21 very very RB 40436 1179 22 actively actively RB 40436 1179 23 in in IN 40436 1179 24 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 1179 25 politics politic NNS 40436 1179 26 . . . 40436 1180 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1180 2 may may MD 40436 1180 3 easily easily RB 40436 1180 4 have have VB 40436 1180 5 seen see VBN 40436 1180 6 during during IN 40436 1180 7 these these DT 40436 1180 8 years year NNS 40436 1180 9 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 1180 10 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 1180 11 who who WP 40436 1180 12 had have VBD 40436 1180 13 been be VBN 40436 1180 14 up up IN 40436 1180 15 to to IN 40436 1180 16 the the DT 40436 1180 17 Persian persian JJ 40436 1180 18 court court NN 40436 1180 19 on on IN 40436 1180 20 military military JJ 40436 1180 21 or or CC 40436 1180 22 political political JJ 40436 1180 23 business business NN 40436 1180 24 . . . 40436 1181 1 Both both DT 40436 1181 2 the the DT 40436 1181 3 Persian persian JJ 40436 1181 4 kings king NNS 40436 1181 5 and and CC 40436 1181 6 the the DT 40436 1181 7 Spartan spartan JJ 40436 1181 8 kings king NNS 40436 1181 9 were be VBD 40436 1181 10 then then RB 40436 1181 11 in in IN 40436 1181 12 the the DT 40436 1181 13 maximum maximum NN 40436 1181 14 of of IN 40436 1181 15 power power NN 40436 1181 16 and and CC 40436 1181 17 ascendancy ascendancy NN 40436 1181 18 -- -- : 40436 1181 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1181 20 is be VBZ 40436 1181 21 no no DT 40436 1181 22 wonder wonder NN 40436 1181 23 therefore therefore RB 40436 1181 24 that that IN 40436 1181 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1181 26 should should MD 40436 1181 27 here here RB 40436 1181 28 be be VB 40436 1181 29 made make VBN 40436 1181 30 to to TO 40436 1181 31 dwell dwell VB 40436 1181 32 upon upon IN 40436 1181 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1181 34 prodigious prodigious JJ 40436 1181 35 dignity dignity NN 40436 1181 36 in in IN 40436 1181 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1181 38 discourse discourse NN 40436 1181 39 with with IN 40436 1181 40 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1181 41 . . . 40436 1182 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1182 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1182 3 Einl Einl NNP 40436 1182 4 . . . 40436 1183 1 p. p. NN 40436 1183 2 150 150 CD 40436 1183 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1183 4 feels feel VBZ 40436 1183 5 the the DT 40436 1183 6 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 1183 7 of of IN 40436 1183 8 reconciling reconcile VBG 40436 1183 9 this this DT 40436 1183 10 part part NN 40436 1183 11 of of IN 40436 1183 12 the the DT 40436 1183 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1183 14 with with IN 40436 1183 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1183 16 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 1183 17 that that IN 40436 1183 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1183 19 was be VBD 40436 1183 20 composed compose VBN 40436 1183 21 in in IN 40436 1183 22 406 406 CD 40436 1183 23 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 1184 1 : : : 40436 1184 2 yet yet CC 40436 1184 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1184 4 and and CC 40436 1184 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1184 6 both both DT 40436 1184 7 insist insist VBP 40436 1184 8 that that IN 40436 1184 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1184 10 must must MD 40436 1184 11 have have VB 40436 1184 12 been be VBN 40436 1184 13 composed compose VBN 40436 1184 14 before before IN 40436 1184 15 the the DT 40436 1184 16 death death NN 40436 1184 17 of of IN 40436 1184 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1184 19 , , , 40436 1184 20 for for IN 40436 1184 21 which which WDT 40436 1184 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1184 23 really really RB 40436 1184 24 produce produce VBP 40436 1184 25 no no DT 40436 1184 26 grounds ground NNS 40436 1184 27 at at RB 40436 1184 28 all all RB 40436 1184 29 . . . 40436 1184 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1185 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1185 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1185 3 53 53 CD 40436 1185 4 : : : 40436 1185 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 1185 6 . . . 40436 1186 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1186 2 . . . 40436 1187 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1188 1 2 2 CD 40436 1188 2 , , , 40436 1188 3 14 14 CD 40436 1188 4 . . . 40436 1189 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1189 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1189 3 : : : 40436 1189 4 toi toi NNP 40436 1189 5 = = SYM 40436 1189 6 s s NNP 40436 1189 7 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1189 8 dialegome dialegome NNP 40436 1189 9 / / SYM 40436 1189 10 nois nois NNP 40436 1189 11 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 1189 12 pa pa NNP 40436 1189 13 = = SYM 40436 1189 14 si si NNP 40436 1189 15 chrô chrô NNP 40436 1189 16 / / SYM 40436 1189 17 menon menon NNP 40436 1189 18 e)n e)n NNP 40436 1189 19 toi toi NNP 40436 1189 20 = = SYM 40436 1189 21 s s NNP 40436 1189 22 lo lo NNP 40436 1189 23 / / SYM 40436 1189 24 gois gois NNP 40436 1189 25 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 1189 26 bou bou NNP 40436 1189 27 / / SYM 40436 1189 28 loito loito NNP 40436 1189 29 . . . 40436 1189 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1189 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1190 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1190 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1190 3 54 54 CD 40436 1190 4 : : : 40436 1190 5 Aristoph Aristoph NNS 40436 1190 6 . . . 40436 1191 1 Ran ran NN 40436 1191 2 . . . 40436 1192 1 1431 1431 CD 40436 1192 2 . . . 40436 1193 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1193 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1193 3 : : : 40436 1193 4 ou ou NNP 40436 1193 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1193 6 chrê\ chrê\ NNP 40436 1193 7 le le NNP 40436 1193 8 / / SYM 40436 1193 9 ontos ontos NNP 40436 1193 10 sku sku NNP 40436 1193 11 / / SYM 40436 1193 12 mnon mnon NNP 40436 1193 13 e)n e)n NNP 40436 1193 14 po po NNP 40436 1193 15 / / SYM 40436 1193 16 lei lei NNP 40436 1193 17 tre tre NNP 40436 1193 18 / / SYM 40436 1193 19 phein phein NNP 40436 1193 20 . . . 40436 1193 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1194 1 Thucyd Thucyd NNP 40436 1194 2 . . . 40436 1195 1 vi vi NNP 40436 1195 2 . . . 40436 1196 1 15 15 CD 40436 1196 2 . . . 40436 1197 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1197 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1197 3 : : : 40436 1197 4 phobêthe phobêthe NNS 40436 1197 5 / / SYM 40436 1197 6 ntes nte NNS 40436 1197 7 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 1197 8 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 1197 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1197 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1197 11 Alkib alkib UH 40436 1197 12 . . . 40436 1197 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1198 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1198 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1198 3 : : : 40436 1198 4 oi oi NNP 40436 1198 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1198 6 polloi\ polloi\ NNP 40436 1198 7 to\ to\ VB 40436 1198 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1198 9 / / SYM 40436 1198 10 gethos gethos VBP 40436 1198 11 tê tê NNP 40436 1198 12 = = SYM 40436 1198 13 s s NNP 40436 1198 14 te te NNP 40436 1198 15 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 1198 16 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1198 17 e(autou= e(autou= NNP 40436 1198 18 sô sô NNP 40436 1198 19 = = SYM 40436 1198 20 ma ma NNP 40436 1198 21 paranomi paranomi NNP 40436 1198 22 / / SYM 40436 1198 23 as as IN 40436 1198 24 e)s e)s NNP 40436 1198 25 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 1198 26 di di NNP 40436 1198 27 / / SYM 40436 1198 28 aitan aitan NNP 40436 1198 29 , , , 40436 1198 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1198 31 tê tê NNP 40436 1198 32 = = SYM 40436 1198 33 s s NNP 40436 1198 34 dianoi dianoi NN 40436 1198 35 / / SYM 40436 1198 36 as as IN 40436 1198 37 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 1198 38 kath kath NN 40436 1198 39 ' ' '' 40436 1198 40 e(\n e(\n NNP 40436 1198 41 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 1198 42 , , , 40436 1198 43 e)n e)n NNP 40436 1198 44 o(/tô| o(/tô| NNP 40436 1198 45 gi gi NNP 40436 1198 46 / / SYM 40436 1198 47 gnoito gnoito NNP 40436 1198 48 , , , 40436 1198 49 e)/prassen e)/prassen NNP 40436 1198 50 , , , 40436 1198 51 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 1198 52 turanni turanni NNP 40436 1198 53 / / SYM 40436 1198 54 dos dos NNP 40436 1198 55 e)pithumou e)pithumou , 40436 1198 56 = = SYM 40436 1198 57 nti nti NNP 40436 1198 58 pole pole NNP 40436 1198 59 / / SYM 40436 1198 60 mioi mioi NNP 40436 1198 61 kathe kathe NNP 40436 1198 62 / / SYM 40436 1198 63 stasan stasan NNP 40436 1198 64 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1198 65 , , , 40436 1198 66 & & CC 40436 1198 67 c. c. NNP 40436 1198 68 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1198 69 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1198 70 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1198 71 55 55 CD 40436 1198 72 : : : 40436 1198 73 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1198 74 . . . 40436 1199 1 Memorab Memorab NNP 40436 1199 2 . . . 40436 1200 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1201 1 2 2 CD 40436 1201 2 , , , 40436 1201 3 17 17 CD 40436 1201 4 . . . 40436 1201 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1202 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1202 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1202 3 56 56 CD 40436 1202 4 : : : 40436 1202 5 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 1202 6 , , , 40436 1202 7 Tusc tusc JJ 40436 1202 8 . . . 40436 1203 1 Disp disp RB 40436 1203 2 . . . 40436 1204 1 iii iii NNP 40436 1204 2 . . . 40436 1205 1 32 32 CD 40436 1205 2 , , , 40436 1205 3 77 77 CD 40436 1205 4 ; ; : 40436 1205 5 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40436 1205 6 , , , 40436 1205 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1205 8 . . . 40436 1206 1 c. c. NNP 40436 1206 2 4 4 CD 40436 1206 3 - - SYM 40436 1206 4 6 6 CD 40436 1206 5 . . . 40436 1207 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 1207 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1207 3 , , , 40436 1207 4 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1207 5 . . . 40436 1208 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1208 2 p. p. NN 40436 1208 3 127 127 CD 40436 1208 4 D d NN 40436 1208 5 , , , 40436 1208 6 135 135 CD 40436 1208 7 C c NN 40436 1208 8 ; ; : 40436 1208 9 Symposion symposion NN 40436 1208 10 , , , 40436 1208 11 p. p. NN 40436 1209 1 215 215 CD 40436 1209 2 - - SYM 40436 1209 3 216 216 CD 40436 1209 4 . . . 40436 1209 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1210 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1210 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1210 3 57 57 CD 40436 1210 4 : : : 40436 1210 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1210 6 . . . 40436 1211 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 1211 2 . . . 40436 1212 1 iv iv XX 40436 1212 2 . . . 40436 1213 1 2 2 CD 40436 1213 2 , , , 40436 1213 3 39 39 CD 40436 1213 4 - - SYM 40436 1213 5 40 40 CD 40436 1213 6 . . . 40436 1213 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1214 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1214 2 Side side NN 40436 1214 3 - - HYPH 40436 1214 4 note note NN 40436 1214 5 : : : 40436 1214 6 The the DT 40436 1214 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 1214 8 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 1214 9 by by IN 40436 1214 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1214 11 in in IN 40436 1214 12 the the DT 40436 1214 13 Apology Apology NNP 40436 1214 14 is be VBZ 40436 1214 15 followed follow VBN 40436 1214 16 out out RP 40436 1214 17 in in IN 40436 1214 18 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1214 19 . . . 40436 1215 1 I. I. NNP 40436 1216 1 Warfare warfare VB 40436 1216 2 against against IN 40436 1216 3 the the DT 40436 1216 4 false false JJ 40436 1216 5 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 1216 6 of of IN 40436 1216 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1216 8 . . . 40436 1216 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1217 1 Looking look VBG 40436 1217 2 at at IN 40436 1217 3 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1217 4 I. I. NNP 40436 1217 5 and and CC 40436 1217 6 II II NNP 40436 1217 7 . . . 40436 1218 1 in in IN 40436 1218 2 this this DT 40436 1218 3 point point NN 40436 1218 4 of of IN 40436 1218 5 view view NN 40436 1218 6 , , , 40436 1218 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1218 8 shall shall MD 40436 1218 9 find find VB 40436 1218 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1218 11 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 1218 12 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1218 13 both both CC 40436 1218 14 in in IN 40436 1218 15 topics topic NNS 40436 1218 16 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 1218 17 and and CC 40436 1218 18 in in IN 40436 1218 19 manner manner NN 40436 1218 20 -- -- : 40436 1218 21 whatever whatever WDT 40436 1218 22 may may MD 40436 1218 23 be be VB 40436 1218 24 said say VBN 40436 1218 25 about about IN 40436 1218 26 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 40436 1218 27 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 1218 28 and and CC 40436 1218 29 common common JJ 40436 1218 30 - - HYPH 40436 1218 31 place place NN 40436 1218 32 here here RB 40436 1218 33 and and CC 40436 1218 34 there there RB 40436 1218 35 . . . 40436 1219 1 The the DT 40436 1219 2 leading lead VBG 40436 1219 3 ideas idea NNS 40436 1219 4 of of IN 40436 1219 5 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1219 6 I. I. NNP 40436 1219 7 may may MD 40436 1219 8 be be VB 40436 1219 9 found find VBN 40436 1219 10 , , , 40436 1219 11 nearly nearly RB 40436 1219 12 all all DT 40436 1219 13 , , , 40436 1219 14 in in IN 40436 1219 15 the the DT 40436 1219 16 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1219 17 Apology Apology NNP 40436 1219 18 . . . 40436 1220 1 That that DT 40436 1220 2 warfare warfare NN 40436 1220 3 , , , 40436 1220 4 which which WDT 40436 1220 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1220 6 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 1220 7 in in IN 40436 1220 8 the the DT 40436 1220 9 Apology Apology NNP 40436 1220 10 as as IN 40436 1220 11 having have VBG 40436 1220 12 been be VBN 40436 1220 13 the the DT 40436 1220 14 mission mission NN 40436 1220 15 of of IN 40436 1220 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1220 17 life life NN 40436 1220 18 , , , 40436 1220 19 against against IN 40436 1220 20 the the DT 40436 1220 21 false false JJ 40436 1220 22 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 1220 23 of of IN 40436 1220 24 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1220 25 , , , 40436 1220 26 or or CC 40436 1220 27 against against IN 40436 1220 28 beliefs belief NNS 40436 1220 29 ethical ethical JJ 40436 1220 30 and and CC 40436 1220 31 æsthetical æsthetical JJ 40436 1220 32 , , , 40436 1220 33 firmly firmly RB 40436 1220 34 entertained entertain VBD 40436 1220 35 without without IN 40436 1220 36 having have VBG 40436 1220 37 been be VBN 40436 1220 38 preceded precede VBN 40436 1220 39 by by IN 40436 1220 40 conscious conscious JJ 40436 1220 41 study study NN 40436 1220 42 or or CC 40436 1220 43 subjected subject VBN 40436 1220 44 to to IN 40436 1220 45 serious serious JJ 40436 1220 46 examination examination NN 40436 1220 47 -- -- : 40436 1220 48 is be VBZ 40436 1220 49 exemplified exemplify VBN 40436 1220 50 in in IN 40436 1220 51 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1220 52 I. I. NNP 40436 1220 53 and and CC 40436 1220 54 II II NNP 40436 1220 55 . . . 40436 1221 1 as as RB 40436 1221 2 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 1221 3 as as IN 40436 1221 4 in in IN 40436 1221 5 any any DT 40436 1221 6 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1221 7 composition composition NN 40436 1221 8 . . . 40436 1222 1 In in IN 40436 1222 2 both both PDT 40436 1222 3 these these DT 40436 1222 4 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1222 5 , , , 40436 1222 6 indeed indeed RB 40436 1222 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1222 8 especially especially RB 40436 1222 9 in in IN 40436 1222 10 the the DT 40436 1222 11 first first JJ 40436 1222 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1222 13 , , , 40436 1222 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1222 15 find find VBP 40436 1222 16 an an DT 40436 1222 17 excessive excessive JJ 40436 1222 18 repetition repetition NN 40436 1222 19 of of IN 40436 1222 20 specialising specialise VBG 40436 1222 21 illustrations illustration NNS 40436 1222 22 , , , 40436 1222 23 often often RB 40436 1222 24 needless needless JJ 40436 1222 25 and and CC 40436 1222 26 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1222 27 tiresome tiresome JJ 40436 1222 28 : : : 40436 1222 29 a a DT 40436 1222 30 defect defect NN 40436 1222 31 easily easily RB 40436 1222 32 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 1222 33 if if IN 40436 1222 34 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1222 35 assume assume VBP 40436 1222 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1222 37 to to TO 40436 1222 38 have have VB 40436 1222 39 been be VBN 40436 1222 40 written write VBN 40436 1222 41 when when WRB 40436 1222 42 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1222 43 was be VBD 40436 1222 44 still still RB 40436 1222 45 a a DT 40436 1222 46 novice novice NN 40436 1222 47 in in IN 40436 1222 48 the the DT 40436 1222 49 art art NN 40436 1222 50 of of IN 40436 1222 51 dialogic dialogic JJ 40436 1222 52 composition composition NN 40436 1222 53 . . . 40436 1223 1 But but CC 40436 1223 2 both both DT 40436 1223 3 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1223 4 are be VBP 40436 1223 5 fully fully RB 40436 1223 6 impregnated impregnate VBN 40436 1223 7 with with IN 40436 1223 8 the the DT 40436 1223 9 spirit spirit NN 40436 1223 10 of of IN 40436 1223 11 the the DT 40436 1223 12 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1223 13 process process NN 40436 1223 14 , , , 40436 1223 15 exposing exposing NN 40436 1223 16 , , , 40436 1223 17 though though RB 40436 1223 18 with with IN 40436 1223 19 exuberant exuberant JJ 40436 1223 20 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 1223 21 , , , 40436 1223 22 the the DT 40436 1223 23 firm firm JJ 40436 1223 24 and and CC 40436 1223 25 universal universal JJ 40436 1223 26 belief belief NN 40436 1223 27 , , , 40436 1223 28 held hold VBN 40436 1223 29 and and CC 40436 1223 30 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 1223 31 by by IN 40436 1223 32 every every DT 40436 1223 33 one one NN 40436 1223 34 even even RB 40436 1223 35 at at IN 40436 1223 36 the the DT 40436 1223 37 age age NN 40436 1223 38 of of IN 40436 1223 39 boyhood boyhood NN 40436 1223 40 , , , 40436 1223 41 without without IN 40436 1223 42 any any DT 40436 1223 43 assignable assignable JJ 40436 1223 44 grounds ground NNS 40436 1223 45 or or CC 40436 1223 46 modes mode NNS 40436 1223 47 of of IN 40436 1223 48 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 1223 49 , , , 40436 1223 50 and and CC 40436 1223 51 amidst amidst IN 40436 1223 52 angry angry JJ 40436 1223 53 discordance discordance NN 40436 1223 54 between between IN 40436 1223 55 the the DT 40436 1223 56 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 1223 57 of of IN 40436 1223 58 one one CD 40436 1223 59 man man NN 40436 1223 60 and and CC 40436 1223 61 another another DT 40436 1223 62 . . . 40436 1224 1 The the DT 40436 1224 2 emphasis emphasis NN 40436 1224 3 too too RB 40436 1224 4 with with IN 40436 1224 5 which which WDT 40436 1224 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1224 7 insists insist VBZ 40436 1224 8 upon upon IN 40436 1224 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1224 10 own own JJ 40436 1224 11 single single JJ 40436 1224 12 function function NN 40436 1224 13 of of IN 40436 1224 14 merely merely RB 40436 1224 15 questioning question VBG 40436 1224 16 , , , 40436 1224 17 and and CC 40436 1224 18 upon upon IN 40436 1224 19 the the DT 40436 1224 20 fact fact NN 40436 1224 21 that that IN 40436 1224 22 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1224 23 gives give VBZ 40436 1224 24 all all PDT 40436 1224 25 the the DT 40436 1224 26 answers answer NNS 40436 1224 27 and and CC 40436 1224 28 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 1224 29 all all PDT 40436 1224 30 the the DT 40436 1224 31 self self NN 40436 1224 32 - - HYPH 40436 1224 33 condemnation condemnation NN 40436 1224 34 with with IN 40436 1224 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1224 36 own own JJ 40436 1224 37 mouth[58]--is mouth[58]--is NN 40436 1224 38 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 1224 39 in in IN 40436 1224 40 this this DT 40436 1224 41 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1224 42 : : : 40436 1224 43 as as RB 40436 1224 44 well well RB 40436 1224 45 as as IN 40436 1224 46 the the DT 40436 1224 47 confidence confidence NN 40436 1224 48 with with IN 40436 1224 49 which which WDT 40436 1224 50 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1224 51 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 1224 52 the the DT 40436 1224 53 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1224 54 as as IN 40436 1224 55 affording afford VBG 40436 1224 56 the the DT 40436 1224 57 only only JJ 40436 1224 58 , , , 40436 1224 59 but but CC 40436 1224 60 effective effective JJ 40436 1224 61 , , , 40436 1224 62 cure cure JJ 40436 1224 63 . . . 40436 1225 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1225 2 59 59 CD 40436 1225 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1225 4 The the DT 40436 1225 5 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 1225 6 of of IN 40436 1225 7 which which WDT 40436 1225 8 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1225 9 stands stand VBZ 40436 1225 10 unexpectedly unexpectedly RB 40436 1225 11 convicted convict VBN 40436 1225 12 , , , 40436 1225 13 is be VBZ 40436 1225 14 expressly expressly RB 40436 1225 15 declared declare VBN 40436 1225 16 to to TO 40436 1225 17 be be VB 40436 1225 18 common common JJ 40436 1225 19 to to IN 40436 1225 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1225 21 with with IN 40436 1225 22 the the DT 40436 1225 23 other other JJ 40436 1225 24 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 1225 25 politicians politician NNS 40436 1225 26 : : : 40436 1225 27 an an DT 40436 1225 28 exception exception NN 40436 1225 29 being be VBG 40436 1225 30 half half NN 40436 1225 31 allowed allow VBN 40436 1225 32 to to TO 40436 1225 33 pass pass VB 40436 1225 34 in in IN 40436 1225 35 favour favour NN 40436 1225 36 of of IN 40436 1225 37 the the DT 40436 1225 38 semi semi JJ 40436 1225 39 - - JJ 40436 1225 40 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 1225 41 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 1225 42 , , , 40436 1225 43 whom whom WP 40436 1225 44 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1225 45 judges judge NNS 40436 1225 46 here here RB 40436 1225 47 with with IN 40436 1225 48 less less JJR 40436 1225 49 severity severity NN 40436 1225 50 than than IN 40436 1225 51 elsewhere[60]--and elsewhere[60]--and CC 40436 1225 52 a a DT 40436 1225 53 decided decide VBN 40436 1225 54 superiority superiority NN 40436 1225 55 being be VBG 40436 1225 56 claimed claim VBN 40436 1225 57 for for IN 40436 1225 58 the the DT 40436 1225 59 Spartan Spartan NNP 40436 1225 60 and and CC 40436 1225 61 Persian persian JJ 40436 1225 62 kings king NNS 40436 1225 63 , , , 40436 1225 64 who who WP 40436 1225 65 are be VBP 40436 1225 66 extolled extoll VBN 40436 1225 67 as as IN 40436 1225 68 systematically systematically RB 40436 1225 69 trained train VBN 40436 1225 70 from from IN 40436 1225 71 childhood childhood NN 40436 1225 72 . . . 40436 1226 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1226 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1226 3 58 58 CD 40436 1226 4 : : : 40436 1226 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1226 6 , , , 40436 1226 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1226 8 . . . 40436 1227 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1227 2 p. p. NNP 40436 1228 1 112 112 CD 40436 1228 2 - - SYM 40436 1228 3 113 113 CD 40436 1228 4 . . . 40436 1228 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1229 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1229 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1229 3 59 59 CD 40436 1229 4 : : : 40436 1229 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1229 6 , , , 40436 1229 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1229 8 . . . 40436 1230 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1230 2 p. p. NN 40436 1230 3 127 127 CD 40436 1230 4 E. E. NNP 40436 1230 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1230 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1230 7 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1230 8 60 60 CD 40436 1230 9 : : : 40436 1230 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1230 11 , , , 40436 1230 12 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1230 13 . . . 40436 1231 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1231 2 p. p. NNP 40436 1232 1 118 118 CD 40436 1232 2 - - SYM 40436 1232 3 120 120 CD 40436 1232 4 . . . 40436 1232 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1233 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1233 2 Side side NN 40436 1233 3 - - HYPH 40436 1233 4 note note NN 40436 1233 5 : : : 40436 1233 6 Difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 1233 7 multiplied multiply VBN 40436 1233 8 for for IN 40436 1233 9 the the DT 40436 1233 10 purpose purpose NN 40436 1233 11 of of IN 40436 1233 12 bringing bring VBG 40436 1233 13 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1233 14 to to IN 40436 1233 15 a a DT 40436 1233 16 conviction conviction NN 40436 1233 17 of of IN 40436 1233 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1233 19 own own JJ 40436 1233 20 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 1233 21 . . . 40436 1233 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1234 1 The the DT 40436 1234 2 main main JJ 40436 1234 3 purpose purpose NN 40436 1234 4 of of IN 40436 1234 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1234 6 is be VBZ 40436 1234 7 to to TO 40436 1234 8 drive drive VB 40436 1234 9 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1234 10 into into IN 40436 1234 11 self self NN 40436 1234 12 - - HYPH 40436 1234 13 contradictions contradiction NNS 40436 1234 14 , , , 40436 1234 15 and and CC 40436 1234 16 to to TO 40436 1234 17 force force VB 40436 1234 18 upon upon IN 40436 1234 19 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1234 20 a a DT 40436 1234 21 painful painful JJ 40436 1234 22 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 1234 23 of of IN 40436 1234 24 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 1234 25 and and CC 40436 1234 26 mental mental JJ 40436 1234 27 defect defect NN 40436 1234 28 , , , 40436 1234 29 upon upon IN 40436 1234 30 grave grave JJ 40436 1234 31 and and CC 40436 1234 32 important important JJ 40436 1234 33 subjects subject NNS 40436 1234 34 , , , 40436 1234 35 while while IN 40436 1234 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1234 37 is be VBZ 40436 1234 38 yet yet RB 40436 1234 39 young young JJ 40436 1234 40 enough enough RB 40436 1234 41 to to TO 40436 1234 42 amend amend VB 40436 1234 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1234 44 . . . 40436 1235 1 Towards towards IN 40436 1235 2 this this DT 40436 1235 3 purpose purpose NN 40436 1235 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1235 5 is be VBZ 40436 1235 6 made make VBN 40436 1235 7 to to TO 40436 1235 8 lay lay VB 40436 1235 9 claim claim NN 40436 1235 10 to to IN 40436 1235 11 a a DT 40436 1235 12 divine divine JJ 40436 1235 13 mission mission NN 40436 1235 14 similar similar JJ 40436 1235 15 to to IN 40436 1235 16 that that DT 40436 1235 17 which which WDT 40436 1235 18 the the DT 40436 1235 19 real real JJ 40436 1235 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1235 21 announces announce VBZ 40436 1235 22 in in IN 40436 1235 23 the the DT 40436 1235 24 Apology[61 apology[61 CD 40436 1235 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1235 26 A a DT 40436 1235 27 number number NN 40436 1235 28 of of IN 40436 1235 29 perplexing perplex VBG 40436 1235 30 questions question NNS 40436 1235 31 and and CC 40436 1235 32 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 1235 33 are be VBP 40436 1235 34 accumulated accumulate VBN 40436 1235 35 : : : 40436 1235 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1235 37 is be VBZ 40436 1235 38 not not RB 40436 1235 39 meant mean VBN 40436 1235 40 that that IN 40436 1235 41 these these DT 40436 1235 42 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 1235 43 are be VBP 40436 1235 44 insoluble insoluble JJ 40436 1235 45 , , , 40436 1235 46 but but CC 40436 1235 47 that that IN 40436 1235 48 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1235 49 can can MD 40436 1235 50 not not RB 40436 1235 51 be be VB 40436 1235 52 solved solve VBN 40436 1235 53 by by IN 40436 1235 54 one one CD 40436 1235 55 who who WP 40436 1235 56 has have VBZ 40436 1235 57 never never RB 40436 1235 58 seriously seriously RB 40436 1235 59 reflected reflect VBN 40436 1235 60 on on IN 40436 1235 61 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1235 62 -- -- : 40436 1235 63 by by IN 40436 1235 64 one one CD 40436 1235 65 who who WP 40436 1235 66 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1235 67 as as IN 40436 1235 68 the the DT 40436 1235 69 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1235 70 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1235 71 says say VBZ 40436 1235 72 to to IN 40436 1235 73 Euthydemus),[62 euthydemus),[62 VB 40436 1235 74 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1235 75 is be VBZ 40436 1235 76 so so RB 40436 1235 77 confident confident JJ 40436 1235 78 of of IN 40436 1235 79 knowing know VBG 40436 1235 80 the the DT 40436 1235 81 subject subject NN 40436 1235 82 that that IN 40436 1235 83 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1235 84 has have VBZ 40436 1235 85 never never RB 40436 1235 86 meditated meditate VBN 40436 1235 87 upon upon IN 40436 1235 88 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1235 89 at at RB 40436 1235 90 all all RB 40436 1235 91 . . . 40436 1236 1 The the DT 40436 1236 2 disheartened disheartened JJ 40436 1236 3 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1236 4 feels feel VBZ 40436 1236 5 the the DT 40436 1236 6 necessity necessity NN 40436 1236 7 of of IN 40436 1236 8 improving improve VBG 40436 1236 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1236 10 and and CC 40436 1236 11 supplicates supplicate VBZ 40436 1236 12 the the DT 40436 1236 13 assistance assistance NN 40436 1236 14 of of IN 40436 1236 15 Sokrates:[63 Sokrates:[63 NNP 40436 1236 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1236 17 who who WP 40436 1236 18 reminds remind VBZ 40436 1236 19 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1236 20 that that IN 40436 1236 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1236 22 must must MD 40436 1236 23 first first RB 40436 1236 24 determine determine VB 40436 1236 25 what what WP 40436 1236 26 " " `` 40436 1236 27 Himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1236 28 " " '' 40436 1236 29 is be VBZ 40436 1236 30 . . . 40436 1237 1 Here here RB 40436 1237 2 again again RB 40436 1237 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1237 4 find find VBP 40436 1237 5 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 1237 6 upon upon IN 40436 1237 7 the the DT 40436 1237 8 track track NN 40436 1237 9 of of IN 40436 1237 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1237 11 in in IN 40436 1237 12 the the DT 40436 1237 13 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1237 14 Apology Apology NNP 40436 1237 15 , , , 40436 1237 16 and and CC 40436 1237 17 under under IN 40436 1237 18 the the DT 40436 1237 19 influence influence NN 40436 1237 20 of of IN 40436 1237 21 the the DT 40436 1237 22 memorable memorable JJ 40436 1237 23 inscription inscription NN 40436 1237 24 at at IN 40436 1237 25 Delphi--_Nosce Delphi--_Nosce NNP 40436 1237 26 teipsum teipsum NNP 40436 1237 27 _ _ NNP 40436 1237 28 . . . 40436 1238 1 Your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1238 2 mind mind NN 40436 1238 3 is be VBZ 40436 1238 4 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 1238 5 ; ; : 40436 1238 6 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1238 7 body body NN 40436 1238 8 is be VBZ 40436 1238 9 a a DT 40436 1238 10 mere mere JJ 40436 1238 11 instrument instrument NN 40436 1238 12 of of IN 40436 1238 13 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1238 14 mind mind NN 40436 1238 15 : : : 40436 1238 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1238 17 wealth wealth NN 40436 1238 18 and and CC 40436 1238 19 power power NN 40436 1238 20 are be VBP 40436 1238 21 simple simple JJ 40436 1238 22 appurtenances appurtenance NNS 40436 1238 23 or or CC 40436 1238 24 adjuncts adjunct NNS 40436 1238 25 . . . 40436 1239 1 To to TO 40436 1239 2 know know VB 40436 1239 3 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 1239 4 , , , 40436 1239 5 which which WDT 40436 1239 6 is be VBZ 40436 1239 7 genuine genuine JJ 40436 1239 8 Sophrosynê Sophrosynê NNP 40436 1239 9 or or CC 40436 1239 10 temperance temperance NN 40436 1239 11 , , , 40436 1239 12 is be VBZ 40436 1239 13 to to TO 40436 1239 14 know know VB 40436 1239 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1239 16 mind mind NN 40436 1239 17 : : : 40436 1239 18 but but CC 40436 1239 19 this this DT 40436 1239 20 can can MD 40436 1239 21 only only RB 40436 1239 22 be be VB 40436 1239 23 done do VBN 40436 1239 24 by by IN 40436 1239 25 looking look VBG 40436 1239 26 into into IN 40436 1239 27 another another DT 40436 1239 28 mind mind NN 40436 1239 29 , , , 40436 1239 30 and and CC 40436 1239 31 into into IN 40436 1239 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1239 33 most most RBS 40436 1239 34 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 1239 35 compartment compartment NN 40436 1239 36 : : : 40436 1239 37 just just RB 40436 1239 38 as as IN 40436 1239 39 the the DT 40436 1239 40 eye eye NN 40436 1239 41 can can MD 40436 1239 42 only only RB 40436 1239 43 see see VB 40436 1239 44 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 1239 45 by by IN 40436 1239 46 looking look VBG 40436 1239 47 into into IN 40436 1239 48 the the DT 40436 1239 49 centre centre NN 40436 1239 50 of of IN 40436 1239 51 vision vision NN 40436 1239 52 of of IN 40436 1239 53 another another DT 40436 1239 54 eye eye NN 40436 1239 55 . . . 40436 1240 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1240 2 64 64 CD 40436 1240 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1240 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1240 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1240 6 61 61 CD 40436 1240 7 : : : 40436 1240 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1240 9 , , , 40436 1240 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1240 11 . . . 40436 1241 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1241 2 p. p. NN 40436 1241 3 124 124 CD 40436 1241 4 C-127 C-127 NNP 40436 1241 5 E. E. NNP 40436 1241 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1241 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1241 8 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1241 9 62 62 CD 40436 1241 10 : : : 40436 1241 11 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1241 12 . . . 40436 1242 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1242 2 . . . 40436 1243 1 iv iv XX 40436 1243 2 . . . 40436 1244 1 2 2 CD 40436 1244 2 , , , 40436 1244 3 36 36 CD 40436 1244 4 . . . 40436 1245 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1245 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1245 3 : : : 40436 1245 4 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 1245 5 tau tau NNP 40436 1245 6 = = SYM 40436 1245 7 ta ta NNP 40436 1245 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1245 9 / / SYM 40436 1245 10 n n CC 40436 1245 11 , , , 40436 1245 12 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 1245 13 o o UH 40436 1245 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1245 15 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 1245 16 / / SYM 40436 1245 17 tês tês NN 40436 1245 18 , , , 40436 1245 19 i)/sôs i)/sôs NNP 40436 1245 20 , , , 40436 1245 21 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 1245 22 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1245 23 spho spho NNP 40436 1245 24 / / SYM 40436 1245 25 dra dra NNP 40436 1245 26 posteu posteu NN 40436 1245 27 / / SYM 40436 1245 28 ein ein NNP 40436 1245 29 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 1245 30 / / SYM 40436 1245 31 nai nai NNP 40436 1245 32 , , , 40436 1245 33 ou)d ou)d NNP 40436 1245 34 ' ' POS 40436 1245 35 e)/skepsai e)/skepsai NNP 40436 1245 36 . . . 40436 1245 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1245 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1246 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1246 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1246 3 63 63 CD 40436 1246 4 : : : 40436 1246 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1246 6 , , , 40436 1246 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1246 8 . . . 40436 1247 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1247 2 p. p. NN 40436 1247 3 128 128 CD 40436 1247 4 - - SYM 40436 1247 5 132 132 CD 40436 1247 6 A. a. NN 40436 1247 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1248 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1248 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1248 3 64 64 CD 40436 1248 4 : : : 40436 1248 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1248 6 , , , 40436 1248 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1248 8 . . . 40436 1249 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1249 2 p. p. NNP 40436 1249 3 133 133 CD 40436 1249 4 . . . 40436 1250 1 A a DT 40436 1250 2 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1250 3 metaphor metaphor NN 40436 1250 4 , , , 40436 1250 5 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 1250 6 the the DT 40436 1250 7 necessity necessity NN 40436 1250 8 for for IN 40436 1250 9 two two CD 40436 1250 10 separate separate JJ 40436 1250 11 minds mind NNS 40436 1250 12 co co VBD 40436 1250 13 - - NN 40436 1250 14 operating operate VBG 40436 1250 15 in in IN 40436 1250 16 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 1250 17 colloquy colloquy NN 40436 1250 18 . . . 40436 1250 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1251 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1251 2 Side side NN 40436 1251 3 - - HYPH 40436 1251 4 note note NN 40436 1251 5 : : : 40436 1251 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1251 7 furnishes furnish VBZ 40436 1251 8 no no DT 40436 1251 9 means means NN 40436 1251 10 of of IN 40436 1251 11 solving solve VBG 40436 1251 12 these these DT 40436 1251 13 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 1251 14 . . . 40436 1252 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1252 2 exhorts exhort VBZ 40436 1252 3 to to IN 40436 1252 4 Justice Justice NNP 40436 1252 5 and and CC 40436 1252 6 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 1252 7 -- -- : 40436 1252 8 but but CC 40436 1252 9 these these DT 40436 1252 10 are be VBP 40436 1252 11 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 1252 12 Incognita Incognita NNP 40436 1252 13 . . . 40436 1252 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1253 1 At at IN 40436 1253 2 the the DT 40436 1253 3 same same JJ 40436 1253 4 time time NN 40436 1253 5 , , , 40436 1253 6 when when WRB 40436 1253 7 , , , 40436 1253 8 after after IN 40436 1253 9 having have VBG 40436 1253 10 convicted convict VBN 40436 1253 11 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1253 12 of of IN 40436 1253 13 deplorable deplorable JJ 40436 1253 14 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 1253 15 , , , 40436 1253 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1253 17 is be VBZ 40436 1253 18 called call VBN 40436 1253 19 upon upon IN 40436 1253 20 to to TO 40436 1253 21 prescribe prescribe VB 40436 1253 22 remedies remedy NNS 40436 1253 23 -- -- : 40436 1253 24 all all DT 40436 1253 25 distinctness distinctness NN 40436 1253 26 of of IN 40436 1253 27 indication indication NN 40436 1253 28 disappears disappear VBZ 40436 1253 29 . . . 40436 1254 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1254 2 is be VBZ 40436 1254 3 exacted exact VBN 40436 1254 4 only only RB 40436 1254 5 when when WRB 40436 1254 6 the the DT 40436 1254 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 1254 8 is be VBZ 40436 1254 9 to to TO 40436 1254 10 bring bring VB 40436 1254 11 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 1254 12 and and CC 40436 1254 13 contradictions contradiction NNS 40436 1254 14 to to TO 40436 1254 15 view view VB 40436 1254 16 : : : 40436 1254 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1254 18 is be VBZ 40436 1254 19 dispensed dispense VBN 40436 1254 20 with with IN 40436 1254 21 , , , 40436 1254 22 when when WRB 40436 1254 23 the the DT 40436 1254 24 purpose purpose NN 40436 1254 25 is be VBZ 40436 1254 26 to to TO 40436 1254 27 solve solve VB 40436 1254 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1254 29 . . . 40436 1255 1 The the DT 40436 1255 2 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 1255 3 is be VBZ 40436 1255 4 , , , 40436 1255 5 that that IN 40436 1255 6 assuming assume VBG 40436 1255 7 happiness happiness NN 40436 1255 8 as as IN 40436 1255 9 the the DT 40436 1255 10 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 1255 11 ultimate ultimate JJ 40436 1255 12 end,[65 end,[65 NNP 40436 1255 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1255 14 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1255 15 can can MD 40436 1255 16 not not RB 40436 1255 17 secure secure VB 40436 1255 18 this this DT 40436 1255 19 either either CC 40436 1255 20 for for IN 40436 1255 21 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1255 22 or or CC 40436 1255 23 for for IN 40436 1255 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1255 25 city city NN 40436 1255 26 , , , 40436 1255 27 by by IN 40436 1255 28 striving strive VBG 40436 1255 29 for for IN 40436 1255 30 wealth wealth NN 40436 1255 31 and and CC 40436 1255 32 power power NN 40436 1255 33 , , , 40436 1255 34 private private JJ 40436 1255 35 or or CC 40436 1255 36 public public JJ 40436 1255 37 : : : 40436 1255 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1255 39 can can MD 40436 1255 40 only only RB 40436 1255 41 secure secure VB 40436 1255 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1255 43 by by IN 40436 1255 44 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 1255 45 for for IN 40436 1255 46 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1255 47 , , , 40436 1255 48 and and CC 40436 1255 49 implanting implant VBG 40436 1255 50 in in IN 40436 1255 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1255 52 country country NN 40436 1255 53 - - HYPH 40436 1255 54 men man NNS 40436 1255 55 , , , 40436 1255 56 justice justice NN 40436 1255 57 , , , 40436 1255 58 temperance temperance NN 40436 1255 59 , , , 40436 1255 60 and and CC 40436 1255 61 virtue virtue NNP 40436 1255 62 . . . 40436 1256 1 This this DT 40436 1256 2 is be VBZ 40436 1256 3 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 1256 4 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1256 5 , , , 40436 1256 6 and and CC 40436 1256 7 conformable conformable JJ 40436 1256 8 to to IN 40436 1256 9 what what WP 40436 1256 10 is be VBZ 40436 1256 11 said say VBN 40436 1256 12 by by IN 40436 1256 13 the the DT 40436 1256 14 real real JJ 40436 1256 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1256 16 in in IN 40436 1256 17 the the DT 40436 1256 18 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1256 19 Apology Apology NNP 40436 1256 20 . . . 40436 1257 1 But but CC 40436 1257 2 coming come VBG 40436 1257 3 at at IN 40436 1257 4 the the DT 40436 1257 5 close close NN 40436 1257 6 of of IN 40436 1257 7 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1257 8 I. I. NNP 40436 1257 9 , , , 40436 1257 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1257 11 presents present VBZ 40436 1257 12 no no DT 40436 1257 13 meaning meaning NN 40436 1257 14 and and CC 40436 1257 15 imparts impart VBZ 40436 1257 16 no no DT 40436 1257 17 instruction instruction NN 40436 1257 18 : : : 40436 1257 19 because because IN 40436 1257 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1257 21 had have VBD 40436 1257 22 shown show VBN 40436 1257 23 in in IN 40436 1257 24 the the DT 40436 1257 25 earlier early JJR 40436 1257 26 part part NN 40436 1257 27 of of IN 40436 1257 28 the the DT 40436 1257 29 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1257 30 , , , 40436 1257 31 that that IN 40436 1257 32 neither neither CC 40436 1257 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1257 34 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1257 35 , , , 40436 1257 36 nor nor CC 40436 1257 37 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 1257 38 , , , 40436 1257 39 nor nor CC 40436 1257 40 the the DT 40436 1257 41 general general JJ 40436 1257 42 public public NN 40436 1257 43 , , , 40436 1257 44 knew know VBD 40436 1257 45 what what WP 40436 1257 46 justice justice NN 40436 1257 47 and and CC 40436 1257 48 virtue virtue NNP 40436 1257 49 were be VBD 40436 1257 50 . . . 40436 1258 1 The the DT 40436 1258 2 positive positive JJ 40436 1258 3 solution solution NN 40436 1258 4 which which WDT 40436 1258 5 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 1258 6 professes profess VBZ 40436 1258 7 to to TO 40436 1258 8 give give VB 40436 1258 9 , , , 40436 1258 10 is be VBZ 40436 1258 11 therefore therefore RB 40436 1258 12 illusory illusory JJ 40436 1258 13 . . . 40436 1259 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1259 2 throws throw VBZ 40436 1259 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1259 4 back back RB 40436 1259 5 upon upon IN 40436 1259 6 those those DT 40436 1259 7 old old JJ 40436 1259 8 , , , 40436 1259 9 familiar familiar JJ 40436 1259 10 , , , 40436 1259 11 emotional emotional JJ 40436 1259 12 , , , 40436 1259 13 associations association NNS 40436 1259 14 , , , 40436 1259 15 unconscious unconscious JJ 40436 1259 16 products product NNS 40436 1259 17 and and CC 40436 1259 18 unexamined unexamined JJ 40436 1259 19 transmissions transmission NNS 40436 1259 20 from from IN 40436 1259 21 mind mind NN 40436 1259 22 to to IN 40436 1259 23 mind mind NN 40436 1259 24 -- -- : 40436 1259 25 which which WDT 40436 1259 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1259 27 had have VBD 40436 1259 28 already already RB 40436 1259 29 shown show VBN 40436 1259 30 to to TO 40436 1259 31 represent represent VB 40436 1259 32 the the DT 40436 1259 33 fancy fancy NN 40436 1259 34 of of IN 40436 1259 35 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1259 36 without without IN 40436 1259 37 the the DT 40436 1259 38 reality reality NN 40436 1259 39 -- -- : 40436 1259 40 deep deep RB 40436 1259 41 - - HYPH 40436 1259 42 seated seat VBN 40436 1259 43 belief belief NN 40436 1259 44 without without IN 40436 1259 45 any any DT 40436 1259 46 assignable assignable JJ 40436 1259 47 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 1259 48 basis basis NN 40436 1259 49 , , , 40436 1259 50 or or CC 40436 1259 51 outward outward JJ 40436 1259 52 standard standard NN 40436 1259 53 of of IN 40436 1259 54 rectitude rectitude NN 40436 1259 55 . . . 40436 1260 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1260 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1260 3 65 65 CD 40436 1260 4 : : : 40436 1260 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1260 6 . . . 40436 1261 1 Alkibiad Alkibiad NNP 40436 1261 2 . . . 40436 1262 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1262 2 p. p. NNP 40436 1263 1 134 134 CD 40436 1263 2 . . . 40436 1263 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1264 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1264 2 Side side NN 40436 1264 3 - - HYPH 40436 1264 4 note note NN 40436 1264 5 : : : 40436 1264 6 Prolixity prolixity NN 40436 1264 7 of of IN 40436 1264 8 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1264 9 I.--Extreme i.--extreme NN 40436 1264 10 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 1264 11 of of IN 40436 1264 12 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 1264 13 examples example NNS 40436 1264 14 -- -- : 40436 1264 15 How how WRB 40436 1264 16 explained explain VBN 40436 1264 17 . . . 40436 1264 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1265 1 Throughout throughout IN 40436 1265 2 the the DT 40436 1265 3 various various JJ 40436 1265 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1265 5 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1265 6 , , , 40436 1265 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1265 8 find find VBP 40436 1265 9 alternately alternately RB 40436 1265 10 two two CD 40436 1265 11 distinct distinct JJ 40436 1265 12 and and CC 40436 1265 13 opposite opposite JJ 40436 1265 14 methods method NNS 40436 1265 15 of of IN 40436 1265 16 handling handling NN 40436 1265 17 -- -- : 40436 1265 18 the the DT 40436 1265 19 generalising generalising NN 40436 1265 20 of of IN 40436 1265 21 the the DT 40436 1265 22 special special JJ 40436 1265 23 , , , 40436 1265 24 and and CC 40436 1265 25 the the DT 40436 1265 26 specialising specialising NN 40436 1265 27 of of IN 40436 1265 28 the the DT 40436 1265 29 general general NN 40436 1265 30 . . . 40436 1266 1 In in IN 40436 1266 2 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1266 3 I I NNP 40436 1266 4 , , , 40436 1266 5 the the DT 40436 1266 6 specialising specialising NN 40436 1266 7 of of IN 40436 1266 8 the the DT 40436 1266 9 general general JJ 40436 1266 10 preponderates preponderate NNS 40436 1266 11 -- -- : 40436 1266 12 as as IN 40436 1266 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1266 14 does do VBZ 40436 1266 15 in in IN 40436 1266 16 most most JJS 40436 1266 17 of of IN 40436 1266 18 the the DT 40436 1266 19 conversations conversation NNS 40436 1266 20 of of IN 40436 1266 21 the the DT 40436 1266 22 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1266 23 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1266 24 : : : 40436 1266 25 the the DT 40436 1266 26 number number NN 40436 1266 27 of of IN 40436 1266 28 exemplifying exemplify VBG 40436 1266 29 particulars particular NNS 40436 1266 30 is be VBZ 40436 1266 31 unusually unusually RB 40436 1266 32 great great JJ 40436 1266 33 . . . 40436 1267 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1267 2 does do VBZ 40436 1267 3 not not RB 40436 1267 4 accept accept VB 40436 1267 5 as as IN 40436 1267 6 an an DT 40436 1267 7 answer answer NN 40436 1267 8 a a DT 40436 1267 9 general general JJ 40436 1267 10 term term NN 40436 1267 11 , , , 40436 1267 12 without without IN 40436 1267 13 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 1267 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1267 15 by by IN 40436 1267 16 several several JJ 40436 1267 17 of of IN 40436 1267 18 the the DT 40436 1267 19 specific specific JJ 40436 1267 20 terms term NNS 40436 1267 21 comprehended comprehend VBD 40436 1267 22 under under IN 40436 1267 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1267 24 : : : 40436 1267 25 and and CC 40436 1267 26 this this DT 40436 1267 27 several several JJ 40436 1267 28 times time NNS 40436 1267 29 on on IN 40436 1267 30 occasions occasion NNS 40436 1267 31 when when WRB 40436 1267 32 an an DT 40436 1267 33 instructed instruct VBN 40436 1267 34 reader reader NN 40436 1267 35 thinks think VBZ 40436 1267 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1267 37 superfluous superfluous JJ 40436 1267 38 and and CC 40436 1267 39 tiresome tiresome JJ 40436 1267 40 : : : 40436 1267 41 hence hence RB 40436 1267 42 , , , 40436 1267 43 partly partly RB 40436 1267 44 , , , 40436 1267 45 the the DT 40436 1267 46 inclination inclination NN 40436 1267 47 of of IN 40436 1267 48 some some DT 40436 1267 49 modern modern JJ 40436 1267 50 critics critic NNS 40436 1267 51 to to TO 40436 1267 52 disallow disallow VB 40436 1267 53 the the DT 40436 1267 54 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1267 55 . . . 40436 1268 1 But but CC 40436 1268 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1268 3 must must MD 40436 1268 4 recollect recollect VB 40436 1268 5 that that IN 40436 1268 6 though though IN 40436 1268 7 a a DT 40436 1268 8 modern modern JJ 40436 1268 9 reader reader NN 40436 1268 10 practised practise VBN 40436 1268 11 in in IN 40436 1268 12 the the DT 40436 1268 13 use use NN 40436 1268 14 of of IN 40436 1268 15 general general JJ 40436 1268 16 terms term NNS 40436 1268 17 may may MD 40436 1268 18 seize seize VB 40436 1268 19 the the DT 40436 1268 20 meaning meaning NN 40436 1268 21 at at IN 40436 1268 22 once once RB 40436 1268 23 , , , 40436 1268 24 an an DT 40436 1268 25 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 1268 26 youth youth NN 40436 1268 27 of of IN 40436 1268 28 the the DT 40436 1268 29 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1268 30 age age NN 40436 1268 31 would would MD 40436 1268 32 not not RB 40436 1268 33 be be VB 40436 1268 34 sure sure JJ 40436 1268 35 of of IN 40436 1268 36 doing do VBG 40436 1268 37 the the DT 40436 1268 38 same same JJ 40436 1268 39 . . . 40436 1269 1 No no DT 40436 1269 2 conscious conscious JJ 40436 1269 3 analysis analysis NN 40436 1269 4 had have VBD 40436 1269 5 yet yet RB 40436 1269 6 been be VBN 40436 1269 7 applied apply VBN 40436 1269 8 to to IN 40436 1269 9 general general JJ 40436 1269 10 terms term NNS 40436 1269 11 : : : 40436 1269 12 no no DT 40436 1269 13 grammar grammar NN 40436 1269 14 or or CC 40436 1269 15 logic logic NN 40436 1269 16 then then RB 40436 1269 17 entered enter VBD 40436 1269 18 into into IN 40436 1269 19 education education NN 40436 1269 20 . . . 40436 1270 1 Confident confident JJ 40436 1270 2 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 1270 3 , , , 40436 1270 4 without without IN 40436 1270 5 fully fully RB 40436 1270 6 knowing know VBG 40436 1270 7 the the DT 40436 1270 8 meaning meaning NN 40436 1270 9 of of IN 40436 1270 10 what what WP 40436 1270 11 is be VBZ 40436 1270 12 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 1270 13 , , , 40436 1270 14 is be VBZ 40436 1270 15 the the DT 40436 1270 16 besetting besetting NN 40436 1270 17 sin sin NN 40436 1270 18 against against IN 40436 1270 19 which which WDT 40436 1270 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1270 21 here here RB 40436 1270 22 makes make VBZ 40436 1270 23 war war NN 40436 1270 24 : : : 40436 1270 25 and and CC 40436 1270 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1270 27 precautions precaution NNS 40436 1270 28 for for IN 40436 1270 29 exposing expose VBG 40436 1270 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1270 31 are be VBP 40436 1270 32 pushed push VBN 40436 1270 33 to to IN 40436 1270 34 extreme extreme JJ 40436 1270 35 minuteness minuteness NN 40436 1270 36 . . . 40436 1271 1 So so RB 40436 1271 2 , , , 40436 1271 3 too too RB 40436 1271 4 , , , 40436 1271 5 in in IN 40436 1271 6 the the DT 40436 1271 7 Sophistês Sophistês NNP 40436 1271 8 and and CC 40436 1271 9 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 1271 10 , , , 40436 1271 11 when when WRB 40436 1271 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1271 13 wishes wish VBZ 40436 1271 14 to to TO 40436 1271 15 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 1271 16 the the DT 40436 1271 17 process process NN 40436 1271 18 of of IN 40436 1271 19 logical logical JJ 40436 1271 20 division division NN 40436 1271 21 and and CC 40436 1271 22 subdivision subdivision NN 40436 1271 23 , , , 40436 1271 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1271 25 applies apply VBZ 40436 1271 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1271 27 to to IN 40436 1271 28 cases case NNS 40436 1271 29 so so RB 40436 1271 30 trifling trifle VBG 40436 1271 31 and and CC 40436 1271 32 so so RB 40436 1271 33 multiplied multiplied JJ 40436 1271 34 , , , 40436 1271 35 that that DT 40436 1271 36 Socher Socher NNP 40436 1271 37 is be VBZ 40436 1271 38 revolted revolt VBN 40436 1271 39 and and CC 40436 1271 40 rejects reject VBZ 40436 1271 41 the the DT 40436 1271 42 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1271 43 altogether altogether RB 40436 1271 44 . . . 40436 1272 1 But but CC 40436 1272 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1272 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1272 4 foresees foresee VBZ 40436 1272 5 and and CC 40436 1272 6 replies reply VBZ 40436 1272 7 to to IN 40436 1272 8 the the DT 40436 1272 9 objection objection NN 40436 1272 10 ; ; : 40436 1272 11 declaring declare VBG 40436 1272 12 expressly expressly RB 40436 1272 13 that that IN 40436 1272 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1272 15 main main JJ 40436 1272 16 purpose purpose NN 40436 1272 17 is be VBZ 40436 1272 18 , , , 40436 1272 19 not not RB 40436 1272 20 to to TO 40436 1272 21 expound expound VB 40436 1272 22 the the DT 40436 1272 23 particular particular JJ 40436 1272 24 subject subject NN 40436 1272 25 chosen choose VBN 40436 1272 26 , , , 40436 1272 27 but but CC 40436 1272 28 to to TO 40436 1272 29 make make VB 40436 1272 30 manifest manifest NN 40436 1272 31 and and CC 40436 1272 32 familiar familiar JJ 40436 1272 33 the the DT 40436 1272 34 steps step NNS 40436 1272 35 and and CC 40436 1272 36 conditions condition NNS 40436 1272 37 of of IN 40436 1272 38 the the DT 40436 1272 39 general general JJ 40436 1272 40 classifying classifying NN 40436 1272 41 process process NN 40436 1272 42 -- -- : 40436 1272 43 and and CC 40436 1272 44 that that DT 40436 1272 45 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 1272 46 can can MD 40436 1272 47 not not RB 40436 1272 48 be be VB 40436 1272 49 avoided avoid VBN 40436 1272 50 . . . 40436 1273 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1273 2 66 66 CD 40436 1273 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1273 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1273 5 must must MD 40436 1273 6 reckon reckon VB 40436 1273 7 upon upon IN 40436 1273 8 a a DT 40436 1273 9 similar similar JJ 40436 1273 10 purpose purpose NN 40436 1273 11 in in IN 40436 1273 12 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1273 13 I. I. NNP 40436 1274 1 The the DT 40436 1274 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1274 3 is be VBZ 40436 1274 4 a a DT 40436 1274 5 specimen speciman NNS 40436 1274 6 of of IN 40436 1274 7 that that DT 40436 1274 8 which which WDT 40436 1274 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 1274 10 calls call VBZ 40436 1274 11 Inductive Inductive NNP 40436 1274 12 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 1274 13 , , , 40436 1274 14 as as IN 40436 1274 15 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 1274 16 from from IN 40436 1274 17 Syllogistic Syllogistic NNP 40436 1274 18 : : : 40436 1274 19 the the DT 40436 1274 20 Inductive Inductive NNP 40436 1274 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1274 22 considers consider VBZ 40436 1274 23 to to TO 40436 1274 24 be be VB 40436 1274 25 plainer plainer NN 40436 1274 26 and and CC 40436 1274 27 easier easy JJR 40436 1274 28 , , , 40436 1274 29 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1274 30 when when WRB 40436 1274 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1274 32 have have VBP 40436 1274 33 an an DT 40436 1274 34 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 1274 35 collocutor collocutor NN 40436 1274 36 -- -- : 40436 1274 37 the the DT 40436 1274 38 Syllogistic Syllogistic NNP 40436 1274 39 is be VBZ 40436 1274 40 the the DT 40436 1274 41 more more RBR 40436 1274 42 cogent cogent JJ 40436 1274 43 , , , 40436 1274 44 when when WRB 40436 1274 45 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1274 46 are be VBP 40436 1274 47 dealing deal VBG 40436 1274 48 with with IN 40436 1274 49 a a DT 40436 1274 50 practised practise VBN 40436 1274 51 disputant disputant NN 40436 1274 52 . . . 40436 1275 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1275 2 67 67 CD 40436 1275 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1275 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1275 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1275 6 66 66 CD 40436 1275 7 : : : 40436 1275 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1275 9 , , , 40436 1275 10 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 1275 11 , , , 40436 1275 12 285 285 CD 40436 1275 13 - - SYM 40436 1275 14 286 286 CD 40436 1275 15 . . . 40436 1275 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1276 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1276 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1276 3 67 67 CD 40436 1276 4 : : : 40436 1276 5 Aristotel Aristotel NNP 40436 1276 6 . . . 40436 1277 1 Topic topic NN 40436 1277 2 . . . 40436 1278 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1279 1 104 104 CD 40436 1279 2 , , , 40436 1279 3 a. a. NN 40436 1280 1 16 16 CD 40436 1280 2 . . . 40436 1281 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1281 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1281 3 : : : 40436 1281 4 Po Po NNP 40436 1281 5 / / SYM 40436 1281 6 sa sa NNP 40436 1281 7 tô tô NNP 40436 1281 8 = = SYM 40436 1281 9 n n NNP 40436 1281 10 lo lo NNP 40436 1281 11 / / SYM 40436 1281 12 gôn gôn NNP 40436 1281 13 ei)/dê ei)/dê NNP 40436 1281 14 tô tô NNP 40436 1281 15 = = SYM 40436 1281 16 n n CC 40436 1281 17 dialektikô dialektikô NNP 40436 1281 18 = = SYM 40436 1281 19 n n NNP 40436 1281 20 -- -- : 40436 1281 21 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 1281 22 de\ de\ NN 40436 1281 23 to\ to\ NN 40436 1281 24 me\n me\n NNP 40436 1281 25 e)pagôgê/ e)pagôgê/ NNP 40436 1281 26 , , , 40436 1281 27 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1281 28 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1281 29 sullogismo sullogismo NNP 40436 1281 30 / / SYM 40436 1281 31 s s NN 40436 1281 32 . . . 40436 1282 1 . . . 40436 1283 1 . . . 40436 1284 1 . . . 40436 1285 1 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 1285 2 d d NN 40436 1285 3 ' ' `` 40436 1285 4 ê ê NN 40436 1285 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1285 6 me\n me\n NNP 40436 1285 7 e)pagôgê\ e)pagôgê\ NNP 40436 1285 8 pithanô pithanô NN 40436 1285 9 / / SYM 40436 1285 10 teron teron NNP 40436 1285 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1285 12 saphe saphe NNP 40436 1285 13 / / SYM 40436 1285 14 steron steron NNP 40436 1285 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1285 16 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 1285 17 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 1285 18 ai)/sthêsin ai)/sthêsin NNP 40436 1285 19 gnôrimô gnôrimô NNP 40436 1285 20 / / SYM 40436 1285 21 teron teron NNP 40436 1285 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1285 23 toi toi NNP 40436 1285 24 = = SYM 40436 1285 25 s s NNP 40436 1285 26 polloi polloi NNP 40436 1285 27 = = SYM 40436 1285 28 s s NNP 40436 1285 29 koino koino NNP 40436 1285 30 / / SYM 40436 1285 31 n n JJ 40436 1285 32 ; ; : 40436 1285 33 o o NN 40436 1285 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1285 35 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1285 36 sullogismo\s sullogismo\s CC 40436 1285 37 biastikô biastikô NNP 40436 1285 38 / / SYM 40436 1285 39 teron teron NNP 40436 1285 40 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1285 41 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 1285 42 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 1285 43 a)ntilogikou\s a)ntilogikou\s NNP 40436 1285 44 e)nerge e)nerge NNS 40436 1285 45 / / SYM 40436 1285 46 steron steron NN 40436 1285 47 . . . 40436 1285 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1285 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1286 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1286 2 Side side NN 40436 1286 3 - - HYPH 40436 1286 4 note note NN 40436 1286 5 : : : 40436 1286 6 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1286 7 II ii CD 40436 1286 8 . . . 40436 1287 1 leaves leave VBZ 40436 1287 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1287 3 problem problem NN 40436 1287 4 avowedly avowedly RB 40436 1287 5 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 1287 6 . . . 40436 1287 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1288 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1288 2 has have VBZ 40436 1288 3 been be VBN 40436 1288 4 seen see VBN 40436 1288 5 that that IN 40436 1288 6 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1288 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1288 8 , , , 40436 1288 9 though though IN 40436 1288 10 professing profess VBG 40436 1288 11 to to TO 40436 1288 12 give give VB 40436 1288 13 something something NN 40436 1288 14 like like IN 40436 1288 15 a a DT 40436 1288 16 solution solution NN 40436 1288 17 , , , 40436 1288 18 gives give VBZ 40436 1288 19 what what WP 40436 1288 20 is be VBZ 40436 1288 21 really really RB 40436 1288 22 no no DT 40436 1288 23 solution solution NN 40436 1288 24 at at RB 40436 1288 25 all all RB 40436 1288 26 . . . 40436 1289 1 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1289 2 II II NNP 40436 1289 3 . . NNP 40436 1289 4 , , , 40436 1289 5 similar similar JJ 40436 1289 6 in in IN 40436 1289 7 many many JJ 40436 1289 8 respects respect NNS 40436 1289 9 , , , 40436 1289 10 is be VBZ 40436 1289 11 here here RB 40436 1289 12 different different JJ 40436 1289 13 , , , 40436 1289 14 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 40436 1289 15 as as IN 40436 1289 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1289 17 does do VBZ 40436 1289 18 not not RB 40436 1289 19 even even RB 40436 1289 20 profess profess JJ 40436 1289 21 to to TO 40436 1289 22 solve solve VB 40436 1289 23 the the DT 40436 1289 24 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 1289 25 which which WDT 40436 1289 26 had have VBD 40436 1289 27 been be VBN 40436 1289 28 raised raise VBN 40436 1289 29 . . . 40436 1290 1 The the DT 40436 1290 2 general general JJ 40436 1290 3 mental mental JJ 40436 1290 4 defect defect NN 40436 1290 5 -- -- : 40436 1290 6 false false JJ 40436 1290 7 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 1290 8 of of IN 40436 1290 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1290 10 without without IN 40436 1290 11 the the DT 40436 1290 12 reality reality NN 40436 1290 13 -- -- : 40436 1290 14 is be VBZ 40436 1290 15 presented present VBN 40436 1290 16 in in IN 40436 1290 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1290 18 application application NN 40436 1290 19 to to IN 40436 1290 20 a a DT 40436 1290 21 particular particular JJ 40436 1290 22 case case NN 40436 1290 23 . . . 40436 1291 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1291 2 is be VBZ 40436 1291 3 obliged oblige VBN 40436 1291 4 to to TO 40436 1291 5 admit admit VB 40436 1291 6 that that IN 40436 1291 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1291 8 does do VBZ 40436 1291 9 not not RB 40436 1291 10 know know VB 40436 1291 11 what what WP 40436 1291 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1291 13 ought ought MD 40436 1291 14 to to TO 40436 1291 15 pray pray VB 40436 1291 16 to to IN 40436 1291 17 the the DT 40436 1291 18 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1291 19 for for IN 40436 1291 20 : : : 40436 1291 21 neither neither CC 40436 1291 22 what what WP 40436 1291 23 is be VBZ 40436 1291 24 _ _ NNP 40436 1291 25 good good JJ 40436 1291 26 _ _ NNP 40436 1291 27 , , , 40436 1291 28 to to TO 40436 1291 29 be be VB 40436 1291 30 granted grant VBN 40436 1291 31 , , , 40436 1291 32 nor nor CC 40436 1291 33 what what WP 40436 1291 34 is be VBZ 40436 1291 35 _ _ NNP 40436 1291 36 evil evil JJ 40436 1291 37 _ _ NNP 40436 1291 38 , , , 40436 1291 39 to to TO 40436 1291 40 be be VB 40436 1291 41 averted avert VBN 40436 1291 42 . . . 40436 1292 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1292 2 relies rely VBZ 40436 1292 3 upon upon IN 40436 1292 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1292 5 for for IN 40436 1292 6 dispelling dispel VBG 40436 1292 7 this this DT 40436 1292 8 mist mist NN 40436 1292 9 from from IN 40436 1292 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1292 11 mind mind NN 40436 1292 12 : : : 40436 1292 13 which which WDT 40436 1292 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1292 15 promises promise NNS 40436 1292 16 to to TO 40436 1292 17 do do VB 40436 1292 18 , , , 40436 1292 19 but but CC 40436 1292 20 adjourns adjourn NNS 40436 1292 21 for for IN 40436 1292 22 another another DT 40436 1292 23 occasion occasion NN 40436 1292 24 . . . 40436 1293 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1293 2 Side side NN 40436 1293 3 - - HYPH 40436 1293 4 note note NN 40436 1293 5 : : : 40436 1293 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1293 7 commends commend VBZ 40436 1293 8 the the DT 40436 1293 9 practice practice NN 40436 1293 10 of of IN 40436 1293 11 praying pray VBG 40436 1293 12 to to IN 40436 1293 13 the the DT 40436 1293 14 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1293 15 for for IN 40436 1293 16 favours favour NNS 40436 1293 17 undefined undefined JJ 40436 1293 18 -- -- : 40436 1293 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1293 20 views view NNS 40436 1293 21 about about IN 40436 1293 22 the the DT 40436 1293 23 semi semi JJ 40436 1293 24 - - JJ 40436 1293 25 regular regular JJ 40436 1293 26 , , , 40436 1293 27 semi semi JJ 40436 1293 28 - - JJ 40436 1293 29 irregular irregular JJ 40436 1293 30 agency agency NN 40436 1293 31 of of IN 40436 1293 32 the the DT 40436 1293 33 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1293 34 -- -- : 40436 1293 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1293 36 prays pray VBZ 40436 1293 37 to to IN 40436 1293 38 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1293 39 for for IN 40436 1293 40 premonitory premonitory JJ 40436 1293 41 warnings warning NNS 40436 1293 42 . . . 40436 1293 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1294 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1294 2 here here RB 40436 1294 3 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 1294 4 to to IN 40436 1294 5 the the DT 40436 1294 6 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1294 7 , , , 40436 1294 8 and and CC 40436 1294 9 to to IN 40436 1294 10 various various JJ 40436 1294 11 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 1294 12 , , , 40436 1294 13 the the DT 40436 1294 14 practice practice NN 40436 1294 15 of of IN 40436 1294 16 putting put VBG 40436 1294 17 up up RP 40436 1294 18 prayers prayer NNS 40436 1294 19 in in IN 40436 1294 20 undefined undefined JJ 40436 1294 21 language language NN 40436 1294 22 , , , 40436 1294 23 for for IN 40436 1294 24 good good JJ 40436 1294 25 and and CC 40436 1294 26 honourable honourable JJ 40436 1294 27 things thing NNS 40436 1294 28 generally generally RB 40436 1294 29 . . . 40436 1295 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1295 2 commends commend VBZ 40436 1295 3 that that DT 40436 1295 4 practice practice NN 40436 1295 5 . . . 40436 1296 1 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1296 2 tells tell VBZ 40436 1296 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1296 4 that that IN 40436 1296 5 the the DT 40436 1296 6 historical historical JJ 40436 1296 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1296 8 observed observe VBN 40436 1296 9 it:[68 it:[68 NNP 40436 1296 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1296 11 but but CC 40436 1296 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1296 13 tells tell VBZ 40436 1296 14 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1296 15 also also RB 40436 1296 16 that that IN 40436 1296 17 the the DT 40436 1296 18 historical historical JJ 40436 1296 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1296 20 , , , 40436 1296 21 though though IN 40436 1296 22 not not RB 40436 1296 23 praying pray VBG 40436 1296 24 for for IN 40436 1296 25 any any DT 40436 1296 26 special special JJ 40436 1296 27 presents present NNS 40436 1296 28 from from IN 40436 1296 29 the the DT 40436 1296 30 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1296 31 , , , 40436 1296 32 yet yet CC 40436 1296 33 prayed pray VBN 40436 1296 34 for for IN 40436 1296 35 and and CC 40436 1296 36 believed believe VBD 40436 1296 37 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1296 38 to to TO 40436 1296 39 receive receive VB 40436 1296 40 special special JJ 40436 1296 41 irregular irregular JJ 40436 1296 42 revelations revelation NNS 40436 1296 43 and and CC 40436 1296 44 advice advice NN 40436 1296 45 as as IN 40436 1296 46 to to IN 40436 1296 47 what what WP 40436 1296 48 was be VBD 40436 1296 49 good good JJ 40436 1296 50 to to TO 40436 1296 51 be be VB 40436 1296 52 done do VBN 40436 1296 53 or or CC 40436 1296 54 avoided avoid VBN 40436 1296 55 in in IN 40436 1296 56 particular particular JJ 40436 1296 57 cases case NNS 40436 1296 58 . . . 40436 1297 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1297 2 held hold VBD 40436 1297 3 that that IN 40436 1297 4 these these DT 40436 1297 5 special special JJ 40436 1297 6 revelations revelation NNS 40436 1297 7 were be VBD 40436 1297 8 essential essential JJ 40436 1297 9 to to IN 40436 1297 10 any any DT 40436 1297 11 tolerable tolerable JJ 40436 1297 12 life life NN 40436 1297 13 : : : 40436 1297 14 that that IN 40436 1297 15 the the DT 40436 1297 16 dispensations dispensation NNS 40436 1297 17 of of IN 40436 1297 18 the the DT 40436 1297 19 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1297 20 , , , 40436 1297 21 though though IN 40436 1297 22 administered administer VBN 40436 1297 23 upon upon IN 40436 1297 24 regular regular JJ 40436 1297 25 principles principle NNS 40436 1297 26 on on IN 40436 1297 27 certain certain JJ 40436 1297 28 subjects subject NNS 40436 1297 29 and and CC 40436 1297 30 up up IN 40436 1297 31 to to IN 40436 1297 32 a a DT 40436 1297 33 certain certain JJ 40436 1297 34 point point NN 40436 1297 35 , , , 40436 1297 36 were be VBD 40436 1297 37 kept keep VBN 40436 1297 38 by by IN 40436 1297 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1297 40 designedly designedly RB 40436 1297 41 inscrutable inscrutable JJ 40436 1297 42 beyond beyond IN 40436 1297 43 that that DT 40436 1297 44 point point NN 40436 1297 45 : : : 40436 1297 46 but but CC 40436 1297 47 that that IN 40436 1297 48 the the DT 40436 1297 49 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1297 50 would would MD 40436 1297 51 , , , 40436 1297 52 if if IN 40436 1297 53 properly properly RB 40436 1297 54 solicited solicit VBN 40436 1297 55 , , , 40436 1297 56 afford afford VB 40436 1297 57 premonitory premonitory JJ 40436 1297 58 warnings warning NNS 40436 1297 59 to to IN 40436 1297 60 any any DT 40436 1297 61 favoured favour VBN 40436 1297 62 person person NN 40436 1297 63 , , , 40436 1297 64 such such JJ 40436 1297 65 as as IN 40436 1297 66 would would MD 40436 1297 67 enable enable VB 40436 1297 68 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1297 69 to to TO 40436 1297 70 keep keep VB 40436 1297 71 out out IN 40436 1297 72 of of IN 40436 1297 73 the the DT 40436 1297 74 way way NN 40436 1297 75 of of IN 40436 1297 76 evil evil NN 40436 1297 77 , , , 40436 1297 78 and and CC 40436 1297 79 put put VBD 40436 1297 80 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1297 81 in in IN 40436 1297 82 the the DT 40436 1297 83 way way NN 40436 1297 84 of of IN 40436 1297 85 good good NN 40436 1297 86 . . . 40436 1298 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1298 2 declared declare VBD 40436 1298 3 that that DT 40436 1298 4 to to TO 40436 1298 5 consult consult VB 40436 1298 6 and and CC 40436 1298 7 obey obey VB 40436 1298 8 oracles oracle NNS 40436 1298 9 and and CC 40436 1298 10 prophets prophet NNS 40436 1298 11 was be VBD 40436 1298 12 not not RB 40436 1298 13 less less JJR 40436 1298 14 a a DT 40436 1298 15 maxim maxim NN 40436 1298 16 of of IN 40436 1298 17 prudence prudence NN 40436 1298 18 than than IN 40436 1298 19 a a DT 40436 1298 20 duty duty NN 40436 1298 21 of of IN 40436 1298 22 piety piety NN 40436 1298 23 : : : 40436 1298 24 for for IN 40436 1298 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1298 26 , , , 40436 1298 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1298 28 was be VBD 40436 1298 29 farther farther RB 40436 1298 30 privileged privileged JJ 40436 1298 31 through through IN 40436 1298 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1298 33 divine divine JJ 40436 1298 34 sign sign NN 40436 1298 35 or or CC 40436 1298 36 monitor monitor NN 40436 1298 37 , , , 40436 1298 38 which which WDT 40436 1298 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1298 40 implicitly implicitly RB 40436 1298 41 followed follow VBD 40436 1298 42 . . . 40436 1299 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1299 2 69 69 CD 40436 1299 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1299 4 Such such JJ 40436 1299 5 premonitory premonitory JJ 40436 1299 6 warnings warning NNS 40436 1299 7 were be VBD 40436 1299 8 the the DT 40436 1299 9 only only JJ 40436 1299 10 special special JJ 40436 1299 11 favour favour NN 40436 1299 12 which which WDT 40436 1299 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1299 14 thought think VBD 40436 1299 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1299 16 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1299 17 to to TO 40436 1299 18 pray pray VB 40436 1299 19 for for IN 40436 1299 20 -- -- : 40436 1299 21 besides besides IN 40436 1299 22 good good JJ 40436 1299 23 things thing NNS 40436 1299 24 generally generally RB 40436 1299 25 . . . 40436 1300 1 For for IN 40436 1300 2 special special JJ 40436 1300 3 presents present NNS 40436 1300 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1300 5 did do VBD 40436 1300 6 not not RB 40436 1300 7 pray pray VB 40436 1300 8 , , , 40436 1300 9 because because IN 40436 1300 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1300 11 professed profess VBD 40436 1300 12 not not RB 40436 1300 13 to to TO 40436 1300 14 know know VB 40436 1300 15 whether whether IN 40436 1300 16 any any DT 40436 1300 17 of of IN 40436 1300 18 the the DT 40436 1300 19 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 1300 20 objects object NNS 40436 1300 21 of of IN 40436 1300 22 desire desire NN 40436 1300 23 were be VBD 40436 1300 24 good good JJ 40436 1300 25 or or CC 40436 1300 26 bad bad JJ 40436 1300 27 . . . 40436 1301 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1301 2 proves prove VBZ 40436 1301 3 in in IN 40436 1301 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1301 5 conversation conversation NN 40436 1301 6 with with IN 40436 1301 7 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 1301 8 , , , 40436 1301 9 that that IN 40436 1301 10 all all PDT 40436 1301 11 those those DT 40436 1301 12 acquisitions acquisition NNS 40436 1301 13 which which WDT 40436 1301 14 are be VBP 40436 1301 15 usually usually RB 40436 1301 16 accounted account VBN 40436 1301 17 means mean NNS 40436 1301 18 of of IN 40436 1301 19 happiness happiness NN 40436 1301 20 -- -- : 40436 1301 21 beauty beauty NN 40436 1301 22 , , , 40436 1301 23 strength strength NN 40436 1301 24 , , , 40436 1301 25 wealth wealth NN 40436 1301 26 , , , 40436 1301 27 reputation reputation NN 40436 1301 28 , , , 40436 1301 29 nay nay NN 40436 1301 30 , , , 40436 1301 31 even even RB 40436 1301 32 good good JJ 40436 1301 33 health health NN 40436 1301 34 and and CC 40436 1301 35 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 1301 36 -- -- : 40436 1301 37 are be VBP 40436 1301 38 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1301 39 good good JJ 40436 1301 40 or or CC 40436 1301 41 causes cause NNS 40436 1301 42 of of IN 40436 1301 43 happiness happiness NN 40436 1301 44 , , , 40436 1301 45 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1301 46 evil evil JJ 40436 1301 47 or or CC 40436 1301 48 causes cause NNS 40436 1301 49 of of IN 40436 1301 50 misery misery NN 40436 1301 51 ; ; : 40436 1301 52 and and CC 40436 1301 53 therefore therefore RB 40436 1301 54 can can MD 40436 1301 55 not not RB 40436 1301 56 be be VB 40436 1301 57 considered consider VBN 40436 1301 58 either either CC 40436 1301 59 as as IN 40436 1301 60 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 1301 61 the the DT 40436 1301 62 one one NN 40436 1301 63 or or CC 40436 1301 64 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 1301 65 the the DT 40436 1301 66 other other JJ 40436 1301 67 . . . 40436 1302 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1302 2 70 70 CD 40436 1302 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1302 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1302 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1302 6 68 68 CD 40436 1302 7 : : : 40436 1302 8 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1302 9 . . . 40436 1303 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1303 2 . . . 40436 1304 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1305 1 3 3 CD 40436 1305 2 , , , 40436 1305 3 2 2 CD 40436 1305 4 ; ; : 40436 1305 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1305 6 . . . 40436 1306 1 Alk alk NN 40436 1306 2 . . . 40436 1307 1 ii ii LS 40436 1307 2 . . . 40436 1308 1 p. p. NN 40436 1309 1 143 143 CD 40436 1309 2 - - SYM 40436 1309 3 148 148 CD 40436 1309 4 . . . 40436 1309 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1310 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1310 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1310 3 69 69 CD 40436 1310 4 : : : 40436 1310 5 These these DT 40436 1310 6 opinions opinion NNS 40436 1310 7 of of IN 40436 1310 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1310 9 are be VBP 40436 1310 10 announced announce VBN 40436 1310 11 in in IN 40436 1310 12 various various JJ 40436 1310 13 passages passage NNS 40436 1310 14 of of IN 40436 1310 15 the the DT 40436 1310 16 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1310 17 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1310 18 , , , 40436 1310 19 i. i. NNP 40436 1311 1 1 1 CD 40436 1311 2 , , , 40436 1311 3 1 1 CD 40436 1311 4 - - SYM 40436 1311 5 10 10 CD 40436 1311 6 - - HYPH 40436 1311 7 -[Greek -[greek NN 40436 1311 8 : : : 40436 1311 9 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 1311 10 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1311 11 dei dei NNP 40436 1311 12 = = SYM 40436 1311 13 n n NNP 40436 1311 14 , , , 40436 1311 15 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 1311 16 me\n me\n NNP 40436 1311 17 matho matho NNP 40436 1311 18 / / SYM 40436 1311 19 ntas ntas NNPS 40436 1311 20 poiei poiei NN 40436 1311 21 = = SYM 40436 1311 22 n n IN 40436 1311 23 e)/dôkan e)/dôkan NNP 40436 1311 24 oi oi NNP 40436 1311 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1311 26 theoi/ theoi/ NN 40436 1311 27 , , , 40436 1311 28 mantha mantha NN 40436 1311 29 / / SYM 40436 1311 30 nein nein RB 40436 1311 31 ; ; : 40436 1311 32 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 1311 33 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1311 34 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 1311 35 dê dê NNP 40436 1311 36 = = NFP 40436 1311 37 la la NNP 40436 1311 38 toi toi NNP 40436 1311 39 = = SYM 40436 1311 40 s s NNP 40436 1311 41 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 1311 42 / / SYM 40436 1311 43 pois pois NNP 40436 1311 44 e)sti/ e)sti/ NNP 40436 1311 45 , , , 40436 1311 46 peira peira NNP 40436 1311 47 = = SYM 40436 1311 48 sthai sthai NNP 40436 1311 49 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 1311 50 mantikê mantikê NNP 40436 1311 51 = = NFP 40436 1311 52 s s NNP 40436 1311 53 para\ para\ NNP 40436 1311 54 tô tô NNP 40436 1311 55 = = SYM 40436 1311 56 n n CC 40436 1311 57 theô theô NN 40436 1311 58 = = SYM 40436 1311 59 n n CC 40436 1311 60 puntha puntha NNP 40436 1311 61 / / SYM 40436 1311 62 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 1311 63 ; ; . 40436 1311 64 tou\s tou\s JJ 40436 1311 65 theou\s theou\s CD 40436 1311 66 ga ga NNP 40436 1311 67 / / SYM 40436 1311 68 r r NNP 40436 1311 69 , , , 40436 1311 70 oi(=s oi(=s JJ 40436 1311 71 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 1311 72 ô)=sin ô)=sin NNP 40436 1311 73 i(/leô| i(/leô| NNP 40436 1311 74 , , , 40436 1311 75 sêmai sêmai NNP 40436 1311 76 / / SYM 40436 1311 77 nein]--i nein]--i NNP 40436 1311 78 . . . 40436 1312 1 3 3 CD 40436 1312 2 , , , 40436 1312 3 4 4 CD 40436 1312 4 ; ; : 40436 1312 5 i. i. NN 40436 1313 1 4 4 CD 40436 1313 2 , , , 40436 1313 3 2 2 CD 40436 1313 4 - - SYM 40436 1313 5 15 15 CD 40436 1313 6 ; ; : 40436 1313 7 iv iv LS 40436 1313 8 . . . 40436 1314 1 3 3 CD 40436 1314 2 , , , 40436 1314 3 12 12 CD 40436 1314 4 ; ; : 40436 1314 5 iv iv LS 40436 1314 6 . . . 40436 1315 1 7 7 CD 40436 1315 2 , , , 40436 1315 3 10 10 CD 40436 1315 4 ; ; : 40436 1315 5 iv iv LS 40436 1315 6 . . . 40436 1316 1 8 8 CD 40436 1316 2 , , , 40436 1316 3 5 5 CD 40436 1316 4 - - SYM 40436 1316 5 11 11 CD 40436 1316 6 . . . 40436 1316 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1317 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1317 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1317 3 70 70 CD 40436 1317 4 : : : 40436 1317 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1317 6 . . . 40436 1318 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 1318 2 . . . 40436 1319 1 iv iv XX 40436 1319 2 . . . 40436 1320 1 2 2 CD 40436 1320 2 , , , 40436 1320 3 31 31 CD 40436 1320 4 - - HYPH 40436 1320 5 32 32 CD 40436 1320 6 - - SYM 40436 1320 7 36 36 CD 40436 1320 8 . . . 40436 1321 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1321 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1321 3 : : : 40436 1321 4 Tau tau NN 40436 1321 5 = = SYM 40436 1321 6 ta ta NN 40436 1321 7 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 1321 8 pote\ pote\ NNP 40436 1321 9 me\n me\n NNP 40436 1321 10 ô)phelou ô)phelou ADD 40436 1321 11 = = SYM 40436 1321 12 nta nta NNP 40436 1321 13 pote\ pote\ NNP 40436 1321 14 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1321 15 bla bla NNP 40436 1321 16 / / SYM 40436 1321 17 ptonta ptonta NNP 40436 1321 18 , , , 40436 1321 19 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 1321 20 ma ma NNP 40436 1321 21 = = SYM 40436 1321 22 llon llon NNP 40436 1321 23 a)gatha\ a)gatha\ NNP 40436 1321 24 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 1321 25 kaka/ kaka/ NNP 40436 1321 26 e)stin e)stin , 40436 1321 27 ? ? . 40436 1321 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1321 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1322 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1322 2 Side side NN 40436 1322 3 - - HYPH 40436 1322 4 note note NN 40436 1322 5 : : : 40436 1322 6 Comparison comparison NN 40436 1322 7 of of IN 40436 1322 8 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1322 9 II II NNP 40436 1322 10 . . . 40436 1323 1 with with IN 40436 1323 2 the the DT 40436 1323 3 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1323 4 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1323 5 , , , 40436 1323 6 especially especially RB 40436 1323 7 the the DT 40436 1323 8 conversation conversation NN 40436 1323 9 of of IN 40436 1323 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1323 11 with with IN 40436 1323 12 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 1323 13 . . . 40436 1324 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1324 2 not not RB 40436 1324 3 always always RB 40436 1324 4 consistent consistent JJ 40436 1324 5 with with IN 40436 1324 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1324 7 . . . 40436 1324 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1325 1 This this DT 40436 1325 2 impossibility impossibility NN 40436 1325 3 of of IN 40436 1325 4 determining determine VBG 40436 1325 5 what what WP 40436 1325 6 is be VBZ 40436 1325 7 good good JJ 40436 1325 8 and and CC 40436 1325 9 what what WP 40436 1325 10 is be VBZ 40436 1325 11 evil evil JJ 40436 1325 12 , , , 40436 1325 13 in in IN 40436 1325 14 consequence consequence NN 40436 1325 15 of of IN 40436 1325 16 the the DT 40436 1325 17 uncertainty uncertainty NN 40436 1325 18 in in IN 40436 1325 19 the the DT 40436 1325 20 dispensations dispensation NNS 40436 1325 21 of of IN 40436 1325 22 the the DT 40436 1325 23 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1325 24 and and CC 40436 1325 25 in in IN 40436 1325 26 human human JJ 40436 1325 27 affairs affair NNS 40436 1325 28 -- -- : 40436 1325 29 is be VBZ 40436 1325 30 a a DT 40436 1325 31 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1325 32 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 1325 33 insisted insist VBD 40436 1325 34 on on IN 40436 1325 35 by by IN 40436 1325 36 the the DT 40436 1325 37 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1325 38 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1325 39 in in IN 40436 1325 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1325 41 discourse discourse NN 40436 1325 42 with with IN 40436 1325 43 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 1325 44 , , , 40436 1325 45 and and CC 40436 1325 46 much much RB 40436 1325 47 akin akin JJ 40436 1325 48 to to IN 40436 1325 49 the the DT 40436 1325 50 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1325 51 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1325 52 II II NNP 40436 1325 53 . . NNP 40436 1325 54 , , , 40436 1325 55 being be VBG 40436 1325 56 applied apply VBN 40436 1325 57 to to IN 40436 1325 58 the the DT 40436 1325 59 special special JJ 40436 1325 60 case case NN 40436 1325 61 of of IN 40436 1325 62 prayer prayer NN 40436 1325 63 . . . 40436 1326 1 But but CC 40436 1326 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1326 3 must must MD 40436 1326 4 not not RB 40436 1326 5 suppose suppose VB 40436 1326 6 that that IN 40436 1326 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1326 8 adheres adhere VBZ 40436 1326 9 to to IN 40436 1326 10 this this DT 40436 1326 11 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1326 12 throughout throughout IN 40436 1326 13 all all PDT 40436 1326 14 the the DT 40436 1326 15 colloquies colloquy NNS 40436 1326 16 of of IN 40436 1326 17 the the DT 40436 1326 18 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1326 19 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1326 20 : : : 40436 1326 21 on on IN 40436 1326 22 the the DT 40436 1326 23 contrary contrary NN 40436 1326 24 , , , 40436 1326 25 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1326 26 find find VBP 40436 1326 27 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1326 28 , , , 40436 1326 29 in in IN 40436 1326 30 other other JJ 40436 1326 31 places place NNS 40436 1326 32 , , , 40436 1326 33 reasoning reason VBG 40436 1326 34 upon upon IN 40436 1326 35 such such JJ 40436 1326 36 matters matter NNS 40436 1326 37 , , , 40436 1326 38 as as IN 40436 1326 39 health health NN 40436 1326 40 , , , 40436 1326 41 strength strength NN 40436 1326 42 , , , 40436 1326 43 and and CC 40436 1326 44 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 1326 45 , , , 40436 1326 46 as as IN 40436 1326 47 if if IN 40436 1326 48 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1326 49 were be VBD 40436 1326 50 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 1326 51 good good JJ 40436 1326 52 . . . 40436 1327 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1327 2 71 71 CD 40436 1327 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1327 4 The the DT 40436 1327 5 fact fact NN 40436 1327 6 is be VBZ 40436 1327 7 , , , 40436 1327 8 that that IN 40436 1327 9 the the DT 40436 1327 10 arguments argument NNS 40436 1327 11 of of IN 40436 1327 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1327 13 , , , 40436 1327 14 in in IN 40436 1327 15 the the DT 40436 1327 16 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1327 17 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1327 18 , , , 40436 1327 19 vary vary VBP 40436 1327 20 materially materially RB 40436 1327 21 according accord VBG 40436 1327 22 to to IN 40436 1327 23 the the DT 40436 1327 24 occasion occasion NN 40436 1327 25 and and CC 40436 1327 26 the the DT 40436 1327 27 person person NN 40436 1327 28 with with IN 40436 1327 29 whom whom WP 40436 1327 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1327 31 is be VBZ 40436 1327 32 discoursing discourse VBG 40436 1327 33 : : : 40436 1327 34 and and CC 40436 1327 35 the the DT 40436 1327 36 case case NN 40436 1327 37 is be VBZ 40436 1327 38 similar similar JJ 40436 1327 39 with with IN 40436 1327 40 the the DT 40436 1327 41 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1327 42 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1327 43 : : : 40436 1327 44 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 1327 45 farther far RBR 40436 1327 46 the the DT 40436 1327 47 questionable questionable JJ 40436 1327 48 evidence evidence NN 40436 1327 49 on on IN 40436 1327 50 which which WDT 40436 1327 51 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1327 52 and and CC 40436 1327 53 other other JJ 40436 1327 54 critics critic NNS 40436 1327 55 proceed proceed VBP 40436 1327 56 , , , 40436 1327 57 when when WRB 40436 1327 58 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1327 59 declare declare VBP 40436 1327 60 one one CD 40436 1327 61 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1327 62 to to TO 40436 1327 63 be be VB 40436 1327 64 spurious spurious JJ 40436 1327 65 , , , 40436 1327 66 because because IN 40436 1327 67 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1327 68 contains contain VBZ 40436 1327 69 reasoning reason VBG 40436 1327 70 inconsistent inconsistent NN 40436 1327 71 with with IN 40436 1327 72 another another DT 40436 1327 73 . . . 40436 1328 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1328 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1328 3 71 71 CD 40436 1328 4 : : : 40436 1328 5 For for IN 40436 1328 6 example example NN 40436 1328 7 , , , 40436 1328 8 Xen Xen NNP 40436 1328 9 . . . 40436 1329 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1329 2 . . . 40436 1330 1 iv iv XX 40436 1330 2 . . . 40436 1331 1 5 5 CD 40436 1331 2 , , , 40436 1331 3 6 6 CD 40436 1331 4 - - HYPH 40436 1331 5 -[Greek -[greek NN 40436 1331 6 : : : 40436 1331 7 sophi sophi NNS 40436 1331 8 / / , 40436 1331 9 an an DT 40436 1331 10 to\ to\ NN 40436 1331 11 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1331 12 / / SYM 40436 1331 13 giston giston NNP 40436 1331 14 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 1331 15 / / SYM 40436 1331 16 n n NNP 40436 1331 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1331 18 , , , 40436 1331 19 & & CC 40436 1331 20 c. c. NNP 40436 1331 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1331 22 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1331 23 find find VBP 40436 1331 24 in in IN 40436 1331 25 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1331 26 II II NNP 40436 1331 27 . . . 40436 1332 1 another another DT 40436 1332 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1332 3 which which WDT 40436 1332 4 is be VBZ 40436 1332 5 also also RB 40436 1332 6 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 1332 7 by by IN 40436 1332 8 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1332 9 in in IN 40436 1332 10 the the DT 40436 1332 11 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1332 12 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1332 13 : : : 40436 1332 14 that that IN 40436 1332 15 the the DT 40436 1332 16 Gods god NNS 40436 1332 17 are be VBP 40436 1332 18 not not RB 40436 1332 19 moved move VBN 40436 1332 20 by by IN 40436 1332 21 costly costly JJ 40436 1332 22 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 1332 23 more more JJR 40436 1332 24 than than IN 40436 1332 25 by by IN 40436 1332 26 humble humble JJ 40436 1332 27 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 1332 28 , , , 40436 1332 29 according accord VBG 40436 1332 30 to to IN 40436 1332 31 the the DT 40436 1332 32 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 1332 33 of of IN 40436 1332 34 the the DT 40436 1332 35 offerer:[72 offerer:[72 NN 40436 1332 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1332 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1332 38 attend attend VBP 40436 1332 39 only only RB 40436 1332 40 to to IN 40436 1332 41 the the DT 40436 1332 42 mind mind NN 40436 1332 43 of of IN 40436 1332 44 the the DT 40436 1332 45 offerer offerer NN 40436 1332 46 , , , 40436 1332 47 whether whether IN 40436 1332 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1332 49 be be VB 40436 1332 50 just just RB 40436 1332 51 and and CC 40436 1332 52 wise wise JJ 40436 1332 53 : : : 40436 1332 54 that that RB 40436 1332 55 is be VBZ 40436 1332 56 , , , 40436 1332 57 " " `` 40436 1332 58 whether whether IN 40436 1332 59 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1332 60 knows know VBZ 40436 1332 61 what what WP 40436 1332 62 ought ought MD 40436 1332 63 to to TO 40436 1332 64 be be VB 40436 1332 65 done do VBN 40436 1332 66 both both DT 40436 1332 67 towards towards IN 40436 1332 68 Gods god NNS 40436 1332 69 and and CC 40436 1332 70 towards towards IN 40436 1332 71 men man NNS 40436 1332 72 " " '' 40436 1332 73 . . . 40436 1333 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1333 2 73 73 CD 40436 1333 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1333 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1333 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1333 6 72 72 CD 40436 1333 7 : : : 40436 1333 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1333 9 , , , 40436 1333 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1333 11 . . . 40436 1334 1 ii ii LS 40436 1334 2 . . . 40436 1335 1 p. p. NN 40436 1335 2 149 149 CD 40436 1335 3 - - SYM 40436 1335 4 150 150 CD 40436 1335 5 ; ; : 40436 1335 6 Xen Xen NNP 40436 1335 7 . . . 40436 1336 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1336 2 . . . 40436 1337 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1338 1 3 3 LS 40436 1338 2 . . . 40436 1339 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 1339 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1339 3 , , , 40436 1339 4 Legg Legg NNP 40436 1339 5 . . . 40436 1340 1 x. x. NNP 40436 1340 2 p. p. NN 40436 1340 3 885 885 CD 40436 1340 4 ; ; : 40436 1340 5 Isokrat Isokrat NNP 40436 1340 6 . . . 40436 1341 1 ad ad NN 40436 1341 2 Nikok Nikok NNP 40436 1341 3 . . . 40436 1341 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1342 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1342 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1342 3 73 73 CD 40436 1342 4 : : : 40436 1342 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1342 6 , , , 40436 1342 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1342 8 . . . 40436 1343 1 ii ii LS 40436 1343 2 . . . 40436 1344 1 p. p. NN 40436 1344 2 149 149 CD 40436 1344 3 E e NN 40436 1344 4 , , , 40436 1344 5 150 150 CD 40436 1344 6 B. B. NNP 40436 1344 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1345 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1345 2 Side side NN 40436 1345 3 - - HYPH 40436 1345 4 note note NN 40436 1345 5 : : : 40436 1345 6 Remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 1345 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1345 8 of of IN 40436 1345 9 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1345 10 II.--that II.--that NNP 40436 1345 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1345 12 is be VBZ 40436 1345 13 not not RB 40436 1345 14 always always RB 40436 1345 15 Good good JJ 40436 1345 16 . . . 40436 1346 1 The the DT 40436 1346 2 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1346 3 of of IN 40436 1346 4 Good good JJ 40436 1346 5 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 1346 6 is be VBZ 40436 1346 7 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 1346 8 : : : 40436 1346 9 without without IN 40436 1346 10 that that DT 40436 1346 11 , , , 40436 1346 12 the the DT 40436 1346 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1346 14 of of IN 40436 1346 15 other other JJ 40436 1346 16 things thing NNS 40436 1346 17 is be VBZ 40436 1346 18 more more RBR 40436 1346 19 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 1346 20 than than IN 40436 1346 21 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 1346 22 . . . 40436 1346 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1347 1 But but CC 40436 1347 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1347 3 find find VBP 40436 1347 4 also also RB 40436 1347 5 in in IN 40436 1347 6 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 1347 7 II II NNP 40436 1347 8 . . . 40436 1348 1 another another DT 40436 1348 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1348 3 , , , 40436 1348 4 more more RBR 40436 1348 5 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 1348 6 . . . 40436 1349 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1349 2 will will MD 40436 1349 3 not not RB 40436 1349 4 proclaim proclaim VB 40436 1349 5 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 1349 6 that that IN 40436 1349 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1349 8 is be VBZ 40436 1349 9 good good JJ 40436 1349 10 , , , 40436 1349 11 and and CC 40436 1349 12 that that DT 40436 1349 13 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 1349 14 is be VBZ 40436 1349 15 evil evil JJ 40436 1349 16 . . . 40436 1350 1 In in IN 40436 1350 2 some some DT 40436 1350 3 cases case NNS 40436 1350 4 , , , 40436 1350 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1350 6 contends contend VBZ 40436 1350 7 , , , 40436 1350 8 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 1350 9 is be VBZ 40436 1350 10 good good JJ 40436 1350 11 ; ; : 40436 1350 12 and and CC 40436 1350 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1350 14 discriminates discriminate VBZ 40436 1350 15 which which WDT 40436 1350 16 the the DT 40436 1350 17 cases case NNS 40436 1350 18 are be VBP 40436 1350 19 . . . 40436 1351 1 That that DT 40436 1351 2 which which WDT 40436 1351 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1351 4 are be VBP 40436 1351 5 principally principally RB 40436 1351 6 interested interested JJ 40436 1351 7 in in IN 40436 1351 8 knowing know VBG 40436 1351 9 , , , 40436 1351 10 is be VBZ 40436 1351 11 _ _ NNP 40436 1351 12 Good Good NNP 40436 1351 13 _ _ NNP 40436 1351 14 , , , 40436 1351 15 or or CC 40436 1351 16 The the DT 40436 1351 17 _ _ NNP 40436 1351 18 Best_--The Best_--The NNP 40436 1351 19 _ _ NNP 40436 1351 20 Profitable_:[74 Profitable_:[74 NNP 40436 1351 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1351 22 phrases phrase NNS 40436 1351 23 used use VBN 40436 1351 24 as as IN 40436 1351 25 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 1351 26 . . . 40436 1352 1 The the DT 40436 1352 2 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1352 3 of of IN 40436 1352 4 this this DT 40436 1352 5 is be VBZ 40436 1352 6 good good JJ 40436 1352 7 , , , 40436 1352 8 and and CC 40436 1352 9 the the DT 40436 1352 10 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 1352 11 of of IN 40436 1352 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1352 13 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 1352 14 , , , 40436 1352 15 under under IN 40436 1352 16 all all DT 40436 1352 17 supposable supposable JJ 40436 1352 18 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 1352 19 . . . 40436 1353 1 And and CC 40436 1353 2 if if IN 40436 1353 3 a a DT 40436 1353 4 man man NN 40436 1353 5 knows know VBZ 40436 1353 6 good good JJ 40436 1353 7 , , , 40436 1353 8 the the DT 40436 1353 9 more more RBR 40436 1353 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1353 11 knows know VBZ 40436 1353 12 of of IN 40436 1353 13 everything everything NN 40436 1353 14 else else RB 40436 1353 15 , , , 40436 1353 16 the the DT 40436 1353 17 better well JJR 40436 1353 18 ; ; : 40436 1353 19 since since IN 40436 1353 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1353 21 will will MD 40436 1353 22 sure sure RB 40436 1353 23 to to TO 40436 1353 24 make make VB 40436 1353 25 a a DT 40436 1353 26 good good JJ 40436 1353 27 use use NN 40436 1353 28 of of IN 40436 1353 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1353 30 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1353 31 . . . 40436 1354 1 But but CC 40436 1354 2 if if IN 40436 1354 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1354 4 does do VBZ 40436 1354 5 not not RB 40436 1354 6 know know VB 40436 1354 7 good good JJ 40436 1354 8 , , , 40436 1354 9 the the DT 40436 1354 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1354 11 of of IN 40436 1354 12 other other JJ 40436 1354 13 things thing NNS 40436 1354 14 will will MD 40436 1354 15 be be VB 40436 1354 16 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 1354 17 rather rather RB 40436 1354 18 than than IN 40436 1354 19 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 1354 20 to to IN 40436 1354 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1354 22 . . . 40436 1355 1 To to TO 40436 1355 2 be be VB 40436 1355 3 skilful skilful JJ 40436 1355 4 in in IN 40436 1355 5 particular particular JJ 40436 1355 6 arts art NNS 40436 1355 7 and and CC 40436 1355 8 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 1355 9 , , , 40436 1355 10 under under IN 40436 1355 11 the the DT 40436 1355 12 capital capital NN 40436 1355 13 mental mental JJ 40436 1355 14 deficiency deficiency NN 40436 1355 15 supposed suppose VBN 40436 1355 16 , , , 40436 1355 17 will will MD 40436 1355 18 render render VB 40436 1355 19 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1355 20 an an DT 40436 1355 21 instrument instrument NN 40436 1355 22 of of IN 40436 1355 23 evil evil NN 40436 1355 24 and and CC 40436 1355 25 not not RB 40436 1355 26 of of IN 40436 1355 27 good good JJ 40436 1355 28 . . . 40436 1356 1 The the DT 40436 1356 2 more more RBR 40436 1356 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1356 4 knows know VBZ 40436 1356 5 -- -- : 40436 1356 6 and and CC 40436 1356 7 the the DT 40436 1356 8 more more RBR 40436 1356 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1356 10 believes believe VBZ 40436 1356 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1356 12 to to TO 40436 1356 13 know know VB 40436 1356 14 -- -- : 40436 1356 15 the the DT 40436 1356 16 more more RBR 40436 1356 17 forward forward RB 40436 1356 18 will will MD 40436 1356 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1356 20 be be VB 40436 1356 21 in in IN 40436 1356 22 acting act VBG 40436 1356 23 , , , 40436 1356 24 and and CC 40436 1356 25 therefore therefore RB 40436 1356 26 the the DT 40436 1356 27 greater great JJR 40436 1356 28 amount amount NN 40436 1356 29 of of IN 40436 1356 30 harm harm NN 40436 1356 31 will will MD 40436 1356 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1356 33 do do VB 40436 1356 34 . . . 40436 1357 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1357 2 is be VBZ 40436 1357 3 better well JJR 40436 1357 4 that that IN 40436 1357 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1357 6 should should MD 40436 1357 7 act act VB 40436 1357 8 as as RB 40436 1357 9 little little JJ 40436 1357 10 as as IN 40436 1357 11 possible possible JJ 40436 1357 12 . . . 40436 1358 1 Such such PDT 40436 1358 2 a a DT 40436 1358 3 man man NN 40436 1358 4 is be VBZ 40436 1358 5 not not RB 40436 1358 6 fit fit JJ 40436 1358 7 to to TO 40436 1358 8 direct direct VB 40436 1358 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1358 10 own own JJ 40436 1358 11 conduct conduct NN 40436 1358 12 , , , 40436 1358 13 like like IN 40436 1358 14 a a DT 40436 1358 15 freeman freeman NN 40436 1358 16 : : : 40436 1358 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1358 18 must must MD 40436 1358 19 be be VB 40436 1358 20 directed direct VBN 40436 1358 21 and and CC 40436 1358 22 controlled control VBN 40436 1358 23 by by IN 40436 1358 24 others other NNS 40436 1358 25 , , , 40436 1358 26 like like IN 40436 1358 27 a a DT 40436 1358 28 slave slave NN 40436 1358 29 . . . 40436 1359 1 The the DT 40436 1359 2 greater great JJR 40436 1359 3 number number NN 40436 1359 4 of of IN 40436 1359 5 mankind mankind NN 40436 1359 6 are be VBP 40436 1359 7 fools fool NNS 40436 1359 8 of of IN 40436 1359 9 this this DT 40436 1359 10 description description NN 40436 1359 11 -- -- : 40436 1359 12 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 1359 13 of of IN 40436 1359 14 good good NN 40436 1359 15 : : : 40436 1359 16 the the DT 40436 1359 17 wise wise JJ 40436 1359 18 men man NNS 40436 1359 19 who who WP 40436 1359 20 know know VBP 40436 1359 21 good good JJ 40436 1359 22 , , , 40436 1359 23 and and CC 40436 1359 24 are be VBP 40436 1359 25 fit fit JJ 40436 1359 26 to to TO 40436 1359 27 direct direct VB 40436 1359 28 , , , 40436 1359 29 are be VBP 40436 1359 30 very very RB 40436 1359 31 few few JJ 40436 1359 32 . . . 40436 1360 1 The the DT 40436 1360 2 wise wise JJ 40436 1360 3 man man NN 40436 1360 4 alone alone RB 40436 1360 5 , , , 40436 1360 6 knowing know VBG 40436 1360 7 good good NN 40436 1360 8 , , , 40436 1360 9 follows follow VBZ 40436 1360 10 reason reason NN 40436 1360 11 : : : 40436 1360 12 the the DT 40436 1360 13 rest rest NN 40436 1360 14 trust trust NN 40436 1360 15 to to IN 40436 1360 16 opinion opinion NN 40436 1360 17 , , , 40436 1360 18 without without IN 40436 1360 19 reason reason NN 40436 1360 20 . . . 40436 1361 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1361 2 75 75 CD 40436 1361 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1361 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1361 5 alone alone RB 40436 1361 6 is be VBZ 40436 1361 7 competent competent JJ 40436 1361 8 to to TO 40436 1361 9 direct direct VB 40436 1361 10 both both CC 40436 1361 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1361 12 own own JJ 40436 1361 13 conduct conduct NN 40436 1361 14 and and CC 40436 1361 15 that that DT 40436 1361 16 of of IN 40436 1361 17 the the DT 40436 1361 18 society society NN 40436 1361 19 . . . 40436 1362 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1362 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1362 3 74 74 CD 40436 1362 4 : : : 40436 1362 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1362 6 , , , 40436 1362 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1362 8 . . . 40436 1363 1 ii ii LS 40436 1363 2 . . . 40436 1364 1 p. p. NN 40436 1364 2 145 145 CD 40436 1364 3 C. C. NNP 40436 1364 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1364 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1364 6 : : : 40436 1364 7 O(/stis o(/stis ADD 40436 1364 8 a)/ra a)/ra UH 40436 1364 9 ti ti XX 40436 1364 10 tô tô NNP 40436 1364 11 = = SYM 40436 1364 12 n n CC 40436 1364 13 toiou toiou NNP 40436 1364 14 / / SYM 40436 1364 15 tôn tôn NNP 40436 1364 16 oi)=den oi)=den CD 40436 1364 17 , , , 40436 1364 18 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 1364 19 me\n me\n NNP 40436 1364 20 pare pare NNP 40436 1364 21 / / SYM 40436 1364 22 pêtai pêtai NNP 40436 1364 23 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 1364 24 ê ê NN 40436 1364 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1364 26 tou= tou= NNP 40436 1364 27 belti belti NN 40436 1364 28 / / SYM 40436 1364 29 stou stou NNP 40436 1364 30 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 1364 31 / / SYM 40436 1364 32 mê mê NNP 40436 1364 33 -- -- : 40436 1364 34 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 1364 35 d d NNP 40436 1364 36 ' ' POS 40436 1364 37 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 1364 38 ê ê NNP 40436 1364 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1364 40 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 1364 41 dê dê NNP 40436 1364 42 / / SYM 40436 1364 43 pou pou NNP 40436 1364 44 ê(per ê(per NNP 40436 1364 45 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1364 46 ê ê NNP 40436 1364 47 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1364 48 tou= tou= NNP 40436 1364 49 ô)pheli ô)pheli NNP 40436 1364 50 / / SYM 40436 1364 51 mou]--also mou]--also NNP 40436 1364 52 146 146 CD 40436 1364 53 B. B. NNP 40436 1364 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1365 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1365 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1365 3 75 75 CD 40436 1365 4 : : : 40436 1365 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1365 6 , , , 40436 1365 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1365 8 . . . 40436 1366 1 ii ii LS 40436 1366 2 . . . 40436 1367 1 p. p. NN 40436 1367 2 146 146 CD 40436 1367 3 A A NNP 40436 1367 4 - - HYPH 40436 1367 5 D. D. NNP 40436 1367 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1367 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1367 8 : : : 40436 1367 9 a)/neu a)/neu VB 40436 1367 10 nou= nou= NNP 40436 1367 11 do do VB 40436 1367 12 / / SYM 40436 1367 13 xê| xê| NNP 40436 1367 14 pepisteuko pepisteuko NN 40436 1367 15 / / SYM 40436 1367 16 tas tas NNP 40436 1367 17 . . . 40436 1367 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1367 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1368 1 The the DT 40436 1368 2 stress stress NN 40436 1368 3 which which WDT 40436 1368 4 is be VBZ 40436 1368 5 laid lay VBN 40436 1368 6 here here RB 40436 1368 7 upon upon IN 40436 1368 8 the the DT 40436 1368 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1368 10 of of IN 40436 1368 11 good good JJ 40436 1368 12 , , , 40436 1368 13 as as IN 40436 1368 14 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 1368 15 from from IN 40436 1368 16 all all DT 40436 1368 17 other other JJ 40436 1368 18 varieties variety NNS 40436 1368 19 of of IN 40436 1368 20 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1368 21 -- -- : 40436 1368 22 the the DT 40436 1368 23 identification identification NN 40436 1368 24 of of IN 40436 1368 25 the the DT 40436 1368 26 good good JJ 40436 1368 27 with with IN 40436 1368 28 the the DT 40436 1368 29 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1368 30 , , , 40436 1368 31 and and CC 40436 1368 32 of of IN 40436 1368 33 the the DT 40436 1368 34 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1368 35 of of IN 40436 1368 36 good good NN 40436 1368 37 with with IN 40436 1368 38 reason reason NN 40436 1368 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1368 40 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1368 41 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1368 42 : : : 40436 1368 43 nou nou NNP 40436 1368 44 = = SYM 40436 1368 45 s s NN 40436 1368 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1368 47 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1368 48 , , , 40436 1368 49 while while IN 40436 1368 50 other other JJ 40436 1368 51 varieties variety NNS 40436 1368 52 of of IN 40436 1368 53 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1368 54 are be VBP 40436 1368 55 ranked rank VBN 40436 1368 56 with with IN 40436 1368 57 opinion opinion NN 40436 1368 58 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1368 59 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1368 60 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1368 61 : : : 40436 1368 62 do do VB 40436 1368 63 / / SYM 40436 1368 64 xa])--these xa])--these NNPS 40436 1368 65 are be VBP 40436 1368 66 points point NNS 40436 1368 67 which which WDT 40436 1368 68 , , , 40436 1368 69 under under IN 40436 1368 70 one one CD 40436 1368 71 phraseology phraseology NN 40436 1368 72 or or CC 40436 1368 73 another another DT 40436 1368 74 , , , 40436 1368 75 pervade pervade NN 40436 1368 76 many many JJ 40436 1368 77 of of IN 40436 1368 78 the the DT 40436 1368 79 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1368 80 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1368 81 . . . 40436 1369 1 The the DT 40436 1369 2 old old JJ 40436 1369 3 phrase phrase NN 40436 1369 4 of of IN 40436 1369 5 Herakleitus--[Greek Herakleitus--[Greek NNP 40436 1369 6 : : : 40436 1369 7 Polumathi polumathi NN 40436 1369 8 / / SYM 40436 1369 9 ê ê NNP 40436 1369 10 no no UH 40436 1369 11 / / SYM 40436 1369 12 on on IN 40436 1369 13 ou ou NNP 40436 1369 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1369 15 dida dida NNP 40436 1369 16 / / SYM 40436 1369 17 skei]--"much skei]--"much NNP 40436 1369 18 learning learning NN 40436 1369 19 does do VBZ 40436 1369 20 not not RB 40436 1369 21 teach teach VB 40436 1369 22 reason"--seems reason"--seem NNS 40436 1369 23 to to TO 40436 1369 24 have have VB 40436 1369 25 been be VBN 40436 1369 26 present present JJ 40436 1369 27 to to IN 40436 1369 28 the the DT 40436 1369 29 mind mind NN 40436 1369 30 of of IN 40436 1369 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1369 32 in in IN 40436 1369 33 composing compose VBG 40436 1369 34 this this DT 40436 1369 35 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1369 36 . . . 40436 1370 1 The the DT 40436 1370 2 man man NN 40436 1370 3 of of IN 40436 1370 4 much much JJ 40436 1370 5 learning learning NN 40436 1370 6 and and CC 40436 1370 7 art art NN 40436 1370 8 , , , 40436 1370 9 without without IN 40436 1370 10 the the DT 40436 1370 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1370 12 of of IN 40436 1370 13 good good JJ 40436 1370 14 , , , 40436 1370 15 and and CC 40436 1370 16 surrendering surrender VBG 40436 1370 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1370 18 to to IN 40436 1370 19 the the DT 40436 1370 20 guidance guidance NN 40436 1370 21 of of IN 40436 1370 22 one one CD 40436 1370 23 or or CC 40436 1370 24 other other JJ 40436 1370 25 among among IN 40436 1370 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1370 27 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 1370 28 , , , 40436 1370 29 is be VBZ 40436 1370 30 like like IN 40436 1370 31 a a DT 40436 1370 32 vessel vessel NN 40436 1370 33 tossed toss VBD 40436 1370 34 about about IN 40436 1370 35 at at IN 40436 1370 36 sea sea NN 40436 1370 37 without without IN 40436 1370 38 a a DT 40436 1370 39 pilot pilot NN 40436 1370 40 . . . 40436 1371 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1371 2 76 76 CD 40436 1371 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1371 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1371 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1371 6 76 76 CD 40436 1371 7 : : : 40436 1371 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1371 9 , , , 40436 1371 10 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 1371 11 . . . 40436 1372 1 ii ii LS 40436 1372 2 . . . 40436 1373 1 p. p. NN 40436 1373 2 147 147 CD 40436 1373 3 A. a. NN 40436 1374 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1374 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1374 3 : : : 40436 1374 4 o o NN 40436 1374 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1374 6 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1374 7 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 1374 8 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 1374 9 kaloume kaloume NNP 40436 1374 10 / / SYM 40436 1374 11 nên nên NNP 40436 1374 12 poluma poluma NNP 40436 1374 13 / / SYM 40436 1374 14 theia theia NNP 40436 1374 15 / / SYM 40436 1374 16 n n NNP 40436 1374 17 te te NNP 40436 1374 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1374 19 polutechni polutechni NNP 40436 1374 20 / / , 40436 1374 21 an an DT 40436 1374 22 kektême kektême NN 40436 1374 23 / / SYM 40436 1374 24 nos nos NNP 40436 1374 25 , , , 40436 1374 26 o)rphano\s o)rphano\s NNP 40436 1374 27 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1374 28 ô)\n ô)\n NNP 40436 1374 29 tau tau NNP 40436 1374 30 / / SYM 40436 1374 31 tês tês NNP 40436 1374 32 tê tê NNP 40436 1374 33 = = SYM 40436 1374 34 s s NNP 40436 1374 35 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 1374 36 / / SYM 40436 1374 37 mês mês NNPS 40436 1374 38 , , , 40436 1374 39 a)go a)go NNP 40436 1374 40 / / SYM 40436 1374 41 menos menos NNP 40436 1374 42 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1374 43 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 1374 44 mia mia NN 40436 1374 45 = = SYM 40436 1374 46 s s NNP 40436 1374 47 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 1374 48 / / SYM 40436 1374 49 stês stês NN 40436 1374 50 tô tô NNS 40436 1374 51 = = NFP 40436 1374 52 n n NN 40436 1374 53 a)/llôn a)/llôn NNP 40436 1374 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1374 55 , , , 40436 1374 56 & & CC 40436 1374 57 c. c. NNP 40436 1374 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1374 59 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1374 60 Side side NN 40436 1374 61 - - HYPH 40436 1374 62 note note NN 40436 1374 63 : : : 40436 1374 64 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1374 65 of of IN 40436 1374 66 Good good JJ 40436 1374 67 -- -- : 40436 1374 68 appears appear VBZ 40436 1374 69 postulated postulate VBN 40436 1374 70 and and CC 40436 1374 71 divined divine VBN 40436 1374 72 , , , 40436 1374 73 in in IN 40436 1374 74 many many JJ 40436 1374 75 of of IN 40436 1374 76 the the DT 40436 1374 77 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1374 78 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1374 79 , , , 40436 1374 80 under under IN 40436 1374 81 different different JJ 40436 1374 82 titles title NNS 40436 1374 83 . . . 40436 1374 84 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1375 1 What what WP 40436 1375 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1375 3 here here RB 40436 1375 4 calls call VBZ 40436 1375 5 the the DT 40436 1375 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1375 7 of of IN 40436 1375 8 Good good JJ 40436 1375 9 , , , 40436 1375 10 or or CC 40436 1375 11 Reason reason NN 40436 1375 12 -- -- : 40436 1375 13 the the DT 40436 1375 14 just just JJ 40436 1375 15 discrimination discrimination NN 40436 1375 16 and and CC 40436 1375 17 comparative comparative JJ 40436 1375 18 appreciation appreciation NN 40436 1375 19 of of IN 40436 1375 20 Ends Ends NNPS 40436 1375 21 and and CC 40436 1375 22 Means Means NNPS 40436 1375 23 -- -- : 40436 1375 24 appears appear VBZ 40436 1375 25 in in IN 40436 1375 26 the the DT 40436 1375 27 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 1375 28 and and CC 40436 1375 29 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 1375 30 , , , 40436 1375 31 under under IN 40436 1375 32 the the DT 40436 1375 33 title title NN 40436 1375 34 of of IN 40436 1375 35 the the DT 40436 1375 36 Regal Regal NNP 40436 1375 37 or or CC 40436 1375 38 Political Political NNP 40436 1375 39 Art Art NNP 40436 1375 40 , , , 40436 1375 41 of of IN 40436 1375 42 employing employing NN 40436 1375 43 or or CC 40436 1375 44 directing[77 directing[77 NNP 40436 1375 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1375 46 the the DT 40436 1375 47 results result NNS 40436 1375 48 of of IN 40436 1375 49 all all DT 40436 1375 50 other other JJ 40436 1375 51 arts art NNS 40436 1375 52 , , , 40436 1375 53 which which WDT 40436 1375 54 are be VBP 40436 1375 55 considered consider VBN 40436 1375 56 as as RB 40436 1375 57 subordinate subordinate JJ 40436 1375 58 : : : 40436 1375 59 in in IN 40436 1375 60 the the DT 40436 1375 61 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 1375 62 , , , 40436 1375 63 under under IN 40436 1375 64 the the DT 40436 1375 65 title title NN 40436 1375 66 of of IN 40436 1375 67 art art NN 40436 1375 68 of of IN 40436 1375 69 calculation calculation NN 40436 1375 70 or or CC 40436 1375 71 mensuration mensuration NN 40436 1375 72 : : : 40436 1375 73 in in IN 40436 1375 74 the the DT 40436 1375 75 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 1375 76 , , , 40436 1375 77 as as IN 40436 1375 78 measure measure NN 40436 1375 79 and and CC 40436 1375 80 proportion proportion NN 40436 1375 81 : : : 40436 1375 82 in in IN 40436 1375 83 the the DT 40436 1375 84 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 1375 85 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1375 86 in in IN 40436 1375 87 regard regard NN 40436 1375 88 to to IN 40436 1375 89 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 1375 90 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1375 91 as as IN 40436 1375 92 the the DT 40436 1375 93 art art NN 40436 1375 94 of of IN 40436 1375 95 turning turn VBG 40436 1375 96 to to IN 40436 1375 97 account account NN 40436 1375 98 , , , 40436 1375 99 for for IN 40436 1375 100 the the DT 40436 1375 101 main main JJ 40436 1375 102 purpose purpose NN 40436 1375 103 of of IN 40436 1375 104 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 1375 105 , , , 40436 1375 106 all all PDT 40436 1375 107 the the DT 40436 1375 108 special special JJ 40436 1375 109 processes process NNS 40436 1375 110 , , , 40436 1375 111 stratagems stratagem NNS 40436 1375 112 , , , 40436 1375 113 decorations decoration NNS 40436 1375 114 , , , 40436 1375 115 & & CC 40436 1375 116 c. c. NNP 40436 1375 117 , , , 40436 1375 118 imparted impart VBN 40436 1375 119 by by IN 40436 1375 120 professional professional JJ 40436 1375 121 masters master NNS 40436 1375 122 . . . 40436 1376 1 In in IN 40436 1376 2 the the DT 40436 1376 3 Republic Republic NNP 40436 1376 4 , , , 40436 1376 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1376 6 is be VBZ 40436 1376 7 personified personify VBN 40436 1376 8 in in IN 40436 1376 9 the the DT 40436 1376 10 few few JJ 40436 1376 11 venerable venerable JJ 40436 1376 12 Elders elder NNS 40436 1376 13 who who WP 40436 1376 14 constitute constitute VBP 40436 1376 15 the the DT 40436 1376 16 Reason Reason NNP 40436 1376 17 of of IN 40436 1376 18 the the DT 40436 1376 19 society society NN 40436 1376 20 , , , 40436 1376 21 and and CC 40436 1376 22 whose whose WP$ 40436 1376 23 directions direction NNS 40436 1376 24 all all PDT 40436 1376 25 the the DT 40436 1376 26 rest rest NN 40436 1376 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1376 28 Guardians Guardians NNPS 40436 1376 29 and and CC 40436 1376 30 Producers Producers NNPS 40436 1376 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1376 32 are be VBP 40436 1376 33 bound bind VBN 40436 1376 34 implicitly implicitly RB 40436 1376 35 to to TO 40436 1376 36 follow follow VB 40436 1376 37 : : : 40436 1376 38 the the DT 40436 1376 39 virtue virtue NN 40436 1376 40 of of IN 40436 1376 41 the the DT 40436 1376 42 subordinates subordinate NNS 40436 1376 43 consisting consist VBG 40436 1376 44 in in IN 40436 1376 45 this this DT 40436 1376 46 implicit implicit JJ 40436 1376 47 obedience obedience NN 40436 1376 48 . . . 40436 1377 1 In in IN 40436 1377 2 the the DT 40436 1377 3 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 1377 4 , , , 40436 1377 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1377 6 is be VBZ 40436 1377 7 defined define VBN 40436 1377 8 as as IN 40436 1377 9 the the DT 40436 1377 10 complete complete JJ 40436 1377 11 subjection subjection NN 40436 1377 12 in in IN 40436 1377 13 the the DT 40436 1377 14 mind mind NN 40436 1377 15 , , , 40436 1377 16 of of IN 40436 1377 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1377 18 and and CC 40436 1377 19 pains pain NNS 40436 1377 20 to to IN 40436 1377 21 right right JJ 40436 1377 22 Reason,[78 reason,[78 NN 40436 1377 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1377 24 without without IN 40436 1377 25 which which WDT 40436 1377 26 , , , 40436 1377 27 no no DT 40436 1377 28 special special JJ 40436 1377 29 aptitudes aptitude NNS 40436 1377 30 are be VBP 40436 1377 31 worth worth JJ 40436 1377 32 having have VBG 40436 1377 33 . . . 40436 1378 1 In in IN 40436 1378 2 the the DT 40436 1378 3 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1378 4 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1378 5 , , , 40436 1378 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1378 7 stands stand VBZ 40436 1378 8 as as IN 40436 1378 9 a a DT 40436 1378 10 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 1378 11 authority authority NN 40436 1378 12 under under IN 40436 1378 13 the the DT 40436 1378 14 title title NN 40436 1378 15 of of IN 40436 1378 16 Sophrosynê Sophrosynê NNP 40436 1378 17 or or CC 40436 1378 18 Temperance:[79 Temperance:[79 NNP 40436 1378 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1378 20 and and CC 40436 1378 21 the the DT 40436 1378 22 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 1378 23 is be VBZ 40436 1378 24 declared declare VBN 40436 1378 25 identical identical JJ 40436 1378 26 with with IN 40436 1378 27 the the DT 40436 1378 28 Good Good NNP 40436 1378 29 , , , 40436 1378 30 as as IN 40436 1378 31 the the DT 40436 1378 32 directing directing NN 40436 1378 33 and and CC 40436 1378 34 limiting limit VBG 40436 1378 35 principle principle NN 40436 1378 36 for for IN 40436 1378 37 all all DT 40436 1378 38 human human JJ 40436 1378 39 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 1378 40 and and CC 40436 1378 41 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 1378 42 . . . 40436 1379 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1379 2 80 80 CD 40436 1379 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1379 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1379 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1379 6 77 77 CD 40436 1379 7 : : : 40436 1379 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1379 9 , , , 40436 1379 10 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 1379 11 , , , 40436 1379 12 292 292 CD 40436 1379 13 B b NN 40436 1379 14 , , , 40436 1379 15 304 304 CD 40436 1379 16 B b NN 40436 1379 17 , , , 40436 1379 18 305 305 CD 40436 1379 19 A a DT 40436 1379 20 ; ; : 40436 1379 21 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 1379 22 , , , 40436 1379 23 291 291 CD 40436 1379 24 B b NN 40436 1379 25 , , , 40436 1379 26 292 292 CD 40436 1379 27 B. b. NN 40436 1380 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 1380 2 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1380 3 , , , 40436 1380 4 Oekonomicus Oekonomicus NNP 40436 1380 5 , , , 40436 1380 6 i. i. NNP 40436 1381 1 8 8 CD 40436 1381 2 , , , 40436 1381 3 13 13 CD 40436 1381 4 . . . 40436 1381 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1382 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1382 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1382 3 78 78 CD 40436 1382 4 : : : 40436 1382 5 Leges Leges NNP 40436 1382 6 , , , 40436 1382 7 iii iii CD 40436 1382 8 . . . 40436 1383 1 689 689 CD 40436 1383 2 A a NN 40436 1383 3 - - HYPH 40436 1383 4 D d NN 40436 1383 5 , , , 40436 1383 6 691 691 CD 40436 1383 7 A. a. NN 40436 1383 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1384 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1384 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1384 3 79 79 CD 40436 1384 4 : : : 40436 1384 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1384 6 . . . 40436 1385 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 1385 2 . . . 40436 1386 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1387 1 2 2 LS 40436 1387 2 . . . 40436 1388 1 17 17 CD 40436 1388 2 ; ; : 40436 1388 3 iv iv LS 40436 1388 4 . . . 40436 1389 1 3 3 LS 40436 1389 2 . . . 40436 1390 1 1 1 LS 40436 1390 2 . . . 40436 1390 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1391 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1391 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1391 3 80 80 CD 40436 1391 4 : : : 40436 1391 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1391 6 . . . 40436 1392 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 1392 2 . . . 40436 1393 1 iv iv XX 40436 1393 2 . . . 40436 1394 1 6 6 CD 40436 1394 2 , , , 40436 1394 3 8 8 CD 40436 1394 4 ; ; : 40436 1394 5 iv iv LS 40436 1394 6 . . . 40436 1395 1 7 7 CD 40436 1395 2 , , , 40436 1395 3 7 7 CD 40436 1395 4 . . . 40436 1395 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1396 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1396 2 Side side NN 40436 1396 3 - - HYPH 40436 1396 4 note note NN 40436 1396 5 : : : 40436 1396 6 The the DT 40436 1396 7 Good good JJ 40436 1396 8 -- -- : 40436 1396 9 the the DT 40436 1396 10 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 1396 11 -- -- : 40436 1396 12 what what WP 40436 1396 13 is be VBZ 40436 1396 14 it?--How it?--how ADD 40436 1396 15 are be VBP 40436 1396 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1396 17 to to TO 40436 1396 18 know know VB 40436 1396 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1396 20 ? ? . 40436 1397 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1397 2 leaves leave VBZ 40436 1397 3 this this DT 40436 1397 4 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 1397 5 . . . 40436 1397 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1398 1 But but CC 40436 1398 2 what what WP 40436 1398 3 are be VBP 40436 1398 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1398 5 to to TO 40436 1398 6 understand understand VB 40436 1398 7 by by IN 40436 1398 8 the the DT 40436 1398 9 _ _ NNP 40436 1398 10 Good Good NNP 40436 1398 11 _ _ NNP 40436 1398 12 , , , 40436 1398 13 about about IN 40436 1398 14 which which WDT 40436 1398 15 there there EX 40436 1398 16 are be VBP 40436 1398 17 so so RB 40436 1398 18 many many JJ 40436 1398 19 disputes dispute NNS 40436 1398 20 , , , 40436 1398 21 according accord VBG 40436 1398 22 to to IN 40436 1398 23 the the DT 40436 1398 24 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 40436 1398 25 of of IN 40436 1398 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1398 27 as as RB 40436 1398 28 well well RB 40436 1398 29 as as IN 40436 1398 30 of of IN 40436 1398 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1398 32 ? ? . 40436 1399 1 And and CC 40436 1399 2 what what WP 40436 1399 3 are be VBP 40436 1399 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1399 5 to to TO 40436 1399 6 understand understand VB 40436 1399 7 by by IN 40436 1399 8 the the DT 40436 1399 9 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 1399 10 ? ? . 40436 1400 1 In in IN 40436 1400 2 what what WDT 40436 1400 3 relation relation NN 40436 1400 4 does do VBZ 40436 1400 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1400 6 stand stand VB 40436 1400 7 to to IN 40436 1400 8 the the DT 40436 1400 9 Pleasurable Pleasurable NNP 40436 1400 10 and and CC 40436 1400 11 the the DT 40436 1400 12 Painful painful JJ 40436 1400 13 ? ? . 40436 1401 1 These these DT 40436 1401 2 are be VBP 40436 1401 3 points point NNS 40436 1401 4 which which WDT 40436 1401 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1401 6 here here RB 40436 1401 7 leaves leave VBZ 40436 1401 8 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 1401 9 . . . 40436 1402 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1402 2 shall shall MD 40436 1402 3 find find VB 40436 1402 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1402 5 again again RB 40436 1402 6 touching touch VBG 40436 1402 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1402 8 , , , 40436 1402 9 and and CC 40436 1402 10 trying try VBG 40436 1402 11 different different JJ 40436 1402 12 ways way NNS 40436 1402 13 of of IN 40436 1402 14 determining determine VBG 40436 1402 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1402 16 , , , 40436 1402 17 in in IN 40436 1402 18 the the DT 40436 1402 19 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 1402 20 , , , 40436 1402 21 the the DT 40436 1402 22 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 1402 23 , , , 40436 1402 24 the the DT 40436 1402 25 Republic Republic NNP 40436 1402 26 , , , 40436 1402 27 and and CC 40436 1402 28 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 1402 29 . . . 40436 1403 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1403 2 have have VBP 40436 1403 3 here here RB 40436 1403 4 the the DT 40436 1403 5 title title NN 40436 1403 6 and and CC 40436 1403 7 the the DT 40436 1403 8 postulate postulate NN 40436 1403 9 , , , 40436 1403 10 but but CC 40436 1403 11 nothing nothing NN 40436 1403 12 more more JJR 40436 1403 13 , , , 40436 1403 14 of of IN 40436 1403 15 a a DT 40436 1403 16 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 1403 17 Teleology teleology NN 40436 1403 18 , , , 40436 1403 19 or or CC 40436 1403 20 right right JJ 40436 1403 21 comparative comparative JJ 40436 1403 22 estimate estimate NN 40436 1403 23 of of IN 40436 1403 24 ends end NNS 40436 1403 25 and and CC 40436 1403 26 means mean VBZ 40436 1403 27 one one CD 40436 1403 28 against against IN 40436 1403 29 another another DT 40436 1403 30 , , , 40436 1403 31 so so IN 40436 1403 32 as as IN 40436 1403 33 to to TO 40436 1403 34 decide decide VB 40436 1403 35 when when WRB 40436 1403 36 , , , 40436 1403 37 how how WRB 40436 1403 38 far far RB 40436 1403 39 , , , 40436 1403 40 under under IN 40436 1403 41 what what WDT 40436 1403 42 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 1403 43 , , , 40436 1403 44 & & CC 40436 1403 45 c. c. NNP 40436 1403 46 , , , 40436 1403 47 each each DT 40436 1403 48 ought ought MD 40436 1403 49 to to TO 40436 1403 50 be be VB 40436 1403 51 pursued pursue VBN 40436 1403 52 . . . 40436 1404 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1404 2 shall shall MD 40436 1404 3 see see VB 40436 1404 4 what what WP 40436 1404 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1404 6 does do VBZ 40436 1404 7 in in IN 40436 1404 8 other other JJ 40436 1404 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1404 10 to to TO 40436 1404 11 connect connect VB 40436 1404 12 this this DT 40436 1404 13 title title NN 40436 1404 14 and and CC 40436 1404 15 postulate postulate NN 40436 1404 16 with with IN 40436 1404 17 a a DT 40436 1404 18 more more RBR 40436 1404 19 definite definite JJ 40436 1404 20 meaning meaning NN 40436 1404 21 . . . 40436 1405 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 1405 2 XIII XIII NNP 40436 1405 3 . . . 40436 1406 1 HIPPIAS HIPPIAS NNP 40436 1406 2 MAJOR MAJOR NNP 40436 1406 3 -- -- : 40436 1406 4 HIPPIAS HIPPIAS NNP 40436 1406 5 MINOR MINOR NNP 40436 1406 6 . . . 40436 1407 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1407 2 Side side NN 40436 1407 3 - - HYPH 40436 1407 4 note note NN 40436 1407 5 : : : 40436 1407 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1407 7 Major major JJ 40436 1407 8 -- -- : 40436 1407 9 situation situation NN 40436 1407 10 supposed suppose VBN 40436 1407 11 -- -- : 40436 1407 12 character character NN 40436 1407 13 of of IN 40436 1407 14 the the DT 40436 1407 15 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1407 16 . . . 40436 1408 1 Sarcasm sarcasm JJ 40436 1408 2 and and CC 40436 1408 3 mockery mockery NN 40436 1408 4 against against IN 40436 1408 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1408 6 . . . 40436 1408 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1409 1 Both both DT 40436 1409 2 these these DT 40436 1409 3 two two CD 40436 1409 4 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1409 5 are be VBP 40436 1409 6 carried carry VBN 40436 1409 7 on on RP 40436 1409 8 between between IN 40436 1409 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1409 10 and and CC 40436 1409 11 the the DT 40436 1409 12 Eleian Eleian NNP 40436 1409 13 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 1409 14 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1409 15 . . . 40436 1410 1 The the DT 40436 1410 2 general general JJ 40436 1410 3 conception conception NN 40436 1410 4 of of IN 40436 1410 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1410 6 -- -- : 40436 1410 7 described describe VBN 40436 1410 8 as as IN 40436 1410 9 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 1410 10 , , , 40436 1410 11 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 1410 12 , , , 40436 1410 13 and and CC 40436 1410 14 successful successful JJ 40436 1410 15 , , , 40436 1410 16 yet yet CC 40436 1410 17 made make VBN 40436 1410 18 to to TO 40436 1410 19 say say VB 40436 1410 20 vain vain JJ 40436 1410 21 and and CC 40436 1410 22 silly silly JJ 40436 1410 23 things thing NNS 40436 1410 24 -- -- : 40436 1410 25 is be VBZ 40436 1410 26 the the DT 40436 1410 27 same same JJ 40436 1410 28 in in IN 40436 1410 29 both both DT 40436 1410 30 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1410 31 : : : 40436 1410 32 in in IN 40436 1410 33 both both DT 40436 1410 34 also also RB 40436 1410 35 the the DT 40436 1410 36 polemics polemic NNS 40436 1410 37 of of IN 40436 1410 38 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1410 39 against against IN 40436 1410 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1410 41 are be VBP 40436 1410 42 conducted conduct VBN 40436 1410 43 in in IN 40436 1410 44 a a DT 40436 1410 45 like like JJ 40436 1410 46 spirit spirit NN 40436 1410 47 , , , 40436 1410 48 of of IN 40436 1410 49 affected affect VBN 40436 1410 50 deference deference NN 40436 1410 51 mingled mingle VBN 40436 1410 52 with with IN 40436 1410 53 insulting insulting JJ 40436 1410 54 sarcasm sarcasm NN 40436 1410 55 . . . 40436 1411 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 1411 2 the the DT 40436 1411 3 figure figure NN 40436 1411 4 assigned assign VBN 40436 1411 5 to to IN 40436 1411 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1411 7 is be VBZ 40436 1411 8 so so RB 40436 1411 9 contemptible contemptible JJ 40436 1411 10 , , , 40436 1411 11 that that IN 40436 1411 12 even even RB 40436 1411 13 an an DT 40436 1411 14 admiring admire VBG 40436 1411 15 critic critic NN 40436 1411 16 like like IN 40436 1411 17 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1411 18 can can MD 40436 1411 19 not not RB 40436 1411 20 avoid avoid VB 40436 1411 21 noticing notice VBG 40436 1411 22 the the DT 40436 1411 23 " " `` 40436 1411 24 petulans petulan NNS 40436 1411 25 pene pene NNP 40436 1411 26 et et FW 40436 1411 27 proterva proterva NN 40436 1411 28 in in IN 40436 1411 29 Hippiam Hippiam NNP 40436 1411 30 oratio oratio NN 40436 1411 31 , , , 40436 1411 32 " " '' 40436 1411 33 and and CC 40436 1411 34 intimating intimate VBG 40436 1411 35 that that IN 40436 1411 36 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1411 37 has have VBZ 40436 1411 38 handled handle VBN 40436 1411 39 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1411 40 more more RBR 40436 1411 41 coarsely coarsely RB 40436 1411 42 than than IN 40436 1411 43 any any DT 40436 1411 44 one one NN 40436 1411 45 else else RB 40436 1411 46 . . . 40436 1412 1 Such such JJ 40436 1412 2 petulance petulance NN 40436 1412 3 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1412 4 attempts attempt VBZ 40436 1412 5 to to TO 40436 1412 6 excuse excuse VB 40436 1412 7 by by IN 40436 1412 8 saying say VBG 40436 1412 9 that that IN 40436 1412 10 the the DT 40436 1412 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1412 12 is be VBZ 40436 1412 13 a a DT 40436 1412 14 youthful youthful JJ 40436 1412 15 composition composition NN 40436 1412 16 of of IN 40436 1412 17 Plato:[1 Plato:[1 NNP 40436 1412 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1412 19 while while IN 40436 1412 20 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1412 21 numbers number VBZ 40436 1412 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1412 23 among among IN 40436 1412 24 the the DT 40436 1412 25 reasons reason NNS 40436 1412 26 for for IN 40436 1412 27 suspecting suspect VBG 40436 1412 28 the the DT 40436 1412 29 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1412 30 , , , 40436 1412 31 and and CC 40436 1412 32 Ast Ast NNP 40436 1412 33 , , , 40436 1412 34 among among IN 40436 1412 35 the the DT 40436 1412 36 reasons reason NNS 40436 1412 37 for for IN 40436 1412 38 declaring declare VBG 40436 1412 39 positively positively RB 40436 1412 40 that that IN 40436 1412 41 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1412 42 is be VBZ 40436 1412 43 not not RB 40436 1412 44 the the DT 40436 1412 45 author author NN 40436 1412 46 . . . 40436 1413 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1413 2 2 2 LS 40436 1413 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1413 4 This this DT 40436 1413 5 last last JJ 40436 1413 6 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 1413 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1413 8 do do VBP 40436 1413 9 not not RB 40436 1413 10 at at RB 40436 1413 11 all all RB 40436 1413 12 accept accept VB 40436 1413 13 : : : 40436 1413 14 nor nor CC 40436 1413 15 even even RB 40436 1413 16 the the DT 40436 1413 17 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 1413 18 of of IN 40436 1413 19 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1413 20 , , , 40436 1413 21 if if IN 40436 1413 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1413 23 be be VB 40436 1413 24 tendered tender VBN 40436 1413 25 as as IN 40436 1413 26 an an DT 40436 1413 27 excuse excuse NN 40436 1413 28 for for IN 40436 1413 29 improprieties impropriety NNS 40436 1413 30 of of IN 40436 1413 31 tone tone NN 40436 1413 32 : : : 40436 1413 33 for for IN 40436 1413 34 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1413 35 believe believe VBP 40436 1413 36 that that IN 40436 1413 37 the the DT 40436 1413 38 earliest early JJS 40436 1413 39 of of IN 40436 1413 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1413 41 's 's POS 40436 1413 42 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1413 43 was be VBD 40436 1413 44 composed compose VBN 40436 1413 45 after after IN 40436 1413 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1413 47 was be VBD 40436 1413 48 twenty twenty CD 40436 1413 49 - - HYPH 40436 1413 50 eight eight CD 40436 1413 51 years year NNS 40436 1413 52 of of IN 40436 1413 53 age age NN 40436 1413 54 -- -- : 40436 1413 55 that that RB 40436 1413 56 is is RB 40436 1413 57 , , , 40436 1413 58 after after IN 40436 1413 59 the the DT 40436 1413 60 death death NN 40436 1413 61 of of IN 40436 1413 62 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1413 63 . . . 40436 1414 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1414 2 is be VBZ 40436 1414 3 however however RB 40436 1414 4 noway noway RB 40436 1414 5 improbable improbable JJ 40436 1414 6 , , , 40436 1414 7 that that IN 40436 1414 8 both both CC 40436 1414 9 the the DT 40436 1414 10 Greater Greater NNP 40436 1414 11 and and CC 40436 1414 12 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 1414 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1414 14 may may MD 40436 1414 15 have have VB 40436 1414 16 been be VBN 40436 1414 17 among among IN 40436 1414 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1414 19 's 's POS 40436 1414 20 earlier early JJR 40436 1414 21 compositions composition NNS 40436 1414 22 . . . 40436 1415 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1415 2 see see VBP 40436 1415 3 by by IN 40436 1415 4 the the DT 40436 1415 5 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1415 6 of of IN 40436 1415 7 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1415 8 that that IN 40436 1415 9 there there EX 40436 1415 10 was be VBD 40436 1415 11 repeated repeat VBN 40436 1415 12 and and CC 40436 1415 13 acrimonious acrimonious JJ 40436 1415 14 controversy controversy NN 40436 1415 15 between between IN 40436 1415 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1415 17 and and CC 40436 1415 18 Hippias Hippias NNPS 40436 1415 19 : : : 40436 1415 20 so so IN 40436 1415 21 that that IN 40436 1415 22 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1415 23 may may MD 40436 1415 24 probably probably RB 40436 1415 25 suppose suppose VB 40436 1415 26 feelings feeling NNS 40436 1415 27 of of IN 40436 1415 28 special special JJ 40436 1415 29 dislike dislike NN 40436 1415 30 , , , 40436 1415 31 determining determine VBG 40436 1415 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1415 33 to to TO 40436 1415 34 compose compose VB 40436 1415 35 two two CD 40436 1415 36 distinct distinct JJ 40436 1415 37 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1415 38 , , , 40436 1415 39 in in IN 40436 1415 40 which which WDT 40436 1415 41 an an DT 40436 1415 42 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 1415 43 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1415 44 is be VBZ 40436 1415 45 mocked mock VBN 40436 1415 46 and and CC 40436 1415 47 scourged scourge VBN 40436 1415 48 by by IN 40436 1415 49 an an DT 40436 1415 50 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 1415 51 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1415 52 . . . 40436 1416 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1416 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1416 3 1 1 CD 40436 1416 4 : : : 40436 1416 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1416 6 , , , 40436 1416 7 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 1416 8 . . . 40436 1417 1 in in IN 40436 1417 2 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1417 3 . . . 40436 1418 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1418 2 . . NNP 40436 1418 3 p. p. NN 40436 1418 4 149 149 CD 40436 1418 5 - - SYM 40436 1418 6 150 150 CD 40436 1418 7 ; ; : 40436 1418 8 also also RB 40436 1418 9 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1418 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1418 11 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 1418 12 , , , 40436 1418 13 p. p. NN 40436 1418 14 42 42 CD 40436 1418 15 - - SYM 40436 1418 16 43 43 CD 40436 1418 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1418 18 , , , 40436 1418 19 who who WP 40436 1418 20 says say VBZ 40436 1418 21 , , , 40436 1418 22 after after IN 40436 1418 23 an an DT 40436 1418 24 outpouring outpouring NN 40436 1418 25 of of IN 40436 1418 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1418 27 usual usual JJ 40436 1418 28 invective invective NN 40436 1418 29 against against IN 40436 1418 30 the the DT 40436 1418 31 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 1418 32 : : : 40436 1418 33 " " `` 40436 1418 34 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 1418 35 the the DT 40436 1418 36 coarse coarse JJ 40436 1418 37 jesting jesting NN 40436 1418 38 of of IN 40436 1418 39 the the DT 40436 1418 40 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1418 41 seems seem VBZ 40436 1418 42 almost almost RB 40436 1418 43 to to TO 40436 1418 44 exceed exceed VB 40436 1418 45 the the DT 40436 1418 46 admissible admissible JJ 40436 1418 47 limit limit NN 40436 1418 48 of of IN 40436 1418 49 comic comic JJ 40436 1418 50 effect effect NN 40436 1418 51 , , , 40436 1418 52 " " '' 40436 1418 53 & & CC 40436 1418 54 c. c. NNP 40436 1418 55 Again Again NNP 40436 1418 56 , , , 40436 1418 57 p. p. NN 40436 1418 58 50 50 CD 40436 1418 59 , , , 40436 1418 60 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1418 61 talks talk NNS 40436 1418 62 of of IN 40436 1418 63 the the DT 40436 1418 64 banter banter NN 40436 1418 65 which which WDT 40436 1418 66 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1418 67 carries carry VBZ 40436 1418 68 on on RP 40436 1418 69 with with IN 40436 1418 70 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1418 71 , , , 40436 1418 72 in in IN 40436 1418 73 a a DT 40436 1418 74 way way NN 40436 1418 75 not not RB 40436 1418 76 less less RBR 40436 1418 77 cruel cruel JJ 40436 1418 78 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1418 79 grausam grausam NN 40436 1418 80 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1418 81 than than IN 40436 1418 82 purposeless purposeless NN 40436 1418 83 , , , 40436 1418 84 tormenting torment VBG 40436 1418 85 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 86 with with IN 40436 1418 87 a a DT 40436 1418 88 string string NN 40436 1418 89 of of IN 40436 1418 90 successive successive JJ 40436 1418 91 new new JJ 40436 1418 92 propositions proposition NNS 40436 1418 93 about about IN 40436 1418 94 the the DT 40436 1418 95 definition definition NN 40436 1418 96 of of IN 40436 1418 97 the the DT 40436 1418 98 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1418 99 , , , 40436 1418 100 which which WDT 40436 1418 101 propositions proposition VBZ 40436 1418 102 , , , 40436 1418 103 as as RB 40436 1418 104 fast fast RB 40436 1418 105 as as IN 40436 1418 106 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1418 107 catches catch VBZ 40436 1418 108 at at IN 40436 1418 109 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 110 , , , 40436 1418 111 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 112 again again RB 40436 1418 113 withdraws withdraw VBZ 40436 1418 114 of of IN 40436 1418 115 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1418 116 own own JJ 40436 1418 117 accord accord NN 40436 1418 118 , , , 40436 1418 119 and and CC 40436 1418 120 thus thus RB 40436 1418 121 at at IN 40436 1418 122 last last JJ 40436 1418 123 dismisses dismisse NNS 40436 1418 124 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 125 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1418 126 as as IN 40436 1418 127 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 128 had have VBD 40436 1418 129 dismissed dismiss VBN 40436 1418 130 Ion Ion NNP 40436 1418 131 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1418 132 uninstructed uninstructed JJ 40436 1418 133 and and CC 40436 1418 134 unimproved unimproved JJ 40436 1418 135 , , , 40436 1418 136 without without IN 40436 1418 137 even even RB 40436 1418 138 leaving leave VBG 40436 1418 139 behind behind RB 40436 1418 140 in in IN 40436 1418 141 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 142 the the DT 40436 1418 143 sting sting NN 40436 1418 144 of of IN 40436 1418 145 anger anger NN 40436 1418 146 , , , 40436 1418 147 & & CC 40436 1418 148 c. c. NNP 40436 1418 149 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 150 requires require VBZ 40436 1418 151 a a DT 40436 1418 152 powerful powerful JJ 40436 1418 153 hatred hatred NN 40436 1418 154 against against IN 40436 1418 155 the the DT 40436 1418 156 persons person NNS 40436 1418 157 called call VBN 40436 1418 158 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 1418 159 , , , 40436 1418 160 to to TO 40436 1418 161 make make VB 40436 1418 162 a a DT 40436 1418 163 critic critic NN 40436 1418 164 take take VB 40436 1418 165 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 1418 166 in in IN 40436 1418 167 a a DT 40436 1418 168 comedy comedy NN 40436 1418 169 wherein wherein WRB 40436 1418 170 silly silly JJ 40436 1418 171 and and CC 40436 1418 172 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 1418 173 speeches speech NNS 40436 1418 174 are be VBP 40436 1418 175 fastened fasten VBN 40436 1418 176 upon upon IN 40436 1418 177 the the DT 40436 1418 178 name name NN 40436 1418 179 of of IN 40436 1418 180 one one CD 40436 1418 181 of of IN 40436 1418 182 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 183 , , , 40436 1418 184 in in IN 40436 1418 185 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1418 186 own own JJ 40436 1418 187 day day NN 40436 1418 188 not not RB 40436 1418 189 merely merely RB 40436 1418 190 honoured honour VBN 40436 1418 191 but but CC 40436 1418 192 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 1418 193 as as IN 40436 1418 194 deserving deserve VBG 40436 1418 195 honour honour NN 40436 1418 196 by by IN 40436 1418 197 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 1418 198 and and CC 40436 1418 199 varied varied JJ 40436 1418 200 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 1418 201 -- -- : 40436 1418 202 and and CC 40436 1418 203 to to TO 40436 1418 204 make make VB 40436 1418 205 the the DT 40436 1418 206 critic critic NN 40436 1418 207 describe describe VB 40436 1418 208 the the DT 40436 1418 209 historical historical JJ 40436 1418 210 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1418 211 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1418 212 whom whom WP 40436 1418 213 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 214 only only RB 40436 1418 215 know know VBP 40436 1418 216 from from IN 40436 1418 217 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1418 218 and and CC 40436 1418 219 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1418 220 -- -- : 40436 1418 221 see see VBP 40436 1418 222 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 1418 223 , , , 40436 1418 224 note note VB 40436 1418 225 7 7 CD 40436 1418 226 , , , 40436 1418 227 p. p. NN 40436 1418 228 89 89 CD 40436 1418 229 ; ; : 40436 1418 230 Socher Socher NNP 40436 1418 231 , , , 40436 1418 232 p. p. NN 40436 1418 233 221 221 CD 40436 1418 234 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1418 235 as as IN 40436 1418 236 if if IN 40436 1418 237 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1418 238 had have VBD 40436 1418 239 really really RB 40436 1418 240 delivered deliver VBN 40436 1418 241 these these DT 40436 1418 242 speeches speech NNS 40436 1418 243 , , , 40436 1418 244 or or CC 40436 1418 245 something something NN 40436 1418 246 equally equally RB 40436 1418 247 absurd absurd JJ 40436 1418 248 . . . 40436 1419 1 How how WRB 40436 1419 2 this this DT 40436 1419 3 comedy comedy NN 40436 1419 4 may may MD 40436 1419 5 be be VB 40436 1419 6 appreciated appreciate VBN 40436 1419 7 is be VBZ 40436 1419 8 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 1419 9 a a DT 40436 1419 10 matter matter NN 40436 1419 11 of of IN 40436 1419 12 individual individual JJ 40436 1419 13 taste taste NN 40436 1419 14 . . . 40436 1420 1 For for IN 40436 1420 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1420 3 part part NN 40436 1420 4 , , , 40436 1420 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1420 6 agree agree VBP 40436 1420 7 with with IN 40436 1420 8 Ast Ast NNP 40436 1420 9 in in IN 40436 1420 10 thinking think VBG 40436 1420 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1420 12 misplaced misplace VBD 40436 1420 13 and and CC 40436 1420 14 unbecoming unbecoming JJ 40436 1420 15 : : : 40436 1420 16 and and CC 40436 1420 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1420 18 am be VBP 40436 1420 19 not not RB 40436 1420 20 surprised surprised JJ 40436 1420 21 that that IN 40436 1420 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1420 23 wishes wish VBZ 40436 1420 24 to to TO 40436 1420 25 remove remove VB 40436 1420 26 the the DT 40436 1420 27 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1420 28 from from IN 40436 1420 29 the the DT 40436 1420 30 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1420 31 canon canon NN 40436 1420 32 , , , 40436 1420 33 though though IN 40436 1420 34 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1420 35 do do VBP 40436 1420 36 not not RB 40436 1420 37 concur concur VB 40436 1420 38 either either CC 40436 1420 39 in in IN 40436 1420 40 this this DT 40436 1420 41 inference inference NN 40436 1420 42 , , , 40436 1420 43 or or CC 40436 1420 44 in in IN 40436 1420 45 the the DT 40436 1420 46 general general JJ 40436 1420 47 principle principle NN 40436 1420 48 on on IN 40436 1420 49 which which WDT 40436 1420 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1420 51 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 1420 52 , , , 40436 1420 53 viz viz NNP 40436 1420 54 . . NNP 40436 1420 55 , , , 40436 1420 56 that that IN 40436 1420 57 all all DT 40436 1420 58 objections objection NNS 40436 1420 59 against against IN 40436 1420 60 the the DT 40436 1420 61 composition composition NN 40436 1420 62 of of IN 40436 1420 63 a a DT 40436 1420 64 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1420 65 are be VBP 40436 1420 66 to to TO 40436 1420 67 be be VB 40436 1420 68 held hold VBN 40436 1420 69 as as IN 40436 1420 70 being be VBG 40436 1420 71 also also RB 40436 1420 72 objections objection NNS 40436 1420 73 against against IN 40436 1420 74 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1420 75 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 1420 76 as as IN 40436 1420 77 a a DT 40436 1420 78 work work NN 40436 1420 79 of of IN 40436 1420 80 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1420 81 . . . 40436 1421 1 The the DT 40436 1421 2 Nubes Nubes NNP 40436 1421 3 of of IN 40436 1421 4 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40436 1421 5 , , , 40436 1421 6 greatly greatly RB 40436 1421 7 superior superior JJ 40436 1421 8 as as IN 40436 1421 9 a a DT 40436 1421 10 comedy comedy NN 40436 1421 11 to to IN 40436 1421 12 the the DT 40436 1421 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1421 14 of of IN 40436 1421 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1421 16 , , , 40436 1421 17 is be VBZ 40436 1421 18 turned turn VBN 40436 1421 19 to to IN 40436 1421 20 an an DT 40436 1421 21 abusive abusive JJ 40436 1421 22 purpose purpose NN 40436 1421 23 when when WRB 40436 1421 24 critics critic NNS 40436 1421 25 put put VBD 40436 1421 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1421 27 into into IN 40436 1421 28 court court NN 40436 1421 29 as as IN 40436 1421 30 evidence evidence NN 40436 1421 31 about about IN 40436 1421 32 the the DT 40436 1421 33 character character NN 40436 1421 34 of of IN 40436 1421 35 the the DT 40436 1421 36 real real JJ 40436 1421 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1421 38 . . . 40436 1422 1 K. K. NNP 40436 1422 2 F. F. NNP 40436 1422 3 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 1422 4 , , , 40436 1422 5 in in IN 40436 1422 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1422 7 judgment judgment NN 40436 1422 8 , , , 40436 1422 9 takes take VBZ 40436 1422 10 a a DT 40436 1422 11 more more RBR 40436 1422 12 rational rational JJ 40436 1422 13 view view NN 40436 1422 14 of of IN 40436 1422 15 the the DT 40436 1422 16 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1422 17 Major Major NNP 40436 1422 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1422 19 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 1422 20 . . . 40436 1423 1 und und JJ 40436 1423 2 Syst Syst NNP 40436 1423 3 . . . 40436 1424 1 der der NNP 40436 1424 2 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1424 3 . . . 40436 1425 1 Phil Phil NNP 40436 1425 2 . . . 40436 1426 1 p. p. NN 40436 1426 2 487 487 CD 40436 1426 3 - - SYM 40436 1426 4 647 647 CD 40436 1426 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1426 6 . . . 40436 1427 1 Instead instead RB 40436 1427 2 of of IN 40436 1427 3 expatiating expatiate VBG 40436 1427 4 on on IN 40436 1427 5 the the DT 40436 1427 6 glory glory NN 40436 1427 7 of of IN 40436 1427 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1427 9 in in IN 40436 1427 10 deriding deride VBG 40436 1427 11 an an DT 40436 1427 12 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 1427 13 contemporary contemporary NN 40436 1427 14 , , , 40436 1427 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1427 16 dwells dwell VBZ 40436 1427 17 upon upon IN 40436 1427 18 the the DT 40436 1427 19 logical logical JJ 40436 1427 20 mistakes mistake NNS 40436 1427 21 and and CC 40436 1427 22 confusion confusion NN 40436 1427 23 which which WDT 40436 1427 24 the the DT 40436 1427 25 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1427 26 brings bring VBZ 40436 1427 27 to to TO 40436 1427 28 view view VB 40436 1427 29 ; ; : 40436 1427 30 and and CC 40436 1427 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1427 32 reminds remind VBZ 40436 1427 33 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1427 34 justly justly RB 40436 1427 35 of of IN 40436 1427 36 the the DT 40436 1427 37 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 1427 38 condition condition NN 40436 1427 39 of of IN 40436 1427 40 the the DT 40436 1427 41 age age NN 40436 1427 42 , , , 40436 1427 43 when when WRB 40436 1427 44 even even RB 40436 1427 45 elementary elementary JJ 40436 1427 46 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 1427 47 in in IN 40436 1427 48 logic logic NN 40436 1427 49 and and CC 40436 1427 50 grammar grammar NNP 40436 1427 51 had have VBD 40436 1427 52 been be VBN 40436 1427 53 scarcely scarcely RB 40436 1427 54 attended attend VBN 40436 1427 55 to to IN 40436 1427 56 . . . 40436 1428 1 Both both DT 40436 1428 2 K. K. NNP 40436 1428 3 F. F. NNP 40436 1428 4 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 1428 5 and and CC 40436 1428 6 Socher Socher NNP 40436 1428 7 consider consider VB 40436 1428 8 the the DT 40436 1428 9 Hippias Hippias NNPS 40436 1428 10 to to TO 40436 1428 11 be be VB 40436 1428 12 not not RB 40436 1428 13 a a DT 40436 1428 14 juvenile juvenile JJ 40436 1428 15 production production NN 40436 1428 16 of of IN 40436 1428 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1428 18 , , , 40436 1428 19 but but CC 40436 1428 20 to to TO 40436 1428 21 belong belong VB 40436 1428 22 to to IN 40436 1428 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1428 24 middle middle JJ 40436 1428 25 age age NN 40436 1428 26 . . . 40436 1428 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1429 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1429 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1429 3 2 2 CD 40436 1429 4 : : : 40436 1429 5 Schleierm Schleierm NNP 40436 1429 6 . . . 40436 1430 1 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 1430 2 . . . 40436 1431 1 p. p. NN 40436 1431 2 401 401 CD 40436 1431 3 ; ; : 40436 1431 4 Ast Ast NNP 40436 1431 5 , , , 40436 1431 6 Platon Platon NNP 40436 1431 7 's 's POS 40436 1431 8 Leben Leben NNP 40436 1431 9 und und NN 40436 1431 10 Schriften Schriften NNP 40436 1431 11 , , , 40436 1431 12 p. p. NN 40436 1432 1 457 457 CD 40436 1432 2 - - SYM 40436 1432 3 459 459 CD 40436 1432 4 . . . 40436 1432 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1433 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1433 2 Side side NN 40436 1433 3 - - HYPH 40436 1433 4 note note NN 40436 1433 5 : : : 40436 1433 6 Real real JJ 40436 1433 7 debate debate NN 40436 1433 8 between between IN 40436 1433 9 the the DT 40436 1433 10 historical historical JJ 40436 1433 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1433 12 and and CC 40436 1433 13 Hippias Hippias NNPS 40436 1433 14 in in IN 40436 1433 15 the the DT 40436 1433 16 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1433 17 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1433 18 -- -- : 40436 1433 19 subject subject JJ 40436 1433 20 of of IN 40436 1433 21 that that DT 40436 1433 22 debate debate NN 40436 1433 23 . . . 40436 1433 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1434 1 One one CD 40436 1434 2 considerable considerable JJ 40436 1434 3 point point NN 40436 1434 4 in in IN 40436 1434 5 the the DT 40436 1434 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1434 7 Major Major NNP 40436 1434 8 appears appear VBZ 40436 1434 9 to to TO 40436 1434 10 have have VB 40436 1434 11 a a DT 40436 1434 12 bearing bearing NN 40436 1434 13 on on IN 40436 1434 14 the the DT 40436 1434 15 debate debate NN 40436 1434 16 between between IN 40436 1434 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1434 18 and and CC 40436 1434 19 Hippias Hippias NNPS 40436 1434 20 in in IN 40436 1434 21 the the DT 40436 1434 22 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 1434 23 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1434 24 : : : 40436 1434 25 in in IN 40436 1434 26 which which WDT 40436 1434 27 debate debate NN 40436 1434 28 , , , 40436 1434 29 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1434 30 taunts taunt VBZ 40436 1434 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1434 32 with with IN 40436 1434 33 always always RB 40436 1434 34 combating combat VBG 40436 1434 35 and and CC 40436 1434 36 deriding deride VBG 40436 1434 37 the the DT 40436 1434 38 opinions opinion NNS 40436 1434 39 of of IN 40436 1434 40 others other NNS 40436 1434 41 , , , 40436 1434 42 while while IN 40436 1434 43 evading evade VBG 40436 1434 44 to to TO 40436 1434 45 give give VB 40436 1434 46 opinions opinion NNS 40436 1434 47 of of IN 40436 1434 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1434 49 own own JJ 40436 1434 50 . . . 40436 1435 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1435 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 1435 3 that that IN 40436 1435 4 some some DT 40436 1435 5 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 1435 6 debates debate NNS 40436 1435 7 between between IN 40436 1435 8 the the DT 40436 1435 9 two two CD 40436 1435 10 had have VBD 40436 1435 11 turned turn VBN 40436 1435 12 upon upon IN 40436 1435 13 the the DT 40436 1435 14 definition definition NN 40436 1435 15 of of IN 40436 1435 16 the the DT 40436 1435 17 Just just JJ 40436 1435 18 , , , 40436 1435 19 and and CC 40436 1435 20 that that IN 40436 1435 21 on on IN 40436 1435 22 these these DT 40436 1435 23 occasions occasion NNS 40436 1435 24 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1435 25 had have VBD 40436 1435 26 been be VBN 40436 1435 27 the the DT 40436 1435 28 respondent respondent NN 40436 1435 29 , , , 40436 1435 30 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 1435 31 the the DT 40436 1435 32 objector objector NN 40436 1435 33 . . . 40436 1436 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1436 2 professes profess VBZ 40436 1436 3 to to TO 40436 1436 4 have have VB 40436 1436 5 reflected reflect VBN 40436 1436 6 upon upon IN 40436 1436 7 these these DT 40436 1436 8 debates debate NNS 40436 1436 9 , , , 40436 1436 10 and and CC 40436 1436 11 to to TO 40436 1436 12 be be VB 40436 1436 13 now now RB 40436 1436 14 prepared prepared JJ 40436 1436 15 with with IN 40436 1436 16 a a DT 40436 1436 17 definition definition NN 40436 1436 18 which which WDT 40436 1436 19 neither neither CC 40436 1436 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1436 21 nor nor CC 40436 1436 22 any any DT 40436 1436 23 one one NN 40436 1436 24 else else RB 40436 1436 25 can can MD 40436 1436 26 successfully successfully RB 40436 1436 27 assail assail VB 40436 1436 28 , , , 40436 1436 29 but but CC 40436 1436 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1436 31 will will MD 40436 1436 32 not not RB 40436 1436 33 say say VB 40436 1436 34 what what WP 40436 1436 35 the the DT 40436 1436 36 definition definition NN 40436 1436 37 is be VBZ 40436 1436 38 , , , 40436 1436 39 until until IN 40436 1436 40 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1436 41 has have VBZ 40436 1436 42 laid lay VBN 40436 1436 43 down down RP 40436 1436 44 one one CD 40436 1436 45 of of IN 40436 1436 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1436 47 own own JJ 40436 1436 48 . . . 40436 1437 1 In in IN 40436 1437 2 reply reply NN 40436 1437 3 to to IN 40436 1437 4 this this DT 40436 1437 5 challenge challenge NN 40436 1437 6 , , , 40436 1437 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1437 8 declares declare VBZ 40436 1437 9 the the DT 40436 1437 10 Just just RB 40436 1437 11 to to TO 40436 1437 12 be be VB 40436 1437 13 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 1437 14 to to IN 40436 1437 15 the the DT 40436 1437 16 Lawful Lawful NNP 40436 1437 17 or or CC 40436 1437 18 Customary Customary NNP 40436 1437 19 : : : 40436 1437 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1437 21 defends defend VBZ 40436 1437 22 this this DT 40436 1437 23 against against IN 40436 1437 24 various various JJ 40436 1437 25 objections objection NNS 40436 1437 26 of of IN 40436 1437 27 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1437 28 , , , 40436 1437 29 who who WP 40436 1437 30 concludes conclude VBZ 40436 1437 31 by by IN 40436 1437 32 admitting admit VBG 40436 1437 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1437 34 . . . 40436 1438 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1438 2 3 3 LS 40436 1438 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1438 4 Probably probably RB 40436 1438 5 this this DT 40436 1438 6 debate debate NN 40436 1438 7 , , , 40436 1438 8 as as IN 40436 1438 9 reported report VBN 40436 1438 10 by by IN 40436 1438 11 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1438 12 , , , 40436 1438 13 or or CC 40436 1438 14 something something NN 40436 1438 15 very very RB 40436 1438 16 like like IN 40436 1438 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1438 18 , , , 40436 1438 19 really really RB 40436 1438 20 took take VBD 40436 1438 21 place place NN 40436 1438 22 . . . 40436 1439 1 If if IN 40436 1439 2 so so RB 40436 1439 3 , , , 40436 1439 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1439 5 remark remark VBP 40436 1439 6 with with IN 40436 1439 7 surprise surprise NN 40436 1439 8 the the DT 40436 1439 9 feebleness feebleness NN 40436 1439 10 of of IN 40436 1439 11 the the DT 40436 1439 12 objections objection NNS 40436 1439 13 of of IN 40436 1439 14 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1439 15 , , , 40436 1439 16 in in IN 40436 1439 17 a a DT 40436 1439 18 case case NN 40436 1439 19 where where WRB 40436 1439 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1439 21 , , , 40436 1439 22 if if IN 40436 1439 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1439 24 had have VBD 40436 1439 25 been be VBN 40436 1439 26 the the DT 40436 1439 27 objector objector NN 40436 1439 28 , , , 40436 1439 29 would would MD 40436 1439 30 have have VB 40436 1439 31 found find VBN 40436 1439 32 such such JJ 40436 1439 33 strong strong JJ 40436 1439 34 ones one NNS 40436 1439 35 -- -- : 40436 1439 36 and and CC 40436 1439 37 the the DT 40436 1439 38 feeble feeble JJ 40436 1439 39 replies reply NNS 40436 1439 40 given give VBN 40436 1439 41 by by IN 40436 1439 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1439 43 , , , 40436 1439 44 whose whose WP$ 40436 1439 45 talent talent NN 40436 1439 46 lay lie VBD 40436 1439 47 in in IN 40436 1439 48 starting start VBG 40436 1439 49 and and CC 40436 1439 50 enforcing enforce VBG 40436 1439 51 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 1439 52 , , , 40436 1439 53 not not RB 40436 1439 54 in in IN 40436 1439 55 solving solve VBG 40436 1439 56 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1439 57 . . . 40436 1440 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1440 2 4 4 CD 40436 1440 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1440 4 Among among IN 40436 1440 5 the the DT 40436 1440 6 remarks remark NNS 40436 1440 7 which which WDT 40436 1440 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1440 9 makes make VBZ 40436 1440 10 in in IN 40436 1440 11 illustration illustration NN 40436 1440 12 to to IN 40436 1440 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1440 14 , , , 40436 1440 15 one one CD 40436 1440 16 is be VBZ 40436 1440 17 -- -- : 40436 1440 18 that that IN 40436 1440 19 Lykurgus Lykurgus NNP 40436 1440 20 had have VBD 40436 1440 21 ensured ensure VBN 40436 1440 22 superiority superiority NN 40436 1440 23 to to IN 40436 1440 24 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1440 25 by by IN 40436 1440 26 creating create VBG 40436 1440 27 in in IN 40436 1440 28 the the DT 40436 1440 29 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1440 30 a a DT 40436 1440 31 habit habit NN 40436 1440 32 of of IN 40436 1440 33 implicit implicit JJ 40436 1440 34 obedience obedience NN 40436 1440 35 to to IN 40436 1440 36 the the DT 40436 1440 37 laws law NNS 40436 1440 38 . . . 40436 1441 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1441 2 5 5 CD 40436 1441 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1441 4 Such such JJ 40436 1441 5 is be VBZ 40436 1441 6 the the DT 40436 1441 7 character character NN 40436 1441 8 of of IN 40436 1441 9 the the DT 40436 1441 10 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 1441 11 debate debate NN 40436 1441 12 . . . 40436 1442 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1442 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1442 3 3 3 CD 40436 1442 4 : : : 40436 1442 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 1442 6 . . . 40436 1443 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1443 2 . . . 40436 1444 1 iv iv XX 40436 1444 2 . . . 40436 1445 1 4 4 CD 40436 1445 2 , , , 40436 1445 3 12 12 CD 40436 1445 4 - - SYM 40436 1445 5 25 25 CD 40436 1445 6 . . . 40436 1445 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1446 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1446 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1446 3 4 4 CD 40436 1446 4 : : : 40436 1446 5 Compare compare VB 40436 1446 6 the the DT 40436 1446 7 puzzling puzzle VBG 40436 1446 8 questions question NNS 40436 1446 9 which which WDT 40436 1446 10 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 1446 11 when when WRB 40436 1446 12 a a DT 40436 1446 13 youth youth NN 40436 1446 14 is be VBZ 40436 1446 15 reported report VBN 40436 1446 16 to to TO 40436 1446 17 have have VB 40436 1446 18 addressed address VBN 40436 1446 19 to to IN 40436 1446 20 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 1446 21 , , , 40436 1446 22 and and CC 40436 1446 23 which which WDT 40436 1446 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1446 25 must must MD 40436 1446 26 unquestionably unquestionably RB 40436 1446 27 have have VB 40436 1446 28 heard hear VBN 40436 1446 29 from from IN 40436 1446 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1446 31 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1446 32 , , , 40436 1446 33 respecting respect VBG 40436 1446 34 the the DT 40436 1446 35 meaning meaning NN 40436 1446 36 of of IN 40436 1446 37 the the DT 40436 1446 38 word word NN 40436 1446 39 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1446 40 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1446 41 : : : 40436 1446 42 No no UH 40436 1446 43 / / SYM 40436 1446 44 mos mos NN 40436 1446 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1446 46 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1446 47 Xen Xen NNP 40436 1446 48 . . . 40436 1447 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1447 2 . . . 40436 1448 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1449 1 2 2 CD 40436 1449 2 , , , 40436 1449 3 42 42 CD 40436 1449 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1449 5 . . . 40436 1450 1 All all PDT 40436 1450 2 the the DT 40436 1450 3 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 1450 4 in in IN 40436 1450 5 determining determine VBG 40436 1450 6 the the DT 40436 1450 7 definition definition NN 40436 1450 8 of of IN 40436 1450 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1450 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1450 11 : : : 40436 1450 12 No no UH 40436 1450 13 / / SYM 40436 1450 14 mos mos NN 40436 1450 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1450 16 , , , 40436 1450 17 occur occur VBP 40436 1450 18 also also RB 40436 1450 19 in in IN 40436 1450 20 determining determine VBG 40436 1450 21 that that DT 40436 1450 22 of of IN 40436 1450 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1450 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1450 25 : : : 40436 1450 26 No no DT 40436 1450 27 / / SYM 40436 1450 28 mimon mimon NN 40436 1450 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1450 30 , , , 40436 1450 31 which which WDT 40436 1450 32 includes include VBZ 40436 1450 33 both both DT 40436 1450 34 Jus Jus NNP 40436 1450 35 Scriptum Scriptum NNP 40436 1450 36 and and CC 40436 1450 37 Jus Jus NNP 40436 1450 38 Moribus Moribus NNP 40436 1450 39 Receptum Receptum NNP 40436 1450 40 . . . 40436 1450 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1451 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1451 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1451 3 5 5 CD 40436 1451 4 : : : 40436 1451 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 1451 6 . . . 40436 1452 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1452 2 . . . 40436 1453 1 iv iv XX 40436 1453 2 . . . 40436 1454 1 4 4 CD 40436 1454 2 , , , 40436 1454 3 15 15 CD 40436 1454 4 . . . 40436 1454 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1455 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1455 2 Side side NN 40436 1455 3 - - HYPH 40436 1455 4 note note NN 40436 1455 5 : : : 40436 1455 6 Opening opening NN 40436 1455 7 of of IN 40436 1455 8 the the DT 40436 1455 9 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1455 10 Major Major NNP 40436 1455 11 -- -- : 40436 1455 12 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1455 13 describes describe VBZ 40436 1455 14 the the DT 40436 1455 15 successful successful JJ 40436 1455 16 circuit circuit NN 40436 1455 17 which which WDT 40436 1455 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1455 19 had have VBD 40436 1455 20 made make VBN 40436 1455 21 through through IN 40436 1455 22 Greece Greece NNP 40436 1455 23 , , , 40436 1455 24 and and CC 40436 1455 25 the the DT 40436 1455 26 renown renown NN 40436 1455 27 as as RB 40436 1455 28 well well RB 40436 1455 29 as as IN 40436 1455 30 the the DT 40436 1455 31 gain gain NN 40436 1455 32 acquired acquire VBN 40436 1455 33 by by IN 40436 1455 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1455 35 lectures lecture NNS 40436 1455 36 . . . 40436 1455 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1456 1 Here here RB 40436 1456 2 , , , 40436 1456 3 in in IN 40436 1456 4 the the DT 40436 1456 5 beginning beginning NN 40436 1456 6 of of IN 40436 1456 7 the the DT 40436 1456 8 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1456 9 Major Major NNP 40436 1456 10 , , , 40436 1456 11 the the DT 40436 1456 12 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1456 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1456 14 remarks remark VBZ 40436 1456 15 that that IN 40436 1456 16 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1456 17 has have VBZ 40436 1456 18 been be VBN 40436 1456 19 long long RB 40436 1456 20 absent absent JJ 40436 1456 21 from from IN 40436 1456 22 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1456 23 : : : 40436 1456 24 which which WDT 40436 1456 25 absence absence NN 40436 1456 26 , , , 40436 1456 27 the the DT 40436 1456 28 latter latter JJ 40436 1456 29 explains explain VBZ 40436 1456 30 , , , 40436 1456 31 by by IN 40436 1456 32 saying say VBG 40436 1456 33 that that IN 40436 1456 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1456 35 has have VBZ 40436 1456 36 visited visit VBN 40436 1456 37 many many JJ 40436 1456 38 cities city NNS 40436 1456 39 in in IN 40436 1456 40 Greece Greece NNP 40436 1456 41 , , , 40436 1456 42 giving give VBG 40436 1456 43 lectures lecture NNS 40436 1456 44 with with IN 40436 1456 45 great great JJ 40436 1456 46 success success NN 40436 1456 47 , , , 40436 1456 48 and and CC 40436 1456 49 receiving receive VBG 40436 1456 50 high high JJ 40436 1456 51 pay pay NN 40436 1456 52 : : : 40436 1456 53 and and CC 40436 1456 54 that that IN 40436 1456 55 especially especially RB 40436 1456 56 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1456 57 has have VBZ 40436 1456 58 often often RB 40436 1456 59 visited visit VBN 40436 1456 60 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1456 61 , , , 40436 1456 62 partly partly RB 40436 1456 63 to to TO 40436 1456 64 give give VB 40436 1456 65 lectures lecture NNS 40436 1456 66 , , , 40436 1456 67 but but CC 40436 1456 68 partly partly RB 40436 1456 69 also also RB 40436 1456 70 to to TO 40436 1456 71 transact transact VB 40436 1456 72 diplomatic diplomatic JJ 40436 1456 73 business business NN 40436 1456 74 for for IN 40436 1456 75 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1456 76 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 1456 77 the the DT 40436 1456 78 Eleians Eleians NNPS 40436 1456 79 , , , 40436 1456 80 who who WP 40436 1456 81 trusted trust VBD 40436 1456 82 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1456 83 more more RBR 40436 1456 84 than than IN 40436 1456 85 any any DT 40436 1456 86 one one NN 40436 1456 87 else else RB 40436 1456 88 for for IN 40436 1456 89 such such JJ 40436 1456 90 duties duty NNS 40436 1456 91 . . . 40436 1457 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1457 2 lectures lecture NNS 40436 1457 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1457 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1457 5 says say VBZ 40436 1457 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1457 7 were be VBD 40436 1457 8 eminently eminently RB 40436 1457 9 instructive instructive JJ 40436 1457 10 and and CC 40436 1457 11 valuable valuable JJ 40436 1457 12 for for IN 40436 1457 13 the the DT 40436 1457 14 training training NN 40436 1457 15 of of IN 40436 1457 16 youth youth NN 40436 1457 17 : : : 40436 1457 18 moreover moreover RB 40436 1457 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1457 20 were be VBD 40436 1457 21 so so RB 40436 1457 22 generally generally RB 40436 1457 23 approved approve VBN 40436 1457 24 , , , 40436 1457 25 that that IN 40436 1457 26 even even RB 40436 1457 27 from from IN 40436 1457 28 a a DT 40436 1457 29 small small JJ 40436 1457 30 Sicilian sicilian JJ 40436 1457 31 town town NN 40436 1457 32 called call VBN 40436 1457 33 Inykus Inykus NNP 40436 1457 34 , , , 40436 1457 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1457 36 obtained obtain VBD 40436 1457 37 a a DT 40436 1457 38 considerable considerable JJ 40436 1457 39 sum sum NN 40436 1457 40 in in IN 40436 1457 41 fees fee NNS 40436 1457 42 . . . 40436 1458 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1458 2 Side side NN 40436 1458 3 - - HYPH 40436 1458 4 note note NN 40436 1458 5 : : : 40436 1458 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1458 7 had have VBD 40436 1458 8 met meet VBN 40436 1458 9 with with IN 40436 1458 10 no no DT 40436 1458 11 success success NN 40436 1458 12 at at IN 40436 1458 13 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1458 14 . . . 40436 1459 1 Why why WRB 40436 1459 2 the the DT 40436 1459 3 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1459 4 did do VBD 40436 1459 5 not not RB 40436 1459 6 admit admit VB 40436 1459 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1459 8 instructions instruction NNS 40436 1459 9 -- -- : 40436 1459 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1459 11 law law NN 40436 1459 12 forbids forbid NNS 40436 1459 13 . . . 40436 1459 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1460 1 Upon upon IN 40436 1460 2 this this DT 40436 1460 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1460 4 asks ask VBZ 40436 1460 5 -- -- : 40436 1460 6 In in IN 40436 1460 7 which which WDT 40436 1460 8 of of IN 40436 1460 9 the the DT 40436 1460 10 cities city NNS 40436 1460 11 were be VBD 40436 1460 12 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1460 13 gains gain NNS 40436 1460 14 the the DT 40436 1460 15 largest large JJS 40436 1460 16 : : : 40436 1460 17 probably probably RB 40436 1460 18 at at IN 40436 1460 19 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1460 20 ? ? . 40436 1461 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1461 2 Hip._--No Hip._--No NNP 40436 1461 3 ; ; : 40436 1461 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1461 5 received receive VBD 40436 1461 6 nothing nothing NN 40436 1461 7 at at RB 40436 1461 8 all all RB 40436 1461 9 at at IN 40436 1461 10 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1461 11 . . . 40436 1462 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1462 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 1462 3 ? ? . 40436 1463 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1463 2 amaze amaze VBP 40436 1463 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1463 4 ! ! . 40436 1464 1 Were be VBD 40436 1464 2 not not RB 40436 1464 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1464 4 lectures lecture NNS 40436 1464 5 calculated calculate VBN 40436 1464 6 to to TO 40436 1464 7 improve improve VB 40436 1464 8 the the DT 40436 1464 9 Spartan spartan JJ 40436 1464 10 youth youth NN 40436 1464 11 ? ? . 40436 1465 1 or or CC 40436 1465 2 did do VBD 40436 1465 3 not not RB 40436 1465 4 the the DT 40436 1465 5 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1465 6 desire desire NN 40436 1465 7 to to TO 40436 1465 8 have have VB 40436 1465 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1465 10 youth youth NN 40436 1465 11 improved improve VBN 40436 1465 12 ? ? . 40436 1466 1 or or CC 40436 1466 2 had have VBD 40436 1466 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1466 4 no no DT 40436 1466 5 money money NN 40436 1466 6 ? ? . 40436 1467 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1467 2 Hip._--Neither Hip._--Neither , 40436 1467 3 one one CD 40436 1467 4 nor nor CC 40436 1467 5 the the DT 40436 1467 6 other other JJ 40436 1467 7 . . . 40436 1468 1 The the DT 40436 1468 2 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1468 3 , , , 40436 1468 4 like like IN 40436 1468 5 others other NNS 40436 1468 6 , , , 40436 1468 7 desire desire VB 40436 1468 8 the the DT 40436 1468 9 improvement improvement NN 40436 1468 10 of of IN 40436 1468 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1468 12 youth youth NN 40436 1468 13 : : : 40436 1468 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1468 15 also also RB 40436 1468 16 have have VBP 40436 1468 17 plenty plenty NN 40436 1468 18 of of IN 40436 1468 19 money money NN 40436 1468 20 : : : 40436 1468 21 moreover moreover RB 40436 1468 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1468 23 lectures lecture NNS 40436 1468 24 were be VBD 40436 1468 25 very very RB 40436 1468 26 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 1468 27 to to IN 40436 1468 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1468 29 as as RB 40436 1468 30 well well RB 40436 1468 31 as as IN 40436 1468 32 to to IN 40436 1468 33 the the DT 40436 1468 34 rest rest NN 40436 1468 35 . . . 40436 1469 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1469 2 6 6 CD 40436 1469 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1469 4 _ _ NNP 40436 1469 5 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 1469 6 could could MD 40436 1469 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1469 8 happen happen VB 40436 1469 9 then then RB 40436 1469 10 , , , 40436 1469 11 that that IN 40436 1469 12 at at IN 40436 1469 13 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1469 14 , , , 40436 1469 15 a a DT 40436 1469 16 city city NN 40436 1469 17 great great JJ 40436 1469 18 and and CC 40436 1469 19 eminent eminent JJ 40436 1469 20 for for IN 40436 1469 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1469 22 good good JJ 40436 1469 23 laws law NNS 40436 1469 24 , , , 40436 1469 25 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1469 26 valuable valuable JJ 40436 1469 27 instructions instruction NNS 40436 1469 28 were be VBD 40436 1469 29 left leave VBN 40436 1469 30 unrewarded unrewarded JJ 40436 1469 31 ; ; : 40436 1469 32 while while IN 40436 1469 33 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1469 34 received receive VBD 40436 1469 35 so so RB 40436 1469 36 much much RB 40436 1469 37 at at IN 40436 1469 38 the the DT 40436 1469 39 inconsiderable inconsiderable JJ 40436 1469 40 town town NN 40436 1469 41 of of IN 40436 1469 42 Inykus Inykus NNP 40436 1469 43 ? ? . 40436 1470 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1470 2 Hip._--It Hip._--It NNP 40436 1470 3 is be VBZ 40436 1470 4 not not RB 40436 1470 5 the the DT 40436 1470 6 custom custom NN 40436 1470 7 of of IN 40436 1470 8 the the DT 40436 1470 9 country country NN 40436 1470 10 , , , 40436 1470 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1470 12 , , , 40436 1470 13 for for IN 40436 1470 14 the the DT 40436 1470 15 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1470 16 to to TO 40436 1470 17 change change VB 40436 1470 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1470 19 laws law NNS 40436 1470 20 , , , 40436 1470 21 or or CC 40436 1470 22 to to TO 40436 1470 23 educate educate VB 40436 1470 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1470 25 sons son NNS 40436 1470 26 in in IN 40436 1470 27 a a DT 40436 1470 28 way way NN 40436 1470 29 different different JJ 40436 1470 30 from from IN 40436 1470 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1470 32 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 1470 33 routine routine NN 40436 1470 34 . . . 40436 1471 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1471 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 1471 3 say say VBP 40436 1471 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1471 5 ? ? . 40436 1472 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1472 2 is be VBZ 40436 1472 3 not not RB 40436 1472 4 the the DT 40436 1472 5 custom custom NN 40436 1472 6 of of IN 40436 1472 7 the the DT 40436 1472 8 country country NN 40436 1472 9 for for IN 40436 1472 10 the the DT 40436 1472 11 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1472 12 to to TO 40436 1472 13 do do VB 40436 1472 14 right right NN 40436 1472 15 , , , 40436 1472 16 but but CC 40436 1472 17 to to TO 40436 1472 18 do do VB 40436 1472 19 wrong wrong NN 40436 1472 20 ? ? . 40436 1473 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1473 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 1473 3 shall shall MD 40436 1473 4 not not RB 40436 1473 5 say say VB 40436 1473 6 that that IN 40436 1473 7 , , , 40436 1473 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1473 9 . . . 40436 1474 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1474 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 1474 3 surely surely RB 40436 1474 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1474 5 would would MD 40436 1474 6 do do VB 40436 1474 7 right right NN 40436 1474 8 , , , 40436 1474 9 in in IN 40436 1474 10 educating educate VBG 40436 1474 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1474 12 children child NNS 40436 1474 13 better well RBR 40436 1474 14 and and CC 40436 1474 15 not not RB 40436 1474 16 worse bad JJR 40436 1474 17 ? ? . 40436 1475 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1475 2 Hip._--Yes Hip._--Yes NNP 40436 1475 3 , , , 40436 1475 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1475 5 would would MD 40436 1475 6 do do VB 40436 1475 7 right right RB 40436 1475 8 : : : 40436 1475 9 but but CC 40436 1475 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1475 11 is be VBZ 40436 1475 12 not not RB 40436 1475 13 lawful lawful JJ 40436 1475 14 for for IN 40436 1475 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1475 16 to to TO 40436 1475 17 admit admit VB 40436 1475 18 a a DT 40436 1475 19 foreign foreign JJ 40436 1475 20 mode mode NN 40436 1475 21 of of IN 40436 1475 22 education education NN 40436 1475 23 . . . 40436 1476 1 If if IN 40436 1476 2 any any DT 40436 1476 3 one one PRP 40436 1476 4 could could MD 40436 1476 5 have have VB 40436 1476 6 obtained obtain VBN 40436 1476 7 payment payment NN 40436 1476 8 there there RB 40436 1476 9 for for IN 40436 1476 10 education education NN 40436 1476 11 , , , 40436 1476 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1476 13 should should MD 40436 1476 14 have have VB 40436 1476 15 obtained obtain VBN 40436 1476 16 a a DT 40436 1476 17 great great JJ 40436 1476 18 deal deal NN 40436 1476 19 ; ; : 40436 1476 20 for for IN 40436 1476 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1476 22 listen listen VBP 40436 1476 23 to to IN 40436 1476 24 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1476 25 with with IN 40436 1476 26 delight delight NN 40436 1476 27 and and CC 40436 1476 28 applaud applaud VB 40436 1476 29 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1476 30 : : : 40436 1476 31 but but CC 40436 1476 32 , , , 40436 1476 33 as as IN 40436 1476 34 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1476 35 told tell VBD 40436 1476 36 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1476 37 , , , 40436 1476 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1476 39 law law NN 40436 1476 40 forbids forbid NNS 40436 1476 41 . . . 40436 1477 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1477 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1477 3 6 6 CD 40436 1477 4 : : : 40436 1477 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1477 6 , , , 40436 1477 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1477 8 . . . 40436 1478 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1478 2 . . . 40436 1479 1 283 283 CD 40436 1479 2 - - SYM 40436 1479 3 284 284 CD 40436 1479 4 . . . 40436 1479 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1480 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1480 2 Side side NN 40436 1480 3 - - HYPH 40436 1480 4 note note NN 40436 1480 5 : : : 40436 1480 6 Question question NN 40436 1480 7 , , , 40436 1480 8 What what WP 40436 1480 9 is be VBZ 40436 1480 10 law law NN 40436 1480 11 ? ? . 40436 1481 1 The the DT 40436 1481 2 law law NN 40436 1481 3 - - HYPH 40436 1481 4 makers maker NNS 40436 1481 5 always always RB 40436 1481 6 aim aim VBP 40436 1481 7 at at IN 40436 1481 8 the the DT 40436 1481 9 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 1481 10 , , , 40436 1481 11 but but CC 40436 1481 12 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1481 13 fail fail VB 40436 1481 14 to to TO 40436 1481 15 attain attain VB 40436 1481 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1481 17 . . . 40436 1482 1 When when WRB 40436 1482 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1482 3 fail fail VBP 40436 1482 4 , , , 40436 1482 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1482 6 fail fail VBP 40436 1482 7 to to TO 40436 1482 8 attain attain VB 40436 1482 9 law law NN 40436 1482 10 . . . 40436 1483 1 The the DT 40436 1483 2 lawful lawful JJ 40436 1483 3 is be VBZ 40436 1483 4 the the DT 40436 1483 5 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 1483 6 : : : 40436 1483 7 the the DT 40436 1483 8 Unprofitable Unprofitable NNP 40436 1483 9 is be VBZ 40436 1483 10 also also RB 40436 1483 11 unlawful unlawful JJ 40436 1483 12 . . . 40436 1483 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1484 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1484 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 1484 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1484 4 call call VBP 40436 1484 5 law law NN 40436 1484 6 a a DT 40436 1484 7 hurt hurt NN 40436 1484 8 or or CC 40436 1484 9 benefit benefit VB 40436 1484 10 to to IN 40436 1484 11 the the DT 40436 1484 12 city city NN 40436 1484 13 ? ? . 40436 1485 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1485 2 Hip._--Law Hip._--Law NNP 40436 1485 3 is be VBZ 40436 1485 4 enacted enact VBN 40436 1485 5 with with IN 40436 1485 6 a a DT 40436 1485 7 view view NN 40436 1485 8 to to TO 40436 1485 9 benefit benefit VB 40436 1485 10 : : : 40436 1485 11 but but CC 40436 1485 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1485 13 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1485 14 hurts hurt VBZ 40436 1485 15 if if IN 40436 1485 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1485 17 be be VB 40436 1485 18 badly badly RB 40436 1485 19 enacted enact VBN 40436 1485 20 . . . 40436 1486 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1486 2 7 7 CD 40436 1486 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1486 4 _ _ NNP 40436 1486 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 1486 6 what what WP 40436 1486 7 ? ? . 40436 1487 1 Do do VBP 40436 1487 2 not not RB 40436 1487 3 the the DT 40436 1487 4 enactors enactor NNS 40436 1487 5 enact enact VB 40436 1487 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1487 7 as as IN 40436 1487 8 the the DT 40436 1487 9 maximum maximum NN 40436 1487 10 of of IN 40436 1487 11 good good JJ 40436 1487 12 , , , 40436 1487 13 without without IN 40436 1487 14 which which WDT 40436 1487 15 the the DT 40436 1487 16 citizens citizen NNS 40436 1487 17 can can MD 40436 1487 18 not not RB 40436 1487 19 live live VB 40436 1487 20 a a DT 40436 1487 21 regulated regulate VBN 40436 1487 22 life life NN 40436 1487 23 ? ? . 40436 1488 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1488 2 Hip._--Certainly hip._--certainly RB 40436 1488 3 : : : 40436 1488 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1488 5 do do VBP 40436 1488 6 so so RB 40436 1488 7 . . . 40436 1489 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1489 2 Sokr._--Therefore Sokr._--Therefore NNP 40436 1489 3 , , , 40436 1489 4 when when WRB 40436 1489 5 those those DT 40436 1489 6 who who WP 40436 1489 7 try try VBP 40436 1489 8 to to TO 40436 1489 9 enact enact VB 40436 1489 10 laws law NNS 40436 1489 11 miss miss VBP 40436 1489 12 the the DT 40436 1489 13 attainment attainment NN 40436 1489 14 of of IN 40436 1489 15 good good JJ 40436 1489 16 , , , 40436 1489 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1489 18 also also RB 40436 1489 19 miss miss VBP 40436 1489 20 the the DT 40436 1489 21 lawful lawful JJ 40436 1489 22 and and CC 40436 1489 23 law law VBP 40436 1489 24 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 1489 25 . . . 40436 1490 1 How how WRB 40436 1490 2 say say VB 40436 1490 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1490 4 ? ? . 40436 1491 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1491 2 Hip._--They hip._--they UH 40436 1491 3 do do VB 40436 1491 4 so so RB 40436 1491 5 , , , 40436 1491 6 if if IN 40436 1491 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1491 8 speak speak VBP 40436 1491 9 with with IN 40436 1491 10 strict strict JJ 40436 1491 11 propriety propriety NN 40436 1491 12 : : : 40436 1491 13 but but CC 40436 1491 14 such such JJ 40436 1491 15 is be VBZ 40436 1491 16 not not RB 40436 1491 17 the the DT 40436 1491 18 language language NN 40436 1491 19 which which WDT 40436 1491 20 men man NNS 40436 1491 21 commonly commonly RB 40436 1491 22 use use VBP 40436 1491 23 . . . 40436 1492 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1492 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 1492 3 men man NNS 40436 1492 4 ? ? . 40436 1493 1 the the DT 40436 1493 2 knowing knowing NN 40436 1493 3 ? ? . 40436 1494 1 or or CC 40436 1494 2 the the DT 40436 1494 3 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 1494 4 ? ? . 40436 1495 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1495 2 Hip._--The Hip._--The NNP 40436 1495 3 Many many JJ 40436 1495 4 . . . 40436 1496 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1496 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 1496 3 Many many JJ 40436 1496 4 ; ; : 40436 1496 5 is be VBZ 40436 1496 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1496 7 _ _ IN 40436 1496 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1496 9 _ _ NNP 40436 1496 10 who who WP 40436 1496 11 know know VBP 40436 1496 12 what what WP 40436 1496 13 truth truth NN 40436 1496 14 is be VBZ 40436 1496 15 ? ? . 40436 1497 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1497 2 Hip._--Assuredly hip._--assuredly RB 40436 1497 3 not not RB 40436 1497 4 . . . 40436 1498 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1498 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 1498 3 surely surely RB 40436 1498 4 those those DT 40436 1498 5 who who WP 40436 1498 6 do do VBP 40436 1498 7 know know VB 40436 1498 8 , , , 40436 1498 9 account account VBP 40436 1498 10 the the DT 40436 1498 11 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1498 12 to to TO 40436 1498 13 be be VB 40436 1498 14 in in IN 40436 1498 15 truth truth NN 40436 1498 16 more more RBR 40436 1498 17 lawful lawful JJ 40436 1498 18 than than IN 40436 1498 19 the the DT 40436 1498 20 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 1498 21 , , , 40436 1498 22 to to IN 40436 1498 23 all all DT 40436 1498 24 men man NNS 40436 1498 25 . . . 40436 1499 1 Do do VBP 40436 1499 2 n't not RB 40436 1499 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1499 4 admit admit VB 40436 1499 5 this this DT 40436 1499 6 ? ? . 40436 1500 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1500 2 Hip._--Yes Hip._--Yes NNP 40436 1500 3 , , , 40436 1500 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1500 5 admit admit VBP 40436 1500 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1500 7 account account VBP 40436 1500 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1500 9 so so RB 40436 1500 10 in in IN 40436 1500 11 truth truth NN 40436 1500 12 . . . 40436 1501 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1501 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 1501 3 , , , 40436 1501 4 and and CC 40436 1501 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1501 6 is be VBZ 40436 1501 7 so so RB 40436 1501 8 , , , 40436 1501 9 too too RB 40436 1501 10 : : : 40436 1501 11 the the DT 40436 1501 12 truth truth NN 40436 1501 13 is be VBZ 40436 1501 14 as as IN 40436 1501 15 the the DT 40436 1501 16 knowing know VBG 40436 1501 17 men man NNS 40436 1501 18 account account VBP 40436 1501 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1501 20 . . . 40436 1502 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1502 2 Hip._--Most hip._--most UH 40436 1502 3 certainly certainly RB 40436 1502 4 . . . 40436 1503 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1503 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 1503 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1503 4 affirm affirm VBP 40436 1503 5 , , , 40436 1503 6 that that IN 40436 1503 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1503 8 is be VBZ 40436 1503 9 more more RBR 40436 1503 10 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1503 11 to to IN 40436 1503 12 the the DT 40436 1503 13 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1503 14 to to TO 40436 1503 15 be be VB 40436 1503 16 educated educate VBN 40436 1503 17 according accord VBG 40436 1503 18 to to IN 40436 1503 19 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1503 20 scheme scheme NN 40436 1503 21 , , , 40436 1503 22 foreign foreign JJ 40436 1503 23 as as IN 40436 1503 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1503 25 is be VBZ 40436 1503 26 , , , 40436 1503 27 than than IN 40436 1503 28 according accord VBG 40436 1503 29 to to IN 40436 1503 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1503 31 own own JJ 40436 1503 32 native native JJ 40436 1503 33 scheme scheme NN 40436 1503 34 . . . 40436 1504 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1504 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 1504 3 affirm affirm VBP 40436 1504 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1504 5 , , , 40436 1504 6 and and CC 40436 1504 7 with with IN 40436 1504 8 truth truth NN 40436 1504 9 too too RB 40436 1504 10 . . . 40436 1505 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1505 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 1505 3 affirm affirm NN 40436 1505 4 besides besides RB 40436 1505 5 , , , 40436 1505 6 that that IN 40436 1505 7 things thing NNS 40436 1505 8 more more RBR 40436 1505 9 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1505 10 are be VBP 40436 1505 11 at at IN 40436 1505 12 the the DT 40436 1505 13 same same JJ 40436 1505 14 time time NN 40436 1505 15 more more RBR 40436 1505 16 lawful lawful JJ 40436 1505 17 ? ? . 40436 1506 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1506 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 1506 3 said say VBD 40436 1506 4 so so RB 40436 1506 5 . . . 40436 1507 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1507 2 Sokr._--According sokr._--according IN 40436 1507 3 to to IN 40436 1507 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1507 5 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 1507 6 , , , 40436 1507 7 then then RB 40436 1507 8 , , , 40436 1507 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1507 10 is be VBZ 40436 1507 11 more more RBR 40436 1507 12 lawful lawful JJ 40436 1507 13 for for IN 40436 1507 14 the the DT 40436 1507 15 Spartan spartan JJ 40436 1507 16 children child NNS 40436 1507 17 to to TO 40436 1507 18 be be VB 40436 1507 19 educated educate VBN 40436 1507 20 by by IN 40436 1507 21 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1507 22 , , , 40436 1507 23 and and CC 40436 1507 24 more more RBR 40436 1507 25 unlawful unlawful JJ 40436 1507 26 for for IN 40436 1507 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1507 28 to to TO 40436 1507 29 be be VB 40436 1507 30 educated educate VBN 40436 1507 31 by by IN 40436 1507 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1507 33 fathers-- fathers-- NN 40436 1507 34 if if IN 40436 1507 35 in in IN 40436 1507 36 reality reality NN 40436 1507 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1507 38 will will MD 40436 1507 39 be be VB 40436 1507 40 more more RBR 40436 1507 41 benefited benefit VBN 40436 1507 42 by by IN 40436 1507 43 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1507 44 ? ? . 40436 1508 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1508 2 Hip._--But Hip._--But NNP 40436 1508 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1508 4 will will MD 40436 1508 5 be be VB 40436 1508 6 more more RBR 40436 1508 7 benefited benefit VBN 40436 1508 8 by by IN 40436 1508 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1508 10 . . . 40436 1509 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1509 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 1509 3 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1509 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 1509 5 act act VBP 40436 1509 6 unlawfully unlawfully RB 40436 1509 7 , , , 40436 1509 8 when when WRB 40436 1509 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1509 10 refuse refuse VBP 40436 1509 11 to to TO 40436 1509 12 give give VB 40436 1509 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1509 14 money money NN 40436 1509 15 and and CC 40436 1509 16 to to TO 40436 1509 17 confide confide VB 40436 1509 18 to to IN 40436 1509 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1509 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1509 21 sons son NNS 40436 1509 22 ? ? . 40436 1510 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1510 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 1510 3 admit admit VBP 40436 1510 4 that that IN 40436 1510 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1510 6 do do VBP 40436 1510 7 : : : 40436 1510 8 indeed indeed RB 40436 1510 9 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1510 10 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 1510 11 seems seem VBZ 40436 1510 12 to to TO 40436 1510 13 make make VB 40436 1510 14 in in IN 40436 1510 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1510 16 favour favour NN 40436 1510 17 , , , 40436 1510 18 so so IN 40436 1510 19 that that IN 40436 1510 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1510 21 am be VBP 40436 1510 22 noway noway RB 40436 1510 23 called call VBN 40436 1510 24 upon upon IN 40436 1510 25 to to TO 40436 1510 26 resist resist VB 40436 1510 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1510 28 . . . 40436 1511 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1511 2 Sokr._--We Sokr._--We NNP 40436 1511 3 find find VBP 40436 1511 4 then then RB 40436 1511 5 , , , 40436 1511 6 after after RB 40436 1511 7 all all RB 40436 1511 8 , , , 40436 1511 9 that that IN 40436 1511 10 the the DT 40436 1511 11 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1511 12 are be VBP 40436 1511 13 enemies enemy NNS 40436 1511 14 of of IN 40436 1511 15 law law NN 40436 1511 16 , , , 40436 1511 17 and and CC 40436 1511 18 that that IN 40436 1511 19 too too RB 40436 1511 20 in in IN 40436 1511 21 the the DT 40436 1511 22 most most RBS 40436 1511 23 important important JJ 40436 1511 24 matters matter NNS 40436 1511 25 -- -- : 40436 1511 26 though though IN 40436 1511 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1511 28 are be VBP 40436 1511 29 esteemed esteem VBN 40436 1511 30 the the DT 40436 1511 31 most most RBS 40436 1511 32 exemplary exemplary JJ 40436 1511 33 followers follower NNS 40436 1511 34 of of IN 40436 1511 35 law law NN 40436 1511 36 . . . 40436 1512 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1512 2 8 8 CD 40436 1512 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1512 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1512 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1512 6 7 7 CD 40436 1512 7 : : : 40436 1512 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1512 9 , , , 40436 1512 10 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1512 11 . . . 40436 1513 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1513 2 . . NNP 40436 1513 3 284 284 CD 40436 1513 4 C C NNP 40436 1513 5 - - HYPH 40436 1513 6 B. B. NNP 40436 1513 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1514 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1514 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1514 3 8 8 CD 40436 1514 4 : : : 40436 1514 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1514 6 , , , 40436 1514 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1514 8 . . . 40436 1515 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1515 2 . . . 40436 1516 1 285 285 CD 40436 1516 2 . . . 40436 1516 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1517 1 * * NFP 40436 1517 2 * * NFP 40436 1517 3 * * NFP 40436 1517 4 * * NFP 40436 1517 5 * * NFP 40436 1517 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1517 7 Side side NN 40436 1517 8 - - HYPH 40436 1517 9 note note NN 40436 1517 10 : : : 40436 1517 11 Comparison comparison NN 40436 1517 12 of of IN 40436 1517 13 the the DT 40436 1517 14 argument argument NN 40436 1517 15 of of IN 40436 1517 16 the the DT 40436 1517 17 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1517 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1517 19 with with IN 40436 1517 20 that that DT 40436 1517 21 of of IN 40436 1517 22 the the DT 40436 1517 23 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1517 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1517 25 . . . 40436 1517 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1518 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 40436 1518 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1518 3 intended intend VBD 40436 1518 4 the the DT 40436 1518 5 above above JJ 40436 1518 6 argument argument NN 40436 1518 7 as as IN 40436 1518 8 a a DT 40436 1518 9 derisory derisory JJ 40436 1518 10 taunt taunt NN 40436 1518 11 against against IN 40436 1518 12 the the DT 40436 1518 13 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 1518 14 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1518 15 , , , 40436 1518 16 for for IN 40436 1518 17 being be VBG 40436 1518 18 vain vain JJ 40436 1518 19 enough enough RB 40436 1518 20 to to TO 40436 1518 21 think think VB 40436 1518 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1518 23 own own JJ 40436 1518 24 tuition tuition NN 40436 1518 25 better well JJR 40436 1518 26 than than IN 40436 1518 27 that that DT 40436 1518 28 of of IN 40436 1518 29 the the DT 40436 1518 30 Spartan Spartan NNP 40436 1518 31 community community NN 40436 1518 32 . . . 40436 1519 1 If if IN 40436 1519 2 such such JJ 40436 1519 3 was be VBD 40436 1519 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1519 5 intention intention NN 40436 1519 6 , , , 40436 1519 7 the the DT 40436 1519 8 argument argument NN 40436 1519 9 might may MD 40436 1519 10 have have VB 40436 1519 11 been be VBN 40436 1519 12 retorted retort VBN 40436 1519 13 against against IN 40436 1519 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1519 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1519 16 , , , 40436 1519 17 for for IN 40436 1519 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1519 19 propositions proposition NNS 40436 1519 20 in in IN 40436 1519 21 the the DT 40436 1519 22 Republic Republic NNP 40436 1519 23 and and CC 40436 1519 24 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 1519 25 : : : 40436 1519 26 and and CC 40436 1519 27 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1519 28 know know VBP 40436 1519 29 that that IN 40436 1519 30 the the DT 40436 1519 31 enemies enemy NNS 40436 1519 32 of of IN 40436 1519 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1519 34 did do VBD 40436 1519 35 taunt taunt VB 40436 1519 36 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1519 37 with with IN 40436 1519 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1519 39 inability inability NN 40436 1519 40 to to TO 40436 1519 41 get get VB 40436 1519 42 these these DT 40436 1519 43 schemes scheme NNS 40436 1519 44 adopted adopt VBN 40436 1519 45 in in IN 40436 1519 46 any any DT 40436 1519 47 actual actual JJ 40436 1519 48 community community NN 40436 1519 49 . . . 40436 1520 1 But but CC 40436 1520 2 the the DT 40436 1520 3 argument argument NN 40436 1520 4 becomes become VBZ 40436 1520 5 interesting interesting JJ 40436 1520 6 when when WRB 40436 1520 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1520 8 compare compare VBP 40436 1520 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1520 10 with with IN 40436 1520 11 the the DT 40436 1520 12 debate debate NN 40436 1520 13 before before IN 40436 1520 14 referred refer VBN 40436 1520 15 to to IN 40436 1520 16 in in IN 40436 1520 17 the the DT 40436 1520 18 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1520 19 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1520 20 , , , 40436 1520 21 where where WRB 40436 1520 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1520 23 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 1520 24 against against IN 40436 1520 25 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1520 26 that that IN 40436 1520 27 the the DT 40436 1520 28 Just just RB 40436 1520 29 is be VBZ 40436 1520 30 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 1520 31 to to IN 40436 1520 32 the the DT 40436 1520 33 Lawful Lawful NNP 40436 1520 34 . . . 40436 1521 1 In in IN 40436 1521 2 that that DT 40436 1521 3 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 1521 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1521 5 , , , 40436 1521 6 all all PDT 40436 1521 7 the the DT 40436 1521 8 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 1521 9 which which WDT 40436 1521 10 embarrass embarrass VBP 40436 1521 11 this this DT 40436 1521 12 explanation explanation NN 40436 1521 13 are be VBP 40436 1521 14 kept keep VBN 40436 1521 15 out out IN 40436 1521 16 of of IN 40436 1521 17 sight sight NN 40436 1521 18 , , , 40436 1521 19 and and CC 40436 1521 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1521 21 is be VBZ 40436 1521 22 represented represent VBN 40436 1521 23 as as IN 40436 1521 24 gaining gain VBG 40436 1521 25 an an DT 40436 1521 26 easy easy JJ 40436 1521 27 victory victory NN 40436 1521 28 over over IN 40436 1521 29 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1521 30 . . . 40436 1522 1 In in IN 40436 1522 2 this this DT 40436 1522 3 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1522 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1522 5 , , , 40436 1522 6 the the DT 40436 1522 7 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 1522 8 use use NN 40436 1522 9 of of IN 40436 1522 10 the the DT 40436 1522 11 word word NN 40436 1522 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1522 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1522 14 : : : 40436 1522 15 no no DT 40436 1522 16 / / SYM 40436 1522 17 mimon mimon NN 40436 1522 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1522 19 is be VBZ 40436 1522 20 expressly expressly RB 40436 1522 21 adverted advert VBN 40436 1522 22 to to IN 40436 1522 23 , , , 40436 1522 24 and and CC 40436 1522 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1522 26 reduces reduce VBZ 40436 1522 27 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1522 28 to to IN 40436 1522 29 a a DT 40436 1522 30 supposed suppose VBN 40436 1522 31 absurdity absurdity NN 40436 1522 32 , , , 40436 1522 33 by by IN 40436 1522 34 making make VBG 40436 1522 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1522 36 pronounce pronounce NN 40436 1522 37 the the DT 40436 1522 38 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1522 39 to to TO 40436 1522 40 be be VB 40436 1522 41 enemies enemy NNS 40436 1522 42 of of IN 40436 1522 43 law law NN 40436 1522 44 : : : 40436 1522 45 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1522 46 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1522 47 : : : 40436 1522 48 paranomou paranomou NN 40436 1522 49 / / SYM 40436 1522 50 s s POS 40436 1522 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1522 52 bearing bear VBG 40436 1522 53 a a DT 40436 1522 54 double double JJ 40436 1522 55 sense sense NN 40436 1522 56 , , , 40436 1522 57 and and CC 40436 1522 58 the the DT 40436 1522 59 proposition proposition NN 40436 1522 60 being be VBG 40436 1522 61 true true JJ 40436 1522 62 in in IN 40436 1522 63 one one CD 40436 1522 64 sense sense NN 40436 1522 65 , , , 40436 1522 66 false false JJ 40436 1522 67 in in IN 40436 1522 68 the the DT 40436 1522 69 other other JJ 40436 1522 70 . . . 40436 1523 1 In in IN 40436 1523 2 the the DT 40436 1523 3 argument argument NN 40436 1523 4 of of IN 40436 1523 5 the the DT 40436 1523 6 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1523 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1523 8 , , , 40436 1523 9 a a DT 40436 1523 10 law law NN 40436 1523 11 which which WDT 40436 1523 12 does do VBZ 40436 1523 13 not not RB 40436 1523 14 attain attain VB 40436 1523 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1523 16 intended intended JJ 40436 1523 17 purpose purpose NN 40436 1523 18 of of IN 40436 1523 19 benefiting benefit VBG 40436 1523 20 the the DT 40436 1523 21 community community NN 40436 1523 22 , , , 40436 1523 23 is be VBZ 40436 1523 24 no no DT 40436 1523 25 law law NN 40436 1523 26 at at IN 40436 1523 27 all,--not all,--not NNP 40436 1523 28 lawful:[9 lawful:[9 NN 40436 1523 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1523 30 so so IN 40436 1523 31 that that IN 40436 1523 32 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1523 33 are be VBP 40436 1523 34 driven drive VBN 40436 1523 35 back back RB 40436 1523 36 again again RB 40436 1523 37 upon upon IN 40436 1523 38 the the DT 40436 1523 39 objections objection NNS 40436 1523 40 of of IN 40436 1523 41 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 1523 42 against against IN 40436 1523 43 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 1523 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1523 45 in in IN 40436 1523 46 the the DT 40436 1523 47 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1523 48 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1523 49 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1523 50 in in IN 40436 1523 51 regard regard NN 40436 1523 52 to to IN 40436 1523 53 what what WP 40436 1523 54 constitutes constitute VBZ 40436 1523 55 a a DT 40436 1523 56 law law NN 40436 1523 57 . . . 40436 1524 1 In in IN 40436 1524 2 the the DT 40436 1524 3 argument argument NN 40436 1524 4 of of IN 40436 1524 5 the the DT 40436 1524 6 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1524 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1524 8 , , , 40436 1524 9 law law NN 40436 1524 10 means mean VBZ 40436 1524 11 a a DT 40436 1524 12 law law NN 40436 1524 13 actually actually RB 40436 1524 14 established establish VBN 40436 1524 15 , , , 40436 1524 16 by by IN 40436 1524 17 official official JJ 40436 1524 18 authority authority NN 40436 1524 19 or or CC 40436 1524 20 custom custom NN 40436 1524 21 -- -- : 40436 1524 22 and and CC 40436 1524 23 the the DT 40436 1524 24 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1524 25 are be VBP 40436 1524 26 produced produce VBN 40436 1524 27 as as IN 40436 1524 28 eminent eminent JJ 40436 1524 29 examples example NNS 40436 1524 30 of of IN 40436 1524 31 a a DT 40436 1524 32 lawfully lawfully RB 40436 1524 33 minded minded JJ 40436 1524 34 community community NN 40436 1524 35 . . . 40436 1525 1 As as RB 40436 1525 2 far far RB 40436 1525 3 as as IN 40436 1525 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1525 5 can can MD 40436 1525 6 assign assign VB 40436 1525 7 positive positive JJ 40436 1525 8 opinion opinion NN 40436 1525 9 to to IN 40436 1525 10 the the DT 40436 1525 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1525 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1525 13 in in IN 40436 1525 14 the the DT 40436 1525 15 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1525 16 Major Major NNP 40436 1525 17 , , , 40436 1525 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1525 19 declares declare VBZ 40436 1525 20 that that IN 40436 1525 21 the the DT 40436 1525 22 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1525 23 or or CC 40436 1525 24 useful useful JJ 40436 1525 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1525 26 being be VBG 40436 1525 27 that that DT 40436 1525 28 which which WDT 40436 1525 29 men man NNS 40436 1525 30 always always RB 40436 1525 31 aim aim VBP 40436 1525 32 at at IN 40436 1525 33 in in IN 40436 1525 34 making make VBG 40436 1525 35 law law NN 40436 1525 36 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1525 37 is be VBZ 40436 1525 38 The the DT 40436 1525 39 Lawful Lawful NNP 40436 1525 40 , , , 40436 1525 41 whether whether IN 40436 1525 42 actually actually RB 40436 1525 43 established establish VBN 40436 1525 44 or or CC 40436 1525 45 not not RB 40436 1525 46 : : : 40436 1525 47 and and CC 40436 1525 48 that that IN 40436 1525 49 the the DT 40436 1525 50 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 1525 51 or or CC 40436 1525 52 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 1525 53 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1525 54 being be VBG 40436 1525 55 that that DT 40436 1525 56 which which WDT 40436 1525 57 men man NNS 40436 1525 58 always always RB 40436 1525 59 intend intend VBP 40436 1525 60 to to TO 40436 1525 61 escape escape VB 40436 1525 62 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1525 63 is be VBZ 40436 1525 64 The the DT 40436 1525 65 Unlawful unlawful JJ 40436 1525 66 , , , 40436 1525 67 whether whether IN 40436 1525 68 prescribed prescribe VBN 40436 1525 69 by by IN 40436 1525 70 any any DT 40436 1525 71 living living NN 40436 1525 72 authority authority NN 40436 1525 73 or or CC 40436 1525 74 not not RB 40436 1525 75 . . . 40436 1526 1 This this DT 40436 1526 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1526 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1526 4 says say VBZ 40436 1526 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1526 6 is be VBZ 40436 1526 7 the the DT 40436 1526 8 opinion opinion NN 40436 1526 9 of of IN 40436 1526 10 the the DT 40436 1526 11 wise wise JJ 40436 1526 12 men man NNS 40436 1526 13 who who WP 40436 1526 14 know know VBP 40436 1526 15 : : : 40436 1526 16 though though IN 40436 1526 17 the the DT 40436 1526 18 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 1526 19 vulgar vulgar NNP 40436 1526 20 hold hold VB 40436 1526 21 the the DT 40436 1526 22 contrary contrary JJ 40436 1526 23 opinion opinion NN 40436 1526 24 . . . 40436 1527 1 The the DT 40436 1527 2 explanation explanation NN 40436 1527 3 of of IN 40436 1527 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1527 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1527 6 : : : 40436 1527 7 to\ to\ NN 40436 1527 8 di di NNP 40436 1527 9 / / SYM 40436 1527 10 kaion kaion NN 40436 1527 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1527 12 given give VBN 40436 1527 13 by by IN 40436 1527 14 the the DT 40436 1527 15 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1527 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1527 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1527 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1527 19 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1527 20 : : : 40436 1527 21 to\ to\ NN 40436 1527 22 di di NNP 40436 1527 23 / / SYM 40436 1527 24 kaion kaion NN 40436 1527 25 = = SYM 40436 1527 26 to\ to\ NN 40436 1527 27 no no NNP 40436 1527 28 / / SYM 40436 1527 29 mimon mimon NN 40436 1527 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1527 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1527 32 , , , 40436 1527 33 would would MD 40436 1527 34 be be VB 40436 1527 35 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 1527 36 , , , 40436 1527 37 if if IN 40436 1527 38 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1527 39 construe construe VBP 40436 1527 40 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1527 41 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1527 42 : : : 40436 1527 43 to\ to\ NN 40436 1527 44 no no DT 40436 1527 45 / / SYM 40436 1527 46 mimon mimon NN 40436 1527 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1527 48 in in IN 40436 1527 49 the the DT 40436 1527 50 sense sense NN 40436 1527 51 of of IN 40436 1527 52 the the DT 40436 1527 53 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1527 54 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1527 55 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1527 56 in in IN 40436 1527 57 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1527 58 Major Major NNP 40436 1527 59 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1527 60 as as IN 40436 1527 61 an an DT 40436 1527 62 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 1527 63 that that IN 40436 1527 64 The the DT 40436 1527 65 Just Just NNP 40436 1527 66 was be VBD 40436 1527 67 the the DT 40436 1527 68 generally generally RB 40436 1527 69 useful--[Greek useful--[greek CD 40436 1527 70 : : : 40436 1527 71 To\ To\ NNP 40436 1527 72 di di NNP 40436 1527 73 / / SYM 40436 1527 74 kaion kaion NN 40436 1527 75 = = SYM 40436 1527 76 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1527 77 koinê=| koinê=| NNP 40436 1527 78 su su NNP 40436 1527 79 / / SYM 40436 1527 80 mphoron mphoron NNP 40436 1527 81 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1527 82 . . . 40436 1528 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1528 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1528 3 9 9 CD 40436 1528 4 : : : 40436 1528 5 Compare compare VB 40436 1528 6 a a DT 40436 1528 7 similar similar JJ 40436 1528 8 argument argument NN 40436 1528 9 of of IN 40436 1528 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1528 11 against against IN 40436 1528 12 Thrasymachus Thrasymachus NNP 40436 1528 13 -- -- : 40436 1528 14 Republic Republic NNP 40436 1528 15 , , , 40436 1528 16 i. i. NNP 40436 1529 1 339 339 CD 40436 1529 2 . . . 40436 1529 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1530 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1530 2 Side side NN 40436 1530 3 - - HYPH 40436 1530 4 note note NN 40436 1530 5 : : : 40436 1530 6 The the DT 40436 1530 7 Just just JJ 40436 1530 8 or or CC 40436 1530 9 Good good JJ 40436 1530 10 is be VBZ 40436 1530 11 the the DT 40436 1530 12 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 1530 13 or or CC 40436 1530 14 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1530 15 . . . 40436 1531 1 This this DT 40436 1531 2 is be VBZ 40436 1531 3 the the DT 40436 1531 4 only only JJ 40436 1531 5 explanation explanation NN 40436 1531 6 which which WDT 40436 1531 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1531 8 ever ever RB 40436 1531 9 gives give VBZ 40436 1531 10 and and CC 40436 1531 11 to to IN 40436 1531 12 this this DT 40436 1531 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1531 14 does do VBZ 40436 1531 15 not not RB 40436 1531 16 always always RB 40436 1531 17 adhere adhere VB 40436 1531 18 . . . 40436 1531 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1532 1 There there EX 40436 1532 2 exists exist VBZ 40436 1532 3 however however RB 40436 1532 4 in in IN 40436 1532 5 all all PDT 40436 1532 6 this this DT 40436 1532 7 , , , 40436 1532 8 a a DT 40436 1532 9 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 1532 10 confusion confusion NN 40436 1532 11 between between IN 40436 1532 12 Law Law NNP 40436 1532 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1532 14 or or CC 40436 1532 15 the the DT 40436 1532 16 Lawful Lawful NNP 40436 1532 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1532 18 as as IN 40436 1532 19 actually actually RB 40436 1532 20 established establish VBN 40436 1532 21 , , , 40436 1532 22 and and CC 40436 1532 23 Law Law NNP 40436 1532 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1532 25 or or CC 40436 1532 26 the the DT 40436 1532 27 Lawful Lawful NNP 40436 1532 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1532 29 as as IN 40436 1532 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1532 31 ought ought MD 40436 1532 32 to to TO 40436 1532 33 be be VB 40436 1532 34 established establish VBN 40436 1532 35 , , , 40436 1532 36 in in IN 40436 1532 37 the the DT 40436 1532 38 judgment judgment NN 40436 1532 39 of of IN 40436 1532 40 the the DT 40436 1532 41 critic critic NN 40436 1532 42 , , , 40436 1532 43 or or CC 40436 1532 44 of of IN 40436 1532 45 those those DT 40436 1532 46 whom whom WP 40436 1532 47 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1532 48 follows follow VBZ 40436 1532 49 : : : 40436 1532 50 that that DT 40436 1532 51 is be VBZ 40436 1532 52 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1532 53 to to TO 40436 1532 54 use use VB 40436 1532 55 the the DT 40436 1532 56 phrase phrase NN 40436 1532 57 of of IN 40436 1532 58 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 1532 59 Austin Austin NNP 40436 1532 60 in in IN 40436 1532 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1532 62 ' ' `` 40436 1532 63 Province Province NNP 40436 1532 64 of of IN 40436 1532 65 Jurisprudence Jurisprudence NNP 40436 1532 66 ' ' '' 40436 1532 67 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1532 68 Law Law NNP 40436 1532 69 as as IN 40436 1532 70 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1532 71 would would MD 40436 1532 72 be be VB 40436 1532 73 , , , 40436 1532 74 if if IN 40436 1532 75 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1532 76 conformed conform VBD 40436 1532 77 to to IN 40436 1532 78 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1532 79 assumed assumed JJ 40436 1532 80 measure measure NN 40436 1532 81 or or CC 40436 1532 82 test test NN 40436 1532 83 . . . 40436 1533 1 In in IN 40436 1533 2 the the DT 40436 1533 3 first first JJ 40436 1533 4 of of IN 40436 1533 5 these these DT 40436 1533 6 senses sense NNS 40436 1533 7 , , , 40436 1533 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1533 9 Greek greek JJ 40436 1533 10 : : : 40436 1533 11 to\ to\ NN 40436 1533 12 no no DT 40436 1533 13 / / SYM 40436 1533 14 mimon mimon NN 40436 1533 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1533 16 is be VBZ 40436 1533 17 not not RB 40436 1533 18 one one CD 40436 1533 19 and and CC 40436 1533 20 the the DT 40436 1533 21 same same JJ 40436 1533 22 , , , 40436 1533 23 but but CC 40436 1533 24 variable variable JJ 40436 1533 25 according accord VBG 40436 1533 26 to to IN 40436 1533 27 place place NN 40436 1533 28 and and CC 40436 1533 29 time time NN 40436 1533 30 -- -- : 40436 1533 31 one one CD 40436 1533 32 thing thing NN 40436 1533 33 at at IN 40436 1533 34 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1533 35 , , , 40436 1533 36 another another DT 40436 1533 37 thing thing NN 40436 1533 38 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 1533 39 : : : 40436 1533 40 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 1533 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1533 42 would would MD 40436 1533 43 not not RB 40436 1533 44 satisfy satisfy VB 40436 1533 45 the the DT 40436 1533 46 demand demand NN 40436 1533 47 of of IN 40436 1533 48 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1533 49 's 's POS 40436 1533 50 mind mind NN 40436 1533 51 , , , 40436 1533 52 when when WRB 40436 1533 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1533 54 asks ask VBZ 40436 1533 55 for for IN 40436 1533 56 an an DT 40436 1533 57 explanation explanation NN 40436 1533 58 of of IN 40436 1533 59 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1533 60 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1533 61 : : : 40436 1533 62 to\ to\ NN 40436 1533 63 di di NNP 40436 1533 64 / / SYM 40436 1533 65 kaion kaion NNP 40436 1533 66 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1533 67 . . . 40436 1534 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1534 2 is be VBZ 40436 1534 3 an an DT 40436 1534 4 explanation explanation NN 40436 1534 5 in in IN 40436 1534 6 the the DT 40436 1534 7 second second JJ 40436 1534 8 of of IN 40436 1534 9 the the DT 40436 1534 10 two two CD 40436 1534 11 senses sense NNS 40436 1534 12 which which WDT 40436 1534 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1534 14 seeks seek VBZ 40436 1534 15 -- -- : 40436 1534 16 a a DT 40436 1534 17 common common JJ 40436 1534 18 measure measure NN 40436 1534 19 or or CC 40436 1534 20 test test NN 40436 1534 21 applicable applicable JJ 40436 1534 22 universally universally RB 40436 1534 23 , , , 40436 1534 24 at at IN 40436 1534 25 all all DT 40436 1534 26 times time NNS 40436 1534 27 and and CC 40436 1534 28 places place NNS 40436 1534 29 . . . 40436 1535 1 In in IN 40436 1535 2 so so RB 40436 1535 3 far far RB 40436 1535 4 as as IN 40436 1535 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1535 6 ever ever RB 40436 1535 7 finds find VBZ 40436 1535 8 one one CD 40436 1535 9 , , , 40436 1535 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1535 11 is be VBZ 40436 1535 12 that that DT 40436 1535 13 which which WDT 40436 1535 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1535 15 have have VBP 40436 1535 16 mentioned mention VBN 40436 1535 17 above above RB 40436 1535 18 as as IN 40436 1535 19 delivered deliver VBN 40436 1535 20 by by IN 40436 1535 21 the the DT 40436 1535 22 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1535 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1535 24 in in IN 40436 1535 25 this this DT 40436 1535 26 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1535 27 : : : 40436 1535 28 viz viz NNP 40436 1535 29 . . NNP 40436 1535 30 , , , 40436 1535 31 the the DT 40436 1535 32 Just just JJ 40436 1535 33 or or CC 40436 1535 34 Good good JJ 40436 1535 35 , , , 40436 1535 36 that that IN 40436 1535 37 which which WDT 40436 1535 38 ought ought MD 40436 1535 39 to to TO 40436 1535 40 be be VB 40436 1535 41 the the DT 40436 1535 42 measure measure NN 40436 1535 43 or or CC 40436 1535 44 test test NN 40436 1535 45 of of IN 40436 1535 46 Law Law NNP 40436 1535 47 and and CC 40436 1535 48 Positive Positive NNP 40436 1535 49 Morality Morality NNP 40436 1535 50 , , , 40436 1535 51 is be VBZ 40436 1535 52 , , , 40436 1535 53 the the DT 40436 1535 54 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 1535 55 or or CC 40436 1535 56 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1535 57 . . . 40436 1536 1 This this DT 40436 1536 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1536 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1536 4 repeat repeat VBP 40436 1536 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1536 6 is be VBZ 40436 1536 7 the the DT 40436 1536 8 only only JJ 40436 1536 9 approach approach NN 40436 1536 10 to to IN 40436 1536 11 a a DT 40436 1536 12 solution solution NN 40436 1536 13 which which WDT 40436 1536 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1536 15 ever ever RB 40436 1536 16 find find VBP 40436 1536 17 in in IN 40436 1536 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1536 19 . . . 40436 1537 1 But but CC 40436 1537 2 this this DT 40436 1537 3 is be VBZ 40436 1537 4 seldom seldom RB 40436 1537 5 clearly clearly RB 40436 1537 6 enunciated enunciate VBN 40436 1537 7 , , , 40436 1537 8 never never RB 40436 1537 9 systematically systematically RB 40436 1537 10 followed follow VBD 40436 1537 11 out out RP 40436 1537 12 , , , 40436 1537 13 and and CC 40436 1537 14 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1537 15 , , , 40436 1537 16 in in IN 40436 1537 17 appearance appearance NN 40436 1537 18 , , , 40436 1537 19 even even RB 40436 1537 20 denied deny VBD 40436 1537 21 . . . 40436 1538 1 * * NFP 40436 1538 2 * * NFP 40436 1538 3 * * NFP 40436 1538 4 * * NFP 40436 1538 5 * * NFP 40436 1538 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1538 7 Side side NN 40436 1538 8 - - HYPH 40436 1538 9 note note NN 40436 1538 10 : : : 40436 1538 11 Lectures lecture NNS 40436 1538 12 of of IN 40436 1538 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1538 14 at at IN 40436 1538 15 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1538 16 not not RB 40436 1538 17 upon upon IN 40436 1538 18 geometry geometry NN 40436 1538 19 , , , 40436 1538 20 or or CC 40436 1538 21 astronomy astronomy NNP 40436 1538 22 , , , 40436 1538 23 & & CC 40436 1538 24 c. c. NNP 40436 1538 25 , , , 40436 1538 26 but but CC 40436 1538 27 upon upon IN 40436 1538 28 the the DT 40436 1538 29 question question NN 40436 1538 30 -- -- : 40436 1538 31 What what WDT 40436 1538 32 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 1538 33 are be VBP 40436 1538 34 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1538 35 , , , 40436 1538 36 fine fine JJ 40436 1538 37 , , , 40436 1538 38 and and CC 40436 1538 39 honourable honourable JJ 40436 1538 40 for for IN 40436 1538 41 youth youth NN 40436 1538 42 . . . 40436 1538 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1539 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1539 2 resume resume VBP 40436 1539 3 the the DT 40436 1539 4 thread thread NN 40436 1539 5 of of IN 40436 1539 6 the the DT 40436 1539 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1539 8 Major Major NNP 40436 1539 9 . . . 40436 1540 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1540 2 asks ask VBZ 40436 1540 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1540 4 what what WP 40436 1540 5 sort sort NN 40436 1540 6 of of IN 40436 1540 7 lectures lecture NNS 40436 1540 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1540 9 were be VBD 40436 1540 10 that that IN 40436 1540 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1540 12 delivered deliver VBD 40436 1540 13 with with IN 40436 1540 14 so so RB 40436 1540 15 much much JJ 40436 1540 16 success success NN 40436 1540 17 at at IN 40436 1540 18 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 1540 19 ? ? . 40436 1541 1 The the DT 40436 1541 2 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1541 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1541 4 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1541 5 replies reply NNS 40436 1541 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1541 7 knew know VBD 40436 1541 8 nothing nothing NN 40436 1541 9 and and CC 40436 1541 10 cared care VBD 40436 1541 11 nothing nothing NN 40436 1541 12 about about IN 40436 1541 13 letters letter NNS 40436 1541 14 , , , 40436 1541 15 geometry geometry NN 40436 1541 16 , , , 40436 1541 17 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 1541 18 , , , 40436 1541 19 astronomy astronomy NN 40436 1541 20 : : : 40436 1541 21 but but CC 40436 1541 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1541 23 took take VBD 40436 1541 24 delight delight NN 40436 1541 25 in in IN 40436 1541 26 hearing hear VBG 40436 1541 27 tales tale NNS 40436 1541 28 about about IN 40436 1541 29 heroes hero NNS 40436 1541 30 , , , 40436 1541 31 early early JJ 40436 1541 32 ancestors ancestor NNS 40436 1541 33 , , , 40436 1541 34 foundation foundation NN 40436 1541 35 - - HYPH 40436 1541 36 legends legend NNS 40436 1541 37 of of IN 40436 1541 38 cities city NNS 40436 1541 39 , , , 40436 1541 40 & & CC 40436 1541 41 c. c. NNP 40436 1541 42 , , , 40436 1541 43 which which WDT 40436 1541 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1541 45 mnemonic mnemonic NNP 40436 1541 46 artifice artifice NN 40436 1541 47 enabled enable VBD 40436 1541 48 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1541 49 to to TO 40436 1541 50 deliver deliver VB 40436 1541 51 . . . 40436 1542 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1542 2 10 10 CD 40436 1542 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1542 4 The the DT 40436 1542 5 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1542 6 delight delight NN 40436 1542 7 in in IN 40436 1542 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1542 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1542 10 observes observe VBZ 40436 1542 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1542 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1542 13 as as IN 40436 1542 14 children child NNS 40436 1542 15 delight delight VBP 40436 1542 16 in in IN 40436 1542 17 old old JJ 40436 1542 18 women woman NNS 40436 1542 19 's 's POS 40436 1542 20 tales tale NNS 40436 1542 21 . . . 40436 1543 1 Yes yes UH 40436 1543 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1543 3 replies reply VBZ 40436 1543 4 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1543 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1543 6 , , , 40436 1543 7 but but CC 40436 1543 8 that that DT 40436 1543 9 is be VBZ 40436 1543 10 not not RB 40436 1543 11 all all DT 40436 1543 12 : : : 40436 1543 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1543 14 discoursed discourse VBD 40436 1543 15 to to IN 40436 1543 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1543 17 also also RB 40436 1543 18 , , , 40436 1543 19 recently recently RB 40436 1543 20 , , , 40436 1543 21 about about IN 40436 1543 22 fine fine JJ 40436 1543 23 and and CC 40436 1543 24 honourable honourable JJ 40436 1543 25 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 1543 26 , , , 40436 1543 27 much much RB 40436 1543 28 to to IN 40436 1543 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1543 30 admiration admiration NN 40436 1543 31 : : : 40436 1543 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1543 33 supposed suppose VBD 40436 1543 34 a a DT 40436 1543 35 conversation conversation NN 40436 1543 36 between between IN 40436 1543 37 Nestor Nestor NNP 40436 1543 38 and and CC 40436 1543 39 Neoptolemus Neoptolemus NNP 40436 1543 40 , , , 40436 1543 41 after after IN 40436 1543 42 the the DT 40436 1543 43 capture capture NN 40436 1543 44 of of IN 40436 1543 45 Troy Troy NNP 40436 1543 46 , , , 40436 1543 47 in in IN 40436 1543 48 which which WDT 40436 1543 49 the the DT 40436 1543 50 veteran veteran NN 40436 1543 51 , , , 40436 1543 52 answering answer VBG 40436 1543 53 a a DT 40436 1543 54 question question NN 40436 1543 55 put put VBN 40436 1543 56 by by IN 40436 1543 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1543 58 youthful youthful JJ 40436 1543 59 companion companion NN 40436 1543 60 , , , 40436 1543 61 enlarged enlarge VBN 40436 1543 62 upon upon IN 40436 1543 63 those those DT 40436 1543 64 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 1543 65 which which WDT 40436 1543 66 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1543 67 was be VBD 40436 1543 68 fine fine JJ 40436 1543 69 , , , 40436 1543 70 honourable honourable JJ 40436 1543 71 , , , 40436 1543 72 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1543 73 for for IN 40436 1543 74 a a DT 40436 1543 75 young young JJ 40436 1543 76 man man NN 40436 1543 77 to to TO 40436 1543 78 engage engage VB 40436 1543 79 in in IN 40436 1543 80 . . . 40436 1544 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1544 2 discourse discourse NN 40436 1544 3 is be VBZ 40436 1544 4 excellent excellent JJ 40436 1544 5 , , , 40436 1544 6 and and CC 40436 1544 7 obtained obtain VBN 40436 1544 8 from from IN 40436 1544 9 the the DT 40436 1544 10 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 1544 11 great great JJ 40436 1544 12 applause applause NN 40436 1544 13 . . . 40436 1545 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1545 2 am be VBP 40436 1545 3 going go VBG 40436 1545 4 to to TO 40436 1545 5 deliver deliver VB 40436 1545 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1545 7 again again RB 40436 1545 8 here here RB 40436 1545 9 at at IN 40436 1545 10 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1545 11 , , , 40436 1545 12 in in IN 40436 1545 13 the the DT 40436 1545 14 school school NN 40436 1545 15 - - HYPH 40436 1545 16 room room NN 40436 1545 17 of of IN 40436 1545 18 Pheidostratus Pheidostratus NNP 40436 1545 19 , , , 40436 1545 20 and and CC 40436 1545 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1545 22 invite invite VBP 40436 1545 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1545 24 , , , 40436 1545 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1545 26 , , , 40436 1545 27 to to TO 40436 1545 28 come come VB 40436 1545 29 and and CC 40436 1545 30 hear hear VB 40436 1545 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1545 32 , , , 40436 1545 33 with with IN 40436 1545 34 as as RB 40436 1545 35 many many JJ 40436 1545 36 friends friend NNS 40436 1545 37 as as IN 40436 1545 38 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1545 39 can can MD 40436 1545 40 bring bring VB 40436 1545 41 . . . 40436 1546 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1546 2 11 11 CD 40436 1546 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1546 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1546 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1546 6 10 10 CD 40436 1546 7 : : : 40436 1546 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1546 9 . . . 40436 1547 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1547 2 . . . 40436 1548 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1548 2 . . NNP 40436 1548 3 285 285 CD 40436 1548 4 E. E. NNP 40436 1548 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1548 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1548 7 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1548 8 11 11 CD 40436 1548 9 : : : 40436 1548 10 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1548 11 . . . 40436 1549 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1549 2 . . . 40436 1550 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1550 2 . . NNP 40436 1550 3 286 286 CD 40436 1550 4 A A NNP 40436 1550 5 - - HYPH 40436 1550 6 B. b. NN 40436 1550 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1551 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1551 2 Side side NN 40436 1551 3 - - HYPH 40436 1551 4 note note NN 40436 1551 5 : : : 40436 1551 6 Question question NN 40436 1551 7 put put VBN 40436 1551 8 by by IN 40436 1551 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1551 10 , , , 40436 1551 11 in in IN 40436 1551 12 the the DT 40436 1551 13 name name NN 40436 1551 14 of of IN 40436 1551 15 a a DT 40436 1551 16 friend friend NN 40436 1551 17 in in IN 40436 1551 18 the the DT 40436 1551 19 background background NN 40436 1551 20 , , , 40436 1551 21 who who WP 40436 1551 22 has have VBZ 40436 1551 23 just just RB 40436 1551 24 been be VBN 40436 1551 25 puzzling puzzle VBG 40436 1551 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1551 27 with with IN 40436 1551 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1551 29 -- -- : 40436 1551 30 What what WP 40436 1551 31 is be VBZ 40436 1551 32 the the DT 40436 1551 33 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1551 34 ? ? . 40436 1551 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1552 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1552 2 shall shall MD 40436 1552 3 come come VB 40436 1552 4 willingly willingly RB 40436 1552 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1552 6 replied replied JJ 40436 1552 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1552 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1552 9 . . . 40436 1553 1 But but CC 40436 1553 2 first first RB 40436 1553 3 answer answer VB 40436 1553 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1553 5 one one CD 40436 1553 6 small small JJ 40436 1553 7 question question NN 40436 1553 8 , , , 40436 1553 9 which which WDT 40436 1553 10 will will MD 40436 1553 11 rescue rescue VB 40436 1553 12 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1553 13 from from IN 40436 1553 14 a a DT 40436 1553 15 present present JJ 40436 1553 16 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 1553 17 . . . 40436 1554 1 Just just RB 40436 1554 2 now now RB 40436 1554 3 , , , 40436 1554 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1554 5 was be VBD 40436 1554 6 shamefully shamefully RB 40436 1554 7 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 1554 8 in in IN 40436 1554 9 conversation conversation NN 40436 1554 10 with with IN 40436 1554 11 a a DT 40436 1554 12 friend friend NN 40436 1554 13 , , , 40436 1554 14 to to IN 40436 1554 15 whom whom WP 40436 1554 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1554 17 had have VBD 40436 1554 18 been be VBN 40436 1554 19 praising praise VBG 40436 1554 20 some some DT 40436 1554 21 things thing NNS 40436 1554 22 as as IN 40436 1554 23 honourable honourable JJ 40436 1554 24 and and CC 40436 1554 25 beautiful,--blaming beautiful,--blame VBG 40436 1554 26 other other JJ 40436 1554 27 things thing NNS 40436 1554 28 as as IN 40436 1554 29 mean mean VBP 40436 1554 30 and and CC 40436 1554 31 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1554 32 . . . 40436 1555 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1555 2 surprised surprise VBD 40436 1555 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1555 4 by by IN 40436 1555 5 the the DT 40436 1555 6 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 1555 7 -- -- : 40436 1555 8 How how WRB 40436 1555 9 do do VBP 40436 1555 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1555 11 know know VB 40436 1555 12 , , , 40436 1555 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1555 14 , , , 40436 1555 15 what what WP 40436 1555 16 things thing NNS 40436 1555 17 are be VBP 40436 1555 18 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1555 19 , , , 40436 1555 20 and and CC 40436 1555 21 what what WP 40436 1555 22 are be VBP 40436 1555 23 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1555 24 ? ? . 40436 1556 1 Come come VB 40436 1556 2 now now RB 40436 1556 3 , , , 40436 1556 4 can can MD 40436 1556 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1556 6 tell tell VB 40436 1556 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1556 8 , , , 40436 1556 9 What what WP 40436 1556 10 is be VBZ 40436 1556 11 the the DT 40436 1556 12 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1556 13 ? ? . 40436 1557 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1557 2 , , , 40436 1557 3 in in IN 40436 1557 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1557 5 stupidity stupidity NN 40436 1557 6 , , , 40436 1557 7 was be VBD 40436 1557 8 altogether altogether RB 40436 1557 9 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 1557 10 , , , 40436 1557 11 and and CC 40436 1557 12 could could MD 40436 1557 13 not not RB 40436 1557 14 answer answer VB 40436 1557 15 the the DT 40436 1557 16 question question NN 40436 1557 17 . . . 40436 1558 1 But but CC 40436 1558 2 after after IN 40436 1558 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 4 had have VBD 40436 1558 5 parted part VBN 40436 1558 6 from from IN 40436 1558 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 8 , , , 40436 1558 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 10 became become VBD 40436 1558 11 mortified mortified JJ 40436 1558 12 and and CC 40436 1558 13 angry angry JJ 40436 1558 14 with with IN 40436 1558 15 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 16 ; ; : 40436 1558 17 and and CC 40436 1558 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 19 vowed vow VBD 40436 1558 20 that that IN 40436 1558 21 the the DT 40436 1558 22 next next JJ 40436 1558 23 time time NN 40436 1558 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 25 met meet VBD 40436 1558 26 any any DT 40436 1558 27 wise wise JJ 40436 1558 28 man man NN 40436 1558 29 , , , 40436 1558 30 like like IN 40436 1558 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 32 , , , 40436 1558 33 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 34 would would MD 40436 1558 35 put put VB 40436 1558 36 the the DT 40436 1558 37 question question NN 40436 1558 38 to to IN 40436 1558 39 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 40 , , , 40436 1558 41 and and CC 40436 1558 42 learn learn VB 40436 1558 43 how how WRB 40436 1558 44 to to TO 40436 1558 45 answer answer VB 40436 1558 46 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 47 ; ; : 40436 1558 48 so so IN 40436 1558 49 that that IN 40436 1558 50 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1558 51 might may MD 40436 1558 52 be be VB 40436 1558 53 able able JJ 40436 1558 54 to to TO 40436 1558 55 renew renew VB 40436 1558 56 the the DT 40436 1558 57 conversation conversation NN 40436 1558 58 with with IN 40436 1558 59 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1558 60 friend friend NN 40436 1558 61 . . . 40436 1559 1 Your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1559 2 coming coming NN 40436 1559 3 here here RB 40436 1559 4 is be VBZ 40436 1559 5 most most JJS 40436 1559 6 opportune opportune JJ 40436 1559 7 . . . 40436 1560 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1560 2 entreat entreat VBP 40436 1560 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1560 4 to to TO 40436 1560 5 answer answer VB 40436 1560 6 and and CC 40436 1560 7 explain explain VB 40436 1560 8 to to IN 40436 1560 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1560 10 clearly clearly RB 40436 1560 11 what what WP 40436 1560 12 the the DT 40436 1560 13 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1560 14 is be VBZ 40436 1560 15 ; ; : 40436 1560 16 in in IN 40436 1560 17 order order NN 40436 1560 18 that that IN 40436 1560 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1560 20 may may MD 40436 1560 21 not not RB 40436 1560 22 again again RB 40436 1560 23 incur incur VB 40436 1560 24 the the DT 40436 1560 25 like like JJ 40436 1560 26 mortification mortification NN 40436 1560 27 . . . 40436 1561 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1561 2 can can MD 40436 1561 3 easily easily RB 40436 1561 4 answer answer VB 40436 1561 5 : : : 40436 1561 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1561 7 is be VBZ 40436 1561 8 a a DT 40436 1561 9 small small JJ 40436 1561 10 matter matter NN 40436 1561 11 for for IN 40436 1561 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1561 13 , , , 40436 1561 14 with with IN 40436 1561 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1561 16 numerous numerous JJ 40436 1561 17 attainments attainment NNS 40436 1561 18 . . . 40436 1562 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1562 2 Side side NN 40436 1562 3 - - HYPH 40436 1562 4 note note NN 40436 1562 5 : : : 40436 1562 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1562 7 thinks think VBZ 40436 1562 8 the the DT 40436 1562 9 question question NN 40436 1562 10 easy easy JJ 40436 1562 11 to to TO 40436 1562 12 answer answer VB 40436 1562 13 . . . 40436 1562 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1563 1 Oh oh UH 40436 1563 2 -- -- : 40436 1563 3 yes yes UH 40436 1563 4 -- -- : 40436 1563 5 a a DT 40436 1563 6 small small JJ 40436 1563 7 matter matter NN 40436 1563 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1563 9 replies reply VBZ 40436 1563 10 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1563 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1563 12 ; ; : 40436 1563 13 the the DT 40436 1563 14 question question NN 40436 1563 15 is be VBZ 40436 1563 16 easy easy JJ 40436 1563 17 to to TO 40436 1563 18 answer answer VB 40436 1563 19 . . . 40436 1564 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1564 2 could could MD 40436 1564 3 teach teach VB 40436 1564 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1564 5 to to TO 40436 1564 6 answer answer VB 40436 1564 7 many many JJ 40436 1564 8 questions question NNS 40436 1564 9 harder hard RBR 40436 1564 10 than than IN 40436 1564 11 that that DT 40436 1564 12 : : : 40436 1564 13 so so IN 40436 1564 14 that that IN 40436 1564 15 no no DT 40436 1564 16 man man NN 40436 1564 17 shall shall MD 40436 1564 18 be be VB 40436 1564 19 able able JJ 40436 1564 20 to to TO 40436 1564 21 convict convict VB 40436 1564 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1564 23 in in IN 40436 1564 24 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1564 25 . . . 40436 1565 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1565 2 12 12 CD 40436 1565 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1565 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1565 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1565 6 12 12 CD 40436 1565 7 : : : 40436 1565 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1565 9 . . . 40436 1566 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1566 2 . . . 40436 1567 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1567 2 . . NNP 40436 1567 3 286 286 CD 40436 1567 4 C C NNP 40436 1567 5 - - HYPH 40436 1567 6 D. D. NNP 40436 1567 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1567 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1567 9 then then RB 40436 1567 10 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 1567 11 to to IN 40436 1567 12 interrogate interrogate JJ 40436 1567 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1567 14 , , , 40436 1567 15 in in IN 40436 1567 16 the the DT 40436 1567 17 name name NN 40436 1567 18 of of IN 40436 1567 19 the the DT 40436 1567 20 absentee absentee NN 40436 1567 21 , , , 40436 1567 22 starting start VBG 40436 1567 23 one one CD 40436 1567 24 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 1567 25 after after IN 40436 1567 26 another another DT 40436 1567 27 as as IN 40436 1567 28 if if IN 40436 1567 29 suggested suggest VBN 40436 1567 30 by by IN 40436 1567 31 this this DT 40436 1567 32 unknown unknown JJ 40436 1567 33 prompter prompter NN 40436 1567 34 , , , 40436 1567 35 and and CC 40436 1567 36 pretending pretend VBG 40436 1567 37 to to TO 40436 1567 38 be be VB 40436 1567 39 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1567 40 under under IN 40436 1567 41 awe awe NN 40436 1567 42 of of IN 40436 1567 43 so so RB 40436 1567 44 impracticable impracticable JJ 40436 1567 45 a a DT 40436 1567 46 disputant disputant NN 40436 1567 47 . . . 40436 1568 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1568 2 Side side NN 40436 1568 3 - - HYPH 40436 1568 4 note note NN 40436 1568 5 : : : 40436 1568 6 Justice Justice NNP 40436 1568 7 , , , 40436 1568 8 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 40436 1568 9 , , , 40436 1568 10 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1568 11 must must MD 40436 1568 12 each each DT 40436 1568 13 be be VB 40436 1568 14 something something NN 40436 1568 15 . . . 40436 1569 1 What what WP 40436 1569 2 is be VBZ 40436 1569 3 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1569 4 , , , 40436 1569 5 or or CC 40436 1569 6 the the DT 40436 1569 7 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1569 8 ? ? . 40436 1569 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1570 1 All all DT 40436 1570 2 persons person NNS 40436 1570 3 are be VBP 40436 1570 4 just just RB 40436 1570 5 , , , 40436 1570 6 through through IN 40436 1570 7 Justice Justice NNP 40436 1570 8 -- -- : 40436 1570 9 wise wise JJ 40436 1570 10 , , , 40436 1570 11 through through IN 40436 1570 12 Wisdom wisdom NN 40436 1570 13 -- -- : 40436 1570 14 good good JJ 40436 1570 15 , , , 40436 1570 16 through through IN 40436 1570 17 Goodness Goodness NNP 40436 1570 18 or or CC 40436 1570 19 the the DT 40436 1570 20 Good good JJ 40436 1570 21 -- -- : 40436 1570 22 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1570 23 , , , 40436 1570 24 through through IN 40436 1570 25 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1570 26 or or CC 40436 1570 27 the the DT 40436 1570 28 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1570 29 . . . 40436 1571 1 Now now RB 40436 1571 2 Justice Justice NNP 40436 1571 3 , , , 40436 1571 4 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 40436 1571 5 , , , 40436 1571 6 Goodness Goodness NNP 40436 1571 7 , , , 40436 1571 8 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1571 9 or or CC 40436 1571 10 the the DT 40436 1571 11 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1571 12 , , , 40436 1571 13 must must MD 40436 1571 14 each each DT 40436 1571 15 be be VB 40436 1571 16 _ _ NNP 40436 1571 17 something something NN 40436 1571 18 _ _ NNP 40436 1571 19 . . . 40436 1572 1 Tell tell VB 40436 1572 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1572 3 what what WP 40436 1572 4 the the DT 40436 1572 5 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1572 6 is be VBZ 40436 1572 7 ? ? . 40436 1573 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1573 2 Side side NN 40436 1573 3 - - HYPH 40436 1573 4 note note NN 40436 1573 5 : : : 40436 1573 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1573 7 does do VBZ 40436 1573 8 not not RB 40436 1573 9 understand understand VB 40436 1573 10 the the DT 40436 1573 11 question question NN 40436 1573 12 . . . 40436 1574 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1574 2 answers answer VBZ 40436 1574 3 by by IN 40436 1574 4 indicating indicate VBG 40436 1574 5 one one CD 40436 1574 6 particularly particularly RB 40436 1574 7 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1574 8 object object NN 40436 1574 9 . . . 40436 1574 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1575 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1575 2 does do VBZ 40436 1575 3 not not RB 40436 1575 4 conceive conceive VB 40436 1575 5 the the DT 40436 1575 6 question question NN 40436 1575 7 . . . 40436 1576 1 Does do VBZ 40436 1576 2 the the DT 40436 1576 3 man man NN 40436 1576 4 want want VB 40436 1576 5 to to TO 40436 1576 6 know know VB 40436 1576 7 what what WP 40436 1576 8 is be VBZ 40436 1576 9 a a DT 40436 1576 10 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1576 11 thing thing NN 40436 1576 12 ? ? . 40436 1577 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1577 2 Sokr._--No Sokr._--No NNP 40436 1577 3 ; ; : 40436 1577 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1577 5 wants want VBZ 40436 1577 6 to to TO 40436 1577 7 know know VB 40436 1577 8 what what WP 40436 1577 9 is be VBZ 40436 1577 10 _ _ NNP 40436 1577 11 The the DT 40436 1577 12 Beautiful Beautiful NNP 40436 1577 13 _ _ NNP 40436 1577 14 . . . 40436 1578 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1578 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 1578 3 do do VBP 40436 1578 4 not not RB 40436 1578 5 see see VB 40436 1578 6 the the DT 40436 1578 7 difference difference NN 40436 1578 8 . . . 40436 1579 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1579 2 answer answer VBP 40436 1579 3 that that IN 40436 1579 4 a a DT 40436 1579 5 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1579 6 maiden maiden NN 40436 1579 7 is be VBZ 40436 1579 8 a a DT 40436 1579 9 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1579 10 thing thing NN 40436 1579 11 . . . 40436 1580 1 No no DT 40436 1580 2 one one NN 40436 1580 3 can can MD 40436 1580 4 deny deny VB 40436 1580 5 that that DT 40436 1580 6 . . . 40436 1581 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1581 2 13 13 CD 40436 1581 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1581 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1581 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1581 6 13 13 CD 40436 1581 7 : : : 40436 1581 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1581 9 . . . 40436 1582 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1582 2 . . . 40436 1583 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1583 2 . . NNP 40436 1583 3 287 287 CD 40436 1583 4 A. a. NN 40436 1583 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1584 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1584 2 Sokr._--My Sokr._--My NNP 40436 1584 3 disputatious disputatious JJ 40436 1584 4 friend friend NN 40436 1584 5 will will MD 40436 1584 6 not not RB 40436 1584 7 accept accept VB 40436 1584 8 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1584 9 answer answer NN 40436 1584 10 . . . 40436 1585 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1585 2 wants want VBZ 40436 1585 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1585 4 to to TO 40436 1585 5 tell tell VB 40436 1585 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1585 7 , , , 40436 1585 8 What what WP 40436 1585 9 is be VBZ 40436 1585 10 the the DT 40436 1585 11 Self self NN 40436 1585 12 - - HYPH 40436 1585 13 Beautiful?--that beautiful?--that WP 40436 1585 14 Something something NN 40436 1585 15 through through IN 40436 1585 16 which which WDT 40436 1585 17 all all DT 40436 1585 18 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1585 19 things thing NNS 40436 1585 20 become become VBP 40436 1585 21 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1585 22 . . . 40436 1586 1 Am be VBP 40436 1586 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1586 3 to to TO 40436 1586 4 tell tell VB 40436 1586 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1586 6 , , , 40436 1586 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1586 8 is be VBZ 40436 1586 9 because because IN 40436 1586 10 a a DT 40436 1586 11 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1586 12 maiden maiden NN 40436 1586 13 is be VBZ 40436 1586 14 a a DT 40436 1586 15 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1586 16 thing thing NN 40436 1586 17 ? ? . 40436 1587 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1587 2 will will MD 40436 1587 3 say say VB 40436 1587 4 -- -- : 40436 1587 5 Is be VBZ 40436 1587 6 not not RB 40436 1587 7 a a DT 40436 1587 8 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1587 9 mare mare NN 40436 1587 10 a a DT 40436 1587 11 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1587 12 thing thing NN 40436 1587 13 also also RB 40436 1587 14 ? ? . 40436 1588 1 and and CC 40436 1588 2 a a DT 40436 1588 3 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1588 4 lyre lyre NN 40436 1588 5 as as RB 40436 1588 6 well well RB 40436 1588 7 ? ? . 40436 1589 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1589 2 Hip._--Yes;--both Hip._--Yes;--both NFP 40436 1589 3 of of IN 40436 1589 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1589 5 are be VBP 40436 1589 6 so so RB 40436 1589 7 . . . 40436 1590 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1590 2 Sokr._--Ay Sokr._--Ay NNS 40436 1590 3 , , , 40436 1590 4 and and CC 40436 1590 5 a a DT 40436 1590 6 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1590 7 pot pot NN 40436 1590 8 , , , 40436 1590 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1590 10 friend friend NN 40436 1590 11 will will MD 40436 1590 12 add add VB 40436 1590 13 , , , 40436 1590 14 well well UH 40436 1590 15 moulded mould VBN 40436 1590 16 and and CC 40436 1590 17 rounded round VBN 40436 1590 18 by by IN 40436 1590 19 a a DT 40436 1590 20 skilful skilful JJ 40436 1590 21 potter potter NN 40436 1590 22 , , , 40436 1590 23 is be VBZ 40436 1590 24 a a DT 40436 1590 25 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1590 26 thing thing NN 40436 1590 27 too too RB 40436 1590 28 . . . 40436 1591 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1591 2 Hip._--How Hip._--How NNP 40436 1591 3 , , , 40436 1591 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1591 5 ? ? . 40436 1592 1 Who who WP 40436 1592 2 can can MD 40436 1592 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1592 4 disputatious disputatious JJ 40436 1592 5 friend friend NN 40436 1592 6 be be VB 40436 1592 7 ? ? . 40436 1593 1 Some some DT 40436 1593 2 ill ill RB 40436 1593 3 - - HYPH 40436 1593 4 taught taught JJ 40436 1593 5 man man NN 40436 1593 6 , , , 40436 1593 7 surely surely RB 40436 1593 8 ; ; : 40436 1593 9 since since IN 40436 1593 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1593 11 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 1593 12 such such JJ 40436 1593 13 trivial trivial JJ 40436 1593 14 names name NNS 40436 1593 15 into into IN 40436 1593 16 a a DT 40436 1593 17 dignified dignified JJ 40436 1593 18 debate debate NN 40436 1593 19 . . . 40436 1594 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1594 2 Sokr._--Yes Sokr._--Yes NNP 40436 1594 3 ; ; : 40436 1594 4 that that DT 40436 1594 5 is be VBZ 40436 1594 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1594 7 character character NN 40436 1594 8 : : : 40436 1594 9 not not RB 40436 1594 10 polite polite JJ 40436 1594 11 , , , 40436 1594 12 but but CC 40436 1594 13 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 1594 14 , , , 40436 1594 15 anxious anxious JJ 40436 1594 16 for for IN 40436 1594 17 nothing nothing NN 40436 1594 18 else else RB 40436 1594 19 but but CC 40436 1594 20 the the DT 40436 1594 21 truth truth NN 40436 1594 22 . . . 40436 1595 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1595 2 Hip._--A Hip._--A NNP 40436 1595 3 pot pot NN 40436 1595 4 , , , 40436 1595 5 if if IN 40436 1595 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1595 7 be be VB 40436 1595 8 beautifully beautifully RB 40436 1595 9 made make VBN 40436 1595 10 , , , 40436 1595 11 must must MD 40436 1595 12 certainly certainly RB 40436 1595 13 be be VB 40436 1595 14 called call VBN 40436 1595 15 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1595 16 ; ; : 40436 1595 17 yet yet CC 40436 1595 18 still still RB 40436 1595 19 , , , 40436 1595 20 all all DT 40436 1595 21 such such JJ 40436 1595 22 objects object NNS 40436 1595 23 are be VBP 40436 1595 24 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 1595 25 to to TO 40436 1595 26 be be VB 40436 1595 27 counted count VBN 40436 1595 28 as as IN 40436 1595 29 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1595 30 , , , 40436 1595 31 if if IN 40436 1595 32 compared compare VBN 40436 1595 33 with with IN 40436 1595 34 a a DT 40436 1595 35 maiden maiden NN 40436 1595 36 , , , 40436 1595 37 a a DT 40436 1595 38 mare mare NN 40436 1595 39 , , , 40436 1595 40 or or CC 40436 1595 41 a a DT 40436 1595 42 lyre lyre NN 40436 1595 43 . . . 40436 1596 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1596 2 Side side NN 40436 1596 3 - - HYPH 40436 1596 4 note note NN 40436 1596 5 : : : 40436 1596 6 Cross cross NN 40436 1596 7 - - NN 40436 1596 8 questioning questioning NN 40436 1596 9 by by IN 40436 1596 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1596 11 -- -- : 40436 1596 12 Other other JJ 40436 1596 13 things thing NNS 40436 1596 14 also also RB 40436 1596 15 are be VBP 40436 1596 16 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1596 17 ; ; : 40436 1596 18 but but CC 40436 1596 19 each each DT 40436 1596 20 thing thing NN 40436 1596 21 is be VBZ 40436 1596 22 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1596 23 only only RB 40436 1596 24 by by IN 40436 1596 25 comparison comparison NN 40436 1596 26 , , , 40436 1596 27 or or CC 40436 1596 28 under under IN 40436 1596 29 some some DT 40436 1596 30 particular particular JJ 40436 1596 31 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 1596 32 -- -- : 40436 1596 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1596 34 is be VBZ 40436 1596 35 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1596 36 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1596 37 , , , 40436 1596 38 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1596 39 not not RB 40436 1596 40 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1596 41 . . . 40436 1596 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1597 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1597 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 1597 3 understand understand VBP 40436 1597 4 . . . 40436 1598 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1598 2 follow follow VBP 40436 1598 3 the the DT 40436 1598 4 analogy analogy NN 40436 1598 5 suggested suggest VBN 40436 1598 6 by by IN 40436 1598 7 Herakleitus Herakleitus NNP 40436 1598 8 in in IN 40436 1598 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1598 10 dictum dictum NN 40436 1598 11 -- -- : 40436 1598 12 That that IN 40436 1598 13 the the DT 40436 1598 14 most most RBS 40436 1598 15 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1598 16 ape ape NN 40436 1598 17 is be VBZ 40436 1598 18 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1598 19 , , , 40436 1598 20 if if IN 40436 1598 21 compared compare VBN 40436 1598 22 with with IN 40436 1598 23 the the DT 40436 1598 24 human human JJ 40436 1598 25 race race NN 40436 1598 26 . . . 40436 1599 1 So so RB 40436 1599 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1599 3 say say VBP 40436 1599 4 , , , 40436 1599 5 the the DT 40436 1599 6 most most RBS 40436 1599 7 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1599 8 pot pot NN 40436 1599 9 is be VBZ 40436 1599 10 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1599 11 , , , 40436 1599 12 when when WRB 40436 1599 13 compared compare VBN 40436 1599 14 with with IN 40436 1599 15 the the DT 40436 1599 16 race race NN 40436 1599 17 of of IN 40436 1599 18 maidens maiden NNS 40436 1599 19 . . . 40436 1600 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1600 2 Hip_--Yes Hip_--Yes NNP 40436 1600 3 . . . 40436 1601 1 That that DT 40436 1601 2 is be VBZ 40436 1601 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1601 4 meaning meaning NN 40436 1601 5 . . . 40436 1602 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1602 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 1602 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1602 4 friend friend NN 40436 1602 5 will will MD 40436 1602 6 ask ask VB 40436 1602 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1602 8 in in IN 40436 1602 9 return return NN 40436 1602 10 , , , 40436 1602 11 whether whether IN 40436 1602 12 the the DT 40436 1602 13 race race NN 40436 1602 14 of of IN 40436 1602 15 maidens maiden NNS 40436 1602 16 is be VBZ 40436 1602 17 not not RB 40436 1602 18 as as RB 40436 1602 19 much much JJ 40436 1602 20 inferior inferior JJ 40436 1602 21 to to IN 40436 1602 22 the the DT 40436 1602 23 race race NN 40436 1602 24 of of IN 40436 1602 25 Gods Gods NNP 40436 1602 26 , , , 40436 1602 27 as as IN 40436 1602 28 the the DT 40436 1602 29 pot pot NN 40436 1602 30 to to IN 40436 1602 31 the the DT 40436 1602 32 maiden maiden NN 40436 1602 33 ? ? . 40436 1603 1 whether whether IN 40436 1603 2 the the DT 40436 1603 3 most most RBS 40436 1603 4 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1603 5 maiden maiden NN 40436 1603 6 will will MD 40436 1603 7 not not RB 40436 1603 8 appear appear VB 40436 1603 9 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1603 10 , , , 40436 1603 11 when when WRB 40436 1603 12 compared compare VBN 40436 1603 13 to to IN 40436 1603 14 a a DT 40436 1603 15 Goddess Goddess NNP 40436 1603 16 ? ? . 40436 1604 1 whether whether IN 40436 1604 2 the the DT 40436 1604 3 wisest wise JJS 40436 1604 4 of of IN 40436 1604 5 men man NNS 40436 1604 6 will will MD 40436 1604 7 not not RB 40436 1604 8 appear appear VB 40436 1604 9 an an DT 40436 1604 10 ape ape NN 40436 1604 11 , , , 40436 1604 12 when when WRB 40436 1604 13 compared compare VBN 40436 1604 14 to to IN 40436 1604 15 the the DT 40436 1604 16 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1604 17 , , , 40436 1604 18 either either CC 40436 1604 19 in in IN 40436 1604 20 beauty beauty NN 40436 1604 21 or or CC 40436 1604 22 in in IN 40436 1604 23 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 1604 24 . . . 40436 1605 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1605 2 14 14 CD 40436 1605 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1605 4 _ _ NNP 40436 1605 5 Hip._--No Hip._--No NNP 40436 1605 6 one one PRP 40436 1605 7 can can MD 40436 1605 8 dispute dispute VB 40436 1605 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1605 10 . . . 40436 1606 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1606 2 Sokr._--My Sokr._--My NNP 40436 1606 3 friend friend NN 40436 1606 4 will will MD 40436 1606 5 smile smile VB 40436 1606 6 and and CC 40436 1606 7 say say VB 40436 1606 8 -- -- : 40436 1606 9 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1606 10 forget forget VBP 40436 1606 11 what what WP 40436 1606 12 was be VBD 40436 1606 13 the the DT 40436 1606 14 question question NN 40436 1606 15 put put VBN 40436 1606 16 . . . 40436 1607 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1607 2 asked ask VBD 40436 1607 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1607 4 , , , 40436 1607 5 What what WP 40436 1607 6 is be VBZ 40436 1607 7 the the DT 40436 1607 8 Beautiful?--the Beautiful?--the NNP 40436 1607 9 Self Self NNP 40436 1607 10 - - HYPH 40436 1607 11 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1607 12 : : : 40436 1607 13 and and CC 40436 1607 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1607 15 answer answer NN 40436 1607 16 gives give VBZ 40436 1607 17 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1607 18 , , , 40436 1607 19 as as IN 40436 1607 20 the the DT 40436 1607 21 Self Self NNP 40436 1607 22 - - HYPH 40436 1607 23 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1607 24 , , , 40436 1607 25 something something NN 40436 1607 26 which which WDT 40436 1607 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1607 28 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 1607 29 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 40436 1607 30 to to TO 40436 1607 31 be be VB 40436 1607 32 no no DT 40436 1607 33 more more RBR 40436 1607 34 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1607 35 than than IN 40436 1607 36 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1607 37 ? ? . 40436 1608 1 If if IN 40436 1608 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1608 3 had have VBD 40436 1608 4 asked ask VBN 40436 1608 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1608 6 , , , 40436 1608 7 from from IN 40436 1608 8 the the DT 40436 1608 9 first first JJ 40436 1608 10 , , , 40436 1608 11 what what WP 40436 1608 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1608 13 was be VBD 40436 1608 14 that that DT 40436 1608 15 was be VBD 40436 1608 16 both both CC 40436 1608 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1608 18 and and CC 40436 1608 19 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1608 20 , , , 40436 1608 21 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1608 22 answer answer NN 40436 1608 23 would would MD 40436 1608 24 have have VB 40436 1608 25 been be VBN 40436 1608 26 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 1608 27 to to IN 40436 1608 28 the the DT 40436 1608 29 question question NN 40436 1608 30 . . . 40436 1609 1 Can Can MD 40436 1609 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1609 3 still still RB 40436 1609 4 think think VB 40436 1609 5 that that IN 40436 1609 6 the the DT 40436 1609 7 Self self NN 40436 1609 8 - - HYPH 40436 1609 9 Beautiful,--that beautiful,--that WP 40436 1609 10 Something something NN 40436 1609 11 , , , 40436 1609 12 by by IN 40436 1609 13 the the DT 40436 1609 14 presence presence NN 40436 1609 15 of of IN 40436 1609 16 which which WDT 40436 1609 17 all all DT 40436 1609 18 other other JJ 40436 1609 19 things thing NNS 40436 1609 20 become become VBP 40436 1609 21 beautiful,--is beautiful,--is WP$ 40436 1609 22 a a DT 40436 1609 23 maiden maiden NN 40436 1609 24 , , , 40436 1609 25 or or CC 40436 1609 26 a a DT 40436 1609 27 mare mare NN 40436 1609 28 , , , 40436 1609 29 or or CC 40436 1609 30 a a DT 40436 1609 31 lyre lyre NN 40436 1609 32 ? ? . 40436 1610 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1610 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1610 3 14 14 CD 40436 1610 4 : : : 40436 1610 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1610 6 . . . 40436 1611 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1611 2 . . . 40436 1612 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1612 2 . . . 40436 1613 1 289 289 CD 40436 1613 2 . . . 40436 1613 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1614 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1614 2 Side side NN 40436 1614 3 - - HYPH 40436 1614 4 note note NN 40436 1614 5 : : : 40436 1614 6 Second second JJ 40436 1614 7 answer answer NN 40436 1614 8 of of IN 40436 1614 9 Hippias--_Gold Hippias--_Gold NNP 40436 1614 10 _ _ NNP 40436 1614 11 , , , 40436 1614 12 is be VBZ 40436 1614 13 that that IN 40436 1614 14 by by IN 40436 1614 15 the the DT 40436 1614 16 presence presence NN 40436 1614 17 of of IN 40436 1614 18 which which WDT 40436 1614 19 all all DT 40436 1614 20 things thing NNS 40436 1614 21 become become VBP 40436 1614 22 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1614 23 -- -- : 40436 1614 24 scrutiny scrutiny NN 40436 1614 25 applied apply VBN 40436 1614 26 to to IN 40436 1614 27 the the DT 40436 1614 28 answer answer NN 40436 1614 29 . . . 40436 1615 1 Complaint complaint NN 40436 1615 2 by by IN 40436 1615 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1615 4 about about IN 40436 1615 5 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 1615 6 analogies analogy NNS 40436 1615 7 . . . 40436 1615 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1616 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1616 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 1616 3 have have VBP 40436 1616 4 another another DT 40436 1616 5 answer answer NN 40436 1616 6 to to TO 40436 1616 7 which which WDT 40436 1616 8 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1616 9 friend friend NN 40436 1616 10 can can MD 40436 1616 11 take take VB 40436 1616 12 no no DT 40436 1616 13 exception exception NN 40436 1616 14 . . . 40436 1617 1 That that IN 40436 1617 2 , , , 40436 1617 3 by by IN 40436 1617 4 the the DT 40436 1617 5 presence presence NN 40436 1617 6 of of IN 40436 1617 7 which which WDT 40436 1617 8 all all DT 40436 1617 9 things thing NNS 40436 1617 10 become become VBP 40436 1617 11 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1617 12 , , , 40436 1617 13 is be VBZ 40436 1617 14 Gold gold NN 40436 1617 15 . . . 40436 1618 1 What what WP 40436 1618 2 was be VBD 40436 1618 3 before before RB 40436 1618 4 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1618 5 , , , 40436 1618 6 will will MD 40436 1618 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1618 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1618 9 all all DT 40436 1618 10 know know VBP 40436 1618 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1618 12 , , , 40436 1618 13 when when WRB 40436 1618 14 ornamented ornament VBN 40436 1618 15 with with IN 40436 1618 16 gold gold NN 40436 1618 17 , , , 40436 1618 18 appear appear VB 40436 1618 19 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1618 20 . . . 40436 1619 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1619 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 1619 3 little little JJ 40436 1619 4 know know VB 40436 1619 5 what what WP 40436 1619 6 sort sort NN 40436 1619 7 of of IN 40436 1619 8 man man NN 40436 1619 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1619 10 friend friend NN 40436 1619 11 is be VBZ 40436 1619 12 . . . 40436 1620 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1620 2 will will MD 40436 1620 3 laugh laugh VB 40436 1620 4 at at IN 40436 1620 5 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1620 6 answer answer NN 40436 1620 7 , , , 40436 1620 8 and and CC 40436 1620 9 ask ask VB 40436 1620 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1620 11 -- -- : 40436 1620 12 Do do VBP 40436 1620 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1620 14 think think VB 40436 1620 15 , , , 40436 1620 16 then then RB 40436 1620 17 , , , 40436 1620 18 that that IN 40436 1620 19 Pheidias Pheidias NNP 40436 1620 20 did do VBD 40436 1620 21 not not RB 40436 1620 22 know know VB 40436 1620 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1620 24 profession profession NN 40436 1620 25 as as IN 40436 1620 26 a a DT 40436 1620 27 sculptor sculptor NN 40436 1620 28 ? ? . 40436 1621 1 How how WRB 40436 1621 2 came come VBD 40436 1621 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1621 4 not not RB 40436 1621 5 to to TO 40436 1621 6 make make VB 40436 1621 7 the the DT 40436 1621 8 statue statue NN 40436 1621 9 of of IN 40436 1621 10 Athênê athênê JJ 40436 1621 11 all all DT 40436 1621 12 gold gold NN 40436 1621 13 , , , 40436 1621 14 instead instead RB 40436 1621 15 of of IN 40436 1621 16 making make VBG 40436 1621 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1621 18 as as IN 40436 1621 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1621 20 has have VBZ 40436 1621 21 done do VBN 40436 1621 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1621 23 the the DT 40436 1621 24 face face NN 40436 1621 25 , , , 40436 1621 26 hands hand NNS 40436 1621 27 , , , 40436 1621 28 and and CC 40436 1621 29 feet foot NNS 40436 1621 30 of of IN 40436 1621 31 ivory ivory NN 40436 1621 32 , , , 40436 1621 33 and and CC 40436 1621 34 the the DT 40436 1621 35 pupils pupil NNS 40436 1621 36 of of IN 40436 1621 37 the the DT 40436 1621 38 eyes eye NNS 40436 1621 39 of of IN 40436 1621 40 a a DT 40436 1621 41 particular particular JJ 40436 1621 42 stone stone NN 40436 1621 43 ? ? . 40436 1622 1 Is be VBZ 40436 1622 2 not not RB 40436 1622 3 ivory ivory JJ 40436 1622 4 also also RB 40436 1622 5 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1622 6 , , , 40436 1622 7 and and CC 40436 1622 8 particular particular JJ 40436 1622 9 kinds kind NNS 40436 1622 10 of of IN 40436 1622 11 stone stone NN 40436 1622 12 ? ? . 40436 1623 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1623 2 Hip._--Yes Hip._--Yes NNP 40436 1623 3 , , , 40436 1623 4 each each DT 40436 1623 5 is be VBZ 40436 1623 6 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1623 7 , , , 40436 1623 8 where where WRB 40436 1623 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1623 10 is be VBZ 40436 1623 11 becoming become VBG 40436 1623 12 . . . 40436 1624 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1624 2 Sokr._--And Sokr._--And NNP 40436 1624 3 ugly ugly RB 40436 1624 4 , , , 40436 1624 5 where where WRB 40436 1624 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1624 7 is be VBZ 40436 1624 8 not not RB 40436 1624 9 becoming become VBG 40436 1624 10 . . . 40436 1625 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1625 2 15 15 CD 40436 1625 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1625 4 _ _ NNP 40436 1625 5 Hip._--Doubtless Hip._--Doubtless NNP 40436 1625 6 . . . 40436 1626 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1626 2 admit admit VBP 40436 1626 3 that that IN 40436 1626 4 what what WP 40436 1626 5 is be VBZ 40436 1626 6 becoming become VBG 40436 1626 7 or or CC 40436 1626 8 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1626 9 , , , 40436 1626 10 makes make VBZ 40436 1626 11 that that DT 40436 1626 12 to to TO 40436 1626 13 which which WDT 40436 1626 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1626 15 is be VBZ 40436 1626 16 applied apply VBN 40436 1626 17 appear appear VBP 40436 1626 18 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1626 19 : : : 40436 1626 20 that that IN 40436 1626 21 which which WDT 40436 1626 22 is be VBZ 40436 1626 23 not not RB 40436 1626 24 becoming become VBG 40436 1626 25 or or CC 40436 1626 26 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1626 27 , , , 40436 1626 28 makes make VBZ 40436 1626 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1626 30 appear appear VB 40436 1626 31 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1626 32 . . . 40436 1627 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1627 2 Sokr._--My Sokr._--My NNP 40436 1627 3 friend friend NN 40436 1627 4 will will MD 40436 1627 5 next next RB 40436 1627 6 ask ask VB 40436 1627 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1627 8 , , , 40436 1627 9 when when WRB 40436 1627 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1627 11 are be VBP 40436 1627 12 boiling boil VBG 40436 1627 13 the the DT 40436 1627 14 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1627 15 pot pot NN 40436 1627 16 of of IN 40436 1627 17 which which WDT 40436 1627 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1627 19 spoke speak VBD 40436 1627 20 just just RB 40436 1627 21 now now RB 40436 1627 22 , , , 40436 1627 23 full full JJ 40436 1627 24 of of IN 40436 1627 25 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1627 26 soup soup NN 40436 1627 27 , , , 40436 1627 28 what what WDT 40436 1627 29 sort sort NN 40436 1627 30 of of IN 40436 1627 31 ladle ladle NN 40436 1627 32 will will MD 40436 1627 33 be be VB 40436 1627 34 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1627 35 and and CC 40436 1627 36 becoming become VBG 40436 1627 37 -- -- : 40436 1627 38 one one CD 40436 1627 39 made make VBN 40436 1627 40 of of IN 40436 1627 41 gold gold NN 40436 1627 42 , , , 40436 1627 43 or or CC 40436 1627 44 of of IN 40436 1627 45 fig fig NN 40436 1627 46 - - HYPH 40436 1627 47 tree tree NN 40436 1627 48 wood wood NN 40436 1627 49 ? ? . 40436 1628 1 Will Will MD 40436 1628 2 not not RB 40436 1628 3 the the DT 40436 1628 4 golden golden JJ 40436 1628 5 ladle ladle NN 40436 1628 6 spoil spoil VB 40436 1628 7 the the DT 40436 1628 8 soup soup NN 40436 1628 9 , , , 40436 1628 10 and and CC 40436 1628 11 the the DT 40436 1628 12 wooden wooden JJ 40436 1628 13 ladle ladle NN 40436 1628 14 turn turn VB 40436 1628 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1628 16 out out RP 40436 1628 17 good good JJ 40436 1628 18 ? ? . 40436 1629 1 Is be VBZ 40436 1629 2 not not RB 40436 1629 3 the the DT 40436 1629 4 wooden wooden JJ 40436 1629 5 ladle ladle NN 40436 1629 6 , , , 40436 1629 7 therefore therefore RB 40436 1629 8 , , , 40436 1629 9 better well JJR 40436 1629 10 than than IN 40436 1629 11 the the DT 40436 1629 12 golden golden JJ 40436 1629 13 ? ? . 40436 1630 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1630 2 Hip._--By Hip._--By NNP 40436 1630 3 Hêraklês Hêraklês NNP 40436 1630 4 , , , 40436 1630 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1630 6 ! ! . 40436 1631 1 what what WDT 40436 1631 2 a a DT 40436 1631 3 coarse coarse JJ 40436 1631 4 and and CC 40436 1631 5 stupid stupid JJ 40436 1631 6 fellow fellow NN 40436 1631 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1631 8 friend friend NN 40436 1631 9 is be VBZ 40436 1631 10 ! ! . 40436 1632 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1632 2 can can MD 40436 1632 3 not not RB 40436 1632 4 continue continue VB 40436 1632 5 to to TO 40436 1632 6 converse converse VB 40436 1632 7 with with IN 40436 1632 8 a a DT 40436 1632 9 man man NN 40436 1632 10 who who WP 40436 1632 11 talks talk VBZ 40436 1632 12 of of IN 40436 1632 13 such such JJ 40436 1632 14 matters matter NNS 40436 1632 15 . . . 40436 1633 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1633 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 1633 3 am be VBP 40436 1633 4 not not RB 40436 1633 5 surprised surprised JJ 40436 1633 6 that that IN 40436 1633 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1633 8 , , , 40436 1633 9 with with IN 40436 1633 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1633 11 fine fine JJ 40436 1633 12 attire attire NN 40436 1633 13 and and CC 40436 1633 14 lofty lofty JJ 40436 1633 15 reputation reputation NN 40436 1633 16 , , , 40436 1633 17 are be VBP 40436 1633 18 offended offend VBN 40436 1633 19 with with IN 40436 1633 20 these these DT 40436 1633 21 low low JJ 40436 1633 22 allusions allusion NNS 40436 1633 23 . . . 40436 1634 1 But but CC 40436 1634 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1634 3 have have VBP 40436 1634 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 1634 5 to to TO 40436 1634 6 spoil spoil VB 40436 1634 7 by by IN 40436 1634 8 intercourse intercourse NN 40436 1634 9 with with IN 40436 1634 10 this this DT 40436 1634 11 man man NN 40436 1634 12 ; ; : 40436 1634 13 and and CC 40436 1634 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1634 15 entreat entreat VBP 40436 1634 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1634 17 to to IN 40436 1634 18 persevere persevere RB 40436 1634 19 , , , 40436 1634 20 as as IN 40436 1634 21 a a DT 40436 1634 22 favour favour NN 40436 1634 23 to to IN 40436 1634 24 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1634 25 . . . 40436 1635 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1635 2 will will MD 40436 1635 3 ask ask VB 40436 1635 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1635 5 whether whether IN 40436 1635 6 a a DT 40436 1635 7 wooden wooden JJ 40436 1635 8 soup soup NN 40436 1635 9 - - HYPH 40436 1635 10 ladle ladle NN 40436 1635 11 is be VBZ 40436 1635 12 not not RB 40436 1635 13 more more RBR 40436 1635 14 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1635 15 than than IN 40436 1635 16 a a DT 40436 1635 17 ladle ladle NN 40436 1635 18 of of IN 40436 1635 19 gold,--since gold,--since NNP 40436 1635 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1635 21 is be VBZ 40436 1635 22 more more RBR 40436 1635 23 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1635 24 and and CC 40436 1635 25 becoming become VBG 40436 1635 26 ? ? . 40436 1636 1 So so IN 40436 1636 2 that that DT 40436 1636 3 though though IN 40436 1636 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1636 5 said say VBD 40436 1636 6 -- -- : 40436 1636 7 The the DT 40436 1636 8 Self self NN 40436 1636 9 - - HYPH 40436 1636 10 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1636 11 is be VBZ 40436 1636 12 Gold gold NN 40436 1636 13 -- -- : 40436 1636 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1636 15 are be VBP 40436 1636 16 now now RB 40436 1636 17 obliged oblige VBN 40436 1636 18 to to TO 40436 1636 19 acknowledge acknowledge VB 40436 1636 20 that that IN 40436 1636 21 gold gold NN 40436 1636 22 is be VBZ 40436 1636 23 not not RB 40436 1636 24 more more RBR 40436 1636 25 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1636 26 than than IN 40436 1636 27 fig fig NN 40436 1636 28 - - HYPH 40436 1636 29 tree tree NN 40436 1636 30 wood wood NN 40436 1636 31 ? ? . 40436 1637 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1637 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1637 3 15 15 CD 40436 1637 4 : : : 40436 1637 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1637 6 . . . 40436 1638 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1638 2 . . . 40436 1639 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1639 2 . . . 40436 1640 1 290 290 CD 40436 1640 2 . . . 40436 1640 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1641 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1641 2 Side side NN 40436 1641 3 - - HYPH 40436 1641 4 note note NN 40436 1641 5 : : : 40436 1641 6 Third third JJ 40436 1641 7 answer answer NN 40436 1641 8 of of IN 40436 1641 9 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1641 10 -- -- : 40436 1641 11 questions question NNS 40436 1641 12 upon upon IN 40436 1641 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1641 14 -- -- : 40436 1641 15 proof proof NN 40436 1641 16 given give VBN 40436 1641 17 that that IN 40436 1641 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1641 19 fails fail VBZ 40436 1641 20 of of IN 40436 1641 21 universal universal JJ 40436 1641 22 application application NN 40436 1641 23 . . . 40436 1641 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1642 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1642 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 1642 3 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 40436 1642 4 that that IN 40436 1642 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1642 6 is be VBZ 40436 1642 7 so so RB 40436 1642 8 . . . 40436 1643 1 But but CC 40436 1643 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1643 3 have have VBP 40436 1643 4 another another DT 40436 1643 5 answer answer NN 40436 1643 6 ready ready JJ 40436 1643 7 which which WDT 40436 1643 8 will will MD 40436 1643 9 silence silence VB 40436 1643 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1643 11 friend friend NN 40436 1643 12 . . . 40436 1644 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1644 2 presume presume VBP 40436 1644 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1644 4 wish wish VBP 40436 1644 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1644 6 to to TO 40436 1644 7 indicate indicate VB 40436 1644 8 as as IN 40436 1644 9 The the DT 40436 1644 10 Beautiful Beautiful NNP 40436 1644 11 , , , 40436 1644 12 something something NN 40436 1644 13 which which WDT 40436 1644 14 will will MD 40436 1644 15 never never RB 40436 1644 16 appear appear VB 40436 1644 17 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1644 18 to to IN 40436 1644 19 any any DT 40436 1644 20 one one CD 40436 1644 21 , , , 40436 1644 22 at at IN 40436 1644 23 any any DT 40436 1644 24 time time NN 40436 1644 25 , , , 40436 1644 26 or or CC 40436 1644 27 at at IN 40436 1644 28 any any DT 40436 1644 29 place place NN 40436 1644 30 . . . 40436 1645 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1645 2 16 16 CD 40436 1645 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1645 4 _ _ NNP 40436 1645 5 Sokr._--That Sokr._--That NNP 40436 1645 6 is be VBZ 40436 1645 7 exactly exactly RB 40436 1645 8 what what WP 40436 1645 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1645 10 desire desire VBP 40436 1645 11 . . . 40436 1646 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1646 2 Hip._--Well hip._--well UH 40436 1646 3 , , , 40436 1646 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1646 5 affirm affirm VBP 40436 1646 6 , , , 40436 1646 7 then then RB 40436 1646 8 , , , 40436 1646 9 that that IN 40436 1646 10 to to IN 40436 1646 11 every every DT 40436 1646 12 man man NN 40436 1646 13 , , , 40436 1646 14 always always RB 40436 1646 15 , , , 40436 1646 16 and and CC 40436 1646 17 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 1646 18 , , , 40436 1646 19 the the DT 40436 1646 20 following follow VBG 40436 1646 21 is be VBZ 40436 1646 22 most most RBS 40436 1646 23 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1646 24 . . . 40436 1647 1 A a DT 40436 1647 2 man man NN 40436 1647 3 being be VBG 40436 1647 4 healthy healthy JJ 40436 1647 5 , , , 40436 1647 6 rich rich JJ 40436 1647 7 , , , 40436 1647 8 honoured honour VBN 40436 1647 9 by by IN 40436 1647 10 the the DT 40436 1647 11 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 1647 12 , , , 40436 1647 13 having have VBG 40436 1647 14 come come VBN 40436 1647 15 to to IN 40436 1647 16 old old JJ 40436 1647 17 age age NN 40436 1647 18 and and CC 40436 1647 19 buried bury VBD 40436 1647 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1647 21 own own JJ 40436 1647 22 parents parent NNS 40436 1647 23 well well RB 40436 1647 24 , , , 40436 1647 25 to to TO 40436 1647 26 be be VB 40436 1647 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1647 28 buried bury VBN 40436 1647 29 by by IN 40436 1647 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1647 31 own own JJ 40436 1647 32 sons son NNS 40436 1647 33 well well RB 40436 1647 34 and and CC 40436 1647 35 magnificently magnificently RB 40436 1647 36 . . . 40436 1648 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1648 2 Sokr._--Your Sokr._--Your NNP 40436 1648 3 answer answer NN 40436 1648 4 sounds sound VBZ 40436 1648 5 imposing impose VBG 40436 1648 6 ; ; : 40436 1648 7 but but CC 40436 1648 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1648 9 friend friend NN 40436 1648 10 will will MD 40436 1648 11 laugh laugh VB 40436 1648 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1648 13 to to TO 40436 1648 14 scorn scorn VB 40436 1648 15 , , , 40436 1648 16 and and CC 40436 1648 17 will will MD 40436 1648 18 remind remind VB 40436 1648 19 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1648 20 again again RB 40436 1648 21 , , , 40436 1648 22 that that IN 40436 1648 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1648 24 question question NN 40436 1648 25 pointed point VBD 40436 1648 26 to to IN 40436 1648 27 the the DT 40436 1648 28 Beautiful Beautiful NNP 40436 1648 29 _ _ NNP 40436 1648 30 itself_[17]--something itself_[17]--something NNP 40436 1648 31 which which WDT 40436 1648 32 , , , 40436 1648 33 being be VBG 40436 1648 34 present present JJ 40436 1648 35 as as IN 40436 1648 36 attribute attribute NN 40436 1648 37 in in IN 40436 1648 38 any any DT 40436 1648 39 subject subject NN 40436 1648 40 , , , 40436 1648 41 will will MD 40436 1648 42 make make VB 40436 1648 43 that that DT 40436 1648 44 subject subject JJ 40436 1648 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1648 46 whether whether IN 40436 1648 47 stone stone NN 40436 1648 48 , , , 40436 1648 49 wood wood NN 40436 1648 50 , , , 40436 1648 51 man man NN 40436 1648 52 , , , 40436 1648 53 God God NNP 40436 1648 54 , , , 40436 1648 55 action action NN 40436 1648 56 , , , 40436 1648 57 study study NN 40436 1648 58 , , , 40436 1648 59 & & CC 40436 1648 60 c. c. NNP 40436 1648 61 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1648 62 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1648 63 . . . 40436 1649 1 Now now RB 40436 1649 2 that that IN 40436 1649 3 which which WDT 40436 1649 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1649 5 have have VBP 40436 1649 6 asserted assert VBN 40436 1649 7 to to TO 40436 1649 8 be be VB 40436 1649 9 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1649 10 to to IN 40436 1649 11 every every DT 40436 1649 12 one one NN 40436 1649 13 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 1649 14 , , , 40436 1649 15 was be VBD 40436 1649 16 not not RB 40436 1649 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1649 18 to to IN 40436 1649 19 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 1649 20 , , , 40436 1649 21 who who WP 40436 1649 22 accepted accept VBD 40436 1649 23 by by IN 40436 1649 24 preference preference NN 40436 1649 25 the the DT 40436 1649 26 lot lot NN 40436 1649 27 of of IN 40436 1649 28 dying die VBG 40436 1649 29 before before IN 40436 1649 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1649 31 father father NN 40436 1649 32 -- -- : 40436 1649 33 nor nor CC 40436 1649 34 is be VBZ 40436 1649 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1649 36 so so RB 40436 1649 37 to to IN 40436 1649 38 the the DT 40436 1649 39 heroes hero NNS 40436 1649 40 , , , 40436 1649 41 or or CC 40436 1649 42 to to IN 40436 1649 43 the the DT 40436 1649 44 sons son NNS 40436 1649 45 of of IN 40436 1649 46 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1649 47 , , , 40436 1649 48 who who WP 40436 1649 49 do do VBP 40436 1649 50 not not RB 40436 1649 51 survive survive VB 40436 1649 52 or or CC 40436 1649 53 bury bury VB 40436 1649 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1649 55 fathers father NNS 40436 1649 56 . . . 40436 1650 1 To to IN 40436 1650 2 some some DT 40436 1650 3 , , , 40436 1650 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 1650 5 , , , 40436 1650 6 what what WP 40436 1650 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1650 8 specify specify VBP 40436 1650 9 is be VBZ 40436 1650 10 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1650 11 -- -- : 40436 1650 12 to to IN 40436 1650 13 others other NNS 40436 1650 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1650 15 is be VBZ 40436 1650 16 not not RB 40436 1650 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1650 18 but but CC 40436 1650 19 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1650 20 : : : 40436 1650 21 that that RB 40436 1650 22 is is RB 40436 1650 23 , , , 40436 1650 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1650 25 is be VBZ 40436 1650 26 both both CC 40436 1650 27 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1650 28 and and CC 40436 1650 29 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1650 30 , , , 40436 1650 31 like like IN 40436 1650 32 the the DT 40436 1650 33 maiden maiden NN 40436 1650 34 , , , 40436 1650 35 the the DT 40436 1650 36 lyre lyre NN 40436 1650 37 , , , 40436 1650 38 the the DT 40436 1650 39 pot pot NN 40436 1650 40 , , , 40436 1650 41 on on IN 40436 1650 42 which which WDT 40436 1650 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1650 44 have have VBP 40436 1650 45 already already RB 40436 1650 46 remarked remark VBN 40436 1650 47 . . . 40436 1651 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1651 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 1651 3 did do VBD 40436 1651 4 not not RB 40436 1651 5 speak speak VB 40436 1651 6 about about IN 40436 1651 7 the the DT 40436 1651 8 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 1651 9 or or CC 40436 1651 10 Heroes Heroes NNPS 40436 1651 11 . . . 40436 1652 1 Your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1652 2 friend friend NN 40436 1652 3 is be VBZ 40436 1652 4 intolerable intolerable JJ 40436 1652 5 , , , 40436 1652 6 for for IN 40436 1652 7 touching touch VBG 40436 1652 8 on on IN 40436 1652 9 such such JJ 40436 1652 10 profanities profanity NNS 40436 1652 11 . . . 40436 1653 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1653 2 18 18 CD 40436 1653 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1653 4 _ _ NNP 40436 1653 5 Sokr._--However Sokr._--However NNP 40436 1653 6 , , , 40436 1653 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1653 8 can can MD 40436 1653 9 not not RB 40436 1653 10 deny deny VB 40436 1653 11 that that IN 40436 1653 12 what what WP 40436 1653 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1653 14 have have VBP 40436 1653 15 indicated indicate VBN 40436 1653 16 is be VBZ 40436 1653 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1653 18 only only RB 40436 1653 19 for for IN 40436 1653 20 the the DT 40436 1653 21 sons son NNS 40436 1653 22 of of IN 40436 1653 23 men man NNS 40436 1653 24 , , , 40436 1653 25 and and CC 40436 1653 26 not not RB 40436 1653 27 for for IN 40436 1653 28 the the DT 40436 1653 29 sons son NNS 40436 1653 30 of of IN 40436 1653 31 Gods god NNS 40436 1653 32 . . . 40436 1654 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1654 2 friend friend NN 40436 1654 3 will will MD 40436 1654 4 thus thus RB 40436 1654 5 make make VB 40436 1654 6 good good JJ 40436 1654 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1654 8 reproach reproach NN 40436 1654 9 against against IN 40436 1654 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1654 11 answer answer NN 40436 1654 12 . . . 40436 1655 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1655 2 will will MD 40436 1655 3 tell tell VB 40436 1655 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1655 5 , , , 40436 1655 6 that that IN 40436 1655 7 all all PDT 40436 1655 8 the the DT 40436 1655 9 answers answer NNS 40436 1655 10 , , , 40436 1655 11 which which WDT 40436 1655 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1655 13 have have VBP 40436 1655 14 as as RB 40436 1655 15 yet yet RB 40436 1655 16 given give VBN 40436 1655 17 , , , 40436 1655 18 are be VBP 40436 1655 19 too too RB 40436 1655 20 absurd absurd JJ 40436 1655 21 . . . 40436 1656 1 And and CC 40436 1656 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1656 3 may may MD 40436 1656 4 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 1656 5 at at IN 40436 1656 6 the the DT 40436 1656 7 same same JJ 40436 1656 8 time time NN 40436 1656 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1656 10 suggest suggest VBP 40436 1656 11 another another DT 40436 1656 12 , , , 40436 1656 13 as as IN 40436 1656 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1656 15 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1656 16 does do VBZ 40436 1656 17 in in IN 40436 1656 18 pity pity NN 40436 1656 19 for for IN 40436 1656 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1656 21 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 1656 22 . . . 40436 1657 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1657 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1657 3 16 16 CD 40436 1657 4 : : : 40436 1657 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1657 6 , , , 40436 1657 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1657 8 . . . 40436 1658 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1658 2 . . NNP 40436 1658 3 291 291 CD 40436 1658 4 C C NNP 40436 1658 5 - - HYPH 40436 1658 6 D. D. NNP 40436 1658 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1658 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1658 9 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1658 10 17 17 CD 40436 1658 11 : : : 40436 1658 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1658 13 , , , 40436 1658 14 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1658 15 . . . 40436 1659 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1659 2 . . NNP 40436 1659 3 292 292 CD 40436 1659 4 D. D. NNP 40436 1659 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1659 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1659 7 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1659 8 18 18 CD 40436 1659 9 : : : 40436 1659 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1659 11 , , , 40436 1659 12 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1659 13 . . . 40436 1660 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1660 2 . . NNP 40436 1660 3 293 293 CD 40436 1660 4 B. B. NNP 40436 1660 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1661 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1661 2 Side side NN 40436 1661 3 - - HYPH 40436 1661 4 note note NN 40436 1661 5 : : : 40436 1661 6 Farther farther JJ 40436 1661 7 answers answer NNS 40436 1661 8 , , , 40436 1661 9 suggested suggest VBN 40436 1661 10 by by IN 40436 1661 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1661 12 himself--1 himself--1 NNP 40436 1661 13 . . . 40436 1662 1 The the DT 40436 1662 2 Suitable suitable JJ 40436 1662 3 or or CC 40436 1662 4 Becoming become VBG 40436 1662 5 -- -- : 40436 1662 6 objections objection NNS 40436 1662 7 thereunto thereunto NNS 40436 1662 8 -- -- : 40436 1662 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1662 10 is be VBZ 40436 1662 11 rejected reject VBN 40436 1662 12 . . . 40436 1662 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1663 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1663 2 then then RB 40436 1663 3 mentions mention VBZ 40436 1663 4 , , , 40436 1663 5 as as IN 40436 1663 6 coming come VBG 40436 1663 7 from from IN 40436 1663 8 hints hint NNS 40436 1663 9 of of IN 40436 1663 10 the the DT 40436 1663 11 absent absent JJ 40436 1663 12 friend friend NN 40436 1663 13 , , , 40436 1663 14 three three CD 40436 1663 15 or or CC 40436 1663 16 four four CD 40436 1663 17 different different JJ 40436 1663 18 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1663 19 of of IN 40436 1663 20 the the DT 40436 1663 21 Self Self NNP 40436 1663 22 - - HYPH 40436 1663 23 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1663 24 : : : 40436 1663 25 each each DT 40436 1663 26 of of IN 40436 1663 27 which which WDT 40436 1663 28 , , , 40436 1663 29 when when WRB 40436 1663 30 first first RB 40436 1663 31 introduced introduce VBN 40436 1663 32 , , , 40436 1663 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1663 34 approves approve VBZ 40436 1663 35 , , , 40436 1663 36 and and CC 40436 1663 37 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1663 38 approves approve VBZ 40436 1663 39 also also RB 40436 1663 40 : : : 40436 1663 41 but but CC 40436 1663 42 each each DT 40436 1663 43 of of IN 40436 1663 44 which which WDT 40436 1663 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1663 46 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 1663 47 successively successively RB 40436 1663 48 to to TO 40436 1663 49 test test NN 40436 1663 50 and and CC 40436 1663 51 condemn condemn VB 40436 1663 52 . . . 40436 1664 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1664 2 is be VBZ 40436 1664 3 to to TO 40436 1664 4 be be VB 40436 1664 5 remarked remark VBN 40436 1664 6 that that IN 40436 1664 7 all all DT 40436 1664 8 of of IN 40436 1664 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1664 10 are be VBP 40436 1664 11 general general JJ 40436 1664 12 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1664 13 : : : 40436 1664 14 not not RB 40436 1664 15 consisting consist VBG 40436 1664 16 in in IN 40436 1664 17 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 1664 18 particular particular JJ 40436 1664 19 instances instance NNS 40436 1664 20 , , , 40436 1664 21 like like IN 40436 1664 22 those those DT 40436 1664 23 which which WDT 40436 1664 24 had have VBD 40436 1664 25 come come VBN 40436 1664 26 from from IN 40436 1664 27 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1664 28 . . . 40436 1665 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1665 2 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1665 3 are be VBP 40436 1665 4 the the DT 40436 1665 5 following:-- following:-- CD 40436 1665 6 1 1 CD 40436 1665 7 . . . 40436 1666 1 The the DT 40436 1666 2 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1666 3 or or CC 40436 1666 4 becoming become VBG 40436 1666 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1666 6 which which WDT 40436 1666 7 had have VBD 40436 1666 8 before before RB 40436 1666 9 been be VBN 40436 1666 10 glanced glance VBN 40436 1666 11 at at IN 40436 1666 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1666 13 . . . 40436 1667 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1667 2 is be VBZ 40436 1667 3 the the DT 40436 1667 4 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1667 5 or or CC 40436 1667 6 becoming become VBG 40436 1667 7 which which WDT 40436 1667 8 constitutes constitute VBZ 40436 1667 9 the the DT 40436 1667 10 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1667 11 . . . 40436 1668 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1668 2 19 19 CD 40436 1668 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1668 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1668 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1668 6 19 19 CD 40436 1668 7 : : : 40436 1668 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1668 9 , , , 40436 1668 10 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1668 11 . . . 40436 1669 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1669 2 . . NNP 40436 1669 3 293 293 CD 40436 1669 4 E. E. NNP 40436 1669 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1669 6 To to IN 40436 1669 7 this this DT 40436 1669 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1669 9 objects object VBZ 40436 1669 10 : : : 40436 1669 11 The the DT 40436 1669 12 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1669 13 , , , 40436 1669 14 or or CC 40436 1669 15 becoming become VBG 40436 1669 16 , , , 40436 1669 17 is be VBZ 40436 1669 18 what what WP 40436 1669 19 causes cause VBZ 40436 1669 20 objects object NNS 40436 1669 21 to to IN 40436 1669 22 _ _ NNP 40436 1669 23 appear appear VB 40436 1669 24 _ _ NNP 40436 1669 25 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1669 26 -- -- : 40436 1669 27 not not RB 40436 1669 28 what what WP 40436 1669 29 causes cause VBZ 40436 1669 30 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1669 31 to to IN 40436 1669 32 _ _ NNP 40436 1669 33 be be VB 40436 1669 34 really really RB 40436 1669 35 _ _ NNP 40436 1669 36 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1669 37 . . . 40436 1670 1 Now now RB 40436 1670 2 the the DT 40436 1670 3 latter latter JJ 40436 1670 4 is be VBZ 40436 1670 5 that that IN 40436 1670 6 which which WDT 40436 1670 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1670 8 are be VBP 40436 1670 9 seeking seek VBG 40436 1670 10 . . . 40436 1671 1 The the DT 40436 1671 2 two two CD 40436 1671 3 conditions condition NNS 40436 1671 4 do do VBP 40436 1671 5 not not RB 40436 1671 6 always always RB 40436 1671 7 go go VB 40436 1671 8 together together RB 40436 1671 9 . . . 40436 1672 1 Those those DT 40436 1672 2 objects object NNS 40436 1672 3 , , , 40436 1672 4 institutions institution NNS 40436 1672 5 , , , 40436 1672 6 and and CC 40436 1672 7 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 1672 8 which which WDT 40436 1672 9 _ _ NNP 40436 1672 10 are be VBP 40436 1672 11 really really RB 40436 1672 12 _ _ NNP 40436 1672 13 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1672 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1672 15 fine fine JJ 40436 1672 16 , , , 40436 1672 17 honourable honourable JJ 40436 1672 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1672 19 very very RB 40436 1672 20 often often RB 40436 1672 21 do do VBP 40436 1672 22 not not RB 40436 1672 23 appear appear VB 40436 1672 24 so so RB 40436 1672 25 , , , 40436 1672 26 either either CC 40436 1672 27 to to IN 40436 1672 28 individuals individual NNS 40436 1672 29 or or CC 40436 1672 30 to to IN 40436 1672 31 cities city NNS 40436 1672 32 collectively collectively RB 40436 1672 33 ; ; : 40436 1672 34 so so IN 40436 1672 35 that that IN 40436 1672 36 there there EX 40436 1672 37 is be VBZ 40436 1672 38 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 1672 39 dispute dispute NN 40436 1672 40 and and CC 40436 1672 41 fighting fighting NN 40436 1672 42 on on IN 40436 1672 43 the the DT 40436 1672 44 subject subject NN 40436 1672 45 . . . 40436 1673 1 The the DT 40436 1673 2 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1673 3 or or CC 40436 1673 4 becoming become VBG 40436 1673 5 , , , 40436 1673 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 1673 7 , , , 40436 1673 8 as as IN 40436 1673 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1673 10 is be VBZ 40436 1673 11 certainly certainly RB 40436 1673 12 what what WP 40436 1673 13 makes make VBZ 40436 1673 14 objects object NNS 40436 1673 15 appear appear VB 40436 1673 16 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1673 17 , , , 40436 1673 18 so so IN 40436 1673 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1673 20 can can MD 40436 1673 21 not not RB 40436 1673 22 be be VB 40436 1673 23 what what WP 40436 1673 24 makes make VBZ 40436 1673 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1673 26 really really RB 40436 1673 27 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1673 28 . . . 40436 1674 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1674 2 20 20 CD 40436 1674 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1674 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1674 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1674 6 20 20 CD 40436 1674 7 : : : 40436 1674 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1674 9 , , , 40436 1674 10 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1674 11 . . . 40436 1675 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1675 2 . . NNP 40436 1675 3 294 294 CD 40436 1675 4 B B NNP 40436 1675 5 - - HYPH 40436 1675 6 E. E. NNP 40436 1675 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1675 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1675 9 Side side NN 40436 1675 10 - - HYPH 40436 1675 11 note note NN 40436 1675 12 : : : 40436 1675 13 2 2 CD 40436 1675 14 . . . 40436 1676 1 The the DT 40436 1676 2 useful useful JJ 40436 1676 3 or or CC 40436 1676 4 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1676 5 -- -- : 40436 1676 6 objections objection NNS 40436 1676 7 -- -- : 40436 1676 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1676 9 will will MD 40436 1676 10 not not RB 40436 1676 11 hold hold VB 40436 1676 12 . . . 40436 1676 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1677 1 2 2 LS 40436 1677 2 . . . 40436 1678 1 The the DT 40436 1678 2 useful useful JJ 40436 1678 3 or or CC 40436 1678 4 profitable.--We profitable.--we NN 40436 1678 5 call call VBP 40436 1678 6 objects object NNS 40436 1678 7 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1678 8 , , , 40436 1678 9 looking look VBG 40436 1678 10 to to IN 40436 1678 11 the the DT 40436 1678 12 purpose purpose NN 40436 1678 13 which which WDT 40436 1678 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1678 15 are be VBP 40436 1678 16 calculated calculate VBN 40436 1678 17 or or CC 40436 1678 18 intended intend VBN 40436 1678 19 to to TO 40436 1678 20 serve serve VB 40436 1678 21 : : : 40436 1678 22 the the DT 40436 1678 23 human human JJ 40436 1678 24 body body NN 40436 1678 25 , , , 40436 1678 26 with with IN 40436 1678 27 a a DT 40436 1678 28 view view NN 40436 1678 29 to to IN 40436 1678 30 running run VBG 40436 1678 31 , , , 40436 1678 32 wrestling wrestling NN 40436 1678 33 , , , 40436 1678 34 and and CC 40436 1678 35 other other JJ 40436 1678 36 exercises exercise NNS 40436 1678 37 -- -- : 40436 1678 38 a a DT 40436 1678 39 horse horse NN 40436 1678 40 , , , 40436 1678 41 an an DT 40436 1678 42 ox ox NN 40436 1678 43 , , , 40436 1678 44 a a DT 40436 1678 45 cock cock NN 40436 1678 46 , , , 40436 1678 47 looking look VBG 40436 1678 48 to to IN 40436 1678 49 the the DT 40436 1678 50 service service NN 40436 1678 51 required require VBN 40436 1678 52 from from IN 40436 1678 53 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1678 54 -- -- : 40436 1678 55 implements implement NNS 40436 1678 56 , , , 40436 1678 57 vehicles vehicle NNS 40436 1678 58 on on IN 40436 1678 59 land land NN 40436 1678 60 and and CC 40436 1678 61 ships ship NNS 40436 1678 62 at at IN 40436 1678 63 sea sea NN 40436 1678 64 , , , 40436 1678 65 instruments instrument NNS 40436 1678 66 for for IN 40436 1678 67 music music NN 40436 1678 68 and and CC 40436 1678 69 other other JJ 40436 1678 70 arts art NNS 40436 1678 71 all all DT 40436 1678 72 upon upon IN 40436 1678 73 the the DT 40436 1678 74 same same JJ 40436 1678 75 principle principle NN 40436 1678 76 , , , 40436 1678 77 looking look VBG 40436 1678 78 to to IN 40436 1678 79 the the DT 40436 1678 80 end end NN 40436 1678 81 which which WDT 40436 1678 82 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1678 83 accomplish accomplish VBP 40436 1678 84 or or CC 40436 1678 85 help help VBP 40436 1678 86 to to TO 40436 1678 87 accomplish accomplish VB 40436 1678 88 . . . 40436 1679 1 Laws law NNS 40436 1679 2 and and CC 40436 1679 3 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 1679 4 are be VBP 40436 1679 5 characterised characterise VBN 40436 1679 6 in in IN 40436 1679 7 the the DT 40436 1679 8 same same JJ 40436 1679 9 way way NN 40436 1679 10 . . . 40436 1680 1 In in IN 40436 1680 2 each each DT 40436 1680 3 of of IN 40436 1680 4 these these DT 40436 1680 5 , , , 40436 1680 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1680 7 give give VBP 40436 1680 8 the the DT 40436 1680 9 name name NN 40436 1680 10 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1680 11 to to IN 40436 1680 12 the the DT 40436 1680 13 useful useful JJ 40436 1680 14 , , , 40436 1680 15 in in IN 40436 1680 16 so so RB 40436 1680 17 far far RB 40436 1680 18 as as IN 40436 1680 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1680 20 is be VBZ 40436 1680 21 useful useful JJ 40436 1680 22 , , , 40436 1680 23 when when WRB 40436 1680 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1680 25 is be VBZ 40436 1680 26 useful useful JJ 40436 1680 27 , , , 40436 1680 28 and and CC 40436 1680 29 for for IN 40436 1680 30 the the DT 40436 1680 31 purpose purpose NN 40436 1680 32 to to TO 40436 1680 33 which which WDT 40436 1680 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1680 35 is be VBZ 40436 1680 36 useful useful JJ 40436 1680 37 . . . 40436 1681 1 To to IN 40436 1681 2 that that DT 40436 1681 3 which which WDT 40436 1681 4 is be VBZ 40436 1681 5 useless useless JJ 40436 1681 6 or or CC 40436 1681 7 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 1681 8 , , , 40436 1681 9 in in IN 40436 1681 10 the the DT 40436 1681 11 same same JJ 40436 1681 12 manner manner NN 40436 1681 13 , , , 40436 1681 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1681 15 give give VBP 40436 1681 16 the the DT 40436 1681 17 name name NN 40436 1681 18 Ugly Ugly NNP 40436 1681 19 . . . 40436 1682 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1682 2 21 21 CD 40436 1682 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1682 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1682 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1682 6 21 21 CD 40436 1682 7 : : : 40436 1682 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1682 9 . . . 40436 1683 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1683 2 . . . 40436 1684 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1684 2 . . NNP 40436 1684 3 295 295 CD 40436 1684 4 C C NNP 40436 1684 5 - - HYPH 40436 1684 6 D. D. NNP 40436 1684 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1684 8 Now now RB 40436 1684 9 that that IN 40436 1684 10 which which WDT 40436 1684 11 is be VBZ 40436 1684 12 capable capable JJ 40436 1684 13 of of IN 40436 1684 14 accomplishing accomplish VBG 40436 1684 15 each each DT 40436 1684 16 end end NN 40436 1684 17 , , , 40436 1684 18 is be VBZ 40436 1684 19 useful useful JJ 40436 1684 20 for for IN 40436 1684 21 such such JJ 40436 1684 22 end end NN 40436 1684 23 : : : 40436 1684 24 that that IN 40436 1684 25 which which WDT 40436 1684 26 is be VBZ 40436 1684 27 incapable incapable JJ 40436 1684 28 , , , 40436 1684 29 is be VBZ 40436 1684 30 useless useless JJ 40436 1684 31 . . . 40436 1685 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1685 2 is be VBZ 40436 1685 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 1685 4 capacity capacity NN 40436 1685 5 , , , 40436 1685 6 or or CC 40436 1685 7 power power NN 40436 1685 8 , , , 40436 1685 9 which which WDT 40436 1685 10 is be VBZ 40436 1685 11 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1685 12 : : : 40436 1685 13 incapacity incapacity NN 40436 1685 14 , , , 40436 1685 15 or or CC 40436 1685 16 impotence impotence NN 40436 1685 17 , , , 40436 1685 18 is be VBZ 40436 1685 19 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1685 20 . . . 40436 1686 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1686 2 22 22 CD 40436 1686 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1686 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1686 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1686 6 22 22 CD 40436 1686 7 : : : 40436 1686 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1686 9 . . . 40436 1687 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1687 2 . . . 40436 1688 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1688 2 . . NNP 40436 1688 3 295 295 CD 40436 1688 4 E. E. NNP 40436 1688 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1688 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1688 7 : : : 40436 1688 8 Ou)kou ou)kou CD 40436 1688 9 = = SYM 40436 1688 10 n n CC 40436 1688 11 to\ to\ NN 40436 1688 12 dunato\n dunato\n ADD 40436 1688 13 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 1688 14 a)perga a)perga NNP 40436 1688 15 / / SYM 40436 1688 16 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 1688 17 , , , 40436 1688 18 ei)s ei)s NNP 40436 1688 19 o(/per o(/per NNP 40436 1688 20 dunato dunato NNP 40436 1688 21 / / SYM 40436 1688 22 n n NNP 40436 1688 23 , , , 40436 1688 24 ei)s ei)s , 40436 1688 25 tou tou NNP 40436 1688 26 = = NNPS 40436 1688 27 to to IN 40436 1688 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1688 29 chrê chrê NNP 40436 1688 30 / / SYM 40436 1688 31 simon simon NNP 40436 1688 32 ; ; : 40436 1688 33 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1688 34 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1688 35 a)du a)du NNP 40436 1688 36 / / SYM 40436 1688 37 naton naton NNP 40436 1688 38 a)/chrêston a)/chrêston NNP 40436 1688 39 ? ? . 40436 1689 1 . . . 40436 1690 1 . . . 40436 1691 1 . . . 40436 1692 1 . . . 40436 1693 1 Du Du NNP 40436 1693 2 / / SYM 40436 1693 3 namis namis NNP 40436 1693 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 1693 5 a)/ra a)/ra FW 40436 1693 6 kalo kalo NNP 40436 1693 7 / / SYM 40436 1693 8 n n NNP 40436 1693 9 -- -- : 40436 1693 10 a)dunami a)dunami ADD 40436 1693 11 / / SYM 40436 1693 12 a a DT 40436 1693 13 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1693 14 ai)schro ai)schro NN 40436 1693 15 / / SYM 40436 1693 16 n n NN 40436 1693 17 ? ? . 40436 1693 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1693 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1694 1 Most most RBS 40436 1694 2 certainly certainly RB 40436 1694 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1694 4 replies reply VBZ 40436 1694 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1694 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1694 7 : : : 40436 1694 8 this this DT 40436 1694 9 is be VBZ 40436 1694 10 especially especially RB 40436 1694 11 true true JJ 40436 1694 12 in in IN 40436 1694 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1694 14 cities city NNS 40436 1694 15 and and CC 40436 1694 16 communities community NNS 40436 1694 17 , , , 40436 1694 18 wherein wherein WRB 40436 1694 19 political political JJ 40436 1694 20 power power NN 40436 1694 21 is be VBZ 40436 1694 22 the the DT 40436 1694 23 finest fine JJS 40436 1694 24 thing thing NN 40436 1694 25 possible possible JJ 40436 1694 26 , , , 40436 1694 27 political political JJ 40436 1694 28 impotence impotence NN 40436 1694 29 , , , 40436 1694 30 the the DT 40436 1694 31 meanest mean JJS 40436 1694 32 . . . 40436 1695 1 Yet yet RB 40436 1695 2 , , , 40436 1695 3 on on IN 40436 1695 4 closer close JJR 40436 1695 5 inspection inspection NN 40436 1695 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1695 7 continues continue VBZ 40436 1695 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1695 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1695 10 , , , 40436 1695 11 such such PDT 40436 1695 12 a a DT 40436 1695 13 theory theory NN 40436 1695 14 will will MD 40436 1695 15 not not RB 40436 1695 16 hold hold VB 40436 1695 17 . . . 40436 1696 1 Power power NN 40436 1696 2 is be VBZ 40436 1696 3 employed employ VBN 40436 1696 4 by by IN 40436 1696 5 all all DT 40436 1696 6 men man NNS 40436 1696 7 , , , 40436 1696 8 though though IN 40436 1696 9 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 1696 10 , , , 40436 1696 11 for for IN 40436 1696 12 bad bad JJ 40436 1696 13 purposes purpose NNS 40436 1696 14 : : : 40436 1696 15 and and CC 40436 1696 16 each each DT 40436 1696 17 man man NN 40436 1696 18 , , , 40436 1696 19 through through IN 40436 1696 20 such such JJ 40436 1696 21 employment employment NN 40436 1696 22 of of IN 40436 1696 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1696 24 power power NN 40436 1696 25 , , , 40436 1696 26 does do VBZ 40436 1696 27 much much RB 40436 1696 28 more more JJR 40436 1696 29 harm harm NN 40436 1696 30 than than IN 40436 1696 31 good good JJ 40436 1696 32 , , , 40436 1696 33 beginning begin VBG 40436 1696 34 with with IN 40436 1696 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1696 36 childhood childhood NN 40436 1696 37 . . . 40436 1697 1 Now now RB 40436 1697 2 power power NN 40436 1697 3 , , , 40436 1697 4 which which WDT 40436 1697 5 is be VBZ 40436 1697 6 useful useful JJ 40436 1697 7 for for IN 40436 1697 8 the the DT 40436 1697 9 doing doing NN 40436 1697 10 of of IN 40436 1697 11 evil evil NN 40436 1697 12 , , , 40436 1697 13 can can MD 40436 1697 14 never never RB 40436 1697 15 be be VB 40436 1697 16 called call VBN 40436 1697 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1697 18 . . . 40436 1698 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1698 2 23 23 CD 40436 1698 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1698 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1698 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1698 6 23 23 CD 40436 1698 7 : : : 40436 1698 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1698 9 . . . 40436 1699 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1699 2 . . . 40436 1700 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1700 2 . . NNP 40436 1700 3 296 296 CD 40436 1700 4 C C NNP 40436 1700 5 - - HYPH 40436 1700 6 D. D. NNP 40436 1700 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1700 8 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1700 9 can can MD 40436 1700 10 not not RB 40436 1700 11 therefore therefore RB 40436 1700 12 say say VB 40436 1700 13 that that IN 40436 1700 14 Power power NN 40436 1700 15 , , , 40436 1700 16 taken take VBN 40436 1700 17 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 1700 18 , , , 40436 1700 19 is be VBZ 40436 1700 20 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1700 21 . . . 40436 1701 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1701 2 must must MD 40436 1701 3 add add VB 40436 1701 4 the the DT 40436 1701 5 qualification qualification NN 40436 1701 6 -- -- : 40436 1701 7 Power power NN 40436 1701 8 used use VBN 40436 1701 9 for for IN 40436 1701 10 the the DT 40436 1701 11 production production NN 40436 1701 12 of of IN 40436 1701 13 some some DT 40436 1701 14 good good JJ 40436 1701 15 , , , 40436 1701 16 is be VBZ 40436 1701 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1701 18 . . . 40436 1702 1 This this DT 40436 1702 2 , , , 40436 1702 3 then then RB 40436 1702 4 , , , 40436 1702 5 would would MD 40436 1702 6 be be VB 40436 1702 7 the the DT 40436 1702 8 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1702 9 -- -- : 40436 1702 10 the the DT 40436 1702 11 cause cause NN 40436 1702 12 or or CC 40436 1702 13 generator generator NN 40436 1702 14 of of IN 40436 1702 15 good good NN 40436 1702 16 . . . 40436 1703 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1703 2 24 24 CD 40436 1703 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1703 4 But but CC 40436 1703 5 the the DT 40436 1703 6 cause cause NN 40436 1703 7 is be VBZ 40436 1703 8 different different JJ 40436 1703 9 from from IN 40436 1703 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1703 11 effect effect NN 40436 1703 12 : : : 40436 1703 13 the the DT 40436 1703 14 generator generator NN 40436 1703 15 or or CC 40436 1703 16 father father NN 40436 1703 17 is be VBZ 40436 1703 18 different different JJ 40436 1703 19 from from IN 40436 1703 20 the the DT 40436 1703 21 generated generate VBN 40436 1703 22 or or CC 40436 1703 23 son son NN 40436 1703 24 . . . 40436 1704 1 The the DT 40436 1704 2 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1704 3 would would MD 40436 1704 4 , , , 40436 1704 5 upon upon IN 40436 1704 6 this this DT 40436 1704 7 view view NN 40436 1704 8 , , , 40436 1704 9 be be VB 40436 1704 10 the the DT 40436 1704 11 cause cause NN 40436 1704 12 of of IN 40436 1704 13 the the DT 40436 1704 14 good good NN 40436 1704 15 . . . 40436 1705 1 But but CC 40436 1705 2 then then RB 40436 1705 3 the the DT 40436 1705 4 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1705 5 would would MD 40436 1705 6 be be VB 40436 1705 7 different different JJ 40436 1705 8 from from IN 40436 1705 9 the the DT 40436 1705 10 good good NN 40436 1705 11 , , , 40436 1705 12 and and CC 40436 1705 13 the the DT 40436 1705 14 good good JJ 40436 1705 15 different different JJ 40436 1705 16 from from IN 40436 1705 17 the the DT 40436 1705 18 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1705 19 ? ? . 40436 1706 1 Who who WP 40436 1706 2 can can MD 40436 1706 3 admit admit VB 40436 1706 4 this this DT 40436 1706 5 ? ? . 40436 1707 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1707 2 is be VBZ 40436 1707 3 obviously obviously RB 40436 1707 4 wrong wrong JJ 40436 1707 5 : : : 40436 1707 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1707 7 is be VBZ 40436 1707 8 the the DT 40436 1707 9 most most RBS 40436 1707 10 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 1707 11 theory theory NN 40436 1707 12 which which WDT 40436 1707 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1707 14 have have VBP 40436 1707 15 yet yet RB 40436 1707 16 hit hit VBN 40436 1707 17 upon upon IN 40436 1707 18 . . . 40436 1708 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1708 2 25 25 CD 40436 1708 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1708 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1708 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1708 6 24 24 CD 40436 1708 7 : : : 40436 1708 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1708 9 . . . 40436 1709 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1709 2 . . . 40436 1710 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1710 2 . . NNP 40436 1710 3 297 297 CD 40436 1710 4 B. B. NNP 40436 1710 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1711 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1711 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1711 3 25 25 CD 40436 1711 4 : : : 40436 1711 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1711 6 . . . 40436 1712 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1712 2 . . . 40436 1713 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1713 2 . . NNP 40436 1713 3 297 297 CD 40436 1713 4 D D NNP 40436 1713 5 - - HYPH 40436 1713 6 E. e. NN 40436 1713 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1713 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1713 9 : : : 40436 1713 10 ei ei NNP 40436 1713 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1713 12 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 1713 13 / / SYM 40436 1713 14 n n CC 40436 1713 15 t t NNP 40436 1713 16 ' ' '' 40436 1713 17 e)sti e)sti NNS 40436 1713 18 / / SYM 40436 1713 19 n n LS 40436 1713 20 , , , 40436 1713 21 e(kei e(kei JJ 40436 1713 22 / / SYM 40436 1713 23 nôn nôn NNP 40436 1713 24 ei)=nai ei)=nai FW 40436 1713 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1713 26 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 1713 27 / / SYM 40436 1713 28 ei ei NNP 40436 1713 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1713 30 geloio geloio NN 40436 1713 31 / / SYM 40436 1713 32 teros tero NNS 40436 1713 33 tô tô NNP 40436 1713 34 = = SYM 40436 1713 35 n n NNP 40436 1713 36 prô prô NNP 40436 1713 37 / / SYM 40436 1713 38 tôn tôn NNP 40436 1713 39 . . . 40436 1713 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1713 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1714 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1714 2 Side side NN 40436 1714 3 - - HYPH 40436 1714 4 note note NN 40436 1714 5 : : : 40436 1714 6 3 3 CD 40436 1714 7 . . . 40436 1715 1 The the DT 40436 1715 2 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1715 3 is be VBZ 40436 1715 4 a a DT 40436 1715 5 variety variety NN 40436 1715 6 of of IN 40436 1715 7 the the DT 40436 1715 8 Pleasurable Pleasurable NNP 40436 1715 9 -- -- : 40436 1715 10 that that IN 40436 1715 11 which which WDT 40436 1715 12 is be VBZ 40436 1715 13 received receive VBN 40436 1715 14 through through IN 40436 1715 15 the the DT 40436 1715 16 eye eye NN 40436 1715 17 and and CC 40436 1715 18 the the DT 40436 1715 19 ear ear NN 40436 1715 20 . . . 40436 1715 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1716 1 3 3 LS 40436 1716 2 . . . 40436 1717 1 The the DT 40436 1717 2 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1717 3 is be VBZ 40436 1717 4 a a DT 40436 1717 5 particular particular JJ 40436 1717 6 variety variety NN 40436 1717 7 of of IN 40436 1717 8 the the DT 40436 1717 9 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 1717 10 or or CC 40436 1717 11 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 1717 12 : : : 40436 1717 13 that that IN 40436 1717 14 which which WDT 40436 1717 15 characterises characterise VBZ 40436 1717 16 those those DT 40436 1717 17 things thing NNS 40436 1717 18 which which WDT 40436 1717 19 cause cause VBP 40436 1717 20 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 1717 21 to to IN 40436 1717 22 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1717 23 through through IN 40436 1717 24 sight sight NN 40436 1717 25 and and CC 40436 1717 26 hearing hearing NN 40436 1717 27 . . . 40436 1718 1 Thus thus RB 40436 1718 2 the the DT 40436 1718 3 men man NNS 40436 1718 4 , , , 40436 1718 5 the the DT 40436 1718 6 ornaments ornament NNS 40436 1718 7 , , , 40436 1718 8 the the DT 40436 1718 9 works work NNS 40436 1718 10 of of IN 40436 1718 11 painting painting NN 40436 1718 12 or or CC 40436 1718 13 sculpture sculpture NN 40436 1718 14 , , , 40436 1718 15 upon upon IN 40436 1718 16 which which WDT 40436 1718 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1718 18 look look VBP 40436 1718 19 with with IN 40436 1718 20 admiration,[26 admiration,[26 NNP 40436 1718 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1718 22 are be VBP 40436 1718 23 called call VBN 40436 1718 24 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1718 25 : : : 40436 1718 26 also also RB 40436 1718 27 songs song NNS 40436 1718 28 , , , 40436 1718 29 music music NN 40436 1718 30 , , , 40436 1718 31 poetry poetry NN 40436 1718 32 , , , 40436 1718 33 fable fable JJ 40436 1718 34 , , , 40436 1718 35 discourse discourse JJ 40436 1718 36 , , , 40436 1718 37 in in IN 40436 1718 38 like like NNP 40436 1718 39 manner manner NN 40436 1718 40 ; ; : 40436 1718 41 nay nay NNP 40436 1718 42 even even RB 40436 1718 43 laws law NNS 40436 1718 44 , , , 40436 1718 45 customs custom NNS 40436 1718 46 , , , 40436 1718 47 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 1718 48 , , , 40436 1718 49 which which WDT 40436 1718 50 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1718 51 consider consider VBP 40436 1718 52 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1718 53 , , , 40436 1718 54 might may MD 40436 1718 55 be be VB 40436 1718 56 brought bring VBN 40436 1718 57 under under IN 40436 1718 58 the the DT 40436 1718 59 same same JJ 40436 1718 60 head head NN 40436 1718 61 . . . 40436 1719 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1719 2 27 27 CD 40436 1719 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1719 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1719 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1719 6 26 26 CD 40436 1719 7 : : : 40436 1719 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1719 9 . . . 40436 1720 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1720 2 . . . 40436 1721 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1721 2 . . NNP 40436 1721 3 298 298 CD 40436 1721 4 A A NNP 40436 1721 5 - - HYPH 40436 1721 6 B. b. NN 40436 1721 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1722 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1722 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1722 3 27 27 CD 40436 1722 4 : : : 40436 1722 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1722 6 . . . 40436 1723 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1723 2 . . . 40436 1724 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1724 2 . . NNP 40436 1724 3 298 298 CD 40436 1724 4 D. D. NNP 40436 1724 5 Professor Professor NNP 40436 1724 6 Bain Bain NNP 40436 1724 7 observes:--"The observes:--"The . 40436 1724 8 eye eye NN 40436 1724 9 and and CC 40436 1724 10 the the DT 40436 1724 11 ear ear NN 40436 1724 12 are be VBP 40436 1724 13 the the DT 40436 1724 14 great great JJ 40436 1724 15 avenues avenue NNS 40436 1724 16 to to IN 40436 1724 17 the the DT 40436 1724 18 mind mind NN 40436 1724 19 for for IN 40436 1724 20 the the DT 40436 1724 21 æsthetic æsthetic JJ 40436 1724 22 class class NN 40436 1724 23 of of IN 40436 1724 24 influences influence NNS 40436 1724 25 ; ; : 40436 1724 26 the the DT 40436 1724 27 other other JJ 40436 1724 28 senses sense NNS 40436 1724 29 are be VBP 40436 1724 30 more more RBR 40436 1724 31 or or CC 40436 1724 32 less less JJR 40436 1724 33 in in IN 40436 1724 34 the the DT 40436 1724 35 monopolist monopolist JJ 40436 1724 36 interest interest NN 40436 1724 37 . . . 40436 1725 1 The the DT 40436 1725 2 blue blue JJ 40436 1725 3 sky sky NN 40436 1725 4 , , , 40436 1725 5 the the DT 40436 1725 6 green green JJ 40436 1725 7 woods wood NNS 40436 1725 8 , , , 40436 1725 9 and and CC 40436 1725 10 all all PDT 40436 1725 11 the the DT 40436 1725 12 beauties beauty NNS 40436 1725 13 of of IN 40436 1725 14 the the DT 40436 1725 15 landscape landscape NN 40436 1725 16 , , , 40436 1725 17 can can MD 40436 1725 18 fill fill VB 40436 1725 19 the the DT 40436 1725 20 vision vision NN 40436 1725 21 of of IN 40436 1725 22 a a DT 40436 1725 23 countless countless JJ 40436 1725 24 throng throng NN 40436 1725 25 of of IN 40436 1725 26 admirers admirer NNS 40436 1725 27 . . . 40436 1726 1 So so RB 40436 1726 2 with with IN 40436 1726 3 the the DT 40436 1726 4 pleasing pleasing JJ 40436 1726 5 sounds sound NNS 40436 1726 6 , , , 40436 1726 7 & & CC 40436 1726 8 c. c. NNP 40436 1726 9 " " `` 40436 1726 10 ' ' `` 40436 1726 11 The the DT 40436 1726 12 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 1726 13 and and CC 40436 1726 14 the the DT 40436 1726 15 Will Will NNP 40436 1726 16 . . . 40436 1726 17 ' ' '' 40436 1727 1 ch ch NNP 40436 1727 2 . . . 40436 1728 1 xiv xiv NNP 40436 1728 2 . . . 40436 1729 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1729 2 The the DT 40436 1729 3 Æsthetic Æsthetic NNP 40436 1729 4 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 1729 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1729 6 , , , 40436 1729 7 sect sect NN 40436 1729 8 . . . 40436 1730 1 2 2 CD 40436 1730 2 , , , 40436 1730 3 p. p. NN 40436 1730 4 226 226 CD 40436 1730 5 , , , 40436 1730 6 3rd 3rd NNP 40436 1730 7 ed ed NNP 40436 1730 8 . . . 40436 1730 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1731 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1731 2 Side side NN 40436 1731 3 - - HYPH 40436 1731 4 note note NN 40436 1731 5 : : : 40436 1731 6 Objections objection NNS 40436 1731 7 to to IN 40436 1731 8 this this DT 40436 1731 9 last last JJ 40436 1731 10 -- -- : 40436 1731 11 What what WDT 40436 1731 12 property property NN 40436 1731 13 is be VBZ 40436 1731 14 there there RB 40436 1731 15 common common JJ 40436 1731 16 to to IN 40436 1731 17 both both DT 40436 1731 18 sight sight NN 40436 1731 19 and and CC 40436 1731 20 hearing hearing NN 40436 1731 21 , , , 40436 1731 22 which which WDT 40436 1731 23 confers confer VBZ 40436 1731 24 upon upon IN 40436 1731 25 the the DT 40436 1731 26 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1731 27 of of IN 40436 1731 28 these these DT 40436 1731 29 two two CD 40436 1731 30 senses sense NNS 40436 1731 31 the the DT 40436 1731 32 exclusive exclusive JJ 40436 1731 33 privilege privilege NN 40436 1731 34 of of IN 40436 1731 35 being be VBG 40436 1731 36 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1731 37 ? ? . 40436 1731 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1732 1 The the DT 40436 1732 2 objector objector NN 40436 1732 3 , , , 40436 1732 4 however however RB 40436 1732 5 , , , 40436 1732 6 must must MD 40436 1732 7 now now RB 40436 1732 8 be be VB 40436 1732 9 dealt deal VBN 40436 1732 10 with with IN 40436 1732 11 . . . 40436 1733 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1733 2 will will MD 40436 1733 3 ask ask VB 40436 1733 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1733 5 -- -- : 40436 1733 6 Upon upon IN 40436 1733 7 what what WDT 40436 1733 8 ground ground NN 40436 1733 9 do do VBP 40436 1733 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1733 11 make make VB 40436 1733 12 so so RB 40436 1733 13 marked mark VBN 40436 1733 14 a a DT 40436 1733 15 distinction distinction NN 40436 1733 16 between between IN 40436 1733 17 the the DT 40436 1733 18 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1733 19 of of IN 40436 1733 20 sight sight NN 40436 1733 21 and and CC 40436 1733 22 hearing hearing NN 40436 1733 23 , , , 40436 1733 24 and and CC 40436 1733 25 other other JJ 40436 1733 26 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1733 27 ? ? . 40436 1734 1 Do do VBP 40436 1734 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1734 3 deny deny VB 40436 1734 4 that that IN 40436 1734 5 these these DT 40436 1734 6 others other NNS 40436 1734 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1734 8 those those DT 40436 1734 9 of of IN 40436 1734 10 taste taste NN 40436 1734 11 , , , 40436 1734 12 smell smell NN 40436 1734 13 , , , 40436 1734 14 eating eating NN 40436 1734 15 , , , 40436 1734 16 drinking drinking NN 40436 1734 17 , , , 40436 1734 18 sex sex NN 40436 1734 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1734 20 are be VBP 40436 1734 21 really really RB 40436 1734 22 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1734 23 ? ? . 40436 1735 1 No no UH 40436 1735 2 , , , 40436 1735 3 surely surely RB 40436 1735 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1735 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1735 6 shall shall MD 40436 1735 7 reply reply VB 40436 1735 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1735 9 ; ; : 40436 1735 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1735 11 admit admit VBP 40436 1735 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1735 13 to to TO 40436 1735 14 be be VB 40436 1735 15 pleasures,--but pleasures,--but NN 40436 1735 16 no no DT 40436 1735 17 one one NN 40436 1735 18 will will MD 40436 1735 19 tolerate tolerate VB 40436 1735 20 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1735 21 in in IN 40436 1735 22 calling call VBG 40436 1735 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1735 24 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1735 25 : : : 40436 1735 26 especially especially RB 40436 1735 27 the the DT 40436 1735 28 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1735 29 of of IN 40436 1735 30 sex sex NN 40436 1735 31 , , , 40436 1735 32 which which WDT 40436 1735 33 as as IN 40436 1735 34 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1735 35 are be VBP 40436 1735 36 the the DT 40436 1735 37 greatest great JJS 40436 1735 38 of of IN 40436 1735 39 all all DT 40436 1735 40 , , , 40436 1735 41 but but CC 40436 1735 42 which which WDT 40436 1735 43 are be VBP 40436 1735 44 ugly ugly JJ 40436 1735 45 and and CC 40436 1735 46 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 1735 47 to to TO 40436 1735 48 behold behold VB 40436 1735 49 . . . 40436 1736 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 2 will will MD 40436 1736 3 answer answer VB 40436 1736 4 -- -- : 40436 1736 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 6 understand understand VBP 40436 1736 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 8 : : : 40436 1736 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 10 are be VBP 40436 1736 11 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 1736 12 to to TO 40436 1736 13 call call VB 40436 1736 14 these these DT 40436 1736 15 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1736 16 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1736 17 , , , 40436 1736 18 because because IN 40436 1736 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 20 do do VBP 40436 1736 21 not not RB 40436 1736 22 seem seem VB 40436 1736 23 so so RB 40436 1736 24 to to IN 40436 1736 25 the the DT 40436 1736 26 multitude multitude NN 40436 1736 27 : : : 40436 1736 28 but but CC 40436 1736 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 30 did do VBD 40436 1736 31 not not RB 40436 1736 32 ask ask VB 40436 1736 33 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 34 , , , 40436 1736 35 what what WP 40436 1736 36 _ _ NNP 40436 1736 37 seems seem VBZ 40436 1736 38 _ _ NNP 40436 1736 39 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1736 40 to to IN 40436 1736 41 the the DT 40436 1736 42 multitude multitude NN 40436 1736 43 -- -- : 40436 1736 44 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 45 asked ask VBD 40436 1736 46 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1736 47 , , , 40436 1736 48 what what WP 40436 1736 49 _ _ NNP 40436 1736 50 is be VBZ 40436 1736 51 _ _ NNP 40436 1736 52 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1736 53 . . . 40436 1737 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1737 2 28 28 CD 40436 1737 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1737 4 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1737 5 mean mean VBP 40436 1737 6 to to TO 40436 1737 7 affirm affirm VB 40436 1737 8 , , , 40436 1737 9 that that IN 40436 1737 10 all all DT 40436 1737 11 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1737 12 which which WDT 40436 1737 13 do do VBP 40436 1737 14 not not RB 40436 1737 15 belong belong VB 40436 1737 16 to to IN 40436 1737 17 sight sight NN 40436 1737 18 and and CC 40436 1737 19 hearing hearing NN 40436 1737 20 , , , 40436 1737 21 are be VBP 40436 1737 22 not not RB 40436 1737 23 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1737 24 : : : 40436 1737 25 Do do VBP 40436 1737 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1737 27 mean mean VB 40436 1737 28 , , , 40436 1737 29 all all DT 40436 1737 30 which which WDT 40436 1737 31 do do VBP 40436 1737 32 not not RB 40436 1737 33 belong belong VB 40436 1737 34 to to IN 40436 1737 35 both both DT 40436 1737 36 ? ? . 40436 1738 1 or or CC 40436 1738 2 all all DT 40436 1738 3 which which WDT 40436 1738 4 do do VBP 40436 1738 5 not not RB 40436 1738 6 belong belong VB 40436 1738 7 to to IN 40436 1738 8 one one CD 40436 1738 9 or or CC 40436 1738 10 the the DT 40436 1738 11 other other JJ 40436 1738 12 ? ? . 40436 1739 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1739 2 shall shall MD 40436 1739 3 reply reply VB 40436 1739 4 -- -- : 40436 1739 5 To to IN 40436 1739 6 either either DT 40436 1739 7 one one CD 40436 1739 8 of of IN 40436 1739 9 the the DT 40436 1739 10 two two CD 40436 1739 11 -- -- : 40436 1739 12 or or CC 40436 1739 13 to to IN 40436 1739 14 both both DT 40436 1739 15 the the DT 40436 1739 16 two two CD 40436 1739 17 . . . 40436 1740 1 Well well UH 40436 1740 2 ! ! . 40436 1741 1 but but CC 40436 1741 2 , , , 40436 1741 3 why why WRB 40436 1741 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1741 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1741 6 will will MD 40436 1741 7 ask ask VB 40436 1741 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1741 9 do do VBP 40436 1741 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1741 11 single single VB 40436 1741 12 out out RP 40436 1741 13 these these DT 40436 1741 14 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1741 15 of of IN 40436 1741 16 sight sight NN 40436 1741 17 and and CC 40436 1741 18 hearing hearing NN 40436 1741 19 , , , 40436 1741 20 as as IN 40436 1741 21 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1741 22 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 1741 23 ? ? . 40436 1742 1 What what WP 40436 1742 2 is be VBZ 40436 1742 3 there there RB 40436 1742 4 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 1742 5 in in IN 40436 1742 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1742 7 , , , 40436 1742 8 which which WDT 40436 1742 9 gives give VBZ 40436 1742 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1742 11 a a DT 40436 1742 12 title title NN 40436 1742 13 to to IN 40436 1742 14 such such JJ 40436 1742 15 distinction distinction NN 40436 1742 16 ? ? . 40436 1743 1 All all DT 40436 1743 2 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1743 3 are be VBP 40436 1743 4 alike alike RB 40436 1743 5 , , , 40436 1743 6 so so RB 40436 1743 7 far far RB 40436 1743 8 forth forth RB 40436 1743 9 as as IN 40436 1743 10 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1743 11 , , , 40436 1743 12 differing differ VBG 40436 1743 13 only only RB 40436 1743 14 in in IN 40436 1743 15 the the DT 40436 1743 16 more more RBR 40436 1743 17 or or CC 40436 1743 18 less less RBR 40436 1743 19 . . . 40436 1744 1 Next next RB 40436 1744 2 , , , 40436 1744 3 the the DT 40436 1744 4 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1744 5 of of IN 40436 1744 6 sight sight NN 40436 1744 7 can can MD 40436 1744 8 not not RB 40436 1744 9 be be VB 40436 1744 10 considered consider VBN 40436 1744 11 as as RB 40436 1744 12 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1744 13 by by IN 40436 1744 14 reason reason NN 40436 1744 15 of of IN 40436 1744 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1744 17 coming come VBG 40436 1744 18 through through IN 40436 1744 19 sight sight NN 40436 1744 20 -- -- : 40436 1744 21 for for IN 40436 1744 22 that that DT 40436 1744 23 reason reason NN 40436 1744 24 would would MD 40436 1744 25 not not RB 40436 1744 26 apply apply VB 40436 1744 27 to to IN 40436 1744 28 the the DT 40436 1744 29 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1744 30 of of IN 40436 1744 31 hearing hearing NN 40436 1744 32 : : : 40436 1744 33 nor nor CC 40436 1744 34 again again RB 40436 1744 35 can can MD 40436 1744 36 the the DT 40436 1744 37 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1744 38 of of IN 40436 1744 39 hearing hearing NN 40436 1744 40 be be VB 40436 1744 41 considered consider VBN 40436 1744 42 as as RB 40436 1744 43 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1744 44 by by IN 40436 1744 45 reason reason NN 40436 1744 46 of of IN 40436 1744 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1744 48 coming come VBG 40436 1744 49 through through IN 40436 1744 50 hearing hearing NN 40436 1744 51 . . . 40436 1745 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1745 2 29 29 CD 40436 1745 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1745 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1745 5 must must MD 40436 1745 6 find find VB 40436 1745 7 something something NN 40436 1745 8 possessed possess VBN 40436 1745 9 as as RB 40436 1745 10 well well RB 40436 1745 11 by by IN 40436 1745 12 sight sight NN 40436 1745 13 as as IN 40436 1745 14 by by IN 40436 1745 15 hearing hear VBG 40436 1745 16 , , , 40436 1745 17 common common JJ 40436 1745 18 to to IN 40436 1745 19 both both DT 40436 1745 20 , , , 40436 1745 21 and and CC 40436 1745 22 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 1745 23 to to IN 40436 1745 24 them,--which them,--which NNP 40436 1745 25 confers confer NNS 40436 1745 26 beauty beauty VBP 40436 1745 27 upon upon IN 40436 1745 28 the the DT 40436 1745 29 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1745 30 of of IN 40436 1745 31 both both DT 40436 1745 32 and and CC 40436 1745 33 of of IN 40436 1745 34 each each DT 40436 1745 35 . . . 40436 1746 1 Any any DT 40436 1746 2 attribute attribute NN 40436 1746 3 of of IN 40436 1746 4 one one CD 40436 1746 5 , , , 40436 1746 6 which which WDT 40436 1746 7 does do VBZ 40436 1746 8 not not RB 40436 1746 9 also also RB 40436 1746 10 belong belong VB 40436 1746 11 to to IN 40436 1746 12 the the DT 40436 1746 13 other other JJ 40436 1746 14 , , , 40436 1746 15 will will MD 40436 1746 16 not not RB 40436 1746 17 be be VB 40436 1746 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 1746 19 for for IN 40436 1746 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1746 21 purpose purpose NN 40436 1746 22 . . . 40436 1747 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1747 2 30 30 CD 40436 1747 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1747 4 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1747 5 must must MD 40436 1747 6 depend depend VB 40436 1747 7 upon upon IN 40436 1747 8 some some DT 40436 1747 9 essential essential JJ 40436 1747 10 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 1747 11 which which WDT 40436 1747 12 both both DT 40436 1747 13 have have VBP 40436 1747 14 in in IN 40436 1747 15 common common JJ 40436 1747 16 . . . 40436 1748 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1748 2 31 31 CD 40436 1748 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1748 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1748 5 must must MD 40436 1748 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 1748 7 look look VB 40436 1748 8 out out RP 40436 1748 9 for for IN 40436 1748 10 some some DT 40436 1748 11 such such JJ 40436 1748 12 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 1748 13 , , , 40436 1748 14 which which WDT 40436 1748 15 belongs belong VBZ 40436 1748 16 to to IN 40436 1748 17 both both DT 40436 1748 18 as as RB 40436 1748 19 well well RB 40436 1748 20 as as IN 40436 1748 21 to to IN 40436 1748 22 each each DT 40436 1748 23 separately separately RB 40436 1748 24 . . . 40436 1749 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1749 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1749 3 28 28 CD 40436 1749 4 : : : 40436 1749 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1749 6 , , , 40436 1749 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1749 8 . . . 40436 1750 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1750 2 . . NNP 40436 1750 3 298 298 CD 40436 1750 4 E e NN 40436 1750 5 , , , 40436 1750 6 299 299 CD 40436 1750 7 A. a. NN 40436 1751 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1751 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1751 3 : : : 40436 1751 4 Mantha Mantha NNP 40436 1751 5 / / SYM 40436 1751 6 nô nô NNP 40436 1751 7 , , , 40436 1751 8 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 1751 9 i)/sôs i)/sôs NNP 40436 1751 10 phai phai NNP 40436 1751 11 / / SYM 40436 1751 12 ê ê NNP 40436 1751 13 , , , 40436 1751 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1751 15 e)gô/ e)gô/ NNP 40436 1751 16 , , , 40436 1751 17 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 1751 18 pa pa NNP 40436 1751 19 / / SYM 40436 1751 20 lai lai NNP 40436 1751 21 ai)schu ai)schu NNP 40436 1751 22 / / SYM 40436 1751 23 nesthe nesthe NNP 40436 1751 24 tau tau NN 40436 1751 25 / / SYM 40436 1751 26 tas tas NN 40436 1751 27 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 1751 28 ê(dona\s ê(dona\s NNP 40436 1751 29 pha pha NNP 40436 1751 30 / / SYM 40436 1751 31 nai nai NNP 40436 1751 32 kala\s kala\s NNP 40436 1751 33 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 1751 34 , , , 40436 1751 35 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 1751 36 ou ou NNP 40436 1751 37 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1751 38 dokei= dokei= NNP 40436 1751 39 toi toi NNP 40436 1751 40 = = SYM 40436 1751 41 s s NNP 40436 1751 42 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 1751 43 / / SYM 40436 1751 44 pois pois NN 40436 1751 45 ; ; : 40436 1751 46 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 1751 47 ' ' `` 40436 1751 48 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 1751 49 ou ou NNP 40436 1751 50 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1751 51 tou tou NNP 40436 1751 52 = = SYM 40436 1751 53 to to IN 40436 1751 54 ê)rô ê)rô NNP 40436 1751 55 / / SYM 40436 1751 56 tôn tôn NNP 40436 1751 57 , , , 40436 1751 58 _ _ NNP 40436 1751 59 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 1751 60 dokei= dokei= NNP 40436 1751 61 toi toi NNP 40436 1751 62 = = SYM 40436 1751 63 s s NNP 40436 1751 64 polloi polloi NNP 40436 1751 65 = = SYM 40436 1751 66 s s NNP 40436 1751 67 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 1751 68 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 1751 69 _ _ NNP 40436 1751 70 , , , 40436 1751 71 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 1751 72 ' ' '' 40436 1751 73 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 1751 74 , , , 40436 1751 75 _ _ NNP 40436 1751 76 ti ti NNP 40436 1751 77 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 1751 78 _ _ NNP 40436 1751 79 . . . 40436 1751 80 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1751 81 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1752 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1752 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1752 3 29 29 CD 40436 1752 4 : : : 40436 1752 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1752 6 , , , 40436 1752 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1752 8 . . . 40436 1753 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1753 2 . . NNP 40436 1753 3 299 299 CD 40436 1753 4 D D NNP 40436 1753 5 - - HYPH 40436 1753 6 E. e. NN 40436 1753 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1753 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1753 9 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1753 10 30 30 CD 40436 1753 11 : : : 40436 1753 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1753 13 , , , 40436 1753 14 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1753 15 . . . 40436 1754 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1754 2 . . NNP 40436 1754 3 300 300 CD 40436 1754 4 B. B. NNP 40436 1755 1 A a DT 40436 1755 2 separate separate JJ 40436 1755 3 argument argument NN 40436 1755 4 between between IN 40436 1755 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1755 6 and and CC 40436 1755 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1755 8 is be VBZ 40436 1755 9 here here RB 40436 1755 10 as as IN 40436 1755 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1755 12 were be VBD 40436 1755 13 interpolated interpolate VBN 40436 1755 14 ; ; : 40436 1755 15 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1755 16 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 1755 17 that that IN 40436 1755 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1755 19 does do VBZ 40436 1755 20 not not RB 40436 1755 21 see see VB 40436 1755 22 how how WRB 40436 1755 23 any any DT 40436 1755 24 predicate predicate NN 40436 1755 25 can can MD 40436 1755 26 be be VB 40436 1755 27 true true JJ 40436 1755 28 of of IN 40436 1755 29 both both DT 40436 1755 30 which which WDT 40436 1755 31 is be VBZ 40436 1755 32 not not RB 40436 1755 33 true true JJ 40436 1755 34 of of IN 40436 1755 35 either either CC 40436 1755 36 separately separately RB 40436 1755 37 . . . 40436 1756 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1756 2 points point VBZ 40436 1756 3 out out RP 40436 1756 4 that that IN 40436 1756 5 two two CD 40436 1756 6 men man NNS 40436 1756 7 are be VBP 40436 1756 8 Both both DT 40436 1756 9 , , , 40436 1756 10 even even RB 40436 1756 11 in in IN 40436 1756 12 number number NN 40436 1756 13 , , , 40436 1756 14 while while IN 40436 1756 15 each each DT 40436 1756 16 is be VBZ 40436 1756 17 One one CD 40436 1756 18 , , , 40436 1756 19 an an DT 40436 1756 20 odd odd JJ 40436 1756 21 number number NN 40436 1756 22 . . . 40436 1757 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1757 2 can can MD 40436 1757 3 not not RB 40436 1757 4 say say VB 40436 1757 5 of of IN 40436 1757 6 the the DT 40436 1757 7 two two CD 40436 1757 8 that that WDT 40436 1757 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1757 10 are be VBP 40436 1757 11 one one CD 40436 1757 12 , , , 40436 1757 13 nor nor CC 40436 1757 14 can can MD 40436 1757 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1757 16 say say VB 40436 1757 17 of of IN 40436 1757 18 either either DT 40436 1757 19 that that IN 40436 1757 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1757 21 is be VBZ 40436 1757 22 Both both DT 40436 1757 23 . . . 40436 1758 1 There there EX 40436 1758 2 are be VBP 40436 1758 3 two two CD 40436 1758 4 classes class NNS 40436 1758 5 of of IN 40436 1758 6 predicates predicate NNS 40436 1758 7 ; ; : 40436 1758 8 some some DT 40436 1758 9 which which WDT 40436 1758 10 are be VBP 40436 1758 11 true true JJ 40436 1758 12 of of IN 40436 1758 13 either either DT 40436 1758 14 but but CC 40436 1758 15 not not RB 40436 1758 16 true true JJ 40436 1758 17 of of IN 40436 1758 18 the the DT 40436 1758 19 two two CD 40436 1758 20 together together RB 40436 1758 21 , , , 40436 1758 22 or or CC 40436 1758 23 _ _ NNP 40436 1758 24 vice vice NN 40436 1758 25 versâ versâ NNP 40436 1758 26 _ _ NNP 40436 1758 27 ; ; : 40436 1758 28 some some DT 40436 1758 29 again again RB 40436 1758 30 which which WDT 40436 1758 31 are be VBP 40436 1758 32 true true JJ 40436 1758 33 of of IN 40436 1758 34 the the DT 40436 1758 35 two two CD 40436 1758 36 and and CC 40436 1758 37 true true JJ 40436 1758 38 also also RB 40436 1758 39 of of IN 40436 1758 40 each each DT 40436 1758 41 one one CD 40436 1758 42 -- -- : 40436 1758 43 such such JJ 40436 1758 44 as as IN 40436 1758 45 just just RB 40436 1758 46 , , , 40436 1758 47 wise wise JJ 40436 1758 48 , , , 40436 1758 49 handsome handsome JJ 40436 1758 50 , , , 40436 1758 51 & & CC 40436 1758 52 c. c. NNP 40436 1758 53 p. p. NNP 40436 1758 54 301 301 CD 40436 1758 55 - - SYM 40436 1758 56 303 303 CD 40436 1758 57 B. b. NN 40436 1758 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1759 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1759 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1759 3 31 31 CD 40436 1759 4 : : : 40436 1759 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1759 6 . . . 40436 1760 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1760 2 . . . 40436 1761 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1761 2 . . NNP 40436 1761 3 302 302 CD 40436 1761 4 C. C. NNP 40436 1761 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1761 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1761 7 : : : 40436 1761 8 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 1761 9 ou)si ou)si NNS 40436 1761 10 / / SYM 40436 1761 11 a| a| NN 40436 1761 12 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 1761 13 e)p e)p NNP 40436 1761 14 ' ' POS 40436 1761 15 a)mpho a)mpho NNS 40436 1761 16 / / SYM 40436 1761 17 tera tera NN 40436 1761 18 e(pome e(pome NN 40436 1761 19 / / SYM 40436 1761 20 nê| nê| NNP 40436 1761 21 ô)=|mên ô)=|mên NNP 40436 1761 22 , , , 40436 1761 23 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 1761 24 a)mpho a)mpho NNP 40436 1761 25 / / SYM 40436 1761 26 tera/ tera/ NNP 40436 1761 27 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 1761 28 kala/ kala/ NNP 40436 1761 29 , , , 40436 1761 30 tau tau NNP 40436 1761 31 / / SYM 40436 1761 32 tê| tê| NNP 40436 1761 33 dei dei NNP 40436 1761 34 = = SYM 40436 1761 35 n n NNP 40436 1761 36 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 1761 37 kala\ kala\ NNP 40436 1761 38 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 1761 39 , , , 40436 1761 40 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 1761 41 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1761 42 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 1761 43 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 1761 44 e(/tera e(/tera NNP 40436 1761 45 a)poleipome a)poleipome NNP 40436 1761 46 / / SYM 40436 1761 47 nê| nê| NNP 40436 1761 48 mê/. mê/. NN 40436 1762 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1762 2 e(/ti e(/ti NNP 40436 1762 3 nu nu NNP 40436 1762 4 = = SYM 40436 1762 5 n n NNP 40436 1762 6 oi)=omai oi)=omai NNP 40436 1762 7 . . . 40436 1762 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1762 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1763 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1763 2 Side side NN 40436 1763 3 - - HYPH 40436 1763 4 note note NN 40436 1763 5 : : : 40436 1763 6 Answer answer VB 40436 1763 7 -- -- . 40436 1763 8 There there EX 40436 1763 9 is be VBZ 40436 1763 10 , , , 40436 1763 11 belonging belong VBG 40436 1763 12 to to IN 40436 1763 13 each each DT 40436 1763 14 and and CC 40436 1763 15 to to IN 40436 1763 16 both both DT 40436 1763 17 in in IN 40436 1763 18 common common JJ 40436 1763 19 , , , 40436 1763 20 the the DT 40436 1763 21 property property NN 40436 1763 22 of of IN 40436 1763 23 being be VBG 40436 1763 24 innocuous innocuous JJ 40436 1763 25 and and CC 40436 1763 26 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1763 27 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1763 28 -- -- : 40436 1763 29 upon upon IN 40436 1763 30 this this DT 40436 1763 31 ground ground NN 40436 1763 32 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1763 33 are be VBP 40436 1763 34 called call VBN 40436 1763 35 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1763 36 . . . 40436 1763 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1764 1 Now now RB 40436 1764 2 there there EX 40436 1764 3 is be VBZ 40436 1764 4 one one CD 40436 1764 5 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 1764 6 which which WDT 40436 1764 7 may may MD 40436 1764 8 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 1764 9 serve serve VB 40436 1764 10 . . . 40436 1765 1 The the DT 40436 1765 2 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1765 3 of of IN 40436 1765 4 sight sight NN 40436 1765 5 and and CC 40436 1765 6 hearing hearing NN 40436 1765 7 , , , 40436 1765 8 both both DT 40436 1765 9 and and CC 40436 1765 10 each each DT 40436 1765 11 , , , 40436 1765 12 are be VBP 40436 1765 13 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 1765 14 from from IN 40436 1765 15 other other JJ 40436 1765 16 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 1765 17 by by IN 40436 1765 18 being be VBG 40436 1765 19 the the DT 40436 1765 20 most most RBS 40436 1765 21 innocuous innocuous JJ 40436 1765 22 and and CC 40436 1765 23 the the DT 40436 1765 24 best good JJS 40436 1765 25 . . . 40436 1766 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1766 2 32 32 CD 40436 1766 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1766 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1766 5 is be VBZ 40436 1766 6 for for IN 40436 1766 7 this this DT 40436 1766 8 reason reason NN 40436 1766 9 that that WDT 40436 1766 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1766 11 call call VBP 40436 1766 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1766 13 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1766 14 . . . 40436 1767 1 The the DT 40436 1767 2 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1767 3 , , , 40436 1767 4 then then RB 40436 1767 5 , , , 40436 1767 6 is be VBZ 40436 1767 7 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1767 8 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 1767 9 -- -- : 40436 1767 10 or or CC 40436 1767 11 pleasure pleasure VBP 40436 1767 12 producing produce VBG 40436 1767 13 good good NN 40436 1767 14 -- -- : 40436 1767 15 for for IN 40436 1767 16 the the DT 40436 1767 17 profitable profitable JJ 40436 1767 18 is be VBZ 40436 1767 19 , , , 40436 1767 20 that that WDT 40436 1767 21 which which WDT 40436 1767 22 produces produce VBZ 40436 1767 23 good good JJ 40436 1767 24 . . . 40436 1768 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1768 2 33 33 CD 40436 1768 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1768 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1768 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1768 6 32 32 CD 40436 1768 7 : : : 40436 1768 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1768 9 . . . 40436 1769 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1769 2 . . . 40436 1770 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1770 2 . . NNP 40436 1770 3 303 303 CD 40436 1770 4 E. E. NNP 40436 1770 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1770 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1770 7 : : : 40436 1770 8 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 1770 9 a)sine a)sine NNP 40436 1770 10 / / SYM 40436 1770 11 statai statai NNP 40436 1770 12 au(=tai au(=tai UH 40436 1770 13 tô tô NNP 40436 1770 14 = = SYM 40436 1770 15 n n XX 40436 1770 16 ê(donô ê(donô NNP 40436 1770 17 = = SYM 40436 1770 18 n n CC 40436 1770 19 ei)si ei)si NNP 40436 1770 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1770 21 be be VB 40436 1770 22 / / SYM 40436 1770 23 ltistai ltistai NNP 40436 1770 24 , , , 40436 1770 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1770 26 a)mpho a)mpho NNP 40436 1770 27 / / SYM 40436 1770 28 terai terai NNP 40436 1770 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1770 30 e(kate e(kate NNP 40436 1770 31 / / SYM 40436 1770 32 ra ra NNP 40436 1770 33 . . . 40436 1770 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1770 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1771 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1771 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1771 3 33 33 CD 40436 1771 4 : : : 40436 1771 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1771 6 . . . 40436 1772 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1772 2 . . . 40436 1773 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1773 2 . . NNP 40436 1773 3 303 303 CD 40436 1773 4 E. E. NNP 40436 1773 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1773 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1773 7 : : : 40436 1773 8 le le NNP 40436 1773 9 / / SYM 40436 1773 10 gete gete NNP 40436 1773 11 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 1773 12 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1773 13 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 1773 14 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 1773 15 , , , 40436 1773 16 _ _ NNP 40436 1773 17 ê(donê\n ê(donê\n NNP 40436 1773 18 ô)phe ô)phe NNP 40436 1773 19 / / SYM 40436 1773 20 limon limon NNP 40436 1773 21 _ _ NNP 40436 1773 22 . . . 40436 1773 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1773 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1774 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1774 2 Side side NN 40436 1774 3 - - HYPH 40436 1774 4 note note NN 40436 1774 5 : : : 40436 1774 6 This this DT 40436 1774 7 will will MD 40436 1774 8 not not RB 40436 1774 9 hold hold VB 40436 1774 10 -- -- : 40436 1774 11 the the DT 40436 1774 12 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 1774 13 is be VBZ 40436 1774 14 the the DT 40436 1774 15 cause cause NN 40436 1774 16 of of IN 40436 1774 17 Good Good NNP 40436 1774 18 , , , 40436 1774 19 and and CC 40436 1774 20 is be VBZ 40436 1774 21 therefore therefore RB 40436 1774 22 different different JJ 40436 1774 23 from from IN 40436 1774 24 Good Good NNP 40436 1774 25 -- -- : 40436 1774 26 to to TO 40436 1774 27 say say VB 40436 1774 28 that that IN 40436 1774 29 the the DT 40436 1774 30 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1774 31 is be VBZ 40436 1774 32 the the DT 40436 1774 33 Profitable Profitable NNP 40436 1774 34 , , , 40436 1774 35 is be VBZ 40436 1774 36 to to TO 40436 1774 37 say say VB 40436 1774 38 that that IN 40436 1774 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1774 40 is be VBZ 40436 1774 41 different different JJ 40436 1774 42 from from IN 40436 1774 43 Good Good NNP 40436 1774 44 but but CC 40436 1774 45 this this DT 40436 1774 46 has have VBZ 40436 1774 47 been be VBN 40436 1774 48 already already RB 40436 1774 49 declared declare VBN 40436 1774 50 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 1774 51 . . . 40436 1774 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1775 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 1775 2 the the DT 40436 1775 3 objector objector NN 40436 1775 4 will will MD 40436 1775 5 not not RB 40436 1775 6 be be VB 40436 1775 7 satisfied satisfy VBN 40436 1775 8 even even RB 40436 1775 9 with with IN 40436 1775 10 this this DT 40436 1775 11 . . . 40436 1776 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1776 2 will will MD 40436 1776 3 tell tell VB 40436 1776 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1776 5 -- -- : 40436 1776 6 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1776 7 declare declare VBP 40436 1776 8 the the DT 40436 1776 9 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1776 10 to to TO 40436 1776 11 be be VB 40436 1776 12 Pleasure pleasure NN 40436 1776 13 producing produce VBG 40436 1776 14 good good NN 40436 1776 15 . . . 40436 1777 1 But but CC 40436 1777 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1777 3 before before RB 40436 1777 4 agreed agree VBD 40436 1777 5 , , , 40436 1777 6 that that IN 40436 1777 7 the the DT 40436 1777 8 producing produce VBG 40436 1777 9 agent agent NN 40436 1777 10 or or CC 40436 1777 11 cause cause NN 40436 1777 12 is be VBZ 40436 1777 13 different different JJ 40436 1777 14 from from IN 40436 1777 15 what what WP 40436 1777 16 is be VBZ 40436 1777 17 produced produce VBN 40436 1777 18 or or CC 40436 1777 19 the the DT 40436 1777 20 effect effect NN 40436 1777 21 . . . 40436 1778 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 1778 2 , , , 40436 1778 3 the the DT 40436 1778 4 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1778 5 is be VBZ 40436 1778 6 different different JJ 40436 1778 7 from from IN 40436 1778 8 the the DT 40436 1778 9 good good NN 40436 1778 10 : : : 40436 1778 11 or or CC 40436 1778 12 , , , 40436 1778 13 in in IN 40436 1778 14 other other JJ 40436 1778 15 words word NNS 40436 1778 16 , , , 40436 1778 17 the the DT 40436 1778 18 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1778 19 is be VBZ 40436 1778 20 not not RB 40436 1778 21 good good JJ 40436 1778 22 , , , 40436 1778 23 nor nor CC 40436 1778 24 is be VBZ 40436 1778 25 the the DT 40436 1778 26 Good good JJ 40436 1778 27 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1778 28 -- -- : 40436 1778 29 if if IN 40436 1778 30 each each DT 40436 1778 31 of of IN 40436 1778 32 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1778 33 is be VBZ 40436 1778 34 a a DT 40436 1778 35 different different JJ 40436 1778 36 thing thing NN 40436 1778 37 . . . 40436 1779 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1779 2 34 34 CD 40436 1779 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1779 4 Now now RB 40436 1779 5 these these DT 40436 1779 6 propositions proposition NNS 40436 1779 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1779 8 have have VBP 40436 1779 9 already already RB 40436 1779 10 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 1779 11 to to TO 40436 1779 12 be be VB 40436 1779 13 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 1779 14 , , , 40436 1779 15 so so IN 40436 1779 16 that that IN 40436 1779 17 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1779 18 present present JJ 40436 1779 19 explanation explanation NN 40436 1779 20 will will MD 40436 1779 21 not not RB 40436 1779 22 stand stand VB 40436 1779 23 better well JJR 40436 1779 24 than than IN 40436 1779 25 the the DT 40436 1779 26 preceding preceding NN 40436 1779 27 . . . 40436 1780 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1780 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1780 3 34 34 CD 40436 1780 4 : : : 40436 1780 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1780 6 . . . 40436 1781 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1781 2 . . . 40436 1782 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1782 2 . . NNP 40436 1782 3 303 303 CD 40436 1782 4 E--304 e--304 SYM 40436 1782 5 A. a. NN 40436 1783 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1783 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1783 3 : : : 40436 1783 4 Ou)/koun Ou)/koun NNP 40436 1783 5 ô)phe ô)phe NNP 40436 1783 6 / / SYM 40436 1783 7 limon limon NNP 40436 1783 8 , , , 40436 1783 9 phê phê NNP 40436 1783 10 / / SYM 40436 1783 11 sei sei NN 40436 1783 12 , , , 40436 1783 13 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1783 14 poiou poiou NNP 40436 1783 15 = = SYM 40436 1783 16 n n CC 40436 1783 17 ta)gatho ta)gatho NNP 40436 1783 18 / / SYM 40436 1783 19 n n NN 40436 1783 20 , , , 40436 1783 21 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1783 22 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1783 23 poiou poiou NNP 40436 1783 24 = = SYM 40436 1783 25 n n NNP 40436 1783 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1783 27 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1783 28 poiou poiou NNP 40436 1783 29 / / SYM 40436 1783 30 menon menon NNP 40436 1783 31 , , , 40436 1783 32 e(/teron e(/teron NNP 40436 1783 33 nu nu NNP 40436 1783 34 = = SYM 40436 1783 35 n n CC 40436 1783 36 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 1783 37 e)pha e)pha NNPS 40436 1783 38 / / SYM 40436 1783 39 nê nê NNP 40436 1783 40 , , , 40436 1783 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1783 42 ei)s ei) VBZ 40436 1783 43 to\n to\n NNP 40436 1783 44 pro pro JJ 40436 1783 45 / / SYM 40436 1783 46 teron teron NNP 40436 1783 47 lo lo NNP 40436 1783 48 / / SYM 40436 1783 49 gon gon NNP 40436 1783 50 ê(/kei ê(/kei NNP 40436 1783 51 u(mi u(mi NNP 40436 1783 52 = = SYM 40436 1783 53 n n CC 40436 1783 54 o o NN 40436 1783 55 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1783 56 lo lo NNP 40436 1783 57 / / SYM 40436 1783 58 gos gos NN 40436 1783 59 ? ? . 40436 1784 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1784 2 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 1784 3 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 1784 4 to\ to\ NN 40436 1784 5 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n JJ 40436 1784 6 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 1784 7 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 1784 8 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 1784 9 ou)/te ou)/te XX 40436 1784 10 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1784 11 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 1784 12 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 1784 13 / / SYM 40436 1784 14 n n NNP 40436 1784 15 , , , 40436 1784 16 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 1784 17 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 1784 18 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 1784 19 = = SYM 40436 1784 20 n n NNP 40436 1784 21 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 1784 22 / / SYM 40436 1784 23 tero tero NNP 40436 1784 24 / / SYM 40436 1784 25 n n NNP 40436 1784 26 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 1784 27 _ _ NNP 40436 1784 28 . . . 40436 1784 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1785 1 These these DT 40436 1785 2 last last JJ 40436 1785 3 words word NNS 40436 1785 4 deserve deserve VBP 40436 1785 5 attention attention NN 40436 1785 6 , , , 40436 1785 7 because because IN 40436 1785 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1785 9 coincide coincide VBP 40436 1785 10 with with IN 40436 1785 11 the the DT 40436 1785 12 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1785 13 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 1785 14 to to IN 40436 1785 15 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNP 40436 1785 16 , , , 40436 1785 17 which which WDT 40436 1785 18 has have VBZ 40436 1785 19 caused cause VBN 40436 1785 20 so so RB 40436 1785 21 many many JJ 40436 1785 22 hard hard JJ 40436 1785 23 words word NNS 40436 1785 24 to to TO 40436 1785 25 be be VB 40436 1785 26 applied apply VBN 40436 1785 27 to to IN 40436 1785 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1785 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1785 30 as as RB 40436 1785 31 well well RB 40436 1785 32 as as IN 40436 1785 33 to to IN 40436 1785 34 Stilpon Stilpon NNP 40436 1785 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1785 36 by by IN 40436 1785 37 critics critic NNS 40436 1785 38 , , , 40436 1785 39 from from IN 40436 1785 40 Kolôtes Kolôtes NNP 40436 1785 41 downwards downwards RB 40436 1785 42 . . . 40436 1786 1 The the DT 40436 1786 2 general general JJ 40436 1786 3 principle principle NN 40436 1786 4 here here RB 40436 1786 5 laid lay VBD 40436 1786 6 down down RP 40436 1786 7 by by IN 40436 1786 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1786 9 is be VBZ 40436 1786 10 -- -- : 40436 1786 11 A a NN 40436 1786 12 is be VBZ 40436 1786 13 something something NN 40436 1786 14 different different JJ 40436 1786 15 from from IN 40436 1786 16 B b NN 40436 1786 17 , , , 40436 1786 18 therefore therefore RB 40436 1786 19 A a NN 40436 1786 20 is be VBZ 40436 1786 21 not not RB 40436 1786 22 B b NN 40436 1786 23 and and CC 40436 1786 24 B b NN 40436 1786 25 is be VBZ 40436 1786 26 not not RB 40436 1786 27 A. a. NN 40436 1787 1 In in IN 40436 1787 2 other other JJ 40436 1787 3 words word NNS 40436 1787 4 , , , 40436 1787 5 A a DT 40436 1787 6 can can MD 40436 1787 7 not not RB 40436 1787 8 be be VB 40436 1787 9 predicated predicate VBN 40436 1787 10 of of IN 40436 1787 11 B b NN 40436 1787 12 nor nor CC 40436 1787 13 B B NNP 40436 1787 14 of of IN 40436 1787 15 A. A. NNP 40436 1787 16 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNPS 40436 1787 17 said say VBD 40436 1787 18 in in IN 40436 1787 19 like like UH 40436 1787 20 manner--[Greek manner--[greek CD 40436 1787 21 : : : 40436 1787 22 A)/nthrôpos A)/nthrôpos NNP 40436 1787 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1787 24 and and CC 40436 1787 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1787 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1787 27 : : : 40436 1787 28 A)gatho\s A)gatho\s NNP 40436 1787 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1787 30 are be VBP 40436 1787 31 different different JJ 40436 1787 32 from from IN 40436 1787 33 each each DT 40436 1787 34 other other JJ 40436 1787 35 , , , 40436 1787 36 therefore therefore RB 40436 1787 37 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1787 38 can can MD 40436 1787 39 not not RB 40436 1787 40 say say VB 40436 1787 41 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1787 42 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1787 43 : : : 40436 1787 44 A)/nthrôpos A)/nthrôpos NNP 40436 1787 45 e)stin e)stin , 40436 1787 46 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 1787 47 / / SYM 40436 1787 48 s s NN 40436 1787 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1787 50 . . . 40436 1788 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 1788 2 can can MD 40436 1788 3 only only RB 40436 1788 4 say say VB 40436 1788 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1788 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1788 7 : : : 40436 1788 8 A)/nthrôpos A)/nthrôpos NNP 40436 1788 9 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 1788 10 A)/nthrôpos]--A)gatho a)/nthrôpos]--a)gatho ADD 40436 1788 11 / / SYM 40436 1788 12 s s NNPS 40436 1788 13 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 1788 14 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 1788 15 / / SYM 40436 1788 16 s s NN 40436 1788 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1788 18 . . . 40436 1789 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1789 2 have have VBP 40436 1789 3 touched touch VBN 40436 1789 4 farther far RBR 40436 1789 5 upon upon IN 40436 1789 6 this this DT 40436 1789 7 point point NN 40436 1789 8 in in IN 40436 1789 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1789 10 chapter chapter NN 40436 1789 11 upon upon IN 40436 1789 12 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNPS 40436 1789 13 and and CC 40436 1789 14 the the DT 40436 1789 15 other other JJ 40436 1789 16 Viri Viri NNP 40436 1789 17 Sokratici Sokratici NNP 40436 1789 18 . . . 40436 1789 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1790 1 * * NFP 40436 1790 2 * * NFP 40436 1790 3 * * NFP 40436 1790 4 * * NFP 40436 1790 5 * * NFP 40436 1790 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1790 7 Side side NN 40436 1790 8 - - HYPH 40436 1790 9 note note NN 40436 1790 10 : : : 40436 1790 11 Remarks remark NNS 40436 1790 12 upon upon IN 40436 1790 13 the the DT 40436 1790 14 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 1790 15 -- -- : 40436 1790 16 the the DT 40436 1790 17 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1790 18 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 1790 19 to to IN 40436 1790 20 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1790 21 are be VBP 40436 1790 22 special special JJ 40436 1790 23 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 1790 24 examples example NNS 40436 1790 25 : : : 40436 1790 26 those those DT 40436 1790 27 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 1790 28 to to IN 40436 1790 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1790 30 are be VBP 40436 1790 31 attempts attempt NNS 40436 1790 32 to to TO 40436 1790 33 assign assign VB 40436 1790 34 some some DT 40436 1790 35 general general JJ 40436 1790 36 concept concept NN 40436 1790 37 . . . 40436 1790 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1791 1 Thus thus RB 40436 1791 2 finish finish VB 40436 1791 3 the the DT 40436 1791 4 three three CD 40436 1791 5 distinct distinct JJ 40436 1791 6 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1791 7 of of IN 40436 1791 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1791 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1791 10 : : : 40436 1791 11 To\ To\ NNP 40436 1791 12 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 1791 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1791 14 , , , 40436 1791 15 which which WDT 40436 1791 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1791 17 in in IN 40436 1791 18 this this DT 40436 1791 19 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1791 20 causes cause VBZ 40436 1791 21 to to TO 40436 1791 22 be be VB 40436 1791 23 first first RB 40436 1791 24 suggested suggest VBN 40436 1791 25 by by IN 40436 1791 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1791 27 , , , 40436 1791 28 successively successively RB 40436 1791 29 accepted accept VBN 40436 1791 30 by by IN 40436 1791 31 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1791 32 , , , 40436 1791 33 and and CC 40436 1791 34 successively successively RB 40436 1791 35 refuted refute VBN 40436 1791 36 by by IN 40436 1791 37 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1791 38 . . . 40436 1792 1 In in IN 40436 1792 2 comparing compare VBG 40436 1792 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1792 4 with with IN 40436 1792 5 the the DT 40436 1792 6 three three CD 40436 1792 7 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1792 8 which which WDT 40436 1792 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1792 10 puts put VBZ 40436 1792 11 into into IN 40436 1792 12 the the DT 40436 1792 13 mouth mouth NN 40436 1792 14 of of IN 40436 1792 15 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1792 16 , , , 40436 1792 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1792 18 note note VBP 40436 1792 19 this this DT 40436 1792 20 distinction distinction NN 40436 1792 21 : : : 40436 1792 22 That that IN 40436 1792 23 the the DT 40436 1792 24 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1792 25 proposed propose VBN 40436 1792 26 by by IN 40436 1792 27 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1792 28 are be VBP 40436 1792 29 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 1792 30 particular particular JJ 40436 1792 31 exemplifications exemplification NNS 40436 1792 32 of of IN 40436 1792 33 the the DT 40436 1792 34 Beautiful Beautiful NNP 40436 1792 35 , , , 40436 1792 36 substituted substitute VBN 40436 1792 37 in in IN 40436 1792 38 place place NN 40436 1792 39 of of IN 40436 1792 40 the the DT 40436 1792 41 general general JJ 40436 1792 42 concept concept NN 40436 1792 43 : : : 40436 1792 44 as as IN 40436 1792 45 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1792 46 remarked remark VBD 40436 1792 47 , , , 40436 1792 48 in in IN 40436 1792 49 the the DT 40436 1792 50 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 1792 51 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 1792 52 , , , 40436 1792 53 that that IN 40436 1792 54 the the DT 40436 1792 55 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1792 56 of of IN 40436 1792 57 the the DT 40436 1792 58 Holy Holy NNP 40436 1792 59 given give VBN 40436 1792 60 by by IN 40436 1792 61 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 1792 62 in in IN 40436 1792 63 reply reply NN 40436 1792 64 to to IN 40436 1792 65 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1792 66 , , , 40436 1792 67 were be VBD 40436 1792 68 of of IN 40436 1792 69 the the DT 40436 1792 70 same same JJ 40436 1792 71 exemplifying exemplifying JJ 40436 1792 72 character character NN 40436 1792 73 . . . 40436 1793 1 On on IN 40436 1793 2 the the DT 40436 1793 3 contrary contrary NN 40436 1793 4 , , , 40436 1793 5 those those DT 40436 1793 6 suggested suggest VBN 40436 1793 7 by by IN 40436 1793 8 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1793 9 keep keep VBP 40436 1793 10 in in IN 40436 1793 11 the the DT 40436 1793 12 region region NN 40436 1793 13 of of IN 40436 1793 14 abstractions abstraction NNS 40436 1793 15 , , , 40436 1793 16 and and CC 40436 1793 17 seek seek VB 40436 1793 18 to to TO 40436 1793 19 discover discover VB 40436 1793 20 some some DT 40436 1793 21 more more RBR 40436 1793 22 general general JJ 40436 1793 23 concept concept NN 40436 1793 24 , , , 40436 1793 25 of of IN 40436 1793 26 which which WDT 40436 1793 27 the the DT 40436 1793 28 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1793 29 is be VBZ 40436 1793 30 only only RB 40436 1793 31 a a DT 40436 1793 32 derivative derivative NN 40436 1793 33 or or CC 40436 1793 34 a a DT 40436 1793 35 modification modification NN 40436 1793 36 , , , 40436 1793 37 so so IN 40436 1793 38 as as IN 40436 1793 39 to to TO 40436 1793 40 render render VB 40436 1793 41 a a DT 40436 1793 42 definition definition NN 40436 1793 43 of of IN 40436 1793 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1793 45 practicable practicable JJ 40436 1793 46 . . . 40436 1794 1 To to TO 40436 1794 2 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 1794 3 this this DT 40436 1794 4 difference difference NN 40436 1794 5 by by IN 40436 1794 6 the the DT 40436 1794 7 language language NN 40436 1794 8 of of IN 40436 1794 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 1794 10 Whewell Whewell NNP 40436 1794 11 respecting respect VBG 40436 1794 12 many many JJ 40436 1794 13 of of IN 40436 1794 14 the the DT 40436 1794 15 classifications classification NNS 40436 1794 16 in in IN 40436 1794 17 Natural Natural NNP 40436 1794 18 History History NNP 40436 1794 19 , , , 40436 1794 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1794 21 may may MD 40436 1794 22 say say VB 40436 1794 23 -- -- : 40436 1794 24 That that IN 40436 1794 25 according accord VBG 40436 1794 26 to to IN 40436 1794 27 the the DT 40436 1794 28 views view NNS 40436 1794 29 here here RB 40436 1794 30 represented represent VBN 40436 1794 31 by by IN 40436 1794 32 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1794 33 , , , 40436 1794 34 the the DT 40436 1794 35 group group NN 40436 1794 36 of of IN 40436 1794 37 objects object NNS 40436 1794 38 called call VBN 40436 1794 39 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1794 40 is be VBZ 40436 1794 41 given give VBN 40436 1794 42 by by IN 40436 1794 43 Type type NN 40436 1794 44 , , , 40436 1794 45 not not RB 40436 1794 46 by by IN 40436 1794 47 Definition:[35 Definition:[35 NNP 40436 1794 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1794 49 while while IN 40436 1794 50 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1794 51 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 1794 52 like like IN 40436 1794 53 one one CD 40436 1794 54 convinced convince VBD 40436 1794 55 that that IN 40436 1794 56 some some DT 40436 1794 57 common common JJ 40436 1794 58 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 1794 59 attribute attribute NN 40436 1794 60 may may MD 40436 1794 61 be be VB 40436 1794 62 found find VBN 40436 1794 63 , , , 40436 1794 64 on on IN 40436 1794 65 which which WDT 40436 1794 66 to to TO 40436 1794 67 rest rest VB 40436 1794 68 a a DT 40436 1794 69 Definition definition NN 40436 1794 70 . . . 40436 1795 1 To to TO 40436 1795 2 search search VB 40436 1795 3 for for IN 40436 1795 4 Definitions definition NNS 40436 1795 5 of of IN 40436 1795 6 general general JJ 40436 1795 7 words word NNS 40436 1795 8 , , , 40436 1795 9 was be VBD 40436 1795 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1795 11 as as IN 40436 1795 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 1795 13 remarks remark VBZ 40436 1795 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1795 15 a a DT 40436 1795 16 novelty novelty NN 40436 1795 17 , , , 40436 1795 18 and and CC 40436 1795 19 a a DT 40436 1795 20 valuable valuable JJ 40436 1795 21 novelty novelty NN 40436 1795 22 , , , 40436 1795 23 introduced introduce VBN 40436 1795 24 by by IN 40436 1795 25 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1795 26 . . . 40436 1796 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1796 2 contemporaries contemporary NNS 40436 1796 3 , , , 40436 1796 4 the the DT 40436 1796 5 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 1796 6 among among IN 40436 1796 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1796 8 , , , 40436 1796 9 were be VBD 40436 1796 10 not not RB 40436 1796 11 accustomed accustomed JJ 40436 1796 12 to to IN 40436 1796 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1796 14 : : : 40436 1796 15 and and CC 40436 1796 16 here here RB 40436 1796 17 the the DT 40436 1796 18 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 1796 19 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1796 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1796 21 according accord VBG 40436 1796 22 to to IN 40436 1796 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1796 24 's 's POS 40436 1796 25 frequent frequent JJ 40436 1796 26 manner manner NN 40436 1796 27 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1796 28 is be VBZ 40436 1796 29 derided deride VBN 40436 1796 30 as as IN 40436 1796 31 talking talk VBG 40436 1796 32 nonsense,[36 nonsense,[36 NNP 40436 1796 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1796 34 because because IN 40436 1796 35 , , , 40436 1796 36 when when WRB 40436 1796 37 asked ask VBN 40436 1796 38 for for IN 40436 1796 39 an an DT 40436 1796 40 explanation explanation NN 40436 1796 41 of of IN 40436 1796 42 The the DT 40436 1796 43 Self Self NNP 40436 1796 44 - - HYPH 40436 1796 45 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1796 46 , , , 40436 1796 47 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1796 48 answers answer VBZ 40436 1796 49 by by IN 40436 1796 50 citing cite VBG 40436 1796 51 special special JJ 40436 1796 52 instances instance NNS 40436 1796 53 of of IN 40436 1796 54 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1796 55 objects object NNS 40436 1796 56 . . . 40436 1797 1 But but CC 40436 1797 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1797 3 must must MD 40436 1797 4 remember remember VB 40436 1797 5 , , , 40436 1797 6 first first RB 40436 1797 7 , , , 40436 1797 8 that that IN 40436 1797 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1797 10 , , , 40436 1797 11 who who WP 40436 1797 12 is be VBZ 40436 1797 13 introduced introduce VBN 40436 1797 14 as as IN 40436 1797 15 trying try VBG 40436 1797 16 several several JJ 40436 1797 17 general general JJ 40436 1797 18 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1797 19 of of IN 40436 1797 20 the the DT 40436 1797 21 Self Self NNP 40436 1797 22 - - HYPH 40436 1797 23 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1797 24 , , , 40436 1797 25 does do VBZ 40436 1797 26 not not RB 40436 1797 27 find find VB 40436 1797 28 one one CD 40436 1797 29 which which WDT 40436 1797 30 will will MD 40436 1797 31 stand stand VB 40436 1797 32 : : : 40436 1797 33 next next RB 40436 1797 34 , , , 40436 1797 35 that that IN 40436 1797 36 even even RB 40436 1797 37 if if IN 40436 1797 38 one one CD 40436 1797 39 such such JJ 40436 1797 40 could could MD 40436 1797 41 be be VB 40436 1797 42 found find VBN 40436 1797 43 , , , 40436 1797 44 particular particular JJ 40436 1797 45 instances instance NNS 40436 1797 46 can can MD 40436 1797 47 never never RB 40436 1797 48 be be VB 40436 1797 49 dispensed dispense VBN 40436 1797 50 with with IN 40436 1797 51 , , , 40436 1797 52 in in IN 40436 1797 53 the the DT 40436 1797 54 way way NN 40436 1797 55 of of IN 40436 1797 56 illustration illustration NN 40436 1797 57 ; ; : 40436 1797 58 lastly lastly RB 40436 1797 59 , , , 40436 1797 60 that that IN 40436 1797 61 there there EX 40436 1797 62 are be VBP 40436 1797 63 many many JJ 40436 1797 64 general general JJ 40436 1797 65 terms term NNS 40436 1797 66 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1797 67 the the DT 40436 1797 68 Beautiful Beautiful NNP 40436 1797 69 being be VBG 40436 1797 70 one one CD 40436 1797 71 of of IN 40436 1797 72 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1797 73 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1797 74 of of IN 40436 1797 75 which which WDT 40436 1797 76 no no DT 40436 1797 77 definitions definition NNS 40436 1797 78 can can MD 40436 1797 79 be be VB 40436 1797 80 provided provide VBN 40436 1797 81 , , , 40436 1797 82 and and CC 40436 1797 83 which which WDT 40436 1797 84 can can MD 40436 1797 85 only only RB 40436 1797 86 be be VB 40436 1797 87 imperfectly imperfectly RB 40436 1797 88 explained explain VBN 40436 1797 89 , , , 40436 1797 90 by by IN 40436 1797 91 enumerating enumerate VBG 40436 1797 92 a a DT 40436 1797 93 variety variety NN 40436 1797 94 of of IN 40436 1797 95 objects object NNS 40436 1797 96 to to TO 40436 1797 97 which which WDT 40436 1797 98 the the DT 40436 1797 99 term term NN 40436 1797 100 in in IN 40436 1797 101 question question NN 40436 1797 102 is be VBZ 40436 1797 103 applied apply VBN 40436 1797 104 . . . 40436 1798 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1798 2 37 37 CD 40436 1798 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1798 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1798 5 thought think VBD 40436 1798 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1798 7 entitled entitle VBD 40436 1798 8 to to TO 40436 1798 9 objectivise objectivise VB 40436 1798 10 every every DT 40436 1798 11 general general JJ 40436 1798 12 term term NN 40436 1798 13 , , , 40436 1798 14 or or CC 40436 1798 15 to to TO 40436 1798 16 assume assume VB 40436 1798 17 a a DT 40436 1798 18 substantive substantive JJ 40436 1798 19 Ens Ens NNP 40436 1798 20 , , , 40436 1798 21 called call VBD 40436 1798 22 a a DT 40436 1798 23 Form Form NNP 40436 1798 24 or or CC 40436 1798 25 Idea Idea NNP 40436 1798 26 , , , 40436 1798 27 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 1798 28 to to IN 40436 1798 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1798 30 . . . 40436 1799 1 This this DT 40436 1799 2 was be VBD 40436 1799 3 a a DT 40436 1799 4 logical logical JJ 40436 1799 5 mistake mistake NN 40436 1799 6 quite quite RB 40436 1799 7 as as RB 40436 1799 8 serious serious JJ 40436 1799 9 as as IN 40436 1799 10 any any DT 40436 1799 11 which which WDT 40436 1799 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1799 13 know know VBP 40436 1799 14 to to TO 40436 1799 15 have have VB 40436 1799 16 been be VBN 40436 1799 17 committed commit VBN 40436 1799 18 by by IN 40436 1799 19 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1799 20 or or CC 40436 1799 21 any any DT 40436 1799 22 other other JJ 40436 1799 23 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 1799 24 . . . 40436 1800 1 The the DT 40436 1800 2 assumption assumption NN 40436 1800 3 that that IN 40436 1800 4 wherever wherever WRB 40436 1800 5 there there EX 40436 1800 6 is be VBZ 40436 1800 7 a a DT 40436 1800 8 general general JJ 40436 1800 9 term term NN 40436 1800 10 , , , 40436 1800 11 there there EX 40436 1800 12 must must MD 40436 1800 13 also also RB 40436 1800 14 be be VB 40436 1800 15 a a DT 40436 1800 16 generic generic JJ 40436 1800 17 attribute attribute NN 40436 1800 18 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 1800 19 to to IN 40436 1800 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1800 21 -- -- : 40436 1800 22 is be VBZ 40436 1800 23 one one CD 40436 1800 24 which which WDT 40436 1800 25 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 1800 26 takes take VBZ 40436 1800 27 much much JJ 40436 1800 28 pains pain NNS 40436 1800 29 to to IN 40436 1800 30 negative negative JJ 40436 1800 31 : : : 40436 1800 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1800 33 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 1800 34 terms term NNS 40436 1800 35 of of IN 40436 1800 36 transitional transitional JJ 40436 1800 37 analogy analogy NN 40436 1800 38 , , , 40436 1800 39 as as RB 40436 1800 40 well well RB 40436 1800 41 as as IN 40436 1800 42 terms term NNS 40436 1800 43 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 1800 44 : : : 40436 1800 45 while while IN 40436 1800 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1800 47 also also RB 40436 1800 48 especially especially RB 40436 1800 49 numbers number VBZ 40436 1800 50 the the DT 40436 1800 51 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1800 52 among among IN 40436 1800 53 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 1800 54 terms term NNS 40436 1800 55 . . . 40436 1801 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1801 2 38 38 CD 40436 1801 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1801 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1801 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1801 6 35 35 CD 40436 1801 7 : : : 40436 1801 8 See see VB 40436 1801 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 1801 10 Whewell Whewell NNP 40436 1801 11 's 's POS 40436 1801 12 ' ' `` 40436 1801 13 History history NN 40436 1801 14 of of IN 40436 1801 15 the the DT 40436 1801 16 Inductive Inductive NNP 40436 1801 17 Sciences Sciences NNPS 40436 1801 18 , , , 40436 1801 19 ' ' '' 40436 1801 20 ii ii PRP 40436 1801 21 . . . 40436 1802 1 120 120 CD 40436 1802 2 seq seq NN 40436 1802 3 . . . 40436 1803 1 ; ; : 40436 1803 2 and and CC 40436 1803 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 1803 4 John John NNP 40436 1803 5 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 1803 6 Mill Mill NNP 40436 1803 7 's 's POS 40436 1803 8 ' ' '' 40436 1803 9 System System NNP 40436 1803 10 of of IN 40436 1803 11 Logic Logic NNP 40436 1803 12 , , , 40436 1803 13 ' ' '' 40436 1803 14 iv iv XX 40436 1803 15 . . . 40436 1804 1 8 8 CD 40436 1804 2 , , , 40436 1804 3 3 3 CD 40436 1804 4 . . . 40436 1805 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1805 2 shall shall MD 40436 1805 3 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 1805 4 this this DT 40436 1805 5 subject subject NN 40436 1805 6 farther farther RB 40436 1805 7 when when WRB 40436 1805 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1805 9 come come VBP 40436 1805 10 to to IN 40436 1805 11 the the DT 40436 1805 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1805 13 called call VBN 40436 1805 14 Lysis lysis NN 40436 1805 15 . . . 40436 1805 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1806 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1806 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 1806 3 36 36 CD 40436 1806 4 : : : 40436 1806 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1806 6 , , , 40436 1806 7 in in IN 40436 1806 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1806 9 notes note NNS 40436 1806 10 , , , 40436 1806 11 bursts burst NNS 40436 1806 12 into into IN 40436 1806 13 exclamations exclamation NNS 40436 1806 14 of of IN 40436 1806 15 wonder wonder NN 40436 1806 16 at at IN 40436 1806 17 the the DT 40436 1806 18 incredible incredible JJ 40436 1806 19 stupidity stupidity NN 40436 1806 20 of of IN 40436 1806 21 Hippias--"En Hippias--"En NNP 40436 1806 22 hominis hominis NNP 40436 1806 23 stuporem stuporem NN 40436 1806 24 prorsus prorsus NNP 40436 1806 25 admirabilem admirabilem NNP 40436 1806 26 , , , 40436 1806 27 " " '' 40436 1806 28 p. p. NN 40436 1806 29 289 289 CD 40436 1806 30 E. E. NNP 40436 1806 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1806 32 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1806 33 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1806 34 37 37 CD 40436 1806 35 : : : 40436 1806 36 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 1806 37 John John NNP 40436 1806 38 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 1806 39 Mill Mill NNP 40436 1806 40 observes observe VBZ 40436 1806 41 in in IN 40436 1806 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1806 43 System System NNP 40436 1806 44 of of IN 40436 1806 45 Logic Logic NNP 40436 1806 46 , , , 40436 1806 47 i. i. NNP 40436 1807 1 1 1 CD 40436 1807 2 , , , 40436 1807 3 5 5 CD 40436 1807 4 : : : 40436 1807 5 " " `` 40436 1807 6 One one CD 40436 1807 7 of of IN 40436 1807 8 the the DT 40436 1807 9 chief chief JJ 40436 1807 10 sources source NNS 40436 1807 11 of of IN 40436 1807 12 lax lax JJ 40436 1807 13 habits habit NNS 40436 1807 14 of of IN 40436 1807 15 thought thought NN 40436 1807 16 is be VBZ 40436 1807 17 the the DT 40436 1807 18 custom custom NN 40436 1807 19 of of IN 40436 1807 20 using use VBG 40436 1807 21 connotative connotative JJ 40436 1807 22 terms term NNS 40436 1807 23 without without IN 40436 1807 24 a a DT 40436 1807 25 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 1807 26 ascertained ascertain VBN 40436 1807 27 connotation connotation NN 40436 1807 28 , , , 40436 1807 29 and and CC 40436 1807 30 with with IN 40436 1807 31 no no DT 40436 1807 32 more more RBR 40436 1807 33 precise precise JJ 40436 1807 34 notion notion NN 40436 1807 35 of of IN 40436 1807 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1807 37 meaning meaning NN 40436 1807 38 than than IN 40436 1807 39 can can MD 40436 1807 40 be be VB 40436 1807 41 loosely loosely RB 40436 1807 42 collected collect VBN 40436 1807 43 from from IN 40436 1807 44 observing observe VBG 40436 1807 45 what what WP 40436 1807 46 objects object NNS 40436 1807 47 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1807 48 are be VBP 40436 1807 49 used use VBN 40436 1807 50 to to TO 40436 1807 51 denote denote VB 40436 1807 52 . . . 40436 1808 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1808 2 is be VBZ 40436 1808 3 in in IN 40436 1808 4 this this DT 40436 1808 5 manner manner NN 40436 1808 6 that that IN 40436 1808 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1808 8 all all DT 40436 1808 9 acquire acquire VBP 40436 1808 10 , , , 40436 1808 11 and and CC 40436 1808 12 inevitably inevitably RB 40436 1808 13 so so RB 40436 1808 14 , , , 40436 1808 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1808 16 first first JJ 40436 1808 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 1808 18 of of IN 40436 1808 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1808 20 vernacular vernacular JJ 40436 1808 21 language language NN 40436 1808 22 . . . 40436 1809 1 A a DT 40436 1809 2 child child NN 40436 1809 3 learns learn VBZ 40436 1809 4 the the DT 40436 1809 5 meaning meaning NN 40436 1809 6 of of IN 40436 1809 7 Man Man NNP 40436 1809 8 , , , 40436 1809 9 White White NNP 40436 1809 10 , , , 40436 1809 11 & & CC 40436 1809 12 c. c. NNP 40436 1809 13 , , , 40436 1809 14 by by IN 40436 1809 15 hearing hear VBG 40436 1809 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1809 17 applied apply VBD 40436 1809 18 to to IN 40436 1809 19 a a DT 40436 1809 20 number number NN 40436 1809 21 of of IN 40436 1809 22 individual individual JJ 40436 1809 23 objects object NNS 40436 1809 24 , , , 40436 1809 25 and and CC 40436 1809 26 finding find VBG 40436 1809 27 out out RP 40436 1809 28 , , , 40436 1809 29 by by IN 40436 1809 30 a a DT 40436 1809 31 process process NN 40436 1809 32 of of IN 40436 1809 33 generalisation generalisation NN 40436 1809 34 of of IN 40436 1809 35 which which WDT 40436 1809 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1809 37 is be VBZ 40436 1809 38 but but CC 40436 1809 39 imperfectly imperfectly RB 40436 1809 40 conscious conscious JJ 40436 1809 41 , , , 40436 1809 42 what what WP 40436 1809 43 those those DT 40436 1809 44 different different JJ 40436 1809 45 objects object NNS 40436 1809 46 have have VBP 40436 1809 47 in in IN 40436 1809 48 common common JJ 40436 1809 49 . . . 40436 1810 1 In in IN 40436 1810 2 many many JJ 40436 1810 3 cases case NNS 40436 1810 4 objects object NNS 40436 1810 5 bear bear VBP 40436 1810 6 a a DT 40436 1810 7 general general JJ 40436 1810 8 resemblance resemblance NN 40436 1810 9 to to IN 40436 1810 10 each each DT 40436 1810 11 other other JJ 40436 1810 12 , , , 40436 1810 13 which which WDT 40436 1810 14 leads lead VBZ 40436 1810 15 to to IN 40436 1810 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1810 17 being be VBG 40436 1810 18 familiarly familiarly RB 40436 1810 19 classed class VBN 40436 1810 20 together together RB 40436 1810 21 under under IN 40436 1810 22 a a DT 40436 1810 23 common common JJ 40436 1810 24 name name NN 40436 1810 25 , , , 40436 1810 26 while while IN 40436 1810 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1810 28 is be VBZ 40436 1810 29 not not RB 40436 1810 30 immediately immediately RB 40436 1810 31 apparent apparent JJ 40436 1810 32 what what WP 40436 1810 33 are be VBP 40436 1810 34 the the DT 40436 1810 35 particular particular JJ 40436 1810 36 attributes attribute NNS 40436 1810 37 upon upon IN 40436 1810 38 the the DT 40436 1810 39 possession possession NN 40436 1810 40 of of IN 40436 1810 41 which which WDT 40436 1810 42 in in IN 40436 1810 43 common common JJ 40436 1810 44 by by IN 40436 1810 45 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1810 46 all all DT 40436 1810 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1810 48 general general JJ 40436 1810 49 resemblance resemblance NN 40436 1810 50 depends depend VBZ 40436 1810 51 . . . 40436 1811 1 In in IN 40436 1811 2 this this DT 40436 1811 3 manner manner NN 40436 1811 4 names name NNS 40436 1811 5 creep creep VBP 40436 1811 6 on on RP 40436 1811 7 from from IN 40436 1811 8 subject subject NN 40436 1811 9 to to IN 40436 1811 10 subject subject NN 40436 1811 11 until until IN 40436 1811 12 all all DT 40436 1811 13 traces trace NNS 40436 1811 14 of of IN 40436 1811 15 a a DT 40436 1811 16 common common JJ 40436 1811 17 meaning meaning NN 40436 1811 18 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1811 19 disappear disappear VBP 40436 1811 20 , , , 40436 1811 21 and and CC 40436 1811 22 the the DT 40436 1811 23 word word NN 40436 1811 24 comes come VBZ 40436 1811 25 to to TO 40436 1811 26 denote denote VB 40436 1811 27 a a DT 40436 1811 28 number number NN 40436 1811 29 of of IN 40436 1811 30 things thing NNS 40436 1811 31 not not RB 40436 1811 32 only only RB 40436 1811 33 independently independently RB 40436 1811 34 of of IN 40436 1811 35 any any DT 40436 1811 36 common common JJ 40436 1811 37 attribute attribute NN 40436 1811 38 , , , 40436 1811 39 but but CC 40436 1811 40 which which WDT 40436 1811 41 have have VBP 40436 1811 42 actually actually RB 40436 1811 43 no no DT 40436 1811 44 attribute attribute NN 40436 1811 45 in in IN 40436 1811 46 common common JJ 40436 1811 47 , , , 40436 1811 48 or or CC 40436 1811 49 none none NN 40436 1811 50 but but CC 40436 1811 51 what what WP 40436 1811 52 is be VBZ 40436 1811 53 shared share VBN 40436 1811 54 by by IN 40436 1811 55 other other JJ 40436 1811 56 things thing NNS 40436 1811 57 to to TO 40436 1811 58 which which WDT 40436 1811 59 the the DT 40436 1811 60 name name NN 40436 1811 61 is be VBZ 40436 1811 62 capriciously capriciously RB 40436 1811 63 refused refuse VBN 40436 1811 64 . . . 40436 1812 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1812 2 would would MD 40436 1812 3 be be VB 40436 1812 4 well well JJ 40436 1812 5 if if IN 40436 1812 6 this this DT 40436 1812 7 degeneracy degeneracy NN 40436 1812 8 of of IN 40436 1812 9 language language NN 40436 1812 10 took take VBD 40436 1812 11 place place NN 40436 1812 12 only only RB 40436 1812 13 in in IN 40436 1812 14 the the DT 40436 1812 15 hands hand NNS 40436 1812 16 of of IN 40436 1812 17 the the DT 40436 1812 18 untaught untaught JJ 40436 1812 19 vulgar vulgar NN 40436 1812 20 ; ; : 40436 1812 21 but but CC 40436 1812 22 some some DT 40436 1812 23 of of IN 40436 1812 24 the the DT 40436 1812 25 most most RBS 40436 1812 26 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 1812 27 instances instance NNS 40436 1812 28 are be VBP 40436 1812 29 to to TO 40436 1812 30 be be VB 40436 1812 31 found find VBN 40436 1812 32 in in IN 40436 1812 33 terms term NNS 40436 1812 34 of of IN 40436 1812 35 art art NN 40436 1812 36 , , , 40436 1812 37 and and CC 40436 1812 38 among among IN 40436 1812 39 technically technically RB 40436 1812 40 educated educate VBN 40436 1812 41 persons person NNS 40436 1812 42 , , , 40436 1812 43 such such JJ 40436 1812 44 as as IN 40436 1812 45 English English NNP 40436 1812 46 lawyers lawyer NNS 40436 1812 47 . . . 40436 1813 1 _ _ NNP 40436 1813 2 Felony Felony NNP 40436 1813 3 _ _ NNP 40436 1813 4 , , , 40436 1813 5 _ _ NNP 40436 1813 6 e.g. e.g. RB 40436 1813 7 _ _ NNP 40436 1813 8 , , , 40436 1813 9 is be VBZ 40436 1813 10 a a DT 40436 1813 11 law law NN 40436 1813 12 - - HYPH 40436 1813 13 term term NN 40436 1813 14 with with IN 40436 1813 15 the the DT 40436 1813 16 sound sound NN 40436 1813 17 of of IN 40436 1813 18 which which WDT 40436 1813 19 all all DT 40436 1813 20 are be VBP 40436 1813 21 familiar familiar JJ 40436 1813 22 : : : 40436 1813 23 _ _ NNP 40436 1813 24 but but CC 40436 1813 25 there there EX 40436 1813 26 is be VBZ 40436 1813 27 no no DT 40436 1813 28 lawyer lawyer NN 40436 1813 29 who who WP 40436 1813 30 would would MD 40436 1813 31 undertake undertake VB 40436 1813 32 to to TO 40436 1813 33 tell tell VB 40436 1813 34 what what WP 40436 1813 35 a a DT 40436 1813 36 felony felony NN 40436 1813 37 is be VBZ 40436 1813 38 , , , 40436 1813 39 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 1813 40 than than IN 40436 1813 41 by by IN 40436 1813 42 enumerating enumerate VBG 40436 1813 43 the the DT 40436 1813 44 various various JJ 40436 1813 45 offences offence NNS 40436 1813 46 so so RB 40436 1813 47 called call VBN 40436 1813 48 . . . 40436 1813 49 _ _ NNP 40436 1813 50 Originally originally RB 40436 1813 51 the the DT 40436 1813 52 word word NN 40436 1813 53 _ _ NNP 40436 1813 54 felony felony NN 40436 1813 55 _ _ NNP 40436 1813 56 had have VBD 40436 1813 57 a a DT 40436 1813 58 meaning meaning NN 40436 1813 59 ; ; : 40436 1813 60 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1813 61 denoted denote VBD 40436 1813 62 all all DT 40436 1813 63 offences offence NNS 40436 1813 64 , , , 40436 1813 65 the the DT 40436 1813 66 penalty penalty NN 40436 1813 67 of of IN 40436 1813 68 which which WDT 40436 1813 69 included include VBD 40436 1813 70 forfeiture forfeiture NN 40436 1813 71 of of IN 40436 1813 72 lands land NNS 40436 1813 73 or or CC 40436 1813 74 goods good NNS 40436 1813 75 , , , 40436 1813 76 but but CC 40436 1813 77 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 1813 78 Acts Acts NNPS 40436 1813 79 of of IN 40436 1813 80 Parliament Parliament NNP 40436 1813 81 have have VBP 40436 1813 82 declared declare VBN 40436 1813 83 various various JJ 40436 1813 84 offences offence NNS 40436 1813 85 to to TO 40436 1813 86 be be VB 40436 1813 87 felonies felony NNS 40436 1813 88 without without IN 40436 1813 89 enjoining enjoin VBG 40436 1813 90 that that DT 40436 1813 91 penalty penalty NN 40436 1813 92 , , , 40436 1813 93 and and CC 40436 1813 94 have have VBP 40436 1813 95 taken take VBN 40436 1813 96 away away RB 40436 1813 97 that that DT 40436 1813 98 penalty penalty NN 40436 1813 99 from from IN 40436 1813 100 others other NNS 40436 1813 101 which which WDT 40436 1813 102 continue continue VBP 40436 1813 103 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 1813 104 to to TO 40436 1813 105 be be VB 40436 1813 106 called call VBN 40436 1813 107 felonies felony NNS 40436 1813 108 , , , 40436 1813 109 insomuch insomuch VB 40436 1813 110 that that IN 40436 1813 111 the the DT 40436 1813 112 acts act NNS 40436 1813 113 so so RB 40436 1813 114 called call VBN 40436 1813 115 have have VBP 40436 1813 116 now now RB 40436 1813 117 no no DT 40436 1813 118 property property NN 40436 1813 119 whatever whatever WDT 40436 1813 120 in in IN 40436 1813 121 common common JJ 40436 1813 122 save save NN 40436 1813 123 that that DT 40436 1813 124 of of IN 40436 1813 125 being be VBG 40436 1813 126 unlawful unlawful JJ 40436 1813 127 and and CC 40436 1813 128 punishable punishable JJ 40436 1813 129 . . . 40436 1813 130 " " '' 40436 1813 131 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1814 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1814 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1814 3 38 38 CD 40436 1814 4 : : : 40436 1814 5 Aristot aristot NN 40436 1814 6 . . . 40436 1815 1 Topic Topic NNP 40436 1815 2 , , , 40436 1815 3 i. i. NNP 40436 1816 1 106 106 CD 40436 1816 2 , , , 40436 1816 3 a. a. NN 40436 1817 1 21 21 CD 40436 1817 2 . . . 40436 1818 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1818 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1818 3 : : : 40436 1818 4 Ta\ Ta\ NNP 40436 1818 5 pollachô pollachô NNP 40436 1818 6 = = NFP 40436 1818 7 s s NNP 40436 1818 8 lego lego NNP 40436 1818 9 / / SYM 40436 1818 10 mena mena NNP 40436 1818 11 -- -- : 40436 1818 12 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 1818 13 pleonachô pleonachô NNP 40436 1818 14 = = NFP 40436 1818 15 s s NNP 40436 1818 16 lego lego NNP 40436 1818 17 / / SYM 40436 1818 18 mena]--are mena]--are NN 40436 1818 19 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 1818 20 noted note VBN 40436 1818 21 and and CC 40436 1818 22 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 1818 23 by by IN 40436 1818 24 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 1818 25 . . . 40436 1818 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1819 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1819 2 Side side NN 40436 1819 3 - - HYPH 40436 1819 4 note note NN 40436 1819 5 : : : 40436 1819 6 Analogy analogy NN 40436 1819 7 between between IN 40436 1819 8 the the DT 40436 1819 9 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1819 10 here here RB 40436 1819 11 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 1819 12 to to IN 40436 1819 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1819 14 , , , 40436 1819 15 and and CC 40436 1819 16 those those DT 40436 1819 17 given give VBN 40436 1819 18 by by IN 40436 1819 19 the the DT 40436 1819 20 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1819 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1819 22 in in IN 40436 1819 23 the the DT 40436 1819 24 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1819 25 . . . 40436 1819 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1820 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1820 2 read read VBP 40436 1820 3 in in IN 40436 1820 4 the the DT 40436 1820 5 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1820 6 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1820 7 a a DT 40436 1820 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1820 9 between between IN 40436 1820 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1820 11 and and CC 40436 1820 12 Aristippus Aristippus NNP 40436 1820 13 , , , 40436 1820 14 on on IN 40436 1820 15 this this DT 40436 1820 16 same same JJ 40436 1820 17 subject subject NN 40436 1820 18 -- -- : 40436 1820 19 What what WP 40436 1820 20 is be VBZ 40436 1820 21 the the DT 40436 1820 22 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1820 23 , , , 40436 1820 24 which which WDT 40436 1820 25 affords afford VBZ 40436 1820 26 a a DT 40436 1820 27 sort sort NN 40436 1820 28 of of IN 40436 1820 29 contrast contrast NN 40436 1820 30 between between IN 40436 1820 31 the the DT 40436 1820 32 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1820 33 of of IN 40436 1820 34 Search Search NNP 40436 1820 35 and and CC 40436 1820 36 those those DT 40436 1820 37 of of IN 40436 1820 38 Exposition Exposition NNP 40436 1820 39 . . . 40436 1821 1 In in IN 40436 1821 2 the the DT 40436 1821 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1821 4 Major Major NNP 40436 1821 5 , , , 40436 1821 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1821 7 have have VBP 40436 1821 8 the the DT 40436 1821 9 problem problem NN 40436 1821 10 approached approach VBN 40436 1821 11 on on IN 40436 1821 12 several several JJ 40436 1821 13 different different JJ 40436 1821 14 sides side NNS 40436 1821 15 , , , 40436 1821 16 various various JJ 40436 1821 17 suggestions suggestion NNS 40436 1821 18 being be VBG 40436 1821 19 proposed propose VBN 40436 1821 20 , , , 40436 1821 21 and and CC 40436 1821 22 each each DT 40436 1821 23 successively successively RB 40436 1821 24 disallowed disallow VBN 40436 1821 25 , , , 40436 1821 26 on on IN 40436 1821 27 reasons reason NNS 40436 1821 28 shown show VBN 40436 1821 29 , , , 40436 1821 30 as as IN 40436 1821 31 failures failure NNS 40436 1821 32 : : : 40436 1821 33 while while IN 40436 1821 34 in in IN 40436 1821 35 the the DT 40436 1821 36 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 1821 37 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1821 38 , , , 40436 1821 39 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1821 40 declares declare VBZ 40436 1821 41 an an DT 40436 1821 42 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 1821 43 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1821 44 , , , 40436 1821 45 and and CC 40436 1821 46 stands stand VBZ 40436 1821 47 to to IN 40436 1821 48 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1821 49 -- -- : 40436 1821 50 but but CC 40436 1821 51 no no DT 40436 1821 52 pains pain NNS 40436 1821 53 are be VBP 40436 1821 54 taken take VBN 40436 1821 55 to to TO 40436 1821 56 bring bring VB 40436 1821 57 out out RP 40436 1821 58 the the DT 40436 1821 59 objections objection NNS 40436 1821 60 against against IN 40436 1821 61 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1821 62 and and CC 40436 1821 63 rebut rebut VB 40436 1821 64 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1821 65 . . . 40436 1822 1 The the DT 40436 1822 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1822 3 is be VBZ 40436 1822 4 , , , 40436 1822 5 that that IN 40436 1822 6 the the DT 40436 1822 7 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1822 8 is be VBZ 40436 1822 9 coincident coincident NN 40436 1822 10 with with IN 40436 1822 11 the the DT 40436 1822 12 Good Good NNP 40436 1822 13 , , , 40436 1822 14 and and CC 40436 1822 15 that that IN 40436 1822 16 both both DT 40436 1822 17 of of IN 40436 1822 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1822 19 are be VBP 40436 1822 20 resolvable resolvable JJ 40436 1822 21 into into IN 40436 1822 22 the the DT 40436 1822 23 Useful Useful NNP 40436 1822 24 : : : 40436 1822 25 thus thus RB 40436 1822 26 all all DT 40436 1822 27 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1822 28 objects object NNS 40436 1822 29 , , , 40436 1822 30 unlike unlike IN 40436 1822 31 as as IN 40436 1822 32 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1822 33 may may MD 40436 1822 34 be be VB 40436 1822 35 to to IN 40436 1822 36 the the DT 40436 1822 37 eye eye NN 40436 1822 38 or or CC 40436 1822 39 touch touch NN 40436 1822 40 , , , 40436 1822 41 bear bear VBP 40436 1822 42 that that DT 40436 1822 43 name name NN 40436 1822 44 because because IN 40436 1822 45 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1822 46 have have VBP 40436 1822 47 in in IN 40436 1822 48 common common JJ 40436 1822 49 the the DT 40436 1822 50 attribute attribute NN 40436 1822 51 of of IN 40436 1822 52 conducing conduce VBG 40436 1822 53 to to IN 40436 1822 54 one one CD 40436 1822 55 and and CC 40436 1822 56 the the DT 40436 1822 57 same same JJ 40436 1822 58 purpose purpose NN 40436 1822 59 -- -- : 40436 1822 60 the the DT 40436 1822 61 security security NN 40436 1822 62 , , , 40436 1822 63 advantage advantage NN 40436 1822 64 , , , 40436 1822 65 or or CC 40436 1822 66 gratification gratification NN 40436 1822 67 , , , 40436 1822 68 of of IN 40436 1822 69 man man NN 40436 1822 70 , , , 40436 1822 71 in in IN 40436 1822 72 some some DT 40436 1822 73 form form NN 40436 1822 74 or or CC 40436 1822 75 other other JJ 40436 1822 76 . . . 40436 1823 1 This this DT 40436 1823 2 is be VBZ 40436 1823 3 one one CD 40436 1823 4 of of IN 40436 1823 5 the the DT 40436 1823 6 three three CD 40436 1823 7 explanations explanation NNS 40436 1823 8 broached broach VBN 40436 1823 9 by by IN 40436 1823 10 the the DT 40436 1823 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1823 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1823 13 , , , 40436 1823 14 and and CC 40436 1823 15 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 1823 16 refuted refute VBN 40436 1823 17 by by IN 40436 1823 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1823 19 , , , 40436 1823 20 in in IN 40436 1823 21 the the DT 40436 1823 22 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1823 23 : : : 40436 1823 24 while while IN 40436 1823 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1823 26 declaration declaration NN 40436 1823 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1823 28 which which WDT 40436 1823 29 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1823 30 puts put VBZ 40436 1823 31 aside aside RB 40436 1823 32 as as IN 40436 1823 33 unseemly)--that unseemly)--that NNP 40436 1823 34 a a DT 40436 1823 35 pot pot NN 40436 1823 36 and and CC 40436 1823 37 a a DT 40436 1823 38 wooden wooden JJ 40436 1823 39 soup soup NN 40436 1823 40 - - HYPH 40436 1823 41 ladle ladle NN 40436 1823 42 conveniently conveniently RB 40436 1823 43 made make VBN 40436 1823 44 are be VBP 40436 1823 45 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1823 46 is be VBZ 40436 1823 47 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 1823 48 in in IN 40436 1823 49 harmony harmony NN 40436 1823 50 with with IN 40436 1823 51 that that DT 40436 1823 52 of of IN 40436 1823 53 the the DT 40436 1823 54 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1823 55 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1823 56 , , , 40436 1823 57 that that IN 40436 1823 58 a a DT 40436 1823 59 basket basket NN 40436 1823 60 for for IN 40436 1823 61 carrying carry VBG 40436 1823 62 dung dung NN 40436 1823 63 is be VBZ 40436 1823 64 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1823 65 , , , 40436 1823 66 if if IN 40436 1823 67 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1823 68 performs perform VBZ 40436 1823 69 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1823 70 work work NN 40436 1823 71 well well RB 40436 1823 72 . . . 40436 1824 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1824 2 39 39 CD 40436 1824 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1824 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1824 5 must must MD 40436 1824 6 moreover moreover RB 40436 1824 7 remark remark VB 40436 1824 8 , , , 40436 1824 9 that that IN 40436 1824 10 the the DT 40436 1824 11 objections objection NNS 40436 1824 12 whereby whereby WRB 40436 1824 13 the the DT 40436 1824 14 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1824 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1824 16 , , , 40436 1824 17 after after IN 40436 1824 18 proposing propose VBG 40436 1824 19 the the DT 40436 1824 20 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1824 21 and and CC 40436 1824 22 saying say VBG 40436 1824 23 much much RB 40436 1824 24 in in IN 40436 1824 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1824 26 favour favour NN 40436 1824 27 , , , 40436 1824 28 finds find VBZ 40436 1824 29 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1824 30 compelled compel VBN 40436 1824 31 at at IN 40436 1824 32 last last JJ 40436 1824 33 to to TO 40436 1824 34 disallow disallow VB 40436 1824 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1824 36 -- -- : 40436 1824 37 these these DT 40436 1824 38 objections objection NNS 40436 1824 39 are be VBP 40436 1824 40 not not RB 40436 1824 41 produced produce VBN 40436 1824 42 and and CC 40436 1824 43 refuted refute VBN 40436 1824 44 , , , 40436 1824 45 but but CC 40436 1824 46 passed pass VBD 40436 1824 47 over over RP 40436 1824 48 without without IN 40436 1824 49 notice notice NN 40436 1824 50 , , , 40436 1824 51 in in IN 40436 1824 52 the the DT 40436 1824 53 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 1824 54 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1824 55 , , , 40436 1824 56 wherein wherein WRB 40436 1824 57 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1824 58 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 1824 59 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1824 60 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 1824 61 . . . 40436 1825 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1825 2 40 40 CD 40436 1825 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1825 4 The the DT 40436 1825 5 affirming affirm VBG 40436 1825 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1825 7 , , , 40436 1825 8 and and CC 40436 1825 9 the the DT 40436 1825 10 objecting object VBG 40436 1825 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1825 12 , , , 40436 1825 13 are be VBP 40436 1825 14 not not RB 40436 1825 15 on on IN 40436 1825 16 the the DT 40436 1825 17 stage stage NN 40436 1825 18 at at IN 40436 1825 19 once once RB 40436 1825 20 . . . 40436 1826 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1826 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1826 3 39 39 CD 40436 1826 4 : : : 40436 1826 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 1826 6 . . . 40436 1827 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1827 2 . . . 40436 1828 1 iii iii NNP 40436 1828 2 . . . 40436 1829 1 6 6 CD 40436 1829 2 , , , 40436 1829 3 2 2 CD 40436 1829 4 , , , 40436 1829 5 7 7 CD 40436 1829 6 ; ; : 40436 1829 7 iv iv LS 40436 1829 8 . . . 40436 1830 1 6 6 CD 40436 1830 2 , , , 40436 1830 3 8 8 CD 40436 1830 4 . . . 40436 1831 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1831 2 , , , 40436 1831 3 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1831 4 . . . 40436 1832 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1832 2 . . NNP 40436 1832 3 288 288 CD 40436 1832 4 D d NN 40436 1832 5 , , , 40436 1832 6 290 290 CD 40436 1832 7 D. D. NNP 40436 1832 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1832 9 am be VBP 40436 1832 10 obliged oblige VBN 40436 1832 11 to to TO 40436 1832 12 translate translate VB 40436 1832 13 the the DT 40436 1832 14 words word NNS 40436 1832 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1832 16 Greek greek JJ 40436 1832 17 : : : 40436 1832 18 to\ to\ NN 40436 1832 19 Kalo Kalo NNP 40436 1832 20 / / SYM 40436 1832 21 n n NNP 40436 1832 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1832 23 by by IN 40436 1832 24 the the DT 40436 1832 25 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1832 26 or or CC 40436 1832 27 beauty beauty NN 40436 1832 28 , , , 40436 1832 29 to to TO 40436 1832 30 avoid avoid VB 40436 1832 31 a a DT 40436 1832 32 tiresome tiresome JJ 40436 1832 33 periphrasis periphrasis NN 40436 1832 34 . . . 40436 1833 1 But but CC 40436 1833 2 in in IN 40436 1833 3 reality reality NN 40436 1833 4 the the DT 40436 1833 5 Greek greek JJ 40436 1833 6 words word NNS 40436 1833 7 include include VBP 40436 1833 8 more more JJR 40436 1833 9 besides besides IN 40436 1833 10 : : : 40436 1833 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1833 12 mean mean VBP 40436 1833 13 also also RB 40436 1833 14 the the DT 40436 1833 15 _ _ NNP 40436 1833 16 fine fine JJ 40436 1833 17 _ _ NNP 40436 1833 18 , , , 40436 1833 19 the the DT 40436 1833 20 _ _ NNP 40436 1833 21 honourable honourable JJ 40436 1833 22 or or CC 40436 1833 23 that that IN 40436 1833 24 which which WDT 40436 1833 25 is be VBZ 40436 1833 26 worthy worthy JJ 40436 1833 27 of of IN 40436 1833 28 honour honour NN 40436 1833 29 _ _ NNP 40436 1833 30 , , , 40436 1833 31 the the DT 40436 1833 32 _ _ NNP 40436 1833 33 exalted exalt VBD 40436 1833 34 _ _ NNP 40436 1833 35 , , , 40436 1833 36 & & CC 40436 1833 37 c. c. NNP 40436 1833 38 If if IN 40436 1833 39 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1833 40 have have VBP 40436 1833 41 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 1833 42 in in IN 40436 1833 43 finding find VBG 40436 1833 44 any any DT 40436 1833 45 common common JJ 40436 1833 46 property property NN 40436 1833 47 connoted connote VBN 40436 1833 48 by by IN 40436 1833 49 the the DT 40436 1833 50 English english JJ 40436 1833 51 word word NN 40436 1833 52 , , , 40436 1833 53 the the DT 40436 1833 54 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 1833 55 in in IN 40436 1833 56 the the DT 40436 1833 57 case case NN 40436 1833 58 of of IN 40436 1833 59 the the DT 40436 1833 60 Greek greek JJ 40436 1833 61 word word NN 40436 1833 62 is be VBZ 40436 1833 63 still still RB 40436 1833 64 greater great JJR 40436 1833 65 . . . 40436 1833 66 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1834 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1834 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1834 3 40 40 CD 40436 1834 4 : : : 40436 1834 5 In in IN 40436 1834 6 regard regard NN 40436 1834 7 to to IN 40436 1834 8 the the DT 40436 1834 9 question question NN 40436 1834 10 , , , 40436 1834 11 Wherein Wherein NNP 40436 1834 12 consists consist VBZ 40436 1834 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1834 14 Greek greek NN 40436 1834 15 : : : 40436 1834 16 To\ To\ NNP 40436 1834 17 Kalo Kalo NNP 40436 1834 18 / / SYM 40436 1834 19 n n NNP 40436 1834 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1834 21 ? ? . 40436 1835 1 and and CC 40436 1835 2 objections objection NNS 40436 1835 3 against against IN 40436 1835 4 the the DT 40436 1835 5 theory theory NN 40436 1835 6 of of IN 40436 1835 7 the the DT 40436 1835 8 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1835 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1835 10 , , , 40436 1835 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1835 12 is be VBZ 40436 1835 13 worth worth JJ 40436 1835 14 while while IN 40436 1835 15 to to TO 40436 1835 16 compare compare VB 40436 1835 17 the the DT 40436 1835 18 views view NNS 40436 1835 19 of of IN 40436 1835 20 modern modern JJ 40436 1835 21 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 1835 22 . . . 40436 1836 1 Dugald Dugald NNP 40436 1836 2 Stewart Stewart NNP 40436 1836 3 says say VBZ 40436 1836 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1836 5 on on IN 40436 1836 6 the the DT 40436 1836 7 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1836 8 , , , 40436 1836 9 ' ' '' 40436 1836 10 Philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 1836 11 Essays essay NNS 40436 1836 12 , , , 40436 1836 13 ' ' '' 40436 1836 14 p. p. NN 40436 1836 15 214 214 CD 40436 1836 16 seq seq NN 40436 1836 17 . . . 40436 1837 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1837 2 , , , 40436 1837 3 " " `` 40436 1837 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 1837 5 has have VBZ 40436 1837 6 long long RB 40436 1837 7 been be VBN 40436 1837 8 a a DT 40436 1837 9 favourite favourite JJ 40436 1837 10 problem problem NN 40436 1837 11 with with IN 40436 1837 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 1837 13 to to TO 40436 1837 14 ascertain ascertain VB 40436 1837 15 the the DT 40436 1837 16 common common JJ 40436 1837 17 quality quality NN 40436 1837 18 or or CC 40436 1837 19 qualities quality NNS 40436 1837 20 which which WDT 40436 1837 21 entitle entitle VBP 40436 1837 22 a a DT 40436 1837 23 thing thing NN 40436 1837 24 to to IN 40436 1837 25 the the DT 40436 1837 26 denomination denomination NN 40436 1837 27 of of IN 40436 1837 28 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1837 29 . . . 40436 1838 1 But but CC 40436 1838 2 the the DT 40436 1838 3 success success NN 40436 1838 4 of of IN 40436 1838 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1838 6 speculations speculation NNS 40436 1838 7 has have VBZ 40436 1838 8 been be VBN 40436 1838 9 so so RB 40436 1838 10 inconsiderable inconsiderable JJ 40436 1838 11 , , , 40436 1838 12 that that IN 40436 1838 13 little little JJ 40436 1838 14 can can MD 40436 1838 15 be be VB 40436 1838 16 inferred infer VBN 40436 1838 17 from from IN 40436 1838 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1838 19 except except IN 40436 1838 20 the the DT 40436 1838 21 impossibility impossibility NN 40436 1838 22 of of IN 40436 1838 23 the the DT 40436 1838 24 problem problem NN 40436 1838 25 to to TO 40436 1838 26 which which WDT 40436 1838 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1838 28 have have VBP 40436 1838 29 been be VBN 40436 1838 30 directed direct VBN 40436 1838 31 . . . 40436 1839 1 The the DT 40436 1839 2 speculations speculation NNS 40436 1839 3 which which WDT 40436 1839 4 have have VBP 40436 1839 5 given give VBN 40436 1839 6 occasion occasion NN 40436 1839 7 to to IN 40436 1839 8 these these DT 40436 1839 9 remarks remark NNS 40436 1839 10 have have VBP 40436 1839 11 evidently evidently RB 40436 1839 12 originated originate VBN 40436 1839 13 in in IN 40436 1839 14 a a DT 40436 1839 15 prejudice prejudice NN 40436 1839 16 which which WDT 40436 1839 17 has have VBZ 40436 1839 18 descended descend VBN 40436 1839 19 to to IN 40436 1839 20 modern modern JJ 40436 1839 21 times time NNS 40436 1839 22 from from IN 40436 1839 23 the the DT 40436 1839 24 scholastic scholastic JJ 40436 1839 25 ages age NNS 40436 1839 26 . . . 40436 1840 1 That that IN 40436 1840 2 when when WRB 40436 1840 3 a a DT 40436 1840 4 word word NN 40436 1840 5 admits admit VBZ 40436 1840 6 of of IN 40436 1840 7 a a DT 40436 1840 8 variety variety NN 40436 1840 9 of of IN 40436 1840 10 significations signification NNS 40436 1840 11 , , , 40436 1840 12 these these DT 40436 1840 13 different different JJ 40436 1840 14 significations signification NNS 40436 1840 15 must must MD 40436 1840 16 all all DT 40436 1840 17 be be VB 40436 1840 18 species specie NNS 40436 1840 19 of of IN 40436 1840 20 the the DT 40436 1840 21 same same JJ 40436 1840 22 genus genus NN 40436 1840 23 , , , 40436 1840 24 and and CC 40436 1840 25 must must MD 40436 1840 26 consequently consequently RB 40436 1840 27 include include VB 40436 1840 28 some some DT 40436 1840 29 essential essential JJ 40436 1840 30 idea idea NN 40436 1840 31 common common JJ 40436 1840 32 to to IN 40436 1840 33 every every DT 40436 1840 34 individual individual NN 40436 1840 35 to to TO 40436 1840 36 which which WDT 40436 1840 37 the the DT 40436 1840 38 generic generic JJ 40436 1840 39 term term NN 40436 1840 40 can can MD 40436 1840 41 be be VB 40436 1840 42 applied apply VBN 40436 1840 43 . . . 40436 1841 1 Of of IN 40436 1841 2 this this DT 40436 1841 3 principle principle NN 40436 1841 4 , , , 40436 1841 5 which which WDT 40436 1841 6 has have VBZ 40436 1841 7 been be VBN 40436 1841 8 an an DT 40436 1841 9 abundant abundant JJ 40436 1841 10 source source NN 40436 1841 11 of of IN 40436 1841 12 obscurity obscurity NN 40436 1841 13 and and CC 40436 1841 14 mystery mystery NN 40436 1841 15 in in IN 40436 1841 16 the the DT 40436 1841 17 different different JJ 40436 1841 18 sciences science NNS 40436 1841 19 , , , 40436 1841 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1841 21 would would MD 40436 1841 22 be be VB 40436 1841 23 easy easy JJ 40436 1841 24 to to TO 40436 1841 25 expose expose VB 40436 1841 26 the the DT 40436 1841 27 unsoundness unsoundness NN 40436 1841 28 and and CC 40436 1841 29 futility futility NN 40436 1841 30 . . . 40436 1842 1 Socrates Socrates NNP 40436 1842 2 , , , 40436 1842 3 whose whose WP$ 40436 1842 4 plain plain JJ 40436 1842 5 good good JJ 40436 1842 6 sense sense NN 40436 1842 7 appears appear VBZ 40436 1842 8 , , , 40436 1842 9 on on IN 40436 1842 10 this this DT 40436 1842 11 as as IN 40436 1842 12 on on IN 40436 1842 13 other other JJ 40436 1842 14 occasions occasion NNS 40436 1842 15 , , , 40436 1842 16 to to TO 40436 1842 17 have have VB 40436 1842 18 fortified fortify VBN 40436 1842 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1842 20 understanding understanding NN 40436 1842 21 to to IN 40436 1842 22 a a DT 40436 1842 23 wonderful wonderful JJ 40436 1842 24 degree degree NN 40436 1842 25 against against IN 40436 1842 26 the the DT 40436 1842 27 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 40436 1842 28 subtleties subtlety NNS 40436 1842 29 which which WDT 40436 1842 30 misled mislead VBD 40436 1842 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1842 32 successors successor NNS 40436 1842 33 , , , 40436 1842 34 was be VBD 40436 1842 35 evidently evidently RB 40436 1842 36 apprised apprise VBN 40436 1842 37 fully fully RB 40436 1842 38 of of IN 40436 1842 39 the the DT 40436 1842 40 justice justice NN 40436 1842 41 of of IN 40436 1842 42 the the DT 40436 1842 43 foregoing forego VBG 40436 1842 44 remarks remark NNS 40436 1842 45 , , , 40436 1842 46 if if IN 40436 1842 47 any any DT 40436 1842 48 reliance reliance NN 40436 1842 49 can can MD 40436 1842 50 be be VB 40436 1842 51 placed place VBN 40436 1842 52 on on IN 40436 1842 53 the the DT 40436 1842 54 account account NN 40436 1842 55 given give VBN 40436 1842 56 by by IN 40436 1842 57 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 1842 58 of of IN 40436 1842 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1842 60 conversation conversation NN 40436 1842 61 with with IN 40436 1842 62 Aristippus Aristippus NNP 40436 1842 63 about about IN 40436 1842 64 the the DT 40436 1842 65 Good good JJ 40436 1842 66 and and CC 40436 1842 67 the the DT 40436 1842 68 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1842 69 , , , 40436 1842 70 " " '' 40436 1842 71 & & CC 40436 1842 72 c. c. NNP 40436 1842 73 Stewart Stewart NNP 40436 1842 74 then then RB 40436 1842 75 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 1842 76 to to TO 40436 1842 77 translate translate VB 40436 1842 78 a a DT 40436 1842 79 portion portion NN 40436 1842 80 of of IN 40436 1842 81 the the DT 40436 1842 82 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 1842 83 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1842 84 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1842 85 Memorab Memorab NNP 40436 1842 86 . . . 40436 1843 1 iii iii NNP 40436 1843 2 . . . 40436 1844 1 8) 8) CD 40436 1844 2 . . . 40436 1845 1 But but CC 40436 1845 2 unfortunately unfortunately RB 40436 1845 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1845 4 does do VBZ 40436 1845 5 not not RB 40436 1845 6 translate translate VB 40436 1845 7 the the DT 40436 1845 8 whole whole NN 40436 1845 9 of of IN 40436 1845 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1845 11 . . . 40436 1846 1 If if IN 40436 1846 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1846 3 had have VBD 40436 1846 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1846 5 would would MD 40436 1846 6 have have VB 40436 1846 7 seen see VBN 40436 1846 8 that that IN 40436 1846 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1846 10 has have VBZ 40436 1846 11 misconceived misconceive VBN 40436 1846 12 the the DT 40436 1846 13 opinion opinion NN 40436 1846 14 of of IN 40436 1846 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1846 16 , , , 40436 1846 17 who who WP 40436 1846 18 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 1846 19 the the DT 40436 1846 20 very very JJ 40436 1846 21 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1846 22 here here RB 40436 1846 23 disallowed disallow VBN 40436 1846 24 by by IN 40436 1846 25 Stewart Stewart NNP 40436 1846 26 , , , 40436 1846 27 viz viz NNP 40436 1846 28 . . . 40436 1846 29 , , , 40436 1846 30 That that IN 40436 1846 31 there there EX 40436 1846 32 is be VBZ 40436 1846 33 an an DT 40436 1846 34 essential essential JJ 40436 1846 35 idea idea NN 40436 1846 36 common common JJ 40436 1846 37 to to IN 40436 1846 38 all all DT 40436 1846 39 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1846 40 objects object NNS 40436 1846 41 , , , 40436 1846 42 the the DT 40436 1846 43 fact fact NN 40436 1846 44 of of IN 40436 1846 45 being be VBG 40436 1846 46 conducive conducive JJ 40436 1846 47 to to IN 40436 1846 48 human human JJ 40436 1846 49 security security NN 40436 1846 50 , , , 40436 1846 51 comfort comfort NN 40436 1846 52 , , , 40436 1846 53 or or CC 40436 1846 54 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 1846 55 . . . 40436 1847 1 This this DT 40436 1847 2 is be VBZ 40436 1847 3 unquestionably unquestionably RB 40436 1847 4 an an DT 40436 1847 5 important important JJ 40436 1847 6 common common JJ 40436 1847 7 property property NN 40436 1847 8 , , , 40436 1847 9 though though IN 40436 1847 10 the the DT 40436 1847 11 multifarious multifarious JJ 40436 1847 12 objects object NNS 40436 1847 13 which which WDT 40436 1847 14 possess possess VBP 40436 1847 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1847 16 may may MD 40436 1847 17 be be VB 40436 1847 18 unlike unlike IN 40436 1847 19 in in IN 40436 1847 20 all all DT 40436 1847 21 other other JJ 40436 1847 22 respects respect NNS 40436 1847 23 . . . 40436 1848 1 As as IN 40436 1848 2 to to IN 40436 1848 3 the the DT 40436 1848 4 general general JJ 40436 1848 5 theory theory NN 40436 1848 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1848 7 think think VBP 40436 1848 8 that that IN 40436 1848 9 Stewart Stewart NNP 40436 1848 10 is be VBZ 40436 1848 11 right right JJ 40436 1848 12 : : : 40436 1848 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1848 14 is be VBZ 40436 1848 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1848 16 compliment compliment NN 40436 1848 17 to to IN 40436 1848 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1848 19 , , , 40436 1848 20 on on IN 40436 1848 21 this this DT 40436 1848 22 occasion occasion NN 40436 1848 23 , , , 40436 1848 24 which which WDT 40436 1848 25 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1848 26 consider consider VBP 40436 1848 27 misplaced misplace VBN 40436 1848 28 . . . 40436 1849 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1849 2 certainly certainly RB 40436 1849 3 would would MD 40436 1849 4 not not RB 40436 1849 5 have have VB 40436 1849 6 agreed agree VBN 40436 1849 7 with with IN 40436 1849 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1849 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1849 10 nor nor CC 40436 1849 11 should should MD 40436 1849 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1849 13 agree agree VB 40436 1849 14 with with IN 40436 1849 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1849 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1849 17 in in IN 40436 1849 18 calling call VBG 40436 1849 19 by by IN 40436 1849 20 the the DT 40436 1849 21 epithet epithet NN 40436 1849 22 _ _ NNP 40436 1849 23 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1849 24 _ _ NNP 40436 1849 25 a a DT 40436 1849 26 basket basket NN 40436 1849 27 for for IN 40436 1849 28 carrying carry VBG 40436 1849 29 dung dung NN 40436 1849 30 when when WRB 40436 1849 31 well well RB 40436 1849 32 made make VBN 40436 1849 33 for for IN 40436 1849 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1849 35 own own JJ 40436 1849 36 purpose purpose NN 40436 1849 37 , , , 40436 1849 38 or or CC 40436 1849 39 a a DT 40436 1849 40 convenient convenient JJ 40436 1849 41 boiling boiling NN 40436 1849 42 - - HYPH 40436 1849 43 pot pot NN 40436 1849 44 , , , 40436 1849 45 or or CC 40436 1849 46 a a DT 40436 1849 47 soup soup NN 40436 1849 48 - - HYPH 40436 1849 49 ladle ladle NN 40436 1849 50 made make VBN 40436 1849 51 of of IN 40436 1849 52 fig fig NN 40436 1849 53 - - HYPH 40436 1849 54 tree tree NN 40436 1849 55 wood wood NN 40436 1849 56 , , , 40436 1849 57 as as IN 40436 1849 58 the the DT 40436 1849 59 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1849 60 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1849 61 affirms affirm NNS 40436 1849 62 in in IN 40436 1849 63 the the DT 40436 1849 64 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1849 65 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1849 66 288 288 CD 40436 1849 67 D d NN 40436 1849 68 , , , 40436 1849 69 290 290 CD 40436 1849 70 D d NN 40436 1849 71 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1849 72 . . . 40436 1850 1 The the DT 40436 1850 2 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1850 3 and and CC 40436 1850 4 the the DT 40436 1850 5 Useful useful JJ 40436 1850 6 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 1850 7 coincide coincide VBP 40436 1850 8 ; ; : 40436 1850 9 more more RBR 40436 1850 10 often often RB 40436 1850 11 or or CC 40436 1850 12 at at IN 40436 1850 13 least least JJS 40436 1850 14 very very RB 40436 1850 15 often often RB 40436 1850 16 , , , 40436 1850 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1850 18 do do VBP 40436 1850 19 not not RB 40436 1850 20 . . . 40436 1851 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1851 2 is be VBZ 40436 1851 3 made make VBN 40436 1851 4 to to TO 40436 1851 5 protest protest VB 40436 1851 6 , , , 40436 1851 7 in in IN 40436 1851 8 this this DT 40436 1851 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1851 10 , , , 40436 1851 11 against against IN 40436 1851 12 the the DT 40436 1851 13 mention mention NN 40436 1851 14 of of IN 40436 1851 15 such such JJ 40436 1851 16 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 1851 17 objects object NNS 40436 1851 18 as as IN 40436 1851 19 the the DT 40436 1851 20 pot pot NN 40436 1851 21 and and CC 40436 1851 22 the the DT 40436 1851 23 ladle ladle NN 40436 1851 24 ; ; : 40436 1851 25 and and CC 40436 1851 26 this this DT 40436 1851 27 is be VBZ 40436 1851 28 apparently apparently RB 40436 1851 29 intended intend VBN 40436 1851 30 by by IN 40436 1851 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1851 32 as as IN 40436 1851 33 a a DT 40436 1851 34 defective defective JJ 40436 1851 35 point point NN 40436 1851 36 in in IN 40436 1851 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1851 38 character character NN 40436 1851 39 , , , 40436 1851 40 denoting denote VBG 40436 1851 41 silly silly JJ 40436 1851 42 affectation affectation NN 40436 1851 43 and and CC 40436 1851 44 conceit conceit NN 40436 1851 45 , , , 40436 1851 46 like like IN 40436 1851 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1851 48 fine fine JJ 40436 1851 49 apparel apparel NN 40436 1851 50 . . . 40436 1852 1 But but CC 40436 1852 2 Dugald Dugald NNP 40436 1852 3 Stewart Stewart NNP 40436 1852 4 would would MD 40436 1852 5 have have VB 40436 1852 6 agreed agree VBN 40436 1852 7 in in IN 40436 1852 8 the the DT 40436 1852 9 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 1852 10 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 1852 11 to to IN 40436 1852 12 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1852 13 -- -- : 40436 1852 14 that that DT 40436 1852 15 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 1852 16 and and CC 40436 1852 17 mean mean JJ 40436 1852 18 objects object NNS 40436 1852 19 have have VBP 40436 1852 20 no no DT 40436 1852 21 place place NN 40436 1852 22 in in IN 40436 1852 23 an an DT 40436 1852 24 inquiry inquiry NN 40436 1852 25 into into IN 40436 1852 26 the the DT 40436 1852 27 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1852 28 ; ; : 40436 1852 29 and and CC 40436 1852 30 that that IN 40436 1852 31 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1852 32 belong belong VBP 40436 1852 33 , , , 40436 1852 34 when when WRB 40436 1852 35 well well RB 40436 1852 36 - - HYPH 40436 1852 37 formed form VBN 40436 1852 38 for for IN 40436 1852 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1852 40 respective respective JJ 40436 1852 41 purposes purpose NNS 40436 1852 42 , , , 40436 1852 43 to to IN 40436 1852 44 the the DT 40436 1852 45 category category NN 40436 1852 46 of of IN 40436 1852 47 the the DT 40436 1852 48 Useful Useful NNP 40436 1852 49 . . . 40436 1853 1 The the DT 40436 1853 2 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 1853 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1853 4 in in IN 40436 1853 5 the the DT 40436 1853 6 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1853 7 is be VBZ 40436 1853 8 mistaken mistaken JJ 40436 1853 9 in in IN 40436 1853 10 confounding confound VBG 40436 1853 11 the the DT 40436 1853 12 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1853 13 with with IN 40436 1853 14 the the DT 40436 1853 15 Good good JJ 40436 1853 16 and and CC 40436 1853 17 the the DT 40436 1853 18 Useful useful JJ 40436 1853 19 . . . 40436 1854 1 But but CC 40436 1854 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1854 3 remarks remark NNS 40436 1854 4 are be VBP 40436 1854 5 valuable valuable JJ 40436 1854 6 in in IN 40436 1854 7 another another DT 40436 1854 8 point point NN 40436 1854 9 of of IN 40436 1854 10 view view NN 40436 1854 11 , , , 40436 1854 12 as as IN 40436 1854 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1854 14 insist insist VBP 40436 1854 15 most most RBS 40436 1854 16 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 1854 17 on on IN 40436 1854 18 the the DT 40436 1854 19 essential essential JJ 40436 1854 20 relativity relativity NN 40436 1854 21 both both DT 40436 1854 22 of of IN 40436 1854 23 the the DT 40436 1854 24 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1854 25 and and CC 40436 1854 26 the the DT 40436 1854 27 Good good JJ 40436 1854 28 . . . 40436 1855 1 The the DT 40436 1855 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 1855 3 of of IN 40436 1855 4 Dugald Dugald NNP 40436 1855 5 Stewart Stewart NNP 40436 1855 6 is be VBZ 40436 1855 7 supported support VBN 40436 1855 8 by by IN 40436 1855 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 1855 10 John John NNP 40436 1855 11 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 1855 12 Mill Mill NNP 40436 1855 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1855 14 ' ' `` 40436 1855 15 System System NNP 40436 1855 16 of of IN 40436 1855 17 Logic Logic NNP 40436 1855 18 , , , 40436 1855 19 ' ' '' 40436 1855 20 iv iv XX 40436 1855 21 . . . 40436 1856 1 4 4 CD 40436 1856 2 , , , 40436 1856 3 5 5 CD 40436 1856 4 , , , 40436 1856 5 p. p. NN 40436 1856 6 220 220 CD 40436 1856 7 seq seq NN 40436 1856 8 . . . 40436 1857 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1857 2 ; ; : 40436 1857 3 * * NFP 40436 1857 4 * * NFP 40436 1857 5 and and CC 40436 1857 6 Professor Professor NNP 40436 1857 7 Bain Bain NNP 40436 1857 8 has have VBZ 40436 1857 9 expounded expound VBN 40436 1857 10 the the DT 40436 1857 11 whole whole JJ 40436 1857 12 subject subject NN 40436 1857 13 still still RB 40436 1857 14 more more RBR 40436 1857 15 fully fully RB 40436 1857 16 in in IN 40436 1857 17 a a DT 40436 1857 18 chapter chapter NN 40436 1857 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1857 20 xiv xiv NN 40436 1857 21 . . . 40436 1858 1 p. p. NN 40436 1858 2 225 225 CD 40436 1858 3 seq seq NN 40436 1858 4 . . . 40436 1858 5 , , , 40436 1858 6 on on IN 40436 1858 7 the the DT 40436 1858 8 Æsthetic Æsthetic NNP 40436 1858 9 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 1858 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1858 11 of of IN 40436 1858 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1858 13 work work NN 40436 1858 14 on on IN 40436 1858 15 the the DT 40436 1858 16 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 1858 17 and and CC 40436 1858 18 the the DT 40436 1858 19 Will Will NNP 40436 1858 20 . . . 40436 1858 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1859 1 The the DT 40436 1859 2 concluding conclude VBG 40436 1859 3 observations observation NNS 40436 1859 4 of of IN 40436 1859 5 this this DT 40436 1859 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1859 7 , , , 40436 1859 8 interchanged interchange VBN 40436 1859 9 between between IN 40436 1859 10 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1859 11 and and CC 40436 1859 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1859 13 , , , 40436 1859 14 are be VBP 40436 1859 15 interesting interesting JJ 40436 1859 16 as as IN 40436 1859 17 bringing bring VBG 40436 1859 18 out out RP 40436 1859 19 the the DT 40436 1859 20 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 1859 21 between between IN 40436 1859 22 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 1859 23 and and CC 40436 1859 24 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 1859 25 -- -- : 40436 1859 26 between between IN 40436 1859 27 the the DT 40436 1859 28 concrete concrete NN 40436 1859 29 and and CC 40436 1859 30 exemplifying exemplifying NN 40436 1859 31 , , , 40436 1859 32 as as IN 40436 1859 33 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 1859 34 with with IN 40436 1859 35 the the DT 40436 1859 36 abstract abstract JJ 40436 1859 37 and and CC 40436 1859 38 analytical analytical JJ 40436 1859 39 . . . 40436 1860 1 Immediately immediately RB 40436 1860 2 after after IN 40436 1860 3 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1860 4 has have VBZ 40436 1860 5 brought bring VBN 40436 1860 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1860 7 own own JJ 40436 1860 8 third third JJ 40436 1860 9 suggestion suggestion NN 40436 1860 10 to to IN 40436 1860 11 an an DT 40436 1860 12 inextricable inextricable JJ 40436 1860 13 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 1860 14 , , , 40436 1860 15 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1860 16 remarks-- remarks-- NNP 40436 1860 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1860 18 Side side NN 40436 1860 19 - - HYPH 40436 1860 20 note note NN 40436 1860 21 : : : 40436 1860 22 Concluding concluding NN 40436 1860 23 thrust thrust NN 40436 1860 24 exchanged exchange VBD 40436 1860 25 between between IN 40436 1860 26 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1860 27 and and CC 40436 1860 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1860 29 . . . 40436 1860 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1861 1 " " `` 40436 1861 2 Well well UH 40436 1861 3 , , , 40436 1861 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1861 5 , , , 40436 1861 6 what what WP 40436 1861 7 do do VBP 40436 1861 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1861 9 think think VB 40436 1861 10 now now RB 40436 1861 11 of of IN 40436 1861 12 all all PDT 40436 1861 13 these these DT 40436 1861 14 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 1861 15 of of IN 40436 1861 16 yours -PRON- PRP 40436 1861 17 ? ? . 40436 1862 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 1862 2 are be VBP 40436 1862 3 what what WP 40436 1862 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1862 5 declared declare VBD 40436 1862 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1862 7 to to TO 40436 1862 8 be be VB 40436 1862 9 just just RB 40436 1862 10 now,--scrapings now,--scraping NNS 40436 1862 11 and and CC 40436 1862 12 parings paring NNS 40436 1862 13 of of IN 40436 1862 14 discourse discourse NN 40436 1862 15 , , , 40436 1862 16 divided divide VBD 40436 1862 17 into into IN 40436 1862 18 minute minute JJ 40436 1862 19 fragments fragment NNS 40436 1862 20 . . . 40436 1863 1 But but CC 40436 1863 2 the the DT 40436 1863 3 really really RB 40436 1863 4 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1863 5 and and CC 40436 1863 6 precious precious JJ 40436 1863 7 acquirement acquirement NN 40436 1863 8 is be VBZ 40436 1863 9 , , , 40436 1863 10 to to TO 40436 1863 11 be be VB 40436 1863 12 able able JJ 40436 1863 13 to to TO 40436 1863 14 set set VB 40436 1863 15 out out RP 40436 1863 16 well well RB 40436 1863 17 and and CC 40436 1863 18 finely finely RB 40436 1863 19 a a DT 40436 1863 20 regular regular JJ 40436 1863 21 discourse discourse NN 40436 1863 22 before before IN 40436 1863 23 the the DT 40436 1863 24 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 1863 25 or or CC 40436 1863 26 the the DT 40436 1863 27 public public JJ 40436 1863 28 assembly assembly NN 40436 1863 29 , , , 40436 1863 30 to to TO 40436 1863 31 persuade persuade VB 40436 1863 32 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1863 33 auditors auditor NNS 40436 1863 34 , , , 40436 1863 35 and and CC 40436 1863 36 to to TO 40436 1863 37 depart depart VB 40436 1863 38 carrying carry VBG 40436 1863 39 with with IN 40436 1863 40 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1863 41 not not RB 40436 1863 42 the the DT 40436 1863 43 least least JJS 40436 1863 44 but but CC 40436 1863 45 the the DT 40436 1863 46 greatest great JJS 40436 1863 47 of of IN 40436 1863 48 all all DT 40436 1863 49 prizes prize NNS 40436 1863 50 -- -- : 40436 1863 51 safety safety NN 40436 1863 52 for for IN 40436 1863 53 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 1863 54 , , , 40436 1863 55 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1863 56 property property NN 40436 1863 57 , , , 40436 1863 58 and and CC 40436 1863 59 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1863 60 friends friend NNS 40436 1863 61 . . . 40436 1864 1 These these DT 40436 1864 2 are be VBP 40436 1864 3 the the DT 40436 1864 4 real real JJ 40436 1864 5 objects object NNS 40436 1864 6 to to TO 40436 1864 7 strive strive VB 40436 1864 8 for for IN 40436 1864 9 . . . 40436 1865 1 Leave leave VB 40436 1865 2 off off RP 40436 1865 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1865 4 petty petty JJ 40436 1865 5 cavils cavil NNS 40436 1865 6 , , , 40436 1865 7 that that IN 40436 1865 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1865 9 may may MD 40436 1865 10 not not RB 40436 1865 11 look look VB 40436 1865 12 like like IN 40436 1865 13 an an DT 40436 1865 14 extreme extreme JJ 40436 1865 15 simpleton simpleton NN 40436 1865 16 , , , 40436 1865 17 handling handle VBG 40436 1865 18 silly silly JJ 40436 1865 19 trifles trifle NNS 40436 1865 20 as as IN 40436 1865 21 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1865 22 do do VBP 40436 1865 23 at at IN 40436 1865 24 present present JJ 40436 1865 25 . . . 40436 1866 1 " " `` 40436 1866 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1866 3 41 41 CD 40436 1866 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1866 5 " " `` 40436 1866 6 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1866 7 dear dear JJ 40436 1866 8 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1866 9 , , , 40436 1866 10 " " '' 40436 1866 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1866 12 replies reply VBZ 40436 1866 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1866 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1866 15 " " `` 40436 1866 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1866 17 are be VBP 40436 1866 18 a a DT 40436 1866 19 happy happy JJ 40436 1866 20 man man NN 40436 1866 21 , , , 40436 1866 22 since since IN 40436 1866 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1866 24 know know VBP 40436 1866 25 what what WP 40436 1866 26 pursuits pursuit VBZ 40436 1866 27 a a DT 40436 1866 28 man man NN 40436 1866 29 ought ought MD 40436 1866 30 to to TO 40436 1866 31 follow follow VB 40436 1866 32 , , , 40436 1866 33 and and CC 40436 1866 34 have have VB 40436 1866 35 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 1866 36 followed follow VBN 40436 1866 37 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1866 38 , , , 40436 1866 39 as as IN 40436 1866 40 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1866 41 say say VBP 40436 1866 42 , , , 40436 1866 43 with with IN 40436 1866 44 good good JJ 40436 1866 45 success success NN 40436 1866 46 . . . 40436 1867 1 But but CC 40436 1867 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1867 3 , , , 40436 1867 4 as as IN 40436 1867 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1867 6 seems seem VBZ 40436 1867 7 , , , 40436 1867 8 am be VBP 40436 1867 9 under under IN 40436 1867 10 the the DT 40436 1867 11 grasp grasp NN 40436 1867 12 of of IN 40436 1867 13 an an DT 40436 1867 14 unaccountable unaccountable JJ 40436 1867 15 fortune fortune NN 40436 1867 16 : : : 40436 1867 17 for for IN 40436 1867 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1867 19 am be VBP 40436 1867 20 always always RB 40436 1867 21 fluctuating fluctuate VBG 40436 1867 22 and and CC 40436 1867 23 puzzling puzzle VBG 40436 1867 24 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 1867 25 , , , 40436 1867 26 and and CC 40436 1867 27 when when WRB 40436 1867 28 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1867 29 lay lay VBP 40436 1867 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1867 31 puzzle puzzle NN 40436 1867 32 before before IN 40436 1867 33 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1867 34 wise wise JJ 40436 1867 35 men man NNS 40436 1867 36 , , , 40436 1867 37 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1867 38 am be VBP 40436 1867 39 requited requite VBN 40436 1867 40 by by IN 40436 1867 41 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1867 42 with with IN 40436 1867 43 hard hard JJ 40436 1867 44 words word NNS 40436 1867 45 . . . 40436 1868 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1868 2 am be VBP 40436 1868 3 told tell VBN 40436 1868 4 just just RB 40436 1868 5 what what WP 40436 1868 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1868 7 have have VBP 40436 1868 8 now now RB 40436 1868 9 been be VBN 40436 1868 10 telling tell VBG 40436 1868 11 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1868 12 , , , 40436 1868 13 that that IN 40436 1868 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1868 15 busy busy VBP 40436 1868 16 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 1868 17 about about IN 40436 1868 18 matters matter NNS 40436 1868 19 silly silly JJ 40436 1868 20 , , , 40436 1868 21 petty petty JJ 40436 1868 22 , , , 40436 1868 23 and and CC 40436 1868 24 worthless worthless JJ 40436 1868 25 . . . 40436 1869 1 When when WRB 40436 1869 2 on on IN 40436 1869 3 the the DT 40436 1869 4 contrary contrary JJ 40436 1869 5 , , , 40436 1869 6 overborne overborne JJ 40436 1869 7 by by IN 40436 1869 8 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1869 9 authority authority NN 40436 1869 10 , , , 40436 1869 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1869 12 declare declare VBP 40436 1869 13 as as IN 40436 1869 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1869 15 do do VBP 40436 1869 16 , , , 40436 1869 17 that that IN 40436 1869 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1869 19 is be VBZ 40436 1869 20 the the DT 40436 1869 21 finest fine JJS 40436 1869 22 thing thing NN 40436 1869 23 possible possible JJ 40436 1869 24 to to TO 40436 1869 25 be be VB 40436 1869 26 able able JJ 40436 1869 27 to to TO 40436 1869 28 set set VB 40436 1869 29 out out RP 40436 1869 30 well well RB 40436 1869 31 and and CC 40436 1869 32 beautifully beautifully RB 40436 1869 33 a a DT 40436 1869 34 regular regular JJ 40436 1869 35 discourse discourse NN 40436 1869 36 before before IN 40436 1869 37 the the DT 40436 1869 38 public public NNP 40436 1869 39 assembly assembly NN 40436 1869 40 , , , 40436 1869 41 and and CC 40436 1869 42 bring bring VB 40436 1869 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1869 44 to to IN 40436 1869 45 successful successful JJ 40436 1869 46 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 1869 47 -- -- : 40436 1869 48 then then RB 40436 1869 49 there there EX 40436 1869 50 are be VBP 40436 1869 51 other other JJ 40436 1869 52 men man NNS 40436 1869 53 at at IN 40436 1869 54 hand hand NN 40436 1869 55 who who WP 40436 1869 56 heap heap VBP 40436 1869 57 upon upon IN 40436 1869 58 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1869 59 bitter bitter JJ 40436 1869 60 reproaches reproach NNS 40436 1869 61 : : : 40436 1869 62 especially especially RB 40436 1869 63 that that IN 40436 1869 64 one one CD 40436 1869 65 man man NN 40436 1869 66 , , , 40436 1869 67 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1869 68 nearest near JJS 40436 1869 69 kinsman kinsman NN 40436 1869 70 and and CC 40436 1869 71 inmate inmate VB 40436 1869 72 , , , 40436 1869 73 who who WP 40436 1869 74 never never RB 40436 1869 75 omits omit VBZ 40436 1869 76 to to TO 40436 1869 77 convict convict VB 40436 1869 78 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1869 79 . . . 40436 1870 1 When when WRB 40436 1870 2 on on IN 40436 1870 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1870 4 return return NN 40436 1870 5 home home RB 40436 1870 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1870 7 hears hear VBZ 40436 1870 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1870 9 repeat repeat VB 40436 1870 10 what what WP 40436 1870 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1870 12 have have VBP 40436 1870 13 told tell VBN 40436 1870 14 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1870 15 , , , 40436 1870 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1870 17 asks ask VBZ 40436 1870 18 , , , 40436 1870 19 if if IN 40436 1870 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1870 21 am be VBP 40436 1870 22 not not RB 40436 1870 23 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 1870 24 of of IN 40436 1870 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1870 26 impudence impudence NN 40436 1870 27 in in IN 40436 1870 28 talking talk VBG 40436 1870 29 about about IN 40436 1870 30 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1870 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1870 32 honourable honourable JJ 40436 1870 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1870 34 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 1870 35 , , , 40436 1870 36 when when WRB 40436 1870 37 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1870 38 am be VBP 40436 1870 39 so so RB 40436 1870 40 manifestly manifestly RB 40436 1870 41 convicted convict VBN 40436 1870 42 upon upon IN 40436 1870 43 this this DT 40436 1870 44 subject subject NN 40436 1870 45 , , , 40436 1870 46 of of IN 40436 1870 47 not not RB 40436 1870 48 even even RB 40436 1870 49 knowing know VBG 40436 1870 50 what what WP 40436 1870 51 the the DT 40436 1870 52 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1870 53 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1870 54 Honourable honourable JJ 40436 1870 55 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1870 56 is be VBZ 40436 1870 57 . . . 40436 1871 1 How how WRB 40436 1871 2 can can MD 40436 1871 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1871 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1871 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1871 6 says say VBZ 40436 1871 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1871 8 , , , 40436 1871 9 being be VBG 40436 1871 10 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 1871 11 what what WP 40436 1871 12 the the DT 40436 1871 13 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1871 14 is be VBZ 40436 1871 15 , , , 40436 1871 16 know know VB 40436 1871 17 _ _ NNP 40436 1871 18 who who WP 40436 1871 19 _ _ NNP 40436 1871 20 has have VBZ 40436 1871 21 set set VBN 40436 1871 22 out out RP 40436 1871 23 a a DT 40436 1871 24 discourse discourse NN 40436 1871 25 beautifully beautifully RB 40436 1871 26 and and CC 40436 1871 27 _ _ NNP 40436 1871 28 who who WP 40436 1871 29 _ _ NNP 40436 1871 30 has have VBZ 40436 1871 31 not--_who not--_who NNP 40436 1871 32 _ _ NNP 40436 1871 33 has have VBZ 40436 1871 34 performed perform VBN 40436 1871 35 a a DT 40436 1871 36 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1871 37 exploit exploit NN 40436 1871 38 and and CC 40436 1871 39 _ _ NNP 40436 1871 40 who who WP 40436 1871 41 _ _ NNP 40436 1871 42 has have VBZ 40436 1871 43 not not RB 40436 1871 44 ? ? . 40436 1872 1 Since since IN 40436 1872 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1872 3 are be VBP 40436 1872 4 in in IN 40436 1872 5 a a DT 40436 1872 6 condition condition NN 40436 1872 7 so so RB 40436 1872 8 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 1872 9 , , , 40436 1872 10 can can MD 40436 1872 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1872 12 think think VB 40436 1872 13 life life NN 40436 1872 14 better well JJR 40436 1872 15 for for IN 40436 1872 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1872 17 than than IN 40436 1872 18 death death NN 40436 1872 19 ? ? . 40436 1873 1 Such such JJ 40436 1873 2 then then RB 40436 1873 3 is be VBZ 40436 1873 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1873 5 fate fate NN 40436 1873 6 -- -- : 40436 1873 7 to to TO 40436 1873 8 hear hear VB 40436 1873 9 disparagement disparagement NN 40436 1873 10 and and CC 40436 1873 11 reproaches reproach NNS 40436 1873 12 from from IN 40436 1873 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 1873 14 on on IN 40436 1873 15 the the DT 40436 1873 16 one one CD 40436 1873 17 side side NN 40436 1873 18 , , , 40436 1873 19 and and CC 40436 1873 20 from from IN 40436 1873 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 1873 22 on on IN 40436 1873 23 the the DT 40436 1873 24 other other JJ 40436 1873 25 . . . 40436 1874 1 Necessity necessity NN 40436 1874 2 however however RB 40436 1874 3 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 1874 4 requires require VBZ 40436 1874 5 that that IN 40436 1874 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1874 7 should should MD 40436 1874 8 endure endure VB 40436 1874 9 all all PDT 40436 1874 10 these these DT 40436 1874 11 discomforts discomfort NNS 40436 1874 12 : : : 40436 1874 13 for for IN 40436 1874 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1874 15 will will MD 40436 1874 16 be be VB 40436 1874 17 nothing nothing NN 40436 1874 18 strange strange JJ 40436 1874 19 if if IN 40436 1874 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1874 21 profit profit VBP 40436 1874 22 by by IN 40436 1874 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1874 24 . . . 40436 1875 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 1875 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1875 3 think think VBP 40436 1875 4 that that IN 40436 1875 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1875 6 have have VBP 40436 1875 7 already already RB 40436 1875 8 profited profit VBN 40436 1875 9 both both DT 40436 1875 10 by by IN 40436 1875 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1875 12 society society NN 40436 1875 13 , , , 40436 1875 14 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1875 15 , , , 40436 1875 16 and and CC 40436 1875 17 by by IN 40436 1875 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1875 19 : : : 40436 1875 20 for for IN 40436 1875 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1875 22 now now RB 40436 1875 23 think think VBP 40436 1875 24 that that IN 40436 1875 25 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1875 26 know know VBP 40436 1875 27 what what WP 40436 1875 28 the the DT 40436 1875 29 proverb proverb NN 40436 1875 30 means mean VBZ 40436 1875 31 -- -- : 40436 1875 32 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1875 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1875 34 Honourable honourable JJ 40436 1875 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1875 36 things thing NNS 40436 1875 37 are be VBP 40436 1875 38 difficult difficult JJ 40436 1875 39 . . . 40436 1876 1 " " `` 40436 1876 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1876 3 42 42 CD 40436 1876 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1876 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1876 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1876 7 41 41 CD 40436 1876 8 : : : 40436 1876 9 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1876 10 . . . 40436 1877 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1877 2 . . . 40436 1878 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1878 2 . . NNP 40436 1878 3 304 304 CD 40436 1878 4 A. a. NN 40436 1878 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1879 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1879 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1879 3 42 42 CD 40436 1879 4 : : : 40436 1879 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1879 6 . . . 40436 1880 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1880 2 . . . 40436 1881 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1881 2 . . NNP 40436 1881 3 304 304 CD 40436 1881 4 D D NNP 40436 1881 5 - - HYPH 40436 1881 6 E. e. NN 40436 1881 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1881 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1881 9 Side side NN 40436 1881 10 - - HYPH 40436 1881 11 note note NN 40436 1881 12 : : : 40436 1881 13 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 1881 14 against against IN 40436 1881 15 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 1881 16 . . . 40436 1881 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1882 1 Here here RB 40436 1882 2 is be VBZ 40436 1882 3 a a DT 40436 1882 4 suitable suitable JJ 40436 1882 5 termination termination NN 40436 1882 6 for for IN 40436 1882 7 one one CD 40436 1882 8 of of IN 40436 1882 9 the the DT 40436 1882 10 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1882 11 of of IN 40436 1882 12 Search Search NNP 40436 1882 13 : : : 40436 1882 14 " " `` 40436 1882 15 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1882 16 mind mind NN 40436 1882 17 has have VBZ 40436 1882 18 been be VBN 40436 1882 19 embarrassed embarrass VBN 40436 1882 20 by by IN 40436 1882 21 contradictions contradiction NNS 40436 1882 22 as as IN 40436 1882 23 yet yet RB 40436 1882 24 unreconciled unreconciled JJ 40436 1882 25 , , , 40436 1882 26 but but CC 40436 1882 27 this this DT 40436 1882 28 is be VBZ 40436 1882 29 a a DT 40436 1882 30 stage stage NN 40436 1882 31 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 1882 32 to to IN 40436 1882 33 future future JJ 40436 1882 34 improvement improvement NN 40436 1882 35 " " '' 40436 1882 36 . . . 40436 1883 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 1883 2 have have VBP 40436 1883 3 moreover moreover RB 40436 1883 4 an an DT 40436 1883 5 interesting interesting JJ 40436 1883 6 passage passage NN 40436 1883 7 of of IN 40436 1883 8 arms arm NNS 40436 1883 9 between between IN 40436 1883 10 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 1883 11 and and CC 40436 1883 12 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 1883 13 : : : 40436 1883 14 two two CD 40436 1883 15 contemporaneous contemporaneous JJ 40436 1883 16 and and CC 40436 1883 17 contending contend VBG 40436 1883 18 agencies agency NNS 40436 1883 19 , , , 40436 1883 20 among among IN 40436 1883 21 the the DT 40436 1883 22 stirring stir VBG 40436 1883 23 minds mind NNS 40436 1883 24 of of IN 40436 1883 25 Athens Athens NNP 40436 1883 26 , , , 40436 1883 27 in in IN 40436 1883 28 the the DT 40436 1883 29 time time NN 40436 1883 30 of of IN 40436 1883 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1883 32 and and CC 40436 1883 33 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 1883 34 . . . 40436 1884 1 The the DT 40436 1884 2 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 1884 3 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 1884 4 the the DT 40436 1884 5 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 1884 6 of of IN 40436 1884 7 departing depart VBG 40436 1884 8 from from IN 40436 1884 9 the the DT 40436 1884 10 conditions condition NNS 40436 1884 11 of of IN 40436 1884 12 reality reality NN 40436 1884 13 -- -- : 40436 1884 14 of of IN 40436 1884 15 breaking break VBG 40436 1884 16 up up RP 40436 1884 17 the the DT 40436 1884 18 integrity integrity NN 40436 1884 19 of of IN 40436 1884 20 those those DT 40436 1884 21 concretes concrete NNS 40436 1884 22 , , , 40436 1884 23 which which WDT 40436 1884 24 occur occur VBP 40436 1884 25 in in IN 40436 1884 26 nature nature NN 40436 1884 27 each each DT 40436 1884 28 as as IN 40436 1884 29 continuous continuous JJ 40436 1884 30 and and CC 40436 1884 31 indivisible indivisible JJ 40436 1884 32 wholes whole NNS 40436 1884 33 . . . 40436 1885 1 Each each DT 40436 1885 2 of of IN 40436 1885 3 the the DT 40436 1885 4 analogous analogous JJ 40436 1885 5 particular particular JJ 40436 1885 6 cases case NNS 40436 1885 7 forms form VBZ 40436 1885 8 a a DT 40436 1885 9 continuum continuum NN 40436 1885 10 or or CC 40436 1885 11 concrete concrete NN 40436 1885 12 by by IN 40436 1885 13 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 1885 14 , , , 40436 1885 15 which which WDT 40436 1885 16 may may MD 40436 1885 17 be be VB 40436 1885 18 compared compare VBN 40436 1885 19 with with IN 40436 1885 20 the the DT 40436 1885 21 others other NNS 40436 1885 22 , , , 40436 1885 23 but but CC 40436 1885 24 can can MD 40436 1885 25 not not RB 40436 1885 26 be be VB 40436 1885 27 taken take VBN 40436 1885 28 to to IN 40436 1885 29 pieces piece NNS 40436 1885 30 , , , 40436 1885 31 and and CC 40436 1885 32 studied study VBN 40436 1885 33 in in IN 40436 1885 34 separate separate JJ 40436 1885 35 fragments fragment NNS 40436 1885 36 . . . 40436 1886 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1886 2 43 43 CD 40436 1886 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1886 4 The the DT 40436 1886 5 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 1886 6 on on IN 40436 1886 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1886 8 side side NN 40436 1886 9 treats treat VBZ 40436 1886 10 the the DT 40436 1886 11 Abstract Abstract NNP 40436 1886 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1886 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1886 14 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1886 15 : : : 40436 1886 16 to\ to\ NN 40436 1886 17 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 1886 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1886 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1886 20 as as IN 40436 1886 21 the the DT 40436 1886 22 real real JJ 40436 1886 23 Integer Integer NNP 40436 1886 24 , , , 40436 1886 25 and and CC 40436 1886 26 the the DT 40436 1886 27 highest high JJS 40436 1886 28 abstraction abstraction NN 40436 1886 29 as as IN 40436 1886 30 the the DT 40436 1886 31 first first JJ 40436 1886 32 of of IN 40436 1886 33 all all DT 40436 1886 34 integers integer NNS 40436 1886 35 , , , 40436 1886 36 containing contain VBG 40436 1886 37 in in IN 40436 1886 38 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 1886 39 and and CC 40436 1886 40 capable capable JJ 40436 1886 41 of of IN 40436 1886 42 evolving evolve VBG 40436 1886 43 all all PDT 40436 1886 44 the the DT 40436 1886 45 subordinate subordinate JJ 40436 1886 46 integers integer NNS 40436 1886 47 : : : 40436 1886 48 the the DT 40436 1886 49 various various JJ 40436 1886 50 accompaniments accompaniment NNS 40436 1886 51 , , , 40436 1886 52 which which WDT 40436 1886 53 go go VBP 40436 1886 54 along along RP 40436 1886 55 with with IN 40436 1886 56 each each DT 40436 1886 57 Abstract Abstract NNP 40436 1886 58 to to TO 40436 1886 59 make make VB 40436 1886 60 up up RP 40436 1886 61 a a DT 40436 1886 62 concrete concrete NN 40436 1886 63 , , , 40436 1886 64 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1886 65 disregards disregard VBZ 40436 1886 66 as as IN 40436 1886 67 shadowy shadowy JJ 40436 1886 68 and and CC 40436 1886 69 transient transient JJ 40436 1886 70 disguises disguise NNS 40436 1886 71 . . . 40436 1887 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1887 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1887 3 43 43 CD 40436 1887 4 : : : 40436 1887 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 1887 6 . . . 40436 1888 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 1888 2 . . . 40436 1889 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1889 2 . . NNP 40436 1889 3 301 301 CD 40436 1889 4 B. b. NN 40436 1890 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1890 2 Greek greek NN 40436 1890 3 : : : 40436 1890 4 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 1890 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 1890 6 dê\ dê\ JJ 40436 1890 7 su/ su/ NN 40436 1890 8 , , , 40436 1890 9 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 1890 10 Sô Sô NNP 40436 1890 11 / / SYM 40436 1890 12 krates krate NNS 40436 1890 13 , , , 40436 1890 14 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 1890 15 me\n me\n NNP 40436 1890 16 o(/la o(/la NNP 40436 1890 17 tô tô NNP 40436 1890 18 = = SYM 40436 1890 19 n n NNP 40436 1890 20 pragma pragma NNP 40436 1890 21 / / SYM 40436 1890 22 tôn tôn NNP 40436 1890 23 ou ou NNP 40436 1890 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1890 25 skopei skopei NNP 40436 1890 26 = = SYM 40436 1890 27 s s NN 40436 1890 28 , , , 40436 1890 29 ou)d ou)d JJ 40436 1890 30 ' ' '' 40436 1890 31 e)kei e)kei NNPS 40436 1890 32 = = SYM 40436 1890 33 noi noi NNP 40436 1890 34 , , , 40436 1890 35 oi(=s oi(=s JJ 40436 1890 36 su\ su\ JJ 40436 1890 37 ei)/ôthas ei)/ôtha VBZ 40436 1890 38 diale diale NNP 40436 1890 39 / / SYM 40436 1890 40 gesthai gesthai NNP 40436 1890 41 , , , 40436 1890 42 krou krou NNP 40436 1890 43 / / SYM 40436 1890 44 ete ete NNP 40436 1890 45 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1890 46 a)polamba a)polamba NNPS 40436 1890 47 / / SYM 40436 1890 48 nontes nonte NNS 40436 1890 49 to\ to\ VBP 40436 1890 50 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 1890 51 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1890 52 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 1890 53 tô tô NNP 40436 1890 54 = = SYM 40436 1890 55 n n CC 40436 1890 56 o)/ntôn o)/ntôn NNP 40436 1890 57 e)n e)n NNP 40436 1890 58 toi toi NNP 40436 1890 59 = = SYM 40436 1890 60 s s NNP 40436 1890 61 lo lo NNP 40436 1890 62 / / SYM 40436 1890 63 gois gois NNP 40436 1890 64 katate katate NNP 40436 1890 65 / / SYM 40436 1890 66 mnontes mnontes NNPS 40436 1890 67 ; ; : 40436 1890 68 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 1890 69 tau tau NNP 40436 1890 70 = = SYM 40436 1890 71 ta ta NNP 40436 1890 72 ou(/tô ou(/tô IN 40436 1890 73 mega mega NNP 40436 1890 74 / / SYM 40436 1890 75 la la NNP 40436 1890 76 u(ma u(ma NNP 40436 1890 77 = = SYM 40436 1890 78 s s NNP 40436 1890 79 lantha lantha NNP 40436 1890 80 / / SYM 40436 1890 81 nei nei NNP 40436 1890 82 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1890 83 _ _ NNP 40436 1890 84 dianekê= dianekê= NNP 40436 1890 85 sô sô NNP 40436 1890 86 / / SYM 40436 1890 87 mata mata NNP 40436 1890 88 tê tê NNP 40436 1890 89 = = SYM 40436 1890 90 s s NNP 40436 1890 91 ou)si ou)si NNP 40436 1890 92 / / SYM 40436 1890 93 as as IN 40436 1890 94 pephuko pephuko NNP 40436 1890 95 / / SYM 40436 1890 96 ta ta NNP 40436 1890 97 _ _ NNP 40436 1890 98 . . . 40436 1890 99 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1891 1 Compare compare VB 40436 1891 2 301 301 CD 40436 1891 3 E. e. NN 40436 1891 4 The the DT 40436 1891 5 words word NNS 40436 1891 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1891 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1891 8 : : : 40436 1891 9 dianekê= dianekê= NNP 40436 1891 10 sô sô NNP 40436 1891 11 / / SYM 40436 1891 12 mata mata NNP 40436 1891 13 tê tê NNP 40436 1891 14 = = SYM 40436 1891 15 s s NNP 40436 1891 16 ou)si ou)si NNP 40436 1891 17 / / SYM 40436 1891 18 as as IN 40436 1891 19 pephuko pephuko NNP 40436 1891 20 / / SYM 40436 1891 21 ta ta NNP 40436 1891 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1891 23 correspond correspond VB 40436 1891 24 as as RB 40436 1891 25 nearly nearly RB 40436 1891 26 as as IN 40436 1891 27 can can MD 40436 1891 28 be be VB 40436 1891 29 to to IN 40436 1891 30 the the DT 40436 1891 31 logical logical JJ 40436 1891 32 term term NN 40436 1891 33 _ _ NNP 40436 1891 34 Concrete Concrete NNP 40436 1891 35 _ _ NNP 40436 1891 36 , , , 40436 1891 37 opposed oppose VBN 40436 1891 38 to to IN 40436 1891 39 _ _ NNP 40436 1891 40 Abstract Abstract NNP 40436 1891 41 _ _ NNP 40436 1891 42 . . . 40436 1892 1 Nature nature NN 40436 1892 2 furnishes furnish VBZ 40436 1892 3 only only RB 40436 1892 4 Concreta Concreta NNP 40436 1892 5 , , , 40436 1892 6 not not RB 40436 1892 7 Abstracta Abstracta NNP 40436 1892 8 . . . 40436 1892 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1893 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1893 2 Side side NN 40436 1893 3 - - HYPH 40436 1893 4 note note NN 40436 1893 5 : : : 40436 1893 6 Men man NNS 40436 1893 7 who who WP 40436 1893 8 dealt deal VBD 40436 1893 9 with with IN 40436 1893 10 real real JJ 40436 1893 11 life life NN 40436 1893 12 , , , 40436 1893 13 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 1893 14 with with IN 40436 1893 15 the the DT 40436 1893 16 speculative speculative JJ 40436 1893 17 and and CC 40436 1893 18 analytical analytical JJ 40436 1893 19 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 1893 20 . . . 40436 1893 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1894 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1894 2 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 1894 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1894 4 of of IN 40436 1894 5 never never RB 40436 1894 6 taking take VBG 40436 1894 7 into into IN 40436 1894 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1894 9 view view NN 40436 1894 10 Wholes Wholes NNP 40436 1894 11 , , , 40436 1894 12 and and CC 40436 1894 13 of of IN 40436 1894 14 confining confine VBG 40436 1894 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1894 16 attention attention NN 40436 1894 17 to to IN 40436 1894 18 separate separate JJ 40436 1894 19 parts part NNS 40436 1894 20 and and CC 40436 1894 21 fragments fragment NNS 40436 1894 22 , , , 40436 1894 23 obtained obtain VBN 40436 1894 24 by by IN 40436 1894 25 logical logical JJ 40436 1894 26 analysis analysis NN 40436 1894 27 and and CC 40436 1894 28 subdivision subdivision NN 40436 1894 29 . . . 40436 1895 1 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40436 1895 2 , , , 40436 1895 3 when when WRB 40436 1895 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1895 5 attacks attack VBZ 40436 1895 6 the the DT 40436 1895 7 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 1895 8 of of IN 40436 1895 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1895 10 , , , 40436 1895 11 takes take VBZ 40436 1895 12 the the DT 40436 1895 13 same same JJ 40436 1895 14 ground ground NN 40436 1895 15 , , , 40436 1895 16 employing employ VBG 40436 1895 17 numerous numerous JJ 40436 1895 18 comic comic JJ 40436 1895 19 metaphors metaphor NNS 40436 1895 20 to to TO 40436 1895 21 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 1895 22 the the DT 40436 1895 23 small small JJ 40436 1895 24 and and CC 40436 1895 25 impalpable impalpable JJ 40436 1895 26 fragments fragment NNS 40436 1895 27 handled handle VBN 40436 1895 28 , , , 40436 1895 29 and and CC 40436 1895 30 the the DT 40436 1895 31 subtle subtle JJ 40436 1895 32 transpositions transposition NNS 40436 1895 33 which which WDT 40436 1895 34 they -PRON- PRP 40436 1895 35 underwent undergo VBD 40436 1895 36 in in IN 40436 1895 37 the the DT 40436 1895 38 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 1895 39 . . . 40436 1896 1 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 1896 2 again again RB 40436 1896 3 deprecates deprecate VBZ 40436 1896 4 the the DT 40436 1896 5 over over NN 40436 1896 6 - - HYPH 40436 1896 7 subtlety subtlety NN 40436 1896 8 of of IN 40436 1896 9 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 1896 10 debate debate NN 40436 1896 11 , , , 40436 1896 12 contrasting contrast VBG 40436 1896 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1896 14 with with IN 40436 1896 15 discussions discussion NNS 40436 1896 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1896 17 in in IN 40436 1896 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1896 19 opinion opinion NN 40436 1896 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1896 21 more more RBR 40436 1896 22 useful useful JJ 40436 1896 23 ; ; : 40436 1896 24 wherein wherein WRB 40436 1896 25 entire entire JJ 40436 1896 26 situations situation NNS 40436 1896 27 , , , 40436 1896 28 each each DT 40436 1896 29 with with IN 40436 1896 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1896 31 full full JJ 40436 1896 32 clothing clothing NN 40436 1896 33 and and CC 40436 1896 34 assemblage assemblage NN 40436 1896 35 of of IN 40436 1896 36 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 1896 37 , , , 40436 1896 38 were be VBD 40436 1896 39 reviewed review VBN 40436 1896 40 and and CC 40436 1896 41 estimated estimate VBN 40436 1896 42 . . . 40436 1897 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1897 2 44 44 CD 40436 1897 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1897 4 All all PDT 40436 1897 5 these these DT 40436 1897 6 are be VBP 40436 1897 7 protests protest NNS 40436 1897 8 , , , 40436 1897 9 by by IN 40436 1897 10 persons person NNS 40436 1897 11 accustomed accustom VBN 40436 1897 12 to to TO 40436 1897 13 deal deal VB 40436 1897 14 with with IN 40436 1897 15 real real JJ 40436 1897 16 life life NN 40436 1897 17 , , , 40436 1897 18 and and CC 40436 1897 19 to to TO 40436 1897 20 talk talk VB 40436 1897 21 to to IN 40436 1897 22 auditors auditor NNS 40436 1897 23 both both CC 40436 1897 24 numerous numerous JJ 40436 1897 25 and and CC 40436 1897 26 commonplace commonplace JJ 40436 1897 27 , , , 40436 1897 28 against against IN 40436 1897 29 that that DT 40436 1897 30 conscious conscious JJ 40436 1897 31 analysis analysis NN 40436 1897 32 and and CC 40436 1897 33 close close JJ 40436 1897 34 attention attention NN 40436 1897 35 to to IN 40436 1897 36 general general JJ 40436 1897 37 and and CC 40436 1897 38 abstract abstract JJ 40436 1897 39 terms term NNS 40436 1897 40 , , , 40436 1897 41 which which WDT 40436 1897 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1897 43 first first RB 40436 1897 44 insisted insist VBD 40436 1897 45 on on IN 40436 1897 46 and and CC 40436 1897 47 transmitted transmit VBN 40436 1897 48 to to IN 40436 1897 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1897 50 disciples disciple NNS 40436 1897 51 . . . 40436 1898 1 On on IN 40436 1898 2 the the DT 40436 1898 3 other other JJ 40436 1898 4 side side NN 40436 1898 5 , , , 40436 1898 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1898 7 have have VBP 40436 1898 8 the the DT 40436 1898 9 emphatic emphatic JJ 40436 1898 10 declaration declaration NN 40436 1898 11 made make VBN 40436 1898 12 by by IN 40436 1898 13 the the DT 40436 1898 14 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 1898 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1898 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1898 17 and and CC 40436 1898 18 made make VBN 40436 1898 19 still still RB 40436 1898 20 earlier early RBR 40436 1898 21 by by IN 40436 1898 22 the the DT 40436 1898 23 Xenophontic[45 xenophontic[45 NN 40436 1898 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1898 25 or or CC 40436 1898 26 historical historical JJ 40436 1898 27 Sokrates)--That sokrates)--that NN 40436 1898 28 a a DT 40436 1898 29 man man NN 40436 1898 30 was be VBD 40436 1898 31 not not RB 40436 1898 32 fit fit JJ 40436 1898 33 to to TO 40436 1898 34 talk talk VB 40436 1898 35 about about IN 40436 1898 36 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1898 37 things thing NNS 40436 1898 38 in in IN 40436 1898 39 the the DT 40436 1898 40 concrete concrete NN 40436 1898 41 -- -- : 40436 1898 42 that that IN 40436 1898 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1898 44 had have VBD 40436 1898 45 no no DT 40436 1898 46 right right NN 40436 1898 47 to to TO 40436 1898 48 affirm affirm VB 40436 1898 49 or or CC 40436 1898 50 deny deny VB 40436 1898 51 that that DT 40436 1898 52 attribute attribute NN 40436 1898 53 , , , 40436 1898 54 with with IN 40436 1898 55 respect respect NN 40436 1898 56 to to IN 40436 1898 57 any any DT 40436 1898 58 given give VBN 40436 1898 59 subject subject NN 40436 1898 60 -- -- : 40436 1898 61 that that IN 40436 1898 62 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1898 63 was be VBD 40436 1898 64 not not RB 40436 1898 65 * * NFP 40436 1898 66 * * NFP 40436 1898 67 even even RB 40436 1898 68 fit fit VBP 40436 1898 69 to to TO 40436 1898 70 live live VB 40436 1898 71 unless unless IN 40436 1898 72 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1898 73 could could MD 40436 1898 74 explain explain VB 40436 1898 75 what what WP 40436 1898 76 was be VBD 40436 1898 77 meant mean VBN 40436 1898 78 by by IN 40436 1898 79 The the DT 40436 1898 80 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1898 81 , , , 40436 1898 82 or or CC 40436 1898 83 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1898 84 in in IN 40436 1898 85 the the DT 40436 1898 86 abstract abstract NN 40436 1898 87 . . . 40436 1899 1 Here here RB 40436 1899 2 are be VBP 40436 1899 3 two two CD 40436 1899 4 distinct distinct JJ 40436 1899 5 and and CC 40436 1899 6 conflicting conflicting JJ 40436 1899 7 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 1899 8 habits habit NNS 40436 1899 9 , , , 40436 1899 10 the the DT 40436 1899 11 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 1899 12 between between IN 40436 1899 13 which which WDT 40436 1899 14 , , , 40436 1899 15 indicated indicate VBD 40436 1899 16 in in IN 40436 1899 17 this this DT 40436 1899 18 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1899 19 , , , 40436 1899 20 is be VBZ 40436 1899 21 described describe VBN 40436 1899 22 at at IN 40436 1899 23 large large JJ 40436 1899 24 and and CC 40436 1899 25 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 1899 26 in in IN 40436 1899 27 the the DT 40436 1899 28 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 1899 29 . . . 40436 1900 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1900 2 46 46 CD 40436 1900 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1900 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1900 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1900 6 44 44 CD 40436 1900 7 : : : 40436 1900 8 Aristophan Aristophan NNP 40436 1900 9 . . . 40436 1901 1 Nubes Nubes NNP 40436 1901 2 , , , 40436 1901 3 130 130 CD 40436 1901 4 . . . 40436 1902 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1902 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1902 3 : : : 40436 1902 4 lo lo NNP 40436 1902 5 / / SYM 40436 1902 6 gôn gôn NNP 40436 1902 7 a)kribô a)kribô NNPS 40436 1902 8 = = SYM 40436 1902 9 n n CC 40436 1902 10 schindala schindala NN 40436 1902 11 / / SYM 40436 1902 12 mous mous JJ 40436 1902 13 -- -- : 40436 1902 14 paipa paipa NNP 40436 1902 15 / / SYM 40436 1902 16 lê lê NNP 40436 1902 17 . . . 40436 1902 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1903 1 Nub nub UH 40436 1903 2 . . . 40436 1904 1 261 261 CD 40436 1904 2 , , , 40436 1904 3 Aves Aves NNP 40436 1904 4 , , , 40436 1904 5 430 430 CD 40436 1904 6 . . . 40436 1905 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1905 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1905 3 : : : 40436 1905 4 leptota leptota NNP 40436 1905 5 / / SYM 40436 1905 6 tôn tôn NNP 40436 1905 7 lê lê NNP 40436 1905 8 / / SYM 40436 1905 9 rôn rôn NNP 40436 1905 10 i(ereu= i(ereu= NNP 40436 1905 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1905 12 , , , 40436 1905 13 Nub Nub NNP 40436 1905 14 . . . 40436 1906 1 359 359 CD 40436 1906 2 . . . 40436 1907 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1907 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1907 3 : : : 40436 1907 4 gnô gnô NNP 40436 1907 5 / / SYM 40436 1907 6 mais mais NNP 40436 1907 7 leptais leptais NNP 40436 1907 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1907 9 , , , 40436 1907 10 Nub Nub NNP 40436 1907 11 . . . 40436 1908 1 1404 1404 CD 40436 1908 2 . . . 40436 1909 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1909 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1909 3 : : : 40436 1909 4 skariphismoi skariphismoi NNP 40436 1909 5 = = NFP 40436 1909 6 si si FW 40436 1909 7 lê lê NNP 40436 1909 8 / / SYM 40436 1909 9 rôn rôn NN 40436 1909 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1909 11 , , , 40436 1909 12 Ran Ran NNP 40436 1909 13 . . . 40436 1910 1 1497 1497 CD 40436 1910 2 . . . 40436 1911 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1911 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1911 3 : : : 40436 1911 4 smileu smileu NN 40436 1911 5 / / SYM 40436 1911 6 mata]--id mata]--id NNP 40436 1911 7 . . . 40436 1912 1 819 819 CD 40436 1912 2 . . . 40436 1913 1 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 1913 2 , , , 40436 1913 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1913 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1913 5 : : : 40436 1913 6 Pro\s Pro\s NNP 40436 1913 7 Nikokle Nikokle NNP 40436 1913 8 / / SYM 40436 1913 9 a a NN 40436 1913 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1913 11 , , , 40436 1913 12 s. s. NNP 40436 1913 13 69 69 CD 40436 1913 14 , , , 40436 1913 15 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 1913 16 of of IN 40436 1913 17 the the DT 40436 1913 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1913 19 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1913 20 : : : 40436 1913 21 lo lo NNP 40436 1913 22 / / SYM 40436 1913 23 goi goi NNP 40436 1913 24 politikoi\ politikoi\ NNP 40436 1913 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1913 26 and and CC 40436 1913 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1913 28 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1913 29 : : : 40436 1913 30 lo lo NNP 40436 1913 31 / / SYM 40436 1913 32 goi goi NNP 40436 1913 33 e)ristikoi/--ma e)ristikoi/--ma NNP 40436 1913 34 / / SYM 40436 1913 35 lista lista NNP 40436 1913 36 me\n me\n NNP 40436 1913 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 1913 38 a)po\ a)po\ NNP 40436 1913 39 tôn tôn NNP 40436 1913 40 kairô kairô NN 40436 1913 41 = = SYM 40436 1913 42 n n CC 40436 1913 43 theôrei theôrei NN 40436 1913 44 = = SYM 40436 1913 45 n n CC 40436 1913 46 sumbouleu sumbouleu NNP 40436 1913 47 / / SYM 40436 1913 48 ontas ontas NNP 40436 1913 49 , , , 40436 1913 50 ei ei NNP 40436 1913 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1913 52 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1913 53 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 1913 54 , , , 40436 1913 55 _ _ NNP 40436 1913 56 kath kath NNP 40436 1913 57 ' ' `` 40436 1913 58 o(/lôn o(/lôn NNP 40436 1913 59 tô tô NNP 40436 1913 60 = = NFP 40436 1913 61 n n NNP 40436 1913 62 pragma pragma NNP 40436 1913 63 / / SYM 40436 1913 64 tôn tôn NNP 40436 1913 65 _ _ NNP 40436 1913 66 le le NNP 40436 1913 67 / / SYM 40436 1913 68 gontas]--which gontas]--which NNP 40436 1913 69 is be VBZ 40436 1913 70 almost almost RB 40436 1913 71 exactly exactly RB 40436 1913 72 the the DT 40436 1913 73 phrase phrase NN 40436 1913 74 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 1913 75 to to IN 40436 1913 76 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1913 77 by by IN 40436 1913 78 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1913 79 in in IN 40436 1913 80 this this DT 40436 1913 81 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1913 82 Major Major NNP 40436 1913 83 . . . 40436 1914 1 Also also RB 40436 1914 2 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 1914 3 , , , 40436 1914 4 Contra Contra NNP 40436 1914 5 Sophistas Sophistas NNP 40436 1914 6 , , , 40436 1914 7 s. s. NNP 40436 1914 8 24 24 CD 40436 1914 9 - - SYM 40436 1914 10 25 25 CD 40436 1914 11 , , , 40436 1914 12 where where WRB 40436 1914 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1914 14 contrasts contrast VBZ 40436 1914 15 the the DT 40436 1914 16 useless useless JJ 40436 1914 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1914 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1914 19 : : : 40436 1914 20 logi logi NNP 40436 1914 21 / / SYM 40436 1914 22 dia dia NNP 40436 1914 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1914 24 , , , 40436 1914 25 debated debate VBN 40436 1914 26 by by IN 40436 1914 27 the the DT 40436 1914 28 contentious contentious JJ 40436 1914 29 dialecticians dialectician NNS 40436 1914 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1914 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1914 32 and and CC 40436 1914 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1914 34 being be VBG 40436 1914 35 probably probably RB 40436 1914 36 included include VBN 40436 1914 37 in in IN 40436 1914 38 this this DT 40436 1914 39 designation designation NN 40436 1914 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1914 41 , , , 40436 1914 42 with with IN 40436 1914 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1914 44 own own JJ 40436 1914 45 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1914 46 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1914 47 : : : 40436 1914 48 lo lo NNP 40436 1914 49 / / SYM 40436 1914 50 goi goi NNP 40436 1914 51 politikoi/ politikoi/ NNP 40436 1914 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1914 53 . . . 40436 1915 1 Compare compare VB 40436 1915 2 also also RB 40436 1915 3 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 1915 4 , , , 40436 1915 5 Or or CC 40436 1915 6 . . . 40436 1916 1 xv xv NNP 40436 1916 2 . . . 40436 1917 1 De De NNP 40436 1917 2 Permutatione Permutatione NNP 40436 1917 3 , , , 40436 1917 4 s. s. NNP 40436 1918 1 211 211 CD 40436 1918 2 - - SYM 40436 1918 3 213 213 CD 40436 1918 4 - - HYPH 40436 1918 5 285 285 CD 40436 1918 6 - - HYPH 40436 1918 7 287 287 CD 40436 1918 8 . . . 40436 1918 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1919 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1919 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1919 3 45 45 CD 40436 1919 4 : : : 40436 1919 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 1919 6 . . . 40436 1920 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 1920 2 . . . 40436 1921 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1922 1 1 1 CD 40436 1922 2 , , , 40436 1922 3 16 16 CD 40436 1922 4 . . . 40436 1922 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1923 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1923 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1923 3 46 46 CD 40436 1923 4 : : : 40436 1923 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1923 6 , , , 40436 1923 7 Theætêt Theætêt NNP 40436 1923 8 . . . 40436 1924 1 pp pp NNP 40436 1924 2 . . . 40436 1925 1 173 173 CD 40436 1925 2 - - SYM 40436 1925 3 174 174 CD 40436 1925 4 - - HYPH 40436 1925 5 175 175 CD 40436 1925 6 . . . 40436 1925 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1926 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1926 2 Side side NN 40436 1926 3 - - HYPH 40436 1926 4 note note NN 40436 1926 5 : : : 40436 1926 6 Concrete Concrete NNP 40436 1926 7 Aggregates Aggregates NNPS 40436 1926 8 -- -- : 40436 1926 9 abstract abstract JJ 40436 1926 10 or or CC 40436 1926 11 logical logical JJ 40436 1926 12 Aggregates Aggregates NNPS 40436 1926 13 . . . 40436 1927 1 Distinct distinct JJ 40436 1927 2 aptitudes aptitude NNS 40436 1927 3 required require VBN 40436 1927 4 by by IN 40436 1927 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 1927 6 for for IN 40436 1927 7 the the DT 40436 1927 8 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 1927 9 . . . 40436 1927 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1928 1 When when WRB 40436 1928 2 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1928 3 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 1928 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 1928 5 of of IN 40436 1928 6 neglecting neglect VBG 40436 1928 7 to to TO 40436 1928 8 notice notice VB 40436 1928 9 Wholes whole NNS 40436 1928 10 or or CC 40436 1928 11 Aggregates Aggregates NNPS 40436 1928 12 , , , 40436 1928 13 this this DT 40436 1928 14 is be VBZ 40436 1928 15 true true JJ 40436 1928 16 in in IN 40436 1928 17 the the DT 40436 1928 18 sense sense NN 40436 1928 19 of of IN 40436 1928 20 Concrete Concrete NNP 40436 1928 21 Wholes Wholes NNPS 40436 1928 22 -- -- : 40436 1928 23 the the DT 40436 1928 24 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 40436 1928 25 sequences sequence NNS 40436 1928 26 and and CC 40436 1928 27 co co NNS 40436 1928 28 - - NNS 40436 1928 29 existences existence NNS 40436 1928 30 , , , 40436 1928 31 perceived perceive VBN 40436 1928 32 by by IN 40436 1928 33 sense sense NN 40436 1928 34 or or CC 40436 1928 35 imagined imagine VBD 40436 1928 36 . . . 40436 1929 1 But but CC 40436 1929 2 the the DT 40436 1929 3 Universal Universal NNP 40436 1929 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1929 5 as as IN 40436 1929 6 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 1929 7 says)[47 says)[47 , 40436 1929 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1929 9 is be VBZ 40436 1929 10 one one CD 40436 1929 11 kind kind NN 40436 1929 12 of of IN 40436 1929 13 Whole whole NN 40436 1929 14 : : : 40436 1929 15 a a DT 40436 1929 16 Logical logical JJ 40436 1929 17 Whole Whole NNP 40436 1929 18 , , , 40436 1929 19 having have VBG 40436 1929 20 logical logical JJ 40436 1929 21 parts part NNS 40436 1929 22 . . . 40436 1930 1 In in IN 40436 1930 2 the the DT 40436 1930 3 minds mind NNS 40436 1930 4 of of IN 40436 1930 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1930 6 and and CC 40436 1930 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1930 8 , , , 40436 1930 9 the the DT 40436 1930 10 Logical logical JJ 40436 1930 11 Whole Whole NNP 40436 1930 12 separable separable NN 40436 1930 13 into into IN 40436 1930 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1930 15 logical logical JJ 40436 1930 16 parts part NNS 40436 1930 17 and and CC 40436 1930 18 into into IN 40436 1930 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1930 20 only only RB 40436 1930 21 , , , 40436 1930 22 were be VBD 40436 1930 23 preponderant preponderant JJ 40436 1930 24 . . . 40436 1931 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1931 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1931 3 47 47 CD 40436 1931 4 : : : 40436 1931 5 Aristot aristot NN 40436 1931 6 . . . 40436 1932 1 Physic Physic NNP 40436 1932 2 . . . 40436 1933 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1934 1 1 1 LS 40436 1934 2 . . . 40436 1935 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1935 2 Greek greek NN 40436 1935 3 : : : 40436 1935 4 to\ to\ NN 40436 1935 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 1935 6 o(/lon o(/lon NN 40436 1935 7 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 1935 8 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 1935 9 ai)/sthêsin ai)/sthêsin VBZ 40436 1935 10 gnôrimô gnôrimô NNP 40436 1935 11 / / SYM 40436 1935 12 teron teron NNP 40436 1935 13 , , , 40436 1935 14 _ _ NNP 40436 1935 15 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1935 16 de\ de\ NNP 40436 1935 17 katho katho NNP 40436 1935 18 / / SYM 40436 1935 19 lou lou NNP 40436 1935 20 o(/lon o(/lon NNP 40436 1935 21 ti ti NNP 40436 1935 22 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 1935 23 ; ; : 40436 1935 24 polla\ polla\ NNP 40436 1935 25 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 1935 26 perilamba perilamba NN 40436 1935 27 / / SYM 40436 1935 28 nei nei NNP 40436 1935 29 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 1935 30 me -PRON- PRP 40436 1935 31 / / SYM 40436 1935 32 rê rê NNP 40436 1935 33 to\ to\ NNP 40436 1935 34 katho katho NNP 40436 1935 35 / / SYM 40436 1935 36 lou lou NNP 40436 1935 37 _ _ NNP 40436 1935 38 . . . 40436 1935 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1936 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 1936 2 Simplikius Simplikius NNP 40436 1936 3 , , , 40436 1936 4 Schol Schol NNP 40436 1936 5 . . . 40436 1937 1 Brandis Brandis NNP 40436 1937 2 ad ad NN 40436 1937 3 loc loc NN 40436 1937 4 . . . 40436 1938 1 p. p. NN 40436 1938 2 324 324 CD 40436 1938 3 , , , 40436 1938 4 a. a. NN 40436 1939 1 10 10 CD 40436 1939 2 - - SYM 40436 1939 3 26 26 CD 40436 1939 4 . . . 40436 1939 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1940 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1940 2 Side side NN 40436 1940 3 - - HYPH 40436 1940 4 note note NN 40436 1940 5 : : : 40436 1940 6 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 1940 7 of of IN 40436 1940 8 Absolute Absolute NNP 40436 1940 9 and and CC 40436 1940 10 Relative Relative NNP 40436 1940 11 , , , 40436 1940 12 here here RB 40436 1940 13 brought bring VBD 40436 1940 14 into into IN 40436 1940 15 debate debate NN 40436 1940 16 by by IN 40436 1940 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1940 18 , , , 40436 1940 19 in in IN 40436 1940 20 regard regard NN 40436 1940 21 to to IN 40436 1940 22 the the DT 40436 1940 23 Idea Idea NNP 40436 1940 24 of of IN 40436 1940 25 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1940 26 . . . 40436 1940 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1941 1 One one CD 40436 1941 2 other other JJ 40436 1941 3 point point NN 40436 1941 4 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 1941 5 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 1941 6 notice notice NN 40436 1941 7 , , , 40436 1941 8 in in IN 40436 1941 9 the the DT 40436 1941 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 1941 11 under under IN 40436 1941 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1941 13 review review NN 40436 1941 14 . . . 40436 1942 1 The the DT 40436 1942 2 problem problem NN 40436 1942 3 started start VBD 40436 1942 4 is be VBZ 40436 1942 5 , , , 40436 1942 6 What what WP 40436 1942 7 is be VBZ 40436 1942 8 the the DT 40436 1942 9 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1942 10 -- -- : 40436 1942 11 the the DT 40436 1942 12 Self self NN 40436 1942 13 - - HYPH 40436 1942 14 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1942 15 , , , 40436 1942 16 or or CC 40436 1942 17 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1942 18 _ _ NNP 40436 1942 19 per per FW 40436 1942 20 se se FW 40436 1942 21 _ _ NNP 40436 1942 22 : : : 40436 1942 23 and and CC 40436 1942 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1942 25 is be VBZ 40436 1942 26 assumed assume VBN 40436 1942 27 that that IN 40436 1942 28 this this DT 40436 1942 29 must must MD 40436 1942 30 be be VB 40436 1942 31 Something,[48 Something,[48 VBN 40436 1942 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1942 33 that that IN 40436 1942 34 from from IN 40436 1942 35 the the DT 40436 1942 36 accession accession NN 40436 1942 37 of of IN 40436 1942 38 which which WDT 40436 1942 39 , , , 40436 1942 40 each each DT 40436 1942 41 particular particular JJ 40436 1942 42 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1942 43 thing thing NN 40436 1942 44 becomes become VBZ 40436 1942 45 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1942 46 . . . 40436 1943 1 But but CC 40436 1943 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 1943 3 presently presently RB 40436 1943 4 comes come VBZ 40436 1943 5 to to TO 40436 1943 6 make make VB 40436 1943 7 a a DT 40436 1943 8 distinction distinction NN 40436 1943 9 between between IN 40436 1943 10 that that DT 40436 1943 11 which which WDT 40436 1943 12 is be VBZ 40436 1943 13 really really RB 40436 1943 14 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1943 15 and and CC 40436 1943 16 that that IN 40436 1943 17 which which WDT 40436 1943 18 appears appear VBZ 40436 1943 19 to to TO 40436 1943 20 be be VB 40436 1943 21 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1943 22 . . . 40436 1944 1 Some some DT 40436 1944 2 things thing NNS 40436 1944 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1944 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1944 5 says say VBZ 40436 1944 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1944 7 appear appear VB 40436 1944 8 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1944 9 , , , 40436 1944 10 but but CC 40436 1944 11 are be VBP 40436 1944 12 not not RB 40436 1944 13 so so RB 40436 1944 14 in in IN 40436 1944 15 reality reality NN 40436 1944 16 : : : 40436 1944 17 some some DT 40436 1944 18 are be VBP 40436 1944 19 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1944 20 , , , 40436 1944 21 but but CC 40436 1944 22 do do VBP 40436 1944 23 not not RB 40436 1944 24 appear appear VB 40436 1944 25 so so RB 40436 1944 26 . . . 40436 1945 1 The the DT 40436 1945 2 problem problem NN 40436 1945 3 , , , 40436 1945 4 as as IN 40436 1945 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1945 6 states state VBZ 40436 1945 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1945 8 , , , 40436 1945 9 is be VBZ 40436 1945 10 , , , 40436 1945 11 to to TO 40436 1945 12 find find VB 40436 1945 13 , , , 40436 1945 14 not not RB 40436 1945 15 what what WP 40436 1945 16 that that DT 40436 1945 17 is be VBZ 40436 1945 18 which which WDT 40436 1945 19 makes make VBZ 40436 1945 20 objects object NNS 40436 1945 21 appear appear VB 40436 1945 22 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1945 23 , , , 40436 1945 24 but but CC 40436 1945 25 what what WP 40436 1945 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1945 27 is be VBZ 40436 1945 28 that that DT 40436 1945 29 makes make VBZ 40436 1945 30 them -PRON- PRP 40436 1945 31 really really RB 40436 1945 32 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1945 33 . . . 40436 1946 1 This this DT 40436 1946 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 1946 3 , , , 40436 1946 4 as as IN 40436 1946 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1946 6 find find VBP 40436 1946 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1946 8 in in IN 40436 1946 9 the the DT 40436 1946 10 language language NN 40436 1946 11 of of IN 40436 1946 12 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1946 13 , , , 40436 1946 14 is be VBZ 40436 1946 15 one one CD 40436 1946 16 of of IN 40436 1946 17 degree degree NN 40436 1946 18 only:[49 only:[49 NNP 40436 1946 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1946 20 that that IN 40436 1946 21 _ _ NNP 40436 1946 22 is be VBZ 40436 1946 23 _ _ NNP 40436 1946 24 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1946 25 which which WDT 40436 1946 26 appears appear VBZ 40436 1946 27 so so RB 40436 1946 28 to to IN 40436 1946 29 every every DT 40436 1946 30 one one CD 40436 1946 31 and and CC 40436 1946 32 at at IN 40436 1946 33 all all DT 40436 1946 34 times time NNS 40436 1946 35 . . . 40436 1947 1 But but CC 40436 1947 2 in in IN 40436 1947 3 the the DT 40436 1947 4 language language NN 40436 1947 5 of of IN 40436 1947 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1947 7 , , , 40436 1947 8 the the DT 40436 1947 9 distinction distinction NN 40436 1947 10 is be VBZ 40436 1947 11 radical radical JJ 40436 1947 12 : : : 40436 1947 13 to to TO 40436 1947 14 _ _ NNP 40436 1947 15 be be VB 40436 1947 16 _ _ NNP 40436 1947 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1947 18 is be VBZ 40436 1947 19 one one CD 40436 1947 20 thing thing NN 40436 1947 21 , , , 40436 1947 22 to to IN 40436 1947 23 _ _ NNP 40436 1947 24 appear appear VB 40436 1947 25 _ _ NNP 40436 1947 26 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1947 27 is be VBZ 40436 1947 28 another another DT 40436 1947 29 ; ; : 40436 1947 30 whatever whatever WDT 40436 1947 31 makes make VBZ 40436 1947 32 a a DT 40436 1947 33 thing thing NN 40436 1947 34 appear appear VB 40436 1947 35 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1947 36 without without IN 40436 1947 37 being be VBG 40436 1947 38 so so RB 40436 1947 39 in in IN 40436 1947 40 reality reality NN 40436 1947 41 , , , 40436 1947 42 is be VBZ 40436 1947 43 a a DT 40436 1947 44 mere mere JJ 40436 1947 45 engine engine NN 40436 1947 46 of of IN 40436 1947 47 deceit deceit NN 40436 1947 48 , , , 40436 1947 49 and and CC 40436 1947 50 not not RB 40436 1947 51 what what WDT 40436 1947 52 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1947 53 is be VBZ 40436 1947 54 enquiring enquire VBG 40436 1947 55 for for IN 40436 1947 56 . . . 40436 1948 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1948 2 50 50 CD 40436 1948 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1948 4 The the DT 40436 1948 5 Self self NN 40436 1948 6 - - HYPH 40436 1948 7 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1948 8 or or CC 40436 1948 9 real real JJ 40436 1948 10 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1948 11 is be VBZ 40436 1948 12 so so RB 40436 1948 13 , , , 40436 1948 14 whether whether IN 40436 1948 15 any any DT 40436 1948 16 one one NN 40436 1948 17 perceives perceive VBZ 40436 1948 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1948 19 to to TO 40436 1948 20 be be VB 40436 1948 21 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1948 22 or or CC 40436 1948 23 not not RB 40436 1948 24 : : : 40436 1948 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1948 26 is be VBZ 40436 1948 27 an an DT 40436 1948 28 Absolute Absolute NNP 40436 1948 29 , , , 40436 1948 30 which which WDT 40436 1948 31 exists exist VBZ 40436 1948 32 _ _ NNP 40436 1948 33 per per FW 40436 1948 34 se se FW 40436 1948 35 _ _ NNP 40436 1948 36 , , , 40436 1948 37 having have VBG 40436 1948 38 no no DT 40436 1948 39 relation relation NN 40436 1948 40 to to IN 40436 1948 41 any any DT 40436 1948 42 sentient sentient NN 40436 1948 43 or or CC 40436 1948 44 percipient percipient NN 40436 1948 45 subject subject NN 40436 1948 46 . . . 40436 1949 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1949 2 51 51 CD 40436 1949 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1949 4 At at IN 40436 1949 5 any any DT 40436 1949 6 rate rate NN 40436 1949 7 , , , 40436 1949 8 such such JJ 40436 1949 9 is be VBZ 40436 1949 10 the the DT 40436 1949 11 manner manner NN 40436 1949 12 in in IN 40436 1949 13 which which WDT 40436 1949 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1949 15 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 1949 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1949 17 , , , 40436 1949 18 when when WRB 40436 1949 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1949 20 starts start VBZ 40436 1949 21 here here RB 40436 1949 22 as as IN 40436 1949 23 a a DT 40436 1949 24 problem problem NN 40436 1949 25 to to TO 40436 1949 26 enquire enquire VB 40436 1949 27 , , , 40436 1949 28 What what WP 40436 1949 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1949 30 is be VBZ 40436 1949 31 . . . 40436 1950 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1950 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1950 3 48 48 CD 40436 1950 4 : : : 40436 1950 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1950 6 , , , 40436 1950 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1950 8 . . . 40436 1951 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1951 2 . . NNP 40436 1951 3 286 286 CD 40436 1951 4 K. K. NNP 40436 1951 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1951 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 1951 7 : : : 40436 1951 8 au)to\ au)to\ UH 40436 1951 9 to\ to\ NN 40436 1951 10 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 1951 11 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 1951 12 , , , 40436 1951 13 ti ti NNP 40436 1951 14 e)/stin e)/stin NN 40436 1951 15 . . . 40436 1951 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1952 1 Also also RB 40436 1952 2 287 287 CD 40436 1952 3 D d NN 40436 1952 4 , , , 40436 1952 5 289 289 CD 40436 1952 6 D. D. NNP 40436 1952 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1952 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1952 9 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1952 10 49 49 CD 40436 1952 11 : : : 40436 1952 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1952 13 , , , 40436 1952 14 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1952 15 . . . 40436 1953 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1953 2 . . NNP 40436 1953 3 291 291 CD 40436 1953 4 D d NN 40436 1953 5 , , , 40436 1953 6 292 292 CD 40436 1953 7 E. E. NNP 40436 1953 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1953 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1953 10 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1953 11 50 50 CD 40436 1953 12 : : : 40436 1953 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1953 14 , , , 40436 1953 15 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1953 16 . . . 40436 1954 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1954 2 . . NNP 40436 1954 3 294 294 CD 40436 1954 4 A a NN 40436 1954 5 - - HYPH 40436 1954 6 B b NN 40436 1954 7 , , , 40436 1954 8 299 299 CD 40436 1954 9 A. a. NN 40436 1954 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1955 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1955 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1955 3 51 51 CD 40436 1955 4 : : : 40436 1955 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 1955 6 Hutcheson Hutcheson NNP 40436 1955 7 , , , 40436 1955 8 in in IN 40436 1955 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1955 10 inquiry inquiry NN 40436 1955 11 into into IN 40436 1955 12 the the DT 40436 1955 13 Original Original NNP 40436 1955 14 of of IN 40436 1955 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1955 16 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 1955 17 of of IN 40436 1955 18 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1955 19 and and CC 40436 1955 20 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 1955 21 , , , 40436 1955 22 observes observe NNS 40436 1955 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1955 24 sect sect JJ 40436 1955 25 . . . 40436 1956 1 i. i. NNP 40436 1956 2 and and CC 40436 1956 3 ii ii NNP 40436 1956 4 . . . 40436 1957 1 p. p. NN 40436 1957 2 14 14 CD 40436 1957 3 - - HYPH 40436 1957 4 16):-- 16):-- CD 40436 1957 5 " " `` 40436 1957 6 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1957 7 is be VBZ 40436 1957 8 either either CC 40436 1957 9 original original JJ 40436 1957 10 or or CC 40436 1957 11 comparative comparative JJ 40436 1957 12 , , , 40436 1957 13 or or CC 40436 1957 14 , , , 40436 1957 15 if if IN 40436 1957 16 any any DT 40436 1957 17 like like IN 40436 1957 18 the the DT 40436 1957 19 terms term NNS 40436 1957 20 better well RBR 40436 1957 21 , , , 40436 1957 22 absolute absolute JJ 40436 1957 23 or or CC 40436 1957 24 relative relative JJ 40436 1957 25 ; ; : 40436 1957 26 only only RB 40436 1957 27 let let VB 40436 1957 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1957 29 be be VB 40436 1957 30 observed observe VBN 40436 1957 31 , , , 40436 1957 32 that that IN 40436 1957 33 by by IN 40436 1957 34 _ _ NNP 40436 1957 35 absolute absolute JJ 40436 1957 36 _ _ NNP 40436 1957 37 or or CC 40436 1957 38 _ _ NNP 40436 1957 39 original original JJ 40436 1957 40 _ _ NNP 40436 1957 41 , , , 40436 1957 42 is be VBZ 40436 1957 43 not not RB 40436 1957 44 understood understand VBN 40436 1957 45 any any DT 40436 1957 46 quality quality NN 40436 1957 47 supposed suppose VBN 40436 1957 48 to to TO 40436 1957 49 be be VB 40436 1957 50 in in IN 40436 1957 51 the the DT 40436 1957 52 object object NN 40436 1957 53 , , , 40436 1957 54 which which WDT 40436 1957 55 should should MD 40436 1957 56 of of IN 40436 1957 57 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 1957 58 be be VB 40436 1957 59 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1957 60 , , , 40436 1957 61 without without IN 40436 1957 62 relation relation NN 40436 1957 63 to to IN 40436 1957 64 any any DT 40436 1957 65 mind mind NN 40436 1957 66 which which WDT 40436 1957 67 perceives perceive VBZ 40436 1957 68 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1957 69 . . . 40436 1958 1 For for IN 40436 1958 2 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1958 3 , , , 40436 1958 4 like like IN 40436 1958 5 other other JJ 40436 1958 6 names name NNS 40436 1958 7 of of IN 40436 1958 8 sensible sensible JJ 40436 1958 9 ideas idea NNS 40436 1958 10 , , , 40436 1958 11 properly properly RB 40436 1958 12 denotes denote VBZ 40436 1958 13 the the DT 40436 1958 14 perception perception NN 40436 1958 15 of of IN 40436 1958 16 some some DT 40436 1958 17 mind mind NN 40436 1958 18 . . . 40436 1959 1 . . . 40436 1960 1 . . . 40436 1961 1 . . . 40436 1962 1 . . . 40436 1963 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1963 2 inquiry inquiry NN 40436 1963 3 is be VBZ 40436 1963 4 only only RB 40436 1963 5 about about IN 40436 1963 6 the the DT 40436 1963 7 qualities quality NNS 40436 1963 8 which which WDT 40436 1963 9 are be VBP 40436 1963 10 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1963 11 to to IN 40436 1963 12 men man NNS 40436 1963 13 , , , 40436 1963 14 or or CC 40436 1963 15 about about IN 40436 1963 16 the the DT 40436 1963 17 foundation foundation NN 40436 1963 18 of of IN 40436 1963 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1963 20 sense sense NN 40436 1963 21 of of IN 40436 1963 22 beauty beauty NN 40436 1963 23 , , , 40436 1963 24 for for IN 40436 1963 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1963 26 as as IN 40436 1963 27 above above RB 40436 1963 28 hinted hint VBN 40436 1963 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1963 30 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1963 31 has have VBZ 40436 1963 32 always always RB 40436 1963 33 relation relation NN 40436 1963 34 to to IN 40436 1963 35 the the DT 40436 1963 36 sense sense NN 40436 1963 37 of of IN 40436 1963 38 some some DT 40436 1963 39 mind mind NN 40436 1963 40 ; ; : 40436 1963 41 and and CC 40436 1963 42 when when WRB 40436 1963 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1963 44 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 1963 45 show show VBP 40436 1963 46 how how WRB 40436 1963 47 generally generally RB 40436 1963 48 the the DT 40436 1963 49 objects object NNS 40436 1963 50 that that WDT 40436 1963 51 occur occur VBP 40436 1963 52 to to IN 40436 1963 53 us -PRON- PRP 40436 1963 54 are be VBP 40436 1963 55 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 1963 56 , , , 40436 1963 57 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1963 58 mean mean VBP 40436 1963 59 that that IN 40436 1963 60 such such JJ 40436 1963 61 objects object NNS 40436 1963 62 are be VBP 40436 1963 63 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 1963 64 to to IN 40436 1963 65 the the DT 40436 1963 66 sense sense NN 40436 1963 67 of of IN 40436 1963 68 men man NNS 40436 1963 69 , , , 40436 1963 70 & & CC 40436 1963 71 c. c. NNP 40436 1963 72 " " `` 40436 1963 73 The the DT 40436 1963 74 same same JJ 40436 1963 75 is be VBZ 40436 1963 76 repeated repeat VBN 40436 1963 77 , , , 40436 1963 78 sect sect JJ 40436 1963 79 . . . 40436 1964 1 iv iv XX 40436 1964 2 . . . 40436 1965 1 p. p. NN 40436 1965 2 40 40 CD 40436 1965 3 ; ; : 40436 1965 4 sect sect JJ 40436 1965 5 . . . 40436 1966 1 vi vi NNP 40436 1966 2 . . . 40436 1967 1 p. p. NN 40436 1968 1 72 72 CD 40436 1968 2 . . . 40436 1968 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1969 1 Herein Herein NNP 40436 1969 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1969 3 note note VBP 40436 1969 4 one one CD 40436 1969 5 of of IN 40436 1969 6 the the DT 40436 1969 7 material material JJ 40436 1969 8 points point NNS 40436 1969 9 of of IN 40436 1969 10 disagreement disagreement NN 40436 1969 11 between between IN 40436 1969 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1969 13 and and CC 40436 1969 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1969 15 master master NN 40436 1969 16 : : : 40436 1969 17 for for IN 40436 1969 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1969 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1969 20 in in IN 40436 1969 21 the the DT 40436 1969 22 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 1969 23 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 1969 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1969 25 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 1969 26 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 1969 27 that that IN 40436 1969 28 Beauty Beauty NNP 40436 1969 29 is be VBZ 40436 1969 30 altogether altogether RB 40436 1969 31 relative relative JJ 40436 1969 32 to to IN 40436 1969 33 human human JJ 40436 1969 34 wants want NNS 40436 1969 35 and and CC 40436 1969 36 appreciations appreciation NNS 40436 1969 37 . . . 40436 1970 1 The the DT 40436 1970 2 Real Real NNP 40436 1970 3 and and CC 40436 1970 4 Absolute Absolute NNP 40436 1970 5 , , , 40436 1970 6 on on IN 40436 1970 7 the the DT 40436 1970 8 one one CD 40436 1970 9 hand hand NN 40436 1970 10 , , , 40436 1970 11 wherein wherein WRB 40436 1970 12 alone alone RB 40436 1970 13 resides reside VBZ 40436 1970 14 truth truth NN 40436 1970 15 and and CC 40436 1970 16 beauty beauty NN 40436 1970 17 -- -- : 40436 1970 18 as as IN 40436 1970 19 against against IN 40436 1970 20 the the DT 40436 1970 21 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 40436 1970 22 and and CC 40436 1970 23 relative relative JJ 40436 1970 24 , , , 40436 1970 25 on on IN 40436 1970 26 the the DT 40436 1970 27 other other JJ 40436 1970 28 hand hand NN 40436 1970 29 , , , 40436 1970 30 the the DT 40436 1970 31 world world NN 40436 1970 32 of of IN 40436 1970 33 illusion illusion NN 40436 1970 34 and and CC 40436 1970 35 meanness meanness JJ 40436 1970 36 -- -- : 40436 1970 37 this this DT 40436 1970 38 is be VBZ 40436 1970 39 an an DT 40436 1970 40 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 1970 41 which which WDT 40436 1970 42 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1970 43 shall shall MD 40436 1970 44 find find VB 40436 1970 45 often often RB 40436 1970 46 reproduced reproduce VBN 40436 1970 47 in in IN 40436 1970 48 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1970 49 . . . 40436 1971 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1971 2 shall shall MD 40436 1971 3 take take VB 40436 1971 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 1971 5 up up RP 40436 1971 6 more more RBR 40436 1971 7 at at IN 40436 1971 8 large large JJ 40436 1971 9 , , , 40436 1971 10 when when WRB 40436 1971 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1971 12 come come VBP 40436 1971 13 to to TO 40436 1971 14 discuss discuss VB 40436 1971 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1971 16 argument argument NN 40436 1971 17 against against IN 40436 1971 18 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 1971 19 in in IN 40436 1971 20 the the DT 40436 1971 21 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 1971 22 . . . 40436 1972 1 * * NFP 40436 1972 2 * * NFP 40436 1972 3 * * NFP 40436 1972 4 * * NFP 40436 1972 5 * * NFP 40436 1972 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1972 7 Side side NN 40436 1972 8 - - HYPH 40436 1972 9 note note NN 40436 1972 10 : : : 40436 1972 11 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1972 12 Minor minor JJ 40436 1972 13 -- -- : 40436 1972 14 characters character NNS 40436 1972 15 and and CC 40436 1972 16 situation situation NN 40436 1972 17 supposed suppose VBN 40436 1972 18 . . . 40436 1972 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1973 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 1973 2 now now RB 40436 1973 3 come come VBP 40436 1973 4 to to IN 40436 1973 5 the the DT 40436 1973 6 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 1973 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1973 8 : : : 40436 1973 9 in in IN 40436 1973 10 which which WDT 40436 1973 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1973 12 as as IN 40436 1973 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 1973 14 have have VBP 40436 1973 15 already already RB 40436 1973 16 seen see VBN 40436 1973 17 in in IN 40436 1973 18 the the DT 40436 1973 19 Greater Greater NNP 40436 1973 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1973 21 that that IN 40436 1973 22 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 1973 23 is be VBZ 40436 1973 24 described describe VBN 40436 1973 25 by by IN 40436 1973 26 epithets epithet NNS 40436 1973 27 , , , 40436 1973 28 affirming affirm VBG 40436 1973 29 varied varied JJ 40436 1973 30 and and CC 40436 1973 31 extensive extensive JJ 40436 1973 32 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 1973 33 , , , 40436 1973 34 as as IN 40436 1973 35 master master NN 40436 1973 36 of of IN 40436 1973 37 arithmetic arithmetic NNP 40436 1973 38 , , , 40436 1973 39 geometry geometry NN 40436 1973 40 , , , 40436 1973 41 astronomy astronomy NN 40436 1973 42 , , , 40436 1973 43 poetry poetry NN 40436 1973 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1973 45 especially especially RB 40436 1973 46 that that DT 40436 1973 47 of of IN 40436 1973 48 Homer Homer NNP 40436 1973 49 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1973 50 , , , 40436 1973 51 legendary legendary JJ 40436 1973 52 lore lore NN 40436 1973 53 , , , 40436 1973 54 music music NN 40436 1973 55 , , , 40436 1973 56 metrical metrical JJ 40436 1973 57 and and CC 40436 1973 58 rhythmical rhythmical JJ 40436 1973 59 diversities diversity NNS 40436 1973 60 , , , 40436 1973 61 & & CC 40436 1973 62 c. c. NNP 40436 1973 63 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1973 64 memory memory NN 40436 1973 65 was be VBD 40436 1973 66 prodigious prodigious JJ 40436 1973 67 , , , 40436 1973 68 and and CC 40436 1973 69 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1973 70 had have VBD 40436 1973 71 even even RB 40436 1973 72 invented invent VBN 40436 1973 73 for for IN 40436 1973 74 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1973 75 a a DT 40436 1973 76 technical technical JJ 40436 1973 77 scheme scheme NN 40436 1973 78 for for IN 40436 1973 79 assisting assist VBG 40436 1973 80 memory memory NN 40436 1973 81 . . . 40436 1974 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1974 2 had have VBD 40436 1974 3 composed compose VBN 40436 1974 4 poems poem NNS 40436 1974 5 , , , 40436 1974 6 epic epic NN 40436 1974 7 , , , 40436 1974 8 lyric lyric NN 40436 1974 9 , , , 40436 1974 10 and and CC 40436 1974 11 tragic tragic JJ 40436 1974 12 , , , 40436 1974 13 as as RB 40436 1974 14 well well RB 40436 1974 15 as as IN 40436 1974 16 many many JJ 40436 1974 17 works work NNS 40436 1974 18 in in IN 40436 1974 19 prose prose NN 40436 1974 20 : : : 40436 1974 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1974 22 was be VBD 40436 1974 23 , , , 40436 1974 24 besides besides RB 40436 1974 25 , , , 40436 1974 26 a a DT 40436 1974 27 splendid splendid JJ 40436 1974 28 lecturer lecturer NN 40436 1974 29 on on IN 40436 1974 30 ethical ethical JJ 40436 1974 31 and and CC 40436 1974 32 political political JJ 40436 1974 33 subjects subject NNS 40436 1974 34 , , , 40436 1974 35 and and CC 40436 1974 36 professed profess VBD 40436 1974 37 to to TO 40436 1974 38 answer answer VB 40436 1974 39 any any DT 40436 1974 40 question question NN 40436 1974 41 which which WDT 40436 1974 42 might may MD 40436 1974 43 be be VB 40436 1974 44 asked ask VBN 40436 1974 45 . . . 40436 1975 1 Furthermore furthermore RB 40436 1975 2 , , , 40436 1975 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1975 4 was be VBD 40436 1975 5 skilful skilful JJ 40436 1975 6 in in IN 40436 1975 7 many many JJ 40436 1975 8 kinds kind NNS 40436 1975 9 of of IN 40436 1975 10 manual manual JJ 40436 1975 11 dexterity dexterity NN 40436 1975 12 : : : 40436 1975 13 having have VBG 40436 1975 14 woven weave VBN 40436 1975 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1975 16 own own JJ 40436 1975 17 garments garment NNS 40436 1975 18 , , , 40436 1975 19 plaited plait VBD 40436 1975 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1975 21 own own JJ 40436 1975 22 girdle girdle NN 40436 1975 23 , , , 40436 1975 24 made make VBD 40436 1975 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1975 26 own own JJ 40436 1975 27 shoes shoe NNS 40436 1975 28 , , , 40436 1975 29 engraved engrave VBD 40436 1975 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1975 31 own own JJ 40436 1975 32 seal seal NN 40436 1975 33 - - HYPH 40436 1975 34 ring ring NN 40436 1975 35 , , , 40436 1975 36 and and CC 40436 1975 37 fabricated fabricate VBD 40436 1975 38 for for IN 40436 1975 39 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1975 40 a a DT 40436 1975 41 curry curry NN 40436 1975 42 - - HYPH 40436 1975 43 comb comb NN 40436 1975 44 and and CC 40436 1975 45 oil oil NN 40436 1975 46 - - HYPH 40436 1975 47 flask flask NN 40436 1975 48 . . . 40436 1976 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1976 2 52 52 CD 40436 1976 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1976 4 Lastly lastly RB 40436 1976 5 , , , 40436 1976 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1976 7 is be VBZ 40436 1976 8 described describe VBN 40436 1976 9 as as IN 40436 1976 10 wearing wear VBG 40436 1976 11 fine fine JJ 40436 1976 12 and and CC 40436 1976 13 showy showy JJ 40436 1976 14 apparel apparel NN 40436 1976 15 . . . 40436 1977 1 What what WP 40436 1977 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1977 3 is be VBZ 40436 1977 4 made make VBN 40436 1977 5 to to TO 40436 1977 6 say say VB 40436 1977 7 is be VBZ 40436 1977 8 rather rather RB 40436 1977 9 in in IN 40436 1977 10 harmony harmony NN 40436 1977 11 with with IN 40436 1977 12 this this DT 40436 1977 13 last last JJ 40436 1977 14 point point NN 40436 1977 15 of of IN 40436 1977 16 character character NN 40436 1977 17 , , , 40436 1977 18 than than IN 40436 1977 19 with with IN 40436 1977 20 the the DT 40436 1977 21 preceding precede VBG 40436 1977 22 . . . 40436 1978 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 1978 2 talks talk VBZ 40436 1978 3 with with IN 40436 1978 4 silliness silliness NN 40436 1978 5 and and CC 40436 1978 6 presumption presumption NN 40436 1978 7 , , , 40436 1978 8 so so IN 40436 1978 9 as as IN 40436 1978 10 to to TO 40436 1978 11 invite invite VB 40436 1978 12 and and CC 40436 1978 13 excuse excuse VB 40436 1978 14 the the DT 40436 1978 15 derisory derisory JJ 40436 1978 16 sting sting NN 40436 1978 17 of of IN 40436 1978 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 1978 19 , , , 40436 1978 20 There there EX 40436 1978 21 is be VBZ 40436 1978 22 a a DT 40436 1978 23 third third JJ 40436 1978 24 interlocutor interlocutor NN 40436 1978 25 , , , 40436 1978 26 Eudikus Eudikus NNP 40436 1978 27 : : : 40436 1978 28 but but CC 40436 1978 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1978 30 says say VBZ 40436 1978 31 very very RB 40436 1978 32 little little JJ 40436 1978 33 , , , 40436 1978 34 and and CC 40436 1978 35 other other JJ 40436 1978 36 auditors auditor NNS 40436 1978 37 are be VBP 40436 1978 38 alluded allude VBN 40436 1978 39 to to IN 40436 1978 40 generally generally RB 40436 1978 41 , , , 40436 1978 42 who who WP 40436 1978 43 say say VBP 40436 1978 44 nothing nothing NN 40436 1978 45 . . . 40436 1979 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1979 2 53 53 CD 40436 1979 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1979 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1979 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1979 6 52 52 CD 40436 1979 7 : : : 40436 1979 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1979 9 , , , 40436 1979 10 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1979 11 . . . 40436 1980 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 1980 2 , , , 40436 1980 3 368 368 CD 40436 1980 4 . . . 40436 1980 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 1981 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 1981 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 1981 3 53 53 CD 40436 1981 4 : : : 40436 1981 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1981 6 , , , 40436 1981 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1981 8 . . . 40436 1982 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 1982 2 , , , 40436 1982 3 369 369 CD 40436 1982 4 D d NN 40436 1982 5 , , , 40436 1982 6 373 373 CD 40436 1982 7 B. B. NNP 40436 1982 8 Ast Ast NNP 40436 1982 9 rejects reject VBZ 40436 1982 10 both both CC 40436 1982 11 the the DT 40436 1982 12 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1982 13 called call VBN 40436 1982 14 by by IN 40436 1982 15 the the DT 40436 1982 16 name name NN 40436 1982 17 of of IN 40436 1982 18 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1982 19 , , , 40436 1982 20 as as IN 40436 1982 21 not not RB 40436 1982 22 composed compose VBN 40436 1982 23 by by IN 40436 1982 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1982 25 . . . 40436 1983 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 1983 2 doubts doubt VBZ 40436 1983 3 about about IN 40436 1983 4 both both DT 40436 1983 5 , , , 40436 1983 6 and and CC 40436 1983 7 rejects reject VBZ 40436 1983 8 the the DT 40436 1983 9 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1983 10 Minor Minor NNP 40436 1983 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1983 12 which which WDT 40436 1983 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 1983 14 considers consider VBZ 40436 1983 15 as as IN 40436 1983 16 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 1983 17 worked work VBN 40436 1983 18 up up RP 40436 1983 19 by by IN 40436 1983 20 a a DT 40436 1983 21 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 1983 22 scholar scholar NN 40436 1983 23 from from IN 40436 1983 24 a a DT 40436 1983 25 genuine genuine JJ 40436 1983 26 sketch sketch NN 40436 1983 27 by by IN 40436 1983 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1983 29 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 1983 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1983 31 but but CC 40436 1983 32 will will MD 40436 1983 33 not not RB 40436 1983 34 pass pass VB 40436 1983 35 the the DT 40436 1983 36 same same JJ 40436 1983 37 sentence sentence NN 40436 1983 38 upon upon IN 40436 1983 39 the the DT 40436 1983 40 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 1983 41 Major Major NNP 40436 1983 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1983 43 Schleierm Schleierm NNP 40436 1983 44 . . . 40436 1984 1 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 1984 2 . . . 40436 1985 1 vol vol NNP 40436 1985 2 . . . 40436 1986 1 ii ii LS 40436 1986 2 . . . 40436 1987 1 pp pp NNP 40436 1987 2 . . . 40436 1988 1 293 293 CD 40436 1988 2 - - SYM 40436 1988 3 296 296 CD 40436 1988 4 ; ; : 40436 1988 5 vol vol NNP 40436 1988 6 . . . 40436 1989 1 v. v. CC 40436 1989 2 399 399 CD 40436 1989 3 - - SYM 40436 1989 4 403 403 CD 40436 1989 5 . . . 40436 1990 1 Ast Ast NNP 40436 1990 2 , , , 40436 1990 3 Platon Platon NNP 40436 1990 4 's 's POS 40436 1990 5 Leben Leben NNP 40436 1990 6 und und NN 40436 1990 7 Schriften Schriften NNP 40436 1990 8 , , , 40436 1990 9 pp pp NNP 40436 1990 10 . . . 40436 1991 1 457 457 CD 40436 1991 2 - - SYM 40436 1991 3 464 464 CD 40436 1991 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1991 5 . . . 40436 1992 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 1992 2 defends defend VBZ 40436 1992 3 both both CC 40436 1992 4 the the DT 40436 1992 5 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 1992 6 as as IN 40436 1992 7 genuine genuine JJ 40436 1992 8 works work NNS 40436 1992 9 of of IN 40436 1992 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 1992 11 , , , 40436 1992 12 and and CC 40436 1992 13 in in IN 40436 1992 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 1992 15 judgment judgment NN 40436 1992 16 with with IN 40436 1992 17 good good JJ 40436 1992 18 reason reason NN 40436 1992 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 1992 20 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 1992 21 . . . 40436 1993 1 ad ad NN 40436 1993 2 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1993 3 . . . 40436 1994 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 1994 2 . . NNP 40436 1994 3 vol vol NNP 40436 1994 4 . . . 40436 1995 1 iv iv XX 40436 1995 2 . . . 40436 1996 1 pp pp NNP 40436 1996 2 . . . 40436 1997 1 145 145 CD 40436 1997 2 - - SYM 40436 1997 3 150 150 CD 40436 1997 4 ; ; : 40436 1997 5 ad ad NN 40436 1997 6 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 1997 7 . . . 40436 1998 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 1998 2 , , , 40436 1998 3 pp pp NN 40436 1998 4 . . . 40436 1999 1 227 227 CD 40436 1999 2 - - SYM 40436 1999 3 235 235 CD 40436 1999 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 1999 5 . . . 40436 2000 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 2000 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2000 3 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 2000 4 . . . 40436 2001 1 p. p. NN 40436 2001 2 99 99 CD 40436 2001 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2001 4 and and CC 40436 2001 5 Socher Socher NNP 40436 2001 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2001 7 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 2001 8 Platon Platon NNP 40436 2001 9 , , , 40436 2001 10 p. p. NN 40436 2001 11 144 144 CD 40436 2001 12 seq seq NN 40436 2001 13 . . . 40436 2001 14 , , , 40436 2001 15 215 215 CD 40436 2001 16 seq seq NN 40436 2001 17 . . . 40436 2001 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2002 1 maintain maintain VB 40436 2002 2 the the DT 40436 2002 3 same same JJ 40436 2002 4 opinion opinion NN 40436 2002 5 on on IN 40436 2002 6 these these DT 40436 2002 7 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2002 8 as as IN 40436 2002 9 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 2002 10 . . . 40436 2003 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2003 2 is be VBZ 40436 2003 3 to to TO 40436 2003 4 be be VB 40436 2003 5 remarked remark VBN 40436 2003 6 that that IN 40436 2003 7 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2003 8 states state VBZ 40436 2003 9 the the DT 40436 2003 10 reasons reason NNS 40436 2003 11 both both DT 40436 2003 12 for for IN 40436 2003 13 and and CC 40436 2003 14 against against IN 40436 2003 15 the the DT 40436 2003 16 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 2003 17 of of IN 40436 2003 18 the the DT 40436 2003 19 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2003 20 ; ; : 40436 2003 21 and and CC 40436 2003 22 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2003 23 think think VBP 40436 2003 24 that that IN 40436 2003 25 even even RB 40436 2003 26 in in IN 40436 2003 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2003 28 own own JJ 40436 2003 29 statement statement NN 40436 2003 30 the the DT 40436 2003 31 reasons reason NNS 40436 2003 32 _ _ NNP 40436 2003 33 for for IN 40436 2003 34 _ _ NNP 40436 2003 35 preponderate preponderate NN 40436 2003 36 . . . 40436 2004 1 The the DT 40436 2004 2 reasons reason NNS 40436 2004 3 which which WDT 40436 2004 4 both both CC 40436 2004 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2004 6 and and CC 40436 2004 7 Ast Ast NNP 40436 2004 8 produce produce VBP 40436 2004 9 as as IN 40436 2004 10 proving prove VBG 40436 2004 11 the the DT 40436 2004 12 spuriousness spuriousness NN 40436 2004 13 , , , 40436 2004 14 are be VBP 40436 2004 15 in in IN 40436 2004 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2004 17 view view NN 40436 2004 18 quite quite RB 40436 2004 19 insufficient insufficient JJ 40436 2004 20 to to TO 40436 2004 21 sustain sustain VB 40436 2004 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2004 23 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2004 24 . . . 40436 2005 1 There there EX 40436 2005 2 is be VBZ 40436 2005 3 bad bad JJ 40436 2005 4 taste taste NN 40436 2005 5 , , , 40436 2005 6 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 2005 7 , , , 40436 2005 8 an an DT 40436 2005 9 overdose overdose NN 40436 2005 10 of of IN 40436 2005 11 banter banter NN 40436 2005 12 and and CC 40436 2005 13 derision derision NN 40436 2005 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2005 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2005 16 say say VBP 40436 2005 17 very very RB 40436 2005 18 truly truly RB 40436 2005 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2005 20 , , , 40436 2005 21 in in IN 40436 2005 22 the the DT 40436 2005 23 part part NN 40436 2005 24 assigned assign VBN 40436 2005 25 to to IN 40436 2005 26 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2005 27 : : : 40436 2005 28 there there EX 40436 2005 29 are be VBP 40436 2005 30 also also RB 40436 2005 31 differences difference NNS 40436 2005 32 of of IN 40436 2005 33 view view NN 40436 2005 34 , , , 40436 2005 35 as as IN 40436 2005 36 compared compare VBN 40436 2005 37 with with IN 40436 2005 38 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2005 39 in in IN 40436 2005 40 other other JJ 40436 2005 41 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2005 42 ; ; , 40436 2005 43 various various JJ 40436 2005 44 other other JJ 40436 2005 45 affirmations affirmation NNS 40436 2005 46 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2005 47 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2005 48 tell tell VBP 40436 2005 49 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2005 50 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2005 51 are be VBP 40436 2005 52 _ _ NNP 40436 2005 53 not not RB 40436 2005 54 _ _ NNP 40436 2005 55 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2005 56 . . . 40436 2006 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2006 2 admit admit VBP 40436 2006 3 much much JJ 40436 2006 4 of of IN 40436 2006 5 this this DT 40436 2006 6 , , , 40436 2006 7 but but CC 40436 2006 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2006 9 still still RB 40436 2006 10 do do VBP 40436 2006 11 not not RB 40436 2006 12 accept accept VB 40436 2006 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2006 14 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2006 15 . . . 40436 2007 1 These these DT 40436 2007 2 critics critic NNS 40436 2007 3 can can MD 40436 2007 4 not not RB 40436 2007 5 bear bear VB 40436 2007 6 to to TO 40436 2007 7 admit admit VB 40436 2007 8 any any DT 40436 2007 9 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2007 10 work work NN 40436 2007 11 as as RB 40436 2007 12 genuine genuine JJ 40436 2007 13 unless unless IN 40436 2007 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2007 15 affords afford VBZ 40436 2007 16 to to IN 40436 2007 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2007 18 ground ground VB 40436 2007 19 for for IN 40436 2007 20 superlative superlative JJ 40436 2007 21 admiration admiration NN 40436 2007 22 and and CC 40436 2007 23 glorification glorification NN 40436 2007 24 of of IN 40436 2007 25 the the DT 40436 2007 26 author author NN 40436 2007 27 . . . 40436 2008 1 This this DT 40436 2008 2 postulate postulate NN 40436 2008 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2008 4 altogether altogether RB 40436 2008 5 contest contest VBP 40436 2008 6 ; ; : 40436 2008 7 and and CC 40436 2008 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2008 9 think think VBP 40436 2008 10 that that IN 40436 2008 11 differences difference NNS 40436 2008 12 of of IN 40436 2008 13 view view NN 40436 2008 14 , , , 40436 2008 15 as as IN 40436 2008 16 between between IN 40436 2008 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2008 18 in in IN 40436 2008 19 one one CD 40436 2008 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2008 21 and and CC 40436 2008 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2008 23 in in IN 40436 2008 24 another another DT 40436 2008 25 , , , 40436 2008 26 are be VBP 40436 2008 27 both both DT 40436 2008 28 naturally naturally RB 40436 2008 29 to to TO 40436 2008 30 be be VB 40436 2008 31 expected expect VBN 40436 2008 32 and and CC 40436 2008 33 actually actually RB 40436 2008 34 manifested manifest VBN 40436 2008 35 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2008 36 witness witness NN 40436 2008 37 the the DT 40436 2008 38 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2008 39 and and CC 40436 2008 40 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 2008 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2008 42 . . . 40436 2009 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 2009 2 Ast Ast NNP 40436 2009 3 designates designate NNS 40436 2009 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2009 5 p. p. NN 40436 2009 6 404 404 CD 40436 2009 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2009 8 a a DT 40436 2009 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 2009 10 as as IN 40436 2009 11 " " `` 40436 2009 12 durchaus durchaus NNP 40436 2009 13 unsokratisch unsokratisch NNP 40436 2009 14 " " '' 40436 2009 15 which which WDT 40436 2009 16 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 2009 17 justly justly RB 40436 2009 18 remarks remark VBZ 40436 2009 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2009 20 p. p. NN 40436 2009 21 233 233 CD 40436 2009 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2009 23 to to TO 40436 2009 24 have have VB 40436 2009 25 been be VBN 40436 2009 26 actually actually RB 40436 2009 27 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 2009 28 by by IN 40436 2009 29 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2009 30 in in IN 40436 2009 31 the the DT 40436 2009 32 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 2009 33 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 2009 34 . . . 40436 2010 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 2010 2 thinks think VBZ 40436 2010 3 that that IN 40436 2010 4 both both CC 40436 2010 5 the the DT 40436 2010 6 two two CD 40436 2010 7 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2010 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2010 9 Socher socher UH 40436 2010 10 , , , 40436 2010 11 that that IN 40436 2010 12 the the DT 40436 2010 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2010 14 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2010 15 only only RB 40436 2010 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2010 17 were be VBD 40436 2010 18 composed compose VBN 40436 2010 19 by by IN 40436 2010 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2010 21 among among IN 40436 2010 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2010 23 earlier early JJR 40436 2010 24 works work NNS 40436 2010 25 , , , 40436 2010 26 and and CC 40436 2010 27 this this DT 40436 2010 28 may may MD 40436 2010 29 probably probably RB 40436 2010 30 be be VB 40436 2010 31 true true JJ 40436 2010 32 . . . 40436 2011 1 The the DT 40436 2011 2 citation citation NN 40436 2011 3 and and CC 40436 2011 4 refutation refutation NN 40436 2011 5 of of IN 40436 2011 6 the the DT 40436 2011 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2011 8 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2011 9 by by IN 40436 2011 10 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2011 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2011 12 Metaphys Metaphys NNP 40436 2011 13 . . . 40436 2012 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2012 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2012 3 : : : 40436 2012 4 D d NN 40436 2012 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2012 6 . . . 40436 2013 1 1025 1025 CD 40436 2013 2 , , , 40436 2013 3 a. a. NN 40436 2014 1 6 6 LS 40436 2014 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2014 3 counts count VBZ 40436 2014 4 with with IN 40436 2014 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2014 6 as as IN 40436 2014 7 a a DT 40436 2014 8 strong strong JJ 40436 2014 9 corroborative corroborative JJ 40436 2014 10 proof proof NN 40436 2014 11 that that IN 40436 2014 12 the the DT 40436 2014 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2014 14 is be VBZ 40436 2014 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2014 16 's 's POS 40436 2014 17 work work NN 40436 2014 18 . . . 40436 2015 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2015 2 and and CC 40436 2015 3 Ast Ast NNP 40436 2015 4 set set VBD 40436 2015 5 this this DT 40436 2015 6 evidence evidence NN 40436 2015 7 aside aside RB 40436 2015 8 because because IN 40436 2015 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2015 10 does do VBZ 40436 2015 11 not not RB 40436 2015 12 name name VB 40436 2015 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2015 14 as as IN 40436 2015 15 the the DT 40436 2015 16 author author NN 40436 2015 17 . . . 40436 2016 1 But but CC 40436 2016 2 if if IN 40436 2016 3 the the DT 40436 2016 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2016 5 had have VBD 40436 2016 6 been be VBN 40436 2016 7 composed compose VBN 40436 2016 8 by by IN 40436 2016 9 any any DT 40436 2016 10 one one NN 40436 2016 11 less less RBR 40436 2016 12 celebrated celebrate VBN 40436 2016 13 than than IN 40436 2016 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2016 15 , , , 40436 2016 16 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2016 17 would would MD 40436 2016 18 have have VB 40436 2016 19 named name VBN 40436 2016 20 the the DT 40436 2016 21 author author NN 40436 2016 22 . . . 40436 2017 1 Mention mention NN 40436 2017 2 by by IN 40436 2017 3 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2017 4 , , , 40436 2017 5 though though IN 40436 2017 6 without without IN 40436 2017 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2017 8 's 's POS 40436 2017 9 name name NN 40436 2017 10 , , , 40436 2017 11 is be VBZ 40436 2017 12 of of IN 40436 2017 13 greater great JJR 40436 2017 14 value value NN 40436 2017 15 to to TO 40436 2017 16 support support VB 40436 2017 17 the the DT 40436 2017 18 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 2017 19 than than IN 40436 2017 20 the the DT 40436 2017 21 purely purely RB 40436 2017 22 internal internal JJ 40436 2017 23 grounds ground NNS 40436 2017 24 stated state VBN 40436 2017 25 by by IN 40436 2017 26 Ast Ast NNP 40436 2017 27 and and CC 40436 2017 28 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2017 29 against against IN 40436 2017 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2017 31 . . . 40436 2017 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2018 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2018 2 Side side NN 40436 2018 3 - - HYPH 40436 2018 4 note note NN 40436 2018 5 : : : 40436 2018 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2018 7 has have VBZ 40436 2018 8 just just RB 40436 2018 9 delivered deliver VBN 40436 2018 10 a a DT 40436 2018 11 lecture lecture NN 40436 2018 12 , , , 40436 2018 13 in in IN 40436 2018 14 which which WDT 40436 2018 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2018 16 extols extol VBZ 40436 2018 17 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2018 18 as as RB 40436 2018 19 better well JJR 40436 2018 20 than than IN 40436 2018 21 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 2018 22 -- -- : 40436 2018 23 the the DT 40436 2018 24 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2018 25 and and CC 40436 2018 26 straightforward straightforward JJ 40436 2018 27 hero hero NN 40436 2018 28 better well RBR 40436 2018 29 than than IN 40436 2018 30 the the DT 40436 2018 31 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2018 32 and and CC 40436 2018 33 crafty crafty JJ 40436 2018 34 . . . 40436 2018 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2019 1 In in IN 40436 2019 2 the the DT 40436 2019 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2019 4 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2019 5 , , , 40436 2019 6 that that IN 40436 2019 7 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 2019 8 appears appear VBZ 40436 2019 9 as as IN 40436 2019 10 having have VBG 40436 2019 11 just just RB 40436 2019 12 concluded conclude VBN 40436 2019 13 a a DT 40436 2019 14 lecture lecture NN 40436 2019 15 upon upon IN 40436 2019 16 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2019 17 , , , 40436 2019 18 in in IN 40436 2019 19 which which WDT 40436 2019 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2019 21 had have VBD 40436 2019 22 extolled extoll VBN 40436 2019 23 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2019 24 as as RB 40436 2019 25 better well JJR 40436 2019 26 than than IN 40436 2019 27 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 2019 28 : : : 40436 2019 29 Achilles achille NNS 40436 2019 30 being be VBG 40436 2019 31 depicted depict VBN 40436 2019 32 as as IN 40436 2019 33 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2019 34 and and CC 40436 2019 35 straightforward straightforward JJ 40436 2019 36 , , , 40436 2019 37 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 2019 38 as as IN 40436 2019 39 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2019 40 and and CC 40436 2019 41 full full JJ 40436 2019 42 of of IN 40436 2019 43 tricks trick NNS 40436 2019 44 . . . 40436 2020 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2020 2 , , , 40436 2020 3 who who WP 40436 2020 4 had have VBD 40436 2020 5 been be VBN 40436 2020 6 among among IN 40436 2020 7 the the DT 40436 2020 8 auditors auditor NNS 40436 2020 9 , , , 40436 2020 10 cross cross NN 40436 2020 11 - - NNS 40436 2020 12 examines examine VBZ 40436 2020 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2020 14 upon upon IN 40436 2020 15 the the DT 40436 2020 16 subject subject NN 40436 2020 17 of of IN 40436 2020 18 this this DT 40436 2020 19 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 2020 20 . . . 40436 2021 1 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2021 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2021 3 says say VBZ 40436 2021 4 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2021 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2021 6 considers consider VBZ 40436 2021 7 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2021 8 men man NNS 40436 2021 9 , , , 40436 2021 10 and and CC 40436 2021 11 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2021 12 men man NNS 40436 2021 13 , , , 40436 2021 14 to to TO 40436 2021 15 be be VB 40436 2021 16 not not RB 40436 2021 17 merely merely RB 40436 2021 18 different different JJ 40436 2021 19 , , , 40436 2021 20 but but CC 40436 2021 21 opposite opposite JJ 40436 2021 22 : : : 40436 2021 23 and and CC 40436 2021 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2021 25 agree agree VBP 40436 2021 26 with with IN 40436 2021 27 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2021 28 . . . 40436 2022 1 Permit permit VB 40436 2022 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2022 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2022 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2022 5 remarks remark NNS 40436 2022 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2022 7 to to TO 40436 2022 8 ask ask VB 40436 2022 9 some some DT 40436 2022 10 questions question NNS 40436 2022 11 about about IN 40436 2022 12 the the DT 40436 2022 13 meaning meaning NN 40436 2022 14 of of IN 40436 2022 15 this this DT 40436 2022 16 from from IN 40436 2022 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2022 18 , , , 40436 2022 19 since since IN 40436 2022 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2022 21 can can MD 40436 2022 22 not not RB 40436 2022 23 ask ask VB 40436 2022 24 any any DT 40436 2022 25 from from IN 40436 2022 26 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2022 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2022 28 . . . 40436 2023 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2023 2 will will MD 40436 2023 3 answer answer VB 40436 2023 4 both both DT 40436 2023 5 for for IN 40436 2023 6 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 2023 7 and and CC 40436 2023 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2023 9 . . . 40436 2024 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2024 2 54 54 CD 40436 2024 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2024 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2024 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2024 6 54 54 CD 40436 2024 7 : : : 40436 2024 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2024 9 . . . 40436 2025 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2025 2 . . . 40436 2026 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 2026 2 , , , 40436 2026 3 365 365 CD 40436 2026 4 C C NNP 40436 2026 5 - - HYPH 40436 2026 6 D. D. NNP 40436 2027 1 The the DT 40436 2027 2 remark remark NN 40436 2027 3 here here RB 40436 2027 4 made make VBN 40436 2027 5 by by IN 40436 2027 6 Sokrates--"The sokrates--"the CD 40436 2027 7 poet poet NN 40436 2027 8 is be VBZ 40436 2027 9 not not RB 40436 2027 10 here here RB 40436 2027 11 to to TO 40436 2027 12 answer answer VB 40436 2027 13 for for IN 40436 2027 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2027 15 , , , 40436 2027 16 so so IN 40436 2027 17 that that IN 40436 2027 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2027 19 can can MD 40436 2027 20 not not RB 40436 2027 21 put put VB 40436 2027 22 any any DT 40436 2027 23 questions question NNS 40436 2027 24 to to IN 40436 2027 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2027 26 " " `` 40436 2027 27 is be VBZ 40436 2027 28 a a DT 40436 2027 29 point point NN 40436 2027 30 of of IN 40436 2027 31 view view NN 40436 2027 32 familiar familiar JJ 40436 2027 33 to to IN 40436 2027 34 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2027 35 : : : 40436 2027 36 insisted insist VBN 40436 2027 37 upon upon IN 40436 2027 38 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 2027 39 in in IN 40436 2027 40 the the DT 40436 2027 41 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2027 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2027 43 347 347 CD 40436 2027 44 E e NN 40436 2027 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2027 46 , , , 40436 2027 47 and and CC 40436 2027 48 farther farther RB 40436 2027 49 generalised generalise VBD 40436 2027 50 in in IN 40436 2027 51 the the DT 40436 2027 52 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 2027 53 , , , 40436 2027 54 so so IN 40436 2027 55 as as IN 40436 2027 56 to to TO 40436 2027 57 apply apply VB 40436 2027 58 to to IN 40436 2027 59 all all DT 40436 2027 60 written write VBN 40436 2027 61 matter matter NN 40436 2027 62 compared compare VBN 40436 2027 63 with with IN 40436 2027 64 personal personal JJ 40436 2027 65 converse converse NN 40436 2027 66 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2027 67 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 2027 68 , , , 40436 2027 69 p. p. NN 40436 2027 70 275 275 CD 40436 2027 71 D d NN 40436 2027 72 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2027 73 . . . 40436 2028 1 This this DT 40436 2028 2 ought ought MD 40436 2028 3 to to TO 40436 2028 4 count count VB 40436 2028 5 , , , 40436 2028 6 so so RB 40436 2028 7 far far RB 40436 2028 8 as as IN 40436 2028 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2028 10 goes go VBZ 40436 2028 11 , , , 40436 2028 12 as as IN 40436 2028 13 a a DT 40436 2028 14 fragment fragment NN 40436 2028 15 of of IN 40436 2028 16 proof proof NN 40436 2028 17 that that IN 40436 2028 18 the the DT 40436 2028 19 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2028 20 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2028 21 is be VBZ 40436 2028 22 a a DT 40436 2028 23 genuine genuine JJ 40436 2028 24 work work NN 40436 2028 25 of of IN 40436 2028 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2028 27 , , , 40436 2028 28 instead instead RB 40436 2028 29 of of IN 40436 2028 30 which which WDT 40436 2028 31 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2028 32 treats treat VBZ 40436 2028 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2028 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2028 35 p. p. NN 40436 2028 36 295 295 CD 40436 2028 37 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2028 38 as as IN 40436 2028 39 evincing evince VBG 40436 2028 40 a a DT 40436 2028 41 poor poor JJ 40436 2028 42 copy copy NN 40436 2028 43 , , , 40436 2028 44 made make VBN 40436 2028 45 by by IN 40436 2028 46 some some DT 40436 2028 47 imitator imitator NN 40436 2028 48 of of IN 40436 2028 49 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2028 50 , , , 40436 2028 51 from from IN 40436 2028 52 the the DT 40436 2028 53 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2028 54 . . . 40436 2028 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2029 1 Mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2029 2 men man NNS 40436 2029 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2029 4 answers answer NNS 40436 2029 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2029 6 , , , 40436 2029 7 to to IN 40436 2029 8 a a DT 40436 2029 9 string string NN 40436 2029 10 of of IN 40436 2029 11 questions question NNS 40436 2029 12 , , , 40436 2029 13 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 2029 14 prolix prolix JJ 40436 2029 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2029 16 are be VBP 40436 2029 17 capable capable JJ 40436 2029 18 , , , 40436 2029 19 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 2029 20 , , , 40436 2029 21 wise wise JJ 40436 2029 22 : : : 40436 2029 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2029 24 are be VBP 40436 2029 25 not not RB 40436 2029 26 incapable incapable JJ 40436 2029 27 or or CC 40436 2029 28 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2029 29 . . . 40436 2030 1 If if IN 40436 2030 2 a a DT 40436 2030 3 man man NN 40436 2030 4 be be VB 40436 2030 5 incapable incapable JJ 40436 2030 6 of of IN 40436 2030 7 speaking speak VBG 40436 2030 8 falsely falsely RB 40436 2030 9 , , , 40436 2030 10 or or CC 40436 2030 11 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2030 12 , , , 40436 2030 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2030 14 is be VBZ 40436 2030 15 not not RB 40436 2030 16 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2030 17 . . . 40436 2031 1 Now now RB 40436 2031 2 the the DT 40436 2031 3 capable capable JJ 40436 2031 4 man man NN 40436 2031 5 is be VBZ 40436 2031 6 one one CD 40436 2031 7 who who WP 40436 2031 8 can can MD 40436 2031 9 make make VB 40436 2031 10 sure sure JJ 40436 2031 11 of of IN 40436 2031 12 doing do VBG 40436 2031 13 what what WP 40436 2031 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2031 15 wishes wish VBZ 40436 2031 16 to to TO 40436 2031 17 do do VB 40436 2031 18 , , , 40436 2031 19 at at IN 40436 2031 20 the the DT 40436 2031 21 time time NN 40436 2031 22 and and CC 40436 2031 23 occasion occasion NN 40436 2031 24 when when WRB 40436 2031 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2031 26 does do VBZ 40436 2031 27 wish wish VB 40436 2031 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2031 29 , , , 40436 2031 30 without without IN 40436 2031 31 let let NN 40436 2031 32 or or CC 40436 2031 33 hindrance hindrance VB 40436 2031 34 . . . 40436 2032 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2032 2 55 55 CD 40436 2032 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2032 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2032 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2032 6 55 55 CD 40436 2032 7 : : : 40436 2032 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2032 9 . . . 40436 2033 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2033 2 . . . 40436 2034 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 2034 2 , , , 40436 2034 3 366 366 CD 40436 2034 4 B B NNP 40436 2034 5 - - HYPH 40436 2034 6 C. C. NNP 40436 2034 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2034 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2034 9 Side side NN 40436 2034 10 - - HYPH 40436 2034 11 note note NN 40436 2034 12 : : : 40436 2034 13 This this DT 40436 2034 14 is be VBZ 40436 2034 15 contested contest VBN 40436 2034 16 by by IN 40436 2034 17 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2034 18 . . . 40436 2035 1 The the DT 40436 2035 2 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2035 3 man man NN 40436 2035 4 and and CC 40436 2035 5 the the DT 40436 2035 6 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2035 7 man man NN 40436 2035 8 are be VBP 40436 2035 9 one one CD 40436 2035 10 and and CC 40436 2035 11 the the DT 40436 2035 12 same same JJ 40436 2035 13 -- -- : 40436 2035 14 the the DT 40436 2035 15 only only JJ 40436 2035 16 man man NN 40436 2035 17 who who WP 40436 2035 18 can can MD 40436 2035 19 answer answer VB 40436 2035 20 truly truly RB 40436 2035 21 if if IN 40436 2035 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2035 23 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2035 24 , , , 40436 2035 25 is be VBZ 40436 2035 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2035 27 who who WP 40436 2035 28 can can MD 40436 2035 29 also also RB 40436 2035 30 answer answer VB 40436 2035 31 falsely falsely RB 40436 2035 32 if if IN 40436 2035 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2035 34 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2035 35 , , , 40436 2035 36 _ _ NNP 40436 2035 37 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 2035 38 _ _ NNP 40436 2035 39 the the DT 40436 2035 40 knowing know VBG 40436 2035 41 man man NN 40436 2035 42 -- -- : 40436 2035 43 the the DT 40436 2035 44 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2035 45 man man NN 40436 2035 46 can can MD 40436 2035 47 not not RB 40436 2035 48 make make VB 40436 2035 49 sure sure JJ 40436 2035 50 of of IN 40436 2035 51 doing do VBG 40436 2035 52 either either CC 40436 2035 53 the the DT 40436 2035 54 one one CD 40436 2035 55 or or CC 40436 2035 56 the the DT 40436 2035 57 other other JJ 40436 2035 58 . . . 40436 2035 59 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2036 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2036 2 , , , 40436 2036 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2036 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2036 5 says say VBZ 40436 2036 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2036 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2036 8 , , , 40436 2036 9 are be VBP 40436 2036 10 expert expert JJ 40436 2036 11 on on IN 40436 2036 12 matters matter NNS 40436 2036 13 of of IN 40436 2036 14 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 2036 15 : : : 40436 2036 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2036 17 can can MD 40436 2036 18 make make VB 40436 2036 19 sure sure JJ 40436 2036 20 of of IN 40436 2036 21 answering answer VBG 40436 2036 22 truly truly RB 40436 2036 23 any any DT 40436 2036 24 question question NN 40436 2036 25 put put VBN 40436 2036 26 to to IN 40436 2036 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2036 28 on on IN 40436 2036 29 the the DT 40436 2036 30 subject subject NN 40436 2036 31 . . . 40436 2037 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2037 2 are be VBP 40436 2037 3 _ _ NNP 40436 2037 4 better well JJR 40436 2037 5 _ _ NNP 40436 2037 6 on on IN 40436 2037 7 the the DT 40436 2037 8 subject subject NN 40436 2037 9 than than IN 40436 2037 10 the the DT 40436 2037 11 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2037 12 man man NN 40436 2037 13 , , , 40436 2037 14 who who WP 40436 2037 15 can can MD 40436 2037 16 not not RB 40436 2037 17 make make VB 40436 2037 18 sure sure JJ 40436 2037 19 of of IN 40436 2037 20 doing do VBG 40436 2037 21 the the DT 40436 2037 22 same same JJ 40436 2037 23 . . . 40436 2038 1 But but CC 40436 2038 2 as as IN 40436 2038 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2038 4 can can MD 40436 2038 5 make make VB 40436 2038 6 sure sure JJ 40436 2038 7 of of IN 40436 2038 8 answering answer VBG 40436 2038 9 truly truly RB 40436 2038 10 , , , 40436 2038 11 so so RB 40436 2038 12 likewise likewise RB 40436 2038 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2038 14 can can MD 40436 2038 15 make make VB 40436 2038 16 sure sure JJ 40436 2038 17 of of IN 40436 2038 18 answering answer VBG 40436 2038 19 falsely falsely RB 40436 2038 20 , , , 40436 2038 21 whenever whenever WRB 40436 2038 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2038 23 choose choose VBP 40436 2038 24 to to TO 40436 2038 25 do do VB 40436 2038 26 so so RB 40436 2038 27 . . . 40436 2039 1 Now now RB 40436 2039 2 the the DT 40436 2039 3 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2039 4 man man NN 40436 2039 5 can can MD 40436 2039 6 not not RB 40436 2039 7 make make VB 40436 2039 8 sure sure JJ 40436 2039 9 of of IN 40436 2039 10 answering answer VBG 40436 2039 11 falsely falsely RB 40436 2039 12 . . . 40436 2040 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2040 2 may may MD 40436 2040 3 , , , 40436 2040 4 by by IN 40436 2040 5 reason reason NN 40436 2040 6 of of IN 40436 2040 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2040 8 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 2040 9 , , , 40436 2040 10 when when WRB 40436 2040 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2040 12 wishes wish VBZ 40436 2040 13 to to TO 40436 2040 14 answer answer VB 40436 2040 15 falsely falsely RB 40436 2040 16 , , , 40436 2040 17 answer answer VB 40436 2040 18 truly truly RB 40436 2040 19 without without IN 40436 2040 20 intending intend VBG 40436 2040 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2040 22 . . . 40436 2041 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2041 2 , , , 40436 2041 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 2041 4 , , , 40436 2041 5 the the DT 40436 2041 6 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 2041 7 man man NN 40436 2041 8 and and CC 40436 2041 9 the the DT 40436 2041 10 good good JJ 40436 2041 11 in in IN 40436 2041 12 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 2041 13 , , , 40436 2041 14 are be VBP 40436 2041 15 better well JJR 40436 2041 16 than than IN 40436 2041 17 the the DT 40436 2041 18 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2041 19 and and CC 40436 2041 20 the the DT 40436 2041 21 bad bad JJ 40436 2041 22 for for IN 40436 2041 23 both both DT 40436 2041 24 purposes purpose NNS 40436 2041 25 -- -- : 40436 2041 26 for for IN 40436 2041 27 speaking speak VBG 40436 2041 28 falsely falsely RB 40436 2041 29 , , , 40436 2041 30 and and CC 40436 2041 31 for for IN 40436 2041 32 speaking speak VBG 40436 2041 33 truly truly RB 40436 2041 34 . . . 40436 2042 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2042 2 56 56 CD 40436 2042 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2042 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2042 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2042 6 56 56 CD 40436 2042 7 : : : 40436 2042 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2042 9 , , , 40436 2042 10 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2042 11 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2042 12 , , , 40436 2042 13 366 366 CD 40436 2042 14 E. E. NNP 40436 2042 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2042 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2042 17 : : : 40436 2042 18 Po Po NNP 40436 2042 19 / / SYM 40436 2042 20 teron teron NNP 40436 2042 21 su\ su\ NNP 40436 2042 22 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2042 23 ma ma NNP 40436 2042 24 / / SYM 40436 2042 25 lista lista NNP 40436 2042 26 pseu pseu NNP 40436 2042 27 / / SYM 40436 2042 28 doio doio NNP 40436 2042 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2042 30 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 2042 31 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 2042 32 tau)ta\ tau)ta\ SYM 40436 2042 33 pseudê= pseudê= NNP 40436 2042 34 le le NNP 40436 2042 35 / / SYM 40436 2042 36 gois gois NNP 40436 2042 37 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 2042 38 tou tou NNP 40436 2042 39 / / SYM 40436 2042 40 tôn tôn NNP 40436 2042 41 , , , 40436 2042 42 boulo boulo NNP 40436 2042 43 / / SYM 40436 2042 44 menos menos NNP 40436 2042 45 pseu pseu NNP 40436 2042 46 / / SYM 40436 2042 47 desthai desthai NNP 40436 2042 48 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2042 49 mêde mêde NNP 40436 2042 50 / / SYM 40436 2042 51 pote pote NNP 40436 2042 52 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 2042 53 a)pokri a)pokri , 40436 2042 54 / / SYM 40436 2042 55 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 2042 56 ? ? . 40436 2043 1 ê)/ ê)/ NNP 40436 2043 2 o o XX 40436 2043 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2043 4 a)mathê\s a)mathê\s NNP 40436 2043 5 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 2043 6 logismou\s logismou\s '' 40436 2043 7 du du NNP 40436 2043 8 / / SYM 40436 2043 9 nait nait NNP 40436 2043 10 ' ' POS 40436 2043 11 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2043 12 sou= sou= NNP 40436 2043 13 ma ma NNP 40436 2043 14 = = SYM 40436 2043 15 llon llon NNP 40436 2043 16 pseu pseu NNP 40436 2043 17 / / SYM 40436 2043 18 desthai desthai NNP 40436 2043 19 boulome boulome NNP 40436 2043 20 / / SYM 40436 2043 21 nou nou NN 40436 2043 22 ? ? . 40436 2044 1 ê)\ ê)\ NFP 40436 2044 2 o o FW 40436 2044 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2044 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 2044 5 a)mathê\s a)mathê\s NNP 40436 2044 6 polla polla NN 40436 2044 7 / / SYM 40436 2044 8 kis kis NNP 40436 2044 9 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 2044 10 boulo boulo NNP 40436 2044 11 / / SYM 40436 2044 12 menos menos NNP 40436 2044 13 pseudê= pseudê= NNP 40436 2044 14 le le NNP 40436 2044 15 / / SYM 40436 2044 16 gein gein NNP 40436 2044 17 ta)lêthê= ta)lêthê= FW 40436 2044 18 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2044 19 ei)/poi ei)/poi NNP 40436 2044 20 a)/kôn a)/kôn NNP 40436 2044 21 , , , 40436 2044 22 ei ei NNP 40436 2044 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2044 24 tu tu NNP 40436 2044 25 / / SYM 40436 2044 26 choi choi NNP 40436 2044 27 , , , 40436 2044 28 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 2044 29 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2044 30 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 2044 31 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 2044 32 / / SYM 40436 2044 33 nai nai NN 40436 2044 34 -- -- : 40436 2044 35 su\ su\ NNP 40436 2044 36 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2044 37 o o NN 40436 2044 38 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2044 39 sopho sopho NNP 40436 2044 40 / / SYM 40436 2044 41 s s NNPS 40436 2044 42 , , , 40436 2044 43 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 2044 44 bou bou NNP 40436 2044 45 / / SYM 40436 2044 46 loio loio NNP 40436 2044 47 pseu pseu NNP 40436 2044 48 / / SYM 40436 2044 49 desthai desthai NNP 40436 2044 50 , , , 40436 2044 51 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 2044 52 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2044 53 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 2044 54 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 2044 55 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 2044 56 pseu pseu NNS 40436 2044 57 / / SYM 40436 2044 58 doio doio NN 40436 2044 59 ? ? . 40436 2044 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2044 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2045 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2045 2 Side side NN 40436 2045 3 - - HYPH 40436 2045 4 note note NN 40436 2045 5 : : : 40436 2045 6 Analogy analogy NN 40436 2045 7 of of IN 40436 2045 8 special special JJ 40436 2045 9 arts art NNS 40436 2045 10 -- -- : 40436 2045 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2045 12 is be VBZ 40436 2045 13 only only RB 40436 2045 14 the the DT 40436 2045 15 arithmetician arithmetician NN 40436 2045 16 who who WP 40436 2045 17 can can MD 40436 2045 18 speak speak VB 40436 2045 19 falsely falsely RB 40436 2045 20 on on IN 40436 2045 21 a a DT 40436 2045 22 question question NN 40436 2045 23 of of IN 40436 2045 24 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 2045 25 when when WRB 40436 2045 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2045 27 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2045 28 . . . 40436 2045 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2046 1 What what WP 40436 2046 2 is be VBZ 40436 2046 3 true true JJ 40436 2046 4 about about IN 40436 2046 5 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 2046 6 , , , 40436 2046 7 is be VBZ 40436 2046 8 true true JJ 40436 2046 9 in in IN 40436 2046 10 other other JJ 40436 2046 11 departments department NNS 40436 2046 12 also also RB 40436 2046 13 . . . 40436 2047 1 The the DT 40436 2047 2 only only JJ 40436 2047 3 man man NN 40436 2047 4 who who WP 40436 2047 5 can can MD 40436 2047 6 speak speak VB 40436 2047 7 falsely falsely RB 40436 2047 8 whenever whenever WRB 40436 2047 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2047 10 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2047 11 is be VBZ 40436 2047 12 the the DT 40436 2047 13 man man NN 40436 2047 14 who who WP 40436 2047 15 can can MD 40436 2047 16 speak speak VB 40436 2047 17 truly truly RB 40436 2047 18 whenever whenever WRB 40436 2047 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2047 20 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2047 21 . . . 40436 2048 1 Now now RB 40436 2048 2 , , , 40436 2048 3 the the DT 40436 2048 4 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2048 5 man man NN 40436 2048 6 , , , 40436 2048 7 as as IN 40436 2048 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2048 9 agreed agree VBD 40436 2048 10 , , , 40436 2048 11 is be VBZ 40436 2048 12 the the DT 40436 2048 13 man man NN 40436 2048 14 who who WP 40436 2048 15 can can MD 40436 2048 16 speak speak VB 40436 2048 17 falsely falsely RB 40436 2048 18 whenever whenever WRB 40436 2048 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2048 20 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2048 21 . . . 40436 2049 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 2049 2 , , , 40436 2049 3 the the DT 40436 2049 4 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2049 5 man man NN 40436 2049 6 , , , 40436 2049 7 and and CC 40436 2049 8 the the DT 40436 2049 9 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2049 10 man man NN 40436 2049 11 , , , 40436 2049 12 are be VBP 40436 2049 13 the the DT 40436 2049 14 same same JJ 40436 2049 15 . . . 40436 2050 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 2050 2 are be VBP 40436 2050 3 not not RB 40436 2050 4 different different JJ 40436 2050 5 , , , 40436 2050 6 still still RB 40436 2050 7 less less RBR 40436 2050 8 opposite opposite JJ 40436 2050 9 : : : 40436 2050 10 nay nay NNP 40436 2050 11 , , , 40436 2050 12 the the DT 40436 2050 13 two two CD 40436 2050 14 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2050 15 belong belong VBP 40436 2050 16 only only RB 40436 2050 17 to to IN 40436 2050 18 one one CD 40436 2050 19 and and CC 40436 2050 20 the the DT 40436 2050 21 same same JJ 40436 2050 22 person person NN 40436 2050 23 . . . 40436 2051 1 The the DT 40436 2051 2 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2051 3 man man NN 40436 2051 4 is be VBZ 40436 2051 5 not not RB 40436 2051 6 better well JJR 40436 2051 7 than than IN 40436 2051 8 the the DT 40436 2051 9 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2051 10 -- -- : 40436 2051 11 seeing see VBG 40436 2051 12 that that IN 40436 2051 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2051 14 is be VBZ 40436 2051 15 one one CD 40436 2051 16 and and CC 40436 2051 17 the the DT 40436 2051 18 same same JJ 40436 2051 19 . . . 40436 2052 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2052 2 57 57 CD 40436 2052 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2052 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2052 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2052 6 57 57 CD 40436 2052 7 : : : 40436 2052 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2052 9 , , , 40436 2052 10 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 2052 11 . . . 40436 2053 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 2053 2 , , , 40436 2053 3 367 367 CD 40436 2053 4 C c NN 40436 2053 5 , , , 40436 2053 6 368 368 CD 40436 2053 7 E e NN 40436 2053 8 , , , 40436 2053 9 369 369 CD 40436 2053 10 A A NNP 40436 2053 11 - - HYPH 40436 2053 12 B. b. NN 40436 2053 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2054 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2054 2 see see VBP 40436 2054 3 , , , 40436 2054 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 2054 5 , , , 40436 2054 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2054 7 , , , 40436 2054 8 that that IN 40436 2054 9 the the DT 40436 2054 10 distinction distinction NN 40436 2054 11 , , , 40436 2054 12 which which WDT 40436 2054 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2054 14 drew draw VBD 40436 2054 15 and and CC 40436 2054 16 which which WDT 40436 2054 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2054 18 said say VBD 40436 2054 19 that that IN 40436 2054 20 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2054 21 drew draw VBD 40436 2054 22 , , , 40436 2054 23 between between IN 40436 2054 24 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2054 25 and and CC 40436 2054 26 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 2054 27 , , , 40436 2054 28 will will MD 40436 2054 29 not not RB 40436 2054 30 hold hold VB 40436 2054 31 . . . 40436 2055 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2055 2 called call VBD 40436 2055 3 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2055 4 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2055 5 , , , 40436 2055 6 and and CC 40436 2055 7 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 2055 8 , , , 40436 2055 9 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2055 10 : : : 40436 2055 11 but but CC 40436 2055 12 if if IN 40436 2055 13 one one CD 40436 2055 14 of of IN 40436 2055 15 the the DT 40436 2055 16 two two CD 40436 2055 17 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2055 18 belongs belong VBZ 40436 2055 19 to to IN 40436 2055 20 either either DT 40436 2055 21 of of IN 40436 2055 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2055 23 , , , 40436 2055 24 the the DT 40436 2055 25 other other JJ 40436 2055 26 must must MD 40436 2055 27 belong belong VB 40436 2055 28 to to IN 40436 2055 29 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2055 30 also also RB 40436 2055 31 . . . 40436 2056 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2056 2 58 58 CD 40436 2056 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2056 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2056 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2056 6 58 58 CD 40436 2056 7 : : : 40436 2056 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2056 9 . . . 40436 2057 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2057 2 . . . 40436 2058 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 2058 2 , , , 40436 2058 3 360 360 CD 40436 2058 4 B. b. NN 40436 2058 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2059 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2059 2 Side side NN 40436 2059 3 - - HYPH 40436 2059 4 note note NN 40436 2059 5 : : : 40436 2059 6 View view NN 40436 2059 7 of of IN 40436 2059 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2059 9 respecting respect VBG 40436 2059 10 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2059 11 in in IN 40436 2059 12 the the DT 40436 2059 13 Iliad Iliad NNP 40436 2059 14 . . . 40436 2060 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2060 2 thinks think VBZ 40436 2060 3 that that IN 40436 2060 4 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2060 5 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2060 6 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 2060 7 cleverly cleverly RB 40436 2060 8 . . . 40436 2061 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2061 2 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 2061 3 that that IN 40436 2061 4 if if IN 40436 2061 5 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2061 6 ever ever RB 40436 2061 7 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2061 8 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 2061 9 , , , 40436 2061 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2061 11 is be VBZ 40436 2061 12 with with IN 40436 2061 13 an an DT 40436 2061 14 innocent innocent JJ 40436 2061 15 purpose purpose NN 40436 2061 16 , , , 40436 2061 17 whereas whereas IN 40436 2061 18 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 2061 19 does do VBZ 40436 2061 20 the the DT 40436 2061 21 like like VB 40436 2061 22 with with IN 40436 2061 23 fraudulent fraudulent JJ 40436 2061 24 purpose purpose NN 40436 2061 25 . . . 40436 2061 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2062 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2062 2 then then RB 40436 2062 3 tries try VBZ 40436 2062 4 to to TO 40436 2062 5 make make VB 40436 2062 6 out out RP 40436 2062 7 that that IN 40436 2062 8 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2062 9 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2062 10 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 2062 11 in in IN 40436 2062 12 the the DT 40436 2062 13 Iliad Iliad NNP 40436 2062 14 , , , 40436 2062 15 and and CC 40436 2062 16 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2062 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2062 18 very very RB 40436 2062 19 cleverly cleverly RB 40436 2062 20 , , , 40436 2062 21 because because IN 40436 2062 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2062 23 does do VBZ 40436 2062 24 so so RB 40436 2062 25 in in IN 40436 2062 26 a a DT 40436 2062 27 way way NN 40436 2062 28 to to TO 40436 2062 29 escape escape VB 40436 2062 30 detection detection NN 40436 2062 31 from from IN 40436 2062 32 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 2062 33 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2062 34 . . . 40436 2063 1 To to IN 40436 2063 2 this this DT 40436 2063 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2063 4 replies reply VBZ 40436 2063 5 , , , 40436 2063 6 that that IN 40436 2063 7 if if IN 40436 2063 8 Achilles Achilles NNP 40436 2063 9 ever ever RB 40436 2063 10 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2063 11 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 2063 12 , , , 40436 2063 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2063 14 does do VBZ 40436 2063 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2063 16 innocently innocently RB 40436 2063 17 , , , 40436 2063 18 without without IN 40436 2063 19 any any DT 40436 2063 20 purpose purpose NN 40436 2063 21 of of IN 40436 2063 22 cheating cheat VBG 40436 2063 23 or or CC 40436 2063 24 injuring injure VBG 40436 2063 25 any any DT 40436 2063 26 one one CD 40436 2063 27 ; ; : 40436 2063 28 whereas whereas IN 40436 2063 29 the the DT 40436 2063 30 falsehoods falsehood NNS 40436 2063 31 of of IN 40436 2063 32 Odysseus Odysseus NNP 40436 2063 33 are be VBP 40436 2063 34 delivered deliver VBN 40436 2063 35 with with IN 40436 2063 36 fraudulent fraudulent JJ 40436 2063 37 and and CC 40436 2063 38 wicked wicked JJ 40436 2063 39 intent intent NN 40436 2063 40 . . . 40436 2064 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2064 2 59 59 CD 40436 2064 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2064 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2064 5 is be VBZ 40436 2064 6 impossible impossible JJ 40436 2064 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2064 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2064 9 contends contend VBZ 40436 2064 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2064 11 that that IN 40436 2064 12 men man NNS 40436 2064 13 who who WP 40436 2064 14 deceive deceive VBP 40436 2064 15 and and CC 40436 2064 16 do do VBP 40436 2064 17 wrong wrong NN 40436 2064 18 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2064 19 and and CC 40436 2064 20 intentionally intentionally RB 40436 2064 21 , , , 40436 2064 22 should should MD 40436 2064 23 be be VB 40436 2064 24 better well JJR 40436 2064 25 than than IN 40436 2064 26 those those DT 40436 2064 27 who who WP 40436 2064 28 do do VBP 40436 2064 29 so so RB 40436 2064 30 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2064 31 and and CC 40436 2064 32 without without IN 40436 2064 33 design design NN 40436 2064 34 . . . 40436 2065 1 The the DT 40436 2065 2 laws law NNS 40436 2065 3 deal deal VBP 40436 2065 4 much much RB 40436 2065 5 more more RBR 40436 2065 6 severely severely RB 40436 2065 7 with with IN 40436 2065 8 the the DT 40436 2065 9 former former JJ 40436 2065 10 than than IN 40436 2065 11 with with IN 40436 2065 12 the the DT 40436 2065 13 latter latter JJ 40436 2065 14 . . . 40436 2066 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2066 2 60 60 CD 40436 2066 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2066 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2066 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2066 6 59 59 CD 40436 2066 7 : : : 40436 2066 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2066 9 . . . 40436 2067 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2067 2 . . . 40436 2068 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 2068 2 , , , 40436 2068 3 370 370 CD 40436 2068 4 E. e. NN 40436 2068 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2068 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2068 7 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2068 8 60 60 CD 40436 2068 9 : : : 40436 2068 10 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2068 11 . . . 40436 2069 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2069 2 . . . 40436 2070 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 2070 2 , , , 40436 2070 3 372 372 CD 40436 2070 4 A. a. NN 40436 2070 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2071 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2071 2 Side side NN 40436 2071 3 - - HYPH 40436 2071 4 note note NN 40436 2071 5 : : : 40436 2071 6 Issue issue NN 40436 2071 7 here here RB 40436 2071 8 taken take VBN 40436 2071 9 -- -- : 40436 2071 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2071 11 contends contend VBZ 40436 2071 12 that that IN 40436 2071 13 those those DT 40436 2071 14 who who WP 40436 2071 15 hurt hurt VBP 40436 2071 16 , , , 40436 2071 17 or or CC 40436 2071 18 cheat cheat VB 40436 2071 19 , , , 40436 2071 20 or or CC 40436 2071 21 lie lie NN 40436 2071 22 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2071 23 , , , 40436 2071 24 are be VBP 40436 2071 25 better well JJR 40436 2071 26 than than IN 40436 2071 27 those those DT 40436 2071 28 who who WP 40436 2071 29 do do VBP 40436 2071 30 the the DT 40436 2071 31 like like UH 40436 2071 32 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2071 33 -- -- : 40436 2071 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2071 35 entreats entreat VBZ 40436 2071 36 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2071 37 to to TO 40436 2071 38 enlighten enlighten VB 40436 2071 39 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2071 40 and and CC 40436 2071 41 answer answer VB 40436 2071 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2071 43 questions question NNS 40436 2071 44 . . . 40436 2071 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2072 1 Upon upon IN 40436 2072 2 this this DT 40436 2072 3 point point NN 40436 2072 4 , , , 40436 2072 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2072 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2072 7 says say VBZ 40436 2072 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2072 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2072 10 , , , 40436 2072 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2072 12 dissent dissent VBP 40436 2072 13 from from IN 40436 2072 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2072 15 entirely entirely RB 40436 2072 16 . . . 40436 2073 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2073 2 am be VBP 40436 2073 3 , , , 40436 2073 4 unhappily unhappily RB 40436 2073 5 , , , 40436 2073 6 a a DT 40436 2073 7 stupid stupid JJ 40436 2073 8 person person NN 40436 2073 9 , , , 40436 2073 10 who who WP 40436 2073 11 can can MD 40436 2073 12 not not RB 40436 2073 13 find find VB 40436 2073 14 out out RP 40436 2073 15 the the DT 40436 2073 16 reality reality NN 40436 2073 17 of of IN 40436 2073 18 things thing NNS 40436 2073 19 : : : 40436 2073 20 and and CC 40436 2073 21 this this DT 40436 2073 22 appears appear VBZ 40436 2073 23 plainly plainly RB 40436 2073 24 enough enough RB 40436 2073 25 when when WRB 40436 2073 26 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2073 27 come come VBP 40436 2073 28 to to TO 40436 2073 29 talk talk VB 40436 2073 30 with with IN 40436 2073 31 wise wise JJ 40436 2073 32 men man NNS 40436 2073 33 like like IN 40436 2073 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2073 35 , , , 40436 2073 36 for for IN 40436 2073 37 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2073 38 always always RB 40436 2073 39 find find VBP 40436 2073 40 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 2073 41 differing differ VBG 40436 2073 42 from from IN 40436 2073 43 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2073 44 . . . 40436 2074 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2074 2 only only JJ 40436 2074 3 salvation salvation NN 40436 2074 4 consists consist VBZ 40436 2074 5 in in IN 40436 2074 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2074 7 earnest earnest JJ 40436 2074 8 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 2074 9 to to TO 40436 2074 10 put put VB 40436 2074 11 questions question NNS 40436 2074 12 and and CC 40436 2074 13 learn learn VB 40436 2074 14 from from IN 40436 2074 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2074 16 , , , 40436 2074 17 and and CC 40436 2074 18 in in IN 40436 2074 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2074 20 gratitude gratitude NN 40436 2074 21 for for IN 40436 2074 22 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2074 23 answers answer NNS 40436 2074 24 and and CC 40436 2074 25 teaching teaching NN 40436 2074 26 . . . 40436 2075 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2075 2 think think VBP 40436 2075 3 that that IN 40436 2075 4 those those DT 40436 2075 5 who who WP 40436 2075 6 hurt hurt VBP 40436 2075 7 mankind mankind NN 40436 2075 8 , , , 40436 2075 9 or or CC 40436 2075 10 cheat cheat VB 40436 2075 11 , , , 40436 2075 12 or or CC 40436 2075 13 lie lie VBP 40436 2075 14 , , , 40436 2075 15 or or CC 40436 2075 16 do do VB 40436 2075 17 wrong wrong NN 40436 2075 18 , , , 40436 2075 19 _ _ NNP 40436 2075 20 wilfully_--are wilfully_--are NNP 40436 2075 21 better well JJR 40436 2075 22 than than IN 40436 2075 23 those those DT 40436 2075 24 who who WP 40436 2075 25 do do VBP 40436 2075 26 the the DT 40436 2075 27 same same JJ 40436 2075 28 _ _ NNP 40436 2075 29 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2075 30 _ _ NNP 40436 2075 31 . . . 40436 2076 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 40436 2076 2 , , , 40436 2076 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 2076 4 , , , 40436 2076 5 from from IN 40436 2076 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2076 7 stupidity stupidity NN 40436 2076 8 , , , 40436 2076 9 the the DT 40436 2076 10 opposite opposite JJ 40436 2076 11 view view NN 40436 2076 12 presents present VBZ 40436 2076 13 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 2076 14 to to IN 40436 2076 15 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2076 16 , , , 40436 2076 17 and and CC 40436 2076 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2076 19 become become VBP 40436 2076 20 confused confused JJ 40436 2076 21 : : : 40436 2076 22 but but CC 40436 2076 23 now now RB 40436 2076 24 , , , 40436 2076 25 after after IN 40436 2076 26 talking talk VBG 40436 2076 27 with with IN 40436 2076 28 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2076 29 , , , 40436 2076 30 the the DT 40436 2076 31 fit fit NN 40436 2076 32 of of IN 40436 2076 33 confidence confidence NN 40436 2076 34 has have VBZ 40436 2076 35 come come VBN 40436 2076 36 round round RB 40436 2076 37 upon upon IN 40436 2076 38 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2076 39 again again RB 40436 2076 40 , , , 40436 2076 41 to to IN 40436 2076 42 pronounce pronounce NN 40436 2076 43 and and CC 40436 2076 44 characterise characterise VB 40436 2076 45 the the DT 40436 2076 46 persons person NNS 40436 2076 47 who who WP 40436 2076 48 do do VBP 40436 2076 49 wrong wrong NN 40436 2076 50 _ _ NNP 40436 2076 51 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2076 52 _ _ NNP 40436 2076 53 , , , 40436 2076 54 as as IN 40436 2076 55 worse bad JJR 40436 2076 56 than than IN 40436 2076 57 those those DT 40436 2076 58 who who WP 40436 2076 59 do do VBP 40436 2076 60 wrong wrong NN 40436 2076 61 _ _ NNP 40436 2076 62 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2076 63 _ _ NNP 40436 2076 64 . . . 40436 2077 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2077 2 entreat entreat VBP 40436 2077 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2077 4 to to TO 40436 2077 5 heal heal VB 40436 2077 6 this this DT 40436 2077 7 disorder disorder NN 40436 2077 8 of of IN 40436 2077 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2077 10 mind mind NN 40436 2077 11 . . . 40436 2078 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2078 2 will will MD 40436 2078 3 do do VB 40436 2078 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2078 5 much much RB 40436 2078 6 more more RBR 40436 2078 7 good good JJ 40436 2078 8 than than IN 40436 2078 9 if if IN 40436 2078 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2078 11 cured cure VBD 40436 2078 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2078 13 body body NN 40436 2078 14 of of IN 40436 2078 15 a a DT 40436 2078 16 distemper distemper NN 40436 2078 17 . . . 40436 2079 1 But but CC 40436 2079 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2079 3 will will MD 40436 2079 4 be be VB 40436 2079 5 useless useless JJ 40436 2079 6 for for IN 40436 2079 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2079 8 to to TO 40436 2079 9 give give VB 40436 2079 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2079 11 one one CD 40436 2079 12 of of IN 40436 2079 13 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2079 14 long long JJ 40436 2079 15 discourses discourse NNS 40436 2079 16 : : : 40436 2079 17 for for IN 40436 2079 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2079 19 warn warn VBP 40436 2079 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2079 21 that that IN 40436 2079 22 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2079 23 can can MD 40436 2079 24 not not RB 40436 2079 25 follow follow VB 40436 2079 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2079 27 . . . 40436 2080 1 The the DT 40436 2080 2 only only JJ 40436 2080 3 way way NN 40436 2080 4 to to TO 40436 2080 5 confer confer VB 40436 2080 6 upon upon IN 40436 2080 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2080 8 real real JJ 40436 2080 9 service service NN 40436 2080 10 , , , 40436 2080 11 will will MD 40436 2080 12 be be VB 40436 2080 13 to to TO 40436 2080 14 answer answer VB 40436 2080 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2080 16 questions question NNS 40436 2080 17 again again RB 40436 2080 18 , , , 40436 2080 19 as as IN 40436 2080 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2080 21 have have VBP 40436 2080 22 hitherto hitherto VBN 40436 2080 23 done do VBN 40436 2080 24 . . . 40436 2081 1 Assist assist VB 40436 2081 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2081 3 , , , 40436 2081 4 Eudikus Eudikus NNP 40436 2081 5 , , , 40436 2081 6 in in IN 40436 2081 7 persuading persuade VBG 40436 2081 8 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2081 9 to to TO 40436 2081 10 do do VB 40436 2081 11 so so RB 40436 2081 12 . . . 40436 2082 1 Assistance assistance NN 40436 2082 2 from from IN 40436 2082 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2082 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2082 5 says say VBZ 40436 2082 6 Eudikus Eudikus NNP 40436 2082 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2082 8 will will MD 40436 2082 9 hardly hardly RB 40436 2082 10 be be VB 40436 2082 11 needed need VBN 40436 2082 12 , , , 40436 2082 13 for for IN 40436 2082 14 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2082 15 professed profess VBD 40436 2082 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2082 17 ready ready JJ 40436 2082 18 to to TO 40436 2082 19 answer answer VB 40436 2082 20 any any DT 40436 2082 21 man man NN 40436 2082 22 's 's POS 40436 2082 23 questions question NNS 40436 2082 24 . . . 40436 2083 1 Yes yes UH 40436 2083 2 -- -- : 40436 2083 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2083 4 did do VBD 40436 2083 5 so so RB 40436 2083 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2083 7 replies reply NNS 40436 2083 8 Hippias)--but Hippias)--but NNP 40436 2083 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2083 10 always always RB 40436 2083 11 brings bring VBZ 40436 2083 12 trouble trouble NN 40436 2083 13 into into IN 40436 2083 14 the the DT 40436 2083 15 debate debate NN 40436 2083 16 , , , 40436 2083 17 and and CC 40436 2083 18 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 2083 19 like like IN 40436 2083 20 one one CD 40436 2083 21 disposed dispose VBD 40436 2083 22 to to TO 40436 2083 23 do do VB 40436 2083 24 mischief mischief NN 40436 2083 25 . . . 40436 2084 1 Eudikus Eudikus NNP 40436 2084 2 repeats repeat VBZ 40436 2084 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2084 4 request request NN 40436 2084 5 , , , 40436 2084 6 and and CC 40436 2084 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2084 8 , , , 40436 2084 9 in in IN 40436 2084 10 deference deference NN 40436 2084 11 to to IN 40436 2084 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2084 13 , , , 40436 2084 14 consents consent NNS 40436 2084 15 to to TO 40436 2084 16 resume resume VB 40436 2084 17 the the DT 40436 2084 18 task task NN 40436 2084 19 of of IN 40436 2084 20 answering answering NN 40436 2084 21 . . . 40436 2085 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2085 2 61 61 CD 40436 2085 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2085 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2085 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2085 6 61 61 CD 40436 2085 7 : : : 40436 2085 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2085 9 . . . 40436 2086 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2086 2 . . . 40436 2087 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2087 2 . . . 40436 2088 1 373 373 CD 40436 2088 2 B. B. NNP 40436 2088 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2089 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2089 2 Side side NN 40436 2089 3 - - HYPH 40436 2089 4 note note NN 40436 2089 5 : : : 40436 2089 6 Questions question NNS 40436 2089 7 of of IN 40436 2089 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2089 9 -- -- : 40436 2089 10 multiplied multiply VBN 40436 2089 11 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2089 12 of of IN 40436 2089 13 the the DT 40436 2089 14 special special JJ 40436 2089 15 arts art NNS 40436 2089 16 . . . 40436 2090 1 The the DT 40436 2090 2 unskilful unskilful JJ 40436 2090 3 artist artist NN 40436 2090 4 , , , 40436 2090 5 who who WP 40436 2090 6 runs run VBZ 40436 2090 7 , , , 40436 2090 8 wrestles wrestle NNS 40436 2090 9 , , , 40436 2090 10 or or CC 40436 2090 11 sings sing VBZ 40436 2090 12 badly badly RB 40436 2090 13 , , , 40436 2090 14 whether whether IN 40436 2090 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2090 16 will will MD 40436 2090 17 or or CC 40436 2090 18 not not RB 40436 2090 19 , , , 40436 2090 20 is be VBZ 40436 2090 21 worse bad JJR 40436 2090 22 than than IN 40436 2090 23 the the DT 40436 2090 24 skilful skilful JJ 40436 2090 25 , , , 40436 2090 26 who who WP 40436 2090 27 can can MD 40436 2090 28 sing sing VB 40436 2090 29 well well RB 40436 2090 30 when when WRB 40436 2090 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2090 32 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2090 33 , , , 40436 2090 34 but but CC 40436 2090 35 can can MD 40436 2090 36 also also RB 40436 2090 37 sing sing VB 40436 2090 38 badly badly RB 40436 2090 39 when when WRB 40436 2090 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2090 41 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2090 42 . . . 40436 2090 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2091 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2091 2 then then RB 40436 2091 3 produces produce VBZ 40436 2091 4 a a DT 40436 2091 5 string string NN 40436 2091 6 of of IN 40436 2091 7 questions question NNS 40436 2091 8 , , , 40436 2091 9 with with IN 40436 2091 10 a a DT 40436 2091 11 view view NN 40436 2091 12 to to TO 40436 2091 13 show show VB 40436 2091 14 that that IN 40436 2091 15 those those DT 40436 2091 16 who who WP 40436 2091 17 do do VBP 40436 2091 18 wrong wrong NN 40436 2091 19 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2091 20 , , , 40436 2091 21 are be VBP 40436 2091 22 better well JJR 40436 2091 23 than than IN 40436 2091 24 those those DT 40436 2091 25 who who WP 40436 2091 26 do do VBP 40436 2091 27 wrong wrong NN 40436 2091 28 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2091 29 . . . 40436 2092 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2092 2 appeals appeal VBZ 40436 2092 3 to to IN 40436 2092 4 various various JJ 40436 2092 5 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2092 6 . . . 40436 2093 1 In in IN 40436 2093 2 running run VBG 40436 2093 3 , , , 40436 2093 4 the the DT 40436 2093 5 good good JJ 40436 2093 6 runner runner NN 40436 2093 7 is be VBZ 40436 2093 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2093 9 who who WP 40436 2093 10 runs run VBZ 40436 2093 11 quickly quickly RB 40436 2093 12 , , , 40436 2093 13 the the DT 40436 2093 14 bad bad JJ 40436 2093 15 runner runner NN 40436 2093 16 is be VBZ 40436 2093 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2093 18 who who WP 40436 2093 19 runs run VBZ 40436 2093 20 slowly slowly RB 40436 2093 21 . . . 40436 2094 1 What what WP 40436 2094 2 is be VBZ 40436 2094 3 evil evil JJ 40436 2094 4 and and CC 40436 2094 5 base base NN 40436 2094 6 in in IN 40436 2094 7 running running NN 40436 2094 8 is be VBZ 40436 2094 9 , , , 40436 2094 10 to to TO 40436 2094 11 run run VB 40436 2094 12 slowly slowly RB 40436 2094 13 . . . 40436 2095 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2095 2 is be VBZ 40436 2095 3 the the DT 40436 2095 4 good good JJ 40436 2095 5 runner runner NN 40436 2095 6 who who WP 40436 2095 7 does do VBZ 40436 2095 8 this this DT 40436 2095 9 evil evil NN 40436 2095 10 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2095 11 : : : 40436 2095 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2095 13 is be VBZ 40436 2095 14 the the DT 40436 2095 15 bad bad JJ 40436 2095 16 runner runner NN 40436 2095 17 who who WP 40436 2095 18 does do VBZ 40436 2095 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2095 20 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2095 21 . . . 40436 2096 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2096 2 62 62 CD 40436 2096 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2096 4 The the DT 40436 2096 5 like like NN 40436 2096 6 is be VBZ 40436 2096 7 true true JJ 40436 2096 8 about about IN 40436 2096 9 wrestling wrestling NN 40436 2096 10 and and CC 40436 2096 11 other other JJ 40436 2096 12 bodily bodily JJ 40436 2096 13 exercises exercise NNS 40436 2096 14 . . . 40436 2097 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2097 2 that that DT 40436 2097 3 is be VBZ 40436 2097 4 good good JJ 40436 2097 5 in in IN 40436 2097 6 the the DT 40436 2097 7 body body NN 40436 2097 8 , , , 40436 2097 9 can can MD 40436 2097 10 work work VB 40436 2097 11 either either CC 40436 2097 12 strongly strongly RB 40436 2097 13 or or CC 40436 2097 14 feebly,--can feebly,--can NNP 40436 2097 15 do do VBP 40436 2097 16 either either CC 40436 2097 17 what what WP 40436 2097 18 is be VBZ 40436 2097 19 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2097 20 or or CC 40436 2097 21 what what WP 40436 2097 22 is be VBZ 40436 2097 23 base base NN 40436 2097 24 ; ; : 40436 2097 25 so so IN 40436 2097 26 that that IN 40436 2097 27 when when WRB 40436 2097 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2097 29 does do VBZ 40436 2097 30 what what WP 40436 2097 31 is be VBZ 40436 2097 32 base base NN 40436 2097 33 , , , 40436 2097 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2097 35 does do VBZ 40436 2097 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2097 37 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2097 38 . . . 40436 2098 1 But but CC 40436 2098 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2098 3 that that DT 40436 2098 4 is be VBZ 40436 2098 5 bad bad JJ 40436 2098 6 in in IN 40436 2098 7 the the DT 40436 2098 8 body body NN 40436 2098 9 does do VBZ 40436 2098 10 what what WP 40436 2098 11 is be VBZ 40436 2098 12 base base NN 40436 2098 13 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2098 14 , , , 40436 2098 15 not not RB 40436 2098 16 being be VBG 40436 2098 17 able able JJ 40436 2098 18 to to TO 40436 2098 19 help help VB 40436 2098 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2098 21 . . . 40436 2099 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2099 2 63 63 CD 40436 2099 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2099 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2099 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2099 6 62 62 CD 40436 2099 7 : : : 40436 2099 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2099 9 . . . 40436 2100 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2100 2 . . . 40436 2101 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2101 2 . . . 40436 2102 1 373 373 CD 40436 2102 2 D D NNP 40436 2102 3 - - HYPH 40436 2102 4 E. e. NN 40436 2102 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2102 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2102 7 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2102 8 63 63 CD 40436 2102 9 : : : 40436 2102 10 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2102 11 . . . 40436 2103 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2103 2 . . . 40436 2104 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2104 2 . . . 40436 2105 1 374 374 CD 40436 2105 2 B. B. NNP 40436 2105 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2106 1 What what WP 40436 2106 2 is be VBZ 40436 2106 3 true true JJ 40436 2106 4 about about IN 40436 2106 5 the the DT 40436 2106 6 bodily bodily JJ 40436 2106 7 movements movement NNS 40436 2106 8 depending depend VBG 40436 2106 9 upon upon IN 40436 2106 10 strength strength NN 40436 2106 11 , , , 40436 2106 12 is be VBZ 40436 2106 13 not not RB 40436 2106 14 less less RBR 40436 2106 15 true true JJ 40436 2106 16 about about IN 40436 2106 17 those those DT 40436 2106 18 depending depend VBG 40436 2106 19 on on IN 40436 2106 20 grace grace NN 40436 2106 21 and and CC 40436 2106 22 elegance elegance NN 40436 2106 23 . . . 40436 2107 1 To to TO 40436 2107 2 be be VB 40436 2107 3 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2107 4 ungraceful ungraceful JJ 40436 2107 5 , , , 40436 2107 6 belongs belong VBZ 40436 2107 7 only only RB 40436 2107 8 to to IN 40436 2107 9 the the DT 40436 2107 10 well well RB 40436 2107 11 - - HYPH 40436 2107 12 constituted constitute VBN 40436 2107 13 body body NN 40436 2107 14 : : : 40436 2107 15 none none NN 40436 2107 16 but but CC 40436 2107 17 the the DT 40436 2107 18 badly badly RB 40436 2107 19 - - HYPH 40436 2107 20 constituted constitute VBN 40436 2107 21 body body NN 40436 2107 22 is be VBZ 40436 2107 23 ungraceful ungraceful JJ 40436 2107 24 without without IN 40436 2107 25 wishing wish VBG 40436 2107 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2107 27 . . . 40436 2108 1 The the DT 40436 2108 2 same same JJ 40436 2108 3 , , , 40436 2108 4 also also RB 40436 2108 5 , , , 40436 2108 6 about about IN 40436 2108 7 the the DT 40436 2108 8 feet foot NNS 40436 2108 9 , , , 40436 2108 10 voice voice NN 40436 2108 11 , , , 40436 2108 12 eyes eye NNS 40436 2108 13 , , , 40436 2108 14 ears ear NNS 40436 2108 15 , , , 40436 2108 16 nose nose NN 40436 2108 17 : : : 40436 2108 18 of of IN 40436 2108 19 these these DT 40436 2108 20 organs organ NNS 40436 2108 21 , , , 40436 2108 22 those those DT 40436 2108 23 which which WDT 40436 2108 24 act act VBP 40436 2108 25 badly badly RB 40436 2108 26 through through IN 40436 2108 27 will will NN 40436 2108 28 and and CC 40436 2108 29 intention intention NN 40436 2108 30 , , , 40436 2108 31 are be VBP 40436 2108 32 preferable preferable JJ 40436 2108 33 to to IN 40436 2108 34 those those DT 40436 2108 35 which which WDT 40436 2108 36 act act VBP 40436 2108 37 badly badly RB 40436 2108 38 without without IN 40436 2108 39 will will NN 40436 2108 40 or or CC 40436 2108 41 intention intention VB 40436 2108 42 . . . 40436 2109 1 Lameness lameness NN 40436 2109 2 of of IN 40436 2109 3 feet foot NNS 40436 2109 4 is be VBZ 40436 2109 5 a a DT 40436 2109 6 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 2109 7 and and CC 40436 2109 8 disgrace disgrace NN 40436 2109 9 : : : 40436 2109 10 feet foot NNS 40436 2109 11 which which WDT 40436 2109 12 go go VBP 40436 2109 13 lame lame JJ 40436 2109 14 only only RB 40436 2109 15 by by IN 40436 2109 16 intention intention NN 40436 2109 17 are be VBP 40436 2109 18 much much JJ 40436 2109 19 to to TO 40436 2109 20 be be VB 40436 2109 21 preferred prefer VBN 40436 2109 22 . . . 40436 2110 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2110 2 64 64 CD 40436 2110 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2110 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2110 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2110 6 64 64 CD 40436 2110 7 : : : 40436 2110 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2110 9 . . . 40436 2111 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2111 2 . . . 40436 2112 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2112 2 . . . 40436 2113 1 374 374 CD 40436 2113 2 C C NNP 40436 2113 3 - - HYPH 40436 2113 4 D. D. NNP 40436 2113 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2113 6 Again again RB 40436 2113 7 , , , 40436 2113 8 in in IN 40436 2113 9 the the DT 40436 2113 10 instruments instrument NNS 40436 2113 11 which which WDT 40436 2113 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2113 13 use use VBP 40436 2113 14 , , , 40436 2113 15 a a DT 40436 2113 16 rudder rudder NN 40436 2113 17 or or CC 40436 2113 18 a a DT 40436 2113 19 bow,--or bow,--or NN 40436 2113 20 the the DT 40436 2113 21 animals animal NNS 40436 2113 22 about about IN 40436 2113 23 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2113 24 , , , 40436 2113 25 horses horse NNS 40436 2113 26 or or CC 40436 2113 27 dogs,--those dogs,--those NNP 40436 2113 28 are be VBP 40436 2113 29 better well JJR 40436 2113 30 with with IN 40436 2113 31 which which WDT 40436 2113 32 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2113 33 work work VBP 40436 2113 34 badly badly RB 40436 2113 35 when when WRB 40436 2113 36 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2113 37 choose choose VBP 40436 2113 38 ; ; : 40436 2113 39 those those DT 40436 2113 40 are be VBP 40436 2113 41 worse bad JJR 40436 2113 42 , , , 40436 2113 43 with with IN 40436 2113 44 which which WDT 40436 2113 45 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2113 46 work work VBP 40436 2113 47 badly badly RB 40436 2113 48 without without IN 40436 2113 49 design design NN 40436 2113 50 , , , 40436 2113 51 and and CC 40436 2113 52 contrary contrary JJ 40436 2113 53 to to IN 40436 2113 54 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2113 55 own own JJ 40436 2113 56 wishes wish NNS 40436 2113 57 . . . 40436 2114 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2114 2 Side side NN 40436 2114 3 - - HYPH 40436 2114 4 note note NN 40436 2114 5 : : : 40436 2114 6 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2114 7 is be VBZ 40436 2114 8 better well JJR 40436 2114 9 to to TO 40436 2114 10 have have VB 40436 2114 11 the the DT 40436 2114 12 mind mind NN 40436 2114 13 of of IN 40436 2114 14 a a DT 40436 2114 15 bowman bowman NN 40436 2114 16 who who WP 40436 2114 17 misses miss VBZ 40436 2114 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2114 19 mark mark NN 40436 2114 20 only only RB 40436 2114 21 by by IN 40436 2114 22 design design NN 40436 2114 23 , , , 40436 2114 24 than than IN 40436 2114 25 that that DT 40436 2114 26 of of IN 40436 2114 27 one one NN 40436 2114 28 who who WP 40436 2114 29 misses miss VBZ 40436 2114 30 even even RB 40436 2114 31 when when WRB 40436 2114 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2114 33 intends intend VBZ 40436 2114 34 to to TO 40436 2114 35 hit hit VB 40436 2114 36 . . . 40436 2114 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2115 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2115 2 is be VBZ 40436 2115 3 better well JJR 40436 2115 4 to to TO 40436 2115 5 have have VB 40436 2115 6 the the DT 40436 2115 7 mind mind NN 40436 2115 8 of of IN 40436 2115 9 a a DT 40436 2115 10 bowman bowman NN 40436 2115 11 who who WP 40436 2115 12 misses miss VBZ 40436 2115 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2115 14 mark mark NN 40436 2115 15 by by IN 40436 2115 16 design design NN 40436 2115 17 , , , 40436 2115 18 than than IN 40436 2115 19 that that DT 40436 2115 20 of of IN 40436 2115 21 one one NN 40436 2115 22 who who WP 40436 2115 23 misses miss VBZ 40436 2115 24 when when WRB 40436 2115 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2115 26 tries try VBZ 40436 2115 27 to to TO 40436 2115 28 hit hit VB 40436 2115 29 . . . 40436 2116 1 The the DT 40436 2116 2 like like JJ 40436 2116 3 about about IN 40436 2116 4 all all DT 40436 2116 5 other other JJ 40436 2116 6 arts art NNS 40436 2116 7 -- -- : 40436 2116 8 the the DT 40436 2116 9 physician physician NN 40436 2116 10 , , , 40436 2116 11 the the DT 40436 2116 12 harper harper NN 40436 2116 13 , , , 40436 2116 14 the the DT 40436 2116 15 flute flute NN 40436 2116 16 - - HYPH 40436 2116 17 player player NN 40436 2116 18 . . . 40436 2117 1 In in IN 40436 2117 2 each each DT 40436 2117 3 of of IN 40436 2117 4 these these DT 40436 2117 5 artists artist NNS 40436 2117 6 , , , 40436 2117 7 _ _ NNP 40436 2117 8 that that IN 40436 2117 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2117 10 mind mind NN 40436 2117 11 is be VBZ 40436 2117 12 better well JJR 40436 2117 13 , , , 40436 2117 14 which which WDT 40436 2117 15 goes go VBZ 40436 2117 16 wrong wrong JJ 40436 2117 17 only only RB 40436 2117 18 wilfully--_that wilfully--_that WDT 40436 2117 19 _ _ NNP 40436 2117 20 mind mind NN 40436 2117 21 is be VBZ 40436 2117 22 worse bad JJR 40436 2117 23 , , , 40436 2117 24 which which WDT 40436 2117 25 goes go VBZ 40436 2117 26 wrong wrong JJ 40436 2117 27 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2117 28 , , , 40436 2117 29 while while IN 40436 2117 30 wishing wish VBG 40436 2117 31 to to TO 40436 2117 32 go go VB 40436 2117 33 right right RB 40436 2117 34 . . . 40436 2118 1 In in IN 40436 2118 2 regard regard NN 40436 2118 3 to to IN 40436 2118 4 the the DT 40436 2118 5 minds mind NNS 40436 2118 6 of of IN 40436 2118 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2118 8 slaves slave NNS 40436 2118 9 , , , 40436 2118 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2118 11 should should MD 40436 2118 12 all all RB 40436 2118 13 prefer prefer VB 40436 2118 14 those those DT 40436 2118 15 which which WDT 40436 2118 16 go go VBP 40436 2118 17 wrong wrong RB 40436 2118 18 only only RB 40436 2118 19 when when WRB 40436 2118 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2118 21 choose choose VBP 40436 2118 22 , , , 40436 2118 23 to to IN 40436 2118 24 those those DT 40436 2118 25 which which WDT 40436 2118 26 go go VBP 40436 2118 27 wrong wrong JJ 40436 2118 28 without without IN 40436 2118 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2118 30 own own JJ 40436 2118 31 choice choice NN 40436 2118 32 . . . 40436 2119 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2119 2 65 65 CD 40436 2119 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2119 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2119 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2119 6 65 65 CD 40436 2119 7 : : : 40436 2119 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2119 9 . . . 40436 2120 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2120 2 . . . 40436 2121 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2121 2 . . . 40436 2122 1 376 376 CD 40436 2122 2 B B NNP 40436 2122 3 - - HYPH 40436 2122 4 D. D. NNP 40436 2122 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2122 6 Having have VBG 40436 2122 7 carried carry VBN 40436 2122 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2122 9 examination examination NN 40436 2122 10 through through IN 40436 2122 11 this this DT 40436 2122 12 string string NN 40436 2122 13 of of IN 40436 2122 14 analogous analogous JJ 40436 2122 15 particulars particular NNS 40436 2122 16 , , , 40436 2122 17 and and CC 40436 2122 18 having have VBG 40436 2122 19 obtained obtain VBN 40436 2122 20 from from IN 40436 2122 21 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2122 22 successive successive JJ 40436 2122 23 answers--"Yes answers--"Yes NNP 40436 2122 24 -- -- : 40436 2122 25 true true JJ 40436 2122 26 in in IN 40436 2122 27 that that DT 40436 2122 28 particular particular JJ 40436 2122 29 case case NN 40436 2122 30 , , , 40436 2122 31 " " `` 40436 2122 32 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2122 33 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 2122 34 to to TO 40436 2122 35 sum sum VB 40436 2122 36 up up RP 40436 2122 37 the the DT 40436 2122 38 result:-- result:-- CD 40436 2122 39 _ _ NNP 40436 2122 40 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 2122 41 ! ! . 40436 2123 1 should should MD 40436 2123 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2123 3 not not RB 40436 2123 4 wish wish VB 40436 2123 5 to to TO 40436 2123 6 have have VB 40436 2123 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2123 8 own own JJ 40436 2123 9 minds mind NNS 40436 2123 10 as as RB 40436 2123 11 good good JJ 40436 2123 12 as as IN 40436 2123 13 possible possible JJ 40436 2123 14 ? ? . 40436 2124 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2124 2 Hip._--Yes Hip._--Yes NNP 40436 2124 3 . . . 40436 2125 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2125 2 Sokr._--We Sokr._--We NNP 40436 2125 3 have have VBP 40436 2125 4 seen see VBN 40436 2125 5 that that IN 40436 2125 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2125 7 will will MD 40436 2125 8 be be VB 40436 2125 9 better well JJR 40436 2125 10 if if IN 40436 2125 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2125 12 do do VBP 40436 2125 13 mischief mischief NN 40436 2125 14 and and CC 40436 2125 15 go go VB 40436 2125 16 wrong wrong NN 40436 2125 17 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2125 18 , , , 40436 2125 19 than than IN 40436 2125 20 if if IN 40436 2125 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2125 22 do do VBP 40436 2125 23 so so RB 40436 2125 24 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2125 25 ? ? . 40436 2126 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2126 2 Hip._--But Hip._--But NNP 40436 2126 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2126 4 will will MD 40436 2126 5 be be VB 40436 2126 6 dreadful dreadful JJ 40436 2126 7 , , , 40436 2126 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2126 9 , , , 40436 2126 10 if if IN 40436 2126 11 the the DT 40436 2126 12 willing willing JJ 40436 2126 13 wrong wrong NN 40436 2126 14 - - HYPH 40436 2126 15 doers doer NNS 40436 2126 16 are be VBP 40436 2126 17 to to TO 40436 2126 18 pass pass VB 40436 2126 19 for for IN 40436 2126 20 better well JJR 40436 2126 21 men man NNS 40436 2126 22 than than IN 40436 2126 23 the the DT 40436 2126 24 unwilling unwilling NN 40436 2126 25 . . . 40436 2127 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2127 2 Side side NN 40436 2127 3 - - HYPH 40436 2127 4 note note NN 40436 2127 5 : : : 40436 2127 6 Dissent dissent NN 40436 2127 7 and and CC 40436 2127 8 repugnance repugnance NN 40436 2127 9 of of IN 40436 2127 10 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2127 11 . . . 40436 2127 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2128 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2128 2 Sokr._--Nevertheless Sokr._--Nevertheless NNP 40436 2128 3 -- -- : 40436 2128 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2128 5 seems seem VBZ 40436 2128 6 so so RB 40436 2128 7 : : : 40436 2128 8 from from IN 40436 2128 9 what what WP 40436 2128 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2128 11 have have VBP 40436 2128 12 said say VBD 40436 2128 13 . . . 40436 2129 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2129 2 Hip._--It Hip._--It NNP 40436 2129 3 does do VBZ 40436 2129 4 not not RB 40436 2129 5 seem seem VB 40436 2129 6 so so RB 40436 2129 7 to to IN 40436 2129 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2129 9 . . . 40436 2130 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2130 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 2130 3 thought think VBD 40436 2130 4 that that IN 40436 2130 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2130 6 would would MD 40436 2130 7 have have VB 40436 2130 8 seemed seem VBN 40436 2130 9 so so RB 40436 2130 10 to to IN 40436 2130 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2130 12 , , , 40436 2130 13 as as IN 40436 2130 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2130 15 does do VBZ 40436 2130 16 to to IN 40436 2130 17 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2130 18 . . . 40436 2131 1 However however RB 40436 2131 2 , , , 40436 2131 3 answer answer VB 40436 2131 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2131 5 once once RB 40436 2131 6 more more RBR 40436 2131 7 -- -- : 40436 2131 8 Is be VBZ 40436 2131 9 not not RB 40436 2131 10 justice justice NN 40436 2131 11 either either CC 40436 2131 12 a a DT 40436 2131 13 certain certain JJ 40436 2131 14 mental mental JJ 40436 2131 15 capacity capacity NN 40436 2131 16 ? ? . 40436 2132 1 or or CC 40436 2132 2 else else JJ 40436 2132 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2132 4 ? ? . 40436 2133 1 or or CC 40436 2133 2 both both CC 40436 2133 3 together together RB 40436 2133 4 ? ? . 40436 2134 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2134 2 66 66 CD 40436 2134 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2134 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2134 5 Hip._--Yes Hip._--Yes NNP 40436 2134 6 ! ! . 40436 2135 1 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2135 2 is be VBZ 40436 2135 3 . . . 40436 2136 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2136 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 2136 3 justice justice NN 40436 2136 4 be be VB 40436 2136 5 a a DT 40436 2136 6 capacity capacity NN 40436 2136 7 of of IN 40436 2136 8 the the DT 40436 2136 9 mind mind NN 40436 2136 10 , , , 40436 2136 11 the the DT 40436 2136 12 more more RBR 40436 2136 13 capable capable JJ 40436 2136 14 mind mind NN 40436 2136 15 will will MD 40436 2136 16 also also RB 40436 2136 17 be be VB 40436 2136 18 the the DT 40436 2136 19 juster juster NN 40436 2136 20 : : : 40436 2136 21 and and CC 40436 2136 22 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2136 23 have have VBP 40436 2136 24 already already RB 40436 2136 25 seen see VBN 40436 2136 26 that that IN 40436 2136 27 the the DT 40436 2136 28 more more RBR 40436 2136 29 capable capable JJ 40436 2136 30 soul soul NN 40436 2136 31 is be VBZ 40436 2136 32 the the DT 40436 2136 33 better well JJR 40436 2136 34 . . . 40436 2137 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2137 2 Hip._--We Hip._--We NNP 40436 2137 3 have have VBP 40436 2137 4 . . . 40436 2138 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2138 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 2138 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2138 4 be be VB 40436 2138 5 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2138 6 , , , 40436 2138 7 the the DT 40436 2138 8 more more RBR 40436 2138 9 knowing knowing JJ 40436 2138 10 or or CC 40436 2138 11 wiser wise JJR 40436 2138 12 mind mind NN 40436 2138 13 will will MD 40436 2138 14 of of IN 40436 2138 15 course course NN 40436 2138 16 be be VB 40436 2138 17 the the DT 40436 2138 18 juster juster NN 40436 2138 19 : : : 40436 2138 20 if if IN 40436 2138 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2138 22 be be VB 40436 2138 23 a a DT 40436 2138 24 combination combination NN 40436 2138 25 of of IN 40436 2138 26 both both DT 40436 2138 27 capacity capacity NN 40436 2138 28 and and CC 40436 2138 29 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2138 30 , , , 40436 2138 31 that that DT 40436 2138 32 mind mind NN 40436 2138 33 which which WDT 40436 2138 34 is be VBZ 40436 2138 35 more more RBR 40436 2138 36 capable capable JJ 40436 2138 37 as as RB 40436 2138 38 well well RB 40436 2138 39 as as IN 40436 2138 40 more more JJR 40436 2138 41 knowing,--will knowing,--will NNP 40436 2138 42 be be VB 40436 2138 43 the the DT 40436 2138 44 juster juster NN 40436 2138 45 that that IN 40436 2138 46 which which WDT 40436 2138 47 is be VBZ 40436 2138 48 less less RBR 40436 2138 49 capable capable JJ 40436 2138 50 and and CC 40436 2138 51 less less RBR 40436 2138 52 knowing knowing JJ 40436 2138 53 , , , 40436 2138 54 will will MD 40436 2138 55 be be VB 40436 2138 56 the the DT 40436 2138 57 more more RBR 40436 2138 58 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2138 59 . . . 40436 2139 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2139 2 Hip._--So Hip._--So NNP 40436 2139 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2139 4 appears appear VBZ 40436 2139 5 . . . 40436 2140 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2140 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 2140 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2140 4 have have VBP 40436 2140 5 shown show VBN 40436 2140 6 that that IN 40436 2140 7 the the DT 40436 2140 8 more more RBR 40436 2140 9 capable capable JJ 40436 2140 10 and and CC 40436 2140 11 knowing knowing JJ 40436 2140 12 mind mind NN 40436 2140 13 is be VBZ 40436 2140 14 at at IN 40436 2140 15 once once IN 40436 2140 16 the the DT 40436 2140 17 better well JJR 40436 2140 18 mind mind NN 40436 2140 19 , , , 40436 2140 20 and and CC 40436 2140 21 more more RBR 40436 2140 22 competent competent JJ 40436 2140 23 to to TO 40436 2140 24 exert exert VB 40436 2140 25 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 2140 26 both both DT 40436 2140 27 ways way NNS 40436 2140 28 -- -- : 40436 2140 29 to to TO 40436 2140 30 do do VB 40436 2140 31 what what WP 40436 2140 32 is be VBZ 40436 2140 33 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2140 34 as as RB 40436 2140 35 well well RB 40436 2140 36 as as IN 40436 2140 37 what what WP 40436 2140 38 is be VBZ 40436 2140 39 base base NN 40436 2140 40 -- -- : 40436 2140 41 in in IN 40436 2140 42 every every DT 40436 2140 43 employment employment NN 40436 2140 44 . . . 40436 2141 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2141 2 Hip._--Yes Hip._--Yes NNP 40436 2141 3 . . . 40436 2142 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2142 2 Sokr._--When Sokr._--When NNP 40436 2142 3 , , , 40436 2142 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 2142 5 , , , 40436 2142 6 such such PDT 40436 2142 7 a a DT 40436 2142 8 mind mind NN 40436 2142 9 does do VBZ 40436 2142 10 what what WP 40436 2142 11 is be VBZ 40436 2142 12 base base NN 40436 2142 13 , , , 40436 2142 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2142 15 does do VBZ 40436 2142 16 so so RB 40436 2142 17 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2142 18 , , , 40436 2142 19 through through IN 40436 2142 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2142 21 capacity capacity NN 40436 2142 22 or or CC 40436 2142 23 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2142 24 , , , 40436 2142 25 which which WDT 40436 2142 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2142 27 have have VBP 40436 2142 28 seen see VBN 40436 2142 29 to to TO 40436 2142 30 be be VB 40436 2142 31 of of IN 40436 2142 32 the the DT 40436 2142 33 nature nature NN 40436 2142 34 of of IN 40436 2142 35 justice justice NN 40436 2142 36 ? ? . 40436 2143 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2143 2 Hip._--It Hip._--It NNP 40436 2143 3 seems seem VBZ 40436 2143 4 so so RB 40436 2143 5 . . . 40436 2144 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2144 2 Sokr._--Doing Sokr._--Doing NNP 40436 2144 3 base base NN 40436 2144 4 things thing NNS 40436 2144 5 , , , 40436 2144 6 is be VBZ 40436 2144 7 acting act VBG 40436 2144 8 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 2144 9 : : : 40436 2144 10 doing do VBG 40436 2144 11 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2144 12 things thing NNS 40436 2144 13 , , , 40436 2144 14 is be VBZ 40436 2144 15 acting act VBG 40436 2144 16 justly justly RB 40436 2144 17 . . . 40436 2145 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 2145 2 , , , 40436 2145 3 when when WRB 40436 2145 4 this this DT 40436 2145 5 more more RBR 40436 2145 6 capable capable JJ 40436 2145 7 and and CC 40436 2145 8 better well JJR 40436 2145 9 mind mind NN 40436 2145 10 acts act VBZ 40436 2145 11 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 2145 12 , , , 40436 2145 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2145 14 will will MD 40436 2145 15 do do VB 40436 2145 16 so so RB 40436 2145 17 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2145 18 ; ; : 40436 2145 19 while while IN 40436 2145 20 the the DT 40436 2145 21 less less RBR 40436 2145 22 capable capable JJ 40436 2145 23 and and CC 40436 2145 24 worse bad JJR 40436 2145 25 mind mind NN 40436 2145 26 will will MD 40436 2145 27 do do VB 40436 2145 28 so so RB 40436 2145 29 without without IN 40436 2145 30 willing will VBG 40436 2145 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2145 32 ? ? . 40436 2146 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2146 2 Hip._--Apparently Hip._--Apparently NNP 40436 2146 3 . . . 40436 2147 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2147 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2147 3 66 66 CD 40436 2147 4 : : : 40436 2147 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2147 6 . . . 40436 2148 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2148 2 . . . 40436 2149 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2149 2 . . . 40436 2150 1 375 375 CD 40436 2150 2 D. D. NNP 40436 2150 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2150 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2150 5 : : : 40436 2150 6 ê ê NNP 40436 2150 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2150 8 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 2150 9 / / SYM 40436 2150 10 nê nê NNP 40436 2150 11 ou)chi ou)chi NNP 40436 2150 12 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 2150 13 du du NNP 40436 2150 14 / / SYM 40436 2150 15 nami nami NNP 40436 2150 16 / / SYM 40436 2150 17 s s NNP 40436 2150 18 ti ti NNP 40436 2150 19 / / SYM 40436 2150 20 s s NNP 40436 2150 21 e)stin e)stin NNP 40436 2150 22 , , , 40436 2150 23 ê)\ ê)\ ADD 40436 2150 24 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 2150 25 / / SYM 40436 2150 26 mê mê NNP 40436 2150 27 , , , 40436 2150 28 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 2150 29 a)mpho a)mpho NNP 40436 2150 30 / / SYM 40436 2150 31 tera tera NN 40436 2150 32 ? ? . 40436 2150 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2150 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2151 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2151 2 Side side NN 40436 2151 3 - - HYPH 40436 2151 4 note note NN 40436 2151 5 : : : 40436 2151 6 Conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2151 7 -- -- : 40436 2151 8 That that IN 40436 2151 9 none none NN 40436 2151 10 but but CC 40436 2151 11 the the DT 40436 2151 12 good good JJ 40436 2151 13 man man NN 40436 2151 14 can can MD 40436 2151 15 do do VB 40436 2151 16 evil evil NN 40436 2151 17 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2151 18 : : : 40436 2151 19 the the DT 40436 2151 20 bad bad JJ 40436 2151 21 man man NN 40436 2151 22 does do VBZ 40436 2151 23 evil evil NN 40436 2151 24 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2151 25 . . . 40436 2152 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2152 2 can can MD 40436 2152 3 not not RB 40436 2152 4 resist resist VB 40436 2152 5 the the DT 40436 2152 6 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2152 7 , , , 40436 2152 8 but but CC 40436 2152 9 will will MD 40436 2152 10 not not RB 40436 2152 11 accept accept VB 40436 2152 12 the the DT 40436 2152 13 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2152 14 -- -- : 40436 2152 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2152 16 confesses confess VBZ 40436 2152 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2152 18 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 2152 19 . . . 40436 2152 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2153 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2153 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 2153 3 the the DT 40436 2153 4 good good JJ 40436 2153 5 man man NN 40436 2153 6 is be VBZ 40436 2153 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2153 8 that that WDT 40436 2153 9 has have VBZ 40436 2153 10 the the DT 40436 2153 11 good good JJ 40436 2153 12 mind mind NN 40436 2153 13 : : : 40436 2153 14 the the DT 40436 2153 15 bad bad JJ 40436 2153 16 man man NN 40436 2153 17 is be VBZ 40436 2153 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2153 19 that that WDT 40436 2153 20 has have VBZ 40436 2153 21 the the DT 40436 2153 22 bad bad JJ 40436 2153 23 mind mind NN 40436 2153 24 . . . 40436 2154 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2154 2 belongs belong VBZ 40436 2154 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 2154 4 to to IN 40436 2154 5 the the DT 40436 2154 6 good good JJ 40436 2154 7 man man NN 40436 2154 8 to to TO 40436 2154 9 do do VB 40436 2154 10 wrong wrong NN 40436 2154 11 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2154 12 , , , 40436 2154 13 to to IN 40436 2154 14 the the DT 40436 2154 15 bad bad JJ 40436 2154 16 man man NN 40436 2154 17 , , , 40436 2154 18 to to TO 40436 2154 19 do do VB 40436 2154 20 wrong wrong NN 40436 2154 21 without without IN 40436 2154 22 wishing wish VBG 40436 2154 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2154 24 -- -- : 40436 2154 25 that that RB 40436 2154 26 is is RB 40436 2154 27 , , , 40436 2154 28 if if IN 40436 2154 29 the the DT 40436 2154 30 good good JJ 40436 2154 31 man man NN 40436 2154 32 be be VB 40436 2154 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2154 34 that that DT 40436 2154 35 has have VBZ 40436 2154 36 the the DT 40436 2154 37 good good JJ 40436 2154 38 mind mind NN 40436 2154 39 ? ? . 40436 2155 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2155 2 Hip._--But Hip._--But NNP 40436 2155 3 that that WDT 40436 2155 4 is be VBZ 40436 2155 5 unquestionable unquestionable JJ 40436 2155 6 -- -- : 40436 2155 7 that that IN 40436 2155 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2155 9 has have VBZ 40436 2155 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2155 11 . . . 40436 2156 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2156 2 Sokr._--Accordingly Sokr._--Accordingly NNP 40436 2156 3 , , , 40436 2156 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2156 5 that that WDT 40436 2156 6 goes go VBZ 40436 2156 7 wrong wrong JJ 40436 2156 8 and and CC 40436 2156 9 does do VBZ 40436 2156 10 base base NN 40436 2156 11 and and CC 40436 2156 12 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2156 13 things thing NNS 40436 2156 14 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2156 15 , , , 40436 2156 16 if if IN 40436 2156 17 there there EX 40436 2156 18 be be VB 40436 2156 19 any any DT 40436 2156 20 such such JJ 40436 2156 21 character character NN 40436 2156 22 -- -- : 40436 2156 23 can can MD 40436 2156 24 be be VB 40436 2156 25 no no DT 40436 2156 26 other other JJ 40436 2156 27 than than IN 40436 2156 28 the the DT 40436 2156 29 good good JJ 40436 2156 30 man man NN 40436 2156 31 . . . 40436 2157 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2157 2 Hip._--I Hip._--I NNP 40436 2157 3 do do VBP 40436 2157 4 not not RB 40436 2157 5 know know VB 40436 2157 6 how how WRB 40436 2157 7 to to TO 40436 2157 8 concede concede VB 40436 2157 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2157 10 that that IN 40436 2157 11 _ _ NNP 40436 2157 12 to to IN 40436 2157 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2157 14 , , , 40436 2157 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2157 16 . . . 40436 2158 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2158 2 67 67 CD 40436 2158 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2158 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2158 5 Sokr._--Nor Sokr._--Nor NNP 40436 2158 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2158 7 , , , 40436 2158 8 how how WRB 40436 2158 9 to to TO 40436 2158 10 concede concede VB 40436 2158 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2158 12 to to IN 40436 2158 13 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 2158 14 , , , 40436 2158 15 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2158 16 : : : 40436 2158 17 yet yet CC 40436 2158 18 so so IN 40436 2158 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2158 20 must must MD 40436 2158 21 appear appear VB 40436 2158 22 to to IN 40436 2158 23 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2158 24 , , , 40436 2158 25 now now RB 40436 2158 26 at at IN 40436 2158 27 least least JJS 40436 2158 28 , , , 40436 2158 29 from from IN 40436 2158 30 the the DT 40436 2158 31 past past JJ 40436 2158 32 debate debate NN 40436 2158 33 . . . 40436 2159 1 As as IN 40436 2159 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2159 3 told tell VBD 40436 2159 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2159 5 long long RB 40436 2159 6 ago ago RB 40436 2159 7 , , , 40436 2159 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2159 9 waver waver VBP 40436 2159 10 hither hither NN 40436 2159 11 and and CC 40436 2159 12 thither thither NN 40436 2159 13 upon upon IN 40436 2159 14 this this DT 40436 2159 15 matter matter NN 40436 2159 16 ; ; : 40436 2159 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2159 18 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 2159 19 never never RB 40436 2159 20 remain remain VBP 40436 2159 21 the the DT 40436 2159 22 same same JJ 40436 2159 23 . . . 40436 2160 1 No no DT 40436 2160 2 wonder wonder NN 40436 2160 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 2160 4 that that IN 40436 2160 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2160 6 and and CC 40436 2160 7 other other JJ 40436 2160 8 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 2160 9 men man NNS 40436 2160 10 waver waver RB 40436 2160 11 ; ; : 40436 2160 12 but but CC 40436 2160 13 if if IN 40436 2160 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2160 15 wise wise JJ 40436 2160 16 men man NNS 40436 2160 17 waver waver VBP 40436 2160 18 also also RB 40436 2160 19 , , , 40436 2160 20 that that DT 40436 2160 21 becomes become VBZ 40436 2160 22 a a DT 40436 2160 23 fearful fearful JJ 40436 2160 24 mischief mischief NN 40436 2160 25 even even RB 40436 2160 26 to to IN 40436 2160 27 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2160 28 , , , 40436 2160 29 since since IN 40436 2160 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2160 31 can can MD 40436 2160 32 not not RB 40436 2160 33 even even RB 40436 2160 34 by by IN 40436 2160 35 coming come VBG 40436 2160 36 to to IN 40436 2160 37 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2160 38 escape escape VB 40436 2160 39 from from IN 40436 2160 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2160 41 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 2160 42 . . . 40436 2161 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2161 2 68 68 CD 40436 2161 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2161 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2161 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2161 6 67 67 CD 40436 2161 7 : : : 40436 2161 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2161 9 . . . 40436 2162 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 2162 2 . . . 40436 2163 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2163 2 . . . 40436 2164 1 375 375 CD 40436 2164 2 E e NN 40436 2164 3 , , , 40436 2164 4 376 376 CD 40436 2164 5 B. B. NNP 40436 2164 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2165 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2165 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2165 3 68 68 CD 40436 2165 4 : : : 40436 2165 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2165 6 , , , 40436 2165 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 2165 8 . . . 40436 2166 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2166 2 . . . 40436 2167 1 376 376 CD 40436 2167 2 C. C. NNP 40436 2167 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2167 4 * * NFP 40436 2167 5 * * NFP 40436 2167 6 * * NFP 40436 2167 7 * * NFP 40436 2167 8 * * NFP 40436 2167 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2167 10 will will MD 40436 2167 11 here here RB 40436 2167 12 again again RB 40436 2167 13 remind remind VB 40436 2167 14 the the DT 40436 2167 15 reader reader NN 40436 2167 16 , , , 40436 2167 17 that that IN 40436 2167 18 in in IN 40436 2167 19 this this DT 40436 2167 20 , , , 40436 2167 21 as as IN 40436 2167 22 in in IN 40436 2167 23 the the DT 40436 2167 24 other other JJ 40436 2167 25 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2167 26 , , , 40436 2167 27 the the DT 40436 2167 28 real real JJ 40436 2167 29 speaker speaker NN 40436 2167 30 is be VBZ 40436 2167 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2167 32 throughout throughout IN 40436 2167 33 : : : 40436 2167 34 and and CC 40436 2167 35 that that IN 40436 2167 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2167 37 is be VBZ 40436 2167 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2167 39 alone alone RB 40436 2167 40 who who WP 40436 2167 41 prefixes prefix VBZ 40436 2167 42 the the DT 40436 2167 43 different different JJ 40436 2167 44 names name NNS 40436 2167 45 to to IN 40436 2167 46 words word NNS 40436 2167 47 determined determine VBN 40436 2167 48 by by IN 40436 2167 49 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2167 50 . . . 40436 2168 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2168 2 Side side NN 40436 2168 3 - - HYPH 40436 2168 4 note note NN 40436 2168 5 : : : 40436 2168 6 Remarks remark NNS 40436 2168 7 on on IN 40436 2168 8 the the DT 40436 2168 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2168 10 . . . 40436 2169 1 If if IN 40436 2169 2 the the DT 40436 2169 3 parts part NNS 40436 2169 4 had have VBD 40436 2169 5 been be VBN 40436 2169 6 inverted invert VBN 40436 2169 7 , , , 40436 2169 8 the the DT 40436 2169 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2169 10 would would MD 40436 2169 11 have have VB 40436 2169 12 been be VBN 40436 2169 13 cited cite VBN 40436 2169 14 by by IN 40436 2169 15 critics critic NNS 40436 2169 16 as as IN 40436 2169 17 a a DT 40436 2169 18 specimen speciman NNS 40436 2169 19 of of IN 40436 2169 20 the the DT 40436 2169 21 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 2169 22 and and CC 40436 2169 23 corruption corruption NN 40436 2169 24 of of IN 40436 2169 25 the the DT 40436 2169 26 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 2169 27 . . . 40436 2169 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2170 1 Now now RB 40436 2170 2 , , , 40436 2170 3 if if IN 40436 2170 4 the the DT 40436 2170 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2170 6 just just RB 40436 2170 7 concluded conclude VBD 40436 2170 8 had have VBD 40436 2170 9 come come VBN 40436 2170 10 down down RP 40436 2170 11 to to IN 40436 2170 12 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2170 13 with with IN 40436 2170 14 the the DT 40436 2170 15 parts part NNS 40436 2170 16 inverted invert VBN 40436 2170 17 , , , 40436 2170 18 and and CC 40436 2170 19 with with IN 40436 2170 20 the the DT 40436 2170 21 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2170 22 of of IN 40436 2170 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2170 24 assigned assign VBN 40436 2170 25 to to IN 40436 2170 26 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2170 27 , , , 40436 2170 28 most most JJS 40436 2170 29 critics critic NNS 40436 2170 30 would would MD 40436 2170 31 probably probably RB 40436 2170 32 have have VB 40436 2170 33 produced produce VBN 40436 2170 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2170 35 as as IN 40436 2170 36 a a DT 40436 2170 37 tissue tissue NN 40436 2170 38 of of IN 40436 2170 39 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 2170 40 justifying justify VBG 40436 2170 41 the the DT 40436 2170 42 harsh harsh JJ 40436 2170 43 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2170 44 which which WDT 40436 2170 45 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2170 46 bestow bestow VBP 40436 2170 47 upon upon IN 40436 2170 48 the the DT 40436 2170 49 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 2170 50 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 2170 51 -- -- : 40436 2170 52 as as IN 40436 2170 53 persons person NNS 40436 2170 54 who who WP 40436 2170 55 considered consider VBD 40436 2170 56 truth truth NN 40436 2170 57 and and CC 40436 2170 58 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 2170 59 to to TO 40436 2170 60 be be VB 40436 2170 61 on on IN 40436 2170 62 a a DT 40436 2170 63 par par NN 40436 2170 64 -- -- : 40436 2170 65 subverters subverter NNS 40436 2170 66 of of IN 40436 2170 67 morality morality NN 40436 2170 68 -- -- : 40436 2170 69 and and CC 40436 2170 70 corruptors corruptor NNS 40436 2170 71 of of IN 40436 2170 72 the the DT 40436 2170 73 youth youth NN 40436 2170 74 of of IN 40436 2170 75 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2170 76 . . . 40436 2171 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2171 2 69 69 CD 40436 2171 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2171 4 But but CC 40436 2171 5 as as IN 40436 2171 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2171 7 read read VBP 40436 2171 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2171 9 , , , 40436 2171 10 all all PDT 40436 2171 11 that that DT 40436 2171 12 , , , 40436 2171 13 which which WDT 40436 2171 14 in in IN 40436 2171 15 the the DT 40436 2171 16 mouth mouth NN 40436 2171 17 of of IN 40436 2171 18 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2171 19 would would MD 40436 2171 20 have have VB 40436 2171 21 passed pass VBN 40436 2171 22 for for IN 40436 2171 23 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 2171 24 , , , 40436 2171 25 is be VBZ 40436 2171 26 here here RB 40436 2171 27 put put VBN 40436 2171 28 forward forward RP 40436 2171 29 by by IN 40436 2171 30 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2171 31 ; ; : 40436 2171 32 while while IN 40436 2171 33 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2171 34 not not RB 40436 2171 35 only only RB 40436 2171 36 resists resist VBZ 40436 2171 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2171 38 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 2171 39 , , , 40436 2171 40 and and CC 40436 2171 41 adheres adhere VBZ 40436 2171 42 to to IN 40436 2171 43 the the DT 40436 2171 44 received receive VBN 40436 2171 45 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2171 46 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2171 47 tenaciously tenaciously RB 40436 2171 48 , , , 40436 2171 49 even even RB 40436 2171 50 when when WRB 40436 2171 51 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2171 52 is be VBZ 40436 2171 53 unable unable JJ 40436 2171 54 to to TO 40436 2171 55 defend defend VB 40436 2171 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2171 57 , , , 40436 2171 58 but but CC 40436 2171 59 hates hate VBZ 40436 2171 60 the the DT 40436 2171 61 propositions proposition NNS 40436 2171 62 forced force VBN 40436 2171 63 upon upon IN 40436 2171 64 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2171 65 , , , 40436 2171 66 protests protest NNS 40436 2171 67 against against IN 40436 2171 68 the the DT 40436 2171 69 perverse perverse JJ 40436 2171 70 captiousness captiousness NN 40436 2171 71 of of IN 40436 2171 72 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2171 73 , , , 40436 2171 74 and and CC 40436 2171 75 requires require VBZ 40436 2171 76 much much RB 40436 2171 77 pressing press VBG 40436 2171 78 to to TO 40436 2171 79 induce induce VB 40436 2171 80 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2171 81 to to TO 40436 2171 82 continue continue VB 40436 2171 83 the the DT 40436 2171 84 debate debate NN 40436 2171 85 . . . 40436 2172 1 Upon upon IN 40436 2172 2 the the DT 40436 2172 3 views view NNS 40436 2172 4 adopted adopt VBN 40436 2172 5 by by IN 40436 2172 6 the the DT 40436 2172 7 critics critic NNS 40436 2172 8 , , , 40436 2172 9 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2172 10 ought ought MD 40436 2172 11 to to TO 40436 2172 12 receive receive VB 40436 2172 13 credit credit NN 40436 2172 14 for for IN 40436 2172 15 this this DT 40436 2172 16 conduct conduct NN 40436 2172 17 , , , 40436 2172 18 as as IN 40436 2172 19 a a DT 40436 2172 20 friend friend NN 40436 2172 21 of of IN 40436 2172 22 virtue virtue NN 40436 2172 23 and and CC 40436 2172 24 morality morality NN 40436 2172 25 . . . 40436 2173 1 To to IN 40436 2173 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2173 3 , , , 40436 2173 4 such such JJ 40436 2173 5 reluctance reluctance NN 40436 2173 6 to to TO 40436 2173 7 debate debate NN 40436 2173 8 appears appear VBZ 40436 2173 9 a a DT 40436 2173 10 defect defect NN 40436 2173 11 rather rather RB 40436 2173 12 than than IN 40436 2173 13 a a DT 40436 2173 14 merit merit NN 40436 2173 15 ; ; : 40436 2173 16 but but CC 40436 2173 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2173 18 cite cite VBP 40436 2173 19 the the DT 40436 2173 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2173 21 as as IN 40436 2173 22 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 2173 23 what what WP 40436 2173 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2173 25 have have VBP 40436 2173 26 already already RB 40436 2173 27 said say VBN 40436 2173 28 in in IN 40436 2173 29 another another DT 40436 2173 30 place place NN 40436 2173 31 -- -- : 40436 2173 32 that that IN 40436 2173 33 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2173 34 and and CC 40436 2173 35 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2173 36 threw throw VBD 40436 2173 37 out out RP 40436 2173 38 more more JJR 40436 2173 39 startling startling JJ 40436 2173 40 novelties novelty NNS 40436 2173 41 in in IN 40436 2173 42 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2173 43 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 2173 44 , , , 40436 2173 45 than than IN 40436 2173 46 either either DT 40436 2173 47 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2173 48 or or CC 40436 2173 49 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2173 50 , , , 40436 2173 51 or or CC 40436 2173 52 any any DT 40436 2173 53 of of IN 40436 2173 54 the the DT 40436 2173 55 other other JJ 40436 2173 56 persons person NNS 40436 2173 57 denounced denounce VBN 40436 2173 58 as as IN 40436 2173 59 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 2173 60 . . . 40436 2174 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2174 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2174 3 69 69 CD 40436 2174 4 : : : 40436 2174 5 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 2174 6 one one CD 40436 2174 7 of of IN 40436 2174 8 the the DT 40436 2174 9 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2174 10 critics critic NNS 40436 2174 11 , , , 40436 2174 12 Schwalbe Schwalbe NNP 40436 2174 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2174 14 Oeuvres Oeuvres NNP 40436 2174 15 de de NNP 40436 2174 16 Platon Platon NNP 40436 2174 17 , , , 40436 2174 18 p. p. NN 40436 2174 19 116 116 CD 40436 2174 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2174 21 , , , 40436 2174 22 explains explain VBZ 40436 2174 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2174 24 's 's POS 40436 2174 25 purpose purpose NN 40436 2174 26 in in IN 40436 2174 27 the the DT 40436 2174 28 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2174 29 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2174 30 by by IN 40436 2174 31 saying say VBG 40436 2174 32 , , , 40436 2174 33 that that IN 40436 2174 34 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2174 35 here here RB 40436 2174 36 serves serve VBZ 40436 2174 37 out out RP 40436 2174 38 to to IN 40436 2174 39 the the DT 40436 2174 40 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 2174 41 a a DT 40436 2174 42 specimen speciman NNS 40436 2174 43 of of IN 40436 2174 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2174 45 own own JJ 40436 2174 46 procedure procedure NN 40436 2174 47 , , , 40436 2174 48 and and CC 40436 2174 49 gives give VBZ 40436 2174 50 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2174 51 an an DT 40436 2174 52 example example NN 40436 2174 53 of of IN 40436 2174 54 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 2174 55 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 2174 56 , , , 40436 2174 57 by by IN 40436 2174 58 defending defend VBG 40436 2174 59 a a DT 40436 2174 60 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 2174 61 thesis thesis NN 40436 2174 62 in in IN 40436 2174 63 a a DT 40436 2174 64 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 2174 65 manner manner NN 40436 2174 66 : : : 40436 2174 67 That that IN 40436 2174 68 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2174 69 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2174 70 and and CC 40436 2174 71 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 40436 2174 72 at at IN 40436 2174 73 length length NN 40436 2174 74 the the DT 40436 2174 75 thesis thesis NN 40436 2174 76 -- -- : 40436 2174 77 the the DT 40436 2174 78 liar liar NN 40436 2174 79 is be VBZ 40436 2174 80 not not RB 40436 2174 81 different different JJ 40436 2174 82 from from IN 40436 2174 83 the the DT 40436 2174 84 truth truth NN 40436 2174 85 - - HYPH 40436 2174 86 teller teller NN 40436 2174 87 -- -- : 40436 2174 88 as as IN 40436 2174 89 an an DT 40436 2174 90 exposure exposure NN 40436 2174 91 of of IN 40436 2174 92 the the DT 40436 2174 93 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 2174 94 art art NN 40436 2174 95 of of IN 40436 2174 96 proving prove VBG 40436 2174 97 the the DT 40436 2174 98 contrary contrary NN 40436 2174 99 of of IN 40436 2174 100 any any DT 40436 2174 101 given give VBN 40436 2174 102 proposition proposition NN 40436 2174 103 , , , 40436 2174 104 and and CC 40436 2174 105 for for IN 40436 2174 106 the the DT 40436 2174 107 purpose purpose NN 40436 2174 108 of of IN 40436 2174 109 deriding deride VBG 40436 2174 110 and and CC 40436 2174 111 unmasking unmask VBG 40436 2174 112 the the DT 40436 2174 113 false false JJ 40436 2174 114 morality morality NN 40436 2174 115 of of IN 40436 2174 116 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2174 117 , , , 40436 2174 118 who who WP 40436 2174 119 in in IN 40436 2174 120 this this DT 40436 2174 121 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2174 122 talks talk VBZ 40436 2174 123 reasonably reasonably RB 40436 2174 124 enough enough RB 40436 2174 125 . . . 40436 2175 1 Schwalbe Schwalbe NNP 40436 2175 2 , , , 40436 2175 3 while while IN 40436 2175 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2175 5 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 2175 6 that that IN 40436 2175 7 this this DT 40436 2175 8 is be VBZ 40436 2175 9 the the DT 40436 2175 10 purpose purpose NN 40436 2175 11 of of IN 40436 2175 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2175 13 , , , 40436 2175 14 admits admit VBZ 40436 2175 15 that that IN 40436 2175 16 the the DT 40436 2175 17 part part NN 40436 2175 18 here here RB 40436 2175 19 assigned assign VBN 40436 2175 20 to to IN 40436 2175 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2175 22 is be VBZ 40436 2175 23 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 2175 24 of of IN 40436 2175 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2175 26 ; ; : 40436 2175 27 and and CC 40436 2175 28 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 2175 29 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 2175 30 that that IN 40436 2175 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2175 32 never never RB 40436 2175 33 could could MD 40436 2175 34 have have VB 40436 2175 35 had have VBN 40436 2175 36 any any DT 40436 2175 37 such such JJ 40436 2175 38 purpose purpose NN 40436 2175 39 , , , 40436 2175 40 " " `` 40436 2175 41 however however RB 40436 2175 42 frequently frequently RB 40436 2175 43 " " '' 40436 2175 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2175 45 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 2175 46 says say VBZ 40436 2175 47 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2175 48 , , , 40436 2175 49 " " `` 40436 2175 50 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 2175 51 artifices artifice NNS 40436 2175 52 may may MD 40436 2175 53 occur occur VB 40436 2175 54 in in IN 40436 2175 55 this this DT 40436 2175 56 conversation conversation NN 40436 2175 57 of of IN 40436 2175 58 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2175 59 , , , 40436 2175 60 which which WDT 40436 2175 61 artifices artifice VBZ 40436 2175 62 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2175 63 no no DT 40436 2175 64 more more RBR 40436 2175 65 disdained disdained JJ 40436 2175 66 to to TO 40436 2175 67 employ employ VB 40436 2175 68 than than IN 40436 2175 69 any any DT 40436 2175 70 other other JJ 40436 2175 71 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 2175 72 or or CC 40436 2175 73 rhetorician rhetorician NN 40436 2175 74 of of IN 40436 2175 75 that that DT 40436 2175 76 day day NN 40436 2175 77 " " '' 40436 2175 78 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2175 79 " " `` 40436 2175 80 so so RB 40436 2175 81 häufig häufig DT 40436 2175 82 auch auch NN 40436 2175 83 in in IN 40436 2175 84 seinen seinen NN 40436 2175 85 Erörterungen Erörterungen NNP 40436 2175 86 sophistische sophistische NN 40436 2175 87 Kunstgriffe Kunstgriffe NNP 40436 2175 88 vorkommen vorkommen VBZ 40436 2175 89 mögen mögen NN 40436 2175 90 , , , 40436 2175 91 die die VBP 40436 2175 92 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2175 93 eben eben NNS 40436 2175 94 so so RB 40436 2175 95 wenig wenig NNP 40436 2175 96 verschmaht verschmaht NNP 40436 2175 97 hat hat NN 40436 2175 98 , , , 40436 2175 99 als als NN 40436 2175 100 irgend irgend NN 40436 2175 101 ein ein NNP 40436 2175 102 Philosoph Philosoph NNP 40436 2175 103 oder oder VBP 40436 2175 104 Redekünstler Redekünstler NNP 40436 2175 105 dieser dieser NN 40436 2175 106 Zeit Zeit NNP 40436 2175 107 " " '' 40436 2175 108 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2175 109 . . . 40436 2176 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 2176 2 , , , 40436 2176 3 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 2176 4 zum zum NN 40436 2176 5 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 2176 6 . . . 40436 2177 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 2177 2 , , , 40436 2177 3 p. p. NN 40436 2177 4 109 109 CD 40436 2177 5 . . . 40436 2178 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2178 2 do do VBP 40436 2178 3 not not RB 40436 2178 4 admit admit VB 40436 2178 5 the the DT 40436 2178 6 purpose purpose NN 40436 2178 7 here here RB 40436 2178 8 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 2178 9 to to IN 40436 2178 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2178 11 by by IN 40436 2178 12 Schwalbe Schwalbe NNP 40436 2178 13 , , , 40436 2178 14 but but CC 40436 2178 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2178 16 refer refer VBP 40436 2178 17 to to IN 40436 2178 18 the the DT 40436 2178 19 passage passage NN 40436 2178 20 as as IN 40436 2178 21 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 2178 22 what what WP 40436 2178 23 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2178 24 critics critic NNS 40436 2178 25 think think VBP 40436 2178 26 of of IN 40436 2178 27 the the DT 40436 2178 28 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2178 29 assigned assign VBN 40436 2178 30 to to IN 40436 2178 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2178 32 in in IN 40436 2178 33 the the DT 40436 2178 34 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2178 35 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2178 36 , , , 40436 2178 37 and and CC 40436 2178 38 the the DT 40436 2178 39 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 40436 2178 40 which which WDT 40436 2178 41 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2178 42 introduce introduce VBP 40436 2178 43 to to TO 40436 2178 44 colour colour VB 40436 2178 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2178 46 . . . 40436 2179 1 The the DT 40436 2179 2 passage passage NN 40436 2179 3 cited cite VBD 40436 2179 4 from from IN 40436 2179 5 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 2179 6 also also RB 40436 2179 7 -- -- : 40436 2179 8 that that IN 40436 2179 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2179 10 no no DT 40436 2179 11 more more RBR 40436 2179 12 disdained disdained JJ 40436 2179 13 to to TO 40436 2179 14 employ employ VB 40436 2179 15 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 2179 16 artifices artifice NNS 40436 2179 17 than than IN 40436 2179 18 any any DT 40436 2179 19 other other JJ 40436 2179 20 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 2179 21 or or CC 40436 2179 22 rhetorician rhetorician NN 40436 2179 23 of of IN 40436 2179 24 the the DT 40436 2179 25 age age NN 40436 2179 26 -- -- : 40436 2179 27 is be VBZ 40436 2179 28 worthy worthy JJ 40436 2179 29 of of IN 40436 2179 30 note note NN 40436 2179 31 , , , 40436 2179 32 as as IN 40436 2179 33 coming come VBG 40436 2179 34 from from IN 40436 2179 35 one one CD 40436 2179 36 who who WP 40436 2179 37 is be VBZ 40436 2179 38 so so RB 40436 2179 39 very very RB 40436 2179 40 bitter bitter JJ 40436 2179 41 in in IN 40436 2179 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2179 43 invectives invective NNS 40436 2179 44 against against IN 40436 2179 45 the the DT 40436 2179 46 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 2179 47 of of IN 40436 2179 48 the the DT 40436 2179 49 persons person NNS 40436 2179 50 called call VBN 40436 2179 51 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 2179 52 , , , 40436 2179 53 of of IN 40436 2179 54 which which WDT 40436 2179 55 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2179 56 have have VBP 40436 2179 57 no no DT 40436 2179 58 specimens specimen NNS 40436 2179 59 left leave VBN 40436 2179 60 . . . 40436 2179 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2180 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2180 2 Side side NN 40436 2180 3 - - HYPH 40436 2180 4 note note NN 40436 2180 5 : : : 40436 2180 6 Polemical polemical JJ 40436 2180 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 2180 8 of of IN 40436 2180 9 the the DT 40436 2180 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2180 11 -- -- : 40436 2180 12 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2180 13 humiliated humiliate VBN 40436 2180 14 by by IN 40436 2180 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2180 16 . . . 40436 2180 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2181 1 That that IN 40436 2181 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2181 3 intended intend VBD 40436 2181 4 to to TO 40436 2181 5 represent represent VB 40436 2181 6 this this DT 40436 2181 7 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 2181 8 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 2181 9 as as IN 40436 2181 10 humiliated humiliate VBN 40436 2181 11 by by IN 40436 2181 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2181 13 , , , 40436 2181 14 is be VBZ 40436 2181 15 evident evident JJ 40436 2181 16 enough enough RB 40436 2181 17 : : : 40436 2181 18 and and CC 40436 2181 19 the the DT 40436 2181 20 words word NNS 40436 2181 21 put put VBN 40436 2181 22 into into IN 40436 2181 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2181 24 mouth mouth NN 40436 2181 25 are be VBP 40436 2181 26 suited suit VBN 40436 2181 27 to to IN 40436 2181 28 this this DT 40436 2181 29 purpose purpose NN 40436 2181 30 . . . 40436 2182 1 The the DT 40436 2182 2 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 2182 3 lecturer lecturer NN 40436 2182 4 , , , 40436 2182 5 so so RB 40436 2182 6 soon soon RB 40436 2182 7 as as IN 40436 2182 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2182 9 admiring admire VBG 40436 2182 10 crowd crowd NN 40436 2182 11 of of IN 40436 2182 12 auditors auditor NNS 40436 2182 13 has have VBZ 40436 2182 14 retired retire VBN 40436 2182 15 , , , 40436 2182 16 proves prove VBZ 40436 2182 17 unable unable JJ 40436 2182 18 to to TO 40436 2182 19 parry parry VB 40436 2182 20 the the DT 40436 2182 21 questions question NNS 40436 2182 22 of of IN 40436 2182 23 a a DT 40436 2182 24 single single JJ 40436 2182 25 expert expert NN 40436 2182 26 dialectician dialectician NN 40436 2182 27 who who WP 40436 2182 28 remains remain VBZ 40436 2182 29 behind behind RB 40436 2182 30 , , , 40436 2182 31 upon upon IN 40436 2182 32 a a DT 40436 2182 33 matter matter NN 40436 2182 34 which which WDT 40436 2182 35 appears appear VBZ 40436 2182 36 to to IN 40436 2182 37 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2182 38 almost almost RB 40436 2182 39 self self NN 40436 2182 40 - - HYPH 40436 2182 41 evident evident JJ 40436 2182 42 , , , 40436 2182 43 and and CC 40436 2182 44 upon upon IN 40436 2182 45 which which WDT 40436 2182 46 every every DT 40436 2182 47 one one NN 40436 2182 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2182 49 from from IN 40436 2182 50 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2182 51 downward downward RB 40436 2182 52 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2182 53 agrees agree VBZ 40436 2182 54 with with IN 40436 2182 55 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2182 56 . . . 40436 2183 1 Besides besides IN 40436 2183 2 this this DT 40436 2183 3 , , , 40436 2183 4 however however RB 40436 2183 5 , , , 40436 2183 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2183 7 is be VBZ 40436 2183 8 not not RB 40436 2183 9 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 2183 10 without without IN 40436 2183 11 making make VBG 40436 2183 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2183 13 say say VB 40436 2183 14 very very RB 40436 2183 15 simple simple JJ 40436 2183 16 and and CC 40436 2183 17 absurd absurd JJ 40436 2183 18 things thing NNS 40436 2183 19 . . . 40436 2184 1 All all PDT 40436 2184 2 this this DT 40436 2184 3 is be VBZ 40436 2184 4 the the DT 40436 2184 5 personal personal JJ 40436 2184 6 , , , 40436 2184 7 polemical polemical JJ 40436 2184 8 , , , 40436 2184 9 comic comic JJ 40436 2184 10 scope scope NN 40436 2184 11 of of IN 40436 2184 12 the the DT 40436 2184 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2184 14 . . . 40436 2185 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2185 2 lends lend VBZ 40436 2185 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2185 4 whether whether IN 40436 2185 5 well well RB 40436 2185 6 - - HYPH 40436 2185 7 placed place VBN 40436 2185 8 or or CC 40436 2185 9 not not RB 40436 2185 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2185 11 a a DT 40436 2185 12 certain certain JJ 40436 2185 13 animation animation NN 40436 2185 14 and and CC 40436 2185 15 variety variety NN 40436 2185 16 , , , 40436 2185 17 which which WDT 40436 2185 18 the the DT 40436 2185 19 author author NN 40436 2185 20 naturally naturally RB 40436 2185 21 looked look VBD 40436 2185 22 out out RP 40436 2185 23 for for IN 40436 2185 24 , , , 40436 2185 25 in in IN 40436 2185 26 an an DT 40436 2185 27 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 2185 28 of of IN 40436 2185 29 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2185 30 all all DT 40436 2185 31 handling handle VBG 40436 2185 32 analogous analogous JJ 40436 2185 33 matters matter NNS 40436 2185 34 about about IN 40436 2185 35 man man NN 40436 2185 36 and and CC 40436 2185 37 society society NN 40436 2185 38 . . . 40436 2186 1 But but CC 40436 2186 2 though though IN 40436 2186 3 the the DT 40436 2186 4 polemical polemical JJ 40436 2186 5 purpose purpose NN 40436 2186 6 of of IN 40436 2186 7 the the DT 40436 2186 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2186 9 is be VBZ 40436 2186 10 thus thus RB 40436 2186 11 plain plain JJ 40436 2186 12 , , , 40436 2186 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2186 14 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 2186 15 purpose purpose NN 40436 2186 16 perplexes perplex VBZ 40436 2186 17 the the DT 40436 2186 18 critics critic NNS 40436 2186 19 considerably considerably RB 40436 2186 20 . . . 40436 2187 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 2187 2 do do VBP 40436 2187 3 not not RB 40436 2187 4 like like VB 40436 2187 5 to to TO 40436 2187 6 see see VB 40436 2187 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2187 8 employing employ VBG 40436 2187 9 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 2187 10 against against IN 40436 2187 11 the the DT 40436 2187 12 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 2187 13 : : : 40436 2187 14 that that RB 40436 2187 15 is is RB 40436 2187 16 , , , 40436 2187 17 as as IN 40436 2187 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2187 19 think think VBP 40436 2187 20 , , , 40436 2187 21 casting cast VBG 40436 2187 22 out out RP 40436 2187 23 devils devil NNS 40436 2187 24 by by IN 40436 2187 25 the the DT 40436 2187 26 help help NN 40436 2187 27 of of IN 40436 2187 28 Beelzebub Beelzebub NNP 40436 2187 29 . . . 40436 2188 1 And and CC 40436 2188 2 certainly certainly RB 40436 2188 3 , , , 40436 2188 4 upon upon IN 40436 2188 5 the the DT 40436 2188 6 theory theory NN 40436 2188 7 which which WDT 40436 2188 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2188 9 adopt adopt VBP 40436 2188 10 , , , 40436 2188 11 respecting respect VBG 40436 2188 12 the the DT 40436 2188 13 relation relation NN 40436 2188 14 between between IN 40436 2188 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2188 16 and and CC 40436 2188 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2188 18 on on IN 40436 2188 19 one one CD 40436 2188 20 side side NN 40436 2188 21 , , , 40436 2188 22 and and CC 40436 2188 23 the the DT 40436 2188 24 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 2188 25 on on IN 40436 2188 26 the the DT 40436 2188 27 other other JJ 40436 2188 28 , , , 40436 2188 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2188 30 think think VBP 40436 2188 31 this this DT 40436 2188 32 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2188 33 is be VBZ 40436 2188 34 very very RB 40436 2188 35 difficult difficult JJ 40436 2188 36 to to TO 40436 2188 37 explain explain VB 40436 2188 38 . . . 40436 2189 1 But but CC 40436 2189 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2189 3 do do VBP 40436 2189 4 not not RB 40436 2189 5 think think VB 40436 2189 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2189 7 is be VBZ 40436 2189 8 difficult difficult JJ 40436 2189 9 , , , 40436 2189 10 upon upon IN 40436 2189 11 a a DT 40436 2189 12 true true JJ 40436 2189 13 theory theory NN 40436 2189 14 of of IN 40436 2189 15 the the DT 40436 2189 16 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2189 17 writings writing NNS 40436 2189 18 . . . 40436 2190 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2190 2 Side side NN 40436 2190 3 - - HYPH 40436 2190 4 note note NN 40436 2190 5 : : : 40436 2190 6 Philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 2190 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 2190 8 of of IN 40436 2190 9 the the DT 40436 2190 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2190 11 -- -- : 40436 2190 12 theory theory NN 40436 2190 13 of of IN 40436 2190 14 the the DT 40436 2190 15 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2190 16 of of IN 40436 2190 17 Search Search NNP 40436 2190 18 generally generally RB 40436 2190 19 , , , 40436 2190 20 and and CC 40436 2190 21 of of IN 40436 2190 22 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 40436 2190 23 as as IN 40436 2190 24 understood understand VBN 40436 2190 25 by by IN 40436 2190 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2190 27 . . . 40436 2190 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2191 1 In in IN 40436 2191 2 a a DT 40436 2191 3 former former JJ 40436 2191 4 chapter chapter NN 40436 2191 5 , , , 40436 2191 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2191 7 tried try VBD 40436 2191 8 to to TO 40436 2191 9 elucidate elucidate VB 40436 2191 10 the the DT 40436 2191 11 general general JJ 40436 2191 12 character character NN 40436 2191 13 and and CC 40436 2191 14 purpose purpose NN 40436 2191 15 of of IN 40436 2191 16 those those DT 40436 2191 17 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2191 18 of of IN 40436 2191 19 Search Search NNP 40436 2191 20 , , , 40436 2191 21 which which WDT 40436 2191 22 occupy occupy VBP 40436 2191 23 more more JJR 40436 2191 24 than than IN 40436 2191 25 half half PDT 40436 2191 26 the the DT 40436 2191 27 Thrasyllean Thrasyllean NNP 40436 2191 28 Canon Canon NNP 40436 2191 29 , , , 40436 2191 30 and and CC 40436 2191 31 of of IN 40436 2191 32 which which WDT 40436 2191 33 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2191 34 have have VBP 40436 2191 35 already already RB 40436 2191 36 reviewed review VBN 40436 2191 37 two two CD 40436 2191 38 or or CC 40436 2191 39 three three CD 40436 2191 40 specimens specimen NNS 40436 2191 41 -- -- : 40436 2191 42 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 2191 43 , , , 40436 2191 44 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 2191 45 , , , 40436 2191 46 & & CC 40436 2191 47 c. c. NNP 40436 2191 48 We -PRON- PRP 40436 2191 49 have have VBP 40436 2191 50 seen see VBN 40436 2191 51 that that IN 40436 2191 52 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2191 53 are be VBP 40436 2191 54 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 2191 55 by by IN 40436 2191 56 the the DT 40436 2191 57 absence absence NN 40436 2191 58 of of IN 40436 2191 59 any any DT 40436 2191 60 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 2191 61 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2191 62 : : : 40436 2191 63 that that IN 40436 2191 64 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2191 65 prove prove VBP 40436 2191 66 nothing nothing NN 40436 2191 67 , , , 40436 2191 68 but but CC 40436 2191 69 only only RB 40436 2191 70 , , , 40436 2191 71 at at IN 40436 2191 72 the the DT 40436 2191 73 most most JJS 40436 2191 74 , , , 40436 2191 75 disprove disprove VB 40436 2191 76 one one CD 40436 2191 77 or or CC 40436 2191 78 more more JJR 40436 2191 79 supposable supposable JJ 40436 2191 80 solutions solution NNS 40436 2191 81 : : : 40436 2191 82 that that IN 40436 2191 83 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2191 84 are be VBP 40436 2191 85 not not RB 40436 2191 86 processes process NNS 40436 2191 87 in in IN 40436 2191 88 which which WDT 40436 2191 89 one one CD 40436 2191 90 man man NN 40436 2191 91 who who WP 40436 2191 92 knows know VBZ 40436 2191 93 communicates communicate VBZ 40436 2191 94 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2191 95 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2191 96 to to IN 40436 2191 97 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2191 98 hearers hearer NNS 40436 2191 99 , , , 40436 2191 100 but but CC 40436 2191 101 in in IN 40436 2191 102 which which WDT 40436 2191 103 all all DT 40436 2191 104 are be VBP 40436 2191 105 alike alike RB 40436 2191 106 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2191 107 , , , 40436 2191 108 and and CC 40436 2191 109 all all DT 40436 2191 110 are be VBP 40436 2191 111 employed employ VBN 40436 2191 112 , , , 40436 2191 113 either either CC 40436 2191 114 in in IN 40436 2191 115 groping grope VBG 40436 2191 116 , , , 40436 2191 117 or or CC 40436 2191 118 guessing guess VBG 40436 2191 119 , , , 40436 2191 120 or or CC 40436 2191 121 testing test VBG 40436 2191 122 the the DT 40436 2191 123 guesses guess NNS 40436 2191 124 of of IN 40436 2191 125 the the DT 40436 2191 126 rest rest NN 40436 2191 127 . . . 40436 2192 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 2192 2 have have VBP 40436 2192 3 farther farther RB 40436 2192 4 seen see VBN 40436 2192 5 that that IN 40436 2192 6 the the DT 40436 2192 7 value value NN 40436 2192 8 of of IN 40436 2192 9 these these DT 40436 2192 10 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2192 11 depends depend VBZ 40436 2192 12 upon upon IN 40436 2192 13 the the DT 40436 2192 14 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2192 15 theory theory NN 40436 2192 16 about about IN 40436 2192 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2192 18 ; ; : 40436 2192 19 that that IN 40436 2192 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2192 21 did do VBD 40436 2192 22 not not RB 40436 2192 23 consider consider VB 40436 2192 24 any any DT 40436 2192 25 one one NN 40436 2192 26 to to TO 40436 2192 27 know know VB 40436 2192 28 , , , 40436 2192 29 who who WP 40436 2192 30 could could MD 40436 2192 31 not not RB 40436 2192 32 explain explain VB 40436 2192 33 to to IN 40436 2192 34 others other NNS 40436 2192 35 all all DT 40436 2192 36 that that WDT 40436 2192 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2192 38 knew know VBD 40436 2192 39 , , , 40436 2192 40 reply reply VB 40436 2192 41 to to IN 40436 2192 42 the the DT 40436 2192 43 cross cross NN 40436 2192 44 - - NN 40436 2192 45 examination examination NN 40436 2192 46 of of IN 40436 2192 47 a a DT 40436 2192 48 Sokratic Sokratic NNP 40436 2192 49 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 2192 50 , , , 40436 2192 51 and and CC 40436 2192 52 cross cross VB 40436 2192 53 - - JJ 40436 2192 54 examine examine VBP 40436 2192 55 others other NNS 40436 2192 56 to to TO 40436 2192 57 test test VB 40436 2192 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2192 59 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2192 60 : : : 40436 2192 61 that that IN 40436 2192 62 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2192 63 in in IN 40436 2192 64 this this DT 40436 2192 65 sense sense NN 40436 2192 66 could could MD 40436 2192 67 not not RB 40436 2192 68 be be VB 40436 2192 69 attained attain VBN 40436 2192 70 by by IN 40436 2192 71 hearing hear VBG 40436 2192 72 , , , 40436 2192 73 or or CC 40436 2192 74 reading read VBG 40436 2192 75 , , , 40436 2192 76 or or CC 40436 2192 77 committing commit VBG 40436 2192 78 to to IN 40436 2192 79 memory memory NN 40436 2192 80 a a DT 40436 2192 81 theorem theorem NN 40436 2192 82 , , , 40436 2192 83 together together RB 40436 2192 84 with with IN 40436 2192 85 the the DT 40436 2192 86 steps step NNS 40436 2192 87 of of IN 40436 2192 88 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2192 89 which which WDT 40436 2192 90 directly directly RB 40436 2192 91 conducted conduct VBN 40436 2192 92 to to IN 40436 2192 93 it:--but it:--but ADD 40436 2192 94 that that IN 40436 2192 95 there there EX 40436 2192 96 was be VBD 40436 2192 97 required require VBN 40436 2192 98 , , , 40436 2192 99 besides besides RB 40436 2192 100 , , , 40436 2192 101 an an DT 40436 2192 102 acquaintance acquaintance NN 40436 2192 103 with with IN 40436 2192 104 many many JJ 40436 2192 105 counter counter NN 40436 2192 106 - - NNS 40436 2192 107 theorems theorem NNS 40436 2192 108 , , , 40436 2192 109 each each DT 40436 2192 110 having have VBG 40436 2192 111 more more RBR 40436 2192 112 or or CC 40436 2192 113 less less JJR 40436 2192 114 appearance appearance NN 40436 2192 115 of of IN 40436 2192 116 truth truth NN 40436 2192 117 ; ; : 40436 2192 118 as as RB 40436 2192 119 well well RB 40436 2192 120 as as IN 40436 2192 121 with with IN 40436 2192 122 various various JJ 40436 2192 123 embarrassing embarrassing JJ 40436 2192 124 aspects aspect NNS 40436 2192 125 and and CC 40436 2192 126 plausible plausible JJ 40436 2192 127 delusions delusion NNS 40436 2192 128 on on IN 40436 2192 129 the the DT 40436 2192 130 subject subject NN 40436 2192 131 , , , 40436 2192 132 which which WDT 40436 2192 133 an an DT 40436 2192 134 expert expert NN 40436 2192 135 cross cross NN 40436 2192 136 - - NN 40436 2192 137 examiner examiner NN 40436 2192 138 would would MD 40436 2192 139 not not RB 40436 2192 140 fail fail VB 40436 2192 141 to to TO 40436 2192 142 urge urge VB 40436 2192 143 . . . 40436 2193 1 Unless unless IN 40436 2193 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2193 3 are be VBP 40436 2193 4 practised practise VBN 40436 2193 5 in in IN 40436 2193 6 meeting meet VBG 40436 2193 7 all all PDT 40436 2193 8 the the DT 40436 2193 9 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 2193 10 which which WDT 40436 2193 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2193 12 can can MD 40436 2193 13 devise devise VB 40436 2193 14 , , , 40436 2193 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2193 16 can can MD 40436 2193 17 not not RB 40436 2193 18 be be VB 40436 2193 19 said say VBN 40436 2193 20 _ _ NNP 40436 2193 21 to to TO 40436 2193 22 know know VB 40436 2193 23 _ _ NNP 40436 2193 24 . . . 40436 2194 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 2194 2 , , , 40436 2194 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2194 4 is be VBZ 40436 2194 5 in in IN 40436 2194 6 this this DT 40436 2194 7 last last JJ 40436 2194 8 portion portion NN 40436 2194 9 of of IN 40436 2194 10 the the DT 40436 2194 11 conditions condition NNS 40436 2194 12 of of IN 40436 2194 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2194 14 , , , 40436 2194 15 that that IN 40436 2194 16 most most JJS 40436 2194 17 aspirants aspirant NNS 40436 2194 18 are be VBP 40436 2194 19 found find VBN 40436 2194 20 wanting want VBG 40436 2194 21 . . . 40436 2195 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2195 2 Side side NN 40436 2195 3 - - HYPH 40436 2195 4 note note NN 40436 2195 5 : : : 40436 2195 6 The the DT 40436 2195 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2195 8 is be VBZ 40436 2195 9 an an DT 40436 2195 10 exemplification exemplification NN 40436 2195 11 of of IN 40436 2195 12 this this DT 40436 2195 13 theory theory NN 40436 2195 14 -- -- : 40436 2195 15 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2195 16 sets set VBZ 40436 2195 17 forth forth RB 40436 2195 18 a a DT 40436 2195 19 case case NN 40436 2195 20 of of IN 40436 2195 21 confusion confusion NN 40436 2195 22 , , , 40436 2195 23 and and CC 40436 2195 24 avows avow VBZ 40436 2195 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2195 26 inability inability NN 40436 2195 27 to to TO 40436 2195 28 clear clear VB 40436 2195 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2195 30 up up RP 40436 2195 31 . . . 40436 2196 1 Confusion confusion NN 40436 2196 2 shown show VBN 40436 2196 3 up up RP 40436 2196 4 in in IN 40436 2196 5 the the DT 40436 2196 6 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 2196 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2196 8 -- -- : 40436 2196 9 Error error NN 40436 2196 10 in in IN 40436 2196 11 the the DT 40436 2196 12 Greater Greater NNP 40436 2196 13 . . . 40436 2196 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2197 1 Now now RB 40436 2197 2 the the DT 40436 2197 3 Greater Greater NNP 40436 2197 4 and and CC 40436 2197 5 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 2197 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2197 7 are be VBP 40436 2197 8 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 2197 9 specimens specimen NNS 40436 2197 10 of of IN 40436 2197 11 these these DT 40436 2197 12 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2197 13 of of IN 40436 2197 14 Search Search NNP 40436 2197 15 , , , 40436 2197 16 and and CC 40436 2197 17 each each DT 40436 2197 18 serves serve VBZ 40436 2197 19 the the DT 40436 2197 20 purpose purpose NN 40436 2197 21 above above IN 40436 2197 22 indicated indicate VBD 40436 2197 23 . . . 40436 2198 1 The the DT 40436 2198 2 Greater Greater NNP 40436 2198 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2198 4 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 2198 5 a a DT 40436 2198 6 string string NN 40436 2198 7 of of IN 40436 2198 8 tentatives tentative NNS 40436 2198 9 , , , 40436 2198 10 each each DT 40436 2198 11 one one CD 40436 2198 12 of of IN 40436 2198 13 which which WDT 40436 2198 14 ends end VBZ 40436 2198 15 in in IN 40436 2198 16 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 2198 17 failure failure NN 40436 2198 18 : : : 40436 2198 19 the the DT 40436 2198 20 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 2198 21 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2198 22 enunciates enunciate VBZ 40436 2198 23 a a DT 40436 2198 24 thesis thesis NN 40436 2198 25 , , , 40436 2198 26 which which WDT 40436 2198 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2198 28 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 2198 29 to to IN 40436 2198 30 demonstrate demonstrate VB 40436 2198 31 , , , 40436 2198 32 by by IN 40436 2198 33 plausible plausible JJ 40436 2198 34 arguments argument NNS 40436 2198 35 such such JJ 40436 2198 36 as as IN 40436 2198 37 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2198 38 is be VBZ 40436 2198 39 forced force VBN 40436 2198 40 to to TO 40436 2198 41 admit admit VB 40436 2198 42 . . . 40436 2199 1 But but CC 40436 2199 2 though though IN 40436 2199 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2199 4 admits admit VBZ 40436 2199 5 each each DT 40436 2199 6 successive successive JJ 40436 2199 7 step step NN 40436 2199 8 , , , 40436 2199 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2199 10 still still RB 40436 2199 11 mistrusts mistrust VBZ 40436 2199 12 the the DT 40436 2199 13 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2199 14 , , , 40436 2199 15 and and CC 40436 2199 16 suspects suspect VBZ 40436 2199 17 that that WDT 40436 2199 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2199 19 has have VBZ 40436 2199 20 been be VBN 40436 2199 21 misled mislead VBN 40436 2199 22 -- -- : 40436 2199 23 a a DT 40436 2199 24 feeling feeling NN 40436 2199 25 which which WDT 40436 2199 26 Plato[70 Plato[70 , 40436 2199 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2199 28 describes describe VBZ 40436 2199 29 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 2199 30 as as IN 40436 2199 31 being be VBG 40436 2199 32 frequent frequent JJ 40436 2199 33 among among IN 40436 2199 34 the the DT 40436 2199 35 respondents respondent NNS 40436 2199 36 of of IN 40436 2199 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2199 38 . . . 40436 2200 1 Nay nay UH 40436 2200 2 , , , 40436 2200 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2200 4 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2200 5 shares share NNS 40436 2200 6 in in IN 40436 2200 7 the the DT 40436 2200 8 mistrust mistrust NN 40436 2200 9 -- -- : 40436 2200 10 presents present VBZ 40436 2200 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2200 12 as as IN 40436 2200 13 an an DT 40436 2200 14 unwilling unwilling JJ 40436 2200 15 propounder propounder NN 40436 2200 16 of of IN 40436 2200 17 arguments argument NNS 40436 2200 18 which which WDT 40436 2200 19 force force VBP 40436 2200 20 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 2200 21 upon upon IN 40436 2200 22 him,[71 him,[71 NN 40436 2200 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2200 24 and and CC 40436 2200 25 complains complain VBZ 40436 2200 26 of of IN 40436 2200 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2200 28 own own JJ 40436 2200 29 mental mental JJ 40436 2200 30 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 2200 31 . . . 40436 2201 1 Now now RB 40436 2201 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2201 3 may may MD 40436 2201 4 call call VB 40436 2201 5 this this DT 40436 2201 6 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 2201 7 , , , 40436 2201 8 if if IN 40436 2201 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2201 10 please please VBP 40436 2201 11 ; ; : 40436 2201 12 and and CC 40436 2201 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2201 14 may may MD 40436 2201 15 silence silence VB 40436 2201 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2201 17 propounders propounder NNS 40436 2201 18 by by IN 40436 2201 19 calling call VBG 40436 2201 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2201 21 hard hard JJ 40436 2201 22 names name NNS 40436 2201 23 . . . 40436 2202 1 But but CC 40436 2202 2 such such JJ 40436 2202 3 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2202 4 prudery prudery NN 40436 2202 5 -- -- : 40436 2202 6 hiding hide VBG 40436 2202 7 all all PDT 40436 2202 8 the the DT 40436 2202 9 uncomfortable uncomfortable JJ 40436 2202 10 logical logical JJ 40436 2202 11 puzzles puzzle NNS 40436 2202 12 which which WDT 40436 2202 13 start start VBP 40436 2202 14 up up RP 40436 2202 15 when when WRB 40436 2202 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2202 17 begin begin VBP 40436 2202 18 to to TO 40436 2202 19 analyse analyse VB 40436 2202 20 an an DT 40436 2202 21 established established JJ 40436 2202 22 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2202 23 , , , 40436 2202 24 and and CC 40436 2202 25 treating treat VBG 40436 2202 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2202 27 as as IN 40436 2202 28 non non JJ 40436 2202 29 - - JJ 40436 2202 30 existent existent NN 40436 2202 31 because because IN 40436 2202 32 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2202 33 refuse refuse VBP 40436 2202 34 to to TO 40436 2202 35 look look VB 40436 2202 36 at at IN 40436 2202 37 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2202 38 -- -- : 40436 2202 39 is be VBZ 40436 2202 40 not not RB 40436 2202 41 the the DT 40436 2202 42 way way NN 40436 2202 43 , , , 40436 2202 44 to to TO 40436 2202 45 attain attain VB 40436 2202 46 what what WP 40436 2202 47 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2202 48 calls call VBZ 40436 2202 49 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2202 50 . . . 40436 2203 1 If if IN 40436 2203 2 there there EX 40436 2203 3 be be VB 40436 2203 4 any any DT 40436 2203 5 argument argument NN 40436 2203 6 , , , 40436 2203 7 the the DT 40436 2203 8 process process NN 40436 2203 9 of of IN 40436 2203 10 which which WDT 40436 2203 11 seems seem VBZ 40436 2203 12 indisputable indisputable JJ 40436 2203 13 , , , 40436 2203 14 while while IN 40436 2203 15 yet yet RB 40436 2203 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2203 17 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2203 18 contradicts contradict VBZ 40436 2203 19 , , , 40436 2203 20 or or CC 40436 2203 21 seems seem VBZ 40436 2203 22 to to TO 40436 2203 23 contradict contradict VB 40436 2203 24 , , , 40436 2203 25 what what WP 40436 2203 26 is be VBZ 40436 2203 27 known know VBN 40436 2203 28 , , , 40436 2203 29 upon upon IN 40436 2203 30 other other JJ 40436 2203 31 evidence evidence NN 40436 2203 32 -- -- : 40436 2203 33 the the DT 40436 2203 34 full full JJ 40436 2203 35 and and CC 40436 2203 36 patient patient JJ 40436 2203 37 analysis analysis NN 40436 2203 38 of of IN 40436 2203 39 that that DT 40436 2203 40 argument argument NN 40436 2203 41 is be VBZ 40436 2203 42 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 2203 43 , , , 40436 2203 44 before before IN 40436 2203 45 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2203 46 can can MD 40436 2203 47 become become VB 40436 2203 48 master master NN 40436 2203 49 of of IN 40436 2203 50 the the DT 40436 2203 51 truth truth NN 40436 2203 52 and and CC 40436 2203 53 able able JJ 40436 2203 54 to to TO 40436 2203 55 defend defend VB 40436 2203 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2203 57 . . . 40436 2204 1 Until until IN 40436 2204 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2204 3 have have VBP 40436 2204 4 gone go VBN 40436 2204 5 through through IN 40436 2204 6 such such JJ 40436 2204 7 analysis analysis NN 40436 2204 8 , , , 40436 2204 9 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2204 10 mind mind NN 40436 2204 11 must must MD 40436 2204 12 remain remain VB 40436 2204 13 in in IN 40436 2204 14 that that DT 40436 2204 15 state state NN 40436 2204 16 of of IN 40436 2204 17 confusion confusion NN 40436 2204 18 which which WDT 40436 2204 19 is be VBZ 40436 2204 20 indicated indicate VBN 40436 2204 21 by by IN 40436 2204 22 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2204 23 at at IN 40436 2204 24 the the DT 40436 2204 25 end end NN 40436 2204 26 of of IN 40436 2204 27 the the DT 40436 2204 28 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 2204 29 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2204 30 . . . 40436 2205 1 As as IN 40436 2205 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2205 3 is be VBZ 40436 2205 4 a a DT 40436 2205 5 part part NN 40436 2205 6 of of IN 40436 2205 7 the the DT 40436 2205 8 process process NN 40436 2205 9 of of IN 40436 2205 10 Search Search NNP 40436 2205 11 , , , 40436 2205 12 to to TO 40436 2205 13 travel travel VB 40436 2205 14 in in IN 40436 2205 15 the the DT 40436 2205 16 path path NN 40436 2205 17 of of IN 40436 2205 18 the the DT 40436 2205 19 Greater Greater NNP 40436 2205 20 Hippias Hippias NNPS 40436 2205 21 -- -- : 40436 2205 22 that that RB 40436 2205 23 is is RB 40436 2205 24 , , , 40436 2205 25 to to TO 40436 2205 26 go go VB 40436 2205 27 through through IN 40436 2205 28 a a DT 40436 2205 29 string string NN 40436 2205 30 of of IN 40436 2205 31 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 2205 32 solutions solution NNS 40436 2205 33 , , , 40436 2205 34 each each DT 40436 2205 35 of of IN 40436 2205 36 which which WDT 40436 2205 37 can can MD 40436 2205 38 be be VB 40436 2205 39 proved prove VBN 40436 2205 40 , , , 40436 2205 41 by by IN 40436 2205 42 reasons reason NNS 40436 2205 43 shown show VBN 40436 2205 44 , , , 40436 2205 45 to to IN 40436 2205 46 _ _ NNP 40436 2205 47 be be VB 40436 2205 48 _ _ NNP 40436 2205 49 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 2205 50 : : : 40436 2205 51 so so CC 40436 2205 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2205 53 is be VBZ 40436 2205 54 an an DT 40436 2205 55 equally equally RB 40436 2205 56 important important JJ 40436 2205 57 part part NN 40436 2205 58 of of IN 40436 2205 59 the the DT 40436 2205 60 same same JJ 40436 2205 61 process process NN 40436 2205 62 , , , 40436 2205 63 to to TO 40436 2205 64 travel travel VB 40436 2205 65 in in IN 40436 2205 66 the the DT 40436 2205 67 path path NN 40436 2205 68 of of IN 40436 2205 69 the the DT 40436 2205 70 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 2205 71 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2205 72 -- -- : 40436 2205 73 that that RB 40436 2205 74 is is RB 40436 2205 75 , , , 40436 2205 76 to to TO 40436 2205 77 acquaint acquaint VB 40436 2205 78 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 2205 79 with with IN 40436 2205 80 all all PDT 40436 2205 81 those those DT 40436 2205 82 arguments argument NNS 40436 2205 83 , , , 40436 2205 84 bearing bear VBG 40436 2205 85 on on IN 40436 2205 86 the the DT 40436 2205 87 case case NN 40436 2205 88 , , , 40436 2205 89 in in IN 40436 2205 90 which which WDT 40436 2205 91 two two CD 40436 2205 92 contrary contrary JJ 40436 2205 93 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 2205 94 appear appear VBP 40436 2205 95 to to TO 40436 2205 96 be be VB 40436 2205 97 both both DT 40436 2205 98 of of IN 40436 2205 99 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2205 100 plausibly plausibly RB 40436 2205 101 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 40436 2205 102 , , , 40436 2205 103 and and CC 40436 2205 104 in in IN 40436 2205 105 which which WDT 40436 2205 106 therefore therefore RB 40436 2205 107 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2205 108 can can MD 40436 2205 109 not not RB 40436 2205 110 as as RB 40436 2205 111 yet yet RB 40436 2205 112 determine determine VB 40436 2205 113 which which WDT 40436 2205 114 of of IN 40436 2205 115 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2205 116 is be VBZ 40436 2205 117 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 2205 118 -- -- : 40436 2205 119 or or CC 40436 2205 120 whether whether IN 40436 2205 121 both both DT 40436 2205 122 are be VBP 40436 2205 123 not not RB 40436 2205 124 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 2205 125 . . . 40436 2206 1 The the DT 40436 2206 2 Greater Greater NNP 40436 2206 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2206 4 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 2206 5 errors,--the errors,--the DT 40436 2206 6 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 2206 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2206 8 puts put VBZ 40436 2206 9 before before IN 40436 2206 10 us us NNP 40436 2206 11 confusion confusion NN 40436 2206 12 . . . 40436 2207 1 With with IN 40436 2207 2 both both PDT 40436 2207 3 these these DT 40436 2207 4 enemies enemy NNS 40436 2207 5 the the DT 40436 2207 6 Searcher Searcher NNP 40436 2207 7 for for IN 40436 2207 8 truth truth NN 40436 2207 9 must must MD 40436 2207 10 contend contend VB 40436 2207 11 : : : 40436 2207 12 and and CC 40436 2207 13 Bacon Bacon NNP 40436 2207 14 tells tell VBZ 40436 2207 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2207 16 , , , 40436 2207 17 that that IN 40436 2207 18 confusion confusion NN 40436 2207 19 is be VBZ 40436 2207 20 the the DT 40436 2207 21 worst bad JJS 40436 2207 22 enemy enemy NN 40436 2207 23 of of IN 40436 2207 24 the the DT 40436 2207 25 two--"Citius two--"Citius NNP 40436 2207 26 emergit emergit NN 40436 2207 27 veritas verita VBZ 40436 2207 28 ex ex NNP 40436 2207 29 errore errore NNP 40436 2207 30 , , , 40436 2207 31 quam quam NNP 40436 2207 32 ex ex FW 40436 2207 33 confusione confusione NNP 40436 2207 34 " " '' 40436 2207 35 . . . 40436 2208 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2208 2 , , , 40436 2208 3 in in IN 40436 2208 4 the the DT 40436 2208 5 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 2208 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2208 7 , , , 40436 2208 8 having have VBG 40436 2208 9 in in IN 40436 2208 10 hand hand NN 40436 2208 11 a a DT 40436 2208 12 genuine genuine JJ 40436 2208 13 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 2208 14 thesis thesis NN 40436 2208 15 , , , 40436 2208 16 does do VBZ 40436 2208 17 not not RB 40436 2208 18 disdain disdain VB 40436 2208 19 to to TO 40436 2208 20 invest invest VB 40436 2208 21 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2208 22 with with IN 40436 2208 23 the the DT 40436 2208 24 task task NN 40436 2208 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2208 26 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 2208 27 , , , 40436 2208 28 as as IN 40436 2208 29 some some DT 40436 2208 30 call call VBP 40436 2208 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2208 32 , , , 40436 2208 33 yet yet CC 40436 2208 34 not not RB 40436 2208 35 the the DT 40436 2208 36 less less RBR 40436 2208 37 useful useful JJ 40436 2208 38 and and CC 40436 2208 39 instructive instructive JJ 40436 2208 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2208 41 of of IN 40436 2208 42 setting set VBG 40436 2208 43 forth forth RP 40436 2208 44 at at IN 40436 2208 45 large large JJ 40436 2208 46 this this DT 40436 2208 47 case case NN 40436 2208 48 of of IN 40436 2208 49 confusion confusion NN 40436 2208 50 , , , 40436 2208 51 and and CC 40436 2208 52 avowing avow VBG 40436 2208 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2208 54 inability inability NN 40436 2208 55 to to TO 40436 2208 56 clear clear VB 40436 2208 57 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2208 58 up up RP 40436 2208 59 . . . 40436 2209 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2209 2 is be VBZ 40436 2209 3 enough enough JJ 40436 2209 4 for for IN 40436 2209 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2209 6 that that WDT 40436 2209 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2209 8 brings bring VBZ 40436 2209 9 home home RB 40436 2209 10 the the DT 40436 2209 11 painful painful JJ 40436 2209 12 sense sense NN 40436 2209 13 of of IN 40436 2209 14 confusion confusion NN 40436 2209 15 to to IN 40436 2209 16 the the DT 40436 2209 17 feelings feeling NNS 40436 2209 18 of of IN 40436 2209 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2209 20 hearer hearer NN 40436 2209 21 as as RB 40436 2209 22 well well RB 40436 2209 23 as as IN 40436 2209 24 to to IN 40436 2209 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2209 26 own own JJ 40436 2209 27 . . . 40436 2210 1 In in IN 40436 2210 2 that that DT 40436 2210 3 painful painful JJ 40436 2210 4 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2210 5 lies lie VBZ 40436 2210 6 the the DT 40436 2210 7 stimulus stimulus JJ 40436 2210 8 provocative provocative NN 40436 2210 9 of of IN 40436 2210 10 farther farth JJR 40436 2210 11 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 2210 12 effort effort NN 40436 2210 13 . . . 40436 2211 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2211 2 72 72 CD 40436 2211 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2211 4 The the DT 40436 2211 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2211 6 ends end VBZ 40436 2211 7 but but CC 40436 2211 8 the the DT 40436 2211 9 process process NN 40436 2211 10 of of IN 40436 2211 11 search search NN 40436 2211 12 , , , 40436 2211 13 far far RB 40436 2211 14 from from IN 40436 2211 15 ending end VBG 40436 2211 16 along along RB 40436 2211 17 with with IN 40436 2211 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2211 19 , , , 40436 2211 20 is be VBZ 40436 2211 21 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 2211 22 declared declare VBN 40436 2211 23 to to TO 40436 2211 24 be be VB 40436 2211 25 unfinished unfinished JJ 40436 2211 26 , , , 40436 2211 27 and and CC 40436 2211 28 , , , 40436 2211 29 to to TO 40436 2211 30 be be VB 40436 2211 31 in in IN 40436 2211 32 a a DT 40436 2211 33 condition condition NN 40436 2211 34 not not RB 40436 2211 35 merely merely RB 40436 2211 36 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 2211 37 but but CC 40436 2211 38 intolerable intolerable JJ 40436 2211 39 , , , 40436 2211 40 not not RB 40436 2211 41 to to TO 40436 2211 42 be be VB 40436 2211 43 relieved relieve VBN 40436 2211 44 except except IN 40436 2211 45 by by IN 40436 2211 46 farther farther JJ 40436 2211 47 investigation investigation NN 40436 2211 48 , , , 40436 2211 49 which which WDT 40436 2211 50 thus thus RB 40436 2211 51 becomes become VBZ 40436 2211 52 a a DT 40436 2211 53 necessary necessary JJ 40436 2211 54 sequel sequel NN 40436 2211 55 . . . 40436 2212 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2212 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2212 3 70 70 CD 40436 2212 4 : : : 40436 2212 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2212 6 , , , 40436 2212 7 Republ Republ NNP 40436 2212 8 . . . 40436 2213 1 vi vi NNP 40436 2213 2 . . . 40436 2214 1 487 487 CD 40436 2214 2 B. B. NNP 40436 2215 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2215 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2215 3 : : : 40436 2215 4 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 2215 5 o o NNP 40436 2215 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2215 7 A)dei A)dei NNP 40436 2215 8 / / SYM 40436 2215 9 mantos manto NNS 40436 2215 10 , , , 40436 2215 11 Ô)= Ô)= NNP 40436 2215 12 Sô Sô NNP 40436 2215 13 / / SYM 40436 2215 14 krates krate NNS 40436 2215 15 , , , 40436 2215 16 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 2215 17 , , , 40436 2215 18 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 2215 19 me\n me\n NNP 40436 2215 20 tau tau NNP 40436 2215 21 = = SYM 40436 2215 22 ta/ ta/ NNP 40436 2215 23 soi soi NNP 40436 2215 24 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 2215 25 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2215 26 oi(=os oi(=os NNP 40436 2215 27 t t NN 40436 2215 28 ' ' '' 40436 2215 29 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 2215 30 a)nteipei a)nteipei NFP 40436 2215 31 = = SYM 40436 2215 32 n n XX 40436 2215 33 ; ; : 40436 2215 34 a)lla\ a)lla\ : 40436 2215 35 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 2215 36 toio toio NNP 40436 2215 37 / / SYM 40436 2215 38 nde nde NNP 40436 2215 39 ti ti NNP 40436 2215 40 pa pa NNP 40436 2215 41 / / SYM 40436 2215 42 schousin schousin NNP 40436 2215 43 oi oi NNP 40436 2215 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2215 45 a)kou a)kou NNP 40436 2215 46 / / SYM 40436 2215 47 ontes onte NNS 40436 2215 48 e)ka e)ka JJ 40436 2215 49 / / SYM 40436 2215 50 stote stote NNP 40436 2215 51 a)\ a)\ NNP 40436 2215 52 nu nu NNP 40436 2215 53 = = SYM 40436 2215 54 n n NNP 40436 2215 55 le le NNP 40436 2215 56 / / SYM 40436 2215 57 geis geis NNP 40436 2215 58 ; ; : 40436 2215 59 ê(gou ê(gou NNP 40436 2215 60 = = SYM 40436 2215 61 ntai ntai NNP 40436 2215 62 di di NNP 40436 2215 63 ' ' '' 40436 2215 64 a)peiri a)peiri NNS 40436 2215 65 / / SYM 40436 2215 66 an an DT 40436 2215 67 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2215 68 e)rôta=|n e)rôta=|n NNP 40436 2215 69 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2215 70 a)pokri a)pokri NNP 40436 2215 71 / / SYM 40436 2215 72 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 2215 73 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 2215 74 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2215 75 lo lo NNP 40436 2215 76 / / SYM 40436 2215 77 gou gou NNP 40436 2215 78 par par NNP 40436 2215 79 ' ' `` 40436 2215 80 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 2215 81 to\ to\ NN 40436 2215 82 e)rô e)rô NN 40436 2215 83 / / SYM 40436 2215 84 têma têma NN 40436 2215 85 smikro\n smikro\n ADD 40436 2215 86 parago parago NNP 40436 2215 87 / / SYM 40436 2215 88 menoi menoi NNS 40436 2215 89 , , , 40436 2215 90 a)throisthe a)throisthe NNP 40436 2215 91 / / SYM 40436 2215 92 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 2215 93 tô tô NNP 40436 2215 94 = = SYM 40436 2215 95 n n CC 40436 2215 96 smikrô smikrô JJ 40436 2215 97 = = SYM 40436 2215 98 n n CC 40436 2215 99 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 2215 100 teleutê teleutê NN 40436 2215 101 = = SYM 40436 2215 102 s s NNP 40436 2215 103 tô tô NNP 40436 2215 104 = = SYM 40436 2215 105 n n NNP 40436 2215 106 lo lo NNP 40436 2215 107 / / SYM 40436 2215 108 gôn gôn NNP 40436 2215 109 , , , 40436 2215 110 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2215 111 / / SYM 40436 2215 112 ga ga NNP 40436 2215 113 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2215 114 spha spha NNP 40436 2215 115 / / SYM 40436 2215 116 lma lma NNP 40436 2215 117 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2215 118 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 2215 119 / / SYM 40436 2215 120 on on IN 40436 2215 121 toi toi NNP 40436 2215 122 = = SYM 40436 2215 123 s s NNP 40436 2215 124 prô prô NNP 40436 2215 125 / / SYM 40436 2215 126 tois tois NNP 40436 2215 127 a)naphai a)naphai NNP 40436 2215 128 / / SYM 40436 2215 129 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 2215 130 . . . 40436 2216 1 . . . 40436 2217 1 . . . 40436 2218 1 e)pei e)pei NNP 40436 2218 2 to/ to/ CD 40436 2218 3 ge ge NNP 40436 2218 4 a)lêthe\s a)lêthe\s NNP 40436 2218 5 ou)de ou)de NNP 40436 2218 6 / / SYM 40436 2218 7 n n CC 40436 2218 8 ti ti NNP 40436 2218 9 ma ma NNP 40436 2218 10 = = SYM 40436 2218 11 llon llon NNP 40436 2218 12 tau tau NNP 40436 2218 13 / / SYM 40436 2218 14 tê| tê| NNP 40436 2218 15 e)/chein e)/chein RB 40436 2218 16 . . . 40436 2218 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2219 1 This this DT 40436 2219 2 passage passage NN 40436 2219 3 , , , 40436 2219 4 attesting attest VBG 40436 2219 5 the the DT 40436 2219 6 effect effect NN 40436 2219 7 of of IN 40436 2219 8 the the DT 40436 2219 9 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 2219 10 examination examination NN 40436 2219 11 upon upon IN 40436 2219 12 the the DT 40436 2219 13 minds mind NNS 40436 2219 14 of of IN 40436 2219 15 auditors auditor NNS 40436 2219 16 , , , 40436 2219 17 ought ought MD 40436 2219 18 to to TO 40436 2219 19 be be VB 40436 2219 20 laid lay VBN 40436 2219 21 to to IN 40436 2219 22 heart heart NN 40436 2219 23 by by IN 40436 2219 24 those those DT 40436 2219 25 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2219 26 critics critic NNS 40436 2219 27 who who WP 40436 2219 28 denounce denounce VBP 40436 2219 29 the the DT 40436 2219 30 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 2219 31 for for IN 40436 2219 32 generating generate VBG 40436 2219 33 scepticism scepticism NN 40436 2219 34 and and CC 40436 2219 35 uncertainty uncertainty NN 40436 2219 36 . . . 40436 2219 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2220 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2220 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2220 3 71 71 CD 40436 2220 4 : : : 40436 2220 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2220 6 , , , 40436 2220 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 2220 8 . . . 40436 2221 1 Minor minor JJ 40436 2221 2 , , , 40436 2221 3 373 373 CD 40436 2221 4 B b NN 40436 2221 5 ; ; : 40436 2221 6 also also RB 40436 2221 7 the the DT 40436 2221 8 last last JJ 40436 2221 9 sentence sentence NN 40436 2221 10 of of IN 40436 2221 11 the the DT 40436 2221 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2221 13 . . . 40436 2221 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2222 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2222 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2222 3 72 72 CD 40436 2222 4 : : : 40436 2222 5 See see VB 40436 2222 6 the the DT 40436 2222 7 passage passage NN 40436 2222 8 in in IN 40436 2222 9 Republic Republic NNP 40436 2222 10 , , , 40436 2222 11 vii vii NN 40436 2222 12 . . . 40436 2223 1 523 523 CD 40436 2223 2 - - SYM 40436 2223 3 524 524 CD 40436 2223 4 , , , 40436 2223 5 where where WRB 40436 2223 6 the the DT 40436 2223 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2223 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2223 9 : : : 40436 2223 10 to\ to\ NN 40436 2223 11 paraklêtiko\n paraklêtiko\n '' 40436 2223 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2223 13 e)gertiko\n e)gertiko\n NNP 40436 2223 14 tê tê NNP 40436 2223 15 = = SYM 40436 2223 16 s s NNP 40436 2223 17 noê noê NNP 40436 2223 18 / / SYM 40436 2223 19 seôs seôs NNP 40436 2223 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2223 21 is be VBZ 40436 2223 22 declared declare VBN 40436 2223 23 to to TO 40436 2223 24 arise arise VB 40436 2223 25 from from IN 40436 2223 26 the the DT 40436 2223 27 pain pain NN 40436 2223 28 of of IN 40436 2223 29 a a DT 40436 2223 30 felt feel VBN 40436 2223 31 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 2223 32 . . . 40436 2223 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2224 1 There there EX 40436 2224 2 are be VBP 40436 2224 3 two two CD 40436 2224 4 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 2224 5 which which WDT 40436 2224 6 lend lend VBP 40436 2224 7 particular particular JJ 40436 2224 8 interest interest NN 40436 2224 9 to to IN 40436 2224 10 this this DT 40436 2224 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2224 12 -- -- : 40436 2224 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2224 14 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2224 15 . . . 40436 2225 1 1 1 LS 40436 2225 2 . . . 40436 2226 1 That that IN 40436 2226 2 the the DT 40436 2226 3 thesis thesis NN 40436 2226 4 out out IN 40436 2226 5 of of IN 40436 2226 6 which which WDT 40436 2226 7 the the DT 40436 2226 8 confusion confusion NN 40436 2226 9 arises arise VBZ 40436 2226 10 , , , 40436 2226 11 is be VBZ 40436 2226 12 one one CD 40436 2226 13 which which WDT 40436 2226 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2226 15 know know VBP 40436 2226 16 to to TO 40436 2226 17 have have VB 40436 2226 18 been be VBN 40436 2226 19 laid lay VBN 40436 2226 20 down down RP 40436 2226 21 by by IN 40436 2226 22 the the DT 40436 2226 23 historical historical JJ 40436 2226 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2226 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2226 26 . . . 40436 2227 1 2 2 LS 40436 2227 2 . . . 40436 2228 1 That that IN 40436 2228 2 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2228 3 expressly expressly RB 40436 2228 4 notices notice VBZ 40436 2228 5 this this DT 40436 2228 6 thesis thesis NN 40436 2228 7 , , , 40436 2228 8 as as RB 40436 2228 9 well well RB 40436 2228 10 as as IN 40436 2228 11 the the DT 40436 2228 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2228 13 in in IN 40436 2228 14 which which WDT 40436 2228 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2228 16 is be VBZ 40436 2228 17 contained contain VBN 40436 2228 18 , , , 40436 2228 19 and and CC 40436 2228 20 combats combat VBZ 40436 2228 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2228 22 . . . 40436 2229 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2229 2 Side side NN 40436 2229 3 - - HYPH 40436 2229 4 note note NN 40436 2229 5 : : : 40436 2229 6 The the DT 40436 2229 7 thesis thesis NN 40436 2229 8 maintained maintain VBN 40436 2229 9 here here RB 40436 2229 10 by by IN 40436 2229 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2229 12 , , , 40436 2229 13 is be VBZ 40436 2229 14 also also RB 40436 2229 15 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 2229 16 by by IN 40436 2229 17 the the DT 40436 2229 18 historical historical JJ 40436 2229 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2229 20 in in IN 40436 2229 21 the the DT 40436 2229 22 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 2229 23 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 2229 24 . . . 40436 2229 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2230 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2230 2 in in IN 40436 2230 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2230 4 conversation conversation NN 40436 2230 5 with with IN 40436 2230 6 the the DT 40436 2230 7 youthful youthful JJ 40436 2230 8 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 2230 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2230 10 in in IN 40436 2230 11 the the DT 40436 2230 12 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 2230 13 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 2230 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2230 15 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 2230 16 , , , 40436 2230 17 that that DT 40436 2230 18 of of IN 40436 2230 19 two two CD 40436 2230 20 persons person NNS 40436 2230 21 , , , 40436 2230 22 each each DT 40436 2230 23 of of IN 40436 2230 24 whom whom WP 40436 2230 25 deceives deceive VBZ 40436 2230 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2230 27 friends friend NNS 40436 2230 28 in in IN 40436 2230 29 a a DT 40436 2230 30 manner manner NN 40436 2230 31 to to TO 40436 2230 32 produce produce VB 40436 2230 33 mischief mischief NN 40436 2230 34 , , , 40436 2230 35 the the DT 40436 2230 36 one one NN 40436 2230 37 who who WP 40436 2230 38 does do VBZ 40436 2230 39 so so RB 40436 2230 40 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2230 41 is be VBZ 40436 2230 42 not not RB 40436 2230 43 so so RB 40436 2230 44 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2230 45 as as IN 40436 2230 46 the the DT 40436 2230 47 one one NN 40436 2230 48 who who WP 40436 2230 49 does do VBZ 40436 2230 50 so so RB 40436 2230 51 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2230 52 . . . 40436 2231 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2231 2 73 73 CD 40436 2231 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2231 4 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 2231 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2231 6 like like IN 40436 2231 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2231 8 in in IN 40436 2231 9 this this DT 40436 2231 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2231 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2231 12 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 2231 13 the the DT 40436 2231 14 opposite opposite NN 40436 2231 15 , , , 40436 2231 16 but but CC 40436 2231 17 is be VBZ 40436 2231 18 refuted refute VBN 40436 2231 19 by by IN 40436 2231 20 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2231 21 ; ; : 40436 2231 22 who who WP 40436 2231 23 argues argue VBZ 40436 2231 24 that that IN 40436 2231 25 justice justice NN 40436 2231 26 is be VBZ 40436 2231 27 a a DT 40436 2231 28 matter matter NN 40436 2231 29 to to TO 40436 2231 30 be be VB 40436 2231 31 learnt learn VBN 40436 2231 32 and and CC 40436 2231 33 known know VBN 40436 2231 34 like like IN 40436 2231 35 letters letter NNS 40436 2231 36 ; ; : 40436 2231 37 that that IN 40436 2231 38 the the DT 40436 2231 39 lettered letter VBN 40436 2231 40 man man NN 40436 2231 41 , , , 40436 2231 42 who who WP 40436 2231 43 has have VBZ 40436 2231 44 learnt learn VBN 40436 2231 45 and and CC 40436 2231 46 knows know VBZ 40436 2231 47 letters letter NNS 40436 2231 48 , , , 40436 2231 49 can can MD 40436 2231 50 write write VB 40436 2231 51 wrongly wrongly RB 40436 2231 52 when when WRB 40436 2231 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2231 54 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2231 55 , , , 40436 2231 56 but but CC 40436 2231 57 never never RB 40436 2231 58 writes write VBZ 40436 2231 59 wrongly wrongly RB 40436 2231 60 unless unless IN 40436 2231 61 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2231 62 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2231 63 -- -- : 40436 2231 64 while while IN 40436 2231 65 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2231 66 is be VBZ 40436 2231 67 only only RB 40436 2231 68 the the DT 40436 2231 69 unlettered unlettered JJ 40436 2231 70 man man NN 40436 2231 71 who who WP 40436 2231 72 writes write VBZ 40436 2231 73 wrongly wrongly RB 40436 2231 74 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2231 75 and and CC 40436 2231 76 without without IN 40436 2231 77 intending intend VBG 40436 2231 78 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2231 79 : : : 40436 2231 80 that that IN 40436 2231 81 in in IN 40436 2231 82 like like IN 40436 2231 83 manner manner NN 40436 2231 84 the the DT 40436 2231 85 just just JJ 40436 2231 86 man man NN 40436 2231 87 , , , 40436 2231 88 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2231 89 that that WDT 40436 2231 90 has have VBZ 40436 2231 91 learnt learn VBN 40436 2231 92 and and CC 40436 2231 93 knows know VBZ 40436 2231 94 justice justice NN 40436 2231 95 , , , 40436 2231 96 never never RB 40436 2231 97 commits commit VBZ 40436 2231 98 injustice injustice NN 40436 2231 99 unless unless IN 40436 2231 100 when when WRB 40436 2231 101 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2231 102 intends intend VBZ 40436 2231 103 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2231 104 -- -- : 40436 2231 105 while while IN 40436 2231 106 the the DT 40436 2231 107 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2231 108 man man NN 40436 2231 109 , , , 40436 2231 110 who who WP 40436 2231 111 has have VBZ 40436 2231 112 not not RB 40436 2231 113 learnt learn VBN 40436 2231 114 and and CC 40436 2231 115 does do VBZ 40436 2231 116 not not RB 40436 2231 117 know know VB 40436 2231 118 justice justice NN 40436 2231 119 , , , 40436 2231 120 commits commit VBZ 40436 2231 121 injustice injustice NN 40436 2231 122 whether whether IN 40436 2231 123 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2231 124 will will MD 40436 2231 125 or or CC 40436 2231 126 not not RB 40436 2231 127 . . . 40436 2232 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2232 2 is be VBZ 40436 2232 3 the the DT 40436 2232 4 just just JJ 40436 2232 5 man man NN 40436 2232 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 2232 7 , , , 40436 2232 8 and and CC 40436 2232 9 none none NN 40436 2232 10 but but CC 40436 2232 11 the the DT 40436 2232 12 just just JJ 40436 2232 13 man man NN 40436 2232 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2232 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2232 16 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 2232 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2232 18 , , , 40436 2232 19 who who WP 40436 2232 20 commits commit VBZ 40436 2232 21 injustice injustice NN 40436 2232 22 knowingly knowingly NNP 40436 2232 23 and and CC 40436 2232 24 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2232 25 : : : 40436 2232 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2232 27 is be VBZ 40436 2232 28 the the DT 40436 2232 29 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2232 30 man man NN 40436 2232 31 who who WP 40436 2232 32 commits commit VBZ 40436 2232 33 injustice injustice NN 40436 2232 34 without without IN 40436 2232 35 wishing wish VBG 40436 2232 36 or or CC 40436 2232 37 intending intend VBG 40436 2232 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2232 39 . . . 40436 2233 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2233 2 74 74 CD 40436 2233 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2233 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2233 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2233 6 73 73 CD 40436 2233 7 : : : 40436 2233 8 Xen Xen NNP 40436 2233 9 . . . 40436 2234 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 2234 2 . . . 40436 2235 1 iv iv XX 40436 2235 2 . . . 40436 2236 1 2 2 CD 40436 2236 2 , , , 40436 2236 3 19 19 CD 40436 2236 4 . . . 40436 2237 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2237 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2237 3 : : : 40436 2237 4 tô tô NNP 40436 2237 5 = = SYM 40436 2237 6 n n CC 40436 2237 7 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2237 8 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 2237 9 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 2237 10 phi phi NNP 40436 2237 11 / / SYM 40436 2237 12 lous lous JJ 40436 2237 13 e)xapatô e)xapatô IN 40436 2237 14 / / SYM 40436 2237 15 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 2237 16 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 2237 17 blabê=| blabê=| NNP 40436 2237 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2237 19 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 2237 20 mêde\ mêde\ NNP 40436 2237 21 tou tou NNP 40436 2237 22 = = SYM 40436 2237 23 to to IN 40436 2237 24 paralei paralei NNP 40436 2237 25 / / SYM 40436 2237 26 pômen pôman NNS 40436 2237 27 a)/skepton a)/skepton NNP 40436 2237 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2237 29 po po NNP 40436 2237 30 / / SYM 40436 2237 31 teros teros NNP 40436 2237 32 a)dikô a)dikô NNP 40436 2237 33 / / SYM 40436 2237 34 tero tero NNP 40436 2237 35 / / SYM 40436 2237 36 s s NNP 40436 2237 37 e)stin e)stin NNP 40436 2237 38 , , , 40436 2237 39 o o NNP 40436 2237 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2237 41 e(kô\n e(kô\n NNP 40436 2237 42 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 2237 43 o o NN 40436 2237 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2237 45 a)/kôn a)/kôn NNP 40436 2237 46 ? ? . 40436 2237 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2238 1 The the DT 40436 2238 2 natural natural JJ 40436 2238 3 meaning meaning NN 40436 2238 4 of of IN 40436 2238 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2238 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2238 7 : : : 40436 2238 8 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 2238 9 blabê=| blabê=| NNP 40436 2238 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2238 11 would would MD 40436 2238 12 be be VB 40436 2238 13 , , , 40436 2238 14 " " `` 40436 2238 15 for for IN 40436 2238 16 the the DT 40436 2238 17 purpose purpose NN 40436 2238 18 of of IN 40436 2238 19 mischief mischief NN 40436 2238 20 " " '' 40436 2238 21 ; ; , 40436 2238 22 and and CC 40436 2238 23 Schneider Schneider NNP 40436 2238 24 , , , 40436 2238 25 in in IN 40436 2238 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2238 27 Index Index NNP 40436 2238 28 , , , 40436 2238 29 gives give VBZ 40436 2238 30 " " `` 40436 2238 31 nocendi nocendi NNP 40436 2238 32 causâ causâ NNP 40436 2238 33 " " '' 40436 2238 34 . . . 40436 2239 1 But but CC 40436 2239 2 in in IN 40436 2239 3 that that DT 40436 2239 4 meaning mean VBG 40436 2239 5 the the DT 40436 2239 6 question question NN 40436 2239 7 would would MD 40436 2239 8 involve involve VB 40436 2239 9 an an DT 40436 2239 10 impossibility impossibility NN 40436 2239 11 , , , 40436 2239 12 for for IN 40436 2239 13 the the DT 40436 2239 14 words word NNS 40436 2239 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2239 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2239 17 : : : 40436 2239 18 o o NN 40436 2239 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2239 20 a)/kôn a)/kôn NNP 40436 2239 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2239 22 exclude exclude VB 40436 2239 23 any any DT 40436 2239 24 such such JJ 40436 2239 25 purpose purpose NN 40436 2239 26 . . . 40436 2239 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2240 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2240 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2240 3 74 74 CD 40436 2240 4 : : : 40436 2240 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 2240 6 . . . 40436 2241 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 2241 2 . . . 40436 2242 1 iv iv XX 40436 2242 2 . . . 40436 2243 1 2 2 CD 40436 2243 2 , , , 40436 2243 3 19 19 CD 40436 2243 4 - - SYM 40436 2243 5 22 22 CD 40436 2243 6 . . . 40436 2243 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2244 1 This this DT 40436 2244 2 is be VBZ 40436 2244 3 the the DT 40436 2244 4 same same JJ 40436 2244 5 view view NN 40436 2244 6 which which WDT 40436 2244 7 is be VBZ 40436 2244 8 worked work VBN 40436 2244 9 out out RP 40436 2244 10 by by IN 40436 2244 11 the the DT 40436 2244 12 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2244 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2244 14 in in IN 40436 2244 15 the the DT 40436 2244 16 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2244 17 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2244 18 : : : 40436 2244 19 beginning begin VBG 40436 2244 20 with with IN 40436 2244 21 the the DT 40436 2244 22 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 2244 23 between between IN 40436 2244 24 the the DT 40436 2244 25 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2244 26 and and CC 40436 2244 27 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2244 28 man man NN 40436 2244 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2244 30 as as IN 40436 2244 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2244 32 begins begin VBZ 40436 2244 33 in in IN 40436 2244 34 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 2244 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2244 36 ; ; : 40436 2244 37 and and CC 40436 2244 38 concluding conclude VBG 40436 2244 39 with with IN 40436 2244 40 the the DT 40436 2244 41 general general JJ 40436 2244 42 result result NN 40436 2244 43 -- -- : 40436 2244 44 that that IN 40436 2244 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2244 46 belongs belong VBZ 40436 2244 47 to to IN 40436 2244 48 the the DT 40436 2244 49 good good JJ 40436 2244 50 man man NN 40436 2244 51 to to TO 40436 2244 52 do do VB 40436 2244 53 wrong wrong NN 40436 2244 54 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2244 55 , , , 40436 2244 56 to to IN 40436 2244 57 the the DT 40436 2244 58 bad bad JJ 40436 2244 59 man man NN 40436 2244 60 to to TO 40436 2244 61 do do VB 40436 2244 62 wrong wrong NN 40436 2244 63 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2244 64 . . . 40436 2245 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2245 2 Side side NN 40436 2245 3 - - HYPH 40436 2245 4 note note NN 40436 2245 5 : : : 40436 2245 6 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2245 7 combats combat VBZ 40436 2245 8 the the DT 40436 2245 9 thesis thesis NN 40436 2245 10 . . . 40436 2246 1 Arguments argument NNS 40436 2246 2 against against IN 40436 2246 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2246 4 . . . 40436 2246 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2247 1 Aristotle,[75 Aristotle,[75 NNP 40436 2247 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2247 3 in in IN 40436 2247 4 commenting comment VBG 40436 2247 5 upon upon IN 40436 2247 6 this this DT 40436 2247 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 2247 8 of of IN 40436 2247 9 the the DT 40436 2247 10 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2247 11 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2247 12 , , , 40436 2247 13 remarks remark VBZ 40436 2247 14 justly justly RB 40436 2247 15 , , , 40436 2247 16 that that IN 40436 2247 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2247 18 understands understand VBZ 40436 2247 19 the the DT 40436 2247 20 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2247 21 _ _ NNP 40436 2247 22 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2247 23 _ _ NNP 40436 2247 24 and and CC 40436 2247 25 _ _ NNP 40436 2247 26 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2247 27 _ _ NNP 40436 2247 28 in in IN 40436 2247 29 a a DT 40436 2247 30 sense sense NN 40436 2247 31 different different JJ 40436 2247 32 from from IN 40436 2247 33 that that DT 40436 2247 34 which which WDT 40436 2247 35 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2247 36 usually usually RB 40436 2247 37 bear bear VBP 40436 2247 38 . . . 40436 2248 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2248 2 understands understand VBZ 40436 2248 3 the the DT 40436 2248 4 words word NNS 40436 2248 5 as as IN 40436 2248 6 designating designate VBG 40436 2248 7 one one CD 40436 2248 8 who who WP 40436 2248 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2248 10 can can MD 40436 2248 11 _ _ NNP 40436 2248 12 tell tell VB 40436 2248 13 the the DT 40436 2248 14 truth truth NN 40436 2248 15 if if IN 40436 2248 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2248 17 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2248 18 -- -- : 40436 2248 19 one one CD 40436 2248 20 who who WP 40436 2248 21 _ _ NNP 40436 2248 22 can can MD 40436 2248 23 _ _ NNP 40436 2248 24 speak speak VB 40436 2248 25 falsely falsely RB 40436 2248 26 if if IN 40436 2248 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2248 28 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2248 29 : : : 40436 2248 30 and and CC 40436 2248 31 in in IN 40436 2248 32 this this DT 40436 2248 33 sense sense NN 40436 2248 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2248 35 argues argue VBZ 40436 2248 36 plausibly plausibly RB 40436 2248 37 that that IN 40436 2248 38 the the DT 40436 2248 39 two two CD 40436 2248 40 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2248 41 go go VBP 40436 2248 42 together together RB 40436 2248 43 , , , 40436 2248 44 and and CC 40436 2248 45 that that IN 40436 2248 46 no no DT 40436 2248 47 man man NN 40436 2248 48 can can MD 40436 2248 49 be be VB 40436 2248 50 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2248 51 unless unless IN 40436 2248 52 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2248 53 be be VB 40436 2248 54 also also RB 40436 2248 55 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2248 56 . . . 40436 2249 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2249 2 points point VBZ 40436 2249 3 out out RP 40436 2249 4 that that IN 40436 2249 5 the the DT 40436 2249 6 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2249 7 in in IN 40436 2249 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2249 9 received receive VBN 40436 2249 10 meaning meaning NN 40436 2249 11 are be VBP 40436 2249 12 applied apply VBN 40436 2249 13 , , , 40436 2249 14 not not RB 40436 2249 15 to to IN 40436 2249 16 the the DT 40436 2249 17 power power NN 40436 2249 18 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 2249 19 , , , 40436 2249 20 but but CC 40436 2249 21 to to IN 40436 2249 22 the the DT 40436 2249 23 habitual habitual JJ 40436 2249 24 and and CC 40436 2249 25 intentional intentional JJ 40436 2249 26 use use NN 40436 2249 27 of of IN 40436 2249 28 that that DT 40436 2249 29 power power NN 40436 2249 30 . . . 40436 2250 1 The the DT 40436 2250 2 power power NN 40436 2250 3 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 2250 4 is be VBZ 40436 2250 5 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 2250 6 presupposed presuppose VBN 40436 2250 7 or or CC 40436 2250 8 implied imply VBN 40436 2250 9 as as IN 40436 2250 10 one one CD 40436 2250 11 condition condition NN 40436 2250 12 to to IN 40436 2250 13 the the DT 40436 2250 14 applicability applicability NN 40436 2250 15 of of IN 40436 2250 16 the the DT 40436 2250 17 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2250 18 , , , 40436 2250 19 and and CC 40436 2250 20 is be VBZ 40436 2250 21 one one CD 40436 2250 22 common common JJ 40436 2250 23 condition condition NN 40436 2250 24 to to IN 40436 2250 25 the the DT 40436 2250 26 applicability applicability NN 40436 2250 27 of of IN 40436 2250 28 both both DT 40436 2250 29 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2250 30 : : : 40436 2250 31 but but CC 40436 2250 32 the the DT 40436 2250 33 distinction distinction NN 40436 2250 34 , , , 40436 2250 35 which which WDT 40436 2250 36 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2250 37 are be VBP 40436 2250 38 intended intend VBN 40436 2250 39 to to TO 40436 2250 40 draw draw VB 40436 2250 41 , , , 40436 2250 42 regards regard VBZ 40436 2250 43 the the DT 40436 2250 44 intentions intention NNS 40436 2250 45 and and CC 40436 2250 46 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 2250 47 with with IN 40436 2250 48 which which WDT 40436 2250 49 the the DT 40436 2250 50 power power NN 40436 2250 51 is be VBZ 40436 2250 52 employed employ VBN 40436 2250 53 . . . 40436 2251 1 So so RB 40436 2251 2 also also RB 40436 2251 3 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2251 4 observes observe VBZ 40436 2251 5 that that IN 40436 2251 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2251 7 's 's POS 40436 2251 8 conclusion--"He conclusion--"he NN 40436 2251 9 that that WDT 40436 2251 10 does do VBZ 40436 2251 11 wrong wrong NN 40436 2251 12 wilfully wilfully RB 40436 2251 13 is be VBZ 40436 2251 14 a a DT 40436 2251 15 better well JJR 40436 2251 16 man man NN 40436 2251 17 than than IN 40436 2251 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2251 19 that that WDT 40436 2251 20 does do VBZ 40436 2251 21 wrong wrong VB 40436 2251 22 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2251 23 , , , 40436 2251 24 " " '' 40436 2251 25 is be VBZ 40436 2251 26 falsely falsely RB 40436 2251 27 collected collect VBN 40436 2251 28 from from IN 40436 2251 29 induction induction NN 40436 2251 30 or or CC 40436 2251 31 analogy analogy NN 40436 2251 32 . . . 40436 2252 1 The the DT 40436 2252 2 analogy analogy NN 40436 2252 3 of of IN 40436 2252 4 the the DT 40436 2252 5 special special JJ 40436 2252 6 arts art NNS 40436 2252 7 and and CC 40436 2252 8 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 2252 9 , , , 40436 2252 10 upon upon IN 40436 2252 11 which which WDT 40436 2252 12 the the DT 40436 2252 13 argument argument NN 40436 2252 14 is be VBZ 40436 2252 15 built build VBN 40436 2252 16 , , , 40436 2252 17 is be VBZ 40436 2252 18 not not RB 40436 2252 19 applicable applicable JJ 40436 2252 20 . . . 40436 2253 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2253 2 Better Better NNP 40436 2253 3 _ _ NNP 40436 2253 4 has have VBZ 40436 2253 5 reference reference NN 40436 2253 6 , , , 40436 2253 7 not not RB 40436 2253 8 to to IN 40436 2253 9 the the DT 40436 2253 10 amount amount NN 40436 2253 11 of of IN 40436 2253 12 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2253 13 but but CC 40436 2253 14 to to IN 40436 2253 15 the the DT 40436 2253 16 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 2253 17 and and CC 40436 2253 18 habitual habitual JJ 40436 2253 19 intentions intention NNS 40436 2253 20 ; ; : 40436 2253 21 though though IN 40436 2253 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2253 23 presupposes presuppose VBZ 40436 2253 24 a a DT 40436 2253 25 certain certain JJ 40436 2253 26 state state NN 40436 2253 27 and and CC 40436 2253 28 amount amount NN 40436 2253 29 of of IN 40436 2253 30 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2253 31 as as IN 40436 2253 32 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 2253 33 . . . 40436 2254 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2254 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2254 3 75 75 CD 40436 2254 4 : : : 40436 2254 5 Aristotel Aristotel NNP 40436 2254 6 . . . 40436 2255 1 Metaphys metaphys RB 40436 2255 2 . . . 40436 2256 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2256 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2256 3 : : : 40436 2256 4 D d NN 40436 2256 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2256 6 . . . 40436 2257 1 p. p. NN 40436 2257 2 1025 1025 CD 40436 2257 3 , , , 40436 2257 4 a. a. NN 40436 2258 1 8 8 LS 40436 2258 2 ; ; : 40436 2258 3 compare compare VB 40436 2258 4 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 2258 5 . . . 40436 2259 1 Nikomach Nikomach NNP 40436 2259 2 . . . 40436 2260 1 iv iv XX 40436 2260 2 . . . 40436 2261 1 p. p. NN 40436 2261 2 1127 1127 CD 40436 2261 3 , , , 40436 2261 4 b. b. NNP 40436 2262 1 16 16 CD 40436 2262 2 . . . 40436 2262 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2263 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2263 2 Side side NN 40436 2263 3 - - HYPH 40436 2263 4 note note NN 40436 2263 5 : : : 40436 2263 6 Mistake mistake NN 40436 2263 7 of of IN 40436 2263 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2263 9 and and CC 40436 2263 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2263 11 in in IN 40436 2263 12 dwelling dwell VBG 40436 2263 13 too too RB 40436 2263 14 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 2263 15 on on IN 40436 2263 16 the the DT 40436 2263 17 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 2263 18 conditions condition NNS 40436 2263 19 of of IN 40436 2263 20 human human JJ 40436 2263 21 conduct conduct NN 40436 2263 22 . . . 40436 2263 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2264 1 Both both DT 40436 2264 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2264 3 and and CC 40436 2264 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2264 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2264 6 in in IN 40436 2264 7 many many JJ 40436 2264 8 of of IN 40436 2264 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2264 10 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2264 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2264 12 commit commit VBP 40436 2264 13 the the DT 40436 2264 14 error error NN 40436 2264 15 of of IN 40436 2264 16 which which WDT 40436 2264 17 the the DT 40436 2264 18 above above RB 40436 2264 19 is be VBZ 40436 2264 20 one one CD 40436 2264 21 particular particular JJ 40436 2264 22 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 2264 23 -- -- : 40436 2264 24 that that DT 40436 2264 25 of of IN 40436 2264 26 dwelling dwell VBG 40436 2264 27 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 2264 28 on on IN 40436 2264 29 the the DT 40436 2264 30 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 2264 31 conditions condition NNS 40436 2264 32 of of IN 40436 2264 33 human human NN 40436 2264 34 conduct,[76 conduct,[76 CD 40436 2264 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2264 36 and and CC 40436 2264 37 omitting omit VBG 40436 2264 38 to to TO 40436 2264 39 give give VB 40436 2264 40 proper proper JJ 40436 2264 41 attention attention NN 40436 2264 42 to to IN 40436 2264 43 the the DT 40436 2264 44 emotional emotional JJ 40436 2264 45 and and CC 40436 2264 46 volitional volitional JJ 40436 2264 47 , , , 40436 2264 48 as as IN 40436 2264 49 essentially essentially RB 40436 2264 50 co co JJ 40436 2264 51 - - NNS 40436 2264 52 operating operate VBG 40436 2264 53 or or CC 40436 2264 54 preponderating preponderate VBG 40436 2264 55 in in IN 40436 2264 56 the the DT 40436 2264 57 complex complex JJ 40436 2264 58 meaning meaning NN 40436 2264 59 of of IN 40436 2264 60 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2264 61 attributes attribute NNS 40436 2264 62 . . . 40436 2265 1 The the DT 40436 2265 2 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2265 3 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 2265 4 to to IN 40436 2265 5 the the DT 40436 2265 6 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2265 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2265 8 in in IN 40436 2265 9 the the DT 40436 2265 10 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2265 11 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2265 12 exemplifies exemplify VBZ 40436 2265 13 this this DT 40436 2265 14 one one CD 40436 2265 15 - - HYPH 40436 2265 16 sided sided JJ 40436 2265 17 view view NN 40436 2265 18 . . . 40436 2266 1 What what WP 40436 2266 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2266 3 says say VBZ 40436 2266 4 is be VBZ 40436 2266 5 true true JJ 40436 2266 6 , , , 40436 2266 7 but but CC 40436 2266 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2266 9 is be VBZ 40436 2266 10 only only RB 40436 2266 11 a a DT 40436 2266 12 part part NN 40436 2266 13 of of IN 40436 2266 14 the the DT 40436 2266 15 truth truth NN 40436 2266 16 . . . 40436 2267 1 When when WRB 40436 2267 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2267 3 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2267 4 of of IN 40436 2267 5 a a DT 40436 2267 6 person person NN 40436 2267 7 " " `` 40436 2267 8 who who WP 40436 2267 9 does do VBZ 40436 2267 10 wrong wrong NN 40436 2267 11 unwillingly unwillingly RB 40436 2267 12 , , , 40436 2267 13 " " '' 40436 2267 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2267 15 seems seem VBZ 40436 2267 16 to to TO 40436 2267 17 have have VB 40436 2267 18 in in IN 40436 2267 19 view view NN 40436 2267 20 one one CD 40436 2267 21 who who WP 40436 2267 22 does do VBZ 40436 2267 23 wrong wrong NN 40436 2267 24 without without IN 40436 2267 25 knowing know VBG 40436 2267 26 that that IN 40436 2267 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2267 28 does do VBZ 40436 2267 29 so so RB 40436 2267 30 : : : 40436 2267 31 one one CD 40436 2267 32 whose whose WP$ 40436 2267 33 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2267 34 is be VBZ 40436 2267 35 so so RB 40436 2267 36 defective defective JJ 40436 2267 37 that that IN 40436 2267 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2267 39 does do VBZ 40436 2267 40 not not RB 40436 2267 41 know know VB 40436 2267 42 when when WRB 40436 2267 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2267 44 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2267 45 truth truth NN 40436 2267 46 and and CC 40436 2267 47 when when WRB 40436 2267 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2267 49 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2267 50 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 2267 51 . . . 40436 2268 1 Now now RB 40436 2268 2 a a DT 40436 2268 3 person person NN 40436 2268 4 thus thus RB 40436 2268 5 unhappily unhappily RB 40436 2268 6 circumstanced circumstance VBN 40436 2268 7 must must MD 40436 2268 8 be be VB 40436 2268 9 regarded regard VBN 40436 2268 10 as as IN 40436 2268 11 half half JJ 40436 2268 12 - - HYPH 40436 2268 13 witted witted JJ 40436 2268 14 or or CC 40436 2268 15 imbecile imbecile JJ 40436 2268 16 , , , 40436 2268 17 coming come VBG 40436 2268 18 under under IN 40436 2268 19 the the DT 40436 2268 20 head head NN 40436 2268 21 which which WDT 40436 2268 22 the the DT 40436 2268 23 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 2268 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2268 25 called call VBD 40436 2268 26 _ _ NNP 40436 2268 27 madness_:[77 madness_:[77 NN 40436 2268 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2268 29 unfit unfit JJ 40436 2268 30 to to TO 40436 2268 31 perform perform VB 40436 2268 32 any any DT 40436 2268 33 part part NN 40436 2268 34 in in IN 40436 2268 35 society society NN 40436 2268 36 , , , 40436 2268 37 and and CC 40436 2268 38 requiring require VBG 40436 2268 39 to to TO 40436 2268 40 be be VB 40436 2268 41 placed place VBN 40436 2268 42 under under IN 40436 2268 43 tutelage tutelage NN 40436 2268 44 . . . 40436 2269 1 Compared compare VBN 40436 2269 2 with with IN 40436 2269 3 such such PDT 40436 2269 4 a a DT 40436 2269 5 person person NN 40436 2269 6 , , , 40436 2269 7 the the DT 40436 2269 8 opinion opinion NN 40436 2269 9 of of IN 40436 2269 10 the the DT 40436 2269 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2269 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2269 13 may may MD 40436 2269 14 be be VB 40436 2269 15 defended defend VBN 40436 2269 16 -- -- : 40436 2269 17 that that IN 40436 2269 18 the the DT 40436 2269 19 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2269 20 person person NN 40436 2269 21 , , , 40436 2269 22 who who WP 40436 2269 23 _ _ NNP 40436 2269 24 can can MD 40436 2269 25 _ _ IN 40436 2269 26 tell tell VB 40436 2269 27 truth truth NN 40436 2269 28 when when WRB 40436 2269 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2269 30 chooses choose VBZ 40436 2269 31 , , , 40436 2269 32 is be VBZ 40436 2269 33 the the DT 40436 2269 34 better well JJR 40436 2269 35 of of IN 40436 2269 36 the the DT 40436 2269 37 two two CD 40436 2269 38 in in IN 40436 2269 39 the the DT 40436 2269 40 sense sense NN 40436 2269 41 of of IN 40436 2269 42 less less RBR 40436 2269 43 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 2269 44 or or CC 40436 2269 45 dangerous dangerous JJ 40436 2269 46 . . . 40436 2270 1 But but CC 40436 2270 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2270 3 is be VBZ 40436 2270 4 the the DT 40436 2270 5 object object NN 40436 2270 6 of of IN 40436 2270 7 a a DT 40436 2270 8 very very RB 40436 2270 9 different different JJ 40436 2270 10 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2270 11 ; ; : 40436 2270 12 moreover moreover RB 40436 2270 13 , , , 40436 2270 14 this this DT 40436 2270 15 is be VBZ 40436 2270 16 not not RB 40436 2270 17 the the DT 40436 2270 18 comparison comparison NN 40436 2270 19 present present JJ 40436 2270 20 to to IN 40436 2270 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2270 22 minds mind NNS 40436 2270 23 when when WRB 40436 2270 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2270 25 call call VBP 40436 2270 26 one one CD 40436 2270 27 man man NN 40436 2270 28 veracious veracious JJ 40436 2270 29 , , , 40436 2270 30 another another DT 40436 2270 31 man man NN 40436 2270 32 mendacious mendacious JJ 40436 2270 33 . . . 40436 2271 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 2271 2 always always RB 40436 2271 3 assume assume VBP 40436 2271 4 , , , 40436 2271 5 in in IN 40436 2271 6 every every DT 40436 2271 7 one one CD 40436 2271 8 , , , 40436 2271 9 a a DT 40436 2271 10 measure measure NN 40436 2271 11 of of IN 40436 2271 12 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2271 13 equal equal JJ 40436 2271 14 or or CC 40436 2271 15 superior superior JJ 40436 2271 16 to to IN 40436 2271 17 the the DT 40436 2271 18 admissible admissible JJ 40436 2271 19 minimum minimum NN 40436 2271 20 ; ; , 40436 2271 21 under under IN 40436 2271 22 such such JJ 40436 2271 23 assumption assumption NN 40436 2271 24 , , , 40436 2271 25 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2271 26 compare compare VBP 40436 2271 27 two two CD 40436 2271 28 persons person NNS 40436 2271 29 , , , 40436 2271 30 one one CD 40436 2271 31 of of IN 40436 2271 32 whom whom WP 40436 2271 33 speaks speak VBZ 40436 2271 34 to to IN 40436 2271 35 the the DT 40436 2271 36 best good JJS 40436 2271 37 of of IN 40436 2271 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2271 39 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2271 40 and and CC 40436 2271 41 belief belief NN 40436 2271 42 , , , 40436 2271 43 the the DT 40436 2271 44 other other JJ 40436 2271 45 , , , 40436 2271 46 contrary contrary JJ 40436 2271 47 to to IN 40436 2271 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2271 49 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2271 50 and and CC 40436 2271 51 belief belief NN 40436 2271 52 . . . 40436 2272 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 2272 2 approve approve VBP 40436 2272 3 the the DT 40436 2272 4 former former JJ 40436 2272 5 and and CC 40436 2272 6 disapprove disapprove VB 40436 2272 7 the the DT 40436 2272 8 latter latter JJ 40436 2272 9 , , , 40436 2272 10 according accord VBG 40436 2272 11 to to IN 40436 2272 12 the the DT 40436 2272 13 different different JJ 40436 2272 14 intention intention NN 40436 2272 15 and and CC 40436 2272 16 purpose purpose NN 40436 2272 17 of of IN 40436 2272 18 each each DT 40436 2272 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2272 20 as as IN 40436 2272 21 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2272 22 observes observe VBZ 40436 2272 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2272 24 ; ; : 40436 2272 25 that that RB 40436 2272 26 is is RB 40436 2272 27 , , , 40436 2272 28 looking look VBG 40436 2272 29 at at IN 40436 2272 30 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2272 31 under under IN 40436 2272 32 the the DT 40436 2272 33 point point NN 40436 2272 34 of of IN 40436 2272 35 view view NN 40436 2272 36 of of IN 40436 2272 37 emotion emotion NN 40436 2272 38 and and CC 40436 2272 39 volition volition NN 40436 2272 40 -- -- : 40436 2272 41 which which WDT 40436 2272 42 is be VBZ 40436 2272 43 logically logically RB 40436 2272 44 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 40436 2272 45 from from IN 40436 2272 46 the the DT 40436 2272 47 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2272 48 , , , 40436 2272 49 though though IN 40436 2272 50 always always RB 40436 2272 51 acting act VBG 40436 2272 52 in in IN 40436 2272 53 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 2272 54 with with IN 40436 2272 55 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2272 56 . . . 40436 2273 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2273 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2273 3 76 76 CD 40436 2273 4 : : : 40436 2273 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2273 6 has have VBZ 40436 2273 7 very very RB 40436 2273 8 just just RB 40436 2273 9 observations observation NNS 40436 2273 10 on on IN 40436 2273 11 these these DT 40436 2273 12 views view NNS 40436 2273 13 of of IN 40436 2273 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2273 15 , , , 40436 2273 16 and and CC 40436 2273 17 on on IN 40436 2273 18 the the DT 40436 2273 19 incompleteness incompleteness NN 40436 2273 20 of of IN 40436 2273 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2273 22 views view NNS 40436 2273 23 when when WRB 40436 2273 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2273 25 resolved resolve VBD 40436 2273 26 all all DT 40436 2273 27 virtue virtue NN 40436 2273 28 into into IN 40436 2273 29 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2273 30 , , , 40436 2273 31 all all DT 40436 2273 32 vice vice NN 40436 2273 33 into into IN 40436 2273 34 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 2273 35 . . . 40436 2274 1 See see VB 40436 2274 2 , , , 40436 2274 3 among among IN 40436 2274 4 other other JJ 40436 2274 5 passages passage NNS 40436 2274 6 , , , 40436 2274 7 Aristot Aristot NNP 40436 2274 8 . . . 40436 2275 1 Ethica Ethica NNP 40436 2275 2 Magna Magna NNP 40436 2275 3 , , , 40436 2275 4 i. i. NNP 40436 2276 1 1182 1182 CD 40436 2276 2 , , , 40436 2276 3 a. a. NN 40436 2277 1 16 16 CD 40436 2277 2 ; ; : 40436 2277 3 1183 1183 CD 40436 2277 4 , , , 40436 2277 5 b. b. NNP 40436 2278 1 9 9 CD 40436 2278 2 ; ; SYM 40436 2278 3 1190 1190 CD 40436 2278 4 , , , 40436 2278 5 b. b. NNP 40436 2279 1 28 28 CD 40436 2279 2 ; ; : 40436 2279 3 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 2279 4 . . . 40436 2280 1 Eudem Eudem NNP 40436 2280 2 . . . 40436 2281 1 i. i. NNP 40436 2282 1 1216 1216 CD 40436 2282 2 , , , 40436 2282 3 b b NN 40436 2282 4 , , , 40436 2282 5 4 4 CD 40436 2282 6 . . . 40436 2283 1 The the DT 40436 2283 2 remarks remark NNS 40436 2283 3 of of IN 40436 2283 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2283 5 upon upon IN 40436 2283 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2283 7 and and CC 40436 2283 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2283 9 evince evince VBP 40436 2283 10 a a DT 40436 2283 11 real real JJ 40436 2283 12 progress progress NN 40436 2283 13 in in IN 40436 2283 14 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2283 15 theory theory NN 40436 2283 16 . . . 40436 2283 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2284 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2284 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2284 3 77 77 CD 40436 2284 4 : : : 40436 2284 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 2284 6 . . . 40436 2285 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 2285 2 . . . 40436 2286 1 iii iii NNP 40436 2286 2 . . . 40436 2287 1 9 9 CD 40436 2287 2 , , , 40436 2287 3 7 7 CD 40436 2287 4 . . . 40436 2288 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2288 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2288 3 : : . 40436 2288 4 tou\s tou\s VB 40436 2288 5 diêmartêko diêmartêko NN 40436 2288 6 / / SYM 40436 2288 7 tas tas NN 40436 2288 8 , , , 40436 2288 9 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 2288 10 oi oi NNP 40436 2288 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2288 12 polloi\ polloi\ NNP 40436 2288 13 gignô gignô NNP 40436 2288 14 / / SYM 40436 2288 15 skousi skousi NNP 40436 2288 16 , , , 40436 2288 17 mainome mainome JJ 40436 2288 18 / / SYM 40436 2288 19 nous nous JJ 40436 2288 20 kalei kalei NN 40436 2288 21 = = SYM 40436 2288 22 n n NNP 40436 2288 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2288 24 , , , 40436 2288 25 & & CC 40436 2288 26 c. c. NNP 40436 2288 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2288 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2288 29 Side side NN 40436 2288 30 - - HYPH 40436 2288 31 note note NN 40436 2288 32 : : : 40436 2288 33 They -PRON- PRP 40436 2288 34 rely rely VBP 40436 2288 35 too too RB 40436 2288 36 much much RB 40436 2288 37 on on IN 40436 2288 38 the the DT 40436 2288 39 analogy analogy NN 40436 2288 40 of of IN 40436 2288 41 the the DT 40436 2288 42 special special JJ 40436 2288 43 arts art NNS 40436 2288 44 -- -- : 40436 2288 45 They -PRON- PRP 40436 2288 46 take take VBP 40436 2288 47 no no DT 40436 2288 48 note note NN 40436 2288 49 of of IN 40436 2288 50 the the DT 40436 2288 51 tacit tacit JJ 40436 2288 52 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 2288 53 underlying underlie VBG 40436 2288 54 the the DT 40436 2288 55 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2288 56 of of IN 40436 2288 57 praise praise NN 40436 2288 58 and and CC 40436 2288 59 blame blame NN 40436 2288 60 . . . 40436 2288 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2289 1 Again again RB 40436 2289 2 , , , 40436 2289 3 the the DT 40436 2289 4 analogy analogy NN 40436 2289 5 of of IN 40436 2289 6 the the DT 40436 2289 7 special special JJ 40436 2289 8 arts art NNS 40436 2289 9 , , , 40436 2289 10 upon upon IN 40436 2289 11 which which WDT 40436 2289 12 the the DT 40436 2289 13 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2289 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2289 15 dwells dwell NNS 40436 2289 16 in in IN 40436 2289 17 the the DT 40436 2289 18 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2289 19 Minor Minor NNP 40436 2289 20 , , , 40436 2289 21 fails fail VBZ 40436 2289 22 in in IN 40436 2289 23 sustaining sustain VBG 40436 2289 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2289 25 inference inference NN 40436 2289 26 . . . 40436 2290 1 By by IN 40436 2290 2 a a DT 40436 2290 3 good good JJ 40436 2290 4 runner runner NN 40436 2290 5 , , , 40436 2290 6 wrestler wrestler NNP 40436 2290 7 , , , 40436 2290 8 harper harper NNP 40436 2290 9 , , , 40436 2290 10 singer singer NN 40436 2290 11 , , , 40436 2290 12 speaker speaker NNP 40436 2290 13 , , , 40436 2290 14 & & CC 40436 2290 15 c. c. NNP 40436 2290 16 , , , 40436 2290 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2290 18 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 2290 19 mean mean VBP 40436 2290 20 one one CD 40436 2290 21 who who WP 40436 2290 22 can can MD 40436 2290 23 , , , 40436 2290 24 if if IN 40436 2290 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2290 26 pleases please VBZ 40436 2290 27 , , , 40436 2290 28 perform perform VB 40436 2290 29 some some DT 40436 2290 30 one one CD 40436 2290 31 of of IN 40436 2290 32 these these DT 40436 2290 33 operations operation NNS 40436 2290 34 well well RB 40436 2290 35 ; ; : 40436 2290 36 although although IN 40436 2290 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2290 38 can can MD 40436 2290 39 also also RB 40436 2290 40 , , , 40436 2290 41 if if IN 40436 2290 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2290 43 pleases please VBZ 40436 2290 44 , , , 40436 2290 45 perform perform VB 40436 2290 46 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2290 47 badly badly RB 40436 2290 48 . . . 40436 2291 1 But but CC 40436 2291 2 the the DT 40436 2291 3 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2291 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2291 5 good good JJ 40436 2291 6 _ _ NNP 40436 2291 7 or or CC 40436 2291 8 _ _ NNP 40436 2291 9 bad bad JJ 40436 2291 10 _ _ NNP 40436 2291 11 , , , 40436 2291 12 in in IN 40436 2291 13 this this DT 40436 2291 14 case case NN 40436 2291 15 , , , 40436 2291 16 consider consider VB 40436 2291 17 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 2291 18 that that IN 40436 2291 19 element element NN 40436 2291 20 which which WDT 40436 2291 21 was be VBD 40436 2291 22 left leave VBN 40436 2291 23 out out RP 40436 2291 24 , , , 40436 2291 25 and and CC 40436 2291 26 leave leave VB 40436 2291 27 out out RP 40436 2291 28 that that IN 40436 2291 29 element element NN 40436 2291 30 which which WDT 40436 2291 31 was be VBD 40436 2291 32 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 2291 33 considered consider VBN 40436 2291 34 , , , 40436 2291 35 in in IN 40436 2291 36 the the DT 40436 2291 37 former former JJ 40436 2291 38 case case NN 40436 2291 39 . . . 40436 2292 1 The the DT 40436 2292 2 good good JJ 40436 2292 3 singer singer NN 40436 2292 4 is be VBZ 40436 2292 5 declared declare VBN 40436 2292 6 to to TO 40436 2292 7 stand stand VB 40436 2292 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 2292 9 from from IN 40436 2292 10 the the DT 40436 2292 11 bad bad JJ 40436 2292 12 singer singer NN 40436 2292 13 , , , 40436 2292 14 or or CC 40436 2292 15 from from IN 40436 2292 16 the the DT 40436 2292 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2292 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2292 19 : : : 40436 2292 20 i)diô i)diô NNP 40436 2292 21 / / SYM 40436 2292 22 tês tês NNP 40436 2292 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2292 24 , , , 40436 2292 25 who who WP 40436 2292 26 , , , 40436 2292 27 if if IN 40436 2292 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2292 29 sings sing VBZ 40436 2292 30 at at RB 40436 2292 31 all all RB 40436 2292 32 , , , 40436 2292 33 will will MD 40436 2292 34 certainly certainly RB 40436 2292 35 sing sing VB 40436 2292 36 badly badly RB 40436 2292 37 , , , 40436 2292 38 by by IN 40436 2292 39 an an DT 40436 2292 40 attribute attribute NN 40436 2292 41 belonging belong VBG 40436 2292 42 to to IN 40436 2292 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2292 44 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2292 45 and and CC 40436 2292 46 vocal vocal JJ 40436 2292 47 organs organ NNS 40436 2292 48 . . . 40436 2293 1 To to TO 40436 2293 2 sing sing VB 40436 2293 3 well well RB 40436 2293 4 is be VBZ 40436 2293 5 a a DT 40436 2293 6 special special JJ 40436 2293 7 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 2293 8 , , , 40436 2293 9 which which WDT 40436 2293 10 is be VBZ 40436 2293 11 possessed possess VBN 40436 2293 12 only only RB 40436 2293 13 by by IN 40436 2293 14 a a DT 40436 2293 15 few few JJ 40436 2293 16 , , , 40436 2293 17 and and CC 40436 2293 18 which which WDT 40436 2293 19 no no DT 40436 2293 20 man man NN 40436 2293 21 is be VBZ 40436 2293 22 blamed blame VBN 40436 2293 23 for for IN 40436 2293 24 not not RB 40436 2293 25 possessing possess VBG 40436 2293 26 . . . 40436 2294 1 The the DT 40436 2294 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 2294 3 between between IN 40436 2294 4 such such JJ 40436 2294 5 special special JJ 40436 2294 6 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 2294 7 , , , 40436 2294 8 and and CC 40436 2294 9 justice justice NN 40436 2294 10 or or CC 40436 2294 11 rectitude rectitude NN 40436 2294 12 of of IN 40436 2294 13 behaviour behaviour NN 40436 2294 14 , , , 40436 2294 15 is be VBZ 40436 2294 16 well well RB 40436 2294 17 brought bring VBN 40436 2294 18 out out RP 40436 2294 19 in in IN 40436 2294 20 the the DT 40436 2294 21 speech speech NN 40436 2294 22 which which WDT 40436 2294 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2294 24 puts put VBZ 40436 2294 25 into into IN 40436 2294 26 the the DT 40436 2294 27 mouth mouth NN 40436 2294 28 of of IN 40436 2294 29 the the DT 40436 2294 30 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 2294 31 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2294 32 . . . 40436 2295 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2295 2 78 78 CD 40436 2295 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2295 4 " " `` 40436 2295 5 The the DT 40436 2295 6 special special JJ 40436 2295 7 artists artist NNS 40436 2295 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2295 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2295 10 says say VBZ 40436 2295 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2295 12 are be VBP 40436 2295 13 few few JJ 40436 2295 14 in in IN 40436 2295 15 number number NN 40436 2295 16 : : : 40436 2295 17 one one CD 40436 2295 18 of of IN 40436 2295 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2295 20 is be VBZ 40436 2295 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 2295 22 for for IN 40436 2295 23 many many JJ 40436 2295 24 private private JJ 40436 2295 25 citizens citizen NNS 40436 2295 26 . . . 40436 2296 1 But but CC 40436 2296 2 every every DT 40436 2296 3 citizen citizen NN 40436 2296 4 , , , 40436 2296 5 without without IN 40436 2296 6 exception exception NN 40436 2296 7 , , , 40436 2296 8 must must MD 40436 2296 9 possess possess VB 40436 2296 10 justice justice NN 40436 2296 11 and and CC 40436 2296 12 a a DT 40436 2296 13 sense sense NN 40436 2296 14 of of IN 40436 2296 15 shame shame NN 40436 2296 16 : : : 40436 2296 17 if if IN 40436 2296 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2296 19 does do VBZ 40436 2296 20 not not RB 40436 2296 21 , , , 40436 2296 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2296 23 must must MD 40436 2296 24 be be VB 40436 2296 25 put put VBN 40436 2296 26 away away RB 40436 2296 27 as as IN 40436 2296 28 a a DT 40436 2296 29 nuisance nuisance NN 40436 2296 30 -- -- : 40436 2296 31 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 2296 32 , , , 40436 2296 33 society society NN 40436 2296 34 could could MD 40436 2296 35 not not RB 40436 2296 36 be be VB 40436 2296 37 maintained maintain VBN 40436 2296 38 . . . 40436 2296 39 " " '' 40436 2297 1 The the DT 40436 2297 2 special special JJ 40436 2297 3 artist artist NN 40436 2297 4 is be VBZ 40436 2297 5 a a DT 40436 2297 6 citizen citizen NN 40436 2297 7 also also RB 40436 2297 8 ; ; : 40436 2297 9 and and CC 40436 2297 10 as as IN 40436 2297 11 such such JJ 40436 2297 12 , , , 40436 2297 13 must must MD 40436 2297 14 be be VB 40436 2297 15 subject subject JJ 40436 2297 16 to to IN 40436 2297 17 the the DT 40436 2297 18 obligations obligation NNS 40436 2297 19 binding bind VBG 40436 2297 20 on on IN 40436 2297 21 all all DT 40436 2297 22 citizens citizen NNS 40436 2297 23 universally universally RB 40436 2297 24 . . . 40436 2298 1 In in IN 40436 2298 2 predicating predicating NN 40436 2298 3 of of IN 40436 2298 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2298 5 that that IN 40436 2298 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2298 7 is be VBZ 40436 2298 8 _ _ NNP 40436 2298 9 good good JJ 40436 2298 10 _ _ NNP 40436 2298 11 or or CC 40436 2298 12 _ _ NNP 40436 2298 13 bad bad JJ 40436 2298 14 _ _ NNP 40436 2298 15 as as IN 40436 2298 16 a a DT 40436 2298 17 citizen citizen NN 40436 2298 18 , , , 40436 2298 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2298 20 merely merely RB 40436 2298 21 assume assume VBP 40436 2298 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2298 23 to to TO 40436 2298 24 possess possess VB 40436 2298 25 the the DT 40436 2298 26 average average JJ 40436 2298 27 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2298 28 , , , 40436 2298 29 of of IN 40436 2298 30 the the DT 40436 2298 31 community community NN 40436 2298 32 ; ; : 40436 2298 33 and and CC 40436 2298 34 the the DT 40436 2298 35 epithet epithet NN 40436 2298 36 declares declare VBZ 40436 2298 37 whether whether IN 40436 2298 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2298 39 emotional emotional JJ 40436 2298 40 and and CC 40436 2298 41 volitional volitional JJ 40436 2298 42 attributes attribute NNS 40436 2298 43 exceed exceed VBP 40436 2298 44 , , , 40436 2298 45 or or CC 40436 2298 46 fall fall VBP 40436 2298 47 short short RB 40436 2298 48 of of IN 40436 2298 49 , , , 40436 2298 50 the the DT 40436 2298 51 minimum minimum NN 40436 2298 52 required require VBN 40436 2298 53 in in IN 40436 2298 54 the the DT 40436 2298 55 application application NN 40436 2298 56 of of IN 40436 2298 57 that that DT 40436 2298 58 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2298 59 to to IN 40436 2298 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2298 61 social social JJ 40436 2298 62 obligations obligation NNS 40436 2298 63 . . . 40436 2299 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2299 2 is be VBZ 40436 2299 3 thus thus RB 40436 2299 4 that that IN 40436 2299 5 the the DT 40436 2299 6 words word NNS 40436 2299 7 _ _ NNP 40436 2299 8 good good JJ 40436 2299 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2299 10 or or CC 40436 2299 11 _ _ NNP 40436 2299 12 bad bad JJ 40436 2299 13 _ _ NNP 40436 2299 14 when when WRB 40436 2299 15 applied apply VBN 40436 2299 16 to to IN 40436 2299 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2299 18 as as IN 40436 2299 19 a a DT 40436 2299 20 citizen citizen NN 40436 2299 21 , , , 40436 2299 22 have have VBP 40436 2299 23 a a DT 40436 2299 24 totally totally RB 40436 2299 25 different different JJ 40436 2299 26 bearing bearing NN 40436 2299 27 from from IN 40436 2299 28 that that DT 40436 2299 29 which which WDT 40436 2299 30 the the DT 40436 2299 31 same same JJ 40436 2299 32 words word NNS 40436 2299 33 have have VBP 40436 2299 34 when when WRB 40436 2299 35 applied apply VBN 40436 2299 36 to to IN 40436 2299 37 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2299 38 in in IN 40436 2299 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2299 40 character character NN 40436 2299 41 of of IN 40436 2299 42 special special JJ 40436 2299 43 artist artist NN 40436 2299 44 . . . 40436 2300 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2300 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2300 3 78 78 CD 40436 2300 4 : : : 40436 2300 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2300 6 , , , 40436 2300 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2300 8 , , , 40436 2300 9 322 322 CD 40436 2300 10 . . . 40436 2300 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2301 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2301 2 Side side NN 40436 2301 3 - - HYPH 40436 2301 4 note note NN 40436 2301 5 : : : 40436 2301 6 Value value NN 40436 2301 7 of of IN 40436 2301 8 a a DT 40436 2301 9 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 2301 10 of of IN 40436 2301 11 Search Search NNP 40436 2301 12 , , , 40436 2301 13 that that IN 40436 2301 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2301 15 shall shall MD 40436 2301 16 be be VB 40436 2301 17 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 2301 18 , , , 40436 2301 19 and and CC 40436 2301 20 that that IN 40436 2301 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2301 22 shall shall MD 40436 2301 23 bring bring VB 40436 2301 24 before before RB 40436 2301 25 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2301 26 different different JJ 40436 2301 27 aspects aspect NNS 40436 2301 28 of of IN 40436 2301 29 the the DT 40436 2301 30 question question NN 40436 2301 31 under under IN 40436 2301 32 review review NN 40436 2301 33 . . . 40436 2301 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2302 1 The the DT 40436 2302 2 value value NN 40436 2302 3 of of IN 40436 2302 4 these these DT 40436 2302 5 debates debate NNS 40436 2302 6 in in IN 40436 2302 7 the the DT 40436 2302 8 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2302 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2302 10 consists consist VBZ 40436 2302 11 in in IN 40436 2302 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2302 13 raising raise VBG 40436 2302 14 questions question NNS 40436 2302 15 like like IN 40436 2302 16 the the DT 40436 2302 17 preceding preceding NN 40436 2302 18 , , , 40436 2302 19 for for IN 40436 2302 20 the the DT 40436 2302 21 reflection reflection NN 40436 2302 22 of of IN 40436 2302 23 the the DT 40436 2302 24 reader reader NN 40436 2302 25 -- -- : 40436 2302 26 whether whether IN 40436 2302 27 the the DT 40436 2302 28 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2302 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2302 30 may may MD 40436 2302 31 or or CC 40436 2302 32 may may MD 40436 2302 33 not not RB 40436 2302 34 be be VB 40436 2302 35 represented represent VBN 40436 2302 36 as as IN 40436 2302 37 taking take VBG 40436 2302 38 what what WP 40436 2302 39 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2302 40 think think VBP 40436 2302 41 the the DT 40436 2302 42 right right JJ 40436 2302 43 view view NN 40436 2302 44 of of IN 40436 2302 45 the the DT 40436 2302 46 question question NN 40436 2302 47 . . . 40436 2303 1 For for IN 40436 2303 2 a a DT 40436 2303 3 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 2303 4 of of IN 40436 2303 5 Search Search NNP 40436 2303 6 , , , 40436 2303 7 the the DT 40436 2303 8 great great JJ 40436 2303 9 merit merit NN 40436 2303 10 is be VBZ 40436 2303 11 , , , 40436 2303 12 that that IN 40436 2303 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2303 14 should should MD 40436 2303 15 be be VB 40436 2303 16 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 2303 17 ; ; : 40436 2303 18 that that IN 40436 2303 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2303 20 should should MD 40436 2303 21 bring bring VB 40436 2303 22 before before RB 40436 2303 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2303 24 attention attention NN 40436 2303 25 the the DT 40436 2303 26 conditions condition NNS 40436 2303 27 requisite requisite JJ 40436 2303 28 for for IN 40436 2303 29 a a DT 40436 2303 30 right right JJ 40436 2303 31 and and CC 40436 2303 32 proper proper JJ 40436 2303 33 use use NN 40436 2303 34 of of IN 40436 2303 35 these these DT 40436 2303 36 common common JJ 40436 2303 37 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2303 38 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2303 39 , , , 40436 2303 40 and and CC 40436 2303 41 the the DT 40436 2303 42 state state NN 40436 2303 43 of of IN 40436 2303 44 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 2303 45 which which WDT 40436 2303 46 is be VBZ 40436 2303 47 tacitly tacitly RB 40436 2303 48 implied implied JJ 40436 2303 49 whenever whenever WRB 40436 2303 50 any any DT 40436 2303 51 one one NN 40436 2303 52 uses use VBZ 40436 2303 53 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2303 54 . . . 40436 2304 1 No no DT 40436 2304 2 man man NN 40436 2304 3 ever ever RB 40436 2304 4 learns learn VBZ 40436 2304 5 to to TO 40436 2304 6 reflect reflect VB 40436 2304 7 upon upon IN 40436 2304 8 the the DT 40436 2304 9 meaning meaning NN 40436 2304 10 of of IN 40436 2304 11 such such JJ 40436 2304 12 familiar familiar JJ 40436 2304 13 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2304 14 , , , 40436 2304 15 which which WDT 40436 2304 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2304 17 has have VBZ 40436 2304 18 been be VBN 40436 2304 19 using use VBG 40436 2304 20 all all PDT 40436 2304 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2304 22 life life NN 40436 2304 23 -- -- : 40436 2304 24 unless unless IN 40436 2304 25 the the DT 40436 2304 26 process process NN 40436 2304 27 be be VB 40436 2304 28 forced force VBN 40436 2304 29 upon upon IN 40436 2304 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2304 31 attention attention NN 40436 2304 32 by by IN 40436 2304 33 some some DT 40436 2304 34 special special JJ 40436 2304 35 conversation conversation NN 40436 2304 36 which which WDT 40436 2304 37 brings bring VBZ 40436 2304 38 home home RB 40436 2304 39 to to IN 40436 2304 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2304 41 an an DT 40436 2304 42 uncomfortable uncomfortable JJ 40436 2304 43 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2304 44 of of IN 40436 2304 45 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 2304 46 and and CC 40436 2304 47 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 2304 48 . . . 40436 2305 1 If if IN 40436 2305 2 a a DT 40436 2305 3 man man NN 40436 2305 4 intends intend VBZ 40436 2305 5 to to TO 40436 2305 6 acquire acquire VB 40436 2305 7 any any DT 40436 2305 8 grasp grasp NN 40436 2305 9 of of IN 40436 2305 10 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2305 11 or or CC 40436 2305 12 political political JJ 40436 2305 13 theory theory NN 40436 2305 14 , , , 40436 2305 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2305 16 must must MD 40436 2305 17 render render VB 40436 2305 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2305 19 master master NN 40436 2305 20 , , , 40436 2305 21 not not RB 40436 2305 22 only only RB 40436 2305 23 of of IN 40436 2305 24 the the DT 40436 2305 25 sound sound JJ 40436 2305 26 arguments argument NNS 40436 2305 27 and and CC 40436 2305 28 the the DT 40436 2305 29 guiding guide VBG 40436 2305 30 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2305 31 but but CC 40436 2305 32 also also RB 40436 2305 33 of of IN 40436 2305 34 the the DT 40436 2305 35 unsound unsound JJ 40436 2305 36 arguments argument NNS 40436 2305 37 and and CC 40436 2305 38 the the DT 40436 2305 39 misleading misleading JJ 40436 2305 40 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2305 41 , , , 40436 2305 42 which which WDT 40436 2305 43 bear bear VBP 40436 2305 44 upon upon IN 40436 2305 45 each each DT 40436 2305 46 portion portion NN 40436 2305 47 of of IN 40436 2305 48 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2305 49 . . . 40436 2306 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2306 2 Side side NN 40436 2306 3 - - HYPH 40436 2306 4 note note NN 40436 2306 5 : : : 40436 2306 6 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 2306 7 between between IN 40436 2306 8 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 2306 9 and and CC 40436 2306 10 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 2306 11 . . . 40436 2306 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2307 1 There there EX 40436 2307 2 is be VBZ 40436 2307 3 one one CD 40436 2307 4 other other JJ 40436 2307 5 point point NN 40436 2307 6 of of IN 40436 2307 7 similitude similitude JJ 40436 2307 8 deserving deserving NN 40436 2307 9 notice notice NN 40436 2307 10 , , , 40436 2307 11 between between IN 40436 2307 12 the the DT 40436 2307 13 Greater Greater NNP 40436 2307 14 and and CC 40436 2307 15 Lesser Lesser NNP 40436 2307 16 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2307 17 . . . 40436 2308 1 In in IN 40436 2308 2 both both DT 40436 2308 3 of of IN 40436 2308 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2308 5 , , , 40436 2308 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2308 7 makes make VBZ 40436 2308 8 special special JJ 40436 2308 9 complaint complaint NN 40436 2308 10 of of IN 40436 2308 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2308 12 , , , 40436 2308 13 for for IN 40436 2308 14 breaking break VBG 40436 2308 15 the the DT 40436 2308 16 question question NN 40436 2308 17 in in IN 40436 2308 18 pieces piece NNS 40436 2308 19 and and CC 40436 2308 20 picking pick VBG 40436 2308 21 out out RP 40436 2308 22 the the DT 40436 2308 23 minute minute NN 40436 2308 24 puzzling puzzling JJ 40436 2308 25 fragments fragment NNS 40436 2308 26 -- -- : 40436 2308 27 instead instead RB 40436 2308 28 of of IN 40436 2308 29 keeping keep VBG 40436 2308 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2308 31 together together RB 40436 2308 32 as as IN 40436 2308 33 a a DT 40436 2308 34 whole whole NN 40436 2308 35 , , , 40436 2308 36 and and CC 40436 2308 37 applying apply VBG 40436 2308 38 to to IN 40436 2308 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2308 40 the the DT 40436 2308 41 predicates predicate NNS 40436 2308 42 which which WDT 40436 2308 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2308 44 merits merit VBZ 40436 2308 45 when when WRB 40436 2308 46 so so RB 40436 2308 47 considered consider VBD 40436 2308 48 . . . 40436 2309 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2309 2 79 79 CD 40436 2309 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2309 4 Here here RB 40436 2309 5 is be VBZ 40436 2309 6 the the DT 40436 2309 7 standing stand VBG 40436 2309 8 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 2309 9 between between IN 40436 2309 10 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 2309 11 and and CC 40436 2309 12 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 2309 13 : : : 40436 2309 14 between between IN 40436 2309 15 those those DT 40436 2309 16 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 2309 17 acquired acquire VBN 40436 2309 18 mental mental JJ 40436 2309 19 combinations combination NNS 40436 2309 20 which which WDT 40436 2309 21 are be VBP 40436 2309 22 poured pour VBN 40436 2309 23 out out RP 40436 2309 24 in in IN 40436 2309 25 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 2309 26 , , , 40436 2309 27 impressive impressive JJ 40436 2309 28 , , , 40436 2309 29 unconditional unconditional JJ 40436 2309 30 , , , 40436 2309 31 and and CC 40436 2309 32 undistinguishing undistinguishe VBG 40436 2309 33 generalities generality NNS 40436 2309 34 -- -- : 40436 2309 35 and and CC 40436 2309 36 the the DT 40436 2309 37 logical logical JJ 40436 2309 38 analysis analysis NN 40436 2309 39 which which WDT 40436 2309 40 resolves resolve VBZ 40436 2309 41 the the DT 40436 2309 42 generality generality NN 40436 2309 43 into into IN 40436 2309 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2309 45 specialities speciality NNS 40436 2309 46 , , , 40436 2309 47 bringing bring VBG 40436 2309 48 to to TO 40436 2309 49 view view VB 40436 2309 50 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 40436 2309 51 , , , 40436 2309 52 contradictions contradiction NNS 40436 2309 53 , , , 40436 2309 54 limits limit NNS 40436 2309 55 , , , 40436 2309 56 qualifications qualification NNS 40436 2309 57 , , , 40436 2309 58 & & CC 40436 2309 59 c. c. NNP 40436 2309 60 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2309 61 have have VBP 40436 2309 62 already already RB 40436 2309 63 touched touch VBN 40436 2309 64 upon upon IN 40436 2309 65 this this DT 40436 2309 66 at at IN 40436 2309 67 the the DT 40436 2309 68 close close NN 40436 2309 69 of of IN 40436 2309 70 the the DT 40436 2309 71 Greater Greater NNP 40436 2309 72 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2309 73 . . . 40436 2310 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2310 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2310 3 79 79 CD 40436 2310 4 : : : 40436 2310 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2310 6 , , , 40436 2310 7 Hipp Hipp NNP 40436 2310 8 . . . 40436 2311 1 Min Min NNP 40436 2311 2 . . . 40436 2312 1 369 369 CD 40436 2312 2 B B NNP 40436 2312 3 - - HYPH 40436 2312 4 C. C. NNP 40436 2312 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2312 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2312 7 : : : 40436 2312 8 Ô)= ô)= XX 40436 2312 9 Sô Sô NNP 40436 2312 10 / / SYM 40436 2312 11 krates krate NNS 40436 2312 12 , , , 40436 2312 13 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 2312 14 su/ su/ NNP 40436 2312 15 tinas tinas NNP 40436 2312 16 toiou toiou NNP 40436 2312 17 / / SYM 40436 2312 18 tous tous JJ 40436 2312 19 ple ple NNP 40436 2312 20 / / SYM 40436 2312 21 keis keis NNP 40436 2312 22 lo lo NNP 40436 2312 23 / / SYM 40436 2312 24 gous gous NNP 40436 2312 25 , , , 40436 2312 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2312 27 a)polamba a)polamba NNP 40436 2312 28 / / SYM 40436 2312 29 nôn nôn NN 40436 2312 30 o(/ o(/ JJ 40436 2312 31 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2312 32 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 2312 33 duschere duschere NNP 40436 2312 34 / / SYM 40436 2312 35 staton staton NNP 40436 2312 36 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2312 37 lo lo NNP 40436 2312 38 / / SYM 40436 2312 39 gou gou NNP 40436 2312 40 , , , 40436 2312 41 tou tou NNP 40436 2312 42 / / SYM 40436 2312 43 tou tou NNP 40436 2312 44 e)/chei e)/chei NNP 40436 2312 45 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 2312 46 smikro\n smikro\n ADD 40436 2312 47 e)phapto e)phapto NNP 40436 2312 48 / / SYM 40436 2312 49 menos menos NNP 40436 2312 50 , , , 40436 2312 51 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2312 52 ou)ch ou)ch NNP 40436 2312 53 o(/lô o(/lô CD 40436 2312 54 a)gôni a)gôni NNP 40436 2312 55 / / SYM 40436 2312 56 zei zei NNP 40436 2312 57 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 2312 58 pra pra NNP 40436 2312 59 / / SYM 40436 2312 60 gmati gmati NNS 40436 2312 61 , , , 40436 2312 62 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 2312 63 o(/tou o(/tou NNP 40436 2312 64 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2312 65 o o NNP 40436 2312 66 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2312 67 lo lo NNP 40436 2312 68 / / SYM 40436 2312 69 gos gos NNP 40436 2312 70 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 2312 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2312 72 , , , 40436 2312 73 & & CC 40436 2312 74 c. c. NNP 40436 2312 75 A a DT 40436 2312 76 remark remark NN 40436 2312 77 of of IN 40436 2312 78 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2312 79 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2312 80 Topica Topica NNP 40436 2312 81 , , , 40436 2312 82 viii viii JJ 40436 2312 83 . . . 40436 2313 1 164 164 CD 40436 2313 2 , , , 40436 2313 3 b. b. NNP 40436 2314 1 2 2 LS 40436 2314 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2314 3 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40436 2314 4 this this DT 40436 2314 5 dissecting dissect VBG 40436 2314 6 function function NN 40436 2314 7 of of IN 40436 2314 8 the the DT 40436 2314 9 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 2314 10 . . . 40436 2315 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2315 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2315 3 : : : 40436 2315 4 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 2315 5 ga ga NNP 40436 2315 6 / / SYM 40436 2315 7 r r NNP 40436 2315 8 , , , 40436 2315 9 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 2315 10 a(plô a(plô NN 40436 2315 11 = = SYM 40436 2315 12 s s NNP 40436 2315 13 ei)pei ei)pei NN 40436 2315 14 = = SYM 40436 2315 15 n n NN 40436 2315 16 , , , 40436 2315 17 dialektiko\s dialektiko\s -LRB- 40436 2315 18 o o FW 40436 2315 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2315 20 protatiko\s protatiko\s NNP 40436 2315 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2315 22 e)nstatiko e)nstatiko NNP 40436 2315 23 / / SYM 40436 2315 24 s s NNP 40436 2315 25 ; ; : 40436 2315 26 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 2315 27 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2315 28 to\ to\ NN 40436 2315 29 me\n me\n NNP 40436 2315 30 protei protei NNP 40436 2315 31 / / SYM 40436 2315 32 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 2315 33 , , , 40436 2315 34 e(\n e(\n NNP 40436 2315 35 poiei poiei NN 40436 2315 36 = = SYM 40436 2315 37 n n CC 40436 2315 38 ta\ ta\ JJ 40436 2315 39 plei plei NN 40436 2315 40 / / SYM 40436 2315 41 ô ô FW 40436 2315 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2315 43 dei= dei= NNP 40436 2315 44 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 2315 45 e(\n e(\n NN 40436 2315 46 o(/lô| o(/lô| NNP 40436 2315 47 lêphthê lêphthê NNP 40436 2315 48 = = SYM 40436 2315 49 nai nai NNP 40436 2315 50 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 2315 51 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 2315 52 o o NN 40436 2315 53 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2315 54 lo lo NNP 40436 2315 55 / / SYM 40436 2315 56 gos gos NNP 40436 2315 57 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2315 58 , , , 40436 2315 59 to\ to\ NN 40436 2315 60 d d NN 40436 2315 61 ' ' '' 40436 2315 62 e)ni e)ni NN 40436 2315 63 / / SYM 40436 2315 64 stasthai stasthai NN 40436 2315 65 , , , 40436 2315 66 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2315 67 e(n e(n NNP 40436 2315 68 polla/ polla/ NN 40436 2315 69 ; ; : 40436 2315 70 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 2315 71 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 2315 72 diairei= diairei= NN 40436 2315 73 , , , 40436 2315 74 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 2315 75 a)nairei= a)nairei= NN 40436 2315 76 , , , 40436 2315 77 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2315 78 me\n me\n NNP 40436 2315 79 didou didou NNP 40436 2315 80 / / SYM 40436 2315 81 s s NNP 40436 2315 82 , , , 40436 2315 83 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2315 84 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2315 85 ou)/ ou)/ RB 40436 2315 86 , , , 40436 2315 87 tô tô NNP 40436 2315 88 = = SYM 40436 2315 89 n n CC 40436 2315 90 proteinome proteinome NNP 40436 2315 91 / / SYM 40436 2315 92 nôn nôn NN 40436 2315 93 . . . 40436 2315 94 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2315 95 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2316 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 2316 2 XIV XIV NNP 40436 2316 3 . . . 40436 2317 1 HIPPARCHUS HIPPARCHUS NNP 40436 2317 2 -- -- : 40436 2317 3 MINOS MINOS NNP 40436 2317 4 . . . 40436 2318 1 In in IN 40436 2318 2 these these DT 40436 2318 3 two two CD 40436 2318 4 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2318 5 , , , 40436 2318 6 Plato plato JJ 40436 2318 7 sets set NNS 40436 2318 8 before before IN 40436 2318 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2318 10 two two CD 40436 2318 11 farther farther JJ 40436 2318 12 specimens specimen NNS 40436 2318 13 of of IN 40436 2318 14 that that DT 40436 2318 15 error error NN 40436 2318 16 and and CC 40436 2318 17 confusion confusion NN 40436 2318 18 which which WDT 40436 2318 19 beset beset VBP 40436 2318 20 the the DT 40436 2318 21 enquirer enquirer NN 40436 2318 22 during during IN 40436 2318 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2318 24 search search NN 40436 2318 25 after after IN 40436 2318 26 " " `` 40436 2318 27 reasoned reasoned JJ 40436 2318 28 truth truth NN 40436 2318 29 " " '' 40436 2318 30 . . . 40436 2319 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2319 2 forces force NNS 40436 2319 3 upon upon IN 40436 2319 4 the the DT 40436 2319 5 attention attention NN 40436 2319 6 of of IN 40436 2319 7 a a DT 40436 2319 8 companion companion NN 40436 2319 9 two two CD 40436 2319 10 of of IN 40436 2319 11 the the DT 40436 2319 12 most most RBS 40436 2319 13 familiar familiar JJ 40436 2319 14 words word NNS 40436 2319 15 of of IN 40436 2319 16 the the DT 40436 2319 17 market market NN 40436 2319 18 - - HYPH 40436 2319 19 place place NN 40436 2319 20 , , , 40436 2319 21 to to TO 40436 2319 22 see see VB 40436 2319 23 whether whether IN 40436 2319 24 a a DT 40436 2319 25 clear clear JJ 40436 2319 26 explanation explanation NN 40436 2319 27 of of IN 40436 2319 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2319 29 meaning meaning NN 40436 2319 30 can can MD 40436 2319 31 be be VB 40436 2319 32 obtained obtain VBN 40436 2319 33 . . . 40436 2320 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2320 2 Side side NN 40436 2320 3 - - HYPH 40436 2320 4 note note NN 40436 2320 5 : : : 40436 2320 6 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2320 7 -- -- : 40436 2320 8 Question question NN 40436 2320 9 -- -- : 40436 2320 10 What what WP 40436 2320 11 is be VBZ 40436 2320 12 the the DT 40436 2320 13 definition definition NN 40436 2320 14 of of IN 40436 2320 15 Lover Lover NNP 40436 2320 16 of of IN 40436 2320 17 Gain Gain NNP 40436 2320 18 ? ? . 40436 2321 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2321 2 is be VBZ 40436 2321 3 one one CD 40436 2321 4 who who WP 40436 2321 5 thinks think VBZ 40436 2321 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2321 7 right right JJ 40436 2321 8 to to TO 40436 2321 9 gain gain VB 40436 2321 10 from from IN 40436 2321 11 things thing NNS 40436 2321 12 worth worth JJ 40436 2321 13 nothing nothing NN 40436 2321 14 . . . 40436 2322 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2322 2 cross cross NN 40436 2322 3 - - NNS 40436 2322 4 examines examine NNS 40436 2322 5 upon upon IN 40436 2322 6 this this DT 40436 2322 7 explanation explanation NN 40436 2322 8 . . . 40436 2323 1 No no DT 40436 2323 2 man man NN 40436 2323 3 expects expect VBZ 40436 2323 4 to to TO 40436 2323 5 gain gain VB 40436 2323 6 from from IN 40436 2323 7 things thing NNS 40436 2323 8 which which WDT 40436 2323 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2323 10 knows know VBZ 40436 2323 11 to to TO 40436 2323 12 be be VB 40436 2323 13 worth worth JJ 40436 2323 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 2323 15 : : : 40436 2323 16 in in IN 40436 2323 17 this this DT 40436 2323 18 sense sense NN 40436 2323 19 , , , 40436 2323 20 no no DT 40436 2323 21 man man NN 40436 2323 22 is be VBZ 40436 2323 23 a a DT 40436 2323 24 lover lover NN 40436 2323 25 of of IN 40436 2323 26 gain gain NN 40436 2323 27 . . . 40436 2323 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2324 1 In in IN 40436 2324 2 the the DT 40436 2324 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2324 4 called call VBN 40436 2324 5 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2324 6 , , , 40436 2324 7 the the DT 40436 2324 8 debate debate NN 40436 2324 9 turns turn VBZ 40436 2324 10 on on IN 40436 2324 11 the the DT 40436 2324 12 definition definition NN 40436 2324 13 of of IN 40436 2324 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2324 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2324 16 : : : 40436 2324 17 to\ to\ NN 40436 2324 18 philokerde\s philokerde\s . 40436 2324 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2324 20 or or CC 40436 2324 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2324 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2324 23 : : : 40436 2324 24 o o NNP 40436 2324 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2324 26 philokerdê philokerdê NNP 40436 2324 27 / / , 40436 2324 28 s]--the s]--the DT 40436 2324 29 love love NN 40436 2324 30 of of IN 40436 2324 31 gain gain NN 40436 2324 32 or or CC 40436 2324 33 the the DT 40436 2324 34 lover lover NN 40436 2324 35 of of IN 40436 2324 36 gain gain NN 40436 2324 37 . . . 40436 2325 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2325 2 asks ask VBZ 40436 2325 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2325 4 Companion companion NN 40436 2325 5 to to TO 40436 2325 6 define define VB 40436 2325 7 the the DT 40436 2325 8 word word NN 40436 2325 9 . . . 40436 2326 1 The the DT 40436 2326 2 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2326 3 replies reply VBZ 40436 2326 4 -- -- : 40436 2326 5 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2326 6 is be VBZ 40436 2326 7 one one CD 40436 2326 8 who who WP 40436 2326 9 thinks think VBZ 40436 2326 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2326 11 right right JJ 40436 2326 12 to to TO 40436 2326 13 gain gain VB 40436 2326 14 from from IN 40436 2326 15 things thing NNS 40436 2326 16 worth worth JJ 40436 2326 17 nothing nothing NN 40436 2326 18 . . . 40436 2327 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2327 2 1 1 LS 40436 2327 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2327 4 Does do VBZ 40436 2327 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2327 6 do do VB 40436 2327 7 this this DT 40436 2327 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2327 9 asks ask VBZ 40436 2327 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2327 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2327 12 knowing know VBG 40436 2327 13 that that IN 40436 2327 14 the the DT 40436 2327 15 things thing NNS 40436 2327 16 are be VBP 40436 2327 17 worth worth JJ 40436 2327 18 nothing nothing NN 40436 2327 19 ? ? . 40436 2328 1 or or CC 40436 2328 2 not not RB 40436 2328 3 knowing know VBG 40436 2328 4 ? ? . 40436 2329 1 If if IN 40436 2329 2 the the DT 40436 2329 3 latter latter JJ 40436 2329 4 , , , 40436 2329 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2329 6 is be VBZ 40436 2329 7 simply simply RB 40436 2329 8 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2329 9 . . . 40436 2330 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2330 2 knows know VBZ 40436 2330 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2330 4 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 2330 5 well well RB 40436 2330 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2330 7 is be VBZ 40436 2330 8 the the DT 40436 2330 9 reply reply NN 40436 2330 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2330 11 . . . 40436 2331 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2331 2 is be VBZ 40436 2331 3 cunning cunning JJ 40436 2331 4 and and CC 40436 2331 5 wicked wicked JJ 40436 2331 6 ; ; : 40436 2331 7 and and CC 40436 2331 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2331 9 is be VBZ 40436 2331 10 because because IN 40436 2331 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2331 12 can can MD 40436 2331 13 not not RB 40436 2331 14 resist resist VB 40436 2331 15 the the DT 40436 2331 16 temptation temptation NN 40436 2331 17 of of IN 40436 2331 18 gain gain NN 40436 2331 19 , , , 40436 2331 20 that that IN 40436 2331 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2331 22 has have VBZ 40436 2331 23 the the DT 40436 2331 24 impudence impudence NN 40436 2331 25 to to TO 40436 2331 26 make make VB 40436 2331 27 profit profit NN 40436 2331 28 by by IN 40436 2331 29 such such JJ 40436 2331 30 things thing NNS 40436 2331 31 , , , 40436 2331 32 though though IN 40436 2331 33 well well RB 40436 2331 34 aware aware JJ 40436 2331 35 that that IN 40436 2331 36 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2331 37 are be VBP 40436 2331 38 worth worth JJ 40436 2331 39 nothing nothing NN 40436 2331 40 . . . 40436 2332 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2332 2 Sokr._--Suppose Sokr._--Suppose NNP 40436 2332 3 a a DT 40436 2332 4 husbandman husbandman NN 40436 2332 5 , , , 40436 2332 6 knowing know VBG 40436 2332 7 that that IN 40436 2332 8 the the DT 40436 2332 9 plant plant NN 40436 2332 10 which which WDT 40436 2332 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2332 12 is be VBZ 40436 2332 13 tending tend VBG 40436 2332 14 is be VBZ 40436 2332 15 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2332 16 -- -- : 40436 2332 17 and and CC 40436 2332 18 yet yet RB 40436 2332 19 thinking think VBG 40436 2332 20 that that IN 40436 2332 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2332 22 ought ought MD 40436 2332 23 to to TO 40436 2332 24 gain gain VB 40436 2332 25 by by IN 40436 2332 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2332 27 : : : 40436 2332 28 does do VBZ 40436 2332 29 not not RB 40436 2332 30 that that RB 40436 2332 31 correspond correspond VB 40436 2332 32 to to IN 40436 2332 33 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2332 34 description description NN 40436 2332 35 of of IN 40436 2332 36 the the DT 40436 2332 37 lover lover NN 40436 2332 38 of of IN 40436 2332 39 gain gain NN 40436 2332 40 ? ? . 40436 2333 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2333 2 Comp._--The Comp._--The NNP 40436 2333 3 lover lover NN 40436 2333 4 of of IN 40436 2333 5 gain gain NN 40436 2333 6 , , , 40436 2333 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2333 8 , , , 40436 2333 9 thinks think VBZ 40436 2333 10 that that IN 40436 2333 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2333 12 ought ought MD 40436 2333 13 to to TO 40436 2333 14 gain gain VB 40436 2333 15 from from IN 40436 2333 16 every every DT 40436 2333 17 thing thing NN 40436 2333 18 . . . 40436 2334 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2334 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 2334 3 not not RB 40436 2334 4 answer answer VB 40436 2334 5 in in IN 40436 2334 6 that that DT 40436 2334 7 reckless reckless JJ 40436 2334 8 manner,[2 manner,[2 NN 40436 2334 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2334 10 as as IN 40436 2334 11 if if IN 40436 2334 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2334 13 had have VBD 40436 2334 14 been be VBN 40436 2334 15 wronged wrong VBN 40436 2334 16 by by IN 40436 2334 17 any any DT 40436 2334 18 one one CD 40436 2334 19 ; ; : 40436 2334 20 but but CC 40436 2334 21 answer answer VB 40436 2334 22 with with IN 40436 2334 23 attention attention NN 40436 2334 24 . . . 40436 2335 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2335 2 agree agree VBP 40436 2335 3 that that IN 40436 2335 4 the the DT 40436 2335 5 lover lover NN 40436 2335 6 of of IN 40436 2335 7 gain gain NN 40436 2335 8 knows know VBZ 40436 2335 9 the the DT 40436 2335 10 value value NN 40436 2335 11 of of IN 40436 2335 12 that that DT 40436 2335 13 from from IN 40436 2335 14 which which WDT 40436 2335 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2335 16 intends intend VBZ 40436 2335 17 to to TO 40436 2335 18 derive derive VB 40436 2335 19 profit profit NN 40436 2335 20 ; ; : 40436 2335 21 and and CC 40436 2335 22 that that IN 40436 2335 23 the the DT 40436 2335 24 husbandman husbandman NNP 40436 2335 25 is be VBZ 40436 2335 26 the the DT 40436 2335 27 person person NN 40436 2335 28 cognizant cognizant JJ 40436 2335 29 of of IN 40436 2335 30 the the DT 40436 2335 31 value value NN 40436 2335 32 of of IN 40436 2335 33 plants plant NNS 40436 2335 34 . . . 40436 2336 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2336 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2336 3 : : : 40436 2336 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2336 5 agree agree VBP 40436 2336 6 . . . 40436 2337 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2337 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 2337 3 not not RB 40436 2337 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 2337 5 attempt attempt NN 40436 2337 6 , , , 40436 2337 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2337 8 are be VBP 40436 2337 9 so so RB 40436 2337 10 young young JJ 40436 2337 11 , , , 40436 2337 12 to to TO 40436 2337 13 deceive deceive VB 40436 2337 14 an an DT 40436 2337 15 old old JJ 40436 2337 16 man man NN 40436 2337 17 like like IN 40436 2337 18 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2337 19 , , , 40436 2337 20 by by IN 40436 2337 21 giving give VBG 40436 2337 22 answers answer NNS 40436 2337 23 not not RB 40436 2337 24 in in IN 40436 2337 25 conformity conformity NN 40436 2337 26 with with IN 40436 2337 27 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2337 28 own own JJ 40436 2337 29 admissions admission NNS 40436 2337 30 ; ; : 40436 2337 31 but but CC 40436 2337 32 tell tell VB 40436 2337 33 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2337 34 plainly plainly RB 40436 2337 35 , , , 40436 2337 36 Do do VBP 40436 2337 37 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2337 38 believe believe VB 40436 2337 39 that that IN 40436 2337 40 the the DT 40436 2337 41 experienced experienced JJ 40436 2337 42 husbandman husbandman NN 40436 2337 43 , , , 40436 2337 44 when when WRB 40436 2337 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2337 46 knows know VBZ 40436 2337 47 that that IN 40436 2337 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2337 49 is be VBZ 40436 2337 50 planting plant VBG 40436 2337 51 a a DT 40436 2337 52 tree tree NN 40436 2337 53 worth worth JJ 40436 2337 54 nothing nothing NN 40436 2337 55 , , , 40436 2337 56 thinks think VBZ 40436 2337 57 that that IN 40436 2337 58 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2337 59 shall shall MD 40436 2337 60 gain gain VB 40436 2337 61 by by IN 40436 2337 62 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2337 63 ? ? . 40436 2338 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2338 2 Comp._--No Comp._--No NNP 40436 2338 3 , , , 40436 2338 4 certainly certainly RB 40436 2338 5 : : : 40436 2338 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2338 7 do do VBP 40436 2338 8 not not RB 40436 2338 9 believe believe VB 40436 2338 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2338 11 . . . 40436 2339 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2339 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2339 3 1 1 CD 40436 2339 4 : : : 40436 2339 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2339 6 , , , 40436 2339 7 Hipparch Hipparch NNP 40436 2339 8 . . . 40436 2340 1 225 225 CD 40436 2340 2 A. a. NN 40436 2341 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2341 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2341 3 : : : 40436 2341 4 oi(\ oi(\ NNP 40436 2341 5 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 2341 6 kerdai kerdai NNP 40436 2341 7 / / SYM 40436 2341 8 nein nein NNP 40436 2341 9 a)xiô a)xiô NNP 40436 2341 10 = = SYM 40436 2341 11 sin sin NN 40436 2341 12 a)po\ a)po\ NNP 40436 2341 13 tô tô NNP 40436 2341 14 = = SYM 40436 2341 15 n n NN 40436 2341 16 mêdeno\s mêdeno\s CD 40436 2341 17 a)xi a)xi NNS 40436 2341 18 / / SYM 40436 2341 19 ôn ôn NNP 40436 2341 20 . . . 40436 2341 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2341 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2342 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2342 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2342 3 2 2 CD 40436 2342 4 : : : 40436 2342 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2342 6 , , , 40436 2342 7 Hipparch Hipparch NNP 40436 2342 8 . . . 40436 2343 1 225 225 CD 40436 2343 2 C. C. NNP 40436 2343 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2343 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2343 5 then then RB 40436 2343 6 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 2343 7 to to TO 40436 2343 8 multiply multiply VB 40436 2343 9 illustrations illustration NNS 40436 2343 10 to to IN 40436 2343 11 the the DT 40436 2343 12 same same JJ 40436 2343 13 general general JJ 40436 2343 14 point point NN 40436 2343 15 . . . 40436 2344 1 The the DT 40436 2344 2 good good JJ 40436 2344 3 horseman horseman NN 40436 2344 4 does do VBZ 40436 2344 5 not not RB 40436 2344 6 expect expect VB 40436 2344 7 to to TO 40436 2344 8 gain gain VB 40436 2344 9 by by IN 40436 2344 10 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2344 11 food food NN 40436 2344 12 given give VBN 40436 2344 13 to to IN 40436 2344 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2344 15 horse horse NN 40436 2344 16 : : : 40436 2344 17 the the DT 40436 2344 18 good good JJ 40436 2344 19 pilot pilot NN 40436 2344 20 , , , 40436 2344 21 by by IN 40436 2344 22 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2344 23 tackle tackle NN 40436 2344 24 put put VBN 40436 2344 25 into into IN 40436 2344 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2344 27 ship ship NN 40436 2344 28 : : : 40436 2344 29 the the DT 40436 2344 30 good good JJ 40436 2344 31 commander commander NN 40436 2344 32 , , , 40436 2344 33 by by IN 40436 2344 34 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2344 35 arms arm NNS 40436 2344 36 delivered deliver VBN 40436 2344 37 to to IN 40436 2344 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2344 39 soldiers soldier NNS 40436 2344 40 : : : 40436 2344 41 the the DT 40436 2344 42 good good JJ 40436 2344 43 fifer fifer NNP 40436 2344 44 , , , 40436 2344 45 harper harper NNP 40436 2344 46 , , , 40436 2344 47 bowman bowman NNP 40436 2344 48 , , , 40436 2344 49 by by IN 40436 2344 50 employing employ VBG 40436 2344 51 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2344 52 instruments instrument NNS 40436 2344 53 of of IN 40436 2344 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2344 55 respective respective JJ 40436 2344 56 arts art NNS 40436 2344 57 , , , 40436 2344 58 if if IN 40436 2344 59 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2344 60 know know VBP 40436 2344 61 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2344 62 to to TO 40436 2344 63 be be VB 40436 2344 64 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2344 65 . . . 40436 2345 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2345 2 Side side NN 40436 2345 3 - - HYPH 40436 2345 4 note note NN 40436 2345 5 : : : 40436 2345 6 Gain gain NN 40436 2345 7 is be VBZ 40436 2345 8 good good JJ 40436 2345 9 . . . 40436 2346 1 Every every DT 40436 2346 2 man man NN 40436 2346 3 loves love VBZ 40436 2346 4 good good JJ 40436 2346 5 : : : 40436 2346 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 2346 7 all all DT 40436 2346 8 men man NNS 40436 2346 9 are be VBP 40436 2346 10 lovers lover NNS 40436 2346 11 of of IN 40436 2346 12 gain gain NN 40436 2346 13 . . . 40436 2346 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2347 1 None none NN 40436 2347 2 of of IN 40436 2347 3 these these DT 40436 2347 4 persons person NNS 40436 2347 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2347 6 concludes conclude VBZ 40436 2347 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2347 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2347 9 correspond correspond VBP 40436 2347 10 to to IN 40436 2347 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2347 12 description description NN 40436 2347 13 of of IN 40436 2347 14 the the DT 40436 2347 15 lover lover NN 40436 2347 16 of of IN 40436 2347 17 gain gain NN 40436 2347 18 . . . 40436 2348 1 Where where WRB 40436 2348 2 then then RB 40436 2348 3 can can MD 40436 2348 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2348 5 find find VB 40436 2348 6 a a DT 40436 2348 7 lover lover NN 40436 2348 8 of of IN 40436 2348 9 gain gain NN 40436 2348 10 ? ? . 40436 2349 1 On on IN 40436 2349 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2349 3 explanation explanation NN 40436 2349 4 , , , 40436 2349 5 no no DT 40436 2349 6 man man NN 40436 2349 7 is be VBZ 40436 2349 8 so so RB 40436 2349 9 . . . 40436 2350 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2350 2 3 3 CD 40436 2350 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2350 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2350 5 Comp._--I comp._--i NN 40436 2350 6 mean mean NN 40436 2350 7 , , , 40436 2350 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2350 9 , , , 40436 2350 10 that that IN 40436 2350 11 the the DT 40436 2350 12 lovers lover NNS 40436 2350 13 of of IN 40436 2350 14 gain gain NN 40436 2350 15 are be VBP 40436 2350 16 those those DT 40436 2350 17 , , , 40436 2350 18 who who WP 40436 2350 19 , , , 40436 2350 20 through through IN 40436 2350 21 greediness greediness NN 40436 2350 22 , , , 40436 2350 23 long long RB 40436 2350 24 eagerly eagerly RB 40436 2350 25 for for IN 40436 2350 26 things thing NNS 40436 2350 27 altogether altogether RB 40436 2350 28 petty petty JJ 40436 2350 29 and and CC 40436 2350 30 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2350 31 ; ; : 40436 2350 32 and and CC 40436 2350 33 thus thus RB 40436 2350 34 display display VB 40436 2350 35 a a DT 40436 2350 36 love love NN 40436 2350 37 of of IN 40436 2350 38 gain gain NN 40436 2350 39 . . . 40436 2351 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2351 2 4 4 CD 40436 2351 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2351 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2351 5 Sokr._--Not Sokr._--Not NNP 40436 2351 6 surely surely RB 40436 2351 7 knowing know VBG 40436 2351 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2351 9 to to TO 40436 2351 10 be be VB 40436 2351 11 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2351 12 -- -- : 40436 2351 13 for for IN 40436 2351 14 this this DT 40436 2351 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2351 16 have have VBP 40436 2351 17 shown show VBN 40436 2351 18 to to TO 40436 2351 19 be be VB 40436 2351 20 impossible impossible JJ 40436 2351 21 -- -- : 40436 2351 22 but but CC 40436 2351 23 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2351 24 that that IN 40436 2351 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2351 26 are be VBP 40436 2351 27 worthless worthless JJ 40436 2351 28 , , , 40436 2351 29 and and CC 40436 2351 30 believing believe VBG 40436 2351 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2351 32 to to TO 40436 2351 33 be be VB 40436 2351 34 valuable valuable JJ 40436 2351 35 . . . 40436 2352 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2352 2 Comp._--It Comp._--It NNP 40436 2352 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 2352 4 so so RB 40436 2352 5 . . . 40436 2353 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2353 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 2353 3 gain gain NN 40436 2353 4 is be VBZ 40436 2353 5 the the DT 40436 2353 6 opposite opposite NN 40436 2353 7 of of IN 40436 2353 8 loss loss NN 40436 2353 9 : : : 40436 2353 10 and and CC 40436 2353 11 loss loss NN 40436 2353 12 is be VBZ 40436 2353 13 evil evil JJ 40436 2353 14 and and CC 40436 2353 15 hurt hurt VBN 40436 2353 16 to to IN 40436 2353 17 every every DT 40436 2353 18 one one NN 40436 2353 19 : : : 40436 2353 20 therefore therefore RB 40436 2353 21 gain gain VBP 40436 2353 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2353 23 as as IN 40436 2353 24 the the DT 40436 2353 25 opposite opposite NN 40436 2353 26 of of IN 40436 2353 27 loss loss NN 40436 2353 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2353 29 is be VBZ 40436 2353 30 good good JJ 40436 2353 31 . . . 40436 2354 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2354 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2354 3 . . . 40436 2355 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2355 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 2355 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 2355 4 then then RB 40436 2355 5 that that IN 40436 2355 6 the the DT 40436 2355 7 lovers lover NNS 40436 2355 8 of of IN 40436 2355 9 good good NN 40436 2355 10 are be VBP 40436 2355 11 those those DT 40436 2355 12 whom whom WP 40436 2355 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2355 14 call call VBP 40436 2355 15 lovers lover NNS 40436 2355 16 of of IN 40436 2355 17 gain gain NN 40436 2355 18 ? ? . 40436 2356 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2356 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2356 3 : : : 40436 2356 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2356 5 appears appear VBZ 40436 2356 6 so so RB 40436 2356 7 . . . 40436 2357 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2357 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 2357 3 not not RB 40436 2357 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2357 5 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 2357 6 love love VBP 40436 2357 7 good good RB 40436 2357 8 -- -- : 40436 2357 9 all all DT 40436 2357 10 good good JJ 40436 2357 11 things thing NNS 40436 2357 12 ? ? . 40436 2358 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2358 2 Comp._--Certainly Comp._--Certainly NNP 40436 2358 3 . . . 40436 2359 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2359 2 Sokr._--And Sokr._--And NNP 40436 2359 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2359 4 too too RB 40436 2359 5 , , , 40436 2359 6 and and CC 40436 2359 7 every every DT 40436 2359 8 one one NN 40436 2359 9 else else RB 40436 2359 10 . . . 40436 2360 1 All all DT 40436 2360 2 men man NNS 40436 2360 3 love love VBP 40436 2360 4 good good JJ 40436 2360 5 things thing NNS 40436 2360 6 , , , 40436 2360 7 and and CC 40436 2360 8 hate hate VB 40436 2360 9 evil evil NN 40436 2360 10 . . . 40436 2361 1 Now now RB 40436 2361 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2361 3 agreed agree VBD 40436 2361 4 that that IN 40436 2361 5 gain gain NN 40436 2361 6 was be VBD 40436 2361 7 a a DT 40436 2361 8 good good NN 40436 2361 9 : : : 40436 2361 10 so so IN 40436 2361 11 that that IN 40436 2361 12 by by IN 40436 2361 13 this this DT 40436 2361 14 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2361 15 , , , 40436 2361 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2361 17 appears appear VBZ 40436 2361 18 that that IN 40436 2361 19 all all DT 40436 2361 20 men man NNS 40436 2361 21 are be VBP 40436 2361 22 lovers lover NNS 40436 2361 23 of of IN 40436 2361 24 gain gain NN 40436 2361 25 while while IN 40436 2361 26 by by IN 40436 2361 27 the the DT 40436 2361 28 former former JJ 40436 2361 29 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2361 30 , , , 40436 2361 31 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2361 32 made make VBD 40436 2361 33 out out RP 40436 2361 34 that that IN 40436 2361 35 none none NN 40436 2361 36 were be VBD 40436 2361 37 so so RB 40436 2361 38 . . . 40436 2362 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2362 2 5 5 CD 40436 2362 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2362 4 Which which WDT 40436 2362 5 of of IN 40436 2362 6 the the DT 40436 2362 7 two two CD 40436 2362 8 shall shall MD 40436 2362 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2362 10 adopt adopt VB 40436 2362 11 , , , 40436 2362 12 to to TO 40436 2362 13 avoid avoid VB 40436 2362 14 error error NN 40436 2362 15 . . . 40436 2363 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2363 2 Comp._--We Comp._--We NNP 40436 2363 3 shall shall MD 40436 2363 4 commit commit VB 40436 2363 5 no no DT 40436 2363 6 error error NN 40436 2363 7 , , , 40436 2363 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2363 9 , , , 40436 2363 10 if if IN 40436 2363 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2363 12 rightly rightly RB 40436 2363 13 conceive conceive VBP 40436 2363 14 the the DT 40436 2363 15 lover lover NN 40436 2363 16 of of IN 40436 2363 17 gain gain NN 40436 2363 18 . . . 40436 2364 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2364 2 is be VBZ 40436 2364 3 one one CD 40436 2364 4 who who WP 40436 2364 5 busies busy VBZ 40436 2364 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2364 7 upon upon IN 40436 2364 8 , , , 40436 2364 9 and and CC 40436 2364 10 seeks seek VBZ 40436 2364 11 to to TO 40436 2364 12 gain gain VB 40436 2364 13 from from IN 40436 2364 14 , , , 40436 2364 15 things thing NNS 40436 2364 16 from from IN 40436 2364 17 which which WDT 40436 2364 18 good good JJ 40436 2364 19 men man NNS 40436 2364 20 do do VBP 40436 2364 21 not not RB 40436 2364 22 venture venture VB 40436 2364 23 to to TO 40436 2364 24 gain gain VB 40436 2364 25 . . . 40436 2365 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2365 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2365 3 3 3 CD 40436 2365 4 : : : 40436 2365 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2365 6 . . . 40436 2366 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2366 2 . . . 40436 2367 1 226 226 CD 40436 2367 2 D. D. NNP 40436 2367 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2367 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2367 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2367 6 4 4 CD 40436 2367 7 : : : 40436 2367 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2367 9 . . . 40436 2368 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2368 2 . . . 40436 2369 1 226 226 CD 40436 2369 2 D. D. NNP 40436 2369 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2369 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2369 5 : : : 40436 2369 6 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 2369 7 ' ' '' 40436 2369 8 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 2369 9 , , , 40436 2369 10 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 2369 11 Sô Sô NNP 40436 2369 12 / / SYM 40436 2369 13 krates krate NNS 40436 2369 14 , , , 40436 2369 15 bou bou NNP 40436 2369 16 / / SYM 40436 2369 17 lomai lomai NNP 40436 2369 18 le le NNP 40436 2369 19 / / SYM 40436 2369 20 gein gein NNP 40436 2369 21 tou tou NNP 40436 2369 22 / / SYM 40436 2369 23 tous tous NNP 40436 2369 24 philokerdei philokerdei NNP 40436 2369 25 = = SYM 40436 2369 26 s s NNP 40436 2369 27 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 2369 28 , , , 40436 2369 29 oi(\ oi(\ NNP 40436 2369 30 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 2369 31 / / SYM 40436 2369 32 stote stote NNP 40436 2369 33 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 2369 34 a)plêsti a)plêsti NNP 40436 2369 35 / / SYM 40436 2369 36 as as IN 40436 2369 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2369 38 panu\ panu\ NNP 40436 2369 39 smikra\ smikra\ NNP 40436 2369 40 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2369 41 o)li o)li NNP 40436 2369 42 / / SYM 40436 2369 43 gou gou NN 40436 2369 44 a)/xia a)/xia IN 40436 2369 45 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2369 46 ou)deno\s ou)deno\s NNP 40436 2369 47 gli gli NN 40436 2369 48 / / SYM 40436 2369 49 chontai chontai JJ 40436 2369 50 u(perphuô u(perphuô NNS 40436 2369 51 = = SYM 40436 2369 52 s s NNP 40436 2369 53 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2369 54 philokerdou philokerdou NNP 40436 2369 55 = = SYM 40436 2369 56 sin sin NN 40436 2369 57 . . . 40436 2369 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2369 59 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2370 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2370 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2370 3 5 5 CD 40436 2370 4 : : : 40436 2370 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2370 6 . . . 40436 2371 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2371 2 . . . 40436 2372 1 227 227 CD 40436 2372 2 C. c. NN 40436 2372 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2372 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2372 5 Side side NN 40436 2372 6 - - HYPH 40436 2372 7 note note NN 40436 2372 8 : : : 40436 2372 9 Apparent apparent JJ 40436 2372 10 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 2372 11 . . . 40436 2373 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2373 2 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 2373 3 the the DT 40436 2373 4 companion companion NN 40436 2373 5 of of IN 40436 2373 6 trying try VBG 40436 2373 7 to to TO 40436 2373 8 deceive deceive VB 40436 2373 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2373 10 . . . 40436 2374 1 Accusation accusation NN 40436 2374 2 is be VBZ 40436 2374 3 retorted retort VBN 40436 2374 4 upon upon IN 40436 2374 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2374 6 . . . 40436 2374 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2375 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2375 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 2375 3 , , , 40436 2375 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2375 5 friend friend NN 40436 2375 6 , , , 40436 2375 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2375 8 agreed agree VBD 40436 2375 9 just just RB 40436 2375 10 now now RB 40436 2375 11 , , , 40436 2375 12 that that IN 40436 2375 13 gain gain NN 40436 2375 14 was be VBD 40436 2375 15 a a DT 40436 2375 16 good good JJ 40436 2375 17 , , , 40436 2375 18 and and CC 40436 2375 19 that that IN 40436 2375 20 all all DT 40436 2375 21 men man NNS 40436 2375 22 always always RB 40436 2375 23 love love VBP 40436 2375 24 good good JJ 40436 2375 25 . . . 40436 2376 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2376 2 follows follow VBZ 40436 2376 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 2376 4 , , , 40436 2376 5 that that IN 40436 2376 6 good good JJ 40436 2376 7 men man NNS 40436 2376 8 as as RB 40436 2376 9 well well RB 40436 2376 10 as as IN 40436 2376 11 others other NNS 40436 2376 12 love love VBP 40436 2376 13 all all DT 40436 2376 14 gains gain NNS 40436 2376 15 , , , 40436 2376 16 if if IN 40436 2376 17 gains gain NNS 40436 2376 18 are be VBP 40436 2376 19 good good JJ 40436 2376 20 things thing NNS 40436 2376 21 . . . 40436 2377 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2377 2 Comp._--Not Comp._--Not NNP 40436 2377 3 , , , 40436 2377 4 certainly certainly RB 40436 2377 5 , , , 40436 2377 6 those those DT 40436 2377 7 gains gain NNS 40436 2377 8 by by IN 40436 2377 9 which which WDT 40436 2377 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2377 11 will will MD 40436 2377 12 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 2377 13 be be VB 40436 2377 14 hurt hurt VBN 40436 2377 15 . . . 40436 2378 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2378 2 Sokr._--Be Sokr._--Be NNP 40436 2378 3 hurt hurt NN 40436 2378 4 : : : 40436 2378 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2378 6 mean mean VBP 40436 2378 7 , , , 40436 2378 8 by by IN 40436 2378 9 which which WDT 40436 2378 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2378 11 will will MD 40436 2378 12 become become VB 40436 2378 13 losers loser NNS 40436 2378 14 . . . 40436 2379 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2379 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNP 40436 2379 3 mean mean VBP 40436 2379 4 that that DT 40436 2379 5 and and CC 40436 2379 6 nothing nothing NN 40436 2379 7 else else RB 40436 2379 8 . . . 40436 2380 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2380 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 2380 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2380 4 become become VBP 40436 2380 5 losers loser NNS 40436 2380 6 by by IN 40436 2380 7 gain gain NN 40436 2380 8 , , , 40436 2380 9 or or CC 40436 2380 10 by by IN 40436 2380 11 loss loss NN 40436 2380 12 ? ? . 40436 2381 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2381 2 Comp._--By Comp._--By NNP 40436 2381 3 both both DT 40436 2381 4 : : : 40436 2381 5 by by IN 40436 2381 6 loss loss NN 40436 2381 7 , , , 40436 2381 8 and and CC 40436 2381 9 by by IN 40436 2381 10 evil evil JJ 40436 2381 11 gain gain NN 40436 2381 12 . . . 40436 2382 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2382 2 Sokr._--Does Sokr._--Does NNP 40436 2382 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2382 4 appear appear VBP 40436 2382 5 to to IN 40436 2382 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2382 7 that that IN 40436 2382 8 any any DT 40436 2382 9 useful useful JJ 40436 2382 10 and and CC 40436 2382 11 good good JJ 40436 2382 12 thing thing NN 40436 2382 13 is be VBZ 40436 2382 14 evil evil JJ 40436 2382 15 ? ? . 40436 2383 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2383 2 Comp._--No Comp._--No NNP 40436 2383 3 . . . 40436 2384 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2384 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 2384 3 ! ! . 40436 2385 1 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2385 2 agreed agree VBD 40436 2385 3 just just RB 40436 2385 4 now now RB 40436 2385 5 that that IN 40436 2385 6 gain gain NN 40436 2385 7 was be VBD 40436 2385 8 the the DT 40436 2385 9 opposite opposite NN 40436 2385 10 of of IN 40436 2385 11 loss loss NN 40436 2385 12 , , , 40436 2385 13 which which WDT 40436 2385 14 was be VBD 40436 2385 15 evil evil JJ 40436 2385 16 ; ; : 40436 2385 17 and and CC 40436 2385 18 that that IN 40436 2385 19 , , , 40436 2385 20 being be VBG 40436 2385 21 the the DT 40436 2385 22 opposite opposite NN 40436 2385 23 of of IN 40436 2385 24 evil evil NN 40436 2385 25 , , , 40436 2385 26 gain gain NN 40436 2385 27 was be VBD 40436 2385 28 good good JJ 40436 2385 29 . . . 40436 2386 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2386 2 Comp._--That Comp._--That NNP 40436 2386 3 was be VBD 40436 2386 4 what what WP 40436 2386 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2386 6 agreed agree VBD 40436 2386 7 . . . 40436 2387 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2387 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 2387 3 see see VB 40436 2387 4 how how WRB 40436 2387 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2387 6 is be VBZ 40436 2387 7 : : : 40436 2387 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2387 9 are be VBP 40436 2387 10 trying try VBG 40436 2387 11 to to TO 40436 2387 12 deceive deceive VB 40436 2387 13 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2387 14 : : : 40436 2387 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2387 16 purposely purposely RB 40436 2387 17 contradict contradict VBP 40436 2387 18 what what WP 40436 2387 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2387 20 just just RB 40436 2387 21 now now RB 40436 2387 22 agreed agree VBD 40436 2387 23 upon upon IN 40436 2387 24 . . . 40436 2388 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2388 2 Comp._--Not Comp._--Not NNP 40436 2388 3 at at RB 40436 2388 4 all all RB 40436 2388 5 , , , 40436 2388 6 by by IN 40436 2388 7 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 2388 8 : : : 40436 2388 9 on on IN 40436 2388 10 the the DT 40436 2388 11 contrary contrary NN 40436 2388 12 , , , 40436 2388 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2388 14 is be VBZ 40436 2388 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2388 16 , , , 40436 2388 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2388 18 , , , 40436 2388 19 who who WP 40436 2388 20 deceive deceive VBP 40436 2388 21 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2388 22 , , , 40436 2388 23 wriggling wriggle VBG 40436 2388 24 up up IN 40436 2388 25 and and CC 40436 2388 26 down down RB 40436 2388 27 in in IN 40436 2388 28 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2388 29 talk talk NN 40436 2388 30 , , , 40436 2388 31 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2388 32 can can MD 40436 2388 33 not not RB 40436 2388 34 tell tell VB 40436 2388 35 how how WRB 40436 2388 36 . . . 40436 2389 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2389 2 6 6 CD 40436 2389 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2389 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2389 5 Sokr._--Be Sokr._--Be VBD 40436 2389 6 careful careful JJ 40436 2389 7 what what WP 40436 2389 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2389 9 say say VBP 40436 2389 10 : : : 40436 2389 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2389 12 should should MD 40436 2389 13 be be VB 40436 2389 14 very very RB 40436 2389 15 culpable culpable JJ 40436 2389 16 , , , 40436 2389 17 if if IN 40436 2389 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2389 19 disobeyed disobey VBD 40436 2389 20 a a DT 40436 2389 21 good good JJ 40436 2389 22 and and CC 40436 2389 23 wise wise JJ 40436 2389 24 monitor monitor NN 40436 2389 25 . . . 40436 2390 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2390 2 Comp._--Whom Comp._--Whom NNP 40436 2390 3 do do VBP 40436 2390 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2390 5 mean mean VB 40436 2390 6 : : : 40436 2390 7 and and CC 40436 2390 8 what what WP 40436 2390 9 do do VBP 40436 2390 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2390 11 mean mean VB 40436 2390 12 ? ? . 40436 2391 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2391 2 Sokr._--Hipparchus Sokr._--Hipparchus NNP 40436 2391 3 , , , 40436 2391 4 son son NN 40436 2391 5 of of IN 40436 2391 6 Peisistratus Peisistratus NNP 40436 2391 7 . . . 40436 2392 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2392 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2392 3 6 6 CD 40436 2392 4 : : : 40436 2392 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2392 6 . . . 40436 2393 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2393 2 . . . 40436 2394 1 228 228 CD 40436 2394 2 A. a. NN 40436 2395 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2395 2 Sokr._--[Greek sokr._--[greek NN 40436 2395 3 : : : 40436 2395 4 O(ra=|s O(ra=|s NNP 40436 2395 5 ou)=n ou)=n JJ 40436 2395 6 ? ? . 40436 2396 1 e)picheirei e)picheirei NFP 40436 2396 2 = = SYM 40436 2396 3 s s VBZ 40436 2396 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2396 5 e)xapata=|n e)xapata=|n NNP 40436 2396 6 , , , 40436 2396 7 e)pi e)pi NN 40436 2396 8 / / SYM 40436 2396 9 têdes têde NNS 40436 2396 10 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 2396 11 / / SYM 40436 2396 12 a a DT 40436 2396 13 le le NNP 40436 2396 14 / / SYM 40436 2396 15 gôn gôn NN 40436 2396 16 oi(=s oi(=s `` 40436 2396 17 a)/rti a)/rti NNP 40436 2396 18 ô(mologê ô(mologê NNP 40436 2396 19 / / NFP 40436 2396 20 samen saman NNS 40436 2396 21 . . . 40436 2396 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2397 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2397 2 Comp Comp NNP 40436 2397 3 . . . 40436 2397 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2397 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2397 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2397 7 : : : 40436 2397 8 Ou Ou NNP 40436 2397 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2397 10 ma\ ma\ JJ 40436 2397 11 Di/ Di/ NNP 40436 2397 12 ' ' '' 40436 2397 13 , , , 40436 2397 14 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 2397 15 Sô Sô NNP 40436 2397 16 / / SYM 40436 2397 17 krates krate NNS 40436 2397 18 ; ; : 40436 2397 19 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 2397 20 tou)nanti tou)nanti NNP 40436 2397 21 / / SYM 40436 2397 22 on on IN 40436 2397 23 su\ su\ NN 40436 2397 24 e)me\ e)me\ NNP 40436 2397 25 e)xapata=|s e)xapata=|s NNP 40436 2397 26 , , , 40436 2397 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2397 28 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 2397 29 oi)=da oi)=da NNP 40436 2397 30 o(pê=| o(pê=| NNP 40436 2397 31 e)n e)n NNP 40436 2397 32 toi toi NNP 40436 2397 33 = = SYM 40436 2397 34 s s NNP 40436 2397 35 lo lo NNP 40436 2397 36 / / SYM 40436 2397 37 gois gois NNP 40436 2397 38 a)/nô a)/nô NNPS 40436 2397 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2397 40 ka ka NNP 40436 2397 41 / / SYM 40436 2397 42 tô tô NNP 40436 2397 43 stre stre NNP 40436 2397 44 / / SYM 40436 2397 45 pheis pheis NNP 40436 2397 46 . . . 40436 2397 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2397 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2398 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2398 2 Side side NN 40436 2398 3 - - HYPH 40436 2398 4 note note NN 40436 2398 5 : : : 40436 2398 6 Precept Precept NNP 40436 2398 7 inscribed inscribe VBN 40436 2398 8 formerly formerly RB 40436 2398 9 by by IN 40436 2398 10 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2398 11 the the DT 40436 2398 12 Peisistratid--"Never Peisistratid--"Never NNP 40436 2398 13 deceive deceive VB 40436 2398 14 a a DT 40436 2398 15 friend friend NN 40436 2398 16 " " '' 40436 2398 17 . . . 40436 2399 1 Eulogy eulogy NN 40436 2399 2 of of IN 40436 2399 3 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2399 4 by by IN 40436 2399 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2399 6 . . . 40436 2399 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2400 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2400 2 then then RB 40436 2400 3 describes describe VBZ 40436 2400 4 at at IN 40436 2400 5 some some DT 40436 2400 6 length length NN 40436 2400 7 the the DT 40436 2400 8 excellent excellent JJ 40436 2400 9 character character NN 40436 2400 10 of of IN 40436 2400 11 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2400 12 : : : 40436 2400 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2400 14 beneficent beneficent JJ 40436 2400 15 rule rule NN 40436 2400 16 , , , 40436 2400 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2400 18 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 2400 19 , , , 40436 2400 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2400 21 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 2400 22 for for IN 40436 2400 23 the the DT 40436 2400 24 moral moral JJ 40436 2400 25 improvement improvement NN 40436 2400 26 of of IN 40436 2400 27 the the DT 40436 2400 28 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 2400 29 : : : 40436 2400 30 the the DT 40436 2400 31 causes cause NNS 40436 2400 32 , , , 40436 2400 33 different different JJ 40436 2400 34 from from IN 40436 2400 35 what what WP 40436 2400 36 was be VBD 40436 2400 37 commonly commonly RB 40436 2400 38 believed believe VBN 40436 2400 39 , , , 40436 2400 40 which which WDT 40436 2400 41 led lead VBD 40436 2400 42 to to IN 40436 2400 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2400 44 death death NN 40436 2400 45 ; ; : 40436 2400 46 and and CC 40436 2400 47 the the DT 40436 2400 48 wholesome wholesome JJ 40436 2400 49 precepts precept NNS 40436 2400 50 which which WDT 40436 2400 51 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2400 52 during during IN 40436 2400 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2400 54 life life NN 40436 2400 55 had have VBD 40436 2400 56 caused cause VBN 40436 2400 57 to to TO 40436 2400 58 be be VB 40436 2400 59 inscribed inscribe VBN 40436 2400 60 on on IN 40436 2400 61 various various JJ 40436 2400 62 busts bust NNS 40436 2400 63 of of IN 40436 2400 64 Hermes Hermes NNP 40436 2400 65 throughout throughout IN 40436 2400 66 Attica Attica NNP 40436 2400 67 . . . 40436 2401 1 One one CD 40436 2401 2 of of IN 40436 2401 3 these these DT 40436 2401 4 busts bust NNS 40436 2401 5 or or CC 40436 2401 6 Hermæ Hermæ NNP 40436 2401 7 bore bear VBD 40436 2401 8 the the DT 40436 2401 9 words word NNS 40436 2401 10 -- -- : 40436 2401 11 Do do VB 40436 2401 12 not not RB 40436 2401 13 deceive deceive VB 40436 2401 14 a a DT 40436 2401 15 friend friend NN 40436 2401 16 . . . 40436 2402 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2402 2 7 7 CD 40436 2402 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2402 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2402 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2402 6 7 7 CD 40436 2402 7 : : : 40436 2402 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2402 9 . . . 40436 2403 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2403 2 . . . 40436 2404 1 228 228 CD 40436 2404 2 B-229 B-229 NNP 40436 2404 3 D. D. NNP 40436 2404 4 The the DT 40436 2404 5 picture picture NN 40436 2404 6 here here RB 40436 2404 7 given give VBN 40436 2404 8 of of IN 40436 2404 9 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2404 10 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 2404 11 notice notice NN 40436 2404 12 . . . 40436 2405 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 2405 2 are be VBP 40436 2405 3 informed inform VBN 40436 2405 4 that that IN 40436 2405 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2405 6 was be VBD 40436 2405 7 older old JJR 40436 2405 8 than than IN 40436 2405 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2405 10 brother brother NN 40436 2405 11 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2405 12 , , , 40436 2405 13 which which WDT 40436 2405 14 was be VBD 40436 2405 15 the the DT 40436 2405 16 general general JJ 40436 2405 17 belief belief NN 40436 2405 18 at at IN 40436 2405 19 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2405 20 , , , 40436 2405 21 as as IN 40436 2405 22 Thucydides Thucydides NNP 40436 2405 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2405 24 i. i. NNP 40436 2406 1 20 20 CD 40436 2406 2 , , , 40436 2406 3 vi vi NNP 40436 2406 4 . . . 40436 2407 1 58 58 LS 40436 2407 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2407 3 affirms affirm NNS 40436 2407 4 , , , 40436 2407 5 though though IN 40436 2407 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2407 7 contradicting contradict VBG 40436 2407 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2407 9 , , , 40436 2407 10 and and CC 40436 2407 11 affirming affirm VBG 40436 2407 12 that that IN 40436 2407 13 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2407 14 was be VBD 40436 2407 15 the the DT 40436 2407 16 elder elder JJ 40436 2407 17 brother brother NN 40436 2407 18 . . . 40436 2408 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2408 2 however however RB 40436 2408 3 agrees agree VBZ 40436 2408 4 with with IN 40436 2408 5 Thucydides thucydide NNS 40436 2408 6 in in IN 40436 2408 7 this this DT 40436 2408 8 point point NN 40436 2408 9 , , , 40436 2408 10 that that IN 40436 2408 11 the the DT 40436 2408 12 three three CD 40436 2408 13 years year NNS 40436 2408 14 after after IN 40436 2408 15 the the DT 40436 2408 16 assassination assassination NN 40436 2408 17 of of IN 40436 2408 18 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2408 19 , , , 40436 2408 20 during during IN 40436 2408 21 which which WDT 40436 2408 22 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2408 23 ruled rule VBD 40436 2408 24 alone alone RB 40436 2408 25 , , , 40436 2408 26 were be VBD 40436 2408 27 years year NNS 40436 2408 28 of of IN 40436 2408 29 oppression oppression NN 40436 2408 30 and and CC 40436 2408 31 tyranny tyranny NN 40436 2408 32 ; ; : 40436 2408 33 and and CC 40436 2408 34 that that IN 40436 2408 35 the the DT 40436 2408 36 hateful hateful JJ 40436 2408 37 recollection recollection NN 40436 2408 38 of of IN 40436 2408 39 the the DT 40436 2408 40 Peisistratidæ Peisistratidæ NNP 40436 2408 41 , , , 40436 2408 42 which which WDT 40436 2408 43 always always RB 40436 2408 44 survived survive VBD 40436 2408 45 in in IN 40436 2408 46 the the DT 40436 2408 47 minds mind NNS 40436 2408 48 of of IN 40436 2408 49 the the DT 40436 2408 50 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 2408 51 , , , 40436 2408 52 was be VBD 40436 2408 53 derived derive VBN 40436 2408 54 from from IN 40436 2408 55 these these DT 40436 2408 56 three three CD 40436 2408 57 last last JJ 40436 2408 58 years year NNS 40436 2408 59 . . . 40436 2409 1 The the DT 40436 2409 2 picture picture NN 40436 2409 3 which which WDT 40436 2409 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2409 5 here here RB 40436 2409 6 gives give VBZ 40436 2409 7 of of IN 40436 2409 8 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2409 9 is be VBZ 40436 2409 10 such such JJ 40436 2409 11 as as IN 40436 2409 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2409 13 might may MD 40436 2409 14 expect expect VB 40436 2409 15 from from IN 40436 2409 16 a a DT 40436 2409 17 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 2409 18 . . . 40436 2410 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2410 2 dwells dwell VBZ 40436 2410 3 upon upon IN 40436 2410 4 the the DT 40436 2410 5 pains pain NNS 40436 2410 6 which which WDT 40436 2410 7 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2410 8 took take VBD 40436 2410 9 to to TO 40436 2410 10 have have VB 40436 2410 11 the the DT 40436 2410 12 recitation recitation NN 40436 2410 13 of of IN 40436 2410 14 the the DT 40436 2410 15 Homeric Homeric NNP 40436 2410 16 poems poem NNS 40436 2410 17 made make VBD 40436 2410 18 frequent frequent JJ 40436 2410 19 and and CC 40436 2410 20 complete complete JJ 40436 2410 21 : : : 40436 2410 22 also also RB 40436 2410 23 upon upon IN 40436 2410 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2410 25 intimacy intimacy NN 40436 2410 26 with with IN 40436 2410 27 the the DT 40436 2410 28 poets poet NNS 40436 2410 29 Anakreon Anakreon NNP 40436 2410 30 and and CC 40436 2410 31 Simonides Simonides NNPS 40436 2410 32 . . . 40436 2411 1 The the DT 40436 2411 2 colouring colouring NN 40436 2411 3 which which WDT 40436 2411 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2411 5 gives give VBZ 40436 2411 6 to to IN 40436 2411 7 the the DT 40436 2411 8 intimacy intimacy NN 40436 2411 9 between between IN 40436 2411 10 Aristogeiton Aristogeiton NNP 40436 2411 11 and and CC 40436 2411 12 Harmodius Harmodius NNP 40436 2411 13 is be VBZ 40436 2411 14 also also RB 40436 2411 15 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 2411 16 . . . 40436 2412 1 The the DT 40436 2412 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2412 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2412 4 : : : 40436 2412 5 e)rastê\s e)rastê\s LS 40436 2412 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2412 7 is be VBZ 40436 2412 8 represented represent VBN 40436 2412 9 by by IN 40436 2412 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2412 11 as as RB 40436 2412 12 eager eager JJ 40436 2412 13 for for IN 40436 2412 14 the the DT 40436 2412 15 education education NN 40436 2412 16 and and CC 40436 2412 17 improvement improvement NN 40436 2412 18 of of IN 40436 2412 19 the the DT 40436 2412 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2412 21 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2412 22 : : : 40436 2412 23 e)rô e)rô NN 40436 2412 24 / / SYM 40436 2412 25 menos menos NNP 40436 2412 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2412 27 ; ; : 40436 2412 28 and and CC 40436 2412 29 the the DT 40436 2412 30 jealousy jealousy NN 40436 2412 31 felt feel VBD 40436 2412 32 towards towards IN 40436 2412 33 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2412 34 is be VBZ 40436 2412 35 described describe VBN 40436 2412 36 as as IN 40436 2412 37 arising arise VBG 40436 2412 38 from from IN 40436 2412 39 the the DT 40436 2412 40 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 2412 41 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2412 42 and and CC 40436 2412 43 abilities ability NNS 40436 2412 44 of of IN 40436 2412 45 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2412 46 , , , 40436 2412 47 which which WDT 40436 2412 48 rendered render VBD 40436 2412 49 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2412 50 so so RB 40436 2412 51 much much RB 40436 2412 52 superior superior JJ 40436 2412 53 and and CC 40436 2412 54 more more RBR 40436 2412 55 effective effective JJ 40436 2412 56 as as IN 40436 2412 57 an an DT 40436 2412 58 educator educator NN 40436 2412 59 . . . 40436 2412 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2413 1 The the DT 40436 2413 2 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2413 3 resumes resume VBZ 40436 2413 4 : : : 40436 2413 5 Apparently apparently RB 40436 2413 6 , , , 40436 2413 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2413 8 , , , 40436 2413 9 either either CC 40436 2413 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2413 11 do do VBP 40436 2413 12 not not RB 40436 2413 13 account account VB 40436 2413 14 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2413 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2413 16 friend friend NN 40436 2413 17 , , , 40436 2413 18 or or CC 40436 2413 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2413 20 do do VBP 40436 2413 21 not not RB 40436 2413 22 obey obey VB 40436 2413 23 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2413 24 : : : 40436 2413 25 for for IN 40436 2413 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2413 27 are be VBP 40436 2413 28 certainly certainly RB 40436 2413 29 deceiving deceive VBG 40436 2413 30 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2413 31 in in IN 40436 2413 32 some some DT 40436 2413 33 unaccountable unaccountable JJ 40436 2413 34 way way NN 40436 2413 35 in in IN 40436 2413 36 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2413 37 talk talk NN 40436 2413 38 . . . 40436 2414 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2414 2 can can MD 40436 2414 3 not not RB 40436 2414 4 persuade persuade VB 40436 2414 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2414 6 to to IN 40436 2414 7 the the DT 40436 2414 8 contrary contrary NN 40436 2414 9 . . . 40436 2415 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2415 2 Side side NN 40436 2415 3 - - HYPH 40436 2415 4 note note NN 40436 2415 5 : : : 40436 2415 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2415 7 allows allow VBZ 40436 2415 8 the the DT 40436 2415 9 companion companion NN 40436 2415 10 to to TO 40436 2415 11 retract retract VB 40436 2415 12 some some DT 40436 2415 13 of of IN 40436 2415 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2415 15 answers answer NNS 40436 2415 16 . . . 40436 2416 1 The the DT 40436 2416 2 companion companion NN 40436 2416 3 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 2416 4 that that IN 40436 2416 5 some some DT 40436 2416 6 gain gain NN 40436 2416 7 is be VBZ 40436 2416 8 good good JJ 40436 2416 9 , , , 40436 2416 10 other other JJ 40436 2416 11 gain gain NN 40436 2416 12 is be VBZ 40436 2416 13 evil evil JJ 40436 2416 14 . . . 40436 2416 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2417 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2417 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 2417 3 then then RB 40436 2417 4 ! ! . 40436 2418 1 in in IN 40436 2418 2 order order NN 40436 2418 3 that that IN 40436 2418 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2418 5 may may MD 40436 2418 6 not not RB 40436 2418 7 think think VB 40436 2418 8 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 2418 9 deceived deceive VBN 40436 2418 10 , , , 40436 2418 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2418 12 may may MD 40436 2418 13 take take VB 40436 2418 14 back back RB 40436 2418 15 any any DT 40436 2418 16 move move NN 40436 2418 17 that that WDT 40436 2418 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2418 19 choose choose VBP 40436 2418 20 , , , 40436 2418 21 as as IN 40436 2418 22 if if IN 40436 2418 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2418 24 were be VBD 40436 2418 25 playing play VBG 40436 2418 26 at at IN 40436 2418 27 draughts draught NNS 40436 2418 28 . . . 40436 2419 1 Which which WDT 40436 2419 2 of of IN 40436 2419 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2419 4 admissions admission NNS 40436 2419 5 do do VBP 40436 2419 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2419 7 wish wish VB 40436 2419 8 to to TO 40436 2419 9 retract retract VB 40436 2419 10 -- -- : 40436 2419 11 That that IN 40436 2419 12 all all DT 40436 2419 13 men man NNS 40436 2419 14 desire desire VBP 40436 2419 15 good good JJ 40436 2419 16 things thing NNS 40436 2419 17 ? ? . 40436 2420 1 That that DT 40436 2420 2 loss loss NN 40436 2420 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2420 4 to to TO 40436 2420 5 be be VB 40436 2420 6 a a DT 40436 2420 7 loser loser NN 40436 2420 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2420 9 is be VBZ 40436 2420 10 evil evil JJ 40436 2420 11 ? ? . 40436 2421 1 That that DT 40436 2421 2 gain gain NN 40436 2421 3 is be VBZ 40436 2421 4 the the DT 40436 2421 5 opposite opposite NN 40436 2421 6 of of IN 40436 2421 7 loss loss NN 40436 2421 8 : : : 40436 2421 9 that that IN 40436 2421 10 to to TO 40436 2421 11 gain gain VB 40436 2421 12 is be VBZ 40436 2421 13 the the DT 40436 2421 14 opposite opposite NN 40436 2421 15 of of IN 40436 2421 16 to to TO 40436 2421 17 lose lose VB 40436 2421 18 ? ? . 40436 2422 1 That that IN 40436 2422 2 to to TO 40436 2422 3 gain gain VB 40436 2422 4 , , , 40436 2422 5 as as IN 40436 2422 6 being be VBG 40436 2422 7 the the DT 40436 2422 8 opposite opposite NN 40436 2422 9 of of IN 40436 2422 10 evil evil NN 40436 2422 11 is be VBZ 40436 2422 12 a a DT 40436 2422 13 good good JJ 40436 2422 14 thing thing NN 40436 2422 15 ? ? . 40436 2423 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2423 2 Comp._--No Comp._--No NNP 40436 2423 3 . . . 40436 2424 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2424 2 do do VBP 40436 2424 3 not not RB 40436 2424 4 retract retract VB 40436 2424 5 any any DT 40436 2424 6 one one CD 40436 2424 7 of of IN 40436 2424 8 these these DT 40436 2424 9 . . . 40436 2425 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2425 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 2425 3 think think VBP 40436 2425 4 then then RB 40436 2425 5 , , , 40436 2425 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2425 7 appears appear VBZ 40436 2425 8 , , , 40436 2425 9 that that IN 40436 2425 10 some some DT 40436 2425 11 gain gain NN 40436 2425 12 is be VBZ 40436 2425 13 good good JJ 40436 2425 14 , , , 40436 2425 15 other other JJ 40436 2425 16 gain gain NN 40436 2425 17 evil evil NN 40436 2425 18 ? ? . 40436 2426 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2426 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2426 3 , , , 40436 2426 4 that that DT 40436 2426 5 is be VBZ 40436 2426 6 what what WP 40436 2426 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2426 8 do do VBP 40436 2426 9 think think VB 40436 2426 10 . . . 40436 2427 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2427 2 8 8 CD 40436 2427 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2427 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2427 5 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 2427 6 , , , 40436 2427 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2427 8 give give VBP 40436 2427 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2427 10 back back RB 40436 2427 11 that that DT 40436 2427 12 move move NN 40436 2427 13 : : : 40436 2427 14 let let VB 40436 2427 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2427 16 stand stand VB 40436 2427 17 as as IN 40436 2427 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2427 19 say say VBP 40436 2427 20 . . . 40436 2428 1 Some some DT 40436 2428 2 gain gain NN 40436 2428 3 is be VBZ 40436 2428 4 good good JJ 40436 2428 5 : : : 40436 2428 6 other other JJ 40436 2428 7 gain gain NN 40436 2428 8 is be VBZ 40436 2428 9 bad bad JJ 40436 2428 10 . . . 40436 2429 1 But but CC 40436 2429 2 surely surely RB 40436 2429 3 the the DT 40436 2429 4 good good JJ 40436 2429 5 gain gain NN 40436 2429 6 is be VBZ 40436 2429 7 no no DT 40436 2429 8 more more JJR 40436 2429 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2429 10 gain gain NN 40436 2429 11 _ _ NNP 40436 2429 12 , , , 40436 2429 13 than than IN 40436 2429 14 the the DT 40436 2429 15 bad bad JJ 40436 2429 16 gain gain NN 40436 2429 17 : : : 40436 2429 18 both both DT 40436 2429 19 are be VBP 40436 2429 20 _ _ NNP 40436 2429 21 gain gain NN 40436 2429 22 _ _ NNP 40436 2429 23 , , , 40436 2429 24 alike alike RB 40436 2429 25 and and CC 40436 2429 26 equally equally RB 40436 2429 27 . . . 40436 2430 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2430 2 Comp._--How Comp._--How NNP 40436 2430 3 do do VBP 40436 2430 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2430 5 mean mean VB 40436 2430 6 ? ? . 40436 2431 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2431 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2431 3 8 8 CD 40436 2431 4 : : : 40436 2431 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2431 6 . . . 40436 2432 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2432 2 . . . 40436 2433 1 229 229 CD 40436 2433 2 E e NN 40436 2433 3 , , , 40436 2433 4 230 230 CD 40436 2433 5 A. a. NN 40436 2433 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2434 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2434 2 Side side NN 40436 2434 3 - - HYPH 40436 2434 4 note note NN 40436 2434 5 : : : 40436 2434 6 Questions question NNS 40436 2434 7 by by IN 40436 2434 8 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2434 9 -- -- : 40436 2434 10 bad bad JJ 40436 2434 11 gain gain NN 40436 2434 12 is be VBZ 40436 2434 13 _ _ NNP 40436 2434 14 gain gain NN 40436 2434 15 _ _ NNP 40436 2434 16 , , , 40436 2434 17 as as RB 40436 2434 18 much much RB 40436 2434 19 as as IN 40436 2434 20 good good JJ 40436 2434 21 gain gain NN 40436 2434 22 . . . 40436 2435 1 What what WP 40436 2435 2 is be VBZ 40436 2435 3 the the DT 40436 2435 4 common common JJ 40436 2435 5 property property NN 40436 2435 6 , , , 40436 2435 7 in in IN 40436 2435 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 2435 9 of of IN 40436 2435 10 which which WDT 40436 2435 11 both both DT 40436 2435 12 are be VBP 40436 2435 13 called call VBN 40436 2435 14 Gain gain NN 40436 2435 15 ? ? . 40436 2436 1 Every every DT 40436 2436 2 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 2436 3 , , , 40436 2436 4 made make VBN 40436 2436 5 with with IN 40436 2436 6 no no DT 40436 2436 7 outlay outlay NN 40436 2436 8 , , , 40436 2436 9 or or CC 40436 2436 10 with with IN 40436 2436 11 a a DT 40436 2436 12 smaller small JJR 40436 2436 13 outlay outlay NN 40436 2436 14 , , , 40436 2436 15 is be VBZ 40436 2436 16 gain gain NN 40436 2436 17 . . . 40436 2437 1 Objections objection NNS 40436 2437 2 -- -- : 40436 2437 3 the the DT 40436 2437 4 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 2437 5 may may MD 40436 2437 6 be be VB 40436 2437 7 evil evil JJ 40436 2437 8 -- -- : 40436 2437 9 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 2437 10 confessed confess VBN 40436 2437 11 . . . 40436 2437 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2438 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2438 2 then then RB 40436 2438 3 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40436 2438 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2438 5 question question NN 40436 2438 6 by by IN 40436 2438 7 two two CD 40436 2438 8 or or CC 40436 2438 9 three three CD 40436 2438 10 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2438 11 . . . 40436 2439 1 Bad bad JJ 40436 2439 2 food food NN 40436 2439 3 is be VBZ 40436 2439 4 just just RB 40436 2439 5 as as RB 40436 2439 6 much much JJ 40436 2439 7 _ _ NNP 40436 2439 8 food food NN 40436 2439 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2439 10 , , , 40436 2439 11 as as IN 40436 2439 12 good good JJ 40436 2439 13 food food NN 40436 2439 14 : : : 40436 2439 15 bad bad JJ 40436 2439 16 drink drink NN 40436 2439 17 , , , 40436 2439 18 as as IN 40436 2439 19 much much JJ 40436 2439 20 _ _ NNP 40436 2439 21 drink drink NN 40436 2439 22 _ _ NNP 40436 2439 23 as as IN 40436 2439 24 good good JJ 40436 2439 25 drink drink NN 40436 2439 26 : : : 40436 2439 27 a a DT 40436 2439 28 good good JJ 40436 2439 29 man man NN 40436 2439 30 is be VBZ 40436 2439 31 no no RB 40436 2439 32 more more JJR 40436 2439 33 _ _ NNP 40436 2439 34 man man NN 40436 2439 35 _ _ NNP 40436 2439 36 than than IN 40436 2439 37 a a DT 40436 2439 38 bad bad JJ 40436 2439 39 man man NN 40436 2439 40 . . . 40436 2440 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2440 2 9 9 CD 40436 2440 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2440 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2440 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2440 6 9 9 CD 40436 2440 7 : : : 40436 2440 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2440 9 . . . 40436 2441 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2441 2 . . . 40436 2442 1 230 230 CD 40436 2442 2 C. C. NNP 40436 2442 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2442 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2442 5 Sokr._--In Sokr._--In NNP 40436 2442 6 like like IN 40436 2442 7 manner manner NN 40436 2442 8 , , , 40436 2442 9 bad bad JJ 40436 2442 10 gain gain NN 40436 2442 11 , , , 40436 2442 12 and and CC 40436 2442 13 good good JJ 40436 2442 14 gain gain NN 40436 2442 15 , , , 40436 2442 16 are be VBP 40436 2442 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2442 18 both both DT 40436 2442 19 of of IN 40436 2442 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2442 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2442 22 _ _ NNP 40436 2442 23 gain gain VBP 40436 2442 24 _ _ NNP 40436 2442 25 alike alike RB 40436 2442 26 -- -- : 40436 2442 27 neither neither DT 40436 2442 28 of of IN 40436 2442 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2442 30 more more RBR 40436 2442 31 or or CC 40436 2442 32 less less JJR 40436 2442 33 than than IN 40436 2442 34 the the DT 40436 2442 35 other other JJ 40436 2442 36 . . . 40436 2443 1 Such such JJ 40436 2443 2 being be VBG 40436 2443 3 the the DT 40436 2443 4 case case NN 40436 2443 5 , , , 40436 2443 6 what what WP 40436 2443 7 is be VBZ 40436 2443 8 that that DT 40436 2443 9 common common JJ 40436 2443 10 quality quality NN 40436 2443 11 possessed possess VBN 40436 2443 12 by by IN 40436 2443 13 both both DT 40436 2443 14 , , , 40436 2443 15 which which WDT 40436 2443 16 induces induce VBZ 40436 2443 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2443 18 to to TO 40436 2443 19 call call VB 40436 2443 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2443 21 by by IN 40436 2443 22 the the DT 40436 2443 23 same same JJ 40436 2443 24 name name NN 40436 2443 25 _ _ NNP 40436 2443 26 Gain Gain NNP 40436 2443 27 _ _ NNP 40436 2443 28 ? ? . 40436 2444 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2444 2 10 10 CD 40436 2444 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2444 4 Would Would MD 40436 2444 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2444 6 call call VB 40436 2444 7 _ _ NNP 40436 2444 8 Gain Gain NNP 40436 2444 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2444 10 any any DT 40436 2444 11 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 2444 12 which which WDT 40436 2444 13 one one PRP 40436 2444 14 makes make VBZ 40436 2444 15 either either CC 40436 2444 16 with with IN 40436 2444 17 a a DT 40436 2444 18 smaller small JJR 40436 2444 19 outlay outlay NN 40436 2444 20 or or CC 40436 2444 21 with with IN 40436 2444 22 no no DT 40436 2444 23 outlay outlay NN 40436 2444 24 at at RB 40436 2444 25 all all RB 40436 2444 26 ? ? . 40436 2445 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2445 2 11 11 CD 40436 2445 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2445 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2445 5 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2445 6 . . . 40436 2446 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2446 2 should should MD 40436 2446 3 call call VB 40436 2446 4 that that DT 40436 2446 5 gain gain NN 40436 2446 6 . . . 40436 2447 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2447 2 Sokr._--For Sokr._--For NNP 40436 2447 3 example example NN 40436 2447 4 , , , 40436 2447 5 if if IN 40436 2447 6 after after IN 40436 2447 7 being be VBG 40436 2447 8 at at IN 40436 2447 9 a a DT 40436 2447 10 banquet banquet NN 40436 2447 11 , , , 40436 2447 12 not not RB 40436 2447 13 only only RB 40436 2447 14 without without IN 40436 2447 15 any any DT 40436 2447 16 outlay outlay NN 40436 2447 17 , , , 40436 2447 18 but but CC 40436 2447 19 receiving receive VBG 40436 2447 20 an an DT 40436 2447 21 excellent excellent JJ 40436 2447 22 dinner dinner NN 40436 2447 23 , , , 40436 2447 24 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2447 25 acquire acquire VBP 40436 2447 26 an an DT 40436 2447 27 illness illness NN 40436 2447 28 ? ? . 40436 2448 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2448 2 Comp._--Not Comp._--Not NNP 40436 2448 3 at at RB 40436 2448 4 all all RB 40436 2448 5 : : : 40436 2448 6 that that DT 40436 2448 7 is be VBZ 40436 2448 8 no no DT 40436 2448 9 gain gain NN 40436 2448 10 . . . 40436 2449 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2449 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 2449 3 if if IN 40436 2449 4 from from IN 40436 2449 5 the the DT 40436 2449 6 banquet banquet NN 40436 2449 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2449 8 acquire acquire VBP 40436 2449 9 health health NN 40436 2449 10 , , , 40436 2449 11 would would MD 40436 2449 12 that that DT 40436 2449 13 be be VB 40436 2449 14 gain gain NN 40436 2449 15 or or CC 40436 2449 16 loss loss VB 40436 2449 17 ? ? . 40436 2450 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2450 2 Comp._--It Comp._--It NNP 40436 2450 3 would would MD 40436 2450 4 be be VB 40436 2450 5 gain gain JJ 40436 2450 6 . . . 40436 2451 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2451 2 Sokr._--Not Sokr._--Not NNP 40436 2451 3 every every DT 40436 2451 4 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 2451 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 2451 6 is be VBZ 40436 2451 7 gain gain NN 40436 2451 8 , , , 40436 2451 9 but but CC 40436 2451 10 only only RB 40436 2451 11 such such JJ 40436 2451 12 acquisitions acquisition NNS 40436 2451 13 as as IN 40436 2451 14 are be VBP 40436 2451 15 good good JJ 40436 2451 16 and and CC 40436 2451 17 not not RB 40436 2451 18 evil evil JJ 40436 2451 19 : : : 40436 2451 20 if if IN 40436 2451 21 the the DT 40436 2451 22 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 2451 23 be be VB 40436 2451 24 evil evil JJ 40436 2451 25 , , , 40436 2451 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2451 27 is be VBZ 40436 2451 28 loss loss NN 40436 2451 29 . . . 40436 2452 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2452 2 Comp._--Exactly Comp._--Exactly NNP 40436 2452 3 so so RB 40436 2452 4 . . . 40436 2453 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2453 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 2453 3 , , , 40436 2453 4 now now RB 40436 2453 5 , , , 40436 2453 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2453 7 see see VBP 40436 2453 8 , , , 40436 2453 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2453 10 are be VBP 40436 2453 11 come come VBN 40436 2453 12 round round RB 40436 2453 13 again again RB 40436 2453 14 to to IN 40436 2453 15 the the DT 40436 2453 16 very very RB 40436 2453 17 same same JJ 40436 2453 18 point point NN 40436 2453 19 : : : 40436 2453 20 Gain gain NN 40436 2453 21 is be VBZ 40436 2453 22 good good JJ 40436 2453 23 . . . 40436 2454 1 Loss loss NN 40436 2454 2 is be VBZ 40436 2454 3 evil evil JJ 40436 2454 4 . . . 40436 2455 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2455 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNS 40436 2455 3 am be VBP 40436 2455 4 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 2455 5 what what WP 40436 2455 6 to to TO 40436 2455 7 say say VB 40436 2455 8 . . . 40436 2456 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2456 2 12 12 CD 40436 2456 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2456 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2456 5 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 2456 6 have have VBP 40436 2456 7 good good JJ 40436 2456 8 reason reason NN 40436 2456 9 to to TO 40436 2456 10 be be VB 40436 2456 11 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 2456 12 . . . 40436 2457 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2457 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2457 3 10 10 CD 40436 2457 4 : : : 40436 2457 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2457 6 . . . 40436 2458 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2458 2 . . . 40436 2459 1 230 230 CD 40436 2459 2 E. E. NNP 40436 2459 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2459 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2459 5 : : : 40436 2459 6 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 2459 7 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 2459 8 pote pote NNP 40436 2459 9 a)mpho a)mpho NNPS 40436 2459 10 / / SYM 40436 2459 11 tera tera NN 40436 2459 12 au)ta\ au)ta\ JJ 40436 2459 13 ke ke NNP 40436 2459 14 / / SYM 40436 2459 15 rdos rdos NNP 40436 2459 16 kalei kalei NNP 40436 2459 17 = = NFP 40436 2459 18 s s XX 40436 2459 19 ? ? . 40436 2460 1 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 2460 2 tau)to\n tau)to\n NNP 40436 2460 3 e)n e)n NNP 40436 2460 4 a)mphote a)mphote NNP 40436 2460 5 / / SYM 40436 2460 6 rois rois NN 40436 2460 7 o(rô o(rô NNS 40436 2460 8 = = SYM 40436 2460 9 n n XX 40436 2460 10 ? ? . 40436 2460 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2460 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2461 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2461 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2461 3 11 11 CD 40436 2461 4 : : : 40436 2461 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2461 6 . . . 40436 2462 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2462 2 . . . 40436 2463 1 231 231 CD 40436 2463 2 A. a. NN 40436 2463 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2464 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2464 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2464 3 12 12 CD 40436 2464 4 : : : 40436 2464 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2464 6 . . . 40436 2465 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2465 2 . . . 40436 2466 1 231 231 CD 40436 2466 2 C. C. NNP 40436 2466 3 _ _ NNP 40436 2466 4 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 2466 5 . . . 40436 2466 6 _ _ NNP 40436 2466 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2466 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2466 9 : : : 40436 2466 10 O(ra=|s O(ra=|s NNP 40436 2466 11 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 2466 12 , , , 40436 2466 13 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 2466 14 pa pa NNP 40436 2466 15 / / SYM 40436 2466 16 lin lin NNP 40436 2466 17 au)= au)= NNP 40436 2466 18 peritre peritre NNP 40436 2466 19 / / SYM 40436 2466 20 cheis cheis NNP 40436 2466 21 ei)s ei)s NNP 40436 2466 22 to\ to\ NN 40436 2466 23 au)to\--to\ au)to\--to\ NNP 40436 2466 24 me\n me\n NNP 40436 2466 25 ke ke NNP 40436 2466 26 / / SYM 40436 2466 27 rdos rdos NNP 40436 2466 28 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 2466 29 phai phai NNP 40436 2466 30 / / SYM 40436 2466 31 netai netai NNP 40436 2466 32 , , , 40436 2466 33 ê ê NNP 40436 2466 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2466 35 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2466 36 zêmi zêmi NNP 40436 2466 37 / / SYM 40436 2466 38 a a DT 40436 2466 39 kako kako NNP 40436 2466 40 / / SYM 40436 2466 41 n n NNP 40436 2466 42 ? ? . 40436 2466 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2467 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2467 2 Comp Comp NNP 40436 2467 3 . . . 40436 2467 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2467 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2467 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2467 7 : : : 40436 2467 8 A)porô= a)porô= NN 40436 2467 9 e)/gôge e)/gôge NNP 40436 2467 10 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 2467 11 , , , 40436 2467 12 ti ti NNP 40436 2467 13 ei)/pô ei)/pô NNP 40436 2467 14 . . . 40436 2467 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2468 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2468 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 2468 3 . . . 40436 2468 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2468 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2468 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2468 7 : : : 40436 2468 8 Ou)k Ou)k NNP 40436 2468 9 a)di a)di NNP 40436 2468 10 / / SYM 40436 2468 11 kôs kôs NNP 40436 2468 12 ge ge NNP 40436 2468 13 su\ su\ NNP 40436 2468 14 a)porô a)porô NNPS 40436 2468 15 = = SYM 40436 2468 16 n n NN 40436 2468 17 . . . 40436 2468 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2468 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2469 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2469 2 Side side NN 40436 2469 3 - - HYPH 40436 2469 4 note note NN 40436 2469 5 : : : 40436 2469 6 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2469 7 is be VBZ 40436 2469 8 essential essential JJ 40436 2469 9 to to TO 40436 2469 10 gain gain VB 40436 2469 11 , , , 40436 2469 12 that that IN 40436 2469 13 the the DT 40436 2469 14 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 2469 15 made make VBN 40436 2469 16 shall shall MD 40436 2469 17 be be VB 40436 2469 18 greater great JJR 40436 2469 19 not not RB 40436 2469 20 merely merely RB 40436 2469 21 in in IN 40436 2469 22 quantity quantity NN 40436 2469 23 , , , 40436 2469 24 but but CC 40436 2469 25 also also RB 40436 2469 26 in in IN 40436 2469 27 value value NN 40436 2469 28 , , , 40436 2469 29 than than IN 40436 2469 30 the the DT 40436 2469 31 outlay outlay NN 40436 2469 32 . . . 40436 2470 1 The the DT 40436 2470 2 valuable valuable JJ 40436 2470 3 is be VBZ 40436 2470 4 the the DT 40436 2470 5 profitable profitable JJ 40436 2470 6 -- -- : 40436 2470 7 the the DT 40436 2470 8 profitable profitable JJ 40436 2470 9 is be VBZ 40436 2470 10 the the DT 40436 2470 11 good good JJ 40436 2470 12 . . . 40436 2471 1 Conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2471 2 comes come VBZ 40436 2471 3 back back RB 40436 2471 4 . . . 40436 2472 1 That that IN 40436 2472 2 Gain Gain NNP 40436 2472 3 is be VBZ 40436 2472 4 Good good JJ 40436 2472 5 . . . 40436 2472 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2473 1 But but CC 40436 2473 2 tell tell VB 40436 2473 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2473 4 : : : 40436 2473 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2473 6 say say VBP 40436 2473 7 that that IN 40436 2473 8 if if IN 40436 2473 9 a a DT 40436 2473 10 man man NN 40436 2473 11 lays lay VBZ 40436 2473 12 out out RP 40436 2473 13 little little JJ 40436 2473 14 and and CC 40436 2473 15 acquires acquire NNS 40436 2473 16 much much RB 40436 2473 17 , , , 40436 2473 18 that that DT 40436 2473 19 is be VBZ 40436 2473 20 gain gain JJ 40436 2473 21 ? ? . 40436 2474 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2474 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2474 3 : : : 40436 2474 4 but but CC 40436 2474 5 not not RB 40436 2474 6 if if IN 40436 2474 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2474 8 be be VB 40436 2474 9 evil evil JJ 40436 2474 10 : : : 40436 2474 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2474 12 is be VBZ 40436 2474 13 gain gain NN 40436 2474 14 , , , 40436 2474 15 if if IN 40436 2474 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2474 17 be be VB 40436 2474 18 good good JJ 40436 2474 19 , , , 40436 2474 20 like like IN 40436 2474 21 gold gold NN 40436 2474 22 or or CC 40436 2474 23 silver silver NN 40436 2474 24 . . . 40436 2475 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2475 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 2475 3 will will MD 40436 2475 4 ask ask VB 40436 2475 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2475 6 about about IN 40436 2475 7 gold gold NN 40436 2475 8 and and CC 40436 2475 9 silver silver NN 40436 2475 10 . . . 40436 2476 1 Suppose suppose VB 40436 2476 2 a a DT 40436 2476 3 man man NN 40436 2476 4 by by IN 40436 2476 5 laying lay VBG 40436 2476 6 out out RP 40436 2476 7 one one CD 40436 2476 8 pound pound NN 40436 2476 9 of of IN 40436 2476 10 gold gold NN 40436 2476 11 acquires acquire NNS 40436 2476 12 two two CD 40436 2476 13 pounds pound NNS 40436 2476 14 of of IN 40436 2476 15 silver silver NN 40436 2476 16 , , , 40436 2476 17 is be VBZ 40436 2476 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2476 19 gain gain NN 40436 2476 20 or or CC 40436 2476 21 loss loss VB 40436 2476 22 ? ? . 40436 2477 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2477 2 Comp._--It Comp._--It NNP 40436 2477 3 is be VBZ 40436 2477 4 loss loss NN 40436 2477 5 , , , 40436 2477 6 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 2477 7 , , , 40436 2477 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2477 9 : : : 40436 2477 10 gold gold NN 40436 2477 11 is be VBZ 40436 2477 12 twelve twelve CD 40436 2477 13 times time NNS 40436 2477 14 the the DT 40436 2477 15 value value NN 40436 2477 16 of of IN 40436 2477 17 silver silver NN 40436 2477 18 . . . 40436 2478 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2478 2 Sokr._--Nevertheless Sokr._--Nevertheless NNP 40436 2478 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2478 4 has have VBZ 40436 2478 5 acquired acquire VBN 40436 2478 6 more more JJR 40436 2478 7 : : : 40436 2478 8 double double JJ 40436 2478 9 is be VBZ 40436 2478 10 more more JJR 40436 2478 11 than than IN 40436 2478 12 half half NN 40436 2478 13 . . . 40436 2479 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2479 2 Comp._--Not Comp._--Not NNP 40436 2479 3 in in IN 40436 2479 4 value value NN 40436 2479 5 : : : 40436 2479 6 double double JJ 40436 2479 7 silver silver NN 40436 2479 8 is be VBZ 40436 2479 9 not not RB 40436 2479 10 more more JJR 40436 2479 11 than than IN 40436 2479 12 half half JJ 40436 2479 13 gold gold NN 40436 2479 14 . . . 40436 2480 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2480 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 2480 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 2480 4 then then RB 40436 2480 5 that that IN 40436 2480 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2480 7 must must MD 40436 2480 8 include include VB 40436 2480 9 value value NN 40436 2480 10 as as IN 40436 2480 11 essential essential JJ 40436 2480 12 to to TO 40436 2480 13 gain gain VB 40436 2480 14 , , , 40436 2480 15 not not RB 40436 2480 16 merely merely RB 40436 2480 17 quantity quantity NN 40436 2480 18 . . . 40436 2481 1 The the DT 40436 2481 2 valuable valuable JJ 40436 2481 3 is be VBZ 40436 2481 4 gain gain NN 40436 2481 5 : : : 40436 2481 6 the the DT 40436 2481 7 valueless valueless NN 40436 2481 8 is be VBZ 40436 2481 9 no no DT 40436 2481 10 gain gain NN 40436 2481 11 . . . 40436 2482 1 The the DT 40436 2482 2 valuable valuable JJ 40436 2482 3 is be VBZ 40436 2482 4 that that DT 40436 2482 5 which which WDT 40436 2482 6 is be VBZ 40436 2482 7 valuable valuable JJ 40436 2482 8 to to TO 40436 2482 9 possess possess VB 40436 2482 10 : : : 40436 2482 11 is be VBZ 40436 2482 12 that that IN 40436 2482 13 the the DT 40436 2482 14 profitable profitable JJ 40436 2482 15 , , , 40436 2482 16 or or CC 40436 2482 17 the the DT 40436 2482 18 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 2482 19 ? ? . 40436 2483 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2483 2 Comp._--It Comp._--It NNP 40436 2483 3 is be VBZ 40436 2483 4 the the DT 40436 2483 5 profitable profitable JJ 40436 2483 6 . . . 40436 2484 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2484 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 2484 3 the the DT 40436 2484 4 profitable profitable NN 40436 2484 5 is be VBZ 40436 2484 6 good good JJ 40436 2484 7 ? ? . 40436 2485 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2485 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2485 3 : : : 40436 2485 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2485 5 is be VBZ 40436 2485 6 . . . 40436 2486 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2486 2 Sokr._--Why Sokr._--Why NNP 40436 2486 3 then then RB 40436 2486 4 , , , 40436 2486 5 here here RB 40436 2486 6 , , , 40436 2486 7 the the DT 40436 2486 8 same same JJ 40436 2486 9 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2486 10 comes come VBZ 40436 2486 11 back back RB 40436 2486 12 to to IN 40436 2486 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2486 14 as as IN 40436 2486 15 agreed agree VBN 40436 2486 16 , , , 40436 2486 17 for for IN 40436 2486 18 the the DT 40436 2486 19 third third JJ 40436 2486 20 or or CC 40436 2486 21 fourth fourth JJ 40436 2486 22 time time NN 40436 2486 23 . . . 40436 2487 1 The the DT 40436 2487 2 gainful gainful JJ 40436 2487 3 is be VBZ 40436 2487 4 good good JJ 40436 2487 5 . . . 40436 2488 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2488 2 Comp._--It Comp._--It NNP 40436 2488 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 2488 4 so so RB 40436 2488 5 . . . 40436 2489 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2489 2 13 13 CD 40436 2489 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2489 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2489 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2489 6 13 13 CD 40436 2489 7 : : : 40436 2489 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2489 9 , , , 40436 2489 10 Hipparch Hipparch NNP 40436 2489 11 . . . 40436 2490 1 231 231 CD 40436 2490 2 D d NN 40436 2490 3 - - HYPH 40436 2490 4 E e NN 40436 2490 5 , , , 40436 2490 6 232 232 CD 40436 2490 7 A. a. NN 40436 2490 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2491 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2491 2 Side side NN 40436 2491 3 - - HYPH 40436 2491 4 note note NN 40436 2491 5 : : : 40436 2491 6 Recapitulation recapitulation NN 40436 2491 7 . . . 40436 2492 1 The the DT 40436 2492 2 debate debate NN 40436 2492 3 has have VBZ 40436 2492 4 shown show VBN 40436 2492 5 that that IN 40436 2492 6 all all DT 40436 2492 7 gain gain NN 40436 2492 8 is be VBZ 40436 2492 9 good good JJ 40436 2492 10 , , , 40436 2492 11 and and CC 40436 2492 12 that that IN 40436 2492 13 there there EX 40436 2492 14 is be VBZ 40436 2492 15 no no DT 40436 2492 16 evil evil JJ 40436 2492 17 gain gain NN 40436 2492 18 -- -- : 40436 2492 19 all all DT 40436 2492 20 men man NNS 40436 2492 21 are be VBP 40436 2492 22 lovers lover NNS 40436 2492 23 of of IN 40436 2492 24 gain gain NN 40436 2492 25 -- -- : 40436 2492 26 no no DT 40436 2492 27 man man NN 40436 2492 28 ought ought MD 40436 2492 29 to to TO 40436 2492 30 be be VB 40436 2492 31 reproached reproach VBN 40436 2492 32 for for IN 40436 2492 33 being be VBG 40436 2492 34 so so RB 40436 2492 35 . . . 40436 2493 1 The the DT 40436 2493 2 companion companion NN 40436 2493 3 is be VBZ 40436 2493 4 compelled compel VBN 40436 2493 5 to to TO 40436 2493 6 admit admit VB 40436 2493 7 this this DT 40436 2493 8 , , , 40436 2493 9 though though IN 40436 2493 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2493 11 declares declare VBZ 40436 2493 12 that that IN 40436 2493 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2493 14 is be VBZ 40436 2493 15 not not RB 40436 2493 16 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 2493 17 . . . 40436 2493 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2494 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2494 2 Sokr._--Let Sokr._--Let NNP 40436 2494 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2494 4 remind remind VB 40436 2494 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2494 6 of of IN 40436 2494 7 what what WP 40436 2494 8 has have VBZ 40436 2494 9 passed pass VBN 40436 2494 10 . . . 40436 2495 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2495 2 contended contend VBD 40436 2495 3 that that IN 40436 2495 4 good good JJ 40436 2495 5 men man NNS 40436 2495 6 did do VBD 40436 2495 7 not not RB 40436 2495 8 wish wish VB 40436 2495 9 to to TO 40436 2495 10 acquire acquire VB 40436 2495 11 all all DT 40436 2495 12 sorts sort NNS 40436 2495 13 of of IN 40436 2495 14 gain gain NN 40436 2495 15 , , , 40436 2495 16 but but CC 40436 2495 17 only only RB 40436 2495 18 such such JJ 40436 2495 19 as as IN 40436 2495 20 were be VBD 40436 2495 21 good good JJ 40436 2495 22 , , , 40436 2495 23 and and CC 40436 2495 24 not not RB 40436 2495 25 such such JJ 40436 2495 26 as as IN 40436 2495 27 were be VBD 40436 2495 28 evil evil JJ 40436 2495 29 . . . 40436 2496 1 But but CC 40436 2496 2 now now RB 40436 2496 3 , , , 40436 2496 4 the the DT 40436 2496 5 debate debate NN 40436 2496 6 has have VBZ 40436 2496 7 compelled compel VBN 40436 2496 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2496 9 to to TO 40436 2496 10 acknowledge acknowledge VB 40436 2496 11 that that IN 40436 2496 12 all all DT 40436 2496 13 gains gain NNS 40436 2496 14 are be VBP 40436 2496 15 good good JJ 40436 2496 16 , , , 40436 2496 17 whether whether IN 40436 2496 18 small small JJ 40436 2496 19 or or CC 40436 2496 20 great great JJ 40436 2496 21 . . . 40436 2497 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2497 2 Comp._--As Comp._--As NNP 40436 2497 3 for for IN 40436 2497 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2497 5 , , , 40436 2497 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2497 7 , , , 40436 2497 8 the the DT 40436 2497 9 debate debate NN 40436 2497 10 has have VBZ 40436 2497 11 compelled compel VBN 40436 2497 12 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2497 13 rather rather RB 40436 2497 14 than than IN 40436 2497 15 persuaded persuade VBD 40436 2497 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2497 17 . . . 40436 2498 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2498 2 14 14 CD 40436 2498 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2498 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2498 5 Sokr._--Presently Sokr._--Presently NNP 40436 2498 6 , , , 40436 2498 7 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 2498 8 , , , 40436 2498 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2498 10 may may MD 40436 2498 11 even even RB 40436 2498 12 persuade persuade VB 40436 2498 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2498 14 . . . 40436 2499 1 But but CC 40436 2499 2 now now RB 40436 2499 3 , , , 40436 2499 4 whether whether IN 40436 2499 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2499 6 have have VBP 40436 2499 7 been be VBN 40436 2499 8 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 2499 9 or or CC 40436 2499 10 not not RB 40436 2499 11 , , , 40436 2499 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2499 13 at at IN 40436 2499 14 least least JJS 40436 2499 15 concur concur VB 40436 2499 16 with with IN 40436 2499 17 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2499 18 in in IN 40436 2499 19 affirming affirming NN 40436 2499 20 that that IN 40436 2499 21 all all DT 40436 2499 22 gains gain NNS 40436 2499 23 , , , 40436 2499 24 whether whether IN 40436 2499 25 small small JJ 40436 2499 26 or or CC 40436 2499 27 great great JJ 40436 2499 28 , , , 40436 2499 29 are be VBP 40436 2499 30 good good JJ 40436 2499 31 . . . 40436 2500 1 That that IN 40436 2500 2 all all DT 40436 2500 3 good good JJ 40436 2500 4 men man NNS 40436 2500 5 wish wish VBP 40436 2500 6 for for IN 40436 2500 7 all all DT 40436 2500 8 good good JJ 40436 2500 9 things thing NNS 40436 2500 10 . . . 40436 2501 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2501 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNP 40436 2501 3 do do VBP 40436 2501 4 concur concur VB 40436 2501 5 . . . 40436 2502 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2502 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 2502 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2502 4 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 2502 5 stated state VBD 40436 2502 6 that that IN 40436 2502 7 evil evil JJ 40436 2502 8 men man NNS 40436 2502 9 love love VBP 40436 2502 10 all all DT 40436 2502 11 gains gain NNS 40436 2502 12 , , , 40436 2502 13 small small JJ 40436 2502 14 and and CC 40436 2502 15 great great JJ 40436 2502 16 ? ? . 40436 2503 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2503 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNP 40436 2503 3 said say VBD 40436 2503 4 so so RB 40436 2503 5 . . . 40436 2504 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2504 2 Sokr._--According sokr._--according IN 40436 2504 3 to to IN 40436 2504 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2504 5 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 2504 6 then then RB 40436 2504 7 , , , 40436 2504 8 all all DT 40436 2504 9 men man NNS 40436 2504 10 are be VBP 40436 2504 11 lovers lover NNS 40436 2504 12 of of IN 40436 2504 13 gain gain NN 40436 2504 14 , , , 40436 2504 15 the the DT 40436 2504 16 good good JJ 40436 2504 17 men man NNS 40436 2504 18 as as RB 40436 2504 19 well well RB 40436 2504 20 as as IN 40436 2504 21 the the DT 40436 2504 22 evil evil NN 40436 2504 23 ? ? . 40436 2505 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2505 2 Comp._--Apparently Comp._--Apparently NNP 40436 2505 3 so so RB 40436 2505 4 . . . 40436 2506 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2506 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 2506 3 is be VBZ 40436 2506 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 2506 5 wrong wrong JJ 40436 2506 6 to to TO 40436 2506 7 reproach reproach VB 40436 2506 8 any any DT 40436 2506 9 man man NN 40436 2506 10 as as IN 40436 2506 11 a a DT 40436 2506 12 lover lover NN 40436 2506 13 of of IN 40436 2506 14 gain gain NN 40436 2506 15 : : : 40436 2506 16 for for IN 40436 2506 17 the the DT 40436 2506 18 person person NN 40436 2506 19 who who WP 40436 2506 20 reproaches reproach VBZ 40436 2506 21 is be VBZ 40436 2506 22 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2506 23 a a DT 40436 2506 24 lover lover NN 40436 2506 25 of of IN 40436 2506 26 gain gain NN 40436 2506 27 , , , 40436 2506 28 just just RB 40436 2506 29 as as RB 40436 2506 30 much much JJ 40436 2506 31 . . . 40436 2507 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2507 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2507 3 14 14 CD 40436 2507 4 : : : 40436 2507 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 2507 6 . . . 40436 2508 1 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2508 2 . . . 40436 2509 1 232 232 CD 40436 2509 2 A A NNP 40436 2509 3 - - HYPH 40436 2509 4 B. b. NN 40436 2510 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2510 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 2510 3 . . . 40436 2510 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2510 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2510 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2510 7 : : : 40436 2510 8 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 2510 9 = = SYM 40436 2510 10 n n NNP 40436 2510 11 nu nu NNP 40436 2510 12 = = SYM 40436 2510 13 n n NNP 40436 2510 14 pa pa NNP 40436 2510 15 / / SYM 40436 2510 16 nta nta NNP 40436 2510 17 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 2510 18 ke ke NNP 40436 2510 19 / / SYM 40436 2510 20 rdê rdê NNP 40436 2510 21 o o NNP 40436 2510 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2510 23 lo lo NNP 40436 2510 24 / / SYM 40436 2510 25 gos gos NNP 40436 2510 26 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 2510 27 = = SYM 40436 2510 28 s s NNP 40436 2510 29 ê)na ê)na NNP 40436 2510 30 / / SYM 40436 2510 31 gkake gkake NNP 40436 2510 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2510 33 smikra\ smikra\ NNP 40436 2510 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2510 35 mega mega NNP 40436 2510 36 / / SYM 40436 2510 37 la la JJ 40436 2510 38 o(mologei o(mologei NNP 40436 2510 39 = = SYM 40436 2510 40 n n CC 40436 2510 41 a)gatha\ a)gatha\ NNP 40436 2510 42 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 2510 43 ? ? . 40436 2510 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2511 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2511 2 Comp Comp NNP 40436 2511 3 . . . 40436 2511 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2511 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2511 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2511 7 : : : 40436 2511 8 Ê)na Ê)na NNP 40436 2511 9 / / SYM 40436 2511 10 gkake gkake NNP 40436 2511 11 ga ga NNP 40436 2511 12 / / SYM 40436 2511 13 r r NNP 40436 2511 14 , , , 40436 2511 15 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 2511 16 Sô Sô NNP 40436 2511 17 / / SYM 40436 2511 18 krates krates NNPS 40436 2511 19 , , , 40436 2511 20 ma ma NNP 40436 2511 21 = = SYM 40436 2511 22 llon llon NNP 40436 2511 23 e)me/ e)me/ CD 40436 2511 24 ge ge NNP 40436 2511 25 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 2511 26 pe pe NNP 40436 2511 27 / / SYM 40436 2511 28 peiken peiken VBN 40436 2511 29 . . . 40436 2511 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2512 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2512 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 2512 3 . . . 40436 2512 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2512 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2512 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2512 7 : : : 40436 2512 8 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 2512 9 ' ' `` 40436 2512 10 i)/sôs i)/sôs NNP 40436 2512 11 meta\ meta\ . 40436 2512 12 tou tou NNP 40436 2512 13 = = SYM 40436 2512 14 to to IN 40436 2512 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2512 16 pei pei NNP 40436 2512 17 / / SYM 40436 2512 18 seien seien NNP 40436 2512 19 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2512 20 . . . 40436 2512 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2512 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2513 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2513 2 Side side NN 40436 2513 3 - - HYPH 40436 2513 4 note note NN 40436 2513 5 : : : 40436 2513 6 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2513 7 . . . 40436 2514 1 Question question NN 40436 2514 2 put put VBN 40436 2514 3 by by IN 40436 2514 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2514 5 to to IN 40436 2514 6 the the DT 40436 2514 7 companion companion NN 40436 2514 8 . . . 40436 2515 1 What what WP 40436 2515 2 is be VBZ 40436 2515 3 Law Law NNP 40436 2515 4 , , , 40436 2515 5 or or CC 40436 2515 6 The the DT 40436 2515 7 Law Law NNP 40436 2515 8 ? ? . 40436 2516 1 All all DT 40436 2516 2 law law NN 40436 2516 3 is be VBZ 40436 2516 4 the the DT 40436 2516 5 same same JJ 40436 2516 6 , , , 40436 2516 7 _ _ NNP 40436 2516 8 quatenus quatenus NN 40436 2516 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2516 10 law law NN 40436 2516 11 : : : 40436 2516 12 what what WP 40436 2516 13 is be VBZ 40436 2516 14 the the DT 40436 2516 15 common common JJ 40436 2516 16 constituent constituent NN 40436 2516 17 attribute attribute NN 40436 2516 18 ? ? . 40436 2516 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2517 1 The the DT 40436 2517 2 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2517 3 , , , 40436 2517 4 like like IN 40436 2517 5 the the DT 40436 2517 6 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2517 7 , , , 40436 2517 8 is be VBZ 40436 2517 9 a a DT 40436 2517 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2517 11 carried carry VBN 40436 2517 12 on on RP 40436 2517 13 between between IN 40436 2517 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2517 15 and and CC 40436 2517 16 a a DT 40436 2517 17 companion companion NN 40436 2517 18 not not RB 40436 2517 19 named name VBN 40436 2517 20 . . . 40436 2518 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2518 2 relates relate VBZ 40436 2518 3 to to IN 40436 2518 4 Law Law NNP 40436 2518 5 , , , 40436 2518 6 or or CC 40436 2518 7 The the DT 40436 2518 8 Law-- law-- NN 40436 2518 9 _ _ NN 40436 2518 10 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 2518 11 is be VBZ 40436 2518 12 Law Law NNP 40436 2518 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2518 14 asks ask VBZ 40436 2518 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2518 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2518 17 ? ? . 40436 2519 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2519 2 Comp._--Respecting Comp._--Respecting NNP 40436 2519 3 what what WP 40436 2519 4 sort sort NN 40436 2519 5 of of IN 40436 2519 6 Law Law NNP 40436 2519 7 do do VBP 40436 2519 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2519 9 enquire enquire VB 40436 2519 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2519 11 replies reply VBZ 40436 2519 12 the the DT 40436 2519 13 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2519 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2519 15 ? ? . 40436 2520 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2520 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 2520 3 ! ! . 40436 2521 1 is be VBZ 40436 2521 2 there there EX 40436 2521 3 any any DT 40436 2521 4 difference difference NN 40436 2521 5 between between IN 40436 2521 6 one one CD 40436 2521 7 law law NN 40436 2521 8 and and CC 40436 2521 9 another another DT 40436 2521 10 law law NN 40436 2521 11 , , , 40436 2521 12 as as IN 40436 2521 13 to to IN 40436 2521 14 that that DT 40436 2521 15 identical identical JJ 40436 2521 16 circumstance circumstance NN 40436 2521 17 , , , 40436 2521 18 of of IN 40436 2521 19 being be VBG 40436 2521 20 Law Law NNP 40436 2521 21 ? ? . 40436 2522 1 Gold gold NN 40436 2522 2 does do VBZ 40436 2522 3 not not RB 40436 2522 4 differ differ VB 40436 2522 5 from from IN 40436 2522 6 gold gold NN 40436 2522 7 , , , 40436 2522 8 so so RB 40436 2522 9 far far RB 40436 2522 10 as as IN 40436 2522 11 the the DT 40436 2522 12 being be VBG 40436 2522 13 gold gold NN 40436 2522 14 is be VBZ 40436 2522 15 concerned concern VBN 40436 2522 16 -- -- : 40436 2522 17 nor nor CC 40436 2522 18 stone stone NN 40436 2522 19 from from IN 40436 2522 20 stone stone NN 40436 2522 21 , , , 40436 2522 22 so so RB 40436 2522 23 far far RB 40436 2522 24 as as IN 40436 2522 25 being be VBG 40436 2522 26 stone stone NN 40436 2522 27 is be VBZ 40436 2522 28 concerned concern VBN 40436 2522 29 . . . 40436 2523 1 In in IN 40436 2523 2 like like JJ 40436 2523 3 manner manner NN 40436 2523 4 , , , 40436 2523 5 one one CD 40436 2523 6 law law NN 40436 2523 7 does do VBZ 40436 2523 8 not not RB 40436 2523 9 differ differ VB 40436 2523 10 from from IN 40436 2523 11 another another DT 40436 2523 12 , , , 40436 2523 13 all all DT 40436 2523 14 are be VBP 40436 2523 15 the the DT 40436 2523 16 same same JJ 40436 2523 17 , , , 40436 2523 18 in in IN 40436 2523 19 so so RB 40436 2523 20 far far RB 40436 2523 21 as as IN 40436 2523 22 each each DT 40436 2523 23 is be VBZ 40436 2523 24 Law Law NNP 40436 2523 25 alike:--not alike:--not NN 40436 2523 26 , , , 40436 2523 27 one one CD 40436 2523 28 of of IN 40436 2523 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2523 30 more more RBR 40436 2523 31 , , , 40436 2523 32 and and CC 40436 2523 33 another another DT 40436 2523 34 less less RBR 40436 2523 35 . . . 40436 2524 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2524 2 is be VBZ 40436 2524 3 about about IN 40436 2524 4 this this DT 40436 2524 5 as as IN 40436 2524 6 a a DT 40436 2524 7 whole whole NN 40436 2524 8 that that WDT 40436 2524 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2524 10 ask ask VBP 40436 2524 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2524 12 -- -- : 40436 2524 13 What what WP 40436 2524 14 is be VBZ 40436 2524 15 Law Law NNP 40436 2524 16 ? ? . 40436 2525 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2525 2 Side side NN 40436 2525 3 - - HYPH 40436 2525 4 note note NN 40436 2525 5 : : : 40436 2525 6 Answer answer NN 40436 2525 7 -- -- : 40436 2525 8 Law Law NNP 40436 2525 9 is be VBZ 40436 2525 10 , , , 40436 2525 11 1 1 CD 40436 2525 12 . . . 40436 2526 1 The the DT 40436 2526 2 consecrated consecrated JJ 40436 2526 3 and and CC 40436 2526 4 binding bind VBG 40436 2526 5 customs custom NNS 40436 2526 6 . . . 40436 2527 1 2 2 LS 40436 2527 2 . . . 40436 2528 1 The the DT 40436 2528 2 decree decree NN 40436 2528 3 of of IN 40436 2528 4 the the DT 40436 2528 5 city city NN 40436 2528 6 . . . 40436 2529 1 3 3 LS 40436 2529 2 . . . 40436 2530 1 Social social JJ 40436 2530 2 or or CC 40436 2530 3 civic civic JJ 40436 2530 4 opinion opinion NN 40436 2530 5 . . . 40436 2530 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2531 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2531 2 Comp._--What Comp._--What NNP 40436 2531 3 should should MD 40436 2531 4 Law Law NNP 40436 2531 5 be be VB 40436 2531 6 , , , 40436 2531 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2531 8 , , , 40436 2531 9 other other JJ 40436 2531 10 than than IN 40436 2531 11 the the DT 40436 2531 12 various various JJ 40436 2531 13 assemblage assemblage NN 40436 2531 14 of of IN 40436 2531 15 consecrated consecrated JJ 40436 2531 16 and and CC 40436 2531 17 binding bind VBG 40436 2531 18 customs custom NNS 40436 2531 19 and and CC 40436 2531 20 beliefs belief NNS 40436 2531 21 ? ? . 40436 2532 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2532 2 15 15 CD 40436 2532 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2532 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2532 5 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 2532 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2532 7 think think VBP 40436 2532 8 , , , 40436 2532 9 then then RB 40436 2532 10 , , , 40436 2532 11 that that DT 40436 2532 12 discourse discourse NN 40436 2532 13 is be VBZ 40436 2532 14 , , , 40436 2532 15 the the DT 40436 2532 16 things thing NNS 40436 2532 17 spoken speak VBN 40436 2532 18 : : : 40436 2532 19 that that DT 40436 2532 20 sight sight NN 40436 2532 21 is be VBZ 40436 2532 22 , , , 40436 2532 23 the the DT 40436 2532 24 things thing NNS 40436 2532 25 seen see VBN 40436 2532 26 ? ? . 40436 2533 1 that that DT 40436 2533 2 hearing hearing NN 40436 2533 3 is be VBZ 40436 2533 4 , , , 40436 2533 5 the the DT 40436 2533 6 things thing NNS 40436 2533 7 heard hear VBN 40436 2533 8 ? ? . 40436 2534 1 Or or CC 40436 2534 2 are be VBP 40436 2534 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2534 4 not not RB 40436 2534 5 distinct distinct JJ 40436 2534 6 , , , 40436 2534 7 in in IN 40436 2534 8 each each DT 40436 2534 9 of of IN 40436 2534 10 the the DT 40436 2534 11 three three CD 40436 2534 12 cases case NNS 40436 2534 13 -- -- : 40436 2534 14 and and CC 40436 2534 15 is be VBZ 40436 2534 16 not not RB 40436 2534 17 Law Law NNP 40436 2534 18 also also RB 40436 2534 19 one one CD 40436 2534 20 thing thing NN 40436 2534 21 , , , 40436 2534 22 the the DT 40436 2534 23 various various JJ 40436 2534 24 customs custom NNS 40436 2534 25 and and CC 40436 2534 26 beliefs belief NNS 40436 2534 27 another another DT 40436 2534 28 ? ? . 40436 2535 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2535 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2535 3 ! ! . 40436 2536 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2536 2 now now RB 40436 2536 3 think think VBP 40436 2536 4 that that IN 40436 2536 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2536 6 are be VBP 40436 2536 7 distinct distinct JJ 40436 2536 8 . . . 40436 2537 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2537 2 16 16 CD 40436 2537 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2537 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2537 5 Sokr._--Law Sokr._--Law NNP 40436 2537 6 is be VBZ 40436 2537 7 that that IN 40436 2537 8 whereby whereby WRB 40436 2537 9 these these DT 40436 2537 10 binding bind VBG 40436 2537 11 customs custom NNS 40436 2537 12 become become VBP 40436 2537 13 binding binding JJ 40436 2537 14 . . . 40436 2538 1 What what WP 40436 2538 2 is be VBZ 40436 2538 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2538 4 ? ? . 40436 2539 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2539 2 Comp._--Law Comp._--Law NNP 40436 2539 3 can can MD 40436 2539 4 be be VB 40436 2539 5 nothing nothing NN 40436 2539 6 else else RB 40436 2539 7 than than IN 40436 2539 8 the the DT 40436 2539 9 public public JJ 40436 2539 10 resolutions resolution NNS 40436 2539 11 and and CC 40436 2539 12 decrees decree NNS 40436 2539 13 promulgated promulgate VBD 40436 2539 14 among among IN 40436 2539 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2539 16 . . . 40436 2540 1 Law Law NNP 40436 2540 2 is be VBZ 40436 2540 3 the the DT 40436 2540 4 decree decree NN 40436 2540 5 of of IN 40436 2540 6 the the DT 40436 2540 7 city city NN 40436 2540 8 . . . 40436 2541 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2541 2 17 17 CD 40436 2541 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2541 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2541 5 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 2541 6 mean mean NN 40436 2541 7 , , , 40436 2541 8 that that IN 40436 2541 9 Law Law NNP 40436 2541 10 is be VBZ 40436 2541 11 social social JJ 40436 2541 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 2541 13 . . . 40436 2542 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2542 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2542 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2542 4 do do VBP 40436 2542 5 . . . 40436 2543 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2543 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2543 3 15 15 CD 40436 2543 4 : : : 40436 2543 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2543 6 , , , 40436 2543 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2543 8 , , , 40436 2543 9 313 313 CD 40436 2543 10 B. B. NNP 40436 2544 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2544 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2544 3 : : : 40436 2544 4 Ti/ Ti/ NNP 40436 2544 5 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 2544 6 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 2544 7 no no UH 40436 2544 8 / / SYM 40436 2544 9 mos mos NN 40436 2544 10 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 2544 11 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2544 12 a)ll a)ll NN 40436 2544 13 ' ' '' 40436 2544 14 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 2544 15 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 2544 16 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2544 17 / / SYM 40436 2544 18 mena mena NN 40436 2544 19 ? ? . 40436 2544 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2544 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2545 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2545 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2545 3 16 16 CD 40436 2545 4 : : : 40436 2545 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2545 6 , , , 40436 2545 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2545 8 , , , 40436 2545 9 313 313 CD 40436 2545 10 B B NNP 40436 2545 11 - - HYPH 40436 2545 12 C. C. NNP 40436 2546 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2546 2 pass pass VBP 40436 2546 3 over over RB 40436 2546 4 here here RB 40436 2546 5 an an DT 40436 2546 6 analogy analogy NN 40436 2546 7 started start VBN 40436 2546 8 by by IN 40436 2546 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2546 10 in in IN 40436 2546 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2546 12 next next JJ 40436 2546 13 question question NN 40436 2546 14 ; ; : 40436 2546 15 as as IN 40436 2546 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2546 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2546 18 : : : 40436 2546 19 o)/psis o)/psis NN 40436 2546 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2546 21 to to IN 40436 2546 22 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2546 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2546 24 : : : 40436 2546 25 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 2546 26 o(rô o(rô NN 40436 2546 27 / / SYM 40436 2546 28 mena mena NN 40436 2546 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2546 30 , , , 40436 2546 31 so so RB 40436 2546 32 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2546 33 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2546 34 : : : 40436 2546 35 no no UH 40436 2546 36 / / SYM 40436 2546 37 mos mos NN 40436 2546 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2546 39 to to IN 40436 2546 40 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2546 41 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2546 42 : : : 40436 2546 43 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 2546 44 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2546 45 / / SYM 40436 2546 46 mena mena NNP 40436 2546 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2546 48 , , , 40436 2546 49 & & CC 40436 2546 50 c. c. NNP 40436 2546 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2546 52 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2546 53 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2546 54 17 17 CD 40436 2546 55 : : : 40436 2546 56 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2546 57 , , , 40436 2546 58 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2546 59 , , , 40436 2546 60 814 814 CD 40436 2546 61 A. a. NN 40436 2547 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2547 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2547 3 : : : 40436 2547 4 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ NN 40436 2547 5 no no UH 40436 2547 6 / / SYM 40436 2547 7 mô| mô| NNP 40436 2547 8 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 2547 9 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2547 10 / / SYM 40436 2547 11 mena mena NNP 40436 2547 12 nomi nomi NNP 40436 2547 13 / / SYM 40436 2547 14 zetai zetai NNP 40436 2547 15 , , , 40436 2547 16 ti ti NNP 40436 2547 17 / / SYM 40436 2547 18 ni ni NNP 40436 2547 19 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 2547 20 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 2547 21 no no UH 40436 2547 22 / / SYM 40436 2547 23 mô| mô| NNP 40436 2547 24 nomi nomi NN 40436 2547 25 / / SYM 40436 2547 26 zetai zetai NN 40436 2547 27 ? ? . 40436 2547 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2547 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2548 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2548 2 Side side NN 40436 2548 3 - - HYPH 40436 2548 4 note note NN 40436 2548 5 : : : 40436 2548 6 Cross cross NN 40436 2548 7 - - NN 40436 2548 8 examination examination NN 40436 2548 9 by by IN 40436 2548 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2548 11 -- -- : 40436 2548 12 just just RB 40436 2548 13 and and CC 40436 2548 14 lawfully lawfully RB 40436 2548 15 - - HYPH 40436 2548 16 behaving behave VBG 40436 2548 17 men man NNS 40436 2548 18 are be VBP 40436 2548 19 so so RB 40436 2548 20 through through IN 40436 2548 21 law law NN 40436 2548 22 ; ; : 40436 2548 23 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2548 24 and and CC 40436 2548 25 lawless lawless JJ 40436 2548 26 men man NNS 40436 2548 27 are be VBP 40436 2548 28 so so RB 40436 2548 29 through through IN 40436 2548 30 the the DT 40436 2548 31 absence absence NN 40436 2548 32 of of IN 40436 2548 33 law law NN 40436 2548 34 . . . 40436 2549 1 Law Law NNP 40436 2549 2 is be VBZ 40436 2549 3 highly highly RB 40436 2549 4 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2549 5 and and CC 40436 2549 6 useful useful JJ 40436 2549 7 : : : 40436 2549 8 lawlessness lawlessness NN 40436 2549 9 is be VBZ 40436 2549 10 ruinous ruinous JJ 40436 2549 11 . . . 40436 2550 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 2550 2 , , , 40436 2550 3 bad bad JJ 40436 2550 4 decrees decree NNS 40436 2550 5 of of IN 40436 2550 6 the the DT 40436 2550 7 city city NN 40436 2550 8 -- -- : 40436 2550 9 or or CC 40436 2550 10 bad bad JJ 40436 2550 11 social social JJ 40436 2550 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 2550 13 -- -- : 40436 2550 14 cannot cannot NNP 40436 2550 15 be be VB 40436 2550 16 law law NN 40436 2550 17 . . . 40436 2550 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2551 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2551 2 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 2551 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2551 4 are be VBP 40436 2551 5 right right JJ 40436 2551 6 : : : 40436 2551 7 but but CC 40436 2551 8 let let VB 40436 2551 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2551 10 examine examine VB 40436 2551 11 . . . 40436 2552 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2552 2 call call VBP 40436 2552 3 some some DT 40436 2552 4 persons person NNS 40436 2552 5 wise:--they wise:--they PRP 40436 2552 6 are be VBP 40436 2552 7 wise wise JJ 40436 2552 8 through through IN 40436 2552 9 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 2552 10 . . . 40436 2553 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2553 2 call call VBP 40436 2553 3 some some DT 40436 2553 4 just:--they just:--they NNS 40436 2553 5 are be VBP 40436 2553 6 just just RB 40436 2553 7 through through IN 40436 2553 8 justice justice NN 40436 2553 9 . . . 40436 2554 1 In in IN 40436 2554 2 like like JJ 40436 2554 3 manner manner NN 40436 2554 4 , , , 40436 2554 5 the the DT 40436 2554 6 lawfully lawfully RB 40436 2554 7 - - HYPH 40436 2554 8 behaving behave VBG 40436 2554 9 men man NNS 40436 2554 10 are be VBP 40436 2554 11 so so RB 40436 2554 12 through through IN 40436 2554 13 law law NN 40436 2554 14 : : : 40436 2554 15 the the DT 40436 2554 16 lawless lawless JJ 40436 2554 17 men man NNS 40436 2554 18 are be VBP 40436 2554 19 so so RB 40436 2554 20 through through IN 40436 2554 21 lawlessness lawlessness NN 40436 2554 22 . . . 40436 2555 1 Now now RB 40436 2555 2 the the DT 40436 2555 3 lawfully lawfully RB 40436 2555 4 - - HYPH 40436 2555 5 behaving behave VBG 40436 2555 6 men man NNS 40436 2555 7 are be VBP 40436 2555 8 just just RB 40436 2555 9 : : : 40436 2555 10 the the DT 40436 2555 11 lawless lawless JJ 40436 2555 12 men man NNS 40436 2555 13 are be VBP 40436 2555 14 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2555 15 . . . 40436 2556 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2556 2 Comp._--It Comp._--It NNP 40436 2556 3 is be VBZ 40436 2556 4 so so RB 40436 2556 5 . . . 40436 2557 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2557 2 Sokr._--Justice Sokr._--Justice NNP 40436 2557 3 and and CC 40436 2557 4 Law Law NNP 40436 2557 5 , , , 40436 2557 6 are be VBP 40436 2557 7 highly highly RB 40436 2557 8 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2557 9 : : : 40436 2557 10 injustice injustice NN 40436 2557 11 and and CC 40436 2557 12 lawlessness lawlessness JJ 40436 2557 13 , , , 40436 2557 14 highly highly RB 40436 2557 15 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 2557 16 : : : 40436 2557 17 the the DT 40436 2557 18 former former JJ 40436 2557 19 preserves preserve NNS 40436 2557 20 cities city NNS 40436 2557 21 , , , 40436 2557 22 the the DT 40436 2557 23 latter latter NN 40436 2557 24 ruins ruin VBZ 40436 2557 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2557 26 . . . 40436 2558 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2558 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2558 3 -- -- : 40436 2558 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2558 5 does do VBZ 40436 2558 6 . . . 40436 2559 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2559 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 2559 3 , , , 40436 2559 4 then then RB 40436 2559 5 ! ! . 40436 2560 1 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2560 2 must must MD 40436 2560 3 consider consider VB 40436 2560 4 law law NN 40436 2560 5 as as IN 40436 2560 6 something something NN 40436 2560 7 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2560 8 ; ; : 40436 2560 9 and and CC 40436 2560 10 seek seek VB 40436 2560 11 after after IN 40436 2560 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2560 13 , , , 40436 2560 14 under under IN 40436 2560 15 the the DT 40436 2560 16 assumption assumption NN 40436 2560 17 that that IN 40436 2560 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2560 19 is be VBZ 40436 2560 20 a a DT 40436 2560 21 good good JJ 40436 2560 22 thing thing NN 40436 2560 23 . . . 40436 2561 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2561 2 defined define VBD 40436 2561 3 law law NN 40436 2561 4 to to TO 40436 2561 5 be be VB 40436 2561 6 the the DT 40436 2561 7 decree decree NN 40436 2561 8 of of IN 40436 2561 9 the the DT 40436 2561 10 city city NN 40436 2561 11 : : : 40436 2561 12 Are be VBP 40436 2561 13 not not RB 40436 2561 14 some some DT 40436 2561 15 decrees decree NNS 40436 2561 16 good good JJ 40436 2561 17 , , , 40436 2561 18 others other NNS 40436 2561 19 evil evil JJ 40436 2561 20 ? ? . 40436 2562 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2562 2 Comp._--Unquestionably Comp._--Unquestionably NNP 40436 2562 3 . . . 40436 2563 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2563 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 2563 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2563 4 have have VBP 40436 2563 5 already already RB 40436 2563 6 said say VBN 40436 2563 7 that that IN 40436 2563 8 law law NN 40436 2563 9 is be VBZ 40436 2563 10 not not RB 40436 2563 11 evil evil JJ 40436 2563 12 . . . 40436 2564 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2564 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNP 40436 2564 3 admit admit VBP 40436 2564 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2564 5 . . . 40436 2565 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2565 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 2565 3 is be VBZ 40436 2565 4 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 2565 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 2565 6 to to TO 40436 2565 7 answer answer VB 40436 2565 8 , , , 40436 2565 9 as as IN 40436 2565 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2565 11 did do VBD 40436 2565 12 broadly broadly RB 40436 2565 13 , , , 40436 2565 14 that that DT 40436 2565 15 law law NN 40436 2565 16 is be VBZ 40436 2565 17 the the DT 40436 2565 18 decree decree NN 40436 2565 19 of of IN 40436 2565 20 the the DT 40436 2565 21 city city NN 40436 2565 22 . . . 40436 2566 1 An an DT 40436 2566 2 evil evil JJ 40436 2566 3 decree decree NN 40436 2566 4 can can MD 40436 2566 5 not not RB 40436 2566 6 be be VB 40436 2566 7 law law NN 40436 2566 8 . . . 40436 2567 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2567 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNS 40436 2567 3 see see VBP 40436 2567 4 that that IN 40436 2567 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2567 6 is be VBZ 40436 2567 7 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 2567 8 . . . 40436 2568 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2568 2 18 18 CD 40436 2568 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2568 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2568 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2568 6 18 18 CD 40436 2568 7 : : : 40436 2568 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2568 9 , , , 40436 2568 10 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2568 11 , , , 40436 2568 12 314 314 CD 40436 2568 13 B B NNP 40436 2568 14 - - HYPH 40436 2568 15 C C NNP 40436 2568 16 - - HYPH 40436 2568 17 D. D. NNP 40436 2568 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2568 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2568 20 Side side NN 40436 2568 21 - - HYPH 40436 2568 22 note note NN 40436 2568 23 : : : 40436 2568 24 Suggestion suggestion NN 40436 2568 25 by by IN 40436 2568 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2568 27 -- -- : 40436 2568 28 Law Law NNP 40436 2568 29 is be VBZ 40436 2568 30 the the DT 40436 2568 31 _ _ NNP 40436 2568 32 good good JJ 40436 2568 33 _ _ NNP 40436 2568 34 opinion opinion NN 40436 2568 35 of of IN 40436 2568 36 the the DT 40436 2568 37 city city NN 40436 2568 38 -- -- : 40436 2568 39 but but CC 40436 2568 40 good good JJ 40436 2568 41 opinion opinion NN 40436 2568 42 is be VBZ 40436 2568 43 true true JJ 40436 2568 44 opinion opinion NN 40436 2568 45 , , , 40436 2568 46 or or CC 40436 2568 47 the the DT 40436 2568 48 finding finding NN 40436 2568 49 out out IN 40436 2568 50 of of IN 40436 2568 51 reality reality NN 40436 2568 52 . . . 40436 2569 1 Law law NN 40436 2569 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 2569 3 wishes wish VBZ 40436 2569 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2569 5 tends tend VBZ 40436 2569 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2569 7 to to TO 40436 2569 8 be be VB 40436 2569 9 the the DT 40436 2569 10 finding finding NN 40436 2569 11 out out IN 40436 2569 12 of of IN 40436 2569 13 reality reality NN 40436 2569 14 , , , 40436 2569 15 though though IN 40436 2569 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2569 17 does do VBZ 40436 2569 18 not not RB 40436 2569 19 always always RB 40436 2569 20 succeed succeed VB 40436 2569 21 in in IN 40436 2569 22 doing do VBG 40436 2569 23 so so RB 40436 2569 24 . . . 40436 2569 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2570 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2570 2 Sokr._--Still Sokr._--Still NNP 40436 2570 3 -- -- : 40436 2570 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2570 5 think think VBP 40436 2570 6 , , , 40436 2570 7 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 2570 8 , , , 40436 2570 9 that that DT 40436 2570 10 law law NN 40436 2570 11 is be VBZ 40436 2570 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 2570 13 of of IN 40436 2570 14 some some DT 40436 2570 15 sort sort NN 40436 2570 16 ; ; : 40436 2570 17 and and CC 40436 2570 18 since since IN 40436 2570 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2570 20 is be VBZ 40436 2570 21 not not RB 40436 2570 22 evil evil JJ 40436 2570 23 opinion opinion NN 40436 2570 24 , , , 40436 2570 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2570 26 must must MD 40436 2570 27 be be VB 40436 2570 28 good good JJ 40436 2570 29 opinion opinion NN 40436 2570 30 . . . 40436 2571 1 Now now RB 40436 2571 2 good good JJ 40436 2571 3 opinion opinion NN 40436 2571 4 is be VBZ 40436 2571 5 true true JJ 40436 2571 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 2571 7 : : : 40436 2571 8 and and CC 40436 2571 9 true true JJ 40436 2571 10 opinion opinion NN 40436 2571 11 is be VBZ 40436 2571 12 , , , 40436 2571 13 the the DT 40436 2571 14 finding finding NN 40436 2571 15 out out IN 40436 2571 16 of of IN 40436 2571 17 reality reality NN 40436 2571 18 . . . 40436 2572 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2572 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNP 40436 2572 3 admit admit VBP 40436 2572 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2572 5 . . . 40436 2573 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2573 2 Sokr._--Law Sokr._--Law NNP 40436 2573 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 2573 4 wishes wish VBZ 40436 2573 5 or or CC 40436 2573 6 tends tend VBZ 40436 2573 7 to to TO 40436 2573 8 be be VB 40436 2573 9 , , , 40436 2573 10 the the DT 40436 2573 11 finding finding NN 40436 2573 12 out out IN 40436 2573 13 of of IN 40436 2573 14 reality reality NN 40436 2573 15 . . . 40436 2574 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2574 2 19 19 CD 40436 2574 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2574 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2574 5 Comp._--But Comp._--But NNP 40436 2574 6 , , , 40436 2574 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2574 8 , , , 40436 2574 9 if if IN 40436 2574 10 law law NN 40436 2574 11 is be VBZ 40436 2574 12 the the DT 40436 2574 13 finding finding NN 40436 2574 14 out out IN 40436 2574 15 of of IN 40436 2574 16 reality reality NN 40436 2574 17 -- -- : 40436 2574 18 if if IN 40436 2574 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2574 20 have have VBP 40436 2574 21 therein therein RB 40436 2574 22 already already RB 40436 2574 23 found find VBN 40436 2574 24 out out RP 40436 2574 25 realities reality NNS 40436 2574 26 -- -- : 40436 2574 27 how how WRB 40436 2574 28 comes come VBZ 40436 2574 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2574 30 that that IN 40436 2574 31 all all DT 40436 2574 32 communities community NNS 40436 2574 33 of of IN 40436 2574 34 men man NNS 40436 2574 35 do do VBP 40436 2574 36 not not RB 40436 2574 37 use use VB 40436 2574 38 the the DT 40436 2574 39 same same JJ 40436 2574 40 laws law NNS 40436 2574 41 respecting respect VBG 40436 2574 42 the the DT 40436 2574 43 same same JJ 40436 2574 44 matters matter NNS 40436 2574 45 ? ? . 40436 2575 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2575 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 2575 3 law law NN 40436 2575 4 does do VBZ 40436 2575 5 not not RB 40436 2575 6 the the DT 40436 2575 7 less less JJR 40436 2575 8 wish wish NN 40436 2575 9 or or CC 40436 2575 10 tend tend VB 40436 2575 11 to to TO 40436 2575 12 find find VB 40436 2575 13 out out RP 40436 2575 14 realities reality NNS 40436 2575 15 ; ; : 40436 2575 16 but but CC 40436 2575 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2575 18 is be VBZ 40436 2575 19 unable unable JJ 40436 2575 20 to to TO 40436 2575 21 do do VB 40436 2575 22 so so RB 40436 2575 23 . . . 40436 2576 1 That that RB 40436 2576 2 is is RB 40436 2576 3 , , , 40436 2576 4 if if IN 40436 2576 5 the the DT 40436 2576 6 fact fact NN 40436 2576 7 be be VB 40436 2576 8 true true JJ 40436 2576 9 as as IN 40436 2576 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2576 11 state state VBP 40436 2576 12 -- -- : 40436 2576 13 that that IN 40436 2576 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2576 15 change change VBP 40436 2576 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2576 17 laws law NNS 40436 2576 18 , , , 40436 2576 19 and and CC 40436 2576 20 do do VBP 40436 2576 21 not not RB 40436 2576 22 all all DT 40436 2576 23 of of IN 40436 2576 24 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2576 25 use use VBP 40436 2576 26 the the DT 40436 2576 27 same same JJ 40436 2576 28 . . . 40436 2577 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2577 2 Comp._--Surely Comp._--Surely NNP 40436 2577 3 , , , 40436 2577 4 the the DT 40436 2577 5 fact fact NN 40436 2577 6 as as IN 40436 2577 7 a a DT 40436 2577 8 fact fact NN 40436 2577 9 is be VBZ 40436 2577 10 obvious obvious JJ 40436 2577 11 enough enough RB 40436 2577 12 . . . 40436 2578 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2578 2 20 20 CD 40436 2578 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2578 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2578 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2578 6 19 19 CD 40436 2578 7 : : : 40436 2578 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2578 9 , , , 40436 2578 10 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2578 11 , , , 40436 2578 12 315 315 CD 40436 2578 13 A. a. NN 40436 2579 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2579 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2579 3 : : : 40436 2579 4 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 2579 5 = = SYM 40436 2579 6 n n CC 40436 2579 7 ê ê NNP 40436 2579 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2579 9 a)lêthê\s a)lêthê\s RB 40436 2579 10 do do VB 40436 2579 11 / / SYM 40436 2579 12 xa xa NNP 40436 2579 13 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2579 14 o)/ntos o)/nto NNS 40436 2579 15 e)stin e)stin NFP 40436 2579 16 e)xeu e)xeu . 40436 2579 17 / / SYM 40436 2579 18 resis resis NN 40436 2579 19 ? ? . 40436 2580 1 . . . 40436 2581 1 . . . 40436 2582 1 . . . 40436 2583 1 o o UH 40436 2583 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2583 3 no no UH 40436 2583 4 / / SYM 40436 2583 5 mos mos NN 40436 2583 6 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 2583 7 bou bou NN 40436 2583 8 / / SYM 40436 2583 9 letai letai JJ 40436 2583 10 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2583 11 o)/ntos o)/ntos NN 40436 2583 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 2583 13 e)xeu e)xeu NNS 40436 2583 14 / / SYM 40436 2583 15 resis resis NN 40436 2583 16 ? ? . 40436 2583 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2583 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2584 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2584 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2584 3 20 20 CD 40436 2584 4 : : : 40436 2584 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2584 6 , , , 40436 2584 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2584 8 , , , 40436 2584 9 315 315 CD 40436 2584 10 A A NNP 40436 2584 11 - - HYPH 40436 2584 12 B. b. NN 40436 2584 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2585 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2585 2 Side side NN 40436 2585 3 - - HYPH 40436 2585 4 note note NN 40436 2585 5 : : : 40436 2585 6 Objection objection NN 40436 2585 7 taken take VBN 40436 2585 8 by by IN 40436 2585 9 the the DT 40436 2585 10 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2585 11 -- -- : 40436 2585 12 That that IN 40436 2585 13 there there EX 40436 2585 14 is be VBZ 40436 2585 15 great great JJ 40436 2585 16 discordance discordance NN 40436 2585 17 of of IN 40436 2585 18 laws law NNS 40436 2585 19 in in IN 40436 2585 20 different different JJ 40436 2585 21 places place NNS 40436 2585 22 -- -- : 40436 2585 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2585 24 specifies specify VBZ 40436 2585 25 several several JJ 40436 2585 26 cases case NNS 40436 2585 27 of of IN 40436 2585 28 such such JJ 40436 2585 29 discordance discordance NN 40436 2585 30 at at IN 40436 2585 31 some some DT 40436 2585 32 length length NN 40436 2585 33 . . . 40436 2586 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2586 2 reproves reprove VBZ 40436 2586 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2586 4 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 2586 5 , , , 40436 2586 6 and and CC 40436 2586 7 requests request VBZ 40436 2586 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2586 9 to to TO 40436 2586 10 confine confine VB 40436 2586 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2586 12 to to TO 40436 2586 13 question question VB 40436 2586 14 or or CC 40436 2586 15 answer answer VB 40436 2586 16 . . . 40436 2586 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2587 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2587 2 The the DT 40436 2587 3 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2587 4 here here RB 40436 2587 5 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 2587 6 some some DT 40436 2587 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 2587 8 local local JJ 40436 2587 9 rites rite NNS 40436 2587 10 , , , 40436 2587 11 venerable venerable JJ 40436 2587 12 in in IN 40436 2587 13 one one CD 40436 2587 14 place place NN 40436 2587 15 , , , 40436 2587 16 abhorrent abhorrent NN 40436 2587 17 in in IN 40436 2587 18 another another DT 40436 2587 19 , , , 40436 2587 20 such such JJ 40436 2587 21 as as IN 40436 2587 22 the the DT 40436 2587 23 human human JJ 40436 2587 24 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 40436 2587 25 at at IN 40436 2587 26 Carthage Carthage NNP 40436 2587 27 , , , 40436 2587 28 & & CC 40436 2587 29 c. c. NNP 40436 2587 30 , , , 40436 2587 31 thus thus RB 40436 2587 32 lengthening lengthen VBG 40436 2587 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2587 34 answer answer NN 40436 2587 35 much much RB 40436 2587 36 beyond beyond IN 40436 2587 37 what what WP 40436 2587 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2587 39 had have VBD 40436 2587 40 been be VBN 40436 2587 41 before before RB 40436 2587 42 . . . 40436 2588 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2588 2 then then RB 40436 2588 3 continues continue VBZ 40436 2588 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2588 5 : : : 40436 2588 6 _ _ NNP 40436 2588 7 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 2588 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2588 9 are be VBP 40436 2588 10 right right JJ 40436 2588 11 , , , 40436 2588 12 and and CC 40436 2588 13 these these DT 40436 2588 14 matters matter NNS 40436 2588 15 have have VBP 40436 2588 16 escaped escape VBN 40436 2588 17 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2588 18 . . . 40436 2589 1 But but CC 40436 2589 2 if if IN 40436 2589 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2589 4 and and CC 40436 2589 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2589 6 go go VBP 40436 2589 7 on on RP 40436 2589 8 making make VBG 40436 2589 9 long long JJ 40436 2589 10 speeches speech NNS 40436 2589 11 each each DT 40436 2589 12 for for IN 40436 2589 13 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 2589 14 , , , 40436 2589 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2589 16 shall shall MD 40436 2589 17 never never RB 40436 2589 18 come come VB 40436 2589 19 to to IN 40436 2589 20 an an DT 40436 2589 21 agreement agreement NN 40436 2589 22 . . . 40436 2590 1 If if IN 40436 2590 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2590 3 are be VBP 40436 2590 4 to to TO 40436 2590 5 carry carry VB 40436 2590 6 on on RP 40436 2590 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2590 8 research research NN 40436 2590 9 together together RB 40436 2590 10 , , , 40436 2590 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2590 12 must must MD 40436 2590 13 do do VB 40436 2590 14 so so RB 40436 2590 15 by by IN 40436 2590 16 question question NN 40436 2590 17 and and CC 40436 2590 18 answer answer NN 40436 2590 19 . . . 40436 2591 1 Question question VB 40436 2591 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2591 3 , , , 40436 2591 4 if if IN 40436 2591 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2591 6 prefer:--if prefer:--if VBP 40436 2591 7 not not RB 40436 2591 8 , , , 40436 2591 9 answer answer VB 40436 2591 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2591 11 . . . 40436 2592 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2592 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNS 40436 2592 3 am be VBP 40436 2592 4 quite quite RB 40436 2592 5 ready ready JJ 40436 2592 6 , , , 40436 2592 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2592 8 , , , 40436 2592 9 to to TO 40436 2592 10 answer answer VB 40436 2592 11 whatever whatever WDT 40436 2592 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2592 13 ask ask VBP 40436 2592 14 . . . 40436 2593 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2593 2 Side side NN 40436 2593 3 - - HYPH 40436 2593 4 note note NN 40436 2593 5 : : : 40436 2593 6 Farther farther JJ 40436 2593 7 questions question NNS 40436 2593 8 by by IN 40436 2593 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2593 10 -- -- : 40436 2593 11 Things thing NNS 40436 2593 12 heavy heavy JJ 40436 2593 13 and and CC 40436 2593 14 light light JJ 40436 2593 15 , , , 40436 2593 16 just just RB 40436 2593 17 and and CC 40436 2593 18 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2593 19 , , , 40436 2593 20 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2593 21 and and CC 40436 2593 22 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 2593 23 , , , 40436 2593 24 & & CC 40436 2593 25 c. c. NNP 40436 2593 26 , , , 40436 2593 27 are be VBP 40436 2593 28 so so RB 40436 2593 29 , , , 40436 2593 30 and and CC 40436 2593 31 are be VBP 40436 2593 32 accounted account VBN 40436 2593 33 so so RB 40436 2593 34 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2593 35 . . . 40436 2594 1 Real real JJ 40436 2594 2 things thing NNS 40436 2594 3 are be VBP 40436 2594 4 always always RB 40436 2594 5 accounted account VBN 40436 2594 6 real real JJ 40436 2594 7 . . . 40436 2595 1 Whoever whoever WP 40436 2595 2 fails fail VBZ 40436 2595 3 in in IN 40436 2595 4 attaining attain VBG 40436 2595 5 the the DT 40436 2595 6 real real JJ 40436 2595 7 , , , 40436 2595 8 fails fail VBZ 40436 2595 9 in in IN 40436 2595 10 attaining attain VBG 40436 2595 11 the the DT 40436 2595 12 lawful lawful JJ 40436 2595 13 . . . 40436 2595 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2596 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2596 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 2596 3 , , , 40436 2596 4 then then RB 40436 2596 5 ! ! . 40436 2597 1 do do VBP 40436 2597 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2597 3 think think VB 40436 2597 4 that that IN 40436 2597 5 just just JJ 40436 2597 6 things thing NNS 40436 2597 7 are be VBP 40436 2597 8 just just RB 40436 2597 9 and and CC 40436 2597 10 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2597 11 things thing NNS 40436 2597 12 are be VBP 40436 2597 13 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2597 14 ? ? . 40436 2598 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2598 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNS 40436 2598 3 think think VBP 40436 2598 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2598 5 are be VBP 40436 2598 6 . . . 40436 2599 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2599 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 2599 3 not not RB 40436 2599 4 all all DT 40436 2599 5 men man NNS 40436 2599 6 in in IN 40436 2599 7 all all DT 40436 2599 8 communities community NNS 40436 2599 9 , , , 40436 2599 10 among among IN 40436 2599 11 the the DT 40436 2599 12 Persians Persians NNPS 40436 2599 13 as as RB 40436 2599 14 well well RB 40436 2599 15 as as IN 40436 2599 16 here here RB 40436 2599 17 , , , 40436 2599 18 now now RB 40436 2599 19 as as RB 40436 2599 20 well well RB 40436 2599 21 as as IN 40436 2599 22 formerly formerly RB 40436 2599 23 , , , 40436 2599 24 think think VB 40436 2599 25 so so RB 40436 2599 26 too too RB 40436 2599 27 ? ? . 40436 2600 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2600 2 Comp._--Unquestionably Comp._--Unquestionably NNP 40436 2600 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2600 4 do do VBP 40436 2600 5 . . . 40436 2601 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2601 2 Sokr._--Are Sokr._--Are NNP 40436 2601 3 not not RB 40436 2601 4 things thing NNS 40436 2601 5 which which WDT 40436 2601 6 weigh weigh VBP 40436 2601 7 more more RBR 40436 2601 8 , , , 40436 2601 9 accounted account VBD 40436 2601 10 heavier heavier RBR 40436 2601 11 ; ; : 40436 2601 12 and and CC 40436 2601 13 things thing NNS 40436 2601 14 which which WDT 40436 2601 15 weigh weigh VBP 40436 2601 16 less less RBR 40436 2601 17 , , , 40436 2601 18 accounted account VBD 40436 2601 19 lighter lighter RBR 40436 2601 20 , , , 40436 2601 21 here here RB 40436 2601 22 , , , 40436 2601 23 at at IN 40436 2601 24 Carthage carthage NN 40436 2601 25 , , , 40436 2601 26 and and CC 40436 2601 27 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2601 28 else else RB 40436 2601 29 ? ? . 40436 2602 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2602 2 21 21 CD 40436 2602 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2602 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2602 5 Comp._--Certainly Comp._--Certainly NNP 40436 2602 6 . . . 40436 2603 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2603 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 2603 3 seems seem VBZ 40436 2603 4 , , , 40436 2603 5 then then RB 40436 2603 6 , , , 40436 2603 7 that that IN 40436 2603 8 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2603 9 things thing NNS 40436 2603 10 are be VBP 40436 2603 11 accounted account VBN 40436 2603 12 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2603 13 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2603 14 , , , 40436 2603 15 and and CC 40436 2603 16 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 2603 17 things thing NNS 40436 2603 18 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 2603 19 ? ? . 40436 2604 1 not not RB 40436 2604 2 the the DT 40436 2604 3 reverse reverse NN 40436 2604 4 . . . 40436 2605 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2605 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2605 3 , , , 40436 2605 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2605 5 is be VBZ 40436 2605 6 so so RB 40436 2605 7 . . . 40436 2606 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2606 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 2606 3 , , , 40436 2606 4 speaking speak VBG 40436 2606 5 universally universally RB 40436 2606 6 , , , 40436 2606 7 existent existent NN 40436 2606 8 things thing NNS 40436 2606 9 or or CC 40436 2606 10 realities reality NNS 40436 2606 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2606 12 not not RB 40436 2606 13 non non JJ 40436 2606 14 - - JJ 40436 2606 15 existents existent NNS 40436 2606 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2606 17 are be VBP 40436 2606 18 accounted account VBN 40436 2606 19 existent existent NN 40436 2606 20 and and CC 40436 2606 21 real real JJ 40436 2606 22 , , , 40436 2606 23 among among IN 40436 2606 24 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2606 25 as as RB 40436 2606 26 well well RB 40436 2606 27 as as IN 40436 2606 28 among among IN 40436 2606 29 all all DT 40436 2606 30 other other JJ 40436 2606 31 men man NNS 40436 2606 32 ? ? . 40436 2607 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2607 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNS 40436 2607 3 think think VBP 40436 2607 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2607 5 are be VBP 40436 2607 6 . . . 40436 2608 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2608 2 Sokr._--Whoever Sokr._--Whoever NNP 40436 2608 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 2608 4 fails fail VBZ 40436 2608 5 in in IN 40436 2608 6 attaining attain VBG 40436 2608 7 the the DT 40436 2608 8 real real JJ 40436 2608 9 fails fail NNS 40436 2608 10 in in IN 40436 2608 11 attaining attain VBG 40436 2608 12 the the DT 40436 2608 13 lawful lawful JJ 40436 2608 14 . . . 40436 2609 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2609 2 22 22 CD 40436 2609 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2609 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2609 5 Comp._--As Comp._--As NNP 40436 2609 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2609 7 now now RB 40436 2609 8 put put VBP 40436 2609 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2609 10 , , , 40436 2609 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2609 12 , , , 40436 2609 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2609 14 would would MD 40436 2609 15 seem seem VB 40436 2609 16 that that IN 40436 2609 17 the the DT 40436 2609 18 same same JJ 40436 2609 19 things thing NNS 40436 2609 20 are be VBP 40436 2609 21 accounted account VBN 40436 2609 22 lawful lawful JJ 40436 2609 23 both both CC 40436 2609 24 by by IN 40436 2609 25 us -PRON- PRP 40436 2609 26 at at IN 40436 2609 27 all all DT 40436 2609 28 times time NNS 40436 2609 29 , , , 40436 2609 30 and and CC 40436 2609 31 by by IN 40436 2609 32 all all PDT 40436 2609 33 the the DT 40436 2609 34 rest rest NN 40436 2609 35 of of IN 40436 2609 36 mankind mankind NN 40436 2609 37 besides besides RB 40436 2609 38 . . . 40436 2610 1 But but CC 40436 2610 2 when when WRB 40436 2610 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2610 4 reflect reflect VBP 40436 2610 5 that that IN 40436 2610 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2610 7 are be VBP 40436 2610 8 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 2610 9 changing change VBG 40436 2610 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2610 11 laws law NNS 40436 2610 12 , , , 40436 2610 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2610 14 can can MD 40436 2610 15 not not RB 40436 2610 16 persuade persuade VB 40436 2610 17 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 2610 18 of of IN 40436 2610 19 what what WP 40436 2610 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2610 21 affirm affirm VBP 40436 2610 22 . . . 40436 2611 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2611 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2611 3 21 21 CD 40436 2611 4 : : : 40436 2611 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2611 6 , , , 40436 2611 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2611 8 , , , 40436 2611 9 316 316 CD 40436 2611 10 A. a. NN 40436 2612 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2612 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2612 3 : : : 40436 2612 4 Po Po NNP 40436 2612 5 / / SYM 40436 2612 6 teron teron NNP 40436 2612 7 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2612 8 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 2612 9 plei plei NNP 40436 2612 10 = = SYM 40436 2612 11 on on IN 40436 2612 12 e)/lkonta e)/lkonta NNP 40436 2612 13 baru baru NNP 40436 2612 14 / / SYM 40436 2612 15 tera tera NNP 40436 2612 16 nomi nomi NN 40436 2612 17 / / SYM 40436 2612 18 zetai zetai NNP 40436 2612 19 e)ntha e)ntha NNP 40436 2612 20 / / SYM 40436 2612 21 de de JJ 40436 2612 22 , , , 40436 2612 23 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 2612 24 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2612 25 e)/latton e)/latton NNP 40436 2612 26 , , , 40436 2612 27 koupho koupho NNP 40436 2612 28 / / SYM 40436 2612 29 tera tera NNP 40436 2612 30 , , , 40436 2612 31 ê)\ ê)\ CD 40436 2612 32 tou)nanti tou)nanti NNP 40436 2612 33 / / SYM 40436 2612 34 on on RB 40436 2612 35 ? ? . 40436 2612 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2613 1 The the DT 40436 2613 2 verb verb NN 40436 2613 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2613 4 Greek greek JJ 40436 2613 5 : : : 40436 2613 6 nomi nomi NN 40436 2613 7 / / SYM 40436 2613 8 zetai zetai NNP 40436 2613 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2613 10 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 2613 11 attention attention NN 40436 2613 12 here here RB 40436 2613 13 , , , 40436 2613 14 being be VBG 40436 2613 15 the the DT 40436 2613 16 same same JJ 40436 2613 17 word word NN 40436 2613 18 as as IN 40436 2613 19 has have VBZ 40436 2613 20 been be VBN 40436 2613 21 employed employ VBN 40436 2613 22 in in IN 40436 2613 23 regard regard NN 40436 2613 24 to to IN 40436 2613 25 law law NN 40436 2613 26 , , , 40436 2613 27 and and CC 40436 2613 28 derived derive VBN 40436 2613 29 from from IN 40436 2613 30 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2613 31 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2613 32 : : : 40436 2613 33 no no UH 40436 2613 34 / / SYM 40436 2613 35 mos mos NN 40436 2613 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2613 37 . . . 40436 2613 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2614 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2614 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2614 3 22 22 CD 40436 2614 4 : : : 40436 2614 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2614 6 , , , 40436 2614 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2614 8 , , , 40436 2614 9 316 316 CD 40436 2614 10 B. B. NNP 40436 2615 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2615 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2615 3 : : : 40436 2615 4 ou)kou ou)kou NN 40436 2615 5 = = SYM 40436 2615 6 n n NN 40436 2615 7 , , , 40436 2615 8 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 2615 9 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 2615 10 pa pa NNP 40436 2615 11 / / SYM 40436 2615 12 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 2615 13 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 2615 14 = = SYM 40436 2615 15 n n NN 40436 2615 16 , , , 40436 2615 17 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 2615 18 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 2615 19 nomi nomi NN 40436 2615 20 / / SYM 40436 2615 21 zetai zetai NNP 40436 2615 22 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 2615 23 , , , 40436 2615 24 ou ou NNP 40436 2615 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2615 26 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 2615 27 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 2615 28 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 2615 29 , , , 40436 2615 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2615 31 par par NNP 40436 2615 32 ' ' `` 40436 2615 33 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 2615 34 = = SYM 40436 2615 35 n n NNP 40436 2615 36 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2615 37 para\ para\ NNP 40436 2615 38 toi toi NNP 40436 2615 39 = = SYM 40436 2615 40 s s NNP 40436 2615 41 a)/llois a)/llois NNP 40436 2615 42 a(/pasin a(/pasin NNP 40436 2615 43 . . . 40436 2615 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2616 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2616 2 Comp Comp NNP 40436 2616 3 . . . 40436 2616 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2616 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2616 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2616 7 : : : 40436 2616 8 E)/moige E)/moige NNP 40436 2616 9 dokei=. dokei=. FW 40436 2616 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2617 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2617 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 2617 3 . . . 40436 2617 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2617 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2617 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2617 7 : : : 40436 2617 8 O(\s o(\s NN 40436 2617 9 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2617 10 a)/ra a)/ra VBP 40436 2617 11 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2617 12 o)/ntos o)/ntos NN 40436 2617 13 a(marta a(marta NNP 40436 2617 14 / / SYM 40436 2617 15 nê| nê| NNP 40436 2617 16 , , , 40436 2617 17 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2617 18 nomi nomi NN 40436 2617 19 / / SYM 40436 2617 20 mou mou NN 40436 2617 21 a(marta a(marta NNP 40436 2617 22 / / SYM 40436 2617 23 nei nei NNP 40436 2617 24 . . . 40436 2617 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2617 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2618 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2618 2 Side side NN 40436 2618 3 - - HYPH 40436 2618 4 note note NN 40436 2618 5 : : : 40436 2618 6 There there EX 40436 2618 7 are be VBP 40436 2618 8 laws law NNS 40436 2618 9 of of IN 40436 2618 10 health health NN 40436 2618 11 and and CC 40436 2618 12 of of IN 40436 2618 13 cure cure NN 40436 2618 14 , , , 40436 2618 15 composed compose VBN 40436 2618 16 by by IN 40436 2618 17 the the DT 40436 2618 18 few few JJ 40436 2618 19 physicians physician NNS 40436 2618 20 wise wise JJ 40436 2618 21 upon upon IN 40436 2618 22 those those DT 40436 2618 23 subjects subject NNS 40436 2618 24 , , , 40436 2618 25 and and CC 40436 2618 26 unanimously unanimously RB 40436 2618 27 declared declare VBD 40436 2618 28 by by IN 40436 2618 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2618 30 . . . 40436 2619 1 So so RB 40436 2619 2 also also RB 40436 2619 3 there there EX 40436 2619 4 are be VBP 40436 2619 5 laws law NNS 40436 2619 6 of of IN 40436 2619 7 farming farming NN 40436 2619 8 , , , 40436 2619 9 gardening gardening NN 40436 2619 10 , , , 40436 2619 11 cookery cookery NN 40436 2619 12 , , , 40436 2619 13 declared declare VBN 40436 2619 14 by by IN 40436 2619 15 the the DT 40436 2619 16 few few JJ 40436 2619 17 wise wise JJ 40436 2619 18 in in IN 40436 2619 19 those those DT 40436 2619 20 respective respective JJ 40436 2619 21 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 2619 22 . . . 40436 2620 1 In in IN 40436 2620 2 like like JJ 40436 2620 3 manner manner NN 40436 2620 4 , , , 40436 2620 5 the the DT 40436 2620 6 laws law NNS 40436 2620 7 of of IN 40436 2620 8 a a DT 40436 2620 9 city city NN 40436 2620 10 are be VBP 40436 2620 11 the the DT 40436 2620 12 judgments judgment NNS 40436 2620 13 declared declare VBN 40436 2620 14 by by IN 40436 2620 15 the the DT 40436 2620 16 few few JJ 40436 2620 17 wise wise JJ 40436 2620 18 men man NNS 40436 2620 19 who who WP 40436 2620 20 know know VBP 40436 2620 21 how how WRB 40436 2620 22 to to TO 40436 2620 23 rule rule VB 40436 2620 24 . . . 40436 2620 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2621 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2621 2 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 2621 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2621 4 do do VBP 40436 2621 5 not not RB 40436 2621 6 reflect reflect VB 40436 2621 7 that that IN 40436 2621 8 pieces piece NNS 40436 2621 9 on on IN 40436 2621 10 the the DT 40436 2621 11 draught draught NN 40436 2621 12 - - HYPH 40436 2621 13 board board NN 40436 2621 14 , , , 40436 2621 15 when when WRB 40436 2621 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2621 17 position position NN 40436 2621 18 is be VBZ 40436 2621 19 changed change VBN 40436 2621 20 , , , 40436 2621 21 still still RB 40436 2621 22 remain remain VBP 40436 2621 23 the the DT 40436 2621 24 same same JJ 40436 2621 25 . . . 40436 2622 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2622 2 know know VBP 40436 2622 3 medical medical JJ 40436 2622 4 treatises treatise NNS 40436 2622 5 : : : 40436 2622 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2622 7 know know VBP 40436 2622 8 that that IN 40436 2622 9 physicians physician NNS 40436 2622 10 are be VBP 40436 2622 11 the the DT 40436 2622 12 really really RB 40436 2622 13 knowing know VBG 40436 2622 14 about about IN 40436 2622 15 matters matter NNS 40436 2622 16 of of IN 40436 2622 17 health health NN 40436 2622 18 : : : 40436 2622 19 and and CC 40436 2622 20 that that IN 40436 2622 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2622 22 agree agree VBP 40436 2622 23 with with IN 40436 2622 24 each each DT 40436 2622 25 other other JJ 40436 2622 26 in in IN 40436 2622 27 writing write VBG 40436 2622 28 about about IN 40436 2622 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2622 30 . . . 40436 2623 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2623 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2623 3 -- -- : 40436 2623 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2623 5 know know VBP 40436 2623 6 that that DT 40436 2623 7 . . . 40436 2624 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2624 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 2624 3 case case NN 40436 2624 4 is be VBZ 40436 2624 5 the the DT 40436 2624 6 same same JJ 40436 2624 7 whether whether IN 40436 2624 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2624 9 be be VBP 40436 2624 10 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 2624 11 or or CC 40436 2624 12 not not RB 40436 2624 13 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 2624 14 : : : 40436 2624 15 Those those DT 40436 2624 16 who who WP 40436 2624 17 know know VBP 40436 2624 18 , , , 40436 2624 19 must must MD 40436 2624 20 of of IN 40436 2624 21 necessity necessity NN 40436 2624 22 hold hold VB 40436 2624 23 the the DT 40436 2624 24 same same JJ 40436 2624 25 opinion opinion NN 40436 2624 26 with with IN 40436 2624 27 each each DT 40436 2624 28 other other JJ 40436 2624 29 , , , 40436 2624 30 on on IN 40436 2624 31 matters matter NNS 40436 2624 32 which which WDT 40436 2624 33 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2624 34 know know VBP 40436 2624 35 : : : 40436 2624 36 always always RB 40436 2624 37 and and CC 40436 2624 38 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2624 39 . . . 40436 2625 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2625 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2625 3 -- -- : 40436 2625 4 always always RB 40436 2625 5 and and CC 40436 2625 6 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2625 7 . . . 40436 2626 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2626 2 Sokr._--Physicians Sokr._--Physicians NNP 40436 2626 3 write write VB 40436 2626 4 respecting respect VBG 40436 2626 5 matters matter NNS 40436 2626 6 of of IN 40436 2626 7 health health NN 40436 2626 8 what what WP 40436 2626 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2626 10 account account VBP 40436 2626 11 to to TO 40436 2626 12 be be VB 40436 2626 13 true true JJ 40436 2626 14 , , , 40436 2626 15 and and CC 40436 2626 16 these these DT 40436 2626 17 writings writing NNS 40436 2626 18 of of IN 40436 2626 19 theirs -PRON- PRP 40436 2626 20 are be VBP 40436 2626 21 the the DT 40436 2626 22 medical medical JJ 40436 2626 23 laws law NNS 40436 2626 24 ? ? . 40436 2627 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2627 2 Comp._--Certainly Comp._--Certainly NNP 40436 2627 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2627 4 are be VBP 40436 2627 5 . . . 40436 2628 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2628 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 2628 3 like like UH 40436 2628 4 is be VBZ 40436 2628 5 true true JJ 40436 2628 6 respecting respect VBG 40436 2628 7 the the DT 40436 2628 8 laws law NNS 40436 2628 9 of of IN 40436 2628 10 farming farming NN 40436 2628 11 -- -- : 40436 2628 12 the the DT 40436 2628 13 laws law NNS 40436 2628 14 of of IN 40436 2628 15 gardening gardening NN 40436 2628 16 -- -- : 40436 2628 17 the the DT 40436 2628 18 laws law NNS 40436 2628 19 of of IN 40436 2628 20 cookery cookery NN 40436 2628 21 . . . 40436 2629 1 All all PDT 40436 2629 2 these these DT 40436 2629 3 are be VBP 40436 2629 4 the the DT 40436 2629 5 writings writing NNS 40436 2629 6 of of IN 40436 2629 7 persons person NNS 40436 2629 8 , , , 40436 2629 9 knowing know VBG 40436 2629 10 in in IN 40436 2629 11 each each DT 40436 2629 12 of of IN 40436 2629 13 the the DT 40436 2629 14 respective respective JJ 40436 2629 15 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 2629 16 ? ? . 40436 2630 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2630 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2630 3 . . . 40436 2631 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2631 2 23 23 CD 40436 2631 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2631 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2631 5 Sokr._--In Sokr._--In NNP 40436 2631 6 like like IN 40436 2631 7 manner manner NN 40436 2631 8 , , , 40436 2631 9 what what WP 40436 2631 10 are be VBP 40436 2631 11 the the DT 40436 2631 12 laws law NNS 40436 2631 13 respecting respect VBG 40436 2631 14 the the DT 40436 2631 15 government government NN 40436 2631 16 of of IN 40436 2631 17 a a DT 40436 2631 18 city city NN 40436 2631 19 ? ? . 40436 2632 1 Are be VBP 40436 2632 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2632 3 not not RB 40436 2632 4 the the DT 40436 2632 5 writings writing NNS 40436 2632 6 of of IN 40436 2632 7 those those DT 40436 2632 8 who who WP 40436 2632 9 know know VBP 40436 2632 10 how how WRB 40436 2632 11 to to TO 40436 2632 12 govern govern VB 40436 2632 13 -- -- : 40436 2632 14 kings king NNS 40436 2632 15 , , , 40436 2632 16 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 2632 17 , , , 40436 2632 18 and and CC 40436 2632 19 men man NNS 40436 2632 20 of of IN 40436 2632 21 superior superior JJ 40436 2632 22 excellence excellence NN 40436 2632 23 ? ? . 40436 2633 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2633 2 Comp._--Truly Comp._--Truly NNP 40436 2633 3 so so RB 40436 2633 4 . . . 40436 2634 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2634 2 Sokr._--Knowing Sokr._--Knowing NNP 40436 2634 3 men man NNS 40436 2634 4 like like IN 40436 2634 5 these these DT 40436 2634 6 will will MD 40436 2634 7 not not RB 40436 2634 8 write write VB 40436 2634 9 differently differently RB 40436 2634 10 from from IN 40436 2634 11 each each DT 40436 2634 12 other other JJ 40436 2634 13 about about IN 40436 2634 14 the the DT 40436 2634 15 same same JJ 40436 2634 16 things thing NNS 40436 2634 17 , , , 40436 2634 18 nor nor CC 40436 2634 19 change change VB 40436 2634 20 what what WP 40436 2634 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2634 22 have have VBP 40436 2634 23 once once RB 40436 2634 24 written write VBN 40436 2634 25 . . . 40436 2635 1 If if IN 40436 2635 2 , , , 40436 2635 3 then then RB 40436 2635 4 , , , 40436 2635 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2635 6 see see VBP 40436 2635 7 some some DT 40436 2635 8 doing do VBG 40436 2635 9 this this DT 40436 2635 10 , , , 40436 2635 11 are be VBP 40436 2635 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2635 13 to to TO 40436 2635 14 declare declare VB 40436 2635 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2635 16 knowing know VBG 40436 2635 17 or or CC 40436 2635 18 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2635 19 ? ? . 40436 2636 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2636 2 Comp._--Ignorant Comp._--Ignorant NNP 40436 2636 3 -- -- : 40436 2636 4 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 2636 5 . . . 40436 2637 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2637 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2637 3 23 23 CD 40436 2637 4 : : : 40436 2637 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2637 6 , , , 40436 2637 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2637 8 , , , 40436 2637 9 316 316 CD 40436 2637 10 D D NNP 40436 2637 11 - - HYPH 40436 2637 12 E. e. NN 40436 2637 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2637 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2637 15 Side side NN 40436 2637 16 - - HYPH 40436 2637 17 note note NN 40436 2637 18 : : : 40436 2637 19 That that IN 40436 2637 20 which which WDT 40436 2637 21 is be VBZ 40436 2637 22 right right JJ 40436 2637 23 is be VBZ 40436 2637 24 the the DT 40436 2637 25 regal regal JJ 40436 2637 26 law law NN 40436 2637 27 , , , 40436 2637 28 the the DT 40436 2637 29 only only JJ 40436 2637 30 true true JJ 40436 2637 31 and and CC 40436 2637 32 real real JJ 40436 2637 33 law law NN 40436 2637 34 -- -- : 40436 2637 35 that that IN 40436 2637 36 which which WDT 40436 2637 37 is be VBZ 40436 2637 38 not not RB 40436 2637 39 right right JJ 40436 2637 40 , , , 40436 2637 41 is be VBZ 40436 2637 42 not not RB 40436 2637 43 law law NN 40436 2637 44 , , , 40436 2637 45 but but CC 40436 2637 46 only only RB 40436 2637 47 seems seem VBZ 40436 2637 48 to to TO 40436 2637 49 be be VB 40436 2637 50 law law NN 40436 2637 51 in in IN 40436 2637 52 the the DT 40436 2637 53 eyes eye NNS 40436 2637 54 of of IN 40436 2637 55 the the DT 40436 2637 56 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2637 57 . . . 40436 2637 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2638 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2638 2 Sokr._--Whatever Sokr._--Whatever NNP 40436 2638 3 is be VBZ 40436 2638 4 right right JJ 40436 2638 5 , , , 40436 2638 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 2638 7 , , , 40436 2638 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2638 9 may may MD 40436 2638 10 pronounce pronounce VB 40436 2638 11 to to TO 40436 2638 12 be be VB 40436 2638 13 lawful lawful JJ 40436 2638 14 ; ; : 40436 2638 15 in in IN 40436 2638 16 medicine medicine NN 40436 2638 17 , , , 40436 2638 18 gardening gardening NN 40436 2638 19 , , , 40436 2638 20 or or CC 40436 2638 21 cookery cookery NN 40436 2638 22 : : : 40436 2638 23 whatever whatever WDT 40436 2638 24 is be VBZ 40436 2638 25 not not RB 40436 2638 26 right right JJ 40436 2638 27 , , , 40436 2638 28 not not RB 40436 2638 29 to to TO 40436 2638 30 be be VB 40436 2638 31 lawful lawful JJ 40436 2638 32 but but CC 40436 2638 33 lawless lawless JJ 40436 2638 34 . . . 40436 2639 1 And and CC 40436 2639 2 the the DT 40436 2639 3 like like JJ 40436 2639 4 in in IN 40436 2639 5 treatises treatise NNS 40436 2639 6 respecting respect VBG 40436 2639 7 just just RB 40436 2639 8 and and CC 40436 2639 9 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2639 10 , , , 40436 2639 11 prescribing prescribe VBG 40436 2639 12 how how WRB 40436 2639 13 the the DT 40436 2639 14 city city NN 40436 2639 15 is be VBZ 40436 2639 16 to to TO 40436 2639 17 be be VB 40436 2639 18 administered administer VBN 40436 2639 19 : : : 40436 2639 20 That that IN 40436 2639 21 which which WDT 40436 2639 22 is be VBZ 40436 2639 23 right right JJ 40436 2639 24 , , , 40436 2639 25 is be VBZ 40436 2639 26 the the DT 40436 2639 27 regal regal JJ 40436 2639 28 law law NN 40436 2639 29 -- -- : 40436 2639 30 that that IN 40436 2639 31 which which WDT 40436 2639 32 is be VBZ 40436 2639 33 not not RB 40436 2639 34 right right JJ 40436 2639 35 , , , 40436 2639 36 is be VBZ 40436 2639 37 not not RB 40436 2639 38 so so RB 40436 2639 39 , , , 40436 2639 40 but but CC 40436 2639 41 only only RB 40436 2639 42 seems seem VBZ 40436 2639 43 to to TO 40436 2639 44 be be VB 40436 2639 45 law law NN 40436 2639 46 in in IN 40436 2639 47 the the DT 40436 2639 48 eyes eye NNS 40436 2639 49 of of IN 40436 2639 50 the the DT 40436 2639 51 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2639 52 -- -- : 40436 2639 53 being be VBG 40436 2639 54 in in IN 40436 2639 55 truth truth NN 40436 2639 56 lawless lawless NN 40436 2639 57 . . . 40436 2640 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2640 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2640 3 . . . 40436 2641 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2641 2 Sokr._--We Sokr._--We NNP 40436 2641 3 were be VBD 40436 2641 4 correct correct JJ 40436 2641 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 2641 6 in in IN 40436 2641 7 declaring declare VBG 40436 2641 8 Law Law NNP 40436 2641 9 to to TO 40436 2641 10 be be VB 40436 2641 11 the the DT 40436 2641 12 finding finding NN 40436 2641 13 out out IN 40436 2641 14 of of IN 40436 2641 15 reality reality NN 40436 2641 16 . . . 40436 2642 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2642 2 Comp._--It Comp._--It NNP 40436 2642 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 2642 4 so so RB 40436 2642 5 . . . 40436 2643 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2643 2 24 24 CD 40436 2643 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2643 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2643 5 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 2643 6 is be VBZ 40436 2643 7 the the DT 40436 2643 8 skilful skilful JJ 40436 2643 9 husbandman husbandman NN 40436 2643 10 who who WP 40436 2643 11 gives give VBZ 40436 2643 12 right right JJ 40436 2643 13 laws law NNS 40436 2643 14 on on IN 40436 2643 15 the the DT 40436 2643 16 sowing sowing NN 40436 2643 17 of of IN 40436 2643 18 land land NN 40436 2643 19 : : : 40436 2643 20 the the DT 40436 2643 21 skilful skilful JJ 40436 2643 22 musician musician NN 40436 2643 23 on on IN 40436 2643 24 the the DT 40436 2643 25 touching touching NN 40436 2643 26 of of IN 40436 2643 27 instruments instrument NNS 40436 2643 28 : : : 40436 2643 29 the the DT 40436 2643 30 skilful skilful JJ 40436 2643 31 trainer trainer NN 40436 2643 32 , , , 40436 2643 33 respecting respect VBG 40436 2643 34 exercise exercise NN 40436 2643 35 of of IN 40436 2643 36 the the DT 40436 2643 37 body body NN 40436 2643 38 : : : 40436 2643 39 the the DT 40436 2643 40 skilful skilful JJ 40436 2643 41 king king NN 40436 2643 42 or or CC 40436 2643 43 governor governor NN 40436 2643 44 , , , 40436 2643 45 respecting respect VBG 40436 2643 46 the the DT 40436 2643 47 minds mind NNS 40436 2643 48 of of IN 40436 2643 49 the the DT 40436 2643 50 citizens citizen NNS 40436 2643 51 . . . 40436 2644 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2644 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2644 3 -- -- : 40436 2644 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2644 5 is be VBZ 40436 2644 6 . . . 40436 2645 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2645 2 25 25 CD 40436 2645 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2645 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2645 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2645 6 24 24 CD 40436 2645 7 : : : 40436 2645 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2645 9 , , , 40436 2645 10 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2645 11 , , , 40436 2645 12 317 317 CD 40436 2645 13 C. C. NNP 40436 2645 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2645 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2645 16 : : : 40436 2645 17 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2645 18 me\n me\n NNP 40436 2645 19 o)rtho\n o)rtho\n NNP 40436 2645 20 no no NNP 40436 2645 21 / / SYM 40436 2645 22 mos mos NNP 40436 2645 23 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 2645 24 basiliko basiliko NNP 40436 2645 25 / / SYM 40436 2645 26 s s NNP 40436 2645 27 ; ; : 40436 2645 28 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2645 29 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2645 30 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 2645 31 o)rtho o)rtho NNS 40436 2645 32 / / SYM 40436 2645 33 n n CC 40436 2645 34 ou)/ ou)/ RB 40436 2645 35 , , , 40436 2645 36 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 2645 37 dokei= dokei= NN 40436 2645 38 no no DT 40436 2645 39 / / SYM 40436 2645 40 mos mos NNP 40436 2645 41 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 2645 42 toi toi NNP 40436 2645 43 = = SYM 40436 2645 44 s s NNP 40436 2645 45 ei)do ei)do NNP 40436 2645 46 / / SYM 40436 2645 47 sin sin NN 40436 2645 48 ; ; : 40436 2645 49 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 2645 50 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 2645 51 a)/nomon a)/nomon NNP 40436 2645 52 . . . 40436 2645 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2645 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2646 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2646 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2646 3 25 25 CD 40436 2646 4 : : : 40436 2646 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2646 6 , , , 40436 2646 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2646 8 , , , 40436 2646 9 318 318 CD 40436 2646 10 A. a. NN 40436 2646 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2647 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2647 2 Side side NN 40436 2647 3 - - HYPH 40436 2647 4 note note NN 40436 2647 5 : : : 40436 2647 6 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2647 7 , , , 40436 2647 8 King King NNP 40436 2647 9 of of IN 40436 2647 10 Krete Krete NNP 40436 2647 11 -- -- : 40436 2647 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2647 13 laws law NNS 40436 2647 14 were be VBD 40436 2647 15 divine divine JJ 40436 2647 16 and and CC 40436 2647 17 excellent excellent JJ 40436 2647 18 , , , 40436 2647 19 and and CC 40436 2647 20 have have VBP 40436 2647 21 remained remain VBN 40436 2647 22 unchanged unchanged JJ 40436 2647 23 from from IN 40436 2647 24 time time NN 40436 2647 25 immemorial immemorial JJ 40436 2647 26 . . . 40436 2647 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2648 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2648 2 Sokr._--Can Sokr._--Can NNP 40436 2648 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2648 4 tell tell VBP 40436 2648 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2648 6 which which WDT 40436 2648 7 of of IN 40436 2648 8 the the DT 40436 2648 9 ancient ancient JJ 40436 2648 10 kings king NNS 40436 2648 11 has have VBZ 40436 2648 12 the the DT 40436 2648 13 glory glory NN 40436 2648 14 of of IN 40436 2648 15 having have VBG 40436 2648 16 been be VBN 40436 2648 17 a a DT 40436 2648 18 good good JJ 40436 2648 19 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2648 20 , , , 40436 2648 21 so so IN 40436 2648 22 that that IN 40436 2648 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2648 24 laws law NNS 40436 2648 25 still still RB 40436 2648 26 remain remain VBP 40436 2648 27 in in IN 40436 2648 28 force force NN 40436 2648 29 as as IN 40436 2648 30 divine divine JJ 40436 2648 31 institutions institution NNS 40436 2648 32 ? ? . 40436 2649 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2649 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNS 40436 2649 3 can can MD 40436 2649 4 not not RB 40436 2649 5 tell tell VB 40436 2649 6 . . . 40436 2650 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2650 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 2650 3 can can MD 40436 2650 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2650 5 not not RB 40436 2650 6 say say VB 40436 2650 7 which which WDT 40436 2650 8 among among IN 40436 2650 9 the the DT 40436 2650 10 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 2650 11 have have VBP 40436 2650 12 the the DT 40436 2650 13 most most RBS 40436 2650 14 ancient ancient JJ 40436 2650 15 laws law NNS 40436 2650 16 ? ? . 40436 2651 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2651 2 Comp._--Perhaps Comp._--Perhaps NNP 40436 2651 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2651 4 mean mean VBP 40436 2651 5 the the DT 40436 2651 6 Lacedæmonians Lacedæmonians NNPS 40436 2651 7 and and CC 40436 2651 8 Lykurgus Lykurgus NNP 40436 2651 9 ? ? . 40436 2652 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2652 2 Sokr._--Why Sokr._--Why NNP 40436 2652 3 , , , 40436 2652 4 the the DT 40436 2652 5 Lacedæmonian lacedæmonian JJ 40436 2652 6 laws law NNS 40436 2652 7 are be VBP 40436 2652 8 hardly hardly RB 40436 2652 9 more more JJR 40436 2652 10 than than IN 40436 2652 11 three three CD 40436 2652 12 hundred hundred CD 40436 2652 13 years year NNS 40436 2652 14 old old JJ 40436 2652 15 : : : 40436 2652 16 besides besides RB 40436 2652 17 , , , 40436 2652 18 whence whence NN 40436 2652 19 is be VBZ 40436 2652 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2652 21 that that WDT 40436 2652 22 the the DT 40436 2652 23 best good JJS 40436 2652 24 of of IN 40436 2652 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2652 26 come come VBP 40436 2652 27 ? ? . 40436 2653 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2653 2 Comp._--From Comp._--From NNP 40436 2653 3 Krete Krete NNP 40436 2653 4 , , , 40436 2653 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2653 6 say say VBP 40436 2653 7 . . . 40436 2654 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2654 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 2654 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2654 4 is be VBZ 40436 2654 5 the the DT 40436 2654 6 Kretans Kretans NNPS 40436 2654 7 who who WP 40436 2654 8 have have VBP 40436 2654 9 the the DT 40436 2654 10 most most RBS 40436 2654 11 ancient ancient JJ 40436 2654 12 laws law NNS 40436 2654 13 in in IN 40436 2654 14 Greece Greece NNP 40436 2654 15 ? ? . 40436 2655 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2655 2 Comp._--Yes Comp._--Yes NNP 40436 2655 3 . . . 40436 2656 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2656 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 2656 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2656 4 know know VBP 40436 2656 5 those those DT 40436 2656 6 good good JJ 40436 2656 7 kings king NNS 40436 2656 8 of of IN 40436 2656 9 Krete Krete NNP 40436 2656 10 , , , 40436 2656 11 from from IN 40436 2656 12 whom whom WP 40436 2656 13 these these DT 40436 2656 14 laws law NNS 40436 2656 15 are be VBP 40436 2656 16 derived derive VBN 40436 2656 17 -- -- : 40436 2656 18 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2656 19 and and CC 40436 2656 20 Rhadamanthus Rhadamanthus NNP 40436 2656 21 , , , 40436 2656 22 sons son NNS 40436 2656 23 of of IN 40436 2656 24 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 2656 25 and and CC 40436 2656 26 Europa Europa NNP 40436 2656 27 ? ? . 40436 2657 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2657 2 Comp._--Rhadamanthus Comp._--Rhadamanthus NNP 40436 2657 3 certainly certainly RB 40436 2657 4 is be VBZ 40436 2657 5 said say VBN 40436 2657 6 to to TO 40436 2657 7 have have VB 40436 2657 8 been be VBN 40436 2657 9 a a DT 40436 2657 10 just just JJ 40436 2657 11 man man NN 40436 2657 12 , , , 40436 2657 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2657 14 ; ; : 40436 2657 15 but but CC 40436 2657 16 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2657 17 quite quite PDT 40436 2657 18 the the DT 40436 2657 19 reverse reverse JJ 40436 2657 20 -- -- : 40436 2657 21 savage savage NN 40436 2657 22 , , , 40436 2657 23 ill ill RB 40436 2657 24 - - HYPH 40436 2657 25 tempered tempered JJ 40436 2657 26 , , , 40436 2657 27 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2657 28 . . . 40436 2658 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2658 2 Sokr._--What sokr._--what WP 40436 2658 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2658 4 affirm affirm VBP 40436 2658 5 , , , 40436 2658 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2658 7 friend friend NN 40436 2658 8 , , , 40436 2658 9 is be VBZ 40436 2658 10 a a DT 40436 2658 11 fiction fiction NN 40436 2658 12 of of IN 40436 2658 13 the the DT 40436 2658 14 Attic attic JJ 40436 2658 15 tragedians tragedian NNS 40436 2658 16 . . . 40436 2659 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2659 2 is be VBZ 40436 2659 3 not not RB 40436 2659 4 stated state VBN 40436 2659 5 either either CC 40436 2659 6 by by IN 40436 2659 7 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2659 8 or or CC 40436 2659 9 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 40436 2659 10 , , , 40436 2659 11 who who WP 40436 2659 12 are be VBP 40436 2659 13 far far RB 40436 2659 14 more more RBR 40436 2659 15 worthy worthy JJ 40436 2659 16 of of IN 40436 2659 17 credit credit NN 40436 2659 18 than than IN 40436 2659 19 all all PDT 40436 2659 20 the the DT 40436 2659 21 tragedians tragedians NNPS 40436 2659 22 put put VBP 40436 2659 23 together together RB 40436 2659 24 . . . 40436 2660 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2660 2 Comp._--What Comp._--What NNP 40436 2660 3 is be VBZ 40436 2660 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2660 5 that that WDT 40436 2660 6 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2660 7 and and CC 40436 2660 8 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 40436 2660 9 say say VBP 40436 2660 10 about about IN 40436 2660 11 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2660 12 ? ? . 40436 2661 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2661 2 26 26 CD 40436 2661 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2661 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2661 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2661 6 26 26 CD 40436 2661 7 : : : 40436 2661 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2661 9 , , , 40436 2661 10 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2661 11 , , , 40436 2661 12 318 318 CD 40436 2661 13 E. E. NNP 40436 2661 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2661 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2661 16 Side side NN 40436 2661 17 - - HYPH 40436 2661 18 note note NN 40436 2661 19 : : : 40436 2661 20 Question question NN 40436 2661 21 about about IN 40436 2661 22 the the DT 40436 2661 23 character character NN 40436 2661 24 of of IN 40436 2661 25 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2661 26 -- -- : 40436 2661 27 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2661 28 and and CC 40436 2661 29 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 40436 2661 30 declare declare VBP 40436 2661 31 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2661 32 to to TO 40436 2661 33 have have VB 40436 2661 34 been be VBN 40436 2661 35 admirable admirable JJ 40436 2661 36 , , , 40436 2661 37 the the DT 40436 2661 38 Attic attic JJ 40436 2661 39 tragedians tragedians NNPS 40436 2661 40 defame defame VBP 40436 2661 41 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2661 42 as as IN 40436 2661 43 a a DT 40436 2661 44 tyrant tyrant NN 40436 2661 45 , , , 40436 2661 46 because because IN 40436 2661 47 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2661 48 was be VBD 40436 2661 49 an an DT 40436 2661 50 enemy enemy NN 40436 2661 51 of of IN 40436 2661 52 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2661 53 . . . 40436 2661 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2662 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2662 2 replies reply VBZ 40436 2662 3 by by IN 40436 2662 4 citing cite VBG 40436 2662 5 , , , 40436 2662 6 and and CC 40436 2662 7 commenting comment VBG 40436 2662 8 upon upon IN 40436 2662 9 , , , 40436 2662 10 the the DT 40436 2662 11 statements statement NNS 40436 2662 12 of of IN 40436 2662 13 Homer Homer NNP 40436 2662 14 and and CC 40436 2662 15 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 40436 2662 16 respecting respect VBG 40436 2662 17 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2662 18 , , , 40436 2662 19 as as IN 40436 2662 20 the the DT 40436 2662 21 cherished cherish VBN 40436 2662 22 son son NN 40436 2662 23 , , , 40436 2662 24 companion companion NN 40436 2662 25 , , , 40436 2662 26 and and CC 40436 2662 27 pupil pupil NN 40436 2662 28 , , , 40436 2662 29 of of IN 40436 2662 30 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 2662 31 ; ; : 40436 2662 32 who who WP 40436 2662 33 bestowed bestow VBD 40436 2662 34 upon upon IN 40436 2662 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2662 36 an an DT 40436 2662 37 admirable admirable JJ 40436 2662 38 training training NN 40436 2662 39 , , , 40436 2662 40 teaching teach VBG 40436 2662 41 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2662 42 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 2662 43 and and CC 40436 2662 44 justice justice NN 40436 2662 45 , , , 40436 2662 46 and and CC 40436 2662 47 thus thus RB 40436 2662 48 rendering render VBG 40436 2662 49 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2662 50 consummate consummate VB 40436 2662 51 as as IN 40436 2662 52 a a DT 40436 2662 53 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2662 54 and and CC 40436 2662 55 ruler ruler NN 40436 2662 56 of of IN 40436 2662 57 men man NNS 40436 2662 58 . . . 40436 2663 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2663 2 was be VBD 40436 2663 3 through through IN 40436 2663 4 these these DT 40436 2663 5 laws law NNS 40436 2663 6 , , , 40436 2663 7 divine divine JJ 40436 2663 8 as as IN 40436 2663 9 emanating emanate VBG 40436 2663 10 from from IN 40436 2663 11 the the DT 40436 2663 12 teaching teaching NN 40436 2663 13 of of IN 40436 2663 14 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 2663 15 , , , 40436 2663 16 that that IN 40436 2663 17 Krete Krete NNP 40436 2663 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2663 19 and and CC 40436 2663 20 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 2663 21 as as IN 40436 2663 22 the the DT 40436 2663 23 imitator imitator NN 40436 2663 24 of of IN 40436 2663 25 Krete Krete NNP 40436 2663 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2663 27 had have VBD 40436 2663 28 been be VBN 40436 2663 29 for for IN 40436 2663 30 so so RB 40436 2663 31 long long RB 40436 2663 32 a a DT 40436 2663 33 period period NN 40436 2663 34 happy happy JJ 40436 2663 35 and and CC 40436 2663 36 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 2663 37 . . . 40436 2664 1 As as IN 40436 2664 2 ruler ruler NN 40436 2664 3 of of IN 40436 2664 4 Krete Krete NNP 40436 2664 5 , , , 40436 2664 6 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2664 7 had have VBD 40436 2664 8 made make VBN 40436 2664 9 war war NN 40436 2664 10 upon upon IN 40436 2664 11 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2664 12 , , , 40436 2664 13 and and CC 40436 2664 14 compelled compel VBD 40436 2664 15 the the DT 40436 2664 16 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 2664 17 to to TO 40436 2664 18 pay pay VB 40436 2664 19 tribute tribute NN 40436 2664 20 . . . 40436 2665 1 Hence hence RB 40436 2665 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2665 3 had have VBD 40436 2665 4 become become VBN 40436 2665 5 odious odious JJ 40436 2665 6 to to IN 40436 2665 7 the the DT 40436 2665 8 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 2665 9 , , , 40436 2665 10 and and CC 40436 2665 11 especially especially RB 40436 2665 12 odious odious JJ 40436 2665 13 to to IN 40436 2665 14 the the DT 40436 2665 15 tragic tragic JJ 40436 2665 16 poets poet NNS 40436 2665 17 who who WP 40436 2665 18 were be VBD 40436 2665 19 the the DT 40436 2665 20 great great JJ 40436 2665 21 teachers teacher NNS 40436 2665 22 and and CC 40436 2665 23 charmers charmer NNS 40436 2665 24 of of IN 40436 2665 25 the the DT 40436 2665 26 crowd crowd NN 40436 2665 27 . . . 40436 2666 1 These these DT 40436 2666 2 poets poet NNS 40436 2666 3 , , , 40436 2666 4 whom whom WP 40436 2666 5 every every DT 40436 2666 6 one one NN 40436 2666 7 ought ought MD 40436 2666 8 to to TO 40436 2666 9 be be VB 40436 2666 10 cautious cautious JJ 40436 2666 11 of of IN 40436 2666 12 offending offending NN 40436 2666 13 , , , 40436 2666 14 had have VBD 40436 2666 15 calumniated calumniate VBN 40436 2666 16 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2666 17 as as IN 40436 2666 18 the the DT 40436 2666 19 old old JJ 40436 2666 20 enemy enemy NN 40436 2666 21 of of IN 40436 2666 22 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2666 23 . . . 40436 2667 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2667 2 27 27 CD 40436 2667 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2667 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2667 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2667 6 27 27 CD 40436 2667 7 : : : 40436 2667 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2667 9 , , , 40436 2667 10 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2667 11 , , , 40436 2667 12 319 319 CD 40436 2667 13 - - SYM 40436 2667 14 320 320 CD 40436 2667 15 . . . 40436 2667 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2668 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2668 2 Side side NN 40436 2668 3 - - HYPH 40436 2668 4 note note NN 40436 2668 5 : : : 40436 2668 6 That that IN 40436 2668 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2668 8 was be VBD 40436 2668 9 really really RB 40436 2668 10 admirable admirable JJ 40436 2668 11 -- -- : 40436 2668 12 and and CC 40436 2668 13 that that IN 40436 2668 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2668 15 has have VBZ 40436 2668 16 found find VBN 40436 2668 17 out out RP 40436 2668 18 truth truth NN 40436 2668 19 and and CC 40436 2668 20 reality reality NN 40436 2668 21 respecting respect VBG 40436 2668 22 the the DT 40436 2668 23 administration administration NN 40436 2668 24 of of IN 40436 2668 25 the the DT 40436 2668 26 city city NN 40436 2668 27 -- -- : 40436 2668 28 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2668 29 may may MD 40436 2668 30 be be VB 40436 2668 31 sure sure JJ 40436 2668 32 from from IN 40436 2668 33 the the DT 40436 2668 34 fact fact NN 40436 2668 35 that that IN 40436 2668 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2668 37 laws law NNS 40436 2668 38 have have VBP 40436 2668 39 remained remain VBN 40436 2668 40 so so RB 40436 2668 41 long long RB 40436 2668 42 unaltered unaltered JJ 40436 2668 43 . . . 40436 2668 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2669 1 But but CC 40436 2669 2 that that IN 40436 2669 3 these these DT 40436 2669 4 tales tale NNS 40436 2669 5 are be VBP 40436 2669 6 mere mere JJ 40436 2669 7 calumny calumny NN 40436 2669 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2669 9 continues continue VBZ 40436 2669 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2669 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2669 12 , , , 40436 2669 13 and and CC 40436 2669 14 that that IN 40436 2669 15 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2669 16 was be VBD 40436 2669 17 truly truly RB 40436 2669 18 a a DT 40436 2669 19 good good JJ 40436 2669 20 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2669 21 , , , 40436 2669 22 and and CC 40436 2669 23 a a DT 40436 2669 24 good good JJ 40436 2669 25 shepherd shepherd NN 40436 2669 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2669 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2669 28 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2669 29 : : : 40436 2669 30 nomeu\s nomeu\s ADD 40436 2669 31 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 2669 32 / / SYM 40436 2669 33 s s NNP 40436 2669 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2669 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2669 36 of of IN 40436 2669 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2669 38 people people NNS 40436 2669 39 -- -- : 40436 2669 40 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2669 41 have have VBP 40436 2669 42 proof proof NN 40436 2669 43 through through IN 40436 2669 44 the the DT 40436 2669 45 fact fact NN 40436 2669 46 , , , 40436 2669 47 that that IN 40436 2669 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2669 49 laws law NNS 40436 2669 50 still still RB 40436 2669 51 remain remain VBP 40436 2669 52 unchanged unchanged JJ 40436 2669 53 : : : 40436 2669 54 which which WDT 40436 2669 55 shows show VBZ 40436 2669 56 that that IN 40436 2669 57 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2669 58 has have VBZ 40436 2669 59 really really RB 40436 2669 60 found find VBN 40436 2669 61 out out RP 40436 2669 62 truth truth NN 40436 2669 63 and and CC 40436 2669 64 reality reality NN 40436 2669 65 respecting respect VBG 40436 2669 66 the the DT 40436 2669 67 administration administration NN 40436 2669 68 of of IN 40436 2669 69 a a DT 40436 2669 70 city city NN 40436 2669 71 . . . 40436 2670 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2670 2 28 28 CD 40436 2670 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2670 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2670 5 Comp._--Your Comp._--Your NNP 40436 2670 6 view view NN 40436 2670 7 seems seem VBZ 40436 2670 8 plausible plausible JJ 40436 2670 9 , , , 40436 2670 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2670 11 . . . 40436 2671 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2671 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 2671 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2671 4 am be VBP 40436 2671 5 right right JJ 40436 2671 6 , , , 40436 2671 7 then then RB 40436 2671 8 , , , 40436 2671 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2671 10 think think VBP 40436 2671 11 that that IN 40436 2671 12 the the DT 40436 2671 13 Kretans Kretans NNPS 40436 2671 14 have have VBP 40436 2671 15 more more JJR 40436 2671 16 ancient ancient JJ 40436 2671 17 laws law NNS 40436 2671 18 than than IN 40436 2671 19 any any DT 40436 2671 20 other other JJ 40436 2671 21 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 2671 22 ? ? . 40436 2672 1 and and CC 40436 2672 2 that that IN 40436 2672 3 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2672 4 and and CC 40436 2672 5 Rhadamanthus Rhadamanthus NNP 40436 2672 6 are be VBP 40436 2672 7 the the DT 40436 2672 8 best good JJS 40436 2672 9 of of IN 40436 2672 10 all all DT 40436 2672 11 ancient ancient JJ 40436 2672 12 lawgivers lawgiver NNS 40436 2672 13 , , , 40436 2672 14 rulers ruler NNS 40436 2672 15 , , , 40436 2672 16 and and CC 40436 2672 17 shepherds shepherd NNS 40436 2672 18 of of IN 40436 2672 19 mankind mankind NN 40436 2672 20 ? ? . 40436 2673 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2673 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNS 40436 2673 3 think think VBP 40436 2673 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2673 5 are be VBP 40436 2673 6 . . . 40436 2674 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2674 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2674 3 28 28 CD 40436 2674 4 : : : 40436 2674 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2674 6 , , , 40436 2674 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2674 8 , , , 40436 2674 9 321 321 CD 40436 2674 10 B. B. NNP 40436 2675 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2675 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2675 3 : : : 40436 2675 4 tou tou NNP 40436 2675 5 = = SYM 40436 2675 6 to to IN 40436 2675 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2675 8 / / SYM 40436 2675 9 giston giston NNP 40436 2675 10 sêmei sêmei NNP 40436 2675 11 = = NFP 40436 2675 12 on on IN 40436 2675 13 , , , 40436 2675 14 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 2675 15 a)ki a)ki NNP 40436 2675 16 / / SYM 40436 2675 17 nêtoi nêtoi NNP 40436 2675 18 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 2675 19 oi oi NN 40436 2675 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2675 21 no no UH 40436 2675 22 / / SYM 40436 2675 23 moi moi NNP 40436 2675 24 ei)si ei)si NNP 40436 2675 25 / / SYM 40436 2675 26 n n CD 40436 2675 27 , , , 40436 2675 28 a)/te a)/te NNP 40436 2675 29 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2675 30 o)/ntos o)/ntos NN 40436 2675 31 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 2675 32 po po NNP 40436 2675 33 / / SYM 40436 2675 34 leôs leôs NNP 40436 2675 35 oi)kê oi)kê NNP 40436 2675 36 / / SYM 40436 2675 37 seôs seôs JJ 40436 2675 38 e)xeuro e)xeuro CD 40436 2675 39 / / SYM 40436 2675 40 ntos ntos NN 40436 2675 41 eu)= eu)= '' 40436 2675 42 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 2675 43 a)lê a)lê NN 40436 2675 44 / / SYM 40436 2675 45 theian theian NN 40436 2675 46 . . . 40436 2675 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2675 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2676 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2676 2 Side side NN 40436 2676 3 - - HYPH 40436 2676 4 note note NN 40436 2676 5 : : : 40436 2676 6 The the DT 40436 2676 7 question question NN 40436 2676 8 is be VBZ 40436 2676 9 made make VBN 40436 2676 10 more more JJR 40436 2676 11 determinate determinate NN 40436 2676 12 -- -- : 40436 2676 13 What what WP 40436 2676 14 is be VBZ 40436 2676 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2676 16 that that WDT 40436 2676 17 the the DT 40436 2676 18 good good JJ 40436 2676 19 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2676 20 prescribes prescribe NNS 40436 2676 21 and and CC 40436 2676 22 measures measure NNS 40436 2676 23 out out RP 40436 2676 24 for for IN 40436 2676 25 the the DT 40436 2676 26 health health NN 40436 2676 27 of of IN 40436 2676 28 the the DT 40436 2676 29 mind mind NN 40436 2676 30 , , , 40436 2676 31 as as IN 40436 2676 32 the the DT 40436 2676 33 physician physician NN 40436 2676 34 measures measure VBZ 40436 2676 35 out out RP 40436 2676 36 food food NN 40436 2676 37 and and CC 40436 2676 38 exercise exercise NN 40436 2676 39 for for IN 40436 2676 40 the the DT 40436 2676 41 body body NN 40436 2676 42 ? ? . 40436 2677 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2677 2 can can MD 40436 2677 3 not not RB 40436 2677 4 tell tell VB 40436 2677 5 . . . 40436 2678 1 Close close JJ 40436 2678 2 . . . 40436 2678 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2679 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2679 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 2679 3 take take VB 40436 2679 4 the the DT 40436 2679 5 case case NN 40436 2679 6 of of IN 40436 2679 7 the the DT 40436 2679 8 good good JJ 40436 2679 9 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2679 10 and and CC 40436 2679 11 good good JJ 40436 2679 12 shepherd shepherd NN 40436 2679 13 for for IN 40436 2679 14 the the DT 40436 2679 15 body body NN 40436 2679 16 -- -- : 40436 2679 17 If if IN 40436 2679 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2679 19 were be VBD 40436 2679 20 asked ask VBN 40436 2679 21 , , , 40436 2679 22 what what WP 40436 2679 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2679 24 is be VBZ 40436 2679 25 that that IN 40436 2679 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2679 27 prescribes prescribe VBZ 40436 2679 28 for for IN 40436 2679 29 the the DT 40436 2679 30 body body NN 40436 2679 31 , , , 40436 2679 32 so so IN 40436 2679 33 as as IN 40436 2679 34 to to TO 40436 2679 35 render render VB 40436 2679 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2679 37 better well RBR 40436 2679 38 ? ? . 40436 2680 1 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2680 2 should should MD 40436 2680 3 answer answer VB 40436 2680 4 , , , 40436 2680 5 at at IN 40436 2680 6 once once RB 40436 2680 7 , , , 40436 2680 8 briefly briefly RB 40436 2680 9 , , , 40436 2680 10 and and CC 40436 2680 11 well well UH 40436 2680 12 , , , 40436 2680 13 by by IN 40436 2680 14 saying say VBG 40436 2680 15 -- -- : 40436 2680 16 food food NN 40436 2680 17 and and CC 40436 2680 18 labour labour NN 40436 2680 19 : : : 40436 2680 20 the the DT 40436 2680 21 former former JJ 40436 2680 22 to to TO 40436 2680 23 sustain sustain VB 40436 2680 24 the the DT 40436 2680 25 body body NN 40436 2680 26 , , , 40436 2680 27 the the DT 40436 2680 28 latter latter JJ 40436 2680 29 to to TO 40436 2680 30 exercise exercise VB 40436 2680 31 and and CC 40436 2680 32 consolidate consolidate VB 40436 2680 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2680 34 . . . 40436 2681 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2681 2 Comp._--Quite Comp._--Quite NNP 40436 2681 3 correct correct JJ 40436 2681 4 . . . 40436 2682 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2682 2 Sokr._--And Sokr._--And NNP 40436 2682 3 if if IN 40436 2682 4 after after IN 40436 2682 5 that that IN 40436 2682 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2682 7 were be VBD 40436 2682 8 asked ask VBN 40436 2682 9 , , , 40436 2682 10 What what WP 40436 2682 11 are be VBP 40436 2682 12 those those DT 40436 2682 13 things thing NNS 40436 2682 14 which which WDT 40436 2682 15 the the DT 40436 2682 16 good good JJ 40436 2682 17 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2682 18 prescribes prescribe NNS 40436 2682 19 for for IN 40436 2682 20 the the DT 40436 2682 21 mind mind NN 40436 2682 22 to to TO 40436 2682 23 make make VB 40436 2682 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2682 25 better well JJR 40436 2682 26 , , , 40436 2682 27 what what WP 40436 2682 28 should should MD 40436 2682 29 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2682 30 say say VB 40436 2682 31 , , , 40436 2682 32 so so IN 40436 2682 33 as as IN 40436 2682 34 to to TO 40436 2682 35 avoid avoid VB 40436 2682 36 discrediting discredit VBG 40436 2682 37 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 2682 38 ? ? . 40436 2683 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2683 2 Comp._--I Comp._--I NNS 40436 2683 3 really really RB 40436 2683 4 can can MD 40436 2683 5 not not RB 40436 2683 6 tell tell VB 40436 2683 7 . . . 40436 2684 1 _ _ NNP 40436 2684 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 2684 3 surely surely RB 40436 2684 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2684 5 is be VBZ 40436 2684 6 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 2684 7 enough enough RB 40436 2684 8 both both DT 40436 2684 9 for for IN 40436 2684 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2684 11 mind mind NN 40436 2684 12 and and CC 40436 2684 13 mine -PRON- PRP 40436 2684 14 -- -- : 40436 2684 15 to to TO 40436 2684 16 confess confess VB 40436 2684 17 , , , 40436 2684 18 that that IN 40436 2684 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2684 20 do do VBP 40436 2684 21 not not RB 40436 2684 22 know know VB 40436 2684 23 upon upon IN 40436 2684 24 what what WP 40436 2684 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2684 26 is be VBZ 40436 2684 27 that that DT 40436 2684 28 good good JJ 40436 2684 29 and and CC 40436 2684 30 evil evil NN 40436 2684 31 for for IN 40436 2684 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2684 33 minds mind NNS 40436 2684 34 depends depend VBZ 40436 2684 35 , , , 40436 2684 36 while while IN 40436 2684 37 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2684 38 can can MD 40436 2684 39 define define VB 40436 2684 40 upon upon IN 40436 2684 41 what what WP 40436 2684 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2684 43 is be VBZ 40436 2684 44 that that IN 40436 2684 45 the the DT 40436 2684 46 good good JJ 40436 2684 47 or or CC 40436 2684 48 evil evil NN 40436 2684 49 of of IN 40436 2684 50 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2684 51 bodies body NNS 40436 2684 52 depends depend VBZ 40436 2684 53 ? ? . 40436 2685 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2685 2 29 29 CD 40436 2685 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2685 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2685 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2685 6 29 29 CD 40436 2685 7 : : : 40436 2685 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2685 9 , , , 40436 2685 10 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2685 11 , , , 40436 2685 12 321 321 CD 40436 2685 13 C C NNP 40436 2685 14 - - HYPH 40436 2685 15 B. B. NNP 40436 2685 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2686 1 * * NFP 40436 2686 2 * * NFP 40436 2686 3 * * NFP 40436 2686 4 * * NFP 40436 2686 5 * * NFP 40436 2686 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2686 7 Side side NN 40436 2686 8 - - HYPH 40436 2686 9 note note NN 40436 2686 10 : : : 40436 2686 11 The the DT 40436 2686 12 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2686 13 and and CC 40436 2686 14 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2686 15 are be VBP 40436 2686 16 analogous analogous JJ 40436 2686 17 to to IN 40436 2686 18 each each DT 40436 2686 19 other other JJ 40436 2686 20 , , , 40436 2686 21 and and CC 40436 2686 22 both both DT 40436 2686 23 of of IN 40436 2686 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2686 25 inferior inferior JJ 40436 2686 26 works work NNS 40436 2686 27 of of IN 40436 2686 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2686 29 , , , 40436 2686 30 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 2686 31 unfinished unfinished JJ 40436 2686 32 . . . 40436 2686 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2687 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2687 2 have have VBP 40436 2687 3 put put VBN 40436 2687 4 together together RB 40436 2687 5 the the DT 40436 2687 6 two two CD 40436 2687 7 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2687 8 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2687 9 and and CC 40436 2687 10 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2687 11 , , , 40436 2687 12 partly partly RB 40436 2687 13 because because IN 40436 2687 14 of of IN 40436 2687 15 the the DT 40436 2687 16 analogy analogy NN 40436 2687 17 which which WDT 40436 2687 18 really really RB 40436 2687 19 exists exist VBZ 40436 2687 20 between between IN 40436 2687 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2687 22 , , , 40436 2687 23 partly partly RB 40436 2687 24 because because IN 40436 2687 25 that that DT 40436 2687 26 analogy analogy NN 40436 2687 27 is be VBZ 40436 2687 28 much much RB 40436 2687 29 insisted insist VBN 40436 2687 30 on on IN 40436 2687 31 by by IN 40436 2687 32 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2687 33 , , , 40436 2687 34 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2687 35 , , , 40436 2687 36 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 2687 37 , , , 40436 2687 38 and and CC 40436 2687 39 other other JJ 40436 2687 40 recent recent JJ 40436 2687 41 critics critic NNS 40436 2687 42 ; ; : 40436 2687 43 who who WP 40436 2687 44 not not RB 40436 2687 45 only only RB 40436 2687 46 strike strike VBP 40436 2687 47 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2687 48 both both DT 40436 2687 49 out out IN 40436 2687 50 of of IN 40436 2687 51 the the DT 40436 2687 52 list list NN 40436 2687 53 of of IN 40436 2687 54 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2687 55 works work NNS 40436 2687 56 , , , 40436 2687 57 but but CC 40436 2687 58 speak speak VB 40436 2687 59 of of IN 40436 2687 60 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2687 61 with with IN 40436 2687 62 contempt contempt NN 40436 2687 63 as as IN 40436 2687 64 compositions composition NNS 40436 2687 65 . . . 40436 2688 1 On on IN 40436 2688 2 the the DT 40436 2688 3 first first JJ 40436 2688 4 point point NN 40436 2688 5 , , , 40436 2688 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2688 7 dissent dissent VBP 40436 2688 8 from from IN 40436 2688 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2688 10 altogether altogether RB 40436 2688 11 : : : 40436 2688 12 on on IN 40436 2688 13 the the DT 40436 2688 14 second second JJ 40436 2688 15 , , , 40436 2688 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2688 17 agree agree VBP 40436 2688 18 with with IN 40436 2688 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2688 20 thus thus RB 40436 2688 21 far far RB 40436 2688 22 -- -- : 40436 2688 23 that that IN 40436 2688 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2688 25 consider consider VBP 40436 2688 26 the the DT 40436 2688 27 two two CD 40436 2688 28 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2688 29 inferior inferior JJ 40436 2688 30 works work NNS 40436 2688 31 of of IN 40436 2688 32 Plato:--much Plato:--much NNP 40436 2688 33 inferior inferior JJ 40436 2688 34 to to IN 40436 2688 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2688 36 greatest great JJS 40436 2688 37 and and CC 40436 2688 38 best good JJS 40436 2688 39 compositions,--certainly compositions,--certainly RB 40436 2688 40 displaying display VBG 40436 2688 41 both both DT 40436 2688 42 less less JJR 40436 2688 43 genius genius NN 40436 2688 44 and and CC 40436 2688 45 less less RBR 40436 2688 46 careful careful JJ 40436 2688 47 elaboration elaboration NN 40436 2688 48 -- -- : 40436 2688 49 probably probably RB 40436 2688 50 among among IN 40436 2688 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2688 52 early early JJ 40436 2688 53 performances performance NNS 40436 2688 54 -- -- : 40436 2688 55 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 2688 56 even even RB 40436 2688 57 unfinished unfinished JJ 40436 2688 58 projects project NNS 40436 2688 59 , , , 40436 2688 60 destined destine VBN 40436 2688 61 for for IN 40436 2688 62 a a DT 40436 2688 63 farther farth JJR 40436 2688 64 elaboration elaboration NN 40436 2688 65 , , , 40436 2688 66 which which WDT 40436 2688 67 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2688 68 never never RB 40436 2688 69 received receive VBD 40436 2688 70 , , , 40436 2688 71 and and CC 40436 2688 72 not not RB 40436 2688 73 published publish VBN 40436 2688 74 until until IN 40436 2688 75 after after IN 40436 2688 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2688 77 decease decease NN 40436 2688 78 . . . 40436 2689 1 Yet yet CC 40436 2689 2 in in IN 40436 2689 3 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2689 4 as as RB 40436 2689 5 well well RB 40436 2689 6 as as IN 40436 2689 7 in in IN 40436 2689 8 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2689 9 , , , 40436 2689 10 the the DT 40436 2689 11 subjects subject NNS 40436 2689 12 debated debate VBN 40436 2689 13 are be VBP 40436 2689 14 important important JJ 40436 2689 15 as as IN 40436 2689 16 regards regard VBZ 40436 2689 17 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2689 18 theory theory NN 40436 2689 19 . . . 40436 2690 1 Several several JJ 40436 2690 2 questions question NNS 40436 2690 3 are be VBP 40436 2690 4 raised raise VBN 40436 2690 5 and and CC 40436 2690 6 partially partially RB 40436 2690 7 canvassed canvass VBN 40436 2690 8 : : : 40436 2690 9 no no DT 40436 2690 10 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2690 11 is be VBZ 40436 2690 12 finally finally RB 40436 2690 13 attained attain VBN 40436 2690 14 . . . 40436 2691 1 These these DT 40436 2691 2 characteristics characteristic NNS 40436 2691 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2691 4 have have VBP 40436 2691 5 in in IN 40436 2691 6 common common NN 40436 2691 7 with with IN 40436 2691 8 several several JJ 40436 2691 9 of of IN 40436 2691 10 the the DT 40436 2691 11 best good JJS 40436 2691 12 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2691 13 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2691 14 . . . 40436 2692 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2692 2 Side side NN 40436 2692 3 - - HYPH 40436 2692 4 note note NN 40436 2692 5 : : : 40436 2692 6 Hipparchus hipparchus VB 40436 2692 7 -- -- : 40436 2692 8 Double double JJ 40436 2692 9 meaning meaning NN 40436 2692 10 of of IN 40436 2692 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2692 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2692 13 : : : 40436 2692 14 philokerdê\s philokerdê\s ADD 40436 2692 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2692 16 and and CC 40436 2692 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2692 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2692 19 : : : 40436 2692 20 ke ke NNP 40436 2692 21 / / SYM 40436 2692 22 rdos rdos NNP 40436 2692 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2692 24 . . . 40436 2692 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2693 1 In in IN 40436 2693 2 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2693 3 , , , 40436 2693 4 the the DT 40436 2693 5 question question NN 40436 2693 6 put put VBN 40436 2693 7 by by IN 40436 2693 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2693 9 is be VBZ 40436 2693 10 , , , 40436 2693 11 about about IN 40436 2693 12 the the DT 40436 2693 13 definition definition NN 40436 2693 14 of of IN 40436 2693 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2693 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2693 17 : : : 40436 2693 18 o o NN 40436 2693 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2693 20 philokerdê\s philokerdê\s FW 40436 2693 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2693 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2693 23 the the DT 40436 2693 24 lover lover NN 40436 2693 25 of of IN 40436 2693 26 gain gain NN 40436 2693 27 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2693 28 , , , 40436 2693 29 and and CC 40436 2693 30 of of IN 40436 2693 31 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2693 32 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2693 33 : : : 40436 2693 34 ke ke NNP 40436 2693 35 / / SYM 40436 2693 36 rdos rdos NNP 40436 2693 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2693 38 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 2693 39 -- -- : 40436 2693 40 gain gain NN 40436 2693 41 . . . 40436 2694 1 The the DT 40436 2694 2 first first JJ 40436 2694 3 of of IN 40436 2694 4 these these DT 40436 2694 5 two two CD 40436 2694 6 words word NNS 40436 2694 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2694 8 like like IN 40436 2694 9 many many JJ 40436 2694 10 in in IN 40436 2694 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2694 12 as as RB 40436 2694 13 well well RB 40436 2694 14 as as IN 40436 2694 15 in in IN 40436 2694 16 English English NNP 40436 2694 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2694 18 is be VBZ 40436 2694 19 used use VBN 40436 2694 20 in in IN 40436 2694 21 two two CD 40436 2694 22 senses sense NNS 40436 2694 23 . . . 40436 2695 1 In in IN 40436 2695 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2695 3 plain plain JJ 40436 2695 4 , , , 40436 2695 5 etymological etymological JJ 40436 2695 6 sense sense NN 40436 2695 7 , , , 40436 2695 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2695 9 means mean VBZ 40436 2695 10 an an DT 40436 2695 11 attribute attribute NN 40436 2695 12 belonging belong VBG 40436 2695 13 to to IN 40436 2695 14 all all DT 40436 2695 15 men man NNS 40436 2695 16 : : : 40436 2695 17 all all DT 40436 2695 18 men man NNS 40436 2695 19 love love VBP 40436 2695 20 gain gain NN 40436 2695 21 , , , 40436 2695 22 hate hate NN 40436 2695 23 loss loss NN 40436 2695 24 . . . 40436 2696 1 But but CC 40436 2696 2 since since IN 40436 2696 3 this this DT 40436 2696 4 is be VBZ 40436 2696 5 predicable predicable JJ 40436 2696 6 of of IN 40436 2696 7 all all DT 40436 2696 8 , , , 40436 2696 9 there there EX 40436 2696 10 is be VBZ 40436 2696 11 seldom seldom RB 40436 2696 12 any any DT 40436 2696 13 necessity necessity NN 40436 2696 14 for for IN 40436 2696 15 predicating predicate VBG 40436 2696 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2696 17 of of IN 40436 2696 18 any any DT 40436 2696 19 one one CD 40436 2696 20 man man NN 40436 2696 21 or or CC 40436 2696 22 knot knot NN 40436 2696 23 of of IN 40436 2696 24 men man NNS 40436 2696 25 in in IN 40436 2696 26 particular particular JJ 40436 2696 27 . . . 40436 2697 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 2697 2 , , , 40436 2697 3 when when WRB 40436 2697 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2697 5 employ employ VBP 40436 2697 6 the the DT 40436 2697 7 epithet epithet NN 40436 2697 8 as as IN 40436 2697 9 a a DT 40436 2697 10 predicate predicate NN 40436 2697 11 of of IN 40436 2697 12 A a NN 40436 2697 13 or or CC 40436 2697 14 B b NN 40436 2697 15 , , , 40436 2697 16 what what WP 40436 2697 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2697 18 generally generally RB 40436 2697 19 mean mean VBP 40436 2697 20 is be VBZ 40436 2697 21 , , , 40436 2697 22 to to TO 40436 2697 23 assert assert VB 40436 2697 24 something something NN 40436 2697 25 more more JJR 40436 2697 26 than than IN 40436 2697 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2697 28 strict strict JJ 40436 2697 29 etymological etymological JJ 40436 2697 30 meaning meaning NN 40436 2697 31 : : : 40436 2697 32 to to TO 40436 2697 33 declare declare VB 40436 2697 34 that that IN 40436 2697 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2697 36 has have VBZ 40436 2697 37 the the DT 40436 2697 38 attribute attribute NN 40436 2697 39 in in IN 40436 2697 40 unusual unusual JJ 40436 2697 41 measure measure NN 40436 2697 42 ; ; : 40436 2697 43 or or CC 40436 2697 44 that that IN 40436 2697 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2697 46 has have VBZ 40436 2697 47 shown show VBN 40436 2697 48 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2697 49 , , , 40436 2697 50 on on IN 40436 2697 51 various various JJ 40436 2697 52 occasions occasion NNS 40436 2697 53 , , , 40436 2697 54 wanting want VBG 40436 2697 55 in in IN 40436 2697 56 other other JJ 40436 2697 57 attributes attribute NNS 40436 2697 58 , , , 40436 2697 59 which which WDT 40436 2697 60 on on IN 40436 2697 61 those those DT 40436 2697 62 occasions occasion NNS 40436 2697 63 ought ought MD 40436 2697 64 , , , 40436 2697 65 in in IN 40436 2697 66 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2697 67 judgment judgment NN 40436 2697 68 , , , 40436 2697 69 to to TO 40436 2697 70 have have VB 40436 2697 71 countervailed countervail VBN 40436 2697 72 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2697 73 . . . 40436 2698 1 The the DT 40436 2698 2 epithet epithet NN 40436 2698 3 thus thus RB 40436 2698 4 comes come VBZ 40436 2698 5 to to TO 40436 2698 6 connote connote VB 40436 2698 7 a a DT 40436 2698 8 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2698 9 of of IN 40436 2698 10 blame blame NN 40436 2698 11 or or CC 40436 2698 12 reproach reproach NN 40436 2698 13 , , , 40436 2698 14 in in IN 40436 2698 15 the the DT 40436 2698 16 mind mind NN 40436 2698 17 of of IN 40436 2698 18 the the DT 40436 2698 19 speaker speaker NN 40436 2698 20 . . . 40436 2699 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2699 2 30 30 CD 40436 2699 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2699 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2699 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2699 6 30 30 CD 40436 2699 7 : : : 40436 2699 8 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2699 9 adverts advert VBZ 40436 2699 10 to to IN 40436 2699 11 this this DT 40436 2699 12 class class NN 40436 2699 13 of of IN 40436 2699 14 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2699 15 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2699 16 , , , 40436 2699 17 connoting connote VBG 40436 2699 18 both both CC 40436 2699 19 an an DT 40436 2699 20 attribute attribute NN 40436 2699 21 in in IN 40436 2699 22 the the DT 40436 2699 23 person person NN 40436 2699 24 designated designate VBN 40436 2699 25 and and CC 40436 2699 26 an an DT 40436 2699 27 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 40436 2699 28 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2699 29 in in IN 40436 2699 30 the the DT 40436 2699 31 speaker speaker NN 40436 2699 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2699 33 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 2699 34 . . . 40436 2700 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 2700 2 . . . 40436 2701 1 ii ii LS 40436 2701 2 . . . 40436 2702 1 6 6 CD 40436 2702 2 , , , 40436 2702 3 p. p. NN 40436 2702 4 1107 1107 CD 40436 2702 5 , , , 40436 2702 6 a. a. NN 40436 2703 1 9 9 LS 40436 2703 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2703 3 . . . 40436 2704 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2704 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2704 3 : : : 40436 2704 4 Ou Ou NNP 40436 2704 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2704 6 pa pa NNP 40436 2704 7 = = SYM 40436 2704 8 sa sa NNP 40436 2704 9 d d NNP 40436 2704 10 ' ' POS 40436 2704 11 e)pide e)pide CD 40436 2704 12 / / SYM 40436 2704 13 chetai chetai NNP 40436 2704 14 pra pra NNP 40436 2704 15 = = SYM 40436 2704 16 xis xis NNP 40436 2704 17 , , , 40436 2704 18 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 2704 19 pa pa NNP 40436 2704 20 = = SYM 40436 2704 21 n n NNP 40436 2704 22 pa pa NNP 40436 2704 23 / / , 40436 2704 24 thos thos NNP 40436 2704 25 , , , 40436 2704 26 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 2704 27 meso meso NN 40436 2704 28 / / SYM 40436 2704 29 têta têta NN 40436 2704 30 ; ; : 40436 2704 31 e)/nia e)/nia NNP 40436 2704 32 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 2704 33 eu)thu\s eu)thu\ VBG 40436 2704 34 ô)no ô)no NNP 40436 2704 35 / / SYM 40436 2704 36 mastai mastai NNP 40436 2704 37 suneilêmme suneilêmme NNP 40436 2704 38 / / SYM 40436 2704 39 na na NNP 40436 2704 40 meta\ meta\ NNP 40436 2704 41 tê tê NNP 40436 2704 42 = = SYM 40436 2704 43 s s NNP 40436 2704 44 phaulo phaulo NNP 40436 2704 45 / / SYM 40436 2704 46 têtos têto NNS 40436 2704 47 , , , 40436 2704 48 oi)=on oi)=on NNP 40436 2704 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2704 50 , , , 40436 2704 51 & & CC 40436 2704 52 c. c. NNP 40436 2704 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2704 54 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2704 55 Side side NN 40436 2704 56 - - HYPH 40436 2704 57 note note NN 40436 2704 58 : : : 40436 2704 59 State state NN 40436 2704 60 or or CC 40436 2704 61 mind mind NN 40436 2704 62 of of IN 40436 2704 63 the the DT 40436 2704 64 agent agent NN 40436 2704 65 , , , 40436 2704 66 as as IN 40436 2704 67 to to IN 40436 2704 68 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2704 69 , , , 40436 2704 70 frequent frequent JJ 40436 2704 71 inquiry inquiry NN 40436 2704 72 in in IN 40436 2704 73 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2704 74 . . . 40436 2705 1 No no DT 40436 2705 2 tenable tenable JJ 40436 2705 3 definition definition NN 40436 2705 4 found find VBN 40436 2705 5 . . . 40436 2705 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2706 1 The the DT 40436 2706 2 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2706 3 or or CC 40436 2706 4 Collocutor Collocutor NNP 40436 2706 5 , , , 40436 2706 6 being be VBG 40436 2706 7 called call VBN 40436 2706 8 upon upon IN 40436 2706 9 by by IN 40436 2706 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2706 11 to to TO 40436 2706 12 explain explain VB 40436 2706 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2706 14 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2706 15 : : : 40436 2706 16 to\ to\ NN 40436 2706 17 philokerde\s philokerde\s NNP 40436 2706 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2706 19 , , , 40436 2706 20 defines define VBZ 40436 2706 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2706 22 in in IN 40436 2706 23 this this DT 40436 2706 24 last last JJ 40436 2706 25 sense sense NN 40436 2706 26 , , , 40436 2706 27 as as IN 40436 2706 28 conveying convey VBG 40436 2706 29 or or CC 40436 2706 30 connoting connote VBG 40436 2706 31 a a DT 40436 2706 32 reproach reproach NN 40436 2706 33 . . . 40436 2707 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2707 2 gives give VBZ 40436 2707 3 three three CD 40436 2707 4 different different JJ 40436 2707 5 explanations explanation NNS 40436 2707 6 of of IN 40436 2707 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2707 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2707 9 always always RB 40436 2707 10 in in IN 40436 2707 11 this this DT 40436 2707 12 sense sense NN 40436 2707 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2707 14 , , , 40436 2707 15 each each DT 40436 2707 16 of of IN 40436 2707 17 which which WDT 40436 2707 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2707 19 shows show VBZ 40436 2707 20 to to TO 40436 2707 21 be be VB 40436 2707 22 untenable untenable JJ 40436 2707 23 . . . 40436 2708 1 A a DT 40436 2708 2 variety variety NN 40436 2708 3 of of IN 40436 2708 4 parallel parallel JJ 40436 2708 5 cases case NNS 40436 2708 6 are be VBP 40436 2708 7 compared compare VBN 40436 2708 8 , , , 40436 2708 9 and and CC 40436 2708 10 the the DT 40436 2708 11 question question NN 40436 2708 12 is be VBZ 40436 2708 13 put put VBN 40436 2708 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2708 15 so so RB 40436 2708 16 constantly constantly RB 40436 2708 17 recurring recur VBG 40436 2708 18 in in IN 40436 2708 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2708 20 's 's POS 40436 2708 21 writings writing NNS 40436 2708 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2708 23 , , , 40436 2708 24 what what WP 40436 2708 25 is be VBZ 40436 2708 26 the the DT 40436 2708 27 state state NN 40436 2708 28 of of IN 40436 2708 29 the the DT 40436 2708 30 agent agent NN 40436 2708 31 's 's POS 40436 2708 32 mind mind NN 40436 2708 33 as as IN 40436 2708 34 to to IN 40436 2708 35 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2708 36 ? ? . 40436 2709 1 The the DT 40436 2709 2 cross cross NN 40436 2709 3 - - NN 40436 2709 4 examination examination NN 40436 2709 5 makes make VBZ 40436 2709 6 out out RP 40436 2709 7 , , , 40436 2709 8 that that IN 40436 2709 9 if if IN 40436 2709 10 the the DT 40436 2709 11 agent agent NN 40436 2709 12 be be VB 40436 2709 13 supposed suppose VBN 40436 2709 14 to to IN 40436 2709 15 know,--then know,--then NNP 40436 2709 16 there there EX 40436 2709 17 is be VBZ 40436 2709 18 no no DT 40436 2709 19 man man NN 40436 2709 20 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 2709 21 to to IN 40436 2709 22 the the DT 40436 2709 23 definition definition NN 40436 2709 24 of of IN 40436 2709 25 a a DT 40436 2709 26 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2709 27 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2709 28 : : : 40436 2709 29 philokerdê philokerdê NNP 40436 2709 30 / / SYM 40436 2709 31 s s NNP 40436 2709 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2709 33 : : : 40436 2709 34 if if IN 40436 2709 35 the the DT 40436 2709 36 agent agent NN 40436 2709 37 be be VB 40436 2709 38 supposed suppose VBN 40436 2709 39 not not RB 40436 2709 40 to to TO 40436 2709 41 know know VB 40436 2709 42 -- -- : 40436 2709 43 then then RB 40436 2709 44 , , , 40436 2709 45 on on IN 40436 2709 46 the the DT 40436 2709 47 contrary contrary NN 40436 2709 48 , , , 40436 2709 49 every every DT 40436 2709 50 man man NN 40436 2709 51 will will MD 40436 2709 52 come come VB 40436 2709 53 under under IN 40436 2709 54 the the DT 40436 2709 55 definition definition NN 40436 2709 56 . . . 40436 2710 1 The the DT 40436 2710 2 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2710 3 is be VBZ 40436 2710 4 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 2710 5 that that IN 40436 2710 6 there there EX 40436 2710 7 is be VBZ 40436 2710 8 such such PDT 40436 2710 9 a a DT 40436 2710 10 thing thing NN 40436 2710 11 as as IN 40436 2710 12 " " `` 40436 2710 13 love love NN 40436 2710 14 of of IN 40436 2710 15 gain gain NN 40436 2710 16 " " '' 40436 2710 17 in in IN 40436 2710 18 the the DT 40436 2710 19 blamable blamable JJ 40436 2710 20 sense sense NN 40436 2710 21 . . . 40436 2711 1 Yet yet CC 40436 2711 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2711 3 can can MD 40436 2711 4 not not RB 40436 2711 5 find find VB 40436 2711 6 any any DT 40436 2711 7 tenable tenable JJ 40436 2711 8 definition definition NN 40436 2711 9 , , , 40436 2711 10 to to TO 40436 2711 11 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 2711 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2711 13 from from IN 40436 2711 14 " " `` 40436 2711 15 love love NN 40436 2711 16 of of IN 40436 2711 17 gain gain NN 40436 2711 18 " " '' 40436 2711 19 in in IN 40436 2711 20 the the DT 40436 2711 21 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 2711 22 or or CC 40436 2711 23 innocent innocent JJ 40436 2711 24 sense sense NN 40436 2711 25 . . . 40436 2712 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2712 2 Side side NN 40436 2712 3 - - HYPH 40436 2712 4 note note NN 40436 2712 5 : : : 40436 2712 6 Admitting admit VBG 40436 2712 7 that that IN 40436 2712 8 there there EX 40436 2712 9 is be VBZ 40436 2712 10 bad bad JJ 40436 2712 11 gain gain NN 40436 2712 12 , , , 40436 2712 13 as as RB 40436 2712 14 well well RB 40436 2712 15 as as IN 40436 2712 16 good good JJ 40436 2712 17 gain gain NN 40436 2712 18 , , , 40436 2712 19 what what WP 40436 2712 20 is be VBZ 40436 2712 21 the the DT 40436 2712 22 meaning meaning NN 40436 2712 23 of of IN 40436 2712 24 the the DT 40436 2712 25 word word NN 40436 2712 26 _ _ NNP 40436 2712 27 gain gain NN 40436 2712 28 _ _ NNP 40436 2712 29 ? ? . 40436 2713 1 None none NN 40436 2713 2 is be VBZ 40436 2713 3 found find VBN 40436 2713 4 . . . 40436 2713 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2714 1 The the DT 40436 2714 2 same same JJ 40436 2714 3 question question NN 40436 2714 4 comes come VBZ 40436 2714 5 back back RB 40436 2714 6 in in IN 40436 2714 7 another another DT 40436 2714 8 form form NN 40436 2714 9 , , , 40436 2714 10 after after IN 40436 2714 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2714 12 has have VBZ 40436 2714 13 given give VBN 40436 2714 14 the the DT 40436 2714 15 liberty liberty NN 40436 2714 16 of of IN 40436 2714 17 retractation retractation NN 40436 2714 18 . . . 40436 2715 1 The the DT 40436 2715 2 Collocutor Collocutor NNP 40436 2715 3 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 2715 4 that that IN 40436 2715 5 there there EX 40436 2715 6 is be VBZ 40436 2715 7 bad bad JJ 40436 2715 8 _ _ NNP 40436 2715 9 gain gain NN 40436 2715 10 _ _ NNP 40436 2715 11 , , , 40436 2715 12 as as RB 40436 2715 13 well well RB 40436 2715 14 as as IN 40436 2715 15 good good JJ 40436 2715 16 _ _ NNP 40436 2715 17 gain gain NN 40436 2715 18 _ _ NNP 40436 2715 19 . . . 40436 2716 1 But but CC 40436 2716 2 what what WP 40436 2716 3 is be VBZ 40436 2716 4 that that DT 40436 2716 5 common common JJ 40436 2716 6 , , , 40436 2716 7 generic generic JJ 40436 2716 8 , , , 40436 2716 9 quality quality NN 40436 2716 10 , , , 40436 2716 11 designated designate VBN 40436 2716 12 well well RB 40436 2716 13 as as IN 40436 2716 14 good good JJ 40436 2716 15 by by IN 40436 2716 16 the the DT 40436 2716 17 word word NN 40436 2716 18 _ _ NNP 40436 2716 19 gain gain NN 40436 2716 20 _ _ NNP 40436 2716 21 , , , 40436 2716 22 apart apart RB 40436 2716 23 from from IN 40436 2716 24 these these DT 40436 2716 25 two two CD 40436 2716 26 distinctive distinctive JJ 40436 2716 27 epithets epithet NNS 40436 2716 28 ? ? . 40436 2717 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2717 2 can can MD 40436 2717 3 not not RB 40436 2717 4 find find VB 40436 2717 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2717 6 out out RP 40436 2717 7 or or CC 40436 2717 8 describe describe VB 40436 2717 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2717 10 . . . 40436 2718 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2718 2 gives give VBZ 40436 2718 3 two two CD 40436 2718 4 definitions definition NNS 40436 2718 5 , , , 40436 2718 6 each each DT 40436 2718 7 of of IN 40436 2718 8 which which WDT 40436 2718 9 is be VBZ 40436 2718 10 torn tear VBN 40436 2718 11 up up RP 40436 2718 12 by by IN 40436 2718 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2718 14 . . . 40436 2719 1 To to TO 40436 2719 2 deserve deserve VB 40436 2719 3 the the DT 40436 2719 4 name name NN 40436 2719 5 of of IN 40436 2719 6 _ _ NNP 40436 2719 7 gain gain NN 40436 2719 8 _ _ NNP 40436 2719 9 , , , 40436 2719 10 that that DT 40436 2719 11 which which WDT 40436 2719 12 a a DT 40436 2719 13 man man NN 40436 2719 14 acquires acquire NNS 40436 2719 15 must must MD 40436 2719 16 be be VB 40436 2719 17 good good JJ 40436 2719 18 ; ; : 40436 2719 19 and and CC 40436 2719 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2719 21 must must MD 40436 2719 22 surpass surpass VB 40436 2719 23 , , , 40436 2719 24 in in IN 40436 2719 25 value value NN 40436 2719 26 as as RB 40436 2719 27 well well RB 40436 2719 28 as as IN 40436 2719 29 in in IN 40436 2719 30 quantity quantity NN 40436 2719 31 , , , 40436 2719 32 the the DT 40436 2719 33 loss loss NN 40436 2719 34 or or CC 40436 2719 35 outlay outlay NN 40436 2719 36 which which WDT 40436 2719 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2719 38 incurs incur VBZ 40436 2719 39 in in IN 40436 2719 40 order order NN 40436 2719 41 to to TO 40436 2719 42 acquire acquire VB 40436 2719 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2719 44 . . . 40436 2720 1 But but CC 40436 2720 2 when when WRB 40436 2720 3 thus thus RB 40436 2720 4 understood understand VBD 40436 2720 5 , , , 40436 2720 6 all all DT 40436 2720 7 gains gain NNS 40436 2720 8 are be VBP 40436 2720 9 good good JJ 40436 2720 10 . . . 40436 2721 1 There there EX 40436 2721 2 is be VBZ 40436 2721 3 no no DT 40436 2721 4 meaning meaning NN 40436 2721 5 in in IN 40436 2721 6 the the DT 40436 2721 7 distinction distinction NN 40436 2721 8 between between IN 40436 2721 9 good good JJ 40436 2721 10 and and CC 40436 2721 11 bad bad JJ 40436 2721 12 gains gain NNS 40436 2721 13 : : : 40436 2721 14 all all DT 40436 2721 15 men man NNS 40436 2721 16 are be VBP 40436 2721 17 lovers lover NNS 40436 2721 18 of of IN 40436 2721 19 gain gain NN 40436 2721 20 . . . 40436 2722 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2722 2 Side side NN 40436 2722 3 - - HYPH 40436 2722 4 note note NN 40436 2722 5 : : : 40436 2722 6 Purpose purpose NN 40436 2722 7 of of IN 40436 2722 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2722 9 in in IN 40436 2722 10 the the DT 40436 2722 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2722 12 -- -- : 40436 2722 13 to to TO 40436 2722 14 lay lay VB 40436 2722 15 bare bare JJ 40436 2722 16 the the DT 40436 2722 17 confusion confusion NN 40436 2722 18 , , , 40436 2722 19 and and CC 40436 2722 20 to to TO 40436 2722 21 force force VB 40436 2722 22 the the DT 40436 2722 23 mind mind NN 40436 2722 24 of of IN 40436 2722 25 the the DT 40436 2722 26 respondent respondent NN 40436 2722 27 into into IN 40436 2722 28 efforts effort NNS 40436 2722 29 for for IN 40436 2722 30 clearing clear VBG 40436 2722 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2722 32 up up RP 40436 2722 33 . . . 40436 2722 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2723 1 With with IN 40436 2723 2 this this DT 40436 2723 3 confusion confusion NN 40436 2723 4 , , , 40436 2723 5 the the DT 40436 2723 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2723 7 closes close VBZ 40436 2723 8 . . . 40436 2724 1 The the DT 40436 2724 2 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 2724 3 notion notion NN 40436 2724 4 of of IN 40436 2724 5 _ _ NNP 40436 2724 6 good good JJ 40436 2724 7 _ _ NNP 40436 2724 8 , , , 40436 2724 9 as as IN 40436 2724 10 what what WP 40436 2724 11 every every DT 40436 2724 12 one one CD 40436 2724 13 loves--_evil loves--_evil NN 40436 2724 14 _ _ NNP 40436 2724 15 as as IN 40436 2724 16 what what WP 40436 2724 17 every every DT 40436 2724 18 one one NN 40436 2724 19 hates hate VBZ 40436 2724 20 -- -- : 40436 2724 21 also also RB 40436 2724 22 of of IN 40436 2724 23 evil evil NN 40436 2724 24 - - HYPH 40436 2724 25 doing doing NN 40436 2724 26 , , , 40436 2724 27 as as IN 40436 2724 28 performed perform VBN 40436 2724 29 by by IN 40436 2724 30 every every DT 40436 2724 31 evil evil NN 40436 2724 32 - - HYPH 40436 2724 33 doer doer NN 40436 2724 34 only only RB 40436 2724 35 through through IN 40436 2724 36 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 2724 37 or or CC 40436 2724 38 mistake mistake NN 40436 2724 39 is be VBZ 40436 2724 40 brought bring VBN 40436 2724 41 out out RP 40436 2724 42 and and CC 40436 2724 43 applied apply VBD 40436 2724 44 to to TO 40436 2724 45 test test VB 40436 2724 46 the the DT 40436 2724 47 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2724 48 phraseology phraseology NN 40436 2724 49 of of IN 40436 2724 50 a a DT 40436 2724 51 common common JJ 40436 2724 52 - - HYPH 40436 2724 53 place place NN 40436 2724 54 respondent respondent NN 40436 2724 55 . . . 40436 2725 1 But but CC 40436 2725 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2725 3 only only RB 40436 2725 4 serves serve VBZ 40436 2725 5 to to TO 40436 2725 6 lay lay VB 40436 2725 7 bare bare JJ 40436 2725 8 a a DT 40436 2725 9 state state NN 40436 2725 10 of of IN 40436 2725 11 confusion confusion NN 40436 2725 12 and and CC 40436 2725 13 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 2725 14 , , , 40436 2725 15 without without IN 40436 2725 16 clearing clear VBG 40436 2725 17 up up RP 40436 2725 18 any any DT 40436 2725 19 thing thing NN 40436 2725 20 . . . 40436 2726 1 Herein Herein NNP 40436 2726 2 , , , 40436 2726 3 so so RB 40436 2726 4 far far RB 40436 2726 5 as as IN 40436 2726 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2726 7 can can MD 40436 2726 8 see see VB 40436 2726 9 , , , 40436 2726 10 lies lie VBZ 40436 2726 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2726 12 's 's POS 40436 2726 13 purpose purpose NN 40436 2726 14 in in IN 40436 2726 15 the the DT 40436 2726 16 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2726 17 . . . 40436 2727 1 The the DT 40436 2727 2 respondent respondent NN 40436 2727 3 is be VBZ 40436 2727 4 made make VBN 40436 2727 5 aware aware JJ 40436 2727 6 of of IN 40436 2727 7 the the DT 40436 2727 8 confusion confusion NN 40436 2727 9 , , , 40436 2727 10 which which WDT 40436 2727 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2727 12 did do VBD 40436 2727 13 not not RB 40436 2727 14 know know VB 40436 2727 15 before before RB 40436 2727 16 ; ; : 40436 2727 17 and and CC 40436 2727 18 this this DT 40436 2727 19 , , , 40436 2727 20 in in IN 40436 2727 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2727 22 's 's POS 40436 2727 23 view view NN 40436 2727 24 , , , 40436 2727 25 is be VBZ 40436 2727 26 a a DT 40436 2727 27 progress progress NN 40436 2727 28 . . . 40436 2728 1 The the DT 40436 2728 2 respondent respondent NN 40436 2728 3 can can MD 40436 2728 4 not not RB 40436 2728 5 avoid avoid VB 40436 2728 6 giving give VBG 40436 2728 7 contradictory contradictory JJ 40436 2728 8 answers answer NNS 40436 2728 9 , , , 40436 2728 10 under under IN 40436 2728 11 an an DT 40436 2728 12 acute acute JJ 40436 2728 13 cross cross NN 40436 2728 14 - - NN 40436 2728 15 examination examination NN 40436 2728 16 : : : 40436 2728 17 but but CC 40436 2728 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2728 19 does do VBZ 40436 2728 20 not not RB 40436 2728 21 adopt adopt VB 40436 2728 22 any any DT 40436 2728 23 new new JJ 40436 2728 24 belief belief NN 40436 2728 25 . . . 40436 2729 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2729 2 says say VBZ 40436 2729 3 to to IN 40436 2729 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2729 5 at at IN 40436 2729 6 the the DT 40436 2729 7 close--"The close--"The NNP 40436 2729 8 debate debate NN 40436 2729 9 has have VBZ 40436 2729 10 constrained constrain VBN 40436 2729 11 rather rather RB 40436 2729 12 than than IN 40436 2729 13 persuaded persuade VBD 40436 2729 14 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2729 15 " " '' 40436 2729 16 . . . 40436 2730 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2730 2 31 31 CD 40436 2730 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2730 4 This this DT 40436 2730 5 is be VBZ 40436 2730 6 a a DT 40436 2730 7 simple simple JJ 40436 2730 8 but but CC 40436 2730 9 instructive instructive JJ 40436 2730 10 declaration declaration NN 40436 2730 11 of of IN 40436 2730 12 the the DT 40436 2730 13 force force NN 40436 2730 14 put put VBN 40436 2730 15 by by IN 40436 2730 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2730 17 upon upon IN 40436 2730 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2730 19 collocutors collocutor NNS 40436 2730 20 ; ; : 40436 2730 21 and and CC 40436 2730 22 of of IN 40436 2730 23 the the DT 40436 2730 24 reactionary reactionary JJ 40436 2730 25 effort effort NN 40436 2730 26 likely likely JJ 40436 2730 27 to to TO 40436 2730 28 be be VB 40436 2730 29 provoked provoke VBN 40436 2730 30 in in IN 40436 2730 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2730 32 minds mind NNS 40436 2730 33 , , , 40436 2730 34 with with IN 40436 2730 35 a a DT 40436 2730 36 view view NN 40436 2730 37 to to TO 40436 2730 38 extricate extricate VB 40436 2730 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 2730 40 from from IN 40436 2730 41 a a DT 40436 2730 42 painful painful JJ 40436 2730 43 sense sense NN 40436 2730 44 of of IN 40436 2730 45 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 2730 46 . . . 40436 2731 1 If if IN 40436 2731 2 such such JJ 40436 2731 3 effort effort NN 40436 2731 4 be be VB 40436 2731 5 provoked provoke VBN 40436 2731 6 , , , 40436 2731 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2731 8 's 's POS 40436 2731 9 purpose purpose NN 40436 2731 10 is be VBZ 40436 2731 11 attained attain VBN 40436 2731 12 . . . 40436 2732 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2732 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2732 3 31 31 CD 40436 2732 4 : : : 40436 2732 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2732 6 , , , 40436 2732 7 Hipparch hipparch NN 40436 2732 8 . . . 40436 2733 1 232 232 CD 40436 2733 2 B. B. NNP 40436 2734 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2734 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2734 3 : : : 40436 2734 4 ê)na ê)na NNS 40436 2734 5 / / SYM 40436 2734 6 gkake gkake NNP 40436 2734 7 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 2734 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2734 9 o o NNP 40436 2734 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2734 11 lo lo NNP 40436 2734 12 / / SYM 40436 2734 13 gos gos NNP 40436 2734 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2734 15 ma ma NNP 40436 2734 16 = = SYM 40436 2734 17 llon llon NNP 40436 2734 18 e)me/ e)me/ CD 40436 2734 19 ge ge NNP 40436 2734 20 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 2734 21 pe pe NNP 40436 2734 22 / / SYM 40436 2734 23 peiken peiken VBN 40436 2734 24 . . . 40436 2734 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2734 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2735 1 One one CD 40436 2735 2 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 2735 3 there there RB 40436 2735 4 is be VBZ 40436 2735 5 , , , 40436 2735 6 analogous analogous JJ 40436 2735 7 to to IN 40436 2735 8 what what WP 40436 2735 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2735 10 have have VBP 40436 2735 11 already already RB 40436 2735 12 seen see VBN 40436 2735 13 in in IN 40436 2735 14 the the DT 40436 2735 15 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2735 16 Major Major NNP 40436 2735 17 . . . 40436 2736 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2736 2 is be VBZ 40436 2736 3 not not RB 40436 2736 4 merely merely RB 40436 2736 5 the the DT 40436 2736 6 Collocutor Collocutor NNP 40436 2736 7 who who WP 40436 2736 8 charges charge VBZ 40436 2736 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2736 10 , , , 40436 2736 11 but but CC 40436 2736 12 also also RB 40436 2736 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2736 14 who who WP 40436 2736 15 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 2736 16 the the DT 40436 2736 17 Collocutor Collocutor NNP 40436 2736 18 -- -- : 40436 2736 19 each each DT 40436 2736 20 charging charge VBG 40436 2736 21 the the DT 40436 2736 22 other other JJ 40436 2736 23 with with IN 40436 2736 24 attempts attempt NNS 40436 2736 25 to to TO 40436 2736 26 deceive deceive VB 40436 2736 27 a a DT 40436 2736 28 friend friend NN 40436 2736 29 . . . 40436 2737 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2737 2 32 32 CD 40436 2737 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2737 4 This this DT 40436 2737 5 seems seem VBZ 40436 2737 6 intended intend VBN 40436 2737 7 by by IN 40436 2737 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2737 9 to to TO 40436 2737 10 create create VB 40436 2737 11 an an DT 40436 2737 12 occasion occasion NN 40436 2737 13 for for IN 40436 2737 14 introducing introduce VBG 40436 2737 15 what what WP 40436 2737 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2737 17 had have VBD 40436 2737 18 to to TO 40436 2737 19 say say VB 40436 2737 20 about about IN 40436 2737 21 Hipparchus--_apropos hipparchus--_apropo NNS 40436 2737 22 _ _ NNP 40436 2737 23 of of IN 40436 2737 24 the the DT 40436 2737 25 motto motto NN 40436 2737 26 on on IN 40436 2737 27 the the DT 40436 2737 28 Hipparchean Hipparchean NNP 40436 2737 29 Hermes--[Greek hermes--[greek NN 40436 2737 30 : : : 40436 2737 31 mê\ mê\ VB 40436 2737 32 phi phi NN 40436 2737 33 / / SYM 40436 2737 34 lon lon NNP 40436 2737 35 e)xapa e)xapa NNP 40436 2737 36 / / SYM 40436 2737 37 ta ta NNP 40436 2737 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2737 39 . . . 40436 2738 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2738 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2738 3 32 32 CD 40436 2738 4 : : : 40436 2738 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2738 6 , , , 40436 2738 7 Hipparch Hipparch NNP 40436 2738 8 . . . 40436 2739 1 225 225 CD 40436 2739 2 E e NN 40436 2739 3 , , , 40436 2739 4 228 228 CD 40436 2739 5 A. a. NN 40436 2739 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2740 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2740 2 Side side NN 40436 2740 3 - - HYPH 40436 2740 4 note note NN 40436 2740 5 : : : 40436 2740 6 Historical historical JJ 40436 2740 7 narrative narrative NN 40436 2740 8 and and CC 40436 2740 9 comments comment NNS 40436 2740 10 given give VBN 40436 2740 11 in in IN 40436 2740 12 the the DT 40436 2740 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2740 14 respecting respect VBG 40436 2740 15 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2740 16 -- -- : 40436 2740 17 afford afford VB 40436 2740 18 no no DT 40436 2740 19 ground ground NN 40436 2740 20 for for IN 40436 2740 21 declaring declare VBG 40436 2740 22 the the DT 40436 2740 23 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2740 24 to to TO 40436 2740 25 be be VB 40436 2740 26 spurious spurious JJ 40436 2740 27 . . . 40436 2740 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2741 1 The the DT 40436 2741 2 modern modern JJ 40436 2741 3 critics critic NNS 40436 2741 4 , , , 40436 2741 5 who who WP 40436 2741 6 proclaim proclaim VBP 40436 2741 7 the the DT 40436 2741 8 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNPS 40436 2741 9 not not RB 40436 2741 10 to to TO 40436 2741 11 be be VB 40436 2741 12 the the DT 40436 2741 13 work work NN 40436 2741 14 of of IN 40436 2741 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2741 16 , , , 40436 2741 17 allege allege NN 40436 2741 18 as as IN 40436 2741 19 one one CD 40436 2741 20 of of IN 40436 2741 21 the the DT 40436 2741 22 proofs proof NNS 40436 2741 23 of of IN 40436 2741 24 spuriousness spuriousness NN 40436 2741 25 , , , 40436 2741 26 the the DT 40436 2741 27 occurrence occurrence NN 40436 2741 28 of of IN 40436 2741 29 this this DT 40436 2741 30 long long JJ 40436 2741 31 narrative narrative NN 40436 2741 32 and and CC 40436 2741 33 comment comment NN 40436 2741 34 upon upon IN 40436 2741 35 the the DT 40436 2741 36 historical historical JJ 40436 2741 37 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2741 38 and and CC 40436 2741 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2741 40 behaviour behaviour NN 40436 2741 41 ; ; : 40436 2741 42 which which WDT 40436 2741 43 narrative narrative NN 40436 2741 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2741 45 the the DT 40436 2741 46 critics critic NNS 40436 2741 47 maintain maintain VBP 40436 2741 48 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2741 49 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2741 50 would would MD 40436 2741 51 never never RB 40436 2741 52 have have VB 40436 2741 53 introduced introduce VBN 40436 2741 54 , , , 40436 2741 55 seeing see VBG 40436 2741 56 that that IN 40436 2741 57 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2741 58 contributes contribute VBZ 40436 2741 59 nothing nothing NN 40436 2741 60 to to IN 40436 2741 61 the the DT 40436 2741 62 settlement settlement NN 40436 2741 63 of of IN 40436 2741 64 the the DT 40436 2741 65 question question NN 40436 2741 66 debated debate VBD 40436 2741 67 . . . 40436 2742 1 But but CC 40436 2742 2 to to IN 40436 2742 3 this this DT 40436 2742 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2742 5 may may MD 40436 2742 6 reply reply VB 40436 2742 7 , , , 40436 2742 8 first first RB 40436 2742 9 , , , 40436 2742 10 That that IN 40436 2742 11 there there EX 40436 2742 12 are be VBP 40436 2742 13 other other JJ 40436 2742 14 dialogues[33 dialogues[33 NN 40436 2742 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2742 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2742 17 not not RB 40436 2742 18 to to TO 40436 2742 19 mention mention VB 40436 2742 20 the the DT 40436 2742 21 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2742 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2742 23 in in IN 40436 2742 24 which which WDT 40436 2742 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2742 26 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 2742 27 recitals recital NNS 40436 2742 28 of of IN 40436 2742 29 considerable considerable JJ 40436 2742 30 length length NN 40436 2742 31 , , , 40436 2742 32 historical historical JJ 40436 2742 33 or or CC 40436 2742 34 quasi quasi JJ 40436 2742 35 - - JJ 40436 2742 36 historical historical JJ 40436 2742 37 recitals recital NNS 40436 2742 38 ; ; : 40436 2742 39 bearing bear VBG 40436 2742 40 remotely remotely RB 40436 2742 41 , , , 40436 2742 42 or or CC 40436 2742 43 hardly hardly RB 40436 2742 44 bearing bear VBG 40436 2742 45 at at RB 40436 2742 46 all all RB 40436 2742 47 , , , 40436 2742 48 upon upon IN 40436 2742 49 the the DT 40436 2742 50 precise precise JJ 40436 2742 51 question question NN 40436 2742 52 under under IN 40436 2742 53 discussion discussion NN 40436 2742 54 ; ; : 40436 2742 55 next,--That next,--that RB 40436 2742 56 even even RB 40436 2742 57 if if IN 40436 2742 58 no no DT 40436 2742 59 such such JJ 40436 2742 60 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2742 61 could could MD 40436 2742 62 be be VB 40436 2742 63 cited cite VBN 40436 2742 64 , , , 40436 2742 65 and and CC 40436 2742 66 if if IN 40436 2742 67 the the DT 40436 2742 68 case case NN 40436 2742 69 stood stand VBD 40436 2742 70 single single JJ 40436 2742 71 , , , 40436 2742 72 no no DT 40436 2742 73 modern modern JJ 40436 2742 74 critic critic NN 40436 2742 75 could could MD 40436 2742 76 fairly fairly RB 40436 2742 77 pretend pretend VB 40436 2742 78 to to TO 40436 2742 79 be be VB 40436 2742 80 so so RB 40436 2742 81 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 2742 82 acquainted acquaint VBN 40436 2742 83 with with IN 40436 2742 84 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2742 85 's 's POS 40436 2742 86 views view NNS 40436 2742 87 and and CC 40436 2742 88 the the DT 40436 2742 89 surrounding surround VBG 40436 2742 90 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 2742 91 , , , 40436 2742 92 as as IN 40436 2742 93 to to TO 40436 2742 94 put put VB 40436 2742 95 a a DT 40436 2742 96 limit limit NN 40436 2742 97 on on IN 40436 2742 98 the the DT 40436 2742 99 means mean NNS 40436 2742 100 which which WDT 40436 2742 101 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2742 102 might may MD 40436 2742 103 choose choose VB 40436 2742 104 to to TO 40436 2742 105 take take VB 40436 2742 106 , , , 40436 2742 107 for for IN 40436 2742 108 rendering render VBG 40436 2742 109 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2742 110 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2742 111 acceptable acceptable JJ 40436 2742 112 and and CC 40436 2742 113 interesting interesting JJ 40436 2742 114 . . . 40436 2743 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2743 2 's 's POS 40436 2743 3 political political JJ 40436 2743 4 views view NNS 40436 2743 5 made make VBD 40436 2743 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2743 7 disinclined disinclined JJ 40436 2743 8 to to IN 40436 2743 9 popular popular JJ 40436 2743 10 government government NN 40436 2743 11 generally generally RB 40436 2743 12 , , , 40436 2743 13 and and CC 40436 2743 14 to to IN 40436 2743 15 the the DT 40436 2743 16 democracy democracy NN 40436 2743 17 of of IN 40436 2743 18 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2743 19 in in IN 40436 2743 20 particular particular JJ 40436 2743 21 . . . 40436 2744 1 Conformably conformably RB 40436 2744 2 with with IN 40436 2744 3 such such JJ 40436 2744 4 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2744 5 , , , 40436 2744 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2744 7 is be VBZ 40436 2744 8 disposed dispose VBN 40436 2744 9 to to TO 40436 2744 10 surround surround VB 40436 2744 11 the the DT 40436 2744 12 rule rule NN 40436 2744 13 of of IN 40436 2744 14 the the DT 40436 2744 15 Peisistratidæ Peisistratidæ NNP 40436 2744 16 with with IN 40436 2744 17 an an DT 40436 2744 18 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2744 19 and and CC 40436 2744 20 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 2744 21 colouring colouring NN 40436 2744 22 : : : 40436 2744 23 to to TO 40436 2744 24 depict depict VB 40436 2744 25 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2744 26 as as IN 40436 2744 27 a a DT 40436 2744 28 wise wise JJ 40436 2744 29 man man NN 40436 2744 30 busied busy VBN 40436 2744 31 in in IN 40436 2744 32 instructing instruct VBG 40436 2744 33 and and CC 40436 2744 34 elevating elevate VBG 40436 2744 35 the the DT 40436 2744 36 citizens citizen NNS 40436 2744 37 ; ; : 40436 2744 38 and and CC 40436 2744 39 to to TO 40436 2744 40 discredit discredit VB 40436 2744 41 the the DT 40436 2744 42 renown renown NN 40436 2744 43 of of IN 40436 2744 44 Harmodius Harmodius NNP 40436 2744 45 and and CC 40436 2744 46 Aristogeiton Aristogeiton NNP 40436 2744 47 , , , 40436 2744 48 by by IN 40436 2744 49 affirming affirm VBG 40436 2744 50 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2744 51 to to TO 40436 2744 52 have have VB 40436 2744 53 been be VBN 40436 2744 54 envious envious JJ 40436 2744 55 of of IN 40436 2744 56 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2744 57 , , , 40436 2744 58 as as IN 40436 2744 59 a a DT 40436 2744 60 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 2744 61 who who WP 40436 2744 62 surpassed surpass VBD 40436 2744 63 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 2744 64 by by IN 40436 2744 65 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2744 66 own own JJ 40436 2744 67 mental mental JJ 40436 2744 68 worth worth NN 40436 2744 69 . . . 40436 2745 1 All all DT 40436 2745 2 this this DT 40436 2745 3 lay lie VBD 40436 2745 4 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 2745 5 in in IN 40436 2745 6 the the DT 40436 2745 7 vein vein NN 40436 2745 8 of of IN 40436 2745 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2745 10 's 's POS 40436 2745 11 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2745 12 ; ; : 40436 2745 13 and and CC 40436 2745 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2745 15 may may MD 40436 2745 16 say say VB 40436 2745 17 the the DT 40436 2745 18 same same JJ 40436 2745 19 about about IN 40436 2745 20 the the DT 40436 2745 21 narrative narrative NN 40436 2745 22 in in IN 40436 2745 23 the the DT 40436 2745 24 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2745 25 , , , 40436 2745 26 respecting respect VBG 40436 2745 27 the the DT 40436 2745 28 divine divine JJ 40436 2745 29 parentage parentage NN 40436 2745 30 and and CC 40436 2745 31 teaching teaching NN 40436 2745 32 of of IN 40436 2745 33 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2745 34 , , , 40436 2745 35 giving give VBG 40436 2745 36 rise rise NN 40436 2745 37 to to IN 40436 2745 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2745 39 superhuman superhuman JJ 40436 2745 40 efficacy efficacy NN 40436 2745 41 as as IN 40436 2745 42 a a DT 40436 2745 43 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2745 44 and and CC 40436 2745 45 ruler ruler NN 40436 2745 46 . . . 40436 2746 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2746 2 is be VBZ 40436 2746 3 surely surely RB 40436 2746 4 very very RB 40436 2746 5 conceivable conceivable JJ 40436 2746 6 , , , 40436 2746 7 that that IN 40436 2746 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2746 9 , , , 40436 2746 10 as as IN 40436 2746 11 a a DT 40436 2746 12 composer composer NN 40436 2746 13 of of IN 40436 2746 14 ethical ethical JJ 40436 2746 15 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2746 16 or or CC 40436 2746 17 dramas drama NNS 40436 2746 18 , , , 40436 2746 19 might may MD 40436 2746 20 think think VB 40436 2746 21 that that IN 40436 2746 22 such such JJ 40436 2746 23 recitals recital NNS 40436 2746 24 lent lend VBD 40436 2746 25 a a DT 40436 2746 26 charm charm NN 40436 2746 27 or or CC 40436 2746 28 interest interest NN 40436 2746 29 to to IN 40436 2746 30 some some DT 40436 2746 31 of of IN 40436 2746 32 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2746 33 . . . 40436 2747 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 2747 2 , , , 40436 2747 3 something something NN 40436 2747 4 like like IN 40436 2747 5 variety variety NN 40436 2747 6 , , , 40436 2747 7 or or CC 40436 2747 8 distinctive distinctive JJ 40436 2747 9 features feature NNS 40436 2747 10 as as IN 40436 2747 11 between between IN 40436 2747 12 one one CD 40436 2747 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2747 14 and and CC 40436 2747 15 another another DT 40436 2747 16 , , , 40436 2747 17 was be VBD 40436 2747 18 a a DT 40436 2747 19 point point NN 40436 2747 20 of of IN 40436 2747 21 no no DT 40436 2747 22 inconsiderable inconsiderable JJ 40436 2747 23 moment moment NN 40436 2747 24 . . . 40436 2748 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2748 2 am be VBP 40436 2748 3 of of IN 40436 2748 4 opinion opinion NN 40436 2748 5 that that IN 40436 2748 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2748 7 did do VBD 40436 2748 8 so so RB 40436 2748 9 conceive conceive VB 40436 2748 10 these these DT 40436 2748 11 narratives narrative NNS 40436 2748 12 . . . 40436 2749 1 But but CC 40436 2749 2 at at IN 40436 2749 3 any any DT 40436 2749 4 rate rate NN 40436 2749 5 , , , 40436 2749 6 what what WP 40436 2749 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2749 8 here here RB 40436 2749 9 contend contend VBP 40436 2749 10 is be VBZ 40436 2749 11 , , , 40436 2749 12 that that IN 40436 2749 13 no no DT 40436 2749 14 modern modern JJ 40436 2749 15 critics critic NNS 40436 2749 16 have have VBP 40436 2749 17 a a DT 40436 2749 18 right right NN 40436 2749 19 to to TO 40436 2749 20 assume assume VB 40436 2749 21 as as IN 40436 2749 22 certain certain JJ 40436 2749 23 that that IN 40436 2749 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2749 25 did do VBD 40436 2749 26 not not RB 40436 2749 27 . . . 40436 2750 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2750 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2750 3 33 33 CD 40436 2750 4 : : : 40436 2750 5 See see VB 40436 2750 6 Alkibiad Alkibiad NNP 40436 2750 7 . . . 40436 2751 1 ii ii LS 40436 2751 2 . . . 40436 2752 1 pp pp NNP 40436 2752 2 . . . 40436 2753 1 142 142 CD 40436 2753 2 - - HYPH 40436 2753 3 149 149 CD 40436 2753 4 - - HYPH 40436 2753 5 150 150 CD 40436 2753 6 ; ; : 40436 2753 7 Alkibiad Alkibiad NNP 40436 2753 8 . . . 40436 2754 1 i. i. NNP 40436 2754 2 pp pp NNP 40436 2754 3 . . . 40436 2755 1 121 121 CD 40436 2755 2 - - SYM 40436 2755 3 122 122 CD 40436 2755 4 : : : 40436 2755 5 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2755 6 , , , 40436 2755 7 342 342 CD 40436 2755 8 - - SYM 40436 2755 9 344 344 CD 40436 2755 10 ; ; : 40436 2755 11 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2755 12 , , , 40436 2755 13 268 268 CD 40436 2755 14 D. D. NNP 40436 2755 15 , , , 40436 2755 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2755 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2755 18 : : : 40436 2755 19 schedo\n schedo\n ADD 40436 2755 20 paidia\n paidia\n CD 40436 2755 21 e)gkerasame e)gkerasame , 40436 2755 22 / / SYM 40436 2755 23 nous nous JJ 40436 2755 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2755 25 and and CC 40436 2755 26 the the DT 40436 2755 27 two two CD 40436 2755 28 or or CC 40436 2755 29 three three CD 40436 2755 30 pages page NNS 40436 2755 31 which which WDT 40436 2755 32 follow follow VBP 40436 2755 33 . . . 40436 2756 1 F. F. NNP 40436 2756 2 A. a. NN 40436 2756 3 Wolf Wolf NNP 40436 2756 4 , , , 40436 2756 5 and and CC 40436 2756 6 various various JJ 40436 2756 7 critics critic NNS 40436 2756 8 after after IN 40436 2756 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2756 10 , , , 40436 2756 11 contend contend VBP 40436 2756 12 that that IN 40436 2756 13 the the DT 40436 2756 14 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 2756 15 of of IN 40436 2756 16 the the DT 40436 2756 17 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2756 18 was be VBD 40436 2756 19 doubted doubt VBN 40436 2756 20 in in IN 40436 2756 21 antiquity antiquity NN 40436 2756 22 , , , 40436 2756 23 on on IN 40436 2756 24 the the DT 40436 2756 25 authority authority NN 40436 2756 26 of of IN 40436 2756 27 Ælian Ælian NNP 40436 2756 28 , , , 40436 2756 29 V. V. NNP 40436 2756 30 H. H. NNP 40436 2756 31 viii viii NN 40436 2756 32 . . . 40436 2757 1 2 2 LS 40436 2757 2 . . . 40436 2758 1 But but CC 40436 2758 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2758 3 maintain maintain VBP 40436 2758 4 that that IN 40436 2758 5 this this DT 40436 2758 6 is be VBZ 40436 2758 7 not not RB 40436 2758 8 the the DT 40436 2758 9 meaning meaning NN 40436 2758 10 of of IN 40436 2758 11 the the DT 40436 2758 12 passage passage NN 40436 2758 13 , , , 40436 2758 14 unless unless IN 40436 2758 15 upon upon IN 40436 2758 16 the the DT 40436 2758 17 supposition supposition NN 40436 2758 18 that that IN 40436 2758 19 the the DT 40436 2758 20 word word NN 40436 2758 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2758 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2758 23 : : : 40436 2758 24 mathêtê\s mathêtê\s ADD 40436 2758 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2758 26 is be VBZ 40436 2758 27 struck strike VBN 40436 2758 28 out out IN 40436 2758 29 of of IN 40436 2758 30 the the DT 40436 2758 31 text text NN 40436 2758 32 conjecturally conjecturally RB 40436 2758 33 . . . 40436 2759 1 The the DT 40436 2759 2 passage passage NN 40436 2759 3 may may MD 40436 2759 4 be be VB 40436 2759 5 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 2759 6 well well RB 40436 2759 7 construed construed JJ 40436 2759 8 , , , 40436 2759 9 leaving leave VBG 40436 2759 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2759 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2759 12 : : : 40436 2759 13 mathêtê\s mathêtê\s ADD 40436 2759 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2759 15 in in IN 40436 2759 16 the the DT 40436 2759 17 text text NN 40436 2759 18 : : : 40436 2759 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2759 20 must must MD 40436 2759 21 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 2759 22 suppose suppose VB 40436 2759 23 the the DT 40436 2759 24 author author NN 40436 2759 25 to to TO 40436 2759 26 have have VB 40436 2759 27 made make VBN 40436 2759 28 an an DT 40436 2759 29 assertion assertion NN 40436 2759 30 historically historically RB 40436 2759 31 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 2759 32 : : : 40436 2759 33 but but CC 40436 2759 34 this this DT 40436 2759 35 is be VBZ 40436 2759 36 nowise nowise NN 40436 2759 37 impossible impossible JJ 40436 2759 38 in in IN 40436 2759 39 the the DT 40436 2759 40 case case NN 40436 2759 41 of of IN 40436 2759 42 Ælian Ælian NNP 40436 2759 43 . . . 40436 2760 1 If if IN 40436 2760 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2760 3 construe construe VBP 40436 2760 4 the the DT 40436 2760 5 passage passage NN 40436 2760 6 as as IN 40436 2760 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2760 8 stands stand VBZ 40436 2760 9 , , , 40436 2760 10 without without IN 40436 2760 11 such such JJ 40436 2760 12 conjectural conjectural JJ 40436 2760 13 alteration alteration NN 40436 2760 14 , , , 40436 2760 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2760 16 does do VBZ 40436 2760 17 not not RB 40436 2760 18 justify justify VB 40436 2760 19 Wolf Wolf NNP 40436 2760 20 's 's POS 40436 2760 21 inference inference NN 40436 2760 22 . . . 40436 2760 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2761 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2761 2 Side side NN 40436 2761 3 - - HYPH 40436 2761 4 note note NN 40436 2761 5 : : : 40436 2761 6 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2761 7 . . . 40436 2762 1 Question question NN 40436 2762 2 -- -- : 40436 2762 3 What what WP 40436 2762 4 is be VBZ 40436 2762 5 the the DT 40436 2762 6 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 2762 7 property property NN 40436 2762 8 connoted connote VBN 40436 2762 9 by by IN 40436 2762 10 the the DT 40436 2762 11 word word NN 40436 2762 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2762 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2762 14 : : : 40436 2762 15 No no UH 40436 2762 16 / / SYM 40436 2762 17 mos mos NN 40436 2762 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2762 19 or or CC 40436 2762 20 law law NN 40436 2762 21 ? ? . 40436 2762 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2763 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2763 2 now now RB 40436 2763 3 come come VBP 40436 2763 4 to to IN 40436 2763 5 the the DT 40436 2763 6 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2763 7 . . . 40436 2764 1 The the DT 40436 2764 2 subject subject NN 40436 2764 3 of of IN 40436 2764 4 this this DT 40436 2764 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2764 6 is be VBZ 40436 2764 7 , , , 40436 2764 8 the the DT 40436 2764 9 explanation explanation NN 40436 2764 10 or or CC 40436 2764 11 definition definition NN 40436 2764 12 of of IN 40436 2764 13 Law Law NNP 40436 2764 14 . . . 40436 2765 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2765 2 says say VBZ 40436 2765 3 to to IN 40436 2765 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2765 5 Companion companion NN 40436 2765 6 or or CC 40436 2765 7 Collocutor,--Tell collocutor,--tell VB 40436 2765 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2765 9 what what WP 40436 2765 10 is be VBZ 40436 2765 11 the the DT 40436 2765 12 generic generic JJ 40436 2765 13 constituent constituent NN 40436 2765 14 of of IN 40436 2765 15 Law Law NNP 40436 2765 16 : : : 40436 2765 17 All all DT 40436 2765 18 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 2765 19 are be VBP 40436 2765 20 alike alike RB 40436 2765 21 _ _ NNP 40436 2765 22 quatenus quatenus NN 40436 2765 23 _ _ NNP 40436 2765 24 Law Law NNP 40436 2765 25 . . . 40436 2766 1 Take take VB 40436 2766 2 no no DT 40436 2766 3 note note NN 40436 2766 4 of of IN 40436 2766 5 the the DT 40436 2766 6 difference difference NN 40436 2766 7 between between IN 40436 2766 8 one one CD 40436 2766 9 law law NN 40436 2766 10 and and CC 40436 2766 11 another another DT 40436 2766 12 , , , 40436 2766 13 but but CC 40436 2766 14 explain explain VB 40436 2766 15 to to IN 40436 2766 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2766 17 what what WP 40436 2766 18 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 2766 19 property property NN 40436 2766 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2766 21 is be VBZ 40436 2766 22 , , , 40436 2766 23 which which WDT 40436 2766 24 is be VBZ 40436 2766 25 common common JJ 40436 2766 26 to to IN 40436 2766 27 all all DT 40436 2766 28 Law Law NNP 40436 2766 29 , , , 40436 2766 30 and and CC 40436 2766 31 is be VBZ 40436 2766 32 implied imply VBN 40436 2766 33 in in IN 40436 2766 34 or or CC 40436 2766 35 connoted connote VBN 40436 2766 36 by by IN 40436 2766 37 the the DT 40436 2766 38 name name NN 40436 2766 39 Law Law NNP 40436 2766 40 . . . 40436 2767 1 This this DT 40436 2767 2 question question NN 40436 2767 3 is be VBZ 40436 2767 4 logically logically RB 40436 2767 5 the the DT 40436 2767 6 same same JJ 40436 2767 7 as as IN 40436 2767 8 that that DT 40436 2767 9 which which WDT 40436 2767 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2767 11 asks ask VBZ 40436 2767 12 in in IN 40436 2767 13 the the DT 40436 2767 14 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2767 15 with with IN 40436 2767 16 reference reference NN 40436 2767 17 to to IN 40436 2767 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2767 19 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2767 20 : : : 40436 2767 21 ke ke NNP 40436 2767 22 / / SYM 40436 2767 23 rdos rdos NNP 40436 2767 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2767 25 or or CC 40436 2767 26 gain gain VB 40436 2767 27 . . . 40436 2768 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2768 2 Side side NN 40436 2768 3 - - HYPH 40436 2768 4 note note NN 40436 2768 5 : : : 40436 2768 6 This this DT 40436 2768 7 question question NN 40436 2768 8 was be VBD 40436 2768 9 discussed discuss VBN 40436 2768 10 by by IN 40436 2768 11 the the DT 40436 2768 12 historical historical JJ 40436 2768 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2768 14 , , , 40436 2768 15 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 2768 16 of of IN 40436 2768 17 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 2768 18 . . . 40436 2768 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2769 1 That that IN 40436 2769 2 the the DT 40436 2769 3 definition definition NN 40436 2769 4 of of IN 40436 2769 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2769 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2769 7 : : : 40436 2769 8 No no UH 40436 2769 9 / / SYM 40436 2769 10 mos mos NN 40436 2769 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2769 12 or or CC 40436 2769 13 Law Law NNP 40436 2769 14 was be VBD 40436 2769 15 discussed discuss VBN 40436 2769 16 by by IN 40436 2769 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2769 18 , , , 40436 2769 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2769 20 know know VBP 40436 2769 21 , , , 40436 2769 22 not not RB 40436 2769 23 only only RB 40436 2769 24 from from IN 40436 2769 25 the the DT 40436 2769 26 general general JJ 40436 2769 27 description description NN 40436 2769 28 of of IN 40436 2769 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2769 30 debates debate NNS 40436 2769 31 given give VBN 40436 2769 32 in in IN 40436 2769 33 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 2769 34 , , , 40436 2769 35 but but CC 40436 2769 36 also also RB 40436 2769 37 from from IN 40436 2769 38 the the DT 40436 2769 39 interesting interesting JJ 40436 2769 40 description description NN 40436 2769 41 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2769 42 in in IN 40436 2769 43 that that DT 40436 2769 44 author author NN 40436 2769 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2769 46 of of IN 40436 2769 47 the the DT 40436 2769 48 conversation conversation NN 40436 2769 49 between between IN 40436 2769 50 the the DT 40436 2769 51 youthful youthful JJ 40436 2769 52 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 2769 53 and and CC 40436 2769 54 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 2769 55 . . . 40436 2770 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2770 2 34 34 CD 40436 2770 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2770 4 The the DT 40436 2770 5 interrogations interrogation NNS 40436 2770 6 employed employ VBN 40436 2770 7 by by IN 40436 2770 8 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 2770 9 on on IN 40436 2770 10 that that DT 40436 2770 11 occasion occasion NN 40436 2770 12 are be VBP 40436 2770 13 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 2770 14 , , , 40436 2770 15 and and CC 40436 2770 16 must must MD 40436 2770 17 have have VB 40436 2770 18 been be VBN 40436 2770 19 derived derive VBN 40436 2770 20 , , , 40436 2770 21 directly directly RB 40436 2770 22 or or CC 40436 2770 23 indirectly indirectly RB 40436 2770 24 , , , 40436 2770 25 from from IN 40436 2770 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2770 27 . . . 40436 2771 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 2771 2 are be VBP 40436 2771 3 partially partially RB 40436 2771 4 analogous analogous JJ 40436 2771 5 to to IN 40436 2771 6 the the DT 40436 2771 7 questions question NNS 40436 2771 8 of of IN 40436 2771 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2771 10 in in IN 40436 2771 11 the the DT 40436 2771 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2771 13 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2771 14 , , , 40436 2771 15 and and CC 40436 2771 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2771 17 end end VBP 40436 2771 18 by by IN 40436 2771 19 driving drive VBG 40436 2771 20 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 2771 21 into into IN 40436 2771 22 a a DT 40436 2771 23 confusion confusion NN 40436 2771 24 , , , 40436 2771 25 left leave VBD 40436 2771 26 unexplained unexplained JJ 40436 2771 27 , , , 40436 2771 28 between between IN 40436 2771 29 Law Law NNP 40436 2771 30 and and CC 40436 2771 31 Lawlessness Lawlessness NNP 40436 2771 32 . . . 40436 2772 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2772 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2772 3 34 34 CD 40436 2772 4 : : : 40436 2772 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 2772 6 . . . 40436 2773 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 2773 2 . . . 40436 2774 1 i. i. NNP 40436 2775 1 1 1 CD 40436 2775 2 , , , 40436 2775 3 16 16 CD 40436 2775 4 ; ; : 40436 2775 5 i. i. NNP 40436 2776 1 2 2 CD 40436 2776 2 , , , 40436 2776 3 42 42 CD 40436 2776 4 - - SYM 40436 2776 5 46 46 CD 40436 2776 6 . . . 40436 2776 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2777 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2777 2 Side side NN 40436 2777 3 - - HYPH 40436 2777 4 note note NN 40436 2777 5 : : : 40436 2777 6 Definitions definition NNS 40436 2777 7 of of IN 40436 2777 8 law law NN 40436 2777 9 -- -- : 40436 2777 10 suggested suggest VBN 40436 2777 11 and and CC 40436 2777 12 refuted refute VBN 40436 2777 13 . . . 40436 2778 1 Law Law NNP 40436 2778 2 includes include VBZ 40436 2778 3 , , , 40436 2778 4 as as IN 40436 2778 5 a a DT 40436 2778 6 portion portion NN 40436 2778 7 of of IN 40436 2778 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2778 9 meaning meaning NN 40436 2778 10 , , , 40436 2778 11 justice justice NN 40436 2778 12 , , , 40436 2778 13 goodness goodness NN 40436 2778 14 , , , 40436 2778 15 usefulness usefulness NNP 40436 2778 16 , , , 40436 2778 17 & & CC 40436 2778 18 c. c. NNP 40436 2778 19 Bad bad JJ 40436 2778 20 decrees decree NNS 40436 2778 21 are be VBP 40436 2778 22 not not RB 40436 2778 23 laws law NNS 40436 2778 24 . . . 40436 2778 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2779 1 Definitions definition NNS 40436 2779 2 of of IN 40436 2779 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2779 4 Greek greek JJ 40436 2779 5 : : : 40436 2779 6 No no UH 40436 2779 7 / / SYM 40436 2779 8 mos mos NN 40436 2779 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2779 10 are be VBP 40436 2779 11 here here RB 40436 2779 12 given give VBN 40436 2779 13 by by IN 40436 2779 14 the the DT 40436 2779 15 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2779 16 , , , 40436 2779 17 who who WP 40436 2779 18 undergoes undergo VBZ 40436 2779 19 a a DT 40436 2779 20 cross cross NN 40436 2779 21 - - NN 40436 2779 22 examination examination NN 40436 2779 23 upon upon IN 40436 2779 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2779 25 . . . 40436 2780 1 First first RB 40436 2780 2 , , , 40436 2780 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2780 4 says say VBZ 40436 2780 5 , , , 40436 2780 6 that that IN 40436 2780 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2780 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2780 9 : : : 40436 2780 10 No no UH 40436 2780 11 / / SYM 40436 2780 12 mos mo NNS 40436 2780 13 = = NFP 40436 2780 14 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 2780 15 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2780 16 / / SYM 40436 2780 17 mena mena NN 40436 2780 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2780 19 . . . 40436 2781 1 But but CC 40436 2781 2 this this DT 40436 2781 3 is be VBZ 40436 2781 4 rejected reject VBN 40436 2781 5 by by IN 40436 2781 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2781 7 , , , 40436 2781 8 who who WP 40436 2781 9 intimates intimate VBZ 40436 2781 10 that that IN 40436 2781 11 Law Law NNP 40436 2781 12 is be VBZ 40436 2781 13 not not RB 40436 2781 14 the the DT 40436 2781 15 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 2781 16 of of IN 40436 2781 17 laws law NNS 40436 2781 18 enacted enact VBN 40436 2781 19 or or CC 40436 2781 20 of of IN 40436 2781 21 customs custom NNS 40436 2781 22 held hold VBN 40436 2781 23 binding bind VBG 40436 2781 24 : : : 40436 2781 25 but but CC 40436 2781 26 that that DT 40436 2781 27 which which WDT 40436 2781 28 lies lie VBZ 40436 2781 29 behind behind IN 40436 2781 30 these these DT 40436 2781 31 laws law NNS 40436 2781 32 and and CC 40436 2781 33 customs custom NNS 40436 2781 34 , , , 40436 2781 35 imparting impart VBG 40436 2781 36 to to IN 40436 2781 37 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2781 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2781 39 binding bind VBG 40436 2781 40 force force NN 40436 2781 41 . . . 40436 2782 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2782 2 35 35 CD 40436 2782 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2782 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 2782 5 are be VBP 40436 2782 6 to to TO 40436 2782 7 enquire enquire VB 40436 2782 8 what what WP 40436 2782 9 this this DT 40436 2782 10 is be VBZ 40436 2782 11 . . . 40436 2783 1 The the DT 40436 2783 2 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2783 3 declares declare VBZ 40436 2783 4 that that IN 40436 2783 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2783 6 is be VBZ 40436 2783 7 the the DT 40436 2783 8 public public JJ 40436 2783 9 decree decree NN 40436 2783 10 of of IN 40436 2783 11 the the DT 40436 2783 12 city city NN 40436 2783 13 : : : 40436 2783 14 political political JJ 40436 2783 15 or or CC 40436 2783 16 social social JJ 40436 2783 17 opinion opinion NN 40436 2783 18 . . . 40436 2784 1 But but CC 40436 2784 2 this this DT 40436 2784 3 again again RB 40436 2784 4 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 2784 5 contests contest NNS 40436 2784 6 : : : 40436 2784 7 putting put VBG 40436 2784 8 questions question NNS 40436 2784 9 to to TO 40436 2784 10 show show VB 40436 2784 11 that that IN 40436 2784 12 Law Law NNP 40436 2784 13 includes include VBZ 40436 2784 14 , , , 40436 2784 15 as as IN 40436 2784 16 a a DT 40436 2784 17 portion portion NN 40436 2784 18 of of IN 40436 2784 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2784 20 meaning meaning NN 40436 2784 21 , , , 40436 2784 22 justice justice NN 40436 2784 23 , , , 40436 2784 24 goodness goodness NN 40436 2784 25 , , , 40436 2784 26 beauty beauty NN 40436 2784 27 , , , 40436 2784 28 and and CC 40436 2784 29 preservation preservation NN 40436 2784 30 of of IN 40436 2784 31 the the DT 40436 2784 32 city city NN 40436 2784 33 with with IN 40436 2784 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2784 35 possessions possession NNS 40436 2784 36 ; ; : 40436 2784 37 while while IN 40436 2784 38 lawlessness lawlessness NN 40436 2784 39 includes include VBZ 40436 2784 40 injustice injustice NN 40436 2784 41 , , , 40436 2784 42 evil evil JJ 40436 2784 43 , , , 40436 2784 44 ugliness ugliness JJ 40436 2784 45 , , , 40436 2784 46 and and CC 40436 2784 47 destruction destruction NN 40436 2784 48 . . . 40436 2785 1 There there EX 40436 2785 2 can can MD 40436 2785 3 be be VB 40436 2785 4 no no DT 40436 2785 5 such such JJ 40436 2785 6 thing thing NN 40436 2785 7 as as RB 40436 2785 8 bad bad JJ 40436 2785 9 or or CC 40436 2785 10 wicked wicked JJ 40436 2785 11 law law NN 40436 2785 12 . . . 40436 2786 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2786 2 36 36 CD 40436 2786 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2786 4 But but CC 40436 2786 5 among among IN 40436 2786 6 decrees decree NNS 40436 2786 7 of of IN 40436 2786 8 the the DT 40436 2786 9 city city NN 40436 2786 10 , , , 40436 2786 11 some some DT 40436 2786 12 are be VBP 40436 2786 13 bad bad JJ 40436 2786 14 , , , 40436 2786 15 some some DT 40436 2786 16 are be VBP 40436 2786 17 good good JJ 40436 2786 18 . . . 40436 2787 1 Therefore therefore RB 40436 2787 2 to to TO 40436 2787 3 define define VB 40436 2787 4 Law Law NNP 40436 2787 5 as as IN 40436 2787 6 a a DT 40436 2787 7 decree decree NN 40436 2787 8 of of IN 40436 2787 9 the the DT 40436 2787 10 city city NN 40436 2787 11 , , , 40436 2787 12 thus thus RB 40436 2787 13 generally generally RB 40436 2787 14 , , , 40436 2787 15 is be VBZ 40436 2787 16 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 2787 17 . . . 40436 2788 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2788 2 is be VBZ 40436 2788 3 only only RB 40436 2788 4 the the DT 40436 2788 5 good good JJ 40436 2788 6 decree decree NN 40436 2788 7 , , , 40436 2788 8 not not RB 40436 2788 9 the the DT 40436 2788 10 bad bad JJ 40436 2788 11 decree decree NN 40436 2788 12 , , , 40436 2788 13 which which WDT 40436 2788 14 is be VBZ 40436 2788 15 Law Law NNP 40436 2788 16 . . . 40436 2789 1 Now now RB 40436 2789 2 the the DT 40436 2789 3 good good JJ 40436 2789 4 decree decree NN 40436 2789 5 or or CC 40436 2789 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 2789 7 , , , 40436 2789 8 is be VBZ 40436 2789 9 the the DT 40436 2789 10 true true JJ 40436 2789 11 opinion opinion NN 40436 2789 12 : : : 40436 2789 13 that that RB 40436 2789 14 is is RB 40436 2789 15 , , , 40436 2789 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2789 17 is be VBZ 40436 2789 18 the the DT 40436 2789 19 finding finding NN 40436 2789 20 out out IN 40436 2789 21 of of IN 40436 2789 22 reality reality NN 40436 2789 23 . . . 40436 2790 1 Law law NN 40436 2790 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 2790 3 wishes wish VBZ 40436 2790 4 or or CC 40436 2790 5 aims aim VBZ 40436 2790 6 to to TO 40436 2790 7 be be VB 40436 2790 8 the the DT 40436 2790 9 finding finding NN 40436 2790 10 out out IN 40436 2790 11 of of IN 40436 2790 12 reality reality NN 40436 2790 13 : : : 40436 2790 14 and and CC 40436 2790 15 if if IN 40436 2790 16 there there EX 40436 2790 17 are be VBP 40436 2790 18 differences difference NNS 40436 2790 19 between between IN 40436 2790 20 different different JJ 40436 2790 21 nations nation NNS 40436 2790 22 , , , 40436 2790 23 this this DT 40436 2790 24 is be VBZ 40436 2790 25 because because IN 40436 2790 26 the the DT 40436 2790 27 power power NN 40436 2790 28 to to TO 40436 2790 29 find find VB 40436 2790 30 out out RP 40436 2790 31 does do VBZ 40436 2790 32 not not RB 40436 2790 33 always always RB 40436 2790 34 accompany accompany VB 40436 2790 35 the the DT 40436 2790 36 wish wish NN 40436 2790 37 to to TO 40436 2790 38 find find VB 40436 2790 39 out out RP 40436 2790 40 . . . 40436 2791 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2791 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2791 3 35 35 CD 40436 2791 4 : : : 40436 2791 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2791 6 , , , 40436 2791 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2791 8 , , , 40436 2791 9 314 314 CD 40436 2791 10 A. a. NN 40436 2792 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2792 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2792 3 : : : 40436 2792 4 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ NN 40436 2792 5 no no UH 40436 2792 6 / / SYM 40436 2792 7 mô| mô| NNP 40436 2792 8 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 2792 9 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2792 10 / / SYM 40436 2792 11 mena mena NNP 40436 2792 12 nomi nomi NNP 40436 2792 13 / / SYM 40436 2792 14 zetai zetai NNP 40436 2792 15 , , , 40436 2792 16 ti ti NNP 40436 2792 17 / / SYM 40436 2792 18 ni ni NNP 40436 2792 19 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 2792 20 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 2792 21 no no UH 40436 2792 22 / / SYM 40436 2792 23 mô| mô| NNP 40436 2792 24 nomi nomi NN 40436 2792 25 / / SYM 40436 2792 26 zetai zetai NN 40436 2792 27 ? ? . 40436 2792 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2792 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2793 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2793 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 2793 3 36 36 CD 40436 2793 4 : : : 40436 2793 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2793 6 , , , 40436 2793 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2793 8 , , , 40436 2793 9 314 314 CD 40436 2793 10 E. E. NNP 40436 2793 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2793 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2793 13 : : : 40436 2793 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2793 15 mê\n mê\n NNP 40436 2793 16 no no NNP 40436 2793 17 / / SYM 40436 2793 18 mos mos NNP 40436 2793 19 ge ge NNP 40436 2793 20 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 2793 21 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 2793 22 ponêro ponêro NNP 40436 2793 23 / / SYM 40436 2793 24 s s NNP 40436 2793 25 . . . 40436 2793 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2793 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2794 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2794 2 Side side NN 40436 2794 3 - - HYPH 40436 2794 4 note note NN 40436 2794 5 : : : 40436 2794 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2794 7 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 2794 8 that that DT 40436 2794 9 law law NN 40436 2794 10 is be VBZ 40436 2794 11 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2794 12 the the DT 40436 2794 13 same same JJ 40436 2794 14 -- -- : 40436 2794 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2794 16 is be VBZ 40436 2794 17 the the DT 40436 2794 18 declared declared JJ 40436 2794 19 judgment judgment NN 40436 2794 20 and and CC 40436 2794 21 command command NN 40436 2794 22 of of IN 40436 2794 23 the the DT 40436 2794 24 Wise wise JJ 40436 2794 25 man man NN 40436 2794 26 upon upon IN 40436 2794 27 the the DT 40436 2794 28 subject subject NN 40436 2794 29 to to IN 40436 2794 30 which which WDT 40436 2794 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2794 32 refers refer VBZ 40436 2794 33 -- -- : 40436 2794 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2794 35 is be VBZ 40436 2794 36 truth truth NN 40436 2794 37 and and CC 40436 2794 38 reality reality NN 40436 2794 39 , , , 40436 2794 40 found find VBD 40436 2794 41 out out RP 40436 2794 42 and and CC 40436 2794 43 certified certify VBN 40436 2794 44 by by IN 40436 2794 45 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2794 46 . . . 40436 2794 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2795 1 As as IN 40436 2795 2 to to IN 40436 2795 3 the the DT 40436 2795 4 assertion assertion NN 40436 2795 5 -- -- : 40436 2795 6 that that IN 40436 2795 7 Law Law NNP 40436 2795 8 is be VBZ 40436 2795 9 one one CD 40436 2795 10 thing thing NN 40436 2795 11 here here RB 40436 2795 12 , , , 40436 2795 13 another another DT 40436 2795 14 thing thing NN 40436 2795 15 there there RB 40436 2795 16 , , , 40436 2795 17 one one CD 40436 2795 18 thing thing NN 40436 2795 19 at at IN 40436 2795 20 one one CD 40436 2795 21 time time NN 40436 2795 22 , , , 40436 2795 23 another another DT 40436 2795 24 thing thing NN 40436 2795 25 at at IN 40436 2795 26 another another DT 40436 2795 27 -- -- : 40436 2795 28 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2795 29 contests contest NNS 40436 2795 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2795 31 . . . 40436 2796 1 Just just RB 40436 2796 2 things thing NNS 40436 2796 3 are be VBP 40436 2796 4 just just RB 40436 2796 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2796 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2796 7 says say VBZ 40436 2796 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2796 9 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2796 10 and and CC 40436 2796 11 at at IN 40436 2796 12 all all DT 40436 2796 13 times time NNS 40436 2796 14 ; ; : 40436 2796 15 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2796 16 things thing NNS 40436 2796 17 are be VBP 40436 2796 18 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2796 19 also also RB 40436 2796 20 . . . 40436 2797 1 Heavy heavy JJ 40436 2797 2 things thing NNS 40436 2797 3 are be VBP 40436 2797 4 heavy heavy JJ 40436 2797 5 , , , 40436 2797 6 light light JJ 40436 2797 7 things thing NNS 40436 2797 8 light light JJ 40436 2797 9 , , , 40436 2797 10 at at IN 40436 2797 11 one one CD 40436 2797 12 time time NN 40436 2797 13 , , , 40436 2797 14 as as RB 40436 2797 15 well well RB 40436 2797 16 as as IN 40436 2797 17 at at IN 40436 2797 18 another another DT 40436 2797 19 . . . 40436 2798 1 So so RB 40436 2798 2 also also RB 40436 2798 3 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2798 4 things thing NNS 40436 2798 5 are be VBP 40436 2798 6 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2798 7 honourable honourable JJ 40436 2798 8 , , , 40436 2798 9 base base JJ 40436 2798 10 things thing NNS 40436 2798 11 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2798 12 base base NN 40436 2798 13 . . . 40436 2799 1 In in IN 40436 2799 2 general general JJ 40436 2799 3 phrase phrase NN 40436 2799 4 , , , 40436 2799 5 existent existent NN 40436 2799 6 things thing NNS 40436 2799 7 are be VBP 40436 2799 8 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2799 9 existent,[37 existent,[37 NN 40436 2799 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2799 11 non non JJ 40436 2799 12 - - JJ 40436 2799 13 existent existent JJ 40436 2799 14 things thing NNS 40436 2799 15 are be VBP 40436 2799 16 not not RB 40436 2799 17 existent existent NN 40436 2799 18 . . . 40436 2800 1 Whoever whoever WP 40436 2800 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 2800 3 fails fail VBZ 40436 2800 4 to to TO 40436 2800 5 attain attain VB 40436 2800 6 the the DT 40436 2800 7 existent existent NN 40436 2800 8 and and CC 40436 2800 9 real real JJ 40436 2800 10 , , , 40436 2800 11 fails fail VBZ 40436 2800 12 to to TO 40436 2800 13 attain attain VB 40436 2800 14 the the DT 40436 2800 15 lawful lawful JJ 40436 2800 16 and and CC 40436 2800 17 just just RB 40436 2800 18 . . . 40436 2801 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2801 2 is be VBZ 40436 2801 3 only only RB 40436 2801 4 the the DT 40436 2801 5 man man NN 40436 2801 6 of of IN 40436 2801 7 art art NN 40436 2801 8 and and CC 40436 2801 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2801 10 , , , 40436 2801 11 in in IN 40436 2801 12 this this DT 40436 2801 13 or or CC 40436 2801 14 that that DT 40436 2801 15 department department NN 40436 2801 16 , , , 40436 2801 17 who who WP 40436 2801 18 attains attain VBZ 40436 2801 19 the the DT 40436 2801 20 existent existent NN 40436 2801 21 , , , 40436 2801 22 the the DT 40436 2801 23 real real JJ 40436 2801 24 , , , 40436 2801 25 the the DT 40436 2801 26 right right JJ 40436 2801 27 , , , 40436 2801 28 true true JJ 40436 2801 29 , , , 40436 2801 30 lawful lawful JJ 40436 2801 31 , , , 40436 2801 32 just just RB 40436 2801 33 . . . 40436 2802 1 Thus thus RB 40436 2802 2 the the DT 40436 2802 3 authoritative authoritative JJ 40436 2802 4 rescripts rescript NNS 40436 2802 5 or or CC 40436 2802 6 laws law NNS 40436 2802 7 in in IN 40436 2802 8 matters matter NNS 40436 2802 9 of of IN 40436 2802 10 medicine medicine NN 40436 2802 11 , , , 40436 2802 12 are be VBP 40436 2802 13 those those DT 40436 2802 14 laid lay VBN 40436 2802 15 down down RP 40436 2802 16 by by IN 40436 2802 17 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 2802 18 who who WP 40436 2802 19 know know VBP 40436 2802 20 that that DT 40436 2802 21 subject subject NN 40436 2802 22 , , , 40436 2802 23 all all DT 40436 2802 24 of of IN 40436 2802 25 whom whom WP 40436 2802 26 agree agree VBP 40436 2802 27 in in IN 40436 2802 28 what what WP 40436 2802 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2802 30 lay lay VBP 40436 2802 31 down down RP 40436 2802 32 : : : 40436 2802 33 the the DT 40436 2802 34 laws law NNS 40436 2802 35 of of IN 40436 2802 36 cookery cookery NN 40436 2802 37 , , , 40436 2802 38 the the DT 40436 2802 39 laws law NNS 40436 2802 40 of of IN 40436 2802 41 agriculture agriculture NN 40436 2802 42 and and CC 40436 2802 43 of of IN 40436 2802 44 gardening gardening NN 40436 2802 45 -- -- : 40436 2802 46 are be VBP 40436 2802 47 rescripts rescript NNS 40436 2802 48 delivered deliver VBN 40436 2802 49 by by IN 40436 2802 50 artists artist NNS 40436 2802 51 who who WP 40436 2802 52 know know VBP 40436 2802 53 respectively respectively RB 40436 2802 54 each each DT 40436 2802 55 of of IN 40436 2802 56 those those DT 40436 2802 57 subjects subject NNS 40436 2802 58 . . . 40436 2803 1 So so RB 40436 2803 2 also also RB 40436 2803 3 about about IN 40436 2803 4 Just Just NNP 40436 2803 5 and and CC 40436 2803 6 Unjust Unjust NNP 40436 2803 7 , , , 40436 2803 8 about about IN 40436 2803 9 the the DT 40436 2803 10 political political JJ 40436 2803 11 and and CC 40436 2803 12 social social JJ 40436 2803 13 arrangements arrangement NNS 40436 2803 14 of of IN 40436 2803 15 the the DT 40436 2803 16 city city NN 40436 2803 17 -- -- : 40436 2803 18 the the DT 40436 2803 19 authoritative authoritative JJ 40436 2803 20 rescripts rescript NNS 40436 2803 21 or or CC 40436 2803 22 laws law NNS 40436 2803 23 are be VBP 40436 2803 24 , , , 40436 2803 25 those those DT 40436 2803 26 laid lay VBN 40436 2803 27 down down RP 40436 2803 28 by by IN 40436 2803 29 the the DT 40436 2803 30 artists artist NNS 40436 2803 31 or or CC 40436 2803 32 men man NNS 40436 2803 33 of of IN 40436 2803 34 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2803 35 in in IN 40436 2803 36 that that DT 40436 2803 37 department department NN 40436 2803 38 , , , 40436 2803 39 all all DT 40436 2803 40 of of IN 40436 2803 41 whom whom WP 40436 2803 42 agree agree VBP 40436 2803 43 in in IN 40436 2803 44 laying lay VBG 40436 2803 45 down down RP 40436 2803 46 the the DT 40436 2803 47 same same JJ 40436 2803 48 : : : 40436 2803 49 that that RB 40436 2803 50 is is RB 40436 2803 51 , , , 40436 2803 52 all all PDT 40436 2803 53 the the DT 40436 2803 54 men man NNS 40436 2803 55 of of IN 40436 2803 56 art art NN 40436 2803 57 called call VBN 40436 2803 58 kings king NNS 40436 2803 59 or or CC 40436 2803 60 lawgivers lawgiver NNS 40436 2803 61 . . . 40436 2804 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2804 2 is be VBZ 40436 2804 3 only only RB 40436 2804 4 the the DT 40436 2804 5 right right NN 40436 2804 6 , , , 40436 2804 7 the the DT 40436 2804 8 true true JJ 40436 2804 9 , , , 40436 2804 10 the the DT 40436 2804 11 real real JJ 40436 2804 12 -- -- : 40436 2804 13 that that IN 40436 2804 14 which which WDT 40436 2804 15 these these DT 40436 2804 16 artists artist NNS 40436 2804 17 attain attain VBP 40436 2804 18 -- -- : 40436 2804 19 which which WDT 40436 2804 20 is be VBZ 40436 2804 21 properly properly RB 40436 2804 22 a a DT 40436 2804 23 law law NN 40436 2804 24 and and CC 40436 2804 25 is be VBZ 40436 2804 26 entitled entitle VBN 40436 2804 27 to to TO 40436 2804 28 be be VB 40436 2804 29 so so RB 40436 2804 30 called call VBN 40436 2804 31 . . . 40436 2805 1 That that DT 40436 2805 2 which which WDT 40436 2805 3 is be VBZ 40436 2805 4 not not RB 40436 2805 5 right right JJ 40436 2805 6 is be VBZ 40436 2805 7 not not RB 40436 2805 8 a a DT 40436 2805 9 law,--ought law,--ought NN 40436 2805 10 not not RB 40436 2805 11 to to TO 40436 2805 12 be be VB 40436 2805 13 so so RB 40436 2805 14 called call VBN 40436 2805 15 -- -- : 40436 2805 16 and and CC 40436 2805 17 is be VBZ 40436 2805 18 only only RB 40436 2805 19 supposed suppose VBN 40436 2805 20 to to TO 40436 2805 21 be be VB 40436 2805 22 a a DT 40436 2805 23 law law NN 40436 2805 24 by by IN 40436 2805 25 the the DT 40436 2805 26 error error NN 40436 2805 27 of of IN 40436 2805 28 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2805 29 men man NNS 40436 2805 30 . . . 40436 2806 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2806 2 38 38 CD 40436 2806 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2806 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2806 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2806 6 37 37 CD 40436 2806 7 : : : 40436 2806 8 M. M. NNP 40436 2806 9 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2806 10 remarks remark VBZ 40436 2806 11 justly justly RB 40436 2806 12 in in IN 40436 2806 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2806 14 note note NN 40436 2806 15 on on IN 40436 2806 16 this this DT 40436 2806 17 passage--"neque passage--"neque : 40436 2806 18 enim enim NNP 40436 2806 19 illud illud NNP 40436 2806 20 demonstratum demonstratum NNP 40436 2806 21 est est NNP 40436 2806 22 , , , 40436 2806 23 eadem eadem NNP 40436 2806 24 omnibus omnibus NNP 40436 2806 25 legitima legitima NNP 40436 2806 26 esse esse NNP 40436 2806 27 -- -- : 40436 2806 28 sed se VBD 40436 2806 29 tantum tantum NNP 40436 2806 30 , , , 40436 2806 31 _ _ NNP 40436 2806 32 notionem notionem NN 40436 2806 33 _ _ NNP 40436 2806 34 " " '' 40436 2806 35 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2806 36 rather rather RB 40436 2806 37 the the DT 40436 2806 38 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 2806 39 or or CC 40436 2806 40 emotion emotion NN 40436 2806 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2806 42 " " '' 40436 2806 43 _ _ NNP 40436 2806 44 legitimi legitimi NNP 40436 2806 45 _ _ NNP 40436 2806 46 omnibus omnibus NNP 40436 2806 47 eandem eandem NNP 40436 2806 48 esse esse NNP 40436 2806 49 . . . 40436 2807 1 Sed Sed NNP 40436 2807 2 omnia omnia NNP 40436 2807 3 scriptor scriptor NN 40436 2807 4 hic hic NNP 40436 2807 5 confundit confundit NN 40436 2807 6 . . . 40436 2807 7 " " '' 40436 2807 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2808 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2808 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2808 3 38 38 CD 40436 2808 4 : : : 40436 2808 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2808 6 , , , 40436 2808 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2808 8 , , , 40436 2808 9 317 317 CD 40436 2808 10 C. c. NN 40436 2808 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2808 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2808 13 Side side NN 40436 2808 14 - - HYPH 40436 2808 15 note note NN 40436 2808 16 : : : 40436 2808 17 Reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2808 18 of of IN 40436 2808 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2808 20 in in IN 40436 2808 21 the the DT 40436 2808 22 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2808 23 is be VBZ 40436 2808 24 unsound unsound JJ 40436 2808 25 , , , 40436 2808 26 but but CC 40436 2808 27 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2808 28 . . . 40436 2809 1 The the DT 40436 2809 2 Good good JJ 40436 2809 3 , , , 40436 2809 4 True true JJ 40436 2809 5 , , , 40436 2809 6 and and CC 40436 2809 7 Real real JJ 40436 2809 8 , , , 40436 2809 9 coalesce coalesce NN 40436 2809 10 in in IN 40436 2809 11 the the DT 40436 2809 12 mind mind NN 40436 2809 13 of of IN 40436 2809 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2809 15 -- -- : 40436 2809 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2809 17 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 40436 2809 18 nothing nothing NN 40436 2809 19 to to TO 40436 2809 20 be be VB 40436 2809 21 Law Law NNP 40436 2809 22 , , , 40436 2809 23 except except IN 40436 2809 24 what what WP 40436 2809 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2809 26 thinks think VBZ 40436 2809 27 ought ought MD 40436 2809 28 to to TO 40436 2809 29 _ _ NNP 40436 2809 30 be be VB 40436 2809 31 _ _ NNP 40436 2809 32 Law Law NNP 40436 2809 33 . . . 40436 2809 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2810 1 That that IN 40436 2810 2 the the DT 40436 2810 3 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2810 4 of of IN 40436 2810 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2810 6 in in IN 40436 2810 7 this this DT 40436 2810 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2810 9 is be VBZ 40436 2810 10 confused confused JJ 40436 2810 11 and and CC 40436 2810 12 unsound unsound JJ 40436 2810 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2810 14 as as IN 40436 2810 15 M. M. NNP 40436 2810 16 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2810 17 and and CC 40436 2810 18 other other JJ 40436 2810 19 critics critic NNS 40436 2810 20 have have VBP 40436 2810 21 remarked remark VBN 40436 2810 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2810 23 , , , 40436 2810 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2810 25 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 2810 26 agree agree VBP 40436 2810 27 . . . 40436 2811 1 But but CC 40436 2811 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2811 3 is be VBZ 40436 2811 4 not not RB 40436 2811 5 the the DT 40436 2811 6 less less RBR 40436 2811 7 completely completely RB 40436 2811 8 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2811 9 ; ; : 40436 2811 10 resting rest VBG 40436 2811 11 upon upon IN 40436 2811 12 views view NNS 40436 2811 13 and and CC 40436 2811 14 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 2811 15 much much RB 40436 2811 16 cherished cherish VBN 40436 2811 17 and and CC 40436 2811 18 often often RB 40436 2811 19 reproduced reproduce VBN 40436 2811 20 by by IN 40436 2811 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2811 22 . . . 40436 2812 1 The the DT 40436 2812 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2812 3 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2812 4 presents present VBZ 40436 2812 5 , , , 40436 2812 6 in in IN 40436 2812 7 a a DT 40436 2812 8 rude rude JJ 40436 2812 9 and and CC 40436 2812 10 awkward awkward JJ 40436 2812 11 manner manner NN 40436 2812 12 , , , 40436 2812 13 without without IN 40436 2812 14 explanation explanation NN 40436 2812 15 or or CC 40436 2812 16 amplification amplification NN 40436 2812 17 , , , 40436 2812 18 that that WDT 40436 2812 19 worship worship NN 40436 2812 20 of of IN 40436 2812 21 the the DT 40436 2812 22 Abstract Abstract NNP 40436 2812 23 and and CC 40436 2812 24 the the DT 40436 2812 25 Ideal Ideal NNP 40436 2812 26 , , , 40436 2812 27 which which WDT 40436 2812 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2812 29 , , , 40436 2812 30 in in IN 40436 2812 31 other other JJ 40436 2812 32 and and CC 40436 2812 33 longer long JJR 40436 2812 34 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2812 35 , , , 40436 2812 36 seeks seek VBZ 40436 2812 37 to to TO 40436 2812 38 diversify diversify VB 40436 2812 39 as as RB 40436 2812 40 well well RB 40436 2812 41 as as IN 40436 2812 42 to to TO 40436 2812 43 elaborate elaborate VB 40436 2812 44 . . . 40436 2813 1 The the DT 40436 2813 2 definitions definition NNS 40436 2813 3 of of IN 40436 2813 4 Law Law NNP 40436 2813 5 here here RB 40436 2813 6 combated combat VBD 40436 2813 7 and and CC 40436 2813 8 given give VBN 40436 2813 9 by by IN 40436 2813 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2813 11 , , , 40436 2813 12 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 2813 13 this this DT 40436 2813 14 . . . 40436 2814 1 The the DT 40436 2814 2 good good JJ 40436 2814 3 , , , 40436 2814 4 the the DT 40436 2814 5 true true JJ 40436 2814 6 , , , 40436 2814 7 the the DT 40436 2814 8 right right NN 40436 2814 9 , , , 40436 2814 10 the the DT 40436 2814 11 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 2814 12 , , , 40436 2814 13 the the DT 40436 2814 14 real real JJ 40436 2814 15 -- -- : 40436 2814 16 all all DT 40436 2814 17 coalesce coalesce NN 40436 2814 18 in in IN 40436 2814 19 the the DT 40436 2814 20 mind mind NN 40436 2814 21 of of IN 40436 2814 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2814 23 . . . 40436 2815 1 There there EX 40436 2815 2 is be VBZ 40436 2815 3 nothing nothing NN 40436 2815 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2815 5 in in IN 40436 2815 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2815 7 view view NN 40436 2815 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2815 9 real real RB 40436 2815 10 , , , 40436 2815 11 except except IN 40436 2815 12 _ _ NNP 40436 2815 13 The the DT 40436 2815 14 _ _ NNP 40436 2815 15 Good Good NNP 40436 2815 16 , , , 40436 2815 17 _ _ NNP 40436 2815 18 The the DT 40436 2815 19 _ _ NNP 40436 2815 20 Just Just NNP 40436 2815 21 , , , 40436 2815 22 & & CC 40436 2815 23 c. c. NNP 40436 2815 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2815 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2815 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2815 27 : : : 40436 2815 28 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2815 29 au)to au)to NNP 40436 2815 30 - - HYPH 40436 2815 31 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 2815 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2815 33 ; ; : 40436 2815 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2815 35 Greek greek JJ 40436 2815 36 : : : 40436 2815 37 au)to au)to NNP 40436 2815 38 - - HYPH 40436 2815 39 di di NNP 40436 2815 40 / / SYM 40436 2815 41 kaion]--Absolute kaion]--Absolute NNP 40436 2815 42 Goodness Goodness NNP 40436 2815 43 and and CC 40436 2815 44 Justice Justice NNP 40436 2815 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2815 46 : : : 40436 2815 47 particular particular JJ 40436 2815 48 good good JJ 40436 2815 49 and and CC 40436 2815 50 just just RB 40436 2815 51 things thing NNS 40436 2815 52 have have VBP 40436 2815 53 no no DT 40436 2815 54 reality reality NN 40436 2815 55 , , , 40436 2815 56 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2815 57 are be VBP 40436 2815 58 no no RB 40436 2815 59 more more RBR 40436 2815 60 good good JJ 40436 2815 61 and and CC 40436 2815 62 just just RB 40436 2815 63 than than IN 40436 2815 64 bad bad JJ 40436 2815 65 and and CC 40436 2815 66 unjust unjust JJ 40436 2815 67 -- -- : 40436 2815 68 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2815 69 are be VBP 40436 2815 70 one one CD 40436 2815 71 or or CC 40436 2815 72 the the DT 40436 2815 73 other other JJ 40436 2815 74 , , , 40436 2815 75 according accord VBG 40436 2815 76 to to IN 40436 2815 77 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 2815 78 -- -- : 40436 2815 79 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2815 80 are be VBP 40436 2815 81 ever ever RB 40436 2815 82 variable variable JJ 40436 2815 83 , , , 40436 2815 84 floating float VBG 40436 2815 85 midway midway NN 40436 2815 86 between between IN 40436 2815 87 the the DT 40436 2815 88 real real JJ 40436 2815 89 and and CC 40436 2815 90 unreal unreal JJ 40436 2815 91 . . . 40436 2816 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2816 2 39 39 CD 40436 2816 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2816 4 The the DT 40436 2816 5 real real JJ 40436 2816 6 alone alone RB 40436 2816 7 is be VBZ 40436 2816 8 knowable knowable JJ 40436 2816 9 , , , 40436 2816 10 correlating correlate VBG 40436 2816 11 with with IN 40436 2816 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2816 13 or or CC 40436 2816 14 with with IN 40436 2816 15 the the DT 40436 2816 16 knowing know VBG 40436 2816 17 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2816 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2816 19 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2816 20 : : : 40436 2816 21 Nou Nou NNP 40436 2816 22 = = SYM 40436 2816 23 s s NN 40436 2816 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2816 25 . . . 40436 2817 1 As as IN 40436 2817 2 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2817 3 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 40436 2817 4 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 2817 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2817 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2817 7 : : : 40436 2817 8 to\ to\ NN 40436 2817 9 di di NNP 40436 2817 10 / / SYM 40436 2817 11 kaion kaion NN 40436 2817 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2817 13 or or CC 40436 2817 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2817 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2817 16 : : : 40436 2817 17 au)to au)to NNP 40436 2817 18 - - HYPH 40436 2817 19 di di NNP 40436 2817 20 / / SYM 40436 2817 21 kaion kaion NN 40436 2817 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2817 23 from from IN 40436 2817 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2817 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2817 26 : : : 40436 2817 27 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 2817 28 di di NNP 40436 2817 29 / / SYM 40436 2817 30 kaia]--so kaia]--so UH 40436 2817 31 here here RB 40436 2817 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2817 33 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 40436 2817 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2817 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2817 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2817 37 : : : 40436 2817 38 no no UH 40436 2817 39 / / SYM 40436 2817 40 mos mos NN 40436 2817 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2817 42 from from IN 40436 2817 43 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2817 44 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2817 45 : : : 40436 2817 46 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 2817 47 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2817 48 / / SYM 40436 2817 49 mena mena NN 40436 2817 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2817 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2817 52 _ _ NNP 40436 2817 53 Law Law NNP 40436 2817 54 _ _ NNP 40436 2817 55 , , , 40436 2817 56 from from IN 40436 2817 57 the the DT 40436 2817 58 assemblage assemblage NN 40436 2817 59 of of IN 40436 2817 60 actual actual JJ 40436 2817 61 commands command NNS 40436 2817 62 or or CC 40436 2817 63 customs custom NNS 40436 2817 64 received receive VBD 40436 2817 65 as as IN 40436 2817 66 _ _ NNP 40436 2817 67 laws law NNS 40436 2817 68 _ _ NNP 40436 2817 69 among among IN 40436 2817 70 mankind mankind NN 40436 2817 71 . . . 40436 2818 1 These these DT 40436 2818 2 latter latter JJ 40436 2818 3 are be VBP 40436 2818 4 variable variable JJ 40436 2818 5 according accord VBG 40436 2818 6 to to IN 40436 2818 7 time time NN 40436 2818 8 and and CC 40436 2818 9 place place NN 40436 2818 10 ; ; : 40436 2818 11 but but CC 40436 2818 12 Law Law NNP 40436 2818 13 is be VBZ 40436 2818 14 always always RB 40436 2818 15 one one CD 40436 2818 16 and and CC 40436 2818 17 the the DT 40436 2818 18 same same JJ 40436 2818 19 . . . 40436 2819 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2819 2 will will MD 40436 2819 3 acknowledge acknowledge VB 40436 2819 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 2819 5 to to IN 40436 2819 6 _ _ NNP 40436 2819 7 be be VB 40436 2819 8 _ _ NNP 40436 2819 9 Law Law NNP 40436 2819 10 , , , 40436 2819 11 except except IN 40436 2819 12 that that DT 40436 2819 13 which which WDT 40436 2819 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2819 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2819 16 thinks think VBZ 40436 2819 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2819 18 _ _ NNP 40436 2819 19 ought ought MD 40436 2819 20 to to TO 40436 2819 21 be be VB 40436 2819 22 _ _ NNP 40436 2819 23 Law Law NNP 40436 2819 24 : : : 40436 2819 25 that that IN 40436 2819 26 which which WDT 40436 2819 27 emanates emanate VBZ 40436 2819 28 from from IN 40436 2819 29 a a DT 40436 2819 30 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2819 31 of of IN 40436 2819 32 consummate consummate JJ 40436 2819 33 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2819 34 , , , 40436 2819 35 who who WP 40436 2819 36 aims aim VBZ 40436 2819 37 at at IN 40436 2819 38 the the DT 40436 2819 39 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 2819 40 of of IN 40436 2819 41 the the DT 40436 2819 42 good good JJ 40436 2819 43 and and CC 40436 2819 44 the the DT 40436 2819 45 real real JJ 40436 2819 46 , , , 40436 2819 47 and and CC 40436 2819 48 knows know VBZ 40436 2819 49 how how WRB 40436 2819 50 to to TO 40436 2819 51 discover discover VB 40436 2819 52 and and CC 40436 2819 53 realise realise VB 40436 2819 54 that that DT 40436 2819 55 end end NN 40436 2819 56 . . . 40436 2820 1 So so RB 40436 2820 2 far far RB 40436 2820 3 as as IN 40436 2820 4 " " `` 40436 2820 5 the the DT 40436 2820 6 decree decree NN 40436 2820 7 of of IN 40436 2820 8 the the DT 40436 2820 9 city city NN 40436 2820 10 " " `` 40436 2820 11 coincides coincide VBZ 40436 2820 12 with with IN 40436 2820 13 what what WP 40436 2820 14 would would MD 40436 2820 15 have have VB 40436 2820 16 been be VBN 40436 2820 17 enacted enact VBN 40436 2820 18 by by IN 40436 2820 19 this this DT 40436 2820 20 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2820 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2820 22 _ _ NNP 40436 2820 23 i i PRP 40436 2820 24 . . . 40436 2821 1 e. e. NNP 40436 2821 2 _ _ NNP 40436 2821 3 so so RB 40436 2821 4 far far RB 40436 2821 5 as as IN 40436 2821 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2821 7 is be VBZ 40436 2821 8 good good JJ 40436 2821 9 and and CC 40436 2821 10 right right JJ 40436 2821 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2821 12 , , , 40436 2821 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2821 14 admits admit VBZ 40436 2821 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2821 16 as as IN 40436 2821 17 a a DT 40436 2821 18 valid valid JJ 40436 2821 19 explanation explanation NN 40436 2821 20 of of IN 40436 2821 21 Law Law NNP 40436 2821 22 ; ; : 40436 2821 23 but but CC 40436 2821 24 no no DT 40436 2821 25 farther farther RB 40436 2821 26 . . . 40436 2822 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2822 2 considers consider VBZ 40436 2822 3 the the DT 40436 2822 4 phrase phrase NN 40436 2822 5 _ _ NNP 40436 2822 6 bad bad JJ 40436 2822 7 law law NN 40436 2822 8 _ _ NN 40436 2822 9 to to TO 40436 2822 10 express express VB 40436 2822 11 a a DT 40436 2822 12 logical logical JJ 40436 2822 13 impossibility impossibility NN 40436 2822 14 , , , 40436 2822 15 involving involve VBG 40436 2822 16 a a DT 40436 2822 17 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 2822 18 _ _ NNP 40436 2822 19 in in IN 40436 2822 20 adjecto adjecto NN 40436 2822 21 _ _ NNP 40436 2822 22 . . . 40436 2823 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2823 2 40 40 CD 40436 2823 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2823 4 What what WP 40436 2823 5 others other NNS 40436 2823 6 call call VBP 40436 2823 7 a a DT 40436 2823 8 bad bad JJ 40436 2823 9 law law NN 40436 2823 10 , , , 40436 2823 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2823 12 regards regard VBZ 40436 2823 13 as as IN 40436 2823 14 being be VBG 40436 2823 15 no no DT 40436 2823 16 real real JJ 40436 2823 17 law law NN 40436 2823 18 , , , 40436 2823 19 but but CC 40436 2823 20 only only RB 40436 2823 21 a a DT 40436 2823 22 fallacious fallacious JJ 40436 2823 23 image image NN 40436 2823 24 , , , 40436 2823 25 mistaken mistake VBN 40436 2823 26 for for IN 40436 2823 27 such such JJ 40436 2823 28 by by IN 40436 2823 29 the the DT 40436 2823 30 ignorant ignorant NN 40436 2823 31 . . . 40436 2824 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2824 2 does do VBZ 40436 2824 3 not not RB 40436 2824 4 consider consider VB 40436 2824 5 such such JJ 40436 2824 6 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 2824 7 persons person NNS 40436 2824 8 as as IN 40436 2824 9 qualified qualified JJ 40436 2824 10 to to TO 40436 2824 11 judge judge VB 40436 2824 12 : : : 40436 2824 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2824 14 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 2824 15 only only RB 40436 2824 16 the the DT 40436 2824 17 judgment judgment NN 40436 2824 18 of of IN 40436 2824 19 the the DT 40436 2824 20 knowing know VBG 40436 2824 21 one one CD 40436 2824 22 or or CC 40436 2824 23 few few JJ 40436 2824 24 , , , 40436 2824 25 among among IN 40436 2824 26 whom whom WP 40436 2824 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2824 28 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 2824 29 that that IN 40436 2824 30 there there EX 40436 2824 31 can can MD 40436 2824 32 be be VB 40436 2824 33 no no DT 40436 2824 34 difference difference NN 40436 2824 35 of of IN 40436 2824 36 opinion opinion NN 40436 2824 37 . . . 40436 2825 1 Every every DT 40436 2825 2 one one NN 40436 2825 3 admits admit VBZ 40436 2825 4 just just RB 40436 2825 5 things thing NNS 40436 2825 6 to to TO 40436 2825 7 be be VB 40436 2825 8 just,--unjust just,--unjust . 40436 2825 9 things thing NNS 40436 2825 10 to to TO 40436 2825 11 be be VB 40436 2825 12 unjust,--heavy unjust,--heavy CD 40436 2825 13 things thing NNS 40436 2825 14 to to TO 40436 2825 15 be be VB 40436 2825 16 heavy,--the heavy,--the DT 40436 2825 17 existent existent NN 40436 2825 18 and and CC 40436 2825 19 the the DT 40436 2825 20 real real JJ 40436 2825 21 , , , 40436 2825 22 to to TO 40436 2825 23 be be VB 40436 2825 24 the the DT 40436 2825 25 existent existent NN 40436 2825 26 and and CC 40436 2825 27 the the DT 40436 2825 28 real real JJ 40436 2825 29 . . . 40436 2826 1 If if IN 40436 2826 2 then then RB 40436 2826 3 the the DT 40436 2826 4 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 2826 5 in in IN 40436 2826 6 any any DT 40436 2826 7 of of IN 40436 2826 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2826 9 laws law NNS 40436 2826 10 fails fail VBZ 40436 2826 11 to to TO 40436 2826 12 attain attain VB 40436 2826 13 this this DT 40436 2826 14 reality reality NN 40436 2826 15 , , , 40436 2826 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2826 17 fails fail VBZ 40436 2826 18 in in IN 40436 2826 19 the the DT 40436 2826 20 very very JJ 40436 2826 21 purpose purpose NN 40436 2826 22 essential essential JJ 40436 2826 23 to to IN 40436 2826 24 the the DT 40436 2826 25 conception conception NN 40436 2826 26 of of IN 40436 2826 27 law:[41 law:[41 NNP 40436 2826 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2826 29 _ _ NNP 40436 2826 30 i. i. NNP 40436 2827 1 e. e. NNP 40436 2827 2 _ _ NNP 40436 2827 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2827 4 pretended pretended JJ 40436 2827 5 law law NN 40436 2827 6 is be VBZ 40436 2827 7 no no DT 40436 2827 8 law law NN 40436 2827 9 at at RB 40436 2827 10 all all RB 40436 2827 11 . . . 40436 2828 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2828 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2828 3 39 39 CD 40436 2828 4 : : : 40436 2828 5 See see VB 40436 2828 6 the the DT 40436 2828 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 2828 8 passage passage NN 40436 2828 9 in in IN 40436 2828 10 the the DT 40436 2828 11 fifth fifth JJ 40436 2828 12 book book NN 40436 2828 13 of of IN 40436 2828 14 the the DT 40436 2828 15 Republic Republic NNP 40436 2828 16 , , , 40436 2828 17 pp pp NNP 40436 2828 18 . . . 40436 2829 1 479 479 CD 40436 2829 2 - - SYM 40436 2829 3 480 480 CD 40436 2829 4 ; ; : 40436 2829 5 compare compare VB 40436 2829 6 vii vii NN 40436 2829 7 . . . 40436 2830 1 538 538 CD 40436 2830 2 E. E. NNP 40436 2830 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2830 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2830 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2830 6 40 40 CD 40436 2830 7 : : : 40436 2830 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2830 9 , , , 40436 2830 10 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2830 11 , , , 40436 2830 12 314 314 CD 40436 2830 13 D. D. NNP 40436 2830 14 The the DT 40436 2830 15 same same JJ 40436 2830 16 argument argument NN 40436 2830 17 is be VBZ 40436 2830 18 brought bring VBN 40436 2830 19 to to TO 40436 2830 20 bear bear VB 40436 2830 21 by by IN 40436 2830 22 the the DT 40436 2830 23 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2830 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2830 25 against against IN 40436 2830 26 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2830 27 in in IN 40436 2830 28 the the DT 40436 2830 29 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2830 30 Major Major NNP 40436 2830 31 , , , 40436 2830 32 284 284 CD 40436 2830 33 - - SYM 40436 2830 34 285 285 CD 40436 2830 35 . . . 40436 2831 1 If if IN 40436 2831 2 the the DT 40436 2831 3 laws law NNS 40436 2831 4 are be VBP 40436 2831 5 not not RB 40436 2831 6 really really RB 40436 2831 7 profitable profitable JJ 40436 2831 8 , , , 40436 2831 9 which which WDT 40436 2831 10 is be VBZ 40436 2831 11 the the DT 40436 2831 12 only only JJ 40436 2831 13 real real JJ 40436 2831 14 purpose purpose NN 40436 2831 15 for for IN 40436 2831 16 which which WDT 40436 2831 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2831 18 were be VBD 40436 2831 19 established establish VBN 40436 2831 20 , , , 40436 2831 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2831 22 are be VBP 40436 2831 23 no no DT 40436 2831 24 laws law NNS 40436 2831 25 at at RB 40436 2831 26 all all RB 40436 2831 27 . . . 40436 2832 1 The the DT 40436 2832 2 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 2832 3 are be VBP 40436 2832 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2832 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2832 6 : : : 40436 2832 7 para para NNP 40436 2832 8 / / SYM 40436 2832 9 nomoi nomoi NNP 40436 2832 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2832 11 . . . 40436 2833 1 Some some DT 40436 2833 2 of of IN 40436 2833 3 the the DT 40436 2833 4 answers answer NNS 40436 2833 5 assigned assign VBN 40436 2833 6 to to IN 40436 2833 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 2833 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2833 9 284 284 CD 40436 2833 10 D d NN 40436 2833 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2833 12 are be VBP 40436 2833 13 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 2833 14 enough enough RB 40436 2833 15 ; ; : 40436 2833 16 but but CC 40436 2833 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2833 18 is be VBZ 40436 2833 19 overborne overborne JJ 40436 2833 20 . . . 40436 2833 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2834 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2834 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2834 3 41 41 CD 40436 2834 4 : : : 40436 2834 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2834 6 , , , 40436 2834 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2834 8 , , , 40436 2834 9 316 316 CD 40436 2834 10 B. B. NNP 40436 2835 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2835 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2835 3 : : : 40436 2835 4 O(\s o(\s NN 40436 2835 5 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2835 6 a)/ra a)/ra VBP 40436 2835 7 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2835 8 o)/ntos o)/ntos NN 40436 2835 9 a(marta a(marta NNS 40436 2835 10 / / SYM 40436 2835 11 nê nê NN 40436 2835 12 , , , 40436 2835 13 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2835 14 nomi nomi NN 40436 2835 15 / / SYM 40436 2835 16 mou mou NN 40436 2835 17 a(marta a(marta NNP 40436 2835 18 / / SYM 40436 2835 19 nei nei NNP 40436 2835 20 . . . 40436 2835 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2835 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2836 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2836 2 Side side NN 40436 2836 3 - - HYPH 40436 2836 4 note note NN 40436 2836 5 : : : 40436 2836 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2836 7 worships worship VBZ 40436 2836 8 the the DT 40436 2836 9 Ideal Ideal NNP 40436 2836 10 of of IN 40436 2836 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2836 12 own own JJ 40436 2836 13 mind mind NN 40436 2836 14 -- -- : 40436 2836 15 the the DT 40436 2836 16 work work NN 40436 2836 17 of of IN 40436 2836 18 systematic systematic JJ 40436 2836 19 constructive constructive JJ 40436 2836 20 theory theory NN 40436 2836 21 by by IN 40436 2836 22 the the DT 40436 2836 23 Wise Wise NNP 40436 2836 24 Man Man NNP 40436 2836 25 . . . 40436 2836 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2837 1 By by IN 40436 2837 2 _ _ NNP 40436 2837 3 Law Law NNP 40436 2837 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2837 5 then then RB 40436 2837 6 , , , 40436 2837 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2837 8 means mean VBZ 40436 2837 9 -- -- : 40436 2837 10 not not RB 40436 2837 11 the the DT 40436 2837 12 assemblage assemblage NN 40436 2837 13 of of IN 40436 2837 14 actual actual JJ 40436 2837 15 positive positive JJ 40436 2837 16 rules rule NNS 40436 2837 17 , , , 40436 2837 18 nor nor CC 40436 2837 19 any any DT 40436 2837 20 general general JJ 40436 2837 21 property property NN 40436 2837 22 common common JJ 40436 2837 23 to to IN 40436 2837 24 and and CC 40436 2837 25 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 2837 26 of of IN 40436 2837 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2837 28 , , , 40436 2837 29 nor nor CC 40436 2837 30 the the DT 40436 2837 31 free free JJ 40436 2837 32 determination determination NN 40436 2837 33 of of IN 40436 2837 34 an an DT 40436 2837 35 assembled assemble VBN 40436 2837 36 Demos Demos NNP 40436 2837 37 as as IN 40436 2837 38 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 2837 39 from from IN 40436 2837 40 the the DT 40436 2837 41 mandates mandate NNS 40436 2837 42 of of IN 40436 2837 43 a a DT 40436 2837 44 despot despot NN 40436 2837 45 -- -- : 40436 2837 46 but but CC 40436 2837 47 the the DT 40436 2837 48 Type Type NNP 40436 2837 49 of of IN 40436 2837 50 Law Law NNP 40436 2837 51 as as IN 40436 2837 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2837 53 ought ought MD 40436 2837 54 to to TO 40436 2837 55 be be VB 40436 2837 56 , , , 40436 2837 57 and and CC 40436 2837 58 as as IN 40436 2837 59 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2837 60 would would MD 40436 2837 61 be be VB 40436 2837 62 , , , 40436 2837 63 if if IN 40436 2837 64 prescribed prescribe VBN 40436 2837 65 by by IN 40436 2837 66 a a DT 40436 2837 67 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 2837 68 wise wise JJ 40436 2837 69 ruler ruler NN 40436 2837 70 , , , 40436 2837 71 aiming aim VBG 40436 2837 72 at at IN 40436 2837 73 good good JJ 40436 2837 74 and and CC 40436 2837 75 knowing know VBG 40436 2837 76 how how WRB 40436 2837 77 to to TO 40436 2837 78 realise realise VB 40436 2837 79 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2837 80 . . . 40436 2838 1 This this DT 40436 2838 2 , , , 40436 2838 3 which which WDT 40436 2838 4 is be VBZ 40436 2838 5 the the DT 40436 2838 6 ideal ideal NN 40436 2838 7 of of IN 40436 2838 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2838 9 own own JJ 40436 2838 10 mind mind NN 40436 2838 11 , , , 40436 2838 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2838 13 worships worship NNS 40436 2838 14 and and CC 40436 2838 15 reasons reason NNS 40436 2838 16 upon upon IN 40436 2838 17 as as IN 40436 2838 18 if if IN 40436 2838 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2838 20 were be VBD 40436 2838 21 the the DT 40436 2838 22 only only JJ 40436 2838 23 reality reality NN 40436 2838 24 ; ; : 40436 2838 25 as as IN 40436 2838 26 Law Law NNP 40436 2838 27 by by IN 40436 2838 28 nature nature NN 40436 2838 29 , , , 40436 2838 30 or or CC 40436 2838 31 natural natural JJ 40436 2838 32 Law Law NNP 40436 2838 33 , , , 40436 2838 34 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 2838 35 from from IN 40436 2838 36 actual actual JJ 40436 2838 37 positive positive JJ 40436 2838 38 laws law NNS 40436 2838 39 : : : 40436 2838 40 which which WDT 40436 2838 41 last last RB 40436 2838 42 have have VBP 40436 2838 43 either either CC 40436 2838 44 been be VBN 40436 2838 45 set set VBN 40436 2838 46 by by IN 40436 2838 47 some some DT 40436 2838 48 ill ill JJ 40436 2838 49 - - HYPH 40436 2838 50 qualified qualified JJ 40436 2838 51 historical historical JJ 40436 2838 52 ruler ruler NN 40436 2838 53 , , , 40436 2838 54 or or CC 40436 2838 55 have have VBP 40436 2838 56 grown grow VBN 40436 2838 57 up up RP 40436 2838 58 insensibly insensibly RB 40436 2838 59 . . . 40436 2839 1 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 2839 2 , , , 40436 2839 3 art art NN 40436 2839 4 , , , 40436 2839 5 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 2839 6 , , , 40436 2839 7 systematic systematic JJ 40436 2839 8 and and CC 40436 2839 9 constructive constructive JJ 40436 2839 10 , , , 40436 2839 11 applied apply VBN 40436 2839 12 by by IN 40436 2839 13 some some DT 40436 2839 14 one one CD 40436 2839 15 or or CC 40436 2839 16 few few JJ 40436 2839 17 exalted exalted JJ 40436 2839 18 individuals individual NNS 40436 2839 19 , , , 40436 2839 20 is be VBZ 40436 2839 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2839 22 in in IN 40436 2839 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2839 24 view view NN 40436 2839 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2839 26 the the DT 40436 2839 27 only only JJ 40436 2839 28 cause cause NN 40436 2839 29 capable capable JJ 40436 2839 30 of of IN 40436 2839 31 producing produce VBG 40436 2839 32 that that IN 40436 2839 33 typical typical JJ 40436 2839 34 result result NN 40436 2839 35 which which WDT 40436 2839 36 is be VBZ 40436 2839 37 true true JJ 40436 2839 38 , , , 40436 2839 39 good good JJ 40436 2839 40 , , , 40436 2839 41 real real JJ 40436 2839 42 , , , 40436 2839 43 permanent permanent JJ 40436 2839 44 , , , 40436 2839 45 and and CC 40436 2839 46 worthy worthy JJ 40436 2839 47 of of IN 40436 2839 48 the the DT 40436 2839 49 generic generic JJ 40436 2839 50 name name NN 40436 2839 51 . . . 40436 2840 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2840 2 Side side NN 40436 2840 3 - - HYPH 40436 2840 4 note note NN 40436 2840 5 : : : 40436 2840 6 Different different JJ 40436 2840 7 applications application NNS 40436 2840 8 of of IN 40436 2840 9 this this DT 40436 2840 10 general general JJ 40436 2840 11 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2840 12 view view NN 40436 2840 13 , , , 40436 2840 14 in in IN 40436 2840 15 the the DT 40436 2840 16 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2840 17 , , , 40436 2840 18 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2840 19 , , , 40436 2840 20 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 2840 21 , , , 40436 2840 22 & & CC 40436 2840 23 c. c. NNP 40436 2840 24 _ _ NNP 40436 2840 25 Natural Natural NNP 40436 2840 26 _ _ NNP 40436 2840 27 Rectitude Rectitude NNP 40436 2840 28 of of IN 40436 2840 29 Law Law NNP 40436 2840 30 , , , 40436 2840 31 Government Government NNP 40436 2840 32 , , , 40436 2840 33 Names Names NNP 40436 2840 34 , , , 40436 2840 35 & & CC 40436 2840 36 c. c. NN 40436 2840 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2840 38 In in IN 40436 2840 39 the the DT 40436 2840 40 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2840 41 , , , 40436 2840 42 this this DT 40436 2840 43 general general JJ 40436 2840 44 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2840 45 view view NN 40436 2840 46 is be VBZ 40436 2840 47 applied apply VBN 40436 2840 48 to to IN 40436 2840 49 Law Law NNP 40436 2840 50 : : : 40436 2840 51 in in IN 40436 2840 52 the the DT 40436 2840 53 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2840 54 , , , 40436 2840 55 to to IN 40436 2840 56 government government NN 40436 2840 57 and and CC 40436 2840 58 social social JJ 40436 2840 59 administration administration NN 40436 2840 60 : : : 40436 2840 61 in in IN 40436 2840 62 the the DT 40436 2840 63 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 2840 64 , , , 40436 2840 65 to to IN 40436 2840 66 naming naming NN 40436 2840 67 or or CC 40436 2840 68 language language VB 40436 2840 69 . . . 40436 2841 1 In in IN 40436 2841 2 the the DT 40436 2841 3 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2841 4 , , , 40436 2841 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2841 6 find find VBP 40436 2841 7 the the DT 40436 2841 8 received received JJ 40436 2841 9 classification classification NN 40436 2841 10 of of IN 40436 2841 11 governments government NNS 40436 2841 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2841 13 monarchy monarchy NN 40436 2841 14 , , , 40436 2841 15 aristocracy aristocracy NN 40436 2841 16 , , , 40436 2841 17 and and CC 40436 2841 18 democracy democracy NN 40436 2841 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2841 20 discarded discard VBN 40436 2841 21 as as IN 40436 2841 22 improper improper JJ 40436 2841 23 ; ; : 40436 2841 24 and and CC 40436 2841 25 the the DT 40436 2841 26 assertion assertion NN 40436 2841 27 advanced advance VBD 40436 2841 28 , , , 40436 2841 29 That that IN 40436 2841 30 there there EX 40436 2841 31 is be VBZ 40436 2841 32 only only RB 40436 2841 33 one one CD 40436 2841 34 government government NN 40436 2841 35 right right UH 40436 2841 36 , , , 40436 2841 37 true true JJ 40436 2841 38 , , , 40436 2841 39 genuine genuine JJ 40436 2841 40 , , , 40436 2841 41 really really RB 40436 2841 42 existing existing JJ 40436 2841 43 -- -- : 40436 2841 44 government government NN 40436 2841 45 by by IN 40436 2841 46 the the DT 40436 2841 47 uncontrolled uncontrolled JJ 40436 2841 48 authority authority NNP 40436 2841 49 and and CC 40436 2841 50 superintendence superintendence NN 40436 2841 51 of of IN 40436 2841 52 the the DT 40436 2841 53 man man NN 40436 2841 54 of of IN 40436 2841 55 exalted exalt VBN 40436 2841 56 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 2841 57 : : : 40436 2841 58 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2841 59 who who WP 40436 2841 60 is be VBZ 40436 2841 61 master master NN 40436 2841 62 in in IN 40436 2841 63 the the DT 40436 2841 64 art art NN 40436 2841 65 of of IN 40436 2841 66 governing governing NN 40436 2841 67 , , , 40436 2841 68 whether whether IN 40436 2841 69 such such JJ 40436 2841 70 man man NN 40436 2841 71 do do VB 40436 2841 72 in in IN 40436 2841 73 fact fact NN 40436 2841 74 hold hold VB 40436 2841 75 power power NN 40436 2841 76 anywhere anywhere RB 40436 2841 77 or or CC 40436 2841 78 not not RB 40436 2841 79 . . . 40436 2842 1 All all DT 40436 2842 2 other other JJ 40436 2842 3 governments government NNS 40436 2842 4 are be VBP 40436 2842 5 degenerate degenerate VB 40436 2842 6 substitutes substitute NNS 40436 2842 7 for for IN 40436 2842 8 this this DT 40436 2842 9 type type NN 40436 2842 10 , , , 40436 2842 11 some some DT 40436 2842 12 receding recede VBG 40436 2842 13 from from IN 40436 2842 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2842 15 less less RBR 40436 2842 16 , , , 40436 2842 17 some some DT 40436 2842 18 more more RBR 40436 2842 19 . . . 40436 2843 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2843 2 42 42 CD 40436 2843 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2843 4 Again again RB 40436 2843 5 , , , 40436 2843 6 in in IN 40436 2843 7 the the DT 40436 2843 8 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 2843 9 , , , 40436 2843 10 where where WRB 40436 2843 11 names name NNS 40436 2843 12 and and CC 40436 2843 13 name name NN 40436 2843 14 - - HYPH 40436 2843 15 giving giving NN 40436 2843 16 are be VBP 40436 2843 17 discussed discuss VBN 40436 2843 18 , , , 40436 2843 19 Sokrates[43 Sokrates[43 . 40436 2843 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2843 21 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 2843 22 that that IN 40436 2843 23 things thing NNS 40436 2843 24 can can MD 40436 2843 25 only only RB 40436 2843 26 be be VB 40436 2843 27 named name VBN 40436 2843 28 according accord VBG 40436 2843 29 to to IN 40436 2843 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2843 31 true true JJ 40436 2843 32 and and CC 40436 2843 33 real real JJ 40436 2843 34 nature nature NN 40436 2843 35 -- -- : 40436 2843 36 that that IN 40436 2843 37 there there EX 40436 2843 38 is be VBZ 40436 2843 39 , , , 40436 2843 40 belonging belong VBG 40436 2843 41 to to IN 40436 2843 42 each each DT 40436 2843 43 thing thing NN 40436 2843 44 , , , 40436 2843 45 one one CD 40436 2843 46 special special JJ 40436 2843 47 and and CC 40436 2843 48 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 2843 49 Name Name NNP 40436 2843 50 - - HYPH 40436 2843 51 Form Form NNP 40436 2843 52 , , , 40436 2843 53 discernible discernible JJ 40436 2843 54 only only RB 40436 2843 55 by by IN 40436 2843 56 the the DT 40436 2843 57 sagacity sagacity NN 40436 2843 58 of of IN 40436 2843 59 the the DT 40436 2843 60 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 2843 61 Lawgiver Lawgiver NNP 40436 2843 62 : : : 40436 2843 63 who who WP 40436 2843 64 alone alone RB 40436 2843 65 is be VBZ 40436 2843 66 competent competent JJ 40436 2843 67 to to TO 40436 2843 68 bestow bestow VB 40436 2843 69 upon upon IN 40436 2843 70 each each DT 40436 2843 71 thing thing NN 40436 2843 72 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2843 73 right right JJ 40436 2843 74 , , , 40436 2843 75 true true JJ 40436 2843 76 , , , 40436 2843 77 genuine genuine JJ 40436 2843 78 , , , 40436 2843 79 real real JJ 40436 2843 80 name name NN 40436 2843 81 , , , 40436 2843 82 possessing possess VBG 40436 2843 83 rectitude rectitude NN 40436 2843 84 by by IN 40436 2843 85 nature nature NN 40436 2843 86 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2843 87 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2843 88 Greek greek JJ 40436 2843 89 : : : 40436 2843 90 o)rtho o)rtho NNS 40436 2843 91 / / SYM 40436 2843 92 tês tês NNP 40436 2843 93 phu phu NNP 40436 2843 94 / / SYM 40436 2843 95 sei sei NNP 40436 2843 96 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2843 97 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2843 98 . . . 40436 2844 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2844 2 44 44 CD 40436 2844 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2844 4 This this DT 40436 2844 5 Name Name NNP 40436 2844 6 - - HYPH 40436 2844 7 Form Form NNP 40436 2844 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2844 9 according accord VBG 40436 2844 10 to to IN 40436 2844 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2844 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2844 13 is be VBZ 40436 2844 14 the the DT 40436 2844 15 same same JJ 40436 2844 16 in in IN 40436 2844 17 all all DT 40436 2844 18 languages language NNS 40436 2844 19 in in IN 40436 2844 20 so so RB 40436 2844 21 far far RB 40436 2844 22 as as IN 40436 2844 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2844 24 are be VBP 40436 2844 25 constructed construct VBN 40436 2844 26 by by IN 40436 2844 27 different different JJ 40436 2844 28 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 2844 29 Lawgivers Lawgivers NNPS 40436 2844 30 , , , 40436 2844 31 although although IN 40436 2844 32 the the DT 40436 2844 33 letters letter NNS 40436 2844 34 and and CC 40436 2844 35 syllables syllable NNS 40436 2844 36 in in IN 40436 2844 37 which which WDT 40436 2844 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2844 39 may may MD 40436 2844 40 clothe clothe VB 40436 2844 41 the the DT 40436 2844 42 Form Form NNP 40436 2844 43 are be VBP 40436 2844 44 very very RB 40436 2844 45 different different JJ 40436 2844 46 . . . 40436 2845 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2845 2 45 45 CD 40436 2845 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2845 4 If if IN 40436 2845 5 names name NNS 40436 2845 6 be be VBP 40436 2845 7 not not RB 40436 2845 8 thus thus RB 40436 2845 9 apportioned apportion VBN 40436 2845 10 by by IN 40436 2845 11 the the DT 40436 2845 12 systematic systematic JJ 40436 2845 13 purpose purpose NN 40436 2845 14 of of IN 40436 2845 15 an an DT 40436 2845 16 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 2845 17 Lawgiver Lawgiver NNP 40436 2845 18 , , , 40436 2845 19 but but CC 40436 2845 20 raised raise VBD 40436 2845 21 up up RP 40436 2845 22 by by IN 40436 2845 23 insensible insensible JJ 40436 2845 24 and and CC 40436 2845 25 unsystematic unsystematic JJ 40436 2845 26 growth growth NN 40436 2845 27 -- -- : 40436 2845 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2845 29 will will MD 40436 2845 30 be be VB 40436 2845 31 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 2845 32 substitutes substitute NNS 40436 2845 33 for for IN 40436 2845 34 the the DT 40436 2845 35 genuine genuine JJ 40436 2845 36 type type NN 40436 2845 37 , , , 40436 2845 38 though though IN 40436 2845 39 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2845 40 are be VBP 40436 2845 41 the the DT 40436 2845 42 best good JJS 40436 2845 43 which which WDT 40436 2845 44 actual actual JJ 40436 2845 45 societies society NNS 40436 2845 46 possess possess VBP 40436 2845 47 ; ; : 40436 2845 48 according accord VBG 40436 2845 49 to to IN 40436 2845 50 the the DT 40436 2845 51 opinion opinion NN 40436 2845 52 announced announce VBN 40436 2845 53 by by IN 40436 2845 54 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 2845 55 in in IN 40436 2845 56 that that DT 40436 2845 57 same same JJ 40436 2845 58 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2845 59 , , , 40436 2845 60 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2845 61 will will MD 40436 2845 62 not not RB 40436 2845 63 be be VB 40436 2845 64 names name NNS 40436 2845 65 at at RB 40436 2845 66 all all RB 40436 2845 67 . . . 40436 2846 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2846 2 46 46 CD 40436 2846 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2846 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2846 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2846 6 42 42 CD 40436 2846 7 : : : 40436 2846 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2846 9 , , , 40436 2846 10 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2846 11 , , , 40436 2846 12 293 293 CD 40436 2846 13 C C NNP 40436 2846 14 - - HYPH 40436 2846 15 E. E. NNP 40436 2846 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2846 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2846 18 : : : 40436 2846 19 tau tau NNP 40436 2846 20 / / SYM 40436 2846 21 tên tên NNP 40436 2846 22 o)rthê\n o)rthê\n NNP 40436 2846 23 diaphero diaphero NNP 40436 2846 24 / / SYM 40436 2846 25 ntôs ntôs NNP 40436 2846 26 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 2846 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2846 28 mo mo NNP 40436 2846 29 / / SYM 40436 2846 30 nên nên NNP 40436 2846 31 politei politei NNP 40436 2846 32 / / SYM 40436 2846 33 an an DT 40436 2846 34 , , , 40436 2846 35 e)n e)n NNP 40436 2846 36 ê(=| ê(=| JJ 40436 2846 37 tis tis NN 40436 2846 38 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2846 39 eu(/riskoi eu(/riskoi NNP 40436 2846 40 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 2846 41 a)/rchontas a)/rchonta NNS 40436 2846 42 a)lêthô a)lêthô CD 40436 2846 43 = = SYM 40436 2846 44 s s NNP 40436 2846 45 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 2846 46 / / SYM 40436 2846 47 monas monas NNP 40436 2846 48 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2846 49 ou ou NNP 40436 2846 50 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2846 51 dokou dokou NNP 40436 2846 52 = = SYM 40436 2846 53 ntas ntas FW 40436 2846 54 mo mo NNP 40436 2846 55 / / SYM 40436 2846 56 non non JJ 40436 2846 57 . . . 40436 2847 1 . . . 40436 2848 1 . . . 40436 2849 1 to to IN 40436 2849 2 / / SYM 40436 2849 3 te te NNP 40436 2849 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2849 5 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 2849 6 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 2849 7 toiou toiou NNP 40436 2849 8 / / SYM 40436 2849 9 tous tous JJ 40436 2849 10 o(/rous o(/rous JJ 40436 2849 11 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 2849 12 = = SYM 40436 2849 13 n n CC 40436 2849 14 mo mo NN 40436 2849 15 / / SYM 40436 2849 16 nên nên NNP 40436 2849 17 o)rthê\n o)rthê\n NNP 40436 2849 18 politei politei NN 40436 2849 19 / / , 40436 2849 20 an an DT 40436 2849 21 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 2849 22 r(ête r(ête NN 40436 2849 23 / / SYM 40436 2849 24 on on RB 40436 2849 25 . . . 40436 2850 1 o(/sas o(/sas NNP 40436 2850 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2850 3 a)/llas a)/llas NNP 40436 2850 4 le le NNP 40436 2850 5 / / SYM 40436 2850 6 gomen gomen NNP 40436 2850 7 , , , 40436 2850 8 _ _ NNP 40436 2850 9 ou ou NNP 40436 2850 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2850 11 gnêsi gnêsi NN 40436 2850 12 / / SYM 40436 2850 13 as as IN 40436 2850 14 ou)d ou)d JJ 40436 2850 15 ' ' '' 40436 2850 16 o)/ntôs o)/ntôs RB 40436 2850 17 ou)/sas ou)/sas NNP 40436 2850 18 lekte lekte NNP 40436 2850 19 / / , 40436 2850 20 on on IN 40436 2850 21 _ _ NNP 40436 2850 22 , , , 40436 2850 23 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 2850 24 memimême memimême NNP 40436 2850 25 / / SYM 40436 2850 26 nas nas NNP 40436 2850 27 tau tau NNP 40436 2850 28 / / SYM 40436 2850 29 tên tên NNP 40436 2850 30 , , , 40436 2850 31 a(/s a(/s NNP 40436 2850 32 me\n me\n NNP 40436 2850 33 eu)no eu)no NNP 40436 2850 34 / / SYM 40436 2850 35 mous mous JJ 40436 2850 36 le le NNP 40436 2850 37 / / SYM 40436 2850 38 gomen gomen NNP 40436 2850 39 , , , 40436 2850 40 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 2850 41 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 2850 42 kalli kalli NNP 40436 2850 43 / / SYM 40436 2850 44 ô ô NN 40436 2850 45 , , , 40436 2850 46 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 2850 47 de\ de\ NNP 40436 2850 48 a)/llas a)/llas XX 40436 2850 49 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 2850 50 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 2850 51 ai)schi ai)schi NNP 40436 2850 52 / / SYM 40436 2850 53 ona ona NNP 40436 2850 54 memimê memimê NNP 40436 2850 55 = = SYM 40436 2850 56 sthai sthai NNP 40436 2850 57 . . . 40436 2850 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2851 1 The the DT 40436 2851 2 historical historical JJ 40436 2851 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2851 4 Xenophontic xenophontic NN 40436 2851 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2851 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2851 7 asserts assert VBZ 40436 2851 8 this this DT 40436 2851 9 same same JJ 40436 2851 10 position position NN 40436 2851 11 in in IN 40436 2851 12 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 2851 13 's 's POS 40436 2851 14 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 2851 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2851 16 iii iii NNP 40436 2851 17 . . . 40436 2852 1 9 9 CD 40436 2852 2 , , , 40436 2852 3 10 10 CD 40436 2852 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2852 5 . . . 40436 2853 1 " " `` 40436 2853 2 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2853 3 said say VBD 40436 2853 4 that that IN 40436 2853 5 Kings king NNS 40436 2853 6 and and CC 40436 2853 7 Rulers ruler NNS 40436 2853 8 were be VBD 40436 2853 9 those those DT 40436 2853 10 who who WP 40436 2853 11 knew know VBD 40436 2853 12 how how WRB 40436 2853 13 to to TO 40436 2853 14 command command VB 40436 2853 15 , , , 40436 2853 16 not not RB 40436 2853 17 those those DT 40436 2853 18 who who WP 40436 2853 19 held hold VBD 40436 2853 20 the the DT 40436 2853 21 sceptre sceptre NN 40436 2853 22 or or CC 40436 2853 23 were be VBD 40436 2853 24 chosen choose VBN 40436 2853 25 by by IN 40436 2853 26 election election NN 40436 2853 27 or or CC 40436 2853 28 lot lot NN 40436 2853 29 , , , 40436 2853 30 or or CC 40436 2853 31 had have VBD 40436 2853 32 acquired acquire VBN 40436 2853 33 power power NN 40436 2853 34 by by IN 40436 2853 35 force force NN 40436 2853 36 or or CC 40436 2853 37 fraud fraud NN 40436 2853 38 , , , 40436 2853 39 " " '' 40436 2853 40 & & CC 40436 2853 41 c. c. NNP 40436 2853 42 The the DT 40436 2853 43 Kings king NNS 40436 2853 44 of of IN 40436 2853 45 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 2853 46 and and CC 40436 2853 47 Macedonia Macedonia NNP 40436 2853 48 , , , 40436 2853 49 the the DT 40436 2853 50 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2853 51 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2853 52 : : : 40436 2853 53 Boulê\ boulê\ ADD 40436 2853 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2853 55 and and CC 40436 2853 56 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2853 57 Greek greek NN 40436 2853 58 : : : 40436 2853 59 Dê dê NN 40436 2853 60 = = SYM 40436 2853 61 mos mos NN 40436 2853 62 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2853 63 of of IN 40436 2853 64 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2853 65 , , , 40436 2853 66 the the DT 40436 2853 67 Despot Despot NNP 40436 2853 68 of of IN 40436 2853 69 Syracuse Syracuse NNP 40436 2853 70 or or CC 40436 2853 71 Pheræ Pheræ NNP 40436 2853 72 are be VBP 40436 2853 73 here here RB 40436 2853 74 declared declare VBN 40436 2853 75 to to TO 40436 2853 76 be be VB 40436 2853 77 not not RB 40436 2853 78 real real JJ 40436 2853 79 rulers ruler NNS 40436 2853 80 at at RB 40436 2853 81 all all RB 40436 2853 82 . . . 40436 2853 83 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2854 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2854 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2854 3 43 43 CD 40436 2854 4 : : : 40436 2854 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2854 6 , , , 40436 2854 7 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 2854 8 , , , 40436 2854 9 387 387 CD 40436 2854 10 D. D. NNP 40436 2854 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2854 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2854 13 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2854 14 44 44 CD 40436 2854 15 : : : 40436 2854 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2854 17 , , , 40436 2854 18 Kratyl Kratyl NNP 40436 2854 19 . . . 40436 2855 1 388 388 CD 40436 2855 2 A A NNP 40436 2855 3 - - HYPH 40436 2855 4 E. e. NN 40436 2855 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2855 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2855 7 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2855 8 45 45 CD 40436 2855 9 : : : 40436 2855 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2855 11 , , , 40436 2855 12 Kratyl Kratyl NNP 40436 2855 13 . . . 40436 2856 1 389 389 CD 40436 2856 2 E e NN 40436 2856 3 , , , 40436 2856 4 390 390 CD 40436 2856 5 A a NN 40436 2856 6 , , , 40436 2856 7 432 432 CD 40436 2856 8 E. e. NN 40436 2856 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2856 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2856 11 : : : 40436 2856 12 Ou)kou ou)kou ADD 40436 2856 13 = = SYM 40436 2856 14 n n CC 40436 2856 15 ou)/tôs ou)/tôs NNP 40436 2856 16 a)xiô a)xiô NNP 40436 2856 17 / / SYM 40436 2856 18 seis seis NNP 40436 2856 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2856 20 to\n to\n NNP 40436 2856 21 nomothe nomothe NN 40436 2856 22 / / SYM 40436 2856 23 tên tên NN 40436 2856 24 to to IN 40436 2856 25 / / SYM 40436 2856 26 n n NNP 40436 2856 27 te te NNP 40436 2856 28 e)ntha e)ntha NNP 40436 2856 29 / / SYM 40436 2856 30 de de NNP 40436 2856 31 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 2856 32 to\n to\n NNP 40436 2856 33 e)n e)n NNP 40436 2856 34 toi toi NNP 40436 2856 35 = = SYM 40436 2856 36 s s NNP 40436 2856 37 barba barba NNP 40436 2856 38 / / SYM 40436 2856 39 rois rois NNP 40436 2856 40 , , , 40436 2856 41 e(/ôs e(/ôs JJ 40436 2856 42 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 2856 43 to\ to\ NNP 40436 2856 44 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2856 45 o)no o)no VBN 40436 2856 46 / / SYM 40436 2856 47 matos matos NN 40436 2856 48 ei)=dos ei)=dos NFP 40436 2856 49 a)podidô=| a)podidô=| CD 40436 2856 50 to\ to\ NN 40436 2856 51 prosê prosê NNS 40436 2856 52 = = SYM 40436 2856 53 kon kon NNP 40436 2856 54 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 2856 55 / / SYM 40436 2856 56 stô| stô| NNP 40436 2856 57 e)n e)n NNP 40436 2856 58 o(poiaisou o(poiaisou NNP 40436 2856 59 = = SYM 40436 2856 60 n n IN 40436 2856 61 sullabai sullabai NNS 40436 2856 62 = = SYM 40436 2856 63 s s NN 40436 2856 64 , , , 40436 2856 65 ou)de\n ou)de\n NNP 40436 2856 66 chei chei NNP 40436 2856 67 / / SYM 40436 2856 68 rô rô NNP 40436 2856 69 nomothe nomothe NNP 40436 2856 70 / / SYM 40436 2856 71 tên tên NN 40436 2856 72 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 2856 73 to\n to\n NNP 40436 2856 74 e)ntha e)ntha NNP 40436 2856 75 / / SYM 40436 2856 76 de de FW 40436 2856 77 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 2856 78 to\n to\n NNP 40436 2856 79 o(pouou o(pouou NN 40436 2856 80 = = SYM 40436 2856 81 n n CC 40436 2856 82 a)/llothi a)/llothi NN 40436 2856 83 ? ? . 40436 2856 84 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2857 1 Compare compare VB 40436 2857 2 this this DT 40436 2857 3 with with IN 40436 2857 4 the the DT 40436 2857 5 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2857 6 , , , 40436 2857 7 315 315 CD 40436 2857 8 E e NN 40436 2857 9 , , , 40436 2857 10 316 316 CD 40436 2857 11 D d NN 40436 2857 12 , , , 40436 2857 13 where where WRB 40436 2857 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2857 15 evades evade NNS 40436 2857 16 , , , 40436 2857 17 by by IN 40436 2857 18 an an DT 40436 2857 19 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 2857 20 very very RB 40436 2857 21 similar similar JJ 40436 2857 22 , , , 40436 2857 23 the the DT 40436 2857 24 objection objection NN 40436 2857 25 made make VBN 40436 2857 26 by by IN 40436 2857 27 the the DT 40436 2857 28 collocutor collocutor NN 40436 2857 29 , , , 40436 2857 30 that that IN 40436 2857 31 the the DT 40436 2857 32 laws law NNS 40436 2857 33 in in IN 40436 2857 34 one one CD 40436 2857 35 country country NN 40436 2857 36 are be VBP 40436 2857 37 very very RB 40436 2857 38 different different JJ 40436 2857 39 from from IN 40436 2857 40 those those DT 40436 2857 41 in in IN 40436 2857 42 another--[Greek another--[greek CD 40436 2857 43 : : : 40436 2857 44 i)/sôs i)/sôs NN 40436 2857 45 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 2857 46 ou)k ou)k CD 40436 2857 47 e)nnoei e)nnoei NNP 40436 2857 48 = = SYM 40436 2857 49 s s NNP 40436 2857 50 tau tau NNP 40436 2857 51 = = SYM 40436 2857 52 ta ta NNP 40436 2857 53 metapetteuo metapetteuo NNP 40436 2857 54 / / SYM 40436 2857 55 mena mena NNP 40436 2857 56 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 2857 57 tau)ta/ tau)ta/ NNP 40436 2857 58 e)stin e)stin NFP 40436 2857 59 . . . 40436 2857 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2857 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2858 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2858 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2858 3 46 46 CD 40436 2858 4 : : : 40436 2858 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2858 6 , , , 40436 2858 7 Kratyl Kratyl NNP 40436 2858 8 . . . 40436 2859 1 430 430 CD 40436 2859 2 A a DT 40436 2859 3 , , , 40436 2859 4 432 432 CD 40436 2859 5 A a NN 40436 2859 6 , , , 40436 2859 7 433 433 CD 40436 2859 8 D d NN 40436 2859 9 , , , 40436 2859 10 435 435 CD 40436 2859 11 C. C. NNP 40436 2859 12 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 2859 13 says say VBZ 40436 2859 14 that that IN 40436 2859 15 a a DT 40436 2859 16 name name NN 40436 2859 17 badly badly RB 40436 2859 18 given give VBN 40436 2859 19 is be VBZ 40436 2859 20 no no DT 40436 2859 21 name name NN 40436 2859 22 at at RB 40436 2859 23 all all RB 40436 2859 24 ; ; : 40436 2859 25 just just RB 40436 2859 26 as as IN 40436 2859 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2859 28 says say VBZ 40436 2859 29 in in IN 40436 2859 30 the the DT 40436 2859 31 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2859 32 that that WDT 40436 2859 33 a a DT 40436 2859 34 bad bad JJ 40436 2859 35 law law NN 40436 2859 36 is be VBZ 40436 2859 37 no no DT 40436 2859 38 law law NN 40436 2859 39 at at RB 40436 2859 40 all all RB 40436 2859 41 . . . 40436 2859 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2860 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2860 2 Side side NN 40436 2860 3 - - HYPH 40436 2860 4 note note NN 40436 2860 5 : : : 40436 2860 6 Eulogy eulogy NN 40436 2860 7 on on IN 40436 2860 8 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2860 9 , , , 40436 2860 10 as as IN 40436 2860 11 having have VBG 40436 2860 12 established establish VBN 40436 2860 13 laws law NNS 40436 2860 14 on on IN 40436 2860 15 this this DT 40436 2860 16 divine divine JJ 40436 2860 17 type type NN 40436 2860 18 or or CC 40436 2860 19 natural natural JJ 40436 2860 20 rectitude rectitude NN 40436 2860 21 . . . 40436 2860 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2861 1 The the DT 40436 2861 2 Kretan Kretan NNP 40436 2861 3 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2861 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2861 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2861 6 here here RB 40436 2861 7 find find VBP 40436 2861 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2861 9 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 2861 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2861 11 , , , 40436 2861 12 son son NN 40436 2861 13 , , , 40436 2861 14 companion companion NNP 40436 2861 15 , , , 40436 2861 16 and and CC 40436 2861 17 pupil pupil NN 40436 2861 18 of of IN 40436 2861 19 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 2861 20 , , , 40436 2861 21 has have VBZ 40436 2861 22 learnt learn VBN 40436 2861 23 to to TO 40436 2861 24 establish establish VB 40436 2861 25 laws law NNS 40436 2861 26 of of IN 40436 2861 27 this this DT 40436 2861 28 divine divine JJ 40436 2861 29 type type NN 40436 2861 30 or or CC 40436 2861 31 natural natural JJ 40436 2861 32 rectitude rectitude NN 40436 2861 33 : : : 40436 2861 34 the the DT 40436 2861 35 proof proof NN 40436 2861 36 of of IN 40436 2861 37 which which WDT 40436 2861 38 is be VBZ 40436 2861 39 , , , 40436 2861 40 that that IN 40436 2861 41 the the DT 40436 2861 42 ancient ancient JJ 40436 2861 43 Kretan Kretan NNP 40436 2861 44 laws law NNS 40436 2861 45 have have VBP 40436 2861 46 for for IN 40436 2861 47 immemorial immemorial JJ 40436 2861 48 ages age NNS 40436 2861 49 remained remain VBD 40436 2861 50 , , , 40436 2861 51 and and CC 40436 2861 52 still still RB 40436 2861 53 do do VB 40436 2861 54 remain,[47 remain,[47 CD 40436 2861 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2861 56 unchanged unchanged JJ 40436 2861 57 . . . 40436 2862 1 But but CC 40436 2862 2 when when WRB 40436 2862 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2862 4 tries try VBZ 40436 2862 5 to to TO 40436 2862 6 determine determine VB 40436 2862 7 , , , 40436 2862 8 Wherein Wherein NNP 40436 2862 9 consists consist VBZ 40436 2862 10 this this DT 40436 2862 11 Law Law NNP 40436 2862 12 - - HYPH 40436 2862 13 Type Type NNP 40436 2862 14 ? ? . 40436 2863 1 What what WP 40436 2863 2 is be VBZ 40436 2863 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2863 4 that that WDT 40436 2863 5 the the DT 40436 2863 6 wise wise JJ 40436 2863 7 Lawgiver Lawgiver NNP 40436 2863 8 prescribes prescribe NNS 40436 2863 9 for for IN 40436 2863 10 the the DT 40436 2863 11 minds mind NNS 40436 2863 12 of of IN 40436 2863 13 the the DT 40436 2863 14 citizens citizen NNS 40436 2863 15 -- -- : 40436 2863 16 as as IN 40436 2863 17 the the DT 40436 2863 18 wise wise JJ 40436 2863 19 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 2863 20 trainer trainer NN 40436 2863 21 prescribes prescribe VBZ 40436 2863 22 proper proper JJ 40436 2863 23 measure measure NN 40436 2863 24 of of IN 40436 2863 25 nourishment nourishment NN 40436 2863 26 and and CC 40436 2863 27 exercise exercise NN 40436 2863 28 for for IN 40436 2863 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2863 30 bodies?--the bodies?--the JJ 40436 2863 31 question question NN 40436 2863 32 is be VBZ 40436 2863 33 left leave VBN 40436 2863 34 unanswered unanswere VBN 40436 2863 35 . . . 40436 2864 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2864 2 confesses confess VBZ 40436 2864 3 with with IN 40436 2864 4 shame shame NN 40436 2864 5 that that WDT 40436 2864 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2864 7 can can MD 40436 2864 8 not not RB 40436 2864 9 answer answer VB 40436 2864 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2864 11 : : : 40436 2864 12 and and CC 40436 2864 13 the the DT 40436 2864 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2864 15 ends end VBZ 40436 2864 16 in in IN 40436 2864 17 a a DT 40436 2864 18 blank blank NN 40436 2864 19 . . . 40436 2865 1 The the DT 40436 2865 2 reader reader NN 40436 2865 3 -- -- : 40436 2865 4 according accord VBG 40436 2865 5 to to IN 40436 2865 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2865 7 's 's POS 40436 2865 8 manner manner NN 40436 2865 9 -- -- : 40436 2865 10 is be VBZ 40436 2865 11 to to TO 40436 2865 12 be be VB 40436 2865 13 piqued pique VBN 40436 2865 14 and and CC 40436 2865 15 shamed shame VBN 40436 2865 16 into into IN 40436 2865 17 the the DT 40436 2865 18 effort effort NN 40436 2865 19 of of IN 40436 2865 20 meditating meditate VBG 40436 2865 21 the the DT 40436 2865 22 question question NN 40436 2865 23 for for IN 40436 2865 24 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2865 25 . . . 40436 2866 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2866 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2866 3 47 47 CD 40436 2866 4 : : : 40436 2866 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2866 6 , , , 40436 2866 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2866 8 , , , 40436 2866 9 319 319 CD 40436 2866 10 B b NN 40436 2866 11 , , , 40436 2866 12 321 321 CD 40436 2866 13 A. a. NN 40436 2866 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2867 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2867 2 Side side NN 40436 2867 3 - - HYPH 40436 2867 4 note note NN 40436 2867 5 : : : 40436 2867 6 The the DT 40436 2867 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2867 8 was be VBD 40436 2867 9 arranged arrange VBN 40436 2867 10 by by IN 40436 2867 11 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40436 2867 12 at at IN 40436 2867 13 first first RB 40436 2867 14 in in IN 40436 2867 15 a a DT 40436 2867 16 Trilogy trilogy NN 40436 2867 17 along along IN 40436 2867 18 with with IN 40436 2867 19 the the DT 40436 2867 20 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 2867 21 . . . 40436 2867 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2868 1 An an DT 40436 2868 2 attempt attempt NN 40436 2868 3 to to TO 40436 2868 4 answer answer VB 40436 2868 5 this this DT 40436 2868 6 question question NN 40436 2868 7 will will MD 40436 2868 8 be be VB 40436 2868 9 found find VBN 40436 2868 10 in in IN 40436 2868 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2868 12 's 's POS 40436 2868 13 Treatise Treatise NNP 40436 2868 14 De De NNP 40436 2868 15 Legibus Legibus NNP 40436 2868 16 -- -- : 40436 2868 17 in in IN 40436 2868 18 the the DT 40436 2868 19 projected project VBN 40436 2868 20 Kretan Kretan NNP 40436 2868 21 colony colony NN 40436 2868 22 , , , 40436 2868 23 of of IN 40436 2868 24 which which WDT 40436 2868 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2868 26 there there RB 40436 2868 27 sketches sketch VBZ 40436 2868 28 the the DT 40436 2868 29 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 2868 30 laws law NNS 40436 2868 31 . . . 40436 2869 1 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40436 2869 2 of of IN 40436 2869 3 Byzantium Byzantium NNP 40436 2869 4 very very RB 40436 2869 5 naturally naturally RB 40436 2869 6 placed place VBD 40436 2869 7 this this DT 40436 2869 8 treatise treatise NN 40436 2869 9 as as IN 40436 2869 10 sequel sequel NN 40436 2869 11 to to IN 40436 2869 12 the the DT 40436 2869 13 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2869 14 ; ; : 40436 2869 15 second second JJ 40436 2869 16 in in IN 40436 2869 17 the the DT 40436 2869 18 Trilogy Trilogy NNP 40436 2869 19 of of IN 40436 2869 20 which which WDT 40436 2869 21 the the DT 40436 2869 22 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2869 23 was be VBD 40436 2869 24 first first RB 40436 2869 25 . . . 40436 2870 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2870 2 48 48 CD 40436 2870 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2870 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2870 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2870 6 48 48 CD 40436 2870 7 : : : 40436 2870 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2870 9 reserve reserve VBP 40436 2870 10 for for IN 40436 2870 11 an an DT 40436 2870 12 Appendix Appendix NNP 40436 2870 13 some some DT 40436 2870 14 further further JJ 40436 2870 15 remarks remark NNS 40436 2870 16 upon upon IN 40436 2870 17 the the DT 40436 2870 18 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 2870 19 of of IN 40436 2870 20 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2870 21 and and CC 40436 2870 22 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2870 23 . . . 40436 2870 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2871 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2871 2 Side side NN 40436 2871 3 - - HYPH 40436 2871 4 note note NN 40436 2871 5 : : : 40436 2871 6 Explanations explanation NNS 40436 2871 7 of of IN 40436 2871 8 the the DT 40436 2871 9 word word NN 40436 2871 10 Law law NN 40436 2871 11 -- -- : 40436 2871 12 confusion confusion NN 40436 2871 13 in in IN 40436 2871 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2871 15 meaning meaning NN 40436 2871 16 . . . 40436 2871 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2872 1 Whoever whoever WP 40436 2872 2 has have VBZ 40436 2872 3 followed follow VBN 40436 2872 4 the the DT 40436 2872 5 abstract abstract NN 40436 2872 6 of of IN 40436 2872 7 the the DT 40436 2872 8 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2872 9 , , , 40436 2872 10 which which WDT 40436 2872 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2872 12 have have VBP 40436 2872 13 just just RB 40436 2872 14 given give VBN 40436 2872 15 , , , 40436 2872 16 will will MD 40436 2872 17 remark remark VB 40436 2872 18 the the DT 40436 2872 19 different different JJ 40436 2872 20 explanations explanation NNS 40436 2872 21 of of IN 40436 2872 22 the the DT 40436 2872 23 word word NN 40436 2872 24 Law law NN 40436 2872 25 -- -- : 40436 2872 26 both both PDT 40436 2872 27 those those DT 40436 2872 28 which which WDT 40436 2872 29 are be VBP 40436 2872 30 disallowed disallow VBN 40436 2872 31 , , , 40436 2872 32 and and CC 40436 2872 33 that that IN 40436 2872 34 which which WDT 40436 2872 35 is be VBZ 40436 2872 36 preferred prefer VBN 40436 2872 37 , , , 40436 2872 38 though though IN 40436 2872 39 left leave VBN 40436 2872 40 incomplete incomplete JJ 40436 2872 41 , , , 40436 2872 42 by by IN 40436 2872 43 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2872 44 . . . 40436 2873 1 On on IN 40436 2873 2 this this DT 40436 2873 3 same same JJ 40436 2873 4 subject subject NN 40436 2873 5 , , , 40436 2873 6 there there EX 40436 2873 7 are be VBP 40436 2873 8 in in IN 40436 2873 9 many many JJ 40436 2873 10 writers writer NNS 40436 2873 11 , , , 40436 2873 12 modern modern JJ 40436 2873 13 as as RB 40436 2873 14 well well RB 40436 2873 15 an an DT 40436 2873 16 ancient ancient JJ 40436 2873 17 , , , 40436 2873 18 two two CD 40436 2873 19 distinct distinct JJ 40436 2873 20 modes mode NNS 40436 2873 21 of of IN 40436 2873 22 confusion confusion NN 40436 2873 23 traceable traceable JJ 40436 2873 24 -- -- : 40436 2873 25 pointed point VBD 40436 2873 26 out out RP 40436 2873 27 by by IN 40436 2873 28 eminent eminent JJ 40436 2873 29 recent recent JJ 40436 2873 30 jurists jurist NNS 40436 2873 31 , , , 40436 2873 32 such such JJ 40436 2873 33 as as IN 40436 2873 34 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 2873 35 Bentham Bentham NNP 40436 2873 36 , , , 40436 2873 37 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 2873 38 Austin Austin NNP 40436 2873 39 , , , 40436 2873 40 and and CC 40436 2873 41 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 2873 42 Maine Maine NNP 40436 2873 43 . . . 40436 2874 1 1 1 LS 40436 2874 2 . . . 40436 2875 1 Between between IN 40436 2875 2 Law Law NNP 40436 2875 3 as as IN 40436 2875 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2875 5 is be VBZ 40436 2875 6 , , , 40436 2875 7 and and CC 40436 2875 8 Law Law NNP 40436 2875 9 as as IN 40436 2875 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2875 11 ought ought MD 40436 2875 12 to to TO 40436 2875 13 be be VB 40436 2875 14 . . . 40436 2876 1 2 2 LS 40436 2876 2 . . . 40436 2877 1 Between between IN 40436 2877 2 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 2877 3 Imperative Imperative NNP 40436 2877 4 , , , 40436 2877 5 set set VBN 40436 2877 6 by by IN 40436 2877 7 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 2877 8 rulers ruler NNS 40436 2877 9 , , , 40436 2877 10 and and CC 40436 2877 11 enforced enforce VBN 40436 2877 12 by by IN 40436 2877 13 penal penal JJ 40436 2877 14 sanction sanction NN 40436 2877 15 -- -- : 40436 2877 16 and and CC 40436 2877 17 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 2877 18 signifying signify VBG 40436 2877 19 uniformities uniformity NNS 40436 2877 20 of of IN 40436 2877 21 fact fact NN 40436 2877 22 expressed express VBN 40436 2877 23 in in IN 40436 2877 24 general general JJ 40436 2877 25 terms term NNS 40436 2877 26 , , , 40436 2877 27 such such JJ 40436 2877 28 as as IN 40436 2877 29 the the DT 40436 2877 30 Law Law NNP 40436 2877 31 of of IN 40436 2877 32 Gravitation Gravitation NNP 40436 2877 33 , , , 40436 2877 34 Crystallisation Crystallisation NNP 40436 2877 35 , , , 40436 2877 36 & & CC 40436 2877 37 c.--We c.--We NNP 40436 2877 38 can can MD 40436 2877 39 hardly hardly RB 40436 2877 40 say say VB 40436 2877 41 that that IN 40436 2877 42 in in IN 40436 2877 43 the the DT 40436 2877 44 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2877 45 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2877 46 , , , 40436 2877 47 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2877 48 falls fall VBZ 40436 2877 49 into into IN 40436 2877 50 the the DT 40436 2877 51 first first JJ 40436 2877 52 of of IN 40436 2877 53 these these DT 40436 2877 54 two two CD 40436 2877 55 modes mode NNS 40436 2877 56 of of IN 40436 2877 57 confusion confusion NN 40436 2877 58 : : : 40436 2877 59 for for IN 40436 2877 60 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2877 61 expressly expressly RB 40436 2877 62 says say VBZ 40436 2877 63 that that IN 40436 2877 64 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2877 65 only only RB 40436 2877 66 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 2877 67 the the DT 40436 2877 68 Ideal Ideal NNP 40436 2877 69 of of IN 40436 2877 70 Law Law NNP 40436 2877 71 , , , 40436 2877 72 or or CC 40436 2877 73 Law Law NNP 40436 2877 74 as as IN 40436 2877 75 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2877 76 ought ought MD 40436 2877 77 to to TO 40436 2877 78 be be VB 40436 2877 79 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2877 80 actual actual JJ 40436 2877 81 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 2877 82 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 2877 83 being be VBG 40436 2877 84 disallowed disallow VBN 40436 2877 85 , , , 40436 2877 86 except except IN 40436 2877 87 in in IN 40436 2877 88 so so RB 40436 2877 89 far far RB 40436 2877 90 as as IN 40436 2877 91 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2877 92 conform conform VBP 40436 2877 93 thereunto thereunto NNP 40436 2877 94 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2877 95 . . . 40436 2878 1 But but CC 40436 2878 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2878 3 does do VBZ 40436 2878 4 fall fall VB 40436 2878 5 into into IN 40436 2878 6 the the DT 40436 2878 7 second second JJ 40436 2878 8 , , , 40436 2878 9 when when WRB 40436 2878 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2878 11 identifies identify VBZ 40436 2878 12 the the DT 40436 2878 13 Lawful Lawful NNP 40436 2878 14 with with IN 40436 2878 15 the the DT 40436 2878 16 Real Real NNP 40436 2878 17 or or CC 40436 2878 18 Existent Existent NNP 40436 2878 19 . . . 40436 2879 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2879 2 Ideal Ideal NNP 40436 2879 3 stands stand VBZ 40436 2879 4 in in IN 40436 2879 5 place place NN 40436 2879 6 of of IN 40436 2879 7 generalisations generalisation NNS 40436 2879 8 of of IN 40436 2879 9 fact fact NN 40436 2879 10 . . . 40436 2880 1 There there EX 40436 2880 2 is be VBZ 40436 2880 3 also also RB 40436 2880 4 much much JJ 40436 2880 5 confusion confusion NN 40436 2880 6 , , , 40436 2880 7 if if IN 40436 2880 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2880 9 compare compare VBP 40436 2880 10 the the DT 40436 2880 11 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2880 12 with with IN 40436 2880 13 other other JJ 40436 2880 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2880 15 ; ; : 40436 2880 16 wherein wherein WRB 40436 2880 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2880 18 frequently frequently RB 40436 2880 19 talks talk VBZ 40436 2880 20 of of IN 40436 2880 21 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 2880 22 as as IN 40436 2880 23 the the DT 40436 2880 24 laws law NNS 40436 2880 25 and and CC 40436 2880 26 customs custom NNS 40436 2880 27 actually actually RB 40436 2880 28 existing exist VBG 40436 2880 29 or or CC 40436 2880 30 imperative imperative JJ 40436 2880 31 in in IN 40436 2880 32 any any DT 40436 2880 33 given give VBN 40436 2880 34 state state NN 40436 2880 35 -- -- : 40436 2880 36 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2880 37 , , , 40436 2880 38 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 2880 39 , , , 40436 2880 40 or or CC 40436 2880 41 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 2880 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2880 43 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2880 44 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2880 45 : : : 40436 2880 46 No no UH 40436 2880 47 / / SYM 40436 2880 48 mos mo NNS 40436 2880 49 = = NFP 40436 2880 50 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 2880 51 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2880 52 / / SYM 40436 2880 53 mena mena NN 40436 2880 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2880 55 , , , 40436 2880 56 according accord VBG 40436 2880 57 to to IN 40436 2880 58 the the DT 40436 2880 59 first first JJ 40436 2880 60 words word NNS 40436 2880 61 in in IN 40436 2880 62 the the DT 40436 2880 63 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2880 64 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2880 65 . . . 40436 2881 1 For for IN 40436 2881 2 example example NN 40436 2881 3 , , , 40436 2881 4 in in IN 40436 2881 5 the the DT 40436 2881 6 harangue harangue NN 40436 2881 7 which which WDT 40436 2881 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2881 9 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 2881 10 to to TO 40436 2881 11 be be VB 40436 2881 12 addressed address VBN 40436 2881 13 to to IN 40436 2881 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2881 15 in in IN 40436 2881 16 the the DT 40436 2881 17 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 2881 18 , , , 40436 2881 19 and and CC 40436 2881 20 which which WDT 40436 2881 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2881 22 invests invest VBZ 40436 2881 23 with with IN 40436 2881 24 so so RB 40436 2881 25 impressive impressive JJ 40436 2881 26 a a DT 40436 2881 27 character character NN 40436 2881 28 -- -- : 40436 2881 29 the the DT 40436 2881 30 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 2881 31 of of IN 40436 2881 32 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2881 33 are be VBP 40436 2881 34 introduced introduce VBN 40436 2881 35 as as IN 40436 2881 36 speakers speaker NNS 40436 2881 37 : : : 40436 2881 38 but but CC 40436 2881 39 according accord VBG 40436 2881 40 to to IN 40436 2881 41 the the DT 40436 2881 42 principles principle NNS 40436 2881 43 laid lay VBN 40436 2881 44 down down RP 40436 2881 45 in in IN 40436 2881 46 the the DT 40436 2881 47 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2881 48 , , , 40436 2881 49 three three CD 40436 2881 50 - - HYPH 40436 2881 51 fourths fourth NNS 40436 2881 52 of of IN 40436 2881 53 the the DT 40436 2881 54 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 2881 55 of of IN 40436 2881 56 Athens Athens NNP 40436 2881 57 could could MD 40436 2881 58 not not RB 40436 2881 59 be be VB 40436 2881 60 regarded regard VBN 40436 2881 61 as as IN 40436 2881 62 laws law NNS 40436 2881 63 at at RB 40436 2881 64 all all RB 40436 2881 65 . . . 40436 2882 1 If if IN 40436 2882 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 2882 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2882 4 take take VBP 40436 2882 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2882 6 's 's POS 40436 2882 7 writings writing NNS 40436 2882 8 throughout throughout IN 40436 2882 9 , , , 40436 2882 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2882 11 shall shall MD 40436 2882 12 not not RB 40436 2882 13 find find VB 40436 2882 14 that that IN 40436 2882 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2882 16 is be VBZ 40436 2882 17 constant constant JJ 40436 2882 18 to to IN 40436 2882 19 one one CD 40436 2882 20 uniform uniform JJ 40436 2882 21 sense sense NN 40436 2882 22 of of IN 40436 2882 23 the the DT 40436 2882 24 word word NN 40436 2882 25 Law law NN 40436 2882 26 , , , 40436 2882 27 or or CC 40436 2882 28 that that IN 40436 2882 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2882 30 escapes escape VBZ 40436 2882 31 the the DT 40436 2882 32 frequent frequent JJ 40436 2882 33 confusion confusion NN 40436 2882 34 between between IN 40436 2882 35 Law Law NNP 40436 2882 36 as as IN 40436 2882 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2882 38 actually actually RB 40436 2882 39 exists exist VBZ 40436 2882 40 and and CC 40436 2882 41 Law Law NNP 40436 2882 42 as as IN 40436 2882 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2882 44 ought ought MD 40436 2882 45 to to TO 40436 2882 46 be be VB 40436 2882 47 . . . 40436 2883 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2883 2 49 49 CD 40436 2883 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2883 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2883 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 2883 6 49 49 CD 40436 2883 7 : : : 40436 2883 8 The the DT 40436 2883 9 first first JJ 40436 2883 10 explanation explanation NN 40436 2883 11 of of IN 40436 2883 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2883 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2883 14 : : : 40436 2883 15 No no UH 40436 2883 16 / / SYM 40436 2883 17 mos mos NN 40436 2883 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2883 19 advanced advance VBN 40436 2883 20 by by IN 40436 2883 21 the the DT 40436 2883 22 Companion Companion NNP 40436 2883 23 in in IN 40436 2883 24 reply reply NN 40436 2883 25 to to IN 40436 2883 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2883 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2883 28 viz viz NN 40436 2883 29 . . . 40436 2884 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2884 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2884 3 : : : 40436 2884 4 No no UH 40436 2884 5 / / SYM 40436 2884 6 mos mo NNS 40436 2884 7 = = NFP 40436 2884 8 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 2884 9 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2884 10 / / SYM 40436 2884 11 mena mena NN 40436 2884 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2884 13 , , , 40436 2884 14 coincides coincide VBZ 40436 2884 15 substantially substantially RB 40436 2884 16 with with IN 40436 2884 17 the the DT 40436 2884 18 meaning meaning NN 40436 2884 19 of of IN 40436 2884 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2884 21 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2884 22 : : : 40436 2884 23 No no UH 40436 2884 24 / / SYM 40436 2884 25 mos mos NN 40436 2884 26 basileu\s basileu\s NN 40436 2884 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2884 28 in in IN 40436 2884 29 Pindar Pindar NNP 40436 2884 30 and and CC 40436 2884 31 Herodotus Herodotus NNP 40436 2884 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2884 33 see see VB 40436 2884 34 above above RB 40436 2884 35 , , , 40436 2884 36 chap chap NNP 40436 2884 37 . . . 40436 2885 1 viii viii RB 40436 2885 2 . . . 40436 2886 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2886 2 , , , 40436 2886 3 who who WP 40436 2886 4 is be VBZ 40436 2886 5 an an DT 40436 2886 6 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 2886 7 ruler ruler NN 40436 2886 8 , , , 40436 2886 9 occupying occupy VBG 40436 2886 10 a a DT 40436 2886 11 given give VBN 40436 2886 12 region region NN 40436 2886 13 , , , 40436 2886 14 and and CC 40436 2886 15 enforcing enforce VBG 40436 2886 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2886 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2886 18 : : : 40436 2886 19 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 2886 20 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2886 21 / / SYM 40436 2886 22 mena mena NN 40436 2886 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2886 24 . . . 40436 2887 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2887 2 coincides coincide VBZ 40436 2887 3 also also RB 40436 2887 4 with with IN 40436 2887 5 the the DT 40436 2887 6 precept precept NN 40436 2887 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2887 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2887 9 : : : 40436 2887 10 No no UH 40436 2887 11 / / SYM 40436 2887 12 mô| mô| NNP 40436 2887 13 po po NN 40436 2887 14 / / SYM 40436 2887 15 leôs leôs NN 40436 2887 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2887 17 , , , 40436 2887 18 as as IN 40436 2887 19 prescribed prescribe VBN 40436 2887 20 by by IN 40436 2887 21 the the DT 40436 2887 22 Pythian pythian JJ 40436 2887 23 priestess priestess NN 40436 2887 24 to to IN 40436 2887 25 applicants applicant NNS 40436 2887 26 who who WP 40436 2887 27 asked ask VBD 40436 2887 28 advice advice NN 40436 2887 29 about about IN 40436 2887 30 the the DT 40436 2887 31 proper proper JJ 40436 2887 32 forms form NNS 40436 2887 33 of of IN 40436 2887 34 religious religious JJ 40436 2887 35 worship worship NN 40436 2887 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2887 37 Xen Xen NNP 40436 2887 38 . . . 40436 2888 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 2888 2 . . . 40436 2889 1 i. i. NNP 40436 2890 1 3 3 CD 40436 2890 2 , , , 40436 2890 3 1 1 CD 40436 2890 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2890 5 ; ; : 40436 2890 6 though though IN 40436 2890 7 this this DT 40436 2890 8 precept precept NN 40436 2890 9 , , , 40436 2890 10 when when WRB 40436 2890 11 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 2890 12 comes come VBZ 40436 2890 13 to to TO 40436 2890 14 report report VB 40436 2890 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2890 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2890 17 Legg Legg NNP 40436 2890 18 . . . 40436 2891 1 ii ii LS 40436 2891 2 . . . 40436 2892 1 16 16 CD 40436 2892 2 , , , 40436 2892 3 40 40 CD 40436 2892 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2892 5 , , , 40436 2892 6 appears appear VBZ 40436 2892 7 divested divest VBN 40436 2892 8 of of IN 40436 2892 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2892 10 simplicity simplicity NN 40436 2892 11 , , , 40436 2892 12 and and CC 40436 2892 13 over over RB 40436 2892 14 - - HYPH 40436 2892 15 clouded clouded JJ 40436 2892 16 with with IN 40436 2892 17 the the DT 40436 2892 18 very very JJ 40436 2892 19 confusion confusion NN 40436 2892 20 touched touch VBN 40436 2892 21 upon upon IN 40436 2892 22 in in IN 40436 2892 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2892 24 text text NN 40436 2892 25 . . . 40436 2893 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 2893 2 does do VBZ 40436 2893 3 not not RB 40436 2893 4 keep keep VB 40436 2893 5 clear clear JJ 40436 2893 6 of of IN 40436 2893 7 the the DT 40436 2893 8 confusion confusion NN 40436 2893 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2893 10 compare compare VB 40436 2893 11 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 2893 12 . . . 40436 2894 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 2894 2 . . . 40436 2895 1 i. i. NNP 40436 2896 1 1 1 CD 40436 2896 2 , , , 40436 2896 3 1094 1094 CD 40436 2896 4 , , , 40436 2896 5 b. b. NNP 40436 2897 1 16 16 CD 40436 2897 2 , , , 40436 2897 3 and and CC 40436 2897 4 v. v. CC 40436 2897 5 5 5 CD 40436 2897 6 , , , 40436 2897 7 1130 1130 CD 40436 2897 8 , , , 40436 2897 9 b. b. NNP 40436 2898 1 24 24 CD 40436 2898 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2898 3 . . . 40436 2899 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2899 2 shall shall MD 40436 2899 3 revert revert VB 40436 2899 4 again again RB 40436 2899 5 to to IN 40436 2899 6 the the DT 40436 2899 7 distinction distinction NN 40436 2899 8 between between IN 40436 2899 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2899 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2899 11 : : : 40436 2899 12 no no UH 40436 2899 13 / / SYM 40436 2899 14 mos mos NN 40436 2899 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2899 16 and and CC 40436 2899 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2899 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2899 19 : : : 40436 2899 20 phu phu NN 40436 2899 21 / / SYM 40436 2899 22 sis sis NNP 40436 2899 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2899 24 , , , 40436 2899 25 in in IN 40436 2899 26 touching touch VBG 40436 2899 27 on on IN 40436 2899 28 other other JJ 40436 2899 29 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2899 30 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2899 31 . . . 40436 2900 1 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 2900 2 expressly expressly RB 40436 2900 3 declares declare VBZ 40436 2900 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2900 5 Legg Legg NNP 40436 2900 6 . . . 40436 2901 1 ii ii LS 40436 2901 2 . . . 40436 2902 1 5 5 CD 40436 2902 2 , , , 40436 2902 3 11 11 CD 40436 2902 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2902 5 , , , 40436 2902 6 conformably conformably RB 40436 2902 7 to to IN 40436 2902 8 what what WP 40436 2902 9 is be VBZ 40436 2902 10 said say VBN 40436 2902 11 by by IN 40436 2902 12 the the DT 40436 2902 13 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2902 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2902 15 in in IN 40436 2902 16 the the DT 40436 2902 17 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2902 18 , , , 40436 2902 19 that that IN 40436 2902 20 a a DT 40436 2902 21 bad bad JJ 40436 2902 22 law law NN 40436 2902 23 , , , 40436 2902 24 however however RB 40436 2902 25 passed pass VBN 40436 2902 26 in in IN 40436 2902 27 regular regular JJ 40436 2902 28 form form NN 40436 2902 29 , , , 40436 2902 30 is be VBZ 40436 2902 31 no no DT 40436 2902 32 law law NN 40436 2902 33 at at RB 40436 2902 34 all all RB 40436 2902 35 ; ; : 40436 2902 36 and and CC 40436 2902 37 this this DT 40436 2902 38 might may MD 40436 2902 39 be be VB 40436 2902 40 well well RB 40436 2902 41 if if IN 40436 2902 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2902 43 adhered adhere VBD 40436 2902 44 consistently consistently RB 40436 2902 45 to to IN 40436 2902 46 the the DT 40436 2902 47 same same JJ 40436 2902 48 phraseology phraseology NN 40436 2902 49 , , , 40436 2902 50 but but CC 40436 2902 51 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2902 52 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 2902 53 uses use VBZ 40436 2902 54 , , , 40436 2902 55 in in IN 40436 2902 56 other other JJ 40436 2902 57 places place NNS 40436 2902 58 , , , 40436 2902 59 the the DT 40436 2902 60 words word NNS 40436 2902 61 _ _ NNP 40436 2902 62 Lex Lex NNP 40436 2902 63 _ _ NNP 40436 2902 64 and and CC 40436 2902 65 _ _ NNP 40436 2902 66 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 2902 67 _ _ NNP 40436 2902 68 to to TO 40436 2902 69 signify signify VB 40436 2902 70 laws law NNS 40436 2902 71 actually actually RB 40436 2902 72 in in IN 40436 2902 73 force force NN 40436 2902 74 at at IN 40436 2902 75 Rome Rome NNP 40436 2902 76 , , , 40436 2902 77 good good JJ 40436 2902 78 or or CC 40436 2902 79 bad bad JJ 40436 2902 80 . . . 40436 2903 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 2903 2 Bentham Bentham NNP 40436 2903 3 gives give VBZ 40436 2903 4 an an DT 40436 2903 5 explanation explanation NN 40436 2903 6 of of IN 40436 2903 7 Law Law NNP 40436 2903 8 or or CC 40436 2903 9 The the DT 40436 2903 10 Law Law NNP 40436 2903 11 , , , 40436 2903 12 which which WDT 40436 2903 13 coincides coincide VBZ 40436 2903 14 with with IN 40436 2903 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2903 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2903 17 : : : 40436 2903 18 No no UH 40436 2903 19 / / SYM 40436 2903 20 mos mo NNS 40436 2903 21 = = NFP 40436 2903 22 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 2903 23 nomizo nomizo NN 40436 2903 24 / / SYM 40436 2903 25 mena mena NN 40436 2903 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2903 27 . . . 40436 2904 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2904 2 says say VBZ 40436 2904 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2904 4 Principles principle NNS 40436 2904 5 of of IN 40436 2904 6 Morals Morals NNPS 40436 2904 7 and and CC 40436 2904 8 Legislation Legislation NNP 40436 2904 9 , , , 40436 2904 10 vol vol NNP 40436 2904 11 . . . 40436 2905 1 ii ii LS 40436 2905 2 . . . 40436 2906 1 ch ch NNP 40436 2906 2 . . . 40436 2907 1 17 17 CD 40436 2907 2 , , , 40436 2907 3 p. p. NN 40436 2907 4 257 257 CD 40436 2907 5 , , , 40436 2907 6 ed ed NN 40436 2907 7 . . . 40436 2908 1 1823 1823 CD 40436 2908 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2908 3 , , , 40436 2908 4 " " `` 40436 2908 5 Now now RB 40436 2908 6 Law Law NNP 40436 2908 7 , , , 40436 2908 8 or or CC 40436 2908 9 The the DT 40436 2908 10 Law Law NNP 40436 2908 11 , , , 40436 2908 12 taken take VBN 40436 2908 13 indefinitely indefinitely RB 40436 2908 14 , , , 40436 2908 15 is be VBZ 40436 2908 16 an an DT 40436 2908 17 abstract abstract JJ 40436 2908 18 and and CC 40436 2908 19 collective collective JJ 40436 2908 20 term term NN 40436 2908 21 , , , 40436 2908 22 which which WDT 40436 2908 23 , , , 40436 2908 24 when when WRB 40436 2908 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2908 26 means mean VBZ 40436 2908 27 anything anything NN 40436 2908 28 , , , 40436 2908 29 can can MD 40436 2908 30 mean mean VB 40436 2908 31 neither neither CC 40436 2908 32 more more JJR 40436 2908 33 nor nor CC 40436 2908 34 less less JJR 40436 2908 35 than than IN 40436 2908 36 the the DT 40436 2908 37 sum sum NN 40436 2908 38 total total NN 40436 2908 39 of of IN 40436 2908 40 a a DT 40436 2908 41 number number NN 40436 2908 42 of of IN 40436 2908 43 individual individual JJ 40436 2908 44 laws law NNS 40436 2908 45 taken take VBN 40436 2908 46 together together RB 40436 2908 47 " " '' 40436 2908 48 . . . 40436 2909 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 2909 2 Austin Austin NNP 40436 2909 3 in in IN 40436 2909 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2909 5 Lectures lecture NNS 40436 2909 6 , , , 40436 2909 7 ' ' '' 40436 2909 8 The the DT 40436 2909 9 Province Province NNP 40436 2909 10 of of IN 40436 2909 11 Jurisprudence Jurisprudence NNP 40436 2909 12 Determined Determined NNP 40436 2909 13 ' ' '' 40436 2909 14 , , , 40436 2909 15 has have VBZ 40436 2909 16 explained explain VBN 40436 2909 17 more more RBR 40436 2909 18 clearly clearly RB 40436 2909 19 and and CC 40436 2909 20 copiously copiously RB 40436 2909 21 than than IN 40436 2909 22 any any DT 40436 2909 23 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 2909 24 author author NN 40436 2909 25 , , , 40436 2909 26 the the DT 40436 2909 27 confused confused JJ 40436 2909 28 meanings meaning NNS 40436 2909 29 of of IN 40436 2909 30 the the DT 40436 2909 31 word word NN 40436 2909 32 Law Law NNP 40436 2909 33 adverted advert VBD 40436 2909 34 to to IN 40436 2909 35 in in IN 40436 2909 36 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2909 37 text text NN 40436 2909 38 . . . 40436 2910 1 See see VB 40436 2910 2 especially especially RB 40436 2910 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2910 4 first first JJ 40436 2910 5 lecture lecture NN 40436 2910 6 and and CC 40436 2910 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2910 8 fifth fifth JJ 40436 2910 9 , , , 40436 2910 10 pp pp NNP 40436 2910 11 . . . 40436 2911 1 88 88 CD 40436 2911 2 seq seq NN 40436 2911 3 . . . 40436 2912 1 and and CC 40436 2912 2 171 171 CD 40436 2912 3 seq seq NN 40436 2912 4 . . . 40436 2912 5 , , , 40436 2912 6 4th 4th NNP 40436 2912 7 ed ed NNP 40436 2912 8 . . . 40436 2912 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2913 1 * * NFP 40436 2913 2 * * NFP 40436 2913 3 * * NFP 40436 2913 4 * * NFP 40436 2913 5 * * NFP 40436 2913 6 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 40436 2913 7 . . . 40436 2914 1 In in IN 40436 2914 2 continuing continue VBG 40436 2914 3 to to TO 40436 2914 4 recognise recognise VB 40436 2914 5 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2914 6 and and CC 40436 2914 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2914 8 as as IN 40436 2914 9 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2914 10 works work NNS 40436 2914 11 , , , 40436 2914 12 contrary contrary JJ 40436 2914 13 to to IN 40436 2914 14 the the DT 40436 2914 15 opinion opinion NN 40436 2914 16 of of IN 40436 2914 17 many many JJ 40436 2914 18 modern modern JJ 40436 2914 19 critics critic NNS 40436 2914 20 , , , 40436 2914 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2914 22 have have VBP 40436 2914 23 to to TO 40436 2914 24 remind remind VB 40436 2914 25 the the DT 40436 2914 26 reader reader NN 40436 2914 27 , , , 40436 2914 28 not not RB 40436 2914 29 only only RB 40436 2914 30 that that IN 40436 2914 31 both both DT 40436 2914 32 are be VBP 40436 2914 33 included include VBN 40436 2914 34 in in IN 40436 2914 35 the the DT 40436 2914 36 Canon Canon NNP 40436 2914 37 of of IN 40436 2914 38 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 2914 39 , , , 40436 2914 40 but but CC 40436 2914 41 that that IN 40436 2914 42 the the DT 40436 2914 43 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2914 44 was be VBD 40436 2914 45 expressly expressly RB 40436 2914 46 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 2914 47 by by IN 40436 2914 48 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40436 2914 49 of of IN 40436 2914 50 Byzantium Byzantium NNP 40436 2914 51 , , , 40436 2914 52 and and CC 40436 2914 53 included include VBN 40436 2914 54 by by IN 40436 2914 55 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2914 56 among among IN 40436 2914 57 the the DT 40436 2914 58 Trilogies Trilogies NNP 40436 2914 59 : : : 40436 2914 60 showing show VBG 40436 2914 61 that that IN 40436 2914 62 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2914 63 existed exist VBD 40436 2914 64 then then RB 40436 2914 65 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2914 66 220 220 CD 40436 2914 67 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 2914 68 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2915 1 in in IN 40436 2915 2 the the DT 40436 2915 3 Alexandrine Alexandrine NNP 40436 2915 4 Museum Museum NNP 40436 2915 5 as as IN 40436 2915 6 a a DT 40436 2915 7 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2915 8 work work NN 40436 2915 9 . . . 40436 2916 1 The the DT 40436 2916 2 similarity similarity NN 40436 2916 3 between between IN 40436 2916 4 the the DT 40436 2916 5 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2916 6 and and CC 40436 2916 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2916 8 is be VBZ 40436 2916 9 recognised recognise VBN 40436 2916 10 by by IN 40436 2916 11 all all PDT 40436 2916 12 the the DT 40436 2916 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2916 14 critics critic NNS 40436 2916 15 , , , 40436 2916 16 most most JJS 40436 2916 17 of of IN 40436 2916 18 whom whom WP 40436 2916 19 declare declare VBP 40436 2916 20 that that IN 40436 2916 21 both both DT 40436 2916 22 of of IN 40436 2916 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2916 24 are be VBP 40436 2916 25 spurious spurious JJ 40436 2916 26 . . . 40436 2917 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2917 2 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 2917 3 and and CC 40436 2917 4 vindicates vindicate VBZ 40436 2917 5 this this DT 40436 2917 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 2917 7 in in IN 40436 2917 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2917 9 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 2917 10 and and CC 40436 2917 11 notes note NNS 40436 2917 12 : : : 40436 2917 13 but but CC 40436 2917 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2917 15 will will MD 40436 2917 16 be be VB 40436 2917 17 convenient convenient JJ 40436 2917 18 to to TO 40436 2917 19 take take VB 40436 2917 20 the the DT 40436 2917 21 arguments argument NNS 40436 2917 22 advanced advance VBN 40436 2917 23 to to TO 40436 2917 24 prove prove VB 40436 2917 25 the the DT 40436 2917 26 spuriousness spuriousness NN 40436 2917 27 , , , 40436 2917 28 as as IN 40436 2917 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2917 30 are be VBP 40436 2917 31 set set VBN 40436 2917 32 forth forth RP 40436 2917 33 by by IN 40436 2917 34 M. M. NNP 40436 2917 35 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2917 36 , , , 40436 2917 37 in in IN 40436 2917 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2917 39 " " `` 40436 2917 40 Comment comment NN 40436 2917 41 . . . 40436 2918 1 in in IN 40436 2918 2 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 2918 3 qui qui VBD 40436 2918 4 vulgo vulgo NN 40436 2918 5 fertur fertur JJ 40436 2918 6 Minoem Minoem NNP 40436 2918 7 " " '' 40436 2918 8 : : : 40436 2918 9 in in IN 40436 2918 10 which which WDT 40436 2918 11 treatise treatise NN 40436 2918 12 , , , 40436 2918 13 though though IN 40436 2918 14 among among IN 40436 2918 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2918 16 early early JJ 40436 2918 17 works work NNS 40436 2918 18 , , , 40436 2918 19 the the DT 40436 2918 20 case case NN 40436 2918 21 is be VBZ 40436 2918 22 argued argue VBN 40436 2918 23 with with IN 40436 2918 24 all all DT 40436 2918 25 that that DT 40436 2918 26 copious copious JJ 40436 2918 27 learning learning NN 40436 2918 28 and and CC 40436 2918 29 critical critical JJ 40436 2918 30 ability ability NN 40436 2918 31 , , , 40436 2918 32 which which WDT 40436 2918 33 usually usually RB 40436 2918 34 adorn adorn VBP 40436 2918 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2918 36 many many JJ 40436 2918 37 admirable admirable JJ 40436 2918 38 contributions contribution NNS 40436 2918 39 to to IN 40436 2918 40 the the DT 40436 2918 41 improvement improvement NN 40436 2918 42 of of IN 40436 2918 43 philology philology NN 40436 2918 44 . . . 40436 2919 1 M. M. NNP 40436 2919 2 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2919 3 not not RB 40436 2919 4 only only RB 40436 2919 5 rejects reject VBZ 40436 2919 6 the the DT 40436 2919 7 pretensions pretension NNS 40436 2919 8 of of IN 40436 2919 9 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2919 10 and and CC 40436 2919 11 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2919 12 to to TO 40436 2919 13 be be VB 40436 2919 14 considered consider VBN 40436 2919 15 as as IN 40436 2919 16 works work NNS 40436 2919 17 of of IN 40436 2919 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2919 19 , , , 40436 2919 20 but but CC 40436 2919 21 advances advance VBZ 40436 2919 22 an an DT 40436 2919 23 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 2919 24 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 2919 25 to to TO 40436 2919 26 show show VB 40436 2919 27 what what WP 40436 2919 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2919 29 are be VBP 40436 2919 30 . . . 40436 2920 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2920 2 considers consider VBZ 40436 2920 3 these these DT 40436 2920 4 two two CD 40436 2920 5 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2920 6 , , , 40436 2920 7 together together RB 40436 2920 8 with with IN 40436 2920 9 those those DT 40436 2920 10 De De NNP 40436 2920 11 Justo Justo NNP 40436 2920 12 , , , 40436 2920 13 and and CC 40436 2920 14 De De NNP 40436 2920 15 Virtute Virtute NNP 40436 2920 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2920 17 two two CD 40436 2920 18 short short JJ 40436 2920 19 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2920 20 in in IN 40436 2920 21 the the DT 40436 2920 22 pseudo pseudo JJ 40436 2920 23 - - JJ 40436 2920 24 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2920 25 list list NN 40436 2920 26 , , , 40436 2920 27 not not RB 40436 2920 28 recognised recognise VBN 40436 2920 29 by by IN 40436 2920 30 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 2920 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2920 32 as as IN 40436 2920 33 among among IN 40436 2920 34 the the DT 40436 2920 35 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2920 36 published publish VBN 40436 2920 37 by by IN 40436 2920 38 Simon Simon NNP 40436 2920 39 ; ; : 40436 2920 40 an an DT 40436 2920 41 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 2920 42 citizen citizen NN 40436 2920 43 and and CC 40436 2920 44 a a DT 40436 2920 45 shoemaker shoemaker NN 40436 2920 46 by by IN 40436 2920 47 trade trade NN 40436 2920 48 , , , 40436 2920 49 in in IN 40436 2920 50 whose whose WP$ 40436 2920 51 shop shop NN 40436 2920 52 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2920 53 is be VBZ 40436 2920 54 said say VBN 40436 2920 55 to to TO 40436 2920 56 have have VB 40436 2920 57 held hold VBN 40436 2920 58 many many JJ 40436 2920 59 of of IN 40436 2920 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2920 61 conversations conversation NNS 40436 2920 62 . . . 40436 2921 1 Simon Simon NNP 40436 2921 2 is be VBZ 40436 2921 3 reported report VBN 40436 2921 4 to to TO 40436 2921 5 have have VB 40436 2921 6 made make VBN 40436 2921 7 many many JJ 40436 2921 8 notes note NNS 40436 2921 9 of of IN 40436 2921 10 these these DT 40436 2921 11 conversations conversation NNS 40436 2921 12 , , , 40436 2921 13 and and CC 40436 2921 14 to to TO 40436 2921 15 have have VB 40436 2921 16 composed compose VBN 40436 2921 17 and and CC 40436 2921 18 published publish VBN 40436 2921 19 , , , 40436 2921 20 from from IN 40436 2921 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2921 22 , , , 40436 2921 23 a a DT 40436 2921 24 volume volume NN 40436 2921 25 of of IN 40436 2921 26 thirty thirty CD 40436 2921 27 - - HYPH 40436 2921 28 three three CD 40436 2921 29 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2921 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2921 31 Diog diog VB 40436 2921 32 . . . 40436 2922 1 L. L. NNP 40436 2922 2 ii ii NNP 40436 2922 3 . . . 40436 2923 1 122 122 CD 40436 2923 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2923 3 , , , 40436 2923 4 among among IN 40436 2923 5 the the DT 40436 2923 6 titles title NNS 40436 2923 7 of of IN 40436 2923 8 which which WDT 40436 2923 9 there there EX 40436 2923 10 are be VBP 40436 2923 11 two--[Greek two--[greek NN 40436 2923 12 : : : 40436 2923 13 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 2923 14 Philkerdou Philkerdou NNP 40436 2923 15 = = SYM 40436 2923 16 s s NN 40436 2923 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2923 18 and and CC 40436 2923 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2923 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2923 21 : : : 40436 2923 22 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 2923 23 No no NN 40436 2923 24 / / SYM 40436 2923 25 mou mou NN 40436 2923 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2923 27 . . . 40436 2924 1 Simon Simon NNP 40436 2924 2 was be VBD 40436 2924 3 , , , 40436 2924 4 of of IN 40436 2924 5 course course NN 40436 2924 6 , , , 40436 2924 7 contemporary contemporary JJ 40436 2924 8 with with IN 40436 2924 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2924 10 ; ; : 40436 2924 11 but but CC 40436 2924 12 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 2924 13 older old JJR 40436 2924 14 in in IN 40436 2924 15 years year NNS 40436 2924 16 . . . 40436 2925 1 With with IN 40436 2925 2 this this DT 40436 2925 3 part part NN 40436 2925 4 of of IN 40436 2925 5 M. M. NNP 40436 2925 6 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2925 7 's 's POS 40436 2925 8 treatise treatise NN 40436 2925 9 , , , 40436 2925 10 respecting respect VBG 40436 2925 11 the the DT 40436 2925 12 supposed suppose VBN 40436 2925 13 authorship authorship NN 40436 2925 14 of of IN 40436 2925 15 Simon Simon NNP 40436 2925 16 , , , 40436 2925 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2925 18 have have VBP 40436 2925 19 nothing nothing NN 40436 2925 20 to to TO 40436 2925 21 do do VB 40436 2925 22 . . . 40436 2926 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2926 2 only only RB 40436 2926 3 notice notice VBP 40436 2926 4 the the DT 40436 2926 5 arguments argument NNS 40436 2926 6 by by IN 40436 2926 7 which which WDT 40436 2926 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2926 9 proposes propose VBZ 40436 2926 10 to to TO 40436 2926 11 show show VB 40436 2926 12 that that IN 40436 2926 13 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2926 14 and and CC 40436 2926 15 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2926 16 are be VBP 40436 2926 17 not not RB 40436 2926 18 works work NNS 40436 2926 19 of of IN 40436 2926 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2926 21 . . . 40436 2927 1 In in IN 40436 2927 2 the the DT 40436 2927 3 first first JJ 40436 2927 4 place place NN 40436 2927 5 , , , 40436 2927 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2927 7 notice notice VBP 40436 2927 8 that that IN 40436 2927 9 M. M. NNP 40436 2927 10 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2927 11 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 2927 12 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 2927 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2927 14 as as IN 40436 2927 15 works work NNS 40436 2927 16 of of IN 40436 2927 17 an an DT 40436 2927 18 author author NN 40436 2927 19 contemporary contemporary NN 40436 2927 20 with with IN 40436 2927 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2927 22 , , , 40436 2927 23 not not RB 40436 2927 24 later later RB 40436 2927 25 than than IN 40436 2927 26 380 380 CD 40436 2927 27 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 2928 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2928 2 p. p. NN 40436 2928 3 46 46 CD 40436 2928 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2928 5 . . . 40436 2929 1 Hereby Hereby NNP 40436 2929 2 many many JJ 40436 2929 3 of of IN 40436 2929 4 the the DT 40436 2929 5 tests test NNS 40436 2929 6 , , , 40436 2929 7 whereby whereby WRB 40436 2929 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2929 9 usually usually RB 40436 2929 10 detect detect VBP 40436 2929 11 spurious spurious JJ 40436 2929 12 works work NNS 40436 2929 13 , , , 40436 2929 14 become become VB 40436 2929 15 inapplicable inapplicable JJ 40436 2929 16 . . . 40436 2930 1 In in IN 40436 2930 2 the the DT 40436 2930 3 second second JJ 40436 2930 4 place place NN 40436 2930 5 , , , 40436 2930 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2930 7 admits admit VBZ 40436 2930 8 that that IN 40436 2930 9 the the DT 40436 2930 10 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2930 11 are be VBP 40436 2930 12 composed compose VBN 40436 2930 13 in in IN 40436 2930 14 good good JJ 40436 2930 15 Attic Attic NNP 40436 2930 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2930 17 , , , 40436 2930 18 suitable suitable JJ 40436 2930 19 to to IN 40436 2930 20 the the DT 40436 2930 21 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2930 22 age age NN 40436 2930 23 both both CC 40436 2930 24 in in IN 40436 2930 25 character character NN 40436 2930 26 and and CC 40436 2930 27 manners--"At manners--"At NNP 40436 2930 28 veteris veteris NNP 40436 2930 29 esse esse NNP 40436 2930 30 et et NNP 40436 2930 31 Attici Attici NNP 40436 2930 32 scriptoris scriptoris NNP 40436 2930 33 , , , 40436 2930 34 probus probus NNP 40436 2930 35 sermo sermo NNP 40436 2930 36 , , , 40436 2930 37 antiqui antiqui NNP 40436 2930 38 mores more NNS 40436 2930 39 , , , 40436 2930 40 totus totus NN 40436 2930 41 denique denique NN 40436 2930 42 character character NN 40436 2930 43 , , , 40436 2930 44 spondeat spondeat NN 40436 2930 45 , , , 40436 2930 46 " " '' 40436 2930 47 p. p. NN 40436 2930 48 32 32 CD 40436 2930 49 . . . 40436 2931 1 The the DT 40436 2931 2 reasons reason NNS 40436 2931 3 urged urge VBN 40436 2931 4 by by IN 40436 2931 5 M. M. NNP 40436 2931 6 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2931 7 to to TO 40436 2931 8 prove prove VB 40436 2931 9 the the DT 40436 2931 10 spuriousness spuriousness NN 40436 2931 11 of of IN 40436 2931 12 the the DT 40436 2931 13 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2931 14 , , , 40436 2931 15 are be VBP 40436 2931 16 first first JJ 40436 2931 17 , , , 40436 2931 18 that that IN 40436 2931 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2931 20 is be VBZ 40436 2931 21 unlike unlike IN 40436 2931 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2931 23 -- -- : 40436 2931 24 next next RB 40436 2931 25 , , , 40436 2931 26 that that IN 40436 2931 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2931 28 is be VBZ 40436 2931 29 too too RB 40436 2931 30 much much JJ 40436 2931 31 like like IN 40436 2931 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2931 33 . . . 40436 2932 1 " " `` 40436 2932 2 Dupliciter dupliciter VB 40436 2932 3 dialogus dialogus NN 40436 2932 4 a a DT 40436 2932 5 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 2932 6 ingenio ingenio NN 40436 2932 7 discrepat discrepat NNS 40436 2932 8 : : : 40436 2932 9 partim partim JJ 40436 2932 10 quod quod NN 40436 2932 11 parum parum NNP 40436 2932 12 , , , 40436 2932 13 partim partim JJ 40436 2932 14 quod quod NN 40436 2932 15 nimium nimium NNP 40436 2932 16 , , , 40436 2932 17 similis similis NNP 40436 2932 18 ceteris ceteris NNP 40436 2932 19 ejusdem ejusdem NNP 40436 2932 20 scriptis scriptis NNP 40436 2932 21 sit sit VBP 40436 2932 22 . . . 40436 2933 1 Parum Parum NNP 40436 2933 2 similis similis NNP 40436 2933 3 est est NNP 40436 2933 4 in in IN 40436 2933 5 rebus rebus NNP 40436 2933 6 permultis permultis NNP 40436 2933 7 . . . 40436 2934 1 Nam Nam NNP 40436 2934 2 cum cum NNP 40436 2934 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2934 4 adhuc adhuc VBP 40436 2934 5 vivos vivos NNP 40436 2934 6 ac ac NNP 40436 2934 7 videntes videntes NNP 40436 2934 8 aut aut NNP 40436 2934 9 nuper nuper NNP 40436 2934 10 defunctos defunctos NNP 40436 2934 11 notosque notosque NNP 40436 2934 12 homines homines NNPS 40436 2934 13 , , , 40436 2934 14 ut ut NNP 40436 2934 15 scenicus scenicus NNP 40436 2934 16 poeta poeta NNP 40436 2934 17 actores actores NNP 40436 2934 18 , , , 40436 2934 19 moribus moribus NNP 40436 2934 20 ingeniisque ingeniisque NNP 40436 2934 21 accurate accurate NNP 40436 2934 22 descriptis descriptis NNP 40436 2934 23 , , , 40436 2934 24 nominatim nominatim NNP 40436 2934 25 producat producat NN 40436 2934 26 in in IN 40436 2934 27 medium medium NN 40436 2934 28 -- -- : 40436 2934 29 in in IN 40436 2934 30 isto isto NNP 40436 2934 31 opusculo opusculo JJ 40436 2934 32 cum cum NNP 40436 2934 33 Socrate Socrate NNP 40436 2934 34 colloquens colloquen NNS 40436 2934 35 persona persona NN 40436 2934 36 plané plané NN 40436 2934 37 incerta incerta NNP 40436 2934 38 est est NNP 40436 2934 39 ac ac IN 40436 2934 40 nomine nomine NNP 40436 2934 41 carens caren VBZ 40436 2934 42 : : : 40436 2934 43 quippe quippe NNP 40436 2934 44 cum cum NNP 40436 2934 45 imperitus imperitus NNP 40436 2934 46 scriptor scriptor NNP 40436 2934 47 esset esset NN 40436 2934 48 artis artis NNP 40436 2934 49 illius illius NNP 40436 2934 50 colloquiis colloquiis NNP 40436 2934 51 suis suis NNP 40436 2934 52 _ _ NNP 40436 2934 53 dulcissimas dulcissimas NNP 40436 2934 54 veneres veneres NNP 40436 2934 55 _ _ NNP 40436 2934 56 illas illas NNP 40436 2934 57 inferendi inferendi NNP 40436 2934 58 , , , 40436 2934 59 quæ quæ NNP 40436 2934 60 ex ex NNP 40436 2934 61 peculiaribus peculiaribus NNP 40436 2934 62 personarum personarum NNP 40436 2934 63 moribus moribus NNP 40436 2934 64 pingendis pingendis NNP 40436 2934 65 redundant redundant NNP 40436 2934 66 , , , 40436 2934 67 atque atque NNP 40436 2934 68 à à NNP 40436 2934 69 Platone platone NN 40436 2934 70 ut ut UH 40436 2934 71 flores flore NNS 40436 2934 72 per per IN 40436 2934 73 amplos amplos NNP 40436 2934 74 dialogorum dialogorum NNP 40436 2934 75 hortos hortos NNP 40436 2934 76 sunt sunt NNP 40436 2934 77 disseminatæ disseminatæ NNP 40436 2934 78 " " '' 40436 2934 79 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2934 80 pp pp NNP 40436 2934 81 . . . 40436 2935 1 7 7 CD 40436 2935 2 - - SYM 40436 2935 3 8 8 CD 40436 2935 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2935 5 : : : 40436 2935 6 again again RB 40436 2935 7 , , , 40436 2935 8 p. p. NN 40436 2935 9 9 9 CD 40436 2935 10 , , , 40436 2935 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2935 12 is be VBZ 40436 2935 13 complained complain VBN 40436 2935 14 that that IN 40436 2935 15 there there EX 40436 2935 16 is be VBZ 40436 2935 17 an an DT 40436 2935 18 " " `` 40436 2935 19 infinitus infinitus NN 40436 2935 20 secundarius secundarius NNP 40436 2935 21 collocutor collocutor NNP 40436 2935 22 " " '' 40436 2935 23 in in IN 40436 2935 24 the the DT 40436 2935 25 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2935 26 . . . 40436 2936 1 Now now RB 40436 2936 2 the the DT 40436 2936 3 sentence sentence NN 40436 2936 4 , , , 40436 2936 5 just just RB 40436 2936 6 transcribed transcribe VBN 40436 2936 7 from from IN 40436 2936 8 M. M. NNP 40436 2936 9 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2936 10 , , , 40436 2936 11 shows show VBZ 40436 2936 12 that that IN 40436 2936 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2936 14 had have VBD 40436 2936 15 in in IN 40436 2936 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2936 17 mind mind NN 40436 2936 18 as as IN 40436 2936 19 standard standard NN 40436 2936 20 of of IN 40436 2936 21 comparison comparison NN 40436 2936 22 , , , 40436 2936 23 a a DT 40436 2936 24 certain certain JJ 40436 2936 25 number number NN 40436 2936 26 of of IN 40436 2936 27 the the DT 40436 2936 28 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2936 29 works work NNS 40436 2936 30 , , , 40436 2936 31 but but CC 40436 2936 32 that that IN 40436 2936 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2936 34 did do VBD 40436 2936 35 not not RB 40436 2936 36 take take VB 40436 2936 37 account account NN 40436 2936 38 of of IN 40436 2936 39 all all DT 40436 2936 40 of of IN 40436 2936 41 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2936 42 . . . 40436 2937 1 The the DT 40436 2937 2 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2937 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2937 4 begins begin VBZ 40436 2937 5 with with IN 40436 2937 6 a a DT 40436 2937 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2937 8 between between IN 40436 2937 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 2937 10 and and CC 40436 2937 11 an an DT 40436 2937 12 unknown unknown JJ 40436 2937 13 , , , 40436 2937 14 nameless nameless JJ 40436 2937 15 person person NN 40436 2937 16 ; ; : 40436 2937 17 to to TO 40436 2937 18 whom whom WP 40436 2937 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 2937 20 , , , 40436 2937 21 after after IN 40436 2937 22 a a DT 40436 2937 23 page page NN 40436 2937 24 of of IN 40436 2937 25 conversation conversation NN 40436 2937 26 with with IN 40436 2937 27 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2937 28 , , , 40436 2937 29 recounts recount NNS 40436 2937 30 what what WP 40436 2937 31 has have VBZ 40436 2937 32 just just RB 40436 2937 33 passed pass VBN 40436 2937 34 between between IN 40436 2937 35 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2937 36 , , , 40436 2937 37 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 2937 38 , , , 40436 2937 39 and and CC 40436 2937 40 others other NNS 40436 2937 41 . . . 40436 2938 1 Next next RB 40436 2938 2 , , , 40436 2938 3 if if IN 40436 2938 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2938 5 turn turn VBP 40436 2938 6 to to IN 40436 2938 7 the the DT 40436 2938 8 Sophistês Sophistês NNP 40436 2938 9 and and CC 40436 2938 10 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2938 11 , , , 40436 2938 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2938 13 find find VBP 40436 2938 14 that that IN 40436 2938 15 in in IN 40436 2938 16 both both DT 40436 2938 17 of of IN 40436 2938 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2938 19 , , , 40436 2938 20 not not RB 40436 2938 21 simply simply RB 40436 2938 22 the the DT 40436 2938 23 secundarius secundarius NNP 40436 2938 24 collocutor collocutor NN 40436 2938 25 , , , 40436 2938 26 but but CC 40436 2938 27 even even RB 40436 2938 28 the the DT 40436 2938 29 principal principal JJ 40436 2938 30 speaker speaker NN 40436 2938 31 , , , 40436 2938 32 is be VBZ 40436 2938 33 an an DT 40436 2938 34 unknown unknown JJ 40436 2938 35 and and CC 40436 2938 36 nameless nameless JJ 40436 2938 37 person person NN 40436 2938 38 , , , 40436 2938 39 described describe VBN 40436 2938 40 only only RB 40436 2938 41 as as IN 40436 2938 42 a a DT 40436 2938 43 Stranger Stranger NNP 40436 2938 44 from from IN 40436 2938 45 Elea Elea NNP 40436 2938 46 , , , 40436 2938 47 and and CC 40436 2938 48 never never RB 40436 2938 49 before before IN 40436 2938 50 seen see VBN 40436 2938 51 by by IN 40436 2938 52 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 2938 53 . . . 40436 2939 1 Again again RB 40436 2939 2 , , , 40436 2939 3 in in IN 40436 2939 4 the the DT 40436 2939 5 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 2939 6 , , , 40436 2939 7 the the DT 40436 2939 8 principal principal JJ 40436 2939 9 speaker speaker NN 40436 2939 10 is be VBZ 40436 2939 11 only only RB 40436 2939 12 an an DT 40436 2939 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2939 14 Greek greek JJ 40436 2939 15 : : : 40436 2939 16 A)thênai A)thênai NNP 40436 2939 17 = = SYM 40436 2939 18 os os NNP 40436 2939 19 xe xe NNP 40436 2939 20 / / SYM 40436 2939 21 nos nos NNP 40436 2939 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2939 23 , , , 40436 2939 24 without without IN 40436 2939 25 a a DT 40436 2939 26 name name NN 40436 2939 27 . . . 40436 2940 1 In in IN 40436 2940 2 the the DT 40436 2940 3 face face NN 40436 2940 4 of of IN 40436 2940 5 such such JJ 40436 2940 6 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2940 7 , , , 40436 2940 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2940 9 is be VBZ 40436 2940 10 unsafe unsafe JJ 40436 2940 11 to to TO 40436 2940 12 lay lay VB 40436 2940 13 down down RP 40436 2940 14 a a DT 40436 2940 15 peremptory peremptory JJ 40436 2940 16 rule rule NN 40436 2940 17 , , , 40436 2940 18 that that IN 40436 2940 19 no no DT 40436 2940 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2940 21 can can MD 40436 2940 22 be be VB 40436 2940 23 the the DT 40436 2940 24 work work NN 40436 2940 25 of of IN 40436 2940 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2940 27 , , , 40436 2940 28 which which WDT 40436 2940 29 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 40436 2940 30 as as IN 40436 2940 31 _ _ NNP 40436 2940 32 collocutor collocutor NN 40436 2940 33 _ _ NNP 40436 2940 34 an an DT 40436 2940 35 unnamed unnamed JJ 40436 2940 36 person person NN 40436 2940 37 . . . 40436 2941 1 Then then RB 40436 2941 2 again again RB 40436 2941 3 -- -- : 40436 2941 4 when when WRB 40436 2941 5 M. M. NNP 40436 2941 6 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2941 7 complains complain VBZ 40436 2941 8 that that IN 40436 2941 9 the the DT 40436 2941 10 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2941 11 and and CC 40436 2941 12 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2941 13 are be VBP 40436 2941 14 destitute destitute JJ 40436 2941 15 of of IN 40436 2941 16 those those DT 40436 2941 17 " " `` 40436 2941 18 _ _ NNP 40436 2941 19 flores flore NNS 40436 2941 20 et et NN 40436 2941 21 dulcissimæ dulcissimæ NN 40436 2941 22 Veneres Veneres NNP 40436 2941 23 _ _ NNP 40436 2941 24 " " '' 40436 2941 25 which which WDT 40436 2941 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2941 27 is be VBZ 40436 2941 28 accustomed accustom VBN 40436 2941 29 to to TO 40436 2941 30 spread spread VB 40436 2941 31 through through IN 40436 2941 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2941 33 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2941 34 -- -- : 40436 2941 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2941 36 ask ask VBP 40436 2941 37 , , , 40436 2941 38 Where where WRB 40436 2941 39 are be VBP 40436 2941 40 the the DT 40436 2941 41 " " `` 40436 2941 42 dulcissimæ dulcissimæ NN 40436 2941 43 Veneres Veneres NNP 40436 2941 44 " " '' 40436 2941 45 in in IN 40436 2941 46 the the DT 40436 2941 47 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 2941 48 , , , 40436 2941 49 Sophistês Sophistês NNP 40436 2941 50 , , , 40436 2941 51 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2941 52 , , , 40436 2941 53 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 2941 54 , , , 40436 2941 55 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 2941 56 , , , 40436 2941 57 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 2941 58 ? ? . 40436 2942 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2942 2 find find VBP 40436 2942 3 none none NN 40436 2942 4 . . . 40436 2943 1 The the DT 40436 2943 2 presence presence NN 40436 2943 3 of of IN 40436 2943 4 " " `` 40436 2943 5 dulcissimæ dulcissimæ NN 40436 2943 6 Veneres Veneres NNP 40436 2943 7 " " '' 40436 2943 8 is be VBZ 40436 2943 9 not not RB 40436 2943 10 a a DT 40436 2943 11 condition condition NN 40436 2943 12 _ _ NNP 40436 2943 13 sine sine NN 40436 2943 14 quâ quâ NNP 40436 2943 15 non non AFX 40436 2943 16 _ _ NNP 40436 2943 17 , , , 40436 2943 18 in in IN 40436 2943 19 every every DT 40436 2943 20 composition composition NN 40436 2943 21 which which WDT 40436 2943 22 pretends pretend VBZ 40436 2943 23 to to IN 40436 2943 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2943 25 as as IN 40436 2943 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2943 27 author author NN 40436 2943 28 : : : 40436 2943 29 nor nor CC 40436 2943 30 can can MD 40436 2943 31 the the DT 40436 2943 32 absence absence NN 40436 2943 33 of of IN 40436 2943 34 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2943 35 be be VB 40436 2943 36 admitted admit VBN 40436 2943 37 as as IN 40436 2943 38 a a DT 40436 2943 39 reason reason NN 40436 2943 40 for for IN 40436 2943 41 disallowing disallow VBG 40436 2943 42 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2943 43 and and CC 40436 2943 44 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2943 45 . . . 40436 2944 1 The the DT 40436 2944 2 analogy analogy NN 40436 2944 3 of of IN 40436 2944 4 the the DT 40436 2944 5 Sophistês Sophistês NNP 40436 2944 6 and and CC 40436 2944 7 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2944 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2944 9 besides besides IN 40436 2944 10 Symposium Symposium NNP 40436 2944 11 , , , 40436 2944 12 Republic Republic NNP 40436 2944 13 , , , 40436 2944 14 and and CC 40436 2944 15 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 2944 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2944 17 farther farther RB 40436 2944 18 shows show VBZ 40436 2944 19 , , , 40436 2944 20 that that IN 40436 2944 21 there there EX 40436 2944 22 is be VBZ 40436 2944 23 nothing nothing NN 40436 2944 24 wonderful wonderful JJ 40436 2944 25 in in IN 40436 2944 26 finding find VBG 40436 2944 27 the the DT 40436 2944 28 titles title NNS 40436 2944 29 of of IN 40436 2944 30 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2944 31 and and CC 40436 2944 32 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2944 33 derived derive VBN 40436 2944 34 from from IN 40436 2944 35 the the DT 40436 2944 36 subjects subject NNS 40436 2944 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2944 38 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2944 39 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2944 40 : : : 40436 2944 41 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 2944 42 Philkerdou Philkerdou NNP 40436 2944 43 = = SYM 40436 2944 44 s s NN 40436 2944 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2944 46 and and CC 40436 2944 47 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2944 48 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2944 49 : : : 40436 2944 50 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 2944 51 No no NN 40436 2944 52 / / SYM 40436 2944 53 mou mou NN 40436 2944 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2944 55 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2944 56 , , , 40436 2944 57 not not RB 40436 2944 58 from from IN 40436 2944 59 the the DT 40436 2944 60 name name NN 40436 2944 61 of of IN 40436 2944 62 one one CD 40436 2944 63 of of IN 40436 2944 64 the the DT 40436 2944 65 collocutors:--whether collocutors:--whether UH 40436 2944 66 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2944 67 suppose suppose VBP 40436 2944 68 the the DT 40436 2944 69 titles title NNS 40436 2944 70 to to TO 40436 2944 71 have have VB 40436 2944 72 been be VBN 40436 2944 73 bestowed bestow VBN 40436 2944 74 by by IN 40436 2944 75 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2944 76 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2944 77 , , , 40436 2944 78 or or CC 40436 2944 79 by by IN 40436 2944 80 some some DT 40436 2944 81 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 2944 82 editor editor NN 40436 2944 83 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2944 84 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2944 85 , , , 40436 2944 86 p. p. NN 40436 2944 87 10 10 CD 40436 2944 88 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2944 89 . . . 40436 2945 1 To to TO 40436 2945 2 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 2945 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2945 4 first first JJ 40436 2945 5 ground ground NN 40436 2945 6 of of IN 40436 2945 7 objection objection NN 40436 2945 8 -- -- : 40436 2945 9 Dissimilarity dissimilarity NN 40436 2945 10 between between IN 40436 2945 11 the the DT 40436 2945 12 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2945 13 and and CC 40436 2945 14 the the DT 40436 2945 15 true true JJ 40436 2945 16 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2945 17 writings writing NNS 40436 2945 18 -- -- : 40436 2945 19 M. M. NNP 40436 2945 20 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2945 21 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 2945 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2945 23 pp pp NNP 40436 2945 24 . . . 40436 2946 1 12 12 CD 40436 2946 2 - - SYM 40436 2946 3 23 23 CD 40436 2946 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2946 5 several several JJ 40436 2946 6 passages passage NNS 40436 2946 7 of of IN 40436 2946 8 the the DT 40436 2946 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2946 10 which which WDT 40436 2946 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2946 12 considers consider VBZ 40436 2946 13 unplatonic unplatonic JJ 40436 2946 14 . . . 40436 2947 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 2947 2 , , , 40436 2947 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2947 4 includes include VBZ 40436 2947 5 among among IN 40436 2947 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2947 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2947 8 p. p. NN 40436 2947 9 12 12 CD 40436 2947 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2947 11 examples example NNS 40436 2947 12 of of IN 40436 2947 13 confused confused JJ 40436 2947 14 and and CC 40436 2947 15 illogical illogical JJ 40436 2947 16 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2947 17 . . . 40436 2948 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2948 2 confess confess VBP 40436 2948 3 that that IN 40436 2948 4 to to IN 40436 2948 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2948 6 this this DT 40436 2948 7 evidence evidence NN 40436 2948 8 is be VBZ 40436 2948 9 noway noway RB 40436 2948 10 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 2948 11 to to TO 40436 2948 12 prove prove VB 40436 2948 13 that that IN 40436 2948 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2948 15 is be VBZ 40436 2948 16 not not RB 40436 2948 17 the the DT 40436 2948 18 author author NN 40436 2948 19 . . . 40436 2949 1 That that IN 40436 2949 2 certain certain JJ 40436 2949 3 passages passage NNS 40436 2949 4 may may MD 40436 2949 5 be be VB 40436 2949 6 picked pick VBN 40436 2949 7 out out RP 40436 2949 8 which which WDT 40436 2949 9 are be VBP 40436 2949 10 obscure obscure JJ 40436 2949 11 , , , 40436 2949 12 confused confused JJ 40436 2949 13 , , , 40436 2949 14 inelegant inelegant NN 40436 2949 15 -- -- : 40436 2949 16 is be VBZ 40436 2949 17 certainly certainly RB 40436 2949 18 no no DT 40436 2949 19 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 2949 20 evidence evidence NN 40436 2949 21 . . . 40436 2950 1 If if IN 40436 2950 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2950 3 thought think VBD 40436 2950 4 so so RB 40436 2950 5 , , , 40436 2950 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2950 7 should should MD 40436 2950 8 go go VB 40436 2950 9 along along RP 40436 2950 10 with with IN 40436 2950 11 Ast Ast NNP 40436 2950 12 in in IN 40436 2950 13 rejecting reject VBG 40436 2950 14 the the DT 40436 2950 15 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 2950 16 , , , 40436 2950 17 Menon Menon NNP 40436 2950 18 , , , 40436 2950 19 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 2950 20 , , , 40436 2950 21 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 2950 22 , , , 40436 2950 23 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 2950 24 , , , 40436 2950 25 & & CC 40436 2950 26 c. c. NNP 40436 2950 27 , , , 40436 2950 28 against against IN 40436 2950 29 all all DT 40436 2950 30 which which WDT 40436 2950 31 Ast Ast NNP 40436 2950 32 argues argue VBZ 40436 2950 33 as as IN 40436 2950 34 spurious spurious JJ 40436 2950 35 , , , 40436 2950 36 upon upon IN 40436 2950 37 evidence evidence NN 40436 2950 38 of of IN 40436 2950 39 the the DT 40436 2950 40 same same JJ 40436 2950 41 kind kind NN 40436 2950 42 . . . 40436 2951 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2951 2 is be VBZ 40436 2951 3 not not RB 40436 2951 4 too too RB 40436 2951 5 much much JJ 40436 2951 6 to to TO 40436 2951 7 say say VB 40436 2951 8 , , , 40436 2951 9 that that IN 40436 2951 10 against against IN 40436 2951 11 almost almost RB 40436 2951 12 every every DT 40436 2951 13 one one CD 40436 2951 14 of of IN 40436 2951 15 the the DT 40436 2951 16 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2951 17 , , , 40436 2951 18 taken take VBN 40436 2951 19 severally severally RB 40436 2951 20 , , , 40436 2951 21 a a DT 40436 2951 22 case case NN 40436 2951 23 of of IN 40436 2951 24 the the DT 40436 2951 25 same same JJ 40436 2951 26 kind kind NN 40436 2951 27 , , , 40436 2951 28 more more RBR 40436 2951 29 or or CC 40436 2951 30 less less RBR 40436 2951 31 plausible plausible JJ 40436 2951 32 , , , 40436 2951 33 might may MD 40436 2951 34 be be VB 40436 2951 35 made make VBN 40436 2951 36 out out RP 40436 2951 37 . . . 40436 2952 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 2952 2 might may MD 40436 2952 3 in in IN 40436 2952 4 each each DT 40436 2952 5 of of IN 40436 2952 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2952 7 find find VBP 40436 2952 8 passages passage NNS 40436 2952 9 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 2952 10 , , , 40436 2952 11 careless careless JJ 40436 2952 12 , , , 40436 2952 13 awkwardly awkwardly RB 40436 2952 14 expressed express VBN 40436 2952 15 . . . 40436 2953 1 The the DT 40436 2953 2 expression expression NN 40436 2953 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2953 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 2953 5 : : : 40436 2953 6 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 2953 7 a)nthrôpei a)nthrôpei NNP 40436 2953 8 / / , 40436 2953 9 an an DT 40436 2953 10 a)ge a)ge NN 40436 2953 11 / / SYM 40436 2953 12 lên lên IN 40436 2953 13 tou= tou= NNP 40436 2953 14 sô sô NNP 40436 2953 15 / / SYM 40436 2953 16 matos matos NNP 40436 2953 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2953 18 , , , 40436 2953 19 which which WDT 40436 2953 20 M. M. NNP 40436 2953 21 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2953 22 insists insist VBZ 40436 2953 23 upon upon IN 40436 2953 24 so so RB 40436 2953 25 much much JJ 40436 2953 26 as as IN 40436 2953 27 improper improper JJ 40436 2953 28 , , , 40436 2953 29 would would MD 40436 2953 30 probably probably RB 40436 2953 31 have have VB 40436 2953 32 been be VBN 40436 2953 33 considered consider VBN 40436 2953 34 as as IN 40436 2953 35 a a DT 40436 2953 36 mere mere JJ 40436 2953 37 case case NN 40436 2953 38 of of IN 40436 2953 39 faulty faulty JJ 40436 2953 40 text text NN 40436 2953 41 , , , 40436 2953 42 if if IN 40436 2953 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2953 44 had have VBD 40436 2953 45 occurred occur VBN 40436 2953 46 in in IN 40436 2953 47 any any DT 40436 2953 48 other other JJ 40436 2953 49 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2953 50 : : : 40436 2953 51 and and CC 40436 2953 52 so so RB 40436 2953 53 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2953 54 may may MD 40436 2953 55 fairly fairly RB 40436 2953 56 be be VB 40436 2953 57 considered consider VBN 40436 2953 58 in in IN 40436 2953 59 the the DT 40436 2953 60 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2953 61 . . . 40436 2954 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 2954 2 as as IN 40436 2954 3 to to IN 40436 2954 4 faults fault NNS 40436 2954 5 of of IN 40436 2954 6 logic logic NN 40436 2954 7 and and CC 40436 2954 8 consistency consistency NN 40436 2954 9 in in IN 40436 2954 10 the the DT 40436 2954 11 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2954 12 , , , 40436 2954 13 most most RBS 40436 2954 14 certainly certainly RB 40436 2954 15 these these DT 40436 2954 16 can can MD 40436 2954 17 not not RB 40436 2954 18 be be VB 40436 2954 19 held hold VBN 40436 2954 20 as as IN 40436 2954 21 proving prove VBG 40436 2954 22 the the DT 40436 2954 23 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2954 24 not not RB 40436 2954 25 to to TO 40436 2954 26 be be VB 40436 2954 27 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2954 28 's 's POS 40436 2954 29 work work NN 40436 2954 30 . . . 40436 2955 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2955 2 would would MD 40436 2955 3 engage engage VB 40436 2955 4 to to TO 40436 2955 5 produce produce VB 40436 2955 6 , , , 40436 2955 7 from from IN 40436 2955 8 most most JJS 40436 2955 9 of of IN 40436 2955 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2955 11 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2955 12 , , , 40436 2955 13 defects defect NNS 40436 2955 14 of of IN 40436 2955 15 reasoning reason VBG 40436 2955 16 quite quite RB 40436 2955 17 as as RB 40436 2955 18 grave grave JJ 40436 2955 19 as as IN 40436 2955 20 any any DT 40436 2955 21 which which WDT 40436 2955 22 the the DT 40436 2955 23 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2955 24 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 2955 25 . . . 40436 2956 1 On on IN 40436 2956 2 the the DT 40436 2956 3 principle principle NN 40436 2956 4 assumed assume VBN 40436 2956 5 by by IN 40436 2956 6 M. M. NNP 40436 2956 7 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2956 8 , , , 40436 2956 9 every every DT 40436 2956 10 one one NN 40436 2956 11 who who WP 40436 2956 12 agreed agree VBD 40436 2956 13 with with IN 40436 2956 14 Panætius Panætius NNP 40436 2956 15 in in IN 40436 2956 16 considering consider VBG 40436 2956 17 the the DT 40436 2956 18 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 2956 19 proof proof NN 40436 2956 20 given give VBN 40436 2956 21 in in IN 40436 2956 22 the the DT 40436 2956 23 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 2956 24 , , , 40436 2956 25 of of IN 40436 2956 26 the the DT 40436 2956 27 immortality immortality NN 40436 2956 28 of of IN 40436 2956 29 the the DT 40436 2956 30 soul soul NN 40436 2956 31 , , , 40436 2956 32 as as IN 40436 2956 33 illogical illogical JJ 40436 2956 34 and and CC 40436 2956 35 delusive delusive JJ 40436 2956 36 -- -- : 40436 2956 37 would would MD 40436 2956 38 also also RB 40436 2956 39 agree agree VB 40436 2956 40 with with IN 40436 2956 41 Panætius Panætius NNP 40436 2956 42 in in IN 40436 2956 43 declaring declare VBG 40436 2956 44 that that IN 40436 2956 45 the the DT 40436 2956 46 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 2956 47 was be VBD 40436 2956 48 not not RB 40436 2956 49 the the DT 40436 2956 50 work work NN 40436 2956 51 of of IN 40436 2956 52 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2956 53 . . . 40436 2957 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2957 2 is be VBZ 40436 2957 3 one one CD 40436 2957 4 question question NN 40436 2957 5 , , , 40436 2957 6 whether whether IN 40436 2957 7 the the DT 40436 2957 8 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 2957 9 in in IN 40436 2957 10 any any DT 40436 2957 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2957 12 be be VB 40436 2957 13 good good JJ 40436 2957 14 or or CC 40436 2957 15 bad bad JJ 40436 2957 16 : : : 40436 2957 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2957 18 is be VBZ 40436 2957 19 another another DT 40436 2957 20 question question NN 40436 2957 21 , , , 40436 2957 22 whether whether IN 40436 2957 23 the the DT 40436 2957 24 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2957 25 be be VB 40436 2957 26 written write VBN 40436 2957 27 by by IN 40436 2957 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2957 29 or or CC 40436 2957 30 not not RB 40436 2957 31 . . . 40436 2958 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 40436 2958 2 , , , 40436 2958 3 the the DT 40436 2958 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2958 5 critics critic NNS 40436 2958 6 often often RB 40436 2958 7 treat treat VBP 40436 2958 8 the the DT 40436 2958 9 first first JJ 40436 2958 10 question question NN 40436 2958 11 as as IN 40436 2958 12 if if IN 40436 2958 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2958 14 determined determine VBD 40436 2958 15 the the DT 40436 2958 16 second second NN 40436 2958 17 . . . 40436 2959 1 M. M. NNP 40436 2959 2 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2959 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2959 4 considers consider VBZ 40436 2959 5 that that IN 40436 2959 6 the the DT 40436 2959 7 evidence evidence NN 40436 2959 8 arising arise VBG 40436 2959 9 from from IN 40436 2959 10 dissimilarity dissimilarity NN 40436 2959 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2959 12 upon upon IN 40436 2959 13 which which WDT 40436 2959 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2959 15 have have VBP 40436 2959 16 just just RB 40436 2959 17 dwelt dwell VBN 40436 2959 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2959 19 is be VBZ 40436 2959 20 not not RB 40436 2959 21 the the DT 40436 2959 22 strongest strong JJS 40436 2959 23 part part NN 40436 2959 24 of of IN 40436 2959 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2959 26 case case NN 40436 2959 27 . . . 40436 2960 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2960 2 relies rely VBZ 40436 2960 3 more more JJR 40436 2960 4 upon upon IN 40436 2960 5 the the DT 40436 2960 6 evidence evidence NN 40436 2960 7 arising arise VBG 40436 2960 8 from from IN 40436 2960 9 _ _ NNP 40436 2960 10 too too RB 40436 2960 11 much much JJ 40436 2960 12 similarity similarity NN 40436 2960 13 _ _ NNP 40436 2960 14 , , , 40436 2960 15 as as IN 40436 2960 16 proving prove VBG 40436 2960 17 still still RB 40436 2960 18 more more RBR 40436 2960 19 clearly clearly RB 40436 2960 20 the the DT 40436 2960 21 spuriousness spuriousness NN 40436 2960 22 of of IN 40436 2960 23 the the DT 40436 2960 24 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2960 25 . . . 40436 2961 1 " " `` 40436 2961 2 Jam Jam NNP 40436 2961 3 pergamus pergamus NNP 40436 2961 4 ad ad NNP 40436 2961 5 alteram alteram NNP 40436 2961 6 partem partem NNP 40436 2961 7 nostræ nostræ NNP 40436 2961 8 argumentationis argumentationis NNP 40436 2961 9 , , , 40436 2961 10 _ _ NNP 40436 2961 11 eamque eamque NNP 40436 2961 12 etiam etiam NNP 40436 2961 13 firmiorem firmiorem NNP 40436 2961 14 _ _ NNP 40436 2961 15 , , , 40436 2961 16 de de NNP 40436 2961 17 _ _ NNP 40436 2961 18 nimia nimia NN 40436 2961 19 similitudine similitudine NN 40436 2961 20 _ _ NNP 40436 2961 21 Platonicorum Platonicorum NNP 40436 2961 22 aliquot aliquot VBZ 40436 2961 23 locorum locorum NN 40436 2961 24 , , , 40436 2961 25 quæ quæ NNP 40436 2961 26 imitationem imitationem NNP 40436 2961 27 doceat doceat NNP 40436 2961 28 subesse subesse NNP 40436 2961 29 . . . 40436 2962 1 Nam Nam NNP 40436 2962 2 de de FW 40436 2962 3 hoc hoc FW 40436 2962 4 quidem quidem NNP 40436 2962 5 conveniet conveniet NNP 40436 2962 6 inter inter NNP 40436 2962 7 omnes omnes NNP 40436 2962 8 doctos doctos NNP 40436 2962 9 et et NNP 40436 2962 10 indoctos indoctos NNP 40436 2962 11 , , , 40436 2962 12 Platonem Platonem NNP 40436 2962 13 se se NNP 40436 2962 14 ipsum ipsum NNP 40436 2962 15 haud haud NNP 40436 2962 16 posse posse NNP 40436 2962 17 imitari imitari NNP 40436 2962 18 : : : 40436 2962 19 nisi nisi NNP 40436 2962 20 si si NNP 40436 2962 21 quis quis NNP 40436 2962 22 dubitet dubitet NNP 40436 2962 23 de de NNP 40436 2962 24 sanâ sanâ NNP 40436 2962 25 ejus ejus NNP 40436 2962 26 mente mente NNP 40436 2962 27 " " '' 40436 2962 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2962 29 p. p. NN 40436 2962 30 23 23 CD 40436 2962 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2962 32 . . . 40436 2963 1 Again again RB 40436 2963 2 , , , 40436 2963 3 p. p. NN 40436 2963 4 26 26 CD 40436 2963 5 , , , 40436 2963 6 " " `` 40436 2963 7 Jam Jam NNP 40436 2963 8 vero vero NN 40436 2963 9 in in IN 40436 2963 10 nostro nostro NNP 40436 2963 11 colloquio colloquio NNP 40436 2963 12 Symposium Symposium NNP 40436 2963 13 , , , 40436 2963 14 Politicum Politicum NNP 40436 2963 15 , , , 40436 2963 16 Euthyphronem Euthyphronem NNP 40436 2963 17 , , , 40436 2963 18 Protagoram Protagoram NNP 40436 2963 19 , , , 40436 2963 20 Gorgiam Gorgiam NNP 40436 2963 21 , , , 40436 2963 22 Cratylum Cratylum NNP 40436 2963 23 , , , 40436 2963 24 Philêbum Philêbum NNP 40436 2963 25 , , , 40436 2963 26 dialogos dialogo NNS 40436 2963 27 expressos expresso VBZ 40436 2963 28 ac ac RB 40436 2963 29 tantum tantum NNP 40436 2963 30 non non NNP 40436 2963 31 compilatos compilatos NN 40436 2963 32 reperies reperie NNS 40436 2963 33 " " '' 40436 2963 34 . . . 40436 2964 1 And and CC 40436 2964 2 M. M. NNP 40436 2964 3 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2964 4 goes go VBZ 40436 2964 5 on on RP 40436 2964 6 to to TO 40436 2964 7 specify specify VB 40436 2964 8 various various JJ 40436 2964 9 passages passage NNS 40436 2964 10 of of IN 40436 2964 11 the the DT 40436 2964 12 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2964 13 , , , 40436 2964 14 which which WDT 40436 2964 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2964 16 considers consider VBZ 40436 2964 17 to to TO 40436 2964 18 have have VB 40436 2964 19 been be VBN 40436 2964 20 imitated imitate VBN 40436 2964 21 , , , 40436 2964 22 and and CC 40436 2964 23 badly badly RB 40436 2964 24 imitated imitate VBN 40436 2964 25 , , , 40436 2964 26 from from IN 40436 2964 27 one one CD 40436 2964 28 or or CC 40436 2964 29 other other JJ 40436 2964 30 of of IN 40436 2964 31 these these DT 40436 2964 32 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2964 33 . . . 40436 2965 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2965 2 can can MD 40436 2965 3 not not RB 40436 2965 4 agree agree VB 40436 2965 5 with with IN 40436 2965 6 M. M. NNP 40436 2965 7 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2965 8 in in IN 40436 2965 9 regarding regard VBG 40436 2965 10 this this DT 40436 2965 11 _ _ NNP 40436 2965 12 nimia nimia NN 40436 2965 13 similitudo similitudo NN 40436 2965 14 _ _ NNP 40436 2965 15 as as IN 40436 2965 16 the the DT 40436 2965 17 strongest strong JJS 40436 2965 18 part part NN 40436 2965 19 of of IN 40436 2965 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2965 21 case case NN 40436 2965 22 . . . 40436 2966 1 On on IN 40436 2966 2 the the DT 40436 2966 3 contrary contrary NN 40436 2966 4 , , , 40436 2966 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2966 6 consider consider VBP 40436 2966 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2966 8 as as IN 40436 2966 9 the the DT 40436 2966 10 weakest weak JJS 40436 2966 11 : : : 40436 2966 12 because because IN 40436 2966 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2966 14 own own JJ 40436 2966 15 premisses premiss NNS 40436 2966 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2966 17 in in IN 40436 2966 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2966 19 judgment judgment NN 40436 2966 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2966 21 not not RB 40436 2966 22 only only RB 40436 2966 23 do do VBP 40436 2966 24 not not RB 40436 2966 25 prove prove VB 40436 2966 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2966 27 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 2966 28 , , , 40436 2966 29 but but CC 40436 2966 30 go go VB 40436 2966 31 far far RB 40436 2966 32 to to TO 40436 2966 33 prove prove VB 40436 2966 34 the the DT 40436 2966 35 opposite opposite NN 40436 2966 36 . . . 40436 2967 1 When when WRB 40436 2967 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2967 3 find find VBP 40436 2967 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 2967 5 insisting insist VBG 40436 2967 6 , , , 40436 2967 7 in in IN 40436 2967 8 such such JJ 40436 2967 9 strong strong JJ 40436 2967 10 language language NN 40436 2967 11 , , , 40436 2967 12 upon upon IN 40436 2967 13 the the DT 40436 2967 14 great great JJ 40436 2967 15 analogy analogy NN 40436 2967 16 which which WDT 40436 2967 17 subsists subsist VBZ 40436 2967 18 between between IN 40436 2967 19 the the DT 40436 2967 20 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2967 21 and and CC 40436 2967 22 seven seven CD 40436 2967 23 of of IN 40436 2967 24 the the DT 40436 2967 25 incontestable incontestable JJ 40436 2967 26 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2967 27 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2967 28 , , , 40436 2967 29 this this DT 40436 2967 30 is be VBZ 40436 2967 31 surely surely RB 40436 2967 32 a a DT 40436 2967 33 fair fair JJ 40436 2967 34 proof proof NN 40436 2967 35 that that IN 40436 2967 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2967 37 author author NN 40436 2967 38 is be VBZ 40436 2967 39 the the DT 40436 2967 40 same same JJ 40436 2967 41 as as IN 40436 2967 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2967 43 author author NN 40436 2967 44 . . . 40436 2968 1 To to IN 40436 2968 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2968 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2968 4 appears appear VBZ 40436 2968 5 as as RB 40436 2968 6 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 2968 7 as as IN 40436 2968 8 internal internal JJ 40436 2968 9 evidence evidence NN 40436 2968 10 ever ever RB 40436 2968 11 can can MD 40436 2968 12 be be VB 40436 2968 13 ; ; : 40436 2968 14 unless unless IN 40436 2968 15 there there EX 40436 2968 16 be be VB 40436 2968 17 some some DT 40436 2968 18 disproof disproof NN 40436 2968 19 _ _ NNP 40436 2968 20 aliunde aliunde NNP 40436 2968 21 _ _ NNP 40436 2968 22 to to TO 40436 2968 23 overthrow overthrow VB 40436 2968 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2968 25 . . . 40436 2969 1 But but CC 40436 2969 2 M. M. NNP 40436 2969 3 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2969 4 produces produce VBZ 40436 2969 5 no no DT 40436 2969 6 such such JJ 40436 2969 7 disproof disproof NN 40436 2969 8 . . . 40436 2970 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2970 2 converts convert VBZ 40436 2970 3 these these DT 40436 2970 4 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2970 5 into into IN 40436 2970 6 testimony testimony NN 40436 2970 7 in in IN 40436 2970 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2970 9 own own JJ 40436 2970 10 favour favour NN 40436 2970 11 , , , 40436 2970 12 simply simply RB 40436 2970 13 by by IN 40436 2970 14 bestowing bestow VBG 40436 2970 15 upon upon IN 40436 2970 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2970 17 the the DT 40436 2970 18 name name NN 40436 2970 19 _ _ NNP 40436 2970 20 imitatio,--stulta imitatio,--stulta NNP 40436 2970 21 imitatio imitatio NNP 40436 2970 22 _ _ NNP 40436 2970 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2970 24 p. p. NN 40436 2970 25 27 27 CD 40436 2970 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2970 27 . . . 40436 2971 1 This this DT 40436 2971 2 word word NN 40436 2971 3 involves involve VBZ 40436 2971 4 an an DT 40436 2971 5 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 2971 6 , , , 40436 2971 7 whereby whereby WRB 40436 2971 8 the the DT 40436 2971 9 point point NN 40436 2971 10 to to TO 40436 2971 11 be be VB 40436 2971 12 proved prove VBN 40436 2971 13 is be VBZ 40436 2971 14 assumed assume VBN 40436 2971 15 -- -- : 40436 2971 16 viz viz NN 40436 2971 17 . . . 40436 2972 1 : : : 40436 2972 2 difference difference NN 40436 2972 3 of of IN 40436 2972 4 authorship authorship NN 40436 2972 5 . . . 40436 2973 1 " " `` 40436 2973 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2973 3 can can MD 40436 2973 4 not not RB 40436 2973 5 have have VB 40436 2973 6 imitated imitate VBN 40436 2973 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2973 8 " " '' 40436 2973 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2973 10 M. M. NNP 40436 2973 11 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2973 12 observes observe VBZ 40436 2973 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2973 14 . . . 40436 2974 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2974 2 can can MD 40436 2974 3 not not RB 40436 2974 4 admit admit VB 40436 2974 5 such such JJ 40436 2974 6 impossibility impossibility NN 40436 2974 7 , , , 40436 2974 8 even even RB 40436 2974 9 if if IN 40436 2974 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2974 11 describe describe VBP 40436 2974 12 the the DT 40436 2974 13 fact fact NN 40436 2974 14 in in IN 40436 2974 15 that that DT 40436 2974 16 phrase phrase NN 40436 2974 17 : : : 40436 2974 18 but but CC 40436 2974 19 if if IN 40436 2974 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 2974 21 say say VBP 40436 2974 22 " " `` 40436 2974 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2974 24 in in IN 40436 2974 25 one one CD 40436 2974 26 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2974 27 thought think VBD 40436 2974 28 and and CC 40436 2974 29 wrote write VBD 40436 2974 30 like like IN 40436 2974 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2974 32 in in IN 40436 2974 33 another"--you another"--you NNP 40436 2974 34 describe describe VBP 40436 2974 35 the the DT 40436 2974 36 same same JJ 40436 2974 37 fact fact NN 40436 2974 38 in in IN 40436 2974 39 a a DT 40436 2974 40 different different JJ 40436 2974 41 phrase phrase NN 40436 2974 42 , , , 40436 2974 43 and and CC 40436 2974 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2974 45 then then RB 40436 2974 46 appears appear VBZ 40436 2974 47 not not RB 40436 2974 48 merely merely RB 40436 2974 49 possible possible JJ 40436 2974 50 but but CC 40436 2974 51 natural natural JJ 40436 2974 52 and and CC 40436 2974 53 probable probable JJ 40436 2974 54 . . . 40436 2975 1 Those those DT 40436 2975 2 very very RB 40436 2975 3 real real JJ 40436 2975 4 analogies analogy NNS 40436 2975 5 , , , 40436 2975 6 to to TO 40436 2975 7 which which WDT 40436 2975 8 M. M. NNP 40436 2975 9 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2975 10 points point VBZ 40436 2975 11 in in IN 40436 2975 12 the the DT 40436 2975 13 word word NN 40436 2975 14 _ _ NNP 40436 2975 15 imitatio imitatio NNP 40436 2975 16 _ _ NNP 40436 2975 17 , , , 40436 2975 18 are be VBP 40436 2975 19 in in IN 40436 2975 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2975 21 judgment judgment NN 40436 2975 22 cases case NNS 40436 2975 23 of of IN 40436 2975 24 the the DT 40436 2975 25 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2975 26 thought thought NN 40436 2975 27 in in IN 40436 2975 28 one one CD 40436 2975 29 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2975 30 being be VBG 40436 2975 31 like like IN 40436 2975 32 the the DT 40436 2975 33 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2975 34 thought thought NN 40436 2975 35 in in IN 40436 2975 36 another another DT 40436 2975 37 . . . 40436 2976 1 The the DT 40436 2976 2 _ _ NNP 40436 2976 3 similitudo similitudo NN 40436 2976 4 _ _ NNP 40436 2976 5 , , , 40436 2976 6 between between IN 40436 2976 7 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2976 8 and and CC 40436 2976 9 these these DT 40436 2976 10 other other JJ 40436 2976 11 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2976 12 , , , 40436 2976 13 can can MD 40436 2976 14 hardly hardly RB 40436 2976 15 be be VB 40436 2976 16 called call VBN 40436 2976 17 _ _ NNP 40436 2976 18 nimia nimia NN 40436 2976 19 _ _ NNP 40436 2976 20 , , , 40436 2976 21 for for IN 40436 2976 22 M. M. NNP 40436 2976 23 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2976 24 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 2976 25 points point VBZ 40436 2976 26 out out RP 40436 2976 27 that that IN 40436 2976 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2976 29 is be VBZ 40436 2976 30 accompanied accompany VBN 40436 2976 31 with with IN 40436 2976 32 much much JJ 40436 2976 33 difference difference NN 40436 2976 34 . . . 40436 2977 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2977 2 is be VBZ 40436 2977 3 a a DT 40436 2977 4 similitude similitude NN 40436 2977 5 , , , 40436 2977 6 such such JJ 40436 2977 7 as as IN 40436 2977 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2977 9 should should MD 40436 2977 10 expect expect VB 40436 2977 11 between between IN 40436 2977 12 one one CD 40436 2977 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2977 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2977 15 and and CC 40436 2977 16 another another DT 40436 2977 17 : : : 40436 2977 18 with with IN 40436 2977 19 this this DT 40436 2977 20 difference difference NN 40436 2977 21 , , , 40436 2977 22 that that IN 40436 2977 23 whereas whereas IN 40436 2977 24 , , , 40436 2977 25 in in IN 40436 2977 26 the the DT 40436 2977 27 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2977 28 , , , 40436 2977 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2977 30 gives give VBZ 40436 2977 31 the the DT 40436 2977 32 same same JJ 40436 2977 33 general general JJ 40436 2977 34 views view NNS 40436 2977 35 in in IN 40436 2977 36 a a DT 40436 2977 37 manner manner NN 40436 2977 38 more more RBR 40436 2977 39 brief brief JJ 40436 2977 40 , , , 40436 2977 41 crude crude JJ 40436 2977 42 , , , 40436 2977 43 abrupt abrupt JJ 40436 2977 44 -- -- : 40436 2977 45 in in IN 40436 2977 46 the the DT 40436 2977 47 other other JJ 40436 2977 48 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2977 49 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2977 50 works work VBZ 40436 2977 51 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2977 52 out out RP 40436 2977 53 with with IN 40436 2977 54 greater great JJR 40436 2977 55 fulness fulness NN 40436 2977 56 of of IN 40436 2977 57 explanation explanation NN 40436 2977 58 and and CC 40436 2977 59 illustration illustration NN 40436 2977 60 , , , 40436 2977 61 and and CC 40436 2977 62 some some DT 40436 2977 63 degree degree NN 40436 2977 64 of of IN 40436 2977 65 change change NN 40436 2977 66 not not RB 40436 2977 67 unimportant unimportant JJ 40436 2977 68 . . . 40436 2978 1 That that IN 40436 2978 2 there there EX 40436 2978 3 should should MD 40436 2978 4 be be VB 40436 2978 5 this this DT 40436 2978 6 amount amount NN 40436 2978 7 of of IN 40436 2978 8 difference difference NN 40436 2978 9 between between IN 40436 2978 10 one one CD 40436 2978 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2978 12 of of IN 40436 2978 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2978 14 and and CC 40436 2978 15 another another DT 40436 2978 16 appears appear VBZ 40436 2978 17 to to IN 40436 2978 18 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2978 19 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 2978 20 natural natural JJ 40436 2978 21 . . . 40436 2979 1 On on IN 40436 2979 2 the the DT 40436 2979 3 other other JJ 40436 2979 4 hand hand NN 40436 2979 5 -- -- : 40436 2979 6 that that IN 40436 2979 7 there there EX 40436 2979 8 should should MD 40436 2979 9 have have VB 40436 2979 10 been be VBN 40436 2979 11 a a DT 40436 2979 12 contemporary contemporary JJ 40436 2979 13 _ _ NNP 40436 2979 14 falsarius falsarius NN 40436 2979 15 _ _ NNP 40436 2979 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2979 17 scriptor scriptor NNP 40436 2979 18 miser miser NNP 40436 2979 19 , , , 40436 2979 20 insulsus insulsus NNP 40436 2979 21 , , , 40436 2979 22 vilissimus vilissimus NNP 40436 2979 23 , , , 40436 2979 24 to to TO 40436 2979 25 use use VB 40436 2979 26 phrases phrase NNS 40436 2979 27 of of IN 40436 2979 28 M. M. NNP 40436 2979 29 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2979 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2979 31 , , , 40436 2979 32 who who WP 40436 2979 33 studied study VBD 40436 2979 34 and and CC 40436 2979 35 pillaged pillage VBD 40436 2979 36 the the DT 40436 2979 37 best good JJS 40436 2979 38 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2979 39 of of IN 40436 2979 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2979 41 , , , 40436 2979 42 for for IN 40436 2979 43 the the DT 40436 2979 44 purpose purpose NN 40436 2979 45 of of IN 40436 2979 46 putting put VBG 40436 2979 47 together together RP 40436 2979 48 a a DT 40436 2979 49 short short JJ 40436 2979 50 and and CC 40436 2979 51 perverted perverted JJ 40436 2979 52 abbreviation abbreviation NN 40436 2979 53 of of IN 40436 2979 54 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2979 55 -- -- : 40436 2979 56 and and CC 40436 2979 57 who who WP 40436 2979 58 contrived contrive VBD 40436 2979 59 to to TO 40436 2979 60 get get VB 40436 2979 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2979 62 miserable miserable JJ 40436 2979 63 abbreviation abbreviation NN 40436 2979 64 recognised recognise VBN 40436 2979 65 by by IN 40436 2979 66 the the DT 40436 2979 67 Byzantine Byzantine NNP 40436 2979 68 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40436 2979 69 among among IN 40436 2979 70 the the DT 40436 2979 71 genuine genuine JJ 40436 2979 72 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2979 73 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 40436 2979 74 the the DT 40436 2979 75 existence existence NN 40436 2979 76 of of IN 40436 2979 77 the the DT 40436 2979 78 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2979 79 school school NN 40436 2979 80 -- -- : 40436 2979 81 this this DT 40436 2979 82 , , , 40436 2979 83 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2979 84 think think VBP 40436 2979 85 highly highly RB 40436 2979 86 improbable improbable JJ 40436 2979 87 . . . 40436 2980 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2980 2 can can MD 40436 2980 3 not not RB 40436 2980 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 2980 5 agree agree VB 40436 2980 6 with with IN 40436 2980 7 M. M. NNP 40436 2980 8 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2980 9 in in IN 40436 2980 10 thinking thinking NN 40436 2980 11 , , , 40436 2980 12 that that IN 40436 2980 13 " " `` 40436 2980 14 ubique ubique JJ 40436 2980 15 se se FW 40436 2980 16 prodens proden VBZ 40436 2980 17 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 2980 18 imitatio imitatio NN 40436 2980 19 " " '' 40436 2980 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2980 21 p. p. NN 40436 2980 22 31 31 CD 40436 2980 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2980 24 is be VBZ 40436 2980 25 an an DT 40436 2980 26 irresistible irresistible JJ 40436 2980 27 proof proof NN 40436 2980 28 of of IN 40436 2980 29 spuriousness spuriousness NN 40436 2980 30 : : : 40436 2980 31 nor nor CC 40436 2980 32 can can MD 40436 2980 33 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2980 34 think think VB 40436 2980 35 that that IN 40436 2980 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2980 37 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 2980 38 shows show VBZ 40436 2980 39 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 2980 40 to to IN 40436 2980 41 advantage advantage NN 40436 2980 42 , , , 40436 2980 43 when when WRB 40436 2980 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 2980 45 says say VBZ 40436 2980 46 , , , 40436 2980 47 p. p. NN 40436 2980 48 10 10 CD 40436 2980 49 - - HYPH 40436 2980 50 -"Ipse -"ipse CD 40436 2980 51 autem autem NN 40436 2980 52 dialogus dialogus NN 40436 2980 53 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2980 54 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2980 55 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2980 56 quum quum NN 40436 2980 57 post post NN 40436 2980 58 Politicum politicum JJ 40436 2980 59 compositus compositus NN 40436 2980 60 sit sit VB 40436 2980 61 , , , 40436 2980 62 quod quod NN 40436 2980 63 quædam quædam NNP 40436 2980 64 in in IN 40436 2980 65 eo eo NNP 40436 2980 66 dicta dicta NNP 40436 2980 67 rebus rebus NNP 40436 2980 68 ibi ibi NNP 40436 2980 69 expositis expositis NNP 40436 2980 70 manifesté manifesté NNP 40436 2980 71 nitantur nitantur NNP 40436 2980 72 , , , 40436 2980 73 ut ut UH 40436 2980 74 paullo paullo NNP 40436 2980 75 post post NNP 40436 2980 76 ostendemus ostendemus NNP 40436 2980 77 -- -- : 40436 2980 78 quis quis NNP 40436 2980 79 est est NNP 40436 2980 80 qui qui VBD 40436 2980 81 artificiosissimum artificiosissimum JJ 40436 2980 82 philosophum philosophum NN 40436 2980 83 , , , 40436 2980 84 postquam postquam NNP 40436 2980 85 ibi ibi NNP 40436 2980 86 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2980 87 in in IN 40436 2980 88 Politico Politico NNP 40436 2980 89 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2980 90 accuratius accuratius NNP 40436 2980 91 de de NNP 40436 2980 92 naturâ naturâ NNP 40436 2980 93 legis legis NNP 40436 2980 94 egisset egisset NNP 40436 2980 95 , , , 40436 2980 96 de de NNP 40436 2980 97 eâ eâ NNP 40436 2980 98 iterum iterum NNP 40436 2980 99 putet putet NNP 40436 2980 100 negligenter negligenter NNP 40436 2980 101 egisse egisse NNP 40436 2980 102 ? ? . 40436 2980 103 " " '' 40436 2981 1 --I --I NFP 40436 2981 2 do do VBP 40436 2981 3 not not RB 40436 2981 4 think think VB 40436 2981 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2981 6 so so RB 40436 2981 7 impossible impossible JJ 40436 2981 8 as as IN 40436 2981 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2981 10 appears appear VBZ 40436 2981 11 to to IN 40436 2981 12 M. M. NNP 40436 2981 13 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2981 14 , , , 40436 2981 15 that that IN 40436 2981 16 a a DT 40436 2981 17 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 2981 18 , , , 40436 2981 19 after after IN 40436 2981 20 having have VBG 40436 2981 21 _ _ NNP 40436 2981 22 written write VBN 40436 2981 23 _ _ NNP 40436 2981 24 upon upon IN 40436 2981 25 a a DT 40436 2981 26 given give VBN 40436 2981 27 subject subject NN 40436 2981 28 _ _ NNP 40436 2981 29 accuratius accuratius NN 40436 2981 30 _ _ NNP 40436 2981 31 , , , 40436 2981 32 should should MD 40436 2981 33 subsequently subsequently RB 40436 2981 34 write write VB 40436 2981 35 upon upon IN 40436 2981 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2981 37 _ _ NNP 40436 2981 38 negligenter negligenter NN 40436 2981 39 _ _ NNP 40436 2981 40 . . . 40436 2982 1 But but CC 40436 2982 2 if if IN 40436 2982 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2982 4 granted grant VBD 40436 2982 5 this this DT 40436 2982 6 ever ever RB 40436 2982 7 so so RB 40436 2982 8 fully fully RB 40436 2982 9 , , , 40436 2982 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2982 11 should should MD 40436 2982 12 still still RB 40436 2982 13 contend contend VB 40436 2982 14 that that IN 40436 2982 15 there there EX 40436 2982 16 remains remain VBZ 40436 2982 17 another another DT 40436 2982 18 alternative alternative NN 40436 2982 19 . . . 40436 2983 1 The the DT 40436 2983 2 negligent negligent JJ 40436 2983 3 workmanship workmanship NN 40436 2983 4 may may MD 40436 2983 5 have have VB 40436 2983 6 preceded precede VBN 40436 2983 7 the the DT 40436 2983 8 accurate accurate JJ 40436 2983 9 : : : 40436 2983 10 an an DT 40436 2983 11 alternative alternative NN 40436 2983 12 which which WDT 40436 2983 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2983 14 think think VBP 40436 2983 15 is be VBZ 40436 2983 16 probably probably RB 40436 2983 17 the the DT 40436 2983 18 truth truth NN 40436 2983 19 , , , 40436 2983 20 and and CC 40436 2983 21 which which WDT 40436 2983 22 has have VBZ 40436 2983 23 nothing nothing NN 40436 2983 24 to to TO 40436 2983 25 exclude exclude VB 40436 2983 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2983 27 except except IN 40436 2983 28 M. M. NNP 40436 2983 29 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2983 30 's 's POS 40436 2983 31 pure pure JJ 40436 2983 32 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 2983 33 , , , 40436 2983 34 that that IN 40436 2983 35 the the DT 40436 2983 36 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2983 37 must must MD 40436 2983 38 have have VB 40436 2983 39 been be VBN 40436 2983 40 copied copy VBN 40436 2983 41 from from IN 40436 2983 42 the the DT 40436 2983 43 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 2983 44 . . . 40436 2984 1 While while IN 40436 2984 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2984 3 admit admit VBP 40436 2984 4 then then RB 40436 2984 5 that that IN 40436 2984 6 the the DT 40436 2984 7 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 2984 8 and and CC 40436 2984 9 Minos Minos NNP 40436 2984 10 are be VBP 40436 2984 11 among among IN 40436 2984 12 the the DT 40436 2984 13 inferior inferior JJ 40436 2984 14 and and CC 40436 2984 15 earlier early JJR 40436 2984 16 compositions composition NNS 40436 2984 17 of of IN 40436 2984 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2984 19 , , , 40436 2984 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2984 21 still still RB 40436 2984 22 contend contend VBP 40436 2984 23 that that IN 40436 2984 24 there there EX 40436 2984 25 is be VBZ 40436 2984 26 no no DT 40436 2984 27 ground ground NN 40436 2984 28 for for IN 40436 2984 29 excluding exclude VBG 40436 2984 30 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2984 31 from from IN 40436 2984 32 the the DT 40436 2984 33 list list NN 40436 2984 34 of of IN 40436 2984 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2984 36 works work NNS 40436 2984 37 . . . 40436 2985 1 Though though IN 40436 2985 2 the the DT 40436 2985 3 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2985 4 critics critic NNS 40436 2985 5 of of IN 40436 2985 6 this this DT 40436 2985 7 century century NN 40436 2985 8 are be VBP 40436 2985 9 for for IN 40436 2985 10 the the DT 40436 2985 11 most most JJS 40436 2985 12 part part NN 40436 2985 13 of of IN 40436 2985 14 an an DT 40436 2985 15 adverse adverse JJ 40436 2985 16 opinion opinion NN 40436 2985 17 , , , 40436 2985 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2985 19 have have VBP 40436 2985 20 with with IN 40436 2985 21 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2985 22 the the DT 40436 2985 23 general general NNP 40436 2985 24 authority authority NNP 40436 2985 25 of of IN 40436 2985 26 the the DT 40436 2985 27 critics critic NNS 40436 2985 28 anterior anterior NNP 40436 2985 29 to to IN 40436 2985 30 this this DT 40436 2985 31 century century NN 40436 2985 32 -- -- : 40436 2985 33 from from IN 40436 2985 34 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40436 2985 35 of of IN 40436 2985 36 Byzantium Byzantium NNP 40436 2985 37 down down RP 40436 2985 38 to to IN 40436 2985 39 Bentley Bentley NNP 40436 2985 40 and and CC 40436 2985 41 Ruhnken Ruhnken NNP 40436 2985 42 -- -- : 40436 2985 43 see see VB 40436 2985 44 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 2985 45 , , , 40436 2985 46 pp pp NNP 40436 2985 47 . . . 40436 2986 1 7 7 CD 40436 2986 2 - - SYM 40436 2986 3 32 32 CD 40436 2986 4 . . . 40436 2987 1 Yxem Yxem NNP 40436 2987 2 defends defend VBZ 40436 2987 3 the the DT 40436 2987 4 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 2987 5 of of IN 40436 2987 6 the the DT 40436 2987 7 Hipparchus--(Ueber Hipparchus--(Ueber NNP 40436 2987 8 Platon Platon NNP 40436 2987 9 's 's POS 40436 2987 10 Kleitophon Kleitophon NNP 40436 2987 11 , , , 40436 2987 12 p. p. NN 40436 2987 13 8 8 CD 40436 2987 14 . . . 40436 2988 1 Berlin Berlin NNP 40436 2988 2 , , , 40436 2988 3 1846 1846 CD 40436 2988 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2988 5 . . . 40436 2989 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 2989 2 XV XV NNP 40436 2989 3 . . . 40436 2990 1 THEAGES THEAGES NNP 40436 2990 2 . . . 40436 2991 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2991 2 Side side NN 40436 2991 3 - - HYPH 40436 2991 4 note note NN 40436 2991 5 : : : 40436 2991 6 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 2991 7 -- -- : 40436 2991 8 has have VBZ 40436 2991 9 been be VBN 40436 2991 10 declared declare VBN 40436 2991 11 spurious spurious JJ 40436 2991 12 by by IN 40436 2991 13 some some DT 40436 2991 14 modern modern JJ 40436 2991 15 critics critic NNS 40436 2991 16 -- -- : 40436 2991 17 grounds ground NNS 40436 2991 18 for for IN 40436 2991 19 such such JJ 40436 2991 20 opinion opinion NN 40436 2991 21 not not RB 40436 2991 22 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 2991 23 . . . 40436 2991 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2992 1 This this DT 40436 2992 2 is be VBZ 40436 2992 3 among among IN 40436 2992 4 the the DT 40436 2992 5 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2992 6 declared declare VBN 40436 2992 7 by by IN 40436 2992 8 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2992 9 , , , 40436 2992 10 Ast Ast NNP 40436 2992 11 , , , 40436 2992 12 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 2992 13 , , , 40436 2992 14 and and CC 40436 2992 15 various various JJ 40436 2992 16 other other JJ 40436 2992 17 modern modern JJ 40436 2992 18 critics critic NNS 40436 2992 19 , , , 40436 2992 20 to to TO 40436 2992 21 be be VB 40436 2992 22 spurious spurious JJ 40436 2992 23 and and CC 40436 2992 24 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 2992 25 of of IN 40436 2992 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2992 27 : : : 40436 2992 28 the the DT 40436 2992 29 production production NN 40436 2992 30 of of IN 40436 2992 31 one one CD 40436 2992 32 who who WP 40436 2992 33 was be VBD 40436 2992 34 not not RB 40436 2992 35 merely merely RB 40436 2992 36 an an DT 40436 2992 37 imitator imitator NN 40436 2992 38 , , , 40436 2992 39 but but CC 40436 2992 40 a a DT 40436 2992 41 bad bad JJ 40436 2992 42 and and CC 40436 2992 43 silly silly JJ 40436 2992 44 imitator imitator NN 40436 2992 45 . . . 40436 2993 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2993 2 1 1 LS 40436 2993 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2993 4 Socher Socher NNP 40436 2993 5 on on IN 40436 2993 6 the the DT 40436 2993 7 other other JJ 40436 2993 8 hand hand NN 40436 2993 9 defends defend VBZ 40436 2993 10 the the DT 40436 2993 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2993 12 against against IN 40436 2993 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 2993 14 , , , 40436 2993 15 reckoning reckon VBG 40436 2993 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2993 17 as as IN 40436 2993 18 a a DT 40436 2993 19 juvenile juvenile JJ 40436 2993 20 production production NN 40436 2993 21 of of IN 40436 2993 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 2993 23 . . . 40436 2994 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 2994 2 2 2 LS 40436 2994 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2994 4 The the DT 40436 2994 5 arguments argument NNS 40436 2994 6 which which WDT 40436 2994 7 are be VBP 40436 2994 8 adduced adduce VBN 40436 2994 9 to to TO 40436 2994 10 prove prove VB 40436 2994 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 2994 12 spuriousness spuriousness NN 40436 2994 13 appear appear VB 40436 2994 14 to to IN 40436 2994 15 me -PRON- PRP 40436 2994 16 altogether altogether RB 40436 2994 17 insufficient insufficient JJ 40436 2994 18 . . . 40436 2995 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 2995 2 has have VBZ 40436 2995 3 some some DT 40436 2995 4 features feature NNS 40436 2995 5 of of IN 40436 2995 6 dissimilarity dissimilarity NN 40436 2995 7 with with IN 40436 2995 8 that that DT 40436 2995 9 which which WDT 40436 2995 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 2995 11 read read VBP 40436 2995 12 in in IN 40436 2995 13 other other JJ 40436 2995 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2995 15 -- -- : 40436 2995 16 these these DT 40436 2995 17 the the DT 40436 2995 18 above above RB 40436 2995 19 - - HYPH 40436 2995 20 mentioned mention VBN 40436 2995 21 critics critic NNS 40436 2995 22 call call VBP 40436 2995 23 un un NNP 40436 2995 24 - - : 40436 2995 25 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 2995 26 : : : 40436 2995 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2995 28 has have VBZ 40436 2995 29 other other JJ 40436 2995 30 features feature NNS 40436 2995 31 of of IN 40436 2995 32 similarity similarity NN 40436 2995 33 -- -- : 40436 2995 34 these these DT 40436 2995 35 they -PRON- PRP 40436 2995 36 call call VBP 40436 2995 37 bad bad JJ 40436 2995 38 imitation imitation NN 40436 2995 39 by by IN 40436 2995 40 a a DT 40436 2995 41 _ _ NNP 40436 2995 42 falsarius falsarius NN 40436 2995 43 _ _ NNP 40436 2995 44 : : : 40436 2995 45 lastly lastly RB 40436 2995 46 , , , 40436 2995 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 2995 48 is be VBZ 40436 2995 49 inferior inferior JJ 40436 2995 50 , , , 40436 2995 51 as as IN 40436 2995 52 a a DT 40436 2995 53 performance performance NN 40436 2995 54 , , , 40436 2995 55 to to IN 40436 2995 56 the the DT 40436 2995 57 best good JJS 40436 2995 58 of of IN 40436 2995 59 the the DT 40436 2995 60 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2995 61 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2995 62 . . . 40436 2996 1 But but CC 40436 2996 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2996 3 am be VBP 40436 2996 4 prepared prepared JJ 40436 2996 5 to to TO 40436 2996 6 expect expect VB 40436 2996 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 2996 8 and and CC 40436 2996 9 have have VBP 40436 2996 10 even even RB 40436 2996 11 the the DT 40436 2996 12 authority authority NN 40436 2996 13 of of IN 40436 2996 14 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 2996 15 for for IN 40436 2996 16 expecting expecting NN 40436 2996 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 2996 18 that that IN 40436 2996 19 some some DT 40436 2996 20 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2996 21 will will MD 40436 2996 22 be be VB 40436 2996 23 inferior inferior JJ 40436 2996 24 to to IN 40436 2996 25 others other NNS 40436 2996 26 . . . 40436 2997 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 2997 2 also also RB 40436 2997 3 reckon reckon VBP 40436 2997 4 with with IN 40436 2997 5 certainty certainty NN 40436 2997 6 , , , 40436 2997 7 that that IN 40436 2997 8 between between IN 40436 2997 9 two two CD 40436 2997 10 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 2997 11 , , , 40436 2997 12 both both CC 40436 2997 13 genuine genuine JJ 40436 2997 14 , , , 40436 2997 15 there there EX 40436 2997 16 will will MD 40436 2997 17 be be VB 40436 2997 18 points point NNS 40436 2997 19 of of IN 40436 2997 20 similarity similarity NN 40436 2997 21 as as RB 40436 2997 22 well well RB 40436 2997 23 as as IN 40436 2997 24 points point NNS 40436 2997 25 of of IN 40436 2997 26 dissimilarity dissimilarity NN 40436 2997 27 . . . 40436 2998 1 Lastly lastly RB 40436 2998 2 , , , 40436 2998 3 the the DT 40436 2998 4 critics critic NNS 40436 2998 5 find find VBP 40436 2998 6 marks mark NNS 40436 2998 7 of of IN 40436 2998 8 a a DT 40436 2998 9 bad bad JJ 40436 2998 10 , , , 40436 2998 11 recent recent JJ 40436 2998 12 , , , 40436 2998 13 un un JJ 40436 2998 14 - - JJ 40436 2998 15 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 2998 16 style style NN 40436 2998 17 : : : 40436 2998 18 but but CC 40436 2998 19 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40436 2998 20 of of IN 40436 2998 21 Halikarnassus Halikarnassus NNP 40436 2998 22 -- -- : 40436 2998 23 a a DT 40436 2998 24 judge judge NN 40436 2998 25 at at IN 40436 2998 26 least least RBS 40436 2998 27 equally equally RB 40436 2998 28 competent competent JJ 40436 2998 29 upon upon IN 40436 2998 30 such such PDT 40436 2998 31 a a DT 40436 2998 32 matter matter NN 40436 2998 33 -- -- : 40436 2998 34 found find VBN 40436 2998 35 no no DT 40436 2998 36 such such JJ 40436 2998 37 marks mark NNS 40436 2998 38 . . . 40436 2999 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 2999 2 expressly expressly RB 40436 2999 3 cites cite VBZ 40436 2999 4 the the DT 40436 2999 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 2999 6 as as IN 40436 2999 7 the the DT 40436 2999 8 work work NN 40436 2999 9 of of IN 40436 2999 10 Plato,[3 Plato,[3 NNP 40436 2999 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 2999 12 and and CC 40436 2999 13 explains explain VBZ 40436 2999 14 the the DT 40436 2999 15 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 2999 16 phraseology phraseology NN 40436 2999 17 assigned assign VBN 40436 2999 18 to to IN 40436 2999 19 Demodokus Demodokus NNP 40436 2999 20 by by IN 40436 2999 21 remarking remark VBG 40436 2999 22 , , , 40436 2999 23 that that IN 40436 2999 24 the the DT 40436 2999 25 latter latter NN 40436 2999 26 is be VBZ 40436 2999 27 presented present VBN 40436 2999 28 as as IN 40436 2999 29 a a DT 40436 2999 30 person person NN 40436 2999 31 of of IN 40436 2999 32 rural rural JJ 40436 2999 33 habits habit NNS 40436 2999 34 and and CC 40436 2999 35 occupations occupation NNS 40436 2999 36 . . . 40436 3000 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3000 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3000 3 1 1 CD 40436 3000 4 : : : 40436 3000 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3000 6 , , , 40436 3000 7 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 3000 8 . . . 40436 3001 1 pp pp NNP 40436 3001 2 . . . 40436 3002 1 220 220 CD 40436 3002 2 - - SYM 40436 3002 3 225 225 CD 40436 3002 4 , , , 40436 3002 5 " " '' 40436 3002 6 ineptus ineptus NN 40436 3002 7 tenebrio tenebrio NN 40436 3002 8 , , , 40436 3002 9 " " '' 40436 3002 10 & & CC 40436 3002 11 c. c. NNP 40436 3002 12 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3002 13 , , , 40436 3002 14 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 3002 15 , , , 40436 3002 16 part part NN 40436 3002 17 ii ii NNP 40436 3002 18 . . . 40436 3003 1 v. v. CC 40436 3003 2 iii iii NNP 40436 3003 3 . . . 40436 3004 1 pp pp NNP 40436 3004 2 . . . 40436 3005 1 247 247 CD 40436 3005 2 - - SYM 40436 3005 3 252 252 CD 40436 3005 4 . . . 40436 3006 1 Ast Ast NNP 40436 3006 2 , , , 40436 3006 3 Platon Platon NNP 40436 3006 4 's 's POS 40436 3006 5 Leben Leben NNP 40436 3006 6 und und NN 40436 3006 7 Schriften Schriften NNP 40436 3006 8 , , , 40436 3006 9 pp pp NNP 40436 3006 10 . . . 40436 3007 1 495 495 CD 40436 3007 2 - - SYM 40436 3007 3 497 497 CD 40436 3007 4 . . . 40436 3008 1 Ast Ast NNP 40436 3008 2 speaks speak VBZ 40436 3008 3 with with IN 40436 3008 4 respect respect NN 40436 3008 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3008 6 differing differ VBG 40436 3008 7 in in IN 40436 3008 8 this this DT 40436 3008 9 respect respect NN 40436 3008 10 from from IN 40436 3008 11 the the DT 40436 3008 12 other other JJ 40436 3008 13 two two CD 40436 3008 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3008 15 of of IN 40436 3008 16 the the DT 40436 3008 17 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3008 18 as as IN 40436 3008 19 a a DT 40436 3008 20 composition composition NN 40436 3008 21 , , , 40436 3008 22 though though IN 40436 3008 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3008 24 does do VBZ 40436 3008 25 not not RB 40436 3008 26 believe believe VB 40436 3008 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3008 28 to to TO 40436 3008 29 be be VB 40436 3008 30 the the DT 40436 3008 31 work work NN 40436 3008 32 of of IN 40436 3008 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3008 34 . . . 40436 3009 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3009 2 also also RB 40436 3009 3 admits admit VBZ 40436 3009 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3009 5 see see VB 40436 3009 6 the the DT 40436 3009 7 end end NN 40436 3009 8 of of IN 40436 3009 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3009 10 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 3009 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3009 12 that that IN 40436 3009 13 the the DT 40436 3009 14 style style NN 40436 3009 15 in in IN 40436 3009 16 general general JJ 40436 3009 17 has have VBZ 40436 3009 18 a a DT 40436 3009 19 good good JJ 40436 3009 20 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3009 21 colouring colouring NN 40436 3009 22 , , , 40436 3009 23 though though IN 40436 3009 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3009 25 considers consider VBZ 40436 3009 26 some some DT 40436 3009 27 particular particular JJ 40436 3009 28 phrases phrase NNS 40436 3009 29 as as IN 40436 3009 30 un un NNP 40436 3009 31 - - : 40436 3009 32 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3009 33 . . . 40436 3009 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3010 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3010 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3010 3 2 2 CD 40436 3010 4 : : : 40436 3010 5 Socher Socher NNP 40436 3010 6 , , , 40436 3010 7 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 3010 8 Platon Platon NNP 40436 3010 9 , , , 40436 3010 10 pp pp NNP 40436 3010 11 . . . 40436 3011 1 92 92 CD 40436 3011 2 - - SYM 40436 3011 3 102 102 CD 40436 3011 4 . . . 40436 3012 1 M. M. NNP 40436 3012 2 Cobet Cobet NNP 40436 3012 3 also also RB 40436 3012 4 speaks speak VBZ 40436 3012 5 of of IN 40436 3012 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3012 7 as as IN 40436 3012 8 a a DT 40436 3012 9 work work NN 40436 3012 10 of of IN 40436 3012 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3012 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3012 13 Novæ Novæ NNP 40436 3012 14 Lectiones Lectiones NNP 40436 3012 15 , , , 40436 3012 16 & & CC 40436 3012 17 c. c. NNP 40436 3012 18 , , , 40436 3012 19 p. p. NN 40436 3012 20 624 624 CD 40436 3012 21 . . . 40436 3013 1 Lugd lugd VB 40436 3013 2 . . . 40436 3014 1 Bat bat NN 40436 3014 2 . . . 40436 3015 1 1858 1858 CD 40436 3015 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3015 3 . . . 40436 3015 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3016 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3016 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3016 3 3 3 CD 40436 3016 4 : : : 40436 3016 5 Dionys dionys NN 40436 3016 6 . . . 40436 3017 1 Hal hal UH 40436 3017 2 . . . 40436 3018 1 Ars Ars NNP 40436 3018 2 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 3018 3 . . . 40436 3019 1 p. p. NN 40436 3019 2 405 405 CD 40436 3019 3 , , , 40436 3019 4 Reiske Reiske NNP 40436 3019 5 . . . 40436 3020 1 Compare compare VB 40436 3020 2 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3020 3 , , , 40436 3020 4 121 121 CD 40436 3020 5 D. D. NNP 40436 3020 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3020 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3020 8 : : : 40436 3020 9 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 3020 10 to\ to\ NN 40436 3020 11 a)/stu a)/stu NNP 40436 3020 12 katabai katabai NNP 40436 3020 13 / / SYM 40436 3020 14 nontes nontes NNP 40436 3020 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3020 16 . . . 40436 3021 1 In in IN 40436 3021 2 general general JJ 40436 3021 3 , , , 40436 3021 4 in in IN 40436 3021 5 discussions discussion NNS 40436 3021 6 on on IN 40436 3021 7 the the DT 40436 3021 8 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 3021 9 of of IN 40436 3021 10 any any DT 40436 3021 11 of of IN 40436 3021 12 the the DT 40436 3021 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3021 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3021 15 , , , 40436 3021 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3021 17 can can MD 40436 3021 18 do do VB 40436 3021 19 nothing nothing NN 40436 3021 20 but but IN 40436 3021 21 reply reply VB 40436 3021 22 to to IN 40436 3021 23 the the DT 40436 3021 24 arguments argument NNS 40436 3021 25 of of IN 40436 3021 26 those those DT 40436 3021 27 critics critic NNS 40436 3021 28 who who WP 40436 3021 29 consider consider VBP 40436 3021 30 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3021 31 spurious spurious JJ 40436 3021 32 . . . 40436 3022 1 But but CC 40436 3022 2 in in IN 40436 3022 3 the the DT 40436 3022 4 case case NN 40436 3022 5 of of IN 40436 3022 6 the the DT 40436 3022 7 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3022 8 there there EX 40436 3022 9 is be VBZ 40436 3022 10 one one CD 40436 3022 11 argument argument NN 40436 3022 12 which which WDT 40436 3022 13 tends tend VBZ 40436 3022 14 to to TO 40436 3022 15 mark mark VB 40436 3022 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3022 17 positively positively RB 40436 3022 18 as as IN 40436 3022 19 the the DT 40436 3022 20 author author NN 40436 3022 21 . . . 40436 3023 1 In in IN 40436 3023 2 the the DT 40436 3023 3 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3023 4 , , , 40436 3023 5 p. p. NN 40436 3023 6 125 125 CD 40436 3023 7 , , , 40436 3023 8 the the DT 40436 3023 9 senarius senarius NN 40436 3023 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3023 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3023 12 : : : 40436 3023 13 sophoi\ sophoi\ NNP 40436 3023 14 tu tu NNP 40436 3023 15 / / SYM 40436 3023 16 rannoi rannoi NNP 40436 3023 17 tô tô NNP 40436 3023 18 = = SYM 40436 3023 19 n n NNP 40436 3023 20 sophô sophô NNP 40436 3023 21 = = SYM 40436 3023 22 n n CC 40436 3023 23 sunousi sunousi NN 40436 3023 24 / / SYM 40436 3023 25 a| a| NN 40436 3023 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3023 27 is be VBZ 40436 3023 28 cited cite VBN 40436 3023 29 as as IN 40436 3023 30 a a DT 40436 3023 31 verse verse NN 40436 3023 32 of of IN 40436 3023 33 _ _ NNP 40436 3023 34 Euripides Euripides NNP 40436 3023 35 _ _ NNP 40436 3023 36 . . . 40436 3024 1 Now now RB 40436 3024 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3024 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 3024 4 that that IN 40436 3024 5 this this DT 40436 3024 6 is be VBZ 40436 3024 7 an an DT 40436 3024 8 error error NN 40436 3024 9 of of IN 40436 3024 10 memory memory NN 40436 3024 11 , , , 40436 3024 12 and and CC 40436 3024 13 that that IN 40436 3024 14 the the DT 40436 3024 15 verse verse NN 40436 3024 16 really really RB 40436 3024 17 belongs belong VBZ 40436 3024 18 to to IN 40436 3024 19 _ _ NNP 40436 3024 20 Sophokles Sophokles NNP 40436 3024 21 _ _ NNP 40436 3024 22 , , , 40436 3024 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3024 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3024 25 : : : 40436 3024 26 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3024 27 Ai)/anti Ai)/anti NNP 40436 3024 28 Lokrô=| Lokrô=| NNP 40436 3024 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3024 30 . . . 40436 3025 1 If if IN 40436 3025 2 the the DT 40436 3025 3 error error NN 40436 3025 4 had have VBD 40436 3025 5 only only RB 40436 3025 6 appeared appear VBN 40436 3025 7 in in IN 40436 3025 8 this this DT 40436 3025 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3025 10 , , , 40436 3025 11 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3025 12 would would MD 40436 3025 13 probably probably RB 40436 3025 14 have have VB 40436 3025 15 cited cite VBN 40436 3025 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3025 17 as as IN 40436 3025 18 one one CD 40436 3025 19 more more JJR 40436 3025 20 instance instance NN 40436 3025 21 of of IN 40436 3025 22 stupidity stupidity NN 40436 3025 23 on on IN 40436 3025 24 the the DT 40436 3025 25 part part NN 40436 3025 26 of of IN 40436 3025 27 the the DT 40436 3025 28 _ _ NNP 40436 3025 29 ineptus ineptus NN 40436 3025 30 tenebrio tenebrio NN 40436 3025 31 _ _ IN 40436 3025 32 whom whom WP 40436 3025 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3025 34 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 3025 35 to to TO 40436 3025 36 have have VB 40436 3025 37 written write VBN 40436 3025 38 the the DT 40436 3025 39 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3025 40 . . . 40436 3026 1 But but CC 40436 3026 2 unfortunately unfortunately RB 40436 3026 3 the the DT 40436 3026 4 error error NN 40436 3026 5 does do VBZ 40436 3026 6 not not RB 40436 3026 7 belong belong VB 40436 3026 8 to to IN 40436 3026 9 the the DT 40436 3026 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3026 11 alone alone RB 40436 3026 12 . . . 40436 3027 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3027 2 is be VBZ 40436 3027 3 found find VBN 40436 3027 4 also also RB 40436 3027 5 in in IN 40436 3027 6 the the DT 40436 3027 7 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3027 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3027 9 viii viii RB 40436 3027 10 . . . 40436 3028 1 568 568 CD 40436 3028 2 B B NNP 40436 3028 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3028 4 , , , 40436 3028 5 the the DT 40436 3028 6 most most RBS 40436 3028 7 unquestionable unquestionable JJ 40436 3028 8 of of IN 40436 3028 9 all all PDT 40436 3028 10 the the DT 40436 3028 11 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3028 12 compositions composition NNS 40436 3028 13 . . . 40436 3029 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 3029 2 , , , 40436 3029 3 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3029 4 tells tell VBZ 40436 3029 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3029 6 in in IN 40436 3029 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3029 8 note note NN 40436 3029 9 that that IN 40436 3029 10 the the DT 40436 3029 11 _ _ NNP 40436 3029 12 falsarius falsarius NN 40436 3029 13 _ _ NNP 40436 3029 14 of of IN 40436 3029 15 the the DT 40436 3029 16 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3029 17 has have VBZ 40436 3029 18 copied copy VBN 40436 3029 19 this this DT 40436 3029 20 error error NN 40436 3029 21 out out IN 40436 3029 22 of of IN 40436 3029 23 the the DT 40436 3029 24 above above RB 40436 3029 25 - - HYPH 40436 3029 26 named name VBN 40436 3029 27 passage passage NN 40436 3029 28 of of IN 40436 3029 29 the the DT 40436 3029 30 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3029 31 of of IN 40436 3029 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3029 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3029 34 notes note NNS 40436 3029 35 , , , 40436 3029 36 p. p. NN 40436 3029 37 500 500 CD 40436 3029 38 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3029 39 . . . 40436 3030 1 This this DT 40436 3030 2 last last JJ 40436 3030 3 supposition supposition NN 40436 3030 4 of of IN 40436 3030 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3030 6 appears appear VBZ 40436 3030 7 to to IN 40436 3030 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3030 9 highly highly RB 40436 3030 10 improbable improbable JJ 40436 3030 11 . . . 40436 3031 1 Since since IN 40436 3031 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3031 3 know know VBP 40436 3031 4 that that IN 40436 3031 5 the the DT 40436 3031 6 mistake mistake NN 40436 3031 7 is be VBZ 40436 3031 8 one one CD 40436 3031 9 made make VBN 40436 3031 10 by by IN 40436 3031 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3031 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3031 13 , , , 40436 3031 14 surely surely RB 40436 3031 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3031 16 ought ought MD 40436 3031 17 rather rather RB 40436 3031 18 to to TO 40436 3031 19 believe believe VB 40436 3031 20 that that IN 40436 3031 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3031 22 made make VBD 40436 3031 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3031 24 in in IN 40436 3031 25 two two CD 40436 3031 26 distinct distinct JJ 40436 3031 27 compositions composition NNS 40436 3031 28 . . . 40436 3032 1 In in IN 40436 3032 2 other other JJ 40436 3032 3 words word NNS 40436 3032 4 , , , 40436 3032 5 the the DT 40436 3032 6 occurrence occurrence NN 40436 3032 7 of of IN 40436 3032 8 the the DT 40436 3032 9 same same JJ 40436 3032 10 exact exact JJ 40436 3032 11 mistake mistake NN 40436 3032 12 in in IN 40436 3032 13 the the DT 40436 3032 14 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3032 15 and and CC 40436 3032 16 the the DT 40436 3032 17 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3032 18 affords afford VBZ 40436 3032 19 strong strong JJ 40436 3032 20 presumption presumption NN 40436 3032 21 that that IN 40436 3032 22 both both DT 40436 3032 23 are be VBP 40436 3032 24 by by IN 40436 3032 25 the the DT 40436 3032 26 same same JJ 40436 3032 27 author author NN 40436 3032 28 -- -- : 40436 3032 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3032 30 . . . 40436 3032 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3033 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3033 2 Side side NN 40436 3033 3 - - HYPH 40436 3033 4 note note NN 40436 3033 5 : : : 40436 3033 6 Persons person NNS 40436 3033 7 of of IN 40436 3033 8 the the DT 40436 3033 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3033 10 -- -- : 40436 3033 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3033 12 , , , 40436 3033 13 with with IN 40436 3033 14 Demodokus Demodokus NNP 40436 3033 15 and and CC 40436 3033 16 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3033 17 , , , 40436 3033 18 father father NN 40436 3033 19 and and CC 40436 3033 20 son son NN 40436 3033 21 . . . 40436 3034 1 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3034 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3034 3 the the DT 40436 3034 4 son son NN 40436 3034 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3034 6 , , , 40436 3034 7 eager eager JJ 40436 3034 8 to to TO 40436 3034 9 acquire acquire VB 40436 3034 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3034 11 , , , 40436 3034 12 desires desire NNS 40436 3034 13 to to TO 40436 3034 14 be be VB 40436 3034 15 placed place VBN 40436 3034 16 under under IN 40436 3034 17 the the DT 40436 3034 18 teaching teaching NN 40436 3034 19 of of IN 40436 3034 20 a a DT 40436 3034 21 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 3034 22 . . . 40436 3034 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3035 1 Demodokus Demodokus NNP 40436 3035 2 , , , 40436 3035 3 an an DT 40436 3035 4 elderly elderly JJ 40436 3035 5 man man NN 40436 3035 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3035 7 of of IN 40436 3035 8 rank rank NN 40436 3035 9 and and CC 40436 3035 10 landed land VBD 40436 3035 11 property property NN 40436 3035 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3035 13 , , , 40436 3035 14 and and CC 40436 3035 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3035 16 youthful youthful JJ 40436 3035 17 son son NN 40436 3035 18 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3035 19 , , , 40436 3035 20 have have VBP 40436 3035 21 come come VBN 40436 3035 22 from from IN 40436 3035 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3035 24 Deme Deme NNP 40436 3035 25 to to IN 40436 3035 26 Athens Athens NNP 40436 3035 27 , , , 40436 3035 28 and and CC 40436 3035 29 enter enter VB 40436 3035 30 into into IN 40436 3035 31 conversation conversation NN 40436 3035 32 with with IN 40436 3035 33 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3035 34 : : : 40436 3035 35 to to TO 40436 3035 36 whom whom WP 40436 3035 37 the the DT 40436 3035 38 father father NN 40436 3035 39 explains explain VBZ 40436 3035 40 , , , 40436 3035 41 that that IN 40436 3035 42 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3035 43 has have VBZ 40436 3035 44 contracted contract VBN 40436 3035 45 , , , 40436 3035 46 from from IN 40436 3035 47 the the DT 40436 3035 48 conversation conversation NN 40436 3035 49 of of IN 40436 3035 50 youthful youthful JJ 40436 3035 51 companions companion NNS 40436 3035 52 , , , 40436 3035 53 an an DT 40436 3035 54 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 40436 3035 55 ardour ardour NN 40436 3035 56 for for IN 40436 3035 57 the the DT 40436 3035 58 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 3035 59 of of IN 40436 3035 60 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3035 61 . . . 40436 3036 1 The the DT 40436 3036 2 son son NN 40436 3036 3 has have VBZ 40436 3036 4 importuned importune VBN 40436 3036 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3036 6 father father NN 40436 3036 7 to to TO 40436 3036 8 put put VB 40436 3036 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3036 10 under under IN 40436 3036 11 the the DT 40436 3036 12 tuition tuition NN 40436 3036 13 of of IN 40436 3036 14 one one CD 40436 3036 15 of of IN 40436 3036 16 the the DT 40436 3036 17 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 3036 18 , , , 40436 3036 19 who who WP 40436 3036 20 profess profess VBP 40436 3036 21 to to TO 40436 3036 22 teach teach VB 40436 3036 23 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3036 24 . . . 40436 3037 1 The the DT 40436 3037 2 father father NN 40436 3037 3 , , , 40436 3037 4 though though IN 40436 3037 5 not not RB 40436 3037 6 unwilling unwilling JJ 40436 3037 7 to to TO 40436 3037 8 comply comply VB 40436 3037 9 with with IN 40436 3037 10 the the DT 40436 3037 11 request request NN 40436 3037 12 , , , 40436 3037 13 is be VBZ 40436 3037 14 deterred deter VBN 40436 3037 15 by by IN 40436 3037 16 the the DT 40436 3037 17 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 3037 18 of of IN 40436 3037 19 finding find VBG 40436 3037 20 a a DT 40436 3037 21 good good JJ 40436 3037 22 teacher teacher NN 40436 3037 23 and and CC 40436 3037 24 avoiding avoid VBG 40436 3037 25 a a DT 40436 3037 26 bad bad JJ 40436 3037 27 one one NN 40436 3037 28 . . . 40436 3038 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3038 2 entreats entreat VBZ 40436 3038 3 the the DT 40436 3038 4 advice advice NN 40436 3038 5 of of IN 40436 3038 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3038 7 , , , 40436 3038 8 who who WP 40436 3038 9 invites invite VBZ 40436 3038 10 the the DT 40436 3038 11 young young JJ 40436 3038 12 man man NN 40436 3038 13 to to TO 40436 3038 14 explain explain VB 40436 3038 15 what what WP 40436 3038 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3038 17 is be VBZ 40436 3038 18 that that IN 40436 3038 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3038 20 wants want VBZ 40436 3038 21 , , , 40436 3038 22 over over RB 40436 3038 23 and and CC 40436 3038 24 above above IN 40436 3038 25 the the DT 40436 3038 26 usual usual JJ 40436 3038 27 education education NN 40436 3038 28 of of IN 40436 3038 29 an an DT 40436 3038 30 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 3038 31 youth youth NN 40436 3038 32 of of IN 40436 3038 33 good good JJ 40436 3038 34 family family NN 40436 3038 35 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3038 36 letters letter NNS 40436 3038 37 , , , 40436 3038 38 the the DT 40436 3038 39 harp harp NN 40436 3038 40 , , , 40436 3038 41 wrestling wrestle VBG 40436 3038 42 , , , 40436 3038 43 & & CC 40436 3038 44 c. c. NNP 40436 3038 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3038 46 , , , 40436 3038 47 which which WDT 40436 3038 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3038 49 has have VBZ 40436 3038 50 already already RB 40436 3038 51 gone go VBN 40436 3038 52 through through RB 40436 3038 53 . . . 40436 3039 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3039 2 4 4 CD 40436 3039 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3039 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3039 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3039 6 4 4 CD 40436 3039 7 : : : 40436 3039 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3039 9 , , , 40436 3039 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3039 11 , , , 40436 3039 12 122 122 CD 40436 3039 13 . . . 40436 3039 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3040 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3040 2 Side side NN 40436 3040 3 - - HYPH 40436 3040 4 note note NN 40436 3040 5 : : : 40436 3040 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3040 7 questions question NNS 40436 3040 8 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3040 9 , , , 40436 3040 10 inviting invite VBG 40436 3040 11 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3040 12 to to TO 40436 3040 13 specify specify VB 40436 3040 14 what what WP 40436 3040 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3040 16 wants want VBZ 40436 3040 17 . . . 40436 3040 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3041 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3041 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 3041 3 desire desire NN 40436 3041 4 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3041 5 : : : 40436 3041 6 but but CC 40436 3041 7 what what WP 40436 3041 8 kind kind NN 40436 3041 9 of of IN 40436 3041 10 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3041 11 ? ? . 40436 3042 1 That that IN 40436 3042 2 by by IN 40436 3042 3 which which WDT 40436 3042 4 men man NNS 40436 3042 5 manage manage VBP 40436 3042 6 chariots chariot NNS 40436 3042 7 ? ? . 40436 3043 1 or or CC 40436 3043 2 govern govern VB 40436 3043 3 horses horse NNS 40436 3043 4 ? ? . 40436 3044 1 or or CC 40436 3044 2 pilot pilot NN 40436 3044 3 ships ship NNS 40436 3044 4 ? ? . 40436 3045 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3045 2 Theag._--No theag._--no NN 40436 3045 3 : : : 40436 3045 4 that that IN 40436 3045 5 by by IN 40436 3045 6 which which WDT 40436 3045 7 men man NNS 40436 3045 8 are be VBP 40436 3045 9 governed govern VBN 40436 3045 10 . . . 40436 3046 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3046 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 3046 3 what what WP 40436 3046 4 men man NNS 40436 3046 5 ? ? . 40436 3047 1 those those DT 40436 3047 2 in in IN 40436 3047 3 a a DT 40436 3047 4 state state NN 40436 3047 5 of of IN 40436 3047 6 sickness sickness NN 40436 3047 7 -- -- : 40436 3047 8 or or CC 40436 3047 9 those those DT 40436 3047 10 who who WP 40436 3047 11 are be VBP 40436 3047 12 singing singe VBG 40436 3047 13 in in IN 40436 3047 14 a a DT 40436 3047 15 chorus chorus NN 40436 3047 16 -- -- : 40436 3047 17 or or CC 40436 3047 18 those those DT 40436 3047 19 who who WP 40436 3047 20 are be VBP 40436 3047 21 under under IN 40436 3047 22 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 3047 23 training training NN 40436 3047 24 ? ? . 40436 3048 1 Each each DT 40436 3048 2 of of IN 40436 3048 3 these these DT 40436 3048 4 classes class NNS 40436 3048 5 has have VBZ 40436 3048 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3048 7 own own JJ 40436 3048 8 governor governor NN 40436 3048 9 , , , 40436 3048 10 who who WP 40436 3048 11 bears bear VBZ 40436 3048 12 a a DT 40436 3048 13 special special JJ 40436 3048 14 title title NN 40436 3048 15 , , , 40436 3048 16 and and CC 40436 3048 17 belongs belong VBZ 40436 3048 18 to to IN 40436 3048 19 a a DT 40436 3048 20 special special JJ 40436 3048 21 art art NN 40436 3048 22 by by IN 40436 3048 23 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 3048 24 -- -- : 40436 3048 25 the the DT 40436 3048 26 medical medical JJ 40436 3048 27 , , , 40436 3048 28 musical musical JJ 40436 3048 29 , , , 40436 3048 30 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 3048 31 , , , 40436 3048 32 & & CC 40436 3048 33 c. c. NNP 40436 3048 34 _ _ NNP 40436 3048 35 Theag._--No theag._--no NN 40436 3048 36 : : : 40436 3048 37 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3048 38 mean mean VBP 40436 3048 39 that that IN 40436 3048 40 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3048 41 by by IN 40436 3048 42 which which WDT 40436 3048 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3048 44 govern govern VBP 40436 3048 45 , , , 40436 3048 46 not not RB 40436 3048 47 these these DT 40436 3048 48 classes class NNS 40436 3048 49 alone alone RB 40436 3048 50 , , , 40436 3048 51 but but CC 40436 3048 52 all all PDT 40436 3048 53 the the DT 40436 3048 54 other other JJ 40436 3048 55 residents resident NNS 40436 3048 56 in in IN 40436 3048 57 the the DT 40436 3048 58 city city NN 40436 3048 59 along along IN 40436 3048 60 with with IN 40436 3048 61 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3048 62 -- -- : 40436 3048 63 professional professional JJ 40436 3048 64 as as RB 40436 3048 65 well well RB 40436 3048 66 as as IN 40436 3048 67 private private JJ 40436 3048 68 -- -- : 40436 3048 69 men man NNS 40436 3048 70 as as RB 40436 3048 71 well well RB 40436 3048 72 as as IN 40436 3048 73 women woman NNS 40436 3048 74 . . . 40436 3049 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3049 2 5 5 CD 40436 3049 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3049 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3049 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3049 6 5 5 CD 40436 3049 7 : : : 40436 3049 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3049 9 , , , 40436 3049 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3049 11 , , , 40436 3049 12 124 124 CD 40436 3049 13 A A NNP 40436 3049 14 - - HYPH 40436 3049 15 B. b. NN 40436 3050 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3050 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3050 3 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 3050 4 . . . 40436 3051 1 p. p. NN 40436 3051 2 250 250 CD 40436 3051 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3051 4 censures censure VBZ 40436 3051 5 the the DT 40436 3051 6 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 3051 7 of of IN 40436 3051 8 the the DT 40436 3051 9 inductive inductive JJ 40436 3051 10 process process NN 40436 3051 11 in in IN 40436 3051 12 this this DT 40436 3051 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3051 14 , , , 40436 3051 15 and and CC 40436 3051 16 the the DT 40436 3051 17 multitude multitude NN 40436 3051 18 of of IN 40436 3051 19 examples example NNS 40436 3051 20 here here RB 40436 3051 21 accumulated accumulate VBN 40436 3051 22 to to TO 40436 3051 23 prove prove VB 40436 3051 24 a a DT 40436 3051 25 general general JJ 40436 3051 26 proposition proposition NN 40436 3051 27 obvious obvious JJ 40436 3051 28 enough enough RB 40436 3051 29 without without IN 40436 3051 30 proof proof NN 40436 3051 31 . . . 40436 3052 1 Let let VB 40436 3052 2 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3052 3 grant grant VB 40436 3052 4 this this DT 40436 3052 5 to to TO 40436 3052 6 be be VB 40436 3052 7 true true JJ 40436 3052 8 ; ; : 40436 3052 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3052 10 can can MD 40436 3052 11 not not RB 40436 3052 12 infer infer VB 40436 3052 13 from from IN 40436 3052 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3052 15 that that IN 40436 3052 16 the the DT 40436 3052 17 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3052 18 is be VBZ 40436 3052 19 not not RB 40436 3052 20 the the DT 40436 3052 21 work work NN 40436 3052 22 of of IN 40436 3052 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3052 24 . . . 40436 3053 1 By by IN 40436 3053 2 very very RB 40436 3053 3 similar similar JJ 40436 3053 4 arguments argument NNS 40436 3053 5 Socher Socher NNP 40436 3053 6 endeavours endeavour NNS 40436 3053 7 to to TO 40436 3053 8 show show VB 40436 3053 9 that that IN 40436 3053 10 the the DT 40436 3053 11 Sophistês Sophistês NNP 40436 3053 12 and and CC 40436 3053 13 the the DT 40436 3053 14 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 3053 15 are be VBP 40436 3053 16 not not RB 40436 3053 17 works work NNS 40436 3053 18 of of IN 40436 3053 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3053 20 , , , 40436 3053 21 because because IN 40436 3053 22 in in IN 40436 3053 23 both both PDT 40436 3053 24 these these DT 40436 3053 25 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3053 26 logical logical JJ 40436 3053 27 division division NN 40436 3053 28 and and CC 40436 3053 29 differentiation differentiation NN 40436 3053 30 is be VBZ 40436 3053 31 accumulated accumulate VBN 40436 3053 32 with with IN 40436 3053 33 tiresome tiresome JJ 40436 3053 34 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 3053 35 , , , 40436 3053 36 and and CC 40436 3053 37 applied apply VBD 40436 3053 38 to to IN 40436 3053 39 most most JJS 40436 3053 40 trivial trivial JJ 40436 3053 41 subjects subject NNS 40436 3053 42 . . . 40436 3054 1 But but CC 40436 3054 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3054 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3054 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3054 5 in in IN 40436 3054 6 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 3054 7 , , , 40436 3054 8 pp pp NNP 40436 3054 9 . . . 40436 3055 1 285 285 CD 40436 3055 2 - - SYM 40436 3055 3 286 286 CD 40436 3055 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3055 5 explains explain VBZ 40436 3055 6 why why WRB 40436 3055 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3055 8 does do VBZ 40436 3055 9 so so RB 40436 3055 10 , , , 40436 3055 11 and and CC 40436 3055 12 tells tell VBZ 40436 3055 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3055 14 that that IN 40436 3055 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3055 16 wishes wish VBZ 40436 3055 17 to to TO 40436 3055 18 familiarise familiarise VB 40436 3055 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3055 20 readers reader NNS 40436 3055 21 with with IN 40436 3055 22 logical logical JJ 40436 3055 23 subdivision subdivision NN 40436 3055 24 and and CC 40436 3055 25 classification classification NN 40436 3055 26 as as IN 40436 3055 27 a a DT 40436 3055 28 process process NN 40436 3055 29 . . . 40436 3056 1 In in IN 40436 3056 2 like like JJ 40436 3056 3 manner manner NN 40436 3056 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3056 5 maintain maintain VBP 40436 3056 6 that that DT 40436 3056 7 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 3056 8 in in IN 40436 3056 9 the the DT 40436 3056 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3056 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3056 12 : : : 40436 3056 13 lo lo NNP 40436 3056 14 / / SYM 40436 3056 15 goi goi NNP 40436 3056 16 e)paktikoi/ e)paktikoi/ NFP 40436 3056 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3056 18 is be VBZ 40436 3056 19 not not RB 40436 3056 20 to to TO 40436 3056 21 be be VB 40436 3056 22 held hold VBN 40436 3056 23 as as IN 40436 3056 24 proof proof NN 40436 3056 25 of of IN 40436 3056 26 spurious spurious JJ 40436 3056 27 authorship authorship NN 40436 3056 28 , , , 40436 3056 29 any any DT 40436 3056 30 more more RBR 40436 3056 31 than than IN 40436 3056 32 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 3056 33 in in IN 40436 3056 34 the the DT 40436 3056 35 process process NN 40436 3056 36 of of IN 40436 3056 37 logical logical JJ 40436 3056 38 subdivision subdivision NN 40436 3056 39 and and CC 40436 3056 40 classification classification NN 40436 3056 41 . . . 40436 3057 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3057 2 noticed notice VBD 40436 3057 3 the the DT 40436 3057 4 same same JJ 40436 3057 5 objection objection NN 40436 3057 6 in in IN 40436 3057 7 the the DT 40436 3057 8 case case NN 40436 3057 9 of of IN 40436 3057 10 the the DT 40436 3057 11 First First NNP 40436 3057 12 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 3057 13 . . . 40436 3057 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3058 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3058 2 Side side NN 40436 3058 3 - - HYPH 40436 3058 4 note note NN 40436 3058 5 : : : 40436 3058 6 Theagês theagês JJ 40436 3058 7 desires desire NNS 40436 3058 8 to to TO 40436 3058 9 acquire acquire VB 40436 3058 10 that that DT 40436 3058 11 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3058 12 by by IN 40436 3058 13 which which WDT 40436 3058 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3058 15 can can MD 40436 3058 16 govern govern VB 40436 3058 17 freemen freeman NNS 40436 3058 18 with with IN 40436 3058 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3058 20 own own JJ 40436 3058 21 consent consent NN 40436 3058 22 . . . 40436 3058 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3059 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3059 2 now now RB 40436 3059 3 proves prove VBZ 40436 3059 4 to to IN 40436 3059 5 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3059 6 , , , 40436 3059 7 that that IN 40436 3059 8 this this DT 40436 3059 9 function function NN 40436 3059 10 and and CC 40436 3059 11 power power NN 40436 3059 12 which which WDT 40436 3059 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3059 14 is be VBZ 40436 3059 15 desirous desirous JJ 40436 3059 16 of of IN 40436 3059 17 obtaining obtain VBG 40436 3059 18 , , , 40436 3059 19 is be VBZ 40436 3059 20 , , , 40436 3059 21 the the DT 40436 3059 22 function function NN 40436 3059 23 and and CC 40436 3059 24 power power NN 40436 3059 25 of of IN 40436 3059 26 a a DT 40436 3059 27 despot despot NN 40436 3059 28 : : : 40436 3059 29 and and CC 40436 3059 30 that that IN 40436 3059 31 no no DT 40436 3059 32 one one NN 40436 3059 33 can can MD 40436 3059 34 aid aid VB 40436 3059 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3059 36 in in IN 40436 3059 37 so so RB 40436 3059 38 culpable culpable JJ 40436 3059 39 a a DT 40436 3059 40 project project NN 40436 3059 41 . . . 40436 3060 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3060 2 might may MD 40436 3060 3 yearn yearn VB 40436 3060 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3060 5 says say VBZ 40436 3060 6 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3060 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3060 8 for for IN 40436 3060 9 such such JJ 40436 3060 10 despotic despotic JJ 40436 3060 11 power power NN 40436 3060 12 over over IN 40436 3060 13 all all DT 40436 3060 14 : : : 40436 3060 15 so so RB 40436 3060 16 probably probably RB 40436 3060 17 would would MD 40436 3060 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3060 19 and and CC 40436 3060 20 every every DT 40436 3060 21 other other JJ 40436 3060 22 man man NN 40436 3060 23 . . . 40436 3061 1 But but CC 40436 3061 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3061 3 is be VBZ 40436 3061 4 not not RB 40436 3061 5 _ _ NNP 40436 3061 6 that that IN 40436 3061 7 _ _ NNP 40436 3061 8 to to IN 40436 3061 9 which which WDT 40436 3061 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3061 11 now now RB 40436 3061 12 aspire aspire VBP 40436 3061 13 . . . 40436 3062 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3062 2 aspire aspire VBP 40436 3062 3 to to TO 40436 3062 4 govern govern VB 40436 3062 5 freemen freeman NNS 40436 3062 6 , , , 40436 3062 7 with with IN 40436 3062 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3062 9 own own JJ 40436 3062 10 consent consent NN 40436 3062 11 ; ; : 40436 3062 12 as as IN 40436 3062 13 was be VBD 40436 3062 14 done do VBN 40436 3062 15 by by IN 40436 3062 16 Themistokles Themistokles NNP 40436 3062 17 , , , 40436 3062 18 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 3062 19 , , , 40436 3062 20 Kimon Kimon NNP 40436 3062 21 , , , 40436 3062 22 and and CC 40436 3062 23 other other JJ 40436 3062 24 illustrious illustrious JJ 40436 3062 25 statesmen,[6 statesmen,[6 NN 40436 3062 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3062 27 who who WP 40436 3062 28 have have VBP 40436 3062 29 been be VBN 40436 3062 30 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 3062 31 in in IN 40436 3062 32 the the DT 40436 3062 33 political political JJ 40436 3062 34 art art NN 40436 3062 35 . . . 40436 3063 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3063 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3063 3 6 6 CD 40436 3063 4 : : : 40436 3063 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3063 6 , , , 40436 3063 7 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3063 8 , , , 40436 3063 9 126 126 CD 40436 3063 10 A. a. NN 40436 3063 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3064 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3064 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 3064 3 , , , 40436 3064 4 if if IN 40436 3064 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3064 6 wished wish VBD 40436 3064 7 to to TO 40436 3064 8 become become VB 40436 3064 9 accomplished accomplished JJ 40436 3064 10 in in IN 40436 3064 11 the the DT 40436 3064 12 art art NN 40436 3064 13 of of IN 40436 3064 14 horsemanship horsemanship NN 40436 3064 15 , , , 40436 3064 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3064 17 would would MD 40436 3064 18 put put VB 40436 3064 19 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 3064 20 under under IN 40436 3064 21 able able JJ 40436 3064 22 horsemen horseman NNS 40436 3064 23 : : : 40436 3064 24 if if IN 40436 3064 25 in in IN 40436 3064 26 the the DT 40436 3064 27 art art NN 40436 3064 28 of of IN 40436 3064 29 darting dart VBG 40436 3064 30 the the DT 40436 3064 31 javelin javelin NN 40436 3064 32 , , , 40436 3064 33 under under IN 40436 3064 34 able able JJ 40436 3064 35 darters darter NNS 40436 3064 36 . . . 40436 3065 1 By by IN 40436 3065 2 parity parity NN 40436 3065 3 of of IN 40436 3065 4 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 3065 5 , , , 40436 3065 6 since since IN 40436 3065 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3065 8 seek seek VBP 40436 3065 9 to to TO 40436 3065 10 learn learn VB 40436 3065 11 the the DT 40436 3065 12 art art NN 40436 3065 13 of of IN 40436 3065 14 statesmanship statesmanship NN 40436 3065 15 , , , 40436 3065 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3065 17 must must MD 40436 3065 18 frequent frequent VB 40436 3065 19 able able JJ 40436 3065 20 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 3065 21 . . . 40436 3066 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3066 2 7 7 CD 40436 3066 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3066 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3066 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3066 6 7 7 CD 40436 3066 7 : : : 40436 3066 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3066 9 , , , 40436 3066 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3066 11 , , , 40436 3066 12 126 126 CD 40436 3066 13 C. c. NN 40436 3066 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3066 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3066 16 Side side NN 40436 3066 17 - - HYPH 40436 3066 18 note note NN 40436 3066 19 : : : 40436 3066 20 Incompetence incompetence NN 40436 3066 21 of of IN 40436 3066 22 the the DT 40436 3066 23 best good JJS 40436 3066 24 practical practical JJ 40436 3066 25 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 3066 26 to to TO 40436 3066 27 teach teach VB 40436 3066 28 any any DT 40436 3066 29 one one NN 40436 3066 30 else else RB 40436 3066 31 . . . 40436 3067 1 Theagês theagês JJ 40436 3067 2 requests request NNS 40436 3067 3 that that IN 40436 3067 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3067 5 will will MD 40436 3067 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3067 7 teach teach VB 40436 3067 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3067 9 . . . 40436 3067 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3068 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3068 2 Theag._--No theag._--no NN 40436 3068 3 , , , 40436 3068 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3068 5 . . . 40436 3069 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3069 2 have have VBP 40436 3069 3 heard hear VBN 40436 3069 4 of of IN 40436 3069 5 the the DT 40436 3069 6 language language NN 40436 3069 7 which which WDT 40436 3069 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3069 9 are be VBP 40436 3069 10 in in IN 40436 3069 11 the the DT 40436 3069 12 habit habit NN 40436 3069 13 of of IN 40436 3069 14 using use VBG 40436 3069 15 to to IN 40436 3069 16 others other NNS 40436 3069 17 . . . 40436 3070 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3070 2 pointed point VBD 40436 3070 3 out out RP 40436 3070 4 to to IN 40436 3070 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3070 6 that that IN 40436 3070 7 these these DT 40436 3070 8 eminent eminent JJ 40436 3070 9 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 3070 10 can can MD 40436 3070 11 not not RB 40436 3070 12 train train VB 40436 3070 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3070 14 own own JJ 40436 3070 15 sons son NNS 40436 3070 16 to to TO 40436 3070 17 be be VB 40436 3070 18 at at RB 40436 3070 19 all all RB 40436 3070 20 better well JJR 40436 3070 21 than than IN 40436 3070 22 curriers currier NNS 40436 3070 23 : : : 40436 3070 24 of of RB 40436 3070 25 course course RB 40436 3070 26 therefore therefore RB 40436 3070 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3070 28 can can MD 40436 3070 29 not not RB 40436 3070 30 do do VB 40436 3070 31 _ _ VB 40436 3070 32 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3070 33 _ _ NNP 40436 3070 34 any any DT 40436 3070 35 good good NN 40436 3070 36 . . . 40436 3071 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3071 2 8 8 CD 40436 3071 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3071 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3071 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 3071 6 what what WP 40436 3071 7 can can MD 40436 3071 8 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3071 9 father father NN 40436 3071 10 do do VB 40436 3071 11 for for IN 40436 3071 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3071 13 better well RBR 40436 3071 14 than than IN 40436 3071 15 this this DT 40436 3071 16 , , , 40436 3071 17 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3071 18 ? ? . 40436 3072 1 What what WDT 40436 3072 2 ground ground NN 40436 3072 3 have have VBP 40436 3072 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3072 5 for for IN 40436 3072 6 complaining complain VBG 40436 3072 7 of of IN 40436 3072 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3072 9 ? ? . 40436 3073 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3073 2 is be VBZ 40436 3073 3 prepared prepared JJ 40436 3073 4 to to TO 40436 3073 5 place place VB 40436 3073 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3073 7 under under IN 40436 3073 8 any any DT 40436 3073 9 one one CD 40436 3073 10 of of IN 40436 3073 11 the the DT 40436 3073 12 best good JJS 40436 3073 13 and and CC 40436 3073 14 most most RBS 40436 3073 15 excellent excellent JJ 40436 3073 16 men man NNS 40436 3073 17 of of IN 40436 3073 18 Athens Athens NNP 40436 3073 19 , , , 40436 3073 20 whichever whichever WDT 40436 3073 21 of of IN 40436 3073 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3073 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3073 24 prefer prefer VBP 40436 3073 25 . . . 40436 3074 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3074 2 Theag._--Why Theag._--Why NNP 40436 3074 3 will will MD 40436 3074 4 not not RB 40436 3074 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3074 6 take take VB 40436 3074 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3074 8 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 3074 9 , , , 40436 3074 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3074 11 ? ? . 40436 3075 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3075 2 look look VBP 40436 3075 3 upon upon IN 40436 3075 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3075 5 as as IN 40436 3075 6 one one CD 40436 3075 7 of of IN 40436 3075 8 these these DT 40436 3075 9 men man NNS 40436 3075 10 , , , 40436 3075 11 and and CC 40436 3075 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3075 13 desire desire VBP 40436 3075 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 3075 15 better well JJR 40436 3075 16 . . . 40436 3076 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3076 2 9 9 CD 40436 3076 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3076 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3076 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3076 6 8 8 CD 40436 3076 7 : : : 40436 3076 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3076 9 , , , 40436 3076 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3076 11 , , , 40436 3076 12 126 126 CD 40436 3076 13 D. D. NNP 40436 3076 14 Here here RB 40436 3076 15 again again RB 40436 3076 16 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3076 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3076 18 p. p. NN 40436 3076 19 222 222 CD 40436 3076 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3076 21 urges urge VBZ 40436 3076 22 , , , 40436 3076 23 among among IN 40436 3076 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3076 25 reasons reason NNS 40436 3076 26 for for IN 40436 3076 27 believing believe VBG 40436 3076 28 the the DT 40436 3076 29 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3076 30 to to TO 40436 3076 31 be be VB 40436 3076 32 spurious spurious JJ 40436 3076 33 -- -- : 40436 3076 34 How how WRB 40436 3076 35 absurd absurd JJ 40436 3076 36 to to TO 40436 3076 37 represent represent VB 40436 3076 38 the the DT 40436 3076 39 youthful youthful JJ 40436 3076 40 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3076 41 as as IN 40436 3076 42 knowing know VBG 40436 3076 43 what what WP 40436 3076 44 arguments argument VBZ 40436 3076 45 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3076 46 had have VBD 40436 3076 47 addressed address VBN 40436 3076 48 to to IN 40436 3076 49 others other NNS 40436 3076 50 ! ! . 40436 3077 1 But but CC 40436 3077 2 the the DT 40436 3077 3 youthful youthful JJ 40436 3077 4 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 3077 5 is be VBZ 40436 3077 6 also also RB 40436 3077 7 represented represent VBN 40436 3077 8 as as IN 40436 3077 9 having have VBG 40436 3077 10 heard hear VBN 40436 3077 11 from from IN 40436 3077 12 others other NNS 40436 3077 13 the the DT 40436 3077 14 cross cross NN 40436 3077 15 - - NNS 40436 3077 16 examinations examination NNS 40436 3077 17 made make VBN 40436 3077 18 by by IN 40436 3077 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3077 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3077 21 Theætêt Theætêt NNP 40436 3077 22 . . . 40436 3078 1 148 148 CD 40436 3078 2 E E NNP 40436 3078 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3078 4 . . . 40436 3079 1 So so RB 40436 3079 2 likewise likewise RB 40436 3079 3 the the DT 40436 3079 4 youthful youthful JJ 40436 3079 5 sons son NNS 40436 3079 6 of of IN 40436 3079 7 Lysimachus--(Lachês Lysimachus--(Lachês NNP 40436 3079 8 , , , 40436 3079 9 181 181 CD 40436 3079 10 A a NN 40436 3079 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3079 12 ; ; : 40436 3079 13 compare compare VB 40436 3079 14 also also RB 40436 3079 15 Lysis lysis NN 40436 3079 16 , , , 40436 3079 17 211 211 CD 40436 3079 18 A. a. NN 40436 3079 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3080 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3080 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3080 3 9 9 CD 40436 3080 4 : : : 40436 3080 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3080 6 , , , 40436 3080 7 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3080 8 , , , 40436 3080 9 127 127 CD 40436 3080 10 A. a. NN 40436 3080 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3081 1 Demodokus Demodokus NNP 40436 3081 2 joins join VBZ 40436 3081 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3081 4 entreaties entreaty NNS 40436 3081 5 with with IN 40436 3081 6 those those DT 40436 3081 7 of of IN 40436 3081 8 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3081 9 to to TO 40436 3081 10 prevail prevail VB 40436 3081 11 upon upon IN 40436 3081 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3081 13 to to TO 40436 3081 14 undertake undertake VB 40436 3081 15 this this DT 40436 3081 16 function function NN 40436 3081 17 . . . 40436 3082 1 But but CC 40436 3082 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3082 3 in in IN 40436 3082 4 reply reply NN 40436 3082 5 says say VBZ 40436 3082 6 that that IN 40436 3082 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3082 8 is be VBZ 40436 3082 9 less less RBR 40436 3082 10 fit fit JJ 40436 3082 11 for for IN 40436 3082 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3082 13 than than IN 40436 3082 14 Demodokus Demodokus NNP 40436 3082 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3082 16 , , , 40436 3082 17 who who WP 40436 3082 18 has have VBZ 40436 3082 19 exercised exercise VBN 40436 3082 20 high high JJ 40436 3082 21 political political JJ 40436 3082 22 duties duty NNS 40436 3082 23 , , , 40436 3082 24 with with IN 40436 3082 25 the the DT 40436 3082 26 esteem esteem NN 40436 3082 27 of of IN 40436 3082 28 every every DT 40436 3082 29 one one CD 40436 3082 30 ; ; : 40436 3082 31 and and CC 40436 3082 32 that that IN 40436 3082 33 if if IN 40436 3082 34 practical practical JJ 40436 3082 35 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 3082 36 are be VBP 40436 3082 37 considered consider VBN 40436 3082 38 unfit unfit JJ 40436 3082 39 , , , 40436 3082 40 there there EX 40436 3082 41 are be VBP 40436 3082 42 the the DT 40436 3082 43 professional professional JJ 40436 3082 44 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 3082 45 , , , 40436 3082 46 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 3082 47 , , , 40436 3082 48 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 3082 49 , , , 40436 3082 50 Polus Polus NNP 40436 3082 51 , , , 40436 3082 52 who who WP 40436 3082 53 teach teach VBP 40436 3082 54 many many JJ 40436 3082 55 pupils pupil NNS 40436 3082 56 , , , 40436 3082 57 and and CC 40436 3082 58 earn earn VBP 40436 3082 59 not not RB 40436 3082 60 merely merely RB 40436 3082 61 good good JJ 40436 3082 62 pay pay NN 40436 3082 63 , , , 40436 3082 64 but but CC 40436 3082 65 also also RB 40436 3082 66 the the DT 40436 3082 67 admiration admiration NN 40436 3082 68 and and CC 40436 3082 69 gratitude gratitude NN 40436 3082 70 of of IN 40436 3082 71 every every DT 40436 3082 72 one one CD 40436 3082 73 -- -- : 40436 3082 74 of of IN 40436 3082 75 the the DT 40436 3082 76 pupils pupil NNS 40436 3082 77 as as RB 40436 3082 78 well well RB 40436 3082 79 as as IN 40436 3082 80 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3082 81 senior senior JJ 40436 3082 82 relatives relative NNS 40436 3082 83 . . . 40436 3083 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3083 2 10 10 CD 40436 3083 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3083 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3083 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3083 6 10 10 CD 40436 3083 7 : : : 40436 3083 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3083 9 , , , 40436 3083 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3083 11 , , , 40436 3083 12 127 127 CD 40436 3083 13 D d NN 40436 3083 14 - - HYPH 40436 3083 15 E e NN 40436 3083 16 , , , 40436 3083 17 128 128 CD 40436 3083 18 A. a. NN 40436 3083 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3084 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3084 2 Side side NN 40436 3084 3 - - HYPH 40436 3084 4 note note NN 40436 3084 5 : : : 40436 3084 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3084 7 declares declare VBZ 40436 3084 8 that that IN 40436 3084 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3084 10 is be VBZ 40436 3084 11 not not RB 40436 3084 12 competent competent JJ 40436 3084 13 to to TO 40436 3084 14 teach teach VB 40436 3084 15 -- -- : 40436 3084 16 that that IN 40436 3084 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3084 18 knows know VBZ 40436 3084 19 nothing nothing NN 40436 3084 20 except except IN 40436 3084 21 about about IN 40436 3084 22 matters matter NNS 40436 3084 23 of of IN 40436 3084 24 love love NN 40436 3084 25 . . . 40436 3085 1 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3085 2 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 3085 3 that that IN 40436 3085 4 many many JJ 40436 3085 5 of of IN 40436 3085 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3085 7 young young JJ 40436 3085 8 friends friend NNS 40436 3085 9 have have VBP 40436 3085 10 profited profit VBN 40436 3085 11 largely largely RB 40436 3085 12 by by IN 40436 3085 13 the the DT 40436 3085 14 conversation conversation NN 40436 3085 15 of of IN 40436 3085 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3085 17 . . . 40436 3085 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3086 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3086 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 3086 3 know know VBP 40436 3086 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 3086 5 of of IN 40436 3086 6 the the DT 40436 3086 7 fine fine JJ 40436 3086 8 things thing NNS 40436 3086 9 which which WDT 40436 3086 10 these these DT 40436 3086 11 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 3086 12 teach teach VBP 40436 3086 13 : : : 40436 3086 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3086 15 wish wish VBP 40436 3086 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3086 17 did do VBD 40436 3086 18 know know VB 40436 3086 19 . . . 40436 3087 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3087 2 declare declare VBP 40436 3087 3 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 3087 4 , , , 40436 3087 5 that that IN 40436 3087 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3087 7 know know VBP 40436 3087 8 nothing nothing NN 40436 3087 9 whatever whatever WDT 40436 3087 10 except except IN 40436 3087 11 one one CD 40436 3087 12 small small JJ 40436 3087 13 matter matter NN 40436 3087 14 -- -- : 40436 3087 15 what what WP 40436 3087 16 belongs belong VBZ 40436 3087 17 to to TO 40436 3087 18 love love VB 40436 3087 19 . . . 40436 3088 1 In in IN 40436 3088 2 that that DT 40436 3088 3 , , , 40436 3088 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3088 5 surpass surpass VBP 40436 3088 6 every every DT 40436 3088 7 one one NN 40436 3088 8 else else RB 40436 3088 9 , , , 40436 3088 10 past past JJ 40436 3088 11 as as RB 40436 3088 12 well well RB 40436 3088 13 as as IN 40436 3088 14 present present JJ 40436 3088 15 . . . 40436 3089 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3089 2 11 11 CD 40436 3089 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3089 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3089 5 Theag._--Sokrates theag._--sokrate NNS 40436 3089 6 is be VBZ 40436 3089 7 only only RB 40436 3089 8 mocking mock VBG 40436 3089 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3089 10 . . . 40436 3090 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3090 2 know know VBP 40436 3090 3 youths youth NNS 40436 3090 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3090 5 of of IN 40436 3090 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3090 7 own own JJ 40436 3090 8 age age NN 40436 3090 9 and and CC 40436 3090 10 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 3090 11 older old JJR 40436 3090 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3090 13 , , , 40436 3090 14 who who WP 40436 3090 15 were be VBD 40436 3090 16 altogether altogether RB 40436 3090 17 worthless worthless JJ 40436 3090 18 and and CC 40436 3090 19 inferior inferior JJ 40436 3090 20 to to IN 40436 3090 21 every every DT 40436 3090 22 one one CD 40436 3090 23 , , , 40436 3090 24 before before IN 40436 3090 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3090 26 went go VBD 40436 3090 27 to to IN 40436 3090 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3090 29 ; ; : 40436 3090 30 but but CC 40436 3090 31 who who WP 40436 3090 32 , , , 40436 3090 33 after after IN 40436 3090 34 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3090 35 had have VBD 40436 3090 36 frequented frequent VBN 40436 3090 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3090 38 society society NN 40436 3090 39 , , , 40436 3090 40 became become VBD 40436 3090 41 in in IN 40436 3090 42 a a DT 40436 3090 43 short short JJ 40436 3090 44 time time NN 40436 3090 45 superior superior JJ 40436 3090 46 to to IN 40436 3090 47 all all DT 40436 3090 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3090 49 former former JJ 40436 3090 50 rivals rival NNS 40436 3090 51 . . . 40436 3091 1 The the DT 40436 3091 2 like like NN 40436 3091 3 will will MD 40436 3091 4 happen happen VB 40436 3091 5 with with IN 40436 3091 6 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3091 7 , , , 40436 3091 8 if if IN 40436 3091 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3091 10 will will MD 40436 3091 11 only only RB 40436 3091 12 consent consent VB 40436 3091 13 to to TO 40436 3091 14 receive receive VB 40436 3091 15 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3091 16 . . . 40436 3092 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3092 2 12 12 CD 40436 3092 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3092 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3092 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3092 6 11 11 CD 40436 3092 7 : : : 40436 3092 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3092 9 , , , 40436 3092 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3092 11 , , , 40436 3092 12 128 128 CD 40436 3092 13 B. b. NN 40436 3093 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3093 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3093 3 : : : 40436 3093 4 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 3093 5 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3093 6 le le NNP 40436 3093 7 / / , 40436 3093 8 gô gô NNP 40436 3093 9 dê dê NNP 40436 3093 10 / / SYM 40436 3093 11 pou pou NNP 40436 3093 12 a)ei/ a)ei/ CD 40436 3093 13 , , , 40436 3093 14 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 3093 15 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 3093 16 tugcha tugcha NNP 40436 3093 17 / / SYM 40436 3093 18 nô nô NNP 40436 3093 19 , , , 40436 3093 20 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3093 21 e)/pos e)/pos NNP 40436 3093 22 ei)pei ei)pei NN 40436 3093 23 = = SYM 40436 3093 24 n n XX 40436 3093 25 , , , 40436 3093 26 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 3093 27 e)pista e)pista , 40436 3093 28 / / SYM 40436 3093 29 menos menos NNP 40436 3093 30 plê plê NNP 40436 3093 31 / / SYM 40436 3093 32 n n NNP 40436 3093 33 ge ge NNP 40436 3093 34 smikrou= smikrou= NNP 40436 3093 35 tino\s tino\s CD 40436 3093 36 mathê mathê NNP 40436 3093 37 / / SYM 40436 3093 38 matos matos NNP 40436 3093 39 , , , 40436 3093 40 tô tô NNP 40436 3093 41 = = SYM 40436 3093 42 n n NNP 40436 3093 43 e)rôtikô e)rôtikô NNP 40436 3093 44 = = SYM 40436 3093 45 n n NNP 40436 3093 46 , , , 40436 3093 47 tou tou NNP 40436 3093 48 = = NNPS 40436 3093 49 to to IN 40436 3093 50 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3093 51 / / SYM 40436 3093 52 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 3093 53 to\ to\ NNP 40436 3093 54 ma ma NNP 40436 3093 55 / / SYM 40436 3093 56 thêma thêma NNP 40436 3093 57 par par NNP 40436 3093 58 ' ' POS 40436 3093 59 o(ntinou o(ntinou NN 40436 3093 60 = = SYM 40436 3093 61 n n CC 40436 3093 62 poiou poiou NNP 40436 3093 63 = = NFP 40436 3093 64 mai mai NN 40436 3093 65 deino\s deino\s -LRB- 40436 3093 66 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 3093 67 , , , 40436 3093 68 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3093 69 tô tô NNP 40436 3093 70 = = SYM 40436 3093 71 n n NNP 40436 3093 72 progegono progegono NNP 40436 3093 73 / / SYM 40436 3093 74 tôn tôn NNP 40436 3093 75 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 3093 76 / / SYM 40436 3093 77 pôn pôn NNP 40436 3093 78 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3093 79 tô tô NNP 40436 3093 80 = = SYM 40436 3093 81 n n NNP 40436 3093 82 nu nu NNP 40436 3093 83 = = SYM 40436 3093 84 n n NNP 40436 3093 85 . . . 40436 3093 86 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3093 87 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3094 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3094 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3094 3 12 12 CD 40436 3094 4 : : : 40436 3094 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3094 6 , , , 40436 3094 7 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3094 8 , , , 40436 3094 9 128 128 CD 40436 3094 10 C. c. NN 40436 3094 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3094 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3094 13 Side side NN 40436 3094 14 - - HYPH 40436 3094 15 note note NN 40436 3094 16 : : : 40436 3094 17 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3094 18 explains explain VBZ 40436 3094 19 how how WRB 40436 3094 20 this this DT 40436 3094 21 has have VBZ 40436 3094 22 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 3094 23 happened happen VBN 40436 3094 24 -- -- : 40436 3094 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3094 26 recites recite VBZ 40436 3094 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3094 28 experience experience NN 40436 3094 29 of of IN 40436 3094 30 the the DT 40436 3094 31 divine divine JJ 40436 3094 32 sign sign NN 40436 3094 33 or or CC 40436 3094 34 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3094 35 . . . 40436 3094 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3095 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3095 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 3095 3 do do VBP 40436 3095 4 not not RB 40436 3095 5 know know VB 40436 3095 6 how how WRB 40436 3095 7 this this DT 40436 3095 8 happens happen VBZ 40436 3095 9 ; ; : 40436 3095 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3095 11 will will MD 40436 3095 12 explain explain VB 40436 3095 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3095 14 to to IN 40436 3095 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3095 16 . . . 40436 3096 1 From from IN 40436 3096 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3096 3 childhood childhood NN 40436 3096 4 , , , 40436 3096 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3096 6 have have VBP 40436 3096 7 had have VBN 40436 3096 8 a a DT 40436 3096 9 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 3096 10 superhuman superhuman NN 40436 3096 11 something something NN 40436 3096 12 attached attach VBN 40436 3096 13 to to IN 40436 3096 14 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3096 15 by by IN 40436 3096 16 divine divine JJ 40436 3096 17 appointment appointment NN 40436 3096 18 : : : 40436 3096 19 a a DT 40436 3096 20 voice voice NN 40436 3096 21 , , , 40436 3096 22 which which WDT 40436 3096 23 , , , 40436 3096 24 whenever whenever WRB 40436 3096 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3096 26 occurs occur VBZ 40436 3096 27 , , , 40436 3096 28 warns warn VBZ 40436 3096 29 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3096 30 to to TO 40436 3096 31 abstain abstain VB 40436 3096 32 from from IN 40436 3096 33 that that DT 40436 3096 34 which which WDT 40436 3096 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3096 36 am be VBP 40436 3096 37 about about JJ 40436 3096 38 to to TO 40436 3096 39 do do VB 40436 3096 40 , , , 40436 3096 41 but but CC 40436 3096 42 never never RB 40436 3096 43 impels impel VBZ 40436 3096 44 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3096 45 . . . 40436 3097 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3097 2 13 13 CD 40436 3097 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3097 4 Moreover moreover RB 40436 3097 5 , , , 40436 3097 6 when when WRB 40436 3097 7 any any DT 40436 3097 8 one one CD 40436 3097 9 of of IN 40436 3097 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3097 11 friends friend NNS 40436 3097 12 mentions mention NNS 40436 3097 13 to to IN 40436 3097 14 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3097 15 what what WP 40436 3097 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3097 17 is be VBZ 40436 3097 18 about about JJ 40436 3097 19 to to TO 40436 3097 20 do do VB 40436 3097 21 , , , 40436 3097 22 if if IN 40436 3097 23 the the DT 40436 3097 24 voice voice NN 40436 3097 25 shall shall MD 40436 3097 26 then then RB 40436 3097 27 occur occur VB 40436 3097 28 to to IN 40436 3097 29 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3097 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3097 31 is be VBZ 40436 3097 32 a a DT 40436 3097 33 warning warning NN 40436 3097 34 for for IN 40436 3097 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3097 36 to to TO 40436 3097 37 abstain abstain VB 40436 3097 38 . . . 40436 3098 1 The the DT 40436 3098 2 examples example NNS 40436 3098 3 of of IN 40436 3098 4 Charmides Charmides NNPS 40436 3098 5 and and CC 40436 3098 6 Timarchus Timarchus NNP 40436 3098 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3098 8 here here RB 40436 3098 9 detailed detail VBN 40436 3098 10 by by IN 40436 3098 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3098 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3098 13 prove prove VBP 40436 3098 14 what what WP 40436 3098 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3098 16 say say VBP 40436 3098 17 : : : 40436 3098 18 and and CC 40436 3098 19 many many JJ 40436 3098 20 persons person NNS 40436 3098 21 will will MD 40436 3098 22 tell tell VB 40436 3098 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3098 24 how how WRB 40436 3098 25 truly truly RB 40436 3098 26 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3098 27 forewarned forewarn VBD 40436 3098 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3098 29 of of IN 40436 3098 30 the the DT 40436 3098 31 ruin ruin NN 40436 3098 32 of of IN 40436 3098 33 the the DT 40436 3098 34 Athenian Athenian NNP 40436 3098 35 armament armament NN 40436 3098 36 at at IN 40436 3098 37 Syracuse Syracuse NNP 40436 3098 38 . . . 40436 3099 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3099 2 14 14 CD 40436 3099 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3099 4 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3099 5 young young JJ 40436 3099 6 friend friend NN 40436 3099 7 Sannion Sannion NNP 40436 3099 8 is be VBZ 40436 3099 9 now now RB 40436 3099 10 absent absent JJ 40436 3099 11 , , , 40436 3099 12 serving serve VBG 40436 3099 13 on on IN 40436 3099 14 the the DT 40436 3099 15 expedition expedition NN 40436 3099 16 under under IN 40436 3099 17 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3099 18 to to IN 40436 3099 19 Ionia Ionia NNP 40436 3099 20 : : : 40436 3099 21 on on IN 40436 3099 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3099 23 departure departure NN 40436 3099 24 , , , 40436 3099 25 the the DT 40436 3099 26 divine divine JJ 40436 3099 27 sign sign NN 40436 3099 28 manifested manifest VBD 40436 3099 29 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 3099 30 to to IN 40436 3099 31 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3099 32 , , , 40436 3099 33 and and CC 40436 3099 34 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3099 35 am be VBP 40436 3099 36 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 3099 37 that that IN 40436 3099 38 some some DT 40436 3099 39 grave grave JJ 40436 3099 40 calamity calamity NN 40436 3099 41 will will MD 40436 3099 42 befall befall VB 40436 3099 43 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3099 44 . . . 40436 3100 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3100 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3100 3 13 13 CD 40436 3100 4 : : : 40436 3100 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3100 6 , , , 40436 3100 7 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3100 8 , , , 40436 3100 9 128 128 CD 40436 3100 10 D. D. NNP 40436 3100 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3100 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3100 13 : : : 40436 3100 14 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 3100 15 ga ga NNP 40436 3100 16 / / SYM 40436 3100 17 r r NNP 40436 3100 18 ti ti NNP 40436 3100 19 thei thei NN 40436 3100 20 / / SYM 40436 3100 21 a| a| NNP 40436 3100 22 moi moi NNP 40436 3100 23 / / SYM 40436 3100 24 ra| ra| NNP 40436 3100 25 parepo parepo NNP 40436 3100 26 / / SYM 40436 3100 27 menon menon NNP 40436 3100 28 e)moi\ e)moi\ NNP 40436 3100 29 e)k e)k NNP 40436 3100 30 paido\s paido\s CC 40436 3100 31 a)rxa a)rxa NNP 40436 3100 32 / / SYM 40436 3100 33 menon menon NNP 40436 3100 34 daimo daimo NNP 40436 3100 35 / / SYM 40436 3100 36 nion nion NN 40436 3100 37 ; ; : 40436 3100 38 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 3100 39 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3100 40 tou tou NNP 40436 3100 41 = = NNP 40436 3100 42 to to IN 40436 3100 43 phônê/ phônê/ NNP 40436 3100 44 , , , 40436 3100 45 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 3100 46 o(/tan o(/tan NNP 40436 3100 47 ge ge NNP 40436 3100 48 / / SYM 40436 3100 49 nêtai nêtai NNP 40436 3100 50 , , , 40436 3100 51 a)ei/ a)ei/ CD 40436 3100 52 moi moi NNP 40436 3100 53 sêmai sêmai NNP 40436 3100 54 / / SYM 40436 3100 55 nei nei NNP 40436 3100 56 , , , 40436 3100 57 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 3100 58 a)\n a)\n VBP 40436 3100 59 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3100 60 / / SYM 40436 3100 61 llô llô NNP 40436 3100 62 pra pra NNP 40436 3100 63 / / SYM 40436 3100 64 ttein ttein NNP 40436 3100 65 , , , 40436 3100 66 tou tou NNP 40436 3100 67 / / SYM 40436 3100 68 tou tou NNP 40436 3100 69 a)potropê a)potropê NNP 40436 3100 70 / / SYM 40436 3100 71 n n NNP 40436 3100 72 , , , 40436 3100 73 protre protre NNP 40436 3100 74 / / SYM 40436 3100 75 pei pei NNP 40436 3100 76 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3100 77 ou)de ou)de NNP 40436 3100 78 / / SYM 40436 3100 79 pote pote NN 40436 3100 80 . . . 40436 3100 81 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3100 82 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3101 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3101 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3101 3 14 14 CD 40436 3101 4 : : : 40436 3101 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3101 6 , , , 40436 3101 7 Theag Theag NNP 40436 3101 8 . . . 40436 3102 1 129 129 CD 40436 3102 2 . . . 40436 3102 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3103 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3103 2 Side side NN 40436 3103 3 - - HYPH 40436 3103 4 note note NN 40436 3103 5 : : : 40436 3103 6 The the DT 40436 3103 7 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3103 8 is be VBZ 40436 3103 9 favourable favourable JJ 40436 3103 10 to to IN 40436 3103 11 some some DT 40436 3103 12 persons person NNS 40436 3103 13 , , , 40436 3103 14 adverse adverse RB 40436 3103 15 to to IN 40436 3103 16 others other NNS 40436 3103 17 . . . 40436 3104 1 Upon upon IN 40436 3104 2 this this DT 40436 3104 3 circumstance circumstance NN 40436 3104 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3104 5 depends depend VBZ 40436 3104 6 how how WRB 40436 3104 7 far far RB 40436 3104 8 any any DT 40436 3104 9 companion companion NN 40436 3104 10 profits profit NNS 40436 3104 11 by by IN 40436 3104 12 the the DT 40436 3104 13 society society NN 40436 3104 14 of of IN 40436 3104 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3104 16 . . . 40436 3105 1 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 3105 2 has have VBZ 40436 3105 3 not not RB 40436 3105 4 learnt learn VBN 40436 3105 5 anything anything NN 40436 3105 6 from from IN 40436 3105 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3105 8 , , , 40436 3105 9 yet yet RB 40436 3105 10 has have VBZ 40436 3105 11 improved improve VBN 40436 3105 12 much much RB 40436 3105 13 by by IN 40436 3105 14 being be VBG 40436 3105 15 near near JJ 40436 3105 16 to to IN 40436 3105 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3105 18 . . . 40436 3105 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3106 1 These these DT 40436 3106 2 facts fact NNS 40436 3106 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3106 4 mention mention VBP 40436 3106 5 to to IN 40436 3106 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3106 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3106 8 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3106 9 continues continue VBZ 40436 3106 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3106 11 because because IN 40436 3106 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3106 13 is be VBZ 40436 3106 14 that that DT 40436 3106 15 same same JJ 40436 3106 16 divine divine JJ 40436 3106 17 power power NN 40436 3106 18 which which WDT 40436 3106 19 exercises exercise VBZ 40436 3106 20 paramount paramount JJ 40436 3106 21 influence influence NN 40436 3106 22 over over IN 40436 3106 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3106 24 intercourse intercourse NN 40436 3106 25 with with IN 40436 3106 26 companions companion NNS 40436 3106 27 . . . 40436 3107 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3107 2 15 15 CD 40436 3107 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3107 4 Towards towards IN 40436 3107 5 many many JJ 40436 3107 6 , , , 40436 3107 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3107 8 is be VBZ 40436 3107 9 positively positively RB 40436 3107 10 adverse adverse JJ 40436 3107 11 ; ; : 40436 3107 12 so so IN 40436 3107 13 that that IN 40436 3107 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3107 15 can can MD 40436 3107 16 not not RB 40436 3107 17 even even RB 40436 3107 18 enter enter VB 40436 3107 19 into into IN 40436 3107 20 companionship companionship NN 40436 3107 21 with with IN 40436 3107 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3107 23 . . . 40436 3108 1 Towards towards IN 40436 3108 2 others other NNS 40436 3108 3 , , , 40436 3108 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3108 5 does do VBZ 40436 3108 6 not not RB 40436 3108 7 forbid forbid VB 40436 3108 8 , , , 40436 3108 9 yet yet CC 40436 3108 10 neither neither RB 40436 3108 11 does do VBZ 40436 3108 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3108 13 co co VB 40436 3108 14 - - VB 40436 3108 15 operate operate VB 40436 3108 16 : : : 40436 3108 17 so so IN 40436 3108 18 that that IN 40436 3108 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3108 20 derive derive VBP 40436 3108 21 no no DT 40436 3108 22 benefit benefit NN 40436 3108 23 from from IN 40436 3108 24 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3108 25 . . . 40436 3109 1 There there EX 40436 3109 2 are be VBP 40436 3109 3 others other NNS 40436 3109 4 again again RB 40436 3109 5 in in IN 40436 3109 6 whose whose WP$ 40436 3109 7 case case NN 40436 3109 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3109 9 co co VBZ 40436 3109 10 - - NN 40436 3109 11 operates operate VBZ 40436 3109 12 ; ; : 40436 3109 13 these these DT 40436 3109 14 are be VBP 40436 3109 15 the the DT 40436 3109 16 persons person NNS 40436 3109 17 to to TO 40436 3109 18 whom whom WP 40436 3109 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3109 20 allude allude VBP 40436 3109 21 , , , 40436 3109 22 who who WP 40436 3109 23 make make VBP 40436 3109 24 rapid rapid JJ 40436 3109 25 progress progress NN 40436 3109 26 . . . 40436 3110 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3110 2 16 16 CD 40436 3110 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3110 4 With with IN 40436 3110 5 some some DT 40436 3110 6 , , , 40436 3110 7 such such JJ 40436 3110 8 improvement improvement NN 40436 3110 9 is be VBZ 40436 3110 10 lasting last VBG 40436 3110 11 : : : 40436 3110 12 others other NNS 40436 3110 13 , , , 40436 3110 14 though though IN 40436 3110 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3110 16 improve improve VBP 40436 3110 17 wonderfully wonderfully RB 40436 3110 18 while while IN 40436 3110 19 in in IN 40436 3110 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3110 21 society society NN 40436 3110 22 , , , 40436 3110 23 yet yet CC 40436 3110 24 relapse relapse VB 40436 3110 25 into into IN 40436 3110 26 commonplace commonplace JJ 40436 3110 27 men man NNS 40436 3110 28 when when WRB 40436 3110 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3110 30 leave leave VBP 40436 3110 31 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3110 32 . . . 40436 3111 1 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 3111 2 , , , 40436 3111 3 for for IN 40436 3111 4 example example NN 40436 3111 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3111 6 grandson grandson NN 40436 3111 7 of of IN 40436 3111 8 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 3111 9 the the DT 40436 3111 10 Just just RB 40436 3111 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3111 12 , , , 40436 3111 13 was be VBD 40436 3111 14 one one CD 40436 3111 15 of of IN 40436 3111 16 those those DT 40436 3111 17 who who WP 40436 3111 18 made make VBD 40436 3111 19 rapid rapid JJ 40436 3111 20 progress progress NN 40436 3111 21 while while IN 40436 3111 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3111 23 was be VBD 40436 3111 24 with with IN 40436 3111 25 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3111 26 . . . 40436 3112 1 But but CC 40436 3112 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3112 3 was be VBD 40436 3112 4 forced force VBN 40436 3112 5 to to TO 40436 3112 6 absent absent VB 40436 3112 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3112 8 on on IN 40436 3112 9 military military JJ 40436 3112 10 service service NN 40436 3112 11 ; ; : 40436 3112 12 and and CC 40436 3112 13 on on IN 40436 3112 14 returning return VBG 40436 3112 15 , , , 40436 3112 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3112 17 found find VBD 40436 3112 18 as as IN 40436 3112 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3112 20 companion companion NN 40436 3112 21 Thucydides Thucydides NNP 40436 3112 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3112 23 son son NN 40436 3112 24 of of IN 40436 3112 25 Melesias Melesias NNP 40436 3112 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3112 27 , , , 40436 3112 28 who who WP 40436 3112 29 however however RB 40436 3112 30 had have VBD 40436 3112 31 quarrelled quarrel VBN 40436 3112 32 with with IN 40436 3112 33 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3112 34 for for IN 40436 3112 35 some some DT 40436 3112 36 debate debate NN 40436 3112 37 of of IN 40436 3112 38 the the DT 40436 3112 39 day day NN 40436 3112 40 before before RB 40436 3112 41 . . . 40436 3113 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3113 2 understand understand VBP 40436 3113 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3113 4 said say VBD 40436 3113 5 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 3113 6 to to IN 40436 3113 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3113 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3113 9 that that IN 40436 3113 10 Thucydides thucydide NNS 40436 3113 11 has have VBZ 40436 3113 12 taken take VBN 40436 3113 13 offence offence NN 40436 3113 14 and and CC 40436 3113 15 gives give VBZ 40436 3113 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3113 17 airs air NNS 40436 3113 18 ; ; : 40436 3113 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3113 20 forgets forget VBZ 40436 3113 21 what what WP 40436 3113 22 a a DT 40436 3113 23 poor poor JJ 40436 3113 24 creature creature NN 40436 3113 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3113 26 was be VBD 40436 3113 27 , , , 40436 3113 28 before before IN 40436 3113 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3113 30 came come VBD 40436 3113 31 to to IN 40436 3113 32 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3113 33 . . . 40436 3114 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3114 2 17 17 CD 40436 3114 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3114 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3114 5 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 3114 6 , , , 40436 3114 7 too too RB 40436 3114 8 , , , 40436 3114 9 have have VBP 40436 3114 10 fallen fall VBN 40436 3114 11 into into IN 40436 3114 12 a a DT 40436 3114 13 despicable despicable JJ 40436 3114 14 condition condition NN 40436 3114 15 . . . 40436 3115 1 When when WRB 40436 3115 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3115 3 left leave VBD 40436 3115 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3115 5 , , , 40436 3115 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3115 7 was be VBD 40436 3115 8 competent competent JJ 40436 3115 9 to to TO 40436 3115 10 discuss discuss VB 40436 3115 11 with with IN 40436 3115 12 any any DT 40436 3115 13 one one NN 40436 3115 14 and and CC 40436 3115 15 make make VB 40436 3115 16 a a DT 40436 3115 17 good good JJ 40436 3115 18 figure figure NN 40436 3115 19 , , , 40436 3115 20 so so IN 40436 3115 21 that that IN 40436 3115 22 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3115 23 courted court VBD 40436 3115 24 debate debate NN 40436 3115 25 with with IN 40436 3115 26 the the DT 40436 3115 27 most most RBS 40436 3115 28 accomplished accomplished JJ 40436 3115 29 men man NNS 40436 3115 30 . . . 40436 3116 1 Now now RB 40436 3116 2 , , , 40436 3116 3 on on IN 40436 3116 4 the the DT 40436 3116 5 contrary contrary NN 40436 3116 6 , , , 40436 3116 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3116 8 avoid avoid VBP 40436 3116 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3116 10 altogether altogether RB 40436 3116 11 -- -- : 40436 3116 12 so so RB 40436 3116 13 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 3116 14 am be VBP 40436 3116 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3116 16 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 3116 17 of of IN 40436 3116 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3116 19 own own JJ 40436 3116 20 incapacity incapacity NN 40436 3116 21 . . . 40436 3117 1 Did do VBD 40436 3117 2 the the DT 40436 3117 3 capacity capacity NN 40436 3117 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3117 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3117 6 , , , 40436 3117 7 _ _ NNP 40436 3117 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3117 9 _ _ NNP 40436 3117 10 , , , 40436 3117 11 asked ask VBD 40436 3117 12 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 3117 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3117 14 forsake forsake VBP 40436 3117 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3117 16 all all DT 40436 3117 17 at at IN 40436 3117 18 once once RB 40436 3117 19 , , , 40436 3117 20 or or CC 40436 3117 21 little little JJ 40436 3117 22 by by IN 40436 3117 23 little little JJ 40436 3117 24 ? ? . 40436 3118 1 Little little JJ 40436 3118 2 by by IN 40436 3118 3 little little JJ 40436 3118 4 , , , 40436 3118 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3118 6 replied reply VBD 40436 3118 7 . . . 40436 3119 1 And and CC 40436 3119 2 when when WRB 40436 3119 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3119 4 possessed possess VBD 40436 3119 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3119 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3119 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3119 8 asked ask VBD 40436 3119 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3119 10 , , , 40436 3119 11 did do VBD 40436 3119 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3119 13 get get VB 40436 3119 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3119 15 by by IN 40436 3119 16 learning learn VBG 40436 3119 17 from from IN 40436 3119 18 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3119 19 ? ? . 40436 3120 1 or or CC 40436 3120 2 in in IN 40436 3120 3 what what WP 40436 3120 4 other other JJ 40436 3120 5 way way NN 40436 3120 6 ? ? . 40436 3121 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3121 2 will will MD 40436 3121 3 tell tell VB 40436 3121 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3121 5 , , , 40436 3121 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3121 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3121 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3121 9 answered answer VBD 40436 3121 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3121 11 , , , 40436 3121 12 what what WP 40436 3121 13 seems seem VBZ 40436 3121 14 incredible incredible JJ 40436 3121 15 , , , 40436 3121 16 yet yet CC 40436 3121 17 is be VBZ 40436 3121 18 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 3121 19 true true JJ 40436 3121 20 . . . 40436 3122 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3122 2 18 18 CD 40436 3122 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3122 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3122 5 never never RB 40436 3122 6 learnt learn VBD 40436 3122 7 from from IN 40436 3122 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3122 9 any any DT 40436 3122 10 thing thing NN 40436 3122 11 at at RB 40436 3122 12 all all RB 40436 3122 13 . . . 40436 3123 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3123 2 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 3123 3 well well UH 40436 3123 4 know know VBP 40436 3123 5 this this DT 40436 3123 6 . . . 40436 3124 1 But but CC 40436 3124 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 3 always always RB 40436 3124 4 made make VBD 40436 3124 5 progress progress NN 40436 3124 6 , , , 40436 3124 7 whenever whenever WRB 40436 3124 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 9 was be VBD 40436 3124 10 along along IN 40436 3124 11 with with IN 40436 3124 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 13 , , , 40436 3124 14 even even RB 40436 3124 15 if if IN 40436 3124 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 17 were be VBD 40436 3124 18 only only RB 40436 3124 19 in in IN 40436 3124 20 the the DT 40436 3124 21 same same JJ 40436 3124 22 house house NN 40436 3124 23 without without IN 40436 3124 24 being be VBG 40436 3124 25 in in IN 40436 3124 26 the the DT 40436 3124 27 same same JJ 40436 3124 28 room room NN 40436 3124 29 ; ; : 40436 3124 30 but but CC 40436 3124 31 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 32 made make VBD 40436 3124 33 greater great JJR 40436 3124 34 progress progress NN 40436 3124 35 , , , 40436 3124 36 if if IN 40436 3124 37 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 38 was be VBD 40436 3124 39 in in IN 40436 3124 40 the the DT 40436 3124 41 same same JJ 40436 3124 42 room room NN 40436 3124 43 -- -- : 40436 3124 44 greater great JJR 40436 3124 45 still still RB 40436 3124 46 , , , 40436 3124 47 if if IN 40436 3124 48 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 49 looked look VBD 40436 3124 50 in in IN 40436 3124 51 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3124 52 face face NN 40436 3124 53 , , , 40436 3124 54 instead instead RB 40436 3124 55 of of IN 40436 3124 56 turning turn VBG 40436 3124 57 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3124 58 eyes eye NNS 40436 3124 59 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 3124 60 -- -- : 40436 3124 61 and and CC 40436 3124 62 the the DT 40436 3124 63 greatest great JJS 40436 3124 64 of of IN 40436 3124 65 all all DT 40436 3124 66 , , , 40436 3124 67 by by IN 40436 3124 68 far far RB 40436 3124 69 , , , 40436 3124 70 if if IN 40436 3124 71 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 72 sat sit VBD 40436 3124 73 close close JJ 40436 3124 74 and and CC 40436 3124 75 touching touch VBG 40436 3124 76 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3124 77 . . . 40436 3125 1 But but CC 40436 3125 2 now now RB 40436 3125 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3125 4 continued continue VBN 40436 3125 5 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 3125 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3125 7 all all DT 40436 3125 8 that that WDT 40436 3125 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3125 10 then then RB 40436 3125 11 acquired acquire VBD 40436 3125 12 has have VBZ 40436 3125 13 dribbled dribble VBN 40436 3125 14 out out IN 40436 3125 15 of of IN 40436 3125 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3125 17 . . . 40436 3126 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3126 2 19 19 CD 40436 3126 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3126 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3126 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3126 6 15 15 CD 40436 3126 7 : : : 40436 3126 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3126 9 , , , 40436 3126 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3126 11 , , , 40436 3126 12 129 129 CD 40436 3126 13 E. E. NNP 40436 3126 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3126 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3126 16 : : : 40436 3126 17 tau tau NNP 40436 3126 18 = = SYM 40436 3126 19 ta ta NNP 40436 3126 20 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 3126 21 pa pa NNP 40436 3126 22 / / SYM 40436 3126 23 nta nta NNP 40436 3126 24 ei)/rêka/ ei)/rêka/ NNP 40436 3126 25 soi soi NNP 40436 3126 26 , , , 40436 3126 27 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 3126 28 ê ê NNP 40436 3126 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3126 30 du du NNP 40436 3126 31 / / SYM 40436 3126 32 namis namis NNP 40436 3126 33 au(/tê au(/tê CD 40436 3126 34 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3126 35 daimoni daimoni NNP 40436 3126 36 / / SYM 40436 3126 37 ou ou NNP 40436 3126 38 tou tou NNP 40436 3126 39 / / SYM 40436 3126 40 tou tou NNP 40436 3126 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3126 42 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 3126 43 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 3126 44 sunousi sunousi NN 40436 3126 45 / / SYM 40436 3126 46 as as IN 40436 3126 47 tô tô NNP 40436 3126 48 = = SYM 40436 3126 49 n n NN 40436 3126 50 met meet VBD 40436 3126 51 ' ' '' 40436 3126 52 e)mou= e)mou= NNP 40436 3126 53 sundiatribo sundiatribo NN 40436 3126 54 / / SYM 40436 3126 55 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 3126 56 to\ to\ NN 40436 3126 57 a(/pan a(/pan NNP 40436 3126 58 du du NNP 40436 3126 59 / / SYM 40436 3126 60 natai natai NN 40436 3126 61 . . . 40436 3127 1 polloi polloi NNP 40436 3127 2 = = SYM 40436 3127 3 s s VBZ 40436 3127 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3127 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3127 6 e)nantiou e)nantiou , 40436 3127 7 = = SYM 40436 3127 8 tai tai NNP 40436 3127 9 , , , 40436 3127 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3127 11 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 3127 12 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 3127 13 tou tou NNP 40436 3127 14 / / SYM 40436 3127 15 tois tois NNP 40436 3127 16 ô)phelêthênai ô)phelêthênai CD 40436 3127 17 met meet VBD 40436 3127 18 ' ' '' 40436 3127 19 e)mou= e)mou= NNP 40436 3127 20 diatri diatri NNP 40436 3127 21 / / SYM 40436 3127 22 bousin bousin NNP 40436 3127 23 . . . 40436 3127 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3127 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3128 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3128 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3128 3 16 16 CD 40436 3128 4 : : : 40436 3128 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3128 6 , , , 40436 3128 7 Theag Theag NNP 40436 3128 8 . . . 40436 3129 1 129 129 CD 40436 3129 2 E. E. NNP 40436 3129 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3129 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3129 5 : : : 40436 3129 6 oi(=s oi(=s JJ 40436 3129 7 d d NN 40436 3129 8 ' ' POS 40436 3129 9 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 3129 10 sulla sulla NNP 40436 3129 11 / / SYM 40436 3129 12 bêtai bêtai NNP 40436 3129 13 tê tê NNP 40436 3129 14 = = SYM 40436 3129 15 s s NNP 40436 3129 16 sunousi sunousi NNP 40436 3129 17 / / SYM 40436 3129 18 as as IN 40436 3129 19 ê ê NN 40436 3129 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3129 21 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3129 22 daimo daimo NNP 40436 3129 23 / / SYM 40436 3129 24 niou niou NNP 40436 3129 25 du du NNP 40436 3129 26 / / SYM 40436 3129 27 namis namis NNP 40436 3129 28 , , , 40436 3129 29 ou(=toi ou(=toi . 40436 3129 30 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 3129 31 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 3129 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3129 33 su\ su\ NNP 40436 3129 34 ê)/|sthêsai ê)/|sthêsai NNP 40436 3129 35 ; ; : 40436 3129 36 tachu\ tachu\ NNP 40436 3129 37 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3129 38 parachrê parachrê NN 40436 3129 39 = = SYM 40436 3129 40 ma ma NNP 40436 3129 41 e)pidido e)pidido NNP 40436 3129 42 / / SYM 40436 3129 43 asin asin NNP 40436 3129 44 . . . 40436 3129 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3129 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3130 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3130 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3130 3 17 17 CD 40436 3130 4 : : : 40436 3130 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3130 6 , , , 40436 3130 7 Theag Theag NNP 40436 3130 8 . . . 40436 3131 1 130 130 CD 40436 3131 2 A A NNP 40436 3131 3 - - HYPH 40436 3131 4 B. b. NN 40436 3132 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3132 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3132 3 : : : 40436 3132 4 Ti/ Ti/ NNP 40436 3132 5 dai/ dai/ NNP 40436 3132 6 ? ? . 40436 3133 1 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 3133 2 oi)=den oi)=den NNP 40436 3133 3 , , , 40436 3133 4 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 3133 5 , , , 40436 3133 6 pri\n pri\n NNPS 40436 3133 7 soi\ soi\ VBP 40436 3133 8 suggene suggene NNP 40436 3133 9 / / SYM 40436 3133 10 sthai sthai NNP 40436 3133 11 , , , 40436 3133 12 oi(=on oi(=on NNP 40436 3133 13 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 3133 14 to\ to\ NNP 40436 3133 15 a)ndra a)ndra NNP 40436 3133 16 / / SYM 40436 3133 17 podon podon NNP 40436 3133 18 ? ? . 40436 3133 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3133 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3134 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3134 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3134 3 18 18 CD 40436 3134 4 : : : 40436 3134 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3134 6 , , , 40436 3134 7 Theag Theag NNP 40436 3134 8 . . . 40436 3135 1 130 130 CD 40436 3135 2 D. D. NNP 40436 3135 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3135 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3135 5 : : : 40436 3135 6 Ê(ni ê(ni VB 40436 3135 7 / / SYM 40436 3135 8 ka ka NNP 40436 3135 9 de/ de/ NNP 40436 3135 10 soi soi NNP 40436 3135 11 parege parege NNP 40436 3135 12 / / SYM 40436 3135 13 neto neto NNP 40436 3135 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3135 15 ê ê NNP 40436 3135 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3135 17 du du NNP 40436 3135 18 / / SYM 40436 3135 19 namis namis NNP 40436 3135 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3135 21 , , , 40436 3135 22 po po NNP 40436 3135 23 / / SYM 40436 3135 24 teron teron NNP 40436 3135 25 matho matho NNP 40436 3135 26 / / SYM 40436 3135 27 nti nti NNP 40436 3135 28 par par NNP 40436 3135 29 ' ' `` 40436 3135 30 e)mou= e)mou= NNP 40436 3135 31 ti ti NNP 40436 3135 32 parege parege NNP 40436 3135 33 / / SYM 40436 3135 34 neto neto NNP 40436 3135 35 , , , 40436 3135 36 ê)/ ê)/ JJ 40436 3135 37 tini tini NN 40436 3135 38 a)/llô| a)/llô| NN 40436 3135 39 tro tro NN 40436 3135 40 / / SYM 40436 3135 41 pô| pô| NN 40436 3135 42 ? ? . 40436 3136 1 E)gô/ E)gô/ NNP 40436 3136 2 soi soi NNP 40436 3136 3 , , , 40436 3136 4 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 3136 5 , , , 40436 3136 6 e)rô= e)rô= NN 40436 3136 7 , , , 40436 3136 8 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 3136 9 Sô Sô NNP 40436 3136 10 / / SYM 40436 3136 11 krates krate NNS 40436 3136 12 , , , 40436 3136 13 a)/piston a)/piston NNP 40436 3136 14 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3136 15 nê\ nê\ NNP 40436 3136 16 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 3136 17 theou theou NNP 40436 3136 18 / / SYM 40436 3136 19 s s NNPS 40436 3136 20 , , , 40436 3136 21 a)lêthe\s a)lêthe\s NNP 40436 3136 22 de/. de/. NNP 40436 3137 1 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 3137 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3137 3 e)/mathon e)/mathon NN 40436 3137 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3137 5 para\ para\ NNP 40436 3137 6 sou= sou= NNP 40436 3137 7 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 3137 8 pô pô NN 40436 3137 9 / / SYM 40436 3137 10 pote pote NN 40436 3137 11 , , , 40436 3137 12 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3137 13 au)to\s au)to\s NN 40436 3137 14 oi)=stha oi)=stha NN 40436 3137 15 ; ; : 40436 3137 16 e)pedi e)pedi , 40436 3137 17 / / SYM 40436 3137 18 doun doun NNP 40436 3137 19 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3137 20 o(pote o(pote CC 40436 3137 21 soi soi NNP 40436 3137 22 sunei sunei NNP 40436 3137 23 / / SYM 40436 3137 24 ên ên NNP 40436 3137 25 , , , 40436 3137 26 ka)\n ka)\n . 40436 3137 27 ei ei NNP 40436 3137 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3137 29 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3137 30 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 3137 31 au)tê=| au)tê=| NNS 40436 3137 32 mo mo NN 40436 3137 33 / / SYM 40436 3137 34 non non AFX 40436 3137 35 oi)ki oi)ki NNP 40436 3137 36 / / SYM 40436 3137 37 a| a| NN 40436 3137 38 ei)/ên ei)/ên CD 40436 3137 39 , , , 40436 3137 40 mê\ mê\ JJ 40436 3137 41 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3137 42 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 3137 43 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 3137 44 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3137 45 oi)kê oi)kê NNP 40436 3137 46 / / SYM 40436 3137 47 mati mati NNPS 40436 3137 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3137 49 , , , 40436 3137 50 & & CC 40436 3137 51 c. c. NNP 40436 3137 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3137 53 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3137 54 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3137 55 19 19 CD 40436 3137 56 : : : 40436 3137 57 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3137 58 , , , 40436 3137 59 Theag Theag NNP 40436 3137 60 . . . 40436 3138 1 130 130 CD 40436 3138 2 E. E. NNP 40436 3138 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3138 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3138 5 : : : 40436 3138 6 polu\ polu\ NNP 40436 3138 7 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3138 8 ma ma NNP 40436 3138 9 / / SYM 40436 3138 10 lista lista NNP 40436 3138 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3138 12 plei plei NNP 40436 3138 13 = = SYM 40436 3138 14 ston ston NNP 40436 3138 15 e)pedi e)pedi , 40436 3138 16 / / SYM 40436 3138 17 doun doun NNP 40436 3138 18 , , , 40436 3138 19 o(po o(po NNP 40436 3138 20 / / SYM 40436 3138 21 te te NNP 40436 3138 22 par par NNP 40436 3138 23 ' ' '' 40436 3138 24 au)to au)to NNP 40436 3138 25 / / SYM 40436 3138 26 n n NNP 40436 3138 27 se se NNP 40436 3138 28 kathoi kathoi NNP 40436 3138 29 / / SYM 40436 3138 30 mên mên NNP 40436 3138 31 e)cho e)cho NNP 40436 3138 32 / / SYM 40436 3138 33 meno meno NNP 40436 3138 34 / / SYM 40436 3138 35 s s NNP 40436 3138 36 sou sou NNP 40436 3138 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3138 38 a(pto a(pto NNP 40436 3138 39 / / SYM 40436 3138 40 menos menos NNP 40436 3138 41 . . . 40436 3139 1 nu nu NNP 40436 3139 2 = = SYM 40436 3139 3 n n NNP 40436 3139 4 de/ de/ NNP 40436 3139 5 , , , 40436 3139 6 ê)= ê)= NNP 40436 3139 7 d d NNP 40436 3139 8 ' ' '' 40436 3139 9 o(/s o(/s NNP 40436 3139 10 , , , 40436 3139 11 pa pa NNP 40436 3139 12 = = SYM 40436 3139 13 sa sa NNP 40436 3139 14 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 3139 15 / / SYM 40436 3139 16 nê nê UH 40436 3139 17 ê(\ ê(\ NNP 40436 3139 18 e(/xis e(/xis NNP 40436 3139 19 e)xer)r(u e)xer)r(u NNP 40436 3139 20 / / SYM 40436 3139 21 êken êken JJ 40436 3139 22 . . . 40436 3139 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3139 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3140 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3140 2 Side side NN 40436 3140 3 - - HYPH 40436 3140 4 note note NN 40436 3140 5 : : : 40436 3140 6 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3140 7 expresses express VBZ 40436 3140 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3140 9 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 3140 10 to to TO 40436 3140 11 be be VB 40436 3140 12 received receive VBN 40436 3140 13 as as IN 40436 3140 14 the the DT 40436 3140 15 companion companion NN 40436 3140 16 of of IN 40436 3140 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3140 18 . . . 40436 3140 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3141 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3141 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 3141 3 have have VBP 40436 3141 4 now now RB 40436 3141 5 explained explain VBN 40436 3141 6 to to IN 40436 3141 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3141 8 , , , 40436 3141 9 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3141 10 , , , 40436 3141 11 what what WP 40436 3141 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3141 13 is be VBZ 40436 3141 14 to to TO 40436 3141 15 become become VB 40436 3141 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3141 17 companion companion NN 40436 3141 18 . . . 40436 3142 1 If if IN 40436 3142 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3142 3 be be VBP 40436 3142 4 the the DT 40436 3142 5 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 3142 6 of of IN 40436 3142 7 the the DT 40436 3142 8 God God NNP 40436 3142 9 , , , 40436 3142 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3142 11 will will MD 40436 3142 12 make make VB 40436 3142 13 great great JJ 40436 3142 14 and and CC 40436 3142 15 rapid rapid JJ 40436 3142 16 progress progress NN 40436 3142 17 : : : 40436 3142 18 if if IN 40436 3142 19 not not RB 40436 3142 20 , , , 40436 3142 21 not not RB 40436 3142 22 . . . 40436 3143 1 Consider consider VB 40436 3143 2 , , , 40436 3143 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 3143 4 , , , 40436 3143 5 whether whether IN 40436 3143 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3143 7 is be VBZ 40436 3143 8 not not RB 40436 3143 9 safer safe JJR 40436 3143 10 for for IN 40436 3143 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3143 12 to to TO 40436 3143 13 seek seek VB 40436 3143 14 instruction instruction NN 40436 3143 15 from from IN 40436 3143 16 some some DT 40436 3143 17 of of IN 40436 3143 18 those those DT 40436 3143 19 who who WP 40436 3143 20 are be VBP 40436 3143 21 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3143 22 masters master NNS 40436 3143 23 of of IN 40436 3143 24 the the DT 40436 3143 25 benefits benefit NNS 40436 3143 26 which which WDT 40436 3143 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3143 28 impart impart VBP 40436 3143 29 , , , 40436 3143 30 rather rather RB 40436 3143 31 than than IN 40436 3143 32 to to TO 40436 3143 33 take take VB 40436 3143 34 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3143 35 chance chance NN 40436 3143 36 of of IN 40436 3143 37 the the DT 40436 3143 38 result result NN 40436 3143 39 with with IN 40436 3143 40 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3143 41 . . . 40436 3144 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3144 2 20 20 CD 40436 3144 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3144 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3144 5 Theag._--I theag._--i CD 40436 3144 6 shall shall MD 40436 3144 7 be be VB 40436 3144 8 glad glad JJ 40436 3144 9 , , , 40436 3144 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3144 11 , , , 40436 3144 12 to to TO 40436 3144 13 become become VB 40436 3144 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3144 15 companion companion NN 40436 3144 16 , , , 40436 3144 17 and and CC 40436 3144 18 to to TO 40436 3144 19 make make VB 40436 3144 20 trial trial NN 40436 3144 21 of of IN 40436 3144 22 this this DT 40436 3144 23 divine divine JJ 40436 3144 24 coadjutor coadjutor NN 40436 3144 25 . . . 40436 3145 1 If if IN 40436 3145 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3145 3 shows show VBZ 40436 3145 4 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3145 5 propitious propitious JJ 40436 3145 6 , , , 40436 3145 7 that that DT 40436 3145 8 will will MD 40436 3145 9 be be VB 40436 3145 10 the the DT 40436 3145 11 best good JJS 40436 3145 12 of of IN 40436 3145 13 all all DT 40436 3145 14 : : : 40436 3145 15 if if IN 40436 3145 16 not not RB 40436 3145 17 , , , 40436 3145 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3145 19 can can MD 40436 3145 20 then then RB 40436 3145 21 take take VB 40436 3145 22 counsel counsel NN 40436 3145 23 , , , 40436 3145 24 whether whether IN 40436 3145 25 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3145 26 shall shall MD 40436 3145 27 try try VB 40436 3145 28 to to TO 40436 3145 29 propitiate propitiate VB 40436 3145 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3145 31 by by IN 40436 3145 32 prayer prayer NN 40436 3145 33 , , , 40436 3145 34 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 3145 35 , , , 40436 3145 36 or or CC 40436 3145 37 any any DT 40436 3145 38 other other JJ 40436 3145 39 means mean NNS 40436 3145 40 which which WDT 40436 3145 41 the the DT 40436 3145 42 prophets prophet NNS 40436 3145 43 may may MD 40436 3145 44 recommend recommend VB 40436 3145 45 or or CC 40436 3145 46 whether whether IN 40436 3145 47 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3145 48 shall shall MD 40436 3145 49 go go VB 40436 3145 50 to to IN 40436 3145 51 some some DT 40436 3145 52 other other JJ 40436 3145 53 teacher teacher NN 40436 3145 54 . . . 40436 3146 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3146 2 21 21 CD 40436 3146 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3146 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3146 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3146 6 20 20 CD 40436 3146 7 : : : 40436 3146 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3146 9 , , , 40436 3146 10 Theag Theag NNP 40436 3146 11 . . . 40436 3147 1 130 130 CD 40436 3147 2 E. E. NNP 40436 3147 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3147 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3147 5 : : : 40436 3147 6 o(/ra o(/ra NNP 40436 3147 7 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 3147 8 mê/ mê/ NNP 40436 3147 9 soi soi NNP 40436 3147 10 a)sphale a)sphale , 40436 3147 11 / / SYM 40436 3147 12 steron steron NNP 40436 3147 13 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 3147 14 par par NNP 40436 3147 15 ' ' '' 40436 3147 16 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 3147 17 / / SYM 40436 3147 18 nôn nôn NNP 40436 3147 19 tini\ tini\ NNP 40436 3147 20 paideu paideu NNP 40436 3147 21 / / SYM 40436 3147 22 esthai esthai NNP 40436 3147 23 , , , 40436 3147 24 oi(\ oi(\ NNP 40436 3147 25 e)gkratei e)gkratei NNP 40436 3147 26 = = SYM 40436 3147 27 s s NNP 40436 3147 28 au)toi/ au)toi/ NNP 40436 3147 29 ei)si ei)si NNP 40436 3147 30 tê tê NNP 40436 3147 31 = = SYM 40436 3147 32 s s NNP 40436 3147 33 ô)phelei ô)phelei NNP 40436 3147 34 / / SYM 40436 3147 35 as as IN 40436 3147 36 , , , 40436 3147 37 ê)\n ê)\n CD 40436 3147 38 ô)phelou ô)phelou , 40436 3147 39 = = NFP 40436 3147 40 si si NNP 40436 3147 41 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 3147 42 a)nthrô a)nthrô CD 40436 3147 43 / / SYM 40436 3147 44 pous pous JJ 40436 3147 45 , , , 40436 3147 46 ma ma NNP 40436 3147 47 = = SYM 40436 3147 48 llon llon NNP 40436 3147 49 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 3147 50 par par NNP 40436 3147 51 ' ' `` 40436 3147 52 e)mou= e)mou= NNP 40436 3147 53 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 3147 54 , , , 40436 3147 55 ti ti IN 40436 3147 56 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 3147 57 tu tu NNP 40436 3147 58 / / SYM 40436 3147 59 chê| chê| NNP 40436 3147 60 , , , 40436 3147 61 tou tou NNP 40436 3147 62 = = SYM 40436 3147 63 to to IN 40436 3147 64 pra pra NNP 40436 3147 65 = = SYM 40436 3147 66 xai xai NNP 40436 3147 67 . . . 40436 3147 68 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3147 69 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3148 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3148 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3148 3 21 21 CD 40436 3148 4 : : : 40436 3148 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3148 6 , , , 40436 3148 7 Theag Theag NNP 40436 3148 8 . . . 40436 3149 1 131 131 CD 40436 3149 2 A. a. NN 40436 3149 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3150 1 * * NFP 40436 3150 2 * * NFP 40436 3150 3 * * NFP 40436 3150 4 * * NFP 40436 3150 5 * * NFP 40436 3150 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3150 7 Side side NN 40436 3150 8 - - HYPH 40436 3150 9 note note NN 40436 3150 10 : : : 40436 3150 11 Remarks remark NNS 40436 3150 12 on on IN 40436 3150 13 the the DT 40436 3150 14 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3150 15 -- -- : 40436 3150 16 analogy analogy NN 40436 3150 17 with with IN 40436 3150 18 the the DT 40436 3150 19 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3150 20 . . . 40436 3150 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3151 1 The the DT 40436 3151 2 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3151 3 figured figure VBD 40436 3151 4 in in IN 40436 3151 5 the the DT 40436 3151 6 list list NN 40436 3151 7 of of IN 40436 3151 8 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3151 9 as as IN 40436 3151 10 first first RB 40436 3151 11 in in IN 40436 3151 12 the the DT 40436 3151 13 fifth fifth JJ 40436 3151 14 Tetralogy Tetralogy NNP 40436 3151 15 : : : 40436 3151 16 the the DT 40436 3151 17 other other JJ 40436 3151 18 three three CD 40436 3151 19 members member NNS 40436 3151 20 of of IN 40436 3151 21 the the DT 40436 3151 22 same same JJ 40436 3151 23 Tetralogy Tetralogy NNP 40436 3151 24 being be VBG 40436 3151 25 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 3151 26 , , , 40436 3151 27 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3151 28 , , , 40436 3151 29 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 3151 30 . . . 40436 3152 1 Some some DT 40436 3152 2 persons person NNS 40436 3152 3 considered consider VBD 40436 3152 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3152 5 suitable suitable JJ 40436 3152 6 to to TO 40436 3152 7 read read VB 40436 3152 8 as as IN 40436 3152 9 first first JJ 40436 3152 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3152 11 of of IN 40436 3152 12 all all DT 40436 3152 13 . . . 40436 3153 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3153 2 22 22 CD 40436 3153 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3153 4 There there EX 40436 3153 5 are be VBP 40436 3153 6 several several JJ 40436 3153 7 points point NNS 40436 3153 8 of of IN 40436 3153 9 analogy analogy NN 40436 3153 10 between between IN 40436 3153 11 the the DT 40436 3153 12 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3153 13 and and CC 40436 3153 14 the the DT 40436 3153 15 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3153 16 , , , 40436 3153 17 though though IN 40436 3153 18 with with IN 40436 3153 19 a a DT 40436 3153 20 different different JJ 40436 3153 21 turn turn NN 40436 3153 22 given give VBN 40436 3153 23 to to IN 40436 3153 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3153 25 . . . 40436 3154 1 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 3154 2 and and CC 40436 3154 3 Thucydides thucydide NNS 40436 3154 4 are be VBP 40436 3154 5 mentioned mention VBN 40436 3154 6 in in IN 40436 3154 7 both both DT 40436 3154 8 of of IN 40436 3154 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3154 10 : : : 40436 3154 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3154 12 also also RB 40436 3154 13 is be VBZ 40436 3154 14 solicited solicit VBN 40436 3154 15 to to TO 40436 3154 16 undertake undertake VB 40436 3154 17 the the DT 40436 3154 18 duty duty NN 40436 3154 19 of of IN 40436 3154 20 teacher teacher NN 40436 3154 21 . . . 40436 3155 1 The the DT 40436 3155 2 ardour ardour NN 40436 3155 3 of of IN 40436 3155 4 the the DT 40436 3155 5 young young JJ 40436 3155 6 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3155 7 to to TO 40436 3155 8 acquire acquire VB 40436 3155 9 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3155 10 reminds remind VBZ 40436 3155 11 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3155 12 of of IN 40436 3155 13 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 3155 14 at at IN 40436 3155 15 the the DT 40436 3155 16 beginning beginning NN 40436 3155 17 of of IN 40436 3155 18 the the DT 40436 3155 19 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 3155 20 . . . 40436 3156 1 The the DT 40436 3156 2 string string NN 40436 3156 3 of of IN 40436 3156 4 questions question NNS 40436 3156 5 put put VBN 40436 3156 6 by by IN 40436 3156 7 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3156 8 to to IN 40436 3156 9 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3156 10 , , , 40436 3156 11 requiring require VBG 40436 3156 12 that that IN 40436 3156 13 what what WP 40436 3156 14 is be VBZ 40436 3156 15 called call VBN 40436 3156 16 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3156 17 shall shall MD 40436 3156 18 be be VB 40436 3156 19 clearly clearly RB 40436 3156 20 defined define VBN 40436 3156 21 and and CC 40436 3156 22 specialised specialise VBN 40436 3156 23 , , , 40436 3156 24 has have VBZ 40436 3156 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3156 26 parallel parallel NN 40436 3156 27 in in IN 40436 3156 28 many many JJ 40436 3156 29 of of IN 40436 3156 30 the the DT 40436 3156 31 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3156 32 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3156 33 . . . 40436 3157 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 3157 2 the the DT 40436 3157 3 declaration declaration NN 40436 3157 4 of of IN 40436 3157 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3157 6 , , , 40436 3157 7 that that IN 40436 3157 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3157 9 knows know VBZ 40436 3157 10 nothing nothing NN 40436 3157 11 except except IN 40436 3157 12 about about IN 40436 3157 13 matters matter NNS 40436 3157 14 of of IN 40436 3157 15 love love NN 40436 3157 16 , , , 40436 3157 17 but but CC 40436 3157 18 that that IN 40436 3157 19 in in IN 40436 3157 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3157 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3157 22 is be VBZ 40436 3157 23 a a DT 40436 3157 24 consummate consummate JJ 40436 3157 25 master master NN 40436 3157 26 -- -- : 40436 3157 27 is be VBZ 40436 3157 28 the the DT 40436 3157 29 same same JJ 40436 3157 30 as as IN 40436 3157 31 what what WP 40436 3157 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3157 33 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 3157 34 declares declare VBZ 40436 3157 35 both both DT 40436 3157 36 in in IN 40436 3157 37 the the DT 40436 3157 38 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 3157 39 and and CC 40436 3157 40 other other JJ 40436 3157 41 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3157 42 . . . 40436 3158 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3158 2 23 23 CD 40436 3158 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3158 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3158 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3158 6 22 22 CD 40436 3158 7 : : : 40436 3158 8 Diog diog VB 40436 3158 9 . . . 40436 3159 1 L. L. NNP 40436 3159 2 iii iii CD 40436 3159 3 . . . 40436 3160 1 59 59 CD 40436 3160 2 - - SYM 40436 3160 3 61 61 CD 40436 3160 4 . . . 40436 3160 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3161 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3161 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3161 3 23 23 CD 40436 3161 4 : : : 40436 3161 5 Symposion symposion NN 40436 3161 6 , , , 40436 3161 7 177 177 CD 40436 3161 8 E. E. NNP 40436 3161 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3161 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3161 11 : : : 40436 3161 12 ou)/te ou)/te XX 40436 3161 13 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3161 14 a)/n a)/n NNP 40436 3161 15 pou pou CC 40436 3161 16 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 3161 17 a)pophê a)pophê NNP 40436 3161 18 / / SYM 40436 3161 19 saimi saimi NN 40436 3161 20 , , , 40436 3161 21 o(\s o(\s NNP 40436 3161 22 ou)de ou)de NNP 40436 3161 23 / / SYM 40436 3161 24 n n RB 40436 3161 25 phêmi phêmi JJ 40436 3161 26 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 3161 27 e)pi e)pi NN 40436 3161 28 / / SYM 40436 3161 29 stasthai stasthai NN 40436 3161 30 ê)\ ê)\ SYM 40436 3161 31 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 3161 32 e)rôtika/. e)rôtika/. CD 40436 3161 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3162 1 Compare compare VB 40436 3162 2 the the DT 40436 3162 3 same same JJ 40436 3162 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3162 5 , , , 40436 3162 6 p. p. NN 40436 3162 7 212 212 CD 40436 3162 8 B b NN 40436 3162 9 , , , 40436 3162 10 216 216 CD 40436 3162 11 C. C. NNP 40436 3162 12 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 3162 13 , , , 40436 3162 14 227 227 CD 40436 3162 15 E e NN 40436 3162 16 , , , 40436 3162 17 257 257 CD 40436 3162 18 A a NN 40436 3162 19 ; ; : 40436 3162 20 Lysis lysis NN 40436 3162 21 , , , 40436 3162 22 204 204 CD 40436 3162 23 B. b. NN 40436 3163 1 Compare compare VB 40436 3163 2 also also RB 40436 3163 3 Xenoph Xenoph NNP 40436 3163 4 . . . 40436 3164 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 3164 2 . . . 40436 3165 1 ii ii LS 40436 3165 2 . . . 40436 3166 1 6 6 CD 40436 3166 2 , , , 40436 3166 3 28 28 CD 40436 3166 4 ; ; : 40436 3166 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNP 40436 3166 6 . . . 40436 3167 1 Sympos Sympos NNP 40436 3167 2 . . . 40436 3168 1 iv iv XX 40436 3168 2 . . . 40436 3169 1 27 27 CD 40436 3169 2 . . . 40436 3170 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3170 2 is be VBZ 40436 3170 3 not not RB 40436 3170 4 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 3170 5 to to TO 40436 3170 6 treat treat VB 40436 3170 7 this this DT 40436 3170 8 declaration declaration NN 40436 3170 9 of of IN 40436 3170 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3170 11 , , , 40436 3170 12 in in IN 40436 3170 13 the the DT 40436 3170 14 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3170 15 , , , 40436 3170 16 as as IN 40436 3170 17 an an DT 40436 3170 18 evidence evidence NN 40436 3170 19 that that IN 40436 3170 20 the the DT 40436 3170 21 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3170 22 is be VBZ 40436 3170 23 the the DT 40436 3170 24 work work NN 40436 3170 25 of of IN 40436 3170 26 a a DT 40436 3170 27 _ _ NNP 40436 3170 28 falsarius falsarius NN 40436 3170 29 _ _ NNP 40436 3170 30 , , , 40436 3170 31 when when WRB 40436 3170 32 a a DT 40436 3170 33 declaration declaration NN 40436 3170 34 quite quite RB 40436 3170 35 similar similar JJ 40436 3170 36 is be VBZ 40436 3170 37 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 3170 38 to to IN 40436 3170 39 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3170 40 in in IN 40436 3170 41 other other JJ 40436 3170 42 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3170 43 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3170 44 . . . 40436 3170 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3171 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3171 2 Side side NN 40436 3171 3 - - HYPH 40436 3171 4 note note NN 40436 3171 5 : : : 40436 3171 6 Chief chief JJ 40436 3171 7 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 3171 8 of of IN 40436 3171 9 the the DT 40436 3171 10 Theagês theagês JJ 40436 3171 11 -- -- : 40436 3171 12 stress stress NN 40436 3171 13 laid lay VBN 40436 3171 14 upon upon IN 40436 3171 15 the the DT 40436 3171 16 divine divine JJ 40436 3171 17 sign sign NN 40436 3171 18 or or CC 40436 3171 19 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3171 20 . . . 40436 3171 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3172 1 But but CC 40436 3172 2 the the DT 40436 3172 3 chief chief JJ 40436 3172 4 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 3172 5 of of IN 40436 3172 6 the the DT 40436 3172 7 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3172 8 consists consist VBZ 40436 3172 9 in in IN 40436 3172 10 the the DT 40436 3172 11 stress stress NN 40436 3172 12 which which WDT 40436 3172 13 is be VBZ 40436 3172 14 laid lay VBN 40436 3172 15 upon upon IN 40436 3172 16 the the DT 40436 3172 17 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3172 18 , , , 40436 3172 19 the the DT 40436 3172 20 divine divine JJ 40436 3172 21 voice voice NN 40436 3172 22 , , , 40436 3172 23 the the DT 40436 3172 24 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3172 25 of of IN 40436 3172 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3172 27 . . . 40436 3173 1 This this DT 40436 3173 2 divine divine JJ 40436 3173 3 auxiliary auxiliary JJ 40436 3173 4 is be VBZ 40436 3173 5 here here RB 40436 3173 6 described describe VBN 40436 3173 7 , , , 40436 3173 8 not not RB 40436 3173 9 only only RB 40436 3173 10 as as IN 40436 3173 11 giving give VBG 40436 3173 12 a a DT 40436 3173 13 timely timely JJ 40436 3173 14 check check NN 40436 3173 15 or or CC 40436 3173 16 warning warning NN 40436 3173 17 to to IN 40436 3173 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3173 19 , , , 40436 3173 20 when when WRB 40436 3173 21 either either CC 40436 3173 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3173 23 or or CC 40436 3173 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3173 25 friends friend NNS 40436 3173 26 contemplated contemplate VBD 40436 3173 27 any any DT 40436 3173 28 inauspicious inauspicious JJ 40436 3173 29 project project NN 40436 3173 30 -- -- : 40436 3173 31 but but CC 40436 3173 32 also also RB 40436 3173 33 as as IN 40436 3173 34 intervening intervene VBG 40436 3173 35 , , , 40436 3173 36 in in IN 40436 3173 37 the the DT 40436 3173 38 case case NN 40436 3173 39 of of IN 40436 3173 40 those those DT 40436 3173 41 youthful youthful JJ 40436 3173 42 companions companion NNS 40436 3173 43 with with IN 40436 3173 44 whom whom WP 40436 3173 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3173 46 conversed converse VBD 40436 3173 47 , , , 40436 3173 48 to to TO 40436 3173 49 promote promote VB 40436 3173 50 the the DT 40436 3173 51 improvement improvement NN 40436 3173 52 of of IN 40436 3173 53 one one CD 40436 3173 54 , , , 40436 3173 55 to to TO 40436 3173 56 obstruct obstruct VB 40436 3173 57 that that DT 40436 3173 58 of of IN 40436 3173 59 others other NNS 40436 3173 60 ; ; : 40436 3173 61 so so IN 40436 3173 62 that that IN 40436 3173 63 whether whether IN 40436 3173 64 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3173 65 will will MD 40436 3173 66 produce produce VB 40436 3173 67 any any DT 40436 3173 68 effect effect NN 40436 3173 69 or or CC 40436 3173 70 not not RB 40436 3173 71 in in IN 40436 3173 72 improving improve VBG 40436 3173 73 any any DT 40436 3173 74 one one CD 40436 3173 75 , , , 40436 3173 76 depends depend VBZ 40436 3173 77 neither neither CC 40436 3173 78 upon upon IN 40436 3173 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3173 80 own own JJ 40436 3173 81 efforts effort NNS 40436 3173 82 nor nor CC 40436 3173 83 upon upon IN 40436 3173 84 those those DT 40436 3173 85 of of IN 40436 3173 86 the the DT 40436 3173 87 recipient recipient NN 40436 3173 88 , , , 40436 3173 89 but but CC 40436 3173 90 upon upon IN 40436 3173 91 the the DT 40436 3173 92 unpredictable unpredictable JJ 40436 3173 93 concurrence concurrence NN 40436 3173 94 of of IN 40436 3173 95 a a DT 40436 3173 96 divine divine JJ 40436 3173 97 agency agency NN 40436 3173 98 . . . 40436 3174 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3174 2 24 24 CD 40436 3174 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3174 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3174 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3174 6 24 24 CD 40436 3174 7 : : : 40436 3174 8 See see VB 40436 3174 9 some some DT 40436 3174 10 remarks remark NNS 40436 3174 11 on on IN 40436 3174 12 this this DT 40436 3174 13 point point NN 40436 3174 14 in in IN 40436 3174 15 Appendix Appendix NNP 40436 3174 16 . . . 40436 3174 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3175 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3175 2 Side side NN 40436 3175 3 - - HYPH 40436 3175 4 note note NN 40436 3175 5 : : : 40436 3175 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3175 7 employs employ VBZ 40436 3175 8 this this DT 40436 3175 9 divine divine JJ 40436 3175 10 sign sign NN 40436 3175 11 here here RB 40436 3175 12 to to TO 40436 3175 13 render render VB 40436 3175 14 some some DT 40436 3175 15 explanation explanation NN 40436 3175 16 of of IN 40436 3175 17 the the DT 40436 3175 18 singularity singularity NN 40436 3175 19 and and CC 40436 3175 20 eccentricity eccentricity NN 40436 3175 21 of of IN 40436 3175 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3175 23 , , , 40436 3175 24 and and CC 40436 3175 25 of of IN 40436 3175 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3175 27 unequal unequal JJ 40436 3175 28 influence influence NN 40436 3175 29 upon upon IN 40436 3175 30 different different JJ 40436 3175 31 companions companion NNS 40436 3175 32 . . . 40436 3175 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3176 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3176 2 employs employ VBZ 40436 3176 3 the the DT 40436 3176 4 Sokratic Sokratic NNP 40436 3176 5 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3176 6 , , , 40436 3176 7 in in IN 40436 3176 8 the the DT 40436 3176 9 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3176 10 , , , 40436 3176 11 for for IN 40436 3176 12 a a DT 40436 3176 13 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 3176 14 purpose purpose NN 40436 3176 15 , , , 40436 3176 16 which which WDT 40436 3176 17 , , , 40436 3176 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3176 19 think think VBP 40436 3176 20 , , , 40436 3176 21 admits admit NNS 40436 3176 22 of of IN 40436 3176 23 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 3176 24 explanation explanation NN 40436 3176 25 . . . 40436 3177 1 During during IN 40436 3177 2 the the DT 40436 3177 3 eight eight CD 40436 3177 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3177 5 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 3177 6 ten ten CD 40436 3177 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3177 8 years year NNS 40436 3177 9 of of IN 40436 3177 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3177 11 personal personal JJ 40436 3177 12 communion communion NN 40436 3177 13 with with IN 40436 3177 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3177 15 , , , 40436 3177 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3177 17 had have VBD 40436 3177 18 had have VBN 40436 3177 19 large large JJ 40436 3177 20 experience experience NN 40436 3177 21 of of IN 40436 3177 22 the the DT 40436 3177 23 variable variable JJ 40436 3177 24 and and CC 40436 3177 25 unaccountable unaccountable JJ 40436 3177 26 effect effect NN 40436 3177 27 produced produce VBN 40436 3177 28 by by IN 40436 3177 29 the the DT 40436 3177 30 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 3177 31 conversation conversation NN 40436 3177 32 upon upon IN 40436 3177 33 different different JJ 40436 3177 34 hearers hearer NNS 40436 3177 35 : : : 40436 3177 36 a a DT 40436 3177 37 fact fact NN 40436 3177 38 which which WDT 40436 3177 39 is be VBZ 40436 3177 40 also also RB 40436 3177 41 attested attest VBN 40436 3177 42 by by IN 40436 3177 43 the the DT 40436 3177 44 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 3177 45 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 3177 46 . . . 40436 3178 1 This this DT 40436 3178 2 difference difference NN 40436 3178 3 of of IN 40436 3178 4 effect effect NN 40436 3178 5 was be VBD 40436 3178 6 in in IN 40436 3178 7 no no DT 40436 3178 8 way way NN 40436 3178 9 commensurate commensurate JJ 40436 3178 10 to to IN 40436 3178 11 the the DT 40436 3178 12 unequal unequal JJ 40436 3178 13 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3178 14 of of IN 40436 3178 15 the the DT 40436 3178 16 hearers hearer NNS 40436 3178 17 . . . 40436 3179 1 Chærephon Chærephon NNP 40436 3179 2 , , , 40436 3179 3 Apollodôrus Apollodôrus NNP 40436 3179 4 , , , 40436 3179 5 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 3179 6 , , , 40436 3179 7 seem seem VBP 40436 3179 8 to to TO 40436 3179 9 have have VB 40436 3179 10 been be VBN 40436 3179 11 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 3179 12 men:--[25 men:--[25 NNP 40436 3179 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3179 14 while while IN 40436 3179 15 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 3179 16 and and CC 40436 3179 17 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 3179 18 , , , 40436 3179 19 who who WP 40436 3179 20 brought bring VBD 40436 3179 21 so so RB 40436 3179 22 much much JJ 40436 3179 23 discredit discredit NN 40436 3179 24 both both DT 40436 3179 25 upon upon IN 40436 3179 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3179 27 and and CC 40436 3179 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3179 29 teaching teaching NN 40436 3179 30 , , , 40436 3179 31 profited profit VBD 40436 3179 32 little little JJ 40436 3179 33 by by IN 40436 3179 34 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3179 35 , , , 40436 3179 36 though though IN 40436 3179 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3179 38 were be VBD 40436 3179 39 among among IN 40436 3179 40 the the DT 40436 3179 41 ablest able JJS 40436 3179 42 pupils pupil NNS 40436 3179 43 that that WDT 40436 3179 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3179 45 ever ever RB 40436 3179 46 addressed address VBD 40436 3179 47 : : : 40436 3179 48 moreover moreover RB 40436 3179 49 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNPS 40436 3179 50 , , , 40436 3179 51 and and CC 40436 3179 52 Aristippus Aristippus NNP 40436 3179 53 , , , 40436 3179 54 probably probably RB 40436 3179 55 did do VBD 40436 3179 56 not not RB 40436 3179 57 appear appear VB 40436 3179 58 to to IN 40436 3179 59 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3179 60 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3179 61 since since IN 40436 3179 62 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3179 63 greatly greatly RB 40436 3179 64 dissented dissent VBD 40436 3179 65 from from IN 40436 3179 66 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3179 67 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 3179 68 views view NNS 40436 3179 69 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3179 70 to to TO 40436 3179 71 have have VB 40436 3179 72 profited profit VBN 40436 3179 73 much much JJ 40436 3179 74 by by IN 40436 3179 75 the the DT 40436 3179 76 common common JJ 40436 3179 77 companionship companionship NN 40436 3179 78 with with IN 40436 3179 79 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3179 80 . . . 40436 3180 1 Other other JJ 40436 3180 2 companions companion NNS 40436 3180 3 there there EX 40436 3180 4 must must MD 40436 3180 5 have have VB 40436 3180 6 been be VBN 40436 3180 7 also also RB 40436 3180 8 personally personally RB 40436 3180 9 known know VBN 40436 3180 10 to to IN 40436 3180 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3180 12 , , , 40436 3180 13 though though IN 40436 3180 14 not not RB 40436 3180 15 to to IN 40436 3180 16 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3180 17 : : : 40436 3180 18 for for IN 40436 3180 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3180 20 must must MD 40436 3180 21 remember remember VB 40436 3180 22 that that IN 40436 3180 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3180 24 passed pass VBD 40436 3180 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3180 26 whole whole JJ 40436 3180 27 day day NN 40436 3180 28 in in IN 40436 3180 29 talking talk VBG 40436 3180 30 with with IN 40436 3180 31 all all DT 40436 3180 32 listeners listener NNS 40436 3180 33 . . . 40436 3181 1 Now now RB 40436 3181 2 when when WRB 40436 3181 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3181 4 in in IN 40436 3181 5 after after IN 40436 3181 6 life life NN 40436 3181 7 came come VBD 40436 3181 8 to to TO 40436 3181 9 cast cast VB 40436 3181 10 the the DT 40436 3181 11 ministry ministry NN 40436 3181 12 of of IN 40436 3181 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3181 14 into into IN 40436 3181 15 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 3181 16 scenes scene NNS 40436 3181 17 , , , 40436 3181 18 and and CC 40436 3181 19 to to TO 40436 3181 20 make make VB 40436 3181 21 each each DT 40436 3181 22 scene scene NN 40436 3181 23 subservient subservient NN 40436 3181 24 to to IN 40436 3181 25 the the DT 40436 3181 26 illustration illustration NN 40436 3181 27 of of IN 40436 3181 28 some some DT 40436 3181 29 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 3181 30 point point NN 40436 3181 31 of of IN 40436 3181 32 view view NN 40436 3181 33 , , , 40436 3181 34 at at IN 40436 3181 35 least least JJS 40436 3181 36 a a DT 40436 3181 37 negative negative JJ 40436 3181 38 -- -- : 40436 3181 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3181 40 was be VBD 40436 3181 41 naturally naturally RB 40436 3181 42 led lead VBN 40436 3181 43 to to IN 40436 3181 44 advert advert VB 40436 3181 45 to to IN 40436 3181 46 the the DT 40436 3181 47 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3181 48 or or CC 40436 3181 49 divine divine JJ 40436 3181 50 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3181 51 , , , 40436 3181 52 which which WDT 40436 3181 53 formed form VBD 40436 3181 54 so so RB 40436 3181 55 marked mark VBD 40436 3181 56 a a DT 40436 3181 57 feature feature NN 40436 3181 58 in in IN 40436 3181 59 the the DT 40436 3181 60 character character NN 40436 3181 61 of of IN 40436 3181 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3181 63 master master NN 40436 3181 64 . . . 40436 3182 1 The the DT 40436 3182 2 concurrence concurrence NN 40436 3182 3 or or CC 40436 3182 4 prohibition prohibition NN 40436 3182 5 of of IN 40436 3182 6 this this DT 40436 3182 7 divine divine JJ 40436 3182 8 auxiliary auxiliary NN 40436 3182 9 served serve VBD 40436 3182 10 to to TO 40436 3182 11 explain explain VB 40436 3182 12 why why WRB 40436 3182 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3182 14 was be VBD 40436 3182 15 that that IN 40436 3182 16 the the DT 40436 3182 17 seed seed NN 40436 3182 18 , , , 40436 3182 19 sown sow VBN 40436 3182 20 broadcast broadcast NN 40436 3182 21 by by IN 40436 3182 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3182 23 , , , 40436 3182 24 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 3182 25 fructified fructify VBD 40436 3182 26 , , , 40436 3182 27 and and CC 40436 3182 28 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 3182 29 did do VBD 40436 3182 30 not not RB 40436 3182 31 fructify fructify VB 40436 3182 32 , , , 40436 3182 33 or or CC 40436 3182 34 speedily speedily RB 40436 3182 35 perished perish VBN 40436 3182 36 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 3182 37 -- -- : 40436 3182 38 when when WRB 40436 3182 39 no no DT 40436 3182 40 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 3182 41 explanatory explanatory JJ 40436 3182 42 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 3182 43 could could MD 40436 3182 44 be be VB 40436 3182 45 pointed point VBN 40436 3182 46 out out RP 40436 3182 47 in in IN 40436 3182 48 the the DT 40436 3182 49 ground ground NN 40436 3182 50 on on IN 40436 3182 51 which which WDT 40436 3182 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3182 53 fell fall VBD 40436 3182 54 . . . 40436 3183 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3183 2 gave give VBD 40436 3183 3 an an DT 40436 3183 4 apparent apparent JJ 40436 3183 5 reason reason NN 40436 3183 6 for for IN 40436 3183 7 the the DT 40436 3183 8 perfect perfect JJ 40436 3183 9 singularity singularity NN 40436 3183 10 of of IN 40436 3183 11 the the DT 40436 3183 12 course course NN 40436 3183 13 pursued pursue VBN 40436 3183 14 by by IN 40436 3183 15 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3183 16 : : : 40436 3183 17 for for IN 40436 3183 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3183 19 preternatural preternatural JJ 40436 3183 20 acuteness acuteness NN 40436 3183 21 in in IN 40436 3183 22 one one CD 40436 3183 23 direction direction NN 40436 3183 24 , , , 40436 3183 25 and and CC 40436 3183 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3183 27 avowed avowed JJ 40436 3183 28 incapacity incapacity NN 40436 3183 29 in in IN 40436 3183 30 another another DT 40436 3183 31 : : : 40436 3183 32 for for IN 40436 3183 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3183 34 mastery mastery NN 40436 3183 35 of of IN 40436 3183 36 the the DT 40436 3183 37 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 3183 38 , , , 40436 3183 39 convicting convict VBG 40436 3183 40 men man NNS 40436 3183 41 of of IN 40436 3183 42 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 3183 43 , , , 40436 3183 44 and and CC 40436 3183 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3183 46 inability inability NN 40436 3183 47 to to TO 40436 3183 48 supply supply VB 40436 3183 49 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3183 50 with with IN 40436 3183 51 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3183 52 : : : 40436 3183 53 for for IN 40436 3183 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3183 55 refusal refusal NN 40436 3183 56 to to TO 40436 3183 57 undertake undertake VB 40436 3183 58 the the DT 40436 3183 59 duties duty NNS 40436 3183 60 of of IN 40436 3183 61 a a DT 40436 3183 62 teacher teacher NN 40436 3183 63 . . . 40436 3184 1 All all PDT 40436 3184 2 these these DT 40436 3184 3 are be VBP 40436 3184 4 mysterious mysterious JJ 40436 3184 5 features feature NNS 40436 3184 6 of of IN 40436 3184 7 the the DT 40436 3184 8 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 3184 9 character character NN 40436 3184 10 . . . 40436 3185 1 The the DT 40436 3185 2 intervention intervention NN 40436 3185 3 of of IN 40436 3185 4 the the DT 40436 3185 5 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3185 6 appears appear VBZ 40436 3185 7 to to TO 40436 3185 8 afford afford VB 40436 3185 9 an an DT 40436 3185 10 explanation explanation NN 40436 3185 11 , , , 40436 3185 12 by by IN 40436 3185 13 converting convert VBG 40436 3185 14 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3185 15 into into IN 40436 3185 16 religious religious JJ 40436 3185 17 mysteries mystery NNS 40436 3185 18 : : : 40436 3185 19 which which WDT 40436 3185 20 , , , 40436 3185 21 though though IN 40436 3185 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3185 23 be be VB 40436 3185 24 no no DT 40436 3185 25 explanation explanation NN 40436 3185 26 at at RB 40436 3185 27 all all RB 40436 3185 28 , , , 40436 3185 29 yet yet RB 40436 3185 30 is be VBZ 40436 3185 31 equally equally RB 40436 3185 32 efficacious efficacious JJ 40436 3185 33 by by IN 40436 3185 34 stopping stop VBG 40436 3185 35 the the DT 40436 3185 36 mouth mouth NN 40436 3185 37 of of IN 40436 3185 38 the the DT 40436 3185 39 questioner questioner NN 40436 3185 40 , , , 40436 3185 41 and and CC 40436 3185 42 by by IN 40436 3185 43 making make VBG 40436 3185 44 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3185 45 believe believe VB 40436 3185 46 that that IN 40436 3185 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3185 48 is be VBZ 40436 3185 49 guilt guilt NN 40436 3185 50 and and CC 40436 3185 51 impiety impiety NN 40436 3185 52 to to TO 40436 3185 53 ask ask VB 40436 3185 54 for for IN 40436 3185 55 explanation explanation NN 40436 3185 56 -- -- : 40436 3185 57 as as IN 40436 3185 58 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3185 59 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3185 60 declared declare VBD 40436 3185 61 in in IN 40436 3185 62 regard regard NN 40436 3185 63 to to IN 40436 3185 64 astronomical astronomical JJ 40436 3185 65 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 3185 66 , , , 40436 3185 67 and and CC 40436 3185 68 as as IN 40436 3185 69 Herodotus Herodotus NNP 40436 3185 70 feels feel VBZ 40436 3185 71 , , , 40436 3185 72 when when WRB 40436 3185 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3185 74 narrative narrative NN 40436 3185 75 is be VBZ 40436 3185 76 crossed cross VBN 40436 3185 77 by by IN 40436 3185 78 strange strange JJ 40436 3185 79 religious religious JJ 40436 3185 80 legends legend NNS 40436 3185 81 . . . 40436 3186 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3186 2 26 26 CD 40436 3186 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3186 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3186 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3186 6 25 25 CD 40436 3186 7 : : : 40436 3186 8 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3186 9 , , , 40436 3186 10 Apol Apol NNP 40436 3186 11 . . . 40436 3187 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 3187 2 . . . 40436 3188 1 28 28 CD 40436 3188 2 . . . 40436 3189 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3189 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3189 3 : : : 40436 3189 4 A)pollo a)pollo NN 40436 3189 5 / / SYM 40436 3189 6 dôros dôro NNS 40436 3189 7 -- -- : 40436 3189 8 e)pithumê e)pithumê , 40436 3189 9 / / SYM 40436 3189 10 tês tês NNP 40436 3189 11 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3189 12 i)schurô i)schurô NNP 40436 3189 13 = = NFP 40436 3189 14 s s NNP 40436 3189 15 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 3189 16 , , , 40436 3189 17 a)/llôs a)/llôs NNP 40436 3189 18 d d NNP 40436 3189 19 ' ' POS 40436 3189 20 eu)ê eu)ê NNP 40436 3189 21 / / SYM 40436 3189 22 thês.]--Plat thês.]--plat NN 40436 3189 23 . . . 40436 3190 1 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 3190 2 , , , 40436 3190 3 117 117 CD 40436 3190 4 D. D. NNP 40436 3190 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3190 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3190 7 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3190 8 26 26 CD 40436 3190 9 : : : 40436 3190 10 Xen Xen NNP 40436 3190 11 . . . 40436 3191 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 3191 2 . . . 40436 3192 1 iv iv XX 40436 3192 2 . . . 40436 3193 1 7 7 CD 40436 3193 2 , , , 40436 3193 3 5 5 CD 40436 3193 4 - - SYM 40436 3193 5 6 6 CD 40436 3193 6 ; ; : 40436 3193 7 Herodot Herodot NNP 40436 3193 8 . . . 40436 3194 1 ii ii LS 40436 3194 2 . . . 40436 3195 1 3 3 CD 40436 3195 2 , , , 40436 3195 3 45 45 CD 40436 3195 4 - - SYM 40436 3195 5 46 46 CD 40436 3195 6 . . . 40436 3195 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3196 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3196 2 Side side NN 40436 3196 3 - - HYPH 40436 3196 4 note note NN 40436 3196 5 : : : 40436 3196 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3196 7 , , , 40436 3196 8 while while IN 40436 3196 9 continually continually RB 40436 3196 10 finding find VBG 40436 3196 11 fault fault NN 40436 3196 12 with with IN 40436 3196 13 other other JJ 40436 3196 14 teachers teacher NNS 40436 3196 15 , , , 40436 3196 16 refused refuse VBD 40436 3196 17 to to TO 40436 3196 18 teach teach VB 40436 3196 19 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3196 20 -- -- : 40436 3196 21 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 3196 22 of of IN 40436 3196 23 finding find VBG 40436 3196 24 an an DT 40436 3196 25 excuse excuse NN 40436 3196 26 for for IN 40436 3196 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3196 28 refusal refusal NN 40436 3196 29 . . . 40436 3197 1 The the DT 40436 3197 2 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3197 3 furnishes furnish VBZ 40436 3197 4 an an DT 40436 3197 5 excuse excuse NN 40436 3197 6 . . . 40436 3197 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3198 1 In in IN 40436 3198 2 this this DT 40436 3198 3 manner manner NN 40436 3198 4 , , , 40436 3198 5 the the DT 40436 3198 6 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3198 7 is be VBZ 40436 3198 8 made make VBN 40436 3198 9 by by IN 40436 3198 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3198 11 to to TO 40436 3198 12 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 3198 13 one one CD 40436 3198 14 way way NN 40436 3198 15 of of IN 40436 3198 16 parrying parry VBG 40436 3198 17 the the DT 40436 3198 18 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 3198 19 frequently frequently RB 40436 3198 20 addressed address VBD 40436 3198 21 to to IN 40436 3198 22 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3198 23 by by IN 40436 3198 24 various various JJ 40436 3198 25 hearers hearer NNS 40436 3198 26 : : : 40436 3198 27 " " `` 40436 3198 28 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3198 29 tell tell VBP 40436 3198 30 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3198 31 that that IN 40436 3198 32 the the DT 40436 3198 33 leading lead VBG 40436 3198 34 citizens citizen NNS 40436 3198 35 can can MD 40436 3198 36 not not RB 40436 3198 37 even even RB 40436 3198 38 teach teach VB 40436 3198 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3198 40 own own JJ 40436 3198 41 sons son NNS 40436 3198 42 , , , 40436 3198 43 and and CC 40436 3198 44 that that IN 40436 3198 45 the the DT 40436 3198 46 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 3198 47 teach teach VBP 40436 3198 48 nothing nothing NN 40436 3198 49 worth worth JJ 40436 3198 50 having have VBG 40436 3198 51 : : : 40436 3198 52 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3198 53 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 3198 54 call call VBP 40436 3198 55 upon upon IN 40436 3198 56 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3198 57 to to TO 40436 3198 58 seek seek VB 40436 3198 59 for for IN 40436 3198 60 better well JJR 40436 3198 61 teachers teacher NNS 40436 3198 62 , , , 40436 3198 63 without without IN 40436 3198 64 telling tell VBG 40436 3198 65 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3198 66 where where WRB 40436 3198 67 such such JJ 40436 3198 68 are be VBP 40436 3198 69 to to TO 40436 3198 70 be be VB 40436 3198 71 found find VBN 40436 3198 72 . . . 40436 3199 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3199 2 entreat entreat VBP 40436 3199 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3199 4 to to TO 40436 3199 5 teach teach VB 40436 3199 6 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3199 7 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 3199 8 , , , 40436 3199 9 conformably conformably RB 40436 3199 10 to to IN 40436 3199 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3199 12 own own JJ 40436 3199 13 views view NNS 40436 3199 14 . . . 40436 3199 15 " " '' 40436 3200 1 If if IN 40436 3200 2 a a DT 40436 3200 3 leader leader NN 40436 3200 4 of of IN 40436 3200 5 political political JJ 40436 3200 6 opposition opposition NN 40436 3200 7 , , , 40436 3200 8 after after IN 40436 3200 9 years year NNS 40436 3200 10 employed employ VBN 40436 3200 11 in in IN 40436 3200 12 denouncing denounce VBG 40436 3200 13 successive successive JJ 40436 3200 14 administrators administrator NNS 40436 3200 15 as as IN 40436 3200 16 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 3200 17 and and CC 40436 3200 18 iniquitous iniquitous JJ 40436 3200 19 , , , 40436 3200 20 refuses refuse NNS 40436 3200 21 , , , 40436 3200 22 when when WRB 40436 3200 23 invited invite VBN 40436 3200 24 , , , 40436 3200 25 to to TO 40436 3200 26 take take VB 40436 3200 27 upon upon IN 40436 3200 28 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3200 29 the the DT 40436 3200 30 business business NN 40436 3200 31 of of IN 40436 3200 32 administration administration NN 40436 3200 33 -- -- : 40436 3200 34 an an DT 40436 3200 35 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 3200 36 admirer admirer NN 40436 3200 37 must must MD 40436 3200 38 find find VB 40436 3200 39 some some DT 40436 3200 40 decent decent JJ 40436 3200 41 pretence pretence NN 40436 3200 42 to to TO 40436 3200 43 colour colour VB 40436 3200 44 the the DT 40436 3200 45 refusal refusal NN 40436 3200 46 . . . 40436 3201 1 Such such PDT 40436 3201 2 a a DT 40436 3201 3 pretence pretence NN 40436 3201 4 is be VBZ 40436 3201 5 found find VBN 40436 3201 6 for for IN 40436 3201 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3201 8 in in IN 40436 3201 9 the the DT 40436 3201 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3201 11 : : : 40436 3201 12 " " `` 40436 3201 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3201 14 am be VBP 40436 3201 15 not not RB 40436 3201 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3201 17 own own JJ 40436 3201 18 master master NN 40436 3201 19 on on IN 40436 3201 20 this this DT 40436 3201 21 point point NN 40436 3201 22 . . . 40436 3202 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3202 2 am be VBP 40436 3202 3 the the DT 40436 3202 4 instrument instrument NN 40436 3202 5 of of IN 40436 3202 6 a a DT 40436 3202 7 divine divine JJ 40436 3202 8 ally ally NN 40436 3202 9 , , , 40436 3202 10 without without IN 40436 3202 11 whose whose WP$ 40436 3202 12 active active JJ 40436 3202 13 working working NN 40436 3202 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3202 15 can can MD 40436 3202 16 accomplish accomplish VB 40436 3202 17 nothing nothing NN 40436 3202 18 : : : 40436 3202 19 who who WP 40436 3202 20 forbids forbid VBZ 40436 3202 21 altogether altogether RB 40436 3202 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3202 23 teaching teaching NN 40436 3202 24 of of IN 40436 3202 25 one one CD 40436 3202 26 man man NN 40436 3202 27 -- -- : 40436 3202 28 tolerates tolerate NNS 40436 3202 29 , , , 40436 3202 30 without without IN 40436 3202 31 assisting assist VBG 40436 3202 32 , , , 40436 3202 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3202 34 unavailing unavaile VBG 40436 3202 35 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3202 36 to to IN 40436 3202 37 another another DT 40436 3202 38 -- -- : 40436 3202 39 assists assist NNS 40436 3202 40 efficaciously efficaciously RB 40436 3202 41 in in IN 40436 3202 42 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3202 43 teaching teaching NN 40436 3202 44 of of IN 40436 3202 45 a a DT 40436 3202 46 third third JJ 40436 3202 47 , , , 40436 3202 48 in in IN 40436 3202 49 which which WDT 40436 3202 50 case case NN 40436 3202 51 alone alone RB 40436 3202 52 the the DT 40436 3202 53 pupil pupil NN 40436 3202 54 receives receive VBZ 40436 3202 55 any any DT 40436 3202 56 real real JJ 40436 3202 57 benefit benefit NN 40436 3202 58 . . . 40436 3203 1 The the DT 40436 3203 2 assistance assistance NN 40436 3203 3 of of IN 40436 3203 4 this this DT 40436 3203 5 divine divine JJ 40436 3203 6 ally ally NN 40436 3203 7 is be VBZ 40436 3203 8 given give VBN 40436 3203 9 or or CC 40436 3203 10 withheld withhold VBN 40436 3203 11 according accord VBG 40436 3203 12 to to IN 40436 3203 13 motives motive NNS 40436 3203 14 of of IN 40436 3203 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3203 16 own own JJ 40436 3203 17 , , , 40436 3203 18 which which WDT 40436 3203 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3203 20 can can MD 40436 3203 21 not not RB 40436 3203 22 even even RB 40436 3203 23 foretell foretell VB 40436 3203 24 , , , 40436 3203 25 much much RB 40436 3203 26 less less JJR 40436 3203 27 influence influence NN 40436 3203 28 . . . 40436 3204 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3204 2 should should MD 40436 3204 3 deceive deceive VB 40436 3204 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3204 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 3204 6 if if IN 40436 3204 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3204 8 undertook undertake VBD 40436 3204 9 to to TO 40436 3204 10 teach teach VB 40436 3204 11 , , , 40436 3204 12 when when WRB 40436 3204 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3204 14 can can MD 40436 3204 15 not not RB 40436 3204 16 tell tell VB 40436 3204 17 whether whether IN 40436 3204 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3204 19 shall shall MD 40436 3204 20 do do VB 40436 3204 21 good good NN 40436 3204 22 or or CC 40436 3204 23 harm harm VB 40436 3204 24 . . . 40436 3204 25 " " '' 40436 3205 1 The the DT 40436 3205 2 reply reply NN 40436 3205 3 of of IN 40436 3205 4 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3205 5 meets meet VBZ 40436 3205 6 this this DT 40436 3205 7 scruple scruple NN 40436 3205 8 . . . 40436 3206 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3206 2 asks ask VBZ 40436 3206 3 permission permission NN 40436 3206 4 to to TO 40436 3206 5 make make VB 40436 3206 6 the the DT 40436 3206 7 experiment experiment NN 40436 3206 8 , , , 40436 3206 9 and and CC 40436 3206 10 promises promise VBZ 40436 3206 11 to to TO 40436 3206 12 propitiate propitiate VB 40436 3206 13 the the DT 40436 3206 14 divine divine JJ 40436 3206 15 auxiliary auxiliary JJ 40436 3206 16 by by IN 40436 3206 17 prayer prayer NN 40436 3206 18 and and CC 40436 3206 19 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 3206 20 ; ; , 40436 3206 21 under under IN 40436 3206 22 which which WDT 40436 3206 23 reserve reserve NN 40436 3206 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3206 25 gives give VBZ 40436 3206 26 consent consent NN 40436 3206 27 . . . 40436 3207 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3207 2 Side side NN 40436 3207 3 - - HYPH 40436 3207 4 note note NN 40436 3207 5 : : : 40436 3207 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3207 7 does do VBZ 40436 3207 8 not not RB 40436 3207 9 always always RB 40436 3207 10 , , , 40436 3207 11 nor nor CC 40436 3207 12 in in IN 40436 3207 13 other other JJ 40436 3207 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3207 15 , , , 40436 3207 16 allude allude VB 40436 3207 17 to to IN 40436 3207 18 the the DT 40436 3207 19 divine divine JJ 40436 3207 20 sign sign NN 40436 3207 21 in in IN 40436 3207 22 the the DT 40436 3207 23 same same JJ 40436 3207 24 way way NN 40436 3207 25 . . . 40436 3208 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3208 2 character character NN 40436 3208 3 and and CC 40436 3208 4 working work VBG 40436 3208 5 essentially essentially RB 40436 3208 6 impenetrable impenetrable JJ 40436 3208 7 . . . 40436 3209 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3209 2 a a DT 40436 3209 3 privileged privileged JJ 40436 3209 4 person person NN 40436 3209 5 . . . 40436 3209 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3210 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3210 2 is be VBZ 40436 3210 3 in in IN 40436 3210 4 this this DT 40436 3210 5 way way NN 40436 3210 6 that that WDT 40436 3210 7 the the DT 40436 3210 8 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3210 9 or or CC 40436 3210 10 divine divine JJ 40436 3210 11 auxiliary auxiliary JJ 40436 3210 12 serves serve VBZ 40436 3210 13 the the DT 40436 3210 14 purpose purpose NN 40436 3210 15 of of IN 40436 3210 16 reconciling reconcile VBG 40436 3210 17 what what WP 40436 3210 18 would would MD 40436 3210 19 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 3210 20 be be VB 40436 3210 21 an an DT 40436 3210 22 inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 3210 23 in in IN 40436 3210 24 the the DT 40436 3210 25 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 3210 26 of of IN 40436 3210 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3210 28 . . . 40436 3211 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3211 2 mean mean VBP 40436 3211 3 , , , 40436 3211 4 that that IN 40436 3211 5 such such JJ 40436 3211 6 is be VBZ 40436 3211 7 the the DT 40436 3211 8 purpose purpose NN 40436 3211 9 served serve VBN 40436 3211 10 in in IN 40436 3211 11 _ _ NNP 40436 3211 12 this this DT 40436 3211 13 _ _ NNP 40436 3211 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3211 15 : : : 40436 3211 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3211 17 know know VBP 40436 3211 18 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 3211 19 that that IN 40436 3211 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3211 21 deals deal NNS 40436 3211 22 with with IN 40436 3211 23 the the DT 40436 3211 24 case case NN 40436 3211 25 differently differently RB 40436 3211 26 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 3211 27 : : : 40436 3211 28 but but CC 40436 3211 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3211 30 am be VBP 40436 3211 31 not not RB 40436 3211 32 bound bind VBN 40436 3211 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3211 34 as as IN 40436 3211 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3211 36 have have VBP 40436 3211 37 said say VBN 40436 3211 38 more more JJR 40436 3211 39 than than IN 40436 3211 40 once once RB 40436 3211 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3211 42 to to TO 40436 3211 43 force force VB 40436 3211 44 upon upon IN 40436 3211 45 all all PDT 40436 3211 46 the the DT 40436 3211 47 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3211 48 one one CD 40436 3211 49 and and CC 40436 3211 50 the the DT 40436 3211 51 same same JJ 40436 3211 52 point point NN 40436 3211 53 of of IN 40436 3211 54 view view NN 40436 3211 55 . . . 40436 3212 1 That that IN 40436 3212 2 the the DT 40436 3212 3 agency agency NN 40436 3212 4 of of IN 40436 3212 5 the the DT 40436 3212 6 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3212 7 was be VBD 40436 3212 8 often often RB 40436 3212 9 and and CC 40436 3212 10 in in IN 40436 3212 11 the the DT 40436 3212 12 most most RBS 40436 3212 13 important important JJ 40436 3212 14 cases case NNS 40436 3212 15 , , , 40436 3212 16 essentially essentially RB 40436 3212 17 undiscoverable undiscoverable JJ 40436 3212 18 and and CC 40436 3212 19 unpredictable unpredictable JJ 40436 3212 20 , , , 40436 3212 21 and and CC 40436 3212 22 that that IN 40436 3212 23 in in IN 40436 3212 24 such such JJ 40436 3212 25 cases case NNS 40436 3212 26 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3212 27 might may MD 40436 3212 28 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 3212 29 be be VB 40436 3212 30 prevailed prevail VBN 40436 3212 31 on on RP 40436 3212 32 to to TO 40436 3212 33 give give VB 40436 3212 34 special special JJ 40436 3212 35 warnings warning NNS 40436 3212 36 to to IN 40436 3212 37 favoured favoured JJ 40436 3212 38 persons person NNS 40436 3212 39 -- -- : 40436 3212 40 were be VBD 40436 3212 41 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 3212 42 which which WDT 40436 3212 43 the the DT 40436 3212 44 historical historical JJ 40436 3212 45 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3212 46 in in IN 40436 3212 47 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3212 48 asserts assert VBZ 40436 3212 49 with with IN 40436 3212 50 emphasis emphasis NN 40436 3212 51 . . . 40436 3213 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3213 2 27 27 CD 40436 3213 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3213 4 The the DT 40436 3213 5 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3213 6 of of IN 40436 3213 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3213 8 was be VBD 40436 3213 9 believed believe VBN 40436 3213 10 , , , 40436 3213 11 both both CC 40436 3213 12 by by IN 40436 3213 13 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3213 14 and and CC 40436 3213 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3213 16 friends friend NNS 40436 3213 17 , , , 40436 3213 18 to to TO 40436 3213 19 be be VB 40436 3213 20 a a DT 40436 3213 21 special special JJ 40436 3213 22 privilege privilege NN 40436 3213 23 and and CC 40436 3213 24 an an DT 40436 3213 25 extreme extreme JJ 40436 3213 26 case case NN 40436 3213 27 of of IN 40436 3213 28 divine divine JJ 40436 3213 29 favour favour NN 40436 3213 30 and and CC 40436 3213 31 communication communication NN 40436 3213 32 to to IN 40436 3213 33 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3213 34 . . . 40436 3214 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3214 2 28 28 CD 40436 3214 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3214 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3214 5 was be VBD 40436 3214 6 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 3214 7 applicable applicable JJ 40436 3214 8 to to IN 40436 3214 9 the the DT 40436 3214 10 scope scope NN 40436 3214 11 of of IN 40436 3214 12 the the DT 40436 3214 13 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3214 14 , , , 40436 3214 15 though though IN 40436 3214 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3214 17 might may MD 40436 3214 18 not not RB 40436 3214 19 choose choose VB 40436 3214 20 always always RB 40436 3214 21 to to TO 40436 3214 22 make make VB 40436 3214 23 the the DT 40436 3214 24 same same JJ 40436 3214 25 employment employment NN 40436 3214 26 of of IN 40436 3214 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3214 28 . . . 40436 3215 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3215 2 is be VBZ 40436 3215 3 used use VBN 40436 3215 4 in in IN 40436 3215 5 the the DT 40436 3215 6 same same JJ 40436 3215 7 general general JJ 40436 3215 8 way way NN 40436 3215 9 in in IN 40436 3215 10 the the DT 40436 3215 11 Theætêtus;[29 Theætêtus;[29 NNP 40436 3215 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3215 13 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 3215 14 with with IN 40436 3215 15 less less JJR 40436 3215 16 expansion expansion NN 40436 3215 17 , , , 40436 3215 18 and and CC 40436 3215 19 blended blend VBD 40436 3215 20 with with IN 40436 3215 21 another another DT 40436 3215 22 analogy analogy NN 40436 3215 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3215 24 that that DT 40436 3215 25 of of IN 40436 3215 26 the the DT 40436 3215 27 mid mid NN 40436 3215 28 - - NN 40436 3215 29 wife wife NN 40436 3215 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3215 31 which which WDT 40436 3215 32 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 3215 33 a a DT 40436 3215 34 considerable considerable JJ 40436 3215 35 difference difference NN 40436 3215 36 . . . 40436 3216 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3216 2 30 30 CD 40436 3216 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3216 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3216 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3216 6 27 27 CD 40436 3216 7 : : : 40436 3216 8 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 3216 9 . . . 40436 3217 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 3217 2 . . . 40436 3218 1 i. i. NNP 40436 3219 1 1 1 CD 40436 3219 2 , , , 40436 3219 3 8 8 CD 40436 3219 4 - - SYM 40436 3219 5 9 9 CD 40436 3219 6 - - HYPH 40436 3219 7 19 19 CD 40436 3219 8 . . . 40436 3220 1 Euripid Euripid NNP 40436 3220 2 . . . 40436 3221 1 Hecub Hecub NNP 40436 3221 2 . . . 40436 3222 1 944 944 CD 40436 3222 2 . . . 40436 3223 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3223 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3223 3 : : : 40436 3223 4 phu phu NNP 40436 3223 5 / / SYM 40436 3223 6 rousi rousi NNP 40436 3223 7 d d NNP 40436 3223 8 ' ' '' 40436 3223 9 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 3223 10 theoi\ theoi\ NNP 40436 3223 11 pa pa NNP 40436 3223 12 / / SYM 40436 3223 13 lin lin NNP 40436 3223 14 te te NNP 40436 3223 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3223 16 pro pro NNP 40436 3223 17 / / SYM 40436 3223 18 sô sô NNP 40436 3223 19 , , , 40436 3223 20 taragmo\n taragmo\n ADD 40436 3223 21 e)ntithe e)ntithe NNP 40436 3223 22 / / SYM 40436 3223 23 ntes nte NNS 40436 3223 24 , , , 40436 3223 25 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3223 26 a)gnôsi a)gnôsi NNS 40436 3223 27 / / SYM 40436 3223 28 a| a| NN 40436 3223 29 se se NNP 40436 3223 30 / / SYM 40436 3223 31 bômen bômen NNP 40436 3223 32 au)tou au)tou NNP 40436 3223 33 / / SYM 40436 3223 34 s s NNP 40436 3223 35 . . . 40436 3223 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3223 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3224 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3224 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3224 3 28 28 CD 40436 3224 4 : : : 40436 3224 5 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 3224 6 . . . 40436 3225 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 3225 2 . . . 40436 3226 1 iv iv XX 40436 3226 2 . . . 40436 3227 1 3 3 CD 40436 3227 2 , , , 40436 3227 3 12 12 CD 40436 3227 4 . . . 40436 3227 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3228 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3228 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3228 3 29 29 CD 40436 3228 4 : : : 40436 3228 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3228 6 , , , 40436 3228 7 Theætêt Theætêt NNP 40436 3228 8 . . . 40436 3229 1 150 150 CD 40436 3229 2 D D NNP 40436 3229 3 - - HYPH 40436 3229 4 E. e. NN 40436 3229 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3229 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3229 7 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3229 8 30 30 CD 40436 3229 9 : : : 40436 3229 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3229 11 , , , 40436 3229 12 Apolog Apolog NNP 40436 3229 13 . . . 40436 3230 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 3230 2 . . . 40436 3231 1 33 33 CD 40436 3231 2 C. C. NNP 40436 3231 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3231 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3231 5 : : : 40436 3231 6 e)moi\ e)moi\ NNP 40436 3231 7 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3231 8 tou tou NNP 40436 3231 9 = = NNP 40436 3231 10 to to IN 40436 3231 11 , , , 40436 3231 12 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3231 13 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 3231 14 phêmi phêmi VBD 40436 3231 15 , , , 40436 3231 16 proste proste VBP 40436 3231 17 / / SYM 40436 3231 18 taktai taktai NNP 40436 3231 19 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 3231 20 toou= toou= NN 40436 3231 21 theou= theou= JJ 40436 3231 22 pra pra NNP 40436 3231 23 / / SYM 40436 3231 24 ttein ttein NNP 40436 3231 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3231 26 e)k e)k NNP 40436 3231 27 manteiô manteiô NNP 40436 3231 28 = = SYM 40436 3231 29 n n NNP 40436 3231 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3231 31 e)x e)x NNP 40436 3231 32 e)nupni e)nupni NNP 40436 3231 33 / / SYM 40436 3231 34 ôn ôn NNP 40436 3231 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3231 36 panti\ panti\ NNP 40436 3231 37 tro tro NNP 40436 3231 38 / / SYM 40436 3231 39 pô| pô| NNP 40436 3231 40 , , , 40436 3231 41 ô(=|pe ô(=|pe NN 40436 3231 42 / / SYM 40436 3231 43 r r NNP 40436 3231 44 ti ti NNP 40436 3231 45 / / SYM 40436 3231 46 s s NNP 40436 3231 47 pote pote NNP 40436 3231 48 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3231 49 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 3231 50 thei thei NNP 40436 3231 51 / / , 40436 3231 52 a a DT 40436 3231 53 moio moio NNP 40436 3231 54 / / SYM 40436 3231 55 ra ra NNP 40436 3231 56 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 3231 57 / / SYM 40436 3231 58 pô| pô| NNP 40436 3231 59 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3231 60 o(tiou o(tiou NNP 40436 3231 61 = = SYM 40436 3231 62 n n CC 40436 3231 63 prose prose NNP 40436 3231 64 / / SYM 40436 3231 65 taxe taxe NN 40436 3231 66 pra pra NNP 40436 3231 67 / / SYM 40436 3231 68 ttein ttein NN 40436 3231 69 . . . 40436 3231 70 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3232 1 40 40 CD 40436 3232 2 A. a. NN 40436 3233 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3233 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3233 3 : : : 40436 3233 4 ê ê NNP 40436 3233 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3233 6 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3233 7 ei)ôthui ei)ôthui NN 40436 3233 8 = = NFP 40436 3233 9 a/ a/ NNP 40436 3233 10 moi moi NNP 40436 3233 11 mantikê\ mantikê\ NNP 40436 3233 12 ê ê NNP 40436 3233 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3233 14 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3233 15 daimoni daimoni NNP 40436 3233 16 / / SYM 40436 3233 17 ou ou NNP 40436 3233 18 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3233 19 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3233 20 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 3233 21 pro pro NN 40436 3233 22 / / SYM 40436 3233 23 sthen sthen NNS 40436 3233 24 _ _ NNP 40436 3233 25 chro chro NNP 40436 3233 26 / / SYM 40436 3233 27 nô| nô| NNP 40436 3233 28 panti\ panti\ NNP 40436 3233 29 pa pa NNP 40436 3233 30 / / SYM 40436 3233 31 nu nu NNP 40436 3233 32 puknê\ puknê\ NN 40436 3233 33 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 3233 34 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 3233 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3233 36 pa pa NNP 40436 3233 37 / / SYM 40436 3233 38 nu nu NNP 40436 3233 39 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 3233 40 smikroi smikroi NNP 40436 3233 41 = = SYM 40436 3233 42 s s XX 40436 3233 43 e)nantioume e)nantioume NNP 40436 3233 44 / / SYM 40436 3233 45 nê nê NNP 40436 3233 46 _ _ NNP 40436 3233 47 , , , 40436 3233 48 ei)/ ei)/ NNP 40436 3233 49 ti ti IN 40436 3233 50 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3233 51 / / SYM 40436 3233 52 lloimi lloimi NNP 40436 3233 53 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 3233 54 o)rthô o)rthô NNS 40436 3233 55 = = SYM 40436 3233 56 s s NNP 40436 3233 57 pra pra NNP 40436 3233 58 / / SYM 40436 3233 59 xein xein NNP 40436 3233 60 . . . 40436 3233 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3234 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 3234 2 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3234 3 , , , 40436 3234 4 Memor Memor NNP 40436 3234 5 . . . 40436 3235 1 iv iv XX 40436 3235 2 . . . 40436 3236 1 8 8 CD 40436 3236 2 , , , 40436 3236 3 5 5 CD 40436 3236 4 ; ; : 40436 3236 5 Apol Apol NNP 40436 3236 6 . . . 40436 3237 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 3237 2 . . . 40436 3238 1 c. c. NNP 40436 3239 1 13 13 CD 40436 3239 2 . . . 40436 3239 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3240 1 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 40436 3240 2 . . . 40436 3241 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3241 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3241 3 : : : 40436 3241 4 To\ to\ NN 40436 3241 5 daimo daimo NN 40436 3241 6 / / SYM 40436 3241 7 nion nion NNP 40436 3241 8 sêmei sêmei NNP 40436 3241 9 = = SYM 40436 3241 10 on on IN 40436 3241 11 . . . 40436 3241 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3242 1 Here here RB 40436 3242 2 is be VBZ 40436 3242 3 one one CD 40436 3242 4 of of IN 40436 3242 5 the the DT 40436 3242 6 points point NNS 40436 3242 7 most most RBS 40436 3242 8 insisted insist VBN 40436 3242 9 on on IN 40436 3242 10 by by IN 40436 3242 11 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3242 12 and and CC 40436 3242 13 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3242 14 , , , 40436 3242 15 as as IN 40436 3242 16 proving prove VBG 40436 3242 17 that that IN 40436 3242 18 the the DT 40436 3242 19 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3242 20 is be VBZ 40436 3242 21 not not RB 40436 3242 22 the the DT 40436 3242 23 work work NN 40436 3242 24 of of IN 40436 3242 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3242 26 . . . 40436 3243 1 These these DT 40436 3243 2 critics critic NNS 40436 3243 3 affirm affirm VBP 40436 3243 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3243 5 to to TO 40436 3243 6 use use VB 40436 3243 7 the the DT 40436 3243 8 language language NN 40436 3243 9 of of IN 40436 3243 10 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3243 11 , , , 40436 3243 12 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 3243 13 . . . 40436 3244 1 p. p. NN 40436 3244 2 220 220 CD 40436 3244 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3244 4 " " '' 40436 3244 5 Quam Quam NNP 40436 3244 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3244 7 alias alia NNS 40436 3244 8 de de FW 40436 3244 9 Socratis socratis JJ 40436 3244 10 dæmonio dæmonio NN 40436 3244 11 prodidit prodidit NN 40436 3244 12 sententiam sententiam NN 40436 3244 13 , , , 40436 3244 14 ea ea NNP 40436 3244 15 longissimè longissimè NNP 40436 3244 16 recedit recedit NNP 40436 3244 17 ab ab NNP 40436 3244 18 illâ illâ NNP 40436 3244 19 ratione ratione NNP 40436 3244 20 , , , 40436 3244 21 quæ quæ NNP 40436 3244 22 in in IN 40436 3244 23 hoc hoc FW 40436 3244 24 sermone sermone NN 40436 3244 25 exposita exposita NNP 40436 3244 26 est est NNP 40436 3244 27 " " '' 40436 3244 28 . . . 40436 3245 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3245 2 says say VBZ 40436 3245 3 that that IN 40436 3245 4 the the DT 40436 3245 5 representation representation NN 40436 3245 6 of of IN 40436 3245 7 the the DT 40436 3245 8 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3245 9 of of IN 40436 3245 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3245 11 , , , 40436 3245 12 given give VBN 40436 3245 13 in in IN 40436 3245 14 the the DT 40436 3245 15 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3245 16 , , , 40436 3245 17 has have VBZ 40436 3245 18 been be VBN 40436 3245 19 copied copy VBN 40436 3245 20 from from IN 40436 3245 21 a a DT 40436 3245 22 passage passage NN 40436 3245 23 in in IN 40436 3245 24 the the DT 40436 3245 25 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 3245 26 , , , 40436 3245 27 by by IN 40436 3245 28 an an DT 40436 3245 29 imitator imitator NN 40436 3245 30 who who WP 40436 3245 31 has have VBZ 40436 3245 32 not not RB 40436 3245 33 understood understand VBN 40436 3245 34 the the DT 40436 3245 35 passage passage NN 40436 3245 36 , , , 40436 3245 37 p. p. NN 40436 3245 38 150 150 CD 40436 3245 39 , , , 40436 3245 40 D D NNP 40436 3245 41 , , , 40436 3245 42 E. E. NNP 40436 3245 43 But but CC 40436 3245 44 Socher Socher NNP 40436 3245 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3245 46 p. p. NN 40436 3245 47 97 97 CD 40436 3245 48 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3245 49 appears appear VBZ 40436 3245 50 to to IN 40436 3245 51 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3245 52 to to TO 40436 3245 53 have have VB 40436 3245 54 shown show VBN 40436 3245 55 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 40436 3245 56 , , , 40436 3245 57 that that IN 40436 3245 58 there there EX 40436 3245 59 is be VBZ 40436 3245 60 no no DT 40436 3245 61 such such JJ 40436 3245 62 material material JJ 40436 3245 63 difference difference NN 40436 3245 64 as as IN 40436 3245 65 these these DT 40436 3245 66 critics critic NNS 40436 3245 67 affirm affirm VBP 40436 3245 68 between between IN 40436 3245 69 this this DT 40436 3245 70 passage passage NN 40436 3245 71 of of IN 40436 3245 72 the the DT 40436 3245 73 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 3245 74 and and CC 40436 3245 75 the the DT 40436 3245 76 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3245 77 . . . 40436 3246 1 In in IN 40436 3246 2 the the DT 40436 3246 3 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 3246 4 , , , 40436 3246 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3246 6 declares declare VBZ 40436 3246 7 , , , 40436 3246 8 that that IN 40436 3246 9 none none NN 40436 3246 10 of of IN 40436 3246 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3246 12 companions companion NNS 40436 3246 13 learnt learn VBD 40436 3246 14 any any DT 40436 3246 15 thing thing NN 40436 3246 16 from from IN 40436 3246 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3246 18 , , , 40436 3246 19 but but CC 40436 3246 20 that that IN 40436 3246 21 all all DT 40436 3246 22 of of IN 40436 3246 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3246 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3246 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3246 26 : : : 40436 3246 27 oi(=sper oi(=sper $ 40436 3246 28 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 3246 29 o o NNP 40436 3246 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3246 31 theo\s theo\s NNP 40436 3246 32 parei parei NNP 40436 3246 33 / / SYM 40436 3246 34 kê| kê| NNP 40436 3246 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3246 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3246 37 the the DT 40436 3246 38 very very RB 40436 3246 39 same same JJ 40436 3246 40 term term NN 40436 3246 41 is be VBZ 40436 3246 42 used use VBN 40436 3246 43 at at IN 40436 3246 44 the the DT 40436 3246 45 close close NN 40436 3246 46 of of IN 40436 3246 47 the the DT 40436 3246 48 Theagês--131 Theagês--131 NNS 40436 3246 49 A A NNP 40436 3246 50 , , , 40436 3246 51 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3246 52 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3246 53 : : : 40436 3246 54 e)a\n e)a\n -RRB- 40436 3246 55 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3246 56 parei parei NN 40436 3246 57 / / SYM 40436 3246 58 kê| kê| NNP 40436 3246 59 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 3246 60 = = SYM 40436 3246 61 n n LS 40436 3246 62 -- -- : 40436 3246 63 to\ to\ NN 40436 3246 64 daimo daimo NN 40436 3246 65 / / SYM 40436 3246 66 nion nion NN 40436 3246 67 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3246 68 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3246 69 made make VBD 40436 3246 70 astonishing astonishing JJ 40436 3246 71 progress progress NN 40436 3246 72 and and CC 40436 3246 73 improvement improvement NN 40436 3246 74 in in IN 40436 3246 75 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3246 76 company company NN 40436 3246 77 . . . 40436 3247 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3247 2 says say VBZ 40436 3247 3 , , , 40436 3247 4 " " `` 40436 3247 5 Itaque Itaque NNP 40436 3247 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3247 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3247 8 : : : 40436 3247 9 o o NN 40436 3247 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3247 11 theo\s theo\s NNP 40436 3247 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3247 13 , , , 40436 3247 14 qui qui NNP 40436 3247 15 ibi ibi NNP 40436 3247 16 memoratur memoratur NNP 40436 3247 17 , , , 40436 3247 18 non non AFX 40436 3247 19 est est JJ 40436 3247 20 Socratis Socratis NNP 40436 3247 21 dæmonium dæmonium NN 40436 3247 22 , , , 40436 3247 23 sed sed NNP 40436 3247 24 potius potius NNP 40436 3247 25 deus deus NNP 40436 3247 26 _ _ NNP 40436 3247 27 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 3247 28 _ _ NNP 40436 3247 29 sors sors NNP 40436 3247 30 divina divina NNP 40436 3247 31 . . . 40436 3248 1 Quod quod JJ 40436 3248 2 non non NNP 40436 3248 3 perspiciens perspicien NNS 40436 3248 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3248 5 noster noster NN 40436 3248 6 tenebrio tenebrio NN 40436 3248 7 _ _ NNP 40436 3248 8 protenus protenus NN 40436 3248 9 illud illud NNP 40436 3248 10 dæmonium dæmonium NN 40436 3248 11 , , , 40436 3248 12 quod quod NN 40436 3248 13 Socrates Socrates NNP 40436 3248 14 sibi sibi NNP 40436 3248 15 semper semper NNP 40436 3248 16 adesse adesse NNP 40436 3248 17 dictitabat dictitabat NNP 40436 3248 18 , , , 40436 3248 19 ad ad NN 40436 3248 20 eum eum NN 40436 3248 21 dignitatis dignitatis NNP 40436 3248 22 et et NNP 40436 3248 23 potentiæ potentiæ NNS 40436 3248 24 gradum gradum NNP 40436 3248 25 evexit evexit NNP 40436 3248 26 , , , 40436 3248 27 ut ut UH 40436 3248 28 , , , 40436 3248 29 & & CC 40436 3248 30 c. c. NNP 40436 3248 31 " " `` 40436 3248 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3248 33 agree agree VBP 40436 3248 34 with with IN 40436 3248 35 Socher Socher NNP 40436 3248 36 in in IN 40436 3248 37 thinking think VBG 40436 3248 38 that that IN 40436 3248 39 the the DT 40436 3248 40 phrase phrase NN 40436 3248 41 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3248 42 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3248 43 : : : 40436 3248 44 o o NN 40436 3248 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3248 46 theo\s theo\s NNP 40436 3248 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3248 48 in in IN 40436 3248 49 the the DT 40436 3248 50 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 3248 51 has have VBZ 40436 3248 52 substantially substantially RB 40436 3248 53 the the DT 40436 3248 54 same same JJ 40436 3248 55 meaning meaning NN 40436 3248 56 as as IN 40436 3248 57 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3248 58 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3248 59 : : : 40436 3248 60 to\ to\ NN 40436 3248 61 daimo daimo NN 40436 3248 62 / / SYM 40436 3248 63 nion nion NN 40436 3248 64 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3248 65 in in IN 40436 3248 66 the the DT 40436 3248 67 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3248 68 . . . 40436 3249 1 Both both DT 40436 3249 2 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3249 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3249 4 Notes note NNS 40436 3249 5 on on IN 40436 3249 6 the the DT 40436 3249 7 Apology apology NN 40436 3249 8 , , , 40436 3249 9 p. p. NN 40436 3249 10 432 432 CD 40436 3249 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3249 12 and and CC 40436 3249 13 Ast Ast NNP 40436 3249 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3249 15 p. p. NN 40436 3249 16 482 482 CD 40436 3249 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3249 18 , , , 40436 3249 19 have have VBP 40436 3249 20 notes note NNS 40436 3249 21 on on IN 40436 3249 22 the the DT 40436 3249 23 phrase phrase NN 40436 3249 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3249 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3249 26 : : : 40436 3249 27 to\ to\ NNP 40436 3249 28 daimo daimo NNP 40436 3249 29 / / SYM 40436 3249 30 nion]--and nion]--and NNP 40436 3249 31 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3249 32 think think VBP 40436 3249 33 the the DT 40436 3249 34 note note NN 40436 3249 35 of of IN 40436 3249 36 Ast Ast NNP 40436 3249 37 is be VBZ 40436 3249 38 the the DT 40436 3249 39 more more RBR 40436 3249 40 instructive instructive JJ 40436 3249 41 of of IN 40436 3249 42 the the DT 40436 3249 43 two two CD 40436 3249 44 . . . 40436 3250 1 In in IN 40436 3250 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3250 3 and and CC 40436 3250 4 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3250 5 , , , 40436 3250 6 the the DT 40436 3250 7 words word NNS 40436 3250 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3250 9 Greek greek JJ 40436 3250 10 : : : 40436 3250 11 to\ to\ NN 40436 3250 12 daimo daimo NN 40436 3250 13 / / SYM 40436 3250 14 nion nion NN 40436 3250 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3250 16 , , , 40436 3250 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3250 18 Greek greek JJ 40436 3250 19 : : : 40436 3250 20 to\ to\ NN 40436 3250 21 thei thei NN 40436 3250 22 = = NFP 40436 3250 23 on on RB 40436 3250 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3250 25 , , , 40436 3250 26 are be VBP 40436 3250 27 in in IN 40436 3250 28 many many JJ 40436 3250 29 cases case NNS 40436 3250 30 undistinguishable undistinguishable JJ 40436 3250 31 in in IN 40436 3250 32 meaning meaning NN 40436 3250 33 from from IN 40436 3250 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3250 35 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3250 36 : : : 40436 3250 37 o o NN 40436 3250 38 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3250 39 dai dai NNP 40436 3250 40 / / SYM 40436 3250 41 môn môn NNP 40436 3250 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3250 43 , , , 40436 3250 44 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3250 45 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3250 46 : : : 40436 3250 47 o o NN 40436 3250 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3250 49 theo theo NNP 40436 3250 50 / / SYM 40436 3250 51 s s NN 40436 3250 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3250 53 . . . 40436 3251 1 Compare compare VB 40436 3251 2 the the DT 40436 3251 3 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 3251 4 , , , 40436 3251 5 242 242 CD 40436 3251 6 E e NN 40436 3251 7 , , , 40436 3251 8 about about IN 40436 3251 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3251 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3251 11 : : : 40436 3251 12 theo\s theo\s ADD 40436 3251 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3251 14 and and CC 40436 3251 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3251 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3251 17 : : : 40436 3251 18 thei thei NN 40436 3251 19 = = SYM 40436 3251 20 o o NN 40436 3251 21 / / SYM 40436 3251 22 n n CC 40436 3251 23 ti ti NN 40436 3251 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3251 25 . . . 40436 3252 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3252 2 , , , 40436 3252 3 in in IN 40436 3252 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3252 5 argument argument NN 40436 3252 6 against against IN 40436 3252 7 Meletus Meletus NNP 40436 3252 8 in in IN 40436 3252 9 the the DT 40436 3252 10 Apology Apology NNP 40436 3252 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3252 12 p. p. NN 40436 3252 13 27 27 CD 40436 3252 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3252 15 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 3252 16 argues argue VBZ 40436 3252 17 that that IN 40436 3252 18 no no DT 40436 3252 19 man man NN 40436 3252 20 could could MD 40436 3252 21 believe believe VB 40436 3252 22 in in IN 40436 3252 23 any any DT 40436 3252 24 thing thing NN 40436 3252 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3252 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3252 27 : : : 40436 3252 28 daimo daimo NN 40436 3252 29 / / SYM 40436 3252 30 nion nion NN 40436 3252 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3252 32 , , , 40436 3252 33 without without IN 40436 3252 34 also also RB 40436 3252 35 believing believe VBG 40436 3252 36 in in IN 40436 3252 37 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3252 38 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3252 39 : : : 40436 3252 40 daimo daimo NNP 40436 3252 41 / / SYM 40436 3252 42 nes nes NNP 40436 3252 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3252 44 . . . 40436 3253 1 The the DT 40436 3253 2 special special JJ 40436 3253 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3253 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3253 5 : : : 40436 3253 6 thei thei NN 40436 3253 7 = = SYM 40436 3253 8 o o NN 40436 3253 9 / / SYM 40436 3253 10 n n CC 40436 3253 11 ti ti NNP 40436 3253 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3253 13 daimo daimo NNP 40436 3253 14 / / SYM 40436 3253 15 nion nion NN 40436 3253 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3253 17 Apol Apol NNP 40436 3253 18 . . . 40436 3254 1 p. p. NN 40436 3254 2 31 31 CD 40436 3254 3 C C NNP 40436 3254 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3254 5 , , , 40436 3254 6 which which WDT 40436 3254 7 presented present VBD 40436 3254 8 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 3254 9 in in IN 40436 3254 10 regard regard NN 40436 3254 11 to to IN 40436 3254 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3254 13 and and CC 40436 3254 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3254 15 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 3254 16 , , , 40436 3254 17 was be VBD 40436 3254 18 only only RB 40436 3254 19 one one CD 40436 3254 20 of of IN 40436 3254 21 the the DT 40436 3254 22 many many JJ 40436 3254 23 modes mode NNS 40436 3254 24 in in IN 40436 3254 25 which which WDT 40436 3254 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3254 27 as as IN 40436 3254 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3254 29 believed believe VBD 40436 3254 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3254 31 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3254 32 Greek greek NN 40436 3254 33 : : : 40436 3254 34 o o NN 40436 3254 35 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3254 36 theo theo NNP 40436 3254 37 / / SYM 40436 3254 38 s s NN 40436 3254 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3254 40 commanded command VBD 40436 3254 41 and and CC 40436 3254 42 stimulated stimulate VBD 40436 3254 43 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3254 44 to to TO 40436 3254 45 work work VB 40436 3254 46 upon upon IN 40436 3254 47 the the DT 40436 3254 48 minds mind NNS 40436 3254 49 of of IN 40436 3254 50 the the DT 40436 3254 51 Athenians:--[Greek Athenians:--[Greek NNP 40436 3254 52 : : : 40436 3254 53 e)moi\ e)moi\ NNP 40436 3254 54 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3254 55 tou tou NNP 40436 3254 56 = = NNP 40436 3254 57 to to IN 40436 3254 58 , , , 40436 3254 59 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3254 60 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 3254 61 phêmi phêmi VBD 40436 3254 62 , , , 40436 3254 63 proste proste VBP 40436 3254 64 / / SYM 40436 3254 65 taktai taktai NN 40436 3254 66 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 3254 67 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3254 68 theou= theou= NN 40436 3254 69 pra pra NNP 40436 3254 70 / / SYM 40436 3254 71 ttein ttein NNP 40436 3254 72 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3254 73 e)k e)k NNP 40436 3254 74 manteiô manteiô NNP 40436 3254 75 = = SYM 40436 3254 76 n n NNP 40436 3254 77 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3254 78 e)x e)x NNP 40436 3254 79 e)nupni e)nupni NNP 40436 3254 80 / / SYM 40436 3254 81 ôn ôn NNP 40436 3254 82 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3254 83 panti\ panti\ NNP 40436 3254 84 tro tro NNP 40436 3254 85 / / SYM 40436 3254 86 pô| pô| NNP 40436 3254 87 , , , 40436 3254 88 ô(=|pe ô(=|pe NN 40436 3254 89 / / SYM 40436 3254 90 r r NNP 40436 3254 91 ti ti NNP 40436 3254 92 / / SYM 40436 3254 93 s s NNP 40436 3254 94 pote pote NNP 40436 3254 95 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3254 96 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 3254 97 thei thei NNP 40436 3254 98 / / SYM 40436 3254 99 a a DT 40436 3254 100 moi moi NNP 40436 3254 101 = = SYM 40436 3254 102 ra ra NNP 40436 3254 103 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 3254 104 / / SYM 40436 3254 105 pô| pô| NNP 40436 3254 106 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3254 107 o(tiou o(tiou NNP 40436 3254 108 = = SYM 40436 3254 109 n n CC 40436 3254 110 prose prose NNP 40436 3254 111 / / SYM 40436 3254 112 taxe taxe NN 40436 3254 113 pra pra NNP 40436 3254 114 / / SYM 40436 3254 115 ttein ttein NN 40436 3254 116 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3254 117 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3254 118 Apol Apol NNP 40436 3254 119 . . . 40436 3255 1 p. p. NN 40436 3255 2 33 33 CD 40436 3255 3 C C NNP 40436 3255 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3255 5 . . . 40436 3256 1 So so RB 40436 3256 2 again again RB 40436 3256 3 in in IN 40436 3256 4 Apol Apol NNP 40436 3256 5 . . . 40436 3257 1 p. p. NN 40436 3257 2 40 40 CD 40436 3257 3 A a NN 40436 3257 4 , , , 40436 3257 5 B b NN 40436 3257 6 , , , 40436 3257 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3257 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3257 9 : : : 40436 3257 10 ê ê NNP 40436 3257 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3257 12 ei)ôthui ei)ôthui NNP 40436 3257 13 = = NFP 40436 3257 14 a/ a/ NNP 40436 3257 15 moi moi NNP 40436 3257 16 mantikê\ mantikê\ NNP 40436 3257 17 ê ê NNP 40436 3257 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3257 19 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3257 20 daimoni daimoni NNP 40436 3257 21 / / SYM 40436 3257 22 ou]--and ou]--and CD 40436 3257 23 four four CD 40436 3257 24 lines line NNS 40436 3257 25 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 3257 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3257 27 read read VBP 40436 3257 28 the the DT 40436 3257 29 very very RB 40436 3257 30 same same JJ 40436 3257 31 fact fact NN 40436 3257 32 intimated intimate VBN 40436 3257 33 in in IN 40436 3257 34 the the DT 40436 3257 35 words word NNS 40436 3257 36 , , , 40436 3257 37 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3257 38 Greek greek JJ 40436 3257 39 : : : 40436 3257 40 to\ to\ NN 40436 3257 41 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3257 42 theou= theou= NN 40436 3257 43 sêmei sêmei NN 40436 3257 44 = = SYM 40436 3257 45 on on RB 40436 3257 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3257 47 , , , 40436 3257 48 where where WRB 40436 3257 49 Sokratis Sokratis NNP 40436 3257 50 dæmonium dæmonium NN 40436 3257 51 -- -- : 40436 3257 52 and and CC 40436 3257 53 Deus Deus NNP 40436 3257 54 -- -- : 40436 3257 55 are be VBP 40436 3257 56 identified identify VBN 40436 3257 57 : : : 40436 3257 58 thus thus RB 40436 3257 59 refuting refute VBG 40436 3257 60 the the DT 40436 3257 61 argument argument NN 40436 3257 62 above above RB 40436 3257 63 cited cite VBN 40436 3257 64 from from IN 40436 3257 65 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3257 66 . . . 40436 3258 1 There there EX 40436 3258 2 is be VBZ 40436 3258 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 3258 4 no no DT 40436 3258 5 such such JJ 40436 3258 6 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40436 3258 7 , , , 40436 3258 8 in in IN 40436 3258 9 reference reference NN 40436 3258 10 to to IN 40436 3258 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3258 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3258 13 : : : 40436 3258 14 to\ to\ NN 40436 3258 15 daimo daimo NN 40436 3258 16 / / SYM 40436 3258 17 nion nion NN 40436 3258 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3258 19 , , , 40436 3258 20 as as IN 40436 3258 21 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3258 22 and and CC 40436 3258 23 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3258 24 contend contend VBP 40436 3258 25 for for IN 40436 3258 26 . . . 40436 3259 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3259 2 perceive perceive VBP 40436 3259 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 3259 4 this this DT 40436 3259 5 difference difference NN 40436 3259 6 between between IN 40436 3259 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3259 8 -- -- : 40436 3259 9 that that IN 40436 3259 10 in in IN 40436 3259 11 the the DT 40436 3259 12 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 3259 13 , , , 40436 3259 14 the the DT 40436 3259 15 simile simile NN 40436 3259 16 of of IN 40436 3259 17 the the DT 40436 3259 18 obstetric obstetric JJ 40436 3259 19 art art NN 40436 3259 20 is be VBZ 40436 3259 21 largely largely RB 40436 3259 22 employed employ VBN 40436 3259 23 , , , 40436 3259 24 while while IN 40436 3259 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3259 26 is be VBZ 40436 3259 27 not not RB 40436 3259 28 noticed notice VBN 40436 3259 29 in in IN 40436 3259 30 the the DT 40436 3259 31 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3259 32 . . . 40436 3260 1 But but CC 40436 3260 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3260 3 should should MD 40436 3260 4 impose impose VB 40436 3260 5 an an DT 40436 3260 6 unwarrantable unwarrantable JJ 40436 3260 7 restriction restriction NN 40436 3260 8 upon upon IN 40436 3260 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3260 10 's 's POS 40436 3260 11 fancy fancy NN 40436 3260 12 , , , 40436 3260 13 if if IN 40436 3260 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3260 15 hindered hinder VBD 40436 3260 16 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3260 17 from from IN 40436 3260 18 working work VBG 40436 3260 19 out out RP 40436 3260 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3260 21 variety variety NN 40436 3260 22 and and CC 40436 3260 23 exuberance exuberance NN 40436 3260 24 of of IN 40436 3260 25 metaphors metaphor NNS 40436 3260 26 , , , 40436 3260 27 and and CC 40436 3260 28 from from IN 40436 3260 29 accommodating accommodate VBG 40436 3260 30 each each DT 40436 3260 31 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3260 32 to to IN 40436 3260 33 the the DT 40436 3260 34 metaphor metaphor NN 40436 3260 35 predominant predominant NN 40436 3260 36 with with IN 40436 3260 37 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3260 38 at at IN 40436 3260 39 the the DT 40436 3260 40 time time NN 40436 3260 41 . . . 40436 3261 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 3261 2 , , , 40436 3261 3 in in IN 40436 3261 4 respect respect NN 40436 3261 5 to to IN 40436 3261 6 what what WP 40436 3261 7 is be VBZ 40436 3261 8 called call VBN 40436 3261 9 the the DT 40436 3261 10 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3261 11 of of IN 40436 3261 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3261 13 , , , 40436 3261 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3261 15 ought ought MD 40436 3261 16 hardly hardly RB 40436 3261 17 to to TO 40436 3261 18 expect expect VB 40436 3261 19 that that IN 40436 3261 20 either either DT 40436 3261 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3261 22 or or CC 40436 3261 23 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3261 24 would would MD 40436 3261 25 always always RB 40436 3261 26 be be VB 40436 3261 27 consistent consistent JJ 40436 3261 28 even even RB 40436 3261 29 with with IN 40436 3261 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3261 31 . . . 40436 3262 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3262 2 is be VBZ 40436 3262 3 unsafe unsafe JJ 40436 3262 4 for for IN 40436 3262 5 a a DT 40436 3262 6 modern modern JJ 40436 3262 7 critic critic NN 40436 3262 8 to to TO 40436 3262 9 determine determine VB 40436 3262 10 beforehand beforehand RB 40436 3262 11 , , , 40436 3262 12 by by IN 40436 3262 13 reason reason NN 40436 3262 14 or or CC 40436 3262 15 feelings feeling NNS 40436 3262 16 of of IN 40436 3262 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3262 18 own own JJ 40436 3262 19 , , , 40436 3262 20 in in IN 40436 3262 21 what what WDT 40436 3262 22 manner manner NN 40436 3262 23 either either CC 40436 3262 24 of of IN 40436 3262 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3262 26 would would MD 40436 3262 27 speak speak VB 40436 3262 28 upon upon IN 40436 3262 29 this this DT 40436 3262 30 mysterious mysterious JJ 40436 3262 31 subject subject NN 40436 3262 32 . . . 40436 3263 1 The the DT 40436 3263 2 belief belief NN 40436 3263 3 and and CC 40436 3263 4 feeling feeling NN 40436 3263 5 of of IN 40436 3263 6 a a DT 40436 3263 7 divine divine JJ 40436 3263 8 intervention intervention NN 40436 3263 9 was be VBD 40436 3263 10 very very RB 40436 3263 11 real real JJ 40436 3263 12 on on IN 40436 3263 13 the the DT 40436 3263 14 part part NN 40436 3263 15 of of IN 40436 3263 16 both both DT 40436 3263 17 , , , 40436 3263 18 but but CC 40436 3263 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3263 20 manner manner NN 40436 3263 21 of of IN 40436 3263 22 conceiving conceive VBG 40436 3263 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3263 24 might may MD 40436 3263 25 naturally naturally RB 40436 3263 26 fluctuate fluctuate VB 40436 3263 27 : : : 40436 3263 28 and and CC 40436 3263 29 there there EX 40436 3263 30 was be VBD 40436 3263 31 , , , 40436 3263 32 throughout throughout IN 40436 3263 33 all all PDT 40436 3263 34 the the DT 40436 3263 35 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 3263 36 of of IN 40436 3263 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3263 38 , , , 40436 3263 39 a a DT 40436 3263 40 mixture mixture NN 40436 3263 41 of of IN 40436 3263 42 the the DT 40436 3263 43 serious serious JJ 40436 3263 44 and and CC 40436 3263 45 the the DT 40436 3263 46 playful playful JJ 40436 3263 47 , , , 40436 3263 48 of of IN 40436 3263 49 the the DT 40436 3263 50 sublime sublime NN 40436 3263 51 and and CC 40436 3263 52 the the DT 40436 3263 53 eccentric eccentric JJ 40436 3263 54 , , , 40436 3263 55 of of IN 40436 3263 56 ratiocinative ratiocinative JJ 40436 3263 57 acuteness acuteness NN 40436 3263 58 with with IN 40436 3263 59 impulsive impulsive JJ 40436 3263 60 superstition superstition NN 40436 3263 61 -- -- : 40436 3263 62 which which WDT 40436 3263 63 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3263 64 is be VBZ 40436 3263 65 difficult difficult JJ 40436 3263 66 to to TO 40436 3263 67 bring bring VB 40436 3263 68 into into IN 40436 3263 69 harmonious harmonious JJ 40436 3263 70 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 3263 71 . . . 40436 3264 1 Such such JJ 40436 3264 2 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ 40436 3264 3 mixture mixture NN 40436 3264 4 is be VBZ 40436 3264 5 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 3264 6 described describe VBN 40436 3264 7 in in IN 40436 3264 8 the the DT 40436 3264 9 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3264 10 Symposium Symposium NNP 40436 3264 11 , , , 40436 3264 12 pp pp NNP 40436 3264 13 . . . 40436 3265 1 215 215 CD 40436 3265 2 - - SYM 40436 3265 3 222 222 CD 40436 3265 4 . . . 40436 3266 1 When when WRB 40436 3266 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3266 3 consider consider VBP 40436 3266 4 how how WRB 40436 3266 5 undefined undefined JJ 40436 3266 6 , , , 40436 3266 7 and and CC 40436 3266 8 undefinable undefinable JJ 40436 3266 9 , , , 40436 3266 10 the the DT 40436 3266 11 idea idea NN 40436 3266 12 of of IN 40436 3266 13 this this DT 40436 3266 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3266 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3266 16 : : : 40436 3266 17 daimo daimo NN 40436 3266 18 / / SYM 40436 3266 19 nion nion NN 40436 3266 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3266 21 was be VBD 40436 3266 22 , , , 40436 3266 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3266 24 can can MD 40436 3266 25 not not RB 40436 3266 26 wonder wonder VB 40436 3266 27 if if IN 40436 3266 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3266 29 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 3266 30 to to IN 40436 3266 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3266 32 different different JJ 40436 3266 33 workings working NNS 40436 3266 34 and and CC 40436 3266 35 manifestations manifestation NNS 40436 3266 36 at at IN 40436 3266 37 different different JJ 40436 3266 38 times time NNS 40436 3266 39 . . . 40436 3267 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3267 2 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 3267 3 that that IN 40436 3267 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3267 5 is be VBZ 40436 3267 6 made make VBN 40436 3267 7 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 3267 8 in in IN 40436 3267 9 the the DT 40436 3267 10 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3267 11 : : : 40436 3267 12 and and CC 40436 3267 13 Kühner Kühner NNP 40436 3267 14 declares declare VBZ 40436 3267 15 that that IN 40436 3267 16 Plutarch plutarch NN 40436 3267 17 makes make VBZ 40436 3267 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3267 19 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 3267 20 , , , 40436 3267 21 in in IN 40436 3267 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3267 23 treatise treatise NN 40436 3267 24 De De NNP 40436 3267 25 Genio Genio NNP 40436 3267 26 Sokratia Sokratia NNP 40436 3267 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3267 28 Comm Comm NNP 40436 3267 29 . . . 40436 3268 1 ad ad NN 40436 3268 2 . . . 40436 3269 1 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 3269 2 . . . 40436 3270 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 3270 2 . . . 40436 3271 1 p. p. NN 40436 3271 2 23 23 CD 40436 3271 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3271 4 . . . 40436 3272 1 But but CC 40436 3272 2 this this DT 40436 3272 3 is be VBZ 40436 3272 4 because because IN 40436 3272 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3272 6 agency agency NN 40436 3272 7 is be VBZ 40436 3272 8 described describe VBN 40436 3272 9 more more RBR 40436 3272 10 in in IN 40436 3272 11 detail detail NN 40436 3272 12 . . . 40436 3273 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3273 2 can can MD 40436 3273 3 easily easily RB 40436 3273 4 present present VB 40436 3273 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3273 6 in in IN 40436 3273 7 a a DT 40436 3273 8 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 3273 9 aspect aspect NN 40436 3273 10 , , , 40436 3273 11 by by IN 40436 3273 12 introducing introduce VBG 40436 3273 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3273 14 as as IN 40436 3273 15 intervening intervene VBG 40436 3273 16 on on IN 40436 3273 17 petty petty JJ 40436 3273 18 and and CC 40436 3273 19 insignificant insignificant JJ 40436 3273 20 matters matter NNS 40436 3273 21 . . . 40436 3274 1 Now now RB 40436 3274 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3274 3 is be VBZ 40436 3274 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 3274 5 , , , 40436 3274 6 that that IN 40436 3274 7 in in IN 40436 3274 8 the the DT 40436 3274 9 Apology Apology NNP 40436 3274 10 , , , 40436 3274 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3274 12 are be VBP 40436 3274 13 expressly expressly RB 40436 3274 14 told tell VBN 40436 3274 15 that that IN 40436 3274 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3274 17 actually actually RB 40436 3274 18 did do VBD 40436 3274 19 intervene intervene VB 40436 3274 20 on on IN 40436 3274 21 the the DT 40436 3274 22 most most RBS 40436 3274 23 trifling trifling NN 40436 3274 24 occasions--[Greek occasions--[greek CD 40436 3274 25 : : : 40436 3274 26 pa pa NNP 40436 3274 27 / / SYM 40436 3274 28 nu nu NNP 40436 3274 29 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 3274 30 smikroi smikroi NNP 40436 3274 31 = = SYM 40436 3274 32 s s XX 40436 3274 33 e)nantioume e)nantioume NNP 40436 3274 34 / / SYM 40436 3274 35 nê nê NNP 40436 3274 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3274 37 . . . 40436 3275 1 The the DT 40436 3275 2 business business NN 40436 3275 3 of of IN 40436 3275 4 an an DT 40436 3275 5 historian historian NN 40436 3275 6 of of IN 40436 3275 7 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3275 8 is be VBZ 40436 3275 9 , , , 40436 3275 10 to to TO 40436 3275 11 describe describe VB 40436 3275 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3275 13 as as IN 40436 3275 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3275 15 was be VBD 40436 3275 16 really really RB 40436 3275 17 felt feel VBN 40436 3275 18 and and CC 40436 3275 19 believed believe VBN 40436 3275 20 by by IN 40436 3275 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3275 22 and and CC 40436 3275 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3275 24 -- -- : 40436 3275 25 whether whether IN 40436 3275 26 a a DT 40436 3275 27 modern modern JJ 40436 3275 28 critic critic NN 40436 3275 29 may may MD 40436 3275 30 consider consider VB 40436 3275 31 the the DT 40436 3275 32 description description NN 40436 3275 33 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 3275 34 or or CC 40436 3275 35 not not RB 40436 3275 36 . . . 40436 3276 1 When when WRB 40436 3276 2 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3276 3 says say VBZ 40436 3276 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3276 5 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 3276 6 , , , 40436 3276 7 p. p. NN 40436 3276 8 248 248 CD 40436 3276 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3276 10 , , , 40436 3276 11 respecting respect VBG 40436 3276 12 the the DT 40436 3276 13 _ _ NNP 40436 3276 14 falsarius falsarius NN 40436 3276 15 _ _ NNP 40436 3276 16 whom whom WP 40436 3276 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3276 18 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 3276 19 to to TO 40436 3276 20 have have VB 40436 3276 21 written write VBN 40436 3276 22 the the DT 40436 3276 23 Theagês--"Damit Theagês--"Damit NNP 40436 3276 24 ist ist NN 40436 3276 25 ihm ihm NN 40436 3276 26 begegnet begegnet NN 40436 3276 27 , , , 40436 3276 28 auf auf NNP 40436 3276 29 eine eine NNP 40436 3276 30 höchst höchst NNP 40436 3276 31 verkehrte verkehrte NNP 40436 3276 32 Art Art NNP 40436 3276 33 wunderbar wunderbar NN 40436 3276 34 zusammenzurühren zusammenzurühren VBZ 40436 3276 35 diese diese JJ 40436 3276 36 göttliche göttliche NNP 40436 3276 37 Schickung Schickung NNP 40436 3276 38 , , , 40436 3276 39 und und JJ 40436 3276 40 jenes jenes NNP 40436 3276 41 persönliche persönliche NNP 40436 3276 42 Vorgefühl Vorgefühl NNP 40436 3276 43 welches welche NNS 40436 3276 44 dem dem NNP 40436 3276 45 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3276 46 zur zur NNP 40436 3276 47 göttlichen göttlichen NN 40436 3276 48 Stimme Stimme NNP 40436 3276 49 ward".--I ward".--I NNP 40436 3276 50 contend contend VB 40436 3276 51 that that IN 40436 3276 52 the the DT 40436 3276 53 mistake mistake NN 40436 3276 54 is be VBZ 40436 3276 55 chargeable chargeable JJ 40436 3276 56 to to IN 40436 3276 57 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3276 58 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3276 59 , , , 40436 3276 60 for for IN 40436 3276 61 bisecting bisect VBG 40436 3276 62 into into IN 40436 3276 63 two two CD 40436 3276 64 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 3276 65 that that WDT 40436 3276 66 which which WDT 40436 3276 67 appears appear VBZ 40436 3276 68 in in IN 40436 3276 69 the the DT 40436 3276 70 Apology Apology NNP 40436 3276 71 as as IN 40436 3276 72 the the DT 40436 3276 73 same same JJ 40436 3276 74 phenomenon phenomenon NN 40436 3276 75 under under IN 40436 3276 76 two two CD 40436 3276 77 different different JJ 40436 3276 78 names--[Greek names--[greek CD 40436 3276 79 : : : 40436 3276 80 to\ to\ NNP 40436 3276 81 daimo daimo NNP 40436 3276 82 / / SYM 40436 3276 83 nion]--[Greek nion]--[Greek NNP 40436 3276 84 : : : 40436 3276 85 to\ to\ NN 40436 3276 86 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3276 87 theou= theou= NN 40436 3276 88 sêmei sêmei NN 40436 3276 89 = = SYM 40436 3276 90 on on IN 40436 3276 91 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3276 92 . . . 40436 3277 1 Besides besides RB 40436 3277 2 , , , 40436 3277 3 to to TO 40436 3277 4 treat treat VB 40436 3277 5 the the DT 40436 3277 6 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 3277 7 as as IN 40436 3277 8 a a DT 40436 3277 9 mere mere JJ 40436 3277 10 " " `` 40436 3277 11 personal personal JJ 40436 3277 12 presentiment presentiment NN 40436 3277 13 " " '' 40436 3277 14 of of IN 40436 3277 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3277 16 , , , 40436 3277 17 may may MD 40436 3277 18 be be VB 40436 3277 19 a a DT 40436 3277 20 true true JJ 40436 3277 21 view:--but view:--but NN 40436 3277 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3277 23 is be VBZ 40436 3277 24 the the DT 40436 3277 25 view view NN 40436 3277 26 of of IN 40436 3277 27 one one CD 40436 3277 28 who who WP 40436 3277 29 does do VBZ 40436 3277 30 not not RB 40436 3277 31 inhale inhale VB 40436 3277 32 the the DT 40436 3277 33 same same JJ 40436 3277 34 religious religious JJ 40436 3277 35 atmosphere atmosphere NN 40436 3277 36 as as IN 40436 3277 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3277 38 , , , 40436 3277 39 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3277 40 , , , 40436 3277 41 and and CC 40436 3277 42 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3277 43 . . . 40436 3278 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3278 2 can can MD 40436 3278 3 not not RB 40436 3278 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 3278 5 be be VB 40436 3278 6 properly properly RB 40436 3278 7 applied apply VBN 40436 3278 8 in in IN 40436 3278 9 explaining explain VBG 40436 3278 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3278 11 sayings saying NNS 40436 3278 12 or or CC 40436 3278 13 doings doing NNS 40436 3278 14 . . . 40436 3279 1 Kühner Kühner NNP 40436 3279 2 , , , 40436 3279 3 who who WP 40436 3279 4 treats treat VBZ 40436 3279 5 the the DT 40436 3279 6 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3279 7 as as IN 40436 3279 8 not not RB 40436 3279 9 composed compose VBN 40436 3279 10 by by IN 40436 3279 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3279 12 , , , 40436 3279 13 grounds ground VBZ 40436 3279 14 this this DT 40436 3279 15 belief belief NN 40436 3279 16 partly partly RB 40436 3279 17 on on IN 40436 3279 18 the the DT 40436 3279 19 assertion assertion NN 40436 3279 20 , , , 40436 3279 21 that that IN 40436 3279 22 the the DT 40436 3279 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3279 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3279 25 : : : 40436 3279 26 daimo daimo NN 40436 3279 27 / / SYM 40436 3279 28 nion nion NN 40436 3279 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3279 30 of of IN 40436 3279 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3279 32 is be VBZ 40436 3279 33 described describe VBN 40436 3279 34 therein therein RB 40436 3279 35 as as IN 40436 3279 36 something something NN 40436 3279 37 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 3279 38 to to IN 40436 3279 39 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3279 40 ; ; : 40436 3279 41 which which WDT 40436 3279 42 , , , 40436 3279 43 according accord VBG 40436 3279 44 to to IN 40436 3279 45 Kühner Kühner NNP 40436 3279 46 , , , 40436 3279 47 was be VBD 40436 3279 48 the the DT 40436 3279 49 fiction fiction NN 40436 3279 50 of of IN 40436 3279 51 a a DT 40436 3279 52 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 3279 53 time time NN 40436 3279 54 . . . 40436 3280 1 By by IN 40436 3280 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3280 3 and and CC 40436 3280 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3280 5 contemporaries contemporary NNS 40436 3280 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3280 7 Kühner Kühner NNP 40436 3280 8 says say VBZ 40436 3280 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3280 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3280 11 was be VBD 40436 3280 12 considered consider VBN 40436 3280 13 " " `` 40436 3280 14 non non AFX 40436 3280 15 sibi sibi NNP 40436 3280 16 soli soli NNP 40436 3280 17 tanquam tanquam NNP 40436 3280 18 proprium proprium NNP 40436 3280 19 quoddam quoddam NNP 40436 3280 20 beneficium beneficium NNP 40436 3280 21 a a DT 40436 3280 22 Diis Diis NNP 40436 3280 23 tributum tributum NN 40436 3280 24 , , , 40436 3280 25 sed sed NNP 40436 3280 26 commune commune NNP 40436 3280 27 sibi sibi NNP 40436 3280 28 esse esse NNP 40436 3280 29 cum cum NNP 40436 3280 30 cæteris cæteris NNP 40436 3280 31 hominibus hominibus NNP 40436 3280 32 " " '' 40436 3280 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3280 34 pp pp NNP 40436 3280 35 . . . 40436 3281 1 20 20 CD 40436 3281 2 - - SYM 40436 3281 3 21 21 CD 40436 3281 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3281 5 . . . 40436 3282 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3282 2 dissent dissent VBP 40436 3282 3 entirely entirely RB 40436 3282 4 from from IN 40436 3282 5 this this DT 40436 3282 6 view view NN 40436 3282 7 , , , 40436 3282 8 which which WDT 40436 3282 9 is be VBZ 40436 3282 10 contradicted contradict VBN 40436 3282 11 by by IN 40436 3282 12 most most JJS 40436 3282 13 of of IN 40436 3282 14 the the DT 40436 3282 15 passages passage NNS 40436 3282 16 noticed notice VBN 40436 3282 17 even even RB 40436 3282 18 by by IN 40436 3282 19 Kühner Kühner NNP 40436 3282 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3282 21 . . . 40436 3283 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3283 2 is be VBZ 40436 3283 3 at at IN 40436 3283 4 variance variance NN 40436 3283 5 with with IN 40436 3283 6 the the DT 40436 3283 7 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3283 8 Apology Apology NNP 40436 3283 9 , , , 40436 3283 10 as as RB 40436 3283 11 well well RB 40436 3283 12 as as IN 40436 3283 13 with with IN 40436 3283 14 the the DT 40436 3283 15 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 3283 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3283 17 150 150 CD 40436 3283 18 D D NNP 40436 3283 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3283 20 , , , 40436 3283 21 and and CC 40436 3283 22 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3283 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3283 24 vi vi NNP 40436 3283 25 . . . 40436 3284 1 496 496 CD 40436 3284 2 C C NNP 40436 3284 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3284 4 . . . 40436 3285 1 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3285 2 does do VBZ 40436 3285 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 3285 4 try try VB 40436 3285 5 , , , 40436 3285 6 in in IN 40436 3285 7 the the DT 40436 3285 8 first first JJ 40436 3285 9 Chapter chapter NN 40436 3285 10 of of IN 40436 3285 11 the the DT 40436 3285 12 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 3285 13 , , , 40436 3285 14 as as IN 40436 3285 15 the the DT 40436 3285 16 defender defender NN 40436 3285 17 of of IN 40436 3285 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3285 19 , , , 40436 3285 20 to to TO 40436 3285 21 soften soften VB 40436 3285 22 the the DT 40436 3285 23 _ _ NNP 40436 3285 24 invidia invidia NNP 40436 3285 25 _ _ NNP 40436 3285 26 against against IN 40436 3285 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3285 28 , , , 40436 3285 29 by by IN 40436 3285 30 intimating intimate VBG 40436 3285 31 that that IN 40436 3285 32 other other JJ 40436 3285 33 persons person NNS 40436 3285 34 had have VBD 40436 3285 35 communications communication NNS 40436 3285 36 from from IN 40436 3285 37 the the DT 40436 3285 38 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3285 39 as as RB 40436 3285 40 well well RB 40436 3285 41 as as IN 40436 3285 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3285 43 . . . 40436 3286 1 But but CC 40436 3286 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3286 3 see see VBP 40436 3286 4 plainly plainly RB 40436 3286 5 , , , 40436 3286 6 even even RB 40436 3286 7 from from IN 40436 3286 8 other other JJ 40436 3286 9 passages passage NNS 40436 3286 10 of of IN 40436 3286 11 the the DT 40436 3286 12 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 3286 13 , , , 40436 3286 14 that that IN 40436 3286 15 this this DT 40436 3286 16 was be VBD 40436 3286 17 not not RB 40436 3286 18 the the DT 40436 3286 19 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 3286 20 of of IN 40436 3286 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3286 22 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3286 23 , , , 40436 3286 24 nor nor CC 40436 3286 25 of of IN 40436 3286 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3286 27 friends friend NNS 40436 3286 28 , , , 40436 3286 29 nor nor CC 40436 3286 30 of of IN 40436 3286 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3286 32 enemies enemy NNS 40436 3286 33 . . . 40436 3287 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 3287 2 all all DT 40436 3287 3 considered consider VBD 40436 3287 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3287 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3287 6 as as IN 40436 3287 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3287 8 is be VBZ 40436 3287 9 depicted depict VBN 40436 3287 10 in in IN 40436 3287 11 the the DT 40436 3287 12 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 3287 13 also also RB 40436 3287 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3287 15 to to TO 40436 3287 16 be be VB 40436 3287 17 a a DT 40436 3287 18 special special JJ 40436 3287 19 privilege privilege NN 40436 3287 20 and and CC 40436 3287 21 revelation revelation NN 40436 3287 22 . . . 40436 3288 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 3288 2 XVI XVI NNP 40436 3288 3 . . . 40436 3289 1 ERASTÆ ERASTÆ NNP 40436 3289 2 OR or CC 40436 3289 3 ANTERASTÆ ANTERASTÆ NNP 40436 3289 4 -- -- : 40436 3289 5 RIVALES rivale NNS 40436 3289 6 . . . 40436 3290 1 The the DT 40436 3290 2 main main JJ 40436 3290 3 subject subject NN 40436 3290 4 of of IN 40436 3290 5 this this DT 40436 3290 6 short short JJ 40436 3290 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3290 8 is be VBZ 40436 3290 9 -- -- : 40436 3290 10 What what WP 40436 3290 11 is be VBZ 40436 3290 12 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3290 13 ? ? . 40436 3291 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3291 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3291 3 : : : 40436 3291 4 ê ê NNP 40436 3291 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3291 6 philosophi philosophi NNP 40436 3291 7 / / SYM 40436 3291 8 a a DT 40436 3291 9 -- -- : 40436 3291 10 to\ to\ NN 40436 3291 11 philosophei philosophei NN 40436 3291 12 = = SYM 40436 3291 13 n n NN 40436 3291 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3291 15 . . . 40436 3292 1 How how WRB 40436 3292 2 are be VBP 40436 3292 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3292 4 to to TO 40436 3292 5 explain explain VB 40436 3292 6 or or CC 40436 3292 7 define define VB 40436 3292 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3292 9 ? ? . 40436 3293 1 What what WP 40436 3293 2 is be VBZ 40436 3293 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3293 4 province province NN 40436 3293 5 and and CC 40436 3293 6 purport purport NN 40436 3293 7 ? ? . 40436 3294 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3294 2 Side side NN 40436 3294 3 - - HYPH 40436 3294 4 note note NN 40436 3294 5 : : : 40436 3294 6 Erastæ erastæ JJ 40436 3294 7 -- -- : 40436 3294 8 subject subject JJ 40436 3294 9 and and CC 40436 3294 10 persons person NNS 40436 3294 11 of of IN 40436 3294 12 the the DT 40436 3294 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3294 14 -- -- : 40436 3294 15 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 3294 16 introduction introduction NN 40436 3294 17 -- -- : 40436 3294 18 interesting interesting JJ 40436 3294 19 youths youth NNS 40436 3294 20 in in IN 40436 3294 21 the the DT 40436 3294 22 palæstra palæstra NN 40436 3294 23 . . . 40436 3294 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3295 1 Instead instead RB 40436 3295 2 of of IN 40436 3295 3 the the DT 40436 3295 4 simple simple JJ 40436 3295 5 , , , 40436 3295 6 naked naked JJ 40436 3295 7 , , , 40436 3295 8 self self NN 40436 3295 9 - - HYPH 40436 3295 10 introducing introduce VBG 40436 3295 11 , , , 40436 3295 12 conversation conversation NN 40436 3295 13 , , , 40436 3295 14 which which WDT 40436 3295 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3295 16 read read VBP 40436 3295 17 in in IN 40436 3295 18 the the DT 40436 3295 19 Menon Menon NNP 40436 3295 20 , , , 40436 3295 21 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 3295 22 , , , 40436 3295 23 Minos Minos NNP 40436 3295 24 , , , 40436 3295 25 & & CC 40436 3295 26 c. c. NNP 40436 3295 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3295 28 recounts recount VBZ 40436 3295 29 a a DT 40436 3295 30 scene scene NN 40436 3295 31 and and CC 40436 3295 32 colloquy colloquy NN 40436 3295 33 , , , 40436 3295 34 which which WDT 40436 3295 35 occurred occur VBD 40436 3295 36 when when WRB 40436 3295 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3295 38 went go VBD 40436 3295 39 into into IN 40436 3295 40 the the DT 40436 3295 41 house house NN 40436 3295 42 of of IN 40436 3295 43 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40436 3295 44 the the DT 40436 3295 45 grammatist grammatist NN 40436 3295 46 or or CC 40436 3295 47 school school NN 40436 3295 48 - - HYPH 40436 3295 49 master,[1 master,[1 NN 40436 3295 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3295 51 frequented frequent VBN 40436 3295 52 by by IN 40436 3295 53 many many JJ 40436 3295 54 elegant elegant JJ 40436 3295 55 and and CC 40436 3295 56 high high JJ 40436 3295 57 - - HYPH 40436 3295 58 born bear VBN 40436 3295 59 youths youth NNS 40436 3295 60 as as IN 40436 3295 61 pupils pupil NNS 40436 3295 62 . . . 40436 3296 1 Two two CD 40436 3296 2 of of IN 40436 3296 3 these these DT 40436 3296 4 youths youth NNS 40436 3296 5 were be VBD 40436 3296 6 engaged engage VBN 40436 3296 7 in in IN 40436 3296 8 animated animate VBN 40436 3296 9 debate debate NN 40436 3296 10 upon upon IN 40436 3296 11 some some DT 40436 3296 12 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 3296 13 or or CC 40436 3296 14 astronomical astronomical JJ 40436 3296 15 problem problem NN 40436 3296 16 , , , 40436 3296 17 in in IN 40436 3296 18 the the DT 40436 3296 19 presence presence NN 40436 3296 20 of of IN 40436 3296 21 various various JJ 40436 3296 22 spectators spectator NNS 40436 3296 23 ; ; : 40436 3296 24 and and CC 40436 3296 25 especially especially RB 40436 3296 26 of of IN 40436 3296 27 two two CD 40436 3296 28 young young JJ 40436 3296 29 men man NNS 40436 3296 30 , , , 40436 3296 31 rivals rival NNS 40436 3296 32 for for IN 40436 3296 33 the the DT 40436 3296 34 affection affection NN 40436 3296 35 of of IN 40436 3296 36 one one CD 40436 3296 37 of of IN 40436 3296 38 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3296 39 . . . 40436 3297 1 Of of IN 40436 3297 2 these these DT 40436 3297 3 rivals rival NNS 40436 3297 4 , , , 40436 3297 5 the the DT 40436 3297 6 one one NN 40436 3297 7 is be VBZ 40436 3297 8 a a DT 40436 3297 9 person person NN 40436 3297 10 devoted devote VBN 40436 3297 11 to to IN 40436 3297 12 music music NN 40436 3297 13 , , , 40436 3297 14 letters letter NNS 40436 3297 15 , , , 40436 3297 16 discourse discourse NN 40436 3297 17 , , , 40436 3297 18 philosophy:--the philosophy:--the JJ 40436 3297 19 other other JJ 40436 3297 20 hates hate NNS 40436 3297 21 and and CC 40436 3297 22 despises despise VBZ 40436 3297 23 these these DT 40436 3297 24 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 3297 25 , , , 40436 3297 26 devoting devote VBG 40436 3297 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3297 28 to to IN 40436 3297 29 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 3297 30 exercise exercise NN 40436 3297 31 , , , 40436 3297 32 and and CC 40436 3297 33 bent bent JJ 40436 3297 34 on on RP 40436 3297 35 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 3297 36 the the DT 40436 3297 37 maximum maximum NN 40436 3297 38 of of IN 40436 3297 39 athletic athletic JJ 40436 3297 40 force force NN 40436 3297 41 . . . 40436 3298 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3298 2 2 2 LS 40436 3298 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3298 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3298 5 is be VBZ 40436 3298 6 much much RB 40436 3298 7 the the DT 40436 3298 8 same same JJ 40436 3298 9 contrast contrast NN 40436 3298 10 as as IN 40436 3298 11 that that DT 40436 3298 12 between between IN 40436 3298 13 the the DT 40436 3298 14 brothers brother NNS 40436 3298 15 Amphion Amphion NNP 40436 3298 16 and and CC 40436 3298 17 Zethus Zethus NNP 40436 3298 18 in in IN 40436 3298 19 the the DT 40436 3298 20 Antiopê Antiopê NNP 40436 3298 21 of of IN 40436 3298 22 Euripides Euripides NNP 40436 3298 23 -- -- : 40436 3298 24 which which WDT 40436 3298 25 is be VBZ 40436 3298 26 beautifully beautifully RB 40436 3298 27 employed employ VBN 40436 3298 28 as as IN 40436 3298 29 an an DT 40436 3298 30 illustration illustration NN 40436 3298 31 by by IN 40436 3298 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3298 33 in in IN 40436 3298 34 the the DT 40436 3298 35 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 3298 36 . . . 40436 3299 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3299 2 3 3 CD 40436 3299 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3299 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3299 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3299 6 1 1 CD 40436 3299 7 : : : 40436 3299 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3299 9 , , , 40436 3299 10 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3299 11 , , , 40436 3299 12 132 132 CD 40436 3299 13 . . . 40436 3300 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3300 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3300 3 : : : 40436 3300 4 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 3300 5 Dionusi Dionusi NNP 40436 3300 6 / / SYM 40436 3300 7 ou ou NNP 40436 3300 8 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3300 9 grammatistou= grammatistou= NN 40436 3300 10 ei)sê ei)sê NNP 40436 3300 11 = = SYM 40436 3300 12 lthon lthon NNP 40436 3300 13 , , , 40436 3300 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3300 15 ei)=don ei)=don NNP 40436 3300 16 au)to au)to NNP 40436 3300 17 / / SYM 40436 3300 18 thi thi NNP 40436 3300 19 tô tô NNP 40436 3300 20 = = SYM 40436 3300 21 n n NNP 40436 3300 22 te te NNP 40436 3300 23 ne ne NNP 40436 3300 24 / / SYM 40436 3300 25 ôn ôn NNP 40436 3300 26 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 3300 27 e)pieikesta e)pieikesta , 40436 3300 28 / / SYM 40436 3300 29 tous tous JJ 40436 3300 30 dokou dokou NN 40436 3300 31 = = SYM 40436 3300 32 ntas ntas FW 40436 3300 33 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 3300 34 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 3300 35 i)de i)de NNP 40436 3300 36 / / , 40436 3300 37 an an DT 40436 3300 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3300 39 pate pate NNP 40436 3300 40 / / SYM 40436 3300 41 rôn rôn NNP 40436 3300 42 eu)doki eu)doki NNP 40436 3300 43 / / SYM 40436 3300 44 môn môn NNP 40436 3300 45 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3300 46 tou tou NNP 40436 3300 47 / / SYM 40436 3300 48 tôn tôn NNP 40436 3300 49 e)rasta e)rasta NNP 40436 3300 50 / / SYM 40436 3300 51 s s NNP 40436 3300 52 . . . 40436 3300 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3300 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3301 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3301 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3301 3 2 2 CD 40436 3301 4 : : : 40436 3301 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3301 6 , , , 40436 3301 7 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3301 8 . . . 40436 3302 1 132 132 CD 40436 3302 2 E. E. NNP 40436 3302 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3302 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3302 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3302 6 3 3 CD 40436 3302 7 : : : 40436 3302 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3302 9 , , , 40436 3302 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 3302 11 , , , 40436 3302 12 485 485 CD 40436 3302 13 - - SYM 40436 3302 14 486 486 CD 40436 3302 15 . . . 40436 3303 1 Compare compare VB 40436 3303 2 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 3303 3 De De NNP 40436 3303 4 Oratore Oratore NNP 40436 3303 5 , , , 40436 3303 6 ii ii NNP 40436 3303 7 . . . 40436 3304 1 37 37 CD 40436 3304 2 , , , 40436 3304 3 156 156 CD 40436 3304 4 . . . 40436 3304 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3305 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3305 2 Side side NN 40436 3305 3 - - HYPH 40436 3305 4 note note NN 40436 3305 5 : : : 40436 3305 6 Two two CD 40436 3305 7 rival rival JJ 40436 3305 8 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3305 9 -- -- : 40436 3305 10 one one CD 40436 3305 11 of of IN 40436 3305 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3305 13 literary literary JJ 40436 3305 14 , , , 40436 3305 15 devoted devote VBN 40436 3305 16 to to IN 40436 3305 17 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3305 18 -- -- : 40436 3305 19 the the DT 40436 3305 20 other other JJ 40436 3305 21 gymnastic gymnastic NN 40436 3305 22 , , , 40436 3305 23 hating hate VBG 40436 3305 24 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3305 25 . . . 40436 3305 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3306 1 As as RB 40436 3306 2 soon soon RB 40436 3306 3 as as IN 40436 3306 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3306 5 begins begin VBZ 40436 3306 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3306 7 interrogatories interrogatory NNS 40436 3306 8 , , , 40436 3306 9 the the DT 40436 3306 10 two two CD 40436 3306 11 youths youth NNS 40436 3306 12 relinquish[4 relinquish[4 VBP 40436 3306 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3306 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3306 15 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 3306 16 talk talk NN 40436 3306 17 , , , 40436 3306 18 and and CC 40436 3306 19 turn turn VB 40436 3306 20 to to IN 40436 3306 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3306 22 as as IN 40436 3306 23 attentive attentive JJ 40436 3306 24 listeners listener NNS 40436 3306 25 . . . 40436 3307 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3307 2 approach approach NN 40436 3307 3 affects affect VBZ 40436 3307 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3307 5 emotions emotion NNS 40436 3307 6 hardly hardly RB 40436 3307 7 less less JJR 40436 3307 8 than than IN 40436 3307 9 those those DT 40436 3307 10 of of IN 40436 3307 11 the the DT 40436 3307 12 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 3307 13 . . . 40436 3308 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3308 2 first first RB 40436 3308 3 enquires enquire VBZ 40436 3308 4 from from IN 40436 3308 5 the the DT 40436 3308 6 athletic athletic JJ 40436 3308 7 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 3308 8 , , , 40436 3308 9 What what WP 40436 3308 10 is be VBZ 40436 3308 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3308 12 that that WDT 40436 3308 13 these these DT 40436 3308 14 two two CD 40436 3308 15 youths youth NNS 40436 3308 16 are be VBP 40436 3308 17 so so RB 40436 3308 18 intently intently RB 40436 3308 19 engaged engage VBN 40436 3308 20 upon upon IN 40436 3308 21 ? ? . 40436 3309 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3309 2 must must MD 40436 3309 3 surely surely RB 40436 3309 4 be be VB 40436 3309 5 something something NN 40436 3309 6 very very RB 40436 3309 7 fine fine JJ 40436 3309 8 , , , 40436 3309 9 to to TO 40436 3309 10 judge judge VB 40436 3309 11 by by IN 40436 3309 12 the the DT 40436 3309 13 eagerness eagerness NN 40436 3309 14 which which WDT 40436 3309 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3309 16 display display VBP 40436 3309 17 ? ? . 40436 3310 1 How how WRB 40436 3310 2 do do VBP 40436 3310 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3310 4 mean mean VB 40436 3310 5 _ _ NNP 40436 3310 6 fine fine JJ 40436 3310 7 _ _ NNP 40436 3310 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3310 9 replies reply VBZ 40436 3310 10 the the DT 40436 3310 11 athlete athlete NN 40436 3310 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3310 13 ? ? . 40436 3311 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 3311 2 are be VBP 40436 3311 3 only only RB 40436 3311 4 prosing prose VBG 40436 3311 5 about about IN 40436 3311 6 astronomical astronomical JJ 40436 3311 7 matters matter NNS 40436 3311 8 -- -- : 40436 3311 9 talking talk VBG 40436 3311 10 nonsense nonsense NN 40436 3311 11 -- -- : 40436 3311 12 philosophising philosophising NN 40436 3311 13 ! ! . 40436 3312 1 The the DT 40436 3312 2 literary literary JJ 40436 3312 3 rival rival NN 40436 3312 4 , , , 40436 3312 5 on on IN 40436 3312 6 the the DT 40436 3312 7 contrary contrary NN 40436 3312 8 , , , 40436 3312 9 treats treat VBZ 40436 3312 10 this this DT 40436 3312 11 athlete athlete NN 40436 3312 12 as as IN 40436 3312 13 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 3312 14 of of IN 40436 3312 15 attention attention NN 40436 3312 16 , , , 40436 3312 17 speaks speak VBZ 40436 3312 18 with with IN 40436 3312 19 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 40436 3312 20 admiration admiration NN 40436 3312 21 of of IN 40436 3312 22 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3312 23 , , , 40436 3312 24 and and CC 40436 3312 25 declares declare VBZ 40436 3312 26 that that IN 40436 3312 27 all all PDT 40436 3312 28 those those DT 40436 3312 29 to to TO 40436 3312 30 whom whom WP 40436 3312 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3312 32 is be VBZ 40436 3312 33 repugnant repugnant JJ 40436 3312 34 are be VBP 40436 3312 35 degraded degrade VBN 40436 3312 36 specimens specimen NNS 40436 3312 37 of of IN 40436 3312 38 humanity humanity NN 40436 3312 39 . . . 40436 3313 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3313 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3313 3 4 4 CD 40436 3313 4 : : : 40436 3313 5 The the DT 40436 3313 6 powerful powerful JJ 40436 3313 7 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 3313 8 of of IN 40436 3313 9 admiration admiration NN 40436 3313 10 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 3313 11 to to IN 40436 3313 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3313 13 in in IN 40436 3313 14 the the DT 40436 3313 15 presence presence NN 40436 3313 16 of of IN 40436 3313 17 these these DT 40436 3313 18 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 3313 19 youths youth NNS 40436 3313 20 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 3313 21 notice notice NN 40436 3313 22 as as IN 40436 3313 23 a a DT 40436 3313 24 point point NN 40436 3313 25 in in IN 40436 3313 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3313 27 character character NN 40436 3313 28 . . . 40436 3314 1 Compare compare VB 40436 3314 2 the the DT 40436 3314 3 beginning beginning NN 40436 3314 4 of of IN 40436 3314 5 the the DT 40436 3314 6 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 3314 7 and and CC 40436 3314 8 the the DT 40436 3314 9 Lysis lysis NN 40436 3314 10 . . . 40436 3314 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3315 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3315 2 Side side NN 40436 3315 3 - - HYPH 40436 3315 4 note note NN 40436 3315 5 : : : 40436 3315 6 Question question NN 40436 3315 7 put put VBN 40436 3315 8 by by IN 40436 3315 9 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3315 10 -- -- : 40436 3315 11 What what WP 40436 3315 12 is be VBZ 40436 3315 13 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3315 14 ? ? . 40436 3316 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3316 2 is be VBZ 40436 3316 3 the the DT 40436 3316 4 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 3316 5 accumulation accumulation NN 40436 3316 6 of of IN 40436 3316 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3316 8 , , , 40436 3316 9 so so IN 40436 3316 10 as as IN 40436 3316 11 to to TO 40436 3316 12 make make VB 40436 3316 13 the the DT 40436 3316 14 largest large JJS 40436 3316 15 sum sum NN 40436 3316 16 total total NN 40436 3316 17 . . . 40436 3316 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3317 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3317 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 3317 3 think think VBP 40436 3317 4 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3317 5 a a DT 40436 3317 6 fine fine JJ 40436 3317 7 thing thing NN 40436 3317 8 ? ? . 40436 3318 1 But but CC 40436 3318 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3318 3 can can MD 40436 3318 4 not not RB 40436 3318 5 tell tell VB 40436 3318 6 whether whether IN 40436 3318 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3318 8 is be VBZ 40436 3318 9 fine fine JJ 40436 3318 10 or or CC 40436 3318 11 not not RB 40436 3318 12 , , , 40436 3318 13 unless unless IN 40436 3318 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3318 15 know know VBP 40436 3318 16 what what WP 40436 3318 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3318 18 is be VBZ 40436 3318 19 . . . 40436 3319 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3319 2 5 5 CD 40436 3319 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3319 4 Pray pray UH 40436 3319 5 explain explain VB 40436 3319 6 to to IN 40436 3319 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3319 8 what what WDT 40436 3319 9 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3319 10 is be VBZ 40436 3319 11 . . . 40436 3320 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3320 2 Erast._--I erast._--i CD 40436 3320 3 will will MD 40436 3320 4 do do VB 40436 3320 5 so so RB 40436 3320 6 readily readily RB 40436 3320 7 . . . 40436 3321 1 Philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3321 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 3321 3 in in IN 40436 3321 4 the the DT 40436 3321 5 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 3321 6 growth growth NN 40436 3321 7 of of IN 40436 3321 8 a a DT 40436 3321 9 man man NN 40436 3321 10 's 's POS 40436 3321 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3321 12 -- -- : 40436 3321 13 in in IN 40436 3321 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3321 15 going go VBG 40436 3321 16 on on RP 40436 3321 17 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 3321 18 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 3321 19 something something NN 40436 3321 20 new new JJ 40436 3321 21 , , , 40436 3321 22 both both CC 40436 3321 23 in in IN 40436 3321 24 youth youth NN 40436 3321 25 and and CC 40436 3321 26 in in IN 40436 3321 27 old old JJ 40436 3321 28 age age NN 40436 3321 29 , , , 40436 3321 30 so so IN 40436 3321 31 that that IN 40436 3321 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3321 33 may may MD 40436 3321 34 learn learn VB 40436 3321 35 as as RB 40436 3321 36 much much JJ 40436 3321 37 as as IN 40436 3321 38 possible possible JJ 40436 3321 39 during during IN 40436 3321 40 life life NN 40436 3321 41 . . . 40436 3322 1 Philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3322 2 is be VBZ 40436 3322 3 polymathy polymathy JJ 40436 3322 4 . . . 40436 3323 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3323 2 6 6 CD 40436 3323 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3323 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3323 5 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 3323 6 think think VBP 40436 3323 7 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3323 8 not not RB 40436 3323 9 only only RB 40436 3323 10 a a DT 40436 3323 11 fine fine JJ 40436 3323 12 thing thing NN 40436 3323 13 , , , 40436 3323 14 but but CC 40436 3323 15 good good JJ 40436 3323 16 ? ? . 40436 3324 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3324 2 Erast._--Yes Erast._--Yes NNP 40436 3324 3 -- -- : 40436 3324 4 very very RB 40436 3324 5 good good JJ 40436 3324 6 . . . 40436 3325 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3325 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 3325 3 is be VBZ 40436 3325 4 the the DT 40436 3325 5 case case NN 40436 3325 6 similar similar JJ 40436 3325 7 in in IN 40436 3325 8 regard regard NN 40436 3325 9 to to IN 40436 3325 10 gymnastic gymnastic NNP 40436 3325 11 ? ? . 40436 3326 1 Is be VBZ 40436 3326 2 a a DT 40436 3326 3 man man NN 40436 3326 4 's 's POS 40436 3326 5 bodily bodily JJ 40436 3326 6 condition condition NN 40436 3326 7 benefited benefit VBN 40436 3326 8 by by IN 40436 3326 9 taking take VBG 40436 3326 10 as as RB 40436 3326 11 much much JJ 40436 3326 12 exercise exercise NN 40436 3326 13 , , , 40436 3326 14 or or CC 40436 3326 15 as as IN 40436 3326 16 much much JJ 40436 3326 17 nourishment nourishment NN 40436 3326 18 , , , 40436 3326 19 as as IN 40436 3326 20 possible possible JJ 40436 3326 21 ? ? . 40436 3327 1 Is be VBZ 40436 3327 2 such such JJ 40436 3327 3 very very RB 40436 3327 4 great great JJ 40436 3327 5 quantity quantity NN 40436 3327 6 good good JJ 40436 3327 7 for for IN 40436 3327 8 the the DT 40436 3327 9 body body NN 40436 3327 10 ? ? . 40436 3328 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3328 2 7 7 CD 40436 3328 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3328 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3328 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3328 6 5 5 CD 40436 3328 7 : : : 40436 3328 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 3328 9 . . . 40436 3329 1 Erast erast VB 40436 3329 2 . . . 40436 3330 1 133 133 CD 40436 3330 2 A A NNP 40436 3330 3 - - HYPH 40436 3330 4 B. b. NN 40436 3330 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3331 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3331 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3331 3 6 6 CD 40436 3331 4 : : : 40436 3331 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3331 6 , , , 40436 3331 7 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3331 8 . . . 40436 3332 1 133 133 CD 40436 3332 2 D. D. NNP 40436 3332 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3332 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3332 5 : : : 40436 3332 6 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 3332 7 philosophi philosophi NN 40436 3332 8 / / SYM 40436 3332 9 an an DT 40436 3332 10 -- -- : 40436 3332 11 poluma poluma NNP 40436 3332 12 / / SYM 40436 3332 13 theian theian NNP 40436 3332 14 . . . 40436 3332 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3332 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3333 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3333 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3333 3 7 7 CD 40436 3333 4 : : : 40436 3333 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3333 6 , , , 40436 3333 7 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3333 8 . . . 40436 3334 1 133 133 CD 40436 3334 2 E. E. NNP 40436 3334 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3334 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3334 5 Side side NN 40436 3334 6 - - HYPH 40436 3334 7 note note NN 40436 3334 8 : : : 40436 3334 9 In in IN 40436 3334 10 the the DT 40436 3334 11 case case NN 40436 3334 12 of of IN 40436 3334 13 the the DT 40436 3334 14 body body NN 40436 3334 15 , , , 40436 3334 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3334 17 is be VBZ 40436 3334 18 not not RB 40436 3334 19 the the DT 40436 3334 20 maximum maximum NN 40436 3334 21 of of IN 40436 3334 22 exercise exercise NN 40436 3334 23 which which WDT 40436 3334 24 does do VBZ 40436 3334 25 good good NN 40436 3334 26 , , , 40436 3334 27 but but CC 40436 3334 28 the the DT 40436 3334 29 proper proper JJ 40436 3334 30 , , , 40436 3334 31 measured measure VBN 40436 3334 32 quantity quantity NN 40436 3334 33 . . . 40436 3335 1 For for IN 40436 3335 2 the the DT 40436 3335 3 mind mind NN 40436 3335 4 also also RB 40436 3335 5 , , , 40436 3335 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3335 7 is be VBZ 40436 3335 8 not not RB 40436 3335 9 the the DT 40436 3335 10 maximum maximum NN 40436 3335 11 of of IN 40436 3335 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3335 13 , , , 40436 3335 14 but but CC 40436 3335 15 the the DT 40436 3335 16 measured measured JJ 40436 3335 17 quantity quantity NN 40436 3335 18 which which WDT 40436 3335 19 is be VBZ 40436 3335 20 good good JJ 40436 3335 21 . . . 40436 3336 1 Who who WP 40436 3336 2 is be VBZ 40436 3336 3 the the DT 40436 3336 4 judge judge NN 40436 3336 5 to to TO 40436 3336 6 determine determine VB 40436 3336 7 this this DT 40436 3336 8 measure measure NN 40436 3336 9 ? ? . 40436 3336 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3337 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3337 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 3337 3 after after IN 40436 3337 4 some some DT 40436 3337 5 debate debate NN 40436 3337 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3337 7 in in IN 40436 3337 8 which which WDT 40436 3337 9 the the DT 40436 3337 10 other other JJ 40436 3337 11 or or CC 40436 3337 12 athletic athletic JJ 40436 3337 13 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 3337 14 sides side NNS 40436 3337 15 with with IN 40436 3337 16 Sokrates[8 sokrates[8 NN 40436 3337 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3337 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3337 19 that that IN 40436 3337 20 in in IN 40436 3337 21 regard regard NN 40436 3337 22 to to TO 40436 3337 23 exercise exercise VB 40436 3337 24 and and CC 40436 3337 25 food food NN 40436 3337 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3337 27 is be VBZ 40436 3337 28 not not RB 40436 3337 29 the the DT 40436 3337 30 great great JJ 40436 3337 31 quantity quantity NN 40436 3337 32 or or CC 40436 3337 33 the the DT 40436 3337 34 small small JJ 40436 3337 35 quantity quantity NN 40436 3337 36 , , , 40436 3337 37 which which WDT 40436 3337 38 is be VBZ 40436 3337 39 good good JJ 40436 3337 40 for for IN 40436 3337 41 the the DT 40436 3337 42 body body NN 40436 3337 43 -- -- : 40436 3337 44 but but CC 40436 3337 45 the the DT 40436 3337 46 moderate moderate JJ 40436 3337 47 or or CC 40436 3337 48 measured measured JJ 40436 3337 49 quantity quantity NN 40436 3337 50 . . . 40436 3338 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3338 2 9 9 CD 40436 3338 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3338 4 For for IN 40436 3338 5 the the DT 40436 3338 6 mind mind NN 40436 3338 7 , , , 40436 3338 8 the the DT 40436 3338 9 case case NN 40436 3338 10 is be VBZ 40436 3338 11 admitted admit VBN 40436 3338 12 to to TO 40436 3338 13 be be VB 40436 3338 14 similar similar JJ 40436 3338 15 . . . 40436 3339 1 Not not RB 40436 3339 2 the the DT 40436 3339 3 _ _ NNP 40436 3339 4 much much JJ 40436 3339 5 _ _ NNP 40436 3339 6 , , , 40436 3339 7 nor nor CC 40436 3339 8 the the DT 40436 3339 9 _ _ NNP 40436 3339 10 little little JJ 40436 3339 11 _ _ NNP 40436 3339 12 , , , 40436 3339 13 of of IN 40436 3339 14 learning learning NN 40436 3339 15 is be VBZ 40436 3339 16 good good JJ 40436 3339 17 for for IN 40436 3339 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3339 19 but but CC 40436 3339 20 the the DT 40436 3339 21 right right JJ 40436 3339 22 or or CC 40436 3339 23 measured measure VBN 40436 3339 24 amount amount NN 40436 3339 25 . . . 40436 3340 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3340 2 Sokr._--And Sokr._--And NNP 40436 3340 3 who who WP 40436 3340 4 is be VBZ 40436 3340 5 the the DT 40436 3340 6 competent competent JJ 40436 3340 7 judge judge NN 40436 3340 8 , , , 40436 3340 9 how how WRB 40436 3340 10 much much JJ 40436 3340 11 of of IN 40436 3340 12 either either CC 40436 3340 13 is be VBZ 40436 3340 14 right right JJ 40436 3340 15 measure measure NN 40436 3340 16 for for IN 40436 3340 17 the the DT 40436 3340 18 body body NN 40436 3340 19 ? ? . 40436 3341 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3341 2 Erast._--The Erast._--The NNP 40436 3341 3 physician physician NN 40436 3341 4 and and CC 40436 3341 5 the the DT 40436 3341 6 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 3341 7 trainer trainer NN 40436 3341 8 . . . 40436 3342 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3342 2 Sokr._--Who Sokr._--Who NNP 40436 3342 3 is be VBZ 40436 3342 4 the the DT 40436 3342 5 competent competent JJ 40436 3342 6 judge judge NN 40436 3342 7 , , , 40436 3342 8 how how WRB 40436 3342 9 much much JJ 40436 3342 10 seed seed NN 40436 3342 11 is be VBZ 40436 3342 12 right right JJ 40436 3342 13 measure measure NN 40436 3342 14 for for IN 40436 3342 15 sowing sow VBG 40436 3342 16 a a DT 40436 3342 17 field field NN 40436 3342 18 ? ? . 40436 3343 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3343 2 Erast._--The Erast._--The NNP 40436 3343 3 farmer farmer NN 40436 3343 4 . . . 40436 3344 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3344 2 Sokr._--Who Sokr._--Who NNP 40436 3344 3 is be VBZ 40436 3344 4 the the DT 40436 3344 5 competent competent JJ 40436 3344 6 judge judge NN 40436 3344 7 , , , 40436 3344 8 in in IN 40436 3344 9 reference reference NN 40436 3344 10 to to IN 40436 3344 11 the the DT 40436 3344 12 sowing sowing NN 40436 3344 13 and and CC 40436 3344 14 planting planting NN 40436 3344 15 of of IN 40436 3344 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3344 17 in in IN 40436 3344 18 the the DT 40436 3344 19 mind mind NN 40436 3344 20 , , , 40436 3344 21 which which WDT 40436 3344 22 varieties variety NNS 40436 3344 23 are be VBP 40436 3344 24 good good JJ 40436 3344 25 , , , 40436 3344 26 and and CC 40436 3344 27 how how WRB 40436 3344 28 much much JJ 40436 3344 29 of of IN 40436 3344 30 each each DT 40436 3344 31 is be VBZ 40436 3344 32 right right JJ 40436 3344 33 measure measure NN 40436 3344 34 ? ? . 40436 3345 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3345 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3345 3 8 8 CD 40436 3345 4 : : : 40436 3345 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 3345 6 . . . 40436 3346 1 Erast erast VB 40436 3346 2 . . . 40436 3347 1 134 134 CD 40436 3347 2 B B NNP 40436 3347 3 - - HYPH 40436 3347 4 C. C. NNP 40436 3348 1 The the DT 40436 3348 2 literary literary JJ 40436 3348 3 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 3348 4 says say VBZ 40436 3348 5 to to IN 40436 3348 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3348 7 , , , 40436 3348 8 " " '' 40436 3348 9 To to IN 40436 3348 10 _ _ NNP 40436 3348 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3348 12 _ _ NNP 40436 3348 13 , , , 40436 3348 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3348 15 have have VBP 40436 3348 16 no no DT 40436 3348 17 objection objection NN 40436 3348 18 to to TO 40436 3348 19 concede concede VB 40436 3348 20 this this DT 40436 3348 21 point point NN 40436 3348 22 , , , 40436 3348 23 and and CC 40436 3348 24 to to TO 40436 3348 25 admit admit VB 40436 3348 26 that that IN 40436 3348 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3348 28 previous previous JJ 40436 3348 29 answer answer NN 40436 3348 30 must must MD 40436 3348 31 be be VB 40436 3348 32 modified modify VBN 40436 3348 33 . . . 40436 3349 1 But but CC 40436 3349 2 if if IN 40436 3349 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3349 4 were be VBD 40436 3349 5 to to TO 40436 3349 6 debate debate VB 40436 3349 7 the the DT 40436 3349 8 point point NN 40436 3349 9 only only RB 40436 3349 10 with with IN 40436 3349 11 _ _ NNP 40436 3349 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3349 13 _ _ NNP 40436 3349 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3349 15 the the DT 40436 3349 16 athletic athletic JJ 40436 3349 17 rival rival NN 40436 3349 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3349 19 , , , 40436 3349 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3349 21 could could MD 40436 3349 22 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 3349 23 well well RB 40436 3349 24 have have VB 40436 3349 25 defended defend VBN 40436 3349 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3349 27 answer answer NN 40436 3349 28 , , , 40436 3349 29 and and CC 40436 3349 30 even even RB 40436 3349 31 worse bad JJR 40436 3349 32 answer answer NN 40436 3349 33 still still RB 40436 3349 34 , , , 40436 3349 35 for for IN 40436 3349 36 _ _ NNP 40436 3349 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3349 38 _ _ NNP 40436 3349 39 is be VBZ 40436 3349 40 quite quite RB 40436 3349 41 worthless worthless JJ 40436 3349 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3349 43 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3349 44 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3349 45 : : : 40436 3349 46 ou)de\n ou)de\n NNP 40436 3349 47 ga ga NNP 40436 3349 48 / / SYM 40436 3349 49 r r NNP 40436 3349 50 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 3349 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3349 52 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3349 53 . . . 40436 3349 54 " " '' 40436 3350 1 This this DT 40436 3350 2 is be VBZ 40436 3350 3 a a DT 40436 3350 4 curious curious JJ 40436 3350 5 passage passage NN 40436 3350 6 , , , 40436 3350 7 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 3350 8 the the DT 40436 3350 9 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 3350 10 habits habit NNS 40436 3350 11 of of IN 40436 3350 12 the the DT 40436 3350 13 day day NN 40436 3350 14 , , , 40436 3350 15 and and CC 40436 3350 16 the the DT 40436 3350 17 pride pride NN 40436 3350 18 felt feel VBD 40436 3350 19 in in IN 40436 3350 20 maintaining maintain VBG 40436 3350 21 an an DT 40436 3350 22 answer answer NN 40436 3350 23 once once RB 40436 3350 24 given give VBN 40436 3350 25 . . . 40436 3350 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3351 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3351 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3351 3 9 9 CD 40436 3351 4 : : : 40436 3351 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3351 6 , , , 40436 3351 7 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3351 8 , , , 40436 3351 9 134 134 CD 40436 3351 10 B B NNP 40436 3351 11 - - HYPH 40436 3351 12 D. D. NNP 40436 3351 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3351 14 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3351 15 : : : 40436 3351 16 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 3351 17 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3351 18 / / SYM 40436 3351 19 tria tria NNP 40436 3351 20 ma ma NNP 40436 3351 21 / / SYM 40436 3351 22 lista lista NNP 40436 3351 23 ô)phelei ô)phelei NNP 40436 3351 24 = = SYM 40436 3351 25 n n CD 40436 3351 26 , , , 40436 3351 27 a)lla\ a)lla\ `` 40436 3351 28 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 3351 29 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 3351 30 polla\ polla\ NNP 40436 3351 31 mêde\ mêde\ NNP 40436 3351 32 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 3351 33 o)li o)li NNP 40436 3351 34 / / SYM 40436 3351 35 ga ga NNP 40436 3351 36 . . . 40436 3351 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3351 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3352 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3352 2 Side side NN 40436 3352 3 - - HYPH 40436 3352 4 note note NN 40436 3352 5 : : : 40436 3352 6 No no DT 40436 3352 7 answer answer NN 40436 3352 8 given give VBN 40436 3352 9 . . . 40436 3353 1 What what WP 40436 3353 2 is be VBZ 40436 3353 3 the the DT 40436 3353 4 best good JJS 40436 3353 5 conjecture conjecture NN 40436 3353 6 ? ? . 40436 3354 1 Answer answer NN 40436 3354 2 of of IN 40436 3354 3 the the DT 40436 3354 4 literary literary JJ 40436 3354 5 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 3354 6 . . . 40436 3355 1 A a DT 40436 3355 2 man man NN 40436 3355 3 must must MD 40436 3355 4 learn learn VB 40436 3355 5 that that IN 40436 3355 6 which which WDT 40436 3355 7 will will MD 40436 3355 8 yield yield VB 40436 3355 9 to to IN 40436 3355 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3355 11 the the DT 40436 3355 12 greatest great JJS 40436 3355 13 reputation reputation NN 40436 3355 14 as as IN 40436 3355 15 a a DT 40436 3355 16 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3355 17 -- -- : 40436 3355 18 as as RB 40436 3355 19 much much RB 40436 3355 20 as as IN 40436 3355 21 will will MD 40436 3355 22 enable enable VB 40436 3355 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3355 24 to to TO 40436 3355 25 talk talk VB 40436 3355 26 like like IN 40436 3355 27 an an DT 40436 3355 28 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 3355 29 critic critic NN 40436 3355 30 , , , 40436 3355 31 though though IN 40436 3355 32 not not RB 40436 3355 33 to to TO 40436 3355 34 practise practise VB 40436 3355 35 . . . 40436 3355 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3356 1 The the DT 40436 3356 2 question question NN 40436 3356 3 is be VBZ 40436 3356 4 one one CD 40436 3356 5 which which WDT 40436 3356 6 none none NN 40436 3356 7 of of IN 40436 3356 8 the the DT 40436 3356 9 persons person NNS 40436 3356 10 present present JJ 40436 3356 11 can can MD 40436 3356 12 answer answer VB 40436 3356 13 . . . 40436 3357 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3357 2 10 10 CD 40436 3357 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3357 4 None none NN 40436 3357 5 of of IN 40436 3357 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3357 7 can can MD 40436 3357 8 tell tell VB 40436 3357 9 who who WP 40436 3357 10 is be VBZ 40436 3357 11 the the DT 40436 3357 12 special special JJ 40436 3357 13 referee referee NN 40436 3357 14 , , , 40436 3357 15 about about IN 40436 3357 16 training training NN 40436 3357 17 of of IN 40436 3357 18 mind mind NN 40436 3357 19 ; ; , 40436 3357 20 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 3357 21 to to IN 40436 3357 22 the the DT 40436 3357 23 physician physician NN 40436 3357 24 or or CC 40436 3357 25 the the DT 40436 3357 26 farmer farmer NN 40436 3357 27 in in IN 40436 3357 28 the the DT 40436 3357 29 analogous analogous JJ 40436 3357 30 cases case NNS 40436 3357 31 . . . 40436 3358 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3358 2 then then RB 40436 3358 3 puts put VBZ 40436 3358 4 a a DT 40436 3358 5 question question NN 40436 3358 6 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 3358 7 different different JJ 40436 3358 8 : : : 40436 3358 9 _ _ NNP 40436 3358 10 Sokr._--Since Sokr._--Since NNP 40436 3358 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3358 12 have have VBP 40436 3358 13 agreed agree VBN 40436 3358 14 , , , 40436 3358 15 that that IN 40436 3358 16 the the DT 40436 3358 17 man man NN 40436 3358 18 who who WP 40436 3358 19 prosecutes prosecute VBZ 40436 3358 20 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3358 21 ought ought MD 40436 3358 22 not not RB 40436 3358 23 to to TO 40436 3358 24 learn learn VB 40436 3358 25 many many JJ 40436 3358 26 things thing NNS 40436 3358 27 , , , 40436 3358 28 still still RB 40436 3358 29 less less RBR 40436 3358 30 all all DT 40436 3358 31 things thing NNS 40436 3358 32 -- -- : 40436 3358 33 what what WP 40436 3358 34 is be VBZ 40436 3358 35 the the DT 40436 3358 36 best good JJS 40436 3358 37 conjecture conjecture NN 40436 3358 38 that that WDT 40436 3358 39 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3358 40 can can MD 40436 3358 41 make make VB 40436 3358 42 , , , 40436 3358 43 respecting respect VBG 40436 3358 44 the the DT 40436 3358 45 matters matter NNS 40436 3358 46 which which WDT 40436 3358 47 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3358 48 ought ought MD 40436 3358 49 to to TO 40436 3358 50 learn learn VB 40436 3358 51 ? ? . 40436 3359 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3359 2 Erast._--The Erast._--The NNP 40436 3359 3 finest fine JJS 40436 3359 4 and and CC 40436 3359 5 most most RBS 40436 3359 6 suitable suitable JJ 40436 3359 7 acquirements acquirement NNS 40436 3359 8 for for IN 40436 3359 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3359 10 to to TO 40436 3359 11 aim aim VB 40436 3359 12 at at IN 40436 3359 13 , , , 40436 3359 14 are be VBP 40436 3359 15 those those DT 40436 3359 16 which which WDT 40436 3359 17 will will MD 40436 3359 18 yield yield VB 40436 3359 19 to to IN 40436 3359 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3359 21 the the DT 40436 3359 22 greatest great JJS 40436 3359 23 reputation reputation NN 40436 3359 24 as as IN 40436 3359 25 a a DT 40436 3359 26 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3359 27 . . . 40436 3360 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3360 2 ought ought MD 40436 3360 3 to to TO 40436 3360 4 appear appear VB 40436 3360 5 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 3360 6 in in IN 40436 3360 7 every every DT 40436 3360 8 variety variety NN 40436 3360 9 of of IN 40436 3360 10 science science NN 40436 3360 11 , , , 40436 3360 12 or or CC 40436 3360 13 at at IN 40436 3360 14 least least JJS 40436 3360 15 in in IN 40436 3360 16 all all PDT 40436 3360 17 the the DT 40436 3360 18 more more RBR 40436 3360 19 important important JJ 40436 3360 20 ; ; : 40436 3360 21 and and CC 40436 3360 22 with with IN 40436 3360 23 that that DT 40436 3360 24 view view NN 40436 3360 25 , , , 40436 3360 26 to to TO 40436 3360 27 learn learn VB 40436 3360 28 as as RB 40436 3360 29 much much JJ 40436 3360 30 of of IN 40436 3360 31 each each DT 40436 3360 32 as as IN 40436 3360 33 becomes become VBZ 40436 3360 34 a a DT 40436 3360 35 freeman freeman NN 40436 3360 36 to to IN 40436 3360 37 know:--that know:--that CD 40436 3360 38 is be VBZ 40436 3360 39 , , , 40436 3360 40 what what WP 40436 3360 41 belongs belong VBZ 40436 3360 42 to to IN 40436 3360 43 the the DT 40436 3360 44 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 3360 45 critic critic NN 40436 3360 46 , , , 40436 3360 47 as as IN 40436 3360 48 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 3360 49 from from IN 40436 3360 50 the the DT 40436 3360 51 manual manual JJ 40436 3360 52 operative operative NN 40436 3360 53 : : : 40436 3360 54 to to IN 40436 3360 55 the the DT 40436 3360 56 planning planning NN 40436 3360 57 and and CC 40436 3360 58 superintending superintend VBG 40436 3360 59 architect architect NN 40436 3360 60 , , , 40436 3360 61 as as IN 40436 3360 62 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 3360 63 from from IN 40436 3360 64 the the DT 40436 3360 65 working work VBG 40436 3360 66 carpenter carpenter NN 40436 3360 67 . . . 40436 3361 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3361 2 11 11 CD 40436 3361 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3361 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3361 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 3361 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3361 7 can can MD 40436 3361 8 not not RB 40436 3361 9 learn learn VB 40436 3361 10 even even RB 40436 3361 11 two two CD 40436 3361 12 different different JJ 40436 3361 13 arts art NNS 40436 3361 14 to to IN 40436 3361 15 this this DT 40436 3361 16 extent extent NN 40436 3361 17 -- -- : 40436 3361 18 much much RB 40436 3361 19 less less RBR 40436 3361 20 several several JJ 40436 3361 21 considerable considerable JJ 40436 3361 22 arts art NNS 40436 3361 23 . . . 40436 3362 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3362 2 Erast._--I erast._--i CD 40436 3362 3 do do VBP 40436 3362 4 not not RB 40436 3362 5 of of RB 40436 3362 6 course course NN 40436 3362 7 mean mean VB 40436 3362 8 that that IN 40436 3362 9 the the DT 40436 3362 10 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3362 11 can can MD 40436 3362 12 be be VB 40436 3362 13 supposed suppose VBN 40436 3362 14 to to TO 40436 3362 15 know know VB 40436 3362 16 each each DT 40436 3362 17 of of IN 40436 3362 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3362 19 accurately accurately RB 40436 3362 20 , , , 40436 3362 21 like like IN 40436 3362 22 the the DT 40436 3362 23 artist artist NN 40436 3362 24 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3362 25 -- -- : 40436 3362 26 but but CC 40436 3362 27 only only RB 40436 3362 28 as as RB 40436 3362 29 much much RB 40436 3362 30 as as IN 40436 3362 31 may may MD 40436 3362 32 be be VB 40436 3362 33 expected expect VBN 40436 3362 34 from from IN 40436 3362 35 the the DT 40436 3362 36 free free JJ 40436 3362 37 and and CC 40436 3362 38 cultivated cultivated JJ 40436 3362 39 citizen citizen NN 40436 3362 40 . . . 40436 3363 1 That that RB 40436 3363 2 is is RB 40436 3363 3 , , , 40436 3363 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3363 5 shall shall MD 40436 3363 6 be be VB 40436 3363 7 able able JJ 40436 3363 8 to to TO 40436 3363 9 appreciate appreciate VB 40436 3363 10 , , , 40436 3363 11 better well JJR 40436 3363 12 than than IN 40436 3363 13 other other JJ 40436 3363 14 hearers hearer NNS 40436 3363 15 , , , 40436 3363 16 the the DT 40436 3363 17 observations observation NNS 40436 3363 18 made make VBN 40436 3363 19 by by IN 40436 3363 20 the the DT 40436 3363 21 artist artist NN 40436 3363 22 : : : 40436 3363 23 and and CC 40436 3363 24 farther far RBR 40436 3363 25 to to TO 40436 3363 26 deliver deliver VB 40436 3363 27 a a DT 40436 3363 28 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 3363 29 opinion opinion NN 40436 3363 30 of of IN 40436 3363 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3363 32 own own JJ 40436 3363 33 , , , 40436 3363 34 so so IN 40436 3363 35 as as IN 40436 3363 36 to to TO 40436 3363 37 be be VB 40436 3363 38 accounted account VBN 40436 3363 39 , , , 40436 3363 40 by by IN 40436 3363 41 all all PDT 40436 3363 42 the the DT 40436 3363 43 hearers hearer NNS 40436 3363 44 , , , 40436 3363 45 more more RBR 40436 3363 46 accomplished accomplished JJ 40436 3363 47 in in IN 40436 3363 48 the the DT 40436 3363 49 affairs affair NNS 40436 3363 50 of of IN 40436 3363 51 the the DT 40436 3363 52 art art NN 40436 3363 53 than than IN 40436 3363 54 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3363 55 . . . 40436 3364 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3364 2 12 12 CD 40436 3364 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3364 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3364 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3364 6 10 10 CD 40436 3364 7 : : : 40436 3364 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3364 9 , , , 40436 3364 10 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3364 11 . . . 40436 3365 1 134 134 CD 40436 3365 2 E e NN 40436 3365 3 , , , 40436 3365 4 135 135 CD 40436 3365 5 A. a. NN 40436 3365 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3366 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3366 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3366 3 11 11 CD 40436 3366 4 : : : 40436 3366 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 3366 6 . . . 40436 3367 1 Erast erast VB 40436 3367 2 . . . 40436 3368 1 135 135 CD 40436 3368 2 B. B. NNP 40436 3369 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3369 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3369 3 : : : 40436 3369 4 o(/sa o(/sa NNP 40436 3369 5 xune xune NNP 40436 3369 6 / / SYM 40436 3369 7 seôs seôs NNP 40436 3369 8 e)/chetai e)/chetai NNP 40436 3369 9 , , , 40436 3369 10 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 3369 11 o(/sa o(/sa CC 40436 3369 12 cheirourgi cheirourgi NN 40436 3369 13 / / SYM 40436 3369 14 as as IN 40436 3369 15 . . . 40436 3369 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3369 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3370 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3370 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3370 3 12 12 CD 40436 3370 4 : : : 40436 3370 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 3370 6 . . . 40436 3371 1 Erast erast VB 40436 3371 2 . . . 40436 3372 1 135 135 CD 40436 3372 2 D. D. NNP 40436 3372 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3372 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3372 5 Side side NN 40436 3372 6 - - HYPH 40436 3372 7 note note NN 40436 3372 8 : : : 40436 3372 9 The the DT 40436 3372 10 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3372 11 is be VBZ 40436 3372 12 one one CD 40436 3372 13 who who WP 40436 3372 14 is be VBZ 40436 3372 15 second second RB 40436 3372 16 - - HYPH 40436 3372 17 best good JJS 40436 3372 18 in in IN 40436 3372 19 several several JJ 40436 3372 20 different different JJ 40436 3372 21 arts art NNS 40436 3372 22 -- -- : 40436 3372 23 a a DT 40436 3372 24 Pentathlus pentathlus NN 40436 3372 25 -- -- : 40436 3372 26 who who WP 40436 3372 27 talks talk VBZ 40436 3372 28 well well RB 40436 3372 29 upon upon IN 40436 3372 30 each each DT 40436 3372 31 . . . 40436 3372 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3373 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3373 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 3373 3 mean mean VBP 40436 3373 4 that that IN 40436 3373 5 the the DT 40436 3373 6 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3373 7 is be VBZ 40436 3373 8 to to TO 40436 3373 9 be be VB 40436 3373 10 second second RB 40436 3373 11 - - HYPH 40436 3373 12 best good JJS 40436 3373 13 in in IN 40436 3373 14 several several JJ 40436 3373 15 distinct distinct JJ 40436 3373 16 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 3373 17 : : : 40436 3373 18 like like IN 40436 3373 19 the the DT 40436 3373 20 Pentathlus Pentathlus NNP 40436 3373 21 , , , 40436 3373 22 who who WP 40436 3373 23 is be VBZ 40436 3373 24 not not RB 40436 3373 25 expected expect VBN 40436 3373 26 to to TO 40436 3373 27 equal equal VB 40436 3373 28 either either CC 40436 3373 29 the the DT 40436 3373 30 runner runner NN 40436 3373 31 or or CC 40436 3373 32 the the DT 40436 3373 33 wrestler wrestler NN 40436 3373 34 in in IN 40436 3373 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3373 36 own own JJ 40436 3373 37 separate separate JJ 40436 3373 38 departments department NNS 40436 3373 39 , , , 40436 3373 40 but but CC 40436 3373 41 only only RB 40436 3373 42 to to TO 40436 3373 43 surpass surpass VB 40436 3373 44 competitors competitor NNS 40436 3373 45 in in IN 40436 3373 46 the the DT 40436 3373 47 five five CD 40436 3373 48 matches match NNS 40436 3373 49 taken take VBN 40436 3373 50 together together RB 40436 3373 51 . . . 40436 3374 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3374 2 13 13 CD 40436 3374 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3374 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3374 5 Erast._--Yes Erast._--Yes NNP 40436 3374 6 -- -- : 40436 3374 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3374 8 mean mean VBP 40436 3374 9 what what WP 40436 3374 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3374 11 say say VBP 40436 3374 12 . . . 40436 3375 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3375 2 is be VBZ 40436 3375 3 one one CD 40436 3375 4 who who WP 40436 3375 5 does do VBZ 40436 3375 6 not not RB 40436 3375 7 enslave enslave VB 40436 3375 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3375 9 to to IN 40436 3375 10 any any DT 40436 3375 11 one one CD 40436 3375 12 matter matter NN 40436 3375 13 , , , 40436 3375 14 nor nor CC 40436 3375 15 works work VBZ 40436 3375 16 out out RP 40436 3375 17 any any DT 40436 3375 18 one one NN 40436 3375 19 with with IN 40436 3375 20 such such JJ 40436 3375 21 strictness strictness NN 40436 3375 22 as as IN 40436 3375 23 to to TO 40436 3375 24 neglect neglect VB 40436 3375 25 all all DT 40436 3375 26 others other NNS 40436 3375 27 : : : 40436 3375 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3375 29 attends attend VBZ 40436 3375 30 to to IN 40436 3375 31 all all DT 40436 3375 32 of of IN 40436 3375 33 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3375 34 in in IN 40436 3375 35 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 3375 36 measure measure NN 40436 3375 37 . . . 40436 3376 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3376 2 14 14 CD 40436 3376 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3376 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3376 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3376 6 13 13 CD 40436 3376 7 : : : 40436 3376 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 3376 9 . . . 40436 3377 1 Erast erast VB 40436 3377 2 . . . 40436 3378 1 135 135 CD 40436 3378 2 E e NN 40436 3378 3 , , , 40436 3378 4 136 136 CD 40436 3378 5 A. a. NN 40436 3379 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3379 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3379 3 : : : 40436 3379 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3379 5 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 3379 6 gi gi NNP 40436 3379 7 / / SYM 40436 3379 8 gnesthai gnesthai NNP 40436 3379 9 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 3379 10 pa pa NNP 40436 3379 11 / / SYM 40436 3379 12 nta nta NNP 40436 3379 13 u(/pakro u(/pakro NNP 40436 3379 14 / / SYM 40436 3379 15 n n NNP 40436 3379 16 tina tina NN 40436 3379 17 a)/ndra a)/ndra NNP 40436 3379 18 to\n to\n NNP 40436 3379 19 pephilosophêko pephilosophêko NNP 40436 3379 20 / / SYM 40436 3379 21 ta ta NNP 40436 3379 22 . . . 40436 3379 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3380 1 The the DT 40436 3380 2 five five CD 40436 3380 3 matches match NNS 40436 3380 4 were be VBD 40436 3380 5 leaping leap VBG 40436 3380 6 , , , 40436 3380 7 running run VBG 40436 3380 8 , , , 40436 3380 9 throwing throw VBG 40436 3380 10 the the DT 40436 3380 11 quoit quoit NNP 40436 3380 12 and and CC 40436 3380 13 the the DT 40436 3380 14 javelin javelin NN 40436 3380 15 , , , 40436 3380 16 wrestling wrestle VBG 40436 3380 17 . . . 40436 3380 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3381 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3381 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3381 3 14 14 CD 40436 3381 4 : : : 40436 3381 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 3381 6 . . . 40436 3382 1 Erast erast VB 40436 3382 2 . . . 40436 3383 1 136 136 CD 40436 3383 2 B. B. NNP 40436 3384 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3384 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3384 3 : : : 40436 3384 4 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 3384 5 pa pa NNP 40436 3384 6 / / SYM 40436 3384 7 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 3384 8 metri metri NNP 40436 3384 9 / / SYM 40436 3384 10 ôs ôs NNP 40436 3384 11 e)phê e)phê NNP 40436 3384 12 = = SYM 40436 3384 13 phthai phthai NNP 40436 3384 14 . . . 40436 3384 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3384 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3385 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3385 2 Side side NN 40436 3385 3 - - HYPH 40436 3385 4 note note NN 40436 3385 5 : : : 40436 3385 6 On on IN 40436 3385 7 what what WDT 40436 3385 8 occasions occasion NNS 40436 3385 9 can can MD 40436 3385 10 such such JJ 40436 3385 11 second second RB 40436 3385 12 - - HYPH 40436 3385 13 best good JJS 40436 3385 14 men man NNS 40436 3385 15 be be VB 40436 3385 16 useful useful JJ 40436 3385 17 ? ? . 40436 3386 1 There there EX 40436 3386 2 are be VBP 40436 3386 3 always always RB 40436 3386 4 regular regular JJ 40436 3386 5 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 3386 6 at at IN 40436 3386 7 hand hand NN 40436 3386 8 , , , 40436 3386 9 and and CC 40436 3386 10 no no DT 40436 3386 11 one one NN 40436 3386 12 will will MD 40436 3386 13 call call VB 40436 3386 14 in in IN 40436 3386 15 the the DT 40436 3386 16 second second RB 40436 3386 17 - - HYPH 40436 3386 18 best good JJS 40436 3386 19 man man NN 40436 3386 20 when when WRB 40436 3386 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3386 22 can can MD 40436 3386 23 have have VB 40436 3386 24 the the DT 40436 3386 25 regular regular JJ 40436 3386 26 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 3386 27 . . . 40436 3386 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3387 1 Upon upon IN 40436 3387 2 this this DT 40436 3387 3 answer answer NN 40436 3387 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3387 5 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 3387 6 to to IN 40436 3387 7 cross cross NN 40436 3387 8 - - NN 40436 3387 9 examine examine VB 40436 3387 10 : : : 40436 3387 11 _ _ NNP 40436 3387 12 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 3387 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3387 14 think think VBP 40436 3387 15 that that IN 40436 3387 16 good good JJ 40436 3387 17 men man NNS 40436 3387 18 are be VBP 40436 3387 19 useful useful JJ 40436 3387 20 , , , 40436 3387 21 bad bad JJ 40436 3387 22 men man NNS 40436 3387 23 useless useless JJ 40436 3387 24 ? ? . 40436 3388 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3388 2 Erast._--Yes Erast._--Yes NNP 40436 3388 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3388 4 do do VBP 40436 3388 5 . . . 40436 3389 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3389 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 3389 3 think think VBP 40436 3389 4 that that IN 40436 3389 5 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 3389 6 , , , 40436 3389 7 as as IN 40436 3389 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3389 9 describe describe VBP 40436 3389 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3389 11 , , , 40436 3389 12 are be VBP 40436 3389 13 useful useful JJ 40436 3389 14 ? ? . 40436 3390 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3390 2 Erast._--Certainly erast._--certainly RB 40436 3390 3 : : : 40436 3390 4 extremely extremely RB 40436 3390 5 useful useful JJ 40436 3390 6 . . . 40436 3391 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3391 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 3391 3 tell tell VB 40436 3391 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3391 5 on on IN 40436 3391 6 what what WP 40436 3391 7 occasions occasion NNS 40436 3391 8 such such JJ 40436 3391 9 second second RB 40436 3391 10 - - HYPH 40436 3391 11 best good JJS 40436 3391 12 men man NNS 40436 3391 13 are be VBP 40436 3391 14 useful useful JJ 40436 3391 15 : : : 40436 3391 16 for for IN 40436 3391 17 obviously obviously RB 40436 3391 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3391 19 are be VBP 40436 3391 20 inferior inferior JJ 40436 3391 21 to to IN 40436 3391 22 each each DT 40436 3391 23 separate separate JJ 40436 3391 24 artist artist NN 40436 3391 25 . . . 40436 3392 1 If if IN 40436 3392 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3392 3 fall fall VBP 40436 3392 4 sick sick JJ 40436 3392 5 will will MD 40436 3392 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3392 7 send send VB 40436 3392 8 for for IN 40436 3392 9 one one CD 40436 3392 10 of of IN 40436 3392 11 _ _ NNP 40436 3392 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3392 13 _ _ NNP 40436 3392 14 , , , 40436 3392 15 or or CC 40436 3392 16 for for IN 40436 3392 17 a a DT 40436 3392 18 professional professional JJ 40436 3392 19 physician physician NN 40436 3392 20 ? ? . 40436 3393 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3393 2 Erast._--I erast._--i CD 40436 3393 3 should should MD 40436 3393 4 send send VB 40436 3393 5 for for IN 40436 3393 6 both both DT 40436 3393 7 . . . 40436 3394 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3394 2 Sokr._--That Sokr._--That NNP 40436 3394 3 is be VBZ 40436 3394 4 no no DT 40436 3394 5 answer answer NN 40436 3394 6 : : : 40436 3394 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3394 8 wish wish VBP 40436 3394 9 to to TO 40436 3394 10 know know VB 40436 3394 11 , , , 40436 3394 12 which which WDT 40436 3394 13 of of IN 40436 3394 14 the the DT 40436 3394 15 two two CD 40436 3394 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3394 17 will will MD 40436 3394 18 send send VB 40436 3394 19 for for IN 40436 3394 20 first first RB 40436 3394 21 and and CC 40436 3394 22 by by IN 40436 3394 23 preference preference NN 40436 3394 24 ? ? . 40436 3395 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3395 2 Erast._--No erast._--no NN 40436 3395 3 doubt doubt NN 40436 3395 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3395 5 shall shall MD 40436 3395 6 send send VB 40436 3395 7 for for IN 40436 3395 8 the the DT 40436 3395 9 professional professional JJ 40436 3395 10 physician physician NN 40436 3395 11 . . . 40436 3396 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3396 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 3396 3 like like UH 40436 3396 4 also also RB 40436 3396 5 , , , 40436 3396 6 if if IN 40436 3396 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3396 8 are be VBP 40436 3396 9 in in IN 40436 3396 10 danger danger NN 40436 3396 11 on on IN 40436 3396 12 shipboard shipboard NNP 40436 3396 13 , , , 40436 3396 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3396 15 will will MD 40436 3396 16 entrust entrust VB 40436 3396 17 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3396 18 life life NN 40436 3396 19 to to IN 40436 3396 20 the the DT 40436 3396 21 pilot pilot NN 40436 3396 22 rather rather RB 40436 3396 23 than than IN 40436 3396 24 to to IN 40436 3396 25 the the DT 40436 3396 26 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3396 27 : : : 40436 3396 28 and and CC 40436 3396 29 so so IN 40436 3396 30 as as IN 40436 3396 31 to to IN 40436 3396 32 all all DT 40436 3396 33 other other JJ 40436 3396 34 matters matter NNS 40436 3396 35 , , , 40436 3396 36 as as RB 40436 3396 37 long long RB 40436 3396 38 as as IN 40436 3396 39 a a DT 40436 3396 40 professional professional JJ 40436 3396 41 man man NN 40436 3396 42 is be VBZ 40436 3396 43 to to TO 40436 3396 44 be be VB 40436 3396 45 found find VBN 40436 3396 46 , , , 40436 3396 47 the the DT 40436 3396 48 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3396 49 is be VBZ 40436 3396 50 of of IN 40436 3396 51 no no DT 40436 3396 52 use use NN 40436 3396 53 ? ? . 40436 3397 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3397 2 Erast._--So erast._--so NN 40436 3397 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3397 4 appears appear VBZ 40436 3397 5 . . . 40436 3398 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3398 2 Sokr._--Our Sokr._--Our NNP 40436 3398 3 philosopher philosopher RB 40436 3398 4 then then RB 40436 3398 5 is be VBZ 40436 3398 6 one one CD 40436 3398 7 of of IN 40436 3398 8 the the DT 40436 3398 9 useless useless JJ 40436 3398 10 persons person NNS 40436 3398 11 : : : 40436 3398 12 for for IN 40436 3398 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3398 14 assuredly assuredly RB 40436 3398 15 have have VBP 40436 3398 16 professional professional JJ 40436 3398 17 men man NNS 40436 3398 18 at at IN 40436 3398 19 hand hand NN 40436 3398 20 . . . 40436 3399 1 Now now RB 40436 3399 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3399 3 agreed agree VBD 40436 3399 4 before before RB 40436 3399 5 , , , 40436 3399 6 that that IN 40436 3399 7 good good JJ 40436 3399 8 men man NNS 40436 3399 9 were be VBD 40436 3399 10 useful useful JJ 40436 3399 11 , , , 40436 3399 12 bad bad JJ 40436 3399 13 men man NNS 40436 3399 14 useless useless JJ 40436 3399 15 . . . 40436 3400 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3400 2 15 15 CD 40436 3400 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3400 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3400 5 Erast._--Yes erast._--yes CD 40436 3400 6 ; ; : 40436 3400 7 that that DT 40436 3400 8 was be VBD 40436 3400 9 agreed agree VBN 40436 3400 10 . . . 40436 3401 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3401 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3401 3 15 15 CD 40436 3401 4 : : : 40436 3401 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 3401 6 . . . 40436 3402 1 Erast erast VB 40436 3402 2 . . . 40436 3403 1 136 136 CD 40436 3403 2 C C NNP 40436 3403 3 - - HYPH 40436 3403 4 D. D. NNP 40436 3403 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3403 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3403 7 Side side NN 40436 3403 8 - - HYPH 40436 3403 9 note note NN 40436 3403 10 : : : 40436 3403 11 Philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3403 12 can can MD 40436 3403 13 not not RB 40436 3403 14 consist consist VB 40436 3403 15 in in IN 40436 3403 16 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 3403 17 of of IN 40436 3403 18 learned learn VBN 40436 3403 19 acquirements acquirement NNS 40436 3403 20 . . . 40436 3403 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3404 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3404 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 3404 3 then then RB 40436 3404 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3404 5 have have VBP 40436 3404 6 correctly correctly RB 40436 3404 7 defined define VBN 40436 3404 8 a a DT 40436 3404 9 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3404 10 to to TO 40436 3404 11 be be VB 40436 3404 12 one one CD 40436 3404 13 who who WP 40436 3404 14 has have VBZ 40436 3404 15 a a DT 40436 3404 16 second second JJ 40436 3404 17 - - HYPH 40436 3404 18 rate rate NN 40436 3404 19 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3404 20 on on IN 40436 3404 21 many many JJ 40436 3404 22 subjects subject NNS 40436 3404 23 , , , 40436 3404 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3404 25 is be VBZ 40436 3404 26 useless useless JJ 40436 3404 27 so so RB 40436 3404 28 long long RB 40436 3404 29 as as IN 40436 3404 30 there there EX 40436 3404 31 exist exist VBP 40436 3404 32 professional professional JJ 40436 3404 33 artists artist NNS 40436 3404 34 on on IN 40436 3404 35 each each DT 40436 3404 36 subject subject NN 40436 3404 37 . . . 40436 3405 1 Your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3405 2 definition definition NN 40436 3405 3 can can MD 40436 3405 4 not not RB 40436 3405 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 3405 6 be be VB 40436 3405 7 correct correct JJ 40436 3405 8 . . . 40436 3406 1 Philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3406 2 must must MD 40436 3406 3 be be VB 40436 3406 4 something something NN 40436 3406 5 quite quite RB 40436 3406 6 apart apart RB 40436 3406 7 from from IN 40436 3406 8 this this DT 40436 3406 9 multifarious multifarious JJ 40436 3406 10 and and CC 40436 3406 11 busy busy JJ 40436 3406 12 meddling meddle VBG 40436 3406 13 with with IN 40436 3406 14 different different JJ 40436 3406 15 professional professional JJ 40436 3406 16 subjects subject NNS 40436 3406 17 , , , 40436 3406 18 or or CC 40436 3406 19 this this DT 40436 3406 20 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 3406 21 of of IN 40436 3406 22 learned learn VBN 40436 3406 23 acquirements acquirement NNS 40436 3406 24 . . . 40436 3407 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 3407 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3407 3 fancied fancy VBD 40436 3407 4 , , , 40436 3407 5 that that DT 40436 3407 6 to to TO 40436 3407 7 be be VB 40436 3407 8 absorbed absorb VBN 40436 3407 9 in in IN 40436 3407 10 professional professional JJ 40436 3407 11 subjects subject NNS 40436 3407 12 and and CC 40436 3407 13 in in IN 40436 3407 14 variety variety NN 40436 3407 15 of of IN 40436 3407 16 studies study NNS 40436 3407 17 , , , 40436 3407 18 was be VBD 40436 3407 19 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 3407 20 and and CC 40436 3407 21 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 3407 22 rather rather RB 40436 3407 23 than than IN 40436 3407 24 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 3407 25 . . . 40436 3408 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3408 2 16 16 CD 40436 3408 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3408 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3408 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3408 6 16 16 CD 40436 3408 7 : : : 40436 3408 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3408 9 , , , 40436 3408 10 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3408 11 . . . 40436 3409 1 137 137 CD 40436 3409 2 B. B. NNP 40436 3409 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3410 1 Let let VB 40436 3410 2 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3410 3 now now RB 40436 3410 4 , , , 40436 3410 5 however however RB 40436 3410 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3410 7 continues continue VBZ 40436 3410 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3410 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3410 10 , , , 40436 3410 11 take take VB 40436 3410 12 up up RP 40436 3410 13 the the DT 40436 3410 14 matter matter NN 40436 3410 15 in in IN 40436 3410 16 another another DT 40436 3410 17 way way NN 40436 3410 18 . . . 40436 3411 1 In in IN 40436 3411 2 regard regard NN 40436 3411 3 to to IN 40436 3411 4 horses horse NNS 40436 3411 5 and and CC 40436 3411 6 dogs dog NNS 40436 3411 7 , , , 40436 3411 8 those those DT 40436 3411 9 who who WP 40436 3411 10 punish punish VBP 40436 3411 11 rightly rightly RB 40436 3411 12 are be VBP 40436 3411 13 also also RB 40436 3411 14 those those DT 40436 3411 15 who who WP 40436 3411 16 know know VBP 40436 3411 17 how how WRB 40436 3411 18 to to TO 40436 3411 19 make make VB 40436 3411 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3411 21 better well JJR 40436 3411 22 , , , 40436 3411 23 and and CC 40436 3411 24 to to TO 40436 3411 25 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 3411 26 with with IN 40436 3411 27 most most JJS 40436 3411 28 exactness exactness JJ 40436 3411 29 the the DT 40436 3411 30 good good JJ 40436 3411 31 from from IN 40436 3411 32 the the DT 40436 3411 33 bad bad JJ 40436 3411 34 ? ? . 40436 3412 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3412 2 Erast._--Yes Erast._--Yes NNP 40436 3412 3 : : : 40436 3412 4 such such JJ 40436 3412 5 is be VBZ 40436 3412 6 the the DT 40436 3412 7 fact fact NN 40436 3412 8 . . . 40436 3413 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3413 2 Side side NN 40436 3413 3 - - HYPH 40436 3413 4 note note NN 40436 3413 5 : : : 40436 3413 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3413 7 changes change VBZ 40436 3413 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3413 9 course course NN 40436 3413 10 of of IN 40436 3413 11 examination examination NN 40436 3413 12 -- -- : 40436 3413 13 questions question NNS 40436 3413 14 put put VBP 40436 3413 15 to to TO 40436 3413 16 show show VB 40436 3413 17 that that IN 40436 3413 18 there there EX 40436 3413 19 is be VBZ 40436 3413 20 one one CD 40436 3413 21 special special JJ 40436 3413 22 art art NN 40436 3413 23 , , , 40436 3413 24 regal regal JJ 40436 3413 25 and and CC 40436 3413 26 political political JJ 40436 3413 27 , , , 40436 3413 28 of of IN 40436 3413 29 administering administer VBG 40436 3413 30 and and CC 40436 3413 31 discriminating discriminate VBG 40436 3413 32 the the DT 40436 3413 33 bad bad JJ 40436 3413 34 from from IN 40436 3413 35 the the DT 40436 3413 36 good good NN 40436 3413 37 . . . 40436 3413 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3414 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3414 2 Sokr._--Is Sokr._--Is NNP 40436 3414 3 not not RB 40436 3414 4 the the DT 40436 3414 5 case case NN 40436 3414 6 similar similar JJ 40436 3414 7 with with IN 40436 3414 8 men man NNS 40436 3414 9 ? ? . 40436 3415 1 Is be VBZ 40436 3415 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3415 3 not not RB 40436 3415 4 the the DT 40436 3415 5 same same JJ 40436 3415 6 art art NN 40436 3415 7 , , , 40436 3415 8 which which WDT 40436 3415 9 punishes punish VBZ 40436 3415 10 men man NNS 40436 3415 11 rightly rightly RB 40436 3415 12 , , , 40436 3415 13 makes make VBZ 40436 3415 14 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3415 15 better well JJR 40436 3415 16 , , , 40436 3415 17 and and CC 40436 3415 18 best good JJS 40436 3415 19 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 40436 3415 20 the the DT 40436 3415 21 good good JJ 40436 3415 22 from from IN 40436 3415 23 the the DT 40436 3415 24 bad bad JJ 40436 3415 25 ? ? . 40436 3416 1 whether whether IN 40436 3416 2 applied apply VBD 40436 3416 3 to to IN 40436 3416 4 one one CD 40436 3416 5 , , , 40436 3416 6 few few JJ 40436 3416 7 , , , 40436 3416 8 or or CC 40436 3416 9 many many JJ 40436 3416 10 ? ? . 40436 3417 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3417 2 Erast._--It Erast._--It NNP 40436 3417 3 is be VBZ 40436 3417 4 so so RB 40436 3417 5 . . . 40436 3418 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3418 2 17 17 CD 40436 3418 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3418 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3418 5 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 3418 6 art art NN 40436 3418 7 or or CC 40436 3418 8 science science NN 40436 3418 9 , , , 40436 3418 10 whereby whereby WRB 40436 3418 11 men man NNS 40436 3418 12 punish punish VBP 40436 3418 13 evil evil JJ 40436 3418 14 - - HYPH 40436 3418 15 doers doer NNS 40436 3418 16 rightly rightly RB 40436 3418 17 , , , 40436 3418 18 is be VBZ 40436 3418 19 the the DT 40436 3418 20 judicial judicial JJ 40436 3418 21 or or CC 40436 3418 22 justice justice NN 40436 3418 23 : : : 40436 3418 24 and and CC 40436 3418 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3418 26 is be VBZ 40436 3418 27 by by IN 40436 3418 28 the the DT 40436 3418 29 same same JJ 40436 3418 30 that that WDT 40436 3418 31 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3418 32 know know VBP 40436 3418 33 the the DT 40436 3418 34 good good JJ 40436 3418 35 apart apart RB 40436 3418 36 from from IN 40436 3418 37 the the DT 40436 3418 38 bad bad JJ 40436 3418 39 , , , 40436 3418 40 either either CC 40436 3418 41 one one CD 40436 3418 42 or or CC 40436 3418 43 many many JJ 40436 3418 44 . . . 40436 3419 1 If if IN 40436 3419 2 any any DT 40436 3419 3 man man NN 40436 3419 4 be be VB 40436 3419 5 a a DT 40436 3419 6 stranger stranger NN 40436 3419 7 to to IN 40436 3419 8 this this DT 40436 3419 9 art art NN 40436 3419 10 , , , 40436 3419 11 so so IN 40436 3419 12 as as IN 40436 3419 13 not not RB 40436 3419 14 to to TO 40436 3419 15 know know VB 40436 3419 16 good good JJ 40436 3419 17 men man NNS 40436 3419 18 apart apart RB 40436 3419 19 from from IN 40436 3419 20 bad bad JJ 40436 3419 21 , , , 40436 3419 22 is be VBZ 40436 3419 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3419 24 not not RB 40436 3419 25 also also RB 40436 3419 26 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 3419 27 of of IN 40436 3419 28 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3419 29 , , , 40436 3419 30 whether whether IN 40436 3419 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3419 32 be be VB 40436 3419 33 a a DT 40436 3419 34 good good JJ 40436 3419 35 or or CC 40436 3419 36 a a DT 40436 3419 37 bad bad JJ 40436 3419 38 man man NN 40436 3419 39 ? ? . 40436 3420 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3420 2 Erast._--Yes Erast._--Yes NNP 40436 3420 3 : : : 40436 3420 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3420 5 is be VBZ 40436 3420 6 . . . 40436 3421 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3421 2 Sokr._--To Sokr._--To NNP 40436 3421 3 be be VB 40436 3421 4 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 3421 5 of of IN 40436 3421 6 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 3421 7 , , , 40436 3421 8 is be VBZ 40436 3421 9 to to TO 40436 3421 10 be be VB 40436 3421 11 wanting want VBG 40436 3421 12 in in IN 40436 3421 13 sobriety sobriety NN 40436 3421 14 or or CC 40436 3421 15 temperance temperance NN 40436 3421 16 ; ; : 40436 3421 17 to to TO 40436 3421 18 know know VB 40436 3421 19 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 3421 20 is be VBZ 40436 3421 21 to to TO 40436 3421 22 be be VB 40436 3421 23 sober sober JJ 40436 3421 24 or or CC 40436 3421 25 temperate temperate VB 40436 3421 26 . . . 40436 3422 1 But but CC 40436 3422 2 this this DT 40436 3422 3 is be VBZ 40436 3422 4 the the DT 40436 3422 5 same same JJ 40436 3422 6 art art NN 40436 3422 7 as as IN 40436 3422 8 that that DT 40436 3422 9 by by IN 40436 3422 10 which which WDT 40436 3422 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3422 12 punish punish VBP 40436 3422 13 rightly rightly RB 40436 3422 14 -- -- : 40436 3422 15 or or CC 40436 3422 16 justice justice NN 40436 3422 17 . . . 40436 3423 1 Therefore therefore RB 40436 3423 2 justice justice NN 40436 3423 3 and and CC 40436 3423 4 temperance temperance NN 40436 3423 5 are be VBP 40436 3423 6 the the DT 40436 3423 7 same same JJ 40436 3423 8 : : : 40436 3423 9 and and CC 40436 3423 10 the the DT 40436 3423 11 Delphian delphian JJ 40436 3423 12 rescript rescript NN 40436 3423 13 , , , 40436 3423 14 _ _ NNP 40436 3423 15 Know Know NNP 40436 3423 16 thyself thyself PRP 40436 3423 17 _ _ NNP 40436 3423 18 , , , 40436 3423 19 does do VBZ 40436 3423 20 in in IN 40436 3423 21 fact fact NN 40436 3423 22 enjoin enjoin VB 40436 3423 23 the the DT 40436 3423 24 practice practice NN 40436 3423 25 both both DT 40436 3423 26 of of IN 40436 3423 27 justice justice NN 40436 3423 28 and and CC 40436 3423 29 of of IN 40436 3423 30 sobriety sobriety NN 40436 3423 31 . . . 40436 3424 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3424 2 18 18 CD 40436 3424 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3424 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3424 5 Erast._--So erast._--so NN 40436 3424 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3424 7 appears appear VBZ 40436 3424 8 . . . 40436 3425 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3425 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 3425 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3425 4 is be VBZ 40436 3425 5 by by IN 40436 3425 6 this this DT 40436 3425 7 same same JJ 40436 3425 8 art art NN 40436 3425 9 , , , 40436 3425 10 when when WRB 40436 3425 11 practised practise VBN 40436 3425 12 by by IN 40436 3425 13 a a DT 40436 3425 14 king king NN 40436 3425 15 , , , 40436 3425 16 rightly rightly RB 40436 3425 17 punishing punish VBG 40436 3425 18 evil evil NN 40436 3425 19 - - HYPH 40436 3425 20 doers doer NNS 40436 3425 21 , , , 40436 3425 22 that that IN 40436 3425 23 cities city NNS 40436 3425 24 are be VBP 40436 3425 25 well well RB 40436 3425 26 governed governed JJ 40436 3425 27 ; ; : 40436 3425 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3425 29 is be VBZ 40436 3425 30 by by IN 40436 3425 31 the the DT 40436 3425 32 same same JJ 40436 3425 33 art art NN 40436 3425 34 practised practise VBN 40436 3425 35 by by IN 40436 3425 36 a a DT 40436 3425 37 private private JJ 40436 3425 38 citizen citizen NN 40436 3425 39 or or CC 40436 3425 40 house house NN 40436 3425 41 - - HYPH 40436 3425 42 master master NNP 40436 3425 43 , , , 40436 3425 44 that that IN 40436 3425 45 the the DT 40436 3425 46 house house NN 40436 3425 47 is be VBZ 40436 3425 48 well well RB 40436 3425 49 - - HYPH 40436 3425 50 governed govern VBN 40436 3425 51 : : : 40436 3425 52 so so IN 40436 3425 53 that that IN 40436 3425 54 this this DT 40436 3425 55 art art NN 40436 3425 56 , , , 40436 3425 57 justice justice NN 40436 3425 58 or or CC 40436 3425 59 sobriety sobriety NN 40436 3425 60 , , , 40436 3425 61 is be VBZ 40436 3425 62 at at IN 40436 3425 63 the the DT 40436 3425 64 same same JJ 40436 3425 65 time time NN 40436 3425 66 political political JJ 40436 3425 67 , , , 40436 3425 68 regal regal JJ 40436 3425 69 , , , 40436 3425 70 economical economical JJ 40436 3425 71 ; ; : 40436 3425 72 and and CC 40436 3425 73 the the DT 40436 3425 74 just just JJ 40436 3425 75 and and CC 40436 3425 76 sober sober JJ 40436 3425 77 man man NN 40436 3425 78 is be VBZ 40436 3425 79 at at IN 40436 3425 80 once once RB 40436 3425 81 the the DT 40436 3425 82 true true JJ 40436 3425 83 king king NN 40436 3425 84 , , , 40436 3425 85 statesman statesman NN 40436 3425 86 , , , 40436 3425 87 house house NN 40436 3425 88 - - HYPH 40436 3425 89 master master NNP 40436 3425 90 . . . 40436 3426 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3426 2 19 19 CD 40436 3426 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3426 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3426 5 Erast._--I erast._--i CD 40436 3426 6 admit admit VB 40436 3426 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3426 8 . . . 40436 3427 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3427 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3427 3 17 17 CD 40436 3427 4 : : : 40436 3427 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3427 6 , , , 40436 3427 7 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3427 8 . . . 40436 3428 1 137 137 CD 40436 3428 2 C C NNP 40436 3428 3 - - HYPH 40436 3428 4 D. D. NNP 40436 3428 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3428 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3428 7 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3428 8 18 18 CD 40436 3428 9 : : : 40436 3428 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3428 11 , , , 40436 3428 12 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3428 13 . . . 40436 3429 1 138 138 CD 40436 3429 2 A. a. NN 40436 3429 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3430 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3430 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3430 3 19 19 CD 40436 3430 4 : : : 40436 3430 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3430 6 , , , 40436 3430 7 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3430 8 . . . 40436 3431 1 138 138 CD 40436 3431 2 C. C. NNP 40436 3431 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3431 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3431 5 Side side NN 40436 3431 6 - - HYPH 40436 3431 7 note note NN 40436 3431 8 : : : 40436 3431 9 In in IN 40436 3431 10 this this DT 40436 3431 11 art art NN 40436 3431 12 the the DT 40436 3431 13 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3431 14 must must MD 40436 3431 15 not not RB 40436 3431 16 only only RB 40436 3431 17 be be VB 40436 3431 18 second second RB 40436 3431 19 - - HYPH 40436 3431 20 best good JJS 40436 3431 21 , , , 40436 3431 22 competent competent JJ 40436 3431 23 to to TO 40436 3431 24 talk talk VB 40436 3431 25 -- -- : 40436 3431 26 but but CC 40436 3431 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3431 28 must must MD 40436 3431 29 be be VB 40436 3431 30 a a DT 40436 3431 31 fully fully RB 40436 3431 32 qualified qualified JJ 40436 3431 33 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 3431 34 , , , 40436 3431 35 competent competent JJ 40436 3431 36 to to TO 40436 3431 37 act act VB 40436 3431 38 . . . 40436 3431 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3432 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3432 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 3432 3 let let VB 40436 3432 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3432 5 ask ask VB 40436 3432 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3432 7 . . . 40436 3433 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3433 2 said say VBD 40436 3433 3 that that IN 40436 3433 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3433 5 was be VBD 40436 3433 6 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 3433 7 for for IN 40436 3433 8 the the DT 40436 3433 9 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3433 10 , , , 40436 3433 11 when when WRB 40436 3433 12 in in IN 40436 3433 13 company company NN 40436 3433 14 with with IN 40436 3433 15 a a DT 40436 3433 16 physician physician NN 40436 3433 17 or or CC 40436 3433 18 any any DT 40436 3433 19 other other JJ 40436 3433 20 craftsman craftsman NN 40436 3433 21 talking talk VBG 40436 3433 22 about about IN 40436 3433 23 matters matter NNS 40436 3433 24 of of IN 40436 3433 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3433 26 own own JJ 40436 3433 27 craft craft NN 40436 3433 28 , , , 40436 3433 29 not not RB 40436 3433 30 to to TO 40436 3433 31 be be VB 40436 3433 32 able able JJ 40436 3433 33 to to TO 40436 3433 34 follow follow VB 40436 3433 35 what what WP 40436 3433 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3433 37 said say VBD 40436 3433 38 and and CC 40436 3433 39 comment comment VB 40436 3433 40 upon upon IN 40436 3433 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3433 42 . . . 40436 3434 1 Would Would MD 40436 3434 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3434 3 not not RB 40436 3434 4 also also RB 40436 3434 5 be be VB 40436 3434 6 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 3434 7 to to IN 40436 3434 8 the the DT 40436 3434 9 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3434 10 , , , 40436 3434 11 when when WRB 40436 3434 12 listening listen VBG 40436 3434 13 to to IN 40436 3434 14 any any DT 40436 3434 15 king king NN 40436 3434 16 , , , 40436 3434 17 judge judge NN 40436 3434 18 , , , 40436 3434 19 or or CC 40436 3434 20 house house NN 40436 3434 21 - - HYPH 40436 3434 22 master master NNP 40436 3434 23 , , , 40436 3434 24 about about IN 40436 3434 25 professional professional JJ 40436 3434 26 affairs affair NNS 40436 3434 27 , , , 40436 3434 28 not not RB 40436 3434 29 to to TO 40436 3434 30 be be VB 40436 3434 31 able able JJ 40436 3434 32 to to TO 40436 3434 33 understand understand VB 40436 3434 34 and and CC 40436 3434 35 comment comment VB 40436 3434 36 ? ? . 40436 3435 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3435 2 Erast._--Assuredly erast._--assuredly RB 40436 3435 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3435 4 would would MD 40436 3435 5 be be VB 40436 3435 6 most most RBS 40436 3435 7 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 3435 8 upon upon IN 40436 3435 9 matters matter NNS 40436 3435 10 of of IN 40436 3435 11 such such JJ 40436 3435 12 grave grave JJ 40436 3435 13 moment moment NN 40436 3435 14 . . . 40436 3436 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3436 2 Sokr._--Shall Sokr._--Shall NNP 40436 3436 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3436 4 say say VBP 40436 3436 5 then then RB 40436 3436 6 , , , 40436 3436 7 that that IN 40436 3436 8 upon upon IN 40436 3436 9 these these DT 40436 3436 10 matters matter NNS 40436 3436 11 also also RB 40436 3436 12 , , , 40436 3436 13 as as RB 40436 3436 14 well well RB 40436 3436 15 as as IN 40436 3436 16 all all DT 40436 3436 17 others other NNS 40436 3436 18 , , , 40436 3436 19 the the DT 40436 3436 20 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3436 21 ought ought MD 40436 3436 22 to to TO 40436 3436 23 be be VB 40436 3436 24 a a DT 40436 3436 25 Pentathlus Pentathlus NNP 40436 3436 26 or or CC 40436 3436 27 second second JJ 40436 3436 28 - - HYPH 40436 3436 29 rate rate NN 40436 3436 30 performer performer NN 40436 3436 31 , , , 40436 3436 32 useless useless JJ 40436 3436 33 so so RB 40436 3436 34 long long RB 40436 3436 35 as as IN 40436 3436 36 the the DT 40436 3436 37 special special JJ 40436 3436 38 craftsman craftsman NN 40436 3436 39 is be VBZ 40436 3436 40 at at IN 40436 3436 41 hand hand NN 40436 3436 42 ? ? . 40436 3437 1 or or CC 40436 3437 2 shall shall MD 40436 3437 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3437 4 not not RB 40436 3437 5 rather rather RB 40436 3437 6 affirm affirm VB 40436 3437 7 , , , 40436 3437 8 that that IN 40436 3437 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3437 10 must must MD 40436 3437 11 not not RB 40436 3437 12 confide confide VB 40436 3437 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3437 14 own own JJ 40436 3437 15 house house NN 40436 3437 16 to to IN 40436 3437 17 any any DT 40436 3437 18 one one NN 40436 3437 19 else else RB 40436 3437 20 , , , 40436 3437 21 nor nor CC 40436 3437 22 be be VB 40436 3437 23 the the DT 40436 3437 24 second second RB 40436 3437 25 - - HYPH 40436 3437 26 best good JJS 40436 3437 27 within within IN 40436 3437 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3437 29 , , , 40436 3437 30 but but CC 40436 3437 31 must must MD 40436 3437 32 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3437 33 judge judge VB 40436 3437 34 and and CC 40436 3437 35 punish punish VB 40436 3437 36 rightly rightly RB 40436 3437 37 , , , 40436 3437 38 if if IN 40436 3437 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3437 40 house house NN 40436 3437 41 is be VBZ 40436 3437 42 to to TO 40436 3437 43 be be VB 40436 3437 44 well well RB 40436 3437 45 administered administer VBN 40436 3437 46 ? ? . 40436 3438 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3438 2 Erast._--That erast._--that CD 40436 3438 3 too too RB 40436 3438 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3438 5 admit admit VBP 40436 3438 6 . . . 40436 3439 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3439 2 20 20 CD 40436 3439 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3439 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3439 5 Sokr._--Farther Sokr._--Farther NNP 40436 3439 6 , , , 40436 3439 7 if if IN 40436 3439 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3439 9 friends friend NNS 40436 3439 10 shall shall MD 40436 3439 11 entrust entrust VB 40436 3439 12 to to IN 40436 3439 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3439 14 the the DT 40436 3439 15 arbitration arbitration NN 40436 3439 16 of of IN 40436 3439 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3439 18 disputes,--if disputes,--if NN 40436 3439 19 the the DT 40436 3439 20 city city NN 40436 3439 21 shall shall MD 40436 3439 22 command command VB 40436 3439 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3439 24 to to TO 40436 3439 25 act act VB 40436 3439 26 as as IN 40436 3439 27 Dikast Dikast NNP 40436 3439 28 or or CC 40436 3439 29 to to TO 40436 3439 30 settle settle VB 40436 3439 31 any any DT 40436 3439 32 difficulty,--in difficulty,--in NN 40436 3439 33 those those DT 40436 3439 34 cases case NNS 40436 3439 35 also also RB 40436 3439 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3439 37 will will MD 40436 3439 38 be be VB 40436 3439 39 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 3439 40 for for IN 40436 3439 41 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3439 42 to to TO 40436 3439 43 stand stand VB 40436 3439 44 second second JJ 40436 3439 45 or or CC 40436 3439 46 third third JJ 40436 3439 47 , , , 40436 3439 48 and and CC 40436 3439 49 not not RB 40436 3439 50 to to TO 40436 3439 51 be be VB 40436 3439 52 first first JJ 40436 3439 53 - - HYPH 40436 3439 54 rate rate NN 40436 3439 55 ? ? . 40436 3440 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3440 2 Erast._--I erast._--i CD 40436 3440 3 think think VBP 40436 3440 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3440 5 will will MD 40436 3440 6 be be VB 40436 3440 7 . . . 40436 3441 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3441 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 3441 3 see see VBP 40436 3441 4 then then RB 40436 3441 5 , , , 40436 3441 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3441 7 friend friend NN 40436 3441 8 , , , 40436 3441 9 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3441 10 is be VBZ 40436 3441 11 something something NN 40436 3441 12 very very RB 40436 3441 13 different different JJ 40436 3441 14 from from IN 40436 3441 15 much much JJ 40436 3441 16 learning learning NN 40436 3441 17 and and CC 40436 3441 18 acquaintance acquaintance NN 40436 3441 19 with with IN 40436 3441 20 multifarious multifarious JJ 40436 3441 21 arts art NNS 40436 3441 22 or or CC 40436 3441 23 sciences science NNS 40436 3441 24 . . . 40436 3442 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3442 2 21 21 CD 40436 3442 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3442 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3442 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3442 6 20 20 CD 40436 3442 7 : : : 40436 3442 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3442 9 , , , 40436 3442 10 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3442 11 . . . 40436 3443 1 138 138 CD 40436 3443 2 E. E. NNP 40436 3443 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3443 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3443 5 : : : 40436 3443 6 Po Po NNP 40436 3443 7 / / SYM 40436 3443 8 teron teron NNP 40436 3443 9 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 3443 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3443 11 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 3443 12 tau tau NNP 40436 3443 13 = = SYM 40436 3443 14 ta ta NNP 40436 3443 15 le le NNP 40436 3443 16 / / SYM 40436 3443 17 gômen gômen NNP 40436 3443 18 , , , 40436 3443 19 pe pe NNP 40436 3443 20 / / SYM 40436 3443 21 ntathlon ntathlon NNP 40436 3443 22 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 3443 23 dei dei NNP 40436 3443 24 = = SYM 40436 3443 25 n n NNP 40436 3443 26 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 3443 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3443 28 u(/pakron u(/pakron NNP 40436 3443 29 , , , 40436 3443 30 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 3443 31 deuterei deuterei NN 40436 3443 32 = = NNS 40436 3443 33 a a DT 40436 3443 34 e)/chonta e)/chonta NNP 40436 3443 35 pa pa NNP 40436 3443 36 / / SYM 40436 3443 37 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 3443 38 , , , 40436 3443 39 to\n to\n NNP 40436 3443 40 philo philo NNP 40436 3443 41 / / SYM 40436 3443 42 sophon sophon NNP 40436 3443 43 , , , 40436 3443 44 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3443 45 a)chrei a)chrei NNP 40436 3443 46 = = SYM 40436 3443 47 on on IN 40436 3443 48 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 3443 49 , , , 40436 3443 50 e(/ôs e(/ôs NNP 40436 3443 51 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 3443 52 tou tou NNP 40436 3443 53 / / SYM 40436 3443 54 tôn tôn NNP 40436 3443 55 tis tis NNP 40436 3443 56 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 3443 57 ? ? . 40436 3444 1 ê)\ ê)\ IN 40436 3444 2 prô prô NNP 40436 3444 3 = = SYM 40436 3444 4 ton ton NN 40436 3444 5 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3444 6 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 3444 7 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 3444 8 oi)ki oi)ki NNP 40436 3444 9 / / , 40436 3444 10 an an DT 40436 3444 11 ou)k ou)k JJ 40436 3444 12 a)llô| a)llô| NN 40436 3444 13 e)pitrepte e)pitrepte VB 40436 3444 14 / / SYM 40436 3444 15 on on IN 40436 3444 16 ou)de ou)de NNPS 40436 3444 17 ta\ ta\ JJ 40436 3444 18 deuterei deuterei NN 40436 3444 19 = = NNS 40436 3444 20 a a DT 40436 3444 21 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3444 22 tou tou NNP 40436 3444 23 / / SYM 40436 3444 24 tô| tô| NNP 40436 3444 25 e(kte e(kte NNP 40436 3444 26 / / SYM 40436 3444 27 on on RB 40436 3444 28 , , , 40436 3444 29 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 3444 30 ' ' POS 40436 3444 31 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 3444 32 kolaste kolaste NNP 40436 3444 33 / / SYM 40436 3444 34 on on IN 40436 3444 35 dika dika NNP 40436 3444 36 / / SYM 40436 3444 37 zonta zonta NNP 40436 3444 38 o)rthô o)rthô NNPS 40436 3444 39 = = SYM 40436 3444 40 s s NNP 40436 3444 41 , , , 40436 3444 42 ei ei NNP 40436 3444 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3444 44 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3444 45 / / SYM 40436 3444 46 llei llei NN 40436 3444 47 eu)= eu)= '' 40436 3444 48 oi)kei oi)kei NNP 40436 3444 49 = = SYM 40436 3444 50 sthai sthai NNP 40436 3444 51 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 3444 52 ê ê NNP 40436 3444 53 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3444 54 oi)ki oi)ki NNP 40436 3444 55 / / SYM 40436 3444 56 a a NN 40436 3444 57 ? ? . 40436 3444 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3444 59 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3445 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3445 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3445 3 21 21 CD 40436 3445 4 : : : 40436 3445 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3445 6 , , , 40436 3445 7 Erast Erast NNP 40436 3445 8 . . . 40436 3446 1 139 139 CD 40436 3446 2 A. a. NN 40436 3447 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3447 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3447 3 : : : 40436 3447 4 Pollou= pollou= XX 40436 3447 5 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 3447 6 dei= dei= NNP 40436 3447 7 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 3447 8 = = SYM 40436 3447 9 n n NN 40436 3447 10 , , , 40436 3447 11 ô)= ô)= UH 40436 3447 12 be be VB 40436 3447 13 / / SYM 40436 3447 14 ltiste ltiste NN 40436 3447 15 , , , 40436 3447 16 to\ to\ NN 40436 3447 17 philosophei philosophei NN 40436 3447 18 = = SYM 40436 3447 19 n n CC 40436 3447 20 poluma poluma NNP 40436 3447 21 / / SYM 40436 3447 22 theia/ theia/ NNP 40436 3447 23 te te NNP 40436 3447 24 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 3447 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3447 26 ê ê NNP 40436 3447 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3447 28 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 3447 29 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 3447 30 te te NNP 40436 3447 31 / / SYM 40436 3447 32 chnas chnas NNP 40436 3447 33 pragmatei pragmatei NNP 40436 3447 34 / / SYM 40436 3447 35 a a NN 40436 3447 36 . . . 40436 3447 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3447 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3448 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3448 2 Side side NN 40436 3448 3 - - HYPH 40436 3448 4 note note NN 40436 3448 5 : : : 40436 3448 6 Close close NN 40436 3448 7 of of IN 40436 3448 8 the the DT 40436 3448 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3448 10 -- -- : 40436 3448 11 humiliation humiliation NN 40436 3448 12 of of IN 40436 3448 13 the the DT 40436 3448 14 literary literary JJ 40436 3448 15 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 3448 16 . . . 40436 3448 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3449 1 Upon upon IN 40436 3449 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3449 3 saying say VBG 40436 3449 4 this this DT 40436 3449 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3449 6 so so RB 40436 3449 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3449 8 concludes conclude VBZ 40436 3449 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3449 10 recital recital NN 40436 3449 11 of of IN 40436 3449 12 the the DT 40436 3449 13 conversation conversation NN 40436 3449 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3449 15 the the DT 40436 3449 16 literary literary JJ 40436 3449 17 one one CD 40436 3449 18 of of IN 40436 3449 19 the the DT 40436 3449 20 two two CD 40436 3449 21 rivals rival NNS 40436 3449 22 was be VBD 40436 3449 23 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 3449 24 and and CC 40436 3449 25 held hold VBD 40436 3449 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3449 27 peace peace NN 40436 3449 28 ; ; : 40436 3449 29 while while IN 40436 3449 30 the the DT 40436 3449 31 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 3449 32 rival rival NN 40436 3449 33 declared declare VBD 40436 3449 34 that that IN 40436 3449 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3449 36 was be VBD 40436 3449 37 in in IN 40436 3449 38 the the DT 40436 3449 39 right right NN 40436 3449 40 , , , 40436 3449 41 and and CC 40436 3449 42 the the DT 40436 3449 43 other other JJ 40436 3449 44 hearers hearer NNS 40436 3449 45 also also RB 40436 3449 46 commended commend VBD 40436 3449 47 what what WP 40436 3449 48 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3449 49 had have VBD 40436 3449 50 said say VBD 40436 3449 51 . . . 40436 3450 1 * * NFP 40436 3450 2 * * NFP 40436 3450 3 * * NFP 40436 3450 4 * * NFP 40436 3450 5 * * NFP 40436 3450 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3450 7 Side side NN 40436 3450 8 - - HYPH 40436 3450 9 note note NN 40436 3450 10 : : : 40436 3450 11 Remarks remark NNS 40436 3450 12 -- -- : 40436 3450 13 animated animate VBN 40436 3450 14 manner manner NN 40436 3450 15 of of IN 40436 3450 16 the the DT 40436 3450 17 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3450 18 . . . 40436 3450 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3451 1 The the DT 40436 3451 2 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 3451 3 between between IN 40436 3451 4 the the DT 40436 3451 5 philo philo JJ 40436 3451 6 - - HYPH 40436 3451 7 gymnast gymnast NN 40436 3451 8 , , , 40436 3451 9 hater hater NN 40436 3451 10 of of IN 40436 3451 11 philosophy,--and philosophy,--and CC 40436 3451 12 the the DT 40436 3451 13 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 40436 3451 14 admirer admirer NN 40436 3451 15 of of IN 40436 3451 16 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3451 17 , , , 40436 3451 18 who who WP 40436 3451 19 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 3451 20 can can MD 40436 3451 21 not not RB 40436 3451 22 explain explain VB 40436 3451 23 what what WP 40436 3451 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3451 25 is be VBZ 40436 3451 26 -- -- : 40436 3451 27 gives give VBZ 40436 3451 28 much much JJ 40436 3451 29 point point NN 40436 3451 30 and and CC 40436 3451 31 vivacity vivacity NN 40436 3451 32 to to IN 40436 3451 33 this this DT 40436 3451 34 short short JJ 40436 3451 35 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3451 36 . . . 40436 3452 1 This this DT 40436 3452 2 last last JJ 40436 3452 3 person person NN 40436 3452 4 is be VBZ 40436 3452 5 exhibited exhibit VBN 40436 3452 6 as as IN 40436 3452 7 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 3452 8 presumptuous presumptuous JJ 40436 3452 9 and and CC 40436 3452 10 confident confident JJ 40436 3452 11 ; ; : 40436 3452 12 thus thus RB 40436 3452 13 affording afford VBG 40436 3452 14 a a DT 40436 3452 15 sort sort NN 40436 3452 16 of of IN 40436 3452 17 excuse excuse NN 40436 3452 18 for for IN 40436 3452 19 the the DT 40436 3452 20 humiliating humiliating JJ 40436 3452 21 cross cross NN 40436 3452 22 - - NN 40436 3452 23 examination examination JJ 40436 3452 24 put put VBD 40436 3452 25 upon upon IN 40436 3452 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3452 27 by by IN 40436 3452 28 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3452 29 to to IN 40436 3452 30 the the DT 40436 3452 31 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 3452 32 of of IN 40436 3452 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3452 34 stupid stupid JJ 40436 3452 35 rival rival NN 40436 3452 36 . . . 40436 3453 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 3453 2 , , , 40436 3453 3 the the DT 40436 3453 4 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 3453 5 introduction introduction NN 40436 3453 6 is be VBZ 40436 3453 7 full full JJ 40436 3453 8 of of IN 40436 3453 9 animation animation NN 40436 3453 10 , , , 40436 3453 11 like like IN 40436 3453 12 that that DT 40436 3453 13 of of IN 40436 3453 14 the the DT 40436 3453 15 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 3453 16 and and CC 40436 3453 17 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 3453 18 . . . 40436 3454 1 Besides besides IN 40436 3454 2 the the DT 40436 3454 3 animated animated JJ 40436 3454 4 style style NN 40436 3454 5 of of IN 40436 3454 6 the the DT 40436 3454 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3454 8 , , , 40436 3454 9 the the DT 40436 3454 10 points point NNS 40436 3454 11 raised raise VBD 40436 3454 12 for for IN 40436 3454 13 discussion discussion NN 40436 3454 14 in in IN 40436 3454 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3454 16 are be VBP 40436 3454 17 of of IN 40436 3454 18 much much JJ 40436 3454 19 interest interest NN 40436 3454 20 . . . 40436 3455 1 The the DT 40436 3455 2 word word NN 40436 3455 3 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3455 4 has have VBZ 40436 3455 5 at at IN 40436 3455 6 all all DT 40436 3455 7 times time NNS 40436 3455 8 been be VBN 40436 3455 9 vague vague JJ 40436 3455 10 and and CC 40436 3455 11 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 40436 3455 12 . . . 40436 3456 1 Certainly certainly RB 40436 3456 2 no no DT 40436 3456 3 one one NN 40436 3456 4 before before IN 40436 3456 5 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3456 6 -- -- : 40436 3456 7 probably probably RB 40436 3456 8 no no DT 40436 3456 9 one one NN 40436 3456 10 before before IN 40436 3456 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3456 12 -- -- : 40436 3456 13 ever ever RB 40436 3456 14 sought seek VBD 40436 3456 15 a a DT 40436 3456 16 definition definition NN 40436 3456 17 of of IN 40436 3456 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3456 19 . . . 40436 3457 1 In in IN 40436 3457 2 no no DT 40436 3457 3 other other JJ 40436 3457 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3457 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3457 6 than than IN 40436 3457 7 this this DT 40436 3457 8 , , , 40436 3457 9 is be VBZ 40436 3457 10 the the DT 40436 3457 11 definition definition NN 40436 3457 12 of of IN 40436 3457 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3457 14 made make VBD 40436 3457 15 a a DT 40436 3457 16 special special JJ 40436 3457 17 topic topic NN 40436 3457 18 of of IN 40436 3457 19 research research NN 40436 3457 20 . . . 40436 3458 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3458 2 Side side NN 40436 3458 3 - - HYPH 40436 3458 4 note note NN 40436 3458 5 : : : 40436 3458 6 Definition definition NN 40436 3458 7 of of IN 40436 3458 8 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3458 9 -- -- : 40436 3458 10 here here RB 40436 3458 11 sought seek VBN 40436 3458 12 for for IN 40436 3458 13 the the DT 40436 3458 14 first first JJ 40436 3458 15 time time NN 40436 3458 16 -- -- : 40436 3458 17 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3458 18 conception conception NN 40436 3458 19 of of IN 40436 3458 20 measure measure NN 40436 3458 21 -- -- : 40436 3458 22 referee referee NN 40436 3458 23 not not RB 40436 3458 24 discovered discover VBN 40436 3458 25 . . . 40436 3458 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3459 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3459 2 is be VBZ 40436 3459 3 here here RB 40436 3459 4 handled handle VBN 40436 3459 5 in in IN 40436 3459 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3459 7 's 's POS 40436 3459 8 negative negative JJ 40436 3459 9 , , , 40436 3459 10 elenchtic elenchtic JJ 40436 3459 11 , , , 40436 3459 12 tentative tentative JJ 40436 3459 13 , , , 40436 3459 14 manner manner NN 40436 3459 15 . . . 40436 3460 1 By by IN 40436 3460 2 some some DT 40436 3460 3 of of IN 40436 3460 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3460 5 contemporaries contemporary NNS 40436 3460 6 , , , 40436 3460 7 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3460 8 was be VBD 40436 3460 9 really really RB 40436 3460 10 considered consider VBN 40436 3460 11 as as IN 40436 3460 12 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 3460 13 to to IN 40436 3460 14 polymathy polymathy NN 40436 3460 15 , , , 40436 3460 16 or or CC 40436 3460 17 to to IN 40436 3460 18 much much JJ 40436 3460 19 and and CC 40436 3460 20 varied varied JJ 40436 3460 21 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3460 22 : : : 40436 3460 23 so so CC 40436 3460 24 at at IN 40436 3460 25 least least JJS 40436 3460 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3460 27 represents represent VBZ 40436 3460 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3460 29 as as IN 40436 3460 30 being be VBG 40436 3460 31 considered consider VBN 40436 3460 32 by by IN 40436 3460 33 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 3460 34 the the DT 40436 3460 35 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 3460 36 , , , 40436 3460 37 contrary contrary JJ 40436 3460 38 to to IN 40436 3460 39 the the DT 40436 3460 40 opinion opinion NN 40436 3460 41 of of IN 40436 3460 42 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 3460 43 . . . 40436 3461 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3461 2 22 22 CD 40436 3461 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3461 4 The the DT 40436 3461 5 exception exception NN 40436 3461 6 taken take VBN 40436 3461 7 by by IN 40436 3461 8 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3461 9 to to IN 40436 3461 10 a a DT 40436 3461 11 definition definition NN 40436 3461 12 founded found VBN 40436 3461 13 on on IN 40436 3461 14 simple simple JJ 40436 3461 15 quantity quantity NN 40436 3461 16 , , , 40436 3461 17 without without IN 40436 3461 18 any any DT 40436 3461 19 standard standard JJ 40436 3461 20 point point NN 40436 3461 21 of of IN 40436 3461 22 sufficiency sufficiency NN 40436 3461 23 by by IN 40436 3461 24 which which WDT 40436 3461 25 much much JJ 40436 3461 26 or or CC 40436 3461 27 little little JJ 40436 3461 28 is be VBZ 40436 3461 29 to to TO 40436 3461 30 be be VB 40436 3461 31 measured measure VBN 40436 3461 32 , , , 40436 3461 33 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 3461 34 that that IN 40436 3461 35 governing govern VBG 40436 3461 36 idea idea NN 40436 3461 37 of of IN 40436 3461 38 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3461 39 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3461 40 : : : 40436 3461 41 to\ to\ VB 40436 3461 42 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3461 43 / / SYM 40436 3461 44 trion trion NN 40436 3461 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3461 46 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3461 47 the the DT 40436 3461 48 moderate moderate JJ 40436 3461 49 , , , 40436 3461 50 that that DT 40436 3461 51 which which WDT 40436 3461 52 conforms conform VBZ 40436 3461 53 to to IN 40436 3461 54 a a DT 40436 3461 55 standard standard JJ 40436 3461 56 measure measure NN 40436 3461 57 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3461 58 upon upon IN 40436 3461 59 which which WDT 40436 3461 60 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3461 61 insists insist VBZ 40436 3461 62 so so RB 40436 3461 63 much much RB 40436 3461 64 in in IN 40436 3461 65 other other JJ 40436 3461 66 more more JJR 40436 3461 67 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 3461 68 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3461 69 . . . 40436 3462 1 The the DT 40436 3462 2 conception conception NN 40436 3462 3 of of IN 40436 3462 4 a a DT 40436 3462 5 measure measure NN 40436 3462 6 , , , 40436 3462 7 of of IN 40436 3462 8 a a DT 40436 3462 9 standard standard NN 40436 3462 10 of of IN 40436 3462 11 measurement measurement NN 40436 3462 12 -- -- : 40436 3462 13 and and CC 40436 3462 14 of of IN 40436 3462 15 conformity conformity NN 40436 3462 16 thereunto thereunto NNS 40436 3462 17 , , , 40436 3462 18 as as IN 40436 3462 19 the the DT 40436 3462 20 main main JJ 40436 3462 21 constituent constituent NN 40436 3462 22 of of IN 40436 3462 23 what what WP 40436 3462 24 is be VBZ 40436 3462 25 good good JJ 40436 3462 26 and and CC 40436 3462 27 desirable desirable JJ 40436 3462 28 -- -- : 40436 3462 29 stands stand VBZ 40436 3462 30 prominent prominent JJ 40436 3462 31 in in IN 40436 3462 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3462 33 mind,[23 mind,[23 CD 40436 3462 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3462 35 though though IN 40436 3462 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3462 37 is be VBZ 40436 3462 38 not not RB 40436 3462 39 always always RB 40436 3462 40 handled handle VBN 40436 3462 41 in in IN 40436 3462 42 the the DT 40436 3462 43 same same JJ 40436 3462 44 way way NN 40436 3462 45 . . . 40436 3463 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3463 2 have have VBP 40436 3463 3 seen see VBN 40436 3463 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3463 5 , , , 40436 3463 6 in in IN 40436 3463 7 the the DT 40436 3463 8 Second Second NNP 40436 3463 9 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 3463 10 , , , 40436 3463 11 indicated indicate VBD 40436 3463 12 under under IN 40436 3463 13 another another DT 40436 3463 14 name name NN 40436 3463 15 as as IN 40436 3463 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3463 17 of of IN 40436 3463 18 Good good JJ 40436 3463 19 or or CC 40436 3463 20 of of IN 40436 3463 21 the the DT 40436 3463 22 Best good JJS 40436 3463 23 : : : 40436 3463 24 without without IN 40436 3463 25 which which WDT 40436 3463 26 , , , 40436 3463 27 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3463 28 on on IN 40436 3463 29 special special JJ 40436 3463 30 matters matter NNS 40436 3463 31 was be VBD 40436 3463 32 declared declare VBN 40436 3463 33 to to TO 40436 3463 34 be be VB 40436 3463 35 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 3463 36 rather rather RB 40436 3463 37 than than IN 40436 3463 38 useful useful JJ 40436 3463 39 . . . 40436 3464 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3464 2 24 24 CD 40436 3464 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3464 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3464 5 considers consider VBZ 40436 3464 6 that that IN 40436 3464 7 this this DT 40436 3464 8 Measure measure NN 40436 3464 9 is be VBZ 40436 3464 10 neither neither CC 40436 3464 11 discernible discernible JJ 40436 3464 12 nor nor CC 40436 3464 13 applicable applicable JJ 40436 3464 14 except except IN 40436 3464 15 by by IN 40436 3464 16 a a DT 40436 3464 17 specially specially RB 40436 3464 18 trained train VBN 40436 3464 19 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3464 20 . . . 40436 3465 1 In in IN 40436 3465 2 the the DT 40436 3465 3 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3465 4 as as IN 40436 3465 5 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 3465 6 , , , 40436 3465 7 such such PDT 40436 3465 8 an an DT 40436 3465 9 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3465 10 is be VBZ 40436 3465 11 called call VBN 40436 3465 12 for for IN 40436 3465 13 in in IN 40436 3465 14 general general JJ 40436 3465 15 terms term NNS 40436 3465 16 : : : 40436 3465 17 but but CC 40436 3465 18 when when WRB 40436 3465 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3465 20 is be VBZ 40436 3465 21 asked ask VBN 40436 3465 22 , , , 40436 3465 23 Where where WRB 40436 3465 24 is be VBZ 40436 3465 25 the the DT 40436 3465 26 person person NN 40436 3465 27 possessing possess VBG 40436 3465 28 such such JJ 40436 3465 29 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3465 30 , , , 40436 3465 31 available available JJ 40436 3465 32 in in IN 40436 3465 33 the the DT 40436 3465 34 case case NN 40436 3465 35 of of IN 40436 3465 36 mental mental JJ 40436 3465 37 training training NN 40436 3465 38 -- -- : 40436 3465 39 neither neither CC 40436 3465 40 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3465 41 nor nor CC 40436 3465 42 any any DT 40436 3465 43 one one NN 40436 3465 44 else else RB 40436 3465 45 can can MD 40436 3465 46 point point VB 40436 3465 47 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3465 48 out out RP 40436 3465 49 . . . 40436 3466 1 To to TO 40436 3466 2 suggest suggest VB 40436 3466 3 a a DT 40436 3466 4 question question NN 40436 3466 5 , , , 40436 3466 6 and and CC 40436 3466 7 direct direct JJ 40436 3466 8 attention attention NN 40436 3466 9 to to IN 40436 3466 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3466 11 , , , 40436 3466 12 yet yet CC 40436 3466 13 still still RB 40436 3466 14 to to TO 40436 3466 15 leave leave VB 40436 3466 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3466 17 unanswered unanswered JJ 40436 3466 18 -- -- : 40436 3466 19 is be VBZ 40436 3466 20 a a DT 40436 3466 21 practice practice NN 40436 3466 22 familiar familiar JJ 40436 3466 23 with with IN 40436 3466 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3466 25 . . . 40436 3467 1 In in IN 40436 3467 2 this this DT 40436 3467 3 respect respect NN 40436 3467 4 the the DT 40436 3467 5 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3467 6 is be VBZ 40436 3467 7 like like IN 40436 3467 8 other other JJ 40436 3467 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3467 10 . . . 40436 3468 1 The the DT 40436 3468 2 answer answer NN 40436 3468 3 , , , 40436 3468 4 if if IN 40436 3468 5 any any DT 40436 3468 6 , , , 40436 3468 7 intended intend VBN 40436 3468 8 to to TO 40436 3468 9 be be VB 40436 3468 10 understood understand VBN 40436 3468 11 or or CC 40436 3468 12 divined divine VBN 40436 3468 13 , , , 40436 3468 14 is be VBZ 40436 3468 15 , , , 40436 3468 16 that that IN 40436 3468 17 such such PDT 40436 3468 18 an an DT 40436 3468 19 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3468 20 is be VBZ 40436 3468 21 the the DT 40436 3468 22 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3468 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3468 24 . . . 40436 3469 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3469 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3469 3 22 22 CD 40436 3469 4 : : : 40436 3469 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3469 6 , , , 40436 3469 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 3469 8 . . . 40436 3470 1 318 318 CD 40436 3470 2 E. E. NNP 40436 3470 3 Compare Compare NNP 40436 3470 4 too too RB 40436 3470 5 , , , 40436 3470 6 the the DT 40436 3470 7 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3470 8 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3470 9 , , , 40436 3470 10 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 3470 11 Major Major NNP 40436 3470 12 and and CC 40436 3470 13 Minor Minor NNP 40436 3470 14 . . . 40436 3470 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3471 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3471 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3471 3 23 23 CD 40436 3471 4 : : : 40436 3471 5 See see VB 40436 3471 6 about about RB 40436 3471 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3471 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3471 9 : : : 40436 3471 10 ê ê NNP 40436 3471 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3471 12 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3471 13 metri metri NN 40436 3471 14 / / SYM 40436 3471 15 ou ou NNP 40436 3471 16 phu phu NNP 40436 3471 17 / / SYM 40436 3471 18 sis sis NN 40436 3471 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3471 20 as as IN 40436 3471 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3471 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3471 23 : : : 40436 3471 24 ou)si ou)si NNP 40436 3471 25 / / SYM 40436 3471 26 a]--as a]--as NNP 40436 3471 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3471 28 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3471 29 : : : 40436 3471 30 o)/ntôs o)/ntôs NNP 40436 3471 31 gigno gigno NNP 40436 3471 32 / / SYM 40436 3471 33 menon].--Plato menon].--Plato NNP 40436 3471 34 , , , 40436 3471 35 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 3471 36 , , , 40436 3471 37 283 283 CD 40436 3471 38 - - SYM 40436 3471 39 284 284 CD 40436 3471 40 . . . 40436 3472 1 Compare compare VB 40436 3472 2 also also RB 40436 3472 3 the the DT 40436 3472 4 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 3472 5 , , , 40436 3472 6 p. p. NN 40436 3472 7 64 64 CD 40436 3472 8 D d NN 40436 3472 9 , , , 40436 3472 10 and and CC 40436 3472 11 the the DT 40436 3472 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 3472 13 , , , 40436 3472 14 pp pp NNP 40436 3472 15 . . . 40436 3473 1 356 356 CD 40436 3473 2 - - SYM 40436 3473 3 357 357 CD 40436 3473 4 , , , 40436 3473 5 where where WRB 40436 3473 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3473 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3473 8 : : : 40436 3473 9 ê ê NNP 40436 3473 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3473 11 metrêtikê\ metrêtikê\ NNP 40436 3473 12 te te NNP 40436 3473 13 / / SYM 40436 3473 14 chnê chnê NNP 40436 3473 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3473 16 is be VBZ 40436 3473 17 declared declare VBN 40436 3473 18 to to TO 40436 3473 19 be be VB 40436 3473 20 the the DT 40436 3473 21 principal principal JJ 40436 3473 22 saviour saviour NN 40436 3473 23 of of IN 40436 3473 24 life life NN 40436 3473 25 and and CC 40436 3473 26 happiness happiness NN 40436 3473 27 . . . 40436 3473 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3474 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3474 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3474 3 24 24 CD 40436 3474 4 : : : 40436 3474 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3474 6 , , , 40436 3474 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 3474 8 . . . 40436 3475 1 ii ii LS 40436 3475 2 . . . 40436 3476 1 145 145 CD 40436 3476 2 - - SYM 40436 3476 3 146 146 CD 40436 3476 4 ; ; : 40436 3476 5 supra supra NNP 40436 3476 6 , , , 40436 3476 7 ch ch NNP 40436 3476 8 . . . 40436 3477 1 xii xii NNP 40436 3477 2 . . . 40436 3478 1 p. p. NN 40436 3479 1 16 16 CD 40436 3479 2 . . . 40436 3479 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3480 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3480 2 Side side NN 40436 3480 3 - - HYPH 40436 3480 4 note note NN 40436 3480 5 : : : 40436 3480 6 View View NNP 40436 3480 7 taken take VBN 40436 3480 8 of of IN 40436 3480 9 the the DT 40436 3480 10 second second RB 40436 3480 11 - - HYPH 40436 3480 12 best good JJS 40436 3480 13 critical critical JJ 40436 3480 14 talking talking NN 40436 3480 15 man man NN 40436 3480 16 , , , 40436 3480 17 as as IN 40436 3480 18 compared compare VBN 40436 3480 19 with with IN 40436 3480 20 the the DT 40436 3480 21 special special JJ 40436 3480 22 proficient proficient NN 40436 3480 23 and and CC 40436 3480 24 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 3480 25 . . . 40436 3480 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3481 1 The the DT 40436 3481 2 second second JJ 40436 3481 3 explanation explanation NN 40436 3481 4 of of IN 40436 3481 5 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3481 6 here here RB 40436 3481 7 given give VBN 40436 3481 8 -- -- : 40436 3481 9 that that IN 40436 3481 10 the the DT 40436 3481 11 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3481 12 is be VBZ 40436 3481 13 one one CD 40436 3481 14 who who WP 40436 3481 15 is be VBZ 40436 3481 16 second second RB 40436 3481 17 - - HYPH 40436 3481 18 best good JJS 40436 3481 19 in in IN 40436 3481 20 many many JJ 40436 3481 21 departments department NNS 40436 3481 22 , , , 40436 3481 23 and and CC 40436 3481 24 a a DT 40436 3481 25 good good JJ 40436 3481 26 talker talker NN 40436 3481 27 upon upon IN 40436 3481 28 all all DT 40436 3481 29 , , , 40436 3481 30 but but CC 40436 3481 31 inferior inferior JJ 40436 3481 32 to to IN 40436 3481 33 the the DT 40436 3481 34 special special JJ 40436 3481 35 master master NN 40436 3481 36 in in IN 40436 3481 37 each each DT 40436 3481 38 -- -- : 40436 3481 39 was be VBD 40436 3481 40 supposed suppose VBN 40436 3481 41 by by IN 40436 3481 42 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3481 43 in in IN 40436 3481 44 ancient ancient JJ 40436 3481 45 times time NNS 40436 3481 46 to to TO 40436 3481 47 be be VB 40436 3481 48 pointed point VBN 40436 3481 49 at at IN 40436 3481 50 Demokritus Demokritus NNP 40436 3481 51 . . . 40436 3482 1 By by IN 40436 3482 2 many many JJ 40436 3482 3 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3482 4 critics critic NNS 40436 3482 5 , , , 40436 3482 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3482 7 is be VBZ 40436 3482 8 referred refer VBN 40436 3482 9 to to IN 40436 3482 10 those those DT 40436 3482 11 persons person NNS 40436 3482 12 whom whom WP 40436 3482 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3482 14 single single VBP 40436 3482 15 out out RP 40436 3482 16 to to TO 40436 3482 17 be be VB 40436 3482 18 called call VBN 40436 3482 19 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 3482 20 . . . 40436 3483 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3483 2 conceive conceive VBP 40436 3483 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3483 4 to to TO 40436 3483 5 be be VB 40436 3483 6 applicable applicable JJ 40436 3483 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3483 8 whether whether CC 40436 3483 9 intended intended JJ 40436 3483 10 or or CC 40436 3483 11 not not RB 40436 3483 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3483 13 to to IN 40436 3483 14 the the DT 40436 3483 15 literary literary JJ 40436 3483 16 men man NNS 40436 3483 17 generally generally RB 40436 3483 18 of of IN 40436 3483 19 that that DT 40436 3483 20 age age NN 40436 3483 21 , , , 40436 3483 22 the the DT 40436 3483 23 persons person NNS 40436 3483 24 called call VBN 40436 3483 25 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 3483 26 included include VBD 40436 3483 27 . . . 40436 3484 1 That that DT 40436 3484 2 which which WDT 40436 3484 3 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 3484 4 expressed express VBN 40436 3484 5 by by IN 40436 3484 6 the the DT 40436 3484 7 word word NN 40436 3484 8 , , , 40436 3484 9 when when WRB 40436 3484 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3484 11 claimed claim VBD 40436 3484 12 the the DT 40436 3484 13 love love NN 40436 3484 14 of of IN 40436 3484 15 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3484 16 and and CC 40436 3484 17 the the DT 40436 3484 18 love love NN 40436 3484 19 of of IN 40436 3484 20 beauty beauty NN 40436 3484 21 as as IN 40436 3484 22 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 3484 23 features feature NNS 40436 3484 24 of of IN 40436 3484 25 the the DT 40436 3484 26 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 3484 27 citizen citizen NN 40436 3484 28 -- -- : 40436 3484 29 referred refer VBD 40436 3484 30 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 3484 31 to to IN 40436 3484 32 the the DT 40436 3484 33 free free JJ 40436 3484 34 and and CC 40436 3484 35 abundant abundant JJ 40436 3484 36 discussion discussion NN 40436 3484 37 , , , 40436 3484 38 the the DT 40436 3484 39 necessity necessity NN 40436 3484 40 felt feel VBD 40436 3484 41 by by IN 40436 3484 42 every every DT 40436 3484 43 one one CD 40436 3484 44 for for IN 40436 3484 45 talking talk VBG 40436 3484 46 over over IN 40436 3484 47 every every DT 40436 3484 48 thing thing NN 40436 3484 49 before before IN 40436 3484 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3484 51 was be VBD 40436 3484 52 done do VBN 40436 3484 53 , , , 40436 3484 54 yet yet CC 40436 3484 55 accompanied accompany VBN 40436 3484 56 with with IN 40436 3484 57 full full JJ 40436 3484 58 energy energy NN 40436 3484 59 in in IN 40436 3484 60 action action NN 40436 3484 61 as as RB 40436 3484 62 soon soon RB 40436 3484 63 as as IN 40436 3484 64 the the DT 40436 3484 65 resolution resolution NN 40436 3484 66 was be VBD 40436 3484 67 taken take VBN 40436 3484 68 to to TO 40436 3484 69 act act VB 40436 3484 70 . . . 40436 3485 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3485 2 25 25 CD 40436 3485 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3485 4 Speech speech NN 40436 3485 5 , , , 40436 3485 6 ready ready JJ 40436 3485 7 and and CC 40436 3485 8 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 3485 9 , , , 40436 3485 10 free free JJ 40436 3485 11 conflict conflict NN 40436 3485 12 of of IN 40436 3485 13 opinion opinion NN 40436 3485 14 on on IN 40436 3485 15 many many JJ 40436 3485 16 different different JJ 40436 3485 17 topics topic NNS 40436 3485 18 -- -- : 40436 3485 19 was be VBD 40436 3485 20 the the DT 40436 3485 21 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 3485 22 and and CC 40436 3485 23 the the DT 40436 3485 24 measure measure NN 40436 3485 25 of of IN 40436 3485 26 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3485 27 acquired acquire VBN 40436 3485 28 . . . 40436 3486 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3486 2 passed pass VBD 40436 3486 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3486 4 life life NN 40436 3486 5 in in IN 40436 3486 6 talking talk VBG 40436 3486 7 , , , 40436 3486 8 with with IN 40436 3486 9 every every DT 40436 3486 10 one one NN 40436 3486 11 indiscriminately indiscriminately RB 40436 3486 12 , , , 40436 3486 13 and and CC 40436 3486 14 upon upon IN 40436 3486 15 each each DT 40436 3486 16 man man NN 40436 3486 17 's 's POS 40436 3486 18 particular particular JJ 40436 3486 19 subject subject NN 40436 3486 20 ; ; : 40436 3486 21 often often RB 40436 3486 22 perplexing perplex VBG 40436 3486 23 the the DT 40436 3486 24 artist artist NN 40436 3486 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3486 26 . . . 40436 3487 1 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3487 2 recounts recount VBZ 40436 3487 3 conversations conversation NNS 40436 3487 4 with with IN 40436 3487 5 various various JJ 40436 3487 6 professional professional JJ 40436 3487 7 men man NNS 40436 3487 8 -- -- : 40436 3487 9 a a DT 40436 3487 10 painter painter NN 40436 3487 11 , , , 40436 3487 12 a a DT 40436 3487 13 sculptor sculptor NN 40436 3487 14 , , , 40436 3487 15 an an DT 40436 3487 16 armourer armourer NN 40436 3487 17 -- -- : 40436 3487 18 and and CC 40436 3487 19 informs inform VBZ 40436 3487 20 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3487 21 that that IN 40436 3487 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3487 23 was be VBD 40436 3487 24 instructive instructive JJ 40436 3487 25 to to IN 40436 3487 26 all all DT 40436 3487 27 of of IN 40436 3487 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3487 29 , , , 40436 3487 30 though though IN 40436 3487 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3487 32 was be VBD 40436 3487 33 no no DT 40436 3487 34 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 3487 35 in in IN 40436 3487 36 any any DT 40436 3487 37 craft craft NN 40436 3487 38 . . . 40436 3488 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3488 2 26 26 CD 40436 3488 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3488 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3488 5 was be VBD 40436 3488 6 not not RB 40436 3488 7 merely merely RB 40436 3488 8 Demokritus Demokritus NNP 40436 3488 9 , , , 40436 3488 10 but but CC 40436 3488 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3488 12 and and CC 40436 3488 13 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 3488 14 also also RB 40436 3488 15 , , , 40436 3488 16 who who WP 40436 3488 17 talked talk VBD 40436 3488 18 or or CC 40436 3488 19 wrote write VBD 40436 3488 20 upon upon IN 40436 3488 21 almost almost RB 40436 3488 22 every every DT 40436 3488 23 subject subject NN 40436 3488 24 included include VBN 40436 3488 25 in in IN 40436 3488 26 contemporary contemporary JJ 40436 3488 27 observation observation NN 40436 3488 28 . . . 40436 3489 1 The the DT 40436 3489 2 voluminous voluminous JJ 40436 3489 3 works work NNS 40436 3489 4 of of IN 40436 3489 5 Aristotle,--the aristotle,--the DT 40436 3489 6 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 3489 7 , , , 40436 3489 8 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3489 9 , , , 40436 3489 10 and and CC 40436 3489 11 Leges Leges NNP 40436 3489 12 , , , 40436 3489 13 of of IN 40436 3489 14 Plato,--embrace Plato,--embrace NNP 40436 3489 15 a a DT 40436 3489 16 large large JJ 40436 3489 17 variety variety NN 40436 3489 18 of of IN 40436 3489 19 subjects subject NNS 40436 3489 20 , , , 40436 3489 21 on on IN 40436 3489 22 each each DT 40436 3489 23 of of IN 40436 3489 24 which which WDT 40436 3489 25 , , , 40436 3489 26 severally severally RB 40436 3489 27 taken take VBN 40436 3489 28 , , , 40436 3489 29 these these DT 40436 3489 30 two two CD 40436 3489 31 great great JJ 40436 3489 32 men man NNS 40436 3489 33 were be VBD 40436 3489 34 second second RB 40436 3489 35 - - HYPH 40436 3489 36 best good JJS 40436 3489 37 or or CC 40436 3489 38 inferior inferior JJ 40436 3489 39 to to IN 40436 3489 40 some some DT 40436 3489 41 special special JJ 40436 3489 42 proficient proficient NN 40436 3489 43 . . . 40436 3490 1 Yet yet RB 40436 3490 2 both both DT 40436 3490 3 of of IN 40436 3490 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3490 5 had have VBD 40436 3490 6 judgments judgment NNS 40436 3490 7 to to TO 40436 3490 8 give give VB 40436 3490 9 , , , 40436 3490 10 which which WDT 40436 3490 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3490 12 was be VBD 40436 3490 13 important important JJ 40436 3490 14 to to TO 40436 3490 15 hear hear VB 40436 3490 16 , , , 40436 3490 17 upon upon IN 40436 3490 18 all all DT 40436 3490 19 subjects:[27 subjects:[27 NNS 40436 3490 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3490 21 and and CC 40436 3490 22 both both DT 40436 3490 23 of of IN 40436 3490 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3490 25 could could MD 40436 3490 26 probably probably RB 40436 3490 27 talk talk VB 40436 3490 28 better well RBR 40436 3490 29 upon upon IN 40436 3490 30 each each DT 40436 3490 31 than than IN 40436 3490 32 the the DT 40436 3490 33 special special JJ 40436 3490 34 proficient proficient NN 40436 3490 35 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3490 36 . . . 40436 3491 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 3491 2 , , , 40436 3491 3 for for IN 40436 3491 4 example example NN 40436 3491 5 , , , 40436 3491 6 would would MD 40436 3491 7 write write VB 40436 3491 8 better well RBR 40436 3491 9 upon upon IN 40436 3491 10 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 3491 11 than than IN 40436 3491 12 Demosthenes demosthene NNS 40436 3491 13 -- -- : 40436 3491 14 upon upon IN 40436 3491 15 tragedy tragedy NN 40436 3491 16 , , , 40436 3491 17 than than IN 40436 3491 18 Sophokles Sophokles NNP 40436 3491 19 . . . 40436 3492 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 3492 2 , , , 40436 3492 3 if if IN 40436 3492 4 an an DT 40436 3492 5 oration oration NN 40436 3492 6 or or CC 40436 3492 7 a a DT 40436 3492 8 tragedy tragedy NN 40436 3492 9 were be VBD 40436 3492 10 to to TO 40436 3492 11 be be VB 40436 3492 12 composed compose VBN 40436 3492 13 -- -- : 40436 3492 14 if if IN 40436 3492 15 resolution resolution NN 40436 3492 16 or or CC 40436 3492 17 action action NN 40436 3492 18 were be VBD 40436 3492 19 required require VBN 40436 3492 20 on on IN 40436 3492 21 any any DT 40436 3492 22 real real JJ 40436 3492 23 state state NN 40436 3492 24 of of IN 40436 3492 25 particular particular JJ 40436 3492 26 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 3492 27 -- -- : 40436 3492 28 the the DT 40436 3492 29 special special JJ 40436 3492 30 proficient proficient NN 40436 3492 31 would would MD 40436 3492 32 be be VB 40436 3492 33 called call VBN 40436 3492 34 upon upon IN 40436 3492 35 to to TO 40436 3492 36 act act VB 40436 3492 37 : : : 40436 3492 38 but but CC 40436 3492 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3492 40 would would MD 40436 3492 41 be be VB 40436 3492 42 a a DT 40436 3492 43 mistake mistake NN 40436 3492 44 to to TO 40436 3492 45 infer infer VB 40436 3492 46 from from IN 40436 3492 47 hence hence RB 40436 3492 48 , , , 40436 3492 49 as as IN 40436 3492 50 the the DT 40436 3492 51 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3492 52 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3492 53 intimates intimate NNS 40436 3492 54 in in IN 40436 3492 55 the the DT 40436 3492 56 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3492 57 , , , 40436 3492 58 that that IN 40436 3492 59 the the DT 40436 3492 60 second second RB 40436 3492 61 - - HYPH 40436 3492 62 best good JJS 40436 3492 63 , , , 40436 3492 64 or or CC 40436 3492 65 theorizing theorize VBG 40436 3492 66 reasoner reasoner NN 40436 3492 67 , , , 40436 3492 68 was be VBD 40436 3492 69 a a DT 40436 3492 70 useless useless JJ 40436 3492 71 man man NN 40436 3492 72 . . . 40436 3493 1 The the DT 40436 3493 2 theoretical theoretical JJ 40436 3493 3 and and CC 40436 3493 4 critical critical JJ 40436 3493 5 point point NN 40436 3493 6 of of IN 40436 3493 7 view view NN 40436 3493 8 , , , 40436 3493 9 with with IN 40436 3493 10 the the DT 40436 3493 11 command command NN 40436 3493 12 of of IN 40436 3493 13 language language NN 40436 3493 14 apt apt JJ 40436 3493 15 for for IN 40436 3493 16 explaining explain VBG 40436 3493 17 and and CC 40436 3493 18 defending defend VBG 40436 3493 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3493 20 , , , 40436 3493 21 has have VBZ 40436 3493 22 a a DT 40436 3493 23 value value NN 40436 3493 24 of of IN 40436 3493 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3493 26 own own JJ 40436 3493 27 ; ; : 40436 3493 28 distinct distinct JJ 40436 3493 29 from from IN 40436 3493 30 , , , 40436 3493 31 yet yet CC 40436 3493 32 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 3493 33 modifying modify VBG 40436 3493 34 and and CC 40436 3493 35 improving improve VBG 40436 3493 36 , , , 40436 3493 37 the the DT 40436 3493 38 practical practical JJ 40436 3493 39 . . . 40436 3494 1 And and CC 40436 3494 2 such such JJ 40436 3494 3 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 3494 4 survey survey NN 40436 3494 5 and and CC 40436 3494 6 comparison comparison NN 40436 3494 7 of of IN 40436 3494 8 numerous numerous JJ 40436 3494 9 objects object NNS 40436 3494 10 , , , 40436 3494 11 without without IN 40436 3494 12 having have VBG 40436 3494 13 the the DT 40436 3494 14 attention attention NN 40436 3494 15 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 3494 16 fastened fasten VBN 40436 3494 17 or or CC 40436 3494 18 enslaved enslave VBN 40436 3494 19 to to IN 40436 3494 20 any any DT 40436 3494 21 one one CD 40436 3494 22 of of IN 40436 3494 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3494 24 , , , 40436 3494 25 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 3494 26 to to TO 40436 3494 27 rank rank NN 40436 3494 28 high high RB 40436 3494 29 as as IN 40436 3494 30 a a DT 40436 3494 31 variety variety NN 40436 3494 32 of of IN 40436 3494 33 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3494 34 whether whether IN 40436 3494 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3494 36 be be VB 40436 3494 37 adopted adopt VBN 40436 3494 38 as as IN 40436 3494 39 the the DT 40436 3494 40 definition definition NN 40436 3494 41 of of IN 40436 3494 42 a a DT 40436 3494 43 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3494 44 , , , 40436 3494 45 or or CC 40436 3494 46 not not RB 40436 3494 47 . . . 40436 3495 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3495 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3495 3 25 25 CD 40436 3495 4 : : : 40436 3495 5 Thucyd thucyd NN 40436 3495 6 . . . 40436 3496 1 ii ii LS 40436 3496 2 . . . 40436 3497 1 39 39 CD 40436 3497 2 fin.--40 fin.--40 CD 40436 3497 3 . . . 40436 3498 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3498 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3498 3 : : : 40436 3498 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3498 5 e)/n e)/n NNP 40436 3498 6 te te NNP 40436 3498 7 tou tou NNP 40436 3498 8 / / SYM 40436 3498 9 tois tois NNP 40436 3498 10 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 3498 11 po po NNP 40436 3498 12 / / SYM 40436 3498 13 lin lin NNP 40436 3498 14 a)xi a)xi NNP 40436 3498 15 / / SYM 40436 3498 16 an an DT 40436 3498 17 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 3498 18 thauma thauma NNP 40436 3498 19 / / SYM 40436 3498 20 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 3498 21 , , , 40436 3498 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3498 23 e)/ti e)/ti NNP 40436 3498 24 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3498 25 a)/llois a)/llois NNP 40436 3498 26 . . . 40436 3499 1 philokalou philokalou NNP 40436 3499 2 = = NFP 40436 3499 3 men man NNS 40436 3499 4 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3499 5 met meet VBN 40436 3499 6 ' ' '' 40436 3499 7 eu)telei eu)telei XX 40436 3499 8 / / SYM 40436 3499 9 as as IN 40436 3499 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3499 11 philosophou philosophou NNP 40436 3499 12 = = NFP 40436 3499 13 men man NNS 40436 3499 14 a)/neu a)/neu IN 40436 3499 15 malaki malaki NN 40436 3499 16 / / SYM 40436 3499 17 as as IN 40436 3499 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3499 19 , , , 40436 3499 20 & & CC 40436 3499 21 c. c. NNP 40436 3499 22 , , , 40436 3499 23 and and CC 40436 3499 24 the the DT 40436 3499 25 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 3499 26 sequel sequel NN 40436 3499 27 of of IN 40436 3499 28 the the DT 40436 3499 29 same same JJ 40436 3499 30 chapter chapter NN 40436 3499 31 about about IN 40436 3499 32 the the DT 40436 3499 33 intimate intimate JJ 40436 3499 34 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 3499 35 of of IN 40436 3499 36 abundant abundant JJ 40436 3499 37 speech speech NN 40436 3499 38 with with IN 40436 3499 39 energetic energetic JJ 40436 3499 40 action action NN 40436 3499 41 in in IN 40436 3499 42 the the DT 40436 3499 43 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 3499 44 character character NN 40436 3499 45 . . . 40436 3499 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3500 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3500 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3500 3 26 26 CD 40436 3500 4 : : : 40436 3500 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 3500 6 . . . 40436 3501 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 3501 2 . . . 40436 3502 1 iii iii NNP 40436 3502 2 . . . 40436 3503 1 10 10 CD 40436 3503 2 ; ; : 40436 3503 3 iii iii CD 40436 3503 4 . . . 40436 3504 1 11 11 CD 40436 3504 2 ; ; : 40436 3504 3 iii iii CD 40436 3504 4 . . . 40436 3505 1 12 12 CD 40436 3505 2 . . . 40436 3505 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3506 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3506 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3506 3 27 27 CD 40436 3506 4 : : : 40436 3506 5 The the DT 40436 3506 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3506 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3506 8 : : : 40436 3506 9 pe pe NNP 40436 3506 10 / / SYM 40436 3506 11 ntathlos ntathlos NNP 40436 3506 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3506 13 or or CC 40436 3506 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3506 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3506 16 : : : 40436 3506 17 u(/pakros u(/pakros NNP 40436 3506 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3506 19 whom whom WP 40436 3506 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3506 21 criticises criticise NNS 40436 3506 22 in in IN 40436 3506 23 this this DT 40436 3506 24 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3506 25 , , , 40436 3506 26 coincides coincide VBZ 40436 3506 27 with with IN 40436 3506 28 what what WP 40436 3506 29 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 3506 30 calls call VBZ 40436 3506 31 " " `` 40436 3506 32 the the DT 40436 3506 33 man man NN 40436 3506 34 of of IN 40436 3506 35 universal universal JJ 40436 3506 36 education education NN 40436 3506 37 or or CC 40436 3506 38 culture".--Ethic culture".--Ethic NNP 40436 3506 39 . . . 40436 3507 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 3507 2 . . . 40436 3508 1 I. I. NNP 40436 3508 2 i. i. NNP 40436 3509 1 1095 1095 CD 40436 3509 2 , , , 40436 3509 3 a. a. NN 40436 3510 1 1 1 LS 40436 3510 2 . . . 40436 3511 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3511 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3511 3 : : : 40436 3511 4 e(/kastos e(/kastos NNP 40436 3511 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3511 6 kri kri NNP 40436 3511 7 / / SYM 40436 3511 8 nei nei NNP 40436 3511 9 kalô kalô NNP 40436 3511 10 = = SYM 40436 3511 11 s s NNP 40436 3511 12 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 3511 13 gignô gignô NNP 40436 3511 14 / / SYM 40436 3511 15 skei skei NNP 40436 3511 16 , , , 40436 3511 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3511 18 tou tou NNP 40436 3511 19 / / SYM 40436 3511 20 tôn tôn NNP 40436 3511 21 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 3511 22 a)gatho\s a)gatho\s NNP 40436 3511 23 kritê kritê NNP 40436 3511 24 / / SYM 40436 3511 25 s s NNP 40436 3511 26 ; ; : 40436 3511 27 kath kath NNP 40436 3511 28 ' ' '' 40436 3511 29 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 3511 30 a)/ra a)/ra NNS 40436 3511 31 , , , 40436 3511 32 o o FW 40436 3511 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3511 34 pepaideume pepaideume NNP 40436 3511 35 / / SYM 40436 3511 36 nos nos NNP 40436 3511 37 ; ; : 40436 3511 38 a(plô a(plô NNP 40436 3511 39 = = SYM 40436 3511 40 s s NNP 40436 3511 41 de/ de/ NNP 40436 3511 42 , , , 40436 3511 43 o o NNP 40436 3511 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3511 45 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 3511 46 pa pa NNP 40436 3511 47 = = SYM 40436 3511 48 n n NNP 40436 3511 49 pepaideume pepaideume NNP 40436 3511 50 / / SYM 40436 3511 51 nos nos NNP 40436 3511 52 . . . 40436 3511 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3511 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3512 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3512 2 Side side NN 40436 3512 3 - - HYPH 40436 3512 4 note note NN 40436 3512 5 : : : 40436 3512 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3512 7 's 's POS 40436 3512 8 view view NN 40436 3512 9 -- -- : 40436 3512 10 that that IN 40436 3512 11 the the DT 40436 3512 12 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3512 13 has have VBZ 40436 3512 14 a a DT 40436 3512 15 province province NN 40436 3512 16 special special JJ 40436 3512 17 to to IN 40436 3512 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3512 19 , , , 40436 3512 20 distinct distinct JJ 40436 3512 21 from from IN 40436 3512 22 other other JJ 40436 3512 23 specialties specialty NNS 40436 3512 24 -- -- : 40436 3512 25 dimly dimly RB 40436 3512 26 indicated indicate VBN 40436 3512 27 -- -- : 40436 3512 28 regal regal JJ 40436 3512 29 or or CC 40436 3512 30 political political JJ 40436 3512 31 art art NN 40436 3512 32 . . . 40436 3512 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3513 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3513 2 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 3513 3 did do VBD 40436 3513 4 not not RB 40436 3513 5 conceive conceive VB 40436 3513 6 the the DT 40436 3513 7 definition definition NN 40436 3513 8 of of IN 40436 3513 9 the the DT 40436 3513 10 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3513 11 in in IN 40436 3513 12 the the DT 40436 3513 13 same same JJ 40436 3513 14 way way NN 40436 3513 15 as as IN 40436 3513 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3513 17 . . . 40436 3514 1 The the DT 40436 3514 2 close close NN 40436 3514 3 of of IN 40436 3514 4 the the DT 40436 3514 5 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3514 6 is be VBZ 40436 3514 7 employed employ VBN 40436 3514 8 in in IN 40436 3514 9 opening open VBG 40436 3514 10 a a DT 40436 3514 11 distant distant JJ 40436 3514 12 and and CC 40436 3514 13 dim dim JJ 40436 3514 14 view view NN 40436 3514 15 of of IN 40436 3514 16 the the DT 40436 3514 17 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3514 18 conception conception NN 40436 3514 19 . . . 40436 3515 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3515 2 are be VBP 40436 3515 3 given give VBN 40436 3515 4 to to TO 40436 3515 5 understand understand VB 40436 3515 6 , , , 40436 3515 7 that that IN 40436 3515 8 the the DT 40436 3515 9 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3515 10 has have VBZ 40436 3515 11 a a DT 40436 3515 12 province province NN 40436 3515 13 of of IN 40436 3515 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3515 15 own own JJ 40436 3515 16 , , , 40436 3515 17 wherein wherein WRB 40436 3515 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3515 19 is be VBZ 40436 3515 20 not not RB 40436 3515 21 second second JJ 40436 3515 22 - - HYPH 40436 3515 23 best good JJS 40436 3515 24 , , , 40436 3515 25 but but CC 40436 3515 26 a a DT 40436 3515 27 first first JJ 40436 3515 28 - - HYPH 40436 3515 29 rate rate NN 40436 3515 30 actor actor NN 40436 3515 31 and and CC 40436 3515 32 adviser adviser NN 40436 3515 33 . . . 40436 3516 1 To to TO 40436 3516 2 indicate indicate VB 40436 3516 3 , , , 40436 3516 4 in in IN 40436 3516 5 many many JJ 40436 3516 6 different different JJ 40436 3516 7 ways way NNS 40436 3516 8 , , , 40436 3516 9 that that IN 40436 3516 10 there there EX 40436 3516 11 is be VBZ 40436 3516 12 or or CC 40436 3516 13 must must MD 40436 3516 14 be be VB 40436 3516 15 such such PDT 40436 3516 16 a a DT 40436 3516 17 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 3516 18 , , , 40436 3516 19 appertaining appertain VBG 40436 3516 20 to to IN 40436 3516 21 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3516 22 -- -- : 40436 3516 23 distinct distinct JJ 40436 3516 24 from from IN 40436 3516 25 , , , 40436 3516 26 though though IN 40436 3516 27 analogous analogous JJ 40436 3516 28 to to IN 40436 3516 29 , , , 40436 3516 30 the the DT 40436 3516 31 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 3516 32 of of IN 40436 3516 33 each each DT 40436 3516 34 several several JJ 40436 3516 35 art art NN 40436 3516 36 -- -- : 40436 3516 37 is be VBZ 40436 3516 38 one one CD 40436 3516 39 leading leading JJ 40436 3516 40 purpose purpose NN 40436 3516 41 in in IN 40436 3516 42 many many JJ 40436 3516 43 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3516 44 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3516 45 . . . 40436 3517 1 But but CC 40436 3517 2 what what WP 40436 3517 3 is be VBZ 40436 3517 4 the the DT 40436 3517 5 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 3517 6 of of IN 40436 3517 7 the the DT 40436 3517 8 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3517 9 ? ? . 40436 3518 1 Here here RB 40436 3518 2 , , , 40436 3518 3 as as IN 40436 3518 4 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 3518 5 , , , 40436 3518 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3518 7 is be VBZ 40436 3518 8 marked mark VBN 40436 3518 9 out out RP 40436 3518 10 in in IN 40436 3518 11 a a DT 40436 3518 12 sort sort NN 40436 3518 13 of of IN 40436 3518 14 misty misty JJ 40436 3518 15 outline outline NN 40436 3518 16 , , , 40436 3518 17 not not RB 40436 3518 18 as as IN 40436 3518 19 by by IN 40436 3518 20 one one CD 40436 3518 21 who who WP 40436 3518 22 already already RB 40436 3518 23 knows know VBZ 40436 3518 24 and and CC 40436 3518 25 is be VBZ 40436 3518 26 familiar familiar JJ 40436 3518 27 with with IN 40436 3518 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3518 29 , , , 40436 3518 30 but but CC 40436 3518 31 as as IN 40436 3518 32 one one CD 40436 3518 33 who who WP 40436 3518 34 is be VBZ 40436 3518 35 trying try VBG 40436 3518 36 to to TO 40436 3518 37 find find VB 40436 3518 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3518 39 without without IN 40436 3518 40 being be VBG 40436 3518 41 sure sure JJ 40436 3518 42 that that IN 40436 3518 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3518 44 has have VBZ 40436 3518 45 succeeded succeed VBN 40436 3518 46 . . . 40436 3519 1 Here here RB 40436 3519 2 , , , 40436 3519 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3519 4 have have VBP 40436 3519 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3519 6 described describe VBN 40436 3519 7 as as IN 40436 3519 8 the the DT 40436 3519 9 art art NN 40436 3519 10 of of IN 40436 3519 11 discriminating discriminate VBG 40436 3519 12 good good JJ 40436 3519 13 from from IN 40436 3519 14 evil evil NN 40436 3519 15 , , , 40436 3519 16 governing governing NN 40436 3519 17 , , , 40436 3519 18 and and CC 40436 3519 19 applying apply VBG 40436 3519 20 penal penal JJ 40436 3519 21 sanctions sanction NNS 40436 3519 22 rightly rightly RB 40436 3519 23 . . . 40436 3520 1 This this DT 40436 3520 2 is be VBZ 40436 3520 3 the the DT 40436 3520 4 supreme supreme NNP 40436 3520 5 art art NN 40436 3520 6 or or CC 40436 3520 7 science science NN 40436 3520 8 , , , 40436 3520 9 of of IN 40436 3520 10 which which WDT 40436 3520 11 the the DT 40436 3520 12 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3520 13 is be VBZ 40436 3520 14 the the DT 40436 3520 15 professor professor NN 40436 3520 16 ; ; , 40436 3520 17 and and CC 40436 3520 18 in in IN 40436 3520 19 which which WDT 40436 3520 20 , , , 40436 3520 21 far far RB 40436 3520 22 from from IN 40436 3520 23 requiring require VBG 40436 3520 24 advice advice NN 40436 3520 25 from from IN 40436 3520 26 others other NNS 40436 3520 27 , , , 40436 3520 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3520 29 is be VBZ 40436 3520 30 the the DT 40436 3520 31 only only JJ 40436 3520 32 person person NN 40436 3520 33 competent competent JJ 40436 3520 34 both both DT 40436 3520 35 to to TO 40436 3520 36 advise advise VB 40436 3520 37 and and CC 40436 3520 38 to to TO 40436 3520 39 act act VB 40436 3520 40 : : : 40436 3520 41 the the DT 40436 3520 42 art art NN 40436 3520 43 which which WDT 40436 3520 44 exercises exercise VBZ 40436 3520 45 control control NN 40436 3520 46 over over IN 40436 3520 47 all all DT 40436 3520 48 other other JJ 40436 3520 49 special special JJ 40436 3520 50 arts art NNS 40436 3520 51 , , , 40436 3520 52 directing direct VBG 40436 3520 53 how how WRB 40436 3520 54 far far RB 40436 3520 55 , , , 40436 3520 56 and and CC 40436 3520 57 on on IN 40436 3520 58 what what WDT 40436 3520 59 occasions occasion NNS 40436 3520 60 , , , 40436 3520 61 each each DT 40436 3520 62 of of IN 40436 3520 63 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3520 64 comes come VBZ 40436 3520 65 into into IN 40436 3520 66 appliance appliance NN 40436 3520 67 . . . 40436 3521 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3521 2 is be VBZ 40436 3521 3 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3521 4 , , , 40436 3521 5 looked look VBD 40436 3521 6 at at IN 40436 3521 7 in in IN 40436 3521 8 one one CD 40436 3521 9 of of IN 40436 3521 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3521 11 two two CD 40436 3521 12 aspects aspect NNS 40436 3521 13 : : : 40436 3521 14 not not RB 40436 3521 15 as as IN 40436 3521 16 a a DT 40436 3521 17 body body NN 40436 3521 18 of of IN 40436 3521 19 speculative speculative JJ 40436 3521 20 truth truth NN 40436 3521 21 , , , 40436 3521 22 to to TO 40436 3521 23 be be VB 40436 3521 24 debated debate VBN 40436 3521 25 , , , 40436 3521 26 proved prove VBN 40436 3521 27 , , , 40436 3521 28 and and CC 40436 3521 29 discriminated discriminate VBN 40436 3521 30 from from IN 40436 3521 31 what what WP 40436 3521 32 can can MD 40436 3521 33 not not RB 40436 3521 34 be be VB 40436 3521 35 proved prove VBN 40436 3521 36 or or CC 40436 3521 37 can can MD 40436 3521 38 be be VB 40436 3521 39 disproved disprove VBN 40436 3521 40 -- -- : 40436 3521 41 but but CC 40436 3521 42 as as IN 40436 3521 43 a a DT 40436 3521 44 critical critical JJ 40436 3521 45 judgment judgment NN 40436 3521 46 bearing bearing NN 40436 3521 47 on on IN 40436 3521 48 actual actual JJ 40436 3521 49 life life NN 40436 3521 50 , , , 40436 3521 51 prescribing prescribe VBG 40436 3521 52 rules rule NNS 40436 3521 53 or or CC 40436 3521 54 giving give VBG 40436 3521 55 directions direction NNS 40436 3521 56 in in IN 40436 3521 57 particular particular JJ 40436 3521 58 cases case NNS 40436 3521 59 , , , 40436 3521 60 with with IN 40436 3521 61 a a DT 40436 3521 62 view view NN 40436 3521 63 to to IN 40436 3521 64 the the DT 40436 3521 65 attainment attainment NN 40436 3521 66 of of IN 40436 3521 67 foreknown foreknown NN 40436 3521 68 ends end NNS 40436 3521 69 , , , 40436 3521 70 recognised recognise VBN 40436 3521 71 as as IN 40436 3521 72 _ _ NNP 40436 3521 73 expetenda expetenda NNP 40436 3521 74 _ _ NNP 40436 3521 75 . . . 40436 3522 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3522 2 28 28 CD 40436 3522 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3522 4 This this DT 40436 3522 5 is be VBZ 40436 3522 6 what what WP 40436 3522 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3522 8 understands understand NNS 40436 3522 9 by by IN 40436 3522 10 the the DT 40436 3522 11 measuring measure VBG 40436 3522 12 or or CC 40436 3522 13 calculating calculate VBG 40436 3522 14 art art NN 40436 3522 15 , , , 40436 3522 16 the the DT 40436 3522 17 regal regal JJ 40436 3522 18 or or CC 40436 3522 19 political political JJ 40436 3522 20 art art NN 40436 3522 21 , , , 40436 3522 22 according accord VBG 40436 3522 23 as as IN 40436 3522 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3522 25 use use VBP 40436 3522 26 the the DT 40436 3522 27 language language NN 40436 3522 28 of of IN 40436 3522 29 the the DT 40436 3522 30 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 3522 31 , , , 40436 3522 32 Politikus Politikus NNP 40436 3522 33 , , , 40436 3522 34 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 3522 35 , , , 40436 3522 36 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3522 37 . . . 40436 3523 1 Both both DT 40436 3523 2 justice justice NN 40436 3523 3 and and CC 40436 3523 4 sobriety sobriety NN 40436 3523 5 are be VBP 40436 3523 6 branches branch NNS 40436 3523 7 of of IN 40436 3523 8 this this DT 40436 3523 9 art art NN 40436 3523 10 ; ; : 40436 3523 11 and and CC 40436 3523 12 the the DT 40436 3523 13 distinction distinction NN 40436 3523 14 between between IN 40436 3523 15 the the DT 40436 3523 16 two two CD 40436 3523 17 loses lose VBZ 40436 3523 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3523 19 importance importance NN 40436 3523 20 when when WRB 40436 3523 21 the the DT 40436 3523 22 art art NN 40436 3523 23 is be VBZ 40436 3523 24 considered consider VBN 40436 3523 25 as as IN 40436 3523 26 a a DT 40436 3523 27 whole whole NN 40436 3523 28 -- -- : 40436 3523 29 as as IN 40436 3523 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3523 31 find find VBP 40436 3523 32 both both DT 40436 3523 33 in in IN 40436 3523 34 the the DT 40436 3523 35 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3523 36 and and CC 40436 3523 37 in in IN 40436 3523 38 the the DT 40436 3523 39 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3523 40 . . . 40436 3524 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3524 2 29 29 CD 40436 3524 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3524 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3524 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3524 6 28 28 CD 40436 3524 7 : : : 40436 3524 8 The the DT 40436 3524 9 difference difference NN 40436 3524 10 between between IN 40436 3524 11 the the DT 40436 3524 12 second second JJ 40436 3524 13 explanation explanation NN 40436 3524 14 of of IN 40436 3524 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 3524 16 and and CC 40436 3524 17 the the DT 40436 3524 18 third third JJ 40436 3524 19 explanation explanation NN 40436 3524 20 , , , 40436 3524 21 suggested suggest VBN 40436 3524 22 in in IN 40436 3524 23 the the DT 40436 3524 24 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3524 25 , , , 40436 3524 26 will will MD 40436 3524 27 be be VB 40436 3524 28 found find VBN 40436 3524 29 to to TO 40436 3524 30 coincide coincide VB 40436 3524 31 pretty pretty RB 40436 3524 32 nearly nearly RB 40436 3524 33 with with IN 40436 3524 34 the the DT 40436 3524 35 distinction distinction NN 40436 3524 36 which which WDT 40436 3524 37 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 3524 38 takes take VBZ 40436 3524 39 much much JJ 40436 3524 40 pains pain NNS 40436 3524 41 to to TO 40436 3524 42 draw draw VB 40436 3524 43 between between IN 40436 3524 44 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3524 45 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3524 46 : : : 40436 3524 47 sophi sophi NNS 40436 3524 48 / / SYM 40436 3524 49 a a NN 40436 3524 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3524 51 and and CC 40436 3524 52 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3524 53 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3524 54 : : : 40436 3524 55 phro phro NN 40436 3524 56 / / SYM 40436 3524 57 nêsis].--Ethic nêsis].--ethic ADD 40436 3524 58 . . . 40436 3525 1 Nikomach Nikomach NNP 40436 3525 2 . . . 40436 3526 1 vi vi NNP 40436 3526 2 . . . 40436 3527 1 5 5 CD 40436 3527 2 , , , 40436 3527 3 pp pp NNP 40436 3527 4 . . . 40436 3528 1 1140 1140 CD 40436 3528 2 - - SYM 40436 3528 3 1141 1141 CD 40436 3528 4 ; ; : 40436 3528 5 also also RB 40436 3528 6 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 3528 7 . . . 40436 3529 1 Magn magn NN 40436 3529 2 . . . 40436 3530 1 i. i. NNP 40436 3530 2 pp pp NNP 40436 3530 3 . . . 40436 3531 1 1197 1197 CD 40436 3531 2 - - SYM 40436 3531 3 1198 1198 CD 40436 3531 4 . . . 40436 3531 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3532 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3532 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3532 3 29 29 CD 40436 3532 4 : : : 40436 3532 5 See See NNP 40436 3532 6 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3532 7 , , , 40436 3532 8 iv iv NNP 40436 3532 9 . . . 40436 3533 1 433 433 CD 40436 3533 2 A a DT 40436 3533 3 ; ; : 40436 3533 4 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 3533 5 , , , 40436 3533 6 526 526 CD 40436 3533 7 C C NNP 40436 3533 8 ; ; : 40436 3533 9 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 3533 10 164 164 CD 40436 3533 11 B b NN 40436 3533 12 ; ; : 40436 3533 13 and and CC 40436 3533 14 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 3533 15 's 's POS 40436 3533 16 note note NN 40436 3533 17 on on IN 40436 3533 18 the the DT 40436 3533 19 passage passage NN 40436 3533 20 in in IN 40436 3533 21 the the DT 40436 3533 22 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 3533 23 . . . 40436 3533 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3534 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3534 2 Side side NN 40436 3534 3 - - HYPH 40436 3534 4 note note NN 40436 3534 5 : : : 40436 3534 6 Philosopher Philosopher NNP 40436 3534 7 -- -- : 40436 3534 8 the the DT 40436 3534 9 supreme supreme NNP 40436 3534 10 artist artist NNP 40436 3534 11 controlling control VBG 40436 3534 12 other other JJ 40436 3534 13 artists artist NNS 40436 3534 14 . . . 40436 3534 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3535 1 Here here RB 40436 3535 2 , , , 40436 3535 3 in in IN 40436 3535 4 the the DT 40436 3535 5 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3535 6 , , , 40436 3535 7 this this DT 40436 3535 8 conception conception NN 40436 3535 9 of of IN 40436 3535 10 the the DT 40436 3535 11 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 3535 12 as as IN 40436 3535 13 the the DT 40436 3535 14 supreme supreme NNP 40436 3535 15 artist artist NNP 40436 3535 16 controlling control VBG 40436 3535 17 all all DT 40436 3535 18 other other JJ 40436 3535 19 artists artist NNS 40436 3535 20 , , , 40436 3535 21 is be VBZ 40436 3535 22 darkly darkly RB 40436 3535 23 indicated indicate VBN 40436 3535 24 and and CC 40436 3535 25 crudely crudely RB 40436 3535 26 sketched sketch VBD 40436 3535 27 . . . 40436 3536 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3536 2 shall shall MD 40436 3536 3 find find VB 40436 3536 4 the the DT 40436 3536 5 same same JJ 40436 3536 6 conception conception NN 40436 3536 7 more more RBR 40436 3536 8 elaborately elaborately RB 40436 3536 9 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 3536 10 in in IN 40436 3536 11 other other JJ 40436 3536 12 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3536 13 ; ; : 40436 3536 14 yet yet CC 40436 3536 15 never never RB 40436 3536 16 passing pass VBG 40436 3536 17 out out IN 40436 3536 18 of of IN 40436 3536 19 that that DT 40436 3536 20 state state NN 40436 3536 21 . . . 40436 3537 1 * * NFP 40436 3537 2 * * NFP 40436 3537 3 * * NFP 40436 3537 4 * * NFP 40436 3537 5 * * NFP 40436 3537 6 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 40436 3537 7 . . . 40436 3538 1 This this DT 40436 3538 2 is be VBZ 40436 3538 3 one one CD 40436 3538 4 of of IN 40436 3538 5 the the DT 40436 3538 6 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3538 7 declared declare VBD 40436 3538 8 to to TO 40436 3538 9 be be VB 40436 3538 10 spurious spurious JJ 40436 3538 11 by by IN 40436 3538 12 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3538 13 , , , 40436 3538 14 Ast Ast NNP 40436 3538 15 , , , 40436 3538 16 Socher Socher NNP 40436 3538 17 , , , 40436 3538 18 and and CC 40436 3538 19 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3538 20 , , , 40436 3538 21 all all DT 40436 3538 22 of of IN 40436 3538 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3538 24 critics critic NNS 40436 3538 25 of of IN 40436 3538 26 the the DT 40436 3538 27 present present JJ 40436 3538 28 century century NN 40436 3538 29 . . . 40436 3539 1 In in IN 40436 3539 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3539 3 judgment judgment NN 40436 3539 4 , , , 40436 3539 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3539 6 grounds ground NNS 40436 3539 7 for for IN 40436 3539 8 such such JJ 40436 3539 9 declaration declaration NN 40436 3539 10 are be VBP 40436 3539 11 altogether altogether RB 40436 3539 12 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 40436 3539 13 . . . 40436 3540 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 3540 2 think think VBP 40436 3540 3 the the DT 40436 3540 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3540 5 an an DT 40436 3540 6 inferior inferior JJ 40436 3540 7 composition composition NN 40436 3540 8 , , , 40436 3540 9 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 3540 10 of of IN 40436 3540 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3540 12 ; ; : 40436 3540 13 and and CC 40436 3540 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3540 15 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 3540 16 find find VBP 40436 3540 17 reasons reason NNS 40436 3540 18 , , , 40436 3540 19 more more RBR 40436 3540 20 or or CC 40436 3540 21 less less RBR 40436 3540 22 ingenious ingenious JJ 40436 3540 23 , , , 40436 3540 24 for for IN 40436 3540 25 relieving relieve VBG 40436 3540 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3540 27 from from IN 40436 3540 28 the the DT 40436 3540 29 discredit discredit NN 40436 3540 30 of of IN 40436 3540 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3540 32 . . . 40436 3541 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3541 2 do do VBP 40436 3541 3 not not RB 40436 3541 4 think think VB 40436 3541 5 so so RB 40436 3541 6 meanly meanly RB 40436 3541 7 of of IN 40436 3541 8 the the DT 40436 3541 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3541 10 as as IN 40436 3541 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3541 12 do do VBP 40436 3541 13 ; ; : 40436 3541 14 but but CC 40436 3541 15 even even RB 40436 3541 16 if if IN 40436 3541 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3541 18 did do VBD 40436 3541 19 , , , 40436 3541 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3541 21 should should MD 40436 3541 22 not not RB 40436 3541 23 pronounce pronounce VB 40436 3541 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3541 25 to to TO 40436 3541 26 be be VB 40436 3541 27 spurious spurious JJ 40436 3541 28 , , , 40436 3541 29 without without IN 40436 3541 30 some some DT 40436 3541 31 evidence evidence NN 40436 3541 32 bearing bear VBG 40436 3541 33 upon upon IN 40436 3541 34 that that DT 40436 3541 35 special special JJ 40436 3541 36 question question NN 40436 3541 37 . . . 40436 3542 1 No no DT 40436 3542 2 such such JJ 40436 3542 3 evidence evidence NN 40436 3542 4 , , , 40436 3542 5 of of IN 40436 3542 6 any any DT 40436 3542 7 value value NN 40436 3542 8 , , , 40436 3542 9 is be VBZ 40436 3542 10 produced produce VBN 40436 3542 11 . . . 40436 3543 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3543 2 is be VBZ 40436 3543 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 3543 4 contended contend VBN 40436 3543 5 , , , 40436 3543 6 on on IN 40436 3543 7 the the DT 40436 3543 8 authority authority NN 40436 3543 9 of of IN 40436 3543 10 a a DT 40436 3543 11 passage passage NN 40436 3543 12 in in IN 40436 3543 13 Diogenes Diogenes NNP 40436 3543 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3543 15 ix ix NNP 40436 3543 16 . . . 40436 3544 1 37 37 CD 40436 3544 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3544 3 , , , 40436 3544 4 that that IN 40436 3544 5 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3544 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3544 7 doubted doubt VBD 40436 3544 8 of of IN 40436 3544 9 the the DT 40436 3544 10 authenticity authenticity NN 40436 3544 11 of of IN 40436 3544 12 the the DT 40436 3544 13 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3544 14 . . . 40436 3545 1 The the DT 40436 3545 2 passage passage NN 40436 3545 3 is be VBZ 40436 3545 4 as as IN 40436 3545 5 follows follow VBZ 40436 3545 6 , , , 40436 3545 7 in in IN 40436 3545 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3545 9 life life NN 40436 3545 10 of of IN 40436 3545 11 Demokritus--[Greek demokritus--[greek NN 40436 3545 12 : : : 40436 3545 13 ei)/per ei)/per NN 40436 3545 14 oi oi PRP 40436 3545 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3545 16 A)nterastai\ A)nterastai\ NNP 40436 3545 17 Pla Pla NNP 40436 3545 18 / / SYM 40436 3545 19 tôno tôno NNP 40436 3545 20 / / SYM 40436 3545 21 s s NNP 40436 3545 22 ei)si ei)si NNP 40436 3545 23 , , , 40436 3545 24 phêsi\ phêsi\ . 40436 3545 25 Thra Thra NNP 40436 3545 26 / / SYM 40436 3545 27 sullos sullos NNPS 40436 3545 28 , , , 40436 3545 29 ou(=tos ou(=tos XX 40436 3545 30 a)\n a)\n `` 40436 3545 31 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 3545 32 o o NN 40436 3545 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3545 34 parageno parageno NNP 40436 3545 35 / / SYM 40436 3545 36 menos menos NNP 40436 3545 37 a)nô a)nô NNP 40436 3545 38 / / SYM 40436 3545 39 numos numo NNS 40436 3545 40 , , , 40436 3545 41 tô tô NNP 40436 3545 42 = = SYM 40436 3545 43 n n NNP 40436 3545 44 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 3545 45 Oi)nopi Oi)nopi NNP 40436 3545 46 / / SYM 40436 3545 47 dên dên NN 40436 3545 48 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3545 49 A)naxago A)naxago NNP 40436 3545 50 / / SYM 40436 3545 51 ran run VBD 40436 3545 52 e(/teros e(/teros NNP 40436 3545 53 , , , 40436 3545 54 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3545 55 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 3545 56 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 3545 57 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 3545 58 / / SYM 40436 3545 59 tên tên NN 40436 3545 60 o(mili o(mili NNS 40436 3545 61 / / SYM 40436 3545 62 a| a| NN 40436 3545 63 dialego dialego NNP 40436 3545 64 / / SYM 40436 3545 65 menos menos NNP 40436 3545 66 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 3545 67 philosophi philosophi NNS 40436 3545 68 / / SYM 40436 3545 69 as as IN 40436 3545 70 ; ; : 40436 3545 71 ô(=| ô(=| JJ 40436 3545 72 , , , 40436 3545 73 phêsi phêsi NN 40436 3545 74 / / SYM 40436 3545 75 n n NN 40436 3545 76 , , , 40436 3545 77 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3545 78 penta penta NN 40436 3545 79 / / SYM 40436 3545 80 thlô| thlô| CD 40436 3545 81 e)/oiken e)/oiken VBN 40436 3545 82 o o XX 40436 3545 83 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3545 84 philo philo NNP 40436 3545 85 / / SYM 40436 3545 86 sophos sophos NN 40436 3545 87 ; ; : 40436 3545 88 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3545 89 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 3545 90 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3545 91 a)lêthô a)lêthô NNP 40436 3545 92 = = SYM 40436 3545 93 s s NNP 40436 3545 94 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3545 95 philosophi philosophi POS 40436 3545 96 / / SYM 40436 3545 97 a| a| NN 40436 3545 98 pe pe NNP 40436 3545 99 / / SYM 40436 3545 100 ntathlos ntathlos NNP 40436 3545 101 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3545 102 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3545 103 Demokritus Demokritus NNP 40436 3545 104 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3545 105 . . . 40436 3546 1 Now now RB 40436 3546 2 in in IN 40436 3546 3 the the DT 40436 3546 4 first first JJ 40436 3546 5 place place NN 40436 3546 6 , , , 40436 3546 7 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3546 8 and and CC 40436 3546 9 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3546 10 both both DT 40436 3546 11 declare declare VBP 40436 3546 12 that that IN 40436 3546 13 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3546 14 can can MD 40436 3546 15 never never RB 40436 3546 16 have have VB 40436 3546 17 said say VBN 40436 3546 18 that that IN 40436 3546 19 which which WDT 40436 3546 20 Diogenes Diogenes NNP 40436 3546 21 here here RB 40436 3546 22 makes make VBZ 40436 3546 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3546 24 say say VB 40436 3546 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3546 26 Schleierm Schleierm NNP 40436 3546 27 . . . 40436 3547 1 p. p. NN 40436 3547 2 510 510 CD 40436 3547 3 ; ; : 40436 3547 4 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3547 5 , , , 40436 3547 6 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 3547 7 . . . 40436 3548 1 ad ad NN 40436 3548 2 . . . 40436 3549 1 Erast erast VB 40436 3549 2 . . . 40436 3550 1 p. p. NN 40436 3550 2 266 266 CD 40436 3550 3 , , , 40436 3550 4 and and CC 40436 3550 5 not not RB 40436 3550 6 . . . 40436 3551 1 p. p. NN 40436 3551 2 273 273 CD 40436 3551 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3551 4 . . . 40436 3552 1 Next next RB 40436 3552 2 , , , 40436 3552 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3552 4 is be VBZ 40436 3552 5 certain certain JJ 40436 3552 6 that that IN 40436 3552 7 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3552 8 did do VBD 40436 3552 9 consider consider VB 40436 3552 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3552 11 the the DT 40436 3552 12 undoubted undoubted JJ 40436 3552 13 work work NN 40436 3552 14 of of IN 40436 3552 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3552 16 , , , 40436 3552 17 for for IN 40436 3552 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3552 19 enrolled enrol VBD 40436 3552 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3552 21 in in IN 40436 3552 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3552 23 classification classification NN 40436 3552 24 , , , 40436 3552 25 as as IN 40436 3552 26 the the DT 40436 3552 27 third third JJ 40436 3552 28 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3552 29 in in IN 40436 3552 30 the the DT 40436 3552 31 fourth fourth JJ 40436 3552 32 tetralogy tetralogy NN 40436 3552 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3552 34 Diog Diog NNP 40436 3552 35 . . . 40436 3553 1 L. L. NNP 40436 3553 2 iii iii CD 40436 3553 3 . . . 40436 3554 1 59 59 LS 40436 3554 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3554 3 . . . 40436 3555 1 Yxem Yxem NNP 40436 3555 2 , , , 40436 3555 3 who who WP 40436 3555 4 defends defend VBZ 40436 3555 5 the the DT 40436 3555 6 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 3555 7 of of IN 40436 3555 8 the the DT 40436 3555 9 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3555 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3555 11 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 3555 12 Platon Platon NNP 40436 3555 13 's 's POS 40436 3555 14 Kleitophon Kleitophon NNP 40436 3555 15 , , , 40436 3555 16 pp pp NNP 40436 3555 17 . . . 40436 3556 1 6 6 CD 40436 3556 2 - - SYM 40436 3556 3 7 7 CD 40436 3556 4 , , , 40436 3556 5 Berlin Berlin NNP 40436 3556 6 , , , 40436 3556 7 1846 1846 CD 40436 3556 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3556 9 , , , 40436 3556 10 insists insist VBZ 40436 3556 11 very very RB 40436 3556 12 properly properly RB 40436 3556 13 on on IN 40436 3556 14 this this DT 40436 3556 15 point point NN 40436 3556 16 ; ; : 40436 3556 17 not not RB 40436 3556 18 merely merely RB 40436 3556 19 as as IN 40436 3556 20 an an DT 40436 3556 21 important important JJ 40436 3556 22 fact fact NN 40436 3556 23 in in IN 40436 3556 24 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 3556 25 , , , 40436 3556 26 but but CC 40436 3556 27 as as IN 40436 3556 28 determining determine VBG 40436 3556 29 the the DT 40436 3556 30 sense sense NN 40436 3556 31 of of IN 40436 3556 32 the the DT 40436 3556 33 words word NNS 40436 3556 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3556 35 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3556 36 : : : 40436 3556 37 ei)/per ei)/per NN 40436 3556 38 oi oi PRP 40436 3556 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3556 40 A)nterastai\ A)nterastai\ NNP 40436 3556 41 Pla Pla NNP 40436 3556 42 / / SYM 40436 3556 43 tôno tôno NNP 40436 3556 44 / / SYM 40436 3556 45 s s NNP 40436 3556 46 ei)si ei)si NNP 40436 3556 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3556 48 , , , 40436 3556 49 and and CC 40436 3556 50 as as IN 40436 3556 51 showing show VBG 40436 3556 52 that that IN 40436 3556 53 the the DT 40436 3556 54 words word NNS 40436 3556 55 rather rather RB 40436 3556 56 affirm affirm VBP 40436 3556 57 , , , 40436 3556 58 than than IN 40436 3556 59 deny deny VB 40436 3556 60 , , , 40436 3556 61 the the DT 40436 3556 62 authenticity authenticity NN 40436 3556 63 of of IN 40436 3556 64 the the DT 40436 3556 65 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3556 66 . . . 40436 3557 1 " " `` 40436 3557 2 If if IN 40436 3557 3 the the DT 40436 3557 4 Anterastæ Anterastæ NNP 40436 3557 5 are be VBP 40436 3557 6 the the DT 40436 3557 7 work work NN 40436 3557 8 of of IN 40436 3557 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3557 10 , , , 40436 3557 11 _ _ NNP 40436 3557 12 as as IN 40436 3557 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3557 14 are be VBP 40436 3557 15 universally universally RB 40436 3557 16 admitted admit VBN 40436 3557 17 to to TO 40436 3557 18 be be VB 40436 3557 19 _ _ NNP 40436 3557 20 . . . 40436 3557 21 " " '' 40436 3558 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3558 2 must must MD 40436 3558 3 supply supply VB 40436 3558 4 the the DT 40436 3558 5 parenthesis parenthesis NN 40436 3558 6 in in IN 40436 3558 7 this this DT 40436 3558 8 way way NN 40436 3558 9 , , , 40436 3558 10 in in IN 40436 3558 11 order order NN 40436 3558 12 to to TO 40436 3558 13 make make VB 40436 3558 14 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3558 15 consistent consistent JJ 40436 3558 16 with with IN 40436 3558 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3558 18 . . . 40436 3559 1 Yxem Yxem NNP 40436 3559 2 cites cite VBZ 40436 3559 3 a a DT 40436 3559 4 passage passage NN 40436 3559 5 from from IN 40436 3559 6 Galen Galen NNP 40436 3559 7 , , , 40436 3559 8 in in IN 40436 3559 9 which which WDT 40436 3559 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3559 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3559 12 : : : 40436 3559 13 ei)/per ei)/per NN 40436 3559 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3559 15 is be VBZ 40436 3559 16 used use VBN 40436 3559 17 , , , 40436 3559 18 and and CC 40436 3559 19 in in IN 40436 3559 20 which which WDT 40436 3559 21 the the DT 40436 3559 22 parenthesis parenthesis NN 40436 3559 23 must must MD 40436 3559 24 be be VB 40436 3559 25 supplied supply VBN 40436 3559 26 in in IN 40436 3559 27 the the DT 40436 3559 28 way way NN 40436 3559 29 indicated indicate VBD 40436 3559 30 : : : 40436 3559 31 no no DT 40436 3559 32 doubt doubt RB 40436 3559 33 at at RB 40436 3559 34 all all RB 40436 3559 35 being be VBG 40436 3559 36 meant mean VBN 40436 3559 37 to to TO 40436 3559 38 be be VB 40436 3559 39 hinted hint VBN 40436 3559 40 . . . 40436 3560 1 And and CC 40436 3560 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3560 3 will will MD 40436 3560 4 produce produce VB 40436 3560 5 another another DT 40436 3560 6 passage passage NN 40436 3560 7 out out IN 40436 3560 8 of of IN 40436 3560 9 Diogenes Diogenes NNP 40436 3560 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3560 11 , , , 40436 3560 12 where where WRB 40436 3560 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3560 14 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3560 15 : : : 40436 3560 16 ei)/per ei)/per NN 40436 3560 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3560 18 is be VBZ 40436 3560 19 used use VBN 40436 3560 20 in in IN 40436 3560 21 the the DT 40436 3560 22 same same JJ 40436 3560 23 way way NN 40436 3560 24 ; ; : 40436 3560 25 not not RB 40436 3560 26 as as RB 40436 3560 27 intended intend VBN 40436 3560 28 to to TO 40436 3560 29 convey convey VB 40436 3560 30 the the DT 40436 3560 31 smallest small JJS 40436 3560 32 doubt doubt NN 40436 3560 33 , , , 40436 3560 34 but but CC 40436 3560 35 merely merely RB 40436 3560 36 introducing introduce VBG 40436 3560 37 the the DT 40436 3560 38 premiss premiss NNP 40436 3560 39 for for IN 40436 3560 40 a a DT 40436 3560 41 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 3560 42 immediately immediately RB 40436 3560 43 following follow VBG 40436 3560 44 . . . 40436 3561 1 Diogenes Diogenes NNP 40436 3561 2 says say VBZ 40436 3561 3 , , , 40436 3561 4 respecting respect VBG 40436 3561 5 the the DT 40436 3561 6 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3561 7 Ideas Ideas NNPS 40436 3561 8 , , , 40436 3561 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3561 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3561 11 : : : 40436 3561 12 ei)/per ei)/per NN 40436 3561 13 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 3561 14 mnê mnê NNP 40436 3561 15 / / SYM 40436 3561 16 mê mê NNP 40436 3561 17 , , , 40436 3561 18 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 3561 19 i)de i)de NNP 40436 3561 20 / / SYM 40436 3561 21 as as IN 40436 3561 22 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3561 23 toi toi NNP 40436 3561 24 = = SYM 40436 3561 25 s s NNP 40436 3561 26 ou)=sin ou)=sin NNP 40436 3561 27 u(pa u(pa NNP 40436 3561 28 / / SYM 40436 3561 29 rchein rchein NNP 40436 3561 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3561 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3561 32 iii iii CD 40436 3561 33 . . . 40436 3562 1 15 15 CD 40436 3562 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3562 3 . . . 40436 3563 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3563 2 does do VBZ 40436 3563 3 not not RB 40436 3563 4 intend intend VB 40436 3563 5 to to TO 40436 3563 6 suggest suggest VB 40436 3563 7 any any DT 40436 3563 8 doubt doubt NN 40436 3563 9 whether whether IN 40436 3563 10 there there EX 40436 3563 11 be be VB 40436 3563 12 such such PDT 40436 3563 13 a a DT 40436 3563 14 fact fact NN 40436 3563 15 as as IN 40436 3563 16 memory memory NN 40436 3563 17 . . . 40436 3564 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3564 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3564 3 : : : 40436 3564 4 Ei)/per ei)/per NN 40436 3564 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3564 6 is be VBZ 40436 3564 7 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 3564 8 the the DT 40436 3564 9 equivalent equivalent NN 40436 3564 10 of of IN 40436 3564 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3564 12 Greek greek JJ 40436 3564 13 : : : 40436 3564 14 e)peidê e)peidê ADD 40436 3564 15 / / SYM 40436 3564 16 per per IN 40436 3564 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3564 18 : : : 40436 3564 19 as as IN 40436 3564 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3564 21 learn learn VBP 40436 3564 22 from from IN 40436 3564 23 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 3564 24 ad ad NN 40436 3564 25 Viger Viger NNP 40436 3564 26 . . . 40436 3565 1 VIII VIII NNP 40436 3565 2 . . . 40436 3566 1 6 6 CD 40436 3566 2 , , , 40436 3566 3 p. p. NN 40436 3566 4 512 512 CD 40436 3566 5 . . . 40436 3567 1 There there EX 40436 3567 2 is be VBZ 40436 3567 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 3567 4 no no DT 40436 3567 5 fair fair JJ 40436 3567 6 ground ground NN 40436 3567 7 for for IN 40436 3567 8 supposing suppose VBG 40436 3567 9 that that IN 40436 3567 10 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3567 11 doubted doubt VBD 40436 3567 12 the the DT 40436 3567 13 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 3567 14 of of IN 40436 3567 15 the the DT 40436 3567 16 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3567 17 . . . 40436 3568 1 And and CC 40436 3568 2 when when WRB 40436 3568 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3568 4 read read VBP 40436 3568 5 what what WDT 40436 3568 6 modern modern JJ 40436 3568 7 critics critic NNS 40436 3568 8 say say VBP 40436 3568 9 in in IN 40436 3568 10 support support NN 40436 3568 11 of of IN 40436 3568 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3568 13 verdict verdict NN 40436 3568 14 of of IN 40436 3568 15 condemnation condemnation NN 40436 3568 16 , , , 40436 3568 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3568 18 feel feel VBP 40436 3568 19 the the DT 40436 3568 20 more more RBR 40436 3568 21 authorised authorised JJ 40436 3568 22 in in IN 40436 3568 23 dissenting dissent VBG 40436 3568 24 from from IN 40436 3568 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3568 26 . . . 40436 3569 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3569 2 will will MD 40436 3569 3 cite cite VB 40436 3569 4 a a DT 40436 3569 5 passage passage NN 40436 3569 6 or or CC 40436 3569 7 two two CD 40436 3569 8 from from IN 40436 3569 9 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3569 10 . . . 40436 3570 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3570 2 begins begin VBZ 40436 3570 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3570 4 Prolegomena Prolegomena NNP 40436 3570 5 as as IN 40436 3570 6 follows follow VBZ 40436 3570 7 , , , 40436 3570 8 pp pp ADD 40436 3570 9 . . . 40436 3571 1 205 205 CD 40436 3571 2 - - SYM 40436 3571 3 206 206 CD 40436 3571 4 : : : 40436 3571 5 " " `` 40436 3571 6 Quanquam quanquam JJ 40436 3571 7 hic hic JJ 40436 3571 8 libellus libellus JJ 40436 3571 9 genus genus JJ 40436 3571 10 dicendi dicendi NN 40436 3571 11 habet habet NN 40436 3571 12 purum purum NN 40436 3571 13 , , , 40436 3571 14 castum castum NN 40436 3571 15 , , , 40436 3571 16 elegans elegans NNPS 40436 3571 17 , , , 40436 3571 18 nihil nihil NNP 40436 3571 19 ut ut NNP 40436 3571 20 inveniri inveniri NNP 40436 3571 21 queat queat UH 40436 3571 22 quod quod NN 40436 3571 23 à à NNP 40436 3571 24 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 3571 25 aut aut NN 40436 3571 26 Xenophontis Xenophontis NNP 40436 3571 27 elegantiâ elegantiâ NN 40436 3571 28 , , , 40436 3571 29 abhorreat abhorreat NN 40436 3571 30 -- -- : 40436 3571 31 tamen taman NNS 40436 3571 32 quin quin NNP 40436 3571 33 à à NNP 40436 3571 34 Boeckhio Boeckhio NNP 40436 3571 35 , , , 40436 3571 36 Schleiermachero Schleiermachero NNP 40436 3571 37 , , , 40436 3571 38 Astio Astio NNP 40436 3571 39 , , , 40436 3571 40 Sochero Sochero NNP 40436 3571 41 , , , 40436 3571 42 Knebelio Knebelio NNP 40436 3571 43 , , , 40436 3571 44 aliis aliis NNP 40436 3571 45 jure jure NNP 40436 3571 46 meritoque meritoque NN 40436 3571 47 pro pro NNP 40436 3571 48 suppositicio suppositicio NNP 40436 3571 49 habitus habitus NNP 40436 3571 50 sit sit NNP 40436 3571 51 , , , 40436 3571 52 haudquaquam haudquaquam NNP 40436 3571 53 dubitamus dubitamus NNP 40436 3571 54 . . . 40436 3572 1 Est Est NNP 40436 3572 2 enim enim NNP 40436 3572 3 materia materia NNP 40436 3572 4 operis operis NNP 40436 3572 5 adeo adeo NNP 40436 3572 6 non non AFX 40436 3572 7 ad ad FW 40436 3572 8 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 3572 9 mentem mentem NN 40436 3572 10 rationemque rationemque NNP 40436 3572 11 elaborata elaborata NNP 40436 3572 12 , , , 40436 3572 13 ut ut NNP 40436 3572 14 potius potius NNP 40436 3572 15 cuivis cuivis NNP 40436 3572 16 alii alii NNP 40436 3572 17 Socraticorum Socraticorum NNP 40436 3572 18 quam quam NNP 40436 3572 19 huic huic NNP 40436 3572 20 rectè rectè NNP 40436 3572 21 adscribi adscribi NNP 40436 3572 22 posse posse NNP 40436 3572 23 videatur videatur NNP 40436 3572 24 . . . 40436 3572 25 " " '' 40436 3573 1 After after IN 40436 3573 2 stating state VBG 40436 3573 3 that that IN 40436 3573 4 the the DT 40436 3573 5 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3573 6 may may MD 40436 3573 7 be be VB 40436 3573 8 divided divide VBN 40436 3573 9 into into IN 40436 3573 10 two two CD 40436 3573 11 principal principal JJ 40436 3573 12 sections section NNS 40436 3573 13 , , , 40436 3573 14 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3573 15 proceeds:--"Neutra proceeds:--"Neutra VBZ 40436 3573 16 harum harum NNP 40436 3573 17 partium partium NNP 40436 3573 18 ita ita NNP 40436 3573 19 tractata tractata NNP 40436 3573 20 est est NNP 40436 3573 21 , , , 40436 3573 22 ut ut NNP 40436 3573 23 nihil nihil NNP 40436 3573 24 desideretur desideretur NNP 40436 3573 25 , , , 40436 3573 26 quod quod NNP 40436 3573 27 ad ad NN 40436 3573 28 justam justam NNP 40436 3573 29 argumenti argumenti NNP 40436 3573 30 explicationem explicationem NNP 40436 3573 31 merito merito NNP 40436 3573 32 requiras requiras NNP 40436 3573 33 -- -- : 40436 3573 34 nihil nihil NNP 40436 3573 35 inculcatum inculcatum NNP 40436 3573 36 reperiatur reperiatur NNP 40436 3573 37 , , , 40436 3573 38 quod quod NNP 40436 3573 39 vel vel NNP 40436 3573 40 alio alio NNP 40436 3573 41 modo modo NNP 40436 3573 42 illustratum illustratum NNP 40436 3573 43 vel vel NNP 40436 3573 44 omnino omnino NNP 40436 3573 45 omissum omissum NNP 40436 3573 46 esse esse NNP 40436 3573 47 cupias cupias NNP 40436 3573 48 " " '' 40436 3573 49 . . . 40436 3574 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3574 2 call call VBP 40436 3574 3 attention attention NN 40436 3574 4 to to IN 40436 3574 5 this this DT 40436 3574 6 sentence sentence NN 40436 3574 7 as as IN 40436 3574 8 a a DT 40436 3574 9 fair fair JJ 40436 3574 10 specimen speciman NNS 40436 3574 11 of of IN 40436 3574 12 the the DT 40436 3574 13 grounds ground NNS 40436 3574 14 upon upon IN 40436 3574 15 which which WDT 40436 3574 16 the the DT 40436 3574 17 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3574 18 critics critic NNS 40436 3574 19 proceed proceed VBP 40436 3574 20 when when WRB 40436 3574 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3574 22 strike strike VBP 40436 3574 23 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3574 24 out out IN 40436 3574 25 of of IN 40436 3574 26 the the DT 40436 3574 27 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3574 28 Canon Canon NNP 40436 3574 29 . . . 40436 3575 1 If if IN 40436 3575 2 there there EX 40436 3575 3 be be VB 40436 3575 4 anything anything NN 40436 3575 5 wanting want VBG 40436 3575 6 in in IN 40436 3575 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3575 8 which which WDT 40436 3575 9 is be VBZ 40436 3575 10 required require VBN 40436 3575 11 for for IN 40436 3575 12 what what WP 40436 3575 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3575 14 consider consider VBP 40436 3575 15 a a DT 40436 3575 16 proper proper JJ 40436 3575 17 setting setting NN 40436 3575 18 forth forth RB 40436 3575 19 of of IN 40436 3575 20 the the DT 40436 3575 21 argument argument NN 40436 3575 22 -- -- : 40436 3575 23 if if IN 40436 3575 24 there there EX 40436 3575 25 be be VB 40436 3575 26 anything anything NN 40436 3575 27 which which WDT 40436 3575 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3575 29 would would MD 40436 3575 30 desire desire VB 40436 3575 31 to to TO 40436 3575 32 see see VB 40436 3575 33 omitted omit VBN 40436 3575 34 or or CC 40436 3575 35 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 3575 36 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 3575 37 -- -- : 40436 3575 38 this this DT 40436 3575 39 is be VBZ 40436 3575 40 with with IN 40436 3575 41 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3575 42 a a DT 40436 3575 43 reason reason NN 40436 3575 44 for for IN 40436 3575 45 deciding decide VBG 40436 3575 46 that that IN 40436 3575 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3575 48 is be VBZ 40436 3575 49 not not RB 40436 3575 50 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3575 51 's 's POS 40436 3575 52 work work NN 40436 3575 53 . . . 40436 3576 1 That that RB 40436 3576 2 is is RB 40436 3576 3 , , , 40436 3576 4 if if IN 40436 3576 5 there there EX 40436 3576 6 be be VB 40436 3576 7 any any DT 40436 3576 8 defects defect NNS 40436 3576 9 in in IN 40436 3576 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3576 11 of of IN 40436 3576 12 any any DT 40436 3576 13 kind kind NN 40436 3576 14 , , , 40436 3576 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3576 16 can can MD 40436 3576 17 not not RB 40436 3576 18 be be VB 40436 3576 19 admitted admit VBN 40436 3576 20 as as IN 40436 3576 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3576 22 's 's POS 40436 3576 23 work;--_his work;--_his CD 40436 3576 24 genuine genuine JJ 40436 3576 25 works work NNS 40436 3576 26 have have VBP 40436 3576 27 no no DT 40436 3576 28 defects defect NNS 40436 3576 29 _ _ NNP 40436 3576 30 . . . 40436 3577 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3577 2 protest protest VBP 40436 3577 3 altogether altogether RB 40436 3577 4 against against IN 40436 3577 5 this this DT 40436 3577 6 _ _ NNP 40436 3577 7 ratio ratio NN 40436 3577 8 decidendi decidendi NNP 40436 3577 9 _ _ NNP 40436 3577 10 . . . 40436 3578 1 If if IN 40436 3578 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3578 3 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 40436 3578 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3578 5 and and CC 40436 3578 6 applied apply VBD 40436 3578 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3578 8 consistently consistently RB 40436 3578 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3578 10 should should MD 40436 3578 11 strike strike VB 40436 3578 12 out out RP 40436 3578 13 every every DT 40436 3578 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3578 15 in in IN 40436 3578 16 the the DT 40436 3578 17 Canon Canon NNP 40436 3578 18 . . . 40436 3579 1 Certainly certainly RB 40436 3579 2 , , , 40436 3579 3 the the DT 40436 3579 4 presumption presumption NN 40436 3579 5 in in IN 40436 3579 6 favour favour NN 40436 3579 7 of of IN 40436 3579 8 the the DT 40436 3579 9 Catalogue Catalogue NNP 40436 3579 10 of of IN 40436 3579 11 Thrasyllus Thrasyllus NNP 40436 3579 12 must must MD 40436 3579 13 be be VB 40436 3579 14 counted count VBN 40436 3579 15 as as IN 40436 3579 16 _ _ NNP 40436 3579 17 nil nil NNP 40436 3579 18 _ _ NNP 40436 3579 19 , , , 40436 3579 20 if if IN 40436 3579 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3579 22 will will MD 40436 3579 23 not not RB 40436 3579 24 outweigh outweigh VB 40436 3579 25 such such JJ 40436 3579 26 feeble feeble JJ 40436 3579 27 counter counter NN 40436 3579 28 - - NNS 40436 3579 29 arguments argument NNS 40436 3579 30 as as IN 40436 3579 31 these these DT 40436 3579 32 . . . 40436 3580 1 One one CD 40436 3580 2 reason reason NN 40436 3580 3 given give VBN 40436 3580 4 by by IN 40436 3580 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3580 6 for for IN 40436 3580 7 considering consider VBG 40436 3580 8 the the DT 40436 3580 9 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 3580 10 as as IN 40436 3580 11 spurious spurious JJ 40436 3580 12 is be VBZ 40436 3580 13 , , , 40436 3580 14 that that IN 40436 3580 15 the the DT 40436 3580 16 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 3580 17 are be VBP 40436 3580 18 not not RB 40436 3580 19 derided deride VBN 40436 3580 20 in in IN 40436 3580 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3580 22 . . . 40436 3581 1 " " `` 40436 3581 2 Quis Quis NNP 40436 3581 3 est est NNP 40436 3581 4 igitur igitur NNP 40436 3581 5 , , , 40436 3581 6 qui qui NNP 40436 3581 7 Platonem Platonem NNP 40436 3581 8 sibi sibi NN 40436 3581 9 persuadeat persuadeat NN 40436 3581 10 illos illos NNP 40436 3581 11 non non AFX 40436 3581 12 fuisse fuisse NNP 40436 3581 13 castigaturum castigaturum NNP 40436 3581 14 , , , 40436 3581 15 et et NNP 40436 3581 16 omnino omnino NNP 40436 3581 17 non non NNP 40436 3581 18 significaturum significaturum NNP 40436 3581 19 , , , 40436 3581 20 quinam quinam NNP 40436 3581 21 illi illi NNP 40436 3581 22 essent essent NNP 40436 3581 23 , , , 40436 3581 24 adversus adversus NNP 40436 3581 25 quos quos NNP 40436 3581 26 hanc hanc NNP 40436 3581 27 disputationem disputationem NNP 40436 3581 28 instituisset instituisset NNP 40436 3581 29 ? ? . 40436 3581 30 " " '' 40436 3582 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3582 2 is be VBZ 40436 3582 3 strange strange JJ 40436 3582 4 to to TO 40436 3582 5 be be VB 40436 3582 6 called call VBN 40436 3582 7 on on RP 40436 3582 8 by by IN 40436 3582 9 learned learn VBN 40436 3582 10 men man NNS 40436 3582 11 to to TO 40436 3582 12 strike strike VB 40436 3582 13 out out RP 40436 3582 14 all all DT 40436 3582 15 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3582 16 from from IN 40436 3582 17 the the DT 40436 3582 18 Canon Canon NNP 40436 3582 19 in in IN 40436 3582 20 which which WDT 40436 3582 21 there there EX 40436 3582 22 is be VBZ 40436 3582 23 no no DT 40436 3582 24 derision derision NN 40436 3582 25 of of IN 40436 3582 26 the the DT 40436 3582 27 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 3582 28 . . . 40436 3583 1 Such such JJ 40436 3583 2 derision derision NN 40436 3583 3 exists exist VBZ 40436 3583 4 already already RB 40436 3583 5 in in IN 40436 3583 6 excess excess NN 40436 3583 7 : : : 40436 3583 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3583 9 hear hear VBP 40436 3583 10 until until IN 40436 3583 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3583 12 are be VBP 40436 3583 13 tired tired JJ 40436 3583 14 how how WRB 40436 3583 15 mean mean VBP 40436 3583 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3583 17 is be VBZ 40436 3583 18 to to TO 40436 3583 19 receive receive VB 40436 3583 20 money money NN 40436 3583 21 for for IN 40436 3583 22 lecturing lecture VBG 40436 3583 23 . . . 40436 3584 1 Again again RB 40436 3584 2 , , , 40436 3584 3 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3584 4 says say VBZ 40436 3584 5 that that IN 40436 3584 6 the the DT 40436 3584 7 persons person NNS 40436 3584 8 whose whose WP$ 40436 3584 9 opinions opinion NNS 40436 3584 10 are be VBP 40436 3584 11 here here RB 40436 3584 12 attacked attack VBN 40436 3584 13 are be VBP 40436 3584 14 not not RB 40436 3584 15 specified specify VBN 40436 3584 16 by by IN 40436 3584 17 name name NN 40436 3584 18 . . . 40436 3585 1 But but CC 40436 3585 2 who who WP 40436 3585 3 are be VBP 40436 3585 4 the the DT 40436 3585 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3585 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3585 7 : : : 40436 3585 8 ei)dô ei)dô NNP 40436 3585 9 = = SYM 40436 3585 10 n n CC 40436 3585 11 phi phi NNP 40436 3585 12 / / SYM 40436 3585 13 loi loi NNP 40436 3585 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3585 15 , , , 40436 3585 16 attacked attack VBN 40436 3585 17 in in IN 40436 3585 18 the the DT 40436 3585 19 Sophistês Sophistês NNP 40436 3585 20 ? ? . 40436 3586 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 3586 2 are be VBP 40436 3586 3 not not RB 40436 3586 4 specified specify VBN 40436 3586 5 by by IN 40436 3586 6 name name NN 40436 3586 7 , , , 40436 3586 8 and and CC 40436 3586 9 critics critic NNS 40436 3586 10 differ differ VBP 40436 3586 11 as as IN 40436 3586 12 to to IN 40436 3586 13 the the DT 40436 3586 14 persons person NNS 40436 3586 15 intended intend VBN 40436 3586 16 . . . 40436 3587 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 3587 2 XVII XVII NNP 40436 3587 3 . . . 40436 3588 1 ION ION NNP 40436 3588 2 . . . 40436 3589 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3589 2 Side side NN 40436 3589 3 - - HYPH 40436 3589 4 note note NN 40436 3589 5 : : : 40436 3589 6 Ion ion VB 40436 3589 7 . . . 40436 3590 1 Persons person NNS 40436 3590 2 of of IN 40436 3590 3 the the DT 40436 3590 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3590 5 . . . 40436 3591 1 Difference difference NN 40436 3591 2 of of IN 40436 3591 3 opinion opinion NN 40436 3591 4 among among IN 40436 3591 5 modern modern JJ 40436 3591 6 critics critic NNS 40436 3591 7 as as IN 40436 3591 8 to to IN 40436 3591 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3591 10 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 3591 11 . . . 40436 3591 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3592 1 The the DT 40436 3592 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3592 3 called call VBN 40436 3592 4 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3592 5 is be VBZ 40436 3592 6 carried carry VBN 40436 3592 7 on on RP 40436 3592 8 between between IN 40436 3592 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3592 10 and and CC 40436 3592 11 the the DT 40436 3592 12 Ephesian Ephesian NNP 40436 3592 13 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3592 14 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3592 15 . . . 40436 3593 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3593 2 is be VBZ 40436 3593 3 among among IN 40436 3593 4 those those DT 40436 3593 5 disallowed disallow VBN 40436 3593 6 by by IN 40436 3593 7 Ast Ast NNP 40436 3593 8 , , , 40436 3593 9 first first RB 40436 3593 10 faintly faintly RB 40436 3593 11 defended defend VBN 40436 3593 12 , , , 40436 3593 13 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 3593 14 disallowed disallow VBN 40436 3593 15 , , , 40436 3593 16 by by IN 40436 3593 17 Schleiermacher,[1 Schleiermacher,[1 NNP 40436 3593 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3593 19 and and CC 40436 3593 20 treated treat VBN 40436 3593 21 contemptuously contemptuously RB 40436 3593 22 by by IN 40436 3593 23 both both DT 40436 3593 24 . . . 40436 3594 1 Subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 3594 2 critics critic NNS 40436 3594 3 , , , 40436 3594 4 Hermann,[2 Hermann,[2 NNP 40436 3594 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3594 6 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 3594 7 , , , 40436 3594 8 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 3594 9 , , , 40436 3594 10 consider consider VB 40436 3594 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3594 12 as as RB 40436 3594 13 genuine genuine JJ 40436 3594 14 , , , 40436 3594 15 yet yet RB 40436 3594 16 as as IN 40436 3594 17 an an DT 40436 3594 18 inferior inferior JJ 40436 3594 19 production production NN 40436 3594 20 , , , 40436 3594 21 of of IN 40436 3594 22 little little JJ 40436 3594 23 worth worth JJ 40436 3594 24 , , , 40436 3594 25 and and CC 40436 3594 26 belonging belong VBG 40436 3594 27 to to IN 40436 3594 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3594 29 's 's POS 40436 3594 30 earliest early JJS 40436 3594 31 years year NNS 40436 3594 32 . . . 40436 3595 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3595 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3595 3 1 1 CD 40436 3595 4 : : : 40436 3595 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 3595 6 , , , 40436 3595 7 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 3595 8 . . . 40436 3596 1 zum zum NNP 40436 3596 2 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3596 3 , , , 40436 3596 4 p. p. NN 40436 3596 5 261 261 CD 40436 3596 6 - - SYM 40436 3596 7 266 266 CD 40436 3596 8 ; ; : 40436 3596 9 Ast Ast NNP 40436 3596 10 , , , 40436 3596 11 Leben Leben NNP 40436 3596 12 und und VBP 40436 3596 13 Schriften Schriften NNP 40436 3596 14 des des FW 40436 3596 15 Platon Platon NNP 40436 3596 16 , , , 40436 3596 17 p. p. NN 40436 3597 1 406 406 CD 40436 3597 2 . . . 40436 3597 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3598 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3598 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3598 3 2 2 CD 40436 3598 4 : : : 40436 3598 5 K. K. NNP 40436 3598 6 F. F. NNP 40436 3598 7 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 3598 8 , , , 40436 3598 9 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 3598 10 . . . 40436 3599 1 und und JJ 40436 3599 2 Syst Syst NNP 40436 3599 3 . . . 40436 3600 1 der der NNP 40436 3600 2 Plat Plat NNP 40436 3600 3 . . . 40436 3601 1 Phil Phil NNP 40436 3601 2 . . . 40436 3602 1 pp pp NNP 40436 3602 2 . . . 40436 3603 1 437 437 CD 40436 3603 2 - - SYM 40436 3603 3 438 438 CD 40436 3603 4 ; ; : 40436 3603 5 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 3603 6 , , , 40436 3603 7 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 3603 8 , , , 40436 3603 9 p. p. NN 40436 3604 1 15 15 CD 40436 3604 2 . . . 40436 3604 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3605 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3605 2 Side side NN 40436 3605 3 - - HYPH 40436 3605 4 note note NN 40436 3605 5 : : : 40436 3605 6 Rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3605 7 as as IN 40436 3605 8 a a DT 40436 3605 9 class class NN 40436 3605 10 in in IN 40436 3605 11 Greece Greece NNP 40436 3605 12 . . . 40436 3606 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 3606 2 competed compete VBD 40436 3606 3 for for IN 40436 3606 4 prizes prize NNS 40436 3606 5 at at IN 40436 3606 6 the the DT 40436 3606 7 festivals festival NNS 40436 3606 8 . . . 40436 3607 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3607 2 has have VBZ 40436 3607 3 been be VBN 40436 3607 4 triumphant triumphant JJ 40436 3607 5 . . . 40436 3607 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3608 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3608 2 hold hold VBP 40436 3608 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3608 4 to to TO 40436 3608 5 be be VB 40436 3608 6 genuine genuine JJ 40436 3608 7 , , , 40436 3608 8 and and CC 40436 3608 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3608 10 may may MD 40436 3608 11 be be VB 40436 3608 12 comparatively comparatively RB 40436 3608 13 early early JJ 40436 3608 14 ; ; : 40436 3608 15 but but CC 40436 3608 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3608 17 see see VBP 40436 3608 18 no no DT 40436 3608 19 ground ground NN 40436 3608 20 for for IN 40436 3608 21 the the DT 40436 3608 22 disparaging disparage VBG 40436 3608 23 criticism criticism NN 40436 3608 24 which which WDT 40436 3608 25 has have VBZ 40436 3608 26 often often RB 40436 3608 27 been be VBN 40436 3608 28 applied apply VBN 40436 3608 29 to to IN 40436 3608 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3608 31 . . . 40436 3609 1 The the DT 40436 3609 2 personage personage NN 40436 3609 3 whom whom WP 40436 3609 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3609 5 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 3609 6 to to IN 40436 3609 7 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3609 8 as as IN 40436 3609 9 subjected subject VBN 40436 3609 10 to to IN 40436 3609 11 the the DT 40436 3609 12 cross cross NN 40436 3609 13 - - NN 40436 3609 14 examination examination NN 40436 3609 15 of of IN 40436 3609 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3609 17 is be VBZ 40436 3609 18 a a DT 40436 3609 19 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3609 20 of of IN 40436 3609 21 celebrity celebrity NN 40436 3609 22 ; ; : 40436 3609 23 one one CD 40436 3609 24 among among IN 40436 3609 25 a a DT 40436 3609 26 class class NN 40436 3609 27 of of IN 40436 3609 28 artists artist NNS 40436 3609 29 at at IN 40436 3609 30 that that DT 40436 3609 31 time time NN 40436 3609 32 both both CC 40436 3609 33 useful useful JJ 40436 3609 34 and and CC 40436 3609 35 esteemed esteemed JJ 40436 3609 36 . . . 40436 3610 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 3610 2 recited recite VBD 40436 3610 3 or or CC 40436 3610 4 sang,[3 sang,[3 NN 40436 3610 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3610 6 with with IN 40436 3610 7 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 3610 8 accent accent NN 40436 3610 9 and and CC 40436 3610 10 gesture gesture NN 40436 3610 11 , , , 40436 3610 12 the the DT 40436 3610 13 compositions composition NNS 40436 3610 14 of of IN 40436 3610 15 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3610 16 and and CC 40436 3610 17 of of IN 40436 3610 18 other other JJ 40436 3610 19 epic epic JJ 40436 3610 20 poets poet NNS 40436 3610 21 : : : 40436 3610 22 thus thus RB 40436 3610 23 serving serve VBG 40436 3610 24 to to IN 40436 3610 25 the the DT 40436 3610 26 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 3610 27 epic epic NN 40436 3610 28 , , , 40436 3610 29 the the DT 40436 3610 30 same same JJ 40436 3610 31 purpose purpose NN 40436 3610 32 as as IN 40436 3610 33 the the DT 40436 3610 34 actors actor NNS 40436 3610 35 served serve VBD 40436 3610 36 to to IN 40436 3610 37 the the DT 40436 3610 38 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 3610 39 , , , 40436 3610 40 and and CC 40436 3610 41 the the DT 40436 3610 42 harp harp NN 40436 3610 43 - - HYPH 40436 3610 44 singers singer NNS 40436 3610 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3610 46 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3610 47 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3610 48 : : : 40436 3610 49 kitharô|doi\ kitharô|doi\ ADD 40436 3610 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3610 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3610 52 to to IN 40436 3610 53 the the DT 40436 3610 54 lyric lyric NN 40436 3610 55 . . . 40436 3611 1 There there EX 40436 3611 2 were be VBD 40436 3611 3 various various JJ 40436 3611 4 solemn solemn JJ 40436 3611 5 festivals festival NNS 40436 3611 6 such such JJ 40436 3611 7 as as IN 40436 3611 8 that that DT 40436 3611 9 of of IN 40436 3611 10 Æsculapius Æsculapius NNP 40436 3611 11 at at IN 40436 3611 12 Epidaurus Epidaurus NNP 40436 3611 13 , , , 40436 3611 14 and and CC 40436 3611 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3611 16 most most RBS 40436 3611 17 especially especially RB 40436 3611 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3611 19 the the DT 40436 3611 20 Panathenæa Panathenæa NNP 40436 3611 21 at at IN 40436 3611 22 Athens Athens NNP 40436 3611 23 , , , 40436 3611 24 where where WRB 40436 3611 25 prizes prize NNS 40436 3611 26 were be VBD 40436 3611 27 awarded award VBN 40436 3611 28 for for IN 40436 3611 29 the the DT 40436 3611 30 competition competition NN 40436 3611 31 of of IN 40436 3611 32 the the DT 40436 3611 33 rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3611 34 . . . 40436 3612 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3612 2 is be VBZ 40436 3612 3 described describe VBN 40436 3612 4 as as IN 40436 3612 5 having have VBG 40436 3612 6 competed compete VBN 40436 3612 7 triumphantly triumphantly RB 40436 3612 8 in in IN 40436 3612 9 the the DT 40436 3612 10 festival festival NN 40436 3612 11 at at IN 40436 3612 12 Epidaurus Epidaurus NNP 40436 3612 13 , , , 40436 3612 14 and and CC 40436 3612 15 carried carry VBD 40436 3612 16 off off RP 40436 3612 17 the the DT 40436 3612 18 first first JJ 40436 3612 19 prize prize NN 40436 3612 20 . . . 40436 3613 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3613 2 appeared appear VBD 40436 3613 3 there there RB 40436 3613 4 in in IN 40436 3613 5 a a DT 40436 3613 6 splendid splendid JJ 40436 3613 7 costume costume NN 40436 3613 8 , , , 40436 3613 9 crowned crown VBN 40436 3613 10 with with IN 40436 3613 11 a a DT 40436 3613 12 golden golden JJ 40436 3613 13 wreath wreath NN 40436 3613 14 , , , 40436 3613 15 amidst amidst IN 40436 3613 16 a a DT 40436 3613 17 crowd crowd NN 40436 3613 18 which which WDT 40436 3613 19 is be VBZ 40436 3613 20 described describe VBN 40436 3613 21 as as IN 40436 3613 22 containing contain VBG 40436 3613 23 more more JJR 40436 3613 24 than than IN 40436 3613 25 20,000 20,000 CD 40436 3613 26 persons person NNS 40436 3613 27 . . . 40436 3614 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3614 2 4 4 CD 40436 3614 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3614 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3614 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3614 6 3 3 CD 40436 3614 7 : : : 40436 3614 8 The the DT 40436 3614 9 word word NN 40436 3614 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3614 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3614 12 : : : 40436 3614 13 a)/|dein a)/|dein ADD 40436 3614 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3614 15 is be VBZ 40436 3614 16 in in IN 40436 3614 17 this this DT 40436 3614 18 very very JJ 40436 3614 19 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3614 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3614 21 532 532 CD 40436 3614 22 D d NN 40436 3614 23 , , , 40436 3614 24 535 535 CD 40436 3614 25 A a NN 40436 3614 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3614 27 applied apply VBD 40436 3614 28 to to IN 40436 3614 29 the the DT 40436 3614 30 rhapsoding rhapsoding NN 40436 3614 31 of of IN 40436 3614 32 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3614 33 . . . 40436 3614 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3615 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3615 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3615 3 4 4 CD 40436 3615 4 : : : 40436 3615 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3615 6 , , , 40436 3615 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3615 8 , , , 40436 3615 9 535 535 CD 40436 3615 10 D. D. NNP 40436 3615 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3615 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3615 13 Side side NN 40436 3615 14 - - HYPH 40436 3615 15 note note NN 40436 3615 16 : : : 40436 3615 17 Functions function NNS 40436 3615 18 of of IN 40436 3615 19 the the DT 40436 3615 20 Rhapsodes Rhapsodes NNPS 40436 3615 21 . . . 40436 3616 1 Recitation recitation NN 40436 3616 2 -- -- : 40436 3616 3 Exposition exposition NN 40436 3616 4 of of IN 40436 3616 5 the the DT 40436 3616 6 poets poet NNS 40436 3616 7 . . . 40436 3617 1 Arbitrary arbitrary JJ 40436 3617 2 exposition exposition NN 40436 3617 3 of of IN 40436 3617 4 the the DT 40436 3617 5 poets poet NNS 40436 3617 6 was be VBD 40436 3617 7 then then RB 40436 3617 8 frequent frequent JJ 40436 3617 9 . . . 40436 3617 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3618 1 Much much JJ 40436 3618 2 of of IN 40436 3618 3 the the DT 40436 3618 4 acquaintance acquaintance NN 40436 3618 5 of of IN 40436 3618 6 cultivated cultivate VBN 40436 3618 7 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 3618 8 with with IN 40436 3618 9 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3618 10 and and CC 40436 3618 11 the the DT 40436 3618 12 other other JJ 40436 3618 13 epic epic JJ 40436 3618 14 poets poet NNS 40436 3618 15 was be VBD 40436 3618 16 both both DT 40436 3618 17 acquired acquire VBN 40436 3618 18 and and CC 40436 3618 19 maintained maintain VBN 40436 3618 20 through through IN 40436 3618 21 such such JJ 40436 3618 22 rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3618 23 ; ; : 40436 3618 24 the the DT 40436 3618 25 best good JJS 40436 3618 26 of of IN 40436 3618 27 whom whom WP 40436 3618 28 contended contend VBD 40436 3618 29 at at IN 40436 3618 30 the the DT 40436 3618 31 festivals festival NNS 40436 3618 32 , , , 40436 3618 33 while while IN 40436 3618 34 others other NNS 40436 3618 35 , , , 40436 3618 36 less less RBR 40436 3618 37 highly highly RB 40436 3618 38 gifted gifted JJ 40436 3618 39 as as IN 40436 3618 40 to to IN 40436 3618 41 vocal vocal JJ 40436 3618 42 power power NN 40436 3618 43 and and CC 40436 3618 44 gesticulation gesticulation NN 40436 3618 45 , , , 40436 3618 46 gave give VBD 40436 3618 47 separate separate JJ 40436 3618 48 declamations declamation NNS 40436 3618 49 and and CC 40436 3618 50 lectures lecture NNS 40436 3618 51 of of IN 40436 3618 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3618 53 own own JJ 40436 3618 54 , , , 40436 3618 55 and and CC 40436 3618 56 even even RB 40436 3618 57 private private JJ 40436 3618 58 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3618 59 to to IN 40436 3618 60 individuals individual NNS 40436 3618 61 . . . 40436 3619 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3619 2 5 5 CD 40436 3619 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3619 4 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 3619 5 , , , 40436 3619 6 in in IN 40436 3619 7 one one CD 40436 3619 8 of of IN 40436 3619 9 the the DT 40436 3619 10 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 3619 11 conversations conversation NNS 40436 3619 12 with with IN 40436 3619 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3619 14 , , , 40436 3619 15 and and CC 40436 3619 16 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNPS 40436 3619 17 in in IN 40436 3619 18 the the DT 40436 3619 19 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 3619 20 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 3619 21 , , , 40436 3619 22 are be VBP 40436 3619 23 made make VBN 40436 3619 24 to to TO 40436 3619 25 declare declare VB 40436 3619 26 that that IN 40436 3619 27 the the DT 40436 3619 28 rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3619 29 as as IN 40436 3619 30 a a DT 40436 3619 31 class class NN 40436 3619 32 were be VBD 40436 3619 33 extremely extremely RB 40436 3619 34 silly silly JJ 40436 3619 35 . . . 40436 3620 1 This this DT 40436 3620 2 , , , 40436 3620 3 if if IN 40436 3620 4 true true JJ 40436 3620 5 at at RB 40436 3620 6 all all RB 40436 3620 7 , , , 40436 3620 8 can can MD 40436 3620 9 apply apply VB 40436 3620 10 only only RB 40436 3620 11 to to IN 40436 3620 12 the the DT 40436 3620 13 expositions exposition NNS 40436 3620 14 and and CC 40436 3620 15 comments comment NNS 40436 3620 16 with with IN 40436 3620 17 which which WDT 40436 3620 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3620 19 accompanied accompany VBD 40436 3620 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3620 21 recital recital NN 40436 3620 22 of of IN 40436 3620 23 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3620 24 and and CC 40436 3620 25 other other JJ 40436 3620 26 poets poet NNS 40436 3620 27 . . . 40436 3621 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 3621 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3621 3 can can MD 40436 3621 4 not not RB 40436 3621 5 reasonably reasonably RB 40436 3621 6 set set VB 40436 3621 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3621 8 down down RP 40436 3621 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3621 10 though though IN 40436 3621 11 some some DT 40436 3621 12 modern modern JJ 40436 3621 13 critics critic NNS 40436 3621 14 do do VBP 40436 3621 15 so so RB 40436 3621 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3621 17 as as IN 40436 3621 18 so so RB 40436 3621 19 much much RB 40436 3621 20 incontestable incontestable JJ 40436 3621 21 truth truth NN 40436 3621 22 : : : 40436 3621 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3621 24 must must MD 40436 3621 25 consider consider VB 40436 3621 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3621 27 as as IN 40436 3621 28 an an DT 40436 3621 29 opinion opinion NN 40436 3621 30 delivered deliver VBN 40436 3621 31 by by IN 40436 3621 32 one one CD 40436 3621 33 of of IN 40436 3621 34 the the DT 40436 3621 35 speakers speaker NNS 40436 3621 36 in in IN 40436 3621 37 the the DT 40436 3621 38 conversation conversation NN 40436 3621 39 , , , 40436 3621 40 but but CC 40436 3621 41 not not RB 40436 3621 42 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 3621 43 well well RB 40436 3621 44 founded found VBN 40436 3621 45 . . . 40436 3622 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3622 2 6 6 CD 40436 3622 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3622 4 Unquestionably unquestionably RB 40436 3622 5 , , , 40436 3622 6 the the DT 40436 3622 7 comments comment NNS 40436 3622 8 made make VBN 40436 3622 9 upon upon IN 40436 3622 10 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3622 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3622 12 both both DT 40436 3622 13 in in IN 40436 3622 14 that that DT 40436 3622 15 age age NN 40436 3622 16 and and CC 40436 3622 17 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 3622 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3622 19 were be VBD 40436 3622 20 often often RB 40436 3622 21 fanciful fanciful JJ 40436 3622 22 and and CC 40436 3622 23 misleading misleading JJ 40436 3622 24 . . . 40436 3623 1 Metrodorus Metrodorus NNP 40436 3623 2 , , , 40436 3623 3 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 3623 4 , , , 40436 3623 5 and and CC 40436 3623 6 others other NNS 40436 3623 7 , , , 40436 3623 8 resolved resolve VBD 40436 3623 9 the the DT 40436 3623 10 Homeric Homeric NNP 40436 3623 11 narrative narrative NN 40436 3623 12 into into IN 40436 3623 13 various various JJ 40436 3623 14 allegories allegory NNS 40436 3623 15 , , , 40436 3623 16 physical physical JJ 40436 3623 17 , , , 40436 3623 18 ethical ethical JJ 40436 3623 19 , , , 40436 3623 20 and and CC 40436 3623 21 theological theological JJ 40436 3623 22 : : : 40436 3623 23 and and CC 40436 3623 24 most most JJS 40436 3623 25 men man NNS 40436 3623 26 who who WP 40436 3623 27 had have VBD 40436 3623 28 an an DT 40436 3623 29 opinion opinion NN 40436 3623 30 to to TO 40436 3623 31 defend defend VB 40436 3623 32 , , , 40436 3623 33 rejoiced rejoice VBN 40436 3623 34 to to TO 40436 3623 35 be be VB 40436 3623 36 able able JJ 40436 3623 37 to to TO 40436 3623 38 support support VB 40436 3623 39 or or CC 40436 3623 40 enforce enforce VB 40436 3623 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3623 42 by by IN 40436 3623 43 some some DT 40436 3623 44 passages passage NNS 40436 3623 45 of of IN 40436 3623 46 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3623 47 , , , 40436 3623 48 well well UH 40436 3623 49 or or CC 40436 3623 50 ill ill RB 40436 3623 51 - - HYPH 40436 3623 52 explained explain VBN 40436 3623 53 -- -- : 40436 3623 54 just just RB 40436 3623 55 as as IN 40436 3623 56 texts text NNS 40436 3623 57 of of IN 40436 3623 58 the the DT 40436 3623 59 Bible Bible NNP 40436 3623 60 are be VBP 40436 3623 61 quoted quote VBN 40436 3623 62 in in IN 40436 3623 63 modern modern JJ 40436 3623 64 times time NNS 40436 3623 65 . . . 40436 3624 1 In in IN 40436 3624 2 this this DT 40436 3624 3 manner manner NN 40436 3624 4 , , , 40436 3624 5 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3624 6 was be VBD 40436 3624 7 pressed press VBN 40436 3624 8 into into IN 40436 3624 9 the the DT 40436 3624 10 service service NN 40436 3624 11 of of IN 40436 3624 12 every every DT 40436 3624 13 disputant disputant NN 40436 3624 14 ; ; : 40436 3624 15 and and CC 40436 3624 16 the the DT 40436 3624 17 Homeric Homeric NNP 40436 3624 18 poems poem NNS 40436 3624 19 were be VBD 40436 3624 20 presented present VBN 40436 3624 21 as as IN 40436 3624 22 containing contain VBG 40436 3624 23 , , , 40436 3624 24 or or CC 40436 3624 25 at at IN 40436 3624 26 least least JJS 40436 3624 27 as as IN 40436 3624 28 implying implying JJ 40436 3624 29 , , , 40436 3624 30 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 3624 31 quite quite RB 40436 3624 32 foreign foreign JJ 40436 3624 33 to to IN 40436 3624 34 the the DT 40436 3624 35 age age NN 40436 3624 36 in in IN 40436 3624 37 which which WDT 40436 3624 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3624 39 were be VBD 40436 3624 40 composed compose VBN 40436 3624 41 . . . 40436 3625 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3625 2 7 7 CD 40436 3625 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3625 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3625 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3625 6 5 5 CD 40436 3625 7 : : : 40436 3625 8 Xen Xen NNP 40436 3625 9 . . . 40436 3626 1 Sympos Sympos NNP 40436 3626 2 . . . 40436 3627 1 iii iii NNP 40436 3627 2 . . . 40436 3628 1 6 6 CD 40436 3628 2 . . . 40436 3629 1 Nikêratus Nikêratus NNP 40436 3629 2 says say VBZ 40436 3629 3 that that IN 40436 3629 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3629 5 heard hear VBD 40436 3629 6 the the DT 40436 3629 7 rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3629 8 nearly nearly RB 40436 3629 9 every every DT 40436 3629 10 day day NN 40436 3629 11 . . . 40436 3630 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3630 2 professes profess VBZ 40436 3630 3 to to TO 40436 3630 4 be be VB 40436 3630 5 able able JJ 40436 3630 6 to to TO 40436 3630 7 repeat repeat VB 40436 3630 8 both both CC 40436 3630 9 the the DT 40436 3630 10 Iliad Iliad NNS 40436 3630 11 and and CC 40436 3630 12 the the DT 40436 3630 13 Odyssey odyssey NN 40436 3630 14 from from IN 40436 3630 15 memory memory NN 40436 3630 16 . . . 40436 3630 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3631 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3631 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3631 3 6 6 CD 40436 3631 4 : : : 40436 3631 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 3631 6 . . . 40436 3632 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 3632 2 . . . 40436 3633 1 iv iv XX 40436 3633 2 . . . 40436 3634 1 2 2 CD 40436 3634 2 , , , 40436 3634 3 10 10 CD 40436 3634 4 ; ; : 40436 3634 5 Sympos Sympos NNP 40436 3634 6 . . . 40436 3635 1 iii iii NNP 40436 3635 2 . . . 40436 3636 1 6 6 LS 40436 3636 2 ; ; : 40436 3636 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3636 4 , , , 40436 3636 5 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3636 6 , , , 40436 3636 7 530 530 CD 40436 3636 8 E. E. NNP 40436 3636 9 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 3636 10 cites cite VBZ 40436 3636 11 this this DT 40436 3636 12 judgment judgment NN 40436 3636 13 about about IN 40436 3636 14 the the DT 40436 3636 15 rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3636 16 as as IN 40436 3636 17 if if IN 40436 3636 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3636 19 had have VBD 40436 3636 20 been be VBN 40436 3636 21 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 3636 22 by by IN 40436 3636 23 the the DT 40436 3636 24 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 3636 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3636 26 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3636 27 , , , 40436 3636 28 which which WDT 40436 3636 29 is be VBZ 40436 3636 30 not not RB 40436 3636 31 the the DT 40436 3636 32 fact fact NN 40436 3636 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3636 34 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 3636 35 , , , 40436 3636 36 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 3636 37 p. p. NN 40436 3637 1 3 3 LS 40436 3637 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3637 3 . . . 40436 3637 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3638 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3638 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3638 3 7 7 CD 40436 3638 4 : : : 40436 3638 5 Diogenes Diogenes NNPS 40436 3638 6 Laert Laert NNP 40436 3638 7 . . . 40436 3639 1 ii ii LS 40436 3639 2 . . . 40436 3640 1 11 11 LS 40436 3640 2 ; ; : 40436 3640 3 Nitzsch Nitzsch NNP 40436 3640 4 , , , 40436 3640 5 Die die VB 40436 3640 6 Heldensage Heldensage NNP 40436 3640 7 des des FW 40436 3640 8 Griechen Griechen NNP 40436 3640 9 , , , 40436 3640 10 pp pp NNP 40436 3640 11 . . . 40436 3641 1 74 74 CD 40436 3641 2 - - SYM 40436 3641 3 78 78 CD 40436 3641 4 ; ; : 40436 3641 5 Lobeck Lobeck NNP 40436 3641 6 , , , 40436 3641 7 Agloaphamus Agloaphamus NNP 40436 3641 8 , , , 40436 3641 9 p. p. NN 40436 3641 10 157 157 CD 40436 3641 11 . . . 40436 3642 1 Seneca Seneca NNP 40436 3642 2 , , , 40436 3642 3 Epistol Epistol NNP 40436 3642 4 . . . 40436 3643 1 88 88 CD 40436 3643 2 : : : 40436 3643 3 " " `` 40436 3643 4 modo modo NNP 40436 3643 5 Stoicum Stoicum NNP 40436 3643 6 Homerum Homerum NNP 40436 3643 7 faciunt faciunt NN 40436 3643 8 -- -- : 40436 3643 9 modo modo JJ 40436 3643 10 Epicureum Epicureum NNP 40436 3643 11 . . . 40436 3644 1 . . . 40436 3645 1 . . . 40436 3646 1 modo modo NNP 40436 3646 2 Peripateticum Peripateticum NNP 40436 3646 3 , , , 40436 3646 4 tria tria NNP 40436 3646 5 genera genera NNP 40436 3646 6 bonorum bonorum NNP 40436 3646 7 inducentem inducentem NN 40436 3646 8 : : : 40436 3646 9 modo modo NNP 40436 3646 10 Academicum Academicum NNP 40436 3646 11 , , , 40436 3646 12 incerta incerta NNP 40436 3646 13 omnia omnia NNP 40436 3646 14 dicentem dicentem NNP 40436 3646 15 . . . 40436 3647 1 Apparet Apparet NNP 40436 3647 2 nihil nihil NNP 40436 3647 3 horum horum NNP 40436 3647 4 esse esse NNP 40436 3647 5 in in IN 40436 3647 6 illo illo NN 40436 3647 7 , , , 40436 3647 8 cui cui NNP 40436 3647 9 omnia omnia NNP 40436 3647 10 insunt insunt NN 40436 3647 11 : : : 40436 3647 12 ista ista NNP 40436 3647 13 enim enim NNP 40436 3647 14 inter inter NNP 40436 3647 15 se se FW 40436 3647 16 dissident dissident JJ 40436 3647 17 . . . 40436 3647 18 " " '' 40436 3647 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3648 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3648 2 Side side NN 40436 3648 3 - - HYPH 40436 3648 4 note note NN 40436 3648 5 : : : 40436 3648 6 The the DT 40436 3648 7 popularity popularity NN 40436 3648 8 of of IN 40436 3648 9 the the DT 40436 3648 10 Rhapsodes Rhapsodes NNPS 40436 3648 11 was be VBD 40436 3648 12 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 3648 13 derived derive VBN 40436 3648 14 from from IN 40436 3648 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3648 16 recitation recitation NN 40436 3648 17 . . . 40436 3649 1 Powerful powerful JJ 40436 3649 2 effect effect NN 40436 3649 3 which which WDT 40436 3649 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3649 5 produced produce VBD 40436 3649 6 . . . 40436 3649 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3650 1 The the DT 40436 3650 2 Rhapsodes Rhapsodes NNPS 40436 3650 3 , , , 40436 3650 4 in in IN 40436 3650 5 so so RB 40436 3650 6 far far RB 40436 3650 7 as as IN 40436 3650 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3650 9 interpreted interpret VBD 40436 3650 10 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3650 11 , , , 40436 3650 12 were be VBD 40436 3650 13 probably probably RB 40436 3650 14 not not RB 40436 3650 15 less less RBR 40436 3650 16 disposed disposed JJ 40436 3650 17 than than IN 40436 3650 18 others other NNS 40436 3650 19 to to TO 40436 3650 20 discover discover VB 40436 3650 21 in in IN 40436 3650 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3650 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3650 24 own own JJ 40436 3650 25 fancies fancy NNS 40436 3650 26 . . . 40436 3651 1 But but CC 40436 3651 2 the the DT 40436 3651 3 character character NN 40436 3651 4 in in IN 40436 3651 5 which which WDT 40436 3651 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3651 7 acquired acquire VBD 40436 3651 8 most most JJS 40436 3651 9 popularity popularity NN 40436 3651 10 , , , 40436 3651 11 was be VBD 40436 3651 12 , , , 40436 3651 13 not not RB 40436 3651 14 as as IN 40436 3651 15 expositors expositor NNS 40436 3651 16 , , , 40436 3651 17 but but CC 40436 3651 18 as as IN 40436 3651 19 reciters reciter NNS 40436 3651 20 , , , 40436 3651 21 of of IN 40436 3651 22 the the DT 40436 3651 23 poems poem NNS 40436 3651 24 . . . 40436 3652 1 The the DT 40436 3652 2 powerful powerful JJ 40436 3652 3 emotion emotion NN 40436 3652 4 which which WDT 40436 3652 5 , , , 40436 3652 6 in in IN 40436 3652 7 the the DT 40436 3652 8 process process NN 40436 3652 9 of of IN 40436 3652 10 reciting recite VBG 40436 3652 11 , , , 40436 3652 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3652 13 both both DT 40436 3652 14 felt feel VBD 40436 3652 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3652 16 and and CC 40436 3652 17 communicated communicate VBN 40436 3652 18 to to IN 40436 3652 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3652 20 auditors auditor NNS 40436 3652 21 , , , 40436 3652 22 is be VBZ 40436 3652 23 declared declare VBN 40436 3652 24 in in IN 40436 3652 25 this this DT 40436 3652 26 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3652 27 : : : 40436 3652 28 " " `` 40436 3652 29 When when WRB 40436 3652 30 that that DT 40436 3652 31 which which WDT 40436 3652 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3652 33 recite recite VBP 40436 3652 34 is be VBZ 40436 3652 35 pathetic pathetic JJ 40436 3652 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3652 37 says say VBZ 40436 3652 38 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3652 39 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3652 40 , , , 40436 3652 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3652 42 eyes eye NNS 40436 3652 43 are be VBP 40436 3652 44 filled fill VBN 40436 3652 45 with with IN 40436 3652 46 tears tear NNS 40436 3652 47 : : : 40436 3652 48 when when WRB 40436 3652 49 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3652 50 is be VBZ 40436 3652 51 awful awful JJ 40436 3652 52 or or CC 40436 3652 53 terrible terrible JJ 40436 3652 54 , , , 40436 3652 55 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3652 56 hair hair NN 40436 3652 57 stands stand VBZ 40436 3652 58 on on IN 40436 3652 59 end end NN 40436 3652 60 , , , 40436 3652 61 and and CC 40436 3652 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3652 63 heart heart NN 40436 3652 64 leaps leaps RB 40436 3652 65 . . . 40436 3653 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 3653 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3653 3 see see VBP 40436 3653 4 the the DT 40436 3653 5 spectators spectator NNS 40436 3653 6 also also RB 40436 3653 7 weeping weep VBG 40436 3653 8 , , , 40436 3653 9 sympathising sympathise VBG 40436 3653 10 with with IN 40436 3653 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3653 12 emotions emotion NNS 40436 3653 13 , , , 40436 3653 14 and and CC 40436 3653 15 looking look VBG 40436 3653 16 aghast aghast NN 40436 3653 17 at at IN 40436 3653 18 what what WP 40436 3653 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3653 20 hear hear VBP 40436 3653 21 . . . 40436 3654 1 " " `` 40436 3654 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3654 3 8 8 CD 40436 3654 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3654 5 This this DT 40436 3654 6 assertion assertion NN 40436 3654 7 of of IN 40436 3654 8 the the DT 40436 3654 9 vehement vehement JJ 40436 3654 10 emotional emotional JJ 40436 3654 11 effect effect NN 40436 3654 12 produced produce VBN 40436 3654 13 by by IN 40436 3654 14 the the DT 40436 3654 15 words word NNS 40436 3654 16 of of IN 40436 3654 17 the the DT 40436 3654 18 poet poet NN 40436 3654 19 as as IN 40436 3654 20 declaimed declaim VBN 40436 3654 21 or or CC 40436 3654 22 sung sing VBN 40436 3654 23 by by IN 40436 3654 24 the the DT 40436 3654 25 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3654 26 , , , 40436 3654 27 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 3654 28 all all PDT 40436 3654 29 the the DT 40436 3654 30 more more JJR 40436 3654 31 credit credit NN 40436 3654 32 -- -- : 40436 3654 33 because because IN 40436 3654 34 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3654 35 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3654 36 , , , 40436 3654 37 far far RB 40436 3654 38 from from IN 40436 3654 39 looking look VBG 40436 3654 40 upon upon IN 40436 3654 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3654 42 favourably favourably RB 40436 3654 43 , , , 40436 3654 44 either either CC 40436 3654 45 derides deride NNS 40436 3654 46 or or CC 40436 3654 47 disapproves disapprove VBZ 40436 3654 48 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3654 49 . . . 40436 3655 1 Accepting accept VBG 40436 3655 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3655 3 as as IN 40436 3655 4 a a DT 40436 3655 5 matter matter NN 40436 3655 6 of of IN 40436 3655 7 fact fact NN 40436 3655 8 , , , 40436 3655 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3655 10 see see VBP 40436 3655 11 that that IN 40436 3655 12 the the DT 40436 3655 13 influence influence NN 40436 3655 14 of of IN 40436 3655 15 rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3655 16 , , , 40436 3655 17 among among IN 40436 3655 18 auditors auditor NNS 40436 3655 19 generally generally RB 40436 3655 20 , , , 40436 3655 21 must must MD 40436 3655 22 have have VB 40436 3655 23 been be VBN 40436 3655 24 derived derive VBN 40436 3655 25 more more RBR 40436 3655 26 from from IN 40436 3655 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3655 28 efficacy efficacy NN 40436 3655 29 as as IN 40436 3655 30 actors actor NNS 40436 3655 31 than than IN 40436 3655 32 from from IN 40436 3655 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3655 34 ability ability NN 40436 3655 35 as as IN 40436 3655 36 expositors expositor NNS 40436 3655 37 . . . 40436 3656 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3656 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3656 3 8 8 CD 40436 3656 4 : : : 40436 3656 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3656 6 , , , 40436 3656 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3656 8 , , , 40436 3656 9 535 535 CD 40436 3656 10 C C NNP 40436 3656 11 - - HYPH 40436 3656 12 E. E. NNP 40436 3657 1 The the DT 40436 3657 2 description description NN 40436 3657 3 here here RB 40436 3657 4 given give VBN 40436 3657 5 is be VBZ 40436 3657 6 the the DT 40436 3657 7 more more RBR 40436 3657 8 interesting interesting JJ 40436 3657 9 because because IN 40436 3657 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3657 11 is be VBZ 40436 3657 12 the the DT 40436 3657 13 only only JJ 40436 3657 14 intimation intimation NN 40436 3657 15 remaining remain VBG 40436 3657 16 of of IN 40436 3657 17 the the DT 40436 3657 18 strong strong JJ 40436 3657 19 effect effect NN 40436 3657 20 produced produce VBN 40436 3657 21 by by IN 40436 3657 22 these these DT 40436 3657 23 rhapsodic rhapsodic JJ 40436 3657 24 representations representation NNS 40436 3657 25 . . . 40436 3657 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3658 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3658 2 Side side NN 40436 3658 3 - - HYPH 40436 3658 4 note note NN 40436 3658 5 : : : 40436 3658 6 Ion ion VB 40436 3658 7 both both CC 40436 3658 8 reciter reciter NN 40436 3658 9 and and CC 40436 3658 10 expositor expositor NN 40436 3658 11 -- -- : 40436 3658 12 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3658 13 was be VBD 40436 3658 14 considered consider VBN 40436 3658 15 more more JJR 40436 3658 16 as as IN 40436 3658 17 an an DT 40436 3658 18 instructor instructor NN 40436 3658 19 than than IN 40436 3658 20 as as IN 40436 3658 21 a a DT 40436 3658 22 poet poet NN 40436 3658 23 . . . 40436 3658 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3659 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3659 2 however however RB 40436 3659 3 is be VBZ 40436 3659 4 described describe VBN 40436 3659 5 in in IN 40436 3659 6 this this DT 40436 3659 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3659 8 as as IN 40436 3659 9 combining combine VBG 40436 3659 10 the the DT 40436 3659 11 two two CD 40436 3659 12 functions function NNS 40436 3659 13 of of IN 40436 3659 14 reciter reciter NN 40436 3659 15 and and CC 40436 3659 16 expositor expositor NN 40436 3659 17 : : : 40436 3659 18 a a DT 40436 3659 19 partnership partnership NN 40436 3659 20 like like IN 40436 3659 21 that that DT 40436 3659 22 of of IN 40436 3659 23 Garrick Garrick NNP 40436 3659 24 and and CC 40436 3659 25 Johnson Johnson NNP 40436 3659 26 , , , 40436 3659 27 in in IN 40436 3659 28 regard regard NN 40436 3659 29 to to IN 40436 3659 30 Shakspeare Shakspeare NNP 40436 3659 31 . . . 40436 3660 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3660 2 is be VBZ 40436 3660 3 in in IN 40436 3660 4 the the DT 40436 3660 5 last last JJ 40436 3660 6 of of IN 40436 3660 7 the the DT 40436 3660 8 two two CD 40436 3660 9 functions function NNS 40436 3660 10 , , , 40436 3660 11 that that IN 40436 3660 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3660 13 here here RB 40436 3660 14 examines examine VBZ 40436 3660 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3660 16 : : : 40436 3660 17 considering consider VBG 40436 3660 18 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3660 19 , , , 40436 3660 20 not not RB 40436 3660 21 as as IN 40436 3660 22 a a DT 40436 3660 23 poet poet NN 40436 3660 24 appealing appeal VBG 40436 3660 25 to to IN 40436 3660 26 the the DT 40436 3660 27 emotions emotion NNS 40436 3660 28 of of IN 40436 3660 29 hearers hearer NNS 40436 3660 30 , , , 40436 3660 31 but but CC 40436 3660 32 as as IN 40436 3660 33 a a DT 40436 3660 34 teacher teacher NN 40436 3660 35 administering administer VBG 40436 3660 36 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3660 37 and and CC 40436 3660 38 imparting impart VBG 40436 3660 39 instruction instruction NN 40436 3660 40 . . . 40436 3661 1 Such such JJ 40436 3661 2 was be VBD 40436 3661 3 the the DT 40436 3661 4 view view NN 40436 3661 5 of of IN 40436 3661 6 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3661 7 entertained entertain VBN 40436 3661 8 by by IN 40436 3661 9 a a DT 40436 3661 10 large large JJ 40436 3661 11 proportion proportion NN 40436 3661 12 of of IN 40436 3661 13 the the DT 40436 3661 14 Hellenic hellenic JJ 40436 3661 15 world world NN 40436 3661 16 . . . 40436 3662 1 In in IN 40436 3662 2 that that DT 40436 3662 3 capacity capacity NN 40436 3662 4 , , , 40436 3662 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3662 6 poems poem NNS 40436 3662 7 served serve VBD 40436 3662 8 as as IN 40436 3662 9 a a DT 40436 3662 10 theme theme NN 40436 3662 11 for for IN 40436 3662 12 rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3662 13 , , , 40436 3662 14 as as RB 40436 3662 15 well well RB 40436 3662 16 as as IN 40436 3662 17 for for IN 40436 3662 18 various various JJ 40436 3662 19 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 3662 20 and and CC 40436 3662 21 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 3662 22 who who WP 40436 3662 23 were be VBD 40436 3662 24 not not RB 40436 3662 25 rhapsodes rhapsode NNS 40436 3662 26 , , , 40436 3662 27 nor nor CC 40436 3662 28 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 3662 29 reciters reciter NNS 40436 3662 30 . . . 40436 3663 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3663 2 Side side NN 40436 3663 3 - - HYPH 40436 3663 4 note note NN 40436 3663 5 : : : 40436 3663 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3663 7 disregards disregard NNS 40436 3663 8 and and CC 40436 3663 9 disapproves disapprove VBZ 40436 3663 10 the the DT 40436 3663 11 poetic poetic JJ 40436 3663 12 or or CC 40436 3663 13 emotional emotional JJ 40436 3663 14 working working NN 40436 3663 15 . . . 40436 3663 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3664 1 The the DT 40436 3664 2 reader reader NN 40436 3664 3 must must MD 40436 3664 4 keep keep VB 40436 3664 5 in in IN 40436 3664 6 mind mind NN 40436 3664 7 , , , 40436 3664 8 in in IN 40436 3664 9 following follow VBG 40436 3664 10 the the DT 40436 3664 11 questions question NNS 40436 3664 12 put put VBN 40436 3664 13 by by IN 40436 3664 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3664 15 , , , 40436 3664 16 that that IN 40436 3664 17 this this DT 40436 3664 18 pædagogic pædagogic NN 40436 3664 19 and and CC 40436 3664 20 edifying edifying NN 40436 3664 21 view view NN 40436 3664 22 of of IN 40436 3664 23 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3664 24 is be VBZ 40436 3664 25 the the DT 40436 3664 26 only only JJ 40436 3664 27 one one CD 40436 3664 28 present present NN 40436 3664 29 to to IN 40436 3664 30 the the DT 40436 3664 31 men man NNS 40436 3664 32 of of IN 40436 3664 33 the the DT 40436 3664 34 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 3664 35 school school NN 40436 3664 36 -- -- : 40436 3664 37 and and CC 40436 3664 38 especially especially RB 40436 3664 39 to to IN 40436 3664 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3664 41 . . . 40436 3665 1 Of of IN 40436 3665 2 the the DT 40436 3665 3 genuine genuine JJ 40436 3665 4 functions function NNS 40436 3665 5 of of IN 40436 3665 6 the the DT 40436 3665 7 gifted gifted JJ 40436 3665 8 poet poet NN 40436 3665 9 , , , 40436 3665 10 who who WP 40436 3665 11 touches touch VBZ 40436 3665 12 the the DT 40436 3665 13 chords chord NNS 40436 3665 14 of of IN 40436 3665 15 strong strong JJ 40436 3665 16 and and CC 40436 3665 17 diversified diversified JJ 40436 3665 18 emotion--"qui emotion--"qui CD 40436 3665 19 pectus pectus NN 40436 3665 20 inaniter inaniter NN 40436 3665 21 angit angit NN 40436 3665 22 , , , 40436 3665 23 Irritat Irritat NNP 40436 3665 24 , , , 40436 3665 25 mulcet mulcet NN 40436 3665 26 , , , 40436 3665 27 falsis falsis NNP 40436 3665 28 terroribus terroribus NNP 40436 3665 29 implet implet NNP 40436 3665 30 " " '' 40436 3665 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3665 32 Horat Horat NNP 40436 3665 33 . . . 40436 3666 1 Epist epist UH 40436 3666 2 . . . 40436 3667 1 II ii CD 40436 3667 2 . . . 40436 3668 1 1 1 CD 40436 3668 2 , , , 40436 3668 3 212)--Plato 212)--plato CD 40436 3668 4 takes take VBZ 40436 3668 5 no no DT 40436 3668 6 account account NN 40436 3668 7 : : : 40436 3668 8 or or CC 40436 3668 9 rather rather RB 40436 3668 10 , , , 40436 3668 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3668 12 declares declare VBZ 40436 3668 13 open open JJ 40436 3668 14 war war NN 40436 3668 15 against against IN 40436 3668 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3668 17 , , , 40436 3668 18 either either CC 40436 3668 19 as as IN 40436 3668 20 childish childish NNP 40436 3668 21 delusions[9 delusions[9 NNP 40436 3668 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3668 23 , , , 40436 3668 24 or or CC 40436 3668 25 as as IN 40436 3668 26 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 3668 27 stimulants stimulant NNS 40436 3668 28 , , , 40436 3668 29 tending tend VBG 40436 3668 30 to to TO 40436 3668 31 exalt exalt VB 40436 3668 32 the the DT 40436 3668 33 unruly unruly JJ 40436 3668 34 elements element NNS 40436 3668 35 of of IN 40436 3668 36 the the DT 40436 3668 37 mind mind NN 40436 3668 38 , , , 40436 3668 39 and and CC 40436 3668 40 to to TO 40436 3668 41 overthrow overthrow VB 40436 3668 42 the the DT 40436 3668 43 sovereign sovereign JJ 40436 3668 44 authority authority NN 40436 3668 45 of of IN 40436 3668 46 reason reason NN 40436 3668 47 . . . 40436 3669 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3669 2 shall shall MD 40436 3669 3 find find VB 40436 3669 4 farther farth JJR 40436 3669 5 manifestations manifestation NNS 40436 3669 6 on on IN 40436 3669 7 this this DT 40436 3669 8 point point NN 40436 3669 9 in in IN 40436 3669 10 the the DT 40436 3669 11 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3669 12 and and CC 40436 3669 13 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 3669 14 . . . 40436 3670 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3670 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3670 3 9 9 CD 40436 3670 4 : : : 40436 3670 5 The the DT 40436 3670 6 question question NN 40436 3670 7 of of IN 40436 3670 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3670 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3670 10 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3670 11 , , , 40436 3670 12 535 535 CD 40436 3670 13 D d NN 40436 3670 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3670 15 , , , 40436 3670 16 about about IN 40436 3670 17 the the DT 40436 3670 18 emotion emotion NN 40436 3670 19 produced produce VBN 40436 3670 20 in in IN 40436 3670 21 the the DT 40436 3670 22 hearers hearer NNS 40436 3670 23 by by IN 40436 3670 24 the the DT 40436 3670 25 recital recital NN 40436 3670 26 of of IN 40436 3670 27 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3670 28 's 's POS 40436 3670 29 poetry poetry NN 40436 3670 30 , , , 40436 3670 31 bears bear VBZ 40436 3670 32 out out RP 40436 3670 33 what what WP 40436 3670 34 is be VBZ 40436 3670 35 here here RB 40436 3670 36 asserted assert VBN 40436 3670 37 . . . 40436 3670 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3671 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3671 2 Side side NN 40436 3671 3 - - HYPH 40436 3671 4 note note NN 40436 3671 5 : : : 40436 3671 6 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3671 7 devoted devote VBD 40436 3671 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3671 9 to to IN 40436 3671 10 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3671 11 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 3671 12 . . . 40436 3672 1 Questions question NNS 40436 3672 2 of of IN 40436 3672 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3672 4 to to IN 40436 3672 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3672 6 -- -- : 40436 3672 7 How how WRB 40436 3672 8 happens happen VBZ 40436 3672 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3672 10 that that IN 40436 3672 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3672 12 can can MD 40436 3672 13 not not RB 40436 3672 14 talk talk VB 40436 3672 15 equally equally RB 40436 3672 16 upon upon IN 40436 3672 17 other other JJ 40436 3672 18 poets poet NNS 40436 3672 19 ? ? . 40436 3673 1 The the DT 40436 3673 2 poetic poetic JJ 40436 3673 3 art art NN 40436 3673 4 is be VBZ 40436 3673 5 one one CD 40436 3673 6 . . . 40436 3673 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3674 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3674 2 professes professe NNS 40436 3674 3 to to TO 40436 3674 4 have have VB 40436 3674 5 devoted devote VBN 40436 3674 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3674 7 to to IN 40436 3674 8 the the DT 40436 3674 9 study study NN 40436 3674 10 of of IN 40436 3674 11 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3674 12 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 3674 13 , , , 40436 3674 14 neglecting neglect VBG 40436 3674 15 other other JJ 40436 3674 16 poets poet NNS 40436 3674 17 : : : 40436 3674 18 so so IN 40436 3674 19 that that IN 40436 3674 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3674 21 can can MD 40436 3674 22 interpret interpret VB 40436 3674 23 the the DT 40436 3674 24 thoughts thought NNS 40436 3674 25 , , , 40436 3674 26 and and CC 40436 3674 27 furnish furnish VB 40436 3674 28 reflections reflection NNS 40436 3674 29 upon upon IN 40436 3674 30 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3674 31 , , , 40436 3674 32 better well JJR 40436 3674 33 than than IN 40436 3674 34 any any DT 40436 3674 35 other other JJ 40436 3674 36 expositor expositor NN 40436 3674 37 . . . 40436 3675 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3675 2 10 10 CD 40436 3675 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3675 4 How how WRB 40436 3675 5 does do VBZ 40436 3675 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3675 7 happen happen VB 40436 3675 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3675 9 asked ask VBD 40436 3675 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3675 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3675 12 that that IN 40436 3675 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3675 14 have have VBP 40436 3675 15 so so RB 40436 3675 16 much much JJ 40436 3675 17 to to TO 40436 3675 18 say say VB 40436 3675 19 about about IN 40436 3675 20 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3675 21 , , , 40436 3675 22 and and CC 40436 3675 23 nothing nothing NN 40436 3675 24 at at RB 40436 3675 25 all all RB 40436 3675 26 about about IN 40436 3675 27 other other JJ 40436 3675 28 poets poet NNS 40436 3675 29 ? ? . 40436 3676 1 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3676 2 may may MD 40436 3676 3 be be VB 40436 3676 4 the the DT 40436 3676 5 best good JJS 40436 3676 6 of of IN 40436 3676 7 all all DT 40436 3676 8 poets poet NNS 40436 3676 9 : : : 40436 3676 10 but but CC 40436 3676 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3676 12 is be VBZ 40436 3676 13 still still RB 40436 3676 14 only only RB 40436 3676 15 one one CD 40436 3676 16 of of IN 40436 3676 17 those those DT 40436 3676 18 who who WP 40436 3676 19 exercise exercise VBP 40436 3676 20 the the DT 40436 3676 21 poetic poetic JJ 40436 3676 22 art art NN 40436 3676 23 , , , 40436 3676 24 and and CC 40436 3676 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3676 26 must must MD 40436 3676 27 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 3676 28 talk talk VB 40436 3676 29 about about IN 40436 3676 30 the the DT 40436 3676 31 same same JJ 40436 3676 32 subjects subject NNS 40436 3676 33 as as IN 40436 3676 34 other other JJ 40436 3676 35 poets poet NNS 40436 3676 36 . . . 40436 3677 1 Now now RB 40436 3677 2 the the DT 40436 3677 3 art art NN 40436 3677 4 of of IN 40436 3677 5 poetry poetry NN 40436 3677 6 is be VBZ 40436 3677 7 _ _ NNP 40436 3677 8 One One NNP 40436 3677 9 _ _ NNP 40436 3677 10 altogether altogether RB 40436 3677 11 -- -- : 40436 3677 12 like like IN 40436 3677 13 that that DT 40436 3677 14 of of IN 40436 3677 15 painting painting NN 40436 3677 16 , , , 40436 3677 17 sculpture sculpture NN 40436 3677 18 , , , 40436 3677 19 playing play VBG 40436 3677 20 on on IN 40436 3677 21 the the DT 40436 3677 22 flute flute NN 40436 3677 23 , , , 40436 3677 24 playing play VBG 40436 3677 25 on on IN 40436 3677 26 the the DT 40436 3677 27 harp harp NN 40436 3677 28 , , , 40436 3677 29 rhapsodizing rhapsodize VBG 40436 3677 30 , , , 40436 3677 31 & & CC 40436 3677 32 c.[11 c.[11 NN 40436 3677 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3677 34 Whoever whoever WP 40436 3677 35 is be VBZ 40436 3677 36 competent competent JJ 40436 3677 37 to to TO 40436 3677 38 judge judge VB 40436 3677 39 and and CC 40436 3677 40 explain explain VB 40436 3677 41 one one CD 40436 3677 42 artist,--what artist,--what WRB 40436 3677 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3677 44 has have VBZ 40436 3677 45 done do VBN 40436 3677 46 well well RB 40436 3677 47 and and CC 40436 3677 48 what what WP 40436 3677 49 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3677 50 has have VBZ 40436 3677 51 done do VBN 40436 3677 52 ill,--is ill,--is NNP 40436 3677 53 competent competent NN 40436 3677 54 also also RB 40436 3677 55 to to TO 40436 3677 56 judge judge VB 40436 3677 57 any any DT 40436 3677 58 other other JJ 40436 3677 59 artist artist NN 40436 3677 60 in in IN 40436 3677 61 the the DT 40436 3677 62 same same JJ 40436 3677 63 profession profession NN 40436 3677 64 . . . 40436 3678 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3678 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3678 3 10 10 CD 40436 3678 4 : : : 40436 3678 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3678 6 , , , 40436 3678 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3678 8 , , , 40436 3678 9 536 536 CD 40436 3678 10 E. e. NN 40436 3678 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3678 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3678 13 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3678 14 11 11 CD 40436 3678 15 : : : 40436 3678 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3678 17 , , , 40436 3678 18 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3678 19 , , , 40436 3678 20 531 531 CD 40436 3678 21 A a NN 40436 3678 22 , , , 40436 3678 23 532 532 CD 40436 3678 24 C C NNP 40436 3678 25 - - HYPH 40436 3678 26 D. D. NNP 40436 3678 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3678 28 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3678 29 : : : 40436 3678 30 poiêtikê\ poiêtikê\ NNP 40436 3678 31 pou/ pou/ NNP 40436 3678 32 e)sti e)sti NNS 40436 3678 33 to\ to\ NNP 40436 3678 34 o(/lon o(/lon NN 40436 3678 35 . . . 40436 3679 1 . . . 40436 3680 1 . . . 40436 3681 1 Ou)kou ou)kou CD 40436 3681 2 = = SYM 40436 3681 3 n n CC 40436 3681 4 e)peida\n e)peida\n XX 40436 3681 5 la la NNP 40436 3681 6 / / SYM 40436 3681 7 bê| bê| NNP 40436 3681 8 tis tis NNP 40436 3681 9 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3681 10 a)/llên a)/llên IN 40436 3681 11 te te NNP 40436 3681 12 / / SYM 40436 3681 13 chnên chnên NNP 40436 3681 14 ê(ntinou ê(ntinou NNS 40436 3681 15 = = SYM 40436 3681 16 n n CC 40436 3681 17 o(/lên o(/lên NN 40436 3681 18 , , , 40436 3681 19 o o NN 40436 3681 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3681 21 au)to\s au)to\s NNP 40436 3681 22 tro tro NN 40436 3681 23 / / SYM 40436 3681 24 pos pos NNP 40436 3681 25 tê tê NNP 40436 3681 26 = = SYM 40436 3681 27 s s NNP 40436 3681 28 ske ske NNP 40436 3681 29 / / SYM 40436 3681 30 pseô pseô NNP 40436 3681 31 / / SYM 40436 3681 32 s s NNP 40436 3681 33 e)sti e)sti NNS 40436 3681 34 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 3681 35 a(pasô a(pasô RP 40436 3681 36 = = SYM 40436 3681 37 n n CC 40436 3681 38 tô tô NNP 40436 3681 39 = = SYM 40436 3681 40 n n CC 40436 3681 41 technô technô NNP 40436 3681 42 = = SYM 40436 3681 43 n n XX 40436 3681 44 ? ? . 40436 3681 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3682 1 533 533 CD 40436 3682 2 A. a. NN 40436 3682 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3683 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3683 2 can can MD 40436 3683 3 not not RB 40436 3683 4 explain explain VB 40436 3683 5 to to IN 40436 3683 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3683 7 how how WRB 40436 3683 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3683 9 happens happen VBZ 40436 3683 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3683 11 replies reply NNS 40436 3683 12 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3683 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3683 14 : : : 40436 3683 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3683 16 only only RB 40436 3683 17 know know VBP 40436 3683 18 the the DT 40436 3683 19 fact fact NN 40436 3683 20 incontestably incontestably RB 40436 3683 21 -- -- : 40436 3683 22 that that IN 40436 3683 23 when when WRB 40436 3683 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3683 25 talk talk VBP 40436 3683 26 about about IN 40436 3683 27 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3683 28 , , , 40436 3683 29 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3683 30 thoughts thought NNS 40436 3683 31 flow flow VBP 40436 3683 32 abundantly abundantly RB 40436 3683 33 , , , 40436 3683 34 and and CC 40436 3683 35 every every DT 40436 3683 36 one one NN 40436 3683 37 tells tell VBZ 40436 3683 38 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3683 39 that that IN 40436 3683 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3683 41 discourse discourse NN 40436 3683 42 is be VBZ 40436 3683 43 excellent excellent JJ 40436 3683 44 . . . 40436 3684 1 Quite quite PDT 40436 3684 2 the the DT 40436 3684 3 reverse reverse NN 40436 3684 4 , , , 40436 3684 5 when when WRB 40436 3684 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3684 7 talk talk VBP 40436 3684 8 of of IN 40436 3684 9 any any DT 40436 3684 10 other other JJ 40436 3684 11 poet poet NN 40436 3684 12 . . . 40436 3685 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3685 2 12 12 CD 40436 3685 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3685 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3685 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3685 6 12 12 CD 40436 3685 7 : : : 40436 3685 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3685 9 , , , 40436 3685 10 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3685 11 , , , 40436 3685 12 533 533 CD 40436 3685 13 C. C. NNP 40436 3685 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3685 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3685 16 Side side NN 40436 3685 17 - - HYPH 40436 3685 18 note note NN 40436 3685 19 : : : 40436 3685 20 Explanation explanation NN 40436 3685 21 given give VBN 40436 3685 22 by by IN 40436 3685 23 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3685 24 . . . 40436 3686 1 Both both DT 40436 3686 2 the the DT 40436 3686 3 Rhapsode Rhapsode NNP 40436 3686 4 and and CC 40436 3686 5 the the DT 40436 3686 6 Poet Poet NNP 40436 3686 7 work work NN 40436 3686 8 , , , 40436 3686 9 not not RB 40436 3686 10 by by IN 40436 3686 11 art art NN 40436 3686 12 and and CC 40436 3686 13 system system NN 40436 3686 14 , , , 40436 3686 15 but but CC 40436 3686 16 by by IN 40436 3686 17 divine divine JJ 40436 3686 18 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3686 19 . . . 40436 3687 1 Fine fine JJ 40436 3687 2 poets poet NNS 40436 3687 3 are be VBP 40436 3687 4 bereft bereft JJ 40436 3687 5 of of IN 40436 3687 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3687 7 reason reason NN 40436 3687 8 , , , 40436 3687 9 and and CC 40436 3687 10 possessed possess VBN 40436 3687 11 by by IN 40436 3687 12 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3687 13 from from IN 40436 3687 14 some some DT 40436 3687 15 God God NNP 40436 3687 16 . . . 40436 3687 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3688 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3688 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3688 3 _ _ NNP 40436 3688 4 can can MD 40436 3688 5 explain explain VB 40436 3688 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3688 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3688 8 says say VBZ 40436 3688 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3688 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3688 11 . . . 40436 3689 1 Your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3689 2 talent talent NN 40436 3689 3 in in IN 40436 3689 4 expounding expound VBG 40436 3689 5 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3689 6 is be VBZ 40436 3689 7 not not RB 40436 3689 8 an an DT 40436 3689 9 art art NN 40436 3689 10 , , , 40436 3689 11 acquired acquire VBN 40436 3689 12 by by IN 40436 3689 13 system system NN 40436 3689 14 and and CC 40436 3689 15 method method NN 40436 3689 16 -- -- : 40436 3689 17 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 3689 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3689 19 would would MD 40436 3689 20 have have VB 40436 3689 21 been be VBN 40436 3689 22 applicable applicable JJ 40436 3689 23 to to IN 40436 3689 24 other other JJ 40436 3689 25 poets poet NNS 40436 3689 26 besides besides RB 40436 3689 27 . . . 40436 3690 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3690 2 is be VBZ 40436 3690 3 a a DT 40436 3690 4 special special JJ 40436 3690 5 gift gift NN 40436 3690 6 , , , 40436 3690 7 imparted impart VBN 40436 3690 8 to to IN 40436 3690 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3690 10 by by IN 40436 3690 11 divine divine JJ 40436 3690 12 power power NN 40436 3690 13 and and CC 40436 3690 14 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3690 15 . . . 40436 3691 1 The the DT 40436 3691 2 like like NN 40436 3691 3 is be VBZ 40436 3691 4 true true JJ 40436 3691 5 of of IN 40436 3691 6 the the DT 40436 3691 7 poet poet NN 40436 3691 8 whom whom WP 40436 3691 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3691 10 expound expound VBP 40436 3691 11 . . . 40436 3692 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3692 2 genius genius NN 40436 3692 3 does do VBZ 40436 3692 4 not not RB 40436 3692 5 spring spring VB 40436 3692 6 from from IN 40436 3692 7 art art NN 40436 3692 8 , , , 40436 3692 9 system system NN 40436 3692 10 , , , 40436 3692 11 or or CC 40436 3692 12 method method NN 40436 3692 13 : : : 40436 3692 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3692 15 is be VBZ 40436 3692 16 a a DT 40436 3692 17 special special JJ 40436 3692 18 gift gift NN 40436 3692 19 emanating emanate VBG 40436 3692 20 from from IN 40436 3692 21 the the DT 40436 3692 22 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3692 23 of of IN 40436 3692 24 the the DT 40436 3692 25 Muses Muses NNPS 40436 3692 26 . . . 40436 3693 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3693 2 13 13 CD 40436 3693 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3693 4 A a DT 40436 3693 5 poet poet NN 40436 3693 6 is be VBZ 40436 3693 7 a a DT 40436 3693 8 light light NN 40436 3693 9 , , , 40436 3693 10 airy airy NNP 40436 3693 11 , , , 40436 3693 12 holy holy JJ 40436 3693 13 , , , 40436 3693 14 person person NN 40436 3693 15 , , , 40436 3693 16 who who WP 40436 3693 17 can can MD 40436 3693 18 not not RB 40436 3693 19 compose compose VB 40436 3693 20 verses verse NNS 40436 3693 21 at at RB 40436 3693 22 all all RB 40436 3693 23 so so RB 40436 3693 24 long long RB 40436 3693 25 as as IN 40436 3693 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3693 27 reason reason NN 40436 3693 28 remains remain VBZ 40436 3693 29 within within IN 40436 3693 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3693 31 . . . 40436 3694 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3694 2 14 14 CD 40436 3694 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3694 4 The the DT 40436 3694 5 Muses muse NNS 40436 3694 6 take take VB 40436 3694 7 away away RB 40436 3694 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3694 9 reason reason NN 40436 3694 10 , , , 40436 3694 11 substituting substitute VBG 40436 3694 12 in in IN 40436 3694 13 place place NN 40436 3694 14 of of IN 40436 3694 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3694 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3694 17 own own JJ 40436 3694 18 divine divine JJ 40436 3694 19 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3694 20 and and CC 40436 3694 21 special special JJ 40436 3694 22 impulse impulse NN 40436 3694 23 , , , 40436 3694 24 either either CC 40436 3694 25 towards towards IN 40436 3694 26 epic epic NN 40436 3694 27 , , , 40436 3694 28 dithyramb dithyramb NNP 40436 3694 29 , , , 40436 3694 30 encomiastic encomiastic JJ 40436 3694 31 hymns hymn NNS 40436 3694 32 , , , 40436 3694 33 hyporchemata hyporchemata NNP 40436 3694 34 , , , 40436 3694 35 & & CC 40436 3694 36 c. c. NNP 40436 3694 37 , , , 40436 3694 38 one one CD 40436 3694 39 or or CC 40436 3694 40 other other JJ 40436 3694 41 of of IN 40436 3694 42 these these DT 40436 3694 43 . . . 40436 3695 1 Each each DT 40436 3695 2 poet poet NN 40436 3695 3 receives receive VBZ 40436 3695 4 one one CD 40436 3695 5 of of IN 40436 3695 6 these these DT 40436 3695 7 special special JJ 40436 3695 8 gifts gift NNS 40436 3695 9 , , , 40436 3695 10 but but CC 40436 3695 11 is be VBZ 40436 3695 12 incompetent incompetent JJ 40436 3695 13 for for IN 40436 3695 14 any any DT 40436 3695 15 of of IN 40436 3695 16 the the DT 40436 3695 17 others other NNS 40436 3695 18 : : : 40436 3695 19 whereas whereas IN 40436 3695 20 , , , 40436 3695 21 if if IN 40436 3695 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3695 23 ability ability NN 40436 3695 24 had have VBD 40436 3695 25 been be VBN 40436 3695 26 methodical methodical JJ 40436 3695 27 or or CC 40436 3695 28 artistic artistic JJ 40436 3695 29 , , , 40436 3695 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3695 31 would would MD 40436 3695 32 have have VB 40436 3695 33 displayed display VBN 40436 3695 34 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 3695 35 in in IN 40436 3695 36 all all DT 40436 3695 37 of of IN 40436 3695 38 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3695 39 alike alike RB 40436 3695 40 . . . 40436 3696 1 Like like IN 40436 3696 2 prophets prophet NNS 40436 3696 3 , , , 40436 3696 4 and and CC 40436 3696 5 deliverers deliverer NNS 40436 3696 6 of of IN 40436 3696 7 oracles oracle NNS 40436 3696 8 , , , 40436 3696 9 these these DT 40436 3696 10 poets poet NNS 40436 3696 11 have have VBP 40436 3696 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3696 13 reason reason NN 40436 3696 14 taken take VBN 40436 3696 15 away away RB 40436 3696 16 , , , 40436 3696 17 and and CC 40436 3696 18 become become VBP 40436 3696 19 servants servant NNS 40436 3696 20 of of IN 40436 3696 21 the the DT 40436 3696 22 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3696 23 . . . 40436 3697 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3697 2 15 15 CD 40436 3697 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3697 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3697 5 is be VBZ 40436 3697 6 not not RB 40436 3697 7 _ _ IN 40436 3697 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3697 9 _ _ NNP 40436 3697 10 who who WP 40436 3697 11 , , , 40436 3697 12 bereft bereft NNS 40436 3697 13 of of IN 40436 3697 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3697 15 reason reason NN 40436 3697 16 , , , 40436 3697 17 speak speak VBP 40436 3697 18 in in IN 40436 3697 19 such such JJ 40436 3697 20 sublime sublime JJ 40436 3697 21 strains strain NNS 40436 3697 22 : : : 40436 3697 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3697 24 is be VBZ 40436 3697 25 the the DT 40436 3697 26 God God NNP 40436 3697 27 who who WP 40436 3697 28 speaks speak VBZ 40436 3697 29 to to IN 40436 3697 30 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3697 31 , , , 40436 3697 32 and and CC 40436 3697 33 speaks speak VBZ 40436 3697 34 through through IN 40436 3697 35 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3697 36 . . . 40436 3698 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3698 2 may may MD 40436 3698 3 see see VB 40436 3698 4 this this DT 40436 3698 5 by by IN 40436 3698 6 Tynnichus Tynnichus NNP 40436 3698 7 of of IN 40436 3698 8 Chalkis Chalkis NNP 40436 3698 9 ; ; : 40436 3698 10 who who WP 40436 3698 11 composed compose VBD 40436 3698 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3698 13 Pæan Pæan NNP 40436 3698 14 , , , 40436 3698 15 the the DT 40436 3698 16 finest fine JJS 40436 3698 17 of of IN 40436 3698 18 all all DT 40436 3698 19 Pæans Pæans NNPS 40436 3698 20 , , , 40436 3698 21 which which WDT 40436 3698 22 is be VBZ 40436 3698 23 in in IN 40436 3698 24 every every DT 40436 3698 25 one one NN 40436 3698 26 's 's POS 40436 3698 27 mouth mouth NN 40436 3698 28 , , , 40436 3698 29 telling tell VBG 40436 3698 30 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3698 31 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3698 32 , , , 40436 3698 33 that that IN 40436 3698 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3698 35 was be VBD 40436 3698 36 the the DT 40436 3698 37 invention invention NN 40436 3698 38 of of IN 40436 3698 39 the the DT 40436 3698 40 Muses Muses NNPS 40436 3698 41 -- -- : 40436 3698 42 but but CC 40436 3698 43 who who WP 40436 3698 44 never never RB 40436 3698 45 composed compose VBD 40436 3698 46 anything anything NN 40436 3698 47 else else RB 40436 3698 48 worth worth JJ 40436 3698 49 hearing hearing NN 40436 3698 50 . . . 40436 3699 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3699 2 is be VBZ 40436 3699 3 through through IN 40436 3699 4 this this DT 40436 3699 5 worthless worthless JJ 40436 3699 6 poet poet NN 40436 3699 7 that that IN 40436 3699 8 the the DT 40436 3699 9 God God NNP 40436 3699 10 has have VBZ 40436 3699 11 sung sing VBN 40436 3699 12 the the DT 40436 3699 13 most most RBS 40436 3699 14 sublime sublime JJ 40436 3699 15 hymn:[16 hymn:[16 NN 40436 3699 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3699 17 for for IN 40436 3699 18 the the DT 40436 3699 19 express express JJ 40436 3699 20 purpose purpose NN 40436 3699 21 of of IN 40436 3699 22 showing show VBG 40436 3699 23 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3699 24 that that IN 40436 3699 25 these these DT 40436 3699 26 fine fine JJ 40436 3699 27 compositions composition NNS 40436 3699 28 are be VBP 40436 3699 29 not not RB 40436 3699 30 human human JJ 40436 3699 31 performances performance NNS 40436 3699 32 at at RB 40436 3699 33 all all RB 40436 3699 34 , , , 40436 3699 35 but but CC 40436 3699 36 divine divine JJ 40436 3699 37 : : : 40436 3699 38 and and CC 40436 3699 39 that that IN 40436 3699 40 the the DT 40436 3699 41 poet poet NN 40436 3699 42 is be VBZ 40436 3699 43 only only RB 40436 3699 44 an an DT 40436 3699 45 interpreter interpreter NN 40436 3699 46 of of IN 40436 3699 47 the the DT 40436 3699 48 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3699 49 , , , 40436 3699 50 possessed possess VBN 40436 3699 51 by by IN 40436 3699 52 one one CD 40436 3699 53 or or CC 40436 3699 54 other other JJ 40436 3699 55 of of IN 40436 3699 56 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3699 57 , , , 40436 3699 58 as as IN 40436 3699 59 the the DT 40436 3699 60 case case NN 40436 3699 61 may may MD 40436 3699 62 be be VB 40436 3699 63 . . . 40436 3700 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3700 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3700 3 13 13 CD 40436 3700 4 : : : 40436 3700 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3700 6 , , , 40436 3700 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3700 8 , , , 40436 3700 9 533 533 CD 40436 3700 10 E--534 E--534 NNS 40436 3700 11 A. a. NN 40436 3701 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3701 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3701 3 : : : 40436 3701 4 pa pa NNP 40436 3701 5 / / SYM 40436 3701 6 ntes ntes NNP 40436 3701 7 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3701 8 oi(/ oi(/ CD 40436 3701 9 te te NNP 40436 3701 10 tô tô NNP 40436 3701 11 = = SYM 40436 3701 12 n n CC 40436 3701 13 e)pô e)pô NNP 40436 3701 14 = = SYM 40436 3701 15 n n NNP 40436 3701 16 poiêtai\ poiêtai\ NNP 40436 3701 17 oi oi NNP 40436 3701 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3701 19 a)gathoi\ a)gathoi\ NNP 40436 3701 20 ou)k ou)k JJ 40436 3701 21 e)k e)k NNP 40436 3701 22 te te NNP 40436 3701 23 / / SYM 40436 3701 24 chnês chnês NNP 40436 3701 25 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 3701 26 ' ' '' 40436 3701 27 e)/ntheoi e)/ntheoi NNP 40436 3701 28 o)/ntes o)/nte VBZ 40436 3701 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3701 30 katecho katecho NNP 40436 3701 31 / / SYM 40436 3701 32 menoi menoi NNP 40436 3701 33 pa pa NNP 40436 3701 34 / / SYM 40436 3701 35 nta nta NNP 40436 3701 36 tau tau NNP 40436 3701 37 = = SYM 40436 3701 38 ta ta NNP 40436 3701 39 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 3701 40 kala\ kala\ NNP 40436 3701 41 le le NNP 40436 3701 42 / / SYM 40436 3701 43 gousi gousi NNP 40436 3701 44 poiê poiê NNP 40436 3701 45 / / SYM 40436 3701 46 mata mata NNP 40436 3701 47 , , , 40436 3701 48 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3701 49 oi oi NNP 40436 3701 50 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3701 51 melopoioi\ melopoioi\ NNP 40436 3701 52 oi oi NNP 40436 3701 53 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3701 54 a)gathoi\ a)gathoi\ NNP 40436 3701 55 ô(sau ô(sau NNP 40436 3701 56 / / SYM 40436 3701 57 tôs tôs NN 40436 3701 58 ; ; : 40436 3701 59 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 3701 60 oi oi FW 40436 3701 61 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3701 62 korubantintiô korubantintiô NNP 40436 3701 63 = = SYM 40436 3701 64 tes tes NNP 40436 3701 65 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 3701 66 e)/mphrones e)/mphrones NNP 40436 3701 67 o)/ntes o)/nte VBZ 40436 3701 68 o)rchou o)rchou NNP 40436 3701 69 = = SYM 40436 3701 70 ntai ntai NNP 40436 3701 71 , , , 40436 3701 72 ou(/tô ou(/tô IN 40436 3701 73 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3701 74 oi oi NNP 40436 3701 75 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3701 76 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3701 77 melopoioi\ melopoioi\ NNP 40436 3701 78 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 3701 79 e)/mphrones e)/mphrones NNP 40436 3701 80 o)/ntes o)/nte NNS 40436 3701 81 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 3701 82 kala\ kala\ NNP 40436 3701 83 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3701 84 / / SYM 40436 3701 85 lê lê NNP 40436 3701 86 tau tau NNP 40436 3701 87 = = SYM 40436 3701 88 ta ta NNP 40436 3701 89 poiou poiou NNP 40436 3701 90 = = SYM 40436 3701 91 sin sin NN 40436 3701 92 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3701 93 , , , 40436 3701 94 & & CC 40436 3701 95 c. c. NNP 40436 3701 96 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3701 97 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3701 98 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3701 99 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3701 100 14 14 CD 40436 3701 101 : : : 40436 3701 102 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3701 103 , , , 40436 3701 104 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3701 105 , , , 40436 3701 106 534 534 CD 40436 3701 107 B. b. NN 40436 3702 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3702 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3702 3 : : : 40436 3702 4 kou kou NNP 40436 3702 5 = = SYM 40436 3702 6 phon phon NNP 40436 3702 7 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3702 8 chrê chrê NN 40436 3702 9 = = SYM 40436 3702 10 ma ma NNP 40436 3702 11 poiêtê poiêtê NNP 40436 3702 12 / / SYM 40436 3702 13 s s NNP 40436 3702 14 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 3702 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3702 16 ptêno\n ptêno\n -LRB- 40436 3702 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3702 18 i(ero i(ero NNP 40436 3702 19 / / SYM 40436 3702 20 n n NNP 40436 3702 21 , , , 40436 3702 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3702 23 ou ou NNP 40436 3702 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3702 25 pro pro JJ 40436 3702 26 / / SYM 40436 3702 27 teron teron NNP 40436 3702 28 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 3702 29 / / SYM 40436 3702 30 s s NNP 40436 3702 31 te te NNP 40436 3702 32 poiei poiei NNP 40436 3702 33 = = SYM 40436 3702 34 n n NNP 40436 3702 35 pri\n pri\n NNPS 40436 3702 36 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 3702 37 e)/ntheo e)/ntheo NNP 40436 3702 38 / / SYM 40436 3702 39 s s NNP 40436 3702 40 te te NNP 40436 3702 41 ge ge NNP 40436 3702 42 / / SYM 40436 3702 43 nêtai nêtai NNP 40436 3702 44 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3702 45 e)/kphrôn e)/kphrôn NNP 40436 3702 46 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3702 47 o o NNP 40436 3702 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3702 49 nou nou NNP 40436 3702 50 = = SYM 40436 3702 51 s s FW 40436 3702 52 mêke mêke FW 40436 3702 53 / / NFP 40436 3702 54 ti ti NNP 40436 3702 55 e)n e)n NNP 40436 3702 56 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 3702 57 e)nê=| e)nê=| NNS 40436 3702 58 ; ; : 40436 3702 59 e(/ôs e(/ôs NNP 40436 3702 60 d d NN 40436 3702 61 ' ' POS 40436 3702 62 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 3702 63 touti\ touti\ NN 40436 3702 64 e)/chê| e)/chê| NNP 40436 3702 65 to\ to\ NNP 40436 3702 66 ktê ktê NNP 40436 3702 67 = = SYM 40436 3702 68 ma ma NNP 40436 3702 69 , , , 40436 3702 70 a)du a)du NNP 40436 3702 71 / / SYM 40436 3702 72 natos natos NNP 40436 3702 73 pa pa NNP 40436 3702 74 = = SYM 40436 3702 75 s s NNP 40436 3702 76 poiei poiei NN 40436 3702 77 = = SYM 40436 3702 78 n n NNP 40436 3702 79 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 3702 80 a)/nthrôpos a)/nthrôpos NNP 40436 3702 81 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3702 82 chrêsmô|dei chrêsmô|dei NNP 40436 3702 83 = = SYM 40436 3702 84 n n NN 40436 3702 85 . . . 40436 3702 86 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3702 87 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3703 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3703 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3703 3 15 15 CD 40436 3703 4 : : : 40436 3703 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3703 6 . . . 40436 3704 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3704 2 , , , 40436 3704 3 534 534 CD 40436 3704 4 C C NNP 40436 3704 5 - - HYPH 40436 3704 6 D. D. NNP 40436 3704 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3704 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3704 9 : : : 40436 3704 10 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 3704 11 tau tau NNP 40436 3704 12 = = SYM 40436 3704 13 ta ta NNP 40436 3704 14 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3704 15 o o NNP 40436 3704 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3704 17 theo\s theo\s NNP 40436 3704 18 e)xairou e)xairou NNP 40436 3704 19 / / SYM 40436 3704 20 menos menos NNP 40436 3704 21 tou tou NNP 40436 3704 22 / / SYM 40436 3704 23 tôn tôn NNP 40436 3704 24 to\n to\n NNP 40436 3704 25 nou nou NNP 40436 3704 26 = = SYM 40436 3704 27 n n NNP 40436 3704 28 tou tou NNP 40436 3704 29 / / SYM 40436 3704 30 tois tois NNP 40436 3704 31 chrê chrê NNP 40436 3704 32 = = SYM 40436 3704 33 tai tai NNP 40436 3704 34 u(pêre u(pêre NNP 40436 3704 35 / / SYM 40436 3704 36 tais tais NNP 40436 3704 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3704 38 toi toi NNP 40436 3704 39 = = SYM 40436 3704 40 s s NNP 40436 3704 41 chrêsmô|doi chrêsmô|doi NNP 40436 3704 42 = = SYM 40436 3704 43 s s NNP 40436 3704 44 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3704 45 toi toi NNP 40436 3704 46 = = SYM 40436 3704 47 s s NNP 40436 3704 48 ma ma NNP 40436 3704 49 / / SYM 40436 3704 50 ntesi ntesi NNP 40436 3704 51 toi toi NNP 40436 3704 52 = = SYM 40436 3704 53 s s NNP 40436 3704 54 thei thei NNP 40436 3704 55 / / SYM 40436 3704 56 ois ois NNP 40436 3704 57 , , , 40436 3704 58 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 3704 59 ê(mei ê(mei NNP 40436 3704 60 = = SYM 40436 3704 61 s s NNP 40436 3704 62 oi oi FW 40436 3704 63 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3704 64 a)kou a)kou NNP 40436 3704 65 / / SYM 40436 3704 66 ontes onte NNS 40436 3704 67 ei)dô ei)dô NNP 40436 3704 68 = = SYM 40436 3704 69 men man NNS 40436 3704 70 , , , 40436 3704 71 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 3704 72 ou)ch ou)ch NNP 40436 3704 73 ou(=toi/ ou(=toi/ -RRB- 40436 3704 74 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 3704 75 oi oi PRP 40436 3704 76 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3704 77 tau tau NNP 40436 3704 78 = = SYM 40436 3704 79 ta ta NNP 40436 3704 80 le le NNP 40436 3704 81 / / SYM 40436 3704 82 gontes gonte NNS 40436 3704 83 ou(/tô ou(/tô IN 40436 3704 84 pollou= pollou= NN 40436 3704 85 a)/xia a)/xia IN 40436 3704 86 , , , 40436 3704 87 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 3704 88 ' ' `` 40436 3704 89 o o NN 40436 3704 90 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3704 91 theo\s theo\s NNP 40436 3704 92 au)to au)to NNP 40436 3704 93 / / SYM 40436 3704 94 s s NNP 40436 3704 95 e)stin e)stin NNP 40436 3704 96 o o NNP 40436 3704 97 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3704 98 le le NNP 40436 3704 99 / / SYM 40436 3704 100 gôn gôn NNP 40436 3704 101 , , , 40436 3704 102 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 3704 103 tou tou NNP 40436 3704 104 / / SYM 40436 3704 105 tôn tôn NNP 40436 3704 106 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3704 107 phthe phthe NNP 40436 3704 108 / / SYM 40436 3704 109 ggetai ggetai NNP 40436 3704 110 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 3704 111 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 3704 112 = = SYM 40436 3704 113 s s NN 40436 3704 114 . . . 40436 3704 115 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3704 116 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3705 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3705 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3705 3 16 16 CD 40436 3705 4 : : : 40436 3705 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3705 6 , , , 40436 3705 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3705 8 . . . 40436 3706 1 534 534 CD 40436 3706 2 E. E. NNP 40436 3706 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3706 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3706 5 : : : 40436 3706 6 tau tau NNP 40436 3706 7 = = SYM 40436 3706 8 ta ta NNP 40436 3706 9 e)ndeiknu e)ndeiknu NNP 40436 3706 10 / / SYM 40436 3706 11 menos menos NNPS 40436 3706 12 o o FW 40436 3706 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3706 14 theo\s theo\s NNP 40436 3706 15 e)xepi e)xepi NNS 40436 3706 16 / / SYM 40436 3706 17 têdes têde NNS 40436 3706 18 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 3706 19 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3706 20 phaulota phaulota NNP 40436 3706 21 / / SYM 40436 3706 22 tou tou NNP 40436 3706 23 poiêtou= poiêtou= NNP 40436 3706 24 to\ to\ NNP 40436 3706 25 ka ka NNP 40436 3706 26 / / SYM 40436 3706 27 lliston lliston NNP 40436 3706 28 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3706 29 / / SYM 40436 3706 30 los los NNP 40436 3706 31 ê)=|sen ê)=|sen NNP 40436 3706 32 . . . 40436 3706 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3706 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3707 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3707 2 Side side NN 40436 3707 3 - - HYPH 40436 3707 4 note note NN 40436 3707 5 : : : 40436 3707 6 Analogy analogy NN 40436 3707 7 of of IN 40436 3707 8 the the DT 40436 3707 9 Magnet Magnet NNP 40436 3707 10 , , , 40436 3707 11 which which WDT 40436 3707 12 holds hold VBZ 40436 3707 13 up up RP 40436 3707 14 by by IN 40436 3707 15 attraction attraction NN 40436 3707 16 successive successive JJ 40436 3707 17 stages stage NNS 40436 3707 18 of of IN 40436 3707 19 iron iron NN 40436 3707 20 rings ring NNS 40436 3707 21 . . . 40436 3708 1 The the DT 40436 3708 2 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3708 3 first first RB 40436 3708 4 inspire inspire VBP 40436 3708 5 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3708 6 , , , 40436 3708 7 then then RB 40436 3708 8 act act VB 40436 3708 9 through through IN 40436 3708 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3708 11 and and CC 40436 3708 12 through through IN 40436 3708 13 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3708 14 upon upon IN 40436 3708 15 the the DT 40436 3708 16 auditors auditor NNS 40436 3708 17 . . . 40436 3708 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3709 1 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3709 2 is be VBZ 40436 3709 3 thus thus RB 40436 3709 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3709 5 continues continue VBZ 40436 3709 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3709 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3709 8 not not RB 40436 3709 9 a a DT 40436 3709 10 man man NN 40436 3709 11 of of IN 40436 3709 12 art art NN 40436 3709 13 or or CC 40436 3709 14 reason reason NN 40436 3709 15 , , , 40436 3709 16 but but CC 40436 3709 17 the the DT 40436 3709 18 interpreter interpreter NN 40436 3709 19 of of IN 40436 3709 20 the the DT 40436 3709 21 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3709 22 ; ; , 40436 3709 23 deprived deprive VBN 40436 3709 24 of of IN 40436 3709 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3709 26 reason reason NN 40436 3709 27 , , , 40436 3709 28 but but CC 40436 3709 29 possessed possess VBD 40436 3709 30 , , , 40436 3709 31 inspired inspire VBN 40436 3709 32 , , , 40436 3709 33 by by IN 40436 3709 34 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3709 35 . . . 40436 3710 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3710 2 , , , 40436 3710 3 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3710 4 , , , 40436 3710 5 are be VBP 40436 3710 6 the the DT 40436 3710 7 interpreter interpreter NN 40436 3710 8 of of IN 40436 3710 9 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3710 10 : : : 40436 3710 11 and and CC 40436 3710 12 the the DT 40436 3710 13 divine divine JJ 40436 3710 14 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3710 15 , , , 40436 3710 16 carrying carry VBG 40436 3710 17 away away RB 40436 3710 18 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3710 19 reason reason NN 40436 3710 20 , , , 40436 3710 21 is be VBZ 40436 3710 22 exercised exercise VBN 40436 3710 23 over over IN 40436 3710 24 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3710 25 through through IN 40436 3710 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3710 27 . . . 40436 3711 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3711 2 is be VBZ 40436 3711 3 in in IN 40436 3711 4 this this DT 40436 3711 5 way way NN 40436 3711 6 that that WDT 40436 3711 7 the the DT 40436 3711 8 influence influence NN 40436 3711 9 of of IN 40436 3711 10 the the DT 40436 3711 11 Magnet Magnet NNP 40436 3711 12 is be VBZ 40436 3711 13 shown show VBN 40436 3711 14 , , , 40436 3711 15 attracting attract VBG 40436 3711 16 and and CC 40436 3711 17 holding hold VBG 40436 3711 18 up up RP 40436 3711 19 successive successive JJ 40436 3711 20 stages stage NNS 40436 3711 21 of of IN 40436 3711 22 iron iron NN 40436 3711 23 rings ring NNS 40436 3711 24 . . . 40436 3712 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3712 2 17 17 CD 40436 3712 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3712 4 The the DT 40436 3712 5 first first JJ 40436 3712 6 ring ring NN 40436 3712 7 is be VBZ 40436 3712 8 in in IN 40436 3712 9 contact contact NN 40436 3712 10 with with IN 40436 3712 11 the the DT 40436 3712 12 Magnet Magnet NNP 40436 3712 13 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 3712 14 : : : 40436 3712 15 the the DT 40436 3712 16 second second JJ 40436 3712 17 is be VBZ 40436 3712 18 suspended suspend VBN 40436 3712 19 to to IN 40436 3712 20 the the DT 40436 3712 21 first first JJ 40436 3712 22 , , , 40436 3712 23 the the DT 40436 3712 24 third third JJ 40436 3712 25 to to IN 40436 3712 26 the the DT 40436 3712 27 second second JJ 40436 3712 28 , , , 40436 3712 29 and and CC 40436 3712 30 so so RB 40436 3712 31 on on RB 40436 3712 32 . . . 40436 3713 1 The the DT 40436 3713 2 attractive attractive JJ 40436 3713 3 influence influence NN 40436 3713 4 of of IN 40436 3713 5 the the DT 40436 3713 6 Magnet Magnet NNP 40436 3713 7 is be VBZ 40436 3713 8 thus thus RB 40436 3713 9 transmitted transmit VBN 40436 3713 10 through through IN 40436 3713 11 a a DT 40436 3713 12 succession succession NN 40436 3713 13 of of IN 40436 3713 14 different different JJ 40436 3713 15 rings ring NNS 40436 3713 16 , , , 40436 3713 17 so so IN 40436 3713 18 as as IN 40436 3713 19 to to TO 40436 3713 20 keep keep VB 40436 3713 21 suspended suspend VBN 40436 3713 22 several several JJ 40436 3713 23 which which WDT 40436 3713 24 are be VBP 40436 3713 25 a a DT 40436 3713 26 good good JJ 40436 3713 27 way way NN 40436 3713 28 removed remove VBN 40436 3713 29 from from IN 40436 3713 30 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 3713 31 . . . 40436 3714 1 So so RB 40436 3714 2 the the DT 40436 3714 3 influence influence NN 40436 3714 4 of of IN 40436 3714 5 the the DT 40436 3714 6 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3714 7 is be VBZ 40436 3714 8 exerted exert VBN 40436 3714 9 directly directly RB 40436 3714 10 and and CC 40436 3714 11 immediately immediately RB 40436 3714 12 upon upon IN 40436 3714 13 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3714 14 : : : 40436 3714 15 through through IN 40436 3714 16 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3714 17 , , , 40436 3714 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3714 19 passes pass VBZ 40436 3714 20 by by IN 40436 3714 21 a a DT 40436 3714 22 second second JJ 40436 3714 23 stage stage NN 40436 3714 24 to to IN 40436 3714 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3714 26 : : : 40436 3714 27 through through IN 40436 3714 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3714 29 and and CC 40436 3714 30 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3714 31 , , , 40436 3714 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3714 33 passes pass VBZ 40436 3714 34 by by IN 40436 3714 35 a a DT 40436 3714 36 third third JJ 40436 3714 37 stage stage NN 40436 3714 38 to to IN 40436 3714 39 those those DT 40436 3714 40 auditors auditor NNS 40436 3714 41 whom whom WP 40436 3714 42 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3714 43 so so RB 40436 3714 44 powerfully powerfully RB 40436 3714 45 affect affect VBP 40436 3714 46 and and CC 40436 3714 47 delight delight NN 40436 3714 48 , , , 40436 3714 49 becoming become VBG 40436 3714 50 however however RB 40436 3714 51 comparatively comparatively RB 40436 3714 52 enfeebled enfeeble VBN 40436 3714 53 at at IN 40436 3714 54 each each DT 40436 3714 55 stage stage NN 40436 3714 56 of of IN 40436 3714 57 transition transition NN 40436 3714 58 . . . 40436 3715 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3715 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3715 3 17 17 CD 40436 3715 4 : : : 40436 3715 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3715 6 , , , 40436 3715 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3715 8 , , , 40436 3715 9 533 533 CD 40436 3715 10 D D NNP 40436 3715 11 - - HYPH 40436 3715 12 E. e. NN 40436 3715 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3715 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3715 15 Side side NN 40436 3715 16 - - HYPH 40436 3715 17 note note NN 40436 3715 18 : : : 40436 3715 19 This this DT 40436 3715 20 comparison comparison NN 40436 3715 21 forms form VBZ 40436 3715 22 the the DT 40436 3715 23 central central JJ 40436 3715 24 point point NN 40436 3715 25 of of IN 40436 3715 26 the the DT 40436 3715 27 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3715 28 . . . 40436 3716 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3716 2 is be VBZ 40436 3716 3 an an DT 40436 3716 4 expansion expansion NN 40436 3716 5 of of IN 40436 3716 6 a a DT 40436 3716 7 judgment judgment NN 40436 3716 8 delivered deliver VBN 40436 3716 9 by by IN 40436 3716 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3716 11 in in IN 40436 3716 12 the the DT 40436 3716 13 Apology Apology NNP 40436 3716 14 . . . 40436 3716 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3717 1 The the DT 40436 3717 2 passage passage NN 40436 3717 3 and and CC 40436 3717 4 comparison comparison NN 40436 3717 5 here here RB 40436 3717 6 given give VBN 40436 3717 7 by by IN 40436 3717 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3717 9 -- -- : 40436 3717 10 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 3717 11 as as IN 40436 3717 12 an an DT 40436 3717 13 early early JJ 40436 3717 14 description description NN 40436 3717 15 of of IN 40436 3717 16 the the DT 40436 3717 17 working working NN 40436 3717 18 of of IN 40436 3717 19 the the DT 40436 3717 20 Magnet Magnet NNP 40436 3717 21 -- -- : 40436 3717 22 forms form VBZ 40436 3717 23 the the DT 40436 3717 24 central central JJ 40436 3717 25 point point NN 40436 3717 26 or or CC 40436 3717 27 kernel kernel NN 40436 3717 28 of of IN 40436 3717 29 the the DT 40436 3717 30 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3717 31 called call VBN 40436 3717 32 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3717 33 . . . 40436 3718 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3718 2 is be VBZ 40436 3718 3 an an DT 40436 3718 4 expansion expansion NN 40436 3718 5 of of IN 40436 3718 6 a a DT 40436 3718 7 judgment judgment NN 40436 3718 8 delivered deliver VBN 40436 3718 9 by by IN 40436 3718 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3718 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3718 12 in in IN 40436 3718 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3718 14 Apology apology NN 40436 3718 15 to to IN 40436 3718 16 the the DT 40436 3718 17 Dikasts Dikasts NNPS 40436 3718 18 , , , 40436 3718 19 and and CC 40436 3718 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3718 21 is be VBZ 40436 3718 22 repeated repeat VBN 40436 3718 23 in in IN 40436 3718 24 more more JJR 40436 3718 25 than than IN 40436 3718 26 one one CD 40436 3718 27 place place NN 40436 3718 28 by by IN 40436 3718 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3718 30 . . . 40436 3719 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3719 2 18 18 CD 40436 3719 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3719 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3719 5 declares declare VBZ 40436 3719 6 in in IN 40436 3719 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3719 8 Apology Apology NNP 40436 3719 9 that that IN 40436 3719 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3719 11 had have VBD 40436 3719 12 applied apply VBN 40436 3719 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3719 14 testing testing NN 40436 3719 15 cross cross NN 40436 3719 16 - - NN 40436 3719 17 examination examination NN 40436 3719 18 to to IN 40436 3719 19 several several JJ 40436 3719 20 excellent excellent JJ 40436 3719 21 poets poet NNS 40436 3719 22 ; ; : 40436 3719 23 and and CC 40436 3719 24 that that IN 40436 3719 25 finding find VBG 40436 3719 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3719 27 unable unable JJ 40436 3719 28 to to TO 40436 3719 29 give give VB 40436 3719 30 any any DT 40436 3719 31 rational rational JJ 40436 3719 32 account account NN 40436 3719 33 of of IN 40436 3719 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3719 35 own own JJ 40436 3719 36 compositions composition NNS 40436 3719 37 , , , 40436 3719 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3719 39 concluded conclude VBD 40436 3719 40 that that IN 40436 3719 41 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3719 42 composed compose VBD 40436 3719 43 without without IN 40436 3719 44 any any DT 40436 3719 45 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 3719 46 of of IN 40436 3719 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3719 48 own own JJ 40436 3719 49 , , , 40436 3719 50 under under IN 40436 3719 51 the the DT 40436 3719 52 same same JJ 40436 3719 53 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3719 54 as as IN 40436 3719 55 prophets prophet NNS 40436 3719 56 and and CC 40436 3719 57 declarers declarer NNS 40436 3719 58 of of IN 40436 3719 59 oracles oracle NNS 40436 3719 60 . . . 40436 3720 1 In in IN 40436 3720 2 the the DT 40436 3720 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3720 4 before before IN 40436 3720 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3720 6 , , , 40436 3720 7 this this DT 40436 3720 8 thought thought NN 40436 3720 9 is be VBZ 40436 3720 10 strikingly strikingly RB 40436 3720 11 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 3720 12 and and CC 40436 3720 13 amplified amplify VBN 40436 3720 14 . . . 40436 3721 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3721 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3721 3 18 18 CD 40436 3721 4 : : : 40436 3721 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3721 6 , , , 40436 3721 7 Apol Apol NNP 40436 3721 8 . . . 40436 3722 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 3722 2 . . . 40436 3723 1 p. p. NN 40436 3723 2 22 22 CD 40436 3723 3 D d NN 40436 3723 4 ; ; : 40436 3723 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3723 6 , , , 40436 3723 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 3723 8 , , , 40436 3723 9 p. p. NN 40436 3723 10 99 99 CD 40436 3723 11 D. D. NNP 40436 3723 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3723 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3723 14 Side side NN 40436 3723 15 - - HYPH 40436 3723 16 note note NN 40436 3723 17 : : : 40436 3723 18 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3723 19 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 3723 20 : : : 40436 3723 21 systematic systematic JJ 40436 3723 22 procedure procedure NN 40436 3723 23 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 3723 24 from from IN 40436 3723 25 unsystematic unsystematic JJ 40436 3723 26 : : : 40436 3723 27 which which WDT 40436 3723 28 latter latter NNP 40436 3723 29 was be VBD 40436 3723 30 either either CC 40436 3723 31 blind blind JJ 40436 3723 32 routine routine JJ 40436 3723 33 , , , 40436 3723 34 or or CC 40436 3723 35 madness madness NN 40436 3723 36 inspired inspire VBN 40436 3723 37 by by IN 40436 3723 38 the the DT 40436 3723 39 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3723 40 . . . 40436 3724 1 Varieties variety NNS 40436 3724 2 of of IN 40436 3724 3 madness madness NN 40436 3724 4 , , , 40436 3724 5 good good JJ 40436 3724 6 and and CC 40436 3724 7 bad bad JJ 40436 3724 8 . . . 40436 3724 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3725 1 The the DT 40436 3725 2 contrast contrast NN 40436 3725 3 between between IN 40436 3725 4 systematic systematic JJ 40436 3725 5 , , , 40436 3725 6 professional professional JJ 40436 3725 7 , , , 40436 3725 8 procedure procedure NN 40436 3725 9 , , , 40436 3725 10 deliberately deliberately RB 40436 3725 11 taught teach VBN 40436 3725 12 and and CC 40436 3725 13 consciously consciously RB 40436 3725 14 acquired acquire VBN 40436 3725 15 , , , 40436 3725 16 capable capable JJ 40436 3725 17 of of IN 40436 3725 18 being be VBG 40436 3725 19 defended defend VBN 40436 3725 20 at at IN 40436 3725 21 every every DT 40436 3725 22 step step NN 40436 3725 23 by by IN 40436 3725 24 appeal appeal NN 40436 3725 25 to to IN 40436 3725 26 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 3725 27 rules rule NNS 40436 3725 28 founded found VBN 40436 3725 29 upon upon IN 40436 3725 30 scientific scientific JJ 40436 3725 31 theory theory NN 40436 3725 32 , , , 40436 3725 33 and and CC 40436 3725 34 enabling enable VBG 40436 3725 35 the the DT 40436 3725 36 person person NN 40436 3725 37 so so RB 40436 3725 38 qualified qualified JJ 40436 3725 39 to to TO 40436 3725 40 impart impart VB 40436 3725 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3725 42 qualification qualification NN 40436 3725 43 to to IN 40436 3725 44 others other NNS 40436 3725 45 -- -- : 40436 3725 46 and and CC 40436 3725 47 a a DT 40436 3725 48 different different JJ 40436 3725 49 procedure procedure NN 40436 3725 50 purely purely RB 40436 3725 51 impulsive impulsive JJ 40436 3725 52 and and CC 40436 3725 53 unthinking unthinking JJ 40436 3725 54 , , , 40436 3725 55 whereby whereby WRB 40436 3725 56 the the DT 40436 3725 57 agent agent NN 40436 3725 58 , , , 40436 3725 59 having have VBG 40436 3725 60 in in IN 40436 3725 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3725 62 mind mind NN 40436 3725 63 a a DT 40436 3725 64 conception conception NN 40436 3725 65 of of IN 40436 3725 66 the the DT 40436 3725 67 end end NN 40436 3725 68 aimed aim VBN 40436 3725 69 at at IN 40436 3725 70 , , , 40436 3725 71 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 3725 72 from from IN 40436 3725 73 one one CD 40436 3725 74 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 3725 75 step step NN 40436 3725 76 to to IN 40436 3725 77 another another DT 40436 3725 78 , , , 40436 3725 79 without without IN 40436 3725 80 knowing know VBG 40436 3725 81 why why WRB 40436 3725 82 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3725 83 does do VBZ 40436 3725 84 so so RB 40436 3725 85 or or CC 40436 3725 86 how how WRB 40436 3725 87 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3725 88 has have VBZ 40436 3725 89 come come VBN 40436 3725 90 to to TO 40436 3725 91 do do VB 40436 3725 92 so so RB 40436 3725 93 , , , 40436 3725 94 and and CC 40436 3725 95 without without IN 40436 3725 96 being be VBG 40436 3725 97 able able JJ 40436 3725 98 to to TO 40436 3725 99 explain explain VB 40436 3725 100 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3725 101 practice practice NN 40436 3725 102 if if IN 40436 3725 103 questioned question VBN 40436 3725 104 or or CC 40436 3725 105 to to TO 40436 3725 106 impart impart VB 40436 3725 107 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3725 108 to to IN 40436 3725 109 others other NNS 40436 3725 110 -- -- : 40436 3725 111 this this DT 40436 3725 112 contrast contrast NN 40436 3725 113 is be VBZ 40436 3725 114 a a DT 40436 3725 115 favourite favourite JJ 40436 3725 116 one one NN 40436 3725 117 with with IN 40436 3725 118 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3725 119 . . . 40436 3726 1 The the DT 40436 3726 2 last last RB 40436 3726 3 - - HYPH 40436 3726 4 mentioned mention VBN 40436 3726 5 procedure procedure NN 40436 3726 6 -- -- : 40436 3726 7 the the DT 40436 3726 8 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 40436 3726 9 or or CC 40436 3726 10 irrational irrational JJ 40436 3726 11 -- -- : 40436 3726 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3726 13 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 3726 14 under under IN 40436 3726 15 different different JJ 40436 3726 16 aspects aspect NNS 40436 3726 17 : : : 40436 3726 18 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 3726 19 as as IN 40436 3726 20 a a DT 40436 3726 21 blind blind JJ 40436 3726 22 routine routine NN 40436 3726 23 or or CC 40436 3726 24 insensibly insensibly RB 40436 3726 25 acquired acquire VBN 40436 3726 26 habit,[19 habit,[19 NFP 40436 3726 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3726 28 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 3726 29 as as IN 40436 3726 30 a a DT 40436 3726 31 stimulus stimulus NN 40436 3726 32 applied apply VBN 40436 3726 33 from from IN 40436 3726 34 without without IN 40436 3726 35 by by IN 40436 3726 36 some some DT 40436 3726 37 God God NNP 40436 3726 38 , , , 40436 3726 39 superseding supersede VBG 40436 3726 40 the the DT 40436 3726 41 reason reason NN 40436 3726 42 of of IN 40436 3726 43 the the DT 40436 3726 44 individual individual NN 40436 3726 45 . . . 40436 3727 1 Such such PDT 40436 3727 2 a a DT 40436 3727 3 condition condition NN 40436 3727 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3727 5 calls call VBZ 40436 3727 6 _ _ NNP 40436 3727 7 madness madness NN 40436 3727 8 _ _ NNP 40436 3727 9 , , , 40436 3727 10 and and CC 40436 3727 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3727 12 considers consider VBZ 40436 3727 13 those those DT 40436 3727 14 under under IN 40436 3727 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3727 16 as as IN 40436 3727 17 persons person NNS 40436 3727 18 out out IN 40436 3727 19 of of IN 40436 3727 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3727 21 senses sense NNS 40436 3727 22 . . . 40436 3728 1 But but CC 40436 3728 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3728 3 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 3728 4 different different JJ 40436 3728 5 varieties variety NNS 40436 3728 6 of of IN 40436 3728 7 madness madness NN 40436 3728 8 , , , 40436 3728 9 according accord VBG 40436 3728 10 to to IN 40436 3728 11 the the DT 40436 3728 12 God God NNP 40436 3728 13 from from IN 40436 3728 14 whom whom WP 40436 3728 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3728 16 came come VBD 40436 3728 17 : : : 40436 3728 18 the the DT 40436 3728 19 bad bad JJ 40436 3728 20 madness madness NN 40436 3728 21 was be VBD 40436 3728 22 a a DT 40436 3728 23 disastrous disastrous JJ 40436 3728 24 visitation visitation NN 40436 3728 25 and and CC 40436 3728 26 distemper distemper NN 40436 3728 27 -- -- : 40436 3728 28 the the DT 40436 3728 29 good good JJ 40436 3728 30 madness madness NN 40436 3728 31 was be VBD 40436 3728 32 a a DT 40436 3728 33 privilege privilege NN 40436 3728 34 and and CC 40436 3728 35 blessing blessing NN 40436 3728 36 , , , 40436 3728 37 an an DT 40436 3728 38 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3728 39 superior superior JJ 40436 3728 40 to to IN 40436 3728 41 human human JJ 40436 3728 42 reason reason NN 40436 3728 43 . . . 40436 3729 1 Among among IN 40436 3729 2 these these DT 40436 3729 3 privileged privileged JJ 40436 3729 4 madmen madman NNS 40436 3729 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3729 6 reckoned reckon VBD 40436 3729 7 prophets prophet NNS 40436 3729 8 and and CC 40436 3729 9 poets poet NNS 40436 3729 10 ; ; : 40436 3729 11 another another DT 40436 3729 12 variety variety NN 40436 3729 13 under under IN 40436 3729 14 the the DT 40436 3729 15 same same JJ 40436 3729 16 genus genus NN 40436 3729 17 , , , 40436 3729 18 is be VBZ 40436 3729 19 , , , 40436 3729 20 that that IN 40436 3729 21 mental mental JJ 40436 3729 22 love love NN 40436 3729 23 , , , 40436 3729 24 between between IN 40436 3729 25 a a DT 40436 3729 26 well well RB 40436 3729 27 - - HYPH 40436 3729 28 trained train VBN 40436 3729 29 adult adult NN 40436 3729 30 , , , 40436 3729 31 and and CC 40436 3729 32 a a DT 40436 3729 33 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 3729 34 , , , 40436 3729 35 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 3729 36 , , , 40436 3729 37 youth youth NN 40436 3729 38 , , , 40436 3729 39 which which WDT 40436 3729 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3729 41 regards regard VBZ 40436 3729 42 as as IN 40436 3729 43 the the DT 40436 3729 44 most most RBS 40436 3729 45 exalted exalted JJ 40436 3729 46 of of IN 40436 3729 47 all all DT 40436 3729 48 human human JJ 40436 3729 49 emotions emotion NNS 40436 3729 50 . . . 40436 3730 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3730 2 20 20 CD 40436 3730 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3730 4 In in IN 40436 3730 5 the the DT 40436 3730 6 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3730 7 , , , 40436 3730 8 this this DT 40436 3730 9 idea idea NN 40436 3730 10 of of IN 40436 3730 11 a a DT 40436 3730 12 privileged privileged JJ 40436 3730 13 madness madness NN 40436 3730 14 -- -- : 40436 3730 15 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3730 16 from from IN 40436 3730 17 the the DT 40436 3730 18 Gods Gods NNP 40436 3730 19 superseding superseding NN 40436 3730 20 reason reason NN 40436 3730 21 -- -- : 40436 3730 22 is be VBZ 40436 3730 23 applied apply VBN 40436 3730 24 not not RB 40436 3730 25 only only RB 40436 3730 26 to to IN 40436 3730 27 the the DT 40436 3730 28 poet poet NN 40436 3730 29 , , , 40436 3730 30 but but CC 40436 3730 31 also also RB 40436 3730 32 to to IN 40436 3730 33 the the DT 40436 3730 34 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3730 35 who who WP 40436 3730 36 recites recite VBZ 40436 3730 37 the the DT 40436 3730 38 poem poem NN 40436 3730 39 , , , 40436 3730 40 and and CC 40436 3730 41 even even RB 40436 3730 42 to to IN 40436 3730 43 the the DT 40436 3730 44 auditors auditor NNS 40436 3730 45 whom whom WP 40436 3730 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3730 47 addresses address VBZ 40436 3730 48 . . . 40436 3731 1 The the DT 40436 3731 2 poet poet NN 40436 3731 3 receives receive VBZ 40436 3731 4 the the DT 40436 3731 5 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3731 6 directly directly RB 40436 3731 7 from from IN 40436 3731 8 the the DT 40436 3731 9 Gods god NNS 40436 3731 10 : : : 40436 3731 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3731 12 inoculates inoculate VBZ 40436 3731 13 the the DT 40436 3731 14 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3731 15 with with IN 40436 3731 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3731 17 , , , 40436 3731 18 who who WP 40436 3731 19 again again RB 40436 3731 20 inoculates inoculate VBZ 40436 3731 21 the the DT 40436 3731 22 auditors auditor NNS 40436 3731 23 -- -- : 40436 3731 24 the the DT 40436 3731 25 fervour fervour NN 40436 3731 26 is be VBZ 40436 3731 27 , , , 40436 3731 28 at at IN 40436 3731 29 each each DT 40436 3731 30 successive successive JJ 40436 3731 31 communication communication NN 40436 3731 32 , , , 40436 3731 33 diminished diminish VBN 40436 3731 34 . . . 40436 3732 1 The the DT 40436 3732 2 auditor auditor NN 40436 3732 3 represents represent VBZ 40436 3732 4 the the DT 40436 3732 5 last last JJ 40436 3732 6 of of IN 40436 3732 7 the the DT 40436 3732 8 rings ring NNS 40436 3732 9 ; ; , 40436 3732 10 held hold VBN 40436 3732 11 in in IN 40436 3732 12 suspension suspension NN 40436 3732 13 , , , 40436 3732 14 through through IN 40436 3732 15 the the DT 40436 3732 16 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 3732 17 agency agency NN 40436 3732 18 of of IN 40436 3732 19 other other JJ 40436 3732 20 rings ring NNS 40436 3732 21 , , , 40436 3732 22 by by IN 40436 3732 23 the the DT 40436 3732 24 inherent inherent JJ 40436 3732 25 force force NN 40436 3732 26 of of IN 40436 3732 27 the the DT 40436 3732 28 magnet magnet NN 40436 3732 29 . . . 40436 3733 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3733 2 21 21 CD 40436 3733 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3733 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3733 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3733 6 19 19 CD 40436 3733 7 : : : 40436 3733 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3733 9 , , , 40436 3733 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 3733 11 , , , 40436 3733 12 82 82 CD 40436 3733 13 A a DT 40436 3733 14 ; ; : 40436 3733 15 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 3733 16 , , , 40436 3733 17 463 463 CD 40436 3733 18 A a NN 40436 3733 19 , , , 40436 3733 20 486 486 CD 40436 3733 21 A. a. NN 40436 3733 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3734 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3734 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3734 3 20 20 CD 40436 3734 4 : : : 40436 3734 5 This this DT 40436 3734 6 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 3734 7 is be VBZ 40436 3734 8 set set VBN 40436 3734 9 forth forth RP 40436 3734 10 at at IN 40436 3734 11 length length NN 40436 3734 12 by by IN 40436 3734 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3734 14 in in IN 40436 3734 15 the the DT 40436 3734 16 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3734 17 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 3734 18 , , , 40436 3734 19 in in IN 40436 3734 20 the the DT 40436 3734 21 second second JJ 40436 3734 22 discourse discourse NN 40436 3734 23 of of IN 40436 3734 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3734 25 about about IN 40436 3734 26 Eros Eros NNP 40436 3734 27 , , , 40436 3734 28 pp pp NNP 40436 3734 29 . . . 40436 3735 1 244 244 CD 40436 3735 2 - - SYM 40436 3735 3 245 245 CD 40436 3735 4 - - HYPH 40436 3735 5 249 249 CD 40436 3735 6 D. d. NN 40436 3735 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3735 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3735 9 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3735 10 21 21 CD 40436 3735 11 : : : 40436 3735 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3735 13 , , , 40436 3735 14 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3735 15 , , , 40436 3735 16 535 535 CD 40436 3735 17 E. E. NNP 40436 3735 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3735 19 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3735 20 : : : 40436 3735 21 ou(=to ou(=to NNP 40436 3735 22 / / SYM 40436 3735 23 s s NN 40436 3735 24 e)stin e)stin NNS 40436 3735 25 o o NNP 40436 3735 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3735 27 theatê\s theatê\s ADD 40436 3735 28 tô tô NNP 40436 3735 29 = = SYM 40436 3735 30 n n NNP 40436 3735 31 daktuli daktuli NNP 40436 3735 32 / / SYM 40436 3735 33 ôn ôn NNP 40436 3735 34 o o NNP 40436 3735 35 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3735 36 e)/schatos e)/schatos NN 40436 3735 37 . . . 40436 3736 1 . . . 40436 3737 1 . . . 40436 3738 1 . . . 40436 3739 1 o o XX 40436 3739 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3739 3 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3739 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3739 5 / / SYM 40436 3739 6 sos sos NNP 40436 3739 7 su\ su\ NNP 40436 3739 8 o o NNP 40436 3739 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3739 10 r(apsô|do\s r(apsô|do\s NNP 40436 3739 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3739 12 u(pokritê\s u(pokritê\s NNP 40436 3739 13 , , , 40436 3739 14 o o NNP 40436 3739 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3739 16 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3739 17 prô prô NNP 40436 3739 18 = = SYM 40436 3739 19 tos tos XX 40436 3739 20 , , , 40436 3739 21 au)to\s au)to\s VBP 40436 3739 22 o o FW 40436 3739 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3739 24 poiêtê poiêtê NNP 40436 3739 25 / / SYM 40436 3739 26 s s NN 40436 3739 27 . . . 40436 3739 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3739 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3740 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3740 2 Side side NN 40436 3740 3 - - HYPH 40436 3740 4 note note NN 40436 3740 5 : : : 40436 3740 6 Special special JJ 40436 3740 7 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3740 8 from from IN 40436 3740 9 the the DT 40436 3740 10 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3740 11 was be VBD 40436 3740 12 a a DT 40436 3740 13 familiar familiar JJ 40436 3740 14 fact fact NN 40436 3740 15 in in IN 40436 3740 16 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 3740 17 life life NN 40436 3740 18 . . . 40436 3741 1 Privileged privileged JJ 40436 3741 2 communications communication NNS 40436 3741 3 from from IN 40436 3741 4 the the DT 40436 3741 5 Gods god NNS 40436 3741 6 to to IN 40436 3741 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3741 8 -- -- : 40436 3741 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3741 10 firm firm JJ 40436 3741 11 belief belief NN 40436 3741 12 in in IN 40436 3741 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3741 14 . . . 40436 3741 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3742 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3742 2 must must MD 40436 3742 3 remember remember VB 40436 3742 4 , , , 40436 3742 5 that that IN 40436 3742 6 privileged privileged JJ 40436 3742 7 communications communication NNS 40436 3742 8 from from IN 40436 3742 9 the the DT 40436 3742 10 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3742 11 to to IN 40436 3742 12 men man NNS 40436 3742 13 , , , 40436 3742 14 and and CC 40436 3742 15 special special JJ 40436 3742 16 persons person NNS 40436 3742 17 recipient recipient NN 40436 3742 18 thereof thereof RB 40436 3742 19 , , , 40436 3742 20 were be VBD 40436 3742 21 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 3742 22 and and CC 40436 3742 23 witnessed witness VBN 40436 3742 24 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 3742 25 as as IN 40436 3742 26 a a DT 40436 3742 27 constant constant JJ 40436 3742 28 phenomenon phenomenon NN 40436 3742 29 of of IN 40436 3742 30 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 3742 31 life life NN 40436 3742 32 . . . 40436 3743 1 There there EX 40436 3743 2 were be VBD 40436 3743 3 not not RB 40436 3743 4 only only RB 40436 3743 5 numerous numerous JJ 40436 3743 6 oracular oracular JJ 40436 3743 7 temples temple NNS 40436 3743 8 , , , 40436 3743 9 which which WDT 40436 3743 10 every every DT 40436 3743 11 one one PRP 40436 3743 12 could could MD 40436 3743 13 visit visit VB 40436 3743 14 to to TO 40436 3743 15 ask ask VB 40436 3743 16 questions question NNS 40436 3743 17 in in IN 40436 3743 18 matters matter NNS 40436 3743 19 of of IN 40436 3743 20 doubt doubt NN 40436 3743 21 -- -- : 40436 3743 22 but but CC 40436 3743 23 also also RB 40436 3743 24 favoured favour VBD 40436 3743 25 persons person NNS 40436 3743 26 who who WP 40436 3743 27 had have VBD 40436 3743 28 received receive VBN 40436 3743 29 from from IN 40436 3743 30 the the DT 40436 3743 31 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3743 32 the the DT 40436 3743 33 gift gift NN 40436 3743 34 of of IN 40436 3743 35 predicting predict VBG 40436 3743 36 the the DT 40436 3743 37 future future NN 40436 3743 38 , , , 40436 3743 39 of of IN 40436 3743 40 interpreting interpret VBG 40436 3743 41 omens omen NNS 40436 3743 42 , , , 40436 3743 43 of of IN 40436 3743 44 determining determine VBG 40436 3743 45 the the DT 40436 3743 46 good good JJ 40436 3743 47 or or CC 40436 3743 48 bad bad JJ 40436 3743 49 indications indication NNS 40436 3743 50 furnished furnish VBN 40436 3743 51 by by IN 40436 3743 52 animals animal NNS 40436 3743 53 sacrificed sacrifice VBN 40436 3743 54 . . . 40436 3744 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3744 2 22 22 CD 40436 3744 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3744 4 In in IN 40436 3744 5 every every DT 40436 3744 6 town town NN 40436 3744 7 or or CC 40436 3744 8 village village NN 40436 3744 9 -- -- : 40436 3744 10 or or CC 40436 3744 11 wherever wherever WRB 40436 3744 12 any any DT 40436 3744 13 body body NN 40436 3744 14 of of IN 40436 3744 15 men man NNS 40436 3744 16 were be VBD 40436 3744 17 assembled assemble VBN 40436 3744 18 -- -- : 40436 3744 19 there there EX 40436 3744 20 were be VBD 40436 3744 21 always always RB 40436 3744 22 persons person NNS 40436 3744 23 who who WP 40436 3744 24 prophesied prophesy VBD 40436 3744 25 or or CC 40436 3744 26 delivered deliver VBD 40436 3744 27 oracles oracle NNS 40436 3744 28 , , , 40436 3744 29 and and CC 40436 3744 30 to to IN 40436 3744 31 whom whom WP 40436 3744 32 special special JJ 40436 3744 33 revelations revelation NNS 40436 3744 34 were be VBD 40436 3744 35 believed believe VBN 40436 3744 36 to to TO 40436 3744 37 be be VB 40436 3744 38 vouchsafed vouchsafe VBN 40436 3744 39 , , , 40436 3744 40 during during IN 40436 3744 41 periods period NNS 40436 3744 42 of of IN 40436 3744 43 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 3744 44 . . . 40436 3745 1 No no DT 40436 3745 2 one one NN 40436 3745 3 was be VBD 40436 3745 4 more more RBR 40436 3745 5 familiar familiar JJ 40436 3745 6 with with IN 40436 3745 7 this this DT 40436 3745 8 fact fact NN 40436 3745 9 than than IN 40436 3745 10 the the DT 40436 3745 11 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 3745 12 disciples disciple NNS 40436 3745 13 : : : 40436 3745 14 for for IN 40436 3745 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3745 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3745 17 had have VBD 40436 3745 18 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 3745 19 a a DT 40436 3745 20 greater great JJR 40436 3745 21 number number NN 40436 3745 22 of of IN 40436 3745 23 special special JJ 40436 3745 24 communications communication NNS 40436 3745 25 from from IN 40436 3745 26 the the DT 40436 3745 27 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3745 28 than than IN 40436 3745 29 any any DT 40436 3745 30 man man NN 40436 3745 31 of of IN 40436 3745 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3745 33 age age NN 40436 3745 34 : : : 40436 3745 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3745 36 divine divine JJ 40436 3745 37 sign sign NN 40436 3745 38 having have VBG 40436 3745 39 begun begin VBN 40436 3745 40 when when WRB 40436 3745 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3745 42 was be VBD 40436 3745 43 a a DT 40436 3745 44 child child NN 40436 3745 45 , , , 40436 3745 46 and and CC 40436 3745 47 continuing continue VBG 40436 3745 48 to to TO 40436 3745 49 move move VB 40436 3745 50 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3745 51 frequently frequently RB 40436 3745 52 , , , 40436 3745 53 even even RB 40436 3745 54 upon upon IN 40436 3745 55 small small JJ 40436 3745 56 matters matter NNS 40436 3745 57 , , , 40436 3745 58 until until IN 40436 3745 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3745 60 death death NN 40436 3745 61 : : : 40436 3745 62 though though IN 40436 3745 63 the the DT 40436 3745 64 revelations revelation NNS 40436 3745 65 were be VBD 40436 3745 66 for for IN 40436 3745 67 the the DT 40436 3745 68 most most JJS 40436 3745 69 part part NN 40436 3745 70 negative negative JJ 40436 3745 71 , , , 40436 3745 72 not not RB 40436 3745 73 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 3745 74 -- -- : 40436 3745 75 telling tell VBG 40436 3745 76 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3745 77 often often RB 40436 3745 78 what what WP 40436 3745 79 was be VBD 40436 3745 80 not not RB 40436 3745 81 to to TO 40436 3745 82 be be VB 40436 3745 83 done do VBN 40436 3745 84 -- -- : 40436 3745 85 seldom seldom RB 40436 3745 86 what what WP 40436 3745 87 was be VBD 40436 3745 88 to to TO 40436 3745 89 be be VB 40436 3745 90 done do VBN 40436 3745 91 -- -- : 40436 3745 92 resembling resemble VBG 40436 3745 93 in in IN 40436 3745 94 this this DT 40436 3745 95 respect respect NN 40436 3745 96 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3745 97 own own JJ 40436 3745 98 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3745 99 with with IN 40436 3745 100 other other JJ 40436 3745 101 persons person NNS 40436 3745 102 . . . 40436 3746 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 3746 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3746 3 inculcated inculcate VBN 40436 3746 4 upon upon IN 40436 3746 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3746 6 friends friend NNS 40436 3746 7 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 3746 8 , , , 40436 3746 9 that that IN 40436 3746 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3746 11 ought ought MD 40436 3746 12 to to TO 40436 3746 13 have have VB 40436 3746 14 constant constant JJ 40436 3746 15 recourse recourse NN 40436 3746 16 to to IN 40436 3746 17 prophecy prophecy NN 40436 3746 18 : : : 40436 3746 19 that that IN 40436 3746 20 none none NN 40436 3746 21 but but CC 40436 3746 22 impious impious JJ 40436 3746 23 men man NNS 40436 3746 24 neglected neglect VBD 40436 3746 25 to to TO 40436 3746 26 do do VB 40436 3746 27 so so RB 40436 3746 28 : : : 40436 3746 29 that that IN 40436 3746 30 the the DT 40436 3746 31 benevolence benevolence NN 40436 3746 32 of of IN 40436 3746 33 the the DT 40436 3746 34 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3746 35 was be VBD 40436 3746 36 nowhere nowhere RB 40436 3746 37 more more RBR 40436 3746 38 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 3746 39 than than IN 40436 3746 40 in in IN 40436 3746 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3746 42 furnishing furnish VBG 40436 3746 43 such such JJ 40436 3746 44 special special JJ 40436 3746 45 revelations revelation NNS 40436 3746 46 and and CC 40436 3746 47 warnings warning NNS 40436 3746 48 , , , 40436 3746 49 to to IN 40436 3746 50 persons person NNS 40436 3746 51 whom whom WP 40436 3746 52 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3746 53 favoured favour VBD 40436 3746 54 : : : 40436 3746 55 that that IN 40436 3746 56 the the DT 40436 3746 57 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3746 58 administered administer VBD 40436 3746 59 the the DT 40436 3746 60 affairs affair NNS 40436 3746 61 of of IN 40436 3746 62 the the DT 40436 3746 63 world world NN 40436 3746 64 partly partly RB 40436 3746 65 upon upon IN 40436 3746 66 principles principle NNS 40436 3746 67 of of IN 40436 3746 68 regular regular JJ 40436 3746 69 sequence sequence NN 40436 3746 70 , , , 40436 3746 71 so so IN 40436 3746 72 that that IN 40436 3746 73 men man NNS 40436 3746 74 by by IN 40436 3746 75 diligent diligent JJ 40436 3746 76 study study NN 40436 3746 77 might may MD 40436 3746 78 learn learn VB 40436 3746 79 what what WP 40436 3746 80 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3746 81 were be VBD 40436 3746 82 to to TO 40436 3746 83 expect,--but expect,--but CC 40436 3746 84 partly partly RB 40436 3746 85 also also RB 40436 3746 86 , , , 40436 3746 87 and and CC 40436 3746 88 by by IN 40436 3746 89 design design NN 40436 3746 90 , , , 40436 3746 91 in in IN 40436 3746 92 a a DT 40436 3746 93 manner manner NN 40436 3746 94 irregular irregular JJ 40436 3746 95 and and CC 40436 3746 96 undecypherable undecypherable JJ 40436 3746 97 , , , 40436 3746 98 such such JJ 40436 3746 99 that that IN 40436 3746 100 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3746 101 could could MD 40436 3746 102 not not RB 40436 3746 103 be be VB 40436 3746 104 fathomed fathom VBN 40436 3746 105 by by IN 40436 3746 106 any any DT 40436 3746 107 human human JJ 40436 3746 108 study study NN 40436 3746 109 , , , 40436 3746 110 and and CC 40436 3746 111 could could MD 40436 3746 112 not not RB 40436 3746 113 be be VB 40436 3746 114 understood understand VBN 40436 3746 115 except except IN 40436 3746 116 through through IN 40436 3746 117 direct direct JJ 40436 3746 118 and and CC 40436 3746 119 special special JJ 40436 3746 120 revelation revelation NN 40436 3746 121 from from IN 40436 3746 122 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3746 123 . . . 40436 3747 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3747 2 23 23 CD 40436 3747 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3747 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3747 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3747 6 22 22 CD 40436 3747 7 : : : 40436 3747 8 Not not RB 40436 3747 9 only only RB 40436 3747 10 the the DT 40436 3747 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3747 12 Greek greek JJ 40436 3747 13 : : : 40436 3747 14 chrêsmolo chrêsmolo NNP 40436 3747 15 / / SYM 40436 3747 16 goi goi NNP 40436 3747 17 , , , 40436 3747 18 ma ma NNP 40436 3747 19 / / SYM 40436 3747 20 nteis nteis NNP 40436 3747 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3747 22 oracular oracular JJ 40436 3747 23 temples temple NNS 40436 3747 24 , , , 40436 3747 25 & & CC 40436 3747 26 c. c. NNP 40436 3747 27 , , , 40436 3747 28 are be VBP 40436 3747 29 often often RB 40436 3747 30 mentioned mention VBN 40436 3747 31 in in IN 40436 3747 32 Herodotus Herodotus NNP 40436 3747 33 , , , 40436 3747 34 Thucydides Thucydides NNPS 40436 3747 35 , , , 40436 3747 36 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3747 37 , , , 40436 3747 38 & & CC 40436 3747 39 c. c. NNP 40436 3747 40 , , , 40436 3747 41 but but CC 40436 3747 42 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 3747 43 also also RB 40436 3747 44 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 3747 45 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3747 46 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3747 47 : : : 40436 3747 48 oi oi NNP 40436 3747 49 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3747 50 numpho numpho NNP 40436 3747 51 / / SYM 40436 3747 52 lêptoi lêptoi NNP 40436 3747 53 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3747 54 theo theo NNP 40436 3747 55 / / SYM 40436 3747 56 lêptoi lêptoi NNP 40436 3747 57 tô tô NNP 40436 3747 58 = = SYM 40436 3747 59 n n NNP 40436 3747 60 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 3747 61 / / SYM 40436 3747 62 pôn pôn NNP 40436 3747 63 , , , 40436 3747 64 e)pipnoi e)pipnoi NNP 40436 3747 65 / / SYM 40436 3747 66 a| a| NN 40436 3747 67 daimoni daimoni NNP 40436 3747 68 / / SYM 40436 3747 69 ou ou NNP 40436 3747 70 tino\s tino\s NNP 40436 3747 71 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 3747 72 e)nthousia e)nthousia NNP 40436 3747 73 / / SYM 40436 3747 74 zontes zonte NNS 40436 3747 75 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3747 76 , , , 40436 3747 77 as as IN 40436 3747 78 a a DT 40436 3747 79 real real JJ 40436 3747 80 and and CC 40436 3747 81 known know VBN 40436 3747 82 class class NN 40436 3747 83 of of IN 40436 3747 84 persons person NNS 40436 3747 85 . . . 40436 3748 1 See see VB 40436 3748 2 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 3748 3 . . . 40436 3749 1 Eudem Eudem NNP 40436 3749 2 . . . 40436 3750 1 i. i. NNP 40436 3750 2 p. p. NNP 40436 3750 3 1214 1214 CD 40436 3750 4 , , , 40436 3750 5 a. a. NN 40436 3751 1 23 23 CD 40436 3751 2 ; ; : 40436 3751 3 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 3751 4 . . . 40436 3752 1 Magna Magna NNP 40436 3752 2 , , , 40436 3752 3 ii ii NNP 40436 3752 4 . . . 40436 3753 1 p. p. NN 40436 3753 2 1207 1207 CD 40436 3753 3 , , , 40436 3753 4 b. b. NNP 40436 3754 1 8 8 LS 40436 3754 2 . . . 40436 3755 1 The the DT 40436 3755 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3755 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3755 4 : : : 40436 3755 5 ma ma NNP 40436 3755 6 / / SYM 40436 3755 7 ntis ntis NNP 40436 3755 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3755 9 is be VBZ 40436 3755 10 a a DT 40436 3755 11 recognised recognised JJ 40436 3755 12 profession profession NN 40436 3755 13 , , , 40436 3755 14 the the DT 40436 3755 15 gift gift NN 40436 3755 16 of of IN 40436 3755 17 Apollo Apollo NNP 40436 3755 18 , , , 40436 3755 19 not not RB 40436 3755 20 merely merely RB 40436 3755 21 according accord VBG 40436 3755 22 to to IN 40436 3755 23 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3755 24 , , , 40436 3755 25 but but CC 40436 3755 26 according accord VBG 40436 3755 27 to to IN 40436 3755 28 Solon Solon NNP 40436 3755 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3755 30 Frag Frag NNP 40436 3755 31 . . . 40436 3756 1 xi xi NNP 40436 3756 2 . . . 40436 3757 1 52 52 CD 40436 3757 2 , , , 40436 3757 3 Schn Schn NNP 40436 3757 4 . . . 40436 3758 1 ): ): NNP 40436 3758 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3758 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3758 4 : : : 40436 3758 5 A)/llon A)/llon NNP 40436 3758 6 ma ma NNP 40436 3758 7 / / SYM 40436 3758 8 ntin ntin NNP 40436 3758 9 e)/thêken e)/thêken VBN 40436 3758 10 a)/nax a)/nax NNP 40436 3758 11 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 3758 12 / / SYM 40436 3758 13 ergos ergos NNP 40436 3758 14 A)po A)po NNPS 40436 3758 15 / / SYM 40436 3758 16 llôn llôn NN 40436 3758 17 , , , 40436 3758 18 e)/gnô e)/gnô NN 40436 3758 19 d d NN 40436 3758 20 ' ' `` 40436 3758 21 a)ndri\ a)ndri\ NNP 40436 3758 22 kako\n kako\n CD 40436 3758 23 têlo têlo JJ 40436 3758 24 / / , 40436 3758 25 then then RB 40436 3758 26 e)rcho e)rcho NNP 40436 3758 27 / / SYM 40436 3758 28 menon menon NNP 40436 3758 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3758 30 , , , 40436 3758 31 & & CC 40436 3758 32 c. c. NNP 40436 3758 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3758 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3758 35 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3758 36 23 23 CD 40436 3758 37 : : : 40436 3758 38 These these DT 40436 3758 39 views view NNS 40436 3758 40 of of IN 40436 3758 41 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3758 42 are be VBP 40436 3758 43 declared declare VBN 40436 3758 44 in in IN 40436 3758 45 the the DT 40436 3758 46 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 3758 47 of of IN 40436 3758 48 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3758 49 , , , 40436 3758 50 i. i. NNP 40436 3759 1 1 1 CD 40436 3759 2 , , , 40436 3759 3 6 6 CD 40436 3759 4 - - SYM 40436 3759 5 10 10 CD 40436 3759 6 ; ; : 40436 3759 7 i. i. NNP 40436 3760 1 4 4 CD 40436 3760 2 , , , 40436 3760 3 2 2 CD 40436 3760 4 - - SYM 40436 3760 5 18 18 CD 40436 3760 6 ; ; : 40436 3760 7 iv iv LS 40436 3760 8 . . . 40436 3761 1 3 3 CD 40436 3761 2 , , , 40436 3761 3 12 12 CD 40436 3761 4 . . . 40436 3762 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3762 2 is be VBZ 40436 3762 3 plain plain JJ 40436 3762 4 from from IN 40436 3762 5 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 3762 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3762 7 Mem Mem NNP 40436 3762 8 . . . 40436 3763 1 i. i. NNP 40436 3764 1 1 1 CD 40436 3764 2 , , , 40436 3764 3 3 3 CD 40436 3764 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3764 5 that that IN 40436 3764 6 many many JJ 40436 3764 7 persons person NNS 40436 3764 8 were be VBD 40436 3764 9 offended offend VBN 40436 3764 10 with with IN 40436 3764 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3764 12 because because IN 40436 3764 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3764 14 believed,--or believed,--or VBP 40436 3764 15 at at IN 40436 3764 16 least least JJS 40436 3764 17 because because IN 40436 3764 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3764 19 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 3764 20 -- -- : 40436 3764 21 that that IN 40436 3764 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3764 23 received receive VBD 40436 3764 24 more more RBR 40436 3764 25 numerous numerous JJ 40436 3764 26 and and CC 40436 3764 27 special special JJ 40436 3764 28 revelations revelation NNS 40436 3764 29 from from IN 40436 3764 30 the the DT 40436 3764 31 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3764 32 than than IN 40436 3764 33 any any DT 40436 3764 34 one one NN 40436 3764 35 else else RB 40436 3764 36 . . . 40436 3764 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3765 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3765 2 Side side NN 40436 3765 3 - - HYPH 40436 3765 4 note note NN 40436 3765 5 : : : 40436 3765 6 Condition condition NN 40436 3765 7 of of IN 40436 3765 8 the the DT 40436 3765 9 inspired inspire VBN 40436 3765 10 person person NN 40436 3765 11 -- -- : 40436 3765 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3765 13 reason reason NN 40436 3765 14 is be VBZ 40436 3765 15 for for IN 40436 3765 16 the the DT 40436 3765 17 time time NN 40436 3765 18 withdrawn withdraw VBN 40436 3765 19 . . . 40436 3765 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3766 1 Here here RB 40436 3766 2 , , , 40436 3766 3 as as RB 40436 3766 4 well well RB 40436 3766 5 as as IN 40436 3766 6 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 3766 7 , , , 40436 3766 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3766 9 places place NNS 40436 3766 10 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3766 11 , , , 40436 3766 12 both both DT 40436 3766 13 of of IN 40436 3766 14 the the DT 40436 3766 15 prophet prophet NN 40436 3766 16 and and CC 40436 3766 17 the the DT 40436 3766 18 poet poet NN 40436 3766 19 , , , 40436 3766 20 in in IN 40436 3766 21 marked mark VBN 40436 3766 22 contrast contrast NN 40436 3766 23 with with IN 40436 3766 24 reason reason NN 40436 3766 25 and and CC 40436 3766 26 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3766 27 . . . 40436 3767 1 Reason reason NN 40436 3767 2 is be VBZ 40436 3767 3 supposed suppose VBN 40436 3767 4 to to TO 40436 3767 5 be be VB 40436 3767 6 for for IN 40436 3767 7 the the DT 40436 3767 8 time time NN 40436 3767 9 withdrawn withdraw VBN 40436 3767 10 or or CC 40436 3767 11 abolished abolish VBD 40436 3767 12 , , , 40436 3767 13 and and CC 40436 3767 14 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3767 15 is be VBZ 40436 3767 16 introduced introduce VBN 40436 3767 17 by by IN 40436 3767 18 the the DT 40436 3767 19 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3767 20 into into IN 40436 3767 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3767 22 place place NN 40436 3767 23 . . . 40436 3768 1 " " `` 40436 3768 2 When when WRB 40436 3768 3 Monarch Monarch NNP 40436 3768 4 Reason Reason NNP 40436 3768 5 sleeps sleep VBZ 40436 3768 6 , , , 40436 3768 7 this this DT 40436 3768 8 mimic mimic JJ 40436 3768 9 wakes wake VBZ 40436 3768 10 . . . 40436 3768 11 " " '' 40436 3769 1 The the DT 40436 3769 2 person person NN 40436 3769 3 inspired inspire VBD 40436 3769 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3769 5 prophet prophet NN 40436 3769 6 or or CC 40436 3769 7 poet poet NN 40436 3769 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3769 9 becomes become VBZ 40436 3769 10 for for IN 40436 3769 11 the the DT 40436 3769 12 time time NN 40436 3769 13 the the DT 40436 3769 14 organ organ NN 40436 3769 15 of of IN 40436 3769 16 an an DT 40436 3769 17 extraneous extraneous JJ 40436 3769 18 agency agency NN 40436 3769 19 , , , 40436 3769 20 speaking speak VBG 40436 3769 21 what what WP 40436 3769 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3769 23 neither neither CC 40436 3769 24 originates originate VBZ 40436 3769 25 nor nor CC 40436 3769 26 understands understand NNS 40436 3769 27 . . . 40436 3770 1 The the DT 40436 3770 2 genuine genuine JJ 40436 3770 3 gift gift NN 40436 3770 4 of of IN 40436 3770 5 prophecy[24 prophecy[24 NN 40436 3770 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3770 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3770 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3770 9 says say VBZ 40436 3770 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3770 11 attaches attach VBZ 40436 3770 12 only only RB 40436 3770 13 to to IN 40436 3770 14 a a DT 40436 3770 15 disabled disabled JJ 40436 3770 16 , , , 40436 3770 17 enfeebled enfeeble VBN 40436 3770 18 , , , 40436 3770 19 distempered distemper VBN 40436 3770 20 , , , 40436 3770 21 condition condition NN 40436 3770 22 of of IN 40436 3770 23 the the DT 40436 3770 24 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3770 25 ; ; : 40436 3770 26 the the DT 40436 3770 27 gift gift NN 40436 3770 28 of of IN 40436 3770 29 poetry poetry NN 40436 3770 30 is be VBZ 40436 3770 31 conferred confer VBN 40436 3770 32 by by IN 40436 3770 33 the the DT 40436 3770 34 Gods god NNS 40436 3770 35 upon upon IN 40436 3770 36 the the DT 40436 3770 37 most most RBS 40436 3770 38 inferior inferior JJ 40436 3770 39 men man NNS 40436 3770 40 , , , 40436 3770 41 as as IN 40436 3770 42 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3770 43 see see VBP 40436 3770 44 by by IN 40436 3770 45 the the DT 40436 3770 46 case case NN 40436 3770 47 of of IN 40436 3770 48 Tynnichus Tynnichus NNP 40436 3770 49 -- -- : 40436 3770 50 whose whose WP$ 40436 3770 51 sublime sublime JJ 40436 3770 52 pæan pæan NNS 40436 3770 53 shows show VBZ 40436 3770 54 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3770 55 , , , 40436 3770 56 that that IN 40436 3770 57 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3770 58 is be VBZ 40436 3770 59 the the DT 40436 3770 60 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3770 61 alone alone RB 40436 3770 62 who who WP 40436 3770 63 utter utter VBP 40436 3770 64 fine fine JJ 40436 3770 65 poetry poetry NN 40436 3770 66 through through IN 40436 3770 67 the the DT 40436 3770 68 organs organ NNS 40436 3770 69 of of IN 40436 3770 70 a a DT 40436 3770 71 person person NN 40436 3770 72 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3770 73 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 3770 74 incompetent incompetent JJ 40436 3770 75 . . . 40436 3771 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3771 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3771 3 24 24 CD 40436 3771 4 : : : 40436 3771 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3771 6 , , , 40436 3771 7 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 3771 8 , , , 40436 3771 9 71 71 CD 40436 3771 10 E. E. NNP 40436 3771 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3771 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3771 13 : : : 40436 3771 14 i(kano\n i(kano\n NNP 40436 3771 15 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3771 16 sêmei sêmei NNP 40436 3771 17 = = NFP 40436 3771 18 on on IN 40436 3771 19 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3771 20 mantikê\n mantikê\n NNP 40436 3771 21 a)phrosu a)phrosu NNS 40436 3771 22 / / SYM 40436 3771 23 nê| nê| NNP 40436 3771 24 theo\s theo\ NNS 40436 3771 25 a)nthrôpi a)nthrôpi NNP 40436 3771 26 / / SYM 40436 3771 27 nê| nê| NNP 40436 3771 28 de de NNP 40436 3771 29 / / SYM 40436 3771 30 dôken dôken VBN 40436 3771 31 ; ; : 40436 3771 32 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 3771 33 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3771 34 e)/nnous e)/nnous JJ 40436 3771 35 e)pha e)pha NNP 40436 3771 36 / / SYM 40436 3771 37 ptetai ptetai NNP 40436 3771 38 mantikê mantikê NNP 40436 3771 39 = = SYM 40436 3771 40 s s NNP 40436 3771 41 e)nthe e)nthe NNP 40436 3771 42 / / SYM 40436 3771 43 ou ou NNP 40436 3771 44 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3771 45 a)lêthou a)lêthou NNP 40436 3771 46 = = SYM 40436 3771 47 s s NNP 40436 3771 48 , , , 40436 3771 49 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 3771 50 ' ' '' 40436 3771 51 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 3771 52 kath kath NNP 40436 3771 53 ' ' '' 40436 3771 54 u(/pnon u(/pnon NNP 40436 3771 55 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 3771 56 tê tê NNP 40436 3771 57 = = SYM 40436 3771 58 s s NNP 40436 3771 59 phronê phronê NNP 40436 3771 60 / / SYM 40436 3771 61 seôs seôs JJ 40436 3771 62 pedêthei\s pedêthei\s NNPS 40436 3771 63 du du NNP 40436 3771 64 / / SYM 40436 3771 65 namin namin NNP 40436 3771 66 , , , 40436 3771 67 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 3771 68 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 3771 69 no no DT 40436 3771 70 / / SYM 40436 3771 71 son son NN 40436 3771 72 ê)/ ê)/ NNP 40436 3771 73 tina tina NNP 40436 3771 74 e)nthousiasmo\n e)nthousiasmo\n NNP 40436 3771 75 paralla paralla NNP 40436 3771 76 / / SYM 40436 3771 77 xas xas NNP 40436 3771 78 . . . 40436 3771 79 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3772 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 3772 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3772 3 , , , 40436 3772 4 Menon Menon NNP 40436 3772 5 , , , 40436 3772 6 pp pp NNP 40436 3772 7 . . . 40436 3773 1 99 99 CD 40436 3773 2 - - SYM 40436 3773 3 100 100 CD 40436 3773 4 . . . 40436 3774 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3774 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3774 3 : : : 40436 3774 4 oi oi UH 40436 3774 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3774 6 chrêsmô|doi/ chrêsmô|doi/ NNP 40436 3774 7 te te NNP 40436 3774 8 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3774 9 oi oi NNP 40436 3774 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3774 11 theoma theoma NNP 40436 3774 12 / / SYM 40436 3774 13 nteis nteis NNP 40436 3774 14 . . . 40436 3775 1 . . . 40436 3776 1 . . . 40436 3777 1 . . . 40436 3778 1 le le NNP 40436 3778 2 / / SYM 40436 3778 3 gousi gousi NNP 40436 3778 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3778 5 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 3778 6 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3778 7 polla\ polla\ NNP 40436 3778 8 i)/sasi i)/sasi NNP 40436 3778 9 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3778 10 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 3778 11 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 3778 12 le le NNP 40436 3778 13 / / SYM 40436 3778 14 gousi gousi NNP 40436 3778 15 . . . 40436 3778 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3779 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 3779 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3779 3 , , , 40436 3779 4 Legg Legg NNP 40436 3779 5 . . . 40436 3780 1 iv iv XX 40436 3780 2 . . . 40436 3781 1 719 719 CD 40436 3781 2 . . . 40436 3781 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3782 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3782 2 Side side NN 40436 3782 3 - - HYPH 40436 3782 4 note note NN 40436 3782 5 : : : 40436 3782 6 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3782 7 does do VBZ 40436 3782 8 not not RB 40436 3782 9 admit admit VB 40436 3782 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3782 11 to to TO 40436 3782 12 be be VB 40436 3782 13 inspired inspire VBN 40436 3782 14 and and CC 40436 3782 15 out out IN 40436 3782 16 of of IN 40436 3782 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3782 18 mind mind NN 40436 3782 19 . . . 40436 3782 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3783 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3783 2 is be VBZ 40436 3783 3 thus thus RB 40436 3783 4 that that IN 40436 3783 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3783 6 , , , 40436 3783 7 setting set VBG 40436 3783 8 before before IN 40436 3783 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3783 10 a a DT 40436 3783 11 process process NN 40436 3783 12 of of IN 40436 3783 13 systematised systematise VBN 40436 3783 14 reason,--originating reason,--originate VBG 40436 3783 15 in in IN 40436 3783 16 a a DT 40436 3783 17 superior superior JJ 40436 3783 18 intellect intellect NN 40436 3783 19 , , , 40436 3783 20 laying lay VBG 40436 3783 21 down down RP 40436 3783 22 universal universal JJ 40436 3783 23 principles principle NNS 40436 3783 24 and and CC 40436 3783 25 deducing deduce VBG 40436 3783 26 consequences consequence NNS 40436 3783 27 from from IN 40436 3783 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3783 29 -- -- : 40436 3783 30 capable capable JJ 40436 3783 31 of of IN 40436 3783 32 being be VBG 40436 3783 33 consistently consistently RB 40436 3783 34 applied apply VBN 40436 3783 35 , , , 40436 3783 36 designedly designedly RB 40436 3783 37 taught teach VBN 40436 3783 38 , , , 40436 3783 39 and and CC 40436 3783 40 defended defend VBN 40436 3783 41 against against IN 40436 3783 42 objections objection NNS 40436 3783 43 -- -- : 40436 3783 44 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 3783 45 the the DT 40436 3783 46 various various JJ 40436 3783 47 mental mental JJ 40436 3783 48 conditions condition NNS 40436 3783 49 opposed oppose VBN 40436 3783 50 to to IN 40436 3783 51 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3783 52 , , , 40436 3783 53 and and CC 40436 3783 54 ranks rank VBZ 40436 3783 55 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3783 56 as as IN 40436 3783 57 one one CD 40436 3783 58 of of IN 40436 3783 59 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3783 60 . . . 40436 3784 1 In in IN 40436 3784 2 this this DT 40436 3784 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3784 4 , , , 40436 3784 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3784 6 seeks seek VBZ 40436 3784 7 to to TO 40436 3784 8 prove prove VB 40436 3784 9 that that IN 40436 3784 10 the the DT 40436 3784 11 success success NN 40436 3784 12 of of IN 40436 3784 13 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3784 14 as as IN 40436 3784 15 a a DT 40436 3784 16 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3784 17 depends depend VBZ 40436 3784 18 upon upon IN 40436 3784 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3784 20 being be VBG 40436 3784 21 out out IN 40436 3784 22 of of IN 40436 3784 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3784 24 mind mind NN 40436 3784 25 or or CC 40436 3784 26 inspired inspire VBD 40436 3784 27 . . . 40436 3785 1 But but CC 40436 3785 2 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3785 3 does do VBZ 40436 3785 4 not not RB 40436 3785 5 accept accept VB 40436 3785 6 the the DT 40436 3785 7 compliment compliment NN 40436 3785 8 : : : 40436 3785 9 _ _ NNP 40436 3785 10 Ion._--You Ion._--You NNP 40436 3785 11 speak speak VBP 40436 3785 12 well well RB 40436 3785 13 , , , 40436 3785 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3785 15 ; ; : 40436 3785 16 but but CC 40436 3785 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3785 18 should should MD 40436 3785 19 be be VB 40436 3785 20 surprised surprised JJ 40436 3785 21 if if IN 40436 3785 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3785 23 spoke speak VBD 40436 3785 24 well well RB 40436 3785 25 enough enough RB 40436 3785 26 to to TO 40436 3785 27 create create VB 40436 3785 28 in in IN 40436 3785 29 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3785 30 the the DT 40436 3785 31 new new JJ 40436 3785 32 conviction conviction NN 40436 3785 33 , , , 40436 3785 34 that that IN 40436 3785 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3785 36 am be VBP 40436 3785 37 possessed possessed JJ 40436 3785 38 and and CC 40436 3785 39 mad mad JJ 40436 3785 40 when when WRB 40436 3785 41 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3785 42 eulogize eulogize VBP 40436 3785 43 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3785 44 . . . 40436 3786 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3786 2 do do VBP 40436 3786 3 not not RB 40436 3786 4 think think VB 40436 3786 5 that that IN 40436 3786 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3786 7 would would MD 40436 3786 8 even even RB 40436 3786 9 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 3786 10 say say VB 40436 3786 11 so so RB 40436 3786 12 , , , 40436 3786 13 if if IN 40436 3786 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3786 15 heard hear VBD 40436 3786 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3786 17 discourse discourse VB 40436 3786 18 on on IN 40436 3786 19 the the DT 40436 3786 20 subject subject NN 40436 3786 21 . . . 40436 3787 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3787 2 25 25 CD 40436 3787 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3787 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3787 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3787 6 25 25 CD 40436 3787 7 : : : 40436 3787 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3787 9 , , , 40436 3787 10 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3787 11 , , , 40436 3787 12 536 536 CD 40436 3787 13 E. e. NN 40436 3787 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3787 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3787 16 Side side NN 40436 3787 17 - - HYPH 40436 3787 18 note note NN 40436 3787 19 : : : 40436 3787 20 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3787 21 talks talk NNS 40436 3787 22 upon upon IN 40436 3787 23 all all DT 40436 3787 24 subjects subject NNS 40436 3787 25 -- -- : 40436 3787 26 Is be VBZ 40436 3787 27 Ion Ion VBN 40436 3787 28 competent competent JJ 40436 3787 29 to to TO 40436 3787 30 explain explain VB 40436 3787 31 what what WP 40436 3787 32 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3787 33 says say VBZ 40436 3787 34 upon upon IN 40436 3787 35 all all DT 40436 3787 36 of of IN 40436 3787 37 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3787 38 ? ? . 40436 3788 1 Rhapsodic rhapsodic JJ 40436 3788 2 art art NN 40436 3788 3 . . . 40436 3789 1 What what WP 40436 3789 2 is be VBZ 40436 3789 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3789 4 province province NN 40436 3789 5 ? ? . 40436 3789 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3790 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3790 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 3790 3 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3790 4 talks talk VBZ 40436 3790 5 upon upon IN 40436 3790 6 all all DT 40436 3790 7 subjects subject NNS 40436 3790 8 . . . 40436 3791 1 Upon upon IN 40436 3791 2 which which WDT 40436 3791 3 of of IN 40436 3791 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3791 5 can can MD 40436 3791 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3791 7 discourse discourse VB 40436 3791 8 ? ? . 40436 3792 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3792 2 Ion._--Upon Ion._--Upon , 40436 3792 3 all all DT 40436 3792 4 . . . 40436 3793 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3793 2 Sokr._--Not Sokr._--Not NNP 40436 3793 3 surely surely RB 40436 3793 4 on on IN 40436 3793 5 such such JJ 40436 3793 6 as as IN 40436 3793 7 belong belong NN 40436 3793 8 to to IN 40436 3793 9 special special JJ 40436 3793 10 arts art NNS 40436 3793 11 , , , 40436 3793 12 professions profession NNS 40436 3793 13 . . . 40436 3794 1 Each each DT 40436 3794 2 portion portion NN 40436 3794 3 of of IN 40436 3794 4 the the DT 40436 3794 5 matter matter NN 40436 3794 6 of of IN 40436 3794 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3794 8 is be VBZ 40436 3794 9 included include VBN 40436 3794 10 under under IN 40436 3794 11 some some DT 40436 3794 12 special special JJ 40436 3794 13 art art NN 40436 3794 14 , , , 40436 3794 15 and and CC 40436 3794 16 is be VBZ 40436 3794 17 known know VBN 40436 3794 18 through through IN 40436 3794 19 that that DT 40436 3794 20 art art NN 40436 3794 21 by by IN 40436 3794 22 those those DT 40436 3794 23 who who WP 40436 3794 24 possess possess VBP 40436 3794 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3794 26 . . . 40436 3795 1 Thus thus RB 40436 3795 2 , , , 40436 3795 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3795 4 and and CC 40436 3795 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3795 6 , , , 40436 3795 7 both both DT 40436 3795 8 of of IN 40436 3795 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3795 10 , , , 40436 3795 11 know know VB 40436 3795 12 the the DT 40436 3795 13 number number NN 40436 3795 14 of of IN 40436 3795 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3795 16 fingers finger NNS 40436 3795 17 ; ; : 40436 3795 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3795 19 know know VBP 40436 3795 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3795 21 through through IN 40436 3795 22 the the DT 40436 3795 23 same same JJ 40436 3795 24 art art NN 40436 3795 25 , , , 40436 3795 26 which which WDT 40436 3795 27 both both DT 40436 3795 28 of of IN 40436 3795 29 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3795 30 possess possess VBP 40436 3795 31 -- -- : 40436 3795 32 the the DT 40436 3795 33 arithmetical arithmetical JJ 40436 3795 34 . . . 40436 3796 1 But but CC 40436 3796 2 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3796 3 talks talk NNS 40436 3796 4 of of IN 40436 3796 5 matters matter NNS 40436 3796 6 belonging belong VBG 40436 3796 7 to to IN 40436 3796 8 many many JJ 40436 3796 9 different different JJ 40436 3796 10 arts art NNS 40436 3796 11 or or CC 40436 3796 12 occupations occupation NNS 40436 3796 13 , , , 40436 3796 14 that that DT 40436 3796 15 of of IN 40436 3796 16 the the DT 40436 3796 17 physician physician NN 40436 3796 18 , , , 40436 3796 19 the the DT 40436 3796 20 charioteer charioteer NN 40436 3796 21 , , , 40436 3796 22 the the DT 40436 3796 23 fisherman fisherman NN 40436 3796 24 , , , 40436 3796 25 & & CC 40436 3796 26 c. c. NNP 40436 3796 27 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3796 28 can can MD 40436 3796 29 not not RB 40436 3796 30 know know VB 40436 3796 31 these these DT 40436 3796 32 ; ; : 40436 3796 33 since since IN 40436 3796 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3796 35 do do VBP 40436 3796 36 not not RB 40436 3796 37 belong belong VB 40436 3796 38 to to IN 40436 3796 39 any any DT 40436 3796 40 of of IN 40436 3796 41 these these DT 40436 3796 42 professions profession NNS 40436 3796 43 , , , 40436 3796 44 but but CC 40436 3796 45 are be VBP 40436 3796 46 a a DT 40436 3796 47 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3796 48 . . . 40436 3797 1 Describe describe VB 40436 3797 2 to to IN 40436 3797 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3797 4 what what WP 40436 3797 5 are be VBP 40436 3797 6 the the DT 40436 3797 7 matters matter NNS 40436 3797 8 included include VBN 40436 3797 9 in in IN 40436 3797 10 the the DT 40436 3797 11 rhapsodic rhapsodic JJ 40436 3797 12 art art NN 40436 3797 13 . . . 40436 3798 1 The the DT 40436 3798 2 rhapsodic rhapsodic JJ 40436 3798 3 art art NN 40436 3798 4 is be VBZ 40436 3798 5 one one CD 40436 3798 6 art art NN 40436 3798 7 by by IN 40436 3798 8 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 3798 9 , , , 40436 3798 10 distinct distinct JJ 40436 3798 11 from from IN 40436 3798 12 the the DT 40436 3798 13 medical medical JJ 40436 3798 14 and and CC 40436 3798 15 others other NNS 40436 3798 16 : : : 40436 3798 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3798 18 can can MD 40436 3798 19 not not RB 40436 3798 20 know know VB 40436 3798 21 every every DT 40436 3798 22 thing thing NN 40436 3798 23 ; ; : 40436 3798 24 tell tell VB 40436 3798 25 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3798 26 what what WDT 40436 3798 27 matters matter NNS 40436 3798 28 come come VBP 40436 3798 29 under under IN 40436 3798 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3798 31 special special JJ 40436 3798 32 province province NN 40436 3798 33 . . . 40436 3799 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3799 2 26 26 CD 40436 3799 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3799 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3799 5 Ion._--The Ion._--The NNP 40436 3799 6 rhapsodic rhapsodic JJ 40436 3799 7 art art NN 40436 3799 8 does do VBZ 40436 3799 9 not not RB 40436 3799 10 know know VB 40436 3799 11 what what WP 40436 3799 12 belongs belong VBZ 40436 3799 13 to to IN 40436 3799 14 any any DT 40436 3799 15 one one CD 40436 3799 16 of of IN 40436 3799 17 the the DT 40436 3799 18 other other JJ 40436 3799 19 special special JJ 40436 3799 20 arts art NNS 40436 3799 21 : : : 40436 3799 22 but but CC 40436 3799 23 that that DT 40436 3799 24 of of IN 40436 3799 25 which which WDT 40436 3799 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3799 27 takes take VBZ 40436 3799 28 cognizance cognizance NN 40436 3799 29 , , , 40436 3799 30 and and CC 40436 3799 31 that that IN 40436 3799 32 which which WDT 40436 3799 33 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3799 34 know know VBP 40436 3799 35 , , , 40436 3799 36 is be VBZ 40436 3799 37 , , , 40436 3799 38 what what WP 40436 3799 39 is be VBZ 40436 3799 40 becoming become VBG 40436 3799 41 and and CC 40436 3799 42 suitable suitable JJ 40436 3799 43 to to IN 40436 3799 44 each each DT 40436 3799 45 variety variety NN 40436 3799 46 of of IN 40436 3799 47 character character NN 40436 3799 48 described describe VBN 40436 3799 49 by by IN 40436 3799 50 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3799 51 : : : 40436 3799 52 to to IN 40436 3799 53 a a DT 40436 3799 54 man man NN 40436 3799 55 or or CC 40436 3799 56 woman woman NN 40436 3799 57 -- -- : 40436 3799 58 to to IN 40436 3799 59 a a DT 40436 3799 60 freeman freeman NN 40436 3799 61 or or CC 40436 3799 62 slave slave NN 40436 3799 63 -- -- : 40436 3799 64 to to IN 40436 3799 65 the the DT 40436 3799 66 commander commander NN 40436 3799 67 who who WP 40436 3799 68 gives give VBZ 40436 3799 69 orders order NNS 40436 3799 70 or or CC 40436 3799 71 to to IN 40436 3799 72 the the DT 40436 3799 73 subordinate subordinate JJ 40436 3799 74 who who WP 40436 3799 75 obeys obey VBZ 40436 3799 76 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3799 77 , , , 40436 3799 78 & & CC 40436 3799 79 c. c. NNP 40436 3799 80 This this DT 40436 3799 81 is be VBZ 40436 3799 82 what what WP 40436 3799 83 belongs belong VBZ 40436 3799 84 to to IN 40436 3799 85 the the DT 40436 3799 86 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 3799 87 province province NN 40436 3799 88 of of IN 40436 3799 89 the the DT 40436 3799 90 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3799 91 to to TO 40436 3799 92 appreciate appreciate VB 40436 3799 93 and and CC 40436 3799 94 understand understand VB 40436 3799 95 . . . 40436 3800 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3800 2 27 27 CD 40436 3800 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3800 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3800 5 Sokr._--Will Sokr._--Will NNP 40436 3800 6 the the DT 40436 3800 7 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3800 8 know know VB 40436 3800 9 what what WP 40436 3800 10 is be VBZ 40436 3800 11 suitable suitable JJ 40436 3800 12 for for IN 40436 3800 13 the the DT 40436 3800 14 commander commander NN 40436 3800 15 of of IN 40436 3800 16 a a DT 40436 3800 17 ship ship NN 40436 3800 18 to to TO 40436 3800 19 say say VB 40436 3800 20 to to IN 40436 3800 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3800 22 seamen seaman NNS 40436 3800 23 , , , 40436 3800 24 during during IN 40436 3800 25 a a DT 40436 3800 26 dangerous dangerous JJ 40436 3800 27 storm storm NN 40436 3800 28 , , , 40436 3800 29 better well JJR 40436 3800 30 than than IN 40436 3800 31 the the DT 40436 3800 32 pilot pilot NN 40436 3800 33 ? ? . 40436 3801 1 Will Will MD 40436 3801 2 the the DT 40436 3801 3 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3801 4 know know VB 40436 3801 5 what what WP 40436 3801 6 is be VBZ 40436 3801 7 suitable suitable JJ 40436 3801 8 for for IN 40436 3801 9 one one CD 40436 3801 10 who who WP 40436 3801 11 gives give VBZ 40436 3801 12 directions direction NNS 40436 3801 13 about about IN 40436 3801 14 the the DT 40436 3801 15 treatment treatment NN 40436 3801 16 of of IN 40436 3801 17 a a DT 40436 3801 18 sick sick JJ 40436 3801 19 man man NN 40436 3801 20 , , , 40436 3801 21 better well JJR 40436 3801 22 than than IN 40436 3801 23 the the DT 40436 3801 24 physician physician NN 40436 3801 25 ? ? . 40436 3802 1 Will Will MD 40436 3802 2 the the DT 40436 3802 3 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3802 4 know know VB 40436 3802 5 what what WP 40436 3802 6 is be VBZ 40436 3802 7 suitable suitable JJ 40436 3802 8 to to TO 40436 3802 9 be be VB 40436 3802 10 said say VBN 40436 3802 11 by by IN 40436 3802 12 the the DT 40436 3802 13 herdsman herdsman NN 40436 3802 14 when when WRB 40436 3802 15 the the DT 40436 3802 16 cattle cattle NNS 40436 3802 17 are be VBP 40436 3802 18 savage savage JJ 40436 3802 19 and and CC 40436 3802 20 distracted distract VBD 40436 3802 21 , , , 40436 3802 22 or or CC 40436 3802 23 to to IN 40436 3802 24 the the DT 40436 3802 25 female female JJ 40436 3802 26 slaves slave NNS 40436 3802 27 when when WRB 40436 3802 28 busy busy JJ 40436 3802 29 in in IN 40436 3802 30 spinning spin VBG 40436 3802 31 ? ? . 40436 3803 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3803 2 Ion._--No Ion._--No NNP 40436 3803 3 : : : 40436 3803 4 the the DT 40436 3803 5 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3803 6 will will MD 40436 3803 7 not not RB 40436 3803 8 know know VB 40436 3803 9 these these DT 40436 3803 10 things thing NNS 40436 3803 11 so so RB 40436 3803 12 well well RB 40436 3803 13 as as IN 40436 3803 14 the the DT 40436 3803 15 pilot pilot NN 40436 3803 16 , , , 40436 3803 17 the the DT 40436 3803 18 physician physician NN 40436 3803 19 , , , 40436 3803 20 the the DT 40436 3803 21 grazier grazier NN 40436 3803 22 , , , 40436 3803 23 the the DT 40436 3803 24 mistress mistress NN 40436 3803 25 , , , 40436 3803 26 & & CC 40436 3803 27 c.[28 c.[28 NNP 40436 3803 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3803 29 _ _ NNP 40436 3803 30 Sokr._--Will Sokr._--Will NNP 40436 3803 31 the the DT 40436 3803 32 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3803 33 know know VB 40436 3803 34 what what WP 40436 3803 35 is be VBZ 40436 3803 36 suitable suitable JJ 40436 3803 37 for for IN 40436 3803 38 the the DT 40436 3803 39 military military JJ 40436 3803 40 commander commander NN 40436 3803 41 to to TO 40436 3803 42 say say VB 40436 3803 43 , , , 40436 3803 44 when when WRB 40436 3803 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3803 46 is be VBZ 40436 3803 47 exhorting exhort VBG 40436 3803 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3803 49 soldiers soldier NNS 40436 3803 50 ? ? . 40436 3804 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3804 2 Ion._--Yes Ion._--Yes NNP 40436 3804 3 : : : 40436 3804 4 the the DT 40436 3804 5 rhapsode rhapsode NNP 40436 3804 6 will will MD 40436 3804 7 know know VB 40436 3804 8 this this DT 40436 3804 9 well well NN 40436 3804 10 : : : 40436 3804 11 at at RB 40436 3804 12 least least JJS 40436 3804 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3804 14 know know VBP 40436 3804 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3804 16 well well RB 40436 3804 17 . . . 40436 3805 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3805 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3805 3 26 26 CD 40436 3805 4 : : : 40436 3805 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3805 6 , , , 40436 3805 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3805 8 , , , 40436 3805 9 538 538 CD 40436 3805 10 - - SYM 40436 3805 11 539 539 CD 40436 3805 12 . . . 40436 3805 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3806 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3806 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3806 3 27 27 CD 40436 3806 4 : : : 40436 3806 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3806 6 , , , 40436 3806 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3806 8 , , , 40436 3806 9 540 540 CD 40436 3806 10 A. a. NN 40436 3807 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3807 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3807 3 : : : 40436 3807 4 a)\ a)\ XX 40436 3807 5 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 3807 6 r(apsô|dô=| r(apsô|dô=| NNP 40436 3807 7 prosê prosê NNP 40436 3807 8 / / SYM 40436 3807 9 kei kei NNP 40436 3807 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3807 11 skopei skopei NNP 40436 3807 12 = = SYM 40436 3807 13 sthai sthai NNP 40436 3807 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3807 15 diakri diakri NNP 40436 3807 16 / / SYM 40436 3807 17 nein nein NNP 40436 3807 18 para\ para\ NNP 40436 3807 19 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 3807 20 a)/llous a)/llous JJ 40436 3807 21 a)nthrô a)nthrô CD 40436 3807 22 / / SYM 40436 3807 23 pous pous JJ 40436 3807 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3807 25 , , , 40436 3807 26 539 539 CD 40436 3807 27 E. E. NNP 40436 3807 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3807 29 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3807 30 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3807 31 28 28 CD 40436 3807 32 : : : 40436 3807 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3807 34 , , , 40436 3807 35 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3807 36 , , , 40436 3807 37 540 540 CD 40436 3807 38 B B NNP 40436 3807 39 - - HYPH 40436 3807 40 C. C. NNP 40436 3807 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3807 42 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3807 43 Side side NN 40436 3807 44 - - HYPH 40436 3807 45 note note NN 40436 3807 46 : : : 40436 3807 47 The the DT 40436 3807 48 Rhapsode Rhapsode NNP 40436 3807 49 does do VBZ 40436 3807 50 not not RB 40436 3807 51 know know VB 40436 3807 52 special special JJ 40436 3807 53 matters matter NNS 40436 3807 54 , , , 40436 3807 55 such such JJ 40436 3807 56 as as IN 40436 3807 57 the the DT 40436 3807 58 craft craft NN 40436 3807 59 of of IN 40436 3807 60 the the DT 40436 3807 61 pilot pilot NN 40436 3807 62 , , , 40436 3807 63 physician physician NN 40436 3807 64 , , , 40436 3807 65 farmer farmer NN 40436 3807 66 , , , 40436 3807 67 & & CC 40436 3807 68 c. c. NNP 40436 3807 69 , , , 40436 3807 70 but but CC 40436 3807 71 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3807 72 knows know VBZ 40436 3807 73 the the DT 40436 3807 74 business business NN 40436 3807 75 of of IN 40436 3807 76 the the DT 40436 3807 77 general general NN 40436 3807 78 , , , 40436 3807 79 and and CC 40436 3807 80 is be VBZ 40436 3807 81 competent competent JJ 40436 3807 82 to to TO 40436 3807 83 command command NN 40436 3807 84 soldiers soldier NNS 40436 3807 85 , , , 40436 3807 86 having have VBG 40436 3807 87 learnt learn VBN 40436 3807 88 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3807 89 from from IN 40436 3807 90 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3807 91 . . . 40436 3807 92 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3808 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3808 2 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 3808 3 , , , 40436 3808 4 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3808 5 , , , 40436 3808 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3808 7 are be VBP 40436 3808 8 not not RB 40436 3808 9 merely merely RB 40436 3808 10 a a DT 40436 3808 11 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3808 12 , , , 40436 3808 13 but but CC 40436 3808 14 possess possess VB 40436 3808 15 also also RB 40436 3808 16 the the DT 40436 3808 17 competence competence NN 40436 3808 18 for for IN 40436 3808 19 being be VBG 40436 3808 20 a a DT 40436 3808 21 general general NN 40436 3808 22 . . . 40436 3809 1 If if IN 40436 3809 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3809 3 know know VBP 40436 3809 4 matters matter NNS 40436 3809 5 belonging belong VBG 40436 3809 6 to to IN 40436 3809 7 military military JJ 40436 3809 8 command command NN 40436 3809 9 , , , 40436 3809 10 do do VBP 40436 3809 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3809 12 know know VB 40436 3809 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3809 14 in in IN 40436 3809 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3809 16 capacity capacity NN 40436 3809 17 of of IN 40436 3809 18 general general JJ 40436 3809 19 , , , 40436 3809 20 or or CC 40436 3809 21 in in IN 40436 3809 22 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3809 23 capacity capacity NN 40436 3809 24 of of IN 40436 3809 25 rhapsode rhapsode NNP 40436 3809 26 ? ? . 40436 3810 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3810 2 Ion._--I Ion._--I NNS 40436 3810 3 think think VBP 40436 3810 4 there there EX 40436 3810 5 is be VBZ 40436 3810 6 no no DT 40436 3810 7 difference difference NN 40436 3810 8 . . . 40436 3811 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3811 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 3811 3 say say VBP 40436 3811 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3811 5 ? ? . 40436 3812 1 Do do VBP 40436 3812 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3812 3 affirm affirm VB 40436 3812 4 that that IN 40436 3812 5 the the DT 40436 3812 6 rhapsodic rhapsodic JJ 40436 3812 7 art art NN 40436 3812 8 , , , 40436 3812 9 and and CC 40436 3812 10 the the DT 40436 3812 11 strategic strategic JJ 40436 3812 12 art art NN 40436 3812 13 , , , 40436 3812 14 are be VBP 40436 3812 15 one one CD 40436 3812 16 ? ? . 40436 3813 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3813 2 Ion._--I Ion._--I NNS 40436 3813 3 think think VBP 40436 3813 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3813 5 are be VBP 40436 3813 6 one one CD 40436 3813 7 . . . 40436 3814 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3814 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 3814 3 whosoever whosoever NN 40436 3814 4 is be VBZ 40436 3814 5 a a DT 40436 3814 6 good good JJ 40436 3814 7 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3814 8 , , , 40436 3814 9 is be VBZ 40436 3814 10 also also RB 40436 3814 11 a a DT 40436 3814 12 good good JJ 40436 3814 13 general general NN 40436 3814 14 ? ? . 40436 3815 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3815 2 Ion._--Unquestionably Ion._--Unquestionably NNP 40436 3815 3 . . . 40436 3816 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3816 2 Sokr._--And Sokr._--And NNP 40436 3816 3 of of IN 40436 3816 4 course course NN 40436 3816 5 , , , 40436 3816 6 whoever whoever WP 40436 3816 7 is be VBZ 40436 3816 8 a a DT 40436 3816 9 good good JJ 40436 3816 10 general general NN 40436 3816 11 , , , 40436 3816 12 is be VBZ 40436 3816 13 also also RB 40436 3816 14 a a DT 40436 3816 15 good good JJ 40436 3816 16 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3816 17 ? ? . 40436 3817 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3817 2 Ion._--No Ion._--No NNP 40436 3817 3 : : : 40436 3817 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3817 5 do do VBP 40436 3817 6 not not RB 40436 3817 7 think think VB 40436 3817 8 that that DT 40436 3817 9 . . . 40436 3818 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3818 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 3818 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3818 4 do do VBP 40436 3818 5 maintain maintain VB 40436 3818 6 , , , 40436 3818 7 that that IN 40436 3818 8 whosoever whosoever NN 40436 3818 9 is be VBZ 40436 3818 10 a a DT 40436 3818 11 good good JJ 40436 3818 12 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3818 13 , , , 40436 3818 14 is be VBZ 40436 3818 15 also also RB 40436 3818 16 a a DT 40436 3818 17 good good JJ 40436 3818 18 general general NN 40436 3818 19 ? ? . 40436 3819 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3819 2 Ion._--Decidedly Ion._--Decidedly , 40436 3819 3 . . . 40436 3820 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3820 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 3820 3 are be VBP 40436 3820 4 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 3820 5 the the DT 40436 3820 6 best good JJS 40436 3820 7 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3820 8 in in IN 40436 3820 9 Greece Greece NNP 40436 3820 10 ? ? . 40436 3821 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3821 2 Ion._--By Ion._--By NNP 40436 3821 3 far far RB 40436 3821 4 . . . 40436 3822 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3822 2 Sokr._--Are Sokr._--Are NNP 40436 3822 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3822 4 then then RB 40436 3822 5 also also RB 40436 3822 6 the the DT 40436 3822 7 best good JJS 40436 3822 8 general general NN 40436 3822 9 in in IN 40436 3822 10 Greece Greece NNP 40436 3822 11 ? ? . 40436 3823 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3823 2 Ion._--Certainly Ion._--Certainly , 40436 3823 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3823 4 am be VBP 40436 3823 5 , , , 40436 3823 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3823 7 : : : 40436 3823 8 and and CC 40436 3823 9 that that IN 40436 3823 10 too too RB 40436 3823 11 , , , 40436 3823 12 by by IN 40436 3823 13 having have VBG 40436 3823 14 learnt learn VBN 40436 3823 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3823 16 from from IN 40436 3823 17 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3823 18 . . . 40436 3824 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3824 2 29 29 CD 40436 3824 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3824 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3824 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3824 6 29 29 CD 40436 3824 7 : : : 40436 3824 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3824 9 , , , 40436 3824 10 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3824 11 , , , 40436 3824 12 540 540 CD 40436 3824 13 D--541 D--541 NNP 40436 3824 14 B. B. NNP 40436 3824 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3825 1 After after IN 40436 3825 2 putting put VBG 40436 3825 3 a a DT 40436 3825 4 question question NN 40436 3825 5 or or CC 40436 3825 6 two two CD 40436 3825 7 , , , 40436 3825 8 not not RB 40436 3825 9 very very RB 40436 3825 10 forcible forcible JJ 40436 3825 11 , , , 40436 3825 12 to to TO 40436 3825 13 ask ask VB 40436 3825 14 how how WRB 40436 3825 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3825 16 happens happen VBZ 40436 3825 17 that that IN 40436 3825 18 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3825 19 , , , 40436 3825 20 being be VBG 40436 3825 21 an an DT 40436 3825 22 excellent excellent JJ 40436 3825 23 general general NN 40436 3825 24 , , , 40436 3825 25 does do VBZ 40436 3825 26 not not RB 40436 3825 27 obtain obtain VB 40436 3825 28 a a DT 40436 3825 29 military military JJ 40436 3825 30 appointment appointment NN 40436 3825 31 from from IN 40436 3825 32 Athens Athens NNP 40436 3825 33 , , , 40436 3825 34 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 3825 35 , , , 40436 3825 36 or or CC 40436 3825 37 some some DT 40436 3825 38 other other JJ 40436 3825 39 city city NN 40436 3825 40 , , , 40436 3825 41 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3825 42 winds wind VBZ 40436 3825 43 up up RP 40436 3825 44 the the DT 40436 3825 45 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3825 46 as as IN 40436 3825 47 follows:-- follows:-- ADD 40436 3825 48 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3825 49 Side side NN 40436 3825 50 - - HYPH 40436 3825 51 note note NN 40436 3825 52 : : : 40436 3825 53 Conclusion conclusion NN 40436 3825 54 . . . 40436 3826 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3826 2 expounds expound NNS 40436 3826 3 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3826 4 , , , 40436 3826 5 not not RB 40436 3826 6 with with IN 40436 3826 7 any any DT 40436 3826 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3826 9 of of IN 40436 3826 10 what what WP 40436 3826 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3826 12 says say VBZ 40436 3826 13 , , , 40436 3826 14 but but CC 40436 3826 15 by by IN 40436 3826 16 divine divine JJ 40436 3826 17 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3826 18 . . . 40436 3826 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3827 1 Well well UH 40436 3827 2 , , , 40436 3827 3 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3827 4 , , , 40436 3827 5 if if IN 40436 3827 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3827 7 be be VB 40436 3827 8 really really RB 40436 3827 9 true true JJ 40436 3827 10 that that IN 40436 3827 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3827 12 possess possess VBP 40436 3827 13 a a DT 40436 3827 14 rational rational JJ 40436 3827 15 and and CC 40436 3827 16 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 3827 17 competence competence NN 40436 3827 18 to to TO 40436 3827 19 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 3827 20 the the DT 40436 3827 21 beauties beauty NNS 40436 3827 22 of of IN 40436 3827 23 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3827 24 , , , 40436 3827 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3827 26 wrong wrong VBP 40436 3827 27 and and CC 40436 3827 28 deceive deceive VB 40436 3827 29 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3827 30 , , , 40436 3827 31 because because IN 40436 3827 32 after after IN 40436 3827 33 promising promise VBG 40436 3827 34 to to TO 40436 3827 35 deliver deliver VB 40436 3827 36 to to IN 40436 3827 37 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3827 38 a a DT 40436 3827 39 fine fine JJ 40436 3827 40 discourse discourse NN 40436 3827 41 about about IN 40436 3827 42 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3827 43 , , , 40436 3827 44 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3827 45 will will MD 40436 3827 46 not not RB 40436 3827 47 even even RB 40436 3827 48 comply comply VB 40436 3827 49 with with IN 40436 3827 50 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3827 51 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 3827 52 entreaty entreaty NN 40436 3827 53 -- -- : 40436 3827 54 that that IN 40436 3827 55 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3827 56 will will MD 40436 3827 57 first first RB 40436 3827 58 tell tell VB 40436 3827 59 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3827 60 what what WP 40436 3827 61 those those DT 40436 3827 62 matters matter NNS 40436 3827 63 are be VBP 40436 3827 64 , , , 40436 3827 65 on on IN 40436 3827 66 which which WDT 40436 3827 67 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3827 68 superiority superiority NN 40436 3827 69 bears bear VBZ 40436 3827 70 . . . 40436 3828 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 3828 2 twist twist VBP 40436 3828 3 every every DT 40436 3828 4 way way NN 40436 3828 5 like like IN 40436 3828 6 Proteus Proteus NNP 40436 3828 7 , , , 40436 3828 8 until until IN 40436 3828 9 at at IN 40436 3828 10 last last RB 40436 3828 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3828 12 slip slip VBP 40436 3828 13 through through IN 40436 3828 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3828 15 fingers finger NNS 40436 3828 16 and and CC 40436 3828 17 appear appear VB 40436 3828 18 as as IN 40436 3828 19 a a DT 40436 3828 20 general general NN 40436 3828 21 . . . 40436 3829 1 If if IN 40436 3829 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3829 3 powers power NNS 40436 3829 4 of of IN 40436 3829 5 expounding expound VBG 40436 3829 6 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3829 7 depend depend VB 40436 3829 8 on on IN 40436 3829 9 art art NN 40436 3829 10 and and CC 40436 3829 11 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3829 12 , , , 40436 3829 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3829 14 are be VBP 40436 3829 15 a a DT 40436 3829 16 wrong wrong JJ 40436 3829 17 - - HYPH 40436 3829 18 doer doer NN 40436 3829 19 and and CC 40436 3829 20 deceiver deceiver NNP 40436 3829 21 , , , 40436 3829 22 for for IN 40436 3829 23 not not RB 40436 3829 24 fulfilling fulfil VBG 40436 3829 25 * * NFP 40436 3829 26 * * NFP 40436 3829 27 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3829 28 promise promise NN 40436 3829 29 to to IN 40436 3829 30 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3829 31 . . . 40436 3830 1 But but CC 40436 3830 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3830 3 are be VBP 40436 3830 4 not not RB 40436 3830 5 chargeable chargeable JJ 40436 3830 6 with with IN 40436 3830 7 wrong wrong NN 40436 3830 8 , , , 40436 3830 9 if if IN 40436 3830 10 the the DT 40436 3830 11 fact fact NN 40436 3830 12 be be VBP 40436 3830 13 as as IN 40436 3830 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3830 15 say say VBP 40436 3830 16 ; ; : 40436 3830 17 that that RB 40436 3830 18 is is RB 40436 3830 19 , , , 40436 3830 20 if if IN 40436 3830 21 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3830 22 know know VBP 40436 3830 23 nothing nothing NN 40436 3830 24 about about IN 40436 3830 25 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3830 26 , , , 40436 3830 27 but but CC 40436 3830 28 are be VBP 40436 3830 29 only only RB 40436 3830 30 able able JJ 40436 3830 31 to to TO 40436 3830 32 discourse discourse VB 40436 3830 33 upon upon IN 40436 3830 34 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3830 35 finely finely RB 40436 3830 36 and and CC 40436 3830 37 abundantly abundantly RB 40436 3830 38 , , , 40436 3830 39 through through IN 40436 3830 40 a a DT 40436 3830 41 divine divine JJ 40436 3830 42 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3830 43 with with IN 40436 3830 44 which which WDT 40436 3830 45 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3830 46 are be VBP 40436 3830 47 possessed possess VBN 40436 3830 48 by by IN 40436 3830 49 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3830 50 . . . 40436 3831 1 Choose choose VB 40436 3831 2 whether whether IN 40436 3831 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3831 4 wish wish VBP 40436 3831 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3831 6 to to TO 40436 3831 7 regard regard VB 40436 3831 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3831 9 as as IN 40436 3831 10 a a DT 40436 3831 11 promise promise NN 40436 3831 12 - - HYPH 40436 3831 13 breaker breaker NN 40436 3831 14 , , , 40436 3831 15 or or CC 40436 3831 16 as as IN 40436 3831 17 a a DT 40436 3831 18 divine divine JJ 40436 3831 19 man man NN 40436 3831 20 . . . 40436 3832 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3832 2 Ion._--I Ion._--I NNS 40436 3832 3 choose choose VB 40436 3832 4 the the DT 40436 3832 5 last last JJ 40436 3832 6 : : : 40436 3832 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3832 8 is be VBZ 40436 3832 9 much much RB 40436 3832 10 better well JJR 40436 3832 11 to to TO 40436 3832 12 be be VB 40436 3832 13 regarded regard VBN 40436 3832 14 as as IN 40436 3832 15 a a DT 40436 3832 16 divine divine JJ 40436 3832 17 man man NN 40436 3832 18 . . . 40436 3833 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3833 2 30 30 CD 40436 3833 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3833 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3833 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3833 6 30 30 CD 40436 3833 7 : : : 40436 3833 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3833 9 , , , 40436 3833 10 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3833 11 , , , 40436 3833 12 541 541 CD 40436 3833 13 E--542 e--542 CD 40436 3833 14 A. a. NN 40436 3834 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3834 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3834 3 : : : 40436 3834 4 ei ei NNP 40436 3834 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3834 6 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3834 7 a)lêthê/ a)lêthê/ NNP 40436 3834 8 le le NNP 40436 3834 9 / / SYM 40436 3834 10 geis geis NNP 40436 3834 11 , , , 40436 3834 12 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3834 13 te te NNP 40436 3834 14 / / SYM 40436 3834 15 chnê| chnê| NNP 40436 3834 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3834 17 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 3834 18 / / SYM 40436 3834 19 mê| mê| NNP 40436 3834 20 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 3834 21 / / SYM 40436 3834 22 s s NNP 40436 3834 23 te te NNP 40436 3834 24 ei)= ei)= NNP 40436 3834 25 O(/mêrou O(/mêrou NNP 40436 3834 26 e)painei e)painei NNP 40436 3834 27 = = SYM 40436 3834 28 n n XX 40436 3834 29 , , , 40436 3834 30 a)dikei a)dikei NNP 40436 3834 31 = = SYM 40436 3834 32 s s NN 40436 3834 33 . . . 40436 3835 1 . . . 40436 3836 1 . . . 40436 3837 1 ei ei NNP 40436 3837 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3837 3 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3837 4 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 3837 5 techniko\s techniko\s -LRB- 40436 3837 6 ei)= ei)= NNS 40436 3837 7 , , , 40436 3837 8 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 3837 9 thei thei NNP 40436 3837 10 / / SYM 40436 3837 11 a| a| NNP 40436 3837 12 moi moi NNP 40436 3837 13 / / SYM 40436 3837 14 ra| ra| NNP 40436 3837 15 katecho katecho NNP 40436 3837 16 / / SYM 40436 3837 17 menos menos NNP 40436 3837 18 e)x e)x NNP 40436 3837 19 O(mê O(mê NNS 40436 3837 20 / / SYM 40436 3837 21 rou rou NN 40436 3837 22 mêde\n mêde\n ADD 40436 3837 23 ei)dô\s ei)dô\s NNP 40436 3837 24 polla\ polla\ NNP 40436 3837 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3837 26 kala\ kala\ NNP 40436 3837 27 le le NNP 40436 3837 28 / / SYM 40436 3837 29 geis geis NNP 40436 3837 30 peri\ peri\ . 40436 3837 31 tou= tou= JJ 40436 3837 32 poiêtou= poiêtou= NN 40436 3837 33 , , , 40436 3837 34 ô(/sper ô(/sper NN 40436 3837 35 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 3837 36 ei)=pon ei)=pon CD 40436 3837 37 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 3837 38 sou= sou= NNP 40436 3837 39 , , , 40436 3837 40 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 3837 41 a)dikei a)dikei NNPS 40436 3837 42 = = SYM 40436 3837 43 s s XX 40436 3837 44 ; ; : 40436 3837 45 e(lou= e(lou= NN 40436 3837 46 ou)=n ou)=n CD 40436 3837 47 , , , 40436 3837 48 po po NN 40436 3837 49 / / SYM 40436 3837 50 tera tera NNP 40436 3837 51 bou bou NN 40436 3837 52 / / SYM 40436 3837 53 lei lei NNP 40436 3837 54 nomi nomi NNP 40436 3837 55 / / SYM 40436 3837 56 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 3837 57 u(ph u(ph NNP 40436 3837 58 ' ' '' 40436 3837 59 ê(mô ê(mô NNP 40436 3837 60 = = SYM 40436 3837 61 n n NN 40436 3837 62 a)/dikos a)/dikos NNPS 40436 3837 63 a)nê\r a)nê\r NNP 40436 3837 64 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 3837 65 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 3837 66 thei thei NNP 40436 3837 67 = = SYM 40436 3837 68 os os NNP 40436 3837 69 . . . 40436 3837 70 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3837 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3838 1 * * NFP 40436 3838 2 * * NFP 40436 3838 3 * * NFP 40436 3838 4 * * NFP 40436 3838 5 * * NFP 40436 3838 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3838 7 Side side NN 40436 3838 8 - - HYPH 40436 3838 9 note note NN 40436 3838 10 : : : 40436 3838 11 The the DT 40436 3838 12 generals general NNS 40436 3838 13 in in IN 40436 3838 14 Greece Greece NNP 40436 3838 15 usually usually RB 40436 3838 16 possessed possess VBD 40436 3838 17 no no DT 40436 3838 18 professional professional JJ 40436 3838 19 experience experience NN 40436 3838 20 -- -- : 40436 3838 21 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3838 22 and and CC 40436 3838 23 the the DT 40436 3838 24 poets poet NNS 40436 3838 25 were be VBD 40436 3838 26 talked talk VBN 40436 3838 27 of of IN 40436 3838 28 as as IN 40436 3838 29 the the DT 40436 3838 30 great great JJ 40436 3838 31 teachers teacher NNS 40436 3838 32 -- -- : 40436 3838 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3838 34 's 's POS 40436 3838 35 view view NN 40436 3838 36 of of IN 40436 3838 37 the the DT 40436 3838 38 poet poet NN 40436 3838 39 , , , 40436 3838 40 as as IN 40436 3838 41 pretending pretend VBG 40436 3838 42 to to TO 40436 3838 43 know know VB 40436 3838 44 everything everything NN 40436 3838 45 , , , 40436 3838 46 but but CC 40436 3838 47 really really RB 40436 3838 48 knowing know VBG 40436 3838 49 nothing nothing NN 40436 3838 50 . . . 40436 3838 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3839 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3839 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 3839 3 strange strange JJ 40436 3839 4 to to TO 40436 3839 5 read read VB 40436 3839 6 such such JJ 40436 3839 7 language language NN 40436 3839 8 put put VBN 40436 3839 9 into into IN 40436 3839 10 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3839 11 's 's POS 40436 3839 12 mouth mouth NN 40436 3839 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3839 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3839 15 are be VBP 40436 3839 16 not not RB 40436 3839 17 warranted warrant VBN 40436 3839 18 in in IN 40436 3839 19 regarding regard VBG 40436 3839 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3839 21 as as IN 40436 3839 22 what what WP 40436 3839 23 any any DT 40436 3839 24 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3839 25 ever ever RB 40436 3839 26 did do VBD 40436 3839 27 say say VB 40436 3839 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3839 29 , , , 40436 3839 30 as as IN 40436 3839 31 the the DT 40436 3839 32 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 3839 33 -- -- : 40436 3839 34 that that IN 40436 3839 35 every every DT 40436 3839 36 good good JJ 40436 3839 37 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3839 38 was be VBD 40436 3839 39 also also RB 40436 3839 40 a a DT 40436 3839 41 good good JJ 40436 3839 42 general general NN 40436 3839 43 , , , 40436 3839 44 and and CC 40436 3839 45 that that IN 40436 3839 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3839 47 had have VBD 40436 3839 48 become become VBN 40436 3839 49 the the DT 40436 3839 50 best good JJS 40436 3839 51 of of IN 40436 3839 52 generals general NNS 40436 3839 53 simply simply RB 40436 3839 54 through through IN 40436 3839 55 complete complete JJ 40436 3839 56 acquaintance acquaintance NN 40436 3839 57 with with IN 40436 3839 58 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3839 59 . . . 40436 3840 1 But but CC 40436 3840 2 this this DT 40436 3840 3 is be VBZ 40436 3840 4 only only RB 40436 3840 5 a a DT 40436 3840 6 caricature caricature NN 40436 3840 7 of of IN 40436 3840 8 a a DT 40436 3840 9 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 3840 10 largely largely RB 40436 3840 11 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 3840 12 at at IN 40436 3840 13 Athens Athens NNP 40436 3840 14 , , , 40436 3840 15 according accord VBG 40436 3840 16 to to IN 40436 3840 17 which which WDT 40436 3840 18 the the DT 40436 3840 19 works work NNS 40436 3840 20 of of IN 40436 3840 21 the the DT 40436 3840 22 poets poet NNS 40436 3840 23 , , , 40436 3840 24 especially especially RB 40436 3840 25 the the DT 40436 3840 26 Homeric Homeric NNP 40436 3840 27 poems poem NNS 40436 3840 28 , , , 40436 3840 29 were be VBD 40436 3840 30 supposed suppose VBN 40436 3840 31 to to TO 40436 3840 32 be be VB 40436 3840 33 a a DT 40436 3840 34 mine mine NN 40436 3840 35 of of IN 40436 3840 36 varied varied JJ 40436 3840 37 instruction instruction NN 40436 3840 38 , , , 40436 3840 39 and and CC 40436 3840 40 were be VBD 40436 3840 41 taught teach VBN 40436 3840 42 as as IN 40436 3840 43 such such JJ 40436 3840 44 to to IN 40436 3840 45 youth youth NN 40436 3840 46 . . . 40436 3841 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3841 2 31 31 CD 40436 3841 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3841 4 In in IN 40436 3841 5 Greece Greece NNP 40436 3841 6 , , , 40436 3841 7 the the DT 40436 3841 8 general general NN 40436 3841 9 was be VBD 40436 3841 10 not not RB 40436 3841 11 often often RB 40436 3841 12 required require VBN 40436 3841 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3841 14 except except IN 40436 3841 15 at at IN 40436 3841 16 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 3841 17 , , , 40436 3841 18 and and CC 40436 3841 19 not not RB 40436 3841 20 always always RB 40436 3841 21 even even RB 40436 3841 22 there there RB 40436 3841 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3841 24 to to TO 40436 3841 25 possess possess VB 40436 3841 26 professional professional JJ 40436 3841 27 experience experience NN 40436 3841 28 . . . 40436 3842 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3842 2 32 32 CD 40436 3842 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3842 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3842 5 , , , 40436 3842 6 in in IN 40436 3842 7 one one CD 40436 3842 8 of of IN 40436 3842 9 the the DT 40436 3842 10 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 3842 11 conversations conversation NNS 40436 3842 12 , , , 40436 3842 13 tries try VBZ 40436 3842 14 to to TO 40436 3842 15 persuade persuade VB 40436 3842 16 Nikomachides Nikomachides NNP 40436 3842 17 , , , 40436 3842 18 a a DT 40436 3842 19 practised practise VBN 40436 3842 20 soldier soldier NN 40436 3842 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3842 22 who who WP 40436 3842 23 had have VBD 40436 3842 24 failed fail VBN 40436 3842 25 in in IN 40436 3842 26 getting get VBG 40436 3842 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3842 28 elected elect VBN 40436 3842 29 general general JJ 40436 3842 30 , , , 40436 3842 31 because because IN 40436 3842 32 a a DT 40436 3842 33 successful successful JJ 40436 3842 34 Chorêgus chorêgus NN 40436 3842 35 had have VBD 40436 3842 36 been be VBN 40436 3842 37 preferred prefer VBN 40436 3842 38 to to IN 40436 3842 39 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3842 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3842 41 , , , 40436 3842 42 how how WRB 40436 3842 43 much much JJ 40436 3842 44 the the DT 40436 3842 45 qualities quality NNS 40436 3842 46 of of IN 40436 3842 47 an an DT 40436 3842 48 effective effective JJ 40436 3842 49 Chorêgus Chorêgus NNP 40436 3842 50 coincided coincide VBN 40436 3842 51 with with IN 40436 3842 52 those those DT 40436 3842 53 of of IN 40436 3842 54 an an DT 40436 3842 55 effective effective JJ 40436 3842 56 general general NN 40436 3842 57 . . . 40436 3843 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3843 2 33 33 CD 40436 3843 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3843 4 The the DT 40436 3843 5 poet poet NN 40436 3843 6 Sophokles Sophokles NNPS 40436 3843 7 was be VBD 40436 3843 8 named name VBN 40436 3843 9 by by IN 40436 3843 10 the the DT 40436 3843 11 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 3843 12 one one CD 40436 3843 13 of of IN 40436 3843 14 the the DT 40436 3843 15 generals general NNS 40436 3843 16 of of IN 40436 3843 17 the the DT 40436 3843 18 very very RB 40436 3843 19 important important JJ 40436 3843 20 armament armament NN 40436 3843 21 for for IN 40436 3843 22 reconquering reconquer VBG 40436 3843 23 Samos Samos NNP 40436 3843 24 : : : 40436 3843 25 though though IN 40436 3843 26 Perikles Perikles NNP 40436 3843 27 , , , 40436 3843 28 one one CD 40436 3843 29 of of IN 40436 3843 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3843 31 colleagues colleague NNS 40436 3843 32 , , , 40436 3843 33 as as RB 40436 3843 34 well well RB 40436 3843 35 as as IN 40436 3843 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3843 37 contemporary contemporary NN 40436 3843 38 declared declare VBD 40436 3843 39 that that IN 40436 3843 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3843 41 was be VBD 40436 3843 42 an an DT 40436 3843 43 excellent excellent JJ 40436 3843 44 poet poet NN 40436 3843 45 , , , 40436 3843 46 but but CC 40436 3843 47 knew know VBD 40436 3843 48 nothing nothing NN 40436 3843 49 of of IN 40436 3843 50 generalship generalship NN 40436 3843 51 . . . 40436 3844 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3844 2 34 34 CD 40436 3844 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3844 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3844 5 frequently frequently RB 40436 3844 6 seeks seek VBZ 40436 3844 7 to to TO 40436 3844 8 make make VB 40436 3844 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3844 10 evident evident JJ 40436 3844 11 how how WRB 40436 3844 12 little little JJ 40436 3844 13 the the DT 40436 3844 14 qualities quality NNS 40436 3844 15 required require VBN 40436 3844 16 for for IN 40436 3844 17 governing govern VBG 40436 3844 18 numbers number NNS 40436 3844 19 , , , 40436 3844 20 either either CC 40436 3844 21 civil civil JJ 40436 3844 22 or or CC 40436 3844 23 military military JJ 40436 3844 24 , , , 40436 3844 25 were be VBD 40436 3844 26 made make VBN 40436 3844 27 matter matter NN 40436 3844 28 of of IN 40436 3844 29 professional professional JJ 40436 3844 30 study study NN 40436 3844 31 or or CC 40436 3844 32 special special JJ 40436 3844 33 teaching teaching NN 40436 3844 34 . . . 40436 3845 1 The the DT 40436 3845 2 picture picture NN 40436 3845 3 of of IN 40436 3845 4 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3845 5 conveyed convey VBN 40436 3845 6 in in IN 40436 3845 7 the the DT 40436 3845 8 tenth tenth JJ 40436 3845 9 book book NN 40436 3845 10 of of IN 40436 3845 11 the the DT 40436 3845 12 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3845 13 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3845 14 is be VBZ 40436 3845 15 , , , 40436 3845 16 that that DT 40436 3845 17 of of IN 40436 3845 18 a a DT 40436 3845 19 man man NN 40436 3845 20 who who WP 40436 3845 21 pretends pretend VBZ 40436 3845 22 to to TO 40436 3845 23 know know VB 40436 3845 24 everything everything NN 40436 3845 25 , , , 40436 3845 26 but but CC 40436 3845 27 really really RB 40436 3845 28 knows know VBZ 40436 3845 29 nothing nothing NN 40436 3845 30 : : : 40436 3845 31 an an DT 40436 3845 32 imitative imitative JJ 40436 3845 33 artist artist NN 40436 3845 34 , , , 40436 3845 35 removed remove VBN 40436 3845 36 by by IN 40436 3845 37 two two CD 40436 3845 38 stages stage NNS 40436 3845 39 from from IN 40436 3845 40 truth truth NN 40436 3845 41 and and CC 40436 3845 42 reality,--who reality,--who NNP 40436 3845 43 gives give VBZ 40436 3845 44 the the DT 40436 3845 45 shadows shadow NNS 40436 3845 46 of of IN 40436 3845 47 shadows shadow NNS 40436 3845 48 , , , 40436 3845 49 resembling resemble VBG 40436 3845 50 only only RB 40436 3845 51 enough enough RB 40436 3845 52 to to TO 40436 3845 53 satisfy satisfy VB 40436 3845 54 an an DT 40436 3845 55 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 3845 56 crowd crowd NN 40436 3845 57 . . . 40436 3846 1 This this DT 40436 3846 2 is be VBZ 40436 3846 3 the the DT 40436 3846 4 picture picture NN 40436 3846 5 there there RB 40436 3846 6 presented present VBN 40436 3846 7 of of IN 40436 3846 8 poets poet NNS 40436 3846 9 generally generally RB 40436 3846 10 , , , 40436 3846 11 and and CC 40436 3846 12 of of IN 40436 3846 13 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3846 14 as as IN 40436 3846 15 the the DT 40436 3846 16 best good JJS 40436 3846 17 among among IN 40436 3846 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3846 19 . . . 40436 3847 1 The the DT 40436 3847 2 rhapsode rhapsode NN 40436 3847 3 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3847 4 is be VBZ 40436 3847 5 here here RB 40436 3847 6 brought bring VBN 40436 3847 7 under under IN 40436 3847 8 the the DT 40436 3847 9 same same JJ 40436 3847 10 category category NN 40436 3847 11 as as IN 40436 3847 12 the the DT 40436 3847 13 poet poet NN 40436 3847 14 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3847 15 , , , 40436 3847 16 whom whom WP 40436 3847 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3847 18 has have VBZ 40436 3847 19 by by IN 40436 3847 20 heart heart NN 40436 3847 21 and and CC 40436 3847 22 recites recite NNS 40436 3847 23 . . . 40436 3848 1 The the DT 40436 3848 2 whole whole JJ 40436 3848 3 field field NN 40436 3848 4 of of IN 40436 3848 5 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3848 6 is be VBZ 40436 3848 7 assumed assume VBN 40436 3848 8 to to TO 40436 3848 9 be be VB 40436 3848 10 distributed distribute VBN 40436 3848 11 among among IN 40436 3848 12 various various JJ 40436 3848 13 specialties specialty NNS 40436 3848 14 , , , 40436 3848 15 not not RB 40436 3848 16 one one CD 40436 3848 17 of of IN 40436 3848 18 which which WDT 40436 3848 19 either either DT 40436 3848 20 of of IN 40436 3848 21 the the DT 40436 3848 22 two two CD 40436 3848 23 can can MD 40436 3848 24 claim claim VB 40436 3848 25 . . . 40436 3849 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 3849 2 , , , 40436 3849 3 both both DT 40436 3849 4 of of IN 40436 3849 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3849 6 under under IN 40436 3849 7 the the DT 40436 3849 8 mask mask NN 40436 3849 9 of of IN 40436 3849 10 universal universal JJ 40436 3849 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3849 12 , , , 40436 3849 13 conceal conceal VB 40436 3849 14 the the DT 40436 3849 15 reality reality NN 40436 3849 16 of of IN 40436 3849 17 universal universal JJ 40436 3849 18 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 3849 19 . . . 40436 3850 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3850 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3850 3 31 31 CD 40436 3850 4 : : : 40436 3850 5 Aristophan Aristophan NNP 40436 3850 6 . . . 40436 3851 1 Ranæ Ranæ NNP 40436 3851 2 , , , 40436 3851 3 1032 1032 CD 40436 3851 4 . . . 40436 3852 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3852 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3852 3 : : : 40436 3852 4 O)rpheu\s O)rpheu\s NNP 40436 3852 5 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3852 6 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3852 7 teleta teleta NN 40436 3852 8 / / SYM 40436 3852 9 s s NN 40436 3852 10 th th XX 40436 3852 11 ' ' '' 40436 3852 12 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 3852 13 = = SYM 40436 3852 14 n n CC 40436 3852 15 kate kate NNP 40436 3852 16 / / SYM 40436 3852 17 deixe deixe NNP 40436 3852 18 pho pho NNP 40436 3852 19 / / SYM 40436 3852 20 nôn nôn NNP 40436 3852 21 t t NNP 40436 3852 22 ' ' '' 40436 3852 23 a)pe a)pe NNP 40436 3852 24 / / SYM 40436 3852 25 chesthai chesthai NNP 40436 3852 26 Mousai Mousai NNP 40436 3852 27 = = SYM 40436 3852 28 os os NNP 40436 3852 29 d d NNP 40436 3852 30 ' ' POS 40436 3852 31 e)xake e)xake NNP 40436 3852 32 / / SYM 40436 3852 33 seis seis NNP 40436 3852 34 te te NNP 40436 3852 35 no no NNP 40436 3852 36 / / SYM 40436 3852 37 sôn sôn NNP 40436 3852 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3852 39 chrêsmou chrêsmou NNP 40436 3852 40 / / SYM 40436 3852 41 s s NNPS 40436 3852 42 , , , 40436 3852 43 Ê(si ê(si NN 40436 3852 44 / / SYM 40436 3852 45 odos odo NNS 40436 3852 46 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3852 47 Gê Gê NNP 40436 3852 48 = = SYM 40436 3852 49 s s NNP 40436 3852 50 e)rgasi e)rgasi NNP 40436 3852 51 / / SYM 40436 3852 52 as as IN 40436 3852 53 , , , 40436 3852 54 karpô karpô NNP 40436 3852 55 = = SYM 40436 3852 56 n n CC 40436 3852 57 ô(/ras ô(/ras NNP 40436 3852 58 , , , 40436 3852 59 a)ro a)ro JJ 40436 3852 60 / / SYM 40436 3852 61 tous tous JJ 40436 3852 62 ; ; : 40436 3852 63 o o NN 40436 3852 64 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3852 65 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3852 66 thei thei NNP 40436 3852 67 = = SYM 40436 3852 68 os os VBP 40436 3852 69 O(/mêros O(/mêros NNP 40436 3852 70 A)po\ A)po\ NNP 40436 3852 71 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3852 72 timê\n timê\n -LRB- 40436 3852 73 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3852 74 kle kle NNP 40436 3852 75 / / SYM 40436 3852 76 os os NNP 40436 3852 77 e)/schein e)/schein NNP 40436 3852 78 , , , 40436 3852 79 plê\n plê\n NNP 40436 3852 80 tou tou NNP 40436 3852 81 = = SYM 40436 3852 82 d d NNP 40436 3852 83 ' ' '' 40436 3852 84 , , , 40436 3852 85 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 3852 86 chrê chrê NNP 40436 3852 87 / / SYM 40436 3852 88 st st NNP 40436 3852 89 ' ' '' 40436 3852 90 e)di e)di NNP 40436 3852 91 / / SYM 40436 3852 92 daxe daxe JJ 40436 3852 93 . . . 40436 3853 1 Ta Ta NNP 40436 3853 2 / / SYM 40436 3853 3 xeis xeis NNP 40436 3853 4 , , , 40436 3853 5 a)reta a)reta NNP 40436 3853 6 / / SYM 40436 3853 7 s s NNPS 40436 3853 8 , , , 40436 3853 9 o(pli o(pli NNP 40436 3853 10 / / SYM 40436 3853 11 seis seis NNP 40436 3853 12 a)ndrô a)ndrô NNPS 40436 3853 13 = = SYM 40436 3853 14 n n XX 40436 3853 15 ? ? . 40436 3854 1 . . . 40436 3855 1 . . . 40436 3856 1 . . . 40436 3857 1 . . . 40436 3858 1 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 3858 2 ' ' `` 40436 3858 3 a)/llous a)/llous JJ 40436 3858 4 toi toi NNP 40436 3858 5 pollou\s pollou\s NNP 40436 3858 6 a)gathou\s a)gathou\s NNP 40436 3858 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3858 8 e)di e)di NN 40436 3858 9 / / SYM 40436 3858 10 daxen daxen NN 40436 3858 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3858 12 , , , 40436 3858 13 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 3858 14 ê)=n ê)=n VBD 40436 3858 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3858 16 La La NNP 40436 3858 17 / / SYM 40436 3858 18 machos machos NNP 40436 3858 19 ê(/rôs ê(/rôs NNP 40436 3858 20 . . . 40436 3858 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3859 1 See see VB 40436 3859 2 these these DT 40436 3859 3 views view NNS 40436 3859 4 combated combat VBN 40436 3859 5 by by IN 40436 3859 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3859 7 , , , 40436 3859 8 Republ Republ NNP 40436 3859 9 . . . 40436 3860 1 x. x. NNP 40436 3861 1 599 599 CD 40436 3861 2 - - SYM 40436 3861 3 600 600 CD 40436 3861 4 - - HYPH 40436 3861 5 606 606 CD 40436 3861 6 E. e. NN 40436 3861 7 The the DT 40436 3861 8 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 40436 3861 9 pretension pretension NN 40436 3861 10 here here RB 40436 3861 11 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 3861 12 to to IN 40436 3861 13 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3861 14 makes make VBZ 40436 3861 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3861 16 look look VB 40436 3861 17 contemptible contemptible JJ 40436 3861 18 -- -- : 40436 3861 19 like like IN 40436 3861 20 the the DT 40436 3861 21 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 3861 22 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 3861 23 to to IN 40436 3861 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3861 25 , , , 40436 3861 26 535 535 CD 40436 3861 27 E e NN 40436 3861 28 , , , 40436 3861 29 " " '' 40436 3861 30 If if IN 40436 3861 31 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3861 32 make make VBP 40436 3861 33 the the DT 40436 3861 34 auditors auditor NNS 40436 3861 35 weep weep VB 40436 3861 36 , , , 40436 3861 37 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3861 38 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 3861 39 shall shall MD 40436 3861 40 laugh laugh VB 40436 3861 41 and and CC 40436 3861 42 pocket pocket VB 40436 3861 43 money money NN 40436 3861 44 , , , 40436 3861 45 " " '' 40436 3861 46 & & CC 40436 3861 47 c. c. NNP 40436 3861 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3861 49 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3861 50 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3861 51 32 32 CD 40436 3861 52 : : : 40436 3861 53 Xenoph Xenoph NNS 40436 3861 54 . . . 40436 3862 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 3862 2 . . . 40436 3863 1 iii iii NNP 40436 3863 2 . . . 40436 3864 1 5 5 CD 40436 3864 2 , , , 40436 3864 3 21 21 CD 40436 3864 4 , , , 40436 3864 5 in in IN 40436 3864 6 the the DT 40436 3864 7 conversation conversation NN 40436 3864 8 between between IN 40436 3864 9 the the DT 40436 3864 10 younger young JJR 40436 3864 11 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 3864 12 and and CC 40436 3864 13 Sokrates--[Greek sokrates--[greek NN 40436 3864 14 : : : 40436 3864 15 tô tô NNP 40436 3864 16 = = SYM 40436 3864 17 n n CC 40436 3864 18 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3864 19 stratêgô stratêgô NNP 40436 3864 20 = = SYM 40436 3864 21 n n NNP 40436 3864 22 oi oi NNP 40436 3864 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3864 24 plei plei NNP 40436 3864 25 = = SYM 40436 3864 26 stoi stoi NNP 40436 3864 27 au)toschedia au)toschedia NNP 40436 3864 28 / / SYM 40436 3864 29 zousin zousin NNP 40436 3864 30 . . . 40436 3864 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3865 1 Also also RB 40436 3865 2 iii iii NNP 40436 3865 3 . . . 40436 3866 1 5 5 CD 40436 3866 2 , , , 40436 3866 3 24 24 CD 40436 3866 4 . . . 40436 3867 1 Compare compare VB 40436 3867 2 , , , 40436 3867 3 respecting respect VBG 40436 3867 4 the the DT 40436 3867 5 generals general NNS 40436 3867 6 , , , 40436 3867 7 the the DT 40436 3867 8 striking strike VBG 40436 3867 9 lines line NNS 40436 3867 10 of of IN 40436 3867 11 Euripides Euripides NNP 40436 3867 12 , , , 40436 3867 13 Androm Androm NNP 40436 3867 14 . . . 40436 3868 1 698 698 CD 40436 3868 2 , , , 40436 3868 3 and and CC 40436 3868 4 the the DT 40436 3868 5 encomium encomium NN 40436 3868 6 of of IN 40436 3868 7 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 3868 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3868 9 Academ Academ NNP 40436 3868 10 . . . 40436 3869 1 Prior prior RB 40436 3869 2 . . . 40436 3870 1 2 2 CD 40436 3870 2 , , , 40436 3870 3 1 1 CD 40436 3870 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3870 5 respecting respect VBG 40436 3870 6 the the DT 40436 3870 7 quickness quickness NN 40436 3870 8 and and CC 40436 3870 9 facility facility NN 40436 3870 10 with with IN 40436 3870 11 which which WDT 40436 3870 12 Lucullus Lucullus NNP 40436 3870 13 made make VBD 40436 3870 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3870 15 an an DT 40436 3870 16 excellent excellent JJ 40436 3870 17 general general NN 40436 3870 18 . . . 40436 3870 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3871 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3871 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3871 3 33 33 CD 40436 3871 4 : : : 40436 3871 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 3871 6 . . . 40436 3872 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 3872 2 . . . 40436 3873 1 iii iii NNP 40436 3873 2 . . . 40436 3874 1 4 4 LS 40436 3874 2 , , , 40436 3874 3 especially especially RB 40436 3874 4 iii iii CD 40436 3874 5 . . . 40436 3875 1 4 4 CD 40436 3875 2 , , , 40436 3875 3 6 6 CD 40436 3875 4 , , , 40436 3875 5 where where WRB 40436 3875 6 Nikomachides Nikomachides NNP 40436 3875 7 asks ask VBZ 40436 3875 8 with with IN 40436 3875 9 surprise surprise NN 40436 3875 10 , , , 40436 3875 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3875 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3875 13 : : : 40436 3875 14 le le NNP 40436 3875 15 / / SYM 40436 3875 16 geis geis NNP 40436 3875 17 su/ su/ NN 40436 3875 18 , , , 40436 3875 19 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 3875 20 Sô Sô NNP 40436 3875 21 / / SYM 40436 3875 22 krates krate NNS 40436 3875 23 , , , 40436 3875 24 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 3875 25 tou= tou= NNP 40436 3875 26 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 3875 27 a)ndro a)ndro NNP 40436 3875 28 / / SYM 40436 3875 29 s s NNP 40436 3875 30 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 3875 31 chorêgei chorêgei NNP 40436 3875 32 = = SYM 40436 3875 33 n n NNP 40436 3875 34 te te NNP 40436 3875 35 kalô kalô NNP 40436 3875 36 = = SYM 40436 3875 37 s s NNP 40436 3875 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3875 39 stratêgei stratêgei NNP 40436 3875 40 = = SYM 40436 3875 41 n n XX 40436 3875 42 ? ? . 40436 3875 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3875 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3876 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3876 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3876 3 34 34 CD 40436 3876 4 : : : 40436 3876 5 See see VB 40436 3876 6 the the DT 40436 3876 7 very very RB 40436 3876 8 curious curious JJ 40436 3876 9 extract extract NN 40436 3876 10 from from IN 40436 3876 11 the the DT 40436 3876 12 contemporary contemporary JJ 40436 3876 13 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3876 14 of of IN 40436 3876 15 Chios Chios NNPS 40436 3876 16 , , , 40436 3876 17 in in IN 40436 3876 18 Athenæus Athenæus NNP 40436 3876 19 , , , 40436 3876 20 xiii xiii NNP 40436 3876 21 . . . 40436 3877 1 604 604 CD 40436 3877 2 . . . 40436 3878 1 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40436 3878 2 of of IN 40436 3878 3 Byzantium Byzantium NNP 40436 3878 4 says say VBZ 40436 3878 5 that that IN 40436 3878 6 the the DT 40436 3878 7 appointment appointment NN 40436 3878 8 of of IN 40436 3878 9 Sophokles Sophokles NNPS 40436 3878 10 to to IN 40436 3878 11 this this DT 40436 3878 12 military military JJ 40436 3878 13 function function NN 40436 3878 14 arose arise VBD 40436 3878 15 from from IN 40436 3878 16 the the DT 40436 3878 17 extra extra JJ 40436 3878 18 - - HYPH 40436 3878 19 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 3878 20 popularity popularity NN 40436 3878 21 of of IN 40436 3878 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3878 23 tragedy tragedy NN 40436 3878 24 Antigonê Antigonê NNP 40436 3878 25 , , , 40436 3878 26 exhibited exhibit VBD 40436 3878 27 a a DT 40436 3878 28 little little JJ 40436 3878 29 time time NN 40436 3878 30 before before RB 40436 3878 31 . . . 40436 3879 1 See see VB 40436 3879 2 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 3879 3 's 's POS 40436 3879 4 valuable valuable JJ 40436 3879 5 ' ' '' 40436 3879 6 Dissertation dissertation NN 40436 3879 7 on on IN 40436 3879 8 the the DT 40436 3879 9 Antigonê Antigonê NNP 40436 3879 10 , , , 40436 3879 11 ' ' '' 40436 3879 12 appended append VBN 40436 3879 13 to to IN 40436 3879 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3879 15 edition edition NN 40436 3879 16 thereof thereof RB 40436 3879 17 , , , 40436 3879 18 pp pp NNP 40436 3879 19 . . . 40436 3880 1 121 121 CD 40436 3880 2 - - SYM 40436 3880 3 124 124 CD 40436 3880 4 . . . 40436 3880 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3881 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3881 2 Side side NN 40436 3881 3 - - HYPH 40436 3881 4 note note NN 40436 3881 5 : : : 40436 3881 6 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3881 7 , , , 40436 3881 8 opposed oppose VBN 40436 3881 9 to to TO 40436 3881 10 divine divine JJ 40436 3881 11 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 3881 12 without without IN 40436 3881 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3881 14 . . . 40436 3881 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3882 1 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3882 2 is be VBZ 40436 3882 3 willing willing JJ 40436 3882 4 enough enough RB 40436 3882 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3882 6 as as IN 40436 3882 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3882 8 promises promise VBZ 40436 3882 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3882 10 to to TO 40436 3882 11 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 3882 12 before before IN 40436 3882 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3882 14 one one CD 40436 3882 15 of of IN 40436 3882 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3882 17 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 3882 18 discourses discourse NNS 40436 3882 19 upon upon IN 40436 3882 20 Homer Homer NNP 40436 3882 21 . . . 40436 3883 1 But but CC 40436 3883 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3883 3 never never RB 40436 3883 4 permits permit VBZ 40436 3883 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3883 6 to to TO 40436 3883 7 arrive arrive VB 40436 3883 8 at at IN 40436 3883 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3883 10 : : : 40436 3883 11 arresting arrest VBG 40436 3883 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3883 13 always always RB 40436 3883 14 by by IN 40436 3883 15 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 3883 16 questions question NNS 40436 3883 17 , , , 40436 3883 18 and and CC 40436 3883 19 requiring require VBG 40436 3883 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3883 21 to to TO 40436 3883 22 furnish furnish VB 40436 3883 23 an an DT 40436 3883 24 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 3883 25 description description NN 40436 3883 26 of of IN 40436 3883 27 the the DT 40436 3883 28 matter matter NN 40436 3883 29 which which WDT 40436 3883 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3883 31 discourse discourse NN 40436 3883 32 is be VBZ 40436 3883 33 intended intend VBN 40436 3883 34 to to TO 40436 3883 35 embrace embrace VB 40436 3883 36 , , , 40436 3883 37 and and CC 40436 3883 38 thus thus RB 40436 3883 39 to to TO 40436 3883 40 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 3883 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3883 42 from from IN 40436 3883 43 other other JJ 40436 3883 44 matters matter NNS 40436 3883 45 left leave VBN 40436 3883 46 untouched untouched JJ 40436 3883 47 . . . 40436 3884 1 A a DT 40436 3884 2 man man NN 40436 3884 3 who who WP 40436 3884 4 can can MD 40436 3884 5 not not RB 40436 3884 6 comply comply VB 40436 3884 7 with with IN 40436 3884 8 this this DT 40436 3884 9 requisition,--who requisition,--who NNP 40436 3884 10 can can MD 40436 3884 11 not not RB 40436 3884 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3884 13 to to TO 40436 3884 14 repeat repeat VB 40436 3884 15 what what WP 40436 3884 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3884 17 said say VBD 40436 3884 18 in in IN 40436 3884 19 a a DT 40436 3884 20 previous previous JJ 40436 3884 21 chapter chapter NN 40436 3884 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3884 23 stand stand VB 40436 3884 24 a a DT 40436 3884 25 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 3884 26 cross cross NN 40436 3884 27 - - NN 40436 3884 28 examination examination NN 40436 3884 29 on on IN 40436 3884 30 the the DT 40436 3884 31 subject subject NN 40436 3884 32 -- -- : 40436 3884 33 possesses possess VBZ 40436 3884 34 no no DT 40436 3884 35 rational rational JJ 40436 3884 36 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 3884 37 of of IN 40436 3884 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3884 39 own own JJ 40436 3884 40 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 3884 41 : : : 40436 3884 42 no no DT 40436 3884 43 art art NN 40436 3884 44 , , , 40436 3884 45 science science NN 40436 3884 46 , , , 40436 3884 47 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3884 48 , , , 40436 3884 49 system system NN 40436 3884 50 , , , 40436 3884 51 or or CC 40436 3884 52 method method NN 40436 3884 53 . . . 40436 3885 1 If if IN 40436 3885 2 as as IN 40436 3885 3 a a DT 40436 3885 4 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 3885 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3885 6 executes execute VBZ 40436 3885 7 well well UH 40436 3885 8 what what WP 40436 3885 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3885 10 promises promise VBZ 40436 3885 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3885 12 which which WDT 40436 3885 13 is be VBZ 40436 3885 14 often often RB 40436 3885 15 the the DT 40436 3885 16 case case NN 40436 3885 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3885 18 , , , 40436 3885 19 and and CC 40436 3885 20 attains attain VBZ 40436 3885 21 success success NN 40436 3885 22 -- -- : 40436 3885 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3885 24 does do VBZ 40436 3885 25 so so RB 40436 3885 26 either either CC 40436 3885 27 by by IN 40436 3885 28 blind blind JJ 40436 3885 29 imitation imitation NN 40436 3885 30 of of IN 40436 3885 31 some some DT 40436 3885 32 master master NN 40436 3885 33 , , , 40436 3885 34 or or CC 40436 3885 35 else else RB 40436 3885 36 under under IN 40436 3885 37 the the DT 40436 3885 38 stimulus stimulus NN 40436 3885 39 and and CC 40436 3885 40 guidance guidance NN 40436 3885 41 of of IN 40436 3885 42 some some DT 40436 3885 43 agency agency NN 40436 3885 44 foreign foreign NN 40436 3885 45 to to IN 40436 3885 46 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3885 47 -- -- : 40436 3885 48 of of IN 40436 3885 49 the the DT 40436 3885 50 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 3885 51 or or CC 40436 3885 52 Fortune Fortune NNP 40436 3885 53 . . . 40436 3886 1 This this DT 40436 3886 2 is be VBZ 40436 3886 3 the the DT 40436 3886 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3886 5 point point NN 40436 3886 6 of of IN 40436 3886 7 view view NN 40436 3886 8 ; ; , 40436 3886 9 developed develop VBN 40436 3886 10 in in IN 40436 3886 11 several several JJ 40436 3886 12 different different JJ 40436 3886 13 ways way NNS 40436 3886 14 and and CC 40436 3886 15 different different JJ 40436 3886 16 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3886 17 , , , 40436 3886 18 but but CC 40436 3886 19 hardly hardly RB 40436 3886 20 anywhere anywhere RB 40436 3886 21 more more RBR 40436 3886 22 conspicuously conspicuously RB 40436 3886 23 than than IN 40436 3886 24 in in IN 40436 3886 25 the the DT 40436 3886 26 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3886 27 . . . 40436 3887 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3887 2 Side side NN 40436 3887 3 - - HYPH 40436 3887 4 note note NN 40436 3887 5 : : : 40436 3887 6 Illustration illustration NN 40436 3887 7 of of IN 40436 3887 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3887 9 's 's POS 40436 3887 10 opinion opinion NN 40436 3887 11 respecting respect VBG 40436 3887 12 the the DT 40436 3887 13 uselessness uselessness NN 40436 3887 14 of of IN 40436 3887 15 written write VBN 40436 3887 16 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 3887 17 treatises treatise NNS 40436 3887 18 . . . 40436 3887 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3888 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3888 2 have have VBP 40436 3888 3 observed observe VBN 40436 3888 4 that that IN 40436 3888 5 in in IN 40436 3888 6 this this DT 40436 3888 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3888 8 , , , 40436 3888 9 Ion Ion NNP 40436 3888 10 is be VBZ 40436 3888 11 anxious anxious JJ 40436 3888 12 to to TO 40436 3888 13 embark embark VB 40436 3888 14 on on IN 40436 3888 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3888 16 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 3888 17 expository expository NN 40436 3888 18 discourse discourse NN 40436 3888 19 , , , 40436 3888 20 but but CC 40436 3888 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3888 22 will will MD 40436 3888 23 not not RB 40436 3888 24 allow allow VB 40436 3888 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3888 26 to to TO 40436 3888 27 begin begin VB 40436 3888 28 : : : 40436 3888 29 requiring require VBG 40436 3888 30 as as IN 40436 3888 31 a a DT 40436 3888 32 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 3888 33 stage stage NN 40436 3888 34 that that IN 40436 3888 35 certain certain JJ 40436 3888 36 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 3888 37 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 3888 38 shall shall MD 40436 3888 39 first first RB 40436 3888 40 be be VB 40436 3888 41 cleared clear VBN 40436 3888 42 up up RP 40436 3888 43 . . . 40436 3889 1 Here here RB 40436 3889 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3889 3 have have VBP 40436 3889 4 an an DT 40436 3889 5 illustration illustration NN 40436 3889 6 of of IN 40436 3889 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3889 8 's 's POS 40436 3889 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 3889 10 , , , 40436 3889 11 to to TO 40436 3889 12 which which WDT 40436 3889 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3889 14 adverted advert VBD 40436 3889 15 in in IN 40436 3889 16 a a DT 40436 3889 17 former former JJ 40436 3889 18 chapter,[35]--that chapter,[35]--that NNP 40436 3889 19 no no DT 40436 3889 20 written write VBN 40436 3889 21 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 3889 22 treatise treatise NN 40436 3889 23 could could MD 40436 3889 24 impart impart VB 40436 3889 25 a a DT 40436 3889 26 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3889 27 of of IN 40436 3889 28 geometry geometry NN 40436 3889 29 to to IN 40436 3889 30 one one CD 40436 3889 31 ignorant ignorant NN 40436 3889 32 thereof thereof RB 40436 3889 33 . . . 40436 3890 1 The the DT 40436 3890 2 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 3890 3 writer writer NN 40436 3890 4 begins begin VBZ 40436 3890 5 by by IN 40436 3890 6 laying lay VBG 40436 3890 7 down down RP 40436 3890 8 a a DT 40436 3890 9 string string NN 40436 3890 10 of of IN 40436 3890 11 definitions definition NNS 40436 3890 12 and and CC 40436 3890 13 axioms axiom NNS 40436 3890 14 ; ; : 40436 3890 15 and and CC 40436 3890 16 then then RB 40436 3890 17 strikes strike VBZ 40436 3890 18 out out RP 40436 3890 19 boldly boldly RB 40436 3890 20 in in IN 40436 3890 21 demonstrating demonstrate VBG 40436 3890 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3890 23 theorems theorem NNS 40436 3890 24 . . . 40436 3891 1 But but CC 40436 3891 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3891 3 would would MD 40436 3891 4 refuse refuse VB 40436 3891 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3891 6 the the DT 40436 3891 7 liberty liberty NN 40436 3891 8 of of IN 40436 3891 9 striking strike VBG 40436 3891 10 out out RP 40436 3891 11 , , , 40436 3891 12 until until IN 40436 3891 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3891 14 should should MD 40436 3891 15 have have VB 40436 3891 16 cleared clear VBN 40436 3891 17 up up RP 40436 3891 18 the the DT 40436 3891 19 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 3891 20 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 3891 21 about about IN 40436 3891 22 the the DT 40436 3891 23 definitions definition NNS 40436 3891 24 and and CC 40436 3891 25 axioms axiom NNS 40436 3891 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3891 27 . . . 40436 3892 1 This this DT 40436 3892 2 the the DT 40436 3892 3 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 3892 4 treatise treatise NN 40436 3892 5 does do VBZ 40436 3892 6 not not RB 40436 3892 7 even even RB 40436 3892 8 attempt attempt VB 40436 3892 9 . . . 40436 3893 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3893 2 36 36 CD 40436 3893 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3893 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3893 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3893 6 35 35 CD 40436 3893 7 : : : 40436 3893 8 Chap Chap NNP 40436 3893 9 . . . 40436 3894 1 viii viii RB 40436 3894 2 . . . 40436 3895 1 p. p. NN 40436 3896 1 353 353 CD 40436 3896 2 . . . 40436 3896 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3897 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3897 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3897 3 36 36 CD 40436 3897 4 : : : 40436 3897 5 Compare Compare NNP 40436 3897 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3897 7 , , , 40436 3897 8 Republic Republic NNP 40436 3897 9 , , , 40436 3897 10 vi vi NNP 40436 3897 11 . . . 40436 3898 1 510 510 CD 40436 3898 2 C c NN 40436 3898 3 ; ; : 40436 3898 4 vii vii NN 40436 3898 5 . . . 40436 3899 1 538 538 CD 40436 3899 2 C C NNP 40436 3899 3 - - HYPH 40436 3899 4 D. D. NNP 40436 3899 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3899 6 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 3899 7 XVIII xviii NN 40436 3899 8 . . . 40436 3900 1 LACHES LACHES NNP 40436 3900 2 . . . 40436 3901 1 The the DT 40436 3901 2 main main JJ 40436 3901 3 substance substance NN 40436 3901 4 of of IN 40436 3901 5 this this DT 40436 3901 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3901 7 consists consist VBZ 40436 3901 8 of of IN 40436 3901 9 a a DT 40436 3901 10 discussion discussion NN 40436 3901 11 , , , 40436 3901 12 carried carry VBN 40436 3901 13 on on RP 40436 3901 14 by by IN 40436 3901 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3901 16 with with IN 40436 3901 17 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3901 18 and and CC 40436 3901 19 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3901 20 , , , 40436 3901 21 respecting respect VBG 40436 3901 22 Courage Courage NNP 40436 3901 23 . . . 40436 3902 1 Each each DT 40436 3902 2 of of IN 40436 3902 3 the the DT 40436 3902 4 two two CD 40436 3902 5 latter latter JJ 40436 3902 6 proposes propose VBZ 40436 3902 7 an an DT 40436 3902 8 explanation explanation NN 40436 3902 9 of of IN 40436 3902 10 Courage Courage NNP 40436 3902 11 : : : 40436 3902 12 Sokratês sokratês NN 40436 3902 13 criticises criticise VBZ 40436 3902 14 both both DT 40436 3902 15 of of IN 40436 3902 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3902 17 , , , 40436 3902 18 and and CC 40436 3902 19 reduces reduce VBZ 40436 3902 20 each each DT 40436 3902 21 to to IN 40436 3902 22 a a DT 40436 3902 23 confessed confessed JJ 40436 3902 24 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 3902 25 . . . 40436 3903 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3903 2 Side side NN 40436 3903 3 - - HYPH 40436 3903 4 note note NN 40436 3903 5 : : : 40436 3903 6 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3903 7 . . . 40436 3904 1 Subject subject JJ 40436 3904 2 and and CC 40436 3904 3 persons person NNS 40436 3904 4 of of IN 40436 3904 5 the the DT 40436 3904 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3904 7 , , , 40436 3904 8 Whether whether IN 40436 3904 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3904 10 is be VBZ 40436 3904 11 useful useful JJ 40436 3904 12 that that IN 40436 3904 13 two two CD 40436 3904 14 young young JJ 40436 3904 15 men man NNS 40436 3904 16 should should MD 40436 3904 17 receive receive VB 40436 3904 18 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3904 19 from from IN 40436 3904 20 a a DT 40436 3904 21 master master NN 40436 3904 22 of of IN 40436 3904 23 arms arm NNS 40436 3904 24 . . . 40436 3905 1 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3905 2 and and CC 40436 3905 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3905 4 differ differ VBP 40436 3905 5 in in IN 40436 3905 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 3905 7 . . . 40436 3905 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3906 1 The the DT 40436 3906 2 discussion discussion NN 40436 3906 3 is be VBZ 40436 3906 4 invited invite VBN 40436 3906 5 , , , 40436 3906 6 or or CC 40436 3906 7 at at IN 40436 3906 8 least least JJS 40436 3906 9 dramatically dramatically RB 40436 3906 10 introduced introduce VBN 40436 3906 11 , , , 40436 3906 12 by by IN 40436 3906 13 two two CD 40436 3906 14 elderly elderly JJ 40436 3906 15 men man NNS 40436 3906 16 -- -- : 40436 3906 17 Lysimachus Lysimachus NNP 40436 3906 18 , , , 40436 3906 19 son son NN 40436 3906 20 of of IN 40436 3906 21 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 3906 22 the the DT 40436 3906 23 Just,--and Just,--and NNP 40436 3906 24 Melêsias Melêsias NNP 40436 3906 25 , , , 40436 3906 26 son son NN 40436 3906 27 of of IN 40436 3906 28 Thucydides Thucydides NNP 40436 3906 29 the the DT 40436 3906 30 rival rival NN 40436 3906 31 of of IN 40436 3906 32 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 3906 33 . . . 40436 3907 1 Lysimachus Lysimachus NNP 40436 3907 2 and and CC 40436 3907 3 Melêsias Melêsias NNP 40436 3907 4 , , , 40436 3907 5 confessing confess VBG 40436 3907 6 with with IN 40436 3907 7 shame shame NN 40436 3907 8 that that IN 40436 3907 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3907 10 are be VBP 40436 3907 11 inferior inferior JJ 40436 3907 12 to to IN 40436 3907 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3907 14 fathers father NNS 40436 3907 15 , , , 40436 3907 16 because because IN 40436 3907 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3907 18 education education NN 40436 3907 19 has have VBZ 40436 3907 20 been be VBN 40436 3907 21 neglected neglect VBN 40436 3907 22 , , , 40436 3907 23 wish wish VB 40436 3907 24 to to TO 40436 3907 25 guard guard VB 40436 3907 26 against against IN 40436 3907 27 the the DT 40436 3907 28 same same JJ 40436 3907 29 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 3907 30 in in IN 40436 3907 31 the the DT 40436 3907 32 case case NN 40436 3907 33 of of IN 40436 3907 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3907 35 own own JJ 40436 3907 36 sons son NNS 40436 3907 37 : : : 40436 3907 38 respecting respect VBG 40436 3907 39 the the DT 40436 3907 40 education education NN 40436 3907 41 of of IN 40436 3907 42 whom whom WP 40436 3907 43 , , , 40436 3907 44 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3907 45 ask ask VBP 40436 3907 46 the the DT 40436 3907 47 advice advice NN 40436 3907 48 of of IN 40436 3907 49 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3907 50 and and CC 40436 3907 51 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3907 52 . . . 40436 3908 1 The the DT 40436 3908 2 question question NN 40436 3908 3 turns turn VBZ 40436 3908 4 especially especially RB 40436 3908 5 upon upon IN 40436 3908 6 the the DT 40436 3908 7 propriety propriety NN 40436 3908 8 of of IN 40436 3908 9 causing cause VBG 40436 3908 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3908 11 sons son NNS 40436 3908 12 to to TO 40436 3908 13 receive receive VB 40436 3908 14 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3908 15 from from IN 40436 3908 16 a a DT 40436 3908 17 master master NN 40436 3908 18 of of IN 40436 3908 19 arms arm NNS 40436 3908 20 just just RB 40436 3908 21 then then RB 40436 3908 22 in in IN 40436 3908 23 vogue vogue NN 40436 3908 24 . . . 40436 3909 1 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3909 2 and and CC 40436 3909 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3909 4 , , , 40436 3909 5 both both DT 40436 3909 6 of of IN 40436 3909 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3909 8 not not RB 40436 3909 9 merely merely RB 40436 3909 10 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 3909 11 citizens citizen NNS 40436 3909 12 but but CC 40436 3909 13 also also RB 40436 3909 14 commanders commander NNS 40436 3909 15 of of IN 40436 3909 16 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 3909 17 armies army NNS 40436 3909 18 , , , 40436 3909 19 are be VBP 40436 3909 20 assumed assume VBN 40436 3909 21 to to TO 40436 3909 22 be be VB 40436 3909 23 well well RB 40436 3909 24 qualified qualified JJ 40436 3909 25 to to TO 40436 3909 26 give give VB 40436 3909 27 advice advice NN 40436 3909 28 . . . 40436 3910 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 3910 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3910 3 deliver deliver VBP 40436 3910 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3910 5 opinions opinion NNS 40436 3910 6 : : : 40436 3910 7 Nikias nikias NN 40436 3910 8 approving approve VBG 40436 3910 9 such such JJ 40436 3910 10 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3910 11 as as IN 40436 3910 12 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 3910 13 , , , 40436 3910 14 in in IN 40436 3910 15 exalting exalt VBG 40436 3910 16 the the DT 40436 3910 17 courage courage NN 40436 3910 18 of of IN 40436 3910 19 a a DT 40436 3910 20 young young JJ 40436 3910 21 man man NN 40436 3910 22 , , , 40436 3910 23 and and CC 40436 3910 24 rendering render VBG 40436 3910 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3910 26 effective effective JJ 40436 3910 27 on on IN 40436 3910 28 the the DT 40436 3910 29 field field NN 40436 3910 30 of of IN 40436 3910 31 battle battle NN 40436 3910 32 : : : 40436 3910 33 while while IN 40436 3910 34 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3910 35 takes take VBZ 40436 3910 36 an an DT 40436 3910 37 opposite opposite JJ 40436 3910 38 view view NN 40436 3910 39 , , , 40436 3910 40 disparages disparage VBZ 40436 3910 41 the the DT 40436 3910 42 masters master NNS 40436 3910 43 of of IN 40436 3910 44 arms arm NNS 40436 3910 45 as as IN 40436 3910 46 being be VBG 40436 3910 47 no no DT 40436 3910 48 soldiers soldier NNS 40436 3910 49 , , , 40436 3910 50 and and CC 40436 3910 51 adds add VBZ 40436 3910 52 that that IN 40436 3910 53 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3910 54 are be VBP 40436 3910 55 despised despise VBN 40436 3910 56 by by IN 40436 3910 57 the the DT 40436 3910 58 Lacedæmonians Lacedæmonians NNPS 40436 3910 59 , , , 40436 3910 60 to to IN 40436 3910 61 whose whose WP$ 40436 3910 62 authority authority NN 40436 3910 63 on on IN 40436 3910 64 military military JJ 40436 3910 65 matters matter NNS 40436 3910 66 general general JJ 40436 3910 67 deference deference NN 40436 3910 68 was be VBD 40436 3910 69 paid pay VBN 40436 3910 70 in in IN 40436 3910 71 Greece Greece NNP 40436 3910 72 . . . 40436 3911 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3911 2 1 1 LS 40436 3911 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3911 4 Sokratês,--commended sokratês,--commende VBN 40436 3911 5 greatly greatly RB 40436 3911 6 by by IN 40436 3911 7 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3911 8 for for IN 40436 3911 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3911 10 acuteness acuteness NN 40436 3911 11 and and CC 40436 3911 12 sagacity sagacity NN 40436 3911 13 , , , 40436 3911 14 by by IN 40436 3911 15 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3911 16 for for IN 40436 3911 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3911 18 courage courage NN 40436 3911 19 in in IN 40436 3911 20 the the DT 40436 3911 21 battle battle NN 40436 3911 22 of of IN 40436 3911 23 Delium,--is Delium,--is NNP 40436 3911 24 invited invite VBN 40436 3911 25 to to TO 40436 3911 26 take take VB 40436 3911 27 part part NN 40436 3911 28 in in IN 40436 3911 29 the the DT 40436 3911 30 consultation consultation NN 40436 3911 31 . . . 40436 3912 1 Being be VBG 40436 3912 2 younger young JJR 40436 3912 3 than than IN 40436 3912 4 both both DT 40436 3912 5 , , , 40436 3912 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3912 7 waits wait VBZ 40436 3912 8 till till IN 40436 3912 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3912 10 have have VBP 40436 3912 11 delivered deliver VBN 40436 3912 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3912 13 opinions opinion NNS 40436 3912 14 , , , 40436 3912 15 and and CC 40436 3912 16 is be VBZ 40436 3912 17 then then RB 40436 3912 18 called call VBN 40436 3912 19 upon upon IN 40436 3912 20 to to TO 40436 3912 21 declare declare VB 40436 3912 22 with with IN 40436 3912 23 which which WDT 40436 3912 24 of of IN 40436 3912 25 the the DT 40436 3912 26 two two CD 40436 3912 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3912 28 own own JJ 40436 3912 29 judgment judgment NN 40436 3912 30 will will MD 40436 3912 31 concur concur VB 40436 3912 32 . . . 40436 3913 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3913 2 2 2 CD 40436 3913 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3913 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3913 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3913 6 1 1 CD 40436 3913 7 : : : 40436 3913 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3913 9 , , , 40436 3913 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3913 11 , , , 40436 3913 12 182 182 CD 40436 3913 13 - - SYM 40436 3913 14 183 183 CD 40436 3913 15 . . . 40436 3913 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3914 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3914 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3914 3 2 2 CD 40436 3914 4 : : : 40436 3914 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3914 6 , , , 40436 3914 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3914 8 , , , 40436 3914 9 184 184 CD 40436 3914 10 D. D. NNP 40436 3914 11 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3914 12 is be VBZ 40436 3914 13 made make VBN 40436 3914 14 to to TO 40436 3914 15 say say VB 40436 3914 16 that that IN 40436 3914 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3914 18 has have VBZ 40436 3914 19 recently recently RB 40436 3914 20 recommended recommend VBN 40436 3914 21 to to IN 40436 3914 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3914 23 Damon Damon NNP 40436 3914 24 , , , 40436 3914 25 as as IN 40436 3914 26 a a DT 40436 3914 27 teacher teacher NN 40436 3914 28 of of IN 40436 3914 29 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3914 30 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3914 31 : : : 40436 3914 32 mousikê\ mousikê\ NNP 40436 3914 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3914 34 to to IN 40436 3914 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3914 36 sons son NNS 40436 3914 37 , , , 40436 3914 38 and and CC 40436 3914 39 that that IN 40436 3914 40 Damon Damon NNP 40436 3914 41 had have VBD 40436 3914 42 proved prove VBN 40436 3914 43 an an DT 40436 3914 44 admirable admirable JJ 40436 3914 45 teacher teacher NN 40436 3914 46 as as RB 40436 3914 47 well well RB 40436 3914 48 as as IN 40436 3914 49 companion companion NN 40436 3914 50 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3914 51 180 180 CD 40436 3914 52 D d NN 40436 3914 53 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3914 54 . . . 40436 3915 1 Damon Damon NNP 40436 3915 2 is be VBZ 40436 3915 3 mentioned mention VBN 40436 3915 4 by by IN 40436 3915 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3915 6 generally generally RB 40436 3915 7 with with IN 40436 3915 8 much much JJ 40436 3915 9 eulogy eulogy NN 40436 3915 10 . . . 40436 3915 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3916 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3916 2 Side side NN 40436 3916 3 - - HYPH 40436 3916 4 note note NN 40436 3916 5 : : : 40436 3916 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3916 7 is be VBZ 40436 3916 8 invited invite VBN 40436 3916 9 to to TO 40436 3916 10 declare declare VB 40436 3916 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3916 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 3916 13 . . . 40436 3917 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3917 2 replies reply VBZ 40436 3917 3 that that IN 40436 3917 4 the the DT 40436 3917 5 point point NN 40436 3917 6 can can MD 40436 3917 7 not not RB 40436 3917 8 be be VB 40436 3917 9 decided decide VBN 40436 3917 10 without without IN 40436 3917 11 a a DT 40436 3917 12 competent competent JJ 40436 3917 13 professional professional JJ 40436 3917 14 judge judge NN 40436 3917 15 . . . 40436 3917 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3918 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3918 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 3918 3 question question NN 40436 3918 4 must must MD 40436 3918 5 not not RB 40436 3918 6 be be VB 40436 3918 7 determined determine VBN 40436 3918 8 by by IN 40436 3918 9 a a DT 40436 3918 10 plurality plurality NN 40436 3918 11 of of IN 40436 3918 12 votes vote NNS 40436 3918 13 , , , 40436 3918 14 but but CC 40436 3918 15 by by IN 40436 3918 16 superiority superiority NN 40436 3918 17 of of IN 40436 3918 18 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3918 19 . . . 40436 3919 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3919 2 3 3 LS 40436 3919 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3919 4 If if IN 40436 3919 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3919 6 were be VBD 40436 3919 7 debating debate VBG 40436 3919 8 about about IN 40436 3919 9 the the DT 40436 3919 10 proper proper JJ 40436 3919 11 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 3919 12 discipline discipline NN 40436 3919 13 for for IN 40436 3919 14 these these DT 40436 3919 15 young young JJ 40436 3919 16 men man NNS 40436 3919 17 , , , 40436 3919 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3919 19 should should MD 40436 3919 20 consult consult VB 40436 3919 21 a a DT 40436 3919 22 known know VBN 40436 3919 23 artist artist NN 40436 3919 24 or or CC 40436 3919 25 professional professional JJ 40436 3919 26 trainer trainer NN 40436 3919 27 , , , 40436 3919 28 or or CC 40436 3919 29 at at IN 40436 3919 30 least least JJS 40436 3919 31 some some DT 40436 3919 32 one one NN 40436 3919 33 who who WP 40436 3919 34 had have VBD 40436 3919 35 gone go VBN 40436 3919 36 through through IN 40436 3919 37 a a DT 40436 3919 38 course course NN 40436 3919 39 of of IN 40436 3919 40 teaching teaching NN 40436 3919 41 and and CC 40436 3919 42 practice practice NN 40436 3919 43 under under IN 40436 3919 44 the the DT 40436 3919 45 trainer trainer NN 40436 3919 46 . . . 40436 3920 1 The the DT 40436 3920 2 first first JJ 40436 3920 3 thing thing NN 40436 3920 4 to to TO 40436 3920 5 be be VB 40436 3920 6 enquired enquire VBN 40436 3920 7 therefore therefore RB 40436 3920 8 is be VBZ 40436 3920 9 , , , 40436 3920 10 whether whether IN 40436 3920 11 , , , 40436 3920 12 in in IN 40436 3920 13 reference reference NN 40436 3920 14 to to IN 40436 3920 15 the the DT 40436 3920 16 point point NN 40436 3920 17 now now RB 40436 3920 18 under under IN 40436 3920 19 discussion discussion NN 40436 3920 20 , , , 40436 3920 21 there there EX 40436 3920 22 be be VB 40436 3920 23 any any DT 40436 3920 24 one one CD 40436 3920 25 of of IN 40436 3920 26 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3920 27 professionally professionally RB 40436 3920 28 or or CC 40436 3920 29 technically technically RB 40436 3920 30 competent competent JJ 40436 3920 31 , , , 40436 3920 32 who who WP 40436 3920 33 has have VBZ 40436 3920 34 studied study VBN 40436 3920 35 under under IN 40436 3920 36 good good JJ 40436 3920 37 masters master NNS 40436 3920 38 , , , 40436 3920 39 and and CC 40436 3920 40 has have VBZ 40436 3920 41 proved prove VBN 40436 3920 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3920 43 own own JJ 40436 3920 44 competence competence NN 40436 3920 45 as as IN 40436 3920 46 a a DT 40436 3920 47 master master NN 40436 3920 48 by by IN 40436 3920 49 producing produce VBG 40436 3920 50 well well RB 40436 3920 51 - - HYPH 40436 3920 52 trained train VBN 40436 3920 53 pupils pupil NNS 40436 3920 54 . . . 40436 3921 1 The the DT 40436 3921 2 next next JJ 40436 3921 3 thing thing NN 40436 3921 4 is be VBZ 40436 3921 5 , , , 40436 3921 6 to to TO 40436 3921 7 understand understand VB 40436 3921 8 clearly clearly RB 40436 3921 9 what what WP 40436 3921 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3921 11 is be VBZ 40436 3921 12 , , , 40436 3921 13 with with IN 40436 3921 14 reference reference NN 40436 3921 15 to to IN 40436 3921 16 which which WDT 40436 3921 17 such such JJ 40436 3921 18 competence competence NN 40436 3921 19 is be VBZ 40436 3921 20 required require VBN 40436 3921 21 . . . 40436 3922 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3922 2 4 4 CD 40436 3922 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3922 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3922 5 Nikias._--Surely nikias._--surely RB 40436 3922 6 the the DT 40436 3922 7 point point NN 40436 3922 8 before before IN 40436 3922 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3922 10 is be VBZ 40436 3922 11 , , , 40436 3922 12 whether whether IN 40436 3922 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3922 14 be be VB 40436 3922 15 wise wise JJ 40436 3922 16 to to TO 40436 3922 17 put put VB 40436 3922 18 these these DT 40436 3922 19 young young JJ 40436 3922 20 men man NNS 40436 3922 21 under under IN 40436 3922 22 the the DT 40436 3922 23 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3922 24 of of IN 40436 3922 25 the the DT 40436 3922 26 master master NN 40436 3922 27 of of IN 40436 3922 28 arms arm NNS 40436 3922 29 ? ? . 40436 3923 1 That that DT 40436 3923 2 is be VBZ 40436 3923 3 what what WP 40436 3923 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3923 5 want want VBP 40436 3923 6 to to TO 40436 3923 7 know know VB 40436 3923 8 . . . 40436 3924 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3924 2 Sokr._--Doubtless Sokr._--Doubtless NNP 40436 3924 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3924 4 is be VBZ 40436 3924 5 : : : 40436 3924 6 but but CC 40436 3924 7 that that DT 40436 3924 8 is be VBZ 40436 3924 9 only only RB 40436 3924 10 one one CD 40436 3924 11 particular particular JJ 40436 3924 12 branch branch NN 40436 3924 13 of of IN 40436 3924 14 a a DT 40436 3924 15 wider wide JJR 40436 3924 16 and and CC 40436 3924 17 more more RBR 40436 3924 18 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 3924 19 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 3924 20 . . . 40436 3925 1 When when WRB 40436 3925 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3925 3 are be VBP 40436 3925 4 considering consider VBG 40436 3925 5 whether whether IN 40436 3925 6 a a DT 40436 3925 7 particular particular JJ 40436 3925 8 ointment ointment NN 40436 3925 9 is be VBZ 40436 3925 10 good good JJ 40436 3925 11 for for IN 40436 3925 12 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3925 13 eyes eye NNS 40436 3925 14 , , , 40436 3925 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3925 16 is be VBZ 40436 3925 17 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3925 18 eyes eye NNS 40436 3925 19 , , , 40436 3925 20 and and CC 40436 3925 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3925 22 general general JJ 40436 3925 23 benefit benefit NN 40436 3925 24 , , , 40436 3925 25 which which WDT 40436 3925 26 form form VBP 40436 3925 27 the the DT 40436 3925 28 subject subject NN 40436 3925 29 of of IN 40436 3925 30 investigation investigation NN 40436 3925 31 -- -- : 40436 3925 32 not not RB 40436 3925 33 the the DT 40436 3925 34 ointment ointment NN 40436 3925 35 simply simply RB 40436 3925 36 . . . 40436 3926 1 The the DT 40436 3926 2 person person NN 40436 3926 3 to to TO 40436 3926 4 assist assist VB 40436 3926 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3926 6 will will MD 40436 3926 7 be be VB 40436 3926 8 , , , 40436 3926 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3926 10 who who WP 40436 3926 11 understands understand VBZ 40436 3926 12 professionally professionally RB 40436 3926 13 the the DT 40436 3926 14 general general JJ 40436 3926 15 treatment treatment NN 40436 3926 16 of of IN 40436 3926 17 the the DT 40436 3926 18 eyes eye NNS 40436 3926 19 . . . 40436 3927 1 So so RB 40436 3927 2 in in IN 40436 3927 3 this this DT 40436 3927 4 case case NN 40436 3927 5 , , , 40436 3927 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3927 7 are be VBP 40436 3927 8 enquiring enquire VBG 40436 3927 9 whether whether IN 40436 3927 10 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3927 11 in in IN 40436 3927 12 arms arm NNS 40436 3927 13 will will MD 40436 3927 14 be be VB 40436 3927 15 improving improve VBG 40436 3927 16 for for IN 40436 3927 17 the the DT 40436 3927 18 minds mind NNS 40436 3927 19 and and CC 40436 3927 20 character character NN 40436 3927 21 of of IN 40436 3927 22 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3927 23 sons son NNS 40436 3927 24 . . . 40436 3928 1 Look look VB 40436 3928 2 out out RP 40436 3928 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 3928 4 for for IN 40436 3928 5 some some DT 40436 3928 6 one one NN 40436 3928 7 who who WP 40436 3928 8 is be VBZ 40436 3928 9 professionally professionally RB 40436 3928 10 competent competent JJ 40436 3928 11 , , , 40436 3928 12 from from IN 40436 3928 13 having have VBG 40436 3928 14 studied study VBN 40436 3928 15 under under IN 40436 3928 16 good good JJ 40436 3928 17 masters master NNS 40436 3928 18 , , , 40436 3928 19 in in IN 40436 3928 20 regard regard NN 40436 3928 21 to to IN 40436 3928 22 the the DT 40436 3928 23 general general JJ 40436 3928 24 treatment treatment NN 40436 3928 25 of of IN 40436 3928 26 the the DT 40436 3928 27 mind mind NN 40436 3928 28 . . . 40436 3929 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3929 2 5 5 CD 40436 3929 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3929 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3929 5 Lachês._--But Lachês._--But NNP 40436 3929 6 there there EX 40436 3929 7 are be VBP 40436 3929 8 various various JJ 40436 3929 9 persons person NNS 40436 3929 10 who who WP 40436 3929 11 , , , 40436 3929 12 without without IN 40436 3929 13 ever ever RB 40436 3929 14 having have VBG 40436 3929 15 studied study VBN 40436 3929 16 under under IN 40436 3929 17 masters master NNS 40436 3929 18 , , , 40436 3929 19 possess possess VBP 40436 3929 20 greater great JJR 40436 3929 21 technical technical JJ 40436 3929 22 competence competence NN 40436 3929 23 than than IN 40436 3929 24 others other NNS 40436 3929 25 who who WP 40436 3929 26 have have VBP 40436 3929 27 so so RB 40436 3929 28 studied study VBN 40436 3929 29 . . . 40436 3930 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3930 2 Sokr._--There Sokr._--There NNP 40436 3930 3 are be VBP 40436 3930 4 such such JJ 40436 3930 5 persons person NNS 40436 3930 6 : : : 40436 3930 7 but but CC 40436 3930 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3930 9 will will MD 40436 3930 10 never never RB 40436 3930 11 believe believe VB 40436 3930 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3930 13 upon upon IN 40436 3930 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3930 15 own own JJ 40436 3930 16 assurance assurance NN 40436 3930 17 , , , 40436 3930 18 unless unless IN 40436 3930 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3930 20 can can MD 40436 3930 21 show show VB 40436 3930 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3930 23 some some DT 40436 3930 24 good good JJ 40436 3930 25 special special JJ 40436 3930 26 work work NN 40436 3930 27 actually actually RB 40436 3930 28 performed perform VBN 40436 3930 29 by by IN 40436 3930 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3930 31 . . . 40436 3931 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3931 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3931 3 3 3 CD 40436 3931 4 : : : 40436 3931 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3931 6 , , , 40436 3931 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3931 8 , , , 40436 3931 9 184 184 CD 40436 3931 10 E. E. NNP 40436 3931 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3931 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3931 13 : : : 40436 3931 14 e)pistê e)pistê ADD 40436 3931 15 / / SYM 40436 3931 16 mê| mê| NNP 40436 3931 17 dei= dei= NNP 40436 3931 18 kri kri NN 40436 3931 19 / / SYM 40436 3931 20 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 3931 21 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 3931 22 ' ' '' 40436 3931 23 ou ou NNP 40436 3931 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3931 25 plê plê NNP 40436 3931 26 / / SYM 40436 3931 27 thei thei NNP 40436 3931 28 to\ to\ NNP 40436 3931 29 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3931 30 / / SYM 40436 3931 31 llon llon NNP 40436 3931 32 kalô kalô NNP 40436 3931 33 = = SYM 40436 3931 34 s s NNP 40436 3931 35 krithê krithê NNP 40436 3931 36 / / SYM 40436 3931 37 sesthai sesthai NNP 40436 3931 38 . . . 40436 3931 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3931 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3932 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3932 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3932 3 4 4 CD 40436 3932 4 : : : 40436 3932 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3932 6 , , , 40436 3932 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3932 8 , , , 40436 3932 9 185 185 CD 40436 3932 10 C. c. NN 40436 3932 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3932 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3932 13 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3932 14 5 5 CD 40436 3932 15 : : : 40436 3932 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3932 17 , , , 40436 3932 18 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3932 19 , , , 40436 3932 20 185 185 CD 40436 3932 21 E. E. NNP 40436 3932 22 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3932 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3932 24 : : : 40436 3932 25 ei)/ ei)/ NNP 40436 3932 26 tis tis NNP 40436 3932 27 ê(mô ê(mô NNP 40436 3932 28 = = SYM 40436 3932 29 n n CC 40436 3932 30 techniko\s techniko\s CD 40436 3932 31 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 3932 32 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 3932 33 = = SYM 40436 3932 34 s s NNP 40436 3932 35 therapei therapei NNP 40436 3932 36 / / SYM 40436 3932 37 an an DT 40436 3932 38 , , , 40436 3932 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3932 40 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 3932 41 / / SYM 40436 3932 42 s s NNP 40436 3932 43 te te NNP 40436 3932 44 kalô kalô NNP 40436 3932 45 = = SYM 40436 3932 46 s s NNP 40436 3932 47 tou tou NNP 40436 3932 48 = = SYM 40436 3932 49 to to TO 40436 3932 50 therapeu therapeu NNP 40436 3932 51 = = SYM 40436 3932 52 sai sai NNP 40436 3932 53 , , , 40436 3932 54 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3932 55 o(/tô| o(/tô| NNP 40436 3932 56 dida dida NNP 40436 3932 57 / / SYM 40436 3932 58 skaloi skaloi NNP 40436 3932 59 a)gathoi\ a)gathoi\ NNP 40436 3932 60 gego gego NNP 40436 3932 61 / / SYM 40436 3932 62 nasi nasi NNP 40436 3932 63 , , , 40436 3932 64 tou tou NNP 40436 3932 65 = = SYM 40436 3932 66 to to IN 40436 3932 67 skepte skepte NNP 40436 3932 68 / / SYM 40436 3932 69 on on RB 40436 3932 70 . . . 40436 3932 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3932 72 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3933 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3933 2 Side side NN 40436 3933 3 - - HYPH 40436 3933 4 note note NN 40436 3933 5 : : : 40436 3933 6 Those those DT 40436 3933 7 who who WP 40436 3933 8 deliver deliver VBP 40436 3933 9 an an DT 40436 3933 10 opinion opinion NN 40436 3933 11 must must MD 40436 3933 12 begin begin VB 40436 3933 13 by by IN 40436 3933 14 proving prove VBG 40436 3933 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3933 16 competence competence NN 40436 3933 17 to to TO 40436 3933 18 judge judge VB 40436 3933 19 -- -- : 40436 3933 20 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3933 21 avows avow VBZ 40436 3933 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3933 23 own own JJ 40436 3933 24 incompetence incompetence NN 40436 3933 25 . . . 40436 3933 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3934 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3934 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 3934 3 then then RB 40436 3934 4 , , , 40436 3934 5 Lysimachus Lysimachus NNP 40436 3934 6 , , , 40436 3934 7 since since IN 40436 3934 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3934 9 have have VBP 40436 3934 10 invited invite VBN 40436 3934 11 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3934 12 and and CC 40436 3934 13 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3934 14 , , , 40436 3934 15 as as RB 40436 3934 16 well well RB 40436 3934 17 as as IN 40436 3934 18 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3934 19 , , , 40436 3934 20 to to TO 40436 3934 21 advise advise VB 40436 3934 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3934 23 on on IN 40436 3934 24 the the DT 40436 3934 25 means mean NNS 40436 3934 26 of of IN 40436 3934 27 most most RBS 40436 3934 28 effectively effectively RB 40436 3934 29 improving improve VBG 40436 3934 30 the the DT 40436 3934 31 mind mind NN 40436 3934 32 of of IN 40436 3934 33 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3934 34 son son NN 40436 3934 35 , , , 40436 3934 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3934 37 is be VBZ 40436 3934 38 for for IN 40436 3934 39 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3934 40 to to TO 40436 3934 41 show show VB 40436 3934 42 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3934 43 that that IN 40436 3934 44 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3934 45 possess possess VBP 40436 3934 46 competent competent JJ 40436 3934 47 professional professional JJ 40436 3934 48 skill skill NN 40436 3934 49 respecting respect VBG 40436 3934 50 the the DT 40436 3934 51 treatment treatment NN 40436 3934 52 of of IN 40436 3934 53 the the DT 40436 3934 54 youthful youthful JJ 40436 3934 55 mind mind NN 40436 3934 56 . . . 40436 3935 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3935 2 must must MD 40436 3935 3 declare declare VB 40436 3935 4 to to IN 40436 3935 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3935 6 who who WP 40436 3935 7 are be VBP 40436 3935 8 the the DT 40436 3935 9 masters master NNS 40436 3935 10 from from IN 40436 3935 11 whom whom WP 40436 3935 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3935 13 have have VBP 40436 3935 14 learnt learn VBN 40436 3935 15 , , , 40436 3935 16 and and CC 40436 3935 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3935 18 must must MD 40436 3935 19 prove prove VB 40436 3935 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3935 21 qualifications qualification NNS 40436 3935 22 . . . 40436 3936 1 Or or CC 40436 3936 2 if if IN 40436 3936 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3936 4 have have VBP 40436 3936 5 had have VBN 40436 3936 6 no no DT 40436 3936 7 masters master NNS 40436 3936 8 , , , 40436 3936 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3936 10 must must MD 40436 3936 11 demonstrate demonstrate VB 40436 3936 12 to to IN 40436 3936 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3936 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3936 15 own own JJ 40436 3936 16 competence competence NN 40436 3936 17 by by IN 40436 3936 18 citing cite VBG 40436 3936 19 cases case NNS 40436 3936 20 of of IN 40436 3936 21 individuals individual NNS 40436 3936 22 , , , 40436 3936 23 whom whom WP 40436 3936 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3936 25 have have VBP 40436 3936 26 successfully successfully RB 40436 3936 27 trained train VBN 40436 3936 28 , , , 40436 3936 29 and and CC 40436 3936 30 who who WP 40436 3936 31 have have VBP 40436 3936 32 become become VBN 40436 3936 33 incontestably incontestably RB 40436 3936 34 good good JJ 40436 3936 35 under under IN 40436 3936 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3936 37 care care NN 40436 3936 38 . . . 40436 3937 1 If if IN 40436 3937 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3937 3 can can MD 40436 3937 4 fulfil fulfil VB 40436 3937 5 neither neither DT 40436 3937 6 of of IN 40436 3937 7 these these DT 40436 3937 8 two two CD 40436 3937 9 conditions condition NNS 40436 3937 10 , , , 40436 3937 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3937 12 ought ought MD 40436 3937 13 to to TO 40436 3937 14 confess confess VB 40436 3937 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3937 16 incompetence incompetence NN 40436 3937 17 and and CC 40436 3937 18 decline decline NN 40436 3937 19 advising advise VBG 40436 3937 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3937 21 . . . 40436 3938 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3938 2 must must MD 40436 3938 3 not not RB 40436 3938 4 begin begin VB 40436 3938 5 to to TO 40436 3938 6 try try VB 40436 3938 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3938 8 hands hand NNS 40436 3938 9 upon upon IN 40436 3938 10 so so RB 40436 3938 11 precious precious JJ 40436 3938 12 a a DT 40436 3938 13 subject subject NN 40436 3938 14 as as IN 40436 3938 15 the the DT 40436 3938 16 son son NN 40436 3938 17 of of IN 40436 3938 18 a a DT 40436 3938 19 friend friend NN 40436 3938 20 , , , 40436 3938 21 at at IN 40436 3938 22 the the DT 40436 3938 23 hazard hazard NN 40436 3938 24 of of IN 40436 3938 25 doing do VBG 40436 3938 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 3938 27 more more JJR 40436 3938 28 harm harm NN 40436 3938 29 than than IN 40436 3938 30 good good JJ 40436 3938 31 . . . 40436 3939 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3939 2 6 6 CD 40436 3939 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3939 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3939 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3939 6 6 6 CD 40436 3939 7 : : : 40436 3939 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3939 9 , , , 40436 3939 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3939 11 , , , 40436 3939 12 186 186 CD 40436 3939 13 B. b. NN 40436 3939 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3940 1 As as IN 40436 3940 2 to to IN 40436 3940 3 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 3940 4 , , , 40436 3940 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3940 6 frankly frankly RB 40436 3940 7 confess confess VBP 40436 3940 8 that that IN 40436 3940 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3940 10 have have VBP 40436 3940 11 neither neither CC 40436 3940 12 had have VBN 40436 3940 13 any any DT 40436 3940 14 master master NN 40436 3940 15 to to TO 40436 3940 16 impart impart VB 40436 3940 17 to to IN 40436 3940 18 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3940 19 such such JJ 40436 3940 20 competence competence NN 40436 3940 21 , , , 40436 3940 22 nor nor CC 40436 3940 23 have have VBP 40436 3940 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3940 25 been be VBN 40436 3940 26 able able JJ 40436 3940 27 to to TO 40436 3940 28 acquire acquire VB 40436 3940 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3940 30 by by IN 40436 3940 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3940 32 own own JJ 40436 3940 33 efforts effort NNS 40436 3940 34 . . . 40436 3941 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3941 2 am be VBP 40436 3941 3 not not RB 40436 3941 4 rich rich JJ 40436 3941 5 enough enough RB 40436 3941 6 to to TO 40436 3941 7 pay pay VB 40436 3941 8 the the DT 40436 3941 9 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 3941 10 , , , 40436 3941 11 who who WP 40436 3941 12 profess profess VBP 40436 3941 13 to to TO 40436 3941 14 teach teach VB 40436 3941 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3941 16 . . . 40436 3942 1 But but CC 40436 3942 2 as as IN 40436 3942 3 to to IN 40436 3942 4 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3942 5 and and CC 40436 3942 6 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3942 7 , , , 40436 3942 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3942 9 are be VBP 40436 3942 10 both both DT 40436 3942 11 older old JJR 40436 3942 12 and and CC 40436 3942 13 richer rich JJR 40436 3942 14 than than IN 40436 3942 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3942 16 am be VBP 40436 3942 17 : : : 40436 3942 18 so so IN 40436 3942 19 that that IN 40436 3942 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3942 21 may may MD 40436 3942 22 well well RB 40436 3942 23 have have VB 40436 3942 24 learnt learn VBN 40436 3942 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3942 26 from from IN 40436 3942 27 others other NNS 40436 3942 28 , , , 40436 3942 29 or or CC 40436 3942 30 acquired acquire VBD 40436 3942 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3942 32 for for IN 40436 3942 33 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3942 34 . . . 40436 3943 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 3943 2 must must MD 40436 3943 3 be be VB 40436 3943 4 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 3943 5 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 3943 6 of of IN 40436 3943 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3943 8 own own JJ 40436 3943 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 3943 10 on on IN 40436 3943 11 the the DT 40436 3943 12 work work NN 40436 3943 13 of of IN 40436 3943 14 education education NN 40436 3943 15 ; ; : 40436 3943 16 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 3943 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3943 18 would would MD 40436 3943 19 hardly hardly RB 40436 3943 20 have have VB 40436 3943 21 given give VBN 40436 3943 22 such such JJ 40436 3943 23 confident confident JJ 40436 3943 24 opinions opinion NNS 40436 3943 25 , , , 40436 3943 26 pronouncing pronounce VBG 40436 3943 27 what what WDT 40436 3943 28 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 3943 29 are be VBP 40436 3943 30 good good JJ 40436 3943 31 or or CC 40436 3943 32 bad bad JJ 40436 3943 33 for for IN 40436 3943 34 youth youth NN 40436 3943 35 . . . 40436 3944 1 For for IN 40436 3944 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3944 3 part part NN 40436 3944 4 , , , 40436 3944 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3944 6 trust trust VBP 40436 3944 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3944 8 implicitly implicitly RB 40436 3944 9 : : : 40436 3944 10 the the DT 40436 3944 11 only only JJ 40436 3944 12 thing thing NN 40436 3944 13 which which WDT 40436 3944 14 surprises surprise VBZ 40436 3944 15 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3944 16 , , , 40436 3944 17 is be VBZ 40436 3944 18 , , , 40436 3944 19 that that IN 40436 3944 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3944 21 dissent dissent VBP 40436 3944 22 from from IN 40436 3944 23 each each DT 40436 3944 24 other other JJ 40436 3944 25 . . . 40436 3945 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3945 2 7 7 CD 40436 3945 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3945 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 3945 5 is be VBZ 40436 3945 6 for for IN 40436 3945 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3945 8 therefore therefore RB 40436 3945 9 , , , 40436 3945 10 Lysimachus Lysimachus NNP 40436 3945 11 , , , 40436 3945 12 to to TO 40436 3945 13 ask ask VB 40436 3945 14 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3945 15 and and CC 40436 3945 16 Lachês,--Who Lachês,--Who NNP 40436 3945 17 have have VBP 40436 3945 18 been be VBN 40436 3945 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3945 20 masters master NNS 40436 3945 21 ? ? . 40436 3946 1 Who who WP 40436 3946 2 have have VBP 40436 3946 3 been be VBN 40436 3946 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3946 5 fellow fellow JJ 40436 3946 6 - - HYPH 40436 3946 7 pupils pupil NNS 40436 3946 8 ? ? . 40436 3947 1 If if IN 40436 3947 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3947 3 have have VBP 40436 3947 4 been be VBN 40436 3947 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3947 6 own own JJ 40436 3947 7 masters master NNS 40436 3947 8 , , , 40436 3947 9 what what WDT 40436 3947 10 proof proof NN 40436 3947 11 can can MD 40436 3947 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3947 13 produce produce VB 40436 3947 14 of of IN 40436 3947 15 previous previous JJ 40436 3947 16 success success NN 40436 3947 17 in in IN 40436 3947 18 teaching teaching NN 40436 3947 19 , , , 40436 3947 20 and and CC 40436 3947 21 what what WDT 40436 3947 22 examples example NNS 40436 3947 23 can can MD 40436 3947 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3947 25 cite cite VB 40436 3947 26 of of IN 40436 3947 27 pupils pupil NNS 40436 3947 28 whom whom WP 40436 3947 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 3947 30 have have VBP 40436 3947 31 converted convert VBN 40436 3947 32 from from IN 40436 3947 33 bad bad JJ 40436 3947 34 to to IN 40436 3947 35 good good JJ 40436 3947 36 ? ? . 40436 3948 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3948 2 8 8 CD 40436 3948 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3948 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3948 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3948 6 7 7 CD 40436 3948 7 : : : 40436 3948 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3948 9 , , , 40436 3948 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3948 11 , , , 40436 3948 12 186 186 CD 40436 3948 13 C C NNP 40436 3948 14 - - HYPH 40436 3948 15 D. D. NNP 40436 3948 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3948 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3948 18 : : : 40436 3948 19 dokou dokou NN 40436 3948 20 = = SYM 40436 3948 21 si si NNP 40436 3948 22 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 3948 23 moi moi NNP 40436 3948 24 dunatoi\ dunatoi\ NNP 40436 3948 25 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 3948 26 paideu paideu NNP 40436 3948 27 = = NFP 40436 3948 28 sai sai NNP 40436 3948 29 a)/nthrôpon a)/nthrôpon NNP 40436 3948 30 ; ; : 40436 3948 31 ou ou NNP 40436 3948 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3948 33 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3948 34 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 3948 35 pote pote NNP 40436 3948 36 a)deô a)deô NNP 40436 3948 37 = = SYM 40436 3948 38 s s NNP 40436 3948 39 a)pephai a)pephai NNP 40436 3948 40 / / SYM 40436 3948 41 nonto nonto NNP 40436 3948 42 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 3948 43 e)pitêdeuma e)pitêdeuma NNP 40436 3948 44 / / SYM 40436 3948 45 tôn tôn NNP 40436 3948 46 ne ne NNP 40436 3948 47 / / SYM 40436 3948 48 ô| ô| NNP 40436 3948 49 chrêstô chrêstô NNP 40436 3948 50 = = SYM 40436 3948 51 n n CC 40436 3948 52 te te NNP 40436 3948 53 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3948 54 ponêrô ponêrô NNP 40436 3948 55 = = SYM 40436 3948 56 n n NNP 40436 3948 57 , , , 40436 3948 58 ei ei NNP 40436 3948 59 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3948 60 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 3948 61 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 3948 62 = = NN 40436 3948 63 s s NN 40436 3948 64 e)pi e)pi NN 40436 3948 65 / / SYM 40436 3948 66 steuon steuon JJ 40436 3948 67 i(kanô i(kanô NNS 40436 3948 68 = = NFP 40436 3948 69 s s NNP 40436 3948 70 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 3948 71 / / SYM 40436 3948 72 nai nai NN 40436 3948 73 . . . 40436 3949 1 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 3949 2 me\n me\n NNP 40436 3949 3 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 3949 4 a)/lla a)/lla NNP 40436 3949 5 , , , 40436 3949 6 e)/gôge e)/gôge NNP 40436 3949 7 tou tou NNP 40436 3949 8 / / SYM 40436 3949 9 tois tois NNP 40436 3949 10 pisteu pisteu NNP 40436 3949 11 / / SYM 40436 3949 12 ô ô NNP 40436 3949 13 , , , 40436 3949 14 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 3949 15 de\ de\ NNP 40436 3949 16 diaphe diaphe NNP 40436 3949 17 / / SYM 40436 3949 18 resthon resthon NNP 40436 3949 19 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 3949 20 / / SYM 40436 3949 21 loin loin NNP 40436 3949 22 , , , 40436 3949 23 e)thau e)thau NNP 40436 3949 24 / / SYM 40436 3949 25 masa masa NNP 40436 3949 26 . . . 40436 3949 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3949 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3950 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3950 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3950 3 8 8 CD 40436 3950 4 : : : 40436 3950 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3950 6 , , , 40436 3950 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3950 8 , , , 40436 3950 9 186 186 CD 40436 3950 10 - - SYM 40436 3950 11 187 187 CD 40436 3950 12 . . . 40436 3950 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3951 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3951 2 Side side NN 40436 3951 3 - - HYPH 40436 3951 4 note note NN 40436 3951 5 : : : 40436 3951 6 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3951 7 and and CC 40436 3951 8 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3951 9 submit submit VBP 40436 3951 10 to to TO 40436 3951 11 be be VB 40436 3951 12 cross cros VBN 40436 3951 13 - - VBN 40436 3951 14 examined examine VBN 40436 3951 15 by by IN 40436 3951 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3951 17 . . . 40436 3951 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3952 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3952 2 Nikias._--I Nikias._--I NNP 40436 3952 3 knew know VBD 40436 3952 4 from from IN 40436 3952 5 the the DT 40436 3952 6 beginning beginning NN 40436 3952 7 that that IN 40436 3952 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3952 9 should should MD 40436 3952 10 both both DT 40436 3952 11 of of IN 40436 3952 12 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3952 13 fall fall VBP 40436 3952 14 under under IN 40436 3952 15 the the DT 40436 3952 16 cross cross NN 40436 3952 17 - - NN 40436 3952 18 examination examination NN 40436 3952 19 of of IN 40436 3952 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3952 21 , , , 40436 3952 22 and and CC 40436 3952 23 be be VB 40436 3952 24 compelled compel VBN 40436 3952 25 to to TO 40436 3952 26 give give VB 40436 3952 27 account account NN 40436 3952 28 of of IN 40436 3952 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3952 30 past past JJ 40436 3952 31 lives life NNS 40436 3952 32 . . . 40436 3953 1 For for IN 40436 3953 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3953 3 part part NN 40436 3953 4 , , , 40436 3953 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3953 6 have have VBP 40436 3953 7 already already RB 40436 3953 8 gone go VBN 40436 3953 9 through through IN 40436 3953 10 this this DT 40436 3953 11 scrutiny scrutiny NN 40436 3953 12 before before RB 40436 3953 13 , , , 40436 3953 14 and and CC 40436 3953 15 am be VBP 40436 3953 16 not not RB 40436 3953 17 averse averse JJ 40436 3953 18 to to TO 40436 3953 19 undergo undergo VB 40436 3953 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3953 21 again again RB 40436 3953 22 . . . 40436 3954 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3954 2 Lachês._--And Lachês._--And NNP 40436 3954 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3954 4 , , , 40436 3954 5 though though IN 40436 3954 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3954 7 have have VBP 40436 3954 8 never never RB 40436 3954 9 experienced experience VBN 40436 3954 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3954 11 before before RB 40436 3954 12 , , , 40436 3954 13 shall shall MD 40436 3954 14 willingly willingly RB 40436 3954 15 submit submit VB 40436 3954 16 to to TO 40436 3954 17 learn learn VB 40436 3954 18 from from IN 40436 3954 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3954 20 , , , 40436 3954 21 whom whom WP 40436 3954 22 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3954 23 know know VBP 40436 3954 24 to to TO 40436 3954 25 be be VB 40436 3954 26 a a DT 40436 3954 27 man man NN 40436 3954 28 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 3954 29 courageous courageous JJ 40436 3954 30 and and CC 40436 3954 31 honest honest JJ 40436 3954 32 in in IN 40436 3954 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3954 34 actions action NNS 40436 3954 35 . . . 40436 3955 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 3955 2 hate hate VBP 40436 3955 3 men man NNS 40436 3955 4 whose whose WP$ 40436 3955 5 lives life NNS 40436 3955 6 are be VBP 40436 3955 7 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 3955 8 with with IN 40436 3955 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3955 10 talk talk NN 40436 3955 11 . . . 40436 3956 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3956 2 9]--Thus 9]--thus CD 40436 3956 3 speak speak VBP 40436 3956 4 both both DT 40436 3956 5 of of IN 40436 3956 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3956 7 . . . 40436 3957 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3957 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3957 3 9 9 CD 40436 3957 4 : : : 40436 3957 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3957 6 , , , 40436 3957 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3957 8 , , , 40436 3957 9 188 188 CD 40436 3957 10 . . . 40436 3958 1 " " `` 40436 3958 2 Ego Ego NNP 40436 3958 3 odi odi NNP 40436 3958 4 homines homines NNP 40436 3958 5 ignavâ ignavâ NNP 40436 3958 6 operâ operâ NNP 40436 3958 7 et et NNP 40436 3958 8 philosophiâ philosophiâ NN 40436 3958 9 sententiâ sententiâ VBP 40436 3958 10 , , , 40436 3958 11 " " '' 40436 3958 12 is be VBZ 40436 3958 13 a a DT 40436 3958 14 line line NN 40436 3958 15 cited cite VBN 40436 3958 16 by by IN 40436 3958 17 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 3958 18 out out IN 40436 3958 19 of of IN 40436 3958 20 one one CD 40436 3958 21 of of IN 40436 3958 22 the the DT 40436 3958 23 Latin latin JJ 40436 3958 24 comic comic JJ 40436 3958 25 writers writer NNS 40436 3958 26 . . . 40436 3958 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3959 1 * * NFP 40436 3959 2 * * NFP 40436 3959 3 * * NFP 40436 3959 4 * * NFP 40436 3959 5 * * NFP 40436 3959 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3959 7 Side side NN 40436 3959 8 - - HYPH 40436 3959 9 note note NN 40436 3959 10 : : : 40436 3959 11 Both both DT 40436 3959 12 of of IN 40436 3959 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3959 14 give give VBP 40436 3959 15 opinions opinion NNS 40436 3959 16 offhand offhand JJ 40436 3959 17 , , , 40436 3959 18 according accord VBG 40436 3959 19 to to IN 40436 3959 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3959 21 feelings feeling NNS 40436 3959 22 on on IN 40436 3959 23 the the DT 40436 3959 24 special special JJ 40436 3959 25 case case NN 40436 3959 26 -- -- : 40436 3959 27 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 3959 28 requires require VBZ 40436 3959 29 that that IN 40436 3959 30 the the DT 40436 3959 31 question question NN 40436 3959 32 shall shall MD 40436 3959 33 be be VB 40436 3959 34 generalised generalise VBN 40436 3959 35 , , , 40436 3959 36 and and CC 40436 3959 37 examined examine VBD 40436 3959 38 as as IN 40436 3959 39 a a DT 40436 3959 40 branch branch NN 40436 3959 41 of of IN 40436 3959 42 education education NN 40436 3959 43 . . . 40436 3959 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3960 1 This this DT 40436 3960 2 portion portion NN 40436 3960 3 of of IN 40436 3960 4 the the DT 40436 3960 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 3960 6 , , , 40436 3960 7 which which WDT 40436 3960 8 forms form VBZ 40436 3960 9 a a DT 40436 3960 10 sort sort NN 40436 3960 11 of of IN 40436 3960 12 preamble preamble NN 40436 3960 13 to to IN 40436 3960 14 the the DT 40436 3960 15 main main JJ 40436 3960 16 discussion discussion NN 40436 3960 17 , , , 40436 3960 18 brings bring VBZ 40436 3960 19 out out RP 40436 3960 20 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 3960 21 some some DT 40436 3960 22 of of IN 40436 3960 23 the the DT 40436 3960 24 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3960 25 points point NNS 40436 3960 26 of of IN 40436 3960 27 view view NN 40436 3960 28 . . . 40436 3961 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3961 2 have have VBP 40436 3961 3 seen see VBN 40436 3961 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3961 5 laid lay VBN 40436 3961 6 down down RP 40436 3961 7 in in IN 40436 3961 8 the the DT 40436 3961 9 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 3961 10 -- -- : 40436 3961 11 That that IN 40436 3961 12 in in IN 40436 3961 13 questions question NNS 40436 3961 14 about about IN 40436 3961 15 right right JJ 40436 3961 16 and and CC 40436 3961 17 wrong wrong JJ 40436 3961 18 , , , 40436 3961 19 good good JJ 40436 3961 20 and and CC 40436 3961 21 evil evil NN 40436 3961 22 , , , 40436 3961 23 & & CC 40436 3961 24 c. c. NNP 40436 3961 25 , , , 40436 3961 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3961 27 ought ought MD 40436 3961 28 not not RB 40436 3961 29 to to TO 40436 3961 30 trust trust VB 40436 3961 31 the the DT 40436 3961 32 decision decision NN 40436 3961 33 of of IN 40436 3961 34 the the DT 40436 3961 35 Many many JJ 40436 3961 36 , , , 40436 3961 37 but but CC 40436 3961 38 only only RB 40436 3961 39 that that DT 40436 3961 40 of of IN 40436 3961 41 the the DT 40436 3961 42 One one CD 40436 3961 43 Wise Wise NNP 40436 3961 44 Man Man NNP 40436 3961 45 . . . 40436 3962 1 Here here RB 40436 3962 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3962 3 learn learn VBP 40436 3962 4 something something NN 40436 3962 5 about about IN 40436 3962 6 the the DT 40436 3962 7 criteria criterion NNS 40436 3962 8 by by IN 40436 3962 9 which which WDT 40436 3962 10 this this DT 40436 3962 11 One one CD 40436 3962 12 man man NN 40436 3962 13 may may MD 40436 3962 14 be be VB 40436 3962 15 known know VBN 40436 3962 16 . . . 40436 3963 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 3963 2 must must MD 40436 3963 3 be be VB 40436 3963 4 one one CD 40436 3963 5 who who WP 40436 3963 6 has have VBZ 40436 3963 7 gone go VBN 40436 3963 8 through through IN 40436 3963 9 a a DT 40436 3963 10 regular regular JJ 40436 3963 11 training training NN 40436 3963 12 under under IN 40436 3963 13 some some DT 40436 3963 14 master master NN 40436 3963 15 approved approve VBN 40436 3963 16 in in IN 40436 3963 17 ethical ethical JJ 40436 3963 18 or or CC 40436 3963 19 educational educational JJ 40436 3963 20 teaching teaching NN 40436 3963 21 : : : 40436 3963 22 or or CC 40436 3963 23 , , , 40436 3963 24 if if IN 40436 3963 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3963 26 can can MD 40436 3963 27 not not RB 40436 3963 28 produce produce VB 40436 3963 29 such such PDT 40436 3963 30 a a DT 40436 3963 31 certificate certificate NN 40436 3963 32 , , , 40436 3963 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3963 34 must must MD 40436 3963 35 at at IN 40436 3963 36 least least JJS 40436 3963 37 cite cite VB 40436 3963 38 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 3963 39 examples example NNS 40436 3963 40 of of IN 40436 3963 41 men man NNS 40436 3963 42 whom whom WP 40436 3963 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3963 44 has have VBZ 40436 3963 45 taught teach VBN 40436 3963 46 well well UH 40436 3963 47 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 3963 48 . . . 40436 3964 1 This this DT 40436 3964 2 is be VBZ 40436 3964 3 the the DT 40436 3964 4 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 3964 5 comparison comparison NN 40436 3964 6 , , , 40436 3964 7 assimilating assimilate VBG 40436 3964 8 the the DT 40436 3964 9 general general JJ 40436 3964 10 art art NN 40436 3964 11 of of IN 40436 3964 12 living live VBG 40436 3964 13 well well RB 40436 3964 14 to to IN 40436 3964 15 the the DT 40436 3964 16 requirements requirement NNS 40436 3964 17 of of IN 40436 3964 18 a a DT 40436 3964 19 special special JJ 40436 3964 20 profession profession NN 40436 3964 21 , , , 40436 3964 22 which which WDT 40436 3964 23 a a DT 40436 3964 24 man man NN 40436 3964 25 must must MD 40436 3964 26 learn learn VB 40436 3964 27 through through IN 40436 3964 28 express express JJ 40436 3964 29 teaching teaching NN 40436 3964 30 , , , 40436 3964 31 from from IN 40436 3964 32 a a DT 40436 3964 33 master master NN 40436 3964 34 who who WP 40436 3964 35 has have VBZ 40436 3964 36 proved prove VBN 40436 3964 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3964 38 ability ability NN 40436 3964 39 , , , 40436 3964 40 and and CC 40436 3964 41 through through IN 40436 3964 42 conscious conscious JJ 40436 3964 43 application application NN 40436 3964 44 of of IN 40436 3964 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3964 46 own own JJ 40436 3964 47 . . . 40436 3965 1 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3965 2 and and CC 40436 3965 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3965 4 give give VBP 40436 3965 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3965 6 opinions opinion NNS 40436 3965 7 offhand offhand JJ 40436 3965 8 and and CC 40436 3965 9 confidently confidently RB 40436 3965 10 , , , 40436 3965 11 upon upon IN 40436 3965 12 the the DT 40436 3965 13 question question NN 40436 3965 14 whether whether IN 40436 3965 15 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3965 16 from from IN 40436 3965 17 the the DT 40436 3965 18 master master NN 40436 3965 19 of of IN 40436 3965 20 arms arm NNS 40436 3965 21 be be VB 40436 3965 22 profitable profitable JJ 40436 3965 23 to to IN 40436 3965 24 youth youth NN 40436 3965 25 or or CC 40436 3965 26 not not RB 40436 3965 27 . . . 40436 3966 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3966 2 , , , 40436 3966 3 on on IN 40436 3966 4 the the DT 40436 3966 5 contrary contrary NN 40436 3966 6 , , , 40436 3966 7 speaking speak VBG 40436 3966 8 through through IN 40436 3966 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 3966 10 , , , 40436 3966 11 points point VBZ 40436 3966 12 out out RP 40436 3966 13 that that IN 40436 3966 14 this this DT 40436 3966 15 is be VBZ 40436 3966 16 only only RB 40436 3966 17 one one CD 40436 3966 18 branch branch NN 40436 3966 19 of of IN 40436 3966 20 the the DT 40436 3966 21 more more RBR 40436 3966 22 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 3966 23 question question NN 40436 3966 24 as as IN 40436 3966 25 to to IN 40436 3966 26 education education NN 40436 3966 27 generally--"What generally--"what DT 40436 3966 28 are be VBP 40436 3966 29 the the DT 40436 3966 30 qualities quality NNS 40436 3966 31 and and CC 40436 3966 32 habits habit NNS 40436 3966 33 proper proper JJ 40436 3966 34 to to TO 40436 3966 35 be be VB 40436 3966 36 imparted impart VBN 40436 3966 37 to to IN 40436 3966 38 youth youth NN 40436 3966 39 by by IN 40436 3966 40 training training NN 40436 3966 41 ? ? . 40436 3967 1 What what WP 40436 3967 2 is be VBZ 40436 3967 3 the the DT 40436 3967 4 proper proper JJ 40436 3967 5 treatment treatment NN 40436 3967 6 of of IN 40436 3967 7 the the DT 40436 3967 8 mind mind NN 40436 3967 9 ? ? . 40436 3968 1 No no DT 40436 3968 2 one one NN 40436 3968 3 is be VBZ 40436 3968 4 competent competent JJ 40436 3968 5 to to TO 40436 3968 6 decide decide VB 40436 3968 7 the the DT 40436 3968 8 special special JJ 40436 3968 9 question question NN 40436 3968 10 , , , 40436 3968 11 except except IN 40436 3968 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 3968 13 who who WP 40436 3968 14 has have VBZ 40436 3968 15 professionally professionally RB 40436 3968 16 studied study VBN 40436 3968 17 the the DT 40436 3968 18 treatment treatment NN 40436 3968 19 of of IN 40436 3968 20 the the DT 40436 3968 21 mind mind NN 40436 3968 22 . . . 40436 3968 23 " " '' 40436 3969 1 To to TO 40436 3969 2 deal deal VB 40436 3969 3 with with IN 40436 3969 4 the the DT 40436 3969 5 special special JJ 40436 3969 6 question question NN 40436 3969 7 , , , 40436 3969 8 without without IN 40436 3969 9 such such JJ 40436 3969 10 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 3969 11 general general JJ 40436 3969 12 preparation preparation NN 40436 3969 13 , , , 40436 3969 14 involves involve VBZ 40436 3969 15 rash rash JJ 40436 3969 16 and and CC 40436 3969 17 unverified unverified JJ 40436 3969 18 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 3969 19 , , , 40436 3969 20 which which WDT 40436 3969 21 render render VBP 40436 3969 22 any any DT 40436 3969 23 opinion opinion NN 40436 3969 24 so so RB 40436 3969 25 given give VBN 40436 3969 26 dangerous dangerous JJ 40436 3969 27 to to TO 40436 3969 28 act act VB 40436 3969 29 upon upon IN 40436 3969 30 . . . 40436 3970 1 Such such JJ 40436 3970 2 is be VBZ 40436 3970 3 the the DT 40436 3970 4 judgment judgment NN 40436 3970 5 of of IN 40436 3970 6 the the DT 40436 3970 7 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 3970 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3970 9 , , , 40436 3970 10 insisting insist VBG 40436 3970 11 on on IN 40436 3970 12 the the DT 40436 3970 13 necessity necessity NN 40436 3970 14 of of IN 40436 3970 15 taking take VBG 40436 3970 16 up up RP 40436 3970 17 ethical ethical JJ 40436 3970 18 questions question NNS 40436 3970 19 in in IN 40436 3970 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3970 21 most most RBS 40436 3970 22 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 3970 23 aspect aspect NN 40436 3970 24 . . . 40436 3971 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3971 2 Side side NN 40436 3971 3 - - HYPH 40436 3971 4 note note NN 40436 3971 5 : : : 40436 3971 6 Appeal appeal NN 40436 3971 7 of of IN 40436 3971 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 3971 9 to to IN 40436 3971 10 the the DT 40436 3971 11 judgment judgment NN 40436 3971 12 of of IN 40436 3971 13 the the DT 40436 3971 14 One one CD 40436 3971 15 Wise Wise NNP 40436 3971 16 Man Man NNP 40436 3971 17 -- -- : 40436 3971 18 this this DT 40436 3971 19 man man NN 40436 3971 20 is be VBZ 40436 3971 21 never never RB 40436 3971 22 seen see VBN 40436 3971 23 or or CC 40436 3971 24 identified identify VBN 40436 3971 25 . . . 40436 3971 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3972 1 Consequent consequent NN 40436 3972 2 upon upon IN 40436 3972 3 this this DT 40436 3972 4 preamble preamble NN 40436 3972 5 , , , 40436 3972 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3972 7 should should MD 40436 3972 8 expect expect VB 40436 3972 9 that that IN 40436 3972 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3972 11 and and CC 40436 3972 12 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 3972 13 would would MD 40436 3972 14 be be VB 40436 3972 15 made make VBN 40436 3972 16 to to TO 40436 3972 17 cite cite VB 40436 3972 18 the the DT 40436 3972 19 names name NNS 40436 3972 20 of of IN 40436 3972 21 those those DT 40436 3972 22 who who WP 40436 3972 23 had have VBD 40436 3972 24 been be VBN 40436 3972 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3972 26 masters master NNS 40436 3972 27 ; ; : 40436 3972 28 or or CC 40436 3972 29 to to TO 40436 3972 30 produce produce VB 40436 3972 31 some some DT 40436 3972 32 examples example NNS 40436 3972 33 of of IN 40436 3972 34 persons person NNS 40436 3972 35 effectively effectively RB 40436 3972 36 taught teach VBN 40436 3972 37 by by IN 40436 3972 38 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3972 39 . . . 40436 3973 1 This this DT 40436 3973 2 would would MD 40436 3973 3 bring bring VB 40436 3973 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 3973 5 a a DT 40436 3973 6 step step NN 40436 3973 7 nearer nearer RB 40436 3973 8 to to IN 40436 3973 9 that that DT 40436 3973 10 One one CD 40436 3973 11 Wise Wise NNP 40436 3973 12 Man Man NNP 40436 3973 13 -- -- : 40436 3973 14 often often RB 40436 3973 15 darkly darkly RB 40436 3973 16 indicated indicate VBN 40436 3973 17 , , , 40436 3973 18 but but CC 40436 3973 19 nowhere nowhere RB 40436 3973 20 named name VBN 40436 3973 21 or or CC 40436 3973 22 brought bring VBN 40436 3973 23 into into IN 40436 3973 24 daylight daylight NN 40436 3973 25 -- -- : 40436 3973 26 from from IN 40436 3973 27 whom whom WP 40436 3973 28 alone alone RB 40436 3973 29 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3973 30 can can MD 40436 3973 31 receive receive VB 40436 3973 32 a a DT 40436 3973 33 trustworthy trustworthy JJ 40436 3973 34 judgment judgment NN 40436 3973 35 . . . 40436 3974 1 But but CC 40436 3974 2 here here RB 40436 3974 3 , , , 40436 3974 4 as as IN 40436 3974 5 in in IN 40436 3974 6 the the DT 40436 3974 7 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 3974 8 and and CC 40436 3974 9 so so RB 40436 3974 10 many many JJ 40436 3974 11 other other JJ 40436 3974 12 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 3974 13 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 3974 14 , , , 40436 3974 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3974 16 get get VBP 40436 3974 17 only only RB 40436 3974 18 a a DT 40436 3974 19 Pisgah pisgah JJ 40436 3974 20 view view NN 40436 3974 21 of of IN 40436 3974 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3974 23 promised promise VBN 40436 3974 24 adviser adviser NN 40436 3974 25 -- -- : 40436 3974 26 nothing nothing NN 40436 3974 27 more more JJR 40436 3974 28 . . . 40436 3975 1 The the DT 40436 3975 2 discussion discussion NN 40436 3975 3 takes take VBZ 40436 3975 4 a a DT 40436 3975 5 different different JJ 40436 3975 6 turn turn NN 40436 3975 7 . . . 40436 3976 1 * * NFP 40436 3976 2 * * NFP 40436 3976 3 * * NFP 40436 3976 4 * * NFP 40436 3976 5 * * NFP 40436 3976 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3976 7 Side side NN 40436 3976 8 - - HYPH 40436 3976 9 note note NN 40436 3976 10 : : : 40436 3976 11 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3976 12 must must MD 40436 3976 13 know know VB 40436 3976 14 what what WP 40436 3976 15 virtue virtue NN 40436 3976 16 is be VBZ 40436 3976 17 , , , 40436 3976 18 before before IN 40436 3976 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3976 20 give give VBP 40436 3976 21 an an DT 40436 3976 22 opinion opinion NN 40436 3976 23 on on IN 40436 3976 24 education education NN 40436 3976 25 . . . 40436 3977 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 3977 2 , , , 40436 3977 3 as as IN 40436 3977 4 a a DT 40436 3977 5 whole whole NN 40436 3977 6 , , , 40436 3977 7 is be VBZ 40436 3977 8 too too RB 40436 3977 9 large large JJ 40436 3977 10 a a DT 40436 3977 11 question question NN 40436 3977 12 . . . 40436 3978 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3978 2 will will MD 40436 3978 3 enquire enquire VB 40436 3978 4 about about IN 40436 3978 5 one one CD 40436 3978 6 branch branch NN 40436 3978 7 of of IN 40436 3978 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 3978 9 -- -- : 40436 3978 10 courage courage NN 40436 3978 11 . . . 40436 3978 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3979 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3979 2 Sokr._--"We Sokr._--"We NNP 40436 3979 3 will will MD 40436 3979 4 pursue pursue VB 40436 3979 5 a a DT 40436 3979 6 line line NN 40436 3979 7 of of IN 40436 3979 8 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 3979 9 which which WDT 40436 3979 10 conducts conduct VBZ 40436 3979 11 to to IN 40436 3979 12 the the DT 40436 3979 13 same same JJ 40436 3979 14 result result NN 40436 3979 15 ; ; : 40436 3979 16 and and CC 40436 3979 17 which which WDT 40436 3979 18 starts start VBZ 40436 3979 19 even even RB 40436 3979 20 more more RBR 40436 3979 21 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 3979 22 from from IN 40436 3979 23 the the DT 40436 3979 24 beginning beginning NN 40436 3979 25 . . . 40436 3980 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3980 2 10 10 CD 40436 3980 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3980 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3980 5 are be VBP 40436 3980 6 called call VBN 40436 3980 7 upon upon IN 40436 3980 8 to to TO 40436 3980 9 advise advise VB 40436 3980 10 by by IN 40436 3980 11 what what WP 40436 3980 12 means mean VBZ 40436 3980 13 virtue virtue NNP 40436 3980 14 can can MD 40436 3980 15 be be VB 40436 3980 16 imparted impart VBN 40436 3980 17 to to IN 40436 3980 18 these these DT 40436 3980 19 youths youth NNS 40436 3980 20 , , , 40436 3980 21 so so IN 40436 3980 22 as as IN 40436 3980 23 to to TO 40436 3980 24 make make VB 40436 3980 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 3980 26 better well JJR 40436 3980 27 men man NNS 40436 3980 28 . . . 40436 3981 1 Of of RB 40436 3981 2 course course RB 40436 3981 3 , , , 40436 3981 4 this this DT 40436 3981 5 implies imply VBZ 40436 3981 6 that that IN 40436 3981 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3981 8 know know VBP 40436 3981 9 what what WP 40436 3981 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 3981 11 is be VBZ 40436 3981 12 : : : 40436 3981 13 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 3981 14 how how WRB 40436 3981 15 can can MD 40436 3981 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3981 17 give give VB 40436 3981 18 advice advice NN 40436 3981 19 as as IN 40436 3981 20 to to IN 40436 3981 21 the the DT 40436 3981 22 means mean NNS 40436 3981 23 of of IN 40436 3981 24 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 3981 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3981 26 ? ? . 40436 3982 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3982 2 Lachês._--We Lachês._--We NNP 40436 3982 3 could could MD 40436 3982 4 give give VB 40436 3982 5 no no DT 40436 3982 6 advice advice NN 40436 3982 7 at at RB 40436 3982 8 all all RB 40436 3982 9 . . . 40436 3983 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3983 2 Sokr._--We Sokr._--We NNP 40436 3983 3 affirm affirm VBP 40436 3983 4 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 3983 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 3983 6 to to TO 40436 3983 7 know know VB 40436 3983 8 what what WP 40436 3983 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 3983 10 is be VBZ 40436 3983 11 ? ? . 40436 3984 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3984 2 Lachês._--We Lachês._--We NNP 40436 3984 3 do do VBP 40436 3984 4 . . . 40436 3985 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3985 2 Sokr._--Since Sokr._--Since NNP 40436 3985 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 3985 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3985 5 know know VBP 40436 3985 6 , , , 40436 3985 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3985 8 can can MD 40436 3985 9 farther farther RB 40436 3985 10 declare declare VB 40436 3985 11 what what WP 40436 3985 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3985 13 is be VBZ 40436 3985 14 . . . 40436 3986 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3986 2 11 11 CD 40436 3986 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3986 4 _ _ NNP 40436 3986 5 Lachês._--Of Lachês._--Of NNS 40436 3986 6 course course NN 40436 3986 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3986 8 can can MD 40436 3986 9 . . . 40436 3987 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3987 2 Sokr._--Still Sokr._--Still NNP 40436 3987 3 , , , 40436 3987 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3987 5 will will MD 40436 3987 6 not not RB 40436 3987 7 at at RB 40436 3987 8 once once RB 40436 3987 9 enquire enquire VB 40436 3987 10 as as IN 40436 3987 11 to to IN 40436 3987 12 the the DT 40436 3987 13 whole whole NN 40436 3987 14 of of IN 40436 3987 15 virtue virtue NN 40436 3987 16 , , , 40436 3987 17 which which WDT 40436 3987 18 might may MD 40436 3987 19 be be VB 40436 3987 20 an an DT 40436 3987 21 arduous arduous JJ 40436 3987 22 task task NN 40436 3987 23 , , , 40436 3987 24 but but CC 40436 3987 25 as as IN 40436 3987 26 to to IN 40436 3987 27 a a DT 40436 3987 28 part part NN 40436 3987 29 of of IN 40436 3987 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3987 31 -- -- : 40436 3987 32 Courage courage NN 40436 3987 33 : : : 40436 3987 34 that that DT 40436 3987 35 part part NN 40436 3987 36 to to TO 40436 3987 37 which which WDT 40436 3987 38 the the DT 40436 3987 39 lessons lesson NNS 40436 3987 40 of of IN 40436 3987 41 the the DT 40436 3987 42 master master NN 40436 3987 43 of of IN 40436 3987 44 arms arm NNS 40436 3987 45 are be VBP 40436 3987 46 supposed suppose VBN 40436 3987 47 to to TO 40436 3987 48 tend tend VB 40436 3987 49 . . . 40436 3988 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 3988 2 will will MD 40436 3988 3 first first RB 40436 3988 4 enquire enquire VB 40436 3988 5 what what WDT 40436 3988 6 courage courage NN 40436 3988 7 is be VBZ 40436 3988 8 : : : 40436 3988 9 after after IN 40436 3988 10 that that DT 40436 3988 11 has have VBZ 40436 3988 12 been be VBN 40436 3988 13 determined determine VBN 40436 3988 14 , , , 40436 3988 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 3988 16 will will MD 40436 3988 17 then then RB 40436 3988 18 consider consider VB 40436 3988 19 how how WRB 40436 3988 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 3988 21 can can MD 40436 3988 22 best well RBS 40436 3988 23 be be VB 40436 3988 24 imparted impart VBN 40436 3988 25 to to IN 40436 3988 26 these these DT 40436 3988 27 youths youth NNS 40436 3988 28 . . . 40436 3988 29 " " '' 40436 3989 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3989 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3989 3 10 10 CD 40436 3989 4 : : : 40436 3989 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3989 6 , , , 40436 3989 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3989 8 , , , 40436 3989 9 189 189 CD 40436 3989 10 E. E. NNP 40436 3989 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3989 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3989 13 : : : 40436 3989 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3989 15 ê ê NNP 40436 3989 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3989 17 toia toia NNP 40436 3989 18 / / SYM 40436 3989 19 de de NNP 40436 3989 20 ske ske NN 40436 3989 21 / / SYM 40436 3989 22 psis psis NN 40436 3989 23 ei)s ei)s , 40436 3989 24 tau)to\n tau)to\n NNP 40436 3989 25 phe phe NN 40436 3989 26 / / SYM 40436 3989 27 rei rei NN 40436 3989 28 , , , 40436 3989 29 schedo\n schedo\n ADD 40436 3989 30 de/ de/ NNP 40436 3989 31 ti ti NNP 40436 3989 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 3989 33 ma ma NNP 40436 3989 34 = = SYM 40436 3989 35 llon llon NNP 40436 3989 36 e)x e)x NNP 40436 3989 37 a)rchê a)rchê SYM 40436 3989 38 = = SYM 40436 3989 39 s s NN 40436 3989 40 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 3989 41 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 3989 42 . . . 40436 3989 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3989 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3990 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3990 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 3990 3 11 11 CD 40436 3990 4 : : : 40436 3990 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3990 6 , , , 40436 3990 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3990 8 , , , 40436 3990 9 190 190 CD 40436 3990 10 C. C. NNP 40436 3990 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3990 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 3990 13 : : : 40436 3990 14 phame\n phame\n ADD 40436 3990 15 a)/ra a)/ra UH 40436 3990 16 , , , 40436 3990 17 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 3990 18 La La NNP 40436 3990 19 / / SYM 40436 3990 20 chês chês JJ 40436 3990 21 , , , 40436 3990 22 ei)de ei)de JJ 40436 3990 23 / / SYM 40436 3990 24 nai nai NN 40436 3990 25 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 3990 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 3990 27 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 3990 28 a)retê\n a)retê\n NN 40436 3990 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 3990 30 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 3990 31 , , , 40436 3990 32 ti ti NNP 40436 3990 33 e)/sti e)/sti NN 40436 3990 34 . . . 40436 3991 1 Phame\n phame\n RB 40436 3991 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3991 3 / / SYM 40436 3991 4 ntoi ntoi JJ 40436 3991 5 . . . 40436 3992 1 Ou)kou ou)kou CD 40436 3992 2 = = SYM 40436 3992 3 n n NNP 40436 3992 4 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 3992 5 ge ge NNP 40436 3992 6 i)/smen i)/sman NNS 40436 3992 7 , , , 40436 3992 8 ka)\n ka)\n NNP 40436 3992 9 ei)/poimen ei)/poimen VBZ 40436 3992 10 dê dê NNP 40436 3992 11 / / SYM 40436 3992 12 pou pou NNP 40436 3992 13 , , , 40436 3992 14 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 3992 15 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 3992 16 . . . 40436 3993 1 Pô Pô NNP 40436 3993 2 = = NFP 40436 3993 3 s s NNP 40436 3993 4 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 3993 5 ou)/ ou)/ RB 40436 3993 6 ? ? . 40436 3993 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3993 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3994 1 " " `` 40436 3994 2 Try try VB 40436 3994 3 then then RB 40436 3994 4 if if IN 40436 3994 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3994 6 can can MD 40436 3994 7 tell tell VB 40436 3994 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 3994 9 , , , 40436 3994 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3994 11 , , , 40436 3994 12 what what WDT 40436 3994 13 courage courage NN 40436 3994 14 is be VBZ 40436 3994 15 . . . 40436 3995 1 _ _ NNP 40436 3995 2 Lachês._--There Lachês._--There NNP 40436 3995 3 is be VBZ 40436 3995 4 no no DT 40436 3995 5 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 3995 6 in in IN 40436 3995 7 telling tell VBG 40436 3995 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 3995 9 that that DT 40436 3995 10 . . . 40436 3996 1 Whoever whoever WP 40436 3996 2 keeps keep VBZ 40436 3996 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 3996 4 place place NN 40436 3996 5 in in IN 40436 3996 6 the the DT 40436 3996 7 rank rank NN 40436 3996 8 , , , 40436 3996 9 repels repel VBZ 40436 3996 10 the the DT 40436 3996 11 enemy enemy NN 40436 3996 12 , , , 40436 3996 13 and and CC 40436 3996 14 does do VBZ 40436 3996 15 not not RB 40436 3996 16 run run VB 40436 3996 17 away away RB 40436 3996 18 , , , 40436 3996 19 is be VBZ 40436 3996 20 a a DT 40436 3996 21 courageous courageous JJ 40436 3996 22 man man NN 40436 3996 23 . . . 40436 3997 1 " " `` 40436 3997 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3997 3 12 12 CD 40436 3997 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3997 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3997 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 3997 7 12 12 CD 40436 3997 8 : : : 40436 3997 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 3997 10 , , , 40436 3997 11 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3997 12 , , , 40436 3997 13 190 190 CD 40436 3997 14 D D NNP 40436 3997 15 - - HYPH 40436 3997 16 E. e. NN 40436 3997 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 3997 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 3997 19 Side side NN 40436 3997 20 - - HYPH 40436 3997 21 note note NN 40436 3997 22 : : : 40436 3997 23 Question question NN 40436 3997 24 -- -- : 40436 3997 25 what what WP 40436 3997 26 is be VBZ 40436 3997 27 courage courage NN 40436 3997 28 ? ? . 40436 3998 1 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 3998 2 answers answer NNS 40436 3998 3 by by IN 40436 3998 4 citing cite VBG 40436 3998 5 one one CD 40436 3998 6 particularly particularly RB 40436 3998 7 manifest manif JJS 40436 3998 8 case case NN 40436 3998 9 of of IN 40436 3998 10 courage courage NN 40436 3998 11 . . . 40436 3999 1 Mistake mistake NN 40436 3999 2 of of IN 40436 3999 3 not not RB 40436 3999 4 giving give VBG 40436 3999 5 a a DT 40436 3999 6 general general JJ 40436 3999 7 explanation explanation NN 40436 3999 8 . . . 40436 3999 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4000 1 Here here RB 40436 4000 2 is be VBZ 40436 4000 3 the the DT 40436 4000 4 same same JJ 40436 4000 5 error error NN 40436 4000 6 in in IN 40436 4000 7 replying reply VBG 40436 4000 8 , , , 40436 4000 9 as as IN 40436 4000 10 was be VBD 40436 4000 11 committed commit VBN 40436 4000 12 by by IN 40436 4000 13 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 4000 14 when when WRB 40436 4000 15 asked ask VBN 40436 4000 16 , , , 40436 4000 17 What what WP 40436 4000 18 is be VBZ 40436 4000 19 the the DT 40436 4000 20 Holy Holy NNP 40436 4000 21 ? ? . 40436 4001 1 and and CC 40436 4001 2 by by IN 40436 4001 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 4001 4 , , , 40436 4001 5 about about IN 40436 4001 6 the the DT 40436 4001 7 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4001 8 . . . 40436 4002 1 One one CD 40436 4002 2 particular particular JJ 40436 4002 3 case case NN 40436 4002 4 of of IN 40436 4002 5 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4002 6 behaviour behaviour NN 40436 4002 7 , , , 40436 4002 8 among among IN 40436 4002 9 many many JJ 40436 4002 10 , , , 40436 4002 11 is be VBZ 40436 4002 12 indicated indicate VBN 40436 4002 13 , , , 40436 4002 14 as as IN 40436 4002 15 if if IN 40436 4002 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4002 17 were be VBD 40436 4002 18 an an DT 40436 4002 19 explanation explanation NN 40436 4002 20 of of IN 40436 4002 21 the the DT 40436 4002 22 whole whole NN 40436 4002 23 : : : 40436 4002 24 but but CC 40436 4002 25 the the DT 40436 4002 26 general general JJ 40436 4002 27 feature feature NN 40436 4002 28 common common JJ 40436 4002 29 to to IN 40436 4002 30 all all DT 40436 4002 31 acts act NNS 40436 4002 32 of of IN 40436 4002 33 courage courage NN 40436 4002 34 is be VBZ 40436 4002 35 not not RB 40436 4002 36 declared declare VBN 40436 4002 37 . . . 40436 4003 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4003 2 points point VBZ 40436 4003 3 out out RP 40436 4003 4 that that IN 40436 4003 5 men man NNS 40436 4003 6 are be VBP 40436 4003 7 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4003 8 , , , 40436 4003 9 not not RB 40436 4003 10 merely merely RB 40436 4003 11 among among IN 40436 4003 12 hoplites hoplite NNS 40436 4003 13 who who WP 40436 4003 14 keep keep VBP 40436 4003 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4003 16 rank rank NN 40436 4003 17 and and CC 40436 4003 18 fight fight NN 40436 4003 19 , , , 40436 4003 20 but but CC 40436 4003 21 also also RB 40436 4003 22 among among IN 40436 4003 23 the the DT 40436 4003 24 Scythian scythian JJ 40436 4003 25 horsemen horseman NNS 40436 4003 26 who who WP 40436 4003 27 fight fight VBP 40436 4003 28 while while IN 40436 4003 29 running run VBG 40436 4003 30 away away RB 40436 4003 31 ; ; : 40436 4003 32 others other NNS 40436 4003 33 also also RB 40436 4003 34 are be VBP 40436 4003 35 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4003 36 against against IN 40436 4003 37 disease disease NN 40436 4003 38 , , , 40436 4003 39 poverty poverty NN 40436 4003 40 , , , 40436 4003 41 political political JJ 40436 4003 42 adversity adversity NN 40436 4003 43 , , , 40436 4003 44 pain pain NN 40436 4003 45 and and CC 40436 4003 46 fear fear NN 40436 4003 47 of of IN 40436 4003 48 every every DT 40436 4003 49 sort sort NN 40436 4003 50 ; ; : 40436 4003 51 others other NNS 40436 4003 52 moreover moreover RB 40436 4003 53 , , , 40436 4003 54 against against IN 40436 4003 55 desires desire NNS 40436 4003 56 and and CC 40436 4003 57 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 4003 58 . . . 40436 4004 1 What what WP 40436 4004 2 is be VBZ 40436 4004 3 the the DT 40436 4004 4 common common JJ 40436 4004 5 attribute attribute NN 40436 4004 6 which which WDT 40436 4004 7 in in IN 40436 4004 8 all all PDT 40436 4004 9 these these DT 40436 4004 10 cases case NNS 40436 4004 11 constitutes constitute VBZ 40436 4004 12 Courage courage NN 40436 4004 13 ? ? . 40436 4005 1 If if IN 40436 4005 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4005 3 asked ask VBD 40436 4005 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4005 5 what what WP 40436 4005 6 is be VBZ 40436 4005 7 _ _ NNP 40436 4005 8 quickness_--common quickness_--common NN 40436 4005 9 to to IN 40436 4005 10 all all PDT 40436 4005 11 those those DT 40436 4005 12 cases case NNS 40436 4005 13 when when WRB 40436 4005 14 a a DT 40436 4005 15 man man NN 40436 4005 16 runs run VBZ 40436 4005 17 , , , 40436 4005 18 speaks speak NNS 40436 4005 19 , , , 40436 4005 20 plays play NNS 40436 4005 21 , , , 40436 4005 22 learns learns NNP 40436 4005 23 , , , 40436 4005 24 & & CC 40436 4005 25 c. c. NNP 40436 4005 26 , , , 40436 4005 27 quickly quickly RB 40436 4005 28 -- -- : 40436 4005 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4005 30 should should MD 40436 4005 31 tell tell VB 40436 4005 32 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4005 33 that that IN 40436 4005 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4005 35 was be VBD 40436 4005 36 that that DT 40436 4005 37 which which WDT 40436 4005 38 accomplished accomplish VBD 40436 4005 39 much much RB 40436 4005 40 in in IN 40436 4005 41 a a DT 40436 4005 42 little little JJ 40436 4005 43 time time NN 40436 4005 44 . . . 40436 4006 1 Tell tell VB 40436 4006 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4006 3 in in RP 40436 4006 4 like like IN 40436 4006 5 manner manner NN 40436 4006 6 , , , 40436 4006 7 what what WP 40436 4006 8 is be VBZ 40436 4006 9 the the DT 40436 4006 10 common common JJ 40436 4006 11 fact fact NN 40436 4006 12 or or CC 40436 4006 13 attribute attribute NN 40436 4006 14 pervading pervade VBG 40436 4006 15 all all DT 40436 4006 16 cases case NNS 40436 4006 17 of of IN 40436 4006 18 courage courage NN 40436 4006 19 ? ? . 40436 4007 1 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4007 2 at at IN 40436 4007 3 first first RB 40436 4007 4 does do VBZ 40436 4007 5 not not RB 40436 4007 6 understand understand VB 40436 4007 7 the the DT 40436 4007 8 question:[13 question:[13 NNS 40436 4007 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4007 10 and and CC 40436 4007 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4007 12 elucidates elucidate VBZ 40436 4007 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4007 14 by by IN 40436 4007 15 giving give VBG 40436 4007 16 the the DT 40436 4007 17 parallel parallel JJ 40436 4007 18 explanation explanation NN 40436 4007 19 of of IN 40436 4007 20 quickness quickness NN 40436 4007 21 . . . 40436 4008 1 Here here RB 40436 4008 2 , , , 40436 4008 3 as as IN 40436 4008 4 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 4008 5 , , , 40436 4008 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4008 7 takes take VBZ 40436 4008 8 great great JJ 40436 4008 9 pains pain NNS 40436 4008 10 to to TO 40436 4008 11 impress impress VB 40436 4008 12 the the DT 40436 4008 13 conception conception NN 40436 4008 14 in in IN 40436 4008 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4008 16 full full JJ 40436 4008 17 generality generality NN 40436 4008 18 , , , 40436 4008 19 and and CC 40436 4008 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4008 21 seems seem VBZ 40436 4008 22 to to TO 40436 4008 23 have have VB 40436 4008 24 found find VBN 40436 4008 25 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 4008 26 in in IN 40436 4008 27 making make VBG 40436 4008 28 others other NNS 40436 4008 29 follow follow VB 40436 4008 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4008 31 . . . 40436 4009 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4009 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4009 3 13 13 CD 40436 4009 4 : : : 40436 4009 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4009 6 , , , 40436 4009 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4009 8 , , , 40436 4009 9 191 191 CD 40436 4009 10 - - SYM 40436 4009 11 192 192 CD 40436 4009 12 . . . 40436 4010 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4010 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4010 3 : : : 40436 4010 4 pa pa NNP 40436 4010 5 / / SYM 40436 4010 6 lin lin NNP 40436 4010 7 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 4010 8 peirô= peirô= NNP 40436 4010 9 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 4010 10 = = SYM 40436 4010 11 n n CC 40436 4010 12 a)ndrei a)ndrei CD 40436 4010 13 / / SYM 40436 4010 14 an an DT 40436 4010 15 prô prô NN 40436 4010 16 = = SYM 40436 4010 17 ton ton NN 40436 4010 18 , , , 40436 4010 19 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 4010 20 o)\n o)\n NNP 40436 4010 21 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4010 22 pa pa NNP 40436 4010 23 = = SYM 40436 4010 24 si si NNP 40436 4010 25 tou tou NNP 40436 4010 26 / / SYM 40436 4010 27 tois tois NNP 40436 4010 28 tau)to tau)to NNP 40436 4010 29 / / SYM 40436 4010 30 n n NNP 40436 4010 31 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 4010 32 . . . 40436 4011 1 ê)\ ê)\ NFP 40436 4011 2 ou)/pô ou)/pô CD 40436 4011 3 katamantha katamantha NNP 40436 4011 4 / / SYM 40436 4011 5 neis neis NNP 40436 4011 6 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 4011 7 le le NNP 40436 4011 8 / / SYM 40436 4011 9 gô gô NNP 40436 4011 10 ? ? . 40436 4011 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4012 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4012 2 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4012 3 . . . 40436 4012 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4012 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4012 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4012 7 : : : 40436 4012 8 Ou Ou NNP 40436 4012 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4012 10 pa pa NNP 40436 4012 11 / / SYM 40436 4012 12 nu nu NNP 40436 4012 13 ti ti NNP 40436 4012 14 . . . 40436 4013 1 . . . 40436 4014 1 . . . 40436 4015 1 . . . 40436 4015 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4016 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4016 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 4016 3 . . . 40436 4016 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4016 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4016 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4016 7 : : : 40436 4016 8 peirô= peirô= NN 40436 4016 9 dê\ dê\ NN 40436 4016 10 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 4016 11 a)ndrei a)ndrei NNP 40436 4016 12 / / SYM 40436 4016 13 an an DT 40436 4016 14 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 4016 15 ei)pein ei)pein NN 40436 4016 16 , , , 40436 4016 17 ti ti NNP 40436 4016 18 / / SYM 40436 4016 19 s s NNP 40436 4016 20 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 4016 21 du du NNP 40436 4016 22 / / SYM 40436 4016 23 namis namis NNP 40436 4016 24 ê ê NNP 40436 4016 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4016 26 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 4016 27 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4016 28 ê(donê=| ê(donê=| CD 40436 4016 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4016 30 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4016 31 lu lu NNP 40436 4016 32 / / SYM 40436 4016 33 pê| pê| NNP 40436 4016 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4016 35 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4016 36 a(/pasin a(/pasin NNP 40436 4016 37 oi(=s oi(=s NN 40436 4016 38 nu nu NNP 40436 4016 39 = = SYM 40436 4016 40 n n CC 40436 4016 41 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4016 42 e)le e)le NNP 40436 4016 43 / / SYM 40436 4016 44 gomen gomen NNP 40436 4016 45 au)tê\n au)tê\n NNP 40436 4016 46 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4016 47 , , , 40436 4016 48 e)/peit e)/peit NNP 40436 4016 49 ' ' POS 40436 4016 50 a)ndrei a)ndrei CD 40436 4016 51 / / SYM 40436 4016 52 a a DT 40436 4016 53 ke ke NNP 40436 4016 54 / / SYM 40436 4016 55 klêtai klêtai NNP 40436 4016 56 . . . 40436 4016 57 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4016 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4017 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4017 2 Side side NN 40436 4017 3 - - HYPH 40436 4017 4 note note NN 40436 4017 5 : : : 40436 4017 6 Second second JJ 40436 4017 7 answer answer NN 40436 4017 8 . . . 40436 4018 1 Courage courage NN 40436 4018 2 is be VBZ 40436 4018 3 a a DT 40436 4018 4 sort sort NN 40436 4018 5 of of IN 40436 4018 6 endurance endurance NN 40436 4018 7 of of IN 40436 4018 8 the the DT 40436 4018 9 mind mind NN 40436 4018 10 . . . 40436 4019 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4019 2 points point VBZ 40436 4019 3 out out RP 40436 4019 4 that that IN 40436 4019 5 the the DT 40436 4019 6 answer answer NN 40436 4019 7 is be VBZ 40436 4019 8 vague vague JJ 40436 4019 9 and and CC 40436 4019 10 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 4019 11 . . . 40436 4020 1 Endurance endurance NN 40436 4020 2 is be VBZ 40436 4020 3 not not RB 40436 4020 4 always always RB 40436 4020 5 courage courage NN 40436 4020 6 : : : 40436 4020 7 even even RB 40436 4020 8 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4020 9 endurance endurance NN 40436 4020 10 is be VBZ 40436 4020 11 not not RB 40436 4020 12 always always RB 40436 4020 13 courage courage NN 40436 4020 14 . . . 40436 4020 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4021 1 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4021 2 then then RB 40436 4021 3 gives give VBZ 40436 4021 4 a a DT 40436 4021 5 general general JJ 40436 4021 6 definition definition NN 40436 4021 7 of of IN 40436 4021 8 courage courage NN 40436 4021 9 . . . 40436 4022 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4022 2 is be VBZ 40436 4022 3 a a DT 40436 4022 4 sort sort NN 40436 4022 5 of of IN 40436 4022 6 endurance endurance NN 40436 4022 7 of of IN 40436 4022 8 the the DT 40436 4022 9 mind mind NN 40436 4022 10 . . . 40436 4023 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4023 2 14 14 CD 40436 4023 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4023 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4023 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4023 6 14 14 CD 40436 4023 7 : : : 40436 4023 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4023 9 , , , 40436 4023 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4023 11 , , , 40436 4023 12 192 192 CD 40436 4023 13 B. b. NN 40436 4024 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4024 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4024 3 : : : 40436 4024 4 karteri karteri NNP 40436 4024 5 / / , 40436 4024 6 a a DT 40436 4024 7 tis tis NNP 40436 4024 8 tê tê NNP 40436 4024 9 = = SYM 40436 4024 10 s s NNP 40436 4024 11 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 4024 12 = = SYM 40436 4024 13 s s NNP 40436 4024 14 . . . 40436 4024 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4024 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4025 1 Surely surely RB 40436 4025 2 not not RB 40436 4025 3 _ _ IN 40436 4025 4 all all DT 40436 4025 5 _ _ NNP 40436 4025 6 endurance endurance NN 40436 4025 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4025 8 rejoins rejoin VBZ 40436 4025 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4025 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4025 11 ? ? . 40436 4026 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4026 2 admit admit VBP 40436 4026 3 that that IN 40436 4026 4 courage courage NN 40436 4026 5 is be VBZ 40436 4026 6 a a DT 40436 4026 7 fine fine JJ 40436 4026 8 and and CC 40436 4026 9 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4026 10 thing thing NN 40436 4026 11 . . . 40436 4027 1 But but CC 40436 4027 2 endurance endurance NN 40436 4027 3 without without IN 40436 4027 4 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4027 5 is be VBZ 40436 4027 6 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 4027 7 and and CC 40436 4027 8 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 4027 9 : : : 40436 4027 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4027 11 can can MD 40436 4027 12 not not RB 40436 4027 13 therefore therefore RB 40436 4027 14 be be VB 40436 4027 15 courage courage NN 40436 4027 16 . . . 40436 4028 1 Only only RB 40436 4028 2 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4028 3 endurance endurance NN 40436 4028 4 , , , 40436 4028 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 4028 6 , , , 40436 4028 7 can can MD 40436 4028 8 be be VB 40436 4028 9 courage courage NN 40436 4028 10 . . . 40436 4029 1 And and CC 40436 4029 2 then then RB 40436 4029 3 what what WP 40436 4029 4 is be VBZ 40436 4029 5 meant mean VBN 40436 4029 6 by by IN 40436 4029 7 _ _ NNP 40436 4029 8 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4029 9 _ _ NNP 40436 4029 10 ? ? . 40436 4030 1 Intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4030 2 -- -- : 40436 4030 3 of of IN 40436 4030 4 what what WP 40436 4030 5 -- -- : 40436 4030 6 or or CC 40436 4030 7 to to IN 40436 4030 8 what what WDT 40436 4030 9 end end NN 40436 4030 10 ? ? . 40436 4031 1 A a DT 40436 4031 2 man man NN 40436 4031 3 , , , 40436 4031 4 who who WP 40436 4031 5 endures endure VBZ 40436 4031 6 the the DT 40436 4031 7 loss loss NN 40436 4031 8 of of IN 40436 4031 9 money money NN 40436 4031 10 , , , 40436 4031 11 understanding understand VBG 40436 4031 12 well well RB 40436 4031 13 that that IN 40436 4031 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4031 15 will will MD 40436 4031 16 thereby thereby RB 40436 4031 17 gain gain VB 40436 4031 18 a a DT 40436 4031 19 larger large JJR 40436 4031 20 sum sum NN 40436 4031 21 , , , 40436 4031 22 is be VBZ 40436 4031 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4031 24 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4031 25 ? ? . 40436 4032 1 No no UH 40436 4032 2 . . . 40436 4033 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4033 2 who who WP 40436 4033 3 endures endure VBZ 40436 4033 4 fighting fighting NN 40436 4033 5 , , , 40436 4033 6 knowing know VBG 40436 4033 7 that that IN 40436 4033 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4033 9 has have VBZ 40436 4033 10 superior superior JJ 40436 4033 11 skill skill NN 40436 4033 12 , , , 40436 4033 13 numbers number NNS 40436 4033 14 , , , 40436 4033 15 and and CC 40436 4033 16 all all DT 40436 4033 17 other other JJ 40436 4033 18 advantages advantage NNS 40436 4033 19 on on IN 40436 4033 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4033 21 side side NN 40436 4033 22 , , , 40436 4033 23 manifests manifest VBZ 40436 4033 24 more more JJR 40436 4033 25 of of IN 40436 4033 26 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4033 27 endurance endurance NN 40436 4033 28 , , , 40436 4033 29 than than IN 40436 4033 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4033 31 adversary adversary NN 40436 4033 32 who who WP 40436 4033 33 knows know VBZ 40436 4033 34 that that IN 40436 4033 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4033 36 has have VBZ 40436 4033 37 all all PDT 40436 4033 38 these these DT 40436 4033 39 advantages advantage NNS 40436 4033 40 against against IN 40436 4033 41 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4033 42 , , , 40436 4033 43 yet yet CC 40436 4033 44 who who WP 40436 4033 45 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 4033 46 endures endure VBZ 40436 4033 47 fighting fight VBG 40436 4033 48 . . . 40436 4034 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 4034 2 this this DT 40436 4034 3 latter latter NN 40436 4034 4 is be VBZ 40436 4034 5 the the DT 40436 4034 6 most most RBS 40436 4034 7 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4034 8 of of IN 40436 4034 9 the the DT 40436 4034 10 two two CD 40436 4034 11 . . . 40436 4035 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4035 2 15 15 CD 40436 4035 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4035 4 Unintelligent unintelligent JJ 40436 4035 5 endurance endurance NN 40436 4035 6 is be VBZ 40436 4035 7 in in IN 40436 4035 8 this this DT 40436 4035 9 case case NN 40436 4035 10 courage courage NN 40436 4035 11 : : : 40436 4035 12 but but CC 40436 4035 13 unintelligent unintelligent JJ 40436 4035 14 endurance endurance NN 40436 4035 15 was be VBD 40436 4035 16 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 4035 17 to to TO 40436 4035 18 be be VB 40436 4035 19 bad bad JJ 40436 4035 20 and and CC 40436 4035 21 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 4035 22 , , , 40436 4035 23 and and CC 40436 4035 24 courage courage NN 40436 4035 25 to to TO 40436 4035 26 be be VB 40436 4035 27 a a DT 40436 4035 28 fine fine JJ 40436 4035 29 thing thing NN 40436 4035 30 . . . 40436 4036 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4036 2 have have VBP 40436 4036 3 entangled entangle VBN 40436 4036 4 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 4036 5 in in IN 40436 4036 6 a a DT 40436 4036 7 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 4036 8 . . . 40436 4037 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4037 2 must must MD 40436 4037 3 at at IN 40436 4037 4 least least JJS 40436 4037 5 show show VB 40436 4037 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4037 7 own own JJ 40436 4037 8 courage courage NN 40436 4037 9 , , , 40436 4037 10 by by IN 40436 4037 11 enduring endure VBG 40436 4037 12 until until IN 40436 4037 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4037 14 can can MD 40436 4037 15 get get VB 40436 4037 16 right right JJ 40436 4037 17 . . . 40436 4038 1 For for IN 40436 4038 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4038 3 part part NN 40436 4038 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4038 5 replies reply VBZ 40436 4038 6 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4038 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4038 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4038 9 am be VBP 40436 4038 10 quite quite RB 40436 4038 11 prepared prepared JJ 40436 4038 12 for for IN 40436 4038 13 such such JJ 40436 4038 14 endurance endurance NN 40436 4038 15 . . . 40436 4039 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4039 2 am be VBP 40436 4039 3 piqued piqued JJ 40436 4039 4 and and CC 40436 4039 5 angry angry JJ 40436 4039 6 that that IN 40436 4039 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4039 8 can can MD 40436 4039 9 not not RB 40436 4039 10 express express VB 40436 4039 11 what what WP 40436 4039 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4039 13 conceive conceive VBP 40436 4039 14 . . . 40436 4040 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4040 2 seem seem VBP 40436 4040 3 to to TO 40436 4040 4 have have VB 40436 4040 5 in in IN 40436 4040 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4040 7 mind mind NN 40436 4040 8 clearly clearly RB 40436 4040 9 what what WDT 40436 4040 10 courage courage NN 40436 4040 11 is be VBZ 40436 4040 12 : : : 40436 4040 13 but but CC 40436 4040 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4040 15 escapes escape VBZ 40436 4040 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4040 17 somehow somehow RB 40436 4040 18 or or CC 40436 4040 19 other other JJ 40436 4040 20 , , , 40436 4040 21 when when WRB 40436 4040 22 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4040 23 try try VBP 40436 4040 24 to to TO 40436 4040 25 put put VB 40436 4040 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4040 27 in in IN 40436 4040 28 words word NNS 40436 4040 29 . . . 40436 4041 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4041 2 16 16 CD 40436 4041 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4041 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4041 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4041 6 15 15 CD 40436 4041 7 : : : 40436 4041 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4041 9 , , , 40436 4041 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4041 11 , , , 40436 4041 12 192 192 CD 40436 4041 13 D D NNP 40436 4041 14 - - HYPH 40436 4041 15 E. E. NNP 40436 4041 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4041 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4041 18 : : : 40436 4041 19 ê ê NNP 40436 4041 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4041 21 phro phro NNP 40436 4041 22 / / SYM 40436 4041 23 nimos nimos NNP 40436 4041 24 karteri karteri NNP 40436 4041 25 / / SYM 40436 4041 26 a a DT 40436 4041 27 . . . 40436 4042 1 . . . 40436 4043 1 . . . 40436 4044 1 i)/dômen i)/dômen NNP 40436 4044 2 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 4044 3 , , , 40436 4044 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4044 5 ê ê NNP 40436 4044 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4044 7 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 4044 8 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 4044 9 _ _ NNP 40436 4044 10 phro phro NNP 40436 4044 11 / / SYM 40436 4044 12 nimos nimos NNP 40436 4044 13 ; ; : 40436 4044 14 ê)\ ê)\ ADD 40436 4044 15 ê ê NNP 40436 4044 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4044 17 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 4044 18 a(/panta a(/panta NNP 40436 4044 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4044 20 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4044 21 mega mega NNP 40436 4044 22 / / SYM 40436 4044 23 la la NNP 40436 4044 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4044 25 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4044 26 smikra/ smikra/ NNP 40436 4044 27 ? ? . 40436 4044 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4044 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4045 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4045 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4045 3 16 16 CD 40436 4045 4 : : : 40436 4045 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4045 6 , , , 40436 4045 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4045 8 , , , 40436 4045 9 193 193 CD 40436 4045 10 C c NN 40436 4045 11 , , , 40436 4045 12 194 194 CD 40436 4045 13 B. B. NNP 40436 4045 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4046 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4046 2 now now RB 40436 4046 3 asks ask VBZ 40436 4046 4 aid aid NN 40436 4046 5 from from IN 40436 4046 6 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4046 7 . . . 40436 4047 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4047 2 Nikias._--My Nikias._--My NNP 40436 4047 3 explanation explanation NN 40436 4047 4 of of IN 40436 4047 5 courage courage NN 40436 4047 6 is be VBZ 40436 4047 7 , , , 40436 4047 8 that that IN 40436 4047 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4047 10 is be VBZ 40436 4047 11 a a DT 40436 4047 12 sort sort NN 40436 4047 13 of of IN 40436 4047 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4047 15 or or CC 40436 4047 16 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4047 17 . . . 40436 4048 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4048 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 4048 3 what what WP 40436 4048 4 sort sort NN 40436 4048 5 of of IN 40436 4048 6 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4048 7 ? ? . 40436 4049 1 Not not RB 40436 4049 2 certainly certainly RB 40436 4049 3 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4049 4 of of IN 40436 4049 5 piping piping NN 40436 4049 6 or or CC 40436 4049 7 playing play VBG 40436 4049 8 the the DT 40436 4049 9 harp harp NN 40436 4049 10 . . . 40436 4050 1 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4050 2 of of IN 40436 4050 3 what what WP 40436 4050 4 ? ? . 40436 4051 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4051 2 Side side NN 40436 4051 3 - - HYPH 40436 4051 4 note note NN 40436 4051 5 : : : 40436 4051 6 Confusion confusion NN 40436 4051 7 . . . 40436 4052 1 New new JJ 40436 4052 2 answer answer NN 40436 4052 3 given give VBN 40436 4052 4 by by IN 40436 4052 5 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4052 6 . . . 40436 4053 1 Courage courage NN 40436 4053 2 is be VBZ 40436 4053 3 a a DT 40436 4053 4 sort sort NN 40436 4053 5 of of IN 40436 4053 6 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4053 7 -- -- : 40436 4053 8 the the DT 40436 4053 9 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4053 10 of of IN 40436 4053 11 things thing NNS 40436 4053 12 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4053 13 and and CC 40436 4053 14 not not RB 40436 4053 15 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4053 16 . . . 40436 4054 1 Objections objection NNS 40436 4054 2 of of IN 40436 4054 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4054 4 . . . 40436 4054 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4055 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4055 2 Nikias._--Courage Nikias._--Courage NNP 40436 4055 3 is be VBZ 40436 4055 4 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4055 5 of of IN 40436 4055 6 things thing NNS 40436 4055 7 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4055 8 , , , 40436 4055 9 and and CC 40436 4055 10 things thing NNS 40436 4055 11 not not RB 40436 4055 12 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4055 13 , , , 40436 4055 14 both both CC 40436 4055 15 in in IN 40436 4055 16 war war NN 40436 4055 17 and and CC 40436 4055 18 in in IN 40436 4055 19 all all DT 40436 4055 20 other other JJ 40436 4055 21 conjunctures conjuncture NNS 40436 4055 22 . . . 40436 4056 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4056 2 Lachês._--What Lachês._--What NNP 40436 4056 3 nonsense nonsense NN 40436 4056 4 ! ! . 40436 4057 1 Courage courage NN 40436 4057 2 is be VBZ 40436 4057 3 a a DT 40436 4057 4 thing thing NN 40436 4057 5 totally totally RB 40436 4057 6 apart apart RB 40436 4057 7 from from IN 40436 4057 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4057 9 or or CC 40436 4057 10 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4057 11 . . . 40436 4058 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4058 2 17 17 CD 40436 4058 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4058 4 The the DT 40436 4058 5 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4058 6 physician physician NN 40436 4058 7 knows know VBZ 40436 4058 8 best good JJS 40436 4058 9 what what WP 40436 4058 10 is be VBZ 40436 4058 11 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4058 12 , , , 40436 4058 13 and and CC 40436 4058 14 what what WP 40436 4058 15 is be VBZ 40436 4058 16 not not RB 40436 4058 17 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4058 18 , , , 40436 4058 19 in in IN 40436 4058 20 reference reference NN 40436 4058 21 to to IN 40436 4058 22 disease disease NNP 40436 4058 23 : : : 40436 4058 24 the the DT 40436 4058 25 husbandman husbandman NNP 40436 4058 26 , , , 40436 4058 27 in in IN 40436 4058 28 reference reference NN 40436 4058 29 to to IN 40436 4058 30 agriculture agriculture NN 40436 4058 31 . . . 40436 4059 1 But but CC 40436 4059 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4059 3 are be VBP 40436 4059 4 not not RB 40436 4059 5 for for IN 40436 4059 6 that that DT 40436 4059 7 reason reason NN 40436 4059 8 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4059 9 . . . 40436 4060 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4060 2 Nikias._--They Nikias._--They NNP 40436 4060 3 are be VBP 40436 4060 4 not not RB 40436 4060 5 ; ; : 40436 4060 6 but but CC 40436 4060 7 neither neither CC 40436 4060 8 do do VBP 40436 4060 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4060 10 know know VB 40436 4060 11 what what WP 40436 4060 12 is be VBZ 40436 4060 13 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4060 14 , , , 40436 4060 15 or or CC 40436 4060 16 what what WP 40436 4060 17 is be VBZ 40436 4060 18 not not RB 40436 4060 19 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4060 20 . . . 40436 4061 1 Physicians physician NNS 40436 4061 2 can can MD 40436 4061 3 predict predict VB 40436 4061 4 the the DT 40436 4061 5 result result NN 40436 4061 6 of of IN 40436 4061 7 a a DT 40436 4061 8 patient patient NN 40436 4061 9 's 's POS 40436 4061 10 case case NN 40436 4061 11 : : : 40436 4061 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4061 13 can can MD 40436 4061 14 tell tell VB 40436 4061 15 what what WP 40436 4061 16 may may MD 40436 4061 17 cure cure VB 40436 4061 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4061 19 , , , 40436 4061 20 or or CC 40436 4061 21 what what WP 40436 4061 22 will will MD 40436 4061 23 kill kill VB 40436 4061 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4061 25 . . . 40436 4062 1 But but CC 40436 4062 2 whether whether IN 40436 4062 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4062 4 be be VB 40436 4062 5 better well JJR 40436 4062 6 for for IN 40436 4062 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4062 8 to to TO 40436 4062 9 die die VB 40436 4062 10 or or CC 40436 4062 11 to to IN 40436 4062 12 recover--_that recover--_that DT 40436 4062 13 _ _ NNP 40436 4062 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4062 15 do do VBP 40436 4062 16 not not RB 40436 4062 17 know know VB 40436 4062 18 , , , 40436 4062 19 and and CC 40436 4062 20 can can MD 40436 4062 21 not not RB 40436 4062 22 tell tell VB 40436 4062 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4062 24 . . . 40436 4063 1 To to IN 40436 4063 2 some some DT 40436 4063 3 persons person NNS 40436 4063 4 , , , 40436 4063 5 death death NN 40436 4063 6 is be VBZ 40436 4063 7 a a DT 40436 4063 8 less less JJR 40436 4063 9 evil evil NN 40436 4063 10 than than IN 40436 4063 11 life:--defeat life:--defeat CD 40436 4063 12 , , , 40436 4063 13 than than IN 40436 4063 14 victory:--loss victory:--loss CD 40436 4063 15 of of IN 40436 4063 16 wealth wealth NN 40436 4063 17 , , , 40436 4063 18 than than IN 40436 4063 19 gain gain NN 40436 4063 20 . . . 40436 4064 1 None none NN 40436 4064 2 except except IN 40436 4064 3 the the DT 40436 4064 4 person person NN 40436 4064 5 who who WP 40436 4064 6 can can MD 40436 4064 7 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 4064 8 these these DT 40436 4064 9 cases case NNS 40436 4064 10 , , , 40436 4064 11 knows know VBZ 40436 4064 12 what what WP 40436 4064 13 is be VBZ 40436 4064 14 really really RB 40436 4064 15 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4064 16 and and CC 40436 4064 17 what what WP 40436 4064 18 is be VBZ 40436 4064 19 not not RB 40436 4064 20 so so RB 40436 4064 21 . . . 40436 4065 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4065 2 alone alone RB 40436 4065 3 is be VBZ 40436 4065 4 really really RB 40436 4065 5 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4065 6 . . . 40436 4066 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4066 2 18 18 CD 40436 4066 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4066 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4066 5 Lachês._--Where Lachês._--Where NNP 40436 4066 6 is be VBZ 40436 4066 7 there there EX 40436 4066 8 any any DT 40436 4066 9 such such JJ 40436 4066 10 man man NN 40436 4066 11 ? ? . 40436 4067 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4067 2 can can MD 40436 4067 3 be be VB 40436 4067 4 only only RB 40436 4067 5 some some DT 40436 4067 6 God God NNP 40436 4067 7 . . . 40436 4068 1 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4068 2 feels feel VBZ 40436 4068 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4068 4 in in IN 40436 4068 5 a a DT 40436 4068 6 puzzle puzzle NN 40436 4068 7 , , , 40436 4068 8 and and CC 40436 4068 9 instead instead RB 40436 4068 10 of of IN 40436 4068 11 confessing confess VBG 40436 4068 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4068 13 frankly frankly RB 40436 4068 14 as as IN 40436 4068 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4068 16 have have VBP 40436 4068 17 done do VBN 40436 4068 18 , , , 40436 4068 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4068 20 is be VBZ 40436 4068 21 trying try VBG 40436 4068 22 to to TO 40436 4068 23 help help VB 40436 4068 24 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4068 25 out out RP 40436 4068 26 by by IN 40436 4068 27 evasions evasion NNS 40436 4068 28 more more RBR 40436 4068 29 fit fit JJ 40436 4068 30 for for IN 40436 4068 31 a a DT 40436 4068 32 pleader pleader NN 40436 4068 33 before before IN 40436 4068 34 the the DT 40436 4068 35 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 4068 36 . . . 40436 4069 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4069 2 19 19 CD 40436 4069 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4069 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4069 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4069 6 17 17 CD 40436 4069 7 : : : 40436 4069 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4069 9 , , , 40436 4069 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4069 11 , , , 40436 4069 12 195 195 CD 40436 4069 13 A. a. NN 40436 4070 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4070 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4070 3 : : : 40436 4070 4 tê\n tê\n VB 40436 4070 5 tô tô NNP 40436 4070 6 = = SYM 40436 4070 7 n n NN 40436 4070 8 deinôn deinôn NN 40436 4070 9 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4070 10 thar)r(ale thar)r(ale NNP 40436 4070 11 / / SYM 40436 4070 12 ôn ôn NNP 40436 4070 13 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4070 14 / / SYM 40436 4070 15 mên mên NN 40436 4070 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4070 17 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4070 18 pole pole NNP 40436 4070 19 / / SYM 40436 4070 20 mô| mô| NNP 40436 4070 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4070 22 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4070 23 toi toi NNP 40436 4070 24 = = SYM 40436 4070 25 s s NNP 40436 4070 26 a)/llois a)/llois NNP 40436 4070 27 a(/pasin a(/pasin NNP 40436 4070 28 . . . 40436 4070 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4071 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4071 2 Lachês._--[Greek Lachês._--[Greek NNP 40436 4071 3 : : : 40436 4071 4 Ô(s ô(s CD 40436 4071 5 a)/topa a)/topa NNP 40436 4071 6 le le NNP 40436 4071 7 / / SYM 40436 4071 8 gei!--chôri\s gei!--chôri\s NNP 40436 4071 9 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 4071 10 pou pou NNP 40436 4071 11 sophi sophi NNP 40436 4071 12 / / , 40436 4071 13 a a DT 40436 4071 14 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 4071 15 a)ndrei a)ndrei , 40436 4071 16 / / SYM 40436 4071 17 as as IN 40436 4071 18 . . . 40436 4071 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4072 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4072 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 4072 3 from from IN 40436 4072 4 two two CD 40436 4072 5 other other JJ 40436 4072 6 passages passage NNS 40436 4072 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4072 8 195 195 CD 40436 4072 9 E e NN 40436 4072 10 , , , 40436 4072 11 and and CC 40436 4072 12 198 198 CD 40436 4072 13 B B NNP 40436 4072 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4072 15 that that IN 40436 4072 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4072 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4072 18 : : : 40436 4072 19 thar)r(a thar)r(a NN 40436 4072 20 / / SYM 40436 4072 21 leos leo NNS 40436 4072 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4072 23 here here RB 40436 4072 24 is be VBZ 40436 4072 25 simply simply RB 40436 4072 26 the the DT 40436 4072 27 negation negation NN 40436 4072 28 of of IN 40436 4072 29 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4072 30 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4072 31 : : : 40436 4072 32 deino\s deino\s -LRB- 40436 4072 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4072 34 and and CC 40436 4072 35 can can MD 40436 4072 36 not not RB 40436 4072 37 be be VB 40436 4072 38 translated translate VBN 40436 4072 39 by by IN 40436 4072 40 any any DT 40436 4072 41 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 4072 42 word word NN 40436 4072 43 . . . 40436 4072 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4073 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4073 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4073 3 18 18 CD 40436 4073 4 : : : 40436 4073 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4073 6 , , , 40436 4073 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4073 8 , , , 40436 4073 9 195 195 CD 40436 4073 10 - - SYM 40436 4073 11 196 196 CD 40436 4073 12 . . . 40436 4073 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4074 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4074 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4074 3 19 19 CD 40436 4074 4 : : : 40436 4074 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4074 6 , , , 40436 4074 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4074 8 , , , 40436 4074 9 196 196 CD 40436 4074 10 B. b. NN 40436 4074 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4075 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4075 2 Side side NN 40436 4075 3 - - HYPH 40436 4075 4 note note NN 40436 4075 5 : : : 40436 4075 6 Questions question NNS 40436 4075 7 of of IN 40436 4075 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4075 9 to to IN 40436 4075 10 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4075 11 . . . 40436 4076 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4076 2 is be VBZ 40436 4076 3 only only RB 40436 4076 4 future future JJ 40436 4076 5 events event NNS 40436 4076 6 , , , 40436 4076 7 not not RB 40436 4076 8 past past JJ 40436 4076 9 or or CC 40436 4076 10 present present JJ 40436 4076 11 , , , 40436 4076 12 which which WDT 40436 4076 13 are be VBP 40436 4076 14 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4076 15 ; ; : 40436 4076 16 but but CC 40436 4076 17 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4076 18 of of IN 40436 4076 19 future future JJ 40436 4076 20 events event NNS 40436 4076 21 can can MD 40436 4076 22 not not RB 40436 4076 23 be be VB 40436 4076 24 had have VBN 40436 4076 25 without without IN 40436 4076 26 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4076 27 of of IN 40436 4076 28 past past NN 40436 4076 29 or or CC 40436 4076 30 present present NN 40436 4076 31 . . . 40436 4076 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4077 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4077 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 4077 3 do do VBP 40436 4077 4 not not RB 40436 4077 5 admit admit VB 40436 4077 6 , , , 40436 4077 7 then then RB 40436 4077 8 , , , 40436 4077 9 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4077 10 , , , 40436 4077 11 that that IN 40436 4077 12 lions lion NNS 40436 4077 13 , , , 40436 4077 14 tigers tiger NNS 40436 4077 15 , , , 40436 4077 16 boars boars NNP 40436 4077 17 , , , 40436 4077 18 & & CC 40436 4077 19 c. c. NNP 40436 4077 20 , , , 40436 4077 21 and and CC 40436 4077 22 such such JJ 40436 4077 23 animals animal NNS 40436 4077 24 , , , 40436 4077 25 are be VBP 40436 4077 26 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4077 27 ? ? . 40436 4078 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4078 2 Nikias._--No nikias._--no NN 40436 4078 3 : : : 40436 4078 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4078 5 are be VBP 40436 4078 6 without without IN 40436 4078 7 fear fear NN 40436 4078 8 -- -- : 40436 4078 9 simply simply RB 40436 4078 10 from from IN 40436 4078 11 not not RB 40436 4078 12 knowing know VBG 40436 4078 13 the the DT 40436 4078 14 danger danger NN 40436 4078 15 -- -- : 40436 4078 16 like like IN 40436 4078 17 children child NNS 40436 4078 18 : : : 40436 4078 19 but but CC 40436 4078 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4078 21 are be VBP 40436 4078 22 not not RB 40436 4078 23 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4078 24 , , , 40436 4078 25 though though IN 40436 4078 26 most most JJS 40436 4078 27 people people NNS 40436 4078 28 call call VBP 40436 4078 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4078 30 so so RB 40436 4078 31 . . . 40436 4079 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4079 2 may may MD 40436 4079 3 call call VB 40436 4079 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4079 5 bold bold JJ 40436 4079 6 , , , 40436 4079 7 but but CC 40436 4079 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4079 9 reserve reserve VBP 40436 4079 10 the the DT 40436 4079 11 epithet epithet NN 40436 4079 12 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4079 13 for for IN 40436 4079 14 the the DT 40436 4079 15 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4079 16 . . . 40436 4080 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4080 2 Lachês._--See lachês._--see CD 40436 4080 3 how how WRB 40436 4080 4 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4080 5 strips strip VBZ 40436 4080 6 those those DT 40436 4080 7 , , , 40436 4080 8 whom whom WP 40436 4080 9 every every DT 40436 4080 10 one one NN 40436 4080 11 admits admit VBZ 40436 4080 12 to to TO 40436 4080 13 be be VB 40436 4080 14 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4080 15 , , , 40436 4080 16 of of IN 40436 4080 17 this this DT 40436 4080 18 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4080 19 appellation appellation NN 40436 4080 20 ! ! . 40436 4081 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4081 2 Nikias._--Not Nikias._--Not NNP 40436 4081 3 altogether altogether RB 40436 4081 4 , , , 40436 4081 5 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4081 6 : : : 40436 4081 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4081 8 admit admit VBP 40436 4081 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4081 10 , , , 40436 4081 11 and and CC 40436 4081 12 Lamachus Lamachus NNP 40436 4081 13 , , , 40436 4081 14 and and CC 40436 4081 15 many many JJ 40436 4081 16 other other JJ 40436 4081 17 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 4081 18 , , , 40436 4081 19 to to TO 40436 4081 20 be be VB 40436 4081 21 courageous courageous JJ 40436 4081 22 , , , 40436 4081 23 and and CC 40436 4081 24 of of IN 40436 4081 25 course course NN 40436 4081 26 therefore therefore RB 40436 4081 27 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4081 28 . . . 40436 4082 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4082 2 Lachês._--I Lachês._--I VBG 40436 4082 3 feel feel VBP 40436 4082 4 the the DT 40436 4082 5 compliment compliment NN 40436 4082 6 : : : 40436 4082 7 but but CC 40436 4082 8 such such JJ 40436 4082 9 subtle subtle JJ 40436 4082 10 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 4082 11 befit befit VB 40436 4082 12 a a DT 40436 4082 13 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 4082 14 rather rather RB 40436 4082 15 than than IN 40436 4082 16 a a DT 40436 4082 17 general general NN 40436 4082 18 in in IN 40436 4082 19 high high JJ 40436 4082 20 command command NN 40436 4082 21 . . . 40436 4083 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4083 2 20 20 CD 40436 4083 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4083 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4083 5 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 4083 6 highest high JJS 40436 4083 7 measure measure NN 40436 4083 8 of of IN 40436 4083 9 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4083 10 befits befit VBZ 40436 4083 11 one one CD 40436 4083 12 in in IN 40436 4083 13 the the DT 40436 4083 14 highest high JJS 40436 4083 15 command command NN 40436 4083 16 . . . 40436 4084 1 What what WP 40436 4084 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4084 3 have have VBP 40436 4084 4 said say VBD 40436 4084 5 , , , 40436 4084 6 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4084 7 , , , 40436 4084 8 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 4084 9 careful careful JJ 40436 4084 10 examination examination NN 40436 4084 11 . . . 40436 4085 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4085 2 remember remember VBP 40436 4085 3 that that IN 40436 4085 4 in in IN 40436 4085 5 taking take VBG 40436 4085 6 up up RP 40436 4085 7 the the DT 40436 4085 8 investigation investigation NN 40436 4085 9 of of IN 40436 4085 10 courage courage NN 40436 4085 11 , , , 40436 4085 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4085 13 reckoned reckon VBD 40436 4085 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4085 15 only only RB 40436 4085 16 as as IN 40436 4085 17 a a DT 40436 4085 18 portion portion NN 40436 4085 19 of of IN 40436 4085 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 4085 21 : : : 40436 4085 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4085 23 are be VBP 40436 4085 24 aware aware JJ 40436 4085 25 that that IN 40436 4085 26 there there EX 40436 4085 27 are be VBP 40436 4085 28 other other JJ 40436 4085 29 portions portion NNS 40436 4085 30 of of IN 40436 4085 31 virtue virtue NN 40436 4085 32 , , , 40436 4085 33 such such JJ 40436 4085 34 as as IN 40436 4085 35 justice justice NN 40436 4085 36 , , , 40436 4085 37 temperance temperance NN 40436 4085 38 , , , 40436 4085 39 and and CC 40436 4085 40 the the DT 40436 4085 41 like like JJ 40436 4085 42 . . . 40436 4086 1 Now now RB 40436 4086 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4086 3 define define VBP 40436 4086 4 courage courage NN 40436 4086 5 to to TO 40436 4086 6 be be VB 40436 4086 7 , , , 40436 4086 8 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4086 9 of of IN 40436 4086 10 what what WP 40436 4086 11 is be VBZ 40436 4086 12 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4086 13 or or CC 40436 4086 14 not not RB 40436 4086 15 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4086 16 : : : 40436 4086 17 of of IN 40436 4086 18 that that DT 40436 4086 19 which which WDT 40436 4086 20 causes cause VBZ 40436 4086 21 fear fear NN 40436 4086 22 , , , 40436 4086 23 or or CC 40436 4086 24 does do VBZ 40436 4086 25 not not RB 40436 4086 26 cause cause VB 40436 4086 27 fear fear NN 40436 4086 28 . . . 40436 4087 1 But but CC 40436 4087 2 nothing nothing NN 40436 4087 3 causes cause VBZ 40436 4087 4 fear fear NN 40436 4087 5 , , , 40436 4087 6 except except IN 40436 4087 7 future future NN 40436 4087 8 or or CC 40436 4087 9 apprehended apprehend VBN 40436 4087 10 evils evil NNS 40436 4087 11 : : : 40436 4087 12 present present JJ 40436 4087 13 or or CC 40436 4087 14 past past JJ 40436 4087 15 evils evil NNS 40436 4087 16 cause cause VBP 40436 4087 17 no no DT 40436 4087 18 fear fear NN 40436 4087 19 . . . 40436 4088 1 Hence hence RB 40436 4088 2 courage courage NN 40436 4088 3 , , , 40436 4088 4 as as IN 40436 4088 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4088 6 define define VBP 40436 4088 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4088 8 , , , 40436 4088 9 is be VBZ 40436 4088 10 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4088 11 respecting respect VBG 40436 4088 12 future future JJ 40436 4088 13 evils evil NNS 40436 4088 14 , , , 40436 4088 15 and and CC 40436 4088 16 future future JJ 40436 4088 17 events event NNS 40436 4088 18 not not RB 40436 4088 19 evil evil JJ 40436 4088 20 . . . 40436 4089 1 But but CC 40436 4089 2 how how WRB 40436 4089 3 can can MD 40436 4089 4 there there EX 40436 4089 5 be be VB 40436 4089 6 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4089 7 respecting respect VBG 40436 4089 8 the the DT 40436 4089 9 future future NN 40436 4089 10 , , , 40436 4089 11 except except IN 40436 4089 12 in in IN 40436 4089 13 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 4089 14 with with IN 40436 4089 15 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4089 16 respecting respect VBG 40436 4089 17 the the DT 40436 4089 18 present present NN 40436 4089 19 and and CC 40436 4089 20 the the DT 40436 4089 21 past past NN 40436 4089 22 ? ? . 40436 4090 1 In in IN 40436 4090 2 every every DT 40436 4090 3 special special JJ 40436 4090 4 department department NN 40436 4090 5 , , , 40436 4090 6 such such JJ 40436 4090 7 as as IN 40436 4090 8 medicine medicine NN 40436 4090 9 , , , 40436 4090 10 military military JJ 40436 4090 11 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 4090 12 , , , 40436 4090 13 agriculture agriculture NN 40436 4090 14 , , , 40436 4090 15 & & CC 40436 4090 16 c. c. NNP 40436 4090 17 , , , 40436 4090 18 does do VBZ 40436 4090 19 not not RB 40436 4090 20 the the DT 40436 4090 21 same same JJ 40436 4090 22 man man NN 40436 4090 23 , , , 40436 4090 24 who who WP 40436 4090 25 knows know VBZ 40436 4090 26 the the DT 40436 4090 27 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 4090 28 of of IN 40436 4090 29 the the DT 40436 4090 30 future future NN 40436 4090 31 , , , 40436 4090 32 know know VBP 40436 4090 33 also also RB 40436 4090 34 the the DT 40436 4090 35 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 4090 36 of of IN 40436 4090 37 present present JJ 40436 4090 38 and and CC 40436 4090 39 past past JJ 40436 4090 40 ? ? . 40436 4091 1 Are be VBP 40436 4091 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4091 3 not not RB 40436 4091 4 all all DT 40436 4091 5 inseparable inseparable JJ 40436 4091 6 acquirements acquirement NNS 40436 4091 7 of of IN 40436 4091 8 one one CD 40436 4091 9 and and CC 40436 4091 10 the the DT 40436 4091 11 same same JJ 40436 4091 12 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4091 13 mind mind NN 40436 4091 14 ? ? . 40436 4092 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4092 2 21 21 CD 40436 4092 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4092 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4092 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4092 6 20 20 CD 40436 4092 7 : : : 40436 4092 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4092 9 , , , 40436 4092 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4092 11 , , , 40436 4092 12 197 197 CD 40436 4092 13 . . . 40436 4093 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4093 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4093 3 : : : 40436 4093 4 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 4093 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4093 6 pre pre AFX 40436 4093 7 / / SYM 40436 4093 8 pei pei NN 40436 4093 9 , , , 40436 4093 10 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 4093 11 Sô Sô NNP 40436 4093 12 / / SYM 40436 4093 13 krates krate NNS 40436 4093 14 , , , 40436 4093 15 sophistê=| sophistê=| NNP 40436 4093 16 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 4093 17 toiau toiau NNP 40436 4093 18 = = SYM 40436 4093 19 ta ta NNP 40436 4093 20 ma ma NNP 40436 4093 21 = = SYM 40436 4093 22 llon llon NNP 40436 4093 23 kompseu kompseu NNP 40436 4093 24 / / SYM 40436 4093 25 esthai esthai NNP 40436 4093 26 ê)\ ê)\ IN 40436 4093 27 a)ndri\ a)ndri\ NNP 40436 4093 28 o(\n o(\n NNP 40436 4093 29 ê ê NNP 40436 4093 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4093 31 po po NNP 40436 4093 32 / / SYM 40436 4093 33 lis lis NNP 40436 4093 34 a)xioi= a)xioi= NNP 40436 4093 35 au(tê au(tê NNP 40436 4093 36 = = SYM 40436 4093 37 s s NNP 40436 4093 38 proi+sta proi+sta NNP 40436 4093 39 / / SYM 40436 4093 40 nai nai NNP 40436 4093 41 . . . 40436 4093 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4094 1 Assuredly assuredly RB 40436 4094 2 the the DT 40436 4094 3 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 4094 4 which which WDT 40436 4094 5 here here RB 40436 4094 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4094 7 puts put VBZ 40436 4094 8 into into IN 40436 4094 9 the the DT 40436 4094 10 mouth mouth NN 40436 4094 11 of of IN 40436 4094 12 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4094 13 are be VBP 40436 4094 14 nowise nowise RB 40436 4094 15 more more RBR 40436 4094 16 subtle subtle JJ 40436 4094 17 than than IN 40436 4094 18 those those DT 40436 4094 19 which which WDT 40436 4094 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4094 21 is be VBZ 40436 4094 22 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 4094 23 putting put VBG 40436 4094 24 into into IN 40436 4094 25 the the DT 40436 4094 26 mouth mouth NN 40436 4094 27 of of IN 40436 4094 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4094 29 . . . 40436 4095 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4095 2 can can MD 40436 4095 3 not not RB 40436 4095 4 here here RB 40436 4095 5 mean mean VB 40436 4095 6 to to TO 40436 4095 7 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 4095 8 the the DT 40436 4095 9 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 4095 10 from from IN 40436 4095 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4095 12 , , , 40436 4095 13 but but CC 40436 4095 14 to to TO 40436 4095 15 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 4095 16 the the DT 40436 4095 17 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 4095 18 talkers talker NNS 40436 4095 19 , , , 40436 4095 20 including include VBG 40436 4095 21 both both CC 40436 4095 22 one one CD 40436 4095 23 and and CC 40436 4095 24 the the DT 40436 4095 25 other other JJ 40436 4095 26 , , , 40436 4095 27 from from IN 40436 4095 28 the the DT 40436 4095 29 active active JJ 40436 4095 30 political political JJ 40436 4095 31 leaders leader NNS 40436 4095 32 . . . 40436 4095 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4096 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4096 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4096 3 21 21 CD 40436 4096 4 : : : 40436 4096 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4096 6 , , , 40436 4096 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4096 8 , , , 40436 4096 9 198 198 CD 40436 4096 10 D. D. NNP 40436 4096 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4096 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4096 13 : : : 40436 4096 14 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 4096 15 o(/sôn o(/sôn CD 40436 4096 16 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 4096 17 e)pistê e)pistê . 40436 4096 18 / / SYM 40436 4096 19 mê mê NN 40436 4096 20 , , , 40436 4096 21 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 4096 22 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 4096 23 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4096 24 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 4096 25 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 4096 26 gegono gegono NNP 40436 4096 27 / / SYM 40436 4096 28 tos tos JJ 40436 4096 29 , , , 40436 4096 30 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 4096 31 / / SYM 40436 4096 32 nai nai NNP 40436 4096 33 o(/pê| o(/pê| NNP 40436 4096 34 ge ge NNP 40436 4096 35 / / SYM 40436 4096 36 gonen gonen NNP 40436 4096 37 , , , 40436 4096 38 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 4096 39 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4096 40 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 4096 41 gignome gignome NN 40436 4096 42 / / SYM 40436 4096 43 nôn nôn NNP 40436 4096 44 , , , 40436 4096 45 o(/pê| o(/pê| NNP 40436 4096 46 gi gi NNP 40436 4096 47 / / SYM 40436 4096 48 gnetai gnetai NNP 40436 4096 49 , , , 40436 4096 50 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 4096 51 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4096 52 o(/pê| o(/pê| NNP 40436 4096 53 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 4096 54 ka ka NNP 40436 4096 55 / / SYM 40436 4096 56 llista llista NNP 40436 4096 57 ge ge NNP 40436 4096 58 / / SYM 40436 4096 59 noito noito NNP 40436 4096 60 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4096 61 genê genê NNP 40436 4096 62 / / SYM 40436 4096 63 setai setai NNP 40436 4096 64 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4096 65 mê mê NNP 40436 4096 66 / / SYM 40436 4096 67 pô pô NNP 40436 4096 68 gegono gegono NNP 40436 4096 69 / / SYM 40436 4096 70 s s NNP 40436 4096 71 -- -- : 40436 4096 72 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 4096 73 ' ' `` 40436 4096 74 ê ê NN 40436 4096 75 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4096 76 au)tê/. au)tê/. UH 40436 4097 1 oi(=on oi(=on NNP 40436 4097 2 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 4097 3 to\ to\ NN 40436 4097 4 u(gieino\n u(gieino\n NNP 40436 4097 5 ei)s ei)s NN 40436 4097 6 a(/pantas a(/pantas NNP 40436 4097 7 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 4097 8 chro chro NN 40436 4097 9 / / SYM 40436 4097 10 nous nous JJ 40436 4097 11 ou)k ou)k NN 40436 4097 12 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 4097 13 tis tis NNP 40436 4097 14 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 4097 15 ê ê NNP 40436 4097 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4097 17 i)atrikê/ i)atrikê/ '' 40436 4097 18 , , , 40436 4097 19 mi mi NNP 40436 4097 20 / / SYM 40436 4097 21 a a DT 40436 4097 22 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 4097 23 , , , 40436 4097 24 e)phora=| e)phora=| ADD 40436 4097 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4097 26 gigno gigno NNP 40436 4097 27 / / SYM 40436 4097 28 mena mena NNP 40436 4097 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4097 30 gegono gegono NNP 40436 4097 31 / / SYM 40436 4097 32 ta ta NNP 40436 4097 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4097 34 genêso genêso NNP 40436 4097 35 / / SYM 40436 4097 36 mena mena NNP 40436 4097 37 , , , 40436 4097 38 o(/pê| o(/pê| NNP 40436 4097 39 genê genê NNP 40436 4097 40 / / SYM 40436 4097 41 setai setai NNP 40436 4097 42 . . . 40436 4097 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4098 1 199 199 CD 40436 4098 2 B. B. NNP 40436 4099 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4099 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4099 3 : : : 40436 4099 4 ê ê NNP 40436 4099 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4099 6 de/ de/ NNP 40436 4099 7 g g NNP 40436 4099 8 ' ' '' 40436 4099 9 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 4099 10 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4099 11 / / SYM 40436 4099 12 mê mê NNP 40436 4099 13 tô tô NNP 40436 4099 14 = = SYM 40436 4099 15 n n NNP 40436 4099 16 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 4099 17 = = SYM 40436 4099 18 n n CC 40436 4099 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4099 20 mello mello NNP 40436 4099 21 / / SYM 40436 4099 22 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 4099 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4099 24 pa pa NNP 40436 4099 25 / / SYM 40436 4099 26 ntôs ntôs NNP 40436 4099 27 e)cho e)cho NNP 40436 4099 28 / / SYM 40436 4099 29 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 4099 30 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 4099 31 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4099 32 ô(molo ô(molo NNP 40436 4099 33 / / SYM 40436 4099 34 gêtai gêtai NNP 40436 4099 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4099 36 . . . 40436 4099 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4100 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4100 2 Side side NN 40436 4100 3 - - HYPH 40436 4100 4 note note NN 40436 4100 5 : : : 40436 4100 6 Courage courage NN 40436 4100 7 therefore therefore RB 40436 4100 8 must must MD 40436 4100 9 be be VB 40436 4100 10 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4100 11 of of IN 40436 4100 12 good good JJ 40436 4100 13 and and CC 40436 4100 14 evil evil NN 40436 4100 15 generally generally RB 40436 4100 16 . . . 40436 4101 1 But but CC 40436 4101 2 this this DT 40436 4101 3 definition definition NN 40436 4101 4 would would MD 40436 4101 5 include include VB 40436 4101 6 the the DT 40436 4101 7 whole whole NN 40436 4101 8 of of IN 40436 4101 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 4101 10 , , , 40436 4101 11 and and CC 40436 4101 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4101 13 declared declare VBD 40436 4101 14 that that DT 40436 4101 15 courage courage NN 40436 4101 16 was be VBD 40436 4101 17 only only RB 40436 4101 18 a a DT 40436 4101 19 part part NN 40436 4101 20 thereof thereof RB 40436 4101 21 . . . 40436 4102 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4102 2 will will MD 40436 4102 3 not not RB 40436 4102 4 hold hold VB 40436 4102 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 4102 6 as as IN 40436 4102 7 a a DT 40436 4102 8 definition definition NN 40436 4102 9 of of IN 40436 4102 10 courage courage NN 40436 4102 11 . . . 40436 4102 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4103 1 Since since IN 40436 4103 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 4103 3 courage courage NN 40436 4103 4 , , , 40436 4103 5 according accord VBG 40436 4103 6 to to IN 40436 4103 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4103 8 definition definition NN 40436 4103 9 , , , 40436 4103 10 is be VBZ 40436 4103 11 the the DT 40436 4103 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4103 13 of of IN 40436 4103 14 futurities futurity NNS 40436 4103 15 evil evil JJ 40436 4103 16 and and CC 40436 4103 17 not not RB 40436 4103 18 evil evil JJ 40436 4103 19 , , , 40436 4103 20 or or CC 40436 4103 21 future future JJ 40436 4103 22 evil evil NN 40436 4103 23 and and CC 40436 4103 24 good good JJ 40436 4103 25 -- -- : 40436 4103 26 and and CC 40436 4103 27 since since IN 40436 4103 28 such such JJ 40436 4103 29 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4103 30 can can MD 40436 4103 31 not not RB 40436 4103 32 exist exist VB 40436 4103 33 without without IN 40436 4103 34 the the DT 40436 4103 35 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4103 36 of of IN 40436 4103 37 good good JJ 40436 4103 38 and and CC 40436 4103 39 evil evil NN 40436 4103 40 generally generally RB 40436 4103 41 -- -- : 40436 4103 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4103 43 follows follow VBZ 40436 4103 44 that that DT 40436 4103 45 courage courage NN 40436 4103 46 is be VBZ 40436 4103 47 the the DT 40436 4103 48 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4103 49 of of IN 40436 4103 50 good good JJ 40436 4103 51 and and CC 40436 4103 52 evil evil NN 40436 4103 53 generally generally RB 40436 4103 54 . . . 40436 4104 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4104 2 22 22 CD 40436 4104 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4104 4 But but CC 40436 4104 5 a a DT 40436 4104 6 man man NN 40436 4104 7 who who WP 40436 4104 8 knows know VBZ 40436 4104 9 thus thus RB 40436 4104 10 much much RB 40436 4104 11 , , , 40436 4104 12 can can MD 40436 4104 13 not not RB 40436 4104 14 be be VB 40436 4104 15 destitute destitute JJ 40436 4104 16 of of IN 40436 4104 17 any any DT 40436 4104 18 part part NN 40436 4104 19 of of IN 40436 4104 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 4104 21 . . . 40436 4105 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4105 2 must must MD 40436 4105 3 possess possess VB 40436 4105 4 temperance temperance NN 40436 4105 5 and and CC 40436 4105 6 justice justice NN 40436 4105 7 as as RB 40436 4105 8 well well RB 40436 4105 9 as as IN 40436 4105 10 courage courage NN 40436 4105 11 . . . 40436 4106 1 Courage courage NN 40436 4106 2 , , , 40436 4106 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 4106 4 , , , 40436 4106 5 according accord VBG 40436 4106 6 to to IN 40436 4106 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4106 8 definition definition NN 40436 4106 9 , , , 40436 4106 10 is be VBZ 40436 4106 11 not not RB 40436 4106 12 only only RB 40436 4106 13 a a DT 40436 4106 14 part part NN 40436 4106 15 of of IN 40436 4106 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 4106 17 , , , 40436 4106 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4106 19 is be VBZ 40436 4106 20 the the DT 40436 4106 21 whole whole NN 40436 4106 22 . . . 40436 4107 1 Now now RB 40436 4107 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4107 3 began begin VBD 40436 4107 4 the the DT 40436 4107 5 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 4107 6 by by IN 40436 4107 7 stating state VBG 40436 4107 8 that that IN 40436 4107 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4107 10 was be VBD 40436 4107 11 only only RB 40436 4107 12 a a DT 40436 4107 13 part part NN 40436 4107 14 of of IN 40436 4107 15 virtue virtue NN 40436 4107 16 , , , 40436 4107 17 and and CC 40436 4107 18 that that IN 40436 4107 19 there there EX 40436 4107 20 were be VBD 40436 4107 21 other other JJ 40436 4107 22 parts part NNS 40436 4107 23 of of IN 40436 4107 24 virtue virtue NN 40436 4107 25 which which WDT 40436 4107 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4107 27 did do VBD 40436 4107 28 not not RB 40436 4107 29 comprise comprise VB 40436 4107 30 . . . 40436 4108 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4108 2 is be VBZ 40436 4108 3 plain plain RB 40436 4108 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 4108 5 that that IN 40436 4108 6 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4108 7 definition definition NN 40436 4108 8 of of IN 40436 4108 9 courage courage NN 40436 4108 10 is be VBZ 40436 4108 11 not not RB 40436 4108 12 precise precise JJ 40436 4108 13 , , , 40436 4108 14 and and CC 40436 4108 15 can can MD 40436 4108 16 not not RB 40436 4108 17 be be VB 40436 4108 18 sustained sustain VBN 40436 4108 19 . . . 40436 4109 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4109 2 have have VBP 40436 4109 3 not not RB 40436 4109 4 yet yet RB 40436 4109 5 discovered discover VBN 40436 4109 6 what what WDT 40436 4109 7 courage courage NN 40436 4109 8 is be VBZ 40436 4109 9 . . . 40436 4110 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4110 2 23 23 CD 40436 4110 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4110 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4110 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4110 6 22 22 CD 40436 4110 7 : : : 40436 4110 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4110 9 , , , 40436 4110 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4110 11 , , , 40436 4110 12 199 199 CD 40436 4110 13 C. C. NNP 40436 4110 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4110 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4110 16 : : : 40436 4110 17 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 4110 18 to\n to\n NNP 40436 4110 19 so\n so\n NNP 40436 4110 20 lo lo NNP 40436 4110 21 / / SYM 40436 4110 22 gon gon NNP 40436 4110 23 ou ou NNP 40436 4110 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4110 25 mo mo NNP 40436 4110 26 / / SYM 40436 4110 27 non non AFX 40436 4110 28 deinô deinô NNP 40436 4110 29 = = SYM 40436 4110 30 n n NNP 40436 4110 31 te te NNP 40436 4110 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4110 33 thar)r(ale thar)r(ale NNP 40436 4110 34 / / SYM 40436 4110 35 ôn ôn NNP 40436 4110 36 ê ê NN 40436 4110 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4110 38 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4110 39 / / SYM 40436 4110 40 mê mê NNP 40436 4110 41 a)ndrei a)ndrei NNP 40436 4110 42 / / SYM 40436 4110 43 a a DT 40436 4110 44 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 4110 45 / / SYM 40436 4110 46 n n NN 40436 4110 47 , , , 40436 4110 48 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 4110 49 schedo schedo NNP 40436 4110 50 / / SYM 40436 4110 51 n n CC 40436 4110 52 ti ti NNP 40436 4110 53 ê ê NNP 40436 4110 54 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4110 55 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 4110 56 pa pa NNP 40436 4110 57 / / SYM 40436 4110 58 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 4110 59 a)gathô a)gathô NNP 40436 4110 60 = = SYM 40436 4110 61 n n CC 40436 4110 62 te te NNP 40436 4110 63 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4110 64 kakô kakô NNP 40436 4110 65 = = SYM 40436 4110 66 n n NNP 40436 4110 67 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4110 68 pa pa NNP 40436 4110 69 / / SYM 40436 4110 70 ntôs ntôs NNP 40436 4110 71 e)cho e)cho NNP 40436 4110 72 / / SYM 40436 4110 73 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 4110 74 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4110 75 , , , 40436 4110 76 & & CC 40436 4110 77 c. c. NNP 40436 4110 78 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4110 79 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4110 80 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4110 81 23 23 CD 40436 4110 82 : : : 40436 4110 83 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4110 84 , , , 40436 4110 85 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4110 86 , , , 40436 4110 87 199 199 CD 40436 4110 88 E. E. NNP 40436 4110 89 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4110 90 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4110 91 : : : 40436 4110 92 Ou)k Ou)k NNP 40436 4110 93 a)/ra a)/ra XX 40436 4110 94 eu)rê eu)rê NNP 40436 4110 95 / / SYM 40436 4110 96 kamen kamen NNP 40436 4110 97 , , , 40436 4110 98 a)ndrei a)ndrei CD 40436 4110 99 / / SYM 40436 4110 100 a a DT 40436 4110 101 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 4110 102 , , , 40436 4110 103 ti ti NNP 40436 4110 104 e)/stin e)/stin NN 40436 4110 105 . . . 40436 4110 106 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4110 107 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4111 1 * * NFP 40436 4111 2 * * NFP 40436 4111 3 * * NFP 40436 4111 4 * * NFP 40436 4111 5 * * NFP 40436 4111 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4111 7 Side side NN 40436 4111 8 - - HYPH 40436 4111 9 note note NN 40436 4111 10 : : : 40436 4111 11 Remarks remark NNS 40436 4111 12 . . . 40436 4112 1 Warfare warfare NN 40436 4112 2 of of IN 40436 4112 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4112 4 against against IN 40436 4112 5 the the DT 40436 4112 6 false false JJ 40436 4112 7 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 4112 8 of of IN 40436 4112 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4112 10 . . . 40436 4113 1 Brave brave JJ 40436 4113 2 generals general NNS 40436 4113 3 deliver deliver VBP 40436 4113 4 opinions opinion NNS 40436 4113 5 confidently confidently RB 40436 4113 6 about about IN 40436 4113 7 courage courage NN 40436 4113 8 without without IN 40436 4113 9 knowing know VBG 40436 4113 10 what what WP 40436 4113 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4113 12 is be VBZ 40436 4113 13 . . . 40436 4113 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4114 1 Here here RB 40436 4114 2 ends end VBZ 40436 4114 3 the the DT 40436 4114 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4114 5 called call VBN 40436 4114 6 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4114 7 , , , 40436 4114 8 without without IN 40436 4114 9 any any DT 40436 4114 10 positive positive JJ 40436 4114 11 result result NN 40436 4114 12 . . . 40436 4115 1 Nothing nothing NN 40436 4115 2 is be VBZ 40436 4115 3 proved prove VBN 40436 4115 4 except except IN 40436 4115 5 the the DT 40436 4115 6 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4115 7 of of IN 40436 4115 8 two two CD 40436 4115 9 brave brave JJ 40436 4115 10 and and CC 40436 4115 11 eminent eminent JJ 40436 4115 12 generals general NNS 40436 4115 13 respecting respect VBG 40436 4115 14 the the DT 40436 4115 15 moral moral JJ 40436 4115 16 attribute attribute NN 40436 4115 17 known know VBN 40436 4115 18 by by IN 40436 4115 19 the the DT 40436 4115 20 name name NN 40436 4115 21 _ _ NNP 40436 4115 22 Courage Courage NNP 40436 4115 23 _ _ NNP 40436 4115 24 : : : 40436 4115 25 which which WDT 40436 4115 26 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 4115 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4115 28 are be VBP 40436 4115 29 known know VBN 40436 4115 30 to to TO 40436 4115 31 possess possess VB 40436 4115 32 , , , 40436 4115 33 and and CC 40436 4115 34 have have VB 40436 4115 35 the the DT 40436 4115 36 full full JJ 40436 4115 37 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 4115 38 and and CC 40436 4115 39 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 4115 40 of of IN 40436 4115 41 knowing know VBG 40436 4115 42 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 4115 43 ; ; : 40436 4115 44 so so IN 40436 4115 45 that that IN 40436 4115 46 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4115 47 give give VBP 40436 4115 48 confident confident JJ 40436 4115 49 advice advice NN 40436 4115 50 as as IN 40436 4115 51 to to IN 40436 4115 52 the the DT 40436 4115 53 means mean NNS 40436 4115 54 of of IN 40436 4115 55 imparting impart VBG 40436 4115 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4115 57 . . . 40436 4116 1 " " `` 40436 4116 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4116 3 am be VBP 40436 4116 4 unaccustomed unaccustomed JJ 40436 4116 5 to to IN 40436 4116 6 debates debate NNS 40436 4116 7 like like IN 40436 4116 8 these these DT 40436 4116 9 " " '' 40436 4116 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4116 11 says say VBZ 40436 4116 12 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4116 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4116 14 : : : 40436 4116 15 " " `` 40436 4116 16 but but CC 40436 4116 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4116 18 am be VBP 40436 4116 19 piqued pique VBN 40436 4116 20 and and CC 40436 4116 21 mortified mortify VBN 40436 4116 22 -- -- : 40436 4116 23 because because IN 40436 4116 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4116 25 feel feel VBP 40436 4116 26 that that IN 40436 4116 27 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4116 28 know know VBP 40436 4116 29 well well UH 40436 4116 30 what what WP 40436 4116 31 Courage Courage NNP 40436 4116 32 is be VBZ 40436 4116 33 , , , 40436 4116 34 yet yet CC 40436 4116 35 somehow somehow RB 40436 4116 36 or or CC 40436 4116 37 other other JJ 40436 4116 38 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4116 39 can can MD 40436 4116 40 not not RB 40436 4116 41 state state VB 40436 4116 42 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4116 43 own own JJ 40436 4116 44 thoughts thought NNS 40436 4116 45 in in IN 40436 4116 46 words word NNS 40436 4116 47 . . . 40436 4116 48 " " '' 40436 4117 1 Here here RB 40436 4117 2 is be VBZ 40436 4117 3 a a DT 40436 4117 4 description[24 description[24 NN 40436 4117 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4117 6 of of IN 40436 4117 7 the the DT 40436 4117 8 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 4117 9 deficiency deficiency NN 40436 4117 10 which which WDT 40436 4117 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4117 12 seeks seek VBZ 40436 4117 13 to to TO 40436 4117 14 render render VB 40436 4117 15 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 4117 16 to to IN 40436 4117 17 the the DT 40436 4117 18 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 4117 19 , , , 40436 4117 20 instead instead RB 40436 4117 21 of of IN 40436 4117 22 suffering suffer VBG 40436 4117 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4117 24 to to TO 40436 4117 25 remain remain VB 40436 4117 26 latent latent JJ 40436 4117 27 and and CC 40436 4117 28 unknown unknown JJ 40436 4117 29 , , , 40436 4117 30 as as IN 40436 4117 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4117 32 is be VBZ 40436 4117 33 in in IN 40436 4117 34 the the DT 40436 4117 35 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 4117 36 mind mind NN 40436 4117 37 . . . 40436 4118 1 Here here RB 40436 4118 2 , , , 40436 4118 3 as as IN 40436 4118 4 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 4118 5 , , , 40436 4118 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4118 7 impugns impugn VBZ 40436 4118 8 the the DT 40436 4118 9 false false JJ 40436 4118 10 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 4118 11 of of IN 40436 4118 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4118 13 , , , 40436 4118 14 and and CC 40436 4118 15 the the DT 40436 4118 16 unconscious unconscious JJ 40436 4118 17 presumption presumption NN 40436 4118 18 of of IN 40436 4118 19 estimable estimable JJ 40436 4118 20 men man NNS 40436 4118 21 in in IN 40436 4118 22 delivering deliver VBG 40436 4118 23 opinions opinion NNS 40436 4118 24 upon upon IN 40436 4118 25 ethical ethical JJ 40436 4118 26 and and CC 40436 4118 27 social social JJ 40436 4118 28 subjects subject NNS 40436 4118 29 , , , 40436 4118 30 which which WDT 40436 4118 31 have have VBP 40436 4118 32 become become VBN 40436 4118 33 familiar familiar JJ 40436 4118 34 and and CC 40436 4118 35 interwoven interwoven JJ 40436 4118 36 with with IN 40436 4118 37 deeply deeply RB 40436 4118 38 rooted rooted JJ 40436 4118 39 associations association NNS 40436 4118 40 , , , 40436 4118 41 but but CC 40436 4118 42 have have VBP 40436 4118 43 never never RB 40436 4118 44 been be VBN 40436 4118 45 studied study VBN 40436 4118 46 under under IN 40436 4118 47 a a DT 40436 4118 48 master master NN 40436 4118 49 , , , 40436 4118 50 nor nor CC 40436 4118 51 carefully carefully RB 40436 4118 52 analysed analyse VBN 40436 4118 53 and and CC 40436 4118 54 discussed discuss VBN 40436 4118 55 , , , 40436 4118 56 nor nor CC 40436 4118 57 looked look VBD 40436 4118 58 at at IN 40436 4118 59 in in IN 40436 4118 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4118 61 full full JJ 40436 4118 62 generality generality NN 40436 4118 63 . . . 40436 4119 1 This this DT 40436 4119 2 is be VBZ 40436 4119 3 a a DT 40436 4119 4 mental mental JJ 40436 4119 5 defect defect NN 40436 4119 6 which which WDT 40436 4119 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4119 8 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 4119 9 to to TO 40436 4119 10 be be VB 40436 4119 11 universal universal JJ 40436 4119 12 : : : 40436 4119 13 belonging belong VBG 40436 4119 14 not not RB 40436 4119 15 less less JJR 40436 4119 16 to to IN 40436 4119 17 men man NNS 40436 4119 18 of of IN 40436 4119 19 action action NN 40436 4119 20 like like IN 40436 4119 21 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4119 22 and and CC 40436 4119 23 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4119 24 , , , 40436 4119 25 than than IN 40436 4119 26 to to IN 40436 4119 27 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 4119 28 and and CC 40436 4119 29 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 4119 30 like like IN 40436 4119 31 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 4119 32 and and CC 40436 4119 33 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 4119 34 . . . 40436 4120 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4120 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4120 3 24 24 CD 40436 4120 4 : : : 40436 4120 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4120 6 , , , 40436 4120 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4120 8 , , , 40436 4120 9 194 194 CD 40436 4120 10 . . . 40436 4121 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4121 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4121 3 : : : 40436 4121 4 Kai Kai NNP 40436 4121 5 / / SYM 40436 4121 6 toi toi NNP 40436 4121 7 a)ê a)ê NNP 40436 4121 8 / / SYM 40436 4121 9 thês thês NNP 40436 4121 10 g g NN 40436 4121 11 ' ' '' 40436 4121 12 ei)mi\ ei)mi\ NNP 40436 4121 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4121 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4121 15 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4121 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4121 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4121 18 Greek greek NN 40436 4121 19 : : : 40436 4121 20 tô tô NNP 40436 4121 21 = = SYM 40436 4121 22 n n CC 40436 4121 23 toiou toiou NNP 40436 4121 24 / / SYM 40436 4121 25 tôn tôn NNP 40436 4121 26 lo lo NNP 40436 4121 27 / / SYM 40436 4121 28 gôn gôn NNP 40436 4121 29 ; ; : 40436 4121 30 a)lla/ a)lla/ NNP 40436 4121 31 ti ti NNP 40436 4121 32 / / SYM 40436 4121 33 s s POS 40436 4121 34 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4121 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4121 36 philoneiki philoneiki NNP 40436 4121 37 / / SYM 40436 4121 38 a a DT 40436 4121 39 ei)/lêphe ei)/lêphe NNP 40436 4121 40 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 4121 41 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 4121 42 ei)rême ei)rême NN 40436 4121 43 / / , 40436 4121 44 na na RB 40436 4121 45 , , , 40436 4121 46 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4121 47 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 4121 48 a)lêthô a)lêthô NNP 40436 4121 49 = = SYM 40436 4121 50 s s NNP 40436 4121 51 a)ganaktô= a)ganaktô= NNP 40436 4121 52 , , , 40436 4121 53 ei ei NNP 40436 4121 54 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4121 55 ou(tôsi\ ou(tôsi\ NNP 40436 4121 56 a)\ a)\ NNP 40436 4121 57 noô= noô= JJ 40436 4121 58 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 4121 59 oi(=o oi(=o JJ 40436 4121 60 / / SYM 40436 4121 61 s s NNP 40436 4121 62 t t NNP 40436 4121 63 ' ' '' 40436 4121 64 ei)mi\ ei)mi\ NNP 40436 4121 65 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 4121 66 = = SYM 40436 4121 67 n n XX 40436 4121 68 ; ; : 40436 4121 69 noei noei NN 40436 4121 70 = = SYM 40436 4121 71 n n CC 40436 4121 72 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4121 73 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4121 74 e)/moige e)/moige NNP 40436 4121 75 dokô= dokô= JJ 40436 4121 76 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 4121 77 a)ndrei a)ndrei CD 40436 4121 78 / / SYM 40436 4121 79 as as IN 40436 4121 80 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 4121 81 , , , 40436 4121 82 ti ti NNP 40436 4121 83 e)/stin e)/stin NN 40436 4121 84 , , , 40436 4121 85 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 4121 86 oi)=da oi)=da NNP 40436 4121 87 d d NNP 40436 4121 88 ' ' `` 40436 4121 89 o(/pê| o(/pê| CC 40436 4121 90 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4121 91 a)/rti a)/rti NNP 40436 4121 92 die die VBP 40436 4121 93 / / SYM 40436 4121 94 phugen phugen NN 40436 4121 95 , , , 40436 4121 96 ô(/ste ô(/ste LS 40436 4121 97 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 4121 98 xullabei xullabei NN 40436 4121 99 = = SYM 40436 4121 100 n n CC 40436 4121 101 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 4121 102 lo lo NNP 40436 4121 103 / / SYM 40436 4121 104 gô| gô| NNP 40436 4121 105 au)tê\n au)tê\n NN 40436 4121 106 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4121 107 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 4121 108 = = SYM 40436 4121 109 n n NNP 40436 4121 110 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 4121 111 , , , 40436 4121 112 ti ti NNP 40436 4121 113 e)/stin e)/stin NN 40436 4121 114 . . . 40436 4121 115 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4122 1 Compare compare VB 40436 4122 2 the the DT 40436 4122 3 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4122 4 p. p. NN 40436 4122 5 159 159 CD 40436 4122 6 A a NN 40436 4122 7 , , , 40436 4122 8 160 160 CD 40436 4122 9 D d NN 40436 4122 10 , , , 40436 4122 11 where where WRB 40436 4122 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4122 13 professes profess VBZ 40436 4122 14 to to TO 40436 4122 15 tell tell VB 40436 4122 16 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4122 17 , , , 40436 4122 18 If if IN 40436 4122 19 temperance temperance NN 40436 4122 20 is be VBZ 40436 4122 21 really really RB 40436 4122 22 in in IN 40436 4122 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4122 24 , , , 40436 4122 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4122 26 can can MD 40436 4122 27 of of IN 40436 4122 28 course course NN 40436 4122 29 inform inform VB 40436 4122 30 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4122 31 what what WP 40436 4122 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4122 33 is be VBZ 40436 4122 34 . . . 40436 4122 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4123 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4123 2 Side side NN 40436 4123 3 - - HYPH 40436 4123 4 note note NN 40436 4123 5 : : : 40436 4123 6 No no DT 40436 4123 7 solution solution NN 40436 4123 8 given give VBN 40436 4123 9 by by IN 40436 4123 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4123 11 . . . 40436 4124 1 Apparent apparent JJ 40436 4124 2 tendency tendency NN 40436 4124 3 of of IN 40436 4124 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4124 5 mind mind NN 40436 4124 6 , , , 40436 4124 7 in in IN 40436 4124 8 looking look VBG 40436 4124 9 for for IN 40436 4124 10 a a DT 40436 4124 11 solution solution NN 40436 4124 12 . . . 40436 4125 1 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4125 2 -- -- : 40436 4125 3 cannot cannot NN 40436 4125 4 be be VB 40436 4125 5 understood understand VBN 40436 4125 6 without without IN 40436 4125 7 reference reference NN 40436 4125 8 to to IN 40436 4125 9 some some DT 40436 4125 10 object object NN 40436 4125 11 or or CC 40436 4125 12 end end NN 40436 4125 13 . . . 40436 4125 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4126 1 Here here RB 40436 4126 2 , , , 40436 4126 3 as as IN 40436 4126 4 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 4126 5 , , , 40436 4126 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4126 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4126 8 or or CC 40436 4126 9 the the DT 40436 4126 10 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 4126 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4126 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4126 13 exposes expose VBZ 40436 4126 14 the the DT 40436 4126 15 faulty faulty JJ 40436 4126 16 solutions solution NNS 40436 4126 17 of of IN 40436 4126 18 others other NNS 40436 4126 19 , , , 40436 4126 20 but but CC 40436 4126 21 proposes propose VBZ 40436 4126 22 no no DT 40436 4126 23 better well JJR 40436 4126 24 solution solution NN 40436 4126 25 of of IN 40436 4126 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4126 27 own own JJ 40436 4126 28 , , , 40436 4126 29 and and CC 40436 4126 30 even even RB 40436 4126 31 disclaims disclaim VBZ 40436 4126 32 all all DT 40436 4126 33 ability ability NN 40436 4126 34 to to TO 40436 4126 35 do do VB 40436 4126 36 so so RB 40436 4126 37 . . . 40436 4127 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4127 2 may may MD 40436 4127 3 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 4127 4 trace trace VB 40436 4127 5 , , , 40436 4127 6 in in IN 40436 4127 7 the the DT 40436 4127 8 refutation refutation NN 40436 4127 9 which which WDT 40436 4127 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4127 11 gives give VBZ 40436 4127 12 of of IN 40436 4127 13 the the DT 40436 4127 14 two two CD 40436 4127 15 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 4127 16 explanations explanation NNS 40436 4127 17 , , , 40436 4127 18 hints hint NNS 40436 4127 19 guiding guide VBG 40436 4127 20 the the DT 40436 4127 21 mind mind NN 40436 4127 22 into into IN 40436 4127 23 that that DT 40436 4127 24 direction direction NN 40436 4127 25 in in IN 40436 4127 26 which which WDT 40436 4127 27 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4127 28 looks look VBZ 40436 4127 29 to to TO 40436 4127 30 supply supply VB 40436 4127 31 the the DT 40436 4127 32 deficiency deficiency NN 40436 4127 33 . . . 40436 4128 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4128 2 when when WRB 40436 4128 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4128 4 , , , 40436 4128 5 after after IN 40436 4128 6 having have VBG 40436 4128 7 given give VBN 40436 4128 8 as as IN 40436 4128 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4128 10 first first JJ 40436 4128 11 answer answer NN 40436 4128 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4128 13 to to IN 40436 4128 14 the the DT 40436 4128 15 question question NN 40436 4128 16 , , , 40436 4128 17 What what WP 40436 4128 18 is be VBZ 40436 4128 19 Courage courage NN 40436 4128 20 ? ? . 40436 4128 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4129 1 a a DT 40436 4129 2 definition definition NN 40436 4129 3 not not RB 40436 4129 4 even even RB 40436 4129 5 formally formally RB 40436 4129 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 4129 7 , , , 40436 4129 8 is be VBZ 40436 4129 9 put put VBN 40436 4129 10 by by IN 40436 4129 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4129 12 upon upon IN 40436 4129 13 giving give VBG 40436 4129 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4129 15 second second NN 40436 4129 16 answer,--That answer,--that IN 40436 4129 17 Courage Courage NNP 40436 4129 18 is be VBZ 40436 4129 19 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4129 20 endurance endurance NN 40436 4129 21 : : : 40436 4129 22 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4129 23 asks ask VBZ 40436 4129 24 him[25]--"Yes him[25]--"ye NNS 40436 4129 25 , , , 40436 4129 26 _ _ NNP 40436 4129 27 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4129 28 _ _ NNP 40436 4129 29 : : : 40436 4129 30 but but CC 40436 4129 31 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4129 32 to to IN 40436 4129 33 _ _ NNP 40436 4129 34 what what WP 40436 4129 35 end end NN 40436 4129 36 _ _ XX 40436 4129 37 ? ? . 40436 4130 1 Do do VBP 40436 4130 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4130 3 mean mean VB 40436 4130 4 , , , 40436 4130 5 to to IN 40436 4130 6 all all DT 40436 4130 7 things thing NNS 40436 4130 8 alike alike RB 40436 4130 9 , , , 40436 4130 10 great great JJ 40436 4130 11 as as RB 40436 4130 12 well well RB 40436 4130 13 as as IN 40436 4130 14 little little JJ 40436 4130 15 ? ? . 40436 4130 16 " " '' 40436 4131 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4131 2 are be VBP 40436 4131 3 here here RB 40436 4131 4 reminded remind VBN 40436 4131 5 that that IN 40436 4131 6 _ _ NNP 40436 4131 7 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4131 8 _ _ NNP 40436 4131 9 , , , 40436 4131 10 simply simply RB 40436 4131 11 taken take VBN 40436 4131 12 , , , 40436 4131 13 is be VBZ 40436 4131 14 altogether altogether RB 40436 4131 15 undefined undefined JJ 40436 4131 16 ; ; : 40436 4131 17 that that DT 40436 4131 18 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4131 19 must must MD 40436 4131 20 relate relate VB 40436 4131 21 to to IN 40436 4131 22 _ _ NNP 40436 4131 23 something_--and something_--and NNP 40436 4131 24 when when WRB 40436 4131 25 human human JJ 40436 4131 26 conduct conduct NN 40436 4131 27 is be VBZ 40436 4131 28 in in IN 40436 4131 29 question question NN 40436 4131 30 , , , 40436 4131 31 must must MD 40436 4131 32 relate relate VB 40436 4131 33 to to IN 40436 4131 34 some some DT 40436 4131 35 end end NN 40436 4131 36 ; ; : 40436 4131 37 and and CC 40436 4131 38 that that IN 40436 4131 39 the the DT 40436 4131 40 Something something NN 40436 4131 41 , , , 40436 4131 42 and and CC 40436 4131 43 the the DT 40436 4131 44 End end NN 40436 4131 45 , , , 40436 4131 46 to to TO 40436 4131 47 which which WDT 40436 4131 48 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4131 49 relates relate VBZ 40436 4131 50 , , , 40436 4131 51 must must MD 40436 4131 52 be be VB 40436 4131 53 set set VBN 40436 4131 54 forth forth RP 40436 4131 55 , , , 40436 4131 56 before before IN 40436 4131 57 the the DT 40436 4131 58 proposition proposition NN 40436 4131 59 can can MD 40436 4131 60 be be VB 40436 4131 61 clearly clearly RB 40436 4131 62 understood understand VBN 40436 4131 63 . . . 40436 4132 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4132 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4132 3 25 25 CD 40436 4132 4 : : : 40436 4132 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4132 6 , , , 40436 4132 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4132 8 , , , 40436 4132 9 192 192 CD 40436 4132 10 D. D. NNP 40436 4132 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4132 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4132 13 : : : 40436 4132 14 ê ê NNP 40436 4132 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4132 16 phro phro NNP 40436 4132 17 / / SYM 40436 4132 18 nimos nimos NNP 40436 4132 19 karteri karteri NNP 40436 4132 20 / / SYM 40436 4132 21 a a DT 40436 4132 22 . . . 40436 4133 1 . . . 40436 4134 1 . . . 40436 4135 1 i)/dômen i)/dômen NNP 40436 4135 2 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 4135 3 , , , 40436 4135 4 ê ê NNP 40436 4135 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4135 6 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 4135 7 ti ti NNP 40436 4135 8 phro phro NNP 40436 4135 9 / / SYM 40436 4135 10 nimos nimos NNP 40436 4135 11 ; ; : 40436 4135 12 ê)\ ê)\ ADD 40436 4135 13 ê ê NNP 40436 4135 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4135 15 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 4135 16 a(/panta a(/panta NNP 40436 4135 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4135 18 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4135 19 mega mega NNP 40436 4135 20 / / SYM 40436 4135 21 la la NNP 40436 4135 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4135 23 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4135 24 smikra/ smikra/ NNP 40436 4135 25 ? ? . 40436 4135 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4135 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4136 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4136 2 Side side NN 40436 4136 3 - - HYPH 40436 4136 4 note note NN 40436 4136 5 : : : 40436 4136 6 Object object NN 40436 4136 7 -- -- : 40436 4136 8 is be VBZ 40436 4136 9 supplied supply VBN 40436 4136 10 in in IN 40436 4136 11 the the DT 40436 4136 12 answer answer NN 40436 4136 13 of of IN 40436 4136 14 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4136 15 . . . 40436 4137 1 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4137 2 -- -- : 40436 4137 3 of of IN 40436 4137 4 things thing NNS 40436 4137 5 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4137 6 and and CC 40436 4137 7 not not RB 40436 4137 8 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4137 9 . . . 40436 4138 1 Such such JJ 40436 4138 2 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4138 3 is be VBZ 40436 4138 4 not not RB 40436 4138 5 possessed possess VBN 40436 4138 6 by by IN 40436 4138 7 professional professional JJ 40436 4138 8 artists artist NNS 40436 4138 9 . . . 40436 4138 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4139 1 Coming come VBG 40436 4139 2 to to IN 40436 4139 3 the the DT 40436 4139 4 answer answer NN 40436 4139 5 given give VBN 40436 4139 6 by by IN 40436 4139 7 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4139 8 , , , 40436 4139 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4139 10 perceive perceive VBP 40436 4139 11 that that IN 40436 4139 12 this this DT 40436 4139 13 deficiency deficiency NN 40436 4139 14 is be VBZ 40436 4139 15 in in IN 40436 4139 16 a a DT 40436 4139 17 certain certain JJ 40436 4139 18 manner manner NN 40436 4139 19 supplied supply VBN 40436 4139 20 . . . 40436 4140 1 Courage courage NN 40436 4140 2 is be VBZ 40436 4140 3 said say VBN 40436 4140 4 to to TO 40436 4140 5 consist consist VB 40436 4140 6 in in IN 40436 4140 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4140 8 : : : 40436 4140 9 in in IN 40436 4140 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4140 11 of of IN 40436 4140 12 things thing NNS 40436 4140 13 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4140 14 , , , 40436 4140 15 and and CC 40436 4140 16 things thing NNS 40436 4140 17 not not RB 40436 4140 18 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4140 19 . . . 40436 4141 1 When when WRB 40436 4141 2 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4141 3 applies apply VBZ 40436 4141 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4141 5 cross cross NN 40436 4141 6 - - NN 40436 4141 7 examination examination NN 40436 4141 8 to to IN 40436 4141 9 the the DT 40436 4141 10 answer answer NN 40436 4141 11 , , , 40436 4141 12 the the DT 40436 4141 13 manner manner NN 40436 4141 14 in in IN 40436 4141 15 which which WDT 40436 4141 16 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4141 17 defends defend VBZ 40436 4141 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4141 19 puts put VBZ 40436 4141 20 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4141 21 upon upon IN 40436 4141 22 a a DT 40436 4141 23 distinction distinction NN 40436 4141 24 often often RB 40436 4141 25 brought bring VBD 40436 4141 26 to to TO 40436 4141 27 view view NN 40436 4141 28 , , , 40436 4141 29 though though IN 40436 4141 30 not not RB 40436 4141 31 always always RB 40436 4141 32 adhered adhere VBN 40436 4141 33 to to IN 40436 4141 34 , , , 40436 4141 35 in in IN 40436 4141 36 the the DT 40436 4141 37 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 4141 38 writings writing NNS 40436 4141 39 . . . 40436 4142 1 There there EX 40436 4142 2 can can MD 40436 4142 3 be be VB 40436 4142 4 no no DT 40436 4142 5 doubt doubt NN 40436 4142 6 that that IN 40436 4142 7 death death NN 40436 4142 8 , , , 40436 4142 9 distemper distemper NN 40436 4142 10 , , , 40436 4142 11 loss loss NN 40436 4142 12 of of IN 40436 4142 13 wealth wealth NN 40436 4142 14 , , , 40436 4142 15 defeat defeat NN 40436 4142 16 , , , 40436 4142 17 & & CC 40436 4142 18 c. c. NNP 40436 4142 19 are be VBP 40436 4142 20 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4142 21 things thing NNS 40436 4142 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4142 23 _ _ NNP 40436 4142 24 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 4142 25 _ _ NNP 40436 4142 26 the the DT 40436 4142 27 prospect prospect NN 40436 4142 28 of of IN 40436 4142 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4142 30 inspires inspire NNS 40436 4142 31 fear fear VBP 40436 4142 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4142 33 in in IN 40436 4142 34 the the DT 40436 4142 35 estimation estimation NN 40436 4142 36 of of IN 40436 4142 37 mankind mankind NN 40436 4142 38 generally generally RB 40436 4142 39 . . . 40436 4143 1 Correct correct JJ 40436 4143 2 foresight foresight NN 40436 4143 3 of of IN 40436 4143 4 such such JJ 40436 4143 5 contingencies contingency NNS 40436 4143 6 , , , 40436 4143 7 and and CC 40436 4143 8 of of IN 40436 4143 9 the the DT 40436 4143 10 antecedents antecedent NNS 40436 4143 11 tending tend VBG 40436 4143 12 to to TO 40436 4143 13 produce produce VB 40436 4143 14 or or CC 40436 4143 15 avert avert VB 40436 4143 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4143 17 , , , 40436 4143 18 is be VBZ 40436 4143 19 possessed possess VBN 40436 4143 20 by by IN 40436 4143 21 the the DT 40436 4143 22 physician physician NN 40436 4143 23 and and CC 40436 4143 24 other other JJ 40436 4143 25 professional professional JJ 40436 4143 26 persons person NNS 40436 4143 27 : : : 40436 4143 28 who who WP 40436 4143 29 would would MD 40436 4143 30 therefore therefore RB 40436 4143 31 , , , 40436 4143 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4143 33 should should MD 40436 4143 34 seem seem VB 40436 4143 35 , , , 40436 4143 36 possess possess VB 40436 4143 37 the the DT 40436 4143 38 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4143 39 of of IN 40436 4143 40 things thing NNS 40436 4143 41 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4143 42 and and CC 40436 4143 43 not not RB 40436 4143 44 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4143 45 . . . 40436 4144 1 But but CC 40436 4144 2 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4144 3 denies deny VBZ 40436 4144 4 this this DT 40436 4144 5 . . . 40436 4145 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4145 2 does do VBZ 40436 4145 3 not not RB 40436 4145 4 admit admit VB 40436 4145 5 that that IN 40436 4145 6 the the DT 40436 4145 7 contingencies contingency NNS 40436 4145 8 here here RB 40436 4145 9 enumerated enumerate VBN 40436 4145 10 are be VBP 40436 4145 11 , , , 40436 4145 12 always always RB 40436 4145 13 or or CC 40436 4145 14 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 4145 15 , , , 40436 4145 16 proper proper JJ 40436 4145 17 objects object NNS 40436 4145 18 of of IN 40436 4145 19 fear fear NN 40436 4145 20 . . . 40436 4146 1 In in IN 40436 4146 2 some some DT 40436 4146 3 cases case NNS 40436 4146 4 , , , 40436 4146 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4146 6 contends contend VBZ 40436 4146 7 , , , 40436 4146 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4146 9 are be VBP 40436 4146 10 the the DT 40436 4146 11 least least JJS 40436 4146 12 of of IN 40436 4146 13 two two CD 40436 4146 14 evils evil NNS 40436 4146 15 . . . 40436 4147 1 Before before IN 40436 4147 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4147 3 can can MD 40436 4147 4 be be VB 40436 4147 5 said say VBN 40436 4147 6 to to TO 40436 4147 7 possess possess VB 40436 4147 8 the the DT 40436 4147 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4147 10 of of IN 40436 4147 11 things thing NNS 40436 4147 12 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4147 13 and and CC 40436 4147 14 not not RB 40436 4147 15 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4147 16 , , , 40436 4147 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4147 18 must must MD 40436 4147 19 be be VB 40436 4147 20 able able JJ 40436 4147 21 to to TO 40436 4147 22 take take VB 40436 4147 23 correct correct JJ 40436 4147 24 measure measure NN 40436 4147 25 not not RB 40436 4147 26 only only RB 40436 4147 27 of of IN 40436 4147 28 the the DT 40436 4147 29 intervening intervene VBG 40436 4147 30 antecedents antecedent NNS 40436 4147 31 or or CC 40436 4147 32 means mean NNS 40436 4147 33 , , , 40436 4147 34 but but CC 40436 4147 35 also also RB 40436 4147 36 of of IN 40436 4147 37 the the DT 40436 4147 38 end end NN 40436 4147 39 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4147 40 as as IN 40436 4147 41 compared compare VBN 40436 4147 42 with with IN 40436 4147 43 other other JJ 40436 4147 44 alternative alternative JJ 40436 4147 45 ends end NNS 40436 4147 46 : : : 40436 4147 47 whether whether IN 40436 4147 48 , , , 40436 4147 49 in in IN 40436 4147 50 each each DT 40436 4147 51 particular particular JJ 40436 4147 52 case case NN 40436 4147 53 , , , 40436 4147 54 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4147 55 be be VB 40436 4147 56 the the DT 40436 4147 57 end end NN 40436 4147 58 most most RBS 40436 4147 59 to to TO 40436 4147 60 be be VB 40436 4147 61 feared fear VBN 40436 4147 62 , , , 40436 4147 63 or or CC 40436 4147 64 the the DT 40436 4147 65 real real JJ 40436 4147 66 evil evil NN 40436 4147 67 under under IN 40436 4147 68 the the DT 40436 4147 69 given give VBN 40436 4147 70 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 4147 71 . . . 40436 4148 1 The the DT 40436 4148 2 professional professional JJ 40436 4148 3 man man NN 40436 4148 4 can can MD 40436 4148 5 do do VB 40436 4148 6 the the DT 40436 4148 7 former former JJ 40436 4148 8 , , , 40436 4148 9 but but CC 40436 4148 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4148 11 can can MD 40436 4148 12 not not RB 40436 4148 13 do do VB 40436 4148 14 the the DT 40436 4148 15 latter latter JJ 40436 4148 16 . . . 40436 4149 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4149 2 advises advise VBZ 40436 4149 3 as as IN 40436 4149 4 to to IN 40436 4149 5 means mean NNS 40436 4149 6 , , , 40436 4149 7 and and CC 40436 4149 8 executes execute NNS 40436 4149 9 : : : 40436 4149 10 but but CC 40436 4149 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4149 12 assumes assume VBZ 40436 4149 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4149 14 own own JJ 40436 4149 15 one one CD 40436 4149 16 end end NN 40436 4149 17 as as IN 40436 4149 18 an an DT 40436 4149 19 indisputable indisputable JJ 40436 4149 20 datum datum NN 40436 4149 21 . . . 40436 4150 1 The the DT 40436 4150 2 physician physician NN 40436 4150 3 seeks seek VBZ 40436 4150 4 to to TO 40436 4150 5 cure cure VB 40436 4150 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4150 7 patient patient NN 40436 4150 8 , , , 40436 4150 9 without without IN 40436 4150 10 ever ever RB 40436 4150 11 enquiring enquire VBG 40436 4150 12 whether whether IN 40436 4150 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4150 14 may may MD 40436 4150 15 not not RB 40436 4150 16 be be VB 40436 4150 17 a a DT 40436 4150 18 less less JJR 40436 4150 19 evil evil NN 40436 4150 20 for for IN 40436 4150 21 such such JJ 40436 4150 22 patient patient NN 40436 4150 23 to to TO 40436 4150 24 die die VB 40436 4150 25 than than IN 40436 4150 26 to to TO 40436 4150 27 survive survive VB 40436 4150 28 . . . 40436 4151 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4151 2 Side side NN 40436 4151 3 - - HYPH 40436 4151 4 note note NN 40436 4151 5 : : : 40436 4151 6 Postulate Postulate NNP 40436 4151 7 of of IN 40436 4151 8 a a DT 40436 4151 9 Science Science NNP 40436 4151 10 of of IN 40436 4151 11 Ends Ends NNPS 40436 4151 12 , , , 40436 4151 13 or or CC 40436 4151 14 Teleology teleology NN 40436 4151 15 , , , 40436 4151 16 dimly dimly RB 40436 4151 17 indicated indicate VBN 40436 4151 18 by by IN 40436 4151 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4151 20 . . . 40436 4152 1 The the DT 40436 4152 2 Unknown unknown JJ 40436 4152 3 Wise Wise NNP 40436 4152 4 Man Man NNP 40436 4152 5 -- -- : 40436 4152 6 correlates correlate VBZ 40436 4152 7 with with IN 40436 4152 8 the the DT 40436 4152 9 undiscovered undiscovered JJ 40436 4152 10 Science Science NNP 40436 4152 11 of of IN 40436 4152 12 Ends Ends NNPS 40436 4152 13 . . . 40436 4152 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4153 1 The the DT 40436 4153 2 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 4153 3 , , , 40436 4153 4 yet yet CC 40436 4153 5 not not RB 40436 4153 6 less less RBR 40436 4153 7 important important JJ 40436 4153 8 , , , 40436 4153 9 estimate estimate NN 40436 4153 10 of of IN 40436 4153 11 the the DT 40436 4153 12 comparative comparative JJ 40436 4153 13 worth worth NN 40436 4153 14 of of IN 40436 4153 15 different different JJ 40436 4153 16 ends end NNS 40436 4153 17 , , , 40436 4153 18 is be VBZ 40436 4153 19 reserved reserve VBN 40436 4153 20 for for IN 40436 4153 21 that that DT 40436 4153 22 unknown unknown JJ 40436 4153 23 master master NN 40436 4153 24 whom whom WP 40436 4153 25 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4153 26 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4153 27 does do VBZ 40436 4153 28 not not RB 40436 4153 29 farther farther RB 40436 4153 30 specify specify VB 40436 4153 31 , , , 40436 4153 32 and and CC 40436 4153 33 whom whom WP 40436 4153 34 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4153 35 sets set VBZ 40436 4153 36 aside aside RB 40436 4153 37 as as RB 40436 4153 38 nowhere nowhere RB 40436 4153 39 to to TO 40436 4153 40 be be VB 40436 4153 41 found find VBN 40436 4153 42 , , , 40436 4153 43 under under IN 40436 4153 44 the the DT 40436 4153 45 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 4153 46 phrase phrase NN 40436 4153 47 of of IN 40436 4153 48 " " `` 40436 4153 49 some some DT 40436 4153 50 God God NNP 40436 4153 51 " " '' 40436 4153 52 . . . 40436 4154 1 Subjectively subjectively RB 40436 4154 2 considered consider VBN 40436 4154 3 , , , 40436 4154 4 this this DT 40436 4154 5 is be VBZ 40436 4154 6 an an DT 40436 4154 7 appeal appeal NN 40436 4154 8 to to IN 40436 4154 9 the the DT 40436 4154 10 judgment judgment NN 40436 4154 11 of of IN 40436 4154 12 that that DT 40436 4154 13 One one CD 40436 4154 14 Wise Wise NNP 40436 4154 15 Man Man NNP 40436 4154 16 , , , 40436 4154 17 often often RB 40436 4154 18 alluded allude VBD 40436 4154 19 to to IN 40436 4154 20 by by IN 40436 4154 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4154 22 as as IN 40436 4154 23 an an DT 40436 4154 24 absent absent JJ 40436 4154 25 Expert expert NN 40436 4154 26 who who WP 40436 4154 27 might may MD 40436 4154 28 be be VB 40436 4154 29 called call VBN 40436 4154 30 into into IN 40436 4154 31 court court NN 40436 4154 32 -- -- : 40436 4154 33 yet yet CC 40436 4154 34 never never RB 40436 4154 35 to to TO 40436 4154 36 be be VB 40436 4154 37 found find VBN 40436 4154 38 at at IN 40436 4154 39 the the DT 40436 4154 40 exact exact JJ 40436 4154 41 moment moment NN 40436 4154 42 , , , 40436 4154 43 nor nor CC 40436 4154 44 produced produce VBN 40436 4154 45 in in IN 40436 4154 46 visible visible JJ 40436 4154 47 presence presence NN 40436 4154 48 : : : 40436 4154 49 Objectively objectively RB 40436 4154 50 considered consider VBN 40436 4154 51 , , , 40436 4154 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4154 53 is be VBZ 40436 4154 54 a a DT 40436 4154 55 postulate postulate NN 40436 4154 56 or or CC 40436 4154 57 divination divination NN 40436 4154 58 of of IN 40436 4154 59 some some DT 40436 4154 60 yet yet CC 40436 4154 61 undiscovered undiscovered JJ 40436 4154 62 Teleology Teleology NNP 40436 4154 63 or or CC 40436 4154 64 Science Science NNP 40436 4154 65 of of IN 40436 4154 66 Ends Ends NNPS 40436 4154 67 : : : 40436 4154 68 that that IN 40436 4154 69 Science Science NNP 40436 4154 70 of of IN 40436 4154 71 the the DT 40436 4154 72 Good Good NNP 40436 4154 73 , , , 40436 4154 74 which which WDT 40436 4154 75 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4154 76 as as IN 40436 4154 77 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4154 78 have have VBP 40436 4154 79 already already RB 40436 4154 80 noticed notice VBN 40436 4154 81 in in IN 40436 4154 82 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 4154 83 II II NNP 40436 4154 84 . . . 40436 4154 85 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4155 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4155 2 pronounces pronounce NNS 40436 4155 3 to to TO 40436 4155 4 be be VB 40436 4155 5 the the DT 40436 4155 6 crowning crowning JJ 40436 4155 7 and and CC 40436 4155 8 capital capital NN 40436 4155 9 science science NN 40436 4155 10 of of IN 40436 4155 11 all all DT 40436 4155 12 -- -- : 40436 4155 13 and and CC 40436 4155 14 without without IN 40436 4155 15 which which WDT 40436 4155 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4155 17 there there RB 40436 4155 18 declared declare VBD 40436 4155 19 , , , 40436 4155 20 that that DT 40436 4155 21 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4155 22 on on IN 40436 4155 23 all all DT 40436 4155 24 other other JJ 40436 4155 25 topics topic NNS 40436 4155 26 was be VBD 40436 4155 27 useless useless JJ 40436 4155 28 and and CC 40436 4155 29 even even RB 40436 4155 30 worse bad JJR 40436 4155 31 than than IN 40436 4155 32 useless useless JJ 40436 4155 33 . . . 40436 4156 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4156 2 26 26 CD 40436 4156 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4156 4 The the DT 40436 4156 5 One one CD 40436 4156 6 Wise Wise NNP 40436 4156 7 Man Man NNP 40436 4156 8 -- -- : 40436 4156 9 the the DT 40436 4156 10 _ _ NNP 40436 4156 11 Science Science NNP 40436 4156 12 of of IN 40436 4156 13 Good_--are Good_--are NNP 40436 4156 14 the the DT 40436 4156 15 Subject Subject NNP 40436 4156 16 and and CC 40436 4156 17 Object object NN 40436 4156 18 corresponding corresponding JJ 40436 4156 19 to to IN 40436 4156 20 each each DT 40436 4156 21 other other JJ 40436 4156 22 , , , 40436 4156 23 and and CC 40436 4156 24 postulated postulate VBN 40436 4156 25 by by IN 40436 4156 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4156 27 . . . 40436 4157 1 None none NN 40436 4157 2 but but CC 40436 4157 3 the the DT 40436 4157 4 One one CD 40436 4157 5 Wise Wise NNP 40436 4157 6 Man Man NNP 40436 4157 7 can can MD 40436 4157 8 measure measure VB 40436 4157 9 things thing NNS 40436 4157 10 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4157 11 and and CC 40436 4157 12 not not RB 40436 4157 13 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4157 14 : : : 40436 4157 15 none none NN 40436 4157 16 else else RB 40436 4157 17 can can MD 40436 4157 18 estimate estimate VB 40436 4157 19 the the DT 40436 4157 20 good good JJ 40436 4157 21 or or CC 40436 4157 22 evil evil NN 40436 4157 23 , , , 40436 4157 24 or or CC 40436 4157 25 the the DT 40436 4157 26 comparative comparative JJ 40436 4157 27 value value NN 40436 4157 28 of of IN 40436 4157 29 two two CD 40436 4157 30 alternative alternative JJ 40436 4157 31 evils evil NNS 40436 4157 32 , , , 40436 4157 33 in in IN 40436 4157 34 each each DT 40436 4157 35 individual individual JJ 40436 4157 36 case case NN 40436 4157 37 . . . 40436 4158 1 The the DT 40436 4158 2 items item NNS 40436 4158 3 here here RB 40436 4158 4 directed direct VBD 40436 4158 5 to to TO 40436 4158 6 be be VB 40436 4158 7 taken take VBN 40436 4158 8 into into IN 40436 4158 9 the the DT 40436 4158 10 calculation calculation NN 40436 4158 11 , , , 40436 4158 12 correspond correspond VB 40436 4158 13 with with IN 40436 4158 14 what what WP 40436 4158 15 is be VBZ 40436 4158 16 laid lay VBN 40436 4158 17 down down RP 40436 4158 18 by by IN 40436 4158 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4158 20 in in IN 40436 4158 21 the the DT 40436 4158 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 4158 23 , , , 40436 4158 24 not not RB 40436 4158 25 with with IN 40436 4158 26 that that DT 40436 4158 27 laid lay VBN 40436 4158 28 down down RP 40436 4158 29 in in IN 40436 4158 30 the the DT 40436 4158 31 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 4158 32 : : : 40436 4158 33 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4158 34 find find VBP 40436 4158 35 here here RB 40436 4158 36 none none NN 40436 4158 37 of of IN 40436 4158 38 that that DT 40436 4158 39 marked marked JJ 40436 4158 40 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 4158 41 between between IN 40436 4158 42 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 4158 43 and and CC 40436 4158 44 good good NN 40436 4158 45 -- -- : 40436 4158 46 between between IN 40436 4158 47 pain pain NN 40436 4158 48 and and CC 40436 4158 49 evil evil NN 40436 4158 50 -- -- : 40436 4158 51 upon upon IN 40436 4158 52 which which WDT 40436 4158 53 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4158 54 expatiates expatiate VBZ 40436 4158 55 in in IN 40436 4158 56 the the DT 40436 4158 57 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 4158 58 . . . 40436 4159 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4159 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4159 3 26 26 CD 40436 4159 4 : : : 40436 4159 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4159 6 , , , 40436 4159 7 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 4159 8 . . . 40436 4160 1 ii ii LS 40436 4160 2 . . . 40436 4161 1 146 146 CD 40436 4161 2 - - SYM 40436 4161 3 147 147 CD 40436 4161 4 . . . 40436 4162 1 See see VB 40436 4162 2 above above RB 40436 4162 3 , , , 40436 4162 4 ch ch NN 40436 4162 5 . . . 40436 4163 1 xii xii NNP 40436 4163 2 . . . 40436 4164 1 p. p. NN 40436 4165 1 16 16 CD 40436 4165 2 . . . 40436 4165 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4166 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4166 2 Side side NN 40436 4166 3 - - HYPH 40436 4166 4 note note NN 40436 4166 5 : : : 40436 4166 6 Perfect perfect JJ 40436 4166 7 condition condition NN 40436 4166 8 of of IN 40436 4166 9 the the DT 40436 4166 10 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4166 11 -- -- : 40436 4166 12 is be VBZ 40436 4166 13 the the DT 40436 4166 14 one one CD 40436 4166 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 4166 16 condition condition NN 40436 4166 17 of of IN 40436 4166 18 virtue virtue NN 40436 4166 19 . . . 40436 4166 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4167 1 This this DT 40436 4167 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 4167 3 still still RB 40436 4167 4 farther farther RB 40436 4167 5 when when WRB 40436 4167 6 the the DT 40436 4167 7 cross cross NN 40436 4167 8 - - NN 40436 4167 9 examination examination NN 40436 4167 10 is be VBZ 40436 4167 11 taken take VBN 40436 4167 12 up up RP 40436 4167 13 by by IN 40436 4167 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4167 15 instead instead RB 40436 4167 16 of of IN 40436 4167 17 by by IN 40436 4167 18 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4167 19 . . . 40436 4168 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4168 2 are be VBP 40436 4168 3 then then RB 40436 4168 4 made make VBN 40436 4168 5 to to TO 40436 4168 6 perceive perceive VB 40436 4168 7 , , , 40436 4168 8 that that IN 40436 4168 9 the the DT 40436 4168 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4168 11 of of IN 40436 4168 12 things thing NNS 40436 4168 13 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4168 14 and and CC 40436 4168 15 not not RB 40436 4168 16 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4168 17 is be VBZ 40436 4168 18 a a DT 40436 4168 19 part part NN 40436 4168 20 , , , 40436 4168 21 but but CC 40436 4168 22 an an DT 40436 4168 23 inseparable inseparable JJ 40436 4168 24 part part NN 40436 4168 25 , , , 40436 4168 26 of of IN 40436 4168 27 the the DT 40436 4168 28 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4168 29 of of IN 40436 4168 30 good good JJ 40436 4168 31 and and CC 40436 4168 32 evil evil NN 40436 4168 33 generally generally RB 40436 4168 34 : : : 40436 4168 35 the the DT 40436 4168 36 lesser less JJR 40436 4168 37 can can MD 40436 4168 38 not not RB 40436 4168 39 be be VB 40436 4168 40 had have VBN 40436 4168 41 without without IN 40436 4168 42 the the DT 40436 4168 43 greater great JJR 40436 4168 44 -- -- : 40436 4168 45 and and CC 40436 4168 46 the the DT 40436 4168 47 greater great JJR 40436 4168 48 carries carry VBZ 40436 4168 49 with with IN 40436 4168 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4168 51 not not RB 40436 4168 52 merely merely RB 40436 4168 53 courage courage NN 40436 4168 54 , , , 40436 4168 55 but but CC 40436 4168 56 all all PDT 40436 4168 57 the the DT 40436 4168 58 other other JJ 40436 4168 59 virtues virtue NNS 40436 4168 60 besides besides RB 40436 4168 61 . . . 40436 4169 1 None none NN 40436 4169 2 can can MD 40436 4169 3 know know VB 40436 4169 4 good good JJ 40436 4169 5 or or CC 40436 4169 6 evil evil NN 40436 4169 7 generally generally RB 40436 4169 8 except except IN 40436 4169 9 the the DT 40436 4169 10 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 4169 11 Wise Wise NNP 40436 4169 12 Man Man NNP 40436 4169 13 . . . 40436 4170 1 The the DT 40436 4170 2 perfect perfect JJ 40436 4170 3 condition condition NN 40436 4170 4 of of IN 40436 4170 5 the the DT 40436 4170 6 Intelligence Intelligence NNP 40436 4170 7 , , , 40436 4170 8 is be VBZ 40436 4170 9 the the DT 40436 4170 10 sole sole JJ 40436 4170 11 and and CC 40436 4170 12 all all RB 40436 4170 13 - - HYPH 40436 4170 14 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 4170 15 condition condition NN 40436 4170 16 of of IN 40436 4170 17 virtue virtue NN 40436 4170 18 . . . 40436 4171 1 None none NN 40436 4171 2 can can MD 40436 4171 3 possess possess VB 40436 4171 4 one one CD 40436 4171 5 mode mode NN 40436 4171 6 of of IN 40436 4171 7 virtue virtue NN 40436 4171 8 separately separately RB 40436 4171 9 . . . 40436 4172 1 This this DT 40436 4172 2 is be VBZ 40436 4172 3 the the DT 40436 4172 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 4172 5 to to TO 40436 4172 6 which which WDT 40436 4172 7 the the DT 40436 4172 8 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 4172 9 of of IN 40436 4172 10 the the DT 40436 4172 11 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4172 12 points point NNS 40436 4172 13 , , , 40436 4172 14 though though IN 40436 4172 15 the the DT 40436 4172 16 question question NN 40436 4172 17 debated debate VBN 40436 4172 18 is be VBZ 40436 4172 19 confessedly confessedly RB 40436 4172 20 left leave VBN 40436 4172 21 without without IN 40436 4172 22 solution solution NN 40436 4172 23 . . . 40436 4173 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4173 2 is be VBZ 40436 4173 3 a a DT 40436 4173 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 4173 5 which which WDT 40436 4173 6 seems seem VBZ 40436 4173 7 to to TO 40436 4173 8 have have VB 40436 4173 9 been be VBN 40436 4173 10 really really RB 40436 4173 11 maintained maintain VBN 40436 4173 12 by by IN 40436 4173 13 the the DT 40436 4173 14 historical historical JJ 40436 4173 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4173 16 , , , 40436 4173 17 and and CC 40436 4173 18 is be VBZ 40436 4173 19 often often RB 40436 4173 20 implied imply VBN 40436 4173 21 in in IN 40436 4173 22 the the DT 40436 4173 23 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 4173 24 of of IN 40436 4173 25 the the DT 40436 4173 26 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 4173 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4173 28 , , , 40436 4173 29 but but CC 40436 4173 30 not not RB 40436 4173 31 always always RB 40436 4173 32 nor nor CC 40436 4173 33 consistently consistently RB 40436 4173 34 . . . 40436 4174 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4174 2 Side side NN 40436 4174 3 - - HYPH 40436 4174 4 note note NN 40436 4174 5 : : : 40436 4174 6 Dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4174 7 contrast contrast NN 40436 4174 8 between between IN 40436 4174 9 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4174 10 and and CC 40436 4174 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4174 12 , , , 40436 4174 13 as as IN 40436 4174 14 cross cross NN 40436 4174 15 - - NNS 40436 4174 16 examiners examiner NNS 40436 4174 17 . . . 40436 4174 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4175 1 In in IN 40436 4175 2 reference reference NN 40436 4175 3 to to IN 40436 4175 4 this this DT 40436 4175 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4175 6 , , , 40436 4175 7 the the DT 40436 4175 8 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4175 9 contrast contrast NN 40436 4175 10 is be VBZ 40436 4175 11 very very RB 40436 4175 12 forcible forcible JJ 40436 4175 13 , , , 40436 4175 14 between between IN 40436 4175 15 the the DT 40436 4175 16 cross cross NN 40436 4175 17 - - NN 40436 4175 18 examination examination NN 40436 4175 19 carried carry VBN 40436 4175 20 on on RP 40436 4175 21 by by IN 40436 4175 22 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4175 23 , , , 40436 4175 24 and and CC 40436 4175 25 that that IN 40436 4175 26 carried carry VBD 40436 4175 27 on on RP 40436 4175 28 by by IN 40436 4175 29 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4175 30 . . . 40436 4176 1 The the DT 40436 4176 2 former former JJ 40436 4176 3 is be VBZ 40436 4176 4 pettish pettish JJ 40436 4176 5 and and CC 40436 4176 6 impatient impatient JJ 40436 4176 7 , , , 40436 4176 8 bringing bring VBG 40436 4176 9 out out RP 40436 4176 10 no no DT 40436 4176 11 result result NN 40436 4176 12 , , , 40436 4176 13 and and CC 40436 4176 14 accusing accuse VBG 40436 4176 15 the the DT 40436 4176 16 respondent respondent NN 40436 4176 17 of of IN 40436 4176 18 cavil cavil NN 40436 4176 19 and and CC 40436 4176 20 disingenuousness disingenuousness NN 40436 4176 21 : : : 40436 4176 22 the the DT 40436 4176 23 latter latter NN 40436 4176 24 takes take VBZ 40436 4176 25 up up RP 40436 4176 26 the the DT 40436 4176 27 same same JJ 40436 4176 28 answer answer NN 40436 4176 29 patiently patiently RB 40436 4176 30 , , , 40436 4176 31 expands expand VBZ 40436 4176 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4176 33 into into IN 40436 4176 34 the the DT 40436 4176 35 full full JJ 40436 4176 36 generality generality NN 40436 4176 37 wrapped wrap VBN 40436 4176 38 up up RP 40436 4176 39 in in IN 40436 4176 40 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4176 41 , , , 40436 4176 42 and and CC 40436 4176 43 renders render VBZ 40436 4176 44 palpable palpable VBP 40436 4176 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4176 46 inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 4176 47 with with IN 40436 4176 48 previous previous JJ 40436 4176 49 admissions admission NNS 40436 4176 50 . . . 40436 4177 1 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 40436 4177 2 . . . 40436 4178 1 Ast Ast NNP 40436 4178 2 is be VBZ 40436 4178 3 the the DT 40436 4178 4 only only JJ 40436 4178 5 critic critic NN 40436 4178 6 who who WP 40436 4178 7 declares declare VBZ 40436 4178 8 the the DT 40436 4178 9 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4178 10 not not RB 40436 4178 11 to to TO 40436 4178 12 be be VB 40436 4178 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4178 14 's 's POS 40436 4178 15 work work NN 40436 4178 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4178 17 Platon Platon NNP 40436 4178 18 's 's POS 40436 4178 19 Leben Leben NNP 40436 4178 20 und und NN 40436 4178 21 Schr Schr NNP 40436 4178 22 . . . 40436 4179 1 pp pp NNP 40436 4179 2 . . . 40436 4180 1 451 451 CD 40436 4180 2 - - SYM 40436 4180 3 456 456 CD 40436 4180 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4180 5 . . . 40436 4181 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4181 2 indeed indeed RB 40436 4181 3 even even RB 40436 4181 4 finds find VBZ 40436 4181 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4181 6 difficult difficult JJ 40436 4181 7 to to TO 40436 4181 8 imagine imagine VB 40436 4181 9 how how WRB 40436 4181 10 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 4181 11 can can MD 40436 4181 12 accept accept VB 40436 4181 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4181 14 as as IN 40436 4181 15 genuine genuine JJ 40436 4181 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4181 17 p. p. NN 40436 4181 18 454 454 CD 40436 4181 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4181 20 . . . 40436 4182 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4182 2 justifies justify VBZ 40436 4182 3 this this DT 40436 4182 4 opinion opinion NN 40436 4182 5 by by IN 40436 4182 6 numerous numerous JJ 40436 4182 7 reasons reason NNS 40436 4182 8 -- -- : 40436 4182 9 pointing point VBG 40436 4182 10 out out RP 40436 4182 11 what what WP 40436 4182 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4182 13 thinks think VBZ 40436 4182 14 glaring glare VBG 40436 4182 15 defects defect NNS 40436 4182 16 , , , 40436 4182 17 absurdity absurdity NN 40436 4182 18 , , , 40436 4182 19 and and CC 40436 4182 20 bad bad JJ 40436 4182 21 taste taste NN 40436 4182 22 , , , 40436 4182 23 both both CC 40436 4182 24 in in IN 40436 4182 25 the the DT 40436 4182 26 ratiocination ratiocination NN 40436 4182 27 and and CC 40436 4182 28 in in IN 40436 4182 29 the the DT 40436 4182 30 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4182 31 handling handling NN 40436 4182 32 , , , 40436 4182 33 also also RB 40436 4182 34 _ _ NNP 40436 4182 35 dicta dicta NN 40436 4182 36 _ _ NNP 40436 4182 37 alleged allege VBD 40436 4182 38 to to TO 40436 4182 39 be be VB 40436 4182 40 _ _ NNP 40436 4182 41 un un NNP 40436 4182 42 - - HYPH 40436 4182 43 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 4182 44 _ _ NNP 40436 4182 45 . . . 40436 4183 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 4183 2 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 4183 3 's 's POS 40436 4183 4 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 4183 5 zum zum NN 40436 4183 6 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4183 7 , , , 40436 4183 8 p. p. NN 40436 4183 9 324 324 CD 40436 4183 10 seq seq NN 40436 4183 11 . . . 40436 4184 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4184 2 do do VBP 40436 4184 3 not not RB 40436 4184 4 concur concur VB 40436 4184 5 with with IN 40436 4184 6 Ast Ast NNP 40436 4184 7 in in IN 40436 4184 8 the the DT 40436 4184 9 estimation estimation NN 40436 4184 10 of of IN 40436 4184 11 those those DT 40436 4184 12 passages passage NNS 40436 4184 13 which which WDT 40436 4184 14 serve serve VBP 40436 4184 15 as as IN 40436 4184 16 premisses premiss NNS 40436 4184 17 to to IN 40436 4184 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4184 19 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 4184 20 . . . 40436 4185 1 But but CC 40436 4185 2 even even RB 40436 4185 3 if if IN 40436 4185 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4185 5 admitted admit VBD 40436 4185 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4185 7 premisses premiss NNS 40436 4185 8 , , , 40436 4185 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4185 10 still still RB 40436 4185 11 should should MD 40436 4185 12 not not RB 40436 4185 13 admit admit VB 40436 4185 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4185 15 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 4185 16 . . . 40436 4186 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4186 2 should should MD 40436 4186 3 conclude conclude VB 40436 4186 4 that that IN 40436 4186 5 the the DT 40436 4186 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4186 7 was be VBD 40436 4186 8 an an DT 40436 4186 9 inferior inferior JJ 40436 4186 10 work work NN 40436 4186 11 of of IN 40436 4186 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4186 13 , , , 40436 4186 14 but but CC 40436 4186 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4186 16 should should MD 40436 4186 17 conclude conclude VB 40436 4186 18 nothing nothing NN 40436 4186 19 beyond beyond IN 40436 4186 20 . . . 40436 4187 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 4187 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4187 3 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 4187 4 . . . 40436 4188 1 ad ad NN 40436 4188 2 Lachet Lachet NNP 40436 4188 3 . . . 40436 4189 1 p. p. NN 40436 4189 2 29 29 CD 40436 4189 3 - - SYM 40436 4189 4 30 30 CD 40436 4189 5 , , , 40436 4189 6 2nd 2nd NNP 40436 4189 7 ed ed NNP 40436 4189 8 . . . 40436 4189 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4190 1 and and CC 40436 4190 2 Socher Socher NNP 40436 4190 3 discover discover VB 40436 4190 4 " " `` 40436 4190 5 adolescentiæ adolescentiæ NN 40436 4190 6 vestigia vestigia NN 40436 4190 7 " " '' 40436 4190 8 in in IN 40436 4190 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4190 10 , , , 40436 4190 11 which which WDT 40436 4190 12 are be VBP 40436 4190 13 not not RB 40436 4190 14 apparent apparent JJ 40436 4190 15 to to IN 40436 4190 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4190 17 . . . 40436 4191 1 Socher Socher NNP 40436 4191 2 , , , 40436 4191 3 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 4191 4 , , , 40436 4191 5 and and CC 40436 4191 6 K. K. NNP 40436 4191 7 F. F. NNP 40436 4191 8 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 4191 9 pass pass VB 40436 4191 10 lightly lightly RB 40436 4191 11 over over IN 40436 4191 12 the the DT 40436 4191 13 objections objection NNS 40436 4191 14 of of IN 40436 4191 15 Ast Ast NNP 40436 4191 16 ; ; : 40436 4191 17 and and CC 40436 4191 18 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4191 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4191 20 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 4191 21 . . . 40436 4192 1 p. p. NN 40436 4192 2 355 355 CD 40436 4192 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4192 4 declares declare VBZ 40436 4192 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4192 6 to to TO 40436 4192 7 be be VB 40436 4192 8 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 4192 9 of of IN 40436 4192 10 a a DT 40436 4192 11 serious serious JJ 40436 4192 12 answer answer NN 40436 4192 13 . . . 40436 4193 1 For for IN 40436 4193 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4193 3 part part NN 40436 4193 4 , , , 40436 4193 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4193 6 draw draw VBP 40436 4193 7 from from IN 40436 4193 8 these these DT 40436 4193 9 dissensions dissension NNS 40436 4193 10 among among IN 40436 4193 11 the the DT 40436 4193 12 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 4193 13 critics critic NNS 40436 4193 14 a a DT 40436 4193 15 conviction conviction NN 40436 4193 16 of of IN 40436 4193 17 the the DT 40436 4193 18 uncertain uncertain JJ 40436 4193 19 evidence evidence NN 40436 4193 20 upon upon IN 40436 4193 21 which which WDT 40436 4193 22 all all DT 40436 4193 23 of of IN 40436 4193 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4193 25 proceed proceed VBP 40436 4193 26 . . . 40436 4194 1 Each each DT 40436 4194 2 has have VBZ 40436 4194 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4194 4 own own JJ 40436 4194 5 belief belief NN 40436 4194 6 as as IN 40436 4194 7 to to IN 40436 4194 8 what what WP 40436 4194 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4194 10 _ _ NNP 40436 4194 11 must must MD 40436 4194 12 _ _ NNP 40436 4194 13 say say VB 40436 4194 14 , , , 40436 4194 15 _ _ NNP 40436 4194 16 ought ought MD 40436 4194 17 to to IN 40436 4194 18 _ _ NNP 40436 4194 19 say say VB 40436 4194 20 , , , 40436 4194 21 and and CC 40436 4194 22 _ _ NNP 40436 4194 23 could could MD 40436 4194 24 not not RB 40436 4194 25 _ _ NNP 40436 4194 26 have have VBP 40436 4194 27 said say VBD 40436 4194 28 ; ; : 40436 4194 29 and and CC 40436 4194 30 each each DT 40436 4194 31 adjudicates adjudicate NNS 40436 4194 32 thereupon thereupon RB 40436 4194 33 with with IN 40436 4194 34 a a DT 40436 4194 35 degree degree NN 40436 4194 36 of of IN 40436 4194 37 confidence confidence NN 40436 4194 38 which which WDT 40436 4194 39 surprises surprise VBZ 40436 4194 40 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4194 41 . . . 40436 4195 1 The the DT 40436 4195 2 grounds ground NNS 40436 4195 3 upon upon IN 40436 4195 4 which which WDT 40436 4195 5 Ast Ast NNP 40436 4195 6 rejects reject VBZ 40436 4195 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4195 8 , , , 40436 4195 9 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4195 10 , , , 40436 4195 11 and and CC 40436 4195 12 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4195 13 , , , 40436 4195 14 though though IN 40436 4195 15 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 40436 4195 16 , , , 40436 4195 17 appear appear VB 40436 4195 18 to to IN 40436 4195 19 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4195 20 not not RB 40436 4195 21 more more RBR 40436 4195 22 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 40436 4195 23 than than IN 40436 4195 24 those those DT 40436 4195 25 on on IN 40436 4195 26 which which WDT 40436 4195 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4195 28 and and CC 40436 4195 29 other other JJ 40436 4195 30 critics critic NNS 40436 4195 31 reject reject VBP 40436 4195 32 the the DT 40436 4195 33 Erastæ erastæ JJ 40436 4195 34 , , , 40436 4195 35 Theagês Theagês NNP 40436 4195 36 . . . 40436 4196 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 4196 2 Major Major NNP 40436 4196 3 , , , 40436 4196 4 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 4196 5 II II NNP 40436 4196 6 . . NNP 40436 4196 7 , , , 40436 4196 8 & & CC 40436 4196 9 c. c. NNP 40436 4196 10 The the DT 40436 4196 11 dates date NNS 40436 4196 12 which which WDT 40436 4196 13 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 4196 14 , , , 40436 4196 15 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 4196 16 , , , 40436 4196 17 Socher Socher NNP 40436 4196 18 , , , 40436 4196 19 and and CC 40436 4196 20 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4196 21 assign assign NN 40436 4196 22 to to IN 40436 4196 23 the the DT 40436 4196 24 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4196 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4196 26 about about RB 40436 4196 27 406 406 CD 40436 4196 28 - - SYM 40436 4196 29 404 404 CD 40436 4196 30 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 4196 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4197 1 are be VBP 40436 4197 2 in in IN 40436 4197 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4197 4 judgment judgment NN 40436 4197 5 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 4197 6 . . . 40436 4198 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4198 2 have have VBP 40436 4198 3 already already RB 40436 4198 4 shown show VBN 40436 4198 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4198 6 reasons reason NNS 40436 4198 7 for for IN 40436 4198 8 believing believe VBG 40436 4198 9 that that IN 40436 4198 10 not not RB 40436 4198 11 one one CD 40436 4198 12 of of IN 40436 4198 13 the the DT 40436 4198 14 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 4198 15 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4198 16 was be VBD 40436 4198 17 composed compose VBN 40436 4198 18 until until IN 40436 4198 19 after after IN 40436 4198 20 the the DT 40436 4198 21 death death NN 40436 4198 22 of of IN 40436 4198 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4198 24 . . . 40436 4199 1 The the DT 40436 4199 2 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 40436 4199 3 also also RB 40436 4199 4 of of IN 40436 4199 5 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4199 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4199 7 p. p. NN 40436 4199 8 357 357 CD 40436 4199 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4199 10 as as IN 40436 4199 11 to to IN 40436 4199 12 the the DT 40436 4199 13 special special JJ 40436 4199 14 purposes purpose NNS 40436 4199 15 of of IN 40436 4199 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4199 17 in in IN 40436 4199 18 composing compose VBG 40436 4199 19 the the DT 40436 4199 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4199 21 are be VBP 40436 4199 22 unsupported unsupported JJ 40436 4199 23 by by IN 40436 4199 24 any any DT 40436 4199 25 evidence evidence NN 40436 4199 26 ; ; : 40436 4199 27 and and CC 40436 4199 28 are be VBP 40436 4199 29 all all DT 40436 4199 30 imagined imagine VBN 40436 4199 31 so so IN 40436 4199 32 as as IN 40436 4199 33 to to TO 40436 4199 34 fit fit VB 40436 4199 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4199 36 supposition supposition NN 40436 4199 37 as as IN 40436 4199 38 to to IN 40436 4199 39 the the DT 40436 4199 40 date date NN 40436 4199 41 . . . 40436 4200 1 So so RB 40436 4200 2 also also RB 40436 4200 3 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 4200 4 tells tell VBZ 40436 4200 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4200 6 that that IN 40436 4200 7 a a DT 40436 4200 8 portion portion NN 40436 4200 9 of of IN 40436 4200 10 the the DT 40436 4200 11 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4200 12 is be VBZ 40436 4200 13 intended intend VBN 40436 4200 14 by by IN 40436 4200 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4200 16 as as IN 40436 4200 17 a a DT 40436 4200 18 defence defence NN 40436 4200 19 of of IN 40436 4200 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4200 21 against against IN 40436 4200 22 accusations accusation NNS 40436 4200 23 which which WDT 40436 4200 24 had have VBD 40436 4200 25 been be VBN 40436 4200 26 brought bring VBN 40436 4200 27 against against IN 40436 4200 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4200 29 , , , 40436 4200 30 a a DT 40436 4200 31 young young JJ 40436 4200 32 man man NN 40436 4200 33 , , , 40436 4200 34 for for IN 40436 4200 35 impertinence impertinence NN 40436 4200 36 in in IN 40436 4200 37 having have VBG 40436 4200 38 attacked attack VBN 40436 4200 39 Lysias Lysias NNP 40436 4200 40 in in IN 40436 4200 41 the the DT 40436 4200 42 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 4200 43 , , , 40436 4200 44 and and CC 40436 4200 45 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 4200 46 in in IN 40436 4200 47 the the DT 40436 4200 48 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 4200 49 , , , 40436 4200 50 both both DT 40436 4200 51 of of IN 40436 4200 52 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4200 53 much much RB 40436 4200 54 older old JJR 40436 4200 55 than than IN 40436 4200 56 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4200 57 . . . 40436 4201 1 But but CC 40436 4201 2 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4201 3 justly justly RB 40436 4201 4 remarks remark VBZ 40436 4201 5 that that IN 40436 4201 6 this this DT 40436 4201 7 explanation explanation NN 40436 4201 8 can can MD 40436 4201 9 only only RB 40436 4201 10 be be VB 40436 4201 11 valid valid JJ 40436 4201 12 if if IN 40436 4201 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4201 14 admit admit VBP 40436 4201 15 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 4201 16 's 's POS 40436 4201 17 theory theory NN 40436 4201 18 that that IN 40436 4201 19 the the DT 40436 4201 20 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 4201 21 and and CC 40436 4201 22 the the DT 40436 4201 23 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 4201 24 are be VBP 40436 4201 25 earlier early JJR 40436 4201 26 compositions composition NNS 40436 4201 27 than than IN 40436 4201 28 the the DT 40436 4201 29 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4201 30 , , , 40436 4201 31 which which WDT 40436 4201 32 theory theory NN 40436 4201 33 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4201 34 and and CC 40436 4201 35 most most JJS 40436 4201 36 of of IN 40436 4201 37 the the DT 40436 4201 38 others other NNS 40436 4201 39 deny deny VBP 40436 4201 40 . . . 40436 4202 1 Steinhart steinhart VB 40436 4202 2 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4202 3 adapts adapt VBZ 40436 4202 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4202 5 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 40436 4202 6 to to IN 40436 4202 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4202 8 own own JJ 40436 4202 9 idea idea NN 40436 4202 10 of of IN 40436 4202 11 the the DT 40436 4202 12 date date NN 40436 4202 13 of of IN 40436 4202 14 the the DT 40436 4202 15 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4202 16 : : : 40436 4202 17 and and CC 40436 4202 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4202 19 is be VBZ 40436 4202 20 open open JJ 40436 4202 21 to to IN 40436 4202 22 the the DT 40436 4202 23 same same JJ 40436 4202 24 remark remark NN 40436 4202 25 as as IN 40436 4202 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4202 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4202 28 makes make VBZ 40436 4202 29 upon upon IN 40436 4202 30 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 4202 31 . . . 40436 4203 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 4203 2 XIX XIX NNP 40436 4203 3 . . . 40436 4204 1 CHARMIDES charmide NNS 40436 4204 2 . . . 40436 4205 1 As as IN 40436 4205 2 in in IN 40436 4205 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4205 4 , , , 40436 4205 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4205 6 have have VBP 40436 4205 7 pursued pursue VBN 40436 4205 8 an an DT 40436 4205 9 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 4205 10 into into IN 40436 4205 11 the the DT 40436 4205 12 nature nature NN 40436 4205 13 of of IN 40436 4205 14 Courage Courage NNP 40436 4205 15 -- -- : 40436 4205 16 so so RB 40436 4205 17 in in IN 40436 4205 18 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4205 19 , , , 40436 4205 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4205 21 find find VBP 40436 4205 22 an an DT 40436 4205 23 examination examination NN 40436 4205 24 of of IN 40436 4205 25 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4205 26 , , , 40436 4205 27 Sobriety Sobriety NNP 40436 4205 28 , , , 40436 4205 29 Moderation Moderation NNP 40436 4205 30 . . . 40436 4206 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4206 2 1 1 LS 40436 4206 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4206 4 Both both DT 40436 4206 5 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4206 6 conclude conclude VBP 40436 4206 7 without without IN 40436 4206 8 providing provide VBG 40436 4206 9 any any DT 40436 4206 10 tenable tenable JJ 40436 4206 11 explanation explanation NN 40436 4206 12 . . . 40436 4207 1 In in IN 40436 4207 2 both both DT 40436 4207 3 there there EX 40436 4207 4 is be VBZ 40436 4207 5 an an DT 40436 4207 6 abundant abundant JJ 40436 4207 7 introduction introduction NN 40436 4207 8 -- -- : 40436 4207 9 in in IN 40436 4207 10 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4207 11 , , , 40436 4207 12 there there EX 40436 4207 13 is be VBZ 40436 4207 14 even even RB 40436 4207 15 the the DT 40436 4207 16 bustle bustle NN 40436 4207 17 of of IN 40436 4207 18 a a DT 40436 4207 19 crowded crowded JJ 40436 4207 20 palæstra palæstra NN 40436 4207 21 , , , 40436 4207 22 with with IN 40436 4207 23 much much JJ 40436 4207 24 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4207 25 incident incident NN 40436 4207 26 -- -- : 40436 4207 27 preluding prelude VBG 40436 4207 28 to to IN 40436 4207 29 the the DT 40436 4207 30 substantive substantive JJ 40436 4207 31 discussion discussion NN 40436 4207 32 . . . 40436 4208 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4208 2 omit omit VBP 40436 4208 3 the the DT 40436 4208 4 notice notice NN 40436 4208 5 of of IN 40436 4208 6 this this DT 40436 4208 7 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4208 8 incident incident NN 40436 4208 9 , , , 40436 4208 10 though though IN 40436 4208 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4208 12 is be VBZ 40436 4208 13 highly highly RB 40436 4208 14 interesting interesting JJ 40436 4208 15 to to TO 40436 4208 16 read read VB 40436 4208 17 . . . 40436 4209 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4209 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4209 3 1 1 CD 40436 4209 4 : : : 40436 4209 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4209 6 translate translate VBP 40436 4209 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4209 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4209 9 : : : 40436 4209 10 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4209 11 / / SYM 40436 4209 12 nê nê NNP 40436 4209 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4209 14 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4209 15 , , , 40436 4209 16 though though IN 40436 4209 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4209 18 is be VBZ 40436 4209 19 very very RB 40436 4209 20 inadequate inadequate JJ 40436 4209 21 , , , 40436 4209 22 but but CC 40436 4209 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4209 24 know know VBP 40436 4209 25 no no DT 40436 4209 26 single single JJ 40436 4209 27 English english JJ 40436 4209 28 word word NN 40436 4209 29 better better RB 40436 4209 30 suited suit VBN 40436 4209 31 . . . 40436 4209 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4210 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4210 2 Side side NN 40436 4210 3 - - HYPH 40436 4210 4 note note NN 40436 4210 5 : : : 40436 4210 6 Scene scene NN 40436 4210 7 and and CC 40436 4210 8 personages personage NNS 40436 4210 9 of of IN 40436 4210 10 the the DT 40436 4210 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4210 12 . . . 40436 4211 1 Crowded crowd VBN 40436 4211 2 palæstra palæstra NNP 40436 4211 3 . . . 40436 4212 1 Emotions emotion NNS 40436 4212 2 of of IN 40436 4212 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4212 4 . . . 40436 4212 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4213 1 The the DT 40436 4213 2 two two CD 40436 4213 3 persons person NNS 40436 4213 4 with with IN 40436 4213 5 whom whom WP 40436 4213 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4213 7 here here RB 40436 4213 8 carries carry VBZ 40436 4213 9 on on IN 40436 4213 10 the the DT 40436 4213 11 discussion discussion NN 40436 4213 12 , , , 40436 4213 13 are be VBP 40436 4213 14 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 4213 15 and and CC 40436 4213 16 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4213 17 ; ; : 40436 4213 18 both both DT 40436 4213 19 of of IN 40436 4213 20 whom whom WP 40436 4213 21 , , , 40436 4213 22 as as IN 40436 4213 23 historical historical JJ 40436 4213 24 persons person NNS 40436 4213 25 , , , 40436 4213 26 were be VBD 40436 4213 27 active active JJ 40436 4213 28 movers mover NNS 40436 4213 29 in in IN 40436 4213 30 the the DT 40436 4213 31 oligarchical oligarchical JJ 40436 4213 32 government government NN 40436 4213 33 of of IN 40436 4213 34 the the DT 40436 4213 35 Thirty Thirty NNP 40436 4213 36 , , , 40436 4213 37 with with IN 40436 4213 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4213 39 numerous numerous JJ 40436 4213 40 enormities enormity NNS 40436 4213 41 . . . 40436 4214 1 In in IN 40436 4214 2 this this DT 40436 4214 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4214 4 , , , 40436 4214 5 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 4214 6 appears appear VBZ 40436 4214 7 as as IN 40436 4214 8 a a DT 40436 4214 9 youth youth NN 40436 4214 10 just just RB 40436 4214 11 rising rise VBG 40436 4214 12 into into IN 40436 4214 13 manhood manhood NN 40436 4214 14 , , , 40436 4214 15 strikingly strikingly RB 40436 4214 16 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4214 17 both both CC 40436 4214 18 in in IN 40436 4214 19 face face NN 40436 4214 20 and and CC 40436 4214 21 stature stature NN 40436 4214 22 : : : 40436 4214 23 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4214 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4214 25 cousin cousin NN 40436 4214 26 is be VBZ 40436 4214 27 an an DT 40436 4214 28 accomplished accomplished JJ 40436 4214 29 literary literary JJ 40436 4214 30 man man NN 40436 4214 31 of of IN 40436 4214 32 mature mature JJ 40436 4214 33 age age NN 40436 4214 34 . . . 40436 4215 1 The the DT 40436 4215 2 powerful powerful JJ 40436 4215 3 emotion emotion NN 40436 4215 4 which which WDT 40436 4215 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4215 6 describes describe VBZ 40436 4215 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4215 8 as as IN 40436 4215 9 experiencing,[2 experiencing,[2 NNP 40436 4215 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4215 11 from from IN 40436 4215 12 the the DT 40436 4215 13 sight sight NN 40436 4215 14 and and CC 40436 4215 15 close close JJ 40436 4215 16 neighbourhood neighbourhood NN 40436 4215 17 of of IN 40436 4215 18 the the DT 40436 4215 19 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4215 20 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 4215 21 , , , 40436 4215 22 is be VBZ 40436 4215 23 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 4215 24 , , , 40436 4215 25 as as IN 40436 4215 26 a a DT 40436 4215 27 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 4215 28 of of IN 40436 4215 29 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 40436 4215 30 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 4215 31 . . . 40436 4216 1 The the DT 40436 4216 2 same same JJ 40436 4216 3 exaltation exaltation NN 40436 4216 4 of of IN 40436 4216 5 the the DT 40436 4216 6 feelings feeling NNS 40436 4216 7 and and CC 40436 4216 8 imagination imagination NN 40436 4216 9 , , , 40436 4216 10 which which WDT 40436 4216 11 is be VBZ 40436 4216 12 now now RB 40436 4216 13 produced produce VBN 40436 4216 14 only only RB 40436 4216 15 by by IN 40436 4216 16 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4216 17 women woman NNS 40436 4216 18 , , , 40436 4216 19 was be VBD 40436 4216 20 then then RB 40436 4216 21 excited excite VBN 40436 4216 22 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 4216 23 by by IN 40436 4216 24 fine fine JJ 40436 4216 25 youths youth NNS 40436 4216 26 . . . 40436 4217 1 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4217 2 is be VBZ 40436 4217 3 described describe VBN 40436 4217 4 by by IN 40436 4217 5 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4217 6 as as IN 40436 4217 7 exhibiting exhibit VBG 40436 4217 8 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 4217 9 at at IN 40436 4217 10 once once RB 40436 4217 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 4217 12 and and CC 40436 4217 13 poetical:[3 poetical:[3 JJ 40436 4217 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4217 15 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 4217 16 the the DT 40436 4217 17 affinity affinity NN 40436 4217 18 of of IN 40436 4217 19 these these DT 40436 4217 20 two two CD 40436 4217 21 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 4217 22 veins vein NNS 40436 4217 23 , , , 40436 4217 24 as as IN 40436 4217 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4217 26 conceived conceive VBD 40436 4217 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4217 28 . . . 40436 4218 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4218 2 is be VBZ 40436 4218 3 also also RB 40436 4218 4 described describe VBN 40436 4218 5 as as IN 40436 4218 6 eminently eminently RB 40436 4218 7 temperate temperate NN 40436 4218 8 and and CC 40436 4218 9 modest:[4 modest:[4 LS 40436 4218 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4218 11 from from IN 40436 4218 12 whence whence NN 40436 4218 13 the the DT 40436 4218 14 questions question NNS 40436 4218 15 of of IN 40436 4218 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4218 17 take take VBP 40436 4218 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4218 19 departure departure NN 40436 4218 20 . . . 40436 4219 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4219 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4219 3 2 2 CD 40436 4219 4 : : : 40436 4219 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4219 6 , , , 40436 4219 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4219 8 . . . 40436 4220 1 154 154 CD 40436 4220 2 C. C. NNP 40436 4220 3 Ficinus Ficinus NNP 40436 4220 4 , , , 40436 4220 5 in in IN 40436 4220 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4220 7 Argumentum argumentum NN 40436 4220 8 to to IN 40436 4220 9 this this DT 40436 4220 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4220 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4220 12 p. p. NN 40436 4220 13 767 767 CD 40436 4220 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4220 15 , , , 40436 4220 16 considers consider VBZ 40436 4220 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4220 18 as as RB 40436 4220 19 mainly mainly RB 40436 4220 20 allegorical allegorical JJ 40436 4220 21 , , , 40436 4220 22 especially especially RB 40436 4220 23 the the DT 40436 4220 24 warm warm JJ 40436 4220 25 expressions expression NNS 40436 4220 26 of of IN 40436 4220 27 erotic erotic JJ 40436 4220 28 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 4220 29 contained contain VBD 40436 4220 30 therein therein RB 40436 4220 31 , , , 40436 4220 32 which which WDT 40436 4220 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4220 34 compares compare VBZ 40436 4220 35 to to IN 40436 4220 36 the the DT 40436 4220 37 Song Song NNP 40436 4220 38 of of IN 40436 4220 39 Solomon Solomon NNP 40436 4220 40 . . . 40436 4221 1 " " `` 40436 4221 2 Etsi etsi JJ 40436 4221 3 omnia omnia NN 40436 4221 4 in in IN 40436 4221 5 hoc hoc FW 40436 4221 6 dialogo dialogo VBD 40436 4221 7 mirificam mirificam NNP 40436 4221 8 habeant habeant NNP 40436 4221 9 allegoriam allegoriam NNP 40436 4221 10 , , , 40436 4221 11 amatoria amatoria NNP 40436 4221 12 maxime maxime NNP 40436 4221 13 , , , 40436 4221 14 non non AFX 40436 4221 15 aliter aliter NN 40436 4221 16 quam quam NNP 40436 4221 17 Cantica Cantica NNP 40436 4221 18 Salomonis Salomonis NNP 40436 4221 19 -- -- : 40436 4221 20 mutavi mutavi NN 40436 4221 21 tamen tamen NNP 40436 4221 22 nonnihil nonnihil NNP 40436 4221 23 -- -- : 40436 4221 24 nonnihil nonnihil NNP 40436 4221 25 etiam etiam NNP 40436 4221 26 prætermisi prætermisi NNP 40436 4221 27 . . . 40436 4222 1 Quæ Quæ NNP 40436 4222 2 enim enim NNP 40436 4222 3 consonabant consonabant JJ 40436 4222 4 castigatissimis castigatissimis NN 40436 4222 5 auribus auribus NNP 40436 4222 6 Atticorum Atticorum NNP 40436 4222 7 , , , 40436 4222 8 rudioribus rudioribus NNP 40436 4222 9 fortè fortè NN 40436 4222 10 auribus auribus NN 40436 4222 11 minimé minimé NN 40436 4222 12 consonarent consonarent NN 40436 4222 13 . . . 40436 4222 14 " " '' 40436 4222 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4223 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4223 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4223 3 3 3 CD 40436 4223 4 : : : 40436 4223 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4223 6 , , , 40436 4223 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4223 8 . . . 40436 4224 1 155 155 CD 40436 4224 2 A. a. NN 40436 4224 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4225 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4225 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4225 3 4 4 CD 40436 4225 4 : : : 40436 4225 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4225 6 , , , 40436 4225 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4225 8 . . . 40436 4226 1 157 157 CD 40436 4226 2 D. D. NNP 40436 4226 3 About about IN 40436 4226 4 the the DT 40436 4226 5 diffidence diffidence NN 40436 4226 6 of of IN 40436 4226 7 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4226 8 in in IN 40436 4226 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4226 10 younger young JJR 40436 4226 11 years year NNS 40436 4226 12 , , , 40436 4226 13 see see VB 40436 4226 14 Xen Xen NNP 40436 4226 15 . . . 40436 4227 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 4227 2 . . . 40436 4228 1 iii iii NNP 40436 4228 2 . . . 40436 4229 1 7 7 CD 40436 4229 2 , , , 40436 4229 3 1 1 CD 40436 4229 4 . . . 40436 4229 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4230 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4230 2 Side side NN 40436 4230 3 - - HYPH 40436 4230 4 note note NN 40436 4230 5 : : : 40436 4230 6 Question question NN 40436 4230 7 , , , 40436 4230 8 What what WP 40436 4230 9 is be VBZ 40436 4230 10 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4230 11 ? ? . 40436 4231 1 addressed address VBN 40436 4231 2 by by IN 40436 4231 3 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4231 4 to to IN 40436 4231 5 the the DT 40436 4231 6 temperate temperate NN 40436 4231 7 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4231 8 . . . 40436 4232 1 Answer answer VB 40436 4232 2 , , , 40436 4232 3 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4232 4 is be VBZ 40436 4232 5 a a DT 40436 4232 6 kind kind NN 40436 4232 7 of of IN 40436 4232 8 sedateness sedateness NN 40436 4232 9 or or CC 40436 4232 10 slowness slowness NN 40436 4232 11 . . . 40436 4232 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4233 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4233 2 are be VBP 40436 4233 3 said say VBN 40436 4233 4 to to TO 40436 4233 5 be be VB 40436 4233 6 temperate temperate NN 40436 4233 7 , , , 40436 4233 8 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4233 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4233 10 says say VBZ 40436 4233 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4233 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4233 13 . . . 40436 4234 1 If if IN 40436 4234 2 so so RB 40436 4234 3 , , , 40436 4234 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4234 5 temperance temperance NN 40436 4234 6 will will MD 40436 4234 7 surely surely RB 40436 4234 8 manifest manifest VB 40436 4234 9 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4234 10 within within IN 40436 4234 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4234 12 in in IN 40436 4234 13 some some DT 40436 4234 14 way way NN 40436 4234 15 , , , 40436 4234 16 so so IN 40436 4234 17 as as IN 40436 4234 18 to to TO 40436 4234 19 enable enable VB 40436 4234 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4234 21 to to TO 40436 4234 22 form form VB 40436 4234 23 and and CC 40436 4234 24 deliver deliver VB 40436 4234 25 an an DT 40436 4234 26 opinion opinion NN 40436 4234 27 , , , 40436 4234 28 What what WP 40436 4234 29 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4234 30 is be VBZ 40436 4234 31 . . . 40436 4235 1 Tell tell VB 40436 4235 2 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4235 3 in in IN 40436 4235 4 plain plain JJ 40436 4235 5 language language NN 40436 4235 6 what what WP 40436 4235 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4235 8 conceive conceive VBP 40436 4235 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4235 10 to to TO 40436 4235 11 be be VB 40436 4235 12 . . . 40436 4236 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4236 2 , , , 40436 4236 3 replies reply VBZ 40436 4236 4 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 4236 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4236 6 after after IN 40436 4236 7 some some DT 40436 4236 8 hesitation),[5 hesitation),[5 JJ 40436 4236 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4236 10 consists consist VBZ 40436 4236 11 in in IN 40436 4236 12 doing do VBG 40436 4236 13 every every DT 40436 4236 14 thing thing NN 40436 4236 15 in in IN 40436 4236 16 an an DT 40436 4236 17 orderly orderly JJ 40436 4236 18 and and CC 40436 4236 19 sedate sedate JJ 40436 4236 20 manner manner NN 40436 4236 21 , , , 40436 4236 22 when when WRB 40436 4236 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4236 24 walk walk VBP 40436 4236 25 in in IN 40436 4236 26 the the DT 40436 4236 27 highway highway NN 40436 4236 28 , , , 40436 4236 29 or or CC 40436 4236 30 talk talk NN 40436 4236 31 , , , 40436 4236 32 or or CC 40436 4236 33 perform perform VB 40436 4236 34 other other JJ 40436 4236 35 matters matter NNS 40436 4236 36 in in IN 40436 4236 37 the the DT 40436 4236 38 presence presence NN 40436 4236 39 of of IN 40436 4236 40 others other NNS 40436 4236 41 . . . 40436 4237 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4237 2 is be VBZ 40436 4237 3 , , , 40436 4237 4 in in IN 40436 4237 5 short short JJ 40436 4237 6 , , , 40436 4237 7 a a DT 40436 4237 8 kind kind NN 40436 4237 9 of of IN 40436 4237 10 sedateness sedateness NN 40436 4237 11 or or CC 40436 4237 12 slowness slowness NN 40436 4237 13 . . . 40436 4238 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4238 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4238 3 5 5 CD 40436 4238 4 : : : 40436 4238 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4238 6 , , , 40436 4238 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4238 8 . . . 40436 4239 1 159 159 CD 40436 4239 2 B. b. NN 40436 4240 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4240 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4240 3 : : : 40436 4240 4 to\ to\ NN 40436 4240 5 kosmi kosmi NNP 40436 4240 6 / / SYM 40436 4240 7 ôs ôs NNP 40436 4240 8 pa pa NNP 40436 4240 9 / / SYM 40436 4240 10 nta nta NNP 40436 4240 11 pra pra NNP 40436 4240 12 / / SYM 40436 4240 13 ttein ttein NNP 40436 4240 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4240 15 ê(suchê=| ê(suchê=| NNP 40436 4240 16 , , , 40436 4240 17 e)/n e)/n NNP 40436 4240 18 te te NNP 40436 4240 19 tai tai NNP 40436 4240 20 = = SYM 40436 4240 21 s s NNP 40436 4240 22 o)doi o)doi NNP 40436 4240 23 = = SYM 40436 4240 24 s s NNP 40436 4240 25 badi badi NNP 40436 4240 26 / / SYM 40436 4240 27 zein zein NNP 40436 4240 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4240 29 diale diale NNP 40436 4240 30 / / SYM 40436 4240 31 gesthai gesthai NNP 40436 4240 32 . . . 40436 4241 1 . . . 40436 4242 1 . . . 40436 4243 1 sullê sullê NNP 40436 4243 2 / / SYM 40436 4243 3 bdên bdên NNP 40436 4243 4 ê(suchio ê(suchio NNP 40436 4243 5 / / SYM 40436 4243 6 tês tês NNP 40436 4243 7 tis tis NNP 40436 4243 8 . . . 40436 4243 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4243 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4244 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4244 2 Side side NN 40436 4244 3 - - HYPH 40436 4244 4 note note NN 40436 4244 5 : : : 40436 4244 6 But but CC 40436 4244 7 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4244 8 is be VBZ 40436 4244 9 a a DT 40436 4244 10 fine fine JJ 40436 4244 11 or or CC 40436 4244 12 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4244 13 thing thing NN 40436 4244 14 , , , 40436 4244 15 and and CC 40436 4244 16 slowness slowness NN 40436 4244 17 is be VBZ 40436 4244 18 , , , 40436 4244 19 in in IN 40436 4244 20 many many JJ 40436 4244 21 or or CC 40436 4244 22 most most JJS 40436 4244 23 cases case NNS 40436 4244 24 , , , 40436 4244 25 not not RB 40436 4244 26 fine fine JJ 40436 4244 27 or or CC 40436 4244 28 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4244 29 , , , 40436 4244 30 but but CC 40436 4244 31 the the DT 40436 4244 32 contrary contrary NN 40436 4244 33 . . . 40436 4245 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4245 2 can can MD 40436 4245 3 not not RB 40436 4245 4 be be VB 40436 4245 5 slowness slowness JJ 40436 4245 6 . . . 40436 4245 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4246 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4246 2 begins begin VBZ 40436 4246 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4246 4 cross cross NN 40436 4246 5 - - NN 40436 4246 6 examination examination NN 40436 4246 7 upon upon IN 40436 4246 8 this this DT 40436 4246 9 answer answer NN 40436 4246 10 , , , 40436 4246 11 in in IN 40436 4246 12 the the DT 40436 4246 13 same same JJ 40436 4246 14 manner manner NN 40436 4246 15 as as IN 40436 4246 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4246 17 had have VBD 40436 4246 18 begun begin VBN 40436 4246 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4246 20 with with IN 40436 4246 21 Laches Laches NNP 40436 4246 22 in in IN 40436 4246 23 respect respect NN 40436 4246 24 to to IN 40436 4246 25 courage courage NN 40436 4246 26 . . . 40436 4247 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4247 2 Sokr._--Is Sokr._--Is NNP 40436 4247 3 not not RB 40436 4247 4 temperance temperance VBP 40436 4247 5 a a DT 40436 4247 6 fine fine JJ 40436 4247 7 and and CC 40436 4247 8 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4247 9 thing thing NN 40436 4247 10 ? ? . 40436 4248 1 Does do VBZ 40436 4248 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4248 3 not not RB 40436 4248 4 partake partake VB 40436 4248 5 of of IN 40436 4248 6 the the DT 40436 4248 7 essence essence NN 40436 4248 8 and and CC 40436 4248 9 come come VB 40436 4248 10 under under IN 40436 4248 11 the the DT 40436 4248 12 definition definition NN 40436 4248 13 , , , 40436 4248 14 of of IN 40436 4248 15 what what WP 40436 4248 16 is be VBZ 40436 4248 17 fine fine JJ 40436 4248 18 or or CC 40436 4248 19 and and CC 40436 4248 20 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4248 21 ? ? . 40436 4249 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4249 2 6 6 CD 40436 4249 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4249 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4249 5 Char._--Undoubtedly Char._--Undoubtedly NNP 40436 4249 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4249 7 does do VBZ 40436 4249 8 . . . 40436 4250 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4250 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 4250 3 if if IN 40436 4250 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4250 5 specify specify VBP 40436 4250 6 in in IN 40436 4250 7 detail detail NN 40436 4250 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4250 9 various various JJ 40436 4250 10 operations operation NNS 40436 4250 11 , , , 40436 4250 12 either either CC 40436 4250 13 of of IN 40436 4250 14 body body NN 40436 4250 15 or or CC 40436 4250 16 mind mind NN 40436 4250 17 -- -- : 40436 4250 18 such such JJ 40436 4250 19 as as IN 40436 4250 20 writing writing NN 40436 4250 21 , , , 40436 4250 22 reading reading NN 40436 4250 23 , , , 40436 4250 24 playing play VBG 40436 4250 25 on on IN 40436 4250 26 the the DT 40436 4250 27 harp harp NN 40436 4250 28 , , , 40436 4250 29 boxing box VBG 40436 4250 30 , , , 40436 4250 31 running run VBG 40436 4250 32 , , , 40436 4250 33 jumping jump VBG 40436 4250 34 , , , 40436 4250 35 learning learning NN 40436 4250 36 , , , 40436 4250 37 teaching teaching NN 40436 4250 38 , , , 40436 4250 39 recollecting recollect VBG 40436 4250 40 , , , 40436 4250 41 comprehending comprehend VBG 40436 4250 42 , , , 40436 4250 43 deliberating deliberate VBG 40436 4250 44 , , , 40436 4250 45 determining determine VBG 40436 4250 46 , , , 40436 4250 47 & & CC 40436 4250 48 c.--we c.--we NNP 40436 4250 49 shall shall MD 40436 4250 50 find find VB 40436 4250 51 that that DT 40436 4250 52 to to TO 40436 4250 53 do do VB 40436 4250 54 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4250 55 quickly quickly RB 40436 4250 56 is be VBZ 40436 4250 57 more more RBR 40436 4250 58 fine fine JJ 40436 4250 59 and and CC 40436 4250 60 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4250 61 than than IN 40436 4250 62 to to TO 40436 4250 63 do do VB 40436 4250 64 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4250 65 slowly slowly RB 40436 4250 66 . . . 40436 4251 1 Slowness slowness NN 40436 4251 2 does do VBZ 40436 4251 3 not not RB 40436 4251 4 , , , 40436 4251 5 except except IN 40436 4251 6 by by IN 40436 4251 7 accident accident NN 40436 4251 8 , , , 40436 4251 9 belong belong VB 40436 4251 10 to to IN 40436 4251 11 the the DT 40436 4251 12 fine fine JJ 40436 4251 13 and and CC 40436 4251 14 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4251 15 : : : 40436 4251 16 therefore therefore RB 40436 4251 17 temperance temperance NN 40436 4251 18 , , , 40436 4251 19 which which WDT 40436 4251 20 does do VBZ 40436 4251 21 so so RB 40436 4251 22 belong belong VB 40436 4251 23 to to IN 40436 4251 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4251 25 , , , 40436 4251 26 can can MD 40436 4251 27 not not RB 40436 4251 28 be be VB 40436 4251 29 a a DT 40436 4251 30 kind kind NN 40436 4251 31 of of IN 40436 4251 32 slowness slowness NN 40436 4251 33 . . . 40436 4252 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4252 2 7 7 CD 40436 4252 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4252 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4252 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4252 6 6 6 CD 40436 4252 7 : : : 40436 4252 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4252 9 , , , 40436 4252 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4252 11 . . . 40436 4253 1 159 159 CD 40436 4253 2 C--160 c--160 NN 40436 4253 3 D. D. NNP 40436 4253 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4253 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4253 6 : : : 40436 4253 7 ou ou NNP 40436 4253 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4253 9 tô tô NNP 40436 4253 10 = = SYM 40436 4253 11 n n CC 40436 4253 12 kalô kalô NN 40436 4253 13 = = SYM 40436 4253 14 n n CC 40436 4253 15 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4253 16 / / SYM 40436 4253 17 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 4253 18 ê ê NNP 40436 4253 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4253 20 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4253 21 / / SYM 40436 4253 22 nê nê NNP 40436 4253 23 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 4253 24 / / SYM 40436 4253 25 n n JJ 40436 4253 26 ? ? . 40436 4254 1 . . . 40436 4255 1 . . . 40436 4256 1 . . . 40436 4257 1 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ NNP 40436 4257 2 _ _ NNP 40436 4257 3 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4257 4 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 4257 5 lo lo NNP 40436 4257 6 / / , 40436 4257 7 gô| gô| NNP 40436 4257 8 _ _ NNP 40436 4257 9 tô tô NNP 40436 4257 10 = = SYM 40436 4257 11 n n CC 40436 4257 12 kalô kalô NN 40436 4257 13 = = SYM 40436 4257 14 n n CC 40436 4257 15 ti ti NN 40436 4257 16 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 4257 17 = = SYM 40436 4257 18 n n CC 40436 4257 19 ê ê NNP 40436 4257 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4257 21 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4257 22 / / SYM 40436 4257 23 nê nê NNP 40436 4257 24 u(pete u(pete NNP 40436 4257 25 / / SYM 40436 4257 26 thê thê NNP 40436 4257 27 . . . 40436 4257 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4257 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4258 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4258 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4258 3 7 7 CD 40436 4258 4 : : : 40436 4258 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4258 6 , , , 40436 4258 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4258 8 . . . 40436 4259 1 160 160 CD 40436 4259 2 C. C. NNP 40436 4259 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4259 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4259 5 Side side NN 40436 4259 6 - - HYPH 40436 4259 7 note note NN 40436 4259 8 : : : 40436 4259 9 Second second JJ 40436 4259 10 answer answer NN 40436 4259 11 . . . 40436 4260 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4260 2 is be VBZ 40436 4260 3 a a DT 40436 4260 4 variety variety NN 40436 4260 5 of of IN 40436 4260 6 the the DT 40436 4260 7 feeling feeling NN 40436 4260 8 of of IN 40436 4260 9 shame shame NN 40436 4260 10 . . . 40436 4261 1 Refuted refute VBN 40436 4261 2 by by IN 40436 4261 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4261 4 . . . 40436 4261 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4262 1 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4262 2 next next JJ 40436 4262 3 declares declare NNS 40436 4262 4 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4262 5 to to TO 40436 4262 6 be be VB 40436 4262 7 a a DT 40436 4262 8 variety variety NN 40436 4262 9 of of IN 40436 4262 10 the the DT 40436 4262 11 feeling feeling NN 40436 4262 12 of of IN 40436 4262 13 shame shame NN 40436 4262 14 or or CC 40436 4262 15 modesty modesty NN 40436 4262 16 . . . 40436 4263 1 But but CC 40436 4263 2 this this DT 40436 4263 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4263 4 observes observe VBZ 40436 4263 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4263 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4263 7 will will MD 40436 4263 8 not not RB 40436 4263 9 hold hold VB 40436 4263 10 more more JJR 40436 4263 11 than than IN 40436 4263 12 the the DT 40436 4263 13 former former JJ 40436 4263 14 explanation explanation NN 40436 4263 15 : : : 40436 4263 16 since since IN 40436 4263 17 Homer Homer NNP 40436 4263 18 has have VBZ 40436 4263 19 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 4263 20 shame shame NN 40436 4263 21 not not RB 40436 4263 22 to to TO 40436 4263 23 be be VB 40436 4263 24 good good JJ 40436 4263 25 , , , 40436 4263 26 for for IN 40436 4263 27 certain certain JJ 40436 4263 28 persons person NNS 40436 4263 29 and and CC 40436 4263 30 under under IN 40436 4263 31 certain certain JJ 40436 4263 32 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 4263 33 . . . 40436 4264 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4264 2 8 8 CD 40436 4264 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4264 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4264 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4264 6 8 8 CD 40436 4264 7 : : : 40436 4264 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4264 9 , , , 40436 4264 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4264 11 . . . 40436 4265 1 161 161 CD 40436 4265 2 A. a. NN 40436 4265 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4266 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4266 2 Side side NN 40436 4266 3 - - HYPH 40436 4266 4 note note NN 40436 4266 5 : : : 40436 4266 6 Third third JJ 40436 4266 7 answer answer NN 40436 4266 8 . . . 40436 4267 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4267 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 4267 3 in in IN 40436 4267 4 doing do VBG 40436 4267 5 one one PRP 40436 4267 6 's 's POS 40436 4267 7 own own JJ 40436 4267 8 business business NN 40436 4267 9 . . . 40436 4268 1 Defended defend VBN 40436 4268 2 by by IN 40436 4268 3 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4268 4 . . . 40436 4269 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4269 2 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 4269 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4269 4 a a DT 40436 4269 5 riddle riddle NN 40436 4269 6 , , , 40436 4269 7 and and CC 40436 4269 8 refutes refute VBZ 40436 4269 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4269 10 . . . 40436 4270 1 Distinction distinction NN 40436 4270 2 between between IN 40436 4270 3 making make VBG 40436 4270 4 and and CC 40436 4270 5 doing do VBG 40436 4270 6 . . . 40436 4270 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4271 1 " " `` 40436 4271 2 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4271 3 consists consist VBZ 40436 4271 4 in in IN 40436 4271 5 doing do VBG 40436 4271 6 one one PRP 40436 4271 7 's 's POS 40436 4271 8 own own JJ 40436 4271 9 business business NN 40436 4271 10 . . . 40436 4271 11 " " '' 40436 4272 1 Here here RB 40436 4272 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4272 3 have have VBP 40436 4272 4 a a DT 40436 4272 5 third third JJ 40436 4272 6 explanation explanation NN 40436 4272 7 , , , 40436 4272 8 proposed propose VBN 40436 4272 9 by by IN 40436 4272 10 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4272 11 and and CC 40436 4272 12 presently presently RB 40436 4272 13 espoused espouse VBN 40436 4272 14 by by IN 40436 4272 15 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4272 16 . . . 40436 4273 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4273 2 professes profess VBZ 40436 4273 3 not not RB 40436 4273 4 to to TO 40436 4273 5 understand understand VB 40436 4273 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4273 7 , , , 40436 4273 8 and and CC 40436 4273 9 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 4273 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4273 11 to to TO 40436 4273 12 be be VB 40436 4273 13 like like IN 40436 4273 14 a a DT 40436 4273 15 riddle riddle NN 40436 4273 16 . . . 40436 4274 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4274 2 9 9 CD 40436 4274 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4274 4 Every every DT 40436 4274 5 tradesman tradesman NN 40436 4274 6 or or CC 40436 4274 7 artisan artisan NNP 40436 4274 8 does do VBZ 40436 4274 9 the the DT 40436 4274 10 business business NN 40436 4274 11 of of IN 40436 4274 12 others other NNS 40436 4274 13 as as RB 40436 4274 14 well well RB 40436 4274 15 as as IN 40436 4274 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4274 17 own own JJ 40436 4274 18 . . . 40436 4275 1 Are be VBP 40436 4275 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4275 3 to to TO 40436 4275 4 say say VB 40436 4275 5 for for IN 40436 4275 6 that that DT 40436 4275 7 reason reason NN 40436 4275 8 that that IN 40436 4275 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4275 10 is be VBZ 40436 4275 11 not not RB 40436 4275 12 temperate temperate VB 40436 4275 13 ? ? . 40436 4276 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4276 2 distinguish distinguish VBP 40436 4276 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4276 4 says say VBZ 40436 4276 5 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4276 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4276 7 between between IN 40436 4276 8 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 9 making make VBG 40436 4276 10 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 11 and and CC 40436 4276 12 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 13 doing do VBG 40436 4276 14 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 15 : : : 40436 4276 16 the the DT 40436 4276 17 artisan artisan NNP 40436 4276 18 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 19 makes make VBZ 40436 4276 20 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 21 for for IN 40436 4276 22 others other NNS 40436 4276 23 , , , 40436 4276 24 but but CC 40436 4276 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4276 26 does do VBZ 40436 4276 27 not not RB 40436 4276 28 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 29 do do VB 40436 4276 30 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 31 for for IN 40436 4276 32 others other NNS 40436 4276 33 , , , 40436 4276 34 and and CC 40436 4276 35 often often RB 40436 4276 36 can can MD 40436 4276 37 not not RB 40436 4276 38 be be VB 40436 4276 39 said say VBN 40436 4276 40 to to IN 40436 4276 41 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 42 do do VB 40436 4276 43 _ _ NNP 40436 4276 44 at at RB 40436 4276 45 all all RB 40436 4276 46 . . . 40436 4277 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4277 2 To to TO 40436 4277 3 do do VB 40436 4277 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4277 5 , , , 40436 4277 6 implies imply VBZ 40436 4277 7 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4277 8 , , , 40436 4277 9 profitable profitable JJ 40436 4277 10 , , , 40436 4277 11 good good JJ 40436 4277 12 , , , 40436 4277 13 occupation occupation NN 40436 4277 14 : : : 40436 4277 15 this this DT 40436 4277 16 alone alone RB 40436 4277 17 is be VBZ 40436 4277 18 a a DT 40436 4277 19 man man NN 40436 4277 20 's 's POS 40436 4277 21 own own JJ 40436 4277 22 business business NN 40436 4277 23 , , , 40436 4277 24 and and CC 40436 4277 25 this this DT 40436 4277 26 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4277 27 call call VBP 40436 4277 28 temperance temperance NN 40436 4277 29 . . . 40436 4278 1 When when WRB 40436 4278 2 a a DT 40436 4278 3 man man NN 40436 4278 4 acts act VBZ 40436 4278 5 so so IN 40436 4278 6 as as IN 40436 4278 7 to to TO 40436 4278 8 harm harm VB 40436 4278 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4278 10 , , , 40436 4278 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4278 12 does do VBZ 40436 4278 13 not not RB 40436 4278 14 do do VB 40436 4278 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4278 16 own own JJ 40436 4278 17 business business NN 40436 4278 18 . . . 40436 4279 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4279 2 10 10 CD 40436 4279 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4279 4 The the DT 40436 4279 5 doing doing NN 40436 4279 6 of of IN 40436 4279 7 good good JJ 40436 4279 8 things thing NNS 40436 4279 9 , , , 40436 4279 10 is be VBZ 40436 4279 11 temperance temperance NN 40436 4279 12 . . . 40436 4280 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4280 2 11 11 CD 40436 4280 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4280 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4280 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4280 6 9 9 CD 40436 4280 7 : : : 40436 4280 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4280 9 , , , 40436 4280 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4280 11 . . . 40436 4281 1 161 161 CD 40436 4281 2 C--162 c--162 SYM 40436 4281 3 B. B. NNP 40436 4282 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4282 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4282 3 : : : 40436 4282 4 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4282 5 / / SYM 40436 4282 6 nê nê UH 40436 4282 7 -- -- : 40436 4282 8 to\ to\ NN 40436 4282 9 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 4282 10 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 4282 11 pra pra NNP 40436 4282 12 / / SYM 40436 4282 13 ttein ttein NN 40436 4282 14 . . . 40436 4283 1 . . . 40436 4284 1 . . . 40436 4285 1 ai)ni ai)ni JJ 40436 4285 2 / / SYM 40436 4285 3 gmati/ gmati/ NNP 40436 4285 4 tini tini NN 40436 4285 5 e)/oiken e)/oiken NNS 40436 4285 6 . . . 40436 4285 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4286 1 There there EX 40436 4286 2 is be VBZ 40436 4286 3 here here RB 40436 4286 4 a a DT 40436 4286 5 good good JJ 40436 4286 6 deal deal NN 40436 4286 7 of of IN 40436 4286 8 playful playful JJ 40436 4286 9 vivacity vivacity NN 40436 4286 10 in in IN 40436 4286 11 the the DT 40436 4286 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4286 13 : : : 40436 4286 14 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4286 15 gives give VBZ 40436 4286 16 this this DT 40436 4286 17 last last JJ 40436 4286 18 answer answer NN 40436 4286 19 , , , 40436 4286 20 which which WDT 40436 4286 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4286 22 has have VBZ 40436 4286 23 heard hear VBN 40436 4286 24 from from IN 40436 4286 25 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4286 26 , , , 40436 4286 27 who who WP 40436 4286 28 is be VBZ 40436 4286 29 at at IN 40436 4286 30 first first RB 40436 4286 31 not not RB 40436 4286 32 forward forward RB 40436 4286 33 to to TO 40436 4286 34 defend defend VB 40436 4286 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4286 36 , , , 40436 4286 37 until until IN 40436 4286 38 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 4286 39 forces force VBZ 40436 4286 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4286 41 to to TO 40436 4286 42 come come VB 40436 4286 43 forward forward RB 40436 4286 44 , , , 40436 4286 45 by by IN 40436 4286 46 hints hint NNS 40436 4286 47 and and CC 40436 4286 48 side side NN 40436 4286 49 - - HYPH 40436 4286 50 insinuations insinuation NNS 40436 4286 51 . . . 40436 4287 1 This this DT 40436 4287 2 is be VBZ 40436 4287 3 the the DT 40436 4287 4 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4287 5 art art NN 40436 4287 6 and and CC 40436 4287 7 variety variety NN 40436 4287 8 of of IN 40436 4287 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4287 10 , , , 40436 4287 11 charming charm VBG 40436 4287 12 to to TO 40436 4287 13 read read VB 40436 4287 14 , , , 40436 4287 15 but but CC 40436 4287 16 not not RB 40436 4287 17 bearing bear VBG 40436 4287 18 upon upon IN 40436 4287 19 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4287 20 as as IN 40436 4287 21 a a DT 40436 4287 22 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 4287 23 . . . 40436 4287 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4288 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4288 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4288 3 10 10 CD 40436 4288 4 : : : 40436 4288 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4288 6 , , , 40436 4288 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4288 8 . . . 40436 4289 1 163 163 CD 40436 4289 2 C C NNP 40436 4289 3 - - HYPH 40436 4289 4 D. D. NNP 40436 4289 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4289 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4289 7 : : : 40436 4289 8 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4289 9 kalô kalô NNP 40436 4289 10 = = SYM 40436 4289 11 s s NNP 40436 4289 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4289 13 ô)pheli ô)pheli NNP 40436 4289 14 / / SYM 40436 4289 15 môs môs NNP 40436 4289 16 poiou poiou NNP 40436 4289 17 / / SYM 40436 4289 18 mena mena NNP 40436 4289 19 . . . 40436 4290 1 . . . 40436 4291 1 . . . 40436 4292 1 oi)kei oi)kei NNP 40436 4292 2 = = SYM 40436 4292 3 a a DT 40436 4292 4 mo mo NN 40436 4292 5 / / SYM 40436 4292 6 na na TO 40436 4292 7 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4292 8 toiau toiau NNP 40436 4292 9 = = SYM 40436 4292 10 ta ta NNP 40436 4292 11 ê(gei ê(gei NNP 40436 4292 12 = = SYM 40436 4292 13 sthai sthai NNP 40436 4292 14 , , , 40436 4292 15 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4292 16 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4292 17 blabera\ blabera\ NNP 40436 4292 18 pa pa NNP 40436 4292 19 / / SYM 40436 4292 20 nta nta NNP 40436 4292 21 a)llo a)llo NNP 40436 4292 22 / / SYM 40436 4292 23 tria tria NNP 40436 4292 24 . . . 40436 4293 1 . . . 40436 4294 1 . . . 40436 4295 1 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 4295 2 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4295 3 oi)kei oi)kei NNP 40436 4295 4 = = SYM 40436 4295 5 a a DT 40436 4295 6 te te NNP 40436 4295 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4295 8 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 4295 9 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 4295 10 a)gatha\ a)gatha\ NNP 40436 4295 11 kaloi kaloi NN 40436 4295 12 / / SYM 40436 4295 13 ês ês NNP 40436 4295 14 , , , 40436 4295 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4295 16 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 4295 17 tô tô NNP 40436 4295 18 = = SYM 40436 4295 19 n n NNP 40436 4295 20 a)gathô a)gathô CD 40436 4295 21 = = SYM 40436 4295 22 n n NNP 40436 4295 23 poiê poiê NNP 40436 4295 24 / / SYM 40436 4295 25 seis seis NNP 40436 4295 26 pra pra NNP 40436 4295 27 / / SYM 40436 4295 28 xeis xeis NNP 40436 4295 29 . . . 40436 4295 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4295 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4296 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4296 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4296 3 11 11 CD 40436 4296 4 : : : 40436 4296 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4296 6 , , , 40436 4296 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4296 8 . . . 40436 4297 1 163 163 CD 40436 4297 2 E. E. NNP 40436 4297 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4297 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4297 5 : : : 40436 4297 6 tê\n tê\n VB 40436 4297 7 tô tô NNP 40436 4297 8 = = SYM 40436 4297 9 n n NNP 40436 4297 10 a)gathô a)gathô CD 40436 4297 11 = = SYM 40436 4297 12 n n CC 40436 4297 13 pra pra NNP 40436 4297 14 = = SYM 40436 4297 15 xin xin NNP 40436 4297 16 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4297 17 / / SYM 40436 4297 18 nên nên NNP 40436 4297 19 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4297 20 saphô saphô NN 40436 4297 21 = = SYM 40436 4297 22 s s NNP 40436 4297 23 soi soi NNP 40436 4297 24 diori diori NNP 40436 4297 25 / / SYM 40436 4297 26 zomai zomai NNP 40436 4297 27 . . . 40436 4297 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4297 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4298 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4298 2 Side side NN 40436 4298 3 - - HYPH 40436 4298 4 note note NN 40436 4298 5 : : : 40436 4298 6 Fourth fourth JJ 40436 4298 7 answer answer NN 40436 4298 8 , , , 40436 4298 9 by by IN 40436 4298 10 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4298 11 . . . 40436 4299 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4299 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 4299 3 in in IN 40436 4299 4 self self NN 40436 4299 5 - - HYPH 40436 4299 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4299 7 . . . 40436 4299 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4300 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4300 2 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 4300 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4300 4 is be VBZ 40436 4300 5 . . . 40436 4301 1 But but CC 40436 4301 2 does do VBZ 40436 4301 3 the the DT 40436 4301 4 well well RB 40436 4301 5 - - HYPH 40436 4301 6 doer doer NN 40436 4301 7 always always RB 40436 4301 8 and and CC 40436 4301 9 certainly certainly RB 40436 4301 10 know know VBP 40436 4301 11 that that IN 40436 4301 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4301 13 is be VBZ 40436 4301 14 doing do VBG 40436 4301 15 well well RB 40436 4301 16 ? ? . 40436 4302 1 Does do VBZ 40436 4302 2 the the DT 40436 4302 3 temperate temperate NN 40436 4302 4 man man NN 40436 4302 5 know know VB 40436 4302 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4302 7 own own JJ 40436 4302 8 temperance temperance NN 40436 4302 9 ? ? . 40436 4303 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4303 2 Krit._--He Krit._--He NNP 40436 4303 3 certainly certainly RB 40436 4303 4 must must MD 40436 4303 5 . . . 40436 4304 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 4304 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4304 3 think think VBP 40436 4304 4 that that IN 40436 4304 5 the the DT 40436 4304 6 essence essence NN 40436 4304 7 of of IN 40436 4304 8 temperance temperance NN 40436 4304 9 is be VBZ 40436 4304 10 , , , 40436 4304 11 _ _ NNP 40436 4304 12 Self Self NNP 40436 4304 13 - - HYPH 40436 4304 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4304 15 _ _ NN 40436 4304 16 . . . 40436 4305 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4305 2 Know Know NNP 40436 4305 3 thyself thyself PRP 40436 4305 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4305 5 is be VBZ 40436 4305 6 the the DT 40436 4305 7 precept precept NN 40436 4305 8 of of IN 40436 4305 9 the the DT 40436 4305 10 Delphian delphian JJ 40436 4305 11 God God NNP 40436 4305 12 , , , 40436 4305 13 who who WP 40436 4305 14 means mean VBZ 40436 4305 15 thereby thereby RB 40436 4305 16 the the DT 40436 4305 17 same same JJ 40436 4305 18 as as IN 40436 4305 19 if if IN 40436 4305 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4305 21 had have VBD 40436 4305 22 said say VBN 40436 4305 23 -- -- : 40436 4305 24 Be be VB 40436 4305 25 temperate temperate NN 40436 4305 26 . . . 40436 4306 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4306 2 now now RB 40436 4306 3 put put VBP 40436 4306 4 aside aside RB 40436 4306 5 all all DT 40436 4306 6 that that WDT 40436 4306 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4306 8 have have VBP 40436 4306 9 said say VBD 40436 4306 10 before before RB 40436 4306 11 , , , 40436 4306 12 and and CC 40436 4306 13 take take VB 40436 4306 14 up up RP 40436 4306 15 this this DT 40436 4306 16 new new JJ 40436 4306 17 position position NN 40436 4306 18 , , , 40436 4306 19 That that DT 40436 4306 20 temperance temperance NN 40436 4306 21 consists consist VBZ 40436 4306 22 in in IN 40436 4306 23 a a DT 40436 4306 24 man man NN 40436 4306 25 's 's POS 40436 4306 26 knowing know VBG 40436 4306 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4306 28 . . . 40436 4307 1 If if IN 40436 4307 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4307 3 do do VBP 40436 4307 4 not not RB 40436 4307 5 admit admit VB 40436 4307 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4307 7 , , , 40436 4307 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4307 9 challenge challenge VBP 40436 4307 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4307 11 cross cross NN 40436 4307 12 - - NN 40436 4307 13 examination examination NN 40436 4307 14 . . . 40436 4308 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4308 2 12 12 CD 40436 4308 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4308 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4308 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4308 6 12 12 CD 40436 4308 7 : : : 40436 4308 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4308 9 , , , 40436 4308 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4308 11 . . . 40436 4309 1 164 164 CD 40436 4309 2 - - SYM 40436 4309 3 165 165 CD 40436 4309 4 . . . 40436 4309 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4310 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4310 2 Side side NN 40436 4310 3 - - HYPH 40436 4310 4 note note NN 40436 4310 5 : : : 40436 4310 6 Questions question NNS 40436 4310 7 of of IN 40436 4310 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4310 9 thereupon thereupon RB 40436 4310 10 . . . 40436 4311 1 What what WDT 40436 4311 2 good good NN 40436 4311 3 does do VBZ 40436 4311 4 self self NN 40436 4311 5 - - HYPH 40436 4311 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4311 7 procure procure NN 40436 4311 8 for for IN 40436 4311 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4311 10 ? ? . 40436 4312 1 What what WP 40436 4312 2 is be VBZ 40436 4312 3 the the DT 40436 4312 4 object object NN 40436 4312 5 known know VBN 40436 4312 6 , , , 40436 4312 7 in in IN 40436 4312 8 this this DT 40436 4312 9 case case NN 40436 4312 10 ? ? . 40436 4313 1 Answer answer NN 40436 4313 2 : : : 40436 4313 3 There there EX 40436 4313 4 is be VBZ 40436 4313 5 no no DT 40436 4313 6 object object NN 40436 4313 7 of of IN 40436 4313 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4313 9 , , , 40436 4313 10 distinct distinct JJ 40436 4313 11 from from IN 40436 4313 12 the the DT 40436 4313 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4313 14 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4313 15 . . . 40436 4313 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4314 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4314 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 4314 3 can can MD 40436 4314 4 not not RB 40436 4314 5 tell tell VB 40436 4314 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4314 7 whether whether IN 40436 4314 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4314 9 admit admit VBP 40436 4314 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4314 11 or or CC 40436 4314 12 not not RB 40436 4314 13 , , , 40436 4314 14 until until IN 40436 4314 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4314 16 have have VBP 40436 4314 17 investigated investigate VBN 40436 4314 18 . . . 40436 4315 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4315 2 address address VBP 40436 4315 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4315 4 as as IN 40436 4315 5 if if IN 40436 4315 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4315 7 professed profess VBD 40436 4315 8 to to TO 40436 4315 9 know know VB 40436 4315 10 the the DT 40436 4315 11 subject subject NN 40436 4315 12 : : : 40436 4315 13 but but CC 40436 4315 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4315 15 is be VBZ 40436 4315 16 because because IN 40436 4315 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4315 18 do do VBP 40436 4315 19 not not RB 40436 4315 20 know know VB 40436 4315 21 , , , 40436 4315 22 that that IN 40436 4315 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4315 24 examine examine VBP 40436 4315 25 , , , 40436 4315 26 in in IN 40436 4315 27 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 4315 28 with with IN 40436 4315 29 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4315 30 , , , 40436 4315 31 each each DT 40436 4315 32 successive successive JJ 40436 4315 33 answer answer NN 40436 4315 34 . . . 40436 4316 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4316 2 13 13 CD 40436 4316 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4316 4 If if IN 40436 4316 5 temperance temperance NN 40436 4316 6 consists consist VBZ 40436 4316 7 in in IN 40436 4316 8 knowing know VBG 40436 4316 9 , , , 40436 4316 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4316 11 must must MD 40436 4316 12 be be VB 40436 4316 13 a a DT 40436 4316 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4316 15 of of IN 40436 4316 16 something something NN 40436 4316 17 . . . 40436 4317 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4317 2 Krit._--It Krit._--It NNP 40436 4317 3 is be VBZ 40436 4317 4 so so RB 40436 4317 5 : : : 40436 4317 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4317 7 is be VBZ 40436 4317 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4317 9 of of IN 40436 4317 10 a a DT 40436 4317 11 man man NN 40436 4317 12 's 's POS 40436 4317 13 self self NN 40436 4317 14 . . . 40436 4318 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4318 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 4318 3 good good NN 40436 4318 4 does do VBZ 40436 4318 5 this this DT 40436 4318 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4318 7 procure procure NN 40436 4318 8 for for IN 40436 4318 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4318 10 ? ? . 40436 4319 1 as as IN 40436 4319 2 medical medical JJ 40436 4319 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4319 4 procures procure NNS 40436 4319 5 for for IN 40436 4319 6 us us NNP 40436 4319 7 health health NN 40436 4319 8 -- -- : 40436 4319 9 architectural architectural JJ 40436 4319 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4319 11 , , , 40436 4319 12 buildings building NNS 40436 4319 13 , , , 40436 4319 14 & & CC 40436 4319 15 c. c. NNP 40436 4319 16 ? ? . 40436 4320 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4320 2 Krit._--It Krit._--It NNP 40436 4320 3 has have VBZ 40436 4320 4 no no DT 40436 4320 5 object object NN 40436 4320 6 positive positive JJ 40436 4320 7 result result NN 40436 4320 8 of of IN 40436 4320 9 analogous analogous JJ 40436 4320 10 character character NN 40436 4320 11 : : . 40436 4320 12 but but CC 40436 4320 13 neither neither DT 40436 4320 14 have have VB 40436 4320 15 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 4320 16 nor nor CC 40436 4320 17 geometry geometry NN 40436 4320 18 . . . 40436 4321 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4321 2 Sokr._--True Sokr._--True NNP 40436 4321 3 , , , 40436 4321 4 but but CC 40436 4321 5 in in IN 40436 4321 6 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 4321 7 and and CC 40436 4321 8 geometry geometry NN 40436 4321 9 , , , 40436 4321 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4321 11 can can MD 40436 4321 12 at at IN 40436 4321 13 least least JJS 40436 4321 14 indicate indicate VB 40436 4321 15 a a DT 40436 4321 16 something something NN 40436 4321 17 known know VBN 40436 4321 18 , , , 40436 4321 19 distinct distinct JJ 40436 4321 20 from from IN 40436 4321 21 the the DT 40436 4321 22 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4321 23 . . . 40436 4322 1 Number number NN 40436 4322 2 and and CC 40436 4322 3 proportion proportion NN 40436 4322 4 are be VBP 40436 4322 5 distinct distinct JJ 40436 4322 6 from from IN 40436 4322 7 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 4322 8 , , , 40436 4322 9 the the DT 40436 4322 10 science science NN 40436 4322 11 which which WDT 40436 4322 12 takes take VBZ 40436 4322 13 cognizance cognizance NN 40436 4322 14 of of IN 40436 4322 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4322 16 . . . 40436 4323 1 Now now RB 40436 4323 2 what what WP 40436 4323 3 is be VBZ 40436 4323 4 that that IN 40436 4323 5 , , , 40436 4323 6 of of IN 40436 4323 7 which which WDT 40436 4323 8 temperance temperance NN 40436 4323 9 is be VBZ 40436 4323 10 the the DT 40436 4323 11 knowledge,--distinct knowledge,--distinct NNP 40436 4323 12 from from IN 40436 4323 13 temperance temperance NN 40436 4323 14 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4323 15 ? ? . 40436 4324 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4324 2 Krit._--It Krit._--It NNP 40436 4324 3 is be VBZ 40436 4324 4 on on IN 40436 4324 5 this this DT 40436 4324 6 very very JJ 40436 4324 7 point point NN 40436 4324 8 that that IN 40436 4324 9 temperance temperance NN 40436 4324 10 differs differ VBZ 40436 4324 11 from from IN 40436 4324 12 all all PDT 40436 4324 13 the the DT 40436 4324 14 other other JJ 40436 4324 15 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4324 16 . . . 40436 4325 1 Each each DT 40436 4325 2 of of IN 40436 4325 3 the the DT 40436 4325 4 others other NNS 40436 4325 5 is be VBZ 40436 4325 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4325 7 of of IN 40436 4325 8 something something NN 40436 4325 9 different different JJ 40436 4325 10 from from IN 40436 4325 11 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4325 12 , , , 40436 4325 13 but but CC 40436 4325 14 not not RB 40436 4325 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4325 16 of of IN 40436 4325 17 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4325 18 : : : 40436 4325 19 while while IN 40436 4325 20 temperance temperance NN 40436 4325 21 is be VBZ 40436 4325 22 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4325 23 of of IN 40436 4325 24 all all PDT 40436 4325 25 the the DT 40436 4325 26 other other JJ 40436 4325 27 sciences science NNS 40436 4325 28 and and CC 40436 4325 29 of of IN 40436 4325 30 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4325 31 also also RB 40436 4325 32 . . . 40436 4326 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4326 2 14 14 CD 40436 4326 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4326 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4326 5 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 4326 6 this this DT 40436 4326 7 be be VB 40436 4326 8 so so RB 40436 4326 9 , , , 40436 4326 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4326 11 will will MD 40436 4326 12 of of IN 40436 4326 13 course course NN 40436 4326 14 be be VB 40436 4326 15 a a DT 40436 4326 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4326 17 of of IN 40436 4326 18 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4326 19 , , , 40436 4326 20 as as RB 40436 4326 21 well well RB 40436 4326 22 as as IN 40436 4326 23 a a DT 40436 4326 24 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4326 25 of of IN 40436 4326 26 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4326 27 ? ? . 40436 4327 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4327 2 Krit._--Certainly Krit._--Certainly NNP 40436 4327 3 . . . 40436 4328 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4328 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4328 3 13 13 CD 40436 4328 4 : : : 40436 4328 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4328 6 , , , 40436 4328 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4328 8 . . . 40436 4329 1 165 165 CD 40436 4329 2 C. C. NNP 40436 4329 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4329 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4329 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4329 6 14 14 CD 40436 4329 7 : : : 40436 4329 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4329 9 , , , 40436 4329 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4329 11 . . . 40436 4330 1 166 166 CD 40436 4330 2 C. C. NNP 40436 4330 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4330 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4330 5 : : : 40436 4330 6 ai ai VB 40436 4330 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4330 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4330 9 a)/llai a)/llai NNP 40436 4330 10 pa pa NNP 40436 4330 11 = = SYM 40436 4330 12 sai sai NNP 40436 4330 13 a)/llou a)/llou NNP 40436 4330 14 ei)si\n ei)si\n NNS 40436 4330 15 e)pistê e)pistê , 40436 4330 16 = = SYM 40436 4330 17 mai mai UH 40436 4330 18 , , , 40436 4330 19 e(autô e(autô NFP 40436 4330 20 = = SYM 40436 4330 21 n n CC 40436 4330 22 d d NN 40436 4330 23 ' ' '' 40436 4330 24 ou)/ ou)/ NN 40436 4330 25 ; ; : 40436 4330 26 ê ê NNP 40436 4330 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4330 28 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4330 29 mo mo NNP 40436 4330 30 / / SYM 40436 4330 31 nê nê NNP 40436 4330 32 tô tô NNP 40436 4330 33 = = SYM 40436 4330 34 n n NNP 40436 4330 35 te te NNP 40436 4330 36 a)/llôn a)/llôn NNP 40436 4330 37 e)pistêmô e)pistêmô NNP 40436 4330 38 = = SYM 40436 4330 39 n n CC 40436 4330 40 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4330 41 / / SYM 40436 4330 42 mê mê NNP 40436 4330 43 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 4330 44 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4330 45 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 4330 46 e(autê e(autê NNP 40436 4330 47 = = SYM 40436 4330 48 s s NNP 40436 4330 49 . . . 40436 4330 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4331 1 So so RB 40436 4331 2 also also RB 40436 4331 3 166 166 CD 40436 4331 4 E. E. NNP 40436 4331 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4331 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4331 7 Side side NN 40436 4331 8 - - HYPH 40436 4331 9 note note NN 40436 4331 10 : : : 40436 4331 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4331 12 doubts doubt VBZ 40436 4331 13 the the DT 40436 4331 14 possibility possibility NN 40436 4331 15 of of IN 40436 4331 16 any any DT 40436 4331 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4331 18 , , , 40436 4331 19 without without IN 40436 4331 20 a a DT 40436 4331 21 given give VBN 40436 4331 22 _ _ NNP 40436 4331 23 cognitum cognitum NN 40436 4331 24 _ _ NNP 40436 4331 25 as as IN 40436 4331 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4331 27 object object NN 40436 4331 28 . . . 40436 4332 1 Analogies analogy NNS 40436 4332 2 to to TO 40436 4332 3 prove prove VB 40436 4332 4 that that DT 40436 4332 5 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4332 6 of of IN 40436 4332 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4332 8 is be VBZ 40436 4332 9 impossible impossible JJ 40436 4332 10 . . . 40436 4332 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4333 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4333 2 Sokr._--According sokr._--according IN 40436 4333 3 to to IN 40436 4333 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4333 5 explanation explanation NN 40436 4333 6 , , , 40436 4333 7 then then RB 40436 4333 8 , , , 40436 4333 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4333 10 is be VBZ 40436 4333 11 only only RB 40436 4333 12 the the DT 40436 4333 13 temperate temperate NN 40436 4333 14 man man NN 40436 4333 15 who who WP 40436 4333 16 knows know VBZ 40436 4333 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4333 18 . . . 40436 4334 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4334 2 alone alone RB 40436 4334 3 is be VBZ 40436 4334 4 able able JJ 40436 4334 5 to to TO 40436 4334 6 examine examine VB 40436 4334 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4334 8 , , , 40436 4334 9 and and CC 40436 4334 10 thus thus RB 40436 4334 11 to to TO 40436 4334 12 find find VB 40436 4334 13 out out RP 40436 4334 14 what what WP 40436 4334 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4334 16 really really RB 40436 4334 17 knows know VBZ 40436 4334 18 and and CC 40436 4334 19 does do VBZ 40436 4334 20 not not RB 40436 4334 21 know know VB 40436 4334 22 : : : 40436 4334 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4334 24 alone alone RB 40436 4334 25 is be VBZ 40436 4334 26 able able JJ 40436 4334 27 to to TO 40436 4334 28 examine examine VB 40436 4334 29 others other NNS 40436 4334 30 , , , 40436 4334 31 and and CC 40436 4334 32 thus thus RB 40436 4334 33 to to TO 40436 4334 34 find find VB 40436 4334 35 out out RP 40436 4334 36 what what WP 40436 4334 37 each each DT 40436 4334 38 man man NN 40436 4334 39 knows know VBZ 40436 4334 40 , , , 40436 4334 41 or or CC 40436 4334 42 what what WP 40436 4334 43 each each DT 40436 4334 44 man man NN 40436 4334 45 only only RB 40436 4334 46 believes believe VBZ 40436 4334 47 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4334 48 to to TO 40436 4334 49 know know VB 40436 4334 50 without without IN 40436 4334 51 really really RB 40436 4334 52 knowing know VBG 40436 4334 53 . . . 40436 4335 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4335 2 , , , 40436 4335 3 or or CC 40436 4335 4 self self NN 40436 4335 5 - - HYPH 40436 4335 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4335 7 , , , 40436 4335 8 is be VBZ 40436 4335 9 the the DT 40436 4335 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4335 11 what what WDT 40436 4335 12 a a DT 40436 4335 13 man man NN 40436 4335 14 knows know VBZ 40436 4335 15 , , , 40436 4335 16 and and CC 40436 4335 17 what what WP 40436 4335 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4335 19 does do VBZ 40436 4335 20 not not RB 40436 4335 21 know know VB 40436 4335 22 . . . 40436 4336 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4336 2 15 15 CD 40436 4336 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4336 4 Now now RB 40436 4336 5 two two CD 40436 4336 6 questions question NNS 40436 4336 7 arise arise VBP 40436 4336 8 upon upon IN 40436 4336 9 this this DT 40436 4336 10 : : : 40436 4336 11 First first RB 40436 4336 12 , , , 40436 4336 13 is be VBZ 40436 4336 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4336 15 possible possible JJ 40436 4336 16 for for IN 40436 4336 17 a a DT 40436 4336 18 man man NN 40436 4336 19 to to TO 40436 4336 20 know know VB 40436 4336 21 , , , 40436 4336 22 that that IN 40436 4336 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4336 24 knows know VBZ 40436 4336 25 what what WP 40436 4336 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4336 27 does do VBZ 40436 4336 28 know know VB 40436 4336 29 , , , 40436 4336 30 and and CC 40436 4336 31 that that IN 40436 4336 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4336 33 does do VBZ 40436 4336 34 not not RB 40436 4336 35 know know VB 40436 4336 36 what what WP 40436 4336 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4336 38 does do VBZ 40436 4336 39 not not RB 40436 4336 40 know know VB 40436 4336 41 ? ? . 40436 4337 1 Next next RB 40436 4337 2 , , , 40436 4337 3 granting grant VBG 40436 4337 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4337 5 to to TO 40436 4337 6 be be VB 40436 4337 7 possible possible JJ 40436 4337 8 , , , 40436 4337 9 in in IN 40436 4337 10 what what WDT 40436 4337 11 way way NN 40436 4337 12 do do VBP 40436 4337 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4337 14 gain gain VB 40436 4337 15 by by IN 40436 4337 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4337 17 ? ? . 40436 4338 1 The the DT 40436 4338 2 first first JJ 40436 4338 3 of of IN 40436 4338 4 these these DT 40436 4338 5 two two CD 40436 4338 6 questions question NNS 40436 4338 7 involves involve VBZ 40436 4338 8 much much JJ 40436 4338 9 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 4338 10 . . . 40436 4339 1 How how WRB 40436 4339 2 can can MD 40436 4339 3 there there EX 40436 4339 4 be be VB 40436 4339 5 any any DT 40436 4339 6 cognition cognition NN 40436 4339 7 , , , 40436 4339 8 which which WDT 40436 4339 9 is be VBZ 40436 4339 10 not not RB 40436 4339 11 cognition cognition NN 40436 4339 12 of of IN 40436 4339 13 a a DT 40436 4339 14 given give VBN 40436 4339 15 _ _ NNP 40436 4339 16 cognitum cognitum NN 40436 4339 17 _ _ NNP 40436 4339 18 , , , 40436 4339 19 but but CC 40436 4339 20 cognition cognition NN 40436 4339 21 merely merely RB 40436 4339 22 of of IN 40436 4339 23 other other JJ 40436 4339 24 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4339 25 and and CC 40436 4339 26 non non NNS 40436 4339 27 - - NNS 40436 4339 28 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4339 29 ? ? . 40436 4340 1 There there EX 40436 4340 2 is be VBZ 40436 4340 3 no no DT 40436 4340 4 vision vision NN 40436 4340 5 except except IN 40436 4340 6 of of IN 40436 4340 7 some some DT 40436 4340 8 colour colour NN 40436 4340 9 , , , 40436 4340 10 no no DT 40436 4340 11 audition audition NN 40436 4340 12 except except IN 40436 4340 13 of of IN 40436 4340 14 some some DT 40436 4340 15 sound sound NN 40436 4340 16 : : : 40436 4340 17 there there EX 40436 4340 18 can can MD 40436 4340 19 be be VB 40436 4340 20 no no DT 40436 4340 21 vision vision NN 40436 4340 22 of of IN 40436 4340 23 visions vision NNS 40436 4340 24 , , , 40436 4340 25 or or CC 40436 4340 26 audition audition NN 40436 4340 27 of of IN 40436 4340 28 auditions audition NNS 40436 4340 29 . . . 40436 4341 1 So so RB 40436 4341 2 likewise likewise RB 40436 4341 3 , , , 40436 4341 4 all all DT 40436 4341 5 desire desire NN 40436 4341 6 is be VBZ 40436 4341 7 desire desire NN 40436 4341 8 of of IN 40436 4341 9 some some DT 40436 4341 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 4341 11 ; ; : 40436 4341 12 there there EX 40436 4341 13 is be VBZ 40436 4341 14 no no DT 40436 4341 15 desire desire NN 40436 4341 16 of of IN 40436 4341 17 desires desire NNS 40436 4341 18 . . . 40436 4342 1 All all DT 40436 4342 2 volition volition NN 40436 4342 3 is be VBZ 40436 4342 4 volition volition NN 40436 4342 5 of of IN 40436 4342 6 some some DT 40436 4342 7 good good JJ 40436 4342 8 ; ; : 40436 4342 9 there there EX 40436 4342 10 is be VBZ 40436 4342 11 no no DT 40436 4342 12 volition volition NN 40436 4342 13 of of IN 40436 4342 14 volitions volition NNS 40436 4342 15 : : : 40436 4342 16 all all DT 40436 4342 17 love love NN 40436 4342 18 applies apply VBZ 40436 4342 19 to to IN 40436 4342 20 something something NN 40436 4342 21 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4342 22 -- -- : 40436 4342 23 there there EX 40436 4342 24 is be VBZ 40436 4342 25 no no DT 40436 4342 26 love love NN 40436 4342 27 of of IN 40436 4342 28 other other JJ 40436 4342 29 loves love NNS 40436 4342 30 . . . 40436 4343 1 The the DT 40436 4343 2 like like NN 40436 4343 3 is be VBZ 40436 4343 4 true true JJ 40436 4343 5 of of IN 40436 4343 6 fear fear NN 40436 4343 7 , , , 40436 4343 8 opinion opinion NN 40436 4343 9 , , , 40436 4343 10 & & CC 40436 4343 11 c. c. NNP 40436 4343 12 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4343 13 would would MD 40436 4343 14 be be VB 40436 4343 15 singular singular JJ 40436 4343 16 therefore therefore RB 40436 4343 17 , , , 40436 4343 18 if if IN 40436 4343 19 contrary contrary RB 40436 4343 20 to to IN 40436 4343 21 all all PDT 40436 4343 22 these these DT 40436 4343 23 analogies analogy NNS 40436 4343 24 , , , 40436 4343 25 there there EX 40436 4343 26 were be VBD 40436 4343 27 any any DT 40436 4343 28 cognition cognition NN 40436 4343 29 not not RB 40436 4343 30 of of IN 40436 4343 31 some some DT 40436 4343 32 _ _ NNP 40436 4343 33 cognitum cognitum NN 40436 4343 34 _ _ NNP 40436 4343 35 , , , 40436 4343 36 but but CC 40436 4343 37 of of IN 40436 4343 38 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4343 39 and and CC 40436 4343 40 other other JJ 40436 4343 41 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4343 42 . . . 40436 4344 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4344 2 16 16 CD 40436 4344 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4344 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4344 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4344 6 15 15 CD 40436 4344 7 : : : 40436 4344 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4344 9 , , , 40436 4344 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4344 11 . . . 40436 4345 1 167 167 CD 40436 4345 2 A. a. NN 40436 4345 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4346 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4346 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4346 3 16 16 CD 40436 4346 4 : : : 40436 4346 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4346 6 , , , 40436 4346 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4346 8 . . . 40436 4347 1 167 167 CD 40436 4347 2 - - SYM 40436 4347 3 168 168 CD 40436 4347 4 . . . 40436 4347 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4348 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4348 2 Side side NN 40436 4348 3 - - HYPH 40436 4348 4 note note NN 40436 4348 5 : : : 40436 4348 6 All all DT 40436 4348 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4348 8 must must MD 40436 4348 9 be be VB 40436 4348 10 relative relative JJ 40436 4348 11 to to IN 40436 4348 12 some some DT 40436 4348 13 object object NN 40436 4348 14 . . . 40436 4348 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4349 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4349 2 is be VBZ 40436 4349 3 of of IN 40436 4349 4 the the DT 40436 4349 5 essence essence NN 40436 4349 6 of of IN 40436 4349 7 cognition cognition NN 40436 4349 8 to to TO 40436 4349 9 be be VB 40436 4349 10 cognition cognition NN 40436 4349 11 of of IN 40436 4349 12 something something NN 40436 4349 13 , , , 40436 4349 14 and and CC 40436 4349 15 to to TO 40436 4349 16 have have VB 40436 4349 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4349 18 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 4349 19 property property NN 40436 4349 20 with with IN 40436 4349 21 reference reference NN 40436 4349 22 to to IN 40436 4349 23 some some DT 40436 4349 24 correlate correlate JJ 40436 4349 25 . . . 40436 4350 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4350 2 17 17 CD 40436 4350 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4350 4 What what WP 40436 4350 5 is be VBZ 40436 4350 6 greater great JJR 40436 4350 7 , , , 40436 4350 8 has have VBZ 40436 4350 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4350 10 property property NN 40436 4350 11 of of IN 40436 4350 12 being be VBG 40436 4350 13 greater great JJR 40436 4350 14 in in IN 40436 4350 15 relation relation NN 40436 4350 16 to to IN 40436 4350 17 something something NN 40436 4350 18 else else RB 40436 4350 19 , , , 40436 4350 20 which which WDT 40436 4350 21 is be VBZ 40436 4350 22 less less JJR 40436 4350 23 -- -- : 40436 4350 24 not not RB 40436 4350 25 in in IN 40436 4350 26 relation relation NN 40436 4350 27 to to IN 40436 4350 28 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4350 29 . . . 40436 4351 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4351 2 can can MD 40436 4351 3 not not RB 40436 4351 4 be be VB 40436 4351 5 greater great JJR 40436 4351 6 than than IN 40436 4351 7 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4351 8 , , , 40436 4351 9 for for IN 40436 4351 10 then then RB 40436 4351 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4351 12 would would MD 40436 4351 13 also also RB 40436 4351 14 be be VB 40436 4351 15 less less JJR 40436 4351 16 than than IN 40436 4351 17 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4351 18 . . . 40436 4352 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4352 2 can can MD 40436 4352 3 not not RB 40436 4352 4 include include VB 40436 4352 5 in in IN 40436 4352 6 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4352 7 the the DT 40436 4352 8 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 4352 9 property property NN 40436 4352 10 of of IN 40436 4352 11 the the DT 40436 4352 12 _ _ NNP 40436 4352 13 correlatum correlatum NN 40436 4352 14 _ _ NNP 40436 4352 15 as as RB 40436 4352 16 well well RB 40436 4352 17 as as IN 40436 4352 18 that that DT 40436 4352 19 of of IN 40436 4352 20 the the DT 40436 4352 21 _ _ NNP 40436 4352 22 relatum relatum NN 40436 4352 23 _ _ NNP 40436 4352 24 . . . 40436 4353 1 So so RB 40436 4353 2 too too RB 40436 4353 3 about about IN 40436 4353 4 what what WP 40436 4353 5 is be VBZ 40436 4353 6 older old JJR 40436 4353 7 , , , 40436 4353 8 younger young JJR 40436 4353 9 , , , 40436 4353 10 heavier heavy JJR 40436 4353 11 , , , 40436 4353 12 lighter light JJR 40436 4353 13 : : : 40436 4353 14 there there EX 40436 4353 15 is be VBZ 40436 4353 16 always always RB 40436 4353 17 a a DT 40436 4353 18 something something NN 40436 4353 19 distinct distinct JJ 40436 4353 20 , , , 40436 4353 21 to to TO 40436 4353 22 which which WDT 40436 4353 23 reference reference NN 40436 4353 24 is be VBZ 40436 4353 25 made make VBN 40436 4353 26 . . . 40436 4354 1 Vision vision NN 40436 4354 2 does do VBZ 40436 4354 3 not not RB 40436 4354 4 include include VB 40436 4354 5 in in IN 40436 4354 6 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4354 7 both both CC 40436 4354 8 the the DT 40436 4354 9 property property NN 40436 4354 10 of of IN 40436 4354 11 seeing see VBG 40436 4354 12 , , , 40436 4354 13 and and CC 40436 4354 14 that that DT 40436 4354 15 of of IN 40436 4354 16 being be VBG 40436 4354 17 seen see VBN 40436 4354 18 : : : 40436 4354 19 the the DT 40436 4354 20 _ _ NNP 40436 4354 21 videns viden NNS 40436 4354 22 _ _ NNP 40436 4354 23 is be VBZ 40436 4354 24 distinct distinct JJ 40436 4354 25 from from IN 40436 4354 26 the the DT 40436 4354 27 _ _ NNP 40436 4354 28 visum visum NNP 40436 4354 29 _ _ NNP 40436 4354 30 . . . 40436 4355 1 A a DT 40436 4355 2 movement movement NN 40436 4355 3 implies imply VBZ 40436 4355 4 something something NN 40436 4355 5 else else RB 40436 4355 6 to to TO 40436 4355 7 be be VB 40436 4355 8 moved move VBN 40436 4355 9 : : : 40436 4355 10 a a DT 40436 4355 11 heater heater NN 40436 4355 12 something something NN 40436 4355 13 else else RB 40436 4355 14 to to TO 40436 4355 15 be be VB 40436 4355 16 heated heat VBN 40436 4355 17 . . . 40436 4356 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4356 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4356 3 17 17 CD 40436 4356 4 : : : 40436 4356 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4356 6 , , , 40436 4356 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4356 8 . . . 40436 4357 1 168 168 CD 40436 4357 2 B. B. NNP 40436 4358 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4358 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4358 3 : : : 40436 4358 4 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 4358 5 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4358 6 au(tê\ au(tê\ NNP 40436 4358 7 ê ê NNP 40436 4358 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4358 9 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4358 10 / / SYM 40436 4358 11 mê mê NNP 40436 4358 12 tino\s tino\s ADD 40436 4358 13 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4358 14 / / SYM 40436 4358 15 mê mê NNP 40436 4358 16 , , , 40436 4358 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4358 18 e)/chei e)/chei NNP 40436 4358 19 tina tina NNP 40436 4358 20 toiau toiau NNP 40436 4358 21 / / SYM 40436 4358 22 tên tên NNP 40436 4358 23 du du NNP 40436 4358 24 / / SYM 40436 4358 25 namin namin NNP 40436 4358 26 ô(/ste ô(/ste NNP 40436 4358 27 tino\s tino\s NFP 40436 4358 28 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4358 29 . . . 40436 4358 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4358 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4359 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4359 2 Side side NN 40436 4359 3 - - HYPH 40436 4359 4 note note NN 40436 4359 5 : : : 40436 4359 6 All all DT 40436 4359 7 properties property NNS 40436 4359 8 are be VBP 40436 4359 9 relative relative JJ 40436 4359 10 -- -- : 40436 4359 11 every every DT 40436 4359 12 thing thing NN 40436 4359 13 in in IN 40436 4359 14 nature nature NN 40436 4359 15 has have VBZ 40436 4359 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4359 17 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 4359 18 property property NN 40436 4359 19 with with IN 40436 4359 20 reference reference NN 40436 4359 21 to to IN 40436 4359 22 something something NN 40436 4359 23 else else RB 40436 4359 24 . . . 40436 4359 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4360 1 In in IN 40436 4360 2 all all PDT 40436 4360 3 these these DT 40436 4360 4 cases case NNS 40436 4360 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4360 6 concludes conclude VBZ 40436 4360 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4360 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4360 9 the the DT 40436 4360 10 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 4360 11 property property NN 40436 4360 12 is be VBZ 40436 4360 13 essentially essentially RB 40436 4360 14 relative relative JJ 40436 4360 15 , , , 40436 4360 16 implying imply VBG 40436 4360 17 something something NN 40436 4360 18 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 40436 4360 19 from from IN 40436 4360 20 , , , 40436 4360 21 yet yet CC 40436 4360 22 correlating correlate VBG 40436 4360 23 with with IN 40436 4360 24 , , , 40436 4360 25 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4360 26 . . . 40436 4361 1 May May MD 40436 4361 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4361 3 generalise generalise VB 40436 4361 4 the the DT 40436 4361 5 proposition proposition NN 40436 4361 6 , , , 40436 4361 7 and and CC 40436 4361 8 affirm affirm NN 40436 4361 9 , , , 40436 4361 10 That that IN 40436 4361 11 all all DT 40436 4361 12 properties property NNS 40436 4361 13 are be VBP 40436 4361 14 relative relative JJ 40436 4361 15 , , , 40436 4361 16 and and CC 40436 4361 17 that that IN 40436 4361 18 every every DT 40436 4361 19 thing thing NN 40436 4361 20 in in IN 40436 4361 21 nature nature NN 40436 4361 22 has have VBZ 40436 4361 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4361 24 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 4361 25 property property NN 40436 4361 26 with with IN 40436 4361 27 reference reference NN 40436 4361 28 , , , 40436 4361 29 not not RB 40436 4361 30 to to IN 40436 4361 31 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4361 32 , , , 40436 4361 33 but but CC 40436 4361 34 to to IN 40436 4361 35 something something NN 40436 4361 36 else else RB 40436 4361 37 ? ? . 40436 4362 1 Or or CC 40436 4362 2 is be VBZ 40436 4362 3 this this DT 40436 4362 4 true true JJ 40436 4362 5 only only RB 40436 4362 6 of of IN 40436 4362 7 some some DT 40436 4362 8 things thing NNS 40436 4362 9 and and CC 40436 4362 10 not not RB 40436 4362 11 of of IN 40436 4362 12 all all DT 40436 4362 13 -- -- : 40436 4362 14 so so IN 40436 4362 15 that that IN 40436 4362 16 cognition cognition NN 40436 4362 17 may may MD 40436 4362 18 be be VB 40436 4362 19 something something NN 40436 4362 20 in in IN 40436 4362 21 the the DT 40436 4362 22 latter latter JJ 40436 4362 23 category category NN 40436 4362 24 ? ? . 40436 4363 1 This this DT 40436 4363 2 is be VBZ 40436 4363 3 an an DT 40436 4363 4 embarrassing embarrassing JJ 40436 4363 5 question question NN 40436 4363 6 , , , 40436 4363 7 which which WDT 40436 4363 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4363 9 do do VBP 40436 4363 10 not not RB 40436 4363 11 feel feel VB 40436 4363 12 qualified qualified JJ 40436 4363 13 to to TO 40436 4363 14 decide decide VB 40436 4363 15 : : : 40436 4363 16 neither neither CC 40436 4363 17 the the DT 40436 4363 18 general general JJ 40436 4363 19 question question NN 40436 4363 20 , , , 40436 4363 21 whether whether IN 40436 4363 22 there there EX 40436 4363 23 be be VB 40436 4363 24 any any DT 40436 4363 25 cases case NNS 40436 4363 26 of of IN 40436 4363 27 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 4363 28 properties property NNS 40436 4363 29 having have VBG 40436 4363 30 no no DT 40436 4363 31 reference reference NN 40436 4363 32 to to IN 40436 4363 33 any any DT 40436 4363 34 thing thing NN 40436 4363 35 beyond beyond IN 40436 4363 36 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 4363 37 , , , 40436 4363 38 and and CC 40436 4363 39 therefore therefore RB 40436 4363 40 not not RB 40436 4363 41 relative relative JJ 40436 4363 42 , , , 40436 4363 43 but but CC 40436 4363 44 absolute absolute JJ 40436 4363 45 -- -- : 40436 4363 46 nor nor CC 40436 4363 47 the the DT 40436 4363 48 particular particular JJ 40436 4363 49 question question NN 40436 4363 50 , , , 40436 4363 51 whether whether IN 40436 4363 52 cognition cognition NN 40436 4363 53 be be VBP 40436 4363 54 one one CD 40436 4363 55 of of IN 40436 4363 56 those those DT 40436 4363 57 cases case NNS 40436 4363 58 , , , 40436 4363 59 implying imply VBG 40436 4363 60 no no DT 40436 4363 61 separate separate JJ 40436 4363 62 _ _ NNP 40436 4363 63 cognitum cognitum NN 40436 4363 64 _ _ NNP 40436 4363 65 , , , 40436 4363 66 but but CC 40436 4363 67 being be VBG 40436 4363 68 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4363 69 both both DT 40436 4363 70 _ _ NNP 40436 4363 71 relatum relatum NN 40436 4363 72 _ _ NNP 40436 4363 73 and and CC 40436 4363 74 _ _ NNP 40436 4363 75 correlatum_--cognition correlatum_--cognition NN 40436 4363 76 of of IN 40436 4363 77 cognition cognition NN 40436 4363 78 . . . 40436 4364 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4364 2 18 18 CD 40436 4364 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4364 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4364 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4364 6 18 18 CD 40436 4364 7 : : : 40436 4364 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4364 9 , , , 40436 4364 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4364 11 . . . 40436 4365 1 168 168 CD 40436 4365 2 - - SYM 40436 4365 3 169 169 CD 40436 4365 4 . . . 40436 4366 1 169 169 CD 40436 4366 2 A a NN 40436 4366 3 : : : 40436 4366 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4366 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4366 6 : : : 40436 4366 7 mega mega NNP 40436 4366 8 / / SYM 40436 4366 9 lou lou NNP 40436 4366 10 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 4366 11 tinos tinos NNP 40436 4366 12 a)ndro\s a)ndro\s NNP 40436 4366 13 dei= dei= NNP 40436 4366 14 , , , 40436 4366 15 o(/stis o(/stis NNP 40436 4366 16 tou tou NNP 40436 4366 17 = = NNP 40436 4366 18 to to IN 40436 4366 19 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 4366 20 pa pa NNP 40436 4366 21 / / SYM 40436 4366 22 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 4366 23 i(kanô i(kanô VBZ 40436 4366 24 = = NFP 40436 4366 25 s s NNP 40436 4366 26 diairê diairê NNP 40436 4366 27 / / SYM 40436 4366 28 setai setai NN 40436 4366 29 , , , 40436 4366 30 po po NNP 40436 4366 31 / / SYM 40436 4366 32 teron teron NNP 40436 4366 33 ou)de\n ou)de\n NNPS 40436 4366 34 tô tô NNP 40436 4366 35 = = SYM 40436 4366 36 n n NN 40436 4366 37 o)/ntôn o)/ntôn NN 40436 4366 38 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 4366 39 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 4366 40 du du NNP 40436 4366 41 / / SYM 40436 4366 42 namin namin NN 40436 4366 43 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 4366 44 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 4366 45 e(auto\ e(auto\ NNP 40436 4366 46 pe pe NN 40436 4366 47 / / SYM 40436 4366 48 phuken phuken VBN 40436 4366 49 e)/chein e)/chein NNP 40436 4366 50 , , , 40436 4366 51 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 4366 52 pro\s pro\s NN 40436 4366 53 a)llo\--ê)\ a)llo\--ê)\ NNP 40436 4366 54 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 4366 55 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4366 56 , , , 40436 4366 57 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 4366 58 d d NN 40436 4366 59 ' ' '' 40436 4366 60 ou)/ ou)/ RB 40436 4366 61 ; ; : 40436 4366 62 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4366 63 ei ei NNP 40436 4366 64 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4366 65 e)/stin e)/stin NFP 40436 4366 66 au(= au(= . 40436 4366 67 a(/tina a(/tina NNP 40436 4366 68 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 4366 69 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 4366 70 e(auta\ e(auta\ CD 40436 4366 71 e)/chei e)/chei NN 40436 4366 72 , , , 40436 4366 73 a)=r a)=r UH 40436 4366 74 ' ' '' 40436 4366 75 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4366 76 tou tou NNP 40436 4366 77 / / SYM 40436 4366 78 tois tois NNP 40436 4366 79 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 4366 80 e)pistê e)pistê . 40436 4366 81 / / SYM 40436 4366 82 mê mê NNP 40436 4366 83 , , , 40436 4366 84 ê(\n ê(\n NNP 40436 4366 85 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4366 86 ê(mei ê(mei NNP 40436 4366 87 = = NFP 40436 4366 88 s s FW 40436 4366 89 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4366 90 / / SYM 40436 4366 91 nên nên NNP 40436 4366 92 phame\n phame\n NNP 40436 4366 93 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4366 94 . . . 40436 4367 1 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 4367 2 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4367 3 ou ou NNP 40436 4367 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4367 5 pisteu pisteu NN 40436 4367 6 / / SYM 40436 4367 7 ô ô NN 40436 4367 8 e)mautô=| e)mautô=| ADD 40436 4367 9 i(kano\s i(kano\s NNP 40436 4367 10 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 4367 11 tau tau NNP 40436 4367 12 = = SYM 40436 4367 13 ta ta NNP 40436 4367 14 diele diele NNP 40436 4367 15 / / SYM 40436 4367 16 sthtai sthtai NNP 40436 4367 17 . . . 40436 4367 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4367 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4368 1 But but CC 40436 4368 2 even even RB 40436 4368 3 if if IN 40436 4368 4 cognition cognition NN 40436 4368 5 of of IN 40436 4368 6 cognition cognition NN 40436 4368 7 be be VBP 40436 4368 8 possible possible JJ 40436 4368 9 , , , 40436 4368 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4368 11 shall shall MD 40436 4368 12 not not RB 40436 4368 13 admit admit VB 40436 4368 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4368 15 as as IN 40436 4368 16 an an DT 40436 4368 17 explanation explanation NN 40436 4368 18 of of IN 40436 4368 19 what what WDT 40436 4368 20 temperance temperance NN 40436 4368 21 is be VBZ 40436 4368 22 , , , 40436 4368 23 until until IN 40436 4368 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4368 25 have have VBP 40436 4368 26 satisfied satisfy VBN 40436 4368 27 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 4368 28 that that IN 40436 4368 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4368 30 is be VBZ 40436 4368 31 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 4368 32 . . . 40436 4369 1 For for IN 40436 4369 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4369 3 have have VBP 40436 4369 4 a a DT 40436 4369 5 presentiment presentiment NN 40436 4369 6 that that IN 40436 4369 7 temperance temperance NN 40436 4369 8 must must MD 40436 4369 9 be be VB 40436 4369 10 something something NN 40436 4369 11 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 4369 12 and and CC 40436 4369 13 good good JJ 40436 4369 14 . . . 40436 4370 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4370 2 19 19 CD 40436 4370 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4370 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4370 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4370 6 19 19 CD 40436 4370 7 : : : 40436 4370 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4370 9 , , , 40436 4370 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4370 11 . . . 40436 4371 1 169 169 CD 40436 4371 2 B. B. NNP 40436 4372 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4372 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4372 3 : : : 40436 4372 4 ô)phelimo ô)phelimo ADD 40436 4372 5 / / SYM 40436 4372 6 n n CC 40436 4372 7 ti ti IN 40436 4372 8 ka)gatho\n ka)gatho\n NNP 40436 4372 9 manteu manteu NN 40436 4372 10 / / SYM 40436 4372 11 omai omai NNP 40436 4372 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 4372 13 . . . 40436 4372 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4372 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4373 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4373 2 Side side NN 40436 4373 3 - - HYPH 40436 4373 4 note note NN 40436 4373 5 : : : 40436 4373 6 Even even RB 40436 4373 7 if if IN 40436 4373 8 cognition cognition NN 40436 4373 9 of of IN 40436 4373 10 cognition cognition NN 40436 4373 11 were be VBD 40436 4373 12 possible possible JJ 40436 4373 13 , , , 40436 4373 14 cognition cognition NN 40436 4373 15 of of IN 40436 4373 16 non non JJ 40436 4373 17 - - NN 40436 4373 18 cognition cognition NN 40436 4373 19 would would MD 40436 4373 20 be be VB 40436 4373 21 impossible impossible JJ 40436 4373 22 . . . 40436 4374 1 A a DT 40436 4374 2 man man NN 40436 4374 3 may may MD 40436 4374 4 know know VB 40436 4374 5 what what WP 40436 4374 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4374 7 knows know VBZ 40436 4374 8 , , , 40436 4374 9 but but CC 40436 4374 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4374 11 can can MD 40436 4374 12 not not RB 40436 4374 13 know know VB 40436 4374 14 what what WP 40436 4374 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4374 16 is be VBZ 40436 4374 17 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 4374 18 of of IN 40436 4374 19 . . . 40436 4375 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4375 2 knows know VBZ 40436 4375 3 the the DT 40436 4375 4 fact fact NN 40436 4375 5 _ _ IN 40436 4375 6 that that IN 40436 4375 7 _ _ NNP 40436 4375 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4375 9 knows know VBZ 40436 4375 10 : : : 40436 4375 11 but but CC 40436 4375 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4375 13 does do VBZ 40436 4375 14 not not RB 40436 4375 15 know know VB 40436 4375 16 how how WRB 40436 4375 17 much much JJ 40436 4375 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4375 19 knows know VBZ 40436 4375 20 , , , 40436 4375 21 and and CC 40436 4375 22 how how WRB 40436 4375 23 much much JJ 40436 4375 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4375 25 does do VBZ 40436 4375 26 not not RB 40436 4375 27 know know VB 40436 4375 28 . . . 40436 4375 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4376 1 Let let VB 40436 4376 2 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4376 3 concede concede VB 40436 4376 4 for for IN 40436 4376 5 the the DT 40436 4376 6 present present JJ 40436 4376 7 discussion discussion NN 40436 4376 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4376 9 continues continue VBZ 40436 4376 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4376 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4376 12 that that DT 40436 4376 13 cognition cognition NN 40436 4376 14 of of IN 40436 4376 15 cognition cognition NN 40436 4376 16 is be VBZ 40436 4376 17 possible possible JJ 40436 4376 18 . . . 40436 4377 1 Still still RB 40436 4377 2 how how WRB 40436 4377 3 does do VBZ 40436 4377 4 this this DT 40436 4377 5 prove prove VB 40436 4377 6 that that IN 40436 4377 7 there there EX 40436 4377 8 can can MD 40436 4377 9 be be VB 40436 4377 10 cognition cognition NN 40436 4377 11 of of IN 40436 4377 12 non non JJ 40436 4377 13 - - JJ 40436 4377 14 cognition cognition JJ 40436 4377 15 ? ? . 40436 4378 1 that that IN 40436 4378 2 a a DT 40436 4378 3 man man NN 40436 4378 4 can can MD 40436 4378 5 know know VB 40436 4378 6 both both DT 40436 4378 7 what what WP 40436 4378 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4378 9 knows know VBZ 40436 4378 10 and and CC 40436 4378 11 what what WP 40436 4378 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4378 13 does do VBZ 40436 4378 14 not not RB 40436 4378 15 know know VB 40436 4378 16 ? ? . 40436 4379 1 For for IN 40436 4379 2 this this DT 40436 4379 3 is be VBZ 40436 4379 4 what what WP 40436 4379 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4379 6 declared declare VBD 40436 4379 7 self self NN 40436 4379 8 - - HYPH 40436 4379 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4379 10 and and CC 40436 4379 11 temperance temperance NN 40436 4379 12 to to TO 40436 4379 13 be be VB 40436 4379 14 . . . 40436 4380 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4380 2 20 20 CD 40436 4380 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4380 4 To to TO 40436 4380 5 have have VB 40436 4380 6 cognition cognition NN 40436 4380 7 of of IN 40436 4380 8 cognition cognition NN 40436 4380 9 is be VBZ 40436 4380 10 one one CD 40436 4380 11 thing thing NN 40436 4380 12 : : : 40436 4380 13 to to TO 40436 4380 14 have have VB 40436 4380 15 cognition cognition NN 40436 4380 16 of of IN 40436 4380 17 non non JJ 40436 4380 18 - - JJ 40436 4380 19 cognition cognition NN 40436 4380 20 is be VBZ 40436 4380 21 a a DT 40436 4380 22 different different JJ 40436 4380 23 thing thing NN 40436 4380 24 , , , 40436 4380 25 not not RB 40436 4380 26 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 4380 27 connected connect VBN 40436 4380 28 with with IN 40436 4380 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4380 30 . . . 40436 4381 1 If if IN 40436 4381 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4381 3 have have VBP 40436 4381 4 cognition cognition NN 40436 4381 5 of of IN 40436 4381 6 cognition cognition NN 40436 4381 7 , , , 40436 4381 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4381 9 will will MD 40436 4381 10 be be VB 40436 4381 11 enabled enable VBN 40436 4381 12 to to TO 40436 4381 13 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 4381 14 that that DT 40436 4381 15 which which WDT 40436 4381 16 is be VBZ 40436 4381 17 cognition cognition NN 40436 4381 18 from from IN 40436 4381 19 that that DT 40436 4381 20 which which WDT 40436 4381 21 is be VBZ 40436 4381 22 not not RB 40436 4381 23 -- -- : 40436 4381 24 but but CC 40436 4381 25 no no DT 40436 4381 26 more more JJR 40436 4381 27 . . . 40436 4382 1 Now now RB 40436 4382 2 the the DT 40436 4382 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4382 4 or or CC 40436 4382 5 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4382 6 of of IN 40436 4382 7 the the DT 40436 4382 8 matter matter NN 40436 4382 9 of of IN 40436 4382 10 health health NN 40436 4382 11 is be VBZ 40436 4382 12 known know VBN 40436 4382 13 by by IN 40436 4382 14 medical medical JJ 40436 4382 15 science science NN 40436 4382 16 : : : 40436 4382 17 that that DT 40436 4382 18 of of IN 40436 4382 19 justice justice NN 40436 4382 20 known know VBN 40436 4382 21 by by IN 40436 4382 22 political political JJ 40436 4382 23 science science NN 40436 4382 24 . . . 40436 4383 1 The the DT 40436 4383 2 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4383 3 of of IN 40436 4383 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4383 5 simply simply RB 40436 4383 6 -- -- : 40436 4383 7 cognition cognition NN 40436 4383 8 of of IN 40436 4383 9 cognition cognition NN 40436 4383 10 -- -- : 40436 4383 11 is be VBZ 40436 4383 12 different different JJ 40436 4383 13 from from IN 40436 4383 14 both both DT 40436 4383 15 . . . 40436 4384 1 The the DT 40436 4384 2 person person NN 40436 4384 3 who who WP 40436 4384 4 possesses possess VBZ 40436 4384 5 this this DT 40436 4384 6 last last JJ 40436 4384 7 only only RB 40436 4384 8 , , , 40436 4384 9 without without IN 40436 4384 10 knowing know VBG 40436 4384 11 either either CC 40436 4384 12 medicine medicine NN 40436 4384 13 or or CC 40436 4384 14 politics politic NNS 40436 4384 15 , , , 40436 4384 16 will will MD 40436 4384 17 become become VB 40436 4384 18 aware aware JJ 40436 4384 19 that that IN 40436 4384 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4384 21 knows know VBZ 40436 4384 22 something something NN 40436 4384 23 and and CC 40436 4384 24 possesses possess VBZ 40436 4384 25 some some DT 40436 4384 26 sort sort NN 40436 4384 27 of of IN 40436 4384 28 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4384 29 , , , 40436 4384 30 and and CC 40436 4384 31 will will MD 40436 4384 32 be be VB 40436 4384 33 able able JJ 40436 4384 34 to to TO 40436 4384 35 verify verify VB 40436 4384 36 so so RB 40436 4384 37 much much RB 40436 4384 38 with with IN 40436 4384 39 regard regard NN 40436 4384 40 to to IN 40436 4384 41 others other NNS 40436 4384 42 . . . 40436 4385 1 But but CC 40436 4385 2 _ _ NNP 40436 4385 3 what what WP 40436 4385 4 _ _ IN 40436 4385 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4385 6 is be VBZ 40436 4385 7 that that IN 40436 4385 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4385 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4385 10 knows know VBZ 40436 4385 11 , , , 40436 4385 12 or or CC 40436 4385 13 that that IN 40436 4385 14 others other NNS 40436 4385 15 know know VBP 40436 4385 16 , , , 40436 4385 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4385 18 will will MD 40436 4385 19 not not RB 40436 4385 20 thereby thereby RB 40436 4385 21 be be VB 40436 4385 22 enabled enable VBN 40436 4385 23 to to TO 40436 4385 24 find find VB 40436 4385 25 out out RP 40436 4385 26 : : : 40436 4385 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4385 28 will will MD 40436 4385 29 not not RB 40436 4385 30 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 4385 31 whether whether IN 40436 4385 32 that that DT 40436 4385 33 which which WDT 40436 4385 34 is be VBZ 40436 4385 35 known know VBN 40436 4385 36 belong belong NN 40436 4385 37 to to IN 40436 4385 38 physiology physiology NN 40436 4385 39 or or CC 40436 4385 40 to to IN 40436 4385 41 politics politic NNS 40436 4385 42 ; ; : 40436 4385 43 to to TO 40436 4385 44 do do VB 40436 4385 45 this this DT 40436 4385 46 , , , 40436 4385 47 special special JJ 40436 4385 48 acquirements acquirement NNS 40436 4385 49 are be VBP 40436 4385 50 needed need VBN 40436 4385 51 . . . 40436 4386 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4386 2 , , , 40436 4386 3 a a DT 40436 4386 4 temperate temperate NN 40436 4386 5 man man NN 40436 4386 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 4386 7 , , , 40436 4386 8 as as IN 40436 4386 9 such such JJ 40436 4386 10 , , , 40436 4386 11 do do VB 40436 4386 12 not not RB 40436 4386 13 know know VB 40436 4386 14 _ _ IN 40436 4386 15 what what WP 40436 4386 16 _ _ NNP 40436 4386 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4386 18 know know VBP 40436 4386 19 and and CC 40436 4386 20 _ _ VBP 40436 4386 21 what what WP 40436 4386 22 _ _ NNP 40436 4386 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4386 24 do do VBP 40436 4386 25 not not RB 40436 4386 26 know know VB 40436 4386 27 ; ; : 40436 4386 28 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4386 29 know know VBP 40436 4386 30 the the DT 40436 4386 31 bare bare JJ 40436 4386 32 fact fact NN 40436 4386 33 , , , 40436 4386 34 _ _ NNP 40436 4386 35 that that IN 40436 4386 36 _ _ NNP 40436 4386 37 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4386 38 know know VBP 40436 4386 39 and and CC 40436 4386 40 _ _ NNP 40436 4386 41 that that IN 40436 4386 42 _ _ NNP 40436 4386 43 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4386 44 do do VBP 40436 4386 45 not not RB 40436 4386 46 know know VB 40436 4386 47 . . . 40436 4387 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4387 2 will will MD 40436 4387 3 not not RB 40436 4387 4 be be VB 40436 4387 5 competent competent JJ 40436 4387 6 to to TO 40436 4387 7 cross cross VB 40436 4387 8 - - VB 40436 4387 9 examine examine VB 40436 4387 10 any any DT 40436 4387 11 one one NN 40436 4387 12 who who WP 40436 4387 13 professes profess VBZ 40436 4387 14 to to TO 40436 4387 15 know know VB 40436 4387 16 medicine medicine NN 40436 4387 17 or or CC 40436 4387 18 any any DT 40436 4387 19 other other JJ 40436 4387 20 particular particular JJ 40436 4387 21 subject subject NN 40436 4387 22 , , , 40436 4387 23 so so IN 40436 4387 24 as as IN 40436 4387 25 to to TO 40436 4387 26 ascertain ascertain VB 40436 4387 27 whether whether IN 40436 4387 28 the the DT 40436 4387 29 man man NN 40436 4387 30 really really RB 40436 4387 31 possesses possess VBZ 40436 4387 32 what what WP 40436 4387 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4387 34 pretends pretend VBZ 40436 4387 35 to to TO 40436 4387 36 possess possess VB 40436 4387 37 . . . 40436 4388 1 There there EX 40436 4388 2 will will MD 40436 4388 3 be be VB 40436 4388 4 no no DT 40436 4388 5 point point NN 40436 4388 6 in in IN 40436 4388 7 common common JJ 40436 4388 8 between between IN 40436 4388 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4388 10 and and CC 40436 4388 11 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4388 12 . . . 40436 4389 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4389 2 , , , 40436 4389 3 as as IN 40436 4389 4 a a DT 40436 4389 5 temperate temperate NN 40436 4389 6 man man NN 40436 4389 7 , , , 40436 4389 8 possess possess VB 40436 4389 9 cognition cognition NN 40436 4389 10 of of IN 40436 4389 11 cognition cognition NN 40436 4389 12 , , , 40436 4389 13 but but CC 40436 4389 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4389 15 do do VBP 40436 4389 16 not not RB 40436 4389 17 know know VB 40436 4389 18 any any DT 40436 4389 19 special special JJ 40436 4389 20 _ _ NNP 40436 4389 21 cognitum cognitum NN 40436 4389 22 _ _ NNP 40436 4389 23 : : : 40436 4389 24 the the DT 40436 4389 25 special special JJ 40436 4389 26 man man NN 40436 4389 27 knows know VBZ 40436 4389 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4389 29 own own JJ 40436 4389 30 special special JJ 40436 4389 31 _ _ NNP 40436 4389 32 cognitum cognitum NN 40436 4389 33 _ _ NNP 40436 4389 34 but but CC 40436 4389 35 is be VBZ 40436 4389 36 a a DT 40436 4389 37 stranger stranger NN 40436 4389 38 to to IN 40436 4389 39 cognition cognition NN 40436 4389 40 generally generally RB 40436 4389 41 . . . 40436 4390 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4390 2 can can MD 40436 4390 3 not not RB 40436 4390 4 question question VB 40436 4390 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4390 6 , , , 40436 4390 7 nor nor CC 40436 4390 8 criticise criticise VB 40436 4390 9 what what WP 40436 4390 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4390 11 says say VBZ 40436 4390 12 or or CC 40436 4390 13 performs perform VBZ 40436 4390 14 , , , 40436 4390 15 in in IN 40436 4390 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4390 17 own own JJ 40436 4390 18 specialty specialty NN 40436 4390 19 -- -- : 40436 4390 20 for for IN 40436 4390 21 of of IN 40436 4390 22 that that DT 40436 4390 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4390 24 are be VBP 40436 4390 25 ignorant:--no ignorant:--no VBG 40436 4390 26 one one PRP 40436 4390 27 can can MD 40436 4390 28 do do VB 40436 4390 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4390 30 except except IN 40436 4390 31 some some DT 40436 4390 32 fellow fellow NN 40436 4390 33 _ _ NNP 40436 4390 34 expert expert NN 40436 4390 35 _ _ NNP 40436 4390 36 . . . 40436 4391 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4391 2 can can MD 40436 4391 3 ascertain ascertain VB 40436 4391 4 that that IN 40436 4391 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4391 6 possesses possess VBZ 40436 4391 7 some some DT 40436 4391 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4391 9 : : : 40436 4391 10 but but CC 40436 4391 11 whether whether IN 40436 4391 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4391 13 possesses possess VBZ 40436 4391 14 that that IN 40436 4391 15 particular particular JJ 40436 4391 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4391 17 to to TO 40436 4391 18 which which WDT 40436 4391 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4391 20 lays lay VBZ 40436 4391 21 claim claim NN 40436 4391 22 , , , 40436 4391 23 or or CC 40436 4391 24 whether whether IN 40436 4391 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4391 26 falsely falsely RB 40436 4391 27 pretends pretend VBZ 40436 4391 28 to to IN 40436 4391 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4391 30 , , , 40436 4391 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4391 32 can can MD 40436 4391 33 not not RB 40436 4391 34 ascertain:--since ascertain:--since VB 40436 4391 35 , , , 40436 4391 36 as as IN 40436 4391 37 a a DT 40436 4391 38 temperate temperate NN 40436 4391 39 man man NN 40436 4391 40 , , , 40436 4391 41 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4391 42 know know VBP 40436 4391 43 only only RB 40436 4391 44 cognition cognition NN 40436 4391 45 and and CC 40436 4391 46 non non JJ 40436 4391 47 - - JJ 40436 4391 48 cognition cognition JJ 40436 4391 49 generally generally RB 40436 4391 50 . . . 40436 4392 1 To to TO 40436 4392 2 ascertain ascertain VB 40436 4392 3 this this DT 40436 4392 4 point point NN 40436 4392 5 , , , 40436 4392 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4392 7 must must MD 40436 4392 8 be be VB 40436 4392 9 not not RB 40436 4392 10 only only RB 40436 4392 11 a a DT 40436 4392 12 temperate temperate NN 40436 4392 13 man man NN 40436 4392 14 , , , 40436 4392 15 but but CC 40436 4392 16 a a DT 40436 4392 17 man man NN 40436 4392 18 of of IN 40436 4392 19 special special JJ 40436 4392 20 cognition cognition NN 40436 4392 21 besides besides RB 40436 4392 22 . . . 40436 4393 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4393 2 21 21 CD 40436 4393 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4393 4 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4393 5 can can MD 40436 4393 6 question question VB 40436 4393 7 and and CC 40436 4393 8 test test VB 40436 4393 9 no no DT 40436 4393 10 one one NN 40436 4393 11 , , , 40436 4393 12 except except IN 40436 4393 13 another another DT 40436 4393 14 temperate temperate NN 40436 4393 15 man man NN 40436 4393 16 like like IN 40436 4393 17 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 4393 18 . . . 40436 4394 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4394 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4394 3 20 20 CD 40436 4394 4 : : : 40436 4394 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4394 6 , , , 40436 4394 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4394 8 . . . 40436 4395 1 169 169 CD 40436 4395 2 D. D. NNP 40436 4395 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4395 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4395 5 : : : 40436 4395 6 nu nu NNP 40436 4395 7 = = SYM 40436 4395 8 n n NNP 40436 4395 9 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4395 10 tou tou NNP 40436 4395 11 = = SYM 40436 4395 12 to to IN 40436 4395 13 xugchôrê xugchôrê NNP 40436 4395 14 / / SYM 40436 4395 15 sômen sômen NNP 40436 4395 16 , , , 40436 4395 17 dunato\n dunato\n ADD 40436 4395 18 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 4395 19 gene gene NN 40436 4395 20 / / SYM 40436 4395 21 sthai sthai NNP 40436 4395 22 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4395 23 / / SYM 40436 4395 24 mên mên NNP 40436 4395 25 e)pistê e)pistê NNS 40436 4395 26 / / SYM 40436 4395 27 mês mês JJ 40436 4395 28 -- -- : 40436 4395 29 i)/thi i)/thi NNP 40436 4395 30 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4395 31 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 4395 32 , , , 40436 4395 33 ei ei NNP 40436 4395 34 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4395 35 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 4395 36 , , , 40436 4395 37 ti ti NNP 40436 4395 38 ma ma NNP 40436 4395 39 / / SYM 40436 4395 40 lista lista NNP 40436 4395 41 dunato\n dunato\n ADD 40436 4395 42 tou tou NNP 40436 4395 43 = = NNPS 40436 4395 44 to to IN 40436 4395 45 , , , 40436 4395 46 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 4395 47 ma ma NNP 40436 4395 48 = = SYM 40436 4395 49 llon llon NNP 40436 4395 50 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 4395 51 / / SYM 40436 4395 52 n n NNP 40436 4395 53 te/ te/ CD 40436 4395 54 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 4395 55 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 4395 56 / / SYM 40436 4395 57 nai nai NNP 40436 4395 58 a(/ a(/ NNP 40436 4395 59 te/ te/ CD 40436 4395 60 tis tis NN 40436 4395 61 oi)=de oi)=de NNP 40436 4395 62 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4395 63 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 4395 64 mê/ mê/ NNP 40436 4395 65 ? ? . 40436 4396 1 tou tou NNP 40436 4396 2 = = VBZ 40436 4396 3 to to TO 40436 4396 4 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4396 5 dê dê NN 40436 4396 6 / / SYM 40436 4396 7 pou pou NNP 40436 4396 8 e)/phamen e)/phamen NNP 40436 4396 9 ei)=nai ei)=nai CC 40436 4396 10 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4396 11 gignô gignô NNP 40436 4396 12 / / , 40436 4396 13 skein skein NN 40436 4396 14 au(to\n au(to\n NNP 40436 4396 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4396 16 sôphronei sôphronei NNP 40436 4396 17 = = SYM 40436 4396 18 n n NNP 40436 4396 19 . . . 40436 4396 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4396 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4397 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4397 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4397 3 21 21 CD 40436 4397 4 : : : 40436 4397 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4397 6 , , , 40436 4397 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4397 8 . . . 40436 4398 1 170 170 CD 40436 4398 2 - - SYM 40436 4398 3 171 171 CD 40436 4398 4 . . . 40436 4399 1 171 171 CD 40436 4399 2 C c NN 40436 4399 3 : : : 40436 4399 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4399 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4399 6 : : : 40436 4399 7 Panto\s Panto\s NNP 40436 4399 8 a)/ra a)/ra VBZ 40436 4399 9 ma ma NNP 40436 4399 10 = = SYM 40436 4399 11 llon llon NNP 40436 4399 12 , , , 40436 4399 13 ei ei NNP 40436 4399 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4399 15 ê ê NNP 40436 4399 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4399 17 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4399 18 / / SYM 40436 4399 19 nê nê NNP 40436 4399 20 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4399 21 / / SYM 40436 4399 22 mês mês NNP 40436 4399 23 e)pisê e)pisê NNP 40436 4399 24 / / SYM 40436 4399 25 mê mê NNP 40436 4399 26 mo mo NNP 40436 4399 27 / / SYM 40436 4399 28 non non NNP 40436 4399 29 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 4399 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4399 31 a)nepistêmosu a)nepistêmosu NNP 40436 4399 32 / / SYM 40436 4399 33 nês nês NNP 40436 4399 34 , , , 40436 4399 35 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 4399 36 i)atro\n i)atro\n NNP 40436 4399 37 diakri diakri NNP 40436 4399 38 = = SYM 40436 4399 39 nai nai NNP 40436 4399 40 oi(/a oi(/a NNP 40436 4399 41 te te NNP 40436 4399 42 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 4399 43 e)pista e)pista NNP 40436 4399 44 / / SYM 40436 4399 45 menon menon NNP 40436 4399 46 ta\ ta\ NNPS 40436 4399 47 tê tê NNP 40436 4399 48 = = SYM 40436 4399 49 s s NNP 40436 4399 50 te te NNP 40436 4399 51 / / SYM 40436 4399 52 chnês chnês NNP 40436 4399 53 , , , 40436 4399 54 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 4399 55 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 4399 56 e)pista e)pista , 40436 4399 57 / / SYM 40436 4399 58 menon menon NNP 40436 4399 59 prospoiou prospoiou NNP 40436 4399 60 / / SYM 40436 4399 61 menon menon NNP 40436 4399 62 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4399 63 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 4399 64 oi)o oi)o NNP 40436 4399 65 / / SYM 40436 4399 66 menon menon NNP 40436 4399 67 , , , 40436 4399 68 ou)/te ou)/te XX 40436 4399 69 a)//lon a)//lon NNP 40436 4399 70 ou)de ou)de NNP 40436 4399 71 / / SYM 40436 4399 72 na na NN 40436 4399 73 tô tô NNP 40436 4399 74 = = SYM 40436 4399 75 n n CC 40436 4399 76 e)pistame e)pistame NNP 40436 4399 77 / / SYM 40436 4399 78 nôn nôn NNP 40436 4399 79 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4399 80 o(tiou o(tiou NNP 40436 4399 81 = = SYM 40436 4399 82 n n NNP 40436 4399 83 , , , 40436 4399 84 plê plê NNP 40436 4399 85 / / SYM 40436 4399 86 n n NNP 40436 4399 87 ge ge NNP 40436 4399 88 to\n to\n NNP 40436 4399 89 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 4399 90 o(mo o(mo NNP 40436 4399 91 / / SYM 40436 4399 92 technon technon NNP 40436 4399 93 , , , 40436 4399 94 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 4399 95 oi oi UH 40436 4399 96 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4399 97 a)/lloi a)/lloi NNP 40436 4399 98 dêmiourgoi/. dêmiourgoi/. NNP 40436 4399 99 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4399 100 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4400 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4400 2 Side side NN 40436 4400 3 - - HYPH 40436 4400 4 note note NN 40436 4400 5 : : : 40436 4400 6 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4400 7 , , , 40436 4400 8 therefore therefore RB 40436 4400 9 , , , 40436 4400 10 as as IN 40436 4400 11 thus thus RB 40436 4400 12 defined define VBN 40436 4400 13 , , , 40436 4400 14 would would MD 40436 4400 15 be be VB 40436 4400 16 of of IN 40436 4400 17 little little JJ 40436 4400 18 or or CC 40436 4400 19 no no DT 40436 4400 20 value value NN 40436 4400 21 . . . 40436 4400 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4401 1 But but CC 40436 4401 2 if if IN 40436 4401 3 this this DT 40436 4401 4 be be VB 40436 4401 5 all all DT 40436 4401 6 that that DT 40436 4401 7 temperance temperance NN 40436 4401 8 can can MD 40436 4401 9 do do VB 40436 4401 10 , , , 40436 4401 11 of of IN 40436 4401 12 what what WDT 40436 4401 13 use use NN 40436 4401 14 is be VBZ 40436 4401 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4401 16 to to IN 40436 4401 17 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4401 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4401 19 continues continue VBZ 40436 4401 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4401 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4401 22 ? ? . 40436 4402 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4402 2 is be VBZ 40436 4402 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 4402 4 a a DT 40436 4402 5 great great JJ 40436 4402 6 benefit benefit NN 40436 4402 7 to to TO 40436 4402 8 know know VB 40436 4402 9 how how WRB 40436 4402 10 much much RB 40436 4402 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4402 12 know know VBP 40436 4402 13 , , , 40436 4402 14 and and CC 40436 4402 15 how how WRB 40436 4402 16 much much JJ 40436 4402 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4402 18 do do VBP 40436 4402 19 not not RB 40436 4402 20 know know VB 40436 4402 21 : : : 40436 4402 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4402 23 is be VBZ 40436 4402 24 also also RB 40436 4402 25 a a DT 40436 4402 26 great great JJ 40436 4402 27 benefit benefit NN 40436 4402 28 to to TO 40436 4402 29 know know VB 40436 4402 30 respecting respect VBG 40436 4402 31 others other NNS 40436 4402 32 , , , 40436 4402 33 how how WRB 40436 4402 34 much much RB 40436 4402 35 _ _ NNP 40436 4402 36 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4402 37 _ _ NNP 40436 4402 38 know know VBP 40436 4402 39 , , , 40436 4402 40 and and CC 40436 4402 41 how how WRB 40436 4402 42 much much RB 40436 4402 43 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4402 44 do do VBP 40436 4402 45 not not RB 40436 4402 46 know know VB 40436 4402 47 . . . 40436 4403 1 If if IN 40436 4403 2 thus thus RB 40436 4403 3 instructed instruct VBN 40436 4403 4 , , , 40436 4403 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4403 6 should should MD 40436 4403 7 make make VB 40436 4403 8 fewer few JJR 40436 4403 9 mistakes mistake NNS 40436 4403 10 : : : 40436 4403 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4403 12 should should MD 40436 4403 13 do do VB 40436 4403 14 by by IN 40436 4403 15 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 4403 16 only only RB 40436 4403 17 what what WP 40436 4403 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4403 19 knew know VBD 40436 4403 20 how how WRB 40436 4403 21 to to IN 40436 4403 22 do,--we do,--we NNP 40436 4403 23 should should MD 40436 4403 24 commit commit VB 40436 4403 25 to to IN 40436 4403 26 others other NNS 40436 4403 27 that that IN 40436 4403 28 which which WDT 40436 4403 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4403 30 knew know VBD 40436 4403 31 how how WRB 40436 4403 32 to to TO 40436 4403 33 do do VB 40436 4403 34 , , , 40436 4403 35 and and CC 40436 4403 36 which which WDT 40436 4403 37 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4403 38 did do VBD 40436 4403 39 not not RB 40436 4403 40 know know VB 40436 4403 41 . . . 40436 4404 1 But but CC 40436 4404 2 temperance temperance NN 40436 4404 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4404 4 meaning mean VBG 40436 4404 5 thereby thereby RB 40436 4404 6 cognition cognition NN 40436 4404 7 of of IN 40436 4404 8 cognition cognition NN 40436 4404 9 and and CC 40436 4404 10 of of IN 40436 4404 11 non non JJ 40436 4404 12 - - JJ 40436 4404 13 cognition cognition JJ 40436 4404 14 generally generally RB 40436 4404 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4404 16 does do VBZ 40436 4404 17 not not RB 40436 4404 18 confer confer VB 40436 4404 19 such such JJ 40436 4404 20 instruction instruction NN 40436 4404 21 , , , 40436 4404 22 nor nor CC 40436 4404 23 have have VBP 40436 4404 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4404 25 found find VBN 40436 4404 26 any any DT 40436 4404 27 science science NN 40436 4404 28 which which WDT 40436 4404 29 does do VBZ 40436 4404 30 . . . 40436 4405 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4405 2 22 22 CD 40436 4405 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4405 4 How how WRB 40436 4405 5 temperance temperance NN 40436 4405 6 benefits benefit VBZ 40436 4405 7 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4405 8 , , , 40436 4405 9 does do VBZ 40436 4405 10 not not RB 40436 4405 11 yet yet RB 40436 4405 12 appear appear VB 40436 4405 13 . . . 40436 4406 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4406 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4406 3 22 22 CD 40436 4406 4 : : : 40436 4406 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4406 6 , , , 40436 4406 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4406 8 . . . 40436 4407 1 172 172 CD 40436 4407 2 A. a. NN 40436 4408 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4408 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4408 3 : : : 40436 4408 4 o(ra=|s o(ra=|s NN 40436 4408 5 , , , 40436 4408 6 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 4408 7 ou)damou= ou)damou= NNP 40436 4408 8 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4408 9 / / SYM 40436 4408 10 mê mê NNP 40436 4408 11 ou)demi ou)demi NNP 40436 4408 12 / / , 40436 4408 13 a a DT 40436 4408 14 toiau toiau NN 40436 4408 15 / / , 40436 4408 16 tê tê DT 40436 4408 17 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 4408 18 pe pe NNP 40436 4408 19 / / SYM 40436 4408 20 phantai phantai NNP 40436 4408 21 . . . 40436 4408 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4408 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4409 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4409 2 Side side NN 40436 4409 3 - - HYPH 40436 4409 4 note note NN 40436 4409 5 : : : 40436 4409 6 But but CC 40436 4409 7 even even RB 40436 4409 8 granting grant VBG 40436 4409 9 the the DT 40436 4409 10 possibility possibility NN 40436 4409 11 of of IN 40436 4409 12 that that DT 40436 4409 13 which which WDT 40436 4409 14 has have VBZ 40436 4409 15 just just RB 40436 4409 16 been be VBN 40436 4409 17 denied deny VBN 40436 4409 18 , , , 40436 4409 19 still still RB 40436 4409 20 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4409 21 would would MD 40436 4409 22 be be VB 40436 4409 23 of of IN 40436 4409 24 little little JJ 40436 4409 25 value value NN 40436 4409 26 . . . 40436 4410 1 Suppose suppose VB 40436 4410 2 that that IN 40436 4410 3 all all DT 40436 4410 4 separate separate JJ 40436 4410 5 work work NN 40436 4410 6 were be VBD 40436 4410 7 well well RB 40436 4410 8 performed perform VBN 40436 4410 9 , , , 40436 4410 10 by by IN 40436 4410 11 special special JJ 40436 4410 12 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 4410 13 , , , 40436 4410 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4410 15 should should MD 40436 4410 16 not not RB 40436 4410 17 attain attain VB 40436 4410 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4410 19 end end NN 40436 4410 20 -- -- : 40436 4410 21 Happiness happiness NN 40436 4410 22 . . . 40436 4410 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4411 1 But but CC 40436 4411 2 let let VB 40436 4411 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4411 4 even even RB 40436 4411 5 concede concede VB 40436 4411 6 -- -- : 40436 4411 7 what what WP 40436 4411 8 has have VBZ 40436 4411 9 been be VBN 40436 4411 10 just just RB 40436 4411 11 shown show VBN 40436 4411 12 to to TO 40436 4411 13 be be VB 40436 4411 14 impossible impossible JJ 40436 4411 15 -- -- : 40436 4411 16 that that IN 40436 4411 17 through through IN 40436 4411 18 temperance temperance NN 40436 4411 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4411 20 become become VBP 40436 4411 21 aware aware JJ 40436 4411 22 of of IN 40436 4411 23 what what WP 40436 4411 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4411 25 do do VBP 40436 4411 26 know know VB 40436 4411 27 and and CC 40436 4411 28 what what WP 40436 4411 29 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4411 30 do do VBP 40436 4411 31 not not RB 40436 4411 32 know know VB 40436 4411 33 . . . 40436 4412 1 Even even RB 40436 4412 2 upon upon IN 40436 4412 3 this this DT 40436 4412 4 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 4412 5 , , , 40436 4412 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4412 7 will will MD 40436 4412 8 be be VB 40436 4412 9 of of IN 40436 4412 10 little little JJ 40436 4412 11 service service NN 40436 4412 12 to to IN 40436 4412 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4412 14 . . . 40436 4413 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4413 2 have have VBP 40436 4413 3 been be VBN 40436 4413 4 too too RB 40436 4413 5 hasty hasty JJ 40436 4413 6 in in IN 40436 4413 7 conceding concede VBG 40436 4413 8 that that IN 40436 4413 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4413 10 would would MD 40436 4413 11 be be VB 40436 4413 12 a a DT 40436 4413 13 great great JJ 40436 4413 14 benefit benefit NN 40436 4413 15 if if IN 40436 4413 16 each each DT 40436 4413 17 of of IN 40436 4413 18 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4413 19 did do VBD 40436 4413 20 only only RB 40436 4413 21 what what WP 40436 4413 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4413 23 knew know VBD 40436 4413 24 , , , 40436 4413 25 committing commit VBG 40436 4413 26 to to IN 40436 4413 27 others other NNS 40436 4413 28 to to TO 40436 4413 29 do do VB 40436 4413 30 only only RB 40436 4413 31 what what WP 40436 4413 32 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4413 33 knew know VBD 40436 4413 34 . . . 40436 4414 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4414 2 have have VBP 40436 4414 3 an an DT 40436 4414 4 awkward awkward JJ 40436 4414 5 suspicion suspicion NN 40436 4414 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4414 7 continues continue VBZ 40436 4414 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4414 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4414 10 that that IN 40436 4414 11 after after RB 40436 4414 12 all all RB 40436 4414 13 , , , 40436 4414 14 this this DT 40436 4414 15 would would MD 40436 4414 16 be be VB 40436 4414 17 no no DT 40436 4414 18 great great JJ 40436 4414 19 benefit benefit NN 40436 4414 20 . . . 40436 4415 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4415 2 23 23 CD 40436 4415 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4415 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4415 5 is be VBZ 40436 4415 6 true true JJ 40436 4415 7 that that IN 40436 4415 8 upon upon IN 40436 4415 9 this this DT 40436 4415 10 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 4415 11 , , , 40436 4415 12 all all DT 40436 4415 13 operations operation NNS 40436 4415 14 in in IN 40436 4415 15 society society NN 40436 4415 16 would would MD 40436 4415 17 be be VB 40436 4415 18 conducted conduct VBN 40436 4415 19 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 4415 20 and and CC 40436 4415 21 skilfully skilfully RB 40436 4415 22 . . . 40436 4416 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4416 2 should should MD 40436 4416 3 have have VB 40436 4416 4 none none NN 40436 4416 5 but but CC 40436 4416 6 competent competent JJ 40436 4416 7 pilots pilot NNS 40436 4416 8 , , , 40436 4416 9 physicians physician NNS 40436 4416 10 , , , 40436 4416 11 generals general NNS 40436 4416 12 , , , 40436 4416 13 & & CC 40436 4416 14 c. c. NNP 40436 4416 15 , , , 40436 4416 16 acting act VBG 40436 4416 17 for for IN 40436 4416 18 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4416 19 , , , 40436 4416 20 each each DT 40436 4416 21 of of IN 40436 4416 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4416 23 doing do VBG 40436 4416 24 the the DT 40436 4416 25 work work NN 40436 4416 26 for for IN 40436 4416 27 which which WDT 40436 4416 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4416 29 was be VBD 40436 4416 30 fit fit JJ 40436 4416 31 . . . 40436 4417 1 The the DT 40436 4417 2 supervision supervision NN 40436 4417 3 exercised exercise VBN 40436 4417 4 by by IN 40436 4417 5 temperance temperance NN 40436 4417 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4417 7 in in IN 40436 4417 8 the the DT 40436 4417 9 sense sense NN 40436 4417 10 above above IN 40436 4417 11 defined define VBN 40436 4417 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4417 13 would would MD 40436 4417 14 guard guard VB 40436 4417 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4417 16 against against IN 40436 4417 17 all all DT 40436 4417 18 pretenders pretender NNS 40436 4417 19 . . . 40436 4418 1 Let let VB 40436 4418 2 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4418 3 even even RB 40436 4418 4 admit admit VB 40436 4418 5 that that IN 40436 4418 6 as as IN 40436 4418 7 to to IN 40436 4418 8 prediction prediction NN 40436 4418 9 of of IN 40436 4418 10 the the DT 40436 4418 11 future future NN 40436 4418 12 , , , 40436 4418 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4418 14 should should MD 40436 4418 15 have have VB 40436 4418 16 none none NN 40436 4418 17 but but CC 40436 4418 18 competent competent JJ 40436 4418 19 and and CC 40436 4418 20 genuine genuine JJ 40436 4418 21 prophets prophet NNS 40436 4418 22 to to TO 40436 4418 23 advise advise VB 40436 4418 24 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4418 25 ; ; : 40436 4418 26 charlatans charlatan NNS 40436 4418 27 being be VBG 40436 4418 28 kept keep VBN 40436 4418 29 aloof aloof JJ 40436 4418 30 by by IN 40436 4418 31 this this DT 40436 4418 32 same same JJ 40436 4418 33 supervision supervision NN 40436 4418 34 . . . 40436 4419 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4419 2 should should MD 40436 4419 3 thus thus RB 40436 4419 4 have have VB 40436 4419 5 every every DT 40436 4419 6 thing thing NN 40436 4419 7 done do VBN 40436 4419 8 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 4419 9 and and CC 40436 4419 10 in in IN 40436 4419 11 a a DT 40436 4419 12 workmanlike workmanlike JJ 40436 4419 13 manner manner NN 40436 4419 14 . . . 40436 4420 1 But but CC 40436 4420 2 should should MD 40436 4420 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4420 4 for for IN 40436 4420 5 that that DT 40436 4420 6 reason reason NN 40436 4420 7 do do VBP 40436 4420 8 well well RB 40436 4420 9 and and CC 40436 4420 10 be be VB 40436 4420 11 happy happy JJ 40436 4420 12 ? ? . 40436 4421 1 Can Can MD 40436 4421 2 that that WDT 40436 4421 3 be be VB 40436 4421 4 made make VBN 40436 4421 5 out out RP 40436 4421 6 , , , 40436 4421 7 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4421 8 ? ? . 40436 4422 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4422 2 24 24 CD 40436 4422 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4422 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4422 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4422 6 23 23 CD 40436 4422 7 : : : 40436 4422 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4422 9 , , , 40436 4422 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4422 11 . . . 40436 4423 1 172 172 CD 40436 4423 2 - - SYM 40436 4423 3 173 173 CD 40436 4423 4 . . . 40436 4423 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4424 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4424 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4424 3 24 24 CD 40436 4424 4 : : : 40436 4424 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4424 6 , , , 40436 4424 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4424 8 . . . 40436 4425 1 173 173 CD 40436 4425 2 C C NNP 40436 4425 3 - - HYPH 40436 4425 4 D. D. NNP 40436 4425 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4425 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4425 7 : : : 40436 4425 8 kateskeuasme kateskeuasme NNP 40436 4425 9 / / SYM 40436 4425 10 non non AFX 40436 4425 11 dê\ dê\ NN 40436 4425 12 ou(/tô ou(/tô IN 40436 4425 13 to\ to\ NN 40436 4425 14 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 4425 15 / / SYM 40436 4425 16 pinon pinon NNP 40436 4425 17 ge ge NNP 40436 4425 18 / / SYM 40436 4425 19 nos nos NNP 40436 4425 20 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 4425 21 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4425 22 e)pistêmo e)pistêmo NNP 40436 4425 23 / / SYM 40436 4425 24 nôs nôs NNP 40436 4425 25 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 4425 26 pra pra NNP 40436 4425 27 / / SYM 40436 4425 28 ttoi ttoi NNP 40436 4425 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4425 30 zô=|ê zô=|ê NNP 40436 4425 31 , , , 40436 4425 32 e(/pomai e(/pomai NNP 40436 4425 33 -- -- : 40436 4425 34 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 4425 35 d d NNP 40436 4425 36 ' ' POS 40436 4425 37 e)pistêmo e)pistêmo NNP 40436 4425 38 / / SYM 40436 4425 39 nôs nôs NNP 40436 4425 40 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 4425 41 pra pra NNP 40436 4425 42 / / SYM 40436 4425 43 ttontes ttontes NNPS 40436 4425 44 eu)= eu)= VBZ 40436 4425 45 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 4425 46 pra pra NNP 40436 4425 47 / / SYM 40436 4425 48 ttoimen ttoimen NNP 40436 4425 49 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4425 50 eu)daimonoi eu)daimonoi NNP 40436 4425 51 = = SYM 40436 4425 52 men man NNS 40436 4425 53 , , , 40436 4425 54 tou tou NNP 40436 4425 55 = = SYM 40436 4425 56 to to IN 40436 4425 57 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4425 58 ou(/pô ou(/pô NNP 40436 4425 59 duna duna NNP 40436 4425 60 / / SYM 40436 4425 61 metha metha NNP 40436 4425 62 mathei mathei NNP 40436 4425 63 = = SYM 40436 4425 64 n n NNP 40436 4425 65 , , , 40436 4425 66 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 4425 67 phi phi NNP 40436 4425 68 / / SYM 40436 4425 69 le le NNP 40436 4425 70 Kriti Kriti NNP 40436 4425 71 / / SYM 40436 4425 72 a a NNP 40436 4425 73 . . . 40436 4425 74 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4425 75 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4426 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4426 2 Side side NN 40436 4426 3 - - HYPH 40436 4426 4 note note NN 40436 4426 5 : : : 40436 4426 6 Which which WDT 40436 4426 7 of of IN 40436 4426 8 the the DT 40436 4426 9 varieties variety NNS 40436 4426 10 of of IN 40436 4426 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4426 12 contributes contribute VBZ 40436 4426 13 most most RBS 40436 4426 14 to to IN 40436 4426 15 well well RB 40436 4426 16 - - HYPH 40436 4426 17 doing doing NN 40436 4426 18 or or CC 40436 4426 19 happiness happiness NN 40436 4426 20 ? ? . 40436 4427 1 That that IN 40436 4427 2 by by IN 40436 4427 3 which which WDT 40436 4427 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4427 5 know know VBP 40436 4427 6 good good JJ 40436 4427 7 and and CC 40436 4427 8 evil evil NN 40436 4427 9 . . . 40436 4427 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4428 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4428 2 Krit._--You Krit._--You NNP 40436 4428 3 will will MD 40436 4428 4 hardly hardly RB 40436 4428 5 find find VB 40436 4428 6 the the DT 40436 4428 7 end end NN 40436 4428 8 of of IN 40436 4428 9 well well RB 40436 4428 10 - - HYPH 40436 4428 11 doing do VBG 40436 4428 12 anywhere anywhere RB 40436 4428 13 else else RB 40436 4428 14 , , , 40436 4428 15 if if IN 40436 4428 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4428 17 deny deny VBP 40436 4428 18 that that IN 40436 4428 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4428 20 follows follow VBZ 40436 4428 21 on on RP 40436 4428 22 doing do VBG 40436 4428 23 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 4428 24 or or CC 40436 4428 25 according accord VBG 40436 4428 26 to to IN 40436 4428 27 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4428 28 . . . 40436 4429 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4429 2 25 25 CD 40436 4429 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4429 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4429 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 4429 6 according accord VBG 40436 4429 7 to to IN 40436 4429 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4429 9 , , , 40436 4429 10 of of IN 40436 4429 11 _ _ NNP 40436 4429 12 what what WP 40436 4429 13 _ _ NNP 40436 4429 14 ? ? . 40436 4430 1 Of of IN 40436 4430 2 leather leather NN 40436 4430 3 - - HYPH 40436 4430 4 cutting cutting NN 40436 4430 5 , , , 40436 4430 6 brazen brazen NN 40436 4430 7 work work NN 40436 4430 8 , , , 40436 4430 9 wool wool NN 40436 4430 10 , , , 40436 4430 11 wood wood NN 40436 4430 12 , , , 40436 4430 13 & & CC 40436 4430 14 c. c. NNP 40436 4430 15 ? ? . 40436 4431 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4431 2 Krit._--No Krit._--No NNP 40436 4431 3 , , , 40436 4431 4 none none NN 40436 4431 5 of of IN 40436 4431 6 these these DT 40436 4431 7 . . . 40436 4432 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4432 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 4432 3 then then RB 40436 4432 4 , , , 40436 4432 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4432 6 see see VBP 40436 4432 7 , , , 40436 4432 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4432 9 do do VBP 40436 4432 10 not not RB 40436 4432 11 follow follow VB 40436 4432 12 out out RP 40436 4432 13 consistently consistently RB 40436 4432 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4432 15 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 4432 16 -- -- : 40436 4432 17 That that IN 40436 4432 18 the the DT 40436 4432 19 happy happy JJ 40436 4432 20 man man NN 40436 4432 21 is be VBZ 40436 4432 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4432 23 who who WP 40436 4432 24 lives live VBZ 40436 4432 25 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 4432 26 , , , 40436 4432 27 or or CC 40436 4432 28 according accord VBG 40436 4432 29 to to IN 40436 4432 30 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4432 31 . . . 40436 4433 1 For for IN 40436 4433 2 all all PDT 40436 4433 3 these these DT 40436 4433 4 men man NNS 40436 4433 5 live live VBP 40436 4433 6 according accord VBG 40436 4433 7 to to IN 40436 4433 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4433 9 , , , 40436 4433 10 and and CC 40436 4433 11 still still RB 40436 4433 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4433 13 do do VBP 40436 4433 14 not not RB 40436 4433 15 admit admit VB 40436 4433 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4433 17 to to TO 40436 4433 18 be be VB 40436 4433 19 happy happy JJ 40436 4433 20 . . . 40436 4434 1 Your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4434 2 definition definition NN 40436 4434 3 of of IN 40436 4434 4 happiness happiness NN 40436 4434 5 applies apply VBZ 40436 4434 6 only only RB 40436 4434 7 to to IN 40436 4434 8 some some DT 40436 4434 9 portion portion NN 40436 4434 10 of of IN 40436 4434 11 those those DT 40436 4434 12 who who WP 40436 4434 13 live live VBP 40436 4434 14 according accord VBG 40436 4434 15 to to IN 40436 4434 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4434 17 , , , 40436 4434 18 but but CC 40436 4434 19 not not RB 40436 4434 20 to to IN 40436 4434 21 all all DT 40436 4434 22 . . . 40436 4435 1 How how WRB 40436 4435 2 are be VBP 40436 4435 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4435 4 to to TO 40436 4435 5 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 4435 6 which which WDT 40436 4435 7 of of IN 40436 4435 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4435 9 ? ? . 40436 4436 1 Suppose suppose VB 40436 4436 2 a a DT 40436 4436 3 man man NN 40436 4436 4 to to TO 40436 4436 5 know know VB 40436 4436 6 every every DT 40436 4436 7 thing thing NN 40436 4436 8 past past NN 40436 4436 9 , , , 40436 4436 10 present present JJ 40436 4436 11 , , , 40436 4436 12 and and CC 40436 4436 13 future future NN 40436 4436 14 ; ; , 40436 4436 15 which which WDT 40436 4436 16 among among IN 40436 4436 17 the the DT 40436 4436 18 fractions fraction NNS 40436 4436 19 of of IN 40436 4436 20 such such JJ 40436 4436 21 omniscience omniscience NN 40436 4436 22 would would MD 40436 4436 23 contribute contribute VB 40436 4436 24 most most RBS 40436 4436 25 to to TO 40436 4436 26 make make VB 40436 4436 27 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4436 28 happy happy JJ 40436 4436 29 ? ? . 40436 4437 1 Would Would MD 40436 4437 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4437 3 all all DT 40436 4437 4 contribute contribute VB 40436 4437 5 equally equally RB 40436 4437 6 ? ? . 40436 4438 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4438 2 Krit._--By Krit._--By NNP 40436 4438 3 no no DT 40436 4438 4 means mean VBZ 40436 4438 5 . . . 40436 4439 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4439 2 Sokr._--Which Sokr._--Which NNP 40436 4439 3 of of IN 40436 4439 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4439 5 then then RB 40436 4439 6 would would MD 40436 4439 7 contribute contribute VB 40436 4439 8 most most RBS 40436 4439 9 ? ? . 40436 4440 1 Would Would MD 40436 4440 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4440 3 be be VB 40436 4440 4 that that IN 40436 4440 5 by by IN 40436 4440 6 which which WDT 40436 4440 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4440 8 knew know VBD 40436 4440 9 the the DT 40436 4440 10 art art NN 40436 4440 11 of of IN 40436 4440 12 gaming gaming NN 40436 4440 13 ? ? . 40436 4441 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4441 2 Krit._--Certainly Krit._--Certainly NNP 40436 4441 3 not not RB 40436 4441 4 . . . 40436 4442 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4442 2 Sokr._--Or Sokr._--Or NNP 40436 4442 3 that that IN 40436 4442 4 by by IN 40436 4442 5 which which WDT 40436 4442 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4442 7 knew know VBD 40436 4442 8 the the DT 40436 4442 9 art art NN 40436 4442 10 of of IN 40436 4442 11 computing compute VBG 40436 4442 12 ? ? . 40436 4443 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4443 2 Krit._--No Krit._--No NNP 40436 4443 3 . . . 40436 4444 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4444 2 Sokr._--Or Sokr._--Or NNP 40436 4444 3 that that IN 40436 4444 4 by by IN 40436 4444 5 which which WDT 40436 4444 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4444 7 knew know VBD 40436 4444 8 the the DT 40436 4444 9 conditions condition NNS 40436 4444 10 of of IN 40436 4444 11 health health NN 40436 4444 12 ? ? . 40436 4445 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4445 2 Krit._--That Krit._--That NNP 40436 4445 3 will will MD 40436 4445 4 suit suit VB 40436 4445 5 better well RBR 40436 4445 6 . . . 40436 4446 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4446 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 4446 3 which which WDT 40436 4446 4 of of IN 40436 4446 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4446 6 most most JJS 40436 4446 7 of of IN 40436 4446 8 all all DT 40436 4446 9 ? ? . 40436 4447 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4447 2 Krit._--That Krit._--That NNP 40436 4447 3 by by IN 40436 4447 4 which which WDT 40436 4447 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4447 6 knew know VBD 40436 4447 7 good good JJ 40436 4447 8 and and CC 40436 4447 9 evil evil NN 40436 4447 10 . . . 40436 4448 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4448 2 26 26 CD 40436 4448 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4448 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4448 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4448 6 25 25 CD 40436 4448 7 : : : 40436 4448 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4448 9 , , , 40436 4448 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4448 11 . . . 40436 4449 1 173 173 CD 40436 4449 2 D. D. NNP 40436 4449 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4449 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4449 5 : : : 40436 4449 6 A)lla\ a)lla\ VB 40436 4449 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4449 8 / / SYM 40436 4449 9 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 4449 10 , , , 40436 4449 11 ê)= ê)= FW 40436 4449 12 d d NNP 40436 4449 13 ' ' `` 40436 4449 14 o(/s o(/s NNP 40436 4449 15 , , , 40436 4449 16 ou ou NNP 40436 4449 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4449 18 r(a|di r(a|di NNP 40436 4449 19 / / SYM 40436 4449 20 ôs ôs NNP 40436 4449 21 eu(rê eu(rê NNPS 40436 4449 22 / / SYM 40436 4449 23 seis seis NNP 40436 4449 24 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 4449 25 ti ti NNP 40436 4449 26 te te NNP 40436 4449 27 / / SYM 40436 4449 28 los los NNP 40436 4449 29 tou= tou= NNP 40436 4449 30 eu)= eu)= NN 40436 4449 31 pra pra NNP 40436 4449 32 / / SYM 40436 4449 33 ttein ttein NN 40436 4449 34 e)a\n e)a\n -RRB- 40436 4449 35 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4449 36 e)pistêmo e)pistêmo . 40436 4449 37 / / SYM 40436 4449 38 nôs nôs NNP 40436 4449 39 a)tima a)tima NNP 40436 4449 40 / / SYM 40436 4449 41 sês sês NNP 40436 4449 42 . . . 40436 4449 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4449 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4450 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4450 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4450 3 26 26 CD 40436 4450 4 : : : 40436 4450 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4450 6 , , , 40436 4450 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4450 8 . . . 40436 4451 1 174 174 CD 40436 4451 2 . . . 40436 4451 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4452 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4452 2 Side side NN 40436 4452 3 - - HYPH 40436 4452 4 note note NN 40436 4452 5 : : : 40436 4452 6 Without without IN 40436 4452 7 the the DT 40436 4452 8 science science NN 40436 4452 9 of of IN 40436 4452 10 good good NN 40436 4452 11 and and CC 40436 4452 12 evil evil NN 40436 4452 13 , , , 40436 4452 14 the the DT 40436 4452 15 other other JJ 40436 4452 16 special special JJ 40436 4452 17 science science NN 40436 4452 18 will will MD 40436 4452 19 be be VB 40436 4452 20 of of IN 40436 4452 21 little little JJ 40436 4452 22 or or CC 40436 4452 23 of of IN 40436 4452 24 no no DT 40436 4452 25 service service NN 40436 4452 26 . . . 40436 4453 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4453 2 is be VBZ 40436 4453 3 not not RB 40436 4453 4 the the DT 40436 4453 5 science science NN 40436 4453 6 of of IN 40436 4453 7 good good NN 40436 4453 8 and and CC 40436 4453 9 evil evil NN 40436 4453 10 , , , 40436 4453 11 and and CC 40436 4453 12 is be VBZ 40436 4453 13 of of IN 40436 4453 14 little little JJ 40436 4453 15 service service NN 40436 4453 16 . . . 40436 4453 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4454 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4454 2 Sokr._--Here Sokr._--Here NNP 40436 4454 3 then then RB 40436 4454 4 , , , 40436 4454 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4454 6 have have VBP 40436 4454 7 been be VBN 40436 4454 8 long long RB 40436 4454 9 dragging drag VBG 40436 4454 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4454 11 round round RB 40436 4454 12 in in IN 40436 4454 13 a a DT 40436 4454 14 circle circle NN 40436 4454 15 , , , 40436 4454 16 keeping keep VBG 40436 4454 17 back back RP 40436 4454 18 the the DT 40436 4454 19 fact fact NN 40436 4454 20 , , , 40436 4454 21 that that IN 40436 4454 22 well well RB 40436 4454 23 - - HYPH 40436 4454 24 doing doing NN 40436 4454 25 and and CC 40436 4454 26 happiness happiness NN 40436 4454 27 does do VBZ 40436 4454 28 not not RB 40436 4454 29 arise arise VB 40436 4454 30 from from IN 40436 4454 31 living live VBG 40436 4454 32 according accord VBG 40436 4454 33 to to IN 40436 4454 34 science science NN 40436 4454 35 generally generally RB 40436 4454 36 , , , 40436 4454 37 not not RB 40436 4454 38 of of IN 40436 4454 39 all all DT 40436 4454 40 other other JJ 40436 4454 41 matters matter NNS 40436 4454 42 taken take VBN 40436 4454 43 together together RB 40436 4454 44 -- -- : 40436 4454 45 but but CC 40436 4454 46 from from IN 40436 4454 47 living live VBG 40436 4454 48 according accord VBG 40436 4454 49 to to IN 40436 4454 50 the the DT 40436 4454 51 science science NN 40436 4454 52 of of IN 40436 4454 53 this this DT 40436 4454 54 one one CD 40436 4454 55 single single JJ 40436 4454 56 matter matter NN 40436 4454 57 , , , 40436 4454 58 good good JJ 40436 4454 59 and and CC 40436 4454 60 evil evil NN 40436 4454 61 . . . 40436 4455 1 If if IN 40436 4455 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4455 3 exclude exclude VBP 40436 4455 4 this this DT 40436 4455 5 last last JJ 40436 4455 6 , , , 40436 4455 7 and and CC 40436 4455 8 leave leave VB 40436 4455 9 only only RB 40436 4455 10 the the DT 40436 4455 11 other other JJ 40436 4455 12 sciences science NNS 40436 4455 13 , , , 40436 4455 14 each each DT 40436 4455 15 of of IN 40436 4455 16 these these DT 40436 4455 17 others other NNS 40436 4455 18 will will MD 40436 4455 19 work work VB 40436 4455 20 as as IN 40436 4455 21 before before IN 40436 4455 22 : : : 40436 4455 23 the the DT 40436 4455 24 medical medical JJ 40436 4455 25 man man NN 40436 4455 26 will will MD 40436 4455 27 heal heal VB 40436 4455 28 , , , 40436 4455 29 the the DT 40436 4455 30 weaver weaver NN 40436 4455 31 will will MD 40436 4455 32 prepare prepare VB 40436 4455 33 clothes clothe NNS 40436 4455 34 , , , 40436 4455 35 the the DT 40436 4455 36 pilot pilot NN 40436 4455 37 will will MD 40436 4455 38 navigate navigate VB 40436 4455 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4455 40 vessel vessel NN 40436 4455 41 , , , 40436 4455 42 the the DT 40436 4455 43 general general NN 40436 4455 44 will will MD 40436 4455 45 conduct conduct VB 40436 4455 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4455 47 army army NN 40436 4455 48 -- -- : 40436 4455 49 each each DT 40436 4455 50 of of IN 40436 4455 51 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4455 52 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 4455 53 . . . 40436 4456 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 4456 2 , , , 40436 4456 3 that that IN 40436 4456 4 each each DT 40436 4456 5 of of IN 40436 4456 6 these these DT 40436 4456 7 things thing NNS 40436 4456 8 shall shall MD 40436 4456 9 conduce conduce VB 40436 4456 10 to to IN 40436 4456 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4456 12 well well NN 40436 4456 13 - - HYPH 40436 4456 14 being being NN 40436 4456 15 and and CC 40436 4456 16 profit profit NN 40436 4456 17 , , , 40436 4456 18 will will MD 40436 4456 19 be be VB 40436 4456 20 an an DT 40436 4456 21 impossibility impossibility NN 40436 4456 22 , , , 40436 4456 23 if if IN 40436 4456 24 the the DT 40436 4456 25 science science NN 40436 4456 26 of of IN 40436 4456 27 good good NN 40436 4456 28 and and CC 40436 4456 29 evil evil NN 40436 4456 30 be be VB 40436 4456 31 wanting want VBG 40436 4456 32 . . . 40436 4457 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4457 2 27 27 CD 40436 4457 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4457 4 Now now RB 40436 4457 5 this this DT 40436 4457 6 science science NN 40436 4457 7 of of IN 40436 4457 8 good good NN 40436 4457 9 and and CC 40436 4457 10 evil evil NN 40436 4457 11 , , , 40436 4457 12 the the DT 40436 4457 13 special special JJ 40436 4457 14 purpose purpose NN 40436 4457 15 of of IN 40436 4457 16 which which WDT 40436 4457 17 is be VBZ 40436 4457 18 to to TO 40436 4457 19 benefit benefit VB 40436 4457 20 us,[28 us,[28 NNS 40436 4457 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4457 22 is be VBZ 40436 4457 23 altogether altogether RB 40436 4457 24 different different JJ 40436 4457 25 from from IN 40436 4457 26 temperance temperance NN 40436 4457 27 ; ; : 40436 4457 28 which which WDT 40436 4457 29 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4457 30 have have VBP 40436 4457 31 defined define VBN 40436 4457 32 as as IN 40436 4457 33 the the DT 40436 4457 34 science science NN 40436 4457 35 of of IN 40436 4457 36 cognition cognition NN 40436 4457 37 and and CC 40436 4457 38 non non JJ 40436 4457 39 - - JJ 40436 4457 40 cognition cognition JJ 40436 4457 41 , , , 40436 4457 42 and and CC 40436 4457 43 which which WDT 40436 4457 44 appears appear VBZ 40436 4457 45 not not RB 40436 4457 46 to to TO 40436 4457 47 benefit benefit VB 40436 4457 48 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4457 49 at at RB 40436 4457 50 all all RB 40436 4457 51 . . . 40436 4458 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4458 2 Krit._--Surely Krit._--Surely NNP 40436 4458 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4458 4 does do VBZ 40436 4458 5 benefit benefit VB 40436 4458 6 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4458 7 : : : 40436 4458 8 for for IN 40436 4458 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4458 10 presides preside VBZ 40436 4458 11 over over RP 40436 4458 12 and and CC 40436 4458 13 regulates regulate VBZ 40436 4458 14 all all PDT 40436 4458 15 the the DT 40436 4458 16 other other JJ 40436 4458 17 sciences science NNS 40436 4458 18 , , , 40436 4458 19 and and CC 40436 4458 20 of of IN 40436 4458 21 course course NN 40436 4458 22 regulates regulate VBZ 40436 4458 23 this this DT 40436 4458 24 very very JJ 40436 4458 25 science science NN 40436 4458 26 , , , 40436 4458 27 of of IN 40436 4458 28 good good NN 40436 4458 29 and and CC 40436 4458 30 evil evil NN 40436 4458 31 , , , 40436 4458 32 among among IN 40436 4458 33 the the DT 40436 4458 34 rest rest NN 40436 4458 35 . . . 40436 4459 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4459 2 Sokr._--In Sokr._--In NNP 40436 4459 3 what what WDT 40436 4459 4 way way NN 40436 4459 5 can can MD 40436 4459 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4459 7 benefit benefit VB 40436 4459 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4459 9 ? ? . 40436 4460 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4460 2 does do VBZ 40436 4460 3 not not RB 40436 4460 4 procure procure VB 40436 4460 5 for for IN 40436 4460 6 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4460 7 any any DT 40436 4460 8 special special JJ 40436 4460 9 service service NN 40436 4460 10 , , , 40436 4460 11 such such JJ 40436 4460 12 as as IN 40436 4460 13 good good JJ 40436 4460 14 health health NN 40436 4460 15 : : : 40436 4460 16 _ _ NNP 40436 4460 17 that that IN 40436 4460 18 _ _ NNP 40436 4460 19 is be VBZ 40436 4460 20 the the DT 40436 4460 21 province province NN 40436 4460 22 of of IN 40436 4460 23 medicine medicine NN 40436 4460 24 : : : 40436 4460 25 in in IN 40436 4460 26 like like NNP 40436 4460 27 manner manner NN 40436 4460 28 , , , 40436 4460 29 each each DT 40436 4460 30 separate separate JJ 40436 4460 31 result result NN 40436 4460 32 arises arise VBZ 40436 4460 33 from from IN 40436 4460 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4460 35 own own JJ 40436 4460 36 producing produce VBG 40436 4460 37 art art NN 40436 4460 38 . . . 40436 4461 1 To to TO 40436 4461 2 confer confer VB 40436 4461 3 benefit benefit NN 40436 4461 4 is be VBZ 40436 4461 5 , , , 40436 4461 6 as as IN 40436 4461 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4461 8 have have VBP 40436 4461 9 just just RB 40436 4461 10 laid lay VBN 40436 4461 11 down down RP 40436 4461 12 , , , 40436 4461 13 the the DT 40436 4461 14 special special JJ 40436 4461 15 province province NN 40436 4461 16 of of IN 40436 4461 17 the the DT 40436 4461 18 science science NN 40436 4461 19 of of IN 40436 4461 20 good good NN 40436 4461 21 and and CC 40436 4461 22 evil evil NN 40436 4461 23 . . . 40436 4462 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4462 2 29 29 CD 40436 4462 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4462 4 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4462 5 , , , 40436 4462 6 as as IN 40436 4462 7 the the DT 40436 4462 8 science science NN 40436 4462 9 of of IN 40436 4462 10 cognition cognition NN 40436 4462 11 and and CC 40436 4462 12 non non JJ 40436 4462 13 - - JJ 40436 4462 14 cognition cognition JJ 40436 4462 15 , , , 40436 4462 16 can can MD 40436 4462 17 not not RB 40436 4462 18 work work VB 40436 4462 19 any any DT 40436 4462 20 benefit benefit NN 40436 4462 21 at at RB 40436 4462 22 all all RB 40436 4462 23 . . . 40436 4463 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4463 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4463 3 27 27 CD 40436 4463 4 : : : 40436 4463 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4463 6 , , , 40436 4463 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4463 8 . . . 40436 4464 1 174 174 CD 40436 4464 2 C C NNP 40436 4464 3 - - HYPH 40436 4464 4 D. D. NNP 40436 4464 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4464 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4464 7 : : : 40436 4464 8 e)pei\ e)pei\ `` 40436 4464 9 ei ei NNP 40436 4464 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4464 11 the the DT 40436 4464 12 / / SYM 40436 4464 13 leis leis NNP 40436 4464 14 e)xelei e)xelei NNP 40436 4464 15 = = SYM 40436 4464 16 n n CC 40436 4464 17 tau tau NN 40436 4464 18 / / SYM 40436 4464 19 tên tên NN 40436 4464 20 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 4464 21 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4464 22 / / SYM 40436 4464 23 mên mên NN 40436 4464 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4464 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4464 26 of of IN 40436 4464 27 good good NN 40436 4464 28 and and CC 40436 4464 29 evil evil NN 40436 4464 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4464 31 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4464 32 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4464 33 : : : 40436 4464 34 e)k e)k NNP 40436 4464 35 tô tô NNP 40436 4464 36 = = SYM 40436 4464 37 n n NN 40436 4464 38 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 4464 39 e)pistêmô e)pistêmô NN 40436 4464 40 = = SYM 40436 4464 41 n n CC 40436 4464 42 , , , 40436 4464 43 ê(=tto ê(=tto `` 40436 4464 44 / / SYM 40436 4464 45 n n CC 40436 4464 46 ti ti NN 40436 4464 47 ê ê NN 40436 4464 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4464 49 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4464 50 i)atrikê\ i)atrikê\ NNP 40436 4464 51 u(giai u(giai NNP 40436 4464 52 / / SYM 40436 4464 53 nein nein NNP 40436 4464 54 poiê poiê NNP 40436 4464 55 / / SYM 40436 4464 56 sei sei NNP 40436 4464 57 , , , 40436 4464 58 ê ê NNP 40436 4464 59 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4464 60 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4464 61 skutikê\ skutikê\ NNP 40436 4464 62 u(podede u(podede NNP 40436 4464 63 / / SYM 40436 4464 64 sthai sthai NNP 40436 4464 65 , , , 40436 4464 66 ê ê NNP 40436 4464 67 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4464 68 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4464 69 u(phantikê\ u(phantikê\ NNP 40436 4464 70 ê(mphie ê(mphie NNP 40436 4464 71 / / SYM 40436 4464 72 sthai sthai NNP 40436 4464 73 , , , 40436 4464 74 ê ê NNP 40436 4464 75 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4464 76 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4464 77 kubbernêtikê\ kubbernêtikê\ NNP 40436 4464 78 kôlu kôlu NNP 40436 4464 79 / / SYM 40436 4464 80 sei sei NNP 40436 4464 81 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4464 82 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 4464 83 thala thala NNP 40436 4464 84 / / SYM 40436 4464 85 ttê| ttê| NNP 40436 4464 86 a)pothnê a)pothnê NNP 40436 4464 87 / / SYM 40436 4464 88 skein skein NNP 40436 4464 89 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4464 90 ê ê NNP 40436 4464 91 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4464 92 stratêgikê\ stratêgikê\ NNP 40436 4464 93 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4464 94 pole pole NNP 40436 4464 95 / / SYM 40436 4464 96 mô| mô| NNP 40436 4464 97 ? ? . 40436 4465 1 Ou)de\n Ou)de\n NNP 40436 4465 2 ê(=tton ê(=tton NNP 40436 4465 3 , , , 40436 4465 4 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 4465 5 . . . 40436 4466 1 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 4466 2 to\ to\ NN 40436 4466 3 eu)= eu)= NN 40436 4466 4 te te NNP 40436 4466 5 tou tou NNP 40436 4466 6 / / SYM 40436 4466 7 tôn tôn NNP 40436 4466 8 e(/kasta e(/kasta NNP 40436 4466 9 gi gi NNP 40436 4466 10 / / SYM 40436 4466 11 gnesthai gnesthai NNP 40436 4466 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4466 13 ô)pheli ô)pheli NNP 40436 4466 14 / / SYM 40436 4466 15 môs môs JJ 40436 4466 16 a)poleloipo\s a)poleloipo\s NNP 40436 4466 17 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 4466 18 = = SYM 40436 4466 19 s s NNP 40436 4466 20 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 4466 21 tau tau NNP 40436 4466 22 / / SYM 40436 4466 23 tês tês NNP 40436 4466 24 a)pou a)pou NNP 40436 4466 25 / / SYM 40436 4466 26 sês sês NNP 40436 4466 27 . . . 40436 4466 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4466 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4467 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4467 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4467 3 28 28 CD 40436 4467 4 : : : 40436 4467 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4467 6 , , , 40436 4467 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4467 8 . . . 40436 4468 1 174 174 CD 40436 4468 2 D. D. NNP 40436 4468 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4468 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4468 5 : : : 40436 4468 6 ê(=s ê(=s CD 40436 4468 7 e)/rgon e)/rgon NN 40436 4468 8 e)sti\ e)sti\ NN 40436 4468 9 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4468 10 ô)phelei ô)phelei NN 40436 4468 11 = = NFP 40436 4468 12 n n NN 40436 4468 13 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 4468 14 = = SYM 40436 4468 15 s s NN 40436 4468 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4468 17 , , , 40436 4468 18 & & CC 40436 4468 19 c. c. NNP 40436 4468 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4468 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4468 22 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4468 23 29 29 CD 40436 4468 24 : : : 40436 4468 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4468 26 , , , 40436 4468 27 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4468 28 . . . 40436 4469 1 175 175 CD 40436 4469 2 A. a. NN 40436 4470 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4470 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4470 3 : : : 40436 4470 4 Ou)k Ou)k NNP 40436 4470 5 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 4470 6 u(giei u(giei NNP 40436 4470 7 / / SYM 40436 4470 8 as as IN 40436 4470 9 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 4470 10 dêmiourgo dêmiourgo NNP 40436 4470 11 / / SYM 40436 4470 12 s s NNP 40436 4470 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4470 14 ê ê NNP 40436 4470 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4470 16 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4470 17 / / SYM 40436 4470 18 nê nê NNP 40436 4470 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4470 20 . . . 40436 4471 1 Ou Ou NNP 40436 4471 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4471 3 dê dê NN 40436 4471 4 = = SYM 40436 4471 5 ta ta ADD 40436 4471 6 . . . 40436 4472 1 A)/llês a)/llê NNS 40436 4472 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4472 3 ê)=n ê)=n IN 40436 4472 4 te te NNP 40436 4472 5 / / SYM 40436 4472 6 chnês chnês NNP 40436 4472 7 u(giei u(giei NNP 40436 4472 8 / / , 40436 4472 9 a a DT 40436 4472 10 , , , 40436 4472 11 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 4472 12 ou)/ ou)/ JJ 40436 4472 13 ? ? . 40436 4473 1 A)/llês a)/llê NNS 40436 4473 2 . . . 40436 4474 1 Ou)d Ou)d NNP 40436 4474 2 ' ' '' 40436 4474 3 a)/ra a)/ra RB 40436 4474 4 ô)phelei ô)phelei NNP 40436 4474 5 / / SYM 40436 4474 6 as as IN 40436 4474 7 , , , 40436 4474 8 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 4474 9 e(/taire e(/taire NNP 40436 4474 10 ; ; : 40436 4474 11 a)/llê| a)/llê| NNP 40436 4474 12 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4474 13 au)= au)= JJ 40436 4474 14 a)pe a)pe NNP 40436 4474 15 / / SYM 40436 4474 16 domen domen NNP 40436 4474 17 tou tou NNP 40436 4474 18 = = NNP 40436 4474 19 to to TO 40436 4474 20 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4474 21 e)/rgon e)/rgon NNP 40436 4474 22 te te NNP 40436 4474 23 / / SYM 40436 4474 24 chnê| chnê| NNP 40436 4474 25 nu nu NNP 40436 4474 26 = = SYM 40436 4474 27 n n CC 40436 4474 28 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 4474 29 ; ; : 40436 4474 30 ê)= ê)= NNP 40436 4474 31 ga ga NNP 40436 4474 32 / / SYM 40436 4474 33 r r NNP 40436 4474 34 ? ? . 40436 4475 1 Pa Pa NNP 40436 4475 2 / / SYM 40436 4475 3 nu nu NNP 40436 4475 4 ge ge NNP 40436 4475 5 . . . 40436 4476 1 Pô Pô NNP 40436 4476 2 = = SYM 40436 4476 3 s s NNP 40436 4476 4 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 4476 5 ô)phe ô)phe NNP 40436 4476 6 / / SYM 40436 4476 7 limos limos NNP 40436 4476 8 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 4476 9 ê ê NNP 40436 4476 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4476 11 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4476 12 / / SYM 40436 4476 13 nê nê NNP 40436 4476 14 , , , 40436 4476 15 ou)demia ou)demia NN 40436 4476 16 = = SYM 40436 4476 17 s s NNP 40436 4476 18 ô)phelei ô)phelei NNP 40436 4476 19 / / SYM 40436 4476 20 as as IN 40436 4476 21 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 4476 22 dêmiourgo dêmiourgo NNP 40436 4476 23 / / SYM 40436 4476 24 s s JJ 40436 4476 25 ? ? . 40436 4477 1 Ou)damô Ou)damô NNP 40436 4477 2 = = SYM 40436 4477 3 s s NNP 40436 4477 4 , , , 40436 4477 5 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 4477 6 Sô Sô NNP 40436 4477 7 / / SYM 40436 4477 8 krates krate NNS 40436 4477 9 , , , 40436 4477 10 e)/oike/ e)/oike/ NNP 40436 4477 11 ge ge NNP 40436 4477 12 . . . 40436 4477 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4477 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4478 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4478 2 Side side NN 40436 4478 3 - - HYPH 40436 4478 4 note note NN 40436 4478 5 : : : 40436 4478 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4478 7 confesses confess VBZ 40436 4478 8 to to IN 40436 4478 9 entire entire JJ 40436 4478 10 failure failure NN 40436 4478 11 in in IN 40436 4478 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4478 13 research research NN 40436 4478 14 . . . 40436 4479 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4479 2 can can MD 40436 4479 3 not not RB 40436 4479 4 find find VB 40436 4479 5 out out RP 40436 4479 6 what what WP 40436 4479 7 temperance temperance NN 40436 4479 8 is be VBZ 40436 4479 9 : : : 40436 4479 10 although although IN 40436 4479 11 several several JJ 40436 4479 12 concessions concession NNS 40436 4479 13 have have VBP 40436 4479 14 been be VBN 40436 4479 15 made make VBN 40436 4479 16 which which WDT 40436 4479 17 can can MD 40436 4479 18 not not RB 40436 4479 19 be be VB 40436 4479 20 justified justify VBN 40436 4479 21 . . . 40436 4479 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4480 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4480 2 then then RB 40436 4480 3 , , , 40436 4480 4 concludes conclude VBZ 40436 4480 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4480 6 , , , 40436 4480 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4480 8 are be VBP 40436 4480 9 baffled baffle VBN 40436 4480 10 in in IN 40436 4480 11 every every DT 40436 4480 12 way way NN 40436 4480 13 : : : 40436 4480 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4480 15 can can MD 40436 4480 16 not not RB 40436 4480 17 find find VB 40436 4480 18 out out RP 40436 4480 19 what what WP 40436 4480 20 temperance temperance NN 40436 4480 21 is be VBZ 40436 4480 22 , , , 40436 4480 23 nor nor CC 40436 4480 24 what what WP 40436 4480 25 that that DT 40436 4480 26 name name NN 40436 4480 27 has have VBZ 40436 4480 28 been be VBN 40436 4480 29 intended intend VBN 40436 4480 30 to to TO 40436 4480 31 designate designate VB 40436 4480 32 . . . 40436 4481 1 All all DT 40436 4481 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4481 3 tentatives tentative NNS 40436 4481 4 have have VBP 40436 4481 5 failed fail VBN 40436 4481 6 ; ; : 40436 4481 7 although although IN 40436 4481 8 , , , 40436 4481 9 in in IN 40436 4481 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4481 11 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 4481 12 to to TO 40436 4481 13 secure secure VB 40436 4481 14 some some DT 40436 4481 15 result result NN 40436 4481 16 , , , 40436 4481 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4481 18 have have VBP 40436 4481 19 accepted accept VBN 40436 4481 20 more more JJR 40436 4481 21 than than IN 40436 4481 22 one one CD 40436 4481 23 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 4481 24 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 4481 25 . . . 40436 4482 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4482 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4482 3 have have VBP 40436 4482 4 admitted admit VBN 40436 4482 5 that that IN 40436 4482 6 there there EX 40436 4482 7 might may MD 40436 4482 8 exist exist VB 40436 4482 9 cognition cognition NN 40436 4482 10 of of IN 40436 4482 11 cognition cognition NN 40436 4482 12 , , , 40436 4482 13 though though IN 40436 4482 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4482 15 discussion discussion NN 40436 4482 16 tended tend VBD 40436 4482 17 to to IN 40436 4482 18 negative negative JJ 40436 4482 19 such such PDT 40436 4482 20 a a DT 40436 4482 21 possibility possibility NN 40436 4482 22 . . . 40436 4483 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4483 2 have have VBP 40436 4483 3 farther far RBR 40436 4483 4 granted grant VBN 40436 4483 5 , , , 40436 4483 6 that that IN 40436 4483 7 this this DT 40436 4483 8 cognition cognition NN 40436 4483 9 of of IN 40436 4483 10 cognition cognition NN 40436 4483 11 , , , 40436 4483 12 or or CC 40436 4483 13 science science NN 40436 4483 14 of of IN 40436 4483 15 science science NN 40436 4483 16 , , , 40436 4483 17 might may MD 40436 4483 18 know know VB 40436 4483 19 all all PDT 40436 4483 20 the the DT 40436 4483 21 operations operation NNS 40436 4483 22 of of IN 40436 4483 23 each each DT 40436 4483 24 separate separate JJ 40436 4483 25 and and CC 40436 4483 26 special special JJ 40436 4483 27 science science NN 40436 4483 28 : : : 40436 4483 29 so so IN 40436 4483 30 that that IN 40436 4483 31 the the DT 40436 4483 32 temperate temperate NN 40436 4483 33 man man NN 40436 4483 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4483 35 _ _ NNP 40436 4483 36 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 4483 37 _ _ NNP 40436 4483 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4483 39 who who WP 40436 4483 40 possesses possess VBZ 40436 4483 41 cognition cognition NN 40436 4483 42 of of IN 40436 4483 43 cognition cognition NN 40436 4483 44 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4483 45 might may MD 40436 4483 46 know know VB 40436 4483 47 both both DT 40436 4483 48 what what WP 40436 4483 49 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4483 50 knows know VBZ 40436 4483 51 and and CC 40436 4483 52 what what WP 40436 4483 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4483 54 does do VBZ 40436 4483 55 not not RB 40436 4483 56 know know VB 40436 4483 57 : : : 40436 4483 58 might may MD 40436 4483 59 know know VB 40436 4483 60 , , , 40436 4483 61 namely namely RB 40436 4483 62 , , , 40436 4483 63 that that IN 40436 4483 64 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4483 65 knows know VBZ 40436 4483 66 the the DT 40436 4483 67 former former JJ 40436 4483 68 and and CC 40436 4483 69 that that IN 40436 4483 70 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4483 71 does do VBZ 40436 4483 72 not not RB 40436 4483 73 know know VB 40436 4483 74 the the DT 40436 4483 75 latter latter JJ 40436 4483 76 . . . 40436 4484 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4484 2 have have VBP 40436 4484 3 granted grant VBN 40436 4484 4 this this DT 40436 4484 5 , , , 40436 4484 6 though though IN 40436 4484 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4484 8 is be VBZ 40436 4484 9 really really RB 40436 4484 10 an an DT 40436 4484 11 absurdity absurdity NN 40436 4484 12 to to TO 40436 4484 13 say say VB 40436 4484 14 , , , 40436 4484 15 that that IN 40436 4484 16 what what WP 40436 4484 17 a a DT 40436 4484 18 man man NN 40436 4484 19 does do VBZ 40436 4484 20 not not RB 40436 4484 21 know know VB 40436 4484 22 at at RB 40436 4484 23 all all RB 40436 4484 24 , , , 40436 4484 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4484 26 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 4484 27 does do VBZ 40436 4484 28 know know VB 40436 4484 29 after after IN 40436 4484 30 a a DT 40436 4484 31 certain certain JJ 40436 4484 32 fashion fashion NN 40436 4484 33 . . . 40436 4485 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4485 2 30 30 CD 40436 4485 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4485 4 Yet yet CC 40436 4485 5 after after IN 40436 4485 6 these these DT 40436 4485 7 multiplied multiply VBN 40436 4485 8 concessions concession NNS 40436 4485 9 against against IN 40436 4485 10 strict strict JJ 40436 4485 11 truth truth NN 40436 4485 12 , , , 40436 4485 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4485 14 have have VBP 40436 4485 15 still still RB 40436 4485 16 been be VBN 40436 4485 17 unable unable JJ 40436 4485 18 to to TO 40436 4485 19 establish establish VB 40436 4485 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4485 21 definition definition NN 40436 4485 22 of of IN 40436 4485 23 temperance temperance NN 40436 4485 24 : : : 40436 4485 25 for for IN 40436 4485 26 temperance temperance NN 40436 4485 27 as as IN 40436 4485 28 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4485 29 defined define VBD 40436 4485 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4485 31 has have VBZ 40436 4485 32 , , , 40436 4485 33 after after RB 40436 4485 34 all all RB 40436 4485 35 , , , 40436 4485 36 turned turn VBD 40436 4485 37 out out RP 40436 4485 38 to to TO 40436 4485 39 be be VB 40436 4485 40 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 4485 41 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 4485 42 . . . 40436 4486 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4486 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4486 3 30 30 CD 40436 4486 4 : : : 40436 4486 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4486 6 , , , 40436 4486 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4486 8 . . . 40436 4487 1 175 175 CD 40436 4487 2 B. B. NNP 40436 4488 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4488 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4488 3 : : : 40436 4488 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4488 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4488 6 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4488 7 / / SYM 40436 4488 8 mên mên NN 40436 4488 9 e)pistê e)pistê NNS 40436 4488 10 / / SYM 40436 4488 11 mês mês NNP 40436 4488 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4488 13 xunechôrê xunechôrê NNP 40436 4488 14 / / SYM 40436 4488 15 samen saman NNS 40436 4488 16 , , , 40436 4488 17 ou)k ou)k '' 40436 4488 18 e)ô e)ô NNP 40436 4488 19 = = SYM 40436 4488 20 ntos ntos JJ 40436 4488 21 tou= tou= NNP 40436 4488 22 lo lo NNP 40436 4488 23 / / SYM 40436 4488 24 gou gou NN 40436 4488 25 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 4488 26 pha pha NN 40436 4488 27 / / SYM 40436 4488 28 skontos skontos NNP 40436 4488 29 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4488 30 ; ; : 40436 4488 31 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4488 32 tau tau NNP 40436 4488 33 / / SYM 40436 4488 34 tê| tê| NNP 40436 4488 35 au)= au)= NNP 40436 4488 36 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 4488 37 e)pistê e)pistê CD 40436 4488 38 / / SYM 40436 4488 39 mê| mê| NNP 40436 4488 40 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4488 41 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 4488 42 tô tô NNP 40436 4488 43 = = NFP 40436 4488 44 n n NN 40436 4488 45 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 4488 46 e)pistêmô e)pistêmô NN 40436 4488 47 = = SYM 40436 4488 48 n n CC 40436 4488 49 e)/rga e)/rga NNP 40436 4488 50 gignô gignô NNP 40436 4488 51 / / SYM 40436 4488 52 skein skein NNP 40436 4488 53 xunechôrê xunechôrê NNP 40436 4488 54 / / SYM 40436 4488 55 samen saman NNS 40436 4488 56 , , , 40436 4488 57 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 4488 58 tou tou NNP 40436 4488 59 = = SYM 40436 4488 60 t t NN 40436 4488 61 ' ' `` 40436 4488 62 e)ô e)ô NNP 40436 4488 63 = = SYM 40436 4488 64 ntos ntos JJ 40436 4488 65 tou= tou= NNP 40436 4488 66 lo lo NNP 40436 4488 67 / / SYM 40436 4488 68 gou gou NNP 40436 4488 69 , , , 40436 4488 70 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 4488 71 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4488 72 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 4488 73 = = SYM 40436 4488 74 n n NNP 40436 4488 75 ge ge NNP 40436 4488 76 / / SYM 40436 4488 77 noito noito NNP 40436 4488 78 o o NNP 40436 4488 79 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4488 80 sô sô NNP 40436 4488 81 / / SYM 40436 4488 82 phrôn phrôn NNP 40436 4488 83 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4488 84 / / SYM 40436 4488 85 môn môn NNP 40436 4488 86 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 4488 87 te te NNP 40436 4488 88 oi)=den oi)=den CD 40436 4488 89 , , , 40436 4488 90 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 4488 91 oi)=de oi)=de NNP 40436 4488 92 , , , 40436 4488 93 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4488 94 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 4488 95 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 4488 96 oi)=den oi)=den CD 40436 4488 97 , , , 40436 4488 98 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 4488 99 ou)k ou)k NN 40436 4488 100 oi)=de oi)=de NNP 40436 4488 101 . . . 40436 4489 1 tou tou NNP 40436 4489 2 = = NNPS 40436 4489 3 to to IN 40436 4489 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4489 5 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4489 6 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4489 7 panta panta NNP 40436 4489 8 / / SYM 40436 4489 9 pasi pasi NNP 40436 4489 10 megaloprepô megaloprepô NNP 40436 4489 11 = = NFP 40436 4489 12 s s NNP 40436 4489 13 xunechôrê xunechôrê NNP 40436 4489 14 / / SYM 40436 4489 15 samen saman NNS 40436 4489 16 , , , 40436 4489 17 ou)d ou)d JJ 40436 4489 18 ' ' '' 40436 4489 19 e)piskepsa e)piskepsa '' 40436 4489 20 / / SYM 40436 4489 21 menoi menoi NNP 40436 4489 22 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4489 23 a)du a)du NNP 40436 4489 24 / / SYM 40436 4489 25 naton naton NNP 40436 4489 26 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 4489 27 a(/ a(/ NNP 40436 4489 28 tis tis NNP 40436 4489 29 mê\ mê\ VBP 40436 4489 30 oi)=de oi)=de NNP 40436 4489 31 mêdamô mêdamô NNP 40436 4489 32 = = SYM 40436 4489 33 s s NNP 40436 4489 34 , , , 40436 4489 35 tau tau NNP 40436 4489 36 = = SYM 40436 4489 37 ta ta NNP 40436 4489 38 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 4489 39 / / SYM 40436 4489 40 nai nai NNP 40436 4489 41 a(mô a(mô NNP 40436 4489 42 = = SYM 40436 4489 43 s s NNP 40436 4489 44 ge/ ge/ NNP 40436 4489 45 pôs pôs NN 40436 4489 46 ; ; , 40436 4489 47 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 4489 48 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4489 49 ou)k ou)k JJ 40436 4489 50 oi)=de oi)=de NNP 40436 4489 51 , , , 40436 4489 52 phêsi\n phêsi\n NFP 40436 4489 53 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 4489 54 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 4489 55 / / SYM 40436 4489 56 nai nai NNP 40436 4489 57 ê ê NNP 40436 4489 58 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4489 59 ê(mete ê(mete NNP 40436 4489 60 / / SYM 40436 4489 61 ra ra NNP 40436 4489 62 o(mologi o(mologi NNP 40436 4489 63 / / , 40436 4489 64 a a DT 40436 4489 65 . . . 40436 4490 1 kai kai NNP 40436 4490 2 / / SYM 40436 4490 3 toi toi NNP 40436 4490 4 , , , 40436 4490 5 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 4490 6 e)gô e)gô NNP 40436 4490 7 = = SYM 40436 4490 8 mai mai UH 40436 4490 9 , , , 40436 4490 10 ou)deno\s ou)deno\s NNP 40436 4490 11 o(/tou o(/tou NNP 40436 4490 12 ou)chi\ ou)chi\ NNP 40436 4490 13 a)logô a)logô NNP 40436 4490 14 / / SYM 40436 4490 15 teron teron NNP 40436 4490 16 tou tou NNP 40436 4490 17 = = SYM 40436 4490 18 t t NNP 40436 4490 19 ' ' '' 40436 4490 20 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 4490 21 phanei phanei NNP 40436 4490 22 / / SYM 40436 4490 23 ê ê NNP 40436 4490 24 . . . 40436 4490 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4491 1 This this DT 40436 4491 2 would would MD 40436 4491 3 not not RB 40436 4491 4 appear appear VB 40436 4491 5 an an DT 40436 4491 6 absurdity absurdity NN 40436 4491 7 to to IN 40436 4491 8 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 4491 9 . . . 40436 4492 1 See see VB 40436 4492 2 Analyt Analyt NNP 40436 4492 3 . . . 40436 4493 1 Priora Priora NNP 40436 4493 2 , , , 40436 4493 3 ii ii NNP 40436 4493 4 . . . 40436 4494 1 p. p. NN 40436 4494 2 67 67 CD 40436 4494 3 , , , 40436 4494 4 a. a. NN 40436 4495 1 21 21 LS 40436 4495 2 ; ; : 40436 4495 3 Anal Anal NNP 40436 4495 4 . . . 40436 4496 1 Post Post NNP 40436 4496 2 . . . 40436 4497 1 i. i. NNP 40436 4498 1 71 71 CD 40436 4498 2 , , , 40436 4498 3 a. a. NN 40436 4499 1 28 28 CD 40436 4499 2 . . . 40436 4499 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4500 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4500 2 Side side NN 40436 4500 3 - - HYPH 40436 4500 4 note note NN 40436 4500 5 : : : 40436 4500 6 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4500 7 is be VBZ 40436 4500 8 and and CC 40436 4500 9 must must MD 40436 4500 10 be be VB 40436 4500 11 a a DT 40436 4500 12 good good JJ 40436 4500 13 thing thing NN 40436 4500 14 : : : 40436 4500 15 but but CC 40436 4500 16 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4500 17 can can MD 40436 4500 18 not not RB 40436 4500 19 tell tell VB 40436 4500 20 whether whether IN 40436 4500 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4500 22 is be VBZ 40436 4500 23 temperate temperate NN 40436 4500 24 or or CC 40436 4500 25 not not RB 40436 4500 26 ; ; : 40436 4500 27 since since IN 40436 4500 28 what what WDT 40436 4500 29 temperance temperance NN 40436 4500 30 is be VBZ 40436 4500 31 remains remain VBZ 40436 4500 32 unknown unknown JJ 40436 4500 33 . . . 40436 4500 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4501 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4501 2 is be VBZ 40436 4501 3 plain plain JJ 40436 4501 4 that that IN 40436 4501 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4501 6 have have VBP 40436 4501 7 taken take VBN 40436 4501 8 the the DT 40436 4501 9 wrong wrong JJ 40436 4501 10 road road NN 40436 4501 11 , , , 40436 4501 12 and and CC 40436 4501 13 that that IN 40436 4501 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4501 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4501 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4501 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4501 18 do do VBP 40436 4501 19 not not RB 40436 4501 20 know know VB 40436 4501 21 how how WRB 40436 4501 22 to to TO 40436 4501 23 conduct conduct VB 40436 4501 24 the the DT 40436 4501 25 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 4501 26 . . . 40436 4502 1 For for IN 40436 4502 2 temperance temperance NN 40436 4502 3 , , , 40436 4502 4 whatever whatever WDT 40436 4502 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4502 6 may may MD 40436 4502 7 consist consist VB 40436 4502 8 in in RB 40436 4502 9 , , , 40436 4502 10 must must MD 40436 4502 11 assuredly assuredly RB 40436 4502 12 be be VB 40436 4502 13 a a DT 40436 4502 14 great great JJ 40436 4502 15 benefit benefit NN 40436 4502 16 : : : 40436 4502 17 and and CC 40436 4502 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4502 19 , , , 40436 4502 20 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 4502 21 , , , 40436 4502 22 are be VBP 40436 4502 23 happy happy JJ 40436 4502 24 if if IN 40436 4502 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4502 26 possess possess VBP 40436 4502 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4502 28 . . . 40436 4503 1 How how WRB 40436 4503 2 can can MD 40436 4503 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4503 4 tell tell VB 40436 4503 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4503 6 rejoins rejoin NNS 40436 4503 7 Charmides charmide NNS 40436 4503 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4503 9 whether whether IN 40436 4503 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4503 11 possess possess VBP 40436 4503 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4503 13 or or CC 40436 4503 14 not not RB 40436 4503 15 : : : 40436 4503 16 since since IN 40436 4503 17 even even RB 40436 4503 18 men man NNS 40436 4503 19 like like IN 40436 4503 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4503 21 and and CC 40436 4503 22 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4503 23 can can MD 40436 4503 24 not not RB 40436 4503 25 discover discover VB 40436 4503 26 what what WP 40436 4503 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4503 28 is be VBZ 40436 4503 29 ? ? . 40436 4504 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4504 2 31 31 CD 40436 4504 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4504 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4504 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4504 6 31 31 CD 40436 4504 7 : : : 40436 4504 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4504 9 , , , 40436 4504 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4504 11 . . . 40436 4505 1 176 176 CD 40436 4505 2 A. a. NN 40436 4505 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4506 1 * * NFP 40436 4506 2 * * NFP 40436 4506 3 * * NFP 40436 4506 4 * * NFP 40436 4506 5 * * NFP 40436 4506 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4506 7 Side side NN 40436 4506 8 - - HYPH 40436 4506 9 note note NN 40436 4506 10 : : : 40436 4506 11 Expressions expression NNS 40436 4506 12 both both CC 40436 4506 13 from from IN 40436 4506 14 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 4506 15 and and CC 40436 4506 16 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4506 17 of of IN 40436 4506 18 praise praise NN 40436 4506 19 and and CC 40436 4506 20 devotion devotion NN 40436 4506 21 to to IN 40436 4506 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4506 23 , , , 40436 4506 24 at at IN 40436 4506 25 the the DT 40436 4506 26 close close NN 40436 4506 27 of of IN 40436 4506 28 the the DT 40436 4506 29 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4506 30 . . . 40436 4507 1 Dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4507 2 ornament ornament NN 40436 4507 3 throughout throughout RB 40436 4507 4 . . . 40436 4507 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4508 1 Here here RB 40436 4508 2 ends end VBZ 40436 4508 3 the the DT 40436 4508 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4508 5 called call VBN 40436 4508 6 Charmidês[32 Charmidês[32 NNP 40436 4508 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4508 8 after after IN 40436 4508 9 the the DT 40436 4508 10 interchange interchange NN 40436 4508 11 of of IN 40436 4508 12 a a DT 40436 4508 13 few few JJ 40436 4508 14 concluding concluding NN 40436 4508 15 compliments compliment NNS 40436 4508 16 , , , 40436 4508 17 forming form VBG 40436 4508 18 part part NN 40436 4508 19 of of IN 40436 4508 20 the the DT 40436 4508 21 great great JJ 40436 4508 22 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4508 23 richness richness NN 40436 4508 24 which which WDT 40436 4508 25 characterises characterise VBZ 40436 4508 26 this this DT 40436 4508 27 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4508 28 from from IN 40436 4508 29 the the DT 40436 4508 30 beginning beginning NN 40436 4508 31 . . . 40436 4509 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4509 2 make make VBP 40436 4509 3 no no DT 40436 4509 4 attempt attempt NN 40436 4509 5 to to TO 40436 4509 6 reproduce reproduce VB 40436 4509 7 this this DT 40436 4509 8 latter latter JJ 40436 4509 9 attribute attribute NN 40436 4509 10 ; ; : 40436 4509 11 though though IN 40436 4509 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4509 13 is be VBZ 40436 4509 14 one one CD 40436 4509 15 of of IN 40436 4509 16 the the DT 40436 4509 17 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 4509 18 merits merit NNS 40436 4509 19 of of IN 40436 4509 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4509 21 in in IN 40436 4509 22 reference reference NN 40436 4509 23 to to IN 40436 4509 24 ethical ethical JJ 40436 4509 25 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 4509 26 , , , 40436 4509 27 imparting impart VBG 40436 4509 28 to to IN 40436 4509 29 the the DT 40436 4509 30 subject subject NN 40436 4509 31 a a DT 40436 4509 32 charm charm NN 40436 4509 33 which which WDT 40436 4509 34 does do VBZ 40436 4509 35 not not RB 40436 4509 36 naturally naturally RB 40436 4509 37 belong belong VB 40436 4509 38 to to IN 40436 4509 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4509 40 . . . 40436 4510 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4510 2 confine confine VBP 40436 4510 3 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 4510 4 to to IN 40436 4510 5 the the DT 40436 4510 6 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 4510 7 bearing bearing NN 40436 4510 8 of of IN 40436 4510 9 the the DT 40436 4510 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4510 11 . . . 40436 4511 1 According accord VBG 40436 4511 2 to to IN 40436 4511 3 the the DT 40436 4511 4 express express JJ 40436 4511 5 declaration declaration NN 40436 4511 6 of of IN 40436 4511 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4511 8 , , , 40436 4511 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4511 10 ends end VBZ 40436 4511 11 in in IN 40436 4511 12 nothing nothing NN 40436 4511 13 but but IN 40436 4511 14 disappointment disappointment NN 40436 4511 15 . . . 40436 4512 1 No no DT 40436 4512 2 positive positive JJ 40436 4512 3 result result NN 40436 4512 4 is be VBZ 40436 4512 5 attained attain VBN 40436 4512 6 . . . 40436 4513 1 The the DT 40436 4513 2 problem problem NN 40436 4513 3 -- -- : 40436 4513 4 What what WP 40436 4513 5 is be VBZ 40436 4513 6 Temperance?--remains temperance?--remains LS 40436 4513 7 unsolved unsolved JJ 40436 4513 8 , , , 40436 4513 9 after after IN 40436 4513 10 four four CD 40436 4513 11 or or CC 40436 4513 12 five five CD 40436 4513 13 different different JJ 40436 4513 14 solutions solution NNS 40436 4513 15 have have VBP 40436 4513 16 been be VBN 40436 4513 17 successively successively RB 40436 4513 18 tested test VBN 40436 4513 19 and and CC 40436 4513 20 repudiated repudiate VBD 40436 4513 21 . . . 40436 4514 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4514 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4514 3 32 32 CD 40436 4514 4 : : : 40436 4514 5 See see VB 40436 4514 6 Appendix Appendix NNP 40436 4514 7 at at IN 40436 4514 8 end end NN 40436 4514 9 of of IN 40436 4514 10 chapter chapter NN 40436 4514 11 . . . 40436 4514 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4515 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4515 2 Side side NN 40436 4515 3 - - HYPH 40436 4515 4 note note NN 40436 4515 5 : : : 40436 4515 6 The the DT 40436 4515 7 Charmides Charmides NNPS 40436 4515 8 is be VBZ 40436 4515 9 an an DT 40436 4515 10 excellent excellent JJ 40436 4515 11 specimen speciman NNS 40436 4515 12 of of IN 40436 4515 13 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4515 14 of of IN 40436 4515 15 Search Search NNP 40436 4515 16 . . . 40436 4516 1 Abundance abundance NN 40436 4516 2 of of IN 40436 4516 3 guesses guess NNS 40436 4516 4 and and CC 40436 4516 5 tentatives tentative NNS 40436 4516 6 , , , 40436 4516 7 all all DT 40436 4516 8 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 4516 9 disallowed disallow VBD 40436 4516 10 . . . 40436 4516 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4517 1 The the DT 40436 4517 2 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4517 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4517 4 like like IN 40436 4517 5 the the DT 40436 4517 6 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4517 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4517 8 is be VBZ 40436 4517 9 a a DT 40436 4517 10 good good JJ 40436 4517 11 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 4517 12 specimen speciman NNS 40436 4517 13 of of IN 40436 4517 14 those those DT 40436 4517 15 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4517 16 of of IN 40436 4517 17 Search Search NNP 40436 4517 18 , , , 40436 4517 19 the the DT 40436 4517 20 general general JJ 40436 4517 21 character character NN 40436 4517 22 and and CC 40436 4517 23 purpose purpose NN 40436 4517 24 of of IN 40436 4517 25 which which WDT 40436 4517 26 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4517 27 have have VBP 40436 4517 28 explained explain VBN 40436 4517 29 in in IN 40436 4517 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4517 31 eighth eighth JJ 40436 4517 32 * * NFP 40436 4517 33 * * NFP 40436 4517 34 chapter chapter NN 40436 4517 35 . . . 40436 4518 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4518 2 proves prove VBZ 40436 4518 3 nothing nothing NN 40436 4518 4 : : : 40436 4518 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4518 6 disproves disprove VBZ 40436 4518 7 several several JJ 40436 4518 8 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 40436 4518 9 : : : 40436 4518 10 but but CC 40436 4518 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4518 12 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 4518 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4518 14 and and CC 40436 4518 15 therein therein RB 40436 4518 16 consists consist VBZ 40436 4518 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4518 18 value value NN 40436 4518 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4518 20 the the DT 40436 4518 21 anticipating anticipating NN 40436 4518 22 , , , 40436 4518 23 guessing guessing NN 40436 4518 24 , , , 40436 4518 25 tentative tentative JJ 40436 4518 26 , , , 40436 4518 27 and and CC 40436 4518 28 eliminating eliminate VBG 40436 4518 29 process process NN 40436 4518 30 , , , 40436 4518 31 without without IN 40436 4518 32 which which WDT 40436 4518 33 no no DT 40436 4518 34 defensible defensible JJ 40436 4518 35 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 4518 36 can can MD 40436 4518 37 be be VB 40436 4518 38 obtained obtain VBN 40436 4518 39 -- -- : 40436 4518 40 without without IN 40436 4518 41 which which WDT 40436 4518 42 , , , 40436 4518 43 even even RB 40436 4518 44 if if IN 40436 4518 45 such such JJ 40436 4518 46 be be VB 40436 4518 47 found find VBN 40436 4518 48 , , , 40436 4518 49 no no DT 40436 4518 50 advocate advocate NN 40436 4518 51 can can MD 40436 4518 52 be be VB 40436 4518 53 formed form VBN 40436 4518 54 capable capable JJ 40436 4518 55 of of IN 40436 4518 56 defending defend VBG 40436 4518 57 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4518 58 against against IN 40436 4518 59 an an DT 40436 4518 60 acute acute JJ 40436 4518 61 cross cross NN 40436 4518 62 - - NN 40436 4518 63 examiner examiner NN 40436 4518 64 . . . 40436 4519 1 In in IN 40436 4519 2 most most JJS 40436 4519 3 cases case NNS 40436 4519 4 , , , 40436 4519 5 this this DT 40436 4519 6 tentative tentative JJ 40436 4519 7 process process NN 40436 4519 8 is be VBZ 40436 4519 9 forgotten forget VBN 40436 4519 10 or or CC 40436 4519 11 ignored ignore VBN 40436 4519 12 : : : 40436 4519 13 even even RB 40436 4519 14 when when WRB 40436 4519 15 recognised recognise VBN 40436 4519 16 as as IN 40436 4519 17 a a DT 40436 4519 18 reality reality NN 40436 4519 19 , , , 40436 4519 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4519 21 is be VBZ 40436 4519 22 set set VBN 40436 4519 23 aside aside RB 40436 4519 24 with with IN 40436 4519 25 indifference indifference NN 40436 4519 26 , , , 40436 4519 27 often often RB 40436 4519 28 with with IN 40436 4519 29 ridicule ridicule NN 40436 4519 30 . . . 40436 4520 1 A a DT 40436 4520 2 writer writer NN 40436 4520 3 who who WP 40436 4520 4 believes believe VBZ 40436 4520 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4520 6 to to TO 40436 4520 7 have have VB 40436 4520 8 solved solve VBN 40436 4520 9 any any DT 40436 4520 10 problem problem NN 40436 4520 11 , , , 40436 4520 12 publishes publish VBZ 40436 4520 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4520 14 solution solution NN 40436 4520 15 together together RB 40436 4520 16 with with IN 40436 4520 17 the the DT 40436 4520 18 proofs proof NNS 40436 4520 19 ; ; , 40436 4520 20 and and CC 40436 4520 21 acquires acquire VBZ 40436 4520 22 deserved deserve VBD 40436 4520 23 credit credit NN 40436 4520 24 for for IN 40436 4520 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4520 26 , , , 40436 4520 27 if if IN 40436 4520 28 those those DT 40436 4520 29 proofs proof NNS 40436 4520 30 give give VBP 40436 4520 31 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 4520 32 . . . 40436 4521 1 But but CC 40436 4521 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4521 3 does do VBZ 40436 4521 4 not not RB 40436 4521 5 care care VB 40436 4521 6 to to TO 40436 4521 7 preserve preserve VB 40436 4521 8 , , , 40436 4521 9 nor nor CC 40436 4521 10 do do VB 40436 4521 11 the the DT 40436 4521 12 public public JJ 40436 4521 13 care care NN 40436 4521 14 to to TO 40436 4521 15 know know VB 40436 4521 16 , , , 40436 4521 17 the the DT 40436 4521 18 steps step NNS 40436 4521 19 by by IN 40436 4521 20 which which WDT 40436 4521 21 such such JJ 40436 4521 22 solution solution NN 40436 4521 23 has have VBZ 40436 4521 24 been be VBN 40436 4521 25 reached reach VBN 40436 4521 26 . . . 40436 4522 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 4522 2 in in IN 40436 4522 3 most most JJS 40436 4522 4 cases case NNS 40436 4522 5 , , , 40436 4522 6 and and CC 40436 4522 7 in in IN 40436 4522 8 all all DT 40436 4522 9 cases case NNS 40436 4522 10 involving involve VBG 40436 4522 11 much much JJ 40436 4522 12 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 4522 13 , , , 40436 4522 14 there there EX 40436 4522 15 has have VBZ 40436 4522 16 been be VBN 40436 4522 17 a a DT 40436 4522 18 process process NN 40436 4522 19 , , , 40436 4522 20 more more RBR 40436 4522 21 or or CC 40436 4522 22 less less RBR 40436 4522 23 tedious tedious JJ 40436 4522 24 , , , 40436 4522 25 of of IN 40436 4522 26 tentative tentative NN 40436 4522 27 and and CC 40436 4522 28 groping groping JJ 40436 4522 29 -- -- : 40436 4522 30 of of IN 40436 4522 31 guesses guess NNS 40436 4522 32 at at IN 40436 4522 33 first first RB 40436 4522 34 hailed hail VBN 40436 4522 35 as as IN 40436 4522 36 promising promising JJ 40436 4522 37 , , , 40436 4522 38 then then RB 40436 4522 39 followed follow VBD 40436 4522 40 out out RP 40436 4522 41 to to IN 40436 4522 42 a a DT 40436 4522 43 certain certain JJ 40436 4522 44 extent extent NN 40436 4522 45 , , , 40436 4522 46 lastly lastly RB 40436 4522 47 discovered discover VBD 40436 4522 48 to to TO 40436 4522 49 be be VB 40436 4522 50 untenable untenable JJ 40436 4522 51 . . . 40436 4523 1 The the DT 40436 4523 2 history history NN 40436 4523 3 of of IN 40436 4523 4 science,[33 science,[33 NN 40436 4523 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4523 6 astronomical astronomical JJ 40436 4523 7 , , , 40436 4523 8 physical physical JJ 40436 4523 9 , , , 40436 4523 10 chemical chemical JJ 40436 4523 11 , , , 40436 4523 12 physiological physiological JJ 40436 4523 13 , , , 40436 4523 14 & & CC 40436 4523 15 c. c. NNP 40436 4523 16 , , , 40436 4523 17 wherever wherever WRB 40436 4523 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4523 19 has have VBZ 40436 4523 20 been be VBN 40436 4523 21 at at RB 40436 4523 22 all all RB 40436 4523 23 recorded record VBN 40436 4523 24 , , , 40436 4523 25 attests attest VBZ 40436 4523 26 this this DT 40436 4523 27 constant constant JJ 40436 4523 28 antecedence antecedence NN 40436 4523 29 of of IN 40436 4523 30 a a DT 40436 4523 31 period period NN 40436 4523 32 of of IN 40436 4523 33 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4523 34 , , , 40436 4523 35 confusion confusion NN 40436 4523 36 , , , 40436 4523 37 and and CC 40436 4523 38 dispute dispute NN 40436 4523 39 , , , 40436 4523 40 even even RB 40436 4523 41 in in IN 40436 4523 42 cases case NNS 40436 4523 43 where where WRB 40436 4523 44 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 4523 45 a a DT 40436 4523 46 solution solution NN 40436 4523 47 has have VBZ 40436 4523 48 been be VBN 40436 4523 49 found find VBN 40436 4523 50 commanding command VBG 40436 4523 51 the the DT 40436 4523 52 nearly nearly RB 40436 4523 53 unanimous unanimous JJ 40436 4523 54 adhesion adhesion NN 40436 4523 55 of of IN 40436 4523 56 the the DT 40436 4523 57 scientific scientific JJ 40436 4523 58 world world NN 40436 4523 59 . . . 40436 4524 1 But but CC 40436 4524 2 on on IN 40436 4524 3 subjects subject NNS 40436 4524 4 connected connect VBN 40436 4524 5 with with IN 40436 4524 6 man man NN 40436 4524 7 and and CC 40436 4524 8 society society NN 40436 4524 9 , , , 40436 4524 10 this this DT 40436 4524 11 period period NN 40436 4524 12 of of IN 40436 4524 13 dispute dispute NN 40436 4524 14 and and CC 40436 4524 15 confusion confusion NN 40436 4524 16 continues continue VBZ 40436 4524 17 to to IN 40436 4524 18 the the DT 40436 4524 19 present present JJ 40436 4524 20 moment moment NN 40436 4524 21 . . . 40436 4525 1 No no DT 40436 4525 2 unanimity unanimity NN 40436 4525 3 has have VBZ 40436 4525 4 ever ever RB 40436 4525 5 been be VBN 40436 4525 6 approached approach VBN 40436 4525 7 , , , 40436 4525 8 among among IN 40436 4525 9 nations nation NNS 40436 4525 10 at at IN 40436 4525 11 once once RB 40436 4525 12 active active JJ 40436 4525 13 in in IN 40436 4525 14 intellect intellect NN 40436 4525 15 and and CC 40436 4525 16 enjoying enjoy VBG 40436 4525 17 tolerable tolerable JJ 40436 4525 18 liberty liberty NN 40436 4525 19 of of IN 40436 4525 20 dissent dissent NN 40436 4525 21 . . . 40436 4526 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 4526 2 -- -- : 40436 4526 3 apart apart RB 40436 4526 4 from from IN 40436 4526 5 the the DT 40436 4526 6 condition condition NN 40436 4526 7 of of IN 40436 4526 8 different different JJ 40436 4526 9 sciences science NNS 40436 4526 10 among among IN 40436 4526 11 mature mature JJ 40436 4526 12 men man NNS 40436 4526 13 -- -- : 40436 4526 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4526 15 must must MD 40436 4526 16 remember remember VB 40436 4526 17 that that IN 40436 4526 18 the the DT 40436 4526 19 transitive transitive JJ 40436 4526 20 process process NN 40436 4526 21 , , , 40436 4526 22 above above IN 40436 4526 23 described describe VBN 40436 4526 24 , , , 40436 4526 25 represents represent VBZ 40436 4526 26 the the DT 40436 4526 27 successive successive JJ 40436 4526 28 stages stage NNS 40436 4526 29 by by IN 40436 4526 30 which which WDT 40436 4526 31 every every DT 40436 4526 32 adult adult NN 40436 4526 33 mind mind NN 40436 4526 34 has have VBZ 40436 4526 35 been be VBN 40436 4526 36 gradually gradually RB 40436 4526 37 built build VBN 40436 4526 38 up up RP 40436 4526 39 from from IN 40436 4526 40 infancy infancy NN 40436 4526 41 . . . 40436 4527 1 Trial trial NN 40436 4527 2 and and CC 40436 4527 3 error error NN 40436 4527 4 -- -- : 40436 4527 5 alternate alternate JJ 40436 4527 6 guess guess NN 40436 4527 7 and and CC 40436 4527 8 rejection rejection NN 40436 4527 9 , , , 40436 4527 10 generation generation NN 40436 4527 11 and and CC 40436 4527 12 destruction destruction NN 40436 4527 13 of of IN 40436 4527 14 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 4527 15 and and CC 40436 4527 16 beliefs belief NNS 40436 4527 17 -- -- : 40436 4527 18 is be VBZ 40436 4527 19 among among IN 40436 4527 20 the the DT 40436 4527 21 most most RBS 40436 4527 22 widespread widespread JJ 40436 4527 23 facts fact NNS 40436 4527 24 of of IN 40436 4527 25 human human JJ 40436 4527 26 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4527 27 . . . 40436 4528 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4528 2 34 34 CD 40436 4528 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4528 4 Even even RB 40436 4528 5 those those DT 40436 4528 6 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 4528 7 minds mind NNS 40436 4528 8 , , , 40436 4528 9 which which WDT 40436 4528 10 in in IN 40436 4528 11 mature mature JJ 40436 4528 12 life life NN 40436 4528 13 harden harden NNS 40436 4528 14 with with IN 40436 4528 15 the the DT 40436 4528 16 most most RBS 40436 4528 17 exemplary exemplary JJ 40436 4528 18 fidelity fidelity NN 40436 4528 19 into into IN 40436 4528 20 the the DT 40436 4528 21 locally locally RB 40436 4528 22 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 4528 23 type type NN 40436 4528 24 of of IN 40436 4528 25 orthodoxy,--have orthodoxy,--have NN 40436 4528 26 all all DT 40436 4528 27 in in IN 40436 4528 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4528 29 earlier early JJR 40436 4528 30 years year NNS 40436 4528 31 gone go VBN 40436 4528 32 through through IN 40436 4528 33 that that DT 40436 4528 34 semi semi JJ 40436 4528 35 - - JJ 40436 4528 36 fluid fluid JJ 40436 4528 37 and and CC 40436 4528 38 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 40436 4528 39 period period NN 40436 4528 40 , , , 40436 4528 41 in in IN 40436 4528 42 which which WDT 40436 4528 43 the the DT 40436 4528 44 type type NN 40436 4528 45 to to TO 40436 4528 46 come come VB 40436 4528 47 is be VBZ 40436 4528 48 yet yet RB 40436 4528 49 a a DT 40436 4528 50 matter matter NN 40436 4528 51 of of IN 40436 4528 52 doubt doubt NN 40436 4528 53 -- -- : 40436 4528 54 in in IN 40436 4528 55 which which WDT 40436 4528 56 the the DT 40436 4528 57 head head NN 40436 4528 58 might may MD 40436 4528 59 have have VB 40436 4528 60 been be VBN 40436 4528 61 permanently permanently RB 40436 4528 62 lengthened lengthen VBN 40436 4528 63 or or CC 40436 4528 64 permanently permanently RB 40436 4528 65 flattened flatten VBN 40436 4528 66 , , , 40436 4528 67 according accord VBG 40436 4528 68 to to IN 40436 4528 69 the the DT 40436 4528 70 direction direction NN 40436 4528 71 in in IN 40436 4528 72 which which WDT 40436 4528 73 pressure pressure NN 40436 4528 74 was be VBD 40436 4528 75 applied apply VBN 40436 4528 76 . . . 40436 4529 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4529 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4529 3 33 33 CD 40436 4529 4 : : : 40436 4529 5 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4529 6 is be VBZ 40436 4529 7 not not RB 40436 4529 8 often often RB 40436 4529 9 that that IN 40436 4529 10 historians historian NNS 40436 4529 11 of of IN 40436 4529 12 science science NN 40436 4529 13 take take VBP 40436 4529 14 much much JJ 40436 4529 15 pains pain NNS 40436 4529 16 to to TO 40436 4529 17 preserve preserve VB 40436 4529 18 and and CC 40436 4529 19 bring bring VB 40436 4529 20 together together RB 40436 4529 21 the the DT 40436 4529 22 mistaken mistaken JJ 40436 4529 23 guesses guess NNS 40436 4529 24 and and CC 40436 4529 25 tentatives tentative NNS 40436 4529 26 which which WDT 40436 4529 27 have have VBP 40436 4529 28 preceded precede VBN 40436 4529 29 great great JJ 40436 4529 30 physical physical JJ 40436 4529 31 discoveries discovery NNS 40436 4529 32 . . . 40436 4530 1 One one CD 40436 4530 2 instance instance NN 40436 4530 3 in in IN 40436 4530 4 which which WDT 40436 4530 5 this this DT 40436 4530 6 has have VBZ 40436 4530 7 been be VBN 40436 4530 8 ably ably RB 40436 4530 9 and and CC 40436 4530 10 carefully carefully RB 40436 4530 11 done do VBN 40436 4530 12 is be VBZ 40436 4530 13 in in IN 40436 4530 14 the the DT 40436 4530 15 ' ' `` 40436 4530 16 Biography Biography NNP 40436 4530 17 of of IN 40436 4530 18 Cavendish Cavendish NNP 40436 4530 19 , , , 40436 4530 20 ' ' '' 40436 4530 21 the the DT 40436 4530 22 chemist chemist NN 40436 4530 23 and and CC 40436 4530 24 natural natural JJ 40436 4530 25 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 4530 26 , , , 40436 4530 27 by by IN 40436 4530 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 4530 29 Geo Geo NNP 40436 4530 30 . . . 40436 4531 1 Wilson Wilson NNP 40436 4531 2 . . . 40436 4532 1 The the DT 40436 4532 2 great great JJ 40436 4532 3 chemical chemical JJ 40436 4532 4 discovery discovery NN 40436 4532 5 of of IN 40436 4532 6 the the DT 40436 4532 7 composition composition NN 40436 4532 8 of of IN 40436 4532 9 water water NN 40436 4532 10 , , , 40436 4532 11 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 4532 12 during during IN 40436 4532 13 the the DT 40436 4532 14 last last JJ 40436 4532 15 quarter quarter NN 40436 4532 16 of of IN 40436 4532 17 the the DT 40436 4532 18 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 40436 4532 19 century century NN 40436 4532 20 , , , 40436 4532 21 has have VBZ 40436 4532 22 been be VBN 40436 4532 23 claimed claim VBN 40436 4532 24 as as IN 40436 4532 25 the the DT 40436 4532 26 privilege privilege NN 40436 4532 27 of of IN 40436 4532 28 three three CD 40436 4532 29 eminent eminent JJ 40436 4532 30 scientific scientific JJ 40436 4532 31 men man NNS 40436 4532 32 -- -- : 40436 4532 33 Cavendish Cavendish NNP 40436 4532 34 , , , 40436 4532 35 Watt Watt NNP 40436 4532 36 , , , 40436 4532 37 and and CC 40436 4532 38 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 40436 4532 39 . . . 40436 4533 1 The the DT 40436 4533 2 controversy controversy NN 40436 4533 3 on on IN 40436 4533 4 the the DT 40436 4533 5 subject subject JJ 40436 4533 6 , , , 40436 4533 7 voluminous voluminous JJ 40436 4533 8 and and CC 40436 4533 9 bitter bitter JJ 40436 4533 10 , , , 40436 4533 11 has have VBZ 40436 4533 12 been be VBN 40436 4533 13 the the DT 40436 4533 14 means mean NNS 40436 4533 15 of of IN 40436 4533 16 recording record VBG 40436 4533 17 each each DT 40436 4533 18 successive successive JJ 40436 4533 19 scientific scientific JJ 40436 4533 20 phase phase NN 40436 4533 21 and and CC 40436 4533 22 point point NN 40436 4533 23 of of IN 40436 4533 24 view view NN 40436 4533 25 . . . 40436 4534 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4534 2 will will MD 40436 4534 3 be be VB 40436 4534 4 found find VBN 40436 4534 5 admirably admirably RB 40436 4534 6 expounded expound VBN 40436 4534 7 in in IN 40436 4534 8 this this DT 40436 4534 9 biography biography NN 40436 4534 10 . . . 40436 4535 1 Wilson Wilson NNP 40436 4535 2 sets set VBZ 40436 4535 3 forth forth RB 40436 4535 4 the the DT 40436 4535 5 misconceptions misconception NNS 40436 4535 6 , , , 40436 4535 7 confusion confusion NN 40436 4535 8 of of IN 40436 4535 9 ideas idea NNS 40436 4535 10 , , , 40436 4535 11 approximations approximation NNS 40436 4535 12 to to IN 40436 4535 13 truth truth NN 40436 4535 14 seen see VBN 40436 4535 15 but but CC 40436 4535 16 not not RB 40436 4535 17 followed follow VBN 40436 4535 18 out out RP 40436 4535 19 , , , 40436 4535 20 & & CC 40436 4535 21 c. c. NNP 40436 4535 22 , , , 40436 4535 23 which which WDT 40436 4535 24 prevailed prevail VBD 40436 4535 25 upon upon IN 40436 4535 26 the the DT 40436 4535 27 scientific scientific JJ 40436 4535 28 men man NNS 40436 4535 29 of of IN 40436 4535 30 that that DT 40436 4535 31 day day NN 40436 4535 32 , , , 40436 4535 33 especially especially RB 40436 4535 34 under under IN 40436 4535 35 the the DT 40436 4535 36 misleading misleading JJ 40436 4535 37 influence influence NN 40436 4535 38 of of IN 40436 4535 39 the the DT 40436 4535 40 " " `` 40436 4535 41 phlogiston phlogiston NNP 40436 4535 42 theory theory NN 40436 4535 43 , , , 40436 4535 44 " " '' 40436 4535 45 then then RB 40436 4535 46 universally universally RB 40436 4535 47 received receive VBN 40436 4535 48 . . . 40436 4536 1 To to IN 40436 4536 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4536 3 such such PDT 40436 4536 4 a a DT 40436 4536 5 period period NN 40436 4536 6 of of IN 40436 4536 7 mental mental JJ 40436 4536 8 confusion confusion NN 40436 4536 9 would would MD 40436 4536 10 have have VB 40436 4536 11 been be VBN 40436 4536 12 in in IN 40436 4536 13 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4536 14 an an DT 40436 4536 15 interesting interesting JJ 40436 4536 16 object object NN 40436 4536 17 for for IN 40436 4536 18 contemplation contemplation NN 40436 4536 19 and and CC 40436 4536 20 description description NN 40436 4536 21 . . . 40436 4537 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4537 2 might may MD 40436 4537 3 have have VB 40436 4537 4 dramatised dramatise VBN 40436 4537 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4537 6 under under IN 40436 4537 7 the the DT 40436 4537 8 names name NNS 40436 4537 9 of of IN 40436 4537 10 various various JJ 40436 4537 11 disputants disputant NNS 40436 4537 12 , , , 40436 4537 13 with with IN 40436 4537 14 the the DT 40436 4537 15 cross cross NN 40436 4537 16 - - HYPH 40436 4537 17 examining examine VBG 40436 4537 18 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 4537 19 , , , 40436 4537 20 personified personify VBN 40436 4537 21 in in IN 40436 4537 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4537 23 , , , 40436 4537 24 introduced introduce VBN 40436 4537 25 to to TO 40436 4537 26 stir stir VB 40436 4537 27 up up RP 40436 4537 28 the the DT 40436 4537 29 debate debate NN 40436 4537 30 , , , 40436 4537 31 either either CC 40436 4537 32 by by IN 40436 4537 33 first first RB 40436 4537 34 advocating advocating NN 40436 4537 35 , , , 40436 4537 36 then then RB 40436 4537 37 refuting refute VBG 40436 4537 38 , , , 40436 4537 39 a a DT 40436 4537 40 string string NN 40436 4537 41 of of IN 40436 4537 42 successive successive JJ 40436 4537 43 guesses guess NNS 40436 4537 44 and and CC 40436 4537 45 dreams dream NNS 40436 4537 46 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4537 47 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4537 48 , , , 40436 4537 49 173 173 CD 40436 4537 50 A a NN 40436 4537 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4537 52 of of IN 40436 4537 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4537 54 own own JJ 40436 4537 55 , , , 40436 4537 56 or or CC 40436 4537 57 by by IN 40436 4537 58 exposing expose VBG 40436 4537 59 similar similar JJ 40436 4537 60 suggestions suggestion NNS 40436 4537 61 emanating emanate VBG 40436 4537 62 from from IN 40436 4537 63 others other NNS 40436 4537 64 ; ; : 40436 4537 65 especially especially RB 40436 4537 66 in in IN 40436 4537 67 regard regard NN 40436 4537 68 to to IN 40436 4537 69 the the DT 40436 4537 70 definition definition NN 40436 4537 71 of of IN 40436 4537 72 _ _ NNP 40436 4537 73 phlogiston phlogiston NNP 40436 4537 74 _ _ NNP 40436 4537 75 , , , 40436 4537 76 an an DT 40436 4537 77 entity entity NN 40436 4537 78 which which WDT 40436 4537 79 then then RB 40436 4537 80 overspread overspread VBD 40436 4537 81 and and CC 40436 4537 82 darkened darken VBD 40436 4537 83 all all DT 40436 4537 84 chemical chemical NN 40436 4537 85 speculation speculation NN 40436 4537 86 , , , 40436 4537 87 but but CC 40436 4537 88 which which WDT 40436 4537 89 every every DT 40436 4537 90 theorist theorist NN 40436 4537 91 thought think VBD 40436 4537 92 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4537 93 obliged oblige VBD 40436 4537 94 to to TO 40436 4537 95 define define VB 40436 4537 96 . . . 40436 4538 1 The the DT 40436 4538 2 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4538 3 would would MD 40436 4538 4 have have VB 40436 4538 5 ended end VBN 40436 4538 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4538 7 as as IN 40436 4538 8 the the DT 40436 4538 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 4538 10 , , , 40436 4538 11 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4538 12 , , , 40436 4538 13 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4538 14 , , , 40436 4538 15 & & CC 40436 4538 16 c. c. NNP 40436 4538 17 , , , 40436 4538 18 now now RB 40436 4538 19 end end VBP 40436 4538 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4538 21 by by IN 40436 4538 22 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4538 23 deriding deride VBG 40436 4538 24 the the DT 40436 4538 25 ill ill JJ 40436 4538 26 success success NN 40436 4538 27 which which WDT 40436 4538 28 had have VBD 40436 4538 29 attended attend VBN 40436 4538 30 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4538 31 in in IN 40436 4538 32 the the DT 40436 4538 33 search search NN 40436 4538 34 for for IN 40436 4538 35 an an DT 40436 4538 36 explanation explanation NN 40436 4538 37 , , , 40436 4538 38 and and CC 40436 4538 39 by by IN 40436 4538 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4538 41 pointing pointing NN 40436 4538 42 out out RP 40436 4538 43 that that IN 40436 4538 44 while while IN 40436 4538 45 all all PDT 40436 4538 46 the the DT 40436 4538 47 theorists theorist NNS 40436 4538 48 talked talk VBD 40436 4538 49 familiarly familiarly RB 40436 4538 50 about about IN 40436 4538 51 _ _ NNP 40436 4538 52 phlogiston phlogiston NNP 40436 4538 53 _ _ NNP 40436 4538 54 as as IN 40436 4538 55 a a DT 40436 4538 56 powerful powerful JJ 40436 4538 57 agent agent NN 40436 4538 58 , , , 40436 4538 59 none none NN 40436 4538 60 of of IN 40436 4538 61 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4538 62 could could MD 40436 4538 63 agree agree VB 40436 4538 64 what what WP 40436 4538 65 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4538 66 was be VBD 40436 4538 67 . . . 40436 4539 1 See see VB 40436 4539 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 4539 3 Wilson Wilson NNP 40436 4539 4 's 's POS 40436 4539 5 ' ' `` 40436 4539 6 Biography Biography NNP 40436 4539 7 of of IN 40436 4539 8 Cavendish Cavendish NNP 40436 4539 9 , , , 40436 4539 10 ' ' '' 40436 4539 11 pp pp NN 40436 4539 12 . . . 40436 4540 1 36 36 CD 40436 4540 2 - - SYM 40436 4540 3 198 198 CD 40436 4540 4 - - HYPH 40436 4540 5 320 320 CD 40436 4540 6 - - HYPH 40436 4540 7 325 325 CD 40436 4540 8 , , , 40436 4540 9 and and CC 40436 4540 10 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 4540 11 . . . 40436 4540 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4541 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4541 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4541 3 34 34 CD 40436 4541 4 : : : 40436 4541 5 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4541 6 is be VBZ 40436 4541 7 strikingly strikingly RB 40436 4541 8 described describe VBN 40436 4541 9 by by IN 40436 4541 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4541 11 in in IN 40436 4541 12 one one CD 40436 4541 13 of of IN 40436 4541 14 the the DT 40436 4541 15 most most RBS 40436 4541 16 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 4541 17 passages passage NNS 40436 4541 18 of of IN 40436 4541 19 the the DT 40436 4541 20 speech speech NN 40436 4541 21 of of IN 40436 4541 22 Diotima Diotima NNP 40436 4541 23 in in IN 40436 4541 24 the the DT 40436 4541 25 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 4541 26 , , , 40436 4541 27 pp pp NNP 40436 4541 28 . . . 40436 4542 1 207 207 CD 40436 4542 2 - - SYM 40436 4542 3 208 208 CD 40436 4542 4 . . . 40436 4542 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4543 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4543 2 Side side NN 40436 4543 3 - - HYPH 40436 4543 4 note note NN 40436 4543 5 : : : 40436 4543 6 Trial trial NN 40436 4543 7 and and CC 40436 4543 8 Error Error NNP 40436 4543 9 , , , 40436 4543 10 the the DT 40436 4543 11 natural natural JJ 40436 4543 12 process process NN 40436 4543 13 of of IN 40436 4543 14 the the DT 40436 4543 15 human human JJ 40436 4543 16 mind mind NN 40436 4543 17 . . . 40436 4544 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4544 2 stands stand VBZ 40436 4544 3 alone alone RB 40436 4544 4 in in IN 40436 4544 5 bringing bring VBG 40436 4544 6 to to TO 40436 4544 7 view view VB 40436 4544 8 and and CC 40436 4544 9 dramatising dramatise VBG 40436 4544 10 this this DT 40436 4544 11 part part NN 40436 4544 12 of of IN 40436 4544 13 the the DT 40436 4544 14 mental mental JJ 40436 4544 15 process process NN 40436 4544 16 . . . 40436 4545 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4545 2 accepts accept VBZ 40436 4545 3 for for IN 40436 4545 4 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4545 5 the the DT 40436 4545 6 condition condition NN 40436 4545 7 of of IN 40436 4545 8 conscious conscious JJ 40436 4545 9 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4545 10 . . . 40436 4545 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4546 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4546 2 shall shall MD 40436 4546 3 follow follow VB 40436 4546 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4546 5 towards towards IN 40436 4546 6 the the DT 40436 4546 7 close close NN 40436 4546 8 of of IN 40436 4546 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4546 10 career career NN 40436 4546 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4546 12 Treatise Treatise NNP 40436 4546 13 De De NNP 40436 4546 14 Legibus Legibus NNP 40436 4546 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4546 16 , , , 40436 4546 17 into into IN 40436 4546 18 an an DT 40436 4546 19 imperative imperative JJ 40436 4546 20 and and CC 40436 4546 21 stationary stationary JJ 40436 4546 22 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 40436 4546 23 of of IN 40436 4546 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4546 25 own own JJ 40436 4546 26 : : : 40436 4546 27 but but CC 40436 4546 28 in in IN 40436 4546 29 the the DT 40436 4546 30 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4546 31 which which WDT 40436 4546 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4546 33 have have VBP 40436 4546 34 already already RB 40436 4546 35 reviewed review VBN 40436 4546 36 , , , 40436 4546 37 as as RB 40436 4546 38 well well RB 40436 4546 39 as as IN 40436 4546 40 in in IN 40436 4546 41 several several JJ 40436 4546 42 others other NNS 40436 4546 43 which which WDT 40436 4546 44 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4546 45 shall shall MD 40436 4546 46 presently presently RB 40436 4546 47 notice notice VB 40436 4546 48 , , , 40436 4546 49 no no DT 40436 4546 50 mention mention NN 40436 4546 51 is be VBZ 40436 4546 52 made make VBN 40436 4546 53 of of IN 40436 4546 54 any any DT 40436 4546 55 given give VBN 40436 4546 56 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 4546 57 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 4546 58 as as IN 40436 4546 59 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 4546 60 to to TO 40436 4546 61 arrive arrive VB 40436 4546 62 at at IN 40436 4546 63 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 4546 64 . . . 40436 4547 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4547 2 here here RB 40436 4547 3 concentrates concentrate VBZ 40436 4547 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4547 5 attention attention NN 40436 4547 6 upon upon IN 40436 4547 7 the the DT 40436 4547 8 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 40436 4547 9 period period NN 40436 4547 10 of of IN 40436 4547 11 the the DT 40436 4547 12 mind mind NN 40436 4547 13 : : : 40436 4547 14 looking look VBG 40436 4547 15 upon upon IN 40436 4547 16 the the DT 40436 4547 17 mind mind NN 40436 4547 18 not not RB 40436 4547 19 as as IN 40436 4547 20 an an DT 40436 4547 21 empty empty JJ 40436 4547 22 vessel vessel NN 40436 4547 23 , , , 40436 4547 24 requiring require VBG 40436 4547 25 to to TO 40436 4547 26 be be VB 40436 4547 27 filled fill VBN 40436 4547 28 by by IN 40436 4547 29 ready ready JJ 40436 4547 30 - - HYPH 40436 4547 31 made make VBN 40436 4547 32 matter matter NN 40436 4547 33 from from IN 40436 4547 34 without without IN 40436 4547 35 -- -- : 40436 4547 36 nor nor CC 40436 4547 37 as as IN 40436 4547 38 a a DT 40436 4547 39 blank blank JJ 40436 4547 40 sheet sheet NN 40436 4547 41 , , , 40436 4547 42 awaiting await VBG 40436 4547 43 a a DT 40436 4547 44 foreign foreign JJ 40436 4547 45 hand hand NN 40436 4547 46 to to TO 40436 4547 47 write write VB 40436 4547 48 characters character NNS 40436 4547 49 upon upon IN 40436 4547 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4547 51 -- -- : 40436 4547 52 but but CC 40436 4547 53 as as IN 40436 4547 54 an an DT 40436 4547 55 assemblage assemblage NN 40436 4547 56 of of IN 40436 4547 57 latent latent JJ 40436 4547 58 capacities capacity NNS 40436 4547 59 , , , 40436 4547 60 which which WDT 40436 4547 61 must must MD 40436 4547 62 be be VB 40436 4547 63 called call VBN 40436 4547 64 into into IN 40436 4547 65 action action NN 40436 4547 66 by by IN 40436 4547 67 stimulus stimulus NN 40436 4547 68 and and CC 40436 4547 69 example example NN 40436 4547 70 , , , 40436 4547 71 but but CC 40436 4547 72 which which WDT 40436 4547 73 can can MD 40436 4547 74 only only RB 40436 4547 75 attain attain VB 40436 4547 76 improvement improvement NN 40436 4547 77 through through IN 40436 4547 78 multiplied multiplied JJ 40436 4547 79 trials trial NNS 40436 4547 80 and and CC 40436 4547 81 multiplied multiply VBN 40436 4547 82 failures failure NNS 40436 4547 83 . . . 40436 4548 1 Whereas whereas IN 40436 4548 2 in in IN 40436 4548 3 most most JJS 40436 4548 4 cases case NNS 40436 4548 5 these these DT 40436 4548 6 failures failure NNS 40436 4548 7 are be VBP 40436 4548 8 forgotten forget VBN 40436 4548 9 , , , 40436 4548 10 the the DT 40436 4548 11 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 4548 12 of of IN 40436 4548 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4548 14 consists consist VBZ 40436 4548 15 in in IN 40436 4548 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4548 17 bringing bring VBG 40436 4548 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4548 19 to to TO 40436 4548 20 view view VB 40436 4548 21 with with IN 40436 4548 22 full full JJ 40436 4548 23 detail detail NN 40436 4548 24 , , , 40436 4548 25 explaining explain VBG 40436 4548 26 the the DT 40436 4548 27 reasons reason NNS 40436 4548 28 of of IN 40436 4548 29 each each DT 40436 4548 30 . . . 40436 4549 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4549 2 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40436 4549 3 abundantly abundantly RB 40436 4549 4 , , , 40436 4549 5 and and CC 40436 4549 6 dramatises dramatise NNS 40436 4549 7 with with IN 40436 4549 8 the the DT 40436 4549 9 greatest great JJS 40436 4549 10 vivacity vivacity NN 40436 4549 11 , , , 40436 4549 12 the the DT 40436 4549 13 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 4549 14 process process NN 40436 4549 15 whereby whereby WRB 40436 4549 16 opinions opinion NNS 40436 4549 17 are be VBP 40436 4549 18 broached broach VBN 40436 4549 19 , , , 40436 4549 20 at at IN 40436 4549 21 first first RB 40436 4549 22 adopted adopt VBN 40436 4549 23 , , , 40436 4549 24 then then RB 40436 4549 25 mistrusted mistrusted JJ 40436 4549 26 , , , 40436 4549 27 unmade unmade JJ 40436 4549 28 , , , 40436 4549 29 and and CC 40436 4549 30 re re NNS 40436 4549 31 - - VBN 40436 4549 32 made make VBN 40436 4549 33 -- -- : 40436 4549 34 or or CC 40436 4549 35 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 4549 36 not not RB 40436 4549 37 re re VB 40436 4549 38 - - VBN 40436 4549 39 made make VBN 40436 4549 40 at at RB 40436 4549 41 all all RB 40436 4549 42 , , , 40436 4549 43 but but CC 40436 4549 44 exchanged exchange VBD 40436 4549 45 for for IN 40436 4549 46 a a DT 40436 4549 47 state state NN 40436 4549 48 of of IN 40436 4549 49 conscious conscious JJ 40436 4549 50 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4549 51 . . . 40436 4550 1 The the DT 40436 4550 2 great great JJ 40436 4550 3 hero hero NN 40436 4550 4 and and CC 40436 4550 5 operator operator NN 40436 4550 6 in in IN 40436 4550 7 this this DT 40436 4550 8 process process NN 40436 4550 9 is be VBZ 40436 4550 10 the the DT 40436 4550 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 4550 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4550 13 , , , 40436 4550 14 who who WP 40436 4550 15 accepts accept VBZ 40436 4550 16 for for IN 40436 4550 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4550 18 this this DT 40436 4550 19 condition condition NN 40436 4550 20 of of IN 40436 4550 21 conscious conscious JJ 40436 4550 22 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4550 23 , , , 40436 4550 24 and and CC 40436 4550 25 even even RB 40436 4550 26 makes make VBZ 40436 4550 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4550 28 a a DT 40436 4550 29 matter matter NN 40436 4550 30 of of IN 40436 4550 31 comparative comparative JJ 40436 4550 32 pride pride NN 40436 4550 33 , , , 40436 4550 34 that that IN 40436 4550 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4550 36 stands stand VBZ 40436 4550 37 nearly nearly RB 40436 4550 38 alone alone RB 40436 4550 39 in in IN 40436 4550 40 such such JJ 40436 4550 41 confession confession NN 40436 4550 42 . . . 40436 4551 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4551 2 35 35 CD 40436 4551 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4551 4 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4551 5 colloquial colloquial JJ 40436 4551 6 influence influence NN 40436 4551 7 , , , 40436 4551 8 working work VBG 40436 4551 9 powerfully powerfully RB 40436 4551 10 and and CC 40436 4551 11 almost almost RB 40436 4551 12 preternaturally,[36 preternaturally,[36 CD 40436 4551 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4551 14 not not RB 40436 4551 15 only only RB 40436 4551 16 serves serve VBZ 40436 4551 17 both both DT 40436 4551 18 to to TO 40436 4551 19 spur spur VB 40436 4551 20 and and CC 40436 4551 21 to to TO 40436 4551 22 direct direct VB 40436 4551 23 the the DT 40436 4551 24 activity activity NN 40436 4551 25 of of IN 40436 4551 26 hearers hearer NNS 40436 4551 27 still still RB 40436 4551 28 youthful youthful JJ 40436 4551 29 and and CC 40436 4551 30 undecided undecided JJ 40436 4551 31 , , , 40436 4551 32 but but CC 40436 4551 33 also also RB 40436 4551 34 exposes expose VBZ 40436 4551 35 those those DT 40436 4551 36 who who WP 40436 4551 37 have have VBP 40436 4551 38 already already RB 40436 4551 39 made make VBN 40436 4551 40 up up RP 40436 4551 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4551 42 minds mind NNS 40436 4551 43 and and CC 40436 4551 44 confidently confidently RB 40436 4551 45 believe believe VB 40436 4551 46 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 4551 47 to to TO 40436 4551 48 know know VB 40436 4551 49 . . . 40436 4552 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4552 2 brings bring VBZ 40436 4552 3 back back RB 40436 4552 4 these these DT 40436 4552 5 latter latter JJ 40436 4552 6 from from IN 40436 4552 7 the the DT 40436 4552 8 false false JJ 40436 4552 9 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 4552 10 of of IN 40436 4552 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4552 12 to to IN 40436 4552 13 the the DT 40436 4552 14 state state NN 40436 4552 15 of of IN 40436 4552 16 conscious conscious JJ 40436 4552 17 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4552 18 , , , 40436 4552 19 and and CC 40436 4552 20 to to IN 40436 4552 21 the the DT 40436 4552 22 prior prior JJ 40436 4552 23 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 40436 4552 24 condition condition NN 40436 4552 25 of of IN 40436 4552 26 mind mind NN 40436 4552 27 , , , 40436 4552 28 in in IN 40436 4552 29 which which WDT 40436 4552 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4552 31 opinions opinion NNS 40436 4552 32 have have VBP 40436 4552 33 again again RB 40436 4552 34 to to TO 40436 4552 35 be be VB 40436 4552 36 put put VBN 40436 4552 37 together together RP 40436 4552 38 by by IN 40436 4552 39 the the DT 40436 4552 40 tentative tentative NN 40436 4552 41 and and CC 40436 4552 42 guessing guessing NN 40436 4552 43 process process NN 40436 4552 44 . . . 40436 4553 1 This this DT 40436 4553 2 tentative tentative JJ 40436 4553 3 process process NN 40436 4553 4 , , , 40436 4553 5 prosecuted prosecute VBN 40436 4553 6 under under IN 40436 4553 7 the the DT 40436 4553 8 drill drill NN 40436 4553 9 of of IN 40436 4553 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4553 11 , , , 40436 4553 12 is be VBZ 40436 4553 13 in in IN 40436 4553 14 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4553 15 full full JJ 40436 4553 16 of of IN 40436 4553 17 charm charm NN 40436 4553 18 and and CC 40436 4553 19 interest interest NN 40436 4553 20 for for IN 40436 4553 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4553 22 , , , 40436 4553 23 whether whether IN 40436 4553 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4553 25 ends end VBZ 40436 4553 26 by by IN 40436 4553 27 finding find VBG 40436 4553 28 a a DT 40436 4553 29 good good JJ 40436 4553 30 solution solution NN 40436 4553 31 or or CC 40436 4553 32 only only RB 40436 4553 33 by by IN 40436 4553 34 discarding discard VBG 40436 4553 35 a a DT 40436 4553 36 bad bad JJ 40436 4553 37 one one NN 40436 4553 38 . . . 40436 4554 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4554 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4554 3 35 35 CD 40436 4554 4 : : : 40436 4554 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4554 6 , , , 40436 4554 7 Apolog Apolog NNP 40436 4554 8 . . . 40436 4555 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 4555 2 . . . 40436 4556 1 pp pp NNP 40436 4556 2 . . . 40436 4557 1 21 21 CD 40436 4557 2 - - HYPH 40436 4557 3 22 22 CD 40436 4557 4 - - HYPH 40436 4557 5 23 23 CD 40436 4557 6 . . . 40436 4557 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4558 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4558 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4558 3 36 36 CD 40436 4558 4 : : : 40436 4558 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4558 6 , , , 40436 4558 7 Symposion symposion NN 40436 4558 8 , , , 40436 4558 9 213 213 CD 40436 4558 10 E e NN 40436 4558 11 , , , 40436 4558 12 215 215 CD 40436 4558 13 - - SYM 40436 4558 14 216 216 CD 40436 4558 15 ; ; : 40436 4558 16 Menon Menon NNP 40436 4558 17 , , , 40436 4558 18 80 80 CD 40436 4558 19 A A NNP 40436 4558 20 - - HYPH 40436 4558 21 B. b. NN 40436 4558 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4559 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4559 2 Side side NN 40436 4559 3 - - HYPH 40436 4559 4 note note NN 40436 4559 5 : : : 40436 4559 6 Familiar familiar JJ 40436 4559 7 words word NNS 40436 4559 8 -- -- : 40436 4559 9 constantly constantly RB 40436 4559 10 used use VBN 40436 4559 11 , , , 40436 4559 12 with with IN 40436 4559 13 much much RB 40436 4559 14 earnest earnest JJ 40436 4559 15 feeling feeling NN 40436 4559 16 , , , 40436 4559 17 but but CC 40436 4559 18 never never RB 40436 4559 19 understood understand VBD 40436 4559 20 nor nor CC 40436 4559 21 defined define VBN 40436 4559 22 -- -- : 40436 4559 23 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 4559 24 phenomenon phenomenon NN 40436 4559 25 in in IN 40436 4559 26 human human JJ 40436 4559 27 society society NN 40436 4559 28 . . . 40436 4559 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4560 1 The the DT 40436 4560 2 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4560 3 is be VBZ 40436 4560 4 one one CD 40436 4560 5 of of IN 40436 4560 6 the the DT 40436 4560 7 many many JJ 40436 4560 8 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 4560 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4560 10 wherein wherein WRB 40436 4560 11 such such JJ 40436 4560 12 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 4560 13 experimentation experimentation NN 40436 4560 14 appears appear VBZ 40436 4560 15 depicted depict VBN 40436 4560 16 without without IN 40436 4560 17 any any DT 40436 4560 18 positive positive JJ 40436 4560 19 result result NN 40436 4560 20 : : : 40436 4560 21 except except IN 40436 4560 22 as as IN 40436 4560 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4560 24 adds add VBZ 40436 4560 25 fresh fresh JJ 40436 4560 26 matter matter NN 40436 4560 27 to to TO 40436 4560 28 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 4560 29 that that IN 40436 4560 30 wide wide RB 40436 4560 31 - - HYPH 40436 4560 32 spread spread NN 40436 4560 33 mental mental JJ 40436 4560 34 fact,--(which fact,--(which NN 40436 4560 35 has have VBZ 40436 4560 36 already already RB 40436 4560 37 come come VBN 40436 4560 38 before before IN 40436 4560 39 the the DT 40436 4560 40 reader reader NN 40436 4560 41 , , , 40436 4560 42 in in IN 40436 4560 43 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 4560 44 , , , 40436 4560 45 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 4560 46 , , , 40436 4560 47 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 4560 48 , , , 40436 4560 49 Erastæ Erastæ NNP 40436 4560 50 , , , 40436 4560 51 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4560 52 , , , 40436 4560 53 & & CC 40436 4560 54 c. c. NNP 40436 4560 55 , , , 40436 4560 56 as as IN 40436 4560 57 to to IN 40436 4560 58 holiness holiness NN 40436 4560 59 , , , 40436 4560 60 beauty beauty NN 40436 4560 61 , , , 40436 4560 62 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 4560 63 , , , 40436 4560 64 courage courage NN 40436 4560 65 , , , 40436 4560 66 & & CC 40436 4560 67 c. c. NNP 40436 4560 68 , , , 40436 4560 69 and and CC 40436 4560 70 is be VBZ 40436 4560 71 now now RB 40436 4560 72 brought bring VBN 40436 4560 73 to to TO 40436 4560 74 view view VB 40436 4560 75 in in IN 40436 4560 76 the the DT 40436 4560 77 case case NN 40436 4560 78 of of IN 40436 4560 79 _ _ NNP 40436 4560 80 temperance temperance NN 40436 4560 81 _ _ NNP 40436 4560 82 also also RB 40436 4560 83 ; ; : 40436 4560 84 all all DT 40436 4560 85 of of IN 40436 4560 86 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4560 87 words word NNS 40436 4560 88 in in IN 40436 4560 89 every every DT 40436 4560 90 one one NN 40436 4560 91 's 's POS 40436 4560 92 mouth mouth NN 40436 4560 93 , , , 40436 4560 94 and and CC 40436 4560 95 tacitly tacitly RB 40436 4560 96 assumed assume VBN 40436 4560 97 by by IN 40436 4560 98 every every DT 40436 4560 99 one one CD 40436 4560 100 as as IN 40436 4560 101 known know VBN 40436 4560 102 quantities quantity NNS 40436 4560 103 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4560 104 the the DT 40436 4560 105 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 4560 106 and and CC 40436 4560 107 confident confident JJ 40436 4560 108 judgments judgment NNS 40436 4560 109 which which WDT 40436 4560 110 mankind mankind NN 40436 4560 111 are be VBP 40436 4560 112 in in IN 40436 4560 113 the the DT 40436 4560 114 habit habit NN 40436 4560 115 of of IN 40436 4560 116 delivering deliver VBG 40436 4560 117 -- -- : 40436 4560 118 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4560 119 apportionment apportionment NN 40436 4560 120 of of IN 40436 4560 121 praise praise NN 40436 4560 122 and and CC 40436 4560 123 blame blame NN 40436 4560 124 , , , 40436 4560 125 as as RB 40436 4560 126 well well RB 40436 4560 127 as as IN 40436 4560 128 of of IN 40436 4560 129 reward reward NN 40436 4560 130 and and CC 40436 4560 131 punishment punishment NN 40436 4560 132 consequent consequent NN 40436 4560 133 on on IN 40436 4560 134 praise praise NN 40436 4560 135 and and CC 40436 4560 136 blame blame NN 40436 4560 137 -- -- : 40436 4560 138 without without IN 40436 4560 139 any any DT 40436 4560 140 better well JJR 40436 4560 141 basis basis NN 40436 4560 142 than than IN 40436 4560 143 that that DT 40436 4560 144 of of IN 40436 4560 145 strong strong JJ 40436 4560 146 emotion emotion NN 40436 4560 147 imbibed imbibe VBD 40436 4560 148 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4560 149 know know VBP 40436 4560 150 not not RB 40436 4560 151 how how WRB 40436 4560 152 , , , 40436 4560 153 and and CC 40436 4560 154 without without IN 40436 4560 155 being be VBG 40436 4560 156 able able JJ 40436 4560 157 to to TO 40436 4560 158 render render VB 40436 4560 159 any any DT 40436 4560 160 rational rational JJ 40436 4560 161 explanation explanation NN 40436 4560 162 even even RB 40436 4560 163 of of IN 40436 4560 164 the the DT 40436 4560 165 familiar familiar JJ 40436 4560 166 words word NNS 40436 4560 167 round round IN 40436 4560 168 which which WDT 40436 4560 169 such such JJ 40436 4560 170 emotions emotion NNS 40436 4560 171 are be VBP 40436 4560 172 grouped group VBN 40436 4560 173 . . . 40436 4561 1 No no DT 40436 4561 2 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 4561 3 has have VBZ 40436 4561 4 done do VBN 40436 4561 5 so so RB 40436 4561 6 much much RB 40436 4561 7 as as IN 40436 4561 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4561 9 to to TO 40436 4561 10 depict depict VB 40436 4561 11 in in IN 40436 4561 12 detail detail NN 40436 4561 13 this this DT 40436 4561 14 important important JJ 40436 4561 15 fact fact NN 40436 4561 16 -- -- : 40436 4561 17 the the DT 40436 4561 18 habitual habitual JJ 40436 4561 19 condition condition NN 40436 4561 20 of of IN 40436 4561 21 human human JJ 40436 4561 22 society society NN 40436 4561 23 , , , 40436 4561 24 modern modern JJ 40436 4561 25 as as RB 40436 4561 26 well well RB 40436 4561 27 as as IN 40436 4561 28 ancient ancient JJ 40436 4561 29 , , , 40436 4561 30 and and CC 40436 4561 31 for for IN 40436 4561 32 that that DT 40436 4561 33 very very JJ 40436 4561 34 reason reason NN 40436 4561 35 generally generally RB 40436 4561 36 unnoticed unnoticed JJ 40436 4561 37 . . . 40436 4562 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4562 2 37 37 CD 40436 4562 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4562 4 The the DT 40436 4562 5 emotional emotional JJ 40436 4562 6 or or CC 40436 4562 7 subjective subjective JJ 40436 4562 8 value value NN 40436 4562 9 of of IN 40436 4562 10 temperance temperance NN 40436 4562 11 is be VBZ 40436 4562 12 all all DT 40436 4562 13 that that WDT 40436 4562 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4562 15 determines determine VBZ 40436 4562 16 , , , 40436 4562 17 and and CC 40436 4562 18 which which WDT 40436 4562 19 indeed indeed RB 40436 4562 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4562 21 makes make VBZ 40436 4562 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4562 23 point point NN 40436 4562 24 of of IN 40436 4562 25 departure departure NN 40436 4562 26 . . . 40436 4563 1 Temperance temperance NN 40436 4563 2 is be VBZ 40436 4563 3 essentially essentially RB 40436 4563 4 among among IN 40436 4563 5 the the DT 40436 4563 6 fine fine JJ 40436 4563 7 , , , 40436 4563 8 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4563 9 , , , 40436 4563 10 honourable honourable JJ 40436 4563 11 , , , 40436 4563 12 things:[38 things:[38 ADD 40436 4563 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4563 14 but but CC 40436 4563 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4563 16 rational rational JJ 40436 4563 17 or or CC 40436 4563 18 objective objective JJ 40436 4563 19 value value NN 40436 4563 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4563 21 _ _ NNP 40436 4563 22 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 4563 23 _ _ NNP 40436 4563 24 , , , 40436 4563 25 what what WP 40436 4563 26 is be VBZ 40436 4563 27 the the DT 40436 4563 28 common common JJ 40436 4563 29 object object NN 40436 4563 30 characterising characterise VBG 40436 4563 31 all all DT 40436 4563 32 temperate temperate NN 40436 4563 33 acts act NNS 40436 4563 34 or or CC 40436 4563 35 persons person NNS 40436 4563 36 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4563 37 , , , 40436 4563 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4563 39 can can MD 40436 4563 40 not not RB 40436 4563 41 determine determine VB 40436 4563 42 . . . 40436 4564 1 Here here RB 40436 4564 2 indeed indeed RB 40436 4564 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4564 4 is be VBZ 40436 4564 5 not not RB 40436 4564 6 always always RB 40436 4564 7 consistent consistent JJ 40436 4564 8 with with IN 40436 4564 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4564 10 : : : 40436 4564 11 for for IN 40436 4564 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4564 13 shall shall MD 40436 4564 14 come come VB 40436 4564 15 to to IN 40436 4564 16 other other JJ 40436 4564 17 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4564 18 wherein wherein WRB 40436 4564 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4564 20 professes profess VBZ 40436 4564 21 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4564 22 incompetent incompetent JJ 40436 4564 23 to to TO 40436 4564 24 say say VB 40436 4564 25 whether whether IN 40436 4564 26 a a DT 40436 4564 27 thing thing NN 40436 4564 28 be be VB 40436 4564 29 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4564 30 or or CC 40436 4564 31 not not RB 40436 4564 32 , , , 40436 4564 33 until until IN 40436 4564 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4564 35 be be VB 40436 4564 36 determined determine VBN 40436 4564 37 what what WP 40436 4564 38 the the DT 40436 4564 39 thing thing NN 40436 4564 40 is:[39 is:[39 NNP 40436 4564 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4564 42 and and CC 40436 4564 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4564 44 have have VBP 40436 4564 45 already already RB 40436 4564 46 found find VBN 40436 4564 47 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4564 48 declaring declare VBG 40436 4564 49 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4564 50 in in IN 40436 4564 51 the the DT 40436 4564 52 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 4564 53 Major Major NNP 40436 4564 54 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4564 55 , , , 40436 4564 56 that that IN 40436 4564 57 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4564 58 can can MD 40436 4564 59 not not RB 40436 4564 60 determine determine VB 40436 4564 61 whether whether IN 40436 4564 62 any any DT 40436 4564 63 particular particular JJ 40436 4564 64 object object NN 40436 4564 65 is be VBZ 40436 4564 66 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4564 67 or or CC 40436 4564 68 not not RB 40436 4564 69 , , , 40436 4564 70 until until IN 40436 4564 71 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4564 72 have have VBP 40436 4564 73 first first RB 40436 4564 74 determined determine VBN 40436 4564 75 , , , 40436 4564 76 What what WP 40436 4564 77 is be VBZ 40436 4564 78 Beauty beauty NN 40436 4564 79 in in IN 40436 4564 80 the the DT 40436 4564 81 Absolute Absolute NNP 40436 4564 82 , , , 40436 4564 83 or or CC 40436 4564 84 the the DT 40436 4564 85 Self self NN 40436 4564 86 - - HYPH 40436 4564 87 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 4564 88 ? ? . 40436 4565 1 a a DT 40436 4565 2 problem problem NN 40436 4565 3 nowhere nowhere RB 40436 4565 4 solved solve VBN 40436 4565 5 by by IN 40436 4565 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4565 7 . . . 40436 4566 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4566 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4566 3 37 37 CD 40436 4566 4 : : : 40436 4566 5 " " `` 40436 4566 6 Whoever whoever WP 40436 4566 7 has have VBZ 40436 4566 8 reflected reflect VBN 40436 4566 9 on on IN 40436 4566 10 the the DT 40436 4566 11 generation generation NN 40436 4566 12 of of IN 40436 4566 13 ideas idea NNS 40436 4566 14 in in IN 40436 4566 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4566 16 own own JJ 40436 4566 17 mind mind NN 40436 4566 18 , , , 40436 4566 19 or or CC 40436 4566 20 has have VBZ 40436 4566 21 investigated investigate VBN 40436 4566 22 the the DT 40436 4566 23 causes cause NNS 40436 4566 24 of of IN 40436 4566 25 misunderstandings misunderstanding NNS 40436 4566 26 among among IN 40436 4566 27 mankind mankind NN 40436 4566 28 , , , 40436 4566 29 will will MD 40436 4566 30 be be VB 40436 4566 31 obliged oblige VBN 40436 4566 32 to to TO 40436 4566 33 proclaim proclaim VB 40436 4566 34 as as IN 40436 4566 35 a a DT 40436 4566 36 fact fact NN 40436 4566 37 deeply deeply RB 40436 4566 38 seated seat VBN 40436 4566 39 in in IN 40436 4566 40 human human JJ 40436 4566 41 nature nature NN 40436 4566 42 -- -- : 40436 4566 43 That that IN 40436 4566 44 most most JJS 40436 4566 45 of of IN 40436 4566 46 the the DT 40436 4566 47 misunderstandings misunderstanding NNS 40436 4566 48 and and CC 40436 4566 49 contradictions contradiction NNS 40436 4566 50 among among IN 40436 4566 51 men man NNS 40436 4566 52 , , , 40436 4566 53 most most JJS 40436 4566 54 of of IN 40436 4566 55 the the DT 40436 4566 56 controversies controversy NNS 40436 4566 57 and and CC 40436 4566 58 errors error NNS 40436 4566 59 both both CC 40436 4566 60 in in IN 40436 4566 61 science science NN 40436 4566 62 and and CC 40436 4566 63 in in IN 40436 4566 64 society society NN 40436 4566 65 , , , 40436 4566 66 arise arise VBP 40436 4566 67 usually usually RB 40436 4566 68 from from IN 40436 4566 69 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4566 70 assuming assuming NN 40436 4566 71 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4566 72 consciously consciously RB 40436 4566 73 or or CC 40436 4566 74 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 4566 75 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4566 76 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 4566 77 maxims maxim NNS 40436 4566 78 and and CC 40436 4566 79 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 4566 80 facts fact NNS 40436 4566 81 as as IN 40436 4566 82 if if IN 40436 4566 83 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4566 84 were be VBD 40436 4566 85 self self NN 40436 4566 86 - - HYPH 40436 4566 87 evident evident JJ 40436 4566 88 , , , 40436 4566 89 and and CC 40436 4566 90 as as IN 40436 4566 91 if if IN 40436 4566 92 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4566 93 must must MD 40436 4566 94 be be VB 40436 4566 95 assumed assume VBN 40436 4566 96 by by IN 40436 4566 97 every every DT 40436 4566 98 one one CD 40436 4566 99 else else RB 40436 4566 100 besides besides RB 40436 4566 101 . . . 40436 4567 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 4567 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4567 3 never never RB 40436 4567 4 think think VBP 40436 4567 5 of of IN 40436 4567 6 closely closely RB 40436 4567 7 examining examine VBG 40436 4567 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4567 9 , , , 40436 4567 10 until until IN 40436 4567 11 at at IN 40436 4567 12 length length NN 40436 4567 13 experience experience NN 40436 4567 14 has have VBZ 40436 4567 15 taught teach VBN 40436 4567 16 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4567 17 that that IN 40436 4567 18 these these DT 40436 4567 19 _ _ NNP 40436 4567 20 self self NN 40436 4567 21 - - HYPH 40436 4567 22 evident evident JJ 40436 4567 23 _ _ NNP 40436 4567 24 matters matter NNS 40436 4567 25 are be VBP 40436 4567 26 exactly exactly RB 40436 4567 27 what what WP 40436 4567 28 stand stand VBP 40436 4567 29 most most RBS 40436 4567 30 in in IN 40436 4567 31 need need NN 40436 4567 32 of of IN 40436 4567 33 proof proof NN 40436 4567 34 , , , 40436 4567 35 and and CC 40436 4567 36 what what WDT 40436 4567 37 form form NN 40436 4567 38 the the DT 40436 4567 39 special special JJ 40436 4567 40 root root NN 40436 4567 41 of of IN 40436 4567 42 divergent divergent JJ 40436 4567 43 opinions opinion NNS 40436 4567 44 . . . 40436 4567 45 "--(L. "--(L. '' 40436 4568 1 O. O. NNP 40436 4568 2 Bröcker Bröcker NNP 40436 4568 3 -- -- : 40436 4568 4 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 40436 4568 5 über über NN 40436 4568 6 die die VBP 40436 4568 7 Glaubwürdigkeit Glaubwürdigkeit NNP 40436 4568 8 der der RB 40436 4568 9 alt alt NNP 40436 4568 10 - - HYPH 40436 4568 11 Römischen Römischen NNP 40436 4568 12 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 40436 4568 13 , , , 40436 4568 14 p. p. NN 40436 4569 1 490 490 CD 40436 4569 2 . . . 40436 4569 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4569 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4570 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4570 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4570 3 38 38 CD 40436 4570 4 : : : 40436 4570 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4570 6 , , , 40436 4570 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4570 8 . . . 40436 4571 1 159 159 CD 40436 4571 2 B b NN 40436 4571 3 , , , 40436 4571 4 160 160 CD 40436 4571 5 D. D. NNP 40436 4571 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4571 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4571 8 : : : 40436 4571 9 ê ê NNP 40436 4571 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4571 11 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4571 12 / / SYM 40436 4571 13 nê nê UH 40436 4571 14 -- -- : 40436 4571 15 tô tô NNP 40436 4571 16 = = SYM 40436 4571 17 n n CC 40436 4571 18 kalô kalô NN 40436 4571 19 = = SYM 40436 4571 20 n n CC 40436 4571 21 ti ti NN 40436 4571 22 -- -- : 40436 4571 23 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4571 24 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 4571 25 lo lo NNP 40436 4571 26 / / SYM 40436 4571 27 gô=| gô=| NNP 40436 4571 28 tô tô NNP 40436 4571 29 = = SYM 40436 4571 30 n n CC 40436 4571 31 kalô kalô NN 40436 4571 32 = = SYM 40436 4571 33 n n CC 40436 4571 34 ti ti NN 40436 4571 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4571 36 . . . 40436 4572 1 So so RB 40436 4572 2 also also RB 40436 4572 3 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 4572 4 in in IN 40436 4572 5 the the DT 40436 4572 6 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4572 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4572 8 192 192 CD 40436 4572 9 C C NNP 40436 4572 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4572 11 , , , 40436 4572 12 assumes assume VBZ 40436 4572 13 that that DT 40436 4572 14 courage courage NN 40436 4572 15 is be VBZ 40436 4572 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4572 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4572 18 : : : 40436 4572 19 tô tô NNP 40436 4572 20 = = SYM 40436 4572 21 n n NNP 40436 4572 22 pa pa NNP 40436 4572 23 / / SYM 40436 4572 24 nu nu NNP 40436 4572 25 kalô kalô NNP 40436 4572 26 = = SYM 40436 4572 27 n n NNP 40436 4572 28 pragma pragma NNP 40436 4572 29 / / SYM 40436 4572 30 tôn tôn NNP 40436 4572 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4572 32 , , , 40436 4572 33 though though IN 40436 4572 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4572 35 professes profess VBZ 40436 4572 36 not not RB 40436 4572 37 to to TO 40436 4572 38 know know VB 40436 4572 39 nor nor CC 40436 4572 40 to to TO 40436 4572 41 be be VB 40436 4572 42 able able JJ 40436 4572 43 to to TO 40436 4572 44 discover discover VB 40436 4572 45 what what WP 40436 4572 46 courage courage NN 40436 4572 47 is be VBZ 40436 4572 48 . . . 40436 4572 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4573 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4573 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4573 3 39 39 CD 40436 4573 4 : : : 40436 4573 5 See see VB 40436 4573 6 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 4573 7 , , , 40436 4573 8 462 462 CD 40436 4573 9 B b NN 40436 4573 10 , , , 40436 4573 11 448 448 CD 40436 4573 12 E e NN 40436 4573 13 ; ; : 40436 4573 14 Menon Menon NNP 40436 4573 15 , , , 40436 4573 16 70 70 CD 40436 4573 17 B. B. NNP 40436 4573 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4574 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4574 2 Side side NN 40436 4574 3 - - HYPH 40436 4574 4 note note NN 40436 4574 5 : : : 40436 4574 6 Different different JJ 40436 4574 7 ethical ethical JJ 40436 4574 8 points point NNS 40436 4574 9 of of IN 40436 4574 10 view view NN 40436 4574 11 in in IN 40436 4574 12 different different JJ 40436 4574 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 4574 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4574 15 . . . 40436 4574 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4575 1 Among among IN 40436 4575 2 the the DT 40436 4575 3 various various JJ 40436 4575 4 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 40436 4575 5 definitions definition NNS 40436 4575 6 of of IN 40436 4575 7 temperance temperance NN 40436 4575 8 propounded propound VBN 40436 4575 9 , , , 40436 4575 10 there there EX 40436 4575 11 is be VBZ 40436 4575 12 more more JJR 40436 4575 13 than than IN 40436 4575 14 one one CD 40436 4575 15 which which WDT 40436 4575 16 affords afford VBZ 40436 4575 17 farther farther JJ 40436 4575 18 example example NN 40436 4575 19 to to TO 40436 4575 20 show show VB 40436 4575 21 how how WRB 40436 4575 22 differently differently RB 40436 4575 23 Plato plato JJ 40436 4575 24 deals deal NNS 40436 4575 25 with with IN 40436 4575 26 the the DT 40436 4575 27 same same JJ 40436 4575 28 subject subject NN 40436 4575 29 in in IN 40436 4575 30 different different JJ 40436 4575 31 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4575 32 . . . 40436 4576 1 Here here RB 40436 4576 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4576 3 have have VBP 40436 4576 4 the the DT 40436 4576 5 phrase--"to phrase--"to NNP 40436 4576 6 do do VB 40436 4576 7 one one PRP 40436 4576 8 's 's POS 40436 4576 9 own own JJ 40436 4576 10 business"--treated business"--treate VBN 40436 4576 11 as as IN 40436 4576 12 an an DT 40436 4576 13 unmeaning unmeaning JJ 40436 4576 14 puzzle puzzle NN 40436 4576 15 , , , 40436 4576 16 and and CC 40436 4576 17 exhibited exhibit VBN 40436 4576 18 as as IN 40436 4576 19 if if IN 40436 4576 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4576 21 were be VBD 40436 4576 22 analogous analogous JJ 40436 4576 23 to to IN 40436 4576 24 various various JJ 40436 4576 25 other other JJ 40436 4576 26 phrases phrase NNS 40436 4576 27 , , , 40436 4576 28 with with IN 40436 4576 29 which which WDT 40436 4576 30 the the DT 40436 4576 31 analogy analogy NN 40436 4576 32 is be VBZ 40436 4576 33 more more RBR 40436 4576 34 verbal verbal JJ 40436 4576 35 than than IN 40436 4576 36 real real JJ 40436 4576 37 . . . 40436 4577 1 But but CC 40436 4577 2 in in IN 40436 4577 3 the the DT 40436 4577 4 Republic Republic NNP 40436 4577 5 , , , 40436 4577 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4577 7 admits admit VBZ 40436 4577 8 this this DT 40436 4577 9 phrase phrase NN 40436 4577 10 as as RB 40436 4577 11 well well RB 40436 4577 12 understood understand VBD 40436 4577 13 , , , 40436 4577 14 and and CC 40436 4577 15 sets set VBZ 40436 4577 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4577 17 forth forth RB 40436 4577 18 as as IN 40436 4577 19 the the DT 40436 4577 20 constituent constituent NN 40436 4577 21 element element NN 40436 4577 22 of of IN 40436 4577 23 justice justice NN 40436 4577 24 ; ; : 40436 4577 25 in in IN 40436 4577 26 the the DT 40436 4577 27 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 4577 28 , , , 40436 4577 29 as as IN 40436 4577 30 the the DT 40436 4577 31 leading lead VBG 40436 4577 32 mark mark NN 40436 4577 33 of of IN 40436 4577 34 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 4577 35 life life NN 40436 4577 36 . . . 40436 4578 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4578 2 40 40 CD 40436 4578 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4578 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4578 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4578 6 40 40 CD 40436 4578 7 : : : 40436 4578 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4578 9 , , , 40436 4578 10 Republ Republ NNP 40436 4578 11 . . . 40436 4579 1 iv iv XX 40436 4579 2 . . . 40436 4580 1 433 433 CD 40436 4580 2 , , , 40436 4580 3 vi vi NNP 40436 4580 4 . . . 40436 4581 1 496 496 CD 40436 4581 2 C c NN 40436 4581 3 , , , 40436 4581 4 viii viii JJ 40436 4581 5 . . . 40436 4582 1 550 550 CD 40436 4582 2 A a NN 40436 4582 3 ; ; : 40436 4582 4 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 4582 5 , , , 40436 4582 6 526 526 CD 40436 4582 7 C. C. NNP 40436 4582 8 Compare Compare NNP 40436 4582 9 also also RB 40436 4582 10 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 4582 11 , , , 40436 4582 12 72 72 CD 40436 4582 13 A a NN 40436 4582 14 , , , 40436 4582 15 Xen Xen NNP 40436 4582 16 , , , 40436 4582 17 Mem Mem NNP 40436 4582 18 . . . 40436 4583 1 ii ii LS 40436 4583 2 . . . 40436 4584 1 9 9 CD 40436 4584 2 , , , 40436 4584 3 1 1 CD 40436 4584 4 . . . 40436 4584 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4585 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4585 2 Side side NN 40436 4585 3 - - HYPH 40436 4585 4 note note NN 40436 4585 5 : : : 40436 4585 6 Self self NN 40436 4585 7 - - HYPH 40436 4585 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4585 9 is be VBZ 40436 4585 10 here here RB 40436 4585 11 declared declare VBN 40436 4585 12 to to TO 40436 4585 13 be be VB 40436 4585 14 impossible impossible JJ 40436 4585 15 . . . 40436 4585 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4586 1 Again again RB 40436 4586 2 , , , 40436 4586 3 another another DT 40436 4586 4 definition definition NN 40436 4586 5 given give VBN 40436 4586 6 by by IN 40436 4586 7 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4586 8 is be VBZ 40436 4586 9 , , , 40436 4586 10 That that DT 40436 4586 11 temperance temperance NN 40436 4586 12 consists consist VBZ 40436 4586 13 in in IN 40436 4586 14 knowing know VBG 40436 4586 15 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 4586 16 , , , 40436 4586 17 or or CC 40436 4586 18 in in IN 40436 4586 19 self self NN 40436 4586 20 - - HYPH 40436 4586 21 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4586 22 . . . 40436 4587 1 In in IN 40436 4587 2 commenting comment VBG 40436 4587 3 upon upon IN 40436 4587 4 this this DT 40436 4587 5 definition definition NN 40436 4587 6 , , , 40436 4587 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4587 8 makes make VBZ 40436 4587 9 out out RP 40436 4587 10 -- -- : 40436 4587 11 first first RB 40436 4587 12 , , , 40436 4587 13 that that IN 40436 4587 14 self self NN 40436 4587 15 - - HYPH 40436 4587 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4587 17 is be VBZ 40436 4587 18 impossible impossible JJ 40436 4587 19 : : : 40436 4587 20 next next RB 40436 4587 21 , , , 40436 4587 22 that that IN 40436 4587 23 if if IN 40436 4587 24 possible possible JJ 40436 4587 25 , , , 40436 4587 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4587 27 would would MD 40436 4587 28 be be VB 40436 4587 29 useless useless JJ 40436 4587 30 . . . 40436 4588 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 2 can can MD 40436 4588 3 not not RB 40436 4588 4 know know VB 40436 4588 5 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 6 , , , 40436 4588 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 8 argues argue VBZ 40436 4588 9 : : : 40436 4588 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 11 can can MD 40436 4588 12 not not RB 40436 4588 13 know know VB 40436 4588 14 what what WP 40436 4588 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 16 know know VBP 40436 4588 17 , , , 40436 4588 18 and and CC 40436 4588 19 what what WP 40436 4588 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 21 do do VBP 40436 4588 22 not not RB 40436 4588 23 know know VB 40436 4588 24 : : : 40436 4588 25 to to TO 40436 4588 26 say say VB 40436 4588 27 that that IN 40436 4588 28 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 29 know know VBP 40436 4588 30 what what WP 40436 4588 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 32 know know VBP 40436 4588 33 , , , 40436 4588 34 is be VBZ 40436 4588 35 either either CC 40436 4588 36 tautological tautological JJ 40436 4588 37 or or CC 40436 4588 38 untrue untrue JJ 40436 4588 39 -- -- : 40436 4588 40 to to TO 40436 4588 41 say say VB 40436 4588 42 that that IN 40436 4588 43 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 44 know know VBP 40436 4588 45 what what WP 40436 4588 46 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4588 47 do do VBP 40436 4588 48 not not RB 40436 4588 49 know know VB 40436 4588 50 , , , 40436 4588 51 is be VBZ 40436 4588 52 a a DT 40436 4588 53 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 4588 54 . . . 40436 4589 1 All all DT 40436 4589 2 cognition cognition NN 40436 4589 3 must must MD 40436 4589 4 be be VB 40436 4589 5 cognition cognition NN 40436 4589 6 of of IN 40436 4589 7 something something NN 40436 4589 8 distinct distinct JJ 40436 4589 9 from from IN 40436 4589 10 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 4589 11 : : : 40436 4589 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4589 13 is be VBZ 40436 4589 14 a a DT 40436 4589 15 relative relative JJ 40436 4589 16 term term NN 40436 4589 17 which which WDT 40436 4589 18 must must MD 40436 4589 19 have have VB 40436 4589 20 some some DT 40436 4589 21 correlate correlate JJ 40436 4589 22 , , , 40436 4589 23 and and CC 40436 4589 24 can can MD 40436 4589 25 not not RB 40436 4589 26 be be VB 40436 4589 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4589 28 own own JJ 40436 4589 29 correlate correlate NN 40436 4589 30 : : : 40436 4589 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4589 32 can can MD 40436 4589 33 not not RB 40436 4589 34 have have VB 40436 4589 35 cognition cognition NN 40436 4589 36 of of IN 40436 4589 37 cognition cognition NN 40436 4589 38 , , , 40436 4589 39 still still RB 40436 4589 40 less less JJR 40436 4589 41 cognition cognition NN 40436 4589 42 of of IN 40436 4589 43 non non JJ 40436 4589 44 - - JJ 40436 4589 45 cognition cognition JJ 40436 4589 46 . . . 40436 4590 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4590 2 Side side NN 40436 4590 3 - - HYPH 40436 4590 4 note note NN 40436 4590 5 : : : 40436 4590 6 In in IN 40436 4590 7 other other JJ 40436 4590 8 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4590 9 , , , 40436 4590 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4590 11 declares declare VBZ 40436 4590 12 self self NN 40436 4590 13 - - HYPH 40436 4590 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4590 15 to to TO 40436 4590 16 be be VB 40436 4590 17 essential essential JJ 40436 4590 18 and and CC 40436 4590 19 inestimable inestimable JJ 40436 4590 20 . . . 40436 4591 1 Necessity necessity NN 40436 4591 2 for for IN 40436 4591 3 the the DT 40436 4591 4 student student NN 40436 4591 5 to to TO 40436 4591 6 have have VB 40436 4591 7 presented present VBN 40436 4591 8 to to IN 40436 4591 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4591 10 dissentient dissentient JJ 40436 4591 11 points point NNS 40436 4591 12 of of IN 40436 4591 13 view view NN 40436 4591 14 . . . 40436 4591 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4592 1 This this DT 40436 4592 2 is be VBZ 40436 4592 3 an an DT 40436 4592 4 important important JJ 40436 4592 5 point point NN 40436 4592 6 of of IN 40436 4592 7 view view NN 40436 4592 8 , , , 40436 4592 9 which which WDT 40436 4592 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4592 11 shall shall MD 40436 4592 12 discuss discuss VB 40436 4592 13 more more JJR 40436 4592 14 at at IN 40436 4592 15 length length NN 40436 4592 16 when when WRB 40436 4592 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4592 18 come come VBP 40436 4592 19 to to IN 40436 4592 20 the the DT 40436 4592 21 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 4592 22 Theætetus Theætetus NNP 40436 4592 23 . . . 40436 4593 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4593 2 bring bring VBP 40436 4593 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4593 4 to to TO 40436 4593 5 view view VB 40436 4593 6 here here RB 40436 4593 7 only only RB 40436 4593 8 as as IN 40436 4593 9 contrasting contrast VBG 40436 4593 10 with with IN 40436 4593 11 different different JJ 40436 4593 12 language language NN 40436 4593 13 held hold VBN 40436 4593 14 by by IN 40436 4593 15 the the DT 40436 4593 16 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 4593 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4593 18 in in IN 40436 4593 19 other other JJ 40436 4593 20 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4593 21 ; ; : 40436 4593 22 where where WRB 40436 4593 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4593 24 insists insist VBZ 40436 4593 25 on on IN 40436 4593 26 the the DT 40436 4593 27 great great JJ 40436 4593 28 value value NN 40436 4593 29 and and CC 40436 4593 30 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 4593 31 necessity necessity NN 40436 4593 32 of of IN 40436 4593 33 self self NN 40436 4593 34 - - HYPH 40436 4593 35 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4593 36 , , , 40436 4593 37 as as IN 40436 4593 38 a a DT 40436 4593 39 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 4593 40 to to IN 40436 4593 41 all all DT 40436 4593 42 other other JJ 40436 4593 43 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4593 44 -- -- : 40436 4593 45 upon upon IN 40436 4593 46 the the DT 40436 4593 47 duty duty NN 40436 4593 48 of of IN 40436 4593 49 eradicating eradicate VBG 40436 4593 50 from from IN 40436 4593 51 men man NNS 40436 4593 52 's 's POS 40436 4593 53 minds mind NNS 40436 4593 54 that that IN 40436 4593 55 false false JJ 40436 4593 56 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 4593 57 of of IN 40436 4593 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4593 59 own own JJ 40436 4593 60 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4593 61 which which WDT 40436 4593 62 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4593 63 universally universally RB 40436 4593 64 cherished cherish VBD 40436 4593 65 -- -- : 40436 4593 66 and and CC 40436 4593 67 upon upon IN 40436 4593 68 the the DT 40436 4593 69 importance importance NN 40436 4593 70 of of IN 40436 4593 71 forcing force VBG 40436 4593 72 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4593 73 to to TO 40436 4593 74 know know VB 40436 4593 75 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4593 76 own own JJ 40436 4593 77 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4593 78 as as RB 40436 4593 79 well well RB 40436 4593 80 as as IN 40436 4593 81 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4593 82 own own JJ 40436 4593 83 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4593 84 . . . 40436 4594 1 In in IN 40436 4594 2 the the DT 40436 4594 3 face face NN 40436 4594 4 of of IN 40436 4594 5 this this DT 40436 4594 6 last last JJ 40436 4594 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 4594 8 , , , 40436 4594 9 so so RB 40436 4594 10 frequently frequently RB 40436 4594 11 avowed avow VBN 40436 4594 12 by by IN 40436 4594 13 the the DT 40436 4594 14 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 4594 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4594 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4594 17 indirectly indirectly RB 40436 4594 18 even even RB 40436 4594 19 in in IN 40436 4594 20 this this DT 40436 4594 21 very very RB 40436 4594 22 dialogue),[41 dialogue),[41 NNP 40436 4594 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4594 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4594 25 remark remark VBP 40436 4594 26 a a DT 40436 4594 27 material material JJ 40436 4594 28 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40436 4594 29 , , , 40436 4594 30 when when WRB 40436 4594 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4594 32 here here RB 40436 4594 33 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 4594 34 self self NN 40436 4594 35 - - HYPH 40436 4594 36 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4594 37 to to TO 40436 4594 38 be be VB 40436 4594 39 impossible impossible JJ 40436 4594 40 . . . 40436 4595 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4595 2 must must MD 40436 4595 3 judge judge VB 40436 4595 4 every every DT 40436 4595 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4595 6 by by IN 40436 4595 7 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4595 8 , , , 40436 4595 9 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 4595 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4595 11 when when WRB 40436 4595 12 practicable practicable JJ 40436 4595 13 by by IN 40436 4595 14 comparison comparison NN 40436 4595 15 with with IN 40436 4595 16 others other NNS 40436 4595 17 , , , 40436 4595 18 but but CC 40436 4595 19 not not RB 40436 4595 20 assuming assume VBG 40436 4595 21 consistence consistence NN 40436 4595 22 between between IN 40436 4595 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4595 24 as as IN 40436 4595 25 a a DT 40436 4595 26 postulate postulate NN 40436 4595 27 _ _ NNP 40436 4595 28 à à NNP 40436 4595 29 priori priori VBP 40436 4595 30 _ _ NNP 40436 4595 31 . . . 40436 4596 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4596 2 is be VBZ 40436 4596 3 a a DT 40436 4596 4 part part NN 40436 4596 5 of of IN 40436 4596 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4596 7 's 's POS 40436 4596 8 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4596 9 and and CC 40436 4596 10 tentative tentative JJ 40436 4596 11 mode mode NN 40436 4596 12 of of IN 40436 4596 13 philosophising philosophise VBG 40436 4596 14 to to TO 40436 4596 15 work work VB 40436 4596 16 out out RP 40436 4596 17 different different JJ 40436 4596 18 ethical ethical JJ 40436 4596 19 points point NNS 40436 4596 20 of of IN 40436 4596 21 view view NN 40436 4596 22 , , , 40436 4596 23 and and CC 40436 4596 24 to to TO 40436 4596 25 have have VB 40436 4596 26 present present JJ 40436 4596 27 to to IN 40436 4596 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4596 29 mind mind NN 40436 4596 30 one one CD 40436 4596 31 or or CC 40436 4596 32 other other JJ 40436 4596 33 of of IN 40436 4596 34 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4596 35 , , , 40436 4596 36 with with IN 40436 4596 37 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 4596 38 force force NN 40436 4596 39 in in IN 40436 4596 40 each each DT 40436 4596 41 different different JJ 40436 4596 42 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4596 43 . . . 40436 4597 1 The the DT 40436 4597 2 subject subject NN 40436 4597 3 is be VBZ 40436 4597 4 thus thus RB 40436 4597 5 brought bring VBN 40436 4597 6 before before IN 40436 4597 7 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4597 8 on on IN 40436 4597 9 all all DT 40436 4597 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4597 11 sides side NNS 40436 4597 12 , , , 40436 4597 13 and and CC 40436 4597 14 the the DT 40436 4597 15 reader reader NN 40436 4597 16 is be VBZ 40436 4597 17 familiarised familiarise VBN 40436 4597 18 with with IN 40436 4597 19 what what WP 40436 4597 20 a a DT 40436 4597 21 dialectician dialectician NN 40436 4597 22 might may MD 40436 4597 23 say say VB 40436 4597 24 , , , 40436 4597 25 whether whether IN 40436 4597 26 capable capable JJ 40436 4597 27 of of IN 40436 4597 28 being be VBG 40436 4597 29 refuted refute VBN 40436 4597 30 or or CC 40436 4597 31 not not RB 40436 4597 32 . . . 40436 4598 1 Inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 4598 2 between between IN 40436 4598 3 one one CD 40436 4598 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4598 5 and and CC 40436 4598 6 another another DT 40436 4598 7 is be VBZ 40436 4598 8 not not RB 40436 4598 9 a a DT 40436 4598 10 fault fault NN 40436 4598 11 in in IN 40436 4598 12 the the DT 40436 4598 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 4598 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4598 15 of of IN 40436 4598 16 Search Search NNP 40436 4598 17 ; ; : 40436 4598 18 but but CC 40436 4598 19 is be VBZ 40436 4598 20 , , , 40436 4598 21 on on IN 40436 4598 22 the the DT 40436 4598 23 contrary contrary NN 40436 4598 24 , , , 40436 4598 25 a a DT 40436 4598 26 part part NN 40436 4598 27 of of IN 40436 4598 28 the the DT 40436 4598 29 training training NN 40436 4598 30 process process NN 40436 4598 31 , , , 40436 4598 32 for for IN 40436 4598 33 any any DT 40436 4598 34 student student NN 40436 4598 35 who who WP 40436 4598 36 is be VBZ 40436 4598 37 destined destine VBN 40436 4598 38 to to TO 40436 4598 39 acquire acquire VB 40436 4598 40 that that DT 40436 4598 41 full full JJ 40436 4598 42 mastery mastery NN 40436 4598 43 of of IN 40436 4598 44 question question NN 40436 4598 45 and and CC 40436 4598 46 answer answer NN 40436 4598 47 which which WDT 40436 4598 48 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4598 49 regards regard VBZ 40436 4598 50 as as IN 40436 4598 51 the the DT 40436 4598 52 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 4598 53 test test NN 40436 4598 54 of of IN 40436 4598 55 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4598 56 . . . 40436 4599 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4599 2 is be VBZ 40436 4599 3 a a DT 40436 4599 4 puzzle puzzle NN 40436 4599 5 and and CC 40436 4599 6 provocative provocative JJ 40436 4599 7 to to IN 40436 4599 8 the the DT 40436 4599 9 internal internal JJ 40436 4599 10 meditation meditation NN 40436 4599 11 of of IN 40436 4599 12 the the DT 40436 4599 13 student student NN 40436 4599 14 . . . 40436 4600 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4600 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4600 3 41 41 CD 40436 4600 4 : : : 40436 4600 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4600 6 , , , 40436 4600 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4600 8 . . . 40436 4601 1 166 166 CD 40436 4601 2 D. D. NNP 40436 4601 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4601 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4601 5 Side side NN 40436 4601 6 - - HYPH 40436 4601 7 note note NN 40436 4601 8 : : : 40436 4601 9 Courage Courage NNP 40436 4601 10 and and CC 40436 4601 11 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4601 12 are be VBP 40436 4601 13 shown show VBN 40436 4601 14 to to TO 40436 4601 15 have have VB 40436 4601 16 no no DT 40436 4601 17 distinct distinct JJ 40436 4601 18 meaning meaning NN 40436 4601 19 , , , 40436 4601 20 except except IN 40436 4601 21 as as IN 40436 4601 22 founded found VBN 40436 4601 23 on on IN 40436 4601 24 the the DT 40436 4601 25 general general JJ 40436 4601 26 cognizance cognizance NN 40436 4601 27 of of IN 40436 4601 28 good good JJ 40436 4601 29 and and CC 40436 4601 30 evil evil NN 40436 4601 31 . . . 40436 4601 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4602 1 In in IN 40436 4602 2 analyzing analyze VBG 40436 4602 3 the the DT 40436 4602 4 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4602 5 , , , 40436 4602 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4602 7 observed observe VBD 40436 4602 8 that that IN 40436 4602 9 the the DT 40436 4602 10 definition definition NN 40436 4602 11 of of IN 40436 4602 12 courage courage NN 40436 4602 13 given give VBN 40436 4602 14 by by IN 40436 4602 15 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 4602 16 was be VBD 40436 4602 17 shown show VBN 40436 4602 18 by by IN 40436 4602 19 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4602 20 to to TO 40436 4602 21 have have VB 40436 4602 22 no no DT 40436 4602 23 meaning meaning NN 40436 4602 24 , , , 40436 4602 25 except except IN 40436 4602 26 in in IN 40436 4602 27 so so RB 40436 4602 28 far far RB 40436 4602 29 as as IN 40436 4602 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4602 31 coincided coincide VBD 40436 4602 32 with with IN 40436 4602 33 the the DT 40436 4602 34 general general JJ 40436 4602 35 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4602 36 or or CC 40436 4602 37 cognition cognition NN 40436 4602 38 of of IN 40436 4602 39 good good JJ 40436 4602 40 and and CC 40436 4602 41 evil evil NN 40436 4602 42 . . . 40436 4603 1 Here here RB 40436 4603 2 , , , 40436 4603 3 too too RB 40436 4603 4 , , , 40436 4603 5 in in IN 40436 4603 6 the the DT 40436 4603 7 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4603 8 , , , 40436 4603 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4603 10 are be VBP 40436 4603 11 brought bring VBN 40436 4603 12 in in RP 40436 4603 13 the the DT 40436 4603 14 last last JJ 40436 4603 15 result result NN 40436 4603 16 to to IN 40436 4603 17 the the DT 40436 4603 18 same same JJ 40436 4603 19 terminus terminus NN 40436 4603 20 -- -- : 40436 4603 21 the the DT 40436 4603 22 general general JJ 40436 4603 23 cognition cognition NN 40436 4603 24 of of IN 40436 4603 25 good good JJ 40436 4603 26 and and CC 40436 4603 27 evil evil NN 40436 4603 28 . . . 40436 4604 1 But but CC 40436 4604 2 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4604 3 , , , 40436 4604 4 as as IN 40436 4604 5 previously previously RB 40436 4604 6 good good JJ 40436 4604 7 and and CC 40436 4604 8 defined define VBN 40436 4604 9 , , , 40436 4604 10 is be VBZ 40436 4604 11 not not RB 40436 4604 12 comprehended comprehend VBN 40436 4604 13 under under IN 40436 4604 14 that that DT 40436 4604 15 cognition cognition NN 40436 4604 16 , , , 40436 4604 17 and and CC 40436 4604 18 is be VBZ 40436 4604 19 therefore therefore RB 40436 4604 20 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 4604 21 to to TO 40436 4604 22 be be VB 40436 4604 23 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 4604 24 . . . 40436 4605 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4605 2 Side side NN 40436 4605 3 - - HYPH 40436 4605 4 note note NN 40436 4605 5 : : : 40436 4605 6 Distinction distinction NN 40436 4605 7 made make VBN 40436 4605 8 between between IN 40436 4605 9 the the DT 40436 4605 10 special special JJ 40436 4605 11 sciences science NNS 40436 4605 12 and and CC 40436 4605 13 the the DT 40436 4605 14 science science NN 40436 4605 15 of of IN 40436 4605 16 Good Good NNP 40436 4605 17 and and CC 40436 4605 18 Evil Evil NNP 40436 4605 19 . . . 40436 4606 1 Without without IN 40436 4606 2 this this DT 40436 4606 3 last last JJ 40436 4606 4 , , , 40436 4606 5 the the DT 40436 4606 6 special special JJ 40436 4606 7 sciences science NNS 40436 4606 8 are be VBP 40436 4606 9 of of IN 40436 4606 10 no no DT 40436 4606 11 use use NN 40436 4606 12 . . . 40436 4606 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4607 1 This this DT 40436 4607 2 cognition cognition NN 40436 4607 3 of of IN 40436 4607 4 good good JJ 40436 4607 5 and and CC 40436 4607 6 evil evil NN 40436 4607 7 -- -- : 40436 4607 8 the the DT 40436 4607 9 science science NN 40436 4607 10 of of IN 40436 4607 11 the the DT 40436 4607 12 profitable profitable JJ 40436 4607 13 -- -- : 40436 4607 14 is be VBZ 40436 4607 15 here here RB 40436 4607 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4607 17 in in IN 40436 4607 18 the the DT 40436 4607 19 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4607 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4607 21 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 4607 22 by by IN 40436 4607 23 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4607 24 to to TO 40436 4607 25 have have VB 40436 4607 26 a a DT 40436 4607 27 place place NN 40436 4607 28 of of IN 40436 4607 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4607 30 own own JJ 40436 4607 31 among among IN 40436 4607 32 the the DT 40436 4607 33 other other JJ 40436 4607 34 sciences science NNS 40436 4607 35 ; ; : 40436 4607 36 and and CC 40436 4607 37 even even RB 40436 4607 38 to to TO 40436 4607 39 be be VB 40436 4607 40 first first JJ 40436 4607 41 among among IN 40436 4607 42 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4607 43 , , , 40436 4607 44 essentially essentially RB 40436 4607 45 necessary necessary JJ 40436 4607 46 to to TO 40436 4607 47 supervise supervise VB 40436 4607 48 and and CC 40436 4607 49 direct direct VB 40436 4607 50 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4607 51 , , , 40436 4607 52 as as IN 40436 4607 53 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4607 54 had have VBD 40436 4607 55 been be VBN 40436 4607 56 declared declare VBN 40436 4607 57 in in IN 40436 4607 58 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 4607 59 II II NNP 40436 4607 60 . . . 40436 4608 1 Now now RB 40436 4608 2 the the DT 40436 4608 3 same same JJ 40436 4608 4 supervising supervising NN 40436 4608 5 place place NN 40436 4608 6 and and CC 40436 4608 7 directorship directorship NN 40436 4608 8 had have VBD 40436 4608 9 been be VBN 40436 4608 10 claimed claim VBN 40436 4608 11 by by IN 40436 4608 12 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 4608 13 for for IN 40436 4608 14 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4608 15 as as IN 40436 4608 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4608 17 defines define VBZ 40436 4608 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4608 19 -- -- : 40436 4608 20 that that RB 40436 4608 21 is is RB 40436 4608 22 , , , 40436 4608 23 self self NN 40436 4608 24 - - HYPH 40436 4608 25 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4608 26 , , , 40436 4608 27 or or CC 40436 4608 28 the the DT 40436 4608 29 cognition cognition NN 40436 4608 30 of of IN 40436 4608 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4608 32 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4608 33 and and CC 40436 4608 34 non non NNS 40436 4608 35 - - NNS 40436 4608 36 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4608 37 . . . 40436 4609 1 But but CC 40436 4609 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4609 3 doubts doubt VBZ 40436 4609 4 even even RB 40436 4609 5 the the DT 40436 4609 6 reality reality NN 40436 4609 7 of of IN 40436 4609 8 such such JJ 40436 4609 9 self self NN 40436 4609 10 - - HYPH 40436 4609 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4609 12 : : : 40436 4609 13 and and CC 40436 4609 14 granting grant VBG 40436 4609 15 for for IN 40436 4609 16 argument argument NN 40436 4609 17 's 's POS 40436 4609 18 sake sake NN 40436 4609 19 that that IN 40436 4609 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4609 21 exists exist VBZ 40436 4609 22 , , , 40436 4609 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4609 24 still still RB 40436 4609 25 does do VBZ 40436 4609 26 not not RB 40436 4609 27 see see VB 40436 4609 28 how how WRB 40436 4609 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4609 30 can can MD 40436 4609 31 be be VB 40436 4609 32 profitable profitable JJ 40436 4609 33 . . . 40436 4610 1 For for IN 40436 4610 2 the the DT 40436 4610 3 utmost utmost NN 40436 4610 4 which which WDT 40436 4610 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4610 6 supervision supervision NN 40436 4610 7 can can MD 40436 4610 8 ensure ensure VB 40436 4610 9 would would MD 40436 4610 10 be be VB 40436 4610 11 , , , 40436 4610 12 that that IN 40436 4610 13 each each DT 40436 4610 14 description description NN 40436 4610 15 of of IN 40436 4610 16 work work NN 40436 4610 17 shall shall MD 40436 4610 18 be be VB 40436 4610 19 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 4610 20 done do VBN 40436 4610 21 , , , 40436 4610 22 by by IN 40436 4610 23 the the DT 40436 4610 24 skilful skilful JJ 40436 4610 25 man man NN 40436 4610 26 , , , 40436 4610 27 and and CC 40436 4610 28 not not RB 40436 4610 29 by by IN 40436 4610 30 the the DT 40436 4610 31 unskilful unskilful JJ 40436 4610 32 . . . 40436 4611 1 But but CC 40436 4611 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4611 3 is be VBZ 40436 4611 4 not not RB 40436 4611 5 true true JJ 40436 4611 6 , , , 40436 4611 7 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 4611 8 speaking speak VBG 40436 4611 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4611 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4611 11 argues argue VBZ 40436 4611 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4611 13 , , , 40436 4611 14 that that IN 40436 4611 15 acting act VBG 40436 4611 16 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 4611 17 or or CC 40436 4611 18 with with IN 40436 4611 19 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4611 20 is be VBZ 40436 4611 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 4611 22 for for IN 40436 4611 23 well well RB 40436 4611 24 doing doing NN 40436 4611 25 or or CC 40436 4611 26 for for IN 40436 4611 27 happiness happiness NN 40436 4611 28 : : : 40436 4611 29 for for IN 40436 4611 30 the the DT 40436 4611 31 question question NN 40436 4611 32 must must MD 40436 4611 33 next next RB 40436 4611 34 be be VB 40436 4611 35 asked ask VBN 40436 4611 36 -- -- : 40436 4611 37 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4611 38 -- -- : 40436 4611 39 of of IN 40436 4611 40 what what WP 40436 4611 41 ? ? . 40436 4612 1 Not not RB 40436 4612 2 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4612 3 of of IN 40436 4612 4 leather leather NN 40436 4612 5 - - HYPH 40436 4612 6 cutting cutting NN 40436 4612 7 , , , 40436 4612 8 carpenter carpenter NNP 40436 4612 9 's 's POS 40436 4612 10 or or CC 40436 4612 11 brazier brazier NNP 40436 4612 12 's 's POS 40436 4612 13 work work NN 40436 4612 14 , , , 40436 4612 15 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 4612 16 , , , 40436 4612 17 or or CC 40436 4612 18 even even RB 40436 4612 19 medicine medicine NN 40436 4612 20 : : : 40436 4612 21 these these DT 40436 4612 22 , , , 40436 4612 23 and and CC 40436 4612 24 many many JJ 40436 4612 25 others other NNS 40436 4612 26 , , , 40436 4612 27 a a DT 40436 4612 28 man man NN 40436 4612 29 may may MD 40436 4612 30 possess possess VB 40436 4612 31 , , , 40436 4612 32 and and CC 40436 4612 33 may may MD 40436 4612 34 act act VB 40436 4612 35 according accord VBG 40436 4612 36 to to IN 40436 4612 37 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4612 38 ; ; : 40436 4612 39 but but CC 40436 4612 40 still still RB 40436 4612 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4612 42 will will MD 40436 4612 43 not not RB 40436 4612 44 attain attain VB 40436 4612 45 the the DT 40436 4612 46 end end NN 40436 4612 47 of of IN 40436 4612 48 being be VBG 40436 4612 49 happy happy JJ 40436 4612 50 . . . 40436 4613 1 All all DT 40436 4613 2 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4613 3 contribute contribute VBP 40436 4613 4 in in IN 40436 4613 5 greater great JJR 40436 4613 6 or or CC 40436 4613 7 less less JJR 40436 4613 8 proportion proportion NN 40436 4613 9 towards towards IN 40436 4613 10 that that DT 40436 4613 11 end end NN 40436 4613 12 : : : 40436 4613 13 but but CC 40436 4613 14 what what WP 40436 4613 15 contributes contribute VBZ 40436 4613 16 most most RBS 40436 4613 17 , , , 40436 4613 18 and and CC 40436 4613 19 most most RBS 40436 4613 20 essentially essentially RB 40436 4613 21 , , , 40436 4613 22 is be VBZ 40436 4613 23 the the DT 40436 4613 24 cognition cognition NN 40436 4613 25 of of IN 40436 4613 26 good good JJ 40436 4613 27 and and CC 40436 4613 28 evil evil NN 40436 4613 29 , , , 40436 4613 30 without without IN 40436 4613 31 which which WDT 40436 4613 32 all all PDT 40436 4613 33 the the DT 40436 4613 34 rest rest NN 40436 4613 35 are be VBP 40436 4613 36 insufficient insufficient JJ 40436 4613 37 . . . 40436 4614 1 Of of IN 40436 4614 2 this this DT 40436 4614 3 last last RB 40436 4614 4 - - HYPH 40436 4614 5 mentioned mention VBN 40436 4614 6 cognition cognition NN 40436 4614 7 or or CC 40436 4614 8 science science NN 40436 4614 9 , , , 40436 4614 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4614 11 is be VBZ 40436 4614 12 the the DT 40436 4614 13 special special JJ 40436 4614 14 object object NN 40436 4614 15 to to TO 40436 4614 16 ensure ensure VB 40436 4614 17 profit profit NN 40436 4614 18 or or CC 40436 4614 19 benefit:[42 benefit:[42 NNS 40436 4614 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4614 21 to to TO 40436 4614 22 take take VB 40436 4614 23 care care NN 40436 4614 24 that that IN 40436 4614 25 everything everything NN 40436 4614 26 done do VBN 40436 4614 27 by by IN 40436 4614 28 the the DT 40436 4614 29 other other JJ 40436 4614 30 sciences science NNS 40436 4614 31 shall shall MD 40436 4614 32 be be VB 40436 4614 33 done do VBN 40436 4614 34 well well RB 40436 4614 35 or or CC 40436 4614 36 in in IN 40436 4614 37 a a DT 40436 4614 38 manner manner NN 40436 4614 39 conducing conduce VBG 40436 4614 40 towards towards IN 40436 4614 41 the the DT 40436 4614 42 end end NN 40436 4614 43 Happiness happiness NN 40436 4614 44 . . . 40436 4615 1 After after IN 40436 4615 2 this this DT 40436 4615 3 , , , 40436 4615 4 there there EX 40436 4615 5 is be VBZ 40436 4615 6 no no DT 40436 4615 7 province province NN 40436 4615 8 left leave VBN 40436 4615 9 for for IN 40436 4615 10 temperance--_i.e temperance--_i.e NNP 40436 4615 11 . . . 40436 4615 12 _ _ NNP 40436 4615 13 , , , 40436 4615 14 self self NN 40436 4615 15 - - HYPH 40436 4615 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4615 17 , , , 40436 4615 18 or or CC 40436 4615 19 the the DT 40436 4615 20 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4615 21 of of IN 40436 4615 22 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4615 23 and and CC 40436 4615 24 non non NNS 40436 4615 25 - - NNS 40436 4615 26 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 4615 27 : : : 40436 4615 28 no no DT 40436 4615 29 assignable assignable JJ 40436 4615 30 way way NN 40436 4615 31 in in IN 40436 4615 32 which which WDT 40436 4615 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4615 34 can can MD 40436 4615 35 yield yield VB 40436 4615 36 any any DT 40436 4615 37 benefit benefit NN 40436 4615 38 . . . 40436 4616 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4616 2 43 43 CD 40436 4616 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4616 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4616 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4616 6 42 42 CD 40436 4616 7 : : : 40436 4616 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4616 9 , , , 40436 4616 10 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4616 11 . . . 40436 4617 1 174 174 CD 40436 4617 2 D. D. NNP 40436 4617 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4617 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4617 5 : : : 40436 4617 6 Ou)ch ou)ch CD 40436 4617 7 au(/tê| au(/tê| NNP 40436 4617 8 de/ de/ NNP 40436 4617 9 ge ge NNP 40436 4617 10 , , , 40436 4617 11 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 4617 12 e)/oiken e)/oiken NNP 40436 4617 13 , , , 40436 4617 14 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 4617 15 ê ê NNP 40436 4617 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4617 17 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 4617 18 / / SYM 40436 4617 19 nê nê UH 40436 4617 20 , , , 40436 4617 21 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 4617 22 ' ' '' 40436 4617 23 ê(=s ê(=s CD 40436 4617 24 e)/rgon e)/rgon NN 40436 4617 25 e)sti\ e)sti\ NN 40436 4617 26 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4617 27 ô)phelei ô)phelei NN 40436 4617 28 = = NFP 40436 4617 29 n n NNP 40436 4617 30 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 4617 31 = = SYM 40436 4617 32 s s NN 40436 4617 33 . . . 40436 4618 1 Ou Ou NNP 40436 4618 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4618 3 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4618 4 e)pistêmô e)pistêmô CD 40436 4618 5 = = SYM 40436 4618 6 n n CC 40436 4618 7 ge ge NNP 40436 4618 8 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4618 9 a)nepistêmosunô a)nepistêmosunô NNP 40436 4618 10 = = SYM 40436 4618 11 n n CC 40436 4618 12 ê ê NNP 40436 4618 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4618 14 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 4618 15 / / SYM 40436 4618 16 mê mê NNP 40436 4618 17 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 4618 18 / / SYM 40436 4618 19 n n NNP 40436 4618 20 , , , 40436 4618 21 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 4618 22 a)gathou= a)gathou= NN 40436 4618 23 te te NNP 40436 4618 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4618 25 kakou=. kakou=. NNP 40436 4618 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4618 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4619 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4619 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4619 3 43 43 CD 40436 4619 4 : : : 40436 4619 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4619 6 , , , 40436 4619 7 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4619 8 . . . 40436 4620 1 174 174 CD 40436 4620 2 E. E. NNP 40436 4620 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4620 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4620 5 : : : 40436 4620 6 Ou)k Ou)k NNP 40436 4620 7 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 4620 8 u(giei u(giei NNP 40436 4620 9 / / SYM 40436 4620 10 as as IN 40436 4620 11 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 4620 12 dêmiourgo dêmiourgo NNP 40436 4620 13 / / SYM 40436 4620 14 s s NN 40436 4620 15 ? ? . 40436 4621 1 Ou Ou NNP 40436 4621 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4621 3 dê dê NN 40436 4621 4 = = SYM 40436 4621 5 ta ta ADD 40436 4621 6 . . . 40436 4622 1 A)/llês a)/llê NNS 40436 4622 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4622 3 ê)=n ê)=n IN 40436 4622 4 te te NNP 40436 4622 5 / / SYM 40436 4622 6 chnês chnês NN 40436 4622 7 u(gi u(gi NNP 40436 4622 8 / / SYM 40436 4622 9 eia eia NN 40436 4622 10 ? ? . 40436 4623 1 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 4623 2 ou)/ ou)/ RB 40436 4623 3 ? ? . 40436 4624 1 A)/llês a)/llê NNS 40436 4624 2 ; ; : 40436 4624 3 Ou)d Ou)d NNP 40436 4624 4 ' ' '' 40436 4624 5 a)/ra a)/ra RB 40436 4624 6 ô)phelei ô)phelei NNP 40436 4624 7 / / SYM 40436 4624 8 as as IN 40436 4624 9 , , , 40436 4624 10 ô)= ô)= UH 40436 4624 11 e(tai e(tai JJ 40436 4624 12 = = SYM 40436 4624 13 re re IN 40436 4624 14 ; ; , 40436 4624 15 a)/llê| a)/llê| NNP 40436 4624 16 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4624 17 au)= au)= JJ 40436 4624 18 a)pe a)pe NNP 40436 4624 19 / / SYM 40436 4624 20 domen domen NNP 40436 4624 21 tou tou NNP 40436 4624 22 = = NNP 40436 4624 23 to to TO 40436 4624 24 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4624 25 e)/rgon e)/rgon NNP 40436 4624 26 te te NNP 40436 4624 27 / / SYM 40436 4624 28 chnê| chnê| NNP 40436 4624 29 nu nu NNP 40436 4624 30 = = SYM 40436 4624 31 n n CC 40436 4624 32 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 4624 33 ; ; : 40436 4624 34 ê)= ê)= . 40436 4624 35 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4624 36 ? ? . 40436 4625 1 Pa Pa NNP 40436 4625 2 / / SYM 40436 4625 3 nu nu NNP 40436 4625 4 ge ge NNP 40436 4625 5 . . . 40436 4626 1 Pô Pô NNP 40436 4626 2 = = SYM 40436 4626 3 s s NNP 40436 4626 4 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 4626 5 ô)phe ô)phe NNP 40436 4626 6 / / SYM 40436 4626 7 limos limo NNS 40436 4626 8 e)/stai e)/stai NFP 40436 4626 9 ê(sôphrosu ê(sôphrosu NNP 40436 4626 10 / / SYM 40436 4626 11 nê nê JJ 40436 4626 12 , , , 40436 4626 13 ou)demia ou)demia NN 40436 4626 14 = = SYM 40436 4626 15 s s NNP 40436 4626 16 ô)phelei ô)phelei NNP 40436 4626 17 / / SYM 40436 4626 18 as as IN 40436 4626 19 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 4626 20 dêmiourgo dêmiourgo NNP 40436 4626 21 / / SYM 40436 4626 22 s s JJ 40436 4626 23 ? ? . 40436 4627 1 Ou)damô Ou)damô NNP 40436 4627 2 = = SYM 40436 4627 3 s s NNP 40436 4627 4 , , , 40436 4627 5 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 4627 6 Sô Sô NNP 40436 4627 7 / / SYM 40436 4627 8 krates krate NNS 40436 4627 9 , , , 40436 4627 10 e)/oike/ e)/oike/ NNP 40436 4627 11 ge ge NNP 40436 4627 12 . . . 40436 4627 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4627 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4628 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4628 2 Side side NN 40436 4628 3 - - HYPH 40436 4628 4 note note NN 40436 4628 5 : : : 40436 4628 6 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4628 7 , , , 40436 4628 8 always always RB 40436 4628 9 relative relative JJ 40436 4628 10 to to IN 40436 4628 11 some some DT 40436 4628 12 object object NN 40436 4628 13 known know VBN 40436 4628 14 . . . 40436 4629 1 Postulate postulate NN 40436 4629 2 or or CC 40436 4629 3 divination divination NN 40436 4629 4 of of IN 40436 4629 5 a a DT 40436 4629 6 Science Science NNP 40436 4629 7 of of IN 40436 4629 8 Teleology Teleology NNP 40436 4629 9 . . . 40436 4629 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4630 1 Two two CD 40436 4630 2 points point NNS 40436 4630 3 are be VBP 40436 4630 4 here here RB 40436 4630 5 to to TO 40436 4630 6 be be VB 40436 4630 7 noted note VBN 40436 4630 8 , , , 40436 4630 9 as as IN 40436 4630 10 contained contain VBN 40436 4630 11 and and CC 40436 4630 12 debated debate VBN 40436 4630 13 in in IN 40436 4630 14 the the DT 40436 4630 15 handling handling NN 40436 4630 16 of of IN 40436 4630 17 this this DT 40436 4630 18 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4630 19 . . . 40436 4631 1 1 1 LS 40436 4631 2 . . . 40436 4632 1 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4632 2 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 4632 3 , , , 40436 4632 4 is be VBZ 40436 4632 5 a a DT 40436 4632 6 word word NN 40436 4632 7 without without IN 40436 4632 8 meaning mean VBG 40436 4632 9 : : : 40436 4632 10 all all DT 40436 4632 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4632 12 is be VBZ 40436 4632 13 relative relative JJ 40436 4632 14 , , , 40436 4632 15 and and CC 40436 4632 16 has have VBZ 40436 4632 17 a a DT 40436 4632 18 definite definite JJ 40436 4632 19 object object NN 40436 4632 20 or or CC 40436 4632 21 _ _ NNP 40436 4632 22 cognitum cognitum NNP 40436 4632 23 _ _ NNP 40436 4632 24 : : : 40436 4632 25 there there EX 40436 4632 26 can can MD 40436 4632 27 be be VB 40436 4632 28 no no DT 40436 4632 29 _ _ NNP 40436 4632 30 scientia scientia NN 40436 4632 31 scientiarum scientiarum NNP 40436 4632 32 _ _ NNP 40436 4632 33 . . . 40436 4633 1 2 2 LS 40436 4633 2 . . . 40436 4634 1 Among among IN 40436 4634 2 the the DT 40436 4634 3 various various JJ 40436 4634 4 objects object NNS 40436 4634 5 of of IN 40436 4634 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4634 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4634 8 _ _ NNP 40436 4634 9 cognita cognita NNP 40436 4634 10 _ _ NNP 40436 4634 11 or or CC 40436 4634 12 _ _ NNP 40436 4634 13 cognoscenda cognoscenda NNP 40436 4634 14 _ _ NNP 40436 4634 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4634 16 , , , 40436 4634 17 one one CD 40436 4634 18 is be VBZ 40436 4634 19 , , , 40436 4634 20 _ _ NNP 40436 4634 21 good good JJ 40436 4634 22 and and CC 40436 4634 23 evil evil JJ 40436 4634 24 _ _ NNP 40436 4634 25 . . . 40436 4635 1 There there EX 40436 4635 2 is be VBZ 40436 4635 3 a a DT 40436 4635 4 science science NN 40436 4635 5 of of IN 40436 4635 6 good good NN 40436 4635 7 and and CC 40436 4635 8 evil evil NN 40436 4635 9 , , , 40436 4635 10 the the DT 40436 4635 11 function function NN 40436 4635 12 of of IN 40436 4635 13 which which WDT 40436 4635 14 is be VBZ 40436 4635 15 , , , 40436 4635 16 to to TO 40436 4635 17 watch watch VB 40436 4635 18 over over RP 40436 4635 19 and and CC 40436 4635 20 compare compare VB 40436 4635 21 the the DT 40436 4635 22 results result NNS 40436 4635 23 of of IN 40436 4635 24 the the DT 40436 4635 25 other other JJ 40436 4635 26 sciences science NNS 40436 4635 27 , , , 40436 4635 28 in in IN 40436 4635 29 order order NN 40436 4635 30 to to TO 40436 4635 31 promote promote VB 40436 4635 32 results result NNS 40436 4635 33 of of IN 40436 4635 34 happiness happiness NN 40436 4635 35 , , , 40436 4635 36 and and CC 40436 4635 37 to to TO 40436 4635 38 prevent prevent VB 40436 4635 39 results result NNS 40436 4635 40 of of IN 40436 4635 41 misery misery NN 40436 4635 42 : : : 40436 4635 43 without without IN 40436 4635 44 the the DT 40436 4635 45 supervision supervision NN 40436 4635 46 of of IN 40436 4635 47 this this DT 40436 4635 48 latter latter JJ 40436 4635 49 science science NN 40436 4635 50 , , , 40436 4635 51 the the DT 40436 4635 52 other other JJ 40436 4635 53 sciences science NNS 40436 4635 54 might may MD 40436 4635 55 be be VB 40436 4635 56 all all DT 40436 4635 57 exactly exactly RB 40436 4635 58 followed follow VBN 40436 4635 59 out out RP 40436 4635 60 , , , 40436 4635 61 but but CC 40436 4635 62 no no DT 40436 4635 63 rational rational JJ 40436 4635 64 comparison comparison NN 40436 4635 65 could could MD 40436 4635 66 be be VB 40436 4635 67 had have VBN 40436 4635 68 between between IN 40436 4635 69 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4635 70 . . . 40436 4636 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4636 2 44 44 CD 40436 4636 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4636 4 In in IN 40436 4636 5 other other JJ 40436 4636 6 words word NNS 40436 4636 7 , , , 40436 4636 8 there there EX 40436 4636 9 is be VBZ 40436 4636 10 a a DT 40436 4636 11 science science NN 40436 4636 12 of of IN 40436 4636 13 Ends end NNS 40436 4636 14 , , , 40436 4636 15 estimating estimate VBG 40436 4636 16 the the DT 40436 4636 17 comparative comparative JJ 40436 4636 18 worth worth NN 40436 4636 19 of of IN 40436 4636 20 each each DT 40436 4636 21 End end NN 40436 4636 22 in in IN 40436 4636 23 relation relation NN 40436 4636 24 to to IN 40436 4636 25 other other JJ 40436 4636 26 Ends Ends NNPS 40436 4636 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4636 28 Teleology teleology NN 40436 4636 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4636 30 : : : 40436 4636 31 distinct distinct JJ 40436 4636 32 from from IN 40436 4636 33 those those DT 40436 4636 34 other other JJ 40436 4636 35 more more RBR 40436 4636 36 special special JJ 40436 4636 37 sciences science NNS 40436 4636 38 , , , 40436 4636 39 which which WDT 40436 4636 40 study study VBP 40436 4636 41 the the DT 40436 4636 42 means mean NNS 40436 4636 43 each each DT 40436 4636 44 towards towards IN 40436 4636 45 a a DT 40436 4636 46 separate separate JJ 40436 4636 47 End end NN 40436 4636 48 of of IN 40436 4636 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4636 50 own own JJ 40436 4636 51 . . . 40436 4637 1 Here here RB 40436 4637 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4637 3 fall fall VBP 40436 4637 4 into into IN 40436 4637 5 the the DT 40436 4637 6 same same JJ 40436 4637 7 track track NN 40436 4637 8 as as IN 40436 4637 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4637 10 have have VBP 40436 4637 11 already already RB 40436 4637 12 indicated indicate VBN 40436 4637 13 in in IN 40436 4637 14 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4637 15 and and CC 40436 4637 16 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 4637 17 II II NNP 40436 4637 18 . . . 40436 4638 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4638 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4638 3 44 44 CD 40436 4638 4 : : : 40436 4638 5 Compare compare VB 40436 4638 6 what what WP 40436 4638 7 has have VBZ 40436 4638 8 been be VBN 40436 4638 9 said say VBN 40436 4638 10 upon upon IN 40436 4638 11 the the DT 40436 4638 12 same same JJ 40436 4638 13 subject subject NN 40436 4638 14 in in IN 40436 4638 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4638 16 remarks remark NNS 40436 4638 17 on on IN 40436 4638 18 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 4638 19 . . . 40436 4639 1 i. i. NNP 40436 4639 2 and and CC 40436 4639 3 ii ii NNP 40436 4639 4 . . . 40436 4640 1 p. p. NN 40436 4641 1 31 31 CD 40436 4641 2 . . . 40436 4642 1 * * NFP 40436 4642 2 * * NFP 40436 4642 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4642 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4642 5 Side side NN 40436 4642 6 - - HYPH 40436 4642 7 note note NN 40436 4642 8 : : : 40436 4642 9 Courage Courage NNP 40436 4642 10 and and CC 40436 4642 11 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4642 12 , , , 40436 4642 13 handled handle VBD 40436 4642 14 both both CC 40436 4642 15 by by IN 40436 4642 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4642 17 and and CC 40436 4642 18 by by IN 40436 4642 19 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 4642 20 . . . 40436 4643 1 Comparison comparison NN 40436 4643 2 between between IN 40436 4643 3 the the DT 40436 4643 4 two two CD 40436 4643 5 . . . 40436 4643 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4644 1 These these DT 40436 4644 2 matters matter NNS 40436 4644 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4644 4 shall shall MD 40436 4644 5 revert revert VB 40436 4644 6 to to IN 40436 4644 7 in in IN 40436 4644 8 other other JJ 40436 4644 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4644 10 , , , 40436 4644 11 where where WRB 40436 4644 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4644 13 shall shall MD 40436 4644 14 find find VB 40436 4644 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4644 16 turned turn VBN 40436 4644 17 over over RP 40436 4644 18 and and CC 40436 4644 19 canvassed canvass VBN 40436 4644 20 in in IN 40436 4644 21 many many JJ 40436 4644 22 different different JJ 40436 4644 23 ways way NNS 40436 4644 24 . . . 40436 4645 1 One one CD 40436 4645 2 farther farther JJ 40436 4645 3 observation observation NN 40436 4645 4 remains remain VBZ 40436 4645 5 to to TO 40436 4645 6 be be VB 40436 4645 7 made make VBN 40436 4645 8 on on IN 40436 4645 9 the the DT 40436 4645 10 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4645 11 and and CC 40436 4645 12 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4645 13 , , , 40436 4645 14 discussing discuss VBG 40436 4645 15 as as IN 40436 4645 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4645 17 do do VBP 40436 4645 18 Courage Courage NNP 40436 4645 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4645 20 which which WDT 40436 4645 21 is be VBZ 40436 4645 22 also also RB 40436 4645 23 again again RB 40436 4645 24 discussed discuss VBN 40436 4645 25 in in IN 40436 4645 26 the the DT 40436 4645 27 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 4645 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4645 29 and and CC 40436 4645 30 Temperance Temperance NNP 40436 4645 31 . . . 40436 4646 1 An an DT 40436 4646 2 interesting interesting JJ 40436 4646 3 comparison comparison NN 40436 4646 4 may may MD 40436 4646 5 be be VB 40436 4646 6 made make VBN 40436 4646 7 between between IN 40436 4646 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4646 9 and and CC 40436 4646 10 the the DT 40436 4646 11 third third JJ 40436 4646 12 book book NN 40436 4646 13 of of IN 40436 4646 14 the the DT 40436 4646 15 Nikomachean Nikomachean NNP 40436 4646 16 Ethics Ethics NNPS 40436 4646 17 of of IN 40436 4646 18 Aristotle,[45 Aristotle,[45 NNP 40436 4646 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4646 20 where where WRB 40436 4646 21 the the DT 40436 4646 22 same same JJ 40436 4646 23 two two CD 40436 4646 24 subjects subject NNS 40436 4646 25 are be VBP 40436 4646 26 handled handle VBN 40436 4646 27 in in IN 40436 4646 28 the the DT 40436 4646 29 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40436 4646 30 manner manner NN 40436 4646 31 . . . 40436 4647 1 The the DT 40436 4647 2 direct direct JJ 40436 4647 3 , , , 40436 4647 4 didactic didactic JJ 40436 4647 5 , , , 40436 4647 6 systematising systematising JJ 40436 4647 7 , , , 40436 4647 8 brevity brevity NN 40436 4647 9 of of IN 40436 4647 10 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 4647 11 contrasts contrast VBZ 40436 4647 12 remarkably remarkably RB 40436 4647 13 with with IN 40436 4647 14 the the DT 40436 4647 15 indirect indirect JJ 40436 4647 16 and and CC 40436 4647 17 circuitous circuitous JJ 40436 4647 18 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 4647 19 , , , 40436 4647 20 the the DT 40436 4647 21 multiplied multiply VBN 40436 4647 22 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 4647 23 comparisons comparison NNS 40436 4647 24 , , , 40436 4647 25 the the DT 40436 4647 26 shifting shift VBG 40436 4647 27 points point NNS 40436 4647 28 of of IN 40436 4647 29 view view NN 40436 4647 30 , , , 40436 4647 31 which which WDT 40436 4647 32 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4647 33 find find VBP 40436 4647 34 in in IN 40436 4647 35 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4647 36 . . . 40436 4648 1 Each each DT 40436 4648 2 has have VBZ 40436 4648 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4648 4 advantages advantage NNS 40436 4648 5 : : : 40436 4648 6 and and CC 40436 4648 7 both both DT 40436 4648 8 together together RB 40436 4648 9 will will MD 40436 4648 10 be be VB 40436 4648 11 found find VBN 40436 4648 12 not not RB 40436 4648 13 more more JJR 40436 4648 14 than than IN 40436 4648 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 4648 16 , , , 40436 4648 17 for for IN 40436 4648 18 any any DT 40436 4648 19 one one NN 40436 4648 20 who who WP 40436 4648 21 is be VBZ 40436 4648 22 seriously seriously RB 40436 4648 23 bent bent JJ 40436 4648 24 on on IN 40436 4648 25 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 4648 26 what what WP 40436 4648 27 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4648 28 calls call VBZ 40436 4648 29 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4648 30 , , , 40436 4648 31 with with IN 40436 4648 32 the the DT 40436 4648 33 cross cross NN 40436 4648 34 - - HYPH 40436 4648 35 examining examine VBG 40436 4648 36 power power NN 40436 4648 37 included include VBN 40436 4648 38 in in IN 40436 4648 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4648 40 . . . 40436 4649 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 4649 2 is be VBZ 40436 4649 3 greatly greatly RB 40436 4649 4 superior superior JJ 40436 4649 5 to to IN 40436 4649 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4649 7 in in IN 40436 4649 8 one one CD 40436 4649 9 important important JJ 40436 4649 10 attribute attribute NN 40436 4649 11 of of IN 40436 4649 12 a a DT 40436 4649 13 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 4649 14 : : : 40436 4649 15 in in IN 40436 4649 16 the the DT 40436 4649 17 care care NN 40436 4649 18 which which WDT 40436 4649 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4649 20 takes take VBZ 40436 4649 21 to to TO 40436 4649 22 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 4649 23 the the DT 40436 4649 24 different different JJ 40436 4649 25 significations signification NNS 40436 4649 26 of of IN 40436 4649 27 the the DT 40436 4649 28 same same JJ 40436 4649 29 word word NN 40436 4649 30 : : : 40436 4649 31 the the DT 40436 4649 32 univocal univocal JJ 40436 4649 33 and and CC 40436 4649 34 the the DT 40436 4649 35 equivocal equivocal NN 40436 4649 36 , , , 40436 4649 37 the the DT 40436 4649 38 generically generically RB 40436 4649 39 identical identical JJ 40436 4649 40 from from IN 40436 4649 41 the the DT 40436 4649 42 remotely remotely RB 40436 4649 43 analogical analogical JJ 40436 4649 44 , , , 40436 4649 45 the the DT 40436 4649 46 proper proper JJ 40436 4649 47 from from IN 40436 4649 48 the the DT 40436 4649 49 improper improper NN 40436 4649 50 , , , 40436 4649 51 the the DT 40436 4649 52 literal literal JJ 40436 4649 53 from from IN 40436 4649 54 the the DT 40436 4649 55 metaphorical metaphorical JJ 40436 4649 56 . . . 40436 4650 1 Of of IN 40436 4650 2 such such JJ 40436 4650 3 precautions precaution NNS 40436 4650 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4650 5 discover discover VBP 40436 4650 6 little little JJ 40436 4650 7 or or CC 40436 4650 8 no no DT 40436 4650 9 trace trace NN 40436 4650 10 in in IN 40436 4650 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4650 12 , , , 40436 4650 13 who who WP 40436 4650 14 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 4650 15 seems seem VBZ 40436 4650 16 not not RB 40436 4650 17 merely merely RB 40436 4650 18 to to TO 40436 4650 19 neglect neglect VB 40436 4650 20 , , , 40436 4650 21 but but CC 40436 4650 22 even even RB 40436 4650 23 to to TO 40436 4650 24 deride deride VB 40436 4650 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4650 26 . . . 40436 4651 1 Yet yet CC 40436 4651 2 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 4651 3 , , , 40436 4651 4 assisted assist VBN 40436 4651 5 as as IN 40436 4651 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4651 7 was be VBD 40436 4651 8 by by IN 40436 4651 9 all all DT 40436 4651 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4651 11 's 's POS 40436 4651 12 speculations speculation NNS 40436 4651 13 before before IN 40436 4651 14 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4651 15 , , , 40436 4651 16 is be VBZ 40436 4651 17 not not RB 40436 4651 18 to to TO 40436 4651 19 be be VB 40436 4651 20 understood understand VBN 40436 4651 21 as as IN 40436 4651 22 having have VBG 40436 4651 23 superseded supersede VBN 40436 4651 24 the the DT 40436 4651 25 necessity necessity NN 40436 4651 26 for for IN 40436 4651 27 that that DT 40436 4651 28 negative negative JJ 40436 4651 29 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 4651 30 which which WDT 40436 4651 31 animates animate VBZ 40436 4651 32 the the DT 40436 4651 33 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 4651 34 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 4651 35 of of IN 40436 4651 36 Search search NN 40436 4651 37 : : : 40436 4651 38 nor nor CC 40436 4651 39 would would MD 40436 4651 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4651 41 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 4651 42 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 4651 43 have have VBP 40436 4651 44 held hold VBN 40436 4651 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4651 46 grounds ground NNS 40436 4651 47 before before IN 40436 4651 48 a a DT 40436 4651 49 cross cross NN 40436 4651 50 - - JJ 40436 4651 51 examining examine VBG 40436 4651 52 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4651 53 . . . 40436 4652 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4652 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4652 3 45 45 CD 40436 4652 4 : : : 40436 4652 5 Aristot Aristot NNP 40436 4652 6 . . . 40436 4653 1 Ethic ethic NN 40436 4653 2 . . . 40436 4654 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 4654 2 . . . 40436 4655 1 iii iii NNP 40436 4655 2 . . . 40436 4656 1 p. p. NN 40436 4656 2 1115 1115 CD 40436 4656 3 , , , 40436 4656 4 1119 1119 CD 40436 4656 5 ; ; : 40436 4656 6 also also RB 40436 4656 7 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 4656 8 . . . 40436 4657 1 Eudem Eudem NNP 40436 4657 2 . . . 40436 4658 1 iii iii NNP 40436 4658 2 . . . 40436 4659 1 1229 1229 CD 40436 4659 2 - - SYM 40436 4659 3 1231 1231 CD 40436 4659 4 . . . 40436 4660 1 The the DT 40436 4660 2 comments comment NNS 40436 4660 3 of of IN 40436 4660 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 4660 5 upon upon IN 40436 4660 6 the the DT 40436 4660 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 4660 8 of of IN 40436 4660 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4660 10 respecting respect VBG 40436 4660 11 Courage Courage NNP 40436 4660 12 seem seem VBP 40436 4660 13 to to TO 40436 4660 14 relate relate VB 40436 4660 15 rather rather RB 40436 4660 16 to to IN 40436 4660 17 the the DT 40436 4660 18 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 4660 19 than than IN 40436 4660 20 to to IN 40436 4660 21 the the DT 40436 4660 22 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4660 23 of of IN 40436 4660 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4660 25 . . . 40436 4661 1 See see VB 40436 4661 2 Eth Eth NNP 40436 4661 3 . . . 40436 4662 1 Nik Nik NNP 40436 4662 2 . . . 40436 4663 1 1116 1116 CD 40436 4663 2 , , , 40436 4663 3 6 6 CD 40436 4663 4 , , , 40436 4663 5 4 4 CD 40436 4663 6 ; ; : 40436 4663 7 Eth Eth NNP 40436 4663 8 . . . 40436 4664 1 Eud Eud NNP 40436 4664 2 . . . 40436 4665 1 1229 1229 CD 40436 4665 2 , , , 40436 4665 3 a. a. NN 40436 4666 1 15 15 CD 40436 4666 2 . . . 40436 4666 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4667 1 APPENDIX APPENDIX NNP 40436 4667 2 . . . 40436 4668 1 The the DT 40436 4668 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4668 3 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4668 4 is be VBZ 40436 4668 5 declared declare VBN 40436 4668 6 to to TO 40436 4668 7 be be VB 40436 4668 8 spurious spurious JJ 40436 4668 9 , , , 40436 4668 10 not not RB 40436 4668 11 only only RB 40436 4668 12 by by IN 40436 4668 13 Ast Ast NNP 40436 4668 14 , , , 40436 4668 15 but but CC 40436 4668 16 also also RB 40436 4668 17 by by IN 40436 4668 18 Socher Socher NNP 40436 4668 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4668 20 Ast Ast NNP 40436 4668 21 , , , 40436 4668 22 Platon Platon NNP 40436 4668 23 's 's POS 40436 4668 24 Leb Leb NNP 40436 4668 25 . . . 40436 4669 1 pp pp NNP 40436 4669 2 . . . 40436 4670 1 419 419 CD 40436 4670 2 - - SYM 40436 4670 3 428 428 CD 40436 4670 4 ; ; : 40436 4670 5 Socher Socher NNP 40436 4670 6 , , , 40436 4670 7 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 4670 8 Platon Platon NNP 40436 4670 9 , , , 40436 4670 10 pp pp NNP 40436 4670 11 . . . 40436 4671 1 130 130 CD 40436 4671 2 - - SYM 40436 4671 3 137 137 CD 40436 4671 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4671 5 . . . 40436 4672 1 Steinhart steinhart NN 40436 4672 2 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 4672 3 the the DT 40436 4672 4 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 4672 5 of of IN 40436 4672 6 the the DT 40436 4672 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4672 8 against against IN 40436 4672 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4672 10 ; ; : 40436 4672 11 declaring declare VBG 40436 4672 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4672 13 as as IN 40436 4672 14 in in IN 40436 4672 15 regard regard NN 40436 4672 16 to to IN 40436 4672 17 the the DT 40436 4672 18 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4672 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4672 20 that that IN 40436 4672 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4672 22 can can MD 40436 4672 23 hardly hardly RB 40436 4672 24 conceive conceive VB 40436 4672 25 how how WRB 40436 4672 26 critics critic NNS 40436 4672 27 can can MD 40436 4672 28 mistake mistake VB 40436 4672 29 the the DT 40436 4672 30 truly truly RB 40436 4672 31 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 4672 32 character character NN 40436 4672 33 of of IN 40436 4672 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4672 35 , , , 40436 4672 36 though though IN 40436 4672 37 here here RB 40436 4672 38 too too RB 40436 4672 39 , , , 40436 4672 40 as as IN 40436 4672 41 in in IN 40436 4672 42 the the DT 40436 4672 43 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4672 44 , , , 40436 4672 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4672 46 detects detect VBZ 40436 4672 47 " " `` 40436 4672 48 adolescentiæ adolescentiæ NN 40436 4672 49 vestigia vestigia NN 40436 4672 50 " " '' 40436 4672 51 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4672 52 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4672 53 , , , 40436 4672 54 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 4672 55 . . . 40436 4673 1 zum zum NNP 40436 4673 2 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4673 3 , , , 40436 4673 4 pp pp NNP 40436 4673 5 . . . 40436 4674 1 290 290 CD 40436 4674 2 - - SYM 40436 4674 3 293 293 CD 40436 4674 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4674 5 . . . 40436 4675 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 4675 2 considers consider VBZ 40436 4675 3 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4675 4 as as RB 40436 4675 5 well well RB 40436 4675 6 as as IN 40436 4675 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 4675 8 to to TO 40436 4675 9 be be VB 40436 4675 10 appendixes appendix NNS 40436 4675 11 to to IN 40436 4675 12 the the DT 40436 4675 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 4675 14 , , , 40436 4675 15 which which WDT 40436 4675 16 opinion opinion NN 40436 4675 17 both both DT 40436 4675 18 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 4675 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4675 20 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 4675 21 . . . 40436 4676 1 ad ad NN 40436 4676 2 Charm Charm NNP 40436 4676 3 , , , 40436 4676 4 p. p. NN 40436 4676 5 121 121 CD 40436 4676 6 ; ; : 40436 4676 7 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 4676 8 . . . 40436 4677 1 ad ad NN 40436 4677 2 Lachet Lachet NNP 40436 4677 3 . . . 40436 4678 1 p. p. NN 40436 4678 2 30 30 CD 40436 4678 3 , , , 40436 4678 4 2nd 2nd NNP 40436 4678 5 ed ed NNP 40436 4678 6 . . . 40436 4678 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4679 1 and and CC 40436 4679 2 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4679 3 controvert controvert NN 40436 4679 4 . . . 40436 4680 1 The the DT 40436 4680 2 views view NNS 40436 4680 3 of of IN 40436 4680 4 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 4680 5 respecting respect VBG 40436 4680 6 the the DT 40436 4680 7 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4680 8 are be VBP 40436 4680 9 declared declare VBN 40436 4680 10 by by IN 40436 4680 11 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4680 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4680 13 p. p. NN 40436 4680 14 290 290 CD 40436 4680 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4680 16 to to TO 40436 4680 17 be be VB 40436 4680 18 " " `` 40436 4680 19 recht recht NNP 40436 4680 20 äusserlich äusserlich NNP 40436 4680 21 und und NNP 40436 4680 22 oberflächlich oberflächlich NNP 40436 4680 23 " " '' 40436 4680 24 . . . 40436 4681 1 To to IN 40436 4681 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4681 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4681 4 appear appear VBP 40436 4681 5 much much RB 40436 4681 6 nearer nearer IN 40436 4681 7 the the DT 40436 4681 8 truth truth NN 40436 4681 9 than than IN 40436 4681 10 the the DT 40436 4681 11 profound profound JJ 40436 4681 12 and and CC 40436 4681 13 recondite recondite JJ 40436 4681 14 meanings meaning NNS 40436 4681 15 , , , 40436 4681 16 the the DT 40436 4681 17 far far RB 40436 4681 18 - - HYPH 40436 4681 19 sighted sighted JJ 40436 4681 20 indirect indirect JJ 40436 4681 21 hints hint NNS 40436 4681 22 , , , 40436 4681 23 which which WDT 40436 4681 24 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4681 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4681 26 perceives perceive VBZ 40436 4681 27 or or CC 40436 4681 28 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 4681 29 in in IN 40436 4681 30 the the DT 40436 4681 31 words word NNS 40436 4681 32 of of IN 40436 4681 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4681 34 . . . 40436 4682 1 These these DT 40436 4682 2 critics critic NNS 40436 4682 3 consider consider VBP 40436 4682 4 the the DT 40436 4682 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4682 6 as as IN 40436 4682 7 composed compose VBN 40436 4682 8 during during IN 40436 4682 9 the the DT 40436 4682 10 government government NN 40436 4682 11 of of IN 40436 4682 12 the the DT 40436 4682 13 Thirty Thirty NNP 40436 4682 14 at at IN 40436 4682 15 Athens Athens NNP 40436 4682 16 , , , 40436 4682 17 in in IN 40436 4682 18 which which WDT 40436 4682 19 opinion opinion NN 40436 4682 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4682 21 do do VBP 40436 4682 22 not not RB 40436 4682 23 concur concur VB 40436 4682 24 . . . 40436 4683 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 4683 2 XX XX NNP 40436 4683 3 . . . 40436 4684 1 LYSIS LYSIS NNP 40436 4684 2 . . . 40436 4685 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4685 2 Side side NN 40436 4685 3 - - HYPH 40436 4685 4 note note NN 40436 4685 5 : : : 40436 4685 6 Analogy analogy NN 40436 4685 7 between between IN 40436 4685 8 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4685 9 and and CC 40436 4685 10 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4685 11 . . . 40436 4686 1 Richness richness NN 40436 4686 2 of of IN 40436 4686 3 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4686 4 incident incident NN 40436 4686 5 in in IN 40436 4686 6 both both DT 40436 4686 7 . . . 40436 4687 1 Youthful youthful JJ 40436 4687 2 beauty beauty NN 40436 4687 3 . . . 40436 4687 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4688 1 The the DT 40436 4688 2 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4688 3 , , , 40436 4688 4 as as RB 40436 4688 5 well well RB 40436 4688 6 as as IN 40436 4688 7 the the DT 40436 4688 8 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4688 9 , , , 40436 4688 10 is be VBZ 40436 4688 11 a a DT 40436 4688 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4688 13 recounted recount VBN 40436 4688 14 by by IN 40436 4688 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4688 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4688 17 , , , 40436 4688 18 describing describe VBG 40436 4688 19 both both DT 40436 4688 20 incidents incident NNS 40436 4688 21 and and CC 40436 4688 22 a a DT 40436 4688 23 conversation conversation NN 40436 4688 24 in in IN 40436 4688 25 a a DT 40436 4688 26 crowded crowded JJ 40436 4688 27 Palæstra Palæstra NNP 40436 4688 28 ; ; : 40436 4688 29 wherein wherein WRB 40436 4688 30 not not RB 40436 4688 31 merely merely RB 40436 4688 32 bodily bodily JJ 40436 4688 33 exercises exercise NNS 40436 4688 34 were be VBD 40436 4688 35 habitually habitually RB 40436 4688 36 practised practise VBN 40436 4688 37 , , , 40436 4688 38 but but CC 40436 4688 39 debate debate NN 40436 4688 40 was be VBD 40436 4688 41 carried carry VBN 40436 4688 42 on on IN 40436 4688 43 and and CC 40436 4688 44 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 4688 45 instruction instruction NN 40436 4688 46 given give VBN 40436 4688 47 by by IN 40436 4688 48 a a DT 40436 4688 49 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 4688 50 named name VBN 40436 4688 51 Mikkus Mikkus NNP 40436 4688 52 , , , 40436 4688 53 companion companion NN 40436 4688 54 and and CC 40436 4688 55 admirer admirer NN 40436 4688 56 of of IN 40436 4688 57 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4688 58 . . . 40436 4689 1 There there EX 40436 4689 2 is be VBZ 40436 4689 3 a a DT 40436 4689 4 lively lively RB 40436 4689 5 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 4689 6 commencement commencement NN 40436 4689 7 , , , 40436 4689 8 introducing introduce VBG 40436 4689 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4689 10 into into IN 40436 4689 11 the the DT 40436 4689 12 Palæstra Palæstra NNP 40436 4689 13 , , , 40436 4689 14 and and CC 40436 4689 15 detailing detail VBG 40436 4689 16 the the DT 40436 4689 17 preparation preparation NN 40436 4689 18 and and CC 40436 4689 19 scenic scenic JJ 40436 4689 20 arrangements arrangement NNS 40436 4689 21 , , , 40436 4689 22 before before IN 40436 4689 23 the the DT 40436 4689 24 real real JJ 40436 4689 25 discussion discussion NN 40436 4689 26 opens open VBZ 40436 4689 27 . . . 40436 4690 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4690 2 is be VBZ 40436 4690 3 the the DT 40436 4690 4 day day NN 40436 4690 5 of of IN 40436 4690 6 the the DT 40436 4690 7 Hermæa Hermæa NNP 40436 4690 8 , , , 40436 4690 9 or or CC 40436 4690 10 festival festival NN 40436 4690 11 of of IN 40436 4690 12 Hermes Hermes NNP 40436 4690 13 , , , 40436 4690 14 celebrated celebrate VBN 40436 4690 15 by by IN 40436 4690 16 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 4690 17 and and CC 40436 4690 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4690 19 accompanying accompanying JJ 40436 4690 20 banquets banquet NNS 40436 4690 21 among among IN 40436 4690 22 the the DT 40436 4690 23 frequenters frequenter NNS 40436 4690 24 of of IN 40436 4690 25 gymnasia gymnasia NNP 40436 4690 26 . . . 40436 4691 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4691 2 Side side NN 40436 4691 3 - - HYPH 40436 4691 4 note note NN 40436 4691 5 : : : 40436 4691 6 Scenery scenery NN 40436 4691 7 and and CC 40436 4691 8 personages personage NNS 40436 4691 9 of of IN 40436 4691 10 the the DT 40436 4691 11 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4691 12 . . . 40436 4691 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4692 1 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4692 2 , , , 40436 4692 3 like like IN 40436 4692 4 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 4692 5 , , , 40436 4692 6 is be VBZ 40436 4692 7 an an DT 40436 4692 8 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 4692 9 youth youth NN 40436 4692 10 , , , 40436 4692 11 of of IN 40436 4692 12 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 4692 13 beauty beauty NN 40436 4692 14 , , , 40436 4692 15 modesty modesty NN 40436 4692 16 , , , 40436 4692 17 and and CC 40436 4692 18 promise promise VBP 40436 4692 19 . . . 40436 4693 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4693 2 father father NN 40436 4693 3 Demokrates Demokrates NNP 40436 4693 4 represents represent VBZ 40436 4693 5 an an DT 40436 4693 6 ancient ancient JJ 40436 4693 7 family family NN 40436 4693 8 of of IN 40436 4693 9 the the DT 40436 4693 10 Æxonian Æxonian NNP 40436 4693 11 Deme Deme NNP 40436 4693 12 in in IN 40436 4693 13 Attica Attica NNP 40436 4693 14 , , , 40436 4693 15 and and CC 40436 4693 16 is be VBZ 40436 4693 17 said say VBN 40436 4693 18 to to TO 40436 4693 19 be be VB 40436 4693 20 descended descend VBN 40436 4693 21 from from IN 40436 4693 22 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 4693 23 and and CC 40436 4693 24 the the DT 40436 4693 25 daughter daughter NN 40436 4693 26 of of IN 40436 4693 27 the the DT 40436 4693 28 Archêgetês Archêgetês NNP 40436 4693 29 or or CC 40436 4693 30 Heroic Heroic NNP 40436 4693 31 Founder Founder NNP 40436 4693 32 of of IN 40436 4693 33 that that DT 40436 4693 34 Deme Deme NNP 40436 4693 35 . . . 40436 4694 1 The the DT 40436 4694 2 family family NN 40436 4694 3 moreover moreover RB 40436 4694 4 are be VBP 40436 4694 5 so so RB 40436 4694 6 wealthy wealthy JJ 40436 4694 7 , , , 40436 4694 8 that that IN 40436 4694 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4694 10 have have VBP 40436 4694 11 gained gain VBN 40436 4694 12 many many JJ 40436 4694 13 victories victory NNS 40436 4694 14 at at IN 40436 4694 15 the the DT 40436 4694 16 Pythian pythian JJ 40436 4694 17 , , , 40436 4694 18 Isthmian isthmian JJ 40436 4694 19 , , , 40436 4694 20 and and CC 40436 4694 21 Nemean nemean JJ 40436 4694 22 games game NNS 40436 4694 23 , , , 40436 4694 24 both both CC 40436 4694 25 with with IN 40436 4694 26 horses horse NNS 40436 4694 27 and and CC 40436 4694 28 with with IN 40436 4694 29 chariots chariot NNS 40436 4694 30 and and CC 40436 4694 31 four four CD 40436 4694 32 . . . 40436 4695 1 Menexenus menexenus NN 40436 4695 2 , , , 40436 4695 3 companion companion NN 40436 4695 4 of of IN 40436 4695 5 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4695 6 , , , 40436 4695 7 is be VBZ 40436 4695 8 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 4695 9 older old JJR 40436 4695 10 , , , 40436 4695 11 and and CC 40436 4695 12 is be VBZ 40436 4695 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4695 14 affectionate affectionate JJ 40436 4695 15 friend friend NN 40436 4695 16 . . . 40436 4696 1 The the DT 40436 4696 2 persons person NNS 40436 4696 3 who who WP 40436 4696 4 invite invite VBP 40436 4696 5 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4696 6 into into IN 40436 4696 7 the the DT 40436 4696 8 palæstra palæstra NN 40436 4696 9 , , , 40436 4696 10 and and CC 40436 4696 11 give give VB 40436 4696 12 occasion occasion NN 40436 4696 13 to to IN 40436 4696 14 the the DT 40436 4696 15 debate debate NN 40436 4696 16 , , , 40436 4696 17 are be VBP 40436 4696 18 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 4696 19 and and CC 40436 4696 20 Hippothalês Hippothalês NNPS 40436 4696 21 : : : 40436 4696 22 both both DT 40436 4696 23 of of IN 40436 4696 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4696 25 adults adult NNS 40436 4696 26 , , , 40436 4696 27 yet yet RB 40436 4696 28 in in IN 40436 4696 29 the the DT 40436 4696 30 vigour vigour NN 40436 4696 31 of of IN 40436 4696 32 age age NN 40436 4696 33 . . . 40436 4697 1 Hippothalês Hippothalês NNP 40436 4697 2 is be VBZ 40436 4697 3 the the DT 40436 4697 4 Erastes Erastes NNPS 40436 4697 5 of of IN 40436 4697 6 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4697 7 , , , 40436 4697 8 passionately passionately RB 40436 4697 9 attached attach VBN 40436 4697 10 to to IN 40436 4697 11 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4697 12 . . . 40436 4698 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4698 2 is be VBZ 40436 4698 3 ridiculed ridicule VBN 40436 4698 4 by by IN 40436 4698 5 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 4698 6 for for IN 40436 4698 7 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 4698 8 talking talk VBG 40436 4698 9 about about IN 40436 4698 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4698 11 , , , 40436 4698 12 as as RB 40436 4698 13 well well RB 40436 4698 14 as as IN 40436 4698 15 for for IN 40436 4698 16 addressing address VBG 40436 4698 17 to to IN 40436 4698 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4698 19 compositions composition VBZ 40436 4698 20 both both DT 40436 4698 21 in in IN 40436 4698 22 prose prose NN 40436 4698 23 and and CC 40436 4698 24 verse verse NN 40436 4698 25 , , , 40436 4698 26 full full JJ 40436 4698 27 of of IN 40436 4698 28 praise praise NN 40436 4698 29 and and CC 40436 4698 30 flattery flattery NN 40436 4698 31 ; ; : 40436 4698 32 extolling extoll VBG 40436 4698 33 not not RB 40436 4698 34 only only RB 40436 4698 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4698 36 personal personal JJ 40436 4698 37 beauty beauty NN 40436 4698 38 , , , 40436 4698 39 but but CC 40436 4698 40 also also RB 40436 4698 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4698 42 splendid splendid JJ 40436 4698 43 ancestry ancestry NN 40436 4698 44 and and CC 40436 4698 45 position position NN 40436 4698 46 . . . 40436 4699 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4699 2 1 1 CD 40436 4699 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4699 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4699 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4699 6 1 1 CD 40436 4699 7 : : : 40436 4699 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4699 9 , , , 40436 4699 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4699 11 , , , 40436 4699 12 203 203 CD 40436 4699 13 - - SYM 40436 4699 14 205 205 CD 40436 4699 15 . . . 40436 4699 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4700 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4700 2 Side side NN 40436 4700 3 - - HYPH 40436 4700 4 note note NN 40436 4700 5 : : : 40436 4700 6 Origin origin NN 40436 4700 7 of of IN 40436 4700 8 the the DT 40436 4700 9 conversation conversation NN 40436 4700 10 . . . 40436 4701 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4701 2 promises promise NNS 40436 4701 3 to to TO 40436 4701 4 give give VB 40436 4701 5 an an DT 40436 4701 6 example example NN 40436 4701 7 of of IN 40436 4701 8 the the DT 40436 4701 9 proper proper JJ 40436 4701 10 way way NN 40436 4701 11 of of IN 40436 4701 12 talking talk VBG 40436 4701 13 to to IN 40436 4701 14 a a DT 40436 4701 15 youth youth NN 40436 4701 16 , , , 40436 4701 17 for for IN 40436 4701 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4701 19 benefit benefit NN 40436 4701 20 . . . 40436 4701 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4702 1 In in IN 40436 4702 2 reference reference NN 40436 4702 3 to to IN 40436 4702 4 these these DT 40436 4702 5 addresses address NNS 40436 4702 6 , , , 40436 4702 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4702 8 remonstrates remonstrate VBZ 40436 4702 9 with with IN 40436 4702 10 Hippothalês hippothalê NNS 40436 4702 11 on on IN 40436 4702 12 the the DT 40436 4702 13 imprudence imprudence NN 40436 4702 14 and and CC 40436 4702 15 mischief mischief NN 40436 4702 16 of of IN 40436 4702 17 addressing address VBG 40436 4702 18 to to IN 40436 4702 19 a a DT 40436 4702 20 youth youth NN 40436 4702 21 flatteries flattery NNS 40436 4702 22 calculated calculate VBN 40436 4702 23 to to TO 40436 4702 24 turn turn VB 40436 4702 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4702 26 head head NN 40436 4702 27 . . . 40436 4703 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4703 2 is be VBZ 40436 4703 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4703 4 then then RB 40436 4703 5 invited invite VBN 40436 4703 6 by by IN 40436 4703 7 Hippothalês hippothalê NNS 40436 4703 8 to to TO 40436 4703 9 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 4703 10 a a DT 40436 4703 11 specimen speciman NNS 40436 4703 12 of of IN 40436 4703 13 the the DT 40436 4703 14 proper proper JJ 40436 4703 15 mode mode NN 40436 4703 16 of of IN 40436 4703 17 talking talk VBG 40436 4703 18 to to IN 40436 4703 19 youth youth NN 40436 4703 20 ; ; , 40436 4703 21 such such JJ 40436 4703 22 as as IN 40436 4703 23 shall shall MD 40436 4703 24 be be VB 40436 4703 25 at at RB 40436 4703 26 once once RB 40436 4703 27 acceptable acceptable JJ 40436 4703 28 to to IN 40436 4703 29 the the DT 40436 4703 30 person person NN 40436 4703 31 addressed address VBD 40436 4703 32 , , , 40436 4703 33 and and CC 40436 4703 34 unobjectionable unobjectionable JJ 40436 4703 35 . . . 40436 4704 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4704 2 agrees agree VBZ 40436 4704 3 to to TO 40436 4704 4 do do VB 40436 4704 5 so so RB 40436 4704 6 , , , 40436 4704 7 if if IN 40436 4704 8 an an DT 40436 4704 9 opportunity opportunity NN 40436 4704 10 be be VB 40436 4704 11 afforded afford VBN 40436 4704 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4704 13 of of IN 40436 4704 14 conversing converse VBG 40436 4704 15 with with IN 40436 4704 16 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4704 17 . . . 40436 4705 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4705 2 2 2 LS 40436 4705 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4705 4 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 4705 5 after after IN 40436 4705 6 some some DT 40436 4705 7 well well RB 40436 4705 8 - - HYPH 40436 4705 9 imagined imagine VBN 40436 4705 10 incidents incident NNS 40436 4705 11 , , , 40436 4705 12 interesting interesting JJ 40436 4705 13 as as IN 40436 4705 14 marks mark NNS 40436 4705 15 of of IN 40436 4705 16 Greek greek JJ 40436 4705 17 manners manner NNS 40436 4705 18 -- -- : 40436 4705 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4705 20 and and CC 40436 4705 21 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 4705 22 with with IN 40436 4705 23 others other NNS 40436 4705 24 seat seat VBP 40436 4705 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 4705 26 in in IN 40436 4705 27 the the DT 40436 4705 28 palæstra palæstra NN 40436 4705 29 , , , 40436 4705 30 amidst amidst IN 40436 4705 31 a a DT 40436 4705 32 crowd crowd NN 40436 4705 33 of of IN 40436 4705 34 listeners listener NNS 40436 4705 35 . . . 40436 4706 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4706 2 3 3 LS 40436 4706 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4706 4 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4706 5 , , , 40436 4706 6 too too RB 40436 4706 7 modest modest JJ 40436 4706 8 at at IN 40436 4706 9 first first RB 40436 4706 10 to to TO 40436 4706 11 approach approach NN 40436 4706 12 , , , 40436 4706 13 is be VBZ 40436 4706 14 emboldened embolden VBN 40436 4706 15 to to TO 40436 4706 16 sit sit VB 40436 4706 17 down down RP 40436 4706 18 by by IN 40436 4706 19 seeing see VBG 40436 4706 20 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4706 21 seated seat VBN 40436 4706 22 by by IN 40436 4706 23 the the DT 40436 4706 24 side side NN 40436 4706 25 of of IN 40436 4706 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4706 27 : : : 40436 4706 28 while while IN 40436 4706 29 Hippothalês Hippothalês NNP 40436 4706 30 , , , 40436 4706 31 not not RB 40436 4706 32 daring dare VBG 40436 4706 33 to to TO 40436 4706 34 put put VB 40436 4706 35 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4706 36 where where WRB 40436 4706 37 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4706 38 can can MD 40436 4706 39 see see VB 40436 4706 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4706 41 , , , 40436 4706 42 listens listen VBZ 40436 4706 43 , , , 40436 4706 44 but but CC 40436 4706 45 conceals conceal NNS 40436 4706 46 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4706 47 behind behind IN 40436 4706 48 some some DT 40436 4706 49 of of IN 40436 4706 50 the the DT 40436 4706 51 crowd crowd NN 40436 4706 52 . . . 40436 4707 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4707 2 begins begin VBZ 40436 4707 3 the the DT 40436 4707 4 conversation conversation NN 40436 4707 5 with with IN 40436 4707 6 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4707 7 and and CC 40436 4707 8 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4707 9 jointly jointly RB 40436 4707 10 : : : 40436 4707 11 but but CC 40436 4707 12 presently presently RB 40436 4707 13 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4707 14 is be VBZ 40436 4707 15 called call VBN 40436 4707 16 away away RB 40436 4707 17 for for IN 40436 4707 18 a a DT 40436 4707 19 moment moment NN 40436 4707 20 , , , 40436 4707 21 and and CC 40436 4707 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4707 23 talks talk VBZ 40436 4707 24 with with IN 40436 4707 25 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4707 26 singly singly RB 40436 4707 27 . . . 40436 4708 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4708 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4708 3 2 2 CD 40436 4708 4 : : : 40436 4708 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4708 6 , , , 40436 4708 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4708 8 , , , 40436 4708 9 206 206 CD 40436 4708 10 . . . 40436 4708 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4709 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4709 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4709 3 3 3 CD 40436 4709 4 : : : 40436 4709 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4709 6 , , , 40436 4709 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4709 8 , , , 40436 4709 9 206 206 CD 40436 4709 10 - - SYM 40436 4709 11 207 207 CD 40436 4709 12 . . . 40436 4709 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4710 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4710 2 Side side NN 40436 4710 3 - - HYPH 40436 4710 4 note note NN 40436 4710 5 : : : 40436 4710 6 Conversation conversation NN 40436 4710 7 of of IN 40436 4710 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4710 9 with with IN 40436 4710 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4710 11 . . . 40436 4710 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4711 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4711 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 4711 3 -- -- : 40436 4711 4 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4711 5 -- -- : 40436 4711 6 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4711 7 father father NN 40436 4711 8 and and CC 40436 4711 9 mother mother NN 40436 4711 10 love love VBP 40436 4711 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4711 12 extremely extremely RB 40436 4711 13 . . . 40436 4712 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4712 2 Lysis._--Assuredly Lysis._--Assuredly NNP 40436 4712 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4712 4 do do VBP 40436 4712 5 . . . 40436 4713 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4713 2 Sokr._--They Sokr._--They NNP 40436 4713 3 would would MD 40436 4713 4 wish wish VB 40436 4713 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4713 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 4713 7 to to TO 40436 4713 8 be be VB 40436 4713 9 as as RB 40436 4713 10 happy happy JJ 40436 4713 11 as as IN 40436 4713 12 possible possible JJ 40436 4713 13 . . . 40436 4714 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4714 2 Lysis._--Undoubtedly lysis._--undoubtedly RB 40436 4714 3 . . . 40436 4715 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4715 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 4715 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4715 4 think think VBP 40436 4715 5 any any DT 40436 4715 6 man man NN 40436 4715 7 happy happy JJ 40436 4715 8 , , , 40436 4715 9 who who WP 40436 4715 10 is be VBZ 40436 4715 11 a a DT 40436 4715 12 slave slave NN 40436 4715 13 , , , 40436 4715 14 and and CC 40436 4715 15 who who WP 40436 4715 16 is be VBZ 40436 4715 17 not not RB 40436 4715 18 allowed allow VBN 40436 4715 19 to to TO 40436 4715 20 do do VB 40436 4715 21 any any DT 40436 4715 22 thing thing NN 40436 4715 23 that that WDT 40436 4715 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4715 25 desires desire VBZ 40436 4715 26 ? ? . 40436 4716 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4716 2 Lysis._--I Lysis._--I NNP 40436 4716 3 do do VBP 40436 4716 4 not not RB 40436 4716 5 think think VB 40436 4716 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4716 7 happy happy JJ 40436 4716 8 at at RB 40436 4716 9 all all RB 40436 4716 10 . . . 40436 4717 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4717 2 Sokr._--Since Sokr._--Since NNP 40436 4717 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 4717 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4717 5 father father NN 40436 4717 6 and and CC 40436 4717 7 mother mother NN 40436 4717 8 are be VBP 40436 4717 9 so so RB 40436 4717 10 anxious anxious JJ 40436 4717 11 that that IN 40436 4717 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4717 13 should should MD 40436 4717 14 be be VB 40436 4717 15 happy happy JJ 40436 4717 16 , , , 40436 4717 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4717 18 of of IN 40436 4717 19 course course RB 40436 4717 20 allow allow VBP 40436 4717 21 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4717 22 to to TO 40436 4717 23 do do VB 40436 4717 24 the the DT 40436 4717 25 things thing NNS 40436 4717 26 which which WDT 40436 4717 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4717 28 desire desire VBP 40436 4717 29 , , , 40436 4717 30 and and CC 40436 4717 31 never never RB 40436 4717 32 reprove reprove VB 40436 4717 33 nor nor CC 40436 4717 34 forbid forbid VB 40436 4717 35 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4717 36 . . . 40436 4718 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4718 2 Lysis._--Not Lysis._--Not NNP 40436 4718 3 at at RB 40436 4718 4 all all RB 40436 4718 5 , , , 40436 4718 6 by by IN 40436 4718 7 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 4718 8 , , , 40436 4718 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4718 10 : : : 40436 4718 11 there there EX 40436 4718 12 are be VBP 40436 4718 13 a a DT 40436 4718 14 great great JJ 40436 4718 15 many many JJ 40436 4718 16 things thing NNS 40436 4718 17 that that WDT 40436 4718 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4718 19 forbid forbid VBP 40436 4718 20 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4718 21 . . . 40436 4719 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4719 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 4719 3 say say VBP 40436 4719 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4719 5 ! ! . 40436 4720 1 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4720 2 wish wish VBP 40436 4720 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4720 4 to to TO 40436 4720 5 be be VB 40436 4720 6 happy happy JJ 40436 4720 7 -- -- : 40436 4720 8 and and CC 40436 4720 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4720 10 hinder hinder VBP 40436 4720 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4720 12 from from IN 40436 4720 13 doing do VBG 40436 4720 14 what what WP 40436 4720 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4720 16 wish wish VBP 40436 4720 17 ! ! . 40436 4721 1 Tell tell VB 40436 4721 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4721 3 , , , 40436 4721 4 for for IN 40436 4721 5 example example NN 40436 4721 6 , , , 40436 4721 7 when when WRB 40436 4721 8 one one CD 40436 4721 9 of of IN 40436 4721 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4721 11 father father NN 40436 4721 12 's 's POS 40436 4721 13 chariots chariot NNS 40436 4721 14 is be VBZ 40436 4721 15 going go VBG 40436 4721 16 to to TO 40436 4721 17 run run VB 40436 4721 18 a a DT 40436 4721 19 race race NN 40436 4721 20 , , , 40436 4721 21 if if IN 40436 4721 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4721 23 wished wish VBD 40436 4721 24 to to TO 40436 4721 25 mount mount VB 40436 4721 26 and and CC 40436 4721 27 take take VB 40436 4721 28 the the DT 40436 4721 29 reins rein NNS 40436 4721 30 , , , 40436 4721 31 would would MD 40436 4721 32 not not RB 40436 4721 33 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4721 34 allow allow VB 40436 4721 35 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4721 36 to to TO 40436 4721 37 do do VB 40436 4721 38 so so RB 40436 4721 39 ? ? . 40436 4722 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4722 2 Lysis._--No lysis._--no NN 40436 4722 3 -- -- : 40436 4722 4 certainly certainly RB 40436 4722 5 : : : 40436 4722 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4722 7 would would MD 40436 4722 8 not not RB 40436 4722 9 allow allow VB 40436 4722 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4722 11 . . . 40436 4723 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4723 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 4723 3 whom whom WP 40436 4723 4 do do VBP 40436 4723 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4723 6 allow allow VB 40436 4723 7 , , , 40436 4723 8 then then RB 40436 4723 9 ? ? . 40436 4724 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4724 2 Lysis._--My Lysis._--My NNP 40436 4724 3 father father NNP 40436 4724 4 employs employ VBZ 40436 4724 5 a a DT 40436 4724 6 paid pay VBN 40436 4724 7 charioteer charioteer NN 40436 4724 8 . . . 40436 4725 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4725 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 4725 3 ! ! . 40436 4726 1 do do VBP 40436 4726 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4726 3 permit permit VB 40436 4726 4 a a DT 40436 4726 5 hireling hireling NN 40436 4726 6 , , , 40436 4726 7 in in IN 40436 4726 8 preference preference NN 40436 4726 9 to to IN 40436 4726 10 _ _ NNP 40436 4726 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4726 12 _ _ NNP 40436 4726 13 , , , 40436 4726 14 to to TO 40436 4726 15 do do VB 40436 4726 16 what what WP 40436 4726 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4726 18 wishes wish VBZ 40436 4726 19 with with IN 40436 4726 20 the the DT 40436 4726 21 horses horse NNS 40436 4726 22 ? ? . 40436 4727 1 and and CC 40436 4727 2 do do VBP 40436 4727 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4727 4 give give VB 40436 4727 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4727 6 pay pay VB 40436 4727 7 besides besides RB 40436 4727 8 for for IN 40436 4727 9 doing do VBG 40436 4727 10 so so RB 40436 4727 11 ? ? . 40436 4728 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4728 2 Lysis._--Why Lysis._--Why NNP 40436 4728 3 -- -- : 40436 4728 4 to to TO 40436 4728 5 be be VB 40436 4728 6 sure sure JJ 40436 4728 7 . . . 40436 4729 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4729 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 4729 3 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 4729 4 , , , 40436 4729 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4729 6 imagine imagine VBP 40436 4729 7 , , , 40436 4729 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4729 9 trust trust VBP 40436 4729 10 the the DT 40436 4729 11 team team NN 40436 4729 12 of of IN 40436 4729 13 mules mule NNS 40436 4729 14 to to IN 40436 4729 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4729 16 direction direction NN 40436 4729 17 ; ; : 40436 4729 18 and and CC 40436 4729 19 if if IN 40436 4729 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4729 21 chose choose VBD 40436 4729 22 to to TO 40436 4729 23 take take VB 40436 4729 24 the the DT 40436 4729 25 whip whip NN 40436 4729 26 and and CC 40436 4729 27 flog flog NN 40436 4729 28 , , , 40436 4729 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4729 30 would would MD 40436 4729 31 allow allow VB 40436 4729 32 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4729 33 ? ? . 40436 4730 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4730 2 Lysis._--Allow lysis._--allow VB 40436 4730 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4730 4 ? ? . 40436 4731 1 not not RB 40436 4731 2 at at RB 40436 4731 3 all all RB 40436 4731 4 . . . 40436 4732 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4732 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 4732 3 ! ! . 40436 4733 1 is be VBZ 40436 4733 2 no no DT 40436 4733 3 one one NN 40436 4733 4 allowed allow VBN 40436 4733 5 to to TO 40436 4733 6 flog flog VB 40436 4733 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4733 8 ? ? . 40436 4734 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4734 2 Lysis._--Yes Lysis._--Yes NNP 40436 4734 3 -- -- : 40436 4734 4 certainly certainly RB 40436 4734 5 -- -- : 40436 4734 6 the the DT 40436 4734 7 mule mule JJ 40436 4734 8 - - HYPH 40436 4734 9 groom groom NN 40436 4734 10 . . . 40436 4735 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4735 2 Sokr._--Is Sokr._--Is NNP 40436 4735 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4735 4 a a DT 40436 4735 5 slave slave NN 40436 4735 6 or or CC 40436 4735 7 free free JJ 40436 4735 8 ? ? . 40436 4736 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4736 2 Lysis._--A Lysis._--A NNP 40436 4736 3 slave slave NN 40436 4736 4 . . . 40436 4737 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4737 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 4737 3 , , , 40436 4737 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 5 seems seem VBZ 40436 4737 6 , , , 40436 4737 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 8 esteem esteem VBP 40436 4737 9 a a DT 40436 4737 10 slave slave NN 40436 4737 11 higher high JJR 40436 4737 12 than than IN 40436 4737 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4737 15 son son NN 40436 4737 16 ; ; : 40436 4737 17 trusting trust VBG 40436 4737 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4737 19 property property NN 40436 4737 20 to to IN 40436 4737 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 22 rather rather RB 40436 4737 23 than than IN 40436 4737 24 to to IN 40436 4737 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 26 , , , 40436 4737 27 letting let VBG 40436 4737 28 _ _ XX 40436 4737 29 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 30 _ _ NNP 40436 4737 31 do do VB 40436 4737 32 what what WP 40436 4737 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 34 pleases please VBZ 40436 4737 35 , , , 40436 4737 36 while while IN 40436 4737 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 38 forbid forbid VBP 40436 4737 39 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4737 40 . . . 40436 4738 1 But but CC 40436 4738 2 tell tell VB 40436 4738 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4738 4 farther farther RB 40436 4738 5 : : : 40436 4738 6 do do VBP 40436 4738 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4738 8 allow allow VB 40436 4738 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4738 10 to to TO 40436 4738 11 direct direct VB 40436 4738 12 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 4738 13 -- -- : 40436 4738 14 or or CC 40436 4738 15 do do VBP 40436 4738 16 not not RB 40436 4738 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4738 18 even even RB 40436 4738 19 trust trust VBP 40436 4738 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4738 21 so so RB 40436 4738 22 far far RB 40436 4738 23 as as IN 40436 4738 24 that that DT 40436 4738 25 ? ? . 40436 4739 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4739 2 Lysis._--How Lysis._--How NNP 40436 4739 3 can can MD 40436 4739 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4739 5 imagine imagine VB 40436 4739 6 that that IN 40436 4739 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4739 8 trust trust VBP 40436 4739 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4739 10 ? ? . 40436 4740 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4740 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 4740 3 does do VBZ 40436 4740 4 any any DT 40436 4740 5 one one NN 40436 4740 6 else else RB 40436 4740 7 direct direct VB 40436 4740 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4740 9 ? ? . 40436 4741 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4741 2 Lysis._--Yes Lysis._--Yes NNP 40436 4741 3 -- -- : 40436 4741 4 this this DT 40436 4741 5 tutor tutor NN 40436 4741 6 here here RB 40436 4741 7 . . . 40436 4742 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4742 2 Sokr._--Is Sokr._--Is NNP 40436 4742 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4742 4 a a DT 40436 4742 5 slave slave NN 40436 4742 6 ? ? . 40436 4743 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4743 2 Lysis._--To lysis._--to NN 40436 4743 3 be be VB 40436 4743 4 sure sure JJ 40436 4743 5 : : : 40436 4743 6 belonging belong VBG 40436 4743 7 to to IN 40436 4743 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4743 9 family family NN 40436 4743 10 . . . 40436 4744 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4744 2 Sokr._--That Sokr._--That NNP 40436 4744 3 is be VBZ 40436 4744 4 shocking shocking JJ 40436 4744 5 : : : 40436 4744 6 one one CD 40436 4744 7 of of IN 40436 4744 8 free free JJ 40436 4744 9 birth birth NN 40436 4744 10 to to TO 40436 4744 11 be be VB 40436 4744 12 under under IN 40436 4744 13 the the DT 40436 4744 14 direction direction NN 40436 4744 15 of of IN 40436 4744 16 a a DT 40436 4744 17 slave slave NN 40436 4744 18 ! ! . 40436 4745 1 But but CC 40436 4745 2 what what WP 40436 4745 3 is be VBZ 40436 4745 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4745 5 that that WDT 40436 4745 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4745 7 does do VBZ 40436 4745 8 , , , 40436 4745 9 as as IN 40436 4745 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4745 11 director director NN 40436 4745 12 ? ? . 40436 4746 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4746 2 Lysis._--He lysis._--he NN 40436 4746 3 conducts conduct VBZ 40436 4746 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4746 5 to to IN 40436 4746 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4746 7 teacher teacher NN 40436 4746 8 's 's POS 40436 4746 9 house house NN 40436 4746 10 . . . 40436 4747 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4747 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 4747 3 ! ! . 40436 4748 1 do do VBP 40436 4748 2 _ _ NNP 40436 4748 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4748 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4748 5 govern govern VBP 40436 4748 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4748 7 also also RB 40436 4748 8 , , , 40436 4748 9 these these DT 40436 4748 10 teachers teacher NNS 40436 4748 11 ? ? . 40436 4749 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4749 2 Lysis._--Undoubtedly lysis._--undoubtedly RB 40436 4749 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4749 4 do do VBP 40436 4749 5 . . . 40436 4750 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4750 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 4750 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4750 4 father father NN 40436 4750 5 certainly certainly RB 40436 4750 6 is be VBZ 40436 4750 7 bent bent JJ 40436 4750 8 on on IN 40436 4750 9 putting put VBG 40436 4750 10 over over RP 40436 4750 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4750 12 plenty plenty NN 40436 4750 13 of of IN 40436 4750 14 directors director NNS 40436 4750 15 and and CC 40436 4750 16 governors governor NNS 40436 4750 17 . . . 40436 4751 1 But but CC 40436 4751 2 surely surely RB 40436 4751 3 , , , 40436 4751 4 when when WRB 40436 4751 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 6 come come VBP 40436 4751 7 home home RB 40436 4751 8 to to IN 40436 4751 9 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4751 10 mother mother NN 40436 4751 11 , , , 40436 4751 12 she -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 13 at at IN 40436 4751 14 least least JJS 40436 4751 15 , , , 40436 4751 16 anxious anxious JJ 40436 4751 17 that that IN 40436 4751 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 19 should should MD 40436 4751 20 be be VB 40436 4751 21 happy happy JJ 40436 4751 22 as as RB 40436 4751 23 far far RB 40436 4751 24 as as IN 40436 4751 25 she -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 26 is be VBZ 40436 4751 27 concerned concern VBN 40436 4751 28 , , , 40436 4751 29 lets let VBZ 40436 4751 30 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 31 do do VB 40436 4751 32 what what WP 40436 4751 33 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 34 please please VBP 40436 4751 35 about about IN 40436 4751 36 the the DT 40436 4751 37 wool wool NN 40436 4751 38 or or CC 40436 4751 39 the the DT 40436 4751 40 web web NN 40436 4751 41 , , , 40436 4751 42 when when WRB 40436 4751 43 she -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 44 is be VBZ 40436 4751 45 weaving weave VBG 40436 4751 46 : : : 40436 4751 47 she -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 48 does do VBZ 40436 4751 49 not not RB 40436 4751 50 forbid forbid VB 40436 4751 51 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4751 52 to to TO 40436 4751 53 meddle meddle VB 40436 4751 54 with with IN 40436 4751 55 the the DT 40436 4751 56 bodkin bodkin NN 40436 4751 57 or or CC 40436 4751 58 any any DT 40436 4751 59 of of IN 40436 4751 60 the the DT 40436 4751 61 other other JJ 40436 4751 62 instruments instrument NNS 40436 4751 63 of of IN 40436 4751 64 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4751 65 work work NN 40436 4751 66 ? ? . 40436 4752 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4752 2 Lysis._--Ridiculous Lysis._--Ridiculous NNP 40436 4752 3 ! ! . 40436 4753 1 not not RB 40436 4753 2 only only RB 40436 4753 3 does do VBZ 40436 4753 4 she -PRON- PRP 40436 4753 5 forbid forbid VB 40436 4753 6 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4753 7 , , , 40436 4753 8 but but CC 40436 4753 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4753 10 should should MD 40436 4753 11 be be VB 40436 4753 12 beaten beat VBN 40436 4753 13 if if IN 40436 4753 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4753 15 did do VBD 40436 4753 16 meddle meddle VB 40436 4753 17 . . . 40436 4754 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4754 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 4754 3 is be VBZ 40436 4754 4 this this DT 40436 4754 5 , , , 40436 4754 6 by by IN 40436 4754 7 Heraklês heraklê NNS 40436 4754 8 ? ? . 40436 4755 1 Have have VBP 40436 4755 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4755 3 done do VBN 40436 4755 4 any any DT 40436 4755 5 wrong wrong NN 40436 4755 6 to to IN 40436 4755 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4755 8 father father NN 40436 4755 9 and and CC 40436 4755 10 mother mother NN 40436 4755 11 ? ? . 40436 4756 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4756 2 Lysis._--Never Lysis._--Never NNP 40436 4756 3 at at RB 40436 4756 4 all all RB 40436 4756 5 , , , 40436 4756 6 by by IN 40436 4756 7 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 4756 8 . . . 40436 4757 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4757 2 Sokr._--From Sokr._--From NNP 40436 4757 3 what what WDT 40436 4757 4 provocation provocation NN 40436 4757 5 is be VBZ 40436 4757 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4757 7 , , , 40436 4757 8 then then RB 40436 4757 9 , , , 40436 4757 10 that that IN 40436 4757 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4757 12 prevent prevent VBP 40436 4757 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4757 14 in in IN 40436 4757 15 this this DT 40436 4757 16 terrible terrible JJ 40436 4757 17 way way NN 40436 4757 18 , , , 40436 4757 19 from from IN 40436 4757 20 being be VBG 40436 4757 21 happy happy JJ 40436 4757 22 and and CC 40436 4757 23 doing do VBG 40436 4757 24 what what WP 40436 4757 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4757 26 wish wish VBP 40436 4757 27 ? ? . 40436 4758 1 keeping keep VBG 40436 4758 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4758 3 the the DT 40436 4758 4 whole whole JJ 40436 4758 5 day day NN 40436 4758 6 in in IN 40436 4758 7 servitude servitude NN 40436 4758 8 to to IN 40436 4758 9 some some DT 40436 4758 10 one one NN 40436 4758 11 , , , 40436 4758 12 and and CC 40436 4758 13 never never RB 40436 4758 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4758 15 own own JJ 40436 4758 16 master master NN 40436 4758 17 ? ? . 40436 4759 1 so so IN 40436 4759 2 that that IN 40436 4759 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4759 4 derive derive VBP 40436 4759 5 no no DT 40436 4759 6 benefit benefit NN 40436 4759 7 either either CC 40436 4759 8 from from IN 40436 4759 9 the the DT 40436 4759 10 great great JJ 40436 4759 11 wealth wealth NN 40436 4759 12 of of IN 40436 4759 13 the the DT 40436 4759 14 family family NN 40436 4759 15 , , , 40436 4759 16 which which WDT 40436 4759 17 is be VBZ 40436 4759 18 managed manage VBN 40436 4759 19 by by IN 40436 4759 20 every every DT 40436 4759 21 one one NN 40436 4759 22 else else RB 40436 4759 23 rather rather RB 40436 4759 24 than than IN 40436 4759 25 by by IN 40436 4759 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4759 27 -- -- : 40436 4759 28 or or CC 40436 4759 29 from from IN 40436 4759 30 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4759 31 own own JJ 40436 4759 32 body body NN 40436 4759 33 , , , 40436 4759 34 noble noble JJ 40436 4759 35 as as IN 40436 4759 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4759 37 is be VBZ 40436 4759 38 . . . 40436 4760 1 Even even RB 40436 4760 2 _ _ NNP 40436 4760 3 that that IN 40436 4760 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4760 5 is be VBZ 40436 4760 6 consigned consigned JJ 40436 4760 7 to to IN 40436 4760 8 the the DT 40436 4760 9 watch watch NN 40436 4760 10 and and CC 40436 4760 11 direction direction NN 40436 4760 12 of of IN 40436 4760 13 another another DT 40436 4760 14 : : : 40436 4760 15 while while IN 40436 4760 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4760 17 , , , 40436 4760 18 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4760 19 , , , 40436 4760 20 are be VBP 40436 4760 21 master master NN 40436 4760 22 of of IN 40436 4760 23 nothing nothing NN 40436 4760 24 , , , 40436 4760 25 nor nor CC 40436 4760 26 can can MD 40436 4760 27 do do VB 40436 4760 28 any any DT 40436 4760 29 one one CD 40436 4760 30 thing thing NN 40436 4760 31 of of IN 40436 4760 32 what what WP 40436 4760 33 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4760 34 desire desire VBP 40436 4760 35 . . . 40436 4761 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4761 2 Lysis._--The Lysis._--The NNP 40436 4761 3 reason reason NN 40436 4761 4 is be VBZ 40436 4761 5 , , , 40436 4761 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4761 7 , , , 40436 4761 8 that that IN 40436 4761 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4761 10 am be VBP 40436 4761 11 not not RB 40436 4761 12 yet yet RB 40436 4761 13 old old JJ 40436 4761 14 enough enough RB 40436 4761 15 . . . 40436 4762 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4762 2 Sokr._--That Sokr._--That NNP 40436 4762 3 can can MD 40436 4762 4 hardly hardly RB 40436 4762 5 be be VB 40436 4762 6 the the DT 40436 4762 7 reason reason NN 40436 4762 8 ; ; : 40436 4762 9 for for IN 40436 4762 10 to to IN 40436 4762 11 a a DT 40436 4762 12 certain certain JJ 40436 4762 13 extent extent NN 40436 4762 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4762 15 father father NN 40436 4762 16 and and CC 40436 4762 17 mother mother NN 40436 4762 18 do do VBP 40436 4762 19 trust trust VB 40436 4762 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4762 21 , , , 40436 4762 22 without without IN 40436 4762 23 waiting wait VBG 40436 4762 24 for for IN 40436 4762 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4762 26 to to TO 40436 4762 27 grow grow VB 40436 4762 28 older old JJR 40436 4762 29 . . . 40436 4763 1 If if IN 40436 4763 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4763 3 want want VBP 40436 4763 4 any any DT 40436 4763 5 thing thing NN 40436 4763 6 to to TO 40436 4763 7 be be VB 40436 4763 8 written write VBN 40436 4763 9 or or CC 40436 4763 10 read read VB 40436 4763 11 for for IN 40436 4763 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4763 13 , , , 40436 4763 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4763 15 employ employ VBP 40436 4763 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4763 17 for for IN 40436 4763 18 that that DT 40436 4763 19 purpose purpose NN 40436 4763 20 in in IN 40436 4763 21 preference preference NN 40436 4763 22 to to IN 40436 4763 23 any any DT 40436 4763 24 one one CD 40436 4763 25 in in IN 40436 4763 26 the the DT 40436 4763 27 house house NN 40436 4763 28 : : : 40436 4763 29 and and CC 40436 4763 30 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4763 31 are be VBP 40436 4763 32 then then RB 40436 4763 33 allowed allow VBN 40436 4763 34 to to TO 40436 4763 35 write write VB 40436 4763 36 or or CC 40436 4763 37 read read VB 40436 4763 38 first first RB 40436 4763 39 , , , 40436 4763 40 whichever whichever WDT 40436 4763 41 of of IN 40436 4763 42 the the DT 40436 4763 43 letters letter NNS 40436 4763 44 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4763 45 think think VBP 40436 4763 46 proper proper JJ 40436 4763 47 . . . 40436 4764 1 Again again RB 40436 4764 2 , , , 40436 4764 3 when when WRB 40436 4764 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4764 5 take take VBP 40436 4764 6 up up RP 40436 4764 7 the the DT 40436 4764 8 lyre lyre NN 40436 4764 9 , , , 40436 4764 10 neither neither CC 40436 4764 11 father father NN 40436 4764 12 nor nor CC 40436 4764 13 mother mother NN 40436 4764 14 hinder hinder VB 40436 4764 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4764 16 from from IN 40436 4764 17 tightening tighten VBG 40436 4764 18 or or CC 40436 4764 19 relaxing relax VBG 40436 4764 20 the the DT 40436 4764 21 strings string NNS 40436 4764 22 , , , 40436 4764 23 or or CC 40436 4764 24 striking strike VBG 40436 4764 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4764 26 either either CC 40436 4764 27 with with IN 40436 4764 28 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4764 29 finger finger NN 40436 4764 30 or or CC 40436 4764 31 with with IN 40436 4764 32 the the DT 40436 4764 33 plectrum plectrum NN 40436 4764 34 . . . 40436 4765 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4765 2 Lysis._--They Lysis._--They NNP 40436 4765 3 do do VBP 40436 4765 4 not not RB 40436 4765 5 . . . 40436 4766 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4766 2 Sokr._--Why Sokr._--Why NNP 40436 4766 3 is be VBZ 40436 4766 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4766 5 , , , 40436 4766 6 then then RB 40436 4766 7 , , , 40436 4766 8 that that IN 40436 4766 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4766 10 do do VBP 40436 4766 11 not not RB 40436 4766 12 hinder hinder VB 40436 4766 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4766 14 in in IN 40436 4766 15 this this DT 40436 4766 16 last last JJ 40436 4766 17 case case NN 40436 4766 18 , , , 40436 4766 19 as as IN 40436 4766 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4766 21 did do VBD 40436 4766 22 in in IN 40436 4766 23 the the DT 40436 4766 24 cases case NNS 40436 4766 25 before before IN 40436 4766 26 mentioned mention VBN 40436 4766 27 ? ? . 40436 4767 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4767 2 Lysis._--I Lysis._--I NNP 40436 4767 3 suppose suppose VB 40436 4767 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4767 5 is be VBZ 40436 4767 6 because because IN 40436 4767 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4767 8 know know VBP 40436 4767 9 this this DT 40436 4767 10 last last JJ 40436 4767 11 , , , 40436 4767 12 but but CC 40436 4767 13 did do VBD 40436 4767 14 not not RB 40436 4767 15 know know VB 40436 4767 16 the the DT 40436 4767 17 others other NNS 40436 4767 18 . . . 40436 4768 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4768 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 4768 3 , , , 40436 4768 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4768 5 good good JJ 40436 4768 6 friend friend NN 40436 4768 7 , , , 40436 4768 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4768 9 see see VBP 40436 4768 10 that that IN 40436 4768 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4768 12 is be VBZ 40436 4768 13 not not RB 40436 4768 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4768 15 increase increase NN 40436 4768 16 of of IN 40436 4768 17 years year NNS 40436 4768 18 that that WDT 40436 4768 19 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4768 20 father father NN 40436 4768 21 waits wait VBZ 40436 4768 22 for for IN 40436 4768 23 ; ; : 40436 4768 24 but but CC 40436 4768 25 on on IN 40436 4768 26 the the DT 40436 4768 27 very very JJ 40436 4768 28 day day NN 40436 4768 29 that that WRB 40436 4768 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4768 31 becomes become VBZ 40436 4768 32 convinced convinced JJ 40436 4768 33 that that IN 40436 4768 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4768 35 know know VBP 40436 4768 36 better well RBR 40436 4768 37 than than IN 40436 4768 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4768 39 , , , 40436 4768 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4768 41 will will MD 40436 4768 42 entrust entrust VB 40436 4768 43 both both DT 40436 4768 44 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4768 45 and and CC 40436 4768 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4768 47 property property NN 40436 4768 48 to to IN 40436 4768 49 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4768 50 management management NN 40436 4768 51 . . . 40436 4769 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4769 2 Lysis._--I Lysis._--I NNP 40436 4769 3 suppose suppose VB 40436 4769 4 that that IN 40436 4769 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4769 6 will will MD 40436 4769 7 . . . 40436 4770 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4770 2 Sokr._--Ay Sokr._--Ay NNS 40436 4770 3 -- -- : 40436 4770 4 and and CC 40436 4770 5 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4770 6 neighbour neighbour NN 40436 4770 7 too too RB 40436 4770 8 will will MD 40436 4770 9 judge judge VB 40436 4770 10 in in IN 40436 4770 11 the the DT 40436 4770 12 same same JJ 40436 4770 13 way way NN 40436 4770 14 as as IN 40436 4770 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4770 16 father father NN 40436 4770 17 . . . 40436 4771 1 As as RB 40436 4771 2 soon soon RB 40436 4771 3 as as IN 40436 4771 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4771 5 is be VBZ 40436 4771 6 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 4771 7 that that IN 40436 4771 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4771 9 understand understand VBP 40436 4771 10 house house NN 40436 4771 11 - - HYPH 40436 4771 12 management management NN 40436 4771 13 better well RBR 40436 4771 14 than than IN 40436 4771 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4771 16 does do VBZ 40436 4771 17 , , , 40436 4771 18 which which WDT 40436 4771 19 do do VBP 40436 4771 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4771 21 think think VB 40436 4771 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4771 23 will will MD 40436 4771 24 rather rather RB 40436 4771 25 do do VB 40436 4771 26 -- -- : 40436 4771 27 confide confide VB 40436 4771 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4771 29 house house NN 40436 4771 30 to to IN 40436 4771 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4771 32 , , , 40436 4771 33 or or CC 40436 4771 34 continue continue VB 40436 4771 35 to to TO 40436 4771 36 manage manage VB 40436 4771 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4771 38 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4771 39 ? ? . 40436 4772 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4772 2 Lysis._--I Lysis._--I NNP 40436 4772 3 think think VBP 40436 4772 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4772 5 will will MD 40436 4772 6 confide confide VB 40436 4772 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4772 8 to to IN 40436 4772 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4772 10 . . . 40436 4773 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4773 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 4773 3 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 4773 4 too too RB 40436 4773 5 : : : 40436 4773 6 do do VBP 40436 4773 7 not not RB 40436 4773 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4773 9 think think VB 40436 4773 10 that that IN 40436 4773 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4773 12 also also RB 40436 4773 13 will will MD 40436 4773 14 put put VB 40436 4773 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4773 16 affairs affair NNS 40436 4773 17 into into IN 40436 4773 18 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4773 19 management management NN 40436 4773 20 , , , 40436 4773 21 as as RB 40436 4773 22 soon soon RB 40436 4773 23 as as IN 40436 4773 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4773 25 perceive perceive VBP 40436 4773 26 that that IN 40436 4773 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4773 28 have have VBP 40436 4773 29 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4773 30 adequate adequate JJ 40436 4773 31 to to IN 40436 4773 32 the the DT 40436 4773 33 task task NN 40436 4773 34 ? ? . 40436 4774 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4774 2 Lysis._--Yes Lysis._--Yes NNP 40436 4774 3 : : : 40436 4774 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4774 5 do do VBP 40436 4774 6 . . . 40436 4775 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4775 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 4775 3 do do VBP 40436 4775 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4775 5 say say VB 40436 4775 6 about about IN 40436 4775 7 the the DT 40436 4775 8 Great Great NNP 40436 4775 9 King King NNP 40436 4775 10 also also RB 40436 4775 11 , , , 40436 4775 12 by by IN 40436 4775 13 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 4775 14 ! ! . 40436 4776 1 When when WRB 40436 4776 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4776 3 meat meat NN 40436 4776 4 is be VBZ 40436 4776 5 being be VBG 40436 4776 6 boiled boil VBN 40436 4776 7 , , , 40436 4776 8 would would MD 40436 4776 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4776 10 permit permit VB 40436 4776 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4776 12 eldest eld JJS 40436 4776 13 son son NN 40436 4776 14 who who WP 40436 4776 15 is be VBZ 40436 4776 16 to to TO 40436 4776 17 succeed succeed VB 40436 4776 18 to to IN 40436 4776 19 the the DT 40436 4776 20 rule rule NN 40436 4776 21 of of IN 40436 4776 22 Asia Asia NNP 40436 4776 23 , , , 40436 4776 24 to to TO 40436 4776 25 throw throw VB 40436 4776 26 in in RP 40436 4776 27 any any DT 40436 4776 28 thing thing NN 40436 4776 29 that that WDT 40436 4776 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4776 31 pleases please VBZ 40436 4776 32 into into IN 40436 4776 33 the the DT 40436 4776 34 sauce sauce NN 40436 4776 35 , , , 40436 4776 36 rather rather RB 40436 4776 37 than than IN 40436 4776 38 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4776 39 , , , 40436 4776 40 if if IN 40436 4776 41 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4776 42 come come VBP 40436 4776 43 and and CC 40436 4776 44 prove prove VBP 40436 4776 45 to to IN 40436 4776 46 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4776 47 that that IN 40436 4776 48 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4776 49 know know VBP 40436 4776 50 better well RBR 40436 4776 51 than than IN 40436 4776 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4776 53 son son NN 40436 4776 54 the the DT 40436 4776 55 way way NN 40436 4776 56 of of IN 40436 4776 57 preparing prepare VBG 40436 4776 58 sauce sauce NN 40436 4776 59 ? ? . 40436 4777 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4777 2 Lysis._--Clearly Lysis._--Clearly NNP 40436 4777 3 , , , 40436 4777 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4777 5 will will MD 40436 4777 6 rather rather RB 40436 4777 7 permit permit VB 40436 4777 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4777 9 . . . 40436 4778 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4778 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 4778 3 Great great JJ 40436 4778 4 King King NNP 40436 4778 5 will will MD 40436 4778 6 not not RB 40436 4778 7 let let VB 40436 4778 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4778 9 son son NN 40436 4778 10 throw throw VB 40436 4778 11 in in RP 40436 4778 12 even even RB 40436 4778 13 a a DT 40436 4778 14 pinch pinch NN 40436 4778 15 of of IN 40436 4778 16 salt salt NN 40436 4778 17 : : : 40436 4778 18 while while IN 40436 4778 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4778 20 , , , 40436 4778 21 if if IN 40436 4778 22 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4778 23 chose choose VBD 40436 4778 24 to to TO 40436 4778 25 take take VB 40436 4778 26 up up RP 40436 4778 27 an an DT 40436 4778 28 entire entire JJ 40436 4778 29 handful handful NN 40436 4778 30 , , , 40436 4778 31 should should MD 40436 4778 32 be be VB 40436 4778 33 allowed allow VBN 40436 4778 34 to to TO 40436 4778 35 throw throw VB 40436 4778 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4778 37 in in RP 40436 4778 38 . . . 40436 4779 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4779 2 Lysis._--No lysis._--no JJ 40436 4779 3 doubt doubt NN 40436 4779 4 . . . 40436 4780 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4780 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 4780 3 if if IN 40436 4780 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4780 5 son son NN 40436 4780 6 has have VBZ 40436 4780 7 a a DT 40436 4780 8 complaint complaint NN 40436 4780 9 in in IN 40436 4780 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4780 11 eyes eye NNS 40436 4780 12 ; ; : 40436 4780 13 would would MD 40436 4780 14 the the DT 40436 4780 15 Great Great NNP 40436 4780 16 King King NNP 40436 4780 17 , , , 40436 4780 18 knowing know VBG 40436 4780 19 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4780 20 to to TO 40436 4780 21 be be VB 40436 4780 22 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 4780 23 of of IN 40436 4780 24 medicine medicine NN 40436 4780 25 , , , 40436 4780 26 allow allow VB 40436 4780 27 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4780 28 even even RB 40436 4780 29 to to TO 40436 4780 30 touch touch VB 40436 4780 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4780 32 own own JJ 40436 4780 33 eyes eye NNS 40436 4780 34 or or CC 40436 4780 35 would would MD 40436 4780 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4780 37 forbid forbid VB 40436 4780 38 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4780 39 ? ? . 40436 4781 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4781 2 Lysis._--He lysis._--he NN 40436 4781 3 would would MD 40436 4781 4 forbid forbid VB 40436 4781 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4781 6 . . . 40436 4782 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4782 2 Sokr._--As Sokr._--As NNP 40436 4782 3 to to IN 40436 4782 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 5 , , , 40436 4782 6 on on IN 40436 4782 7 the the DT 40436 4782 8 contrary contrary NN 40436 4782 9 , , , 40436 4782 10 if if IN 40436 4782 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 12 accounted account VBD 40436 4782 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 14 good good JJ 40436 4782 15 physicians physician NNS 40436 4782 16 , , , 40436 4782 17 and and CC 40436 4782 18 if if IN 40436 4782 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 20 desired desire VBD 40436 4782 21 even even RB 40436 4782 22 to to TO 40436 4782 23 open open VB 40436 4782 24 the the DT 40436 4782 25 eyes eye NNS 40436 4782 26 and and CC 40436 4782 27 drop drop VB 40436 4782 28 a a DT 40436 4782 29 powder powder NN 40436 4782 30 into into IN 40436 4782 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 32 , , , 40436 4782 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 34 would would MD 40436 4782 35 not not RB 40436 4782 36 hinder hinder VB 40436 4782 37 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 38 , , , 40436 4782 39 in in IN 40436 4782 40 the the DT 40436 4782 41 conviction conviction NN 40436 4782 42 that that IN 40436 4782 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 44 understood understand VBD 40436 4782 45 what what WP 40436 4782 46 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4782 47 were be VBD 40436 4782 48 doing do VBG 40436 4782 49 . . . 40436 4783 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4783 2 Lysis._--You lysis._--you CD 40436 4783 3 speak speak VBP 40436 4783 4 truly truly RB 40436 4783 5 . . . 40436 4784 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4784 2 Sokr._--All Sokr._--All NNP 40436 4784 3 other other JJ 40436 4784 4 matters matter NNS 40436 4784 5 , , , 40436 4784 6 in in IN 40436 4784 7 short short JJ 40436 4784 8 , , , 40436 4784 9 on on IN 40436 4784 10 which which WDT 40436 4784 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4784 12 believed believe VBD 40436 4784 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4784 14 to to TO 40436 4784 15 be be VB 40436 4784 16 wiser wise JJR 40436 4784 17 than than IN 40436 4784 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4784 19 or or CC 40436 4784 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4784 21 son son NN 40436 4784 22 , , , 40436 4784 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4784 24 would would MD 40436 4784 25 entrust entrust VB 40436 4784 26 to to IN 40436 4784 27 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4784 28 rather rather RB 40436 4784 29 than than IN 40436 4784 30 to to IN 40436 4784 31 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4784 32 or or CC 40436 4784 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4784 34 son son NN 40436 4784 35 ? ? . 40436 4785 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4785 2 Lysis._--Necessarily Lysis._--Necessarily NNP 40436 4785 3 so so RB 40436 4785 4 , , , 40436 4785 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4785 6 . . . 40436 4786 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4786 2 Sokr._--This Sokr._--This NNP 40436 4786 3 is be VBZ 40436 4786 4 the the DT 40436 4786 5 state state NN 40436 4786 6 of of IN 40436 4786 7 the the DT 40436 4786 8 case case NN 40436 4786 9 , , , 40436 4786 10 then then RB 40436 4786 11 , , , 40436 4786 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4786 13 dear dear JJ 40436 4786 14 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4786 15 : : : 40436 4786 16 On on IN 40436 4786 17 those those DT 40436 4786 18 matters matter NNS 40436 4786 19 on on IN 40436 4786 20 which which WDT 40436 4786 21 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4786 22 shall shall MD 40436 4786 23 have have VB 40436 4786 24 become become VBN 40436 4786 25 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4786 26 , , , 40436 4786 27 all all DT 40436 4786 28 persons person NNS 40436 4786 29 will will MD 40436 4786 30 put put VB 40436 4786 31 trust trust NN 40436 4786 32 in in IN 40436 4786 33 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4786 34 -- -- : 40436 4786 35 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 4786 36 as as RB 40436 4786 37 well well RB 40436 4786 38 as as IN 40436 4786 39 barbarians barbarian NNS 40436 4786 40 , , , 40436 4786 41 men man NNS 40436 4786 42 as as RB 40436 4786 43 well well RB 40436 4786 44 as as IN 40436 4786 45 women woman NNS 40436 4786 46 . . . 40436 4787 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4787 2 shall shall MD 40436 4787 3 do do VB 40436 4787 4 whatever whatever WDT 40436 4787 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4787 6 please please VBP 40436 4787 7 respecting respect VBG 40436 4787 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4787 9 : : : 40436 4787 10 no no DT 40436 4787 11 one one NN 40436 4787 12 will will MD 40436 4787 13 be be VB 40436 4787 14 at at RB 40436 4787 15 all all RB 40436 4787 16 inclined inclined JJ 40436 4787 17 to to TO 40436 4787 18 interfere interfere VB 40436 4787 19 with with IN 40436 4787 20 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4787 21 on on IN 40436 4787 22 such such JJ 40436 4787 23 matters matter NNS 40436 4787 24 ; ; : 40436 4787 25 not not RB 40436 4787 26 only only RB 40436 4787 27 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4787 28 shall shall MD 40436 4787 29 be be VB 40436 4787 30 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 4787 31 free free JJ 40436 4787 32 , , , 40436 4787 33 but but CC 40436 4787 34 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4787 35 shall shall MD 40436 4787 36 have have VB 40436 4787 37 command command NN 40436 4787 38 over over IN 40436 4787 39 others other NNS 40436 4787 40 besides besides RB 40436 4787 41 . . . 40436 4788 1 These these DT 40436 4788 2 matters matter NNS 40436 4788 3 will will MD 40436 4788 4 be be VB 40436 4788 5 really really RB 40436 4788 6 ours ours JJ 40436 4788 7 , , , 40436 4788 8 because because IN 40436 4788 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4788 10 shall shall MD 40436 4788 11 derive derive VB 40436 4788 12 real real JJ 40436 4788 13 good good RB 40436 4788 14 from from IN 40436 4788 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4788 16 . . . 40436 4789 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4789 2 4 4 LS 40436 4789 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4789 4 As as IN 40436 4789 5 to to IN 40436 4789 6 those those DT 40436 4789 7 subjects subject NNS 40436 4789 8 , , , 40436 4789 9 on on IN 40436 4789 10 the the DT 40436 4789 11 contrary contrary NN 40436 4789 12 , , , 40436 4789 13 on on IN 40436 4789 14 which which WDT 40436 4789 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 16 shall shall MD 40436 4789 17 not not RB 40436 4789 18 have have VB 40436 4789 19 acquired acquire VBN 40436 4789 20 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4789 21 , , , 40436 4789 22 no no DT 40436 4789 23 one one NN 40436 4789 24 will will MD 40436 4789 25 trust trust VB 40436 4789 26 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 27 to to TO 40436 4789 28 do do VB 40436 4789 29 what what WP 40436 4789 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 31 think think VBP 40436 4789 32 right right RB 40436 4789 33 : : : 40436 4789 34 every every DT 40436 4789 35 one,--not one,--not NN 40436 4789 36 merely merely RB 40436 4789 37 strangers stranger NNS 40436 4789 38 , , , 40436 4789 39 but but CC 40436 4789 40 father father NN 40436 4789 41 and and CC 40436 4789 42 mother mother NN 40436 4789 43 and and CC 40436 4789 44 nearer nearer VB 40436 4789 45 relatives relative NNS 40436 4789 46 if if IN 40436 4789 47 there there EX 40436 4789 48 were be VBD 40436 4789 49 any,--will any,--will NN 40436 4789 50 obstruct obstruct VB 40436 4789 51 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 52 as as RB 40436 4789 53 much much RB 40436 4789 54 as as IN 40436 4789 55 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 56 can can MD 40436 4789 57 : : : 40436 4789 58 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 59 shall shall MD 40436 4789 60 be be VB 40436 4789 61 in in IN 40436 4789 62 servitude servitude NN 40436 4789 63 so so RB 40436 4789 64 far far RB 40436 4789 65 as as IN 40436 4789 66 these these DT 40436 4789 67 subjects subject NNS 40436 4789 68 are be VBP 40436 4789 69 concerned concerned JJ 40436 4789 70 ; ; : 40436 4789 71 and and CC 40436 4789 72 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 73 will will MD 40436 4789 74 be be VB 40436 4789 75 really really RB 40436 4789 76 alien alien JJ 40436 4789 77 to to IN 40436 4789 78 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 79 , , , 40436 4789 80 for for IN 40436 4789 81 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 82 shall shall MD 40436 4789 83 derive derive VB 40436 4789 84 no no DT 40436 4789 85 real real RB 40436 4789 86 good good RB 40436 4789 87 from from IN 40436 4789 88 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4789 89 . . . 40436 4790 1 Do do VBP 40436 4790 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4790 3 admit admit VB 40436 4790 4 that that IN 40436 4790 5 this this DT 40436 4790 6 is be VBZ 40436 4790 7 the the DT 40436 4790 8 case case NN 40436 4790 9 ? ? . 40436 4791 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4791 2 5 5 CD 40436 4791 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4791 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4791 5 Lysis._--I lysis._--i NN 40436 4791 6 do do VBP 40436 4791 7 admit admit VB 40436 4791 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4791 9 . . . 40436 4792 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4792 2 Sokr._--Shall Sokr._--Shall NNP 40436 4792 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4792 4 then then RB 40436 4792 5 be be VB 40436 4792 6 friends friend NNS 40436 4792 7 to to IN 40436 4792 8 any any DT 40436 4792 9 one one CD 40436 4792 10 , , , 40436 4792 11 or or CC 40436 4792 12 will will MD 40436 4792 13 any any DT 40436 4792 14 one one CD 40436 4792 15 love love VB 40436 4792 16 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4792 17 , , , 40436 4792 18 on on IN 40436 4792 19 those those DT 40436 4792 20 matters matter NNS 40436 4792 21 on on IN 40436 4792 22 which which WDT 40436 4792 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4792 24 are be VBP 40436 4792 25 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 4792 26 _ _ NNP 40436 4792 27 Lysis._--Certainly lysis._--certainly RB 40436 4792 28 not not RB 40436 4792 29 . . . 40436 4793 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4793 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 4793 3 see see VBP 40436 4793 4 that that IN 40436 4793 5 neither neither CC 40436 4793 6 does do VBZ 40436 4793 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4793 8 father father NN 40436 4793 9 love love VB 40436 4793 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4793 11 , , , 40436 4793 12 nor nor CC 40436 4793 13 does do VBZ 40436 4793 14 any any DT 40436 4793 15 man man NN 40436 4793 16 love love VB 40436 4793 17 another another DT 40436 4793 18 , , , 40436 4793 19 in in IN 40436 4793 20 so so RB 40436 4793 21 far far RB 40436 4793 22 as as IN 40436 4793 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4793 24 is be VBZ 40436 4793 25 useless useless JJ 40436 4793 26 ? ? . 40436 4794 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4794 2 Lysis._--Apparently lysis._--apparently RB 40436 4794 3 not not RB 40436 4794 4 . . . 40436 4795 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4795 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 4795 3 then then RB 40436 4795 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4795 5 become become VBP 40436 4795 6 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 4795 7 , , , 40436 4795 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4795 9 boy boy NN 40436 4795 10 , , , 40436 4795 11 all all DT 40436 4795 12 persons person NNS 40436 4795 13 will will MD 40436 4795 14 be be VB 40436 4795 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4795 16 friends friend NNS 40436 4795 17 and and CC 40436 4795 18 all all DT 40436 4795 19 persons person NNS 40436 4795 20 will will MD 40436 4795 21 be be VB 40436 4795 22 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4795 23 kinsmen kinsman NNS 40436 4795 24 : : : 40436 4795 25 for for IN 40436 4795 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4795 27 will will MD 40436 4795 28 be be VB 40436 4795 29 useful useful JJ 40436 4795 30 and and CC 40436 4795 31 good good JJ 40436 4795 32 : : : 40436 4795 33 if if IN 40436 4795 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4795 35 do do VBP 40436 4795 36 not not RB 40436 4795 37 , , , 40436 4795 38 no no DT 40436 4795 39 one one NN 40436 4795 40 will will MD 40436 4795 41 be be VB 40436 4795 42 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4795 43 friend,--not friend,--not ADD 40436 4795 44 even even RB 40436 4795 45 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4795 46 father father NN 40436 4795 47 nor nor CC 40436 4795 48 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4795 49 mother mother NN 40436 4795 50 nor nor CC 40436 4795 51 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4795 52 other other JJ 40436 4795 53 relatives relative NNS 40436 4795 54 . . . 40436 4796 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4796 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4796 3 4 4 CD 40436 4796 4 : : : 40436 4796 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4796 6 , , , 40436 4796 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4796 8 , , , 40436 4796 9 210 210 CD 40436 4796 10 B. b. NN 40436 4797 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4797 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4797 3 : : : 40436 4797 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4797 5 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 4797 6 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 4797 7 = = SYM 40436 4797 8 s s NNP 40436 4797 9 e(kô\n e(kô\n NNP 40436 4797 10 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4797 11 e)mpodiei= e)mpodiei= NNP 40436 4797 12 , , , 40436 4797 13 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 4797 14 ' ' '' 40436 4797 15 au)toi/ au)toi/ NN 40436 4797 16 te te NNP 40436 4797 17 e)leu e)leu NNP 40436 4797 18 / / SYM 40436 4797 19 theroi theroi VBZ 40436 4797 20 e)so e)so NNP 40436 4797 21 / / SYM 40436 4797 22 metha metha NNP 40436 4797 23 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4797 24 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 4797 25 = = SYM 40436 4797 26 s s NNP 40436 4797 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4797 28 a)/llôn a)/llôn NNP 40436 4797 29 a)/rchontes a)/rchontes NNP 40436 4797 30 , , , 40436 4797 31 ê(me ê(me NNP 40436 4797 32 / / SYM 40436 4797 33 tera/ tera/ NNP 40436 4797 34 te te NNP 40436 4797 35 tau tau NNP 40436 4797 36 = = SYM 40436 4797 37 ta ta NNP 40436 4797 38 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 4797 39 ; ; : 40436 4797 40 o)nêso o)nêso ADD 40436 4797 41 / / SYM 40436 4797 42 metha metha NN 40436 4797 43 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4797 44 a)p a)p NNP 40436 4797 45 ' ' POS 40436 4797 46 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 4797 47 = = SYM 40436 4797 48 n n NN 40436 4797 49 . . . 40436 4797 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4797 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4798 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4798 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4798 3 5 5 CD 40436 4798 4 : : : 40436 4798 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4798 6 , , , 40436 4798 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4798 8 , , , 40436 4798 9 210 210 CD 40436 4798 10 C. C. NNP 40436 4798 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4798 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4798 13 : : : 40436 4798 14 au)toi/ au)toi/ NN 40436 4798 15 te te NNP 40436 4798 16 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4798 17 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 4798 18 = = NNP 40436 4798 19 s s NNP 40436 4798 20 e)so e)so NNP 40436 4798 21 / / SYM 40436 4798 22 metha metha NNP 40436 4798 23 a)/llôn a)/llôn NNP 40436 4798 24 u(pêkooi u(pêkooi NNP 40436 4798 25 , , , 40436 4798 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4798 27 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 4798 28 = = SYM 40436 4798 29 n n CD 40436 4798 30 e)/stai e)/stai SYM 40436 4798 31 a)llo a)llo NNP 40436 4798 32 / / SYM 40436 4798 33 tria tria NNS 40436 4798 34 ; ; : 40436 4798 35 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 4798 36 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4798 37 a)p a)p NNP 40436 4798 38 ' ' POS 40436 4798 39 au)tô au)tô NN 40436 4798 40 = = SYM 40436 4798 41 n n CC 40436 4798 42 o)nêso o)nêso NNP 40436 4798 43 / / SYM 40436 4798 44 metha metha NNP 40436 4798 45 . . . 40436 4799 1 Sugchôrei Sugchôrei NNP 40436 4799 2 = = SYM 40436 4799 3 s s NN 40436 4799 4 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 4799 5 e)/chein e)/chein NN 40436 4799 6 ? ? . 40436 4800 1 Sugchôrô=. Sugchôrô=. NNP 40436 4800 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4800 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4801 1 Is be VBZ 40436 4801 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4801 3 possible possible JJ 40436 4801 4 then then RB 40436 4801 5 , , , 40436 4801 6 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4801 7 , , , 40436 4801 8 for for IN 40436 4801 9 a a DT 40436 4801 10 man man NN 40436 4801 11 to to TO 40436 4801 12 think think VB 40436 4801 13 highly highly RB 40436 4801 14 of of IN 40436 4801 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4801 16 on on IN 40436 4801 17 those those DT 40436 4801 18 matters matter NNS 40436 4801 19 on on IN 40436 4801 20 which which WDT 40436 4801 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4801 22 does do VBZ 40436 4801 23 not not RB 40436 4801 24 yet yet RB 40436 4801 25 think think VB 40436 4801 26 aright aright JJ 40436 4801 27 ? ? . 40436 4802 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4802 2 Lysis._--How Lysis._--How NNP 40436 4802 3 can can MD 40436 4802 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4802 5 be be VB 40436 4802 6 possible possible JJ 40436 4802 7 ? ? . 40436 4803 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4803 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 4803 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4803 4 stand stand VBP 40436 4803 5 in in IN 40436 4803 6 need need NN 40436 4803 7 of of IN 40436 4803 8 a a DT 40436 4803 9 teacher teacher NN 40436 4803 10 , , , 40436 4803 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4803 12 do do VBP 40436 4803 13 not not RB 40436 4803 14 yet yet RB 40436 4803 15 think think VB 40436 4803 16 aright aright JJ 40436 4803 17 ? ? . 40436 4804 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4804 2 Lysis._--True Lysis._--True NNP 40436 4804 3 . . . 40436 4805 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4805 2 Sokr._--Accordingly Sokr._--Accordingly NNP 40436 4805 3 , , , 40436 4805 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4805 5 are be VBP 40436 4805 6 not not RB 40436 4805 7 presumptuous presumptuous JJ 40436 4805 8 on on IN 40436 4805 9 the the DT 40436 4805 10 score score NN 40436 4805 11 of of IN 40436 4805 12 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4805 13 , , , 40436 4805 14 since since IN 40436 4805 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4805 16 are be VBP 40436 4805 17 still still RB 40436 4805 18 without without IN 40436 4805 19 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 4805 20 . . . 40436 4806 1 _ _ NNP 40436 4806 2 Lysis._--By lysis._--by JJ 40436 4806 3 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 4806 4 , , , 40436 4806 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4806 6 , , , 40436 4806 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4806 8 think think VBP 40436 4806 9 not not RB 40436 4806 10 . . . 40436 4807 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4807 2 6 6 CD 40436 4807 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4807 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4807 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4807 6 6 6 CD 40436 4807 7 : : : 40436 4807 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4807 9 , , , 40436 4807 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4807 11 , , , 40436 4807 12 210 210 CD 40436 4807 13 D. D. NNP 40436 4807 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4807 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4807 16 : : : 40436 4807 17 Oi(=o Oi(=o NNP 40436 4807 18 / / SYM 40436 4807 19 n n NNP 40436 4807 20 te te NNP 40436 4807 21 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 4807 22 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 4807 23 tou tou NNP 40436 4807 24 / / SYM 40436 4807 25 tois tois NNP 40436 4807 26 , , , 40436 4807 27 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 4807 28 Lu Lu NNP 40436 4807 29 / / SYM 40436 4807 30 si si UH 40436 4807 31 , , , 40436 4807 32 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4807 33 / / SYM 40436 4807 34 ga ga NNP 40436 4807 35 phronei phronei NNP 40436 4807 36 = = SYM 40436 4807 37 n n NNP 40436 4807 38 , , , 40436 4807 39 e)n e)n NNP 40436 4807 40 oi(=s oi(=s NN 40436 4807 41 tis tis NNP 40436 4807 42 mê mê NNP 40436 4807 43 / / SYM 40436 4807 44 pô pô NNP 40436 4807 45 phronei= phronei= NNP 40436 4807 46 ? ? . 40436 4808 1 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 4808 2 pô pô NNP 40436 4808 3 = = NFP 40436 4808 4 s s NNP 40436 4808 5 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 4808 6 ? ? . 40436 4809 1 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 4809 2 . . . 40436 4810 1 Ei Ei NNP 40436 4810 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4810 3 d d NN 40436 4810 4 ' ' '' 40436 4810 5 a)/ra a)/ra NFP 40436 4810 6 su\ su\ JJ 40436 4810 7 didaska didaska NNP 40436 4810 8 / / SYM 40436 4810 9 lou lou NNP 40436 4810 10 de de NNP 40436 4810 11 / / SYM 40436 4810 12 ei ei NNP 40436 4810 13 , , , 40436 4810 14 ou)/pô ou)/pô CD 40436 4810 15 phronei phronei NNP 40436 4810 16 = = SYM 40436 4810 17 s s NN 40436 4810 18 . . . 40436 4811 1 A)lêthê=. A)lêthê=. NNP 40436 4812 1 Ou)d Ou)d NNP 40436 4812 2 ' ' '' 40436 4812 3 a)/ra a)/ra UH 40436 4812 4 megalo megalo NNP 40436 4812 5 / / SYM 40436 4812 6 phrôn phrôn NN 40436 4812 7 ei)= ei)= NNS 40436 4812 8 , , , 40436 4812 9 ei)/per ei)/per NN 40436 4812 10 a)/phrôn a)/phrôn NNP 40436 4812 11 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 4812 12 . . . 40436 4813 1 Ma\ Ma\ NNP 40436 4813 2 Di/ Di/ NNP 40436 4813 3 ' ' POS 40436 4813 4 , , , 40436 4813 5 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 4813 6 , , , 40436 4813 7 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 4813 8 Sô Sô NNP 40436 4813 9 / / SYM 40436 4813 10 krates krate NNS 40436 4813 11 , , , 40436 4813 12 ou)/ ou)/ NNP 40436 4813 13 moi moi NNP 40436 4813 14 dokei=. dokei=. NNP 40436 4813 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4814 1 There there EX 40436 4814 2 is be VBZ 40436 4814 3 here here RB 40436 4814 4 a a DT 40436 4814 5 double double JJ 40436 4814 6 sense sense NN 40436 4814 7 of of IN 40436 4814 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4814 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4814 10 : : : 40436 4814 11 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4814 12 / / SYM 40436 4814 13 ga ga NNP 40436 4814 14 phronei phronei NNP 40436 4814 15 = = SYM 40436 4814 16 n n NNP 40436 4814 17 , , , 40436 4814 18 megalo megalo NNP 40436 4814 19 / / SYM 40436 4814 20 phrôn phrôn NN 40436 4814 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4814 22 , , , 40436 4814 23 which which WDT 40436 4814 24 can can MD 40436 4814 25 not not RB 40436 4814 26 easily easily RB 40436 4814 27 be be VB 40436 4814 28 made make VBN 40436 4814 29 to to TO 40436 4814 30 pass pass VB 40436 4814 31 into into IN 40436 4814 32 any any DT 40436 4814 33 other other JJ 40436 4814 34 language language NN 40436 4814 35 . . . 40436 4814 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4815 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4815 2 Side side NN 40436 4815 3 - - HYPH 40436 4815 4 note note NN 40436 4815 5 : : : 40436 4815 6 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4815 7 is be VBZ 40436 4815 8 humiliated humiliate VBN 40436 4815 9 . . . 40436 4816 1 Distress Distress NNP 40436 4816 2 of of IN 40436 4816 3 Hippothalês Hippothalês NNPS 40436 4816 4 . . . 40436 4816 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4817 1 When when WRB 40436 4817 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 3 heard hear VBD 40436 4817 4 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4817 5 speak speak VB 40436 4817 6 thus thus RB 40436 4817 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4817 8 continues continue VBZ 40436 4817 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4817 10 , , , 40436 4817 11 who who WP 40436 4817 12 is be VBZ 40436 4817 13 here here RB 40436 4817 14 the the DT 40436 4817 15 narrator narrator NN 40436 4817 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4817 17 , , , 40436 4817 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 19 looked look VBD 40436 4817 20 towards towards IN 40436 4817 21 Hippothalês Hippothalês NNP 40436 4817 22 and and CC 40436 4817 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 24 was be VBD 40436 4817 25 on on IN 40436 4817 26 the the DT 40436 4817 27 point point NN 40436 4817 28 of of IN 40436 4817 29 committing commit VBG 40436 4817 30 a a DT 40436 4817 31 blunder blunder NN 40436 4817 32 : : : 40436 4817 33 for for IN 40436 4817 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 35 occurred occur VBD 40436 4817 36 to to IN 40436 4817 37 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 38 to to TO 40436 4817 39 say say VB 40436 4817 40 , , , 40436 4817 41 That that DT 40436 4817 42 is be VBZ 40436 4817 43 the the DT 40436 4817 44 way way NN 40436 4817 45 , , , 40436 4817 46 Hippothalês Hippothalês NNP 40436 4817 47 , , , 40436 4817 48 to to TO 40436 4817 49 address address VB 40436 4817 50 a a DT 40436 4817 51 youth youth NN 40436 4817 52 whom whom WP 40436 4817 53 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 54 love love VBP 40436 4817 55 : : : 40436 4817 56 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 57 ought ought MD 40436 4817 58 to to TO 40436 4817 59 check check VB 40436 4817 60 and and CC 40436 4817 61 humble humble VB 40436 4817 62 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 63 , , , 40436 4817 64 not not RB 40436 4817 65 puff puff VB 40436 4817 66 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 67 up up RP 40436 4817 68 and and CC 40436 4817 69 spoil spoil VB 40436 4817 70 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 71 , , , 40436 4817 72 as as IN 40436 4817 73 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4817 74 have have VBP 40436 4817 75 hitherto hitherto VBN 40436 4817 76 done do VBN 40436 4817 77 . . . 40436 4818 1 But but CC 40436 4818 2 when when WRB 40436 4818 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4818 4 saw see VBD 40436 4818 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4818 6 agitated agitate VBN 40436 4818 7 and and CC 40436 4818 8 distressed distress VBN 40436 4818 9 by by IN 40436 4818 10 what what WP 40436 4818 11 had have VBD 40436 4818 12 been be VBN 40436 4818 13 said say VBN 40436 4818 14 , , , 40436 4818 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4818 16 called call VBD 40436 4818 17 to to TO 40436 4818 18 mind mind VB 40436 4818 19 that that IN 40436 4818 20 , , , 40436 4818 21 though though IN 40436 4818 22 standing stand VBG 40436 4818 23 close close RB 40436 4818 24 by by RB 40436 4818 25 , , , 40436 4818 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4818 27 wished wish VBD 40436 4818 28 not not RB 40436 4818 29 to to TO 40436 4818 30 be be VB 40436 4818 31 seen see VBN 40436 4818 32 by by IN 40436 4818 33 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4818 34 . . . 40436 4819 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 4819 2 , , , 40436 4819 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4819 4 restrained restrain VBD 40436 4819 5 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 4819 6 and and CC 40436 4819 7 said say VBD 40436 4819 8 nothing nothing NN 40436 4819 9 of of IN 40436 4819 10 the the DT 40436 4819 11 kind kind NN 40436 4819 12 . . . 40436 4820 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4820 2 7 7 CD 40436 4820 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4820 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4820 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4820 6 7 7 CD 40436 4820 7 : : : 40436 4820 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4820 9 , , , 40436 4820 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4820 11 , , , 40436 4820 12 210 210 CD 40436 4820 13 E. e. NN 40436 4820 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4820 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4820 16 Side side NN 40436 4820 17 - - HYPH 40436 4820 18 note note NN 40436 4820 19 : : : 40436 4820 20 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4820 21 entreats entreat NNS 40436 4820 22 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4820 23 to to TO 40436 4820 24 talk talk VB 40436 4820 25 in in IN 40436 4820 26 the the DT 40436 4820 27 like like JJ 40436 4820 28 strain strain NN 40436 4820 29 to to IN 40436 4820 30 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4820 31 . . . 40436 4820 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4821 1 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4821 2 accepts accept VBZ 40436 4821 3 this this DT 40436 4821 4 as as IN 40436 4821 5 a a DT 40436 4821 6 friendly friendly JJ 40436 4821 7 lesson lesson NN 40436 4821 8 , , , 40436 4821 9 inculcating inculcate VBG 40436 4821 10 humility humility NN 40436 4821 11 : : : 40436 4821 12 and and CC 40436 4821 13 seeing see VBG 40436 4821 14 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4821 15 just just RB 40436 4821 16 then then RB 40436 4821 17 coming come VBG 40436 4821 18 back back RB 40436 4821 19 , , , 40436 4821 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4821 21 says say VBZ 40436 4821 22 aside aside RB 40436 4821 23 to to IN 40436 4821 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4821 25 , , , 40436 4821 26 Talk talk VB 40436 4821 27 to to IN 40436 4821 28 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4821 29 , , , 40436 4821 30 as as IN 40436 4821 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4821 32 have have VBP 40436 4821 33 been be VBN 40436 4821 34 talking talk VBG 40436 4821 35 to to IN 40436 4821 36 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4821 37 . . . 40436 4822 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4822 2 can can MD 40436 4822 3 tell tell VB 40436 4822 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4822 5 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 4822 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4822 7 replies reply VBZ 40436 4822 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4822 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4822 10 what what WP 40436 4822 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4822 12 have have VBP 40436 4822 13 heard hear VBN 40436 4822 14 from from IN 40436 4822 15 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4822 16 : : : 40436 4822 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4822 18 listened listen VBD 40436 4822 19 very very RB 40436 4822 20 attentively attentively RB 40436 4822 21 . . . 40436 4823 1 Most most RBS 40436 4823 2 certainly certainly RB 40436 4823 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4823 4 shall shall MD 40436 4823 5 tell tell VB 40436 4823 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4823 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4823 8 says say VBZ 40436 4823 9 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4823 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4823 11 : : : 40436 4823 12 but but CC 40436 4823 13 meanwhile meanwhile RB 40436 4823 14 pray pray VB 40436 4823 15 address address NN 40436 4823 16 to to IN 40436 4823 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4823 18 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 4823 19 some some DT 40436 4823 20 other other JJ 40436 4823 21 questions question NNS 40436 4823 22 , , , 40436 4823 23 for for IN 40436 4823 24 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4823 25 to to TO 40436 4823 26 hear hear VB 40436 4823 27 . . . 40436 4824 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4824 2 must must MD 40436 4824 3 engage engage VB 40436 4824 4 to to TO 40436 4824 5 help help VB 40436 4824 6 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4824 7 if if IN 40436 4824 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4824 9 require require VBP 40436 4824 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4824 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4824 12 answers answer NNS 40436 4824 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4824 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4824 15 : : : 40436 4824 16 for for IN 40436 4824 17 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4824 18 is be VBZ 40436 4824 19 a a DT 40436 4824 20 formidable formidable JJ 40436 4824 21 disputant disputant NN 40436 4824 22 , , , 40436 4824 23 scholar scholar NN 40436 4824 24 of of IN 40436 4824 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4824 26 friend friend NN 40436 4824 27 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 4824 28 , , , 40436 4824 29 who who WP 40436 4824 30 is be VBZ 40436 4824 31 here here RB 40436 4824 32 ready ready JJ 40436 4824 33 to to TO 40436 4824 34 assist assist VB 40436 4824 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4824 36 . . . 40436 4825 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4825 2 know know VBP 40436 4825 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4825 4 is be VBZ 40436 4825 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4825 6 rejoined rejoin VBN 40436 4825 7 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4825 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4825 9 , , , 40436 4825 10 and and CC 40436 4825 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4825 12 is be VBZ 40436 4825 13 for for IN 40436 4825 14 that that DT 40436 4825 15 very very JJ 40436 4825 16 reason reason NN 40436 4825 17 that that WDT 40436 4825 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4825 19 want want VBP 40436 4825 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4825 21 to to TO 40436 4825 22 talk talk VB 40436 4825 23 to to IN 40436 4825 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4825 25 -- -- : 40436 4825 26 that that IN 40436 4825 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4825 28 may may MD 40436 4825 29 chasten chasten VB 40436 4825 30 and and CC 40436 4825 31 punish punish VB 40436 4825 32 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4825 33 . . . 40436 4826 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4826 2 8 8 CD 40436 4826 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4826 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4826 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4826 6 8 8 CD 40436 4826 7 : : : 40436 4826 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4826 9 , , , 40436 4826 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4826 11 , , , 40436 4826 12 211 211 CD 40436 4826 13 B B NNP 40436 4826 14 - - HYPH 40436 4826 15 C. C. NNP 40436 4826 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4826 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4826 18 : : : 40436 4826 19 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 4826 20 ' ' '' 40436 4826 21 o(/ra o(/ra CD 40436 4826 22 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 4826 23 e)pikourê e)pikourê NNP 40436 4826 24 / / SYM 40436 4826 25 seis seis NNP 40436 4826 26 moi moi NNP 40436 4826 27 , , , 40436 4826 28 e)a e)a NNP 40436 4826 29 / / SYM 40436 4826 30 n n CC 40436 4826 31 me -PRON- PRP 40436 4826 32 e)le e)le NN 40436 4826 33 / / SYM 40436 4826 34 gchein gchein NN 40436 4826 35 e)picheirê=| e)picheirê=| ADD 40436 4826 36 o o NN 40436 4826 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4826 38 Mene Mene NNP 40436 4826 39 / / SYM 40436 4826 40 xenos xenos NNP 40436 4826 41 . . . 40436 4827 1 ê)\ ê)\ TO 40436 4827 2 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 4827 3 oi)=stha oi)=stha `` 40436 4827 4 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 4827 5 e)ristiko e)ristiko NNP 40436 4827 6 / / SYM 40436 4827 7 s s NNP 40436 4827 8 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 4827 9 ? ? . 40436 4828 1 Nai\ nai\ CD 40436 4828 2 ma\ ma\ JJ 40436 4828 3 Di Di NNP 40436 4828 4 / / SYM 40436 4828 5 a a NNP 40436 4828 6 , , , 40436 4828 7 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 4828 8 , , , 40436 4828 9 spho spho NNP 40436 4828 10 / / SYM 40436 4828 11 dra dra NNP 40436 4828 12 ge ge NNP 40436 4828 13 . . . 40436 4829 1 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 4829 2 tau tau NNP 40436 4829 3 = = NNP 40436 4829 4 ta/ ta/ NNP 40436 4829 5 toi toi NNP 40436 4829 6 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4829 7 bou bou NNP 40436 4829 8 / / SYM 40436 4829 9 lomai/ lomai/ NNP 40436 4829 10 se se NNP 40436 4829 11 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 4829 12 diale diale NNP 40436 4829 13 / / SYM 40436 4829 14 gesthai gesthai NNP 40436 4829 15 -- -- : 40436 4829 16 i(/n i(/n NNP 40436 4829 17 ' ' '' 40436 4829 18 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 4829 19 kola kola NNP 40436 4829 20 / / SYM 40436 4829 21 sê|s sê|s NNP 40436 4829 22 . . . 40436 4829 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4830 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 4830 2 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 4830 3 , , , 40436 4830 4 Memor Memor NNP 40436 4830 5 . . . 40436 4831 1 i. i. NNP 40436 4832 1 4 4 CD 40436 4832 2 , , , 40436 4832 3 1 1 CD 40436 4832 4 , , , 40436 4832 5 where where WRB 40436 4832 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4832 7 speaks speak VBZ 40436 4832 8 of of IN 40436 4832 9 the the DT 40436 4832 10 chastising chastise VBG 40436 4832 11 purpose purpose NN 40436 4832 12 often often RB 40436 4832 13 contemplated contemplate VBN 40436 4832 14 by by IN 40436 4832 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4832 16 in in IN 40436 4832 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4832 18 conversation--[Greek conversation--[greek CD 40436 4832 19 : : : 40436 4832 20 a)\ a)\ NNP 40436 4832 21 e)kei e)kei NNPS 40436 4832 22 = = NFP 40436 4832 23 nos nos NNP 40436 4832 24 kolastêri kolastêri NNP 40436 4832 25 / / SYM 40436 4832 26 ou ou NNP 40436 4832 27 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 4832 28 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 4832 29 pa pa NNP 40436 4832 30 / / SYM 40436 4832 31 nt nt RB 40436 4832 32 ' ' '' 40436 4832 33 oi)ome oi)ome NNP 40436 4832 34 / / SYM 40436 4832 35 nous nous JJ 40436 4832 36 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 4832 37 / / SYM 40436 4832 38 nai nai NNP 40436 4832 39 e)rôtô e)rôtô NNP 40436 4832 40 = = SYM 40436 4832 41 n n NNP 40436 4832 42 ê)/legchen ê)/legchen NNP 40436 4832 43 . . . 40436 4832 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4832 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4833 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4833 2 Side side NN 40436 4833 3 - - HYPH 40436 4833 4 note note NN 40436 4833 5 : : : 40436 4833 6 Value value NN 40436 4833 7 of of IN 40436 4833 8 the the DT 40436 4833 9 first first JJ 40436 4833 10 conversation conversation NN 40436 4833 11 between between IN 40436 4833 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4833 13 and and CC 40436 4833 14 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4833 15 , , , 40436 4833 16 as as IN 40436 4833 17 an an DT 40436 4833 18 illustration illustration NN 40436 4833 19 of of IN 40436 4833 20 the the DT 40436 4833 21 Platonico Platonico NNP 40436 4833 22 - - HYPH 40436 4833 23 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 4833 24 manner manner NN 40436 4833 25 . . . 40436 4833 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4834 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4834 2 have have VBP 40436 4834 3 given give VBN 40436 4834 4 at at IN 40436 4834 5 length length NN 40436 4834 6 , , , 40436 4834 7 and and CC 40436 4834 8 almost almost RB 40436 4834 9 literally literally RB 40436 4834 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4834 11 with with IN 40436 4834 12 some some DT 40436 4834 13 few few JJ 40436 4834 14 abbreviations abbreviation NNS 40436 4834 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4834 16 , , , 40436 4834 17 this this DT 40436 4834 18 first first JJ 40436 4834 19 conversation conversation NN 40436 4834 20 between between IN 40436 4834 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4834 22 and and CC 40436 4834 23 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4834 24 , , , 40436 4834 25 because because IN 40436 4834 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4834 27 is be VBZ 40436 4834 28 a a DT 40436 4834 29 very very RB 40436 4834 30 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 4834 31 passage passage NN 40436 4834 32 , , , 40436 4834 33 exhibiting exhibit VBG 40436 4834 34 conspicuously conspicuously RB 40436 4834 35 several several JJ 40436 4834 36 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 4834 37 features feature NNS 40436 4834 38 of of IN 40436 4834 39 the the DT 40436 4834 40 Platonico Platonico NNP 40436 4834 41 - - HYPH 40436 4834 42 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 4834 43 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 4834 44 . . . 40436 4835 1 Facts fact NNS 40436 4835 2 common common JJ 40436 4835 3 and and CC 40436 4835 4 familiar familiar JJ 40436 4835 5 are be VBP 40436 4835 6 placed place VBN 40436 4835 7 in in IN 40436 4835 8 a a DT 40436 4835 9 novel novel JJ 40436 4835 10 point point NN 40436 4835 11 of of IN 40436 4835 12 view view NN 40436 4835 13 , , , 40436 4835 14 ingeniously ingeniously RB 40436 4835 15 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 4835 16 , , , 40436 4835 17 and and CC 40436 4835 18 introduced introduce VBN 40436 4835 19 as as IN 40436 4835 20 stepping stepping JJ 40436 4835 21 - - : 40436 4835 22 stones stone NNS 40436 4835 23 to to IN 40436 4835 24 a a DT 40436 4835 25 very very RB 40436 4835 26 wide wide JJ 40436 4835 27 generality generality NN 40436 4835 28 . . . 40436 4836 1 Wisdom wisdom NN 40436 4836 2 or or CC 40436 4836 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4836 4 is be VBZ 40436 4836 5 exalted exalt VBN 40436 4836 6 into into IN 40436 4836 7 the the DT 40436 4836 8 ruling rule VBG 40436 4836 9 force force NN 40436 4836 10 with with IN 40436 4836 11 liberty liberty NN 40436 4836 12 of of IN 40436 4836 13 action action NN 40436 4836 14 not not RB 40436 4836 15 admissible admissible JJ 40436 4836 16 except except IN 40436 4836 17 under under IN 40436 4836 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4836 19 guidance guidance NN 40436 4836 20 : : : 40436 4836 21 the the DT 40436 4836 22 questions question NNS 40436 4836 23 are be VBP 40436 4836 24 put put VBN 40436 4836 25 in in IN 40436 4836 26 an an DT 40436 4836 27 inverted invert VBN 40436 4836 28 half half JJ 40436 4836 29 - - HYPH 40436 4836 30 ironical ironical JJ 40436 4836 31 tone tone NN 40436 4836 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4836 33 not not RB 40436 4836 34 uncommon uncommon JJ 40436 4836 35 with with IN 40436 4836 36 the the DT 40436 4836 37 historical historical JJ 40436 4836 38 Sokrates[9 sokrates[9 NN 40436 4836 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4836 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4836 41 , , , 40436 4836 42 as as IN 40436 4836 43 if if IN 40436 4836 44 an an DT 40436 4836 45 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 4836 46 answer answer NN 40436 4836 47 were be VBD 40436 4836 48 expected expect VBN 40436 4836 49 as as IN 40436 4836 50 a a DT 40436 4836 51 matter matter NN 40436 4836 52 of of IN 40436 4836 53 course course NN 40436 4836 54 , , , 40436 4836 55 while while IN 40436 4836 56 in in IN 40436 4836 57 truth truth NN 40436 4836 58 the the DT 40436 4836 59 answer answer NN 40436 4836 60 is be VBZ 40436 4836 61 sure sure JJ 40436 4836 62 to to TO 40436 4836 63 be be VB 40436 4836 64 negative negative JJ 40436 4836 65 : : : 40436 4836 66 lastly lastly RB 40436 4836 67 , , , 40436 4836 68 the the DT 40436 4836 69 purpose purpose NN 40436 4836 70 of of IN 40436 4836 71 checking check VBG 40436 4836 72 undue undue JJ 40436 4836 73 self self NN 40436 4836 74 - - HYPH 40436 4836 75 esteem esteem NN 40436 4836 76 is be VBZ 40436 4836 77 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 4836 78 . . . 40436 4837 1 The the DT 40436 4837 2 rest rest NN 40436 4837 3 of of IN 40436 4837 4 the the DT 40436 4837 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4837 6 , , , 40436 4837 7 which which WDT 40436 4837 8 contains contain VBZ 40436 4837 9 the the DT 40436 4837 10 main main JJ 40436 4837 11 substantive substantive JJ 40436 4837 12 question question NN 40436 4837 13 investigated investigate VBN 40436 4837 14 , , , 40436 4837 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4837 16 can can MD 40436 4837 17 report report VB 40436 4837 18 only only RB 40436 4837 19 in in IN 40436 4837 20 brief brief JJ 40436 4837 21 abridgment abridgment NN 40436 4837 22 , , , 40436 4837 23 with with IN 40436 4837 24 a a DT 40436 4837 25 few few JJ 40436 4837 26 remarks remark NNS 40436 4837 27 following follow VBG 40436 4837 28 . . . 40436 4838 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4838 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4838 3 9 9 CD 40436 4838 4 : : : 40436 4838 5 See see VB 40436 4838 6 the the DT 40436 4838 7 conversation conversation NN 40436 4838 8 of of IN 40436 4838 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4838 10 with with IN 40436 4838 11 Glaukon Glaukon NNP 40436 4838 12 in in IN 40436 4838 13 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 4838 14 , , , 40436 4838 15 Memor Memor NNP 40436 4838 16 . . . 40436 4839 1 iii iii NNP 40436 4839 2 . . . 40436 4840 1 6 6 LS 40436 4840 2 ; ; : 40436 4840 3 also also RB 40436 4840 4 the the DT 40436 4840 5 conversation conversation NN 40436 4840 6 with with IN 40436 4840 7 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 4840 8 , , , 40436 4840 9 iii iii CD 40436 4840 10 . . . 40436 4841 1 5 5 CD 40436 4841 2 , , , 40436 4841 3 23 23 CD 40436 4841 4 - - SYM 40436 4841 5 24 24 CD 40436 4841 6 . . . 40436 4841 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4842 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4842 2 Side side NN 40436 4842 3 - - HYPH 40436 4842 4 note note NN 40436 4842 5 : : : 40436 4842 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4842 7 begins begin VBZ 40436 4842 8 to to TO 40436 4842 9 examine examine VB 40436 4842 10 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4842 11 respecting respecting NN 40436 4842 12 friendship friendship NN 40436 4842 13 . . . 40436 4843 1 Who who WP 40436 4843 2 is be VBZ 40436 4843 3 to to TO 40436 4843 4 be be VB 40436 4843 5 called call VBN 40436 4843 6 a a DT 40436 4843 7 friend friend NN 40436 4843 8 ? ? . 40436 4844 1 Halt halt VB 40436 4844 2 in in IN 40436 4844 3 the the DT 40436 4844 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4844 5 . . . 40436 4844 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4845 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4845 2 begins begin VBZ 40436 4845 3 , , , 40436 4845 4 as as IN 40436 4845 5 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4845 6 requests request NNS 40436 4845 7 , , , 40436 4845 8 to to TO 40436 4845 9 interrogate interrogate VB 40436 4845 10 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4845 11 -- -- : 40436 4845 12 first first RB 40436 4845 13 premising premising NN 40436 4845 14 -- -- : 40436 4845 15 Different different JJ 40436 4845 16 men man NNS 40436 4845 17 have have VBP 40436 4845 18 different different JJ 40436 4845 19 tastes taste NNS 40436 4845 20 : : : 40436 4845 21 some some DT 40436 4845 22 love love NN 40436 4845 23 horses horse NNS 40436 4845 24 and and CC 40436 4845 25 dogs dog NNS 40436 4845 26 , , , 40436 4845 27 others other NNS 40436 4845 28 wealth wealth NN 40436 4845 29 or or CC 40436 4845 30 honours honour NNS 40436 4845 31 . . . 40436 4846 1 For for IN 40436 4846 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4846 3 part part NN 40436 4846 4 , , , 40436 4846 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4846 6 care care VBP 40436 4846 7 little little JJ 40436 4846 8 about about IN 40436 4846 9 all all DT 40436 4846 10 such such JJ 40436 4846 11 acquisitions acquisition NNS 40436 4846 12 : : : 40436 4846 13 but but CC 40436 4846 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4846 15 ardently ardently RB 40436 4846 16 desire desire VBP 40436 4846 17 to to TO 40436 4846 18 possess possess VB 40436 4846 19 friends friend NNS 40436 4846 20 , , , 40436 4846 21 and and CC 40436 4846 22 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4846 23 would would MD 40436 4846 24 rather rather RB 40436 4846 25 have have VB 40436 4846 26 a a DT 40436 4846 27 good good JJ 40436 4846 28 friend friend NN 40436 4846 29 than than IN 40436 4846 30 all all PDT 40436 4846 31 the the DT 40436 4846 32 treasures treasure NNS 40436 4846 33 of of IN 40436 4846 34 Persia Persia NNP 40436 4846 35 . . . 40436 4847 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4847 2 two two CD 40436 4847 3 , , , 40436 4847 4 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4847 5 and and CC 40436 4847 6 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4847 7 , , , 40436 4847 8 are be VBP 40436 4847 9 much much JJ 40436 4847 10 to to TO 40436 4847 11 be be VB 40436 4847 12 envied envy VBN 40436 4847 13 , , , 40436 4847 14 because because IN 40436 4847 15 at at IN 40436 4847 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4847 17 early early JJ 40436 4847 18 age age NN 40436 4847 19 , , , 40436 4847 20 each each DT 40436 4847 21 of of IN 40436 4847 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4847 23 has have VBZ 40436 4847 24 made make VBN 40436 4847 25 an an DT 40436 4847 26 attached attach VBN 40436 4847 27 friend friend NN 40436 4847 28 of of IN 40436 4847 29 the the DT 40436 4847 30 other other JJ 40436 4847 31 . . . 40436 4848 1 But but CC 40436 4848 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4848 3 am be VBP 40436 4848 4 so so RB 40436 4848 5 far far RB 40436 4848 6 from from IN 40436 4848 7 any any DT 40436 4848 8 such such JJ 40436 4848 9 good good JJ 40436 4848 10 fortune fortune NN 40436 4848 11 , , , 40436 4848 12 that that IN 40436 4848 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4848 14 do do VBP 40436 4848 15 not not RB 40436 4848 16 even even RB 40436 4848 17 know know VB 40436 4848 18 how how WRB 40436 4848 19 any any DT 40436 4848 20 man man NN 40436 4848 21 becomes become VBZ 40436 4848 22 the the DT 40436 4848 23 friend friend NN 40436 4848 24 of of IN 40436 4848 25 another another DT 40436 4848 26 . . . 40436 4849 1 This this DT 40436 4849 2 is be VBZ 40436 4849 3 what what WP 40436 4849 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4849 5 want want VBP 40436 4849 6 to to TO 40436 4849 7 ask ask VB 40436 4849 8 from from IN 40436 4849 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4849 10 , , , 40436 4849 11 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4849 12 , , , 40436 4849 13 as as IN 40436 4849 14 one one CD 40436 4849 15 who who WP 40436 4849 16 must must MD 40436 4849 17 know,[10 know,[10 CD 40436 4849 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4849 19 having have VBG 40436 4849 20 acquired acquire VBN 40436 4849 21 such such PDT 40436 4849 22 a a DT 40436 4849 23 friend friend NN 40436 4849 24 already already RB 40436 4849 25 . . . 40436 4850 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4850 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4850 3 10 10 CD 40436 4850 4 : : : 40436 4850 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4850 6 , , , 40436 4850 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4850 8 , , , 40436 4850 9 211 211 CD 40436 4850 10 - - SYM 40436 4850 11 212 212 CD 40436 4850 12 . . . 40436 4850 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4851 1 When when WRB 40436 4851 2 one one CD 40436 4851 3 man man NN 40436 4851 4 loves love VBZ 40436 4851 5 another another DT 40436 4851 6 , , , 40436 4851 7 which which WDT 40436 4851 8 becomes become VBZ 40436 4851 9 the the DT 40436 4851 10 friend friend NN 40436 4851 11 of of IN 40436 4851 12 which which WDT 40436 4851 13 ? ? . 40436 4852 1 Does do VBZ 40436 4852 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4852 3 who who WP 40436 4852 4 loves love VBZ 40436 4852 5 , , , 40436 4852 6 become become VB 40436 4852 7 the the DT 40436 4852 8 friend friend NN 40436 4852 9 of of IN 40436 4852 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4852 11 whom whom WP 40436 4852 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4852 13 loves love VBZ 40436 4852 14 , , , 40436 4852 15 whether whether IN 40436 4852 16 the the DT 40436 4852 17 latter latter JJ 40436 4852 18 returns return VBZ 40436 4852 19 the the DT 40436 4852 20 affection affection NN 40436 4852 21 or or CC 40436 4852 22 not not RB 40436 4852 23 ? ? . 40436 4853 1 Or or CC 40436 4853 2 is be VBZ 40436 4853 3 the the DT 40436 4853 4 person person NN 40436 4853 5 loved love VBN 40436 4853 6 , , , 40436 4853 7 whatever whatever WDT 40436 4853 8 be be VB 40436 4853 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4853 10 own own JJ 40436 4853 11 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 4853 12 , , , 40436 4853 13 the the DT 40436 4853 14 friend friend NN 40436 4853 15 of of IN 40436 4853 16 the the DT 40436 4853 17 person person NN 40436 4853 18 who who WP 40436 4853 19 loves love VBZ 40436 4853 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4853 21 ? ? . 40436 4854 1 Or or CC 40436 4854 2 is be VBZ 40436 4854 3 reciprocity reciprocity NN 40436 4854 4 of of IN 40436 4854 5 affection affection NN 40436 4854 6 necessary necessary JJ 40436 4854 7 , , , 40436 4854 8 in in IN 40436 4854 9 order order NN 40436 4854 10 that that IN 40436 4854 11 either either DT 40436 4854 12 shall shall MD 40436 4854 13 be be VB 40436 4854 14 the the DT 40436 4854 15 friend friend NN 40436 4854 16 of of IN 40436 4854 17 the the DT 40436 4854 18 other other JJ 40436 4854 19 ? ? . 40436 4855 1 The the DT 40436 4855 2 speakers speaker NNS 40436 4855 3 can can MD 40436 4855 4 not not RB 40436 4855 5 satisfy satisfy VB 40436 4855 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 4855 7 that that IN 40436 4855 8 the the DT 40436 4855 9 title title NN 40436 4855 10 of of IN 40436 4855 11 _ _ NNP 40436 4855 12 friend friend NN 40436 4855 13 _ _ NNP 40436 4855 14 fits fit VBZ 40436 4855 15 either either DT 40436 4855 16 of of IN 40436 4855 17 the the DT 40436 4855 18 three three CD 40436 4855 19 cases;[11 cases;[11 NNP 40436 4855 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4855 21 so so IN 40436 4855 22 that that IN 40436 4855 23 this this DT 40436 4855 24 line line NN 40436 4855 25 of of IN 40436 4855 26 interrogating interrogate VBG 40436 4855 27 comes come VBZ 40436 4855 28 to to IN 40436 4855 29 a a DT 40436 4855 30 dead dead JJ 40436 4855 31 lock lock NN 40436 4855 32 . . . 40436 4856 1 Menexenus menexenus NN 40436 4856 2 avows avow VBZ 40436 4856 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4856 4 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 4856 5 , , , 40436 4856 6 while while IN 40436 4856 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4856 8 expresses express VBZ 40436 4856 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4856 10 more more RBR 40436 4856 11 hopefully hopefully RB 40436 4856 12 . . . 40436 4857 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4857 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4857 3 11 11 CD 40436 4857 4 : : : 40436 4857 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4857 6 , , , 40436 4857 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4857 8 , , , 40436 4857 9 212 212 CD 40436 4857 10 - - SYM 40436 4857 11 213 213 CD 40436 4857 12 . . . 40436 4858 1 213 213 CD 40436 4858 2 C:--[Greek c:--[greek NN 40436 4858 3 : : : 40436 4858 4 ei ei NNP 40436 4858 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4858 6 mê mê NNP 40436 4858 7 / / SYM 40436 4858 8 te te NNP 40436 4858 9 oi oi NNP 40436 4858 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4858 11 philou philou NNP 40436 4858 12 = = SYM 40436 4858 13 ntes ntes NNP 40436 4858 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4858 15 1 1 LS 40436 4858 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4858 17 phi phi NNP 40436 4858 18 / / SYM 40436 4858 19 loi loi NNP 40436 4858 20 e)/sontai e)/sontai NNP 40436 4858 21 , , , 40436 4858 22 mê mê NNP 40436 4858 23 / / SYM 40436 4858 24 th th NNP 40436 4858 25 ' ' `` 40436 4858 26 oi oi NNP 40436 4858 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4858 28 philou philou NNP 40436 4858 29 / / SYM 40436 4858 30 menoi menoi NNP 40436 4858 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4858 32 2 2 CD 40436 4858 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4858 34 , , , 40436 4858 35 mê mê NNP 40436 4858 36 / / SYM 40436 4858 37 th th NNP 40436 4858 38 ' ' `` 40436 4858 39 oi oi NNP 40436 4858 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4858 41 philou philou NNP 40436 4858 42 = = SYM 40436 4858 43 nte nte NNP 40436 4858 44 / / SYM 40436 4858 45 s s NNP 40436 4858 46 te te NNP 40436 4858 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4858 48 philou philou NNP 40436 4858 49 / / SYM 40436 4858 50 menoi menoi NNP 40436 4858 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4858 52 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4858 53 3 3 CD 40436 4858 54 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4858 55 , , , 40436 4858 56 & & CC 40436 4858 57 c. c. NNP 40436 4858 58 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4858 59 here here RB 40436 4858 60 professes profess VBZ 40436 4858 61 to to TO 40436 4858 62 have have VB 40436 4858 63 shown show VBN 40436 4858 64 grounds ground NNS 40436 4858 65 for for IN 40436 4858 66 rejecting reject VBG 40436 4858 67 all all PDT 40436 4858 68 these these DT 40436 4858 69 three three CD 40436 4858 70 suppositions supposition NNS 40436 4858 71 . . . 40436 4859 1 But but CC 40436 4859 2 if if IN 40436 4859 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4859 4 follow follow VBP 40436 4859 5 the the DT 40436 4859 6 preceding precede VBG 40436 4859 7 argument argument NN 40436 4859 8 , , , 40436 4859 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4859 10 shall shall MD 40436 4859 11 see see VB 40436 4859 12 that that IN 40436 4859 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4859 14 has have VBZ 40436 4859 15 shown show VBN 40436 4859 16 grounds ground NNS 40436 4859 17 only only RB 40436 4859 18 against against IN 40436 4859 19 the the DT 40436 4859 20 first first JJ 40436 4859 21 two two CD 40436 4859 22 , , , 40436 4859 23 not not RB 40436 4859 24 against against IN 40436 4859 25 the the DT 40436 4859 26 third third JJ 40436 4859 27 . . . 40436 4859 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4860 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4860 2 Side side NN 40436 4860 3 - - HYPH 40436 4860 4 note note NN 40436 4860 5 : : : 40436 4860 6 Questions question NNS 40436 4860 7 addressed address VBD 40436 4860 8 to to IN 40436 4860 9 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4860 10 . . . 40436 4861 1 Appeal appeal VB 40436 4861 2 to to IN 40436 4861 3 the the DT 40436 4861 4 maxims maxim NNS 40436 4861 5 of of IN 40436 4861 6 the the DT 40436 4861 7 poets poet NNS 40436 4861 8 . . . 40436 4862 1 Like like UH 40436 4862 2 is be VBZ 40436 4862 3 the the DT 40436 4862 4 friend friend NN 40436 4862 5 of of IN 40436 4862 6 like like UH 40436 4862 7 . . . 40436 4863 1 Canvassed canvass VBN 40436 4863 2 and and CC 40436 4863 3 rejected reject VBN 40436 4863 4 . . . 40436 4863 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4864 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4864 2 now now RB 40436 4864 3 takes take VBZ 40436 4864 4 up up RP 40436 4864 5 a a DT 40436 4864 6 different different JJ 40436 4864 7 aspect aspect NN 40436 4864 8 of of IN 40436 4864 9 the the DT 40436 4864 10 question question NN 40436 4864 11 , , , 40436 4864 12 and and CC 40436 4864 13 turns turn VBZ 40436 4864 14 to to IN 40436 4864 15 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4864 16 , , , 40436 4864 17 inviting invite VBG 40436 4864 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4864 19 to to TO 40436 4864 20 consider consider VB 40436 4864 21 what what WP 40436 4864 22 has have VBZ 40436 4864 23 been be VBN 40436 4864 24 laid lay VBN 40436 4864 25 down down RP 40436 4864 26 by by IN 40436 4864 27 the the DT 40436 4864 28 poets poet NNS 40436 4864 29 , , , 40436 4864 30 " " `` 40436 4864 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4864 32 fathers father NNS 40436 4864 33 and and CC 40436 4864 34 guides guide NNS 40436 4864 35 in in IN 40436 4864 36 respect respect NN 40436 4864 37 of of IN 40436 4864 38 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 4864 39 " " '' 40436 4864 40 . . . 40436 4865 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4865 2 12 12 CD 40436 4865 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4865 4 Homer Homer NNP 40436 4865 5 says say VBZ 40436 4865 6 that that IN 40436 4865 7 the the DT 40436 4865 8 Gods god NNS 40436 4865 9 originate originate VBP 40436 4865 10 friendship friendship NN 40436 4865 11 , , , 40436 4865 12 by by IN 40436 4865 13 bringing bring VBG 40436 4865 14 the the DT 40436 4865 15 like like JJ 40436 4865 16 man man NN 40436 4865 17 to to IN 40436 4865 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4865 19 like like NN 40436 4865 20 : : : 40436 4865 21 Empedokles empedokle NNS 40436 4865 22 and and CC 40436 4865 23 other other JJ 40436 4865 24 physical physical JJ 40436 4865 25 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 4865 26 have have VBP 40436 4865 27 also also RB 40436 4865 28 asserted assert VBN 40436 4865 29 , , , 40436 4865 30 that that IN 40436 4865 31 like like UH 40436 4865 32 must must MD 40436 4865 33 always always RB 40436 4865 34 and and CC 40436 4865 35 of of IN 40436 4865 36 necessity necessity NN 40436 4865 37 be be VB 40436 4865 38 the the DT 40436 4865 39 friend friend NN 40436 4865 40 of of IN 40436 4865 41 like like UH 40436 4865 42 . . . 40436 4866 1 These these DT 40436 4866 2 wise wise JJ 40436 4866 3 teachers teacher NNS 40436 4866 4 can can MD 40436 4866 5 not not RB 40436 4866 6 mean mean VB 40436 4866 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4866 8 continues continue VBZ 40436 4866 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4866 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4866 11 that that IN 40436 4866 12 bad bad JJ 40436 4866 13 men man NNS 40436 4866 14 are be VBP 40436 4866 15 friends friend NNS 40436 4866 16 of of IN 40436 4866 17 each each DT 40436 4866 18 other other JJ 40436 4866 19 . . . 40436 4867 1 The the DT 40436 4867 2 bad bad JJ 40436 4867 3 man man NN 40436 4867 4 can can MD 40436 4867 5 be be VB 40436 4867 6 no no DT 40436 4867 7 one one NN 40436 4867 8 's 's POS 40436 4867 9 friend friend NN 40436 4867 10 . . . 40436 4868 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4868 2 is be VBZ 40436 4868 3 not not RB 40436 4868 4 even even RB 40436 4868 5 like like IN 40436 4868 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4868 7 , , , 40436 4868 8 but but CC 40436 4868 9 ever ever RB 40436 4868 10 wayward wayward JJ 40436 4868 11 and and CC 40436 4868 12 insane:--much insane:--much CD 40436 4868 13 less less JJR 40436 4868 14 can can MD 40436 4868 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4868 16 be be VB 40436 4868 17 like like IN 40436 4868 18 to to IN 40436 4868 19 any any DT 40436 4868 20 one one NN 40436 4868 21 else else RB 40436 4868 22 , , , 40436 4868 23 even even RB 40436 4868 24 to to IN 40436 4868 25 another another DT 40436 4868 26 bad bad JJ 40436 4868 27 man man NN 40436 4868 28 . . . 40436 4869 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 4869 2 mean mean VBP 40436 4869 3 that that IN 40436 4869 4 the the DT 40436 4869 5 good good NN 40436 4869 6 alone alone RB 40436 4869 7 are be VBP 40436 4869 8 like like IN 40436 4869 9 to to IN 40436 4869 10 each each DT 40436 4869 11 other other JJ 40436 4869 12 , , , 40436 4869 13 and and CC 40436 4869 14 friends friend NNS 40436 4869 15 to to IN 40436 4869 16 each each DT 40436 4869 17 other other JJ 40436 4869 18 . . . 40436 4870 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4870 2 13 13 CD 40436 4870 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4870 4 But but CC 40436 4870 5 is be VBZ 40436 4870 6 this this DT 40436 4870 7 true true JJ 40436 4870 8 ? ? . 40436 4871 1 What what WP 40436 4871 2 good good JJ 40436 4871 3 , , , 40436 4871 4 or or CC 40436 4871 5 what what WDT 40436 4871 6 harm harm NN 40436 4871 7 , , , 40436 4871 8 can can MD 40436 4871 9 like like VB 40436 4871 10 do do VB 40436 4871 11 to to TO 40436 4871 12 like like VB 40436 4871 13 , , , 40436 4871 14 which which WDT 40436 4871 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4871 16 does do VBZ 40436 4871 17 not not RB 40436 4871 18 also also RB 40436 4871 19 do do VB 40436 4871 20 to to IN 40436 4871 21 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4871 22 ? ? . 40436 4872 1 How how WRB 40436 4872 2 can can MD 40436 4872 3 there there EX 40436 4872 4 be be VB 40436 4872 5 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 4872 6 love love NN 40436 4872 7 between between IN 40436 4872 8 parties party NNS 40436 4872 9 who who WP 40436 4872 10 render render VBP 40436 4872 11 to to IN 40436 4872 12 each each DT 40436 4872 13 other other JJ 40436 4872 14 no no DT 40436 4872 15 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 4872 16 aid aid NN 40436 4872 17 ? ? . 40436 4873 1 Is be VBZ 40436 4873 2 not not RB 40436 4873 3 the the DT 40436 4873 4 good good JJ 40436 4873 5 man man NN 40436 4873 6 , , , 40436 4873 7 so so RB 40436 4873 8 far far RB 40436 4873 9 forth forth RB 40436 4873 10 as as IN 40436 4873 11 good good JJ 40436 4873 12 , , , 40436 4873 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 4873 14 to to IN 40436 4873 15 himself,--standing himself,--stande VBG 40436 4873 16 in in IN 40436 4873 17 need need NN 40436 4873 18 of of IN 40436 4873 19 no no DT 40436 4873 20 one one NN 40436 4873 21 -- -- : 40436 4873 22 and and CC 40436 4873 23 therefore therefore RB 40436 4873 24 loving love VBG 40436 4873 25 no no DT 40436 4873 26 one one NN 40436 4873 27 ? ? . 40436 4874 1 How how WRB 40436 4874 2 can can MD 40436 4874 3 good good JJ 40436 4874 4 men man NNS 40436 4874 5 care care VB 40436 4874 6 much much JJ 40436 4874 7 for for IN 40436 4874 8 each each DT 40436 4874 9 other other JJ 40436 4874 10 , , , 40436 4874 11 seeing see VBG 40436 4874 12 that that IN 40436 4874 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4874 14 thus thus RB 40436 4874 15 neither neither CC 40436 4874 16 regret regret VBP 40436 4874 17 each each DT 40436 4874 18 other other JJ 40436 4874 19 when when WRB 40436 4874 20 absent absent JJ 40436 4874 21 , , , 40436 4874 22 nor nor CC 40436 4874 23 have have VBP 40436 4874 24 need need NN 40436 4874 25 of of IN 40436 4874 26 each each DT 40436 4874 27 other other JJ 40436 4874 28 when when WRB 40436 4874 29 present present JJ 40436 4874 30 ? ? . 40436 4875 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4875 2 14 14 CD 40436 4875 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4875 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4875 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4875 6 12 12 CD 40436 4875 7 : : : 40436 4875 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4875 9 , , , 40436 4875 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4875 11 , , , 40436 4875 12 213 213 CD 40436 4875 13 E e NN 40436 4875 14 : : : 40436 4875 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4875 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4875 17 : : : 40436 4875 18 skopou skopou NNP 40436 4875 19 = = SYM 40436 4875 20 nta nta NNP 40436 4875 21 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 4875 22 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 4875 23 poiêta poiêta NN 40436 4875 24 / / SYM 40436 4875 25 s s NN 40436 4875 26 ; ; : 40436 4875 27 ou(=toi ou(=toi . 40436 4875 28 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4875 29 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 4875 30 = = SYM 40436 4875 31 n n CC 40436 4875 32 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 4875 33 pate pate NN 40436 4875 34 / / , 40436 4875 35 res res NNP 40436 4875 36 tê tê NNP 40436 4875 37 = = SYM 40436 4875 38 s s NNP 40436 4875 39 sophi sophi NNP 40436 4875 40 / / , 40436 4875 41 as as IN 40436 4875 42 ei)si\ ei)si\ NNP 40436 4875 43 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4875 44 ê(gemo ê(gemo NNP 40436 4875 45 / / SYM 40436 4875 46 nes nes NNP 40436 4875 47 . . . 40436 4875 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4875 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4876 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4876 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4876 3 13 13 CD 40436 4876 4 : : : 40436 4876 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4876 6 , , , 40436 4876 7 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4876 8 , , , 40436 4876 9 214 214 CD 40436 4876 10 . . . 40436 4876 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4877 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4877 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4877 3 14 14 CD 40436 4877 4 : : : 40436 4877 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4877 6 , , , 40436 4877 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4877 8 215 215 CD 40436 4877 9 B b NN 40436 4877 10 : : : 40436 4877 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4877 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4877 13 : : : 40436 4877 14 O o NN 40436 4877 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4877 16 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4877 17 mê/ mê/ NNP 40436 4877 18 tou tou NNP 40436 4877 19 deo deo NNP 40436 4877 20 / / SYM 40436 4877 21 menos menos NNP 40436 4877 22 , , , 40436 4877 23 ou)de/ ou)de/ NNP 40436 4877 24 ti ti IN 40436 4877 25 a)gapô/| a)gapô/| JJ 40436 4877 26 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 4877 27 . . . 40436 4878 1 . . . 40436 4879 1 . . . 40436 4880 1 . . . 40436 4881 1 O(\ O(\ NNP 40436 4881 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4881 3 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 4881 4 a)gapô/|ê a)gapô/|ê NNP 40436 4881 5 , , , 40436 4881 6 ou)d ou)d JJ 40436 4881 7 ' ' '' 40436 4881 8 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 4881 9 philoi=. philoi=. ADD 40436 4882 1 . . . 40436 4883 1 . . . 40436 4884 1 . . . 40436 4885 1 Pô Pô NNP 40436 4885 2 = = SYM 40436 4885 3 s s NNP 40436 4885 4 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 4885 5 oi oi NNP 40436 4885 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4885 7 a)gathoi\ a)gathoi\ NNP 40436 4885 8 toi toi NNP 40436 4885 9 = = SYM 40436 4885 10 s s NNP 40436 4885 11 a)gathoi a)gathoi NNP 40436 4885 12 = = SYM 40436 4885 13 s s NNP 40436 4885 14 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 4885 15 = = SYM 40436 4885 16 n n CC 40436 4885 17 phi phi NN 40436 4885 18 / / SYM 40436 4885 19 loi loi NN 40436 4885 20 e)/sontai e)/sontai NNP 40436 4885 21 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 4885 22 a)rchê a)rchê NNP 40436 4885 23 / / SYM 40436 4885 24 n n CD 40436 4885 25 , , , 40436 4885 26 oi(\ oi(\ NNP 40436 4885 27 mê mê NNP 40436 4885 28 / / SYM 40436 4885 29 te te NNP 40436 4885 30 a(po a(po NNP 40436 4885 31 / / SYM 40436 4885 32 ntes ntes NNPS 40436 4885 33 potheinoi\ potheinoi\ NNP 40436 4885 34 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 4885 35 / / SYM 40436 4885 36 lois lois JJ 40436 4885 37 -- -- : 40436 4885 38 i(kanoi\ i(kanoi\ CD 40436 4885 39 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4885 40 e(autoi e(autoi NNP 40436 4885 41 = = SYM 40436 4885 42 s s NNP 40436 4885 43 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4885 44 chôri\s chôri\s XX 40436 4885 45 o)/ntes o)/ntes NNP 40436 4885 46 -- -- : 40436 4885 47 mê mê NNP 40436 4885 48 / / SYM 40436 4885 49 te te NNP 40436 4885 50 paro paro NNP 40436 4885 51 / / SYM 40436 4885 52 ntes ntes NNP 40436 4885 53 chrei chrei NNP 40436 4885 54 / / NFP 40436 4885 55 an an DT 40436 4885 56 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 4885 57 = = SYM 40436 4885 58 n n NN 40436 4885 59 e)/chousi e)/chousi NNP 40436 4885 60 ? ? . 40436 4886 1 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 4886 2 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4886 3 toiou toiou NN 40436 4886 4 / / SYM 40436 4886 5 tous tous JJ 40436 4886 6 ti ti NNP 40436 4886 7 / / SYM 40436 4886 8 s s NNP 40436 4886 9 mêchanê\ mêchanê\ NNP 40436 4886 10 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 4886 11 pollou= pollou= NNP 40436 4886 12 poiei poiei NN 40436 4886 13 = = SYM 40436 4886 14 sthai sthai NNP 40436 4886 15 a)llêlous a)llêlous JJ 40436 4886 16 ? ? . 40436 4886 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4886 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4887 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4887 2 Side side NN 40436 4887 3 - - HYPH 40436 4887 4 note note NN 40436 4887 5 : : : 40436 4887 6 Other other JJ 40436 4887 7 poets poet NNS 40436 4887 8 declare declare VBP 40436 4887 9 that that IN 40436 4887 10 likeness likeness NN 40436 4887 11 is be VBZ 40436 4887 12 a a DT 40436 4887 13 cause cause NN 40436 4887 14 of of IN 40436 4887 15 aversion aversion NN 40436 4887 16 ; ; , 40436 4887 17 unlikeness unlikeness NN 40436 4887 18 , , , 40436 4887 19 of of IN 40436 4887 20 friendship friendship NN 40436 4887 21 . . . 40436 4888 1 Reasons Reasons NNP 40436 4888 2 _ _ NNP 40436 4888 3 pro pro JJ 40436 4888 4 _ _ NNP 40436 4888 5 and and CC 40436 4888 6 _ _ NNP 40436 4888 7 con con XX 40436 4888 8 _ _ NNP 40436 4888 9 . . . 40436 4889 1 Rejected reject VBN 40436 4889 2 . . . 40436 4889 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4890 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4890 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 4890 3 , , , 40436 4890 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 4890 5 , , , 40436 4890 6 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4890 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4890 8 continues continue VBZ 40436 4890 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4890 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4890 11 , , , 40436 4890 12 that that IN 40436 4890 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4890 14 are be VBP 40436 4890 15 travelling travel VBG 40436 4890 16 in in IN 40436 4890 17 the the DT 40436 4890 18 wrong wrong JJ 40436 4890 19 road road NN 40436 4890 20 , , , 40436 4890 21 and and CC 40436 4890 22 must must MD 40436 4890 23 try try VB 40436 4890 24 another another DT 40436 4890 25 direction direction NN 40436 4890 26 . . . 40436 4891 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4891 2 now now RB 40436 4891 3 remember remember VBP 40436 4891 4 to to TO 40436 4891 5 have have VB 40436 4891 6 recently recently RB 40436 4891 7 heard hear VBN 40436 4891 8 some some DT 40436 4891 9 one one CD 40436 4891 10 affirming affirming NN 40436 4891 11 -- -- : 40436 4891 12 contrary contrary JJ 40436 4891 13 to to IN 40436 4891 14 what what WP 40436 4891 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4891 16 have have VBP 40436 4891 17 just just RB 40436 4891 18 said say VBN 40436 4891 19 -- -- : 40436 4891 20 that that IN 40436 4891 21 likeness likeness NN 40436 4891 22 is be VBZ 40436 4891 23 a a DT 40436 4891 24 cause cause NN 40436 4891 25 of of IN 40436 4891 26 aversion aversion NN 40436 4891 27 , , , 40436 4891 28 and and CC 40436 4891 29 * * NFP 40436 4891 30 * * NFP 40436 4891 31 unlikeness unlikeness VBP 40436 4891 32 a a DT 40436 4891 33 cause cause NN 40436 4891 34 of of IN 40436 4891 35 friendship friendship NN 40436 4891 36 . . . 40436 4892 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4892 2 too too RB 40436 4892 3 produced produce VBD 40436 4892 4 evidence evidence NN 40436 4892 5 from from IN 40436 4892 6 the the DT 40436 4892 7 poets poet NNS 40436 4892 8 : : : 40436 4892 9 for for IN 40436 4892 10 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 40436 4892 11 tells tell VBZ 40436 4892 12 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4892 13 , , , 40436 4892 14 that that IN 40436 4892 15 " " `` 40436 4892 16 potter potter NN 40436 4892 17 is be VBZ 40436 4892 18 jealous jealous JJ 40436 4892 19 of of IN 40436 4892 20 potter potter NN 40436 4892 21 , , , 40436 4892 22 and and CC 40436 4892 23 bard bard NNP 40436 4892 24 of of IN 40436 4892 25 bard bard NNP 40436 4892 26 " " '' 40436 4892 27 . . . 40436 4893 1 Things thing NNS 40436 4893 2 most most RBS 40436 4893 3 alike alike RB 40436 4893 4 are be VBP 40436 4893 5 most most RBS 40436 4893 6 full full JJ 40436 4893 7 of of IN 40436 4893 8 envy envy NN 40436 4893 9 , , , 40436 4893 10 jealousy jealousy NN 40436 4893 11 and and CC 40436 4893 12 hatred hatred NN 40436 4893 13 to to IN 40436 4893 14 each each DT 40436 4893 15 other other JJ 40436 4893 16 : : : 40436 4893 17 things thing NNS 40436 4893 18 most most RBS 40436 4893 19 unlike unlike RB 40436 4893 20 , , , 40436 4893 21 are be VBP 40436 4893 22 most most RBS 40436 4893 23 full full JJ 40436 4893 24 of of IN 40436 4893 25 friendship friendship NN 40436 4893 26 . . . 40436 4894 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4894 2 the the DT 40436 4894 3 poor poor JJ 40436 4894 4 man man NN 40436 4894 5 is be VBZ 40436 4894 6 of of IN 40436 4894 7 necessity necessity NN 40436 4894 8 a a DT 40436 4894 9 friend friend NN 40436 4894 10 to to IN 40436 4894 11 the the DT 40436 4894 12 rich rich JJ 40436 4894 13 , , , 40436 4894 14 the the DT 40436 4894 15 weak weak JJ 40436 4894 16 man man NN 40436 4894 17 to to IN 40436 4894 18 the the DT 40436 4894 19 strong strong JJ 40436 4894 20 , , , 40436 4894 21 for for IN 40436 4894 22 the the DT 40436 4894 23 sake sake NN 40436 4894 24 of of IN 40436 4894 25 protection protection NN 40436 4894 26 : : : 40436 4894 27 the the DT 40436 4894 28 sick sick JJ 40436 4894 29 man man NN 40436 4894 30 , , , 40436 4894 31 for for IN 40436 4894 32 similar similar JJ 40436 4894 33 reason reason NN 40436 4894 34 , , , 40436 4894 35 to to IN 40436 4894 36 the the DT 40436 4894 37 physician physician NN 40436 4894 38 . . . 40436 4895 1 In in IN 40436 4895 2 general general JJ 40436 4895 3 , , , 40436 4895 4 every every DT 40436 4895 5 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 4895 6 man man NN 40436 4895 7 loves love VBZ 40436 4895 8 , , , 40436 4895 9 and and CC 40436 4895 10 is be VBZ 40436 4895 11 a a DT 40436 4895 12 friend friend NN 40436 4895 13 to to TO 40436 4895 14 , , , 40436 4895 15 the the DT 40436 4895 16 man man NN 40436 4895 17 of of IN 40436 4895 18 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 4895 19 . . . 40436 4896 1 Nay nay UH 40436 4896 2 , , , 40436 4896 3 there there EX 40436 4896 4 are be VBP 40436 4896 5 also also RB 40436 4896 6 physical physical JJ 40436 4896 7 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 4896 8 , , , 40436 4896 9 who who WP 40436 4896 10 assert assert VBP 40436 4896 11 that that IN 40436 4896 12 this this DT 40436 4896 13 principle principle NN 40436 4896 14 pervades pervade VBZ 40436 4896 15 all all DT 40436 4896 16 nature nature NN 40436 4896 17 ; ; : 40436 4896 18 that that DT 40436 4896 19 dry dry VBP 40436 4896 20 is be VBZ 40436 4896 21 the the DT 40436 4896 22 friend friend NN 40436 4896 23 of of IN 40436 4896 24 moist moist JJ 40436 4896 25 , , , 40436 4896 26 cold cold JJ 40436 4896 27 of of IN 40436 4896 28 hot hot JJ 40436 4896 29 , , , 40436 4896 30 and and CC 40436 4896 31 so so RB 40436 4896 32 forth forth RB 40436 4896 33 : : : 40436 4896 34 that that IN 40436 4896 35 all all DT 40436 4896 36 contraries contrary NNS 40436 4896 37 serve serve VBP 40436 4896 38 as as IN 40436 4896 39 nourishment nourishment NN 40436 4896 40 to to IN 40436 4896 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4896 42 contraries contrary NNS 40436 4896 43 . . . 40436 4897 1 These these DT 40436 4897 2 are be VBP 40436 4897 3 ingenious ingenious JJ 40436 4897 4 teachers teacher NNS 40436 4897 5 : : : 40436 4897 6 but but CC 40436 4897 7 if if IN 40436 4897 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4897 9 follow follow VBP 40436 4897 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4897 11 , , , 40436 4897 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4897 13 shall shall MD 40436 4897 14 have have VB 40436 4897 15 the the DT 40436 4897 16 cleverest clever JJS 40436 4897 17 disputants disputant NNS 40436 4897 18 attacking attack VBG 40436 4897 19 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4897 20 immediately immediately RB 40436 4897 21 , , , 40436 4897 22 and and CC 40436 4897 23 asking ask VBG 40436 4897 24 -- -- : 40436 4897 25 What what WP 40436 4897 26 ! ! . 40436 4898 1 is be VBZ 40436 4898 2 the the DT 40436 4898 3 opposite opposite JJ 40436 4898 4 essentially essentially RB 40436 4898 5 a a DT 40436 4898 6 friend friend NN 40436 4898 7 to to IN 40436 4898 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4898 9 opposite opposite NN 40436 4898 10 ? ? . 40436 4899 1 Do do VBP 40436 4899 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4899 3 mean mean VB 40436 4899 4 that that IN 40436 4899 5 unjust unjust JJ 40436 4899 6 is be VBZ 40436 4899 7 essentially essentially RB 40436 4899 8 the the DT 40436 4899 9 friend friend NN 40436 4899 10 of of IN 40436 4899 11 just just RB 40436 4899 12 -- -- : 40436 4899 13 temperate temperate NN 40436 4899 14 of of IN 40436 4899 15 intemperate intemperate NN 40436 4899 16 -- -- : 40436 4899 17 good good JJ 40436 4899 18 of of IN 40436 4899 19 evil evil NN 40436 4899 20 ? ? . 40436 4900 1 Impossible impossible JJ 40436 4900 2 : : : 40436 4900 3 the the DT 40436 4900 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 4900 5 can can MD 40436 4900 6 not not RB 40436 4900 7 be be VB 40436 4900 8 maintained maintain VBN 40436 4900 9 . . . 40436 4901 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4901 2 15 15 CD 40436 4901 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4901 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4901 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4901 6 15 15 CD 40436 4901 7 : : : 40436 4901 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4901 9 , , , 40436 4901 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4901 11 , , , 40436 4901 12 215 215 CD 40436 4901 13 - - SYM 40436 4901 14 216 216 CD 40436 4901 15 . . . 40436 4901 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4902 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4902 2 Side side NN 40436 4902 3 - - HYPH 40436 4902 4 note note NN 40436 4902 5 : : : 40436 4902 6 Confusion confusion NN 40436 4902 7 of of IN 40436 4902 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4902 9 . . . 40436 4903 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4903 2 suggests suggest VBZ 40436 4903 3 , , , 40436 4903 4 That that IN 40436 4903 5 the the DT 40436 4903 6 Indifferent Indifferent NNP 40436 4903 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4903 8 neither neither CC 40436 4903 9 good good JJ 40436 4903 10 nor nor CC 40436 4903 11 evil evil JJ 40436 4903 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4903 13 is be VBZ 40436 4903 14 friend friend NN 40436 4903 15 to to IN 40436 4903 16 the the DT 40436 4903 17 Good Good NNP 40436 4903 18 . . . 40436 4903 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4904 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4904 2 head head NN 40436 4904 3 turns turn VBZ 40436 4904 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4904 5 continues continue VBZ 40436 4904 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4904 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4904 8 with with IN 40436 4904 9 this this DT 40436 4904 10 confusion confusion NN 40436 4904 11 and and CC 40436 4904 12 puzzle puzzle NN 40436 4904 13 -- -- : 40436 4904 14 since since IN 40436 4904 15 neither neither DT 40436 4904 16 like like UH 40436 4904 17 is be VBZ 40436 4904 18 the the DT 40436 4904 19 friend friend NN 40436 4904 20 of of IN 40436 4904 21 like like UH 40436 4904 22 , , , 40436 4904 23 nor nor CC 40436 4904 24 contrary contrary JJ 40436 4904 25 of of IN 40436 4904 26 contrary contrary NN 40436 4904 27 . . . 40436 4905 1 But but CC 40436 4905 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4905 3 will will MD 40436 4905 4 now now RB 40436 4905 5 hazard hazard VB 40436 4905 6 a a DT 40436 4905 7 different different JJ 40436 4905 8 guess guess NN 40436 4905 9 of of IN 40436 4905 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4905 11 own own JJ 40436 4905 12 . . . 40436 4906 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4906 2 16 16 CD 40436 4906 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4906 4 There there EX 40436 4906 5 are be VBP 40436 4906 6 three three CD 40436 4906 7 genera genera NN 40436 4906 8 in in IN 40436 4906 9 all all RB 40436 4906 10 : : : 40436 4906 11 the the DT 40436 4906 12 good good JJ 40436 4906 13 -- -- : 40436 4906 14 the the DT 40436 4906 15 evil evil NN 40436 4906 16 -- -- : 40436 4906 17 and and CC 40436 4906 18 that that IN 40436 4906 19 which which WDT 40436 4906 20 is be VBZ 40436 4906 21 neither neither CC 40436 4906 22 good good JJ 40436 4906 23 nor nor CC 40436 4906 24 evil evil JJ 40436 4906 25 , , , 40436 4906 26 the the DT 40436 4906 27 indifferent indifferent NN 40436 4906 28 . . . 40436 4907 1 Now now RB 40436 4907 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4907 3 have have VBP 40436 4907 4 found find VBN 40436 4907 5 that that IN 40436 4907 6 good good JJ 40436 4907 7 is be VBZ 40436 4907 8 not not RB 40436 4907 9 a a DT 40436 4907 10 friend friend NN 40436 4907 11 to to IN 40436 4907 12 good good JJ 40436 4907 13 -- -- : 40436 4907 14 nor nor CC 40436 4907 15 evil evil JJ 40436 4907 16 to to IN 40436 4907 17 evil evil NN 40436 4907 18 -- -- : 40436 4907 19 nor nor CC 40436 4907 20 good good JJ 40436 4907 21 to to IN 40436 4907 22 evil evil NN 40436 4907 23 -- -- : 40436 4907 24 nor nor CC 40436 4907 25 evil evil JJ 40436 4907 26 to to IN 40436 4907 27 good good JJ 40436 4907 28 . . . 40436 4908 1 If if IN 40436 4908 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 4908 3 there there EX 40436 4908 4 exist exist VBP 40436 4908 5 any any DT 40436 4908 6 friendship friendship NN 40436 4908 7 at at RB 40436 4908 8 all all RB 40436 4908 9 , , , 40436 4908 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4908 11 must must MD 40436 4908 12 be be VB 40436 4908 13 the the DT 40436 4908 14 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 4908 15 that that WDT 40436 4908 16 is be VBZ 40436 4908 17 friend friend NN 40436 4908 18 , , , 40436 4908 19 either either CC 40436 4908 20 to to IN 40436 4908 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4908 22 like like JJ 40436 4908 23 , , , 40436 4908 24 or or CC 40436 4908 25 to to IN 40436 4908 26 the the DT 40436 4908 27 good good NN 40436 4908 28 : : : 40436 4908 29 for for IN 40436 4908 30 nothing nothing NN 40436 4908 31 whatever whatever WDT 40436 4908 32 can can MD 40436 4908 33 be be VB 40436 4908 34 a a DT 40436 4908 35 friend friend NN 40436 4908 36 to to IN 40436 4908 37 evil evil NN 40436 4908 38 . . . 40436 4909 1 But but CC 40436 4909 2 if if IN 40436 4909 3 the the DT 40436 4909 4 indifferent indifferent NN 40436 4909 5 be be VB 40436 4909 6 a a DT 40436 4909 7 friend friend NN 40436 4909 8 at at RB 40436 4909 9 all all RB 40436 4909 10 , , , 40436 4909 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4909 12 can can MD 40436 4909 13 not not RB 40436 4909 14 be be VB 40436 4909 15 a a DT 40436 4909 16 friend friend NN 40436 4909 17 to to IN 40436 4909 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4909 19 own own JJ 40436 4909 20 like like NN 40436 4909 21 ; ; : 40436 4909 22 since since IN 40436 4909 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4909 24 have have VBP 40436 4909 25 already already RB 40436 4909 26 shown show VBN 40436 4909 27 that that DT 40436 4909 28 like like UH 40436 4909 29 generally generally RB 40436 4909 30 is be VBZ 40436 4909 31 not not RB 40436 4909 32 friend friend NN 40436 4909 33 to to TO 40436 4909 34 like like VB 40436 4909 35 . . . 40436 4910 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4910 2 remains remain VBZ 40436 4910 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 4910 4 , , , 40436 4910 5 that that IN 40436 4910 6 the the DT 40436 4910 7 indifferent indifferent NN 40436 4910 8 , , , 40436 4910 9 in in IN 40436 4910 10 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4910 11 neither neither CC 40436 4910 12 good good JJ 40436 4910 13 nor nor CC 40436 4910 14 evil evil JJ 40436 4910 15 , , , 40436 4910 16 is be VBZ 40436 4910 17 friend friend NN 40436 4910 18 to to IN 40436 4910 19 the the DT 40436 4910 20 good good NN 40436 4910 21 . . . 40436 4911 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4911 2 17 17 CD 40436 4911 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4911 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4911 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4911 6 16 16 CD 40436 4911 7 : : : 40436 4911 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4911 9 , , , 40436 4911 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4911 11 , , , 40436 4911 12 216 216 CD 40436 4911 13 C c NN 40436 4911 14 - - HYPH 40436 4911 15 D d NN 40436 4911 16 : : : 40436 4911 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4911 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4911 19 : : : 40436 4911 20 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 4911 21 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 4911 22 au)to\s au)to\s NNP 40436 4911 23 i)liggiô= i)liggiô= NNP 40436 4911 24 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 4911 25 tê tê NNP 40436 4911 26 = = SYM 40436 4911 27 s s NNP 40436 4911 28 tou= tou= NNP 40436 4911 29 lo lo NNP 40436 4911 30 / / SYM 40436 4911 31 gou gou NNP 40436 4911 32 a)pori a)pori CD 40436 4911 33 / / SYM 40436 4911 34 as as IN 40436 4911 35 -- -- : 40436 4911 36 Le Le NNP 40436 4911 37 / / SYM 40436 4911 38 gô gô NNP 40436 4911 39 toi toi NNP 40436 4911 40 / / SYM 40436 4911 41 nun nun NNP 40436 4911 42 a)pomanteuo a)pomanteuo NNPS 40436 4911 43 / / SYM 40436 4911 44 menos menos NNP 40436 4911 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4911 46 , , , 40436 4911 47 & & CC 40436 4911 48 c. c. NNP 40436 4911 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4911 50 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4911 51 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4911 52 17 17 CD 40436 4911 53 : : : 40436 4911 54 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4911 55 , , , 40436 4911 56 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4911 57 , , , 40436 4911 58 216 216 CD 40436 4911 59 D. d. NN 40436 4911 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4911 61 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4911 62 Side side NN 40436 4911 63 - - HYPH 40436 4911 64 note note NN 40436 4911 65 : : : 40436 4911 66 Suggestion suggestion NN 40436 4911 67 canvassed canvass VBN 40436 4911 68 . . . 40436 4912 1 If if IN 40436 4912 2 the the DT 40436 4912 3 Indifferent Indifferent NNP 40436 4912 4 is be VBZ 40436 4912 5 friend friend NN 40436 4912 6 to to IN 40436 4912 7 the the DT 40436 4912 8 Good Good NNP 40436 4912 9 , , , 40436 4912 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4912 11 is be VBZ 40436 4912 12 determined determined JJ 40436 4912 13 to to TO 40436 4912 14 become become VB 40436 4912 15 so so RB 40436 4912 16 by by IN 40436 4912 17 the the DT 40436 4912 18 contact contact NN 40436 4912 19 of of IN 40436 4912 20 felt feel VBN 40436 4912 21 evil evil JJ 40436 4912 22 , , , 40436 4912 23 from from IN 40436 4912 24 which which WDT 40436 4912 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4912 26 is be VBZ 40436 4912 27 anxious anxious JJ 40436 4912 28 to to TO 40436 4912 29 escape escape VB 40436 4912 30 . . . 40436 4912 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4913 1 Yet yet CC 40436 4913 2 hold hold VB 40436 4913 3 ! ! . 40436 4914 1 Are be VBP 40436 4914 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4914 3 on on IN 40436 4914 4 the the DT 40436 4914 5 right right JJ 40436 4914 6 scent scent NN 40436 4914 7 ? ? . 40436 4915 1 What what WDT 40436 4915 2 reason reason NN 40436 4915 3 is be VBZ 40436 4915 4 there there RB 40436 4915 5 to to TO 40436 4915 6 determine determine VB 40436 4915 7 , , , 40436 4915 8 on on IN 40436 4915 9 the the DT 40436 4915 10 part part NN 40436 4915 11 of of IN 40436 4915 12 the the DT 40436 4915 13 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 4915 14 , , , 40436 4915 15 attachment attachment NN 40436 4915 16 to to IN 40436 4915 17 the the DT 40436 4915 18 good good NN 40436 4915 19 ? ? . 40436 4916 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4916 2 will will MD 40436 4916 3 only only RB 40436 4916 4 have have VB 40436 4916 5 such such JJ 40436 4916 6 attachment attachment NN 40436 4916 7 under under IN 40436 4916 8 certain certain JJ 40436 4916 9 given give VBN 40436 4916 10 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 4916 11 : : : 40436 4916 12 when when WRB 40436 4916 13 , , , 40436 4916 14 though though IN 40436 4916 15 neither neither CC 40436 4916 16 good good JJ 40436 4916 17 nor nor CC 40436 4916 18 evil evil JJ 40436 4916 19 in in IN 40436 4916 20 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4916 21 , , , 40436 4916 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4916 23 has have VBZ 40436 4916 24 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 4916 25 evil evil NN 40436 4916 26 associated associate VBN 40436 4916 27 with with IN 40436 4916 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4916 29 , , , 40436 4916 30 of of IN 40436 4916 31 which which WDT 40436 4916 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4916 33 desires desire VBZ 40436 4916 34 to to TO 40436 4916 35 be be VB 40436 4916 36 rid rid VBN 40436 4916 37 . . . 40436 4917 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4917 2 the the DT 40436 4917 3 body body NN 40436 4917 4 in in IN 40436 4917 5 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4917 6 is be VBZ 40436 4917 7 neither neither CC 40436 4917 8 good good JJ 40436 4917 9 nor nor CC 40436 4917 10 evil evil JJ 40436 4917 11 : : : 40436 4917 12 but but CC 40436 4917 13 when when WRB 40436 4917 14 diseased disease VBN 40436 4917 15 , , , 40436 4917 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4917 17 has have VBZ 40436 4917 18 evil evil JJ 40436 4917 19 clinging cling VBG 40436 4917 20 to to IN 40436 4917 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4917 22 , , , 40436 4917 23 and and CC 40436 4917 24 becomes become VBZ 40436 4917 25 in in IN 40436 4917 26 consequence consequence NN 40436 4917 27 of of IN 40436 4917 28 this this DT 40436 4917 29 evil evil NN 40436 4917 30 , , , 40436 4917 31 friendly friendly JJ 40436 4917 32 to to IN 40436 4917 33 the the DT 40436 4917 34 medical medical JJ 40436 4917 35 art art NN 40436 4917 36 as as IN 40436 4917 37 a a DT 40436 4917 38 remedy remedy NN 40436 4917 39 . . . 40436 4918 1 But but CC 40436 4918 2 this this DT 40436 4918 3 is be VBZ 40436 4918 4 true true JJ 40436 4918 5 only only RB 40436 4918 6 so so RB 40436 4918 7 long long RB 40436 4918 8 as as IN 40436 4918 9 the the DT 40436 4918 10 evil evil NN 40436 4918 11 is be VBZ 40436 4918 12 only only RB 40436 4918 13 apparent apparent JJ 40436 4918 14 , , , 40436 4918 15 and and CC 40436 4918 16 not not RB 40436 4918 17 real real JJ 40436 4918 18 : : : 40436 4918 19 so so RB 40436 4918 20 long long RB 40436 4918 21 as as IN 40436 4918 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4918 23 is be VBZ 40436 4918 24 a a DT 40436 4918 25 mere mere JJ 40436 4918 26 superficial superficial JJ 40436 4918 27 appendage appendage NN 40436 4918 28 , , , 40436 4918 29 and and CC 40436 4918 30 has have VBZ 40436 4918 31 not not RB 40436 4918 32 become become VBN 40436 4918 33 incorporated incorporated JJ 40436 4918 34 with with IN 40436 4918 35 the the DT 40436 4918 36 essential essential JJ 40436 4918 37 nature nature NN 40436 4918 38 of of IN 40436 4918 39 the the DT 40436 4918 40 body body NN 40436 4918 41 . . . 40436 4919 1 When when WRB 40436 4919 2 evil evil NN 40436 4919 3 has have VBZ 40436 4919 4 become become VBN 40436 4919 5 engrained engrained JJ 40436 4919 6 , , , 40436 4919 7 the the DT 40436 4919 8 body body NN 40436 4919 9 ceases cease VBZ 40436 4919 10 to to TO 40436 4919 11 be be VB 40436 4919 12 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 4919 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4919 14 _ _ NNP 40436 4919 15 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 4919 16 _ _ NNP 40436 4919 17 , , , 40436 4919 18 neither neither CC 40436 4919 19 good good JJ 40436 4919 20 nor nor CC 40436 4919 21 evil evil JJ 40436 4919 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4919 23 , , , 40436 4919 24 and and CC 40436 4919 25 loses lose VBZ 40436 4919 26 all all PDT 40436 4919 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4919 28 attachment attachment NN 40436 4919 29 to to IN 40436 4919 30 good good NN 40436 4919 31 . . . 40436 4920 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4920 2 that that DT 40436 4920 3 which which WDT 40436 4920 4 determines determine VBZ 40436 4920 5 the the DT 40436 4920 6 indifferent indifferent NN 40436 4920 7 to to TO 40436 4920 8 become become VB 40436 4920 9 friend friend NN 40436 4920 10 of of IN 40436 4920 11 the the DT 40436 4920 12 good good JJ 40436 4920 13 , , , 40436 4920 14 is be VBZ 40436 4920 15 , , , 40436 4920 16 the the DT 40436 4920 17 contact contact NN 40436 4920 18 and and CC 40436 4920 19 pressure pressure NN 40436 4920 20 of of IN 40436 4920 21 accessory accessory NN 40436 4920 22 evil evil NN 40436 4920 23 not not RB 40436 4920 24 in in IN 40436 4920 25 harmony harmony NN 40436 4920 26 with with IN 40436 4920 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4920 28 own own JJ 40436 4920 29 nature nature NN 40436 4920 30 , , , 40436 4920 31 accompanied accompany VBN 40436 4920 32 by by IN 40436 4920 33 a a DT 40436 4920 34 desire desire NN 40436 4920 35 for for IN 40436 4920 36 the the DT 40436 4920 37 cure cure NN 40436 4920 38 of of IN 40436 4920 39 such such JJ 40436 4920 40 evil evil NN 40436 4920 41 . . . 40436 4921 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4921 2 18 18 CD 40436 4921 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4921 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4921 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4921 6 18 18 CD 40436 4921 7 : : : 40436 4921 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4921 9 , , , 40436 4921 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4921 11 , , , 40436 4921 12 217 217 CD 40436 4921 13 E e NN 40436 4921 14 : : : 40436 4921 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4921 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4921 17 : : : 40436 4921 18 To\ To\ NNP 40436 4921 19 mê mê NNP 40436 4921 20 / / SYM 40436 4921 21 te te NNP 40436 4921 22 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 4921 23 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 4921 24 mê mê NNP 40436 4921 25 / / SYM 40436 4921 26 t t NNP 40436 4921 27 ' ' `` 40436 4921 28 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 4921 29 e)ni e)ni NNP 40436 4921 30 / / SYM 40436 4921 31 ote ote NNP 40436 4921 32 kakou= kakou= NNP 40436 4921 33 paro paro NNP 40436 4921 34 / / SYM 40436 4921 35 ntos ntos NNP 40436 4921 36 ou)/pô ou)/pô NNP 40436 4921 37 kako kako NNP 40436 4921 38 / / SYM 40436 4921 39 n n NNP 40436 4921 40 e)stin e)stin NNP 40436 4921 41 , , , 40436 4921 42 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 4921 43 d d LS 40436 4921 44 ' ' `` 40436 4921 45 o(/te o(/te NN 40436 4921 46 ê)/dê ê)/dê NNPS 40436 4921 47 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4921 48 toiou toiou NNP 40436 4921 49 = = NFP 40436 4921 50 ton ton NN 40436 4921 51 ge ge NNP 40436 4921 52 / / SYM 40436 4921 53 gonen gonen NNP 40436 4921 54 . . . 40436 4922 1 Pa Pa NNP 40436 4922 2 / / SYM 40436 4922 3 nu nu NNP 40436 4922 4 ge ge NNP 40436 4922 5 . . . 40436 4923 1 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 4923 2 = = SYM 40436 4923 3 n n CC 40436 4923 4 o(/tan o(/tan NNP 40436 4923 5 mê mê NNP 40436 4923 6 / / SYM 40436 4923 7 pô pô NNP 40436 4923 8 lalo\n lalo\n NNP 40436 4923 9 ê(=| ê(=| NNP 40436 4923 10 kakou= kakou= NNP 40436 4923 11 paro paro NNP 40436 4923 12 / / SYM 40436 4923 13 ntos ntos NNP 40436 4923 14 , , , 40436 4923 15 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 4923 16 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4923 17 ê ê NNP 40436 4923 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4923 19 parousi parousi NNP 40436 4923 20 / / , 40436 4923 21 a a DT 40436 4923 22 a)gathou= a)gathou= JJ 40436 4923 23 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 4923 24 poiei= poiei= NN 40436 4923 25 e)pithumei e)pithumei NNS 40436 4923 26 = = SYM 40436 4923 27 n n NN 40436 4923 28 , , , 40436 4923 29 ê ê NNP 40436 4923 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4923 31 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4923 32 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 4923 33 poiou poiou NNP 40436 4923 34 = = SYM 40436 4923 35 sa sa NNP 40436 4923 36 a)posterei= a)posterei= NNP 40436 4923 37 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 4923 38 tê tê NNP 40436 4923 39 = = SYM 40436 4923 40 s s NNP 40436 4923 41 t t NNP 40436 4923 42 ' ' POS 40436 4923 43 e)pithumi e)pithumi CD 40436 4923 44 / / SYM 40436 4923 45 as as IN 40436 4923 46 a)/ma a)/ma NNP 40436 4923 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4923 48 tê tê NNP 40436 4923 49 = = SYM 40436 4923 50 s s NNP 40436 4923 51 phili phili NNP 40436 4923 52 / / SYM 40436 4923 53 as as IN 40436 4923 54 ta)gathou=. ta)gathou=. NNP 40436 4924 1 Ou Ou NNP 40436 4924 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4924 3 ga\r ga\r VB 40436 4924 4 e)/ti e)/ti FW 40436 4924 5 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 4924 6 ou)/te ou)/te XX 40436 4924 7 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 4924 8 ou)/t ou)/t NNP 40436 4924 9 ' ' POS 40436 4924 10 a)gatho a)gatho CD 40436 4924 11 / / SYM 40436 4924 12 n n CD 40436 4924 13 , , , 40436 4924 14 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 4924 15 kako kako NNP 40436 4924 16 / / SYM 40436 4924 17 n n NNP 40436 4924 18 ; ; : 40436 4924 19 phi phi NNP 40436 4924 20 / / SYM 40436 4924 21 lon lon NNP 40436 4924 22 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4924 23 a)gathô=| a)gathô=| NNP 40436 4924 24 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 4924 25 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 4924 26 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 4924 27 . . . 40436 4924 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4924 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4925 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4925 2 Side side NN 40436 4925 3 - - HYPH 40436 4925 4 note note NN 40436 4925 5 : : : 40436 4925 6 Principle principle NN 40436 4925 7 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 4925 8 by by IN 40436 4925 9 the the DT 40436 4925 10 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 4925 11 . . . 40436 4926 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4926 2 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 4926 3 condition condition NN 40436 4926 4 -- -- : 40436 4926 5 not not RB 40436 4926 6 wise wise JJ 40436 4926 7 , , , 40436 4926 8 yet yet CC 40436 4926 9 painfully painfully RB 40436 4926 10 feeling feel VBG 40436 4926 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4926 12 own own JJ 40436 4926 13 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4926 14 . . . 40436 4926 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4927 1 Under under IN 40436 4927 2 this this DT 40436 4927 3 head head NN 40436 4927 4 comes come VBZ 40436 4927 5 the the DT 40436 4927 6 explanation explanation NN 40436 4927 7 of of IN 40436 4927 8 the the DT 40436 4927 9 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 4927 10 -- -- : 40436 4927 11 the the DT 40436 4927 12 friend friend NN 40436 4927 13 or or CC 40436 4927 14 lover lover NN 40436 4927 15 of of IN 40436 4927 16 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 4927 17 . . . 40436 4928 1 The the DT 40436 4928 2 man man NN 40436 4928 3 already already RB 40436 4928 4 wise wise JJ 40436 4928 5 is be VBZ 40436 4928 6 not not RB 40436 4928 7 a a DT 40436 4928 8 lover lover NN 40436 4928 9 of of IN 40436 4928 10 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 4928 11 : : : 40436 4928 12 nor nor CC 40436 4928 13 the the DT 40436 4928 14 man man NN 40436 4928 15 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 4928 16 bad bad JJ 40436 4928 17 and and CC 40436 4928 18 stupid stupid JJ 40436 4928 19 , , , 40436 4928 20 with with IN 40436 4928 21 whose whose WP$ 40436 4928 22 nature nature NN 40436 4928 23 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4928 24 is be VBZ 40436 4928 25 engrained engrained JJ 40436 4928 26 . . . 40436 4929 1 Like like IN 40436 4929 2 does do VBZ 40436 4929 3 not not RB 40436 4929 4 love love VB 40436 4929 5 like like IN 40436 4929 6 , , , 40436 4929 7 nor nor CC 40436 4929 8 does do VBZ 40436 4929 9 contrary contrary JJ 40436 4929 10 love love NN 40436 4929 11 contrary contrary JJ 40436 4929 12 . . . 40436 4930 1 The the DT 40436 4930 2 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 4930 3 is be VBZ 40436 4930 4 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 4930 5 between between IN 40436 4930 6 the the DT 40436 4930 7 two two CD 40436 4930 8 : : : 40436 4930 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4930 10 is be VBZ 40436 4930 11 not not RB 40436 4930 12 wise wise JJ 40436 4930 13 , , , 40436 4930 14 but but CC 40436 4930 15 neither neither DT 40436 4930 16 has have VBZ 40436 4930 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4930 18 yet yet RB 40436 4930 19 become become VBN 40436 4930 20 radically radically RB 40436 4930 21 stupid stupid JJ 40436 4930 22 and and CC 40436 4930 23 unteachable unteachable JJ 40436 4930 24 . . . 40436 4931 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4931 2 has have VBZ 40436 4931 3 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4931 4 cleaving cleave VBG 40436 4931 5 to to IN 40436 4931 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4931 7 as as IN 40436 4931 8 an an DT 40436 4931 9 evil evil NN 40436 4931 10 , , , 40436 4931 11 but but CC 40436 4931 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4931 13 knows know VBZ 40436 4931 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4931 15 own own JJ 40436 4931 16 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 4931 17 , , , 40436 4931 18 and and CC 40436 4931 19 yearns yearn NNS 40436 4931 20 for for IN 40436 4931 21 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 4931 22 as as IN 40436 4931 23 a a DT 40436 4931 24 cure cure NN 40436 4931 25 for for IN 40436 4931 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4931 27 . . . 40436 4932 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4932 2 19 19 CD 40436 4932 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4932 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4932 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 4932 6 19 19 CD 40436 4932 7 : : : 40436 4932 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4932 9 , , , 40436 4932 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4932 11 , , , 40436 4932 12 218 218 CD 40436 4932 13 A. a. NN 40436 4933 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4933 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4933 3 : : : 40436 4933 4 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 4933 5 tau tau NNP 40436 4933 6 = = SYM 40436 4933 7 ta ta NNP 40436 4933 8 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4933 9 phai phai NNP 40436 4933 10 = = SYM 40436 4933 11 men man NNS 40436 4933 12 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 4933 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4933 14 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 4933 15 ê)/dê ê)/dê NNPS 40436 4933 16 sophou\s sophou\s ADD 40436 4933 17 mêke mêke VB 40436 4933 18 / / NFP 40436 4933 19 ti ti NNP 40436 4933 20 philosophei philosophei NN 40436 4933 21 = = SYM 40436 4933 22 n n XX 40436 4933 23 , , , 40436 4933 24 ei)/te ei)/te NNP 40436 4933 25 theoi\ theoi\ NNP 40436 4933 26 ei)/te ei)/te NNP 40436 4933 27 a)/nthrôpoi/ a)/nthrôpoi/ NNP 40436 4933 28 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 4933 29 ou(=toi ou(=toi VBZ 40436 4933 30 ; ; : 40436 4933 31 ou)d ou)d LS 40436 4933 32 ' ' '' 40436 4933 33 au)= au)= : 40436 4933 34 e)kei e)kei JJ 40436 4933 35 / / SYM 40436 4933 36 nous nous JJ 40436 4933 37 philosophei philosophei NN 40436 4933 38 = = SYM 40436 4933 39 n n NNP 40436 4933 40 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 4933 41 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 4933 42 a)/gnoian a)/gnoian JJ 40436 4933 43 e)/chontas e)/chonta NNS 40436 4933 44 ô(/ste ô(/ste NN 40436 4933 45 kakou\s kakou\s NNP 40436 4933 46 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4933 47 ; ; : 40436 4933 48 kako\n kako\n ADD 40436 4933 49 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4933 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4933 51 a)mathê= a)mathê= NNP 40436 4933 52 ou)de ou)de NNP 40436 4933 53 / / SYM 40436 4933 54 na na TO 40436 4933 55 philosophei philosophei NN 40436 4933 56 = = SYM 40436 4933 57 n n XX 40436 4933 58 . . . 40436 4934 1 lei lei NNP 40436 4934 2 / / SYM 40436 4934 3 pontai pontai NNP 40436 4934 4 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4934 5 oi oi UH 40436 4934 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4934 7 e)/chontes e)/chonte VBZ 40436 4934 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 4934 9 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4934 10 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 4934 11 tou tou NNP 40436 4934 12 = = SYM 40436 4934 13 to to IN 40436 4934 14 , , , 40436 4934 15 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 4934 16 a)/gnoian a)/gnoian NNP 40436 4934 17 , , , 40436 4934 18 mê mê NNP 40436 4934 19 / / SYM 40436 4934 20 pô pô NNP 40436 4934 21 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4934 22 u(p u(p NNP 40436 4934 23 ' ' '' 40436 4934 24 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 4934 25 o)/ntes o)/nte NNS 40436 4934 26 a)gnô a)gnô NN 40436 4934 27 / / SYM 40436 4934 28 mones mones NNPS 40436 4934 29 mêd mêd NNP 40436 4934 30 ' ' '' 40436 4934 31 a)mathei a)mathei NNP 40436 4934 32 = = SYM 40436 4934 33 s s NNP 40436 4934 34 , , , 40436 4934 35 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 4934 36 ' ' '' 40436 4934 37 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 4934 38 ê(gou ê(gou NNP 40436 4934 39 / / SYM 40436 4934 40 menoi menoi NNP 40436 4934 41 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 4934 42 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 4934 43 / / SYM 40436 4934 44 nai nai NNP 40436 4934 45 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 4934 46 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 4934 47 i)/sasin i)/sasin NNS 40436 4934 48 . . . 40436 4935 1 dio\ dio\ NNP 40436 4935 2 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4935 3 philosophou philosophou NNP 40436 4935 4 = = NFP 40436 4935 5 sin sin NN 40436 4935 6 oi oi NNP 40436 4935 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4935 8 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 4935 9 a)gathoi\ a)gathoi\ NNP 40436 4935 10 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 4935 11 kakoi/ kakoi/ NNP 40436 4935 12 pô pô NN 40436 4935 13 o)/ntes o)/nte NNS 40436 4935 14 . . . 40436 4936 1 o(/soi o(/soi NNP 40436 4936 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4936 3 kakoi\ kakoi\ NNP 40436 4936 4 , , , 40436 4936 5 ou ou NNP 40436 4936 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4936 7 philosophou philosophou NNP 40436 4936 8 = = NFP 40436 4936 9 sin sin NN 40436 4936 10 , , , 40436 4936 11 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 4936 12 oi oi FW 40436 4936 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4936 14 a)gathoi/. a)gathoi/. NN 40436 4936 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4937 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 4937 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4937 3 , , , 40436 4937 4 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 4937 5 , , , 40436 4937 6 204 204 CD 40436 4937 7 . . . 40436 4937 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4938 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4938 2 Side side NN 40436 4938 3 - - HYPH 40436 4938 4 note note NN 40436 4938 5 : : : 40436 4938 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 4938 7 dissatisfied dissatisfied JJ 40436 4938 8 . . . 40436 4939 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4939 2 originates originate VBZ 40436 4939 3 a a DT 40436 4939 4 new new JJ 40436 4939 5 suggestion suggestion NN 40436 4939 6 . . . 40436 4940 1 The the DT 40436 4940 2 Primum Primum NNP 40436 4940 3 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 4940 4 , , , 40436 4940 5 or or CC 40436 4940 6 object object VBP 40436 4940 7 originally originally RB 40436 4940 8 dear dear JJ 40436 4940 9 to to IN 40436 4940 10 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4940 11 , , , 40436 4940 12 _ _ NNP 40436 4940 13 per per FW 40436 4940 14 se se FW 40436 4940 15 _ _ NNP 40436 4940 16 : : : 40436 4940 17 by by IN 40436 4940 18 relation relation NN 40436 4940 19 or or CC 40436 4940 20 resemblance resemblance NN 40436 4940 21 to to TO 40436 4940 22 which which WDT 40436 4940 23 other other JJ 40436 4940 24 objects object NNS 40436 4940 25 become become VBP 40436 4940 26 dear dear JJ 40436 4940 27 . . . 40436 4940 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4941 1 The the DT 40436 4941 2 two two CD 40436 4941 3 young young JJ 40436 4941 4 collocutors collocutor NNS 40436 4941 5 with with IN 40436 4941 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4941 7 welcome welcome VBP 40436 4941 8 this this DT 40436 4941 9 explanation explanation NN 40436 4941 10 heartily heartily RB 40436 4941 11 , , , 40436 4941 12 and and CC 40436 4941 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 4941 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4941 15 appears appear VBZ 40436 4941 16 for for IN 40436 4941 17 the the DT 40436 4941 18 moment moment NN 40436 4941 19 satisfied satisfy VBD 40436 4941 20 with with IN 40436 4941 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4941 22 . . . 40436 4942 1 But but CC 40436 4942 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4942 3 presently presently RB 40436 4942 4 bethinks bethink VBZ 40436 4942 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 4942 6 , , , 40436 4942 7 and and CC 40436 4942 8 exclaims exclaim NNS 40436 4942 9 , , , 40436 4942 10 Ah ah UH 40436 4942 11 ! ! . 40436 4943 1 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4943 2 and and CC 40436 4943 3 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4943 4 , , , 40436 4943 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4943 6 wealth wealth NN 40436 4943 7 is be VBZ 40436 4943 8 all all PDT 40436 4943 9 a a DT 40436 4943 10 dream dream NN 40436 4943 11 ! ! . 40436 4944 1 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4944 2 have have VBP 40436 4944 3 been be VBN 40436 4944 4 yielding yield VBG 40436 4944 5 again again RB 40436 4944 6 to to IN 40436 4944 7 delusions delusion NNS 40436 4944 8 ! ! . 40436 4945 1 Let let VB 40436 4945 2 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4945 3 once once RB 40436 4945 4 more more JJR 40436 4945 5 examine examine JJ 40436 4945 6 . . . 40436 4946 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 4946 2 will will MD 40436 4946 3 admit admit VB 40436 4946 4 that that IN 40436 4946 5 all all DT 40436 4946 6 friendship friendship NN 40436 4946 7 is be VBZ 40436 4946 8 on on IN 40436 4946 9 account account NN 40436 4946 10 of of IN 40436 4946 11 something something NN 40436 4946 12 and and CC 40436 4946 13 for for IN 40436 4946 14 the the DT 40436 4946 15 sake sake NN 40436 4946 16 of of IN 40436 4946 17 something something NN 40436 4946 18 : : : 40436 4946 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4946 20 is be VBZ 40436 4946 21 relative relative JJ 40436 4946 22 both both DT 40436 4946 23 to to IN 40436 4946 24 some some DT 40436 4946 25 producing produce VBG 40436 4946 26 cause cause NN 40436 4946 27 , , , 40436 4946 28 and and CC 40436 4946 29 to to IN 40436 4946 30 some some DT 40436 4946 31 prospective prospective JJ 40436 4946 32 end end NN 40436 4946 33 . . . 40436 4947 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4947 2 the the DT 40436 4947 3 body body NN 40436 4947 4 , , , 40436 4947 5 which which WDT 40436 4947 6 is be VBZ 40436 4947 7 in in IN 40436 4947 8 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4947 9 neither neither CC 40436 4947 10 good good JJ 40436 4947 11 nor nor CC 40436 4947 12 evil evil JJ 40436 4947 13 , , , 40436 4947 14 becomes become VBZ 40436 4947 15 when when WRB 40436 4947 16 sick sick JJ 40436 4947 17 a a DT 40436 4947 18 friend friend NN 40436 4947 19 to to IN 40436 4947 20 the the DT 40436 4947 21 medical medical JJ 40436 4947 22 art art NN 40436 4947 23 : : : 40436 4947 24 on on IN 40436 4947 25 account account NN 40436 4947 26 of of IN 40436 4947 27 sickness sickness NN 40436 4947 28 , , , 40436 4947 29 which which WDT 40436 4947 30 is be VBZ 40436 4947 31 an an DT 40436 4947 32 evil evil NN 40436 4947 33 -- -- : 40436 4947 34 and and CC 40436 4947 35 for for IN 40436 4947 36 the the DT 40436 4947 37 sake sake NN 40436 4947 38 of of IN 40436 4947 39 health health NN 40436 4947 40 , , , 40436 4947 41 which which WDT 40436 4947 42 is be VBZ 40436 4947 43 a a DT 40436 4947 44 good good NN 40436 4947 45 . . . 40436 4948 1 The the DT 40436 4948 2 medical medical JJ 40436 4948 3 art art NN 40436 4948 4 is be VBZ 40436 4948 5 dear dear JJ 40436 4948 6 to to IN 40436 4948 7 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4948 8 , , , 40436 4948 9 because because IN 40436 4948 10 health health NN 40436 4948 11 is be VBZ 40436 4948 12 dear dear JJ 40436 4948 13 : : : 40436 4948 14 but but CC 40436 4948 15 is be VBZ 40436 4948 16 there there EX 40436 4948 17 any any DT 40436 4948 18 thing thing NN 40436 4948 19 behind behind RB 40436 4948 20 , , , 40436 4948 21 for for IN 40436 4948 22 the the DT 40436 4948 23 sake sake NN 40436 4948 24 of of IN 40436 4948 25 which which WDT 40436 4948 26 health health NN 40436 4948 27 also also RB 40436 4948 28 is be VBZ 40436 4948 29 dear dear JJ 40436 4948 30 ? ? . 40436 4949 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4949 2 is be VBZ 40436 4949 3 plain plain JJ 40436 4949 4 that that IN 40436 4949 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4949 6 can can MD 40436 4949 7 not not RB 40436 4949 8 push push VB 40436 4949 9 the the DT 40436 4949 10 series series NN 40436 4949 11 of of IN 40436 4949 12 references reference NNS 40436 4949 13 onward onward RB 40436 4949 14 for for IN 40436 4949 15 ever ever RB 40436 4949 16 , , , 40436 4949 17 and and CC 40436 4949 18 that that IN 40436 4949 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4949 20 must must MD 40436 4949 21 come come VB 40436 4949 22 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 4949 23 to to IN 40436 4949 24 something something NN 40436 4949 25 which which WDT 40436 4949 26 is be VBZ 40436 4949 27 dear dear JJ 40436 4949 28 _ _ NNP 40436 4949 29 per per FW 40436 4949 30 se se FW 40436 4949 31 _ _ NNP 40436 4949 32 , , , 40436 4949 33 not not RB 40436 4949 34 from from IN 40436 4949 35 reference reference NN 40436 4949 36 to to IN 40436 4949 37 any any DT 40436 4949 38 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 4949 39 _ _ NNP 40436 4949 40 aliud aliud NNS 40436 4949 41 _ _ NNP 40436 4949 42 . . . 40436 4950 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4950 2 must must MD 40436 4950 3 come come VB 40436 4950 4 to to IN 40436 4950 5 some some DT 40436 4950 6 _ _ NNP 40436 4950 7 primum primum NN 40436 4950 8 amabile amabile NN 40436 4950 9 _ _ NNP 40436 4950 10 , , , 40436 4950 11 dear dear JJ 40436 4950 12 by by IN 40436 4950 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4950 14 own own JJ 40436 4950 15 nature nature NN 40436 4950 16 , , , 40436 4950 17 to to TO 40436 4950 18 which which WDT 40436 4950 19 all all DT 40436 4950 20 other other JJ 40436 4950 21 dear dear JJ 40436 4950 22 things thing NNS 40436 4950 23 refer refer VBP 40436 4950 24 , , , 40436 4950 25 and and CC 40436 4950 26 from from IN 40436 4950 27 which which WDT 40436 4950 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 4950 29 are be VBP 40436 4950 30 derivatives derivative NNS 40436 4950 31 . . . 40436 4951 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4951 2 20 20 CD 40436 4951 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4951 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4951 5 is be VBZ 40436 4951 6 this this DT 40436 4951 7 _ _ NNP 40436 4951 8 primum primum NN 40436 4951 9 amabile amabile NN 40436 4951 10 _ _ NNP 40436 4951 11 which which WDT 40436 4951 12 is be VBZ 40436 4951 13 the the DT 40436 4951 14 primitive primitive JJ 40436 4951 15 , , , 40436 4951 16 essential essential JJ 40436 4951 17 , , , 40436 4951 18 and and CC 40436 4951 19 constant constant JJ 40436 4951 20 , , , 40436 4951 21 object object NN 40436 4951 22 of of IN 40436 4951 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4951 24 affections affection NNS 40436 4951 25 : : : 40436 4951 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4951 27 love love VBP 40436 4951 28 other other JJ 40436 4951 29 things thing NNS 40436 4951 30 only only RB 40436 4951 31 from from IN 40436 4951 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4951 33 being be VBG 40436 4951 34 associated associate VBN 40436 4951 35 with with IN 40436 4951 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4951 37 . . . 40436 4952 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4952 2 suppose suppose VB 40436 4952 3 a a DT 40436 4952 4 father father NN 40436 4952 5 tenderly tenderly RB 40436 4952 6 attached attach VBD 40436 4952 7 to to IN 40436 4952 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4952 9 son son NN 40436 4952 10 , , , 40436 4952 11 and and CC 40436 4952 12 that that IN 40436 4952 13 the the DT 40436 4952 14 son son NN 40436 4952 15 has have VBZ 40436 4952 16 drunk drunk JJ 40436 4952 17 hemlock hemlock NNP 40436 4952 18 , , , 40436 4952 19 for for IN 40436 4952 20 which which WDT 40436 4952 21 wine wine NN 40436 4952 22 is be VBZ 40436 4952 23 an an DT 40436 4952 24 antidote antidote NN 40436 4952 25 ; ; : 40436 4952 26 the the DT 40436 4952 27 father father NN 40436 4952 28 will will MD 40436 4952 29 come come VB 40436 4952 30 by by IN 40436 4952 31 association association NN 40436 4952 32 to to TO 40436 4952 33 prize prize VB 40436 4952 34 highly highly RB 40436 4952 35 , , , 40436 4952 36 not not RB 40436 4952 37 merely merely RB 40436 4952 38 the the DT 40436 4952 39 wine wine NN 40436 4952 40 which which WDT 40436 4952 41 saves save VBZ 40436 4952 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4952 43 son son NN 40436 4952 44 's 's POS 40436 4952 45 life life NN 40436 4952 46 , , , 40436 4952 47 but but CC 40436 4952 48 even even RB 40436 4952 49 the the DT 40436 4952 50 cup cup NN 40436 4952 51 in in IN 40436 4952 52 which which WDT 40436 4952 53 the the DT 40436 4952 54 wine wine NN 40436 4952 55 is be VBZ 40436 4952 56 contained contain VBN 40436 4952 57 . . . 40436 4953 1 Yet yet CC 40436 4953 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4953 3 would would MD 40436 4953 4 be be VB 40436 4953 5 wrong wrong JJ 40436 4953 6 to to TO 40436 4953 7 say say VB 40436 4953 8 that that IN 40436 4953 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4953 10 prizes prize VBZ 40436 4953 11 the the DT 40436 4953 12 wine wine NN 40436 4953 13 or or CC 40436 4953 14 the the DT 40436 4953 15 cup cup NN 40436 4953 16 as as RB 40436 4953 17 much much RB 40436 4953 18 as as IN 40436 4953 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4953 20 son son NN 40436 4953 21 : : : 40436 4953 22 for for IN 40436 4953 23 the the DT 40436 4953 24 truth truth NN 40436 4953 25 is be VBZ 40436 4953 26 , , , 40436 4953 27 that that IN 40436 4953 28 all all PDT 40436 4953 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4953 30 solicitude solicitude NN 40436 4953 31 is be VBZ 40436 4953 32 really really RB 40436 4953 33 on on IN 40436 4953 34 behalf behalf NN 40436 4953 35 of of IN 40436 4953 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4953 37 son son NN 40436 4953 38 , , , 40436 4953 39 and and CC 40436 4953 40 extends extend VBZ 40436 4953 41 only only RB 40436 4953 42 in in IN 40436 4953 43 a a DT 40436 4953 44 derivative derivative JJ 40436 4953 45 and and CC 40436 4953 46 secondary secondary JJ 40436 4953 47 way way NN 40436 4953 48 to to IN 40436 4953 49 the the DT 40436 4953 50 wine wine NN 40436 4953 51 and and CC 40436 4953 52 the the DT 40436 4953 53 cup cup NN 40436 4953 54 . . . 40436 4954 1 So so RB 40436 4954 2 about about IN 40436 4954 3 gold gold NN 40436 4954 4 and and CC 40436 4954 5 silver silver NN 40436 4954 6 : : : 40436 4954 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4954 8 talk talk VBP 40436 4954 9 of of IN 40436 4954 10 prizing prize VBG 40436 4954 11 highly highly RB 40436 4954 12 gold gold NN 40436 4954 13 and and CC 40436 4954 14 silver silver NN 40436 4954 15 -- -- : 40436 4954 16 but but CC 40436 4954 17 this this DT 40436 4954 18 is be VBZ 40436 4954 19 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 4954 20 , , , 40436 4954 21 for for IN 40436 4954 22 what what WP 40436 4954 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4954 24 really really RB 40436 4954 25 prize prize VBP 40436 4954 26 is be VBZ 40436 4954 27 not not RB 40436 4954 28 gold gold JJ 40436 4954 29 , , , 40436 4954 30 but but CC 40436 4954 31 the the DT 40436 4954 32 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 4954 33 something something NN 40436 4954 34 , , , 40436 4954 35 whatever whatever WDT 40436 4954 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4954 37 be be VB 40436 4954 38 , , , 40436 4954 39 for for IN 40436 4954 40 the the DT 40436 4954 41 attainment attainment NN 40436 4954 42 of of IN 40436 4954 43 which which WDT 40436 4954 44 gold gold NN 40436 4954 45 and and CC 40436 4954 46 other other JJ 40436 4954 47 instrumental instrumental JJ 40436 4954 48 means mean NNS 40436 4954 49 are be VBP 40436 4954 50 accumulated accumulate VBN 40436 4954 51 . . . 40436 4955 1 In in IN 40436 4955 2 general general JJ 40436 4955 3 terms term NNS 40436 4955 4 -- -- : 40436 4955 5 when when WRB 40436 4955 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4955 7 say say VBP 40436 4955 8 that that IN 40436 4955 9 B b NN 40436 4955 10 is be VBZ 40436 4955 11 dear dear JJ 40436 4955 12 on on IN 40436 4955 13 account account NN 40436 4955 14 of of IN 40436 4955 15 A a NN 40436 4955 16 , , , 40436 4955 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4955 18 are be VBP 40436 4955 19 really really RB 40436 4955 20 speaking speak VBG 40436 4955 21 of of IN 40436 4955 22 A a DT 40436 4955 23 under under IN 40436 4955 24 the the DT 40436 4955 25 name name NN 40436 4955 26 of of IN 40436 4955 27 B. B. NNP 40436 4956 1 What what WP 40436 4956 2 is be VBZ 40436 4956 3 really really RB 40436 4956 4 dear dear JJ 40436 4956 5 , , , 40436 4956 6 is be VBZ 40436 4956 7 that that DT 40436 4956 8 primitive primitive JJ 40436 4956 9 object object NN 40436 4956 10 of of IN 40436 4956 11 love love NN 40436 4956 12 , , , 40436 4956 13 _ _ NNP 40436 4956 14 primum primum NN 40436 4956 15 amabile amabile NN 40436 4956 16 _ _ NNP 40436 4956 17 , , , 40436 4956 18 towards towards IN 40436 4956 19 which which WDT 40436 4956 20 all all PDT 40436 4956 21 the the DT 40436 4956 22 affections affection NNS 40436 4956 23 which which WDT 40436 4956 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4956 25 bear bear VBP 40436 4956 26 to to IN 40436 4956 27 other other JJ 40436 4956 28 things thing NNS 40436 4956 29 , , , 40436 4956 30 refer refer VB 40436 4956 31 and and CC 40436 4956 32 tend tend VBP 40436 4956 33 . . . 40436 4957 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4957 2 21 21 CD 40436 4957 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4957 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4957 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4957 6 20 20 CD 40436 4957 7 : : : 40436 4957 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4957 9 , , , 40436 4957 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4957 11 , , , 40436 4957 12 219 219 CD 40436 4957 13 C C NNP 40436 4957 14 - - HYPH 40436 4957 15 D. D. NNP 40436 4957 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4957 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4957 18 : : : 40436 4957 19 A)=r A)=r NNP 40436 4957 20 ' ' POS 40436 4957 21 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 4957 22 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 4957 23 a)na a)na NNP 40436 4957 24 / / SYM 40436 4957 25 gkê gkê NNP 40436 4957 26 a)peipei a)peipei -RRB- 40436 4957 27 = = SYM 40436 4957 28 n n NNP 40436 4957 29 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 4957 30 = = SYM 40436 4957 31 s s NN 40436 4957 32 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 4957 33 i)o i)o NNP 40436 4957 34 / / SYM 40436 4957 35 ntas ntas RB 40436 4957 36 , , , 40436 4957 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4957 38 a)phike a)phike NNP 40436 4957 39 / / SYM 40436 4957 40 sthai sthai NNP 40436 4957 41 e)pi/ e)pi/ CD 40436 4957 42 tina tina NNP 40436 4957 43 a)rchê\n a)rchê\n NNP 40436 4957 44 , , , 40436 4957 45 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 4957 46 ou)ke ou)ke NNP 40436 4957 47 / / SYM 40436 4957 48 t t NN 40436 4957 49 ' ' '' 40436 4957 50 e)panoi e)panoi CD 40436 4957 51 / / SYM 40436 4957 52 sei sei NNP 40436 4957 53 e)p e)p NNP 40436 4957 54 ' ' POS 40436 4957 55 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 4957 56 phi phi NNP 40436 4957 57 / / SYM 40436 4957 58 lon lon NNP 40436 4957 59 , , , 40436 4957 60 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 4957 61 ' ' '' 40436 4957 62 ê(/xei ê(/xei NNP 40436 4957 63 e)p e)p NNP 40436 4957 64 ' ' POS 40436 4957 65 e)kei e)kei NN 40436 4957 66 = = NFP 40436 4957 67 no no UH 40436 4957 68 o(/ o(/ JJ 40436 4957 69 e)sti e)sti NNPS 40436 4957 70 _ _ NNP 40436 4957 71 prô prô NNP 40436 4957 72 = = SYM 40436 4957 73 ton ton NN 40436 4957 74 phi phi NNP 40436 4957 75 / / SYM 40436 4957 76 lon lon NNP 40436 4957 77 _ _ NNP 40436 4957 78 , , , 40436 4957 79 ou(= ou(= ADD 40436 4957 80 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 4957 81 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4957 82 ta)/lla ta)/lla NNP 40436 4957 83 phame\n phame\n NNP 40436 4957 84 pa pa NNP 40436 4957 85 / / SYM 40436 4957 86 nta nta NNP 40436 4957 87 phi phi NNP 40436 4957 88 / / SYM 40436 4957 89 la la NNP 40436 4957 90 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4957 91 ? ? . 40436 4957 92 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4957 93 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4958 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4958 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4958 3 21 21 CD 40436 4958 4 : : : 40436 4958 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4958 6 , , , 40436 4958 7 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4958 8 , , , 40436 4958 9 c. c. NNP 40436 4958 10 37 37 CD 40436 4958 11 , , , 40436 4958 12 p. p. NN 40436 4958 13 220 220 CD 40436 4958 14 B. B. NNP 40436 4959 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4959 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4959 3 : : : 40436 4959 4 O(/sa O(/sa NNP 40436 4959 5 ga ga NNP 40436 4959 6 / / SYM 40436 4959 7 r r NNP 40436 4959 8 phamen phaman NNS 40436 4959 9 phi phi NNP 40436 4959 10 / / SYM 40436 4959 11 la la NNP 40436 4959 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 4959 13 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 4959 14 = = SYM 40436 4959 15 n n CC 40436 4959 16 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 4959 17 phi phi NNP 40436 4959 18 / / SYM 40436 4959 19 lou lou NNP 40436 4959 20 tino tino NNP 40436 4959 21 / / SYM 40436 4959 22 s s NNPS 40436 4959 23 , , , 40436 4959 24 e(te e(te NNP 40436 4959 25 / / SYM 40436 4959 26 rô| rô| NNP 40436 4959 27 r(ê r(ê NNP 40436 4959 28 / / SYM 40436 4959 29 mati mati NNPS 40436 4959 30 phaino phaino NNP 40436 4959 31 / / SYM 40436 4959 32 metha metha NNP 40436 4959 33 le le NNP 40436 4959 34 / / SYM 40436 4959 35 gontes gonte NNS 40436 4959 36 _ _ NNP 40436 4959 37 au)to/ au)to/ NNP 40436 4959 38 _ _ NNP 40436 4959 39 ; ; : 40436 4959 40 phi phi NNP 40436 4959 41 / / SYM 40436 4959 42 lon lon NNP 40436 4959 43 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4959 44 _ _ NNP 40436 4959 45 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 4959 46 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 4959 47 _ _ NNP 40436 4959 48 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 4959 49 / / SYM 40436 4959 50 ei ei NNP 40436 4959 51 _ _ NNP 40436 4959 52 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 4959 53 = = NFP 40436 4959 54 no no UH 40436 4959 55 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 4959 56 _ _ NNP 40436 4959 57 , , , 40436 4959 58 ei)s ei)s '' 40436 4959 59 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 4959 60 pa pa NNP 40436 4959 61 = = SYM 40436 4959 62 sai sai NNP 40436 4959 63 au(=tai au(=tai NNP 40436 4959 64 ai ai NNP 40436 4959 65 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4959 66 lego lego NNP 40436 4959 67 / / SYM 40436 4959 68 menai menai NNP 40436 4959 69 phili phili NNP 40436 4959 70 / / SYM 40436 4959 71 ai ai NNP 40436 4959 72 teleutô teleutô NNP 40436 4959 73 = = SYM 40436 4959 74 sin sin NN 40436 4959 75 . . . 40436 4959 76 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4959 77 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4960 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4960 2 Side side NN 40436 4960 3 - - HYPH 40436 4960 4 note note NN 40436 4960 5 : : : 40436 4960 6 The the DT 40436 4960 7 cause cause NN 40436 4960 8 of of IN 40436 4960 9 love love NN 40436 4960 10 is be VBZ 40436 4960 11 desire desire NN 40436 4960 12 . . . 40436 4961 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4961 2 desire desire VBP 40436 4961 3 that that DT 40436 4961 4 which which WDT 40436 4961 5 is be VBZ 40436 4961 6 akin akin JJ 40436 4961 7 to to IN 40436 4961 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4961 9 or or CC 40436 4961 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4961 11 own own JJ 40436 4961 12 . . . 40436 4961 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4962 1 Is be VBZ 40436 4962 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4962 3 then then RB 40436 4962 4 true true JJ 40436 4962 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4962 6 continues continue VBZ 40436 4962 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 4962 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4962 9 that that IN 40436 4962 10 good good NN 40436 4962 11 is be VBZ 40436 4962 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4962 13 _ _ NNP 40436 4962 14 primum primum NN 40436 4962 15 amabile amabile NN 40436 4962 16 _ _ NNP 40436 4962 17 , , , 40436 4962 18 and and CC 40436 4962 19 dear dear JJ 40436 4962 20 to to IN 40436 4962 21 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4962 22 in in IN 40436 4962 23 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 4962 24 ? ? . 40436 4963 1 If if IN 40436 4963 2 so so RB 40436 4963 3 , , , 40436 4963 4 is be VBZ 40436 4963 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4963 6 dear dear JJ 40436 4963 7 to to IN 40436 4963 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4963 9 on on IN 40436 4963 10 account account NN 40436 4963 11 of of IN 40436 4963 12 evil evil NN 40436 4963 13 ? ? . 40436 4964 1 that that RB 40436 4964 2 is is RB 40436 4964 3 , , , 40436 4964 4 only only RB 40436 4964 5 as as IN 40436 4964 6 a a DT 40436 4964 7 remedy remedy NN 40436 4964 8 for for IN 40436 4964 9 evil evil NN 40436 4964 10 ; ; : 40436 4964 11 so so IN 40436 4964 12 that that IN 40436 4964 13 if if IN 40436 4964 14 evil evil NN 40436 4964 15 were be VBD 40436 4964 16 totally totally RB 40436 4964 17 banished banish VBN 40436 4964 18 , , , 40436 4964 19 good good JJ 40436 4964 20 would would MD 40436 4964 21 cease cease VB 40436 4964 22 to to TO 40436 4964 23 be be VB 40436 4964 24 prized prize VBN 40436 4964 25 ? ? . 40436 4965 1 Is be VBZ 40436 4965 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4965 3 true true JJ 40436 4965 4 that that IN 40436 4965 5 evil evil NN 40436 4965 6 is be VBZ 40436 4965 7 the the DT 40436 4965 8 cause cause NN 40436 4965 9 why why WRB 40436 4965 10 any any DT 40436 4965 11 thing thing NN 40436 4965 12 is be VBZ 40436 4965 13 dear dear JJ 40436 4965 14 to to IN 40436 4965 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4965 16 ? ? . 40436 4966 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4966 2 22 22 CD 40436 4966 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4966 4 This this DT 40436 4966 5 can can MD 40436 4966 6 not not RB 40436 4966 7 be be VB 40436 4966 8 : : : 40436 4966 9 because because IN 40436 4966 10 even even RB 40436 4966 11 if if IN 40436 4966 12 all all DT 40436 4966 13 evil evil NN 40436 4966 14 were be VBD 40436 4966 15 banished banish VBN 40436 4966 16 , , , 40436 4966 17 the the DT 40436 4966 18 appetites appetite NNS 40436 4966 19 and and CC 40436 4966 20 desires desire NNS 40436 4966 21 , , , 40436 4966 22 such such JJ 40436 4966 23 of of IN 40436 4966 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 4966 25 as as IN 40436 4966 26 were be VBD 40436 4966 27 neither neither CC 40436 4966 28 good good JJ 40436 4966 29 nor nor CC 40436 4966 30 evil evil JJ 40436 4966 31 , , , 40436 4966 32 would would MD 40436 4966 33 still still RB 40436 4966 34 remain remain VB 40436 4966 35 : : : 40436 4966 36 and and CC 40436 4966 37 the the DT 40436 4966 38 things thing NNS 40436 4966 39 which which WDT 40436 4966 40 gratify gratify VBP 40436 4966 41 those those DT 40436 4966 42 appetites appetite NNS 40436 4966 43 will will MD 40436 4966 44 be be VB 40436 4966 45 dear dear JJ 40436 4966 46 to to IN 40436 4966 47 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4966 48 . . . 40436 4967 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4967 2 is be VBZ 40436 4967 3 not not RB 40436 4967 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 4967 5 true true JJ 40436 4967 6 that that IN 40436 4967 7 evil evil NN 40436 4967 8 is be VBZ 40436 4967 9 the the DT 40436 4967 10 cause cause NN 40436 4967 11 of of IN 40436 4967 12 things thing NNS 40436 4967 13 being be VBG 40436 4967 14 dear dear JJ 40436 4967 15 to to IN 40436 4967 16 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4967 17 . . . 40436 4968 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4968 2 have have VBP 40436 4968 3 just just RB 40436 4968 4 found find VBN 40436 4968 5 out out RP 40436 4968 6 another another DT 40436 4968 7 cause cause NN 40436 4968 8 for for IN 40436 4968 9 loving love VBG 40436 4968 10 and and CC 40436 4968 11 being be VBG 40436 4968 12 loved love VBN 40436 4968 13 -- -- : 40436 4968 14 desire desire NN 40436 4968 15 . . . 40436 4969 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4969 2 who who WP 40436 4969 3 desires desire VBZ 40436 4969 4 , , , 40436 4969 5 loves love VBZ 40436 4969 6 what what WP 40436 4969 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4969 8 desires desire VBZ 40436 4969 9 and and CC 40436 4969 10 as as RB 40436 4969 11 long long RB 40436 4969 12 as as IN 40436 4969 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4969 14 desires desire VBZ 40436 4969 15 : : : 40436 4969 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4969 17 desires desire VBZ 40436 4969 18 moreover moreover RB 40436 4969 19 that that IN 40436 4969 20 of of IN 40436 4969 21 which which WDT 40436 4969 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4969 23 is be VBZ 40436 4969 24 in in IN 40436 4969 25 want want NN 40436 4969 26 , , , 40436 4969 27 and and CC 40436 4969 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4969 29 is be VBZ 40436 4969 30 in in IN 40436 4969 31 want want NN 40436 4969 32 of of IN 40436 4969 33 that that DT 40436 4969 34 which which WDT 40436 4969 35 has have VBZ 40436 4969 36 been be VBN 40436 4969 37 taken take VBN 40436 4969 38 away away RB 40436 4969 39 from from IN 40436 4969 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4969 41 -- -- : 40436 4969 42 of of IN 40436 4969 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4969 44 own own JJ 40436 4969 45 . . . 40436 4970 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4970 2 23 23 CD 40436 4970 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4970 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4970 5 is be VBZ 40436 4970 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 4970 7 this this DT 40436 4970 8 _ _ NNP 40436 4970 9 own own JJ 40436 4970 10 _ _ NNP 40436 4970 11 which which WDT 40436 4970 12 is be VBZ 40436 4970 13 the the DT 40436 4970 14 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 4970 15 object object NN 40436 4970 16 of of IN 40436 4970 17 desire desire NN 40436 4970 18 , , , 40436 4970 19 friendship friendship NN 40436 4970 20 , , , 40436 4970 21 and and CC 40436 4970 22 love love NN 40436 4970 23 . . . 40436 4971 1 If if IN 40436 4971 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4971 3 two two CD 40436 4971 4 , , , 40436 4971 5 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 4971 6 and and CC 40436 4971 7 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4971 8 , , , 40436 4971 9 love love VB 40436 4971 10 each each DT 40436 4971 11 other other JJ 40436 4971 12 , , , 40436 4971 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4971 14 is be VBZ 40436 4971 15 because because IN 40436 4971 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 4971 17 are be VBP 40436 4971 18 somehow somehow RB 40436 4971 19 of of IN 40436 4971 20 kindred kindred JJ 40436 4971 21 nature nature NN 40436 4971 22 with with IN 40436 4971 23 each each DT 40436 4971 24 other other JJ 40436 4971 25 . . . 40436 4972 1 The the DT 40436 4972 2 lover lover NN 40436 4972 3 would would MD 40436 4972 4 not not RB 40436 4972 5 become become VB 40436 4972 6 a a DT 40436 4972 7 lover lover NN 40436 4972 8 , , , 40436 4972 9 unless unless IN 40436 4972 10 there there EX 40436 4972 11 were be VBD 40436 4972 12 , , , 40436 4972 13 between between IN 40436 4972 14 him -PRON- PRP 40436 4972 15 and and CC 40436 4972 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4972 17 beloved beloved JJ 40436 4972 18 , , , 40436 4972 19 a a DT 40436 4972 20 certain certain JJ 40436 4972 21 kinship kinship NN 40436 4972 22 or or CC 40436 4972 23 affinity affinity NN 40436 4972 24 in in IN 40436 4972 25 mind mind NN 40436 4972 26 , , , 40436 4972 27 disposition disposition NN 40436 4972 28 , , , 40436 4972 29 tastes taste NNS 40436 4972 30 , , , 40436 4972 31 or or CC 40436 4972 32 form form NN 40436 4972 33 . . . 40436 4973 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4973 2 love love VBP 40436 4973 3 , , , 40436 4973 4 by by IN 40436 4973 5 necessary necessary JJ 40436 4973 6 law law NN 40436 4973 7 , , , 40436 4973 8 that that WDT 40436 4973 9 which which WDT 40436 4973 10 has have VBZ 40436 4973 11 a a DT 40436 4973 12 natural natural JJ 40436 4973 13 affinity affinity NN 40436 4973 14 to to IN 40436 4973 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4973 16 ; ; : 40436 4973 17 so so IN 40436 4973 18 that that IN 40436 4973 19 the the DT 40436 4973 20 real real JJ 40436 4973 21 and and CC 40436 4973 22 genuine genuine JJ 40436 4973 23 lover lover NN 40436 4973 24 may may MD 40436 4973 25 be be VB 40436 4973 26 certain certain JJ 40436 4973 27 of of IN 40436 4973 28 a a DT 40436 4973 29 return return NN 40436 4973 30 of of IN 40436 4973 31 affection affection NN 40436 4973 32 from from IN 40436 4973 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4973 34 beloved beloved JJ 40436 4973 35 . . . 40436 4974 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4974 2 24 24 CD 40436 4974 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4974 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4974 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4974 6 22 22 CD 40436 4974 7 : : : 40436 4974 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4974 9 , , , 40436 4974 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4974 11 , , , 40436 4974 12 220 220 CD 40436 4974 13 D. D. NNP 40436 4974 14 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4974 15 may may MD 40436 4974 16 see see VB 40436 4974 17 that that DT 40436 4974 18 in in IN 40436 4974 19 this this DT 40436 4974 20 chapter chapter NN 40436 4974 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4974 22 runs run VBZ 40436 4974 23 into into IN 40436 4974 24 a a DT 40436 4974 25 confusion confusion NN 40436 4974 26 between between IN 40436 4974 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4974 28 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4974 29 : : : 40436 4974 30 to\ to\ NN 40436 4974 31 dia/ dia/ NNP 40436 4974 32 ti ti NN 40436 4974 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4974 34 and and CC 40436 4974 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4974 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4974 37 : : : 40436 4974 38 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4974 39 e(/neka/ e(/neka/ NNP 40436 4974 40 tou tou NNP 40436 4974 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4974 42 , , , 40436 4974 43 which which WDT 40436 4974 44 two two CD 40436 4974 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4974 46 began begin VBD 40436 4974 47 by by IN 40436 4974 48 carefully carefully RB 40436 4974 49 distinguishing distinguish VBG 40436 4974 50 . . . 40436 4975 1 Thus thus RB 40436 4975 2 in in IN 40436 4975 3 218 218 CD 40436 4975 4 D d NN 40436 4975 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4975 6 says say VBZ 40436 4975 7 , , , 40436 4975 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4975 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4975 10 : : : 40436 4975 11 o o NNP 40436 4975 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4975 13 phi phi NNP 40436 4975 14 / / SYM 40436 4975 15 los los NNP 40436 4975 16 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 4975 17 tô| tô| NNP 40436 4975 18 phi phi NNP 40436 4975 19 / / SYM 40436 4975 20 los los NNP 40436 4975 21 -- -- : 40436 4975 22 e(/neka/ e(/neka/ NNP 40436 4975 23 tou tou NNP 40436 4975 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4975 25 dia/ dia/ NNP 40436 4975 26 ti ti NNP 40436 4975 27 . . . 40436 4975 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4976 1 Again again RB 40436 4976 2 219 219 CD 40436 4976 3 A a DT 40436 4976 4 , , , 40436 4976 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4976 6 says--[Greek says--[greek XX 40436 4976 7 : : : 40436 4976 8 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4976 9 sô sô NNP 40436 4976 10 = = SYM 40436 4976 11 ma ma NNP 40436 4976 12 tê tê NNP 40436 4976 13 = = SYM 40436 4976 14 s s NNP 40436 4976 15 i)atrikê i)atrikê NNP 40436 4976 16 = = SYM 40436 4976 17 s s NNP 40436 4976 18 phi phi NNP 40436 4976 19 / / SYM 40436 4976 20 lon lon NNP 40436 4976 21 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 4976 22 / / SYM 40436 4976 23 n n NNP 40436 4976 24 , , , 40436 4976 25 _ _ NNP 40436 4976 26 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 4976 27 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 4976 28 no no NNP 40436 4976 29 / / SYM 40436 4976 30 son son NN 40436 4976 31 , , , 40436 4976 32 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 4976 33 tê tê NNP 40436 4976 34 = = SYM 40436 4976 35 s s NNP 40436 4976 36 u(giei u(giei NNP 40436 4976 37 / / SYM 40436 4976 38 as as IN 40436 4976 39 _ _ NNP 40436 4976 40 . . . 40436 4976 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4977 1 This this DT 40436 4977 2 is be VBZ 40436 4977 3 a a DT 40436 4977 4 very very RB 40436 4977 5 clear clear JJ 40436 4977 6 and and CC 40436 4977 7 important important JJ 40436 4977 8 distinction distinction NN 40436 4977 9 . . . 40436 4978 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 4978 2 is be VBZ 40436 4978 3 continued continue VBN 40436 4978 4 in in IN 40436 4978 5 220 220 CD 40436 4978 6 D--[Greek d--[greek NN 40436 4978 7 : : : 40436 4978 8 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 4978 9 _ _ NNP 40436 4978 10 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 4978 11 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4978 12 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 4978 13 _ _ NNP 40436 4978 14 ta)gatho\n ta)gatho\n NNP 40436 4978 15 ê)gapô ê)gapô , 40436 4978 16 = = SYM 40436 4978 17 men man NNS 40436 4978 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4978 19 e)philou e)philou , 40436 4978 20 = = SYM 40436 4978 21 men man NNS 40436 4978 22 , , , 40436 4978 23 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 4978 24 pha pha NN 40436 4978 25 / / SYM 40436 4978 26 rmakon rmakon JJ 40436 4978 27 o)\n o)\n JJ 40436 4978 28 tou= tou= NNP 40436 4978 29 kakou= kakou= NN 40436 4978 30 to\ to\ NN 40436 4978 31 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 4978 32 / / SYM 40436 4978 33 n n NN 40436 4978 34 , , , 40436 4978 35 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4978 36 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4978 37 kako kako NNP 40436 4978 38 / / SYM 40436 4978 39 n n NNP 40436 4978 40 no no NNP 40436 4978 41 / / SYM 40436 4978 42 sma sma NN 40436 4978 43 . . . 40436 4978 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4979 1 But but CC 40436 4979 2 in in IN 40436 4979 3 220 220 CD 40436 4979 4 E--[Greek e--[greek NN 40436 4979 5 : : : 40436 4979 6 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4979 7 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4979 8 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 4979 9 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 4979 10 phi phi NNP 40436 4979 11 / / SYM 40436 4979 12 lon lon NNP 40436 4979 13 pa pa NNP 40436 4979 14 = = SYM 40436 4979 15 n n NNP 40436 4979 16 tou)nanti tou)nanti NNP 40436 4979 17 / / , 40436 4979 18 on on IN 40436 4979 19 tou tou NNP 40436 4979 20 / / SYM 40436 4979 21 tou tou NNP 40436 4979 22 phai phai NNP 40436 4979 23 / / SYM 40436 4979 24 netai netai NNP 40436 4979 25 pephuko pephuko NNP 40436 4979 26 / / SYM 40436 4979 27 s s NNP 40436 4979 28 ; ; : 40436 4979 29 _ _ NNP 40436 4979 30 phi phi NNP 40436 4979 31 / / SYM 40436 4979 32 lon lon NN 40436 4979 33 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 4979 34 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 4979 35 = = SYM 40436 4979 36 n n CC 40436 4979 37 a)nepha a)nepha CD 40436 4979 38 / / SYM 40436 4979 39 nê nê NNP 40436 4979 40 o(\n o(\n NNP 40436 4979 41 e(chthrou= e(chthrou= NNP 40436 4979 42 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 4979 43 _ _ NNP 40436 4979 44 . . . 40436 4979 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4980 1 To to TO 40436 4980 2 make make VB 40436 4980 3 the the DT 40436 4980 4 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 4980 5 consistent consistent JJ 40436 4980 6 with with IN 40436 4980 7 what what WP 40436 4980 8 had have VBD 40436 4980 9 gone go VBN 40436 4980 10 before before RB 40436 4980 11 , , , 40436 4980 12 these these DT 40436 4980 13 two two CD 40436 4980 14 last last JJ 40436 4980 15 words word NNS 40436 4980 16 ought ought MD 40436 4980 17 to to TO 40436 4980 18 be be VB 40436 4980 19 exchanged exchange VBN 40436 4980 20 for for IN 40436 4980 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4980 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4980 23 : : : 40436 4980 24 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 4980 25 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4980 26 e)chthro e)chthro , 40436 4980 27 / / SYM 40436 4980 28 n n NN 40436 4980 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4980 30 . . . 40436 4981 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4981 2 had have VBD 40436 4981 3 laid lay VBN 40436 4981 4 down down RP 40436 4981 5 the the DT 40436 4981 6 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 4981 7 that that IN 40436 4981 8 good good NN 40436 4981 9 is be VBZ 40436 4981 10 loved--[Greek loved--[greek CD 40436 4981 11 : : : 40436 4981 12 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 4981 13 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4981 14 kako kako NNP 40436 4981 15 / / SYM 40436 4981 16 n n NNP 40436 4981 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4981 18 , , , 40436 4981 19 not not RB 40436 4981 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4981 21 Greek greek NN 40436 4981 22 : : : 40436 4981 23 e(/neka e(/neka VB 40436 4981 24 tou= tou= NNP 40436 4981 25 kakou= kakou= NN 40436 4981 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4981 27 . . . 40436 4982 1 Good good JJ 40436 4982 2 is be VBZ 40436 4982 3 loved love VBN 40436 4982 4 on on IN 40436 4982 5 _ _ NNP 40436 4982 6 account account NN 40436 4982 7 of of IN 40436 4982 8 evil evil JJ 40436 4982 9 _ _ NNP 40436 4982 10 , , , 40436 4982 11 but but CC 40436 4982 12 for for IN 40436 4982 13 _ _ NNP 40436 4982 14 the the DT 40436 4982 15 sake sake NN 40436 4982 16 of of IN 40436 4982 17 obtaining obtain VBG 40436 4982 18 _ _ NNP 40436 4982 19 a a DT 40436 4982 20 remedy remedy NN 40436 4982 21 to to IN 40436 4982 22 or or CC 40436 4982 23 cessation cessation NN 40436 4982 24 of of IN 40436 4982 25 the the DT 40436 4982 26 evil evil NN 40436 4982 27 . . . 40436 4983 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4983 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4983 3 in in IN 40436 4983 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4983 5 note note NN 40436 4983 6 on on IN 40436 4983 7 Hieron Hieron NNP 40436 4983 8 . . . 40436 4984 1 Müller Müller NNP 40436 4984 2 's 's POS 40436 4984 3 translation translation NN 40436 4984 4 of of IN 40436 4984 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4984 6 , , , 40436 4984 7 p. p. NN 40436 4984 8 268 268 CD 40436 4984 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4984 10 calls call VBZ 40436 4984 11 this this DT 40436 4984 12 a a DT 40436 4984 13 " " `` 40436 4984 14 sophistisches sophistische VBZ 40436 4984 15 Räthselspiel Räthselspiel NNP 40436 4984 16 " " '' 40436 4984 17 ; ; : 40436 4984 18 and and CC 40436 4984 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4984 20 notes note VBZ 40436 4984 21 other other JJ 40436 4984 22 portions portion NNS 40436 4984 23 of of IN 40436 4984 24 the the DT 40436 4984 25 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 4984 26 which which WDT 40436 4984 27 " " `` 40436 4984 28 remind remind VBP 40436 4984 29 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4984 30 of of IN 40436 4984 31 the the DT 40436 4984 32 deceptive deceptive JJ 40436 4984 33 tricks trick NNS 40436 4984 34 of of IN 40436 4984 35 the the DT 40436 4984 36 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 4984 37 " " '' 40436 4984 38 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4984 39 die die VB 40436 4984 40 Trugspiele Trugspiele NNP 40436 4984 41 der der NN 40436 4984 42 Sophisten Sophisten NNP 40436 4984 43 , , , 40436 4984 44 see see VB 40436 4984 45 p. p. NN 40436 4984 46 222 222 CD 40436 4984 47 - - SYM 40436 4984 48 224 224 CD 40436 4984 49 - - HYPH 40436 4984 50 227 227 CD 40436 4984 51 - - HYPH 40436 4984 52 230 230 CD 40436 4984 53 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4984 54 . . . 40436 4985 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 4985 2 praises praise VBZ 40436 4985 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4985 4 here here RB 40436 4985 5 for for IN 40436 4985 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 4985 7 " " `` 40436 4985 8 fine fine JJ 40436 4985 9 pleasantry pleasantry NN 40436 4985 10 on on IN 40436 4985 11 the the DT 40436 4985 12 deceptive deceptive JJ 40436 4985 13 arts art NNS 40436 4985 14 of of IN 40436 4985 15 the the DT 40436 4985 16 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 4985 17 " " '' 40436 4985 18 . . . 40436 4986 1 Admitting admit VBG 40436 4986 2 that that IN 40436 4986 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4986 4 puts put VBZ 40436 4986 5 forward forward RB 40436 4986 6 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 4986 7 quibbles quibble NNS 40436 4986 8 with with IN 40436 4986 9 the the DT 40436 4986 10 word word NN 40436 4986 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4986 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4986 13 : : : 40436 4986 14 phi phi NNP 40436 4986 15 / / SYM 40436 4986 16 los los NNP 40436 4986 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4986 18 , , , 40436 4986 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 4986 20 tells tell VBZ 40436 4986 21 us -PRON- PRP 40436 4986 22 that that IN 40436 4986 23 this this DT 40436 4986 24 is be VBZ 40436 4986 25 suitable suitable JJ 40436 4986 26 for for IN 40436 4986 27 the the DT 40436 4986 28 purpose purpose NN 40436 4986 29 of of IN 40436 4986 30 puzzling puzzle VBG 40436 4986 31 the the DT 40436 4986 32 contentious contentious JJ 40436 4986 33 young young JJ 40436 4986 34 man man NN 40436 4986 35 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 4986 36 . . . 40436 4987 1 The the DT 40436 4987 2 confusion confusion NN 40436 4987 3 between between IN 40436 4987 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4987 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4987 6 : : : 40436 4987 7 e(/neka/ e(/neka/ NNP 40436 4987 8 tou tou NNP 40436 4987 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4987 10 and and CC 40436 4987 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4987 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4987 13 : : : 40436 4987 14 dia/ dia/ NNP 40436 4987 15 ti ti NNP 40436 4987 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4987 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4987 18 noticed notice VBN 40436 4987 19 above above RB 40436 4987 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4987 21 appears appear VBZ 40436 4987 22 to to TO 40436 4987 23 be be VB 40436 4987 24 numbered number VBN 40436 4987 25 by by IN 40436 4987 26 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 4987 27 among among IN 40436 4987 28 the the DT 40436 4987 29 fine fine JJ 40436 4987 30 jests jest NNS 40436 4987 31 against against IN 40436 4987 32 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 4987 33 , , , 40436 4987 34 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 4987 35 , , , 40436 4987 36 or or CC 40436 4987 37 some some DT 40436 4987 38 of of IN 40436 4987 39 the the DT 40436 4987 40 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 4987 41 . . . 40436 4988 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 4988 2 can can MD 40436 4988 3 see see VB 40436 4988 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 4988 5 in in IN 40436 4988 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 4988 7 except except IN 40436 4988 8 an an DT 40436 4988 9 unconscious unconscious JJ 40436 4988 10 inaccuracy inaccuracy NN 40436 4988 11 in in IN 40436 4988 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4988 13 's 's POS 40436 4988 14 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 4988 15 . . . 40436 4988 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4989 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4989 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4989 3 23 23 CD 40436 4989 4 : : : 40436 4989 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4989 6 , , , 40436 4989 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4989 8 , , , 40436 4989 9 221 221 CD 40436 4989 10 E. E. NNP 40436 4989 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4989 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4989 13 : : : 40436 4989 14 To\ To\ NNP 40436 4989 15 e)pithumou e)pithumou CD 40436 4989 16 = = SYM 40436 4989 17 n n NN 40436 4989 18 ou(= ou(= CD 40436 4989 19 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 4989 20 e)ndee\s e)ndee\s NNP 40436 4989 21 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 4989 22 , , , 40436 4989 23 tou tou NNP 40436 4989 24 / / SYM 40436 4989 25 tou tou NNP 40436 4989 26 e)pithumei=--e)ndee\s e)pithumei=--e)ndee\s NNP 40436 4989 27 de\ de\ NNP 40436 4989 28 gi gi NNP 40436 4989 29 / / SYM 40436 4989 30 gnetai gnetai NNP 40436 4989 31 ou(= ou(= UH 40436 4989 32 a)/n a)/n UH 40436 4989 33 tis tis NNP 40436 4989 34 a)phairê a)phairê NNPS 40436 4989 35 = = SYM 40436 4989 36 tai tai NN 40436 4989 37 -- -- : 40436 4989 38 tou= tou= NNP 40436 4989 39 oi)kei oi)kei NNP 40436 4989 40 / / SYM 40436 4989 41 ou ou NNP 40436 4989 42 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 4989 43 , , , 40436 4989 44 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 4989 45 e)/oiken e)/oiken NNS 40436 4989 46 , , , 40436 4989 47 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 4989 48 te te NNP 40436 4989 49 e)/rôs e)/rôs NNP 40436 4989 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4989 51 ê ê NNP 40436 4989 52 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4989 53 phili phili NNP 40436 4989 54 / / SYM 40436 4989 55 a a DT 40436 4989 56 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 4989 57 ê ê NNP 40436 4989 58 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4989 59 e)pithumi e)pithumi NNP 40436 4989 60 / / SYM 40436 4989 61 a a DT 40436 4989 62 tugcha tugcha NN 40436 4989 63 / / SYM 40436 4989 64 nei nei NN 40436 4989 65 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 4989 66 . . . 40436 4989 67 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4990 1 This this DT 40436 4990 2 is be VBZ 40436 4990 3 the the DT 40436 4990 4 same same JJ 40436 4990 5 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 4990 6 as as IN 40436 4990 7 that that DT 40436 4990 8 which which WDT 40436 4990 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4990 10 read read VBP 40436 4990 11 , , , 40436 4990 12 expanded expand VBD 40436 4990 13 and and CC 40436 4990 14 cast cast VBN 40436 4990 15 into into IN 40436 4990 16 a a DT 40436 4990 17 myth myth NN 40436 4990 18 with with IN 40436 4990 19 comic comic JJ 40436 4990 20 turn turn NN 40436 4990 21 , , , 40436 4990 22 in in IN 40436 4990 23 the the DT 40436 4990 24 speech speech NN 40436 4990 25 of of IN 40436 4990 26 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40436 4990 27 in in IN 40436 4990 28 the the DT 40436 4990 29 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 4990 30 , , , 40436 4990 31 pp pp NNP 40436 4990 32 . . . 40436 4991 1 191 191 CD 40436 4991 2 - - HYPH 40436 4991 3 192 192 CD 40436 4991 4 - - HYPH 40436 4991 5 193 193 CD 40436 4991 6 . . . 40436 4992 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4992 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 4992 3 : : : 40436 4992 4 e(/kastos e(/kastos NN 40436 4992 5 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 4992 6 ê(mô ê(mô NNP 40436 4992 7 = = SYM 40436 4992 8 n n NNP 40436 4992 9 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 4992 10 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 4992 11 / / SYM 40436 4992 12 pou pou NNP 40436 4992 13 su su NNP 40436 4992 14 / / SYM 40436 4992 15 mbolon mbolon NNP 40436 4992 16 , , , 40436 4992 17 a)/te a)/te NNP 40436 4992 18 tetmême tetmême NN 40436 4992 19 / / SYM 40436 4992 20 nos nos NNP 40436 4992 21 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 4992 22 ai ai VBP 40436 4992 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4992 24 psê psê NNP 40436 4992 25 = = SYM 40436 4992 26 ttai ttai NNP 40436 4992 27 e)x e)x NNP 40436 4992 28 e(no\s e(no\s NNP 40436 4992 29 du du NNP 40436 4992 30 / / SYM 40436 4992 31 o o NN 40436 4992 32 . . . 40436 4993 1 zêtei= zêtei= NNP 40436 4993 2 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 4993 3 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 4993 4 to\ to\ NN 40436 4993 5 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 4993 6 e(/kastos e(/kastos NNP 40436 4993 7 xu xu NNP 40436 4993 8 / / SYM 40436 4993 9 mbolon mbolon NNP 40436 4993 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4993 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4993 12 191 191 CD 40436 4993 13 D)--[Greek d)--[greek NN 40436 4993 14 : : : 40436 4993 15 dikai dikai NNP 40436 4993 16 / / SYM 40436 4993 17 ôs ôs NNP 40436 4993 18 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 4993 19 u(mnoi u(mnoi NN 40436 4993 20 = = NFP 40436 4993 21 men man NNS 40436 4993 22 E)/rôta E)/rôta NNP 40436 4993 23 , , , 40436 4993 24 o(\s o(\s NNP 40436 4993 25 e)/n e)/n NNP 40436 4993 26 te te NNP 40436 4993 27 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 4993 28 paro paro NNP 40436 4993 29 / / SYM 40436 4993 30 nti nti NNP 40436 4993 31 plei plei NNP 40436 4993 32 = = SYM 40436 4993 33 sta sta NNP 40436 4993 34 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 4993 35 = = SYM 40436 4993 36 s s NNP 40436 4993 37 o)ni o)ni NNP 40436 4993 38 / / SYM 40436 4993 39 nêsin nêsin NNP 40436 4993 40 ei)s ei)s , 40436 4993 41 to\ to\ NNP 40436 4993 42 oi)kei oi)kei NNP 40436 4993 43 = = NFP 40436 4993 44 on on IN 40436 4993 45 a)/gôn a)/gôn NNP 40436 4993 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4993 47 , , , 40436 4993 48 & & CC 40436 4993 49 c. c. NNP 40436 4993 50 ( ( -LRB- 40436 4993 51 193 193 CD 40436 4993 52 D D NNP 40436 4993 53 ) ) -RRB- 40436 4993 54 . . . 40436 4993 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4994 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4994 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 4994 3 24 24 CD 40436 4994 4 : : : 40436 4994 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 4994 6 , , , 40436 4994 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 4994 8 , , , 40436 4994 9 221 221 CD 40436 4994 10 - - SYM 40436 4994 11 222 222 CD 40436 4994 12 . . . 40436 4994 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4995 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 4995 2 Side side NN 40436 4995 3 - - HYPH 40436 4995 4 note note NN 40436 4995 5 : : : 40436 4995 6 Good good JJ 40436 4995 7 is be VBZ 40436 4995 8 of of IN 40436 4995 9 a a DT 40436 4995 10 nature nature NN 40436 4995 11 akin akin JJ 40436 4995 12 to to IN 40436 4995 13 every every DT 40436 4995 14 one one CD 40436 4995 15 , , , 40436 4995 16 evil evil NN 40436 4995 17 is be VBZ 40436 4995 18 alien alien JJ 40436 4995 19 to to IN 40436 4995 20 every every DT 40436 4995 21 one one CD 40436 4995 22 . . . 40436 4996 1 Inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 4996 2 with with IN 40436 4996 3 what what WP 40436 4996 4 has have VBZ 40436 4996 5 been be VBN 40436 4996 6 previously previously RB 40436 4996 7 laid lay VBN 40436 4996 8 down down RP 40436 4996 9 . . . 40436 4996 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 4997 1 But but CC 40436 4997 2 is be VBZ 40436 4997 3 there there EX 40436 4997 4 any any DT 40436 4997 5 real real JJ 40436 4997 6 difference difference NN 40436 4997 7 between between IN 40436 4997 8 what what WP 40436 4997 9 is be VBZ 40436 4997 10 akin akin JJ 40436 4997 11 and and CC 40436 4997 12 what what WP 40436 4997 13 is be VBZ 40436 4997 14 like like IN 40436 4997 15 ? ? . 40436 4998 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 4998 2 must must MD 40436 4998 3 assume assume VB 40436 4998 4 that that IN 40436 4998 5 there there EX 40436 4998 6 is be VBZ 40436 4998 7 : : : 40436 4998 8 for for IN 40436 4998 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4998 10 showed show VBD 40436 4998 11 before before RB 40436 4998 12 , , , 40436 4998 13 that that IN 40436 4998 14 like like UH 40436 4998 15 was be VBD 40436 4998 16 useless useless JJ 40436 4998 17 to to TO 40436 4998 18 like like UH 40436 4998 19 , , , 40436 4998 20 and and CC 40436 4998 21 therefore therefore RB 40436 4998 22 not not RB 40436 4998 23 dear dear JJ 40436 4998 24 to to TO 40436 4998 25 like like UH 40436 4998 26 . . . 40436 4999 1 Shall Shall MD 40436 4999 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 4999 3 say say VB 40436 4999 4 that that IN 40436 4999 5 good good JJ 40436 4999 6 is be VBZ 40436 4999 7 of of IN 40436 4999 8 a a DT 40436 4999 9 nature nature NN 40436 4999 10 akin akin JJ 40436 4999 11 to to IN 40436 4999 12 every every DT 40436 4999 13 one one CD 40436 4999 14 , , , 40436 4999 15 and and CC 40436 4999 16 evil evil NN 40436 4999 17 of of IN 40436 4999 18 a a DT 40436 4999 19 nature nature NN 40436 4999 20 foreign foreign JJ 40436 4999 21 to to IN 40436 4999 22 every every DT 40436 4999 23 one one CD 40436 4999 24 ? ? . 40436 5000 1 If if IN 40436 5000 2 so so RB 40436 5000 3 , , , 40436 5000 4 then then RB 40436 5000 5 there there EX 40436 5000 6 can can MD 40436 5000 7 be be VB 40436 5000 8 no no DT 40436 5000 9 friendship friendship NN 40436 5000 10 except except IN 40436 5000 11 between between IN 40436 5000 12 one one CD 40436 5000 13 good good JJ 40436 5000 14 man man NN 40436 5000 15 and and CC 40436 5000 16 another another DT 40436 5000 17 good good JJ 40436 5000 18 man man NN 40436 5000 19 . . . 40436 5001 1 But but CC 40436 5001 2 this this DT 40436 5001 3 too too RB 40436 5001 4 has have VBZ 40436 5001 5 been be VBN 40436 5001 6 proved prove VBN 40436 5001 7 to to TO 40436 5001 8 be be VB 40436 5001 9 impossible impossible JJ 40436 5001 10 . . . 40436 5002 1 All all DT 40436 5002 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5002 3 tentatives tentative NNS 40436 5002 4 have have VBP 40436 5002 5 been be VBN 40436 5002 6 alike alike RB 40436 5002 7 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 40436 5002 8 . . . 40436 5003 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5003 2 Side side NN 40436 5003 3 - - HYPH 40436 5003 4 note note NN 40436 5003 5 : : : 40436 5003 6 Failure failure NN 40436 5003 7 of of IN 40436 5003 8 the the DT 40436 5003 9 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 5003 10 . . . 40436 5004 1 Close close NN 40436 5004 2 of of IN 40436 5004 3 the the DT 40436 5004 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5004 5 . . . 40436 5004 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5005 1 In in IN 40436 5005 2 this this DT 40436 5005 3 dilemma dilemma NN 40436 5005 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5005 5 continues continue VBZ 40436 5005 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5005 7 , , , 40436 5005 8 the the DT 40436 5005 9 narrator narrator NN 40436 5005 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5005 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5005 12 was be VBD 40436 5005 13 about about JJ 40436 5005 14 to to TO 40436 5005 15 ask ask VB 40436 5005 16 assistance assistance NN 40436 5005 17 from from IN 40436 5005 18 some some DT 40436 5005 19 of of IN 40436 5005 20 the the DT 40436 5005 21 older old JJR 40436 5005 22 men man NNS 40436 5005 23 around around RB 40436 5005 24 . . . 40436 5006 1 But but CC 40436 5006 2 the the DT 40436 5006 3 tutors tutor NNS 40436 5006 4 of of IN 40436 5006 5 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 5006 6 and and CC 40436 5006 7 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5006 8 came come VBD 40436 5006 9 up up RP 40436 5006 10 to to IN 40436 5006 11 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5006 12 and and CC 40436 5006 13 insisted insist VBD 40436 5006 14 on on IN 40436 5006 15 conveying convey VBG 40436 5006 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5006 17 pupils pupil NNS 40436 5006 18 home home RB 40436 5006 19 -- -- : 40436 5006 20 the the DT 40436 5006 21 hour hour NN 40436 5006 22 being be VBG 40436 5006 23 late late JJ 40436 5006 24 . . . 40436 5007 1 As as IN 40436 5007 2 the the DT 40436 5007 3 youths youth NNS 40436 5007 4 were be VBD 40436 5007 5 departing depart VBG 40436 5007 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5007 7 said say VBD 40436 5007 8 to to IN 40436 5007 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5007 10 -- -- : 40436 5007 11 Well well UH 40436 5007 12 , , , 40436 5007 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5007 14 must must MD 40436 5007 15 close close VB 40436 5007 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5007 17 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5007 18 with with IN 40436 5007 19 the the DT 40436 5007 20 confession confession NN 40436 5007 21 , , , 40436 5007 22 that that IN 40436 5007 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5007 24 have have VBP 40436 5007 25 all all DT 40436 5007 26 three three CD 40436 5007 27 made make VBN 40436 5007 28 a a DT 40436 5007 29 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 5007 30 figure figure NN 40436 5007 31 in in IN 40436 5007 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5007 33 : : : 40436 5007 34 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5007 35 , , , 40436 5007 36 an an DT 40436 5007 37 old old JJ 40436 5007 38 man man NN 40436 5007 39 , , , 40436 5007 40 as as RB 40436 5007 41 well well RB 40436 5007 42 as as IN 40436 5007 43 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5007 44 two two CD 40436 5007 45 youths youth NNS 40436 5007 46 . . . 40436 5008 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5008 2 hearers hearer NNS 40436 5008 3 will will MD 40436 5008 4 go go VB 40436 5008 5 away away RB 40436 5008 6 declaring declare VBG 40436 5008 7 , , , 40436 5008 8 that that IN 40436 5008 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5008 10 fancy fancy VBP 40436 5008 11 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5008 12 to to TO 40436 5008 13 be be VB 40436 5008 14 friends friend NNS 40436 5008 15 each each DT 40436 5008 16 to to IN 40436 5008 17 the the DT 40436 5008 18 other other JJ 40436 5008 19 two two CD 40436 5008 20 ; ; : 40436 5008 21 but but CC 40436 5008 22 that that IN 40436 5008 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5008 24 have have VBP 40436 5008 25 not not RB 40436 5008 26 yet yet RB 40436 5008 27 been be VBN 40436 5008 28 able able JJ 40436 5008 29 to to TO 40436 5008 30 find find VB 40436 5008 31 out out RP 40436 5008 32 what what WP 40436 5008 33 a a DT 40436 5008 34 friend friend NN 40436 5008 35 is be VBZ 40436 5008 36 . . . 40436 5009 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5009 2 25 25 CD 40436 5009 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5009 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5009 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5009 6 25 25 CD 40436 5009 7 : : : 40436 5009 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5009 9 , , , 40436 5009 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5009 11 , , , 40436 5009 12 223 223 CD 40436 5009 13 B. b. NN 40436 5010 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5010 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5010 3 : : : 40436 5010 4 Nu Nu NNP 40436 5010 5 = = SYM 40436 5010 6 n n CC 40436 5010 7 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5010 8 katage katage NN 40436 5010 9 / / SYM 40436 5010 10 lastoi lastoi NNP 40436 5010 11 gego gego NNP 40436 5010 12 / / SYM 40436 5010 13 namen namen NNP 40436 5010 14 e)gô/ e)gô/ NNP 40436 5010 15 te te NNP 40436 5010 16 , , , 40436 5010 17 gerô\n gerô\n ADD 40436 5010 18 a)nê a)nê NNP 40436 5010 19 / / SYM 40436 5010 20 r r NNP 40436 5010 21 , , , 40436 5010 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5010 23 u(mei u(mei NNP 40436 5010 24 = = SYM 40436 5010 25 s s NNP 40436 5010 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5010 27 , , , 40436 5010 28 & & CC 40436 5010 29 c. c. NNP 40436 5010 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5010 31 * * NFP 40436 5010 32 * * NFP 40436 5010 33 * * NFP 40436 5010 34 * * NFP 40436 5010 35 * * NFP 40436 5010 36 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5010 37 Side side NN 40436 5010 38 - - HYPH 40436 5010 39 note note NN 40436 5010 40 : : : 40436 5010 41 Remarks remark NNS 40436 5010 42 . . . 40436 5011 1 No no DT 40436 5011 2 positive positive JJ 40436 5011 3 result result NN 40436 5011 4 . . . 40436 5012 1 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 5012 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 5012 3 in in IN 40436 5012 4 analysing analyse VBG 40436 5012 5 the the DT 40436 5012 6 familiar familiar JJ 40436 5012 7 words word NNS 40436 5012 8 -- -- : 40436 5012 9 to to TO 40436 5012 10 expose expose VB 40436 5012 11 the the DT 40436 5012 12 false false JJ 40436 5012 13 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 5012 14 of of IN 40436 5012 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5012 16 . . . 40436 5012 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5013 1 Thus thus RB 40436 5013 2 ends end VBZ 40436 5013 3 the the DT 40436 5013 4 main main JJ 40436 5013 5 discussion discussion NN 40436 5013 6 of of IN 40436 5013 7 the the DT 40436 5013 8 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5013 9 : : : 40436 5013 10 not not RB 40436 5013 11 only only RB 40436 5013 12 without without IN 40436 5013 13 any any DT 40436 5013 14 positive positive JJ 40436 5013 15 result result NN 40436 5013 16 , , , 40436 5013 17 but but CC 40436 5013 18 with with IN 40436 5013 19 speakers speaker NNS 40436 5013 20 and and CC 40436 5013 21 hearers hearer NNS 40436 5013 22 more more RBR 40436 5013 23 puzzled puzzle VBD 40436 5013 24 than than IN 40436 5013 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5013 26 were be VBD 40436 5013 27 at at IN 40436 5013 28 the the DT 40436 5013 29 beginning beginning NN 40436 5013 30 : : : 40436 5013 31 having have VBG 40436 5013 32 been be VBN 40436 5013 33 made make VBN 40436 5013 34 to to TO 40436 5013 35 feel feel VB 40436 5013 36 a a DT 40436 5013 37 great great JJ 40436 5013 38 many many JJ 40436 5013 39 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 5013 40 which which WDT 40436 5013 41 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5013 42 never never RB 40436 5013 43 felt feel VBD 40436 5013 44 before before RB 40436 5013 45 . . . 40436 5014 1 Nor nor CC 40436 5014 2 can can MD 40436 5014 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5014 4 perceive perceive VB 40436 5014 5 any any DT 40436 5014 6 general general JJ 40436 5014 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 5014 8 running run VBG 40436 5014 9 through through IN 40436 5014 10 the the DT 40436 5014 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5014 12 , , , 40436 5014 13 except except IN 40436 5014 14 that that DT 40436 5014 15 truly truly RB 40436 5014 16 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 5014 17 and and CC 40436 5014 18 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5014 19 purpose purpose NN 40436 5014 20 -- -- : 40436 5014 21 To to TO 40436 5014 22 show show VB 40436 5014 23 , , , 40436 5014 24 by by IN 40436 5014 25 cross cross NN 40436 5014 26 - - NN 40436 5014 27 examination examination NN 40436 5014 28 on on IN 40436 5014 29 the the DT 40436 5014 30 commonest common JJS 40436 5014 31 words word NNS 40436 5014 32 that that WDT 40436 5014 33 what what WP 40436 5014 34 every every DT 40436 5014 35 one one NN 40436 5014 36 appears appear VBZ 40436 5014 37 to to TO 40436 5014 38 know know VB 40436 5014 39 , , , 40436 5014 40 and and CC 40436 5014 41 talks talk NNS 40436 5014 42 about about IN 40436 5014 43 most most RBS 40436 5014 44 confidently confidently RB 40436 5014 45 , , , 40436 5014 46 no no DT 40436 5014 47 one one NN 40436 5014 48 really really RB 40436 5014 49 knows know VBZ 40436 5014 50 or or CC 40436 5014 51 can can MD 40436 5014 52 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 5014 53 explain explain VB 40436 5014 54 . . . 40436 5015 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5015 2 26 26 CD 40436 5015 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5015 4 This this DT 40436 5015 5 is be VBZ 40436 5015 6 the the DT 40436 5015 7 meaning meaning NN 40436 5015 8 of of IN 40436 5015 9 the the DT 40436 5015 10 final final JJ 40436 5015 11 declaration declaration NN 40436 5015 12 put put VBD 40436 5015 13 into into IN 40436 5015 14 the the DT 40436 5015 15 mouth mouth NN 40436 5015 16 of of IN 40436 5015 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5015 18 . . . 40436 5016 1 " " `` 40436 5016 2 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5016 3 believe believe VBP 40436 5016 4 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5016 5 to to TO 40436 5016 6 be be VB 40436 5016 7 each each DT 40436 5016 8 other other JJ 40436 5016 9 's 's POS 40436 5016 10 friends friend NNS 40436 5016 11 , , , 40436 5016 12 yet yet CC 40436 5016 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5016 14 none none NN 40436 5016 15 of of IN 40436 5016 16 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5016 17 know know VB 40436 5016 18 what what WP 40436 5016 19 a a DT 40436 5016 20 friend friend NN 40436 5016 21 is be VBZ 40436 5016 22 . . . 40436 5016 23 " " '' 40436 5017 1 The the DT 40436 5017 2 question question NN 40436 5017 3 is be VBZ 40436 5017 4 one one CD 40436 5017 5 , , , 40436 5017 6 which which WDT 40436 5017 7 no no DT 40436 5017 8 one one NN 40436 5017 9 had have VBD 40436 5017 10 ever ever RB 40436 5017 11 troubled trouble VBN 40436 5017 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5017 13 to to TO 40436 5017 14 investigate investigate VB 40436 5017 15 , , , 40436 5017 16 or or CC 40436 5017 17 thought think VBD 40436 5017 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5017 19 requisite requisite JJ 40436 5017 20 to to TO 40436 5017 21 ask ask VB 40436 5017 22 from from IN 40436 5017 23 others other NNS 40436 5017 24 . . . 40436 5018 1 Every every DT 40436 5018 2 one one NN 40436 5018 3 supposed suppose VBD 40436 5018 4 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5018 5 to to TO 40436 5018 6 know know VB 40436 5018 7 , , , 40436 5018 8 and and CC 40436 5018 9 every every DT 40436 5018 10 one one NN 40436 5018 11 had have VBD 40436 5018 12 in in IN 40436 5018 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5018 14 memory memory NN 40436 5018 15 an an DT 40436 5018 16 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 5018 17 of of IN 40436 5018 18 conceptions conception NNS 40436 5018 19 and and CC 40436 5018 20 beliefs belief NNS 40436 5018 21 which which WDT 40436 5018 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5018 23 accounted account VBD 40436 5018 24 tantamount tantamount JJ 40436 5018 25 to to IN 40436 5018 26 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5018 27 : : : 40436 5018 28 an an DT 40436 5018 29 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 5018 30 generated generate VBN 40436 5018 31 by by IN 40436 5018 32 the the DT 40436 5018 33 unconscious unconscious JJ 40436 5018 34 addition addition NN 40436 5018 35 of of IN 40436 5018 36 a a DT 40436 5018 37 thousand thousand CD 40436 5018 38 facts fact NNS 40436 5018 39 and and CC 40436 5018 40 associations association NNS 40436 5018 41 , , , 40436 5018 42 each each DT 40436 5018 43 separately separately RB 40436 5018 44 unimportant unimportant JJ 40436 5018 45 and and CC 40436 5018 46 often often RB 40436 5018 47 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 5018 48 with with IN 40436 5018 49 the the DT 40436 5018 50 remainder remainder NN 40436 5018 51 : : : 40436 5018 52 while while IN 40436 5018 53 no no DT 40436 5018 54 rational rational JJ 40436 5018 55 analysis analysis NN 40436 5018 56 had have VBD 40436 5018 57 ever ever RB 40436 5018 58 been be VBN 40436 5018 59 applied apply VBN 40436 5018 60 to to TO 40436 5018 61 verify verify VB 40436 5018 62 the the DT 40436 5018 63 consistency consistency NN 40436 5018 64 of of IN 40436 5018 65 this this DT 40436 5018 66 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 40436 5018 67 product product NN 40436 5018 68 , , , 40436 5018 69 or or CC 40436 5018 70 to to TO 40436 5018 71 define define VB 40436 5018 72 the the DT 40436 5018 73 familiar familiar JJ 40436 5018 74 words word NNS 40436 5018 75 in in IN 40436 5018 76 which which WDT 40436 5018 77 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5018 78 is be VBZ 40436 5018 79 expressed express VBN 40436 5018 80 . . . 40436 5019 1 The the DT 40436 5019 2 reader reader NN 40436 5019 3 is be VBZ 40436 5019 4 here here RB 40436 5019 5 involved involved JJ 40436 5019 6 in in IN 40436 5019 7 a a DT 40436 5019 8 cloud cloud NN 40436 5019 9 of of IN 40436 5019 10 confusion confusion NN 40436 5019 11 respecting respect VBG 40436 5019 12 Friendship friendship NN 40436 5019 13 . . . 40436 5020 1 No no DT 40436 5020 2 way way NN 40436 5020 3 out out IN 40436 5020 4 of of IN 40436 5020 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5020 6 is be VBZ 40436 5020 7 shown show VBN 40436 5020 8 , , , 40436 5020 9 and and CC 40436 5020 10 how how WRB 40436 5020 11 is be VBZ 40436 5020 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5020 13 to to TO 40436 5020 14 find find VB 40436 5020 15 one one CD 40436 5020 16 ? ? . 40436 5021 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5021 2 must must MD 40436 5021 3 take take VB 40436 5021 4 the the DT 40436 5021 5 matter matter NN 40436 5021 6 into into IN 40436 5021 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5021 8 own own JJ 40436 5021 9 active active JJ 40436 5021 10 and and CC 40436 5021 11 studious studious JJ 40436 5021 12 meditation meditation NN 40436 5021 13 : : : 40436 5021 14 which which WDT 40436 5021 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5021 16 has have VBZ 40436 5021 17 never never RB 40436 5021 18 yet yet RB 40436 5021 19 done do VBN 40436 5021 20 , , , 40436 5021 21 though though IN 40436 5021 22 the the DT 40436 5021 23 word word NN 40436 5021 24 is be VBZ 40436 5021 25 always always RB 40436 5021 26 in in IN 40436 5021 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5021 28 mouth mouth NN 40436 5021 29 , , , 40436 5021 30 and and CC 40436 5021 31 though though IN 40436 5021 32 the the DT 40436 5021 33 topic topic NN 40436 5021 34 is be VBZ 40436 5021 35 among among IN 40436 5021 36 the the DT 40436 5021 37 most most RBS 40436 5021 38 common common JJ 40436 5021 39 and and CC 40436 5021 40 familiar familiar JJ 40436 5021 41 , , , 40436 5021 42 upon upon IN 40436 5021 43 which which WDT 40436 5021 44 " " `` 40436 5021 45 the the DT 40436 5021 46 swain swain NN 40436 5021 47 treads tread VBZ 40436 5021 48 daily daily RB 40436 5021 49 with with IN 40436 5021 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5021 51 clouted clouted JJ 40436 5021 52 shoon shoon NN 40436 5021 53 " " '' 40436 5021 54 . . . 40436 5022 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5022 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5022 3 26 26 CD 40436 5022 4 : : : 40436 5022 5 Among among IN 40436 5022 6 the the DT 40436 5022 7 many many JJ 40436 5022 8 points point NNS 40436 5022 9 of of IN 40436 5022 10 analogy analogy NN 40436 5022 11 between between IN 40436 5022 12 the the DT 40436 5022 13 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5022 14 and and CC 40436 5022 15 the the DT 40436 5022 16 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 5022 17 , , , 40436 5022 18 one one CD 40436 5022 19 is be VBZ 40436 5022 20 , , , 40436 5022 21 That that IN 40436 5022 22 both both DT 40436 5022 23 of of IN 40436 5022 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5022 25 are be VBP 40436 5022 26 declared declare VBN 40436 5022 27 to to TO 40436 5022 28 be be VB 40436 5022 29 spurious spurious JJ 40436 5022 30 and and CC 40436 5022 31 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 5022 32 of of IN 40436 5022 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5022 34 , , , 40436 5022 35 by by IN 40436 5022 36 Socher Socher NNP 40436 5022 37 as as RB 40436 5022 38 well well RB 40436 5022 39 as as IN 40436 5022 40 by by IN 40436 5022 41 Ast Ast NNP 40436 5022 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5022 43 Ast Ast NNP 40436 5022 44 , , , 40436 5022 45 Platon Platon NNP 40436 5022 46 's 's POS 40436 5022 47 Leben Leben NNP 40436 5022 48 , , , 40436 5022 49 pp pp NNP 40436 5022 50 . . . 40436 5023 1 429 429 CD 40436 5023 2 - - SYM 40436 5023 3 434 434 CD 40436 5023 4 ; ; : 40436 5023 5 Socher Socher NNP 40436 5023 6 , , , 40436 5023 7 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 5023 8 Platon Platon NNP 40436 5023 9 , , , 40436 5023 10 pp pp NNP 40436 5023 11 . . . 40436 5024 1 137 137 CD 40436 5024 2 - - SYM 40436 5024 3 144 144 CD 40436 5024 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5024 5 . . . 40436 5025 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5025 2 ranks rank VBZ 40436 5025 3 the the DT 40436 5025 4 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5025 5 as as IN 40436 5025 6 second second JJ 40436 5025 7 in in IN 40436 5025 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5025 9 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5025 10 series series NN 40436 5025 11 of of IN 40436 5025 12 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5025 13 , , , 40436 5025 14 an an DT 40436 5025 15 appendix appendix NNP 40436 5025 16 to to IN 40436 5025 17 the the DT 40436 5025 18 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 5025 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5025 20 Einl Einl NNP 40436 5025 21 . . . 40436 5026 1 p. p. NN 40436 5026 2 174 174 CD 40436 5026 3 seq seq NN 40436 5026 4 . . . 40436 5027 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5027 2 ; ; : 40436 5027 3 K. K. NNP 40436 5027 4 F. F. NNP 40436 5027 5 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 5027 6 , , , 40436 5027 7 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5027 8 , , , 40436 5027 9 and and CC 40436 5027 10 nearly nearly RB 40436 5027 11 all all PDT 40436 5027 12 the the DT 40436 5027 13 other other JJ 40436 5027 14 critics critic NNS 40436 5027 15 dissent dissent NN 40436 5027 16 from from IN 40436 5027 17 this this DT 40436 5027 18 view view NN 40436 5027 19 : : : 40436 5027 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5027 21 place place VBP 40436 5027 22 the the DT 40436 5027 23 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5027 24 as as IN 40436 5027 25 an an DT 40436 5027 26 early early JJ 40436 5027 27 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5027 28 , , , 40436 5027 29 along along IN 40436 5027 30 with with IN 40436 5027 31 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 5027 32 and and CC 40436 5027 33 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 5027 34 , , , 40436 5027 35 anterior anterior NN 40436 5027 36 to to IN 40436 5027 37 the the DT 40436 5027 38 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5027 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5027 40 K. K. NNP 40436 5027 41 F. F. NNP 40436 5027 42 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 5027 43 , , , 40436 5027 44 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 5027 45 . . . 40436 5028 1 und und JJ 40436 5028 2 Syst Syst NNP 40436 5028 3 . . . 40436 5029 1 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5029 2 . . . 40436 5030 1 Phil Phil NNP 40436 5030 2 . . . 40436 5031 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5031 2 . . . 40436 5032 1 447 447 CD 40436 5032 2 - - SYM 40436 5032 3 448 448 CD 40436 5032 4 ; ; : 40436 5032 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5032 6 , , , 40436 5032 7 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 5032 8 . . . 40436 5033 1 ad ad NN 40436 5033 2 Lys Lys NNP 40436 5033 3 . . . 40436 5034 1 p. p. NN 40436 5034 2 90 90 CD 40436 5034 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5034 4 110 110 CD 40436 5034 5 2nd 2nd JJ 40436 5034 6 ed ed NN 40436 5034 7 . . . 40436 5035 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5035 2 ; ; : 40436 5035 3 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 5035 4 , , , 40436 5035 5 Einl Einl NNP 40436 5035 6 . . . 40436 5036 1 p. p. NN 40436 5036 2 221 221 CD 40436 5036 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5036 4 near near RB 40436 5036 5 to to IN 40436 5036 6 or or CC 40436 5036 7 during during IN 40436 5036 8 the the DT 40436 5036 9 government government NN 40436 5036 10 of of IN 40436 5036 11 the the DT 40436 5036 12 Thirty Thirty NNP 40436 5036 13 . . . 40436 5037 1 All all DT 40436 5037 2 of of IN 40436 5037 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5037 4 profess profess JJ 40436 5037 5 to to TO 40436 5037 6 discover discover VB 40436 5037 7 in in IN 40436 5037 8 the the DT 40436 5037 9 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5037 10 " " '' 40436 5037 11 adolescentiæ adolescentiæ NN 40436 5037 12 vestigia vestigia NN 40436 5037 13 " " '' 40436 5037 14 . . . 40436 5038 1 Ast Ast NNP 40436 5038 2 and and CC 40436 5038 3 Socher Socher NNP 40436 5038 4 characterise characterise VBP 40436 5038 5 the the DT 40436 5038 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5038 7 as as IN 40436 5038 8 a a DT 40436 5038 9 tissue tissue NN 40436 5038 10 of of IN 40436 5038 11 subtle subtle JJ 40436 5038 12 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 5038 13 and and CC 40436 5038 14 eristic eristic JJ 40436 5038 15 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 5038 16 , , , 40436 5038 17 such such JJ 40436 5038 18 as as IN 40436 5038 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5038 20 in in IN 40436 5038 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5038 22 opinion opinion NN 40436 5038 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5038 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5038 25 can can MD 40436 5038 26 not not RB 40436 5038 27 have have VB 40436 5038 28 composed compose VBN 40436 5038 29 . . . 40436 5039 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5039 2 concedes concede VBZ 40436 5039 3 the the DT 40436 5039 4 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 5039 5 , , , 40436 5039 6 but but CC 40436 5039 7 contends contend VBZ 40436 5039 8 that that IN 40436 5039 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5039 10 is be VBZ 40436 5039 11 put put VBN 40436 5039 12 by by IN 40436 5039 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5039 14 intentionally intentionally RB 40436 5039 15 , , , 40436 5039 16 for for IN 40436 5039 17 the the DT 40436 5039 18 purpose purpose NN 40436 5039 19 of of IN 40436 5039 20 deriding deride VBG 40436 5039 21 , , , 40436 5039 22 exposing expose VBG 40436 5039 23 , , , 40436 5039 24 disgracing disgrace VBG 40436 5039 25 , , , 40436 5039 26 the the DT 40436 5039 27 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5039 28 and and CC 40436 5039 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5039 30 dialectical dialectical JJ 40436 5039 31 tricks trick NNS 40436 5039 32 : : : 40436 5039 33 " " `` 40436 5039 34 ludibrii ludibrii NNP 40436 5039 35 causâ causâ NN 40436 5039 36 " " '' 40436 5039 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5039 38 p. p. NN 40436 5039 39 88 88 CD 40436 5039 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5039 41 ; ; : 40436 5039 42 " " `` 40436 5039 43 ut ut NNP 40436 5039 44 illustri illustri NNP 40436 5039 45 aliquo aliquo NNP 40436 5039 46 exemplo exemplo NNP 40436 5039 47 demonstretur demonstretur NNP 40436 5039 48 dialecticam dialecticam NNP 40436 5039 49 istam istam NNP 40436 5039 50 , , , 40436 5039 51 quam quam NNP 40436 5039 52 adolescentes adolescente NNS 40436 5039 53 magno magno VBP 40436 5039 54 quodam quodam NNP 40436 5039 55 studio studio NNP 40436 5039 56 sectabantur sectabantur NNP 40436 5039 57 , , , 40436 5039 58 nihil nihil NNP 40436 5039 59 esse esse NNP 40436 5039 60 aliud aliud NNP 40436 5039 61 , , , 40436 5039 62 nisi nisi NNP 40436 5039 63 inanem inanem NNP 40436 5039 64 quandam quandam NNP 40436 5039 65 argutiarum argutiarum NNP 40436 5039 66 captatricem captatricem NNP 40436 5039 67 , , , 40436 5039 68 " " '' 40436 5039 69 & & CC 40436 5039 70 c. c. NNP 40436 5039 71 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5039 72 p. p. NN 40436 5039 73 87 87 CD 40436 5039 74 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5039 75 . . . 40436 5040 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5040 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5040 3 contends contend VBZ 40436 5040 4 that that IN 40436 5040 5 along along IN 40436 5040 6 with with IN 40436 5040 7 this this DT 40436 5040 8 derisory derisory JJ 40436 5040 9 matter matter NN 40436 5040 10 there there EX 40436 5040 11 is be VBZ 40436 5040 12 intermingled intermingle VBN 40436 5040 13 serious serious JJ 40436 5040 14 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5040 15 which which WDT 40436 5040 16 may may MD 40436 5040 17 be be VB 40436 5040 18 easily easily RB 40436 5040 19 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 5040 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5040 21 p. p. NN 40436 5040 22 87 87 CD 40436 5040 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5040 24 , , , 40436 5040 25 but but CC 40436 5040 26 which which WDT 40436 5040 27 certainly certainly RB 40436 5040 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5040 29 does do VBZ 40436 5040 30 not not RB 40436 5040 31 clearly clearly RB 40436 5040 32 point point VB 40436 5040 33 out out RP 40436 5040 34 . . . 40436 5041 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5041 2 Compare compare VB 40436 5041 3 pp pp NN 40436 5041 4 . . . 40436 5042 1 108 108 CD 40436 5042 2 - - SYM 40436 5042 3 9 9 CD 40436 5042 4 - - HYPH 40436 5042 5 14 14 CD 40436 5042 6 - - HYPH 40436 5042 7 15 15 CD 40436 5042 8 , , , 40436 5042 9 2nd 2nd NNP 40436 5042 10 ed ed NNP 40436 5042 11 . . . 40436 5042 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5043 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5043 2 and and CC 40436 5043 3 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 5043 4 also also RB 40436 5043 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5043 6 pp pp NNP 40436 5043 7 . . . 40436 5044 1 222 222 CD 40436 5044 2 - - SYM 40436 5044 3 224 224 CD 40436 5044 4 - - HYPH 40436 5044 5 227 227 CD 40436 5044 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5044 7 admit admit VBP 40436 5044 8 the the DT 40436 5044 9 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 5044 10 in in IN 40436 5044 11 which which WDT 40436 5044 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5044 13 is be VBZ 40436 5044 14 here here RB 40436 5044 15 made make VBN 40436 5044 16 to to TO 40436 5044 17 indulge indulge VB 40436 5044 18 . . . 40436 5045 1 But but CC 40436 5045 2 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 5045 3 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 5045 4 that that IN 40436 5045 5 there there EX 40436 5045 6 is be VBZ 40436 5045 7 an an DT 40436 5045 8 assignable assignable JJ 40436 5045 9 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 5045 10 purpose purpose NN 40436 5045 11 in in IN 40436 5045 12 the the DT 40436 5045 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5045 14 , , , 40436 5045 15 which which WDT 40436 5045 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5045 17 purposely purposely RB 40436 5045 18 wrapped wrap VBD 40436 5045 19 up up RP 40436 5045 20 in in IN 40436 5045 21 enigmatical enigmatical JJ 40436 5045 22 language language NN 40436 5045 23 , , , 40436 5045 24 but but CC 40436 5045 25 of of IN 40436 5045 26 which which WDT 40436 5045 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5045 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5045 29 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 5045 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5045 31 professes profess VBZ 40436 5045 32 to to TO 40436 5045 33 give give VB 40436 5045 34 the the DT 40436 5045 35 solution solution NN 40436 5045 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5045 37 p. p. NN 40436 5046 1 228 228 CD 40436 5046 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5046 3 . . . 40436 5046 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5047 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5047 2 Side side NN 40436 5047 3 - - HYPH 40436 5047 4 note note NN 40436 5047 5 : : : 40436 5047 6 Subject subject NN 40436 5047 7 of of IN 40436 5047 8 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5047 9 . . . 40436 5048 1 Suited suit VBN 40436 5048 2 for for IN 40436 5048 3 a a DT 40436 5048 4 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 5048 5 of of IN 40436 5048 6 Search Search NNP 40436 5048 7 . . . 40436 5049 1 Manner Manner NNP 40436 5049 2 of of IN 40436 5049 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5049 4 , , , 40436 5049 5 multiplying multiply VBG 40436 5049 6 defective defective JJ 40436 5049 7 explanations explanation NNS 40436 5049 8 , , , 40436 5049 9 and and CC 40436 5049 10 showing show VBG 40436 5049 11 reasons reason NNS 40436 5049 12 why why WRB 40436 5049 13 each each DT 40436 5049 14 is be VBZ 40436 5049 15 defective defective JJ 40436 5049 16 . . . 40436 5049 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5050 1 This this DT 40436 5050 2 was be VBD 40436 5050 3 a a DT 40436 5050 4 proper proper JJ 40436 5050 5 subject subject NN 40436 5050 6 for for IN 40436 5050 7 a a DT 40436 5050 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5050 9 of of IN 40436 5050 10 Search Search NNP 40436 5050 11 . . . 40436 5051 1 In in IN 40436 5051 2 the the DT 40436 5051 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5051 4 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5051 5 , , , 40436 5051 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5051 7 describes describe VBZ 40436 5051 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5051 9 as as IN 40436 5051 10 engaged engage VBN 40436 5051 11 in in IN 40436 5051 12 one one CD 40436 5051 13 of of IN 40436 5051 14 these these DT 40436 5051 15 searches search NNS 40436 5051 16 , , , 40436 5051 17 handling handling NN 40436 5051 18 , , , 40436 5051 19 testing testing NN 40436 5051 20 , , , 40436 5051 21 and and CC 40436 5051 22 dropping dropping NN 40436 5051 23 , , , 40436 5051 24 one one CD 40436 5051 25 point point NN 40436 5051 26 of of IN 40436 5051 27 view view NN 40436 5051 28 after after IN 40436 5051 29 another another DT 40436 5051 30 , , , 40436 5051 31 respecting respect VBG 40436 5051 32 the the DT 40436 5051 33 idea idea NN 40436 5051 34 and and CC 40436 5051 35 foundation foundation NN 40436 5051 36 of of IN 40436 5051 37 friendship friendship NN 40436 5051 38 . . . 40436 5052 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5052 2 speaks speak VBZ 40436 5052 3 , , , 40436 5052 4 professedly professedly RB 40436 5052 5 , , , 40436 5052 6 as as IN 40436 5052 7 a a DT 40436 5052 8 diviner diviner NN 40436 5052 9 or or CC 40436 5052 10 guesser guesser NN 40436 5052 11 ; ; : 40436 5052 12 following follow VBG 40436 5052 13 out out RP 40436 5052 14 obscure obscure JJ 40436 5052 15 promptings prompting NNS 40436 5052 16 which which WDT 40436 5052 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5052 18 does do VBZ 40436 5052 19 not not RB 40436 5052 20 yet yet RB 40436 5052 21 understand understand VB 40436 5052 22 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5052 23 . . . 40436 5053 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5053 2 27 27 CD 40436 5053 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5053 4 In in IN 40436 5053 5 this this DT 40436 5053 6 character character NN 40436 5053 7 , , , 40436 5053 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5053 9 suggests suggest VBZ 40436 5053 10 several several JJ 40436 5053 11 different different JJ 40436 5053 12 explanations explanation NNS 40436 5053 13 , , , 40436 5053 14 not not RB 40436 5053 15 only only RB 40436 5053 16 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5053 17 but but CC 40436 5053 18 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 5053 19 with with IN 40436 5053 20 each each DT 40436 5053 21 other other JJ 40436 5053 22 ; ; : 40436 5053 23 each each DT 40436 5053 24 of of IN 40436 5053 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5053 26 true true JJ 40436 5053 27 to to IN 40436 5053 28 a a DT 40436 5053 29 certain certain JJ 40436 5053 30 extent extent NN 40436 5053 31 , , , 40436 5053 32 under under IN 40436 5053 33 certain certain JJ 40436 5053 34 conditions condition NNS 40436 5053 35 and and CC 40436 5053 36 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 5053 37 : : : 40436 5053 38 but but CC 40436 5053 39 each each DT 40436 5053 40 of of IN 40436 5053 41 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5053 42 untrue untrue JJ 40436 5053 43 , , , 40436 5053 44 when when WRB 40436 5053 45 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5053 46 travel travel VBP 40436 5053 47 beyond beyond IN 40436 5053 48 those those DT 40436 5053 49 limits limit NNS 40436 5053 50 : : : 40436 5053 51 other other JJ 40436 5053 52 contradictory contradictory JJ 40436 5053 53 considerations consideration NNS 40436 5053 54 then then RB 40436 5053 55 interfering interfere VBG 40436 5053 56 . . . 40436 5054 1 To to TO 40436 5054 2 multiply multiply VB 40436 5054 3 defective defective JJ 40436 5054 4 explanations explanation NNS 40436 5054 5 , , , 40436 5054 6 and and CC 40436 5054 7 to to TO 40436 5054 8 indicate indicate VB 40436 5054 9 why why WRB 40436 5054 10 each each DT 40436 5054 11 is be VBZ 40436 5054 12 defective defective JJ 40436 5054 13 , , , 40436 5054 14 is be VBZ 40436 5054 15 the the DT 40436 5054 16 whole whole JJ 40436 5054 17 business business NN 40436 5054 18 of of IN 40436 5054 19 the the DT 40436 5054 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5054 21 . . . 40436 5055 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5055 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5055 3 27 27 CD 40436 5055 4 : : : 40436 5055 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5055 6 , , , 40436 5055 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5055 8 , , , 40436 5055 9 216 216 CD 40436 5055 10 D. D. NNP 40436 5055 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5055 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5055 13 : : : 40436 5055 14 le le NNP 40436 5055 15 / / SYM 40436 5055 16 gô gô NNP 40436 5055 17 toi toi NNP 40436 5055 18 / / SYM 40436 5055 19 nun nun NNP 40436 5055 20 a)pomanteuo a)pomanteuo NNPS 40436 5055 21 / / SYM 40436 5055 22 menos menos NNP 40436 5055 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5055 24 , , , 40436 5055 25 & & CC 40436 5055 26 c. c. NNP 40436 5055 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5055 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5055 29 Side side NN 40436 5055 30 - - HYPH 40436 5055 31 note note NN 40436 5055 32 : : : 40436 5055 33 The the DT 40436 5055 34 process process NN 40436 5055 35 of of IN 40436 5055 36 trial trial NN 40436 5055 37 and and CC 40436 5055 38 error error NN 40436 5055 39 is be VBZ 40436 5055 40 better well RBR 40436 5055 41 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 5055 42 by by IN 40436 5055 43 a a DT 40436 5055 44 search search NN 40436 5055 45 without without IN 40436 5055 46 result result NN 40436 5055 47 than than IN 40436 5055 48 with with IN 40436 5055 49 result result NN 40436 5055 50 . . . 40436 5056 1 Usefulness usefulness NN 40436 5056 2 of of IN 40436 5056 3 the the DT 40436 5056 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5056 5 for for IN 40436 5056 6 self self NN 40436 5056 7 - - HYPH 40436 5056 8 working work VBG 40436 5056 9 minds mind NNS 40436 5056 10 . . . 40436 5056 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5057 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5057 2 discovers discover NNS 40436 5057 3 in in IN 40436 5057 4 this this DT 40436 5057 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5057 6 indications indication NNS 40436 5057 7 of of IN 40436 5057 8 a a DT 40436 5057 9 positive positive JJ 40436 5057 10 result result NN 40436 5057 11 not not RB 40436 5057 12 plainly plainly RB 40436 5057 13 enunciated enunciate VBN 40436 5057 14 : : : 40436 5057 15 but but CC 40436 5057 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5057 17 admits admit VBZ 40436 5057 18 that that IN 40436 5057 19 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5057 20 did do VBD 40436 5057 21 not not RB 40436 5057 22 discover discover VB 40436 5057 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5057 24 -- -- : 40436 5057 25 nor nor CC 40436 5057 26 can can MD 40436 5057 27 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5057 28 believe believe VB 40436 5057 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5057 30 to to TO 40436 5057 31 have have VB 40436 5057 32 been be VBN 40436 5057 33 intended intend VBN 40436 5057 34 by by IN 40436 5057 35 the the DT 40436 5057 36 author author NN 40436 5057 37 . . . 40436 5058 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5058 2 28 28 CD 40436 5058 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5058 4 But but CC 40436 5058 5 most most JJS 40436 5058 6 critics critic NNS 40436 5058 7 speak speak VBP 40436 5058 8 slightingly slightingly RB 40436 5058 9 of of IN 40436 5058 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5058 11 , , , 40436 5058 12 as as IN 40436 5058 13 alike alike RB 40436 5058 14 sceptical sceptical JJ 40436 5058 15 and and CC 40436 5058 16 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 5058 17 : : : 40436 5058 18 and and CC 40436 5058 19 some some DT 40436 5058 20 even even RB 40436 5058 21 deny deny VBP 40436 5058 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5058 23 authenticity authenticity NN 40436 5058 24 on on IN 40436 5058 25 these these DT 40436 5058 26 grounds ground NNS 40436 5058 27 . . . 40436 5059 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5059 2 might may MD 40436 5059 3 have have VB 40436 5059 4 replied reply VBN 40436 5059 5 by by IN 40436 5059 6 saying say VBG 40436 5059 7 that that IN 40436 5059 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5059 9 intended intend VBD 40436 5059 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5059 11 as as IN 40436 5059 12 a a DT 40436 5059 13 specimen speciman NNS 40436 5059 14 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 5059 15 the the DT 40436 5059 16 process process NN 40436 5059 17 of of IN 40436 5059 18 search search NN 40436 5059 19 for for IN 40436 5059 20 an an DT 40436 5059 21 unknown unknown JJ 40436 5059 22 _ _ NNP 40436 5059 23 quæsitum quæsitum NN 40436 5059 24 _ _ NNP 40436 5059 25 ; ; : 40436 5059 26 and and CC 40436 5059 27 as as IN 40436 5059 28 an an DT 40436 5059 29 exposition exposition NN 40436 5059 30 of of IN 40436 5059 31 what what WP 40436 5059 32 can can MD 40436 5059 33 be be VB 40436 5059 34 said say VBN 40436 5059 35 for for IN 40436 5059 36 , , , 40436 5059 37 as as RB 40436 5059 38 well well RB 40436 5059 39 as as IN 40436 5059 40 against against IN 40436 5059 41 , , , 40436 5059 42 many many JJ 40436 5059 43 different different JJ 40436 5059 44 points point NNS 40436 5059 45 of of IN 40436 5059 46 view view NN 40436 5059 47 . . . 40436 5060 1 The the DT 40436 5060 2 process process NN 40436 5060 3 of of IN 40436 5060 4 trial trial NN 40436 5060 5 and and CC 40436 5060 6 error error NN 40436 5060 7 , , , 40436 5060 8 the the DT 40436 5060 9 most most RBS 40436 5060 10 general general JJ 40436 5060 11 fact fact NN 40436 5060 12 of of IN 40436 5060 13 human human JJ 40436 5060 14 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5060 15 , , , 40436 5060 16 is be VBZ 40436 5060 17 even even RB 40436 5060 18 better well RBR 40436 5060 19 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 5060 20 when when WRB 40436 5060 21 the the DT 40436 5060 22 search search NN 40436 5060 23 is be VBZ 40436 5060 24 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 40436 5060 25 : : : 40436 5060 26 because because IN 40436 5060 27 when when WRB 40436 5060 28 a a DT 40436 5060 29 result result NN 40436 5060 30 is be VBZ 40436 5060 31 once once RB 40436 5060 32 obtained obtain VBN 40436 5060 33 , , , 40436 5060 34 most most JJS 40436 5060 35 persons person NNS 40436 5060 36 care care VBP 40436 5060 37 for for IN 40436 5060 38 nothing nothing NN 40436 5060 39 else else RB 40436 5060 40 and and CC 40436 5060 41 forget forget VB 40436 5060 42 the the DT 40436 5060 43 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 5060 44 blunders blunder NNS 40436 5060 45 . . . 40436 5061 1 To to IN 40436 5061 2 those those DT 40436 5061 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 5061 4 , , , 40436 5061 5 who who WP 40436 5061 6 ask ask VBP 40436 5061 7 only only RB 40436 5061 8 to to TO 40436 5061 9 hear hear VB 40436 5061 10 the the DT 40436 5061 11 result result NN 40436 5061 12 as as RB 40436 5061 13 soon soon RB 40436 5061 14 as as IN 40436 5061 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5061 16 is be VBZ 40436 5061 17 found find VBN 40436 5061 18 , , , 40436 5061 19 and and CC 40436 5061 20 who who WP 40436 5061 21 wait wait VBP 40436 5061 22 for for IN 40436 5061 23 others other NNS 40436 5061 24 to to TO 40436 5061 25 look look VB 40436 5061 26 for for IN 40436 5061 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5061 28 -- -- : 40436 5061 29 such such PDT 40436 5061 30 a a DT 40436 5061 31 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5061 32 as as IN 40436 5061 33 the the DT 40436 5061 34 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5061 35 will will MD 40436 5061 36 appear appear VB 40436 5061 37 of of IN 40436 5061 38 little little JJ 40436 5061 39 value value NN 40436 5061 40 . . . 40436 5062 1 But but CC 40436 5062 2 to to IN 40436 5062 3 any any DT 40436 5062 4 one one NN 40436 5062 5 who who WP 40436 5062 6 intends intend VBZ 40436 5062 7 to to TO 40436 5062 8 search search VB 40436 5062 9 for for IN 40436 5062 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5062 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5062 12 , , , 40436 5062 13 or or CC 40436 5062 14 to to TO 40436 5062 15 study study VB 40436 5062 16 the the DT 40436 5062 17 same same JJ 40436 5062 18 problem problem NN 40436 5062 19 for for IN 40436 5062 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5062 21 , , , 40436 5062 22 the the DT 40436 5062 23 report report NN 40436 5062 24 thus thus RB 40436 5062 25 presented present VBN 40436 5062 26 of of IN 40436 5062 27 a a DT 40436 5062 28 previous previous JJ 40436 5062 29 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 40436 5062 30 search search NN 40436 5062 31 , , , 40436 5062 32 is be VBZ 40436 5062 33 useful useful JJ 40436 5062 34 both both DT 40436 5062 35 as as IN 40436 5062 36 guidance guidance NN 40436 5062 37 and and CC 40436 5062 38 warning warning NN 40436 5062 39 . . . 40436 5063 1 Every every DT 40436 5063 2 one one CD 40436 5063 3 of of IN 40436 5063 4 the the DT 40436 5063 5 tentative tentative JJ 40436 5063 6 solutions solution NNS 40436 5063 7 indicated indicate VBN 40436 5063 8 in in IN 40436 5063 9 the the DT 40436 5063 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5063 11 has have VBZ 40436 5063 12 something something NN 40436 5063 13 in in IN 40436 5063 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5063 15 favour favour NN 40436 5063 16 , , , 40436 5063 17 yet yet RB 40436 5063 18 is be VBZ 40436 5063 19 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5063 20 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 5063 21 . . . 40436 5064 1 To to TO 40436 5064 2 learn learn VB 40436 5064 3 the the DT 40436 5064 4 grounds ground NNS 40436 5064 5 which which WDT 40436 5064 6 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 5064 7 compel compel VBP 40436 5064 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5064 9 to to TO 40436 5064 10 reject reject VB 40436 5064 11 what what WP 40436 5064 12 at at IN 40436 5064 13 first first JJ 40436 5064 14 appears appear VBZ 40436 5064 15 admissible admissible JJ 40436 5064 16 , , , 40436 5064 17 is be VBZ 40436 5064 18 instruction instruction NN 40436 5064 19 not not RB 40436 5064 20 to to TO 40436 5064 21 be be VB 40436 5064 22 despised despise VBN 40436 5064 23 ; ; : 40436 5064 24 at at IN 40436 5064 25 the the DT 40436 5064 26 very very RB 40436 5064 27 least least JJS 40436 5064 28 , , , 40436 5064 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5064 30 helps help VBZ 40436 5064 31 to to TO 40436 5064 32 preserve preserve VB 40436 5064 33 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5064 34 from from IN 40436 5064 35 mistake mistake NN 40436 5064 36 , , , 40436 5064 37 and and CC 40436 5064 38 to to TO 40436 5064 39 state state VB 40436 5064 40 the the DT 40436 5064 41 problem problem NN 40436 5064 42 in in IN 40436 5064 43 the the DT 40436 5064 44 manner manner NN 40436 5064 45 most most RBS 40436 5064 46 suitable suitable JJ 40436 5064 47 for for IN 40436 5064 48 obtaining obtain VBG 40436 5064 49 a a DT 40436 5064 50 solution solution NN 40436 5064 51 . . . 40436 5065 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5065 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5065 3 28 28 CD 40436 5065 4 : : : 40436 5065 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5065 6 , , , 40436 5065 7 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 5065 8 zum zum NNP 40436 5065 9 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5065 10 , , , 40436 5065 11 i. i. NN 40436 5065 12 p. p. NN 40436 5066 1 177 177 CD 40436 5066 2 . . . 40436 5066 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5067 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5067 2 Side side NN 40436 5067 3 - - HYPH 40436 5067 4 note note NN 40436 5067 5 : : : 40436 5067 6 Subject subject NN 40436 5067 7 of of IN 40436 5067 8 friendship friendship NN 40436 5067 9 , , , 40436 5067 10 handled handle VBD 40436 5067 11 both both CC 40436 5067 12 by by IN 40436 5067 13 the the DT 40436 5067 14 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 5067 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5067 16 , , , 40436 5067 17 and and CC 40436 5067 18 by by IN 40436 5067 19 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5067 20 . . . 40436 5067 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5068 1 In in IN 40436 5068 2 truth truth NN 40436 5068 3 , , , 40436 5068 4 no no DT 40436 5068 5 one one CD 40436 5068 6 general general JJ 40436 5068 7 solution solution NN 40436 5068 8 is be VBZ 40436 5068 9 attainable attainable JJ 40436 5068 10 , , , 40436 5068 11 such such JJ 40436 5068 12 as as IN 40436 5068 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5068 14 here here RB 40436 5068 15 professes profess VBZ 40436 5068 16 to to TO 40436 5068 17 search search VB 40436 5068 18 for for IN 40436 5068 19 . . . 40436 5069 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5069 2 29 29 CD 40436 5069 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5069 4 In in IN 40436 5069 5 one one CD 40436 5069 6 of of IN 40436 5069 7 the the DT 40436 5069 8 three three CD 40436 5069 9 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 5069 10 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5069 11 wherein wherein WRB 40436 5069 12 the the DT 40436 5069 13 subject subject NN 40436 5069 14 of of IN 40436 5069 15 friendship friendship NN 40436 5069 16 is be VBZ 40436 5069 17 discussed discuss VBN 40436 5069 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5069 19 find find VBP 40436 5069 20 the the DT 40436 5069 21 real real JJ 40436 5069 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5069 23 presenting present VBG 40436 5069 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5069 25 with with IN 40436 5069 26 a a DT 40436 5069 27 juster juster NN 40436 5069 28 view view NN 40436 5069 29 of of IN 40436 5069 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5069 31 real real JJ 40436 5069 32 complications complication NNS 40436 5069 33 . . . 40436 5070 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5070 2 30 30 CD 40436 5070 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5070 4 The the DT 40436 5070 5 same same JJ 40436 5070 6 remark remark NN 40436 5070 7 may may MD 40436 5070 8 be be VB 40436 5070 9 made make VBN 40436 5070 10 upon upon IN 40436 5070 11 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5070 12 's 's POS 40436 5070 13 manner manner NN 40436 5070 14 of of IN 40436 5070 15 handling handle VBG 40436 5070 16 friendship friendship NN 40436 5070 17 in in IN 40436 5070 18 the the DT 40436 5070 19 Ethics Ethics NNP 40436 5070 20 . . . 40436 5071 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5071 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 5071 3 plainly plainly RB 40436 5071 4 to to TO 40436 5071 5 allude allude VB 40436 5071 6 to to IN 40436 5071 7 the the DT 40436 5071 8 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5071 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5071 10 though though IN 40436 5071 11 not not RB 40436 5071 12 mentioning mention VBG 40436 5071 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5071 14 by by IN 40436 5071 15 name name NN 40436 5071 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5071 17 ; ; : 40436 5071 18 and and CC 40436 5071 19 to to TO 40436 5071 20 profit profit VB 40436 5071 21 by by IN 40436 5071 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5071 23 at at IN 40436 5071 24 least least JJS 40436 5071 25 in in IN 40436 5071 26 what what WP 40436 5071 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5071 28 puts put VBZ 40436 5071 29 out out IN 40436 5071 30 of of IN 40436 5071 31 consideration consideration NN 40436 5071 32 , , , 40436 5071 33 if if IN 40436 5071 34 not not RB 40436 5071 35 in in IN 40436 5071 36 what what WP 40436 5071 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5071 38 brings bring VBZ 40436 5071 39 forward forward RB 40436 5071 40 . . . 40436 5072 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5072 2 31 31 CD 40436 5072 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5072 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5072 5 discards discard VBZ 40436 5072 6 the the DT 40436 5072 7 physical physical JJ 40436 5072 8 and and CC 40436 5072 9 cosmical cosmical JJ 40436 5072 10 analogies analogy NNS 40436 5072 11 , , , 40436 5072 12 which which WDT 40436 5072 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5072 14 borrows borrow VBZ 40436 5072 15 from from IN 40436 5072 16 Empedokles Empedokles NNP 40436 5072 17 and and CC 40436 5072 18 Herakleitus Herakleitus NNP 40436 5072 19 , , , 40436 5072 20 as as RB 40436 5072 21 too too RB 40436 5072 22 remote remote JJ 40436 5072 23 and and CC 40436 5072 24 inapplicable inapplicable JJ 40436 5072 25 : : : 40436 5072 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5072 27 considers consider VBZ 40436 5072 28 that that IN 40436 5072 29 the the DT 40436 5072 30 question question NN 40436 5072 31 must must MD 40436 5072 32 be be VB 40436 5072 33 determined determine VBN 40436 5072 34 by by IN 40436 5072 35 facts fact NNS 40436 5072 36 and and CC 40436 5072 37 principles principle NNS 40436 5072 38 relating relate VBG 40436 5072 39 to to IN 40436 5072 40 human human JJ 40436 5072 41 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 5072 42 and and CC 40436 5072 43 conduct conduct NN 40436 5072 44 . . . 40436 5073 1 In in IN 40436 5073 2 other other JJ 40436 5073 3 ways way NNS 40436 5073 4 , , , 40436 5073 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5073 6 circumscribes circumscribe VBZ 40436 5073 7 the the DT 40436 5073 8 problem problem NN 40436 5073 9 , , , 40436 5073 10 by by IN 40436 5073 11 setting set VBG 40436 5073 12 aside aside RB 40436 5073 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5073 14 what what WP 40436 5073 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5073 16 includes include VBZ 40436 5073 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5073 18 all all DT 40436 5073 19 objects object NNS 40436 5073 20 of of IN 40436 5073 21 attachment attachment NN 40436 5073 22 which which WDT 40436 5073 23 are be VBP 40436 5073 24 not not RB 40436 5073 25 capable capable JJ 40436 5073 26 of of IN 40436 5073 27 reciprocating reciprocate VBG 40436 5073 28 attachment attachment NN 40436 5073 29 . . . 40436 5074 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5074 2 32 32 CD 40436 5074 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5074 4 The the DT 40436 5074 5 problem problem NN 40436 5074 6 , , , 40436 5074 7 as as IN 40436 5074 8 set set VBN 40436 5074 9 forth forth RP 40436 5074 10 here here RB 40436 5074 11 by by IN 40436 5074 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5074 13 , , , 40436 5074 14 is be VBZ 40436 5074 15 conceived conceive VBN 40436 5074 16 in in IN 40436 5074 17 great great JJ 40436 5074 18 generality generality NN 40436 5074 19 . . . 40436 5075 1 In in IN 40436 5075 2 what what WDT 40436 5075 3 manner manner NN 40436 5075 4 does do VBZ 40436 5075 5 one one CD 40436 5075 6 man man NN 40436 5075 7 become become VB 40436 5075 8 the the DT 40436 5075 9 friend friend NN 40436 5075 10 of of IN 40436 5075 11 another another DT 40436 5075 12 ? ? . 40436 5076 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5076 2 33 33 CD 40436 5076 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5076 4 How how WRB 40436 5076 5 does do VBZ 40436 5076 6 a a DT 40436 5076 7 man man NN 40436 5076 8 become become VB 40436 5076 9 the the DT 40436 5076 10 object object NN 40436 5076 11 of of IN 40436 5076 12 friendship friendship NN 40436 5076 13 or or CC 40436 5076 14 love love NN 40436 5076 15 from from IN 40436 5076 16 another another DT 40436 5076 17 ? ? . 40436 5077 1 What what WP 40436 5077 2 is be VBZ 40436 5077 3 that that DT 40436 5077 4 object object NN 40436 5077 5 towards towards IN 40436 5077 6 which which WDT 40436 5077 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5077 8 love love NN 40436 5077 9 or or CC 40436 5077 10 friendship friendship NN 40436 5077 11 is be VBZ 40436 5077 12 determined determine VBN 40436 5077 13 ? ? . 40436 5078 1 These these DT 40436 5078 2 terms term NNS 40436 5078 3 are be VBP 40436 5078 4 so so RB 40436 5078 5 large large JJ 40436 5078 6 , , , 40436 5078 7 that that IN 40436 5078 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5078 9 include include VBP 40436 5078 10 everything everything NN 40436 5078 11 belonging belong VBG 40436 5078 12 to to IN 40436 5078 13 the the DT 40436 5078 14 Tender Tender NNP 40436 5078 15 Emotion Emotion NNP 40436 5078 16 generally generally RB 40436 5078 17 . . . 40436 5079 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5079 2 34 34 CD 40436 5079 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5079 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5079 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5079 6 29 29 CD 40436 5079 7 : : : 40436 5079 8 Turgot Turgot NNP 40436 5079 9 has have VBZ 40436 5079 10 some some DT 40436 5079 11 excellent excellent JJ 40436 5079 12 remarks remark NNS 40436 5079 13 on on IN 40436 5079 14 the the DT 40436 5079 15 hopelessness hopelessness NN 40436 5079 16 of of IN 40436 5079 17 such such JJ 40436 5079 18 problems problem NNS 40436 5079 19 as as IN 40436 5079 20 that that DT 40436 5079 21 which which WDT 40436 5079 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5079 23 propounds propound VBZ 40436 5079 24 , , , 40436 5079 25 here here RB 40436 5079 26 well well RB 40436 5079 27 as as IN 40436 5079 28 in in IN 40436 5079 29 other other JJ 40436 5079 30 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5079 31 , , , 40436 5079 32 to to TO 40436 5079 33 find find VB 40436 5079 34 definitions definition NNS 40436 5079 35 of of IN 40436 5079 36 common common JJ 40436 5079 37 and and CC 40436 5079 38 vague vague JJ 40436 5079 39 terms term NNS 40436 5079 40 . . . 40436 5080 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5080 2 read read VBP 40436 5080 3 in in IN 40436 5080 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5080 5 article article NN 40436 5080 6 Etymologie Etymologie NNP 40436 5080 7 , , , 40436 5080 8 in in IN 40436 5080 9 the the DT 40436 5080 10 Encyclopédie Encyclopédie NNP 40436 5080 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5080 12 vol vol NNP 40436 5080 13 . . . 40436 5081 1 iii iii NNP 40436 5081 2 . . . 40436 5082 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5082 2 . . . 40436 5083 1 70 70 CD 40436 5083 2 - - SYM 40436 5083 3 72 72 CD 40436 5083 4 of of IN 40436 5083 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5083 6 Oeuvres Oeuvres NNPS 40436 5083 7 Complets Complets NNPS 40436 5083 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5083 9 : : : 40436 5083 10 " " `` 40436 5083 11 Qu'on Qu'on NNP 40436 5083 12 se se FW 40436 5083 13 répresente répresente FW 40436 5083 14 la la FW 40436 5083 15 foule foule NNP 40436 5083 16 des des NNP 40436 5083 17 acceptions acception NNS 40436 5083 18 du du NNP 40436 5083 19 mot mot NNP 40436 5083 20 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 21 esprit esprit FW 40436 5083 22 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 23 , , , 40436 5083 24 depuis depuis NNP 40436 5083 25 son son NN 40436 5083 26 sens sens NNP 40436 5083 27 primitif primitif NNP 40436 5083 28 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 29 spiritus spiritus NN 40436 5083 30 , , , 40436 5083 31 haleine haleine NNP 40436 5083 32 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 33 , , , 40436 5083 34 jusqu'à jusqu'à NNP 40436 5083 35 ceux ceux NNP 40436 5083 36 qu'on qu'on NN 40436 5083 37 lui lui NNP 40436 5083 38 donne donne NN 40436 5083 39 dans dan NNS 40436 5083 40 la la NNP 40436 5083 41 chimie chimie NNP 40436 5083 42 , , , 40436 5083 43 dans dan NNS 40436 5083 44 la la NNP 40436 5083 45 littérature littérature VBP 40436 5083 46 , , , 40436 5083 47 dans dan NNS 40436 5083 48 la la NNP 40436 5083 49 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 40436 5083 50 , , , 40436 5083 51 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 52 esprit esprit FW 40436 5083 53 acide acide IN 40436 5083 54 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 55 , , , 40436 5083 56 esprit esprit FW 40436 5083 57 de de FW 40436 5083 58 Montaigne Montaigne NNP 40436 5083 59 , , , 40436 5083 60 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 61 esprit esprit FW 40436 5083 62 des des FW 40436 5083 63 loix loix NNP 40436 5083 64 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 65 , , , 40436 5083 66 & & CC 40436 5083 67 c.--qu'on c.--qu'on NNP 40436 5083 68 essaie essaie NNP 40436 5083 69 d'extraire d'extraire NNP 40436 5083 70 de de NNP 40436 5083 71 toutes toutes NNP 40436 5083 72 ces ces NNP 40436 5083 73 acceptions acception NNS 40436 5083 74 une une VBP 40436 5083 75 idée idée NNP 40436 5083 76 qui qui NNP 40436 5083 77 soit soit NNP 40436 5083 78 commune commune NNP 40436 5083 79 à à NNP 40436 5083 80 toutes toute NNS 40436 5083 81 -- -- : 40436 5083 82 on on IN 40436 5083 83 verra verra NNP 40436 5083 84 s'évanouir s'évanouir NNP 40436 5083 85 tous tous JJ 40436 5083 86 les les NNP 40436 5083 87 caractères caractères NNP 40436 5083 88 qui qui NNP 40436 5083 89 distinguent distinguent NNP 40436 5083 90 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 91 l'esprit l'esprit NNP 40436 5083 92 _ _ NNP 40436 5083 93 de de NNP 40436 5083 94 toute toute NNP 40436 5083 95 autre autre NNP 40436 5083 96 chose choose VBD 40436 5083 97 , , , 40436 5083 98 dans dan NNS 40436 5083 99 quelque quelque NNP 40436 5083 100 sens sens NNP 40436 5083 101 qu'on qu'on NNP 40436 5083 102 le le NNP 40436 5083 103 prenne prenne NNP 40436 5083 104 . . . 40436 5084 1 . . . 40436 5085 1 . . . 40436 5086 1 . . . 40436 5087 1 La La NNP 40436 5087 2 multitude multitude NNP 40436 5087 3 et et FW 40436 5087 4 l'incompatibilité l'incompatibilité NNP 40436 5087 5 des des NNP 40436 5087 6 acceptions acception NNS 40436 5087 7 du du NNP 40436 5087 8 mot mot NNP 40436 5087 9 _ _ NNP 40436 5087 10 esprit esprit FW 40436 5087 11 _ _ NNP 40436 5087 12 , , , 40436 5087 13 sont sont NN 40436 5087 14 telles telle NNS 40436 5087 15 , , , 40436 5087 16 que que NNP 40436 5087 17 personne personne NNP 40436 5087 18 n'a n'a RB 40436 5087 19 été été NNP 40436 5087 20 tenté tenté NNP 40436 5087 21 de de FW 40436 5087 22 les les NNP 40436 5087 23 comprendre comprendre NNP 40436 5087 24 toutes toute NNS 40436 5087 25 dans dan VBZ 40436 5087 26 une une VBP 40436 5087 27 seule seule NNP 40436 5087 28 _ _ NNP 40436 5087 29 définition définition NN 40436 5087 30 _ _ NNP 40436 5087 31 , , , 40436 5087 32 et et NNP 40436 5087 33 de de NNP 40436 5087 34 définir définir NNP 40436 5087 35 l'esprit l'esprit NNP 40436 5087 36 en en FW 40436 5087 37 général général FW 40436 5087 38 . . . 40436 5088 1 Mais Mais NNP 40436 5088 2 le le NNP 40436 5088 3 vice vice NNP 40436 5088 4 de de NNP 40436 5088 5 cette cette NNP 40436 5088 6 méthode méthode NNP 40436 5088 7 n'est n'est NNP 40436 5088 8 pas pas NNP 40436 5088 9 moins moin NNS 40436 5088 10 réel réel VBD 40436 5088 11 lorsqu'il lorsqu'il NNP 40436 5088 12 n'est n'est NNP 40436 5088 13 pas pas NNP 40436 5088 14 assez assez NNP 40436 5088 15 sensible sensible NNP 40436 5088 16 pour pour VBP 40436 5088 17 empêcher empêcher JJ 40436 5088 18 qu'on qu'on NN 40436 5088 19 ne ne NNP 40436 5088 20 la la NNP 40436 5088 21 suive suive NNP 40436 5088 22 . . . 40436 5089 1 " " `` 40436 5089 2 A a DT 40436 5089 3 mesure mesure NN 40436 5089 4 que que NNP 40436 5089 5 le le NNP 40436 5089 6 nombre nombre NNP 40436 5089 7 et et NNP 40436 5089 8 la la NNP 40436 5089 9 diversité diversité NNP 40436 5089 10 des des NNP 40436 5089 11 acceptions acception NNS 40436 5089 12 diminue diminue NNP 40436 5089 13 , , , 40436 5089 14 l'absurdité l'absurdité NNP 40436 5089 15 s'affoiblit s'affoiblit NNP 40436 5089 16 : : : 40436 5089 17 et et NNP 40436 5089 18 quand quand NNP 40436 5089 19 elle elle NNP 40436 5089 20 disparoit disparoit NNP 40436 5089 21 , , , 40436 5089 22 il il NNP 40436 5089 23 reste reste NNP 40436 5089 24 encore encore NNP 40436 5089 25 l'erreur l'erreur NNP 40436 5089 26 . . . 40436 5090 1 J'ose j'ose VB 40436 5090 2 dire dire JJ 40436 5090 3 , , , 40436 5090 4 que que NN 40436 5090 5 presque presque NN 40436 5090 6 toutes toute NNS 40436 5090 7 les les NNP 40436 5090 8 _ _ NNP 40436 5090 9 définitions définition NNS 40436 5090 10 _ _ NNP 40436 5090 11 où où IN 40436 5090 12 l'on l'on NNP 40436 5090 13 annonce annonce NNP 40436 5090 14 qu'on qu'on NNP 40436 5090 15 va va NNP 40436 5090 16 définir définir NNP 40436 5090 17 les les NNP 40436 5090 18 choses chose NNS 40436 5090 19 _ _ NNP 40436 5090 20 dans dan NNS 40436 5090 21 le le NNP 40436 5090 22 sens sens NNP 40436 5090 23 le le NNP 40436 5090 24 plus plus CC 40436 5090 25 général général NNP 40436 5090 26 _ _ NNP 40436 5090 27 , , , 40436 5090 28 ont ont NNP 40436 5090 29 ce ce NNP 40436 5090 30 défaut défaut NNP 40436 5090 31 , , , 40436 5090 32 et et NNP 40436 5090 33 ne ne NNP 40436 5090 34 définissent définissent NNP 40436 5090 35 véritablement véritablement NNP 40436 5090 36 rien rien NNP 40436 5090 37 : : : 40436 5090 38 parceque parceque NNP 40436 5090 39 leurs leurs NNP 40436 5090 40 auteurs auteur NNS 40436 5090 41 , , , 40436 5090 42 en en FW 40436 5090 43 voulant voulant JJ 40436 5090 44 renfermer renfermer NN 40436 5090 45 toutes toute NNS 40436 5090 46 les les VBP 40436 5090 47 acceptions acception NNS 40436 5090 48 d'un d'un NNP 40436 5090 49 mot mot NN 40436 5090 50 , , , 40436 5090 51 ont ont NNP 40436 5090 52 entrepris entrepris NNP 40436 5090 53 une une NNP 40436 5090 54 chose choose VBD 40436 5090 55 impossible impossible JJ 40436 5090 56 : : : 40436 5090 57 je je NNP 40436 5090 58 veux veux NNP 40436 5090 59 dire dire NNP 40436 5090 60 , , , 40436 5090 61 de de FW 40436 5090 62 rassembler rassembler NNP 40436 5090 63 sous sous JJ 40436 5090 64 une une NNP 40436 5090 65 seule seule NNP 40436 5090 66 idée idée NN 40436 5090 67 générale générale NNP 40436 5090 68 des des FW 40436 5090 69 idées idées NNP 40436 5090 70 très très NN 40436 5090 71 différentes différente VBZ 40436 5090 72 entre entre NNP 40436 5090 73 elles elle NNS 40436 5090 74 , , , 40436 5090 75 et et NNP 40436 5090 76 qu'un qu'un NNP 40436 5090 77 même même NNP 40436 5090 78 nom nom NNP 40436 5090 79 n'a n'a RB 40436 5090 80 jamais jamais NNP 40436 5090 81 pu pu NNP 40436 5090 82 désigner désigner NN 40436 5090 83 que que NNP 40436 5090 84 successivement successivement NN 40436 5090 85 , , , 40436 5090 86 en en IN 40436 5090 87 cessant cessant NN 40436 5090 88 en en IN 40436 5090 89 quelque quelque NNP 40436 5090 90 sorte sorte NNP 40436 5090 91 d'être d'être NNP 40436 5090 92 le le NNP 40436 5090 93 même même NNP 40436 5090 94 mot mot NNP 40436 5090 95 . . . 40436 5090 96 " " '' 40436 5091 1 See see VB 40436 5091 2 also also RB 40436 5091 3 the the DT 40436 5091 4 remarks remark NNS 40436 5091 5 of of IN 40436 5091 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5091 7 John John NNP 40436 5091 8 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 5091 9 Mill Mill NNP 40436 5091 10 on on IN 40436 5091 11 the the DT 40436 5091 12 same same JJ 40436 5091 13 subject subject NN 40436 5091 14 . . . 40436 5092 1 System system NN 40436 5092 2 of of IN 40436 5092 3 Logic Logic NNP 40436 5092 4 , , , 40436 5092 5 Book Book NNP 40436 5092 6 IV IV NNP 40436 5092 7 . . . 40436 5093 1 chap chap NNP 40436 5093 2 . . . 40436 5094 1 4 4 LS 40436 5094 2 , , , 40436 5094 3 s. s. NNP 40436 5095 1 5 5 CD 40436 5095 2 . . . 40436 5095 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5096 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5096 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5096 3 30 30 CD 40436 5096 4 : : : 40436 5096 5 See see VB 40436 5096 6 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 5096 7 , , , 40436 5096 8 Memor Memor NNP 40436 5096 9 . . . 40436 5097 1 ii ii LS 40436 5097 2 . . . 40436 5098 1 4 4 LS 40436 5098 2 - - SYM 40436 5098 3 5 5 CD 40436 5098 4 - - SYM 40436 5098 5 6 6 CD 40436 5098 6 . . . 40436 5099 1 In in IN 40436 5099 2 the the DT 40436 5099 3 last last JJ 40436 5099 4 of of IN 40436 5099 5 these these DT 40436 5099 6 three three CD 40436 5099 7 conversations conversation NNS 40436 5099 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5099 9 s. s. NNP 40436 5099 10 21 21 CD 40436 5099 11 - - SYM 40436 5099 12 22 22 CD 40436 5099 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5099 14 , , , 40436 5099 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5099 16 says say VBZ 40436 5099 17 to to IN 40436 5099 18 Kritobulus Kritobulus NNP 40436 5099 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5099 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5099 21 : : : 40436 5099 22 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 5099 23 ' ' '' 40436 5099 24 e)/chei e)/chei . 40436 5099 25 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5099 26 poiki poiki NNP 40436 5099 27 / / SYM 40436 5099 28 lôs lôs NNP 40436 5099 29 pôs pôs NNP 40436 5099 30 tau tau NNP 40436 5099 31 = = SYM 40436 5099 32 ta ta NNP 40436 5099 33 , , , 40436 5099 34 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 5099 35 Krito Krito NNP 40436 5099 36 / / SYM 40436 5099 37 boule boule RB 40436 5099 38 ; ; : 40436 5099 39 phu phu NN 40436 5099 40 / / SYM 40436 5099 41 sei sei NN 40436 5099 42 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5099 43 e)/chousin e)/chousin NN 40436 5099 44 oi oi PRP 40436 5099 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5099 46 a)/nthrôpoi a)/nthrôpoi NNP 40436 5099 47 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 5099 48 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5099 49 philika/ philika/ NNP 40436 5099 50 ; ; : 40436 5099 51 de de NNP 40436 5099 52 / / SYM 40436 5099 53 ontai ontai NN 40436 5099 54 te te NNP 40436 5099 55 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5099 56 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 5099 57 / / SYM 40436 5099 58 lôn lôn NN 40436 5099 59 , , , 40436 5099 60 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5099 61 e)leou e)leou ADD 40436 5099 62 = = SYM 40436 5099 63 si si NNP 40436 5099 64 , , , 40436 5099 65 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5099 66 sunergou sunergou NNP 40436 5099 67 = = SYM 40436 5099 68 ntes ntes NNP 40436 5099 69 ô)phelou ô)phelou , 40436 5099 70 = = SYM 40436 5099 71 si si UH 40436 5099 72 , , , 40436 5099 73 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5099 74 tou tou NNP 40436 5099 75 = = SYM 40436 5099 76 to to TO 40436 5099 77 sunie sunie VB 40436 5099 78 / / SYM 40436 5099 79 ntes ntes NNPS 40436 5099 80 cha cha NNP 40436 5099 81 / / SYM 40436 5099 82 rin rin VB 40436 5099 83 e)/chousin e)/chousin NNP 40436 5099 84 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 5099 85 / / SYM 40436 5099 86 lois lois NNP 40436 5099 87 , , , 40436 5099 88 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 5099 89 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5099 90 polemika/ polemika/ NNP 40436 5099 91 ; ; : 40436 5099 92 ta/ ta/ NNP 40436 5099 93 te te NNP 40436 5099 94 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5099 95 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 5099 96 kala\ kala\ NNP 40436 5099 97 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5099 98 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 5099 99 / / SYM 40436 5099 100 a a DT 40436 5099 101 nomi nomi NN 40436 5099 102 / / SYM 40436 5099 103 zontes zontes NNPS 40436 5099 104 u(pe\r u(pe\r NNP 40436 5099 105 tou tou NNP 40436 5099 106 / / SYM 40436 5099 107 tôn tôn NNP 40436 5099 108 ma ma NNP 40436 5099 109 / / SYM 40436 5099 110 chontai chontai NNP 40436 5099 111 , , , 40436 5099 112 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5099 113 dichognômonou dichognômonou NNP 40436 5099 114 = = SYM 40436 5099 115 ntes ntes NNP 40436 5099 116 e)nantiou e)nantiou , 40436 5099 117 = = SYM 40436 5099 118 ntai ntai NNP 40436 5099 119 ; ; : 40436 5099 120 polemiko\n polemiko\n ADD 40436 5099 121 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5099 122 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5099 123 e)/ris e)/ris NNP 40436 5099 124 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5099 125 o)rgê/ o)rgê/ NNP 40436 5099 126 ; ; : 40436 5099 127 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5099 128 dusmene\s dusmene\s . 40436 5099 129 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5099 130 o o XX 40436 5099 131 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5099 132 tou= tou= NNP 40436 5099 133 pleonektei pleonektei NN 40436 5099 134 = = SYM 40436 5099 135 n n NN 40436 5099 136 e)/rôs e)/rô NNS 40436 5099 137 , , , 40436 5099 138 misêto\n misêto\n ADD 40436 5099 139 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5099 140 o o NNP 40436 5099 141 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5099 142 phtho phtho NNP 40436 5099 143 / / SYM 40436 5099 144 nos nos NNP 40436 5099 145 . . . 40436 5099 146 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5100 1 This this DT 40436 5100 2 observation observation NN 40436 5100 3 of of IN 40436 5100 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5100 5 is be VBZ 40436 5100 6 very very RB 40436 5100 7 true true JJ 40436 5100 8 and and CC 40436 5100 9 valuable valuable JJ 40436 5100 10 -- -- : 40436 5100 11 that that IN 40436 5100 12 the the DT 40436 5100 13 causes cause NNS 40436 5100 14 of of IN 40436 5100 15 friendship friendship NN 40436 5100 16 and and CC 40436 5100 17 the the DT 40436 5100 18 causes cause NNS 40436 5100 19 of of IN 40436 5100 20 enmity enmity NN 40436 5100 21 are be VBP 40436 5100 22 both both DT 40436 5100 23 of of IN 40436 5100 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5100 25 equally equally RB 40436 5100 26 natural natural JJ 40436 5100 27 , , , 40436 5100 28 _ _ NNP 40436 5100 29 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 5100 30 _ _ NNP 40436 5100 31 equally equally RB 40436 5100 32 interwoven interwoven JJ 40436 5100 33 with with IN 40436 5100 34 the the DT 40436 5100 35 constant constant JJ 40436 5100 36 conditions condition NNS 40436 5100 37 of of IN 40436 5100 38 individual individual JJ 40436 5100 39 and and CC 40436 5100 40 social social JJ 40436 5100 41 life life NN 40436 5100 42 . . . 40436 5101 1 This this DT 40436 5101 2 is be VBZ 40436 5101 3 very very RB 40436 5101 4 different different JJ 40436 5101 5 from from IN 40436 5101 6 the the DT 40436 5101 7 vague vague JJ 40436 5101 8 , , , 40436 5101 9 partial partial JJ 40436 5101 10 , , , 40436 5101 11 and and CC 40436 5101 12 encomiastic encomiastic JJ 40436 5101 13 predicates predicate NNS 40436 5101 14 with with IN 40436 5101 15 which which WDT 40436 5101 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5101 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5101 18 : : : 40436 5101 19 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5101 20 phu phu NN 40436 5101 21 / / SYM 40436 5101 22 sei sei NN 40436 5101 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5101 24 is be VBZ 40436 5101 25 often often RB 40436 5101 26 decorated decorate VBN 40436 5101 27 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 5101 28 by by IN 40436 5101 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5101 30 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5101 31 , , , 40436 5101 32 as as RB 40436 5101 33 well well RB 40436 5101 34 as as IN 40436 5101 35 by by IN 40436 5101 36 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5101 37 and and CC 40436 5101 38 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5101 39 . . . 40436 5101 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5102 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5102 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5102 3 31 31 CD 40436 5102 4 : : : 40436 5102 5 Aristot aristot NN 40436 5102 6 . . . 40436 5103 1 Eth Eth NNP 40436 5103 2 . . . 40436 5104 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 5104 2 . . . 40436 5105 1 viii viii RB 40436 5105 2 . . . 40436 5106 1 1 1 CD 40436 5106 2 , , , 40436 5106 3 p. p. NN 40436 5106 4 1155 1155 CD 40436 5106 5 b. b. NNP 40436 5107 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 5107 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5107 3 , , , 40436 5107 4 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5107 5 , , , 40436 5107 6 214 214 CD 40436 5107 7 A--215 a--215 CD 40436 5107 8 E. e. NN 40436 5107 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5107 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5107 11 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5107 12 32 32 CD 40436 5107 13 : : : 40436 5107 14 Aristot aristot NN 40436 5107 15 . . . 40436 5108 1 Ethic ethic NN 40436 5108 2 . . . 40436 5109 1 Nik Nik NNP 40436 5109 2 . . . 40436 5110 1 viii viii RB 40436 5110 2 . . . 40436 5111 1 2 2 CD 40436 5111 2 , , , 40436 5111 3 p. p. NN 40436 5111 4 1155 1155 CD 40436 5111 5 , , , 40436 5111 6 b. b. NNP 40436 5112 1 28 28 CD 40436 5112 2 ; ; : 40436 5112 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5112 4 , , , 40436 5112 5 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5112 6 , , , 40436 5112 7 212 212 CD 40436 5112 8 D. d. NN 40436 5112 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5112 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5112 11 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5112 12 33 33 CD 40436 5112 13 : : : 40436 5112 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5112 15 , , , 40436 5112 16 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5112 17 , , , 40436 5112 18 212 212 CD 40436 5112 19 A a NN 40436 5112 20 : : : 40436 5112 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5112 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5112 23 : : : 40436 5112 24 o(/ntina o(/ntina NNP 40436 5112 25 tro tro NN 40436 5112 26 / / SYM 40436 5112 27 pon pon NN 40436 5112 28 gi gi NNP 40436 5112 29 / / SYM 40436 5112 30 gnetai gnetai NNP 40436 5112 31 phi phi NNP 40436 5112 32 / / SYM 40436 5112 33 los los NNP 40436 5112 34 e(/teros e(/teros NNP 40436 5112 35 e(te e(te NNP 40436 5112 36 / / SYM 40436 5112 37 rou rou NN 40436 5112 38 . . . 40436 5112 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5113 1 223 223 CD 40436 5113 2 ad ad NN 40436 5113 3 fin fin NN 40436 5113 4 . . . 40436 5114 1 : : : 40436 5114 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5114 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5114 4 : : : 40436 5114 5 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 5114 6 , , , 40436 5114 7 ti ti IN 40436 5114 8 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 5114 9 o o NNP 40436 5114 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5114 11 phi phi NNP 40436 5114 12 / / SYM 40436 5114 13 los los NNP 40436 5114 14 . . . 40436 5114 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5114 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5115 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5115 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5115 3 34 34 CD 40436 5115 4 : : : 40436 5115 5 See see VB 40436 5115 6 the the DT 40436 5115 7 chapter chapter NN 40436 5115 8 on on IN 40436 5115 9 Tender Tender NNP 40436 5115 10 Emotion Emotion NNP 40436 5115 11 in in IN 40436 5115 12 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5115 13 Bain Bain NNP 40436 5115 14 's 's POS 40436 5115 15 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 5115 16 classification classification NN 40436 5115 17 and and CC 40436 5115 18 description description NN 40436 5115 19 of of IN 40436 5115 20 the the DT 40436 5115 21 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 5115 22 . . . 40436 5116 1 ' ' `` 40436 5116 2 The the DT 40436 5116 3 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 5116 4 and and CC 40436 5116 5 the the DT 40436 5116 6 Will Will NNP 40436 5116 7 , , , 40436 5116 8 ' ' '' 40436 5116 9 ch ch NN 40436 5116 10 . . . 40436 5117 1 vii vii NN 40436 5117 2 . . . 40436 5118 1 p. p. NN 40436 5118 2 94 94 CD 40436 5118 3 seq seq NN 40436 5118 4 . . . 40436 5119 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5119 2 3rd 3rd NNP 40436 5119 3 ed ed NNP 40436 5119 4 . . NNP 40436 5119 5 , , , 40436 5119 6 p. p. NN 40436 5119 7 124 124 CD 40436 5119 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5119 9 . . . 40436 5120 1 In in IN 40436 5120 2 the the DT 40436 5120 3 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5120 4 , , , 40436 5120 5 216 216 CD 40436 5120 6 C c NN 40436 5120 7 - - HYPH 40436 5120 8 D D NNP 40436 5120 9 , , , 40436 5120 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5120 11 read read VBP 40436 5120 12 , , , 40436 5120 13 among among IN 40436 5120 14 the the DT 40436 5120 15 suppositions supposition NNS 40436 5120 16 thrown throw VBN 40436 5120 17 out out RP 40436 5120 18 by by IN 40436 5120 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5120 20 , , , 40436 5120 21 about about IN 40436 5120 22 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5120 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5120 24 : : : 40436 5120 25 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5120 26 phi phi NNP 40436 5120 27 / / SYM 40436 5120 28 lon lon NNP 40436 5120 29 -- -- : 40436 5120 30 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 5120 31 / / SYM 40436 5120 32 ei ei UH 40436 5120 33 kata\ kata\ . 40436 5120 34 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5120 35 a)rchai a)rchai NNP 40436 5120 36 / / SYM 40436 5120 37 an an DT 40436 5120 38 paroimi paroimi NN 40436 5120 39 / / , 40436 5120 40 an an DT 40436 5120 41 to\ to\ NN 40436 5120 42 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 5120 43 phi phi NNP 40436 5120 44 / / SYM 40436 5120 45 lon lon NNP 40436 5120 46 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 5120 47 . . . 40436 5121 1 e)/oike e)/oike NNP 40436 5121 2 gou gou NNP 40436 5121 3 = = SYM 40436 5121 4 n n CC 40436 5121 5 malakô=| malakô=| NNP 40436 5121 6 tini tini NNP 40436 5121 7 kai\lei kai\lei NNP 40436 5121 8 / / SYM 40436 5121 9 ô| ô| NNP 40436 5121 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5121 11 liparô=| liparô=| NNP 40436 5121 12 ; ; : 40436 5121 13 dio\ dio\ NNP 40436 5121 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5121 15 i)/sôs i)/sôs NNP 40436 5121 16 r(a|di r(a|di NNP 40436 5121 17 / / SYM 40436 5121 18 ôs ôs NNP 40436 5121 19 diolisthai diolisthai NNP 40436 5121 20 / / SYM 40436 5121 21 nei nei NNP 40436 5121 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5121 23 diadu diadu NNP 40436 5121 24 / / SYM 40436 5121 25 etai etai NNP 40436 5121 26 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 5121 27 = = SYM 40436 5121 28 s s NNP 40436 5121 29 , , , 40436 5121 30 a(/te a(/te NNP 40436 5121 31 toiou toiou NNP 40436 5121 32 = = SYM 40436 5121 33 ton ton NN 40436 5121 34 o)/n o)/n NNP 40436 5121 35 ; ; : 40436 5121 36 le le NNP 40436 5121 37 / / SYM 40436 5121 38 gô gô NNP 40436 5121 39 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5121 40 ta)gatho\n ta)gatho\n NNP 40436 5121 41 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 5121 42 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 5121 43 . . . 40436 5121 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5122 1 This this DT 40436 5122 2 allusion allusion NN 40436 5122 3 to to IN 40436 5122 4 the the DT 40436 5122 5 soft soft JJ 40436 5122 6 and and CC 40436 5122 7 the the DT 40436 5122 8 smooth smooth JJ 40436 5122 9 is be VBZ 40436 5122 10 not not RB 40436 5122 11 very very RB 40436 5122 12 clear clear JJ 40436 5122 13 ; ; : 40436 5122 14 a a DT 40436 5122 15 passage passage NN 40436 5122 16 in in IN 40436 5122 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5122 18 Bain Bain NNP 40436 5122 19 's 's POS 40436 5122 20 chapter chapter NN 40436 5122 21 serves serve VBZ 40436 5122 22 to to TO 40436 5122 23 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 5122 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5122 25 . . . 40436 5123 1 " " `` 40436 5123 2 Among among IN 40436 5123 3 the the DT 40436 5123 4 sensations sensation NNS 40436 5123 5 of of IN 40436 5123 6 the the DT 40436 5123 7 senses sense NNS 40436 5123 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5123 9 find find VBP 40436 5123 10 some some DT 40436 5123 11 that that WDT 40436 5123 12 have have VBP 40436 5123 13 the the DT 40436 5123 14 power power NN 40436 5123 15 of of IN 40436 5123 16 awakening awaken VBG 40436 5123 17 tender tender NN 40436 5123 18 emotion emotion NN 40436 5123 19 . . . 40436 5124 1 The the DT 40436 5124 2 sensations sensation NNS 40436 5124 3 that that WDT 40436 5124 4 incline incline VBP 40436 5124 5 to to IN 40436 5124 6 tenderness tenderness NN 40436 5124 7 are be VBP 40436 5124 8 , , , 40436 5124 9 in in IN 40436 5124 10 the the DT 40436 5124 11 first first JJ 40436 5124 12 place place NN 40436 5124 13 , , , 40436 5124 14 the the DT 40436 5124 15 effects effect NNS 40436 5124 16 of of IN 40436 5124 17 very very RB 40436 5124 18 gentle gentle JJ 40436 5124 19 or or CC 40436 5124 20 soft soft JJ 40436 5124 21 stimulants stimulant NNS 40436 5124 22 , , , 40436 5124 23 such such JJ 40436 5124 24 as as IN 40436 5124 25 soft soft JJ 40436 5124 26 touches touch NNS 40436 5124 27 , , , 40436 5124 28 gentle gentle JJ 40436 5124 29 sounds sound NNS 40436 5124 30 , , , 40436 5124 31 slow slow JJ 40436 5124 32 movements movement NNS 40436 5124 33 , , , 40436 5124 34 temperate temperate NN 40436 5124 35 warmth warmth NN 40436 5124 36 , , , 40436 5124 37 mild mild JJ 40436 5124 38 sunshine sunshine NN 40436 5124 39 . . . 40436 5125 1 These these DT 40436 5125 2 sensations sensation NNS 40436 5125 3 must must MD 40436 5125 4 be be VB 40436 5125 5 felt feel VBN 40436 5125 6 in in IN 40436 5125 7 order order NN 40436 5125 8 to to TO 40436 5125 9 produce produce VB 40436 5125 10 the the DT 40436 5125 11 effect effect NN 40436 5125 12 , , , 40436 5125 13 which which WDT 40436 5125 14 is be VBZ 40436 5125 15 mental mental JJ 40436 5125 16 and and CC 40436 5125 17 not not RB 40436 5125 18 simply simply RB 40436 5125 19 organic organic JJ 40436 5125 20 . . . 40436 5126 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5126 2 have have VBP 40436 5126 3 seen see VBN 40436 5126 4 that that IN 40436 5126 5 an an DT 40436 5126 6 acute acute JJ 40436 5126 7 sensation sensation NN 40436 5126 8 raises raise VBZ 40436 5126 9 a a DT 40436 5126 10 vigorous vigorous JJ 40436 5126 11 muscular muscular JJ 40436 5126 12 expression expression NN 40436 5126 13 , , , 40436 5126 14 as as IN 40436 5126 15 in in IN 40436 5126 16 wonder wonder NN 40436 5126 17 ; ; : 40436 5126 18 a a DT 40436 5126 19 contrast contrast NN 40436 5126 20 to to IN 40436 5126 21 this this DT 40436 5126 22 is be VBZ 40436 5126 23 exhibited exhibit VBN 40436 5126 24 by by IN 40436 5126 25 gentle gentle JJ 40436 5126 26 pressure pressure NN 40436 5126 27 or or CC 40436 5126 28 mild mild JJ 40436 5126 29 radiance radiance NN 40436 5126 30 . . . 40436 5127 1 Hence hence RB 40436 5127 2 tenderness tenderness NN 40436 5127 3 is be VBZ 40436 5127 4 passive passive JJ 40436 5127 5 emotion emotion NN 40436 5127 6 by by IN 40436 5127 7 pre pre NN 40436 5127 8 - - NN 40436 5127 9 eminence eminence NN 40436 5127 10 : : : 40436 5127 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5127 12 see see VBP 40436 5127 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5127 14 flourishing flourish VBG 40436 5127 15 best well RBS 40436 5127 16 in in IN 40436 5127 17 the the DT 40436 5127 18 quiescence quiescence NN 40436 5127 19 of of IN 40436 5127 20 the the DT 40436 5127 21 moving move VBG 40436 5127 22 members member NNS 40436 5127 23 . . . 40436 5128 1 Remotely remotely RB 40436 5128 2 there there EX 40436 5128 3 may may MD 40436 5128 4 be be VB 40436 5128 5 a a DT 40436 5128 6 large large JJ 40436 5128 7 amount amount NN 40436 5128 8 of of IN 40436 5128 9 action action NN 40436 5128 10 stimulated stimulate VBN 40436 5128 11 by by IN 40436 5128 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5128 13 , , , 40436 5128 14 but but CC 40436 5128 15 the the DT 40436 5128 16 proper proper JJ 40436 5128 17 outgoing outgoing JJ 40436 5128 18 accompaniment accompaniment NN 40436 5128 19 of of IN 40436 5128 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5128 21 is be VBZ 40436 5128 22 organic organic JJ 40436 5128 23 not not RB 40436 5128 24 muscular muscular JJ 40436 5128 25 . . . 40436 5128 26 " " '' 40436 5129 1 That that IN 40436 5129 2 the the DT 40436 5129 3 sensations sensation NNS 40436 5129 4 of of IN 40436 5129 5 the the DT 40436 5129 6 soft soft JJ 40436 5129 7 and and CC 40436 5129 8 the the DT 40436 5129 9 smooth smooth JJ 40436 5129 10 dispose dispose NN 40436 5129 11 to to IN 40436 5129 12 the the DT 40436 5129 13 Tender Tender NNP 40436 5129 14 Emotion Emotion NNP 40436 5129 15 is be VBZ 40436 5129 16 here here RB 40436 5129 17 pointed point VBN 40436 5129 18 out out RP 40436 5129 19 as as IN 40436 5129 20 a a DT 40436 5129 21 fact fact NN 40436 5129 22 in in IN 40436 5129 23 human human JJ 40436 5129 24 nature nature NN 40436 5129 25 , , , 40436 5129 26 agreeably agreeably RB 40436 5129 27 to to IN 40436 5129 28 the the DT 40436 5129 29 comparison comparison NN 40436 5129 30 of of IN 40436 5129 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5129 32 . . . 40436 5130 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5130 2 Bain Bain NNP 40436 5130 3 's 's POS 40436 5130 4 treatise treatise NN 40436 5130 5 has have VBZ 40436 5130 6 the the DT 40436 5130 7 rare rare JJ 40436 5130 8 merit merit NN 40436 5130 9 of of IN 40436 5130 10 describing describe VBG 40436 5130 11 fully fully RB 40436 5130 12 the the DT 40436 5130 13 physical physical NN 40436 5130 14 as as RB 40436 5130 15 well well RB 40436 5130 16 as as IN 40436 5130 17 the the DT 40436 5130 18 mental mental JJ 40436 5130 19 characteristics characteristic NNS 40436 5130 20 of of IN 40436 5130 21 each each DT 40436 5130 22 separate separate JJ 40436 5130 23 emotion emotion NN 40436 5130 24 . . . 40436 5130 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5131 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5131 2 Side side NN 40436 5131 3 - - HYPH 40436 5131 4 note note NN 40436 5131 5 : : : 40436 5131 6 Debate debate NN 40436 5131 7 in in IN 40436 5131 8 the the DT 40436 5131 9 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5131 10 partly partly RB 40436 5131 11 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5131 12 , , , 40436 5131 13 partly partly RB 40436 5131 14 real real JJ 40436 5131 15 . . . 40436 5132 1 Assumptions assumption NNS 40436 5132 2 made make VBN 40436 5132 3 by by IN 40436 5132 4 the the DT 40436 5132 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5132 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5132 7 , , , 40436 5132 8 questionable questionable JJ 40436 5132 9 , , , 40436 5132 10 such such JJ 40436 5132 11 as as IN 40436 5132 12 the the DT 40436 5132 13 real real JJ 40436 5132 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5132 15 would would MD 40436 5132 16 have have VB 40436 5132 17 found find VBN 40436 5132 18 reason reason NN 40436 5132 19 for for IN 40436 5132 20 challenging challenge VBG 40436 5132 21 . . . 40436 5132 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5133 1 The the DT 40436 5133 2 debate debate NN 40436 5133 3 in in IN 40436 5133 4 the the DT 40436 5133 5 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5133 6 is be VBZ 40436 5133 7 partly partly RB 40436 5133 8 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5133 9 : : : 40436 5133 10 _ _ NNP 40436 5133 11 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 5133 12 _ _ NNP 40436 5133 13 , , , 40436 5133 14 respecting respect VBG 40436 5133 15 the the DT 40436 5133 16 word word NN 40436 5133 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5133 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5133 19 : : : 40436 5133 20 phi phi NNP 40436 5133 21 / / SYM 40436 5133 22 los los NNP 40436 5133 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5133 24 , , , 40436 5133 25 whether whether IN 40436 5133 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5133 27 means mean VBZ 40436 5133 28 the the DT 40436 5133 29 person person NN 40436 5133 30 loving love VBG 40436 5133 31 , , , 40436 5133 32 or or CC 40436 5133 33 the the DT 40436 5133 34 person person NN 40436 5133 35 loved love VBD 40436 5133 36 , , , 40436 5133 37 or or CC 40436 5133 38 whether whether IN 40436 5133 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5133 40 shall shall MD 40436 5133 41 be be VB 40436 5133 42 confined confine VBN 40436 5133 43 to to IN 40436 5133 44 those those DT 40436 5133 45 cases case NNS 40436 5133 46 in in IN 40436 5133 47 which which WDT 40436 5133 48 the the DT 40436 5133 49 love love NN 40436 5133 50 is be VBZ 40436 5133 51 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 5133 52 , , , 40436 5133 53 and and CC 40436 5133 54 then then RB 40436 5133 55 applied apply VBD 40436 5133 56 to to IN 40436 5133 57 both both DT 40436 5133 58 . . . 40436 5134 1 Herein Herein NNP 40436 5134 2 the the DT 40436 5134 3 question question NN 40436 5134 4 is be VBZ 40436 5134 5 about about IN 40436 5134 6 the the DT 40436 5134 7 meaning meaning NN 40436 5134 8 of of IN 40436 5134 9 words word NNS 40436 5134 10 -- -- : 40436 5134 11 a a DT 40436 5134 12 word word NN 40436 5134 13 and and CC 40436 5134 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 5134 15 more more JJR 40436 5134 16 . . . 40436 5135 1 The the DT 40436 5135 2 following follow VBG 40436 5135 3 portions portion NNS 40436 5135 4 of of IN 40436 5135 5 the the DT 40436 5135 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5135 7 enter enter VBP 40436 5135 8 upon upon IN 40436 5135 9 questions question NNS 40436 5135 10 not not RB 40436 5135 11 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5135 12 but but CC 40436 5135 13 real--"Whether real--"whether UH 40436 5135 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5135 15 are be VBP 40436 5135 16 disposed disposed JJ 40436 5135 17 to to TO 40436 5135 18 love love VB 40436 5135 19 what what WP 40436 5135 20 is be VBZ 40436 5135 21 like like IN 40436 5135 22 to to IN 40436 5135 23 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5135 24 , , , 40436 5135 25 or or CC 40436 5135 26 what what WP 40436 5135 27 is be VBZ 40436 5135 28 unlike unlike IN 40436 5135 29 or or CC 40436 5135 30 opposite opposite RB 40436 5135 31 to to IN 40436 5135 32 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5135 33 ? ? . 40436 5135 34 " " '' 40436 5136 1 Though though IN 40436 5136 2 both both CC 40436 5136 3 these these DT 40436 5136 4 are be VBP 40436 5136 5 occasionally occasionally RB 40436 5136 6 true true JJ 40436 5136 7 , , , 40436 5136 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5136 9 is be VBZ 40436 5136 10 shown show VBN 40436 5136 11 that that IN 40436 5136 12 as as IN 40436 5136 13 general general JJ 40436 5136 14 explanations explanation NNS 40436 5136 15 neither neither DT 40436 5136 16 of of IN 40436 5136 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5136 18 will will MD 40436 5136 19 hold hold VB 40436 5136 20 . . . 40436 5137 1 But but CC 40436 5137 2 this this DT 40436 5137 3 is be VBZ 40436 5137 4 shown show VBN 40436 5137 5 by by IN 40436 5137 6 means mean NNS 40436 5137 7 of of IN 40436 5137 8 the the DT 40436 5137 9 following follow VBG 40436 5137 10 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 5137 11 , , , 40436 5137 12 which which WDT 40436 5137 13 not not RB 40436 5137 14 only only RB 40436 5137 15 those those DT 40436 5137 16 whom whom WP 40436 5137 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5137 18 here here RB 40436 5137 19 calls call VBZ 40436 5137 20 the the DT 40436 5137 21 " " `` 40436 5137 22 very very RB 40436 5137 23 clever clever JJ 40436 5137 24 Disputants,"[35 Disputants,"[35 NNP 40436 5137 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5137 26 but but CC 40436 5137 27 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 5137 28 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5137 29 at at IN 40436 5137 30 other other JJ 40436 5137 31 times time NNS 40436 5137 32 , , , 40436 5137 33 would would MD 40436 5137 34 have have VB 40436 5137 35 called call VBN 40436 5137 36 in in RP 40436 5137 37 question question NN 40436 5137 38 , , , 40436 5137 39 viz viz NN 40436 5137 40 . . . 40436 5138 1 : : : 40436 5138 2 " " `` 40436 5138 3 That that DT 40436 5138 4 bad bad JJ 40436 5138 5 men man NNS 40436 5138 6 can can MD 40436 5138 7 not not RB 40436 5138 8 be be VB 40436 5138 9 friends friend NNS 40436 5138 10 to to IN 40436 5138 11 each each DT 40436 5138 12 other other JJ 40436 5138 13 -- -- : 40436 5138 14 that that IN 40436 5138 15 men man NNS 40436 5138 16 like like VBP 40436 5138 17 to to IN 40436 5138 18 each each DT 40436 5138 19 other other JJ 40436 5138 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5138 21 therefore therefore RB 40436 5138 22 good good JJ 40436 5138 23 men man NNS 40436 5138 24 as as RB 40436 5138 25 well well RB 40436 5138 26 as as IN 40436 5138 27 bad bad JJ 40436 5138 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5138 29 can can MD 40436 5138 30 be be VB 40436 5138 31 of of IN 40436 5138 32 no no DT 40436 5138 33 use use NN 40436 5138 34 to to IN 40436 5138 35 each each DT 40436 5138 36 other other JJ 40436 5138 37 , , , 40436 5138 38 and and CC 40436 5138 39 therefore therefore RB 40436 5138 40 there there EX 40436 5138 41 can can MD 40436 5138 42 be be VB 40436 5138 43 no no DT 40436 5138 44 basis basis NN 40436 5138 45 of of IN 40436 5138 46 friendship friendship NN 40436 5138 47 between between IN 40436 5138 48 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5138 49 -- -- : 40436 5138 50 that that IN 40436 5138 51 the the DT 40436 5138 52 good good JJ 40436 5138 53 man man NN 40436 5138 54 is be VBZ 40436 5138 55 self self NN 40436 5138 56 - - HYPH 40436 5138 57 sufficing suffice VBG 40436 5138 58 , , , 40436 5138 59 stands stand VBZ 40436 5138 60 in in IN 40436 5138 61 need need NN 40436 5138 62 of of IN 40436 5138 63 no no DT 40436 5138 64 one one NN 40436 5138 65 , , , 40436 5138 66 and and CC 40436 5138 67 therefore therefore RB 40436 5138 68 will will MD 40436 5138 69 not not RB 40436 5138 70 love love VB 40436 5138 71 any any DT 40436 5138 72 one one CD 40436 5138 73 . . . 40436 5139 1 " " `` 40436 5139 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5139 3 36 36 CD 40436 5139 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5139 5 All all PDT 40436 5139 6 these these DT 40436 5139 7 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 5139 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5139 9 would would MD 40436 5139 10 have have VB 40436 5139 11 found find VBN 40436 5139 12 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 5139 13 reason reason NN 40436 5139 14 for for IN 40436 5139 15 challenging challenging NN 40436 5139 16 , , , 40436 5139 17 if if IN 40436 5139 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5139 19 had have VBD 40436 5139 20 been be VBN 40436 5139 21 advanced advance VBN 40436 5139 22 by by IN 40436 5139 23 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5139 24 or or CC 40436 5139 25 any any DT 40436 5139 26 other other JJ 40436 5139 27 opponents opponent NNS 40436 5139 28 . . . 40436 5140 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5140 2 stand stand VBP 40436 5140 3 here here RB 40436 5140 4 as as IN 40436 5140 5 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 5140 6 by by IN 40436 5140 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5140 8 ; ; : 40436 5140 9 but but CC 40436 5140 10 here here RB 40436 5140 11 , , , 40436 5140 12 as as RB 40436 5140 13 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 5140 14 in in IN 40436 5140 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5140 16 , , , 40436 5140 17 the the DT 40436 5140 18 reader reader NN 40436 5140 19 must must MD 40436 5140 20 apply apply VB 40436 5140 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5140 22 own own JJ 40436 5140 23 critical critical JJ 40436 5140 24 intellect intellect NN 40436 5140 25 , , , 40436 5140 26 and and CC 40436 5140 27 test test VB 40436 5140 28 what what WP 40436 5140 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5140 30 reads read VBZ 40436 5140 31 for for IN 40436 5140 32 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5140 33 . . . 40436 5141 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5141 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5141 3 35 35 CD 40436 5141 4 : : : 40436 5141 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5141 6 , , , 40436 5141 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5141 8 , , , 40436 5141 9 216 216 CD 40436 5141 10 A. a. NN 40436 5141 11 : : : 40436 5141 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5141 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5141 14 : : : 40436 5141 15 oi oi NNP 40436 5141 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5141 17 pa pa NNP 40436 5141 18 / / SYM 40436 5141 19 nsophoi nsophoi NNP 40436 5141 20 a)/ndres a)/ndres NNPS 40436 5141 21 oi oi NNP 40436 5141 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5141 23 a)ntilogikoi/ a)ntilogikoi/ NFP 40436 5141 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5141 25 , , , 40436 5141 26 & & CC 40436 5141 27 c. c. NNP 40436 5141 28 Yet Yet NNP 40436 5141 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5141 30 , , , 40436 5141 31 in in IN 40436 5141 32 the the DT 40436 5141 33 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 5141 34 and and CC 40436 5141 35 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 5141 36 , , , 40436 5141 37 indicates indicate VBZ 40436 5141 38 colloquial colloquial JJ 40436 5141 39 debate debate NN 40436 5141 40 as as IN 40436 5141 41 the the DT 40436 5141 42 great great JJ 40436 5141 43 generating generating NN 40436 5141 44 cause cause NN 40436 5141 45 of of IN 40436 5141 46 the the DT 40436 5141 47 most most RBS 40436 5141 48 intense intense JJ 40436 5141 49 and and CC 40436 5141 50 durable durable JJ 40436 5141 51 friendship friendship NN 40436 5141 52 . . . 40436 5142 1 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 5142 2 the the DT 40436 5142 3 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 5142 4 says say VBZ 40436 5142 5 , , , 40436 5142 6 Orat Orat NNP 40436 5142 7 . . . 40436 5143 1 xlvii xlvii NNP 40436 5143 2 . . . 40436 5144 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5144 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5144 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5144 4 : : : 40436 5144 5 Pro\s Pro\s NNP 40436 5144 6 Kapi Kapi NNP 40436 5144 7 / / SYM 40436 5144 8 tôna tôna NN 40436 5144 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5144 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5144 11 , , , 40436 5144 12 p. p. NN 40436 5144 13 418 418 CD 40436 5144 14 , , , 40436 5144 15 Dindorf Dindorf NNP 40436 5144 16 , , , 40436 5144 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5144 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5144 19 : : : 40436 5144 20 e)pei\ e)pei\ `` 40436 5144 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5144 22 Pla Pla NNP 40436 5144 23 / / SYM 40436 5144 24 tôn tôn NNP 40436 5144 25 to\ to\ NN 40436 5144 26 a)lêthe\s a)lêthe\s NNP 40436 5144 27 a(pantachou= a(pantachou= NNP 40436 5144 28 tima=| tima=| NNP 40436 5144 29 , , , 40436 5144 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5144 31 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 5144 32 e)n e)n NNP 40436 5144 33 toi toi NNP 40436 5144 34 = = SYM 40436 5144 35 s s NNP 40436 5144 36 lo lo NNP 40436 5144 37 / / SYM 40436 5144 38 gois gois NNP 40436 5144 39 sunousi sunousi NNP 40436 5144 40 / / SYM 40436 5144 41 as as IN 40436 5144 42 a)phormê\n a)phormê\n NNP 40436 5144 43 phili phili NNP 40436 5144 44 / / SYM 40436 5144 45 as as IN 40436 5144 46 a)lêthinê a)lêthinê CD 40436 5144 47 = = SYM 40436 5144 48 s s NNP 40436 5144 49 u(polamba u(polamba NNP 40436 5144 50 / / SYM 40436 5144 51 nei nei NNP 40436 5144 52 . . . 40436 5144 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5144 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5145 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5145 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5145 3 36 36 CD 40436 5145 4 : : : 40436 5145 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5145 6 , , , 40436 5145 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5145 8 , , , 40436 5145 9 214 214 CD 40436 5145 10 - - SYM 40436 5145 11 215 215 CD 40436 5145 12 . . . 40436 5146 1 The the DT 40436 5146 2 discourse discourse NN 40436 5146 3 of of IN 40436 5146 4 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 5146 5 , , , 40436 5146 6 De De NNP 40436 5146 7 Amicitiâ Amicitiâ NNP 40436 5146 8 , , , 40436 5146 9 is be VBZ 40436 5146 10 composed compose VBN 40436 5146 11 in in IN 40436 5146 12 a a DT 40436 5146 13 style style NN 40436 5146 14 of of IN 40436 5146 15 pleasing pleasing JJ 40436 5146 16 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 5146 17 ; ; : 40436 5146 18 suitable suitable JJ 40436 5146 19 to to IN 40436 5146 20 Lælius Lælius NNP 40436 5146 21 , , , 40436 5146 22 an an DT 40436 5146 23 ancient ancient JJ 40436 5146 24 Roman roman JJ 40436 5146 25 senator senator NN 40436 5146 26 and and CC 40436 5146 27 active active JJ 40436 5146 28 politician politician NN 40436 5146 29 , , , 40436 5146 30 who who WP 40436 5146 31 expressly expressly RB 40436 5146 32 renounces renounce VBZ 40436 5146 33 the the DT 40436 5146 34 accurate accurate JJ 40436 5146 35 subtlety subtlety NN 40436 5146 36 of of IN 40436 5146 37 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 5146 38 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 5146 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5146 40 v. v. CC 40436 5146 41 18 18 CD 40436 5146 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5146 43 . . . 40436 5147 1 There there EX 40436 5147 2 is be VBZ 40436 5147 3 little little JJ 40436 5147 4 in in IN 40436 5147 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5147 6 which which WDT 40436 5147 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5147 8 can can MD 40436 5147 9 compare compare VB 40436 5147 10 with with IN 40436 5147 11 the the DT 40436 5147 12 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5147 13 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5147 14 ; ; : 40436 5147 15 but but CC 40436 5147 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5147 17 observe observe VBP 40436 5147 18 that that IN 40436 5147 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5147 20 too too RB 40436 5147 21 , , , 40436 5147 22 giving give VBG 40436 5147 23 expression expression NN 40436 5147 24 to to IN 40436 5147 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5147 26 own own JJ 40436 5147 27 feelings feeling NNS 40436 5147 28 , , , 40436 5147 29 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 5147 30 that that IN 40436 5147 31 there there EX 40436 5147 32 can can MD 40436 5147 33 be be VB 40436 5147 34 no no DT 40436 5147 35 friendship friendship NN 40436 5147 36 except except IN 40436 5147 37 between between IN 40436 5147 38 the the DT 40436 5147 39 good good JJ 40436 5147 40 and and CC 40436 5147 41 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 5147 42 : : : 40436 5147 43 a a DT 40436 5147 44 position position NN 40436 5147 45 which which WDT 40436 5147 46 is be VBZ 40436 5147 47 refuted refute VBN 40436 5147 48 by by IN 40436 5147 49 the the DT 40436 5147 50 " " `` 40436 5147 51 nefaria nefaria NNP 40436 5147 52 vox vox NNP 40436 5147 53 , , , 40436 5147 54 " " '' 40436 5147 55 cited cite VBN 40436 5147 56 by by IN 40436 5147 57 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5147 58 as as IN 40436 5147 59 spoken speak VBN 40436 5147 60 by by IN 40436 5147 61 C. C. NNP 40436 5147 62 Blossius Blossius NNP 40436 5147 63 , , , 40436 5147 64 xi xi NNP 40436 5147 65 . . . 40436 5148 1 37 37 CD 40436 5148 2 . . . 40436 5148 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5149 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5149 2 Side side NN 40436 5149 3 - - HYPH 40436 5149 4 note note NN 40436 5149 5 : : : 40436 5149 6 Peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 5149 7 theory theory NN 40436 5149 8 about about IN 40436 5149 9 friendship friendship NN 40436 5149 10 broached broach VBN 40436 5149 11 by by IN 40436 5149 12 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5149 13 . . . 40436 5150 1 Persons person NNS 40436 5150 2 neither neither CC 40436 5150 3 good good JJ 40436 5150 4 nor nor CC 40436 5150 5 evil evil JJ 40436 5150 6 by by IN 40436 5150 7 nature nature NN 40436 5150 8 , , , 40436 5150 9 yet yet CC 40436 5150 10 having have VBG 40436 5150 11 a a DT 40436 5150 12 superficial superficial JJ 40436 5150 13 tinge tinge NN 40436 5150 14 of of IN 40436 5150 15 evil evil NN 40436 5150 16 , , , 40436 5150 17 and and CC 40436 5150 18 desiring desire VBG 40436 5150 19 good good JJ 40436 5150 20 to to TO 40436 5150 21 escape escape VB 40436 5150 22 from from IN 40436 5150 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5150 24 . . . 40436 5150 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5151 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5151 2 is be VBZ 40436 5151 3 thus thus RB 40436 5151 4 shown show VBN 40436 5151 5 , , , 40436 5151 6 or or CC 40436 5151 7 supposed suppose VBN 40436 5151 8 to to TO 40436 5151 9 be be VB 40436 5151 10 shown show VBN 40436 5151 11 , , , 40436 5151 12 that that IN 40436 5151 13 the the DT 40436 5151 14 persons person NNS 40436 5151 15 who who WP 40436 5151 16 love love VBP 40436 5151 17 are be VBP 40436 5151 18 neither neither CC 40436 5151 19 the the DT 40436 5151 20 Good good JJ 40436 5151 21 , , , 40436 5151 22 nor nor CC 40436 5151 23 the the DT 40436 5151 24 Bad bad JJ 40436 5151 25 : : : 40436 5151 26 and and CC 40436 5151 27 that that IN 40436 5151 28 the the DT 40436 5151 29 objects object NNS 40436 5151 30 loved love VBD 40436 5151 31 , , , 40436 5151 32 are be VBP 40436 5151 33 neither neither CC 40436 5151 34 things thing NNS 40436 5151 35 or or CC 40436 5151 36 persons person NNS 40436 5151 37 similar similar JJ 40436 5151 38 , , , 40436 5151 39 nor nor CC 40436 5151 40 opposite opposite JJ 40436 5151 41 , , , 40436 5151 42 to to IN 40436 5151 43 the the DT 40436 5151 44 persons person NNS 40436 5151 45 loving love VBG 40436 5151 46 . . . 40436 5152 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5152 2 now now RB 40436 5152 3 adverts advert VBZ 40436 5152 4 to to IN 40436 5152 5 the the DT 40436 5152 6 existence existence NN 40436 5152 7 of of IN 40436 5152 8 a a DT 40436 5152 9 third third JJ 40436 5152 10 category category NN 40436 5152 11 -- -- : 40436 5152 12 Persons person NNS 40436 5152 13 who who WP 40436 5152 14 are be VBP 40436 5152 15 neither neither RB 40436 5152 16 good good JJ 40436 5152 17 , , , 40436 5152 18 nor nor CC 40436 5152 19 bad bad JJ 40436 5152 20 , , , 40436 5152 21 but but CC 40436 5152 22 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 5152 23 between between IN 40436 5152 24 the the DT 40436 5152 25 two two CD 40436 5152 26 -- -- : 40436 5152 27 Objects object NNS 40436 5152 28 which which WDT 40436 5152 29 are be VBP 40436 5152 30 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 5152 31 between between IN 40436 5152 32 likeness likeness NN 40436 5152 33 and and CC 40436 5152 34 opposition opposition NN 40436 5152 35 . . . 40436 5153 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5153 2 announces announce VBZ 40436 5153 3 as as IN 40436 5153 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5153 5 own own JJ 40436 5153 6 conjecture,[37 conjecture,[37 NN 40436 5153 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5153 8 that that IN 40436 5153 9 the the DT 40436 5153 10 Subject Subject NNP 40436 5153 11 of of IN 40436 5153 12 friendly friendly JJ 40436 5153 13 or or CC 40436 5153 14 loving love VBG 40436 5153 15 feeling feeling NN 40436 5153 16 , , , 40436 5153 17 is be VBZ 40436 5153 18 , , , 40436 5153 19 that that IN 40436 5153 20 which which WDT 40436 5153 21 is be VBZ 40436 5153 22 neither neither CC 40436 5153 23 good good JJ 40436 5153 24 nor nor CC 40436 5153 25 evil evil JJ 40436 5153 26 : : : 40436 5153 27 the the DT 40436 5153 28 Object object NN 40436 5153 29 of of IN 40436 5153 30 the the DT 40436 5153 31 feeling feeling NN 40436 5153 32 , , , 40436 5153 33 Good good NN 40436 5153 34 : : : 40436 5153 35 and and CC 40436 5153 36 the the DT 40436 5153 37 cause cause NN 40436 5153 38 of of IN 40436 5153 39 the the DT 40436 5153 40 feeling feeling NN 40436 5153 41 , , , 40436 5153 42 the the DT 40436 5153 43 superficial superficial JJ 40436 5153 44 presence presence NN 40436 5153 45 of of IN 40436 5153 46 evil evil NN 40436 5153 47 , , , 40436 5153 48 which which WDT 40436 5153 49 the the DT 40436 5153 50 subject subject JJ 40436 5153 51 desires desire NNS 40436 5153 52 to to TO 40436 5153 53 see see VB 40436 5153 54 removed remove VBN 40436 5153 55 . . . 40436 5154 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5154 2 38 38 CD 40436 5154 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5154 4 The the DT 40436 5154 5 evil evil NN 40436 5154 6 must must MD 40436 5154 7 be be VB 40436 5154 8 present present JJ 40436 5154 9 in in IN 40436 5154 10 a a DT 40436 5154 11 superficial superficial JJ 40436 5154 12 and and CC 40436 5154 13 removable removable JJ 40436 5154 14 manner manner NN 40436 5154 15 -- -- : 40436 5154 16 like like IN 40436 5154 17 whiteness whiteness NN 40436 5154 18 in in IN 40436 5154 19 the the DT 40436 5154 20 hair hair NN 40436 5154 21 caused cause VBN 40436 5154 22 by by IN 40436 5154 23 white white JJ 40436 5154 24 paint paint NN 40436 5154 25 , , , 40436 5154 26 not not RB 40436 5154 27 by by IN 40436 5154 28 the the DT 40436 5154 29 grey grey JJ 40436 5154 30 colour colour NN 40436 5154 31 of of IN 40436 5154 32 old old JJ 40436 5154 33 age age NN 40436 5154 34 . . . 40436 5155 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5155 2 applies apply VBZ 40436 5155 3 this this DT 40436 5155 4 to to IN 40436 5155 5 the the DT 40436 5155 6 state state NN 40436 5155 7 of of IN 40436 5155 8 mind mind NN 40436 5155 9 of of IN 40436 5155 10 the the DT 40436 5155 11 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 5155 12 , , , 40436 5155 13 or or CC 40436 5155 14 lover lover NN 40436 5155 15 of of IN 40436 5155 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5155 17 : : : 40436 5155 18 who who WP 40436 5155 19 is be VBZ 40436 5155 20 not not RB 40436 5155 21 yet yet RB 40436 5155 22 either either CC 40436 5155 23 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 5155 24 good good JJ 40436 5155 25 or or CC 40436 5155 26 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 5155 27 bad,--either bad,--either -LRB- 40436 5155 28 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 5155 29 wise wise JJ 40436 5155 30 or or CC 40436 5155 31 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 5155 32 unwise unwise JJ 40436 5155 33 -- -- : 40436 5155 34 but but CC 40436 5155 35 in in IN 40436 5155 36 a a DT 40436 5155 37 state state NN 40436 5155 38 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 5155 39 between between IN 40436 5155 40 the the DT 40436 5155 41 two two CD 40436 5155 42 : : : 40436 5155 43 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 5155 44 , , , 40436 5155 45 yet yet CC 40436 5155 46 conscious conscious JJ 40436 5155 47 of of IN 40436 5155 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5155 49 own own JJ 40436 5155 50 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 5155 51 , , , 40436 5155 52 and and CC 40436 5155 53 feeling feel VBG 40436 5155 54 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5155 55 as as IN 40436 5155 56 a a DT 40436 5155 57 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 5155 58 which which WDT 40436 5155 59 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5155 60 was be VBD 40436 5155 61 anxious anxious JJ 40436 5155 62 to to TO 40436 5155 63 shake shake VB 40436 5155 64 off off RP 40436 5155 65 . . . 40436 5156 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5156 2 39 39 CD 40436 5156 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5156 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5156 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5156 6 37 37 CD 40436 5156 7 : : : 40436 5156 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5156 9 , , , 40436 5156 10 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5156 11 , , , 40436 5156 12 216 216 CD 40436 5156 13 D. D. NNP 40436 5156 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5156 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5156 16 : : : 40436 5156 17 le le NNP 40436 5156 18 / / SYM 40436 5156 19 gô gô NNP 40436 5156 20 toi toi NNP 40436 5156 21 / / SYM 40436 5156 22 nun nun NNP 40436 5156 23 a)pomanteuo a)pomanteuo NNPS 40436 5156 24 / / SYM 40436 5156 25 menos menos NNP 40436 5156 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5156 27 , , , 40436 5156 28 & & CC 40436 5156 29 c. c. NNP 40436 5156 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5156 31 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5156 32 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5156 33 38 38 CD 40436 5156 34 : : : 40436 5156 35 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5156 36 , , , 40436 5156 37 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5156 38 , , , 40436 5156 39 216 216 CD 40436 5156 40 - - SYM 40436 5156 41 217 217 CD 40436 5156 42 . . . 40436 5156 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5157 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5157 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5157 3 39 39 CD 40436 5157 4 : : : 40436 5157 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5157 6 , , , 40436 5157 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5157 8 , , , 40436 5157 9 218 218 CD 40436 5157 10 C. C. NNP 40436 5157 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5157 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5157 13 : : : 40436 5157 14 lei lei NN 40436 5157 15 / / SYM 40436 5157 16 pontai pontai NNP 40436 5157 17 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 5157 18 oi oi UH 40436 5157 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5157 20 e)/chontes e)/chonte VBZ 40436 5157 21 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5157 22 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5157 23 kako\ kako\ NNP 40436 5157 24 tou tou NNP 40436 5157 25 = = SYM 40436 5157 26 to to TO 40436 5157 27 , , , 40436 5157 28 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5157 29 a)/gnoian a)/gnoian NNP 40436 5157 30 , , , 40436 5157 31 mê mê NNP 40436 5157 32 / / SYM 40436 5157 33 pô pô NNP 40436 5157 34 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5157 35 u(p u(p NNP 40436 5157 36 ' ' '' 40436 5157 37 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 5157 38 o)/ntes o)/nte NNS 40436 5157 39 a)gnô a)gnô NN 40436 5157 40 / / SYM 40436 5157 41 mones mones NNPS 40436 5157 42 mêd mêd NNP 40436 5157 43 ' ' '' 40436 5157 44 a)mathei a)mathei NNP 40436 5157 45 = = SYM 40436 5157 46 s s NNP 40436 5157 47 , , , 40436 5157 48 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 5157 49 ' ' '' 40436 5157 50 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 5157 51 ê(gou ê(gou NNP 40436 5157 52 / / SYM 40436 5157 53 menoi menoi NNP 40436 5157 54 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 5157 55 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 5157 56 / / SYM 40436 5157 57 nai nai NNP 40436 5157 58 a)\ a)\ NNP 40436 5157 59 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 5157 60 i)/sasi i)/sasi NNP 40436 5157 61 ; ; : 40436 5157 62 dio\ dio\ NNP 40436 5157 63 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 5157 64 philosophou philosophou NNP 40436 5157 65 = = NFP 40436 5157 66 sin sin NN 40436 5157 67 oi oi NNP 40436 5157 68 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5157 69 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 5157 70 a)gathoi\ a)gathoi\ NNP 40436 5157 71 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 5157 72 kakoi/ kakoi/ NNP 40436 5157 73 pô pô NN 40436 5157 74 o)/ntes o)/nte NNS 40436 5157 75 ; ; : 40436 5157 76 o(/soi o(/soi DT 40436 5157 77 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5157 78 kakoi/ kakoi/ NNP 40436 5157 79 , , , 40436 5157 80 ou ou NNP 40436 5157 81 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5157 82 philosophou philosophou NNP 40436 5157 83 = = NFP 40436 5157 84 sin sin NN 40436 5157 85 , , , 40436 5157 86 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 5157 87 oi oi FW 40436 5157 88 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5157 89 a)gathoi/. a)gathoi/. NN 40436 5157 90 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5158 1 Compare compare VB 40436 5158 2 the the DT 40436 5158 3 phrase phrase NN 40436 5158 4 of of IN 40436 5158 5 Seneca Seneca NNP 40436 5158 6 , , , 40436 5158 7 Epist epist UH 40436 5158 8 . . . 40436 5159 1 59 59 CD 40436 5159 2 , , , 40436 5159 3 p. p. NN 40436 5159 4 211 211 CD 40436 5159 5 , , , 40436 5159 6 Gronov Gronov NNP 40436 5159 7 . . . 40436 5160 1 : : : 40436 5160 2 " " `` 40436 5160 3 Elui elui JJ 40436 5160 4 difficile difficile NN 40436 5160 5 est est NN 40436 5160 6 : : : 40436 5160 7 non non AFX 40436 5160 8 enim enim NNP 40436 5160 9 inquinati inquinati NNP 40436 5160 10 sumus sumus NNP 40436 5160 11 , , , 40436 5160 12 sed sed NNP 40436 5160 13 infecti infecti NNP 40436 5160 14 " " '' 40436 5160 15 . . . 40436 5160 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5161 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5161 2 Side side NN 40436 5161 3 - - HYPH 40436 5161 4 note note NN 40436 5161 5 : : : 40436 5161 6 This this DT 40436 5161 7 general general JJ 40436 5161 8 theory theory NN 40436 5161 9 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 5161 10 by by IN 40436 5161 11 the the DT 40436 5161 12 case case NN 40436 5161 13 of of IN 40436 5161 14 the the DT 40436 5161 15 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 5161 16 or or CC 40436 5161 17 lover lover NN 40436 5161 18 of of IN 40436 5161 19 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5161 20 . . . 40436 5162 1 Painful painful JJ 40436 5162 2 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 5162 3 of of IN 40436 5162 4 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 5162 5 the the DT 40436 5162 6 attribute attribute NN 40436 5162 7 of of IN 40436 5162 8 the the DT 40436 5162 9 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 5162 10 . . . 40436 5163 1 Value value NN 40436 5163 2 set set VBN 40436 5163 3 by by IN 40436 5163 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5163 5 and and CC 40436 5163 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5163 7 upon upon IN 40436 5163 8 this this DT 40436 5163 9 attribute attribute NN 40436 5163 10 . . . 40436 5163 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5164 1 This this DT 40436 5164 2 meaning meaning NN 40436 5164 3 of of IN 40436 5164 4 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5164 5 , , , 40436 5164 6 though though IN 40436 5164 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5164 8 is be VBZ 40436 5164 9 not not RB 40436 5164 10 always always RB 40436 5164 11 and and CC 40436 5164 12 consistently consistently RB 40436 5164 13 maintained maintain VBD 40436 5164 14 throughout throughout IN 40436 5164 15 the the DT 40436 5164 16 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5164 17 writings writing NNS 40436 5164 18 , , , 40436 5164 19 is be VBZ 40436 5164 20 important important JJ 40436 5164 21 as as IN 40436 5164 22 expanding expand VBG 40436 5164 23 and and CC 40436 5164 24 bringing bring VBG 40436 5164 25 into into IN 40436 5164 26 system system NN 40436 5164 27 the the DT 40436 5164 28 position position NN 40436 5164 29 laid lay VBD 40436 5164 30 down down RP 40436 5164 31 by by IN 40436 5164 32 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5164 33 in in IN 40436 5164 34 the the DT 40436 5164 35 Apology Apology NNP 40436 5164 36 . . . 40436 5165 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5165 2 there there RB 40436 5165 3 disclaimed disclaim VBD 40436 5165 4 all all DT 40436 5165 5 pretensions pretension NNS 40436 5165 6 to to IN 40436 5165 7 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5165 8 , , , 40436 5165 9 but but CC 40436 5165 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5165 11 announced announce VBD 40436 5165 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5165 13 as as IN 40436 5165 14 a a DT 40436 5165 15 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 5165 16 , , , 40436 5165 17 in in IN 40436 5165 18 the the DT 40436 5165 19 above above JJ 40436 5165 20 literal literal JJ 40436 5165 21 sense sense NN 40436 5165 22 : : : 40436 5165 23 that that DT 40436 5165 24 is is RB 40436 5165 25 , , , 40436 5165 26 as as IN 40436 5165 27 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 5165 28 , , , 40436 5165 29 yet yet CC 40436 5165 30 as as RB 40436 5165 31 painfully painfully RB 40436 5165 32 conscious conscious JJ 40436 5165 33 of of IN 40436 5165 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5165 35 own own JJ 40436 5165 36 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 5165 37 , , , 40436 5165 38 and and CC 40436 5165 39 anxiously anxiously RB 40436 5165 40 searching search VBG 40436 5165 41 for for IN 40436 5165 42 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5165 43 as as IN 40436 5165 44 a a DT 40436 5165 45 corrective corrective NN 40436 5165 46 to to IN 40436 5165 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5165 48 : : : 40436 5165 49 while while IN 40436 5165 50 most most JJS 40436 5165 51 men man NNS 40436 5165 52 were be VBD 40436 5165 53 equally equally RB 40436 5165 54 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 5165 55 , , , 40436 5165 56 but but CC 40436 5165 57 were be VBD 40436 5165 58 unconscious unconscious JJ 40436 5165 59 of of IN 40436 5165 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5165 61 own own JJ 40436 5165 62 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 5165 63 , , , 40436 5165 64 believed believe VBD 40436 5165 65 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5165 66 to to TO 40436 5165 67 be be VB 40436 5165 68 already already RB 40436 5165 69 wise wise JJ 40436 5165 70 , , , 40436 5165 71 and and CC 40436 5165 72 delivered deliver VBD 40436 5165 73 confident confident JJ 40436 5165 74 opinions opinion NNS 40436 5165 75 without without IN 40436 5165 76 ever ever RB 40436 5165 77 having have VBG 40436 5165 78 analysed analyse VBN 40436 5165 79 the the DT 40436 5165 80 matters matter NNS 40436 5165 81 on on IN 40436 5165 82 which which WDT 40436 5165 83 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5165 84 spoke speak VBD 40436 5165 85 . . . 40436 5166 1 The the DT 40436 5166 2 conversation conversation NN 40436 5166 3 of of IN 40436 5166 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5166 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5166 6 as as IN 40436 5166 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5166 8 have have VBP 40436 5166 9 before before RB 40436 5166 10 remarked remark VBN 40436 5166 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5166 12 was be VBD 40436 5166 13 intended intend VBN 40436 5166 14 , , , 40436 5166 15 not not RB 40436 5166 16 to to TO 40436 5166 17 teach teach VB 40436 5166 18 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5166 19 , , , 40436 5166 20 but but CC 40436 5166 21 to to TO 40436 5166 22 raise raise VB 40436 5166 23 men man NNS 40436 5166 24 out out IN 40436 5166 25 of of IN 40436 5166 26 this this DT 40436 5166 27 false false JJ 40436 5166 28 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 5166 29 of of IN 40436 5166 30 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5166 31 , , , 40436 5166 32 which which WDT 40436 5166 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5166 34 believed believe VBD 40436 5166 35 to to TO 40436 5166 36 be be VB 40436 5166 37 the the DT 40436 5166 38 natural natural JJ 40436 5166 39 state state NN 40436 5166 40 of of IN 40436 5166 41 the the DT 40436 5166 42 human human JJ 40436 5166 43 mind mind NN 40436 5166 44 , , , 40436 5166 45 into into IN 40436 5166 46 that that DT 40436 5166 47 mental mental JJ 40436 5166 48 condition condition NN 40436 5166 49 which which WDT 40436 5166 50 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5166 51 called call VBD 40436 5166 52 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5166 53 . . . 40436 5167 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5167 2 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 5167 3 made make VBD 40436 5167 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5167 5 conscious conscious JJ 40436 5167 6 of of IN 40436 5167 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5167 8 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 5167 9 , , , 40436 5167 10 anxious anxious JJ 40436 5167 11 to to TO 40436 5167 12 escape escape VB 40436 5167 13 from from IN 40436 5167 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5167 15 , , , 40436 5167 16 and and CC 40436 5167 17 prepared prepare VBN 40436 5167 18 for for IN 40436 5167 19 mental mental JJ 40436 5167 20 efforts effort NNS 40436 5167 21 in in IN 40436 5167 22 search search NN 40436 5167 23 of of IN 40436 5167 24 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5167 25 : : : 40436 5167 26 in in IN 40436 5167 27 which which WDT 40436 5167 28 search search NN 40436 5167 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5167 30 assisted assist VBD 40436 5167 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5167 32 , , , 40436 5167 33 but but CC 40436 5167 34 without without IN 40436 5167 35 declaring declare VBG 40436 5167 36 , , , 40436 5167 37 and and CC 40436 5167 38 even even RB 40436 5167 39 professing profess VBG 40436 5167 40 inability inability NN 40436 5167 41 to to TO 40436 5167 42 declare declare VB 40436 5167 43 , , , 40436 5167 44 where where WRB 40436 5167 45 that that DT 40436 5167 46 truth truth NN 40436 5167 47 lay lie VBD 40436 5167 48 in in IN 40436 5167 49 which which WDT 40436 5167 50 the the DT 40436 5167 51 search search NN 40436 5167 52 was be VBD 40436 5167 53 to to TO 40436 5167 54 end end VB 40436 5167 55 . . . 40436 5168 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5168 2 considered consider VBD 40436 5168 3 that that IN 40436 5168 4 this this DT 40436 5168 5 change change NN 40436 5168 6 was be VBD 40436 5168 7 in in IN 40436 5168 8 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5168 9 a a DT 40436 5168 10 great great JJ 40436 5168 11 and and CC 40436 5168 12 serious serious JJ 40436 5168 13 improvement improvement NN 40436 5168 14 , , , 40436 5168 15 converting convert VBG 40436 5168 16 what what WP 40436 5168 17 was be VBD 40436 5168 18 evil evil JJ 40436 5168 19 , , , 40436 5168 20 radical radical JJ 40436 5168 21 , , , 40436 5168 22 and and CC 40436 5168 23 engrained engraine VBN 40436 5168 24 -- -- : 40436 5168 25 into into IN 40436 5168 26 evil evil JJ 40436 5168 27 superficial superficial JJ 40436 5168 28 and and CC 40436 5168 29 removable removable JJ 40436 5168 30 ; ; : 40436 5168 31 which which WDT 40436 5168 32 was be VBD 40436 5168 33 a a DT 40436 5168 34 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 5168 35 condition condition NN 40436 5168 36 to to IN 40436 5168 37 any any DT 40436 5168 38 positive positive JJ 40436 5168 39 acquirement acquirement NN 40436 5168 40 . . . 40436 5169 1 The the DT 40436 5169 2 first first JJ 40436 5169 3 thing thing NN 40436 5169 4 to to TO 40436 5169 5 be be VB 40436 5169 6 done do VBN 40436 5169 7 was be VBD 40436 5169 8 to to TO 40436 5169 9 create create VB 40436 5169 10 searchers searcher NNS 40436 5169 11 after after IN 40436 5169 12 truth truth NN 40436 5169 13 , , , 40436 5169 14 men man NNS 40436 5169 15 who who WP 40436 5169 16 would would MD 40436 5169 17 look look VB 40436 5169 18 at at IN 40436 5169 19 the the DT 40436 5169 20 subject subject NN 40436 5169 21 for for IN 40436 5169 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5169 23 with with IN 40436 5169 24 earnest earnest JJ 40436 5169 25 attention attention NN 40436 5169 26 , , , 40436 5169 27 and and CC 40436 5169 28 make make VB 40436 5169 29 up up RP 40436 5169 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5169 31 own own JJ 40436 5169 32 individual individual JJ 40436 5169 33 convictions conviction NNS 40436 5169 34 . . . 40436 5170 1 Even even RB 40436 5170 2 if if IN 40436 5170 3 nothing nothing NN 40436 5170 4 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 5170 5 were be VBD 40436 5170 6 achieved achieve VBN 40436 5170 7 , , , 40436 5170 8 that that IN 40436 5170 9 alone alone RB 40436 5170 10 would would MD 40436 5170 11 be be VB 40436 5170 12 a a DT 40436 5170 13 great great JJ 40436 5170 14 deal deal NN 40436 5170 15 . . . 40436 5171 1 Such such JJ 40436 5171 2 was be VBD 40436 5171 3 the the DT 40436 5171 4 scope scope NN 40436 5171 5 of of IN 40436 5171 6 the the DT 40436 5171 7 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 5171 8 conversation conversation NN 40436 5171 9 ; ; , 40436 5171 10 and and CC 40436 5171 11 such such PDT 40436 5171 12 the the DT 40436 5171 13 conception conception NN 40436 5171 14 of of IN 40436 5171 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5171 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5171 17 the the DT 40436 5171 18 capital capital NN 40436 5171 19 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 5171 20 which which WDT 40436 5171 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5171 22 borrowed borrow VBD 40436 5171 23 from from IN 40436 5171 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5171 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5171 26 , , , 40436 5171 27 which which WDT 40436 5171 28 is be VBZ 40436 5171 29 briefly briefly RB 40436 5171 30 noted note VBN 40436 5171 31 in in IN 40436 5171 32 this this DT 40436 5171 33 passage passage NN 40436 5171 34 of of IN 40436 5171 35 the the DT 40436 5171 36 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5171 37 , , , 40436 5171 38 and and CC 40436 5171 39 developed develop VBD 40436 5171 40 in in IN 40436 5171 41 other other JJ 40436 5171 42 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5171 43 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5171 44 , , , 40436 5171 45 especially especially RB 40436 5171 46 in in IN 40436 5171 47 the the DT 40436 5171 48 Symposion,[40 symposion,[40 NN 40436 5171 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5171 50 which which WDT 40436 5171 51 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5171 52 shall shall MD 40436 5171 53 reach reach VB 40436 5171 54 presently presently RB 40436 5171 55 . . . 40436 5172 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5172 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5172 3 40 40 CD 40436 5172 4 : : : 40436 5172 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5172 6 , , , 40436 5172 7 Sympos Sympos NNP 40436 5172 8 . . . 40436 5173 1 202 202 CD 40436 5173 2 - - HYPH 40436 5173 3 203 203 CD 40436 5173 4 - - HYPH 40436 5173 5 204 204 CD 40436 5173 6 . . . 40436 5174 1 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 5174 2 , , , 40436 5174 3 278 278 CD 40436 5174 4 D. D. NNP 40436 5174 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5174 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5174 7 Side side NN 40436 5174 8 - - HYPH 40436 5174 9 note note NN 40436 5174 10 : : : 40436 5174 11 Another another DT 40436 5174 12 theory theory NN 40436 5174 13 of of IN 40436 5174 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5174 15 . . . 40436 5175 1 The the DT 40436 5175 2 Primum Primum NNP 40436 5175 3 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 5175 4 , , , 40436 5175 5 or or CC 40436 5175 6 original original JJ 40436 5175 7 and and CC 40436 5175 8 primary primary JJ 40436 5175 9 object object NN 40436 5175 10 of of IN 40436 5175 11 Love Love NNP 40436 5175 12 . . . 40436 5176 1 Particular particular JJ 40436 5176 2 objects object NNS 40436 5176 3 are be VBP 40436 5176 4 loved love VBN 40436 5176 5 through through IN 40436 5176 6 association association NN 40436 5176 7 with with IN 40436 5176 8 this this DT 40436 5176 9 . . . 40436 5177 1 The the DT 40436 5177 2 object object NN 40436 5177 3 is be VBZ 40436 5177 4 , , , 40436 5177 5 Good Good NNP 40436 5177 6 . . . 40436 5177 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5178 1 Still still RB 40436 5178 2 , , , 40436 5178 3 however however RB 40436 5178 4 , , , 40436 5178 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5178 6 is be VBZ 40436 5178 7 not not RB 40436 5178 8 fully fully RB 40436 5178 9 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 5178 10 with with IN 40436 5178 11 this this DT 40436 5178 12 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 5178 13 , , , 40436 5178 14 but but CC 40436 5178 15 passes pass VBZ 40436 5178 16 on on RP 40436 5178 17 to to IN 40436 5178 18 another another DT 40436 5178 19 . . . 40436 5179 1 If if IN 40436 5179 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5179 3 love love VBP 40436 5179 4 anything anything NN 40436 5179 5 , , , 40436 5179 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5179 7 must must MD 40436 5179 8 love love VB 40436 5179 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5179 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5179 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5179 12 says say VBZ 40436 5179 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5179 14 for for IN 40436 5179 15 the the DT 40436 5179 16 sake sake NN 40436 5179 17 of of IN 40436 5179 18 something something NN 40436 5179 19 . . . 40436 5180 1 This this DT 40436 5180 2 implies imply VBZ 40436 5180 3 that that IN 40436 5180 4 there there EX 40436 5180 5 must must MD 40436 5180 6 exist exist VB 40436 5180 7 , , , 40436 5180 8 in in IN 40436 5180 9 the the DT 40436 5180 10 background background NN 40436 5180 11 , , , 40436 5180 12 a a DT 40436 5180 13 something something NN 40436 5180 14 which which WDT 40436 5180 15 is be VBZ 40436 5180 16 the the DT 40436 5180 17 primitive primitive JJ 40436 5180 18 and and CC 40436 5180 19 real real JJ 40436 5180 20 object object NN 40436 5180 21 of of IN 40436 5180 22 affection affection NN 40436 5180 23 . . . 40436 5181 1 The the DT 40436 5181 2 various various JJ 40436 5181 3 things thing NNS 40436 5181 4 which which WDT 40436 5181 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5181 6 actually actually RB 40436 5181 7 love love VBP 40436 5181 8 , , , 40436 5181 9 are be VBP 40436 5181 10 not not RB 40436 5181 11 loved love VBN 40436 5181 12 for for IN 40436 5181 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5181 14 own own JJ 40436 5181 15 sake sake NN 40436 5181 16 , , , 40436 5181 17 but but CC 40436 5181 18 for for IN 40436 5181 19 the the DT 40436 5181 20 sake sake NN 40436 5181 21 of of IN 40436 5181 22 this this DT 40436 5181 23 _ _ NNP 40436 5181 24 primum primum NN 40436 5181 25 amabile amabile NN 40436 5181 26 _ _ NNP 40436 5181 27 , , , 40436 5181 28 and and CC 40436 5181 29 as as IN 40436 5181 30 shadows shadow NNS 40436 5181 31 projected project VBN 40436 5181 32 by by IN 40436 5181 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5181 34 : : : 40436 5181 35 just just RB 40436 5181 36 as as IN 40436 5181 37 a a DT 40436 5181 38 man man NN 40436 5181 39 who who WP 40436 5181 40 loves love VBZ 40436 5181 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5181 42 son son NN 40436 5181 43 , , , 40436 5181 44 comes come VBZ 40436 5181 45 to to IN 40436 5181 46 love love NN 40436 5181 47 by by IN 40436 5181 48 association association NN 40436 5181 49 what what WP 40436 5181 50 is be VBZ 40436 5181 51 salutary salutary JJ 40436 5181 52 or or CC 40436 5181 53 comforting comforting JJ 40436 5181 54 to to IN 40436 5181 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5181 56 son son NN 40436 5181 57 -- -- : 40436 5181 58 or or CC 40436 5181 59 as as IN 40436 5181 60 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5181 61 loves love VBZ 40436 5181 62 money money NN 40436 5181 63 for for IN 40436 5181 64 the the DT 40436 5181 65 sake sake NN 40436 5181 66 of of IN 40436 5181 67 what what WP 40436 5181 68 money money NN 40436 5181 69 will will MD 40436 5181 70 purchase purchase VB 40436 5181 71 . . . 40436 5182 1 The the DT 40436 5182 2 _ _ NNP 40436 5182 3 primum primum NN 40436 5182 4 amabile amabile NN 40436 5182 5 _ _ NNP 40436 5182 6 , , , 40436 5182 7 in in IN 40436 5182 8 the the DT 40436 5182 9 view view NN 40436 5182 10 of of IN 40436 5182 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5182 12 , , , 40436 5182 13 is be VBZ 40436 5182 14 _ _ NNP 40436 5182 15 Good Good NNP 40436 5182 16 _ _ NNP 40436 5182 17 ; ; : 40436 5182 18 particular particular JJ 40436 5182 19 things thing NNS 40436 5182 20 loved love VBD 40436 5182 21 , , , 40436 5182 22 are be VBP 40436 5182 23 loved love VBN 40436 5182 24 as as IN 40436 5182 25 shadows shadow NNS 40436 5182 26 of of IN 40436 5182 27 good good NN 40436 5182 28 . . . 40436 5183 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5183 2 Side side NN 40436 5183 3 - - HYPH 40436 5183 4 note note NN 40436 5183 5 : : : 40436 5183 6 Statement statement NN 40436 5183 7 by by IN 40436 5183 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5183 9 of of IN 40436 5183 10 the the DT 40436 5183 11 general general JJ 40436 5183 12 law law NN 40436 5183 13 of of IN 40436 5183 14 mental mental NNP 40436 5183 15 association association NNP 40436 5183 16 . . . 40436 5183 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5184 1 This this DT 40436 5184 2 is be VBZ 40436 5184 3 a a DT 40436 5184 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5184 5 which which WDT 40436 5184 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5184 7 shall shall MD 40436 5184 8 find find VB 40436 5184 9 reproduced reproduce VBN 40436 5184 10 in in IN 40436 5184 11 other other JJ 40436 5184 12 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5184 13 . . . 40436 5185 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5185 2 note note VBP 40436 5185 3 with with IN 40436 5185 4 interest interest NN 40436 5185 5 here here RB 40436 5185 6 , , , 40436 5185 7 that that IN 40436 5185 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5185 9 appears appear VBZ 40436 5185 10 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 5185 11 , , , 40436 5185 12 by by IN 40436 5185 13 a a DT 40436 5185 14 statement statement NN 40436 5185 15 of of IN 40436 5185 16 the the DT 40436 5185 17 general general JJ 40436 5185 18 law law NN 40436 5185 19 of of IN 40436 5185 20 mental mental NNP 40436 5185 21 association association NN 40436 5185 22 -- -- : 40436 5185 23 the the DT 40436 5185 24 calling calling NN 40436 5185 25 up up RP 40436 5185 26 of of IN 40436 5185 27 one one CD 40436 5185 28 idea idea NN 40436 5185 29 by by IN 40436 5185 30 other other JJ 40436 5185 31 ideas idea NNS 40436 5185 32 or or CC 40436 5185 33 by by IN 40436 5185 34 sensations sensation NNS 40436 5185 35 , , , 40436 5185 36 and and CC 40436 5185 37 the the DT 40436 5185 38 transference transference NN 40436 5185 39 of of IN 40436 5185 40 affections affection NNS 40436 5185 41 from from IN 40436 5185 42 one one CD 40436 5185 43 object object NN 40436 5185 44 to to IN 40436 5185 45 others other NNS 40436 5185 46 which which WDT 40436 5185 47 have have VBP 40436 5185 48 been be VBN 40436 5185 49 apprehended apprehend VBN 40436 5185 50 in in IN 40436 5185 51 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 5185 52 with with IN 40436 5185 53 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5185 54 , , , 40436 5185 55 either either CC 40436 5185 56 as as IN 40436 5185 57 antecedents antecedent NNS 40436 5185 58 or or CC 40436 5185 59 consequents consequent NNS 40436 5185 60 . . . 40436 5186 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5186 2 states state VBZ 40436 5186 3 this this DT 40436 5186 4 law law NN 40436 5186 5 clearly clearly RB 40436 5186 6 in in IN 40436 5186 7 the the DT 40436 5186 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 5186 9 and and CC 40436 5186 10 elsewhere:[41 elsewhere:[41 ADD 40436 5186 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5186 12 but but CC 40436 5186 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5186 14 here here RB 40436 5186 15 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 5186 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5186 17 imperfectly imperfectly RB 40436 5186 18 : : : 40436 5186 19 for for IN 40436 5186 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5186 21 seems seem VBZ 40436 5186 22 to to TO 40436 5186 23 believe believe VB 40436 5186 24 that that IN 40436 5186 25 , , , 40436 5186 26 if if IN 40436 5186 27 an an DT 40436 5186 28 affection affection NN 40436 5186 29 be be VB 40436 5186 30 transferred transfer VBN 40436 5186 31 by by IN 40436 5186 32 association association NN 40436 5186 33 from from IN 40436 5186 34 a a DT 40436 5186 35 primitive primitive JJ 40436 5186 36 object object NN 40436 5186 37 A a NN 40436 5186 38 , , , 40436 5186 39 to to IN 40436 5186 40 other other JJ 40436 5186 41 objects object NNS 40436 5186 42 , , , 40436 5186 43 B B NNP 40436 5186 44 , , , 40436 5186 45 C C NNP 40436 5186 46 , , , 40436 5186 47 D D NNP 40436 5186 48 , , , 40436 5186 49 & & CC 40436 5186 50 c. c. NNP 40436 5186 51 , , , 40436 5186 52 A A NNP 40436 5186 53 always always RB 40436 5186 54 continues continue VBZ 40436 5186 55 to to TO 40436 5186 56 be be VB 40436 5186 57 the the DT 40436 5186 58 only only JJ 40436 5186 59 real real JJ 40436 5186 60 object object NN 40436 5186 61 of of IN 40436 5186 62 affection affection NN 40436 5186 63 , , , 40436 5186 64 while while IN 40436 5186 65 B B NNP 40436 5186 66 , , , 40436 5186 67 C C NNP 40436 5186 68 , , , 40436 5186 69 D D NNP 40436 5186 70 , , , 40436 5186 71 & & CC 40436 5186 72 c. c. NNP 40436 5186 73 , , , 40436 5186 74 operate operate VBP 40436 5186 75 upon upon IN 40436 5186 76 the the DT 40436 5186 77 mind mind NN 40436 5186 78 merely merely RB 40436 5186 79 by by IN 40436 5186 80 carrying carry VBG 40436 5186 81 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5186 82 back back RB 40436 5186 83 to to IN 40436 5186 84 A. a. NN 40436 5187 1 The the DT 40436 5187 2 affection affection NN 40436 5187 3 towards towards IN 40436 5187 4 B b NN 40436 5187 5 , , , 40436 5187 6 C C NNP 40436 5187 7 , , , 40436 5187 8 D D NNP 40436 5187 9 , , , 40436 5187 10 & & CC 40436 5187 11 c. c. NNP 40436 5187 12 , , , 40436 5187 13 therefore therefore RB 40436 5187 14 is be VBZ 40436 5187 15 , , , 40436 5187 16 in in IN 40436 5187 17 the the DT 40436 5187 18 view view NN 40436 5187 19 of of IN 40436 5187 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5187 21 , , , 40436 5187 22 only only RB 40436 5187 23 the the DT 40436 5187 24 affection affection NN 40436 5187 25 for for IN 40436 5187 26 A a DT 40436 5187 27 under under IN 40436 5187 28 other other JJ 40436 5187 29 denominations denomination NNS 40436 5187 30 and and CC 40436 5187 31 disguises disguise NNS 40436 5187 32 . . . 40436 5188 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5188 2 42 42 CD 40436 5188 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5188 4 Now now RB 40436 5188 5 this this DT 40436 5188 6 is be VBZ 40436 5188 7 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 5188 8 often often RB 40436 5188 9 the the DT 40436 5188 10 case case NN 40436 5188 11 ; ; : 40436 5188 12 but but CC 40436 5188 13 often often RB 40436 5188 14 also also RB 40436 5188 15 , , , 40436 5188 16 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 5188 17 even even RB 40436 5188 18 more more RBR 40436 5188 19 generally generally RB 40436 5188 20 , , , 40436 5188 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5188 22 is be VBZ 40436 5188 23 not not RB 40436 5188 24 the the DT 40436 5188 25 case case NN 40436 5188 26 . . . 40436 5189 1 After after IN 40436 5189 2 a a DT 40436 5189 3 certain certain JJ 40436 5189 4 length length NN 40436 5189 5 of of IN 40436 5189 6 repetition repetition NN 40436 5189 7 and and CC 40436 5189 8 habit habit NN 40436 5189 9 , , , 40436 5189 10 all all DT 40436 5189 11 conscious conscious JJ 40436 5189 12 reference reference NN 40436 5189 13 to to IN 40436 5189 14 the the DT 40436 5189 15 primitive primitive JJ 40436 5189 16 object object NN 40436 5189 17 of of IN 40436 5189 18 affection affection NN 40436 5189 19 will will MD 40436 5189 20 commonly commonly RB 40436 5189 21 be be VB 40436 5189 22 left leave VBN 40436 5189 23 out out RP 40436 5189 24 , , , 40436 5189 25 and and CC 40436 5189 26 the the DT 40436 5189 27 affection affection NN 40436 5189 28 towards towards IN 40436 5189 29 the the DT 40436 5189 30 secondary secondary JJ 40436 5189 31 object object NN 40436 5189 32 will will MD 40436 5189 33 become become VB 40436 5189 34 a a DT 40436 5189 35 feeling feeling NN 40436 5189 36 both both DT 40436 5189 37 substantive substantive JJ 40436 5189 38 and and CC 40436 5189 39 immediate immediate JJ 40436 5189 40 . . . 40436 5190 1 What what WP 40436 5190 2 was be VBD 40436 5190 3 originally originally RB 40436 5190 4 loved love VBN 40436 5190 5 as as IN 40436 5190 6 means mean NNS 40436 5190 7 , , , 40436 5190 8 for for IN 40436 5190 9 the the DT 40436 5190 10 sake sake NN 40436 5190 11 of of IN 40436 5190 12 an an DT 40436 5190 13 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 5190 14 end end NN 40436 5190 15 , , , 40436 5190 16 will will MD 40436 5190 17 in in IN 40436 5190 18 time time NN 40436 5190 19 come come VB 40436 5190 20 to to TO 40436 5190 21 be be VB 40436 5190 22 loved love VBN 40436 5190 23 as as IN 40436 5190 24 an an DT 40436 5190 25 end end NN 40436 5190 26 for for IN 40436 5190 27 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5190 28 ; ; : 40436 5190 29 and and CC 40436 5190 30 to to TO 40436 5190 31 constitute constitute VB 40436 5190 32 a a DT 40436 5190 33 new new JJ 40436 5190 34 centre centre NN 40436 5190 35 of of IN 40436 5190 36 force force NN 40436 5190 37 , , , 40436 5190 38 from from IN 40436 5190 39 whence whence NN 40436 5190 40 derivatives derivative NNS 40436 5190 41 may may MD 40436 5190 42 branch branch VB 40436 5190 43 out out RP 40436 5190 44 . . . 40436 5191 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5191 2 may may MD 40436 5191 3 even even RB 40436 5191 4 come come VB 40436 5191 5 to to TO 40436 5191 6 be be VB 40436 5191 7 loved love VBN 40436 5191 8 more more RBR 40436 5191 9 vehemently vehemently RB 40436 5191 10 than than IN 40436 5191 11 any any DT 40436 5191 12 primitive primitive JJ 40436 5191 13 object object NN 40436 5191 14 of of IN 40436 5191 15 affection affection NN 40436 5191 16 , , , 40436 5191 17 if if IN 40436 5191 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5191 19 chance chance VBP 40436 5191 20 to to TO 40436 5191 21 accumulate accumulate VB 40436 5191 22 in in IN 40436 5191 23 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5191 24 derivative derivative JJ 40436 5191 25 influences influence NNS 40436 5191 26 from from IN 40436 5191 27 many many JJ 40436 5191 28 of of IN 40436 5191 29 those those DT 40436 5191 30 objects object NNS 40436 5191 31 . . . 40436 5192 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5192 2 43 43 CD 40436 5192 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5192 4 This this DT 40436 5192 5 remark remark NN 40436 5192 6 naturally naturally RB 40436 5192 7 presents present VBZ 40436 5192 8 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5192 9 , , , 40436 5192 10 when when WRB 40436 5192 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5192 12 meet meet VBP 40436 5192 13 here here RB 40436 5192 14 for for IN 40436 5192 15 the the DT 40436 5192 16 first first JJ 40436 5192 17 time time NN 40436 5192 18 , , , 40436 5192 19 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 5192 20 stated state VBN 40436 5192 21 by by IN 40436 5192 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5192 23 , , , 40436 5192 24 the the DT 40436 5192 25 important important JJ 40436 5192 26 psychological psychological JJ 40436 5192 27 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5192 28 of of IN 40436 5192 29 the the DT 40436 5192 30 transference transference NN 40436 5192 31 of of IN 40436 5192 32 affections affection NNS 40436 5192 33 by by IN 40436 5192 34 association association NN 40436 5192 35 from from IN 40436 5192 36 one one CD 40436 5192 37 object object NN 40436 5192 38 to to IN 40436 5192 39 others other NNS 40436 5192 40 . . . 40436 5193 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5193 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5193 3 41 41 CD 40436 5193 4 : : : 40436 5193 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5193 6 , , , 40436 5193 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 5193 8 , , , 40436 5193 9 73 73 CD 40436 5193 10 - - SYM 40436 5193 11 74 74 CD 40436 5193 12 . . . 40436 5194 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5194 2 is be VBZ 40436 5194 3 declared declare VBN 40436 5194 4 differently differently RB 40436 5194 5 , , , 40436 5194 6 and and CC 40436 5194 7 more more RBR 40436 5194 8 clearly clearly RB 40436 5194 9 , , , 40436 5194 10 by by IN 40436 5194 11 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5194 12 in in IN 40436 5194 13 the the DT 40436 5194 14 treatise treatise NN 40436 5194 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5194 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5194 17 : : : 40436 5194 18 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 5194 19 Mnê Mnê NNP 40436 5194 20 / / SYM 40436 5194 21 mês mês NNP 40436 5194 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5194 23 A)namnê A)namnê NNP 40436 5194 24 / / SYM 40436 5194 25 seôs seôs NNP 40436 5194 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5194 27 , , , 40436 5194 28 pp pp NNP 40436 5194 29 . . . 40436 5195 1 451 451 CD 40436 5195 2 - - SYM 40436 5195 3 452 452 CD 40436 5195 4 . . . 40436 5195 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5196 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5196 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5196 3 42 42 CD 40436 5196 4 : : : 40436 5196 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5196 6 , , , 40436 5196 7 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5196 8 , , , 40436 5196 9 220 220 CD 40436 5196 10 B. b. NN 40436 5197 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5197 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5197 3 : : : 40436 5197 4 o(/sa o(/sa NNP 40436 5197 5 ga ga NNP 40436 5197 6 / / SYM 40436 5197 7 r r NNP 40436 5197 8 phamen phaman NNS 40436 5197 9 phi phi NNP 40436 5197 10 / / SYM 40436 5197 11 la la NNP 40436 5197 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 5197 13 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 5197 14 = = SYM 40436 5197 15 n n CC 40436 5197 16 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 5197 17 phi phi NNP 40436 5197 18 / / SYM 40436 5197 19 lou lou NNP 40436 5197 20 tino tino NNP 40436 5197 21 / / SYM 40436 5197 22 s s NNPS 40436 5197 23 , , , 40436 5197 24 e(te e(te NNP 40436 5197 25 / / SYM 40436 5197 26 rô| rô| NNP 40436 5197 27 r(ê r(ê NNP 40436 5197 28 / / SYM 40436 5197 29 mati mati NNPS 40436 5197 30 phaino phaino NNP 40436 5197 31 / / SYM 40436 5197 32 metha metha NNP 40436 5197 33 le le NNP 40436 5197 34 / / SYM 40436 5197 35 gontes gontes NNPS 40436 5197 36 au)to/ au)to/ NNP 40436 5197 37 ; ; : 40436 5197 38 phi phi NNP 40436 5197 39 / / SYM 40436 5197 40 lon lon NNP 40436 5197 41 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5197 42 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 5197 43 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 5197 44 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 5197 45 / / SYM 40436 5197 46 ei ei UH 40436 5197 47 e)kei e)kei NNPS 40436 5197 48 = = NFP 40436 5197 49 no no UH 40436 5197 50 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 5197 51 ei)=nai ei)=nai NFP 40436 5197 52 , , , 40436 5197 53 ei)s ei)s '' 40436 5197 54 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 5197 55 pa pa NNP 40436 5197 56 = = SYM 40436 5197 57 sai sai NNP 40436 5197 58 au(=tai au(=tai NNP 40436 5197 59 ai ai NNP 40436 5197 60 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5197 61 lego lego NNP 40436 5197 62 / / SYM 40436 5197 63 menai menai NNP 40436 5197 64 phili phili NNP 40436 5197 65 / / SYM 40436 5197 66 ai ai NNP 40436 5197 67 teleutô teleutô NNP 40436 5197 68 = = SYM 40436 5197 69 sin sin NN 40436 5197 70 . . . 40436 5197 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5197 72 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5198 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5198 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5198 3 43 43 CD 40436 5198 4 : : : 40436 5198 5 There there EX 40436 5198 6 is be VBZ 40436 5198 7 no no DT 40436 5198 8 stronger strong JJR 40436 5198 9 illustration illustration NN 40436 5198 10 of of IN 40436 5198 11 this this DT 40436 5198 12 than than IN 40436 5198 13 the the DT 40436 5198 14 love love NN 40436 5198 15 of of IN 40436 5198 16 money money NN 40436 5198 17 , , , 40436 5198 18 which which WDT 40436 5198 19 is be VBZ 40436 5198 20 the the DT 40436 5198 21 very very JJ 40436 5198 22 example example NN 40436 5198 23 that that IN 40436 5198 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5198 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5198 26 here here RB 40436 5198 27 cites cite VBZ 40436 5198 28 . . . 40436 5199 1 The the DT 40436 5199 2 important important JJ 40436 5199 3 point point NN 40436 5199 4 to to TO 40436 5199 5 which which WDT 40436 5199 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5199 7 here here RB 40436 5199 8 call call VBP 40436 5199 9 attention attention NN 40436 5199 10 , , , 40436 5199 11 in in IN 40436 5199 12 respect respect NN 40436 5199 13 to to IN 40436 5199 14 the the DT 40436 5199 15 law law NN 40436 5199 16 of of IN 40436 5199 17 Mental Mental NNP 40436 5199 18 Association Association NNP 40436 5199 19 , , , 40436 5199 20 is be VBZ 40436 5199 21 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 5199 22 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 5199 23 by by IN 40436 5199 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5199 25 James James NNP 40436 5199 26 Mill Mill NNP 40436 5199 27 in in IN 40436 5199 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5199 29 ' ' `` 40436 5199 30 Analysis Analysis NNP 40436 5199 31 of of IN 40436 5199 32 the the DT 40436 5199 33 Human Human NNP 40436 5199 34 Mind Mind NNP 40436 5199 35 , , , 40436 5199 36 ' ' '' 40436 5199 37 chapters chapter NNS 40436 5199 38 xxi xxi NNP 40436 5199 39 . . . 40436 5200 1 and and CC 40436 5200 2 xxii xxii NNP 40436 5200 3 . . . 40436 5200 4 , , , 40436 5200 5 and and CC 40436 5200 6 by by IN 40436 5200 7 Professor Professor NNP 40436 5200 8 Bain Bain NNP 40436 5200 9 in in IN 40436 5200 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5200 11 works work NNS 40436 5200 12 on on IN 40436 5200 13 the the DT 40436 5200 14 Senses sense NNS 40436 5200 15 and and CC 40436 5200 16 the the DT 40436 5200 17 Intellect,--Intellect intellect,--intellect NN 40436 5200 18 , , , 40436 5200 19 chap chap NNP 40436 5200 20 . . . 40436 5201 1 i. i. NNP 40436 5201 2 sect sect NNP 40436 5201 3 . . . 40436 5202 1 47 47 CD 40436 5202 2 - - SYM 40436 5202 3 48 48 CD 40436 5202 4 , , , 40436 5202 5 p. p. NN 40436 5202 6 404 404 CD 40436 5202 7 seq seq NN 40436 5202 8 . . . 40436 5203 1 ed ed NNP 40436 5203 2 . . . 40436 5204 1 3 3 LS 40436 5204 2 ; ; : 40436 5204 3 and and CC 40436 5204 4 on on IN 40436 5204 5 the the DT 40436 5204 6 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 5204 7 and and CC 40436 5204 8 the the DT 40436 5204 9 Will Will NNP 40436 5204 10 , , , 40436 5204 11 chap chap NNP 40436 5204 12 . . . 40436 5205 1 iv iv XX 40436 5205 2 . . . 40436 5206 1 sect sect NNP 40436 5206 2 . . . 40436 5207 1 4 4 LS 40436 5207 2 - - SYM 40436 5207 3 5 5 CD 40436 5207 4 , , , 40436 5207 5 p. p. NN 40436 5207 6 428 428 CD 40436 5207 7 seq seq NN 40436 5207 8 . . . 40436 5208 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5208 2 3rd 3rd NNP 40436 5208 3 ed ed NNP 40436 5208 4 . . . 40436 5209 1 p. p. NN 40436 5209 2 363 363 CD 40436 5209 3 seq seq NN 40436 5209 4 . . . 40436 5209 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5209 6 . . . 40436 5209 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5210 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5210 2 Side side NN 40436 5210 3 - - HYPH 40436 5210 4 note note NN 40436 5210 5 : : : 40436 5210 6 Theory theory NN 40436 5210 7 of of IN 40436 5210 8 the the DT 40436 5210 9 Primum Primum NNP 40436 5210 10 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 5210 11 , , , 40436 5210 12 here here RB 40436 5210 13 introduced introduce VBN 40436 5210 14 by by IN 40436 5210 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5210 16 , , , 40436 5210 17 with with IN 40436 5210 18 numerous numerous JJ 40436 5210 19 derivative derivative JJ 40436 5210 20 objects object NNS 40436 5210 21 of of IN 40436 5210 22 love love NN 40436 5210 23 . . . 40436 5211 1 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5211 2 Idea Idea NNP 40436 5211 3 . . . 40436 5212 1 Generic generic JJ 40436 5212 2 communion communion NN 40436 5212 3 of of IN 40436 5212 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5212 5 , , , 40436 5212 6 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 5212 7 by by IN 40436 5212 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5212 9 from from IN 40436 5212 10 the the DT 40436 5212 11 feebler feebler NN 40436 5212 12 analogical analogical JJ 40436 5212 13 communion communion NN 40436 5212 14 . . . 40436 5212 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5213 1 The the DT 40436 5213 2 _ _ NNP 40436 5213 3 primum primum NN 40436 5213 4 amabile amabile NN 40436 5213 5 _ _ NNP 40436 5213 6 , , , 40436 5213 7 here here RB 40436 5213 8 introduced introduce VBN 40436 5213 9 by by IN 40436 5213 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5213 11 , , , 40436 5213 12 is be VBZ 40436 5213 13 described describe VBN 40436 5213 14 in in IN 40436 5213 15 restricted restricted JJ 40436 5213 16 terms term NNS 40436 5213 17 , , , 40436 5213 18 as as IN 40436 5213 19 valuable valuable JJ 40436 5213 20 merely merely RB 40436 5213 21 to to TO 40436 5213 22 correct correct VB 40436 5213 23 evil evil NN 40436 5213 24 , , , 40436 5213 25 and and CC 40436 5213 26 as as IN 40436 5213 27 having have VBG 40436 5213 28 no no DT 40436 5213 29 value value NN 40436 5213 30 _ _ NNP 40436 5213 31 per per FW 40436 5213 32 se se FW 40436 5213 33 _ _ NNP 40436 5213 34 , , , 40436 5213 35 if if IN 40436 5213 36 evil evil NN 40436 5213 37 were be VBD 40436 5213 38 assumed assume VBN 40436 5213 39 not not RB 40436 5213 40 to to TO 40436 5213 41 exist exist VB 40436 5213 42 . . . 40436 5214 1 In in IN 40436 5214 2 consequence consequence NN 40436 5214 3 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 5214 4 of of IN 40436 5214 5 this this DT 40436 5214 6 restriction restriction NN 40436 5214 7 , , , 40436 5214 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5214 9 discards discard VBZ 40436 5214 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5214 11 as as IN 40436 5214 12 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 5214 13 . . . 40436 5215 1 Such such JJ 40436 5215 2 restriction restriction NN 40436 5215 3 , , , 40436 5215 4 however however RB 40436 5215 5 , , , 40436 5215 6 is be VBZ 40436 5215 7 noway noway RB 40436 5215 8 essential essential JJ 40436 5215 9 to to IN 40436 5215 10 the the DT 40436 5215 11 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5215 12 : : : 40436 5215 13 which which WDT 40436 5215 14 approaches approach VBZ 40436 5215 15 to to IN 40436 5215 16 , , , 40436 5215 17 but but CC 40436 5215 18 is be VBZ 40436 5215 19 not not RB 40436 5215 20 coincident coincident JJ 40436 5215 21 with with IN 40436 5215 22 , , , 40436 5215 23 the the DT 40436 5215 24 Ideal Ideal NNP 40436 5215 25 Good Good NNP 40436 5215 26 or or CC 40436 5215 27 Idea Idea NNP 40436 5215 28 of of IN 40436 5215 29 Good good JJ 40436 5215 30 , , , 40436 5215 31 described describe VBN 40436 5215 32 in in IN 40436 5215 33 other other JJ 40436 5215 34 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5215 35 as as IN 40436 5215 36 what what WP 40436 5215 37 every every DT 40436 5215 38 one one NN 40436 5215 39 yearns yearn VBZ 40436 5215 40 after after RB 40436 5215 41 and and CC 40436 5215 42 aspires aspire VBZ 40436 5215 43 to to TO 40436 5215 44 , , , 40436 5215 45 though though IN 40436 5215 46 without without IN 40436 5215 47 ever ever RB 40436 5215 48 attaining attain VBG 40436 5215 49 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5215 50 and and CC 40436 5215 51 without without IN 40436 5215 52 even even RB 40436 5215 53 knowing know VBG 40436 5215 54 what what WP 40436 5215 55 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5215 56 is be VBZ 40436 5215 57 . . . 40436 5216 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5216 2 44 44 CD 40436 5216 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5216 4 The the DT 40436 5216 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5216 6 Idea Idea NNP 40436 5216 7 was be VBD 40436 5216 8 conceived conceive VBN 40436 5216 9 as as IN 40436 5216 10 a a DT 40436 5216 11 substantive substantive JJ 40436 5216 12 , , , 40436 5216 13 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 5216 14 , , , 40436 5216 15 Ens Ens NNP 40436 5216 16 , , , 40436 5216 17 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5216 18 in in IN 40436 5216 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5216 20 nature nature NN 40436 5216 21 from from IN 40436 5216 22 all all PDT 40436 5216 23 the the DT 40436 5216 24 particulars particular NNS 40436 5216 25 bearing bear VBG 40436 5216 26 the the DT 40436 5216 27 same same JJ 40436 5216 28 name name NN 40436 5216 29 , , , 40436 5216 30 and and CC 40436 5216 31 separated separate VBD 40436 5216 32 from from IN 40436 5216 33 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5216 34 all all DT 40436 5216 35 by by IN 40436 5216 36 a a DT 40436 5216 37 gulf gulf NN 40436 5216 38 which which WDT 40436 5216 39 admitted admit VBD 40436 5216 40 no no DT 40436 5216 41 gradations gradation NNS 40436 5216 42 of of IN 40436 5216 43 nearer nearer NN 40436 5216 44 and and CC 40436 5216 45 farther farther RB 40436 5216 46 -- -- : 40436 5216 47 yet yet CC 40436 5216 48 communicating communicate VBG 40436 5216 49 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5216 50 to to IN 40436 5216 51 , , , 40436 5216 52 or or CC 40436 5216 53 partaken partake VBN 40436 5216 54 by by RB 40436 5216 55 , , , 40436 5216 56 all all DT 40436 5216 57 of of IN 40436 5216 58 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5216 59 , , , 40436 5216 60 in in IN 40436 5216 61 some some DT 40436 5216 62 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 40436 5216 63 way way NN 40436 5216 64 . . . 40436 5217 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5217 2 combated combat VBD 40436 5217 3 this this DT 40436 5217 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5217 5 , , , 40436 5217 6 denying deny VBG 40436 5217 7 the the DT 40436 5217 8 separate separate JJ 40436 5217 9 reality reality NN 40436 5217 10 of of IN 40436 5217 11 the the DT 40436 5217 12 Idea Idea NNP 40436 5217 13 , , , 40436 5217 14 and and CC 40436 5217 15 admitting admit VBG 40436 5217 16 only only RB 40436 5217 17 a a DT 40436 5217 18 common common JJ 40436 5217 19 generic generic JJ 40436 5217 20 essence essence NN 40436 5217 21 , , , 40436 5217 22 dwelling dwell VBG 40436 5217 23 in in RB 40436 5217 24 and and CC 40436 5217 25 pervading pervade VBG 40436 5217 26 the the DT 40436 5217 27 particulars particular NNS 40436 5217 28 , , , 40436 5217 29 but but CC 40436 5217 30 pervading pervade VBG 40436 5217 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5217 32 all all DT 40436 5217 33 equally equally RB 40436 5217 34 . . . 40436 5218 1 The the DT 40436 5218 2 general general JJ 40436 5218 3 word word NN 40436 5218 4 connoting connote VBG 40436 5218 5 this this DT 40436 5218 6 generic generic JJ 40436 5218 7 unity unity NN 40436 5218 8 was be VBD 40436 5218 9 said say VBN 40436 5218 10 by by IN 40436 5218 11 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5218 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5218 13 retaining retain VBG 40436 5218 14 the the DT 40436 5218 15 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5218 16 phraseology phraseology NN 40436 5218 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5218 18 to to TO 40436 5218 19 be be VB 40436 5218 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5218 21 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5218 22 : : : 40436 5218 23 lego lego NNP 40436 5218 24 / / SYM 40436 5218 25 menon menon NNP 40436 5218 26 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 5218 27 mi mi NNP 40436 5218 28 / / SYM 40436 5218 29 an an DT 40436 5218 30 i)de i)de NNP 40436 5218 31 / / SYM 40436 5218 32 an an NN 40436 5218 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5218 34 or or CC 40436 5218 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5218 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5218 37 : : : 40436 5218 38 kath kath NN 40436 5218 39 ' ' '' 40436 5218 40 e(/n e(/n NN 40436 5218 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5218 42 . . . 40436 5219 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5219 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5219 3 44 44 CD 40436 5219 4 : : : 40436 5219 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5219 6 , , , 40436 5219 7 Republ Republ NNP 40436 5219 8 . . . 40436 5220 1 vi vi NNP 40436 5220 2 . . . 40436 5221 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5221 2 . . . 40436 5222 1 505 505 CD 40436 5222 2 - - SYM 40436 5222 3 506 506 CD 40436 5222 4 . . . 40436 5222 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5223 1 But but CC 40436 5223 2 apart apart RB 40436 5223 3 from from IN 40436 5223 4 and and CC 40436 5223 5 beyond beyond IN 40436 5223 6 such such JJ 40436 5223 7 generic generic JJ 40436 5223 8 unity unity NN 40436 5223 9 , , , 40436 5223 10 which which WDT 40436 5223 11 implied imply VBD 40436 5223 12 a a DT 40436 5223 13 common common JJ 40436 5223 14 essence essence NN 40436 5223 15 belonging belong VBG 40436 5223 16 to to IN 40436 5223 17 all all DT 40436 5223 18 , , , 40436 5223 19 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5223 20 recognised recognise VBD 40436 5223 21 a a DT 40436 5223 22 looser loose JJR 40436 5223 23 , , , 40436 5223 24 more more RBR 40436 5223 25 imperfect imperfect JJ 40436 5223 26 , , , 40436 5223 27 yet yet CC 40436 5223 28 more more RBR 40436 5223 29 extensive extensive JJ 40436 5223 30 , , , 40436 5223 31 communion communion NN 40436 5223 32 , , , 40436 5223 33 founded found VBN 40436 5223 34 upon upon IN 40436 5223 35 common common JJ 40436 5223 36 relationship relationship NN 40436 5223 37 towards towards IN 40436 5223 38 some some DT 40436 5223 39 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5223 40 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5223 41 : : : 40436 5223 42 A)rchê\]--First a)rchê\]--first ADD 40436 5223 43 Principle Principle NNP 40436 5223 44 or or CC 40436 5223 45 First First NNP 40436 5223 46 Object Object NNP 40436 5223 47 . . . 40436 5224 1 Such such JJ 40436 5224 2 relationship relationship NN 40436 5224 3 was be VBD 40436 5224 4 not not RB 40436 5224 5 always always RB 40436 5224 6 the the DT 40436 5224 7 same same JJ 40436 5224 8 in in IN 40436 5224 9 kind kind NN 40436 5224 10 : : : 40436 5224 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5224 12 might may MD 40436 5224 13 be be VB 40436 5224 14 either either DT 40436 5224 15 resemblance resemblance NN 40436 5224 16 , , , 40436 5224 17 concomitance concomitance NN 40436 5224 18 , , , 40436 5224 19 antecedence antecedence NN 40436 5224 20 or or CC 40436 5224 21 consequence consequence NN 40436 5224 22 , , , 40436 5224 23 & & CC 40436 5224 24 c. c. NNP 40436 5224 25 : : : 40436 5224 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5224 27 might may MD 40436 5224 28 also also RB 40436 5224 29 be be VB 40436 5224 30 different different JJ 40436 5224 31 in in IN 40436 5224 32 degree degree NN 40436 5224 33 , , , 40436 5224 34 closer close JJR 40436 5224 35 or or CC 40436 5224 36 more more RBR 40436 5224 37 remote remote JJ 40436 5224 38 , , , 40436 5224 39 direct direct JJ 40436 5224 40 or or CC 40436 5224 41 indirect indirect JJ 40436 5224 42 . . . 40436 5225 1 Here here RB 40436 5225 2 , , , 40436 5225 3 then then RB 40436 5225 4 , , , 40436 5225 5 there there EX 40436 5225 6 was be VBD 40436 5225 7 room room NN 40436 5225 8 for for IN 40436 5225 9 graduation graduation NN 40436 5225 10 , , , 40436 5225 11 or or CC 40436 5225 12 ordination ordination NN 40436 5225 13 of of IN 40436 5225 14 objects object NNS 40436 5225 15 as as IN 40436 5225 16 former former JJ 40436 5225 17 and and CC 40436 5225 18 latter latter JJ 40436 5225 19 , , , 40436 5225 20 first first JJ 40436 5225 21 , , , 40436 5225 22 second second JJ 40436 5225 23 , , , 40436 5225 24 third third JJ 40436 5225 25 , , , 40436 5225 26 & & CC 40436 5225 27 c. c. NNP 40436 5225 28 , , , 40436 5225 29 according accord VBG 40436 5225 30 as as IN 40436 5225 31 , , , 40436 5225 32 when when WRB 40436 5225 33 compared compare VBN 40436 5225 34 with with IN 40436 5225 35 each each DT 40436 5225 36 other other JJ 40436 5225 37 , , , 40436 5225 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5225 39 were be VBD 40436 5225 40 more more RBR 40436 5225 41 or or CC 40436 5225 42 less less RBR 40436 5225 43 related related JJ 40436 5225 44 to to IN 40436 5225 45 the the DT 40436 5225 46 common common JJ 40436 5225 47 root root NN 40436 5225 48 . . . 40436 5226 1 This this DT 40436 5226 2 imperfect imperfect JJ 40436 5226 3 communion communion NN 40436 5226 4 was be VBD 40436 5226 5 designated designate VBN 40436 5226 6 by by IN 40436 5226 7 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5226 8 under under IN 40436 5226 9 the the DT 40436 5226 10 title title NN 40436 5226 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5226 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5226 13 : : : 40436 5226 14 kat kat NNP 40436 5226 15 ' ' '' 40436 5226 16 a)nalogi a)nalogi NNS 40436 5226 17 / / SYM 40436 5226 18 an an DT 40436 5226 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5226 20 , , , 40436 5226 21 as as IN 40436 5226 22 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 5226 23 with with IN 40436 5226 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5226 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5226 26 : : : 40436 5226 27 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 5226 28 ge ge NNP 40436 5226 29 / / SYM 40436 5226 30 nos nos NNP 40436 5226 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5226 32 : : : 40436 5226 33 the the DT 40436 5226 34 predicate predicate NN 40436 5226 35 which which WDT 40436 5226 36 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 5226 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5226 38 was be VBD 40436 5226 39 said say VBN 40436 5226 40 to to TO 40436 5226 41 be be VB 40436 5226 42 applied apply VBN 40436 5226 43 , , , 40436 5226 44 not not RB 40436 5226 45 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5226 46 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5226 47 : : : 40436 5226 48 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 5226 49 mi mi NNP 40436 5226 50 / / SYM 40436 5226 51 an an DT 40436 5226 52 i)de i)de NNP 40436 5226 53 / / SYM 40436 5226 54 an an NN 40436 5226 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5226 56 or or CC 40436 5226 57 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5226 58 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5226 59 : : : 40436 5226 60 kath kath NN 40436 5226 61 ' ' '' 40436 5226 62 e(/n e(/n NN 40436 5226 63 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5226 64 , , , 40436 5226 65 but but CC 40436 5226 66 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5226 67 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5226 68 : : : 40436 5226 69 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5226 70 mi mi NNP 40436 5226 71 / / SYM 40436 5226 72 an an DT 40436 5226 73 phu phu NN 40436 5226 74 / / SYM 40436 5226 75 sin sin NN 40436 5226 76 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5226 77 or or CC 40436 5226 78 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5226 79 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5226 80 : : : 40436 5226 81 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5226 82 e(/n]:[45 e(/n]:[45 NN 40436 5226 83 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5226 84 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5226 85 was be VBD 40436 5226 86 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 5226 87 neither neither CC 40436 5226 88 entirely entirely RB 40436 5226 89 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5226 90 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5226 91 : : : 40436 5226 92 sunônu sunônu NNP 40436 5226 93 / / SYM 40436 5226 94 môs môs NNP 40436 5226 95 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5226 96 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5226 97 which which WDT 40436 5226 98 would would MD 40436 5226 99 imply imply VB 40436 5226 100 generic generic JJ 40436 5226 101 communion communion NN 40436 5226 102 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5226 103 , , , 40436 5226 104 nor nor CC 40436 5226 105 entirely entirely RB 40436 5226 106 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5226 107 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5226 108 : : : 40436 5226 109 o(mônu o(mônu . 40436 5226 110 / / SYM 40436 5226 111 môs môs NNP 40436 5226 112 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5226 113 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5226 114 which which WDT 40436 5226 115 would would MD 40436 5226 116 be be VB 40436 5226 117 casual casual JJ 40436 5226 118 and and CC 40436 5226 119 imply imply VB 40436 5226 120 no no DT 40436 5226 121 communion communion NN 40436 5226 122 at at RB 40436 5226 123 all all RB 40436 5226 124 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5226 125 , , , 40436 5226 126 but but CC 40436 5226 127 midway midway NN 40436 5226 128 between between IN 40436 5226 129 the the DT 40436 5226 130 two two CD 40436 5226 131 , , , 40436 5226 132 so so IN 40436 5226 133 as as IN 40436 5226 134 to to TO 40436 5226 135 admit admit VB 40436 5226 136 of of IN 40436 5226 137 a a DT 40436 5226 138 graduated graduate VBN 40436 5226 139 communion communion NN 40436 5226 140 , , , 40436 5226 141 and and CC 40436 5226 142 an an DT 40436 5226 143 arrangement arrangement NN 40436 5226 144 as as IN 40436 5226 145 former former JJ 40436 5226 146 and and CC 40436 5226 147 later later RB 40436 5226 148 , , , 40436 5226 149 first first JJ 40436 5226 150 cousin cousin NN 40436 5226 151 , , , 40436 5226 152 or or CC 40436 5226 153 second second JJ 40436 5226 154 , , , 40436 5226 155 third third JJ 40436 5226 156 cousin cousin NN 40436 5226 157 . . . 40436 5227 1 Members member NNS 40436 5227 2 of of IN 40436 5227 3 the the DT 40436 5227 4 same same JJ 40436 5227 5 Genus Genus NNP 40436 5227 6 were be VBD 40436 5227 7 considered consider VBN 40436 5227 8 to to TO 40436 5227 9 be be VB 40436 5227 10 brothers brother NNS 40436 5227 11 , , , 40436 5227 12 all all RB 40436 5227 13 on on IN 40436 5227 14 a a DT 40436 5227 15 par par NN 40436 5227 16 : : : 40436 5227 17 but but CC 40436 5227 18 wherever wherever WRB 40436 5227 19 there there EX 40436 5227 20 was be VBD 40436 5227 21 this this DT 40436 5227 22 graduated graduate VBN 40436 5227 23 cousinship cousinship NN 40436 5227 24 or or CC 40436 5227 25 communion communion NN 40436 5227 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5227 27 signified signify VBN 40436 5227 28 by by IN 40436 5227 29 the the DT 40436 5227 30 words word NNS 40436 5227 31 Former Former NNP 40436 5227 32 and and CC 40436 5227 33 Later later RBR 40436 5227 34 , , , 40436 5227 35 more more RBR 40436 5227 36 or or CC 40436 5227 37 less less RBR 40436 5227 38 in in IN 40436 5227 39 degree degree NN 40436 5227 40 of of IN 40436 5227 41 relationship relationship NN 40436 5227 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5227 43 , , , 40436 5227 44 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5227 45 did do VBD 40436 5227 46 not not RB 40436 5227 47 admit admit VB 40436 5227 48 a a DT 40436 5227 49 common common JJ 40436 5227 50 Genus Genus NNP 40436 5227 51 , , , 40436 5227 52 nor nor CC 40436 5227 53 did do VBD 40436 5227 54 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5227 55 admit admit VB 40436 5227 56 a a DT 40436 5227 57 Substantive substantive JJ 40436 5227 58 Idea Idea NNP 40436 5227 59 . . . 40436 5228 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5228 2 46 46 CD 40436 5228 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5228 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5228 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5228 6 45 45 CD 40436 5228 7 : : : 40436 5228 8 Arist arist JJ 40436 5228 9 . . . 40436 5229 1 Metaphys metaphys RB 40436 5229 2 . . . 40436 5230 1 A. A. NNP 40436 5231 1 1072 1072 CD 40436 5231 2 , , , 40436 5231 3 a. a. NN 40436 5232 1 26 26 CD 40436 5232 2 - - SYM 40436 5232 3 29 29 CD 40436 5232 4 ; ; : 40436 5232 5 Bonitz Bonitz NNP 40436 5232 6 , , , 40436 5232 7 Comm Comm NNP 40436 5232 8 . . . 40436 5233 1 p. p. NN 40436 5233 2 497 497 CD 40436 5233 3 i -PRON- PRP 40436 5233 4 d d VBN 40436 5233 5 . . . 40436 5234 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5234 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5234 3 : : : 40436 5234 4 Prô Prô NNP 40436 5234 5 = = SYM 40436 5234 6 ton ton NN 40436 5234 7 o)rekto o)rekto CD 40436 5234 8 / / SYM 40436 5234 9 n n NN 40436 5234 10 -- -- : 40436 5234 11 Prô Prô NNP 40436 5234 12 = = SYM 40436 5234 13 ton ton NN 40436 5234 14 voêto voêto NNP 40436 5234 15 / / SYM 40436 5234 16 n n NNP 40436 5234 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5234 18 prô prô NNP 40436 5234 19 = = SYM 40436 5234 20 ton ton NN 40436 5234 21 o)rekto\n]--"quod o)rekto\n]--"quod NNP 40436 5234 22 _ _ NNP 40436 5234 23 per per FW 40436 5234 24 se se FW 40436 5234 25 _ _ NNP 40436 5234 26 appetibile appetibile NN 40436 5234 27 est est NNP 40436 5234 28 et et NNP 40436 5234 29 concupiscitur concupiscitur NNP 40436 5234 30 " " '' 40436 5234 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5234 32 . . . 40436 5235 1 " " `` 40436 5235 2 Quod quod NN 40436 5235 3 autem autem NN 40436 5235 4 primum primum NN 40436 5235 5 est est NNP 40436 5235 6 in in IN 40436 5235 7 aliquâ aliquâ NNP 40436 5235 8 serie serie NNP 40436 5235 9 , , , 40436 5235 10 i -PRON- PRP 40436 5235 11 d d VBD 40436 5235 12 præcipue præcipue RB 40436 5235 13 etiam etiam JJ 40436 5235 14 habet habet NNP 40436 5235 15 qualitatem qualitatem NNP 40436 5235 16 , , , 40436 5235 17 quæ quæ NNP 40436 5235 18 in in IN 40436 5235 19 reliquâ reliquâ NNP 40436 5235 20 cernitur cernitur NNP 40436 5235 21 serie serie NNP 40436 5235 22 , , , 40436 5235 23 c. c. NNP 40436 5235 24 a. a. NNP 40436 5236 1 993 993 CD 40436 5236 2 , , , 40436 5236 3 b. b. NN 40436 5237 1 24 24 CD 40436 5237 2 : : : 40436 5237 3 ergo ergo NNP 40436 5237 4 prima prima NNP 40436 5237 5 illa illa NNP 40436 5237 6 substantia substantia NNP 40436 5237 7 est est NNP 40436 5237 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5237 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5237 10 : : : 40436 5237 11 to\ to\ NN 40436 5237 12 a)/riston]"--also a)/riston]"--also NNP 40436 5237 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5237 14 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5237 15 : : : 40436 5237 16 G g NN 40436 5237 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5237 18 1004 1004 CD 40436 5237 19 , , , 40436 5237 20 a. a. NN 40436 5238 1 25 25 CD 40436 5238 2 - - SYM 40436 5238 3 26 26 CD 40436 5238 4 , , , 40436 5238 5 1005 1005 CD 40436 5238 6 , , , 40436 5238 7 a. a. NN 40436 5239 1 7 7 LS 40436 5239 2 , , , 40436 5239 3 about about IN 40436 5239 4 the the DT 40436 5239 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5239 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5239 7 : : : 40436 5239 8 prô prô NNP 40436 5239 9 = = SYM 40436 5239 10 ton ton NN 40436 5239 11 e(/n e(/n NNP 40436 5239 12 -- -- : 40436 5239 13 prô prô NNP 40436 5239 14 = = SYM 40436 5239 15 ton ton NN 40436 5239 16 o)/n o)/n NNP 40436 5239 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5239 18 . . . 40436 5240 1 These these DT 40436 5240 2 were be VBD 40436 5240 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 4 Greek greek JJ 40436 5240 5 : : : 40436 5240 6 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 5240 7 pollachô pollachô NNP 40436 5240 8 = = NFP 40436 5240 9 s s NNP 40436 5240 10 lego lego NNP 40436 5240 11 / / SYM 40436 5240 12 mena mena NNP 40436 5240 13 -- -- : 40436 5240 14 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 5240 15 pleonachô pleonachô NNP 40436 5240 16 = = NFP 40436 5240 17 s s NNP 40436 5240 18 lego lego NNP 40436 5240 19 / / SYM 40436 5240 20 mena]--which mena]--which NNPS 40436 5240 21 were be VBD 40436 5240 22 something something NN 40436 5240 23 less less JJR 40436 5240 24 than than IN 40436 5240 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 27 : : : 40436 5240 28 sunô sunô NNP 40436 5240 29 / / SYM 40436 5240 30 numa numa NNP 40436 5240 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 32 and and CC 40436 5240 33 more more JJR 40436 5240 34 than than IN 40436 5240 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 37 : : : 40436 5240 38 o(mô o(mô NNP 40436 5240 39 / / SYM 40436 5240 40 numa numa NNP 40436 5240 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 42 ; ; : 40436 5240 43 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 5240 44 between between IN 40436 5240 45 the the DT 40436 5240 46 two two CD 40436 5240 47 , , , 40436 5240 48 having have VBG 40436 5240 49 no no DT 40436 5240 50 common common JJ 40436 5240 51 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 52 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 53 : : : 40436 5240 54 lo lo NNP 40436 5240 55 / / SYM 40436 5240 56 gos gos NN 40436 5240 57 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 58 or or CC 40436 5240 59 generical generical JJ 40436 5240 60 unity unity NN 40436 5240 61 , , , 40436 5240 62 and and CC 40436 5240 63 yet yet RB 40436 5240 64 not not RB 40436 5240 65 entirely entirely RB 40436 5240 66 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 5240 67 , , , 40436 5240 68 but but CC 40436 5240 69 designating designate VBG 40436 5240 70 a a DT 40436 5240 71 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 72 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 73 : : : 40436 5240 74 koino\n koino\n ADD 40436 5240 75 kat kat NNP 40436 5240 76 ' ' '' 40436 5240 77 a)nalogi a)nalogi NNS 40436 5240 78 / / SYM 40436 5240 79 an an DT 40436 5240 80 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 81 : : : 40436 5240 82 not not RB 40436 5240 83 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 84 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 85 : : : 40436 5240 86 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 5240 87 mi mi NNP 40436 5240 88 / / SYM 40436 5240 89 an an DT 40436 5240 90 i)de i)de NNP 40436 5240 91 / / , 40436 5240 92 an an DT 40436 5240 93 lego lego NNP 40436 5240 94 / / SYM 40436 5240 95 mena mena NN 40436 5240 96 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 97 , , , 40436 5240 98 but but CC 40436 5240 99 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 100 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 101 : : : 40436 5240 102 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5240 103 e(\n e(\n NN 40436 5240 104 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 105 or or CC 40436 5240 106 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 107 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 108 : : : 40436 5240 109 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5240 110 mi mi NNP 40436 5240 111 / / SYM 40436 5240 112 an an DT 40436 5240 113 phu phu NN 40436 5240 114 / / SYM 40436 5240 115 sin sin NN 40436 5240 116 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 117 ; ; , 40436 5240 118 having have VBG 40436 5240 119 a a DT 40436 5240 120 certain certain JJ 40436 5240 121 relation relation NN 40436 5240 122 to to IN 40436 5240 123 one one CD 40436 5240 124 common common JJ 40436 5240 125 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 126 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 127 : : : 40436 5240 128 phu phu NN 40436 5240 129 / / SYM 40436 5240 130 sis sis NN 40436 5240 131 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 132 called call VBN 40436 5240 133 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5240 134 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5240 135 : : : 40436 5240 136 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5240 137 prô prô NNP 40436 5240 138 = = SYM 40436 5240 139 ton ton NN 40436 5240 140 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5240 141 . . . 40436 5241 1 See see VB 40436 5241 2 the the DT 40436 5241 3 Metaphys Metaphys NNP 40436 5241 4 . . . 40436 5242 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5242 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5242 3 : : : 40436 5242 4 G g NN 40436 5242 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5242 6 . . . 40436 5243 1 1003 1003 CD 40436 5243 2 , , , 40436 5243 3 a. a. NN 40436 5244 1 33 33 CD 40436 5244 2 - - HYPH 40436 5244 3 -[Greek -[greek NN 40436 5244 4 : : : 40436 5244 5 to/ to/ CD 40436 5244 6 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5244 7 o)/n o)/n NNP 40436 5244 8 le le NNP 40436 5244 9 / / SYM 40436 5244 10 getai getai NNP 40436 5244 11 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5244 12 pollachô pollachô NNP 40436 5244 13 = = SYM 40436 5244 14 s s NNP 40436 5244 15 , , , 40436 5244 16 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 5244 17 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5244 18 e(/n e(/n NNP 40436 5244 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5244 20 mi mi NNP 40436 5244 21 / / SYM 40436 5244 22 an an DT 40436 5244 23 tina\ tina\ CD 40436 5244 24 phu phu NN 40436 5244 25 / / SYM 40436 5244 26 sin sin NN 40436 5244 27 , , , 40436 5244 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5244 29 ou)ch ou)ch NNP 40436 5244 30 o(mônu o(mônu NNP 40436 5244 31 / / SYM 40436 5244 32 môs môs NN 40436 5244 33 , , , 40436 5244 34 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 5244 35 ' ' `` 40436 5244 36 ô(/sper ô(/sper NN 40436 5244 37 to\ to\ NN 40436 5244 38 u(gieino\n u(gieino\n NNP 40436 5244 39 a(/pan a(/pan NNP 40436 5244 40 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5244 41 u(giei u(giei NN 40436 5244 42 / / SYM 40436 5244 43 an an DT 40436 5244 44 , , , 40436 5244 45 to\ to\ NN 40436 5244 46 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5244 47 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 5244 48 phula phula NN 40436 5244 49 / / SYM 40436 5244 50 ttein ttein NN 40436 5244 51 , , , 40436 5244 52 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5244 53 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5244 54 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 5244 55 poiei poiei NN 40436 5244 56 = = SYM 40436 5244 57 n n NN 40436 5244 58 , , , 40436 5244 59 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5244 60 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5244 61 tê| tê| NNP 40436 5244 62 sêmei sêmei NNP 40436 5244 63 = = NFP 40436 5244 64 on on IN 40436 5244 65 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 5244 66 tê tê NNP 40436 5244 67 = = SYM 40436 5244 68 s s NNP 40436 5244 69 u(giei u(giei NNP 40436 5244 70 / / SYM 40436 5244 71 as as IN 40436 5244 72 , , , 40436 5244 73 to\ to\ NN 40436 5244 74 d d NNP 40436 5244 75 ' ' POS 40436 5244 76 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 5244 77 dektiko\n dektiko\n NNP 40436 5244 78 au)tê au)tê NNP 40436 5244 79 = = SYM 40436 5244 80 s s NNP 40436 5244 81 -- -- : 40436 5244 82 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5244 83 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5244 84 i)atriko\n i)atriko\n NNP 40436 5244 85 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5244 86 i)atrikê i)atrikê CD 40436 5244 87 / / SYM 40436 5244 88 n n NN 40436 5244 89 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5244 90 , , , 40436 5244 91 & & CC 40436 5244 92 c. c. NNP 40436 5244 93 The the DT 40436 5244 94 Scholion Scholion NNP 40436 5244 95 of of IN 40436 5244 96 Alexander Alexander NNP 40436 5244 97 upon upon IN 40436 5244 98 this this DT 40436 5244 99 passage passage NN 40436 5244 100 is be VBZ 40436 5244 101 instructive instructive JJ 40436 5244 102 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5244 103 p. p. NN 40436 5244 104 638 638 CD 40436 5244 105 , , , 40436 5244 106 a. a. NN 40436 5244 107 Brandis Brandis NNP 40436 5244 108 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5244 109 ; ; : 40436 5244 110 and and CC 40436 5244 111 a a DT 40436 5244 112 very very RB 40436 5244 113 copious copious JJ 40436 5244 114 explanation explanation NN 40436 5244 115 of of IN 40436 5244 116 the the DT 40436 5244 117 whole whole JJ 40436 5244 118 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5244 119 is be VBZ 40436 5244 120 given give VBN 40436 5244 121 by by IN 40436 5244 122 M. M. NNP 40436 5244 123 Brentano Brentano NNP 40436 5244 124 , , , 40436 5244 125 in in IN 40436 5244 126 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5244 127 valuable valuable JJ 40436 5244 128 treatise treatise NN 40436 5244 129 , , , 40436 5244 130 ' ' '' 40436 5244 131 Von Von NNP 40436 5244 132 der der VBD 40436 5244 133 mannigfachen mannigfachen NNP 40436 5244 134 Bedeutung Bedeutung NNP 40436 5244 135 _ _ NNP 40436 5244 136 des des FW 40436 5244 137 Seienden Seienden NNP 40436 5244 138 _ _ NNP 40436 5244 139 nach nach NN 40436 5244 140 Aristoteles Aristoteles NNP 40436 5244 141 , , , 40436 5244 142 ' ' '' 40436 5244 143 Freiburg Freiburg NNP 40436 5244 144 , , , 40436 5244 145 1862 1862 CD 40436 5244 146 , , , 40436 5244 147 pp pp NNP 40436 5244 148 . . . 40436 5245 1 85 85 CD 40436 5245 2 - - SYM 40436 5245 3 108 108 CD 40436 5245 4 - - HYPH 40436 5245 5 147 147 CD 40436 5245 6 . . . 40436 5246 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 5246 2 Aristotel Aristotel NNP 40436 5246 3 . . . 40436 5247 1 Politic politic JJ 40436 5247 2 . . . 40436 5248 1 III iii CD 40436 5248 2 . . . 40436 5249 1 i. i. NNP 40436 5250 1 9 9 CD 40436 5250 2 , , , 40436 5250 3 p. p. NN 40436 5250 4 1275 1275 CD 40436 5250 5 , , , 40436 5250 6 a. a. NN 40436 5251 1 35 35 CD 40436 5251 2 . . . 40436 5252 1 The the DT 40436 5252 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 5252 3 drawn draw VBN 40436 5252 4 by by IN 40436 5252 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5252 6 between between IN 40436 5252 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5252 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5252 9 : : : 40436 5252 10 to\ to\ NN 40436 5252 11 koino\n koino\n NNP 40436 5252 12 kat kat NNP 40436 5252 13 ' ' '' 40436 5252 14 i)de i)de NNP 40436 5252 15 / / SYM 40436 5252 16 an an NN 40436 5252 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5252 18 and and CC 40436 5252 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5252 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5252 21 : : : 40436 5252 22 to\ to\ NN 40436 5252 23 koino\n koino\n NNP 40436 5252 24 kat kat NNP 40436 5252 25 ' ' '' 40436 5252 26 a)nalogi a)nalogi CD 40436 5252 27 / / SYM 40436 5252 28 an]--between an]--between JJ 40436 5252 29 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5252 30 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5252 31 : : : 40436 5252 32 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 5252 33 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 5252 34 mi mi NNP 40436 5252 35 / / SYM 40436 5252 36 an an DT 40436 5252 37 i)de i)de NNP 40436 5252 38 / / , 40436 5252 39 an an DT 40436 5252 40 lego lego NNP 40436 5252 41 / / SYM 40436 5252 42 mena mena NN 40436 5252 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5252 44 , , , 40436 5252 45 and and CC 40436 5252 46 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5252 47 Greek greek JJ 40436 5252 48 : : : 40436 5252 49 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 5252 50 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5252 51 e(\n e(\n NN 40436 5252 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5252 53 or or CC 40436 5252 54 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5252 55 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5252 56 : : : 40436 5252 57 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5252 58 mi mi NNP 40436 5252 59 / / SYM 40436 5252 60 an an DT 40436 5252 61 phu phu NN 40436 5252 62 / / SYM 40436 5252 63 sin sin NN 40436 5252 64 lego lego NNP 40436 5252 65 / / , 40436 5252 66 mena]--this mena]--this NNP 40436 5252 67 distinction distinction NN 40436 5252 68 corresponds correspond VBZ 40436 5252 69 in in IN 40436 5252 70 part part NN 40436 5252 71 to to IN 40436 5252 72 that that DT 40436 5252 73 which which WDT 40436 5252 74 is be VBZ 40436 5252 75 drawn draw VBN 40436 5252 76 by by IN 40436 5252 77 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 5252 78 Whewell Whewell NNP 40436 5252 79 between between IN 40436 5252 80 classes class NNS 40436 5252 81 which which WDT 40436 5252 82 are be VBP 40436 5252 83 given give VBN 40436 5252 84 by by IN 40436 5252 85 Definition Definition NNP 40436 5252 86 , , , 40436 5252 87 and and CC 40436 5252 88 natural natural JJ 40436 5252 89 groups group NNS 40436 5252 90 which which WDT 40436 5252 91 are be VBP 40436 5252 92 given give VBN 40436 5252 93 by by IN 40436 5252 94 Type type NN 40436 5252 95 . . . 40436 5253 1 " " `` 40436 5253 2 Such such PDT 40436 5253 3 a a DT 40436 5253 4 natural natural JJ 40436 5253 5 group group NN 40436 5253 6 " " '' 40436 5253 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5253 8 says say VBZ 40436 5253 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 5253 10 Whewell Whewell NNP 40436 5253 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5253 12 " " `` 40436 5253 13 is be VBZ 40436 5253 14 steadily steadily RB 40436 5253 15 fixed fix VBN 40436 5253 16 , , , 40436 5253 17 though though IN 40436 5253 18 not not RB 40436 5253 19 precisely precisely RB 40436 5253 20 limited limited JJ 40436 5253 21 ; ; : 40436 5253 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5253 23 is be VBZ 40436 5253 24 given give VBN 40436 5253 25 , , , 40436 5253 26 though though IN 40436 5253 27 not not RB 40436 5253 28 circumscribed circumscribe VBN 40436 5253 29 ; ; : 40436 5253 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5253 31 is be VBZ 40436 5253 32 determined determined JJ 40436 5253 33 , , , 40436 5253 34 not not RB 40436 5253 35 by by IN 40436 5253 36 a a DT 40436 5253 37 boundary boundary NN 40436 5253 38 but but CC 40436 5253 39 by by IN 40436 5253 40 a a DT 40436 5253 41 central central JJ 40436 5253 42 point point NN 40436 5253 43 within within IN 40436 5253 44 , , , 40436 5253 45 & & CC 40436 5253 46 c. c. NNP 40436 5253 47 " " `` 40436 5253 48 The the DT 40436 5253 49 coincidence coincidence NN 40436 5253 50 between between IN 40436 5253 51 this this DT 40436 5253 52 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5253 53 and and CC 40436 5253 54 the the DT 40436 5253 55 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40436 5253 56 is be VBZ 40436 5253 57 real real JJ 40436 5253 58 , , , 40436 5253 59 though though IN 40436 5253 60 only only RB 40436 5253 61 partial partial NN 40436 5253 62 : : : 40436 5253 63 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5253 64 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5253 65 : : : 40436 5253 66 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5253 67 prô prô NNP 40436 5253 68 = = SYM 40436 5253 69 ton ton NNP 40436 5253 70 phi phi NNP 40436 5253 71 / / SYM 40436 5253 72 lon lon NNP 40436 5253 73 , , , 40436 5253 74 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5253 75 prô prô NNP 40436 5253 76 = = SYM 40436 5253 77 ton ton NN 40436 5253 78 o(rekto o(rekto NNP 40436 5253 79 / / SYM 40436 5253 80 n n NN 40436 5253 81 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5253 82 , , , 40436 5253 83 may may MD 40436 5253 84 be be VB 40436 5253 85 considered consider VBN 40436 5253 86 as as IN 40436 5253 87 types type NNS 40436 5253 88 of of IN 40436 5253 89 _ _ NNP 40436 5253 90 objects object NNS 40436 5253 91 loveable loveable JJ 40436 5253 92 , , , 40436 5253 93 objects object NNS 40436 5253 94 desirable desirable JJ 40436 5253 95 _ _ NNP 40436 5253 96 , , , 40436 5253 97 & & CC 40436 5253 98 c. c. NNP 40436 5253 99 , , , 40436 5253 100 but but CC 40436 5253 101 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5253 102 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5253 103 : : : 40436 5253 104 ê ê NNP 40436 5253 105 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5253 106 u(giei u(giei NNP 40436 5253 107 / / SYM 40436 5253 108 a a DT 40436 5253 109 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5253 110 can can MD 40436 5253 111 not not RB 40436 5253 112 be be VB 40436 5253 113 considered consider VBN 40436 5253 114 as as IN 40436 5253 115 a a DT 40436 5253 116 type type NN 40436 5253 117 of of IN 40436 5253 118 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5253 119 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5253 120 : : : 40436 5253 121 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 5253 122 u(gieina\ u(gieina\ CD 40436 5253 123 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5253 124 nor nor CC 40436 5253 125 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5253 126 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5253 127 : : : 40436 5253 128 ê ê NNP 40436 5253 129 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5253 130 i)atrikê\ i)atrikê\ NN 40436 5253 131 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5253 132 as as IN 40436 5253 133 a a DT 40436 5253 134 type type NN 40436 5253 135 of of IN 40436 5253 136 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5253 137 Greek greek JJ 40436 5253 138 : : : 40436 5253 139 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 5253 140 i)atrika/ i)atrika/ NFP 40436 5253 141 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5253 142 , , , 40436 5253 143 though though IN 40436 5253 144 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5253 145 is be VBZ 40436 5253 146 " " `` 40436 5253 147 the the DT 40436 5253 148 central central JJ 40436 5253 149 point point NN 40436 5253 150 " " '' 40436 5253 151 to to TO 40436 5253 152 which which WDT 40436 5253 153 all all DT 40436 5253 154 things thing NNS 40436 5253 155 so so RB 40436 5253 156 called call VBN 40436 5253 157 are be VBP 40436 5253 158 referred refer VBN 40436 5253 159 . . . 40436 5254 1 See see VB 40436 5254 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 5254 3 Whewell Whewell NNP 40436 5254 4 's 's POS 40436 5254 5 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5254 6 stated state VBD 40436 5254 7 in in IN 40436 5254 8 the the DT 40436 5254 9 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 40436 5254 10 of of IN 40436 5254 11 the the DT 40436 5254 12 Inductive Inductive NNP 40436 5254 13 Sciences Sciences NNPS 40436 5254 14 , , , 40436 5254 15 i. i. NNP 40436 5255 1 476 476 CD 40436 5255 2 - - SYM 40436 5255 3 477 477 CD 40436 5255 4 ; ; : 40436 5255 5 and and CC 40436 5255 6 the the DT 40436 5255 7 comments comment NNS 40436 5255 8 of of IN 40436 5255 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5255 10 John John NNP 40436 5255 11 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 5255 12 Mill Mill NNP 40436 5255 13 on on IN 40436 5255 14 the the DT 40436 5255 15 doctrine--'System doctrine--'System NNP 40436 5255 16 of of IN 40436 5255 17 Logic Logic NNP 40436 5255 18 , , , 40436 5255 19 ' ' '' 40436 5255 20 Book book NN 40436 5255 21 iv iv VBZ 40436 5255 22 . . . 40436 5256 1 ch ch NNP 40436 5256 2 . . . 40436 5257 1 7 7 LS 40436 5257 2 . . . 40436 5258 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5258 2 have have VBP 40436 5258 3 adverted advert VBN 40436 5258 4 to to IN 40436 5258 5 this this DT 40436 5258 6 same same JJ 40436 5258 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5258 8 in in IN 40436 5258 9 remarking remarking NN 40436 5258 10 on on IN 40436 5258 11 the the DT 40436 5258 12 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 5258 13 Major Major NNP 40436 5258 14 , , , 40436 5258 15 supra supra NNP 40436 5258 16 , , , 40436 5258 17 p. p. NN 40436 5258 18 47 47 CD 40436 5258 19 ; ; : 40436 5258 20 also also RB 40436 5258 21 on on IN 40436 5258 22 the the DT 40436 5258 23 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 5258 24 , , , 40436 5258 25 infra infra NNP 40436 5258 26 , , , 40436 5258 27 chap chap NNP 40436 5258 28 . . . 40436 5259 1 32 32 CD 40436 5259 2 , , , 40436 5259 3 vol vol NNP 40436 5259 4 . . . 40436 5260 1 III iii CD 40436 5260 2 . . . 40436 5260 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5261 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5261 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5261 3 46 46 CD 40436 5261 4 : : : 40436 5261 5 This this DT 40436 5261 6 is be VBZ 40436 5261 7 attested attest VBN 40436 5261 8 by by IN 40436 5261 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5261 10 , , , 40436 5261 11 Eth Eth NNP 40436 5261 12 . . . 40436 5262 1 Nik Nik NNP 40436 5262 2 . . . 40436 5263 1 i. i. NNP 40436 5264 1 64 64 CD 40436 5264 2 , , , 40436 5264 3 p. p. NN 40436 5264 4 1096 1096 CD 40436 5264 5 , , , 40436 5264 6 a. a. NN 40436 5265 1 16 16 CD 40436 5265 2 . . . 40436 5266 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5266 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5266 3 : : : 40436 5266 4 Oi oi VB 40436 5266 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5266 6 de\ de\ JJ 40436 5266 7 komi komi NN 40436 5266 8 / / SYM 40436 5266 9 santes sante NNS 40436 5266 10 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5266 11 do do VB 40436 5266 12 / / SYM 40436 5266 13 xan xan NNP 40436 5266 14 tau tau NNP 40436 5266 15 / / SYM 40436 5266 16 tên tên NNP 40436 5266 17 , , , 40436 5266 18 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 5266 19 e)poi e)poi NNP 40436 5266 20 / / SYM 40436 5266 21 oun oun NNP 40436 5266 22 i)de i)de NNP 40436 5266 23 / / SYM 40436 5266 24 as as IN 40436 5266 25 e)n e)n NNP 40436 5266 26 oi(=s oi(=s NN 40436 5266 27 to\ to\ NN 40436 5266 28 pro pro JJ 40436 5266 29 / / SYM 40436 5266 30 teron teron NNP 40436 5266 31 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5266 32 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5266 33 u(/steron u(/steron NNP 40436 5266 34 e)/legon e)/legon NNP 40436 5266 35 ; ; : 40436 5266 36 dio dio NN 40436 5266 37 / / , 40436 5266 38 per per IN 40436 5266 39 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 5266 40 tô tô NNP 40436 5266 41 = = SYM 40436 5266 42 n n NNP 40436 5266 43 a)rithmô a)rithmô NNP 40436 5266 44 = = SYM 40436 5266 45 n n CC 40436 5266 46 i)de i)de NNP 40436 5266 47 / / SYM 40436 5266 48 an an DT 40436 5266 49 kateskeu kateskeu NNP 40436 5266 50 / / SYM 40436 5266 51 azon azon NNP 40436 5266 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5266 53 : : : 40436 5266 54 compare compare VB 40436 5266 55 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 5266 56 . . . 40436 5267 1 Eudem Eudem NNP 40436 5267 2 . . . 40436 5268 1 i. i. NNP 40436 5269 1 8 8 CD 40436 5269 2 , , , 40436 5269 3 1218 1218 CD 40436 5269 4 , , , 40436 5269 5 a. a. NN 40436 5270 1 2 2 LS 40436 5270 2 . . . 40436 5271 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5271 2 goes go VBZ 40436 5271 3 on on RP 40436 5271 4 to to TO 40436 5271 5 object object VB 40436 5271 6 that that IN 40436 5271 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5271 8 , , , 40436 5271 9 having have VBG 40436 5271 10 laid lay VBN 40436 5271 11 this this DT 40436 5271 12 down down RP 40436 5271 13 as as IN 40436 5271 14 a a DT 40436 5271 15 general general JJ 40436 5271 16 principle principle NN 40436 5271 17 , , , 40436 5271 18 departed depart VBN 40436 5271 19 from from IN 40436 5271 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5271 21 in in IN 40436 5271 22 recognizing recognize VBG 40436 5271 23 an an DT 40436 5271 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5271 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5271 26 : : : 40436 5271 27 i)de i)de JJ 40436 5271 28 / / , 40436 5271 29 an an DT 40436 5271 30 a)gathou= a)gathou= NN 40436 5271 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5271 32 , , , 40436 5271 33 because because IN 40436 5271 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5271 35 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5271 36 : : : 40436 5271 37 ta)gatho\n ta)gatho\n NNP 40436 5271 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5271 39 was be VBD 40436 5271 40 predicated predicate VBN 40436 5271 41 in in IN 40436 5271 42 all all PDT 40436 5271 43 the the DT 40436 5271 44 categories category NNS 40436 5271 45 , , , 40436 5271 46 in in IN 40436 5271 47 that that DT 40436 5271 48 of of IN 40436 5271 49 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5271 50 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5271 51 : : : 40436 5271 52 ou)si ou)si NNS 40436 5271 53 / / SYM 40436 5271 54 a a LS 40436 5271 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5271 56 as as RB 40436 5271 57 well well RB 40436 5271 58 as as IN 40436 5271 59 in in IN 40436 5271 60 that that DT 40436 5271 61 of of IN 40436 5271 62 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5271 63 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5271 64 : : : 40436 5271 65 pro pro LS 40436 5271 66 / / SYM 40436 5271 67 s s JJ 40436 5271 68 ti ti NN 40436 5271 69 -- -- : 40436 5271 70 to\ to\ NN 40436 5271 71 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5271 72 kath kath NNP 40436 5271 73 ' ' '' 40436 5271 74 au(to\ au(to\ NNP 40436 5271 75 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5271 76 ê ê NNP 40436 5271 77 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5271 78 ou)si ou)si NNS 40436 5271 79 / / SYM 40436 5271 80 a a DT 40436 5271 81 pro pro JJ 40436 5271 82 / / SYM 40436 5271 83 teron teron NNP 40436 5271 84 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 5271 85 phu phu NN 40436 5271 86 / / SYM 40436 5271 87 sei sei NN 40436 5271 88 tou= tou= NNP 40436 5271 89 pro pro JJ 40436 5271 90 / / SYM 40436 5271 91 s s JJ 40436 5271 92 ti ti NN 40436 5271 93 -- -- : 40436 5271 94 ô(/ste ô(/ste NN 40436 5271 95 ou)k ou)k NN 40436 5271 96 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 5271 97 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 5271 98 koinê/ koinê/ NNP 40436 5271 99 tis ti VBD 40436 5271 100 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 5271 101 tou tou NNP 40436 5271 102 / / SYM 40436 5271 103 tôn tôn NNP 40436 5271 104 i)de i)de NNP 40436 5271 105 / / SYM 40436 5271 106 a a NN 40436 5271 107 . . . 40436 5271 108 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5271 109 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5272 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5272 2 Side side NN 40436 5272 3 - - HYPH 40436 5272 4 note note NN 40436 5272 5 : : : 40436 5272 6 Primum Primum NNP 40436 5272 7 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 5272 8 of of IN 40436 5272 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5272 10 , , , 40436 5272 11 compared compare VBN 40436 5272 12 with with IN 40436 5272 13 the the DT 40436 5272 14 Prima Prima NNP 40436 5272 15 Amicitia Amicitia NNP 40436 5272 16 of of IN 40436 5272 17 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5272 18 . . . 40436 5273 1 Each each DT 40436 5273 2 of of IN 40436 5273 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5273 4 is be VBZ 40436 5273 5 head head NN 40436 5273 6 of of IN 40436 5273 7 an an DT 40436 5273 8 analogical analogical JJ 40436 5273 9 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 5273 10 , , , 40436 5273 11 not not RB 40436 5273 12 member member NN 40436 5273 13 of of IN 40436 5273 14 a a DT 40436 5273 15 generic generic JJ 40436 5273 16 family family NN 40436 5273 17 . . . 40436 5273 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5274 1 Now now RB 40436 5274 2 the the DT 40436 5274 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5274 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5274 5 : : : 40436 5274 6 Prô Prô NNP 40436 5274 7 = = SYM 40436 5274 8 ton ton NN 40436 5274 9 phi phi NNP 40436 5274 10 / / SYM 40436 5274 11 lon lon NN 40436 5274 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5274 13 or or CC 40436 5274 14 Primum Primum NNP 40436 5274 15 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 5274 16 which which WDT 40436 5274 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5274 18 find find VBP 40436 5274 19 in in IN 40436 5274 20 the the DT 40436 5274 21 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5274 22 , , , 40436 5274 23 is be VBZ 40436 5274 24 described describe VBN 40436 5274 25 as as IN 40436 5274 26 the the DT 40436 5274 27 principium principium NN 40436 5274 28 or or CC 40436 5274 29 initial initial JJ 40436 5274 30 root root NN 40436 5274 31 of of IN 40436 5274 32 one one CD 40436 5274 33 of of IN 40436 5274 34 these these DT 40436 5274 35 imperfectly imperfectly RB 40436 5274 36 united united JJ 40436 5274 37 aggregates aggregate NNS 40436 5274 38 ; ; , 40436 5274 39 ramifying ramify VBG 40436 5274 40 into into IN 40436 5274 41 many many JJ 40436 5274 42 branches branch NNS 40436 5274 43 more more RBR 40436 5274 44 or or CC 40436 5274 45 less less RBR 40436 5274 46 distant distant JJ 40436 5274 47 , , , 40436 5274 48 in in IN 40436 5274 49 obedience obedience NN 40436 5274 50 to to IN 40436 5274 51 one one CD 40436 5274 52 or or CC 40436 5274 53 other other JJ 40436 5274 54 of of IN 40436 5274 55 the the DT 40436 5274 56 different different JJ 40436 5274 57 laws law NNS 40436 5274 58 of of IN 40436 5274 59 association association NN 40436 5274 60 . . . 40436 5275 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5275 2 expresses express VBZ 40436 5275 3 the the DT 40436 5275 4 same same JJ 40436 5275 5 idea idea NN 40436 5275 6 in in IN 40436 5275 7 another another DT 40436 5275 8 form form NN 40436 5275 9 of of IN 40436 5275 10 words word NNS 40436 5275 11 : : : 40436 5275 12 instead instead RB 40436 5275 13 of of IN 40436 5275 14 a a DT 40436 5275 15 Primum Primum NNP 40436 5275 16 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 5275 17 , , , 40436 5275 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5275 19 gives give VBZ 40436 5275 20 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5275 21 a a DT 40436 5275 22 Prima Prima NNP 40436 5275 23 Amicitia Amicitia NNP 40436 5275 24 -- -- : 40436 5275 25 affirming affirm VBG 40436 5275 26 that that IN 40436 5275 27 the the DT 40436 5275 28 diversities diversity NNS 40436 5275 29 of of IN 40436 5275 30 friendship friendship NN 40436 5275 31 are be VBP 40436 5275 32 not not RB 40436 5275 33 species specie NNS 40436 5275 34 comprehended comprehend VBN 40436 5275 35 under under IN 40436 5275 36 the the DT 40436 5275 37 same same JJ 40436 5275 38 genus genus NN 40436 5275 39 , , , 40436 5275 40 but but CC 40436 5275 41 gradations gradation NNS 40436 5275 42 or or CC 40436 5275 43 degeneracies degeneracy NNS 40436 5275 44 departing depart VBG 40436 5275 45 in in IN 40436 5275 46 one one CD 40436 5275 47 direction direction NN 40436 5275 48 or or CC 40436 5275 49 other other JJ 40436 5275 50 from from IN 40436 5275 51 the the DT 40436 5275 52 First first JJ 40436 5275 53 or or CC 40436 5275 54 pure pure JJ 40436 5275 55 Friendship friendship NN 40436 5275 56 . . . 40436 5276 1 The the DT 40436 5276 2 Primum Primum NNP 40436 5276 3 Amabile Amabile NNP 40436 5276 4 , , , 40436 5276 5 in in IN 40436 5276 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5276 7 's 's POS 40436 5276 8 view view NN 40436 5276 9 , , , 40436 5276 10 appears appear VBZ 40436 5276 11 to to TO 40436 5276 12 be be VB 40436 5276 13 the the DT 40436 5276 14 Good good JJ 40436 5276 15 , , , 40436 5276 16 though though IN 40436 5276 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5276 18 does do VBZ 40436 5276 19 not not RB 40436 5276 20 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 5276 21 declare declare VB 40436 5276 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5276 23 : : : 40436 5276 24 the the DT 40436 5276 25 Prima Prima NNP 40436 5276 26 Amicitia Amicitia NNP 40436 5276 27 , , , 40436 5276 28 with with IN 40436 5276 29 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5276 30 , , , 40436 5276 31 is be VBZ 40436 5276 32 friendship friendship NN 40436 5276 33 subsisting subsist VBG 40436 5276 34 between between IN 40436 5276 35 two two CD 40436 5276 36 good good JJ 40436 5276 37 persons person NNS 40436 5276 38 , , , 40436 5276 39 who who WP 40436 5276 40 have have VBP 40436 5276 41 had have VBN 40436 5276 42 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 5276 43 experience experience NN 40436 5276 44 to to TO 40436 5276 45 know know VB 40436 5276 46 , , , 40436 5276 47 esteem esteem VB 40436 5276 48 , , , 40436 5276 49 and and CC 40436 5276 50 trust trust NN 40436 5276 51 , , , 40436 5276 52 each each DT 40436 5276 53 other other JJ 40436 5276 54 . . . 40436 5277 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5277 2 47 47 CD 40436 5277 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5277 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5277 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5277 6 47 47 CD 40436 5277 7 : : : 40436 5277 8 Aristotel Aristotel NNP 40436 5277 9 . . . 40436 5278 1 Eth Eth NNP 40436 5278 2 . . . 40436 5279 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 5279 2 . . . 40436 5280 1 viii viii RB 40436 5280 2 . . . 40436 5281 1 2 2 CD 40436 5281 2 , , , 40436 5281 3 1155 1155 CD 40436 5281 4 , , , 40436 5281 5 b. b. NNP 40436 5282 1 12 12 CD 40436 5282 2 , , , 40436 5282 3 viii viii JJ 40436 5282 4 . . . 40436 5283 1 5 5 CD 40436 5283 2 , , , 40436 5283 3 1157 1157 CD 40436 5283 4 , , , 40436 5283 5 a. a. NN 40436 5284 1 30 30 CD 40436 5284 2 , , , 40436 5284 3 viii viii JJ 40436 5284 4 . . . 40436 5285 1 4 4 LS 40436 5285 2 ; ; : 40436 5285 3 Eth Eth NNP 40436 5285 4 . . . 40436 5286 1 Eudem Eudem NNP 40436 5286 2 . . . 40436 5287 1 vii vii NN 40436 5287 2 . . . 40436 5288 1 2 2 CD 40436 5288 2 , , , 40436 5288 3 1236 1236 CD 40436 5288 4 , , , 40436 5288 5 a. a. NN 40436 5289 1 15 15 CD 40436 5289 2 . . . 40436 5290 1 The the DT 40436 5290 2 statement statement NN 40436 5290 3 is be VBZ 40436 5290 4 more more RBR 40436 5290 5 full full JJ 40436 5290 6 in in IN 40436 5290 7 the the DT 40436 5290 8 Eudemian eudemian JJ 40436 5290 9 Ethics Ethics NNPS 40436 5290 10 than than IN 40436 5290 11 in in IN 40436 5290 12 the the DT 40436 5290 13 Nikomachean Nikomachean NNP 40436 5290 14 ; ; : 40436 5290 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5290 16 begins begin VBZ 40436 5290 17 the the DT 40436 5290 18 seventh seventh JJ 40436 5290 19 book book NN 40436 5290 20 by by IN 40436 5290 21 saying say VBG 40436 5290 22 that that IN 40436 5290 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5290 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5290 25 : : : 40436 5290 26 phili phili NN 40436 5290 27 / / SYM 40436 5290 28 a a LS 40436 5290 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5290 30 is be VBZ 40436 5290 31 not not RB 40436 5290 32 said say VBN 40436 5290 33 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5290 34 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5290 35 : : : 40436 5290 36 monachô monachô NNP 40436 5290 37 = = SYM 40436 5290 38 s s NNP 40436 5290 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5290 40 but but CC 40436 5290 41 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5290 42 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5290 43 : : : 40436 5290 44 pleonachô pleonachô NNP 40436 5290 45 = = SYM 40436 5290 46 s s NNP 40436 5290 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5290 48 ; ; : 40436 5290 49 and and CC 40436 5290 50 in in IN 40436 5290 51 p. p. NN 40436 5290 52 1236 1236 CD 40436 5290 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5290 54 says say VBZ 40436 5290 55 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5290 56 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5290 57 : : : 40436 5290 58 A)na A)na NNP 40436 5290 59 / / SYM 40436 5290 60 gkê gkê NNP 40436 5290 61 a)/ra a)/ra NFP 40436 5290 62 tri tri NNP 40436 5290 63 / / SYM 40436 5290 64 a a DT 40436 5290 65 phili phili NN 40436 5290 66 / / SYM 40436 5290 67 as as IN 40436 5290 68 ei)/dê ei)/dê NNP 40436 5290 69 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 5290 70 , , , 40436 5290 71 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5290 72 _ _ NNP 40436 5290 73 mête mête NNP 40436 5290 74 kath kath NNP 40436 5290 75 ' ' '' 40436 5290 76 e(\n e(\n NNP 40436 5290 77 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 5290 78 / / SYM 40436 5290 79 sas sas NNP 40436 5290 80 _ _ NNP 40436 5290 81 mêth mêth NNP 40436 5290 82 ' ' POS 40436 5290 83 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 5290 84 _ _ NNP 40436 5290 85 ei)/dê ei)/dê NNP 40436 5290 86 e(no\s e(no\s NNP 40436 5290 87 ge ge NNP 40436 5290 88 / / SYM 40436 5290 89 nous nous JJ 40436 5290 90 _ _ NNP 40436 5290 91 , , , 40436 5290 92 mê mê NNP 40436 5290 93 / / SYM 40436 5290 94 te te NNP 40436 5290 95 pa pa NNP 40436 5290 96 / / SYM 40436 5290 97 mpan mpan NNP 40436 5290 98 le le NNP 40436 5290 99 / / SYM 40436 5290 100 gesthai gesthai NNP 40436 5290 101 o(mônu o(mônu . 40436 5290 102 / / SYM 40436 5290 103 môs môs NNP 40436 5290 104 ; ; : 40436 5290 105 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 5290 106 _ _ NNP 40436 5290 107 mi mi NNP 40436 5290 108 / / SYM 40436 5290 109 an an DT 40436 5290 110 ga ga NNP 40436 5290 111 / / SYM 40436 5290 112 r r NNP 40436 5290 113 tina tina NNP 40436 5290 114 le le NNP 40436 5290 115 / / SYM 40436 5290 116 gontai gontai NNP 40436 5290 117 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5290 118 prô prô NNP 40436 5290 119 / / SYM 40436 5290 120 tên tên NNP 40436 5290 121 , , , 40436 5290 122 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 5290 123 to\ to\ NN 40436 5290 124 i)atriko i)atriko NNP 40436 5290 125 / / SYM 40436 5290 126 n n CC 40436 5290 127 _ _ NNP 40436 5290 128 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5290 129 , , , 40436 5290 130 & & CC 40436 5290 131 c. c. NNP 40436 5290 132 The the DT 40436 5290 133 whole whole JJ 40436 5290 134 passage passage NN 40436 5290 135 is be VBZ 40436 5290 136 instructive instructive JJ 40436 5290 137 , , , 40436 5290 138 but but CC 40436 5290 139 is be VBZ 40436 5290 140 too too RB 40436 5290 141 long long JJ 40436 5290 142 to to TO 40436 5290 143 cite cite VB 40436 5290 144 . . . 40436 5291 1 Bonitz Bonitz NNP 40436 5291 2 gives give VBZ 40436 5291 3 some some DT 40436 5291 4 good good JJ 40436 5291 5 explanations explanation NNS 40436 5291 6 of of IN 40436 5291 7 these these DT 40436 5291 8 passages passage NNS 40436 5291 9 . . . 40436 5292 1 Observationes observatione NNS 40436 5292 2 Criticæ Criticæ NNP 40436 5292 3 in in IN 40436 5292 4 Aristotelis Aristotelis NNP 40436 5292 5 quæ quæ NN 40436 5292 6 feruntur feruntur NNP 40436 5292 7 _ _ NNP 40436 5292 8 Magna Magna NNP 40436 5292 9 Moralia Moralia NNP 40436 5292 10 _ _ NNP 40436 5292 11 et et NNP 40436 5292 12 _ _ NNP 40436 5292 13 Eudemia Eudemia NNP 40436 5292 14 _ _ NNP 40436 5292 15 , , , 40436 5292 16 pp pp NNP 40436 5292 17 . . . 40436 5293 1 55 55 CD 40436 5293 2 - - SYM 40436 5293 3 57 57 CD 40436 5293 4 . . . 40436 5293 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5294 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5294 2 Side side NN 40436 5294 3 - - HYPH 40436 5294 4 note note NN 40436 5294 5 : : : 40436 5294 6 The the DT 40436 5294 7 Good good JJ 40436 5294 8 and and CC 40436 5294 9 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 5294 10 , , , 40436 5294 11 considered consider VBN 40436 5294 12 as as IN 40436 5294 13 objects object NNS 40436 5294 14 of of IN 40436 5294 15 attachment attachment NN 40436 5294 16 . . . 40436 5294 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5295 1 In in IN 40436 5295 2 regard regard NN 40436 5295 3 to to IN 40436 5295 4 the the DT 40436 5295 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5295 6 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 5295 7 , , , 40436 5295 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5295 9 have have VBP 40436 5295 10 already already RB 40436 5295 11 observed observe VBN 40436 5295 12 that that IN 40436 5295 13 no no DT 40436 5295 14 positive positive JJ 40436 5295 15 result result NN 40436 5295 16 can can MD 40436 5295 17 be be VB 40436 5295 18 found find VBN 40436 5295 19 in in IN 40436 5295 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5295 21 , , , 40436 5295 22 and and CC 40436 5295 23 that that IN 40436 5295 24 all all PDT 40436 5295 25 the the DT 40436 5295 26 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 40436 5295 27 broached broach VBD 40436 5295 28 are be VBP 40436 5295 29 successively successively RB 40436 5295 30 negatived negative VBN 40436 5295 31 . . . 40436 5296 1 What what WP 40436 5296 2 is be VBZ 40436 5296 3 kept keep VBN 40436 5296 4 before before IN 40436 5296 5 the the DT 40436 5296 6 reader reader NN 40436 5296 7 's 's POS 40436 5296 8 mind mind NN 40436 5296 9 , , , 40436 5296 10 however however RB 40436 5296 11 , , , 40436 5296 12 more more JJR 40436 5296 13 than than IN 40436 5296 14 anything anything NN 40436 5296 15 else else RB 40436 5296 16 , , , 40436 5296 17 though though IN 40436 5296 18 not not RB 40436 5296 19 embodied embody VBN 40436 5296 20 in in IN 40436 5296 21 any any DT 40436 5296 22 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5296 23 formula formula NN 40436 5296 24 , , , 40436 5296 25 is be VBZ 40436 5296 26 -- -- : 40436 5296 27 The the DT 40436 5296 28 Good good JJ 40436 5296 29 and and CC 40436 5296 30 the the DT 40436 5296 31 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 5296 32 considered consider VBN 40436 5296 33 as as IN 40436 5296 34 objects object NNS 40436 5296 35 of of IN 40436 5296 36 love love NN 40436 5296 37 or or CC 40436 5296 38 attachment attachment NN 40436 5296 39 . . . 40436 5297 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 5297 2 XXI XXI NNP 40436 5297 3 . . . 40436 5298 1 EUTHYDEMUS EUTHYDEMUS NNP 40436 5298 2 . . . 40436 5299 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5299 2 Side side NN 40436 5299 3 - - HYPH 40436 5299 4 note note NN 40436 5299 5 : : : 40436 5299 6 Dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 5299 7 and and CC 40436 5299 8 comic comic JJ 40436 5299 9 exuberance exuberance NN 40436 5299 10 of of IN 40436 5299 11 the the DT 40436 5299 12 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5299 13 . . . 40436 5300 1 Judgments judgment NNS 40436 5300 2 of of IN 40436 5300 3 various various JJ 40436 5300 4 critics critic NNS 40436 5300 5 . . . 40436 5300 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5301 1 Dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 5301 2 vivacity vivacity NN 40436 5301 3 , , , 40436 5301 4 and and CC 40436 5301 5 comic comic JJ 40436 5301 6 force force NN 40436 5301 7 , , , 40436 5301 8 holding hold VBG 40436 5301 9 up up RP 40436 5301 10 various various JJ 40436 5301 11 persons person NNS 40436 5301 12 to to TO 40436 5301 13 ridicule ridicule VB 40436 5301 14 or or CC 40436 5301 15 contempt contempt NN 40436 5301 16 , , , 40436 5301 17 are be VBP 40436 5301 18 attributes attribute NNS 40436 5301 19 which which WDT 40436 5301 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5301 21 manifests manifest NNS 40436 5301 22 often often RB 40436 5301 23 and and CC 40436 5301 24 abundantly abundantly RB 40436 5301 25 . . . 40436 5302 1 But but CC 40436 5302 2 the the DT 40436 5302 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5302 4 in in IN 40436 5302 5 which which WDT 40436 5302 6 these these DT 40436 5302 7 qualities quality NNS 40436 5302 8 reach reach VBP 40436 5302 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5302 10 maximum maximum NN 40436 5302 11 , , , 40436 5302 12 is be VBZ 40436 5302 13 , , , 40436 5302 14 the the DT 40436 5302 15 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5302 16 . . . 40436 5303 1 Some some DT 40436 5303 2 portions portion NNS 40436 5303 3 of of IN 40436 5303 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5303 5 approach approach NN 40436 5303 6 to to IN 40436 5303 7 the the DT 40436 5303 8 Nubes Nubes NNP 40436 5303 9 of of IN 40436 5303 10 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40436 5303 11 : : : 40436 5303 12 so so CC 40436 5303 13 that that IN 40436 5303 14 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5303 15 , , , 40436 5303 16 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5303 17 , , , 40436 5303 18 and and CC 40436 5303 19 other other JJ 40436 5303 20 admiring admire VBG 40436 5303 21 critics critic NNS 40436 5303 22 have have VBP 40436 5303 23 some some DT 40436 5303 24 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 5303 25 in in IN 40436 5303 26 explaining explain VBG 40436 5303 27 , , , 40436 5303 28 to to IN 40436 5303 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5303 30 own own JJ 40436 5303 31 satisfaction,[1 satisfaction,[1 NN 40436 5303 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5303 33 how how WRB 40436 5303 34 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5303 35 , , , 40436 5303 36 the the DT 40436 5303 37 sublime sublime JJ 40436 5303 38 moralist moralist NN 40436 5303 39 and and CC 40436 5303 40 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 5303 41 , , , 40436 5303 42 can can MD 40436 5303 43 here here RB 40436 5303 44 have have VB 40436 5303 45 admitted admit VBN 40436 5303 46 so so RB 40436 5303 47 much much JJ 40436 5303 48 trifling trifling NN 40436 5303 49 and and CC 40436 5303 50 buffoonery buffoonery NN 40436 5303 51 . . . 40436 5304 1 Ast Ast NNP 40436 5304 2 even even RB 40436 5304 3 rejects reject VBZ 40436 5304 4 the the DT 40436 5304 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5304 6 as as IN 40436 5304 7 spurious spurious JJ 40436 5304 8 ; ; : 40436 5304 9 declaring declare VBG 40436 5304 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5304 11 to to TO 40436 5304 12 be be VB 40436 5304 13 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 5304 14 of of IN 40436 5304 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5304 16 and and CC 40436 5304 17 insisting insist VBG 40436 5304 18 on on IN 40436 5304 19 various various JJ 40436 5304 20 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 40436 5304 21 , , , 40436 5304 22 defects defect NNS 40436 5304 23 , , , 40436 5304 24 and and CC 40436 5304 25 even even RB 40436 5304 26 absurdities absurdity NNS 40436 5304 27 , , , 40436 5304 28 which which WDT 40436 5304 29 offend offend VBP 40436 5304 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5304 31 critical critical JJ 40436 5304 32 taste taste NN 40436 5304 33 . . . 40436 5305 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5305 2 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5305 3 in in IN 40436 5305 4 this this DT 40436 5305 5 case case NN 40436 5305 6 has have VBZ 40436 5305 7 found find VBN 40436 5305 8 no no DT 40436 5305 9 favour favour NN 40436 5305 10 : : : 40436 5305 11 yet yet CC 40436 5305 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5305 13 think think VBP 40436 5305 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5305 15 is be VBZ 40436 5305 16 based base VBN 40436 5305 17 on on IN 40436 5305 18 reasons reason NNS 40436 5305 19 quite quite RB 40436 5305 20 as as RB 40436 5305 21 forcible forcible JJ 40436 5305 22 as as IN 40436 5305 23 those those DT 40436 5305 24 upon upon IN 40436 5305 25 which which WDT 40436 5305 26 other other JJ 40436 5305 27 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5305 28 have have VBP 40436 5305 29 been be VBN 40436 5305 30 condemned:[2 condemned:[2 VBN 40436 5305 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5305 32 upon upon IN 40436 5305 33 reasons reason NNS 40436 5305 34 , , , 40436 5305 35 which which WDT 40436 5305 36 , , , 40436 5305 37 even even RB 40436 5305 38 if if IN 40436 5305 39 admitted admit VBN 40436 5305 40 , , , 40436 5305 41 might may MD 40436 5305 42 prove prove VB 40436 5305 43 that that IN 40436 5305 44 the the DT 40436 5305 45 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5305 46 was be VBD 40436 5305 47 an an DT 40436 5305 48 inferior inferior JJ 40436 5305 49 performance performance NN 40436 5305 50 , , , 40436 5305 51 but but CC 40436 5305 52 would would MD 40436 5305 53 not not RB 40436 5305 54 prove prove VB 40436 5305 55 that that IN 40436 5305 56 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5305 57 was be VBD 40436 5305 58 not not RB 40436 5305 59 the the DT 40436 5305 60 author author NN 40436 5305 61 . . . 40436 5306 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5306 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5306 3 1 1 CD 40436 5306 4 : : : 40436 5306 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5306 6 , , , 40436 5306 7 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 5306 8 zum zum NNP 40436 5306 9 Euthydemos Euthydemos NNP 40436 5306 10 , , , 40436 5306 11 vol vol NNP 40436 5306 12 . . . 40436 5307 1 iii iii NNP 40436 5307 2 . . . 40436 5308 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5308 2 . . . 40436 5309 1 400 400 CD 40436 5309 2 - - CD 40436 5309 3 403 403 CD 40436 5309 4 - - HYPH 40436 5309 5 407 407 CD 40436 5309 6 ; ; : 40436 5309 7 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5309 8 . . . 40436 5310 1 Proleg proleg NN 40436 5310 2 . . . 40436 5311 1 in in IN 40436 5311 2 Euthydem Euthydem NNP 40436 5311 3 . . . 40436 5312 1 p. p. NN 40436 5313 1 14 14 CD 40436 5313 2 . . . 40436 5313 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5314 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5314 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5314 3 2 2 CD 40436 5314 4 : : : 40436 5314 5 Ast Ast NNP 40436 5314 6 , , , 40436 5314 7 Platon Platon NNP 40436 5314 8 's 's POS 40436 5314 9 Leben Leben NNP 40436 5314 10 und und NN 40436 5314 11 Schriften Schriften NNP 40436 5314 12 , , , 40436 5314 13 pp pp NNP 40436 5314 14 . . . 40436 5315 1 408 408 CD 40436 5315 2 - - SYM 40436 5315 3 418 418 CD 40436 5315 4 . . . 40436 5315 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5316 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5316 2 Side side NN 40436 5316 3 - - HYPH 40436 5316 4 note note NN 40436 5316 5 : : : 40436 5316 6 Scenery scenery NN 40436 5316 7 and and CC 40436 5316 8 personages personage NNS 40436 5316 9 . . . 40436 5316 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5317 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5317 2 recounts recount NNS 40436 5317 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5317 4 to to IN 40436 5317 5 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5317 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5317 7 a a DT 40436 5317 8 conversation conversation NN 40436 5317 9 in in IN 40436 5317 10 which which WDT 40436 5317 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5317 12 has have VBZ 40436 5317 13 just just RB 40436 5317 14 been be VBN 40436 5317 15 engaged engage VBN 40436 5317 16 with with IN 40436 5317 17 two two CD 40436 5317 18 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5317 19 , , , 40436 5317 20 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5317 21 and and CC 40436 5317 22 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5317 23 , , , 40436 5317 24 in in IN 40436 5317 25 the the DT 40436 5317 26 undressing undressing NN 40436 5317 27 - - HYPH 40436 5317 28 room room NN 40436 5317 29 belonging belong VBG 40436 5317 30 to to IN 40436 5317 31 the the DT 40436 5317 32 gymnasium gymnasium NN 40436 5317 33 of of IN 40436 5317 34 the the DT 40436 5317 35 Lykeium Lykeium NNP 40436 5317 36 . . . 40436 5318 1 There there EX 40436 5318 2 were be VBD 40436 5318 3 present present JJ 40436 5318 4 , , , 40436 5318 5 besides besides RB 40436 5318 6 , , , 40436 5318 7 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5318 8 , , , 40436 5318 9 a a DT 40436 5318 10 youth youth NN 40436 5318 11 of of IN 40436 5318 12 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 5318 13 beauty beauty NN 40436 5318 14 and and CC 40436 5318 15 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5318 16 , , , 40436 5318 17 cousin cousin NN 40436 5318 18 of of IN 40436 5318 19 the the DT 40436 5318 20 great great JJ 40436 5318 21 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 5318 22 -- -- : 40436 5318 23 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 5318 24 , , , 40436 5318 25 an an DT 40436 5318 26 adult adult NN 40436 5318 27 man man NN 40436 5318 28 , , , 40436 5318 29 yet yet CC 40436 5318 30 still still RB 40436 5318 31 young young JJ 40436 5318 32 , , , 40436 5318 33 friend friend NN 40436 5318 34 of of IN 40436 5318 35 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5318 36 and and CC 40436 5318 37 devotedly devotedly RB 40436 5318 38 attached attach VBN 40436 5318 39 to to IN 40436 5318 40 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5318 41 -- -- : 40436 5318 42 and and CC 40436 5318 43 a a DT 40436 5318 44 crowd crowd NN 40436 5318 45 of of IN 40436 5318 46 unnamed unnamed JJ 40436 5318 47 persons person NNS 40436 5318 48 , , , 40436 5318 49 partly partly RB 40436 5318 50 friends friend NNS 40436 5318 51 of of IN 40436 5318 52 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5318 53 , , , 40436 5318 54 partly partly RB 40436 5318 55 admirers admirer NNS 40436 5318 56 and and CC 40436 5318 57 supporters supporter NNS 40436 5318 58 of of IN 40436 5318 59 the the DT 40436 5318 60 two two CD 40436 5318 61 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5318 62 . . . 40436 5319 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5319 2 Side side NN 40436 5319 3 - - HYPH 40436 5319 4 note note NN 40436 5319 5 : : : 40436 5319 6 The the DT 40436 5319 7 two two CD 40436 5319 8 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5319 9 , , , 40436 5319 10 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 5319 11 and and CC 40436 5319 12 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5319 13 : : : 40436 5319 14 manner manner NN 40436 5319 15 in in IN 40436 5319 16 which which WDT 40436 5319 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5319 18 are be VBP 40436 5319 19 here here RB 40436 5319 20 presented present VBN 40436 5319 21 . . . 40436 5319 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5320 1 This this DT 40436 5320 2 couple couple NN 40436 5320 3 are be VBP 40436 5320 4 described describe VBN 40436 5320 5 and and CC 40436 5320 6 treated treat VBN 40436 5320 7 throughout throughout IN 40436 5320 8 by by IN 40436 5320 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5320 10 , , , 40436 5320 11 with with IN 40436 5320 12 the the DT 40436 5320 13 utmost utmost JJ 40436 5320 14 admiration admiration NN 40436 5320 15 and and CC 40436 5320 16 respect respect NN 40436 5320 17 : : : 40436 5320 18 that that RB 40436 5320 19 is is RB 40436 5320 20 , , , 40436 5320 21 in in IN 40436 5320 22 terms term NNS 40436 5320 23 designating designate VBG 40436 5320 24 such such JJ 40436 5320 25 feelings feeling NNS 40436 5320 26 , , , 40436 5320 27 but but CC 40436 5320 28 intended intend VBD 40436 5320 29 as as IN 40436 5320 30 the the DT 40436 5320 31 extreme extreme NN 40436 5320 32 of of IN 40436 5320 33 irony irony NN 40436 5320 34 or or CC 40436 5320 35 caricature caricature NN 40436 5320 36 . . . 40436 5321 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5321 2 are be VBP 40436 5321 3 masters master NNS 40436 5321 4 of of IN 40436 5321 5 the the DT 40436 5321 6 art art NN 40436 5321 7 of of IN 40436 5321 8 Contention Contention NNP 40436 5321 9 , , , 40436 5321 10 in in IN 40436 5321 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5321 12 three three CD 40436 5321 13 varieties[3]--1 varieties[3]--1 NNPS 40436 5321 14 . . . 40436 5322 1 Arms arm NNS 40436 5322 2 , , , 40436 5322 3 and and CC 40436 5322 4 the the DT 40436 5322 5 command command NN 40436 5322 6 of of IN 40436 5322 7 soldiers soldier NNS 40436 5322 8 . . . 40436 5323 1 2 2 LS 40436 5323 2 . . . 40436 5324 1 Judicial judicial JJ 40436 5324 2 and and CC 40436 5324 3 political political JJ 40436 5324 4 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 5324 5 , , , 40436 5324 6 fighting fight VBG 40436 5324 7 an an DT 40436 5324 8 opponent opponent NN 40436 5324 9 before before IN 40436 5324 10 the the DT 40436 5324 11 assembled assemble VBN 40436 5324 12 Dikasts Dikasts NNPS 40436 5324 13 or or CC 40436 5324 14 people people NNS 40436 5324 15 . . . 40436 5325 1 3 3 LS 40436 5325 2 . . . 40436 5326 1 Contentious contentious JJ 40436 5326 2 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 5326 3 -- -- : 40436 5326 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5326 5 can can MD 40436 5326 6 reduce reduce VB 40436 5326 7 every every DT 40436 5326 8 respondent respondent NN 40436 5326 9 to to IN 40436 5326 10 a a DT 40436 5326 11 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 5326 12 , , , 40436 5326 13 if if IN 40436 5326 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5326 15 will will MD 40436 5326 16 only only RB 40436 5326 17 continue continue VB 40436 5326 18 to to TO 40436 5326 19 answer answer VB 40436 5326 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5326 21 questions question NNS 40436 5326 22 -- -- : 40436 5326 23 whether whether IN 40436 5326 24 what what WP 40436 5326 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5326 26 says say VBZ 40436 5326 27 be be VB 40436 5326 28 true true JJ 40436 5326 29 or or CC 40436 5326 30 false false JJ 40436 5326 31 . . . 40436 5327 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5327 2 4 4 LS 40436 5327 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5327 4 All all DT 40436 5327 5 or or CC 40436 5327 6 each each DT 40436 5327 7 of of IN 40436 5327 8 these these DT 40436 5327 9 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 5327 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5327 11 are be VBP 40436 5327 12 prepared prepared JJ 40436 5327 13 to to TO 40436 5327 14 teach teach VB 40436 5327 15 to to IN 40436 5327 16 any any DT 40436 5327 17 pupil pupil NN 40436 5327 18 who who WP 40436 5327 19 will will MD 40436 5327 20 pay pay VB 40436 5327 21 the the DT 40436 5327 22 required require VBN 40436 5327 23 fee fee NN 40436 5327 24 : : : 40436 5327 25 the the DT 40436 5327 26 standing stand VBG 40436 5327 27 sarcasm sarcasm NN 40436 5327 28 of of IN 40436 5327 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5327 30 against against IN 40436 5327 31 the the DT 40436 5327 32 paid pay VBN 40436 5327 33 teacher teacher NN 40436 5327 34 , , , 40436 5327 35 occurring occur VBG 40436 5327 36 here here RB 40436 5327 37 as as IN 40436 5327 38 in in IN 40436 5327 39 so so RB 40436 5327 40 many many JJ 40436 5327 41 other other JJ 40436 5327 42 places place NNS 40436 5327 43 . . . 40436 5328 1 Lastly lastly RB 40436 5328 2 , , , 40436 5328 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5328 4 are be VBP 40436 5328 5 brothers brother NNS 40436 5328 6 , , , 40436 5328 7 old old JJ 40436 5328 8 and and CC 40436 5328 9 almost almost RB 40436 5328 10 toothless toothless JJ 40436 5328 11 -- -- : 40436 5328 12 natives native NNS 40436 5328 13 of of IN 40436 5328 14 Chios chio NNS 40436 5328 15 , , , 40436 5328 16 colonists colonist NNS 40436 5328 17 from from IN 40436 5328 18 thence thence NN 40436 5328 19 to to IN 40436 5328 20 Thurii Thurii NNP 40436 5328 21 , , , 40436 5328 22 and and CC 40436 5328 23 exiles exile NNS 40436 5328 24 from from IN 40436 5328 25 Thurii Thurii NNP 40436 5328 26 and and CC 40436 5328 27 resident resident NN 40436 5328 28 at at IN 40436 5328 29 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5328 30 , , , 40436 5328 31 yet yet RB 40436 5328 32 visiting visit VBG 40436 5328 33 other other JJ 40436 5328 34 cities city NNS 40436 5328 35 for for IN 40436 5328 36 the the DT 40436 5328 37 purpose purpose NN 40436 5328 38 of of IN 40436 5328 39 giving give VBG 40436 5328 40 lessons lesson NNS 40436 5328 41 . . . 40436 5329 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5329 2 5 5 LS 40436 5329 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5329 4 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5329 5 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 5329 6 skill skill NN 40436 5329 7 is be VBZ 40436 5329 8 described describe VBN 40436 5329 9 as as IN 40436 5329 10 a a DT 40436 5329 11 recent recent JJ 40436 5329 12 acquisition,--made acquisition,--made NN 40436 5329 13 during during IN 40436 5329 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5329 15 old old JJ 40436 5329 16 age age NN 40436 5329 17 , , , 40436 5329 18 only only RB 40436 5329 19 in in IN 40436 5329 20 the the DT 40436 5329 21 preceding precede VBG 40436 5329 22 year,--and year,--and NNP 40436 5329 23 completing complete VBG 40436 5329 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5329 25 excellence excellence NN 40436 5329 26 as as IN 40436 5329 27 professors professor NNS 40436 5329 28 of of IN 40436 5329 29 the the DT 40436 5329 30 tripartite tripartite JJ 40436 5329 31 Eristic Eristic NNP 40436 5329 32 . . . 40436 5330 1 But but CC 40436 5330 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5330 3 now now RB 40436 5330 4 devote devote VBP 40436 5330 5 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5330 6 to to IN 40436 5330 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5330 8 more more RBR 40436 5330 9 than than IN 40436 5330 10 to to IN 40436 5330 11 the the DT 40436 5330 12 other other JJ 40436 5330 13 two two CD 40436 5330 14 parts part NNS 40436 5330 15 . . . 40436 5331 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 5331 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5331 3 advertise advertise VBP 40436 5331 4 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5331 5 as as IN 40436 5331 6 teachers teacher NNS 40436 5331 7 of of IN 40436 5331 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 5331 9 . . . 40436 5332 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5332 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5332 3 3 3 CD 40436 5332 4 : : : 40436 5332 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5332 6 , , , 40436 5332 7 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 5332 8 . . . 40436 5333 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5333 2 . . . 40436 5334 1 271 271 CD 40436 5334 2 - - SYM 40436 5334 3 272 272 CD 40436 5334 4 . . . 40436 5334 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5335 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5335 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5335 3 4 4 CD 40436 5335 4 : : : 40436 5335 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5335 6 . . . 40436 5336 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5336 2 . . . 40436 5337 1 p. p. NN 40436 5337 2 272 272 CD 40436 5337 3 B. B. NNP 40436 5338 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5338 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5338 3 : : : 40436 5338 4 e)xele e)xele CD 40436 5338 5 / / SYM 40436 5338 6 gchein gchein NNP 40436 5338 7 to\ to\ NN 40436 5338 8 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 5338 9 lego lego NNP 40436 5338 10 / / SYM 40436 5338 11 menon menon NNP 40436 5338 12 , , , 40436 5338 13 o(moi o(moi NNP 40436 5338 14 / / SYM 40436 5338 15 ôs ôs NNP 40436 5338 16 e)a e)a NNP 40436 5338 17 / / SYM 40436 5338 18 n n CD 40436 5338 19 te te NNP 40436 5338 20 pseu pseu NNS 40436 5338 21 = = SYM 40436 5338 22 dos dos NNP 40436 5338 23 e)a e)a NNP 40436 5338 24 / / SYM 40436 5338 25 n n NN 40436 5338 26 t t NN 40436 5338 27 ' ' POS 40436 5338 28 a)lêthe\s a)lêthe\s NNP 40436 5338 29 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 5338 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5338 31 : : : 40436 5338 32 p. p. NN 40436 5338 33 275 275 CD 40436 5338 34 C. C. NNP 40436 5338 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5338 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5338 37 : : : 40436 5338 38 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 5338 39 diaphe diaphe NNP 40436 5338 40 / / SYM 40436 5338 41 rei rei JJ 40436 5338 42 , , , 40436 5338 43 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 5338 44 mo mo UH 40436 5338 45 / / SYM 40436 5338 46 non non AFX 40436 5338 47 e)the e)the NN 40436 5338 48 / / SYM 40436 5338 49 lê| lê| NNP 40436 5338 50 a)pokri a)pokri NNP 40436 5338 51 / / SYM 40436 5338 52 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 5338 53 o o NNP 40436 5338 54 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5338 55 neani neani NNP 40436 5338 56 / / SYM 40436 5338 57 skos skos NNP 40436 5338 58 . . . 40436 5338 59 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5338 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5339 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5339 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5339 3 5 5 CD 40436 5339 4 : : : 40436 5339 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5339 6 . . . 40436 5340 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5340 2 . . . 40436 5341 1 p. p. NN 40436 5341 2 273 273 CD 40436 5341 3 B B NNP 40436 5341 4 - - HYPH 40436 5341 5 C. C. NNP 40436 5341 6 " " '' 40436 5341 7 quamvis quamvis NNP 40436 5341 8 essent essent NN 40436 5341 9 ætate ætate NN 40436 5341 10 grandiores grandiore NNS 40436 5341 11 et et NNP 40436 5341 12 _ _ NNP 40436 5341 13 edentuli edentuli NN 40436 5341 14 _ _ NNP 40436 5341 15 " " '' 40436 5341 16 says say VBZ 40436 5341 17 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5341 18 in in IN 40436 5341 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5341 20 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 5341 21 . . . 40436 5342 1 p. p. NN 40436 5342 2 10 10 CD 40436 5342 3 . . . 40436 5343 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5343 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 5343 3 to to TO 40436 5343 4 infer infer VB 40436 5343 5 this this DT 40436 5343 6 from from IN 40436 5343 7 page page NN 40436 5343 8 294 294 CD 40436 5343 9 C C NNP 40436 5343 10 ; ; : 40436 5343 11 the the DT 40436 5343 12 inference inference NN 40436 5343 13 , , , 40436 5343 14 though though IN 40436 5343 15 not not RB 40436 5343 16 very very RB 40436 5343 17 certain certain JJ 40436 5343 18 , , , 40436 5343 19 is be VBZ 40436 5343 20 plausible plausible JJ 40436 5343 21 . . . 40436 5344 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 5344 2 , , , 40436 5344 3 in in IN 40436 5344 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5344 5 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 5344 6 zum zum NN 40436 5344 7 Euthydemos Euthydemos NNP 40436 5344 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5344 9 vol vol NNP 40436 5344 10 . . . 40436 5345 1 ii ii LS 40436 5345 2 . . . 40436 5346 1 p. p. NN 40436 5346 2 2 2 CD 40436 5346 3 of of IN 40436 5346 4 Hieronym Hieronym NNP 40436 5346 5 . . . 40436 5347 1 Müller Müller NNP 40436 5347 2 's 's POS 40436 5347 3 translation translation NN 40436 5347 4 of of IN 40436 5347 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5347 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5347 7 repeats repeat VBZ 40436 5347 8 these these DT 40436 5347 9 antecedents antecedent NNS 40436 5347 10 of of IN 40436 5347 11 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 5347 12 and and CC 40436 5347 13 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5347 14 , , , 40436 5347 15 as as IN 40436 5347 16 recited recite VBN 40436 5347 17 in in IN 40436 5347 18 the the DT 40436 5347 19 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5347 20 before before IN 40436 5347 21 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5347 22 , , , 40436 5347 23 as as IN 40436 5347 24 if if IN 40436 5347 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5347 26 were be VBD 40436 5347 27 matter matter NN 40436 5347 28 of of IN 40436 5347 29 real real JJ 40436 5347 30 history history NN 40436 5347 31 , , , 40436 5347 32 exemplifications exemplification NNS 40436 5347 33 of of IN 40436 5347 34 the the DT 40436 5347 35 character character NN 40436 5347 36 of of IN 40436 5347 37 the the DT 40436 5347 38 class class NN 40436 5347 39 called call VBN 40436 5347 40 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5347 41 . . . 40436 5348 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5348 2 might may MD 40436 5348 3 just just RB 40436 5348 4 as as RB 40436 5348 5 well well RB 40436 5348 6 produce produce VB 40436 5348 7 what what WP 40436 5348 8 is be VBZ 40436 5348 9 said say VBN 40436 5348 10 by by IN 40436 5348 11 the the DT 40436 5348 12 comic comic JJ 40436 5348 13 poets poet NNS 40436 5348 14 Eupolis Eupolis NNP 40436 5348 15 and and CC 40436 5348 16 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40436 5348 17 -- -- : 40436 5348 18 the the DT 40436 5348 19 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 5348 20 as as IN 40436 5348 21 recounted recount VBN 40436 5348 22 by by IN 40436 5348 23 the the DT 40436 5348 24 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 5348 25 disciple disciple NN 40436 5348 26 in in IN 40436 5348 27 the the DT 40436 5348 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5348 29 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5348 30 : : : 40436 5348 31 phrontistê phrontistê JJ 40436 5348 32 / / SYM 40436 5348 33 rion rion NN 40436 5348 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5348 35 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5348 36 Nubes)--as nubes)--as DT 40436 5348 37 evidence evidence NN 40436 5348 38 about about IN 40436 5348 39 the the DT 40436 5348 40 character character NN 40436 5348 41 of of IN 40436 5348 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5348 43 . . . 40436 5348 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5349 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5349 2 Side side NN 40436 5349 3 - - HYPH 40436 5349 4 note note NN 40436 5349 5 : : : 40436 5349 6 Conversation conversation NN 40436 5349 7 carried carry VBD 40436 5349 8 on on RP 40436 5349 9 with with IN 40436 5349 10 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5349 11 , , , 40436 5349 12 first first RB 40436 5349 13 by by IN 40436 5349 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5349 15 , , , 40436 5349 16 next next RB 40436 5349 17 by by IN 40436 5349 18 the the DT 40436 5349 19 two two CD 40436 5349 20 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5349 21 . . . 40436 5349 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5350 1 The the DT 40436 5350 2 two two CD 40436 5350 3 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5350 4 , , , 40436 5350 5 having have VBG 40436 5350 6 announced announce VBN 40436 5350 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5350 8 as as IN 40436 5350 9 competent competent JJ 40436 5350 10 to to TO 40436 5350 11 teach teach VB 40436 5350 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 5350 13 and and CC 40436 5350 14 stimulate stimulate VB 40436 5350 15 pupils pupil NNS 40436 5350 16 to to IN 40436 5350 17 a a DT 40436 5350 18 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 5350 19 life life NN 40436 5350 20 , , , 40436 5350 21 are be VBP 40436 5350 22 entreated entreat VBN 40436 5350 23 by by IN 40436 5350 24 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5350 25 to to TO 40436 5350 26 exercise exercise VB 40436 5350 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5350 28 beneficent beneficent JJ 40436 5350 29 influence influence NN 40436 5350 30 upon upon IN 40436 5350 31 the the DT 40436 5350 32 youth youth NN 40436 5350 33 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5350 34 , , , 40436 5350 35 in in IN 40436 5350 36 whose whose WP$ 40436 5350 37 improvement improvement NN 40436 5350 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5350 39 as as RB 40436 5350 40 well well RB 40436 5350 41 as as IN 40436 5350 42 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 5350 43 feels feel VBZ 40436 5350 44 the the DT 40436 5350 45 warmest warm JJS 40436 5350 46 interest interest NN 40436 5350 47 . . . 40436 5351 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5351 2 gives give VBZ 40436 5351 3 a a DT 40436 5351 4 specimen speciman NNS 40436 5351 5 of of IN 40436 5351 6 what what WP 40436 5351 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5351 8 wishes wish VBZ 40436 5351 9 by by IN 40436 5351 10 putting put VBG 40436 5351 11 a a DT 40436 5351 12 series series NN 40436 5351 13 of of IN 40436 5351 14 questions question NNS 40436 5351 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5351 16 . . . 40436 5352 1 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5352 2 follows follow VBZ 40436 5352 3 , , , 40436 5352 4 and and CC 40436 5352 5 begins begin VBZ 40436 5352 6 questioning question VBG 40436 5352 7 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5352 8 ; ; : 40436 5352 9 who who WP 40436 5352 10 , , , 40436 5352 11 after after IN 40436 5352 12 answering answer VBG 40436 5352 13 three three CD 40436 5352 14 or or CC 40436 5352 15 four four CD 40436 5352 16 successive successive JJ 40436 5352 17 questions question NNS 40436 5352 18 , , , 40436 5352 19 is be VBZ 40436 5352 20 forced force VBN 40436 5352 21 to to TO 40436 5352 22 contradict contradict VB 40436 5352 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5352 24 . . . 40436 5353 1 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5353 2 then then RB 40436 5353 3 takes take VBZ 40436 5353 4 up up RP 40436 5353 5 the the DT 40436 5353 6 last last JJ 40436 5353 7 answer answer NN 40436 5353 8 of of IN 40436 5353 9 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5353 10 , , , 40436 5353 11 puts put VBZ 40436 5353 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5353 13 through through IN 40436 5353 14 another another DT 40436 5353 15 series series NN 40436 5353 16 of of IN 40436 5353 17 interrogations interrogation NNS 40436 5353 18 , , , 40436 5353 19 and and CC 40436 5353 20 makes make VBZ 40436 5353 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5353 22 contradict contradict VB 40436 5353 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5353 24 again again RB 40436 5353 25 . . . 40436 5354 1 In in IN 40436 5354 2 this this DT 40436 5354 3 manner manner NN 40436 5354 4 the the DT 40436 5354 5 two two CD 40436 5354 6 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5354 7 toss toss VBP 40436 5354 8 the the DT 40436 5354 9 youthful youthful JJ 40436 5354 10 respondent respondent NN 40436 5354 11 backwards backwards RB 40436 5354 12 and and CC 40436 5354 13 forwards forwards RB 40436 5354 14 to to IN 40436 5354 15 each each DT 40436 5354 16 other other JJ 40436 5354 17 , , , 40436 5354 18 each each DT 40436 5354 19 contriving contrive VBG 40436 5354 20 to to TO 40436 5354 21 entangle entangle VB 40436 5354 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5354 23 in in IN 40436 5354 24 some some DT 40436 5354 25 puzzle puzzle NN 40436 5354 26 and and CC 40436 5354 27 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 5354 28 . . . 40436 5355 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5355 2 even even RB 40436 5355 3 apply apply VBP 40436 5355 4 the the DT 40436 5355 5 same same JJ 40436 5355 6 process process NN 40436 5355 7 to to IN 40436 5355 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5355 9 , , , 40436 5355 10 who who WP 40436 5355 11 can can MD 40436 5355 12 not not RB 40436 5355 13 avoid avoid VB 40436 5355 14 being be VBG 40436 5355 15 entangled entangle VBN 40436 5355 16 in in IN 40436 5355 17 the the DT 40436 5355 18 net net NN 40436 5355 19 ; ; : 40436 5355 20 and and CC 40436 5355 21 to to IN 40436 5355 22 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 5355 23 , , , 40436 5355 24 who who WP 40436 5355 25 becomes become VBZ 40436 5355 26 exasperated exasperate VBN 40436 5355 27 , , , 40436 5355 28 and and CC 40436 5355 29 retorts retort NNS 40436 5355 30 upon upon IN 40436 5355 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5355 32 with with IN 40436 5355 33 contemptuous contemptuous JJ 40436 5355 34 asperity asperity NN 40436 5355 35 . . . 40436 5356 1 The the DT 40436 5356 2 alternate alternate JJ 40436 5356 3 interference interference NN 40436 5356 4 of of IN 40436 5356 5 the the DT 40436 5356 6 two two CD 40436 5356 7 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5356 8 is be VBZ 40436 5356 9 described describe VBN 40436 5356 10 with with IN 40436 5356 11 great great JJ 40436 5356 12 smartness smartness NN 40436 5356 13 and and CC 40436 5356 14 animation animation NN 40436 5356 15 ; ; : 40436 5356 16 which which WDT 40436 5356 17 is be VBZ 40436 5356 18 promoted promote VBN 40436 5356 19 by by IN 40436 5356 20 the the DT 40436 5356 21 use use NN 40436 5356 22 of of IN 40436 5356 23 the the DT 40436 5356 24 dual dual JJ 40436 5356 25 number number NN 40436 5356 26 , , , 40436 5356 27 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 5356 28 to to IN 40436 5356 29 the the DT 40436 5356 30 Greek greek JJ 40436 5356 31 language language NN 40436 5356 32 , , , 40436 5356 33 employed employ VBN 40436 5356 34 by by IN 40436 5356 35 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5356 36 in in IN 40436 5356 37 speaking speak VBG 40436 5356 38 of of IN 40436 5356 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5356 40 . . . 40436 5357 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5357 2 Side side NN 40436 5357 3 - - HYPH 40436 5357 4 note note NN 40436 5357 5 : : : 40436 5357 6 Contrast contrast NN 40436 5357 7 between between IN 40436 5357 8 the the DT 40436 5357 9 two two CD 40436 5357 10 different different JJ 40436 5357 11 modes mode NNS 40436 5357 12 of of IN 40436 5357 13 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 5357 14 . . . 40436 5357 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5358 1 This this DT 40436 5358 2 mode mode NN 40436 5358 3 of of IN 40436 5358 4 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 5358 5 , , , 40436 5358 6 conducted conduct VBN 40436 5358 7 by by IN 40436 5358 8 the the DT 40436 5358 9 two two CD 40436 5358 10 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5358 11 , , , 40436 5358 12 is be VBZ 40436 5358 13 interrupted interrupt VBN 40436 5358 14 on on IN 40436 5358 15 two two CD 40436 5358 16 several several JJ 40436 5358 17 occasions occasion NNS 40436 5358 18 by by IN 40436 5358 19 a a DT 40436 5358 20 counter counter NN 40436 5358 21 - - NN 40436 5358 22 exhibition exhibition NN 40436 5358 23 of of IN 40436 5358 24 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 5358 25 on on IN 40436 5358 26 the the DT 40436 5358 27 part part NN 40436 5358 28 of of IN 40436 5358 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5358 30 : : : 40436 5358 31 who who WP 40436 5358 32 , , , 40436 5358 33 under under IN 40436 5358 34 colour colour NN 40436 5358 35 of of IN 40436 5358 36 again again RB 40436 5358 37 showing show VBG 40436 5358 38 to to IN 40436 5358 39 the the DT 40436 5358 40 couple couple NN 40436 5358 41 a a DT 40436 5358 42 specimen speciman NNS 40436 5358 43 of of IN 40436 5358 44 that that DT 40436 5358 45 which which WDT 40436 5358 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5358 47 wishes wish VBZ 40436 5358 48 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5358 49 to to TO 40436 5358 50 do do VB 40436 5358 51 , , , 40436 5358 52 puts put VBZ 40436 5358 53 two two CD 40436 5358 54 successive successive JJ 40436 5358 55 batches batch NNS 40436 5358 56 of of IN 40436 5358 57 questions question NNS 40436 5358 58 to to IN 40436 5358 59 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5358 60 in in IN 40436 5358 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5358 62 own own JJ 40436 5358 63 manner manner NN 40436 5358 64 . . . 40436 5359 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5359 2 6 6 CD 40436 5359 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5359 4 The the DT 40436 5359 5 contrast contrast NN 40436 5359 6 between between IN 40436 5359 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5359 8 and and CC 40436 5359 9 the the DT 40436 5359 10 two two CD 40436 5359 11 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5359 12 , , , 40436 5359 13 in in IN 40436 5359 14 the the DT 40436 5359 15 same same JJ 40436 5359 16 work work NN 40436 5359 17 , , , 40436 5359 18 carried carry VBN 40436 5359 19 on on RP 40436 5359 20 respectively respectively RB 40436 5359 21 by by IN 40436 5359 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5359 23 and and CC 40436 5359 24 by by IN 40436 5359 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5359 26 , , , 40436 5359 27 of of IN 40436 5359 28 interrogating interrogate VBG 40436 5359 29 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5359 30 , , , 40436 5359 31 is be VBZ 40436 5359 32 evidently evidently RB 40436 5359 33 meant mean VBN 40436 5359 34 as as IN 40436 5359 35 one one CD 40436 5359 36 of of IN 40436 5359 37 the the DT 40436 5359 38 special special JJ 40436 5359 39 matters matter NNS 40436 5359 40 to to TO 40436 5359 41 arrest arrest VB 40436 5359 42 attention attention NN 40436 5359 43 in in IN 40436 5359 44 the the DT 40436 5359 45 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5359 46 . . . 40436 5360 1 The the DT 40436 5360 2 questions question NNS 40436 5360 3 put put VBN 40436 5360 4 by by IN 40436 5360 5 the the DT 40436 5360 6 couple couple NN 40436 5360 7 are be VBP 40436 5360 8 made make VBN 40436 5360 9 to to TO 40436 5360 10 turn turn VB 40436 5360 11 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 5360 12 on on IN 40436 5360 13 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5360 14 quibbles quibble NNS 40436 5360 15 and and CC 40436 5360 16 ambiguities ambiguity NNS 40436 5360 17 : : : 40436 5360 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5360 19 are be VBP 40436 5360 20 purposely purposely RB 40436 5360 21 designed design VBN 40436 5360 22 to to TO 40436 5360 23 make make VB 40436 5360 24 the the DT 40436 5360 25 respondent respondent NN 40436 5360 26 contradict contradict VB 40436 5360 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5360 28 , , , 40436 5360 29 and and CC 40436 5360 30 are be VBP 40436 5360 31 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 5360 32 to to TO 40436 5360 33 be be VB 40436 5360 34 certain certain JJ 40436 5360 35 of of IN 40436 5360 36 bringing bring VBG 40436 5360 37 about about RP 40436 5360 38 this this DT 40436 5360 39 result result NN 40436 5360 40 , , , 40436 5360 41 provided provide VBD 40436 5360 42 the the DT 40436 5360 43 respondent respondent NN 40436 5360 44 will will MD 40436 5360 45 conform conform VB 40436 5360 46 to to IN 40436 5360 47 the the DT 40436 5360 48 laws law NNS 40436 5360 49 of of IN 40436 5360 50 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 5360 51 -- -- : 40436 5360 52 by by IN 40436 5360 53 confining confine VBG 40436 5360 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5360 55 answer answer NN 40436 5360 56 to to IN 40436 5360 57 the the DT 40436 5360 58 special special JJ 40436 5360 59 point point NN 40436 5360 60 of of IN 40436 5360 61 the the DT 40436 5360 62 question question NN 40436 5360 63 , , , 40436 5360 64 without without IN 40436 5360 65 adding add VBG 40436 5360 66 any any DT 40436 5360 67 qualification qualification NN 40436 5360 68 of of IN 40436 5360 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5360 70 own own JJ 40436 5360 71 , , , 40436 5360 72 or or CC 40436 5360 73 asking ask VBG 40436 5360 74 for for IN 40436 5360 75 farther farther JJ 40436 5360 76 explanation explanation NN 40436 5360 77 from from IN 40436 5360 78 the the DT 40436 5360 79 questioner questioner NN 40436 5360 80 , , , 40436 5360 81 or or CC 40436 5360 82 reverting revert VBG 40436 5360 83 to to IN 40436 5360 84 any any DT 40436 5360 85 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 5360 86 answer answer NN 40436 5360 87 lying lie VBG 40436 5360 88 apart apart RB 40436 5360 89 from from IN 40436 5360 90 the the DT 40436 5360 91 actual actual JJ 40436 5360 92 question question NN 40436 5360 93 of of IN 40436 5360 94 the the DT 40436 5360 95 moment moment NN 40436 5360 96 . . . 40436 5361 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5361 2 7 7 CD 40436 5361 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5361 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5361 5 , , , 40436 5361 6 on on IN 40436 5361 7 the the DT 40436 5361 8 contrary contrary NN 40436 5361 9 , , , 40436 5361 10 addresses address VBZ 40436 5361 11 interrogations interrogation NNS 40436 5361 12 , , , 40436 5361 13 each each DT 40436 5361 14 of of IN 40436 5361 15 which which WDT 40436 5361 16 has have VBZ 40436 5361 17 a a DT 40436 5361 18 clear clear JJ 40436 5361 19 and and CC 40436 5361 20 substantive substantive JJ 40436 5361 21 meaning meaning NN 40436 5361 22 , , , 40436 5361 23 and and CC 40436 5361 24 most most JJS 40436 5361 25 of of IN 40436 5361 26 which which WDT 40436 5361 27 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5361 28 is be VBZ 40436 5361 29 able able JJ 40436 5361 30 to to TO 40436 5361 31 answer answer VB 40436 5361 32 without without IN 40436 5361 33 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 5361 34 : : : 40436 5361 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5361 36 professes profess VBZ 40436 5361 37 no no DT 40436 5361 38 other other JJ 40436 5361 39 design design NN 40436 5361 40 except except IN 40436 5361 41 that that DT 40436 5361 42 of of IN 40436 5361 43 encouraging encourage VBG 40436 5361 44 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5361 45 to to TO 40436 5361 46 virtue virtue VB 40436 5361 47 , , , 40436 5361 48 and and CC 40436 5361 49 assisting assist VBG 40436 5361 50 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5361 51 to to TO 40436 5361 52 determine determine VB 40436 5361 53 in in IN 40436 5361 54 what what WDT 40436 5361 55 virtue virtue NN 40436 5361 56 consists consist VBZ 40436 5361 57 : : : 40436 5361 58 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5361 59 resorts resort VBZ 40436 5361 60 to to IN 40436 5361 61 no no DT 40436 5361 62 known know VBN 40436 5361 63 quibbles quibble NNS 40436 5361 64 or or CC 40436 5361 65 words word NNS 40436 5361 66 of of IN 40436 5361 67 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 5361 68 import import NN 40436 5361 69 . . . 40436 5362 1 The the DT 40436 5362 2 effect effect NN 40436 5362 3 of of IN 40436 5362 4 the the DT 40436 5362 5 interrogations interrogation NNS 40436 5362 6 is be VBZ 40436 5362 7 represented represent VBN 40436 5362 8 as as IN 40436 5362 9 being be VBG 40436 5362 10 , , , 40436 5362 11 not not RB 40436 5362 12 to to TO 40436 5362 13 confound confound VB 40436 5362 14 and and CC 40436 5362 15 silence silence VB 40436 5362 16 the the DT 40436 5362 17 youth youth NN 40436 5362 18 , , , 40436 5362 19 but but CC 40436 5362 20 to to TO 40436 5362 21 quicken quicken VB 40436 5362 22 and and CC 40436 5362 23 stimulate stimulate VB 40436 5362 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5362 25 mind mind NN 40436 5362 26 and and CC 40436 5362 27 to to TO 40436 5362 28 call call VB 40436 5362 29 forth forth RP 40436 5362 30 an an DT 40436 5362 31 unexpected unexpected JJ 40436 5362 32 amount amount NN 40436 5362 33 of of IN 40436 5362 34 latent latent JJ 40436 5362 35 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5362 36 : : : 40436 5362 37 insomuch insomuch NN 40436 5362 38 that that IN 40436 5362 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5362 40 makes make VBZ 40436 5362 41 one one CD 40436 5362 42 or or CC 40436 5362 43 two two CD 40436 5362 44 answers answer NNS 40436 5362 45 very very RB 40436 5362 46 much much RB 40436 5362 47 beyond beyond IN 40436 5362 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5362 49 years year NNS 40436 5362 50 , , , 40436 5362 51 exciting excite VBG 40436 5362 52 the the DT 40436 5362 53 greatest great JJS 40436 5362 54 astonishment astonishment NN 40436 5362 55 and and CC 40436 5362 56 admiration admiration NN 40436 5362 57 , , , 40436 5362 58 in in IN 40436 5362 59 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5362 60 as as RB 40436 5362 61 well well RB 40436 5362 62 as as IN 40436 5362 63 in in IN 40436 5362 64 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5362 65 . . . 40436 5363 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5363 2 8 8 CD 40436 5363 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5363 4 In in IN 40436 5363 5 this this DT 40436 5363 6 respect respect NN 40436 5363 7 , , , 40436 5363 8 the the DT 40436 5363 9 youth youth NN 40436 5363 10 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5363 11 serves serve VBZ 40436 5363 12 the the DT 40436 5363 13 same same JJ 40436 5363 14 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 5363 15 purpose purpose NN 40436 5363 16 as as IN 40436 5363 17 the the DT 40436 5363 18 youthful youthful JJ 40436 5363 19 slave slave NN 40436 5363 20 in in IN 40436 5363 21 the the DT 40436 5363 22 Menon:[9 menon:[9 NN 40436 5363 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5363 24 each each DT 40436 5363 25 is be VBZ 40436 5363 26 supposed suppose VBN 40436 5363 27 to to TO 40436 5363 28 be be VB 40436 5363 29 quickened quicken VBN 40436 5363 30 by by IN 40436 5363 31 the the DT 40436 5363 32 interrogatory interrogatory NN 40436 5363 33 of of IN 40436 5363 34 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5363 35 , , , 40436 5363 36 into into IN 40436 5363 37 a a DT 40436 5363 38 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 5363 39 of of IN 40436 5363 40 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5363 41 noway noway RB 40436 5363 42 expected expect VBD 40436 5363 43 , , , 40436 5363 44 nor nor CC 40436 5363 45 traceable traceable JJ 40436 5363 46 to to IN 40436 5363 47 any any DT 40436 5363 48 teaching teaching NN 40436 5363 49 . . . 40436 5364 1 But but CC 40436 5364 2 in in IN 40436 5364 3 the the DT 40436 5364 4 Menon Menon NNP 40436 5364 5 , , , 40436 5364 6 this this DT 40436 5364 7 magical magical JJ 40436 5364 8 evocation evocation NN 40436 5364 9 of of IN 40436 5364 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5364 11 from from IN 40436 5364 12 an an DT 40436 5364 13 untaught untaught JJ 40436 5364 14 youth youth NN 40436 5364 15 is be VBZ 40436 5364 16 explained explain VBN 40436 5364 17 by by IN 40436 5364 18 the the DT 40436 5364 19 theory theory NN 40436 5364 20 of of IN 40436 5364 21 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 5364 22 , , , 40436 5364 23 pre pre NN 40436 5364 24 - - NN 40436 5364 25 existence existence NN 40436 5364 26 , , , 40436 5364 27 and and CC 40436 5364 28 omniscience omniscience NN 40436 5364 29 , , , 40436 5364 30 of of IN 40436 5364 31 the the DT 40436 5364 32 soul soul NN 40436 5364 33 : : : 40436 5364 34 while while IN 40436 5364 35 in in IN 40436 5364 36 the the DT 40436 5364 37 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5364 38 , , , 40436 5364 39 no no DT 40436 5364 40 allusion allusion NN 40436 5364 41 is be VBZ 40436 5364 42 made make VBN 40436 5364 43 to to IN 40436 5364 44 any any DT 40436 5364 45 such such JJ 40436 5364 46 theory theory NN 40436 5364 47 , , , 40436 5364 48 nor nor CC 40436 5364 49 to to IN 40436 5364 50 any any DT 40436 5364 51 other other JJ 40436 5364 52 cause cause NN 40436 5364 53 except except IN 40436 5364 54 the the DT 40436 5364 55 stimulus stimulus NN 40436 5364 56 of of IN 40436 5364 57 the the DT 40436 5364 58 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 5364 59 cross cross NN 40436 5364 60 - - NN 40436 5364 61 questioning questioning NN 40436 5364 62 . . . 40436 5365 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5365 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5365 3 6 6 CD 40436 5365 4 : : : 40436 5365 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5365 6 . . . 40436 5366 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5366 2 . . . 40436 5367 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5367 2 . . . 40436 5368 1 279 279 CD 40436 5368 2 - - SYM 40436 5368 3 288 288 CD 40436 5368 4 . . . 40436 5368 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5369 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5369 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5369 3 7 7 CD 40436 5369 4 : : : 40436 5369 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5369 6 . . . 40436 5370 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5370 2 . . . 40436 5371 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5371 2 . . . 40436 5372 1 275 275 CD 40436 5372 2 E--276 e--276 SYM 40436 5372 3 E. E. NNP 40436 5372 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5372 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5372 6 : : : 40436 5372 7 Pa Pa NNP 40436 5372 8 / / SYM 40436 5372 9 nta nta NNP 40436 5372 10 toiau toiau NNP 40436 5372 11 = = SYM 40436 5372 12 ta ta NNP 40436 5372 13 ê(mei ê(mei NNP 40436 5372 14 = = SYM 40436 5372 15 s s NNP 40436 5372 16 e)rôtô e)rôtô NNP 40436 5372 17 = = SYM 40436 5372 18 men man NNS 40436 5372 19 a)/phukta a)/phukta NNP 40436 5372 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5372 21 , , , 40436 5372 22 pp pp NNP 40436 5372 23 . . . 40436 5373 1 287 287 CD 40436 5373 2 B--295 b--295 SYM 40436 5373 3 B--296 B--296 : 40436 5373 4 A a NN 40436 5373 5 , , , 40436 5373 6 & & CC 40436 5373 7 c. c. NN 40436 5373 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5373 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5373 10 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5373 11 8 8 CD 40436 5373 12 : : : 40436 5373 13 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5373 14 . . . 40436 5374 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5374 2 . . . 40436 5375 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5375 2 . . . 40436 5376 1 290 290 CD 40436 5376 2 - - SYM 40436 5376 3 291 291 CD 40436 5376 4 . . . 40436 5377 1 The the DT 40436 5377 2 unexpected unexpected JJ 40436 5377 3 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5377 4 , , , 40436 5377 5 exhibited exhibit VBN 40436 5377 6 by by IN 40436 5377 7 the the DT 40436 5377 8 youth youth NN 40436 5377 9 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5377 10 in in IN 40436 5377 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5377 12 concluding concluding NN 40436 5377 13 answer answer NN 40436 5377 14 , , , 40436 5377 15 can can MD 40436 5377 16 be be VB 40436 5377 17 understood understand VBN 40436 5377 18 only only RB 40436 5377 19 as as IN 40436 5377 20 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 5377 21 the the DT 40436 5377 22 obstetric obstetric JJ 40436 5377 23 efficacy efficacy NN 40436 5377 24 of of IN 40436 5377 25 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 5377 26 interrogations interrogation NNS 40436 5377 27 . . . 40436 5378 1 See see VB 40436 5378 2 Winckelmann Winckelmann NNP 40436 5378 3 , , , 40436 5378 4 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 5378 5 . . . 40436 5379 1 ad ad NN 40436 5379 2 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 5379 3 . . . 40436 5380 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5380 2 . . . 40436 5381 1 xxxiii xxxiii NNP 40436 5381 2 . . . 40436 5382 1 xxxiv xxxiv NNP 40436 5382 2 . . . 40436 5383 1 The the DT 40436 5383 2 words word NNS 40436 5383 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5383 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5383 5 : : : 40436 5383 6 tô tô NNP 40436 5383 7 = = SYM 40436 5383 8 n n NNP 40436 5383 9 kreitto kreitto NNP 40436 5383 10 / / SYM 40436 5383 11 nôn nôn NNP 40436 5383 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5383 13 must must MD 40436 5383 14 have have VB 40436 5383 15 the the DT 40436 5383 16 usual usual JJ 40436 5383 17 signification signification NN 40436 5383 18 , , , 40436 5383 19 as as IN 40436 5383 20 recognised recognise VBN 40436 5383 21 by by IN 40436 5383 22 Routh Routh NNP 40436 5383 23 and and CC 40436 5383 24 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 5383 25 , , , 40436 5383 26 though though IN 40436 5383 27 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5383 28 treats treat VBZ 40436 5383 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5383 30 as as IN 40436 5383 31 absurd absurd JJ 40436 5383 32 , , , 40436 5383 33 p. p. NN 40436 5383 34 552 552 CD 40436 5383 35 , , , 40436 5383 36 notes note NNS 40436 5383 37 . . . 40436 5383 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5384 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5384 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5384 3 9 9 CD 40436 5384 4 : : : 40436 5384 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5384 6 , , , 40436 5384 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 5384 8 , , , 40436 5384 9 pp pp NNP 40436 5384 10 . . . 40436 5385 1 82 82 CD 40436 5385 2 - - SYM 40436 5385 3 85 85 CD 40436 5385 4 . . . 40436 5385 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5386 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5386 2 Side side NN 40436 5386 3 - - HYPH 40436 5386 4 note note NN 40436 5386 5 : : : 40436 5386 6 Wherein wherein WRB 40436 5386 7 this this DT 40436 5386 8 contrast contrast NN 40436 5386 9 does do VBZ 40436 5386 10 not not RB 40436 5386 11 consist consist VB 40436 5386 12 . . . 40436 5386 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5387 1 In in IN 40436 5387 2 the the DT 40436 5387 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5387 4 _ _ NNP 40436 5387 5 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5387 6 _ _ NNP 40436 5387 7 , , , 40436 5387 8 then then RB 40436 5387 9 , , , 40436 5387 10 one one CD 40436 5387 11 main main JJ 40436 5387 12 purpose purpose NN 40436 5387 13 of of IN 40436 5387 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5387 15 is be VBZ 40436 5387 16 to to TO 40436 5387 17 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 5387 18 in in IN 40436 5387 19 contrast contrast NN 40436 5387 20 two two CD 40436 5387 21 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5387 22 modes mode NNS 40436 5387 23 of of IN 40436 5387 24 questioning question VBG 40436 5387 25 : : : 40436 5387 26 one one CD 40436 5387 27 practised practise VBN 40436 5387 28 by by IN 40436 5387 29 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 5387 30 and and CC 40436 5387 31 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5387 32 ; ; : 40436 5387 33 the the DT 40436 5387 34 other other JJ 40436 5387 35 , , , 40436 5387 36 by by IN 40436 5387 37 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5387 38 . . . 40436 5388 1 Of of IN 40436 5388 2 these these DT 40436 5388 3 two two CD 40436 5388 4 , , , 40436 5388 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5388 6 is be VBZ 40436 5388 7 the the DT 40436 5388 8 first first JJ 40436 5388 9 which which WDT 40436 5388 10 is be VBZ 40436 5388 11 shown show VBN 40436 5388 12 up up RP 40436 5388 13 in in IN 40436 5388 14 the the DT 40436 5388 15 most most RBS 40436 5388 16 copious copious JJ 40436 5388 17 and and CC 40436 5388 18 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 5388 19 manner manner NN 40436 5388 20 : : : 40436 5388 21 the the DT 40436 5388 22 second second JJ 40436 5388 23 is be VBZ 40436 5388 24 made make VBN 40436 5388 25 subordinate subordinate JJ 40436 5388 26 , , , 40436 5388 27 serving serve VBG 40436 5388 28 mainly mainly RB 40436 5388 29 as as IN 40436 5388 30 a a DT 40436 5388 31 standard standard NN 40436 5388 32 of of IN 40436 5388 33 comparison comparison NN 40436 5388 34 with with IN 40436 5388 35 the the DT 40436 5388 36 first first JJ 40436 5388 37 . . . 40436 5389 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5389 2 must must MD 40436 5389 3 take take VB 40436 5389 4 care care NN 40436 5389 5 however however RB 40436 5389 6 to to TO 40436 5389 7 understand understand VB 40436 5389 8 in in IN 40436 5389 9 what what WP 40436 5389 10 the the DT 40436 5389 11 contrast contrast NN 40436 5389 12 between between IN 40436 5389 13 the the DT 40436 5389 14 two two CD 40436 5389 15 consists consist NNS 40436 5389 16 , , , 40436 5389 17 and and CC 40436 5389 18 in in IN 40436 5389 19 what what WP 40436 5389 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5389 21 does do VBZ 40436 5389 22 not not RB 40436 5389 23 consist consist VB 40436 5389 24 . . . 40436 5390 1 The the DT 40436 5390 2 contrast contrast NN 40436 5390 3 does do VBZ 40436 5390 4 not not RB 40436 5390 5 consist consist VB 40436 5390 6 in in IN 40436 5390 7 this this DT 40436 5390 8 -- -- : 40436 5390 9 that that IN 40436 5390 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5390 11 so so RB 40436 5390 12 contrives contrive VBZ 40436 5390 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5390 14 string string NN 40436 5390 15 of of IN 40436 5390 16 questions question NNS 40436 5390 17 as as IN 40436 5390 18 to to TO 40436 5390 19 bring bring VB 40436 5390 20 out out RP 40436 5390 21 some some DT 40436 5390 22 established established JJ 40436 5390 23 and and CC 40436 5390 24 positive positive JJ 40436 5390 25 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5390 26 , , , 40436 5390 27 while while IN 40436 5390 28 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 5390 29 and and CC 40436 5390 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5390 31 brother brother NN 40436 5390 32 leave leave VBP 40436 5390 33 everything everything NN 40436 5390 34 in in IN 40436 5390 35 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 5390 36 . . . 40436 5391 1 Such such JJ 40436 5391 2 is be VBZ 40436 5391 3 not not RB 40436 5391 4 the the DT 40436 5391 5 fact fact NN 40436 5391 6 . . . 40436 5392 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5392 2 ends end VBZ 40436 5392 3 without without IN 40436 5392 4 any any DT 40436 5392 5 result result NN 40436 5392 6 , , , 40436 5392 7 and and CC 40436 5392 8 with with IN 40436 5392 9 a a DT 40436 5392 10 confession confession NN 40436 5392 11 of of IN 40436 5392 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5392 13 inability inability NN 40436 5392 14 to to TO 40436 5392 15 find find VB 40436 5392 16 any any DT 40436 5392 17 . . . 40436 5393 1 Professing profess VBG 40436 5393 2 earnest earnest JJ 40436 5393 3 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 5393 4 to to TO 40436 5393 5 stimulate stimulate VB 40436 5393 6 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5393 7 in in IN 40436 5393 8 the the DT 40436 5393 9 path path NN 40436 5393 10 of of IN 40436 5393 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 5393 12 , , , 40436 5393 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5393 14 is be VBZ 40436 5393 15 at at IN 40436 5393 16 the the DT 40436 5393 17 same same JJ 40436 5393 18 time time NN 40436 5393 19 unable unable JJ 40436 5393 20 to to TO 40436 5393 21 define define VB 40436 5393 22 what what WP 40436 5393 23 the the DT 40436 5393 24 capital capital NN 40436 5393 25 condition condition NN 40436 5393 26 of of IN 40436 5393 27 virtue virtue NN 40436 5393 28 is be VBZ 40436 5393 29 . . . 40436 5394 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5394 2 10 10 CD 40436 5394 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5394 4 On on IN 40436 5394 5 this this DT 40436 5394 6 point point NN 40436 5394 7 , , , 40436 5394 8 then then RB 40436 5394 9 , , , 40436 5394 10 there there EX 40436 5394 11 is be VBZ 40436 5394 12 no no DT 40436 5394 13 contrast contrast NN 40436 5394 14 between between IN 40436 5394 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5394 16 and and CC 40436 5394 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5394 18 competitors competitor NNS 40436 5394 19 : : : 40436 5394 20 if if IN 40436 5394 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5394 22 land land VBP 40436 5394 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5394 24 pupil pupil NN 40436 5394 25 in in IN 40436 5394 26 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 5394 27 , , , 40436 5394 28 so so RB 40436 5394 29 does do VBZ 40436 5394 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5394 31 . . . 40436 5395 1 Nor nor CC 40436 5395 2 , , , 40436 5395 3 again again RB 40436 5395 4 , , , 40436 5395 5 does do VBZ 40436 5395 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5395 7 stand stand VB 40436 5395 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 5395 9 from from IN 40436 5395 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5395 11 by by IN 40436 5395 12 affirming affirm VBG 40436 5395 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5395 14 or or CC 40436 5395 15 rather rather RB 40436 5395 16 implying imply VBG 40436 5395 17 in in IN 40436 5395 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5395 19 questions question NNS 40436 5395 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5395 21 nothing nothing NN 40436 5395 22 but but CC 40436 5395 23 what what WP 40436 5395 24 is be VBZ 40436 5395 25 true true JJ 40436 5395 26 and and CC 40436 5395 27 indisputable indisputable JJ 40436 5395 28 . . . 40436 5396 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5396 2 11 11 CD 40436 5396 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5396 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5396 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5396 6 10 10 CD 40436 5396 7 : : : 40436 5396 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5396 9 . . . 40436 5397 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5397 2 . . . 40436 5398 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5398 2 . . . 40436 5399 1 291 291 CD 40436 5399 2 A--293 a--293 CD 40436 5399 3 A a NN 40436 5399 4 ; ; : 40436 5399 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5399 6 . . . 40436 5400 1 Kleitophon Kleitophon NNP 40436 5400 2 , , , 40436 5400 3 pp pp NNP 40436 5400 4 . . . 40436 5401 1 409 409 CD 40436 5401 2 - - SYM 40436 5401 3 410 410 CD 40436 5401 4 . . . 40436 5401 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5402 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5402 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5402 3 11 11 CD 40436 5402 4 : : : 40436 5402 5 See see VB 40436 5402 6 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5402 7 . . . 40436 5403 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5403 2 . . . 40436 5404 1 p. p. NN 40436 5404 2 281 281 CD 40436 5404 3 C C NNP 40436 5404 4 - - HYPH 40436 5404 5 D D NNP 40436 5404 6 , , , 40436 5404 7 where where WRB 40436 5404 8 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 5404 9 the the DT 40436 5404 10 positions position NNS 40436 5404 11 laid lay VBD 40436 5404 12 down down RP 40436 5404 13 by by IN 40436 5404 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5404 15 would would MD 40436 5404 16 not not RB 40436 5404 17 have have VB 40436 5404 18 passed pass VBN 40436 5404 19 without without IN 40436 5404 20 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 5404 21 by by IN 40436 5404 22 an an DT 40436 5404 23 opponent opponent NN 40436 5404 24 . . . 40436 5404 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5405 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5405 2 Side side NN 40436 5405 3 - - HYPH 40436 5405 4 note note NN 40436 5405 5 : : : 40436 5405 6 Wherein wherein WRB 40436 5405 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5405 8 does do VBZ 40436 5405 9 consist consist VB 40436 5405 10 . . . 40436 5405 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5406 1 The the DT 40436 5406 2 real real JJ 40436 5406 3 contrast contrast NN 40436 5406 4 between between IN 40436 5406 5 the the DT 40436 5406 6 competitors competitor NNS 40436 5406 7 , , , 40436 5406 8 consists consist VBZ 40436 5406 9 , , , 40436 5406 10 first first RB 40436 5406 11 in in IN 40436 5406 12 the the DT 40436 5406 13 pretensions pretension NNS 40436 5406 14 -- -- : 40436 5406 15 next next RB 40436 5406 16 in in IN 40436 5406 17 the the DT 40436 5406 18 method method NN 40436 5406 19 . . . 40436 5407 1 The the DT 40436 5407 2 two two CD 40436 5407 3 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5407 4 are be VBP 40436 5407 5 described describe VBN 40436 5407 6 as as IN 40436 5407 7 persons person NNS 40436 5407 8 of of IN 40436 5407 9 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 5407 10 arrogance arrogance NN 40436 5407 11 , , , 40436 5407 12 professing profess VBG 40436 5407 13 to to TO 40436 5407 14 teach teach VB 40436 5407 15 virtue,[12 virtue,[12 NNP 40436 5407 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5407 17 and and CC 40436 5407 18 claiming claim VBG 40436 5407 19 a a DT 40436 5407 20 fee fee NN 40436 5407 21 as as IN 40436 5407 22 if if IN 40436 5407 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5407 24 did do VBD 40436 5407 25 teach teach VB 40436 5407 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5407 27 : : : 40436 5407 28 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5407 29 disdains disdain VBZ 40436 5407 30 the the DT 40436 5407 31 fee fee NN 40436 5407 32 , , , 40436 5407 33 doubts doubt VBZ 40436 5407 34 whether whether IN 40436 5407 35 such such JJ 40436 5407 36 teaching teaching NN 40436 5407 37 is be VBZ 40436 5407 38 possible possible JJ 40436 5407 39 , , , 40436 5407 40 and and CC 40436 5407 41 professes profess VBZ 40436 5407 42 only only RB 40436 5407 43 to to TO 40436 5407 44 encourage encourage VB 40436 5407 45 or or CC 40436 5407 46 help help VB 40436 5407 47 forward forward RB 40436 5407 48 on on IN 40436 5407 49 the the DT 40436 5407 50 road road NN 40436 5407 51 a a DT 40436 5407 52 willing willing JJ 40436 5407 53 pupil pupil NN 40436 5407 54 . . . 40436 5408 1 The the DT 40436 5408 2 pupil pupil NN 40436 5408 3 in in IN 40436 5408 4 this this DT 40436 5408 5 case case NN 40436 5408 6 is be VBZ 40436 5408 7 a a DT 40436 5408 8 given give VBN 40436 5408 9 subject subject NN 40436 5408 10 , , , 40436 5408 11 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5408 12 , , , 40436 5408 13 a a DT 40436 5408 14 modest modest JJ 40436 5408 15 and and CC 40436 5408 16 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 5408 17 youth youth NN 40436 5408 18 : : : 40436 5408 19 and and CC 40436 5408 20 the the DT 40436 5408 21 whole whole JJ 40436 5408 22 scene scene NN 40436 5408 23 passes pass VBZ 40436 5408 24 in in IN 40436 5408 25 public public NN 40436 5408 26 before before IN 40436 5408 27 an an DT 40436 5408 28 indiscriminate indiscriminate JJ 40436 5408 29 audience audience NN 40436 5408 30 . . . 40436 5409 1 To to IN 40436 5409 2 such such PDT 40436 5409 3 a a DT 40436 5409 4 pupil pupil NN 40436 5409 5 , , , 40436 5409 6 what what WP 40436 5409 7 is be VBZ 40436 5409 8 needed need VBN 40436 5409 9 is be VBZ 40436 5409 10 , , , 40436 5409 11 encouragement encouragement NN 40436 5409 12 and and CC 40436 5409 13 guidance guidance NN 40436 5409 14 . . . 40436 5410 1 Both both DT 40436 5410 2 of of IN 40436 5410 3 these these DT 40436 5410 4 are be VBP 40436 5410 5 really really RB 40436 5410 6 administered administer VBN 40436 5410 7 by by IN 40436 5410 8 the the DT 40436 5410 9 questions question NNS 40436 5410 10 of of IN 40436 5410 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5410 12 , , , 40436 5410 13 which which WDT 40436 5410 14 are be VBP 40436 5410 15 all all DT 40436 5410 16 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 5410 17 and and CC 40436 5410 18 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 5410 19 to to IN 40436 5410 20 the the DT 40436 5410 21 matter matter NN 40436 5410 22 in in IN 40436 5410 23 hand hand NN 40436 5410 24 , , , 40436 5410 25 though though IN 40436 5410 26 failing fail VBG 40436 5410 27 to to TO 40436 5410 28 reach reach VB 40436 5410 29 a a DT 40436 5410 30 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 5410 31 result result NN 40436 5410 32 : : : 40436 5410 33 moreover moreover RB 40436 5410 34 , , , 40436 5410 35 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5410 36 attends attend VBZ 40436 5410 37 only only RB 40436 5410 38 to to IN 40436 5410 39 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5410 40 , , , 40436 5410 41 and and CC 40436 5410 42 is be VBZ 40436 5410 43 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 5410 44 to to IN 40436 5410 45 the the DT 40436 5410 46 effect effect NN 40436 5410 47 on on IN 40436 5410 48 the the DT 40436 5410 49 audience audience NN 40436 5410 50 around around RB 40436 5410 51 . . . 40436 5411 1 The the DT 40436 5411 2 two two CD 40436 5411 3 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5411 4 , , , 40436 5411 5 on on IN 40436 5411 6 the the DT 40436 5411 7 contrary contrary NN 40436 5411 8 , , , 40436 5411 9 do do VB 40436 5411 10 not not RB 40436 5411 11 say say VB 40436 5411 12 a a DT 40436 5411 13 word word NN 40436 5411 14 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 5411 15 to to IN 40436 5411 16 the the DT 40436 5411 17 object object NN 40436 5411 18 desired desire VBN 40436 5411 19 . . . 40436 5412 1 Far far RB 40436 5412 2 from from IN 40436 5412 3 seeking seek VBG 40436 5412 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5412 5 as as IN 40436 5412 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5412 7 promised promise VBD 40436 5412 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5412 9 to to TO 40436 5412 10 encourage encourage VB 40436 5412 11 Kleinias,[13 Kleinias,[13 NNS 40436 5412 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5412 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5412 14 confuse confuse VBP 40436 5412 15 and and CC 40436 5412 16 humiliate humiliate VB 40436 5412 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5412 18 from from IN 40436 5412 19 the the DT 40436 5412 20 beginning beginning NN 40436 5412 21 : : : 40436 5412 22 all all DT 40436 5412 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5412 24 implements implement NNS 40436 5412 25 for for IN 40436 5412 26 teaching teaching NN 40436 5412 27 consist consist VB 40436 5412 28 only only RB 40436 5412 29 of of IN 40436 5412 30 logical logical JJ 40436 5412 31 puzzles puzzle NNS 40436 5412 32 ; ; : 40436 5412 33 lastly lastly RB 40436 5412 34 , , , 40436 5412 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5412 36 main main JJ 40436 5412 37 purpose purpose NN 40436 5412 38 is be VBZ 40436 5412 39 to to TO 40436 5412 40 elicit elicit VB 40436 5412 41 applause applause NN 40436 5412 42 from from IN 40436 5412 43 the the DT 40436 5412 44 by by NN 40436 5412 45 - - HYPH 40436 5412 46 standers stander NNS 40436 5412 47 , , , 40436 5412 48 by by IN 40436 5412 49 reducing reduce VBG 40436 5412 50 both both CC 40436 5412 51 the the DT 40436 5412 52 modest modest JJ 40436 5412 53 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5412 54 and and CC 40436 5412 55 every every DT 40436 5412 56 other other JJ 40436 5412 57 respondent respondent NN 40436 5412 58 to to IN 40436 5412 59 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 5412 60 and and CC 40436 5412 61 stand stand VB 40436 5412 62 - - HYPH 40436 5412 63 still still RB 40436 5412 64 . . . 40436 5413 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5413 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5413 3 12 12 CD 40436 5413 4 : : : 40436 5413 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5413 6 . . . 40436 5414 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5414 2 . . . 40436 5415 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5415 2 . . . 40436 5416 1 273 273 CD 40436 5416 2 D d NN 40436 5416 3 , , , 40436 5416 4 275 275 CD 40436 5416 5 A a DT 40436 5416 6 , , , 40436 5416 7 304 304 CD 40436 5416 8 B. b. NN 40436 5416 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5417 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5417 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5417 3 13 13 CD 40436 5417 4 : : : 40436 5417 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5417 6 . . . 40436 5418 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5418 2 . . . 40436 5419 1 p. p. NN 40436 5419 2 278 278 CD 40436 5419 3 C. C. NNP 40436 5419 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5419 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5419 6 : : : 40436 5419 7 e)pha e)pha ADD 40436 5419 8 / / SYM 40436 5419 9 tên tên NN 40436 5419 10 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5419 11 e)pidei e)pidei NNP 40436 5419 12 / / SYM 40436 5419 13 xasthai xasthai NNP 40436 5419 14 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5419 15 protreptikê\n protreptikê\n -LRB- 40436 5419 16 sophi sophi NNS 40436 5419 17 / / , 40436 5419 18 an an DT 40436 5419 19 . . . 40436 5419 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5419 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5420 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5420 2 Side side NN 40436 5420 3 - - HYPH 40436 5420 4 note note NN 40436 5420 5 : : : 40436 5420 6 Abuse abuse NN 40436 5420 7 of of IN 40436 5420 8 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5420 9 by by IN 40436 5420 10 the the DT 40436 5420 11 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5420 12 -- -- : 40436 5420 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5420 14 bidding bidding NN 40436 5420 15 for for IN 40436 5420 16 the the DT 40436 5420 17 applause applause NN 40436 5420 18 of of IN 40436 5420 19 the the DT 40436 5420 20 by by NN 40436 5420 21 - - HYPH 40436 5420 22 standers stander NNS 40436 5420 23 . . . 40436 5420 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5421 1 Such such JJ 40436 5421 2 is be VBZ 40436 5421 3 the the DT 40436 5421 4 real real JJ 40436 5421 5 contrast contrast NN 40436 5421 6 between between IN 40436 5421 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5421 8 and and CC 40436 5421 9 the the DT 40436 5421 10 two two CD 40436 5421 11 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5421 12 , , , 40436 5421 13 and and CC 40436 5421 14 such such JJ 40436 5421 15 is be VBZ 40436 5421 16 the the DT 40436 5421 17 real real JJ 40436 5421 18 scene scene NN 40436 5421 19 which which WDT 40436 5421 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5421 21 read read VBP 40436 5421 22 in in IN 40436 5421 23 the the DT 40436 5421 24 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5421 25 . . . 40436 5422 1 The the DT 40436 5422 2 presence presence NN 40436 5422 3 , , , 40436 5422 4 as as RB 40436 5422 5 well well RB 40436 5422 6 as as IN 40436 5422 7 the the DT 40436 5422 8 loud loud JJ 40436 5422 9 manifestations manifestation NNS 40436 5422 10 of of IN 40436 5422 11 an an DT 40436 5422 12 indiscriminate indiscriminate JJ 40436 5422 13 crowd crowd NN 40436 5422 14 in in IN 40436 5422 15 the the DT 40436 5422 16 Lykeium Lykeium NNP 40436 5422 17 , , , 40436 5422 18 are be VBP 40436 5422 19 essential essential JJ 40436 5422 20 features feature NNS 40436 5422 21 of of IN 40436 5422 22 the the DT 40436 5422 23 drama drama NN 40436 5422 24 . . . 40436 5423 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5423 2 14 14 CD 40436 5423 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5423 4 The the DT 40436 5423 5 point point NN 40436 5423 6 of of IN 40436 5423 7 view view NN 40436 5423 8 which which WDT 40436 5423 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5423 10 is be VBZ 40436 5423 11 working work VBG 40436 5423 12 out out RP 40436 5423 13 , , , 40436 5423 14 is be VBZ 40436 5423 15 , , , 40436 5423 16 the the DT 40436 5423 17 abusive abusive JJ 40436 5423 18 employment employment NN 40436 5423 19 , , , 40436 5423 20 the the DT 40436 5423 21 excess excess NN 40436 5423 22 , , , 40436 5423 23 and and CC 40436 5423 24 the the DT 40436 5423 25 misplacement misplacement JJ 40436 5423 26 , , , 40436 5423 27 of of IN 40436 5423 28 logical logical JJ 40436 5423 29 puzzles puzzle NNS 40436 5423 30 : : : 40436 5423 31 which which WDT 40436 5423 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5423 33 brings bring VBZ 40436 5423 34 before before IN 40436 5423 35 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5423 36 as as IN 40436 5423 37 administered administer VBN 40436 5423 38 for for IN 40436 5423 39 the the DT 40436 5423 40 humiliation humiliation NN 40436 5423 41 of of IN 40436 5423 42 a a DT 40436 5423 43 youth youth NN 40436 5423 44 who who WP 40436 5423 45 requires require VBZ 40436 5423 46 opposite opposite JJ 40436 5423 47 treatment treatment NN 40436 5423 48 , , , 40436 5423 49 in in IN 40436 5423 50 the the DT 40436 5423 51 prosecution prosecution NN 40436 5423 52 of of IN 40436 5423 53 an an DT 40436 5423 54 object object NN 40436 5423 55 which which WDT 40436 5423 56 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5423 57 do do VBP 40436 5423 58 not not RB 40436 5423 59 really really RB 40436 5423 60 promote promote VB 40436 5423 61 and and CC 40436 5423 62 before before IN 40436 5423 63 undiscerning undiscerne VBG 40436 5423 64 auditors auditor NNS 40436 5423 65 , , , 40436 5423 66 for for IN 40436 5423 67 whose whose WP$ 40436 5423 68 applause applause NN 40436 5423 69 the the DT 40436 5423 70 two two CD 40436 5423 71 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5423 72 are be VBP 40436 5423 73 bidding bid VBG 40436 5423 74 . . . 40436 5424 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5424 2 15 15 CD 40436 5424 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5424 4 The the DT 40436 5424 5 whole whole JJ 40436 5424 6 debate debate NN 40436 5424 7 upon upon IN 40436 5424 8 these these DT 40436 5424 9 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5424 10 is be VBZ 40436 5424 11 rendered render VBN 40436 5424 12 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 5424 13 ; ; : 40436 5424 14 and and CC 40436 5424 15 when when WRB 40436 5424 16 conducted conduct VBN 40436 5424 17 with with IN 40436 5424 18 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 5424 19 , , , 40436 5424 20 degenerates degenerate VBZ 40436 5424 21 into into IN 40436 5424 22 wrangling wrangling NN 40436 5424 23 and and CC 40436 5424 24 ribaldry ribaldry NN 40436 5424 25 . . . 40436 5425 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5425 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5425 3 14 14 CD 40436 5425 4 : : : 40436 5425 5 The the DT 40436 5425 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5425 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5425 8 : : : 40436 5425 9 o)/chlos o)/chlos NNP 40436 5425 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5425 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5425 12 surrounding surround VBG 40436 5425 13 multitude multitude NNP 40436 5425 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5425 15 is be VBZ 40436 5425 16 especially especially RB 40436 5425 17 insisted insist VBN 40436 5425 18 on on IN 40436 5425 19 in in IN 40436 5425 20 the the DT 40436 5425 21 first first JJ 40436 5425 22 sentence sentence NN 40436 5425 23 of of IN 40436 5425 24 the the DT 40436 5425 25 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5425 26 , , , 40436 5425 27 and and CC 40436 5425 28 is be VBZ 40436 5425 29 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 5425 30 adverted adverted JJ 40436 5425 31 to to IN 40436 5425 32 throughout throughout IN 40436 5425 33 all all PDT 40436 5425 34 the the DT 40436 5425 35 recital recital NN 40436 5425 36 of of IN 40436 5425 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5425 38 to to IN 40436 5425 39 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5425 40 , , , 40436 5425 41 pp pp NNP 40436 5425 42 . . . 40436 5426 1 276 276 CD 40436 5426 2 B B NNP 40436 5426 3 - - HYPH 40436 5426 4 D D NNP 40436 5426 5 , , , 40436 5426 6 303 303 CD 40436 5426 7 B. b. NN 40436 5426 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5427 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5427 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5427 3 15 15 CD 40436 5427 4 : : : 40436 5427 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5427 6 . . . 40436 5428 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5428 2 . . . 40436 5429 1 p. p. NN 40436 5429 2 303 303 CD 40436 5429 3 B. B. NNP 40436 5429 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5430 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5430 2 Side side NN 40436 5430 3 - - HYPH 40436 5430 4 note note NN 40436 5430 5 : : : 40436 5430 6 Comparison comparison NN 40436 5430 7 of of IN 40436 5430 8 the the DT 40436 5430 9 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5430 10 with with IN 40436 5430 11 the the DT 40436 5430 12 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 5430 13 . . . 40436 5430 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5431 1 The the DT 40436 5431 2 bearing bearing NN 40436 5431 3 of of IN 40436 5431 4 the the DT 40436 5431 5 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5431 6 , , , 40436 5431 7 as as IN 40436 5431 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5431 9 here here RB 40436 5431 10 state state VBP 40436 5431 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5431 12 , , , 40436 5431 13 will will MD 40436 5431 14 be be VB 40436 5431 15 better well RBR 40436 5431 16 understood understand VBN 40436 5431 17 if if IN 40436 5431 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5431 19 contrast contrast VBP 40436 5431 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5431 21 with with IN 40436 5431 22 the the DT 40436 5431 23 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 5431 24 . . . 40436 5432 1 In in IN 40436 5432 2 this this DT 40436 5432 3 last last RB 40436 5432 4 - - HYPH 40436 5432 5 mentioned mention VBN 40436 5432 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5432 7 , , , 40436 5432 8 the the DT 40436 5432 9 amount amount NN 40436 5432 10 of of IN 40436 5432 11 negative negative JJ 40436 5432 12 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 5432 13 and and CC 40436 5432 14 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 5432 15 is be VBZ 40436 5432 16 greater great JJR 40436 5432 17 and and CC 40436 5432 18 more more RBR 40436 5432 19 serious serious JJ 40436 5432 20 than than IN 40436 5432 21 that that DT 40436 5432 22 which which WDT 40436 5432 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5432 24 read read VBP 40436 5432 25 in in IN 40436 5432 26 the the DT 40436 5432 27 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5432 28 . . . 40436 5433 1 One one CD 40436 5433 2 single single JJ 40436 5433 3 case case NN 40436 5433 4 of of IN 40436 5433 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5433 6 is be VBZ 40436 5433 7 elaborately elaborately RB 40436 5433 8 built build VBN 40436 5433 9 up up RP 40436 5433 10 in in IN 40436 5433 11 the the DT 40436 5433 12 long long JJ 40436 5433 13 Antinomies antinomy NNS 40436 5433 14 at at IN 40436 5433 15 the the DT 40436 5433 16 close close NN 40436 5433 17 of of IN 40436 5433 18 the the DT 40436 5433 19 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 5433 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5433 21 which which WDT 40436 5433 22 occupy occupy VBP 40436 5433 23 as as RB 40436 5433 24 much much JJ 40436 5433 25 space space NN 40436 5433 26 , , , 40436 5433 27 and and CC 40436 5433 28 contain contain VBP 40436 5433 29 nearly nearly RB 40436 5433 30 as as RB 40436 5433 31 much much JJ 40436 5433 32 sophistry sophistry NN 40436 5433 33 , , , 40436 5433 34 as as IN 40436 5433 35 the the DT 40436 5433 36 speeches speech NNS 40436 5433 37 assigned assign VBN 40436 5433 38 to to IN 40436 5433 39 the the DT 40436 5433 40 two two CD 40436 5433 41 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5433 42 in in IN 40436 5433 43 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5433 44 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5433 45 , , , 40436 5433 46 while while IN 40436 5433 47 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5433 48 are be VBP 40436 5433 49 given give VBN 40436 5433 50 to to TO 40436 5433 51 understand understand VB 40436 5433 52 that that IN 40436 5433 53 many many JJ 40436 5433 54 more more JJR 40436 5433 55 remain remain VBP 40436 5433 56 behind behind RB 40436 5433 57 . . . 40436 5434 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5434 2 16 16 CD 40436 5434 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5434 4 These these DT 40436 5434 5 perplexing perplexing NN 40436 5434 6 Antinomies antinomy NNS 40436 5434 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5434 8 addressed address VBN 40436 5434 9 by by IN 40436 5434 10 the the DT 40436 5434 11 veteran veteran NN 40436 5434 12 Parmenides Parmenides NNP 40436 5434 13 to to IN 40436 5434 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5434 15 as as IN 40436 5434 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5434 17 junior junior NN 40436 5434 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5434 19 , , , 40436 5434 20 after after IN 40436 5434 21 a a DT 40436 5434 22 variety variety NN 40436 5434 23 of of IN 40436 5434 24 other other JJ 40436 5434 25 objections objection NNS 40436 5434 26 against against IN 40436 5434 27 the the DT 40436 5434 28 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5434 29 theory theory NN 40436 5434 30 of of IN 40436 5434 31 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 5434 32 , , , 40436 5434 33 which which WDT 40436 5434 34 theory theory NN 40436 5434 35 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5434 36 has have VBZ 40436 5434 37 been be VBN 40436 5434 38 introduced introduce VBN 40436 5434 39 as as IN 40436 5434 40 affirming,--are affirming,--are UH 40436 5434 41 drawn draw VBN 40436 5434 42 up up RP 40436 5434 43 for for IN 40436 5434 44 the the DT 40436 5434 45 avowed avowed JJ 40436 5434 46 purpose purpose NN 40436 5434 47 of of IN 40436 5434 48 checking check VBG 40436 5434 49 premature premature JJ 40436 5434 50 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 5434 51 , , , 40436 5434 52 and and CC 40436 5434 53 of of IN 40436 5434 54 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 5434 55 the the DT 40436 5434 56 difficult difficult JJ 40436 5434 57 exercises exercise NNS 40436 5434 58 and and CC 40436 5434 59 problems problem NNS 40436 5434 60 which which WDT 40436 5434 61 must must MD 40436 5434 62 be be VB 40436 5434 63 solved solve VBN 40436 5434 64 , , , 40436 5434 65 before before IN 40436 5434 66 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 5434 67 can can MD 40436 5434 68 become become VB 40436 5434 69 justifiable justifiable JJ 40436 5434 70 . . . 40436 5435 1 This this DT 40436 5435 2 task task NN 40436 5435 3 , , , 40436 5435 4 though though IN 40436 5435 5 long long JJ 40436 5435 6 and and CC 40436 5435 7 laborious laborious JJ 40436 5435 8 , , , 40436 5435 9 can can MD 40436 5435 10 not not RB 40436 5435 11 be be VB 40436 5435 12 evaded evade VBN 40436 5435 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5435 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5435 15 are be VBP 40436 5435 16 here here RB 40436 5435 17 told tell VBN 40436 5435 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5435 19 by by IN 40436 5435 20 aspirants aspirant NNS 40436 5435 21 in in IN 40436 5435 22 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5435 23 . . . 40436 5436 1 But but CC 40436 5436 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5436 3 is be VBZ 40436 5436 4 a a DT 40436 5436 5 task task NN 40436 5436 6 which which WDT 40436 5436 7 ought ought MD 40436 5436 8 only only RB 40436 5436 9 to to TO 40436 5436 10 be be VB 40436 5436 11 undertaken undertake VBN 40436 5436 12 in in IN 40436 5436 13 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 5436 14 with with IN 40436 5436 15 a a DT 40436 5436 16 few few JJ 40436 5436 17 select select JJ 40436 5436 18 companions companion NNS 40436 5436 19 . . . 40436 5437 1 " " `` 40436 5437 2 Before before IN 40436 5437 3 any any DT 40436 5437 4 large large JJ 40436 5437 5 audience audience NN 40436 5437 6 , , , 40436 5437 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5437 8 would would MD 40436 5437 9 be be VB 40436 5437 10 unseemly unseemly JJ 40436 5437 11 and and CC 40436 5437 12 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 5437 13 : : : 40436 5437 14 for for IN 40436 5437 15 the the DT 40436 5437 16 public public NN 40436 5437 17 are be VBP 40436 5437 18 not not RB 40436 5437 19 aware aware JJ 40436 5437 20 that that IN 40436 5437 21 without without IN 40436 5437 22 such such JJ 40436 5437 23 roundabout roundabout NN 40436 5437 24 and and CC 40436 5437 25 devious devious JJ 40436 5437 26 journey journey NN 40436 5437 27 in in IN 40436 5437 28 all all DT 40436 5437 29 directions direction NNS 40436 5437 30 , , , 40436 5437 31 no no DT 40436 5437 32 man man NN 40436 5437 33 can can MD 40436 5437 34 hit hit VB 40436 5437 35 upon upon IN 40436 5437 36 truth truth NN 40436 5437 37 or or CC 40436 5437 38 acquire acquire VB 40436 5437 39 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5437 40 . . . 40436 5438 1 " " `` 40436 5438 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5438 3 17 17 CD 40436 5438 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5438 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5438 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5438 7 16 16 CD 40436 5438 8 : : : 40436 5438 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5438 10 , , , 40436 5438 11 Parmenid Parmenid NNP 40436 5438 12 . . . 40436 5439 1 p. p. NN 40436 5439 2 136 136 CD 40436 5439 3 B. B. NNP 40436 5439 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5439 5 shall shall MD 40436 5439 6 revert revert VB 40436 5439 7 to to IN 40436 5439 8 this this DT 40436 5439 9 point point NN 40436 5439 10 when when WRB 40436 5439 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5439 12 notice notice VBP 40436 5439 13 the the DT 40436 5439 14 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 5439 15 . . . 40436 5439 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5440 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5440 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5440 3 17 17 CD 40436 5440 4 : : : 40436 5440 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5440 6 . . . 40436 5441 1 Parmen parman NNS 40436 5441 2 . . . 40436 5442 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5442 2 . . . 40436 5443 1 135 135 CD 40436 5443 2 - - SYM 40436 5443 3 136 136 CD 40436 5443 4 . . . 40436 5444 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5444 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5444 3 : : : 40436 5444 4 e(/lkuson e(/lkuson NNP 40436 5444 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5444 6 sauto\n sauto\n ADD 40436 5444 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5444 8 gu gu NNP 40436 5444 9 / / SYM 40436 5444 10 mnasai mnasai NNP 40436 5444 11 ma ma NNP 40436 5444 12 = = SYM 40436 5444 13 llon llon NNP 40436 5444 14 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 5444 15 tê tê NNP 40436 5444 16 = = SYM 40436 5444 17 s s NNP 40436 5444 18 dokou dokou NNP 40436 5444 19 / / SYM 40436 5444 20 sês sês NNP 40436 5444 21 a)chrê a)chrê , 40436 5444 22 / / SYM 40436 5444 23 stou stou NNP 40436 5444 24 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 5444 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5444 26 kaloume kaloume NNP 40436 5444 27 / / SYM 40436 5444 28 nês nês NNP 40436 5444 29 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 5444 30 tô tô NNP 40436 5444 31 = = SYM 40436 5444 32 n n CC 40436 5444 33 pollô pollô NN 40436 5444 34 = = SYM 40436 5444 35 n n CC 40436 5444 36 a)doleschi a)doleschi NNP 40436 5444 37 / / SYM 40436 5444 38 as as IN 40436 5444 39 , , , 40436 5444 40 e(/ôs e(/ôs NNP 40436 5444 41 e(/ti e(/ti NNP 40436 5444 42 ne ne NNP 40436 5444 43 / / SYM 40436 5444 44 os os NNP 40436 5444 45 ei)=--ei ei)=--ei NNP 40436 5444 46 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5444 47 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5444 48 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 5444 49 plei plei NNP 40436 5444 50 / / SYM 40436 5444 51 ous ous NNP 40436 5444 52 ê(=men ê(=men NNPS 40436 5444 53 , , , 40436 5444 54 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 5444 55 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 5444 56 a)/xion a)/xion NNP 40436 5444 57 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 5444 58 dei dei NNP 40436 5444 59 = = SYM 40436 5444 60 sthai sthai NNP 40436 5444 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5444 62 , , , 40436 5444 63 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5444 64 to to TO 40436 5444 65 request request VB 40436 5444 66 Parmenides Parmenides NNP 40436 5444 67 to to TO 40436 5444 68 give give VB 40436 5444 69 a a DT 40436 5444 70 specimen speciman NNS 40436 5444 71 of of IN 40436 5444 72 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 5444 73 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5444 74 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5444 75 Greek greek JJ 40436 5444 76 : : : 40436 5444 77 a)prepê= a)prepê= JJ 40436 5444 78 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5444 79 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 5444 80 toiau toiau NNP 40436 5444 81 = = SYM 40436 5444 82 ta ta NNP 40436 5444 83 pollô pollô NNP 40436 5444 84 = = SYM 40436 5444 85 n n CC 40436 5444 86 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 5444 87 / / SYM 40436 5444 88 on on IN 40436 5444 89 le le NNP 40436 5444 90 / / SYM 40436 5444 91 gein gein NNP 40436 5444 92 , , , 40436 5444 93 a)/llôs a)/llôs NNP 40436 5444 94 te te NNP 40436 5444 95 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5444 96 têlikou têlikou NNP 40436 5444 97 / / SYM 40436 5444 98 tô| tô| NNP 40436 5444 99 ; ; : 40436 5444 100 a)gnoou a)gnoou ADD 40436 5444 101 = = -RRB- 40436 5444 102 si si UH 40436 5444 103 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5444 104 oi oi PRP 40436 5444 105 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5444 106 polloi\ polloi\ NNP 40436 5444 107 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 5444 108 a)/neu a)/neu IN 40436 5444 109 tau tau NNP 40436 5444 110 / / SYM 40436 5444 111 tês tês NNP 40436 5444 112 tê tê NNP 40436 5444 113 = = SYM 40436 5444 114 s s NNP 40436 5444 115 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 5444 116 pa pa NNP 40436 5444 117 / / SYM 40436 5444 118 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 5444 119 diexo diexo NNP 40436 5444 120 / / SYM 40436 5444 121 dou dou FW 40436 5444 122 te te NNP 40436 5444 123 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5444 124 pla pla NNP 40436 5444 125 / / SYM 40436 5444 126 nês nês NN 40436 5444 127 , , , 40436 5444 128 a)du a)du NN 40436 5444 129 / / SYM 40436 5444 130 naton naton NNP 40436 5444 131 e)ntucho e)ntucho , 40436 5444 132 / / SYM 40436 5444 133 nta nta NNP 40436 5444 134 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 5444 135 a)lêthei= a)lêthei= NNP 40436 5444 136 nou nou NNP 40436 5444 137 = = SYM 40436 5444 138 n n NN 40436 5444 139 schei schei NN 40436 5444 140 = = SYM 40436 5444 141 n n NN 40436 5444 142 . . . 40436 5444 143 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5444 144 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5445 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5445 2 Side side NN 40436 5445 3 - - HYPH 40436 5445 4 note note NN 40436 5445 5 : : : 40436 5445 6 Necessity necessity NN 40436 5445 7 of of IN 40436 5445 8 settling settle VBG 40436 5445 9 accounts account NNS 40436 5445 10 with with IN 40436 5445 11 the the DT 40436 5445 12 negative negative JJ 40436 5445 13 , , , 40436 5445 14 before before IN 40436 5445 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5445 16 venture venture VBP 40436 5445 17 upon upon IN 40436 5445 18 the the DT 40436 5445 19 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 5445 20 , , , 40436 5445 21 is be VBZ 40436 5445 22 common common JJ 40436 5445 23 to to IN 40436 5445 24 both both DT 40436 5445 25 : : : 40436 5445 26 in in IN 40436 5445 27 the the DT 40436 5445 28 one one NN 40436 5445 29 the the DT 40436 5445 30 process process NN 40436 5445 31 is be VBZ 40436 5445 32 solitary solitary JJ 40436 5445 33 and and CC 40436 5445 34 serious serious JJ 40436 5445 35 ; ; : 40436 5445 36 in in IN 40436 5445 37 the the DT 40436 5445 38 other other JJ 40436 5445 39 , , , 40436 5445 40 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5445 41 is be VBZ 40436 5445 42 vulgarised vulgarise VBN 40436 5445 43 and and CC 40436 5445 44 ludicrous ludicrous JJ 40436 5445 45 . . . 40436 5445 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5446 1 This this DT 40436 5446 2 important important JJ 40436 5446 3 proposition proposition NN 40436 5446 4 -- -- : 40436 5446 5 That that IN 40436 5446 6 before before IN 40436 5446 7 a a DT 40436 5446 8 man man NN 40436 5446 9 can can MD 40436 5446 10 be be VB 40436 5446 11 entitled entitle VBN 40436 5446 12 to to TO 40436 5446 13 lay lay VB 40436 5446 14 down down RP 40436 5446 15 with with IN 40436 5446 16 confidence confidence NN 40436 5446 17 any any DT 40436 5446 18 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 5446 19 theory theory NN 40436 5446 20 , , , 40436 5446 21 in in IN 40436 5446 22 the the DT 40436 5446 23 domain domain NN 40436 5446 24 of of IN 40436 5446 25 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5446 26 or or CC 40436 5446 27 " " `` 40436 5446 28 reasoned reason VBN 40436 5446 29 truth truth NN 40436 5446 30 , , , 40436 5446 31 " " '' 40436 5446 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5446 33 must must MD 40436 5446 34 have have VB 40436 5446 35 had have VBN 40436 5446 36 before before IN 40436 5446 37 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5446 38 the the DT 40436 5446 39 various various JJ 40436 5446 40 knots knot NNS 40436 5446 41 tied tie VBN 40436 5446 42 by by IN 40436 5446 43 negative negative JJ 40436 5446 44 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 5446 45 , , , 40436 5446 46 and and CC 40436 5446 47 must must MD 40436 5446 48 find find VB 40436 5446 49 out out RP 40436 5446 50 the the DT 40436 5446 51 way way NN 40436 5446 52 of of IN 40436 5446 53 untying untie VBG 40436 5446 54 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5446 55 -- -- : 40436 5446 56 is be VBZ 40436 5446 57 a a DT 40436 5446 58 postulate postulate NN 40436 5446 59 which which WDT 40436 5446 60 lies lie VBZ 40436 5446 61 at at IN 40436 5446 62 the the DT 40436 5446 63 bottom bottom NN 40436 5446 64 of of IN 40436 5446 65 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5446 66 's 's POS 40436 5446 67 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5446 68 of of IN 40436 5446 69 Search Search NNP 40436 5446 70 , , , 40436 5446 71 as as IN 40436 5446 72 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5446 73 have have VBP 40436 5446 74 remarked remark VBN 40436 5446 75 in in IN 40436 5446 76 the the DT 40436 5446 77 eighth eighth JJ 40436 5446 78 chapter chapter NN 40436 5446 79 of of IN 40436 5446 80 this this DT 40436 5446 81 work work NN 40436 5446 82 . . . 40436 5447 1 But but CC 40436 5447 2 there there EX 40436 5447 3 is be VBZ 40436 5447 4 much much JJ 40436 5447 5 difference difference NN 40436 5447 6 in in IN 40436 5447 7 the the DT 40436 5447 8 time time NN 40436 5447 9 , , , 40436 5447 10 manner manner NN 40436 5447 11 , , , 40436 5447 12 and and CC 40436 5447 13 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 5447 14 , , , 40436 5447 15 under under IN 40436 5447 16 which which WDT 40436 5447 17 such such JJ 40436 5447 18 knots knot NNS 40436 5447 19 are be VBP 40436 5447 20 brought bring VBN 40436 5447 21 before before RB 40436 5447 22 the the DT 40436 5447 23 student student NN 40436 5447 24 for for IN 40436 5447 25 solution solution NN 40436 5447 26 . . . 40436 5448 1 In in IN 40436 5448 2 the the DT 40436 5448 3 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 5448 4 the the DT 40436 5448 5 process process NN 40436 5448 6 is be VBZ 40436 5448 7 presented present VBN 40436 5448 8 as as IN 40436 5448 9 one one CD 40436 5448 10 both both DT 40436 5448 11 serious serious JJ 40436 5448 12 and and CC 40436 5448 13 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 5448 14 , , , 40436 5448 15 yet yet CC 40436 5448 16 requiring require VBG 40436 5448 17 some some DT 40436 5448 18 precautions precaution NNS 40436 5448 19 : : : 40436 5448 20 the the DT 40436 5448 21 public public NN 40436 5448 22 must must MD 40436 5448 23 be be VB 40436 5448 24 excluded exclude VBN 40436 5448 25 , , , 40436 5448 26 for for IN 40436 5448 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5448 28 do do VBP 40436 5448 29 not not RB 40436 5448 30 understand understand VB 40436 5448 31 the the DT 40436 5448 32 purpose purpose NN 40436 5448 33 : : : 40436 5448 34 and and CC 40436 5448 35 the the DT 40436 5448 36 student student NN 40436 5448 37 under under IN 40436 5448 38 examination examination NN 40436 5448 39 must must MD 40436 5448 40 be be VB 40436 5448 41 one one CD 40436 5448 42 who who WP 40436 5448 43 is be VBZ 40436 5448 44 competent competent JJ 40436 5448 45 or or CC 40436 5448 46 more more JJR 40436 5448 47 than than IN 40436 5448 48 competent competent JJ 40436 5448 49 to to TO 40436 5448 50 bear bear VB 40436 5448 51 the the DT 40436 5448 52 heavy heavy JJ 40436 5448 53 burthen burthen NN 40436 5448 54 put put VBD 40436 5448 55 upon upon IN 40436 5448 56 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5448 57 , , , 40436 5448 58 as as IN 40436 5448 59 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5448 60 is be VBZ 40436 5448 61 represented represent VBN 40436 5448 62 to to TO 40436 5448 63 be be VB 40436 5448 64 in in IN 40436 5448 65 the the DT 40436 5448 66 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 5448 67 . . . 40436 5449 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5449 2 18 18 CD 40436 5449 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5449 4 In in IN 40436 5449 5 the the DT 40436 5449 6 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5449 7 , , , 40436 5449 8 on on IN 40436 5449 9 the the DT 40436 5449 10 contrary contrary NN 40436 5449 11 , , , 40436 5449 12 the the DT 40436 5449 13 process process NN 40436 5449 14 is be VBZ 40436 5449 15 intended intend VBN 40436 5449 16 to to TO 40436 5449 17 be be VB 40436 5449 18 made make VBN 40436 5449 19 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 5449 20 ; ; : 40436 5449 21 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 5449 22 these these DT 40436 5449 23 precautions precaution NNS 40436 5449 24 are be VBP 40436 5449 25 disregarded disregard VBN 40436 5449 26 . . . 40436 5450 1 The the DT 40436 5450 2 crowd crowd NN 40436 5450 3 of of IN 40436 5450 4 indiscriminate indiscriminate JJ 40436 5450 5 auditors auditor NNS 40436 5450 6 are be VBP 40436 5450 7 not not RB 40436 5450 8 only only RB 40436 5450 9 present present JJ 40436 5450 10 , , , 40436 5450 11 but but CC 40436 5450 12 are be VBP 40436 5450 13 the the DT 40436 5450 14 persons person NNS 40436 5450 15 whose whose WP$ 40436 5450 16 feelings feeling NNS 40436 5450 17 the the DT 40436 5450 18 two two CD 40436 5450 19 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5450 20 address address NN 40436 5450 21 -- -- : 40436 5450 22 and and CC 40436 5450 23 who who WP 40436 5450 24 either either CC 40436 5450 25 admire admire VBP 40436 5450 26 what what WP 40436 5450 27 is be VBZ 40436 5450 28 said say VBN 40436 5450 29 as as IN 40436 5450 30 dexterous dexterous JJ 40436 5450 31 legerdemain legerdemain NN 40436 5450 32 , , , 40436 5450 33 or or CC 40436 5450 34 laugh laugh VBP 40436 5450 35 at at IN 40436 5450 36 the the DT 40436 5450 37 interchange interchange NN 40436 5450 38 of of IN 40436 5450 39 thrusts thrust NNS 40436 5450 40 , , , 40436 5450 41 as as IN 40436 5450 42 the the DT 40436 5450 43 duel duel NN 40436 5450 44 becomes become VBZ 40436 5450 45 warmer warm JJR 40436 5450 46 : : : 40436 5450 47 in in IN 40436 5450 48 fact fact NN 40436 5450 49 , , , 40436 5450 50 the the DT 40436 5450 51 debate debate NN 40436 5450 52 ends end VBZ 40436 5450 53 with with IN 40436 5450 54 general general JJ 40436 5450 55 mirth mirth NNP 40436 5450 56 , , , 40436 5450 57 in in IN 40436 5450 58 which which WDT 40436 5450 59 the the DT 40436 5450 60 couple couple NN 40436 5450 61 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5450 62 are be VBP 40436 5450 63 among among IN 40436 5450 64 the the DT 40436 5450 65 loudest loud JJS 40436 5450 66 . . . 40436 5451 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5451 2 19 19 CD 40436 5451 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5451 4 Lastly Lastly NNP 40436 5451 5 , , , 40436 5451 6 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5451 7 , , , 40436 5451 8 the the DT 40436 5451 9 youth youth NN 40436 5451 10 under under IN 40436 5451 11 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 5451 12 , , , 40436 5451 13 is be VBZ 40436 5451 14 a a DT 40436 5451 15 modest modest JJ 40436 5451 16 novice novice NN 40436 5451 17 ; ; : 40436 5451 18 not not RB 40436 5451 19 represented represent VBN 40436 5451 20 , , , 40436 5451 21 like like IN 40436 5451 22 Lysis lysis NN 40436 5451 23 in in IN 40436 5451 24 the the DT 40436 5451 25 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5451 26 just just RB 40436 5451 27 reviewed review VBN 40436 5451 28 , , , 40436 5451 29 as as IN 40436 5451 30 in in IN 40436 5451 31 danger danger NN 40436 5451 32 of of IN 40436 5451 33 corruption corruption NN 40436 5451 34 from from IN 40436 5451 35 the the DT 40436 5451 36 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 5451 37 flatteries flattery NNS 40436 5451 38 of of IN 40436 5451 39 an an DT 40436 5451 40 Erastes eraste NNS 40436 5451 41 , , , 40436 5451 42 nor nor CC 40436 5451 43 as as IN 40436 5451 44 requiring require VBG 40436 5451 45 a a DT 40436 5451 46 lowering lower VBG 40436 5451 47 medicine medicine NN 40436 5451 48 to to TO 40436 5451 49 be be VB 40436 5451 50 administered administer VBN 40436 5451 51 by by IN 40436 5451 52 a a DT 40436 5451 53 judicious judicious JJ 40436 5451 54 friend friend NN 40436 5451 55 . . . 40436 5452 1 When when WRB 40436 5452 2 the the DT 40436 5452 3 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 5452 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5452 5 historical historical JJ 40436 5452 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5452 7 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 5452 8 cross cross NN 40436 5452 9 - - NNS 40436 5452 10 examines examine NNS 40436 5452 11 and and CC 40436 5452 12 humiliates humiliate VBZ 40436 5452 13 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5452 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5452 15 a a DT 40436 5452 16 youth youth NN 40436 5452 17 , , , 40436 5452 18 but but CC 40436 5452 19 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5452 20 more more RBR 40436 5452 21 advanced advanced JJ 40436 5452 22 than than IN 40436 5452 23 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5452 24 in in IN 40436 5452 25 the the DT 40436 5452 26 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5452 27 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5452 28 is be VBZ 40436 5452 29 represented represent VBN 40436 5452 30 to to TO 40436 5452 31 be be VB 40436 5452 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5452 33 , , , 40436 5452 34 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5452 35 shall shall MD 40436 5452 36 see see VB 40436 5452 37 that that IN 40436 5452 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5452 39 not not RB 40436 5452 40 only only RB 40436 5452 41 lays lay VBZ 40436 5452 42 a a DT 40436 5452 43 train train NN 40436 5452 44 for for IN 40436 5452 45 the the DT 40436 5452 46 process process NN 40436 5452 47 by by IN 40436 5452 48 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 5452 49 suggestions suggestion NNS 40436 5452 50 , , , 40436 5452 51 but but CC 40436 5452 52 takes take VBZ 40436 5452 53 especial especial JJ 40436 5452 54 care care NN 40436 5452 55 to to TO 40436 5452 56 attack attack VB 40436 5452 57 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5452 58 when when WRB 40436 5452 59 alone alone RB 40436 5452 60 . . . 40436 5453 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5453 2 20 20 CD 40436 5453 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5453 4 The the DT 40436 5453 5 cross cross NN 40436 5453 6 - - NN 40436 5453 7 examination examination NN 40436 5453 8 pursued pursue VBN 40436 5453 9 by by IN 40436 5453 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5453 11 inflicts inflict NNS 40436 5453 12 upon upon IN 40436 5453 13 this this DT 40436 5453 14 accomplished accomplished JJ 40436 5453 15 young young JJ 40436 5453 16 man man NN 40436 5453 17 the the DT 40436 5453 18 severest severe JJS 40436 5453 19 distress distress NN 40436 5453 20 and and CC 40436 5453 21 humiliation humiliation NN 40436 5453 22 , , , 40436 5453 23 and and CC 40436 5453 24 would would MD 40436 5453 25 have have VB 40436 5453 26 been be VBN 40436 5453 27 utterly utterly RB 40436 5453 28 intolerable intolerable JJ 40436 5453 29 , , , 40436 5453 30 if if IN 40436 5453 31 there there EX 40436 5453 32 had have VBD 40436 5453 33 been be VBN 40436 5453 34 by by IN 40436 5453 35 - - HYPH 40436 5453 36 standers stander NNS 40436 5453 37 clapping clap VBG 40436 5453 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5453 39 hands hand NNS 40436 5453 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5453 41 as as IN 40436 5453 42 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5453 43 read read VBP 40436 5453 44 in in IN 40436 5453 45 the the DT 40436 5453 46 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5453 47 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5453 48 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5453 49 whenever whenever WRB 40436 5453 50 the the DT 40436 5453 51 respondent respondent NN 40436 5453 52 was be VBD 40436 5453 53 driven drive VBN 40436 5453 54 into into IN 40436 5453 55 a a DT 40436 5453 56 corner corner NN 40436 5453 57 . . . 40436 5454 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5454 2 see see VBP 40436 5454 3 that that IN 40436 5454 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5454 5 was be VBD 40436 5454 6 hardly hardly RB 40436 5454 7 tolerable tolerable JJ 40436 5454 8 even even RB 40436 5454 9 when when WRB 40436 5454 10 the the DT 40436 5454 11 respondent respondent NN 40436 5454 12 was be VBD 40436 5454 13 alone alone JJ 40436 5454 14 with with IN 40436 5454 15 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5454 16 ; ; : 40436 5454 17 for for IN 40436 5454 18 though though IN 40436 5454 19 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5454 20 bore bear VBD 40436 5454 21 up up RP 40436 5454 22 against against IN 40436 5454 23 the the DT 40436 5454 24 temporary temporary JJ 40436 5454 25 suffering suffering NN 40436 5454 26 , , , 40436 5454 27 cultivated cultivate VBD 40436 5454 28 the the DT 40436 5454 29 society society NN 40436 5454 30 of of IN 40436 5454 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5454 32 , , , 40436 5454 33 and and CC 40436 5454 34 was be VBD 40436 5454 35 handled handle VBN 40436 5454 36 by by IN 40436 5454 37 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5454 38 more more RBR 40436 5454 39 gently gently RB 40436 5454 40 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 5454 41 ; ; : 40436 5454 42 yet yet CC 40436 5454 43 there there EX 40436 5454 44 were be VBD 40436 5454 45 many many JJ 40436 5454 46 other other JJ 40436 5454 47 youths youth NNS 40436 5454 48 whom whom WP 40436 5454 49 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 5454 50 cross cross JJ 40436 5454 51 - - VBN 40436 5454 52 examined examine VBN 40436 5454 53 in in IN 40436 5454 54 the the DT 40436 5454 55 same same JJ 40436 5454 56 way way NN 40436 5454 57 , , , 40436 5454 58 and and CC 40436 5454 59 who who WP 40436 5454 60 suffered suffer VBD 40436 5454 61 so so RB 40436 5454 62 much much JJ 40436 5454 63 humiliation humiliation NN 40436 5454 64 from from IN 40436 5454 65 the the DT 40436 5454 66 first first JJ 40436 5454 67 solitary solitary JJ 40436 5454 68 colloquy colloquy NN 40436 5454 69 , , , 40436 5454 70 that that IN 40436 5454 71 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5454 72 never never RB 40436 5454 73 again again RB 40436 5454 74 came come VBD 40436 5454 75 near near IN 40436 5454 76 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5454 77 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5454 78 so so RB 40436 5454 79 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 5454 80 expressly expressly RB 40436 5454 81 tells tell VBZ 40436 5454 82 us)[21 us)[21 NNP 40436 5454 83 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5454 84 for for IN 40436 5454 85 a a DT 40436 5454 86 second second NN 40436 5454 87 . . . 40436 5455 1 This this DT 40436 5455 2 is be VBZ 40436 5455 3 quite quite RB 40436 5455 4 enough enough JJ 40436 5455 5 to to TO 40436 5455 6 show show VB 40436 5455 7 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5455 8 how how WRB 40436 5455 9 important important JJ 40436 5455 10 is be VBZ 40436 5455 11 the the DT 40436 5455 12 injunction injunction NN 40436 5455 13 delivered deliver VBN 40436 5455 14 in in IN 40436 5455 15 the the DT 40436 5455 16 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5455 17 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 5455 18 -- -- : 40436 5455 19 to to TO 40436 5455 20 carry carry VB 40436 5455 21 on on RP 40436 5455 22 these these DT 40436 5455 23 testing testing NN 40436 5455 24 colloquies colloquy NNS 40436 5455 25 apart apart RB 40436 5455 26 from from IN 40436 5455 27 indiscriminate indiscriminate JJ 40436 5455 28 auditors auditor NNS 40436 5455 29 , , , 40436 5455 30 in in IN 40436 5455 31 the the DT 40436 5455 32 presence presence NN 40436 5455 33 , , , 40436 5455 34 at at IN 40436 5455 35 most most RBS 40436 5455 36 , , , 40436 5455 37 of of IN 40436 5455 38 a a DT 40436 5455 39 few few JJ 40436 5455 40 select select JJ 40436 5455 41 companions companion NNS 40436 5455 42 . . . 40436 5456 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5456 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5456 3 18 18 CD 40436 5456 4 : : : 40436 5456 5 See see VB 40436 5456 6 the the DT 40436 5456 7 compliments compliment NNS 40436 5456 8 to to IN 40436 5456 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5456 10 , , , 40436 5456 11 on on IN 40436 5456 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5456 13 strenuous strenuous JJ 40436 5456 14 ardour ardour NN 40436 5456 15 and and CC 40436 5456 16 vocation vocation NN 40436 5456 17 for for IN 40436 5456 18 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5456 19 , , , 40436 5456 20 addressed address VBN 40436 5456 21 by by IN 40436 5456 22 Parmenides Parmenides NNP 40436 5456 23 , , , 40436 5456 24 p. p. NN 40436 5456 25 135 135 CD 40436 5456 26 D. D. NNP 40436 5456 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5456 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5456 29 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5456 30 19 19 CD 40436 5456 31 : : : 40436 5456 32 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5456 33 . . . 40436 5457 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5457 2 . . . 40436 5458 1 p. p. NN 40436 5458 2 303 303 CD 40436 5458 3 B. b. NN 40436 5459 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5459 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5459 3 : : : 40436 5459 4 E)ntau E)ntau NNP 40436 5459 5 = = SYM 40436 5459 6 tha tha VBP 40436 5459 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 5459 8 / / SYM 40436 5459 9 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 5459 10 , , , 40436 5459 11 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 5459 12 phi phi NNP 40436 5459 13 / / SYM 40436 5459 14 le le NNP 40436 5459 15 Kri Kri NNP 40436 5459 16 / / SYM 40436 5459 17 tôn tôn NNP 40436 5459 18 , , , 40436 5459 19 ou)deis ou)deis NNP 40436 5459 20 o(/stis o(/stis NNP 40436 5459 21 ou ou NNP 40436 5459 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5459 23 tô tô NNP 40436 5459 24 = = SYM 40436 5459 25 n n CC 40436 5459 26 paro paro NNP 40436 5459 27 / / SYM 40436 5459 28 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 5459 29 u(perepê u(perepê NNP 40436 5459 30 / / SYM 40436 5459 31 nese nese JJ 40436 5459 32 to\n to\n NNP 40436 5459 33 lo lo NNP 40436 5459 34 / / SYM 40436 5459 35 gon gon NNP 40436 5459 36 , , , 40436 5459 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5459 38 tô\ tô\ NNP 40436 5459 39 a)/ndre a)/ndre NNP 40436 5459 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5459 41 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5459 42 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5459 43 and and CC 40436 5459 44 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5459 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5459 46 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5459 47 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5459 48 : : : 40436 5459 49 gelô gelô NNP 40436 5459 50 = = SYM 40436 5459 51 nte nte NNP 40436 5459 52 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5459 53 krotou krotou NNP 40436 5459 54 = = SYM 40436 5459 55 nte nte NNP 40436 5459 56 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5459 57 chai chai NNP 40436 5459 58 / / SYM 40436 5459 59 ronte ronte NNP 40436 5459 60 o)li o)li NNP 40436 5459 61 / / SYM 40436 5459 62 gou gou NNP 40436 5459 63 pareta pareta NNP 40436 5459 64 / / SYM 40436 5459 65 thêsan thêsan NNP 40436 5459 66 . . . 40436 5459 67 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5459 68 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5460 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5460 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5460 3 20 20 CD 40436 5460 4 : : : 40436 5460 5 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 5460 6 . . . 40436 5461 1 Memor Memor NNP 40436 5461 2 . . . 40436 5462 1 iv iv XX 40436 5462 2 . . . 40436 5463 1 2 2 CD 40436 5463 2 , , , 40436 5463 3 5 5 CD 40436 5463 4 - - SYM 40436 5463 5 8 8 CD 40436 5463 6 . . . 40436 5464 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5464 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5464 3 : : : 40436 5464 4 ô(s ô(s NN 40436 5464 5 d d NN 40436 5464 6 ' ' '' 40436 5464 7 ê)/|stheto ê)/|stheto NN 40436 5464 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5464 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5464 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5464 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5464 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5464 13 Greek greek JJ 40436 5464 14 : : : 40436 5464 15 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 5464 16 e)toimo e)toimo NNP 40436 5464 17 / / SYM 40436 5464 18 teron teron NNP 40436 5464 19 u(pome u(pome NNP 40436 5464 20 / / SYM 40436 5464 21 nonta nonta NNP 40436 5464 22 , , , 40436 5464 23 o(/te o(/te NNP 40436 5464 24 diale diale NNP 40436 5464 25 / / SYM 40436 5464 26 goito goito NNP 40436 5464 27 , , , 40436 5464 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5464 29 prothumo prothumo NNP 40436 5464 30 / / SYM 40436 5464 31 teron teron NNP 40436 5464 32 a)kou a)kou NNP 40436 5464 33 / / SYM 40436 5464 34 onta onta NNP 40436 5464 35 , , , 40436 5464 36 _ _ NNP 40436 5464 37 mo mo NNP 40436 5464 38 / / SYM 40436 5464 39 nos nos NNP 40436 5464 40 ê)=lthen ê)=lthen NNP 40436 5464 41 _ _ NNP 40436 5464 42 ei)s ei)s JJ 40436 5464 43 to\ to\ NN 40436 5464 44 ê(niopoiei ê(niopoiei . 40436 5464 45 = = NFP 40436 5464 46 on on IN 40436 5464 47 ; ; : 40436 5464 48 parakathezome parakathezome NN 40436 5464 49 / / SYM 40436 5464 50 non non AFX 40436 5464 51 d d NN 40436 5464 52 ' ' POS 40436 5464 53 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 5464 54 tou= tou= NNP 40436 5464 55 Eu)thudê eu)thudê NN 40436 5464 56 / / SYM 40436 5464 57 mou mou NN 40436 5464 58 , , , 40436 5464 59 Ei)=pe/ Ei)=pe/ NNP 40436 5464 60 moi moi NNP 40436 5464 61 , , , 40436 5464 62 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 5464 63 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5464 64 , , , 40436 5464 65 & & CC 40436 5464 66 c. c. NNP 40436 5464 67 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5464 68 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5464 69 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5464 70 21 21 CD 40436 5464 71 : : : 40436 5464 72 Xen Xen NNP 40436 5464 73 . . . 40436 5465 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 5465 2 . . . 40436 5466 1 iv iv XX 40436 5466 2 . . . 40436 5467 1 2 2 CD 40436 5467 2 , , , 40436 5467 3 39 39 CD 40436 5467 4 - - SYM 40436 5467 5 40 40 CD 40436 5467 6 . . . 40436 5468 1 Compare compare VB 40436 5468 2 the the DT 40436 5468 3 remarks remark NNS 40436 5468 4 of of IN 40436 5468 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5468 6 in in IN 40436 5468 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5468 8 , , , 40436 5468 9 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 5468 10 , , , 40436 5468 11 p. p. NN 40436 5468 12 151 151 CD 40436 5468 13 C. c. NN 40436 5468 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5468 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5468 16 Side side NN 40436 5468 17 - - HYPH 40436 5468 18 note note NN 40436 5468 19 : : : 40436 5468 20 Opinion opinion NN 40436 5468 21 of of IN 40436 5468 22 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5468 23 and and CC 40436 5468 24 other other JJ 40436 5468 25 critics critic NNS 40436 5468 26 about about IN 40436 5468 27 the the DT 40436 5468 28 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5468 29 , , , 40436 5468 30 that that IN 40436 5468 31 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5468 32 and and CC 40436 5468 33 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5468 34 represent represent VBP 40436 5468 35 the the DT 40436 5468 36 way way NN 40436 5468 37 in in IN 40436 5468 38 which which WDT 40436 5468 39 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5468 40 and and CC 40436 5468 41 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 5468 42 talked talk VBD 40436 5468 43 to to IN 40436 5468 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5468 45 auditors auditor NNS 40436 5468 46 . . . 40436 5468 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5469 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5469 2 , , , 40436 5469 3 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 5469 4 , , , 40436 5469 5 and and CC 40436 5469 6 other other JJ 40436 5469 7 commentators commentator NNS 40436 5469 8 denounce denounce VBP 40436 5469 9 in in IN 40436 5469 10 severe severe JJ 40436 5469 11 terms term NNS 40436 5469 12 the the DT 40436 5469 13 Eristics Eristics NNPS 40436 5469 14 or or CC 40436 5469 15 controversial controversial JJ 40436 5469 16 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5469 17 of of IN 40436 5469 18 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5469 19 , , , 40436 5469 20 as as IN 40436 5469 21 disciples disciple NNS 40436 5469 22 of of IN 40436 5469 23 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5469 24 and and CC 40436 5469 25 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 5469 26 , , , 40436 5469 27 infected infect VBN 40436 5469 28 with with IN 40436 5469 29 the the DT 40436 5469 30 mania mania NN 40436 5469 31 of of IN 40436 5469 32 questioning question VBG 40436 5469 33 and and CC 40436 5469 34 disputing dispute VBG 40436 5469 35 every every DT 40436 5469 36 thing thing NN 40436 5469 37 , , , 40436 5469 38 and and CC 40436 5469 39 thereby thereby RB 40436 5469 40 corrupting corrupt VBG 40436 5469 41 the the DT 40436 5469 42 minds mind NNS 40436 5469 43 of of IN 40436 5469 44 youth youth NN 40436 5469 45 . . . 40436 5470 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5470 2 tell tell VBP 40436 5470 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5470 4 that that IN 40436 5470 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5470 6 was be VBD 40436 5470 7 the the DT 40436 5470 8 constant constant JJ 40436 5470 9 enemy enemy NN 40436 5470 10 of of IN 40436 5470 11 this this DT 40436 5470 12 school school NN 40436 5470 13 , , , 40436 5470 14 but but CC 40436 5470 15 that that IN 40436 5470 16 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5470 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5470 18 was be VBD 40436 5470 19 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 5470 20 confounded confound VBN 40436 5470 21 with with IN 40436 5470 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5470 23 by by IN 40436 5470 24 the the DT 40436 5470 25 comic comic JJ 40436 5470 26 poets poet NNS 40436 5470 27 , , , 40436 5470 28 and and CC 40436 5470 29 others other NNS 40436 5470 30 ; ; : 40436 5470 31 from from IN 40436 5470 32 which which WDT 40436 5470 33 confusion confusion NN 40436 5470 34 alone alone RB 40436 5470 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5470 36 unpopularity unpopularity NN 40436 5470 37 with with IN 40436 5470 38 the the DT 40436 5470 39 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 5470 40 people people NNS 40436 5470 41 arose arise VBD 40436 5470 42 . . . 40436 5471 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5471 2 22 22 CD 40436 5471 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5471 4 In in IN 40436 5471 5 the the DT 40436 5471 6 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5471 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5471 8 of of IN 40436 5471 9 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5471 10 the the DT 40436 5471 11 two two CD 40436 5471 12 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5471 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5471 14 according accord VBG 40436 5471 15 to to IN 40436 5471 16 these these DT 40436 5471 17 commentators commentator NNS 40436 5471 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5471 19 represent represent VBP 40436 5471 20 the the DT 40436 5471 21 way way NN 40436 5471 22 in in IN 40436 5471 23 which which WDT 40436 5471 24 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5471 25 and and CC 40436 5471 26 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 5471 27 with with IN 40436 5471 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5471 29 disciples disciple NNS 40436 5471 30 reasoned reason VBN 40436 5471 31 : : : 40436 5471 32 and and CC 40436 5471 33 the the DT 40436 5471 34 purpose purpose NN 40436 5471 35 of of IN 40436 5471 36 the the DT 40436 5471 37 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5471 38 is be VBZ 40436 5471 39 to to TO 40436 5471 40 contrast contrast VB 40436 5471 41 this this DT 40436 5471 42 with with IN 40436 5471 43 the the DT 40436 5471 44 way way NN 40436 5471 45 in in IN 40436 5471 46 which which WDT 40436 5471 47 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5471 48 reasoned reason VBD 40436 5471 49 . . . 40436 5472 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5472 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5472 3 22 22 CD 40436 5472 4 : : : 40436 5472 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5472 6 , , , 40436 5472 7 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 5472 8 . . . 40436 5473 1 ad ad NNP 40436 5473 2 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5473 3 . . . 40436 5474 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5474 2 . . . 40436 5475 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5475 2 . . . 40436 5476 1 9 9 CD 40436 5476 2 - - SYM 40436 5476 3 11 11 CD 40436 5476 4 - - SYM 40436 5476 5 13 13 CD 40436 5476 6 ; ; : 40436 5476 7 Winckelmann Winckelmann NNP 40436 5476 8 , , , 40436 5476 9 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 5476 10 . . . 40436 5477 1 ad ad NN 40436 5477 2 eundem eundem NNP 40436 5477 3 , , , 40436 5477 4 pp pp NNP 40436 5477 5 . . . 40436 5478 1 xxxiii.-xxxiv xxxiii.-xxxiv NNP 40436 5478 2 . . . 40436 5478 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5479 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5479 2 Side side NN 40436 5479 3 - - HYPH 40436 5479 4 note note NN 40436 5479 5 : : : 40436 5479 6 That that DT 40436 5479 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 5479 8 is be VBZ 40436 5479 9 unfounded unfounded JJ 40436 5479 10 . . . 40436 5480 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5480 2 was be VBD 40436 5480 3 much much RB 40436 5480 4 more more RBR 40436 5480 5 Eristic eristic JJ 40436 5480 6 than than IN 40436 5480 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5480 8 , , , 40436 5480 9 who who WP 40436 5480 10 generally generally RB 40436 5480 11 manifested manifest VBD 40436 5480 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5480 13 by by IN 40436 5480 14 continuous continuous JJ 40436 5480 15 speech speech NN 40436 5480 16 or or CC 40436 5480 17 lecture lecture NN 40436 5480 18 . . . 40436 5480 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5481 1 Now now RB 40436 5481 2 , , , 40436 5481 3 in in IN 40436 5481 4 this this DT 40436 5481 5 opinion opinion NN 40436 5481 6 , , , 40436 5481 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5481 8 think think VBP 40436 5481 9 that that IN 40436 5481 10 there there EX 40436 5481 11 is be VBZ 40436 5481 12 much much JJ 40436 5481 13 of of IN 40436 5481 14 unfounded unfounded JJ 40436 5481 15 assumption assumption NN 40436 5481 16 , , , 40436 5481 17 as as RB 40436 5481 18 well well RB 40436 5481 19 as as IN 40436 5481 20 a a DT 40436 5481 21 misconception misconception NN 40436 5481 22 of of IN 40436 5481 23 the the DT 40436 5481 24 real real JJ 40436 5481 25 contrast contrast NN 40436 5481 26 intended intend VBN 40436 5481 27 in in IN 40436 5481 28 the the DT 40436 5481 29 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5481 30 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5481 31 . . . 40436 5482 1 Comparing compare VBG 40436 5482 2 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5482 3 with with IN 40436 5482 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5482 5 , , , 40436 5482 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5482 7 maintain maintain VBP 40436 5482 8 that that IN 40436 5482 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5482 10 was be VBD 40436 5482 11 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 5482 12 the the DT 40436 5482 13 more more RBR 40436 5482 14 Eristic eristic JJ 40436 5482 15 of of IN 40436 5482 16 the the DT 40436 5482 17 two two CD 40436 5482 18 , , , 40436 5482 19 and and CC 40436 5482 20 left leave VBD 40436 5482 21 behind behind IN 40436 5482 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5482 23 a a DT 40436 5482 24 greater great JJR 40436 5482 25 number number NN 40436 5482 26 of of IN 40436 5482 27 active active JJ 40436 5482 28 disciples disciple NNS 40436 5482 29 . . . 40436 5483 1 In in IN 40436 5483 2 so so RB 40436 5483 3 far far RB 40436 5483 4 as as IN 40436 5483 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5483 6 can can MD 40436 5483 7 trust trust VB 40436 5483 8 the the DT 40436 5483 9 picture picture NN 40436 5483 10 given give VBN 40436 5483 11 by by IN 40436 5483 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5483 13 in in IN 40436 5483 14 the the DT 40436 5483 15 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5483 16 called call VBN 40436 5483 17 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5483 18 , , , 40436 5483 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5483 20 learn learn VBP 40436 5483 21 that that IN 40436 5483 22 the the DT 40436 5483 23 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5483 24 of of IN 40436 5483 25 that that DT 40436 5483 26 name name NN 40436 5483 27 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 5483 28 manifested manifest VBD 40436 5483 29 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5483 30 in in IN 40436 5483 31 long long JJ 40436 5483 32 continuous continuous JJ 40436 5483 33 speeches speech NNS 40436 5483 34 or or CC 40436 5483 35 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 5483 36 ; ; : 40436 5483 37 and and CC 40436 5483 38 though though IN 40436 5483 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5483 40 also also RB 40436 5483 41 professed profess VBD 40436 5483 42 , , , 40436 5483 43 if if IN 40436 5483 44 required require VBN 40436 5483 45 , , , 40436 5483 46 to to TO 40436 5483 47 enter enter VB 40436 5483 48 into into IN 40436 5483 49 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 5483 50 colloquy colloquy NN 40436 5483 51 , , , 40436 5483 52 in in IN 40436 5483 53 this this DT 40436 5483 54 art art NN 40436 5483 55 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5483 56 was be VBD 40436 5483 57 no no DT 40436 5483 58 match match NN 40436 5483 59 for for IN 40436 5483 60 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5483 61 . . . 40436 5484 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5484 2 23 23 CD 40436 5484 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5484 4 Moreover moreover RB 40436 5484 5 , , , 40436 5484 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5484 7 know know VBP 40436 5484 8 by by IN 40436 5484 9 the the DT 40436 5484 10 evidence evidence NN 40436 5484 11 of of IN 40436 5484 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5484 13 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5484 14 , , , 40436 5484 15 that that IN 40436 5484 16 _ _ NNP 40436 5484 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5484 18 _ _ NNP 40436 5484 19 was be VBD 40436 5484 20 an an DT 40436 5484 21 Eristic Eristic NNP 40436 5484 22 not not RB 40436 5484 23 only only RB 40436 5484 24 by by IN 40436 5484 25 taste taste NN 40436 5484 26 , , , 40436 5484 27 but but CC 40436 5484 28 on on IN 40436 5484 29 principle principle NN 40436 5484 30 , , , 40436 5484 31 and and CC 40436 5484 32 by by IN 40436 5484 33 a a DT 40436 5484 34 sense sense NN 40436 5484 35 of of IN 40436 5484 36 duty duty NN 40436 5484 37 . . . 40436 5485 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5485 2 tells tell VBZ 40436 5485 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5485 4 , , , 40436 5485 5 in in IN 40436 5485 6 the the DT 40436 5485 7 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5485 8 Apology Apology NNP 40436 5485 9 , , , 40436 5485 10 that that IN 40436 5485 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5485 12 felt feel VBD 40436 5485 13 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5485 14 under under IN 40436 5485 15 a a DT 40436 5485 16 divine divine JJ 40436 5485 17 mission mission NN 40436 5485 18 to to TO 40436 5485 19 go go VB 40436 5485 20 about about IN 40436 5485 21 convicting convict VBG 40436 5485 22 men man NNS 40436 5485 23 of of IN 40436 5485 24 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 5485 25 , , , 40436 5485 26 and and CC 40436 5485 27 that that IN 40436 5485 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5485 29 had have VBD 40436 5485 30 prosecuted prosecute VBN 40436 5485 31 this this DT 40436 5485 32 vocation vocation NN 40436 5485 33 throughout throughout IN 40436 5485 34 many many JJ 40436 5485 35 years year NNS 40436 5485 36 of of IN 40436 5485 37 a a DT 40436 5485 38 long long JJ 40436 5485 39 life life NN 40436 5485 40 . . . 40436 5486 1 Every every DT 40436 5486 2 one one CD 40436 5486 3 of of IN 40436 5486 4 these these DT 40436 5486 5 convictions conviction NNS 40436 5486 6 must must MD 40436 5486 7 have have VB 40436 5486 8 been be VBN 40436 5486 9 brought bring VBN 40436 5486 10 about about RP 40436 5486 11 by by IN 40436 5486 12 one one CD 40436 5486 13 or or CC 40436 5486 14 more more JJR 40436 5486 15 disputes dispute NNS 40436 5486 16 of of IN 40436 5486 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5486 18 own own JJ 40436 5486 19 seeking seeking NN 40436 5486 20 : : : 40436 5486 21 every every DT 40436 5486 22 such such JJ 40436 5486 23 dispute dispute NN 40436 5486 24 , , , 40436 5486 25 with with IN 40436 5486 26 occasional occasional JJ 40436 5486 27 exceptions exception NNS 40436 5486 28 , , , 40436 5486 29 made make VBD 40436 5486 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5486 31 unpopular unpopular JJ 40436 5486 32 , , , 40436 5486 33 in in IN 40436 5486 34 the the DT 40436 5486 35 outset outset NN 40436 5486 36 at at IN 40436 5486 37 least least JJS 40436 5486 38 , , , 40436 5486 39 with with IN 40436 5486 40 the the DT 40436 5486 41 person person NN 40436 5486 42 convicted convict VBN 40436 5486 43 : : : 40436 5486 44 the the DT 40436 5486 45 rather rather RB 40436 5486 46 , , , 40436 5486 47 as as IN 40436 5486 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5486 49 ability ability NN 40436 5486 50 in in IN 40436 5486 51 the the DT 40436 5486 52 process process NN 40436 5486 53 is be VBZ 40436 5486 54 known know VBN 40436 5486 55 , , , 40436 5486 56 upon upon IN 40436 5486 57 the the DT 40436 5486 58 testimony testimony NN 40436 5486 59 of of IN 40436 5486 60 Xenophon[24 Xenophon[24 NNP 40436 5486 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5486 62 as as RB 40436 5486 63 well well RB 40436 5486 64 as as IN 40436 5486 65 of of IN 40436 5486 66 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5486 67 , , , 40436 5486 68 to to TO 40436 5486 69 have have VB 40436 5486 70 been be VBN 40436 5486 71 consummate consummate JJ 40436 5486 72 . . . 40436 5487 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5487 2 is be VBZ 40436 5487 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 5487 4 a a DT 40436 5487 5 mistake mistake NN 40436 5487 6 to to TO 40436 5487 7 decry decry VB 40436 5487 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5487 9 and and CC 40436 5487 10 the the DT 40436 5487 11 Protagoreans Protagoreans NNPS 40436 5487 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5487 13 if if IN 40436 5487 14 there there EX 40436 5487 15 were be VBD 40436 5487 16 any any DT 40436 5487 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5487 18 as as IN 40436 5487 19 the the DT 40436 5487 20 special special JJ 40436 5487 21 Eristics Eristics NNPS 40436 5487 22 , , , 40436 5487 23 and and CC 40436 5487 24 to to TO 40436 5487 25 represent represent VB 40436 5487 26 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5487 27 as as IN 40436 5487 28 a a DT 40436 5487 29 tutelary tutelary JJ 40436 5487 30 genius genius NN 40436 5487 31 , , , 40436 5487 32 the the DT 40436 5487 33 opponent opponent NN 40436 5487 34 of of IN 40436 5487 35 such such JJ 40436 5487 36 habits habit NNS 40436 5487 37 . . . 40436 5488 1 If if IN 40436 5488 2 the the DT 40436 5488 3 commentators commentator NNS 40436 5488 4 are be VBP 40436 5488 5 right right JJ 40436 5488 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5488 7 which which WDT 40436 5488 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5488 9 do do VBP 40436 5488 10 not not RB 40436 5488 11 think think VB 40436 5488 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5488 13 are be VBP 40436 5488 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5488 15 in in IN 40436 5488 16 declaring declare VBG 40436 5488 17 the the DT 40436 5488 18 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 5488 19 mind mind NN 40436 5488 20 to to TO 40436 5488 21 have have VB 40436 5488 22 been be VBN 40436 5488 23 perverted pervert VBN 40436 5488 24 by by IN 40436 5488 25 Eristic Eristic NNP 40436 5488 26 , , , 40436 5488 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5488 28 is be VBZ 40436 5488 29 much much RB 40436 5488 30 more more RBR 40436 5488 31 chargeable chargeable JJ 40436 5488 32 with with IN 40436 5488 33 the the DT 40436 5488 34 mischief mischief NN 40436 5488 35 than than IN 40436 5488 36 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5488 37 . . . 40436 5489 1 And and CC 40436 5489 2 the the DT 40436 5489 3 comic comic JJ 40436 5489 4 poets poet NNS 40436 5489 5 , , , 40436 5489 6 when when WRB 40436 5489 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5489 8 treated treat VBD 40436 5489 9 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5489 10 as as IN 40436 5489 11 a a DT 40436 5489 12 specimen speciman NNS 40436 5489 13 and and CC 40436 5489 14 teacher teacher NN 40436 5489 15 of of IN 40436 5489 16 Eristic Eristic NNP 40436 5489 17 , , , 40436 5489 18 proceeded proceed VBD 40436 5489 19 very very RB 40436 5489 20 naturally naturally RB 40436 5489 21 upon upon IN 40436 5489 22 what what WP 40436 5489 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5489 24 actually actually RB 40436 5489 25 saw see VBD 40436 5489 26 or or CC 40436 5489 27 heard hear VBD 40436 5489 28 of of IN 40436 5489 29 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5489 30 . . . 40436 5490 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5490 2 25 25 CD 40436 5490 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5490 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5490 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5490 6 23 23 CD 40436 5490 7 : : : 40436 5490 8 See see VB 40436 5490 9 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5490 10 . . . 40436 5491 1 Protag Protag NNP 40436 5491 2 . . . 40436 5491 3 , , , 40436 5491 4 especially especially RB 40436 5491 5 pp pp NNP 40436 5491 6 . . . 40436 5492 1 329 329 CD 40436 5492 2 and and CC 40436 5492 3 336 336 CD 40436 5492 4 . . . 40436 5493 1 About about IN 40436 5493 2 the the DT 40436 5493 3 eristic eristic JJ 40436 5493 4 disposition disposition NN 40436 5493 5 of of IN 40436 5493 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5493 7 , , , 40436 5493 8 see see VB 40436 5493 9 the the DT 40436 5493 10 striking striking JJ 40436 5493 11 passage passage NN 40436 5493 12 in in IN 40436 5493 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5493 14 , , , 40436 5493 15 Theætêt Theætêt NNP 40436 5493 16 . . . 40436 5494 1 169 169 CD 40436 5494 2 B B NNP 40436 5494 3 - - HYPH 40436 5494 4 C C NNP 40436 5494 5 ; ; : 40436 5494 6 also also RB 40436 5494 7 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 5494 8 , , , 40436 5494 9 187 187 CD 40436 5494 10 , , , 40436 5494 11 188 188 CD 40436 5494 12 . . . 40436 5494 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5495 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5495 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5495 3 24 24 CD 40436 5495 4 : : : 40436 5495 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 5495 6 . . . 40436 5496 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 5496 2 . . . 40436 5497 1 i. i. NNP 40436 5498 1 2 2 LS 40436 5498 2 . . . 40436 5498 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5499 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5499 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5499 3 25 25 CD 40436 5499 4 : : : 40436 5499 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5499 6 , , , 40436 5499 7 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 5499 8 . . . 40436 5500 1 in in IN 40436 5500 2 Platon Platon NNP 40436 5500 3 . . . 40436 5501 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5501 2 . . . 40436 5502 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5502 2 . . . 40436 5503 1 50 50 CD 40436 5503 2 - - SYM 40436 5503 3 51 51 CD 40436 5503 4 . . . 40436 5504 1 " " `` 40436 5504 2 Sed Sed NNP 40436 5504 3 hoc hoc FW 40436 5504 4 utcunque utcunque FW 40436 5504 5 se se FW 40436 5504 6 habet habet NN 40436 5504 7 , , , 40436 5504 8 illud illud NNP 40436 5504 9 quidem quidem NNP 40436 5504 10 ex ex NNP 40436 5504 11 Aristophane Aristophane NNP 40436 5504 12 pariter pariter NN 40436 5504 13 atque atque NN 40436 5504 14 ex ex FW 40436 5504 15 ipso ipso FW 40436 5504 16 Platone Platone NNP 40436 5504 17 evidenter evidenter NN 40436 5504 18 apparet apparet NN 40436 5504 19 , , , 40436 5504 20 Socratem Socratem NNP 40436 5504 21 non non JJ 40436 5504 22 tantum tantum NN 40436 5504 23 ab ab NNP 40436 5504 24 orationum orationum NNP 40436 5504 25 scriptoribus scriptoribus NNP 40436 5504 26 , , , 40436 5504 27 sed sed NNP 40436 5504 28 etiam etiam NNP 40436 5504 29 ab ab NNP 40436 5504 30 aliis aliis NNP 40436 5504 31 , , , 40436 5504 32 in in IN 40436 5504 33 vanissimorum vanissimorum NN 40436 5504 34 sophistaram sophistaram NNP 40436 5504 35 loco loco NNP 40436 5504 36 habitum habitum NNP 40436 5504 37 fuisse fuisse NNP 40436 5504 38 . . . 40436 5504 39 " " '' 40436 5504 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5505 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5505 2 Side side NN 40436 5505 3 - - HYPH 40436 5505 4 note note NN 40436 5505 5 : : : 40436 5505 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5505 7 in in IN 40436 5505 8 the the DT 40436 5505 9 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5505 10 is be VBZ 40436 5505 11 drawn draw VBN 40436 5505 12 suitably suitably RB 40436 5505 13 to to IN 40436 5505 14 the the DT 40436 5505 15 purpose purpose NN 40436 5505 16 of of IN 40436 5505 17 that that DT 40436 5505 18 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5505 19 . . . 40436 5505 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5506 1 The the DT 40436 5506 2 fact fact NN 40436 5506 3 is be VBZ 40436 5506 4 , , , 40436 5506 5 that that IN 40436 5506 6 the the DT 40436 5506 7 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5506 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5506 9 when when WRB 40436 5506 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5506 11 talks talk VBZ 40436 5506 12 with with IN 40436 5506 13 the the DT 40436 5506 14 two two CD 40436 5506 15 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5506 16 in in IN 40436 5506 17 the the DT 40436 5506 18 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5506 19 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5506 20 , , , 40436 5506 21 is be VBZ 40436 5506 22 a a DT 40436 5506 23 character character NN 40436 5506 24 drawn draw VBN 40436 5506 25 by by IN 40436 5506 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5506 27 for for IN 40436 5506 28 the the DT 40436 5506 29 purpose purpose NN 40436 5506 30 of of IN 40436 5506 31 that that DT 40436 5506 32 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5506 33 , , , 40436 5506 34 and and CC 40436 5506 35 is be VBZ 40436 5506 36 very very RB 40436 5506 37 different different JJ 40436 5506 38 from from IN 40436 5506 39 the the DT 40436 5506 40 real real JJ 40436 5506 41 historical historical JJ 40436 5506 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5506 43 , , , 40436 5506 44 whom whom WP 40436 5506 45 the the DT 40436 5506 46 public public NN 40436 5506 47 of of IN 40436 5506 48 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5506 49 saw see VBD 40436 5506 50 and and CC 40436 5506 51 heard hear VBD 40436 5506 52 in in IN 40436 5506 53 the the DT 40436 5506 54 market market NN 40436 5506 55 - - HYPH 40436 5506 56 place place NN 40436 5506 57 or or CC 40436 5506 58 gymnasia gymnasia NN 40436 5506 59 . . . 40436 5507 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5507 2 is be VBZ 40436 5507 3 depicted depict VBN 40436 5507 4 as as IN 40436 5507 5 a a DT 40436 5507 6 gentle gentle JJ 40436 5507 7 , , , 40436 5507 8 soothing soothing JJ 40436 5507 9 , , , 40436 5507 10 encouraging encouraging JJ 40436 5507 11 talker talker NN 40436 5507 12 , , , 40436 5507 13 with with IN 40436 5507 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5507 15 claws claws NN 40436 5507 16 drawn draw VBN 40436 5507 17 in in RB 40436 5507 18 , , , 40436 5507 19 and and CC 40436 5507 20 affecting affect VBG 40436 5507 21 inability inability NN 40436 5507 22 even even RB 40436 5507 23 to to TO 40436 5507 24 hold hold VB 40436 5507 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5507 26 own own JJ 40436 5507 27 against against IN 40436 5507 28 the the DT 40436 5507 29 two two CD 40436 5507 30 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5507 31 : : : 40436 5507 32 such such JJ 40436 5507 33 indeed indeed RB 40436 5507 34 as as IN 40436 5507 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5507 36 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 5507 37 may may MD 40436 5507 38 have have VB 40436 5507 39 been be VBN 40436 5507 40 in in IN 40436 5507 41 conversing converse VBG 40436 5507 42 with with IN 40436 5507 43 particular particular JJ 40436 5507 44 persons person NNS 40436 5507 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5507 46 so so RB 40436 5507 47 Xenophon[26 Xenophon[26 NNP 40436 5507 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5507 49 takes take VBZ 40436 5507 50 pains pain NNS 40436 5507 51 to to TO 40436 5507 52 remind remind VB 40436 5507 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5507 54 readers reader NNS 40436 5507 55 in in IN 40436 5507 56 the the DT 40436 5507 57 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 5507 58 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5507 59 , , , 40436 5507 60 but but CC 40436 5507 61 with with IN 40436 5507 62 entire entire JJ 40436 5507 63 elimination elimination NN 40436 5507 64 of of IN 40436 5507 65 that that DT 40436 5507 66 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 5507 67 aggressive aggressive JJ 40436 5507 68 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 5507 69 for for IN 40436 5507 70 which which WDT 40436 5507 71 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5507 72 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5507 73 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5507 74 in in IN 40436 5507 75 the the DT 40436 5507 76 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5507 77 Apology Apology NNP 40436 5507 78 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5507 79 takes take VBZ 40436 5507 80 credit credit NN 40436 5507 81 , , , 40436 5507 82 and and CC 40436 5507 83 which which WDT 40436 5507 84 the the DT 40436 5507 85 auditors auditor NNS 40436 5507 86 usually usually RB 40436 5507 87 heard hear VBD 40436 5507 88 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5507 89 exhibit exhibit NN 40436 5507 90 . . . 40436 5508 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5508 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5508 3 26 26 CD 40436 5508 4 : : : 40436 5508 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 5508 6 . . . 40436 5509 1 Mem Mem NNP 40436 5509 2 . . . 40436 5510 1 i. i. NNP 40436 5511 1 4 4 CD 40436 5511 2 , , , 40436 5511 3 1 1 CD 40436 5511 4 ; ; : 40436 5511 5 iv iv LS 40436 5511 6 . . . 40436 5512 1 2 2 CD 40436 5512 2 , , , 40436 5512 3 40 40 CD 40436 5512 4 . . . 40436 5512 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5513 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5513 2 Side side NN 40436 5513 3 - - HYPH 40436 5513 4 note note NN 40436 5513 5 : : : 40436 5513 6 The the DT 40436 5513 7 two two CD 40436 5513 8 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5513 9 in in IN 40436 5513 10 the the DT 40436 5513 11 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5513 12 are be VBP 40436 5513 13 not not RB 40436 5513 14 to to TO 40436 5513 15 be be VB 40436 5513 16 taken take VBN 40436 5513 17 as as IN 40436 5513 18 real real JJ 40436 5513 19 persons person NNS 40436 5513 20 , , , 40436 5513 21 or or CC 40436 5513 22 representatives representative NNS 40436 5513 23 of of IN 40436 5513 24 real real JJ 40436 5513 25 persons person NNS 40436 5513 26 . . . 40436 5513 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5514 1 This this DT 40436 5514 2 picture picture NN 40436 5514 3 , , , 40436 5514 4 accurate accurate JJ 40436 5514 5 or or CC 40436 5514 6 not not RB 40436 5514 7 , , , 40436 5514 8 suited suit VBD 40436 5514 9 the the DT 40436 5514 10 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 5514 11 scheme scheme NN 40436 5514 12 of of IN 40436 5514 13 the the DT 40436 5514 14 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5514 15 . . . 40436 5515 1 Such such JJ 40436 5515 2 , , , 40436 5515 3 in in IN 40436 5515 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5515 5 judgment judgment NN 40436 5515 6 , , , 40436 5515 7 is be VBZ 40436 5515 8 the the DT 40436 5515 9 value value NN 40436 5515 10 and and CC 40436 5515 11 meaning meaning NN 40436 5515 12 of of IN 40436 5515 13 the the DT 40436 5515 14 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5515 15 , , , 40436 5515 16 as as RB 40436 5515 17 far far RB 40436 5515 18 as as IN 40436 5515 19 regards regard VBZ 40436 5515 20 personal personal JJ 40436 5515 21 contrasts contrast NNS 40436 5515 22 . . . 40436 5516 1 One one CD 40436 5516 2 style style NN 40436 5516 3 of of IN 40436 5516 4 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5516 5 is be VBZ 40436 5516 6 represented represent VBN 40436 5516 7 by by IN 40436 5516 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5516 9 , , , 40436 5516 10 the the DT 40436 5516 11 other other JJ 40436 5516 12 by by IN 40436 5516 13 the the DT 40436 5516 14 two two CD 40436 5516 15 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5516 16 : : : 40436 5516 17 both both DT 40436 5516 18 are be VBP 40436 5516 19 the the DT 40436 5516 20 creatures creature NNS 40436 5516 21 of of IN 40436 5516 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5516 23 , , , 40436 5516 24 having have VBG 40436 5516 25 the the DT 40436 5516 26 same same JJ 40436 5516 27 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 5516 28 reality reality NN 40436 5516 29 as as IN 40436 5516 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5516 31 and and CC 40436 5516 32 Strepsiades Strepsiades NNPS 40436 5516 33 , , , 40436 5516 34 or or CC 40436 5516 35 the the DT 40436 5516 36 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5516 37 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5516 38 : : : 40436 5516 39 Di Di NNP 40436 5516 40 / / SYM 40436 5516 41 kaios kaio NNS 40436 5516 42 Lo Lo NNP 40436 5516 43 / / SYM 40436 5516 44 gos gos NN 40436 5516 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5516 46 and and CC 40436 5516 47 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5516 48 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5516 49 : : : 40436 5516 50 A)/dikos A)/dikos NNP 40436 5516 51 Lo Lo NNP 40436 5516 52 / / , 40436 5516 53 gos gos NNP 40436 5516 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5516 55 , , , 40436 5516 56 of of IN 40436 5516 57 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40436 5516 58 , , , 40436 5516 59 but but CC 40436 5516 60 no no DT 40436 5516 61 more more JJR 40436 5516 62 . . . 40436 5517 1 That that IN 40436 5517 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5517 3 correspond correspond VBP 40436 5517 4 to to IN 40436 5517 5 any any DT 40436 5517 6 actual actual JJ 40436 5517 7 persons person NNS 40436 5517 8 at at IN 40436 5517 9 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5517 10 , , , 40436 5517 11 is be VBZ 40436 5517 12 neither neither DT 40436 5517 13 proved proved JJ 40436 5517 14 nor nor CC 40436 5517 15 probable probable JJ 40436 5517 16 . . . 40436 5518 1 The the DT 40436 5518 2 comic comic JJ 40436 5518 3 poets poet NNS 40436 5518 4 introduce introduce VBP 40436 5518 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5518 6 as as IN 40436 5518 7 talking talk VBG 40436 5518 8 what what WP 40436 5518 9 was be VBD 40436 5518 10 either either CC 40436 5518 11 nonsensical nonsensical JJ 40436 5518 12 , , , 40436 5518 13 or or CC 40436 5518 14 offensive offensive JJ 40436 5518 15 to to IN 40436 5518 16 the the DT 40436 5518 17 feelings feeling NNS 40436 5518 18 of of IN 40436 5518 19 the the DT 40436 5518 20 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 5518 21 : : : 40436 5518 22 and and CC 40436 5518 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5518 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5518 25 in in IN 40436 5518 26 the the DT 40436 5518 27 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5518 28 Apology Apology NNP 40436 5518 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5518 30 complains complain VBZ 40436 5518 31 that that IN 40436 5518 32 the the DT 40436 5518 33 Dikasts Dikasts NNPS 40436 5518 34 judged judge VBD 40436 5518 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5518 36 , , , 40436 5518 37 not not RB 40436 5518 38 according accord VBG 40436 5518 39 to to IN 40436 5518 40 what what WP 40436 5518 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5518 42 had have VBD 40436 5518 43 really really RB 40436 5518 44 said say VBN 40436 5518 45 or or CC 40436 5518 46 done do VBN 40436 5518 47 , , , 40436 5518 48 but but CC 40436 5518 49 according accord VBG 40436 5518 50 to to IN 40436 5518 51 the the DT 40436 5518 52 impression impression NN 40436 5518 53 made make VBN 40436 5518 54 on on IN 40436 5518 55 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5518 56 by by IN 40436 5518 57 this this DT 40436 5518 58 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 5518 59 picture picture NN 40436 5518 60 . . . 40436 5519 1 The the DT 40436 5519 2 Athenian Athenian NNP 40436 5519 3 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5519 4 would would MD 40436 5519 5 have have VB 40436 5519 6 equal equal JJ 40436 5519 7 right right NN 40436 5519 8 to to TO 40436 5519 9 complain complain VB 40436 5519 10 of of IN 40436 5519 11 those those DT 40436 5519 12 critics critic NNS 40436 5519 13 , , , 40436 5519 14 who who WP 40436 5519 15 not not RB 40436 5519 16 only only RB 40436 5519 17 speak speak VBP 40436 5519 18 of of IN 40436 5519 19 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5519 20 and and CC 40436 5519 21 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5519 22 with with IN 40436 5519 23 a a DT 40436 5519 24 degree degree NN 40436 5519 25 of of IN 40436 5519 26 acrimony acrimony NNP 40436 5519 27 applicable applicable JJ 40436 5519 28 only only RB 40436 5519 29 to to IN 40436 5519 30 historical historical JJ 40436 5519 31 persons person NNS 40436 5519 32 , , , 40436 5519 33 but but CC 40436 5519 34 also also RB 40436 5519 35 describe describe VB 40436 5519 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5519 37 as as IN 40436 5519 38 representative representative JJ 40436 5519 39 types type NNS 40436 5519 40 of of IN 40436 5519 41 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5519 42 , , , 40436 5519 43 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 5519 44 , , , 40436 5519 45 and and CC 40436 5519 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5519 47 disciples disciple NNS 40436 5519 48 . . . 40436 5520 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5520 2 27 27 CD 40436 5520 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5520 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5520 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5520 6 27 27 CD 40436 5520 7 : : : 40436 5520 8 The the DT 40436 5520 9 language language NN 40436 5520 10 of of IN 40436 5520 11 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5520 12 is be VBZ 40436 5520 13 more more RBR 40436 5520 14 moderate moderate JJ 40436 5520 15 than than IN 40436 5520 16 that that DT 40436 5520 17 of of IN 40436 5520 18 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5520 19 , , , 40436 5520 20 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 5520 21 , , , 40436 5520 22 and and CC 40436 5520 23 others other NNS 40436 5520 24 . . . 40436 5521 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5521 2 thinks think VBZ 40436 5521 3 moreover moreover RB 40436 5521 4 , , , 40436 5521 5 that that IN 40436 5521 6 the the DT 40436 5521 7 polemical polemical JJ 40436 5521 8 purpose purpose NN 40436 5521 9 of of IN 40436 5521 10 this this DT 40436 5521 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5521 12 is be VBZ 40436 5521 13 directed direct VBN 40436 5521 14 not not RB 40436 5521 15 against against IN 40436 5521 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5521 17 or or CC 40436 5521 18 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 5521 19 , , , 40436 5521 20 but but CC 40436 5521 21 against against IN 40436 5521 22 the the DT 40436 5521 23 Megarics Megarics NNP 40436 5521 24 and and CC 40436 5521 25 against against IN 40436 5521 26 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNPS 40436 5521 27 , , , 40436 5521 28 who who WP 40436 5521 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5521 30 so so RB 40436 5521 31 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5521 32 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 5521 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5521 34 had have VBD 40436 5521 35 brought bring VBN 40436 5521 36 the the DT 40436 5521 37 attack attack NN 40436 5521 38 upon upon IN 40436 5521 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5521 40 by by IN 40436 5521 41 attacking attack VBG 40436 5521 42 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5521 43 first first RB 40436 5521 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5521 45 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 5521 46 zum zum NNP 40436 5521 47 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 5521 48 . . . 40436 5522 1 p. p. NN 40436 5522 2 404 404 CD 40436 5522 3 seq seq NN 40436 5522 4 . . . 40436 5522 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5522 6 . . . 40436 5523 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 5523 2 can can MD 40436 5523 3 not not RB 40436 5523 4 make make VB 40436 5523 5 out out RP 40436 5523 6 who who WP 40436 5523 7 the the DT 40436 5523 8 two two CD 40436 5523 9 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5523 10 were be VBD 40436 5523 11 personally personally RB 40436 5523 12 , , , 40436 5523 13 but but CC 40436 5523 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5523 15 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 5523 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5523 17 as as IN 40436 5523 18 obscure obscure JJ 40436 5523 19 persons person NNS 40436 5523 20 , , , 40436 5523 21 deserving deserve VBG 40436 5523 22 no no DT 40436 5523 23 notice notice NN 40436 5523 24 . . . 40436 5524 1 This this DT 40436 5524 2 is be VBZ 40436 5524 3 a a DT 40436 5524 4 conjecture conjecture NN 40436 5524 5 which which WDT 40436 5524 6 admits admit VBZ 40436 5524 7 of of IN 40436 5524 8 no no DT 40436 5524 9 proof proof NN 40436 5524 10 ; ; : 40436 5524 11 but but CC 40436 5524 12 if if IN 40436 5524 13 any any DT 40436 5524 14 real real JJ 40436 5524 15 victim victim NN 40436 5524 16 is be VBZ 40436 5524 17 here here RB 40436 5524 18 intended intend VBN 40436 5524 19 by by IN 40436 5524 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5524 21 , , , 40436 5524 22 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5524 23 may may MD 40436 5524 24 just just RB 40436 5524 25 as as RB 40436 5524 26 reasonably reasonably RB 40436 5524 27 suppose suppose VB 40436 5524 28 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNPS 40436 5524 29 as as IN 40436 5524 30 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5524 31 . . . 40436 5524 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5525 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5525 2 Side side NN 40436 5525 3 - - HYPH 40436 5525 4 note note NN 40436 5525 5 : : : 40436 5525 6 Colloquy Colloquy NNP 40436 5525 7 of of IN 40436 5525 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5525 9 with with IN 40436 5525 10 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5525 11 -- -- : 40436 5525 12 possession possession NN 40436 5525 13 of of IN 40436 5525 14 good good JJ 40436 5525 15 things thing NNS 40436 5525 16 is be VBZ 40436 5525 17 useless useless JJ 40436 5525 18 , , , 40436 5525 19 unless unless IN 40436 5525 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5525 21 also also RB 40436 5525 22 have have VBP 40436 5525 23 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5525 24 how how WRB 40436 5525 25 to to TO 40436 5525 26 use use VB 40436 5525 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5525 28 . . . 40436 5525 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5526 1 The the DT 40436 5526 2 conversation conversation NN 40436 5526 3 of of IN 40436 5526 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5526 5 with with IN 40436 5526 6 the the DT 40436 5526 7 youth youth NN 40436 5526 8 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5526 9 is be VBZ 40436 5526 10 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 5526 11 for for IN 40436 5526 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5526 13 plainness plainness NN 40436 5526 14 and and CC 40436 5526 15 simplicity simplicity NN 40436 5526 16 . . . 40436 5527 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5527 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 5527 3 is be VBZ 40436 5527 4 to to TO 40436 5527 5 implant implant VB 40436 5527 6 or or CC 40436 5527 7 inflame inflame VB 40436 5527 8 in in IN 40436 5527 9 the the DT 40436 5527 10 youth youth NN 40436 5527 11 the the DT 40436 5527 12 aspiration aspiration NN 40436 5527 13 and and CC 40436 5527 14 effort effort NN 40436 5527 15 towards towards IN 40436 5527 16 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5527 17 or or CC 40436 5527 18 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5527 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5527 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5527 21 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5527 22 : : : 40436 5527 23 philosophi philosophi LS 40436 5527 24 / / SYM 40436 5527 25 a a LS 40436 5527 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5527 27 , , , 40436 5527 28 in in IN 40436 5527 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5527 30 etymological etymological JJ 40436 5527 31 sense sense NN 40436 5527 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5527 33 . . . 40436 5528 1 " " `` 40436 5528 2 You -PRON- PRP 40436 5528 3 , , , 40436 5528 4 like like IN 40436 5528 5 every every DT 40436 5528 6 one one NN 40436 5528 7 else else RB 40436 5528 8 , , , 40436 5528 9 wish wish VB 40436 5528 10 to to TO 40436 5528 11 do do VB 40436 5528 12 well well RB 40436 5528 13 or or CC 40436 5528 14 to to TO 40436 5528 15 be be VB 40436 5528 16 happy happy JJ 40436 5528 17 . . . 40436 5529 1 The the DT 40436 5529 2 way way NN 40436 5529 3 to to TO 40436 5529 4 be be VB 40436 5529 5 happy happy JJ 40436 5529 6 is be VBZ 40436 5529 7 , , , 40436 5529 8 to to TO 40436 5529 9 have have VB 40436 5529 10 many many JJ 40436 5529 11 good good JJ 40436 5529 12 things thing NNS 40436 5529 13 . . . 40436 5530 1 Every every DT 40436 5530 2 one one NN 40436 5530 3 knows know VBZ 40436 5530 4 this this DT 40436 5530 5 : : : 40436 5530 6 every every DT 40436 5530 7 one one NN 40436 5530 8 knows know VBZ 40436 5530 9 too too RB 40436 5530 10 , , , 40436 5530 11 that that IN 40436 5530 12 among among IN 40436 5530 13 these these DT 40436 5530 14 good good JJ 40436 5530 15 things thing NNS 40436 5530 16 , , , 40436 5530 17 wealth wealth NN 40436 5530 18 is be VBZ 40436 5530 19 an an DT 40436 5530 20 indisputable indisputable JJ 40436 5530 21 item:[28 item:[28 NNS 40436 5530 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5530 23 likewise likewise RB 40436 5530 24 health health NN 40436 5530 25 , , , 40436 5530 26 beauty beauty NN 40436 5530 27 , , , 40436 5530 28 bodily bodily JJ 40436 5530 29 activity activity NN 40436 5530 30 , , , 40436 5530 31 good good JJ 40436 5530 32 birth birth NN 40436 5530 33 , , , 40436 5530 34 power power NN 40436 5530 35 over over IN 40436 5530 36 others other NNS 40436 5530 37 , , , 40436 5530 38 honour honour NN 40436 5530 39 in in IN 40436 5530 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5530 41 city city NN 40436 5530 42 , , , 40436 5530 43 temperance temperance NN 40436 5530 44 , , , 40436 5530 45 justice justice NN 40436 5530 46 , , , 40436 5530 47 courage courage NN 40436 5530 48 , , , 40436 5530 49 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5530 50 , , , 40436 5530 51 & & CC 40436 5530 52 c. c. NNP 40436 5530 53 Good Good NNP 40436 5530 54 fortune fortune NN 40436 5530 55 does do VBZ 40436 5530 56 not not RB 40436 5530 57 count count VB 40436 5530 58 as as IN 40436 5530 59 a a DT 40436 5530 60 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5530 61 item item NN 40436 5530 62 , , , 40436 5530 63 because because IN 40436 5530 64 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5530 65 resolves resolve VBZ 40436 5530 66 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5530 67 into into IN 40436 5530 68 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5530 69 . . . 40436 5531 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5531 2 29]--But 29]--but CD 40436 5531 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5531 4 is be VBZ 40436 5531 5 not not RB 40436 5531 6 enough enough JJ 40436 5531 7 to to TO 40436 5531 8 have have VB 40436 5531 9 all all PDT 40436 5531 10 these these DT 40436 5531 11 good good JJ 40436 5531 12 things thing NNS 40436 5531 13 : : : 40436 5531 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5531 15 must must MD 40436 5531 16 not not RB 40436 5531 17 only only RB 40436 5531 18 have have VB 40436 5531 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5531 20 but but CC 40436 5531 21 use use VB 40436 5531 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5531 23 : : : 40436 5531 24 moreover moreover RB 40436 5531 25 , , , 40436 5531 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5531 27 must must MD 40436 5531 28 use use VB 40436 5531 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5531 30 not not RB 40436 5531 31 wrongly wrongly RB 40436 5531 32 , , , 40436 5531 33 but but CC 40436 5531 34 rightly rightly RB 40436 5531 35 . . . 40436 5532 1 If if IN 40436 5532 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5532 3 use use VBP 40436 5532 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5532 5 wrongly wrongly RB 40436 5532 6 , , , 40436 5532 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5532 8 will will MD 40436 5532 9 not not RB 40436 5532 10 produce produce VB 40436 5532 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5532 12 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 5532 13 consequences consequence NNS 40436 5532 14 . . . 40436 5533 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 2 will will MD 40436 5533 3 even even RB 40436 5533 4 make make VB 40436 5533 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 6 more more RBR 40436 5533 7 miserable miserable JJ 40436 5533 8 than than IN 40436 5533 9 if if IN 40436 5533 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 11 had have VBD 40436 5533 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 13 not not RB 40436 5533 14 , , , 40436 5533 15 because because IN 40436 5533 16 the the DT 40436 5533 17 possession possession NN 40436 5533 18 of of IN 40436 5533 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 20 will will MD 40436 5533 21 prompt prompt VB 40436 5533 22 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 23 to to TO 40436 5533 24 be be VB 40436 5533 25 active active JJ 40436 5533 26 and and CC 40436 5533 27 meddlesome meddlesome JJ 40436 5533 28 : : : 40436 5533 29 whereas whereas IN 40436 5533 30 , , , 40436 5533 31 if if IN 40436 5533 32 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 33 have have VBP 40436 5533 34 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 35 not not RB 40436 5533 36 , , , 40436 5533 37 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5533 38 shall shall MD 40436 5533 39 keep keep VB 40436 5533 40 in in IN 40436 5533 41 the the DT 40436 5533 42 back back NN 40436 5533 43 - - HYPH 40436 5533 44 ground ground NN 40436 5533 45 and and CC 40436 5533 46 do do VB 40436 5533 47 little little JJ 40436 5533 48 . . . 40436 5534 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5534 2 30 30 CD 40436 5534 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5534 4 But but CC 40436 5534 5 to to TO 40436 5534 6 use use VB 40436 5534 7 these these DT 40436 5534 8 good good JJ 40436 5534 9 things thing NNS 40436 5534 10 rightly rightly RB 40436 5534 11 , , , 40436 5534 12 depends depend VBZ 40436 5534 13 upon upon IN 40436 5534 14 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5534 15 , , , 40436 5534 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5534 17 , , , 40436 5534 18 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5534 19 . . . 40436 5535 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5535 2 thus thus RB 40436 5535 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 5535 4 that that IN 40436 5535 5 the the DT 40436 5535 6 enumerated enumerate VBN 40436 5535 7 items item NNS 40436 5535 8 are be VBP 40436 5535 9 not not RB 40436 5535 10 really really RB 40436 5535 11 good good JJ 40436 5535 12 , , , 40436 5535 13 except except IN 40436 5535 14 on on IN 40436 5535 15 the the DT 40436 5535 16 assumption assumption NN 40436 5535 17 that that IN 40436 5535 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5535 19 are be VBP 40436 5535 20 under under IN 40436 5535 21 the the DT 40436 5535 22 guidance guidance NN 40436 5535 23 of of IN 40436 5535 24 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5535 25 : : : 40436 5535 26 if if IN 40436 5535 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5535 28 are be VBP 40436 5535 29 under under IN 40436 5535 30 the the DT 40436 5535 31 guidance guidance NN 40436 5535 32 of of IN 40436 5535 33 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 5535 34 , , , 40436 5535 35 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5535 36 are be VBP 40436 5535 37 not not RB 40436 5535 38 good good JJ 40436 5535 39 ; ; : 40436 5535 40 nay nay NN 40436 5535 41 , , , 40436 5535 42 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5535 43 even even RB 40436 5535 44 produce produce VBP 40436 5535 45 more more JJR 40436 5535 46 harm harm NN 40436 5535 47 than than IN 40436 5535 48 good good JJ 40436 5535 49 , , , 40436 5535 50 since since IN 40436 5535 51 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5535 52 are be VBP 40436 5535 53 active active JJ 40436 5535 54 instruments instrument NNS 40436 5535 55 in in IN 40436 5535 56 the the DT 40436 5535 57 service service NN 40436 5535 58 of of IN 40436 5535 59 a a DT 40436 5535 60 foolish foolish JJ 40436 5535 61 master master NN 40436 5535 62 . . . 40436 5536 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5536 2 31 31 CD 40436 5536 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5536 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5536 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5536 6 28 28 CD 40436 5536 7 : : : 40436 5536 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5536 9 , , , 40436 5536 10 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5536 11 . . . 40436 5537 1 p. p. NN 40436 5537 2 279 279 CD 40436 5537 3 A. a. NN 40436 5538 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5538 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5538 3 : : : 40436 5538 4 a)gatha\ a)gatha\ NNP 40436 5538 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5538 6 poi poi NNP 40436 5538 7 = = FW 40436 5538 8 a a LS 40436 5538 9 a)/ra a)/ra XX 40436 5538 10 tô tô NNP 40436 5538 11 = = SYM 40436 5538 12 n n NN 40436 5538 13 o)/ntôn o)/ntôn NNP 40436 5538 14 tugcha tugcha NNP 40436 5538 15 / / SYM 40436 5538 16 nei nei NNP 40436 5538 17 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 5538 18 = = SYM 40436 5538 19 n n IN 40436 5538 20 o)/nta o)/nta NN 40436 5538 21 ? ? . 40436 5539 1 ê)\ ê)\ IN 40436 5539 2 ou ou NNP 40436 5539 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5539 4 chalepo\n chalepo\n . 40436 5539 5 ou)de\ ou)de\ JJ 40436 5539 6 semnou= semnou= JJ 40436 5539 7 a)ndro\s a)ndro\s NNP 40436 5539 8 pa pa NNP 40436 5539 9 / / SYM 40436 5539 10 nu nu NNP 40436 5539 11 ti ti NNP 40436 5539 12 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 5539 13 tou tou NNP 40436 5539 14 = = SYM 40436 5539 15 to to IN 40436 5539 16 e)/oiken e)/oiken NNP 40436 5539 17 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 5539 18 eu(rei eu(rei NN 40436 5539 19 = = SYM 40436 5539 20 n n XX 40436 5539 21 ? ? . 40436 5540 1 pa pa NNP 40436 5540 2 = = SYM 40436 5540 3 s s NNP 40436 5540 4 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5540 5 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 5540 6 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 5540 7 = = SYM 40436 5540 8 n n CC 40436 5540 9 ei)/poi ei)/poi NNP 40436 5540 10 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 5540 11 to\ to\ NN 40436 5540 12 ploutei ploutei NN 40436 5540 13 = = NFP 40436 5540 14 n n JJ 40436 5540 15 a)gatho a)gatho CD 40436 5540 16 / / SYM 40436 5540 17 n n NN 40436 5540 18 ? ? . 40436 5540 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5540 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5541 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5541 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5541 3 29 29 CD 40436 5541 4 : : : 40436 5541 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5541 6 , , , 40436 5541 7 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5541 8 . . . 40436 5542 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5542 2 . . . 40436 5543 1 279 279 CD 40436 5543 2 - - SYM 40436 5543 3 280 280 CD 40436 5543 4 . . . 40436 5543 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5544 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5544 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5544 3 30 30 CD 40436 5544 4 : : : 40436 5544 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5544 6 , , , 40436 5544 7 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5544 8 . . . 40436 5545 1 p. p. NN 40436 5545 2 281 281 CD 40436 5545 3 C. C. NNP 40436 5545 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5545 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5545 6 : : : 40436 5545 7 ê(=tton ê(=tton NNP 40436 5545 8 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5545 9 kakô kakô NNP 40436 5545 10 = = SYM 40436 5545 11 s s NNP 40436 5545 12 pra pra NNP 40436 5545 13 / / SYM 40436 5545 14 ttôn ttôn NNS 40436 5545 15 , , , 40436 5545 16 a)/thlios a)/thlios NNP 40436 5545 17 ê(=tton ê(=tton NNP 40436 5545 18 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 5545 19 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 5545 20 . . . 40436 5545 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5545 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5546 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5546 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5546 3 31 31 CD 40436 5546 4 : : : 40436 5546 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5546 6 , , , 40436 5546 7 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 5546 8 . . . 40436 5547 1 p. p. NN 40436 5547 2 282 282 CD 40436 5547 3 E. E. NNP 40436 5547 4 If if IN 40436 5547 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5547 6 compare compare VBP 40436 5547 7 this this DT 40436 5547 8 with with IN 40436 5547 9 p. p. NN 40436 5547 10 279 279 CD 40436 5547 11 C c NN 40436 5547 12 - - HYPH 40436 5547 13 D D NNP 40436 5547 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5547 15 shall shall MD 40436 5547 16 see see VB 40436 5547 17 that that IN 40436 5547 18 the the DT 40436 5547 19 argument argument NN 40436 5547 20 of of IN 40436 5547 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5547 22 is be VBZ 40436 5547 23 open open JJ 40436 5547 24 to to IN 40436 5547 25 the the DT 40436 5547 26 exception exception NN 40436 5547 27 which which WDT 40436 5547 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5547 29 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5547 30 takes take VBZ 40436 5547 31 in in RP 40436 5547 32 the the DT 40436 5547 33 case case NN 40436 5547 34 of of IN 40436 5547 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5547 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5547 37 : : : 40436 5547 38 eu)tuchi eu)tuchi NNP 40436 5547 39 / / SYM 40436 5547 40 a a LS 40436 5547 41 -- -- : 40436 5547 42 di\s di\s NNP 40436 5547 43 tau)ta\ tau)ta\ SYM 40436 5547 44 le le NNP 40436 5547 45 / / SYM 40436 5547 46 gein gein NNP 40436 5547 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5547 48 . . . 40436 5548 1 Wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5548 2 is be VBZ 40436 5548 3 counted count VBN 40436 5548 4 twice twice RB 40436 5548 5 over over RB 40436 5548 6 . . . 40436 5548 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5549 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5549 2 Side side NN 40436 5549 3 - - HYPH 40436 5549 4 note note NN 40436 5549 5 : : : 40436 5549 6 But but CC 40436 5549 7 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5549 8 -- -- : 40436 5549 9 of of IN 40436 5549 10 what what WP 40436 5549 11 ? ? . 40436 5550 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5550 2 must must MD 40436 5550 3 be be VB 40436 5550 4 such such JJ 40436 5550 5 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5550 6 , , , 40436 5550 7 or or CC 40436 5550 8 such such PDT 40436 5550 9 an an DT 40436 5550 10 art art NN 40436 5550 11 , , , 40436 5550 12 as as IN 40436 5550 13 will will MD 40436 5550 14 include include VB 40436 5550 15 both both CC 40436 5550 16 the the DT 40436 5550 17 making making NN 40436 5550 18 of of IN 40436 5550 19 what what WP 40436 5550 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5550 21 want want VBP 40436 5550 22 , , , 40436 5550 23 and and CC 40436 5550 24 the the DT 40436 5550 25 right right JJ 40436 5550 26 use use NN 40436 5550 27 of of IN 40436 5550 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5550 29 when when WRB 40436 5550 30 made make VBN 40436 5550 31 . . . 40436 5550 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5551 1 " " `` 40436 5551 2 But but CC 40436 5551 3 what what WDT 40436 5551 4 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5551 5 do do VBP 40436 5551 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5551 7 want want VB 40436 5551 8 for for IN 40436 5551 9 the the DT 40436 5551 10 purpose purpose NN 40436 5551 11 ? ? . 40436 5552 1 Is be VBZ 40436 5552 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5552 3 _ _ NNP 40436 5552 4 all all DT 40436 5552 5 _ _ NNP 40436 5552 6 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5552 7 ? ? . 40436 5553 1 Or or CC 40436 5553 2 is be VBZ 40436 5553 3 there there EX 40436 5553 4 any any DT 40436 5553 5 one one CD 40436 5553 6 single single JJ 40436 5553 7 variety variety NN 40436 5553 8 of of IN 40436 5553 9 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5553 10 , , , 40436 5553 11 by by IN 40436 5553 12 the the DT 40436 5553 13 possession possession NN 40436 5553 14 of of IN 40436 5553 15 which which WDT 40436 5553 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5553 17 shall shall MD 40436 5553 18 become become VB 40436 5553 19 good good JJ 40436 5553 20 and and CC 40436 5553 21 happy happy JJ 40436 5553 22 ? ? . 40436 5554 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5554 2 32 32 CD 40436 5554 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5554 4 Obviously obviously RB 40436 5554 5 , , , 40436 5554 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5554 7 must must MD 40436 5554 8 be be VB 40436 5554 9 must must MD 40436 5554 10 be be VB 40436 5554 11 such such JJ 40436 5554 12 as as IN 40436 5554 13 will will MD 40436 5554 14 be be VB 40436 5554 15 profitable profitable JJ 40436 5554 16 to to IN 40436 5554 17 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5554 18 . . . 40436 5555 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5555 2 33 33 CD 40436 5555 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5555 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5555 5 have have VBP 40436 5555 6 seen see VBN 40436 5555 7 that that IN 40436 5555 8 there there EX 40436 5555 9 is be VBZ 40436 5555 10 no no DT 40436 5555 11 good good JJ 40436 5555 12 in in IN 40436 5555 13 possessing possess VBG 40436 5555 14 wealth wealth NN 40436 5555 15 -- -- : 40436 5555 16 that that IN 40436 5555 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5555 18 should should MD 40436 5555 19 gain gain VB 40436 5555 20 nothing nothing NN 40436 5555 21 by by IN 40436 5555 22 knowing know VBG 40436 5555 23 how how WRB 40436 5555 24 to to TO 40436 5555 25 acquire acquire VB 40436 5555 26 wealth wealth NN 40436 5555 27 or or CC 40436 5555 28 even even RB 40436 5555 29 to to TO 40436 5555 30 turn turn VB 40436 5555 31 stones stone NNS 40436 5555 32 into into IN 40436 5555 33 gold gold NN 40436 5555 34 , , , 40436 5555 35 unless unless IN 40436 5555 36 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5555 37 at at IN 40436 5555 38 the the DT 40436 5555 39 same same JJ 40436 5555 40 time time NN 40436 5555 41 knew know VBD 40436 5555 42 how how WRB 40436 5555 43 to to TO 40436 5555 44 use use VB 40436 5555 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5555 46 rightly rightly RB 40436 5555 47 . . . 40436 5556 1 Nor nor CC 40436 5556 2 should should MD 40436 5556 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5556 4 gain gain VB 40436 5556 5 any any DT 40436 5556 6 thing thing NN 40436 5556 7 by by IN 40436 5556 8 knowing know VBG 40436 5556 9 how how WRB 40436 5556 10 to to TO 40436 5556 11 make make VB 40436 5556 12 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5556 13 healthy healthy JJ 40436 5556 14 , , , 40436 5556 15 or or CC 40436 5556 16 even even RB 40436 5556 17 immortal immortal JJ 40436 5556 18 , , , 40436 5556 19 unless unless IN 40436 5556 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5556 21 knew know VBD 40436 5556 22 how how WRB 40436 5556 23 to to TO 40436 5556 24 employ employ VB 40436 5556 25 rightly rightly RB 40436 5556 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5556 27 health health NN 40436 5556 28 or or CC 40436 5556 29 immortality immortality NN 40436 5556 30 . . . 40436 5557 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5557 2 want want VBP 40436 5557 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5557 4 or or CC 40436 5557 5 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5557 6 , , , 40436 5557 7 of of IN 40436 5557 8 such such PDT 40436 5557 9 a a DT 40436 5557 10 nature nature NN 40436 5557 11 , , , 40436 5557 12 as as IN 40436 5557 13 to to TO 40436 5557 14 include include VB 40436 5557 15 both both DT 40436 5557 16 acting acting NN 40436 5557 17 , , , 40436 5557 18 making make VBG 40436 5557 19 , , , 40436 5557 20 or or CC 40436 5557 21 construction construction NN 40436 5557 22 and and CC 40436 5557 23 rightly rightly RB 40436 5557 24 using use VBG 40436 5557 25 what what WP 40436 5557 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5557 27 have have VBP 40436 5557 28 done do VBN 40436 5557 29 , , , 40436 5557 30 made make VBN 40436 5557 31 , , , 40436 5557 32 or or CC 40436 5557 33 constructed construct VBN 40436 5557 34 . . . 40436 5558 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5558 2 34 34 CD 40436 5558 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5558 4 The the DT 40436 5558 5 makers maker NNS 40436 5558 6 of of IN 40436 5558 7 lyres lyre NNS 40436 5558 8 and and CC 40436 5558 9 flutes flute NNS 40436 5558 10 may may MD 40436 5558 11 be be VB 40436 5558 12 men man NNS 40436 5558 13 of of IN 40436 5558 14 skill skill NN 40436 5558 15 , , , 40436 5558 16 but but CC 40436 5558 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5558 18 can can MD 40436 5558 19 not not RB 40436 5558 20 play play VB 40436 5558 21 upon upon IN 40436 5558 22 the the DT 40436 5558 23 instruments instrument NNS 40436 5558 24 which which WDT 40436 5558 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5558 26 have have VBP 40436 5558 27 made make VBN 40436 5558 28 : : : 40436 5558 29 the the DT 40436 5558 30 logographers logographer NNS 40436 5558 31 compose compose VBP 40436 5558 32 fine fine JJ 40436 5558 33 discourses discourse NNS 40436 5558 34 , , , 40436 5558 35 but but CC 40436 5558 36 hand hand VB 40436 5558 37 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5558 38 over over RP 40436 5558 39 for for IN 40436 5558 40 others other NNS 40436 5558 41 to to TO 40436 5558 42 deliver deliver VB 40436 5558 43 . . . 40436 5559 1 Even even RB 40436 5559 2 masters master NNS 40436 5559 3 in in IN 40436 5559 4 the the DT 40436 5559 5 most most RBS 40436 5559 6 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 5559 7 arts art NNS 40436 5559 8 -- -- : 40436 5559 9 such such JJ 40436 5559 10 as as IN 40436 5559 11 military military JJ 40436 5559 12 commanders commander NNS 40436 5559 13 , , , 40436 5559 14 geometers geometer NNS 40436 5559 15 , , , 40436 5559 16 arithmeticians arithmeticians NNPS 40436 5559 17 , , , 40436 5559 18 astronomers astronomer NNS 40436 5559 19 , , , 40436 5559 20 & & CC 40436 5559 21 c. c. NNP 40436 5559 22 , , , 40436 5559 23 do do VBP 40436 5559 24 not not RB 40436 5559 25 come come VB 40436 5559 26 up up RP 40436 5559 27 to to IN 40436 5559 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5559 29 requirement requirement NN 40436 5559 30 . . . 40436 5560 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5560 2 are be VBP 40436 5560 3 all all DT 40436 5560 4 of of IN 40436 5560 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5560 6 varieties variety NNS 40436 5560 7 under under IN 40436 5560 8 the the DT 40436 5560 9 general general JJ 40436 5560 10 class class NNP 40436 5560 11 _ _ NNP 40436 5560 12 hunters hunter NNS 40436 5560 13 _ _ NNP 40436 5560 14 : : : 40436 5560 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5560 16 find find VBP 40436 5560 17 and and CC 40436 5560 18 seize seize VBP 40436 5560 19 , , , 40436 5560 20 but but CC 40436 5560 21 hand hand VB 40436 5560 22 over over RP 40436 5560 23 what what WP 40436 5560 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5560 25 have have VBP 40436 5560 26 seized seize VBN 40436 5560 27 for for IN 40436 5560 28 others other NNS 40436 5560 29 to to TO 40436 5560 30 use use VB 40436 5560 31 . . . 40436 5561 1 The the DT 40436 5561 2 hunter hunter NN 40436 5561 3 , , , 40436 5561 4 when when WRB 40436 5561 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5561 6 has have VBZ 40436 5561 7 caught catch VBN 40436 5561 8 or or CC 40436 5561 9 killed kill VBN 40436 5561 10 game game NN 40436 5561 11 , , , 40436 5561 12 hands hand VBZ 40436 5561 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5561 14 over over RP 40436 5561 15 to to IN 40436 5561 16 the the DT 40436 5561 17 cook cook NN 40436 5561 18 ; ; : 40436 5561 19 the the DT 40436 5561 20 general general NN 40436 5561 21 , , , 40436 5561 22 when when WRB 40436 5561 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5561 24 has have VBZ 40436 5561 25 taken take VBN 40436 5561 26 a a DT 40436 5561 27 town town NN 40436 5561 28 , , , 40436 5561 29 delivers deliver VBZ 40436 5561 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5561 31 to to IN 40436 5561 32 the the DT 40436 5561 33 political political JJ 40436 5561 34 leader leader NN 40436 5561 35 or or CC 40436 5561 36 minister minister NN 40436 5561 37 : : : 40436 5561 38 the the DT 40436 5561 39 geometer geometer NN 40436 5561 40 makes make VBZ 40436 5561 41 over over IN 40436 5561 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5561 43 theorems theorem NNS 40436 5561 44 to to TO 40436 5561 45 be be VB 40436 5561 46 employed employ VBN 40436 5561 47 by by IN 40436 5561 48 the the DT 40436 5561 49 dialectician dialectician JJ 40436 5561 50 or or CC 40436 5561 51 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 5561 52 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 5561 53 . . . 40436 5562 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5562 2 35 35 CD 40436 5562 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5562 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5562 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5562 6 32 32 CD 40436 5562 7 : : : 40436 5562 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5562 9 , , , 40436 5562 10 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5562 11 . . . 40436 5563 1 p. p. NN 40436 5563 2 282 282 CD 40436 5563 3 E. E. NNP 40436 5563 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5563 5 here here RB 40436 5563 6 breaks break VBZ 40436 5563 7 off off RP 40436 5563 8 the the DT 40436 5563 9 string string NN 40436 5563 10 of of IN 40436 5563 11 questions question NNS 40436 5563 12 to to IN 40436 5563 13 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5563 14 , , , 40436 5563 15 but but CC 40436 5563 16 resumes resume VBZ 40436 5563 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5563 18 , , , 40436 5563 19 p. p. NN 40436 5563 20 288 288 CD 40436 5563 21 D. D. NNP 40436 5563 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5563 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5563 24 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5563 25 33 33 CD 40436 5563 26 : : : 40436 5563 27 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5563 28 , , , 40436 5563 29 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5563 30 . . . 40436 5564 1 p. p. NN 40436 5564 2 288 288 CD 40436 5564 3 D. D. NNP 40436 5564 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5564 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5564 6 : : : 40436 5564 7 ti ti NN 40436 5564 8 / / SYM 40436 5564 9 na na IN 40436 5564 10 pot pot NN 40436 5564 11 ' ' '' 40436 5564 12 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 5564 13 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 5564 14 ktêsa ktêsa NNP 40436 5564 15 / / SYM 40436 5564 16 menoi menoi NNP 40436 5564 17 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 5564 18 / / SYM 40436 5564 19 mên mên NNP 40436 5564 20 o)rthô o)rthô NNPS 40436 5564 21 = = SYM 40436 5564 22 s s NNP 40436 5564 23 ktêsai ktêsai NNP 40436 5564 24 / / SYM 40436 5564 25 metha metha NNP 40436 5564 26 ? ? . 40436 5565 1 a)=r a)=r UH 40436 5565 2 ' ' `` 40436 5565 3 ou ou NNP 40436 5565 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5565 5 tou tou NNP 40436 5565 6 = = NNPS 40436 5565 7 to to IN 40436 5565 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5565 9 a(plou a(plou NNP 40436 5565 10 = = SYM 40436 5565 11 n n NNP 40436 5565 12 , , , 40436 5565 13 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 5565 14 tau tau NNP 40436 5565 15 / / SYM 40436 5565 16 tên tên NNP 40436 5565 17 ê(/tis ê(/tis NNP 40436 5565 18 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 5565 19 = = SYM 40436 5565 20 s s NNP 40436 5565 21 o)nê o)nê NNP 40436 5565 22 / / SYM 40436 5565 23 sei sei NN 40436 5565 24 ? ? . 40436 5565 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5565 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5566 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5566 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5566 3 34 34 CD 40436 5566 4 : : : 40436 5566 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5566 6 , , , 40436 5566 7 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 5566 8 . . . 40436 5567 1 p. p. NN 40436 5567 2 289 289 CD 40436 5567 3 B. b. NN 40436 5568 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5568 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5568 3 : : : 40436 5568 4 toiau toiau NNP 40436 5568 5 / / SYM 40436 5568 6 tês tês NNP 40436 5568 7 tino\s tino\s CD 40436 5568 8 a)/r a)/r NNP 40436 5568 9 ' ' '' 40436 5568 10 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 5568 11 = = SYM 40436 5568 12 n n CC 40436 5568 13 e)pistê e)pistê CD 40436 5568 14 / / SYM 40436 5568 15 mês mês NNP 40436 5568 16 dei= dei= NNP 40436 5568 17 , , , 40436 5568 18 e)n e)n NNP 40436 5568 19 ê(=| ê(=| JJ 40436 5568 20 sumpe sumpe NN 40436 5568 21 / / SYM 40436 5568 22 ptôken ptôken VBN 40436 5568 23 a(/ma a(/ma NNP 40436 5568 24 to/ to/ CD 40436 5568 25 te te NNP 40436 5568 26 poiei poiei NNP 40436 5568 27 = = SYM 40436 5568 28 n n NNP 40436 5568 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5568 30 to\ to\ NNP 40436 5568 31 e)pi e)pi NNP 40436 5568 32 / / SYM 40436 5568 33 stasthai stasthai NNP 40436 5568 34 chrê chrê NNP 40436 5568 35 = = SYM 40436 5568 36 sthai sthai NNP 40436 5568 37 ô(=| ô(=| NNP 40436 5568 38 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 5568 39 poiê=| poiê=| NNP 40436 5568 40 . . . 40436 5568 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5568 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5569 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5569 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5569 3 35 35 CD 40436 5569 4 : : : 40436 5569 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5569 6 , , , 40436 5569 7 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 5569 8 . . . 40436 5570 1 p.290 p.290 NNP 40436 5570 2 C C NNP 40436 5570 3 - - HYPH 40436 5570 4 D. D. NNP 40436 5570 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5570 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5570 7 Side side NN 40436 5570 8 - - HYPH 40436 5570 9 note note NN 40436 5570 10 : : : 40436 5570 11 Where where WRB 40436 5570 12 is be VBZ 40436 5570 13 such such PDT 40436 5570 14 an an DT 40436 5570 15 art art NN 40436 5570 16 to to TO 40436 5570 17 be be VB 40436 5570 18 found find VBN 40436 5570 19 ? ? . 40436 5571 1 The the DT 40436 5571 2 regal regal JJ 40436 5571 3 or or CC 40436 5571 4 political political JJ 40436 5571 5 art art NN 40436 5571 6 looks look VBZ 40436 5571 7 like like IN 40436 5571 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5571 9 ; ; : 40436 5571 10 but but CC 40436 5571 11 what what WP 40436 5571 12 does do VBZ 40436 5571 13 this this DT 40436 5571 14 art art NN 40436 5571 15 do do VB 40436 5571 16 for for IN 40436 5571 17 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5571 18 ? ? . 40436 5572 1 No no DT 40436 5572 2 answer answer NN 40436 5572 3 can can MD 40436 5572 4 be be VB 40436 5572 5 found find VBN 40436 5572 6 . . . 40436 5573 1 Ends end NNS 40436 5573 2 in in IN 40436 5573 3 puzzle puzzle NNP 40436 5573 4 . . . 40436 5573 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5574 1 " " `` 40436 5574 2 Where where WRB 40436 5574 3 then then RB 40436 5574 4 can can MD 40436 5574 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5574 6 find find VB 40436 5574 7 such such PDT 40436 5574 8 an an DT 40436 5574 9 art art NN 40436 5574 10 -- -- : 40436 5574 11 such such PDT 40436 5574 12 a a DT 40436 5574 13 variety variety NN 40436 5574 14 of of IN 40436 5574 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5574 16 or or CC 40436 5574 17 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5574 18 -- -- : 40436 5574 19 as as IN 40436 5574 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5574 21 are be VBP 40436 5574 22 seeking seek VBG 40436 5574 23 ? ? . 40436 5575 1 The the DT 40436 5575 2 regal regal JJ 40436 5575 3 or or CC 40436 5575 4 political political JJ 40436 5575 5 art art NN 40436 5575 6 looks look VBZ 40436 5575 7 like like IN 40436 5575 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5575 9 : : : 40436 5575 10 that that DT 40436 5575 11 art art NN 40436 5575 12 which which WDT 40436 5575 13 regulates regulate VBZ 40436 5575 14 and and CC 40436 5575 15 enforces enforce VBZ 40436 5575 16 all all PDT 40436 5575 17 the the DT 40436 5575 18 arrangements arrangement NNS 40436 5575 19 of of IN 40436 5575 20 the the DT 40436 5575 21 city city NN 40436 5575 22 . . . 40436 5576 1 But but CC 40436 5576 2 what what WP 40436 5576 3 is be VBZ 40436 5576 4 the the DT 40436 5576 5 work work NN 40436 5576 6 which which WDT 40436 5576 7 this this DT 40436 5576 8 art art NN 40436 5576 9 performs perform VBZ 40436 5576 10 ? ? . 40436 5577 1 What what WDT 40436 5577 2 product product NN 40436 5577 3 does do VBZ 40436 5577 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5577 5 yield yield VB 40436 5577 6 , , , 40436 5577 7 as as IN 40436 5577 8 the the DT 40436 5577 9 medical medical JJ 40436 5577 10 art art NN 40436 5577 11 supplies supply VBZ 40436 5577 12 good good JJ 40436 5577 13 health health NN 40436 5577 14 , , , 40436 5577 15 and and CC 40436 5577 16 the the DT 40436 5577 17 farmer farmer NN 40436 5577 18 's 's POS 40436 5577 19 art art NN 40436 5577 20 , , , 40436 5577 21 provision provision NN 40436 5577 22 ? ? . 40436 5578 1 What what WDT 40436 5578 2 good good NN 40436 5578 3 does do VBZ 40436 5578 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5578 5 effect effect VB 40436 5578 6 ? ? . 40436 5579 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 5579 2 may may MD 40436 5579 3 say say VB 40436 5579 4 that that IN 40436 5579 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5579 6 makes make VBZ 40436 5579 7 the the DT 40436 5579 8 citizens citizen NNS 40436 5579 9 wealthy wealthy JJ 40436 5579 10 , , , 40436 5579 11 free free JJ 40436 5579 12 , , , 40436 5579 13 harmonious harmonious JJ 40436 5579 14 in in IN 40436 5579 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5579 16 intercourse intercourse NN 40436 5579 17 . . . 40436 5580 1 But but CC 40436 5580 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5580 3 have have VBP 40436 5580 4 already already RB 40436 5580 5 seen see VBN 40436 5580 6 that that IN 40436 5580 7 these these DT 40436 5580 8 acquisitions acquisition NNS 40436 5580 9 are be VBP 40436 5580 10 not not RB 40436 5580 11 good good JJ 40436 5580 12 , , , 40436 5580 13 unless unless IN 40436 5580 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5580 15 be be VBP 40436 5580 16 under under IN 40436 5580 17 the the DT 40436 5580 18 guidance guidance NN 40436 5580 19 of of IN 40436 5580 20 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5580 21 : : : 40436 5580 22 that that IN 40436 5580 23 nothing nothing NN 40436 5580 24 is be VBZ 40436 5580 25 really really RB 40436 5580 26 good good JJ 40436 5580 27 , , , 40436 5580 28 except except IN 40436 5580 29 some some DT 40436 5580 30 variety variety NN 40436 5580 31 of of IN 40436 5580 32 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5580 33 . . . 40436 5581 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5581 2 36 36 CD 40436 5581 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5581 4 Does do VBZ 40436 5581 5 the the DT 40436 5581 6 regal regal JJ 40436 5581 7 art art NN 40436 5581 8 then then RB 40436 5581 9 confer confer VBP 40436 5581 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5581 11 ? ? . 40436 5582 1 If if IN 40436 5582 2 so so RB 40436 5582 3 , , , 40436 5582 4 does do VBZ 40436 5582 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5582 6 confer confer VB 40436 5582 7 every every DT 40436 5582 8 variety variety NN 40436 5582 9 of of IN 40436 5582 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5582 11 -- -- : 40436 5582 12 that that DT 40436 5582 13 of of IN 40436 5582 14 the the DT 40436 5582 15 carpenter carpenter NN 40436 5582 16 , , , 40436 5582 17 currier currier NNP 40436 5582 18 , , , 40436 5582 19 & & CC 40436 5582 20 c. c. NNP 40436 5582 21 , , , 40436 5582 22 as as RB 40436 5582 23 well well RB 40436 5582 24 as as IN 40436 5582 25 others other NNS 40436 5582 26 ? ? . 40436 5583 1 Not not RB 40436 5583 2 certainly certainly RB 40436 5583 3 any any DT 40436 5583 4 of of IN 40436 5583 5 these these DT 40436 5583 6 , , , 40436 5583 7 for for IN 40436 5583 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5583 9 have have VBP 40436 5583 10 already already RB 40436 5583 11 settled settle VBN 40436 5583 12 that that IN 40436 5583 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5583 14 are be VBP 40436 5583 15 in in IN 40436 5583 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5583 17 neither neither CC 40436 5583 18 good good JJ 40436 5583 19 nor nor CC 40436 5583 20 bad bad JJ 40436 5583 21 . . . 40436 5584 1 The the DT 40436 5584 2 regal regal JJ 40436 5584 3 art art NN 40436 5584 4 can can MD 40436 5584 5 thus thus RB 40436 5584 6 impart impart VB 40436 5584 7 no no DT 40436 5584 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5584 9 except except IN 40436 5584 10 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5584 11 ; ; : 40436 5584 12 and and CC 40436 5584 13 what what WP 40436 5584 14 is be VBZ 40436 5584 15 _ _ NNP 40436 5584 16 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5584 17 _ _ NNP 40436 5584 18 ? ? . 40436 5585 1 how how WRB 40436 5585 2 are be VBP 40436 5585 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5585 4 to to TO 40436 5585 5 use use VB 40436 5585 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5585 7 ? ? . 40436 5586 1 If if IN 40436 5586 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5586 3 say say VBP 40436 5586 4 , , , 40436 5586 5 that that IN 40436 5586 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5586 7 shall shall MD 40436 5586 8 render render VB 40436 5586 9 other other JJ 40436 5586 10 men man NNS 40436 5586 11 _ _ IN 40436 5586 12 good_--the good_--the NNP 40436 5586 13 question question NN 40436 5586 14 again again RB 40436 5586 15 recurs recur VBZ 40436 5586 16 , , , 40436 5586 17 _ _ NNP 40436 5586 18 Good_--in Good_--in NNP 40436 5586 19 what what WDT 40436 5586 20 respect respect NN 40436 5586 21 ? ? . 40436 5587 1 _ _ NNP 40436 5587 2 useful_--for useful_--for NNP 40436 5587 3 what what WDT 40436 5587 4 purpose purpose NN 40436 5587 5 ? ? . 40436 5588 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5588 2 37 37 CD 40436 5588 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5588 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5588 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5588 6 36 36 CD 40436 5588 7 : : : 40436 5588 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5588 9 , , , 40436 5588 10 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 5588 11 . . . 40436 5589 1 p. p. NN 40436 5589 2 292 292 CD 40436 5589 3 B. B. NNP 40436 5590 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5590 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5590 3 : : : 40436 5590 4 A)gatho\n A)gatho\n NNP 40436 5590 5 de/ de/ NNP 40436 5590 6 ge/ ge/ NNP 40436 5590 7 pou pou NNP 40436 5590 8 ô(mologê ô(mologê NNP 40436 5590 9 / / SYM 40436 5590 10 samen saman NNS 40436 5590 11 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 5590 12 / / SYM 40436 5590 13 lois lois JJ 40436 5590 14 -- -- : 40436 5590 15 ou)de\n ou)de\n ADD 40436 5590 16 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 5590 17 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 5590 18 ê)\ ê)\ CD 40436 5590 19 e)pistê e)pistê CD 40436 5590 20 / / SYM 40436 5590 21 mên mên NN 40436 5590 22 tina/. tina/. NNP 40436 5590 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5590 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5591 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5591 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5591 3 37 37 CD 40436 5591 4 : : : 40436 5591 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5591 6 . . . 40436 5592 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5592 2 . . . 40436 5593 1 p. p. NN 40436 5593 2 292 292 CD 40436 5593 3 D. D. NNP 40436 5593 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5593 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5593 6 : : : 40436 5593 7 A)lla\ a)lla\ VB 40436 5593 8 ti ti RB 40436 5593 9 / / SYM 40436 5593 10 na na NNP 40436 5593 11 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 5593 12 e)pistê e)pistê CD 40436 5593 13 / / SYM 40436 5593 14 mên mên NN 40436 5593 15 ? ? . 40436 5594 1 ê(=| ê(=| JJ 40436 5594 2 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 5594 3 chrêso chrêso NNP 40436 5594 4 / / SYM 40436 5594 5 metha metha NNP 40436 5594 6 ? ? . 40436 5595 1 tô tô NNP 40436 5595 2 = = SYM 40436 5595 3 n n CC 40436 5595 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5595 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5595 6 e)/rgôn e)/rgôn JJ 40436 5595 7 ou)deno\s ou)deno\s NNP 40436 5595 8 dei= dei= NNP 40436 5595 9 au)tê\n au)tê\n NN 40436 5595 10 dêmiourgo\n dêmiourgo\n -LRB- 40436 5595 11 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 5595 12 tô tô NNP 40436 5595 13 = = SYM 40436 5595 14 n n NNP 40436 5595 15 mê mê NNP 40436 5595 16 / / SYM 40436 5595 17 te te NNP 40436 5595 18 kakô kakô NNP 40436 5595 19 = = SYM 40436 5595 20 n n NNP 40436 5595 21 mê mê NNP 40436 5595 22 / / SYM 40436 5595 23 te te NNP 40436 5595 24 a)gathô a)gathô NNP 40436 5595 25 = = SYM 40436 5595 26 n n CD 40436 5595 27 , , , 40436 5595 28 e)pistê e)pistê CD 40436 5595 29 / / SYM 40436 5595 30 mên mên NNP 40436 5595 31 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5595 32 paradido paradido NNP 40436 5595 33 / / SYM 40436 5595 34 nai nai NNP 40436 5595 35 mêdemi mêdemi NNP 40436 5595 36 / / , 40436 5595 37 an an DT 40436 5595 38 a)/llên a)/llên JJ 40436 5595 39 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 5595 40 au)tê\n au)tê\n NN 40436 5595 41 e(autê e(autê NN 40436 5595 42 / / SYM 40436 5595 43 n n NN 40436 5595 44 ; ; : 40436 5595 45 le le NNP 40436 5595 46 / / SYM 40436 5595 47 gômen gômen NNP 40436 5595 48 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 5595 49 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 5595 50 , , , 40436 5595 51 ti ti NNP 40436 5595 52 / / SYM 40436 5595 53 s s NNP 40436 5595 54 pote pote NN 40436 5595 55 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 5595 56 au(tê\ au(tê\ NNP 40436 5595 57 ê(=| ê(=| JJ 40436 5595 58 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 5595 59 chrêso chrêso NNP 40436 5595 60 / / SYM 40436 5595 61 metha metha NNP 40436 5595 62 ? ? . 40436 5595 63 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5595 64 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5596 1 " " `` 40436 5596 2 Here here RB 40436 5596 3 then then RB 40436 5596 4 " " '' 40436 5596 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5596 6 concludes conclude VBZ 40436 5596 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5596 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5596 9 , , , 40436 5596 10 " " `` 40436 5596 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5596 12 come come VBP 40436 5596 13 to to IN 40436 5596 14 a a DT 40436 5596 15 dead dead JJ 40436 5596 16 lock lock NN 40436 5596 17 : : : 40436 5596 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5596 19 can can MD 40436 5596 20 find find VB 40436 5596 21 no no DT 40436 5596 22 issue issue NN 40436 5596 23 . . . 40436 5597 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5597 2 38 38 CD 40436 5597 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5597 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5597 5 can can MD 40436 5597 6 not not RB 40436 5597 7 discover discover VB 40436 5597 8 what what WP 40436 5597 9 the the DT 40436 5597 10 regal regal JJ 40436 5597 11 art art NN 40436 5597 12 does do VBZ 40436 5597 13 for for IN 40436 5597 14 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5597 15 or or CC 40436 5597 16 gives give VBZ 40436 5597 17 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5597 18 : : : 40436 5597 19 yet yet CC 40436 5597 20 this this DT 40436 5597 21 is be VBZ 40436 5597 22 the the DT 40436 5597 23 art art NN 40436 5597 24 which which WDT 40436 5597 25 is be VBZ 40436 5597 26 to to TO 40436 5597 27 make make VB 40436 5597 28 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5597 29 happy happy JJ 40436 5597 30 . . . 40436 5597 31 " " '' 40436 5598 1 In in IN 40436 5598 2 this this DT 40436 5598 3 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 5598 4 , , , 40436 5598 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5598 6 turns turn VBZ 40436 5598 7 to to IN 40436 5598 8 the the DT 40436 5598 9 two two CD 40436 5598 10 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5598 11 , , , 40436 5598 12 and and CC 40436 5598 13 implores implore VBZ 40436 5598 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5598 15 help help NN 40436 5598 16 . . . 40436 5599 1 The the DT 40436 5599 2 contrast contrast NN 40436 5599 3 between between IN 40436 5599 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5599 5 and and CC 40436 5599 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5599 7 is be VBZ 40436 5599 8 thus thus RB 40436 5599 9 brought bring VBN 40436 5599 10 out out RP 40436 5599 11 . . . 40436 5600 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5600 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5600 3 38 38 CD 40436 5600 4 : : : 40436 5600 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5600 6 . . . 40436 5601 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5601 2 . . . 40436 5602 1 p. p. NN 40436 5602 2 292 292 CD 40436 5602 3 E. E. NNP 40436 5602 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5602 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5602 6 Side side NN 40436 5602 7 - - HYPH 40436 5602 8 note note NN 40436 5602 9 : : : 40436 5602 10 Review review NN 40436 5602 11 of of IN 40436 5602 12 the the DT 40436 5602 13 cross cross NN 40436 5602 14 - - NN 40436 5602 15 examination examination NN 40436 5602 16 just just RB 40436 5602 17 pursued pursue VBN 40436 5602 18 by by IN 40436 5602 19 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5602 20 . . . 40436 5603 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5603 2 is be VBZ 40436 5603 3 very very RB 40436 5603 4 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 5603 5 -- -- : 40436 5603 6 puts put VBZ 40436 5603 7 the the DT 40436 5603 8 mind mind NN 40436 5603 9 upon upon IN 40436 5603 10 what what WP 40436 5603 11 to to TO 40436 5603 12 look look VB 40436 5603 13 for for IN 40436 5603 14 . . . 40436 5603 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5604 1 The the DT 40436 5604 2 argument argument NN 40436 5604 3 of of IN 40436 5604 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5604 5 , , , 40436 5604 6 which which WDT 40436 5604 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5604 8 have have VBP 40436 5604 9 thus thus RB 40436 5604 10 abridged abridge VBN 40436 5604 11 from from IN 40436 5604 12 the the DT 40436 5604 13 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5604 14 , , , 40436 5604 15 arrives arrive VBZ 40436 5604 16 at at IN 40436 5604 17 no no DT 40436 5604 18 solution solution NN 40436 5604 19 : : : 40436 5604 20 but but CC 40436 5604 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5604 22 is be VBZ 40436 5604 23 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5604 24 eminently eminently RB 40436 5604 25 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 5604 26 , , , 40436 5604 27 and and CC 40436 5604 28 puts put VBZ 40436 5604 29 the the DT 40436 5604 30 question question NN 40436 5604 31 in in IN 40436 5604 32 a a DT 40436 5604 33 way way NN 40436 5604 34 to to TO 40436 5604 35 receive receive VB 40436 5604 36 solution solution NN 40436 5604 37 . . . 40436 5605 1 What what WP 40436 5605 2 is be VBZ 40436 5605 3 the the DT 40436 5605 4 regal regal JJ 40436 5605 5 or or CC 40436 5605 6 political political JJ 40436 5605 7 art art NN 40436 5605 8 which which WDT 40436 5605 9 directs direct VBZ 40436 5605 10 or or CC 40436 5605 11 regulates regulate VBZ 40436 5605 12 all all DT 40436 5605 13 others other NNS 40436 5605 14 ? ? . 40436 5606 1 A a DT 40436 5606 2 man man NN 40436 5606 3 has have VBZ 40436 5606 4 many many JJ 40436 5606 5 different different JJ 40436 5606 6 impulses impulse NNS 40436 5606 7 , , , 40436 5606 8 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 5606 9 , , , 40436 5606 10 qualities quality NNS 40436 5606 11 , , , 40436 5606 12 aptitudes aptitude NNS 40436 5606 13 , , , 40436 5606 14 advantages advantage NNS 40436 5606 15 , , , 40436 5606 16 possessions possession NNS 40436 5606 17 , , , 40436 5606 18 & & CC 40436 5606 19 c. c. NNP 40436 5606 20 , , , 40436 5606 21 which which WDT 40436 5606 22 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5606 23 describe describe VBP 40436 5606 24 by by IN 40436 5606 25 saying say VBG 40436 5606 26 that that IN 40436 5606 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5606 28 is be VBZ 40436 5606 29 an an DT 40436 5606 30 artist artist NN 40436 5606 31 , , , 40436 5606 32 a a DT 40436 5606 33 general general NN 40436 5606 34 , , , 40436 5606 35 a a DT 40436 5606 36 tradesman tradesman NN 40436 5606 37 , , , 40436 5606 38 clever clever JJ 40436 5606 39 , , , 40436 5606 40 just just RB 40436 5606 41 , , , 40436 5606 42 temperate temperate NN 40436 5606 43 , , , 40436 5606 44 brave brave JJ 40436 5606 45 , , , 40436 5606 46 strong strong JJ 40436 5606 47 , , , 40436 5606 48 rich rich JJ 40436 5606 49 , , , 40436 5606 50 powerful powerful JJ 40436 5606 51 , , , 40436 5606 52 & & CC 40436 5606 53 c. c. NNP 40436 5606 54 But but CC 40436 5606 55 in in IN 40436 5606 56 the the DT 40436 5606 57 course course NN 40436 5606 58 of of IN 40436 5606 59 life life NN 40436 5606 60 , , , 40436 5606 61 each each DT 40436 5606 62 particular particular JJ 40436 5606 63 situation situation NN 40436 5606 64 has have VBZ 40436 5606 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5606 66 different different JJ 40436 5606 67 exigencies exigency NNS 40436 5606 68 , , , 40436 5606 69 while while IN 40436 5606 70 the the DT 40436 5606 71 prospective prospective JJ 40436 5606 72 future future NN 40436 5606 73 has have VBZ 40436 5606 74 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5606 75 exigencies exigency NNS 40436 5606 76 also also RB 40436 5606 77 . . . 40436 5607 1 The the DT 40436 5607 2 whole whole JJ 40436 5607 3 man man NN 40436 5607 4 is be VBZ 40436 5607 5 one one CD 40436 5607 6 , , , 40436 5607 7 with with IN 40436 5607 8 all all PDT 40436 5607 9 these these DT 40436 5607 10 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5607 11 and and CC 40436 5607 12 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 5607 13 conflicting conflicting JJ 40436 5607 14 attributes attribute NNS 40436 5607 15 : : : 40436 5607 16 in in IN 40436 5607 17 following follow VBG 40436 5607 18 one one CD 40436 5607 19 impulse impulse NN 40436 5607 20 , , , 40436 5607 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5607 22 must must MD 40436 5607 23 resist resist VB 40436 5607 24 others other NNS 40436 5607 25 -- -- : 40436 5607 26 in in IN 40436 5607 27 turning turn VBG 40436 5607 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5607 29 aptitudes aptitude NNS 40436 5607 30 to to IN 40436 5607 31 one one CD 40436 5607 32 object object NN 40436 5607 33 , , , 40436 5607 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5607 35 must must MD 40436 5607 36 turn turn VB 40436 5607 37 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5607 38 away away RB 40436 5607 39 from from IN 40436 5607 40 others other NNS 40436 5607 41 -- -- : 40436 5607 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5607 43 must must MD 40436 5607 44 , , , 40436 5607 45 as as IN 40436 5607 46 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5607 47 says say VBZ 40436 5607 48 , , , 40436 5607 49 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 5607 50 the the DT 40436 5607 51 right right JJ 40436 5607 52 use use NN 40436 5607 53 of of IN 40436 5607 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5607 55 force force NN 40436 5607 56 from from IN 40436 5607 57 the the DT 40436 5607 58 wrong wrong NN 40436 5607 59 , , , 40436 5607 60 by by IN 40436 5607 61 virtue virtue NN 40436 5607 62 of of IN 40436 5607 63 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5607 64 , , , 40436 5607 65 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5607 66 , , , 40436 5607 67 reason reason NN 40436 5607 68 . . . 40436 5608 1 Such such JJ 40436 5608 2 discriminating discriminating NN 40436 5608 3 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5608 4 , , , 40436 5608 5 which which WDT 40436 5608 6 in in IN 40436 5608 7 this this DT 40436 5608 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5608 9 is be VBZ 40436 5608 10 called call VBN 40436 5608 11 the the DT 40436 5608 12 Regal Regal NNP 40436 5608 13 or or CC 40436 5608 14 political political JJ 40436 5608 15 art,--what art,--what WDT 40436 5608 16 is be VBZ 40436 5608 17 the the DT 40436 5608 18 object object NN 40436 5608 19 of of IN 40436 5608 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5608 21 ? ? . 40436 5609 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5609 2 is be VBZ 40436 5609 3 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5609 4 or or CC 40436 5609 5 knowledge,--But knowledge,--But NNP 40436 5609 6 _ _ NNP 40436 5609 7 of of IN 40436 5609 8 what what WP 40436 5609 9 _ _ NNP 40436 5609 10 ? ? . 40436 5610 1 Not not RB 40436 5610 2 certainly certainly RB 40436 5610 3 of of IN 40436 5610 4 the the DT 40436 5610 5 way way NN 40436 5610 6 how how WRB 40436 5610 7 each each DT 40436 5610 8 particular particular JJ 40436 5610 9 act act NN 40436 5610 10 is be VBZ 40436 5610 11 to to TO 40436 5610 12 be be VB 40436 5610 13 performed perform VBN 40436 5610 14 -- -- : 40436 5610 15 how how WRB 40436 5610 16 each each DT 40436 5610 17 particular particular JJ 40436 5610 18 end end NN 40436 5610 19 is be VBZ 40436 5610 20 to to TO 40436 5610 21 be be VB 40436 5610 22 attained attain VBN 40436 5610 23 . . . 40436 5611 1 Each each DT 40436 5611 2 of of IN 40436 5611 3 these these DT 40436 5611 4 separately separately RB 40436 5611 5 is be VBZ 40436 5611 6 the the DT 40436 5611 7 object object NN 40436 5611 8 of of IN 40436 5611 9 some some DT 40436 5611 10 special special JJ 40436 5611 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5611 12 . . . 40436 5612 1 But but CC 40436 5612 2 the the DT 40436 5612 3 whole whole NN 40436 5612 4 of of IN 40436 5612 5 a a DT 40436 5612 6 man man NN 40436 5612 7 's 's POS 40436 5612 8 life life NN 40436 5612 9 is be VBZ 40436 5612 10 passed pass VBN 40436 5612 11 in in IN 40436 5612 12 a a DT 40436 5612 13 series series NN 40436 5612 14 of of IN 40436 5612 15 such such JJ 40436 5612 16 particular particular JJ 40436 5612 17 acts act NNS 40436 5612 18 , , , 40436 5612 19 each each DT 40436 5612 20 of of IN 40436 5612 21 which which WDT 40436 5612 22 is be VBZ 40436 5612 23 the the DT 40436 5612 24 object object NN 40436 5612 25 of of IN 40436 5612 26 some some DT 40436 5612 27 special special JJ 40436 5612 28 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5612 29 : : : 40436 5612 30 what what WP 40436 5612 31 then then RB 40436 5612 32 remains remain VBZ 40436 5612 33 as as IN 40436 5612 34 the the DT 40436 5612 35 object object NN 40436 5612 36 of of IN 40436 5612 37 Regal Regal NNP 40436 5612 38 or or CC 40436 5612 39 political political JJ 40436 5612 40 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5612 41 , , , 40436 5612 42 upon upon IN 40436 5612 43 which which WDT 40436 5612 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5612 45 happiness happiness NN 40436 5612 46 is be VBZ 40436 5612 47 said say VBN 40436 5612 48 to to TO 40436 5612 49 depend depend VB 40436 5612 50 ? ? . 40436 5613 1 Or or CC 40436 5613 2 how how WRB 40436 5613 3 can can MD 40436 5613 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5613 5 have have VB 40436 5613 6 any any DT 40436 5613 7 object object NN 40436 5613 8 at at RB 40436 5613 9 all all RB 40436 5613 10 ? ? . 40436 5614 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5614 2 Side side NN 40436 5614 3 - - HYPH 40436 5614 4 note note NN 40436 5614 5 : : : 40436 5614 6 Comparison comparison NN 40436 5614 7 with with IN 40436 5614 8 other other JJ 40436 5614 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5614 10 -- -- : 40436 5614 11 Republic Republic NNP 40436 5614 12 , , , 40436 5614 13 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 5614 14 , , , 40436 5614 15 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5614 16 . . . 40436 5615 1 The the DT 40436 5615 2 only only JJ 40436 5615 3 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5615 4 answer answer NN 40436 5615 5 is be VBZ 40436 5615 6 found find VBN 40436 5615 7 in in IN 40436 5615 8 the the DT 40436 5615 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5615 10 . . . 40436 5615 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5616 1 The the DT 40436 5616 2 question question NN 40436 5616 3 here here RB 40436 5616 4 raised raise VBN 40436 5616 5 is be VBZ 40436 5616 6 present present JJ 40436 5616 7 to to IN 40436 5616 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5616 9 's 's POS 40436 5616 10 mind mind NN 40436 5616 11 in in IN 40436 5616 12 other other JJ 40436 5616 13 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5616 14 , , , 40436 5616 15 and and CC 40436 5616 16 occurs occur VBZ 40436 5616 17 under under IN 40436 5616 18 other other JJ 40436 5616 19 words word NNS 40436 5616 20 , , , 40436 5616 21 as as IN 40436 5616 22 for for IN 40436 5616 23 example example NN 40436 5616 24 , , , 40436 5616 25 What what WP 40436 5616 26 is be VBZ 40436 5616 27 good good JJ 40436 5616 28 ? ? . 40436 5617 1 Good good JJ 40436 5617 2 is be VBZ 40436 5617 3 the the DT 40436 5617 4 object object NN 40436 5617 5 of of IN 40436 5617 6 the the DT 40436 5617 7 Regal Regal NNP 40436 5617 8 or or CC 40436 5617 9 political political JJ 40436 5617 10 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5617 11 ; ; : 40436 5617 12 but but CC 40436 5617 13 what what WP 40436 5617 14 is be VBZ 40436 5617 15 Good good JJ 40436 5617 16 ? ? . 40436 5618 1 In in IN 40436 5618 2 the the DT 40436 5618 3 Republic Republic NNP 40436 5618 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 5 raises raise VBZ 40436 5618 6 this this DT 40436 5618 7 question question NN 40436 5618 8 , , , 40436 5618 9 but but CC 40436 5618 10 declines decline VBZ 40436 5618 11 to to TO 40436 5618 12 answer answer VB 40436 5618 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 14 , , , 40436 5618 15 confessing confess VBG 40436 5618 16 that that IN 40436 5618 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 18 could could MD 40436 5618 19 not not RB 40436 5618 20 make make VB 40436 5618 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 22 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 5618 23 to to IN 40436 5618 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5618 25 hearers:[39 hearers:[39 ADD 40436 5618 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5618 27 in in IN 40436 5618 28 the the DT 40436 5618 29 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 5618 30 , , , 40436 5618 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 32 takes take VBZ 40436 5618 33 pains pain NNS 40436 5618 34 to to TO 40436 5618 35 tell tell VB 40436 5618 36 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 37 what what WP 40436 5618 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 39 _ _ NNP 40436 5618 40 is be VBZ 40436 5618 41 not not RB 40436 5618 42 _ _ NNP 40436 5618 43 : : : 40436 5618 44 in in IN 40436 5618 45 the the DT 40436 5618 46 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 5618 47 , , , 40436 5618 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 49 does do VBZ 40436 5618 50 indeed indeed RB 40436 5618 51 tell tell VB 40436 5618 52 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 53 what what WP 40436 5618 54 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 55 is be VBZ 40436 5618 56 , , , 40436 5618 57 but but CC 40436 5618 58 in in IN 40436 5618 59 terms term NNS 40436 5618 60 which which WDT 40436 5618 61 need need VBP 40436 5618 62 explanation explanation NN 40436 5618 63 quite quite RB 40436 5618 64 as as RB 40436 5618 65 much much RB 40436 5618 66 as as IN 40436 5618 67 the the DT 40436 5618 68 term term NN 40436 5618 69 which which WDT 40436 5618 70 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5618 71 are be VBP 40436 5618 72 brought bring VBN 40436 5618 73 to to TO 40436 5618 74 explain explain VB 40436 5618 75 . . . 40436 5619 1 There there EX 40436 5619 2 is be VBZ 40436 5619 3 only only RB 40436 5619 4 one one CD 40436 5619 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5619 6 in in IN 40436 5619 7 which which WDT 40436 5619 8 the the DT 40436 5619 9 question question NN 40436 5619 10 is be VBZ 40436 5619 11 answered answer VBN 40436 5619 12 affirmatively affirmatively RB 40436 5619 13 , , , 40436 5619 14 in in IN 40436 5619 15 clear clear JJ 40436 5619 16 and and CC 40436 5619 17 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 40436 5619 18 language language NN 40436 5619 19 , , , 40436 5619 20 and and CC 40436 5619 21 with with IN 40436 5619 22 considerable considerable JJ 40436 5619 23 development development NN 40436 5619 24 -- -- : 40436 5619 25 and and CC 40436 5619 26 that that DT 40436 5619 27 is is RB 40436 5619 28 , , , 40436 5619 29 the the DT 40436 5619 30 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5619 31 : : : 40436 5619 32 where where WRB 40436 5619 33 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5619 34 asserts assert VBZ 40436 5619 35 and and CC 40436 5619 36 proves prove VBZ 40436 5619 37 at at IN 40436 5619 38 length length NN 40436 5619 39 , , , 40436 5619 40 that that DT 40436 5619 41 Good good JJ 40436 5619 42 is be VBZ 40436 5619 43 at at IN 40436 5619 44 the the DT 40436 5619 45 bottom bottom NN 40436 5619 46 identical identical JJ 40436 5619 47 with with IN 40436 5619 48 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 5619 49 , , , 40436 5619 50 and and CC 40436 5619 51 Evil evil NN 40436 5619 52 with with IN 40436 5619 53 pain pain NN 40436 5619 54 : : : 40436 5619 55 that that IN 40436 5619 56 the the DT 40436 5619 57 measuring measure VBG 40436 5619 58 or or CC 40436 5619 59 calculating calculate VBG 40436 5619 60 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5619 61 is be VBZ 40436 5619 62 the the DT 40436 5619 63 truly truly RB 40436 5619 64 regal regal JJ 40436 5619 65 art art NN 40436 5619 66 of of IN 40436 5619 67 life life NN 40436 5619 68 , , , 40436 5619 69 upon upon IN 40436 5619 70 which which WDT 40436 5619 71 the the DT 40436 5619 72 attainment attainment JJ 40436 5619 73 of of IN 40436 5619 74 Good good JJ 40436 5619 75 depends depend VBZ 40436 5619 76 : : : 40436 5619 77 and and CC 40436 5619 78 that that IN 40436 5619 79 the the DT 40436 5619 80 object object NN 40436 5619 81 of of IN 40436 5619 82 that that DT 40436 5619 83 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5619 84 -- -- : 40436 5619 85 the the DT 40436 5619 86 items item NNS 40436 5619 87 which which WDT 40436 5619 88 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5619 89 are be VBP 40436 5619 90 to to TO 40436 5619 91 measure measure VB 40436 5619 92 , , , 40436 5619 93 calculate calculate VB 40436 5619 94 , , , 40436 5619 95 and and CC 40436 5619 96 compare compare VB 40436 5619 97 -- -- : 40436 5619 98 is be VBZ 40436 5619 99 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 5619 100 and and CC 40436 5619 101 pains pain NNS 40436 5619 102 , , , 40436 5619 103 so so IN 40436 5619 104 as as IN 40436 5619 105 to to TO 40436 5619 106 secure secure VB 40436 5619 107 to to IN 40436 5619 108 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5619 109 as as RB 40436 5619 110 much much RB 40436 5619 111 as as IN 40436 5619 112 possible possible JJ 40436 5619 113 of of IN 40436 5619 114 the the DT 40436 5619 115 former former JJ 40436 5619 116 , , , 40436 5619 117 and and CC 40436 5619 118 escape escape VB 40436 5619 119 as as RB 40436 5619 120 much much RB 40436 5619 121 as as IN 40436 5619 122 possible possible JJ 40436 5619 123 of of IN 40436 5619 124 the the DT 40436 5619 125 latter latter JJ 40436 5619 126 . . . 40436 5620 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5620 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5620 3 39 39 CD 40436 5620 4 : : : 40436 5620 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5620 6 , , , 40436 5620 7 Republic Republic NNP 40436 5620 8 , , , 40436 5620 9 vi vi NNP 40436 5620 10 . . . 40436 5621 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5621 2 . . . 40436 5622 1 505 505 CD 40436 5622 2 - - SYM 40436 5622 3 506 506 CD 40436 5622 4 . . . 40436 5622 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5623 1 In in IN 40436 5623 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5623 3 remarks remark NNS 40436 5623 4 on on IN 40436 5623 5 the the DT 40436 5623 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5623 7 , , , 40436 5623 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5623 9 shall shall MD 40436 5623 10 state state VB 40436 5623 11 the the DT 40436 5623 12 view view NN 40436 5623 13 which which WDT 40436 5623 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5623 15 take take VBP 40436 5623 16 of of IN 40436 5623 17 the the DT 40436 5623 18 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5623 19 laid lay VBD 40436 5623 20 down down RP 40436 5623 21 in in IN 40436 5623 22 that that DT 40436 5623 23 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5623 24 by by IN 40436 5623 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5623 26 . . . 40436 5624 1 Persons person NNS 40436 5624 2 may may MD 40436 5624 3 think think VB 40436 5624 4 the the DT 40436 5624 5 answer answer NN 40436 5624 6 insufficient insufficient NN 40436 5624 7 : : : 40436 5624 8 most most JJS 40436 5624 9 of of IN 40436 5624 10 the the DT 40436 5624 11 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5624 12 critics critic NNS 40436 5624 13 declare declare VBP 40436 5624 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5624 15 to to TO 40436 5624 16 be be VB 40436 5624 17 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 5624 18 wrong wrong JJ 40436 5624 19 . . . 40436 5625 1 But but CC 40436 5625 2 at at IN 40436 5625 3 any any DT 40436 5625 4 rate rate NN 40436 5625 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5625 6 is be VBZ 40436 5625 7 the the DT 40436 5625 8 only only RB 40436 5625 9 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5625 10 answer answer NN 40436 5625 11 which which WDT 40436 5625 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5625 13 ever ever RB 40436 5625 14 gives give VBZ 40436 5625 15 , , , 40436 5625 16 to to IN 40436 5625 17 the the DT 40436 5625 18 question question NN 40436 5625 19 raised raise VBN 40436 5625 20 by by IN 40436 5625 21 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5625 22 in in IN 40436 5625 23 the the DT 40436 5625 24 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5625 25 and and CC 40436 5625 26 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 5625 27 . . . 40436 5626 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5626 2 Side side NN 40436 5626 3 - - HYPH 40436 5626 4 note note NN 40436 5626 5 : : : 40436 5626 6 The the DT 40436 5626 7 talk talk NN 40436 5626 8 of of IN 40436 5626 9 the the DT 40436 5626 10 two two CD 40436 5626 11 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5626 12 , , , 40436 5626 13 though though IN 40436 5626 14 ironically ironically RB 40436 5626 15 admired admire VBN 40436 5626 16 while while IN 40436 5626 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5626 18 is be VBZ 40436 5626 19 going go VBG 40436 5626 20 on on RP 40436 5626 21 , , , 40436 5626 22 is be VBZ 40436 5626 23 shown show VBN 40436 5626 24 at at IN 40436 5626 25 the the DT 40436 5626 26 end end NN 40436 5626 27 to to TO 40436 5626 28 produce produce VB 40436 5626 29 no no DT 40436 5626 30 real real JJ 40436 5626 31 admiration admiration NN 40436 5626 32 , , , 40436 5626 33 but but CC 40436 5626 34 the the DT 40436 5626 35 contrary contrary NN 40436 5626 36 . . . 40436 5626 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5627 1 From from IN 40436 5627 2 the the DT 40436 5627 3 abstract abstract NN 40436 5627 4 just just RB 40436 5627 5 given give VBN 40436 5627 6 of of IN 40436 5627 7 the the DT 40436 5627 8 argument argument NN 40436 5627 9 of of IN 40436 5627 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5627 11 in in IN 40436 5627 12 the the DT 40436 5627 13 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5627 14 , , , 40436 5627 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5627 16 will will MD 40436 5627 17 be be VB 40436 5627 18 seen see VBN 40436 5627 19 to to TO 40436 5627 20 be be VB 40436 5627 21 serious serious JJ 40436 5627 22 and and CC 40436 5627 23 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 5627 24 , , , 40436 5627 25 though though IN 40436 5627 26 ending end VBG 40436 5627 27 with with IN 40436 5627 28 a a DT 40436 5627 29 confession confession NN 40436 5627 30 of of IN 40436 5627 31 failure failure NN 40436 5627 32 . . . 40436 5628 1 The the DT 40436 5628 2 observations observation NNS 40436 5628 3 placed place VBN 40436 5628 4 in in IN 40436 5628 5 contrast contrast NN 40436 5628 6 with with IN 40436 5628 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5628 8 and and CC 40436 5628 9 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 5628 10 to to IN 40436 5628 11 the the DT 40436 5628 12 two two CD 40436 5628 13 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5628 14 , , , 40436 5628 15 are be VBP 40436 5628 16 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 5628 17 by by IN 40436 5628 18 being be VBG 40436 5628 19 neither neither CC 40436 5628 20 serious serious JJ 40436 5628 21 nor nor CC 40436 5628 22 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 5628 23 ; ; : 40436 5628 24 but but CC 40436 5628 25 parodies parody NNS 40436 5628 26 of of IN 40436 5628 27 debate debate NN 40436 5628 28 for for IN 40436 5628 29 the the DT 40436 5628 30 most most JJS 40436 5628 31 part part NN 40436 5628 32 , , , 40436 5628 33 put put VBN 40436 5628 34 together together RB 40436 5628 35 for for IN 40436 5628 36 the the DT 40436 5628 37 express express JJ 40436 5628 38 purpose purpose NN 40436 5628 39 of of IN 40436 5628 40 appearing appear VBG 40436 5628 41 obviously obviously RB 40436 5628 42 silly silly JJ 40436 5628 43 to to IN 40436 5628 44 the the DT 40436 5628 45 reader reader NN 40436 5628 46 . . . 40436 5629 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5629 2 keeps keep VBZ 40436 5629 3 up up RP 40436 5629 4 the the DT 40436 5629 5 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 5629 6 or or CC 40436 5629 7 ironical ironical JJ 40436 5629 8 appearance appearance NN 40436 5629 9 , , , 40436 5629 10 that that IN 40436 5629 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5629 12 are be VBP 40436 5629 13 admired admire VBN 40436 5629 14 and and CC 40436 5629 15 welcomed welcome VBD 40436 5629 16 not not RB 40436 5629 17 only only RB 40436 5629 18 by by IN 40436 5629 19 the the DT 40436 5629 20 hearers hearer NNS 40436 5629 21 , , , 40436 5629 22 but but CC 40436 5629 23 even even RB 40436 5629 24 by by IN 40436 5629 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5629 26 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5629 27 . . . 40436 5630 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5630 2 , , , 40436 5630 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5630 4 is be VBZ 40436 5630 5 made make VBN 40436 5630 6 clear clear JJ 40436 5630 7 at at IN 40436 5630 8 the the DT 40436 5630 9 end end NN 40436 5630 10 that that WDT 40436 5630 11 all all PDT 40436 5630 12 this this DT 40436 5630 13 is be VBZ 40436 5630 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 5630 15 but but IN 40436 5630 16 irony irony NN 40436 5630 17 , , , 40436 5630 18 and and CC 40436 5630 19 that that IN 40436 5630 20 the the DT 40436 5630 21 talk talk NN 40436 5630 22 which which WDT 40436 5630 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5630 24 ascribes ascribe NNS 40436 5630 25 to to IN 40436 5630 26 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5630 27 and and CC 40436 5630 28 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5630 29 produced produce VBD 40436 5630 30 , , , 40436 5630 31 according accord VBG 40436 5630 32 to to IN 40436 5630 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5630 34 own own JJ 40436 5630 35 showing showing NN 40436 5630 36 , , , 40436 5630 37 no no DT 40436 5630 38 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 5630 39 of of IN 40436 5630 40 esteem esteem NN 40436 5630 41 for for IN 40436 5630 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5630 43 abilities ability NNS 40436 5630 44 among among IN 40436 5630 45 the the DT 40436 5630 46 by by NN 40436 5630 47 - - HYPH 40436 5630 48 standers stander NNS 40436 5630 49 , , , 40436 5630 50 but but CC 40436 5630 51 quite quite PDT 40436 5630 52 the the DT 40436 5630 53 reverse reverse NN 40436 5630 54 . . . 40436 5631 1 Whether whether IN 40436 5631 2 there there EX 40436 5631 3 were be VBD 40436 5631 4 individual individual JJ 40436 5631 5 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5631 6 at at IN 40436 5631 7 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5631 8 who who WP 40436 5631 9 talked talk VBD 40436 5631 10 in in IN 40436 5631 11 that that DT 40436 5631 12 style style NN 40436 5631 13 , , , 40436 5631 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5631 15 can can MD 40436 5631 16 neither neither CC 40436 5631 17 affirm affirm VB 40436 5631 18 nor nor CC 40436 5631 19 deny deny VB 40436 5631 20 : : : 40436 5631 21 but but CC 40436 5631 22 that that IN 40436 5631 23 there there EX 40436 5631 24 were be VBD 40436 5631 25 an an DT 40436 5631 26 established establish VBN 40436 5631 27 class class NN 40436 5631 28 of of IN 40436 5631 29 persons person NNS 40436 5631 30 who who WP 40436 5631 31 did do VBD 40436 5631 32 so so RB 40436 5631 33 , , , 40436 5631 34 and and CC 40436 5631 35 made make VBD 40436 5631 36 both both DT 40436 5631 37 money money NN 40436 5631 38 and and CC 40436 5631 39 reputation reputation NN 40436 5631 40 by by IN 40436 5631 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5631 42 , , , 40436 5631 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5631 44 can can MD 40436 5631 45 securely securely RB 40436 5631 46 deny deny VB 40436 5631 47 . . . 40436 5632 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5632 2 is be VBZ 40436 5632 3 the the DT 40436 5632 4 more more RBR 40436 5632 5 surprising surprising JJ 40436 5632 6 that that IN 40436 5632 7 the the DT 40436 5632 8 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5632 9 commentators commentator NNS 40436 5632 10 should should MD 40436 5632 11 desire desire VB 40436 5632 12 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5632 13 to to TO 40436 5632 14 regard regard VB 40436 5632 15 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5632 16 and and CC 40436 5632 17 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5632 18 as as IN 40436 5632 19 representative representative JJ 40436 5632 20 samples sample NNS 40436 5632 21 of of IN 40436 5632 22 a a DT 40436 5632 23 special special JJ 40436 5632 24 class class NN 40436 5632 25 named name VBN 40436 5632 26 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5632 27 , , , 40436 5632 28 since since IN 40436 5632 29 one one CD 40436 5632 30 of of IN 40436 5632 31 the the DT 40436 5632 32 most most RBS 40436 5632 33 eminent eminent JJ 40436 5632 34 of of IN 40436 5632 35 those those DT 40436 5632 36 commentators commentator NNS 40436 5632 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5632 38 Stallbaum),[40 stallbaum),[40 LS 40436 5632 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5632 40 both both DT 40436 5632 41 admits admit VBZ 40436 5632 42 that that IN 40436 5632 43 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5632 44 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5632 45 was be VBD 40436 5632 46 generally generally RB 40436 5632 47 numbered number VBN 40436 5632 48 in in IN 40436 5632 49 the the DT 40436 5632 50 class class NN 40436 5632 51 and and CC 40436 5632 52 called call VBN 40436 5632 53 by by IN 40436 5632 54 the the DT 40436 5632 55 name name NN 40436 5632 56 and and CC 40436 5632 57 affirms affirm NNS 40436 5632 58 also also RB 40436 5632 59 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5632 60 incorrectly incorrectly RB 40436 5632 61 , , , 40436 5632 62 in in IN 40436 5632 63 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5632 64 opinion opinion NN 40436 5632 65 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5632 66 that that IN 40436 5632 67 the the DT 40436 5632 68 interrogations interrogation NNS 40436 5632 69 of of IN 40436 5632 70 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5632 71 , , , 40436 5632 72 which which WDT 40436 5632 73 in in IN 40436 5632 74 this this DT 40436 5632 75 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5632 76 stand stand VBP 40436 5632 77 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 5632 78 with with IN 40436 5632 79 those those DT 40436 5632 80 of of IN 40436 5632 81 the the DT 40436 5632 82 two two CD 40436 5632 83 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5632 84 , , , 40436 5632 85 do do VBP 40436 5632 86 not not RB 40436 5632 87 enunciate enunciate VB 40436 5632 88 the the DT 40436 5632 89 opinions opinion NNS 40436 5632 90 either either RB 40436 5632 91 of of IN 40436 5632 92 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5632 93 or or CC 40436 5632 94 of of IN 40436 5632 95 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5632 96 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5632 97 , , , 40436 5632 98 but but CC 40436 5632 99 the the DT 40436 5632 100 opinions opinion NNS 40436 5632 101 of of IN 40436 5632 102 these these DT 40436 5632 103 very very JJ 40436 5632 104 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5632 105 , , , 40436 5632 106 which which WDT 40436 5632 107 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5632 108 adopts adopt NNS 40436 5632 109 and and CC 40436 5632 110 utters utter NNS 40436 5632 111 for for IN 40436 5632 112 the the DT 40436 5632 113 occasion occasion NN 40436 5632 114 . . . 40436 5633 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5633 2 41 41 CD 40436 5633 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5633 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5633 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5633 6 40 40 CD 40436 5633 7 : : : 40436 5633 8 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5633 9 , , , 40436 5633 10 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 5633 11 . . . 40436 5634 1 in in IN 40436 5634 2 Platon Platon NNP 40436 5634 3 . . . 40436 5635 1 Euthydem Euthydem NNP 40436 5635 2 . . . 40436 5636 1 p. p. NN 40436 5636 2 50 50 CD 40436 5636 3 . . . 40436 5637 1 " " `` 40436 5637 2 Illud illud RB 40436 5637 3 quidem quidem NN 40436 5637 4 ex ex NNP 40436 5637 5 Aristophane Aristophane NNP 40436 5637 6 pariter pariter NN 40436 5637 7 atque atque NN 40436 5637 8 ipso ipso FW 40436 5637 9 Platone Platone NNP 40436 5637 10 evidenter evidenter NN 40436 5637 11 apparet apparet NN 40436 5637 12 , , , 40436 5637 13 Socratem Socratem NNP 40436 5637 14 non non JJ 40436 5637 15 tantum tantum NN 40436 5637 16 ab ab NNP 40436 5637 17 orationum orationum NNP 40436 5637 18 scriptoribus scriptoribus NNP 40436 5637 19 , , , 40436 5637 20 sed sed NNP 40436 5637 21 etiam etiam NNP 40436 5637 22 ab ab NNP 40436 5637 23 aliis aliis NNP 40436 5637 24 in in IN 40436 5637 25 vanissimorum vanissimorum NNP 40436 5637 26 sophistarum sophistarum NNP 40436 5637 27 numero numero NNP 40436 5637 28 habitum habitum NNP 40436 5637 29 fuisse fuisse NNP 40436 5637 30 . . . 40436 5637 31 " " '' 40436 5638 1 Ib ib IN 40436 5638 2 . . . 40436 5639 1 p. p. NN 40436 5639 2 49 49 CD 40436 5639 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5639 4 cited cite VBN 40436 5639 5 in in IN 40436 5639 6 a a DT 40436 5639 7 previous previous JJ 40436 5639 8 note note NN 40436 5639 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5639 10 . . . 40436 5640 1 " " `` 40436 5640 2 Videtur Videtur NNP 40436 5640 3 pervulgata pervulgata NN 40436 5640 4 fuisse fuisse NNP 40436 5640 5 hominum hominum NNP 40436 5640 6 opinio opinio NNP 40436 5640 7 , , , 40436 5640 8 quâ quâ NNP 40436 5640 9 Socratem Socratem NNP 40436 5640 10 inter inter NN 40436 5640 11 vanos vanos NNP 40436 5640 12 sophistas sophistas NNP 40436 5640 13 numerandum numerandum IN 40436 5640 14 esse esse NNP 40436 5640 15 existimabant existimabant NNP 40436 5640 16 . . . 40436 5640 17 " " '' 40436 5641 1 Again again RB 40436 5641 2 p. p. NN 40436 5641 3 44 44 CD 40436 5641 4 , , , 40436 5641 5 where where WRB 40436 5641 6 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5641 7 tells tell VBZ 40436 5641 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5641 9 that that IN 40436 5641 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5641 11 was be VBD 40436 5641 12 considered consider VBN 40436 5641 13 by by IN 40436 5641 14 many many JJ 40436 5641 15 to to TO 40436 5641 16 belong belong VB 40436 5641 17 " " `` 40436 5641 18 misellorum misellorum NNP 40436 5641 19 Sophistarum Sophistarum NNP 40436 5641 20 gregi gregi NN 40436 5641 21 " " '' 40436 5641 22 . . . 40436 5641 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5642 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5642 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5642 3 41 41 CD 40436 5642 4 : : : 40436 5642 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5642 6 , , , 40436 5642 7 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 5642 8 . . . 40436 5643 1 ad ad NNP 40436 5643 2 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5643 3 . . . 40436 5644 1 Euthydem Euthydem NNP 40436 5644 2 . . . 40436 5645 1 p. p. NN 40436 5645 2 30 30 CD 40436 5645 3 . . . 40436 5646 1 " " `` 40436 5646 2 Cavendum cavendum NN 40436 5646 3 est est VBD 40436 5646 4 magnopere magnopere RB 40436 5646 5 , , , 40436 5646 6 ne ne NNP 40436 5646 7 quæ quæ NNP 40436 5646 8 hic hic NNP 40436 5646 9 à à DT 40436 5646 10 Socrate socrate JJ 40436 5646 11 disputantur disputantur NN 40436 5646 12 , , , 40436 5646 13 pro pro JJ 40436 5646 14 ipsius ipsius JJ 40436 5646 15 decretis decretis NNP 40436 5646 16 habeamus habeamus NNP 40436 5646 17 : : : 40436 5646 18 _ _ NNP 40436 5646 19 sunt sunt NN 40436 5646 20 enim enim NNP 40436 5646 21 omnia omnia NNP 40436 5646 22 ad ad NN 40436 5646 23 mentem mentem NN 40436 5646 24 Sophistarum Sophistarum NNP 40436 5646 25 disputata disputata NN 40436 5646 26 _ _ NNP 40436 5646 27 , , , 40436 5646 28 quos quos NNP 40436 5646 29 ille ille NNP 40436 5646 30 , , , 40436 5646 31 reprehensis reprehensis NNP 40436 5646 32 eorum eorum NNP 40436 5646 33 opinionibus opinionibus NNP 40436 5646 34 , , , 40436 5646 35 sperat sperat NNP 40436 5646 36 eo eo NNP 40436 5646 37 adductum adductum NNP 40436 5646 38 iri iri NNP 40436 5646 39 , , , 40436 5646 40 ut ut UH 40436 5646 41 gravem gravem NNP 40436 5646 42 prudentemque prudentemque NNP 40436 5646 43 earum earum NNP 40436 5646 44 defensionem defensionem NNP 40436 5646 45 suscipiant suscipiant NN 40436 5646 46 . . . 40436 5646 47 " " '' 40436 5647 1 Compare compare VB 40436 5647 2 p. p. NN 40436 5647 3 66 66 CD 40436 5647 4 . . . 40436 5648 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 5648 2 says say VBZ 40436 5648 3 that that IN 40436 5648 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5648 5 often often RB 40436 5648 6 reasons reason NNS 40436 5648 7 , , , 40436 5648 8 adopting adopt VBG 40436 5648 9 for for IN 40436 5648 10 the the DT 40436 5648 11 occasion occasion NN 40436 5648 12 the the DT 40436 5648 13 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 5648 14 of of IN 40436 5648 15 the the DT 40436 5648 16 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5648 17 . . . 40436 5649 1 See see VB 40436 5649 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5649 3 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 40436 5649 4 . . . 40436 5650 1 to to IN 40436 5650 2 the the DT 40436 5650 3 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 5650 4 and and CC 40436 5650 5 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 5650 6 , , , 40436 5650 7 and and CC 40436 5650 8 still still RB 40436 5650 9 more more JJR 40436 5650 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5650 11 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 5650 12 . . . 40436 5651 1 to to IN 40436 5651 2 the the DT 40436 5651 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5651 4 , , , 40436 5651 5 where where WRB 40436 5651 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5651 7 tells tell VBZ 40436 5651 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5651 9 that that IN 40436 5651 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5651 11 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 5651 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5651 13 spokesman spokesman NN 40436 5651 14 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 5651 15 not not RB 40436 5651 16 only only RB 40436 5651 17 as as IN 40436 5651 18 arguing argue VBG 40436 5651 19 _ _ NNP 40436 5651 20 ex ex FW 40436 5651 21 mente mente NNP 40436 5651 22 Sophistarum Sophistarum NNP 40436 5651 23 _ _ NNP 40436 5651 24 , , , 40436 5651 25 but but CC 40436 5651 26 also also RB 40436 5651 27 as as IN 40436 5651 28 employing employ VBG 40436 5651 29 captious captious JJ 40436 5651 30 and and CC 40436 5651 31 delusive delusive JJ 40436 5651 32 artifice artifice NN 40436 5651 33 , , , 40436 5651 34 such such JJ 40436 5651 35 as as IN 40436 5651 36 in in IN 40436 5651 37 this this DT 40436 5651 38 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5651 39 is be VBZ 40436 5651 40 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 5651 41 to to IN 40436 5651 42 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 5651 43 and and CC 40436 5651 44 Dionysodorus.--pp Dionysodorus.--pp NNP 40436 5651 45 . . . 40436 5652 1 23 23 CD 40436 5652 2 - - SYM 40436 5652 3 24 24 CD 40436 5652 4 . . . 40436 5653 1 " " `` 40436 5653 2 Itaque Itaque NNP 40436 5653 3 Socrates Socrates NNP 40436 5653 4 , , , 40436 5653 5 missâ missâ NNP 40436 5653 6 hujus hujus NNP 40436 5653 7 rei rei NNP 40436 5653 8 disputatione disputatione NN 40436 5653 9 , , , 40436 5653 10 repentè repentè NNP 40436 5653 11 ad ad NNP 40436 5653 12 alia alia NNP 40436 5653 13 progreditur progreditur NNP 40436 5653 14 , , , 40436 5653 15 scilicet scilicet NNP 40436 5653 16 _ _ NNP 40436 5653 17 similibus similibus NNP 40436 5653 18 loqueis loqueis NNP 40436 5653 19 _ _ NNP 40436 5653 20 hominem hominem NNP 40436 5653 21 denuo denuo VBZ 40436 5653 22 irretiturus irretiturus NNP 40436 5653 23 . . . 40436 5654 1 Nemini nemini JJ 40436 5654 2 facilé facilé NN 40436 5654 3 obscurum obscurum VB 40436 5654 4 erit erit NNP 40436 5654 5 , , , 40436 5654 6 hoc hoc FW 40436 5654 7 quoque quoque NNP 40436 5654 8 loco loco NNP 40436 5654 9 Protagoram Protagoram NNP 40436 5654 10 _ _ NNP 40436 5654 11 argutis argutis NNP 40436 5654 12 conclusiunculis conclusiunculis NNP 40436 5654 13 deludi deludi NNP 40436 5654 14 _ _ NNP 40436 5654 15 " " '' 40436 5654 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5654 17 _ _ NNP 40436 5654 18 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 5654 19 _ _ NNP 40436 5654 20 by by IN 40436 5654 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5654 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5654 23 " " '' 40436 5654 24 atque atque NNP 40436 5654 25 _ _ NNP 40436 5654 26 callidé callidé NNPS 40436 5654 27 eo eo NNP 40436 5654 28 permoveri permoveri NN 40436 5654 29 , , , 40436 5654 30 _ _ NNP 40436 5654 31 " " '' 40436 5654 32 & & CC 40436 5654 33 c. c. NNP 40436 5654 34 " " `` 40436 5654 35 Quanquam Quanquam NNP 40436 5654 36 nemo nemo NN 40436 5654 37 erit erit NN 40436 5654 38 , , , 40436 5654 39 quin quin NN 40436 5654 40 videat videat NN 40436 5654 41 , , , 40436 5654 42 _ _ NNP 40436 5654 43 callidé callidé NNS 40436 5654 44 deludi deludi JJ 40436 5654 45 Protagoram Protagoram NNP 40436 5654 46 _ _ NNP 40436 5654 47 , , , 40436 5654 48 ubi ubi NNP 40436 5654 49 ex ex NNP 40436 5654 50 eo eo NNP 40436 5654 51 , , , 40436 5654 52 quod quod NNP 40436 5654 53 qui qui NNP 40436 5654 54 injusté injusté NNP 40436 5654 55 faciat faciat NNP 40436 5654 56 , , , 40436 5654 57 is be VBZ 40436 5654 58 neutiquam neutiquam NNP 40436 5654 59 agat agat NNS 40436 5654 60 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5654 61 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5654 62 : : : 40436 5654 63 sôphro sôphro NN 40436 5654 64 / / SYM 40436 5654 65 nôs nôs NN 40436 5654 66 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5654 67 , , , 40436 5654 68 protinus protinus NNP 40436 5654 69 colligitur colligitur NNP 40436 5654 70 justitiam justitiam NNP 40436 5654 71 et et NNP 40436 5654 72 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5654 73 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5654 74 : : : 40436 5654 75 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 5654 76 / / SYM 40436 5654 77 nê nê NNP 40436 5654 78 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5654 79 unum unum NNP 40436 5654 80 idemque idemque NNP 40436 5654 81 esse esse NNP 40436 5654 82 . . . 40436 5654 83 "--p "--p ADD 40436 5654 84 . . . 40436 5655 1 25 25 CD 40436 5655 2 . . . 40436 5656 1 " " `` 40436 5656 2 Disputat disputat NN 40436 5656 3 enim enim NN 40436 5656 4 Socrates socrate VBZ 40436 5656 5 pleraque pleraque NN 40436 5656 6 omnia omnia NNP 40436 5656 7 ad ad NN 40436 5656 8 mentem mentem NN 40436 5656 9 ipsius ipsius NNP 40436 5656 10 Protagoræ Protagoræ NNP 40436 5656 11 . . . 40436 5656 12 "--p "--p ADD 40436 5656 13 . . . 40436 5657 1 30 30 CD 40436 5657 2 . . . 40436 5658 1 " " `` 40436 5658 2 Platonem Platonem NNP 40436 5658 3 ipsum ipsum NN 40436 5658 4 hæc hæc NNP 40436 5658 5 non non NNP 40436 5658 6 probâsse probâsse NNP 40436 5658 7 , , , 40436 5658 8 sed sed NNP 40436 5658 9 e e NNP 40436 5658 10 vulgi vulgi NNP 40436 5658 11 opinione opinione NNP 40436 5658 12 et et NNP 40436 5658 13 mente mente NNP 40436 5658 14 explicasse explicasse NNP 40436 5658 15 , , , 40436 5658 16 vel vel NNP 40436 5658 17 illud illud RB 40436 5658 18 non non VBP 40436 5658 19 obscuré obscuré JJ 40436 5658 20 significat significat NN 40436 5658 21 , , , 40436 5658 22 " " '' 40436 5658 23 & & CC 40436 5658 24 c.--p c.--p NNP 40436 5658 25 . . . 40436 5659 1 33 33 CD 40436 5659 2 . . . 40436 5659 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5660 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5660 2 Side side NN 40436 5660 3 - - HYPH 40436 5660 4 note note NN 40436 5660 5 : : : 40436 5660 6 Mistaken mistaken JJ 40436 5660 7 representations representation NNS 40436 5660 8 about about IN 40436 5660 9 the the DT 40436 5660 10 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5660 11 -- -- : 40436 5660 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5660 13 's 's POS 40436 5660 14 definition definition NN 40436 5660 15 -- -- : 40436 5660 16 no no DT 40436 5660 17 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 40436 5660 18 line line NN 40436 5660 19 can can MD 40436 5660 20 be be VB 40436 5660 21 drawn draw VBN 40436 5660 22 between between IN 40436 5660 23 the the DT 40436 5660 24 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5660 25 and and CC 40436 5660 26 the the DT 40436 5660 27 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 5660 28 . . . 40436 5660 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5661 1 The the DT 40436 5661 2 received received JJ 40436 5661 3 supposition supposition NN 40436 5661 4 that that IN 40436 5661 5 there there EX 40436 5661 6 were be VBD 40436 5661 7 at at IN 40436 5661 8 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5661 9 a a DT 40436 5661 10 class class NN 40436 5661 11 of of IN 40436 5661 12 men man NNS 40436 5661 13 called call VBN 40436 5661 14 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5661 15 who who WP 40436 5661 16 made make VBD 40436 5661 17 money money NN 40436 5661 18 and and CC 40436 5661 19 reputation reputation NN 40436 5661 20 by by IN 40436 5661 21 obvious obvious JJ 40436 5661 22 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5661 23 employed employ VBN 40436 5661 24 to to TO 40436 5661 25 bring bring VB 40436 5661 26 about about RP 40436 5661 27 contradictions contradiction NNS 40436 5661 28 in in IN 40436 5661 29 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5661 30 -- -- : 40436 5661 31 appears appear VBZ 40436 5661 32 to to IN 40436 5661 33 me -PRON- PRP 40436 5661 34 to to TO 40436 5661 35 pervert pervert VB 40436 5661 36 the the DT 40436 5661 37 representations representation NNS 40436 5661 38 given give VBN 40436 5661 39 of of IN 40436 5661 40 ancient ancient JJ 40436 5661 41 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5661 42 . . . 40436 5662 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5662 2 defines define VBZ 40436 5662 3 a a DT 40436 5662 4 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5662 5 to to TO 40436 5662 6 be be VB 40436 5662 7 " " `` 40436 5662 8 one one CD 40436 5662 9 who who WP 40436 5662 10 seeks seek VBZ 40436 5662 11 to to TO 40436 5662 12 make make VB 40436 5662 13 money money NN 40436 5662 14 by by IN 40436 5662 15 apparent apparent JJ 40436 5662 16 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5662 17 which which WDT 40436 5662 18 is be VBZ 40436 5662 19 not not RB 40436 5662 20 real real JJ 40436 5662 21 wisdom":--the wisdom":--the DT 40436 5662 22 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5662 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5662 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5662 25 says say VBZ 40436 5662 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5662 27 is be VBZ 40436 5662 28 an an DT 40436 5662 29 Eristic Eristic NNP 40436 5662 30 who who WP 40436 5662 31 , , , 40436 5662 32 besides besides IN 40436 5662 33 money money NN 40436 5662 34 - - HYPH 40436 5662 35 making making NN 40436 5662 36 , , , 40436 5662 37 seeks seek VBZ 40436 5662 38 for for IN 40436 5662 39 nothing nothing NN 40436 5662 40 but but IN 40436 5662 41 victory victory NN 40436 5662 42 in in IN 40436 5662 43 debate debate NN 40436 5662 44 and and CC 40436 5662 45 humiliation humiliation NN 40436 5662 46 of of IN 40436 5662 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5662 48 opponent:--Distinguishing opponent:--distinguishe VBG 40436 5662 49 the the DT 40436 5662 50 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 5662 51 from from IN 40436 5662 52 the the DT 40436 5662 53 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5662 54 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5662 55 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5662 56 says say VBZ 40436 5662 57 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5662 58 , , , 40436 5662 59 the the DT 40436 5662 60 Dialectician dialectician JJ 40436 5662 61 impugns impugn NNS 40436 5662 62 or or CC 40436 5662 63 defends defend VBZ 40436 5662 64 , , , 40436 5662 65 by by IN 40436 5662 66 probable probable JJ 40436 5662 67 arguments argument NNS 40436 5662 68 , , , 40436 5662 69 probable probable JJ 40436 5662 70 tenets tenet NNS 40436 5662 71 -- -- : 40436 5662 72 that that RB 40436 5662 73 is is RB 40436 5662 74 , , , 40436 5662 75 tenets tenet NNS 40436 5662 76 which which WDT 40436 5662 77 are be VBP 40436 5662 78 believed believe VBN 40436 5662 79 by by IN 40436 5662 80 a a DT 40436 5662 81 numerous numerous JJ 40436 5662 82 public public NN 40436 5662 83 or or CC 40436 5662 84 by by IN 40436 5662 85 a a DT 40436 5662 86 few few JJ 40436 5662 87 wise wise JJ 40436 5662 88 and and CC 40436 5662 89 eminent eminent JJ 40436 5662 90 individuals:--while individuals:--while IN 40436 5662 91 the the DT 40436 5662 92 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 5662 93 deals deal NNS 40436 5662 94 with with IN 40436 5662 95 tenets tenet NNS 40436 5662 96 which which WDT 40436 5662 97 are be VBP 40436 5662 98 probable probable JJ 40436 5662 99 only only RB 40436 5662 100 in in IN 40436 5662 101 appearance appearance NN 40436 5662 102 and and CC 40436 5662 103 not not RB 40436 5662 104 in in IN 40436 5662 105 reality reality NN 40436 5662 106 -- -- : 40436 5662 107 that that DT 40436 5662 108 is be VBZ 40436 5662 109 to to TO 40436 5662 110 say say VB 40436 5662 111 , , , 40436 5662 112 tenets tenet NNS 40436 5662 113 which which WDT 40436 5662 114 almost almost RB 40436 5662 115 every every DT 40436 5662 116 one one CD 40436 5662 117 by by IN 40436 5662 118 the the DT 40436 5662 119 slightest slight JJS 40436 5662 120 attention attention NN 40436 5662 121 recognises recognise NNS 40436 5662 122 as as IN 40436 5662 123 false false JJ 40436 5662 124 . . . 40436 5663 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5663 2 42 42 CD 40436 5663 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5663 4 This this DT 40436 5663 5 definition definition NN 40436 5663 6 is be VBZ 40436 5663 7 founded found VBN 40436 5663 8 , , , 40436 5663 9 partly partly RB 40436 5663 10 on on IN 40436 5663 11 the the DT 40436 5663 12 personal personal JJ 40436 5663 13 character character NN 40436 5663 14 and and CC 40436 5663 15 purpose purpose NN 40436 5663 16 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 5663 17 to to IN 40436 5663 18 the the DT 40436 5663 19 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5663 20 : : : 40436 5663 21 partly partly RB 40436 5663 22 upon upon IN 40436 5663 23 the the DT 40436 5663 24 distinction distinction NN 40436 5663 25 between between IN 40436 5663 26 apparent apparent JJ 40436 5663 27 and and CC 40436 5663 28 real real JJ 40436 5663 29 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5663 30 , , , 40436 5663 31 assumed assume VBN 40436 5663 32 to to TO 40436 5663 33 be be VB 40436 5663 34 known know VBN 40436 5663 35 and and CC 40436 5663 36 permanent permanent JJ 40436 5663 37 . . . 40436 5664 1 Now now RB 40436 5664 2 such such JJ 40436 5664 3 pseudo pseudo NN 40436 5664 4 - - NN 40436 5664 5 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5664 6 was be VBD 40436 5664 7 declared declare VBN 40436 5664 8 by by IN 40436 5664 9 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5664 10 to to TO 40436 5664 11 be be VB 40436 5664 12 the the DT 40436 5664 13 natural natural JJ 40436 5664 14 state state NN 40436 5664 15 of of IN 40436 5664 16 all all DT 40436 5664 17 mankind mankind NN 40436 5664 18 , , , 40436 5664 19 even even RB 40436 5664 20 the the DT 40436 5664 21 most most RBS 40436 5664 22 eminent eminent JJ 40436 5664 23 , , , 40436 5664 24 which which WDT 40436 5664 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5664 26 was be VBD 40436 5664 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5664 28 mission mission NN 40436 5664 29 to to TO 40436 5664 30 expose expose VB 40436 5664 31 : : : 40436 5664 32 moreover moreover RB 40436 5664 33 , , , 40436 5664 34 the the DT 40436 5664 35 determination determination NN 40436 5664 36 , , , 40436 5664 37 what what WP 40436 5664 38 is be VBZ 40436 5664 39 to to TO 40436 5664 40 be be VB 40436 5664 41 comprised comprise VBN 40436 5664 42 in in IN 40436 5664 43 this this DT 40436 5664 44 description description NN 40436 5664 45 , , , 40436 5664 46 must must MD 40436 5664 47 depend depend VB 40436 5664 48 upon upon IN 40436 5664 49 the the DT 40436 5664 50 judges judge NNS 40436 5664 51 to to TO 40436 5664 52 whom whom WP 40436 5664 53 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5664 54 is be VBZ 40436 5664 55 submitted submit VBN 40436 5664 56 , , , 40436 5664 57 since since IN 40436 5664 58 much much JJ 40436 5664 59 of of IN 40436 5664 60 the the DT 40436 5664 61 works work NNS 40436 5664 62 of of IN 40436 5664 63 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5664 64 and and CC 40436 5664 65 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5664 66 would would MD 40436 5664 67 come come VB 40436 5664 68 under under IN 40436 5664 69 the the DT 40436 5664 70 category category NN 40436 5664 71 , , , 40436 5664 72 in in IN 40436 5664 73 the the DT 40436 5664 74 judgment judgment NN 40436 5664 75 of of IN 40436 5664 76 modern modern JJ 40436 5664 77 readers reader NNS 40436 5664 78 both both CC 40436 5664 79 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 5664 80 and and CC 40436 5664 81 instructed instruct VBD 40436 5664 82 . . . 40436 5665 1 But but CC 40436 5665 2 apart apart RB 40436 5665 3 from from IN 40436 5665 4 this this DT 40436 5665 5 relative relative JJ 40436 5665 6 and and CC 40436 5665 7 variable variable JJ 40436 5665 8 character character NN 40436 5665 9 of of IN 40436 5665 10 the the DT 40436 5665 11 definition definition NN 40436 5665 12 , , , 40436 5665 13 when when WRB 40436 5665 14 applied apply VBN 40436 5665 15 to to IN 40436 5665 16 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5665 17 generally generally RB 40436 5665 18 -- -- : 40436 5665 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5665 20 may may MD 40436 5665 21 confidently confidently RB 40436 5665 22 assert assert VB 40436 5665 23 , , , 40436 5665 24 that that IN 40436 5665 25 there there EX 40436 5665 26 never never RB 40436 5665 27 was be VBD 40436 5665 28 any any DT 40436 5665 29 real real JJ 40436 5665 30 class class NN 40436 5665 31 of of IN 40436 5665 32 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 5665 33 men man NNS 40436 5665 34 , , , 40436 5665 35 in in IN 40436 5665 36 a a DT 40436 5665 37 given give VBN 40436 5665 38 time time NN 40436 5665 39 or or CC 40436 5665 40 place place NN 40436 5665 41 , , , 40436 5665 42 to to TO 40436 5665 43 whom whom WP 40436 5665 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5665 45 could could MD 40436 5665 46 possibly possibly RB 40436 5665 47 apply apply VB 40436 5665 48 . . . 40436 5666 1 Of of IN 40436 5666 2 individuals individual NNS 40436 5666 3 , , , 40436 5666 4 the the DT 40436 5666 5 varieties variety NNS 40436 5666 6 are be VBP 40436 5666 7 innumerable innumerable JJ 40436 5666 8 : : : 40436 5666 9 but but CC 40436 5666 10 no no DT 40436 5666 11 professional professional JJ 40436 5666 12 body body NN 40436 5666 13 of of IN 40436 5666 14 men man NNS 40436 5666 15 ever ever RB 40436 5666 16 acquired acquire VBD 40436 5666 17 gain gain NN 40436 5666 18 or or CC 40436 5666 19 celebrity celebrity NN 40436 5666 20 by by IN 40436 5666 21 maintaining maintain VBG 40436 5666 22 these these DT 40436 5666 23 s s POS 40436 5666 24 , , , 40436 5666 25 and and CC 40436 5666 26 employing employ VBG 40436 5666 27 arguments argument NNS 40436 5666 28 , , , 40436 5666 29 which which WDT 40436 5666 30 every every DT 40436 5666 31 one one NN 40436 5666 32 could could MD 40436 5666 33 easily easily RB 40436 5666 34 detect detect VB 40436 5666 35 as as RB 40436 5666 36 false false JJ 40436 5666 37 . . . 40436 5667 1 Every every DT 40436 5667 2 man man NN 40436 5667 3 employs employ VBZ 40436 5667 4 sophisms sophism NNS 40436 5667 5 more more RBR 40436 5667 6 or or CC 40436 5667 7 less less RBR 40436 5667 8 ; ; : 40436 5667 9 every every DT 40436 5667 10 man man NN 40436 5667 11 does do VBZ 40436 5667 12 so so RB 40436 5667 13 inadvertently inadvertently RB 40436 5667 14 , , , 40436 5667 15 some some DT 40436 5667 16 do do VBP 40436 5667 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5667 18 by by IN 40436 5667 19 design design NN 40436 5667 20 also also RB 40436 5667 21 ; ; : 40436 5667 22 moreover moreover RB 40436 5667 23 , , , 40436 5667 24 almost almost RB 40436 5667 25 every every DT 40436 5667 26 reasoner reasoner NN 40436 5667 27 does do VBZ 40436 5667 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5667 29 largely largely RB 40436 5667 30 , , , 40436 5667 31 in in IN 40436 5667 32 the the DT 40436 5667 33 estimation estimation NN 40436 5667 34 of of IN 40436 5667 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5667 36 opponents opponent NNS 40436 5667 37 . . . 40436 5668 1 No no DT 40436 5668 2 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5668 3 line line NN 40436 5668 4 can can MD 40436 5668 5 be be VB 40436 5668 6 drawn draw VBN 40436 5668 7 between between IN 40436 5668 8 the the DT 40436 5668 9 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5668 10 and and CC 40436 5668 11 the the DT 40436 5668 12 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 5668 13 : : : 40436 5668 14 the the DT 40436 5668 15 definition definition NN 40436 5668 16 given give VBN 40436 5668 17 by by IN 40436 5668 18 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5668 19 applies apply VBZ 40436 5668 20 to to IN 40436 5668 21 an an DT 40436 5668 22 ideal ideal NN 40436 5668 23 in in IN 40436 5668 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5668 25 own own JJ 40436 5668 26 mind mind NN 40436 5668 27 , , , 40436 5668 28 but but CC 40436 5668 29 to to IN 40436 5668 30 no no DT 40436 5668 31 reality reality NN 40436 5668 32 without without IN 40436 5668 33 : : : 40436 5668 34 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5668 35 and and CC 40436 5668 36 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 5668 37 no no DT 40436 5668 38 more more RBR 40436 5668 39 correspond correspond NN 40436 5668 40 to to IN 40436 5668 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5668 42 than than IN 40436 5668 43 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5668 44 and and CC 40436 5668 45 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5668 46 . . . 40436 5669 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5669 2 observes observe VBZ 40436 5669 3 , , , 40436 5669 4 with with IN 40436 5669 5 great great JJ 40436 5669 6 truth truth NN 40436 5669 7 , , , 40436 5669 8 that that IN 40436 5669 9 all all DT 40436 5669 10 men man NNS 40436 5669 11 are be VBP 40436 5669 12 dialecticians dialectician NNS 40436 5669 13 and and CC 40436 5669 14 testers tester NNS 40436 5669 15 of of IN 40436 5669 16 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5669 17 , , , 40436 5669 18 up up IN 40436 5669 19 to to IN 40436 5669 20 a a DT 40436 5669 21 certain certain JJ 40436 5669 22 point point NN 40436 5669 23 : : : 40436 5669 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5669 25 might may MD 40436 5669 26 have have VB 40436 5669 27 added add VBN 40436 5669 28 that that IN 40436 5669 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5669 30 are be VBP 40436 5669 31 all all DT 40436 5669 32 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5669 33 also also RB 40436 5669 34 , , , 40436 5669 35 up up IN 40436 5669 36 to to IN 40436 5669 37 a a DT 40436 5669 38 certain certain JJ 40436 5669 39 point point NN 40436 5669 40 . . . 40436 5670 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5670 2 43 43 CD 40436 5670 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5670 4 Moreover moreover RB 40436 5670 5 , , , 40436 5670 6 when when WRB 40436 5670 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5670 8 attempts attempt VBZ 40436 5670 9 to to TO 40436 5670 10 found found VB 40436 5670 11 a a DT 40436 5670 12 scientific scientific JJ 40436 5670 13 classification classification NN 40436 5670 14 of of IN 40436 5670 15 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 5670 16 processes process NNS 40436 5670 17 upon upon IN 40436 5670 18 a a DT 40436 5670 19 difference difference NN 40436 5670 20 in in IN 40436 5670 21 the the DT 40436 5670 22 purposes purpose NNS 40436 5670 23 of of IN 40436 5670 24 different different JJ 40436 5670 25 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 5670 26 -- -- : 40436 5670 27 whether whether IN 40436 5670 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5670 29 employ employ VBP 40436 5670 30 the the DT 40436 5670 31 same same JJ 40436 5670 32 process process NN 40436 5670 33 for for IN 40436 5670 34 money money NN 40436 5670 35 or or CC 40436 5670 36 display display NN 40436 5670 37 , , , 40436 5670 38 or or CC 40436 5670 39 beneficence beneficence NN 40436 5670 40 , , , 40436 5670 41 or or CC 40436 5670 42 mental mental JJ 40436 5670 43 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 5670 44 to to IN 40436 5670 45 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5670 46 -- -- : 40436 5670 47 this this DT 40436 5670 48 is be VBZ 40436 5670 49 altogether altogether RB 40436 5670 50 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 40436 5670 51 . . . 40436 5671 1 The the DT 40436 5671 2 medical medical JJ 40436 5671 3 art art NN 40436 5671 4 is be VBZ 40436 5671 5 the the DT 40436 5671 6 same same JJ 40436 5671 7 , , , 40436 5671 8 whether whether IN 40436 5671 9 employed employ VBN 40436 5671 10 to to TO 40436 5671 11 advise advise VB 40436 5671 12 gratis gratis NN 40436 5671 13 , , , 40436 5671 14 or or CC 40436 5671 15 in in IN 40436 5671 16 exchange exchange NN 40436 5671 17 for for IN 40436 5671 18 a a DT 40436 5671 19 fee fee NN 40436 5671 20 . . . 40436 5672 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5672 2 44 44 CD 40436 5672 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5672 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5672 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5672 6 42 42 CD 40436 5672 7 : : : 40436 5672 8 Aristotel Aristotel NNP 40436 5672 9 . . . 40436 5673 1 Topic Topic NNP 40436 5673 2 , , , 40436 5673 3 i. i. NNP 40436 5674 1 1 1 CD 40436 5674 2 , , , 40436 5674 3 p. p. NN 40436 5674 4 100 100 CD 40436 5674 5 , , , 40436 5674 6 b. b. NNP 40436 5675 1 21 21 CD 40436 5675 2 . . . 40436 5676 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5676 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5676 3 : : : 40436 5676 4 e)/ndoxa e)/ndoxa NNP 40436 5676 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5676 6 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 5676 7 dokou dokou NNP 40436 5676 8 = = SYM 40436 5676 9 nta nta NNP 40436 5676 10 pa pa NNP 40436 5676 11 = = SYM 40436 5676 12 sin sin NN 40436 5676 13 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 5676 14 toi toi NNP 40436 5676 15 = = SYM 40436 5676 16 s s NNP 40436 5676 17 plei plei NNP 40436 5676 18 / / SYM 40436 5676 19 stois stois NNP 40436 5676 20 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 5676 21 toi toi NNP 40436 5676 22 = = SYM 40436 5676 23 s s NNP 40436 5676 24 sophoi sophoi NNP 40436 5676 25 = = SYM 40436 5676 26 s s NNP 40436 5676 27 , , , 40436 5676 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5676 29 tou tou NNP 40436 5676 30 / / SYM 40436 5676 31 tois tois NNP 40436 5676 32 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 5676 33 pa pa NNP 40436 5676 34 = = SYM 40436 5676 35 sin sin NN 40436 5676 36 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 5676 37 toi toi NNP 40436 5676 38 = = SYM 40436 5676 39 s s NNP 40436 5676 40 plei plei NNP 40436 5676 41 / / SYM 40436 5676 42 stois stois NNP 40436 5676 43 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 5676 44 toi toi NNP 40436 5676 45 = = SYM 40436 5676 46 s s NNP 40436 5676 47 ma ma NNP 40436 5676 48 / / SYM 40436 5676 49 lista lista NNP 40436 5676 50 gnôri gnôri NNP 40436 5676 51 / / SYM 40436 5676 52 mois mois NNP 40436 5676 53 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5676 54 e)ndo e)ndo NNP 40436 5676 55 / / SYM 40436 5676 56 xois xois NNP 40436 5676 57 . . . 40436 5677 1 E)ristiko\s E)ristiko\s NNP 40436 5677 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5677 3 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 5677 4 sullogismo\s sullogismo\s ADD 40436 5677 5 o o XX 40436 5677 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5677 7 e)k e)k NNP 40436 5677 8 phainome phainome NN 40436 5677 9 / / SYM 40436 5677 10 nôn nôn NN 40436 5677 11 e)ndo e)ndo NNP 40436 5677 12 / / SYM 40436 5677 13 xôn xôn NNP 40436 5677 14 , , , 40436 5677 15 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 5677 16 o)/ntôn o)/ntôn NN 40436 5677 17 de\--kai\ de\--kai\ NNP 40436 5677 18 o o NNP 40436 5677 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5677 20 e)x e)x NNP 40436 5677 21 e)ndo e)ndo -RRB- 40436 5677 22 / / SYM 40436 5677 23 xôn xôn NNP 40436 5677 24 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 5677 25 phainome phainome NN 40436 5677 26 / / SYM 40436 5677 27 nôn nôn NNP 40436 5677 28 e)ndo e)ndo NNP 40436 5677 29 / / SYM 40436 5677 30 xôn xôn NNP 40436 5677 31 phaino phaino NNP 40436 5677 32 / / SYM 40436 5677 33 menos menos NNP 40436 5677 34 . . . 40436 5678 1 Ou)the\n ou)the\n XX 40436 5678 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5678 3 tô tô NNP 40436 5678 4 = = NFP 40436 5678 5 n n CC 40436 5678 6 legome legome JJ 40436 5678 7 / / SYM 40436 5678 8 nôn nôn NN 40436 5678 9 e)ndo e)ndo NNP 40436 5678 10 / / SYM 40436 5678 11 xôn xôn NNP 40436 5678 12 e)pipolai e)pipolai NNP 40436 5678 13 / / SYM 40436 5678 14 on on IN 40436 5678 15 e)/chei e)/chei NNP 40436 5678 16 pantelô pantelô NNP 40436 5678 17 = = SYM 40436 5678 18 s s NNP 40436 5678 19 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5678 20 phantasi phantasi NNP 40436 5678 21 / / SYM 40436 5678 22 an an DT 40436 5678 23 , , , 40436 5678 24 katha katha NNP 40436 5678 25 / / SYM 40436 5678 26 per per IN 40436 5678 27 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 5678 28 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 5678 29 tô tô NNP 40436 5678 30 = = SYM 40436 5678 31 n n NNP 40436 5678 32 e)ristikô e)ristikô NNP 40436 5678 33 = = SYM 40436 5678 34 n n CC 40436 5678 35 lo lo NNP 40436 5678 36 / / SYM 40436 5678 37 gôn gôn NNP 40436 5678 38 a)rcha\s a)rcha\s NNP 40436 5678 39 sumbe sumbe NNP 40436 5678 40 / / SYM 40436 5678 41 bêken bêken VBN 40436 5678 42 e)/chein e)/chein RB 40436 5678 43 . . . 40436 5679 1 Parachrê Parachrê NNP 40436 5679 2 = = SYM 40436 5679 3 ma ma NNP 40436 5679 4 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5679 5 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5679 6 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 5679 7 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 5679 8 to\ to\ NN 40436 5679 9 polu\ polu\ . 40436 5679 10 toi toi NNP 40436 5679 11 = = SYM 40436 5679 12 s s NNP 40436 5679 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5679 14 mikra\ mikra\ IN 40436 5679 15 sunora=|n sunora=|n NNP 40436 5679 16 duname duname NNP 40436 5679 17 / / SYM 40436 5679 18 nois nois NNP 40436 5679 19 , , , 40436 5679 20 kata kata NNP 40436 5679 21 / / SYM 40436 5679 22 dêlos dêlos NNP 40436 5679 23 e)n e)n NNP 40436 5679 24 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 5679 25 = = NNP 40436 5679 26 s s NNP 40436 5679 27 ê ê NN 40436 5679 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5679 29 tou= tou= NNP 40436 5679 30 pseu pseu NNS 40436 5679 31 / / SYM 40436 5679 32 dous dous JJ 40436 5679 33 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 5679 34 phu phu NNP 40436 5679 35 / / SYM 40436 5679 36 sis sis NNP 40436 5679 37 . . . 40436 5679 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5680 1 De De NNP 40436 5680 2 Sophisticis Sophisticis NNP 40436 5680 3 Elenchis Elenchis NNP 40436 5680 4 , , , 40436 5680 5 i. i. NNP 40436 5680 6 p. p. NN 40436 5680 7 165 165 CD 40436 5680 8 , , , 40436 5680 9 a. a. NN 40436 5681 1 21 21 CD 40436 5681 2 . . . 40436 5682 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5682 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5682 3 : : : 40436 5682 4 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 5682 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5682 6 ê ê NNP 40436 5682 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5682 8 sophistikê\ sophistikê\ . 40436 5682 9 phainome phainome NNP 40436 5682 10 / / SYM 40436 5682 11 nê nê NNP 40436 5682 12 sophi sophi NNP 40436 5682 13 / / SYM 40436 5682 14 a a DT 40436 5682 15 , , , 40436 5682 16 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 5682 17 d d NNP 40436 5682 18 ' ' '' 40436 5682 19 ou)/ ou)/ RB 40436 5682 20 ; ; : 40436 5682 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5682 22 o o NNP 40436 5682 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5682 24 sophistê\s sophistê\s CD 40436 5682 25 chrêmatistê\s chrêmatistê\s . 40436 5682 26 a)po\ a)po\ NNP 40436 5682 27 phainome phainome NN 40436 5682 28 / / SYM 40436 5682 29 nês nês NN 40436 5682 30 sophi sophi NNP 40436 5682 31 / / , 40436 5682 32 as as IN 40436 5682 33 , , , 40436 5682 34 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 5682 35 ' ' POS 40436 5682 36 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 5682 37 ou)/sês ou)/sês NN 40436 5682 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5682 39 , , , 40436 5682 40 p. p. NN 40436 5682 41 165 165 CD 40436 5682 42 , , , 40436 5682 43 b. b. NNP 40436 5683 1 10 10 CD 40436 5683 2 , , , 40436 5683 3 p. p. NN 40436 5683 4 171 171 CD 40436 5683 5 , , , 40436 5683 6 b. b. NNP 40436 5684 1 8 8 CD 40436 5684 2 - - SYM 40436 5684 3 27 27 CD 40436 5684 4 . . . 40436 5685 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5685 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5685 3 : : : 40436 5685 4 Oi oi VB 40436 5685 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5685 6 phile phile NN 40436 5685 7 / / SYM 40436 5685 8 rides ride NNS 40436 5685 9 , , , 40436 5685 10 e)ristikoi\ e)ristikoi\ NNP 40436 5685 11 , , , 40436 5685 12 a)gônistikoi\ a)gônistikoi\ NNP 40436 5685 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5685 14 , , , 40436 5685 15 are be VBP 40436 5685 16 persons person NNS 40436 5685 17 who who WP 40436 5685 18 break break VBP 40436 5685 19 the the DT 40436 5685 20 rules rule NNS 40436 5685 21 of of IN 40436 5685 22 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 5685 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5685 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5685 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5685 26 : : : 40436 5685 27 a)dikomachi a)dikomachi NNP 40436 5685 28 / / SYM 40436 5685 29 a a NN 40436 5685 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5685 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5685 32 for for IN 40436 5685 33 the the DT 40436 5685 34 purpose purpose NN 40436 5685 35 of of IN 40436 5685 36 gaining gain VBG 40436 5685 37 victory victory NN 40436 5685 38 ; ; . 40436 5685 39 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5685 40 Greek greek JJ 40436 5685 41 : : : 40436 5685 42 oi oi NNP 40436 5685 43 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5685 44 sophistai\ sophistai\ NN 40436 5685 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5685 46 are be VBP 40436 5685 47 those those DT 40436 5685 48 who who WP 40436 5685 49 do do VBP 40436 5685 50 the the DT 40436 5685 51 same same JJ 40436 5685 52 thing thing NN 40436 5685 53 for for IN 40436 5685 54 the the DT 40436 5685 55 purpose purpose NN 40436 5685 56 of of IN 40436 5685 57 getting get VBG 40436 5685 58 money money NN 40436 5685 59 . . . 40436 5686 1 See see VB 40436 5686 2 also also RB 40436 5686 3 Metaphys Metaphys NNP 40436 5686 4 . . . 40436 5687 1 iii iii NNP 40436 5687 2 . . . 40436 5688 1 1004 1004 CD 40436 5688 2 , , , 40436 5688 3 b. b. NNP 40436 5689 1 17 17 CD 40436 5689 2 . . . 40436 5689 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5690 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5690 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5690 3 43 43 CD 40436 5690 4 : : : 40436 5690 5 Aristot aristot NN 40436 5690 6 . . . 40436 5691 1 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 5691 2 . . . 40436 5692 1 Elench elench NN 40436 5692 2 . . . 40436 5693 1 p. p. NN 40436 5693 2 172 172 CD 40436 5693 3 , , , 40436 5693 4 a. a. NN 40436 5694 1 30 30 CD 40436 5694 2 . . . 40436 5694 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5695 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5695 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5695 3 44 44 CD 40436 5695 4 : : : 40436 5695 5 Aristot aristot NN 40436 5695 6 . . . 40436 5696 1 Rhetor rhetor NN 40436 5696 2 , , , 40436 5696 3 i. i. NNP 40436 5697 1 1 1 CD 40436 5697 2 , , , 40436 5697 3 1355 1355 CD 40436 5697 4 , , , 40436 5697 5 b. b. NNP 40436 5698 1 18 18 CD 40436 5698 2 . . . 40436 5699 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5699 2 here here RB 40436 5699 3 admits admit VBZ 40436 5699 4 that that IN 40436 5699 5 the the DT 40436 5699 6 only only JJ 40436 5699 7 difference difference NN 40436 5699 8 between between IN 40436 5699 9 the the DT 40436 5699 10 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 5699 11 and and CC 40436 5699 12 the the DT 40436 5699 13 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 5699 14 lies lie VBZ 40436 5699 15 in in IN 40436 5699 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5699 17 purposes purpose NNS 40436 5699 18 -- -- : 40436 5699 19 that that IN 40436 5699 20 the the DT 40436 5699 21 mental mental JJ 40436 5699 22 activity activity NN 40436 5699 23 employed employ VBN 40436 5699 24 by by IN 40436 5699 25 both both DT 40436 5699 26 is be VBZ 40436 5699 27 the the DT 40436 5699 28 same same JJ 40436 5699 29 . . . 40436 5700 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5700 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5700 3 : : : 40436 5700 4 o o XX 40436 5700 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5700 6 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 5700 7 sophistiko\s sophistiko\s ADD 40436 5700 8 ou)k ou)k CD 40436 5700 9 e)n e)n NNP 40436 5700 10 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 5700 11 duna duna NN 40436 5700 12 / / SYM 40436 5700 13 mei mei NNP 40436 5700 14 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 5700 15 ' ' `` 40436 5700 16 e)n e)n NNP 40436 5700 17 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 5700 18 proaire proaire NN 40436 5700 19 / / SYM 40436 5700 20 sei sei NN 40436 5700 21 ; ; : 40436 5700 22 plê\n plê\n NNP 40436 5700 23 e)ntau e)ntau NNS 40436 5700 24 = = NFP 40436 5700 25 tha tha NNP 40436 5700 26 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5700 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5700 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5700 29 in in IN 40436 5700 30 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 5700 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5700 32 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5700 33 Greek greek NN 40436 5700 34 : : : 40436 5700 35 e)/stai e)/stai NFP 40436 5700 36 o o FW 40436 5700 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5700 38 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5700 39 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 5700 40 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5700 41 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 5700 42 / / SYM 40436 5700 43 mên mên NN 40436 5700 44 o o NN 40436 5700 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5700 46 de\ de\ NN 40436 5700 47 kata\ kata\ . 40436 5700 48 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5700 49 proai proai NN 40436 5700 50 / / SYM 40436 5700 51 resin resin NN 40436 5700 52 , , , 40436 5700 53 r(ê r(ê NN 40436 5700 54 / / SYM 40436 5700 55 tôr tôr NN 40436 5700 56 , , , 40436 5700 57 e)kei= e)kei= NNP 40436 5700 58 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5700 59 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5700 60 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5700 61 in in IN 40436 5700 62 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 5700 63 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5700 64 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5700 65 Greek greek NN 40436 5700 66 : : : 40436 5700 67 sophistê\s sophistê\s NFP 40436 5700 68 me\n me\n NNP 40436 5700 69 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 5700 70 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5700 71 proai proai NN 40436 5700 72 / / SYM 40436 5700 73 resin resin NN 40436 5700 74 , , , 40436 5700 75 dialektiko\s dialektiko\s -LRB- 40436 5700 76 de\ de\ NNP 40436 5700 77 ou ou NNP 40436 5700 78 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5700 79 kata\ kata\ . 40436 5700 80 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5700 81 proai proai NN 40436 5700 82 / / SYM 40436 5700 83 resin resin NN 40436 5700 84 , , , 40436 5700 85 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 5700 86 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 5700 87 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 5700 88 du du NNP 40436 5700 89 / / SYM 40436 5700 90 namin namin NNP 40436 5700 91 . . . 40436 5700 92 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5700 93 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5701 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5701 2 Side side NN 40436 5701 3 - - HYPH 40436 5701 4 note note NN 40436 5701 5 : : : 40436 5701 6 Philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 5701 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 5701 8 of of IN 40436 5701 9 the the DT 40436 5701 10 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5701 11 -- -- : 40436 5701 12 exposure exposure NN 40436 5701 13 of of IN 40436 5701 14 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5701 15 , , , 40436 5701 16 in in IN 40436 5701 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5701 18 's 's POS 40436 5701 19 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 5701 20 manner manner NN 40436 5701 21 , , , 40436 5701 22 by by IN 40436 5701 23 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 5701 24 of of IN 40436 5701 25 particular particular JJ 40436 5701 26 examples example NNS 40436 5701 27 . . . 40436 5701 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5702 1 Though though IN 40436 5702 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5702 3 maintain maintain VBP 40436 5702 4 that that IN 40436 5702 5 no no DT 40436 5702 6 class class NN 40436 5702 7 of of IN 40436 5702 8 professional professional JJ 40436 5702 9 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5702 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5702 11 in in IN 40436 5702 12 the the DT 40436 5702 13 meaning meaning NN 40436 5702 14 given give VBN 40436 5702 15 to to IN 40436 5702 16 that that DT 40436 5702 17 term term NN 40436 5702 18 by by IN 40436 5702 19 the the DT 40436 5702 20 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5702 21 critics critic NNS 40436 5702 22 after after IN 40436 5702 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5702 24 and and CC 40436 5702 25 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5702 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5702 27 ever ever RB 40436 5702 28 existed exist VBD 40436 5702 29 -- -- : 40436 5702 30 and and CC 40436 5702 31 though though IN 40436 5702 32 the the DT 40436 5702 33 distinction distinction NN 40436 5702 34 between between IN 40436 5702 35 the the DT 40436 5702 36 paid pay VBN 40436 5702 37 and and CC 40436 5702 38 the the DT 40436 5702 39 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 40436 5702 40 discourser discourser NN 40436 5702 41 is be VBZ 40436 5702 42 altogether altogether RB 40436 5702 43 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 5702 44 to to TO 40436 5702 45 enter enter VB 40436 5702 46 into into IN 40436 5702 47 the the DT 40436 5702 48 history history NN 40436 5702 49 of of IN 40436 5702 50 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5702 51 -- -- : 40436 5702 52 yet yet CC 40436 5702 53 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5702 54 am be VBP 40436 5702 55 not not RB 40436 5702 56 the the DT 40436 5702 57 less less RBR 40436 5702 58 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 5702 59 that that IN 40436 5702 60 the the DT 40436 5702 61 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5702 62 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5702 63 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5702 64 , , , 40436 5702 65 and and CC 40436 5702 66 the the DT 40436 5702 67 treatise treatise NN 40436 5702 68 of of IN 40436 5702 69 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5702 70 De De NNP 40436 5702 71 Sophisticis Sophisticis NNP 40436 5702 72 Elenchis Elenchis NNP 40436 5702 73 , , , 40436 5702 74 are be VBP 40436 5702 75 very very RB 40436 5702 76 striking striking JJ 40436 5702 77 and and CC 40436 5702 78 useful useful JJ 40436 5702 79 compositions composition NNS 40436 5702 80 . . . 40436 5703 1 This this DT 40436 5703 2 last last RB 40436 5703 3 - - HYPH 40436 5703 4 mentioned mention VBN 40436 5703 5 treatise treatise NN 40436 5703 6 was be VBD 40436 5703 7 composed compose VBN 40436 5703 8 by by IN 40436 5703 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5703 10 very very RB 40436 5703 11 much much RB 40436 5703 12 under under IN 40436 5703 13 the the DT 40436 5703 14 stimulus stimulus NN 40436 5703 15 of of IN 40436 5703 16 the the DT 40436 5703 17 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5703 18 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5703 19 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5703 20 , , , 40436 5703 21 to to TO 40436 5703 22 which which WDT 40436 5703 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5703 24 refers refer VBZ 40436 5703 25 several several JJ 40436 5703 26 times time NNS 40436 5703 27 -- -- : 40436 5703 28 and and CC 40436 5703 29 for for IN 40436 5703 30 the the DT 40436 5703 31 purpose purpose NN 40436 5703 32 of of IN 40436 5703 33 distributing distribute VBG 40436 5703 34 the the DT 40436 5703 35 variety variety NN 40436 5703 36 of of IN 40436 5703 37 possible possible JJ 40436 5703 38 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5703 39 under under IN 40436 5703 40 a a DT 40436 5703 41 limited limited JJ 40436 5703 42 number number NN 40436 5703 43 of of IN 40436 5703 44 general general JJ 40436 5703 45 heads head NNS 40436 5703 46 , , , 40436 5703 47 each each DT 40436 5703 48 described describe VBN 40436 5703 49 by by IN 40436 5703 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5703 51 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 5703 52 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 5703 53 , , , 40436 5703 54 and and CC 40436 5703 55 represented represent VBN 40436 5703 56 by by IN 40436 5703 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5703 58 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 5703 59 type type NN 40436 5703 60 . . . 40436 5704 1 Such such JJ 40436 5704 2 attempt attempt NN 40436 5704 3 at at IN 40436 5704 4 arrangement arrangement NN 40436 5704 5 -- -- : 40436 5704 6 one one CD 40436 5704 7 of of IN 40436 5704 8 the the DT 40436 5704 9 many many JJ 40436 5704 10 valuable valuable JJ 40436 5704 11 contributions contribution NNS 40436 5704 12 of of IN 40436 5704 13 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5704 14 to to IN 40436 5704 15 the the DT 40436 5704 16 theory theory NN 40436 5704 17 of of IN 40436 5704 18 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5704 19 -- -- : 40436 5704 20 is be VBZ 40436 5704 21 expressly expressly RB 40436 5704 22 claimed claim VBN 40436 5704 23 by by IN 40436 5704 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5704 25 as as IN 40436 5704 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5704 27 own own JJ 40436 5704 28 . . . 40436 5705 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5705 2 takes take VBZ 40436 5705 3 a a DT 40436 5705 4 just just JJ 40436 5705 5 pride pride NN 40436 5705 6 in in IN 40436 5705 7 having have VBG 40436 5705 8 been be VBN 40436 5705 9 the the DT 40436 5705 10 first first JJ 40436 5705 11 to to TO 40436 5705 12 introduce introduce VB 40436 5705 13 system system NN 40436 5705 14 where where WRB 40436 5705 15 none none NN 40436 5705 16 had have VBD 40436 5705 17 introduced introduce VBN 40436 5705 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5705 19 before before RB 40436 5705 20 . . . 40436 5706 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5706 2 45 45 CD 40436 5706 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5706 4 No no DT 40436 5706 5 such such JJ 40436 5706 6 system system NN 40436 5706 7 was be VBD 40436 5706 8 known know VBN 40436 5706 9 to to IN 40436 5706 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5706 11 , , , 40436 5706 12 who who WP 40436 5706 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5706 14 in in IN 40436 5706 15 the the DT 40436 5706 16 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5706 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5706 18 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 5706 19 a a DT 40436 5706 20 string string NN 40436 5706 21 of of IN 40436 5706 22 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5706 23 one one CD 40436 5706 24 after after IN 40436 5706 25 another another DT 40436 5706 26 without without IN 40436 5706 27 any any DT 40436 5706 28 project project NN 40436 5706 29 of of IN 40436 5706 30 classifying classify VBG 40436 5706 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5706 32 , , , 40436 5706 33 and and CC 40436 5706 34 who who WP 40436 5706 35 presents present VBZ 40436 5706 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5706 37 as as IN 40436 5706 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5706 39 were be VBD 40436 5706 40 in in IN 40436 5706 41 concrete concrete NN 40436 5706 42 , , , 40436 5706 43 as as IN 40436 5706 44 applied apply VBN 40436 5706 45 by by IN 40436 5706 46 certain certain JJ 40436 5706 47 disputants disputant NNS 40436 5706 48 in in IN 40436 5706 49 an an DT 40436 5706 50 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 5706 51 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5706 52 . . . 40436 5707 1 The the DT 40436 5707 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 5707 3 is be VBZ 40436 5707 4 , , , 40436 5707 5 to to TO 40436 5707 6 make make VB 40436 5707 7 these these DT 40436 5707 8 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5707 9 appear appear VB 40436 5707 10 conspicuously conspicuously RB 40436 5707 11 in in IN 40436 5707 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5707 13 character character NN 40436 5707 14 of of IN 40436 5707 15 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5707 16 : : : 40436 5707 17 a a DT 40436 5707 18 purpose purpose NN 40436 5707 19 which which WDT 40436 5707 20 is be VBZ 40436 5707 21 assisted assist VBN 40436 5707 22 by by IN 40436 5707 23 presenting present VBG 40436 5707 24 the the DT 40436 5707 25 propounders propounder NNS 40436 5707 26 of of IN 40436 5707 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5707 28 as as IN 40436 5707 29 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 5707 30 and and CC 40436 5707 31 contemptible contemptible JJ 40436 5707 32 . . . 40436 5708 1 The the DT 40436 5708 2 lively lively JJ 40436 5708 3 fancy fancy NN 40436 5708 4 of of IN 40436 5708 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5708 6 attaches attach VBZ 40436 5708 7 suitable suitable JJ 40436 5708 8 accessories accessory NNS 40436 5708 9 to to IN 40436 5708 10 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5708 11 and and CC 40436 5708 12 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5708 13 . . . 40436 5709 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5709 2 are be VBP 40436 5709 3 old old JJ 40436 5709 4 men man NNS 40436 5709 5 , , , 40436 5709 6 who who WP 40436 5709 7 have have VBP 40436 5709 8 been be VBN 40436 5709 9 all all DT 40436 5709 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5709 11 lives life NNS 40436 5709 12 engaged engage VBN 40436 5709 13 in in IN 40436 5709 14 teaching teach VBG 40436 5709 15 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 5709 16 and and CC 40436 5709 17 tactics tactic NNS 40436 5709 18 , , , 40436 5709 19 but but CC 40436 5709 20 have have VBP 40436 5709 21 recently recently RB 40436 5709 22 taken take VBN 40436 5709 23 to to IN 40436 5709 24 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 5709 25 , , , 40436 5709 26 and and CC 40436 5709 27 acquired acquire VBD 40436 5709 28 perfect perfect JJ 40436 5709 29 mastery mastery NN 40436 5709 30 thereof thereof RB 40436 5709 31 without without IN 40436 5709 32 any any DT 40436 5709 33 trouble trouble NN 40436 5709 34 -- -- : 40436 5709 35 who who WP 40436 5709 36 make make VBP 40436 5709 37 extravagant extravagant JJ 40436 5709 38 promises promise NNS 40436 5709 39 -- -- : 40436 5709 40 and and CC 40436 5709 41 who who WP 40436 5709 42 as as IN 40436 5709 43 talkers talker NNS 40436 5709 44 play play VBP 40436 5709 45 into into IN 40436 5709 46 each each DT 40436 5709 47 other other JJ 40436 5709 48 's 's POS 40436 5709 49 hands hand NNS 40436 5709 50 , , , 40436 5709 51 making make VBG 40436 5709 52 a a DT 40436 5709 53 shuttlecock shuttlecock NN 40436 5709 54 of of IN 40436 5709 55 the the DT 40436 5709 56 respondent respondent NN 40436 5709 57 , , , 40436 5709 58 a a DT 40436 5709 59 modest modest JJ 40436 5709 60 novice novice NN 40436 5709 61 every every DT 40436 5709 62 way way NN 40436 5709 63 unsuitable unsuitable JJ 40436 5709 64 for for IN 40436 5709 65 such such JJ 40436 5709 66 treatment treatment NN 40436 5709 67 . . . 40436 5710 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5710 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5710 3 45 45 CD 40436 5710 4 : : : 40436 5710 5 See see VB 40436 5710 6 the the DT 40436 5710 7 last last JJ 40436 5710 8 chapter chapter NN 40436 5710 9 of of IN 40436 5710 10 the the DT 40436 5710 11 treatise treatise NN 40436 5710 12 De De NNP 40436 5710 13 Sophisticis Sophisticis NNP 40436 5710 14 Elenchis Elenchis NNP 40436 5710 15 . . . 40436 5710 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5711 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5711 2 Side side NN 40436 5711 3 - - HYPH 40436 5711 4 note note NN 40436 5711 5 : : : 40436 5711 6 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5711 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5711 8 Soph Soph NNP 40436 5711 9 . . . 40436 5712 1 Elench elench NN 40436 5712 2 . . . 40436 5712 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5713 1 attempts attempt VBZ 40436 5713 2 a a DT 40436 5713 3 classification classification NN 40436 5713 4 of of IN 40436 5713 5 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5713 6 : : : 40436 5713 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5713 8 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 5713 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5713 10 without without IN 40436 5713 11 classification classification NN 40436 5713 12 . . . 40436 5713 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5714 1 Thus thus RB 40436 5714 2 different different JJ 40436 5714 3 is be VBZ 40436 5714 4 the the DT 40436 5714 5 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5714 6 manner manner NN 40436 5714 7 , , , 40436 5714 8 from from IN 40436 5714 9 the the DT 40436 5714 10 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40436 5714 11 manner manner NN 40436 5714 12 , , , 40436 5714 13 of of IN 40436 5714 14 exposing expose VBG 40436 5714 15 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5714 16 . . . 40436 5715 1 But but CC 40436 5715 2 those those DT 40436 5715 3 exhibited exhibit VBN 40436 5715 4 in in IN 40436 5715 5 the the DT 40436 5715 6 former former JJ 40436 5715 7 appear appear NN 40436 5715 8 as as IN 40436 5715 9 members member NNS 40436 5715 10 of of IN 40436 5715 11 one one CD 40436 5715 12 or or CC 40436 5715 13 more more JJR 40436 5715 14 among among IN 40436 5715 15 the the DT 40436 5715 16 classes class NNS 40436 5715 17 framed frame VBN 40436 5715 18 by by IN 40436 5715 19 the the DT 40436 5715 20 latter latter JJ 40436 5715 21 . . . 40436 5716 1 The the DT 40436 5716 2 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5716 3 which which WDT 40436 5716 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5716 5 read read VBP 40436 5716 6 in in IN 40436 5716 7 the the DT 40436 5716 8 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5716 9 are be VBP 40436 5716 10 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 5716 11 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5716 12 : : : 40436 5716 13 but but CC 40436 5716 14 some some DT 40436 5716 15 are be VBP 40436 5716 16 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5716 17 , , , 40436 5716 18 and and CC 40436 5716 19 something something NN 40436 5716 20 beyond beyond IN 40436 5716 21 . . . 40436 5717 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5717 2 Side side NN 40436 5717 3 - - HYPH 40436 5717 4 note note NN 40436 5717 5 : : : 40436 5717 6 Fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5717 7 of of IN 40436 5717 8 equivocation equivocation NN 40436 5717 9 propounded propound VBN 40436 5717 10 by by IN 40436 5717 11 the the DT 40436 5717 12 two two CD 40436 5717 13 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5717 14 in in IN 40436 5717 15 the the DT 40436 5717 16 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5717 17 . . . 40436 5717 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5718 1 Thus thus RB 40436 5718 2 , , , 40436 5718 3 for for IN 40436 5718 4 example example NN 40436 5718 5 , , , 40436 5718 6 if if IN 40436 5718 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5718 8 take take VBP 40436 5718 9 the the DT 40436 5718 10 first first JJ 40436 5718 11 sophism sophism NN 40436 5718 12 introduced introduce VBN 40436 5718 13 by by IN 40436 5718 14 the the DT 40436 5718 15 two two CD 40436 5718 16 exhibitors exhibitor NNS 40436 5718 17 , , , 40436 5718 18 upon upon IN 40436 5718 19 which which WDT 40436 5718 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5718 21 bring bring VBP 40436 5718 22 the the DT 40436 5718 23 youth youth NN 40436 5718 24 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5718 25 , , , 40436 5718 26 by by IN 40436 5718 27 suitable suitable JJ 40436 5718 28 questions question NNS 40436 5718 29 , , , 40436 5718 30 to to TO 40436 5718 31 declare declare VB 40436 5718 32 successively successively RB 40436 5718 33 both both DT 40436 5718 34 sides side NNS 40436 5718 35 of of IN 40436 5718 36 the the DT 40436 5718 37 alternative--"Which alternative--"which NN 40436 5718 38 of of IN 40436 5718 39 the the DT 40436 5718 40 two two CD 40436 5718 41 is be VBZ 40436 5718 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5718 43 that that WDT 40436 5718 44 learns learn VBZ 40436 5718 45 , , , 40436 5718 46 the the DT 40436 5718 47 wise wise JJ 40436 5718 48 or or CC 40436 5718 49 the the DT 40436 5718 50 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 5718 51 ? ? . 40436 5718 52 " " '' 40436 5719 1 --Sokrates --Sokrates : 40436 5719 2 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5719 3 elucidates elucidate VBZ 40436 5719 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5719 5 by by IN 40436 5719 6 pointing point VBG 40436 5719 7 out out RP 40436 5719 8 that that IN 40436 5719 9 the the DT 40436 5719 10 terms term NNS 40436 5719 11 used use VBN 40436 5719 12 are be VBP 40436 5719 13 equivocal:[46 equivocal:[46 ADD 40436 5719 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5719 15 You -PRON- PRP 40436 5719 16 might may MD 40436 5719 17 answer answer VB 40436 5719 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5719 19 by by IN 40436 5719 20 using use VBG 40436 5719 21 the the DT 40436 5719 22 language language NN 40436 5719 23 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 5719 24 to to IN 40436 5719 25 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5719 26 in in IN 40436 5719 27 another another DT 40436 5719 28 part part NN 40436 5719 29 of of IN 40436 5719 30 this this DT 40436 5719 31 dialogue--"Neither dialogue--"neither NN 40436 5719 32 and and CC 40436 5719 33 Both both DT 40436 5719 34 " " '' 40436 5719 35 . . . 40436 5720 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5720 2 47 47 CD 40436 5720 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5720 4 The the DT 40436 5720 5 like like NN 40436 5720 6 may may MD 40436 5720 7 be be VB 40436 5720 8 said say VBN 40436 5720 9 about about IN 40436 5720 10 the the DT 40436 5720 11 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5720 12 in in IN 40436 5720 13 page page NN 40436 5720 14 284 284 CD 40436 5720 15 D--"Are D--"Are NNP 40436 5720 16 there there EX 40436 5720 17 persons person NNS 40436 5720 18 who who WP 40436 5720 19 speak speak VBP 40436 5720 20 of of IN 40436 5720 21 things thing NNS 40436 5720 22 as as IN 40436 5720 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5720 24 are be VBP 40436 5720 25 ? ? . 40436 5721 1 Good good JJ 40436 5721 2 men man NNS 40436 5721 3 speak speak VBP 40436 5721 4 of of IN 40436 5721 5 things thing NNS 40436 5721 6 as as IN 40436 5721 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5721 8 are be VBP 40436 5721 9 : : : 40436 5721 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5721 11 speak speak VBP 40436 5721 12 of of IN 40436 5721 13 good good JJ 40436 5721 14 men man NNS 40436 5721 15 well well UH 40436 5721 16 , , , 40436 5721 17 of of IN 40436 5721 18 bad bad JJ 40436 5721 19 men man NNS 40436 5721 20 badly badly RB 40436 5721 21 : : : 40436 5721 22 therefore therefore RB 40436 5721 23 , , , 40436 5721 24 of of IN 40436 5721 25 course course NN 40436 5721 26 , , , 40436 5721 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5721 28 speak speak VBP 40436 5721 29 of of IN 40436 5721 30 stout stout JJ 40436 5721 31 men man NNS 40436 5721 32 stoutly stoutly RB 40436 5721 33 , , , 40436 5721 34 and and CC 40436 5721 35 of of IN 40436 5721 36 hot hot JJ 40436 5721 37 men man NNS 40436 5721 38 hotly hotly RB 40436 5721 39 . . . 40436 5722 1 Ay ay UH 40436 5722 2 ! ! . 40436 5723 1 rejoins rejoin VBZ 40436 5723 2 the the DT 40436 5723 3 respondent respondent JJ 40436 5723 4 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 5723 5 , , , 40436 5723 6 angrily angrily RB 40436 5723 7 -- -- : 40436 5723 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5723 9 speak speak VBP 40436 5723 10 of of IN 40436 5723 11 cold cold JJ 40436 5723 12 men man NNS 40436 5723 13 coldly coldly RB 40436 5723 14 , , , 40436 5723 15 and and CC 40436 5723 16 say say VBP 40436 5723 17 that that IN 40436 5723 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5723 19 talk talk VBP 40436 5723 20 coldly coldly RB 40436 5723 21 . . . 40436 5724 1 " " `` 40436 5724 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5724 3 48 48 CD 40436 5724 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5724 5 These these DT 40436 5724 6 are be VBP 40436 5724 7 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5724 8 of of IN 40436 5724 9 double double JJ 40436 5724 10 meaning meaning NN 40436 5724 11 of of IN 40436 5724 12 words word NNS 40436 5724 13 -- -- : 40436 5724 14 or or CC 40436 5724 15 double double JJ 40436 5724 16 construction construction NN 40436 5724 17 of of IN 40436 5724 18 phrases phrase NNS 40436 5724 19 : : : 40436 5724 20 as as IN 40436 5724 21 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5724 22 read read VBP 40436 5724 23 also also RB 40436 5724 24 in in IN 40436 5724 25 page page NN 40436 5724 26 287 287 CD 40436 5724 27 D d NN 40436 5724 28 , , , 40436 5724 29 where where WRB 40436 5724 30 the the DT 40436 5724 31 same same JJ 40436 5724 32 Greek greek JJ 40436 5724 33 verb verb NN 40436 5724 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5724 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5724 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5724 37 : : : 40436 5724 38 noei noei NN 40436 5724 39 = = SYM 40436 5724 40 n n NNP 40436 5724 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5724 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5724 43 may may MD 40436 5724 44 be be VB 40436 5724 45 construed construe VBN 40436 5724 46 either either CC 40436 5724 47 to to IN 40436 5724 48 _ _ NNP 40436 5724 49 think think VB 40436 5724 50 _ _ NNP 40436 5724 51 or or CC 40436 5724 52 to to IN 40436 5724 53 _ _ NNP 40436 5724 54 mean mean NNP 40436 5724 55 _ _ NNP 40436 5724 56 : : : 40436 5724 57 so so IN 40436 5724 58 that that IN 40436 5724 59 when when WRB 40436 5724 60 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5724 61 talks talk VBZ 40436 5724 62 about about IN 40436 5724 63 what what WP 40436 5724 64 a a DT 40436 5724 65 predication predication NN 40436 5724 66 _ _ IN 40436 5724 67 means_--the means_--the NNP 40436 5724 68 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5724 69 ask ask VBP 40436 5724 70 him--"Does him--"doe VBZ 40436 5724 71 anything anything NN 40436 5724 72 _ _ NNP 40436 5724 73 think think VBP 40436 5724 74 _ _ NNP 40436 5724 75 , , , 40436 5724 76 except except IN 40436 5724 77 things thing NNS 40436 5724 78 having have VBG 40436 5724 79 a a DT 40436 5724 80 soul soul NN 40436 5724 81 ? ? . 40436 5725 1 Did do VBD 40436 5725 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5725 3 ever ever RB 40436 5725 4 know know VB 40436 5725 5 any any DT 40436 5725 6 predication predication NN 40436 5725 7 that that WDT 40436 5725 8 had have VBD 40436 5725 9 a a DT 40436 5725 10 soul soul NN 40436 5725 11 ? ? . 40436 5725 12 " " '' 40436 5726 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5726 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5726 3 46 46 CD 40436 5726 4 : : : 40436 5726 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5726 6 , , , 40436 5726 7 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5726 8 . . . 40436 5727 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5727 2 . . . 40436 5728 1 275 275 CD 40436 5728 2 D--278 d--278 CD 40436 5728 3 D. D. NNP 40436 5728 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5728 5 also also RB 40436 5728 6 adverts advert VBZ 40436 5728 7 to to IN 40436 5728 8 this this DT 40436 5728 9 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5728 10 , , , 40436 5728 11 but but CC 40436 5728 12 without without IN 40436 5728 13 naming name VBG 40436 5728 14 the the DT 40436 5728 15 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5728 16 . . . 40436 5729 1 See see VB 40436 5729 2 Soph Soph NNP 40436 5729 3 . . . 40436 5730 1 El El NNP 40436 5730 2 . . . 40436 5731 1 4 4 CD 40436 5731 2 , , , 40436 5731 3 165 165 CD 40436 5731 4 , , , 40436 5731 5 b. b. NN 40436 5732 1 30 30 CD 40436 5732 2 . . . 40436 5732 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5733 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5733 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5733 3 47 47 CD 40436 5733 4 : : : 40436 5733 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5733 6 , , , 40436 5733 7 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5733 8 . . . 40436 5734 1 p. p. NN 40436 5734 2 300 300 CD 40436 5734 3 D. D. NNP 40436 5734 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5734 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5734 6 : : : 40436 5734 7 Ou)de Ou)de NNP 40436 5734 8 / / SYM 40436 5734 9 tera tera NN 40436 5734 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5734 11 a)mpho a)mpho NNPS 40436 5734 12 / / SYM 40436 5734 13 tera tera NN 40436 5734 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5734 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5734 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5734 17 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5734 18 48 48 CD 40436 5734 19 : : : 40436 5734 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5734 21 , , , 40436 5734 22 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5734 23 . . . 40436 5735 1 p. p. NN 40436 5735 2 284 284 CD 40436 5735 3 E. E. NNP 40436 5735 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5735 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5735 6 : : . 40436 5735 7 tou\s tou\s JJ 40436 5735 8 gou gou NN 40436 5735 9 = = NFP 40436 5735 10 n n CC 40436 5735 11 psuchrou\s psuchrou\s NNP 40436 5735 12 psuchrô psuchrô NNP 40436 5735 13 = = SYM 40436 5735 14 s s NNP 40436 5735 15 le le NNP 40436 5735 16 / / SYM 40436 5735 17 gousi/ gousi/ NNP 40436 5735 18 te te NNP 40436 5735 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 5735 20 phasi\ phasi\ NNP 40436 5735 21 diale diale NNP 40436 5735 22 / / SYM 40436 5735 23 gesthai gesthai NNP 40436 5735 24 . . . 40436 5735 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5736 1 The the DT 40436 5736 2 metaphorical metaphorical JJ 40436 5736 3 sense sense NN 40436 5736 4 of of IN 40436 5736 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5736 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5736 7 : : : 40436 5736 8 psuchro\s psuchro\s NFP 40436 5736 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5736 10 is be VBZ 40436 5736 11 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 12 pointless pointless JJ 40436 5736 13 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 14 , , , 40436 5736 15 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 16 stupid stupid JJ 40436 5736 17 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 18 , , , 40436 5736 19 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 20 out out IN 40436 5736 21 of of IN 40436 5736 22 taste taste NN 40436 5736 23 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 24 , , , 40436 5736 25 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 26 out out IN 40436 5736 27 of of IN 40436 5736 28 place place NN 40436 5736 29 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 30 , , , 40436 5736 31 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 32 & & CC 40436 5736 33 c. c. NNP 40436 5736 34 _ _ NNP 40436 5736 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5736 36 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5736 37 Side side NN 40436 5736 38 - - HYPH 40436 5736 39 note note NN 40436 5736 40 : : : 40436 5736 41 Fallacies--_à Fallacies--_à NNP 40436 5736 42 dicto dicto NNP 40436 5736 43 secundum secundum NN 40436 5736 44 quid quid NNP 40436 5736 45 , , , 40436 5736 46 ad ad NN 40436 5736 47 dictum dictum NN 40436 5736 48 simpliciter_--in simpliciter_--in NNP 40436 5736 49 the the DT 40436 5736 50 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5736 51 . . . 40436 5736 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5737 1 Again again RB 40436 5737 2 , , , 40436 5737 3 the the DT 40436 5737 4 two two CD 40436 5737 5 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5737 6 undertake undertake VBP 40436 5737 7 to to TO 40436 5737 8 prove prove VB 40436 5737 9 that that IN 40436 5737 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5737 11 , , , 40436 5737 12 as as RB 40436 5737 13 well well RB 40436 5737 14 as as IN 40436 5737 15 the the DT 40436 5737 16 youth youth NN 40436 5737 17 Kleinias Kleinias NNP 40436 5737 18 and and CC 40436 5737 19 indeed indeed RB 40436 5737 20 every every DT 40436 5737 21 one one NN 40436 5737 22 else else RB 40436 5737 23 , , , 40436 5737 24 knows know VBZ 40436 5737 25 everything everything NN 40436 5737 26 . . . 40436 5738 1 " " `` 40436 5738 2 Can Can MD 40436 5738 3 any any DT 40436 5738 4 existing exist VBG 40436 5738 5 thing thing NN 40436 5738 6 _ _ NNP 40436 5738 7 be be VB 40436 5738 8 _ _ NNP 40436 5738 9 that that IN 40436 5738 10 which which WDT 40436 5738 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5738 12 is be VBZ 40436 5738 13 , , , 40436 5738 14 and and CC 40436 5738 15 at at IN 40436 5738 16 the the DT 40436 5738 17 same same JJ 40436 5738 18 time time NN 40436 5738 19 _ _ NNP 40436 5738 20 not not RB 40436 5738 21 be be VB 40436 5738 22 _ _ NNP 40436 5738 23 that that IN 40436 5738 24 which which WDT 40436 5738 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5738 26 is?--No.--You is?--no.--you UH 40436 5738 27 know know VBP 40436 5738 28 some some DT 40436 5738 29 things?--Yes.--Then things?--yes.--then IN 40436 5738 30 if if IN 40436 5738 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5738 32 know know VBP 40436 5738 33 , , , 40436 5738 34 _ _ NNP 40436 5738 35 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5738 36 are be VBP 40436 5738 37 knowing_?--Certainly knowing_?--certainly JJ 40436 5738 38 . . . 40436 5739 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5739 2 am be VBP 40436 5739 3 knowing know VBG 40436 5739 4 of of IN 40436 5739 5 those those DT 40436 5739 6 particular particular JJ 40436 5739 7 things.--That things.--that NN 40436 5739 8 makes make VBZ 40436 5739 9 no no DT 40436 5739 10 difference difference NN 40436 5739 11 : : : 40436 5739 12 if if IN 40436 5739 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5739 14 are be VBP 40436 5739 15 knowing know VBG 40436 5739 16 , , , 40436 5739 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5739 18 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 5739 19 know know VBP 40436 5739 20 everything.--Oh everything.--Oh VBN 40436 5739 21 ! ! . 40436 5740 1 no no UH 40436 5740 2 : : : 40436 5740 3 for for IN 40436 5740 4 there there EX 40436 5740 5 are be VBP 40436 5740 6 many many JJ 40436 5740 7 things thing NNS 40436 5740 8 which which WDT 40436 5740 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 10 do do VBP 40436 5740 11 not not RB 40436 5740 12 know.--Then know.--then VB 40436 5740 13 if if IN 40436 5740 14 there there EX 40436 5740 15 be be VB 40436 5740 16 anything anything NN 40436 5740 17 which which WDT 40436 5740 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 19 do do VBP 40436 5740 20 not not RB 40436 5740 21 know know VB 40436 5740 22 , , , 40436 5740 23 _ _ NNP 40436 5740 24 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 25 are be VBP 40436 5740 26 not not RB 40436 5740 27 knowing_?--Yes knowing_?--yes CD 40436 5740 28 , , , 40436 5740 29 doubtless doubtless JJ 40436 5740 30 -- -- : 40436 5740 31 of of IN 40436 5740 32 that that DT 40436 5740 33 particular particular JJ 40436 5740 34 thing.--Still thing.--still CD 40436 5740 35 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 36 are be VBP 40436 5740 37 _ _ NNP 40436 5740 38 not not RB 40436 5740 39 knowing know VBG 40436 5740 40 _ _ NNP 40436 5740 41 : : : 40436 5740 42 and and CC 40436 5740 43 just just RB 40436 5740 44 now now RB 40436 5740 45 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 46 said say VBD 40436 5740 47 that that IN 40436 5740 48 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 49 were be VBD 40436 5740 50 _ _ NNP 40436 5740 51 knowing know VBG 40436 5740 52 _ _ NNP 40436 5740 53 : : : 40436 5740 54 and and CC 40436 5740 55 thus thus RB 40436 5740 56 , , , 40436 5740 57 at at IN 40436 5740 58 one one CD 40436 5740 59 and and CC 40436 5740 60 the the DT 40436 5740 61 same same JJ 40436 5740 62 time time NN 40436 5740 63 , , , 40436 5740 64 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 65 are be VBP 40436 5740 66 what what WP 40436 5740 67 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 68 are be VBP 40436 5740 69 , , , 40436 5740 70 and and CC 40436 5740 71 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 72 are be VBP 40436 5740 73 not not RB 40436 5740 74 what what WP 40436 5740 75 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5740 76 are be VBP 40436 5740 77 . . . 40436 5741 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5741 2 49 49 CD 40436 5741 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5741 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5741 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5741 6 49 49 CD 40436 5741 7 : : : 40436 5741 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5741 9 , , , 40436 5741 10 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5741 11 . . . 40436 5742 1 p. p. NN 40436 5742 2 293 293 CD 40436 5742 3 C. C. NNP 40436 5742 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5742 5 considers consider VBZ 40436 5742 6 _ _ NNP 40436 5742 7 know know VBP 40436 5742 8 _ _ NNP 40436 5742 9 to to TO 40436 5742 10 be be VB 40436 5742 11 an an DT 40436 5742 12 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 5742 13 word word NN 40436 5742 14 ; ; : 40436 5742 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5742 16 admits admit VBZ 40436 5742 17 that that IN 40436 5742 18 in in IN 40436 5742 19 certain certain JJ 40436 5742 20 senses sense NNS 40436 5742 21 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5742 22 may may MD 40436 5742 23 both both DT 40436 5742 24 _ _ NNP 40436 5742 25 know know VB 40436 5742 26 _ _ NNP 40436 5742 27 and and CC 40436 5742 28 _ _ NNP 40436 5742 29 not not RB 40436 5742 30 know know VB 40436 5742 31 _ _ NNP 40436 5742 32 the the DT 40436 5742 33 same same JJ 40436 5742 34 thing thing NN 40436 5742 35 . . . 40436 5743 1 Anal anal JJ 40436 5743 2 . . . 40436 5744 1 Prior prior RB 40436 5744 2 . . . 40436 5745 1 ii ii LS 40436 5745 2 . . . 40436 5746 1 67 67 CD 40436 5746 2 , , , 40436 5746 3 b. b. NN 40436 5747 1 8 8 LS 40436 5747 2 . . . 40436 5748 1 Anal anal JJ 40436 5748 2 . . . 40436 5749 1 Post Post NNP 40436 5749 2 . . . 40436 5750 1 i. i. NNP 40436 5751 1 71 71 CD 40436 5751 2 , , , 40436 5751 3 a. a. NN 40436 5752 1 25 25 CD 40436 5752 2 . . . 40436 5752 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5753 1 " " `` 40436 5753 2 But but CC 40436 5753 3 _ _ NNP 40436 5753 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5753 5 _ _ NNP 40436 5753 6 also also RB 40436 5753 7 " " '' 40436 5753 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5753 9 retorts retort VBZ 40436 5753 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5753 11 upon upon IN 40436 5753 12 the the DT 40436 5753 13 couple couple NN 40436 5753 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5753 15 , , , 40436 5753 16 " " `` 40436 5753 17 do do VBP 40436 5753 18 not not RB 40436 5753 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5753 20 also also RB 40436 5753 21 know know VBP 40436 5753 22 some some DT 40436 5753 23 things thing NNS 40436 5753 24 , , , 40436 5753 25 not not RB 40436 5753 26 know know VB 40436 5753 27 others?--By others?--by IN 40436 5753 28 no no DT 40436 5753 29 means.--What means.--what NN 40436 5753 30 ! ! . 40436 5754 1 do do VBP 40436 5754 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5754 3 know know VB 40436 5754 4 nothing?--Far nothing?--far NN 40436 5754 5 from from IN 40436 5754 6 it.--Then it.--Then NNP 40436 5754 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5754 8 know know VBP 40436 5754 9 all all DT 40436 5754 10 things?--Certainly things?--certainly RB 40436 5754 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5754 12 do,--and do,--and VBP 40436 5754 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5754 14 too too RB 40436 5754 15 : : : 40436 5754 16 if if IN 40436 5754 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5754 18 know know VBP 40436 5754 19 one one CD 40436 5754 20 thing thing NN 40436 5754 21 , , , 40436 5754 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5754 23 know know VBP 40436 5754 24 all all DT 40436 5754 25 things.--What things.--what CD 40436 5754 26 ! ! . 40436 5755 1 do do VBP 40436 5755 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5755 3 know know VB 40436 5755 4 the the DT 40436 5755 5 art art NN 40436 5755 6 of of IN 40436 5755 7 the the DT 40436 5755 8 carpenter carpenter NN 40436 5755 9 , , , 40436 5755 10 the the DT 40436 5755 11 currier currier NN 40436 5755 12 , , , 40436 5755 13 the the DT 40436 5755 14 cobbler cobbler NN 40436 5755 15 -- -- : 40436 5755 16 the the DT 40436 5755 17 number number NN 40436 5755 18 of of IN 40436 5755 19 stars star NNS 40436 5755 20 in in IN 40436 5755 21 the the DT 40436 5755 22 heaven heaven NNP 40436 5755 23 , , , 40436 5755 24 and and CC 40436 5755 25 of of IN 40436 5755 26 grains grain NNS 40436 5755 27 of of IN 40436 5755 28 sand sand NN 40436 5755 29 in in IN 40436 5755 30 the the DT 40436 5755 31 desert desert NN 40436 5755 32 , , , 40436 5755 33 & & CC 40436 5755 34 c.?--Yes c.?--Yes NNP 40436 5755 35 : : : 40436 5755 36 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5755 37 know know VBP 40436 5755 38 all all PDT 40436 5755 39 these these DT 40436 5755 40 things thing NNS 40436 5755 41 . . . 40436 5755 42 " " '' 40436 5756 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5756 2 Side side NN 40436 5756 3 - - HYPH 40436 5756 4 note note NN 40436 5756 5 : : : 40436 5756 6 Obstinacy obstinacy NN 40436 5756 7 shown show VBN 40436 5756 8 by by IN 40436 5756 9 the the DT 40436 5756 10 two two CD 40436 5756 11 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5756 12 in in IN 40436 5756 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5756 14 replies reply NNS 40436 5756 15 -- -- : 40436 5756 16 determination determination NN 40436 5756 17 not not RB 40436 5756 18 to to TO 40436 5756 19 contradict contradict VB 40436 5756 20 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5756 21 . . . 40436 5756 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5757 1 The the DT 40436 5757 2 two two CD 40436 5757 3 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5757 4 maintain maintain VBP 40436 5757 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5757 6 consistency consistency NN 40436 5757 7 by by IN 40436 5757 8 making make VBG 40436 5757 9 reply reply NN 40436 5757 10 in in IN 40436 5757 11 the the DT 40436 5757 12 affirmative affirmative NN 40436 5757 13 to to IN 40436 5757 14 each each DT 40436 5757 15 of of IN 40436 5757 16 these these DT 40436 5757 17 successive successive JJ 40436 5757 18 questions question NNS 40436 5757 19 : : : 40436 5757 20 though though IN 40436 5757 21 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 5757 22 pushes push VBZ 40436 5757 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5757 24 hard hard RB 40436 5757 25 by by IN 40436 5757 26 enquiries enquiry NNS 40436 5757 27 as as IN 40436 5757 28 to to IN 40436 5757 29 a a DT 40436 5757 30 string string NN 40436 5757 31 of of IN 40436 5757 32 mean mean JJ 40436 5757 33 and and CC 40436 5757 34 diverse diverse JJ 40436 5757 35 specialties specialty NNS 40436 5757 36 . . . 40436 5758 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5758 2 50 50 CD 40436 5758 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5758 4 This this DT 40436 5758 5 is be VBZ 40436 5758 6 one one CD 40436 5758 7 of of IN 40436 5758 8 the the DT 40436 5758 9 purposes purpose NNS 40436 5758 10 of of IN 40436 5758 11 the the DT 40436 5758 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5758 13 : : : 40436 5758 14 to to TO 40436 5758 15 represent represent VB 40436 5758 16 the the DT 40436 5758 17 two two CD 40436 5758 18 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5758 19 as as RB 40436 5758 20 willing willing JJ 40436 5758 21 to to TO 40436 5758 22 answer answer VB 40436 5758 23 any any DT 40436 5758 24 thing thing NN 40436 5758 25 , , , 40436 5758 26 however however RB 40436 5758 27 obviously obviously RB 40436 5758 28 wrong wrong JJ 40436 5758 29 and and CC 40436 5758 30 false false JJ 40436 5758 31 , , , 40436 5758 32 for for IN 40436 5758 33 the the DT 40436 5758 34 purpose purpose NN 40436 5758 35 of of IN 40436 5758 36 avoiding avoid VBG 40436 5758 37 defeat defeat NN 40436 5758 38 in in IN 40436 5758 39 the the DT 40436 5758 40 dispute dispute NN 40436 5758 41 -- -- : 40436 5758 42 as as IN 40436 5758 43 using use VBG 40436 5758 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5758 45 best good JJS 40436 5758 46 efforts effort NNS 40436 5758 47 to to TO 40436 5758 48 preserve preserve VB 40436 5758 49 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5758 50 in in IN 40436 5758 51 the the DT 40436 5758 52 position position NN 40436 5758 53 of of IN 40436 5758 54 questioners questioner NNS 40436 5758 55 , , , 40436 5758 56 and and CC 40436 5758 57 to to TO 40436 5758 58 evade evade VB 40436 5758 59 the the DT 40436 5758 60 position position NN 40436 5758 61 of of IN 40436 5758 62 respondents respondent NNS 40436 5758 63 -- -- : 40436 5758 64 and and CC 40436 5758 65 as as IN 40436 5758 66 exacting exact VBG 40436 5758 67 a a DT 40436 5758 68 categorical categorical JJ 40436 5758 69 answer answer NN 40436 5758 70 -- -- : 40436 5758 71 Yes yes UH 40436 5758 72 or or CC 40436 5758 73 No no UH 40436 5758 74 -- -- : 40436 5758 75 to to IN 40436 5758 76 every every DT 40436 5758 77 question question NN 40436 5758 78 which which WDT 40436 5758 79 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5758 80 put put VBD 40436 5758 81 without without RP 40436 5758 82 any any DT 40436 5758 83 qualifying qualifying NN 40436 5758 84 words word NNS 40436 5758 85 , , , 40436 5758 86 and and CC 40436 5758 87 without without IN 40436 5758 88 any any DT 40436 5758 89 assurance assurance NN 40436 5758 90 that that IN 40436 5758 91 the the DT 40436 5758 92 meaning meaning NN 40436 5758 93 of of IN 40436 5758 94 the the DT 40436 5758 95 question question NN 40436 5758 96 was be VBD 40436 5758 97 understood understand VBN 40436 5758 98 . . . 40436 5759 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5759 2 51 51 CD 40436 5759 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5759 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5759 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5759 6 50 50 CD 40436 5759 7 : : : 40436 5759 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5759 9 , , , 40436 5759 10 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5759 11 . . . 40436 5760 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5760 2 . . . 40436 5761 1 293 293 CD 40436 5761 2 - - SYM 40436 5761 3 294 294 CD 40436 5761 4 . . . 40436 5761 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5762 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5762 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5762 3 51 51 CD 40436 5762 4 : : : 40436 5762 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5762 6 , , , 40436 5762 7 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5762 8 . . . 40436 5763 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5763 2 . . . 40436 5764 1 295 295 CD 40436 5764 2 - - SYM 40436 5764 3 296 296 CD 40436 5764 4 . . . 40436 5764 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5765 1 The the DT 40436 5765 2 base base NN 40436 5765 3 of of IN 40436 5765 4 these these DT 40436 5765 5 fallacious fallacious JJ 40436 5765 6 inferences inference NNS 40436 5765 7 is be VBZ 40436 5765 8 , , , 40436 5765 9 That that IN 40436 5765 10 respecting respect VBG 40436 5765 11 the the DT 40436 5765 12 same same JJ 40436 5765 13 subject subject NN 40436 5765 14 , , , 40436 5765 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5765 16 can can MD 40436 5765 17 not not RB 40436 5765 18 both both DT 40436 5765 19 affirm affirm VB 40436 5765 20 and and CC 40436 5765 21 deny deny VB 40436 5765 22 the the DT 40436 5765 23 same same JJ 40436 5765 24 predicate predicate NN 40436 5765 25 : : : 40436 5765 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5765 27 can can MD 40436 5765 28 not not RB 40436 5765 29 say say VB 40436 5765 30 , , , 40436 5765 31 A a DT 40436 5765 32 is be VBZ 40436 5765 33 knowing know VBG 40436 5765 34 -- -- : 40436 5765 35 A a DT 40436 5765 36 is be VBZ 40436 5765 37 not not RB 40436 5765 38 knowing know VBG 40436 5765 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5765 40 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5765 41 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5765 42 : : : 40436 5765 43 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 5765 44 / / SYM 40436 5765 45 môn môn NNP 40436 5765 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5765 47 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5765 48 . . . 40436 5766 1 This this DT 40436 5766 2 is be VBZ 40436 5766 3 a a DT 40436 5766 4 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5766 5 more more JJR 40436 5766 6 than than IN 40436 5766 7 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5766 8 : : : 40436 5766 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5766 10 is be VBZ 40436 5766 11 recognised recognise VBN 40436 5766 12 by by IN 40436 5766 13 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5766 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5766 15 and and CC 40436 5766 16 by by IN 40436 5766 17 all all DT 40436 5766 18 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 5766 19 logicians logicians NNPS 40436 5766 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5766 21 under under IN 40436 5766 22 the the DT 40436 5766 23 name--_à name--_à NNP 40436 5766 24 dicto dicto NNP 40436 5766 25 secundum secundum NNP 40436 5766 26 quid quid NNP 40436 5766 27 , , , 40436 5766 28 ad ad NN 40436 5766 29 dictum dictum NN 40436 5766 30 simpliciter simplicit JJR 40436 5766 31 _ _ NNP 40436 5766 32 . . . 40436 5767 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5767 2 is be VBZ 40436 5767 3 very very RB 40436 5767 4 certain certain JJ 40436 5767 5 that that IN 40436 5767 6 this this DT 40436 5767 7 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5767 8 is be VBZ 40436 5767 9 often often RB 40436 5767 10 inadvertently inadvertently RB 40436 5767 11 committed commit VBN 40436 5767 12 by by IN 40436 5767 13 very very RB 40436 5767 14 competent competent JJ 40436 5767 15 reasoners reasoner NNS 40436 5767 16 , , , 40436 5767 17 including include VBG 40436 5767 18 both both CC 40436 5767 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5767 20 and and CC 40436 5767 21 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5767 22 . . . 40436 5768 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5768 2 Side side NN 40436 5768 3 - - HYPH 40436 5768 4 note note NN 40436 5768 5 : : : 40436 5768 6 Farther farther RB 40436 5768 7 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5768 8 equivocations equivocation NNS 40436 5768 9 . . . 40436 5768 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5769 1 Again again RB 40436 5769 2 -- -- : 40436 5769 3 Sophroniskus Sophroniskus NNP 40436 5769 4 was be VBD 40436 5769 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5769 6 father father NN 40436 5769 7 -- -- : 40436 5769 8 Chæredemus Chæredemus NNP 40436 5769 9 was be VBD 40436 5769 10 the the DT 40436 5769 11 father father NN 40436 5769 12 of of IN 40436 5769 13 Patrokles.--Then Patrokles.--Then , 40436 5769 14 Sophroniskus Sophroniskus NNP 40436 5769 15 was be VBD 40436 5769 16 different different JJ 40436 5769 17 from from IN 40436 5769 18 a a DT 40436 5769 19 father father NN 40436 5769 20 : : : 40436 5769 21 therefore therefore RB 40436 5769 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5769 23 was be VBD 40436 5769 24 not not RB 40436 5769 25 a a DT 40436 5769 26 father father NN 40436 5769 27 . . . 40436 5770 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 5770 2 are be VBP 40436 5770 3 different different JJ 40436 5770 4 from from IN 40436 5770 5 a a DT 40436 5770 6 stone stone NN 40436 5770 7 , , , 40436 5770 8 therefore therefore RB 40436 5770 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5770 10 are be VBP 40436 5770 11 not not RB 40436 5770 12 a a DT 40436 5770 13 stone stone NN 40436 5770 14 : : : 40436 5770 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5770 16 are be VBP 40436 5770 17 different different JJ 40436 5770 18 from from IN 40436 5770 19 gold gold NN 40436 5770 20 , , , 40436 5770 21 therefore therefore RB 40436 5770 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5770 23 are be VBP 40436 5770 24 not not RB 40436 5770 25 gold gold JJ 40436 5770 26 . . . 40436 5771 1 By by IN 40436 5771 2 parity parity NN 40436 5771 3 of of IN 40436 5771 4 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5771 5 , , , 40436 5771 6 Sophroniskus Sophroniskus NNP 40436 5771 7 is be VBZ 40436 5771 8 different different JJ 40436 5771 9 from from IN 40436 5771 10 a a DT 40436 5771 11 father father NN 40436 5771 12 -- -- : 40436 5771 13 therefore therefore RB 40436 5771 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5771 15 is be VBZ 40436 5771 16 not not RB 40436 5771 17 a a DT 40436 5771 18 father father NN 40436 5771 19 . . . 40436 5772 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 5772 2 , , , 40436 5772 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5772 4 , , , 40436 5772 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5772 6 , , , 40436 5772 7 have have VBP 40436 5772 8 no no DT 40436 5772 9 father father NN 40436 5772 10 . . . 40436 5773 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5773 2 52 52 CD 40436 5773 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5773 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5773 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5773 6 52 52 CD 40436 5773 7 : : : 40436 5773 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5773 9 , , , 40436 5773 10 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5773 11 . . . 40436 5774 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5774 2 . . . 40436 5775 1 297 297 CD 40436 5775 2 - - SYM 40436 5775 3 298 298 CD 40436 5775 4 . . . 40436 5775 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5776 1 But but CC 40436 5776 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5776 3 retorts retort VBZ 40436 5776 4 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 5776 5 upon upon IN 40436 5776 6 the the DT 40436 5776 7 couple couple NN 40436 5776 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5776 9 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5776 10 father father NN 40436 5776 11 is be VBZ 40436 5776 12 different different JJ 40436 5776 13 from from IN 40436 5776 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5776 15 father.--Not father.--not NN 40436 5776 16 at at IN 40436 5776 17 all.--How all.--How NNP 40436 5776 18 can can MD 40436 5776 19 that that DT 40436 5776 20 be?--What be?--What NNP 40436 5776 21 ! ! . 40436 5777 1 is be VBZ 40436 5777 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5777 3 father father NN 40436 5777 4 , , , 40436 5777 5 then then RB 40436 5777 6 , , , 40436 5777 7 the the DT 40436 5777 8 father father NN 40436 5777 9 of of IN 40436 5777 10 all all DT 40436 5777 11 men man NNS 40436 5777 12 and and CC 40436 5777 13 of of IN 40436 5777 14 all all DT 40436 5777 15 animals?--Certainly animals?--Certainly , 40436 5777 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5777 17 is be VBZ 40436 5777 18 . . . 40436 5778 1 A a DT 40436 5778 2 man man NN 40436 5778 3 can can MD 40436 5778 4 not not RB 40436 5778 5 be be VB 40436 5778 6 at at IN 40436 5778 7 the the DT 40436 5778 8 same same JJ 40436 5778 9 time time NN 40436 5778 10 a a DT 40436 5778 11 father father NN 40436 5778 12 , , , 40436 5778 13 and and CC 40436 5778 14 not not RB 40436 5778 15 a a DT 40436 5778 16 father father NN 40436 5778 17 . . . 40436 5779 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5779 2 can can MD 40436 5779 3 not not RB 40436 5779 4 be be VB 40436 5779 5 at at IN 40436 5779 6 the the DT 40436 5779 7 same same JJ 40436 5779 8 time time NN 40436 5779 9 a a DT 40436 5779 10 man man NN 40436 5779 11 , , , 40436 5779 12 and and CC 40436 5779 13 not not RB 40436 5779 14 a a DT 40436 5779 15 man man NN 40436 5779 16 -- -- : 40436 5779 17 gold gold NN 40436 5779 18 , , , 40436 5779 19 and and CC 40436 5779 20 not not RB 40436 5779 21 gold gold NN 40436 5779 22 . . . 40436 5780 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5780 2 53 53 CD 40436 5780 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5780 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5780 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5780 6 53 53 CD 40436 5780 7 : : : 40436 5780 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5780 9 , , , 40436 5780 10 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5780 11 . . . 40436 5781 1 p. p. NN 40436 5781 2 298 298 CD 40436 5781 3 . . . 40436 5782 1 Some some DT 40436 5782 2 of of IN 40436 5782 3 the the DT 40436 5782 4 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5782 5 in in IN 40436 5782 6 the the DT 40436 5782 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5782 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5782 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5782 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5782 11 : : : 40436 5782 12 Po Po NNP 40436 5782 13 / / SYM 40436 5782 14 teron teron NN 40436 5782 15 o(rô o(rô NNP 40436 5782 16 = = SYM 40436 5782 17 sin sin NN 40436 5782 18 oi oi NNP 40436 5782 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5782 20 a)/nthrôpoi a)/nthrôpoi NNP 40436 5782 21 ta\ ta\ NNPS 40436 5782 22 dunata\ dunata\ JJ 40436 5782 23 o(ra=|n o(ra=|n VBP 40436 5782 24 ê)\ ê)\ TO 40436 5782 25 ta\ ta\ JJ 40436 5782 26 a)du a)du NN 40436 5782 27 / / SYM 40436 5782 28 nata nata NN 40436 5782 29 ? ? . 40436 5783 1 . . . 40436 5784 1 . . . 40436 5785 1 . . . 40436 5786 1 Ê)= Ê)= `` 40436 5786 2 ou)ch ou)ch VBG 40436 5786 3 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 5786 4 / / SYM 40436 5786 5 n n NNP 40436 5786 6 te te NNP 40436 5786 7 sigô sigô NNP 40436 5786 8 = = SYM 40436 5786 9 nta nta NNP 40436 5786 10 le le NNP 40436 5786 11 / / SYM 40436 5786 12 gein gein NNP 40436 5786 13 ? ? . 40436 5786 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5787 1 p. p. NN 40436 5787 2 300 300 CD 40436 5787 3 A a NN 40436 5787 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5787 5 are be VBP 40436 5787 6 hardly hardly RB 40436 5787 7 translatable translatable JJ 40436 5787 8 into into IN 40436 5787 9 English English NNP 40436 5787 10 , , , 40436 5787 11 since since IN 40436 5787 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5787 13 depend depend VBP 40436 5787 14 upon upon IN 40436 5787 15 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 5787 16 constructions construction NNS 40436 5787 17 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 5787 18 to to IN 40436 5787 19 the the DT 40436 5787 20 Greek greek JJ 40436 5787 21 language language NN 40436 5787 22 . . . 40436 5788 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5788 2 refers refer VBZ 40436 5788 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5788 4 to to IN 40436 5788 5 the the DT 40436 5788 6 general general JJ 40436 5788 7 head head NN 40436 5788 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5788 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5788 10 : : : 40436 5788 11 par par NN 40436 5788 12 ' ' '' 40436 5788 13 a)mphiboli a)mphiboli CD 40436 5788 14 / / SYM 40436 5788 15 an an NN 40436 5788 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5788 17 . . . 40436 5789 1 The the DT 40436 5789 2 same same JJ 40436 5789 3 about about IN 40436 5789 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5789 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5789 6 : : : 40436 5789 7 prosê prosê NNS 40436 5789 8 / / SYM 40436 5789 9 kei kei NNP 40436 5789 10 to\n to\n NNP 40436 5789 11 ma ma NNP 40436 5789 12 / / SYM 40436 5789 13 geiron geiron NNP 40436 5789 14 katako katako NNP 40436 5789 15 / / SYM 40436 5789 16 ptein ptein NNP 40436 5789 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5789 18 , , , 40436 5789 19 p. p. NN 40436 5789 20 301 301 CD 40436 5789 21 D. D. NNP 40436 5789 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5789 23 You -PRON- PRP 40436 5789 24 have have VBP 40436 5789 25 got get VBN 40436 5789 26 a a DT 40436 5789 27 dog dog NN 40436 5789 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5789 29 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5789 30 says say VBZ 40436 5789 31 to to IN 40436 5789 32 Ktesippus).--Yes.--The Ktesippus).--Yes.--The NNP 40436 5789 33 dog dog NN 40436 5789 34 is be VBZ 40436 5789 35 the the DT 40436 5789 36 father father NN 40436 5789 37 of of IN 40436 5789 38 puppies?--Yes.--The puppies?--Yes.--The NNP 40436 5789 39 dog dog NN 40436 5789 40 , , , 40436 5789 41 being be VBG 40436 5789 42 a a DT 40436 5789 43 father father NN 40436 5789 44 , , , 40436 5789 45 is be VBZ 40436 5789 46 yours?--Certainly.--Then yours?--Certainly.--Then NNP 40436 5789 47 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5789 48 father father NN 40436 5789 49 is be VBZ 40436 5789 50 a a DT 40436 5789 51 dog dog NN 40436 5789 52 , , , 40436 5789 53 and and CC 40436 5789 54 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5789 55 are be VBP 40436 5789 56 brother brother NN 40436 5789 57 of of IN 40436 5789 58 the the DT 40436 5789 59 puppies puppy NNS 40436 5789 60 . . . 40436 5790 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 5790 2 beat beat VBP 40436 5790 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5790 4 dog dog NN 40436 5790 5 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 5790 6 ? ? . 40436 5791 1 Then then RB 40436 5791 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5791 3 beat beat VBP 40436 5791 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5791 5 father father NN 40436 5791 6 . . . 40436 5792 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5792 2 54 54 CD 40436 5792 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5792 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5792 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5792 6 54 54 CD 40436 5792 7 : : : 40436 5792 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5792 9 . . . 40436 5793 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5793 2 . . . 40436 5794 1 p. p. NN 40436 5795 1 298 298 CD 40436 5795 2 . . . 40436 5795 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5796 1 Those those DT 40436 5796 2 animals animal NNS 40436 5796 3 , , , 40436 5796 4 and and CC 40436 5796 5 those those DT 40436 5796 6 alone alone JJ 40436 5796 7 are be VBP 40436 5796 8 _ _ NNP 40436 5796 9 yours yours PRP$ 40436 5796 10 _ _ NNP 40436 5796 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5796 12 sheep sheep NN 40436 5796 13 , , , 40436 5796 14 oxen oxen NNP 40436 5796 15 , , , 40436 5796 16 & & CC 40436 5796 17 c. c. NNP 40436 5796 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5796 19 , , , 40436 5796 20 which which WDT 40436 5796 21 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5796 22 can can MD 40436 5796 23 give give VB 40436 5796 24 away away RP 40436 5796 25 , , , 40436 5796 26 or or CC 40436 5796 27 sell sell VB 40436 5796 28 , , , 40436 5796 29 or or CC 40436 5796 30 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 5796 31 at at IN 40436 5796 32 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 5796 33 . . . 40436 5797 1 But but CC 40436 5797 2 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 5797 3 , , , 40436 5797 4 Apollo Apollo NNP 40436 5797 5 , , , 40436 5797 6 and and CC 40436 5797 7 Athênê Athênê NNP 40436 5797 8 are be VBP 40436 5797 9 _ _ NNP 40436 5797 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5797 11 _ _ NNP 40436 5797 12 Gods Gods NNP 40436 5797 13 . . . 40436 5798 1 The the DT 40436 5798 2 Gods god NNS 40436 5798 3 have have VBP 40436 5798 4 a a DT 40436 5798 5 soul soul NN 40436 5798 6 and and CC 40436 5798 7 are be VBP 40436 5798 8 animals animal NNS 40436 5798 9 . . . 40436 5799 1 Therefore therefore RB 40436 5799 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5799 3 Gods god NNS 40436 5799 4 are be VBP 40436 5799 5 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5799 6 animals animal NNS 40436 5799 7 . . . 40436 5800 1 Now now RB 40436 5800 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5800 3 told tell VBD 40436 5800 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5800 5 that that IN 40436 5800 6 those those DT 40436 5800 7 alone alone RB 40436 5800 8 were be VBD 40436 5800 9 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5800 10 animals animal NNS 40436 5800 11 , , , 40436 5800 12 which which WDT 40436 5800 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5800 14 could could MD 40436 5800 15 give give VB 40436 5800 16 away away RP 40436 5800 17 , , , 40436 5800 18 or or CC 40436 5800 19 sell sell VB 40436 5800 20 , , , 40436 5800 21 or or CC 40436 5800 22 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 5800 23 at at IN 40436 5800 24 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 5800 25 . . . 40436 5801 1 Therefore therefore RB 40436 5801 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5801 3 can can MD 40436 5801 4 give give VB 40436 5801 5 away away RP 40436 5801 6 , , , 40436 5801 7 or or CC 40436 5801 8 sell sell VB 40436 5801 9 , , , 40436 5801 10 or or CC 40436 5801 11 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 5801 12 at at IN 40436 5801 13 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 5801 14 , , , 40436 5801 15 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 5801 16 , , , 40436 5801 17 Apollo Apollo NNP 40436 5801 18 , , , 40436 5801 19 and and CC 40436 5801 20 Athênê Athênê NNP 40436 5801 21 . . . 40436 5802 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5802 2 55 55 CD 40436 5802 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5802 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5802 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5802 6 55 55 CD 40436 5802 7 : : : 40436 5802 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5802 9 . . . 40436 5803 1 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5803 2 . . . 40436 5804 1 p. p. NN 40436 5804 2 302 302 CD 40436 5804 3 . . . 40436 5805 1 This this DT 40436 5805 2 same same JJ 40436 5805 3 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5805 4 , , , 40436 5805 5 in in IN 40436 5805 6 substance substance NN 40436 5805 7 , , , 40436 5805 8 is be VBZ 40436 5805 9 given give VBN 40436 5805 10 by by IN 40436 5805 11 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5805 12 , , , 40436 5805 13 De De NNP 40436 5805 14 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5805 15 . . . 40436 5806 1 El El NNP 40436 5806 2 . . . 40436 5807 1 17 17 CD 40436 5807 2 , , , 40436 5807 3 176 176 CD 40436 5807 4 a. a. NN 40436 5808 1 3 3 CD 40436 5808 2 , , , 40436 5808 3 179 179 CD 40436 5808 4 , , , 40436 5808 5 a. a. NN 40436 5809 1 5 5 CD 40436 5809 2 , , , 40436 5809 3 but but CC 40436 5809 4 with with IN 40436 5809 5 different different JJ 40436 5809 6 exemplifying exemplifying NN 40436 5809 7 names name NNS 40436 5809 8 and and CC 40436 5809 9 persons person NNS 40436 5809 10 . . . 40436 5809 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5810 1 This this DT 40436 5810 2 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5810 3 depends depend VBZ 40436 5810 4 upon upon IN 40436 5810 5 the the DT 40436 5810 6 double double JJ 40436 5810 7 and and CC 40436 5810 8 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 5810 9 meaning meaning NN 40436 5810 10 of of IN 40436 5810 11 _ _ NNP 40436 5810 12 yours_--one yours_--one NNP 40436 5810 13 of of IN 40436 5810 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5810 15 different different JJ 40436 5810 16 explanations explanation NNS 40436 5810 17 being be VBG 40436 5810 18 treated treat VBN 40436 5810 19 as as IN 40436 5810 20 if if IN 40436 5810 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5810 22 were be VBD 40436 5810 23 the the DT 40436 5810 24 only only JJ 40436 5810 25 one one CD 40436 5810 26 . . . 40436 5811 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5811 2 Side side NN 40436 5811 3 - - HYPH 40436 5811 4 note note NN 40436 5811 5 : : : 40436 5811 6 Fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5811 7 involving involve VBG 40436 5811 8 deeper deep JJR 40436 5811 9 logical logical JJ 40436 5811 10 principles principle NNS 40436 5811 11 -- -- : 40436 5811 12 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 5811 13 is be VBZ 40436 5811 14 impossible.--To impossible.--to NN 40436 5811 15 speak speak VBP 40436 5811 16 falsely falsely RB 40436 5811 17 is be VBZ 40436 5811 18 impossible impossible JJ 40436 5811 19 . . . 40436 5811 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5812 1 Other other JJ 40436 5812 2 puzzles puzzle NNS 40436 5812 3 cited cite VBD 40436 5812 4 in in IN 40436 5812 5 this this DT 40436 5812 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5812 7 go go VBP 40436 5812 8 deeper:--Contradiction deeper:--contradiction NN 40436 5812 9 is be VBZ 40436 5812 10 impossible impossible JJ 40436 5812 11 -- -- : 40436 5812 12 To to TO 40436 5812 13 speak speak VB 40436 5812 14 falsely falsely RB 40436 5812 15 is be VBZ 40436 5812 16 impossible impossible JJ 40436 5812 17 . . . 40436 5813 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5813 2 56 56 LS 40436 5813 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5813 4 These these DT 40436 5813 5 paradoxes paradox NNS 40436 5813 6 were be VBD 40436 5813 7 maintained maintain VBN 40436 5813 8 by by IN 40436 5813 9 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNPS 40436 5813 10 and and CC 40436 5813 11 others other NNS 40436 5813 12 , , , 40436 5813 13 and and CC 40436 5813 14 appear appear VB 40436 5813 15 to to TO 40436 5813 16 have have VB 40436 5813 17 been be VBN 40436 5813 18 matters matter NNS 40436 5813 19 of of IN 40436 5813 20 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 5813 21 debate debate NN 40436 5813 22 throughout throughout IN 40436 5813 23 the the DT 40436 5813 24 fourth fourth JJ 40436 5813 25 and and CC 40436 5813 26 third third JJ 40436 5813 27 centuries century NNS 40436 5813 28 . . . 40436 5814 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5814 2 shall shall MD 40436 5814 3 say say VB 40436 5814 4 more more JJR 40436 5814 5 of of IN 40436 5814 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5814 7 when when WRB 40436 5814 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5814 9 speak speak VBP 40436 5814 10 about about IN 40436 5814 11 the the DT 40436 5814 12 Megarics Megarics NNPS 40436 5814 13 and and CC 40436 5814 14 Antisthenes Antisthenes NNPS 40436 5814 15 . . . 40436 5815 1 Here here RB 40436 5815 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5815 3 only only RB 40436 5815 4 note note VBP 40436 5815 5 , , , 40436 5815 6 that that IN 40436 5815 7 in in IN 40436 5815 8 this this DT 40436 5815 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5815 10 , , , 40436 5815 11 Ktesippus Ktesippus NNP 40436 5815 12 is be VBZ 40436 5815 13 represented represent VBN 40436 5815 14 as as IN 40436 5815 15 put put VBN 40436 5815 16 to to IN 40436 5815 17 silence silence NN 40436 5815 18 by by IN 40436 5815 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5815 20 , , , 40436 5815 21 and and CC 40436 5815 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5815 23 as as IN 40436 5815 24 making make VBG 40436 5815 25 an an DT 40436 5815 26 answer answer NN 40436 5815 27 which which WDT 40436 5815 28 is be VBZ 40436 5815 29 no no DT 40436 5815 30 answer answer NN 40436 5815 31 at at RB 40436 5815 32 all all RB 40436 5815 33 . . . 40436 5816 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5816 2 57 57 CD 40436 5816 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5816 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5816 5 see see VBP 40436 5816 6 how how WRB 40436 5816 7 much much JJ 40436 5816 8 trouble trouble NN 40436 5816 9 these these DT 40436 5816 10 paradoxes paradox NNS 40436 5816 11 gave give VBD 40436 5816 12 to to IN 40436 5816 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5816 14 , , , 40436 5816 15 when when WRB 40436 5816 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5816 17 read read VBP 40436 5816 18 the the DT 40436 5816 19 Sophistês Sophistês NNP 40436 5816 20 , , , 40436 5816 21 in in IN 40436 5816 22 which which WDT 40436 5816 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5816 24 handles handle VBZ 40436 5816 25 the the DT 40436 5816 26 last last JJ 40436 5816 27 of of IN 40436 5816 28 the the DT 40436 5816 29 two two CD 40436 5816 30 in in IN 40436 5816 31 a a DT 40436 5816 32 manner manner NN 40436 5816 33 elaborate elaborate NN 40436 5816 34 , , , 40436 5816 35 but but CC 40436 5816 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5816 37 to to IN 40436 5816 38 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5816 39 judgment judgment NN 40436 5816 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5816 41 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 5816 42 . . . 40436 5817 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5817 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5817 3 56 56 CD 40436 5817 4 : : : 40436 5817 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5817 6 , , , 40436 5817 7 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5817 8 . . . 40436 5818 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5818 2 . . . 40436 5819 1 285 285 CD 40436 5819 2 - - SYM 40436 5819 3 286 286 CD 40436 5819 4 . . . 40436 5819 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5820 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5820 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5820 3 57 57 CD 40436 5820 4 : : : 40436 5820 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5820 6 , , , 40436 5820 7 Euthydêm Euthydêm NNP 40436 5820 8 . . . 40436 5821 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5821 2 . . . 40436 5822 1 286 286 CD 40436 5822 2 B--287 B--287 NNP 40436 5822 3 A. a. NN 40436 5822 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5823 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5823 2 Side side NN 40436 5823 3 - - HYPH 40436 5823 4 note note NN 40436 5823 5 : : : 40436 5823 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5823 7 's 's POS 40436 5823 8 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5823 9 is be VBZ 40436 5823 10 the the DT 40436 5823 11 earliest early JJS 40436 5823 12 known known JJ 40436 5823 13 attempt attempt NN 40436 5823 14 to to TO 40436 5823 15 set set VB 40436 5823 16 out out RP 40436 5823 17 and and CC 40436 5823 18 expose expose VB 40436 5823 19 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5823 20 -- -- : 40436 5823 21 the the DT 40436 5823 22 only only JJ 40436 5823 23 way way NN 40436 5823 24 of of IN 40436 5823 25 exposing expose VBG 40436 5823 26 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5823 27 is be VBZ 40436 5823 28 to to TO 40436 5823 29 exemplify exemplify VB 40436 5823 30 the the DT 40436 5823 31 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5823 32 by by IN 40436 5823 33 particular particular JJ 40436 5823 34 cases case NNS 40436 5823 35 , , , 40436 5823 36 in in IN 40436 5823 37 which which WDT 40436 5823 38 the the DT 40436 5823 39 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5823 40 proved prove VBD 40436 5823 41 is be VBZ 40436 5823 42 known know VBN 40436 5823 43 _ _ NNP 40436 5823 44 aliunde aliunde NNP 40436 5823 45 _ _ NNP 40436 5823 46 to to TO 40436 5823 47 be be VB 40436 5823 48 false false JJ 40436 5823 49 and and CC 40436 5823 50 absurd absurd JJ 40436 5823 51 . . . 40436 5823 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5824 1 The the DT 40436 5824 2 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5824 3 of of IN 40436 5824 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5824 5 is be VBZ 40436 5824 6 memorable memorable JJ 40436 5824 7 in in IN 40436 5824 8 the the DT 40436 5824 9 history history NN 40436 5824 10 of of IN 40436 5824 11 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5824 12 as as IN 40436 5824 13 the the DT 40436 5824 14 earliest early JJS 40436 5824 15 known known JJ 40436 5824 16 attempt attempt NN 40436 5824 17 to to TO 40436 5824 18 set set VB 40436 5824 19 out out RP 40436 5824 20 , , , 40436 5824 21 and and CC 40436 5824 22 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 5824 23 to to IN 40436 5824 24 attention attention NN 40436 5824 25 , , , 40436 5824 26 a a DT 40436 5824 27 string string NN 40436 5824 28 of of IN 40436 5824 29 fallacious fallacious JJ 40436 5824 30 modes mode NNS 40436 5824 31 of of IN 40436 5824 32 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5824 33 . . . 40436 5825 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5825 2 makes make VBZ 40436 5825 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5825 4 all all DT 40436 5825 5 absurd absurd JJ 40436 5825 6 and and CC 40436 5825 7 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 5825 8 . . . 40436 5826 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5826 2 gives give VBZ 40436 5826 3 a a DT 40436 5826 4 caricature caricature NN 40436 5826 5 of of IN 40436 5826 6 a a DT 40436 5826 7 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 5826 8 debate debate NN 40436 5826 9 , , , 40436 5826 10 not not RB 40436 5826 11 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 5826 12 of of IN 40436 5826 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5826 14 namesake namesake NN 40436 5826 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5826 16 Comicus Comicus NNP 40436 5826 17 -- -- : 40436 5826 18 or or CC 40436 5826 19 of of IN 40436 5826 20 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40436 5826 21 , , , 40436 5826 22 Swift Swift NNP 40436 5826 23 , , , 40436 5826 24 or or CC 40436 5826 25 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 40436 5826 26 . . . 40436 5827 1 The the DT 40436 5827 2 sophisms sophism NNS 40436 5827 3 appear appear VBP 40436 5827 4 for for IN 40436 5827 5 the the DT 40436 5827 6 most most JJS 40436 5827 7 part part NN 40436 5827 8 so so RB 40436 5827 9 silly silly JJ 40436 5827 10 , , , 40436 5827 11 as as IN 40436 5827 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5827 13 puts put VBZ 40436 5827 14 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5827 15 , , , 40436 5827 16 that that IN 40436 5827 17 the the DT 40436 5827 18 reader reader NN 40436 5827 19 asks ask VBZ 40436 5827 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5827 21 how how WRB 40436 5827 22 any any DT 40436 5827 23 one one PRP 40436 5827 24 could could MD 40436 5827 25 have have VB 40436 5827 26 been be VBN 40436 5827 27 ever ever RB 40436 5827 28 imposed impose VBN 40436 5827 29 upon upon IN 40436 5827 30 by by IN 40436 5827 31 such such PDT 40436 5827 32 a a DT 40436 5827 33 palpable palpable JJ 40436 5827 34 delusion delusion NN 40436 5827 35 ? ? . 40436 5828 1 Yet yet CC 40436 5828 2 such such JJ 40436 5828 3 confidence confidence NN 40436 5828 4 is be VBZ 40436 5828 5 by by IN 40436 5828 6 no no DT 40436 5828 7 means means NN 40436 5828 8 justified justified JJ 40436 5828 9 . . . 40436 5829 1 A a DT 40436 5829 2 sophism sophism NN 40436 5829 3 , , , 40436 5829 4 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 5829 5 analogous analogous JJ 40436 5829 6 in in IN 40436 5829 7 character character NN 40436 5829 8 to to IN 40436 5829 9 those those DT 40436 5829 10 which which WDT 40436 5829 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5829 12 here here RB 40436 5829 13 exposes expose VBZ 40436 5829 14 to to TO 40436 5829 15 ridicule ridicule VB 40436 5829 16 , , , 40436 5829 17 may may MD 40436 5829 18 , , , 40436 5829 19 in in IN 40436 5829 20 another another DT 40436 5829 21 case case NN 40436 5829 22 , , , 40436 5829 23 easily easily RB 40436 5829 24 escape escape VB 40436 5829 25 detection detection NN 40436 5829 26 from from IN 40436 5829 27 the the DT 40436 5829 28 hearer hearer NN 40436 5829 29 , , , 40436 5829 30 and and CC 40436 5829 31 even even RB 40436 5829 32 from from IN 40436 5829 33 the the DT 40436 5829 34 reasoner reasoner NN 40436 5829 35 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5829 36 . . . 40436 5830 1 People People NNS 40436 5830 2 are be VBP 40436 5830 3 constantly constantly RB 40436 5830 4 misled mislead VBN 40436 5830 5 by by IN 40436 5830 6 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5830 7 arising arise VBG 40436 5830 8 from from IN 40436 5830 9 the the DT 40436 5830 10 same same JJ 40436 5830 11 word word NN 40436 5830 12 bearing bear VBG 40436 5830 13 two two CD 40436 5830 14 senses sense NNS 40436 5830 15 , , , 40436 5830 16 from from IN 40436 5830 17 double double JJ 40436 5830 18 construction construction NN 40436 5830 19 of of IN 40436 5830 20 the the DT 40436 5830 21 same same JJ 40436 5830 22 phrase phrase NN 40436 5830 23 , , , 40436 5830 24 from from IN 40436 5830 25 unconscious unconscious JJ 40436 5830 26 application application NN 40436 5830 27 of of IN 40436 5830 28 a a DT 40436 5830 29 _ _ NNP 40436 5830 30 dictum dictum NN 40436 5830 31 secundum secundum NN 40436 5830 32 quid quid NNP 40436 5830 33 _ _ NNP 40436 5830 34 , , , 40436 5830 35 as as IN 40436 5830 36 if if IN 40436 5830 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5830 38 were be VBD 40436 5830 39 a a DT 40436 5830 40 _ _ NNP 40436 5830 41 dictum dictum NN 40436 5830 42 simpliciter simpliciter NN 40436 5830 43 _ _ NNP 40436 5830 44 ; ; : 40436 5830 45 from from IN 40436 5830 46 Petitio Petitio NNP 40436 5830 47 Principii Principii NNP 40436 5830 48 , , , 40436 5830 49 & & CC 40436 5830 50 c. c. NNP 40436 5830 51 , , , 40436 5830 52 Ignoratio Ignoratio NNP 40436 5830 53 Elenchi Elenchi NNP 40436 5830 54 , , , 40436 5830 55 & & CC 40436 5830 56 c. c. NNP 40436 5830 57 Neither Neither NNP 40436 5830 58 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5830 59 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5830 60 , , , 40436 5830 61 nor nor CC 40436 5830 62 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5830 63 , , , 40436 5830 64 can can MD 40436 5830 65 boast boast VB 40436 5830 66 of of IN 40436 5830 67 escaping escape VBG 40436 5830 68 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5830 69 . . . 40436 5831 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5831 2 58 58 CD 40436 5831 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5831 4 If if IN 40436 5831 5 these these DT 40436 5831 6 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5831 7 appear appear VBP 40436 5831 8 , , , 40436 5831 9 in in IN 40436 5831 10 the the DT 40436 5831 11 examples example NNS 40436 5831 12 chosen choose VBN 40436 5831 13 by by IN 40436 5831 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5831 15 for for IN 40436 5831 16 the the DT 40436 5831 17 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5831 18 , , , 40436 5831 19 so so RB 40436 5831 20 obviously obviously RB 40436 5831 21 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 40436 5831 22 that that IN 40436 5831 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5831 24 can can MD 40436 5831 25 deceive deceive VB 40436 5831 26 no no DT 40436 5831 27 one one NN 40436 5831 28 -- -- : 40436 5831 29 the the DT 40436 5831 30 reason reason NN 40436 5831 31 lies lie VBZ 40436 5831 32 not not RB 40436 5831 33 in in IN 40436 5831 34 the the DT 40436 5831 35 premisses premiss NNS 40436 5831 36 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5831 37 , , , 40436 5831 38 but but CC 40436 5831 39 in in IN 40436 5831 40 the the DT 40436 5831 41 particular particular JJ 40436 5831 42 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 5831 43 to to TO 40436 5831 44 which which WDT 40436 5831 45 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5831 46 lead lead VBP 40436 5831 47 : : : 40436 5831 48 which which WDT 40436 5831 49 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 5831 50 are be VBP 40436 5831 51 known know VBN 40436 5831 52 on on IN 40436 5831 53 other other JJ 40436 5831 54 grounds ground NNS 40436 5831 55 to to TO 40436 5831 56 be be VB 40436 5831 57 false false JJ 40436 5831 58 , , , 40436 5831 59 and and CC 40436 5831 60 never never RB 40436 5831 61 to to TO 40436 5831 62 be be VB 40436 5831 63 seriously seriously RB 40436 5831 64 maintainable maintainable JJ 40436 5831 65 by by IN 40436 5831 66 any any DT 40436 5831 67 person person NN 40436 5831 68 . . . 40436 5832 1 Such such JJ 40436 5832 2 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 5832 3 as--"Sokrates as--"sokrate NNS 40436 5832 4 had have VBD 40436 5832 5 no no DT 40436 5832 6 father father NN 40436 5832 7 : : : 40436 5832 8 Sophroniskus Sophroniskus NNP 40436 5832 9 , , , 40436 5832 10 if if IN 40436 5832 11 father father NN 40436 5832 12 of of IN 40436 5832 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5832 14 , , , 40436 5832 15 was be VBD 40436 5832 16 father father NN 40436 5832 17 of of IN 40436 5832 18 all all DT 40436 5832 19 men man NNS 40436 5832 20 and and CC 40436 5832 21 all all DT 40436 5832 22 animals animal NNS 40436 5832 23 : : : 40436 5832 24 In in IN 40436 5832 25 beating beat VBG 40436 5832 26 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5832 27 dog dog NN 40436 5832 28 , , , 40436 5832 29 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5832 30 beat beat VBP 40436 5832 31 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5832 32 father father NN 40436 5832 33 : : : 40436 5832 34 If if IN 40436 5832 35 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5832 36 know know VBP 40436 5832 37 one one CD 40436 5832 38 thing thing NN 40436 5832 39 , , , 40436 5832 40 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5832 41 know know VBP 40436 5832 42 everything everything NN 40436 5832 43 , , , 40436 5832 44 " " '' 40436 5832 45 & & CC 40436 5832 46 c. c. NNP 40436 5832 47 , , , 40436 5832 48 being be VBG 40436 5832 49 known know VBN 40436 5832 50 _ _ NNP 40436 5832 51 aliunde aliunde NNP 40436 5832 52 _ _ NNP 40436 5832 53 to to TO 40436 5832 54 be be VB 40436 5832 55 false false JJ 40436 5832 56 , , , 40436 5832 57 prove prove VB 40436 5832 58 that that IN 40436 5832 59 there there EX 40436 5832 60 has have VBZ 40436 5832 61 been be VBN 40436 5832 62 some some DT 40436 5832 63 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5832 64 in in IN 40436 5832 65 the the DT 40436 5832 66 premisses premiss NNS 40436 5832 67 whereby whereby WRB 40436 5832 68 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5832 69 have have VBP 40436 5832 70 been be VBN 40436 5832 71 established establish VBN 40436 5832 72 . . . 40436 5833 1 Such such JJ 40436 5833 2 cases case NNS 40436 5833 3 serve serve VBP 40436 5833 4 as as IN 40436 5833 5 a a DT 40436 5833 6 _ _ NNP 40436 5833 7 reductio reductio NN 40436 5833 8 ad ad NN 40436 5833 9 absurdum absurdum NN 40436 5833 10 _ _ NNP 40436 5833 11 of of IN 40436 5833 12 the the DT 40436 5833 13 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 5833 14 process process NN 40436 5833 15 . . . 40436 5834 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5834 2 make make VBP 40436 5834 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5834 4 aware aware JJ 40436 5834 5 of of IN 40436 5834 6 one one CD 40436 5834 7 mode mode NN 40436 5834 8 of of IN 40436 5834 9 liability liability NN 40436 5834 10 to to TO 40436 5834 11 error error VB 40436 5834 12 , , , 40436 5834 13 and and CC 40436 5834 14 put put VBD 40436 5834 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5834 16 on on IN 40436 5834 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5834 18 guard guard NN 40436 5834 19 against against IN 40436 5834 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5834 21 in in IN 40436 5834 22 analogous analogous JJ 40436 5834 23 cases case NNS 40436 5834 24 . . . 40436 5835 1 This this DT 40436 5835 2 is be VBZ 40436 5835 3 a a DT 40436 5835 4 valuable valuable JJ 40436 5835 5 service service NN 40436 5835 6 , , , 40436 5835 7 and and CC 40436 5835 8 all all PDT 40436 5835 9 the the DT 40436 5835 10 more more RBR 40436 5835 11 valuable valuable JJ 40436 5835 12 , , , 40436 5835 13 because because IN 40436 5835 14 the the DT 40436 5835 15 liability liability NN 40436 5835 16 to to TO 40436 5835 17 error error VB 40436 5835 18 is be VBZ 40436 5835 19 real real JJ 40436 5835 20 and and CC 40436 5835 21 widespread widespread JJ 40436 5835 22 , , , 40436 5835 23 even even RB 40436 5835 24 from from IN 40436 5835 25 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5835 26 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 5835 27 analogous analogous JJ 40436 5835 28 to to IN 40436 5835 29 those those DT 40436 5835 30 which which WDT 40436 5835 31 seem seem VBP 40436 5835 32 so so RB 40436 5835 33 silly silly JJ 40436 5835 34 under under IN 40436 5835 35 the the DT 40436 5835 36 particular particular JJ 40436 5835 37 exemplifications exemplification NNS 40436 5835 38 which which WDT 40436 5835 39 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5835 40 selects select NNS 40436 5835 41 and and CC 40436 5835 42 exposes expose NNS 40436 5835 43 . . . 40436 5836 1 Many many JJ 40436 5836 2 of of IN 40436 5836 3 the the DT 40436 5836 4 illustrations illustration NNS 40436 5836 5 of of IN 40436 5836 6 the the DT 40436 5836 7 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5836 8 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5836 9 are be VBP 40436 5836 10 reproduced reproduce VBN 40436 5836 11 by by IN 40436 5836 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5836 13 in in IN 40436 5836 14 the the DT 40436 5836 15 Treatise Treatise NNP 40436 5836 16 de de FW 40436 5836 17 Sophisticis Sophisticis NNP 40436 5836 18 Elenchis Elenchis NNP 40436 5836 19 , , , 40436 5836 20 together together RB 40436 5836 21 with with IN 40436 5836 22 other other JJ 40436 5836 23 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5836 24 , , , 40436 5836 25 discriminated discriminate VBN 40436 5836 26 with with IN 40436 5836 27 a a DT 40436 5836 28 certain certain JJ 40436 5836 29 method method NN 40436 5836 30 and and CC 40436 5836 31 system system NN 40436 5836 32 . . . 40436 5837 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5837 2 59 59 CD 40436 5837 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5837 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5837 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5837 6 58 58 CD 40436 5837 7 : : : 40436 5837 8 See see VB 40436 5837 9 a a DT 40436 5837 10 passage passage NN 40436 5837 11 in in IN 40436 5837 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5837 13 's 's POS 40436 5837 14 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 5837 15 , , , 40436 5837 16 where where WRB 40436 5837 17 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 5837 18 remarks remark VBZ 40436 5837 19 with with IN 40436 5837 20 propriety propriety NN 40436 5837 21 upon upon IN 40436 5837 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5837 23 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 5837 24 use use NN 40436 5837 25 of of IN 40436 5837 26 the the DT 40436 5837 27 words word NNS 40436 5837 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5837 29 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5837 30 : : : 40436 5837 31 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 5837 32 zê=|n zê=|n CD 40436 5837 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5837 34 and and CC 40436 5837 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5837 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5837 37 : : : 40436 5837 38 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 5837 39 pra pra NNP 40436 5837 40 / / SYM 40436 5837 41 ttein]--also ttein]--also NNPS 40436 5837 42 the the DT 40436 5837 43 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 5837 44 , , , 40436 5837 45 p. p. NN 40436 5837 46 507 507 CD 40436 5837 47 D d NN 40436 5837 48 , , , 40436 5837 49 with with IN 40436 5837 50 the the DT 40436 5837 51 notes note NNS 40436 5837 52 of of IN 40436 5837 53 Routh Routh NNP 40436 5837 54 and and CC 40436 5837 55 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 5837 56 . . . 40436 5838 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5838 2 have have VBP 40436 5838 3 noticed notice VBN 40436 5838 4 both both DT 40436 5838 5 passages passage NNS 40436 5838 6 in in IN 40436 5838 7 discussing discuss VBG 40436 5838 8 these these DT 40436 5838 9 two two CD 40436 5838 10 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5838 11 . . . 40436 5838 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5839 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5839 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 5839 3 59 59 CD 40436 5839 4 : : : 40436 5839 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5839 6 , , , 40436 5839 7 De De NNP 40436 5839 8 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5839 9 . . . 40436 5840 1 Elench elench NN 40436 5840 2 . . . 40436 5841 1 ; ; : 40436 5841 2 also also RB 40436 5841 3 Arist Arist NNP 40436 5841 4 . . . 40436 5842 1 Rhet Rhet NNP 40436 5842 2 . . . 40436 5843 1 ii ii LS 40436 5843 2 . . . 40436 5844 1 p. p. NN 40436 5844 2 1401 1401 CD 40436 5844 3 , , , 40436 5844 4 a a DT 40436 5844 5 - - HYPH 40436 5844 6 b b NN 40436 5844 7 . . . 40436 5844 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5845 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5845 2 Side side NN 40436 5845 3 - - HYPH 40436 5845 4 note note NN 40436 5845 5 : : : 40436 5845 6 Mistake mistake NN 40436 5845 7 of of IN 40436 5845 8 supposing suppose VBG 40436 5845 9 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5845 10 to to TO 40436 5845 11 have have VB 40436 5845 12 been be VBN 40436 5845 13 invented invent VBN 40436 5845 14 and and CC 40436 5845 15 propagated propagate VBN 40436 5845 16 by by IN 40436 5845 17 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 5845 18 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5845 19 -- -- : 40436 5845 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5845 21 are be VBP 40436 5845 22 inherent inherent JJ 40436 5845 23 inadvertencies inadvertency NNS 40436 5845 24 and and CC 40436 5845 25 liabilities liability NNS 40436 5845 26 to to TO 40436 5845 27 error error VB 40436 5845 28 , , , 40436 5845 29 in in IN 40436 5845 30 the the DT 40436 5845 31 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 5845 32 process process NN 40436 5845 33 of of IN 40436 5845 34 thinking think VBG 40436 5845 35 . . . 40436 5846 1 Formal formal JJ 40436 5846 2 debate debate NN 40436 5846 3 affords afford VBZ 40436 5846 4 the the DT 40436 5846 5 best good JJS 40436 5846 6 means mean NNS 40436 5846 7 of of IN 40436 5846 8 correcting correct VBG 40436 5846 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5846 10 . . . 40436 5846 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5847 1 The the DT 40436 5847 2 true true JJ 40436 5847 3 character character NN 40436 5847 4 of of IN 40436 5847 5 these these DT 40436 5847 6 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5847 7 is be VBZ 40436 5847 8 very very RB 40436 5847 9 generally generally RB 40436 5847 10 overlooked overlook VBN 40436 5847 11 by by IN 40436 5847 12 the the DT 40436 5847 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5847 14 critics critic NNS 40436 5847 15 , , , 40436 5847 16 in in IN 40436 5847 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5847 18 appreciation appreciation NN 40436 5847 19 of of IN 40436 5847 20 the the DT 40436 5847 21 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5847 22 ; ; : 40436 5847 23 when when WRB 40436 5847 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5847 25 point point VBP 40436 5847 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5847 27 attention attention NN 40436 5847 28 to to IN 40436 5847 29 the the DT 40436 5847 30 supposed suppose VBN 40436 5847 31 tricks trick NNS 40436 5847 32 and and CC 40436 5847 33 frauds fraud NNS 40436 5847 34 of of IN 40436 5847 35 the the DT 40436 5847 36 persons person NNS 40436 5847 37 whom whom WP 40436 5847 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5847 39 called call VBD 40436 5847 40 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5847 41 , , , 40436 5847 42 as as RB 40436 5847 43 well well RB 40436 5847 44 as as IN 40436 5847 45 to to IN 40436 5847 46 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 5847 47 corruptions corruption NNS 40436 5847 48 alleged allege VBN 40436 5847 49 to to TO 40436 5847 50 arise arise VB 40436 5847 51 from from IN 40436 5847 52 Eristic eristic JJ 40436 5847 53 or or CC 40436 5847 54 formal formal JJ 40436 5847 55 contentious contentious JJ 40436 5847 56 debate debate NN 40436 5847 57 . . . 40436 5848 1 These these DT 40436 5848 2 critics critic NNS 40436 5848 3 speak speak VBP 40436 5848 4 as as IN 40436 5848 5 if if IN 40436 5848 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5848 7 thought think VBD 40436 5848 8 that that IN 40436 5848 9 such such JJ 40436 5848 10 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5848 11 were be VBD 40436 5848 12 the the DT 40436 5848 13 special special JJ 40436 5848 14 inventions invention NNS 40436 5848 15 of of IN 40436 5848 16 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 5848 17 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5848 18 for for IN 40436 5848 19 the the DT 40436 5848 20 purposes purpose NNS 40436 5848 21 of of IN 40436 5848 22 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 5848 23 Eristic Eristic NNP 40436 5848 24 : : : 40436 5848 25 as as IN 40436 5848 26 if if IN 40436 5848 27 such such JJ 40436 5848 28 causes cause NNS 40436 5848 29 of of IN 40436 5848 30 error error NN 40436 5848 31 were be VBD 40436 5848 32 inoperative inoperative JJ 40436 5848 33 on on IN 40436 5848 34 persons person NNS 40436 5848 35 of of IN 40436 5848 36 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 5848 37 honesty honesty NN 40436 5848 38 or or CC 40436 5848 39 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5848 40 , , , 40436 5848 41 who who WP 40436 5848 42 never never RB 40436 5848 43 consulted consult VBD 40436 5848 44 or or CC 40436 5848 45 heard hear VBN 40436 5848 46 the the DT 40436 5848 47 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5848 48 . . . 40436 5849 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5849 2 has have VBZ 40436 5849 3 been be VBN 40436 5849 4 the the DT 40436 5849 5 practice practice NN 40436 5849 6 of of IN 40436 5849 7 writers writer NNS 40436 5849 8 on on IN 40436 5849 9 logic logic NN 40436 5849 10 , , , 40436 5849 11 from from IN 40436 5849 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5849 13 down down RP 40436 5849 14 to to IN 40436 5849 15 Whately whately RB 40436 5849 16 , , , 40436 5849 17 to to TO 40436 5849 18 represent represent VB 40436 5849 19 logical logical JJ 40436 5849 20 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5849 21 as as IN 40436 5849 22 frauds fraud NNS 40436 5849 23 devised devise VBD 40436 5849 24 and and CC 40436 5849 25 maintained maintain VBN 40436 5849 26 by by IN 40436 5849 27 dishonest dishonest JJ 40436 5849 28 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 5849 29 , , , 40436 5849 30 whose whose WP$ 40436 5849 31 art art NN 40436 5849 32 Whately whately RB 40436 5849 33 assimilates assimilate VBZ 40436 5849 34 to to IN 40436 5849 35 that that DT 40436 5849 36 of of IN 40436 5849 37 jugglers juggler NNS 40436 5849 38 . . . 40436 5850 1 This this DT 40436 5850 2 view view NN 40436 5850 3 of of IN 40436 5850 4 the the DT 40436 5850 5 case case NN 40436 5850 6 appears appear VBZ 40436 5850 7 to to IN 40436 5850 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 5850 9 incomplete incomplete JJ 40436 5850 10 and and CC 40436 5850 11 misleading misleading JJ 40436 5850 12 . . . 40436 5851 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5851 2 substitutes substitute VBZ 40436 5851 3 the the DT 40436 5851 4 rare rare JJ 40436 5851 5 and and CC 40436 5851 6 accidental accidental JJ 40436 5851 7 in in IN 40436 5851 8 place place NN 40436 5851 9 of of IN 40436 5851 10 the the DT 40436 5851 11 constant constant JJ 40436 5851 12 and and CC 40436 5851 13 essential essential JJ 40436 5851 14 . . . 40436 5852 1 The the DT 40436 5852 2 various various JJ 40436 5852 3 sophisms sophism NNS 40436 5852 4 , , , 40436 5852 5 of of IN 40436 5852 6 which which WDT 40436 5852 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5852 8 in in IN 40436 5852 9 the the DT 40436 5852 10 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5852 11 gives give VBZ 40436 5852 12 the the DT 40436 5852 13 _ _ NNP 40436 5852 14 reductio reductio NN 40436 5852 15 ad ad NN 40436 5852 16 absurdum absurdum NN 40436 5852 17 _ _ NNP 40436 5852 18 , , , 40436 5852 19 are be VBP 40436 5852 20 not not RB 40436 5852 21 the the DT 40436 5852 22 inventions invention NNS 40436 5852 23 of of IN 40436 5852 24 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5852 25 . . . 40436 5853 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5853 2 are be VBP 40436 5853 3 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 5853 4 tendencies tendency NNS 40436 5853 5 of of IN 40436 5853 6 the the DT 40436 5853 7 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5853 8 process process NN 40436 5853 9 , , , 40436 5853 10 frequently frequently RB 40436 5853 11 incident incident VBP 40436 5853 12 to to IN 40436 5853 13 human human JJ 40436 5853 14 thought thought NN 40436 5853 15 and and CC 40436 5853 16 speech speech NN 40436 5853 17 : : : 40436 5853 18 specimens specimen NNS 40436 5853 19 of of IN 40436 5853 20 those those DT 40436 5853 21 ever ever RB 40436 5853 22 - - HYPH 40436 5853 23 renewed renew VBN 40436 5853 24 " " '' 40436 5853 25 inadvertencies inadvertency NNS 40436 5853 26 of of IN 40436 5853 27 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 5853 28 thinking thinking NN 40436 5853 29 " " '' 40436 5853 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5853 31 to to TO 40436 5853 32 recur recur VB 40436 5853 33 to to IN 40436 5853 34 a a DT 40436 5853 35 phrase phrase NN 40436 5853 36 cited cite VBN 40436 5853 37 in in IN 40436 5853 38 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5853 39 preface preface NN 40436 5853 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5853 41 , , , 40436 5853 42 which which WDT 40436 5853 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5853 44 is be VBZ 40436 5853 45 the the DT 40436 5853 46 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 5853 47 mission mission NN 40436 5853 48 of of IN 40436 5853 49 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5853 50 or or CC 40436 5853 51 " " `` 40436 5853 52 reasoned reasoned JJ 40436 5853 53 truth truth NN 40436 5853 54 " " '' 40436 5853 55 to to TO 40436 5853 56 rectify rectify VB 40436 5853 57 . . . 40436 5854 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 5854 2 the the DT 40436 5854 3 practice practice NN 40436 5854 4 of of IN 40436 5854 5 formal formal JJ 40436 5854 6 debate debate NN 40436 5854 7 , , , 40436 5854 8 which which WDT 40436 5854 9 is be VBZ 40436 5854 10 usually usually RB 40436 5854 11 denounced denounce VBN 40436 5854 12 with with IN 40436 5854 13 so so RB 40436 5854 14 much much JJ 40436 5854 15 asperity asperity NN 40436 5854 16 -- -- : 40436 5854 17 if if IN 40436 5854 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5854 19 affords afford VBZ 40436 5854 20 on on IN 40436 5854 21 some some DT 40436 5854 22 occasions occasion NNS 40436 5854 23 opportunity opportunity NN 40436 5854 24 to to TO 40436 5854 25 produce produce VB 40436 5854 26 such such JJ 40436 5854 27 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5854 28 , , , 40436 5854 29 presents present VBZ 40436 5854 30 not not RB 40436 5854 31 merely merely RB 40436 5854 32 equal equal JJ 40436 5854 33 opportunity opportunity NN 40436 5854 34 , , , 40436 5854 35 but but CC 40436 5854 36 the the DT 40436 5854 37 only only JJ 40436 5854 38 effective effective JJ 40436 5854 39 means mean NNS 40436 5854 40 , , , 40436 5854 41 for for IN 40436 5854 42 exposing expose VBG 40436 5854 43 and and CC 40436 5854 44 confuting confute VBG 40436 5854 45 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5854 46 . . . 40436 5855 1 Whately whately RB 40436 5855 2 in in IN 40436 5855 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5855 4 Logic,[60 logic,[60 NN 40436 5855 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5855 6 like like IN 40436 5855 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5855 8 in in IN 40436 5855 9 the the DT 40436 5855 10 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5855 11 , , , 40436 5855 12 when when WRB 40436 5855 13 bringing bring VBG 40436 5855 14 these these DT 40436 5855 15 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5855 16 into into IN 40436 5855 17 open open JJ 40436 5855 18 daylight daylight NN 40436 5855 19 in in IN 40436 5855 20 order order NN 40436 5855 21 that that IN 40436 5855 22 every every DT 40436 5855 23 one one NN 40436 5855 24 may may MD 40436 5855 25 detect detect VB 40436 5855 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5855 27 , , , 40436 5855 28 may may MD 40436 5855 29 enliven enliven VB 40436 5855 30 the the DT 40436 5855 31 theme theme NN 40436 5855 32 by by IN 40436 5855 33 presenting present VBG 40436 5855 34 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5855 35 as as IN 40436 5855 36 the the DT 40436 5855 37 deliberate deliberate JJ 40436 5855 38 tricks trick NNS 40436 5855 39 of of IN 40436 5855 40 a a DT 40436 5855 41 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 5855 42 . . . 40436 5856 1 Doubtless doubtless RB 40436 5856 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5856 3 are be VBP 40436 5856 4 so so RB 40436 5856 5 by by IN 40436 5856 6 accident accident NN 40436 5856 7 : : : 40436 5856 8 yet yet CC 40436 5856 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5856 10 essential essential JJ 40436 5856 11 character character NN 40436 5856 12 is be VBZ 40436 5856 13 that that DT 40436 5856 14 of of IN 40436 5856 15 infirmities infirmity NNS 40436 5856 16 incident incident NN 40436 5856 17 to to IN 40436 5856 18 the the DT 40436 5856 19 _ _ NNP 40436 5856 20 intellectus intellectus NN 40436 5856 21 sibi sibi NNP 40436 5856 22 permissus permissus NNP 40436 5856 23 _ _ NNP 40436 5856 24 : : : 40436 5856 25 operative operative NN 40436 5856 26 at at IN 40436 5856 27 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5856 28 before before IN 40436 5856 29 Athenian Athenian NNP 40436 5856 30 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5856 31 existed exist VBD 40436 5856 32 , , , 40436 5856 33 and and CC 40436 5856 34 in in IN 40436 5856 35 other other JJ 40436 5856 36 regions region NNS 40436 5856 37 also also RB 40436 5856 38 , , , 40436 5856 39 where where WRB 40436 5856 40 these these DT 40436 5856 41 persons person NNS 40436 5856 42 never never RB 40436 5856 43 penetrated penetrate VBD 40436 5856 44 . . . 40436 5856 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5857 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5857 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5857 3 60 60 CD 40436 5857 4 : : : 40436 5857 5 Whately whately RB 40436 5857 6 's 's POS 40436 5857 7 Logic logic NN 40436 5857 8 , , , 40436 5857 9 ch ch NN 40436 5857 10 . . . 40436 5858 1 v. v. CC 40436 5858 2 sect sect NNP 40436 5858 3 . . . 40436 5859 1 5 5 CD 40436 5859 2 . . . 40436 5860 1 Though though IN 40436 5860 2 Whately whately RB 40436 5860 3 , , , 40436 5860 4 like like IN 40436 5860 5 other other JJ 40436 5860 6 logicians logicians NNPS 40436 5860 7 , , , 40436 5860 8 keeps keep VBZ 40436 5860 9 the the DT 40436 5860 10 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5860 11 in in IN 40436 5860 12 the the DT 40436 5860 13 foreground foreground NN 40436 5860 14 , , , 40436 5860 15 as as IN 40436 5860 16 the the DT 40436 5860 17 fraudulent fraudulent JJ 40436 5860 18 enemy enemy NN 40436 5860 19 who who WP 40436 5860 20 sow sow VBP 40436 5860 21 tares tare NNS 40436 5860 22 among among IN 40436 5860 23 that that DT 40436 5860 24 which which WDT 40436 5860 25 would would MD 40436 5860 26 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 5860 27 come come VB 40436 5860 28 up up RP 40436 5860 29 as as IN 40436 5860 30 a a DT 40436 5860 31 clean clean JJ 40436 5860 32 crop crop NN 40436 5860 33 of of IN 40436 5860 34 wheat wheat NN 40436 5860 35 -- -- : 40436 5860 36 yet yet CC 40436 5860 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5860 38 intimates intimate VBZ 40436 5860 39 also also RB 40436 5860 40 incidentally incidentally RB 40436 5860 41 how how WRB 40436 5860 42 widespread widespread JJ 40436 5860 43 and and CC 40436 5860 44 frequent frequent JJ 40436 5860 45 such such JJ 40436 5860 46 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5860 47 are be VBP 40436 5860 48 , , , 40436 5860 49 quite quite RB 40436 5860 50 apart apart RB 40436 5860 51 from from IN 40436 5860 52 dishonest dishonest JJ 40436 5860 53 design design NN 40436 5860 54 . . . 40436 5861 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5861 2 says--"It says--"it NN 40436 5861 3 seems seem VBZ 40436 5861 4 by by IN 40436 5861 5 most most JJS 40436 5861 6 persons person NNS 40436 5861 7 to to TO 40436 5861 8 be be VB 40436 5861 9 taken take VBN 40436 5861 10 for for IN 40436 5861 11 granted grant VBN 40436 5861 12 , , , 40436 5861 13 that that IN 40436 5861 14 a a DT 40436 5861 15 Fallacy Fallacy NNP 40436 5861 16 is be VBZ 40436 5861 17 to to TO 40436 5861 18 be be VB 40436 5861 19 dreaded dread VBN 40436 5861 20 merely merely RB 40436 5861 21 as as IN 40436 5861 22 a a DT 40436 5861 23 weapon weapon NN 40436 5861 24 fashioned fashion VBN 40436 5861 25 and and CC 40436 5861 26 wielded wield VBN 40436 5861 27 by by IN 40436 5861 28 a a DT 40436 5861 29 skilful skilful JJ 40436 5861 30 Sophist sophist NN 40436 5861 31 : : : 40436 5861 32 or or CC 40436 5861 33 , , , 40436 5861 34 if if IN 40436 5861 35 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5861 36 allow allow VBP 40436 5861 37 that that IN 40436 5861 38 a a DT 40436 5861 39 man man NN 40436 5861 40 may may MD 40436 5861 41 with with IN 40436 5861 42 honest honest JJ 40436 5861 43 intentions intention NNS 40436 5861 44 slide slide VB 40436 5861 45 into into IN 40436 5861 46 one one CD 40436 5861 47 , , , 40436 5861 48 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 5861 49 , , , 40436 5861 50 in in IN 40436 5861 51 the the DT 40436 5861 52 heat heat NN 40436 5861 53 of of IN 40436 5861 54 _ _ NNP 40436 5861 55 argument_--still argument_--still NN 40436 5861 56 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5861 57 seem seem VBP 40436 5861 58 to to TO 40436 5861 59 suppose suppose VB 40436 5861 60 , , , 40436 5861 61 that that IN 40436 5861 62 where where WRB 40436 5861 63 there there EX 40436 5861 64 is be VBZ 40436 5861 65 no no DT 40436 5861 66 _ _ NNP 40436 5861 67 dispute dispute NN 40436 5861 68 _ _ NNP 40436 5861 69 , , , 40436 5861 70 there there EX 40436 5861 71 is be VBZ 40436 5861 72 no no DT 40436 5861 73 cause cause NN 40436 5861 74 to to TO 40436 5861 75 dread dread VB 40436 5861 76 Fallacy Fallacy NNP 40436 5861 77 . . . 40436 5862 1 Whereas whereas IN 40436 5862 2 there there EX 40436 5862 3 is be VBZ 40436 5862 4 much much JJ 40436 5862 5 danger danger NN 40436 5862 6 , , , 40436 5862 7 even even RB 40436 5862 8 in in IN 40436 5862 9 what what WP 40436 5862 10 may may MD 40436 5862 11 be be VB 40436 5862 12 called call VBN 40436 5862 13 _ _ NNP 40436 5862 14 solitary solitary JJ 40436 5862 15 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5862 16 _ _ NNP 40436 5862 17 , , , 40436 5862 18 of of IN 40436 5862 19 sliding slide VBG 40436 5862 20 unawares unaware NNS 40436 5862 21 into into IN 40436 5862 22 some some DT 40436 5862 23 Fallacy Fallacy NNP 40436 5862 24 , , , 40436 5862 25 by by IN 40436 5862 26 which which WDT 40436 5862 27 one one PRP 40436 5862 28 may may MD 40436 5862 29 be be VB 40436 5862 30 so so RB 40436 5862 31 far far RB 40436 5862 32 deceived deceive VBN 40436 5862 33 as as IN 40436 5862 34 even even RB 40436 5862 35 to to TO 40436 5862 36 act act VB 40436 5862 37 upon upon IN 40436 5862 38 the the DT 40436 5862 39 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5862 40 so so RB 40436 5862 41 obtained obtain VBN 40436 5862 42 . . . 40436 5863 1 By by IN 40436 5863 2 _ _ NNP 40436 5863 3 solitary solitary JJ 40436 5863 4 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5863 5 _ _ NNP 40436 5863 6 , , , 40436 5863 7 is be VBZ 40436 5863 8 meant mean VBN 40436 5863 9 the the DT 40436 5863 10 case case NN 40436 5863 11 in in IN 40436 5863 12 which which WDT 40436 5863 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5863 14 are be VBP 40436 5863 15 not not RB 40436 5863 16 seeking seek VBG 40436 5863 17 for for IN 40436 5863 18 arguments argument NNS 40436 5863 19 to to TO 40436 5863 20 prove prove VB 40436 5863 21 a a DT 40436 5863 22 given give VBN 40436 5863 23 question question NN 40436 5863 24 , , , 40436 5863 25 but but CC 40436 5863 26 labouring labour VBG 40436 5863 27 to to IN 40436 5863 28 elicit elicit NN 40436 5863 29 from from IN 40436 5863 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5863 31 previous previous JJ 40436 5863 32 stock stock NN 40436 5863 33 of of IN 40436 5863 34 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5863 35 some some DT 40436 5863 36 useful useful JJ 40436 5863 37 inference inference NN 40436 5863 38 . . . 40436 5863 39 " " '' 40436 5864 1 " " `` 40436 5864 2 To to TO 40436 5864 3 speak speak VB 40436 5864 4 of of IN 40436 5864 5 all all PDT 40436 5864 6 the the DT 40436 5864 7 Fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5864 8 that that WDT 40436 5864 9 have have VBP 40436 5864 10 ever ever RB 40436 5864 11 been be VBN 40436 5864 12 enumerated enumerate VBN 40436 5864 13 , , , 40436 5864 14 as as IN 40436 5864 15 too too RB 40436 5864 16 glaring glaring JJ 40436 5864 17 and and CC 40436 5864 18 obvious obvious JJ 40436 5864 19 to to TO 40436 5864 20 need need VB 40436 5864 21 even even RB 40436 5864 22 being be VBG 40436 5864 23 mentioned mention VBN 40436 5864 24 -- -- : 40436 5864 25 because because IN 40436 5864 26 the the DT 40436 5864 27 simple simple JJ 40436 5864 28 instances instance NNS 40436 5864 29 given give VBN 40436 5864 30 in in IN 40436 5864 31 books book NNS 40436 5864 32 , , , 40436 5864 33 and and CC 40436 5864 34 there there RB 40436 5864 35 stated state VBD 40436 5864 36 in in IN 40436 5864 37 the the DT 40436 5864 38 plainest plain JJS 40436 5864 39 and and CC 40436 5864 40 consequently consequently RB 40436 5864 41 most most RBS 40436 5864 42 easily easily RB 40436 5864 43 detected detect VBN 40436 5864 44 form form NN 40436 5864 45 , , , 40436 5864 46 are be VBP 40436 5864 47 such such JJ 40436 5864 48 as as IN 40436 5864 49 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5864 50 in in IN 40436 5864 51 that that DT 40436 5864 52 form form NN 40436 5864 53 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5864 54 would would MD 40436 5864 55 deceive deceive VB 40436 5864 56 no no DT 40436 5864 57 one one NN 40436 5864 58 -- -- : 40436 5864 59 this this DT 40436 5864 60 , , , 40436 5864 61 surely surely RB 40436 5864 62 , , , 40436 5864 63 shows show VBZ 40436 5864 64 either either CC 40436 5864 65 extreme extreme JJ 40436 5864 66 weakness weakness NN 40436 5864 67 or or CC 40436 5864 68 extreme extreme JJ 40436 5864 69 unfairness unfairness NN 40436 5864 70 . . . 40436 5864 71 " " '' 40436 5865 1 --Aristotle --Aristotle : 40436 5865 2 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5865 3 makes make VBZ 40436 5865 4 the the DT 40436 5865 5 same same JJ 40436 5865 6 remark remark NN 40436 5865 7 as as IN 40436 5865 8 Whately whately RB 40436 5865 9 -- -- : 40436 5865 10 That that IN 40436 5865 11 the the DT 40436 5865 12 man man NN 40436 5865 13 who who WP 40436 5865 14 is be VBZ 40436 5865 15 easily easily RB 40436 5865 16 taken take VBN 40436 5865 17 in in RP 40436 5865 18 by by IN 40436 5865 19 a a DT 40436 5865 20 Fallacy Fallacy NNP 40436 5865 21 advanced advance VBN 40436 5865 22 by by IN 40436 5865 23 another another DT 40436 5865 24 , , , 40436 5865 25 will will MD 40436 5865 26 be be VB 40436 5865 27 easily easily RB 40436 5865 28 misled mislead VBN 40436 5865 29 by by IN 40436 5865 30 the the DT 40436 5865 31 like like IN 40436 5865 32 Fallacy Fallacy NNP 40436 5865 33 in in IN 40436 5865 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5865 35 own own JJ 40436 5865 36 solitary solitary JJ 40436 5865 37 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5865 38 . . . 40436 5866 1 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 5866 2 . . . 40436 5867 1 Elench elench NN 40436 5867 2 . . . 40436 5868 1 16 16 CD 40436 5868 2 , , , 40436 5868 3 175 175 CD 40436 5868 4 , , , 40436 5868 5 a. a. NN 40436 5869 1 10 10 CD 40436 5869 2 . . . 40436 5869 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5870 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5870 2 Side side NN 40436 5870 3 - - HYPH 40436 5870 4 note note NN 40436 5870 5 : : : 40436 5870 6 Wide wide JJ 40436 5870 7 - - HYPH 40436 5870 8 spread spread VBN 40436 5870 9 prevalence prevalence NN 40436 5870 10 of of IN 40436 5870 11 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 5870 12 belief belief NN 40436 5870 13 , , , 40436 5870 14 misguided misguide VBN 40436 5870 15 by by IN 40436 5870 16 one one CD 40436 5870 17 or or CC 40436 5870 18 other other JJ 40436 5870 19 of of IN 40436 5870 20 these these DT 40436 5870 21 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5870 22 , , , 40436 5870 23 attested attest VBN 40436 5870 24 by by IN 40436 5870 25 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5870 26 , , , 40436 5870 27 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5870 28 , , , 40436 5870 29 Bacon Bacon NNP 40436 5870 30 , , , 40436 5870 31 & & CC 40436 5870 32 c c NNP 40436 5870 33 . . . 40436 5870 34 ,--complete ,--complete , 40436 5870 35 enumeration enumeration NN 40436 5870 36 of of IN 40436 5870 37 heads head NNS 40436 5870 38 of of IN 40436 5870 39 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5870 40 by by IN 40436 5870 41 Mill Mill NNP 40436 5870 42 . . . 40436 5870 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5871 1 The the DT 40436 5871 2 wide wide JJ 40436 5871 3 diffusion diffusion NN 40436 5871 4 and and CC 40436 5871 5 constant constant JJ 40436 5871 6 prevalence prevalence NN 40436 5871 7 of of IN 40436 5871 8 such such JJ 40436 5871 9 infirmities infirmity NNS 40436 5871 10 is be VBZ 40436 5871 11 attested attest VBN 40436 5871 12 not not RB 40436 5871 13 less less JJR 40436 5871 14 by by IN 40436 5871 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5871 16 in in IN 40436 5871 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5871 18 last last JJ 40436 5871 19 speech speech NN 40436 5871 20 , , , 40436 5871 21 wherein wherein WRB 40436 5871 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5871 23 declares declare VBZ 40436 5871 24 real real JJ 40436 5871 25 want want NN 40436 5871 26 of of IN 40436 5871 27 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5871 28 and and CC 40436 5871 29 false false JJ 40436 5871 30 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 5871 31 of of IN 40436 5871 32 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5871 33 , , , 40436 5871 34 to to TO 40436 5871 35 be be VB 40436 5871 36 universal universal JJ 40436 5871 37 , , , 40436 5871 38 the the DT 40436 5871 39 mission mission NN 40436 5871 40 of of IN 40436 5871 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5871 42 life life NN 40436 5871 43 being be VBG 40436 5871 44 to to TO 40436 5871 45 expose expose VB 40436 5871 46 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5871 47 , , , 40436 5871 48 though though IN 40436 5871 49 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5871 50 could could MD 40436 5871 51 not not RB 40436 5871 52 correct correct VB 40436 5871 53 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5871 54 -- -- : 40436 5871 55 than than IN 40436 5871 56 by by IN 40436 5871 57 Bacon Bacon NNP 40436 5871 58 in in IN 40436 5871 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5871 60 reformatory reformatory JJ 40436 5871 61 projects project NNS 40436 5871 62 , , , 40436 5871 63 where where WRB 40436 5871 64 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5871 65 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 5871 66 the the DT 40436 5871 67 various various JJ 40436 5871 68 Idola Idola NNP 40436 5871 69 worshipped worship VBN 40436 5871 70 by by IN 40436 5871 71 the the DT 40436 5871 72 human human JJ 40436 5871 73 intellect intellect NN 40436 5871 74 , , , 40436 5871 75 and and CC 40436 5871 76 the the DT 40436 5871 77 false false JJ 40436 5871 78 tendencies tendency NNS 40436 5871 79 acquired acquire VBD 40436 5871 80 " " `` 40436 5871 81 _ _ NNP 40436 5871 82 in in IN 40436 5871 83 primâ primâ JJ 40436 5871 84 digestione digestione NNP 40436 5871 85 mentis mentis NNP 40436 5871 86 _ _ NNP 40436 5871 87 " " '' 40436 5871 88 . . . 40436 5872 1 The the DT 40436 5872 2 psychological psychological JJ 40436 5872 3 analysis analysis NN 40436 5872 4 of of IN 40436 5872 5 the the DT 40436 5872 6 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 5872 7 of of IN 40436 5872 8 belief belief NN 40436 5872 9 with with IN 40436 5872 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5872 11 different different JJ 40436 5872 12 sources source NNS 40436 5872 13 , , , 40436 5872 14 given give VBN 40436 5872 15 in in IN 40436 5872 16 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5872 17 Alexander Alexander NNP 40436 5872 18 Bain Bain NNP 40436 5872 19 's 's POS 40436 5872 20 work work NN 40436 5872 21 on on IN 40436 5872 22 the the DT 40436 5872 23 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 5872 24 and and CC 40436 5872 25 the the DT 40436 5872 26 Will Will NNP 40436 5872 27 , , , 40436 5872 28 shows show VBZ 40436 5872 29 how how WRB 40436 5872 30 this this DT 40436 5872 31 takes take VBZ 40436 5872 32 place place NN 40436 5872 33 ; ; : 40436 5872 34 and and CC 40436 5872 35 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 5872 36 true true JJ 40436 5872 37 or or CC 40436 5872 38 sound sound JJ 40436 5872 39 belief belief NN 40436 5872 40 , , , 40436 5872 41 in in IN 40436 5872 42 so so RB 40436 5872 43 far far RB 40436 5872 44 as as IN 40436 5872 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5872 46 ever ever RB 40436 5872 47 is be VBZ 40436 5872 48 acquired acquire VBN 40436 5872 49 , , , 40436 5872 50 as as IN 40436 5872 51 an an DT 40436 5872 52 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 5872 53 only only RB 40436 5872 54 attained attain VBD 40436 5872 55 after after IN 40436 5872 56 expulsion expulsion NN 40436 5872 57 of of IN 40436 5872 58 earlier early JJR 40436 5872 59 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 5872 60 error error NN 40436 5872 61 . . . 40436 5873 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5873 2 61 61 CD 40436 5873 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5873 4 Of of IN 40436 5873 5 such such JJ 40436 5873 6 error error NN 40436 5873 7 , , , 40436 5873 8 and and CC 40436 5873 9 of of IN 40436 5873 10 the the DT 40436 5873 11 different different JJ 40436 5873 12 ways way NNS 40436 5873 13 in in IN 40436 5873 14 which which WDT 40436 5873 15 apparent apparent JJ 40436 5873 16 evidence evidence NN 40436 5873 17 is be VBZ 40436 5873 18 mistaken mistake VBN 40436 5873 19 for for IN 40436 5873 20 real real JJ 40436 5873 21 evidence evidence NN 40436 5873 22 , , , 40436 5873 23 a a DT 40436 5873 24 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 5873 25 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 5873 26 exposition exposition NN 40436 5873 27 is be VBZ 40436 5873 28 farther farther RB 40436 5873 29 given give VBN 40436 5873 30 by by IN 40436 5873 31 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5873 32 John John NNP 40436 5873 33 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 5873 34 Mill Mill NNP 40436 5873 35 , , , 40436 5873 36 in in IN 40436 5873 37 the the DT 40436 5873 38 fifth fifth JJ 40436 5873 39 book book NN 40436 5873 40 of of IN 40436 5873 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5873 42 System System NNP 40436 5873 43 of of IN 40436 5873 44 Logic Logic NNP 40436 5873 45 , , , 40436 5873 46 devoted devote VBN 40436 5873 47 to to IN 40436 5873 48 the the DT 40436 5873 49 subject subject NN 40436 5873 50 of of IN 40436 5873 51 Fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5873 52 . . . 40436 5874 1 Every every DT 40436 5874 2 variety variety NN 40436 5874 3 of of IN 40436 5874 4 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 5874 5 procedure procedure NN 40436 5874 6 is be VBZ 40436 5874 7 referable referable JJ 40436 5874 8 to to IN 40436 5874 9 some some DT 40436 5874 10 one one NN 40436 5874 11 or or CC 40436 5874 12 more more JJR 40436 5874 13 of of IN 40436 5874 14 the the DT 40436 5874 15 general general JJ 40436 5874 16 heads head NNS 40436 5874 17 of of IN 40436 5874 18 Fallacy Fallacy NNP 40436 5874 19 there there RB 40436 5874 20 enumerated enumerate VBD 40436 5874 21 . . . 40436 5875 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5875 2 is be VBZ 40436 5875 3 the the DT 40436 5875 4 Fallacies Fallacies NNPS 40436 5875 5 of of IN 40436 5875 6 Ratiocination Ratiocination NNP 40436 5875 7 , , , 40436 5875 8 of of IN 40436 5875 9 which which WDT 40436 5875 10 the the DT 40436 5875 11 two two CD 40436 5875 12 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5875 13 , , , 40436 5875 14 in in IN 40436 5875 15 the the DT 40436 5875 16 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 5875 17 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5875 18 , , , 40436 5875 19 are be VBP 40436 5875 20 made make VBN 40436 5875 21 to to TO 40436 5875 22 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 5875 23 specimens specimen NNS 40436 5875 24 : : : 40436 5875 25 and and CC 40436 5875 26 when when WRB 40436 5875 27 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5875 28 regard regard VBP 40436 5875 29 such such JJ 40436 5875 30 Fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5875 31 , , , 40436 5875 32 as as IN 40436 5875 33 one one CD 40436 5875 34 branch branch NN 40436 5875 35 among among IN 40436 5875 36 several several JJ 40436 5875 37 in in IN 40436 5875 38 a a DT 40436 5875 39 complete complete JJ 40436 5875 40 logical logical JJ 40436 5875 41 scheme scheme NN 40436 5875 42 , , , 40436 5875 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5875 44 shall shall MD 40436 5875 45 see see VB 40436 5875 46 at at IN 40436 5875 47 once once RB 40436 5875 48 that that IN 40436 5875 49 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5875 50 are be VBP 40436 5875 51 not not RB 40436 5875 52 inventions invention NNS 40436 5875 53 of of IN 40436 5875 54 the the DT 40436 5875 55 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 5875 56 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5875 57 -- -- : 40436 5875 58 still still RB 40436 5875 59 less less JJR 40436 5875 60 inventions invention NNS 40436 5875 61 for for IN 40436 5875 62 the the DT 40436 5875 63 purpose purpose NN 40436 5875 64 of of IN 40436 5875 65 Eristic eristic JJ 40436 5875 66 or or CC 40436 5875 67 formal formal JJ 40436 5875 68 debate debate NN 40436 5875 69 . . . 40436 5876 1 For for IN 40436 5876 2 every every DT 40436 5876 3 one one CD 40436 5876 4 of of IN 40436 5876 5 these these DT 40436 5876 6 Fallacies Fallacies NNPS 40436 5876 7 is be VBZ 40436 5876 8 of of IN 40436 5876 9 a a DT 40436 5876 10 nature nature NN 40436 5876 11 to to TO 40436 5876 12 ensnare ensnare VB 40436 5876 13 men man NNS 40436 5876 14 , , , 40436 5876 15 and and CC 40436 5876 16 even even RB 40436 5876 17 to to TO 40436 5876 18 ensnare ensnare VB 40436 5876 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5876 20 more more RBR 40436 5876 21 easily easily RB 40436 5876 22 , , , 40436 5876 23 in in IN 40436 5876 24 the the DT 40436 5876 25 common common JJ 40436 5876 26 , , , 40436 5876 27 informal informal JJ 40436 5876 28 , , , 40436 5876 29 conversation conversation NN 40436 5876 30 of of IN 40436 5876 31 life life NN 40436 5876 32 -- -- : 40436 5876 33 or or CC 40436 5876 34 in in IN 40436 5876 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5876 36 separate separate JJ 40436 5876 37 thoughts thought NNS 40436 5876 38 . . . 40436 5877 1 Besides besides IN 40436 5877 2 mistakes mistake NNS 40436 5877 3 on on IN 40436 5877 4 matters matter NNS 40436 5877 5 of of IN 40436 5877 6 fact fact NN 40436 5877 7 , , , 40436 5877 8 the the DT 40436 5877 9 two two CD 40436 5877 10 main main JJ 40436 5877 11 causes cause NNS 40436 5877 12 which which WDT 40436 5877 13 promote promote VBP 40436 5877 14 the the DT 40436 5877 15 success success NN 40436 5877 16 and and CC 40436 5877 17 encourage encourage VB 40436 5877 18 the the DT 40436 5877 19 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 5877 20 of of IN 40436 5877 21 Fallacies Fallacies NNPS 40436 5877 22 generally generally RB 40436 5877 23 , , , 40436 5877 24 are be VBP 40436 5877 25 first first JJ 40436 5877 26 , , , 40436 5877 27 the the DT 40436 5877 28 emotional emotional JJ 40436 5877 29 bias bias NN 40436 5877 30 towards towards IN 40436 5877 31 particular particular JJ 40436 5877 32 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 5877 33 , , , 40436 5877 34 which which WDT 40436 5877 35 disposes dispose VBZ 40436 5877 36 persons person NNS 40436 5877 37 to to TO 40436 5877 38 accept accept VB 40436 5877 39 any any DT 40436 5877 40 apparent apparent JJ 40436 5877 41 evidence evidence NN 40436 5877 42 , , , 40436 5877 43 favourable favourable JJ 40436 5877 44 to to IN 40436 5877 45 such such JJ 40436 5877 46 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5877 47 , , , 40436 5877 48 as as IN 40436 5877 49 if if IN 40436 5877 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5877 51 , , , 40436 5877 52 were be VBD 40436 5877 53 real real JJ 40436 5877 54 evidence evidence NN 40436 5877 55 : : : 40436 5877 56 next next RB 40436 5877 57 , , , 40436 5877 58 the the DT 40436 5877 59 careless careless JJ 40436 5877 60 and and CC 40436 5877 61 elliptical elliptical JJ 40436 5877 62 character character NN 40436 5877 63 of of IN 40436 5877 64 common common JJ 40436 5877 65 speech speech NN 40436 5877 66 , , , 40436 5877 67 in in IN 40436 5877 68 which which WDT 40436 5877 69 some some DT 40436 5877 70 parts part NNS 40436 5877 71 of of IN 40436 5877 72 the the DT 40436 5877 73 evidence evidence NN 40436 5877 74 are be VBP 40436 5877 75 merely merely RB 40436 5877 76 insinuated insinuate VBN 40436 5877 77 , , , 40436 5877 78 and and CC 40436 5877 79 other other JJ 40436 5877 80 parts part NNS 40436 5877 81 altogether altogether RB 40436 5877 82 left leave VBD 40436 5877 83 out out RP 40436 5877 84 . . . 40436 5878 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5878 2 is be VBZ 40436 5878 3 this this DT 40436 5878 4 last last JJ 40436 5878 5 circumstance circumstance NN 40436 5878 6 which which WDT 40436 5878 7 gives give VBZ 40436 5878 8 occasion occasion NN 40436 5878 9 to to IN 40436 5878 10 the the DT 40436 5878 11 very very RB 40436 5878 12 extensive extensive JJ 40436 5878 13 class class NN 40436 5878 14 of of IN 40436 5878 15 Fallacies Fallacies NNPS 40436 5878 16 called call VBN 40436 5878 17 by by IN 40436 5878 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5878 19 Mill Mill NNP 40436 5878 20 Fallacies Fallacies NNPS 40436 5878 21 of of IN 40436 5878 22 Confusion Confusion NNP 40436 5878 23 : : : 40436 5878 24 a a DT 40436 5878 25 class class NN 40436 5878 26 so so RB 40436 5878 27 large large JJ 40436 5878 28 , , , 40436 5878 29 that that IN 40436 5878 30 the the DT 40436 5878 31 greater great JJR 40436 5878 32 number number NN 40436 5878 33 of of IN 40436 5878 34 Fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5878 35 might may MD 40436 5878 36 plausibly plausibly RB 40436 5878 37 be be VB 40436 5878 38 brought bring VBN 40436 5878 39 under under IN 40436 5878 40 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5878 41 . . . 40436 5879 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5879 2 62 62 CD 40436 5879 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5879 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5879 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5879 6 61 61 CD 40436 5879 7 : : : 40436 5879 8 See see VB 40436 5879 9 the the DT 40436 5879 10 instructive instructive JJ 40436 5879 11 and and CC 40436 5879 12 original original JJ 40436 5879 13 chapter chapter NN 40436 5879 14 on on IN 40436 5879 15 the the DT 40436 5879 16 generation generation NN 40436 5879 17 , , , 40436 5879 18 sources source NNS 40436 5879 19 , , , 40436 5879 20 and and CC 40436 5879 21 growth growth NN 40436 5879 22 of of IN 40436 5879 23 Belief Belief NNP 40436 5879 24 , , , 40436 5879 25 in in IN 40436 5879 26 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5879 27 Bain Bain NNP 40436 5879 28 's 's POS 40436 5879 29 work work NN 40436 5879 30 , , , 40436 5879 31 ' ' '' 40436 5879 32 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 5879 33 and and CC 40436 5879 34 Will Will MD 40436 5879 35 , , , 40436 5879 36 ' ' '' 40436 5879 37 p. p. NN 40436 5879 38 568 568 CD 40436 5879 39 seq seq NN 40436 5879 40 . . . 40436 5880 1 After after IN 40436 5880 2 laying lay VBG 40436 5880 3 down down RP 40436 5880 4 the the DT 40436 5880 5 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 5880 6 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 5880 7 of of IN 40436 5880 8 Belief Belief NNP 40436 5880 9 , , , 40436 5880 10 as as IN 40436 5880 11 referable referable JJ 40436 5880 12 altogether altogether RB 40436 5880 13 to to IN 40436 5880 14 intended intended JJ 40436 5880 15 action action NN 40436 5880 16 , , , 40436 5880 17 either either CC 40436 5880 18 certain certain JJ 40436 5880 19 to to TO 40436 5880 20 come come VB 40436 5880 21 , , , 40436 5880 22 or or CC 40436 5880 23 contingent contingent NN 40436 5880 24 under under IN 40436 5880 25 supposed suppose VBN 40436 5880 26 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 5880 27 , , , 40436 5880 28 and and CC 40436 5880 29 after after IN 40436 5880 30 enumerating enumerate VBG 40436 5880 31 the the DT 40436 5880 32 different different JJ 40436 5880 33 Sources source NNS 40436 5880 34 of of IN 40436 5880 35 Belief.--1 Belief.--1 NNP 40436 5880 36 . . . 40436 5881 1 Intuitive intuitive JJ 40436 5881 2 or or CC 40436 5881 3 Instinctive Instinctive NNP 40436 5881 4 . . . 40436 5882 1 2 2 LS 40436 5882 2 . . . 40436 5883 1 Experience experience NN 40436 5883 2 . . . 40436 5884 1 3 3 LS 40436 5884 2 . . . 40436 5885 1 The the DT 40436 5885 2 Influence Influence NNP 40436 5885 3 of of IN 40436 5885 4 the the DT 40436 5885 5 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 5885 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5885 7 sect sect JJ 40436 5885 8 . . . 40436 5886 1 x. x. NNP 40436 5886 2 p. p. NN 40436 5886 3 579)--Mr 579)--mr CD 40436 5886 4 . . . 40436 5886 5 Bain Bain NNP 40436 5886 6 says say VBZ 40436 5886 7 : : : 40436 5886 8 " " `` 40436 5886 9 Having have VBG 40436 5886 10 in in IN 40436 5886 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5886 12 constitution constitution NN 40436 5886 13 primordial primordial JJ 40436 5886 14 fountains fountain NNS 40436 5886 15 of of IN 40436 5886 16 activity activity NN 40436 5886 17 in in IN 40436 5886 18 the the DT 40436 5886 19 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 40436 5886 20 and and CC 40436 5886 21 voluntary voluntary JJ 40436 5886 22 impulses impulse NNS 40436 5886 23 , , , 40436 5886 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5886 25 follow follow VBP 40436 5886 26 the the DT 40436 5886 27 first first JJ 40436 5886 28 clue clue NN 40436 5886 29 that that WDT 40436 5886 30 experience experience NN 40436 5886 31 gives give VBZ 40436 5886 32 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5886 33 , , , 40436 5886 34 and and CC 40436 5886 35 accept accept VB 40436 5886 36 the the DT 40436 5886 37 indication indication NN 40436 5886 38 with with IN 40436 5886 39 the the DT 40436 5886 40 whole whole JJ 40436 5886 41 force force NN 40436 5886 42 of of IN 40436 5886 43 these these DT 40436 5886 44 natural natural JJ 40436 5886 45 promptings prompting NNS 40436 5886 46 . . . 40436 5887 1 Being be VBG 40436 5887 2 under under IN 40436 5887 3 the the DT 40436 5887 4 strongest strong JJS 40436 5887 5 impulses impulse NNS 40436 5887 6 to to TO 40436 5887 7 act act VB 40436 5887 8 somehow somehow RB 40436 5887 9 , , , 40436 5887 10 an an DT 40436 5887 11 animal animal NN 40436 5887 12 accepts accept VBZ 40436 5887 13 any any DT 40436 5887 14 lead lead NN 40436 5887 15 that that WDT 40436 5887 16 is be VBZ 40436 5887 17 presented present VBN 40436 5887 18 , , , 40436 5887 19 and and CC 40436 5887 20 if if IN 40436 5887 21 successful successful JJ 40436 5887 22 , , , 40436 5887 23 abides abide NNS 40436 5887 24 by by IN 40436 5887 25 that that DT 40436 5887 26 lead lead NN 40436 5887 27 with with IN 40436 5887 28 unshaken unshaken JJ 40436 5887 29 confidence confidence NN 40436 5887 30 . . . 40436 5888 1 This this DT 40436 5888 2 is be VBZ 40436 5888 3 that that DT 40436 5888 4 instinct instinct NN 40436 5888 5 of of IN 40436 5888 6 credulity credulity NN 40436 5888 7 so so RB 40436 5888 8 commonly commonly RB 40436 5888 9 attributed attribute VBN 40436 5888 10 to to IN 40436 5888 11 the the DT 40436 5888 12 infant infant NN 40436 5888 13 mind mind NN 40436 5888 14 . . . 40436 5889 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5889 2 is be VBZ 40436 5889 3 not not RB 40436 5889 4 the the DT 40436 5889 5 single single JJ 40436 5889 6 instance instance NN 40436 5889 7 , , , 40436 5889 8 or or CC 40436 5889 9 the the DT 40436 5889 10 repetition repetition NN 40436 5889 11 of of IN 40436 5889 12 two two CD 40436 5889 13 or or CC 40436 5889 14 three three CD 40436 5889 15 , , , 40436 5889 16 that that WDT 40436 5889 17 makes make VBZ 40436 5889 18 up up RP 40436 5889 19 the the DT 40436 5889 20 strong strong JJ 40436 5889 21 tone tone NN 40436 5889 22 of of IN 40436 5889 23 confidence confidence NN 40436 5889 24 ; ; : 40436 5889 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5889 26 is be VBZ 40436 5889 27 the the DT 40436 5889 28 mind mind NN 40436 5889 29 's 's POS 40436 5889 30 own own JJ 40436 5889 31 active active JJ 40436 5889 32 determination determination NN 40436 5889 33 , , , 40436 5889 34 finding find VBG 40436 5889 35 some some DT 40436 5889 36 definite definite JJ 40436 5889 37 vent vent NN 40436 5889 38 in in IN 40436 5889 39 the the DT 40436 5889 40 gratification gratification NN 40436 5889 41 of of IN 40436 5889 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5889 43 ends end NNS 40436 5889 44 , , , 40436 5889 45 and and CC 40436 5889 46 abiding abide VBG 40436 5889 47 by by IN 40436 5889 48 the the DT 40436 5889 49 discovery discovery NN 40436 5889 50 with with IN 40436 5889 51 the the DT 40436 5889 52 whole whole JJ 40436 5889 53 energy energy NN 40436 5889 54 of of IN 40436 5889 55 the the DT 40436 5889 56 character character NN 40436 5889 57 , , , 40436 5889 58 until until IN 40436 5889 59 the the DT 40436 5889 60 occurrence occurrence NN 40436 5889 61 of of IN 40436 5889 62 some some DT 40436 5889 63 check check NN 40436 5889 64 , , , 40436 5889 65 failure failure NN 40436 5889 66 , , , 40436 5889 67 or or CC 40436 5889 68 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 5889 69 . . . 40436 5890 1 The the DT 40436 5890 2 force force NN 40436 5890 3 of of IN 40436 5890 4 belief belief NN 40436 5890 5 , , , 40436 5890 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 5890 7 , , , 40436 5890 8 is be VBZ 40436 5890 9 not not RB 40436 5890 10 one one CD 40436 5890 11 rising rise VBG 40436 5890 12 from from IN 40436 5890 13 zero zero CD 40436 5890 14 to to IN 40436 5890 15 a a DT 40436 5890 16 full full JJ 40436 5890 17 development development NN 40436 5890 18 by by IN 40436 5890 19 slow slow JJ 40436 5890 20 degrees degree NNS 40436 5890 21 , , , 40436 5890 22 according accord VBG 40436 5890 23 to to IN 40436 5890 24 the the DT 40436 5890 25 length length NN 40436 5890 26 of of IN 40436 5890 27 the the DT 40436 5890 28 experience experience NN 40436 5890 29 . . . 40436 5891 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5891 2 must must MD 40436 5891 3 treat treat VB 40436 5891 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5891 5 rather rather RB 40436 5891 6 as as IN 40436 5891 7 a a DT 40436 5891 8 strong strong JJ 40436 5891 9 primitive primitive JJ 40436 5891 10 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 5891 11 , , , 40436 5891 12 derived derive VBN 40436 5891 13 from from IN 40436 5891 14 the the DT 40436 5891 15 natural natural JJ 40436 5891 16 activity activity NN 40436 5891 17 of of IN 40436 5891 18 the the DT 40436 5891 19 system system NN 40436 5891 20 , , , 40436 5891 21 and and CC 40436 5891 22 taking take VBG 40436 5891 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5891 24 direction direction NN 40436 5891 25 and and CC 40436 5891 26 rectification rectification NN 40436 5891 27 from from IN 40436 5891 28 experience experience NN 40436 5891 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5891 30 p. p. NN 40436 5891 31 583 583 CD 40436 5891 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5891 33 . . . 40436 5892 1 The the DT 40436 5892 2 anticipation anticipation NN 40436 5892 3 of of IN 40436 5892 4 nature nature NN 40436 5892 5 , , , 40436 5892 6 so so RB 40436 5892 7 strenuously strenuously RB 40436 5892 8 repudiated repudiate VBN 40436 5892 9 by by IN 40436 5892 10 Bacon Bacon NNP 40436 5892 11 , , , 40436 5892 12 is be VBZ 40436 5892 13 the the DT 40436 5892 14 offspring offspring NN 40436 5892 15 of of IN 40436 5892 16 this this DT 40436 5892 17 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 5892 18 of of IN 40436 5892 19 the the DT 40436 5892 20 mental mental JJ 40436 5892 21 system system NN 40436 5892 22 . . . 40436 5893 1 With with IN 40436 5893 2 the the DT 40436 5893 3 active active JJ 40436 5893 4 tendency tendency NN 40436 5893 5 at at IN 40436 5893 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5893 7 maximum maximum NN 40436 5893 8 , , , 40436 5893 9 and and CC 40436 5893 10 the the DT 40436 5893 11 exercise exercise NN 40436 5893 12 of of IN 40436 5893 13 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 5893 14 and and CC 40436 5893 15 acquired acquire VBN 40436 5893 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 5893 17 at at IN 40436 5893 18 the the DT 40436 5893 19 minimum minimum NN 40436 5893 20 , , , 40436 5893 21 there there EX 40436 5893 22 can can MD 40436 5893 23 issue issue VB 40436 5893 24 nothing nothing NN 40436 5893 25 but but IN 40436 5893 26 a a DT 40436 5893 27 quantity quantity NN 40436 5893 28 of of IN 40436 5893 29 rash rash JJ 40436 5893 30 enterprises enterprise NNS 40436 5893 31 . . . 40436 5894 1 The the DT 40436 5894 2 respectable respectable JJ 40436 5894 3 name name NN 40436 5894 4 _ _ NNP 40436 5894 5 generalisation generalisation NN 40436 5894 6 _ _ NNP 40436 5894 7 , , , 40436 5894 8 implying imply VBG 40436 5894 9 the the DT 40436 5894 10 best good JJS 40436 5894 11 products product NNS 40436 5894 12 of of IN 40436 5894 13 enlightened enlighten VBN 40436 5894 14 scientific scientific JJ 40436 5894 15 research research NN 40436 5894 16 , , , 40436 5894 17 has have VBZ 40436 5894 18 also also RB 40436 5894 19 a a DT 40436 5894 20 different different JJ 40436 5894 21 meaning meaning NN 40436 5894 22 , , , 40436 5894 23 expressing express VBG 40436 5894 24 one one CD 40436 5894 25 of of IN 40436 5894 26 the the DT 40436 5894 27 most most RBS 40436 5894 28 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 5894 29 impulses impulse NNS 40436 5894 30 and and CC 40436 5894 31 crudest crude JJS 40436 5894 32 determinations determination NNS 40436 5894 33 of of IN 40436 5894 34 untutored untutored JJ 40436 5894 35 human human JJ 40436 5894 36 nature nature NN 40436 5894 37 . . . 40436 5895 1 To to TO 40436 5895 2 extend extend VB 40436 5895 3 some some DT 40436 5895 4 familiar familiar JJ 40436 5895 5 and and CC 40436 5895 6 narrow narrow JJ 40436 5895 7 experience experience NN 40436 5895 8 , , , 40436 5895 9 so so IN 40436 5895 10 as as IN 40436 5895 11 to to TO 40436 5895 12 comprehend comprehend VB 40436 5895 13 cases case NNS 40436 5895 14 the the DT 40436 5895 15 most most RBS 40436 5895 16 distant distant JJ 40436 5895 17 , , , 40436 5895 18 is be VBZ 40436 5895 19 a a DT 40436 5895 20 piece piece NN 40436 5895 21 of of IN 40436 5895 22 mere mere JJ 40436 5895 23 reckless reckless JJ 40436 5895 24 instinct instinct NN 40436 5895 25 , , , 40436 5895 26 demanding demand VBG 40436 5895 27 severe severe JJ 40436 5895 28 discipline discipline NN 40436 5895 29 for for IN 40436 5895 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5895 31 correction correction NN 40436 5895 32 . . . 40436 5896 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5896 2 have have VBP 40436 5896 3 mentioned mention VBN 40436 5896 4 the the DT 40436 5896 5 case case NN 40436 5896 6 of of IN 40436 5896 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5896 8 supposing suppose VBG 40436 5896 9 all all DT 40436 5896 10 other other JJ 40436 5896 11 minds mind NNS 40436 5896 12 constituted constitute VBD 40436 5896 13 like like IN 40436 5896 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5896 15 own own JJ 40436 5896 16 . . . 40436 5897 1 The the DT 40436 5897 2 veriest veriest NN 40436 5897 3 infant infant NN 40436 5897 4 has have VBZ 40436 5897 5 got get VBN 40436 5897 6 this this DT 40436 5897 7 length length NN 40436 5897 8 in in IN 40436 5897 9 the the DT 40436 5897 10 career career NN 40436 5897 11 of of IN 40436 5897 12 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5897 13 . . . 40436 5898 1 Sound sound JJ 40436 5898 2 belief belief NN 40436 5898 3 , , , 40436 5898 4 instead instead RB 40436 5898 5 of of IN 40436 5898 6 being be VBG 40436 5898 7 a a DT 40436 5898 8 pacific pacific JJ 40436 5898 9 and and CC 40436 5898 10 gentle gentle JJ 40436 5898 11 growth growth NN 40436 5898 12 , , , 40436 5898 13 is be VBZ 40436 5898 14 in in IN 40436 5898 15 reality reality NN 40436 5898 16 the the DT 40436 5898 17 battering battering NN 40436 5898 18 of of IN 40436 5898 19 a a DT 40436 5898 20 series series NN 40436 5898 21 of of IN 40436 5898 22 strongholds stronghold NNS 40436 5898 23 , , , 40436 5898 24 the the DT 40436 5898 25 conquering conquering NN 40436 5898 26 of of IN 40436 5898 27 a a DT 40436 5898 28 country country NN 40436 5898 29 in in IN 40436 5898 30 hostile hostile JJ 40436 5898 31 occupation occupation NN 40436 5898 32 . . . 40436 5899 1 This this DT 40436 5899 2 is be VBZ 40436 5899 3 a a DT 40436 5899 4 fact fact NN 40436 5899 5 common common JJ 40436 5899 6 both both DT 40436 5899 7 to to IN 40436 5899 8 the the DT 40436 5899 9 individual individual NN 40436 5899 10 and and CC 40436 5899 11 to to IN 40436 5899 12 the the DT 40436 5899 13 race race NN 40436 5899 14 . . . 40436 5900 1 Observation observation NN 40436 5900 2 is be VBZ 40436 5900 3 unanimous unanimous JJ 40436 5900 4 on on IN 40436 5900 5 the the DT 40436 5900 6 point point NN 40436 5900 7 . . . 40436 5901 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5901 2 will will MD 40436 5901 3 probably probably RB 40436 5901 4 be be VB 40436 5901 5 long long RB 40436 5901 6 ere ere RB 40436 5901 7 the the DT 40436 5901 8 last last JJ 40436 5901 9 of of IN 40436 5901 10 the the DT 40436 5901 11 delusions delusion NNS 40436 5901 12 attributable attributable JJ 40436 5901 13 to to IN 40436 5901 14 this this DT 40436 5901 15 method method NN 40436 5901 16 of of IN 40436 5901 17 believing believe VBG 40436 5901 18 first first RB 40436 5901 19 and and CC 40436 5901 20 proving proving NN 40436 5901 21 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 5901 22 can can MD 40436 5901 23 be be VB 40436 5901 24 eradicated eradicate VBN 40436 5901 25 from from IN 40436 5901 26 humanity humanity NN 40436 5901 27 . . . 40436 5901 28 " " '' 40436 5902 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5902 2 3rd 3rd NNP 40436 5902 3 ed ed NNP 40436 5902 4 . . NNP 40436 5902 5 , , , 40436 5902 6 p. p. NN 40436 5902 7 505 505 CD 40436 5902 8 seq seq NN 40436 5902 9 . . . 40436 5902 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5902 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5903 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5903 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5903 3 62 62 CD 40436 5903 4 : : : 40436 5903 5 Mill mill NN 40436 5903 6 , , , 40436 5903 7 ' ' '' 40436 5903 8 System System NNP 40436 5903 9 of of IN 40436 5903 10 Logic Logic NNP 40436 5903 11 , , , 40436 5903 12 ' ' '' 40436 5903 13 Book Book NNP 40436 5903 14 V. V. NNP 40436 5903 15 , , , 40436 5903 16 to to TO 40436 5903 17 which which WDT 40436 5903 18 is be VBZ 40436 5903 19 prefixed prefix VBN 40436 5903 20 the the DT 40436 5903 21 following follow VBG 40436 5903 22 citation citation NN 40436 5903 23 from from IN 40436 5903 24 Hobbes Hobbes NNP 40436 5903 25 's 's POS 40436 5903 26 ' ' `` 40436 5903 27 Logica Logica NNP 40436 5903 28 ' ' '' 40436 5903 29 . . . 40436 5904 1 " " `` 40436 5904 2 Errare errare VB 40436 5904 3 non non AFX 40436 5904 4 modo modo NNP 40436 5904 5 affirmando affirmando NNP 40436 5904 6 et et NNP 40436 5904 7 negando negando NNP 40436 5904 8 , , , 40436 5904 9 sed se VBD 40436 5904 10 etiam etiam NNP 40436 5904 11 in in IN 40436 5904 12 sentiendo sentiendo NNP 40436 5904 13 , , , 40436 5904 14 et et FW 40436 5904 15 in in IN 40436 5904 16 tacitâ tacitâ NNP 40436 5904 17 hominum hominum NNP 40436 5904 18 cogitatione cogitatione NNP 40436 5904 19 , , , 40436 5904 20 contingit contingit JJ 40436 5904 21 . . . 40436 5904 22 " " '' 40436 5905 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5905 2 Mill Mill NNP 40436 5905 3 points point VBZ 40436 5905 4 out out RP 40436 5905 5 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 5905 6 both both CC 40436 5905 7 the the DT 40436 5905 8 operation operation NN 40436 5905 9 of of IN 40436 5905 10 moral moral JJ 40436 5905 11 or or CC 40436 5905 12 emotional emotional JJ 40436 5905 13 bias bias NN 40436 5905 14 in in IN 40436 5905 15 perverting pervert VBG 40436 5905 16 the the DT 40436 5905 17 intellect intellect NN 40436 5905 18 , , , 40436 5905 19 and and CC 40436 5905 20 causing cause VBG 40436 5905 21 sophisms sophism NNS 40436 5905 22 or or CC 40436 5905 23 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5905 24 to to TO 40436 5905 25 produce produce VB 40436 5905 26 conviction conviction NN 40436 5905 27 ; ; : 40436 5905 28 and and CC 40436 5905 29 the the DT 40436 5905 30 increased increase VBN 40436 5905 31 chance chance NN 40436 5905 32 afforded afford VBN 40436 5905 33 for for IN 40436 5905 34 the the DT 40436 5905 35 success success NN 40436 5905 36 of of IN 40436 5905 37 a a DT 40436 5905 38 sophism sophism NN 40436 5905 39 by by IN 40436 5905 40 the the DT 40436 5905 41 suppression suppression NN 40436 5905 42 of of IN 40436 5905 43 part part NN 40436 5905 44 of of IN 40436 5905 45 the the DT 40436 5905 46 premisses premiss NNS 40436 5905 47 , , , 40436 5905 48 which which WDT 40436 5905 49 is be VBZ 40436 5905 50 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 40436 5905 51 in in IN 40436 5905 52 informal informal JJ 40436 5905 53 discussions discussion NNS 40436 5905 54 . . . 40436 5906 1 " " `` 40436 5906 2 Bias bias NN 40436 5906 3 is be VBZ 40436 5906 4 not not RB 40436 5906 5 a a DT 40436 5906 6 direct direct JJ 40436 5906 7 source source NN 40436 5906 8 of of IN 40436 5906 9 wrong wrong JJ 40436 5906 10 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 5906 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5906 12 v. v. CC 40436 5906 13 1 1 CD 40436 5906 14 - - SYM 40436 5906 15 3 3 CD 40436 5906 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5906 17 . . . 40436 5907 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5907 2 can can MD 40436 5907 3 not not RB 40436 5907 4 believe believe VB 40436 5907 5 a a DT 40436 5907 6 proposition proposition NN 40436 5907 7 only only RB 40436 5907 8 by by IN 40436 5907 9 wishing wish VBG 40436 5907 10 , , , 40436 5907 11 or or CC 40436 5907 12 only only RB 40436 5907 13 by by IN 40436 5907 14 dreading dread VBG 40436 5907 15 , , , 40436 5907 16 to to TO 40436 5907 17 believe believe VB 40436 5907 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5907 19 . . . 40436 5908 1 Bias bias NN 40436 5908 2 acts act VBZ 40436 5908 3 indirectly indirectly RB 40436 5908 4 by by IN 40436 5908 5 placing place VBG 40436 5908 6 the the DT 40436 5908 7 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 5908 8 grounds ground NNS 40436 5908 9 of of IN 40436 5908 10 belief belief NN 40436 5908 11 in in IN 40436 5908 12 an an DT 40436 5908 13 incomplete incomplete JJ 40436 5908 14 or or CC 40436 5908 15 distorted distorted JJ 40436 5908 16 shape shape NN 40436 5908 17 before before IN 40436 5908 18 a a DT 40436 5908 19 man man NN 40436 5908 20 's 's POS 40436 5908 21 eyes eye NNS 40436 5908 22 . . . 40436 5909 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5909 2 makes make VBZ 40436 5909 3 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5909 4 shrink shrink VB 40436 5909 5 from from IN 40436 5909 6 the the DT 40436 5909 7 irksome irksome JJ 40436 5909 8 labour labour NN 40436 5909 9 of of IN 40436 5909 10 a a DT 40436 5909 11 rigorous rigorous JJ 40436 5909 12 induction induction NN 40436 5909 13 . . . 40436 5910 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5910 2 operates operate VBZ 40436 5910 3 too too RB 40436 5910 4 by by IN 40436 5910 5 making make VBG 40436 5910 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5910 7 look look VB 40436 5910 8 out out RP 40436 5910 9 eagerly eagerly RB 40436 5910 10 for for IN 40436 5910 11 reasons reason NNS 40436 5910 12 , , , 40436 5910 13 or or CC 40436 5910 14 apparent apparent JJ 40436 5910 15 reasons reason NNS 40436 5910 16 , , , 40436 5910 17 to to TO 40436 5910 18 support support VB 40436 5910 19 opinions opinion NNS 40436 5910 20 which which WDT 40436 5910 21 are be VBP 40436 5910 22 conformable conformable JJ 40436 5910 23 , , , 40436 5910 24 or or CC 40436 5910 25 resist resist VB 40436 5910 26 those those DT 40436 5910 27 which which WDT 40436 5910 28 are be VBP 40436 5910 29 repugnant repugnant JJ 40436 5910 30 , , , 40436 5910 31 to to IN 40436 5910 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5910 33 interests interest NNS 40436 5910 34 or or CC 40436 5910 35 feelings feeling NNS 40436 5910 36 ; ; : 40436 5910 37 and and CC 40436 5910 38 when when WRB 40436 5910 39 the the DT 40436 5910 40 interests interest NNS 40436 5910 41 or or CC 40436 5910 42 feelings feeling NNS 40436 5910 43 are be VBP 40436 5910 44 common common JJ 40436 5910 45 to to IN 40436 5910 46 great great JJ 40436 5910 47 numbers number NNS 40436 5910 48 of of IN 40436 5910 49 persons person NNS 40436 5910 50 , , , 40436 5910 51 reasons reason NNS 40436 5910 52 are be VBP 40436 5910 53 accepted accept VBN 40436 5910 54 or or CC 40436 5910 55 pass pass VB 40436 5910 56 current current NN 40436 5910 57 which which WDT 40436 5910 58 would would MD 40436 5910 59 not not RB 40436 5910 60 for for IN 40436 5910 61 a a DT 40436 5910 62 moment moment NN 40436 5910 63 be be VB 40436 5910 64 listened listen VBN 40436 5910 65 to to IN 40436 5910 66 in in IN 40436 5910 67 that that DT 40436 5910 68 character character NN 40436 5910 69 , , , 40436 5910 70 if if IN 40436 5910 71 the the DT 40436 5910 72 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5910 73 had have VBD 40436 5910 74 nothing nothing NN 40436 5910 75 more more RBR 40436 5910 76 powerful powerful JJ 40436 5910 77 than than IN 40436 5910 78 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5910 79 reasons reason NNS 40436 5910 80 to to TO 40436 5910 81 speak speak VB 40436 5910 82 in in IN 40436 5910 83 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5910 84 behalf behalf NN 40436 5910 85 . . . 40436 5911 1 The the DT 40436 5911 2 natural natural JJ 40436 5911 3 or or CC 40436 5911 4 acquired acquire VBN 40436 5911 5 prejudices prejudice NNS 40436 5911 6 of of IN 40436 5911 7 mankind mankind NN 40436 5911 8 are be VBP 40436 5911 9 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 5911 10 throwing throw VBG 40436 5911 11 up up RP 40436 5911 12 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 5911 13 theories theory NNS 40436 5911 14 , , , 40436 5911 15 the the DT 40436 5911 16 sole sole JJ 40436 5911 17 recommendation recommendation NN 40436 5911 18 of of IN 40436 5911 19 which which WDT 40436 5911 20 consists consist VBZ 40436 5911 21 in in IN 40436 5911 22 the the DT 40436 5911 23 premisses premiss NNS 40436 5911 24 which which WDT 40436 5911 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5911 26 afford afford VBP 40436 5911 27 for for IN 40436 5911 28 proving prove VBG 40436 5911 29 cherished cherish VBN 40436 5911 30 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 5911 31 , , , 40436 5911 32 or or CC 40436 5911 33 justifying justify VBG 40436 5911 34 favourite favourite JJ 40436 5911 35 feelings feeling NNS 40436 5911 36 ; ; : 40436 5911 37 and and CC 40436 5911 38 when when WRB 40436 5911 39 any any DT 40436 5911 40 one one CD 40436 5911 41 of of IN 40436 5911 42 these these DT 40436 5911 43 theories theory NNS 40436 5911 44 has have VBZ 40436 5911 45 become become VBN 40436 5911 46 so so RB 40436 5911 47 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 5911 48 discredited discredit VBN 40436 5911 49 as as IN 40436 5911 50 no no RB 40436 5911 51 longer long RBR 40436 5911 52 to to TO 40436 5911 53 serve serve VB 40436 5911 54 the the DT 40436 5911 55 purpose purpose NN 40436 5911 56 , , , 40436 5911 57 another another DT 40436 5911 58 is be VBZ 40436 5911 59 always always RB 40436 5911 60 ready ready JJ 40436 5911 61 to to TO 40436 5911 62 take take VB 40436 5911 63 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5911 64 place place NN 40436 5911 65 . . . 40436 5911 66 " " '' 40436 5912 1 --"Though --"Though : 40436 5912 2 the the DT 40436 5912 3 opinions opinion NNS 40436 5912 4 of of IN 40436 5912 5 the the DT 40436 5912 6 generality generality NN 40436 5912 7 of of IN 40436 5912 8 mankind mankind NN 40436 5912 9 , , , 40436 5912 10 when when WRB 40436 5912 11 not not RB 40436 5912 12 dependent dependent JJ 40436 5912 13 upon upon IN 40436 5912 14 mere mere JJ 40436 5912 15 habit habit NN 40436 5912 16 and and CC 40436 5912 17 inculcation inculcation NN 40436 5912 18 , , , 40436 5912 19 have have VBP 40436 5912 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5912 21 root root NN 40436 5912 22 much much RB 40436 5912 23 more more RBR 40436 5912 24 in in IN 40436 5912 25 the the DT 40436 5912 26 inclinations inclination NNS 40436 5912 27 than than IN 40436 5912 28 in in IN 40436 5912 29 the the DT 40436 5912 30 intellect intellect NN 40436 5912 31 , , , 40436 5912 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5912 33 is be VBZ 40436 5912 34 a a DT 40436 5912 35 necessary necessary JJ 40436 5912 36 condition condition NN 40436 5912 37 to to IN 40436 5912 38 the the DT 40436 5912 39 triumph triumph NN 40436 5912 40 of of IN 40436 5912 41 the the DT 40436 5912 42 moral moral JJ 40436 5912 43 bias bias NN 40436 5912 44 that that IN 40436 5912 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5912 46 should should MD 40436 5912 47 first first RB 40436 5912 48 pervert pervert VB 40436 5912 49 the the DT 40436 5912 50 understanding understanding NN 40436 5912 51 . . . 40436 5912 52 " " '' 40436 5913 1 Again again RB 40436 5913 2 in in IN 40436 5913 3 v. v. IN 40436 5913 4 2 2 CD 40436 5913 5 , , , 40436 5913 6 3 3 CD 40436 5913 7 . . . 40436 5914 1 " " `` 40436 5914 2 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5914 3 is be VBZ 40436 5914 4 not not RB 40436 5914 5 in in IN 40436 5914 6 the the DT 40436 5914 7 nature nature NN 40436 5914 8 of of IN 40436 5914 9 bad bad JJ 40436 5914 10 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5914 11 to to TO 40436 5914 12 express express VB 40436 5914 13 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 5914 14 unambiguously unambiguously RB 40436 5914 15 . . . 40436 5915 1 When when WRB 40436 5915 2 a a DT 40436 5915 3 sophist sophist NN 40436 5915 4 , , , 40436 5915 5 whether whether IN 40436 5915 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5915 7 is be VBZ 40436 5915 8 imposing impose VBG 40436 5915 9 upon upon IN 40436 5915 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5915 11 or or CC 40436 5915 12 attempting attempt VBG 40436 5915 13 to to TO 40436 5915 14 impose impose VB 40436 5915 15 upon upon IN 40436 5915 16 others other NNS 40436 5915 17 , , , 40436 5915 18 can can MD 40436 5915 19 be be VB 40436 5915 20 constrained constrain VBN 40436 5915 21 to to TO 40436 5915 22 throw throw VB 40436 5915 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5915 24 argument argument NN 40436 5915 25 into into IN 40436 5915 26 so so RB 40436 5915 27 distinct distinct JJ 40436 5915 28 a a DT 40436 5915 29 form form NN 40436 5915 30 , , , 40436 5915 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5915 32 needs need VBZ 40436 5915 33 , , , 40436 5915 34 in in IN 40436 5915 35 a a DT 40436 5915 36 large large JJ 40436 5915 37 number number NN 40436 5915 38 of of IN 40436 5915 39 cases case NNS 40436 5915 40 , , , 40436 5915 41 no no DT 40436 5915 42 farther farther JJ 40436 5915 43 exposure exposure NN 40436 5915 44 . . . 40436 5916 1 In in IN 40436 5916 2 all all DT 40436 5916 3 arguments argument NNS 40436 5916 4 , , , 40436 5916 5 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 5916 6 but but CC 40436 5916 7 in in IN 40436 5916 8 the the DT 40436 5916 9 schools school NNS 40436 5916 10 , , , 40436 5916 11 some some DT 40436 5916 12 of of IN 40436 5916 13 the the DT 40436 5916 14 links link NNS 40436 5916 15 are be VBP 40436 5916 16 suppressed suppress VBN 40436 5916 17 : : : 40436 5916 18 _ _ NNP 40436 5916 19 à à DT 40436 5916 20 fortiori fortiori NN 40436 5916 21 _ _ NNP 40436 5916 22 , , , 40436 5916 23 when when WRB 40436 5916 24 the the DT 40436 5916 25 arguer arguer NN 40436 5916 26 either either CC 40436 5916 27 intends intend VBZ 40436 5916 28 to to TO 40436 5916 29 deceive deceive VB 40436 5916 30 , , , 40436 5916 31 or or CC 40436 5916 32 is be VBZ 40436 5916 33 a a DT 40436 5916 34 lame lame JJ 40436 5916 35 and and CC 40436 5916 36 inexpert inexpert JJ 40436 5916 37 thinker thinker NN 40436 5916 38 , , , 40436 5916 39 little little JJ 40436 5916 40 accustomed accustomed JJ 40436 5916 41 to to TO 40436 5916 42 bring bring VB 40436 5916 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5916 44 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5916 45 processes process NNS 40436 5916 46 to to IN 40436 5916 47 any any DT 40436 5916 48 test test NN 40436 5916 49 ; ; : 40436 5916 50 and and CC 40436 5916 51 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5916 52 is be VBZ 40436 5916 53 in in IN 40436 5916 54 those those DT 40436 5916 55 steps step NNS 40436 5916 56 of of IN 40436 5916 57 the the DT 40436 5916 58 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5916 59 which which WDT 40436 5916 60 are be VBP 40436 5916 61 made make VBN 40436 5916 62 in in IN 40436 5916 63 this this DT 40436 5916 64 tacit tacit JJ 40436 5916 65 and and CC 40436 5916 66 half half JJ 40436 5916 67 - - HYPH 40436 5916 68 conscious conscious JJ 40436 5916 69 , , , 40436 5916 70 or or CC 40436 5916 71 even even RB 40436 5916 72 wholly wholly RB 40436 5916 73 unconscious unconscious JJ 40436 5916 74 , , , 40436 5916 75 manner manner NN 40436 5916 76 , , , 40436 5916 77 that that IN 40436 5916 78 the the DT 40436 5916 79 error error NN 40436 5916 80 oftenest oftenest NN 40436 5916 81 lurks lurk VBZ 40436 5916 82 . . . 40436 5917 1 In in IN 40436 5917 2 order order NN 40436 5917 3 to to TO 40436 5917 4 detect detect VB 40436 5917 5 the the DT 40436 5917 6 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5917 7 the the DT 40436 5917 8 proposition proposition NN 40436 5917 9 thus thus RB 40436 5917 10 silently silently RB 40436 5917 11 assumed assume VBN 40436 5917 12 must must MD 40436 5917 13 be be VB 40436 5917 14 supplied supply VBN 40436 5917 15 , , , 40436 5917 16 but but CC 40436 5917 17 the the DT 40436 5917 18 reasoner reasoner NN 40436 5917 19 , , , 40436 5917 20 most most RBS 40436 5917 21 likely likely JJ 40436 5917 22 , , , 40436 5917 23 has have VBZ 40436 5917 24 never never RB 40436 5917 25 really really RB 40436 5917 26 asked ask VBN 40436 5917 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5917 28 what what WP 40436 5917 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5917 30 was be VBD 40436 5917 31 assuming assume VBG 40436 5917 32 ; ; : 40436 5917 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5917 34 confuter confuter NN 40436 5917 35 , , , 40436 5917 36 unless unless IN 40436 5917 37 permitted permit VBN 40436 5917 38 to to TO 40436 5917 39 extort extort VB 40436 5917 40 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5917 41 from from IN 40436 5917 42 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5917 43 by by IN 40436 5917 44 the the DT 40436 5917 45 Socratic socratic JJ 40436 5917 46 mode mode NN 40436 5917 47 of of IN 40436 5917 48 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 5917 49 , , , 40436 5917 50 must must MD 40436 5917 51 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5917 52 judge judge VB 40436 5917 53 what what WP 40436 5917 54 the the DT 40436 5917 55 suppressed suppress VBN 40436 5917 56 premiss premiss NNP 40436 5917 57 ought ought MD 40436 5917 58 to to TO 40436 5917 59 be be VB 40436 5917 60 , , , 40436 5917 61 in in IN 40436 5917 62 order order NN 40436 5917 63 to to TO 40436 5917 64 support support VB 40436 5917 65 the the DT 40436 5917 66 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5917 67 . . . 40436 5917 68 " " '' 40436 5918 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 5918 2 Mill Mill NNP 40436 5918 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 5918 4 to to TO 40436 5918 5 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 5918 6 this this DT 40436 5918 7 confusion confusion NN 40436 5918 8 by by IN 40436 5918 9 an an DT 40436 5918 10 excellent excellent JJ 40436 5918 11 passage passage NN 40436 5918 12 cited cite VBD 40436 5918 13 from from IN 40436 5918 14 Whately whately RB 40436 5918 15 's 's POS 40436 5918 16 ' ' `` 40436 5918 17 Logic logic NN 40436 5918 18 ' ' '' 40436 5918 19 . . . 40436 5919 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5919 2 may may MD 40436 5919 3 add add VB 40436 5919 4 , , , 40436 5919 5 that that IN 40436 5919 6 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5919 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5919 8 makes make VBZ 40436 5919 9 a a DT 40436 5919 10 remark remark NN 40436 5919 11 substantially substantially RB 40436 5919 12 the the DT 40436 5919 13 same same JJ 40436 5919 14 -- -- : 40436 5919 15 That that IN 40436 5919 16 the the DT 40436 5919 17 same same JJ 40436 5919 18 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 5919 19 may may MD 40436 5919 20 be be VB 40436 5919 21 referred refer VBN 40436 5919 22 to to IN 40436 5919 23 one one CD 40436 5919 24 general general JJ 40436 5919 25 head head NN 40436 5919 26 or or CC 40436 5919 27 to to IN 40436 5919 28 another another DT 40436 5919 29 , , , 40436 5919 30 according accord VBG 40436 5919 31 to to IN 40436 5919 32 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 5919 33 . . . 40436 5920 1 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 5920 2 . . . 40436 5921 1 Elench elench NN 40436 5921 2 . . . 40436 5922 1 33 33 CD 40436 5922 2 , , , 40436 5922 3 182 182 CD 40436 5922 4 , , , 40436 5922 5 b. b. NN 40436 5923 1 10 10 CD 40436 5923 2 . . . 40436 5923 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5924 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5924 2 Side side NN 40436 5924 3 - - HYPH 40436 5924 4 note note NN 40436 5924 5 : : : 40436 5924 6 Value value NN 40436 5924 7 of of IN 40436 5924 8 formal formal JJ 40436 5924 9 debate debate NN 40436 5924 10 as as IN 40436 5924 11 a a DT 40436 5924 12 means means NN 40436 5924 13 for for IN 40436 5924 14 testing testing NN 40436 5924 15 and and CC 40436 5924 16 confuting confute VBG 40436 5924 17 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5924 18 . . . 40436 5924 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5925 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5925 2 thus thus RB 40436 5925 3 see see VBP 40436 5925 4 not not RB 40436 5925 5 only only RB 40436 5925 6 that that IN 40436 5925 7 the the DT 40436 5925 8 fallacious fallacious JJ 40436 5925 9 agencies agency NNS 40436 5925 10 are be VBP 40436 5925 11 self self NN 40436 5925 12 - - HYPH 40436 5925 13 operative operative JJ 40436 5925 14 , , , 40436 5925 15 generating generate VBG 40436 5925 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5925 17 own own JJ 40436 5925 18 weeds weed NNS 40436 5925 19 in in IN 40436 5925 20 the the DT 40436 5925 21 common common JJ 40436 5925 22 soil soil NN 40436 5925 23 of of IN 40436 5925 24 human human JJ 40436 5925 25 thought thought NN 40436 5925 26 and and CC 40436 5925 27 speech speech NN 40436 5925 28 , , , 40436 5925 29 without without IN 40436 5925 30 being be VBG 40436 5925 31 planted plant VBN 40436 5925 32 by by IN 40436 5925 33 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 5925 34 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5925 35 or or CC 40436 5925 36 watered water VBN 40436 5925 37 by by IN 40436 5925 38 Eristic Eristic NNP 40436 5925 39 -- -- : 40436 5925 40 but but CC 40436 5925 41 that that IN 40436 5925 42 this this DT 40436 5925 43 very very RB 40436 5925 44 Eristic eristic JJ 40436 5925 45 affords afford VBZ 40436 5925 46 the the DT 40436 5925 47 best good JJS 40436 5925 48 means mean NNS 40436 5925 49 of of IN 40436 5925 50 restraining restrain VBG 40436 5925 51 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5925 52 diffusion diffusion NN 40436 5925 53 . . . 40436 5926 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 2 is be VBZ 40436 5926 3 only only RB 40436 5926 4 in in IN 40436 5926 5 formal formal JJ 40436 5926 6 debate debate NN 40436 5926 7 that that WDT 40436 5926 8 the the DT 40436 5926 9 disputant disputant NN 40436 5926 10 can can MD 40436 5926 11 be be VB 40436 5926 12 forced force VBN 40436 5926 13 to to TO 40436 5926 14 make make VB 40436 5926 15 clear clear JJ 40436 5926 16 to to IN 40436 5926 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 18 and and CC 40436 5926 19 declare declare VB 40436 5926 20 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 5926 21 to to IN 40436 5926 22 others other NNS 40436 5926 23 , , , 40436 5926 24 without without IN 40436 5926 25 reserve reserve NN 40436 5926 26 or or CC 40436 5926 27 omission omission NN 40436 5926 28 , , , 40436 5926 29 all all PDT 40436 5926 30 the the DT 40436 5926 31 premisses premiss NNS 40436 5926 32 upon upon IN 40436 5926 33 which which WDT 40436 5926 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5926 35 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5926 36 rests rest VBZ 40436 5926 37 -- -- : 40436 5926 38 that that IN 40436 5926 39 every every DT 40436 5926 40 part part NN 40436 5926 41 of of IN 40436 5926 42 these these DT 40436 5926 43 premisses premiss NNS 40436 5926 44 becomes become VBZ 40436 5926 45 liable liable JJ 40436 5926 46 to to IN 40436 5926 47 immediate immediate JJ 40436 5926 48 challenge challenge NN 40436 5926 49 by by IN 40436 5926 50 an an DT 40436 5926 51 opponent opponent NN 40436 5926 52 -- -- : 40436 5926 53 that that IN 40436 5926 54 the the DT 40436 5926 55 question question NN 40436 5926 56 comes come VBZ 40436 5926 57 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 5926 58 under under IN 40436 5926 59 consideration consideration NN 40436 5926 60 , , , 40436 5926 61 what what WP 40436 5926 62 is be VBZ 40436 5926 63 or or CC 40436 5926 64 is be VBZ 40436 5926 65 not not RB 40436 5926 66 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 5926 67 evidence evidence NN 40436 5926 68 -- -- : 40436 5926 69 that that IN 40436 5926 70 the the DT 40436 5926 71 premisses premiss NNS 40436 5926 72 of of IN 40436 5926 73 one one CD 40436 5926 74 argument argument NN 40436 5926 75 can can MD 40436 5926 76 be be VB 40436 5926 77 compared compare VBN 40436 5926 78 with with IN 40436 5926 79 the the DT 40436 5926 80 premisses premiss NNS 40436 5926 81 of of IN 40436 5926 82 another another DT 40436 5926 83 , , , 40436 5926 84 so so IN 40436 5926 85 that that IN 40436 5926 86 if if IN 40436 5926 87 in in IN 40436 5926 88 the the DT 40436 5926 89 former former JJ 40436 5926 90 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 91 are be VBP 40436 5926 92 tempted tempt VBN 40436 5926 93 to to TO 40436 5926 94 acquiesce acquiesce VB 40436 5926 95 in in IN 40436 5926 96 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 97 as as IN 40436 5926 98 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 5926 99 because because IN 40436 5926 100 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 101 have have VBP 40436 5926 102 a a DT 40436 5926 103 bias bias NN 40436 5926 104 favourable favourable JJ 40436 5926 105 to to IN 40436 5926 106 the the DT 40436 5926 107 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5926 108 , , , 40436 5926 109 in in IN 40436 5926 110 the the DT 40436 5926 111 latter latter NN 40436 5926 112 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 113 may may MD 40436 5926 114 be be VB 40436 5926 115 made make VBN 40436 5926 116 to to TO 40436 5926 117 feel feel VB 40436 5926 118 that that IN 40436 5926 119 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 120 are be VBP 40436 5926 121 _ _ NNP 40436 5926 122 insufficient insufficient JJ 40436 5926 123 _ _ NNP 40436 5926 124 , , , 40436 5926 125 because because IN 40436 5926 126 the the DT 40436 5926 127 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 5926 128 which which WDT 40436 5926 129 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 130 prove prove VBP 40436 5926 131 is be VBZ 40436 5926 132 one one CD 40436 5926 133 which which WDT 40436 5926 134 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5926 135 know know VBP 40436 5926 136 to to TO 40436 5926 137 be be VB 40436 5926 138 untrue untrue JJ 40436 5926 139 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5926 140 _ _ NNP 40436 5926 141 reductio reductio NN 40436 5926 142 ad ad NN 40436 5926 143 absurdum absurdum NN 40436 5926 144 _ _ NNP 40436 5926 145 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5926 146 . . . 40436 5927 1 The the DT 40436 5927 2 habit habit NN 40436 5927 3 of of IN 40436 5927 4 formal formal JJ 40436 5927 5 debate debate NN 40436 5927 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5927 7 called call VBN 40436 5927 8 by by IN 40436 5927 9 those those DT 40436 5927 10 who who WP 40436 5927 11 do do VBP 40436 5927 12 not not RB 40436 5927 13 like like VB 40436 5927 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5927 15 , , , 40436 5927 16 Eristic[63 eristic[63 ADD 40436 5927 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5927 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5927 19 is be VBZ 40436 5927 20 thus thus RB 40436 5927 21 an an DT 40436 5927 22 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 5927 23 condition condition NN 40436 5927 24 both both DT 40436 5927 25 for for IN 40436 5927 26 the the DT 40436 5927 27 exposure exposure NN 40436 5927 28 and and CC 40436 5927 29 confutation confutation NN 40436 5927 30 of of IN 40436 5927 31 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5927 32 , , , 40436 5927 33 which which WDT 40436 5927 34 exist exist VBP 40436 5927 35 quite quite RB 40436 5927 36 independent independent JJ 40436 5927 37 of of IN 40436 5927 38 that that DT 40436 5927 39 habit habit NN 40436 5927 40 -- -- : 40436 5927 41 owing owe VBG 40436 5927 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5927 43 rise rise NN 40436 5927 44 and and CC 40436 5927 45 prevalence prevalence NN 40436 5927 46 to to IN 40436 5927 47 deep deep JJ 40436 5927 48 - - HYPH 40436 5927 49 seated seat VBN 40436 5927 50 psychological psychological JJ 40436 5927 51 causes cause NNS 40436 5927 52 . . . 40436 5928 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5928 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5928 3 63 63 CD 40436 5928 4 : : : 40436 5928 5 The the DT 40436 5928 6 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5928 7 critics critic NNS 40436 5928 8 talk talk VBP 40436 5928 9 about about IN 40436 5928 10 the the DT 40436 5928 11 Eristics Eristics NNPS 40436 5928 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5928 13 as as IN 40436 5928 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5928 15 do do VBP 40436 5928 16 about about IN 40436 5928 17 the the DT 40436 5928 18 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5928 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5928 20 as as IN 40436 5928 21 if if IN 40436 5928 22 that that DT 40436 5928 23 name name NN 40436 5928 24 designated designate VBD 40436 5928 25 a a DT 40436 5928 26 known known JJ 40436 5928 27 and and CC 40436 5928 28 definite definite JJ 40436 5928 29 class class NN 40436 5928 30 of of IN 40436 5928 31 persons person NNS 40436 5928 32 . . . 40436 5929 1 This this DT 40436 5929 2 is be VBZ 40436 5929 3 altogether altogether RB 40436 5929 4 misleading misleading JJ 40436 5929 5 . . . 40436 5930 1 The the DT 40436 5930 2 term term NN 40436 5930 3 is be VBZ 40436 5930 4 vituperative vituperative JJ 40436 5930 5 , , , 40436 5930 6 and and CC 40436 5930 7 was be VBD 40436 5930 8 applied apply VBN 40436 5930 9 by by IN 40436 5930 10 different different JJ 40436 5930 11 persons person NNS 40436 5930 12 according accord VBG 40436 5930 13 to to IN 40436 5930 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5930 15 own own JJ 40436 5930 16 tastes taste NNS 40436 5930 17 . . . 40436 5931 1 Ueberweg Ueberweg NNP 40436 5931 2 remarks remark NNS 40436 5931 3 with with IN 40436 5931 4 great great JJ 40436 5931 5 justice justice NN 40436 5931 6 , , , 40436 5931 7 that that IN 40436 5931 8 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 5931 9 called call VBD 40436 5931 10 all all DT 40436 5931 11 speculators speculator NNS 40436 5931 12 on on IN 40436 5931 13 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5931 14 by by IN 40436 5931 15 the the DT 40436 5931 16 name name NN 40436 5931 17 of of IN 40436 5931 18 Eristics Eristics NNPS 40436 5931 19 . . . 40436 5932 1 " " `` 40436 5932 2 Als Als NNP 40436 5932 3 ob ob NNP 40436 5932 4 jener jener NNP 40436 5932 5 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 5932 6 nicht nicht NNP 40436 5932 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5932 8 wie wie NNP 40436 5932 9 ja ja NNP 40436 5932 10 doch doch NNP 40436 5932 11 Spengel Spengel NNP 40436 5932 12 selbst selbst NN 40436 5932 13 gut gut NNP 40436 5932 14 nachgewiesen nachgewiesen NNP 40436 5932 15 hat hat NNP 40436 5932 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5932 17 alle alle NNP 40436 5932 18 und und NNP 40436 5932 19 jede jede NNP 40436 5932 20 Spekulation Spekulation NNP 40436 5932 21 mit mit NN 40436 5932 22 dem dem NNP 40436 5932 23 Nahmen Nahmen NNP 40436 5932 24 der der VB 40436 5932 25 Eristik Eristik NNS 40436 5932 26 bezeichnete bezeichnete JJ 40436 5932 27 . . . 40436 5932 28 " " '' 40436 5933 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5933 2 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 40436 5933 3 über über NN 40436 5933 4 die die VBP 40436 5933 5 Zeitfolge Zeitfolge NNP 40436 5933 6 der der VBP 40436 5933 7 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5933 8 . . . 40436 5934 1 Schriften Schriften NNP 40436 5934 2 , , , 40436 5934 3 p. p. NN 40436 5935 1 257 257 CD 40436 5935 2 . . . 40436 5935 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5936 1 In in IN 40436 5936 2 reference reference NN 40436 5936 3 to to IN 40436 5936 4 the the DT 40436 5936 5 distinction distinction NN 40436 5936 6 which which WDT 40436 5936 7 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5936 8 attempts attempt VBZ 40436 5936 9 to to TO 40436 5936 10 draw draw VB 40436 5936 11 between between IN 40436 5936 12 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 5936 13 and and CC 40436 5936 14 Eristic Eristic NNP 40436 5936 15 -- -- : 40436 5936 16 the the DT 40436 5936 17 former former JJ 40436 5936 18 legitimate legitimate NN 40436 5936 19 , , , 40436 5936 20 the the DT 40436 5936 21 latter latter JJ 40436 5936 22 illegitimate illegitimate NN 40436 5936 23 -- -- : 40436 5936 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5936 25 must must MD 40436 5936 26 remark remark VB 40436 5936 27 that that IN 40436 5936 28 even even RB 40436 5936 29 in in IN 40436 5936 30 the the DT 40436 5936 31 legitimate legitimate JJ 40436 5936 32 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 5936 33 the the DT 40436 5936 34 purpose purpose NN 40436 5936 35 prominent prominent JJ 40436 5936 36 in in IN 40436 5936 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5936 38 mind mind NN 40436 5936 39 is be VBZ 40436 5936 40 that that DT 40436 5936 41 of of IN 40436 5936 42 victory victory NN 40436 5936 43 over over IN 40436 5936 44 an an DT 40436 5936 45 opponent opponent NN 40436 5936 46 . . . 40436 5937 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5937 2 enjoins enjoin VBZ 40436 5937 3 that that IN 40436 5937 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5937 5 are be VBP 40436 5937 6 not not RB 40436 5937 7 only only RB 40436 5937 8 to to TO 40436 5937 9 guard guard VB 40436 5937 10 against against IN 40436 5937 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5937 12 opponent opponent NN 40436 5937 13 , , , 40436 5937 14 lest lest IN 40436 5937 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5937 16 should should MD 40436 5937 17 out out RB 40436 5937 18 - - HYPH 40436 5937 19 manoeuvre manoeuvre VB 40436 5937 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5937 21 , , , 40436 5937 22 but but CC 40436 5937 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5937 24 are be VBP 40436 5937 25 to to TO 40436 5937 26 conceal conceal VB 40436 5937 27 and and CC 40436 5937 28 disguise disguise VB 40436 5937 29 the the DT 40436 5937 30 sequence sequence NN 40436 5937 31 of of IN 40436 5937 32 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5937 33 questions question NNS 40436 5937 34 so so IN 40436 5937 35 as as IN 40436 5937 36 to to IN 40436 5937 37 out out RB 40436 5937 38 - - HYPH 40436 5937 39 manoeuvre manoeuvre VBZ 40436 5937 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5937 41 . . . 40436 5938 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5938 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 5938 3 : : : 40436 5938 4 Chrê\ Chrê\ NNP 40436 5938 5 d d NNP 40436 5938 6 ' ' POS 40436 5938 7 o(/per o(/per NN 40436 5938 8 phula phula NN 40436 5938 9 / / SYM 40436 5938 10 ttesthai ttesthai NNP 40436 5938 11 paragge paragge NNP 40436 5938 12 / / SYM 40436 5938 13 llomen llomen NNP 40436 5938 14 a)pokrinome a)pokrinome CC 40436 5938 15 / / SYM 40436 5938 16 nous nous JJ 40436 5938 17 , , , 40436 5938 18 au)tou\s au)tou\s CD 40436 5938 19 e)picheirou e)picheirou ADD 40436 5938 20 = = SYM 40436 5938 21 ntas ntas JJ 40436 5938 22 peira peira NN 40436 5938 23 = = SYM 40436 5938 24 sthai sthai NNP 40436 5938 25 lantha lantha NNP 40436 5938 26 / / SYM 40436 5938 27 nein nein NNP 40436 5938 28 . . . 40436 5938 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5939 1 Anal anal JJ 40436 5939 2 . . . 40436 5940 1 Prior prior RB 40436 5940 2 . . . 40436 5941 1 ii ii LS 40436 5941 2 . . . 40436 5942 1 66 66 CD 40436 5942 2 , , , 40436 5942 3 a. a. NN 40436 5943 1 32 32 CD 40436 5943 2 . . . 40436 5944 1 Compare compare VB 40436 5944 2 Topic topic NN 40436 5944 3 . . . 40436 5945 1 108 108 CD 40436 5945 2 , , , 40436 5945 3 a. a. NN 40436 5946 1 25 25 CD 40436 5946 2 , , , 40436 5946 3 156 156 CD 40436 5946 4 , , , 40436 5946 5 a. a. NN 40436 5947 1 23 23 CD 40436 5947 2 , , , 40436 5947 3 164 164 CD 40436 5947 4 , , , 40436 5947 5 b. b. NN 40436 5948 1 35 35 CD 40436 5948 2 . . . 40436 5948 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5949 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5949 2 Side side NN 40436 5949 3 - - HYPH 40436 5949 4 note note NN 40436 5949 5 : : : 40436 5949 6 Without without IN 40436 5949 7 the the DT 40436 5949 8 habit habit NN 40436 5949 9 of of IN 40436 5949 10 formal formal JJ 40436 5949 11 debate debate NN 40436 5949 12 , , , 40436 5949 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5949 14 could could MD 40436 5949 15 not not RB 40436 5949 16 have have VB 40436 5949 17 composed compose VBN 40436 5949 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5949 19 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5949 20 , , , 40436 5949 21 nor nor CC 40436 5949 22 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5949 23 the the DT 40436 5949 24 treatise treatise NN 40436 5949 25 De De NNP 40436 5949 26 Sophisticis Sophisticis NNP 40436 5949 27 Elenchis Elenchis NNP 40436 5949 28 . . . 40436 5949 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5950 1 Without without IN 40436 5950 2 the the DT 40436 5950 3 experience experience NN 40436 5950 4 acquired acquire VBN 40436 5950 5 by by IN 40436 5950 6 this this DT 40436 5950 7 habit habit NN 40436 5950 8 of of IN 40436 5950 9 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 5950 10 debate debate NN 40436 5950 11 at at IN 40436 5950 12 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5950 13 , , , 40436 5950 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5950 15 could could MD 40436 5950 16 not not RB 40436 5950 17 have have VB 40436 5950 18 composed compose VBN 40436 5950 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5950 20 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5950 21 , , , 40436 5950 22 exhibiting exhibit VBG 40436 5950 23 a a DT 40436 5950 24 _ _ NNP 40436 5950 25 reductio reductio NN 40436 5950 26 ad ad NN 40436 5950 27 absurdum absurdum NN 40436 5950 28 _ _ NNP 40436 5950 29 of of IN 40436 5950 30 several several JJ 40436 5950 31 verbal verbal JJ 40436 5950 32 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5950 33 -- -- : 40436 5950 34 nor nor CC 40436 5950 35 could could MD 40436 5950 36 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5950 37 have have VB 40436 5950 38 had have VBN 40436 5950 39 the the DT 40436 5950 40 logical logical JJ 40436 5950 41 theories theory NNS 40436 5950 42 of of IN 40436 5950 43 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5950 44 , , , 40436 5950 45 embodied embody VBN 40436 5950 46 in in IN 40436 5950 47 the the DT 40436 5950 48 Analytica Analytica NNP 40436 5950 49 and and CC 40436 5950 50 Topica Topica NNP 40436 5950 51 with with IN 40436 5950 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5950 53 annexed annexed NN 40436 5950 54 treatise treatise NN 40436 5950 55 De De NNP 40436 5950 56 Sophisticis Sophisticis NNP 40436 5950 57 Elenchis Elenchis NNP 40436 5950 58 , , , 40436 5950 59 in in IN 40436 5950 60 which which WDT 40436 5950 61 various various JJ 40436 5950 62 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 5950 63 are be VBP 40436 5950 64 discriminated discriminate VBN 40436 5950 65 and and CC 40436 5950 66 classified classify VBN 40436 5950 67 . . . 40436 5951 1 These these DT 40436 5951 2 theories theory NNS 40436 5951 3 , , , 40436 5951 4 and and CC 40436 5951 5 the the DT 40436 5951 6 corollaries corollary NNS 40436 5951 7 connected connect VBN 40436 5951 8 with with IN 40436 5951 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5951 10 , , , 40436 5951 11 do do VBP 40436 5951 12 infinite infinite VB 40436 5951 13 honour honour NN 40436 5951 14 to to IN 40436 5951 15 the the DT 40436 5951 16 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 5951 17 intellect intellect NN 40436 5951 18 of of IN 40436 5951 19 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5951 20 : : : 40436 5951 21 but but CC 40436 5951 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5951 23 could could MD 40436 5951 24 not not RB 40436 5951 25 have have VB 40436 5951 26 conceived conceive VBN 40436 5951 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5951 28 without without IN 40436 5951 29 previous previous JJ 40436 5951 30 study study NN 40436 5951 31 of of IN 40436 5951 32 the the DT 40436 5951 33 ratiocinative ratiocinative JJ 40436 5951 34 process process NN 40436 5951 35 . . . 40436 5952 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5952 2 , , , 40436 5952 3 as as IN 40436 5952 4 the the DT 40436 5952 5 first first JJ 40436 5952 6 theorizer theorizer NN 40436 5952 7 , , , 40436 5952 8 must must MD 40436 5952 9 have have VB 40436 5952 10 had have VBN 40436 5952 11 before before IN 40436 5952 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5952 13 abundant abundant JJ 40436 5952 14 arguments argument NNS 40436 5952 15 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 5952 16 laid lay VBD 40436 5952 17 out out RP 40436 5952 18 , , , 40436 5952 19 and and CC 40436 5952 20 contested contest VBN 40436 5952 21 , , , 40436 5952 22 or or CC 40436 5952 23 open open JJ 40436 5952 24 to to TO 40436 5952 25 be be VB 40436 5952 26 contested contest VBN 40436 5952 27 , , , 40436 5952 28 at at IN 40436 5952 29 every every DT 40436 5952 30 step step NN 40436 5952 31 by by IN 40436 5952 32 an an DT 40436 5952 33 opponent opponent NN 40436 5952 34 . . . 40436 5953 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5953 2 64 64 CD 40436 5953 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5953 4 Towards towards IN 40436 5953 5 such such JJ 40436 5953 6 habit habit NN 40436 5953 7 of of IN 40436 5953 8 formal formal JJ 40436 5953 9 argumentation argumentation NN 40436 5953 10 , , , 40436 5953 11 a a DT 40436 5953 12 strong strong JJ 40436 5953 13 repugnance repugnance NN 40436 5953 14 was be VBD 40436 5953 15 felt feel VBN 40436 5953 16 by by IN 40436 5953 17 many many JJ 40436 5953 18 of of IN 40436 5953 19 the the DT 40436 5953 20 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 5953 21 public public NN 40436 5953 22 , , , 40436 5953 23 as as IN 40436 5953 24 there there EX 40436 5953 25 is be VBZ 40436 5953 26 among among IN 40436 5953 27 modern modern JJ 40436 5953 28 readers reader NNS 40436 5953 29 generally generally RB 40436 5953 30 : : : 40436 5953 31 but but CC 40436 5953 32 those those DT 40436 5953 33 who who WP 40436 5953 34 felt feel VBD 40436 5953 35 thus thus RB 40436 5953 36 , , , 40436 5953 37 had have VBD 40436 5953 38 probably probably RB 40436 5953 39 little little JJ 40436 5953 40 interest interest NN 40436 5953 41 in in IN 40436 5953 42 the the DT 40436 5953 43 speculations speculation NNS 40436 5953 44 either either CC 40436 5953 45 of of IN 40436 5953 46 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5953 47 or or CC 40436 5953 48 of of IN 40436 5953 49 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 5953 50 . . . 40436 5954 1 That that IN 40436 5954 2 the the DT 40436 5954 3 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5954 4 critics critic NNS 40436 5954 5 should should MD 40436 5954 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5954 7 feel feel VB 40436 5954 8 this this DT 40436 5954 9 same same JJ 40436 5954 10 repugnance repugnance NN 40436 5954 11 , , , 40436 5954 12 seems seem VBZ 40436 5954 13 to to IN 40436 5954 14 me -PRON- PRP 40436 5954 15 not not RB 40436 5954 16 consistent consistent JJ 40436 5954 17 with with IN 40436 5954 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5954 19 admiration admiration NN 40436 5954 20 for for IN 40436 5954 21 the the DT 40436 5954 22 great great JJ 40436 5954 23 dialectician dialectician JJ 40436 5954 24 and and CC 40436 5954 25 logician logician JJ 40436 5954 26 of of IN 40436 5954 27 antiquity antiquity NN 40436 5954 28 : : : 40436 5954 29 nor nor CC 40436 5954 30 can can MD 40436 5954 31 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5954 32 at at RB 40436 5954 33 all all RB 40436 5954 34 subscribe subscribe VB 40436 5954 35 to to IN 40436 5954 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5954 37 view view NN 40436 5954 38 , , , 40436 5954 39 when when WRB 40436 5954 40 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5954 41 present present VBP 40436 5954 42 to to IN 40436 5954 43 us -PRON- PRP 40436 5954 44 the the DT 40436 5954 45 inherent inherent JJ 40436 5954 46 infirmities infirmity NNS 40436 5954 47 of of IN 40436 5954 48 the the DT 40436 5954 49 human human JJ 40436 5954 50 intellect intellect NN 40436 5954 51 as as IN 40436 5954 52 factitious factitious JJ 40436 5954 53 distempers distemper NNS 40436 5954 54 generated generate VBN 40436 5954 55 by by IN 40436 5954 56 the the DT 40436 5954 57 habit habit NN 40436 5954 58 of of IN 40436 5954 59 formal formal JJ 40436 5954 60 debate debate NN 40436 5954 61 , , , 40436 5954 62 and and CC 40436 5954 63 by by IN 40436 5954 64 the the DT 40436 5954 65 rapacity rapacity NN 40436 5954 66 of of IN 40436 5954 67 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 5954 68 , , , 40436 5954 69 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 5954 70 , , , 40436 5954 71 and and CC 40436 5954 72 others other NNS 40436 5954 73 . . . 40436 5955 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5955 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5955 3 64 64 CD 40436 5955 4 : : : 40436 5955 5 Mill mill NN 40436 5955 6 , , , 40436 5955 7 ' ' '' 40436 5955 8 System System NNP 40436 5955 9 of of IN 40436 5955 10 Logic Logic NNP 40436 5955 11 . . . 40436 5955 12 ' ' '' 40436 5956 1 Book book NN 40436 5956 2 VI VI NNP 40436 5956 3 . . . 40436 5957 1 1 1 CD 40436 5957 2 , , , 40436 5957 3 1 1 CD 40436 5957 4 . . . 40436 5958 1 " " `` 40436 5958 2 Principles principle NNS 40436 5958 3 of of IN 40436 5958 4 Evidence evidence NN 40436 5958 5 and and CC 40436 5958 6 Theories Theories NNPS 40436 5958 7 of of IN 40436 5958 8 Method Method NNP 40436 5958 9 , , , 40436 5958 10 are be VBP 40436 5958 11 not not RB 40436 5958 12 to to TO 40436 5958 13 be be VB 40436 5958 14 constructed construct VBN 40436 5958 15 _ _ NNP 40436 5958 16 à à NNP 40436 5958 17 priori priori FW 40436 5958 18 _ _ NNP 40436 5958 19 . . . 40436 5959 1 The the DT 40436 5959 2 laws law NNS 40436 5959 3 of of IN 40436 5959 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5959 5 rational rational JJ 40436 5959 6 faculty faculty NN 40436 5959 7 , , , 40436 5959 8 like like IN 40436 5959 9 those those DT 40436 5959 10 of of IN 40436 5959 11 every every DT 40436 5959 12 other other JJ 40436 5959 13 natural natural JJ 40436 5959 14 agency agency NN 40436 5959 15 , , , 40436 5959 16 are be VBP 40436 5959 17 only only RB 40436 5959 18 got get VBN 40436 5959 19 by by IN 40436 5959 20 seeing see VBG 40436 5959 21 the the DT 40436 5959 22 agent agent NN 40436 5959 23 at at IN 40436 5959 24 work work NN 40436 5959 25 . . . 40436 5959 26 " " '' 40436 5959 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5960 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5960 2 Side side NN 40436 5960 3 - - HYPH 40436 5960 4 note note NN 40436 5960 5 : : : 40436 5960 6 Probable probable JJ 40436 5960 7 popularity popularity NN 40436 5960 8 of of IN 40436 5960 9 the the DT 40436 5960 10 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5960 11 at at IN 40436 5960 12 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5960 13 -- -- : 40436 5960 14 welcomed welcome VBN 40436 5960 15 by by IN 40436 5960 16 all all PDT 40436 5960 17 the the DT 40436 5960 18 enemies enemy NNS 40436 5960 19 of of IN 40436 5960 20 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 5960 21 . . . 40436 5960 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5961 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5961 2 think think VBP 40436 5961 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5961 4 probable probable JJ 40436 5961 5 that that IN 40436 5961 6 the the DT 40436 5961 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5961 8 of of IN 40436 5961 9 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5961 10 , , , 40436 5961 11 as as RB 40436 5961 12 far far RB 40436 5961 13 as as IN 40436 5961 14 the the DT 40436 5961 15 point point NN 40436 5961 16 to to TO 40436 5961 17 which which WDT 40436 5961 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5961 19 have have VBP 40436 5961 20 brought bring VBN 40436 5961 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5961 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5961 23 _ _ NNP 40436 5961 24 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 5961 25 _ _ NNP 40436 5961 26 , , , 40436 5961 27 where where WRB 40436 5961 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5961 29 finishes finish VBZ 40436 5961 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5961 31 recital recital NN 40436 5961 32 to to IN 40436 5961 33 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5961 34 of of IN 40436 5961 35 the the DT 40436 5961 36 conversation conversation NN 40436 5961 37 which which WDT 40436 5961 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5961 39 had have VBD 40436 5961 40 had have VBN 40436 5961 41 with with IN 40436 5961 42 the the DT 40436 5961 43 two two CD 40436 5961 44 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5961 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5961 46 , , , 40436 5961 47 was be VBD 40436 5961 48 among among IN 40436 5961 49 the the DT 40436 5961 50 most most RBS 40436 5961 51 popular popular JJ 40436 5961 52 of of IN 40436 5961 53 all all PDT 40436 5961 54 the the DT 40436 5961 55 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 5961 56 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 5961 57 : : : 40436 5961 58 not not RB 40436 5961 59 merely merely RB 40436 5961 60 because because IN 40436 5961 61 of of IN 40436 5961 62 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5961 63 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 5961 64 vivacity vivacity NN 40436 5961 65 and and CC 40436 5961 66 charm charm NN 40436 5961 67 of of IN 40436 5961 68 expression expression NN 40436 5961 69 , , , 40436 5961 70 but but CC 40436 5961 71 because because IN 40436 5961 72 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5961 73 would would MD 40436 5961 74 be be VB 40436 5961 75 heartily heartily RB 40436 5961 76 welcomed welcome VBN 40436 5961 77 by by IN 40436 5961 78 the the DT 40436 5961 79 numerous numerous JJ 40436 5961 80 enemies enemy NNS 40436 5961 81 of of IN 40436 5961 82 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 5961 83 at at IN 40436 5961 84 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5961 85 . . . 40436 5962 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 5962 2 must must MD 40436 5962 3 remember remember VB 40436 5962 4 that that IN 40436 5962 5 in in IN 40436 5962 6 the the DT 40436 5962 7 estimation estimation NN 40436 5962 8 of of IN 40436 5962 9 most most JJS 40436 5962 10 persons person NNS 40436 5962 11 at at IN 40436 5962 12 Athens Athens NNP 40436 5962 13 , , , 40436 5962 14 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 5962 15 included include VBD 40436 5962 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5962 17 and and CC 40436 5962 18 all all PDT 40436 5962 19 the the DT 40436 5962 20 _ _ NNP 40436 5962 21 viri viri NN 40436 5962 22 Sokratici Sokratici NNP 40436 5962 23 _ _ NNP 40436 5962 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5962 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5962 26 among among IN 40436 5962 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5962 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5962 29 , , , 40436 5962 30 just just RB 40436 5962 31 as as RB 40436 5962 32 much much RB 40436 5962 33 as as IN 40436 5962 34 the the DT 40436 5962 35 persons person NNS 40436 5962 36 called call VBD 40436 5962 37 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 5962 38 . . . 40436 5963 1 The the DT 40436 5963 2 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 5963 3 picture picture NN 40436 5963 4 here here RB 40436 5963 5 given give VBN 40436 5963 6 of of IN 40436 5963 7 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5963 8 and and CC 40436 5963 9 Dionysodorus Dionysodorus NNP 40436 5963 10 , , , 40436 5963 11 would would MD 40436 5963 12 be be VB 40436 5963 13 considered consider VBN 40436 5963 14 as as IN 40436 5963 15 telling tell VBG 40436 5963 16 against against IN 40436 5963 17 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 5963 18 and and CC 40436 5963 19 the the DT 40436 5963 20 Sokratic Sokratic NNP 40436 5963 21 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 5963 22 generally generally RB 40436 5963 23 : : : 40436 5963 24 while while IN 40436 5963 25 the the DT 40436 5963 26 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 5963 27 , , , 40436 5963 28 and and CC 40436 5963 29 others other NNS 40436 5963 30 who who WP 40436 5963 31 dealt deal VBD 40436 5963 32 in in IN 40436 5963 33 long long JJ 40436 5963 34 continuous continuous JJ 40436 5963 35 discourse discourse NN 40436 5963 36 , , , 40436 5963 37 would would MD 40436 5963 38 treat treat VB 40436 5963 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5963 40 as as IN 40436 5963 41 a a DT 40436 5963 42 blow blow NN 40436 5963 43 inflicted inflict VBN 40436 5963 44 upon upon IN 40436 5963 45 the the DT 40436 5963 46 rival rival JJ 40436 5963 47 art art NN 40436 5963 48 of of IN 40436 5963 49 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5963 50 , , , 40436 5963 51 by by IN 40436 5963 52 the the DT 40436 5963 53 professor professor NN 40436 5963 54 of of IN 40436 5963 55 the the DT 40436 5963 56 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5963 57 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5963 58 . . . 40436 5964 1 In in IN 40436 5964 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5964 3 's 's POS 40436 5964 4 view view NN 40436 5964 5 , , , 40436 5964 6 the the DT 40436 5964 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 5964 8 was be VBD 40436 5964 9 the the DT 40436 5964 10 special special JJ 40436 5964 11 and and CC 40436 5964 12 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 5964 13 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 5964 14 of of IN 40436 5964 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5964 16 . . . 40436 5965 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5965 2 Side side NN 40436 5965 3 - - HYPH 40436 5965 4 note note NN 40436 5965 5 : : : 40436 5965 6 Epilogue Epilogue NNP 40436 5965 7 of of IN 40436 5965 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5965 9 to to IN 40436 5965 10 the the DT 40436 5965 11 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 5965 12 , , , 40436 5965 13 trying try VBG 40436 5965 14 to to TO 40436 5965 15 obviate obviate VB 40436 5965 16 this this DT 40436 5965 17 inference inference NN 40436 5965 18 by by IN 40436 5965 19 opponents opponent NNS 40436 5965 20 -- -- : 40436 5965 21 Conversation conversation NN 40436 5965 22 between between IN 40436 5965 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5965 24 and and CC 40436 5965 25 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5965 26 . . . 40436 5965 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5966 1 That that IN 40436 5966 2 the the DT 40436 5966 3 natural natural JJ 40436 5966 4 effect effect NN 40436 5966 5 of of IN 40436 5966 6 the the DT 40436 5966 7 picture picture NN 40436 5966 8 here here RB 40436 5966 9 drawn draw VBN 40436 5966 10 by by IN 40436 5966 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5966 12 , , , 40436 5966 13 was be VBD 40436 5966 14 , , , 40436 5966 15 to to TO 40436 5966 16 justify justify VB 40436 5966 17 the the DT 40436 5966 18 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 5966 19 of of IN 40436 5966 20 those those DT 40436 5966 21 who who WP 40436 5966 22 hated hate VBD 40436 5966 23 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5966 24 -- -- : 40436 5966 25 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5966 26 may may MD 40436 5966 27 see see VB 40436 5966 28 by by IN 40436 5966 29 the the DT 40436 5966 30 epilogue epilogue NN 40436 5966 31 which which WDT 40436 5966 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 5966 33 has have VBZ 40436 5966 34 thought think VBN 40436 5966 35 fit fit NN 40436 5966 36 to to IN 40436 5966 37 annex annex NNP 40436 5966 38 : : : 40436 5966 39 an an DT 40436 5966 40 epilogue epilogue NN 40436 5966 41 so so RB 40436 5966 42 little little JJ 40436 5966 43 in in IN 40436 5966 44 harmony harmony NN 40436 5966 45 with with IN 40436 5966 46 what what WP 40436 5966 47 has have VBZ 40436 5966 48 preceded precede VBN 40436 5966 49 , , , 40436 5966 50 that that IN 40436 5966 51 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5966 52 might may MD 40436 5966 53 almost almost RB 40436 5966 54 imagine imagine VB 40436 5966 55 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5966 56 to to TO 40436 5966 57 be be VB 40436 5966 58 an an DT 40436 5966 59 afterthought afterthought NN 40436 5966 60 -- -- : 40436 5966 61 yet yet CC 40436 5966 62 obviously obviously RB 40436 5966 63 intended intend VBN 40436 5966 64 to to TO 40436 5966 65 protect protect VB 40436 5966 66 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5966 67 against against IN 40436 5966 68 imputations imputation NNS 40436 5966 69 . . . 40436 5967 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 5967 2 having have VBG 40436 5967 3 concluded conclude VBN 40436 5967 4 the the DT 40436 5967 5 recital recital NN 40436 5967 6 , , , 40436 5967 7 in in IN 40436 5967 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5967 9 ironical ironical JJ 40436 5967 10 way way NN 40436 5967 11 , , , 40436 5967 12 by by IN 40436 5967 13 saying say VBG 40436 5967 14 that that IN 40436 5967 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5967 16 intended intend VBD 40436 5967 17 to to TO 40436 5967 18 become become VB 40436 5967 19 a a DT 40436 5967 20 pupil pupil NN 40436 5967 21 under under IN 40436 5967 22 the the DT 40436 5967 23 two two CD 40436 5967 24 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 5967 25 , , , 40436 5967 26 and and CC 40436 5967 27 by by IN 40436 5967 28 inviting invite VBG 40436 5967 29 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5967 30 to to TO 40436 5967 31 be be VB 40436 5967 32 a a DT 40436 5967 33 pupil pupil NN 40436 5967 34 along along IN 40436 5967 35 with with IN 40436 5967 36 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5967 37 -- -- : 40436 5967 38 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5967 39 replies reply VBZ 40436 5967 40 by by IN 40436 5967 41 saying say VBG 40436 5967 42 that that IN 40436 5967 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5967 44 is be VBZ 40436 5967 45 anxious anxious JJ 40436 5967 46 to to TO 40436 5967 47 obtain obtain VB 40436 5967 48 instruction instruction NN 40436 5967 49 from from IN 40436 5967 50 any any DT 40436 5967 51 one one NN 40436 5967 52 who who WP 40436 5967 53 can can MD 40436 5967 54 give give VB 40436 5967 55 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5967 56 , , , 40436 5967 57 but but CC 40436 5967 58 that that IN 40436 5967 59 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5967 60 has have VBZ 40436 5967 61 no no DT 40436 5967 62 sympathy sympathy NN 40436 5967 63 with with IN 40436 5967 64 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5967 65 , , , 40436 5967 66 and and CC 40436 5967 67 would would MD 40436 5967 68 rather rather RB 40436 5967 69 be be VB 40436 5967 70 refuted refute VBN 40436 5967 71 by by IN 40436 5967 72 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5967 73 , , , 40436 5967 74 than than IN 40436 5967 75 learn learn VB 40436 5967 76 from from IN 40436 5967 77 him -PRON- PRP 40436 5967 78 to to TO 40436 5967 79 refute refute VB 40436 5967 80 in in IN 40436 5967 81 such such PDT 40436 5967 82 a a DT 40436 5967 83 manner manner NN 40436 5967 84 . . . 40436 5968 1 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5968 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 5968 3 to to TO 40436 5968 4 report report VB 40436 5968 5 to to IN 40436 5968 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5968 7 the the DT 40436 5968 8 remarks remark NNS 40436 5968 9 of of IN 40436 5968 10 a a DT 40436 5968 11 by by NN 40436 5968 12 - - HYPH 40436 5968 13 stander stander NN 40436 5968 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5968 15 an an DT 40436 5968 16 able able JJ 40436 5968 17 writer writer NN 40436 5968 18 of of IN 40436 5968 19 discourses discourse NNS 40436 5968 20 for for IN 40436 5968 21 the the DT 40436 5968 22 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 5968 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5968 24 who who WP 40436 5968 25 had have VBD 40436 5968 26 heard hear VBN 40436 5968 27 all all DT 40436 5968 28 that that WDT 40436 5968 29 passed pass VBD 40436 5968 30 ; ; : 40436 5968 31 and and CC 40436 5968 32 who who WP 40436 5968 33 expressed express VBD 40436 5968 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5968 35 surprise surprise NN 40436 5968 36 that that IN 40436 5968 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5968 38 could could MD 40436 5968 39 have have VB 40436 5968 40 remained remain VBN 40436 5968 41 so so RB 40436 5968 42 long long RB 40436 5968 43 listening listen VBG 40436 5968 44 to to IN 40436 5968 45 such such JJ 40436 5968 46 nonsense nonsense NN 40436 5968 47 , , , 40436 5968 48 and and CC 40436 5968 49 manifesting manifest VBG 40436 5968 50 so so RB 40436 5968 51 much much JJ 40436 5968 52 deference deference NN 40436 5968 53 for for IN 40436 5968 54 a a DT 40436 5968 55 couple couple NN 40436 5968 56 of of IN 40436 5968 57 foolish foolish JJ 40436 5968 58 men man NNS 40436 5968 59 . . . 40436 5969 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5969 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5969 3 continued continue VBN 40436 5969 4 the the DT 40436 5969 5 by by IN 40436 5969 6 - - HYPH 40436 5969 7 stander stander NN 40436 5969 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5969 9 this this DT 40436 5969 10 couple couple NN 40436 5969 11 are be VBP 40436 5969 12 among among IN 40436 5969 13 the the DT 40436 5969 14 most most RBS 40436 5969 15 powerful powerful JJ 40436 5969 16 talkers talker NNS 40436 5969 17 of of IN 40436 5969 18 the the DT 40436 5969 19 day day NN 40436 5969 20 upon upon IN 40436 5969 21 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5969 22 . . . 40436 5970 1 This this DT 40436 5970 2 shows show VBZ 40436 5970 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5970 4 how how WRB 40436 5970 5 worthless worthless JJ 40436 5970 6 a a DT 40436 5970 7 thing thing NN 40436 5970 8 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5970 9 is be VBZ 40436 5970 10 : : : 40436 5970 11 prodigious prodigious JJ 40436 5970 12 fuss fuss NN 40436 5970 13 , , , 40436 5970 14 with with IN 40436 5970 15 contemptible contemptible JJ 40436 5970 16 result result NN 40436 5970 17 -- -- : 40436 5970 18 men man NNS 40436 5970 19 careless careless JJ 40436 5970 20 what what WP 40436 5970 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5970 22 say say VBP 40436 5970 23 , , , 40436 5970 24 and and CC 40436 5970 25 carping carp VBG 40436 5970 26 at at IN 40436 5970 27 every every DT 40436 5970 28 word word NN 40436 5970 29 that that WDT 40436 5970 30 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5970 31 hear hear VBP 40436 5970 32 . . . 40436 5971 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5971 2 65 65 CD 40436 5971 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5971 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5971 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5971 6 65 65 CD 40436 5971 7 : : : 40436 5971 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5971 9 . . . 40436 5972 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5972 2 . . . 40436 5973 1 pp pp NNP 40436 5973 2 . . . 40436 5974 1 304 304 CD 40436 5974 2 - - SYM 40436 5974 3 305 305 CD 40436 5974 4 . . . 40436 5974 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5975 1 Now now RB 40436 5975 2 , , , 40436 5975 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 5975 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 5975 5 concludes conclude VBZ 40436 5975 6 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 5975 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 5975 8 , , , 40436 5975 9 this this DT 40436 5975 10 man man NN 40436 5975 11 is be VBZ 40436 5975 12 wrong wrong JJ 40436 5975 13 for for IN 40436 5975 14 depreciating depreciate VBG 40436 5975 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5975 16 , , , 40436 5975 17 and and CC 40436 5975 18 all all DT 40436 5975 19 others other NNS 40436 5975 20 who who WP 40436 5975 21 depreciate depreciate VBP 40436 5975 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5975 23 are be VBP 40436 5975 24 wrong wrong JJ 40436 5975 25 also also RB 40436 5975 26 . . . 40436 5976 1 But but CC 40436 5976 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5976 3 was be VBD 40436 5976 4 right right JJ 40436 5976 5 in in IN 40436 5976 6 blaming blame VBG 40436 5976 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5976 8 , , , 40436 5976 9 for for IN 40436 5976 10 disputing dispute VBG 40436 5976 11 with with IN 40436 5976 12 such such PDT 40436 5976 13 a a DT 40436 5976 14 couple couple NN 40436 5976 15 before before IN 40436 5976 16 a a DT 40436 5976 17 large large JJ 40436 5976 18 crowd crowd NN 40436 5976 19 . . . 40436 5977 1 _ _ NNP 40436 5977 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 5977 3 kind kind NN 40436 5977 4 of of IN 40436 5977 5 person person NN 40436 5977 6 is be VBZ 40436 5977 7 this this DT 40436 5977 8 censor censor NN 40436 5977 9 of of IN 40436 5977 10 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5977 11 ? ? . 40436 5978 1 Is be VBZ 40436 5978 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5978 3 a a DT 40436 5978 4 powerful powerful JJ 40436 5978 5 speaker speaker NN 40436 5978 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 5978 7 in in IN 40436 5978 8 the the DT 40436 5978 9 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 5978 10 ? ? . 40436 5979 1 Or or CC 40436 5979 2 is be VBZ 40436 5979 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5979 4 only only RB 40436 5979 5 a a DT 40436 5979 6 composer composer NN 40436 5979 7 of of IN 40436 5979 8 discourses discourse NNS 40436 5979 9 to to TO 40436 5979 10 be be VB 40436 5979 11 spoken speak VBN 40436 5979 12 by by IN 40436 5979 13 others other NNS 40436 5979 14 ? ? . 40436 5980 1 _ _ NNP 40436 5980 2 Krit._--The Krit._--The NNP 40436 5980 3 latter latter NN 40436 5980 4 . . . 40436 5981 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5981 2 do do VBP 40436 5981 3 not not RB 40436 5981 4 think think VB 40436 5981 5 that that IN 40436 5981 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5981 7 has have VBZ 40436 5981 8 ever ever RB 40436 5981 9 spoken speak VBN 40436 5981 10 in in IN 40436 5981 11 court court NN 40436 5981 12 : : : 40436 5981 13 but but CC 40436 5981 14 every every DT 40436 5981 15 one one NN 40436 5981 16 says say VBZ 40436 5981 17 that that IN 40436 5981 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5981 19 knows know VBZ 40436 5981 20 judicial judicial JJ 40436 5981 21 practice practice NN 40436 5981 22 well well RB 40436 5981 23 , , , 40436 5981 24 and and CC 40436 5981 25 that that IN 40436 5981 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 5981 27 composes compose VBZ 40436 5981 28 admirable admirable JJ 40436 5981 29 speeches speech NNS 40436 5981 30 . . . 40436 5982 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5982 2 66 66 CD 40436 5982 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5982 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5982 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 5982 6 66 66 CD 40436 5982 7 : : : 40436 5982 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 5982 9 . . . 40436 5983 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 5983 2 . . . 40436 5984 1 p. p. NN 40436 5985 1 305 305 CD 40436 5985 2 . . . 40436 5985 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5986 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5986 2 Side side NN 40436 5986 3 - - HYPH 40436 5986 4 note note NN 40436 5986 5 : : : 40436 5986 6 Altered altered JJ 40436 5986 7 tone tone NN 40436 5986 8 in in IN 40436 5986 9 speaking speak VBG 40436 5986 10 of of IN 40436 5986 11 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5986 12 -- -- : 40436 5986 13 Disparagement Disparagement NNP 40436 5986 14 of of IN 40436 5986 15 persons person NNS 40436 5986 16 half half JJ 40436 5986 17 - - HYPH 40436 5986 18 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 5986 19 , , , 40436 5986 20 half half NN 40436 5986 21 - - HYPH 40436 5986 22 politicians politician NNS 40436 5986 23 . . . 40436 5986 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5987 1 _ _ NNP 40436 5987 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 5987 3 understand understand VBP 40436 5987 4 the the DT 40436 5987 5 man man NN 40436 5987 6 . . . 40436 5988 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 5988 2 belongs belong VBZ 40436 5988 3 to to IN 40436 5988 4 that that DT 40436 5988 5 class class NN 40436 5988 6 whom whom WP 40436 5988 7 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 5988 8 describes describe VBZ 40436 5988 9 as as IN 40436 5988 10 the the DT 40436 5988 11 border border NN 40436 5988 12 - - HYPH 40436 5988 13 men man NNS 40436 5988 14 between between IN 40436 5988 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5988 16 and and CC 40436 5988 17 politics politic NNS 40436 5988 18 . . . 40436 5989 1 Persons person NNS 40436 5989 2 of of IN 40436 5989 3 this this DT 40436 5989 4 class class NN 40436 5989 5 account account VBP 40436 5989 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5989 7 the the DT 40436 5989 8 wisest wise JJS 40436 5989 9 of of IN 40436 5989 10 mankind mankind NN 40436 5989 11 , , , 40436 5989 12 and and CC 40436 5989 13 think think VB 40436 5989 14 farther farther RB 40436 5989 15 that that DT 40436 5989 16 besides besides IN 40436 5989 17 being be VBG 40436 5989 18 such such JJ 40436 5989 19 in in IN 40436 5989 20 reality reality NN 40436 5989 21 , , , 40436 5989 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5989 23 are be VBP 40436 5989 24 also also RB 40436 5989 25 admired admire VBN 40436 5989 26 as as IN 40436 5989 27 such such JJ 40436 5989 28 by by IN 40436 5989 29 many many JJ 40436 5989 30 : : : 40436 5989 31 insomuch insomuch VB 40436 5989 32 that that IN 40436 5989 33 the the DT 40436 5989 34 admiration admiration NN 40436 5989 35 for for IN 40436 5989 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5989 37 would would MD 40436 5989 38 be be VB 40436 5989 39 universal universal JJ 40436 5989 40 , , , 40436 5989 41 if if IN 40436 5989 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5989 43 were be VBD 40436 5989 44 not not RB 40436 5989 45 for for IN 40436 5989 46 the the DT 40436 5989 47 professors professor NNS 40436 5989 48 of of IN 40436 5989 49 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5989 50 . . . 40436 5990 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 5990 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5990 3 fancy fancy VBP 40436 5990 4 , , , 40436 5990 5 that that IN 40436 5990 6 if if IN 40436 5990 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5990 8 could could MD 40436 5990 9 once once RB 40436 5990 10 discredit discredit VB 40436 5990 11 these these DT 40436 5990 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 5990 13 , , , 40436 5990 14 the the DT 40436 5990 15 prize prize NN 40436 5990 16 of of IN 40436 5990 17 glory glory NN 40436 5990 18 would would MD 40436 5990 19 be be VB 40436 5990 20 awarded award VBN 40436 5990 21 to to IN 40436 5990 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5990 23 , , , 40436 5990 24 without without IN 40436 5990 25 controversy controversy NN 40436 5990 26 , , , 40436 5990 27 by by IN 40436 5990 28 every every DT 40436 5990 29 one one NN 40436 5990 30 : : : 40436 5990 31 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5990 32 being be VBG 40436 5990 33 in in IN 40436 5990 34 truth truth NN 40436 5990 35 the the DT 40436 5990 36 wisest wise JJS 40436 5990 37 men man NNS 40436 5990 38 in in IN 40436 5990 39 society society NN 40436 5990 40 , , , 40436 5990 41 though though IN 40436 5990 42 liable liable JJ 40436 5990 43 , , , 40436 5990 44 if if IN 40436 5990 45 ever ever RB 40436 5990 46 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5990 47 are be VBP 40436 5990 48 caught catch VBN 40436 5990 49 in in IN 40436 5990 50 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 5990 51 debate debate NN 40436 5990 52 , , , 40436 5990 53 to to TO 40436 5990 54 be be VB 40436 5990 55 overpowered overpower VBN 40436 5990 56 and and CC 40436 5990 57 humbled humble VBN 40436 5990 58 by by IN 40436 5990 59 men man NNS 40436 5990 60 like like IN 40436 5990 61 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 5990 62 . . . 40436 5991 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 5991 2 67 67 CD 40436 5991 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5991 4 They -PRON- PRP 40436 5991 5 have have VBP 40436 5991 6 very very RB 40436 5991 7 plausible plausible JJ 40436 5991 8 grounds ground NNS 40436 5991 9 for for IN 40436 5991 10 believing believe VBG 40436 5991 11 in in IN 40436 5991 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5991 13 own own JJ 40436 5991 14 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5991 15 , , , 40436 5991 16 since since IN 40436 5991 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5991 18 pursue pursue VBP 40436 5991 19 both both DT 40436 5991 20 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5991 21 and and CC 40436 5991 22 politics politic NNS 40436 5991 23 to to IN 40436 5991 24 a a DT 40436 5991 25 moderate moderate JJ 40436 5991 26 extent extent NN 40436 5991 27 , , , 40436 5991 28 as as RB 40436 5991 29 far far RB 40436 5991 30 as as IN 40436 5991 31 propriety propriety NN 40436 5991 32 enjoins enjoin NNS 40436 5991 33 ; ; : 40436 5991 34 and and CC 40436 5991 35 thus thus RB 40436 5991 36 pluck pluck VBD 40436 5991 37 the the DT 40436 5991 38 fruit fruit NN 40436 5991 39 of of IN 40436 5991 40 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 5991 41 without without IN 40436 5991 42 encountering encounter VBG 40436 5991 43 either either DT 40436 5991 44 dangers danger NNS 40436 5991 45 or or CC 40436 5991 46 contests contest NNS 40436 5991 47 . . . 40436 5992 1 _ _ NNP 40436 5992 2 Krit._--What Krit._--What NNP 40436 5992 3 do do VBP 40436 5992 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 5992 5 say say VB 40436 5992 6 to to IN 40436 5992 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 5992 8 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 5992 9 , , , 40436 5992 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 5992 11 ? ? . 40436 5993 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 5993 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 5993 3 to to IN 40436 5993 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 5993 5 specious specious JJ 40436 5993 6 . . . 40436 5994 1 _ _ NNP 40436 5994 2 Sokr._--Yes Sokr._--Yes NNP 40436 5994 3 , , , 40436 5994 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5994 5 is be VBZ 40436 5994 6 specious specious JJ 40436 5994 7 , , , 40436 5994 8 but but CC 40436 5994 9 not not RB 40436 5994 10 well well RB 40436 5994 11 founded found VBN 40436 5994 12 . . . 40436 5995 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 5995 2 can can MD 40436 5995 3 not not RB 40436 5995 4 easily easily RB 40436 5995 5 persuade persuade VB 40436 5995 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5995 7 , , , 40436 5995 8 though though IN 40436 5995 9 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5995 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 5995 11 is be VBZ 40436 5995 12 true true JJ 40436 5995 13 , , , 40436 5995 14 that that IN 40436 5995 15 men man NNS 40436 5995 16 who who WP 40436 5995 17 take take VBP 40436 5995 18 a a DT 40436 5995 19 line line NN 40436 5995 20 mid mid NN 40436 5995 21 - - NN 40436 5995 22 way way NN 40436 5995 23 between between IN 40436 5995 24 two two CD 40436 5995 25 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 5995 26 , , , 40436 5995 27 are be VBP 40436 5995 28 _ _ NNP 40436 5995 29 better well RBR 40436 5995 30 _ _ NNP 40436 5995 31 than than IN 40436 5995 32 either either RB 40436 5995 33 , , , 40436 5995 34 if if IN 40436 5995 35 both both DT 40436 5995 36 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 5995 37 be be VBP 40436 5995 38 bad--_worse bad--_worse NNPS 40436 5995 39 _ _ XX 40436 5995 40 than than IN 40436 5995 41 either either RB 40436 5995 42 , , , 40436 5995 43 if if IN 40436 5995 44 both both DT 40436 5995 45 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 5995 46 be be VB 40436 5995 47 good good JJ 40436 5995 48 , , , 40436 5995 49 but but CC 40436 5995 50 tending tend VBG 40436 5995 51 to to IN 40436 5995 52 different different JJ 40436 5995 53 ends--_better ends--_better RB 40436 5995 54 _ _ NNP 40436 5995 55 than than IN 40436 5995 56 one one CD 40436 5995 57 and and CC 40436 5995 58 _ _ NNP 40436 5995 59 worse bad JJR 40436 5995 60 _ _ NNP 40436 5995 61 than than IN 40436 5995 62 the the DT 40436 5995 63 other other JJ 40436 5995 64 , , , 40436 5995 65 if if IN 40436 5995 66 one one CD 40436 5995 67 of of IN 40436 5995 68 the the DT 40436 5995 69 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 5995 70 be be VB 40436 5995 71 bad bad JJ 40436 5995 72 and and CC 40436 5995 73 the the DT 40436 5995 74 other other JJ 40436 5995 75 good--_better good--_better . 40436 5995 76 _ _ XX 40436 5995 77 than than IN 40436 5995 78 both both DT 40436 5995 79 , , , 40436 5995 80 if if IN 40436 5995 81 both both DT 40436 5995 82 be be VB 40436 5995 83 bad bad JJ 40436 5995 84 , , , 40436 5995 85 but but CC 40436 5995 86 tending tend VBG 40436 5995 87 to to IN 40436 5995 88 different different JJ 40436 5995 89 ends end NNS 40436 5995 90 . . . 40436 5996 1 Such such JJ 40436 5996 2 being be VBG 40436 5996 3 the the DT 40436 5996 4 case case NN 40436 5996 5 , , , 40436 5996 6 if if IN 40436 5996 7 the the DT 40436 5996 8 pursuit pursuit NN 40436 5996 9 of of IN 40436 5996 10 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5996 11 and and CC 40436 5996 12 that that DT 40436 5996 13 of of IN 40436 5996 14 active active JJ 40436 5996 15 politics politic NNS 40436 5996 16 be be VB 40436 5996 17 both both DT 40436 5996 18 of of IN 40436 5996 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5996 20 good good JJ 40436 5996 21 , , , 40436 5996 22 but but CC 40436 5996 23 tending tend VBG 40436 5996 24 to to IN 40436 5996 25 different different JJ 40436 5996 26 objects object NNS 40436 5996 27 , , , 40436 5996 28 these these DT 40436 5996 29 men man NNS 40436 5996 30 are be VBP 40436 5996 31 inferior inferior JJ 40436 5996 32 to to IN 40436 5996 33 the the DT 40436 5996 34 pursuers pursuer NNS 40436 5996 35 of of IN 40436 5996 36 one one CD 40436 5996 37 as as RB 40436 5996 38 well well RB 40436 5996 39 as as IN 40436 5996 40 of of IN 40436 5996 41 the the DT 40436 5996 42 other other JJ 40436 5996 43 : : : 40436 5996 44 if if IN 40436 5996 45 one one CD 40436 5996 46 be be VB 40436 5996 47 good good JJ 40436 5996 48 , , , 40436 5996 49 the the DT 40436 5996 50 other other JJ 40436 5996 51 bad bad JJ 40436 5996 52 , , , 40436 5996 53 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5996 54 are be VBP 40436 5996 55 worse bad JJR 40436 5996 56 than than IN 40436 5996 57 the the DT 40436 5996 58 pursuers pursuer NNS 40436 5996 59 of of IN 40436 5996 60 the the DT 40436 5996 61 former former JJ 40436 5996 62 , , , 40436 5996 63 better well JJR 40436 5996 64 than than IN 40436 5996 65 the the DT 40436 5996 66 pursuers pursuer NNS 40436 5996 67 of of IN 40436 5996 68 the the DT 40436 5996 69 latter latter JJ 40436 5996 70 : : : 40436 5996 71 if if IN 40436 5996 72 both both DT 40436 5996 73 be be VB 40436 5996 74 bad bad JJ 40436 5996 75 , , , 40436 5996 76 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5996 77 are be VBP 40436 5996 78 better well JJR 40436 5996 79 than than IN 40436 5996 80 either either RB 40436 5996 81 . . . 40436 5997 1 Now now RB 40436 5997 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 5997 3 am be VBP 40436 5997 4 sure sure JJ 40436 5997 5 that that IN 40436 5997 6 these these DT 40436 5997 7 men man NNS 40436 5997 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 5997 9 account account VBP 40436 5997 10 both both DT 40436 5997 11 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 5997 12 and and CC 40436 5997 13 politics politic NNS 40436 5997 14 to to TO 40436 5997 15 be be VB 40436 5997 16 good good JJ 40436 5997 17 . . . 40436 5998 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 5998 2 , , , 40436 5998 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5998 4 are be VBP 40436 5998 5 inferior inferior JJ 40436 5998 6 both both CC 40436 5998 7 to to IN 40436 5998 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 5998 9 and and CC 40436 5998 10 politicians:[68 politicians:[68 NNP 40436 5998 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 5998 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5998 13 occupy occupy VBP 40436 5998 14 only only RB 40436 5998 15 the the DT 40436 5998 16 third third JJ 40436 5998 17 rank rank NN 40436 5998 18 , , , 40436 5998 19 though though IN 40436 5998 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5998 21 pretend pretend VBP 40436 5998 22 to to TO 40436 5998 23 be be VB 40436 5998 24 in in IN 40436 5998 25 the the DT 40436 5998 26 first first JJ 40436 5998 27 . . . 40436 5999 1 While while IN 40436 5999 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5999 3 pardon pardon VBP 40436 5999 4 such such PDT 40436 5999 5 a a DT 40436 5999 6 pretension pretension NN 40436 5999 7 , , , 40436 5999 8 and and CC 40436 5999 9 refrain refrain VB 40436 5999 10 from from IN 40436 5999 11 judging judge VBG 40436 5999 12 these these DT 40436 5999 13 men man NNS 40436 5999 14 severely severely RB 40436 5999 15 , , , 40436 5999 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 5999 17 must must MD 40436 5999 18 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 5999 19 recognise recognise VB 40436 5999 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 5999 21 for for IN 40436 5999 22 such such JJ 40436 5999 23 as as IN 40436 5999 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 5999 25 really really RB 40436 5999 26 are be VBP 40436 5999 27 . . . 40436 6000 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6000 2 must must MD 40436 6000 3 be be VB 40436 6000 4 content content JJ 40436 6000 5 with with IN 40436 6000 6 every every DT 40436 6000 7 one one CD 40436 6000 8 , , , 40436 6000 9 who who WP 40436 6000 10 announces announce VBZ 40436 6000 11 any any DT 40436 6000 12 scheme scheme NN 40436 6000 13 of of IN 40436 6000 14 life life NN 40436 6000 15 , , , 40436 6000 16 whatever whatever WDT 40436 6000 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6000 18 be be VB 40436 6000 19 , , , 40436 6000 20 coming come VBG 40436 6000 21 within within IN 40436 6000 22 the the DT 40436 6000 23 limits limit NNS 40436 6000 24 of of IN 40436 6000 25 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 6000 26 , , , 40436 6000 27 and and CC 40436 6000 28 who who WP 40436 6000 29 pursues pursue VBZ 40436 6000 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6000 31 work work NN 40436 6000 32 with with IN 40436 6000 33 persevering persevere VBG 40436 6000 34 resolution resolution NN 40436 6000 35 . . . 40436 6001 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6001 2 69 69 CD 40436 6001 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6001 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6001 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6001 6 67 67 CD 40436 6001 7 : : : 40436 6001 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6001 9 . . . 40436 6002 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 6002 2 . . . 40436 6003 1 p. p. NN 40436 6003 2 305 305 CD 40436 6003 3 D. D. NNP 40436 6003 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6003 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6003 6 : : : 40436 6003 7 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 6003 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 6003 9 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6003 10 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 6003 11 a)lêthei a)lêthei CD 40436 6003 12 / / SYM 40436 6003 13 a| a| NN 40436 6003 14 spha spha NNP 40436 6003 15 = = SYM 40436 6003 16 s s NNP 40436 6003 17 sophôta sophôta NNP 40436 6003 18 / / SYM 40436 6003 19 tous tous JJ 40436 6003 20 , , , 40436 6003 21 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6003 22 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6003 23 toi toi NNP 40436 6003 24 = = SYM 40436 6003 25 s s NNP 40436 6003 26 i)di i)di NNP 40436 6003 27 / / SYM 40436 6003 28 ois ois NNP 40436 6003 29 lo lo NNP 40436 6003 30 / / SYM 40436 6003 31 gois gois NNP 40436 6003 32 o(/tan o(/tan NNP 40436 6003 33 a)polêphthô a)polêphthô IN 40436 6003 34 = = SYM 40436 6003 35 sin sin NN 40436 6003 36 , , , 40436 6003 37 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 6003 38 tô tô NNP 40436 6003 39 = = NFP 40436 6003 40 n n CC 40436 6003 41 a)mphi\ a)mphi\ NNP 40436 6003 42 Eu)thu Eu)thu NNP 40436 6003 43 / / SYM 40436 6003 44 dêmon dêmon NNP 40436 6003 45 kolou kolou NNP 40436 6003 46 / / SYM 40436 6003 47 esthai esthai NNP 40436 6003 48 . . . 40436 6003 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6004 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6004 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6004 3 : : : 40436 6004 4 Oi oi VB 40436 6004 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6004 6 a)mphi\ a)mphi\ NNP 40436 6004 7 Eu)thu Eu)thu NNP 40436 6004 8 / / SYM 40436 6004 9 dêmon dêmon NNP 40436 6004 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6004 11 may may MD 40436 6004 12 mean mean VB 40436 6004 13 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6004 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6004 15 and and CC 40436 6004 16 alone alone RB 40436 6004 17 ; ; : 40436 6004 18 yet yet CC 40436 6004 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6004 20 incline incline VBP 40436 6004 21 to to TO 40436 6004 22 think think VB 40436 6004 23 that that IN 40436 6004 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6004 25 here here RB 40436 6004 26 means mean VBZ 40436 6004 27 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6004 28 and and CC 40436 6004 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6004 30 like like UH 40436 6004 31 . . . 40436 6004 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6005 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6005 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6005 3 68 68 CD 40436 6005 4 : : : 40436 6005 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6005 6 . . . 40436 6006 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 6006 2 . . . 40436 6007 1 p. p. NN 40436 6007 2 306 306 CD 40436 6007 3 B. B. NNP 40436 6007 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6008 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6008 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6008 3 69 69 CD 40436 6008 4 : : : 40436 6008 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6008 6 . . . 40436 6009 1 Euthyd euthyd UH 40436 6009 2 . . . 40436 6010 1 p. p. NN 40436 6010 2 306 306 CD 40436 6010 3 C. C. NNP 40436 6010 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6010 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6010 6 : : : 40436 6010 7 suggignô suggignô NN 40436 6010 8 / / , 40436 6010 9 skein skein NN 40436 6010 10 me\n me\n NNP 40436 6010 11 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 6010 12 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 6010 13 = = SYM 40436 6010 14 s s NNP 40436 6010 15 chrê\ chrê\ NNP 40436 6010 16 tê tê NNP 40436 6010 17 = = SYM 40436 6010 18 s s NNP 40436 6010 19 e)pithumi e)pithumi NNP 40436 6010 20 / / SYM 40436 6010 21 as as IN 40436 6010 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6010 23 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 6010 24 chalepai chalepai NNP 40436 6010 25 / / SYM 40436 6010 26 nein nein NNP 40436 6010 27 , , , 40436 6010 28 ê(gei ê(gei NNP 40436 6010 29 = = SYM 40436 6010 30 sthai sthai NNP 40436 6010 31 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6010 32 / / SYM 40436 6010 33 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 6010 34 toiou toiou NNP 40436 6010 35 / / SYM 40436 6010 36 tous tous JJ 40436 6010 37 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 6010 38 oi(=oi/ oi(=oi/ NNP 40436 6010 39 ei)si ei)si NNP 40436 6010 40 ; ; : 40436 6010 41 pa pa NNP 40436 6010 42 / / SYM 40436 6010 43 nta nta NNP 40436 6010 44 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6010 45 a)/ndra a)/ndra NNP 40436 6010 46 chrê\ chrê\ . 40436 6010 47 a)gapa=|n a)gapa=|n NNP 40436 6010 48 , , , 40436 6010 49 o(/stis o(/stis NNP 40436 6010 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6010 51 o(tiou o(tiou NNP 40436 6010 52 = = SYM 40436 6010 53 n n CC 40436 6010 54 le le NNP 40436 6010 55 / / SYM 40436 6010 56 gei gei NNP 40436 6010 57 e)cho e)cho NNP 40436 6010 58 / / SYM 40436 6010 59 menon menon NNP 40436 6010 60 phronê phronê NNP 40436 6010 61 / / SYM 40436 6010 62 seôs seôs JJ 40436 6010 63 pra pra NNP 40436 6010 64 = = SYM 40436 6010 65 gma gma NNP 40436 6010 66 , , , 40436 6010 67 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6010 68 a)ndrei a)ndrei NNP 40436 6010 69 / / SYM 40436 6010 70 ôs ôs NNP 40436 6010 71 diaponei diaponei NNP 40436 6010 72 = = SYM 40436 6010 73 tai tai NN 40436 6010 74 . . . 40436 6010 75 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6010 76 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6011 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6011 2 Side side NN 40436 6011 3 - - HYPH 40436 6011 4 note note NN 40436 6011 5 : : : 40436 6011 6 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 6011 7 asks ask VBZ 40436 6011 8 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6011 9 for for IN 40436 6011 10 advice advice NN 40436 6011 11 about about IN 40436 6011 12 the the DT 40436 6011 13 education education NN 40436 6011 14 of of IN 40436 6011 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6011 16 sons son NNS 40436 6011 17 -- -- : 40436 6011 18 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6011 19 can can MD 40436 6011 20 not not RB 40436 6011 21 recommend recommend VB 40436 6011 22 a a DT 40436 6011 23 teacher teacher NN 40436 6011 24 -- -- : 40436 6011 25 tells tell VBZ 40436 6011 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6011 27 to to TO 40436 6011 28 search search VB 40436 6011 29 for for IN 40436 6011 30 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6011 31 . . . 40436 6011 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6012 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6012 2 Krit Krit NNP 40436 6012 3 . . . 40436 6012 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6012 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6012 6 am be VBP 40436 6012 7 always always RB 40436 6012 8 telling tell VBG 40436 6012 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6012 10 , , , 40436 6012 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6012 12 , , , 40436 6012 13 that that IN 40436 6012 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6012 15 too too RB 40436 6012 16 am be VBP 40436 6012 17 embarrassed embarrassed JJ 40436 6012 18 where where WRB 40436 6012 19 to to TO 40436 6012 20 seek seek VB 40436 6012 21 instructors instructor NNS 40436 6012 22 for for IN 40436 6012 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6012 24 sons son NNS 40436 6012 25 . . . 40436 6013 1 Conversation conversation NN 40436 6013 2 with with IN 40436 6013 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6013 4 has have VBZ 40436 6013 5 satisfied satisfy VBN 40436 6013 6 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6013 7 , , , 40436 6013 8 that that IN 40436 6013 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6013 10 is be VBZ 40436 6013 11 madness madness NN 40436 6013 12 to to TO 40436 6013 13 bestow bestow VB 40436 6013 14 so so RB 40436 6013 15 much much JJ 40436 6013 16 care care NN 40436 6013 17 upon upon IN 40436 6013 18 the the DT 40436 6013 19 fortune fortune NN 40436 6013 20 and and CC 40436 6013 21 position position NN 40436 6013 22 of of IN 40436 6013 23 sons son NNS 40436 6013 24 , , , 40436 6013 25 and and CC 40436 6013 26 so so RB 40436 6013 27 little little JJ 40436 6013 28 upon upon IN 40436 6013 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6013 30 instruction instruction NN 40436 6013 31 . . . 40436 6014 1 Yet yet CC 40436 6014 2 when when WRB 40436 6014 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6014 4 turn turn VBP 40436 6014 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6014 6 eyes eye NNS 40436 6014 7 to to IN 40436 6014 8 the the DT 40436 6014 9 men man NNS 40436 6014 10 who who WP 40436 6014 11 make make VBP 40436 6014 12 profession profession NN 40436 6014 13 of of IN 40436 6014 14 instructing instructing NN 40436 6014 15 , , , 40436 6014 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6014 17 am be VBP 40436 6014 18 really really RB 40436 6014 19 astonished astonished JJ 40436 6014 20 . . . 40436 6015 1 To to TO 40436 6015 2 tell tell VB 40436 6015 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6015 4 the the DT 40436 6015 5 truth truth NN 40436 6015 6 , , , 40436 6015 7 every every DT 40436 6015 8 one one CD 40436 6015 9 of of IN 40436 6015 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6015 11 appears appear VBZ 40436 6015 12 to to IN 40436 6015 13 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6015 14 extravagantly extravagantly RB 40436 6015 15 absurd,[70 absurd,[70 . 40436 6015 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6015 17 so so IN 40436 6015 18 that that IN 40436 6015 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6015 20 know know VBP 40436 6015 21 not not RB 40436 6015 22 how how WRB 40436 6015 23 to to TO 40436 6015 24 help help VB 40436 6015 25 forward forward RB 40436 6015 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6015 27 son son NN 40436 6015 28 towards towards IN 40436 6015 29 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6015 30 . . . 40436 6016 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6016 2 Sokr._--Don't Sokr._--Don't NNP 40436 6016 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6016 4 know know VBP 40436 6016 5 , , , 40436 6016 6 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 6016 7 , , , 40436 6016 8 that that IN 40436 6016 9 in in IN 40436 6016 10 every every DT 40436 6016 11 different different JJ 40436 6016 12 pursuit pursuit NN 40436 6016 13 , , , 40436 6016 14 most most JJS 40436 6016 15 of of IN 40436 6016 16 the the DT 40436 6016 17 professors professor NNS 40436 6016 18 are be VBP 40436 6016 19 foolish foolish JJ 40436 6016 20 and and CC 40436 6016 21 worthless worthless JJ 40436 6016 22 , , , 40436 6016 23 and and CC 40436 6016 24 that that IN 40436 6016 25 a a DT 40436 6016 26 few few JJ 40436 6016 27 only only RB 40436 6016 28 are be VBP 40436 6016 29 excellent excellent JJ 40436 6016 30 and and CC 40436 6016 31 above above IN 40436 6016 32 price price NN 40436 6016 33 ? ? . 40436 6017 1 Is be VBZ 40436 6017 2 not not RB 40436 6017 3 this this DT 40436 6017 4 the the DT 40436 6017 5 case case NN 40436 6017 6 with with IN 40436 6017 7 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 6017 8 , , , 40436 6017 9 commercial commercial JJ 40436 6017 10 business business NN 40436 6017 11 , , , 40436 6017 12 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 6017 13 , , , 40436 6017 14 military military JJ 40436 6017 15 command command NN 40436 6017 16 ? ? . 40436 6018 1 Are be VBP 40436 6018 2 not not RB 40436 6018 3 most most JJS 40436 6018 4 of of IN 40436 6018 5 those those DT 40436 6018 6 who who WP 40436 6018 7 undertake undertake VBP 40436 6018 8 these these DT 40436 6018 9 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 6018 10 ridiculously ridiculously RB 40436 6018 11 silly silly JJ 40436 6018 12 ? ? . 40436 6019 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6019 2 71 71 CD 40436 6019 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6019 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6019 5 Krit._--Unquestionably Krit._--Unquestionably NNP 40436 6019 6 : : : 40436 6019 7 nothing nothing NN 40436 6019 8 can can MD 40436 6019 9 be be VB 40436 6019 10 more more RBR 40436 6019 11 true true JJ 40436 6019 12 . . . 40436 6020 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6020 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 6020 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6020 4 think think VBP 40436 6020 5 _ _ IN 40436 6020 6 that that IN 40436 6020 7 _ _ NNP 40436 6020 8 a a DT 40436 6020 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 6020 10 reason reason NN 40436 6020 11 for for IN 40436 6020 12 avoiding avoid VBG 40436 6020 13 all all PDT 40436 6020 14 these these DT 40436 6020 15 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 6020 16 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6020 17 , , , 40436 6020 18 and and CC 40436 6020 19 keeping keep VBG 40436 6020 20 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6020 21 son son NN 40436 6020 22 out out IN 40436 6020 23 of of IN 40436 6020 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6020 25 also also RB 40436 6020 26 ? ? . 40436 6021 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6021 2 Krit Krit NNP 40436 6021 3 . . . 40436 6021 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6021 5 No no NN 40436 6021 6 : : : 40436 6021 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6021 8 would would MD 40436 6021 9 be be VB 40436 6021 10 wrong wrong JJ 40436 6021 11 to to TO 40436 6021 12 do do VB 40436 6021 13 so so RB 40436 6021 14 . . . 40436 6022 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6022 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 6022 3 then then RB 40436 6022 4 , , , 40436 6022 5 do do VB 40436 6022 6 n't not RB 40436 6022 7 do do VB 40436 6022 8 so so RB 40436 6022 9 . . . 40436 6023 1 Take take VB 40436 6023 2 no no DT 40436 6023 3 heed heed NN 40436 6023 4 about about IN 40436 6023 5 the the DT 40436 6023 6 professors professor NNS 40436 6023 7 of of IN 40436 6023 8 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6023 9 , , , 40436 6023 10 whether whether IN 40436 6023 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6023 12 are be VBP 40436 6023 13 good good JJ 40436 6023 14 or or CC 40436 6023 15 bad bad JJ 40436 6023 16 ; ; : 40436 6023 17 but but CC 40436 6023 18 test test NN 40436 6023 19 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6023 20 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 6023 21 , , , 40436 6023 22 well well UH 40436 6023 23 and and CC 40436 6023 24 carefully carefully RB 40436 6023 25 . . . 40436 6024 1 If if IN 40436 6024 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6024 3 shall shall MD 40436 6024 4 appear appear VB 40436 6024 5 to to IN 40436 6024 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6024 7 worthless worthless JJ 40436 6024 8 , , , 40436 6024 9 dissuade dissuade VBP 40436 6024 10 not not RB 40436 6024 11 merely merely RB 40436 6024 12 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6024 13 sons son NNS 40436 6024 14 , , , 40436 6024 15 but but CC 40436 6024 16 every every DT 40436 6024 17 one one NN 40436 6024 18 else else RB 40436 6024 19 also also RB 40436 6024 20 , , , 40436 6024 21 from from IN 40436 6024 22 following follow VBG 40436 6024 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6024 24 . . . 40436 6025 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6025 2 72 72 CD 40436 6025 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6025 4 But but CC 40436 6025 5 if if IN 40436 6025 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6025 7 shall shall MD 40436 6025 8 appear appear VB 40436 6025 9 to to IN 40436 6025 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6025 11 as as RB 40436 6025 12 valuable valuable JJ 40436 6025 13 as as IN 40436 6025 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6025 15 consider consider VBP 40436 6025 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6025 17 to to TO 40436 6025 18 be be VB 40436 6025 19 , , , 40436 6025 20 then then RB 40436 6025 21 take take VB 40436 6025 22 courage courage NN 40436 6025 23 to to TO 40436 6025 24 pursue pursue VB 40436 6025 25 and and CC 40436 6025 26 practise practise VB 40436 6025 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6025 28 , , , 40436 6025 29 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6025 30 and and CC 40436 6025 31 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6025 32 children child NNS 40436 6025 33 both both DT 40436 6025 34 , , , 40436 6025 35 according accord VBG 40436 6025 36 to to IN 40436 6025 37 the the DT 40436 6025 38 proverb.-- proverb.-- NNP 40436 6025 39 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6025 40 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6025 41 70 70 CD 40436 6025 42 : : : 40436 6025 43 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6025 44 , , , 40436 6025 45 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 6025 46 . . . 40436 6026 1 p. p. NN 40436 6026 2 306 306 CD 40436 6026 3 E. E. NNP 40436 6026 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6026 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6026 6 : : : 40436 6026 7 kai/ kai/ NNP 40436 6026 8 moi moi NNP 40436 6026 9 dokei= dokei= NNP 40436 6026 10 ei)=s ei)=s NNP 40436 6026 11 e(/kastos e(/kastos NNP 40436 6026 12 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 6026 13 = = SYM 40436 6026 14 n n NNP 40436 6026 15 skopou skopou NNP 40436 6026 16 = = SYM 40436 6026 17 nti nti NNP 40436 6026 18 pa pa NNP 40436 6026 19 / / SYM 40436 6026 20 nu nu NNP 40436 6026 21 a)llo a)llo NNP 40436 6026 22 / / SYM 40436 6026 23 kotos kotos NNP 40436 6026 24 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 6026 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6026 26 , , , 40436 6026 27 & & CC 40436 6026 28 c. c. NNP 40436 6026 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6026 30 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6026 31 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6026 32 71 71 CD 40436 6026 33 : : : 40436 6026 34 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6026 35 , , , 40436 6026 36 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 6026 37 . . . 40436 6027 1 p. p. NN 40436 6027 2 307 307 CD 40436 6027 3 B. B. NNP 40436 6028 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6028 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6028 3 : : : 40436 6028 4 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6028 5 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 6028 6 / / SYM 40436 6028 7 stê| stê| NNP 40436 6028 8 tou tou NNP 40436 6028 9 / / SYM 40436 6028 10 tôn tôn NNP 40436 6028 11 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 6028 12 pollou\s pollou\s CC 40436 6028 13 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 6028 14 e(/kaston e(/kaston NN 40436 6028 15 to\ to\ NN 40436 6028 16 e)/rgon e)/rgon NNP 40436 6028 17 ou ou NNP 40436 6028 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6028 19 katagela katagela NNP 40436 6028 20 / / SYM 40436 6028 21 stous stous JJ 40436 6028 22 o(ra=|s o(ra=|s NN 40436 6028 23 ? ? . 40436 6028 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6028 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6029 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6029 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6029 3 72 72 CD 40436 6029 4 : : : 40436 6029 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6029 6 , , , 40436 6029 7 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 6029 8 . . . 40436 6030 1 p. p. NN 40436 6030 2 307 307 CD 40436 6030 3 B. B. NNP 40436 6031 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6031 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6031 3 : : : 40436 6031 4 e)a e)a NNP 40436 6031 5 / / SYM 40436 6031 6 sas sas NNP 40436 6031 7 chai chai NN 40436 6031 8 / / SYM 40436 6031 9 rein rein NN 40436 6031 10 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 6031 11 e)pitêdeu e)pitêdeu NNP 40436 6031 12 / / SYM 40436 6031 13 ontas onta NNS 40436 6031 14 philosophi philosophi NN 40436 6031 15 / / SYM 40436 6031 16 an an DT 40436 6031 17 , , , 40436 6031 18 ei)/te ei)/te NNP 40436 6031 19 chrêstoi/ chrêstoi/ NN 40436 6031 20 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 6031 21 ei)/te ei)/te NNP 40436 6031 22 ponêroi/ ponêroi/ NN 40436 6031 23 , , , 40436 6031 24 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 6031 25 to\ to\ NN 40436 6031 26 pra pra NN 40436 6031 27 = = SYM 40436 6031 28 gma gma NNP 40436 6031 29 basani basani NNP 40436 6031 30 / / SYM 40436 6031 31 sas sas NNP 40436 6031 32 kalô kalô NNP 40436 6031 33 = = SYM 40436 6031 34 s s POS 40436 6031 35 te te NNP 40436 6031 36 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6031 37 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 6031 38 , , , 40436 6031 39 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 6031 40 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6031 41 / / SYM 40436 6031 42 n n NNP 40436 6031 43 soi soi NN 40436 6031 44 phai phai NNP 40436 6031 45 / / SYM 40436 6031 46 nêtai nêtai NNP 40436 6031 47 phaulo\n phaulo\n -LRB- 40436 6031 48 o)/n o)/n NNP 40436 6031 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6031 50 , , , 40436 6031 51 & & CC 40436 6031 52 c. c. NNP 40436 6031 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6031 54 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6031 55 Side side NN 40436 6031 56 - - HYPH 40436 6031 57 note note NN 40436 6031 58 : : : 40436 6031 59 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6031 60 is be VBZ 40436 6031 61 here here RB 40436 6031 62 cited cite VBN 40436 6031 63 as as IN 40436 6031 64 representative representative NN 40436 6031 65 of of IN 40436 6031 66 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 6031 67 and and CC 40436 6031 68 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6031 69 . . . 40436 6031 70 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6032 1 The the DT 40436 6032 2 first first JJ 40436 6032 3 part part NN 40436 6032 4 of of IN 40436 6032 5 this this DT 40436 6032 6 epilogue epilogue NN 40436 6032 7 , , , 40436 6032 8 which which WDT 40436 6032 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6032 10 have have VBP 40436 6032 11 here here RB 40436 6032 12 given give VBN 40436 6032 13 in in IN 40436 6032 14 abridgment abridgment NN 40436 6032 15 , , , 40436 6032 16 has have VBZ 40436 6032 17 a a DT 40436 6032 18 bearing bear VBG 40436 6032 19 very very RB 40436 6032 20 different different JJ 40436 6032 21 from from IN 40436 6032 22 the the DT 40436 6032 23 rest rest NN 40436 6032 24 of of IN 40436 6032 25 the the DT 40436 6032 26 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6032 27 , , , 40436 6032 28 and and CC 40436 6032 29 different different JJ 40436 6032 30 also also RB 40436 6032 31 from from IN 40436 6032 32 most most JJS 40436 6032 33 of of IN 40436 6032 34 the the DT 40436 6032 35 other other JJ 40436 6032 36 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6032 37 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6032 38 . . . 40436 6033 1 In in IN 40436 6033 2 the the DT 40436 6033 3 epilogue epilogue NN 40436 6033 4 , , , 40436 6033 5 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6033 6 is be VBZ 40436 6033 7 cited cite VBN 40436 6033 8 as as IN 40436 6033 9 the the DT 40436 6033 10 representative representative NN 40436 6033 11 of of IN 40436 6033 12 true true JJ 40436 6033 13 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 6033 14 and and CC 40436 6033 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6033 16 : : : 40436 6033 17 the the DT 40436 6033 18 opponents opponent NNS 40436 6033 19 of of IN 40436 6033 20 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6033 21 are be VBP 40436 6033 22 represented represent VBN 40436 6033 23 as as IN 40436 6033 24 afraid afraid JJ 40436 6033 25 of of IN 40436 6033 26 being be VBG 40436 6033 27 put put VBN 40436 6033 28 down down RP 40436 6033 29 by by IN 40436 6033 30 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6033 31 : : : 40436 6033 32 whereas whereas IN 40436 6033 33 , , , 40436 6033 34 previously previously RB 40436 6033 35 , , , 40436 6033 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6033 37 had have VBD 40436 6033 38 been be VBN 40436 6033 39 depicted depict VBN 40436 6033 40 as as IN 40436 6033 41 contemptible,--as contemptible,--as NN 40436 6033 42 a a DT 40436 6033 43 man man NN 40436 6033 44 whose whose WP$ 40436 6033 45 manner manner NN 40436 6033 46 of of IN 40436 6033 47 refuting refute VBG 40436 6033 48 opponents opponent NNS 40436 6033 49 was be VBD 40436 6033 50 more more RBR 40436 6033 51 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 6033 52 to to IN 40436 6033 53 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6033 54 than than IN 40436 6033 55 to to IN 40436 6033 56 the the DT 40436 6033 57 opponent opponent NN 40436 6033 58 refuted refute VBD 40436 6033 59 ; ; : 40436 6033 60 and and CC 40436 6033 61 who who WP 40436 6033 62 had have VBD 40436 6033 63 no no DT 40436 6033 64 chance chance NN 40436 6033 65 of of IN 40436 6033 66 success success NN 40436 6033 67 except except IN 40436 6033 68 among among IN 40436 6033 69 hearers hearer NNS 40436 6033 70 like like IN 40436 6033 71 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6033 72 . . . 40436 6034 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6034 2 are be VBP 40436 6034 3 not not RB 40436 6034 4 here here RB 40436 6034 5 told tell VBN 40436 6034 6 that that IN 40436 6034 7 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6034 8 was be VBD 40436 6034 9 a a DT 40436 6034 10 bad bad JJ 40436 6034 11 specimen speciman NNS 40436 6034 12 of of IN 40436 6034 13 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 6034 14 , , , 40436 6034 15 and and CC 40436 6034 16 that that IN 40436 6034 17 there there EX 40436 6034 18 were be VBD 40436 6034 19 others other NNS 40436 6034 20 better well RBR 40436 6034 21 , , , 40436 6034 22 by by IN 40436 6034 23 the the DT 40436 6034 24 standard standard NN 40436 6034 25 of of IN 40436 6034 26 whom whom WP 40436 6034 27 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6034 28 ought ought MD 40436 6034 29 to to TO 40436 6034 30 be be VB 40436 6034 31 judged judge VBN 40436 6034 32 . . . 40436 6035 1 On on IN 40436 6035 2 the the DT 40436 6035 3 contrary contrary NN 40436 6035 4 , , , 40436 6035 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6035 6 find find VBP 40436 6035 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6035 8 here here RB 40436 6035 9 announced announce VBN 40436 6035 10 by by IN 40436 6035 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6035 12 as as IN 40436 6035 13 among among IN 40436 6035 14 those those DT 40436 6035 15 dreaded dread VBN 40436 6035 16 by by IN 40436 6035 17 men man NNS 40436 6035 18 adverse adverse JJ 40436 6035 19 to to TO 40436 6035 20 philosophy,--and philosophy,--and XX 40436 6035 21 as as IN 40436 6035 22 not not RB 40436 6035 23 undeserving undeserve VBG 40436 6035 24 of of IN 40436 6035 25 that that DT 40436 6035 26 epithet epithet NN 40436 6035 27 which which WDT 40436 6035 28 the the DT 40436 6035 29 semi semi JJ 40436 6035 30 - - JJ 40436 6035 31 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6035 32 cited cite VBN 40436 6035 33 by by IN 40436 6035 34 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 6035 35 applies apply VBZ 40436 6035 36 to to IN 40436 6035 37 " " `` 40436 6035 38 one one CD 40436 6035 39 of of IN 40436 6035 40 the the DT 40436 6035 41 most most RBS 40436 6035 42 powerful powerful JJ 40436 6035 43 champions champion NNS 40436 6035 44 of of IN 40436 6035 45 the the DT 40436 6035 46 day day NN 40436 6035 47 " " '' 40436 6035 48 . . . 40436 6036 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6036 2 , , , 40436 6036 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 6036 4 , , , 40436 6036 5 after after IN 40436 6036 6 having have VBG 40436 6036 7 applied apply VBD 40436 6036 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6036 9 great great JJ 40436 6036 10 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 6036 11 talent talent NN 40436 6036 12 to to TO 40436 6036 13 make make VB 40436 6036 14 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 6036 15 debate debate NN 40436 6036 16 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 6036 17 , , , 40436 6036 18 and and CC 40436 6036 19 thus thus RB 40436 6036 20 said say VBD 40436 6036 21 much much JJ 40436 6036 22 to to TO 40436 6036 23 gratify gratify VB 40436 6036 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6036 25 enemies enemy NNS 40436 6036 26 -- -- : 40436 6036 27 changes change VBZ 40436 6036 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6036 29 battery battery NN 40436 6036 30 , , , 40436 6036 31 and and CC 40436 6036 32 says say VBZ 40436 6036 33 something something NN 40436 6036 34 against against IN 40436 6036 35 these these DT 40436 6036 36 enemies enemy NNS 40436 6036 37 , , , 40436 6036 38 without without IN 40436 6036 39 reflecting reflect VBG 40436 6036 40 whether whether IN 40436 6036 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6036 42 is be VBZ 40436 6036 43 consistent consistent JJ 40436 6036 44 or or CC 40436 6036 45 no no UH 40436 6036 46 with with IN 40436 6036 47 what what WP 40436 6036 48 had have VBD 40436 6036 49 preceded precede VBN 40436 6036 50 . . . 40436 6037 1 Before before IN 40436 6037 2 the the DT 40436 6037 3 close close NN 40436 6037 4 , , , 40436 6037 5 however however RB 40436 6037 6 , , , 40436 6037 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6037 8 comes come VBZ 40436 6037 9 again again RB 40436 6037 10 into into IN 40436 6037 11 consistency consistency NN 40436 6037 12 with with IN 40436 6037 13 the the DT 40436 6037 14 tone tone NN 40436 6037 15 of of IN 40436 6037 16 the the DT 40436 6037 17 earlier early JJR 40436 6037 18 part part NN 40436 6037 19 , , , 40436 6037 20 in in IN 40436 6037 21 the the DT 40436 6037 22 observation observation NN 40436 6037 23 which which WDT 40436 6037 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6037 25 assigns assign VBZ 40436 6037 26 to to IN 40436 6037 27 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 6037 28 , , , 40436 6037 29 that that IN 40436 6037 30 most most JJS 40436 6037 31 of of IN 40436 6037 32 the the DT 40436 6037 33 professors professor NNS 40436 6037 34 of of IN 40436 6037 35 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6037 36 are be VBP 40436 6037 37 worthless worthless JJ 40436 6037 38 ; ; : 40436 6037 39 to to TO 40436 6037 40 which which WDT 40436 6037 41 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6037 42 rejoins rejoin VBZ 40436 6037 43 that that IN 40436 6037 44 this this DT 40436 6037 45 is be VBZ 40436 6037 46 not not RB 40436 6037 47 less less RBR 40436 6037 48 true true JJ 40436 6037 49 of of IN 40436 6037 50 all all DT 40436 6037 51 other other JJ 40436 6037 52 professions profession NNS 40436 6037 53 . . . 40436 6038 1 The the DT 40436 6038 2 concluding conclude VBG 40436 6038 3 inference inference NN 40436 6038 4 is be VBZ 40436 6038 5 , , , 40436 6038 6 that that DT 40436 6038 7 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6038 8 is be VBZ 40436 6038 9 to to TO 40436 6038 10 be be VB 40436 6038 11 judged judge VBN 40436 6038 12 , , , 40436 6038 13 not not RB 40436 6038 14 by by IN 40436 6038 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6038 16 professors professor NNS 40436 6038 17 but but CC 40436 6038 18 by by IN 40436 6038 19 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 6038 20 ; ; : 40436 6038 21 and and CC 40436 6038 22 that that IN 40436 6038 23 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 6038 24 must must MD 40436 6038 25 examine examine VB 40436 6038 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6038 27 for for IN 40436 6038 28 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6038 29 , , , 40436 6038 30 and and CC 40436 6038 31 either either CC 40436 6038 32 pursue pursue VB 40436 6038 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6038 34 or or CC 40436 6038 35 leave leave VB 40436 6038 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6038 37 alone alone RB 40436 6038 38 , , , 40436 6038 39 according accord VBG 40436 6038 40 as as IN 40436 6038 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6038 42 own own JJ 40436 6038 43 convictions conviction NNS 40436 6038 44 dictated dictate VBN 40436 6038 45 . . . 40436 6039 1 This this DT 40436 6039 2 is be VBZ 40436 6039 3 a a DT 40436 6039 4 valuable valuable JJ 40436 6039 5 admonition admonition NN 40436 6039 6 , , , 40436 6039 7 and and CC 40436 6039 8 worthy worthy JJ 40436 6039 9 of of IN 40436 6039 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6039 11 , , , 40436 6039 12 laying lay VBG 40436 6039 13 full full JJ 40436 6039 14 stress stress NN 40436 6039 15 as as IN 40436 6039 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6039 17 does do VBZ 40436 6039 18 upon upon IN 40436 6039 19 the the DT 40436 6039 20 conscientious conscientious JJ 40436 6039 21 conviction conviction NN 40436 6039 22 which which WDT 40436 6039 23 the the DT 40436 6039 24 person person NN 40436 6039 25 examining examine VBG 40436 6039 26 may may MD 40436 6039 27 form form VB 40436 6039 28 for for IN 40436 6039 29 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6039 30 . . . 40436 6040 1 But but CC 40436 6040 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6040 3 is be VBZ 40436 6040 4 no no DT 40436 6040 5 answer answer NN 40436 6040 6 to to IN 40436 6040 7 the the DT 40436 6040 8 question question NN 40436 6040 9 of of IN 40436 6040 10 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 6040 11 ; ; : 40436 6040 12 who who WP 40436 6040 13 says say VBZ 40436 6040 14 that that IN 40436 6040 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6040 16 had have VBD 40436 6040 17 already already RB 40436 6040 18 heard hear VBN 40436 6040 19 from from IN 40436 6040 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6040 21 , , , 40436 6040 22 and and CC 40436 6040 23 was be VBD 40436 6040 24 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6040 25 convinced convinced JJ 40436 6040 26 , , , 40436 6040 27 that that DT 40436 6040 28 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6040 29 was be VBD 40436 6040 30 of of IN 40436 6040 31 first first JJ 40436 6040 32 - - HYPH 40436 6040 33 rate rate NN 40436 6040 34 importance importance NN 40436 6040 35 -- -- : 40436 6040 36 and and CC 40436 6040 37 that that IN 40436 6040 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6040 39 only only RB 40436 6040 40 desired desire VBD 40436 6040 41 to to TO 40436 6040 42 learn learn VB 40436 6040 43 where where WRB 40436 6040 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6040 45 could could MD 40436 6040 46 find find VB 40436 6040 47 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6040 48 to to TO 40436 6040 49 forward forward RB 40436 6040 50 the the DT 40436 6040 51 progress progress NN 40436 6040 52 of of IN 40436 6040 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6040 54 son son NN 40436 6040 55 in in IN 40436 6040 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6040 57 . . . 40436 6041 1 As as IN 40436 6041 2 in in IN 40436 6041 3 so so RB 40436 6041 4 many many JJ 40436 6041 5 other other JJ 40436 6041 6 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6041 7 , , , 40436 6041 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6041 9 leaves leave VBZ 40436 6041 10 the the DT 40436 6041 11 problem problem NN 40436 6041 12 started start VBD 40436 6041 13 , , , 40436 6041 14 but but CC 40436 6041 15 unsolved unsolved JJ 40436 6041 16 . . . 40436 6042 1 The the DT 40436 6042 2 impulse impulse NN 40436 6042 3 towards towards IN 40436 6042 4 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6042 5 being be VBG 40436 6042 6 assured assure VBN 40436 6042 7 , , , 40436 6042 8 those those DT 40436 6042 9 who who WP 40436 6042 10 feel feel VBP 40436 6042 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6042 12 ask ask VB 40436 6042 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6042 14 in in IN 40436 6042 15 what what WDT 40436 6042 16 direction direction NN 40436 6042 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6042 18 are be VBP 40436 6042 19 to to TO 40436 6042 20 move move VB 40436 6042 21 towards towards IN 40436 6042 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6042 23 . . . 40436 6043 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6043 2 gives give VBZ 40436 6043 3 no no DT 40436 6043 4 answer answer NN 40436 6043 5 . . . 40436 6044 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6044 2 can can MD 40436 6044 3 neither neither RB 40436 6044 4 perform perform VB 40436 6044 5 the the DT 40436 6044 6 service service NN 40436 6044 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6044 8 , , , 40436 6044 9 nor nor CC 40436 6044 10 recommend recommend VB 40436 6044 11 any any DT 40436 6044 12 one one NN 40436 6044 13 else else RB 40436 6044 14 , , , 40436 6044 15 as as RB 40436 6044 16 competent competent JJ 40436 6044 17 . . . 40436 6045 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6045 2 shall shall MD 40436 6045 3 find find VB 40436 6045 4 such such JJ 40436 6045 5 silence silence NN 40436 6045 6 made make VBN 40436 6045 7 matter matter NN 40436 6045 8 of of IN 40436 6045 9 pointed point VBN 40436 6045 10 animadversion animadversion NN 40436 6045 11 , , , 40436 6045 12 in in IN 40436 6045 13 the the DT 40436 6045 14 fragment fragment NN 40436 6045 15 called call VBN 40436 6045 16 Kleitophon Kleitophon NNP 40436 6045 17 . . . 40436 6046 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6046 2 Side side NN 40436 6046 3 - - HYPH 40436 6046 4 note note NN 40436 6046 5 : : : 40436 6046 6 Who who WP 40436 6046 7 is be VBZ 40436 6046 8 the the DT 40436 6046 9 person person NN 40436 6046 10 here here RB 40436 6046 11 intended intend VBN 40436 6046 12 by by IN 40436 6046 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6046 14 , , , 40436 6046 15 half half JJ 40436 6046 16 - - HYPH 40436 6046 17 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6046 18 , , , 40436 6046 19 half half JJ 40436 6046 20 - - HYPH 40436 6046 21 politician politician NN 40436 6046 22 ? ? . 40436 6047 1 Is be VBZ 40436 6047 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6047 3 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6047 4 ? ? . 40436 6047 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6048 1 The the DT 40436 6048 2 person person NN 40436 6048 3 , , , 40436 6048 4 whom whom WP 40436 6048 5 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 6048 6 here here RB 40436 6048 7 brings bring VBZ 40436 6048 8 forward forward RP 40436 6048 9 as as IN 40436 6048 10 the the DT 40436 6048 11 censor censor NN 40436 6048 12 of of IN 40436 6048 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6048 14 and and CC 40436 6048 15 the the DT 40436 6048 16 enemy enemy NN 40436 6048 17 of of IN 40436 6048 18 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6048 19 , , , 40436 6048 20 is be VBZ 40436 6048 21 peculiarly peculiarly RB 40436 6048 22 marked mark VBN 40436 6048 23 . . . 40436 6049 1 In in IN 40436 6049 2 general general JJ 40436 6049 3 , , , 40436 6049 4 the the DT 40436 6049 5 persons person NNS 40436 6049 6 whom whom WP 40436 6049 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6049 8 ranks rank VBZ 40436 6049 9 as as IN 40436 6049 10 enemies enemy NNS 40436 6049 11 of of IN 40436 6049 12 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6049 13 are be VBP 40436 6049 14 the the DT 40436 6049 15 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 6049 16 and and CC 40436 6049 17 politicians politician NNS 40436 6049 18 : : : 40436 6049 19 but but CC 40436 6049 20 the the DT 40436 6049 21 example example NN 40436 6049 22 here here RB 40436 6049 23 chosen choose VBN 40436 6049 24 is be VBZ 40436 6049 25 not not RB 40436 6049 26 comprised comprise VBN 40436 6049 27 in in IN 40436 6049 28 either either DT 40436 6049 29 of of IN 40436 6049 30 these these DT 40436 6049 31 classes class NNS 40436 6049 32 : : : 40436 6049 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6049 34 is be VBZ 40436 6049 35 a a DT 40436 6049 36 semi semi JJ 40436 6049 37 - - NN 40436 6049 38 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6049 39 , , , 40436 6049 40 yet yet CC 40436 6049 41 a a DT 40436 6049 42 writer writer NN 40436 6049 43 of of IN 40436 6049 44 discourses discourse NNS 40436 6049 45 for for IN 40436 6049 46 others other NNS 40436 6049 47 . . . 40436 6050 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6050 2 , , , 40436 6050 3 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 6050 4 , , , 40436 6050 5 and and CC 40436 6050 6 Spengel Spengel NNP 40436 6050 7 , , , 40436 6050 8 suppose suppose VB 40436 6050 9 that that IN 40436 6050 10 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6050 11 is be VBZ 40436 6050 12 the the DT 40436 6050 13 person person NN 40436 6050 14 intended intend VBN 40436 6050 15 : : : 40436 6050 16 Winckelmann Winckelmann NNP 40436 6050 17 thinks think VBZ 40436 6050 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6050 19 is be VBZ 40436 6050 20 Thrasymachus Thrasymachus NNP 40436 6050 21 : : : 40436 6050 22 others other NNS 40436 6050 23 refer refer VBP 40436 6050 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6050 25 to to IN 40436 6050 26 Lysias Lysias NNP 40436 6050 27 , , , 40436 6050 28 or or CC 40436 6050 29 Theodorus Theodorus NNP 40436 6050 30 of of IN 40436 6050 31 Byzantium:[73 Byzantium:[73 NNP 40436 6050 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6050 33 Socher Socher NNP 40436 6050 34 and and CC 40436 6050 35 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6050 36 doubt doubt NN 40436 6050 37 whether whether IN 40436 6050 38 any any DT 40436 6050 39 special special JJ 40436 6050 40 person person NN 40436 6050 41 is be VBZ 40436 6050 42 intended intend VBN 40436 6050 43 , , , 40436 6050 44 or or CC 40436 6050 45 any any DT 40436 6050 46 thing thing NN 40436 6050 47 beyond beyond IN 40436 6050 48 some some DT 40436 6050 49 supposed suppose VBN 40436 6050 50 representative representative NN 40436 6050 51 of of IN 40436 6050 52 a a DT 40436 6050 53 class class NN 40436 6050 54 described describe VBN 40436 6050 55 by by IN 40436 6050 56 attributes attribute NNS 40436 6050 57 . . . 40436 6051 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6051 2 rather rather RB 40436 6051 3 agree agree VBP 40436 6051 4 with with IN 40436 6051 5 those those DT 40436 6051 6 who who WP 40436 6051 7 refer refer VBP 40436 6051 8 the the DT 40436 6051 9 passage passage NN 40436 6051 10 to to IN 40436 6051 11 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6051 12 . . . 40436 6052 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6052 2 might may MD 40436 6052 3 naturally naturally RB 40436 6052 4 be be VB 40436 6052 5 described describe VBN 40436 6052 6 as as IN 40436 6052 7 one one CD 40436 6052 8 steering steer VBG 40436 6052 9 a a DT 40436 6052 10 middle middle JJ 40436 6052 11 course course NN 40436 6052 12 between between IN 40436 6052 13 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6052 14 and and CC 40436 6052 15 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 6052 16 : : : 40436 6052 17 which which WDT 40436 6052 18 in in IN 40436 6052 19 fact fact NN 40436 6052 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6052 21 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6052 22 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 6052 23 in in IN 40436 6052 24 the the DT 40436 6052 25 Oration Oration NNP 40436 6052 26 De De NNP 40436 6052 27 Permutatione Permutatione NNP 40436 6052 28 , , , 40436 6052 29 and and CC 40436 6052 30 which which WDT 40436 6052 31 agrees agree VBZ 40436 6052 32 with with IN 40436 6052 33 the the DT 40436 6052 34 language language NN 40436 6052 35 of of IN 40436 6052 36 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6052 37 in in IN 40436 6052 38 the the DT 40436 6052 39 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6052 40 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6052 41 , , , 40436 6052 42 where where WRB 40436 6052 43 Isokrates Isokrates NNP 40436 6052 44 is be VBZ 40436 6052 45 mentioned mention VBN 40436 6052 46 by by IN 40436 6052 47 name name NN 40436 6052 48 along along IN 40436 6052 49 with with IN 40436 6052 50 Lysias Lysias NNP 40436 6052 51 . . . 40436 6053 1 In in IN 40436 6053 2 the the DT 40436 6053 3 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6053 4 , , , 40436 6053 5 moreover moreover RB 40436 6053 6 , , , 40436 6053 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6053 8 speaks speak VBZ 40436 6053 9 of of IN 40436 6053 10 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6053 11 with with IN 40436 6053 12 unusual unusual JJ 40436 6053 13 esteem esteem NN 40436 6053 14 , , , 40436 6053 15 especially especially RB 40436 6053 16 as as IN 40436 6053 17 a a DT 40436 6053 18 favourable favourable JJ 40436 6053 19 contrast contrast NN 40436 6053 20 with with IN 40436 6053 21 Lysias Lysias NNP 40436 6053 22 , , , 40436 6053 23 and and CC 40436 6053 24 as as IN 40436 6053 25 a a DT 40436 6053 26 person person NN 40436 6053 27 who who WP 40436 6053 28 , , , 40436 6053 29 though though IN 40436 6053 30 not not RB 40436 6053 31 yet yet RB 40436 6053 32 a a DT 40436 6053 33 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6053 34 , , , 40436 6053 35 may may MD 40436 6053 36 be be VB 40436 6053 37 expected expect VBN 40436 6053 38 to to TO 40436 6053 39 improve improve VB 40436 6053 40 , , , 40436 6053 41 so so RB 40436 6053 42 as as IN 40436 6053 43 in in IN 40436 6053 44 no no DT 40436 6053 45 long long JJ 40436 6053 46 time time NN 40436 6053 47 to to TO 40436 6053 48 deserve deserve VB 40436 6053 49 that that DT 40436 6053 50 appellation appellation NN 40436 6053 51 . . . 40436 6054 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6054 2 74 74 CD 40436 6054 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6054 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6054 5 must must MD 40436 6054 6 remember remember VB 40436 6054 7 that that IN 40436 6054 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6054 9 in in IN 40436 6054 10 the the DT 40436 6054 11 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6054 12 attacks attack NNS 40436 6054 13 by by IN 40436 6054 14 name name NN 40436 6054 15 , , , 40436 6054 16 and and CC 40436 6054 17 with with IN 40436 6054 18 considerable considerable JJ 40436 6054 19 asperity asperity NN 40436 6054 20 , , , 40436 6054 21 first first JJ 40436 6054 22 Lysias Lysias NNP 40436 6054 23 , , , 40436 6054 24 next next JJ 40436 6054 25 Theodorus Theodorus NNP 40436 6054 26 and and CC 40436 6054 27 Thrasymachus Thrasymachus NNP 40436 6054 28 the the DT 40436 6054 29 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 6054 30 -- -- : 40436 6054 31 all all DT 40436 6054 32 three three CD 40436 6054 33 persons person NNS 40436 6054 34 living live VBG 40436 6054 35 and and CC 40436 6054 36 of of IN 40436 6054 37 note note NN 40436 6054 38 . . . 40436 6055 1 Being be VBG 40436 6055 2 sure sure JJ 40436 6055 3 to to TO 40436 6055 4 offend offend VB 40436 6055 5 all all PDT 40436 6055 6 these these DT 40436 6055 7 , , , 40436 6055 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6055 9 might may MD 40436 6055 10 well well RB 40436 6055 11 feel feel VB 40436 6055 12 disposed disposed JJ 40436 6055 13 to to TO 40436 6055 14 avoid avoid VB 40436 6055 15 making make VBG 40436 6055 16 an an DT 40436 6055 17 enemy enemy NN 40436 6055 18 of of IN 40436 6055 19 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6055 20 at at IN 40436 6055 21 the the DT 40436 6055 22 same same JJ 40436 6055 23 time time NN 40436 6055 24 , , , 40436 6055 25 and and CC 40436 6055 26 to to TO 40436 6055 27 except except IN 40436 6055 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6055 29 honourably honourably RB 40436 6055 30 by by IN 40436 6055 31 name name NN 40436 6055 32 from from IN 40436 6055 33 the the DT 40436 6055 34 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 6055 35 professors professor NNS 40436 6055 36 of of IN 40436 6055 37 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 6055 38 . . . 40436 6056 1 In in IN 40436 6056 2 the the DT 40436 6056 3 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6056 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6056 5 where where WRB 40436 6056 6 the the DT 40436 6056 7 satire satire NN 40436 6056 8 is be VBZ 40436 6056 9 directed direct VBN 40436 6056 10 not not RB 40436 6056 11 against against IN 40436 6056 12 the the DT 40436 6056 13 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 6056 14 , , , 40436 6056 15 but but CC 40436 6056 16 against against IN 40436 6056 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6056 18 competitors competitor NNS 40436 6056 19 the the DT 40436 6056 20 dialecticians dialecticians NNPS 40436 6056 21 or or CC 40436 6056 22 pseudo pseudo NN 40436 6056 23 - - HYPH 40436 6056 24 dialecticians dialecticians NNP 40436 6056 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6056 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6056 27 had have VBD 40436 6056 28 no no DT 40436 6056 29 similar similar JJ 40436 6056 30 motive motive NN 40436 6056 31 to to TO 40436 6056 32 address address VB 40436 6056 33 compliments compliment NNS 40436 6056 34 to to IN 40436 6056 35 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6056 36 : : : 40436 6056 37 respecting respect VBG 40436 6056 38 whom whom WP 40436 6056 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6056 40 speaks speak VBZ 40436 6056 41 in in IN 40436 6056 42 a a DT 40436 6056 43 manner manner NN 40436 6056 44 probably probably RB 40436 6056 45 more more RBR 40436 6056 46 conformable conformable JJ 40436 6056 47 to to IN 40436 6056 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6056 49 real real JJ 40436 6056 50 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 6056 51 , , , 40436 6056 52 as as IN 40436 6056 53 the the DT 40436 6056 54 unnamed unnamed JJ 40436 6056 55 representative representative NN 40436 6056 56 of of IN 40436 6056 57 a a DT 40436 6056 58 certain certain JJ 40436 6056 59 type type NN 40436 6056 60 of of IN 40436 6056 61 character character NN 40436 6056 62 -- -- : 40436 6056 63 a a DT 40436 6056 64 semi semi JJ 40436 6056 65 - - NN 40436 6056 66 philosopher philosopher JJ 40436 6056 67 , , , 40436 6056 68 fancying fancy VBG 40436 6056 69 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6056 70 among among IN 40436 6056 71 the the DT 40436 6056 72 first first JJ 40436 6056 73 men man NNS 40436 6056 74 in in IN 40436 6056 75 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6056 76 , , , 40436 6056 77 and and CC 40436 6056 78 assuming assume VBG 40436 6056 79 unwarrantable unwarrantable JJ 40436 6056 80 superiority superiority NN 40436 6056 81 over over IN 40436 6056 82 the the DT 40436 6056 83 genuine genuine JJ 40436 6056 84 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6056 85 ; ; : 40436 6056 86 but but CC 40436 6056 87 entitled entitle VBN 40436 6056 88 to to IN 40436 6056 89 nothing nothing NN 40436 6056 90 more more JJR 40436 6056 91 than than IN 40436 6056 92 a a DT 40436 6056 93 decent decent JJ 40436 6056 94 measure measure NN 40436 6056 95 of of IN 40436 6056 96 esteem esteem NN 40436 6056 97 , , , 40436 6056 98 such such JJ 40436 6056 99 as as IN 40436 6056 100 belonged belong VBN 40436 6056 101 to to IN 40436 6056 102 sincere sincere JJ 40436 6056 103 mediocrity mediocrity NN 40436 6056 104 of of IN 40436 6056 105 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 6056 106 . . . 40436 6057 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6057 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6057 3 73 73 CD 40436 6057 4 : : : 40436 6057 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6057 6 , , , 40436 6057 7 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 6057 8 . . . 40436 6058 1 ad ad NN 40436 6058 2 Euthyd Euthyd NNP 40436 6058 3 . . . 40436 6059 1 p. p. NN 40436 6059 2 47 47 CD 40436 6059 3 ; ; : 40436 6059 4 Winckelmann Winckelmann NNP 40436 6059 5 . . . 40436 6060 1 Proleg proleg NN 40436 6060 2 . . . 40436 6061 1 p. p. NN 40436 6061 2 xxxv xxxv NNP 40436 6061 3 . . . 40436 6062 1 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 6062 2 , , , 40436 6062 3 in in IN 40436 6062 4 endeavouring endeavour VBG 40436 6062 5 to to TO 40436 6062 6 explain explain VB 40436 6062 7 the the DT 40436 6062 8 difference difference NN 40436 6062 9 between between IN 40436 6062 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6062 11 's 's POS 40436 6062 12 language language NN 40436 6062 13 in in IN 40436 6062 14 the the DT 40436 6062 15 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6062 16 and and CC 40436 6062 17 in in IN 40436 6062 18 the the DT 40436 6062 19 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6062 20 respecting respect VBG 40436 6062 21 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6062 22 , , , 40436 6062 23 assumes assume VBZ 40436 6062 24 as as IN 40436 6062 25 a a DT 40436 6062 26 matter matter NN 40436 6062 27 beyond beyond IN 40436 6062 28 question question NN 40436 6062 29 the the DT 40436 6062 30 theory theory NN 40436 6062 31 of of IN 40436 6062 32 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6062 33 , , , 40436 6062 34 that that IN 40436 6062 35 the the DT 40436 6062 36 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6062 37 was be VBD 40436 6062 38 composed compose VBN 40436 6062 39 during during IN 40436 6062 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6062 41 's 's POS 40436 6062 42 early early JJ 40436 6062 43 years year NNS 40436 6062 44 . . . 40436 6063 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6063 2 have have VBP 40436 6063 3 already already RB 40436 6063 4 intimated intimate VBN 40436 6063 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6063 6 may may NNP 40436 6063 7 dissent dissent NN 40436 6063 8 from from IN 40436 6063 9 this this DT 40436 6063 10 theory theory NN 40436 6063 11 . . . 40436 6063 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6064 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6064 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6064 3 74 74 CD 40436 6064 4 : : : 40436 6064 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6064 6 , , , 40436 6064 7 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6064 8 , , , 40436 6064 9 p. p. NN 40436 6064 10 278 278 CD 40436 6064 11 E. E. NNP 40436 6064 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6064 13 have have VBP 40436 6064 14 already already RB 40436 6064 15 observed observe VBN 40436 6064 16 that that IN 40436 6064 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6064 18 do do VBP 40436 6064 19 not not RB 40436 6064 20 agree agree VB 40436 6064 21 with with IN 40436 6064 22 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6064 23 and and CC 40436 6064 24 the the DT 40436 6064 25 other other JJ 40436 6064 26 critics critic NNS 40436 6064 27 who who WP 40436 6064 28 rank rank VBP 40436 6064 29 the the DT 40436 6064 30 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6064 31 as as IN 40436 6064 32 the the DT 40436 6064 33 earliest early JJS 40436 6064 34 or or CC 40436 6064 35 even even RB 40436 6064 36 among among IN 40436 6064 37 the the DT 40436 6064 38 earliest early JJS 40436 6064 39 compositions composition NNS 40436 6064 40 of of IN 40436 6064 41 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6064 42 . . . 40436 6065 1 That that IN 40436 6065 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6065 3 is be VBZ 40436 6065 4 of of IN 40436 6065 5 much much JJ 40436 6065 6 later later JJ 40436 6065 7 composition composition NN 40436 6065 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6065 9 am be VBP 40436 6065 10 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 6065 11 , , , 40436 6065 12 but but CC 40436 6065 13 of of IN 40436 6065 14 what what WP 40436 6065 15 particular particular JJ 40436 6065 16 date date NN 40436 6065 17 can can MD 40436 6065 18 only only RB 40436 6065 19 be be VB 40436 6065 20 conjectured conjecture VBN 40436 6065 21 . . . 40436 6066 1 The the DT 40436 6066 2 opinion opinion NN 40436 6066 3 of of IN 40436 6066 4 K. K. NNP 40436 6066 5 F. F. NNP 40436 6066 6 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 6066 7 , , , 40436 6066 8 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6066 9 , , , 40436 6066 10 and and CC 40436 6066 11 others other NNS 40436 6066 12 , , , 40436 6066 13 that that IN 40436 6066 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6066 15 was be VBD 40436 6066 16 composed compose VBN 40436 6066 17 about about IN 40436 6066 18 the the DT 40436 6066 19 time time NN 40436 6066 20 when when WRB 40436 6066 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6066 22 began begin VBD 40436 6066 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6066 24 school school NN 40436 6066 25 at at IN 40436 6066 26 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6066 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6066 28 387 387 CD 40436 6066 29 - - SYM 40436 6066 30 386 386 CD 40436 6066 31 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 6066 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6067 1 is be VBZ 40436 6067 2 sufficiently sufficiently RB 40436 6067 3 probable probable JJ 40436 6067 4 . . . 40436 6068 1 The the DT 40436 6068 2 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6068 3 may may MD 40436 6068 4 be be VB 40436 6068 5 earlier early RBR 40436 6068 6 or or CC 40436 6068 7 may may MD 40436 6068 8 be be VB 40436 6068 9 later later RB 40436 6068 10 than than IN 40436 6068 11 the the DT 40436 6068 12 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6068 13 . . . 40436 6069 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6069 2 incline incline VBP 40436 6069 3 to to TO 40436 6069 4 think think VB 40436 6069 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6069 6 later later RB 40436 6069 7 . . . 40436 6070 1 The the DT 40436 6070 2 opinion opinion NN 40436 6070 3 of of IN 40436 6070 4 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6070 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6070 6 resting rest VBG 40436 6070 7 upon upon IN 40436 6070 8 the the DT 40436 6070 9 mention mention NN 40436 6070 10 of of IN 40436 6070 11 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 6070 12 , , , 40436 6070 13 p. p. NN 40436 6070 14 275 275 CD 40436 6070 15 A a NN 40436 6070 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6070 17 , , , 40436 6070 18 that that IN 40436 6070 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6070 20 was be VBD 40436 6070 21 composed compose VBN 40436 6070 22 in in IN 40436 6070 23 or or CC 40436 6070 24 before before IN 40436 6070 25 404 404 CD 40436 6070 26 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 6070 27 , , , 40436 6070 28 appears appear VBZ 40436 6070 29 to to IN 40436 6070 30 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6070 31 untenable untenable JJ 40436 6070 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6070 33 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6070 34 , , , 40436 6070 35 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 6070 36 . . . 40436 6071 1 p. p. NN 40436 6071 2 64 64 CD 40436 6071 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6071 4 . . . 40436 6072 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6072 2 would would MD 40436 6072 3 not not RB 40436 6072 4 be be VB 40436 6072 5 likely likely JJ 40436 6072 6 to to TO 40436 6072 7 introduce introduce VB 40436 6072 8 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6072 9 speaking speak VBG 40436 6072 10 of of IN 40436 6072 11 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 6072 12 as as IN 40436 6072 13 a a DT 40436 6072 14 deceased deceased JJ 40436 6072 15 person person NN 40436 6072 16 , , , 40436 6072 17 whatever whatever WDT 40436 6072 18 time time NN 40436 6072 19 the the DT 40436 6072 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6072 21 was be VBD 40436 6072 22 composed compose VBN 40436 6072 23 . . . 40436 6073 1 Nor nor CC 40436 6073 2 can can MD 40436 6073 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6073 4 agree agree VB 40436 6073 5 with with IN 40436 6073 6 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 6073 7 , , , 40436 6073 8 who who WP 40436 6073 9 refers refer VBZ 40436 6073 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6073 11 to to IN 40436 6073 12 402 402 CD 40436 6073 13 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 6074 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6074 2 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 6074 3 , , , 40436 6074 4 p. p. NN 40436 6074 5 26 26 CD 40436 6074 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6074 7 . . . 40436 6075 1 Ueberweg Ueberweg NNP 40436 6075 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6075 3 Untersuch Untersuch NNP 40436 6075 4 . . . 40436 6076 1 über über NNP 40436 6076 2 die die VBP 40436 6076 3 Zeitfolge Zeitfolge NNP 40436 6076 4 der der VBP 40436 6076 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6076 6 . . . 40436 6077 1 Schr Schr NNP 40436 6077 2 . . . 40436 6078 1 pp pp NNP 40436 6078 2 . . . 40436 6079 1 265 265 CD 40436 6079 2 - - SYM 40436 6079 3 267 267 CD 40436 6079 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6079 5 considers consider VBZ 40436 6079 6 the the DT 40436 6079 7 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6079 8 later later RB 40436 6079 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6079 10 but but CC 40436 6079 11 not not RB 40436 6079 12 much much RB 40436 6079 13 later later RB 40436 6079 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6079 15 than than IN 40436 6079 16 the the DT 40436 6079 17 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6079 18 , , , 40436 6079 19 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 6079 20 to to IN 40436 6079 21 the the DT 40436 6079 22 establishment establishment NN 40436 6079 23 of of IN 40436 6079 24 the the DT 40436 6079 25 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6079 26 school school NN 40436 6079 27 at at IN 40436 6079 28 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6079 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6079 30 387 387 CD 40436 6079 31 - - SYM 40436 6079 32 386 386 CD 40436 6079 33 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 6079 34 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6080 1 This this DT 40436 6080 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 6080 3 to to IN 40436 6080 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6080 5 more more RBR 40436 6080 6 probable probable JJ 40436 6080 7 than than IN 40436 6080 8 the the DT 40436 6080 9 contrary contrary NN 40436 6080 10 . . . 40436 6081 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6081 2 , , , 40436 6081 3 in in IN 40436 6081 4 arranging arrange VBG 40436 6081 5 the the DT 40436 6081 6 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6081 7 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6081 8 , , , 40436 6081 9 ranks rank VBZ 40436 6081 10 the the DT 40436 6081 11 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6081 12 as as IN 40436 6081 13 an an DT 40436 6081 14 immediate immediate JJ 40436 6081 15 sequel sequel NN 40436 6081 16 to to IN 40436 6081 17 the the DT 40436 6081 18 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6081 19 , , , 40436 6081 20 and and CC 40436 6081 21 as as IN 40436 6081 22 presupposing presuppose VBG 40436 6081 23 both both CC 40436 6081 24 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6081 25 and and CC 40436 6081 26 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 6081 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6081 28 Einl Einl NNP 40436 6081 29 . . . 40436 6082 1 pp pp NNP 40436 6082 2 . . . 40436 6083 1 400 400 CD 40436 6083 2 - - SYM 40436 6083 3 401 401 CD 40436 6083 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6083 5 . . . 40436 6084 1 Socher Socher NNP 40436 6084 2 agrees agree VBZ 40436 6084 3 in in IN 40436 6084 4 this this DT 40436 6084 5 opinion opinion NN 40436 6084 6 , , , 40436 6084 7 but but CC 40436 6084 8 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 6084 9 rejects reject VBZ 40436 6084 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6084 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6084 12 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 6084 13 . . . 40436 6085 1 p. p. NN 40436 6085 2 26 26 CD 40436 6085 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6085 4 , , , 40436 6085 5 placing place VBG 40436 6085 6 the the DT 40436 6085 7 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6085 8 immediately immediately RB 40436 6085 9 after after IN 40436 6085 10 the the DT 40436 6085 11 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6085 12 , , , 40436 6085 13 and and CC 40436 6085 14 immediately immediately RB 40436 6085 15 before before IN 40436 6085 16 the the DT 40436 6085 17 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6085 18 and and CC 40436 6085 19 the the DT 40436 6085 20 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6085 21 ; ; : 40436 6085 22 according accord VBG 40436 6085 23 to to IN 40436 6085 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6085 25 , , , 40436 6085 26 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6085 27 , , , 40436 6085 28 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6085 29 , , , 40436 6085 30 and and CC 40436 6085 31 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6085 32 , , , 40436 6085 33 form form VBP 40436 6085 34 a a DT 40436 6085 35 well well RB 40436 6085 36 marked mark VBN 40436 6085 37 Trilogy trilogy NN 40436 6085 38 . . . 40436 6086 1 Neither neither DT 40436 6086 2 of of IN 40436 6086 3 these these DT 40436 6086 4 arrangements arrangement NNS 40436 6086 5 rests rest VBZ 40436 6086 6 upon upon IN 40436 6086 7 any any DT 40436 6086 8 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 6086 9 reasons reason NNS 40436 6086 10 . . . 40436 6087 1 The the DT 40436 6087 2 chronological chronological JJ 40436 6087 3 order order NN 40436 6087 4 can can MD 40436 6087 5 not not RB 40436 6087 6 be be VB 40436 6087 7 determined determine VBN 40436 6087 8 . . . 40436 6087 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6088 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6088 2 Side side NN 40436 6088 3 - - HYPH 40436 6088 4 note note NN 40436 6088 5 : : : 40436 6088 6 Variable variable JJ 40436 6088 7 feeling feeling NN 40436 6088 8 at at IN 40436 6088 9 different different JJ 40436 6088 10 times time NNS 40436 6088 11 , , , 40436 6088 12 between between IN 40436 6088 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6088 14 and and CC 40436 6088 15 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6088 16 . . . 40436 6088 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6089 1 That that IN 40436 6089 2 there there EX 40436 6089 3 prevailed prevail VBD 40436 6089 4 at at IN 40436 6089 5 different different JJ 40436 6089 6 times time NNS 40436 6089 7 different different JJ 40436 6089 8 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 6089 9 , , , 40436 6089 10 more more RBR 40436 6089 11 or or CC 40436 6089 12 less less JJR 40436 6089 13 of of IN 40436 6089 14 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 6089 15 esteem esteem NN 40436 6089 16 or or CC 40436 6089 17 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 6089 18 jealousy jealousy NN 40436 6089 19 , , , 40436 6089 20 between between IN 40436 6089 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6089 22 and and CC 40436 6089 23 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6089 24 , , , 40436 6089 25 ought ought MD 40436 6089 26 not not RB 40436 6089 27 to to TO 40436 6089 28 be be VB 40436 6089 29 matter matter NN 40436 6089 30 of of IN 40436 6089 31 surprise surprise NN 40436 6089 32 . . . 40436 6090 1 Both both DT 40436 6090 2 of of IN 40436 6090 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6090 4 were be VBD 40436 6090 5 celebrated celebrate VBN 40436 6090 6 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6090 7 of of IN 40436 6090 8 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6090 9 , , , 40436 6090 10 each each DT 40436 6090 11 in in IN 40436 6090 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6090 13 own own JJ 40436 6090 14 manner manner NN 40436 6090 15 , , , 40436 6090 16 during during IN 40436 6090 17 the the DT 40436 6090 18 last last JJ 40436 6090 19 forty forty NN 40436 6090 20 years year NNS 40436 6090 21 of of IN 40436 6090 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6090 23 's 's POS 40436 6090 24 life life NN 40436 6090 25 : : : 40436 6090 26 both both DT 40436 6090 27 of of IN 40436 6090 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6090 29 enjoyed enjoy VBD 40436 6090 30 the the DT 40436 6090 31 favour favour NN 40436 6090 32 of of IN 40436 6090 33 foreign foreign JJ 40436 6090 34 princes prince NNS 40436 6090 35 , , , 40436 6090 36 and and CC 40436 6090 37 received receive VBD 40436 6090 38 pupils pupil NNS 40436 6090 39 from from IN 40436 6090 40 outlying outlying JJ 40436 6090 41 , , , 40436 6090 42 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 6090 43 distant distant JJ 40436 6090 44 , , , 40436 6090 45 cities city NNS 40436 6090 46 -- -- : 40436 6090 47 from from IN 40436 6090 48 Bosphorus Bosphorus NNP 40436 6090 49 and and CC 40436 6090 50 Cyprus Cyprus NNP 40436 6090 51 in in IN 40436 6090 52 the the DT 40436 6090 53 East East NNP 40436 6090 54 , , , 40436 6090 55 and and CC 40436 6090 56 from from IN 40436 6090 57 Sicily Sicily NNP 40436 6090 58 in in IN 40436 6090 59 the the DT 40436 6090 60 West West NNP 40436 6090 61 . . . 40436 6091 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6091 2 know know VBP 40436 6091 3 moreover moreover RB 40436 6091 4 that that IN 40436 6091 5 during during IN 40436 6091 6 the the DT 40436 6091 7 years year NNS 40436 6091 8 immediately immediately RB 40436 6091 9 preceding precede VBG 40436 6091 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6091 11 's 's POS 40436 6091 12 death death NN 40436 6091 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6091 14 347 347 CD 40436 6091 15 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 6092 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6092 2 , , , 40436 6092 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6092 4 pupil pupil NN 40436 6092 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6092 6 , , , 40436 6092 7 then then RB 40436 6092 8 rising rise VBG 40436 6092 9 into into IN 40436 6092 10 importance importance NN 40436 6092 11 as as IN 40436 6092 12 a a DT 40436 6092 13 teacher teacher NN 40436 6092 14 of of IN 40436 6092 15 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 6092 16 , , , 40436 6092 17 was be VBD 40436 6092 18 engaged engage VBN 40436 6092 19 in in IN 40436 6092 20 acrimonious acrimonious JJ 40436 6092 21 literary literary JJ 40436 6092 22 warfare warfare NN 40436 6092 23 , , , 40436 6092 24 seemingly seemingly RB 40436 6092 25 of of IN 40436 6092 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6092 27 own own JJ 40436 6092 28 seeking seeking NN 40436 6092 29 , , , 40436 6092 30 with with IN 40436 6092 31 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6092 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6092 33 then then RB 40436 6092 34 advanced advance VBN 40436 6092 35 in in IN 40436 6092 36 years year NNS 40436 6092 37 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6092 38 and and CC 40436 6092 39 some some DT 40436 6092 40 of of IN 40436 6092 41 the the DT 40436 6092 42 Isokratean isokratean JJ 40436 6092 43 pupils pupil NNS 40436 6092 44 . . . 40436 6093 1 The the DT 40436 6093 2 little little JJ 40436 6093 3 which which WDT 40436 6093 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6093 5 learn learn VBP 40436 6093 6 concerning concern VBG 40436 6093 7 the the DT 40436 6093 8 literary literary JJ 40436 6093 9 and and CC 40436 6093 10 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 6093 11 world world NN 40436 6093 12 of of IN 40436 6093 13 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6093 14 , , , 40436 6093 15 represents represent VBZ 40436 6093 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6093 17 as as RB 40436 6093 18 much much RB 40436 6093 19 distracted distract VBN 40436 6093 20 by by IN 40436 6093 21 feuds feud NNS 40436 6093 22 and and CC 40436 6093 23 jealousies jealousy NNS 40436 6093 24 . . . 40436 6094 1 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 6094 2 on on IN 40436 6094 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6094 4 part part NN 40436 6094 5 has have VBZ 40436 6094 6 in in IN 40436 6094 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6094 8 compositions composition NNS 40436 6094 9 various various JJ 40436 6094 10 passages passage NNS 40436 6094 11 which which WDT 40436 6094 12 appear appear VBP 40436 6094 13 to to TO 40436 6094 14 allude allude VB 40436 6094 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6094 16 no no DT 40436 6094 17 name name NN 40436 6094 18 being be VBG 40436 6094 19 mentioned mention VBN 40436 6094 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6094 21 to to IN 40436 6094 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6094 23 among among IN 40436 6094 24 others other NNS 40436 6094 25 , , , 40436 6094 26 in in IN 40436 6094 27 a a DT 40436 6094 28 tone tone NN 40436 6094 29 of of IN 40436 6094 30 depreciation depreciation NN 40436 6094 31 . . . 40436 6095 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6095 2 75 75 CD 40436 6095 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6095 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6095 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6095 6 75 75 CD 40436 6095 7 : : : 40436 6095 8 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 6095 9 , , , 40436 6095 10 ad ad NN 40436 6095 11 Philipp Philipp NNP 40436 6095 12 . . . 40436 6096 1 Or or CC 40436 6096 2 . . . 40436 6097 1 v. v. NNP 40436 6097 2 s. s. NNP 40436 6097 3 14 14 CD 40436 6097 4 , , , 40436 6097 5 p. p. NN 40436 6097 6 84 84 CD 40436 6097 7 ; ; : 40436 6097 8 contra contra NNP 40436 6097 9 Sophistas Sophistas NNP 40436 6097 10 , , , 40436 6097 11 Or or CC 40436 6097 12 . . . 40436 6098 1 xiii xiii NNP 40436 6098 2 . . . 40436 6099 1 ; ; : 40436 6099 2 Or or CC 40436 6099 3 . . . 40436 6100 1 xiii xiii NNP 40436 6100 2 . . . 40436 6101 1 s. s. NNP 40436 6101 2 2 2 CD 40436 6101 3 - - SYM 40436 6101 4 24 24 CD 40436 6101 5 , , , 40436 6101 6 pp pp NNP 40436 6101 7 . . . 40436 6102 1 291 291 CD 40436 6102 2 - - SYM 40436 6102 3 295 295 CD 40436 6102 4 ; ; : 40436 6102 5 Encom Encom NNP 40436 6102 6 . . . 40436 6103 1 Helenæ Helenæ NNP 40436 6103 2 , , , 40436 6103 3 Or or CC 40436 6103 4 . . . 40436 6104 1 x. x. NNP 40436 6105 1 init init NNP 40436 6105 2 . . . 40436 6106 1 ; ; : 40436 6106 2 Panathenaic Panathenaic NNP 40436 6106 3 . . . 40436 6107 1 Or or CC 40436 6107 2 . . . 40436 6108 1 xii xii NNP 40436 6108 2 . . . 40436 6109 1 s. s. NNP 40436 6109 2 126 126 CD 40436 6109 3 , , , 40436 6109 4 p. p. NN 40436 6109 5 257 257 CD 40436 6109 6 ; ; : 40436 6109 7 Or or CC 40436 6109 8 . . . 40436 6110 1 xv xv NNP 40436 6110 2 . . . 40436 6111 1 De De NNP 40436 6111 2 Permutatione Permutatione NNP 40436 6111 3 , , , 40436 6111 4 s. s. NNP 40436 6111 5 90 90 CD 40436 6111 6 , , , 40436 6111 7 p. p. NN 40436 6111 8 440 440 CD 40436 6111 9 , , , 40436 6111 10 Bekk Bekk NNP 40436 6111 11 . . . 40436 6111 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6112 1 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 6112 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 6112 3 , , , 40436 6112 4 as as RB 40436 6112 5 far far RB 40436 6112 6 as as IN 40436 6112 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6112 8 can can MD 40436 6112 9 make make VB 40436 6112 10 out out RP 40436 6112 11 , , , 40436 6112 12 to to TO 40436 6112 13 have have VB 40436 6112 14 been be VBN 40436 6112 15 in in IN 40436 6112 16 early early JJ 40436 6112 17 life life NN 40436 6112 18 , , , 40436 6112 19 like like IN 40436 6112 20 Lysias Lysias NNP 40436 6112 21 , , , 40436 6112 22 a a DT 40436 6112 23 composer composer NN 40436 6112 24 of of IN 40436 6112 25 speeches speech NNS 40436 6112 26 to to TO 40436 6112 27 be be VB 40436 6112 28 spoken speak VBN 40436 6112 29 by by IN 40436 6112 30 clients client NNS 40436 6112 31 in in IN 40436 6112 32 the the DT 40436 6112 33 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 6112 34 . . . 40436 6113 1 This this DT 40436 6113 2 lucrative lucrative JJ 40436 6113 3 profession profession NN 40436 6113 4 was be VBD 40436 6113 5 tempting tempting JJ 40436 6113 6 , , , 40436 6113 7 since since IN 40436 6113 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6113 9 family family NN 40436 6113 10 had have VBD 40436 6113 11 been be VBN 40436 6113 12 nearly nearly RB 40436 6113 13 ruined ruin VBN 40436 6113 14 during during IN 40436 6113 15 the the DT 40436 6113 16 misfortunes misfortune NNS 40436 6113 17 of of IN 40436 6113 18 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6113 19 at at IN 40436 6113 20 the the DT 40436 6113 21 close close NN 40436 6113 22 of of IN 40436 6113 23 the the DT 40436 6113 24 Peloponnesian peloponnesian JJ 40436 6113 25 war war NN 40436 6113 26 . . . 40436 6114 1 Having have VBG 40436 6114 2 gained gain VBN 40436 6114 3 reputation reputation NN 40436 6114 4 by by IN 40436 6114 5 such such JJ 40436 6114 6 means mean NNS 40436 6114 7 , , , 40436 6114 8 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6114 9 became become VBD 40436 6114 10 in in IN 40436 6114 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6114 12 mature mature JJ 40436 6114 13 age age NN 40436 6114 14 a a DT 40436 6114 15 teacher teacher NN 40436 6114 16 of of IN 40436 6114 17 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 6114 18 , , , 40436 6114 19 and and CC 40436 6114 20 a a DT 40436 6114 21 composer composer NN 40436 6114 22 of of IN 40436 6114 23 discourses discourse NNS 40436 6114 24 , , , 40436 6114 25 not not RB 40436 6114 26 for for IN 40436 6114 27 private private JJ 40436 6114 28 use use NN 40436 6114 29 by by IN 40436 6114 30 clients client NNS 40436 6114 31 , , , 40436 6114 32 but but CC 40436 6114 33 for for IN 40436 6114 34 the the DT 40436 6114 35 general general JJ 40436 6114 36 reader reader NN 40436 6114 37 , , , 40436 6114 38 on on IN 40436 6114 39 political political JJ 40436 6114 40 or or CC 40436 6114 41 educational educational JJ 40436 6114 42 topics topic NNS 40436 6114 43 . . . 40436 6115 1 In in IN 40436 6115 2 this this DT 40436 6115 3 character character NN 40436 6115 4 , , , 40436 6115 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6115 6 corresponded correspond VBD 40436 6115 7 to to IN 40436 6115 8 the the DT 40436 6115 9 description description NN 40436 6115 10 given give VBN 40436 6115 11 by by IN 40436 6115 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6115 13 in in IN 40436 6115 14 the the DT 40436 6115 15 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6115 16 : : : 40436 6115 17 being be VBG 40436 6115 18 partly partly RB 40436 6115 19 a a DT 40436 6115 20 public public JJ 40436 6115 21 adviser adviser NN 40436 6115 22 , , , 40436 6115 23 partly partly RB 40436 6115 24 a a DT 40436 6115 25 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6115 26 . . . 40436 6116 1 But but CC 40436 6116 2 the the DT 40436 6116 3 general general JJ 40436 6116 4 principle principle NN 40436 6116 5 under under IN 40436 6116 6 which which WDT 40436 6116 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6116 8 here here RB 40436 6116 9 attacks attack VBZ 40436 6116 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6116 11 , , , 40436 6116 12 though though IN 40436 6116 13 conforming conform VBG 40436 6116 14 to to IN 40436 6116 15 the the DT 40436 6116 16 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6116 17 of of IN 40436 6116 18 the the DT 40436 6116 19 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6116 20 Republic Republic NNP 40436 6116 21 , , , 40436 6116 22 is be VBZ 40436 6116 23 contrary contrary JJ 40436 6116 24 to to IN 40436 6116 25 that that DT 40436 6116 26 of of IN 40436 6116 27 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6116 28 in in IN 40436 6116 29 other other JJ 40436 6116 30 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6116 31 , , , 40436 6116 32 " " `` 40436 6116 33 You -PRON- PRP 40436 6116 34 must must MD 40436 6116 35 devote devote VB 40436 6116 36 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6116 37 either either CC 40436 6116 38 wholly wholly RB 40436 6116 39 to to IN 40436 6116 40 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6116 41 , , , 40436 6116 42 or or CC 40436 6116 43 wholly wholly RB 40436 6116 44 to to IN 40436 6116 45 politics politic NNS 40436 6116 46 : : : 40436 6116 47 a a DT 40436 6116 48 mixture mixture NN 40436 6116 49 of of IN 40436 6116 50 the the DT 40436 6116 51 two two CD 40436 6116 52 is be VBZ 40436 6116 53 worse bad JJR 40436 6116 54 than than IN 40436 6116 55 either"--this either"--this DT 40436 6116 56 agrees agree VBZ 40436 6116 57 with with IN 40436 6116 58 the the DT 40436 6116 59 Republic Republic NNP 40436 6116 60 , , , 40436 6116 61 wherein wherein WRB 40436 6116 62 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6116 63 enjoins enjoin VBZ 40436 6116 64 upon upon IN 40436 6116 65 each each DT 40436 6116 66 man man NN 40436 6116 67 one one CD 40436 6116 68 special special JJ 40436 6116 69 and and CC 40436 6116 70 exclusive exclusive JJ 40436 6116 71 pursuit pursuit NN 40436 6116 72 , , , 40436 6116 73 as as RB 40436 6116 74 well well RB 40436 6116 75 as as IN 40436 6116 76 with with IN 40436 6116 77 the the DT 40436 6116 78 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6116 79 maintained maintain VBD 40436 6116 80 against against IN 40436 6116 81 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 6116 82 in in IN 40436 6116 83 the the DT 40436 6116 84 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6116 85 -- -- : 40436 6116 86 but but CC 40436 6116 87 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6116 88 differs differ VBZ 40436 6116 89 from from IN 40436 6116 90 the the DT 40436 6116 91 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6116 92 , , , 40436 6116 93 where where WRB 40436 6116 94 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6116 95 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 6116 96 the the DT 40436 6116 97 excellence excellence NN 40436 6116 98 of of IN 40436 6116 99 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 6116 100 as as IN 40436 6116 101 a a DT 40436 6116 102 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 6116 103 and and CC 40436 6116 104 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 6116 105 , , , 40436 6116 106 to to IN 40436 6116 107 the the DT 40436 6116 108 fact fact NN 40436 6116 109 of of IN 40436 6116 110 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6116 111 having have VBG 40436 6116 112 acquired acquire VBN 40436 6116 113 a a DT 40436 6116 114 large large JJ 40436 6116 115 tincture tincture NN 40436 6116 116 of of IN 40436 6116 117 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6116 118 . . . 40436 6117 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6117 2 76 76 CD 40436 6117 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6117 4 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 6117 5 quotes quote VBZ 40436 6117 6 this this DT 40436 6117 7 last last JJ 40436 6117 8 passage passage NN 40436 6117 9 as as IN 40436 6117 10 applicable applicable JJ 40436 6117 11 to to IN 40436 6117 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6117 13 own own JJ 40436 6117 14 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 6117 15 career career NN 40436 6117 16 , , , 40436 6117 17 a a DT 40436 6117 18 combination combination NN 40436 6117 19 of of IN 40436 6117 20 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6117 21 with with IN 40436 6117 22 politics politic NNS 40436 6117 23 . . . 40436 6118 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6118 2 77 77 CD 40436 6118 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6118 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6118 5 dissented dissent VBD 40436 6118 6 altogether altogether RB 40436 6118 7 from from IN 40436 6118 8 the the DT 40436 6118 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6118 10 here here RB 40436 6118 11 laid lay VBD 40436 6118 12 down down RP 40436 6118 13 by by IN 40436 6118 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6118 15 in in IN 40436 6118 16 the the DT 40436 6118 17 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6118 18 , , , 40436 6118 19 and and CC 40436 6118 20 many many JJ 40436 6118 21 other other JJ 40436 6118 22 eminent eminent JJ 40436 6118 23 men man NNS 40436 6118 24 would would MD 40436 6118 25 have have VB 40436 6118 26 dissented dissent VBN 40436 6118 27 from from IN 40436 6118 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6118 29 also also RB 40436 6118 30 . . . 40436 6119 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6119 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6119 3 76 76 CD 40436 6119 4 : : : 40436 6119 5 See see VB 40436 6119 6 the the DT 40436 6119 7 facts fact NNS 40436 6119 8 about about IN 40436 6119 9 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6119 10 in in IN 40436 6119 11 a a DT 40436 6119 12 good good JJ 40436 6119 13 Dissertation Dissertation NNP 40436 6119 14 by by IN 40436 6119 15 H. H. NNP 40436 6119 16 P. P. NNP 40436 6119 17 Schröder Schröder NNP 40436 6119 18 , , , 40436 6119 19 Utrecht Utrecht NNP 40436 6119 20 , , , 40436 6119 21 1859 1859 CD 40436 6119 22 , , , 40436 6119 23 Quæstiones Quæstiones NNP 40436 6119 24 Isocrateæ Isocrateæ NNP 40436 6119 25 , , , 40436 6119 26 p. p. NN 40436 6119 27 51 51 CD 40436 6119 28 , , , 40436 6119 29 seq seq NN 40436 6119 30 . . . 40436 6120 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6120 2 , , , 40436 6120 3 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6120 4 , , , 40436 6120 5 p. p. NN 40436 6120 6 270 270 CD 40436 6120 7 ; ; : 40436 6120 8 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40436 6120 9 , , , 40436 6120 10 Periklês Periklês NNP 40436 6120 11 , , , 40436 6120 12 c. c. NN 40436 6120 13 23 23 CD 40436 6120 14 ; ; : 40436 6120 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6120 16 , , , 40436 6120 17 Republic Republic NNP 40436 6120 18 , , , 40436 6120 19 iii iii NNP 40436 6120 20 . . . 40436 6121 1 p. p. NN 40436 6122 1 397 397 CD 40436 6122 2 . . . 40436 6122 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6123 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6123 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6123 3 77 77 CD 40436 6123 4 : : : 40436 6123 5 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 6123 6 , , , 40436 6123 7 De De NNP 40436 6123 8 Orator Orator NNP 40436 6123 9 . . . 40436 6124 1 iii iii NNP 40436 6124 2 . . . 40436 6125 1 34 34 CD 40436 6125 2 , , , 40436 6125 3 138 138 CD 40436 6125 4 ; ; : 40436 6125 5 Orator Orator NNP 40436 6125 6 . . . 40436 6126 1 iv iv XX 40436 6126 2 . . . 40436 6127 1 14 14 CD 40436 6127 2 ; ; : 40436 6127 3 Brutus Brutus NNP 40436 6127 4 , , , 40436 6127 5 11 11 CD 40436 6127 6 , , , 40436 6127 7 44 44 CD 40436 6127 8 . . . 40436 6127 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6128 1 As as IN 40436 6128 2 a a DT 40436 6128 3 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6128 4 of of IN 40436 6128 5 universal universal JJ 40436 6128 6 application application NN 40436 6128 7 , , , 40436 6128 8 in in IN 40436 6128 9 fact fact NN 40436 6128 10 , , , 40436 6128 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6128 12 can can MD 40436 6128 13 not not RB 40436 6128 14 be be VB 40436 6128 15 defended defend VBN 40436 6128 16 . . . 40436 6129 1 The the DT 40436 6129 2 opposite opposite JJ 40436 6129 3 scheme scheme NN 40436 6129 4 of of IN 40436 6129 5 life life NN 40436 6129 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6129 7 which which WDT 40436 6129 8 is be VBZ 40436 6129 9 maintained maintain VBN 40436 6129 10 by by IN 40436 6129 11 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6129 12 in in IN 40436 6129 13 De De NNP 40436 6129 14 Permutatione Permutatione NNP 40436 6129 15 and and CC 40436 6129 16 by by IN 40436 6129 17 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 6129 18 in in IN 40436 6129 19 the the DT 40436 6129 20 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6129 21 Gorgias)[78]--that Gorgias)[78]--that NNP 40436 6129 22 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6129 23 is be VBZ 40436 6129 24 to to TO 40436 6129 25 be be VB 40436 6129 26 attentively attentively RB 40436 6129 27 studied study VBN 40436 6129 28 in in IN 40436 6129 29 the the DT 40436 6129 30 earlier early JJR 40436 6129 31 years year NNS 40436 6129 32 of of IN 40436 6129 33 life life NN 40436 6129 34 as as IN 40436 6129 35 an an DT 40436 6129 36 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 6129 37 training training NN 40436 6129 38 , , , 40436 6129 39 to to TO 40436 6129 40 arm arm VB 40436 6129 41 the the DT 40436 6129 42 mind mind NN 40436 6129 43 with with IN 40436 6129 44 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6129 45 and and CC 40436 6129 46 capacities capacity NNS 40436 6129 47 which which WDT 40436 6129 48 may may MD 40436 6129 49 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 6129 50 be be VB 40436 6129 51 applied apply VBN 40436 6129 52 to to IN 40436 6129 53 the the DT 40436 6129 54 active active JJ 40436 6129 55 duties duty NNS 40436 6129 56 of of IN 40436 6129 57 life life NN 40436 6129 58 -- -- : 40436 6129 59 is be VBZ 40436 6129 60 at at IN 40436 6129 61 least least JJS 40436 6129 62 equally equally RB 40436 6129 63 defensible defensible JJ 40436 6129 64 , , , 40436 6129 65 and and CC 40436 6129 66 suits suit VBZ 40436 6129 67 better well JJR 40436 6129 68 for for IN 40436 6129 69 other other JJ 40436 6129 70 minds mind NNS 40436 6129 71 of of IN 40436 6129 72 a a DT 40436 6129 73 very very RB 40436 6129 74 high high JJ 40436 6129 75 order order NN 40436 6129 76 . . . 40436 6130 1 Not not RB 40436 6130 2 only only RB 40436 6130 3 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 6130 4 and and CC 40436 6130 5 other other JJ 40436 6130 6 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 6130 7 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 6130 8 , , , 40436 6130 9 but but CC 40436 6130 10 also also RB 40436 6130 11 most most JJS 40436 6130 12 of of IN 40436 6130 13 the the DT 40436 6130 14 best good JJS 40436 6130 15 Roman roman JJ 40436 6130 16 citizens citizen NNS 40436 6130 17 , , , 40436 6130 18 held hold VBD 40436 6130 19 the the DT 40436 6130 20 opinion opinion NN 40436 6130 21 which which WDT 40436 6130 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6130 23 in in IN 40436 6130 24 the the DT 40436 6130 25 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6130 26 ascribes ascribe NNS 40436 6130 27 to to IN 40436 6130 28 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 6130 29 and and CC 40436 6130 30 reprobates reprobate NNS 40436 6130 31 through through IN 40436 6130 32 the the DT 40436 6130 33 organ organ NN 40436 6130 34 of of IN 40436 6130 35 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6130 36 -- -- : 40436 6130 37 That that DT 40436 6130 38 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 6130 39 study study NN 40436 6130 40 , , , 40436 6130 41 if if IN 40436 6130 42 prolonged prolong VBN 40436 6130 43 beyond beyond IN 40436 6130 44 what what WP 40436 6130 45 was be VBD 40436 6130 46 necessary necessary JJ 40436 6130 47 for for IN 40436 6130 48 this this DT 40436 6130 49 purpose purpose NN 40436 6130 50 of of IN 40436 6130 51 adequate adequate JJ 40436 6130 52 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 6130 53 training training NN 40436 6130 54 , , , 40436 6130 55 and and CC 40436 6130 56 if if IN 40436 6130 57 made make VBD 40436 6130 58 the the DT 40436 6130 59 permanent permanent JJ 40436 6130 60 occupation occupation NN 40436 6130 61 of of IN 40436 6130 62 life life NN 40436 6130 63 , , , 40436 6130 64 was be VBD 40436 6130 65 more more RBR 40436 6130 66 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 6130 67 than than IN 40436 6130 68 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 6130 69 . . . 40436 6131 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6131 2 79 79 CD 40436 6131 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6131 4 Certainly certainly RB 40436 6131 5 , , , 40436 6131 6 a a DT 40436 6131 7 man man NN 40436 6131 8 may may MD 40436 6131 9 often often RB 40436 6131 10 fail fail VB 40436 6131 11 in in IN 40436 6131 12 the the DT 40436 6131 13 attempt attempt NN 40436 6131 14 to to TO 40436 6131 15 combine combine VB 40436 6131 16 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6131 17 with with IN 40436 6131 18 active active JJ 40436 6131 19 politics politic NNS 40436 6131 20 . . . 40436 6132 1 No no DT 40436 6132 2 one one NN 40436 6132 3 failed fail VBD 40436 6132 4 in in IN 40436 6132 5 such such PDT 40436 6132 6 a a DT 40436 6132 7 career career NN 40436 6132 8 more more RBR 40436 6132 9 lamentably lamentably RB 40436 6132 10 than than IN 40436 6132 11 Dion Dion NNP 40436 6132 12 , , , 40436 6132 13 the the DT 40436 6132 14 friend friend NN 40436 6132 15 of of IN 40436 6132 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6132 17 -- -- : 40436 6132 18 and and CC 40436 6132 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6132 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6132 21 , , , 40436 6132 22 when when WRB 40436 6132 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6132 24 visited visit VBD 40436 6132 25 Sicily Sicily NNP 40436 6132 26 to to IN 40436 6132 27 second second JJ 40436 6132 28 Dion dion NN 40436 6132 29 . . . 40436 6133 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 6133 2 Alkibiadês Alkibiadês NNP 40436 6133 3 and and CC 40436 6133 4 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 6133 5 were be VBD 40436 6133 6 cited cite VBN 40436 6133 7 by by IN 40436 6133 8 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6133 9 and and CC 40436 6133 10 the the DT 40436 6133 11 other other JJ 40436 6133 12 accusers accuser NNS 40436 6133 13 of of IN 40436 6133 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6133 15 as as IN 40436 6133 16 examples example NNS 40436 6133 17 of of IN 40436 6133 18 the the DT 40436 6133 19 like like IN 40436 6133 20 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 6133 21 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 6133 22 . . . 40436 6134 1 But but CC 40436 6134 2 on on IN 40436 6134 3 the the DT 40436 6134 4 other other JJ 40436 6134 5 hand hand NN 40436 6134 6 , , , 40436 6134 7 Archytas Archytas NNP 40436 6134 8 at at IN 40436 6134 9 Tarentum Tarentum NNP 40436 6134 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6134 11 another another DT 40436 6134 12 friend friend NN 40436 6134 13 of of IN 40436 6134 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6134 15 and and CC 40436 6134 16 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6134 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6134 18 administered administer VBD 40436 6134 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6134 20 native native JJ 40436 6134 21 city city NN 40436 6134 22 with with IN 40436 6134 23 success success NN 40436 6134 24 , , , 40436 6134 25 as as RB 40436 6134 26 long long RB 40436 6134 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6134 28 seemingly seemingly RB 40436 6134 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6134 30 as as IN 40436 6134 31 Periklês Periklês NNP 40436 6134 32 administered administer VBD 40436 6134 33 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6134 34 . . . 40436 6135 1 Such such JJ 40436 6135 2 men man NNS 40436 6135 3 as as IN 40436 6135 4 these these DT 40436 6135 5 two two CD 40436 6135 6 are be VBP 40436 6135 7 nowise nowise NN 40436 6135 8 inferior inferior JJ 40436 6135 9 either either CC 40436 6135 10 to to IN 40436 6135 11 the the DT 40436 6135 12 special special JJ 40436 6135 13 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6135 14 or or CC 40436 6135 15 to to IN 40436 6135 16 the the DT 40436 6135 17 special special JJ 40436 6135 18 politician politician NN 40436 6135 19 . . . 40436 6136 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6136 2 has have VBZ 40436 6136 3 laid lay VBN 40436 6136 4 down down RP 40436 6136 5 an an DT 40436 6136 6 untenable untenable JJ 40436 6136 7 generality generality NN 40436 6136 8 , , , 40436 6136 9 in in IN 40436 6136 10 this this DT 40436 6136 11 passage passage NN 40436 6136 12 of of IN 40436 6136 13 the the DT 40436 6136 14 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6136 15 , , , 40436 6136 16 in in IN 40436 6136 17 order order NN 40436 6136 18 to to TO 40436 6136 19 suit suit VB 40436 6136 20 a a DT 40436 6136 21 particular particular JJ 40436 6136 22 point point NN 40436 6136 23 which which WDT 40436 6136 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6136 25 wished wish VBD 40436 6136 26 to to TO 40436 6136 27 make make VB 40436 6136 28 against against IN 40436 6136 29 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6136 30 , , , 40436 6136 31 or or CC 40436 6136 32 against against IN 40436 6136 33 the the DT 40436 6136 34 semi semi JJ 40436 6136 35 - - JJ 40436 6136 36 philosopher philosopher JJ 40436 6136 37 indicated indicate VBD 40436 6136 38 , , , 40436 6136 39 whoever whoever WP 40436 6136 40 else else RB 40436 6136 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6136 42 may may MD 40436 6136 43 have have VB 40436 6136 44 been be VBN 40436 6136 45 . . . 40436 6137 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6137 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6137 3 78 78 CD 40436 6137 4 : : : 40436 6137 5 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6137 6 , , , 40436 6137 7 De De NNP 40436 6137 8 Permutatione Permutatione NNP 40436 6137 9 , , , 40436 6137 10 Or or CC 40436 6137 11 . . . 40436 6138 1 xv xv NNP 40436 6138 2 . . . 40436 6139 1 sect sect NNP 40436 6139 2 . . . 40436 6140 1 278 278 CD 40436 6140 2 - - SYM 40436 6140 3 288 288 CD 40436 6140 4 , , , 40436 6140 5 pp pp NNP 40436 6140 6 . . . 40436 6141 1 485 485 CD 40436 6141 2 - - SYM 40436 6141 3 480 480 CD 40436 6141 4 , , , 40436 6141 5 Bekk Bekk NNP 40436 6141 6 . . . 40436 6142 1 ; ; : 40436 6142 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6142 3 , , , 40436 6142 4 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6142 5 , , , 40436 6142 6 pp pp NNP 40436 6142 7 . . . 40436 6143 1 484 484 CD 40436 6143 2 - - SYM 40436 6143 3 485 485 CD 40436 6143 4 . . . 40436 6143 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6144 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6144 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6144 3 79 79 CD 40436 6144 4 : : : 40436 6144 5 The the DT 40436 6144 6 half half JJ 40436 6144 7 - - HYPH 40436 6144 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 6144 9 and and CC 40436 6144 10 half half NN 40436 6144 11 - - HYPH 40436 6144 12 politicians politician NNS 40436 6144 13 to to IN 40436 6144 14 whom whom WP 40436 6144 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6144 16 here here RB 40436 6144 17 alludes allude NNS 40436 6144 18 , , , 40436 6144 19 are be VBP 40436 6144 20 characterised characterise VBN 40436 6144 21 by by IN 40436 6144 22 one one CD 40436 6144 23 of of IN 40436 6144 24 the the DT 40436 6144 25 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6144 26 critics critic NNS 40436 6144 27 as as IN 40436 6144 28 " " `` 40436 6144 29 jene jene NNP 40436 6144 30 oberflächlichen oberflächlichen NNP 40436 6144 31 und und VBP 40436 6144 32 schwächlichen schwächlichen NNP 40436 6144 33 Naturen Naturen NNP 40436 6144 34 die die VBP 40436 6144 35 sich sich JJ 40436 6144 36 zwischen zwischen NNP 40436 6144 37 beiden beiden NNP 40436 6144 38 Richtungen Richtungen NNP 40436 6144 39 stellen stellen NN 40436 6144 40 , , , 40436 6144 41 und und RB 40436 6144 42 zur zur NNP 40436 6144 43 Erreichung Erreichung NNP 40436 6144 44 selbstsüchtiger selbstsüchtiger NN 40436 6144 45 und und JJ 40436 6144 46 beschränkter beschränkter NN 40436 6144 47 Zwecke Zwecke NNP 40436 6144 48 von von NNP 40436 6144 49 beiden beiden NN 40436 6144 50 aufnehmen aufnehman NNS 40436 6144 51 was be VBD 40436 6144 52 sie sie JJ 40436 6144 53 verstehen verstehen NNP 40436 6144 54 und und NNP 40436 6144 55 was be VBD 40436 6144 56 ihnen ihnen NN 40436 6144 57 gefällt gefällt FW 40436 6144 58 " " '' 40436 6144 59 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6144 60 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 6144 61 , , , 40436 6144 62 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 6144 63 . . . 40436 6145 1 p. p. NN 40436 6145 2 25 25 CD 40436 6145 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6145 4 . . . 40436 6146 1 On on IN 40436 6146 2 the the DT 40436 6146 3 other other JJ 40436 6146 4 hand hand NN 40436 6146 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6146 6 find find VBP 40436 6146 7 in in IN 40436 6146 8 Tacitus Tacitus NNP 40436 6146 9 a a DT 40436 6146 10 striking striking JJ 40436 6146 11 passage passage NN 40436 6146 12 respecting respect VBG 40436 6146 13 the the DT 40436 6146 14 studies study NNS 40436 6146 15 of of IN 40436 6146 16 Agricola Agricola NNP 40436 6146 17 in in IN 40436 6146 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6146 19 youth youth NN 40436 6146 20 at at IN 40436 6146 21 Massilia Massilia NNP 40436 6146 22 . . . 40436 6147 1 " " `` 40436 6147 2 Memoriâ Memoriâ NNP 40436 6147 3 teneo teneo NN 40436 6147 4 , , , 40436 6147 5 solitum solitum RB 40436 6147 6 ipsum ipsum NNP 40436 6147 7 narrare narrare NNP 40436 6147 8 , , , 40436 6147 9 se se NNP 40436 6147 10 in in IN 40436 6147 11 primâ primâ NNP 40436 6147 12 juventâ juventâ NNP 40436 6147 13 studium studium NNP 40436 6147 14 philosophiæ philosophiæ NNP 40436 6147 15 acrius acrius NNP 40436 6147 16 , , , 40436 6147 17 ultra ultra NNP 40436 6147 18 quam quam NNP 40436 6147 19 concessum concessum NNP 40436 6147 20 Romano Romano NNP 40436 6147 21 ac ac NNP 40436 6147 22 senatori senatori NN 40436 6147 23 , , , 40436 6147 24 hausisse hausisse NNP 40436 6147 25 -- -- : 40436 6147 26 ni ni NNP 40436 6147 27 prudentia prudentia NNP 40436 6147 28 matris matris NNP 40436 6147 29 incensum incensum NNP 40436 6147 30 ac ac IN 40436 6147 31 flagrantem flagrantem NNP 40436 6147 32 animum animum NN 40436 6147 33 exercuisset exercuisset NN 40436 6147 34 : : : 40436 6147 35 Scilicet scilicet VB 40436 6147 36 sublime sublime NN 40436 6147 37 et et NNP 40436 6147 38 erectum erectum NNP 40436 6147 39 ingenium ingenium NNP 40436 6147 40 , , , 40436 6147 41 pulchritudinem pulchritudinem NNP 40436 6147 42 ac ac NNP 40436 6147 43 speciem speciem NNP 40436 6147 44 excelsæ excelsæ NNP 40436 6147 45 magnæque magnæque NNP 40436 6147 46 gloriæ gloriæ NNP 40436 6147 47 vehementius vehementius NNP 40436 6147 48 quam quam NNP 40436 6147 49 lauté lauté NNP 40436 6147 50 appetebat appetebat NNP 40436 6147 51 : : : 40436 6147 52 retinuitque retinuitque NNP 40436 6147 53 , , , 40436 6147 54 quod quod NN 40436 6147 55 est est NNP 40436 6147 56 difficillimum difficillimum NNP 40436 6147 57 , , , 40436 6147 58 ex ex NNP 40436 6147 59 sapientiâ sapientiâ JJ 40436 6147 60 modum modum NN 40436 6147 61 " " '' 40436 6147 62 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6147 63 Vit Vit NNP 40436 6147 64 . . . 40436 6148 1 Agr agr RB 40436 6148 2 . . . 40436 6149 1 c. c. NNP 40436 6149 2 4 4 CD 40436 6149 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6149 4 . . . 40436 6150 1 Tacitus Tacitus NNP 40436 6150 2 expresses express VBZ 40436 6150 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6150 4 in in IN 40436 6150 5 the the DT 40436 6150 6 same same JJ 40436 6150 7 manner manner NN 40436 6150 8 about about IN 40436 6150 9 the the DT 40436 6150 10 purpose purpose NN 40436 6150 11 with with IN 40436 6150 12 which which WDT 40436 6150 13 Helvidius Helvidius NNP 40436 6150 14 Priscus Priscus NNP 40436 6150 15 applied apply VBD 40436 6150 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6150 17 to to IN 40436 6150 18 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6150 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6150 20 Hist Hist NNP 40436 6150 21 . . . 40436 6151 1 iv iv XX 40436 6151 2 . . . 40436 6152 1 6 6 LS 40436 6152 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6152 3 : : : 40436 6152 4 " " `` 40436 6152 5 non non JJ 40436 6152 6 , , , 40436 6152 7 ut ut UH 40436 6152 8 plerique plerique NNP 40436 6152 9 , , , 40436 6152 10 ut ut UH 40436 6152 11 nomine nomine NNP 40436 6152 12 magnifico magnifico NNP 40436 6152 13 segne segne NNP 40436 6152 14 otium otium NN 40436 6152 15 velaret velaret NN 40436 6152 16 , , , 40436 6152 17 sed sed NNP 40436 6152 18 quo quo NNP 40436 6152 19 constantior constantior NNP 40436 6152 20 adversus adversus NNP 40436 6152 21 fortuita fortuita NNP 40436 6152 22 rempublicam rempublicam NNP 40436 6152 23 capesseret capesseret NNP 40436 6152 24 " " '' 40436 6152 25 . . . 40436 6153 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6153 2 also also RB 40436 6153 3 the the DT 40436 6153 4 memorable memorable JJ 40436 6153 5 passage passage NN 40436 6153 6 in in IN 40436 6153 7 the the DT 40436 6153 8 Funeral Funeral NNP 40436 6153 9 Oration Oration NNP 40436 6153 10 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 6153 11 by by IN 40436 6153 12 Periklês Periklês NNP 40436 6153 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6153 14 Thuc Thuc NNP 40436 6153 15 . . . 40436 6154 1 ii ii LS 40436 6154 2 . . . 40436 6155 1 40)--[Greek 40)--[greek CD 40436 6155 2 : : : 40436 6155 3 philosophou philosophou NNP 40436 6155 4 = = SYM 40436 6155 5 men man NNS 40436 6155 6 a)/neu a)/neu IN 40436 6155 7 malaki malaki NN 40436 6155 8 / / SYM 40436 6155 9 as as IN 40436 6155 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6155 11 , , , 40436 6155 12 & & CC 40436 6155 13 c. c. NNP 40436 6155 14 , , , 40436 6155 15 which which WDT 40436 6155 16 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 6155 17 the the DT 40436 6155 18 like like JJ 40436 6155 19 views view NNS 40436 6155 20 . . . 40436 6156 1 Aulus Aulus NNP 40436 6156 2 Gellius Gellius NNP 40436 6156 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6156 4 x. x. NNP 40436 6157 1 22 22 CD 40436 6157 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6157 3 , , , 40436 6157 4 who who WP 40436 6157 5 cites cite VBZ 40436 6157 6 the the DT 40436 6157 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6157 8 which which WDT 40436 6157 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6157 10 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 6157 11 to to IN 40436 6157 12 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 6157 13 in in IN 40436 6157 14 the the DT 40436 6157 15 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6157 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6157 17 about about IN 40436 6157 18 the the DT 40436 6157 19 propriety propriety NN 40436 6157 20 of of IN 40436 6157 21 confining confine VBG 40436 6157 22 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6157 23 to to IN 40436 6157 24 the the DT 40436 6157 25 function function NN 40436 6157 26 of of IN 40436 6157 27 training training NN 40436 6157 28 and and CC 40436 6157 29 preparation preparation NN 40436 6157 30 for for IN 40436 6157 31 active active JJ 40436 6157 32 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 6157 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6157 34 , , , 40436 6157 35 tries try VBZ 40436 6157 36 to to TO 40436 6157 37 make make VB 40436 6157 38 out out RP 40436 6157 39 that that IN 40436 6157 40 this this DT 40436 6157 41 was be VBD 40436 6157 42 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6157 43 's 's POS 40436 6157 44 own own JJ 40436 6157 45 opinion opinion NN 40436 6157 46 . . . 40436 6157 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6158 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 6158 2 XXII XXII NNP 40436 6158 3 . . . 40436 6159 1 MENON MENON NNP 40436 6159 2 . . . 40436 6160 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6160 2 Side side NN 40436 6160 3 - - HYPH 40436 6160 4 note note NN 40436 6160 5 : : : 40436 6160 6 Persons person NNS 40436 6160 7 of of IN 40436 6160 8 the the DT 40436 6160 9 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 40436 6160 10 . . . 40436 6160 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6161 1 This this DT 40436 6161 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6161 3 is be VBZ 40436 6161 4 carried carry VBN 40436 6161 5 on on RP 40436 6161 6 between between IN 40436 6161 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6161 8 and and CC 40436 6161 9 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6161 10 , , , 40436 6161 11 a a DT 40436 6161 12 man man NN 40436 6161 13 of of IN 40436 6161 14 noble noble JJ 40436 6161 15 family family NN 40436 6161 16 , , , 40436 6161 17 wealth wealth NN 40436 6161 18 , , , 40436 6161 19 and and CC 40436 6161 20 political political JJ 40436 6161 21 influence influence NN 40436 6161 22 , , , 40436 6161 23 in in IN 40436 6161 24 the the DT 40436 6161 25 Thessalian thessalian JJ 40436 6161 26 city city NN 40436 6161 27 of of IN 40436 6161 28 Larissa Larissa NNP 40436 6161 29 . . . 40436 6162 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6162 2 is be VBZ 40436 6162 3 supposed suppose VBN 40436 6162 4 to to TO 40436 6162 5 have have VB 40436 6162 6 previously previously RB 40436 6162 7 frequented frequent VBN 40436 6162 8 , , , 40436 6162 9 in in IN 40436 6162 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6162 11 native native JJ 40436 6162 12 city city NN 40436 6162 13 , , , 40436 6162 14 the the DT 40436 6162 15 lectures lecture NNS 40436 6162 16 and and CC 40436 6162 17 society society NN 40436 6162 18 of of IN 40436 6162 19 the the DT 40436 6162 20 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 6162 21 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6162 22 . . . 40436 6163 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6163 2 1 1 LS 40436 6163 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6163 4 The the DT 40436 6163 5 name name NN 40436 6163 6 and and CC 40436 6163 7 general general JJ 40436 6163 8 features feature NNS 40436 6163 9 of of IN 40436 6163 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6163 11 are be VBP 40436 6163 12 probably probably RB 40436 6163 13 borrowed borrow VBN 40436 6163 14 from from IN 40436 6163 15 the the DT 40436 6163 16 Thessalian thessalian JJ 40436 6163 17 military military JJ 40436 6163 18 officer officer NN 40436 6163 19 , , , 40436 6163 20 who who WP 40436 6163 21 commanded command VBD 40436 6163 22 a a DT 40436 6163 23 division division NN 40436 6163 24 of of IN 40436 6163 25 the the DT 40436 6163 26 Ten ten CD 40436 6163 27 Thousand thousand CD 40436 6163 28 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 6163 29 , , , 40436 6163 30 and and CC 40436 6163 31 whose whose WP$ 40436 6163 32 character character NN 40436 6163 33 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 6163 34 depicts depict VBZ 40436 6163 35 in in IN 40436 6163 36 the the DT 40436 6163 37 Anabasis Anabasis NNP 40436 6163 38 : : : 40436 6163 39 but but CC 40436 6163 40 there there EX 40436 6163 41 is be VBZ 40436 6163 42 nothing nothing NN 40436 6163 43 in in IN 40436 6163 44 the the DT 40436 6163 45 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6163 46 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6163 47 to to TO 40436 6163 48 mark mark VB 40436 6163 49 that that DT 40436 6163 50 meanness meanness NN 40436 6163 51 and and CC 40436 6163 52 perfidy perfidy NN 40436 6163 53 which which WDT 40436 6163 54 the the DT 40436 6163 55 Xenophontic xenophontic JJ 40436 6163 56 picture picture NN 40436 6163 57 indicates indicate VBZ 40436 6163 58 . . . 40436 6164 1 The the DT 40436 6164 2 conversation conversation NN 40436 6164 3 between between IN 40436 6164 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6164 5 and and CC 40436 6164 6 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6164 7 is be VBZ 40436 6164 8 interrupted interrupt VBN 40436 6164 9 by by IN 40436 6164 10 two two CD 40436 6164 11 episodes episode NNS 40436 6164 12 : : : 40436 6164 13 in in IN 40436 6164 14 the the DT 40436 6164 15 first first JJ 40436 6164 16 of of IN 40436 6164 17 these these DT 40436 6164 18 , , , 40436 6164 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6164 20 questions question NNS 40436 6164 21 an an DT 40436 6164 22 unlettered unlettered JJ 40436 6164 23 youth youth NN 40436 6164 24 , , , 40436 6164 25 the the DT 40436 6164 26 slave slave NN 40436 6164 27 of of IN 40436 6164 28 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6164 29 : : : 40436 6164 30 in in IN 40436 6164 31 the the DT 40436 6164 32 second second JJ 40436 6164 33 , , , 40436 6164 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6164 35 is be VBZ 40436 6164 36 brought bring VBN 40436 6164 37 into into IN 40436 6164 38 conflict conflict NN 40436 6164 39 with with IN 40436 6164 40 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6164 41 , , , 40436 6164 42 the the DT 40436 6164 43 historical historical JJ 40436 6164 44 accuser accuser NN 40436 6164 45 of of IN 40436 6164 46 the the DT 40436 6164 47 historical historical JJ 40436 6164 48 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6164 49 . . . 40436 6165 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6165 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6165 3 1 1 CD 40436 6165 4 : : : 40436 6165 5 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 6165 6 notices notice VBZ 40436 6165 7 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 6165 8 as as IN 40436 6165 9 having have VBG 40436 6165 10 heard hear VBN 40436 6165 11 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6165 12 in in IN 40436 6165 13 Thessaly Thessaly NNP 40436 6165 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6165 15 Orator Orator NNP 40436 6165 16 . . . 40436 6166 1 53 53 CD 40436 6166 2 , , , 40436 6166 3 176 176 CD 40436 6166 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6166 5 . . . 40436 6166 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6167 1 The the DT 40436 6167 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6167 3 is be VBZ 40436 6167 4 begun begin VBN 40436 6167 5 by by IN 40436 6167 6 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6167 7 , , , 40436 6167 8 in in IN 40436 6167 9 a a DT 40436 6167 10 manner manner NN 40436 6167 11 quite quite RB 40436 6167 12 as as RB 40436 6167 13 abrupt abrupt RB 40436 6167 14 as as IN 40436 6167 15 the the DT 40436 6167 16 Hipparchus Hipparchus NNP 40436 6167 17 and and CC 40436 6167 18 Minos Minos NNP 40436 6167 19 : : : 40436 6167 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6167 21 Side side NN 40436 6167 22 - - HYPH 40436 6167 23 note note NN 40436 6167 24 : : : 40436 6167 25 Question question NN 40436 6167 26 put put VBN 40436 6167 27 by by IN 40436 6167 28 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6167 29 -- -- : 40436 6167 30 Is be VBZ 40436 6167 31 virtue virtue NN 40436 6167 32 teachable teachable NN 40436 6167 33 ? ? . 40436 6168 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6168 2 confesses confess VBZ 40436 6168 3 that that IN 40436 6168 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6168 5 does do VBZ 40436 6168 6 not not RB 40436 6168 7 know know VB 40436 6168 8 what what WP 40436 6168 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 6168 10 is be VBZ 40436 6168 11 . . . 40436 6169 1 Surprise Surprise NNP 40436 6169 2 of of IN 40436 6169 3 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6169 4 . . . 40436 6169 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6170 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6170 2 Menon._--Can Menon._--Can NNP 40436 6170 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6170 4 tell tell VBP 40436 6170 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6170 6 , , , 40436 6170 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6170 8 , , , 40436 6170 9 whether whether IN 40436 6170 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 6170 11 is be VBZ 40436 6170 12 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6170 13 -- -- : 40436 6170 14 or or CC 40436 6170 15 acquirable acquirable JJ 40436 6170 16 by by IN 40436 6170 17 exercise exercise NN 40436 6170 18 -- -- : 40436 6170 19 or or CC 40436 6170 20 whether whether IN 40436 6170 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6170 22 comes come VBZ 40436 6170 23 by by IN 40436 6170 24 nature nature NN 40436 6170 25 -- -- : 40436 6170 26 or or CC 40436 6170 27 in in IN 40436 6170 28 what what WP 40436 6170 29 other other JJ 40436 6170 30 manner manner NN 40436 6170 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6170 32 comes come VBZ 40436 6170 33 ? ? . 40436 6171 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6171 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 6171 3 can can MD 40436 6171 4 not not RB 40436 6171 5 answer answer VB 40436 6171 6 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6171 7 question question NN 40436 6171 8 . . . 40436 6172 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6172 2 am be VBP 40436 6172 3 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 6172 4 to to TO 40436 6172 5 say say VB 40436 6172 6 that that IN 40436 6172 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6172 8 do do VBP 40436 6172 9 not not RB 40436 6172 10 even even RB 40436 6172 11 know know VB 40436 6172 12 what what WP 40436 6172 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 6172 14 is be VBZ 40436 6172 15 : : : 40436 6172 16 and and CC 40436 6172 17 when when WRB 40436 6172 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6172 19 do do VBP 40436 6172 20 not not RB 40436 6172 21 know know VB 40436 6172 22 what what WP 40436 6172 23 a a DT 40436 6172 24 thing thing NN 40436 6172 25 is be VBZ 40436 6172 26 , , , 40436 6172 27 how how WRB 40436 6172 28 can can MD 40436 6172 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6172 30 know know VB 40436 6172 31 any any DT 40436 6172 32 thing thing NN 40436 6172 33 about about IN 40436 6172 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6172 35 attributes attribute NNS 40436 6172 36 or or CC 40436 6172 37 accessories accessory NNS 40436 6172 38 ? ? . 40436 6173 1 A a DT 40436 6173 2 man man NN 40436 6173 3 who who WP 40436 6173 4 does do VBZ 40436 6173 5 not not RB 40436 6173 6 know know VB 40436 6173 7 , , , 40436 6173 8 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6173 9 , , , 40436 6173 10 can can MD 40436 6173 11 not not RB 40436 6173 12 tell tell VB 40436 6173 13 whether whether IN 40436 6173 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6173 15 is be VBZ 40436 6173 16 handsome handsome JJ 40436 6173 17 , , , 40436 6173 18 rich rich JJ 40436 6173 19 , , , 40436 6173 20 & & CC 40436 6173 21 c. c. NNP 40436 6173 22 , , , 40436 6173 23 or or CC 40436 6173 24 the the DT 40436 6173 25 contrary contrary NN 40436 6173 26 . . . 40436 6174 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6174 2 Menon._--Certainly menon._--certainly RB 40436 6174 3 not not RB 40436 6174 4 . . . 40436 6175 1 But but CC 40436 6175 2 is be VBZ 40436 6175 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6175 4 really really RB 40436 6175 5 true true JJ 40436 6175 6 , , , 40436 6175 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6175 8 , , , 40436 6175 9 that that IN 40436 6175 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6175 11 do do VBP 40436 6175 12 not not RB 40436 6175 13 know know VB 40436 6175 14 what what WP 40436 6175 15 virtue virtue NN 40436 6175 16 is be VBZ 40436 6175 17 ? ? . 40436 6176 1 Am be VBP 40436 6176 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6176 3 to to TO 40436 6176 4 proclaim proclaim VB 40436 6176 5 this this DT 40436 6176 6 respecting respect VBG 40436 6176 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6176 8 , , , 40436 6176 9 when when WRB 40436 6176 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6176 11 go go VBP 40436 6176 12 home home RB 40436 6176 13 ? ? . 40436 6177 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6177 2 2 2 CD 40436 6177 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6177 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6177 5 Sokr._--Yes Sokr._--Yes NNP 40436 6177 6 -- -- : 40436 6177 7 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 6177 8 : : : 40436 6177 9 and and CC 40436 6177 10 proclaim proclaim VB 40436 6177 11 besides besides IN 40436 6177 12 that that DT 40436 6177 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6177 14 have have VBP 40436 6177 15 never never RB 40436 6177 16 yet yet RB 40436 6177 17 met meet VBN 40436 6177 18 with with IN 40436 6177 19 any any DT 40436 6177 20 one one NN 40436 6177 21 who who WP 40436 6177 22 _ _ NNP 40436 6177 23 did do VBD 40436 6177 24 _ _ NNP 40436 6177 25 know know VB 40436 6177 26 . . . 40436 6178 1 _ _ IN 40436 6178 2 Menon._--What Menon._--What NNP 40436 6178 3 ! ! . 40436 6179 1 have have VBP 40436 6179 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6179 3 not not RB 40436 6179 4 seen see VBN 40436 6179 5 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6179 6 at at IN 40436 6179 7 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6179 8 , , , 40436 6179 9 and and CC 40436 6179 10 did do VBD 40436 6179 11 not not RB 40436 6179 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6179 13 appear appear VB 40436 6179 14 to to IN 40436 6179 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6179 16 to to TO 40436 6179 17 know know VB 40436 6179 18 ? ? . 40436 6180 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6180 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 6180 3 have have VBP 40436 6180 4 met meet VBN 40436 6180 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6180 6 , , , 40436 6180 7 but but CC 40436 6180 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6180 9 do do VBP 40436 6180 10 not not RB 40436 6180 11 quite quite RB 40436 6180 12 recollect recollect VB 40436 6180 13 what what WP 40436 6180 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6180 15 said say VBD 40436 6180 16 . . . 40436 6181 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6181 2 need nee MD 40436 6181 3 not not RB 40436 6181 4 consider consider VB 40436 6181 5 what what WP 40436 6181 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6181 7 said say VBD 40436 6181 8 , , , 40436 6181 9 since since IN 40436 6181 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6181 11 is be VBZ 40436 6181 12 not not RB 40436 6181 13 here here RB 40436 6181 14 to to TO 40436 6181 15 answer answer VB 40436 6181 16 for for IN 40436 6181 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6181 18 . . . 40436 6182 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6182 2 3 3 CD 40436 6182 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6182 4 But but CC 40436 6182 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6182 6 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 6182 7 recollect recollect VB 40436 6182 8 , , , 40436 6182 9 and and CC 40436 6182 10 can can MD 40436 6182 11 tell tell VB 40436 6182 12 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6182 13 , , , 40436 6182 14 both both CC 40436 6182 15 from from IN 40436 6182 16 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6182 17 , , , 40436 6182 18 and and CC 40436 6182 19 from from IN 40436 6182 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6182 21 , , , 40436 6182 22 what what WDT 40436 6182 23 virtue virtue NN 40436 6182 24 is be VBZ 40436 6182 25 ? ? . 40436 6183 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6183 2 Menon._--There Menon._--There NNP 40436 6183 3 is be VBZ 40436 6183 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6183 5 no no DT 40436 6183 6 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 6183 7 _ _ NNP 40436 6183 8 in in IN 40436 6183 9 telling tell VBG 40436 6183 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6183 11 . . . 40436 6184 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6184 2 4 4 CD 40436 6184 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6184 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6184 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6184 6 2 2 CD 40436 6184 7 : : : 40436 6184 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6184 9 , , , 40436 6184 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6184 11 , , , 40436 6184 12 p. p. NN 40436 6184 13 71 71 CD 40436 6184 14 B B NNP 40436 6184 15 - - HYPH 40436 6184 16 C. C. NNP 40436 6184 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6184 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6184 19 : : : 40436 6184 20 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 6184 21 su/ su/ NN 40436 6184 22 , , , 40436 6184 23 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 6184 24 Sô Sô NNP 40436 6184 25 / / SYM 40436 6184 26 krates krate NNS 40436 6184 27 , , , 40436 6184 28 ou)d ou)d LS 40436 6184 29 ' ' '' 40436 6184 30 o(/ o(/ JJ 40436 6184 31 ti ti IN 40436 6184 32 a)retê/ a)retê/ NNP 40436 6184 33 e)stin e)stin . 40436 6184 34 oi)=stha oi)=stha -RRB- 40436 6184 35 , , , 40436 6184 36 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 6184 37 tau tau NNP 40436 6184 38 = = SYM 40436 6184 39 ta ta NNP 40436 6184 40 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6184 41 sou= sou= NNP 40436 6184 42 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6184 43 oi)/kade oi)/kade NNP 40436 6184 44 a)pagge a)pagge NNP 40436 6184 45 / / SYM 40436 6184 46 llômen llômen NN 40436 6184 47 ? ? . 40436 6184 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6184 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6185 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6185 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6185 3 3 3 CD 40436 6185 4 : : : 40436 6185 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6185 6 , , , 40436 6185 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6185 8 , , , 40436 6185 9 p. p. NN 40436 6185 10 71 71 CD 40436 6185 11 D. D. NNP 40436 6185 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6185 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6185 14 : : : 40436 6185 15 a)kei a)kei ADD 40436 6185 16 = = SYM 40436 6185 17 non non VB 40436 6185 18 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6185 19 / / SYM 40436 6185 20 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 6185 21 nu nu NNP 40436 6185 22 = = SYM 40436 6185 23 n n NNP 40436 6185 24 e)ô e)ô NNP 40436 6185 25 = = SYM 40436 6185 26 men man NNS 40436 6185 27 , , , 40436 6185 28 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ NNP 40436 6185 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6185 30 a)/pestin a)/pestin NN 40436 6185 31 . . . 40436 6185 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6186 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6186 2 sets set VBZ 40436 6186 3 little little JJ 40436 6186 4 value value NN 40436 6186 5 upon upon IN 40436 6186 6 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6186 7 unless unless IN 40436 6186 8 where where WRB 40436 6186 9 the the DT 40436 6186 10 person person NN 40436 6186 11 giving give VBG 40436 6186 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6186 13 is be VBZ 40436 6186 14 present present JJ 40436 6186 15 to to TO 40436 6186 16 explain explain VB 40436 6186 17 and and CC 40436 6186 18 defend defend VB 40436 6186 19 : : : 40436 6186 20 compare compare VB 40436 6186 21 what what WP 40436 6186 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6186 23 says say VBZ 40436 6186 24 about about IN 40436 6186 25 the the DT 40436 6186 26 uselessness uselessness NN 40436 6186 27 of of IN 40436 6186 28 citation citation NN 40436 6186 29 from from IN 40436 6186 30 poets poet NNS 40436 6186 31 , , , 40436 6186 32 from from IN 40436 6186 33 whom whom WP 40436 6186 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6186 35 can can MD 40436 6186 36 ask ask VB 40436 6186 37 no no DT 40436 6186 38 questions question NNS 40436 6186 39 , , , 40436 6186 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6186 41 , , , 40436 6186 42 Protagor Protagor NNP 40436 6186 43 . . . 40436 6187 1 p. p. NN 40436 6187 2 347 347 CD 40436 6187 3 E. E. NNP 40436 6187 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6187 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6187 6 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6187 7 4 4 CD 40436 6187 8 : : : 40436 6187 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6187 10 , , , 40436 6187 11 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6187 12 , , , 40436 6187 13 p. p. NN 40436 6187 14 71 71 CD 40436 6187 15 E. E. NNP 40436 6187 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6187 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6187 18 : : : 40436 6187 19 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 6187 20 ' ' '' 40436 6187 21 ou ou NNP 40436 6187 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6187 23 chalepo chalepo NNP 40436 6187 24 / / SYM 40436 6187 25 n n NNP 40436 6187 26 , , , 40436 6187 27 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 6187 28 Sô Sô NNP 40436 6187 29 / / SYM 40436 6187 30 krates krate NNS 40436 6187 31 , , , 40436 6187 32 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 6187 33 = = SYM 40436 6187 34 n n NN 40436 6187 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6187 36 , , , 40436 6187 37 & & CC 40436 6187 38 c. c. NNP 40436 6187 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6187 40 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6187 41 Side side NN 40436 6187 42 - - HYPH 40436 6187 43 note note NN 40436 6187 44 : : : 40436 6187 45 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6187 46 stands stand VBZ 40436 6187 47 alone alone RB 40436 6187 48 in in IN 40436 6187 49 this this DT 40436 6187 50 confession confession NN 40436 6187 51 . . . 40436 6188 1 Unpopularity unpopularity NN 40436 6188 2 entailed entail VBN 40436 6188 3 by by IN 40436 6188 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6188 5 . . . 40436 6188 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6189 1 Many many JJ 40436 6189 2 commentators commentator NNS 40436 6189 3 here here RB 40436 6189 4 speak speak VBP 40436 6189 5 as as IN 40436 6189 6 if if IN 40436 6189 7 such such JJ 40436 6189 8 disclaimer disclaimer NN 40436 6189 9 on on IN 40436 6189 10 the the DT 40436 6189 11 part part NN 40436 6189 12 of of IN 40436 6189 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6189 14 had have VBD 40436 6189 15 reference reference NN 40436 6189 16 merely merely RB 40436 6189 17 to to IN 40436 6189 18 certain certain JJ 40436 6189 19 impudent impudent JJ 40436 6189 20 pretensions pretension NNS 40436 6189 21 to to IN 40436 6189 22 universal universal JJ 40436 6189 23 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6189 24 on on IN 40436 6189 25 the the DT 40436 6189 26 part part NN 40436 6189 27 of of IN 40436 6189 28 the the DT 40436 6189 29 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6189 30 . . . 40436 6190 1 But but CC 40436 6190 2 this this DT 40436 6190 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6190 4 as as IN 40436 6190 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6190 6 have have VBP 40436 6190 7 before before RB 40436 6190 8 remarked remark VBN 40436 6190 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6190 10 is be VBZ 40436 6190 11 a a DT 40436 6190 12 misconception misconception NN 40436 6190 13 of of IN 40436 6190 14 the the DT 40436 6190 15 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 6190 16 or or CC 40436 6190 17 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6190 18 point point NN 40436 6190 19 of of IN 40436 6190 20 view view NN 40436 6190 21 . . . 40436 6191 1 The the DT 40436 6191 2 matter matter NN 40436 6191 3 which which WDT 40436 6191 4 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 6191 5 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 6191 6 that that IN 40436 6191 7 _ _ NNP 40436 6191 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6191 9 _ _ NNP 40436 6191 10 does do VBZ 40436 6191 11 not not RB 40436 6191 12 know know VB 40436 6191 13 , , , 40436 6191 14 is be VBZ 40436 6191 15 , , , 40436 6191 16 what what WP 40436 6191 17 , , , 40436 6191 18 not not RB 40436 6191 19 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6191 20 alone alone RB 40436 6191 21 , , , 40436 6191 22 but but CC 40436 6191 23 every every DT 40436 6191 24 one one NN 40436 6191 25 else else RB 40436 6191 26 also also RB 40436 6191 27 , , , 40436 6191 28 professes profess VBZ 40436 6191 29 to to TO 40436 6191 30 know know VB 40436 6191 31 well well RB 40436 6191 32 . . . 40436 6192 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6192 2 stands stand VBZ 40436 6192 3 alone alone RB 40436 6192 4 in in IN 40436 6192 5 avowing avow VBG 40436 6192 6 that that IN 40436 6192 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6192 8 does do VBZ 40436 6192 9 not not RB 40436 6192 10 know know VB 40436 6192 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6192 12 , , , 40436 6192 13 and and CC 40436 6192 14 that that IN 40436 6192 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6192 16 can can MD 40436 6192 17 find find VB 40436 6192 18 no no DT 40436 6192 19 one one NN 40436 6192 20 else else RB 40436 6192 21 who who WP 40436 6192 22 knows know VBZ 40436 6192 23 . . . 40436 6193 1 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6193 2 treats treat VBZ 40436 6193 3 the the DT 40436 6193 4 question question NN 40436 6193 5 as as IN 40436 6193 6 one one CD 40436 6193 7 of of IN 40436 6193 8 no no DT 40436 6193 9 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 6193 10 -- -- : 40436 6193 11 one one CD 40436 6193 12 on on IN 40436 6193 13 which which WDT 40436 6193 14 confessed confessed JJ 40436 6193 15 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6193 16 was be VBD 40436 6193 17 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 6193 18 . . . 40436 6194 1 " " `` 40436 6194 2 What what WP 40436 6194 3 ! ! . 40436 6194 4 " " '' 40436 6195 1 says say VBZ 40436 6195 2 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6195 3 , , , 40436 6195 4 " " `` 40436 6195 5 am be VBP 40436 6195 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6195 7 really really RB 40436 6195 8 to to IN 40436 6195 9 state state NN 40436 6195 10 respecting respect VBG 40436 6195 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6195 12 , , , 40436 6195 13 that that IN 40436 6195 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6195 15 do do VBP 40436 6195 16 not not RB 40436 6195 17 know know VB 40436 6195 18 what what WP 40436 6195 19 virtue virtue NN 40436 6195 20 is be VBZ 40436 6195 21 ? ? . 40436 6195 22 " " '' 40436 6196 1 The the DT 40436 6196 2 man man NN 40436 6196 3 who who WP 40436 6196 4 makes make VBZ 40436 6196 5 such such PDT 40436 6196 6 a a DT 40436 6196 7 confession confession NN 40436 6196 8 will will MD 40436 6196 9 be be VB 40436 6196 10 looked look VBN 40436 6196 11 upon upon IN 40436 6196 12 by by IN 40436 6196 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6196 14 neighbours neighbour NNS 40436 6196 15 with with IN 40436 6196 16 surprise surprise NN 40436 6196 17 and and CC 40436 6196 18 displeasure displeasure NN 40436 6196 19 -- -- : 40436 6196 20 not not RB 40436 6196 21 to to TO 40436 6196 22 speak speak VB 40436 6196 23 of of IN 40436 6196 24 probable probable JJ 40436 6196 25 consequences consequence NNS 40436 6196 26 yet yet RB 40436 6196 27 worse bad JJR 40436 6196 28 . . . 40436 6197 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6197 2 is be VBZ 40436 6197 3 one one CD 40436 6197 4 whom whom WP 40436 6197 5 the the DT 40436 6197 6 multifarious multifarious JJ 40436 6197 7 agencies agency NNS 40436 6197 8 employed employ VBN 40436 6197 9 by by IN 40436 6197 10 King King NNP 40436 6197 11 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 6197 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6197 13 which which WDT 40436 6197 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6197 15 shall shall MD 40436 6197 16 find find VB 40436 6197 17 described describe VBN 40436 6197 18 more more RBR 40436 6197 19 at at IN 40436 6197 20 length length NN 40436 6197 21 in in IN 40436 6197 22 the the DT 40436 6197 23 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6197 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6197 25 have have VBP 40436 6197 26 failed fail VBN 40436 6197 27 to to TO 40436 6197 28 mould mould VB 40436 6197 29 into into IN 40436 6197 30 perfect perfect JJ 40436 6197 31 and and CC 40436 6197 32 uninquiring uninquiring JJ 40436 6197 33 conformity conformity NN 40436 6197 34 , , , 40436 6197 35 and and CC 40436 6197 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6197 37 is be VBZ 40436 6197 38 still still RB 40436 6197 39 in in IN 40436 6197 40 process process NN 40436 6197 41 of of IN 40436 6197 42 examination examination NN 40436 6197 43 to to TO 40436 6197 44 form form VB 40436 6197 45 a a DT 40436 6197 46 judgment judgment NN 40436 6197 47 for for IN 40436 6197 48 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6197 49 . . . 40436 6198 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6198 2 Side side NN 40436 6198 3 - - HYPH 40436 6198 4 note note NN 40436 6198 5 : : : 40436 6198 6 Answer answer NN 40436 6198 7 of of IN 40436 6198 8 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6198 9 -- -- : 40436 6198 10 plurality plurality NN 40436 6198 11 of of IN 40436 6198 12 virtues virtue NNS 40436 6198 13 , , , 40436 6198 14 one one CD 40436 6198 15 belonging belong VBG 40436 6198 16 to to IN 40436 6198 17 each each DT 40436 6198 18 different different JJ 40436 6198 19 class class NN 40436 6198 20 and and CC 40436 6198 21 condition condition NN 40436 6198 22 . . . 40436 6199 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6199 2 enquires enquire VBZ 40436 6199 3 for for IN 40436 6199 4 the the DT 40436 6199 5 property property NN 40436 6199 6 common common JJ 40436 6199 7 to to IN 40436 6199 8 all all DT 40436 6199 9 of of IN 40436 6199 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6199 11 . . . 40436 6199 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6200 1 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6200 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 6200 3 to to TO 40436 6200 4 answer answer VB 40436 6200 5 that that IN 40436 6200 6 there there EX 40436 6200 7 are be VBP 40436 6200 8 many many JJ 40436 6200 9 virtues virtue NNS 40436 6200 10 : : : 40436 6200 11 the the DT 40436 6200 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 6200 13 of of IN 40436 6200 14 a a DT 40436 6200 15 man man NN 40436 6200 16 -- -- : 40436 6200 17 competence competence NN 40436 6200 18 to to TO 40436 6200 19 transact transact VB 40436 6200 20 the the DT 40436 6200 21 business business NN 40436 6200 22 of of IN 40436 6200 23 the the DT 40436 6200 24 city city NN 40436 6200 25 , , , 40436 6200 26 and and CC 40436 6200 27 in in IN 40436 6200 28 such such JJ 40436 6200 29 business business NN 40436 6200 30 to to TO 40436 6200 31 benefit benefit VB 40436 6200 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6200 33 friends friend NNS 40436 6200 34 and and CC 40436 6200 35 injure injure VB 40436 6200 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6200 37 enemies enemy NNS 40436 6200 38 : : : 40436 6200 39 the the DT 40436 6200 40 virtue virtue NN 40436 6200 41 of of IN 40436 6200 42 a a DT 40436 6200 43 woman woman NN 40436 6200 44 -- -- : 40436 6200 45 to to TO 40436 6200 46 administer administer VB 40436 6200 47 the the DT 40436 6200 48 house house NN 40436 6200 49 well well RB 40436 6200 50 , , , 40436 6200 51 preserving preserve VBG 40436 6200 52 every every DT 40436 6200 53 thing thing NN 40436 6200 54 within within IN 40436 6200 55 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6200 56 and and CC 40436 6200 57 obeying obey VBG 40436 6200 58 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6200 59 husband husband NN 40436 6200 60 : : : 40436 6200 61 the the DT 40436 6200 62 virtue virtue NN 40436 6200 63 of of IN 40436 6200 64 a a DT 40436 6200 65 child child NN 40436 6200 66 , , , 40436 6200 67 of of IN 40436 6200 68 an an DT 40436 6200 69 old old JJ 40436 6200 70 man man NN 40436 6200 71 , , , 40436 6200 72 a a DT 40436 6200 73 slave slave NN 40436 6200 74 , , , 40436 6200 75 & & CC 40436 6200 76 c. c. NNP 40436 6200 77 There there EX 40436 6200 78 is be VBZ 40436 6200 79 in in IN 40436 6200 80 short short JJ 40436 6200 81 a a DT 40436 6200 82 virtue virtue NN 40436 6200 83 -- -- : 40436 6200 84 and and CC 40436 6200 85 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6200 86 contrary contrary NN 40436 6200 87 , , , 40436 6200 88 a a DT 40436 6200 89 vice vice NN 40436 6200 90 -- -- : 40436 6200 91 belonging belong VBG 40436 6200 92 to to IN 40436 6200 93 each each DT 40436 6200 94 of of IN 40436 6200 95 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6200 96 in in IN 40436 6200 97 every every DT 40436 6200 98 work work NN 40436 6200 99 , , , 40436 6200 100 profession profession NN 40436 6200 101 , , , 40436 6200 102 and and CC 40436 6200 103 age age NN 40436 6200 104 . . . 40436 6201 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6201 2 5 5 CD 40436 6201 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6201 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6201 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6201 6 5 5 CD 40436 6201 7 : : : 40436 6201 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6201 9 , , , 40436 6201 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6201 11 , , , 40436 6201 12 p. p. NN 40436 6201 13 72 72 CD 40436 6201 14 A. a. NN 40436 6202 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6202 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6202 3 : : : 40436 6202 4 kath kath NN 40436 6202 5 ' ' '' 40436 6202 6 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 6202 7 / / SYM 40436 6202 8 stên stên JJ 40436 6202 9 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6202 10 tô tô NNP 40436 6202 11 = = SYM 40436 6202 12 n n NNP 40436 6202 13 pra pra NNP 40436 6202 14 / / SYM 40436 6202 15 xeôn xeôn NNP 40436 6202 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6202 17 tô tô NNP 40436 6202 18 = = SYM 40436 6202 19 n n NNP 40436 6202 20 ê(likô ê(likô CC 40436 6202 21 = = SYM 40436 6202 22 n n NNP 40436 6202 23 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 6202 24 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 6202 25 e)/rgon e)/rgon NN 40436 6202 26 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 6202 27 / / SYM 40436 6202 28 stô| stô| NNP 40436 6202 29 ê(mô ê(mô NNP 40436 6202 30 = = SYM 40436 6202 31 n n CC 40436 6202 32 ê ê NNP 40436 6202 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6202 34 a)retê/ a)retê/ NNP 40436 6202 35 e)stin e)stin , 40436 6202 36 . . . 40436 6203 1 ô(sau ô(sau NNP 40436 6203 2 / / SYM 40436 6203 3 tôs tôs NNP 40436 6203 4 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6203 5 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6203 6 ê ê NNP 40436 6203 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6203 8 kaki kaki NNP 40436 6203 9 / / SYM 40436 6203 10 a a NN 40436 6203 11 . . . 40436 6203 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6204 1 Though though IN 40436 6204 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6204 3 disapproves disapprove VBZ 40436 6204 4 this this DT 40436 6204 5 method method NN 40436 6204 6 of of IN 40436 6204 7 answering--[Greek answering--[greek CD 40436 6204 8 : : : 40436 6204 9 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6204 10 e)xarithmei e)xarithmei NNP 40436 6204 11 = = SYM 40436 6204 12 n n NNP 40436 6204 13 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 6204 14 a)reta a)reta NNP 40436 6204 15 / / SYM 40436 6204 16 s s NNPS 40436 6204 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6204 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6204 19 to to TO 40436 6204 20 use use VB 40436 6204 21 the the DT 40436 6204 22 expression expression NN 40436 6204 23 of of IN 40436 6204 24 Aristotle)--yet Aristotle)--yet NNP 40436 6204 25 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6204 26 seems seem VBZ 40436 6204 27 to to TO 40436 6204 28 think think VB 40436 6204 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6204 30 better well RBR 40436 6204 31 than than IN 40436 6204 32 searching search VBG 40436 6204 33 for for IN 40436 6204 34 one one CD 40436 6204 35 general general JJ 40436 6204 36 definition definition NN 40436 6204 37 . . . 40436 6205 1 See see VB 40436 6205 2 Politica Politica NNP 40436 6205 3 , , , 40436 6205 4 i. i. NNP 40436 6206 1 13 13 CD 40436 6206 2 , , , 40436 6206 3 p. p. NN 40436 6206 4 1260 1260 CD 40436 6206 5 , , , 40436 6206 6 a. a. NN 40436 6207 1 15 15 CD 40436 6207 2 - - SYM 40436 6207 3 30 30 CD 40436 6207 4 , , , 40436 6207 5 where where WRB 40436 6207 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6207 7 has have VBZ 40436 6207 8 the the DT 40436 6207 9 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6207 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6207 11 in in IN 40436 6207 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6207 13 mind mind NN 40436 6207 14 . . . 40436 6207 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6208 1 But but CC 40436 6208 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6208 3 replies reply VBZ 40436 6208 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6208 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6208 6 are be VBP 40436 6208 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6208 8 not not RB 40436 6208 9 all all PDT 40436 6208 10 the the DT 40436 6208 11 same same JJ 40436 6208 12 , , , 40436 6208 13 _ _ NNP 40436 6208 14 quatenus quatenus NN 40436 6208 15 _ _ NNP 40436 6208 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 6208 17 ? ? . 40436 6209 1 Health Health NNP 40436 6209 2 , , , 40436 6209 3 _ _ NNP 40436 6209 4 quatenus quatenus NN 40436 6209 5 _ _ NNP 40436 6209 6 Health Health NNP 40436 6209 7 , , , 40436 6209 8 is be VBZ 40436 6209 9 the the DT 40436 6209 10 same same JJ 40436 6209 11 in in IN 40436 6209 12 a a DT 40436 6209 13 man man NN 40436 6209 14 or or CC 40436 6209 15 a a DT 40436 6209 16 woman woman NN 40436 6209 17 : : : 40436 6209 18 is be VBZ 40436 6209 19 not not RB 40436 6209 20 the the DT 40436 6209 21 case case NN 40436 6209 22 similar similar JJ 40436 6209 23 with with IN 40436 6209 24 virtue virtue NN 40436 6209 25 ? ? . 40436 6210 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6210 2 Menon._--Not Menon._--Not NNP 40436 6210 3 exactly exactly RB 40436 6210 4 similar similar JJ 40436 6210 5 . . . 40436 6211 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6211 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 6211 3 so so RB 40436 6211 4 ? ? . 40436 6212 1 Though though IN 40436 6212 2 there there EX 40436 6212 3 are be VBP 40436 6212 4 many many JJ 40436 6212 5 diverse diverse JJ 40436 6212 6 virtues virtue NNS 40436 6212 7 , , , 40436 6212 8 have have VBP 40436 6212 9 not not RB 40436 6212 10 all all DT 40436 6212 11 of of IN 40436 6212 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6212 13 one one CD 40436 6212 14 and and CC 40436 6212 15 the the DT 40436 6212 16 same same JJ 40436 6212 17 form form NN 40436 6212 18 in in IN 40436 6212 19 common common JJ 40436 6212 20 , , , 40436 6212 21 through through IN 40436 6212 22 the the DT 40436 6212 23 communion communion NN 40436 6212 24 of of IN 40436 6212 25 which which WDT 40436 6212 26 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6212 27 _ _ NNP 40436 6212 28 are be VBP 40436 6212 29 _ _ NNP 40436 6212 30 virtues virtue NNS 40436 6212 31 ? ? . 40436 6213 1 In in IN 40436 6213 2 answer answer NN 40436 6213 3 to to IN 40436 6213 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6213 5 question question NN 40436 6213 6 , , , 40436 6213 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6213 8 ought ought MD 40436 6213 9 to to TO 40436 6213 10 declare declare VB 40436 6213 11 what what WP 40436 6213 12 this this DT 40436 6213 13 common common JJ 40436 6213 14 form form NN 40436 6213 15 is be VBZ 40436 6213 16 . . . 40436 6214 1 Thus thus RB 40436 6214 2 , , , 40436 6214 3 both both CC 40436 6214 4 the the DT 40436 6214 5 man man NN 40436 6214 6 who who WP 40436 6214 7 administers administer VBZ 40436 6214 8 the the DT 40436 6214 9 city city NN 40436 6214 10 , , , 40436 6214 11 and and CC 40436 6214 12 the the DT 40436 6214 13 woman woman NN 40436 6214 14 who who WP 40436 6214 15 administers administer VBZ 40436 6214 16 the the DT 40436 6214 17 house house NN 40436 6214 18 , , , 40436 6214 19 must must MD 40436 6214 20 act act VB 40436 6214 21 both both DT 40436 6214 22 of of IN 40436 6214 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6214 24 with with IN 40436 6214 25 justice justice NN 40436 6214 26 and and CC 40436 6214 27 moderation moderation NN 40436 6214 28 . . . 40436 6215 1 Through through IN 40436 6215 2 the the DT 40436 6215 3 same same JJ 40436 6215 4 qualities quality NNS 40436 6215 5 , , , 40436 6215 6 both both CC 40436 6215 7 the the DT 40436 6215 8 one one NN 40436 6215 9 and and CC 40436 6215 10 the the DT 40436 6215 11 other other JJ 40436 6215 12 are be VBP 40436 6215 13 good good JJ 40436 6215 14 . . . 40436 6216 1 There there EX 40436 6216 2 is be VBZ 40436 6216 3 thus thus RB 40436 6216 4 some some DT 40436 6216 5 common common JJ 40436 6216 6 constituent constituent NN 40436 6216 7 : : : 40436 6216 8 tell tell VB 40436 6216 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6216 10 what what WP 40436 6216 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6216 12 is be VBZ 40436 6216 13 , , , 40436 6216 14 according accord VBG 40436 6216 15 to to IN 40436 6216 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6216 17 and and CC 40436 6216 18 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6216 19 ? ? . 40436 6217 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6217 2 Menon._--It Menon._--It NNP 40436 6217 3 is be VBZ 40436 6217 4 to to TO 40436 6217 5 be be VB 40436 6217 6 competent competent JJ 40436 6217 7 to to TO 40436 6217 8 exercise exercise VB 40436 6217 9 command command NN 40436 6217 10 over over IN 40436 6217 11 men man NNS 40436 6217 12 . . . 40436 6218 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6218 2 6 6 CD 40436 6218 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6218 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6218 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 6218 6 that that WDT 40436 6218 7 will will MD 40436 6218 8 not not RB 40436 6218 9 suit suit VB 40436 6218 10 for for IN 40436 6218 11 the the DT 40436 6218 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 6218 13 of of IN 40436 6218 14 a a DT 40436 6218 15 child child NN 40436 6218 16 or or CC 40436 6218 17 a a DT 40436 6218 18 slave slave NN 40436 6218 19 . . . 40436 6219 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 6219 2 , , , 40436 6219 3 must must MD 40436 6219 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6219 5 not not RB 40436 6219 6 superadd superadd VB 40436 6219 7 the the DT 40436 6219 8 condition condition NN 40436 6219 9 , , , 40436 6219 10 to to TO 40436 6219 11 command command VB 40436 6219 12 justly justly RB 40436 6219 13 , , , 40436 6219 14 and and CC 40436 6219 15 not not RB 40436 6219 16 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 6219 17 ? ? . 40436 6220 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6220 2 Menon._--I Menon._--I NNP 40436 6220 3 think think VBP 40436 6220 4 so so RB 40436 6220 5 : : : 40436 6220 6 justice justice NN 40436 6220 7 is be VBZ 40436 6220 8 virtue virtue JJ 40436 6220 9 . . . 40436 6221 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6221 2 Sokr._--Is Sokr._--Is NNP 40436 6221 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6221 4 virtue virtue VBP 40436 6221 5 -- -- : 40436 6221 6 or or CC 40436 6221 7 is be VBZ 40436 6221 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6221 9 one one CD 40436 6221 10 particular particular JJ 40436 6221 11 variety variety NN 40436 6221 12 of of IN 40436 6221 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 6221 14 ? ? . 40436 6222 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6222 2 7 7 CD 40436 6222 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6222 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6222 5 Menon._--How Menon._--How NNP 40436 6222 6 do do VBP 40436 6222 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6222 8 mean mean VB 40436 6222 9 ? ? . 40436 6223 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6223 2 Sokr._--Just Sokr._--Just NNP 40436 6223 3 as as IN 40436 6223 4 if if IN 40436 6223 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6223 6 were be VBD 40436 6223 7 to to TO 40436 6223 8 say say VB 40436 6223 9 about about IN 40436 6223 10 roundness roundness NN 40436 6223 11 , , , 40436 6223 12 that that IN 40436 6223 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6223 14 is be VBZ 40436 6223 15 not not RB 40436 6223 16 figure figure NN 40436 6223 17 , , , 40436 6223 18 but but CC 40436 6223 19 a a DT 40436 6223 20 particular particular JJ 40436 6223 21 variety variety NN 40436 6223 22 of of IN 40436 6223 23 figure figure NN 40436 6223 24 : : : 40436 6223 25 because because IN 40436 6223 26 there there EX 40436 6223 27 are be VBP 40436 6223 28 other other JJ 40436 6223 29 figures figure NNS 40436 6223 30 besides besides IN 40436 6223 31 roundness roundness NN 40436 6223 32 . . . 40436 6224 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6224 2 Menon._--Very menon._--very JJ 40436 6224 3 true true JJ 40436 6224 4 : : : 40436 6224 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6224 6 say say VBP 40436 6224 7 too too RB 40436 6224 8 , , , 40436 6224 9 that that IN 40436 6224 10 there there EX 40436 6224 11 are be VBP 40436 6224 12 other other JJ 40436 6224 13 virtues virtue NNS 40436 6224 14 besides besides IN 40436 6224 15 justice justice NN 40436 6224 16 -- -- : 40436 6224 17 namely namely RB 40436 6224 18 , , , 40436 6224 19 courage courage NN 40436 6224 20 , , , 40436 6224 21 moderation moderation NN 40436 6224 22 , , , 40436 6224 23 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 6224 24 , , , 40436 6224 25 magnanimity magnanimity NN 40436 6224 26 , , , 40436 6224 27 and and CC 40436 6224 28 several several JJ 40436 6224 29 others other NNS 40436 6224 30 also also RB 40436 6224 31 . . . 40436 6225 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6225 2 Sokr._--We Sokr._--We NNP 40436 6225 3 are be VBP 40436 6225 4 thus thus RB 40436 6225 5 still still RB 40436 6225 6 in in IN 40436 6225 7 the the DT 40436 6225 8 same same JJ 40436 6225 9 predicament predicament NN 40436 6225 10 . . . 40436 6226 1 In in IN 40436 6226 2 looking look VBG 40436 6226 3 for for IN 40436 6226 4 one one CD 40436 6226 5 virtue virtue NN 40436 6226 6 , , , 40436 6226 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6226 8 have have VBP 40436 6226 9 found find VBN 40436 6226 10 many many JJ 40436 6226 11 ; ; : 40436 6226 12 but but CC 40436 6226 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6226 14 can can MD 40436 6226 15 not not RB 40436 6226 16 find find VB 40436 6226 17 that that IN 40436 6226 18 one one CD 40436 6226 19 form form NN 40436 6226 20 which which WDT 40436 6226 21 runs run VBZ 40436 6226 22 through through IN 40436 6226 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6226 24 all all DT 40436 6226 25 . . . 40436 6227 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6227 2 Menon._--I Menon._--I NNP 40436 6227 3 can can MD 40436 6227 4 not not RB 40436 6227 5 at at IN 40436 6227 6 present present JJ 40436 6227 7 tell tell VB 40436 6227 8 what what WP 40436 6227 9 that that DT 40436 6227 10 one one NN 40436 6227 11 is be VBZ 40436 6227 12 . . . 40436 6228 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6228 2 8 8 CD 40436 6228 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6228 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6228 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6228 6 6 6 CD 40436 6228 7 : : : 40436 6228 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6228 9 , , , 40436 6228 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6228 11 , , , 40436 6228 12 p. p. NN 40436 6228 13 73 73 CD 40436 6228 14 D. D. NNP 40436 6228 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6228 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6228 17 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6228 18 7 7 CD 40436 6228 19 : : : 40436 6228 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6228 21 , , , 40436 6228 22 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6228 23 , , , 40436 6228 24 p. p. NN 40436 6228 25 73 73 CD 40436 6228 26 E. E. NNP 40436 6228 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6228 28 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6228 29 : : : 40436 6228 30 Po Po NNP 40436 6228 31 / / SYM 40436 6228 32 teron teron NNP 40436 6228 33 a)retê/ a)retê/ NNP 40436 6228 34 , , , 40436 6228 35 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 6228 36 Me Me NNP 40436 6228 37 / / SYM 40436 6228 38 nôn nôn NN 40436 6228 39 , , , 40436 6228 40 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 6228 41 a)retê/ a)retê/ NNP 40436 6228 42 tis tis NNP 40436 6228 43 ? ? . 40436 6228 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6228 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6229 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6229 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6229 3 8 8 CD 40436 6229 4 : : : 40436 6229 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6229 6 , , , 40436 6229 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6229 8 , , , 40436 6229 9 p. p. NN 40436 6229 10 74 74 CD 40436 6229 11 A. a. NN 40436 6230 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6230 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6230 3 : : : 40436 6230 4 ou ou NNP 40436 6230 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6230 6 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6230 7 du du NNP 40436 6230 8 / / SYM 40436 6230 9 namai/ namai/ NNP 40436 6230 10 pô pô NN 40436 6230 11 , , , 40436 6230 12 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 6230 13 Sô Sô NNP 40436 6230 14 / / SYM 40436 6230 15 krates krate NNS 40436 6230 16 , , , 40436 6230 17 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 6230 18 su\ su\ NNP 40436 6230 19 zêtei zêtei NNP 40436 6230 20 = = SYM 40436 6230 21 s s NNP 40436 6230 22 , , , 40436 6230 23 mi mi NNP 40436 6230 24 / / SYM 40436 6230 25 an an DT 40436 6230 26 a)retê\n a)retê\n JJ 40436 6230 27 labei labei NN 40436 6230 28 = = SYM 40436 6230 29 n n NNP 40436 6230 30 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 6230 31 pa pa NNP 40436 6230 32 / / SYM 40436 6230 33 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 6230 34 . . . 40436 6230 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6230 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6231 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6231 2 Side side NN 40436 6231 3 - - HYPH 40436 6231 4 note note NN 40436 6231 5 : : : 40436 6231 6 Analogous analogous JJ 40436 6231 7 cases case NNS 40436 6231 8 cited cite VBD 40436 6231 9 -- -- : 40436 6231 10 definitions definition NNS 40436 6231 11 of of IN 40436 6231 12 figure figure NN 40436 6231 13 and and CC 40436 6231 14 colour colour NN 40436 6231 15 . . . 40436 6231 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6232 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6232 2 proceeds proceed NNS 40436 6232 3 to to TO 40436 6232 4 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 6232 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6232 6 meaning meaning NN 40436 6232 7 by by IN 40436 6232 8 the the DT 40436 6232 9 analogies analogy NNS 40436 6232 10 of of IN 40436 6232 11 figure figure NN 40436 6232 12 and and CC 40436 6232 13 colour colour NN 40436 6232 14 . . . 40436 6233 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 6233 2 call call VBP 40436 6233 3 _ _ NNP 40436 6233 4 round round NN 40436 6233 5 _ _ NNP 40436 6233 6 a a DT 40436 6233 7 figure figure NN 40436 6233 8 , , , 40436 6233 9 and and CC 40436 6233 10 _ _ NNP 40436 6233 11 square square NN 40436 6233 12 _ _ NNP 40436 6233 13 a a DT 40436 6233 14 figure figure NN 40436 6233 15 : : : 40436 6233 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6233 17 call call VBP 40436 6233 18 _ _ NNP 40436 6233 19 white white NNP 40436 6233 20 _ _ NNP 40436 6233 21 and and CC 40436 6233 22 _ _ NNP 40436 6233 23 black black JJ 40436 6233 24 _ _ NNP 40436 6233 25 both both DT 40436 6233 26 colour colour NN 40436 6233 27 , , , 40436 6233 28 the the DT 40436 6233 29 one one NN 40436 6233 30 as as RB 40436 6233 31 much much RB 40436 6233 32 as as IN 40436 6233 33 the the DT 40436 6233 34 other other JJ 40436 6233 35 , , , 40436 6233 36 though though IN 40436 6233 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6233 38 are be VBP 40436 6233 39 unlike unlike JJ 40436 6233 40 and and CC 40436 6233 41 even even RB 40436 6233 42 opposite opposite JJ 40436 6233 43 . . . 40436 6234 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6234 2 9 9 CD 40436 6234 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6234 4 Tell tell VB 40436 6234 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6234 6 , , , 40436 6234 7 What what WP 40436 6234 8 is be VBZ 40436 6234 9 this this DT 40436 6234 10 same same JJ 40436 6234 11 common common JJ 40436 6234 12 figure figure NN 40436 6234 13 and and CC 40436 6234 14 property property NN 40436 6234 15 in in IN 40436 6234 16 both both DT 40436 6234 17 , , , 40436 6234 18 which which WDT 40436 6234 19 makes make VBZ 40436 6234 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6234 21 call call VB 40436 6234 22 both both DT 40436 6234 23 of of IN 40436 6234 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6234 25 figure figure VBP 40436 6234 26 -- -- : 40436 6234 27 both both DT 40436 6234 28 of of IN 40436 6234 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6234 30 colour colour NN 40436 6234 31 ? ? . 40436 6235 1 Take take VB 40436 6235 2 this this DT 40436 6235 3 as as IN 40436 6235 4 a a DT 40436 6235 5 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 6235 6 exercise exercise NN 40436 6235 7 , , , 40436 6235 8 in in IN 40436 6235 9 order order NN 40436 6235 10 to to TO 40436 6235 11 help help VB 40436 6235 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6235 13 in in IN 40436 6235 14 answering answer VBG 40436 6235 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6235 16 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 6235 17 about about IN 40436 6235 18 virtue virtue NN 40436 6235 19 . . . 40436 6236 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6236 2 10 10 CD 40436 6236 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6236 4 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6236 5 can can MD 40436 6236 6 not not RB 40436 6236 7 answer answer VB 40436 6236 8 , , , 40436 6236 9 and and CC 40436 6236 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6236 11 answers answer VBZ 40436 6236 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6236 13 own own JJ 40436 6236 14 question question NN 40436 6236 15 . . . 40436 6237 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6237 2 gives give VBZ 40436 6237 3 a a DT 40436 6237 4 general general JJ 40436 6237 5 definition definition NN 40436 6237 6 , , , 40436 6237 7 first first RB 40436 6237 8 of of IN 40436 6237 9 figure figure NN 40436 6237 10 , , , 40436 6237 11 next next RB 40436 6237 12 of of IN 40436 6237 13 colour colour NN 40436 6237 14 . . . 40436 6238 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6238 2 first first RB 40436 6238 3 defines define VBZ 40436 6238 4 figure figure VBP 40436 6238 5 in in IN 40436 6238 6 a a DT 40436 6238 7 way way NN 40436 6238 8 which which WDT 40436 6238 9 implies imply VBZ 40436 6238 10 colour colour NN 40436 6238 11 to to TO 40436 6238 12 be be VB 40436 6238 13 known know VBN 40436 6238 14 . . . 40436 6239 1 This this DT 40436 6239 2 is be VBZ 40436 6239 3 pointed point VBN 40436 6239 4 out out RP 40436 6239 5 ; ; : 40436 6239 6 and and CC 40436 6239 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6239 8 then then RB 40436 6239 9 admits admit VBZ 40436 6239 10 that that IN 40436 6239 11 in in IN 40436 6239 12 a a DT 40436 6239 13 good good JJ 40436 6239 14 definition definition NN 40436 6239 15 , , , 40436 6239 16 suitable suitable JJ 40436 6239 17 to to IN 40436 6239 18 genuine genuine JJ 40436 6239 19 dialectical dialectical JJ 40436 6239 20 investigation investigation NN 40436 6239 21 , , , 40436 6239 22 nothing nothing NN 40436 6239 23 should should MD 40436 6239 24 be be VB 40436 6239 25 implied imply VBN 40436 6239 26 as as IN 40436 6239 27 known know VBN 40436 6239 28 , , , 40436 6239 29 except except IN 40436 6239 30 what what WP 40436 6239 31 the the DT 40436 6239 32 respondent respondent NN 40436 6239 33 admits admit VBZ 40436 6239 34 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6239 35 to to TO 40436 6239 36 know know VB 40436 6239 37 . . . 40436 6240 1 Figure figure NN 40436 6240 2 and and CC 40436 6240 3 colour colour NN 40436 6240 4 are be VBP 40436 6240 5 both both DT 40436 6240 6 defined define VBN 40436 6240 7 suitably suitably RB 40436 6240 8 to to IN 40436 6240 9 this this DT 40436 6240 10 condition condition NN 40436 6240 11 . . . 40436 6241 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6241 2 11 11 CD 40436 6241 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6241 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6241 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6241 6 9 9 CD 40436 6241 7 : : : 40436 6241 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6241 9 , , , 40436 6241 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6241 11 , , , 40436 6241 12 p. p. NN 40436 6241 13 74 74 CD 40436 6241 14 D. D. NNP 40436 6241 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6241 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6241 17 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6241 18 10 10 CD 40436 6241 19 : : : 40436 6241 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6241 21 , , , 40436 6241 22 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6241 23 , , , 40436 6241 24 c. c. NNP 40436 6241 25 7 7 CD 40436 6241 26 , , , 40436 6241 27 pp pp NNP 40436 6241 28 . . . 40436 6242 1 74 74 CD 40436 6242 2 - - SYM 40436 6242 3 75 75 CD 40436 6242 4 . . . 40436 6243 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6243 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6243 3 : : : 40436 6243 4 Peirô= Peirô= NNP 40436 6243 5 ei)pei ei)pei NN 40436 6243 6 = = SYM 40436 6243 7 n n NNP 40436 6243 8 , , , 40436 6243 9 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 6243 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6243 11 ge ge NNP 40436 6243 12 / / SYM 40436 6243 13 nêtai/ nêtai/ NNP 40436 6243 14 soi soi NNP 40436 6243 15 mele mele NN 40436 6243 16 / / , 40436 6243 17 tê tê NNP 40436 6243 18 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 6243 19 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6243 20 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6243 21 tê tê NNP 40436 6243 22 = = SYM 40436 6243 23 s s NNP 40436 6243 24 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 6243 25 = = SYM 40436 6243 26 s s NNP 40436 6243 27 a)po a)po NNPS 40436 6243 28 / / SYM 40436 6243 29 krisin krisin NN 40436 6243 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6243 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6243 32 75 75 CD 40436 6243 33 A a NN 40436 6243 34 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6243 35 . . . 40436 6244 1 The the DT 40436 6244 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 6244 3 of of IN 40436 6244 4 practising practise VBG 40436 6244 5 the the DT 40436 6244 6 respondent respondent NN 40436 6244 7 is be VBZ 40436 6244 8 here here RB 40436 6244 9 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 6244 10 announced announce VBN 40436 6244 11 . . . 40436 6244 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6245 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6245 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6245 3 11 11 CD 40436 6245 4 : : : 40436 6245 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6245 6 , , , 40436 6245 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6245 8 , , , 40436 6245 9 p. p. NN 40436 6245 10 75 75 CD 40436 6245 11 C C NNP 40436 6245 12 - - HYPH 40436 6245 13 E. E. NNP 40436 6245 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6245 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6245 16 Side side NN 40436 6245 17 - - HYPH 40436 6245 18 note note NN 40436 6245 19 : : : 40436 6245 20 Importance importance NN 40436 6245 21 at at IN 40436 6245 22 that that DT 40436 6245 23 time time NN 40436 6245 24 of of IN 40436 6245 25 bringing bring VBG 40436 6245 26 into into IN 40436 6245 27 conscious conscious JJ 40436 6245 28 view view NN 40436 6245 29 , , , 40436 6245 30 logical logical JJ 40436 6245 31 subordination subordination NN 40436 6245 32 and and CC 40436 6245 33 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 6245 34 -- -- : 40436 6245 35 Neither neither CC 40436 6245 36 logic logic NN 40436 6245 37 nor nor CC 40436 6245 38 grammar grammar NN 40436 6245 39 had have VBD 40436 6245 40 then then RB 40436 6245 41 been be VBN 40436 6245 42 cast cast VBN 40436 6245 43 into into IN 40436 6245 44 system system NN 40436 6245 45 . . . 40436 6245 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6246 1 All all PDT 40436 6246 2 this this DT 40436 6246 3 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 6246 4 matter matter NN 40436 6246 5 seems seem VBZ 40436 6246 6 to to TO 40436 6246 7 be be VB 40436 6246 8 intended intend VBN 40436 6246 9 for for IN 40436 6246 10 the the DT 40436 6246 11 purpose purpose NN 40436 6246 12 of of IN 40436 6246 13 getting get VBG 40436 6246 14 the the DT 40436 6246 15 question question NN 40436 6246 16 clearly clearly RB 40436 6246 17 conceived conceive VBN 40436 6246 18 as as IN 40436 6246 19 a a DT 40436 6246 20 general general JJ 40436 6246 21 question question NN 40436 6246 22 -- -- : 40436 6246 23 of of IN 40436 6246 24 exhibiting exhibit VBG 40436 6246 25 and and CC 40436 6246 26 eliminating eliminate VBG 40436 6246 27 the the DT 40436 6246 28 narrow narrow JJ 40436 6246 29 and and CC 40436 6246 30 partial partial JJ 40436 6246 31 conceptions conception NNS 40436 6246 32 which which WDT 40436 6246 33 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 6246 34 substitute substitute VBP 40436 6246 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6246 36 in in IN 40436 6246 37 the the DT 40436 6246 38 mind mind NN 40436 6246 39 , , , 40436 6246 40 in in IN 40436 6246 41 place place NN 40436 6246 42 of of IN 40436 6246 43 that that DT 40436 6246 44 which which WDT 40436 6246 45 ought ought MD 40436 6246 46 to to TO 40436 6246 47 be be VB 40436 6246 48 conceived conceive VBN 40436 6246 49 as as IN 40436 6246 50 a a DT 40436 6246 51 generic generic JJ 40436 6246 52 whole whole NN 40436 6246 53 -- -- : 40436 6246 54 and and CC 40436 6246 55 of of IN 40436 6246 56 clearing clear VBG 40436 6246 57 up up RP 40436 6246 58 what what WP 40436 6246 59 is be VBZ 40436 6246 60 required require VBN 40436 6246 61 in in IN 40436 6246 62 a a DT 40436 6246 63 good good JJ 40436 6246 64 definition definition NN 40436 6246 65 . . . 40436 6247 1 A a DT 40436 6247 2 generic generic JJ 40436 6247 3 whole whole NN 40436 6247 4 , , , 40436 6247 5 including include VBG 40436 6247 6 various various JJ 40436 6247 7 specific specific JJ 40436 6247 8 portions portion NNS 40436 6247 9 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 40436 6247 10 from from IN 40436 6247 11 each each DT 40436 6247 12 other other JJ 40436 6247 13 , , , 40436 6247 14 was be VBD 40436 6247 15 at at IN 40436 6247 16 that that DT 40436 6247 17 time time NN 40436 6247 18 little little JJ 40436 6247 19 understood understand VBN 40436 6247 20 by by IN 40436 6247 21 any any DT 40436 6247 22 one one CD 40436 6247 23 . . . 40436 6248 1 There there EX 40436 6248 2 existed exist VBD 40436 6248 3 no no DT 40436 6248 4 grammar grammar NN 40436 6248 5 , , , 40436 6248 6 nor nor CC 40436 6248 7 any any DT 40436 6248 8 rules rule NNS 40436 6248 9 of of IN 40436 6248 10 logic logic NN 40436 6248 11 founded found VBN 40436 6248 12 on on IN 40436 6248 13 analysis analysis NN 40436 6248 14 of of IN 40436 6248 15 the the DT 40436 6248 16 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 6248 17 processes process NNS 40436 6248 18 . . . 40436 6249 1 To to TO 40436 6249 2 predicate predicate VB 40436 6249 3 of of IN 40436 6249 4 the the DT 40436 6249 5 genus genus NN 40436 6249 6 what what WP 40436 6249 7 was be VBD 40436 6249 8 true true JJ 40436 6249 9 only only RB 40436 6249 10 of of IN 40436 6249 11 the the DT 40436 6249 12 species specie NNS 40436 6249 13 -- -- : 40436 6249 14 to to TO 40436 6249 15 predicate predicate VB 40436 6249 16 as as IN 40436 6249 17 distinctively distinctively RB 40436 6249 18 characterizing characterize VBG 40436 6249 19 the the DT 40436 6249 20 species specie NNS 40436 6249 21 , , , 40436 6249 22 what what WP 40436 6249 23 is be VBZ 40436 6249 24 true true JJ 40436 6249 25 of of IN 40436 6249 26 the the DT 40436 6249 27 whole whole JJ 40436 6249 28 genus genus NN 40436 6249 29 in in IN 40436 6249 30 which which WDT 40436 6249 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6249 32 is be VBZ 40436 6249 33 contained contain VBN 40436 6249 34 -- -- : 40436 6249 35 to to TO 40436 6249 36 lose lose VB 40436 6249 37 the the DT 40436 6249 38 integrity integrity NN 40436 6249 39 of of IN 40436 6249 40 the the DT 40436 6249 41 genus genus NN 40436 6249 42 in in IN 40436 6249 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6249 44 separate separate JJ 40436 6249 45 parcels parcel NNS 40436 6249 46 or or CC 40436 6249 47 fragments[12]--these fragments[12]--these NNS 40436 6249 48 were be VBD 40436 6249 49 errors error NNS 40436 6249 50 which which WDT 40436 6249 51 men man NNS 40436 6249 52 had have VBD 40436 6249 53 never never RB 40436 6249 54 yet yet RB 40436 6249 55 been be VBN 40436 6249 56 expressly expressly RB 40436 6249 57 taught teach VBN 40436 6249 58 to to TO 40436 6249 59 avoid avoid VB 40436 6249 60 . . . 40436 6250 1 To to TO 40436 6250 2 assign assign VB 40436 6250 3 the the DT 40436 6250 4 one one CD 40436 6250 5 common common JJ 40436 6250 6 meaning meaning NN 40436 6250 7 , , , 40436 6250 8 constituent constituent NN 40436 6250 9 of of IN 40436 6250 10 or or CC 40436 6250 11 connoted connote VBN 40436 6250 12 by by IN 40436 6250 13 a a DT 40436 6250 14 generic generic JJ 40436 6250 15 term term NN 40436 6250 16 , , , 40436 6250 17 had have VBD 40436 6250 18 never never RB 40436 6250 19 yet yet RB 40436 6250 20 been be VBN 40436 6250 21 put put VBN 40436 6250 22 before before IN 40436 6250 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6250 24 as as IN 40436 6250 25 a a DT 40436 6250 26 problem problem NN 40436 6250 27 . . . 40436 6251 1 Such such JJ 40436 6251 2 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 6251 3 clearing clearing NN 40436 6251 4 of of IN 40436 6251 5 the the DT 40436 6251 6 ground ground NN 40436 6251 7 is be VBZ 40436 6251 8 instructive instructive JJ 40436 6251 9 even even RB 40436 6251 10 now now RB 40436 6251 11 , , , 40436 6251 12 when when WRB 40436 6251 13 formal formal JJ 40436 6251 14 and and CC 40436 6251 15 systematic systematic JJ 40436 6251 16 logic logic NN 40436 6251 17 has have VBZ 40436 6251 18 become become VBN 40436 6251 19 more more RBR 40436 6251 20 or or CC 40436 6251 21 less less RBR 40436 6251 22 familiar familiar JJ 40436 6251 23 : : : 40436 6251 24 but but CC 40436 6251 25 in in IN 40436 6251 26 the the DT 40436 6251 27 time time NN 40436 6251 28 of of IN 40436 6251 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6251 30 , , , 40436 6251 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6251 32 must must MD 40436 6251 33 have have VB 40436 6251 34 been be VBN 40436 6251 35 indispensably indispensably RB 40436 6251 36 required require VBN 40436 6251 37 , , , 40436 6251 38 to to TO 40436 6251 39 arrive arrive VB 40436 6251 40 at at IN 40436 6251 41 a a DT 40436 6251 42 full full JJ 40436 6251 43 conception conception NN 40436 6251 44 of of IN 40436 6251 45 any any DT 40436 6251 46 general general JJ 40436 6251 47 question question NN 40436 6251 48 . . . 40436 6252 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6252 2 13 13 CD 40436 6252 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6252 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6252 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6252 6 12 12 CD 40436 6252 7 : : : 40436 6252 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6252 9 , , , 40436 6252 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6252 11 , , , 40436 6252 12 p. p. NN 40436 6252 13 79 79 CD 40436 6252 14 A. a. NN 40436 6253 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6253 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6253 3 : : : 40436 6253 4 e)mou= e)mou= NFP 40436 6253 5 deêthe deêthe NNP 40436 6253 6 / / SYM 40436 6253 7 ntos ntos NNP 40436 6253 8 sou sou NNP 40436 6253 9 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 6253 10 katagnu katagnu NNP 40436 6253 11 / / SYM 40436 6253 12 mai mai NNP 40436 6253 13 mêde\ mêde\ NNP 40436 6253 14 kermati kermati NNP 40436 6253 15 / / SYM 40436 6253 16 zein zein NNP 40436 6253 17 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6253 18 a)retên a)retên NNP 40436 6253 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6253 20 , , , 40436 6253 21 & & CC 40436 6253 22 c. c. NNP 40436 6253 23 79 79 CD 40436 6253 24 B B NNP 40436 6253 25 : : : 40436 6253 26 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6253 27 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6253 28 : : : 40436 6253 29 e)mou= e)mou= NFP 40436 6253 30 deêthe deêthe JJS 40436 6253 31 / / SYM 40436 6253 32 ntos ntos NN 40436 6253 33 o(/lên o(/lên NNP 40436 6253 34 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 6253 35 = = SYM 40436 6253 36 n n CC 40436 6253 37 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6253 38 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 6253 39 / / SYM 40436 6253 40 n n NN 40436 6253 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6253 42 , , , 40436 6253 43 & & CC 40436 6253 44 c. c. NNP 40436 6253 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6253 46 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6253 47 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6253 48 13 13 CD 40436 6253 49 : : : 40436 6253 50 These these DT 40436 6253 51 examples example NNS 40436 6253 52 of of IN 40436 6253 53 trial trial NN 40436 6253 54 , , , 40436 6253 55 error error NN 40436 6253 56 , , , 40436 6253 57 and and CC 40436 6253 58 exposure exposure NN 40436 6253 59 , , , 40436 6253 60 have have VBP 40436 6253 61 great great JJ 40436 6253 62 value value NN 40436 6253 63 and and CC 40436 6253 64 reflect reflect VB 40436 6253 65 high high JJ 40436 6253 66 credit credit NN 40436 6253 67 on on IN 40436 6253 68 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6253 69 , , , 40436 6253 70 when when WRB 40436 6253 71 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6253 72 regard regard VBP 40436 6253 73 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6253 74 as as IN 40436 6253 75 an an DT 40436 6253 76 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 6253 77 or or CC 40436 6253 78 propædeutic propædeutic JJ 40436 6253 79 discipline discipline NN 40436 6253 80 , , , 40436 6253 81 forcing force VBG 40436 6253 82 upon upon IN 40436 6253 83 hearers hearer NNS 40436 6253 84 an an DT 40436 6253 85 attention attention NN 40436 6253 86 to to IN 40436 6253 87 useful useful JJ 40436 6253 88 logical logical JJ 40436 6253 89 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 6253 90 at at IN 40436 6253 91 a a DT 40436 6253 92 time time NN 40436 6253 93 when when WRB 40436 6253 94 there there EX 40436 6253 95 existed exist VBD 40436 6253 96 no no DT 40436 6253 97 systematic systematic JJ 40436 6253 98 grammar grammar NN 40436 6253 99 or or CC 40436 6253 100 logic logic NN 40436 6253 101 . . . 40436 6254 1 But but CC 40436 6254 2 surely surely RB 40436 6254 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6254 4 must must MD 40436 6254 5 appear appear VB 40436 6254 6 degraded degraded JJ 40436 6254 7 , , , 40436 6254 8 as as IN 40436 6254 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6254 10 are be VBP 40436 6254 11 presented present VBN 40436 6254 12 in in IN 40436 6254 13 the the DT 40436 6254 14 Prolegomena Prolegomena NNP 40436 6254 15 of of IN 40436 6254 16 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6254 17 , , , 40436 6254 18 and and CC 40436 6254 19 by by IN 40436 6254 20 some some DT 40436 6254 21 other other JJ 40436 6254 22 critics critic NNS 40436 6254 23 . . . 40436 6255 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6255 2 are be VBP 40436 6255 3 there there RB 40436 6255 4 told tell VBN 40436 6255 5 that that IN 40436 6255 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6255 7 's 's POS 40436 6255 8 main main JJ 40436 6255 9 purpose purpose NN 40436 6255 10 in in IN 40436 6255 11 this this DT 40436 6255 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6255 13 was be VBD 40436 6255 14 to to TO 40436 6255 15 mock mock VB 40436 6255 16 and and CC 40436 6255 17 jeer jeer VB 40436 6255 18 the the DT 40436 6255 19 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6255 20 and and CC 40436 6255 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6255 22 pupil pupil NN 40436 6255 23 , , , 40436 6255 24 and and CC 40436 6255 25 that that IN 40436 6255 26 for for IN 40436 6255 27 this this DT 40436 6255 28 purpose purpose NN 40436 6255 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6255 30 is be VBZ 40436 6255 31 made make VBN 40436 6255 32 to to TO 40436 6255 33 employ employ VB 40436 6255 34 not not RB 40436 6255 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6255 36 own own JJ 40436 6255 37 arguments argument NNS 40436 6255 38 but but CC 40436 6255 39 arguments argument NNS 40436 6255 40 borrowed borrow VBN 40436 6255 41 from from IN 40436 6255 42 the the DT 40436 6255 43 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6255 44 themselves--"ut themselves--"ut NNP 40436 6255 45 callidé callidé VBZ 40436 6255 46 suam suam NNP 40436 6255 47 ipsius ipsius NNP 40436 6255 48 rationem rationem NNP 40436 6255 49 occultare occultare NNP 40436 6255 50 existimandus existimandus NNP 40436 6255 51 sit sit NNP 40436 6255 52 , , , 40436 6255 53 quo quo NN 40436 6255 54 magis magi NNS 40436 6255 55 illudat illudat NNP 40436 6255 56 Sophistarum Sophistarum NNP 40436 6255 57 alumnum alumnum NN 40436 6255 58 " " '' 40436 6255 59 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6255 60 p. p. NN 40436 6255 61 15 15 CD 40436 6255 62 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6255 63 . . . 40436 6256 1 " " `` 40436 6256 2 Quæ Quæ NNP 40436 6256 3 quidem quidem VBP 40436 6256 4 argumentatio argumentatio NN 40436 6256 5 " " '' 40436 6256 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6256 7 that that IN 40436 6256 8 of of IN 40436 6256 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6256 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6256 11 " " '' 40436 6256 12 admodum admodum NN 40436 6256 13 cavendum cavendum NNP 40436 6256 14 est est NNP 40436 6256 15 ne ne NNP 40436 6256 16 pro pro AFX 40436 6256 17 Socraticâ Socraticâ NNP 40436 6256 18 vel vel NNP 40436 6256 19 Platonicâ Platonicâ NNP 40436 6256 20 accipiatur accipiatur NN 40436 6256 21 . . . 40436 6257 1 Est Est NNP 40436 6257 2 enim enim NN 40436 6257 3 prorsus prorsu VBD 40436 6257 4 ad ad NN 40436 6257 5 mentem mentem NN 40436 6257 6 Sophistarum Sophistarum NNP 40436 6257 7 aliorumque aliorumque IN 40436 6257 8 i -PRON- PRP 40436 6257 9 d d VBD 40436 6257 10 genus genus NNP 40436 6257 11 hominum hominum NNP 40436 6257 12 comparata comparata NNP 40436 6257 13 , , , 40436 6257 14 " " '' 40436 6257 15 & & CC 40436 6257 16 c. c. NNP 40436 6257 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6257 18 p. p. NN 40436 6257 19 16 16 CD 40436 6257 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6257 21 . . . 40436 6258 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6258 2 pp pp NN 40436 6258 3 . . . 40436 6259 1 12 12 CD 40436 6259 2 - - SYM 40436 6259 3 13 13 CD 40436 6259 4 seq seq NN 40436 6259 5 . . . 40436 6260 1 The the DT 40436 6260 2 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6260 3 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 6260 4 had have VBD 40436 6260 5 no no DT 40436 6260 6 distinct distinct JJ 40436 6260 7 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 6260 8 , , , 40436 6260 9 any any DT 40436 6260 10 more more RBR 40436 6260 11 than than IN 40436 6260 12 other other JJ 40436 6260 13 persons person NNS 40436 6260 14 , , , 40436 6260 15 of of IN 40436 6260 16 these these DT 40436 6260 17 logical logical JJ 40436 6260 18 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 6260 19 , , , 40436 6260 20 which which WDT 40436 6260 21 were be VBD 40436 6260 22 then then RB 40436 6260 23 for for IN 40436 6260 24 the the DT 40436 6260 25 first first JJ 40436 6260 26 pressed press VBN 40436 6260 27 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 6260 28 upon upon IN 40436 6260 29 attention attention NN 40436 6260 30 . . . 40436 6260 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6261 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6261 2 Side side NN 40436 6261 3 - - HYPH 40436 6261 4 note note NN 40436 6261 5 : : : 40436 6261 6 Definition definition NN 40436 6261 7 of of IN 40436 6261 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 6261 9 given give VBN 40436 6261 10 by by IN 40436 6261 11 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6261 12 : : : 40436 6261 13 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6261 14 pulls pull VBZ 40436 6261 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6261 16 to to IN 40436 6261 17 pieces piece NNS 40436 6261 18 . . . 40436 6261 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6262 1 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6262 2 having have VBG 40436 6262 3 been be VBN 40436 6262 4 thus thus RB 40436 6262 5 made make VBN 40436 6262 6 to to TO 40436 6262 7 understand understand VB 40436 6262 8 the the DT 40436 6262 9 formal formal JJ 40436 6262 10 requisites requisite NNS 40436 6262 11 for for IN 40436 6262 12 a a DT 40436 6262 13 definition definition NN 40436 6262 14 , , , 40436 6262 15 gives give VBZ 40436 6262 16 as as IN 40436 6262 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6262 18 definition definition NN 40436 6262 19 of of IN 40436 6262 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 6262 21 the the DT 40436 6262 22 phrase phrase NN 40436 6262 23 of of IN 40436 6262 24 some some DT 40436 6262 25 lyric lyric NN 40436 6262 26 poet--"To poet--"To NNP 40436 6262 27 delight delight NN 40436 6262 28 in in IN 40436 6262 29 , , , 40436 6262 30 or or CC 40436 6262 31 desire desire NN 40436 6262 32 , , , 40436 6262 33 things thing NNS 40436 6262 34 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 6262 35 , , , 40436 6262 36 fine fine JJ 40436 6262 37 , , , 40436 6262 38 honourable honourable JJ 40436 6262 39 -- -- : 40436 6262 40 and and CC 40436 6262 41 to to TO 40436 6262 42 have have VB 40436 6262 43 the the DT 40436 6262 44 power power NN 40436 6262 45 of of IN 40436 6262 46 getting get VBG 40436 6262 47 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6262 48 " " '' 40436 6262 49 . . . 40436 6263 1 But but CC 40436 6263 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6263 3 remarks remark VBZ 40436 6263 4 that that IN 40436 6263 5 honourable honourable JJ 40436 6263 6 things thing NNS 40436 6263 7 are be VBP 40436 6263 8 good good JJ 40436 6263 9 things thing NNS 40436 6263 10 , , , 40436 6263 11 and and CC 40436 6263 12 that that IN 40436 6263 13 every every DT 40436 6263 14 one one CD 40436 6263 15 without without IN 40436 6263 16 exception exception NN 40436 6263 17 desires desire NNS 40436 6263 18 good good JJ 40436 6263 19 . . . 40436 6264 1 No no DT 40436 6264 2 one one NN 40436 6264 3 desires desire VBZ 40436 6264 4 evil evil JJ 40436 6264 5 except except IN 40436 6264 6 when when WRB 40436 6264 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6264 8 mistakes mistake VBZ 40436 6264 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6264 10 for for IN 40436 6264 11 good good JJ 40436 6264 12 . . . 40436 6265 1 On on IN 40436 6265 2 this this DT 40436 6265 3 point point NN 40436 6265 4 all all DT 40436 6265 5 men man NNS 40436 6265 6 are be VBP 40436 6265 7 alike alike JJ 40436 6265 8 ; ; : 40436 6265 9 the the DT 40436 6265 10 distinctive distinctive JJ 40436 6265 11 feature feature NN 40436 6265 12 of of IN 40436 6265 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 6265 14 must must MD 40436 6265 15 then then RB 40436 6265 16 consist consist VB 40436 6265 17 in in IN 40436 6265 18 the the DT 40436 6265 19 second second JJ 40436 6265 20 half half NN 40436 6265 21 of of IN 40436 6265 22 the the DT 40436 6265 23 definition definition NN 40436 6265 24 -- -- : 40436 6265 25 in in IN 40436 6265 26 the the DT 40436 6265 27 power power NN 40436 6265 28 of of IN 40436 6265 29 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 6265 30 good good JJ 40436 6265 31 things thing NNS 40436 6265 32 , , , 40436 6265 33 such such JJ 40436 6265 34 as as IN 40436 6265 35 health health NN 40436 6265 36 , , , 40436 6265 37 wealth wealth NN 40436 6265 38 , , , 40436 6265 39 money money NN 40436 6265 40 , , , 40436 6265 41 power power NN 40436 6265 42 , , , 40436 6265 43 dignities dignity NNS 40436 6265 44 , , , 40436 6265 45 & & CC 40436 6265 46 c.[14 c.[14 NNP 40436 6265 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6265 48 But but CC 40436 6265 49 the the DT 40436 6265 50 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 6265 51 of of IN 40436 6265 52 these these DT 40436 6265 53 things thing NNS 40436 6265 54 is be VBZ 40436 6265 55 not not RB 40436 6265 56 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 6265 57 , , , 40436 6265 58 unless unless IN 40436 6265 59 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6265 60 be be VB 40436 6265 61 made make VBN 40436 6265 62 consistently consistently RB 40436 6265 63 with with IN 40436 6265 64 justice justice NN 40436 6265 65 and and CC 40436 6265 66 moderation moderation NN 40436 6265 67 : : : 40436 6265 68 moreover moreover CC 40436 6265 69 the the DT 40436 6265 70 man man NN 40436 6265 71 who who WP 40436 6265 72 acts act VBZ 40436 6265 73 justly justly RB 40436 6265 74 is be VBZ 40436 6265 75 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 6265 76 , , , 40436 6265 77 even even RB 40436 6265 78 though though IN 40436 6265 79 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6265 80 does do VBZ 40436 6265 81 not not RB 40436 6265 82 acquire acquire VB 40436 6265 83 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6265 84 . . . 40436 6266 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6266 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 6266 3 then then RB 40436 6266 4 that that IN 40436 6266 5 every every DT 40436 6266 6 agent agent NN 40436 6266 7 who who WP 40436 6266 8 acts act VBZ 40436 6266 9 with with IN 40436 6266 10 justice justice NN 40436 6266 11 and and CC 40436 6266 12 moderation moderation NN 40436 6266 13 is be VBZ 40436 6266 14 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 6266 15 . . . 40436 6267 1 But but CC 40436 6267 2 this this DT 40436 6267 3 is be VBZ 40436 6267 4 nugatory nugatory JJ 40436 6267 5 as as IN 40436 6267 6 a a DT 40436 6267 7 definition definition NN 40436 6267 8 of of IN 40436 6267 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 6267 10 : : : 40436 6267 11 for for IN 40436 6267 12 justice justice NN 40436 6267 13 and and CC 40436 6267 14 moderation moderation NN 40436 6267 15 are be VBP 40436 6267 16 only only RB 40436 6267 17 known know VBN 40436 6267 18 as as IN 40436 6267 19 parts part NNS 40436 6267 20 of of IN 40436 6267 21 virtue virtue NN 40436 6267 22 , , , 40436 6267 23 and and CC 40436 6267 24 require require VB 40436 6267 25 to to TO 40436 6267 26 be be VB 40436 6267 27 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6267 28 defined define VBN 40436 6267 29 . . . 40436 6268 1 No no DT 40436 6268 2 man man NN 40436 6268 3 can can MD 40436 6268 4 know know VB 40436 6268 5 what what WP 40436 6268 6 a a DT 40436 6268 7 part part NN 40436 6268 8 of of IN 40436 6268 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 6268 10 is be VBZ 40436 6268 11 , , , 40436 6268 12 unless unless IN 40436 6268 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6268 14 knows know VBZ 40436 6268 15 what what WP 40436 6268 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 6268 17 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 6268 18 is be VBZ 40436 6268 19 . . . 40436 6269 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6269 2 15 15 CD 40436 6269 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6269 4 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6269 5 must must MD 40436 6269 6 look look VB 40436 6269 7 for for IN 40436 6269 8 a a DT 40436 6269 9 better well JJR 40436 6269 10 definition definition NN 40436 6269 11 , , , 40436 6269 12 including include VBG 40436 6269 13 nothing nothing NN 40436 6269 14 but but CC 40436 6269 15 what what WP 40436 6269 16 is be VBZ 40436 6269 17 already already RB 40436 6269 18 known know VBN 40436 6269 19 or or CC 40436 6269 20 admitted admit VBN 40436 6269 21 . . . 40436 6270 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6270 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6270 3 14 14 CD 40436 6270 4 : : : 40436 6270 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6270 6 , , , 40436 6270 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6270 8 , , , 40436 6270 9 p. p. NN 40436 6270 10 77 77 CD 40436 6270 11 B. B. NNP 40436 6271 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6271 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6271 3 : : : 40436 6271 4 dokei= dokei= NNP 40436 6271 5 toi toi NNP 40436 6271 6 / / SYM 40436 6271 7 nun nun NNP 40436 6271 8 moi moi NNP 40436 6271 9 a)retê\ a)retê\ NNP 40436 6271 10 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 6271 11 , , , 40436 6271 12 katha katha NNP 40436 6271 13 / / SYM 40436 6271 14 per per IN 40436 6271 15 o o FW 40436 6271 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6271 17 poiêtê\s poiêtê\s NFP 40436 6271 18 le le NNP 40436 6271 19 / / SYM 40436 6271 20 gei gei NNP 40436 6271 21 , , , 40436 6271 22 chai chai NNP 40436 6271 23 / / SYM 40436 6271 24 rein rein NNP 40436 6271 25 te te NNP 40436 6271 26 kaloi kaloi NNP 40436 6271 27 = = SYM 40436 6271 28 si si NNP 40436 6271 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6271 30 du du NNP 40436 6271 31 / / SYM 40436 6271 32 nasthai nasthai NNP 40436 6271 33 . . . 40436 6272 1 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 6272 2 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 6272 3 tou tou NNP 40436 6272 4 = = SYM 40436 6272 5 to to IN 40436 6272 6 le le NNP 40436 6272 7 / / SYM 40436 6272 8 gô gô NNP 40436 6272 9 a)retê\n a)retê\n NNP 40436 6272 10 e)pithumou e)pithumou NNS 40436 6272 11 = = SYM 40436 6272 12 nta nta NNP 40436 6272 13 tô tô NNP 40436 6272 14 = = SYM 40436 6272 15 n n CC 40436 6272 16 kalô kalô NN 40436 6272 17 = = SYM 40436 6272 18 n n CC 40436 6272 19 dunato\n dunato\n ADD 40436 6272 20 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 6272 21 pori pori NNP 40436 6272 22 / / SYM 40436 6272 23 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 6272 24 . . . 40436 6272 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6273 1 Whoever whoever WP 40436 6273 2 this this DT 40436 6273 3 lyric lyric JJ 40436 6273 4 poet poet NN 40436 6273 5 was be VBD 40436 6273 6 , , , 40436 6273 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6273 8 real real JJ 40436 6273 9 meaning meaning NN 40436 6273 10 is be VBZ 40436 6273 11 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 6273 12 twisted twisted JJ 40436 6273 13 by by IN 40436 6273 14 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6273 15 in in IN 40436 6273 16 order order NN 40436 6273 17 to to TO 40436 6273 18 furnish furnish VB 40436 6273 19 a a DT 40436 6273 20 basis basis NN 40436 6273 21 for for IN 40436 6273 22 ethical ethical JJ 40436 6273 23 criticism criticism NN 40436 6273 24 , , , 40436 6273 25 as as IN 40436 6273 26 the the DT 40436 6273 27 song song NN 40436 6273 28 of of IN 40436 6273 29 Simonides Simonides NNP 40436 6273 30 is be VBZ 40436 6273 31 in in IN 40436 6273 32 the the DT 40436 6273 33 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6273 34 . . . 40436 6274 1 A a DT 40436 6274 2 person person NN 40436 6274 3 having have VBG 40436 6274 4 power power NN 40436 6274 5 , , , 40436 6274 6 and and CC 40436 6274 7 taking take VBG 40436 6274 8 delight delight NN 40436 6274 9 in in IN 40436 6274 10 honourable honourable JJ 40436 6274 11 or or CC 40436 6274 12 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 6274 13 things thing NNS 40436 6274 14 -- -- : 40436 6274 15 is be VBZ 40436 6274 16 a a DT 40436 6274 17 very very RB 40436 6274 18 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 6274 19 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 40436 6274 20 idéal idéal NN 40436 6274 21 , , , 40436 6274 22 as as IN 40436 6274 23 an an DT 40436 6274 24 object object NN 40436 6274 25 of of IN 40436 6274 26 envy envy NN 40436 6274 27 and and CC 40436 6274 28 admiration admiration NN 40436 6274 29 . . . 40436 6275 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 6275 2 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6275 3 , , , 40436 6275 4 p. p. NN 40436 6275 5 351 351 CD 40436 6275 6 C c NN 40436 6275 7 : : : 40436 6275 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6275 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6275 10 : : : 40436 6275 11 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 6275 12 toi toi NNP 40436 6275 13 = = SYM 40436 6275 14 s s NNP 40436 6275 15 kaloi kaloi NNP 40436 6275 16 = = SYM 40436 6275 17 s s NNP 40436 6275 18 zô/|ê zô/|ê NNP 40436 6275 19 ê(do ê(do NNP 40436 6275 20 / / SYM 40436 6275 21 menos menos NNP 40436 6275 22 . . . 40436 6275 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6276 1 A a DT 40436 6276 2 poor poor JJ 40436 6276 3 man man NN 40436 6276 4 may may MD 40436 6276 5 be be VB 40436 6276 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6276 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6276 8 : : : 40436 6276 9 philo philo JJ 40436 6276 10 / / SYM 40436 6276 11 kalos kalos NNPS 40436 6276 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6276 13 as as RB 40436 6276 14 well well RB 40436 6276 15 as as IN 40436 6276 16 a a DT 40436 6276 17 rich rich JJ 40436 6276 18 man man NN 40436 6276 19 : : : 40436 6276 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6276 21 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6276 22 : : : 40436 6276 23 philokalou philokalou NNP 40436 6276 24 = = NFP 40436 6276 25 men man NNS 40436 6276 26 met meet VBD 40436 6276 27 ' ' '' 40436 6276 28 eu)telei eu)telei XX 40436 6276 29 / / SYM 40436 6276 30 as as IN 40436 6276 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6276 32 , , , 40436 6276 33 is be VBZ 40436 6276 34 the the DT 40436 6276 35 boast boast NN 40436 6276 36 of of IN 40436 6276 37 Periklês Periklês NNPS 40436 6276 38 in in IN 40436 6276 39 the the DT 40436 6276 40 name name NN 40436 6276 41 of of IN 40436 6276 42 the the DT 40436 6276 43 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 6276 44 , , , 40436 6276 45 Thucyd Thucyd NNP 40436 6276 46 . . . 40436 6277 1 ii ii LS 40436 6277 2 . . . 40436 6278 1 40 40 CD 40436 6278 2 . . . 40436 6279 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6279 2 , , , 40436 6279 3 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6279 4 , , , 40436 6279 5 p. p. NN 40436 6279 6 78 78 CD 40436 6279 7 C. C. NNP 40436 6279 8 _ _ NNP 40436 6279 9 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 6279 10 . . . 40436 6279 11 _ _ NNP 40436 6279 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6279 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6279 14 : : : 40436 6279 15 A)gatha\ A)gatha\ NNP 40436 6279 16 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6279 17 kalei kalei NN 40436 6279 18 = = NFP 40436 6279 19 s s NNP 40436 6279 20 ou)chi ou)chi NNP 40436 6279 21 oi(=on oi(=on NNP 40436 6279 22 u(gi u(gi NNP 40436 6279 23 / / SYM 40436 6279 24 eia eia NN 40436 6279 25 / / SYM 40436 6279 26 n n NNP 40436 6279 27 te te NNP 40436 6279 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6279 29 plou plou NNP 40436 6279 30 = = SYM 40436 6279 31 ton ton NN 40436 6279 32 ? ? . 40436 6280 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6280 2 chrusi chrusi NNP 40436 6280 3 / / SYM 40436 6280 4 on on IN 40436 6280 5 le le NNP 40436 6280 6 / / SYM 40436 6280 7 gô gô NNP 40436 6280 8 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6280 9 a)rgu a)rgu NNP 40436 6280 10 / / SYM 40436 6280 11 rion rion NNP 40436 6280 12 kta kta NNP 40436 6280 13 = = SYM 40436 6280 14 sthai sthai NNP 40436 6280 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6280 16 tima\s tima\s ADD 40436 6280 17 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6280 18 po po NNP 40436 6280 19 / / SYM 40436 6280 20 lei lei NNP 40436 6280 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6280 22 a)rcha a)rcha NNP 40436 6280 23 / / SYM 40436 6280 24 s s NNP 40436 6280 25 ? ? . 40436 6281 1 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 6281 2 a)/ll a)/ll NNS 40436 6281 3 ' ' POS 40436 6281 4 a)/tta a)/tta NNP 40436 6281 5 le le NNP 40436 6281 6 / / SYM 40436 6281 7 geis geis NNP 40436 6281 8 ta)gatha\ ta)gatha\ NNP 40436 6281 9 ê)\ ê)\ SYM 40436 6281 10 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 6281 11 toiau toiau NNP 40436 6281 12 = = SYM 40436 6281 13 ta ta ADD 40436 6281 14 ? ? . 40436 6281 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6282 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6282 2 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6282 3 . . . 40436 6282 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6282 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6282 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6282 7 : : : 40436 6282 8 Ou)k Ou)k NNP 40436 6282 9 ; ; : 40436 6282 10 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 6282 11 pa pa NNP 40436 6282 12 / / SYM 40436 6282 13 nta nta NNP 40436 6282 14 le le NNP 40436 6282 15 / / SYM 40436 6282 16 gô gô NNP 40436 6282 17 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 6282 18 toiau toiau NNP 40436 6282 19 = = SYM 40436 6282 20 ta ta NNP 40436 6282 21 . . . 40436 6282 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6282 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6283 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6283 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6283 3 15 15 CD 40436 6283 4 : : : 40436 6283 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6283 6 , , , 40436 6283 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6283 8 , , , 40436 6283 9 p. p. NN 40436 6284 1 79 79 CD 40436 6284 2 . . . 40436 6284 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6285 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6285 2 Side side NN 40436 6285 3 - - HYPH 40436 6285 4 note note NN 40436 6285 5 : : : 40436 6285 6 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6285 7 complains complain VBZ 40436 6285 8 that that IN 40436 6285 9 the the DT 40436 6285 10 conversation conversation NN 40436 6285 11 of of IN 40436 6285 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6285 13 confounds confound VBZ 40436 6285 14 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6285 15 like like IN 40436 6285 16 an an DT 40436 6285 17 electric electric JJ 40436 6285 18 shock shock NN 40436 6285 19 -- -- : 40436 6285 20 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6285 21 replies reply VBZ 40436 6285 22 that that IN 40436 6285 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6285 24 is be VBZ 40436 6285 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6285 26 in in IN 40436 6285 27 the the DT 40436 6285 28 same same JJ 40436 6285 29 state state NN 40436 6285 30 of of IN 40436 6285 31 confusion confusion NN 40436 6285 32 and and CC 40436 6285 33 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6285 34 . . . 40436 6286 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6286 2 urges urge VBZ 40436 6286 3 continuance continuance NN 40436 6286 4 of of IN 40436 6286 5 search search NN 40436 6286 6 by by IN 40436 6286 7 both both DT 40436 6286 8 . . . 40436 6286 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6287 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6287 2 Menon._--Your menon._--your CD 40436 6287 3 conversation conversation NN 40436 6287 4 , , , 40436 6287 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6287 6 , , , 40436 6287 7 produces produce VBZ 40436 6287 8 the the DT 40436 6287 9 effect effect NN 40436 6287 10 of of IN 40436 6287 11 the the DT 40436 6287 12 shock shock NN 40436 6287 13 of of IN 40436 6287 14 the the DT 40436 6287 15 torpedo torpedo NN 40436 6287 16 : : : 40436 6287 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6287 18 stun stun VB 40436 6287 19 and and CC 40436 6287 20 confound confound VB 40436 6287 21 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6287 22 : : : 40436 6287 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6287 24 throw throw VBP 40436 6287 25 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6287 26 into into IN 40436 6287 27 inextricable inextricable JJ 40436 6287 28 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 6287 29 , , , 40436 6287 30 so so IN 40436 6287 31 that that IN 40436 6287 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6287 33 can can MD 40436 6287 34 make make VB 40436 6287 35 no no DT 40436 6287 36 answer answer NN 40436 6287 37 . . . 40436 6288 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6288 2 have have VBP 40436 6288 3 often often RB 40436 6288 4 discoursed discourse VBN 40436 6288 5 copiously copiously RB 40436 6288 6 -- -- : 40436 6288 7 and and CC 40436 6288 8 , , , 40436 6288 9 as as IN 40436 6288 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6288 11 thought think VBD 40436 6288 12 , , , 40436 6288 13 effectively effectively RB 40436 6288 14 -- -- : 40436 6288 15 upon upon IN 40436 6288 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 6288 17 ; ; : 40436 6288 18 but but CC 40436 6288 19 now now RB 40436 6288 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6288 21 have have VBP 40436 6288 22 shown show VBN 40436 6288 23 that that IN 40436 6288 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6288 25 do do VBP 40436 6288 26 not not RB 40436 6288 27 even even RB 40436 6288 28 know know VB 40436 6288 29 what what WP 40436 6288 30 virtue virtue NN 40436 6288 31 is be VBZ 40436 6288 32 . . . 40436 6289 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6289 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 6289 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6289 4 throw throw VBP 40436 6289 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6289 6 into into IN 40436 6289 7 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 6289 8 , , , 40436 6289 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6289 10 is be VBZ 40436 6289 11 only only RB 40436 6289 12 because because IN 40436 6289 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6289 14 am be VBP 40436 6289 15 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 6289 16 in in IN 40436 6289 17 the the DT 40436 6289 18 like like JJ 40436 6289 19 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 6289 20 and and CC 40436 6289 21 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6289 22 . . . 40436 6290 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6290 2 do do VBP 40436 6290 3 not not RB 40436 6290 4 know know VB 40436 6290 5 what what WP 40436 6290 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 6290 7 is be VBZ 40436 6290 8 , , , 40436 6290 9 any any DT 40436 6290 10 more more RBR 40436 6290 11 than than IN 40436 6290 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6290 13 : : : 40436 6290 14 and and CC 40436 6290 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6290 16 shall shall MD 40436 6290 17 be be VB 40436 6290 18 glad glad JJ 40436 6290 19 to to TO 40436 6290 20 continue continue VB 40436 6290 21 the the DT 40436 6290 22 search search NN 40436 6290 23 for for IN 40436 6290 24 finding find VBG 40436 6290 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6290 26 , , , 40436 6290 27 if if IN 40436 6290 28 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6290 29 will will MD 40436 6290 30 assist assist VB 40436 6290 31 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6290 32 . . . 40436 6291 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6291 2 Side side NN 40436 6291 3 - - HYPH 40436 6291 4 note note NN 40436 6291 5 : : : 40436 6291 6 But but CC 40436 6291 7 how how WRB 40436 6291 8 is be VBZ 40436 6291 9 the the DT 40436 6291 10 process process NN 40436 6291 11 of of IN 40436 6291 12 search search NN 40436 6291 13 available available JJ 40436 6291 14 to to IN 40436 6291 15 any any DT 40436 6291 16 purpose purpose NN 40436 6291 17 ? ? . 40436 6292 1 No no DT 40436 6292 2 man man NN 40436 6292 3 searches search VBZ 40436 6292 4 for for IN 40436 6292 5 what what WP 40436 6292 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6292 7 already already RB 40436 6292 8 knows know VBZ 40436 6292 9 : : : 40436 6292 10 and and CC 40436 6292 11 for for IN 40436 6292 12 what what WP 40436 6292 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6292 14 does do VBZ 40436 6292 15 not not RB 40436 6292 16 know know VB 40436 6292 17 , , , 40436 6292 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6292 19 is be VBZ 40436 6292 20 useless useless JJ 40436 6292 21 to to TO 40436 6292 22 search search VB 40436 6292 23 , , , 40436 6292 24 for for IN 40436 6292 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6292 26 can can MD 40436 6292 27 not not RB 40436 6292 28 tell tell VB 40436 6292 29 when when WRB 40436 6292 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6292 31 has have VBZ 40436 6292 32 found find VBN 40436 6292 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6292 34 . . . 40436 6292 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6293 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6293 2 Menon._--But Menon._--But NNP 40436 6293 3 how how WRB 40436 6293 4 are be VBP 40436 6293 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6293 6 to to TO 40436 6293 7 search search VB 40436 6293 8 for for IN 40436 6293 9 that that DT 40436 6293 10 of of IN 40436 6293 11 which which WDT 40436 6293 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6293 13 are be VBP 40436 6293 14 altogether altogether RB 40436 6293 15 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 6293 16 ? ? . 40436 6294 1 Even even RB 40436 6294 2 if if IN 40436 6294 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6294 4 do do VBP 40436 6294 5 find find VB 40436 6294 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6294 7 , , , 40436 6294 8 how how WRB 40436 6294 9 can can MD 40436 6294 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6294 11 ever ever RB 40436 6294 12 know know VB 40436 6294 13 that that IN 40436 6294 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6294 15 have have VBP 40436 6294 16 found find VBN 40436 6294 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6294 18 ? ? . 40436 6295 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6295 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 6295 3 are be VBP 40436 6295 4 now now RB 40436 6295 5 introducing introduce VBG 40436 6295 6 a a DT 40436 6295 7 troublesome troublesome JJ 40436 6295 8 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6295 9 , , , 40436 6295 10 laid lay VBN 40436 6295 11 down down RP 40436 6295 12 by by IN 40436 6295 13 those those DT 40436 6295 14 who who WP 40436 6295 15 are be VBP 40436 6295 16 averse averse JJ 40436 6295 17 to to IN 40436 6295 18 the the DT 40436 6295 19 labour labour NN 40436 6295 20 of of IN 40436 6295 21 thought thought NN 40436 6295 22 . . . 40436 6296 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 6296 2 tell tell VBP 40436 6296 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6296 4 that that IN 40436 6296 5 a a DT 40436 6296 6 man man NN 40436 6296 7 can can MD 40436 6296 8 not not RB 40436 6296 9 search search VB 40436 6296 10 either either CC 40436 6296 11 for for IN 40436 6296 12 what what WP 40436 6296 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6296 14 knows know VBZ 40436 6296 15 , , , 40436 6296 16 or or CC 40436 6296 17 for for IN 40436 6296 18 what what WP 40436 6296 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6296 20 does do VBZ 40436 6296 21 not not RB 40436 6296 22 know know VB 40436 6296 23 . . . 40436 6297 1 For for IN 40436 6297 2 the the DT 40436 6297 3 former former JJ 40436 6297 4 , , , 40436 6297 5 research research NN 40436 6297 6 is be VBZ 40436 6297 7 superfluous superfluous JJ 40436 6297 8 : : : 40436 6297 9 for for IN 40436 6297 10 the the DT 40436 6297 11 latter latter JJ 40436 6297 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6297 13 is be VBZ 40436 6297 14 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 6297 15 and and CC 40436 6297 16 purposeless purposeless JJ 40436 6297 17 , , , 40436 6297 18 since since IN 40436 6297 19 the the DT 40436 6297 20 searcher searcher NN 40436 6297 21 does do VBZ 40436 6297 22 not not RB 40436 6297 23 know know VB 40436 6297 24 what what WP 40436 6297 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6297 26 is be VBZ 40436 6297 27 looking look VBG 40436 6297 28 for for IN 40436 6297 29 . . . 40436 6298 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6298 2 Side side NN 40436 6298 3 - - HYPH 40436 6298 4 note note NN 40436 6298 5 : : : 40436 6298 6 Theory theory NN 40436 6298 7 of of IN 40436 6298 8 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6298 9 propounded propound VBN 40436 6298 10 by by IN 40436 6298 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6298 12 -- -- : 40436 6298 13 anterior anterior NN 40436 6298 14 immortality immortality NN 40436 6298 15 of of IN 40436 6298 16 the the DT 40436 6298 17 soul soul NN 40436 6298 18 -- -- : 40436 6298 19 what what WP 40436 6298 20 is be VBZ 40436 6298 21 called call VBN 40436 6298 22 teaching teaching NN 40436 6298 23 is be VBZ 40436 6298 24 the the DT 40436 6298 25 revival revival NN 40436 6298 26 and and CC 40436 6298 27 recognition recognition NN 40436 6298 28 of of IN 40436 6298 29 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6298 30 acquired acquire VBN 40436 6298 31 in in IN 40436 6298 32 a a DT 40436 6298 33 former former JJ 40436 6298 34 life life NN 40436 6298 35 , , , 40436 6298 36 but but CC 40436 6298 37 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6298 38 . . . 40436 6298 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6299 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6299 2 do do VBP 40436 6299 3 not not RB 40436 6299 4 believe believe VB 40436 6299 5 this this DT 40436 6299 6 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6299 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6299 8 continues continue VBZ 40436 6299 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6299 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6299 11 . . . 40436 6300 1 Priests priest NNS 40436 6300 2 , , , 40436 6300 3 priestesses priestess NNS 40436 6300 4 , , , 40436 6300 5 and and CC 40436 6300 6 poets poet NNS 40436 6300 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6300 8 Pindar Pindar NNP 40436 6300 9 among among IN 40436 6300 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6300 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6300 12 tell tell VBP 40436 6300 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6300 14 , , , 40436 6300 15 that that IN 40436 6300 16 the the DT 40436 6300 17 mind mind NN 40436 6300 18 of of IN 40436 6300 19 man man NN 40436 6300 20 is be VBZ 40436 6300 21 immortal immortal JJ 40436 6300 22 and and CC 40436 6300 23 has have VBZ 40436 6300 24 existed exist VBN 40436 6300 25 throughout throughout IN 40436 6300 26 all all DT 40436 6300 27 past past JJ 40436 6300 28 time time NN 40436 6300 29 , , , 40436 6300 30 in in IN 40436 6300 31 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 6300 32 with with IN 40436 6300 33 successive successive JJ 40436 6300 34 bodies body NNS 40436 6300 35 ; ; : 40436 6300 36 alternately alternately RB 40436 6300 37 abandoning abandon VBG 40436 6300 38 one one CD 40436 6300 39 body body NN 40436 6300 40 , , , 40436 6300 41 or or CC 40436 6300 42 dying die VBG 40436 6300 43 -- -- : 40436 6300 44 and and CC 40436 6300 45 taking take VBG 40436 6300 46 up up RP 40436 6300 47 new new JJ 40436 6300 48 life life NN 40436 6300 49 or or CC 40436 6300 50 reviving reviving NN 40436 6300 51 in in IN 40436 6300 52 another another DT 40436 6300 53 body body NN 40436 6300 54 . . . 40436 6301 1 In in IN 40436 6301 2 this this DT 40436 6301 3 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 6301 4 succession succession NN 40436 6301 5 of of IN 40436 6301 6 existences existence NNS 40436 6301 7 , , , 40436 6301 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6301 9 has have VBZ 40436 6301 10 seen see VBN 40436 6301 11 every every DT 40436 6301 12 thing,--both thing,--both , 40436 6301 13 here here RB 40436 6301 14 and and CC 40436 6301 15 in in IN 40436 6301 16 Hades Hades NNP 40436 6301 17 and and CC 40436 6301 18 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 6301 19 else else RB 40436 6301 20 -- -- : 40436 6301 21 and and CC 40436 6301 22 has have VBZ 40436 6301 23 learnt learn VBN 40436 6301 24 every every DT 40436 6301 25 thing thing NN 40436 6301 26 . . . 40436 6302 1 But but CC 40436 6302 2 though though IN 40436 6302 3 thus thus RB 40436 6302 4 omniscient omniscient JJ 40436 6302 5 , , , 40436 6302 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6302 7 has have VBZ 40436 6302 8 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6302 9 the the DT 40436 6302 10 larger large JJR 40436 6302 11 portion portion NN 40436 6302 12 of of IN 40436 6302 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6302 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6302 15 . . . 40436 6303 1 Yet yet CC 40436 6303 2 what what WP 40436 6303 3 has have VBZ 40436 6303 4 been be VBN 40436 6303 5 thus thus RB 40436 6303 6 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6303 7 may may MD 40436 6303 8 again again RB 40436 6303 9 be be VB 40436 6303 10 revived revive VBN 40436 6303 11 . . . 40436 6304 1 What what WP 40436 6304 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6304 3 call call VBP 40436 6304 4 learning learning NN 40436 6304 5 , , , 40436 6304 6 is be VBZ 40436 6304 7 such such JJ 40436 6304 8 revival revival NN 40436 6304 9 . . . 40436 6305 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6305 2 is be VBZ 40436 6305 3 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6305 4 of of IN 40436 6305 5 something something NN 40436 6305 6 which which WDT 40436 6305 7 the the DT 40436 6305 8 mind mind NN 40436 6305 9 had have VBD 40436 6305 10 seen see VBN 40436 6305 11 in in IN 40436 6305 12 a a DT 40436 6305 13 former former JJ 40436 6305 14 state state NN 40436 6305 15 of of IN 40436 6305 16 existence existence NN 40436 6305 17 , , , 40436 6305 18 and and CC 40436 6305 19 knew know VBD 40436 6305 20 , , , 40436 6305 21 but but CC 40436 6305 22 had have VBD 40436 6305 23 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6305 24 . . . 40436 6306 1 Since since IN 40436 6306 2 then then RB 40436 6306 3 all all PDT 40436 6306 4 the the DT 40436 6306 5 parts part NNS 40436 6306 6 of of IN 40436 6306 7 nature nature NN 40436 6306 8 are be VBP 40436 6306 9 analogous analogous JJ 40436 6306 10 , , , 40436 6306 11 or or CC 40436 6306 12 cognate cognate VB 40436 6306 13 -- -- : 40436 6306 14 and and CC 40436 6306 15 since since IN 40436 6306 16 the the DT 40436 6306 17 mind mind NN 40436 6306 18 has have VBZ 40436 6306 19 gone go VBN 40436 6306 20 through through RB 40436 6306 21 and and CC 40436 6306 22 learnt learn VBD 40436 6306 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6306 24 all all DT 40436 6306 25 -- -- : 40436 6306 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6306 27 can can MD 40436 6306 28 not not RB 40436 6306 29 wonder wonder VB 40436 6306 30 that that IN 40436 6306 31 the the DT 40436 6306 32 revival revival NN 40436 6306 33 of of IN 40436 6306 34 any any DT 40436 6306 35 one one CD 40436 6306 36 part part NN 40436 6306 37 should should MD 40436 6306 38 put put VB 40436 6306 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6306 40 upon upon IN 40436 6306 41 the the DT 40436 6306 42 track track NN 40436 6306 43 of of IN 40436 6306 44 recovering recover VBG 40436 6306 45 for for IN 40436 6306 46 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 6306 47 all all PDT 40436 6306 48 the the DT 40436 6306 49 rest rest NN 40436 6306 50 , , , 40436 6306 51 both both CC 40436 6306 52 about about IN 40436 6306 53 virtue virtue NN 40436 6306 54 and and CC 40436 6306 55 about about RB 40436 6306 56 every every DT 40436 6306 57 thing thing NN 40436 6306 58 else else RB 40436 6306 59 , , , 40436 6306 60 if if IN 40436 6306 61 a a DT 40436 6306 62 man man NN 40436 6306 63 will will MD 40436 6306 64 only only RB 40436 6306 65 persevere persevere RB 40436 6306 66 in in IN 40436 6306 67 intent intent JJ 40436 6306 68 meditation meditation NN 40436 6306 69 . . . 40436 6307 1 All all DT 40436 6307 2 research research NN 40436 6307 3 and and CC 40436 6307 4 all all DT 40436 6307 5 learning learning NN 40436 6307 6 is be VBZ 40436 6307 7 thus thus RB 40436 6307 8 nothing nothing NN 40436 6307 9 but but IN 40436 6307 10 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6307 11 . . . 40436 6308 1 In in IN 40436 6308 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6308 3 researches research NNS 40436 6308 4 , , , 40436 6308 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6308 6 are be VBP 40436 6308 7 not not RB 40436 6308 8 looking look VBG 40436 6308 9 for for IN 40436 6308 10 what what WP 40436 6308 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6308 12 do do VBP 40436 6308 13 not not RB 40436 6308 14 know know VB 40436 6308 15 : : : 40436 6308 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6308 17 are be VBP 40436 6308 18 looking look VBG 40436 6308 19 for for IN 40436 6308 20 what what WP 40436 6308 21 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6308 22 do do VBP 40436 6308 23 know know VB 40436 6308 24 , , , 40436 6308 25 but but CC 40436 6308 26 have have VBP 40436 6308 27 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6308 28 . . . 40436 6309 1 There there EX 40436 6309 2 is be VBZ 40436 6309 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 6309 4 ample ample JJ 40436 6309 5 motive motive NN 40436 6309 6 , , , 40436 6309 7 and and CC 40436 6309 8 ample ample JJ 40436 6309 9 remuneration remuneration NN 40436 6309 10 , , , 40436 6309 11 for for IN 40436 6309 12 prosecuting prosecute VBG 40436 6309 13 enquiries enquiry NNS 40436 6309 14 : : : 40436 6309 15 and and CC 40436 6309 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6309 17 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6309 18 which which WDT 40436 6309 19 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 6309 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6309 21 to to TO 40436 6309 22 be be VB 40436 6309 23 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 6309 24 , , , 40436 6309 25 is be VBZ 40436 6309 26 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 6309 27 . . . 40436 6310 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6310 2 16 16 CD 40436 6310 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6310 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6310 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6310 6 16 16 CD 40436 6310 7 : : : 40436 6310 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6310 9 , , , 40436 6310 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6310 11 , , , 40436 6310 12 pp pp NNP 40436 6310 13 . . . 40436 6311 1 81 81 CD 40436 6311 2 C C NNP 40436 6311 3 - - HYPH 40436 6311 4 D. D. NNP 40436 6311 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6311 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6311 7 : : : 40436 6311 8 A(=te A(=te NNP 40436 6311 9 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 6311 10 ê ê NNP 40436 6311 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6311 12 psuchê\ psuchê\ NNP 40436 6311 13 a)tha a)tha NNP 40436 6311 14 / / SYM 40436 6311 15 nato nato NNP 40436 6311 16 / / SYM 40436 6311 17 s s POS 40436 6311 18 te te NNP 40436 6311 19 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 6311 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6311 21 polla polla NNP 40436 6311 22 / / SYM 40436 6311 23 kis kis NNP 40436 6311 24 gegonui gegonui NNP 40436 6311 25 = = SYM 40436 6311 26 a a DT 40436 6311 27 , , , 40436 6311 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6311 29 e(ôrakui e(ôrakui NNP 40436 6311 30 = = SYM 40436 6311 31 a a DT 40436 6311 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6311 33 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 6311 34 e)ntha e)ntha NNP 40436 6311 35 / / SYM 40436 6311 36 de de NNP 40436 6311 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6311 38 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 6311 39 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6311 40 Ai)/dou Ai)/dou NNP 40436 6311 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6311 42 pa pa NNP 40436 6311 43 / / SYM 40436 6311 44 nta nta NNP 40436 6311 45 chrê chrê NNP 40436 6311 46 / / SYM 40436 6311 47 mata mata NNP 40436 6311 48 , , , 40436 6311 49 ou)k ou)k ADD 40436 6311 50 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 6311 51 o(/ o(/ JJ 40436 6311 52 ti ti NNP 40436 6311 53 ou ou NN 40436 6311 54 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6311 55 mema mema NN 40436 6311 56 / / SYM 40436 6311 57 thêken thêken JJ 40436 6311 58 ; ; : 40436 6311 59 ô(/ste ô(/ste LS 40436 6311 60 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 6311 61 thaumasto\n thaumasto\n ADD 40436 6311 62 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6311 63 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6311 64 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 6311 65 = = SYM 40436 6311 66 s s NNP 40436 6311 67 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6311 68 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6311 69 a)/llôn a)/llôn UH 40436 6311 70 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 6311 71 / / SYM 40436 6311 72 n n NNP 40436 6311 73 te te NNP 40436 6311 74 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 6311 75 au)tê\n au)tê\n NNP 40436 6311 76 a)namnêsthê a)namnêsthê NNPS 40436 6311 77 = = SYM 40436 6311 78 nai nai NNP 40436 6311 79 a(/ a(/ NNP 40436 6311 80 ge ge NNP 40436 6311 81 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6311 82 pro pro JJ 40436 6311 83 / / SYM 40436 6311 84 teron teron NNP 40436 6311 85 ê)pi ê)pi NNP 40436 6311 86 / / SYM 40436 6311 87 stato stato NNP 40436 6311 88 . . . 40436 6312 1 A(=te A(=te NNP 40436 6312 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6312 3 tê tê NN 40436 6312 4 = = SYM 40436 6312 5 s s NNP 40436 6312 6 phu phu NNP 40436 6312 7 / / SYM 40436 6312 8 seôs seôs NNP 40436 6312 9 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 6312 10 / / SYM 40436 6312 11 sês sês NNP 40436 6312 12 suggenou suggenou NNP 40436 6312 13 = = SYM 40436 6312 14 s s POS 40436 6312 15 ou)/sês ou)/sês NNP 40436 6312 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6312 17 memathêkui memathêkui NNP 40436 6312 18 / / SYM 40436 6312 19 as as IN 40436 6312 20 tê tê NNP 40436 6312 21 = = SYM 40436 6312 22 s s NNP 40436 6312 23 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 6312 24 = = SYM 40436 6312 25 s s NNP 40436 6312 26 a(/panta a(/panta NNP 40436 6312 27 , , , 40436 6312 28 ou)de\n ou)de\n NNP 40436 6312 29 kôlu kôlu NNP 40436 6312 30 / / SYM 40436 6312 31 ei ei NNP 40436 6312 32 e(\n e(\n NNP 40436 6312 33 mo mo NN 40436 6312 34 / / SYM 40436 6312 35 non non AFX 40436 6312 36 a)namnêsthe a)namnêsthe NNP 40436 6312 37 / / SYM 40436 6312 38 nta nta NNP 40436 6312 39 , , , 40436 6312 40 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 6312 41 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 6312 42 ma ma NNP 40436 6312 43 / / SYM 40436 6312 44 thêsin thêsin NNP 40436 6312 45 kalou kalou NNP 40436 6312 46 = = SYM 40436 6312 47 sin sin NN 40436 6312 48 a)/nthrôpoi a)/nthrôpoi VBZ 40436 6312 49 , , , 40436 6312 50 ta)/lla ta)/lla NNP 40436 6312 51 pa pa NNP 40436 6312 52 / / SYM 40436 6312 53 nta nta NNP 40436 6312 54 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 6312 55 a)neurei a)neurei CD 40436 6312 56 = = SYM 40436 6312 57 n n LS 40436 6312 58 , , , 40436 6312 59 e)a e)a NNP 40436 6312 60 / / SYM 40436 6312 61 n n CD 40436 6312 62 tis tis CD 40436 6312 63 a)ndrei a)ndrei , 40436 6312 64 = = SYM 40436 6312 65 os os NNP 40436 6312 66 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 6312 67 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6312 68 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 6312 69 a)poka a)poka , 40436 6312 70 / / SYM 40436 6312 71 mnê| mnê| NNP 40436 6312 72 zêtô zêtô NNP 40436 6312 73 = = SYM 40436 6312 74 n n XX 40436 6312 75 . . . 40436 6313 1 To\ To\ NNP 40436 6313 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6313 3 zêtei zêtei NNP 40436 6313 4 = = SYM 40436 6313 5 n n CC 40436 6313 6 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 6313 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6313 8 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6313 9 mantha mantha NNP 40436 6313 10 / / SYM 40436 6313 11 nein nein NNP 40436 6313 12 a)na a)na NNP 40436 6313 13 / / SYM 40436 6313 14 mnêsis mnêsis NN 40436 6313 15 o(/lon o(/lon NNP 40436 6313 16 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 6313 17 / / SYM 40436 6313 18 n n NNP 40436 6313 19 . . . 40436 6313 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6313 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6314 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6314 2 Side side NN 40436 6314 3 - - HYPH 40436 6314 4 note note NN 40436 6314 5 : : : 40436 6314 6 Illustration illustration NN 40436 6314 7 of of IN 40436 6314 8 this this DT 40436 6314 9 theory theory NN 40436 6314 10 -- -- : 40436 6314 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6314 12 may may MD 40436 6314 13 be be VB 40436 6314 14 revived revive VBN 40436 6314 15 by by IN 40436 6314 16 skilful skilful JJ 40436 6314 17 questions question NNS 40436 6314 18 in in IN 40436 6314 19 the the DT 40436 6314 20 mind mind NN 40436 6314 21 of of IN 40436 6314 22 a a DT 40436 6314 23 man man NN 40436 6314 24 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 6314 25 untaught untaught JJ 40436 6314 26 . . . 40436 6315 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6315 2 questions question NNS 40436 6315 3 the the DT 40436 6315 4 slave slave NN 40436 6315 5 of of IN 40436 6315 6 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6315 7 . . . 40436 6315 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6316 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6316 2 proceeds proceed NNS 40436 6316 3 to to TO 40436 6316 4 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 6316 5 the the DT 40436 6316 6 position position NN 40436 6316 7 , , , 40436 6316 8 just just RB 40436 6316 9 laid lay VBN 40436 6316 10 down down RP 40436 6316 11 , , , 40436 6316 12 by by IN 40436 6316 13 cross cross NN 40436 6316 14 - - JJ 40436 6316 15 examining examine VBG 40436 6316 16 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6316 17 's 's POS 40436 6316 18 youthful youthful JJ 40436 6316 19 slave slave NN 40436 6316 20 , , , 40436 6316 21 who who WP 40436 6316 22 , , , 40436 6316 23 though though IN 40436 6316 24 wholly wholly RB 40436 6316 25 untaught untaught JJ 40436 6316 26 and and CC 40436 6316 27 having have VBG 40436 6316 28 never never RB 40436 6316 29 heard hear VBN 40436 6316 30 any any DT 40436 6316 31 mention mention NN 40436 6316 32 of of IN 40436 6316 33 geometry geometry NN 40436 6316 34 , , , 40436 6316 35 is be VBZ 40436 6316 36 brought bring VBN 40436 6316 37 by by IN 40436 6316 38 a a DT 40436 6316 39 proper proper JJ 40436 6316 40 series series NN 40436 6316 41 of of IN 40436 6316 42 questions question NNS 40436 6316 43 to to TO 40436 6316 44 give give VB 40436 6316 45 answers answer NNS 40436 6316 46 out out IN 40436 6316 47 of of IN 40436 6316 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6316 49 own own JJ 40436 6316 50 mind mind NN 40436 6316 51 , , , 40436 6316 52 furnishing furnish VBG 40436 6316 53 the the DT 40436 6316 54 solution solution NN 40436 6316 55 of of IN 40436 6316 56 a a DT 40436 6316 57 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 6316 58 problem problem NN 40436 6316 59 . . . 40436 6317 1 The the DT 40436 6317 2 first first JJ 40436 6317 3 part part NN 40436 6317 4 of of IN 40436 6317 5 the the DT 40436 6317 6 examination examination NN 40436 6317 7 brings bring VBZ 40436 6317 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6317 9 to to IN 40436 6317 10 a a DT 40436 6317 11 perception perception NN 40436 6317 12 of of IN 40436 6317 13 the the DT 40436 6317 14 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 6317 15 , , , 40436 6317 16 and and CC 40436 6317 17 makes make VBZ 40436 6317 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6317 19 feel feel VB 40436 6317 20 a a DT 40436 6317 21 painful painful JJ 40436 6317 22 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 6317 23 , , , 40436 6317 24 from from IN 40436 6317 25 which which WDT 40436 6317 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6317 27 desires desire VBZ 40436 6317 28 to to TO 40436 6317 29 obtain obtain VB 40436 6317 30 relief:[17 relief:[17 NNP 40436 6317 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6317 32 the the DT 40436 6317 33 second second JJ 40436 6317 34 part part NN 40436 6317 35 guides guide VBZ 40436 6317 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6317 37 mind mind NN 40436 6317 38 in in IN 40436 6317 39 the the DT 40436 6317 40 efforts effort NNS 40436 6317 41 necessary necessary JJ 40436 6317 42 for for IN 40436 6317 43 fishing fish VBG 40436 6317 44 up up RP 40436 6317 45 a a DT 40436 6317 46 solution solution NN 40436 6317 47 out out IN 40436 6317 48 of of IN 40436 6317 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6317 50 own own JJ 40436 6317 51 pre pre JJ 40436 6317 52 - - JJ 40436 6317 53 existing existing JJ 40436 6317 54 , , , 40436 6317 55 but but CC 40436 6317 56 forgotten forgotten NNP 40436 6317 57 , , , 40436 6317 58 stores store NNS 40436 6317 59 . . . 40436 6318 1 True true JJ 40436 6318 2 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6318 3 , , , 40436 6318 4 which which WDT 40436 6318 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6318 6 had have VBD 40436 6318 7 long long RB 40436 6318 8 had have VBN 40436 6318 9 within within IN 40436 6318 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6318 11 without without IN 40436 6318 12 knowing know VBG 40436 6318 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6318 14 , , , 40436 6318 15 are be VBP 40436 6318 16 awakened awaken VBN 40436 6318 17 by by IN 40436 6318 18 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 6318 19 , , , 40436 6318 20 and and CC 40436 6318 21 become become VBP 40436 6318 22 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 6318 23 . . . 40436 6319 1 From from IN 40436 6319 2 the the DT 40436 6319 3 fact fact NN 40436 6319 4 that that IN 40436 6319 5 the the DT 40436 6319 6 mind mind NN 40436 6319 7 thus thus RB 40436 6319 8 possesses possess VBZ 40436 6319 9 the the DT 40436 6319 10 truth truth NN 40436 6319 11 of of IN 40436 6319 12 things thing NNS 40436 6319 13 which which WDT 40436 6319 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6319 15 has have VBZ 40436 6319 16 not not RB 40436 6319 17 acquired acquire VBN 40436 6319 18 in in IN 40436 6319 19 this this DT 40436 6319 20 life life NN 40436 6319 21 , , , 40436 6319 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6319 23 infers infer VBZ 40436 6319 24 that that IN 40436 6319 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6319 26 must must MD 40436 6319 27 have have VB 40436 6319 28 gone go VBN 40436 6319 29 through through IN 40436 6319 30 a a DT 40436 6319 31 pre pre NN 40436 6319 32 - - NN 40436 6319 33 existence existence NN 40436 6319 34 of of IN 40436 6319 35 indefinite indefinite JJ 40436 6319 36 duration duration NN 40436 6319 37 , , , 40436 6319 38 or or CC 40436 6319 39 must must MD 40436 6319 40 be be VB 40436 6319 41 immortal immortal JJ 40436 6319 42 . . . 40436 6320 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6320 2 18 18 CD 40436 6320 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6320 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6320 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6320 6 17 17 CD 40436 6320 7 : : : 40436 6320 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6320 9 , , , 40436 6320 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6320 11 , , , 40436 6320 12 p. p. NN 40436 6320 13 84 84 CD 40436 6320 14 C. C. NNP 40436 6320 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6320 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6320 17 : : : 40436 6320 18 Oi)/ei Oi)/ei NNP 40436 6320 19 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 6320 20 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 6320 21 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 6320 22 pro pro NNP 40436 6320 23 / / SYM 40436 6320 24 teron teron NNP 40436 6320 25 e)picheirê e)picheirê , 40436 6320 26 = = NFP 40436 6320 27 sai sai NNP 40436 6320 28 zêtei zêtei NNP 40436 6320 29 = = SYM 40436 6320 30 n n CC 40436 6320 31 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 6320 32 mantha mantha NNP 40436 6320 33 / / SYM 40436 6320 34 nein nein NNP 40436 6320 35 tou tou NNP 40436 6320 36 = = NNPS 40436 6320 37 to to IN 40436 6320 38 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 6320 39 ô)=|eto ô)=|eto NNP 40436 6320 40 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 6320 41 / / SYM 40436 6320 42 nai nai NNP 40436 6320 43 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 6320 44 ei)dô ei)dô NNP 40436 6320 45 / / SYM 40436 6320 46 s s NNPS 40436 6320 47 , , , 40436 6320 48 pri\n pri\n NNPS 40436 6320 49 ei)s ei)s , 40436 6320 50 a)pori a)pori CD 40436 6320 51 / / SYM 40436 6320 52 an an DT 40436 6320 53 kate kate NNP 40436 6320 54 / / SYM 40436 6320 55 pesen pesen VBN 40436 6320 56 ê(gêsa ê(gêsa NNP 40436 6320 57 / / SYM 40436 6320 58 menos menos NNP 40436 6320 59 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 6320 60 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 6320 61 / / SYM 40436 6320 62 nai nai NNP 40436 6320 63 , , , 40436 6320 64 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6320 65 e)po e)po NNP 40436 6320 66 / / SYM 40436 6320 67 thêse thêse NNP 40436 6320 68 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6320 69 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 6320 70 / / SYM 40436 6320 71 nai nai NNP 40436 6320 72 ? ? . 40436 6321 1 Ou)/ Ou)/ NNP 40436 6321 2 moi moi FW 40436 6321 3 dokei=. dokei=. FW 40436 6322 1 Ô)/nêto Ô)/nêto NNP 40436 6322 2 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 6322 3 narkê narkê NNP 40436 6322 4 / / SYM 40436 6322 5 sas sas NNP 40436 6322 6 ? ? . 40436 6322 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6322 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6323 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6323 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6323 3 18 18 CD 40436 6323 4 : : : 40436 6323 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6323 6 , , , 40436 6323 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6323 8 , , , 40436 6323 9 p. p. NN 40436 6323 10 86 86 CD 40436 6323 11 . . . 40436 6324 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6324 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6324 3 : : : 40436 6324 4 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 6324 5 = = SYM 40436 6324 6 n n CC 40436 6324 7 ei ei NNP 40436 6324 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6324 9 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 6324 10 ê ê NNP 40436 6324 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6324 12 a)lê a)lê NN 40436 6324 13 / / SYM 40436 6324 14 theia theia NN 40436 6324 15 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 6324 16 = = SYM 40436 6324 17 n n NN 40436 6324 18 tô tô NNP 40436 6324 19 = = SYM 40436 6324 20 n n NN 40436 6324 21 o)/ntôn o)/ntôn NNP 40436 6324 22 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 6324 23 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6324 24 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 6324 25 psuchê=| psuchê=| NNP 40436 6324 26 , , , 40436 6324 27 a)tha a)tha NNP 40436 6324 28 / / SYM 40436 6324 29 natos natos NNP 40436 6324 30 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 6324 31 ê ê NNP 40436 6324 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6324 33 psuchê\ psuchê\ NN 40436 6324 34 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 6324 35 ? ? . 40436 6324 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6324 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6325 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6325 2 Side side NN 40436 6325 3 - - HYPH 40436 6325 4 note note NN 40436 6325 5 : : : 40436 6325 6 Enquiry enquiry NN 40436 6325 7 taken take VBN 40436 6325 8 up up RP 40436 6325 9 -- -- : 40436 6325 10 Whether whether IN 40436 6325 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 6325 12 is be VBZ 40436 6325 13 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6325 14 ? ? . 40436 6326 1 without without IN 40436 6326 2 determining determine VBG 40436 6326 3 what what WDT 40436 6326 4 virtue virtue NN 40436 6326 5 is be VBZ 40436 6326 6 . . . 40436 6326 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6327 1 The the DT 40436 6327 2 former former JJ 40436 6327 3 topic topic NN 40436 6327 4 of of IN 40436 6327 5 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 6327 6 is be VBZ 40436 6327 7 now now RB 40436 6327 8 resumed resume VBN 40436 6327 9 : : : 40436 6327 10 but but CC 40436 6327 11 at at IN 40436 6327 12 the the DT 40436 6327 13 instance instance NN 40436 6327 14 of of IN 40436 6327 15 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6327 16 , , , 40436 6327 17 the the DT 40436 6327 18 question question NN 40436 6327 19 taken take VBN 40436 6327 20 up up RP 40436 6327 21 , , , 40436 6327 22 is be VBZ 40436 6327 23 not--"What not--"what NN 40436 6327 24 is be VBZ 40436 6327 25 virtue virtue JJ 40436 6327 26 ? ? . 40436 6327 27 " " '' 40436 6328 1 but--"Is but--"Is NNP 40436 6328 2 virtue virtue NN 40436 6328 3 teachable teachable NNP 40436 6328 4 or or CC 40436 6328 5 not not RB 40436 6328 6 ? ? . 40436 6328 7 " " '' 40436 6329 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6329 2 , , , 40436 6329 3 after after IN 40436 6329 4 renewing renew VBG 40436 6329 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6329 6 objection objection NN 40436 6329 7 against against IN 40436 6329 8 the the DT 40436 6329 9 inversion inversion NN 40436 6329 10 of of IN 40436 6329 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 6329 12 order order NN 40436 6329 13 by by IN 40436 6329 14 discussing discuss VBG 40436 6329 15 the the DT 40436 6329 16 second second JJ 40436 6329 17 question question NN 40436 6329 18 without without IN 40436 6329 19 having have VBG 40436 6329 20 determined determine VBN 40436 6329 21 the the DT 40436 6329 22 first first JJ 40436 6329 23 , , , 40436 6329 24 enters enter VBZ 40436 6329 25 upon upon IN 40436 6329 26 the the DT 40436 6329 27 discussion discussion NN 40436 6329 28 hypothetically hypothetically RB 40436 6329 29 , , , 40436 6329 30 assuming assume VBG 40436 6329 31 as as IN 40436 6329 32 a a DT 40436 6329 33 postulate postulate NN 40436 6329 34 , , , 40436 6329 35 that that IN 40436 6329 36 nothing nothing NN 40436 6329 37 can can MD 40436 6329 38 be be VB 40436 6329 39 taught teach VBN 40436 6329 40 except except IN 40436 6329 41 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6329 42 . . . 40436 6330 1 The the DT 40436 6330 2 question question NN 40436 6330 3 then then RB 40436 6330 4 stands stand VBZ 40436 6330 5 thus--"Is thus--"Is NNP 40436 6330 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 6330 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6330 8 ? ? . 40436 6330 9 " " '' 40436 6331 1 If if IN 40436 6331 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6331 3 be be VBP 40436 6331 4 , , , 40436 6331 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6331 6 can can MD 40436 6331 7 be be VB 40436 6331 8 taught teach VBN 40436 6331 9 : : : 40436 6331 10 if if IN 40436 6331 11 not not RB 40436 6331 12 , , , 40436 6331 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6331 14 can can MD 40436 6331 15 not not RB 40436 6331 16 be be VB 40436 6331 17 taught teach VBN 40436 6331 18 . . . 40436 6332 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6332 2 19 19 CD 40436 6332 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6332 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6332 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6332 6 19 19 CD 40436 6332 7 : : : 40436 6332 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6332 9 , , , 40436 6332 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6332 11 , , , 40436 6332 12 p. p. NN 40436 6333 1 87 87 CD 40436 6333 2 . . . 40436 6333 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6334 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6334 2 Side side NN 40436 6334 3 - - HYPH 40436 6334 4 note note NN 40436 6334 5 : : : 40436 6334 6 Virtue virtue NN 40436 6334 7 is be VBZ 40436 6334 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6334 9 -- -- : 40436 6334 10 no no DT 40436 6334 11 possessions possession NNS 40436 6334 12 , , , 40436 6334 13 no no DT 40436 6334 14 attributes attribute NNS 40436 6334 15 , , , 40436 6334 16 either either DT 40436 6334 17 of of IN 40436 6334 18 mind mind NN 40436 6334 19 or or CC 40436 6334 20 body body NN 40436 6334 21 , , , 40436 6334 22 are be VBP 40436 6334 23 good good JJ 40436 6334 24 or or CC 40436 6334 25 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6334 26 , , , 40436 6334 27 except except IN 40436 6334 28 under under IN 40436 6334 29 the the DT 40436 6334 30 guidance guidance NN 40436 6334 31 of of IN 40436 6334 32 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6334 33 . . . 40436 6334 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6335 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6335 2 proceeds proceed NNS 40436 6335 3 to to TO 40436 6335 4 prove prove VB 40436 6335 5 that that DT 40436 6335 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 6335 7 is be VBZ 40436 6335 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6335 9 , , , 40436 6335 10 or or CC 40436 6335 11 a a DT 40436 6335 12 mode mode NN 40436 6335 13 of of IN 40436 6335 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6335 15 . . . 40436 6336 1 Virtue virtue NN 40436 6336 2 is be VBZ 40436 6336 3 good good JJ 40436 6336 4 : : : 40436 6336 5 all all DT 40436 6336 6 good good JJ 40436 6336 7 things thing NNS 40436 6336 8 are be VBP 40436 6336 9 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6336 10 . . . 40436 6337 1 But but CC 40436 6337 2 none none NN 40436 6337 3 of of IN 40436 6337 4 the the DT 40436 6337 5 things thing NNS 40436 6337 6 accounted account VBD 40436 6337 7 good good JJ 40436 6337 8 are be VBP 40436 6337 9 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6337 10 , , , 40436 6337 11 unless unless IN 40436 6337 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6337 13 be be VBP 40436 6337 14 rightly rightly RB 40436 6337 15 employed employ VBN 40436 6337 16 ; ; : 40436 6337 17 that that RB 40436 6337 18 is is RB 40436 6337 19 , , , 40436 6337 20 employed employ VBN 40436 6337 21 with with IN 40436 6337 22 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6337 23 or or CC 40436 6337 24 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 6337 25 . . . 40436 6338 1 This this DT 40436 6338 2 is be VBZ 40436 6338 3 true true JJ 40436 6338 4 not not RB 40436 6338 5 only only RB 40436 6338 6 of of IN 40436 6338 7 health health NN 40436 6338 8 , , , 40436 6338 9 wealth wealth NN 40436 6338 10 , , , 40436 6338 11 beauty beauty NN 40436 6338 12 , , , 40436 6338 13 strength strength NN 40436 6338 14 , , , 40436 6338 15 power power NN 40436 6338 16 , , , 40436 6338 17 & & CC 40436 6338 18 c. c. NNP 40436 6338 19 , , , 40436 6338 20 but but CC 40436 6338 21 also also RB 40436 6338 22 of of IN 40436 6338 23 the the DT 40436 6338 24 mental mental JJ 40436 6338 25 attributes attribute NNS 40436 6338 26 justice justice NN 40436 6338 27 , , , 40436 6338 28 moderation moderation NN 40436 6338 29 , , , 40436 6338 30 courage courage NN 40436 6338 31 , , , 40436 6338 32 quick quick JJ 40436 6338 33 apprehension apprehension NN 40436 6338 34 , , , 40436 6338 35 & & CC 40436 6338 36 c. c. NNP 40436 6338 37 All all DT 40436 6338 38 of of IN 40436 6338 39 these these DT 40436 6338 40 are be VBP 40436 6338 41 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6338 42 , , , 40436 6338 43 and and CC 40436 6338 44 therefore therefore RB 40436 6338 45 good good JJ 40436 6338 46 , , , 40436 6338 47 if if IN 40436 6338 48 brought bring VBN 40436 6338 49 into into IN 40436 6338 50 action action NN 40436 6338 51 under under IN 40436 6338 52 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6338 53 or or CC 40436 6338 54 right right JJ 40436 6338 55 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 6338 56 ; ; : 40436 6338 57 none none NN 40436 6338 58 of of IN 40436 6338 59 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6338 60 are be VBP 40436 6338 61 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6338 62 or or CC 40436 6338 63 good good JJ 40436 6338 64 , , , 40436 6338 65 without without IN 40436 6338 66 this this DT 40436 6338 67 condition condition NN 40436 6338 68 -- -- : 40436 6338 69 which which WDT 40436 6338 70 is be VBZ 40436 6338 71 therefore therefore RB 40436 6338 72 the the DT 40436 6338 73 distinctive distinctive JJ 40436 6338 74 constituent constituent NN 40436 6338 75 of of IN 40436 6338 76 virtue virtue NN 40436 6338 77 . . . 40436 6339 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6339 2 20 20 CD 40436 6339 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6339 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6339 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6339 6 20 20 CD 40436 6339 7 : : : 40436 6339 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6339 9 , , , 40436 6339 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6339 11 , , , 40436 6339 12 p. p. NN 40436 6340 1 89 89 CD 40436 6340 2 . . . 40436 6340 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6341 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 6341 2 , , , 40436 6341 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 6341 4 , , , 40436 6341 5 being be VBG 40436 6341 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6341 7 or or CC 40436 6341 8 a a DT 40436 6341 9 mode mode NN 40436 6341 10 of of IN 40436 6341 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6341 12 , , , 40436 6341 13 can can MD 40436 6341 14 not not RB 40436 6341 15 come come VB 40436 6341 16 by by IN 40436 6341 17 nature nature NN 40436 6341 18 , , , 40436 6341 19 but but CC 40436 6341 20 must must MD 40436 6341 21 be be VB 40436 6341 22 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6341 23 . . . 40436 6342 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6342 2 Side side NN 40436 6342 3 - - HYPH 40436 6342 4 note note NN 40436 6342 5 : : : 40436 6342 6 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 6342 7 , , , 40436 6342 8 as as IN 40436 6342 9 being be VBG 40436 6342 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6342 11 , , , 40436 6342 12 must must MD 40436 6342 13 be be VB 40436 6342 14 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6342 15 . . . 40436 6343 1 Yet yet CC 40436 6343 2 there there EX 40436 6343 3 are be VBP 40436 6343 4 opposing oppose VBG 40436 6343 5 reasons reason NNS 40436 6343 6 , , , 40436 6343 7 showing show VBG 40436 6343 8 that that IN 40436 6343 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6343 10 can can MD 40436 6343 11 not not RB 40436 6343 12 be be VB 40436 6343 13 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6343 14 . . . 40436 6344 1 No no DT 40436 6344 2 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6344 3 of of IN 40436 6344 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6344 5 can can MD 40436 6344 6 be be VB 40436 6344 7 found find VBN 40436 6344 8 . . . 40436 6344 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6345 1 Yet yet RB 40436 6345 2 again again RB 40436 6345 3 there there EX 40436 6345 4 are be VBP 40436 6345 5 other other JJ 40436 6345 6 contrary contrary JJ 40436 6345 7 reasons reason NNS 40436 6345 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6345 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6345 10 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 6345 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6345 12 which which WDT 40436 6345 13 prove prove VBP 40436 6345 14 that that IN 40436 6345 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6345 16 can can MD 40436 6345 17 not not RB 40436 6345 18 be be VB 40436 6345 19 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6345 20 . . . 40436 6346 1 For for IN 40436 6346 2 if if IN 40436 6346 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6346 4 were be VBD 40436 6346 5 so so RB 40436 6346 6 , , , 40436 6346 7 there there EX 40436 6346 8 would would MD 40436 6346 9 be be VB 40436 6346 10 distinct distinct JJ 40436 6346 11 and and CC 40436 6346 12 assignable assignable JJ 40436 6346 13 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6346 14 and and CC 40436 6346 15 learners learner NNS 40436 6346 16 of of IN 40436 6346 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6346 18 , , , 40436 6346 19 and and CC 40436 6346 20 the the DT 40436 6346 21 times time NNS 40436 6346 22 and and CC 40436 6346 23 places place NNS 40436 6346 24 could could MD 40436 6346 25 be be VB 40436 6346 26 pointed point VBN 40436 6346 27 out out RP 40436 6346 28 where where WRB 40436 6346 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6346 30 is be VBZ 40436 6346 31 taught teach VBN 40436 6346 32 and and CC 40436 6346 33 learnt learn VBN 40436 6346 34 . . . 40436 6347 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6347 2 see see VBP 40436 6347 3 that that IN 40436 6347 4 this this DT 40436 6347 5 is be VBZ 40436 6347 6 the the DT 40436 6347 7 case case NN 40436 6347 8 with with IN 40436 6347 9 all all DT 40436 6347 10 arts art NNS 40436 6347 11 and and CC 40436 6347 12 professions profession NNS 40436 6347 13 . . . 40436 6348 1 But but CC 40436 6348 2 in in IN 40436 6348 3 regard regard NN 40436 6348 4 to to IN 40436 6348 5 virtue virtue NN 40436 6348 6 , , , 40436 6348 7 there there EX 40436 6348 8 are be VBP 40436 6348 9 neither neither RB 40436 6348 10 recognised recognise VBN 40436 6348 11 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6348 12 , , , 40436 6348 13 nor nor CC 40436 6348 14 learners learner NNS 40436 6348 15 , , , 40436 6348 16 nor nor CC 40436 6348 17 years year NNS 40436 6348 18 of of IN 40436 6348 19 learning learning NN 40436 6348 20 . . . 40436 6349 1 The the DT 40436 6349 2 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6349 3 pretend pretend VBP 40436 6349 4 to to TO 40436 6349 5 be be VB 40436 6349 6 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6349 7 of of IN 40436 6349 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6349 9 , , , 40436 6349 10 but but CC 40436 6349 11 are be VBP 40436 6349 12 not:[21 not:[21 NN 40436 6349 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6349 14 the the DT 40436 6349 15 leading lead VBG 40436 6349 16 and and CC 40436 6349 17 esteemed esteemed JJ 40436 6349 18 citizens citizen NNS 40436 6349 19 of of IN 40436 6349 20 the the DT 40436 6349 21 community community NN 40436 6349 22 do do VBP 40436 6349 23 not not RB 40436 6349 24 pretend pretend VB 40436 6349 25 to to TO 40436 6349 26 be be VB 40436 6349 27 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6349 28 of of IN 40436 6349 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6349 30 , , , 40436 6349 31 and and CC 40436 6349 32 are be VBP 40436 6349 33 indeed indeed RB 40436 6349 34 incompetent incompetent JJ 40436 6349 35 to to TO 40436 6349 36 teach teach VB 40436 6349 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6349 38 even even RB 40436 6349 39 to to IN 40436 6349 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6349 41 own own JJ 40436 6349 42 sons son NNS 40436 6349 43 -- -- : 40436 6349 44 as as IN 40436 6349 45 the the DT 40436 6349 46 character character NN 40436 6349 47 of of IN 40436 6349 48 those those DT 40436 6349 49 sons son NNS 40436 6349 50 sufficiently sufficiently RB 40436 6349 51 proves prove VBZ 40436 6349 52 . . . 40436 6350 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6350 2 22 22 CD 40436 6350 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6350 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6350 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6350 6 21 21 CD 40436 6350 7 : : : 40436 6350 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6350 9 , , , 40436 6350 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6350 11 , , , 40436 6350 12 p. p. NN 40436 6351 1 92 92 CD 40436 6351 2 . . . 40436 6351 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6352 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6352 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6352 3 22 22 CD 40436 6352 4 : : : 40436 6352 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6352 6 , , , 40436 6352 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6352 8 , , , 40436 6352 9 p. p. NN 40436 6352 10 97 97 CD 40436 6352 11 . . . 40436 6353 1 Isokrates Isokrates NNP 40436 6353 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6353 3 adv adv NNP 40436 6353 4 . . . 40436 6354 1 Sophistas Sophistas NNP 40436 6354 2 , , , 40436 6354 3 s. s. NNP 40436 6354 4 25 25 CD 40436 6354 5 , , , 40436 6354 6 p. p. NN 40436 6354 7 401 401 CD 40436 6354 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6354 9 expressly expressly RB 40436 6354 10 declares declare VBZ 40436 6354 11 that that IN 40436 6354 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6354 13 does do VBZ 40436 6354 14 not not RB 40436 6354 15 believe believe VB 40436 6354 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6354 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6354 18 : : : 40436 6354 19 ô(/s ô(/s NNP 40436 6354 20 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 6354 21 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 6354 22 / / SYM 40436 6354 23 nê nê NNP 40436 6354 24 didakto didakto NNP 40436 6354 25 / / SYM 40436 6354 26 n n IN 40436 6354 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6354 28 . . . 40436 6355 1 There there EX 40436 6355 2 is be VBZ 40436 6355 3 no no DT 40436 6355 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6355 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6355 6 : : : 40436 6355 7 te te NNP 40436 6355 8 / / SYM 40436 6355 9 chnê chnê NNP 40436 6355 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6355 11 which which WDT 40436 6355 12 can can MD 40436 6355 13 teach teach VB 40436 6355 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6355 15 , , , 40436 6355 16 if if IN 40436 6355 17 a a DT 40436 6355 18 man man NN 40436 6355 19 be be VB 40436 6355 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6355 21 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6355 22 : : : 40436 6355 23 kakô kakô NNP 40436 6355 24 = = SYM 40436 6355 25 s s NNP 40436 6355 26 pephukô pephukô NNP 40436 6355 27 / / SYM 40436 6355 28 s s NNP 40436 6355 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6355 30 . . . 40436 6356 1 But but CC 40436 6356 2 if if IN 40436 6356 3 a a DT 40436 6356 4 man man NN 40436 6356 5 be be VB 40436 6356 6 well well RB 40436 6356 7 - - HYPH 40436 6356 8 disposed dispose VBN 40436 6356 9 , , , 40436 6356 10 then then RB 40436 6356 11 education education NN 40436 6356 12 in in IN 40436 6356 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6356 14 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6356 15 : : : 40436 6356 16 lo lo NNP 40436 6356 17 / / SYM 40436 6356 18 goi goi NNP 40436 6356 19 politikoi/ politikoi/ NNP 40436 6356 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6356 21 will will MD 40436 6356 22 serve serve VB 40436 6356 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6356 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6356 25 : : : 40436 6356 26 sumparakeleu sumparakeleu NN 40436 6356 27 / / SYM 40436 6356 28 sasthai/ sasthai/ NNP 40436 6356 29 ge ge NNP 40436 6356 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6356 31 sunaskê sunaskê NNP 40436 6356 32 = = SYM 40436 6356 33 sai sai NNP 40436 6356 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6356 35 . . . 40436 6357 1 For for IN 40436 6357 2 a a DT 40436 6357 3 man man NN 40436 6357 4 to to TO 40436 6357 5 announce announce VB 40436 6357 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6357 7 as as IN 40436 6357 8 a a DT 40436 6357 9 teacher teacher NN 40436 6357 10 of of IN 40436 6357 11 justice justice NN 40436 6357 12 or or CC 40436 6357 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 6357 14 , , , 40436 6357 15 was be VBD 40436 6357 16 an an DT 40436 6357 17 unpopular unpopular JJ 40436 6357 18 and and CC 40436 6357 19 invidious invidious JJ 40436 6357 20 pretension pretension NN 40436 6357 21 . . . 40436 6358 1 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 6358 2 is be VBZ 40436 6358 3 anxious anxious JJ 40436 6358 4 to to TO 40436 6358 5 guard guard VB 40436 6358 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6358 7 against against IN 40436 6358 8 such such JJ 40436 6358 9 unpopularity unpopularity NN 40436 6358 10 . . . 40436 6358 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6359 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6359 2 Side side NN 40436 6359 3 - - HYPH 40436 6359 4 note note NN 40436 6359 5 : : : 40436 6359 6 Conversation conversation NN 40436 6359 7 of of IN 40436 6359 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6359 9 with with IN 40436 6359 10 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6359 11 , , , 40436 6359 12 who who WP 40436 6359 13 detests detest VBZ 40436 6359 14 the the DT 40436 6359 15 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6359 16 , , , 40436 6359 17 and and CC 40436 6359 18 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 6359 19 that that IN 40436 6359 20 any any DT 40436 6359 21 one one CD 40436 6359 22 of of IN 40436 6359 23 the the DT 40436 6359 24 leading lead VBG 40436 6359 25 politicians politician NNS 40436 6359 26 can can MD 40436 6359 27 teach teach VB 40436 6359 28 virtue virtue NN 40436 6359 29 . . . 40436 6359 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6360 1 Here here RB 40436 6360 2 , , , 40436 6360 3 a a DT 40436 6360 4 new new JJ 40436 6360 5 speaker speaker NN 40436 6360 6 is be VBZ 40436 6360 7 introduced introduce VBN 40436 6360 8 into into IN 40436 6360 9 the the DT 40436 6360 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6360 11 -- -- : 40436 6360 12 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6360 13 , , , 40436 6360 14 one one CD 40436 6360 15 of of IN 40436 6360 16 the the DT 40436 6360 17 accusers accuser NNS 40436 6360 18 of of IN 40436 6360 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6360 20 before before IN 40436 6360 21 the the DT 40436 6360 22 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 6360 23 . . . 40436 6361 1 The the DT 40436 6361 2 conversation conversation NN 40436 6361 3 is be VBZ 40436 6361 4 carried carry VBN 40436 6361 5 on on RP 40436 6361 6 for for IN 40436 6361 7 some some DT 40436 6361 8 time time NN 40436 6361 9 between between IN 40436 6361 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6361 11 and and CC 40436 6361 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6361 13 . . . 40436 6362 1 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6362 2 denies deny VBZ 40436 6362 3 altogether altogether RB 40436 6362 4 that that IN 40436 6362 5 the the DT 40436 6362 6 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6362 7 are be VBP 40436 6362 8 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6362 9 of of IN 40436 6362 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 6362 11 , , , 40436 6362 12 and and CC 40436 6362 13 even even RB 40436 6362 14 denounces denounce VBZ 40436 6362 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6362 16 with with IN 40436 6362 17 bitter bitter JJ 40436 6362 18 contempt contempt NN 40436 6362 19 and and CC 40436 6362 20 wrath wrath NN 40436 6362 21 . . . 40436 6363 1 But but CC 40436 6363 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6363 3 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 6363 4 that that IN 40436 6363 5 the the DT 40436 6363 6 leading lead VBG 40436 6363 7 and and CC 40436 6363 8 esteemed esteemed JJ 40436 6363 9 citizens citizen NNS 40436 6363 10 of of IN 40436 6363 11 the the DT 40436 6363 12 state state NN 40436 6363 13 do do VBP 40436 6363 14 really really RB 40436 6363 15 teach teach VB 40436 6363 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6363 17 . . . 40436 6364 1 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6364 2 however however RB 40436 6364 3 presently presently RB 40436 6364 4 breaks break VBZ 40436 6364 5 off off RP 40436 6364 6 in in IN 40436 6364 7 a a DT 40436 6364 8 tone tone NN 40436 6364 9 of of IN 40436 6364 10 displeasure displeasure NN 40436 6364 11 and and CC 40436 6364 12 menace menace NN 40436 6364 13 towards towards IN 40436 6364 14 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 6364 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6364 16 . . . 40436 6365 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6365 2 23 23 CD 40436 6365 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6365 4 The the DT 40436 6365 5 conversation conversation NN 40436 6365 6 is be VBZ 40436 6365 7 then then RB 40436 6365 8 renewed renew VBN 40436 6365 9 with with IN 40436 6365 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6365 11 , , , 40436 6365 12 and and CC 40436 6365 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6365 14 is be VBZ 40436 6365 15 shown show VBN 40436 6365 16 that that IN 40436 6365 17 the the DT 40436 6365 18 leading lead VBG 40436 6365 19 politicians politician NNS 40436 6365 20 can can MD 40436 6365 21 not not RB 40436 6365 22 be be VB 40436 6365 23 considered consider VBN 40436 6365 24 as as IN 40436 6365 25 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6365 26 of of IN 40436 6365 27 virtue virtue NN 40436 6365 28 , , , 40436 6365 29 any any DT 40436 6365 30 more more JJR 40436 6365 31 than than IN 40436 6365 32 the the DT 40436 6365 33 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6365 34 . . . 40436 6366 1 There there EX 40436 6366 2 exist exist VBP 40436 6366 3 no no DT 40436 6366 4 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6366 5 of of IN 40436 6366 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6366 7 ; ; : 40436 6366 8 and and CC 40436 6366 9 therefore therefore RB 40436 6366 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6366 11 must must MD 40436 6366 12 conclude conclude VB 40436 6366 13 that that IN 40436 6366 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6366 15 is be VBZ 40436 6366 16 not not RB 40436 6366 17 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6366 18 . . . 40436 6367 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6367 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6367 3 23 23 CD 40436 6367 4 : : : 40436 6367 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6367 6 , , , 40436 6367 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6367 8 , , , 40436 6367 9 p. p. NN 40436 6367 10 94 94 CD 40436 6367 11 E. E. NNP 40436 6367 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6367 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6367 14 Side side NN 40436 6367 15 - - HYPH 40436 6367 16 note note NN 40436 6367 17 : : : 40436 6367 18 Confused confused JJ 40436 6367 19 state state NN 40436 6367 20 of of IN 40436 6367 21 the the DT 40436 6367 22 discussion discussion NN 40436 6367 23 . . . 40436 6368 1 No no DT 40436 6368 2 way way NN 40436 6368 3 of of IN 40436 6368 4 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 6368 5 virtue virtue NN 40436 6368 6 is be VBZ 40436 6368 7 shown show VBN 40436 6368 8 . . . 40436 6368 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6369 1 The the DT 40436 6369 2 state state NN 40436 6369 3 of of IN 40436 6369 4 the the DT 40436 6369 5 discussion discussion NN 40436 6369 6 as as IN 40436 6369 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6369 8 stands stand VBZ 40436 6369 9 now now RB 40436 6369 10 , , , 40436 6369 11 is be VBZ 40436 6369 12 represented represent VBN 40436 6369 13 by by IN 40436 6369 14 two two CD 40436 6369 15 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 40436 6369 16 syllogisms syllogism NNS 40436 6369 17 , , , 40436 6369 18 as as IN 40436 6369 19 follows follow VBZ 40436 6369 20 : : : 40436 6369 21 1 1 CD 40436 6369 22 . . . 40436 6370 1 If if IN 40436 6370 2 virtue virtue NN 40436 6370 3 is be VBZ 40436 6370 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6370 5 , , , 40436 6370 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6370 7 is be VBZ 40436 6370 8 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6370 9 : : : 40436 6370 10 But but CC 40436 6370 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 6370 12 is be VBZ 40436 6370 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6370 14 : : : 40436 6370 15 Therefore therefore RB 40436 6370 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 6370 17 is be VBZ 40436 6370 18 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6370 19 . . . 40436 6371 1 2 2 LS 40436 6371 2 . . . 40436 6372 1 If if IN 40436 6372 2 virtue virtue NN 40436 6372 3 is be VBZ 40436 6372 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6372 5 , , , 40436 6372 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6372 7 is be VBZ 40436 6372 8 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6372 9 : : : 40436 6372 10 But but CC 40436 6372 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 6372 12 is be VBZ 40436 6372 13 not not RB 40436 6372 14 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6372 15 : : : 40436 6372 16 Therefore therefore RB 40436 6372 17 virtue virtue NN 40436 6372 18 is be VBZ 40436 6372 19 not not RB 40436 6372 20 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6372 21 . . . 40436 6373 1 The the DT 40436 6373 2 premisses premiss NNS 40436 6373 3 of of IN 40436 6373 4 each each DT 40436 6373 5 of of IN 40436 6373 6 these these DT 40436 6373 7 two two CD 40436 6373 8 syllogisms syllogism NNS 40436 6373 9 contradict contradict VBP 40436 6373 10 the the DT 40436 6373 11 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 6373 12 of of IN 40436 6373 13 the the DT 40436 6373 14 other other JJ 40436 6373 15 . . . 40436 6374 1 Both both DT 40436 6374 2 can can MD 40436 6374 3 not not RB 40436 6374 4 be be VB 40436 6374 5 true true JJ 40436 6374 6 . . . 40436 6375 1 If if IN 40436 6375 2 virtue virtue NN 40436 6375 3 is be VBZ 40436 6375 4 not not RB 40436 6375 5 acquired acquire VBN 40436 6375 6 by by IN 40436 6375 7 teaching teach VBG 40436 6375 8 and and CC 40436 6375 9 does do VBZ 40436 6375 10 not not RB 40436 6375 11 come come VB 40436 6375 12 by by IN 40436 6375 13 nature nature NN 40436 6375 14 , , , 40436 6375 15 how how WRB 40436 6375 16 are be VBP 40436 6375 17 there there EX 40436 6375 18 any any DT 40436 6375 19 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 6375 20 men man NNS 40436 6375 21 ? ? . 40436 6376 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6376 2 Side side NN 40436 6376 3 - - HYPH 40436 6376 4 note note NN 40436 6376 5 : : : 40436 6376 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6376 7 modifies modify VBZ 40436 6376 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6376 9 premisses premiss NNS 40436 6376 10 -- -- : 40436 6376 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6376 12 is be VBZ 40436 6376 13 not not RB 40436 6376 14 the the DT 40436 6376 15 only only JJ 40436 6376 16 thing thing NN 40436 6376 17 which which WDT 40436 6376 18 guides guide VBZ 40436 6376 19 to to IN 40436 6376 20 good good JJ 40436 6376 21 results result NNS 40436 6376 22 -- -- : 40436 6376 23 right right JJ 40436 6376 24 opinion opinion NN 40436 6376 25 will will MD 40436 6376 26 do do VB 40436 6376 27 the the DT 40436 6376 28 same same JJ 40436 6376 29 . . . 40436 6376 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6377 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6377 2 continues continue VBZ 40436 6377 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6377 4 argument argument NN 40436 6377 5 : : : 40436 6377 6 The the DT 40436 6377 7 second second JJ 40436 6377 8 premiss premiss NN 40436 6377 9 of of IN 40436 6377 10 the the DT 40436 6377 11 first first JJ 40436 6377 12 syllogism syllogism NN 40436 6377 13 -- -- : 40436 6377 14 that that DT 40436 6377 15 virtue virtue NN 40436 6377 16 is be VBZ 40436 6377 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6377 18 -- -- : 40436 6377 19 is be VBZ 40436 6377 20 true true JJ 40436 6377 21 , , , 40436 6377 22 but but CC 40436 6377 23 not not RB 40436 6377 24 the the DT 40436 6377 25 whole whole JJ 40436 6377 26 truth truth NN 40436 6377 27 . . . 40436 6378 1 In in IN 40436 6378 2 proving prove VBG 40436 6378 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6378 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6378 5 assumed assume VBD 40436 6378 6 that that IN 40436 6378 7 there there EX 40436 6378 8 was be VBD 40436 6378 9 nothing nothing NN 40436 6378 10 except except IN 40436 6378 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6378 12 which which WDT 40436 6378 13 guided guide VBD 40436 6378 14 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6378 15 to to IN 40436 6378 16 useful useful JJ 40436 6378 17 and and CC 40436 6378 18 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6378 19 consequences consequence NNS 40436 6378 20 . . . 40436 6379 1 But but CC 40436 6379 2 this this DT 40436 6379 3 assumption assumption NN 40436 6379 4 will will MD 40436 6379 5 not not RB 40436 6379 6 hold hold VB 40436 6379 7 . . . 40436 6380 1 There there EX 40436 6380 2 is be VBZ 40436 6380 3 something something NN 40436 6380 4 else else RB 40436 6380 5 besides besides IN 40436 6380 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6380 7 , , , 40436 6380 8 which which WDT 40436 6380 9 also also RB 40436 6380 10 guides guide VBZ 40436 6380 11 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6380 12 to to IN 40436 6380 13 the the DT 40436 6380 14 same same JJ 40436 6380 15 useful useful JJ 40436 6380 16 results result NNS 40436 6380 17 . . . 40436 6381 1 That that DT 40436 6381 2 something something NN 40436 6381 3 is be VBZ 40436 6381 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6381 5 right right JJ 40436 6381 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 6381 7 _ _ NNP 40436 6381 8 , , , 40436 6381 9 which which WDT 40436 6381 10 is be VBZ 40436 6381 11 quite quite RB 40436 6381 12 different different JJ 40436 6381 13 from from IN 40436 6381 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6381 15 . . . 40436 6382 1 The the DT 40436 6382 2 man man NN 40436 6382 3 who who WP 40436 6382 4 holds hold VBZ 40436 6382 5 right right JJ 40436 6382 6 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6382 7 is be VBZ 40436 6382 8 just just RB 40436 6382 9 as as RB 40436 6382 10 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6382 11 to to IN 40436 6382 12 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6382 13 , , , 40436 6382 14 and and CC 40436 6382 15 guides guide VBZ 40436 6382 16 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6382 17 quite quite RB 40436 6382 18 as as RB 40436 6382 19 well well RB 40436 6382 20 to to IN 40436 6382 21 right right JJ 40436 6382 22 actions action NNS 40436 6382 23 , , , 40436 6382 24 as as IN 40436 6382 25 if if IN 40436 6382 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6382 27 knew know VBD 40436 6382 28 . . . 40436 6383 1 Right right JJ 40436 6383 2 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6383 3 , , , 40436 6383 4 so so RB 40436 6383 5 long long RB 40436 6383 6 as as IN 40436 6383 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6383 8 stay stay VBP 40436 6383 9 in in IN 40436 6383 10 the the DT 40436 6383 11 mind mind NN 40436 6383 12 , , , 40436 6383 13 are be VBP 40436 6383 14 as as RB 40436 6383 15 good good JJ 40436 6383 16 as as IN 40436 6383 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6383 18 , , , 40436 6383 19 for for IN 40436 6383 20 the the DT 40436 6383 21 purpose purpose NN 40436 6383 22 of of IN 40436 6383 23 guidance guidance NN 40436 6383 24 in in IN 40436 6383 25 practice practice NN 40436 6383 26 . . . 40436 6384 1 But but CC 40436 6384 2 the the DT 40436 6384 3 difference difference NN 40436 6384 4 is be VBZ 40436 6384 5 , , , 40436 6384 6 that that IN 40436 6384 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6384 8 are be VBP 40436 6384 9 evanescent evanescent JJ 40436 6384 10 and and CC 40436 6384 11 will will MD 40436 6384 12 not not RB 40436 6384 13 stay stay VB 40436 6384 14 in in IN 40436 6384 15 the the DT 40436 6384 16 mind mind NN 40436 6384 17 : : : 40436 6384 18 while while IN 40436 6384 19 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6384 20 is be VBZ 40436 6384 21 permanent permanent JJ 40436 6384 22 and and CC 40436 6384 23 ineffaceable ineffaceable JJ 40436 6384 24 . . . 40436 6385 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 6385 2 are be VBP 40436 6385 3 exalted exalt VBN 40436 6385 4 into into IN 40436 6385 5 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6385 6 , , , 40436 6385 7 when when WRB 40436 6385 8 bound bind VBN 40436 6385 9 in in IN 40436 6385 10 the the DT 40436 6385 11 mind mind NN 40436 6385 12 by by IN 40436 6385 13 a a DT 40436 6385 14 chain chain NN 40436 6385 15 of of IN 40436 6385 16 causal causal JJ 40436 6385 17 reasoning:[24 reasoning:[24 NNP 40436 6385 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6385 19 that that RB 40436 6385 20 is is RB 40436 6385 21 , , , 40436 6385 22 by by IN 40436 6385 23 the the DT 40436 6385 24 process process NN 40436 6385 25 of of IN 40436 6385 26 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6385 27 , , , 40436 6385 28 before before IN 40436 6385 29 described describe VBN 40436 6385 30 . . . 40436 6386 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6386 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6386 3 24 24 CD 40436 6386 4 : : : 40436 6386 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6386 6 , , , 40436 6386 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6386 8 , , , 40436 6386 9 pp pp NNP 40436 6386 10 . . . 40436 6387 1 97 97 CD 40436 6387 2 E--98 E--98 NNS 40436 6387 3 A. a. NN 40436 6388 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6388 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6388 3 : : : 40436 6388 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6388 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6388 6 ai ai NNP 40436 6388 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6388 8 do do VB 40436 6388 9 / / SYM 40436 6388 10 xai xai NNP 40436 6388 11 ai ai NNP 40436 6388 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6388 13 a)lêthei a)lêthei NFP 40436 6388 14 = = SYM 40436 6388 15 s s NNP 40436 6388 16 , , , 40436 6388 17 o(/son o(/son NNP 40436 6388 18 me\n me\n NNP 40436 6388 19 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 6388 20 chro chro NN 40436 6388 21 / / SYM 40436 6388 22 non non AFX 40436 6388 23 parame parame NNP 40436 6388 24 / / SYM 40436 6388 25 nôsin nôsin NNP 40436 6388 26 , , , 40436 6388 27 kalo kalo NNP 40436 6388 28 / / SYM 40436 6388 29 n n CC 40436 6388 30 ti ti NNP 40436 6388 31 chrê chrê NNP 40436 6388 32 = = SYM 40436 6388 33 ma ma NNP 40436 6388 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6388 35 pa pa NNP 40436 6388 36 / / SYM 40436 6388 37 nta nta NNP 40436 6388 38 ta)gatha\ ta)gatha\ NNP 40436 6388 39 e)rga e)rga NNP 40436 6388 40 / / SYM 40436 6388 41 zontai zontai NNP 40436 6388 42 ; ; : 40436 6388 43 polu\n polu\n CD 40436 6388 44 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6388 45 chro chro NN 40436 6388 46 / / SYM 40436 6388 47 non non AFX 40436 6388 48 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 6388 49 e)the e)the JJ 40436 6388 50 / / SYM 40436 6388 51 lousi lousi NNP 40436 6388 52 parame parame NNP 40436 6388 53 / / SYM 40436 6388 54 nein nein NNP 40436 6388 55 , , , 40436 6388 56 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 6388 57 drapeteu drapeteu NN 40436 6388 58 / / SYM 40436 6388 59 ousin ousin NNP 40436 6388 60 e)k e)k NNP 40436 6388 61 tê tê NNP 40436 6388 62 = = SYM 40436 6388 63 s s NNP 40436 6388 64 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 6388 65 = = SYM 40436 6388 66 s s NNP 40436 6388 67 tou= tou= NNP 40436 6388 68 a)nthrô a)nthrô CD 40436 6388 69 / / SYM 40436 6388 70 pou pou NNP 40436 6388 71 . . . 40436 6389 1 ô(/ste ô(/ste NNP 40436 6389 2 ou ou NNP 40436 6389 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6389 4 pollou= pollou= NN 40436 6389 5 a)/xiai/ a)/xiai/ NNP 40436 6389 6 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 6389 7 , , , 40436 6389 8 _ _ NNP 40436 6389 9 e(/ôs e(/ôs NNP 40436 6389 10 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 6389 11 tis tis CC 40436 6389 12 au)ta\s au)ta\s NNP 40436 6389 13 dê dê NN 40436 6389 14 / / SYM 40436 6389 15 sê| sê| NNP 40436 6389 16 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 6389 17 / / SYM 40436 6389 18 as as IN 40436 6389 19 logismô=| logismô=| NNP 40436 6389 20 _ _ NNP 40436 6389 21 ; ; : 40436 6389 22 tou tou NNP 40436 6389 23 = = SYM 40436 6389 24 to to IN 40436 6389 25 d d NN 40436 6389 26 ' ' POS 40436 6389 27 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 6389 28 _ _ NNP 40436 6389 29 a)na a)na NNS 40436 6389 30 / / SYM 40436 6389 31 mnêsis mnêsis NN 40436 6389 32 _ _ NNP 40436 6389 33 , , , 40436 6389 34 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 6389 35 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6389 36 toi toi NNP 40436 6389 37 = = SYM 40436 6389 38 s s NN 40436 6389 39 pro pro JJ 40436 6389 40 / / SYM 40436 6389 41 sthen sthen NNP 40436 6389 42 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 6389 43 = = SYM 40436 6389 44 n n CC 40436 6389 45 ô(molo ô(molo NNP 40436 6389 46 / / SYM 40436 6389 47 gêtai gêtai NNP 40436 6389 48 . . . 40436 6389 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6389 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6390 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6390 2 Side side NN 40436 6390 3 - - HYPH 40436 6390 4 note note NN 40436 6390 5 : : : 40436 6390 6 Right right JJ 40436 6390 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 6390 8 can can MD 40436 6390 9 not not RB 40436 6390 10 be be VB 40436 6390 11 relied rely VBN 40436 6390 12 on on RP 40436 6390 13 for for IN 40436 6390 14 staying stay VBG 40436 6390 15 in in IN 40436 6390 16 the the DT 40436 6390 17 mind mind NN 40436 6390 18 , , , 40436 6390 19 and and CC 40436 6390 20 can can MD 40436 6390 21 never never RB 40436 6390 22 give give VB 40436 6390 23 rational rational JJ 40436 6390 24 explanations explanation NNS 40436 6390 25 , , , 40436 6390 26 nor nor CC 40436 6390 27 teach teach VB 40436 6390 28 others other NNS 40436 6390 29 -- -- : 40436 6390 30 good good JJ 40436 6390 31 practical practical JJ 40436 6390 32 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 6390 33 receive receive VBP 40436 6390 34 right right JJ 40436 6390 35 opinion opinion NN 40436 6390 36 by by IN 40436 6390 37 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 6390 38 from from IN 40436 6390 39 the the DT 40436 6390 40 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 6390 41 . . . 40436 6390 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6391 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 6391 2 then then RB 40436 6391 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6391 4 continues continue VBZ 40436 6391 5 Sokrates)--that sokrates)--that DT 40436 6391 6 which which WDT 40436 6391 7 constitutes constitute VBZ 40436 6391 8 the the DT 40436 6391 9 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 6391 10 character character NN 40436 6391 11 and and CC 40436 6391 12 the the DT 40436 6391 13 permanent permanent JJ 40436 6391 14 , , , 40436 6391 15 trustworthy trustworthy JJ 40436 6391 16 , , , 40436 6391 17 useful useful JJ 40436 6391 18 guide guide NN 40436 6391 19 -- -- : 40436 6391 20 consists consist VBZ 40436 6391 21 in in IN 40436 6391 22 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6391 23 . . . 40436 6392 1 But but CC 40436 6392 2 there there EX 40436 6392 3 is be VBZ 40436 6392 4 also also RB 40436 6392 5 right right JJ 40436 6392 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 6392 7 , , , 40436 6392 8 a a DT 40436 6392 9 sort sort NN 40436 6392 10 of of IN 40436 6392 11 _ _ NNP 40436 6392 12 quasi quasi JJ 40436 6392 13 - - JJ 40436 6392 14 knowledge knowledge JJ 40436 6392 15 _ _ NNP 40436 6392 16 , , , 40436 6392 17 which which WDT 40436 6392 18 produces produce VBZ 40436 6392 19 in in IN 40436 6392 20 practice practice NN 40436 6392 21 effects effect NNS 40436 6392 22 as as RB 40436 6392 23 good good JJ 40436 6392 24 as as IN 40436 6392 25 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6392 26 , , , 40436 6392 27 only only RB 40436 6392 28 that that IN 40436 6392 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6392 30 is be VBZ 40436 6392 31 not not RB 40436 6392 32 deeply deeply RB 40436 6392 33 or or CC 40436 6392 34 permanently permanently RB 40436 6392 35 fixed fix VBN 40436 6392 36 in in IN 40436 6392 37 the the DT 40436 6392 38 mind mind NN 40436 6392 39 . . . 40436 6393 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6393 2 25 25 CD 40436 6393 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6393 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6393 5 is be VBZ 40436 6393 6 this this DT 40436 6393 7 right right JJ 40436 6393 8 opinion opinion NN 40436 6393 9 , , , 40436 6393 10 or or CC 40436 6393 11 _ _ NNP 40436 6393 12 quasi quasi JJ 40436 6393 13 - - JJ 40436 6393 14 knowledge knowledge JJ 40436 6393 15 _ _ NNP 40436 6393 16 , , , 40436 6393 17 which which WDT 40436 6393 18 esteemed esteem VBD 40436 6393 19 and and CC 40436 6393 20 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 6393 21 citizens citizen NNS 40436 6393 22 possess possess VBP 40436 6393 23 , , , 40436 6393 24 and and CC 40436 6393 25 by by IN 40436 6393 26 means mean NNS 40436 6393 27 of of IN 40436 6393 28 which which WDT 40436 6393 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6393 30 render render VBP 40436 6393 31 useful useful JJ 40436 6393 32 service service NN 40436 6393 33 to to IN 40436 6393 34 the the DT 40436 6393 35 city city NN 40436 6393 36 . . . 40436 6394 1 That that IN 40436 6394 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6394 3 do do VBP 40436 6394 4 not not RB 40436 6394 5 possess possess VB 40436 6394 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6394 7 , , , 40436 6394 8 is be VBZ 40436 6394 9 certain certain JJ 40436 6394 10 ; ; : 40436 6394 11 for for IN 40436 6394 12 if if IN 40436 6394 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6394 14 did do VBD 40436 6394 15 , , , 40436 6394 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6394 17 would would MD 40436 6394 18 be be VB 40436 6394 19 able able JJ 40436 6394 20 to to TO 40436 6394 21 teach teach VB 40436 6394 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6394 23 to to IN 40436 6394 24 others other NNS 40436 6394 25 , , , 40436 6394 26 and and CC 40436 6394 27 especially especially RB 40436 6394 28 to to IN 40436 6394 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6394 30 own own JJ 40436 6394 31 sons son NNS 40436 6394 32 : : : 40436 6394 33 and and CC 40436 6394 34 this this DT 40436 6394 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6394 36 has have VBZ 40436 6394 37 been be VBN 40436 6394 38 shown show VBN 40436 6394 39 that that IN 40436 6394 40 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6394 41 can can MD 40436 6394 42 not not RB 40436 6394 43 do do VB 40436 6394 44 . . . 40436 6395 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6395 2 26 26 CD 40436 6395 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6395 4 They -PRON- PRP 40436 6395 5 deliver deliver VBP 40436 6395 6 true true JJ 40436 6395 7 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6395 8 and and CC 40436 6395 9 predictions prediction NNS 40436 6395 10 , , , 40436 6395 11 and and CC 40436 6395 12 excellent excellent JJ 40436 6395 13 advice advice NN 40436 6395 14 , , , 40436 6395 15 like like IN 40436 6395 16 prophets prophet NNS 40436 6395 17 and and CC 40436 6395 18 oracular oracular JJ 40436 6395 19 ministers minister NNS 40436 6395 20 , , , 40436 6395 21 by by IN 40436 6395 22 divine divine JJ 40436 6395 23 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 6395 24 and and CC 40436 6395 25 possession possession NN 40436 6395 26 , , , 40436 6395 27 without without IN 40436 6395 28 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6395 29 or or CC 40436 6395 30 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 6395 31 of of IN 40436 6395 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6395 33 own own JJ 40436 6395 34 . . . 40436 6396 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 6396 2 are be VBP 40436 6396 3 divine divine JJ 40436 6396 4 and and CC 40436 6396 5 inspired inspired JJ 40436 6396 6 persons person NNS 40436 6396 7 , , , 40436 6396 8 but but CC 40436 6396 9 not not RB 40436 6396 10 wise wise JJ 40436 6396 11 or or CC 40436 6396 12 knowing knowing JJ 40436 6396 13 . . . 40436 6397 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6397 2 27 27 CD 40436 6397 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6397 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6397 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6397 6 25 25 CD 40436 6397 7 : : : 40436 6397 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6397 9 , , , 40436 6397 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6397 11 , , , 40436 6397 12 p. p. NN 40436 6397 13 99 99 CD 40436 6397 14 A. a. NN 40436 6398 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6398 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6398 3 : : : 40436 6398 4 ô(=| ô(=| NNP 40436 6398 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6398 6 a)/nthrôpos a)/nthrôpos NNP 40436 6398 7 ê(gemô ê(gemô NNP 40436 6398 8 / / SYM 40436 6398 9 n n NNP 40436 6398 10 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 6398 11 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 6398 12 to\ to\ NN 40436 6398 13 o)rtho o)rtho NNS 40436 6398 14 / / SYM 40436 6398 15 n n CC 40436 6398 16 , , , 40436 6398 17 du du NNP 40436 6398 18 / / SYM 40436 6398 19 o o NNP 40436 6398 20 tau tau NNP 40436 6398 21 = = SYM 40436 6398 22 ta ta NNP 40436 6398 23 , , , 40436 6398 24 do do VB 40436 6398 25 / / SYM 40436 6398 26 xa xa NNP 40436 6398 27 a)lêthê\s a)lêthê\s NNP 40436 6398 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6398 29 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6398 30 / / SYM 40436 6398 31 mê mê NNP 40436 6398 32 . . . 40436 6398 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6398 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6399 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6399 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6399 3 26 26 CD 40436 6399 4 : : : 40436 6399 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6399 6 , , , 40436 6399 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6399 8 , , , 40436 6399 9 p. p. NN 40436 6399 10 99 99 CD 40436 6399 11 B. b. NN 40436 6400 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6400 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6400 3 : : : 40436 6400 4 Ou)k Ou)k NNP 40436 6400 5 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 6400 6 sophi sophi NNP 40436 6400 7 / / , 40436 6400 8 a a DT 40436 6400 9 tini\ tini\ NNP 40436 6400 10 ou)de\ ou)de\ JJ 40436 6400 11 sophoi\ sophoi\ JJ 40436 6400 12 o)/ntes o)/nte VBZ 40436 6400 13 oi oi NNP 40436 6400 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6400 15 toiou toiou NNP 40436 6400 16 = = -RRB- 40436 6400 17 toi toi NNP 40436 6400 18 a)/ndres a)/ndres NNP 40436 6400 19 ê(gou ê(gou NNP 40436 6400 20 = = SYM 40436 6400 21 nto nto NNP 40436 6400 22 tai tai NNP 40436 6400 23 = = SYM 40436 6400 24 s s NNP 40436 6400 25 po po NNP 40436 6400 26 / / SYM 40436 6400 27 lesin lesin NNP 40436 6400 28 , , , 40436 6400 29 oi oi NNP 40436 6400 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6400 31 a)mphi\ a)mphi\ NNP 40436 6400 32 Themistokle Themistokle NNP 40436 6400 33 / / SYM 40436 6400 34 a a NN 40436 6400 35 . . . 40436 6401 1 . . . 40436 6402 1 . . . 40436 6403 1 . . . 40436 6404 1 dio\ dio\ NNP 40436 6404 2 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6404 3 ou)ch ou)ch NNP 40436 6404 4 oi(=oi/ oi(=oi/ NNP 40436 6404 5 te te NNP 40436 6404 6 a)/llous a)/llous JJ 40436 6404 7 poiei poiei NN 40436 6404 8 = = SYM 40436 6404 9 n n CC 40436 6404 10 toiou toiou NNP 40436 6404 11 / / SYM 40436 6404 12 tous tous JJ 40436 6404 13 oi(=oi oi(=oi NNPS 40436 6404 14 au)toi/ au)toi/ NNP 40436 6404 15 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 6404 16 , , , 40436 6404 17 a(/te a(/te NNP 40436 6404 18 ou ou NNP 40436 6404 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6404 20 di di NNP 40436 6404 21 ' ' '' 40436 6404 22 e)pistê e)pistê CD 40436 6404 23 / / SYM 40436 6404 24 mên mên NN 40436 6404 25 o)/ntes o)/nte NNS 40436 6404 26 toiou toiou NNP 40436 6404 27 = = -RRB- 40436 6404 28 toi toi NNP 40436 6404 29 . . . 40436 6404 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6404 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6405 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6405 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6405 3 27 27 CD 40436 6405 4 : : : 40436 6405 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6405 6 , , , 40436 6405 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6405 8 , , , 40436 6405 9 p. p. NN 40436 6405 10 99 99 CD 40436 6405 11 D. D. NNP 40436 6405 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6405 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6405 14 : : : 40436 6405 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6405 16 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 6405 17 politikou\s politikou\s NNP 40436 6405 18 ou)ch ou)ch NNP 40436 6405 19 ê(/kista ê(/kista NNP 40436 6405 20 tou tou NNP 40436 6405 21 / / SYM 40436 6405 22 tôn tôn NNP 40436 6405 23 phai phai NNP 40436 6405 24 = = SYM 40436 6405 25 men man NNS 40436 6405 26 , , , 40436 6405 27 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 6405 28 thei thei NNP 40436 6405 29 / / SYM 40436 6405 30 ous ous NNP 40436 6405 31 te te NNP 40436 6405 32 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 6405 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6405 34 e)nthousia e)nthousia NNP 40436 6405 35 / / SYM 40436 6405 36 zein zein NN 40436 6405 37 , , , 40436 6405 38 e)pi e)pi JJ 40436 6405 39 / / SYM 40436 6405 40 pnous pnous JJ 40436 6405 41 o)/ntas o)/ntas NNP 40436 6405 42 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6405 43 katechome katechome NNP 40436 6405 44 / / SYM 40436 6405 45 nous nous JJ 40436 6405 46 e)k e)k NNP 40436 6405 47 tou= tou= NNP 40436 6405 48 theou= theou= NN 40436 6405 49 , , , 40436 6405 50 o(/tan o(/tan NNP 40436 6405 51 katorthô katorthô NNP 40436 6405 52 = = SYM 40436 6405 53 si si FW 40436 6405 54 le le NNP 40436 6405 55 / / SYM 40436 6405 56 gontes gontes NNPS 40436 6405 57 polla\ polla\ NNP 40436 6405 58 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6405 59 mega mega NNP 40436 6405 60 / / SYM 40436 6405 61 la la NNP 40436 6405 62 pra pra NNP 40436 6405 63 / / SYM 40436 6405 64 gmata gmata NNP 40436 6405 65 , , , 40436 6405 66 mêde\n mêde\n ADD 40436 6405 67 ei)do ei)do NNP 40436 6405 68 / / SYM 40436 6405 69 tes tes VBP 40436 6405 70 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 6405 71 le le NNP 40436 6405 72 / / SYM 40436 6405 73 gousin gousin NN 40436 6405 74 . . . 40436 6405 75 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6405 76 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6406 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6406 2 Side side NN 40436 6406 3 - - HYPH 40436 6406 4 note note NN 40436 6406 5 : : : 40436 6406 6 All all PDT 40436 6406 7 the the DT 40436 6406 8 real real JJ 40436 6406 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 6406 10 that that IN 40436 6406 11 there there EX 40436 6406 12 is be VBZ 40436 6406 13 , , , 40436 6406 14 is be VBZ 40436 6406 15 communicated communicate VBN 40436 6406 16 by by IN 40436 6406 17 special special JJ 40436 6406 18 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 6406 19 from from IN 40436 6406 20 the the DT 40436 6406 21 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 6406 22 . . . 40436 6406 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6407 1 And and CC 40436 6407 2 thus thus RB 40436 6407 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6407 4 concludes conclude VBZ 40436 6407 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6407 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6407 7 the the DT 40436 6407 8 answer answer NN 40436 6407 9 to to IN 40436 6407 10 the the DT 40436 6407 11 question question NN 40436 6407 12 originally originally RB 40436 6407 13 started start VBN 40436 6407 14 by by IN 40436 6407 15 Menon--"Whether Menon--"Whether NNP 40436 6407 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 6407 17 is be VBZ 40436 6407 18 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6407 19 ? ? . 40436 6407 20 " " '' 40436 6408 1 --is --is : 40436 6408 2 as as IN 40436 6408 3 follows follow VBZ 40436 6408 4 . . . 40436 6409 1 Virtue virtue VB 40436 6409 2 in in IN 40436 6409 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6409 4 highest high JJS 40436 6409 5 sense sense NN 40436 6409 6 , , , 40436 6409 7 in in IN 40436 6409 8 which which WDT 40436 6409 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6409 10 is be VBZ 40436 6409 11 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 6409 12 to to IN 40436 6409 13 or or CC 40436 6409 14 coincident coincident NN 40436 6409 15 with with IN 40436 6409 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6409 17 , , , 40436 6409 18 is be VBZ 40436 6409 19 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6409 20 : : : 40436 6409 21 but but CC 40436 6409 22 no no DT 40436 6409 23 such such JJ 40436 6409 24 virtue virtue NN 40436 6409 25 exists exist VBZ 40436 6409 26 . . . 40436 6410 1 That that DT 40436 6410 2 which which WDT 40436 6410 3 exists exist VBZ 40436 6410 4 in in IN 40436 6410 5 the the DT 40436 6410 6 most most RBS 40436 6410 7 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 6410 8 citizens citizen NNS 40436 6410 9 under under IN 40436 6410 10 the the DT 40436 6410 11 name name NN 40436 6410 12 of of IN 40436 6410 13 virtue,--or virtue,--or NNP 40436 6410 14 at at IN 40436 6410 15 least least JJS 40436 6410 16 producing produce VBG 40436 6410 17 the the DT 40436 6410 18 results result NNS 40436 6410 19 of of IN 40436 6410 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 6410 21 in in IN 40436 6410 22 practice practice NN 40436 6410 23 -- -- : 40436 6410 24 is be VBZ 40436 6410 25 not not RB 40436 6410 26 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6410 27 . . . 40436 6411 1 Nor nor CC 40436 6411 2 does do VBZ 40436 6411 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6411 4 come come VB 40436 6411 5 by by IN 40436 6411 6 nature nature NN 40436 6411 7 , , , 40436 6411 8 but but CC 40436 6411 9 by by IN 40436 6411 10 special special JJ 40436 6411 11 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 6411 12 from from IN 40436 6411 13 the the DT 40436 6411 14 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 6411 15 . . . 40436 6412 1 The the DT 40436 6412 2 best good JJS 40436 6412 3 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 6412 4 now now RB 40436 6412 5 existing existing JJ 40436 6412 6 can can MD 40436 6412 7 not not RB 40436 6412 8 make make VB 40436 6412 9 any any DT 40436 6412 10 other other JJ 40436 6412 11 person person NN 40436 6412 12 like like IN 40436 6412 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6412 14 : : : 40436 6412 15 if if IN 40436 6412 16 any any DT 40436 6412 17 one one CD 40436 6412 18 of of IN 40436 6412 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6412 20 could could MD 40436 6412 21 do do VB 40436 6412 22 this this DT 40436 6412 23 , , , 40436 6412 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6412 25 would would MD 40436 6412 26 be be VB 40436 6412 27 , , , 40436 6412 28 in in IN 40436 6412 29 comparison comparison NN 40436 6412 30 with with IN 40436 6412 31 the the DT 40436 6412 32 rest rest NN 40436 6412 33 , , , 40436 6412 34 like like IN 40436 6412 35 a a DT 40436 6412 36 real real JJ 40436 6412 37 thing thing NN 40436 6412 38 compared compare VBN 40436 6412 39 with with IN 40436 6412 40 a a DT 40436 6412 41 shadow shadow NN 40436 6412 42 . . . 40436 6413 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6413 2 28 28 CD 40436 6413 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6413 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6413 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6413 6 28 28 CD 40436 6413 7 : : : 40436 6413 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6413 9 , , , 40436 6413 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6413 11 , , , 40436 6413 12 p. p. NN 40436 6414 1 100 100 CD 40436 6414 2 . . . 40436 6414 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6415 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6415 2 Side side NN 40436 6415 3 - - HYPH 40436 6415 4 note note NN 40436 6415 5 : : : 40436 6415 6 But but CC 40436 6415 7 what what WP 40436 6415 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 6415 9 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 6415 10 is be VBZ 40436 6415 11 , , , 40436 6415 12 remains remain VBZ 40436 6415 13 unknown unknown JJ 40436 6415 14 . . . 40436 6415 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6416 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 6416 2 the the DT 40436 6416 3 question question NN 40436 6416 4 which which WDT 40436 6416 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6416 6 have have VBP 40436 6416 7 just just RB 40436 6416 8 discussed--"How discussed--"How NNP 40436 6416 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 6416 10 arises arise NNS 40436 6416 11 or or CC 40436 6416 12 is be VBZ 40436 6416 13 generated generate VBN 40436 6416 14 ? ? . 40436 6416 15 " " '' 40436 6417 1 --must --must NNP 40436 6417 2 be be VB 40436 6417 3 regarded regard VBN 40436 6417 4 as as IN 40436 6417 5 secondary secondary JJ 40436 6417 6 and and CC 40436 6417 7 dependent dependent JJ 40436 6417 8 , , , 40436 6417 9 not not RB 40436 6417 10 capable capable JJ 40436 6417 11 of of IN 40436 6417 12 being be VBG 40436 6417 13 clearly clearly RB 40436 6417 14 understood understand VBN 40436 6417 15 until until IN 40436 6417 16 the the DT 40436 6417 17 primary primary JJ 40436 6417 18 and and CC 40436 6417 19 principal principal JJ 40436 6417 20 question--"What question--"what NN 40436 6417 21 is be VBZ 40436 6417 22 virtue virtue JJ 40436 6417 23 ? ? . 40436 6417 24 " " '' 40436 6418 1 --has --has : 40436 6418 2 been be VBN 40436 6418 3 investigated investigate VBN 40436 6418 4 and and CC 40436 6418 5 brought bring VBN 40436 6418 6 to to IN 40436 6418 7 a a DT 40436 6418 8 solution solution NN 40436 6418 9 . . . 40436 6419 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6419 2 29 29 CD 40436 6419 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6419 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6419 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6419 6 29 29 CD 40436 6419 7 : : : 40436 6419 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6419 9 , , , 40436 6419 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6419 11 , , , 40436 6419 12 p. p. NN 40436 6419 13 100 100 CD 40436 6419 14 B. b. NN 40436 6419 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6420 1 * * NFP 40436 6420 2 * * NFP 40436 6420 3 * * NFP 40436 6420 4 * * NFP 40436 6420 5 * * NFP 40436 6420 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6420 7 Side side NN 40436 6420 8 - - HYPH 40436 6420 9 note note NN 40436 6420 10 : : : 40436 6420 11 Remarks remark NNS 40436 6420 12 on on IN 40436 6420 13 the the DT 40436 6420 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6420 15 . . . 40436 6421 1 Proper proper JJ 40436 6421 2 order order NN 40436 6421 3 for for IN 40436 6421 4 examining examine VBG 40436 6421 5 the the DT 40436 6421 6 different different JJ 40436 6421 7 topics topic NNS 40436 6421 8 , , , 40436 6421 9 is be VBZ 40436 6421 10 pointed point VBN 40436 6421 11 out out RP 40436 6421 12 by by IN 40436 6421 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6421 14 . . . 40436 6421 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6422 1 This this DT 40436 6422 2 last last JJ 40436 6422 3 observation observation NN 40436 6422 4 is be VBZ 40436 6422 5 repeated repeat VBN 40436 6422 6 by by IN 40436 6422 7 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6422 8 at at IN 40436 6422 9 the the DT 40436 6422 10 end end NN 40436 6422 11 -- -- : 40436 6422 12 as as IN 40436 6422 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6422 14 had have VBD 40436 6422 15 been be VBN 40436 6422 16 stated state VBN 40436 6422 17 at at IN 40436 6422 18 the the DT 40436 6422 19 beginning beginning NN 40436 6422 20 , , , 40436 6422 21 and and CC 40436 6422 22 in in IN 40436 6422 23 more more JJR 40436 6422 24 than than IN 40436 6422 25 one one CD 40436 6422 26 place place NN 40436 6422 27 during during IN 40436 6422 28 the the DT 40436 6422 29 continuance continuance NN 40436 6422 30 -- -- : 40436 6422 31 of of IN 40436 6422 32 the the DT 40436 6422 33 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6422 34 . . . 40436 6423 1 In in IN 40436 6423 2 fact fact NN 40436 6423 3 , , , 40436 6423 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6423 5 seems seem VBZ 40436 6423 6 at at IN 40436 6423 7 first first RB 40436 6423 8 resolved resolve VBN 40436 6423 9 to to TO 40436 6423 10 enforce enforce VB 40436 6423 11 the the DT 40436 6423 12 natural natural JJ 40436 6423 13 and and CC 40436 6423 14 necessary necessary JJ 40436 6423 15 priority priority NN 40436 6423 16 of of IN 40436 6423 17 the the DT 40436 6423 18 latter latter JJ 40436 6423 19 question question NN 40436 6423 20 : : : 40436 6423 21 but but CC 40436 6423 22 is be VBZ 40436 6423 23 induced induce VBN 40436 6423 24 by by IN 40436 6423 25 the the DT 40436 6423 26 solicitation solicitation NN 40436 6423 27 of of IN 40436 6423 28 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6423 29 to to TO 40436 6423 30 invert invert VB 40436 6423 31 the the DT 40436 6423 32 order order NN 40436 6423 33 . . . 40436 6424 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6424 2 30 30 CD 40436 6424 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6424 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6424 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6424 6 30 30 CD 40436 6424 7 : : : 40436 6424 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6424 9 , , , 40436 6424 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6424 11 , , , 40436 6424 12 p. p. NN 40436 6425 1 86 86 CD 40436 6425 2 . . . 40436 6425 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6426 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6426 2 Side side NN 40436 6426 3 - - HYPH 40436 6426 4 note note NN 40436 6426 5 : : : 40436 6426 6 Mischief mischief NN 40436 6426 7 of of IN 40436 6426 8 debating debate VBG 40436 6426 9 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 6426 10 and and CC 40436 6426 11 secondary secondary JJ 40436 6426 12 questions question NNS 40436 6426 13 when when WRB 40436 6426 14 the the DT 40436 6426 15 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 6426 16 notions notion NNS 40436 6426 17 and and CC 40436 6426 18 word word NN 40436 6426 19 are be VBP 40436 6426 20 unsettled unsettled JJ 40436 6426 21 . . . 40436 6426 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6427 1 The the DT 40436 6427 2 propriety propriety NN 40436 6427 3 of of IN 40436 6427 4 the the DT 40436 6427 5 order order NN 40436 6427 6 marked mark VBD 40436 6427 7 out out RP 40436 6427 8 , , , 40436 6427 9 but but CC 40436 6427 10 not not RB 40436 6427 11 pursued pursue VBN 40436 6427 12 , , , 40436 6427 13 by by IN 40436 6427 14 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6427 15 is be VBZ 40436 6427 16 indisputable indisputable JJ 40436 6427 17 . . . 40436 6428 1 Before before IN 40436 6428 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6428 3 can can MD 40436 6428 4 enquire enquire VB 40436 6428 5 how how WRB 40436 6428 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 6428 7 is be VBZ 40436 6428 8 generated generate VBN 40436 6428 9 or or CC 40436 6428 10 communicated communicate VBN 40436 6428 11 , , , 40436 6428 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6428 13 must must MD 40436 6428 14 be be VB 40436 6428 15 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 6428 16 that that IN 40436 6428 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6428 18 know know VBP 40436 6428 19 what what WP 40436 6428 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 6428 21 is be VBZ 40436 6428 22 . . . 40436 6429 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 6429 2 must must MD 40436 6429 3 know know VB 40436 6429 4 the the DT 40436 6429 5 essence essence NN 40436 6429 6 of of IN 40436 6429 7 the the DT 40436 6429 8 subject subject NN 40436 6429 9 -- -- : 40436 6429 10 or or CC 40436 6429 11 those those DT 40436 6429 12 predicates predicate NNS 40436 6429 13 which which WDT 40436 6429 14 the the DT 40436 6429 15 word word NN 40436 6429 16 connotes connote VBZ 40436 6429 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6429 18 = = NFP 40436 6429 19 the the DT 40436 6429 20 meaning meaning NN 40436 6429 21 of of IN 40436 6429 22 the the DT 40436 6429 23 term term NN 40436 6429 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6429 25 before before IN 40436 6429 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6429 27 investigate investigate VBP 40436 6429 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6429 29 accidents accident NNS 40436 6429 30 and and CC 40436 6429 31 antecedents antecedent NNS 40436 6429 32 . . . 40436 6430 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6430 2 31 31 CD 40436 6430 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6430 4 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6430 5 begins begin VBZ 40436 6430 6 by by IN 40436 6430 7 being be VBG 40436 6430 8 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 6430 9 that that IN 40436 6430 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6430 11 knows know VBZ 40436 6430 12 what what WDT 40436 6430 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 6430 14 is be VBZ 40436 6430 15 : : : 40436 6430 16 so so RB 40436 6430 17 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 6430 18 , , , 40436 6430 19 that that IN 40436 6430 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6430 21 accounts account VBZ 40436 6430 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6430 23 discreditable discreditable JJ 40436 6430 24 for for IN 40436 6430 25 a a DT 40436 6430 26 man man NN 40436 6430 27 not not RB 40436 6430 28 to to TO 40436 6430 29 know know VB 40436 6430 30 : : : 40436 6430 31 although although IN 40436 6430 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6430 33 is be VBZ 40436 6430 34 made make VBN 40436 6430 35 to to TO 40436 6430 36 answer answer VB 40436 6430 37 like like UH 40436 6430 38 one one CD 40436 6430 39 who who WP 40436 6430 40 has have VBZ 40436 6430 41 never never RB 40436 6430 42 thought think VBN 40436 6430 43 upon upon IN 40436 6430 44 the the DT 40436 6430 45 subject subject NN 40436 6430 46 , , , 40436 6430 47 and and CC 40436 6430 48 does do VBZ 40436 6430 49 not not RB 40436 6430 50 even even RB 40436 6430 51 understand understand VB 40436 6430 52 the the DT 40436 6430 53 question question NN 40436 6430 54 . . . 40436 6431 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6431 2 , , , 40436 6431 3 on on IN 40436 6431 4 the the DT 40436 6431 5 other other JJ 40436 6431 6 hand hand NN 40436 6431 7 , , , 40436 6431 8 not not RB 40436 6431 9 only only RB 40436 6431 10 confesses confess VBZ 40436 6431 11 that that IN 40436 6431 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6431 13 does do VBZ 40436 6431 14 not not RB 40436 6431 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6431 16 know know VB 40436 6431 17 , , , 40436 6431 18 but but CC 40436 6431 19 asserts assert VBZ 40436 6431 20 that that IN 40436 6431 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6431 22 never never RB 40436 6431 23 yet yet RB 40436 6431 24 met meet VBD 40436 6431 25 with with IN 40436 6431 26 a a DT 40436 6431 27 man man NN 40436 6431 28 who who WP 40436 6431 29 did do VBD 40436 6431 30 know know VB 40436 6431 31 . . . 40436 6432 1 One one CD 40436 6432 2 of of IN 40436 6432 3 the the DT 40436 6432 4 most most RBS 40436 6432 5 important important JJ 40436 6432 6 lessons lesson NNS 40436 6432 7 in in IN 40436 6432 8 this this DT 40436 6432 9 , , , 40436 6432 10 as as IN 40436 6432 11 in in IN 40436 6432 12 so so RB 40436 6432 13 many many JJ 40436 6432 14 other other JJ 40436 6432 15 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6432 16 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6432 17 , , , 40436 6432 18 is be VBZ 40436 6432 19 the the DT 40436 6432 20 mischief mischief NN 40436 6432 21 of of IN 40436 6432 22 proceeding proceed VBG 40436 6432 23 to to IN 40436 6432 24 debate debate VB 40436 6432 25 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 6432 26 and and CC 40436 6432 27 secondary secondary JJ 40436 6432 28 questions question NNS 40436 6432 29 , , , 40436 6432 30 without without IN 40436 6432 31 having have VBG 40436 6432 32 settled settle VBN 40436 6432 33 the the DT 40436 6432 34 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 6432 35 words word NNS 40436 6432 36 and and CC 40436 6432 37 notions notion NNS 40436 6432 38 : : : 40436 6432 39 the the DT 40436 6432 40 false false JJ 40436 6432 41 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 6432 42 of of IN 40436 6432 43 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6432 44 , , , 40436 6432 45 common common JJ 40436 6432 46 to to IN 40436 6432 47 almost almost RB 40436 6432 48 every every DT 40436 6432 49 one one CD 40436 6432 50 , , , 40436 6432 51 respecting respect VBG 40436 6432 52 these these DT 40436 6432 53 familiar familiar JJ 40436 6432 54 ethical ethical JJ 40436 6432 55 and and CC 40436 6432 56 social social JJ 40436 6432 57 ideas idea NNS 40436 6432 58 . . . 40436 6433 1 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6433 2 represents represent VBZ 40436 6433 3 the the DT 40436 6433 4 common common JJ 40436 6433 5 state state NN 40436 6433 6 of of IN 40436 6433 7 mind mind NN 40436 6433 8 . . . 40436 6434 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6434 2 begins begin VBZ 40436 6434 3 with with IN 40436 6434 4 the the DT 40436 6434 5 false false JJ 40436 6434 6 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 6434 7 that that IN 40436 6434 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6434 9 as as RB 40436 6434 10 well well RB 40436 6434 11 as as IN 40436 6434 12 every every DT 40436 6434 13 one one CD 40436 6434 14 else else RB 40436 6434 15 knows know VBZ 40436 6434 16 what what WDT 40436 6434 17 virtue virtue NN 40436 6434 18 is be VBZ 40436 6434 19 : : : 40436 6434 20 and and CC 40436 6434 21 even even RB 40436 6434 22 when when WRB 40436 6434 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6434 24 is be VBZ 40436 6434 25 proved prove VBN 40436 6434 26 to to TO 40436 6434 27 be be VB 40436 6434 28 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 6434 29 , , , 40436 6434 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6434 31 still still RB 40436 6434 32 feels feel VBZ 40436 6434 33 no no DT 40436 6434 34 interest interest NN 40436 6434 35 in in IN 40436 6434 36 the the DT 40436 6434 37 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 6434 38 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 6434 39 , , , 40436 6434 40 but but CC 40436 6434 41 turns turn VBZ 40436 6434 42 aside aside RB 40436 6434 43 to to IN 40436 6434 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6434 45 original original JJ 40436 6434 46 object object NN 40436 6434 47 of of IN 40436 6434 48 curiosity--"Whether curiosity--"whether NN 40436 6434 49 virtue virtue NN 40436 6434 50 is be VBZ 40436 6434 51 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6434 52 " " '' 40436 6434 53 . . . 40436 6435 1 Nothing nothing NN 40436 6435 2 can can MD 40436 6435 3 be be VB 40436 6435 4 more more RBR 40436 6435 5 repugnant repugnant JJ 40436 6435 6 to to IN 40436 6435 7 an an DT 40436 6435 8 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 6435 9 mind mind NN 40436 6435 10 than than IN 40436 6435 11 the the DT 40436 6435 12 thorough thorough JJ 40436 6435 13 sifting sifting NN 40436 6435 14 of of IN 40436 6435 15 deep deep JJ 40436 6435 16 - - HYPH 40436 6435 17 seated seated JJ 40436 6435 18 , , , 40436 6435 19 long long RB 40436 6435 20 familiarised familiarised JJ 40436 6435 21 , , , 40436 6435 22 notions--[Greek notions--[greek ADD 40436 6435 23 : : : 40436 6435 24 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6435 25 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6435 26 o)rthou o)rthou NNP 40436 6435 27 = = SYM 40436 6435 28 sthai sthai NNP 40436 6435 29 gnô gnô NNP 40436 6435 30 / / SYM 40436 6435 31 man man NN 40436 6435 32 , , , 40436 6435 33 o)duna=| o)duna=| ADD 40436 6435 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6435 35 . . . 40436 6436 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6436 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6436 3 31 31 CD 40436 6436 4 : : : 40436 6436 5 To to TO 40436 6436 6 use use VB 40436 6436 7 the the DT 40436 6436 8 phrase phrase NN 40436 6436 9 of of IN 40436 6436 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6436 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6436 12 in in IN 40436 6436 13 the the DT 40436 6436 14 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 6436 15 , , , 40436 6436 16 p. p. NN 40436 6436 17 11 11 CD 40436 6436 18 A a DT 40436 6436 19 , , , 40436 6436 20 the the DT 40436 6436 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6436 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6436 23 : : : 40436 6436 24 ou)si ou)si NNS 40436 6436 25 / / SYM 40436 6436 26 a a DT 40436 6436 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6436 28 must must MD 40436 6436 29 be be VB 40436 6436 30 known know VBN 40436 6436 31 before before IN 40436 6436 32 the the DT 40436 6436 33 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6436 34 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6436 35 : : : 40436 6436 36 pa pa NNP 40436 6436 37 / / SYM 40436 6436 38 thê thê NNP 40436 6436 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6436 40 are be VBP 40436 6436 41 sought--[Greek sought--[greek CD 40436 6436 42 : : : 40436 6436 43 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 6436 44 / / SYM 40436 6436 45 eis eis NNP 40436 6436 46 , , , 40436 6436 47 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 6436 48 Eu)thu Eu)thu NNP 40436 6436 49 / / SYM 40436 6436 50 phron phron NN 40436 6436 51 , , , 40436 6436 52 e)rôtô e)rôtô NNP 40436 6436 53 / / SYM 40436 6436 54 menos menos NNP 40436 6436 55 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6436 56 o(/sion o(/sion NN 40436 6436 57 , , , 40436 6436 58 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 6436 59 , , , 40436 6436 60 ti/ ti/ JJ 40436 6436 61 pot pot NN 40436 6436 62 ' ' '' 40436 6436 63 e)sti e)sti NNS 40436 6436 64 , , , 40436 6436 65 _ _ NNP 40436 6436 66 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6436 67 me\n me\n NNP 40436 6436 68 ou)si ou)si NNP 40436 6436 69 / / , 40436 6436 70 an an DT 40436 6436 71 _ _ NNP 40436 6436 72 moi moi NN 40436 6436 73 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 6436 74 ou ou NNP 40436 6436 75 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6436 76 bou bou NN 40436 6436 77 / / SYM 40436 6436 78 lesthai lesthai NNP 40436 6436 79 dêlô dêlô NNP 40436 6436 80 = = SYM 40436 6436 81 sai sai NNP 40436 6436 82 , , , 40436 6436 83 _ _ NNP 40436 6436 84 pa pa NNP 40436 6436 85 / / SYM 40436 6436 86 thos thos NNP 40436 6436 87 de/ de/ NNP 40436 6436 88 ti ti NNP 40436 6436 89 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6436 90 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 6436 91 _ _ NNP 40436 6436 92 le le NNP 40436 6436 93 / / SYM 40436 6436 94 gein gein NN 40436 6436 95 , , , 40436 6436 96 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 6436 97 , , , 40436 6436 98 ti ti IN 40436 6436 99 pe pe XX 40436 6436 100 / / SYM 40436 6436 101 ponthe ponthe NNP 40436 6436 102 tou tou NNP 40436 6436 103 = = SYM 40436 6436 104 to to TO 40436 6436 105 to\ to\ VB 40436 6436 106 o(/sion o(/sion NN 40436 6436 107 , , , 40436 6436 108 philei philei NNP 40436 6436 109 = = SYM 40436 6436 110 sthai sthai NNP 40436 6436 111 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 6436 112 pa pa NNP 40436 6436 113 / / SYM 40436 6436 114 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 6436 115 theô theô NNP 40436 6436 116 = = SYM 40436 6436 117 n n XX 40436 6436 118 ; ; : 40436 6436 119 _ _ NNP 40436 6436 120 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 6436 121 ti ti NNP 40436 6436 122 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6436 123 o)/n o)/n XX 40436 6436 124 , , , 40436 6436 125 ou)/pô ou)/pô NNP 40436 6436 126 ei)=pes ei)=pes . 40436 6436 127 _ _ NNP 40436 6436 128 . . . 40436 6436 129 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6437 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6437 2 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 6437 3 , , , 40436 6437 4 p. p. NN 40436 6437 5 190 190 CD 40436 6437 6 B B NNP 40436 6437 7 and and CC 40436 6437 8 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6437 9 , , , 40436 6437 10 pp pp NNP 40436 6437 11 . . . 40436 6438 1 448 448 CD 40436 6438 2 E e NN 40436 6438 3 , , , 40436 6438 4 462 462 CD 40436 6438 5 C. c. NN 40436 6438 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6438 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6438 8 Side side NN 40436 6438 9 - - HYPH 40436 6438 10 note note NN 40436 6438 11 : : : 40436 6438 12 Doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6438 13 of of IN 40436 6438 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6438 15 in in IN 40436 6438 16 the the DT 40436 6438 17 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6438 18 -- -- : 40436 6438 19 desire desire NN 40436 6438 20 of of IN 40436 6438 21 good good NN 40436 6438 22 alleged allege VBN 40436 6438 23 to to TO 40436 6438 24 be be VB 40436 6438 25 universally universally RB 40436 6438 26 felt feel VBN 40436 6438 27 -- -- : 40436 6438 28 in in IN 40436 6438 29 what what WDT 40436 6438 30 sense sense NN 40436 6438 31 this this DT 40436 6438 32 is be VBZ 40436 6438 33 true true JJ 40436 6438 34 . . . 40436 6438 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6439 1 The the DT 40436 6439 2 confession confession NN 40436 6439 3 of of IN 40436 6439 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6439 5 that that IN 40436 6439 6 neither neither CC 40436 6439 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6439 8 nor nor CC 40436 6439 9 any any DT 40436 6439 10 other other JJ 40436 6439 11 person person NN 40436 6439 12 in in IN 40436 6439 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6439 14 experience experience NN 40436 6439 15 knows know VBZ 40436 6439 16 what what WDT 40436 6439 17 virtue virtue NN 40436 6439 18 is be VBZ 40436 6439 19 -- -- : 40436 6439 20 that that IN 40436 6439 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6439 22 must must MD 40436 6439 23 be be VB 40436 6439 24 made make VBN 40436 6439 25 a a DT 40436 6439 26 subject subject NN 40436 6439 27 of of IN 40436 6439 28 special special JJ 40436 6439 29 and and CC 40436 6439 30 deliberate deliberate JJ 40436 6439 31 investigation investigation NN 40436 6439 32 -- -- : 40436 6439 33 and and CC 40436 6439 34 that that IN 40436 6439 35 no no DT 40436 6439 36 man man NN 40436 6439 37 can can MD 40436 6439 38 know know VB 40436 6439 39 what what WP 40436 6439 40 justice justice NN 40436 6439 41 , , , 40436 6439 42 or or CC 40436 6439 43 any any DT 40436 6439 44 other other JJ 40436 6439 45 part part NN 40436 6439 46 of of IN 40436 6439 47 virtue virtue NN 40436 6439 48 is be VBZ 40436 6439 49 , , , 40436 6439 50 unless unless IN 40436 6439 51 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6439 52 first first RB 40436 6439 53 knows know VBZ 40436 6439 54 what what WDT 40436 6439 55 virtue virtue NN 40436 6439 56 as as IN 40436 6439 57 a a DT 40436 6439 58 whole whole JJ 40436 6439 59 is[32]--are is[32]--are NNP 40436 6439 60 matters matter NNS 40436 6439 61 to to TO 40436 6439 62 be be VB 40436 6439 63 kept keep VBN 40436 6439 64 in in IN 40436 6439 65 mind mind NN 40436 6439 66 also also RB 40436 6439 67 , , , 40436 6439 68 as as IN 40436 6439 69 contrasting contrast VBG 40436 6439 70 with with IN 40436 6439 71 other other JJ 40436 6439 72 portions portion NNS 40436 6439 73 of of IN 40436 6439 74 the the DT 40436 6439 75 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6439 76 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6439 77 , , , 40436 6439 78 wherein wherein WRB 40436 6439 79 virtue virtue NNP 40436 6439 80 , , , 40436 6439 81 justice justice NNP 40436 6439 82 , , , 40436 6439 83 & & CC 40436 6439 84 c. c. NNP 40436 6439 85 , , , 40436 6439 86 are be VBP 40436 6439 87 tacitly tacitly RB 40436 6439 88 assumed assume VBN 40436 6439 89 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6439 90 according accord VBG 40436 6439 91 to to IN 40436 6439 92 the the DT 40436 6439 93 received received JJ 40436 6439 94 habit habit NN 40436 6439 95 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6439 96 as as IN 40436 6439 97 matters matter NNS 40436 6439 98 known know VBN 40436 6439 99 and and CC 40436 6439 100 understood understand VBD 40436 6439 101 . . . 40436 6440 1 The the DT 40436 6440 2 contributions contribution NNS 40436 6440 3 which which WDT 40436 6440 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6440 5 obtain obtain VBP 40436 6440 6 from from IN 40436 6440 7 the the DT 40436 6440 8 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6440 9 towards towards IN 40436 6440 10 finding find VBG 40436 6440 11 out out RP 40436 6440 12 the the DT 40436 6440 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6440 14 notion notion NN 40436 6440 15 of of IN 40436 6440 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 6440 17 , , , 40436 6440 18 are be VBP 40436 6440 19 negative negative JJ 40436 6440 20 rather rather RB 40436 6440 21 than than IN 40436 6440 22 positive positive JJ 40436 6440 23 . . . 40436 6441 1 The the DT 40436 6441 2 comments comment NNS 40436 6441 3 of of IN 40436 6441 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6441 5 upon upon IN 40436 6441 6 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6441 7 's 's POS 40436 6441 8 first first JJ 40436 6441 9 definition definition NN 40436 6441 10 include include VBP 40436 6441 11 the the DT 40436 6441 12 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6441 13 often often RB 40436 6441 14 announced announce VBD 40436 6441 15 in in IN 40436 6441 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6441 17 -- -- : 40436 6441 18 That that IN 40436 6441 19 no no DT 40436 6441 20 man man NN 40436 6441 21 by by IN 40436 6441 22 nature nature NN 40436 6441 23 desires desire NNS 40436 6441 24 suffering suffer VBG 40436 6441 25 or or CC 40436 6441 26 evil evil NN 40436 6441 27 ; ; : 40436 6441 28 every every DT 40436 6441 29 man man NN 40436 6441 30 desires desire VBZ 40436 6441 31 good good RB 40436 6441 32 : : : 40436 6441 33 if if IN 40436 6441 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6441 35 seeks seek VBZ 40436 6441 36 or or CC 40436 6441 37 pursues pursue VBZ 40436 6441 38 suffering suffering NN 40436 6441 39 or or CC 40436 6441 40 evil evil NN 40436 6441 41 , , , 40436 6441 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6441 43 does do VBZ 40436 6441 44 so so RB 40436 6441 45 merely merely RB 40436 6441 46 from from IN 40436 6441 47 error error NN 40436 6441 48 or or CC 40436 6441 49 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6441 50 , , , 40436 6441 51 mistaking mistake VBG 40436 6441 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6441 53 for for IN 40436 6441 54 good good JJ 40436 6441 55 . . . 40436 6442 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6442 2 33 33 CD 40436 6442 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6442 4 This this DT 40436 6442 5 is be VBZ 40436 6442 6 true true JJ 40436 6442 7 , , , 40436 6442 8 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 6442 9 , , , 40436 6442 10 if if IN 40436 6442 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6442 12 mean mean VBP 40436 6442 13 what what WP 40436 6442 14 is be VBZ 40436 6442 15 good good JJ 40436 6442 16 or or CC 40436 6442 17 evil evil JJ 40436 6442 18 for for IN 40436 6442 19 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6442 20 : : : 40436 6442 21 and and CC 40436 6442 22 if if IN 40436 6442 23 by by IN 40436 6442 24 good good JJ 40436 6442 25 or or CC 40436 6442 26 evil evil NN 40436 6442 27 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6442 28 mean mean VBP 40436 6442 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6442 30 according accord VBG 40436 6442 31 to to IN 40436 6442 32 the the DT 40436 6442 33 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6442 34 enforced enforce VBN 40436 6442 35 by by IN 40436 6442 36 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6442 37 in in IN 40436 6442 38 the the DT 40436 6442 39 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6442 40 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6442 41 the the DT 40436 6442 42 result result NN 40436 6442 43 of of IN 40436 6442 44 items item NNS 40436 6442 45 of of IN 40436 6442 46 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 6442 47 and and CC 40436 6442 48 pain pain NN 40436 6442 49 , , , 40436 6442 50 rightly rightly RB 40436 6442 51 estimated estimate VBN 40436 6442 52 and and CC 40436 6442 53 compared compare VBN 40436 6442 54 by by IN 40436 6442 55 the the DT 40436 6442 56 Measuring Measuring NNP 40436 6442 57 Reason Reason NNP 40436 6442 58 . . . 40436 6443 1 Every every DT 40436 6443 2 man man NN 40436 6443 3 naturally naturally RB 40436 6443 4 desires desire VBZ 40436 6443 5 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 6443 6 , , , 40436 6443 7 and and CC 40436 6443 8 the the DT 40436 6443 9 means mean NNS 40436 6443 10 of of IN 40436 6443 11 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 6443 12 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 6443 13 , , , 40436 6443 14 for for IN 40436 6443 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6443 16 : : : 40436 6443 17 every every DT 40436 6443 18 man man NN 40436 6443 19 naturally naturally RB 40436 6443 20 shrinks shrink VBZ 40436 6443 21 from from IN 40436 6443 22 pain pain NN 40436 6443 23 , , , 40436 6443 24 or or CC 40436 6443 25 the the DT 40436 6443 26 causes cause NNS 40436 6443 27 of of IN 40436 6443 28 pain pain NN 40436 6443 29 , , , 40436 6443 30 to to IN 40436 6443 31 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6443 32 : : : 40436 6443 33 every every DT 40436 6443 34 one one NN 40436 6443 35 compares compare VBZ 40436 6443 36 and and CC 40436 6443 37 measures measure VBZ 40436 6443 38 the the DT 40436 6443 39 items item NNS 40436 6443 40 of of IN 40436 6443 41 each each DT 40436 6443 42 with with IN 40436 6443 43 more more RBR 40436 6443 44 or or CC 40436 6443 45 less less JJR 40436 6443 46 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 6443 47 and and CC 40436 6443 48 impartiality impartiality NN 40436 6443 49 . . . 40436 6444 1 But but CC 40436 6444 2 the the DT 40436 6444 3 proposition proposition NN 40436 6444 4 is be VBZ 40436 6444 5 not not RB 40436 6444 6 true true JJ 40436 6444 7 , , , 40436 6444 8 if if IN 40436 6444 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6444 10 mean mean VBP 40436 6444 11 what what WP 40436 6444 12 is be VBZ 40436 6444 13 good good JJ 40436 6444 14 or or CC 40436 6444 15 evil evil JJ 40436 6444 16 for for IN 40436 6444 17 others other NNS 40436 6444 18 : : : 40436 6444 19 and and CC 40436 6444 20 if if IN 40436 6444 21 by by IN 40436 6444 22 good good NN 40436 6444 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6444 24 mean mean VBP 40436 6444 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6444 26 as as IN 40436 6444 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6444 28 is be VBZ 40436 6444 29 made make VBN 40436 6444 30 to to TO 40436 6444 31 declare declare VB 40436 6444 32 in in IN 40436 6444 33 the the DT 40436 6444 34 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6444 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6444 36 something something NN 40436 6444 37 apart apart RB 40436 6444 38 from from IN 40436 6444 39 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 6444 40 , , , 40436 6444 41 and and CC 40436 6444 42 by by IN 40436 6444 43 evil evil JJ 40436 6444 44 something something NN 40436 6444 45 apart apart RB 40436 6444 46 from from IN 40436 6444 47 pain pain NN 40436 6444 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6444 49 understanding understand VBG 40436 6444 50 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 6444 51 and and CC 40436 6444 52 pain pain NN 40436 6444 53 in in IN 40436 6444 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6444 55 largest large JJS 40436 6444 56 sense sense NN 40436 6444 57 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6444 58 . . . 40436 6445 1 A a DT 40436 6445 2 man man NN 40436 6445 3 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 6445 4 desires desire VBZ 40436 6445 5 what what WP 40436 6445 6 is be VBZ 40436 6445 7 good good JJ 40436 6445 8 for for IN 40436 6445 9 others other NNS 40436 6445 10 , , , 40436 6445 11 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 6445 12 what what WP 40436 6445 13 is be VBZ 40436 6445 14 evil evil JJ 40436 6445 15 for for IN 40436 6445 16 others other NNS 40436 6445 17 , , , 40436 6445 18 as as IN 40436 6445 19 the the DT 40436 6445 20 case case NN 40436 6445 21 may may MD 40436 6445 22 be be VB 40436 6445 23 . . . 40436 6446 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6446 2 's 's POS 40436 6446 3 observation observation NN 40436 6446 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 6446 5 can can MD 40436 6446 6 not not RB 40436 6446 7 be be VB 40436 6446 8 admitted admit VBN 40436 6446 9 -- -- : 40436 6446 10 That that IN 40436 6446 11 as as IN 40436 6446 12 to to IN 40436 6446 13 the the DT 40436 6446 14 wish wish NN 40436 6446 15 or or CC 40436 6446 16 desire desire NN 40436 6446 17 , , , 40436 6446 18 all all DT 40436 6446 19 men man NNS 40436 6446 20 are be VBP 40436 6446 21 alike alike RB 40436 6446 22 : : : 40436 6446 23 one one CD 40436 6446 24 man man NN 40436 6446 25 is be VBZ 40436 6446 26 no no RB 40436 6446 27 better well JJR 40436 6446 28 than than IN 40436 6446 29 another another DT 40436 6446 30 . . . 40436 6447 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6447 2 34 34 CD 40436 6447 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6447 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6447 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6447 6 32 32 CD 40436 6447 7 : : : 40436 6447 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6447 9 , , , 40436 6447 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6447 11 , , , 40436 6447 12 p. p. NN 40436 6447 13 79 79 CD 40436 6447 14 B B NNP 40436 6447 15 - - HYPH 40436 6447 16 C. C. NNP 40436 6447 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6447 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6447 19 : : : 40436 6447 20 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6447 21 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6447 22 dikaiosu dikaiosu NN 40436 6447 23 / / SYM 40436 6447 24 nên nên NNP 40436 6447 25 mo mo NNP 40436 6447 26 / / SYM 40436 6447 27 rion rion NN 40436 6447 28 phê\| phê\| NNS 40436 6447 29 a)retê a)retê -LRB- 40436 6447 30 = = SYM 40436 6447 31 s s NNP 40436 6447 32 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 6447 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6447 34 e(/kasta e(/kasta NNP 40436 6447 35 tou tou NNP 40436 6447 36 / / SYM 40436 6447 37 tôn tôn NNP 40436 6447 38 . . . 40436 6448 1 . . . 40436 6449 1 . . . 40436 6450 1 . . . 40436 6451 1 oi)/ei oi)/ei NNP 40436 6451 2 tina tina NNP 40436 6451 3 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 6451 4 / / SYM 40436 6451 5 nai nai NNP 40436 6451 6 mo mo NNP 40436 6451 7 / / SYM 40436 6451 8 rion rion NNP 40436 6451 9 a)retê a)retê ADD 40436 6451 10 = = SYM 40436 6451 11 s s VBZ 40436 6451 12 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 6451 13 ti ti NNP 40436 6451 14 e)/stin e)/stin NN 40436 6451 15 , , , 40436 6451 16 au)tê\n au)tê\n NN 40436 6451 17 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 6451 18 ei)do ei)do NNS 40436 6451 19 / / SYM 40436 6451 20 ta ta NNP 40436 6451 21 ? ? . 40436 6452 1 Ou)k Ou)k NNP 40436 6452 2 e)/moige e)/moige NNP 40436 6452 3 dokei=. dokei=. NNP 40436 6452 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6452 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6453 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6453 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6453 3 33 33 CD 40436 6453 4 : : : 40436 6453 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6453 6 , , , 40436 6453 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6453 8 , , , 40436 6453 9 p. p. NN 40436 6454 1 77 77 CD 40436 6454 2 . . . 40436 6454 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6455 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6455 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6455 3 34 34 CD 40436 6455 4 : : : 40436 6455 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6455 6 , , , 40436 6455 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6455 8 , , , 40436 6455 9 p. p. NN 40436 6455 10 78 78 CD 40436 6455 11 B. b. NN 40436 6456 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6456 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6456 3 : : : 40436 6456 4 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6456 5 me\n me\n NNP 40436 6456 6 bou bou NN 40436 6456 7 / / SYM 40436 6456 8 lesthai lesthai NNP 40436 6456 9 pa pa NNP 40436 6456 10 = = SYM 40436 6456 11 sin sin NN 40436 6456 12 u(pa u(pa NNP 40436 6456 13 / / SYM 40436 6456 14 rchei rchei NNP 40436 6456 15 , , , 40436 6456 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6456 17 tau tau NNP 40436 6456 18 / / SYM 40436 6456 19 tê| tê| NNP 40436 6456 20 ge ge NNP 40436 6456 21 ou)de\n ou)de\n NNP 40436 6456 22 o o NNP 40436 6456 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6456 24 e(/teros e(/teros NNP 40436 6456 25 tou= tou= NNP 40436 6456 26 e(te e(te NNP 40436 6456 27 / / SYM 40436 6456 28 rou rou NNP 40436 6456 29 belti belti NN 40436 6456 30 / / SYM 40436 6456 31 ôn ôn NNP 40436 6456 32 . . . 40436 6456 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6456 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6457 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6457 2 Side side NN 40436 6457 3 - - HYPH 40436 6457 4 note note NN 40436 6457 5 : : : 40436 6457 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6457 7 requires require VBZ 40436 6457 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6457 9 as as IN 40436 6457 10 the the DT 40436 6457 11 principal principal JJ 40436 6457 12 condition condition NN 40436 6457 13 of of IN 40436 6457 14 virtue virtue NN 40436 6457 15 , , , 40436 6457 16 but but CC 40436 6457 17 does do VBZ 40436 6457 18 not not RB 40436 6457 19 determine determine VB 40436 6457 20 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6457 21 , , , 40436 6457 22 of of IN 40436 6457 23 what what WP 40436 6457 24 ? ? . 40436 6457 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6458 1 The the DT 40436 6458 2 second second JJ 40436 6458 3 portion portion NN 40436 6458 4 of of IN 40436 6458 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6458 6 's 's POS 40436 6458 7 theory theory NN 40436 6458 8 , , , 40436 6458 9 advanced advance VBN 40436 6458 10 to to TO 40436 6458 11 explain explain VB 40436 6458 12 what what WDT 40436 6458 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 6458 14 is be VBZ 40436 6458 15 , , , 40436 6458 16 presents present VBZ 40436 6458 17 nothing nothing NN 40436 6458 18 more more RBR 40436 6458 19 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 6458 20 . . . 40436 6459 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 6459 2 is be VBZ 40436 6459 3 useful useful JJ 40436 6459 4 or or CC 40436 6459 5 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6459 6 : : : 40436 6459 7 but but CC 40436 6459 8 neither neither CC 40436 6459 9 health health NN 40436 6459 10 , , , 40436 6459 11 strength strength NN 40436 6459 12 , , , 40436 6459 13 beauty beauty NN 40436 6459 14 , , , 40436 6459 15 wealth wealth NN 40436 6459 16 , , , 40436 6459 17 power power NN 40436 6459 18 , , , 40436 6459 19 & & CC 40436 6459 20 c. c. NNP 40436 6459 21 , , , 40436 6459 22 are be VBP 40436 6459 23 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6459 24 , , , 40436 6459 25 unless unless IN 40436 6459 26 rightly rightly RB 40436 6459 27 used use VBN 40436 6459 28 : : : 40436 6459 29 nor nor CC 40436 6459 30 are be VBP 40436 6459 31 justice justice NN 40436 6459 32 , , , 40436 6459 33 moderation moderation NN 40436 6459 34 , , , 40436 6459 35 courage courage NN 40436 6459 36 , , , 40436 6459 37 quick quick JJ 40436 6459 38 apprehension apprehension NN 40436 6459 39 , , , 40436 6459 40 good good JJ 40436 6459 41 memory memory NN 40436 6459 42 , , , 40436 6459 43 & & CC 40436 6459 44 c. c. NNP 40436 6459 45 , , , 40436 6459 46 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6459 47 , , , 40436 6459 48 unless unless IN 40436 6459 49 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6459 50 are be VBP 40436 6459 51 accompanied accompany VBN 40436 6459 52 and and CC 40436 6459 53 guided guide VBN 40436 6459 54 by by IN 40436 6459 55 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6459 56 or or CC 40436 6459 57 prudence prudence NN 40436 6459 58 . . . 40436 6460 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6460 2 35 35 CD 40436 6460 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6460 4 Now now UH 40436 6460 5 if if IN 40436 6460 6 by by IN 40436 6460 7 _ _ NNP 40436 6460 8 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6460 9 _ _ NNP 40436 6460 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6460 11 have have VBP 40436 6460 12 reference reference NN 40436 6460 13 not not RB 40436 6460 14 to to IN 40436 6460 15 the the DT 40436 6460 16 individual individual JJ 40436 6460 17 agent agent NN 40436 6460 18 alone alone RB 40436 6460 19 , , , 40436 6460 20 but but CC 40436 6460 21 to to IN 40436 6460 22 other other JJ 40436 6460 23 persons person NNS 40436 6460 24 concerned concern VBN 40436 6460 25 also also RB 40436 6460 26 , , , 40436 6460 27 the the DT 40436 6460 28 proposition proposition NN 40436 6460 29 is be VBZ 40436 6460 30 true true JJ 40436 6460 31 , , , 40436 6460 32 but but CC 40436 6460 33 not not RB 40436 6460 34 instructive instructive JJ 40436 6460 35 or or CC 40436 6460 36 distinct distinct JJ 40436 6460 37 . . . 40436 6461 1 For for IN 40436 6461 2 what what WP 40436 6461 3 is be VBZ 40436 6461 4 meant mean VBN 40436 6461 5 by by IN 40436 6461 6 _ _ NNP 40436 6461 7 right right JJ 40436 6461 8 use use NN 40436 6461 9 _ _ NNP 40436 6461 10 ? ? . 40436 6462 1 To to IN 40436 6462 2 what what WDT 40436 6462 3 ends end NNS 40436 6462 4 are be VBP 40436 6462 5 the the DT 40436 6462 6 gifts gift NNS 40436 6462 7 here here RB 40436 6462 8 enumerated enumerate VBD 40436 6462 9 to to TO 40436 6462 10 be be VB 40436 6462 11 turned turn VBN 40436 6462 12 , , , 40436 6462 13 in in IN 40436 6462 14 order order NN 40436 6462 15 to to TO 40436 6462 16 constitute constitute VB 40436 6462 17 right right JJ 40436 6462 18 use use NN 40436 6462 19 ? ? . 40436 6463 1 What what WP 40436 6463 2 again again RB 40436 6463 3 is be VBZ 40436 6463 4 meant mean VBN 40436 6463 5 by by IN 40436 6463 6 _ _ NNP 40436 6463 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6463 8 _ _ NNP 40436 6463 9 ? ? . 40436 6464 1 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6464 2 of of IN 40436 6464 3 what what WP 40436 6464 4 ? ? . 40436 6465 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6465 2 36 36 CD 40436 6465 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6465 4 This this DT 40436 6465 5 is be VBZ 40436 6465 6 a a DT 40436 6465 7 question question NN 40436 6465 8 put put VBN 40436 6465 9 by by IN 40436 6465 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6465 11 in in IN 40436 6465 12 many many JJ 40436 6465 13 other other JJ 40436 6465 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6465 15 , , , 40436 6465 16 and and CC 40436 6465 17 necessary necessary JJ 40436 6465 18 to to TO 40436 6465 19 be be VB 40436 6465 20 put put VBN 40436 6465 21 here here RB 40436 6465 22 also also RB 40436 6465 23 . . . 40436 6466 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 6466 2 , , , 40436 6466 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6466 4 is be VBZ 40436 6466 5 a a DT 40436 6466 6 term term NN 40436 6466 7 which which WDT 40436 6466 8 requires require VBZ 40436 6466 9 to to TO 40436 6466 10 be be VB 40436 6466 11 determined determine VBN 40436 6466 12 , , , 40436 6466 13 not not RB 40436 6466 14 merely merely RB 40436 6466 15 to to IN 40436 6466 16 some some DT 40436 6466 17 assignable assignable JJ 40436 6466 18 object object NN 40436 6466 19 , , , 40436 6466 20 but but CC 40436 6466 21 also also RB 40436 6466 22 in in IN 40436 6466 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6466 24 general general JJ 40436 6466 25 import import NN 40436 6466 26 , , , 40436 6466 27 no no DT 40436 6466 28 less less JJR 40436 6466 29 than than IN 40436 6466 30 virtue virtue NN 40436 6466 31 . . . 40436 6467 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6467 2 shall shall MD 40436 6467 3 come come VB 40436 6467 4 presently presently RB 40436 6467 5 to to IN 40436 6467 6 an an DT 40436 6467 7 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 6467 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6467 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6467 10 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 6467 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6467 12 in in IN 40436 6467 13 which which WDT 40436 6467 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6467 15 makes make VBZ 40436 6467 16 many many JJ 40436 6467 17 attempts attempt NNS 40436 6467 18 to to TO 40436 6467 19 determine determine VB 40436 6467 20 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6467 21 generally generally RB 40436 6467 22 , , , 40436 6467 23 but but CC 40436 6467 24 ends end VBZ 40436 6467 25 in in IN 40436 6467 26 a a DT 40436 6467 27 confessed confessed JJ 40436 6467 28 failure failure NN 40436 6467 29 . . . 40436 6468 1 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6468 2 must must MD 40436 6468 3 be be VB 40436 6468 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6468 5 _ _ NNP 40436 6468 6 possessed possess VBN 40436 6468 7 by by IN 40436 6468 8 some some DT 40436 6468 9 one one CD 40436 6468 10 _ _ NNP 40436 6468 11 , , , 40436 6468 12 and and CC 40436 6468 13 must must MD 40436 6468 14 be be VB 40436 6468 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6468 16 of of IN 40436 6468 17 _ _ NNP 40436 6468 18 something something NN 40436 6468 19 _ _ NNP 40436 6468 20 . . . 40436 6469 1 What what WP 40436 6469 2 is be VBZ 40436 6469 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6469 4 , , , 40436 6469 5 that that IN 40436 6469 6 a a DT 40436 6469 7 man man NN 40436 6469 8 must must MD 40436 6469 9 know know VB 40436 6469 10 , , , 40436 6469 11 in in IN 40436 6469 12 order order NN 40436 6469 13 that that IN 40436 6469 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6469 15 justice justice NN 40436 6469 16 or or CC 40436 6469 17 courage courage NN 40436 6469 18 may may MD 40436 6469 19 become become VB 40436 6469 20 profitable profitable JJ 40436 6469 21 ? ? . 40436 6470 1 Is be VBZ 40436 6470 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6470 3 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 6470 4 and and CC 40436 6470 5 pains pain NNS 40436 6470 6 , , , 40436 6470 7 with with IN 40436 6470 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6470 9 causes cause NNS 40436 6470 10 , , , 40436 6470 11 and and CC 40436 6470 12 the the DT 40436 6470 13 comparative comparative JJ 40436 6470 14 magnitude magnitude NN 40436 6470 15 of of IN 40436 6470 16 each each DT 40436 6470 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6470 18 as as IN 40436 6470 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6470 20 declares declare VBZ 40436 6470 21 in in IN 40436 6470 22 the the DT 40436 6470 23 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6470 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6470 25 , , , 40436 6470 26 in in IN 40436 6470 27 order order NN 40436 6470 28 that that IN 40436 6470 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6470 30 may may MD 40436 6470 31 contribute contribute VB 40436 6470 32 to to TO 40436 6470 33 diminish diminish VB 40436 6470 34 the the DT 40436 6470 35 sum sum NN 40436 6470 36 of of IN 40436 6470 37 pains pain NNS 40436 6470 38 , , , 40436 6470 39 increase increase VB 40436 6470 40 that that DT 40436 6470 41 of of IN 40436 6470 42 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 6470 43 , , , 40436 6470 44 to to IN 40436 6470 45 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6470 46 or or CC 40436 6470 47 to to IN 40436 6470 48 the the DT 40436 6470 49 society society NN 40436 6470 50 ? ? . 40436 6471 1 If if IN 40436 6471 2 this this DT 40436 6471 3 be be VB 40436 6471 4 what what WP 40436 6471 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6471 6 is be VBZ 40436 6471 7 required require VBN 40436 6471 8 to to TO 40436 6471 9 know know VB 40436 6471 10 , , , 40436 6471 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6471 12 should should MD 40436 6471 13 have have VB 40436 6471 14 said say VBD 40436 6471 15 so so RB 40436 6471 16 -- -- : 40436 6471 17 or or CC 40436 6471 18 if if IN 40436 6471 19 not not RB 40436 6471 20 , , , 40436 6471 21 what what WP 40436 6471 22 else else RB 40436 6471 23 -- -- : 40436 6471 24 in in IN 40436 6471 25 order order NN 40436 6471 26 that that IN 40436 6471 27 the the DT 40436 6471 28 requirement requirement NN 40436 6471 29 of of IN 40436 6471 30 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6471 31 might may MD 40436 6471 32 be be VB 40436 6471 33 made make VBN 40436 6471 34 an an DT 40436 6471 35 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 6471 36 condition condition NN 40436 6471 37 . . . 40436 6472 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6472 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6472 3 35 35 CD 40436 6472 4 : : : 40436 6472 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6472 6 , , , 40436 6472 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6472 8 , , , 40436 6472 9 pp pp NNP 40436 6472 10 . . . 40436 6473 1 87 87 CD 40436 6473 2 - - SYM 40436 6473 3 88 88 CD 40436 6473 4 . . . 40436 6473 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6474 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6474 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6474 3 36 36 CD 40436 6474 4 : : : 40436 6474 5 See See NNP 40436 6474 6 Republic Republic NNP 40436 6474 7 , , , 40436 6474 8 vi vi NNP 40436 6474 9 . . . 40436 6475 1 p. p. NN 40436 6475 2 505 505 CD 40436 6475 3 B b NN 40436 6475 4 , , , 40436 6475 5 where where WRB 40436 6475 6 this this DT 40436 6475 7 question question NN 40436 6475 8 is be VBZ 40436 6475 9 put put VBN 40436 6475 10 , , , 40436 6475 11 but but CC 40436 6475 12 not not RB 40436 6475 13 answered answer VBN 40436 6475 14 , , , 40436 6475 15 respecting respect VBG 40436 6475 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6475 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6475 18 : : : 40436 6475 19 phro phro NN 40436 6475 20 / / SYM 40436 6475 21 nêsis nêsis NN 40436 6475 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6475 23 . . . 40436 6475 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6476 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6476 2 Side side NN 40436 6476 3 - - HYPH 40436 6476 4 note note NN 40436 6476 5 : : : 40436 6476 6 Subject subject NN 40436 6476 7 of of IN 40436 6476 8 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6476 9 ; ; : 40436 6476 10 same same JJ 40436 6476 11 as as IN 40436 6476 12 that that DT 40436 6476 13 of of IN 40436 6476 14 the the DT 40436 6476 15 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6476 16 -- -- : 40436 6476 17 diversity diversity NN 40436 6476 18 of of IN 40436 6476 19 handling handling NN 40436 6476 20 -- -- : 40436 6476 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6476 22 is be VBZ 40436 6476 23 not not RB 40436 6476 24 anxious anxious JJ 40436 6476 25 to to TO 40436 6476 26 settle settle VB 40436 6476 27 a a DT 40436 6476 28 question question NN 40436 6476 29 and and CC 40436 6476 30 get get VB 40436 6476 31 rid rid VBN 40436 6476 32 of of IN 40436 6476 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6476 34 . . . 40436 6476 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6477 1 Though though IN 40436 6477 2 the the DT 40436 6477 3 subject subject NN 40436 6477 4 of of IN 40436 6477 5 direct direct JJ 40436 6477 6 debate debate NN 40436 6477 7 in in IN 40436 6477 8 the the DT 40436 6477 9 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6477 10 is be VBZ 40436 6477 11 the the DT 40436 6477 12 same same JJ 40436 6477 13 as as IN 40436 6477 14 that that DT 40436 6477 15 in in IN 40436 6477 16 the the DT 40436 6477 17 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6477 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6477 19 whether whether IN 40436 6477 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 6477 21 be be VBP 40436 6477 22 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6477 23 ? ? . 40436 6477 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6478 1 yet yet CC 40436 6478 2 the the DT 40436 6478 3 manner manner NN 40436 6478 4 of of IN 40436 6478 5 treating treat VBG 40436 6478 6 this this DT 40436 6478 7 subject subject NN 40436 6478 8 is be VBZ 40436 6478 9 very very RB 40436 6478 10 different different JJ 40436 6478 11 in in IN 40436 6478 12 the the DT 40436 6478 13 two two CD 40436 6478 14 . . . 40436 6479 1 One one CD 40436 6479 2 point point NN 40436 6479 3 of of IN 40436 6479 4 difference difference NN 40436 6479 5 between between IN 40436 6479 6 the the DT 40436 6479 7 two two CD 40436 6479 8 has have VBZ 40436 6479 9 been be VBN 40436 6479 10 just just RB 40436 6479 11 noticed notice VBN 40436 6479 12 . . . 40436 6480 1 Another another DT 40436 6480 2 difference difference NN 40436 6480 3 is be VBZ 40436 6480 4 , , , 40436 6480 5 that that IN 40436 6480 6 whereas whereas IN 40436 6480 7 in in IN 40436 6480 8 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6480 9 the the DT 40436 6480 10 teachability teachability NN 40436 6480 11 of of IN 40436 6480 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 6480 13 is be VBZ 40436 6480 14 assumed assume VBN 40436 6480 15 to to TO 40436 6480 16 be be VB 40436 6480 17 disproved disprove VBN 40436 6480 18 , , , 40436 6480 19 because because IN 40436 6480 20 there there EX 40436 6480 21 are be VBP 40436 6480 22 no no DT 40436 6480 23 recognised recognised JJ 40436 6480 24 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6480 25 or or CC 40436 6480 26 learners learner NNS 40436 6480 27 of of IN 40436 6480 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6480 29 -- -- : 40436 6480 30 in in IN 40436 6480 31 the the DT 40436 6480 32 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6480 33 this this DT 40436 6480 34 argument argument NN 40436 6480 35 is be VBZ 40436 6480 36 produced produce VBN 40436 6480 37 by by IN 40436 6480 38 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6480 39 , , , 40436 6480 40 but but CC 40436 6480 41 is be VBZ 40436 6480 42 combated combat VBN 40436 6480 43 at at IN 40436 6480 44 length length NN 40436 6480 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6480 46 as as IN 40436 6480 47 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6480 48 shall shall MD 40436 6480 49 presently presently RB 40436 6480 50 see see VB 40436 6480 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6480 52 by by IN 40436 6480 53 a a DT 40436 6480 54 counter counter NN 40436 6480 55 - - NN 40436 6480 56 argument argument NN 40436 6480 57 on on IN 40436 6480 58 the the DT 40436 6480 59 part part NN 40436 6480 60 of of IN 40436 6480 61 the the DT 40436 6480 62 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6480 63 , , , 40436 6480 64 without without IN 40436 6480 65 any any DT 40436 6480 66 rejoinder rejoinder NN 40436 6480 67 from from IN 40436 6480 68 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6480 69 . . . 40436 6481 1 Of of IN 40436 6481 2 this this DT 40436 6481 3 counter counter NN 40436 6481 4 - - NN 40436 6481 5 argument argument JJ 40436 6481 6 no no DT 40436 6481 7 notice notice NN 40436 6481 8 is be VBZ 40436 6481 9 taken take VBN 40436 6481 10 in in IN 40436 6481 11 the the DT 40436 6481 12 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6481 13 : : : 40436 6481 14 although although IN 40436 6481 15 , , , 40436 6481 16 if if IN 40436 6481 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6481 18 be be VB 40436 6481 19 well well RB 40436 6481 20 - - HYPH 40436 6481 21 founded found VBN 40436 6481 22 , , , 40436 6481 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6481 24 would would MD 40436 6481 25 have have VB 40436 6481 26 served serve VBN 40436 6481 27 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6481 28 no no RB 40436 6481 29 less less JJR 40436 6481 30 than than IN 40436 6481 31 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6481 32 , , , 40436 6481 33 as as IN 40436 6481 34 a a DT 40436 6481 35 solution solution NN 40436 6481 36 of of IN 40436 6481 37 the the DT 40436 6481 38 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 6481 39 raised raise VBN 40436 6481 40 by by IN 40436 6481 41 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6481 42 . . . 40436 6482 1 Such such JJ 40436 6482 2 diversity diversity NN 40436 6482 3 of of IN 40436 6482 4 handling handling NN 40436 6482 5 and and CC 40436 6482 6 argumentative argumentative JJ 40436 6482 7 fertility fertility NN 40436 6482 8 , , , 40436 6482 9 are be VBP 40436 6482 10 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 6482 11 of of IN 40436 6482 12 the the DT 40436 6482 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6482 14 procedure procedure NN 40436 6482 15 . . . 40436 6483 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6483 2 have have VBP 40436 6483 3 already already RB 40436 6483 4 remarked remark VBN 40436 6483 5 , , , 40436 6483 6 that that IN 40436 6483 7 the the DT 40436 6483 8 establishment establishment NN 40436 6483 9 of of IN 40436 6483 10 positive positive JJ 40436 6483 11 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 6483 12 , , , 40436 6483 13 capable capable JJ 40436 6483 14 of of IN 40436 6483 15 being be VBG 40436 6483 16 severed sever VBN 40436 6483 17 from from IN 40436 6483 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6483 19 premisses premiss NNS 40436 6483 20 , , , 40436 6483 21 registered register VBN 40436 6483 22 in in IN 40436 6483 23 the the DT 40436 6483 24 memory memory NN 40436 6483 25 , , , 40436 6483 26 and and CC 40436 6483 27 used use VBN 40436 6483 28 as as IN 40436 6483 29 principles principle NNS 40436 6483 30 for for IN 40436 6483 31 deduction deduction NN 40436 6483 32 -- -- : 40436 6483 33 is be VBZ 40436 6483 34 foreign foreign JJ 40436 6483 35 to to IN 40436 6483 36 the the DT 40436 6483 37 spirit spirit NN 40436 6483 38 of of IN 40436 6483 39 these these DT 40436 6483 40 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6483 41 of of IN 40436 6483 42 Search Search NNP 40436 6483 43 . . . 40436 6484 1 To to TO 40436 6484 2 settle settle VB 40436 6484 3 a a DT 40436 6484 4 question question NN 40436 6484 5 and and CC 40436 6484 6 finish finish NN 40436 6484 7 with with IN 40436 6484 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6484 9 -- -- : 40436 6484 10 to to TO 40436 6484 11 get get VB 40436 6484 12 rid rid VBN 40436 6484 13 of of IN 40436 6484 14 the the DT 40436 6484 15 debate debate NN 40436 6484 16 , , , 40436 6484 17 as as IN 40436 6484 18 if if IN 40436 6484 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6484 20 were be VBD 40436 6484 21 a a DT 40436 6484 22 troublesome troublesome JJ 40436 6484 23 temporary temporary JJ 40436 6484 24 necessity necessity NN 40436 6484 25 -- -- : 40436 6484 26 is be VBZ 40436 6484 27 not not RB 40436 6484 28 what what WP 40436 6484 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6484 30 desires desire NNS 40436 6484 31 . . . 40436 6485 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6485 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 6485 3 is be VBZ 40436 6485 4 , , , 40436 6485 5 to to TO 40436 6485 6 provoke provoke VB 40436 6485 7 the the DT 40436 6485 8 spirit spirit NN 40436 6485 9 of of IN 40436 6485 10 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 6485 11 -- -- : 40436 6485 12 to to TO 40436 6485 13 stimulate stimulate VB 40436 6485 14 responsive responsive JJ 40436 6485 15 efforts effort NNS 40436 6485 16 of of IN 40436 6485 17 the the DT 40436 6485 18 mind mind NN 40436 6485 19 by by IN 40436 6485 20 a a DT 40436 6485 21 painful painful JJ 40436 6485 22 shock shock NN 40436 6485 23 of of IN 40436 6485 24 exposed expose VBN 40436 6485 25 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6485 26 -- -- : 40436 6485 27 and and CC 40436 6485 28 to to TO 40436 6485 29 open open VB 40436 6485 30 before before IN 40436 6485 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6485 32 a a DT 40436 6485 33 multiplicity multiplicity NN 40436 6485 34 of of IN 40436 6485 35 new new JJ 40436 6485 36 roads road NNS 40436 6485 37 with with IN 40436 6485 38 varied varied JJ 40436 6485 39 points point NNS 40436 6485 40 of of IN 40436 6485 41 view view NN 40436 6485 42 . . . 40436 6486 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6486 2 Side side NN 40436 6486 3 - - HYPH 40436 6486 4 note note NN 40436 6486 5 : : : 40436 6486 6 Anxiety anxiety NN 40436 6486 7 of of IN 40436 6486 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6486 9 to to TO 40436 6486 10 keep keep VB 40436 6486 11 up up RP 40436 6486 12 and and CC 40436 6486 13 enforce enforce VB 40436 6486 14 the the DT 40436 6486 15 spirit spirit NN 40436 6486 16 of of IN 40436 6486 17 research research NN 40436 6486 18 . . . 40436 6486 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6487 1 Nowhere nowhere RB 40436 6487 2 in in IN 40436 6487 3 the the DT 40436 6487 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6487 5 writings writing NNS 40436 6487 6 is be VBZ 40436 6487 7 this this DT 40436 6487 8 provocative provocative JJ 40436 6487 9 shock shock NN 40436 6487 10 more more RBR 40436 6487 11 vividly vividly RB 40436 6487 12 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 6487 13 than than IN 40436 6487 14 in in IN 40436 6487 15 the the DT 40436 6487 16 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6487 17 , , , 40436 6487 18 by by IN 40436 6487 19 the the DT 40436 6487 20 simile simile NN 40436 6487 21 of of IN 40436 6487 22 the the DT 40436 6487 23 electrical electrical JJ 40436 6487 24 fish fish NN 40436 6487 25 : : : 40436 6487 26 a a DT 40436 6487 27 simile simile NN 40436 6487 28 as as IN 40436 6487 29 striking striking JJ 40436 6487 30 as as IN 40436 6487 31 that that DT 40436 6487 32 of of IN 40436 6487 33 the the DT 40436 6487 34 magnet magnet NN 40436 6487 35 in in IN 40436 6487 36 Ion Ion NNP 40436 6487 37 . . . 40436 6488 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6488 2 37 37 CD 40436 6488 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6488 4 Nowhere nowhere RB 40436 6488 5 , , , 40436 6488 6 again again RB 40436 6488 7 , , , 40436 6488 8 is be VBZ 40436 6488 9 the the DT 40436 6488 10 true true JJ 40436 6488 11 character character NN 40436 6488 12 of of IN 40436 6488 13 the the DT 40436 6488 14 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 6488 15 intellect intellect NN 40436 6488 16 more more RBR 40436 6488 17 clearly clearly RB 40436 6488 18 enunciated enunciate VBN 40436 6488 19 . . . 40436 6489 1 " " `` 40436 6489 2 You -PRON- PRP 40436 6489 3 complain complain VBP 40436 6489 4 , , , 40436 6489 5 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6489 6 , , , 40436 6489 7 that that IN 40436 6489 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6489 9 plunge plunge VBP 40436 6489 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6489 11 mind mind NN 40436 6489 12 into into IN 40436 6489 13 nothing nothing NN 40436 6489 14 but but IN 40436 6489 15 doubt doubt NN 40436 6489 16 , , , 40436 6489 17 and and CC 40436 6489 18 puzzle puzzle NNP 40436 6489 19 , , , 40436 6489 20 and and CC 40436 6489 21 conscious conscious JJ 40436 6489 22 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6489 23 . . . 40436 6490 1 If if IN 40436 6490 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6490 3 do do VBP 40436 6490 4 this this DT 40436 6490 5 , , , 40436 6490 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6490 7 is be VBZ 40436 6490 8 only only RB 40436 6490 9 because because IN 40436 6490 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6490 11 own own JJ 40436 6490 12 mind mind NN 40436 6490 13 is be VBZ 40436 6490 14 already already RB 40436 6490 15 in in IN 40436 6490 16 that that DT 40436 6490 17 same same JJ 40436 6490 18 condition condition NN 40436 6490 19 . . . 40436 6491 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6491 2 38 38 CD 40436 6491 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6491 4 The the DT 40436 6491 5 only only JJ 40436 6491 6 way way NN 40436 6491 7 out out IN 40436 6491 8 of of IN 40436 6491 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6491 10 is be VBZ 40436 6491 11 , , , 40436 6491 12 through through IN 40436 6491 13 joint joint JJ 40436 6491 14 dialectical dialectical JJ 40436 6491 15 colloquy colloquy NN 40436 6491 16 and and CC 40436 6491 17 search search NN 40436 6491 18 ; ; : 40436 6491 19 in in IN 40436 6491 20 which which WDT 40436 6491 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6491 22 invite invite VBP 40436 6491 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6491 24 to to TO 40436 6491 25 accompany accompany VB 40436 6491 26 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6491 27 , , , 40436 6491 28 though though IN 40436 6491 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6491 30 do do VBP 40436 6491 31 not not RB 40436 6491 32 know know VB 40436 6491 33 when when WRB 40436 6491 34 or or CC 40436 6491 35 where where WRB 40436 6491 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6491 37 will will MD 40436 6491 38 end end VB 40436 6491 39 . . . 40436 6491 40 " " '' 40436 6492 1 And and CC 40436 6492 2 then then RB 40436 6492 3 , , , 40436 6492 4 for for IN 40436 6492 5 the the DT 40436 6492 6 purpose purpose NN 40436 6492 7 of of IN 40436 6492 8 justifying justify VBG 40436 6492 9 as as RB 40436 6492 10 well well RB 40436 6492 11 as as IN 40436 6492 12 encouraging encourage VBG 40436 6492 13 such such JJ 40436 6492 14 prolonged prolong VBN 40436 6492 15 search search NN 40436 6492 16 , , , 40436 6492 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6492 18 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 6492 19 to to TO 40436 6492 20 unfold unfold VB 40436 6492 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6492 22 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 6492 23 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 6492 24 -- -- : 40436 6492 25 eternal eternal JJ 40436 6492 26 pre pre NN 40436 6492 27 - - NN 40436 6492 28 existence existence NN 40436 6492 29 , , , 40436 6492 30 boundless boundless JJ 40436 6492 31 past past JJ 40436 6492 32 experience experience NN 40436 6492 33 , , , 40436 6492 34 and and CC 40436 6492 35 omniscience omniscience NN 40436 6492 36 , , , 40436 6492 37 of of IN 40436 6492 38 the the DT 40436 6492 39 mind mind NN 40436 6492 40 -- -- : 40436 6492 41 identity identity NN 40436 6492 42 of of IN 40436 6492 43 cognition cognition NN 40436 6492 44 with with IN 40436 6492 45 recognition recognition NN 40436 6492 46 , , , 40436 6492 47 dependent dependent JJ 40436 6492 48 on on IN 40436 6492 49 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6492 50 . . . 40436 6493 1 " " `` 40436 6493 2 Research research NN 40436 6493 3 or or CC 40436 6493 4 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 6493 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6493 6 said say VBD 40436 6493 7 some some DT 40436 6493 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6493 9 is be VBZ 40436 6493 10 fruitless fruitless JJ 40436 6493 11 . . . 40436 6494 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 6494 2 must must MD 40436 6494 3 search search VB 40436 6494 4 either either CC 40436 6494 5 for for IN 40436 6494 6 that that DT 40436 6494 7 which which WDT 40436 6494 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6494 9 know know VBP 40436 6494 10 , , , 40436 6494 11 or or CC 40436 6494 12 for for IN 40436 6494 13 that that DT 40436 6494 14 which which WDT 40436 6494 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6494 16 do do VBP 40436 6494 17 not not RB 40436 6494 18 know know VB 40436 6494 19 . . . 40436 6495 1 The the DT 40436 6495 2 first first JJ 40436 6495 3 is be VBZ 40436 6495 4 superfluous superfluous JJ 40436 6495 5 -- -- : 40436 6495 6 the the DT 40436 6495 7 second second JJ 40436 6495 8 impossible impossible JJ 40436 6495 9 : : : 40436 6495 10 for for IN 40436 6495 11 if if IN 40436 6495 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6495 13 do do VBP 40436 6495 14 not not RB 40436 6495 15 know know VB 40436 6495 16 what what WP 40436 6495 17 a a DT 40436 6495 18 thing thing NN 40436 6495 19 is be VBZ 40436 6495 20 , , , 40436 6495 21 how how WRB 40436 6495 22 are be VBP 40436 6495 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6495 24 to to TO 40436 6495 25 be be VB 40436 6495 26 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 6495 27 that that IN 40436 6495 28 the the DT 40436 6495 29 answer answer NN 40436 6495 30 which which WDT 40436 6495 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6495 32 find find VBP 40436 6495 33 is be VBZ 40436 6495 34 that that IN 40436 6495 35 which which WDT 40436 6495 36 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6495 37 are be VBP 40436 6495 38 looking look VBG 40436 6495 39 for for IN 40436 6495 40 ? ? . 40436 6496 1 How how WRB 40436 6496 2 can can MD 40436 6496 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6496 4 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 6496 5 a a DT 40436 6496 6 true true JJ 40436 6496 7 solution solution NN 40436 6496 8 from from IN 40436 6496 9 another another DT 40436 6496 10 which which WDT 40436 6496 11 is be VBZ 40436 6496 12 untrue untrue JJ 40436 6496 13 , , , 40436 6496 14 but but CC 40436 6496 15 plausible plausible JJ 40436 6496 16 ? ? . 40436 6496 17 " " '' 40436 6497 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6497 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6497 3 37 37 CD 40436 6497 4 : : : 40436 6497 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6497 6 , , , 40436 6497 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6497 8 , , , 40436 6497 9 p. p. NN 40436 6497 10 80 80 CD 40436 6497 11 A. a. NN 40436 6498 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6498 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6498 3 : : : 40436 6498 4 na na IN 40436 6498 5 / / SYM 40436 6498 6 rkê rkê NNS 40436 6498 7 thalassi thalassi NNP 40436 6498 8 / / SYM 40436 6498 9 a a NN 40436 6498 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6498 11 . . . 40436 6499 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6499 2 what what WP 40436 6499 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6499 4 have have VBP 40436 6499 5 said say VBD 40436 6499 6 above above IN 40436 6499 7 about about IN 40436 6499 8 the the DT 40436 6499 9 Ion Ion NNP 40436 6499 10 , , , 40436 6499 11 ch ch NN 40436 6499 12 . . . 40436 6500 1 XVII XVII NNP 40436 6500 2 . . NNP 40436 6500 3 , , , 40436 6500 4 p. p. NN 40436 6501 1 128 128 CD 40436 6501 2 . . . 40436 6501 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6502 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6502 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6502 3 38 38 CD 40436 6502 4 : : : 40436 6502 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6502 6 , , , 40436 6502 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6502 8 , , , 40436 6502 9 p. p. NN 40436 6502 10 80 80 CD 40436 6502 11 D. D. NNP 40436 6502 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6502 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6502 14 Side side NN 40436 6502 15 - - HYPH 40436 6502 16 note note NN 40436 6502 17 : : : 40436 6502 18 Great great JJ 40436 6502 19 question question NN 40436 6502 20 discussed discuss VBN 40436 6502 21 among among IN 40436 6502 22 the the DT 40436 6502 23 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 6502 24 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 6502 25 -- -- : 40436 6502 26 criterion criterion NN 40436 6502 27 of of IN 40436 6502 28 truth truth NN 40436 6502 29 -- -- . 40436 6502 30 Wherein wherein WRB 40436 6502 31 consists consist VBZ 40436 6502 32 the the DT 40436 6502 33 process process NN 40436 6502 34 of of IN 40436 6502 35 verification verification NN 40436 6502 36 ? ? . 40436 6502 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6503 1 Here here RB 40436 6503 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6503 3 find find VBP 40436 6503 4 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 6503 5 raised raise VBN 40436 6503 6 , , , 40436 6503 7 for for IN 40436 6503 8 the the DT 40436 6503 9 first first JJ 40436 6503 10 time time NN 40436 6503 11 , , , 40436 6503 12 that that DT 40436 6503 13 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 6503 14 which which WDT 40436 6503 15 embarrassed embarrass VBD 40436 6503 16 the the DT 40436 6503 17 different different JJ 40436 6503 18 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 6503 19 schools school NNS 40436 6503 20 in in IN 40436 6503 21 Greece Greece NNP 40436 6503 22 for for IN 40436 6503 23 the the DT 40436 6503 24 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 6503 25 three three CD 40436 6503 26 centuries century NNS 40436 6503 27 -- -- : 40436 6503 28 What what WP 40436 6503 29 is be VBZ 40436 6503 30 the the DT 40436 6503 31 criterion criterion NN 40436 6503 32 of of IN 40436 6503 33 truth truth NN 40436 6503 34 ? ? . 40436 6504 1 Wherein wherein WRB 40436 6504 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 6504 3 the the DT 40436 6504 4 process process NN 40436 6504 5 called call VBN 40436 6504 6 verification verification NN 40436 6504 7 and and CC 40436 6504 8 proof proof NN 40436 6504 9 , , , 40436 6504 10 of of IN 40436 6504 11 that that DT 40436 6504 12 which which WDT 40436 6504 13 is be VBZ 40436 6504 14 first first RB 40436 6504 15 presented present VBN 40436 6504 16 as as IN 40436 6504 17 an an DT 40436 6504 18 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 6504 19 ? ? . 40436 6505 1 This this DT 40436 6505 2 was be VBD 40436 6505 3 one one CD 40436 6505 4 of of IN 40436 6505 5 the the DT 40436 6505 6 great great JJ 40436 6505 7 problems problem NNS 40436 6505 8 debated debate VBN 40436 6505 9 between between IN 40436 6505 10 the the DT 40436 6505 11 Academics Academics NNPS 40436 6505 12 , , , 40436 6505 13 the the DT 40436 6505 14 Stoics Stoics NNPS 40436 6505 15 , , , 40436 6505 16 and and CC 40436 6505 17 the the DT 40436 6505 18 Sceptics Sceptics NNPS 40436 6505 19 , , , 40436 6505 20 until until IN 40436 6505 21 the the DT 40436 6505 22 extinction extinction NN 40436 6505 23 of of IN 40436 6505 24 the the DT 40436 6505 25 schools school NNS 40436 6505 26 of of IN 40436 6505 27 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6505 28 . . . 40436 6506 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6506 2 39 39 CD 40436 6506 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6506 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6506 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6506 6 39 39 CD 40436 6506 7 : : : 40436 6506 8 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6506 9 here here RB 40436 6506 10 calls call VBZ 40436 6506 11 this this DT 40436 6506 12 problem problem NN 40436 6506 13 an an DT 40436 6506 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6506 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6506 16 : : : 40436 6506 17 e)ristiko\s e)ristiko\s VB 40436 6506 18 lo lo NNP 40436 6506 19 / / SYM 40436 6506 20 gos gos NNP 40436 6506 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6506 22 . . . 40436 6507 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6507 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6507 3 in in IN 40436 6507 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6507 5 Prolegom Prolegom NNP 40436 6507 6 . . . 40436 6508 1 to to IN 40436 6508 2 the the DT 40436 6508 3 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6508 4 , , , 40436 6508 5 p. p. NN 40436 6508 6 14 14 CD 40436 6508 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6508 8 describes describe VBZ 40436 6508 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6508 10 as as IN 40436 6508 11 a a DT 40436 6508 12 " " `` 40436 6508 13 quæstiunculam quæstiunculam JJ 40436 6508 14 , , , 40436 6508 15 haud haud VB 40436 6508 16 dubie dubie NNP 40436 6508 17 e e NNP 40436 6508 18 sophistarum sophistarum NNP 40436 6508 19 disciplinâ disciplinâ NN 40436 6508 20 arreptam arreptam NNS 40436 6508 21 " " '' 40436 6508 22 . . . 40436 6509 1 If if IN 40436 6509 2 the the DT 40436 6509 3 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6509 4 were be VBD 40436 6509 5 the the DT 40436 6509 6 first first JJ 40436 6509 7 to to TO 40436 6509 8 raise raise VB 40436 6509 9 this this DT 40436 6509 10 question question NN 40436 6509 11 , , , 40436 6509 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6509 13 think think VBP 40436 6509 14 that that IN 40436 6509 15 by by IN 40436 6509 16 doing do VBG 40436 6509 17 so so RB 40436 6509 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6509 19 rendered render VBD 40436 6509 20 service service NN 40436 6509 21 to to IN 40436 6509 22 the the DT 40436 6509 23 interests interest NNS 40436 6509 24 of of IN 40436 6509 25 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6509 26 . . . 40436 6510 1 The the DT 40436 6510 2 question question NN 40436 6510 3 is be VBZ 40436 6510 4 among among IN 40436 6510 5 the the DT 40436 6510 6 first first JJ 40436 6510 7 which which WDT 40436 6510 8 ought ought MD 40436 6510 9 to to TO 40436 6510 10 be be VB 40436 6510 11 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 6510 12 debated debate VBN 40436 6510 13 and and CC 40436 6510 14 sifted sift VBN 40436 6510 15 , , , 40436 6510 16 if if IN 40436 6510 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6510 18 are be VBP 40436 6510 19 to to TO 40436 6510 20 have have VB 40436 6510 21 a a DT 40436 6510 22 body body NN 40436 6510 23 of of IN 40436 6510 24 " " `` 40436 6510 25 reasoned reasoned JJ 40436 6510 26 truth truth NN 40436 6510 27 " " '' 40436 6510 28 called call VBN 40436 6510 29 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6510 30 . . . 40436 6511 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6511 2 dissent dissent VBP 40436 6511 3 from from IN 40436 6511 4 the the DT 40436 6511 5 opinion opinion NN 40436 6511 6 of of IN 40436 6511 7 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6511 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6511 9 p. p. NN 40436 6511 10 20 20 CD 40436 6511 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6511 12 , , , 40436 6511 13 though though IN 40436 6511 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6511 15 is be VBZ 40436 6511 16 adopted adopt VBN 40436 6511 17 both both CC 40436 6511 18 by by IN 40436 6511 19 Socher Socher NNP 40436 6511 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6511 21 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 6511 22 Platon Platon NNP 40436 6511 23 , , , 40436 6511 24 p. p. NN 40436 6511 25 185 185 CD 40436 6511 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6511 27 and and CC 40436 6511 28 by by IN 40436 6511 29 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 6511 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6511 31 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 6511 32 zum zum VB 40436 6511 33 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6511 34 , , , 40436 6511 35 p. p. NN 40436 6511 36 123 123 CD 40436 6511 37 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6511 38 , , , 40436 6511 39 that that IN 40436 6511 40 the the DT 40436 6511 41 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6511 42 was be VBD 40436 6511 43 composed compose VBN 40436 6511 44 by by IN 40436 6511 45 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6511 46 during during IN 40436 6511 47 the the DT 40436 6511 48 lifetime lifetime NN 40436 6511 49 of of IN 40436 6511 50 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6511 51 . . . 40436 6512 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6512 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6512 3 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 6512 4 zum zum VB 40436 6512 5 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6512 6 , , , 40436 6512 7 p. p. NN 40436 6512 8 22 22 CD 40436 6512 9 ; ; : 40436 6512 10 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 6512 11 zum zum VB 40436 6512 12 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6512 13 , , , 40436 6512 14 pp pp NNP 40436 6512 15 . . . 40436 6513 1 329 329 CD 40436 6513 2 - - SYM 40436 6513 3 330 330 CD 40436 6513 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6513 5 , , , 40436 6513 6 Ueberweg Ueberweg NNP 40436 6513 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6513 8 Aechth Aechth NNP 40436 6513 9 . . . 40436 6514 1 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6514 2 . . . 40436 6515 1 Schr Schr NNP 40436 6515 2 . . . 40436 6516 1 p. p. NN 40436 6516 2 226 226 CD 40436 6516 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6516 4 , , , 40436 6516 5 and and CC 40436 6516 6 K. K. NNP 40436 6516 7 F. F. NNP 40436 6516 8 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 6516 9 , , , 40436 6516 10 on on IN 40436 6516 11 the the DT 40436 6516 12 other other JJ 40436 6516 13 hand hand NN 40436 6516 14 , , , 40436 6516 15 regard regard VB 40436 6516 16 the the DT 40436 6516 17 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6516 18 as as IN 40436 6516 19 composed compose VBN 40436 6516 20 after after IN 40436 6516 21 the the DT 40436 6516 22 death death NN 40436 6516 23 of of IN 40436 6516 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6516 25 , , , 40436 6516 26 and and CC 40436 6516 27 on on IN 40436 6516 28 this this DT 40436 6516 29 point point NN 40436 6516 30 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6516 31 agree agree VBP 40436 6516 32 with with IN 40436 6516 33 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6516 34 , , , 40436 6516 35 though though IN 40436 6516 36 whether whether IN 40436 6516 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6516 38 was be VBD 40436 6516 39 composed compose VBN 40436 6516 40 not not RB 40436 6516 41 long long RB 40436 6516 42 after after IN 40436 6516 43 that that DT 40436 6516 44 event event NN 40436 6516 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6516 46 as as IN 40436 6516 47 K. K. NNP 40436 6516 48 F. F. NNP 40436 6516 49 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 6516 50 thinks think VBZ 40436 6516 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6516 52 or or CC 40436 6516 53 thirteen thirteen CD 40436 6516 54 years year NNS 40436 6516 55 after after IN 40436 6516 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6516 57 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6516 58 as as IN 40436 6516 59 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6516 60 thinks think VBZ 40436 6516 61 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6516 62 , , , 40436 6516 63 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6516 64 see see VBP 40436 6516 65 no no DT 40436 6516 66 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 6516 67 grounds ground NNS 40436 6516 68 for for IN 40436 6516 69 deciding decide VBG 40436 6516 70 . . . 40436 6517 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6517 2 incline incline VBP 40436 6517 3 to to IN 40436 6517 4 the the DT 40436 6517 5 belief belief NN 40436 6517 6 that that IN 40436 6517 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6517 8 composition composition NN 40436 6517 9 is be VBZ 40436 6517 10 considerably considerably RB 40436 6517 11 later late JJR 40436 6517 12 than than IN 40436 6517 13 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 6517 14 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 6517 15 ; ; : 40436 6517 16 the the DT 40436 6517 17 mention mention NN 40436 6517 18 of of IN 40436 6517 19 the the DT 40436 6517 20 Theban Theban NNP 40436 6517 21 Ismenias Ismenias NNP 40436 6517 22 is be VBZ 40436 6517 23 one one CD 40436 6517 24 among among IN 40436 6517 25 the the DT 40436 6517 26 reasons reason NNS 40436 6517 27 rendering render VBG 40436 6517 28 such such JJ 40436 6517 29 later later JJ 40436 6517 30 origin origin NN 40436 6517 31 probable probable JJ 40436 6517 32 . . . 40436 6518 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6518 2 probably probably RB 40436 6518 3 borrowed borrow VBD 40436 6518 4 from from IN 40436 6518 5 the the DT 40436 6518 6 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 6518 7 Anabasis Anabasis NNP 40436 6518 8 the the DT 40436 6518 9 name name NN 40436 6518 10 , , , 40436 6518 11 country country NN 40436 6518 12 , , , 40436 6518 13 and and CC 40436 6518 14 social social JJ 40436 6518 15 position position NN 40436 6518 16 of of IN 40436 6518 17 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6518 18 , , , 40436 6518 19 who who WP 40436 6518 20 may may MD 40436 6518 21 have have VB 40436 6518 22 received receive VBN 40436 6518 23 teaching teach VBG 40436 6518 24 from from IN 40436 6518 25 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6518 26 , , , 40436 6518 27 as as IN 40436 6518 28 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6518 29 know know VBP 40436 6518 30 that that IN 40436 6518 31 Proxenus Proxenus NNP 40436 6518 32 did do VBD 40436 6518 33 , , , 40436 6518 34 Xen Xen NNP 40436 6518 35 . . . 40436 6519 1 Anab anab UH 40436 6519 2 . . . 40436 6520 1 ii ii LS 40436 6520 2 . . . 40436 6521 1 6 6 CD 40436 6521 2 , , , 40436 6521 3 16 16 CD 40436 6521 4 . . . 40436 6522 1 The the DT 40436 6522 2 reader reader NN 40436 6522 3 can can MD 40436 6522 4 compare compare VB 40436 6522 5 the the DT 40436 6522 6 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 6522 7 of of IN 40436 6522 8 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6522 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6522 10 in in IN 40436 6522 11 which which WDT 40436 6522 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6522 13 professes profess VBZ 40436 6522 14 to to TO 40436 6522 15 prove prove VB 40436 6522 16 that that IN 40436 6522 17 the the DT 40436 6522 18 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6522 19 is be VBZ 40436 6522 20 a a DT 40436 6522 21 corollary corollary NN 40436 6522 22 to to IN 40436 6522 23 the the DT 40436 6522 24 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 6522 25 and and CC 40436 6522 26 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6522 27 , , , 40436 6522 28 and and CC 40436 6522 29 an an DT 40436 6522 30 immediate immediate JJ 40436 6522 31 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 6522 32 to to IN 40436 6522 33 the the DT 40436 6522 34 Euthydêmus,--that euthydêmus,--that NN 40436 6522 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6522 36 solves solve VBZ 40436 6522 37 the the DT 40436 6522 38 riddle riddle NN 40436 6522 39 of of IN 40436 6522 40 the the DT 40436 6522 41 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 6522 42 -- -- : 40436 6522 43 and and CC 40436 6522 44 that that IN 40436 6522 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6522 46 presupposes presuppose VBZ 40436 6522 47 and and CC 40436 6522 48 refers refer VBZ 40436 6522 49 back back RB 40436 6522 50 to to IN 40436 6522 51 the the DT 40436 6522 52 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6522 53 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6522 54 with with IN 40436 6522 55 the the DT 40436 6522 56 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 6522 57 of of IN 40436 6522 58 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 6522 59 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6522 60 p. p. NN 40436 6522 61 120 120 CD 40436 6522 62 seq seq NN 40436 6522 63 . . . 40436 6523 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6523 2 , , , 40436 6523 3 who who WP 40436 6523 4 contests contest VBZ 40436 6523 5 all all PDT 40436 6523 6 these these DT 40436 6523 7 propositions proposition NNS 40436 6523 8 , , , 40436 6523 9 saying say VBG 40436 6523 10 that that IN 40436 6523 11 the the DT 40436 6523 12 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6523 13 is be VBZ 40436 6523 14 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 6523 15 later later RB 40436 6523 16 than than IN 40436 6523 17 the the DT 40436 6523 18 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 6523 19 , , , 40436 6523 20 and and CC 40436 6523 21 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 6523 22 earlier early RBR 40436 6523 23 than than IN 40436 6523 24 the the DT 40436 6523 25 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 6523 26 , , , 40436 6523 27 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6523 28 , , , 40436 6523 29 and and CC 40436 6523 30 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6523 31 ; ; : 40436 6523 32 with with IN 40436 6523 33 the the DT 40436 6523 34 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6523 35 of of IN 40436 6523 36 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6523 37 and and CC 40436 6523 38 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 6523 39 , , , 40436 6523 40 who who WP 40436 6523 41 recognise recognise VBP 40436 6523 42 an an DT 40436 6523 43 order order NN 40436 6523 44 different different JJ 40436 6523 45 from from IN 40436 6523 46 that that DT 40436 6523 47 either either DT 40436 6523 48 of of IN 40436 6523 49 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 6523 50 or or CC 40436 6523 51 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6523 52 ; ; : 40436 6523 53 and and CC 40436 6523 54 with with IN 40436 6523 55 that that DT 40436 6523 56 of of IN 40436 6523 57 Ast Ast NNP 40436 6523 58 , , , 40436 6523 59 who who WP 40436 6523 60 rejects reject VBZ 40436 6523 61 the the DT 40436 6523 62 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6523 63 altogether altogether RB 40436 6523 64 as as IN 40436 6523 65 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 6523 66 of of IN 40436 6523 67 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6523 68 . . . 40436 6524 1 Every every DT 40436 6524 2 one one CD 40436 6524 3 of of IN 40436 6524 4 these these DT 40436 6524 5 dissentient dissentient JJ 40436 6524 6 critics critic NNS 40436 6524 7 has have VBZ 40436 6524 8 _ _ NNP 40436 6524 9 something something NN 40436 6524 10 _ _ NNP 40436 6524 11 to to TO 40436 6524 12 say say VB 40436 6524 13 for for IN 40436 6524 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6524 15 opinion opinion NN 40436 6524 16 , , , 40436 6524 17 while while IN 40436 6524 18 none none NN 40436 6524 19 of of IN 40436 6524 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6524 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6524 22 in in IN 40436 6524 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6524 24 judgment judgment NN 40436 6524 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6524 26 can can MD 40436 6524 27 make make VB 40436 6524 28 out out RP 40436 6524 29 anything anything NN 40436 6524 30 like like IN 40436 6524 31 a a DT 40436 6524 32 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 6524 33 case case NN 40436 6524 34 . . . 40436 6525 1 The the DT 40436 6525 2 mistake mistake NN 40436 6525 3 consists consist VBZ 40436 6525 4 in in IN 40436 6525 5 assuming assume VBG 40436 6525 6 that that IN 40436 6525 7 there there EX 40436 6525 8 must must MD 40436 6525 9 have have VB 40436 6525 10 been be VBN 40436 6525 11 a a DT 40436 6525 12 peremptory peremptory JJ 40436 6525 13 order order NN 40436 6525 14 and and CC 40436 6525 15 intentional intentional JJ 40436 6525 16 interdependence interdependence NN 40436 6525 17 among among IN 40436 6525 18 the the DT 40436 6525 19 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6525 20 Dialogues Dialogues NNPS 40436 6525 21 , , , 40436 6525 22 and and CC 40436 6525 23 next next RB 40436 6525 24 in in IN 40436 6525 25 trying try VBG 40436 6525 26 to to TO 40436 6525 27 show show VB 40436 6525 28 by by IN 40436 6525 29 internal internal JJ 40436 6525 30 evidence evidence NN 40436 6525 31 what what WP 40436 6525 32 that that DT 40436 6525 33 order order NN 40436 6525 34 was be VBD 40436 6525 35 . . . 40436 6525 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6526 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6526 2 Side side NN 40436 6526 3 - - HYPH 40436 6526 4 note note NN 40436 6526 5 : : : 40436 6526 6 None none NN 40436 6526 7 of of IN 40436 6526 8 the the DT 40436 6526 9 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 6526 10 were be VBD 40436 6526 11 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 6526 12 with with IN 40436 6526 13 the the DT 40436 6526 14 answer answer NN 40436 6526 15 here here RB 40436 6526 16 made make VBN 40436 6526 17 by by IN 40436 6526 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6526 19 -- -- : 40436 6526 20 that that IN 40436 6526 21 verification verification NN 40436 6526 22 consists consist VBZ 40436 6526 23 in in IN 40436 6526 24 appeal appeal NN 40436 6526 25 to to IN 40436 6526 26 pre pre JJ 40436 6526 27 - - JJ 40436 6526 28 natal natal JJ 40436 6526 29 experience experience NN 40436 6526 30 . . . 40436 6526 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6527 1 Not not RB 40436 6527 2 one one CD 40436 6527 3 of of IN 40436 6527 4 these these DT 40436 6527 5 schools school NNS 40436 6527 6 was be VBD 40436 6527 7 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 6527 8 with with IN 40436 6527 9 the the DT 40436 6527 10 very very RB 40436 6527 11 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 6527 12 answer answer NN 40436 6527 13 which which WDT 40436 6527 14 the the DT 40436 6527 15 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6527 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6527 17 here here RB 40436 6527 18 gives give VBZ 40436 6527 19 to to IN 40436 6527 20 the the DT 40436 6527 21 question question NN 40436 6527 22 . . . 40436 6528 1 When when WRB 40436 6528 2 truth truth NN 40436 6528 3 is be VBZ 40436 6528 4 presented present VBN 40436 6528 5 to to IN 40436 6528 6 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6528 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6528 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6528 9 intimates intimate VBZ 40436 6528 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6528 11 , , , 40436 6528 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6528 13 recognise recognise VBP 40436 6528 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6528 15 as as IN 40436 6528 16 an an DT 40436 6528 17 old old JJ 40436 6528 18 friend friend NN 40436 6528 19 after after IN 40436 6528 20 a a DT 40436 6528 21 long long JJ 40436 6528 22 absence absence NN 40436 6528 23 . . . 40436 6529 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6529 2 know know VBP 40436 6529 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6529 4 by by IN 40436 6529 5 reason reason NN 40436 6529 6 of of IN 40436 6529 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6529 8 conformity conformity NN 40436 6529 9 to to IN 40436 6529 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6529 11 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 6529 12 , , , 40436 6529 13 pre pre JJ 40436 6529 14 - - JJ 40436 6529 15 natal natal JJ 40436 6529 16 , , , 40436 6529 17 experience experience NN 40436 6529 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6529 19 in in IN 40436 6529 20 the the DT 40436 6529 21 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 6529 22 , , , 40436 6529 23 such such JJ 40436 6529 24 pre pre JJ 40436 6529 25 - - JJ 40436 6529 26 natal natal JJ 40436 6529 27 experience experience NN 40436 6529 28 is be VBZ 40436 6529 29 restricted restrict VBN 40436 6529 30 to to TO 40436 6529 31 commerce commerce VB 40436 6529 32 with with IN 40436 6529 33 the the DT 40436 6529 34 substantial substantial JJ 40436 6529 35 , , , 40436 6529 36 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 6529 37 , , , 40436 6529 38 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 6529 39 , , , 40436 6529 40 which which WDT 40436 6529 41 are be VBP 40436 6529 42 not not RB 40436 6529 43 mentioned mention VBN 40436 6529 44 in in IN 40436 6529 45 the the DT 40436 6529 46 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6529 47 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6529 48 : : : 40436 6529 49 the the DT 40436 6529 50 soul soul NN 40436 6529 51 or or CC 40436 6529 52 mind mind NN 40436 6529 53 is be VBZ 40436 6529 54 immortal immortal JJ 40436 6529 55 , , , 40436 6529 56 has have VBZ 40436 6529 57 gone go VBN 40436 6529 58 through through IN 40436 6529 59 an an DT 40436 6529 60 indefinite indefinite JJ 40436 6529 61 succession succession NN 40436 6529 62 of of IN 40436 6529 63 temporary temporary JJ 40436 6529 64 lives life NNS 40436 6529 65 prior prior RB 40436 6529 66 to to IN 40436 6529 67 the the DT 40436 6529 68 present present NN 40436 6529 69 , , , 40436 6529 70 and and CC 40436 6529 71 will will MD 40436 6529 72 go go VB 40436 6529 73 through through IN 40436 6529 74 an an DT 40436 6529 75 indefinite indefinite JJ 40436 6529 76 succession succession NN 40436 6529 77 of of IN 40436 6529 78 temporary temporary JJ 40436 6529 79 lives life NNS 40436 6529 80 posterior posterior RB 40436 6529 81 to to IN 40436 6529 82 the the DT 40436 6529 83 present--"longæ present--"longæ XX 40436 6529 84 , , , 40436 6529 85 canitis canitis NNP 40436 6529 86 si si FW 40436 6529 87 cognita cognita NNP 40436 6529 88 , , , 40436 6529 89 vitæ vitæ NNP 40436 6529 90 Mors Mors NNP 40436 6529 91 media medium NNS 40436 6529 92 est est NNP 40436 6529 93 " " '' 40436 6529 94 . . . 40436 6530 1 The the DT 40436 6530 2 mind mind NN 40436 6530 3 has have VBZ 40436 6530 4 thus thus RB 40436 6530 5 become become VBN 40436 6530 6 omniscient omniscient JJ 40436 6530 7 , , , 40436 6530 8 having have VBG 40436 6530 9 seen see VBN 40436 6530 10 , , , 40436 6530 11 heard hear VBN 40436 6530 12 , , , 40436 6530 13 and and CC 40436 6530 14 learnt learn VBD 40436 6530 15 every every DT 40436 6530 16 thing thing NN 40436 6530 17 , , , 40436 6530 18 both both CC 40436 6530 19 on on IN 40436 6530 20 earth earth NN 40436 6530 21 and and CC 40436 6530 22 in in IN 40436 6530 23 Hades Hades NNP 40436 6530 24 : : : 40436 6530 25 but but CC 40436 6530 26 such such JJ 40436 6530 27 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6530 28 exists exist VBZ 40436 6530 29 as as IN 40436 6530 30 a a DT 40436 6530 31 confused confused JJ 40436 6530 32 and and CC 40436 6530 33 unavailable unavailable JJ 40436 6530 34 mass mass NN 40436 6530 35 , , , 40436 6530 36 having have VBG 40436 6530 37 been be VBN 40436 6530 38 buried bury VBN 40436 6530 39 and and CC 40436 6530 40 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6530 41 on on IN 40436 6530 42 the the DT 40436 6530 43 commencement commencement NN 40436 6530 44 of of IN 40436 6530 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6530 46 actual actual JJ 40436 6530 47 life life NN 40436 6530 48 . . . 40436 6531 1 Since since IN 40436 6531 2 all all DT 40436 6531 3 nature nature NN 40436 6531 4 is be VBZ 40436 6531 5 in in IN 40436 6531 6 universal universal JJ 40436 6531 7 kindred kindred NNP 40436 6531 8 , , , 40436 6531 9 communion communion NN 40436 6531 10 , , , 40436 6531 11 or or CC 40436 6531 12 interdependence interdependence NN 40436 6531 13 , , , 40436 6531 14 that that IN 40436 6531 15 which which WDT 40436 6531 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6531 17 hear hear VBP 40436 6531 18 or or CC 40436 6531 19 see see VBP 40436 6531 20 here here RB 40436 6531 21 , , , 40436 6531 22 recalls recall VBZ 40436 6531 23 to to IN 40436 6531 24 the the DT 40436 6531 25 memory memory NN 40436 6531 26 , , , 40436 6531 27 by by IN 40436 6531 28 association association NN 40436 6531 29 , , , 40436 6531 30 portions portion NNS 40436 6531 31 of of IN 40436 6531 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6531 33 prior prior JJ 40436 6531 34 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6531 35 omniscience omniscience NN 40436 6531 36 . . . 40436 6532 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6532 2 40 40 CD 40436 6532 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6532 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6532 5 is be VBZ 40436 6532 6 in in IN 40436 6532 7 this this DT 40436 6532 8 recall recall NN 40436 6532 9 or or CC 40436 6532 10 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6532 11 that that DT 40436 6532 12 search search NN 40436 6532 13 , , , 40436 6532 14 learning learning NN 40436 6532 15 , , , 40436 6532 16 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 6532 17 of of IN 40436 6532 18 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6532 19 , , , 40436 6532 20 consists consist VBZ 40436 6532 21 . . . 40436 6533 1 Teaching teaching NN 40436 6533 2 and and CC 40436 6533 3 learning learning NN 40436 6533 4 are be VBP 40436 6533 5 words word NNS 40436 6533 6 without without IN 40436 6533 7 meaning mean VBG 40436 6533 8 : : : 40436 6533 9 the the DT 40436 6533 10 only only JJ 40436 6533 11 process process NN 40436 6533 12 really really RB 40436 6533 13 instructive instructive JJ 40436 6533 14 is be VBZ 40436 6533 15 that that DT 40436 6533 16 of of IN 40436 6533 17 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 6533 18 debate debate NN 40436 6533 19 , , , 40436 6533 20 which which WDT 40436 6533 21 , , , 40436 6533 22 if if IN 40436 6533 23 indefatigably indefatigably RB 40436 6533 24 prosecuted prosecute VBN 40436 6533 25 , , , 40436 6533 26 will will MD 40436 6533 27 dig dig VB 40436 6533 28 out out RP 40436 6533 29 the the DT 40436 6533 30 omniscience omniscience NN 40436 6533 31 buried bury VBN 40436 6533 32 within within IN 40436 6533 33 . . . 40436 6534 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6534 2 41 41 CD 40436 6534 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6534 4 So so RB 40436 6534 5 vast vast JJ 40436 6534 6 is be VBZ 40436 6534 7 the the DT 40436 6534 8 theory theory NN 40436 6534 9 generated generate VBN 40436 6534 10 in in IN 40436 6534 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6534 12 's 's POS 40436 6534 13 mind mind NN 40436 6534 14 , , , 40436 6534 15 by by IN 40436 6534 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6534 17 worship worship NN 40436 6534 18 of of IN 40436 6534 19 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 6534 20 , , , 40436 6534 21 respecting respect VBG 40436 6534 22 that that IN 40436 6534 23 process process NN 40436 6534 24 of of IN 40436 6534 25 search search NN 40436 6534 26 to to TO 40436 6534 27 which which WDT 40436 6534 28 more more JJR 40436 6534 29 than than IN 40436 6534 30 half half NN 40436 6534 31 of of IN 40436 6534 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6534 33 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6534 34 are be VBP 40436 6534 35 devoted devoted JJ 40436 6534 36 . . . 40436 6535 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6535 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6535 3 40 40 CD 40436 6535 4 : : : 40436 6535 5 The the DT 40436 6535 6 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6535 7 of of IN 40436 6535 8 communion communion NN 40436 6535 9 or or CC 40436 6535 10 interdependence interdependence NN 40436 6535 11 pervading pervade VBG 40436 6535 12 all all DT 40436 6535 13 Nature Nature NNP 40436 6535 14 , , , 40436 6535 15 with with IN 40436 6535 16 one one CD 40436 6535 17 continuous continuous JJ 40436 6535 18 cosmical cosmical JJ 40436 6535 19 soul soul NN 40436 6535 20 penetrating penetrate VBG 40436 6535 21 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 6535 22 , , , 40436 6535 23 will will MD 40436 6535 24 be be VB 40436 6535 25 found find VBN 40436 6535 26 set set VBN 40436 6535 27 forth forth RP 40436 6535 28 in in IN 40436 6535 29 the the DT 40436 6535 30 kosmology kosmology NN 40436 6535 31 of of IN 40436 6535 32 the the DT 40436 6535 33 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 6535 34 , , , 40436 6535 35 pp pp NNP 40436 6535 36 . . . 40436 6536 1 37 37 CD 40436 6536 2 - - HYPH 40436 6536 3 42 42 CD 40436 6536 4 - - SYM 40436 6536 5 43 43 CD 40436 6536 6 . . . 40436 6537 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6537 2 was be VBD 40436 6537 3 held hold VBN 40436 6537 4 , , , 40436 6537 5 with with IN 40436 6537 6 various various JJ 40436 6537 7 modifications modification NNS 40436 6537 8 , , , 40436 6537 9 both both CC 40436 6537 10 by by IN 40436 6537 11 the the DT 40436 6537 12 Pythagoreans Pythagoreans NNPS 40436 6537 13 and and CC 40436 6537 14 the the DT 40436 6537 15 Stoics Stoics NNPS 40436 6537 16 . . . 40436 6538 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6538 2 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 6538 3 , , , 40436 6538 4 Divinat Divinat NNP 40436 6538 5 . . . 40436 6539 1 ii ii LS 40436 6539 2 . . . 40436 6540 1 14 14 CD 40436 6540 2 - - SYM 40436 6540 3 15 15 CD 40436 6540 4 ; ; : 40436 6540 5 Virgil Virgil NNP 40436 6540 6 , , , 40436 6540 7 Æneid Æneid NNP 40436 6540 8 vi vi NNP 40436 6540 9 . . . 40436 6541 1 715 715 CD 40436 6541 2 seqq seqq NN 40436 6541 3 . . . 40436 6542 1 ; ; : 40436 6542 2 Georgic Georgic NNP 40436 6542 3 . . . 40436 6543 1 iv iv XX 40436 6543 2 . . . 40436 6544 1 220 220 CD 40436 6544 2 ; ; : 40436 6544 3 Sextus Sextus NNP 40436 6544 4 Empir Empir NNP 40436 6544 5 . . . 40436 6545 1 adv adv NNP 40436 6545 2 . . . 40436 6546 1 Mathem Mathem NNP 40436 6546 2 . . . 40436 6547 1 ix ix IN 40436 6547 2 . . . 40436 6548 1 127 127 CD 40436 6548 2 ; ; : 40436 6548 3 Ekphantus Ekphantus NNP 40436 6548 4 Pythagoreus Pythagoreus NNP 40436 6548 5 ap ap NNP 40436 6548 6 . . . 40436 6549 1 Stobæum Stobæum NNP 40436 6549 2 , , , 40436 6549 3 Tit Tit NNP 40436 6549 4 . . . 40436 6550 1 48 48 CD 40436 6550 2 , , , 40436 6550 3 vol vol NNP 40436 6550 4 . . . 40436 6551 1 ii ii LS 40436 6551 2 . . . 40436 6552 1 p. p. NN 40436 6552 2 320 320 CD 40436 6552 3 , , , 40436 6552 4 Gaisford Gaisford NNP 40436 6552 5 . . . 40436 6553 1 The the DT 40436 6553 2 view view NN 40436 6553 3 here here RB 40436 6553 4 taken take VBN 40436 6553 5 by by IN 40436 6553 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6553 7 , , , 40436 6553 8 that that IN 40436 6553 9 all all DT 40436 6553 10 nature nature NN 40436 6553 11 is be VBZ 40436 6553 12 cognate cognate NN 40436 6553 13 and and CC 40436 6553 14 interdependent--[Greek interdependent--[greek CD 40436 6553 15 : : : 40436 6553 16 a(/te a(/te NNP 40436 6553 17 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6553 18 tê tê NNP 40436 6553 19 = = SYM 40436 6553 20 s s NNP 40436 6553 21 phu phu NNP 40436 6553 22 / / SYM 40436 6553 23 seôs seôs NNP 40436 6553 24 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 6553 25 / / SYM 40436 6553 26 sês sês NNP 40436 6553 27 suggenou suggenou NN 40436 6553 28 = = SYM 40436 6553 29 s s NNP 40436 6553 30 ou)/sês]--is ou)/sês]--is VBP 40436 6553 31 very very RB 40436 6553 32 similar similar JJ 40436 6553 33 to to IN 40436 6553 34 the the DT 40436 6553 35 theory theory NN 40436 6553 36 of of IN 40436 6553 37 Leibnitz:--"Ubique leibnitz:--"ubique JJ 40436 6553 38 per per IN 40436 6553 39 materiam materiam NNP 40436 6553 40 disseminata disseminata NN 40436 6553 41 statuo statuo NNP 40436 6553 42 principia principia NNP 40436 6553 43 vitalia vitalia NNP 40436 6553 44 seu seu NNP 40436 6553 45 percipientia percipientia NNP 40436 6553 46 . . . 40436 6554 1 Omnia Omnia NNP 40436 6554 2 in in IN 40436 6554 3 naturâ naturâ NNP 40436 6554 4 sunt sunt NNP 40436 6554 5 analogica analogica NNP 40436 6554 6 " " '' 40436 6554 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6554 8 Leibnitz Leibnitz NNP 40436 6554 9 , , , 40436 6554 10 Epist Epist NNP 40436 6554 11 . . . 40436 6555 1 ad ad NN 40436 6555 2 Wagnerum Wagnerum NNP 40436 6555 3 , , , 40436 6555 4 p. p. NN 40436 6555 5 466 466 CD 40436 6555 6 ; ; : 40436 6555 7 Leibn Leibn NNP 40436 6555 8 . . . 40436 6556 1 Opp Opp NNP 40436 6556 2 . . . 40436 6557 1 Erdmann Erdmann NNP 40436 6557 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6557 3 . . . 40436 6558 1 Farther farther RB 40436 6558 2 , , , 40436 6558 3 that that IN 40436 6558 4 the the DT 40436 6558 5 human human JJ 40436 6558 6 mind mind NN 40436 6558 7 by by IN 40436 6558 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 6558 9 of of IN 40436 6558 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6558 11 interdependence interdependence NN 40436 6558 12 or or CC 40436 6558 13 kindred kindre VBN 40436 6558 14 with with IN 40436 6558 15 all all DT 40436 6558 16 nature nature NN 40436 6558 17 , , , 40436 6558 18 includes include VBZ 40436 6558 19 a a DT 40436 6558 20 confused confused JJ 40436 6558 21 omniscience omniscience NN 40436 6558 22 , , , 40436 6558 23 is be VBZ 40436 6558 24 also also RB 40436 6558 25 a a DT 40436 6558 26 Leibnitzian leibnitzian JJ 40436 6558 27 view view NN 40436 6558 28 . . . 40436 6559 1 " " `` 40436 6559 2 Car car NN 40436 6559 3 comme comme NN 40436 6559 4 tout tout NN 40436 6559 5 est est NNP 40436 6559 6 plein plein NNP 40436 6559 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6559 8 ce ce NNP 40436 6559 9 qui qui NN 40436 6559 10 rend rend VBP 40436 6559 11 toute toute NN 40436 6559 12 la la FW 40436 6559 13 matière matière NNP 40436 6559 14 liée liée NNP 40436 6559 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6559 16 et et NN 40436 6559 17 comme comme NN 40436 6559 18 dans dan VBZ 40436 6559 19 le le NNP 40436 6559 20 plein plein NNP 40436 6559 21 tout tout NNP 40436 6559 22 mouvement mouvement NN 40436 6559 23 fait fait NNP 40436 6559 24 quelqu quelqu NNP 40436 6559 25 ' ' '' 40436 6559 26 effet effet NNP 40436 6559 27 sur sur NNP 40436 6559 28 les les FW 40436 6559 29 corps corps NNP 40436 6559 30 distans distans NNPS 40436 6559 31 à à NNP 40436 6559 32 mesure mesure NN 40436 6559 33 de de FW 40436 6559 34 la la NNP 40436 6559 35 distance distance NNP 40436 6559 36 , , , 40436 6559 37 de de NNP 40436 6559 38 sorte sorte NNP 40436 6559 39 que que NNP 40436 6559 40 chaque chaque NNP 40436 6559 41 corps corp NNS 40436 6559 42 est e JJS 40436 6559 43 affecté affecté VBP 40436 6559 44 non non AFX 40436 6559 45 seulement seulement NN 40436 6559 46 par par FW 40436 6559 47 ceux ceux FW 40436 6559 48 qui qui NNP 40436 6559 49 le le NNP 40436 6559 50 touchent touchent NN 40436 6559 51 , , , 40436 6559 52 et et FW 40436 6559 53 se se FW 40436 6559 54 ressent ressent NNP 40436 6559 55 en en FW 40436 6559 56 quelque quelque NNP 40436 6559 57 façon façon NN 40436 6559 58 de de IN 40436 6559 59 tout tout NNP 40436 6559 60 ce ce NN 40436 6559 61 qui qui NN 40436 6559 62 leur leur IN 40436 6559 63 arrive arrive NNP 40436 6559 64 -- -- : 40436 6559 65 mais mais NNP 40436 6559 66 aussi aussi NNP 40436 6559 67 par par NNP 40436 6559 68 leur leur IN 40436 6559 69 moyen moyen NNP 40436 6559 70 se se FW 40436 6559 71 ressent ressent FW 40436 6559 72 de de FW 40436 6559 73 ceux ceux FW 40436 6559 74 qui qui NNP 40436 6559 75 touchent touchent NN 40436 6559 76 les les NN 40436 6559 77 premiers premier NNS 40436 6559 78 do do VBP 40436 6559 79 nt not RB 40436 6559 80 il il NNP 40436 6559 81 est est NNP 40436 6559 82 touché touché NNP 40436 6559 83 immédiatement immédiatement NN 40436 6559 84 . . . 40436 6560 1 Il Il NNP 40436 6560 2 s'ensuit s'ensuit NNP 40436 6560 3 que que NNP 40436 6560 4 cette cette NNP 40436 6560 5 communication communication NN 40436 6560 6 va va NNP 40436 6560 7 à à NNP 40436 6560 8 quelque quelque NNP 40436 6560 9 distance distance NNP 40436 6560 10 que que NNP 40436 6560 11 ce ce NNP 40436 6560 12 soit soit NNP 40436 6560 13 . . . 40436 6561 1 Et et NN 40436 6561 2 par par NN 40436 6561 3 consequent consequent JJ 40436 6561 4 tout tout NN 40436 6561 5 corps corps NNP 40436 6561 6 se se FW 40436 6561 7 ressent ressent NNP 40436 6561 8 de de FW 40436 6561 9 tout tout NNP 40436 6561 10 ce ce NNP 40436 6561 11 qui qui FW 40436 6561 12 se se FW 40436 6561 13 fait fait NN 40436 6561 14 dans dan VBZ 40436 6561 15 l'Univers l'univer NNS 40436 6561 16 : : : 40436 6561 17 tellement tellement JJ 40436 6561 18 que que NN 40436 6561 19 celui celui NN 40436 6561 20 , , , 40436 6561 21 qui qui NNP 40436 6561 22 voit voit NNP 40436 6561 23 tout tout NNP 40436 6561 24 , , , 40436 6561 25 pourroit pourroit NNP 40436 6561 26 lire lire NNP 40436 6561 27 dans dan NNS 40436 6561 28 chacun chacun RB 40436 6561 29 ce ce NNP 40436 6561 30 qui qui NNP 40436 6561 31 se se FW 40436 6561 32 fait fait NNP 40436 6561 33 partout partout NNP 40436 6561 34 et et NNP 40436 6561 35 même même NNP 40436 6561 36 ce ce PRP 40436 6561 37 qui qui VBP 40436 6561 38 s'est s'est UH 40436 6561 39 fait fait NNP 40436 6561 40 et et FW 40436 6561 41 se se NNP 40436 6561 42 fera fera NNP 40436 6561 43 , , , 40436 6561 44 en en IN 40436 6561 45 remarquant remarquant JJ 40436 6561 46 dans dan NNS 40436 6561 47 le le VBP 40436 6561 48 présent présent JJ 40436 6561 49 ce ce NNP 40436 6561 50 qui qui NNP 40436 6561 51 est est NNP 40436 6561 52 éloigné éloigné NNP 40436 6561 53 tant tant NNP 40436 6561 54 selon selon NNP 40436 6561 55 les les NNP 40436 6561 56 temps temps NNP 40436 6561 57 que que NNP 40436 6561 58 selon selon NNP 40436 6561 59 les les NNP 40436 6561 60 lieux lieux NNP 40436 6561 61 : : : 40436 6561 62 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6561 63 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6561 64 : : : 40436 6561 65 su su NNP 40436 6561 66 / / SYM 40436 6561 67 mpnoia mpnoia NNP 40436 6561 68 pa pa NNP 40436 6561 69 / / SYM 40436 6561 70 nta nta NNP 40436 6561 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6561 72 , , , 40436 6561 73 disoit disoit NNP 40436 6561 74 Hippocrate Hippocrate NNP 40436 6561 75 . . . 40436 6562 1 Mais Mais NNP 40436 6562 2 une une VBP 40436 6562 3 âme âme NNP 40436 6562 4 ne ne NNP 40436 6562 5 peut peut NNP 40436 6562 6 lire lira NNS 40436 6562 7 en en IN 40436 6562 8 elle elle NNP 40436 6562 9 même même NNP 40436 6562 10 que que NNP 40436 6562 11 ce ce NNP 40436 6562 12 qui qui NNP 40436 6562 13 y y NNP 40436 6562 14 est est NNP 40436 6562 15 representé representé NNP 40436 6562 16 distinctement distinctement NNP 40436 6562 17 : : : 40436 6562 18 elle elle NNP 40436 6562 19 ne ne NNP 40436 6562 20 sauroit sauroit NNP 40436 6562 21 developper developper NNP 40436 6562 22 tout tout NN 40436 6562 23 d'un d'un NNP 40436 6562 24 coup coup NN 40436 6562 25 ses se VBZ 40436 6562 26 règles règle NNS 40436 6562 27 , , , 40436 6562 28 car car NN 40436 6562 29 elles elle NNS 40436 6562 30 vont vont NNP 40436 6562 31 à à NNP 40436 6562 32 l'infini l'infini NNP 40436 6562 33 . . . 40436 6563 1 Ainsi Ainsi NNP 40436 6563 2 quoique quoique NNP 40436 6563 3 chaque chaque NN 40436 6563 4 monade monade NN 40436 6563 5 créée créée VBD 40436 6563 6 représente représente VBZ 40436 6563 7 tout tout NN 40436 6563 8 l'Univers l'Univers NNP 40436 6563 9 , , , 40436 6563 10 elle elle NNP 40436 6563 11 représente représente NNP 40436 6563 12 plus plus CC 40436 6563 13 distinctement distinctement NN 40436 6563 14 le le FW 40436 6563 15 corps corps FW 40436 6563 16 qui qui UH 40436 6563 17 lui lui NNP 40436 6563 18 est est NNP 40436 6563 19 particulièrement particulièrement NN 40436 6563 20 affecté affecté NN 40436 6563 21 , , , 40436 6563 22 et et FW 40436 6563 23 do do VBP 40436 6563 24 nt not RB 40436 6563 25 elle elle NNP 40436 6563 26 fait fait VB 40436 6563 27 l'Entéléchie l'Entéléchie NNP 40436 6563 28 . . . 40436 6564 1 Et et NN 40436 6564 2 comme comme NN 40436 6564 3 ce ce NN 40436 6564 4 corps corps FW 40436 6564 5 exprime exprime NN 40436 6564 6 tout tout NN 40436 6564 7 l'Univers l'Univers NNP 40436 6564 8 par par IN 40436 6564 9 la la JJ 40436 6564 10 connexion connexion NN 40436 6564 11 de de IN 40436 6564 12 toute toute NNP 40436 6564 13 la la NNP 40436 6564 14 matière matière NNP 40436 6564 15 dans dans NNPS 40436 6564 16 le le NNP 40436 6564 17 plein plein NNP 40436 6564 18 , , , 40436 6564 19 l'âme l'âme NNP 40436 6564 20 représente représente NNP 40436 6564 21 aussi aussi NNP 40436 6564 22 tout tout NN 40436 6564 23 l'Univers l'Univers NNP 40436 6564 24 en en IN 40436 6564 25 représentant représentant JJ 40436 6564 26 ce ce NN 40436 6564 27 corps corps FW 40436 6564 28 qui qui UH 40436 6564 29 lui lui NN 40436 6564 30 appartient appartient JJ 40436 6564 31 d'une d'une NNP 40436 6564 32 manière manière JJ 40436 6564 33 particulière particulière NN 40436 6564 34 " " '' 40436 6564 35 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6564 36 Leibnitz Leibnitz NNP 40436 6564 37 , , , 40436 6564 38 Monadologie Monadologie NNP 40436 6564 39 , , , 40436 6564 40 sect sect NN 40436 6564 41 . . . 40436 6565 1 61 61 CD 40436 6565 2 - - SYM 40436 6565 3 62 62 CD 40436 6565 4 , , , 40436 6565 5 No no UH 40436 6565 6 . . . 40436 6566 1 88 88 CD 40436 6566 2 , , , 40436 6566 3 p. p. NN 40436 6566 4 710 710 CD 40436 6566 5 ; ; : 40436 6566 6 Opp Opp NNP 40436 6566 7 . . . 40436 6567 1 Leibn Leibn NNP 40436 6567 2 . . . 40436 6568 1 ed ed NNP 40436 6568 2 . . . 40436 6569 1 Erdmann Erdmann NNP 40436 6569 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6569 3 . . . 40436 6570 1 Again again RB 40436 6570 2 , , , 40436 6570 3 Leibnitz Leibnitz NNP 40436 6570 4 , , , 40436 6570 5 in in IN 40436 6570 6 another another DT 40436 6570 7 Dissertation dissertation NN 40436 6570 8 : : : 40436 6570 9 " " `` 40436 6570 10 Comme Comme NNP 40436 6570 11 à à NNP 40436 6570 12 cause cause NN 40436 6570 13 de de NNP 40436 6570 14 la la NNP 40436 6570 15 plénitude plénitude NNP 40436 6570 16 du du NNP 40436 6570 17 monde monde NNP 40436 6570 18 tout tout NN 40436 6570 19 est est NNP 40436 6570 20 lié lié NNP 40436 6570 21 , , , 40436 6570 22 et et NNP 40436 6570 23 chaque chaque NNP 40436 6570 24 corps corps NNP 40436 6570 25 agit agit NNP 40436 6570 26 sur sur NNP 40436 6570 27 chaque chaque NNP 40436 6570 28 autre autre NNP 40436 6570 29 corps corps NNP 40436 6570 30 , , , 40436 6570 31 plus plus CC 40436 6570 32 ou ou NNP 40436 6570 33 moins moin NNS 40436 6570 34 , , , 40436 6570 35 selon selon NNP 40436 6570 36 la la NNP 40436 6570 37 distance distance NNP 40436 6570 38 , , , 40436 6570 39 et et FW 40436 6570 40 en en IN 40436 6570 41 est est NNP 40436 6570 42 affecté affecté NNP 40436 6570 43 par par NN 40436 6570 44 la la NNP 40436 6570 45 réaction réaction NN 40436 6570 46 -- -- : 40436 6570 47 il il NNP 40436 6570 48 s'ensuit s'ensuit NNP 40436 6570 49 que que NNP 40436 6570 50 chaque chaque NNP 40436 6570 51 monade monade NNP 40436 6570 52 est est NNP 40436 6570 53 un un NNP 40436 6570 54 miroir miroir NNP 40436 6570 55 vivant vivant NNP 40436 6570 56 , , , 40436 6570 57 ou ou NNP 40436 6570 58 doué doué NNP 40436 6570 59 d'action d'action NNP 40436 6570 60 interne interne NNP 40436 6570 61 , , , 40436 6570 62 représentatif représentatif NNP 40436 6570 63 de de IN 40436 6570 64 l'Univers l'Univers NNP 40436 6570 65 , , , 40436 6570 66 suivant suivant JJ 40436 6570 67 son son NN 40436 6570 68 point point NNP 40436 6570 69 de de NNP 40436 6570 70 vue vue NNP 40436 6570 71 , , , 40436 6570 72 et et NNP 40436 6570 73 aussi aussi NNP 40436 6570 74 réglé réglé NNP 40436 6570 75 que que NNP 40436 6570 76 l'Univers l'Univers NNP 40436 6570 77 même même VBD 40436 6570 78 " " '' 40436 6570 79 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6570 80 Principes Principes NNP 40436 6570 81 de de NNP 40436 6570 82 la la NNP 40436 6570 83 Nature Nature NNP 40436 6570 84 et et FW 40436 6570 85 de de FW 40436 6570 86 la la NNP 40436 6570 87 Grace Grace NNP 40436 6570 88 , , , 40436 6570 89 p. p. NN 40436 6570 90 714 714 CD 40436 6570 91 , , , 40436 6570 92 ed ed NN 40436 6570 93 . . . 40436 6571 1 Erdmann erdmann NN 40436 6571 2 ; ; : 40436 6571 3 also also RB 40436 6571 4 Système Système NNP 40436 6571 5 Nouveau Nouveau NNP 40436 6571 6 , , , 40436 6571 7 p. p. NN 40436 6571 8 128 128 CD 40436 6571 9 , , , 40436 6571 10 a. a. NN 40436 6572 1 36 36 CD 40436 6572 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6572 3 . . . 40436 6573 1 Leibnitz Leibnitz NNP 40436 6573 2 expresses express VBZ 40436 6573 3 more more JJR 40436 6573 4 than than IN 40436 6573 5 once once RB 40436 6573 6 how how WRB 40436 6573 7 much much JJ 40436 6573 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6573 9 own own JJ 40436 6573 10 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 40436 6573 11 views view NNS 40436 6573 12 agreed agree VBN 40436 6573 13 with with IN 40436 6573 14 those those DT 40436 6573 15 of of IN 40436 6573 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6573 17 . . . 40436 6574 1 Lettre Lettre NNP 40436 6574 2 à à NNP 40436 6574 3 M. M. NNP 40436 6574 4 Bourguet Bourguet NNP 40436 6574 5 , , , 40436 6574 6 pp pp NNP 40436 6574 7 . . . 40436 6575 1 723 723 CD 40436 6575 2 - - SYM 40436 6575 3 725 725 CD 40436 6575 4 . . . 40436 6576 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6576 2 expresses express VBZ 40436 6576 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6576 4 belief belief NN 40436 6576 5 in in IN 40436 6576 6 the the DT 40436 6576 7 pre pre NN 40436 6576 8 - - NN 40436 6576 9 existence existence NN 40436 6576 10 of of IN 40436 6576 11 the the DT 40436 6576 12 soul soul NN 40436 6576 13 : : : 40436 6576 14 " " `` 40436 6576 15 Tout Tout NNP 40436 6576 16 ce ce NNP 40436 6576 17 que que FW 40436 6576 18 je je NNP 40436 6576 19 crois crois NNP 40436 6576 20 pouvoir pouvoir NNP 40436 6576 21 assurer assurer NNP 40436 6576 22 , , , 40436 6576 23 est est NNP 40436 6576 24 , , , 40436 6576 25 que que NNP 40436 6576 26 l'âme l'âme NNP 40436 6576 27 de de IN 40436 6576 28 tout tout NNP 40436 6576 29 animal animal NNP 40436 6576 30 a a DT 40436 6576 31 préexisté préexisté NN 40436 6576 32 , , , 40436 6576 33 et et FW 40436 6576 34 a a DT 40436 6576 35 été été NN 40436 6576 36 dans dan NNS 40436 6576 37 un un NNP 40436 6576 38 corps corps NNP 40436 6576 39 organique organique NNP 40436 6576 40 : : : 40436 6576 41 qui qui NNP 40436 6576 42 enfin enfin NNP 40436 6576 43 , , , 40436 6576 44 par par NNP 40436 6576 45 beaucoup beaucoup NNP 40436 6576 46 de de NNP 40436 6576 47 changemens changemens NNP 40436 6576 48 , , , 40436 6576 49 involutions involution NNS 40436 6576 50 , , , 40436 6576 51 et et NN 40436 6576 52 évolutions évolution NNS 40436 6576 53 , , , 40436 6576 54 est est NNP 40436 6576 55 devenu devenu NNP 40436 6576 56 l'animal l'animal NNP 40436 6576 57 présent présent NN 40436 6576 58 " " '' 40436 6576 59 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6576 60 Lettre Lettre NNP 40436 6576 61 à à NNP 40436 6576 62 M. M. NNP 40436 6576 63 Bourguet Bourguet NNP 40436 6576 64 , , , 40436 6576 65 p. p. NN 40436 6576 66 731 731 CD 40436 6576 67 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6576 68 . . . 40436 6577 1 And and CC 40436 6577 2 in in IN 40436 6577 3 the the DT 40436 6577 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6577 5 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6577 6 of of IN 40436 6577 7 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6577 8 to to IN 40436 6577 9 a a DT 40436 6577 10 certain certain JJ 40436 6577 11 point point NN 40436 6577 12 : : : 40436 6577 13 " " `` 40436 6577 14 II II NNP 40436 6577 15 y y NNP 40436 6577 16 a a DT 40436 6577 17 quelque quelque NN 40436 6577 18 chose choose VBD 40436 6577 19 de de NNP 40436 6577 20 solide solide NNP 40436 6577 21 dans dan NNS 40436 6577 22 ce ce VBP 40436 6577 23 que que NNP 40436 6577 24 dit dit NNP 40436 6577 25 Platon Platon NNP 40436 6577 26 de de NNP 40436 6577 27 la la NNP 40436 6577 28 réminiscence réminiscence NN 40436 6577 29 " " '' 40436 6577 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6577 31 p. p. NN 40436 6577 32 137 137 CD 40436 6577 33 , , , 40436 6577 34 b. b. NN 40436 6578 1 10 10 LS 40436 6578 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6578 3 . . . 40436 6579 1 Also also RB 40436 6579 2 Leibnitz Leibnitz NNP 40436 6579 3 's 's POS 40436 6579 4 Nouveaux Nouveaux NNP 40436 6579 5 Essais Essais NNP 40436 6579 6 sur sur NN 40436 6579 7 l'Entendement l'Entendement NNP 40436 6579 8 Humain Humain NNP 40436 6579 9 , , , 40436 6579 10 p. p. NN 40436 6579 11 196 196 CD 40436 6579 12 , , , 40436 6579 13 b. b. NNP 40436 6580 1 28 28 CD 40436 6580 2 ; ; : 40436 6580 3 and and CC 40436 6580 4 Epistol Epistol NNP 40436 6580 5 . . . 40436 6581 1 ad ad NNP 40436 6581 2 Hanschium Hanschium NNP 40436 6581 3 , , , 40436 6581 4 p. p. NN 40436 6581 5 446 446 CD 40436 6581 6 , , , 40436 6581 7 a. a. NN 40436 6582 1 12 12 CD 40436 6582 2 . . . 40436 6583 1 See see VB 40436 6583 2 the the DT 40436 6583 3 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 6583 4 account account NN 40436 6583 5 of of IN 40436 6583 6 the the DT 40436 6583 7 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6583 8 of of IN 40436 6583 9 Leibnitz Leibnitz NNP 40436 6583 10 by by IN 40436 6583 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 6583 12 Kuno Kuno NNP 40436 6583 13 Fischer Fischer NNP 40436 6583 14 -- -- : 40436 6583 15 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 40436 6583 16 der der VB 40436 6583 17 neueren neueren NNP 40436 6583 18 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 40436 6583 19 , , , 40436 6583 20 vol vol NNP 40436 6583 21 . . . 40436 6584 1 ii ii LS 40436 6584 2 . . . 40436 6585 1 pp pp NNP 40436 6585 2 . . . 40436 6586 1 226 226 CD 40436 6586 2 - - SYM 40436 6586 3 232 232 CD 40436 6586 4 . . . 40436 6586 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6587 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6587 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6587 3 41 41 CD 40436 6587 4 : : : 40436 6587 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6587 6 , , , 40436 6587 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6587 8 , , , 40436 6587 9 p. p. NN 40436 6587 10 81 81 CD 40436 6587 11 D. D. NNP 40436 6587 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6587 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6587 14 : : : 40436 6587 15 e)a e)a NNP 40436 6587 16 / / SYM 40436 6587 17 n n CD 40436 6587 18 tis tis NN 40436 6587 19 a)ndrei a)ndrei , 40436 6587 20 = = SYM 40436 6587 21 os os NNP 40436 6587 22 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 6587 23 , , , 40436 6587 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6587 25 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 6587 26 a)poka a)poka NNP 40436 6587 27 / / SYM 40436 6587 28 mnê| mnê| NNP 40436 6587 29 zêtô zêtô NNP 40436 6587 30 = = SYM 40436 6587 31 n n NN 40436 6587 32 . . . 40436 6587 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6588 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6588 2 also also RB 40436 6588 3 p. p. NN 40436 6588 4 86 86 CD 40436 6588 5 B. B. NNP 40436 6588 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6589 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6589 2 Side side NN 40436 6589 3 - - HYPH 40436 6589 4 note note NN 40436 6589 5 : : : 40436 6589 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6589 7 's 's POS 40436 6589 8 view view NN 40436 6589 9 of of IN 40436 6589 10 the the DT 40436 6589 11 immortality immortality NN 40436 6589 12 of of IN 40436 6589 13 the the DT 40436 6589 14 soul soul NN 40436 6589 15 -- -- : 40436 6589 16 difference difference NN 40436 6589 17 between between IN 40436 6589 18 the the DT 40436 6589 19 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6589 20 , , , 40436 6589 21 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6589 22 , , , 40436 6589 23 and and CC 40436 6589 24 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 6589 25 . . . 40436 6589 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6590 1 In in IN 40436 6590 2 various various JJ 40436 6590 3 other other JJ 40436 6590 4 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6590 5 of of IN 40436 6590 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6590 7 , , , 40436 6590 8 the the DT 40436 6590 9 same same JJ 40436 6590 10 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 6590 11 is be VBZ 40436 6590 12 found find VBN 40436 6590 13 repeated repeat VBN 40436 6590 14 . . . 40436 6591 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6591 2 conception conception NN 40436 6591 3 of of IN 40436 6591 4 the the DT 40436 6591 5 immortality immortality NN 40436 6591 6 of of IN 40436 6591 7 the the DT 40436 6591 8 soul soul NN 40436 6591 9 or or CC 40436 6591 10 mind mind NN 40436 6591 11 , , , 40436 6591 12 includes include VBZ 40436 6591 13 pre pre JJ 40436 6591 14 - - NN 40436 6591 15 existence existence NN 40436 6591 16 as as RB 40436 6591 17 well well RB 40436 6591 18 as as IN 40436 6591 19 post post JJ 40436 6591 20 - - JJ 40436 6591 21 existence existence NN 40436 6591 22 : : : 40436 6591 23 a a DT 40436 6591 24 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 6591 25 succession succession NN 40436 6591 26 of of IN 40436 6591 27 temporary temporary JJ 40436 6591 28 lives life NNS 40436 6591 29 , , , 40436 6591 30 each each DT 40436 6591 31 in in IN 40436 6591 32 a a DT 40436 6591 33 distinct distinct JJ 40436 6591 34 body body NN 40436 6591 35 , , , 40436 6591 36 each each DT 40436 6591 37 terminated terminate VBN 40436 6591 38 by by IN 40436 6591 39 death death NN 40436 6591 40 , , , 40436 6591 41 and and CC 40436 6591 42 each each DT 40436 6591 43 followed follow VBN 40436 6591 44 by by IN 40436 6591 45 renewed renew VBN 40436 6591 46 life life NN 40436 6591 47 for for IN 40436 6591 48 a a DT 40436 6591 49 time time NN 40436 6591 50 in in IN 40436 6591 51 another another DT 40436 6591 52 body body NN 40436 6591 53 . . . 40436 6592 1 In in IN 40436 6592 2 fact fact NN 40436 6592 3 , , , 40436 6592 4 the the DT 40436 6592 5 pre pre NN 40436 6592 6 - - NN 40436 6592 7 existence existence NN 40436 6592 8 of of IN 40436 6592 9 the the DT 40436 6592 10 mind mind NN 40436 6592 11 formed form VBD 40436 6592 12 the the DT 40436 6592 13 most most RBS 40436 6592 14 important important JJ 40436 6592 15 part part NN 40436 6592 16 of of IN 40436 6592 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6592 18 's 's POS 40436 6592 19 theory theory NN 40436 6592 20 about about IN 40436 6592 21 immortality immortality NN 40436 6592 22 : : : 40436 6592 23 for for IN 40436 6592 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6592 25 employed employ VBD 40436 6592 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6592 27 as as IN 40436 6592 28 the the DT 40436 6592 29 means mean NNS 40436 6592 30 of of IN 40436 6592 31 explaining explain VBG 40436 6592 32 how how WRB 40436 6592 33 the the DT 40436 6592 34 mind mind NN 40436 6592 35 became become VBD 40436 6592 36 possessed possessed JJ 40436 6592 37 of of IN 40436 6592 38 general general JJ 40436 6592 39 notions notion NNS 40436 6592 40 . . . 40436 6593 1 As as IN 40436 6593 2 the the DT 40436 6593 3 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6593 4 is be VBZ 40436 6593 5 stated state VBN 40436 6593 6 in in IN 40436 6593 7 the the DT 40436 6593 8 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6593 9 , , , 40436 6593 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6593 11 is be VBZ 40436 6593 12 made make VBN 40436 6593 13 applicable applicable JJ 40436 6593 14 to to IN 40436 6593 15 all all DT 40436 6593 16 minds mind NNS 40436 6593 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6593 18 instead instead RB 40436 6593 19 of of IN 40436 6593 20 being be VBG 40436 6593 21 confined confine VBN 40436 6593 22 , , , 40436 6593 23 as as IN 40436 6593 24 in in IN 40436 6593 25 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6593 26 , , , 40436 6593 27 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 6593 28 , , , 40436 6593 29 and and CC 40436 6593 30 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 6593 31 , , , 40436 6593 32 to to IN 40436 6593 33 a a DT 40436 6593 34 few few JJ 40436 6593 35 highly highly RB 40436 6593 36 gifted gifted JJ 40436 6593 37 minds mind NNS 40436 6593 38 , , , 40436 6593 39 and and CC 40436 6593 40 to to TO 40436 6593 41 commerce commerce VB 40436 6593 42 with with IN 40436 6593 43 the the DT 40436 6593 44 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 6593 45 substances substance NNS 40436 6593 46 called call VBN 40436 6593 47 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 6593 48 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6593 49 . . . 40436 6594 1 This this DT 40436 6594 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 6594 3 from from IN 40436 6594 4 the the DT 40436 6594 5 person person NN 40436 6594 6 chosen choose VBN 40436 6594 7 to to TO 40436 6594 8 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 6594 9 the the DT 40436 6594 10 alleged allege VBN 40436 6594 11 possibility possibility NN 40436 6594 12 of of IN 40436 6594 13 stimulating stimulate VBG 40436 6594 14 artificial artificial JJ 40436 6594 15 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6594 16 : : : 40436 6594 17 that that DT 40436 6594 18 person person NN 40436 6594 19 is be VBZ 40436 6594 20 an an DT 40436 6594 21 unlettered unlettered JJ 40436 6594 22 youth youth NN 40436 6594 23 , , , 40436 6594 24 taken take VBN 40436 6594 25 at at IN 40436 6594 26 hazard hazard NN 40436 6594 27 from from IN 40436 6594 28 among among IN 40436 6594 29 the the DT 40436 6594 30 numerous numerous JJ 40436 6594 31 slaves slave NNS 40436 6594 32 of of IN 40436 6594 33 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6594 34 . . . 40436 6595 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6595 2 42 42 CD 40436 6595 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6595 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6595 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6595 6 42 42 CD 40436 6595 7 : : : 40436 6595 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6595 9 , , , 40436 6595 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6595 11 , , , 40436 6595 12 pp pp NNP 40436 6595 13 . . . 40436 6596 1 82 82 CD 40436 6596 2 A a DT 40436 6596 3 , , , 40436 6596 4 85 85 CD 40436 6596 5 E. E. NNP 40436 6596 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6596 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6596 8 : : : 40436 6596 9 proska proska NNP 40436 6596 10 / / SYM 40436 6596 11 leson leson NNP 40436 6596 12 tô tô NNP 40436 6596 13 = = SYM 40436 6596 14 n n CC 40436 6596 15 pollô pollô NN 40436 6596 16 = = SYM 40436 6596 17 n n CC 40436 6596 18 a)kolou a)kolou NNP 40436 6596 19 / / SYM 40436 6596 20 thôn thôn NN 40436 6596 21 toutôni\ toutôni\ NNP 40436 6596 22 tô tô NNP 40436 6596 23 = = SYM 40436 6596 24 n n CC 40436 6596 25 sautou= sautou= JJ 40436 6596 26 e(/na e(/na NNP 40436 6596 27 , , , 40436 6596 28 o(/ntina o(/ntina NNP 40436 6596 29 bou bou NN 40436 6596 30 / / SYM 40436 6596 31 lei lei NNP 40436 6596 32 , , , 40436 6596 33 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 6596 34 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6596 35 tou tou NNP 40436 6596 36 / / SYM 40436 6596 37 tô| tô| NNP 40436 6596 38 soi soi NN 40436 6596 39 e)pidei e)pidei NNS 40436 6596 40 / / SYM 40436 6596 41 xômai xômai NNP 40436 6596 42 . . . 40436 6596 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6597 1 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 6597 2 says say VBZ 40436 6597 3 that that IN 40436 6597 4 this this DT 40436 6597 5 allusion allusion NN 40436 6597 6 to to IN 40436 6597 7 the the DT 40436 6597 8 numerous numerous JJ 40436 6597 9 slaves slave NNS 40436 6597 10 in in IN 40436 6597 11 attendance attendance NN 40436 6597 12 is be VBZ 40436 6597 13 intended intend VBN 40436 6597 14 to to TO 40436 6597 15 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 6597 16 conspicuously conspicuously RB 40436 6597 17 the the DT 40436 6597 18 wealth wealth NN 40436 6597 19 and and CC 40436 6597 20 nobility nobility NN 40436 6597 21 of of IN 40436 6597 22 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6597 23 . . . 40436 6598 1 In in IN 40436 6598 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6598 3 judgment judgment NN 40436 6598 4 , , , 40436 6598 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6598 6 is be VBZ 40436 6598 7 rather rather RB 40436 6598 8 intended intend VBN 40436 6598 9 to to TO 40436 6598 10 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 6598 11 the the DT 40436 6598 12 operation operation NN 40436 6598 13 of of IN 40436 6598 14 pure pure JJ 40436 6598 15 accident accident NN 40436 6598 16 -- -- : 40436 6598 17 the the DT 40436 6598 18 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 6598 19 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 6598 20 character character NN 40436 6598 21 of of IN 40436 6598 22 the the DT 40436 6598 23 mind mind NN 40436 6598 24 worked work VBD 40436 6598 25 upon--"one upon--"one JJ 40436 6598 26 among among IN 40436 6598 27 many many JJ 40436 6598 28 , , , 40436 6598 29 which which WDT 40436 6598 30 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6598 31 please please VBP 40436 6598 32 " " '' 40436 6598 33 . . . 40436 6598 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6599 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6599 2 Side side NN 40436 6599 3 - - HYPH 40436 6599 4 note note NN 40436 6599 5 : : : 40436 6599 6 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 40436 6599 7 of of IN 40436 6599 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6599 9 , , , 40436 6599 10 that that DT 40436 6599 11 new new JJ 40436 6599 12 truth truth NN 40436 6599 13 may may MD 40436 6599 14 be be VB 40436 6599 15 elicited elicit VBN 40436 6599 16 by by IN 40436 6599 17 skilful skilful JJ 40436 6599 18 examination examination NN 40436 6599 19 out out IN 40436 6599 20 of of IN 40436 6599 21 the the DT 40436 6599 22 unlettered unlettered JJ 40436 6599 23 mind mind NN 40436 6599 24 -- -- : 40436 6599 25 how how WRB 40436 6599 26 far far RB 40436 6599 27 correct correct JJ 40436 6599 28 ? ? . 40436 6599 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6600 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6600 2 is be VBZ 40436 6600 3 true true JJ 40436 6600 4 , , , 40436 6600 5 indeed indeed RB 40436 6600 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6600 7 as as IN 40436 6600 8 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 6600 9 observes observe VBZ 40436 6600 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6600 11 , , , 40436 6600 12 that that IN 40436 6600 13 the the DT 40436 6600 14 questions question NNS 40436 6600 15 put put VBN 40436 6600 16 by by IN 40436 6600 17 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6600 18 to to IN 40436 6600 19 this this DT 40436 6600 20 youth youth NN 40436 6600 21 are be VBP 40436 6600 22 in in IN 40436 6600 23 great great JJ 40436 6600 24 proportion proportion NN 40436 6600 25 leading lead VBG 40436 6600 26 questions question NNS 40436 6600 27 , , , 40436 6600 28 suggesting suggest VBG 40436 6600 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6600 30 own own JJ 40436 6600 31 answers answer NNS 40436 6600 32 . . . 40436 6601 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 6601 2 would would MD 40436 6601 3 not not RB 40436 6601 4 have have VB 40436 6601 5 served serve VBN 40436 6601 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6601 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 6601 8 unless unless IN 40436 6601 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6601 10 had have VBD 40436 6601 11 been be VBN 40436 6601 12 such such JJ 40436 6601 13 . . . 40436 6602 1 The the DT 40436 6602 2 illustration illustration NN 40436 6602 3 here here RB 40436 6602 4 furnished furnish VBN 40436 6602 5 , , , 40436 6602 6 of of IN 40436 6602 7 the the DT 40436 6602 8 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 6602 9 interrogatory interrogatory JJ 40436 6602 10 process process NN 40436 6602 11 , , , 40436 6602 12 is be VBZ 40436 6602 13 highly highly RB 40436 6602 14 interesting interesting JJ 40436 6602 15 , , , 40436 6602 16 and and CC 40436 6602 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6602 18 theory theory NN 40436 6602 19 is be VBZ 40436 6602 20 in in IN 40436 6602 21 a a DT 40436 6602 22 great great JJ 40436 6602 23 degree degree NN 40436 6602 24 true true JJ 40436 6602 25 . . . 40436 6603 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6603 2 43 43 CD 40436 6603 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6603 4 Not not RB 40436 6603 5 all all DT 40436 6603 6 learning learn VBG 40436 6603 7 , , , 40436 6603 8 but but CC 40436 6603 9 an an DT 40436 6603 10 important important JJ 40436 6603 11 part part NN 40436 6603 12 of of IN 40436 6603 13 learning learning NN 40436 6603 14 , , , 40436 6603 15 consists consist VBZ 40436 6603 16 in in IN 40436 6603 17 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6603 18 -- -- : 40436 6603 19 not not RB 40436 6603 20 indeed indeed RB 40436 6603 21 of of IN 40436 6603 22 acquisitions acquisition NNS 40436 6603 23 made make VBN 40436 6603 24 in in IN 40436 6603 25 an an DT 40436 6603 26 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 6603 27 life life NN 40436 6603 28 , , , 40436 6603 29 but but CC 40436 6603 30 of of IN 40436 6603 31 past past JJ 40436 6603 32 experience experience NN 40436 6603 33 and and CC 40436 6603 34 judgments judgment NNS 40436 6603 35 in in IN 40436 6603 36 this this DT 40436 6603 37 life life NN 40436 6603 38 . . . 40436 6604 1 Of of IN 40436 6604 2 such such JJ 40436 6604 3 experience experience NN 40436 6604 4 and and CC 40436 6604 5 judgments judgment NNS 40436 6604 6 every every DT 40436 6604 7 one one NN 40436 6604 8 has have VBZ 40436 6604 9 travelled travel VBN 40436 6604 10 through through IN 40436 6604 11 a a DT 40436 6604 12 large large JJ 40436 6604 13 course course NN 40436 6604 14 ; ; : 40436 6604 15 which which WDT 40436 6604 16 has have VBZ 40436 6604 17 disappeared disappear VBN 40436 6604 18 from from IN 40436 6604 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6604 20 memory memory NN 40436 6604 21 , , , 40436 6604 22 yet yet CC 40436 6604 23 not not RB 40436 6604 24 irrevocably irrevocably RB 40436 6604 25 . . . 40436 6605 1 Portions portion NNS 40436 6605 2 of of IN 40436 6605 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6605 4 may may MD 40436 6605 5 be be VB 40436 6605 6 revived revive VBN 40436 6605 7 , , , 40436 6605 8 if if IN 40436 6605 9 new new JJ 40436 6605 10 matter matter NN 40436 6605 11 be be VB 40436 6605 12 presented present VBN 40436 6605 13 to to IN 40436 6605 14 the the DT 40436 6605 15 mind mind NN 40436 6605 16 , , , 40436 6605 17 fitted fit VBD 40436 6605 18 to to TO 40436 6605 19 excite excite VB 40436 6605 20 the the DT 40436 6605 21 recollection recollection NN 40436 6605 22 of of IN 40436 6605 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6605 24 by by IN 40436 6605 25 the the DT 40436 6605 26 laws law NNS 40436 6605 27 of of IN 40436 6605 28 association association NN 40436 6605 29 . . . 40436 6606 1 By by IN 40436 6606 2 suitable suitable JJ 40436 6606 3 interrogations interrogation NNS 40436 6606 4 , , , 40436 6606 5 a a DT 40436 6606 6 teacher teacher NN 40436 6606 7 may may MD 40436 6606 8 thus thus RB 40436 6606 9 recall recall VB 40436 6606 10 to to IN 40436 6606 11 the the DT 40436 6606 12 memory memory NN 40436 6606 13 of of IN 40436 6606 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6606 15 pupils pupil NNS 40436 6606 16 many many JJ 40436 6606 17 facts fact NNS 40436 6606 18 and and CC 40436 6606 19 judgments judgment NNS 40436 6606 20 which which WDT 40436 6606 21 have have VBP 40436 6606 22 been be VBN 40436 6606 23 hitherto hitherto VBN 40436 6606 24 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6606 25 : : : 40436 6606 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6606 27 may may MD 40436 6606 28 bring bring VB 40436 6606 29 into into IN 40436 6606 30 juxtaposition juxtaposition NN 40436 6606 31 those those DT 40436 6606 32 which which WDT 40436 6606 33 have have VBP 40436 6606 34 never never RB 40436 6606 35 before before RB 40436 6606 36 been be VBN 40436 6606 37 put put VBN 40436 6606 38 together together RB 40436 6606 39 in in IN 40436 6606 40 the the DT 40436 6606 41 mind mind NN 40436 6606 42 : : : 40436 6606 43 and and CC 40436 6606 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6606 45 may may MD 40436 6606 46 thus thus RB 40436 6606 47 make make VB 40436 6606 48 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6606 49 elicit elicit JJ 40436 6606 50 instructive instructive JJ 40436 6606 51 comparisons comparison NNS 40436 6606 52 and and CC 40436 6606 53 inferences inference NNS 40436 6606 54 . . . 40436 6607 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6607 2 may may MD 40436 6607 3 provoke provoke VB 40436 6607 4 the the DT 40436 6607 5 pupils pupil NNS 40436 6607 6 to to TO 40436 6607 7 strike strike VB 40436 6607 8 out out RP 40436 6607 9 new new JJ 40436 6607 10 results result NNS 40436 6607 11 for for IN 40436 6607 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6607 13 , , , 40436 6607 14 or or CC 40436 6607 15 to to TO 40436 6607 16 follow follow VB 40436 6607 17 , , , 40436 6607 18 by by IN 40436 6607 19 means mean NNS 40436 6607 20 of of IN 40436 6607 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6607 22 own own JJ 40436 6607 23 stock stock NN 40436 6607 24 of of IN 40436 6607 25 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6607 26 , , , 40436 6607 27 in in IN 40436 6607 28 the the DT 40436 6607 29 path path NN 40436 6607 30 suggested suggest VBN 40436 6607 31 by by IN 40436 6607 32 the the DT 40436 6607 33 questions question NNS 40436 6607 34 . . . 40436 6608 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6608 2 may may MD 40436 6608 3 farther farther RB 40436 6608 4 lead lead VB 40436 6608 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6608 6 to to TO 40436 6608 7 perceive perceive VB 40436 6608 8 the the DT 40436 6608 9 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 6608 10 of of IN 40436 6608 11 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 6608 12 analogies analogy NNS 40436 6608 13 which which WDT 40436 6608 14 at at IN 40436 6608 15 first first RB 40436 6608 16 presented present VBD 40436 6608 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6608 18 as as IN 40436 6608 19 plausible plausible JJ 40436 6608 20 ; ; : 40436 6608 21 and and CC 40436 6608 22 to to TO 40436 6608 23 become become VB 40436 6608 24 painfully painfully RB 40436 6608 25 sensible sensible JJ 40436 6608 26 of of IN 40436 6608 27 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 6608 28 and and CC 40436 6608 29 perplexing perplexing NN 40436 6608 30 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6608 31 , , , 40436 6608 32 before before IN 40436 6608 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6608 34 puts put VBZ 40436 6608 35 those those DT 40436 6608 36 questions question NNS 40436 6608 37 which which WDT 40436 6608 38 indicate indicate VBP 40436 6608 39 the the DT 40436 6608 40 way way NN 40436 6608 41 of of IN 40436 6608 42 escape escape NN 40436 6608 43 from from IN 40436 6608 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6608 45 . . . 40436 6609 1 Upon upon IN 40436 6609 2 the the DT 40436 6609 3 necessity necessity NN 40436 6609 4 of of IN 40436 6609 5 producing produce VBG 40436 6609 6 such such JJ 40436 6609 7 painful painful JJ 40436 6609 8 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 6609 9 of of IN 40436 6609 10 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6609 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6609 12 insists insist VBZ 40436 6609 13 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 6609 14 , , , 40436 6609 15 as as IN 40436 6609 16 is be VBZ 40436 6609 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6609 18 custom custom NN 40436 6609 19 . . . 40436 6610 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6610 2 44 44 CD 40436 6610 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6610 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6610 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6610 6 43 43 CD 40436 6610 7 : : : 40436 6610 8 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40436 6610 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6610 10 Fragment Fragment NNP 40436 6610 11 . . . 40436 6611 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6611 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6611 3 : : : 40436 6611 4 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 6611 5 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 6611 6 = = NFP 40436 6611 7 s s NN 40436 6611 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6611 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6611 10 . . . 40436 6612 1 Ei Ei NNP 40436 6612 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6612 3 a)ph a)ph NN 40436 6612 4 ' ' `` 40436 6612 5 e(te e(te NNS 40436 6612 6 / / SYM 40436 6612 7 rou rou NN 40436 6612 8 e(/teron e(/teron NN 40436 6612 9 e)nnoou e)nnoou NNS 40436 6612 10 = = SYM 40436 6612 11 men man NNS 40436 6612 12 ? ? . 40436 6613 1 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 6613 2 a)/n a)/n NNP 40436 6613 3 , , , 40436 6613 4 ei ei NNP 40436 6613 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6613 6 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 6613 7 proe proe NNP 40436 6613 8 / / SYM 40436 6613 9 gnôsto gnôsto NN 40436 6613 10 . . . 40436 6614 1 To\ To\ NNP 40436 6614 2 e)pichei e)pichei CD 40436 6614 3 / / SYM 40436 6614 4 rêma rêma NN 40436 6614 5 Platôniko Platôniko NNP 40436 6614 6 / / SYM 40436 6614 7 n n JJ 40436 6614 8 . . . 40436 6615 1 Ei Ei NNP 40436 6615 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6615 3 prosti prosti NN 40436 6615 4 / / SYM 40436 6615 5 themen themen NNP 40436 6615 6 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6615 7 e)/lleipon e)/lleipon NNP 40436 6615 8 toi toi NNP 40436 6615 9 = = SYM 40436 6615 10 s s NNP 40436 6615 11 ai)sthêtoi ai)sthêtoi CC 40436 6615 12 = = SYM 40436 6615 13 s?--kai\ s?--kai\ ADD 40436 6615 14 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 6615 15 Platôniko Platôniko NNP 40436 6615 16 / / SYM 40436 6615 17 n n JJ 40436 6615 18 . . . 40436 6615 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6616 1 Plutarch plutarch NN 40436 6616 2 , , , 40436 6616 3 in in IN 40436 6616 4 the the DT 40436 6616 5 same same JJ 40436 6616 6 fragment fragment NN 40436 6616 7 , , , 40436 6616 8 indicates indicate VBZ 40436 6616 9 some some DT 40436 6616 10 of of IN 40436 6616 11 the the DT 40436 6616 12 objections objection NNS 40436 6616 13 made make VBN 40436 6616 14 by by IN 40436 6616 15 Bion Bion NNP 40436 6616 16 and and CC 40436 6616 17 Straton Straton NNP 40436 6616 18 against against IN 40436 6616 19 the the DT 40436 6616 20 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6616 21 of of IN 40436 6616 22 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6616 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6616 24 : : : 40436 6616 25 a)na a)na NNS 40436 6616 26 / / SYM 40436 6616 27 mnêsis mnêsis NN 40436 6616 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6616 29 . . . 40436 6617 1 How how WRB 40436 6617 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6617 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6617 4 asked ask VBD 40436 6617 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6617 6 does do VBZ 40436 6617 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6617 8 happen happen VB 40436 6617 9 that that IN 40436 6617 10 this this DT 40436 6617 11 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6617 12 brings bring VBZ 40436 6617 13 up up RP 40436 6617 14 often often RB 40436 6617 15 what what WP 40436 6617 16 is be VBZ 40436 6617 17 false false JJ 40436 6617 18 or or CC 40436 6617 19 absurd absurd JJ 40436 6617 20 ? ? . 40436 6618 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6618 2 asked ask VBN 40436 6618 3 Bion Bion NNP 40436 6618 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6618 5 . . . 40436 6619 1 If if IN 40436 6619 2 such such JJ 40436 6619 3 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6619 4 exists exist VBZ 40436 6619 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6619 6 asked ask VBD 40436 6619 7 Straton Straton NNP 40436 6619 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6619 9 how how WRB 40436 6619 10 comes come VBZ 40436 6619 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6619 12 that that IN 40436 6619 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6619 14 require require VBP 40436 6619 15 demonstrations demonstration NNS 40436 6619 16 to to TO 40436 6619 17 conduct conduct VB 40436 6619 18 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6619 19 to to IN 40436 6619 20 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6619 21 ? ? . 40436 6620 1 and and CC 40436 6620 2 how how WRB 40436 6620 3 is be VBZ 40436 6620 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6620 5 that that WDT 40436 6620 6 no no DT 40436 6620 7 man man NN 40436 6620 8 can can MD 40436 6620 9 play play VB 40436 6620 10 on on IN 40436 6620 11 the the DT 40436 6620 12 flute flute NN 40436 6620 13 or or CC 40436 6620 14 the the DT 40436 6620 15 harp harp NN 40436 6620 16 without without IN 40436 6620 17 practice practice NN 40436 6620 18 ? ? . 40436 6621 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6621 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6621 3 : : : 40436 6621 4 O(/ti O(/ti NNP 40436 6621 5 Bi Bi NNP 40436 6621 6 / / SYM 40436 6621 7 ôn ôn NNP 40436 6621 8 ê)po ê)po NNPS 40436 6621 9 / / SYM 40436 6621 10 rei rei VB 40436 6621 11 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6621 12 tou= tou= NNP 40436 6621 13 pseu pseu NNS 40436 6621 14 / / SYM 40436 6621 15 dous dous JJ 40436 6621 16 , , , 40436 6621 17 ei ei UH 40436 6621 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6621 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6621 20 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 6621 21 kat kat NNP 40436 6621 22 ' ' '' 40436 6621 23 a)na a)na NNS 40436 6621 24 / / SYM 40436 6621 25 mnêsin mnêsin NN 40436 6621 26 , , , 40436 6621 27 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 6621 28 to\ to\ NN 40436 6621 29 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 6621 30 / / SYM 40436 6621 31 on on IN 40436 6621 32 ge ge NNP 40436 6621 33 , , , 40436 6621 34 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 6621 35 ou)/ ou)/ RB 40436 6621 36 ? ? . 40436 6622 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6622 2 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 6622 3 ê ê NNP 40436 6622 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6622 5 a)logi a)logi NNP 40436 6622 6 / / SYM 40436 6622 7 a a NN 40436 6622 8 ? ? . 40436 6623 1 O(/ti O(/ti NNP 40436 6623 2 Stra Stra NNP 40436 6623 3 / / SYM 40436 6623 4 tôn tôn NNP 40436 6623 5 ê)po ê)po NNPS 40436 6623 6 / / SYM 40436 6623 7 rei rei NN 40436 6623 8 , , , 40436 6623 9 ei ei NNP 40436 6623 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6623 11 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 6623 12 a)namnêsis a)namnêsis CD 40436 6623 13 , , , 40436 6623 14 pô pô NNP 40436 6623 15 = = NFP 40436 6623 16 s s POS 40436 6623 17 a)/neu a)/neu NNP 40436 6623 18 a)podei a)podei NNP 40436 6623 19 / / SYM 40436 6623 20 xeôn xeôn NNP 40436 6623 21 ou ou NNP 40436 6623 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6623 23 gigno gigno NNP 40436 6623 24 / / SYM 40436 6623 25 metha metha NNP 40436 6623 26 e)pistê e)pistê NNPS 40436 6623 27 / / SYM 40436 6623 28 mones mone NNS 40436 6623 29 ? ? . 40436 6624 1 pô pô NNP 40436 6624 2 = = SYM 40436 6624 3 s s NNP 40436 6624 4 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6624 5 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 6624 6 au)lêtê\s au)lêtê\s NNP 40436 6624 7 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 6624 8 kitharistê\s kitharistê\s ADD 40436 6624 9 ge ge NNP 40436 6624 10 / / SYM 40436 6624 11 gonen gonen NNP 40436 6624 12 a)/neu a)/neu NNP 40436 6624 13 mele mele NNP 40436 6624 14 / / SYM 40436 6624 15 tês tês NNP 40436 6624 16 ? ? . 40436 6624 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6624 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6625 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6625 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6625 3 44 44 CD 40436 6625 4 : : : 40436 6625 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6625 6 , , , 40436 6625 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6625 8 , , , 40436 6625 9 p. p. NN 40436 6625 10 84 84 CD 40436 6625 11 . . . 40436 6626 1 The the DT 40436 6626 2 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 40436 6626 3 Dissertation Dissertation NNP 40436 6626 4 of of IN 40436 6626 5 Maximus Maximus NNP 40436 6626 6 Tyrius Tyrius NNP 40436 6626 7 presents present VBZ 40436 6626 8 a a DT 40436 6626 9 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 6626 10 amplification amplification NN 40436 6626 11 of of IN 40436 6626 12 this this DT 40436 6626 13 doctrine--[Greek doctrine--[greek CD 40436 6626 14 : : : 40436 6626 15 pa pa NNP 40436 6626 16 = = SYM 40436 6626 17 sa sa NNP 40436 6626 18 ma ma NNP 40436 6626 19 / / SYM 40436 6626 20 thêsis thêsis NNP 40436 6626 21 , , , 40436 6626 22 a)na a)na NNP 40436 6626 23 / / SYM 40436 6626 24 mnêsis]--in mnêsis]--in NNP 40436 6626 25 which which WDT 40436 6626 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6626 27 enters enter VBZ 40436 6626 28 fully fully RB 40436 6626 29 into into IN 40436 6626 30 the the DT 40436 6626 31 spirit spirit NN 40436 6626 32 of of IN 40436 6626 33 the the DT 40436 6626 34 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6626 35 and and CC 40436 6626 36 the the DT 40436 6626 37 Phædon--[Greek Phædon--[Greek NNP 40436 6626 38 : : : 40436 6626 39 au)todi au)todi NNP 40436 6626 40 / / SYM 40436 6626 41 dakto dakto NNP 40436 6626 42 / / SYM 40436 6626 43 n n CC 40436 6626 44 ti ti NNP 40436 6626 45 chrê chrê NNP 40436 6626 46 = = SYM 40436 6626 47 ma ma NNP 40436 6626 48 ê ê NNP 40436 6626 49 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6626 50 psuchê/--ê psuchê/--ê NNP 40436 6626 51 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6626 52 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 6626 53 = = NFP 40436 6626 54 s s NNP 40436 6626 55 eu(/resis eu(/resis NN 40436 6626 56 , , , 40436 6626 57 au)togenê au)togenê NN 40436 6626 58 / / SYM 40436 6626 59 s s NNP 40436 6626 60 tis tis NN 40436 6626 61 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 6626 62 , , , 40436 6626 63 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6626 64 au)tophuê\s au)tophuê\s NNP 40436 6626 65 , , , 40436 6626 66 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6626 67 xu xu NNP 40436 6626 68 / / SYM 40436 6626 69 mphutos mphutos NNP 40436 6626 70 , , , 40436 6626 71 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 6626 72 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 6626 73 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 6626 74 ê)\ ê)\ SYM 40436 6626 75 do do VB 40436 6626 76 / / SYM 40436 6626 77 xai xai NNP 40436 6626 78 a)lêthei a)lêthei , 40436 6626 79 = = SYM 40436 6626 80 s s NNP 40436 6626 81 e)geiro e)geiro NNP 40436 6626 82 / / SYM 40436 6626 83 menai menai NNPS 40436 6626 84 , , , 40436 6626 85 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 6626 86 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 6626 87 e)pege e)pege CD 40436 6626 88 / / SYM 40436 6626 89 rsei rsei NNP 40436 6626 90 te te NNP 40436 6626 91 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6626 92 xunta xunta NNP 40436 6626 93 / / SYM 40436 6626 94 xei xei NNP 40436 6626 95 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6626 96 / / SYM 40436 6626 97 mê mê NNP 40436 6626 98 o)/noma o)/noma NNP 40436 6626 99 ? ? . 40436 6626 100 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6627 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6627 2 c. c. NNP 40436 6627 3 6 6 CD 40436 6627 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6627 5 . . . 40436 6628 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6628 2 also also RB 40436 6628 3 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 6628 4 , , , 40436 6628 5 Tusc tusc JJ 40436 6628 6 . . . 40436 6629 1 D. D. NNP 40436 6629 2 i. i. NNP 40436 6630 1 24 24 CD 40436 6630 2 . . . 40436 6631 1 The the DT 40436 6631 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6631 3 has have VBZ 40436 6631 4 furnished furnish VBN 40436 6631 5 a a DT 40436 6631 6 theme theme NN 40436 6631 7 for for IN 40436 6631 8 very very RB 40436 6631 9 elegant elegant JJ 40436 6631 10 poetry poetry NN 40436 6631 11 : : : 40436 6631 12 both both DT 40436 6631 13 in in IN 40436 6631 14 the the DT 40436 6631 15 Consolatio Consolatio NNP 40436 6631 16 Philosophiæ Philosophiæ NNP 40436 6631 17 of of IN 40436 6631 18 Boethius Boethius NNP 40436 6631 19 -- -- : 40436 6631 20 the the DT 40436 6631 21 piece piece NN 40436 6631 22 which which WDT 40436 6631 23 ends end VBZ 40436 6631 24 with with IN 40436 6631 25 " " `` 40436 6631 26 Ac Ac NNP 40436 6631 27 si si NN 40436 6631 28 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 6631 29 Musa Musa NNP 40436 6631 30 personat personat NN 40436 6631 31 verum verum NN 40436 6631 32 , , , 40436 6631 33 Quod Quod NNP 40436 6631 34 quisque quisque NNP 40436 6631 35 discit discit NN 40436 6631 36 , , , 40436 6631 37 immemor immemor NN 40436 6631 38 recordatur"-- recordatur"-- NNP 40436 6631 39 and and CC 40436 6631 40 in in IN 40436 6631 41 Wordsworth--"Our wordsworth--"our CD 40436 6631 42 birth birth NN 40436 6631 43 is be VBZ 40436 6631 44 but but CC 40436 6631 45 a a DT 40436 6631 46 sleep sleep NN 40436 6631 47 and and CC 40436 6631 48 a a DT 40436 6631 49 forgetting forgetting NN 40436 6631 50 , , , 40436 6631 51 " " '' 40436 6631 52 & & CC 40436 6631 53 c. c. NNP 40436 6631 54 On on IN 40436 6631 55 the the DT 40436 6631 56 other other JJ 40436 6631 57 hand hand NN 40436 6631 58 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6631 59 alludes allude NNS 40436 6631 60 also also RB 40436 6631 61 to to IN 40436 6631 62 the the DT 40436 6631 63 same same JJ 40436 6631 64 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6631 65 and and CC 40436 6631 66 criticises criticise VBZ 40436 6631 67 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6631 68 ; ; : 40436 6631 69 but but CC 40436 6631 70 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6631 71 does do VBZ 40436 6631 72 not not RB 40436 6631 73 seem seem VB 40436 6631 74 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6631 75 so so RB 40436 6631 76 far far RB 40436 6631 77 as as IN 40436 6631 78 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6631 79 can can MD 40436 6631 80 understand understand VB 40436 6631 81 this this DT 40436 6631 82 brief brief JJ 40436 6631 83 allusion allusion NN 40436 6631 84 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6631 85 to to TO 40436 6631 86 seize seize VB 40436 6631 87 exactly exactly RB 40436 6631 88 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6631 89 's 's POS 40436 6631 90 meaning meaning NN 40436 6631 91 . . . 40436 6632 1 This this DT 40436 6632 2 is be VBZ 40436 6632 3 the the DT 40436 6632 4 remark remark NN 40436 6632 5 of of IN 40436 6632 6 the the DT 40436 6632 7 Scholiast Scholiast NNP 40436 6632 8 on on IN 40436 6632 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6632 10 : : : 40436 6632 11 and and CC 40436 6632 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6632 13 think think VBP 40436 6632 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6632 15 just just RB 40436 6632 16 . . . 40436 6633 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6633 2 is be VBZ 40436 6633 3 curious curious JJ 40436 6633 4 to to TO 40436 6633 5 compare compare VB 40436 6633 6 the the DT 40436 6633 7 way way NN 40436 6633 8 in in IN 40436 6633 9 which which WDT 40436 6633 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6633 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6633 12 : : : 40436 6633 13 a)na a)na NNS 40436 6633 14 / / SYM 40436 6633 15 mnêsis mnêsis NN 40436 6633 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6633 17 is be VBZ 40436 6633 18 handled handle VBN 40436 6633 19 by by IN 40436 6633 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6633 21 in in IN 40436 6633 22 the the DT 40436 6633 23 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6633 24 and and CC 40436 6633 25 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 6633 26 , , , 40436 6633 27 and and CC 40436 6633 28 by by IN 40436 6633 29 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6633 30 in in IN 40436 6633 31 the the DT 40436 6633 32 valuable valuable JJ 40436 6633 33 little little JJ 40436 6633 34 tract--[Greek tract--[greek CD 40436 6633 35 : : : 40436 6633 36 Peri\ peri\ NN 40436 6633 37 mnê mnê NNP 40436 6633 38 / / SYM 40436 6633 39 nês nês NNP 40436 6633 40 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6633 41 a)namnê a)namnê NNP 40436 6633 42 / / SYM 40436 6633 43 seôs seôs NNP 40436 6633 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6633 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6633 46 p. p. NN 40436 6633 47 451 451 CD 40436 6633 48 , , , 40436 6633 49 b. b. NNP 40436 6633 50 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6633 51 . . . 40436 6634 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6634 2 has have VBZ 40436 6634 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6634 4 own own JJ 40436 6634 5 way way NN 40436 6634 6 of of IN 40436 6634 7 replying reply VBG 40436 6634 8 to to IN 40436 6634 9 the the DT 40436 6634 10 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 6634 11 raised raise VBN 40436 6634 12 in in IN 40436 6634 13 the the DT 40436 6634 14 question question NN 40436 6634 15 of of IN 40436 6634 16 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6634 17 , , , 40436 6634 18 and and CC 40436 6634 19 tries try VBZ 40436 6634 20 to to TO 40436 6634 21 show show VB 40436 6634 22 that that IN 40436 6634 23 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 6634 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6634 25 _ _ NNP 40436 6634 26 know know VBP 40436 6634 27 _ _ NNP 40436 6634 28 in in IN 40436 6634 29 one one CD 40436 6634 30 sense sense NN 40436 6634 31 and and CC 40436 6634 32 _ _ NNP 40436 6634 33 do do VBP 40436 6634 34 not not RB 40436 6634 35 know know VB 40436 6634 36 _ _ NNP 40436 6634 37 in in IN 40436 6634 38 another another DT 40436 6634 39 . . . 40436 6635 1 See see VB 40436 6635 2 Aristotel Aristotel NNP 40436 6635 3 . . . 40436 6636 1 Anal anal JJ 40436 6636 2 . . . 40436 6637 1 Prior prior RB 40436 6637 2 . . . 40436 6637 3 , , , 40436 6637 4 ii ii NNP 40436 6637 5 . . . 40436 6638 1 p. p. NN 40436 6638 2 67 67 CD 40436 6638 3 , , , 40436 6638 4 a. a. NN 40436 6639 1 22 22 LS 40436 6639 2 ; ; : 40436 6639 3 Anal Anal NNP 40436 6639 4 . . . 40436 6640 1 Poster poster NN 40436 6640 2 . . . 40436 6641 1 i. i. NNP 40436 6641 2 p. p. NNP 40436 6641 3 71 71 CD 40436 6641 4 , , , 40436 6641 5 a. a. NN 40436 6642 1 27 27 CD 40436 6642 2 ; ; : 40436 6642 3 and and CC 40436 6642 4 the the DT 40436 6642 5 Scholia Scholia NNP 40436 6642 6 on on IN 40436 6642 7 the the DT 40436 6642 8 former former JJ 40436 6642 9 passage passage NN 40436 6642 10 , , , 40436 6642 11 p. p. NN 40436 6642 12 193 193 CD 40436 6642 13 , , , 40436 6642 14 b. b. NNP 40436 6643 1 21 21 CD 40436 6643 2 , , , 40436 6643 3 ed ed NN 40436 6643 4 . . . 40436 6644 1 Brandis Brandis NNP 40436 6644 2 . . . 40436 6645 1 Sir Sir NNP 40436 6645 2 William William NNP 40436 6645 3 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 40436 6645 4 , , , 40436 6645 5 in in IN 40436 6645 6 one one CD 40436 6645 7 of of IN 40436 6645 8 the the DT 40436 6645 9 Appendixes Appendixes NNPS 40436 6645 10 to to IN 40436 6645 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6645 12 edition edition NN 40436 6645 13 of of IN 40436 6645 14 Reid Reid NNP 40436 6645 15 's 's POS 40436 6645 16 Works work NNS 40436 6645 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6645 18 Append append NN 40436 6645 19 . . . 40436 6646 1 D. D. NNP 40436 6646 2 p. p. NN 40436 6646 3 890 890 CD 40436 6646 4 seq seq NN 40436 6646 5 . . . 40436 6647 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6647 2 , , , 40436 6647 3 has have VBZ 40436 6647 4 given give VBN 40436 6647 5 a a DT 40436 6647 6 learned learned JJ 40436 6647 7 and and CC 40436 6647 8 valuable valuable JJ 40436 6647 9 translation translation NN 40436 6647 10 and and CC 40436 6647 11 illustration illustration NN 40436 6647 12 of of IN 40436 6647 13 the the DT 40436 6647 14 treatise treatise NN 40436 6647 15 of of IN 40436 6647 16 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6647 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6647 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6647 19 : : : 40436 6647 20 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 6647 21 A)namnê A)namnê NNP 40436 6647 22 / / SYM 40436 6647 23 seôs seôs NNP 40436 6647 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6647 25 . . . 40436 6648 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6648 2 note note VBP 40436 6648 3 , , , 40436 6648 4 however however RB 40436 6648 5 , , , 40436 6648 6 with with IN 40436 6648 7 some some DT 40436 6648 8 surprise surprise NN 40436 6648 9 , , , 40436 6648 10 that that IN 40436 6648 11 while while IN 40436 6648 12 collecting collect VBG 40436 6648 13 many many JJ 40436 6648 14 interesting interesting JJ 40436 6648 15 comments comment NNS 40436 6648 16 from from IN 40436 6648 17 writers writer NNS 40436 6648 18 who who WP 40436 6648 19 lived live VBD 40436 6648 20 _ _ NNP 40436 6648 21 after after IN 40436 6648 22 _ _ NNP 40436 6648 23 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6648 24 , , , 40436 6648 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6648 26 has have VBZ 40436 6648 27 not not RB 40436 6648 28 adverted advert VBN 40436 6648 29 to to IN 40436 6648 30 what what WP 40436 6648 31 was be VBD 40436 6648 32 said say VBN 40436 6648 33 upon upon IN 40436 6648 34 this this DT 40436 6648 35 same same JJ 40436 6648 36 subject subject NN 40436 6648 37 by by IN 40436 6648 38 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6648 39 , , , 40436 6648 40 _ _ NNP 40436 6648 41 before before IN 40436 6648 42 _ _ NNP 40436 6648 43 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6648 44 . . . 40436 6649 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6649 2 was be VBD 40436 6649 3 the the DT 40436 6649 4 more more JJR 40436 6649 5 to to TO 40436 6649 6 be be VB 40436 6649 7 expected expect VBN 40436 6649 8 that that IN 40436 6649 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6649 10 would would MD 40436 6649 11 do do VB 40436 6649 12 this this DT 40436 6649 13 , , , 40436 6649 14 since since IN 40436 6649 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6649 16 insists insist VBZ 40436 6649 17 so so RB 40436 6649 18 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 6649 19 upon upon IN 40436 6649 20 the the DT 40436 6649 21 complete complete JJ 40436 6649 22 originality originality NN 40436 6649 23 of of IN 40436 6649 24 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6649 25 . . . 40436 6649 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6650 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6650 2 Side side NN 40436 6650 3 - - HYPH 40436 6650 4 note note NN 40436 6650 5 : : : 40436 6650 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6650 7 's 's POS 40436 6650 8 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6650 9 about about IN 40436 6650 10 _ _ NNP 40436 6650 11 à à NNP 40436 6650 12 priori priori VBP 40436 6650 13 _ _ NNP 40436 6650 14 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 6650 15 -- -- : 40436 6650 16 Different different JJ 40436 6650 17 from from IN 40436 6650 18 the the DT 40436 6650 19 modern modern JJ 40436 6650 20 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6650 21 . . . 40436 6650 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6651 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6651 2 does do VBZ 40436 6651 3 not not RB 40436 6651 4 intend intend VB 40436 6651 5 here here RB 40436 6651 6 to to TO 40436 6651 7 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 6651 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6651 9 as as IN 40436 6651 10 many many JJ 40436 6651 11 modern modern JJ 40436 6651 12 writers writer NNS 40436 6651 13 distinguish distinguish VBP 40436 6651 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6651 15 geometry geometry NN 40436 6651 16 from from IN 40436 6651 17 other other JJ 40436 6651 18 sciences science NNS 40436 6651 19 , , , 40436 6651 20 as as IN 40436 6651 21 if if IN 40436 6651 22 geometry geometry NN 40436 6651 23 were be VBD 40436 6651 24 known know VBN 40436 6651 25 _ _ NNP 40436 6651 26 à à NNP 40436 6651 27 priori priori FW 40436 6651 28 _ _ NNP 40436 6651 29 , , , 40436 6651 30 and and CC 40436 6651 31 other other JJ 40436 6651 32 sciences science NNS 40436 6651 33 known know VBN 40436 6651 34 _ _ NNP 40436 6651 35 à à NNP 40436 6651 36 posteriori posteriori NN 40436 6651 37 _ _ NNP 40436 6651 38 or or CC 40436 6651 39 from from IN 40436 6651 40 experience experience NN 40436 6651 41 . . . 40436 6652 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6652 2 does do VBZ 40436 6652 3 not not RB 40436 6652 4 suppose suppose VB 40436 6652 5 that that IN 40436 6652 6 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 6652 7 truths truth NNS 40436 6652 8 are be VBP 40436 6652 9 such such JJ 40436 6652 10 that that IN 40436 6652 11 no no DT 40436 6652 12 man man NN 40436 6652 13 can can MD 40436 6652 14 possibly possibly RB 40436 6652 15 believe believe VB 40436 6652 16 the the DT 40436 6652 17 contrary contrary NN 40436 6652 18 of of IN 40436 6652 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6652 20 ; ; : 40436 6652 21 or or CC 40436 6652 22 that that IN 40436 6652 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6652 24 are be VBP 40436 6652 25 different different JJ 40436 6652 26 in in IN 40436 6652 27 this this DT 40436 6652 28 respect respect NN 40436 6652 29 from from IN 40436 6652 30 the the DT 40436 6652 31 truths truth NNS 40436 6652 32 of of IN 40436 6652 33 any any DT 40436 6652 34 other other JJ 40436 6652 35 science science NN 40436 6652 36 . . . 40436 6653 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6653 2 here here RB 40436 6653 3 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 6653 4 that that IN 40436 6653 5 all all PDT 40436 6653 6 the the DT 40436 6653 7 sciences science NNS 40436 6653 8 lie lie VBP 40436 6653 9 equally equally RB 40436 6653 10 in in IN 40436 6653 11 the the DT 40436 6653 12 untaught untaught JJ 40436 6653 13 mind,[45 mind,[45 CD 40436 6653 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6653 15 but but CC 40436 6653 16 buried bury VBN 40436 6653 17 , , , 40436 6653 18 forgotten forget VBN 40436 6653 19 , , , 40436 6653 20 and and CC 40436 6653 21 confused confuse VBD 40436 6653 22 : : : 40436 6653 23 so so IN 40436 6653 24 as as IN 40436 6653 25 to to TO 40436 6653 26 require require VB 40436 6653 27 the the DT 40436 6653 28 skill skill NN 40436 6653 29 of of IN 40436 6653 30 the the DT 40436 6653 31 questioner questioner NN 40436 6653 32 not not RB 40436 6653 33 merely merely RB 40436 6653 34 to to TO 40436 6653 35 recall recall VB 40436 6653 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6653 37 into into IN 40436 6653 38 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 6653 39 , , , 40436 6653 40 but but CC 40436 6653 41 to to TO 40436 6653 42 disentangle disentangle VB 40436 6653 43 truth truth NN 40436 6653 44 from from IN 40436 6653 45 error error NN 40436 6653 46 . . . 40436 6654 1 Far far RB 40436 6654 2 from from IN 40436 6654 3 supposing suppose VBG 40436 6654 4 that that IN 40436 6654 5 the the DT 40436 6654 6 untaught untaught JJ 40436 6654 7 mind mind NN 40436 6654 8 has have VBZ 40436 6654 9 a a DT 40436 6654 10 natural natural JJ 40436 6654 11 tendency tendency NN 40436 6654 12 to to TO 40436 6654 13 answer answer VB 40436 6654 14 correctly correctly RB 40436 6654 15 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 6654 16 questions question NNS 40436 6654 17 , , , 40436 6654 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6654 19 treats treat VBZ 40436 6654 20 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 6654 21 answers answer NNS 40436 6654 22 as as IN 40436 6654 23 springing spring VBG 40436 6654 24 up up RP 40436 6654 25 more more RBR 40436 6654 26 naturally naturally RB 40436 6654 27 than than IN 40436 6654 28 true true JJ 40436 6654 29 answers answer NNS 40436 6654 30 , , , 40436 6654 31 and and CC 40436 6654 32 as as IN 40436 6654 33 requiring require VBG 40436 6654 34 a a DT 40436 6654 35 process process NN 40436 6654 36 of of IN 40436 6654 37 painful painful JJ 40436 6654 38 exposure exposure NN 40436 6654 39 before before IN 40436 6654 40 the the DT 40436 6654 41 mind mind NN 40436 6654 42 can can MD 40436 6654 43 be be VB 40436 6654 44 put put VBN 40436 6654 45 upon upon IN 40436 6654 46 the the DT 40436 6654 47 right right JJ 40436 6654 48 track track NN 40436 6654 49 . . . 40436 6655 1 The the DT 40436 6655 2 questioner questioner NN 40436 6655 3 , , , 40436 6655 4 without without IN 40436 6655 5 possessing possess VBG 40436 6655 6 any any DT 40436 6655 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6655 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6655 9 , , , 40436 6655 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6655 11 so so RB 40436 6655 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6655 13 thinks think VBZ 40436 6655 14 , , , 40436 6655 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6655 16 can can MD 40436 6655 17 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 6655 18 exercise exercise VB 40436 6655 19 an an DT 40436 6655 20 influence influence NN 40436 6655 21 at at IN 40436 6655 22 once once RB 40436 6655 23 stimulating stimulate VBG 40436 6655 24 , , , 40436 6655 25 corrective corrective JJ 40436 6655 26 , , , 40436 6655 27 and and CC 40436 6655 28 directive directive NN 40436 6655 29 . . . 40436 6656 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6656 2 stimulates stimulate VBZ 40436 6656 3 the the DT 40436 6656 4 action action NN 40436 6656 5 of of IN 40436 6656 6 the the DT 40436 6656 7 associative associative JJ 40436 6656 8 process process NN 40436 6656 9 , , , 40436 6656 10 to to TO 40436 6656 11 call call VB 40436 6656 12 up up RP 40436 6656 13 facts fact NNS 40436 6656 14 , , , 40436 6656 15 comparisons comparison NNS 40436 6656 16 , , , 40436 6656 17 and and CC 40436 6656 18 analogies analogy NNS 40436 6656 19 , , , 40436 6656 20 bearing bear VBG 40436 6656 21 on on IN 40436 6656 22 the the DT 40436 6656 23 question question NN 40436 6656 24 : : : 40436 6656 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6656 26 arrests arrest VBZ 40436 6656 27 the the DT 40436 6656 28 respondent respondent NN 40436 6656 29 on on IN 40436 6656 30 a a DT 40436 6656 31 wrong wrong JJ 40436 6656 32 answer answer NN 40436 6656 33 , , , 40436 6656 34 creating create VBG 40436 6656 35 within within IN 40436 6656 36 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6656 37 a a DT 40436 6656 38 painful painful JJ 40436 6656 39 sense sense NN 40436 6656 40 of of IN 40436 6656 41 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 6656 42 and and CC 40436 6656 43 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 6656 44 : : : 40436 6656 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6656 46 directs direct VBZ 40436 6656 47 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6656 48 by by IN 40436 6656 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6656 50 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 6656 51 questions question NNS 40436 6656 52 into into IN 40436 6656 53 the the DT 40436 6656 54 path path NN 40436 6656 55 of of IN 40436 6656 56 right right JJ 40436 6656 57 answers answer NNS 40436 6656 58 . . . 40436 6657 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6657 2 obstetric obstetric JJ 40436 6657 3 aid aid NN 40436 6657 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6657 5 to to TO 40436 6657 6 use use VB 40436 6657 7 the the DT 40436 6657 8 simile simile NN 40436 6657 9 in in IN 40436 6657 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6657 11 's 's POS 40436 6657 12 Theætetus Theætetus NNP 40436 6657 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6657 14 , , , 40436 6657 15 though though IN 40436 6657 16 presupposing presuppose VBG 40436 6657 17 the the DT 40436 6657 18 pregnancy pregnancy NN 40436 6657 19 of of IN 40436 6657 20 the the DT 40436 6657 21 respondent respondent JJ 40436 6657 22 mind mind NN 40436 6657 23 , , , 40436 6657 24 is be VBZ 40436 6657 25 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 6657 26 both both DT 40436 6657 27 to to TO 40436 6657 28 forward forward RB 40436 6657 29 the the DT 40436 6657 30 childbirth childbirth NN 40436 6657 31 , , , 40436 6657 32 and and CC 40436 6657 33 to to TO 40436 6657 34 throw throw VB 40436 6657 35 away away RB 40436 6657 36 any any DT 40436 6657 37 offspring offspring NN 40436 6657 38 which which WDT 40436 6657 39 may may MD 40436 6657 40 happen happen VB 40436 6657 41 to to TO 40436 6657 42 be be VB 40436 6657 43 deformed deform VBN 40436 6657 44 . . . 40436 6658 1 In in IN 40436 6658 2 the the DT 40436 6658 3 Theætetus Theætetus NNP 40436 6658 4 , , , 40436 6658 5 the the DT 40436 6658 6 main main JJ 40436 6658 7 stress stress NN 40436 6658 8 is be VBZ 40436 6658 9 laid lay VBN 40436 6658 10 on on IN 40436 6658 11 that that DT 40436 6658 12 part part NN 40436 6658 13 of of IN 40436 6658 14 the the DT 40436 6658 15 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6658 16 which which WDT 40436 6658 17 is be VBZ 40436 6658 18 performed perform VBN 40436 6658 19 by by IN 40436 6658 20 the the DT 40436 6658 21 questioner questioner NN 40436 6658 22 : : : 40436 6658 23 in in IN 40436 6658 24 the the DT 40436 6658 25 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6658 26 , , , 40436 6658 27 upon upon IN 40436 6658 28 the the DT 40436 6658 29 latent latent NN 40436 6658 30 competence competence NN 40436 6658 31 and and CC 40436 6658 32 large large JJ 40436 6658 33 dead dead JJ 40436 6658 34 stock stock NN 40436 6658 35 of of IN 40436 6658 36 an an DT 40436 6658 37 untaught untaught JJ 40436 6658 38 respondent respondent NN 40436 6658 39 . . . 40436 6659 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6659 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6659 3 45 45 CD 40436 6659 4 : : : 40436 6659 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6659 6 , , , 40436 6659 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6659 8 , , , 40436 6659 9 p. p. NN 40436 6659 10 85 85 CD 40436 6659 11 E. E. NNP 40436 6659 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6659 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6659 14 : : : 40436 6659 15 ou(=tos ou(=tos . 40436 6659 16 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6659 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6659 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6659 19 the the DT 40436 6659 20 untaught untaught JJ 40436 6659 21 slave slave NN 40436 6659 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6659 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6659 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6659 25 : : : 40436 6659 26 poiê poiê NNP 40436 6659 27 / / SYM 40436 6659 28 sei sei NNP 40436 6659 29 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6659 30 pa pa NNP 40436 6659 31 / / SYM 40436 6659 32 sês sês NNP 40436 6659 33 geômetri geômetri NNP 40436 6659 34 / / NFP 40436 6659 35 as as IN 40436 6659 36 tau)ta\ tau)ta\ NNP 40436 6659 37 tau tau NNP 40436 6659 38 = = SYM 40436 6659 39 ta ta NNP 40436 6659 40 , , , 40436 6659 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6659 42 tô tô NNP 40436 6659 43 = = SYM 40436 6659 44 n n CC 40436 6659 45 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 6659 46 mathêma mathêma NNP 40436 6659 47 / / SYM 40436 6659 48 tôn tôn NNP 40436 6659 49 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 6659 50 / / SYM 40436 6659 51 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 6659 52 . . . 40436 6659 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6659 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6660 1 The the DT 40436 6660 2 mind mind NN 40436 6660 3 of of IN 40436 6660 4 the the DT 40436 6660 5 slave slave NN 40436 6660 6 questioned question VBN 40436 6660 7 by by IN 40436 6660 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6660 9 is be VBZ 40436 6660 10 discovered discover VBN 40436 6660 11 to to TO 40436 6660 12 be be VB 40436 6660 13 pregnant pregnant JJ 40436 6660 14 . . . 40436 6661 1 Though though IN 40436 6661 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6661 3 has have VBZ 40436 6661 4 received receive VBN 40436 6661 5 no no DT 40436 6661 6 teaching teaching NN 40436 6661 7 from from IN 40436 6661 8 any any DT 40436 6661 9 professed professed JJ 40436 6661 10 geometer geometer NN 40436 6661 11 , , , 40436 6661 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6661 13 is be VBZ 40436 6661 14 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 6661 15 found find VBN 40436 6661 16 competent competent JJ 40436 6661 17 , , , 40436 6661 18 when when WRB 40436 6661 19 subjected subject VBN 40436 6661 20 to to IN 40436 6661 21 a a DT 40436 6661 22 skilful skilful JJ 40436 6661 23 interrogatory interrogatory NN 40436 6661 24 , , , 40436 6661 25 to to TO 40436 6661 26 arrive arrive VB 40436 6661 27 at at IN 40436 6661 28 last last JJ 40436 6661 29 , , , 40436 6661 30 through through IN 40436 6661 31 a a DT 40436 6661 32 series series NN 40436 6661 33 of of IN 40436 6661 34 mistakes mistake NNS 40436 6661 35 , , , 40436 6661 36 at at IN 40436 6661 37 correct correct JJ 40436 6661 38 answers answer NNS 40436 6661 39 , , , 40436 6661 40 determining determine VBG 40436 6661 41 certain certain JJ 40436 6661 42 simple simple JJ 40436 6661 43 problems problem NNS 40436 6661 44 of of IN 40436 6661 45 geometry geometry NN 40436 6661 46 . . . 40436 6662 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6662 2 knows know VBZ 40436 6662 3 nothing nothing NN 40436 6662 4 about about IN 40436 6662 5 geometry geometry NN 40436 6662 6 : : : 40436 6662 7 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 6662 8 there there EX 40436 6662 9 exist exist VBP 40436 6662 10 in in IN 40436 6662 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6662 12 mind mind NN 40436 6662 13 true true JJ 40436 6662 14 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6662 15 respecting respect VBG 40436 6662 16 that that IN 40436 6662 17 which which WDT 40436 6662 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6662 19 does do VBZ 40436 6662 20 not not RB 40436 6662 21 know know VB 40436 6662 22 . . . 40436 6663 1 These these DT 40436 6663 2 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6663 3 are be VBP 40436 6663 4 " " `` 40436 6663 5 called call VBN 40436 6663 6 up up RP 40436 6663 7 like like IN 40436 6663 8 a a DT 40436 6663 9 dream dream NN 40436 6663 10 " " '' 40436 6663 11 by by IN 40436 6663 12 the the DT 40436 6663 13 interrogatories interrogatory NNS 40436 6663 14 : : : 40436 6663 15 which which WDT 40436 6663 16 , , , 40436 6663 17 if if IN 40436 6663 18 repeated repeat VBN 40436 6663 19 and and CC 40436 6663 20 diversified diversify VBD 40436 6663 21 , , , 40436 6663 22 convert convert VB 40436 6663 23 the the DT 40436 6663 24 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6663 25 into into IN 40436 6663 26 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6663 27 , , , 40436 6663 28 taken take VBN 40436 6663 29 up up RP 40436 6663 30 by by IN 40436 6663 31 the the DT 40436 6663 32 respondent respondent NN 40436 6663 33 out out IN 40436 6663 34 of of IN 40436 6663 35 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6663 36 . . . 40436 6664 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6664 2 46 46 CD 40436 6664 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6664 4 The the DT 40436 6664 5 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6664 6 are be VBP 40436 6664 7 inherited inherit VBN 40436 6664 8 from from IN 40436 6664 9 an an DT 40436 6664 10 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 6664 11 life life NN 40436 6664 12 and and CC 40436 6664 13 born bear VBN 40436 6664 14 with with IN 40436 6664 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6664 16 , , , 40436 6664 17 since since IN 40436 6664 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6664 19 have have VBP 40436 6664 20 never never RB 40436 6664 21 been be VBN 40436 6664 22 taught teach VBN 40436 6664 23 to to IN 40436 6664 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6664 25 during during IN 40436 6664 26 this this DT 40436 6664 27 life life NN 40436 6664 28 . . . 40436 6665 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6665 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6665 3 46 46 CD 40436 6665 4 : : : 40436 6665 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6665 6 , , , 40436 6665 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6665 8 , , , 40436 6665 9 p. p. NN 40436 6665 10 85 85 CD 40436 6665 11 . . . 40436 6666 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6666 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6666 3 : : : 40436 6666 4 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 6666 5 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 6666 6 eido eido NNP 40436 6666 7 / / , 40436 6666 8 ti ti NNP 40436 6666 9 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 6666 10 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 6666 11 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 6666 12 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 6666 13 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 6666 14 ei)dê=| ei)dê=| NNPS 40436 6666 15 e)/neisin e)/neisin NNP 40436 6666 16 a)lêthei a)lêthei NFP 40436 6666 17 = = SYM 40436 6666 18 s s NNP 40436 6666 19 do do VB 40436 6666 20 / / SYM 40436 6666 21 xai xai NNP 40436 6666 22 . . . 40436 6667 1 . . . 40436 6668 1 . . . 40436 6669 1 . . . 40436 6670 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6670 2 nu nu NNP 40436 6670 3 = = SYM 40436 6670 4 n n CC 40436 6670 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6670 6 / / SYM 40436 6670 7 n n CC 40436 6670 8 ge ge NNP 40436 6670 9 _ _ NNP 40436 6670 10 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 6670 11 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 6670 12 o)/nar o)/nar NNP 40436 6670 13 _ _ NNP 40436 6670 14 a)/rti a)/rti NNP 40436 6670 15 a)nakeki a)nakeki NNP 40436 6670 16 / / SYM 40436 6670 17 nêntai nêntai NNP 40436 6670 18 ai ai NNP 40436 6670 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6670 20 do do VB 40436 6670 21 / / SYM 40436 6670 22 xai xai NNP 40436 6670 23 au(=tai au(=tai NNP 40436 6670 24 ; ; : 40436 6670 25 ei ei NNP 40436 6670 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6670 27 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6670 28 au)to au)to NNP 40436 6670 29 / / SYM 40436 6670 30 n n NNP 40436 6670 31 tis tis NNP 40436 6670 32 a)nerê a)nerê , 40436 6670 33 / / SYM 40436 6670 34 setai setai NNP 40436 6670 35 polla polla NNP 40436 6670 36 / / SYM 40436 6670 37 kis kis NNP 40436 6670 38 ta\ ta\ JJ 40436 6670 39 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 6670 40 tau tau NNS 40436 6670 41 = = SYM 40436 6670 42 ta ta NNP 40436 6670 43 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6670 44 pollachê= pollachê= NNP 40436 6670 45 , , , 40436 6670 46 oi)=sth oi)=sth NNP 40436 6670 47 ' ' POS 40436 6670 48 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 6670 49 teleutô teleutô NN 40436 6670 50 = = SYM 40436 6670 51 n n NNP 40436 6670 52 ou)deno\s ou)deno\s NNP 40436 6670 53 ê(=tton ê(=tton NNP 40436 6670 54 a)kribô a)kribô NNP 40436 6670 55 = = SYM 40436 6670 56 s s NNP 40436 6670 57 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6670 58 / / SYM 40436 6670 59 setai setai NN 40436 6670 60 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6670 61 au)tôn au)tôn NNP 40436 6670 62 . . . 40436 6671 1 . . . 40436 6672 1 . . . 40436 6673 1 . . . 40436 6674 1 Ou)kou ou)kou CD 40436 6674 2 = = SYM 40436 6674 3 n n CC 40436 6674 4 ou)deno\s ou)deno\s NNP 40436 6674 5 dida dida NNP 40436 6674 6 / / SYM 40436 6674 7 xantos xantos NN 40436 6674 8 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 6674 9 ' ' `` 40436 6674 10 e)rôtê e)rôtê NNP 40436 6674 11 / / SYM 40436 6674 12 santos santos NNP 40436 6674 13 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6674 14 / / SYM 40436 6674 15 setai setai NN 40436 6674 16 , , , 40436 6674 17 a)nalabô\n a)nalabô\n NNP 40436 6674 18 au)to\s au)to\s NNP 40436 6674 19 e)x e)x NNP 40436 6674 20 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 6674 21 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6674 22 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6674 23 / / SYM 40436 6674 24 mên mên NN 40436 6674 25 ? ? . 40436 6674 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6674 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6675 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6675 2 Side side NN 40436 6675 3 - - HYPH 40436 6675 4 note note NN 40436 6675 5 : : : 40436 6675 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6675 7 's 's POS 40436 6675 8 theory theory NN 40436 6675 9 about about IN 40436 6675 10 pre pre JJ 40436 6675 11 - - JJ 40436 6675 12 natal natal JJ 40436 6675 13 experience experience NN 40436 6675 14 . . . 40436 6676 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6676 2 took take VBD 40436 6676 3 no no DT 40436 6676 4 pains pain NNS 40436 6676 5 to to TO 40436 6676 6 ascertain ascertain VB 40436 6676 7 and and CC 40436 6676 8 measure measure VB 40436 6676 9 the the DT 40436 6676 10 extent extent NN 40436 6676 11 of of IN 40436 6676 12 post post JJ 40436 6676 13 - - JJ 40436 6676 14 natal natal JJ 40436 6676 15 experience experience NN 40436 6676 16 . . . 40436 6676 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6677 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6677 2 is be VBZ 40436 6677 3 thus thus RB 40436 6677 4 that that IN 40436 6677 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6677 6 applies apply VBZ 40436 6677 7 to to IN 40436 6677 8 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 6677 9 theory theory NN 40436 6677 10 the the DT 40436 6677 11 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6677 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6677 13 borrowed borrow VBN 40436 6677 14 from from IN 40436 6677 15 the the DT 40436 6677 16 Pythagoreans Pythagoreans NNPS 40436 6677 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6677 18 of of IN 40436 6677 19 pre pre JJ 40436 6677 20 - - JJ 40436 6677 21 natal natal JJ 40436 6677 22 experience experience NN 40436 6677 23 and and CC 40436 6677 24 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 6677 25 : : : 40436 6677 26 which which WDT 40436 6677 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6677 28 considers consider VBZ 40436 6677 29 , , , 40436 6677 30 not not RB 40436 6677 31 as as RB 40436 6677 32 inherent inherent JJ 40436 6677 33 appurtenances appurtenance NNS 40436 6677 34 of of IN 40436 6677 35 the the DT 40436 6677 36 mind mind NN 40436 6677 37 , , , 40436 6677 38 but but CC 40436 6677 39 as as IN 40436 6677 40 acquisitions acquisition NNS 40436 6677 41 made make VBN 40436 6677 42 by by IN 40436 6677 43 the the DT 40436 6677 44 mind mind NN 40436 6677 45 during during IN 40436 6677 46 various various JJ 40436 6677 47 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 6677 48 lives life NNS 40436 6677 49 . . . 40436 6678 1 These these DT 40436 6678 2 ideas idea NNS 40436 6678 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6678 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6678 5 argues argue VBZ 40436 6678 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6678 7 can can MD 40436 6678 8 not not RB 40436 6678 9 have have VB 40436 6678 10 been be VBN 40436 6678 11 acquired acquire VBN 40436 6678 12 during during IN 40436 6678 13 the the DT 40436 6678 14 present present JJ 40436 6678 15 life life NN 40436 6678 16 , , , 40436 6678 17 because because IN 40436 6678 18 the the DT 40436 6678 19 youth youth NN 40436 6678 20 has have VBZ 40436 6678 21 received receive VBN 40436 6678 22 no no DT 40436 6678 23 special special JJ 40436 6678 24 teaching teaching NN 40436 6678 25 in in IN 40436 6678 26 geometry geometry NN 40436 6678 27 . . . 40436 6679 1 But but CC 40436 6679 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6679 3 here here RB 40436 6679 4 takes take VBZ 40436 6679 5 no no DT 40436 6679 6 account account NN 40436 6679 7 of of IN 40436 6679 8 the the DT 40436 6679 9 multiplicity multiplicity NN 40436 6679 10 and and CC 40436 6679 11 diversity diversity NN 40436 6679 12 of of IN 40436 6679 13 experiences experience NNS 40436 6679 14 gone go VBN 40436 6679 15 through through IN 40436 6679 16 , , , 40436 6679 17 comparisons comparison NNS 40436 6679 18 made make VBN 40436 6679 19 , , , 40436 6679 20 and and CC 40436 6679 21 acquirements acquirement NNS 40436 6679 22 lodged lodge VBN 40436 6679 23 , , , 40436 6679 24 in in IN 40436 6679 25 the the DT 40436 6679 26 mind mind NN 40436 6679 27 of of IN 40436 6679 28 a a DT 40436 6679 29 youthful youthful JJ 40436 6679 30 adult adult NN 40436 6679 31 however however RB 40436 6679 32 unlettered unlettered JJ 40436 6679 33 . . . 40436 6680 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6680 2 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 6680 3 no no DT 40436 6680 4 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 6680 5 of of IN 40436 6680 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6680 7 except except IN 40436 6680 8 through through IN 40436 6680 9 special special JJ 40436 6680 10 teaching teaching NN 40436 6680 11 . . . 40436 6681 1 So so RB 40436 6681 2 , , , 40436 6681 3 too too RB 40436 6681 4 , , , 40436 6681 5 in in IN 40436 6681 6 the the DT 40436 6681 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6681 8 , , , 40436 6681 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6681 10 shall shall MD 40436 6681 11 find find VB 40436 6681 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6681 13 putting put VBG 40436 6681 14 into into IN 40436 6681 15 the the DT 40436 6681 16 mouth mouth NN 40436 6681 17 of of IN 40436 6681 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6681 19 the the DT 40436 6681 20 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6681 21 -- -- : 40436 6681 22 That that DT 40436 6681 23 virtue virtue NN 40436 6681 24 is be VBZ 40436 6681 25 not not RB 40436 6681 26 taught teach VBN 40436 6681 27 and and CC 40436 6681 28 can can MD 40436 6681 29 not not RB 40436 6681 30 be be VB 40436 6681 31 taught teach VBN 40436 6681 32 , , , 40436 6681 33 because because IN 40436 6681 34 there there EX 40436 6681 35 were be VBD 40436 6681 36 no no DT 40436 6681 37 special special JJ 40436 6681 38 masters master NNS 40436 6681 39 or or CC 40436 6681 40 times time NNS 40436 6681 41 of of IN 40436 6681 42 teaching teaching NN 40436 6681 43 . . . 40436 6682 1 But but CC 40436 6682 2 in in IN 40436 6682 3 that that DT 40436 6682 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6682 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6682 6 shall shall MD 40436 6682 7 also also RB 40436 6682 8 see see VB 40436 6682 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6682 10 furnishing furnish VBG 40436 6682 11 an an DT 40436 6682 12 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 6682 13 reply reply NN 40436 6682 14 to to IN 40436 6682 15 this this DT 40436 6682 16 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6682 17 in in IN 40436 6682 18 the the DT 40436 6682 19 speech speech NN 40436 6682 20 of of IN 40436 6682 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6682 22 ; ; : 40436 6682 23 who who WP 40436 6682 24 indicates indicate VBZ 40436 6682 25 the the DT 40436 6682 26 multifarious multifarious JJ 40436 6682 27 and and CC 40436 6682 28 powerful powerful JJ 40436 6682 29 influences influence NNS 40436 6682 30 which which WDT 40436 6682 31 are be VBP 40436 6682 32 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 6682 33 operative operative JJ 40436 6682 34 , , , 40436 6682 35 even even RB 40436 6682 36 without without IN 40436 6682 37 special special JJ 40436 6682 38 professors professor NNS 40436 6682 39 , , , 40436 6682 40 in in IN 40436 6682 41 creating create VBG 40436 6682 42 and and CC 40436 6682 43 enforcing enforce VBG 40436 6682 44 ethical ethical JJ 40436 6682 45 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 6682 46 . . . 40436 6683 1 If if IN 40436 6683 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6683 3 had have VBD 40436 6683 4 taken take VBN 40436 6683 5 pains pain NNS 40436 6683 6 to to TO 40436 6683 7 study study VB 40436 6683 8 the the DT 40436 6683 9 early early JJ 40436 6683 10 life life NN 40436 6683 11 of of IN 40436 6683 12 the the DT 40436 6683 13 untaught untaught JJ 40436 6683 14 slave slave NN 40436 6683 15 , , , 40436 6683 16 with with IN 40436 6683 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6683 18 stock stock NN 40436 6683 19 of of IN 40436 6683 20 facts fact NNS 40436 6683 21 , , , 40436 6683 22 judgments judgment NNS 40436 6683 23 , , , 40436 6683 24 comparisons comparison NNS 40436 6683 25 , , , 40436 6683 26 and and CC 40436 6683 27 inferences inference NNS 40436 6683 28 suggested suggest VBN 40436 6683 29 by by IN 40436 6683 30 analogy analogy NN 40436 6683 31 , , , 40436 6683 32 & & CC 40436 6683 33 c. c. NNP 40436 6683 34 , , , 40436 6683 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6683 36 might may MD 40436 6683 37 easily easily RB 40436 6683 38 have have VB 40436 6683 39 found find VBN 40436 6683 40 enough enough RB 40436 6683 41 to to TO 40436 6683 42 explain explain VB 40436 6683 43 the the DT 40436 6683 44 competence competence NN 40436 6683 45 of of IN 40436 6683 46 the the DT 40436 6683 47 slave slave NN 40436 6683 48 to to TO 40436 6683 49 answer answer VB 40436 6683 50 the the DT 40436 6683 51 questions question NNS 40436 6683 52 appearing appear VBG 40436 6683 53 in in IN 40436 6683 54 the the DT 40436 6683 55 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6683 56 . . . 40436 6684 1 And and CC 40436 6684 2 even even RB 40436 6684 3 if if IN 40436 6684 4 enough enough JJ 40436 6684 5 could could MD 40436 6684 6 not not RB 40436 6684 7 have have VB 40436 6684 8 been be VBN 40436 6684 9 found find VBN 40436 6684 10 , , , 40436 6684 11 to to TO 40436 6684 12 afford afford VB 40436 6684 13 a a DT 40436 6684 14 direct direct JJ 40436 6684 15 and and CC 40436 6684 16 specific specific JJ 40436 6684 17 explanation explanation NN 40436 6684 18 -- -- : 40436 6684 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6684 20 must must MD 40436 6684 21 remember remember VB 40436 6684 22 that that IN 40436 6684 23 only only RB 40436 6684 24 a a DT 40436 6684 25 very very RB 40436 6684 26 small small JJ 40436 6684 27 proportion proportion NN 40436 6684 28 of of IN 40436 6684 29 the the DT 40436 6684 30 long long JJ 40436 6684 31 series series NN 40436 6684 32 of of IN 40436 6684 33 mental mental JJ 40436 6684 34 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 6684 35 realised realise VBN 40436 6684 36 in in IN 40436 6684 37 the the DT 40436 6684 38 infant infant NN 40436 6684 39 , , , 40436 6684 40 the the DT 40436 6684 41 child child NN 40436 6684 42 , , , 40436 6684 43 the the DT 40436 6684 44 youth youth NN 40436 6684 45 , , , 40436 6684 46 ever ever RB 40436 6684 47 comes come VBZ 40436 6684 48 to to TO 40436 6684 49 be be VB 40436 6684 50 remembered remember VBN 40436 6684 51 or or CC 40436 6684 52 recorded record VBN 40436 6684 53 . . . 40436 6685 1 To to TO 40436 6685 2 assume assume VB 40436 6685 3 that that IN 40436 6685 4 the the DT 40436 6685 5 large large JJ 40436 6685 6 unknown unknown JJ 40436 6685 7 remainder remainder NN 40436 6685 8 would would MD 40436 6685 9 be be VB 40436 6685 10 insufficient insufficient JJ 40436 6685 11 , , , 40436 6685 12 if if IN 40436 6685 13 known know VBN 40436 6685 14 , , , 40436 6685 15 to to TO 40436 6685 16 afford afford VB 40436 6685 17 the the DT 40436 6685 18 explanation explanation NN 40436 6685 19 sought seek VBN 40436 6685 20 , , , 40436 6685 21 is be VBZ 40436 6685 22 neither neither CC 40436 6685 23 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 6685 24 nor nor CC 40436 6685 25 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 6685 26 . . . 40436 6686 1 This this DT 40436 6686 2 is be VBZ 40436 6686 3 assumed assume VBN 40436 6686 4 in in IN 40436 6686 5 every every DT 40436 6686 6 form form NN 40436 6686 7 of of IN 40436 6686 8 the the DT 40436 6686 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6686 10 of of IN 40436 6686 11 innate innate JJ 40436 6686 12 ideas idea NNS 40436 6686 13 : : : 40436 6686 14 and and CC 40436 6686 15 assumed assume VBN 40436 6686 16 by by IN 40436 6686 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6686 18 here here RB 40436 6686 19 without without IN 40436 6686 20 even even RB 40436 6686 21 trying try VBG 40436 6686 22 any any DT 40436 6686 23 explanation explanation NN 40436 6686 24 to to TO 40436 6686 25 dispense dispense VB 40436 6686 26 with with IN 40436 6686 27 the the DT 40436 6686 28 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 6686 29 : : : 40436 6686 30 simply simply RB 40436 6686 31 because because IN 40436 6686 32 the the DT 40436 6686 33 youth youth NN 40436 6686 34 interrogated interrogate VBN 40436 6686 35 had have VBD 40436 6686 36 never never RB 40436 6686 37 received receive VBN 40436 6686 38 any any DT 40436 6686 39 special special JJ 40436 6686 40 instruction instruction NN 40436 6686 41 in in IN 40436 6686 42 geometry geometry NN 40436 6686 43 . . . 40436 6687 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6687 2 Side side NN 40436 6687 3 - - HYPH 40436 6687 4 note note NN 40436 6687 5 : : : 40436 6687 6 Little little JJ 40436 6687 7 or or CC 40436 6687 8 nothing nothing NN 40436 6687 9 is be VBZ 40436 6687 10 said say VBN 40436 6687 11 in in IN 40436 6687 12 the the DT 40436 6687 13 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6687 14 about about IN 40436 6687 15 the the DT 40436 6687 16 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6687 17 Ideas Ideas NNPS 40436 6687 18 or or CC 40436 6687 19 Forms Forms NNPS 40436 6687 20 . . . 40436 6687 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6688 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6688 2 have have VBP 40436 6688 3 already already RB 40436 6688 4 observed observe VBN 40436 6688 5 , , , 40436 6688 6 that that IN 40436 6688 7 though though IN 40436 6688 8 great great JJ 40436 6688 9 stress stress NN 40436 6688 10 is be VBZ 40436 6688 11 laid lay VBN 40436 6688 12 in in IN 40436 6688 13 this this DT 40436 6688 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6688 15 upon upon IN 40436 6688 16 the the DT 40436 6688 17 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6688 18 of of IN 40436 6688 19 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6688 20 and and CC 40436 6688 21 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6688 22 inherited inherit VBN 40436 6688 23 from from IN 40436 6688 24 an an DT 40436 6688 25 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 6688 26 life life NN 40436 6688 27 -- -- : 40436 6688 28 upon upon IN 40436 6688 29 the the DT 40436 6688 30 distinction distinction NN 40436 6688 31 between between IN 40436 6688 32 true true JJ 40436 6688 33 opinion opinion NN 40436 6688 34 and and CC 40436 6688 35 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6688 36 -- -- : 40436 6688 37 and and CC 40436 6688 38 upon upon IN 40436 6688 39 the the DT 40436 6688 40 identity identity NN 40436 6688 41 of of IN 40436 6688 42 the the DT 40436 6688 43 process process NN 40436 6688 44 of of IN 40436 6688 45 learning learn VBG 40436 6688 46 with with IN 40436 6688 47 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6688 48 -- -- : 40436 6688 49 yet yet CC 40436 6688 50 nothing nothing NN 40436 6688 51 is be VBZ 40436 6688 52 said say VBN 40436 6688 53 about about IN 40436 6688 54 universal universal JJ 40436 6688 55 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 6688 56 or or CC 40436 6688 57 Forms Forms NNPS 40436 6688 58 , , , 40436 6688 59 so so RB 40436 6688 60 much much JJ 40436 6688 61 dwelt dwelt NNS 40436 6688 62 upon upon IN 40436 6688 63 in in IN 40436 6688 64 other other JJ 40436 6688 65 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6688 66 . . . 40436 6689 1 In in IN 40436 6689 2 the the DT 40436 6689 3 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6689 4 and and CC 40436 6689 5 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 6689 6 , , , 40436 6689 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6689 8 is be VBZ 40436 6689 9 with with IN 40436 6689 10 these these DT 40436 6689 11 universal universal JJ 40436 6689 12 Ideas idea NNS 40436 6689 13 that that IN 40436 6689 14 the the DT 40436 6689 15 mind mind NN 40436 6689 16 is be VBZ 40436 6689 17 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 6689 18 to to TO 40436 6689 19 have have VB 40436 6689 20 had have VBN 40436 6689 21 communion communion NN 40436 6689 22 during during IN 40436 6689 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6689 24 prior prior JJ 40436 6689 25 existence existence NN 40436 6689 26 , , , 40436 6689 27 as as IN 40436 6689 28 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 6689 29 with with IN 40436 6689 30 the the DT 40436 6689 31 particulars particular NNS 40436 6689 32 of of IN 40436 6689 33 sense sense NN 40436 6689 34 apprehended apprehend VBN 40436 6689 35 during during IN 40436 6689 36 the the DT 40436 6689 37 present present JJ 40436 6689 38 life life NN 40436 6689 39 : : : 40436 6689 40 while while IN 40436 6689 41 in in IN 40436 6689 42 the the DT 40436 6689 43 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6689 44 , , , 40436 6689 45 the the DT 40436 6689 46 difference difference NN 40436 6689 47 pointed point VBD 40436 6689 48 out out RP 40436 6689 49 between between IN 40436 6689 50 true true JJ 40436 6689 51 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6689 52 and and CC 40436 6689 53 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6689 54 is be VBZ 40436 6689 55 something something NN 40436 6689 56 much much RB 40436 6689 57 less less RBR 40436 6689 58 marked marked JJ 40436 6689 59 and and CC 40436 6689 60 decisive decisive JJ 40436 6689 61 . . . 40436 6690 1 Both both DT 40436 6690 2 the the DT 40436 6690 3 one one NN 40436 6690 4 and and CC 40436 6690 5 the the DT 40436 6690 6 other other JJ 40436 6690 7 are be VBP 40436 6690 8 said say VBN 40436 6690 9 to to TO 40436 6690 10 be be VB 40436 6690 11 , , , 40436 6690 12 not not RB 40436 6690 13 acquired acquire VBN 40436 6690 14 during during IN 40436 6690 15 this this DT 40436 6690 16 life life NN 40436 6690 17 , , , 40436 6690 18 but but CC 40436 6690 19 inherited inherit VBN 40436 6690 20 from from IN 40436 6690 21 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 6690 22 life life NN 40436 6690 23 : : : 40436 6690 24 to to TO 40436 6690 25 be be VB 40436 6690 26 innate innate JJ 40436 6690 27 , , , 40436 6690 28 yet yet CC 40436 6690 29 unperceived unperceived JJ 40436 6690 30 -- -- : 40436 6690 31 revived revive VBN 40436 6690 32 by by IN 40436 6690 33 way way NN 40436 6690 34 of of IN 40436 6690 35 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 6690 36 and and CC 40436 6690 37 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 6690 38 . . . 40436 6691 1 True true JJ 40436 6691 2 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6691 3 are be VBP 40436 6691 4 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 6691 5 to to TO 40436 6691 6 render render VB 40436 6691 7 as as RB 40436 6691 8 much much JJ 40436 6691 9 service service NN 40436 6691 10 as as IN 40436 6691 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6691 12 , , , 40436 6691 13 in in IN 40436 6691 14 reference reference NN 40436 6691 15 to to TO 40436 6691 16 practice practice VB 40436 6691 17 . . . 40436 6692 1 There there EX 40436 6692 2 is be VBZ 40436 6692 3 only only RB 40436 6692 4 this this DT 40436 6692 5 distinction distinction NN 40436 6692 6 between between IN 40436 6692 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6692 8 -- -- : 40436 6692 9 that that IN 40436 6692 10 true true JJ 40436 6692 11 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6692 12 are be VBP 40436 6692 13 transient transient JJ 40436 6692 14 , , , 40436 6692 15 and and CC 40436 6692 16 will will MD 40436 6692 17 not not RB 40436 6692 18 remain remain VB 40436 6692 19 in in IN 40436 6692 20 the the DT 40436 6692 21 mind mind NN 40436 6692 22 until until IN 40436 6692 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6692 24 are be VBP 40436 6692 25 bound bind VBN 40436 6692 26 in in IN 40436 6692 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6692 28 by by IN 40436 6692 29 causal causal JJ 40436 6692 30 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 6692 31 , , , 40436 6692 32 or or CC 40436 6692 33 become become VB 40436 6692 34 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6692 35 . . . 40436 6693 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6693 2 Side side NN 40436 6693 3 - - HYPH 40436 6693 4 note note NN 40436 6693 5 : : : 40436 6693 6 What what WP 40436 6693 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6693 8 meant mean VBD 40436 6693 9 by by IN 40436 6693 10 Causal Causal NNP 40436 6693 11 Reasoning Reasoning NNP 40436 6693 12 -- -- : 40436 6693 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6693 14 distinction distinction NN 40436 6693 15 between between IN 40436 6693 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6693 17 and and CC 40436 6693 18 right right JJ 40436 6693 19 opinion opinion NN 40436 6693 20 . . . 40436 6693 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6694 1 What what WP 40436 6694 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6694 3 meant mean VBD 40436 6694 4 by by IN 40436 6694 5 this this DT 40436 6694 6 " " `` 40436 6694 7 causal causal JJ 40436 6694 8 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 6694 9 , , , 40436 6694 10 or or CC 40436 6694 11 computation computation NN 40436 6694 12 of of IN 40436 6694 13 cause cause NN 40436 6694 14 , , , 40436 6694 15 " " '' 40436 6694 16 is be VBZ 40436 6694 17 not not RB 40436 6694 18 clearly clearly RB 40436 6694 19 explained explain VBN 40436 6694 20 . . . 40436 6695 1 But but CC 40436 6695 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6695 3 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 6695 4 very very RB 40436 6695 5 unequivocally unequivocally RB 40436 6695 6 , , , 40436 6695 7 first first RB 40436 6695 8 , , , 40436 6695 9 that that IN 40436 6695 10 the the DT 40436 6695 11 distinction distinction NN 40436 6695 12 between between IN 40436 6695 13 true true JJ 40436 6695 14 opinion opinion NN 40436 6695 15 and and CC 40436 6695 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6695 17 is be VBZ 40436 6695 18 one one CD 40436 6695 19 of of IN 40436 6695 20 the the DT 40436 6695 21 few few JJ 40436 6695 22 things thing NNS 40436 6695 23 of of IN 40436 6695 24 which which WDT 40436 6695 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6695 26 feels feel VBZ 40436 6695 27 assured[47]--next assured[47]--next NNP 40436 6695 28 , , , 40436 6695 29 with with IN 40436 6695 30 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 6695 31 less less JJR 40436 6695 32 confidence confidence NN 40436 6695 33 , , , 40436 6695 34 that that IN 40436 6695 35 the the DT 40436 6695 36 distinction distinction NN 40436 6695 37 consists consist VBZ 40436 6695 38 only only RB 40436 6695 39 in in IN 40436 6695 40 the the DT 40436 6695 41 greater great JJR 40436 6695 42 security security NN 40436 6695 43 which which WDT 40436 6695 44 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6695 45 affords afford NNS 40436 6695 46 for for IN 40436 6695 47 permanent permanent JJ 40436 6695 48 in in NN 40436 6695 49 - - HYPH 40436 6695 50 dwelling dwelling NN 40436 6695 51 in in IN 40436 6695 52 the the DT 40436 6695 53 mind mind NN 40436 6695 54 . . . 40436 6696 1 This this DT 40436 6696 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 6696 3 substantially substantially RB 40436 6696 4 the the DT 40436 6696 5 same same JJ 40436 6696 6 distinction distinction NN 40436 6696 7 as as IN 40436 6696 8 what what WP 40436 6696 9 is be VBZ 40436 6696 10 laid lay VBN 40436 6696 11 down down RP 40436 6696 12 in in IN 40436 6696 13 other other JJ 40436 6696 14 words word NNS 40436 6696 15 towards towards IN 40436 6696 16 the the DT 40436 6696 17 close close NN 40436 6696 18 of of IN 40436 6696 19 the the DT 40436 6696 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6696 21 -- -- : 40436 6696 22 That that IN 40436 6696 23 those those DT 40436 6696 24 , , , 40436 6696 25 who who WP 40436 6696 26 have have VBP 40436 6696 27 only only JJ 40436 6696 28 true true JJ 40436 6696 29 opinions opinion NNS 40436 6696 30 and and CC 40436 6696 31 not not RB 40436 6696 32 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6696 33 , , , 40436 6696 34 judge judge VBP 40436 6696 35 rightly rightly RB 40436 6696 36 without without IN 40436 6696 37 knowing know VBG 40436 6696 38 how how WRB 40436 6696 39 or or CC 40436 6696 40 why why WRB 40436 6696 41 ; ; , 40436 6696 42 by by IN 40436 6696 43 an an DT 40436 6696 44 aptitude aptitude NN 40436 6696 45 not not RB 40436 6696 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6696 47 own own JJ 40436 6696 48 but but CC 40436 6696 49 supplied supply VBN 40436 6696 50 to to IN 40436 6696 51 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6696 52 from from IN 40436 6696 53 without without IN 40436 6696 54 for for IN 40436 6696 55 the the DT 40436 6696 56 occasion occasion NN 40436 6696 57 , , , 40436 6696 58 in in IN 40436 6696 59 the the DT 40436 6696 60 nature nature NN 40436 6696 61 of of IN 40436 6696 62 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 6696 63 or or CC 40436 6696 64 prophetic prophetic JJ 40436 6696 65 _ _ NNP 40436 6696 66 oestrus oestrus NNP 40436 6696 67 _ _ NNP 40436 6696 68 . . . 40436 6697 1 Hence hence RB 40436 6697 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6697 3 are be VBP 40436 6697 4 unable unable JJ 40436 6697 5 to to TO 40436 6697 6 teach teach VB 40436 6697 7 others other NNS 40436 6697 8 , , , 40436 6697 9 or or CC 40436 6697 10 to to TO 40436 6697 11 transfer transfer VB 40436 6697 12 this this DT 40436 6697 13 occasional occasional JJ 40436 6697 14 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 6697 15 to to IN 40436 6697 16 any any DT 40436 6697 17 one one NN 40436 6697 18 else else RB 40436 6697 19 . . . 40436 6698 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 6698 2 can can MD 40436 6698 3 not not RB 40436 6698 4 give give VB 40436 6698 5 account account NN 40436 6698 6 of of IN 40436 6698 7 what what WP 40436 6698 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6698 9 affect affect VBP 40436 6698 10 to to TO 40436 6698 11 know know VB 40436 6698 12 , , , 40436 6698 13 nor nor CC 40436 6698 14 answer answer VB 40436 6698 15 scrutinizing scrutinize VBG 40436 6698 16 questions question NNS 40436 6698 17 to to TO 40436 6698 18 test test VB 40436 6698 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6698 20 . . . 40436 6699 1 This this DT 40436 6699 2 power power NN 40436 6699 3 of of IN 40436 6699 4 answering answer VBG 40436 6699 5 and and CC 40436 6699 6 administering administer VBG 40436 6699 7 cross cross NN 40436 6699 8 - - NN 40436 6699 9 examination examination NN 40436 6699 10 , , , 40436 6699 11 is be VBZ 40436 6699 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6699 13 's 's POS 40436 6699 14 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 6699 15 test test NN 40436 6699 16 of of IN 40436 6699 17 real real JJ 40436 6699 18 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6699 19 -- -- : 40436 6699 20 as as IN 40436 6699 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6699 22 have have VBP 40436 6699 23 already already RB 40436 6699 24 observed observe VBN 40436 6699 25 in in IN 40436 6699 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6699 27 eighth eighth JJ 40436 6699 28 * * NFP 40436 6699 29 * * NFP 40436 6699 30 chapter chapter NN 40436 6699 31 . . . 40436 6700 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6700 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6700 3 47 47 CD 40436 6700 4 : : : 40436 6700 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6700 6 , , , 40436 6700 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6700 8 , , , 40436 6700 9 p. p. NN 40436 6700 10 98 98 CD 40436 6700 11 B. b. NN 40436 6701 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6701 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6701 3 : : : 40436 6701 4 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 6701 5 de/ de/ NNP 40436 6701 6 e)sti/ e)sti/ NNP 40436 6701 7 ti ti NNP 40436 6701 8 a)lloi a)lloi NNS 40436 6701 9 = = SYM 40436 6701 10 on on IN 40436 6701 11 o)rthê\ o)rthê\ NNP 40436 6701 12 do do VB 40436 6701 13 / / SYM 40436 6701 14 xa xa NNP 40436 6701 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6701 16 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6701 17 / / SYM 40436 6701 18 mê mê NNP 40436 6701 19 , , , 40436 6701 20 ou ou NNP 40436 6701 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6701 22 pa pa NNP 40436 6701 23 / / SYM 40436 6701 24 nu nu NNP 40436 6701 25 moi moi NNP 40436 6701 26 dokô= dokô= NNP 40436 6701 27 tou tou NNP 40436 6701 28 = = NNPS 40436 6701 29 to to IN 40436 6701 30 ei)ka ei)ka NNP 40436 6701 31 / / SYM 40436 6701 32 zein zein NN 40436 6701 33 ; ; : 40436 6701 34 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 6701 35 ' ' `` 40436 6701 36 ei)/per ei)/per CC 40436 6701 37 ti ti NNP 40436 6701 38 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 6701 39 phai phai NNP 40436 6701 40 / / SYM 40436 6701 41 ên ên NNP 40436 6701 42 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 6701 43 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 6701 44 / / SYM 40436 6701 45 nai nai NNP 40436 6701 46 , , , 40436 6701 47 _ _ NNP 40436 6701 48 o)li o)li NNP 40436 6701 49 / / SYM 40436 6701 50 ga ga NNP 40436 6701 51 d d NNP 40436 6701 52 ' ' POS 40436 6701 53 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 6701 54 phai phai NNP 40436 6701 55 / / SYM 40436 6701 56 ên ên NNP 40436 6701 57 , , , 40436 6701 58 e(\n e(\n NNP 40436 6701 59 d d NNP 40436 6701 60 ' ' POS 40436 6701 61 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 6701 62 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6701 63 tou tou NNP 40436 6701 64 = = NNPS 40436 6701 65 to to IN 40436 6701 66 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 6701 67 / / SYM 40436 6701 68 nôn nôn NNP 40436 6701 69 thei thei NNP 40436 6701 70 / / SYM 40436 6701 71 ên ên NNP 40436 6701 72 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 6701 73 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 6701 74 oi)=da oi)=da NNP 40436 6701 75 _ _ NNP 40436 6701 76 . . . 40436 6701 77 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6701 78 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6702 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6702 2 Side side NN 40436 6702 3 - - HYPH 40436 6702 4 note note NN 40436 6702 5 : : : 40436 6702 6 This this DT 40436 6702 7 distinction distinction NN 40436 6702 8 compared compare VBN 40436 6702 9 with with IN 40436 6702 10 modern modern JJ 40436 6702 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 6702 12 views view NNS 40436 6702 13 . . . 40436 6702 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6703 1 To to TO 40436 6703 2 translate translate VB 40436 6703 3 the the DT 40436 6703 4 views view NNS 40436 6703 5 of of IN 40436 6703 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6703 7 into into IN 40436 6703 8 analogous analogous JJ 40436 6703 9 views view NNS 40436 6703 10 of of IN 40436 6703 11 a a DT 40436 6703 12 modern modern JJ 40436 6703 13 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 6703 14 , , , 40436 6703 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6703 16 may may MD 40436 6703 17 say say VB 40436 6703 18 -- -- : 40436 6703 19 That that IN 40436 6703 20 right right JJ 40436 6703 21 opinion opinion NN 40436 6703 22 , , , 40436 6703 23 as as IN 40436 6703 24 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 6703 25 with with IN 40436 6703 26 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6703 27 , , , 40436 6703 28 is be VBZ 40436 6703 29 a a DT 40436 6703 30 discriminating discriminate VBG 40436 6703 31 and and CC 40436 6703 32 acute acute JJ 40436 6703 33 empirical empirical JJ 40436 6703 34 judgment judgment NN 40436 6703 35 : : : 40436 6703 36 inferring infer VBG 40436 6703 37 only only RB 40436 6703 38 from from IN 40436 6703 39 old old JJ 40436 6703 40 particulars particular NNS 40436 6703 41 to to IN 40436 6703 42 new new JJ 40436 6703 43 particulars particular NNS 40436 6703 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6703 45 without without IN 40436 6703 46 the the DT 40436 6703 47 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 6703 48 help help NN 40436 6703 49 and and CC 40436 6703 50 guarantee guarantee NN 40436 6703 51 of of IN 40436 6703 52 general general JJ 40436 6703 53 propositions proposition NNS 40436 6703 54 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 6703 55 enunciated enunciate VBD 40436 6703 56 and and CC 40436 6703 57 interpreted interpreted JJ 40436 6703 58 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6703 59 , , , 40436 6703 60 but but CC 40436 6703 61 selecting select VBG 40436 6703 62 for for IN 40436 6703 63 every every DT 40436 6703 64 new new JJ 40436 6703 65 case case NN 40436 6703 66 the the DT 40436 6703 67 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 6703 68 analogies analogy NNS 40436 6703 69 out out IN 40436 6703 70 of of IN 40436 6703 71 the the DT 40436 6703 72 past past NN 40436 6703 73 , , , 40436 6703 74 with with IN 40436 6703 75 which which WDT 40436 6703 76 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6703 77 ought ought MD 40436 6703 78 to to TO 40436 6703 79 be be VB 40436 6703 80 compared compare VBN 40436 6703 81 . . . 40436 6704 1 Many many JJ 40436 6704 2 persons person NNS 40436 6704 3 judge judge VBP 40436 6704 4 in in IN 40436 6704 5 this this DT 40436 6704 6 manner manner NN 40436 6704 7 fairly fairly RB 40436 6704 8 well well RB 40436 6704 9 , , , 40436 6704 10 and and CC 40436 6704 11 some some DT 40436 6704 12 with with IN 40436 6704 13 extreme extreme JJ 40436 6704 14 success success NN 40436 6704 15 . . . 40436 6705 1 But but CC 40436 6705 2 let let VB 40436 6705 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6705 4 be be VB 40436 6705 5 ever ever RB 40436 6705 6 so so RB 40436 6705 7 successful successful JJ 40436 6705 8 in in IN 40436 6705 9 practice practice NN 40436 6705 10 , , , 40436 6705 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6705 12 proceed proceed VBP 40436 6705 13 without without IN 40436 6705 14 any any DT 40436 6705 15 conscious conscious JJ 40436 6705 16 method method NN 40436 6705 17 ; ; : 40436 6705 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6705 19 are be VBP 40436 6705 20 unable unable JJ 40436 6705 21 to to TO 40436 6705 22 communicate communicate VB 40436 6705 23 the the DT 40436 6705 24 grounds ground NNS 40436 6705 25 of of IN 40436 6705 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6705 27 inferences inference NNS 40436 6705 28 to to IN 40436 6705 29 others other NNS 40436 6705 30 : : : 40436 6705 31 and and CC 40436 6705 32 when when WRB 40436 6705 33 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6705 34 are be VBP 40436 6705 35 right right JJ 40436 6705 36 , , , 40436 6705 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6705 38 is be VBZ 40436 6705 39 only only RB 40436 6705 40 by by IN 40436 6705 41 haphazard haphazard NN 40436 6705 42 -- -- : 40436 6705 43 that that DT 40436 6705 44 is be VBZ 40436 6705 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6705 46 to to TO 40436 6705 47 use use VB 40436 6705 48 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6705 49 's 's POS 40436 6705 50 language language NN 40436 6705 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6705 52 , , , 40436 6705 53 through through IN 40436 6705 54 special special JJ 40436 6705 55 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 6705 56 vouchsafed vouchsafe VBN 40436 6705 57 to to IN 40436 6705 58 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6705 59 by by IN 40436 6705 60 the the DT 40436 6705 61 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 6705 62 . . . 40436 6706 1 But but CC 40436 6706 2 when when WRB 40436 6706 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6706 4 ascend ascend VBP 40436 6706 5 to to TO 40436 6706 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6706 7 , , , 40436 6706 8 and and CC 40436 6706 9 come come VB 40436 6706 10 to to TO 40436 6706 11 judge judge VB 40436 6706 12 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 6706 13 , , , 40436 6706 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6706 15 then then RB 40436 6706 16 distribute distribute VBP 40436 6706 17 these these DT 40436 6706 18 particular particular JJ 40436 6706 19 facts fact NNS 40436 6706 20 into into IN 40436 6706 21 classes class NNS 40436 6706 22 -- -- : 40436 6706 23 note note VB 40436 6706 24 the the DT 40436 6706 25 constant constant JJ 40436 6706 26 sequences sequence NNS 40436 6706 27 as as IN 40436 6706 28 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 6706 29 from from IN 40436 6706 30 the the DT 40436 6706 31 occasional occasional JJ 40436 6706 32 -- -- : 40436 6706 33 and and CC 40436 6706 34 draw draw VB 40436 6706 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6706 36 inferences inference NNS 40436 6706 37 in in IN 40436 6706 38 every every DT 40436 6706 39 new new JJ 40436 6706 40 case case NN 40436 6706 41 according accord VBG 40436 6706 42 to to IN 40436 6706 43 such such JJ 40436 6706 44 general general JJ 40436 6706 45 laws law NNS 40436 6706 46 or or CC 40436 6706 47 uniformities uniformity NNS 40436 6706 48 of of IN 40436 6706 49 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 6706 50 and and CC 40436 6706 51 consequent consequent NN 40436 6706 52 . . . 40436 6707 1 Such such JJ 40436 6707 2 uniform uniform NN 40436 6707 3 and and CC 40436 6707 4 unconditional unconditional JJ 40436 6707 5 antecedents antecedent NNS 40436 6707 6 are be VBP 40436 6707 7 the the DT 40436 6707 8 only only JJ 40436 6707 9 causes cause NNS 40436 6707 10 of of IN 40436 6707 11 which which WDT 40436 6707 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6707 13 have have VBP 40436 6707 14 cognizance cognizance NN 40436 6707 15 . . . 40436 6708 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 6708 2 admit admit VBP 40436 6708 3 of of IN 40436 6708 4 being be VBG 40436 6708 5 described describe VBN 40436 6708 6 in in IN 40436 6708 7 the the DT 40436 6708 8 language language NN 40436 6708 9 which which WDT 40436 6708 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6708 11 here here RB 40436 6708 12 uses use VBZ 40436 6708 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6708 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6708 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6708 16 : : : 40436 6708 17 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 6708 18 / / SYM 40436 6708 19 as as IN 40436 6708 20 logismô=| logismô=| NNP 40436 6708 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6708 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6708 23 , , , 40436 6708 24 and and CC 40436 6708 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6708 26 also also RB 40436 6708 27 serve serve VBP 40436 6708 28 as as IN 40436 6708 29 reasons reason NNS 40436 6708 30 for for IN 40436 6708 31 justifying justify VBG 40436 6708 32 or or CC 40436 6708 33 explaining explain VBG 40436 6708 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6708 35 inferences inference NNS 40436 6708 36 to to IN 40436 6708 37 others other NNS 40436 6708 38 . . . 40436 6709 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6709 2 48 48 CD 40436 6709 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6709 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6709 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6709 6 48 48 CD 40436 6709 7 : : : 40436 6709 8 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6709 9 have have VBP 40436 6709 10 seen see VBN 40436 6709 11 that that IN 40436 6709 12 in in IN 40436 6709 13 the the DT 40436 6709 14 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6709 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6709 16 denies deny VBZ 40436 6709 17 all all DT 40436 6709 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6709 19 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6709 20 : : : 40436 6709 21 didachê/ didachê/ NNP 40436 6709 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6709 23 , , , 40436 6709 24 and and CC 40436 6709 25 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 6709 26 nothing nothing NN 40436 6709 27 but but IN 40436 6709 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6709 29 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6709 30 : : : 40436 6709 31 a)na a)na NNS 40436 6709 32 / / SYM 40436 6709 33 mnêsis mnêsis NN 40436 6709 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6709 35 . . . 40436 6710 1 The the DT 40436 6710 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6710 3 of of IN 40436 6710 4 the the DT 40436 6710 5 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 6710 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6710 7 p. p. NN 40436 6710 8 51 51 CD 40436 6710 9 D D NNP 40436 6710 10 - - HYPH 40436 6710 11 E e NN 40436 6710 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6710 13 is be VBZ 40436 6710 14 very very RB 40436 6710 15 different different JJ 40436 6710 16 . . . 40436 6711 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6711 2 there there RB 40436 6711 3 lays lay VBZ 40436 6711 4 especial especial JJ 40436 6711 5 stress stress NN 40436 6711 6 on on IN 40436 6711 7 the the DT 40436 6711 8 distinction distinction NN 40436 6711 9 between between IN 40436 6711 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6711 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6711 12 : : : 40436 6711 13 didachê\ didachê\ NNP 40436 6711 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6711 15 and and CC 40436 6711 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6711 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6711 18 : : : 40436 6711 19 peithô/]--the peithô/]--the VB 40436 6711 20 first first RB 40436 6711 21 belonging belong VBG 40436 6711 22 to to IN 40436 6711 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6711 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6711 25 : : : 40436 6711 26 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6711 27 / / SYM 40436 6711 28 mê mê NNP 40436 6711 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6711 30 , , , 40436 6711 31 the the DT 40436 6711 32 second second JJ 40436 6711 33 to to IN 40436 6711 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6711 35 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6711 36 : : : 40436 6711 37 do do VB 40436 6711 38 / / SYM 40436 6711 39 xa xa NNP 40436 6711 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6711 41 . . . 40436 6712 1 Also also RB 40436 6712 2 in in IN 40436 6712 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6712 4 , , , 40436 6712 5 454 454 CD 40436 6712 6 , , , 40436 6712 7 and and CC 40436 6712 8 in in IN 40436 6712 9 Republic Republic NNP 40436 6712 10 , , , 40436 6712 11 v. v. CC 40436 6712 12 pp pp NNP 40436 6712 13 . . . 40436 6713 1 477 477 CD 40436 6713 2 - - SYM 40436 6713 3 479 479 CD 40436 6713 4 , , , 40436 6713 5 about about IN 40436 6713 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6713 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6713 8 : : : 40436 6713 9 do do VB 40436 6713 10 / / SYM 40436 6713 11 xa xa NN 40436 6713 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6713 13 and and CC 40436 6713 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6713 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6713 16 : : : 40436 6713 17 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6713 18 / / SYM 40436 6713 19 mê mê NN 40436 6713 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6713 21 . . . 40436 6714 1 In in IN 40436 6714 2 those those DT 40436 6714 3 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6714 4 the the DT 40436 6714 5 distinction distinction NN 40436 6714 6 between between IN 40436 6714 7 the the DT 40436 6714 8 two two CD 40436 6714 9 is be VBZ 40436 6714 10 presented present VBN 40436 6714 11 as as IN 40436 6714 12 marked marked JJ 40436 6714 13 and and CC 40436 6714 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 6714 15 , , , 40436 6714 16 as as IN 40436 6714 17 if if IN 40436 6714 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6714 19 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6714 20 : : : 40436 6714 21 do do VB 40436 6714 22 / / SYM 40436 6714 23 xa xa NNP 40436 6714 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6714 25 alone alone RB 40436 6714 26 was be VBD 40436 6714 27 fallible fallible JJ 40436 6714 28 and and CC 40436 6714 29 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6714 30 Greek greek JJ 40436 6714 31 : : : 40436 6714 32 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6714 33 / / SYM 40436 6714 34 mê mê NN 40436 6714 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6714 36 infallible infallible JJ 40436 6714 37 . . . 40436 6715 1 In in IN 40436 6715 2 the the DT 40436 6715 3 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6715 4 the the DT 40436 6715 5 distinction distinction NN 40436 6715 6 appears appear VBZ 40436 6715 7 as as RB 40436 6715 8 important important JJ 40436 6715 9 , , , 40436 6715 10 but but CC 40436 6715 11 not not RB 40436 6715 12 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 6715 13 ; ; : 40436 6715 14 the the DT 40436 6715 15 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6715 16 Ideas Ideas NNPS 40436 6715 17 or or CC 40436 6715 18 Universals Universals NNPS 40436 6715 19 being be VBG 40436 6715 20 _ _ NNP 40436 6715 21 not not RB 40436 6715 22 _ _ NNP 40436 6715 23 recognised recognise VBD 40436 6715 24 as as IN 40436 6715 25 constituting constitute VBG 40436 6715 26 a a DT 40436 6715 27 substantive substantive JJ 40436 6715 28 world world NN 40436 6715 29 by by IN 40436 6715 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6715 31 . . . 40436 6716 1 In in IN 40436 6716 2 this this DT 40436 6716 3 respect respect NN 40436 6716 4 the the DT 40436 6716 5 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6716 6 is be VBZ 40436 6716 7 nearer near JJR 40436 6716 8 to to IN 40436 6716 9 the the DT 40436 6716 10 truth truth NN 40436 6716 11 in in IN 40436 6716 12 describing describe VBG 40436 6716 13 the the DT 40436 6716 14 difference difference NN 40436 6716 15 between between IN 40436 6716 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6716 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6716 18 : : : 40436 6716 19 o)rthê\ o)rthê\ NNP 40436 6716 20 do do VB 40436 6716 21 / / SYM 40436 6716 22 xa xa NN 40436 6716 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6716 24 and and CC 40436 6716 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6716 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6716 27 : : : 40436 6716 28 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6716 29 / / SYM 40436 6716 30 mê mê NN 40436 6716 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6716 32 . . . 40436 6717 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 6717 2 John John NNP 40436 6717 3 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 6717 4 Mill Mill NNP 40436 6717 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6717 6 in in IN 40436 6717 7 the the DT 40436 6717 8 chapter chapter NN 40436 6717 9 of of IN 40436 6717 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6717 11 System System NNP 40436 6717 12 of of IN 40436 6717 13 Logic Logic NNP 40436 6717 14 wherein wherein WRB 40436 6717 15 the the DT 40436 6717 16 true true JJ 40436 6717 17 theory theory NN 40436 6717 18 of of IN 40436 6717 19 the the DT 40436 6717 20 Syllogism Syllogism NNP 40436 6717 21 is be VBZ 40436 6717 22 for for IN 40436 6717 23 the the DT 40436 6717 24 first first JJ 40436 6717 25 time time NN 40436 6717 26 expounded expound VBN 40436 6717 27 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6717 28 has have VBZ 40436 6717 29 clearly clearly RB 40436 6717 30 explained explain VBN 40436 6717 31 what what WP 40436 6717 32 that that DT 40436 6717 33 difference difference NN 40436 6717 34 amounts amount VBZ 40436 6717 35 to to IN 40436 6717 36 . . . 40436 6718 1 All all DT 40436 6718 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6718 3 inferences inference NNS 40436 6718 4 are be VBP 40436 6718 5 _ _ NNP 40436 6718 6 from from IN 40436 6718 7 _ _ NNP 40436 6718 8 particulars particular NNS 40436 6718 9 , , , 40436 6718 10 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 6718 11 _ _ NNP 40436 6718 12 to to IN 40436 6718 13 _ _ NNP 40436 6718 14 new new JJ 40436 6718 15 particulars particular NNS 40436 6718 16 directly directly RB 40436 6718 17 and and CC 40436 6718 18 at at IN 40436 6718 19 once once RB 40436 6718 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6718 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6718 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6718 23 : : : 40436 6718 24 do do VB 40436 6718 25 / / SYM 40436 6718 26 xa xa NNP 40436 6718 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6718 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6718 29 , , , 40436 6718 30 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 6718 31 _ _ NNP 40436 6718 32 to to IN 40436 6718 33 _ _ NNP 40436 6718 34 generals general NNS 40436 6718 35 in in IN 40436 6718 36 the the DT 40436 6718 37 first first JJ 40436 6718 38 instance instance NN 40436 6718 39 , , , 40436 6718 40 and and CC 40436 6718 41 through through IN 40436 6718 42 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6718 43 _ _ NNP 40436 6718 44 to to IN 40436 6718 45 _ _ NNP 40436 6718 46 new new JJ 40436 6718 47 particulars particular NNS 40436 6718 48 ; ; : 40436 6718 49 which which WDT 40436 6718 50 latter latter JJ 40436 6718 51 , , , 40436 6718 52 or or CC 40436 6718 53 scientific scientific JJ 40436 6718 54 process process NN 40436 6718 55 , , , 40436 6718 56 is be VBZ 40436 6718 57 highly highly RB 40436 6718 58 valuable valuable JJ 40436 6718 59 as as IN 40436 6718 60 a a DT 40436 6718 61 security security NN 40436 6718 62 for for IN 40436 6718 63 correctness correctness NN 40436 6718 64 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6718 65 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6718 66 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6718 67 : : : 40436 6718 68 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6718 69 / / SYM 40436 6718 70 mê mê NN 40436 6718 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6718 72 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6718 73 . . . 40436 6719 1 " " `` 40436 6719 2 Not not RB 40436 6719 3 only only RB 40436 6719 4 " " '' 40436 6719 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6719 6 says say VBZ 40436 6719 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 6719 8 Mill Mill NNP 40436 6719 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6719 10 " " `` 40436 6719 11 _ _ NNP 40436 6719 12 may may MD 40436 6719 13 _ _ NNP 40436 6719 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6719 15 reason reason VBP 40436 6719 16 from from IN 40436 6719 17 particulars particular NNS 40436 6719 18 to to IN 40436 6719 19 particulars particular NNS 40436 6719 20 without without IN 40436 6719 21 passing pass VBG 40436 6719 22 through through IN 40436 6719 23 generals general NNS 40436 6719 24 , , , 40436 6719 25 but but CC 40436 6719 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6719 27 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 6719 28 _ _ NNP 40436 6719 29 do do VBP 40436 6719 30 _ _ NNP 40436 6719 31 so so CC 40436 6719 32 reason reason NN 40436 6719 33 . . . 40436 6720 1 All all DT 40436 6720 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6720 3 earliest early JJS 40436 6720 4 inferences inference NNS 40436 6720 5 are be VBP 40436 6720 6 of of IN 40436 6720 7 this this DT 40436 6720 8 nature nature NN 40436 6720 9 . . . 40436 6721 1 From from IN 40436 6721 2 the the DT 40436 6721 3 first first JJ 40436 6721 4 dawn dawn NN 40436 6721 5 of of IN 40436 6721 6 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 6721 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6721 8 draw draw VBP 40436 6721 9 inferences inference NNS 40436 6721 10 , , , 40436 6721 11 but but CC 40436 6721 12 years year NNS 40436 6721 13 elapse elapse VBP 40436 6721 14 before before IN 40436 6721 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6721 16 learn learn VBP 40436 6721 17 the the DT 40436 6721 18 use use NN 40436 6721 19 of of IN 40436 6721 20 general general JJ 40436 6721 21 language language NN 40436 6721 22 . . . 40436 6722 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6722 2 are be VBP 40436 6722 3 constantly constantly RB 40436 6722 4 reasoning reason VBG 40436 6722 5 from from IN 40436 6722 6 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6722 7 to to IN 40436 6722 8 other other JJ 40436 6722 9 people people NNS 40436 6722 10 , , , 40436 6722 11 or or CC 40436 6722 12 from from IN 40436 6722 13 one one CD 40436 6722 14 person person NN 40436 6722 15 to to IN 40436 6722 16 another another DT 40436 6722 17 , , , 40436 6722 18 without without IN 40436 6722 19 giving give VBG 40436 6722 20 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6722 21 the the DT 40436 6722 22 trouble trouble NN 40436 6722 23 to to TO 40436 6722 24 erect erect VB 40436 6722 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6722 26 observations observation NNS 40436 6722 27 into into IN 40436 6722 28 general general JJ 40436 6722 29 maxims maxim NNS 40436 6722 30 of of IN 40436 6722 31 human human JJ 40436 6722 32 or or CC 40436 6722 33 external external JJ 40436 6722 34 nature nature NN 40436 6722 35 . . . 40436 6723 1 If if IN 40436 6723 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6723 3 have have VBP 40436 6723 4 an an DT 40436 6723 5 extensive extensive JJ 40436 6723 6 experience experience NN 40436 6723 7 and and CC 40436 6723 8 retain retain VB 40436 6723 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6723 10 impressions impression NNS 40436 6723 11 strongly strongly RB 40436 6723 12 , , , 40436 6723 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6723 14 may may MD 40436 6723 15 acquire acquire VB 40436 6723 16 in in IN 40436 6723 17 this this DT 40436 6723 18 manner manner NN 40436 6723 19 a a DT 40436 6723 20 very very RB 40436 6723 21 considerable considerable JJ 40436 6723 22 power power NN 40436 6723 23 of of IN 40436 6723 24 accurate accurate JJ 40436 6723 25 judgment judgment NN 40436 6723 26 , , , 40436 6723 27 which which WDT 40436 6723 28 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6723 29 may may MD 40436 6723 30 be be VB 40436 6723 31 utterly utterly RB 40436 6723 32 incapable incapable JJ 40436 6723 33 of of IN 40436 6723 34 justifying justify VBG 40436 6723 35 or or CC 40436 6723 36 of of IN 40436 6723 37 communicating communicate VBG 40436 6723 38 to to IN 40436 6723 39 others other NNS 40436 6723 40 . . . 40436 6724 1 Among among IN 40436 6724 2 the the DT 40436 6724 3 higher high JJR 40436 6724 4 order order NN 40436 6724 5 of of IN 40436 6724 6 practical practical JJ 40436 6724 7 intellects intellect NNS 40436 6724 8 , , , 40436 6724 9 there there EX 40436 6724 10 have have VBP 40436 6724 11 been be VBN 40436 6724 12 many many JJ 40436 6724 13 of of IN 40436 6724 14 whom whom WP 40436 6724 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6724 16 was be VBD 40436 6724 17 remarked remark VBN 40436 6724 18 how how WRB 40436 6724 19 admirably admirably RB 40436 6724 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6724 21 suited suit VBD 40436 6724 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6724 23 means mean NNS 40436 6724 24 to to IN 40436 6724 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6724 26 ends end NNS 40436 6724 27 , , , 40436 6724 28 without without IN 40436 6724 29 being be VBG 40436 6724 30 able able JJ 40436 6724 31 to to TO 40436 6724 32 give give VB 40436 6724 33 any any DT 40436 6724 34 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 6724 35 account account NN 40436 6724 36 of of IN 40436 6724 37 what what WP 40436 6724 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6724 39 did do VBD 40436 6724 40 ; ; : 40436 6724 41 and and CC 40436 6724 42 applied apply VBD 40436 6724 43 , , , 40436 6724 44 or or CC 40436 6724 45 seemed seem VBD 40436 6724 46 to to TO 40436 6724 47 apply apply VB 40436 6724 48 , , , 40436 6724 49 recondite recondite NN 40436 6724 50 principles principle NNS 40436 6724 51 which which WDT 40436 6724 52 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6724 53 were be VBD 40436 6724 54 wholly wholly RB 40436 6724 55 unable unable JJ 40436 6724 56 to to IN 40436 6724 57 state state NN 40436 6724 58 . . . 40436 6725 1 This this DT 40436 6725 2 is be VBZ 40436 6725 3 a a DT 40436 6725 4 natural natural JJ 40436 6725 5 consequence consequence NN 40436 6725 6 of of IN 40436 6725 7 having have VBG 40436 6725 8 a a DT 40436 6725 9 mind mind NN 40436 6725 10 stored store VBN 40436 6725 11 with with IN 40436 6725 12 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 6725 13 particulars particular NNS 40436 6725 14 , , , 40436 6725 15 and and CC 40436 6725 16 having have VBG 40436 6725 17 been be VBN 40436 6725 18 accustomed accustom VBN 40436 6725 19 to to TO 40436 6725 20 reason reason NN 40436 6725 21 at at IN 40436 6725 22 once once RB 40436 6725 23 from from IN 40436 6725 24 these these DT 40436 6725 25 to to IN 40436 6725 26 fresh fresh JJ 40436 6725 27 particulars particular NNS 40436 6725 28 , , , 40436 6725 29 without without IN 40436 6725 30 practising practise VBG 40436 6725 31 the the DT 40436 6725 32 habit habit NN 40436 6725 33 of of IN 40436 6725 34 stating state VBG 40436 6725 35 to to IN 40436 6725 36 one one NN 40436 6725 37 's 's POS 40436 6725 38 self self NN 40436 6725 39 or or CC 40436 6725 40 others other NNS 40436 6725 41 the the DT 40436 6725 42 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 6725 43 general general JJ 40436 6725 44 propositions proposition NNS 40436 6725 45 . . . 40436 6726 1 The the DT 40436 6726 2 cases case NNS 40436 6726 3 of of IN 40436 6726 4 men man NNS 40436 6726 5 of of IN 40436 6726 6 talent talent NN 40436 6726 7 performing perform VBG 40436 6726 8 wonderful wonderful JJ 40436 6726 9 things thing NNS 40436 6726 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6726 11 know know VBP 40436 6726 12 not not RB 40436 6726 13 how how WRB 40436 6726 14 , , , 40436 6726 15 are be VBP 40436 6726 16 examples example NNS 40436 6726 17 of of IN 40436 6726 18 the the DT 40436 6726 19 rudest rude JJS 40436 6726 20 and and CC 40436 6726 21 most most RBS 40436 6726 22 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 40436 6726 23 forms form NNS 40436 6726 24 of of IN 40436 6726 25 the the DT 40436 6726 26 operations operation NNS 40436 6726 27 of of IN 40436 6726 28 superior superior JJ 40436 6726 29 minds mind NNS 40436 6726 30 . . . 40436 6727 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6727 2 is be VBZ 40436 6727 3 a a DT 40436 6727 4 defect defect NN 40436 6727 5 in in IN 40436 6727 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6727 7 , , , 40436 6727 8 and and CC 40436 6727 9 often often RB 40436 6727 10 a a DT 40436 6727 11 source source NN 40436 6727 12 of of IN 40436 6727 13 errors error NNS 40436 6727 14 , , , 40436 6727 15 not not RB 40436 6727 16 to to TO 40436 6727 17 have have VB 40436 6727 18 generalised generalise VBN 40436 6727 19 as as IN 40436 6727 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6727 21 went go VBD 40436 6727 22 on on RP 40436 6727 23 ; ; : 40436 6727 24 but but CC 40436 6727 25 generalisation generalisation NN 40436 6727 26 , , , 40436 6727 27 though though IN 40436 6727 28 a a DT 40436 6727 29 help help NN 40436 6727 30 , , , 40436 6727 31 the the DT 40436 6727 32 most most RBS 40436 6727 33 important important JJ 40436 6727 34 indeed indeed RB 40436 6727 35 of of IN 40436 6727 36 all all DT 40436 6727 37 helps help VBZ 40436 6727 38 , , , 40436 6727 39 is be VBZ 40436 6727 40 not not RB 40436 6727 41 an an DT 40436 6727 42 essential essential JJ 40436 6727 43 " " '' 40436 6727 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6727 45 Mill Mill NNP 40436 6727 46 , , , 40436 6727 47 Syst Syst NNP 40436 6727 48 . . . 40436 6728 1 of of IN 40436 6728 2 Logic Logic NNP 40436 6728 3 , , , 40436 6728 4 Book Book NNP 40436 6728 5 II II NNP 40436 6728 6 . . . 40436 6729 1 ch ch NNP 40436 6729 2 . . . 40436 6730 1 iii iii NNP 40436 6730 2 . . . 40436 6730 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6730 4 . . . 40436 6731 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6731 2 the the DT 40436 6731 3 first first JJ 40436 6731 4 chapter chapter NN 40436 6731 5 of of IN 40436 6731 6 the the DT 40436 6731 7 Metaphysica Metaphysica NNP 40436 6731 8 of of IN 40436 6731 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 6731 10 , , , 40436 6731 11 p. p. NN 40436 6731 12 980 980 CD 40436 6731 13 , , , 40436 6731 14 a. a. NN 40436 6732 1 15 15 CD 40436 6732 2 , , , 40436 6732 3 b. b. NNP 40436 6733 1 7 7 LS 40436 6733 2 . . . 40436 6733 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6734 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6734 2 Side side NN 40436 6734 3 - - HYPH 40436 6734 4 note note NN 40436 6734 5 : : : 40436 6734 6 Manifestation Manifestation NNP 40436 6734 7 of of IN 40436 6734 8 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6734 9 -- -- : 40436 6734 10 intense intense JJ 40436 6734 11 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 6734 12 to to IN 40436 6734 13 the the DT 40436 6734 14 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6734 15 and and CC 40436 6734 16 to to TO 40436 6734 17 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6734 18 generally generally RB 40436 6734 19 . . . 40436 6734 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6735 1 The the DT 40436 6735 2 manner manner NN 40436 6735 3 in in IN 40436 6735 4 which which WDT 40436 6735 5 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6735 6 , , , 40436 6735 7 the the DT 40436 6735 8 accuser accuser NN 40436 6735 9 of of IN 40436 6735 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6735 11 before before IN 40436 6735 12 the the DT 40436 6735 13 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 6735 14 , , , 40436 6735 15 is be VBZ 40436 6735 16 introduced introduce VBN 40436 6735 17 into into IN 40436 6735 18 this this DT 40436 6735 19 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6735 20 , , , 40436 6735 21 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 6735 22 notice notice NN 40436 6735 23 . . . 40436 6736 1 The the DT 40436 6736 2 questions question NNS 40436 6736 3 are be VBP 40436 6736 4 put put VBN 40436 6736 5 to to IN 40436 6736 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6736 7 by by IN 40436 6736 8 Sokrates--"Is Sokrates--"Is NNP 40436 6736 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 6736 10 teachable teachable NN 40436 6736 11 ? ? . 40436 6737 1 How how WRB 40436 6737 2 is be VBZ 40436 6737 3 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6737 4 to to TO 40436 6737 5 learn learn VB 40436 6737 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 6737 7 , , , 40436 6737 8 and and CC 40436 6737 9 from from IN 40436 6737 10 whom whom WP 40436 6737 11 ? ? . 40436 6738 1 Ought Ought MD 40436 6738 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6738 3 not not RB 40436 6738 4 to to TO 40436 6738 5 do do VB 40436 6738 6 as as IN 40436 6738 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6738 8 would would MD 40436 6738 9 do do VB 40436 6738 10 if if IN 40436 6738 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6738 12 wished wish VBD 40436 6738 13 to to TO 40436 6738 14 learn learn VB 40436 6738 15 medicine medicine NN 40436 6738 16 or or CC 40436 6738 17 music music NN 40436 6738 18 : : : 40436 6738 19 to to TO 40436 6738 20 put put VB 40436 6738 21 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6738 22 under under IN 40436 6738 23 some some DT 40436 6738 24 paid pay VBN 40436 6738 25 professional professional JJ 40436 6738 26 man man NN 40436 6738 27 as as IN 40436 6738 28 teacher teacher NN 40436 6738 29 ? ? . 40436 6738 30 " " '' 40436 6739 1 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6739 2 answers answer VBZ 40436 6739 3 these these DT 40436 6739 4 questions question NNS 40436 6739 5 in in IN 40436 6739 6 the the DT 40436 6739 7 affirmative affirmative NN 40436 6739 8 : : : 40436 6739 9 but but CC 40436 6739 10 asks ask VBZ 40436 6739 11 , , , 40436 6739 12 where where WRB 40436 6739 13 such such JJ 40436 6739 14 professional professional JJ 40436 6739 15 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6739 16 of of IN 40436 6739 17 virtue virtue NN 40436 6739 18 are be VBP 40436 6739 19 to to TO 40436 6739 20 be be VB 40436 6739 21 found find VBN 40436 6739 22 . . . 40436 6740 1 " " `` 40436 6740 2 There there EX 40436 6740 3 are be VBP 40436 6740 4 the the DT 40436 6740 5 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6740 6 , , , 40436 6740 7 " " '' 40436 6740 8 replies reply VBZ 40436 6740 9 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6740 10 . . . 40436 6741 1 Upon upon IN 40436 6741 2 this this DT 40436 6741 3 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6741 4 breaks break VBZ 40436 6741 5 out out RP 40436 6741 6 into into IN 40436 6741 7 a a DT 40436 6741 8 burst burst NN 40436 6741 9 of of IN 40436 6741 10 angry angry JJ 40436 6741 11 invective invective NN 40436 6741 12 against against IN 40436 6741 13 the the DT 40436 6741 14 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6741 15 ; ; : 40436 6741 16 denouncing denounce VBG 40436 6741 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6741 18 as as IN 40436 6741 19 corruptors corruptor NNS 40436 6741 20 of of IN 40436 6741 21 youth youth NN 40436 6741 22 , , , 40436 6741 23 whom whom WP 40436 6741 24 none none NN 40436 6741 25 but but IN 40436 6741 26 a a DT 40436 6741 27 madman madman NN 40436 6741 28 would would MD 40436 6741 29 consult consult VB 40436 6741 30 , , , 40436 6741 31 and and CC 40436 6741 32 who who WP 40436 6741 33 ought ought MD 40436 6741 34 to to TO 40436 6741 35 be be VB 40436 6741 36 banished banish VBN 40436 6741 37 by by IN 40436 6741 38 public public JJ 40436 6741 39 authority authority NN 40436 6741 40 . . . 40436 6742 1 Why why WRB 40436 6742 2 are be VBP 40436 6742 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6742 4 so so RB 40436 6742 5 bitter bitter JJ 40436 6742 6 against against IN 40436 6742 7 the the DT 40436 6742 8 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6742 9 ? ? . 40436 6743 1 asks ask VBZ 40436 6743 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6743 3 . . . 40436 6744 1 Have have VBP 40436 6744 2 any any DT 40436 6744 3 of of IN 40436 6744 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6744 5 ever ever RB 40436 6744 6 injured injure VBD 40436 6744 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6744 8 ? ? . 40436 6745 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6745 2 Anyt._--No Anyt._--No NNP 40436 6745 3 ; ; : 40436 6745 4 never never RB 40436 6745 5 : : : 40436 6745 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6745 7 have have VBP 40436 6745 8 never never RB 40436 6745 9 been be VBN 40436 6745 10 in in IN 40436 6745 11 the the DT 40436 6745 12 company company NN 40436 6745 13 of of IN 40436 6745 14 any any DT 40436 6745 15 one one CD 40436 6745 16 of of IN 40436 6745 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6745 18 , , , 40436 6745 19 nor nor CC 40436 6745 20 would would MD 40436 6745 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6745 22 ever ever RB 40436 6745 23 suffer suffer VB 40436 6745 24 any any DT 40436 6745 25 of of IN 40436 6745 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6745 27 family family NN 40436 6745 28 to to TO 40436 6745 29 be be VB 40436 6745 30 so so RB 40436 6745 31 . . . 40436 6746 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6746 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 6746 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6746 4 have have VBP 40436 6746 5 no no DT 40436 6746 6 experience experience NN 40436 6746 7 whatever whatever WDT 40436 6746 8 about about IN 40436 6746 9 the the DT 40436 6746 10 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6746 11 ? ? . 40436 6747 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6747 2 Anyt._--None Anyt._--None NNP 40436 6747 3 : : : 40436 6747 4 and and CC 40436 6747 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6747 6 hope hope VBP 40436 6747 7 that that IN 40436 6747 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6747 9 never never RB 40436 6747 10 may may MD 40436 6747 11 have have VB 40436 6747 12 . . . 40436 6748 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6748 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 6748 3 then then RB 40436 6748 4 can can MD 40436 6748 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6748 6 know know VB 40436 6748 7 about about IN 40436 6748 8 this this DT 40436 6748 9 matter matter NN 40436 6748 10 , , , 40436 6748 11 how how WRB 40436 6748 12 far far RB 40436 6748 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6748 14 is be VBZ 40436 6748 15 good good JJ 40436 6748 16 or or CC 40436 6748 17 bad bad JJ 40436 6748 18 , , , 40436 6748 19 if if IN 40436 6748 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6748 21 have have VBP 40436 6748 22 no no DT 40436 6748 23 experience experience NN 40436 6748 24 whatever whatever WDT 40436 6748 25 about about IN 40436 6748 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6748 27 ? ? . 40436 6749 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6749 2 Anyt._--Easily Anyt._--Easily NNP 40436 6749 3 . . . 40436 6750 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6750 2 know know VBP 40436 6750 3 what what WP 40436 6750 4 sort sort NN 40436 6750 5 of of IN 40436 6750 6 men man NNS 40436 6750 7 the the DT 40436 6750 8 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6750 9 are be VBP 40436 6750 10 , , , 40436 6750 11 whether whether IN 40436 6750 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6750 13 have have VBP 40436 6750 14 experience experience NN 40436 6750 15 of of IN 40436 6750 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6750 17 or or CC 40436 6750 18 not not RB 40436 6750 19 . . . 40436 6751 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6751 2 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 6751 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6751 4 are be VBP 40436 6751 5 a a DT 40436 6751 6 prophet prophet NN 40436 6751 7 , , , 40436 6751 8 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6751 9 : : : 40436 6751 10 for for IN 40436 6751 11 how how WRB 40436 6751 12 else else RB 40436 6751 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6751 14 can can MD 40436 6751 15 know know VB 40436 6751 16 about about IN 40436 6751 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6751 18 , , , 40436 6751 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6751 20 do do VBP 40436 6751 21 not not RB 40436 6751 22 understand understand VB 40436 6751 23 , , , 40436 6751 24 even even RB 40436 6751 25 on on IN 40436 6751 26 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6751 27 own own JJ 40436 6751 28 statement statement NN 40436 6751 29 . . . 40436 6752 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6752 2 49 49 CD 40436 6752 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6752 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6752 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6752 6 49 49 CD 40436 6752 7 : : : 40436 6752 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6752 9 , , , 40436 6752 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6752 11 , , , 40436 6752 12 p. p. NN 40436 6753 1 92 92 CD 40436 6753 2 . . . 40436 6753 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6754 1 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6754 2 then then RB 40436 6754 3 declares declare VBZ 40436 6754 4 , , , 40436 6754 5 that that IN 40436 6754 6 the the DT 40436 6754 7 persons person NNS 40436 6754 8 from from IN 40436 6754 9 whom whom WP 40436 6754 10 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6754 11 ought ought MD 40436 6754 12 to to TO 40436 6754 13 learn learn VB 40436 6754 14 virtue virtue NN 40436 6754 15 are be VBP 40436 6754 16 the the DT 40436 6754 17 leading leading JJ 40436 6754 18 practical practical JJ 40436 6754 19 politicians politician NNS 40436 6754 20 ; ; : 40436 6754 21 and and CC 40436 6754 22 that that IN 40436 6754 23 any any DT 40436 6754 24 one one CD 40436 6754 25 of of IN 40436 6754 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6754 27 can can MD 40436 6754 28 teach teach VB 40436 6754 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6754 30 . . . 40436 6755 1 But but CC 40436 6755 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6755 3 puts put VBZ 40436 6755 4 a a DT 40436 6755 5 series series NN 40436 6755 6 of of IN 40436 6755 7 questions question NNS 40436 6755 8 , , , 40436 6755 9 showing show VBG 40436 6755 10 that that IN 40436 6755 11 the the DT 40436 6755 12 leading lead VBG 40436 6755 13 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 6755 14 politicians politician NNS 40436 6755 15 , , , 40436 6755 16 Themistoklês Themistoklês NNPS 40436 6755 17 , , , 40436 6755 18 Periklês Periklês NNP 40436 6755 19 , , , 40436 6755 20 & & CC 40436 6755 21 c. c. NNP 40436 6755 22 , , , 40436 6755 23 have have VBP 40436 6755 24 not not RB 40436 6755 25 been be VBN 40436 6755 26 able able JJ 40436 6755 27 to to TO 40436 6755 28 teach teach VB 40436 6755 29 virtue virtue NN 40436 6755 30 even even RB 40436 6755 31 to to IN 40436 6755 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6755 33 own own JJ 40436 6755 34 sons son NNS 40436 6755 35 : : : 40436 6755 36 _ _ NNP 40436 6755 37 à à DT 40436 6755 38 fortiori fortiori NN 40436 6755 39 _ _ NNP 40436 6755 40 , , , 40436 6755 41 therefore therefore RB 40436 6755 42 , , , 40436 6755 43 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6755 44 can can MD 40436 6755 45 not not RB 40436 6755 46 teach teach VB 40436 6755 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6755 48 to to IN 40436 6755 49 any any DT 40436 6755 50 one one NN 40436 6755 51 else else RB 40436 6755 52 . . . 40436 6756 1 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6756 2 treats treat VBZ 40436 6756 3 this this DT 40436 6756 4 series series NN 40436 6756 5 of of IN 40436 6756 6 questions question NNS 40436 6756 7 as as IN 40436 6756 8 disparaging disparage VBG 40436 6756 9 and and CC 40436 6756 10 calumnious calumnious JJ 40436 6756 11 towards towards IN 40436 6756 12 the the DT 40436 6756 13 great great JJ 40436 6756 14 men man NNS 40436 6756 15 of of IN 40436 6756 16 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6756 17 . . . 40436 6757 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6757 2 breaks break VBZ 40436 6757 3 off off RP 40436 6757 4 the the DT 40436 6757 5 conversation conversation NN 40436 6757 6 abruptly abruptly RB 40436 6757 7 , , , 40436 6757 8 with with IN 40436 6757 9 an an DT 40436 6757 10 angry angry JJ 40436 6757 11 warning warning NN 40436 6757 12 to to IN 40436 6757 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6757 14 to to TO 40436 6757 15 be be VB 40436 6757 16 cautious cautious JJ 40436 6757 17 about about IN 40436 6757 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6757 19 language language NN 40436 6757 20 , , , 40436 6757 21 and and CC 40436 6757 22 to to TO 40436 6757 23 take take VB 40436 6757 24 care care NN 40436 6757 25 of of IN 40436 6757 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6757 27 own own JJ 40436 6757 28 safety safety NN 40436 6757 29 . . . 40436 6758 1 The the DT 40436 6758 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6758 3 is be VBZ 40436 6758 4 then then RB 40436 6758 5 prosecuted prosecute VBN 40436 6758 6 and and CC 40436 6758 7 finished finish VBN 40436 6758 8 between between IN 40436 6758 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6758 10 and and CC 40436 6758 11 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6758 12 : : : 40436 6758 13 and and CC 40436 6758 14 at at IN 40436 6758 15 the the DT 40436 6758 16 close close NN 40436 6758 17 of of IN 40436 6758 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 19 , , , 40436 6758 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6758 21 says--"Talk says--"Talk NNP 40436 6758 22 to to IN 40436 6758 23 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6758 24 , , , 40436 6758 25 and and CC 40436 6758 26 communicate communicate VB 40436 6758 27 to to IN 40436 6758 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 29 that that DT 40436 6758 30 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 6758 31 which which WDT 40436 6758 32 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 33 have have VBP 40436 6758 34 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 35 contracted,[50 contracted,[50 . 40436 6758 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6758 37 in in IN 40436 6758 38 order order NN 40436 6758 39 that that IN 40436 6758 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 41 may may MD 40436 6758 42 be be VB 40436 6758 43 more more RBR 40436 6758 44 mildly mildly RB 40436 6758 45 disposed disposed JJ 40436 6758 46 : : : 40436 6758 47 for for IN 40436 6758 48 , , , 40436 6758 49 if if IN 40436 6758 50 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 51 persuade persuade VBP 40436 6758 52 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 53 , , , 40436 6758 54 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 55 will will MD 40436 6758 56 do do VB 40436 6758 57 some some DT 40436 6758 58 good good NN 40436 6758 59 to to IN 40436 6758 60 the the DT 40436 6758 61 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 6758 62 as as RB 40436 6758 63 well well RB 40436 6758 64 as as IN 40436 6758 65 to to IN 40436 6758 66 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6758 67 . . . 40436 6758 68 " " '' 40436 6759 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6759 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6759 3 50 50 CD 40436 6759 4 : : : 40436 6759 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6759 6 , , , 40436 6759 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6759 8 , , , 40436 6759 9 ad ad NN 40436 6759 10 fin fin NN 40436 6759 11 . . . 40436 6760 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6760 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6760 3 : : : 40436 6760 4 su\ su\ NNP 40436 6760 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6760 6 tau tau NNP 40436 6760 7 = = SYM 40436 6760 8 ta ta NNP 40436 6760 9 a(/per a(/per NNP 40436 6760 10 au)to\s au)to\s NNP 40436 6760 11 pe pe NNP 40436 6760 12 / / SYM 40436 6760 13 peisai peisai NNP 40436 6760 14 , , , 40436 6760 15 pei pei NNP 40436 6760 16 = = -RRB- 40436 6760 17 the the DT 40436 6760 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6760 19 to\n to\n NNP 40436 6760 20 xe xe NNP 40436 6760 21 / / SYM 40436 6760 22 non non NNP 40436 6760 23 to to IN 40436 6760 24 / / SYM 40436 6760 25 nde nde NNP 40436 6760 26 A)/nuton A)/nuton NNP 40436 6760 27 , , , 40436 6760 28 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 6760 29 pra|o pra|o NNP 40436 6760 30 / / SYM 40436 6760 31 teros teros NNP 40436 6760 32 ê)=| ê)=| NNS 40436 6760 33 ; ; : 40436 6760 34 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 6760 35 e)a\n e)a\n HYPH 40436 6760 36 pei pei NNP 40436 6760 37 / / SYM 40436 6760 38 sê|s sê|s NNP 40436 6760 39 tou tou NNP 40436 6760 40 = = SYM 40436 6760 41 ton ton NN 40436 6760 42 , , , 40436 6760 43 e)/stin e)/stin NN 40436 6760 44 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 6760 45 , , , 40436 6760 46 ti ti NNP 40436 6760 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6760 48 A)thênai A)thênai NNP 40436 6760 49 / / SYM 40436 6760 50 ous ous NNP 40436 6760 51 o)nê o)nê NNP 40436 6760 52 / / SYM 40436 6760 53 seis seis NNP 40436 6760 54 . . . 40436 6760 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6760 56 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6761 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6761 2 Side side NN 40436 6761 3 - - HYPH 40436 6761 4 note note NN 40436 6761 5 : : : 40436 6761 6 The the DT 40436 6761 7 enemy enemy NN 40436 6761 8 of of IN 40436 6761 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6761 10 is be VBZ 40436 6761 11 also also RB 40436 6761 12 the the DT 40436 6761 13 enemy enemy NN 40436 6761 14 of of IN 40436 6761 15 the the DT 40436 6761 16 sophists sophist NNS 40436 6761 17 -- -- : 40436 6761 18 Practical practical JJ 40436 6761 19 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 6761 20 . . . 40436 6761 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6762 1 The the DT 40436 6762 2 enemy enemy NN 40436 6762 3 and and CC 40436 6762 4 accuser accuser NN 40436 6762 5 of of IN 40436 6762 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6762 7 is be VBZ 40436 6762 8 here here RB 40436 6762 9 depicted depict VBN 40436 6762 10 as as IN 40436 6762 11 the the DT 40436 6762 12 bitter bitter JJ 40436 6762 13 enemy enemy NN 40436 6762 14 of of IN 40436 6762 15 the the DT 40436 6762 16 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6762 17 also also RB 40436 6762 18 . . . 40436 6763 1 And and CC 40436 6763 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6763 3 takes take VBZ 40436 6763 4 pains pain NNS 40436 6763 5 to to TO 40436 6763 6 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 6763 7 the the DT 40436 6763 8 enmity enmity NN 40436 6763 9 of of IN 40436 6763 10 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6763 11 to to IN 40436 6763 12 the the DT 40436 6763 13 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6763 14 as as IN 40436 6763 15 founded found VBN 40436 6763 16 on on IN 40436 6763 17 no no DT 40436 6763 18 facts fact NNS 40436 6763 19 or or CC 40436 6763 20 experience experience NN 40436 6763 21 . . . 40436 6764 1 Without without IN 40436 6764 2 having have VBG 40436 6764 3 seen see VBN 40436 6764 4 or or CC 40436 6764 5 ascertained ascertain VBN 40436 6764 6 anything anything NN 40436 6764 7 about about IN 40436 6764 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6764 9 , , , 40436 6764 10 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6764 11 hates hate VBZ 40436 6764 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6764 13 as as RB 40436 6764 14 violently violently RB 40436 6764 15 as as IN 40436 6764 16 if if IN 40436 6764 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6764 18 had have VBD 40436 6764 19 sustained sustain VBN 40436 6764 20 from from IN 40436 6764 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6764 22 some some DT 40436 6764 23 personal personal JJ 40436 6764 24 injury injury NN 40436 6764 25 ; ; : 40436 6764 26 a a DT 40436 6764 27 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 6764 28 which which WDT 40436 6764 29 many many JJ 40436 6764 30 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6764 31 critics critic NNS 40436 6764 32 and and CC 40436 6764 33 many many JJ 40436 6764 34 historians historian NNS 40436 6764 35 of of IN 40436 6764 36 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6764 37 have have VBP 40436 6764 38 inherited inherit VBN 40436 6764 39 from from IN 40436 6764 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6764 41 . . . 40436 6765 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6765 2 51 51 CD 40436 6765 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6765 4 Whether whether IN 40436 6765 5 the the DT 40436 6765 6 corruption corruption NN 40436 6765 7 which which WDT 40436 6765 8 these these DT 40436 6765 9 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6765 10 were be VBD 40436 6765 11 accused accuse VBN 40436 6765 12 of of IN 40436 6765 13 bringing bring VBG 40436 6765 14 about about RP 40436 6765 15 in in IN 40436 6765 16 the the DT 40436 6765 17 minds mind NNS 40436 6765 18 of of IN 40436 6765 19 youth youth NN 40436 6765 20 , , , 40436 6765 21 was be VBD 40436 6765 22 intentional intentional JJ 40436 6765 23 or or CC 40436 6765 24 not not RB 40436 6765 25 intentional intentional JJ 40436 6765 26 on on IN 40436 6765 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6765 28 part part NN 40436 6765 29 -- -- : 40436 6765 30 how how WRB 40436 6765 31 such such JJ 40436 6765 32 corruption corruption NN 40436 6765 33 could could MD 40436 6765 34 have have VB 40436 6765 35 been be VBN 40436 6765 36 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 6765 37 continued continue VBN 40436 6765 38 , , , 40436 6765 39 while while IN 40436 6765 40 at at IN 40436 6765 41 the the DT 40436 6765 42 same same JJ 40436 6765 43 time time NN 40436 6765 44 the the DT 40436 6765 45 eminent eminent JJ 40436 6765 46 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6765 47 enjoyed enjoy VBD 40436 6765 48 long long JJ 40436 6765 49 and and CC 40436 6765 50 unabated unabated JJ 40436 6765 51 esteem esteem NN 40436 6765 52 from from IN 40436 6765 53 the the DT 40436 6765 54 youth youth NN 40436 6765 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6765 56 and and CC 40436 6765 57 from from IN 40436 6765 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6765 59 relatives relative NNS 40436 6765 60 -- -- : 40436 6765 61 are be VBP 40436 6765 62 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 6765 63 which which WDT 40436 6765 64 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6765 65 does do VBZ 40436 6765 66 not not RB 40436 6765 67 attempt attempt VB 40436 6765 68 to to TO 40436 6765 69 explain explain VB 40436 6765 70 , , , 40436 6765 71 though though IN 40436 6765 72 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6765 73 are be VBP 40436 6765 74 started start VBN 40436 6765 75 here here RB 40436 6765 76 by by IN 40436 6765 77 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6765 78 . . . 40436 6766 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 6766 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6766 3 find find VBP 40436 6766 4 the the DT 40436 6766 5 same same JJ 40436 6766 6 topics topic NNS 40436 6766 7 employed employ VBN 40436 6766 8 by by IN 40436 6766 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6766 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6766 11 , , , 40436 6766 12 in in IN 40436 6766 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6766 14 defence defence NN 40436 6766 15 before before IN 40436 6766 16 the the DT 40436 6766 17 Dikasts Dikasts NNPS 40436 6766 18 against against IN 40436 6766 19 the the DT 40436 6766 20 same same JJ 40436 6766 21 charge charge NN 40436 6766 22 . . . 40436 6767 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6767 2 52 52 CD 40436 6767 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6767 4 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6767 5 has have VBZ 40436 6767 6 confidence confidence NN 40436 6767 7 in in IN 40436 6767 8 no no DT 40436 6767 9 one one NN 40436 6767 10 except except IN 40436 6767 11 the the DT 40436 6767 12 practical practical JJ 40436 6767 13 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 6767 14 : : : 40436 6767 15 and and CC 40436 6767 16 when when WRB 40436 6767 17 a a DT 40436 6767 18 question question NN 40436 6767 19 is be VBZ 40436 6767 20 raised raise VBN 40436 6767 21 about about IN 40436 6767 22 _ _ NNP 40436 6767 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6767 24 _ _ NNP 40436 6767 25 power power NN 40436 6767 26 to to TO 40436 6767 27 impart impart VB 40436 6767 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6767 29 own own JJ 40436 6767 30 excellence excellence NN 40436 6767 31 to to IN 40436 6767 32 others other NNS 40436 6767 33 , , , 40436 6767 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6767 35 presently presently RB 40436 6767 36 takes take VBZ 40436 6767 37 offence offence NN 40436 6767 38 against against IN 40436 6767 39 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6767 40 also also RB 40436 6767 41 . . . 40436 6768 1 The the DT 40436 6768 2 same same JJ 40436 6768 3 causes cause NNS 40436 6768 4 which which WDT 40436 6768 5 have have VBP 40436 6768 6 determined determine VBN 40436 6768 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6768 8 furious furious JJ 40436 6768 9 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 6768 10 against against IN 40436 6768 11 the the DT 40436 6768 12 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6768 13 , , , 40436 6768 14 make make VB 40436 6768 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6768 16 ready ready JJ 40436 6768 17 to to TO 40436 6768 18 transfer transfer VB 40436 6768 19 the the DT 40436 6768 20 like like JJ 40436 6768 21 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 6768 22 to to IN 40436 6768 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6768 24 . . . 40436 6769 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6769 2 is be VBZ 40436 6769 3 a a DT 40436 6769 4 man man NN 40436 6769 5 of of IN 40436 6769 6 plain plain JJ 40436 6769 7 sense sense NN 40436 6769 8 , , , 40436 6769 9 practical practical JJ 40436 6769 10 habits habit NNS 40436 6769 11 , , , 40436 6769 12 and and CC 40436 6769 13 conservative conservative JJ 40436 6769 14 patriotism patriotism NN 40436 6769 15 -- -- : 40436 6769 16 who who WP 40436 6769 17 worships worship VBZ 40436 6769 18 what what WP 40436 6769 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6769 20 finds find VBZ 40436 6769 21 accredited accredit VBN 40436 6769 22 as as IN 40436 6769 23 virtue virtue NN 40436 6769 24 , , , 40436 6769 25 and and CC 40436 6769 26 dislikes dislike VBZ 40436 6769 27 the the DT 40436 6769 28 talkers talker NNS 40436 6769 29 and and CC 40436 6769 30 theorisers theoriser NNS 40436 6769 31 about about IN 40436 6769 32 virtue virtue NN 40436 6769 33 in in IN 40436 6769 34 general general JJ 40436 6769 35 : : : 40436 6769 36 whether whether IN 40436 6769 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6769 38 debated debate VBD 40436 6769 39 in in IN 40436 6769 40 subtle subtle JJ 40436 6769 41 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 6769 42 and and CC 40436 6769 43 dialectics dialectic NNS 40436 6769 44 , , , 40436 6769 45 like like IN 40436 6769 46 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6769 47 -- -- : 40436 6769 48 or or CC 40436 6769 49 lectured lecture VBN 40436 6769 50 in in IN 40436 6769 51 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 6769 52 continuous continuous JJ 40436 6769 53 discourse discourse NN 40436 6769 54 , , , 40436 6769 55 like like IN 40436 6769 56 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6769 57 . . . 40436 6770 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6770 2 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 6770 3 the the DT 40436 6770 4 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6770 5 , , , 40436 6770 6 in in IN 40436 6770 7 this this DT 40436 6770 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6770 9 , , , 40436 6770 10 of of IN 40436 6770 11 corrupting corrupt VBG 40436 6770 12 the the DT 40436 6770 13 youth youth NN 40436 6770 14 ; ; : 40436 6770 15 just just RB 40436 6770 16 as as IN 40436 6770 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6770 18 and and CC 40436 6770 19 Melêtus Melêtus NNP 40436 6770 20 , , , 40436 6770 21 before before IN 40436 6770 22 the the DT 40436 6770 23 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 6770 24 , , , 40436 6770 25 accused accuse VBD 40436 6770 26 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6770 27 of of IN 40436 6770 28 the the DT 40436 6770 29 same same JJ 40436 6770 30 offence offence NN 40436 6770 31 . . . 40436 6771 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6771 2 understands understand VBZ 40436 6771 3 the the DT 40436 6771 4 use use NN 40436 6771 5 of of IN 40436 6771 6 words word NNS 40436 6771 7 , , , 40436 6771 8 to to TO 40436 6771 9 discuss discuss VB 40436 6771 10 actual actual JJ 40436 6771 11 business business NN 40436 6771 12 before before IN 40436 6771 13 the the DT 40436 6771 14 assembly assembly NN 40436 6771 15 or or CC 40436 6771 16 dikastery dikastery NN 40436 6771 17 ; ; : 40436 6771 18 but but CC 40436 6771 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6771 20 hates hate VBZ 40436 6771 21 discourse discourse JJ 40436 6771 22 on on IN 40436 6771 23 the the DT 40436 6771 24 generalities generality NNS 40436 6771 25 of of IN 40436 6771 26 ethics ethic NNS 40436 6771 27 or or CC 40436 6771 28 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6771 29 . . . 40436 6772 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6772 2 is be VBZ 40436 6772 3 essentially essentially RB 40436 6772 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6772 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6772 6 : : : 40436 6772 7 miso miso NN 40436 6772 8 / / SYM 40436 6772 9 logos logos NNP 40436 6772 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6772 11 . . . 40436 6773 1 The the DT 40436 6773 2 point point NN 40436 6773 3 which which WDT 40436 6773 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6773 5 condemns condemn VBZ 40436 6773 6 in in IN 40436 6773 7 the the DT 40436 6773 8 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6773 9 , , , 40436 6773 10 is be VBZ 40436 6773 11 that that DT 40436 6773 12 which which WDT 40436 6773 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6773 14 have have VBP 40436 6773 15 in in IN 40436 6773 16 common common NN 40436 6773 17 with with IN 40436 6773 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6773 19 . . . 40436 6774 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6774 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6774 3 51 51 CD 40436 6774 4 : : : 40436 6774 5 Upon upon IN 40436 6774 6 the the DT 40436 6774 7 bitter bitter JJ 40436 6774 8 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 6774 9 here here RB 40436 6774 10 expressed express VBN 40436 6774 11 by by IN 40436 6774 12 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6774 13 against against IN 40436 6774 14 the the DT 40436 6774 15 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6774 16 , , , 40436 6774 17 whom whom WP 40436 6774 18 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 6774 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6774 20 admits admit VBZ 40436 6774 21 that that IN 40436 6774 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6774 23 does do VBZ 40436 6774 24 not not RB 40436 6774 25 at at RB 40436 6774 26 all all RB 40436 6774 27 know know VB 40436 6774 28 , , , 40436 6774 29 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 6774 30 remarks remark VBZ 40436 6774 31 as as IN 40436 6774 32 follows:--"Gerade follows:--"Gerade . 40436 6774 33 so so RB 40436 6774 34 haben haben NNP 40436 6774 35 zu zu NNP 40436 6774 36 allen allen NNP 40436 6774 37 Zeiten Zeiten NNP 40436 6774 38 Orthodoxe Orthodoxe NNP 40436 6774 39 und und NN 40436 6774 40 Fanatiker Fanatiker NNP 40436 6774 41 aller aller NN 40436 6774 42 Arten Arten NNP 40436 6774 43 über über NN 40436 6774 44 ihre ihre NN 40436 6774 45 Gegner Gegner NNP 40436 6774 46 abgeurtheilt abgeurtheilt NN 40436 6774 47 , , , 40436 6774 48 ohne ohne NN 40436 6774 49 sie sie NNP 40436 6774 50 zu zu NNP 40436 6774 51 kennen kennen NNP 40436 6774 52 oder oder NNP 40436 6774 53 auch auch NNP 40436 6774 54 nur nur NNP 40436 6774 55 kennen kennen NNP 40436 6774 56 lernen lernen NNP 40436 6774 57 zu zu NNP 40436 6774 58 wollen wollen NN 40436 6774 59 " " '' 40436 6774 60 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6774 61 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 6774 62 . . . 40436 6775 1 zum zum VB 40436 6775 2 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6775 3 , , , 40436 6775 4 not not RB 40436 6775 5 . . . 40436 6776 1 15 15 CD 40436 6776 2 , , , 40436 6776 3 p. p. NN 40436 6776 4 173 173 CD 40436 6776 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6776 6 . . . 40436 6777 1 Certainly certainly RB 40436 6777 2 orthodox orthodox JJ 40436 6777 3 and and CC 40436 6777 4 fanatical fanatical JJ 40436 6777 5 persons person NNS 40436 6777 6 often often RB 40436 6777 7 do do VBP 40436 6777 8 what what WP 40436 6777 9 is be VBZ 40436 6777 10 here here RB 40436 6777 11 imputed imputed JJ 40436 6777 12 to to IN 40436 6777 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6777 14 . . . 40436 6778 1 But but CC 40436 6778 2 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 6778 3 might may MD 40436 6778 4 have have VB 40436 6778 5 found find VBN 40436 6778 6 a a DT 40436 6778 7 still still RB 40436 6778 8 closer close RBR 40436 6778 9 parallel parallel NN 40436 6778 10 with with IN 40436 6778 11 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6778 12 , , , 40436 6778 13 in in IN 40436 6778 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6778 15 own own JJ 40436 6778 16 criticisms criticism NNS 40436 6778 17 , , , 40436 6778 18 and and CC 40436 6778 19 in in IN 40436 6778 20 those those DT 40436 6778 21 of of IN 40436 6778 22 many many JJ 40436 6778 23 other other JJ 40436 6778 24 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6778 25 critics critic NNS 40436 6778 26 on on IN 40436 6778 27 the the DT 40436 6778 28 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6778 29 ; ; : 40436 6778 30 the the DT 40436 6778 31 same same JJ 40436 6778 32 expressions expression NNS 40436 6778 33 of of IN 40436 6778 34 bitterness bitterness NN 40436 6778 35 and and CC 40436 6778 36 severity severity NN 40436 6778 37 , , , 40436 6778 38 with with IN 40436 6778 39 the the DT 40436 6778 40 same same JJ 40436 6778 41 slender slend JJR 40436 6778 42 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6778 43 of of IN 40436 6778 44 the the DT 40436 6778 45 persons person NNS 40436 6778 46 upon upon IN 40436 6778 47 whom whom WP 40436 6778 48 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6778 49 bear bear VBP 40436 6778 50 . . . 40436 6778 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6779 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6779 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6779 3 52 52 CD 40436 6779 4 : : : 40436 6779 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6779 6 , , , 40436 6779 7 Apol Apol NNP 40436 6779 8 . . . 40436 6780 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 6780 2 . . . 40436 6781 1 pp pp NNP 40436 6781 2 . . . 40436 6782 1 26 26 CD 40436 6782 2 A a DT 40436 6782 3 , , , 40436 6782 4 33 33 CD 40436 6782 5 D d NN 40436 6782 6 , , , 40436 6782 7 34 34 CD 40436 6782 8 B. b. NN 40436 6782 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6783 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6783 2 Side side NN 40436 6783 3 - - HYPH 40436 6783 4 note note NN 40436 6783 5 : : : 40436 6783 6 The the DT 40436 6783 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6783 8 brings bring VBZ 40436 6783 9 forward forward RB 40436 6783 10 the the DT 40436 6783 11 point point NN 40436 6783 12 of of IN 40436 6783 13 analogy analogy NN 40436 6783 14 between between IN 40436 6783 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6783 16 and and CC 40436 6783 17 the the DT 40436 6783 18 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6783 19 , , , 40436 6783 20 in in IN 40436 6783 21 which which WDT 40436 6783 22 both both DT 40436 6783 23 were be VBD 40436 6783 24 disliked dislike VBN 40436 6783 25 by by IN 40436 6783 26 the the DT 40436 6783 27 practical practical JJ 40436 6783 28 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 6783 29 . . . 40436 6783 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6784 1 In in IN 40436 6784 2 many many JJ 40436 6784 3 of of IN 40436 6784 4 the the DT 40436 6784 5 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6784 6 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6784 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6784 8 have have VBP 40436 6784 9 the the DT 40436 6784 10 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 6784 11 between between IN 40436 6784 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6784 13 and and CC 40436 6784 14 the the DT 40436 6784 15 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6784 16 brought bring VBD 40436 6784 17 out out RP 40436 6784 18 , , , 40436 6784 19 as as IN 40436 6784 20 to to IN 40436 6784 21 the the DT 40436 6784 22 different different JJ 40436 6784 23 point point NN 40436 6784 24 of of IN 40436 6784 25 view view NN 40436 6784 26 from from IN 40436 6784 27 which which WDT 40436 6784 28 the the DT 40436 6784 29 one one NN 40436 6784 30 and and CC 40436 6784 31 the the DT 40436 6784 32 other other JJ 40436 6784 33 approached approach VBN 40436 6784 34 ethical ethical JJ 40436 6784 35 questions question NNS 40436 6784 36 . . . 40436 6785 1 But but CC 40436 6785 2 in in IN 40436 6785 3 this this DT 40436 6785 4 portion portion NN 40436 6785 5 of of IN 40436 6785 6 the the DT 40436 6785 7 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6785 8 , , , 40436 6785 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6785 10 find find VBP 40436 6785 11 exhibited exhibit VBN 40436 6785 12 the the DT 40436 6785 13 feature feature NN 40436 6785 14 of of IN 40436 6785 15 analogy analogy NN 40436 6785 16 between between IN 40436 6785 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6785 18 , , , 40436 6785 19 in in IN 40436 6785 20 which which WDT 40436 6785 21 both both DT 40436 6785 22 one one CD 40436 6785 23 and and CC 40436 6785 24 the the DT 40436 6785 25 other other JJ 40436 6785 26 stood stand VBD 40436 6785 27 upon upon IN 40436 6785 28 ground ground NN 40436 6785 29 obnoxious obnoxious JJ 40436 6785 30 to to IN 40436 6785 31 the the DT 40436 6785 32 merely merely RB 40436 6785 33 practical practical JJ 40436 6785 34 politicians politician NNS 40436 6785 35 . . . 40436 6786 1 Far far RB 40436 6786 2 from from IN 40436 6786 3 regarding regard VBG 40436 6786 4 hatred hatred NN 40436 6786 5 against against IN 40436 6786 6 the the DT 40436 6786 7 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6786 8 as as IN 40436 6786 9 a a DT 40436 6786 10 mark mark NN 40436 6786 11 of of IN 40436 6786 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 6786 13 in in IN 40436 6786 14 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6786 15 , , , 40436 6786 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6786 17 deprecates deprecate VBZ 40436 6786 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6786 19 as as IN 40436 6786 20 unwarranted unwarranted JJ 40436 6786 21 and and CC 40436 6786 22 as as IN 40436 6786 23 menacing menacing JJ 40436 6786 24 to to IN 40436 6786 25 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 6786 26 in in IN 40436 6786 27 all all DT 40436 6786 28 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6786 29 manifestations manifestation NNS 40436 6786 30 . . . 40436 6787 1 The the DT 40436 6787 2 last last JJ 40436 6787 3 declaration declaration NN 40436 6787 4 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 6787 5 to to IN 40436 6787 6 Anytus Anytus NNP 40436 6787 7 , , , 40436 6787 8 coupled couple VBN 40436 6787 9 with with IN 40436 6787 10 the the DT 40436 6787 11 last last JJ 40436 6787 12 speech speech NN 40436 6787 13 of of IN 40436 6787 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6787 15 in in IN 40436 6787 16 the the DT 40436 6787 17 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6787 18 , , , 40436 6787 19 show show VBP 40436 6787 20 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6787 21 that that IN 40436 6787 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6787 23 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 6787 24 the the DT 40436 6787 25 anti anti JJ 40436 6787 26 - - JJ 40436 6787 27 Sophistic sophistic JJ 40436 6787 28 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 6787 29 as as IN 40436 6787 30 being be VBG 40436 6787 31 anti anti JJ 40436 6787 32 - - JJ 40436 6787 33 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 6787 34 also also RB 40436 6787 35 , , , 40436 6787 36 in in IN 40436 6787 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6787 38 natural natural JJ 40436 6787 39 consequences consequence NNS 40436 6787 40 . . . 40436 6788 1 That that IN 40436 6788 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6788 3 was be VBD 40436 6788 4 in in IN 40436 6788 5 common common JJ 40436 6788 6 parlance parlance NN 40436 6788 7 a a DT 40436 6788 8 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6788 9 , , , 40436 6788 10 disliked dislike VBN 40436 6788 11 by by IN 40436 6788 12 a a DT 40436 6788 13 large large JJ 40436 6788 14 portion portion NN 40436 6788 15 of of IN 40436 6788 16 the the DT 40436 6788 17 general general JJ 40436 6788 18 public public NN 40436 6788 19 , , , 40436 6788 20 and and CC 40436 6788 21 ridiculed ridicule VBN 40436 6788 22 by by IN 40436 6788 23 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNP 40436 6788 24 , , , 40436 6788 25 on on IN 40436 6788 26 the the DT 40436 6788 27 same same JJ 40436 6788 28 grounds ground NNS 40436 6788 29 as as IN 40436 6788 30 those those DT 40436 6788 31 whom whom WP 40436 6788 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6788 33 calls call VBZ 40436 6788 34 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6788 35 -- -- : 40436 6788 36 is be VBZ 40436 6788 37 a a DT 40436 6788 38 point point NN 40436 6788 39 which which WDT 40436 6788 40 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6788 41 have have VBP 40436 6788 42 noticed notice VBN 40436 6788 43 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 6788 44 . . . 40436 6789 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 40436 6789 2 XXIII XXIII NNP 40436 6789 3 . . . 40436 6790 1 PROTAGORAS PROTAGORAS NNP 40436 6790 2 . . . 40436 6791 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6791 2 Side side NN 40436 6791 3 - - HYPH 40436 6791 4 note note NN 40436 6791 5 : : : 40436 6791 6 Scenic scenic JJ 40436 6791 7 arrangement arrangement NN 40436 6791 8 and and CC 40436 6791 9 personages personage NNS 40436 6791 10 of of IN 40436 6791 11 the the DT 40436 6791 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6791 13 . . . 40436 6791 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6792 1 The the DT 40436 6792 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6792 3 called call VBD 40436 6792 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6792 5 presents present VBZ 40436 6792 6 a a DT 40436 6792 7 larger large JJR 40436 6792 8 assemblage assemblage NN 40436 6792 9 of of IN 40436 6792 10 varied varied JJ 40436 6792 11 and and CC 40436 6792 12 celebrated celebrated JJ 40436 6792 13 characters character NNS 40436 6792 14 , , , 40436 6792 15 with with IN 40436 6792 16 more more JJR 40436 6792 17 of of IN 40436 6792 18 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 6792 19 winding winding NN 40436 6792 20 , , , 40436 6792 21 and and CC 40436 6792 22 more more RBR 40436 6792 23 frequent frequent JJ 40436 6792 24 breaks break NNS 40436 6792 25 and and CC 40436 6792 26 resumptions resumption NNS 40436 6792 27 in in IN 40436 6792 28 the the DT 40436 6792 29 conversation conversation NN 40436 6792 30 , , , 40436 6792 31 than than IN 40436 6792 32 any any DT 40436 6792 33 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6792 34 of of IN 40436 6792 35 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6792 36 -- -- : 40436 6792 37 not not RB 40436 6792 38 excepting except VBG 40436 6792 39 even even RB 40436 6792 40 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 6792 41 and and CC 40436 6792 42 Republic Republic NNP 40436 6792 43 . . . 40436 6793 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6793 2 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 6793 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6793 4 in in IN 40436 6793 5 controversy controversy NN 40436 6793 6 with with IN 40436 6793 7 the the DT 40436 6793 8 celebrated celebrated JJ 40436 6793 9 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6793 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6793 11 , , , 40436 6793 12 in in IN 40436 6793 13 the the DT 40436 6793 14 presence presence NN 40436 6793 15 of of IN 40436 6793 16 a a DT 40436 6793 17 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 6793 18 society society NN 40436 6793 19 , , , 40436 6793 20 most most JJS 40436 6793 21 of of IN 40436 6793 22 whom whom WP 40436 6793 23 take take VBP 40436 6793 24 occasional occasional JJ 40436 6793 25 part part NN 40436 6793 26 in in IN 40436 6793 27 the the DT 40436 6793 28 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6793 29 . . . 40436 6794 1 This this DT 40436 6794 2 controversy controversy NN 40436 6794 3 is be VBZ 40436 6794 4 preceded precede VBN 40436 6794 5 by by IN 40436 6794 6 a a DT 40436 6794 7 striking striking JJ 40436 6794 8 conversation conversation NN 40436 6794 9 between between IN 40436 6794 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6794 11 and and CC 40436 6794 12 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6794 13 -- -- : 40436 6794 14 a a DT 40436 6794 15 youth youth NN 40436 6794 16 of of IN 40436 6794 17 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 6794 18 family family NN 40436 6794 19 , , , 40436 6794 20 eager eager JJ 40436 6794 21 to to TO 40436 6794 22 profit profit VB 40436 6794 23 by by IN 40436 6794 24 the the DT 40436 6794 25 instructions instruction NNS 40436 6794 26 of of IN 40436 6794 27 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6794 28 . . . 40436 6795 1 The the DT 40436 6795 2 two two CD 40436 6795 3 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6795 4 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 6795 5 and and CC 40436 6795 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 6795 7 , , , 40436 6795 8 together together RB 40436 6795 9 with with IN 40436 6795 10 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 6795 11 , , , 40436 6795 12 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 6795 13 , , , 40436 6795 14 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 6795 15 , , , 40436 6795 16 Eryximachus Eryximachus NNP 40436 6795 17 , , , 40436 6795 18 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 6795 19 , , , 40436 6795 20 Pausanias Pausanias NNP 40436 6795 21 , , , 40436 6795 22 Agathon Agathon NNP 40436 6795 23 , , , 40436 6795 24 the the DT 40436 6795 25 two two CD 40436 6795 26 sons son NNS 40436 6795 27 of of IN 40436 6795 28 Periklês Periklês NNP 40436 6795 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6795 30 Paralus Paralus NNP 40436 6795 31 and and CC 40436 6795 32 Xanthippus Xanthippus NNP 40436 6795 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6795 34 , , , 40436 6795 35 Charmides Charmides NNP 40436 6795 36 , , , 40436 6795 37 son son NN 40436 6795 38 of of IN 40436 6795 39 Glaukon Glaukon NNP 40436 6795 40 , , , 40436 6795 41 Antimoerus Antimoerus NNP 40436 6795 42 of of IN 40436 6795 43 Mende Mende NNP 40436 6795 44 , , , 40436 6795 45 a a DT 40436 6795 46 promising promising JJ 40436 6795 47 pupil pupil NN 40436 6795 48 of of IN 40436 6795 49 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6795 50 , , , 40436 6795 51 who who WP 40436 6795 52 is be VBZ 40436 6795 53 in in IN 40436 6795 54 training training NN 40436 6795 55 for for IN 40436 6795 56 the the DT 40436 6795 57 profession profession NN 40436 6795 58 of of IN 40436 6795 59 a a DT 40436 6795 60 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6795 61 -- -- : 40436 6795 62 these these DT 40436 6795 63 and and CC 40436 6795 64 others other NNS 40436 6795 65 are be VBP 40436 6795 66 all all RB 40436 6795 67 present present JJ 40436 6795 68 at at IN 40436 6795 69 the the DT 40436 6795 70 meeting meeting NN 40436 6795 71 , , , 40436 6795 72 which which WDT 40436 6795 73 is be VBZ 40436 6795 74 held hold VBN 40436 6795 75 in in IN 40436 6795 76 the the DT 40436 6795 77 house house NN 40436 6795 78 of of IN 40436 6795 79 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 6795 80 . . . 40436 6796 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6796 2 1 1 LS 40436 6796 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6796 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6796 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6796 6 recounts recount VBZ 40436 6796 7 the the DT 40436 6796 8 whole whole NN 40436 6796 9 -- -- : 40436 6796 10 both both DT 40436 6796 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6796 12 conversation conversation NN 40436 6796 13 with with IN 40436 6796 14 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6796 15 and and CC 40436 6796 16 that that IN 40436 6796 17 with with IN 40436 6796 18 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6796 19 -- -- : 40436 6796 20 to to IN 40436 6796 21 a a DT 40436 6796 22 nameless nameless JJ 40436 6796 23 friend friend NN 40436 6796 24 . . . 40436 6797 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6797 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6797 3 1 1 CD 40436 6797 4 : : : 40436 6797 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6797 6 , , , 40436 6797 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6797 8 . . . 40436 6798 1 p. p. NN 40436 6799 1 315 315 CD 40436 6799 2 . . . 40436 6799 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6800 1 This this DT 40436 6800 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6800 3 enters enter VBZ 40436 6800 4 upon upon IN 40436 6800 5 a a DT 40436 6800 6 larger large JJR 40436 6800 7 and and CC 40436 6800 8 more more RBR 40436 6800 9 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 6800 10 ethical ethical JJ 40436 6800 11 theory theory NN 40436 6800 12 than than IN 40436 6800 13 anything anything NN 40436 6800 14 in in IN 40436 6800 15 the the DT 40436 6800 16 others other NNS 40436 6800 17 hitherto hitherto RB 40436 6800 18 noticed notice VBD 40436 6800 19 . . . 40436 6801 1 But but CC 40436 6801 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6801 3 contains contain VBZ 40436 6801 4 also also RB 40436 6801 5 a a DT 40436 6801 6 great great JJ 40436 6801 7 deal deal NN 40436 6801 8 in in IN 40436 6801 9 which which WDT 40436 6801 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6801 11 hardly hardly RB 40436 6801 12 recognise recognise VBP 40436 6801 13 , , , 40436 6801 14 or or CC 40436 6801 15 at at IN 40436 6801 16 least least JJS 40436 6801 17 can can MD 40436 6801 18 not not RB 40436 6801 19 verify verify VB 40436 6801 20 , , , 40436 6801 21 any any DT 40436 6801 22 distinct distinct JJ 40436 6801 23 purpose purpose NN 40436 6801 24 , , , 40436 6801 25 either either DT 40436 6801 26 of of IN 40436 6801 27 search search NN 40436 6801 28 or or CC 40436 6801 29 exposition exposition NN 40436 6801 30 . . . 40436 6802 1 Much much JJ 40436 6802 2 of of IN 40436 6802 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6802 4 seems seem VBZ 40436 6802 5 to to TO 40436 6802 6 be be VB 40436 6802 7 composed compose VBN 40436 6802 8 with with IN 40436 6802 9 a a DT 40436 6802 10 literary literary JJ 40436 6802 11 or or CC 40436 6802 12 poetical poetical JJ 40436 6802 13 view view NN 40436 6802 14 , , , 40436 6802 15 to to TO 40436 6802 16 enhance enhance VB 40436 6802 17 the the DT 40436 6802 18 charm charm NN 40436 6802 19 or or CC 40436 6802 20 interest interest NN 40436 6802 21 of of IN 40436 6802 22 the the DT 40436 6802 23 composition composition NN 40436 6802 24 . . . 40436 6803 1 The the DT 40436 6803 2 personal personal JJ 40436 6803 3 characteristics characteristic NNS 40436 6803 4 of of IN 40436 6803 5 each each DT 40436 6803 6 speaker speaker NN 40436 6803 7 -- -- : 40436 6803 8 the the DT 40436 6803 9 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 6803 10 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 40436 6803 11 of of IN 40436 6803 12 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 6803 13 and and CC 40436 6803 14 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 6803 15 -- -- : 40436 6803 16 the the DT 40436 6803 17 ardent ardent JJ 40436 6803 18 partisanship partisanship NN 40436 6803 19 of of IN 40436 6803 20 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 6803 21 -- -- : 40436 6803 22 are be VBP 40436 6803 23 brought bring VBN 40436 6803 24 out out RP 40436 6803 25 as as IN 40436 6803 26 in in IN 40436 6803 27 a a DT 40436 6803 28 real real JJ 40436 6803 29 drama drama NN 40436 6803 30 . . . 40436 6804 1 But but CC 40436 6804 2 the the DT 40436 6804 3 great great JJ 40436 6804 4 and and CC 40436 6804 5 marked marked JJ 40436 6804 6 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 6804 7 is be VBZ 40436 6804 8 that that IN 40436 6804 9 between between IN 40436 6804 10 the the DT 40436 6804 11 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6804 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 6804 13 and and CC 40436 6804 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6804 15 -- -- : 40436 6804 16 the the DT 40436 6804 17 Hektor Hektor NNP 40436 6804 18 and and CC 40436 6804 19 Ajax Ajax NNP 40436 6804 20 of of IN 40436 6804 21 the the DT 40436 6804 22 piece piece NN 40436 6804 23 : : : 40436 6804 24 who who WP 40436 6804 25 stand stand VBP 40436 6804 26 forward forward RB 40436 6804 27 in in IN 40436 6804 28 single single JJ 40436 6804 29 combat combat NN 40436 6804 30 , , , 40436 6804 31 exchange exchange VB 40436 6804 32 some some DT 40436 6804 33 serious serious JJ 40436 6804 34 blows blow NNS 40436 6804 35 , , , 40436 6804 36 yet yet CC 40436 6804 37 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 6804 38 part part NN 40436 6804 39 as as IN 40436 6804 40 friends friend NNS 40436 6804 41 . . . 40436 6805 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6805 2 Side side NN 40436 6805 3 - - HYPH 40436 6805 4 note note NN 40436 6805 5 : : : 40436 6805 6 Introduction introduction NN 40436 6805 7 . . . 40436 6806 1 Eagerness eagerness NN 40436 6806 2 of of IN 40436 6806 3 the the DT 40436 6806 4 youthful youthful JJ 40436 6806 5 Hippokrates hippokrate NNS 40436 6806 6 to to TO 40436 6806 7 become become VB 40436 6806 8 acquainted acquaint VBN 40436 6806 9 with with IN 40436 6806 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6806 11 . . . 40436 6806 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6807 1 An an DT 40436 6807 2 introduction introduction NN 40436 6807 3 of of IN 40436 6807 4 some some DT 40436 6807 5 length length NN 40436 6807 6 impresses impress NNS 40436 6807 7 upon upon IN 40436 6807 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6807 9 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 6807 10 the the DT 40436 6807 11 celebrity celebrity NN 40436 6807 12 of of IN 40436 6807 13 the the DT 40436 6807 14 Great Great NNP 40436 6807 15 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6807 16 , , , 40436 6807 17 and and CC 40436 6807 18 the the DT 40436 6807 19 earnest earnest JJ 40436 6807 20 interest interest NN 40436 6807 21 excited excite VBN 40436 6807 22 by by IN 40436 6807 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6807 24 visit visit NN 40436 6807 25 to to IN 40436 6807 26 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6807 27 . . . 40436 6808 1 Hippokrates hippokrate NNS 40436 6808 2 , , , 40436 6808 3 a a DT 40436 6808 4 young young JJ 40436 6808 5 man man NN 40436 6808 6 of of IN 40436 6808 7 noble noble JJ 40436 6808 8 family family NN 40436 6808 9 and and CC 40436 6808 10 eager eager JJ 40436 6808 11 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 6808 12 for for IN 40436 6808 13 improvement improvement NN 40436 6808 14 , , , 40436 6808 15 having have VBG 40436 6808 16 just just RB 40436 6808 17 learnt learn VBN 40436 6808 18 the the DT 40436 6808 19 arrival arrival NN 40436 6808 20 of of IN 40436 6808 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6808 22 , , , 40436 6808 23 comes come VBZ 40436 6808 24 to to IN 40436 6808 25 the the DT 40436 6808 26 house house NN 40436 6808 27 of of IN 40436 6808 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6808 29 and and CC 40436 6808 30 awakens awaken VBZ 40436 6808 31 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6808 32 before before IN 40436 6808 33 daylight daylight NN 40436 6808 34 , , , 40436 6808 35 entreating entreat VBG 40436 6808 36 that that IN 40436 6808 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6808 38 will will MD 40436 6808 39 introduce introduce VB 40436 6808 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6808 41 to to IN 40436 6808 42 the the DT 40436 6808 43 new new JJ 40436 6808 44 - - HYPH 40436 6808 45 comer comer NN 40436 6808 46 . . . 40436 6809 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6809 2 is be VBZ 40436 6809 3 ready ready JJ 40436 6809 4 to to TO 40436 6809 5 give give VB 40436 6809 6 all all DT 40436 6809 7 that that WDT 40436 6809 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6809 9 possesses possess VBZ 40436 6809 10 in in IN 40436 6809 11 order order NN 40436 6809 12 that that IN 40436 6809 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6809 14 may may MD 40436 6809 15 become become VB 40436 6809 16 wise wise JJ 40436 6809 17 like like IN 40436 6809 18 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6809 19 . . . 40436 6810 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6810 2 2 2 LS 40436 6810 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6810 4 While while IN 40436 6810 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6810 6 are be VBP 40436 6810 7 awaiting await VBG 40436 6810 8 a a DT 40436 6810 9 suitable suitable JJ 40436 6810 10 hour hour NN 40436 6810 11 for for IN 40436 6810 12 such such JJ 40436 6810 13 introduction introduction NN 40436 6810 14 , , , 40436 6810 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6810 16 puts put VBZ 40436 6810 17 a a DT 40436 6810 18 series series NN 40436 6810 19 of of IN 40436 6810 20 questions question NNS 40436 6810 21 to to TO 40436 6810 22 test test VB 40436 6810 23 the the DT 40436 6810 24 force force NN 40436 6810 25 of of IN 40436 6810 26 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6810 27 . . . 40436 6811 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6811 2 3 3 CD 40436 6811 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6811 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6811 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6811 6 2 2 CD 40436 6811 7 : : : 40436 6811 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6811 9 , , , 40436 6811 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6811 11 . . . 40436 6812 1 pp pp NNP 40436 6812 2 . . . 40436 6813 1 310 310 CD 40436 6813 2 - - SYM 40436 6813 3 311 311 CD 40436 6813 4 A. a. NN 40436 6813 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6814 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6814 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6814 3 3 3 CD 40436 6814 4 : : : 40436 6814 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6814 6 , , , 40436 6814 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6814 8 . . . 40436 6815 1 p. p. NN 40436 6815 2 311 311 CD 40436 6815 3 B. B. NNP 40436 6816 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6816 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6816 3 : : : 40436 6816 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6816 5 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 6816 6 popeirô popeirô NNP 40436 6816 7 / / SYM 40436 6816 8 menos menos JJ 40436 6816 9 tou= tou= NNP 40436 6816 10 I(ppokra i(ppokra JJ 40436 6816 11 / / SYM 40436 6816 12 tous tous JJ 40436 6816 13 tê tê NN 40436 6816 14 = = SYM 40436 6816 15 s s NNP 40436 6816 16 r(ô r(ô NNP 40436 6816 17 / / SYM 40436 6816 18 mês mês NNP 40436 6816 19 diesko diesko NNP 40436 6816 20 / / SYM 40436 6816 21 poun poun NNP 40436 6816 22 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 6816 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6816 24 ê)rô ê)rô NNP 40436 6816 25 / / SYM 40436 6816 26 tôn tôn NNP 40436 6816 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6816 28 , , , 40436 6816 29 & & CC 40436 6816 30 c. c. NNP 40436 6816 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6816 32 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6816 33 Side side NN 40436 6816 34 - - HYPH 40436 6816 35 note note NN 40436 6816 36 : : : 40436 6816 37 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6816 38 questions question NNS 40436 6816 39 Hippokrates hippokrate NNS 40436 6816 40 as as IN 40436 6816 41 to to IN 40436 6816 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6816 43 purpose purpose NN 40436 6816 44 and and CC 40436 6816 45 expectations expectation NNS 40436 6816 46 from from IN 40436 6816 47 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6816 48 . . . 40436 6816 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6817 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6817 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 6817 3 are be VBP 40436 6817 4 now now RB 40436 6817 5 intending intend VBG 40436 6817 6 to to TO 40436 6817 7 visit visit VB 40436 6817 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6817 9 , , , 40436 6817 10 and and CC 40436 6817 11 to to TO 40436 6817 12 pay pay VB 40436 6817 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6817 14 for for IN 40436 6817 15 something something NN 40436 6817 16 to to TO 40436 6817 17 be be VB 40436 6817 18 done do VBN 40436 6817 19 for for IN 40436 6817 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6817 21 -- -- : 40436 6817 22 tell tell VB 40436 6817 23 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6817 24 what what WDT 40436 6817 25 manner manner NN 40436 6817 26 of of IN 40436 6817 27 man man NN 40436 6817 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6817 29 is be VBZ 40436 6817 30 that that IN 40436 6817 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6817 32 are be VBP 40436 6817 33 going go VBG 40436 6817 34 to to TO 40436 6817 35 visit visit VB 40436 6817 36 -- -- : 40436 6817 37 and and CC 40436 6817 38 what what WDT 40436 6817 39 manner manner NN 40436 6817 40 of of IN 40436 6817 41 man man NN 40436 6817 42 do do VBP 40436 6817 43 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6817 44 wish wish VB 40436 6817 45 to to TO 40436 6817 46 become become VB 40436 6817 47 ? ? . 40436 6818 1 If if IN 40436 6818 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6818 3 were be VBD 40436 6818 4 going go VBG 40436 6818 5 in in RP 40436 6818 6 like like IN 40436 6818 7 manner manner NN 40436 6818 8 to to TO 40436 6818 9 pay pay VB 40436 6818 10 a a DT 40436 6818 11 fee fee NN 40436 6818 12 for for IN 40436 6818 13 instruction instruction NN 40436 6818 14 to to IN 40436 6818 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6818 16 namesake namesake NN 40436 6818 17 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6818 18 of of IN 40436 6818 19 Kos Kos NNP 40436 6818 20 , , , 40436 6818 21 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6818 22 would would MD 40436 6818 23 tell tell VB 40436 6818 24 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6818 25 that that IN 40436 6818 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6818 27 were be VBD 40436 6818 28 going go VBG 40436 6818 29 to to IN 40436 6818 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6818 31 as as IN 40436 6818 32 to to IN 40436 6818 33 a a DT 40436 6818 34 physician physician NN 40436 6818 35 -- -- : 40436 6818 36 and and CC 40436 6818 37 that that IN 40436 6818 38 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6818 39 wished wish VBD 40436 6818 40 to to TO 40436 6818 41 qualify qualify VB 40436 6818 42 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6818 43 for for IN 40436 6818 44 becoming become VBG 40436 6818 45 a a DT 40436 6818 46 physician physician NN 40436 6818 47 . . . 40436 6819 1 If if IN 40436 6819 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6819 3 were be VBD 40436 6819 4 addressing address VBG 40436 6819 5 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6819 6 with with IN 40436 6819 7 the the DT 40436 6819 8 like like JJ 40436 6819 9 view view NN 40436 6819 10 to to IN 40436 6819 11 Pheidias Pheidias NNP 40436 6819 12 or or CC 40436 6819 13 Polykleitus Polykleitus NNP 40436 6819 14 , , , 40436 6819 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6819 16 would would MD 40436 6819 17 go go VB 40436 6819 18 to to IN 40436 6819 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6819 20 as as IN 40436 6819 21 to to IN 40436 6819 22 sculptors sculptor NNS 40436 6819 23 , , , 40436 6819 24 and and CC 40436 6819 25 for for IN 40436 6819 26 the the DT 40436 6819 27 purpose purpose NN 40436 6819 28 of of IN 40436 6819 29 becoming become VBG 40436 6819 30 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6819 31 a a DT 40436 6819 32 sculptor sculptor NN 40436 6819 33 . . . 40436 6820 1 Now now RB 40436 6820 2 then then RB 40436 6820 3 that that IN 40436 6820 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6820 5 are be VBP 40436 6820 6 to to TO 40436 6820 7 go go VB 40436 6820 8 in in IN 40436 6820 9 all all PDT 40436 6820 10 this this DT 40436 6820 11 hurry hurry NN 40436 6820 12 to to IN 40436 6820 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6820 14 , , , 40436 6820 15 tell tell VB 40436 6820 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6820 17 who who WP 40436 6820 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6820 19 is be VBZ 40436 6820 20 and and CC 40436 6820 21 what what WDT 40436 6820 22 title title NN 40436 6820 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6820 24 bears bear VBZ 40436 6820 25 , , , 40436 6820 26 as as IN 40436 6820 27 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6820 28 called call VBD 40436 6820 29 Pheidias Pheidias NNP 40436 6820 30 a a DT 40436 6820 31 sculptor sculptor NN 40436 6820 32 ? ? . 40436 6821 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6821 2 Hipp._--They Hipp._--They NNP 40436 6821 3 call call VB 40436 6821 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6821 5 a a DT 40436 6821 6 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6821 7 . . . 40436 6822 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6822 2 4 4 CD 40436 6822 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6822 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6822 5 Sokr._--We Sokr._--We NNP 40436 6822 6 are be VBP 40436 6822 7 going go VBG 40436 6822 8 to to TO 40436 6822 9 pay pay VB 40436 6822 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6822 11 then then RB 40436 6822 12 as as IN 40436 6822 13 a a DT 40436 6822 14 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6822 15 ? ? . 40436 6823 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6823 2 Hipp._--Certainly Hipp._--Certainly NNP 40436 6823 3 . . . 40436 6824 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6824 2 Sokr._--And Sokr._--And NNP 40436 6824 3 what what WP 40436 6824 4 are be VBP 40436 6824 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6824 6 to to TO 40436 6824 7 become become VB 40436 6824 8 by by IN 40436 6824 9 going go VBG 40436 6824 10 to to IN 40436 6824 11 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6824 12 ? ? . 40436 6825 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6825 2 Hipp._--Why Hipp._--Why NNP 40436 6825 3 , , , 40436 6825 4 judging judge VBG 40436 6825 5 from from IN 40436 6825 6 the the DT 40436 6825 7 preceding precede VBG 40436 6825 8 analogies analogy NNS 40436 6825 9 , , , 40436 6825 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6825 11 am be VBP 40436 6825 12 to to TO 40436 6825 13 become become VB 40436 6825 14 a a DT 40436 6825 15 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6825 16 . . . 40436 6826 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6826 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 6826 3 would would MD 40436 6826 4 not not RB 40436 6826 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6826 6 be be VB 40436 6826 7 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 6826 8 of of IN 40436 6826 9 presenting present VBG 40436 6826 10 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6826 11 to to IN 40436 6826 12 the the DT 40436 6826 13 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 6826 14 public public NN 40436 6826 15 as as IN 40436 6826 16 a a DT 40436 6826 17 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6826 18 ? ? . 40436 6827 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6827 2 Hipp._--Yes Hipp._--Yes NNP 40436 6827 3 : : : 40436 6827 4 if if IN 40436 6827 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6827 6 am be VBP 40436 6827 7 to to TO 40436 6827 8 tell tell VB 40436 6827 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6827 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6827 11 real real JJ 40436 6827 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 6827 13 . . . 40436 6828 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6828 2 5 5 CD 40436 6828 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6828 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6828 5 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 6828 6 however however RB 40436 6828 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6828 8 only only RB 40436 6828 9 propose propose VBP 40436 6828 10 to to TO 40436 6828 11 visit visit VB 40436 6828 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6828 13 , , , 40436 6828 14 as as IN 40436 6828 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6828 16 visited visit VBD 40436 6828 17 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6828 18 schoolmaster schoolmaster NN 40436 6828 19 and and CC 40436 6828 20 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6828 21 musical musical JJ 40436 6828 22 or or CC 40436 6828 23 gymnastical gymnastical JJ 40436 6828 24 teacher teacher NN 40436 6828 25 : : : 40436 6828 26 not not RB 40436 6828 27 for for IN 40436 6828 28 the the DT 40436 6828 29 purpose purpose NN 40436 6828 30 of of IN 40436 6828 31 entering enter VBG 40436 6828 32 that that DT 40436 6828 33 career career NN 40436 6828 34 as as IN 40436 6828 35 a a DT 40436 6828 36 professional professional JJ 40436 6828 37 man man NN 40436 6828 38 , , , 40436 6828 39 but but CC 40436 6828 40 to to TO 40436 6828 41 acquire acquire VB 40436 6828 42 such such JJ 40436 6828 43 instruction instruction NN 40436 6828 44 as as IN 40436 6828 45 is be VBZ 40436 6828 46 suitable suitable JJ 40436 6828 47 for for IN 40436 6828 48 a a DT 40436 6828 49 private private JJ 40436 6828 50 citizen citizen NN 40436 6828 51 and and CC 40436 6828 52 a a DT 40436 6828 53 freeman freeman NN 40436 6828 54 ? ? . 40436 6829 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6829 2 Hipp._--That Hipp._--That NNP 40436 6829 3 is be VBZ 40436 6829 4 more more JJR 40436 6829 5 the the DT 40436 6829 6 instruction instruction NN 40436 6829 7 which which WDT 40436 6829 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6829 9 seek seek VBP 40436 6829 10 from from IN 40436 6829 11 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6829 12 . . . 40436 6830 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6830 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 6830 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6830 4 know know VBP 40436 6830 5 then then RB 40436 6830 6 what what WP 40436 6830 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6830 8 are be VBP 40436 6830 9 going go VBG 40436 6830 10 to to TO 40436 6830 11 do do VB 40436 6830 12 ? ? . 40436 6831 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 6831 2 are be VBP 40436 6831 3 consigning consign VBG 40436 6831 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6831 5 mind mind NN 40436 6831 6 to to TO 40436 6831 7 be be VB 40436 6831 8 treated treat VBN 40436 6831 9 by by IN 40436 6831 10 one one CD 40436 6831 11 whom whom WP 40436 6831 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6831 13 call call VBP 40436 6831 14 a a DT 40436 6831 15 Sophist sophist NN 40436 6831 16 : : : 40436 6831 17 but but CC 40436 6831 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6831 19 shall shall MD 40436 6831 20 be be VB 40436 6831 21 surprised surprised JJ 40436 6831 22 if if IN 40436 6831 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6831 24 know know VBP 40436 6831 25 what what WP 40436 6831 26 a a DT 40436 6831 27 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 6831 28 is[6]--and is[6]--and NN 40436 6831 29 if if IN 40436 6831 30 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6831 31 do do VBP 40436 6831 32 not not RB 40436 6831 33 know know VB 40436 6831 34 , , , 40436 6831 35 neither neither CC 40436 6831 36 do do VBP 40436 6831 37 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6831 38 know know VB 40436 6831 39 what what WP 40436 6831 40 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6831 41 is be VBZ 40436 6831 42 -- -- : 40436 6831 43 good good JJ 40436 6831 44 or or CC 40436 6831 45 evil evil NN 40436 6831 46 -- -- : 40436 6831 47 to to TO 40436 6831 48 which which WDT 40436 6831 49 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6831 50 are be VBP 40436 6831 51 consigning consign VBG 40436 6831 52 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6831 53 mind mind NN 40436 6831 54 . . . 40436 6832 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6832 2 Hipp._--I Hipp._--I NNP 40436 6832 3 think think VBP 40436 6832 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6832 5 _ _ NNP 40436 6832 6 do do VBP 40436 6832 7 _ _ NNP 40436 6832 8 know know VB 40436 6832 9 . . . 40436 6833 1 The the DT 40436 6833 2 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6833 3 is be VBZ 40436 6833 4 , , , 40436 6833 5 as as IN 40436 6833 6 the the DT 40436 6833 7 name name NN 40436 6833 8 implies imply VBZ 40436 6833 9 , , , 40436 6833 10 one one CD 40436 6833 11 cognizant cognizant NN 40436 6833 12 of of IN 40436 6833 13 matters matter NNS 40436 6833 14 wise wise JJ 40436 6833 15 and and CC 40436 6833 16 able able JJ 40436 6833 17 . . . 40436 6834 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6834 2 7 7 CD 40436 6834 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6834 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6834 5 Sokr._--That Sokr._--That NNP 40436 6834 6 may may MD 40436 6834 7 be be VB 40436 6834 8 said say VBN 40436 6834 9 also also RB 40436 6834 10 of of IN 40436 6834 11 painters painter NNS 40436 6834 12 and and CC 40436 6834 13 carpenters carpenter NNS 40436 6834 14 . . . 40436 6835 1 If if IN 40436 6835 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6835 3 were be VBD 40436 6835 4 asked ask VBN 40436 6835 5 in in IN 40436 6835 6 what what WP 40436 6835 7 special special JJ 40436 6835 8 department department NN 40436 6835 9 are be VBP 40436 6835 10 painters painter NNS 40436 6835 11 cognizant cognizant JJ 40436 6835 12 of of IN 40436 6835 13 matters matter NNS 40436 6835 14 wise wise JJ 40436 6835 15 and and CC 40436 6835 16 able able JJ 40436 6835 17 , , , 40436 6835 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6835 19 should should MD 40436 6835 20 specify specify VB 40436 6835 21 that that IN 40436 6835 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6835 23 was be VBD 40436 6835 24 in in IN 40436 6835 25 the the DT 40436 6835 26 workmanship workmanship NN 40436 6835 27 of of IN 40436 6835 28 portraits portrait NNS 40436 6835 29 . . . 40436 6836 1 Answer answer VB 40436 6836 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6836 3 the the DT 40436 6836 4 same same JJ 40436 6836 5 question question NN 40436 6836 6 about about IN 40436 6836 7 the the DT 40436 6836 8 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6836 9 . . . 40436 6837 1 What what WDT 40436 6837 2 sort sort NN 40436 6837 3 of of IN 40436 6837 4 workmanship workmanship NN 40436 6837 5 does do VBZ 40436 6837 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6837 7 direct direct VB 40436 6837 8 ? ? . 40436 6838 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6838 2 Hipp._--That Hipp._--That NNP 40436 6838 3 of of IN 40436 6838 4 forming form VBG 40436 6838 5 able able JJ 40436 6838 6 speakers speaker NNS 40436 6838 7 . . . 40436 6839 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6839 2 8 8 CD 40436 6839 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6839 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6839 5 Sokr._--Your Sokr._--Your NNP 40436 6839 6 answer answer NN 40436 6839 7 may may MD 40436 6839 8 be be VB 40436 6839 9 correct correct JJ 40436 6839 10 , , , 40436 6839 11 but but CC 40436 6839 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6839 13 is be VBZ 40436 6839 14 not not RB 40436 6839 15 specific specific JJ 40436 6839 16 enough enough RB 40436 6839 17 : : : 40436 6839 18 for for IN 40436 6839 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6839 20 must must MD 40436 6839 21 still still RB 40436 6839 22 ask ask VB 40436 6839 23 , , , 40436 6839 24 About about IN 40436 6839 25 _ _ NNP 40436 6839 26 what what WP 40436 6839 27 _ _ NNP 40436 6839 28 is be VBZ 40436 6839 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6839 30 that that WDT 40436 6839 31 the the DT 40436 6839 32 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 6839 33 forms form NNS 40436 6839 34 able able JJ 40436 6839 35 speakers speaker NNS 40436 6839 36 ? ? . 40436 6840 1 just just RB 40436 6840 2 as as IN 40436 6840 3 the the DT 40436 6840 4 harp harp NN 40436 6840 5 - - HYPH 40436 6840 6 master master NN 40436 6840 7 makes make VBZ 40436 6840 8 a a DT 40436 6840 9 man man NN 40436 6840 10 an an DT 40436 6840 11 able able JJ 40436 6840 12 speaker speaker NN 40436 6840 13 about about IN 40436 6840 14 harping harp VBG 40436 6840 15 , , , 40436 6840 16 at at IN 40436 6840 17 the the DT 40436 6840 18 same same JJ 40436 6840 19 time time NN 40436 6840 20 that that WDT 40436 6840 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6840 22 teaches teach VBZ 40436 6840 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6840 24 harping harp VBG 40436 6840 25 . . . 40436 6841 1 About about IN 40436 6841 2 _ _ NNP 40436 6841 3 what what WP 40436 6841 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6841 5 is be VBZ 40436 6841 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6841 7 that that WDT 40436 6841 8 the the DT 40436 6841 9 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 6841 10 forms form NNS 40436 6841 11 able able JJ 40436 6841 12 speakers speaker NNS 40436 6841 13 : : : 40436 6841 14 of of RB 40436 6841 15 course course NN 40436 6841 16 about about IN 40436 6841 17 that that DT 40436 6841 18 which which WDT 40436 6841 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6841 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6841 21 knows know VBZ 40436 6841 22 ? ? . 40436 6842 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6842 2 9 9 CD 40436 6842 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6842 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6842 5 Hipp._--Probably Hipp._--Probably NNP 40436 6842 6 . . . 40436 6843 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6843 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 6843 3 then then RB 40436 6843 4 is be VBZ 40436 6843 5 that that DT 40436 6843 6 , , , 40436 6843 7 about about IN 40436 6843 8 which which WDT 40436 6843 9 the the DT 40436 6843 10 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6843 11 is be VBZ 40436 6843 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6843 13 cognizant cognizant JJ 40436 6843 14 , , , 40436 6843 15 and and CC 40436 6843 16 makes make VBZ 40436 6843 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6843 18 pupil pupil NN 40436 6843 19 cognizant cognizant JJ 40436 6843 20 ? ? . 40436 6844 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6844 2 Hipp._--By Hipp._--By NNP 40436 6844 3 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 6844 4 , , , 40436 6844 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6844 6 can can MD 40436 6844 7 not not RB 40436 6844 8 give give VB 40436 6844 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6844 10 any any DT 40436 6844 11 farther farther JJ 40436 6844 12 answer answer NN 40436 6844 13 . . . 40436 6845 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6845 2 10 10 CD 40436 6845 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6845 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6845 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6845 6 4 4 CD 40436 6845 7 : : : 40436 6845 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6845 9 , , , 40436 6845 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6845 11 , , , 40436 6845 12 p. p. NN 40436 6846 1 311 311 CD 40436 6846 2 . . . 40436 6846 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6847 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6847 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6847 3 5 5 CD 40436 6847 4 : : : 40436 6847 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6847 6 , , , 40436 6847 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6847 8 . . . 40436 6848 1 p. p. NN 40436 6848 2 312 312 CD 40436 6848 3 A. a. NN 40436 6849 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6849 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6849 3 : : : 40436 6849 4 su\ su\ NNP 40436 6849 5 de/ de/ NNP 40436 6849 6 , , , 40436 6849 7 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 6849 8 d d NNP 40436 6849 9 ' ' POS 40436 6849 10 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 6849 11 , , , 40436 6849 12 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 6849 13 theô theô NNS 40436 6849 14 = = SYM 40436 6849 15 n n NN 40436 6849 16 , , , 40436 6849 17 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 6849 18 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 6849 19 ai)schu ai)schu NNP 40436 6849 20 / / SYM 40436 6849 21 noio noio NNP 40436 6849 22 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 6849 23 tou\s tou\s JJ 40436 6849 24 E(/llênas e(/llêna NNS 40436 6849 25 sauto\n sauto\n ADD 40436 6849 26 sophistê\n sophistê\n NNP 40436 6849 27 pare pare NNP 40436 6849 28 / / SYM 40436 6849 29 chôn chôn NN 40436 6849 30 ? ? . 40436 6850 1 Nê\ Nê\ NNP 40436 6850 2 to\n to\n NNP 40436 6850 3 Di/ Di/ NNP 40436 6850 4 ' ' POS 40436 6850 5 , , , 40436 6850 6 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 6850 7 Sô Sô NNP 40436 6850 8 / / SYM 40436 6850 9 krates krate NNS 40436 6850 10 , , , 40436 6850 11 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 6850 12 ge ge NNP 40436 6850 13 a)\ a)\ NNP 40436 6850 14 dianoou dianoou NNP 40436 6850 15 = = SYM 40436 6850 16 mai mai FW 40436 6850 17 chrê\ chrê\ NNP 40436 6850 18 le le NNP 40436 6850 19 / / SYM 40436 6850 20 gein gein NNP 40436 6850 21 . . . 40436 6850 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6851 1 Ast Ast NNP 40436 6851 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6851 3 Platon Platon NNP 40436 6851 4 's 's POS 40436 6851 5 Leben Leben NNP 40436 6851 6 , , , 40436 6851 7 p. p. NN 40436 6851 8 78 78 CD 40436 6851 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6851 10 and and CC 40436 6851 11 other other JJ 40436 6851 12 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6851 13 critics critic NNS 40436 6851 14 treat treat VBP 40436 6851 15 this this DT 40436 6851 16 _ _ NNP 40436 6851 17 Sophistomanie Sophistomanie NNP 40436 6851 18 _ _ NNP 40436 6851 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6851 20 as as IN 40436 6851 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6851 22 call call VBP 40436 6851 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6851 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6851 25 of of IN 40436 6851 26 an an DT 40436 6851 27 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 6851 28 youth youth NN 40436 6851 29 as as IN 40436 6851 30 something something NN 40436 6851 31 ludicrous ludicrous JJ 40436 6851 32 and and CC 40436 6851 33 contemptible contemptible JJ 40436 6851 34 : : : 40436 6851 35 all all PDT 40436 6851 36 the the DT 40436 6851 37 more more RBR 40436 6851 38 ludicrous ludicrous JJ 40436 6851 39 because because IN 40436 6851 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6851 41 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6851 42 say say VBP 40436 6851 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6851 44 none none NN 40436 6851 45 of of IN 40436 6851 46 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6851 47 goes go VBZ 40436 6851 48 to to TO 40436 6851 49 qualify qualify VB 40436 6851 50 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6851 51 for for IN 40436 6851 52 becoming become VBG 40436 6851 53 a a DT 40436 6851 54 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6851 55 , , , 40436 6851 56 but but CC 40436 6851 57 would would MD 40436 6851 58 even even RB 40436 6851 59 be be VB 40436 6851 60 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 6851 61 of of IN 40436 6851 62 the the DT 40436 6851 63 title title NN 40436 6851 64 . . . 40436 6852 1 Yet yet CC 40436 6852 2 if if IN 40436 6852 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6852 4 suppose suppose VBP 40436 6852 5 the the DT 40436 6852 6 same same JJ 40436 6852 7 question question NN 40436 6852 8 addressed address VBD 40436 6852 9 to to IN 40436 6852 10 a a DT 40436 6852 11 young young JJ 40436 6852 12 Englishman Englishman NNP 40436 6852 13 of of IN 40436 6852 14 rank rank NN 40436 6852 15 and and CC 40436 6852 16 fortune fortune NN 40436 6852 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6852 18 as as IN 40436 6852 19 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNP 40436 6852 20 was be VBD 40436 6852 21 at at IN 40436 6852 22 Athens Athens NNP 40436 6852 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6852 24 , , , 40436 6852 25 " " `` 40436 6852 26 Why why WRB 40436 6852 27 do do VBP 40436 6852 28 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6852 29 put put VB 40436 6852 30 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6852 31 under under IN 40436 6852 32 the the DT 40436 6852 33 teaching teaching NN 40436 6852 34 of of IN 40436 6852 35 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 6852 36 ---- ---- NNP 40436 6852 37 at at IN 40436 6852 38 Eton Eton NNP 40436 6852 39 or or CC 40436 6852 40 Professor Professor NNP 40436 6852 41 ---- ---- NFP 40436 6852 42 at at IN 40436 6852 43 Oxford Oxford NNP 40436 6852 44 ? ? . 40436 6853 1 Do do VBP 40436 6853 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6853 3 intend intend VB 40436 6853 4 to to TO 40436 6853 5 qualify qualify VB 40436 6853 6 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6853 7 for for IN 40436 6853 8 becoming become VBG 40436 6853 9 a a DT 40436 6853 10 schoolmaster schoolmaster NN 40436 6853 11 or or CC 40436 6853 12 a a DT 40436 6853 13 professor professor NN 40436 6853 14 ? ? . 40436 6853 15 " " '' 40436 6854 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6854 2 will will MD 40436 6854 3 laugh laugh VB 40436 6854 4 at at IN 40436 6854 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6854 6 for for IN 40436 6854 7 the the DT 40436 6854 8 question question NN 40436 6854 9 ; ; : 40436 6854 10 if if IN 40436 6854 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6854 12 answers answer VBZ 40436 6854 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6854 14 seriously seriously RB 40436 6854 15 , , , 40436 6854 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6854 17 will will MD 40436 6854 18 probably probably RB 40436 6854 19 answer answer VB 40436 6854 20 as as IN 40436 6854 21 Hippokrates hippokrate NNS 40436 6854 22 does do VBZ 40436 6854 23 . . . 40436 6855 1 But but CC 40436 6855 2 there there EX 40436 6855 3 is be VBZ 40436 6855 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 6855 5 at at RB 40436 6855 6 all all RB 40436 6855 7 in in IN 40436 6855 8 the the DT 40436 6855 9 question question NN 40436 6855 10 to to TO 40436 6855 11 imply imply VB 40436 6855 12 that that IN 40436 6855 13 the the DT 40436 6855 14 schoolmaster schoolmaster NN 40436 6855 15 or or CC 40436 6855 16 the the DT 40436 6855 17 professor professor NN 40436 6855 18 is be VBZ 40436 6855 19 a a DT 40436 6855 20 worthless worthless JJ 40436 6855 21 pretender pretender NN 40436 6855 22 -- -- : 40436 6855 23 or or CC 40436 6855 24 the the DT 40436 6855 25 youth youth NN 40436 6855 26 foolish foolish JJ 40436 6855 27 , , , 40436 6855 28 for for IN 40436 6855 29 being be VBG 40436 6855 30 anxious anxious JJ 40436 6855 31 to to TO 40436 6855 32 obtain obtain VB 40436 6855 33 instruction instruction NN 40436 6855 34 from from IN 40436 6855 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6855 36 ; ; : 40436 6855 37 which which WDT 40436 6855 38 is be VBZ 40436 6855 39 the the DT 40436 6855 40 inference inference NN 40436 6855 41 that that IN 40436 6855 42 Ast Ast NNP 40436 6855 43 and and CC 40436 6855 44 other other JJ 40436 6855 45 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6855 46 critics critic NNS 40436 6855 47 desire desire VBP 40436 6855 48 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6855 49 to to TO 40436 6855 50 draw draw VB 40436 6855 51 about about IN 40436 6855 52 the the DT 40436 6855 53 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 6855 54 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6855 55 . . . 40436 6855 56 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6856 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6856 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6856 3 6 6 CD 40436 6856 4 : : : 40436 6856 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6856 6 , , , 40436 6856 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6856 8 . . . 40436 6857 1 p. p. NN 40436 6857 2 312 312 CD 40436 6857 3 C. C. NNP 40436 6857 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6857 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6857 6 : : : 40436 6857 7 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 6857 8 , , , 40436 6857 9 ti ti NNP 40436 6857 10 de/ de/ NNP 40436 6857 11 pote pote NNP 40436 6857 12 o o FW 40436 6857 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6857 14 sophistê sophistê NNP 40436 6857 15 / / SYM 40436 6857 16 s s NNP 40436 6857 17 e)sti e)sti NNS 40436 6857 18 , , , 40436 6857 19 thauma thauma NNP 40436 6857 20 / / SYM 40436 6857 21 zoim zoim NNP 40436 6857 22 ' ' POS 40436 6857 23 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 6857 24 ei ei NNP 40436 6857 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6857 26 oi)=stha oi)=stha -RRB- 40436 6857 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6857 28 , , , 40436 6857 29 & & CC 40436 6857 30 c. c. NNP 40436 6857 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6857 32 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6857 33 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6857 34 7 7 CD 40436 6857 35 : : : 40436 6857 36 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6857 37 , , , 40436 6857 38 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6857 39 . . . 40436 6858 1 p. p. NN 40436 6858 2 312 312 CD 40436 6858 3 C. C. NNP 40436 6858 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6858 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6858 6 : : : 40436 6858 7 ô(/s ô(/s ADD 40436 6858 8 per per IN 40436 6858 9 tou)/noma tou)/noma NNP 40436 6858 10 le le NNP 40436 6858 11 / / SYM 40436 6858 12 gei gei NN 40436 6858 13 , , , 40436 6858 14 to\n to\n NNP 40436 6858 15 tô tô NNP 40436 6858 16 = = SYM 40436 6858 17 n n NNP 40436 6858 18 sophô sophô NNP 40436 6858 19 = = SYM 40436 6858 20 n n CC 40436 6858 21 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6858 22 / / SYM 40436 6858 23 mona mona NN 40436 6858 24 . . . 40436 6858 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6859 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6859 2 Quasi Quasi NNP 40436 6859 3 sophistes sophiste NNS 40436 6859 4 sit--[Greek sit--[greek NN 40436 6859 5 : : : 40436 6859 6 o o NN 40436 6859 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6859 8 tô tô NNP 40436 6859 9 = = SYM 40436 6859 10 n n NNP 40436 6859 11 sophô sophô NNP 40436 6859 12 = = SYM 40436 6859 13 n n NNP 40436 6859 14 i)/stês i)/stês NNP 40436 6859 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6859 16 , , , 40436 6859 17 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 6859 18 . . . 40436 6859 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6860 1 If if IN 40436 6860 2 this this DT 40436 6860 3 supposition supposition NN 40436 6860 4 of of IN 40436 6860 5 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 6860 6 be be VB 40436 6860 7 just just RB 40436 6860 8 , , , 40436 6860 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6860 10 may may MD 40436 6860 11 see see VB 40436 6860 12 in in IN 40436 6860 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6860 14 an an DT 40436 6860 15 illustration illustration NN 40436 6860 16 of of IN 40436 6860 17 the the DT 40436 6860 18 etymological etymological JJ 40436 6860 19 views view NNS 40436 6860 20 of of IN 40436 6860 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6860 22 , , , 40436 6860 23 which which WDT 40436 6860 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6860 25 shall shall MD 40436 6860 26 notice notice VB 40436 6860 27 when when WRB 40436 6860 28 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6860 29 come come VBP 40436 6860 30 to to IN 40436 6860 31 the the DT 40436 6860 32 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 6860 33 . . . 40436 6860 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6861 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6861 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6861 3 8 8 CD 40436 6861 4 : : : 40436 6861 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6861 6 , , , 40436 6861 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6861 8 . . . 40436 6862 1 p. p. NN 40436 6862 2 312 312 CD 40436 6862 3 D. D. NNP 40436 6862 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6862 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6862 6 : : : 40436 6862 7 poi poi NNP 40436 6862 8 / / , 40436 6862 9 as as IN 40436 6862 10 e)rgasi e)rgasi NNS 40436 6862 11 / / SYM 40436 6862 12 as as IN 40436 6862 13 e)pista e)pista NNP 40436 6862 14 / / SYM 40436 6862 15 tês tês NN 40436 6862 16 ? ? . 40436 6863 1 e)pista e)pista , 40436 6863 2 / / SYM 40436 6863 3 tên tên NNP 40436 6863 4 tou= tou= NNP 40436 6863 5 poiê poiê NNP 40436 6863 6 = = SYM 40436 6863 7 sai sai NNP 40436 6863 8 deino\n deino\n ADD 40436 6863 9 le le NNP 40436 6863 10 / / SYM 40436 6863 11 gein gein NNP 40436 6863 12 . . . 40436 6863 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6863 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6864 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6864 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6864 3 9 9 CD 40436 6864 4 : : : 40436 6864 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6864 6 , , , 40436 6864 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6864 8 . . . 40436 6865 1 p. p. NN 40436 6865 2 312 312 CD 40436 6865 3 D D NNP 40436 6865 4 - - HYPH 40436 6865 5 E. e. NN 40436 6865 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6865 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6865 8 : : : 40436 6865 9 e)rôtê e)rôtê NNP 40436 6865 10 / / SYM 40436 6865 11 seôs seôs JJ 40436 6865 12 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6865 13 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 6865 14 ê ê NN 40436 6865 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6865 16 a)po a)po NNS 40436 6865 17 / / SYM 40436 6865 18 krisis krisis NN 40436 6865 19 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 6865 20 = = SYM 40436 6865 21 n n CC 40436 6865 22 dei dei NNP 40436 6865 23 = = SYM 40436 6865 24 tai tai NNP 40436 6865 25 , , , 40436 6865 26 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6865 27 o(/tou o(/tou NNP 40436 6865 28 o o NN 40436 6865 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6865 30 sophistê\s sophistê\s CD 40436 6865 31 deino\n deino\n ADD 40436 6865 32 poiei= poiei= NNP 40436 6865 33 le le NNP 40436 6865 34 / / SYM 40436 6865 35 gein gein NNP 40436 6865 36 ; ; : 40436 6865 37 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 6865 38 o o NN 40436 6865 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6865 40 kitharistê\s kitharistê\s NNP 40436 6865 41 deino\n deino\n ADD 40436 6865 42 dê dê NNP 40436 6865 43 / / SYM 40436 6865 44 pou pou CC 40436 6865 45 poiei= poiei= NNP 40436 6865 46 le le NNP 40436 6865 47 / / SYM 40436 6865 48 gein gein NNP 40436 6865 49 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6865 50 ou(=per ou(=per NNP 40436 6865 51 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6865 52 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6865 53 / / SYM 40436 6865 54 mona mona NNP 40436 6865 55 , , , 40436 6865 56 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6865 57 kithari kithari NNP 40436 6865 58 / / SYM 40436 6865 59 seôs seôs NNP 40436 6865 60 . . . 40436 6865 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6865 62 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6866 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6866 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6866 3 10 10 CD 40436 6866 4 : : : 40436 6866 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6866 6 , , , 40436 6866 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6866 8 . . . 40436 6867 1 p. p. NN 40436 6867 2 312 312 CD 40436 6867 3 E. E. NNP 40436 6867 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6867 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6867 6 Side side NN 40436 6867 7 - - HYPH 40436 6867 8 note note NN 40436 6867 9 : : : 40436 6867 10 Danger danger NN 40436 6867 11 of of IN 40436 6867 12 going go VBG 40436 6867 13 to to TO 40436 6867 14 imbibe imbibe VB 40436 6867 15 the the DT 40436 6867 16 instruction instruction NN 40436 6867 17 of of IN 40436 6867 18 a a DT 40436 6867 19 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6867 20 without without IN 40436 6867 21 knowing know VBG 40436 6867 22 beforehand beforehand RB 40436 6867 23 what what WP 40436 6867 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6867 25 is be VBZ 40436 6867 26 about about JJ 40436 6867 27 to to TO 40436 6867 28 teach teach VB 40436 6867 29 . . . 40436 6867 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6868 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6868 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 6868 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6868 4 see see VBP 40436 6868 5 then then RB 40436 6868 6 to to IN 40436 6868 7 what what WP 40436 6868 8 danger danger NN 40436 6868 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6868 10 are be VBP 40436 6868 11 going go VBG 40436 6868 12 to to TO 40436 6868 13 submit submit VB 40436 6868 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6868 15 mind mind NN 40436 6868 16 ? ? . 40436 6869 1 If if IN 40436 6869 2 the the DT 40436 6869 3 question question NN 40436 6869 4 were be VBD 40436 6869 5 about about IN 40436 6869 6 going go VBG 40436 6869 7 to to IN 40436 6869 8 trusting trust VBG 40436 6869 9 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6869 10 body body NN 40436 6869 11 to to IN 40436 6869 12 any any DT 40436 6869 13 one one CD 40436 6869 14 , , , 40436 6869 15 with with IN 40436 6869 16 the the DT 40436 6869 17 risk risk NN 40436 6869 18 whether whether IN 40436 6869 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6869 20 should should MD 40436 6869 21 become become VB 40436 6869 22 sound sound JJ 40436 6869 23 or or CC 40436 6869 24 unsound unsound JJ 40436 6869 25 , , , 40436 6869 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6869 27 would would MD 40436 6869 28 have have VB 40436 6869 29 thought think VBN 40436 6869 30 long long RB 40436 6869 31 , , , 40436 6869 32 and and CC 40436 6869 33 taken take VBN 40436 6869 34 much much JJ 40436 6869 35 advice advice NN 40436 6869 36 , , , 40436 6869 37 before before IN 40436 6869 38 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6869 39 decided decide VBD 40436 6869 40 . . . 40436 6870 1 But but CC 40436 6870 2 now now RB 40436 6870 3 , , , 40436 6870 4 when when WRB 40436 6870 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6870 6 is be VBZ 40436 6870 7 about about IN 40436 6870 8 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6870 9 mind mind NN 40436 6870 10 , , , 40436 6870 11 which which WDT 40436 6870 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6870 13 value value VBP 40436 6870 14 more more JJR 40436 6870 15 than than IN 40436 6870 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6870 17 body body NN 40436 6870 18 , , , 40436 6870 19 and and CC 40436 6870 20 upon upon IN 40436 6870 21 the the DT 40436 6870 22 good good JJ 40436 6870 23 or or CC 40436 6870 24 evil evil NN 40436 6870 25 of of IN 40436 6870 26 which which WDT 40436 6870 27 all all DT 40436 6870 28 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6870 29 affairs affair NNS 40436 6870 30 turn[11]--you turn[11]--you PRP 40436 6870 31 are be VBP 40436 6870 32 hastening hasten VBG 40436 6870 33 without without IN 40436 6870 34 reflection reflection NN 40436 6870 35 and and CC 40436 6870 36 without without IN 40436 6870 37 advice advice NN 40436 6870 38 , , , 40436 6870 39 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6870 40 are be VBP 40436 6870 41 ready ready JJ 40436 6870 42 to to TO 40436 6870 43 pay pay VB 40436 6870 44 all all PDT 40436 6870 45 the the DT 40436 6870 46 money money NN 40436 6870 47 that that WDT 40436 6870 48 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6870 49 possess possess VBP 40436 6870 50 or or CC 40436 6870 51 can can MD 40436 6870 52 obtain obtain VB 40436 6870 53 , , , 40436 6870 54 with with IN 40436 6870 55 a a DT 40436 6870 56 firm firm JJ 40436 6870 57 resolution resolution NN 40436 6870 58 already already RB 40436 6870 59 taken take VBN 40436 6870 60 to to TO 40436 6870 61 put put VB 40436 6870 62 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6870 63 at at RB 40436 6870 64 all all DT 40436 6870 65 hazard hazard NN 40436 6870 66 under under IN 40436 6870 67 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6870 68 : : : 40436 6870 69 whom whom WP 40436 6870 70 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6870 71 do do VBP 40436 6870 72 not not RB 40436 6870 73 know know VB 40436 6870 74 -- -- : 40436 6870 75 with with IN 40436 6870 76 whom whom WP 40436 6870 77 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6870 78 have have VBP 40436 6870 79 never never RB 40436 6870 80 once once RB 40436 6870 81 talked talk VBN 40436 6870 82 -- -- : 40436 6870 83 whom whom WP 40436 6870 84 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6870 85 call call VBP 40436 6870 86 a a DT 40436 6870 87 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6870 88 , , , 40436 6870 89 without without IN 40436 6870 90 knowing know VBG 40436 6870 91 what what WP 40436 6870 92 a a DT 40436 6870 93 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6870 94 is be VBZ 40436 6870 95 ? ? . 40436 6871 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6871 2 Hipp._--I Hipp._--I NNP 40436 6871 3 must must MD 40436 6871 4 admit admit VB 40436 6871 5 the the DT 40436 6871 6 case case NN 40436 6871 7 to to TO 40436 6871 8 be be VB 40436 6871 9 as as IN 40436 6871 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6871 11 say say VBP 40436 6871 12 . . . 40436 6872 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6872 2 12 12 CD 40436 6872 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6872 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6872 5 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 6872 6 the the DT 40436 6872 7 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6872 8 is be VBZ 40436 6872 9 a a DT 40436 6872 10 man man NN 40436 6872 11 who who WP 40436 6872 12 brings bring VBZ 40436 6872 13 for for IN 40436 6872 14 sale sale NN 40436 6872 15 those those DT 40436 6872 16 transportable transportable JJ 40436 6872 17 commodities commodity NNS 40436 6872 18 , , , 40436 6872 19 instruction instruction NN 40436 6872 20 or or CC 40436 6872 21 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6872 22 , , , 40436 6872 23 which which WDT 40436 6872 24 form form VBP 40436 6872 25 the the DT 40436 6872 26 nourishment nourishment NN 40436 6872 27 of of IN 40436 6872 28 the the DT 40436 6872 29 mind mind NN 40436 6872 30 . . . 40436 6873 1 Now now RB 40436 6873 2 the the DT 40436 6873 3 traders trader NNS 40436 6873 4 in in IN 40436 6873 5 food food NN 40436 6873 6 for for IN 40436 6873 7 the the DT 40436 6873 8 body body NN 40436 6873 9 praise praise NN 40436 6873 10 indiscriminately indiscriminately RB 40436 6873 11 all all DT 40436 6873 12 that that WDT 40436 6873 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6873 14 have have VBP 40436 6873 15 to to TO 40436 6873 16 sell sell VB 40436 6873 17 , , , 40436 6873 18 though though IN 40436 6873 19 neither neither CC 40436 6873 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6873 21 nor nor CC 40436 6873 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6873 23 purchasers purchaser NNS 40436 6873 24 know know VBP 40436 6873 25 whether whether IN 40436 6873 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6873 27 is be VBZ 40436 6873 28 good good JJ 40436 6873 29 for for IN 40436 6873 30 the the DT 40436 6873 31 body body NN 40436 6873 32 ; ; : 40436 6873 33 unless unless IN 40436 6873 34 by by IN 40436 6873 35 chance chance NN 40436 6873 36 any any DT 40436 6873 37 one one CD 40436 6873 38 of of IN 40436 6873 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6873 40 be be VBP 40436 6873 41 a a DT 40436 6873 42 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 6873 43 trainer trainer NN 40436 6873 44 or or CC 40436 6873 45 a a DT 40436 6873 46 physician physician NN 40436 6873 47 . . . 40436 6874 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6874 2 13 13 CD 40436 6874 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6874 4 So so CC 40436 6874 5 , , , 40436 6874 6 too too RB 40436 6874 7 , , , 40436 6874 8 these these DT 40436 6874 9 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6874 10 , , , 40436 6874 11 who who WP 40436 6874 12 carry carry VBP 40436 6874 13 about about IN 40436 6874 14 food food NN 40436 6874 15 for for IN 40436 6874 16 the the DT 40436 6874 17 mind mind NN 40436 6874 18 , , , 40436 6874 19 praise praise VBP 40436 6874 20 all all DT 40436 6874 21 that that WDT 40436 6874 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6874 23 have have VBP 40436 6874 24 to to TO 40436 6874 25 sell sell VB 40436 6874 26 : : : 40436 6874 27 but but CC 40436 6874 28 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 6874 29 some some DT 40436 6874 30 of of IN 40436 6874 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6874 32 are be VBP 40436 6874 33 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 6874 34 , , , 40436 6874 35 and and CC 40436 6874 36 assuredly assuredly RB 40436 6874 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6874 38 purchasers purchaser NNS 40436 6874 39 are be VBP 40436 6874 40 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 6874 41 , , , 40436 6874 42 whether whether IN 40436 6874 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6874 44 be be VB 40436 6874 45 good good JJ 40436 6874 46 or or CC 40436 6874 47 bad bad JJ 40436 6874 48 for for IN 40436 6874 49 the the DT 40436 6874 50 mind mind NN 40436 6874 51 : : : 40436 6874 52 unless unless IN 40436 6874 53 by by IN 40436 6874 54 accident accident NN 40436 6874 55 any any DT 40436 6874 56 one one NN 40436 6874 57 possess possess JJ 40436 6874 58 medical medical JJ 40436 6874 59 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6874 60 about about IN 40436 6874 61 the the DT 40436 6874 62 mind mind NN 40436 6874 63 . . . 40436 6875 1 Now now RB 40436 6875 2 if if IN 40436 6875 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6875 4 , , , 40436 6875 5 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6875 6 , , , 40436 6875 7 happen happen VB 40436 6875 8 to to TO 40436 6875 9 possess possess VB 40436 6875 10 such such JJ 40436 6875 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6875 12 of of IN 40436 6875 13 what what WP 40436 6875 14 is be VBZ 40436 6875 15 good good JJ 40436 6875 16 or or CC 40436 6875 17 bad bad JJ 40436 6875 18 for for IN 40436 6875 19 the the DT 40436 6875 20 mind mind NN 40436 6875 21 , , , 40436 6875 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6875 23 may may MD 40436 6875 24 safely safely RB 40436 6875 25 purchase purchase VB 40436 6875 26 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 6875 27 from from IN 40436 6875 28 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6875 29 or or CC 40436 6875 30 from from IN 40436 6875 31 any any DT 40436 6875 32 one one CD 40436 6875 33 else:[14 else:[14 , 40436 6875 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6875 35 but but CC 40436 6875 36 if if IN 40436 6875 37 not not RB 40436 6875 38 , , , 40436 6875 39 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6875 40 are be VBP 40436 6875 41 hazarding hazard VBG 40436 6875 42 and and CC 40436 6875 43 putting put VBG 40436 6875 44 at at IN 40436 6875 45 stake stake NN 40436 6875 46 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6875 47 dearest dear JJS 40436 6875 48 interests interest NNS 40436 6875 49 . . . 40436 6876 1 The the DT 40436 6876 2 purchase purchase NN 40436 6876 3 of of IN 40436 6876 4 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 6876 5 is be VBZ 40436 6876 6 far far RB 40436 6876 7 more more RBR 40436 6876 8 dangerous dangerous JJ 40436 6876 9 than than IN 40436 6876 10 that that DT 40436 6876 11 of of IN 40436 6876 12 eatables eatable NNS 40436 6876 13 or or CC 40436 6876 14 drinkables drinkable NNS 40436 6876 15 . . . 40436 6877 1 As as IN 40436 6877 2 to to IN 40436 6877 3 these these DT 40436 6877 4 latter latter JJ 40436 6877 5 , , , 40436 6877 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6877 7 may may MD 40436 6877 8 carry carry VB 40436 6877 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6877 10 away away RB 40436 6877 11 with with IN 40436 6877 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6877 13 in in IN 40436 6877 14 separate separate JJ 40436 6877 15 vessels vessel NNS 40436 6877 16 , , , 40436 6877 17 and and CC 40436 6877 18 before before IN 40436 6877 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6877 20 take take VBP 40436 6877 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6877 22 into into IN 40436 6877 23 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6877 24 body body NN 40436 6877 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6877 26 may may MD 40436 6877 27 invoke invoke VB 40436 6877 28 the the DT 40436 6877 29 _ _ NNP 40436 6877 30 Expert Expert NNP 40436 6877 31 _ _ NNP 40436 6877 32 , , , 40436 6877 33 to to TO 40436 6877 34 tell tell VB 40436 6877 35 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6877 36 what what WP 40436 6877 37 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6877 38 may may MD 40436 6877 39 safely safely RB 40436 6877 40 eat eat VB 40436 6877 41 and and CC 40436 6877 42 drink drink VB 40436 6877 43 , , , 40436 6877 44 and and CC 40436 6877 45 when when WRB 40436 6877 46 , , , 40436 6877 47 and and CC 40436 6877 48 how how WRB 40436 6877 49 much much JJ 40436 6877 50 . . . 40436 6878 1 But but CC 40436 6878 2 this this DT 40436 6878 3 can can MD 40436 6878 4 not not RB 40436 6878 5 be be VB 40436 6878 6 done do VBN 40436 6878 7 with with IN 40436 6878 8 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 6878 9 . . . 40436 6879 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 6879 2 can can MD 40436 6879 3 not not RB 40436 6879 4 carry carry VB 40436 6879 5 away away RP 40436 6879 6 _ _ IN 40436 6879 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6879 8 _ _ NNP 40436 6879 9 in in IN 40436 6879 10 a a DT 40436 6879 11 separate separate JJ 40436 6879 12 vessel vessel NN 40436 6879 13 to to TO 40436 6879 14 be be VB 40436 6879 15 tested test VBN 40436 6879 16 ; ; : 40436 6879 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6879 18 learn learn VBP 40436 6879 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6879 20 and and CC 40436 6879 21 take take VB 40436 6879 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6879 23 into into IN 40436 6879 24 the the DT 40436 6879 25 mind mind NN 40436 6879 26 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 6879 27 ; ; : 40436 6879 28 so so IN 40436 6879 29 that that IN 40436 6879 30 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6879 31 go go VBP 40436 6879 32 away away RB 40436 6879 33 , , , 40436 6879 34 after after IN 40436 6879 35 having have VBG 40436 6879 36 paid pay VBN 40436 6879 37 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6879 38 money money NN 40436 6879 39 , , , 40436 6879 40 actually actually RB 40436 6879 41 damaged damaged JJ 40436 6879 42 or or CC 40436 6879 43 actually actually RB 40436 6879 44 benefited benefit VBN 40436 6879 45 , , , 40436 6879 46 as as IN 40436 6879 47 the the DT 40436 6879 48 case case NN 40436 6879 49 may may MD 40436 6879 50 be be VB 40436 6879 51 . . . 40436 6880 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6880 2 15 15 CD 40436 6880 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6880 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6880 5 will will MD 40436 6880 6 consider consider VB 40436 6880 7 these these DT 40436 6880 8 matters matter NNS 40436 6880 9 in in IN 40436 6880 10 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 6880 11 with with IN 40436 6880 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6880 13 elders elder NNS 40436 6880 14 . . . 40436 6881 1 But but CC 40436 6881 2 first first RB 40436 6881 3 let let VB 40436 6881 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6881 5 go go VB 40436 6881 6 and and CC 40436 6881 7 talk talk VB 40436 6881 8 with with IN 40436 6881 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6881 10 -- -- : 40436 6881 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6881 12 can can MD 40436 6881 13 consult consult VB 40436 6881 14 the the DT 40436 6881 15 others other NNS 40436 6881 16 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 6881 17 . . . 40436 6882 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6882 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6882 3 11 11 CD 40436 6882 4 : : : 40436 6882 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6882 6 , , , 40436 6882 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6882 8 . . . 40436 6883 1 p. p. NN 40436 6883 2 313 313 CD 40436 6883 3 A. a. NN 40436 6884 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6884 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6884 3 : : : 40436 6884 4 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 6884 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6884 6 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6884 7 plei plei NN 40436 6884 8 / / SYM 40436 6884 9 onos onos NN 40436 6884 10 tou= tou= NNP 40436 6884 11 sô sô NNP 40436 6884 12 / / SYM 40436 6884 13 matos matos NNP 40436 6884 14 ê(gei= ê(gei= NNP 40436 6884 15 , , , 40436 6884 16 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6884 17 psuchê\n psuchê\n NNP 40436 6884 18 , , , 40436 6884 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6884 20 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6884 21 ô)=| ô)=| NNP 40436 6884 22 pa pa NNP 40436 6884 23 / / SYM 40436 6884 24 nt nt NN 40436 6884 25 ' ' '' 40436 6884 26 e)sti\ e)sti\ RB 40436 6884 27 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 6884 28 sa\ sa\ JJ 40436 6884 29 ê)\ ê)\ ADD 40436 6884 30 eu)= eu)= NN 40436 6884 31 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 6884 32 kalô kalô NNP 40436 6884 33 = = SYM 40436 6884 34 s s NNP 40436 6884 35 pra pra NNP 40436 6884 36 / / SYM 40436 6884 37 ttein ttein NNP 40436 6884 38 , , , 40436 6884 39 chrêstou= chrêstou= VBD 40436 6884 40 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 6884 41 ponêrou= ponêrou= NN 40436 6884 42 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 6884 43 genome genome NNP 40436 6884 44 / / SYM 40436 6884 45 nou nou NN 40436 6884 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6884 47 , , , 40436 6884 48 & & CC 40436 6884 49 c. c. NNP 40436 6884 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6884 51 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6884 52 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6884 53 12 12 CD 40436 6884 54 : : : 40436 6884 55 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6884 56 , , , 40436 6884 57 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6884 58 . . . 40436 6885 1 p. p. NN 40436 6885 2 313 313 CD 40436 6885 3 C. C. NNP 40436 6885 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6885 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6885 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6885 7 13 13 CD 40436 6885 8 : : : 40436 6885 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6885 10 , , , 40436 6885 11 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6885 12 . . . 40436 6886 1 p. p. NN 40436 6886 2 313 313 CD 40436 6886 3 D. D. NNP 40436 6886 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6886 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6886 6 Footnote footnote NN 40436 6886 7 14 14 CD 40436 6886 8 : : : 40436 6886 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6886 10 , , , 40436 6886 11 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6886 12 . . . 40436 6887 1 p. p. NN 40436 6887 2 313 313 CD 40436 6887 3 E. E. NNP 40436 6887 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6887 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6887 6 : : : 40436 6887 7 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 6887 8 mê/ mê/ NNP 40436 6887 9 tis tis NNP 40436 6887 10 tu tu NNP 40436 6887 11 / / SYM 40436 6887 12 chê| chê| NN 40436 6887 13 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 6887 14 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6887 15 psuchê\n psuchê\n CD 40436 6887 16 au)= au)= JJ 40436 6887 17 i)atriko\s i)atriko\s XX 40436 6887 18 ô)/n ô)/n NNP 40436 6887 19 . . . 40436 6888 1 ei ei NNP 40436 6888 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6888 3 me\n me\n NNP 40436 6888 4 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 6888 5 su\ su\ NNP 40436 6888 6 tugcha tugcha NNP 40436 6888 7 / / SYM 40436 6888 8 neis neis NNP 40436 6888 9 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 6888 10 / / SYM 40436 6888 11 môn môn NNP 40436 6888 12 tou tou NNP 40436 6888 13 / / SYM 40436 6888 14 tôn tôn NNP 40436 6888 15 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 6888 16 chrêsto\n chrêsto\n ADD 40436 6888 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6888 18 ponêro ponêro NNP 40436 6888 19 / / SYM 40436 6888 20 n n NNP 40436 6888 21 , , , 40436 6888 22 a)sphale a)sphale , 40436 6888 23 / / SYM 40436 6888 24 s s NNP 40436 6888 25 soi soi NN 40436 6888 26 ô)nei ô)nei NNP 40436 6888 27 = = SYM 40436 6888 28 sthai sthai NNP 40436 6888 29 mathê mathê NNP 40436 6888 30 / / SYM 40436 6888 31 mata mata NNP 40436 6888 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6888 33 para\ para\ NNP 40436 6888 34 Prôtago Prôtago NNP 40436 6888 35 / / , 40436 6888 36 rou rou NNP 40436 6888 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6888 38 par par NNP 40436 6888 39 ' ' '' 40436 6888 40 a)/llou a)/llou NNP 40436 6888 41 o(tounou o(tounou NNP 40436 6888 42 = = SYM 40436 6888 43 n n XX 40436 6888 44 ; ; : 40436 6888 45 ei ei NNP 40436 6888 46 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6888 47 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6888 48 mê/ mê/ NN 40436 6888 49 , , , 40436 6888 50 o(/ra o(/ra NNP 40436 6888 51 , , , 40436 6888 52 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 6888 53 phi phi NNP 40436 6888 54 / / SYM 40436 6888 55 ltate ltate NN 40436 6888 56 , , , 40436 6888 57 mê\ mê\ VBP 40436 6888 58 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 6888 59 toi toi NNP 40436 6888 60 = = SYM 40436 6888 61 s s NNP 40436 6888 62 philta philta NNP 40436 6888 63 / / SYM 40436 6888 64 tois tois NNP 40436 6888 65 kubeu kubeu NNP 40436 6888 66 / / SYM 40436 6888 67 ê|s ê|s NNP 40436 6888 68 te te NNP 40436 6888 69 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6888 70 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 6888 71 / / SYM 40436 6888 72 ê|s ê|s NNP 40436 6888 73 . . . 40436 6888 74 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6888 75 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6889 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6889 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6889 3 15 15 CD 40436 6889 4 : : : 40436 6889 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6889 6 , , , 40436 6889 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6889 8 . . . 40436 6890 1 p. p. NN 40436 6890 2 314 314 CD 40436 6890 3 A. a. NN 40436 6891 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6891 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6891 3 : : : 40436 6891 4 siti siti NNP 40436 6891 5 / / SYM 40436 6891 6 a a DT 40436 6891 7 me\n me\n NNP 40436 6891 8 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 6891 9 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6891 10 pota\ pota\ -RRB- 40436 6891 11 pria pria NNP 40436 6891 12 / / SYM 40436 6891 13 menon menon NNP 40436 6891 14 e)/xestin e)/xestin NNP 40436 6891 15 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6891 16 a)/llois a)/llois NNP 40436 6891 17 a)ggei a)ggei NNP 40436 6891 18 / / SYM 40436 6891 19 ois ois NNP 40436 6891 20 a)pophe a)pophe NNP 40436 6891 21 / / SYM 40436 6891 22 rein rein NN 40436 6891 23 , , , 40436 6891 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6891 25 pri\n pri\n NNPS 40436 6891 26 de de NNP 40436 6891 27 / / SYM 40436 6891 28 xasthai xasthai NNP 40436 6891 29 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 6891 30 e)s e)s NNP 40436 6891 31 to\ to\ NN 40436 6891 32 sô sô NNP 40436 6891 33 = = SYM 40436 6891 34 ma ma NNP 40436 6891 35 pio pio NNP 40436 6891 36 / / SYM 40436 6891 37 nta nta NNP 40436 6891 38 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 6891 39 phago phago NNP 40436 6891 40 / / SYM 40436 6891 41 nta nta NNP 40436 6891 42 , , , 40436 6891 43 katathe katathe NNP 40436 6891 44 / / SYM 40436 6891 45 menon menon NNP 40436 6891 46 oi)/kade oi)/kade NNP 40436 6891 47 e)/xesti e)/xesti NNP 40436 6891 48 sumbouleu sumbouleu NNP 40436 6891 49 / / SYM 40436 6891 50 sasthai sasthai NNP 40436 6891 51 parakale parakale NNP 40436 6891 52 / / SYM 40436 6891 53 santa santa NNP 40436 6891 54 to\n to\n NNP 40436 6891 55 e)pai+/onta e)pai+/onta ADD 40436 6891 56 , , , 40436 6891 57 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 6891 58 , , , 40436 6891 59 ti ti NNP 40436 6891 60 te te NNP 40436 6891 61 e)deste e)deste NNP 40436 6891 62 / / SYM 40436 6891 63 on on IN 40436 6891 64 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 6891 65 pote pote NNP 40436 6891 66 / / SYM 40436 6891 67 on on IN 40436 6891 68 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6891 69 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 6891 70 , , , 40436 6891 71 ti ti NNP 40436 6891 72 mê/ mê/ NN 40436 6891 73 , , , 40436 6891 74 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6891 75 o(po o(po NNP 40436 6891 76 / / SYM 40436 6891 77 son son NN 40436 6891 78 , , , 40436 6891 79 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6891 80 o(po o(po NNP 40436 6891 81 / / SYM 40436 6891 82 te te NNP 40436 6891 83 ; ; : 40436 6891 84 . . . 40436 6892 1 . . . 40436 6893 1 . . . 40436 6894 1 . . . 40436 6895 1 mathê mathê NNP 40436 6895 2 / / SYM 40436 6895 3 mata mata NNP 40436 6895 4 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6895 5 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 6895 6 e)/stin e)/stin : 40436 6895 7 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6895 8 a)/llô| a)/llô| NNP 40436 6895 9 a)ggei a)ggei NNP 40436 6895 10 / / SYM 40436 6895 11 ô| ô| NNP 40436 6895 12 a)penegkei a)penegkei NNP 40436 6895 13 = = SYM 40436 6895 14 n n CD 40436 6895 15 , , , 40436 6895 16 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 6895 17 ' ' `` 40436 6895 18 a)na a)na NNS 40436 6895 19 / / SYM 40436 6895 20 gkê gkê NNP 40436 6895 21 katathe katathe NNP 40436 6895 22 / / SYM 40436 6895 23 nta nta NNP 40436 6895 24 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6895 25 timê\n timê\n NN 40436 6895 26 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6895 27 ma ma NNP 40436 6895 28 / / SYM 40436 6895 29 thêma thêma NNP 40436 6895 30 e)n e)n NNP 40436 6895 31 au)tê=| au)tê=| NNP 40436 6895 32 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 6895 33 psuchê=| psuchê=| NNP 40436 6895 34 labo labo NNP 40436 6895 35 / / SYM 40436 6895 36 nta nta NNP 40436 6895 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 6895 38 matho matho NNP 40436 6895 39 / / SYM 40436 6895 40 nta nta NNP 40436 6895 41 a)pie a)pie NNP 40436 6895 42 / / SYM 40436 6895 43 nai nai NNP 40436 6895 44 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 6895 45 beblamme beblamme NNS 40436 6895 46 / / SYM 40436 6895 47 non non AFX 40436 6895 48 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 6895 49 ô)phelême ô)phelême NNP 40436 6895 50 / / SYM 40436 6895 51 non non AFX 40436 6895 52 . . . 40436 6895 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6895 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6896 1 * * NFP 40436 6896 2 * * NFP 40436 6896 3 * * NFP 40436 6896 4 * * NFP 40436 6896 5 * * NFP 40436 6896 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6896 7 Side side NN 40436 6896 8 - - HYPH 40436 6896 9 note note NN 40436 6896 10 : : : 40436 6896 11 Remarks remark NNS 40436 6896 12 on on IN 40436 6896 13 the the DT 40436 6896 14 Introduction introduction NN 40436 6896 15 . . . 40436 6897 1 False false JJ 40436 6897 2 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 6897 3 of of IN 40436 6897 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6897 5 brought bring VBN 40436 6897 6 to to IN 40436 6897 7 light light NN 40436 6897 8 . . . 40436 6897 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6898 1 Such such JJ 40436 6898 2 is be VBZ 40436 6898 3 the the DT 40436 6898 4 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 6898 5 conversation conversation NN 40436 6898 6 of of IN 40436 6898 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6898 8 with with IN 40436 6898 9 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6898 10 , , , 40436 6898 11 before before IN 40436 6898 12 the the DT 40436 6898 13 interview interview NN 40436 6898 14 with with IN 40436 6898 15 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6898 16 . . . 40436 6899 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6899 2 have have VBP 40436 6899 3 given give VBN 40436 6899 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6899 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6899 6 like like IN 40436 6899 7 the the DT 40436 6899 8 introduction introduction NN 40436 6899 9 to to IN 40436 6899 10 the the DT 40436 6899 11 Lysis lysis NN 40436 6899 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6899 13 at at IN 40436 6899 14 considerable considerable JJ 40436 6899 15 length length NN 40436 6899 16 , , , 40436 6899 17 because because IN 40436 6899 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6899 19 is be VBZ 40436 6899 20 a a DT 40436 6899 21 very very RB 40436 6899 22 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 6899 23 specimen speciman NNS 40436 6899 24 of of IN 40436 6899 25 the the DT 40436 6899 26 Sokratico Sokratico NNP 40436 6899 27 - - HYPH 40436 6899 28 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 6899 29 point point NN 40436 6899 30 of of IN 40436 6899 31 view view NN 40436 6899 32 . . . 40436 6900 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6900 2 brings bring VBZ 40436 6900 3 to to TO 40436 6900 4 light light VB 40436 6900 5 that that DT 40436 6900 6 false false JJ 40436 6900 7 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 6900 8 of of IN 40436 6900 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 6900 10 , , , 40436 6900 11 under under IN 40436 6900 12 which which WDT 40436 6900 13 men man NNS 40436 6900 14 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 6900 15 act act VBP 40436 6900 16 , , , 40436 6900 17 especially especially RB 40436 6900 18 in in IN 40436 6900 19 what what WP 40436 6900 20 concerns concern VBZ 40436 6900 21 the the DT 40436 6900 22 mind mind NN 40436 6900 23 and and CC 40436 6900 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6900 25 treatment treatment NN 40436 6900 26 . . . 40436 6901 1 Common common JJ 40436 6901 2 fame fame NN 40436 6901 3 and and CC 40436 6901 4 celebrity celebrity NN 40436 6901 5 suffice suffice NN 40436 6901 6 to to TO 40436 6901 7 determine determine VB 40436 6901 8 the the DT 40436 6901 9 most most RBS 40436 6901 10 vehement vehement JJ 40436 6901 11 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 6901 12 towards towards IN 40436 6901 13 a a DT 40436 6901 14 lecturer lecturer NN 40436 6901 15 , , , 40436 6901 16 in in IN 40436 6901 17 one one NN 40436 6901 18 who who WP 40436 6901 19 has have VBZ 40436 6901 20 never never RB 40436 6901 21 stopped stop VBN 40436 6901 22 to to TO 40436 6901 23 reflect reflect VB 40436 6901 24 or or CC 40436 6901 25 enquire enquire VB 40436 6901 26 what what WP 40436 6901 27 the the DT 40436 6901 28 lecturer lecturer NN 40436 6901 29 does do VBZ 40436 6901 30 . . . 40436 6902 1 The the DT 40436 6902 2 pressure pressure NN 40436 6902 3 applied apply VBN 40436 6902 4 by by IN 40436 6902 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6902 6 in in IN 40436 6902 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6902 8 successive successive JJ 40436 6902 9 questions question NNS 40436 6902 10 , , , 40436 6902 11 to to TO 40436 6902 12 get get VB 40436 6902 13 beyond beyond IN 40436 6902 14 vague vague JJ 40436 6902 15 generalities generality NNS 40436 6902 16 into into IN 40436 6902 17 definite definite JJ 40436 6902 18 particulars particular NNS 40436 6902 19 -- -- : 40436 6902 20 the the DT 40436 6902 21 insufficiency insufficiency NN 40436 6902 22 , , , 40436 6902 23 thereby thereby RB 40436 6902 24 exposed expose VBN 40436 6902 25 , , , 40436 6902 26 of of IN 40436 6902 27 the the DT 40436 6902 28 conceptions conception NNS 40436 6902 29 with with IN 40436 6902 30 which which WDT 40436 6902 31 men man NNS 40436 6902 32 usually usually RB 40436 6902 33 rest rest VBP 40436 6902 34 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 6902 35 -- -- : 40436 6902 36 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 6902 37 the the DT 40436 6902 38 working working NN 40436 6902 39 of of IN 40436 6902 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6902 41 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 6902 42 in in IN 40436 6902 43 one one CD 40436 6902 44 of of IN 40436 6902 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6902 46 most most RBS 40436 6902 47 instructive instructive JJ 40436 6902 48 ways way NNS 40436 6902 49 . . . 40436 6903 1 The the DT 40436 6903 2 parallel parallel NN 40436 6903 3 drawn draw VBN 40436 6903 4 between between IN 40436 6903 5 the the DT 40436 6903 6 body body NN 40436 6903 7 and and CC 40436 6903 8 the the DT 40436 6903 9 mind mind NN 40436 6903 10 -- -- : 40436 6903 11 the the DT 40436 6903 12 constant constant JJ 40436 6903 13 precaution precaution NN 40436 6903 14 taken take VBN 40436 6903 15 in in IN 40436 6903 16 the the DT 40436 6903 17 case case NN 40436 6903 18 of of IN 40436 6903 19 the the DT 40436 6903 20 former former JJ 40436 6903 21 to to TO 40436 6903 22 consult consult VB 40436 6903 23 the the DT 40436 6903 24 professional professional JJ 40436 6903 25 man man NN 40436 6903 26 and and CC 40436 6903 27 to to TO 40436 6903 28 follow follow VB 40436 6903 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6903 30 advice advice NN 40436 6903 31 in in IN 40436 6903 32 respect respect NN 40436 6903 33 both both DT 40436 6903 34 to to TO 40436 6903 35 discipline discipline NN 40436 6903 36 and and CC 40436 6903 37 nourishment nourishment NN 40436 6903 38 -- -- : 40436 6903 39 are be VBP 40436 6903 40 in in IN 40436 6903 41 the the DT 40436 6903 42 same same JJ 40436 6903 43 vein vein NN 40436 6903 44 of of IN 40436 6903 45 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 6903 46 which which WDT 40436 6903 47 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6903 48 have have VBP 40436 6903 49 already already RB 40436 6903 50 followed follow VBN 40436 6903 51 in in IN 40436 6903 52 other other JJ 40436 6903 53 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 6903 54 . . . 40436 6904 1 Here here RB 40436 6904 2 too too RB 40436 6904 3 , , , 40436 6904 4 as as IN 40436 6904 5 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 6904 6 , , , 40436 6904 7 some some DT 40436 6904 8 similar similar JJ 40436 6904 9 _ _ NNP 40436 6904 10 Expert Expert NNP 40436 6904 11 _ _ NNP 40436 6904 12 , , , 40436 6904 13 in in IN 40436 6904 14 reference reference NN 40436 6904 15 to to IN 40436 6904 16 the the DT 40436 6904 17 ethical ethical JJ 40436 6904 18 and and CC 40436 6904 19 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 6904 20 training training NN 40436 6904 21 of of IN 40436 6904 22 mind mind NN 40436 6904 23 , , , 40436 6904 24 is be VBZ 40436 6904 25 desiderated desiderate VBN 40436 6904 26 , , , 40436 6904 27 as as IN 40436 6904 28 still still RB 40436 6904 29 more more RBR 40436 6904 30 imperatively imperatively RB 40436 6904 31 necessary necessary JJ 40436 6904 32 . . . 40436 6905 1 Yet yet CC 40436 6905 2 where where WRB 40436 6905 3 is be VBZ 40436 6905 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6905 5 to to TO 40436 6905 6 be be VB 40436 6905 7 found find VBN 40436 6905 8 ? ? . 40436 6906 1 How how WRB 40436 6906 2 is be VBZ 40436 6906 3 the the DT 40436 6906 4 business business NN 40436 6906 5 of of IN 40436 6906 6 mental mental JJ 40436 6906 7 training training NN 40436 6906 8 to to TO 40436 6906 9 be be VB 40436 6906 10 brought bring VBN 40436 6906 11 to to IN 40436 6906 12 a a DT 40436 6906 13 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 6906 14 issue issue NN 40436 6906 15 without without IN 40436 6906 16 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6906 17 ? ? . 40436 6907 1 Or or CC 40436 6907 2 is be VBZ 40436 6907 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6907 4 the the DT 40436 6907 5 man man NN 40436 6907 6 to to TO 40436 6907 7 supply supply VB 40436 6907 8 such such PDT 40436 6907 9 a a DT 40436 6907 10 demand demand NN 40436 6907 11 ? ? . 40436 6908 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 6908 2 shall shall MD 40436 6908 3 presently presently RB 40436 6908 4 see see VB 40436 6908 5 . . . 40436 6909 1 * * NFP 40436 6909 2 * * NFP 40436 6909 3 * * NFP 40436 6909 4 * * NFP 40436 6909 5 * * NFP 40436 6909 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6909 7 Side side NN 40436 6909 8 - - HYPH 40436 6909 9 note note NN 40436 6909 10 : : : 40436 6909 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6909 12 and and CC 40436 6909 13 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6909 14 go go VBP 40436 6909 15 to to IN 40436 6909 16 the the DT 40436 6909 17 house house NN 40436 6909 18 of of IN 40436 6909 19 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 6909 20 . . . 40436 6910 1 Company company NN 40436 6910 2 therein therein RB 40436 6910 3 . . . 40436 6911 1 Respect respect NN 40436 6911 2 shown show VBN 40436 6911 3 to to IN 40436 6911 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6911 5 . . . 40436 6911 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6912 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6912 2 and and CC 40436 6912 3 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6912 4 proceed proceed VBP 40436 6912 5 to to IN 40436 6912 6 the the DT 40436 6912 7 house house NN 40436 6912 8 of of IN 40436 6912 9 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 6912 10 , , , 40436 6912 11 and and CC 40436 6912 12 find find VB 40436 6912 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6912 14 walking walk VBG 40436 6912 15 about about IN 40436 6912 16 in in IN 40436 6912 17 the the DT 40436 6912 18 fore fore NN 40436 6912 19 - - HYPH 40436 6912 20 court court NN 40436 6912 21 with with IN 40436 6912 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6912 23 , , , 40436 6912 24 and and CC 40436 6912 25 some some DT 40436 6912 26 of of IN 40436 6912 27 the the DT 40436 6912 28 other other JJ 40436 6912 29 company company NN 40436 6912 30 ; ; : 40436 6912 31 all all DT 40436 6912 32 of of IN 40436 6912 33 whom whom WP 40436 6912 34 are be VBP 40436 6912 35 described describe VBN 40436 6912 36 as as IN 40436 6912 37 treating treat VBG 40436 6912 38 the the DT 40436 6912 39 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6912 40 with with IN 40436 6912 41 almost almost RB 40436 6912 42 ostentatious ostentatious JJ 40436 6912 43 respect respect NN 40436 6912 44 . . . 40436 6913 1 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 6913 2 and and CC 40436 6913 3 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 6913 4 have have VBP 40436 6913 5 each each DT 40436 6913 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6913 7 separate separate JJ 40436 6913 8 hearers hearer NNS 40436 6913 9 , , , 40436 6913 10 in in IN 40436 6913 11 or or CC 40436 6913 12 adjoining adjoin VBG 40436 6913 13 to to IN 40436 6913 14 the the DT 40436 6913 15 court court NN 40436 6913 16 . . . 40436 6914 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6914 2 addresses address VBZ 40436 6914 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6914 4 . . . 40436 6915 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6915 2 Side side NN 40436 6915 3 - - HYPH 40436 6915 4 note note NN 40436 6915 5 : : : 40436 6915 6 Questions question NNS 40436 6915 7 of of IN 40436 6915 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6915 9 to to IN 40436 6915 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6915 11 . . . 40436 6916 1 Answer answer NN 40436 6916 2 of of IN 40436 6916 3 the the DT 40436 6916 4 latter latter JJ 40436 6916 5 , , , 40436 6916 6 declaring declare VBG 40436 6916 7 the the DT 40436 6916 8 antiquity antiquity NN 40436 6916 9 of of IN 40436 6916 10 the the DT 40436 6916 11 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 6916 12 profession profession NN 40436 6916 13 , , , 40436 6916 14 and and CC 40436 6916 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6916 16 own own JJ 40436 6916 17 openness openness NN 40436 6916 18 in in IN 40436 6916 19 avowing avow VBG 40436 6916 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6916 21 a a DT 40436 6916 22 sophist sophist NN 40436 6916 23 . . . 40436 6916 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6917 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6917 2 Sokr._--Protagoras Sokr._--Protagoras NNP 40436 6917 3 , , , 40436 6917 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6917 5 and and CC 40436 6917 6 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6917 7 here here RB 40436 6917 8 are be VBP 40436 6917 9 come come VBN 40436 6917 10 to to TO 40436 6917 11 talk talk VB 40436 6917 12 to to IN 40436 6917 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6917 14 about about IN 40436 6917 15 something something NN 40436 6917 16 . . . 40436 6918 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6918 2 Prot._--Do Prot._--Do NNP 40436 6918 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6918 4 wish wish VBP 40436 6918 5 to to IN 40436 6918 6 ta]k ta]k NNP 40436 6918 7 to to IN 40436 6918 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6918 9 alone alone JJ 40436 6918 10 , , , 40436 6918 11 or or CC 40436 6918 12 in in IN 40436 6918 13 presence presence NN 40436 6918 14 of of IN 40436 6918 15 the the DT 40436 6918 16 rest rest NN 40436 6918 17 ? ? . 40436 6919 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6919 2 Sokr._--To Sokr._--To NNP 40436 6919 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6919 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6919 5 is be VBZ 40436 6919 6 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 6919 7 : : : 40436 6919 8 but but CC 40436 6919 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6919 10 will will MD 40436 6919 11 tell tell VB 40436 6919 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6919 13 what what WP 40436 6919 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 6919 15 come come VBP 40436 6919 16 about about RP 40436 6919 17 , , , 40436 6919 18 and and CC 40436 6919 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6919 20 may may MD 40436 6919 21 then then RB 40436 6919 22 determine determine VB 40436 6919 23 for for IN 40436 6919 24 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 6919 25 . . . 40436 6920 1 This this DT 40436 6920 2 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6920 3 is be VBZ 40436 6920 4 a a DT 40436 6920 5 young young JJ 40436 6920 6 man man NN 40436 6920 7 of of IN 40436 6920 8 noble noble JJ 40436 6920 9 family family NN 40436 6920 10 , , , 40436 6920 11 and and CC 40436 6920 12 fully fully RB 40436 6920 13 equal equal JJ 40436 6920 14 to to IN 40436 6920 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6920 16 contemporaries contemporary NNS 40436 6920 17 in in IN 40436 6920 18 capacity capacity NN 40436 6920 19 . . . 40436 6921 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6921 2 wishes wish VBZ 40436 6921 3 to to TO 40436 6921 4 become become VB 40436 6921 5 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 6921 6 in in IN 40436 6921 7 the the DT 40436 6921 8 city city NN 40436 6921 9 ; ; : 40436 6921 10 and and CC 40436 6921 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6921 12 thinks think VBZ 40436 6921 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6921 14 shall shall MD 40436 6921 15 best well RBS 40436 6921 16 attain attain VB 40436 6921 17 that that DT 40436 6921 18 object object NN 40436 6921 19 through through IN 40436 6921 20 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6921 21 society society NN 40436 6921 22 . . . 40436 6922 1 Consider consider VB 40436 6922 2 whether whether IN 40436 6922 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6922 4 would would MD 40436 6922 5 like like VB 40436 6922 6 better well RBR 40436 6922 7 to to TO 40436 6922 8 talk talk VB 40436 6922 9 with with IN 40436 6922 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6922 11 alone alone JJ 40436 6922 12 , , , 40436 6922 13 or or CC 40436 6922 14 in in IN 40436 6922 15 presence presence NN 40436 6922 16 of of IN 40436 6922 17 the the DT 40436 6922 18 rest rest NN 40436 6922 19 . . . 40436 6923 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6923 2 16 16 CD 40436 6923 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6923 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6923 5 Prot._--Your Prot._--Your NNP 40436 6923 6 consideration consideration NN 40436 6923 7 on on IN 40436 6923 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6923 9 behalf behalf NN 40436 6923 10 , , , 40436 6923 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 6923 12 , , , 40436 6923 13 is be VBZ 40436 6923 14 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 6923 15 . . . 40436 6924 1 A a DT 40436 6924 2 person person NN 40436 6924 3 of of IN 40436 6924 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6924 5 profession profession NN 40436 6924 6 must must MD 40436 6924 7 be be VB 40436 6924 8 cautious cautious JJ 40436 6924 9 in in IN 40436 6924 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6924 11 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 6924 12 . . . 40436 6925 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6925 2 , , , 40436 6925 3 a a DT 40436 6925 4 foreigner foreigner NN 40436 6925 5 , , , 40436 6925 6 visit visit VB 40436 6925 7 large large JJ 40436 6925 8 cities city NNS 40436 6925 9 , , , 40436 6925 10 persuading persuade VBG 40436 6925 11 the the DT 40436 6925 12 youth youth NN 40436 6925 13 of of IN 40436 6925 14 best good JJS 40436 6925 15 family family NN 40436 6925 16 to to TO 40436 6925 17 frequent frequent VB 40436 6925 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6925 19 society society NN 40436 6925 20 in in IN 40436 6925 21 preference preference NN 40436 6925 22 to to IN 40436 6925 23 that that DT 40436 6925 24 of of IN 40436 6925 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6925 26 kinsmen kinsman NNS 40436 6925 27 and and CC 40436 6925 28 all all DT 40436 6925 29 others other NNS 40436 6925 30 ; ; : 40436 6925 31 in in IN 40436 6925 32 the the DT 40436 6925 33 conviction conviction NN 40436 6925 34 that that IN 40436 6925 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6925 36 shall shall MD 40436 6925 37 do do VB 40436 6925 38 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6925 39 good good JJ 40436 6925 40 . . . 40436 6926 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6926 2 thus thus RB 40436 6926 3 inevitably inevitably RB 40436 6926 4 become become VBP 40436 6926 5 exposed expose VBN 40436 6926 6 to to IN 40436 6926 7 much much JJ 40436 6926 8 jealousy jealousy NN 40436 6926 9 and and CC 40436 6926 10 even even RB 40436 6926 11 to to IN 40436 6926 12 hostile hostile JJ 40436 6926 13 conspiracies conspiracy NNS 40436 6926 14 . . . 40436 6927 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6927 2 17 17 CD 40436 6927 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6927 4 The the DT 40436 6927 5 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 6927 6 art art NN 40436 6927 7 is be VBZ 40436 6927 8 an an DT 40436 6927 9 old old JJ 40436 6927 10 one;[18 one;[18 NN 40436 6927 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6927 12 but but CC 40436 6927 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6927 14 older old JJR 40436 6927 15 professors professor NNS 40436 6927 16 , , , 40436 6927 17 being be VBG 40436 6927 18 afraid afraid JJ 40436 6927 19 of of IN 40436 6927 20 enmity enmity NN 40436 6927 21 if if IN 40436 6927 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6927 23 proclaimed proclaim VBD 40436 6927 24 what what WP 40436 6927 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6927 26 really really RB 40436 6927 27 were be VBD 40436 6927 28 , , , 40436 6927 29 have have VBP 40436 6927 30 always always RB 40436 6927 31 disguised disguise VBN 40436 6927 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6927 33 under under IN 40436 6927 34 other other JJ 40436 6927 35 titles title NNS 40436 6927 36 . . . 40436 6928 1 Some some DT 40436 6928 2 , , , 40436 6928 3 like like IN 40436 6928 4 Homer Homer NNP 40436 6928 5 , , , 40436 6928 6 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 40436 6928 7 , , , 40436 6928 8 and and CC 40436 6928 9 Simonides Simonides NNP 40436 6928 10 , , , 40436 6928 11 called call VBD 40436 6928 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6928 13 poets poet NNS 40436 6928 14 : : : 40436 6928 15 others other NNS 40436 6928 16 , , , 40436 6928 17 Orpheus Orpheus NNP 40436 6928 18 , , , 40436 6928 19 Musæus Musæus NNP 40436 6928 20 , , , 40436 6928 21 & & CC 40436 6928 22 c. c. NNP 40436 6928 23 , , , 40436 6928 24 professed profess VBD 40436 6928 25 to to TO 40436 6928 26 prescribe prescribe VB 40436 6928 27 religious religious JJ 40436 6928 28 rites rite NNS 40436 6928 29 and and CC 40436 6928 30 mysteries mystery NNS 40436 6928 31 : : : 40436 6928 32 others other NNS 40436 6928 33 announced announce VBD 40436 6928 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6928 35 as as IN 40436 6928 36 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 6928 37 trainers trainer NNS 40436 6928 38 or or CC 40436 6928 39 teachers teacher NNS 40436 6928 40 of of IN 40436 6928 41 music music NN 40436 6928 42 . . . 40436 6929 1 But but CC 40436 6929 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6929 3 have have VBP 40436 6929 4 departed depart VBN 40436 6929 5 altogether altogether RB 40436 6929 6 from from IN 40436 6929 7 this this DT 40436 6929 8 policy policy NN 40436 6929 9 ; ; : 40436 6929 10 which which WDT 40436 6929 11 indeed indeed RB 40436 6929 12 did do VBD 40436 6929 13 not not RB 40436 6929 14 succeed succeed VB 40436 6929 15 in in IN 40436 6929 16 really really RB 40436 6929 17 deceiving deceive VBG 40436 6929 18 any any DT 40436 6929 19 leading lead VBG 40436 6929 20 men man NNS 40436 6929 21 -- -- : 40436 6929 22 whom whom WP 40436 6929 23 alone alone RB 40436 6929 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6929 25 was be VBD 40436 6929 26 intended intend VBN 40436 6929 27 to to TO 40436 6929 28 deceive deceive VB 40436 6929 29 -- -- : 40436 6929 30 and and CC 40436 6929 31 which which WDT 40436 6929 32 , , , 40436 6929 33 when when WRB 40436 6929 34 found find VBD 40436 6929 35 out out RP 40436 6929 36 , , , 40436 6929 37 entailed entail VBN 40436 6929 38 upon upon IN 40436 6929 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6929 40 authors author NNS 40436 6929 41 the the DT 40436 6929 42 additional additional JJ 40436 6929 43 disgrace disgrace NN 40436 6929 44 of of IN 40436 6929 45 being be VBG 40436 6929 46 considered consider VBN 40436 6929 47 deceivers deceiver NNS 40436 6929 48 . . . 40436 6930 1 The the DT 40436 6930 2 true true JJ 40436 6930 3 caution caution NN 40436 6930 4 consists consist VBZ 40436 6930 5 in in IN 40436 6930 6 open open JJ 40436 6930 7 dealing dealing NN 40436 6930 8 ; ; : 40436 6930 9 and and CC 40436 6930 10 this this DT 40436 6930 11 is be VBZ 40436 6930 12 what what WP 40436 6930 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6930 14 have have VBP 40436 6930 15 always always RB 40436 6930 16 adopted adopt VBN 40436 6930 17 . . . 40436 6931 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6931 2 avow avow VBP 40436 6931 3 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 6931 4 a a DT 40436 6931 5 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 6931 6 , , , 40436 6931 7 educating educate VBG 40436 6931 8 men man NNS 40436 6931 9 . . . 40436 6932 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6932 2 am be VBP 40436 6932 3 now now RB 40436 6932 4 advanced advance VBN 40436 6932 5 in in IN 40436 6932 6 years year NNS 40436 6932 7 , , , 40436 6932 8 old old JJ 40436 6932 9 enough enough RB 40436 6932 10 to to TO 40436 6932 11 be be VB 40436 6932 12 the the DT 40436 6932 13 father father NN 40436 6932 14 of of IN 40436 6932 15 any any DT 40436 6932 16 of of IN 40436 6932 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6932 18 , , , 40436 6932 19 and and CC 40436 6932 20 have have VBP 40436 6932 21 grown grow VBN 40436 6932 22 old old JJ 40436 6932 23 in in IN 40436 6932 24 the the DT 40436 6932 25 profession profession NN 40436 6932 26 : : : 40436 6932 27 yet yet CC 40436 6932 28 during during IN 40436 6932 29 all all PDT 40436 6932 30 these these DT 40436 6932 31 years year NNS 40436 6932 32 , , , 40436 6932 33 thank thank VBP 40436 6932 34 God God NNP 40436 6932 35 , , , 40436 6932 36 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6932 37 have have VBP 40436 6932 38 suffered suffer VBN 40436 6932 39 no no DT 40436 6932 40 harm harm NN 40436 6932 41 either either CC 40436 6932 42 from from IN 40436 6932 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6932 44 practice practice NN 40436 6932 45 or or CC 40436 6932 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6932 47 title title NN 40436 6932 48 . . . 40436 6933 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6933 2 19 19 CD 40436 6933 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6933 4 If if IN 40436 6933 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 6933 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6933 7 desire desire VBP 40436 6933 8 to to TO 40436 6933 9 converse converse VB 40436 6933 10 with with IN 40436 6933 11 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6933 12 , , , 40436 6933 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6933 14 will will MD 40436 6933 15 be be VB 40436 6933 16 far far RB 40436 6933 17 more more RBR 40436 6933 18 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 6933 19 to to IN 40436 6933 20 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6933 21 to to TO 40436 6933 22 converse converse VB 40436 6933 23 in in IN 40436 6933 24 presence presence NN 40436 6933 25 of of IN 40436 6933 26 all all DT 40436 6933 27 who who WP 40436 6933 28 are be VBP 40436 6933 29 now now RB 40436 6933 30 in in IN 40436 6933 31 the the DT 40436 6933 32 house house NN 40436 6933 33 . . . 40436 6934 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6934 2 20 20 CD 40436 6934 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6934 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6934 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6934 6 16 16 CD 40436 6934 7 : : : 40436 6934 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6934 9 . . . 40436 6935 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 6935 2 . . . 40436 6936 1 p. p. NN 40436 6936 2 316 316 CD 40436 6936 3 . . . 40436 6937 1 The the DT 40436 6937 2 motive motive NN 40436 6937 3 assigned assign VBN 40436 6937 4 by by IN 40436 6937 5 Hippokrates hippokrate NNS 40436 6937 6 , , , 40436 6937 7 for for IN 40436 6937 8 putting put VBG 40436 6937 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6937 10 under under IN 40436 6937 11 the the DT 40436 6937 12 teaching teaching NN 40436 6937 13 of of IN 40436 6937 14 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6937 15 , , , 40436 6937 16 is be VBZ 40436 6937 17 just just RB 40436 6937 18 the the DT 40436 6937 19 same same JJ 40436 6937 20 as as IN 40436 6937 21 that that DT 40436 6937 22 which which WDT 40436 6937 23 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 6937 24 assigns assign VBZ 40436 6937 25 to to IN 40436 6937 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6937 27 friend friend NN 40436 6937 28 Proxenus Proxenus NNP 40436 6937 29 for for IN 40436 6937 30 taking take VBG 40436 6937 31 lessons lesson NNS 40436 6937 32 and and CC 40436 6937 33 paying pay VBG 40436 6937 34 fees fee NNS 40436 6937 35 to to IN 40436 6937 36 the the DT 40436 6937 37 Leontine Leontine NNP 40436 6937 38 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 6937 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6937 40 Xen Xen NNP 40436 6937 41 . . . 40436 6938 1 Anab anab UH 40436 6938 2 . . . 40436 6939 1 ii ii LS 40436 6939 2 . . . 40436 6940 1 6 6 CD 40436 6940 2 , , , 40436 6940 3 16 16 CD 40436 6940 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6940 5 . . . 40436 6940 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6941 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6941 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6941 3 17 17 CD 40436 6941 4 : : : 40436 6941 5 The the DT 40436 6941 6 jealousy jealousy NN 40436 6941 7 felt feel VBN 40436 6941 8 by by IN 40436 6941 9 fathers father NNS 40436 6941 10 , , , 40436 6941 11 mothers mother NNS 40436 6941 12 , , , 40436 6941 13 and and CC 40436 6941 14 relatives relative NNS 40436 6941 15 against against IN 40436 6941 16 a a DT 40436 6941 17 teacher teacher NN 40436 6941 18 or or CC 40436 6941 19 converser converser NN 40436 6941 20 who who WP 40436 6941 21 acquired acquire VBD 40436 6941 22 great great JJ 40436 6941 23 influence influence NN 40436 6941 24 over over IN 40436 6941 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6941 26 youthful youthful JJ 40436 6941 27 relatives relative NNS 40436 6941 28 , , , 40436 6941 29 is be VBZ 40436 6941 30 alluded allude VBN 40436 6941 31 to to IN 40436 6941 32 by by IN 40436 6941 33 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6941 34 in in IN 40436 6941 35 the the DT 40436 6941 36 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6941 37 Apology Apology NNP 40436 6941 38 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6941 39 p. p. NN 40436 6941 40 37 37 CD 40436 6941 41 E E NNS 40436 6941 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6941 43 , , , 40436 6941 44 and and CC 40436 6941 45 is be VBZ 40436 6941 46 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 6941 47 by by IN 40436 6941 48 a a DT 40436 6941 49 tragical tragical JJ 40436 6941 50 incident incident NN 40436 6941 51 in in IN 40436 6941 52 the the DT 40436 6941 53 Cyropædia Cyropædia NNP 40436 6941 54 of of IN 40436 6941 55 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 6941 56 , , , 40436 6941 57 iii iii NNP 40436 6941 58 . . . 40436 6942 1 1 1 LS 40436 6942 2 . . . 40436 6943 1 14 14 CD 40436 6943 2 - - SYM 40436 6943 3 38 38 CD 40436 6943 4 . . . 40436 6944 1 Compare compare VB 40436 6944 2 also also RB 40436 6944 3 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 6944 4 , , , 40436 6944 5 Memorab Memorab NNP 40436 6944 6 . . . 40436 6945 1 i. i. NNP 40436 6946 1 2 2 CD 40436 6946 2 , , , 40436 6946 3 52 52 CD 40436 6946 4 . . . 40436 6946 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6947 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6947 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6947 3 18 18 CD 40436 6947 4 : : : 40436 6947 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6947 6 . . . 40436 6948 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 6948 2 . . . 40436 6949 1 p. p. NN 40436 6949 2 316 316 CD 40436 6949 3 D. D. NNP 40436 6949 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6949 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6949 6 : : : 40436 6949 7 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 6949 8 de\ de\ NNP 40436 6949 9 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 6949 10 sophistikê\n sophistikê\n CD 40436 6949 11 te te NNP 40436 6949 12 / / SYM 40436 6949 13 chnên chnên NN 40436 6949 14 phêmi\ phêmi\ NNP 40436 6949 15 me\n me\n NNP 40436 6949 16 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 6949 17 palaia palaia NNP 40436 6949 18 / / SYM 40436 6949 19 n n NNP 40436 6949 20 . . . 40436 6949 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6949 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6950 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6950 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6950 3 19 19 CD 40436 6950 4 : : : 40436 6950 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6950 6 . . . 40436 6951 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 6951 2 . . . 40436 6952 1 p. p. NN 40436 6952 2 317 317 CD 40436 6952 3 C. C. NNP 40436 6952 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6952 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6952 6 : : : 40436 6952 7 ô(/ste ô(/ste VB 40436 6952 8 su\n su\n NNP 40436 6952 9 theô=| theô=| NNP 40436 6952 10 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 6952 11 = = SYM 40436 6952 12 n n NN 40436 6952 13 mêde\n mêde\n NNP 40436 6952 14 deino\n deino\n ADD 40436 6952 15 pa pa NNP 40436 6952 16 / / SYM 40436 6952 17 schein schein NNP 40436 6952 18 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 6952 19 to\ to\ NNP 40436 6952 20 o(mologei o(mologei . 40436 6952 21 = = SYM 40436 6952 22 n n NN 40436 6952 23 sophistê\s sophistê\s CD 40436 6952 24 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 6952 25 . . . 40436 6952 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6952 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6953 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6953 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6953 3 20 20 CD 40436 6953 4 : : : 40436 6953 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 6953 6 . . . 40436 6954 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 6954 2 . . . 40436 6955 1 p. p. NN 40436 6955 2 317 317 CD 40436 6955 3 D. D. NNP 40436 6955 4 In In NNP 40436 6955 5 the the DT 40436 6955 6 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6955 7 , , , 40436 6955 8 the the DT 40436 6955 9 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 6955 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6955 11 is be VBZ 40436 6955 12 made make VBN 40436 6955 13 to to TO 40436 6955 14 say say VB 40436 6955 15 that that IN 40436 6955 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6955 17 died die VBD 40436 6955 18 at at IN 40436 6955 19 the the DT 40436 6955 20 age age NN 40436 6955 21 of of IN 40436 6955 22 seventy seventy CD 40436 6955 23 ; ; : 40436 6955 24 that that IN 40436 6955 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6955 26 had have VBD 40436 6955 27 practised practise VBN 40436 6955 28 forty forty CD 40436 6955 29 years year NNS 40436 6955 30 as as IN 40436 6955 31 a a DT 40436 6955 32 Sophist sophist NN 40436 6955 33 ; ; : 40436 6955 34 and and CC 40436 6955 35 that that IN 40436 6955 36 during during IN 40436 6955 37 all all PDT 40436 6955 38 that that DT 40436 6955 39 long long JJ 40436 6955 40 time time NN 40436 6955 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6955 42 had have VBD 40436 6955 43 enjoyed enjoy VBN 40436 6955 44 the the DT 40436 6955 45 highest high JJS 40436 6955 46 esteem esteem NN 40436 6955 47 and and CC 40436 6955 48 reputation reputation NN 40436 6955 49 , , , 40436 6955 50 even even RB 40436 6955 51 after after IN 40436 6955 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6955 53 death death NN 40436 6955 54 , , , 40436 6955 55 " " '' 40436 6955 56 down down RB 40436 6955 57 to to IN 40436 6955 58 the the DT 40436 6955 59 present present JJ 40436 6955 60 day day NN 40436 6955 61 " " '' 40436 6955 62 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6955 63 Menon Menon NNP 40436 6955 64 , , , 40436 6955 65 p. p. NN 40436 6955 66 91 91 CD 40436 6955 67 E e NN 40436 6955 68 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6955 69 . . . 40436 6956 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6956 2 must must MD 40436 6956 3 be be VB 40436 6956 4 remembered remember VBN 40436 6956 5 that that IN 40436 6956 6 the the DT 40436 6956 7 speech speech NN 40436 6956 8 , , , 40436 6956 9 of of IN 40436 6956 10 which which WDT 40436 6956 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6956 12 have have VBP 40436 6956 13 just just RB 40436 6956 14 given give VBN 40436 6956 15 an an DT 40436 6956 16 abstract abstract JJ 40436 6956 17 , , , 40436 6956 18 is be VBZ 40436 6956 19 delivered deliver VBN 40436 6956 20 not not RB 40436 6956 21 by by IN 40436 6956 22 the the DT 40436 6956 23 historical historical JJ 40436 6956 24 , , , 40436 6956 25 real real JJ 40436 6956 26 , , , 40436 6956 27 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6956 28 , , , 40436 6956 29 but but CC 40436 6956 30 by by IN 40436 6956 31 the the DT 40436 6956 32 character character NN 40436 6956 33 named name VBN 40436 6956 34 _ _ NNP 40436 6956 35 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6956 36 _ _ NNP 40436 6956 37 , , , 40436 6956 38 depicted depict VBN 40436 6956 39 by by IN 40436 6956 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6956 41 in in IN 40436 6956 42 this this DT 40436 6956 43 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 6956 44 : : : 40436 6956 45 _ _ NNP 40436 6956 46 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 6956 47 _ _ NNP 40436 6956 48 the the DT 40436 6956 49 speech speech NN 40436 6956 50 is be VBZ 40436 6956 51 composed compose VBN 40436 6956 52 by by IN 40436 6956 53 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6956 54 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6956 55 . . . 40436 6957 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6957 2 read read VBP 40436 6957 3 , , , 40436 6957 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 6957 5 , , , 40436 6957 6 with with IN 40436 6957 7 much much JJ 40436 6957 8 surprise surprise NN 40436 6957 9 , , , 40436 6957 10 a a DT 40436 6957 11 note note NN 40436 6957 12 of of IN 40436 6957 13 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 6957 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6957 15 ad ad NN 40436 6957 16 p. p. NN 40436 6957 17 316 316 CD 40436 6957 18 D D NNP 40436 6957 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6957 20 , , , 40436 6957 21 wherein wherein WRB 40436 6957 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6957 23 says say VBZ 40436 6957 24 about about IN 40436 6957 25 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6957 26 : : : 40436 6957 27 " " `` 40436 6957 28 Callidé Callidé NNPS 40436 6957 29 in in IN 40436 6957 30 postremis postremis NNP 40436 6957 31 reticet reticet NNP 40436 6957 32 , , , 40436 6957 33 quod quod NN 40436 6957 34 addere addere NNP 40436 6957 35 poterat poterat NNP 40436 6957 36 , , , 40436 6957 37 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6957 38 Greek Greek NNP 40436 6957 39 : : : 40436 6957 40 chrê chrê NNP 40436 6957 41 / / SYM 40436 6957 42 mata mata NNP 40436 6957 43 dido dido NNP 40436 6957 44 / / SYM 40436 6957 45 ntas ntas NNP 40436 6957 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6957 47 . . . 40436 6957 48 " " '' 40436 6958 1 " " `` 40436 6958 2 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6958 3 cunningly cunningly RB 40436 6958 4 keeps keep VBZ 40436 6958 5 back back RP 40436 6958 6 , , , 40436 6958 7 what what WP 40436 6958 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6958 9 might may MD 40436 6958 10 have have VB 40436 6958 11 here here RB 40436 6958 12 added add VBN 40436 6958 13 , , , 40436 6958 14 that that IN 40436 6958 15 people people NNS 40436 6958 16 gave give VBD 40436 6958 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6958 18 money money NN 40436 6958 19 for for IN 40436 6958 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6958 21 teaching teaching NN 40436 6958 22 . . . 40436 6958 23 " " '' 40436 6959 1 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 6959 2 must must MD 40436 6959 3 surely surely RB 40436 6959 4 have have VB 40436 6959 5 supposed suppose VBN 40436 6959 6 that that IN 40436 6959 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6959 8 was be VBD 40436 6959 9 commenting comment VBG 40436 6959 10 upon upon IN 40436 6959 11 a a DT 40436 6959 12 real real JJ 40436 6959 13 speech speech NN 40436 6959 14 , , , 40436 6959 15 delivered deliver VBN 40436 6959 16 by by IN 40436 6959 17 the the DT 40436 6959 18 historical historical JJ 40436 6959 19 person person NN 40436 6959 20 called call VBN 40436 6959 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6959 22 . . . 40436 6960 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 40436 6960 2 what what WP 40436 6960 3 can can MD 40436 6960 4 be be VB 40436 6960 5 meant mean VBN 40436 6960 6 by by IN 40436 6960 7 this this DT 40436 6960 8 charge charge NN 40436 6960 9 of of IN 40436 6960 10 " " `` 40436 6960 11 cunning cunne VBG 40436 6960 12 reticence reticence NN 40436 6960 13 or or CC 40436 6960 14 keeping keep VBG 40436 6960 15 back back RB 40436 6960 16 ? ? . 40436 6960 17 " " '' 40436 6961 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6961 2 here here RB 40436 6961 3 speaks speak VBZ 40436 6961 4 what what WP 40436 6961 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6961 6 puts put VBZ 40436 6961 7 into into IN 40436 6961 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6961 9 mouth mouth NN 40436 6961 10 ; ; : 40436 6961 11 neither neither CC 40436 6961 12 more more RBR 40436 6961 13 nor nor CC 40436 6961 14 less less RBR 40436 6961 15 . . . 40436 6962 1 What what WP 40436 6962 2 makes make VBZ 40436 6962 3 the the DT 40436 6962 4 remark remark NN 40436 6962 5 of of IN 40436 6962 6 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 6962 7 the the DT 40436 6962 8 more more RBR 40436 6962 9 preposterous preposterous JJ 40436 6962 10 is be VBZ 40436 6962 11 , , , 40436 6962 12 that that IN 40436 6962 13 in in IN 40436 6962 14 page page NN 40436 6962 15 328 328 CD 40436 6962 16 B b NN 40436 6962 17 the the DT 40436 6962 18 very very JJ 40436 6962 19 fact fact NN 40436 6962 20 , , , 40436 6962 21 which which WDT 40436 6962 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6962 23 is be VBZ 40436 6962 24 here here RB 40436 6962 25 said say VBN 40436 6962 26 " " `` 40436 6962 27 cunningly cunningly RB 40436 6962 28 to to TO 40436 6962 29 keep keep VB 40436 6962 30 back back RB 40436 6962 31 , , , 40436 6962 32 " " '' 40436 6962 33 appears appear VBZ 40436 6962 34 mentioned mention VBN 40436 6962 35 by by IN 40436 6962 36 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6962 37 ; ; : 40436 6962 38 and and CC 40436 6962 39 mentioned mention VBN 40436 6962 40 in in IN 40436 6962 41 the the DT 40436 6962 42 same same JJ 40436 6962 43 spirit spirit NN 40436 6962 44 of of IN 40436 6962 45 honourable honourable JJ 40436 6962 46 frankness frankness NN 40436 6962 47 and and CC 40436 6962 48 fair fair NN 40436 6962 49 - - HYPH 40436 6962 50 dealing dealing NN 40436 6962 51 as as IN 40436 6962 52 that that DT 40436 6962 53 which which WDT 40436 6962 54 pervades pervade VBZ 40436 6962 55 the the DT 40436 6962 56 discourse discourse NN 40436 6962 57 which which WDT 40436 6962 58 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6962 59 have have VBP 40436 6962 60 just just RB 40436 6962 61 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6962 62 freely freely RB 40436 6962 63 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6962 64 translated translate VBN 40436 6962 65 . . . 40436 6963 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 6963 2 nothing nothing NN 40436 6963 3 can can MD 40436 6963 4 be be VB 40436 6963 5 more more RBR 40436 6963 6 marked marked JJ 40436 6963 7 than than IN 40436 6963 8 the the DT 40436 6963 9 way way NN 40436 6963 10 in in IN 40436 6963 11 which which WDT 40436 6963 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6963 13 makes make VBZ 40436 6963 14 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6963 15 dwell dwell VB 40436 6963 16 with with IN 40436 6963 17 emphasis emphasis NN 40436 6963 18 on on IN 40436 6963 19 the the DT 40436 6963 20 frankness frankness NN 40436 6963 21 and and CC 40436 6963 22 openness openness NN 40436 6963 23 of of IN 40436 6963 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6963 25 dealing dealing NN 40436 6963 26 : : : 40436 6963 27 nothing nothing NN 40436 6963 28 can can MD 40436 6963 29 be be VB 40436 6963 30 more more JJR 40436 6963 31 at at IN 40436 6963 32 variance variance NN 40436 6963 33 with with IN 40436 6963 34 the the DT 40436 6963 35 character character NN 40436 6963 36 which which WDT 40436 6963 37 critics critic NNS 40436 6963 38 give give VBP 40436 6963 39 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6963 40 of of IN 40436 6963 41 the the DT 40436 6963 42 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 6963 43 , , , 40436 6963 44 as as IN 40436 6963 45 " " `` 40436 6963 46 cheats cheat NNS 40436 6963 47 , , , 40436 6963 48 who who WP 40436 6963 49 defrauded defraud VBD 40436 6963 50 pupils pupil NNS 40436 6963 51 of of IN 40436 6963 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6963 53 money money NN 40436 6963 54 while while IN 40436 6963 55 teaching teach VBG 40436 6963 56 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6963 57 nothing nothing NN 40436 6963 58 at at RB 40436 6963 59 all all RB 40436 6963 60 , , , 40436 6963 61 or or CC 40436 6963 62 what what WP 40436 6963 63 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6963 64 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 6963 65 knew know VBD 40436 6963 66 to to TO 40436 6963 67 be be VB 40436 6963 68 false false JJ 40436 6963 69 " " '' 40436 6963 70 . . . 40436 6963 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6964 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6964 2 Side side NN 40436 6964 3 - - HYPH 40436 6964 4 note note NN 40436 6964 5 : : : 40436 6964 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6964 7 prefers prefer VBZ 40436 6964 8 to to TO 40436 6964 9 converse converse VB 40436 6964 10 in in IN 40436 6964 11 presence presence NN 40436 6964 12 of of IN 40436 6964 13 the the DT 40436 6964 14 assembled assemble VBN 40436 6964 15 company company NN 40436 6964 16 . . . 40436 6964 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6965 1 On on IN 40436 6965 2 hearing hear VBG 40436 6965 3 this this DT 40436 6965 4 , , , 40436 6965 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 6965 6 -- -- : 40436 6965 7 under under IN 40436 6965 8 the the DT 40436 6965 9 suspicion suspicion NN 40436 6965 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6965 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6965 12 tells tell VBZ 40436 6965 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 6965 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6965 15 that that IN 40436 6965 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6965 17 wanted want VBD 40436 6965 18 to to TO 40436 6965 19 show show VB 40436 6965 20 off off RP 40436 6965 21 in in IN 40436 6965 22 the the DT 40436 6965 23 presence presence NN 40436 6965 24 of of IN 40436 6965 25 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 6965 26 and and CC 40436 6965 27 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 6965 28 -- -- : 40436 6965 29 proposes propose VBZ 40436 6965 30 to to TO 40436 6965 31 convene convene VB 40436 6965 32 all all PDT 40436 6965 33 the the DT 40436 6965 34 dispersed disperse VBN 40436 6965 35 guests guest NNS 40436 6965 36 , , , 40436 6965 37 and and CC 40436 6965 38 to to TO 40436 6965 39 talk talk VB 40436 6965 40 in in IN 40436 6965 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6965 42 hearing hearing NN 40436 6965 43 . . . 40436 6966 1 This this DT 40436 6966 2 is be VBZ 40436 6966 3 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 6966 4 done do VBN 40436 6966 5 , , , 40436 6966 6 and and CC 40436 6966 7 the the DT 40436 6966 8 conversation conversation NN 40436 6966 9 recommences recommence NNS 40436 6966 10 -- -- : 40436 6966 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6966 12 repeating repeat VBG 40436 6966 13 the the DT 40436 6966 14 introductory introductory JJ 40436 6966 15 request request NN 40436 6966 16 which which WDT 40436 6966 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6966 18 had have VBD 40436 6966 19 preferred prefer VBN 40436 6966 20 on on IN 40436 6966 21 behalf behalf NN 40436 6966 22 of of IN 40436 6966 23 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 6966 24 . . . 40436 6967 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6967 2 Side side NN 40436 6967 3 - - HYPH 40436 6967 4 note note NN 40436 6967 5 : : : 40436 6967 6 Answers answer NNS 40436 6967 7 of of IN 40436 6967 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6967 9 . . . 40436 6968 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6968 2 intends intend VBZ 40436 6968 3 to to TO 40436 6968 4 train train VB 40436 6968 5 young young JJ 40436 6968 6 men man NNS 40436 6968 7 as as IN 40436 6968 8 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 6968 9 citizens citizen NNS 40436 6968 10 . . . 40436 6968 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6969 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6969 2 Sokr._--Hippokrates Sokr._--Hippokrates NNP 40436 6969 3 is be VBZ 40436 6969 4 anxious anxious JJ 40436 6969 5 to to TO 40436 6969 6 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 6969 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6969 8 in in IN 40436 6969 9 the the DT 40436 6969 10 city city NN 40436 6969 11 , , , 40436 6969 12 and and CC 40436 6969 13 thinks think VBZ 40436 6969 14 that that IN 40436 6969 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6969 16 shall shall MD 40436 6969 17 best best RB 40436 6969 18 attain attain VB 40436 6969 19 this this DT 40436 6969 20 end end NN 40436 6969 21 by by IN 40436 6969 22 placing place VBG 40436 6969 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6969 24 under under IN 40436 6969 25 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6969 26 instruction instruction NN 40436 6969 27 . . . 40436 6970 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 6970 2 would would MD 40436 6970 3 gladly gladly RB 40436 6970 4 learn learn VB 40436 6970 5 , , , 40436 6970 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6970 7 , , , 40436 6970 8 what what WP 40436 6970 9 will will MD 40436 6970 10 happen happen VB 40436 6970 11 to to IN 40436 6970 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6970 13 , , , 40436 6970 14 if if IN 40436 6970 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6970 16 comes come VBZ 40436 6970 17 into into IN 40436 6970 18 intercourse intercourse NN 40436 6970 19 with with IN 40436 6970 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6970 21 . . . 40436 6971 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6971 2 Prot._--Young Prot._--Young NNP 40436 6971 3 man man NN 40436 6971 4 , , , 40436 6971 5 if if IN 40436 6971 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6971 7 come come VBP 40436 6971 8 to to IN 40436 6971 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 6971 10 , , , 40436 6971 11 on on IN 40436 6971 12 the the DT 40436 6971 13 day day NN 40436 6971 14 of of IN 40436 6971 15 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6971 16 first first JJ 40436 6971 17 visit visit NN 40436 6971 18 , , , 40436 6971 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6971 20 will will MD 40436 6971 21 go go VB 40436 6971 22 home home RB 40436 6971 23 better well RBR 40436 6971 24 than than IN 40436 6971 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6971 26 came come VBD 40436 6971 27 , , , 40436 6971 28 and and CC 40436 6971 29 on on IN 40436 6971 30 the the DT 40436 6971 31 next next JJ 40436 6971 32 day day NN 40436 6971 33 the the DT 40436 6971 34 like like UH 40436 6971 35 : : : 40436 6971 36 each each DT 40436 6971 37 successive successive JJ 40436 6971 38 day day NN 40436 6971 39 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6971 40 will will MD 40436 6971 41 make make VB 40436 6971 42 progress progress NN 40436 6971 43 for for IN 40436 6971 44 the the DT 40436 6971 45 better well JJR 40436 6971 46 . . . 40436 6972 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6972 2 21 21 CD 40436 6972 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6972 4 _ _ NNP 40436 6972 5 Sokr._--Of Sokr._--Of NNP 40436 6972 6 course course NN 40436 6972 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6972 8 will will MD 40436 6972 9 ; ; : 40436 6972 10 there there EX 40436 6972 11 is be VBZ 40436 6972 12 nothing nothing NN 40436 6972 13 surprising surprising JJ 40436 6972 14 in in IN 40436 6972 15 that that DT 40436 6972 16 : : : 40436 6972 17 but but CC 40436 6972 18 towards towards IN 40436 6972 19 _ _ NNP 40436 6972 20 what what WP 40436 6972 21 _ _ NNP 40436 6972 22 , , , 40436 6972 23 and and CC 40436 6972 24 about about RB 40436 6972 25 _ _ NNP 40436 6972 26 what what WP 40436 6972 27 _ _ NNP 40436 6972 28 , , , 40436 6972 29 will will MD 40436 6972 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6972 31 make make VB 40436 6972 32 progress progress NN 40436 6972 33 ? ? . 40436 6973 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6973 2 Prot._--Your Prot._--Your NNP 40436 6973 3 question question NN 40436 6973 4 is be VBZ 40436 6973 5 a a DT 40436 6973 6 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 6973 7 one one NN 40436 6973 8 , , , 40436 6973 9 and and CC 40436 6973 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6973 11 am be VBP 40436 6973 12 glad glad JJ 40436 6973 13 to to TO 40436 6973 14 reply reply VB 40436 6973 15 to to IN 40436 6973 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6973 17 . . . 40436 6974 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6974 2 shall shall MD 40436 6974 3 not not RB 40436 6974 4 throw throw VB 40436 6974 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6974 6 back back RB 40436 6974 7 -- -- : 40436 6974 8 as as IN 40436 6974 9 other other JJ 40436 6974 10 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 6974 11 do do VBP 40436 6974 12 , , , 40436 6974 13 with with IN 40436 6974 14 mischievous mischievous JJ 40436 6974 15 effect effect NN 40436 6974 16 -- -- : 40436 6974 17 into into IN 40436 6974 18 the the DT 40436 6974 19 special special JJ 40436 6974 20 sciences science NNS 40436 6974 21 , , , 40436 6974 22 geometry geometry NN 40436 6974 23 , , , 40436 6974 24 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 6974 25 , , , 40436 6974 26 astronomy astronomy NN 40436 6974 27 , , , 40436 6974 28 music music NN 40436 6974 29 , , , 40436 6974 30 & & CC 40436 6974 31 c. c. NNP 40436 6974 32 , , , 40436 6974 33 just just RB 40436 6974 34 after after IN 40436 6974 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6974 36 has have VBZ 40436 6974 37 completed complete VBN 40436 6974 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6974 39 course course NN 40436 6974 40 in in IN 40436 6974 41 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6974 42 . . . 40436 6975 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6975 2 shall shall MD 40436 6975 3 teach teach VB 40436 6975 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6975 5 what what WP 40436 6975 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6975 7 really really RB 40436 6975 8 comes come VBZ 40436 6975 9 to to TO 40436 6975 10 learn learn VB 40436 6975 11 : : : 40436 6975 12 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 6975 13 and and CC 40436 6975 14 good good JJ 40436 6975 15 counsel counsel NN 40436 6975 16 , , , 40436 6975 17 both both DT 40436 6975 18 respecting respect VBG 40436 6975 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6975 20 domestic domestic JJ 40436 6975 21 affairs affair NNS 40436 6975 22 , , , 40436 6975 23 that that IN 40436 6975 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6975 25 may may MD 40436 6975 26 manage manage VB 40436 6975 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6975 28 own own JJ 40436 6975 29 family family NN 40436 6975 30 well well RB 40436 6975 31 -- -- : 40436 6975 32 and and CC 40436 6975 33 respecting respect VBG 40436 6975 34 the the DT 40436 6975 35 affairs affair NNS 40436 6975 36 of of IN 40436 6975 37 the the DT 40436 6975 38 city city NN 40436 6975 39 , , , 40436 6975 40 that that IN 40436 6975 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6975 42 may may MD 40436 6975 43 address address VB 40436 6975 44 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 6975 45 to to IN 40436 6975 46 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6975 47 most most RBS 40436 6975 48 efficaciously efficaciously RB 40436 6975 49 , , , 40436 6975 50 both both CC 40436 6975 51 in in IN 40436 6975 52 speech speech NN 40436 6975 53 and and CC 40436 6975 54 act act NN 40436 6975 55 . . . 40436 6976 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6976 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 6976 3 speak speak NN 40436 6976 4 of of IN 40436 6976 5 political political JJ 40436 6976 6 or or CC 40436 6976 7 social social JJ 40436 6976 8 science science NN 40436 6976 9 . . . 40436 6977 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 6977 2 engage engage VBP 40436 6977 3 to to TO 40436 6977 4 make make VB 40436 6977 5 men man NNS 40436 6977 6 good good JJ 40436 6977 7 citizens citizen NNS 40436 6977 8 . . . 40436 6978 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6978 2 Prot._--Exactly Prot._--Exactly NNP 40436 6978 3 so so RB 40436 6978 4 . . . 40436 6979 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6979 2 22 22 CD 40436 6979 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6979 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6979 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6979 6 21 21 CD 40436 6979 7 : : : 40436 6979 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6979 9 , , , 40436 6979 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6979 11 . . . 40436 6980 1 p. p. NN 40436 6980 2 318 318 CD 40436 6980 3 A. a. NN 40436 6981 1 " " `` 40436 6981 2 Qui qui NN 40436 6981 3 ad ad NN 40436 6981 4 philosophorum philosophorum NN 40436 6981 5 scholas scholas NNP 40436 6981 6 venit venit NNP 40436 6981 7 , , , 40436 6981 8 quotidie quotidie NNP 40436 6981 9 secum secum NNP 40436 6981 10 aliquid aliquid NNP 40436 6981 11 boni boni NNP 40436 6981 12 ferat ferat NNP 40436 6981 13 : : : 40436 6981 14 aut aut NNP 40436 6981 15 sanior sanior NNP 40436 6981 16 domum domum NNP 40436 6981 17 redeat redeat NNP 40436 6981 18 , , , 40436 6981 19 aut aut NN 40436 6981 20 sanabilior sanabilior NN 40436 6981 21 . . . 40436 6981 22 " " '' 40436 6982 1 Seneca Seneca NNP 40436 6982 2 , , , 40436 6982 3 Epistol Epistol NNP 40436 6982 4 . . . 40436 6983 1 108 108 CD 40436 6983 2 , , , 40436 6983 3 p. p. NN 40436 6984 1 530 530 CD 40436 6984 2 . . . 40436 6984 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6985 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6985 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 6985 3 22 22 CD 40436 6985 4 : : : 40436 6985 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6985 6 , , , 40436 6985 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 6985 8 . . . 40436 6986 1 pp pp NNP 40436 6986 2 . . . 40436 6987 1 318 318 CD 40436 6987 2 - - SYM 40436 6987 3 319 319 CD 40436 6987 4 . . . 40436 6988 1 The the DT 40436 6988 2 declaration declaration NN 40436 6988 3 made make VBN 40436 6988 4 by by IN 40436 6988 5 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6988 6 -- -- : 40436 6988 7 that that IN 40436 6988 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6988 9 will will MD 40436 6988 10 not not RB 40436 6988 11 throw throw VB 40436 6988 12 back back RB 40436 6988 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6988 14 pupils pupil NNS 40436 6988 15 into into IN 40436 6988 16 the the DT 40436 6988 17 special special JJ 40436 6988 18 arts art NNS 40436 6988 19 -- -- : 40436 6988 20 is be VBZ 40436 6988 21 represented represent VBN 40436 6988 22 by by IN 40436 6988 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 6988 24 as as IN 40436 6988 25 intended intend VBN 40436 6988 26 to to TO 40436 6988 27 be be VB 40436 6988 28 an an DT 40436 6988 29 indirect indirect JJ 40436 6988 30 censure censure NN 40436 6988 31 on on IN 40436 6988 32 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 6988 33 , , , 40436 6988 34 then then RB 40436 6988 35 sitting sit VBG 40436 6988 36 by by IN 40436 6988 37 . . . 40436 6988 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6989 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6989 2 Side side NN 40436 6989 3 - - HYPH 40436 6989 4 note note NN 40436 6989 5 : : : 40436 6989 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 6989 7 doubts doubt NNS 40436 6989 8 whether whether IN 40436 6989 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 6989 10 is be VBZ 40436 6989 11 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6989 12 . . . 40436 6990 1 Reasons reason NNS 40436 6990 2 for for IN 40436 6990 3 such such JJ 40436 6990 4 doubt doubt NN 40436 6990 5 . . . 40436 6991 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 6991 2 is be VBZ 40436 6991 3 asked ask VBN 40436 6991 4 to to TO 40436 6991 5 explain explain VB 40436 6991 6 whether whether IN 40436 6991 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6991 8 is be VBZ 40436 6991 9 or or CC 40436 6991 10 not not RB 40436 6991 11 . . . 40436 6991 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6992 1 _ _ NNP 40436 6992 2 Sokr._--That Sokr._--That NNP 40436 6992 3 is be VBZ 40436 6992 4 a a DT 40436 6992 5 fine fine JJ 40436 6992 6 talent talent NN 40436 6992 7 indeed indeed RB 40436 6992 8 , , , 40436 6992 9 which which WDT 40436 6992 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6992 11 possess possess VBP 40436 6992 12 , , , 40436 6992 13 if if IN 40436 6992 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6992 15 _ _ NNP 40436 6992 16 do do VBP 40436 6992 17 _ _ NNP 40436 6992 18 possess possess VB 40436 6992 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6992 20 ; ; : 40436 6992 21 for for IN 40436 6992 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 6992 23 to to TO 40436 6992 24 speak speak VB 40436 6992 25 frankly frankly RB 40436 6992 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 6992 27 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6992 28 thought think VBD 40436 6992 29 that that IN 40436 6992 30 the the DT 40436 6992 31 thing thing NN 40436 6992 32 had have VBD 40436 6992 33 not not RB 40436 6992 34 been be VBN 40436 6992 35 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6992 36 , , , 40436 6992 37 nor nor CC 40436 6992 38 intentionally intentionally RB 40436 6992 39 communicable communicable JJ 40436 6992 40 , , , 40436 6992 41 by by IN 40436 6992 42 man man NN 40436 6992 43 to to IN 40436 6992 44 man man NN 40436 6992 45 . . . 40436 6993 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6993 2 23 23 CD 40436 6993 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6993 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6993 5 will will MD 40436 6993 6 tell tell VB 40436 6993 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 6993 8 why why WRB 40436 6993 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 6993 10 think think VBP 40436 6993 11 so so RB 40436 6993 12 . . . 40436 6994 1 The the DT 40436 6994 2 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 6994 3 are be VBP 40436 6994 4 universally universally RB 40436 6994 5 recognised recognise VBN 40436 6994 6 as as IN 40436 6994 7 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 6994 8 men man NNS 40436 6994 9 . . . 40436 6995 1 Now now RB 40436 6995 2 when when WRB 40436 6995 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6995 4 public public JJ 40436 6995 5 assembly assembly NN 40436 6995 6 is be VBZ 40436 6995 7 convened convene VBN 40436 6995 8 , , , 40436 6995 9 if if IN 40436 6995 10 the the DT 40436 6995 11 subject subject NN 40436 6995 12 of of IN 40436 6995 13 debate debate NN 40436 6995 14 be be VB 40436 6995 15 fortification fortification NN 40436 6995 16 , , , 40436 6995 17 ship ship NN 40436 6995 18 - - HYPH 40436 6995 19 building building NN 40436 6995 20 , , , 40436 6995 21 or or CC 40436 6995 22 any any DT 40436 6995 23 other other JJ 40436 6995 24 specialty specialty NN 40436 6995 25 which which WDT 40436 6995 26 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6995 27 regard regard VBP 40436 6995 28 as as IN 40436 6995 29 learnable learnable JJ 40436 6995 30 and and CC 40436 6995 31 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6995 32 , , , 40436 6995 33 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6995 34 will will MD 40436 6995 35 listen listen VB 40436 6995 36 to to IN 40436 6995 37 no no DT 40436 6995 38 one one NN 40436 6995 39 except except IN 40436 6995 40 a a DT 40436 6995 41 professional professional JJ 40436 6995 42 artist artist NN 40436 6995 43 or or CC 40436 6995 44 craftsman craftsman NN 40436 6995 45 . . . 40436 6996 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6996 2 24 24 CD 40436 6996 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6996 4 If if IN 40436 6996 5 any any DT 40436 6996 6 non non JJ 40436 6996 7 - - JJ 40436 6996 8 professional professional JJ 40436 6996 9 man man NN 40436 6996 10 presumes presume NNS 40436 6996 11 to to TO 40436 6996 12 advise advise VB 40436 6996 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6996 14 on on IN 40436 6996 15 the the DT 40436 6996 16 subject subject NN 40436 6996 17 , , , 40436 6996 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6996 19 refuse refuse VBP 40436 6996 20 to to TO 40436 6996 21 hear hear VB 40436 6996 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 6996 23 , , , 40436 6996 24 however however RB 40436 6996 25 rich rich JJ 40436 6996 26 and and CC 40436 6996 27 well well RB 40436 6996 28 - - HYPH 40436 6996 29 born bear VBN 40436 6996 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6996 31 may may MD 40436 6996 32 be be VB 40436 6996 33 . . . 40436 6997 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6997 2 is be VBZ 40436 6997 3 thus thus RB 40436 6997 4 that that IN 40436 6997 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6997 6 act act VBP 40436 6997 7 in in IN 40436 6997 8 matters matter NNS 40436 6997 9 of of IN 40436 6997 10 any any DT 40436 6997 11 special special JJ 40436 6997 12 art;[25 art;[25 NN 40436 6997 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6997 14 but but CC 40436 6997 15 when when WRB 40436 6997 16 the the DT 40436 6997 17 debate debate NN 40436 6997 18 turns turn VBZ 40436 6997 19 upon upon IN 40436 6997 20 the the DT 40436 6997 21 general general JJ 40436 6997 22 administration administration NN 40436 6997 23 of of IN 40436 6997 24 the the DT 40436 6997 25 city city NN 40436 6997 26 , , , 40436 6997 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6997 28 hear hear VBP 40436 6997 29 every every DT 40436 6997 30 man man NN 40436 6997 31 alike alike RB 40436 6997 32 -- -- : 40436 6997 33 the the DT 40436 6997 34 brass brass NN 40436 6997 35 - - HYPH 40436 6997 36 worker worker NN 40436 6997 37 , , , 40436 6997 38 leather leather NN 40436 6997 39 - - HYPH 40436 6997 40 cutter cutter NN 40436 6997 41 , , , 40436 6997 42 merchant merchant NN 40436 6997 43 , , , 40436 6997 44 navigator navigator NN 40436 6997 45 , , , 40436 6997 46 rich rich JJ 40436 6997 47 , , , 40436 6997 48 poor poor JJ 40436 6997 49 , , , 40436 6997 50 well well RB 40436 6997 51 - - HYPH 40436 6997 52 born bear VBN 40436 6997 53 , , , 40436 6997 54 low low RB 40436 6997 55 - - HYPH 40436 6997 56 born bear VBN 40436 6997 57 , , , 40436 6997 58 & & CC 40436 6997 59 c. c. NN 40436 6997 60 Against against IN 40436 6997 61 none none NN 40436 6997 62 of of IN 40436 6997 63 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6997 64 is be VBZ 40436 6997 65 any any DT 40436 6997 66 exception exception NN 40436 6997 67 taken take VBN 40436 6997 68 , , , 40436 6997 69 as as IN 40436 6997 70 in in IN 40436 6997 71 the the DT 40436 6997 72 former former JJ 40436 6997 73 case case NN 40436 6997 74 -- -- : 40436 6997 75 that that IN 40436 6997 76 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6997 77 comes come VBZ 40436 6997 78 to to TO 40436 6997 79 give give VB 40436 6997 80 advice advice NN 40436 6997 81 on on IN 40436 6997 82 that that DT 40436 6997 83 which which WDT 40436 6997 84 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6997 85 has have VBZ 40436 6997 86 not not RB 40436 6997 87 learnt learn VBN 40436 6997 88 , , , 40436 6997 89 and and CC 40436 6997 90 on on IN 40436 6997 91 which which WDT 40436 6997 92 he -PRON- PRP 40436 6997 93 has have VBZ 40436 6997 94 had have VBN 40436 6997 95 no no DT 40436 6997 96 master master NN 40436 6997 97 . . . 40436 6998 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 6998 2 26 26 CD 40436 6998 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 6998 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 6998 5 is be VBZ 40436 6998 6 plain plain JJ 40436 6998 7 that that IN 40436 6998 8 the the DT 40436 6998 9 public public NN 40436 6998 10 generally generally RB 40436 6998 11 think think VBP 40436 6998 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 6998 13 not not RB 40436 6998 14 teachable teachable JJ 40436 6998 15 . . . 40436 6999 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 6999 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6999 3 best good JJS 40436 6999 4 and and CC 40436 6999 5 wisest wise JJS 40436 6999 6 citizens citizen NNS 40436 6999 7 , , , 40436 6999 8 those those DT 40436 6999 9 who who WP 40436 6999 10 possess possess VBP 40436 6999 11 civic civic JJ 40436 6999 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 6999 13 in in IN 40436 6999 14 the the DT 40436 6999 15 highest high JJS 40436 6999 16 measure measure NN 40436 6999 17 , , , 40436 6999 18 can can MD 40436 6999 19 not not RB 40436 6999 20 communicate communicate VB 40436 6999 21 to to IN 40436 6999 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 6999 23 own own JJ 40436 6999 24 children child NNS 40436 6999 25 this this DT 40436 6999 26 same same JJ 40436 6999 27 virtue virtue NN 40436 6999 28 , , , 40436 6999 29 though though IN 40436 6999 30 they -PRON- PRP 40436 6999 31 cause cause VBP 40436 6999 32 them -PRON- PRP 40436 6999 33 to to TO 40436 6999 34 be be VB 40436 6999 35 taught teach VBN 40436 6999 36 all all PDT 40436 6999 37 those those DT 40436 6999 38 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 6999 39 which which WDT 40436 6999 40 paid pay VBD 40436 6999 41 masters master NNS 40436 6999 42 can can MD 40436 6999 43 impart impart VB 40436 6999 44 . . . 40436 7000 1 Periklês periklê NNS 40436 7000 2 and and CC 40436 7000 3 others other NNS 40436 7000 4 , , , 40436 7000 5 excellent excellent JJ 40436 7000 6 citizens citizen NNS 40436 7000 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7000 8 , , , 40436 7000 9 have have VBP 40436 7000 10 never never RB 40436 7000 11 been be VBN 40436 7000 12 able able JJ 40436 7000 13 to to TO 40436 7000 14 make make VB 40436 7000 15 any any DT 40436 7000 16 one one CD 40436 7000 17 else else RB 40436 7000 18 excellent excellent JJ 40436 7000 19 , , , 40436 7000 20 either either CC 40436 7000 21 in in IN 40436 7000 22 or or CC 40436 7000 23 out out IN 40436 7000 24 of of IN 40436 7000 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7000 26 own own JJ 40436 7000 27 family family NN 40436 7000 28 . . . 40436 7001 1 These these DT 40436 7001 2 reasons reason NNS 40436 7001 3 make make VBP 40436 7001 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7001 5 conclude conclude VB 40436 7001 6 that that IN 40436 7001 7 social social JJ 40436 7001 8 or or CC 40436 7001 9 political political JJ 40436 7001 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 7001 11 is be VBZ 40436 7001 12 not not RB 40436 7001 13 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7001 14 . . . 40436 7002 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7002 2 shall shall MD 40436 7002 3 be be VB 40436 7002 4 glad glad JJ 40436 7002 5 if if IN 40436 7002 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7002 7 can can MD 40436 7002 8 show show VB 40436 7002 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7002 10 that that IN 40436 7002 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7002 12 is be VBZ 40436 7002 13 so so RB 40436 7002 14 . . . 40436 7003 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7003 2 27 27 CD 40436 7003 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7003 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7003 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7003 6 23 23 CD 40436 7003 7 : : : 40436 7003 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7003 9 , , , 40436 7003 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7003 11 . . . 40436 7004 1 p. p. NN 40436 7004 2 319 319 CD 40436 7004 3 B. b. NN 40436 7005 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7005 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7005 3 : : : 40436 7005 4 ou ou NNP 40436 7005 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7005 6 didakto\n didakto\n ADD 40436 7005 7 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7005 8 , , , 40436 7005 9 mêd mêd NNP 40436 7005 10 ' ' `` 40436 7005 11 u(p u(p NNP 40436 7005 12 ' ' '' 40436 7005 13 a)nthrô a)nthrô CD 40436 7005 14 / / SYM 40436 7005 15 pôn pôn NNP 40436 7005 16 paraskeuasto\n paraskeuasto\n NNP 40436 7005 17 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 7005 18 / / SYM 40436 7005 19 pois pois NN 40436 7005 20 . . . 40436 7005 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7005 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7006 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7006 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7006 3 24 24 CD 40436 7006 4 : : : 40436 7006 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7006 6 , , , 40436 7006 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7006 8 . . . 40436 7007 1 p. p. NN 40436 7007 2 319 319 CD 40436 7007 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7007 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7007 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7007 6 : : : 40436 7007 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7007 8 ta)/lla ta)/lla NNP 40436 7007 9 pa pa NNP 40436 7007 10 / / SYM 40436 7007 11 nta nta NNP 40436 7007 12 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 7007 13 , , , 40436 7007 14 o(/sa o(/sa CC 40436 7007 15 ê(gou ê(gou NNP 40436 7007 16 = = SYM 40436 7007 17 ntai ntai NNP 40436 7007 18 mathêta/ mathêta/ NNP 40436 7007 19 te te NNP 40436 7007 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7007 21 didakta\ didakta\ NNP 40436 7007 22 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7007 23 . . . 40436 7008 1 e)a e)a NNP 40436 7008 2 / / SYM 40436 7008 3 n n NN 40436 7008 4 de/ de/ NN 40436 7008 5 tis tis NNP 40436 7008 6 a)/llos a)/llos NNP 40436 7008 7 e)picheirê=| e)picheirê=| ADD 40436 7008 8 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 7008 9 = = SYM 40436 7008 10 s s NNP 40436 7008 11 sumbouleu sumbouleu NNP 40436 7008 12 / / SYM 40436 7008 13 ein ein NNP 40436 7008 14 o(\n o(\n NNP 40436 7008 15 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 7008 16 = = SYM 40436 7008 17 noi noi NNP 40436 7008 18 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 7008 19 oi)/ontai oi)/ontai NNP 40436 7008 20 dêmiourgo\n dêmiourgo\n ADD 40436 7008 21 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7008 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7008 23 , , , 40436 7008 24 & & CC 40436 7008 25 c. c. NNP 40436 7008 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7008 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7008 28 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7008 29 25 25 CD 40436 7008 30 : : : 40436 7008 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7008 32 , , , 40436 7008 33 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7008 34 . . . 40436 7009 1 p. p. NN 40436 7009 2 319 319 CD 40436 7009 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7009 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7009 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7009 6 : : : 40436 7009 7 Peri\ Peri\ NNP 40436 7009 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7009 9 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 7009 10 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 7009 11 _ _ NNP 40436 7009 12 oi)/ontai oi)/ontai NNP 40436 7009 13 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7009 14 te te NNP 40436 7009 15 / / SYM 40436 7009 16 chnê| chnê| NNP 40436 7009 17 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7009 18 _ _ NNP 40436 7009 19 , , , 40436 7009 20 ou(/tô ou(/tô IN 40436 7009 21 diapra diapra NNP 40436 7009 22 / / SYM 40436 7009 23 ttontai ttontai NN 40436 7009 24 . . . 40436 7009 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7009 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7010 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7010 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7010 3 26 26 CD 40436 7010 4 : : : 40436 7010 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7010 6 , , , 40436 7010 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7010 8 . . . 40436 7011 1 p. p. NN 40436 7011 2 319 319 CD 40436 7011 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7011 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7011 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7011 6 : : : 40436 7011 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7011 8 tou tou NNP 40436 7011 9 / / SYM 40436 7011 10 tois tois NNP 40436 7011 11 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s NNP 40436 7011 12 tou tou NNP 40436 7011 13 = = SYM 40436 7011 14 to to IN 40436 7011 15 e)piplê e)piplê NNP 40436 7011 16 / / SYM 40436 7011 17 ssei ssei NN 40436 7011 18 ô(sper ô(sper RBR 40436 7011 19 toi toi NNP 40436 7011 20 = = SYM 40436 7011 21 s s FW 40436 7011 22 pro pro JJ 40436 7011 23 / / SYM 40436 7011 24 teron teron NN 40436 7011 25 , , , 40436 7011 26 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 7011 27 ou)damo ou)damo NNP 40436 7011 28 / / SYM 40436 7011 29 then then RB 40436 7011 30 mathô mathô NNP 40436 7011 31 / / SYM 40436 7011 32 n n JJ 40436 7011 33 , , , 40436 7011 34 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 7011 35 o)/ntos o)/ntos SYM 40436 7011 36 didaska didaska NNP 40436 7011 37 / / SYM 40436 7011 38 lou lou NNP 40436 7011 39 ou)deno\s ou)deno\s NNP 40436 7011 40 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 7011 41 , , , 40436 7011 42 e)/peita e)/peita NNP 40436 7011 43 sumbouleu sumbouleu NNP 40436 7011 44 / / SYM 40436 7011 45 ein ein NNP 40436 7011 46 e)picheirei= e)picheirei= NN 40436 7011 47 ; ; : 40436 7011 48 dê dê NN 40436 7011 49 = = SYM 40436 7011 50 lon lon NN 40436 7011 51 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7011 52 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 7011 53 ou)ch ou)ch JJR 40436 7011 54 ê(gou ê(gou NN 40436 7011 55 = = SYM 40436 7011 56 ntai ntai NNP 40436 7011 57 didakto\n didakto\n -LRB- 40436 7011 58 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7011 59 . . . 40436 7011 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7011 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7012 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7012 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7012 3 27 27 CD 40436 7012 4 : : : 40436 7012 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7012 6 , , , 40436 7012 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7012 8 . . . 40436 7013 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7013 2 . . . 40436 7014 1 319 319 CD 40436 7014 2 - - SYM 40436 7014 3 320 320 CD 40436 7014 4 . . . 40436 7014 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7015 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7015 2 Side side NN 40436 7015 3 - - HYPH 40436 7015 4 note note NN 40436 7015 5 : : : 40436 7015 6 Explanation Explanation NNP 40436 7015 7 of of IN 40436 7015 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7015 9 . . . 40436 7016 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7016 2 begins begin VBZ 40436 7016 3 with with IN 40436 7016 4 a a DT 40436 7016 5 mythe mythe NN 40436 7016 6 . . . 40436 7016 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7017 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7017 2 Prot._--I Prot._--I NNS 40436 7017 3 will will MD 40436 7017 4 readily readily RB 40436 7017 5 show show VB 40436 7017 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7017 7 . . . 40436 7018 1 But but CC 40436 7018 2 shall shall MD 40436 7018 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7018 4 , , , 40436 7018 5 like like IN 40436 7018 6 an an DT 40436 7018 7 old old JJ 40436 7018 8 man man NN 40436 7018 9 addressing address VBG 40436 7018 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7018 11 juniors junior NNS 40436 7018 12 , , , 40436 7018 13 recount recount VB 40436 7018 14 to to IN 40436 7018 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7018 16 an an DT 40436 7018 17 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 7018 18 mythe mythe NN 40436 7018 19 ? ? . 40436 7019 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7019 2 28 28 CD 40436 7019 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7019 4 or or CC 40436 7019 5 shall shall MD 40436 7019 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7019 7 go go VB 40436 7019 8 through through IN 40436 7019 9 an an DT 40436 7019 10 expository expository NN 40436 7019 11 discourse discourse NN 40436 7019 12 ? ? . 40436 7020 1 The the DT 40436 7020 2 mythe mythe NN 40436 7020 3 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 7020 4 will will MD 40436 7020 5 be be VB 40436 7020 6 the the DT 40436 7020 7 more more RBR 40436 7020 8 acceptable acceptable JJ 40436 7020 9 of of IN 40436 7020 10 the the DT 40436 7020 11 two two CD 40436 7020 12 . . . 40436 7021 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7021 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7021 3 28 28 CD 40436 7021 4 : : : 40436 7021 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7021 6 , , , 40436 7021 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7021 8 . . . 40436 7022 1 p. p. NN 40436 7022 2 320 320 CD 40436 7022 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7022 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7022 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7022 6 : : : 40436 7022 7 po po NNP 40436 7022 8 / / SYM 40436 7022 9 teron teron NN 40436 7022 10 u(mi u(mi NNP 40436 7022 11 = = SYM 40436 7022 12 n n NN 40436 7022 13 , , , 40436 7022 14 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7022 15 presbu presbu NN 40436 7022 16 / / SYM 40436 7022 17 teros tero NNS 40436 7022 18 neôte neôte NNP 40436 7022 19 / / SYM 40436 7022 20 rois rois NNP 40436 7022 21 , , , 40436 7022 22 mu mu NNP 40436 7022 23 = = SYM 40436 7022 24 thon thon NNP 40436 7022 25 le le NNP 40436 7022 26 / / SYM 40436 7022 27 gôn gôn NNP 40436 7022 28 e)pidei e)pidei NNPS 40436 7022 29 / / SYM 40436 7022 30 xô xô NNP 40436 7022 31 , , , 40436 7022 32 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7022 33 lo lo NNP 40436 7022 34 / / SYM 40436 7022 35 gô| gô| NNP 40436 7022 36 diexelthô diexelthô NNP 40436 7022 37 / / SYM 40436 7022 38 n n NN 40436 7022 39 ? ? . 40436 7022 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7023 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7023 2 is be VBZ 40436 7023 3 probable probable JJ 40436 7023 4 that that IN 40436 7023 5 the the DT 40436 7023 6 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 7023 7 often often RB 40436 7023 8 delivered deliver VBD 40436 7023 9 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 7023 10 mythes mythe NNS 40436 7023 11 or or CC 40436 7023 12 fables fable NNS 40436 7023 13 as as IN 40436 7023 14 a a DT 40436 7023 15 more more RBR 40436 7023 16 interesting interesting JJ 40436 7023 17 way way NN 40436 7023 18 of of IN 40436 7023 19 handling handle VBG 40436 7023 20 social social JJ 40436 7023 21 matters matter NNS 40436 7023 22 before before IN 40436 7023 23 an an DT 40436 7023 24 audience audience NN 40436 7023 25 . . . 40436 7024 1 Such such JJ 40436 7024 2 was be VBD 40436 7024 3 the the DT 40436 7024 4 memorable memorable JJ 40436 7024 5 fable fable NN 40436 7024 6 called call VBD 40436 7024 7 the the DT 40436 7024 8 choice choice NN 40436 7024 9 of of IN 40436 7024 10 Hêraklês Hêraklês NNP 40436 7024 11 by by IN 40436 7024 12 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7024 13 . . . 40436 7024 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7025 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7025 2 Side side NN 40436 7025 3 - - HYPH 40436 7025 4 note note NN 40436 7025 5 : : : 40436 7025 6 Mythe Mythe NNP 40436 7025 7 . . . 40436 7026 1 First first JJ 40436 7026 2 fabrication fabrication NN 40436 7026 3 of of IN 40436 7026 4 men man NNS 40436 7026 5 by by IN 40436 7026 6 the the DT 40436 7026 7 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 7026 8 . . . 40436 7027 1 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 7027 2 and and CC 40436 7027 3 Epimetheus Epimetheus NNP 40436 7027 4 . . . 40436 7028 1 Bad bad JJ 40436 7028 2 distribution distribution NN 40436 7028 3 of of IN 40436 7028 4 endowments endowment NNS 40436 7028 5 to to TO 40436 7028 6 man man VB 40436 7028 7 by by IN 40436 7028 8 the the DT 40436 7028 9 latter latter JJ 40436 7028 10 . . . 40436 7029 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7029 2 is be VBZ 40436 7029 3 partly partly RB 40436 7029 4 amended amend VBN 40436 7029 5 by by IN 40436 7029 6 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 7029 7 . . . 40436 7029 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7030 1 There there EX 40436 7030 2 was be VBD 40436 7030 3 once once RB 40436 7030 4 a a DT 40436 7030 5 time time NN 40436 7030 6 when when WRB 40436 7030 7 Gods Gods NNP 40436 7030 8 existed exist VBD 40436 7030 9 , , , 40436 7030 10 but but CC 40436 7030 11 neither neither DT 40436 7030 12 men man NNS 40436 7030 13 nor nor CC 40436 7030 14 animals animal NNS 40436 7030 15 had have VBD 40436 7030 16 yet yet RB 40436 7030 17 come come VBN 40436 7030 18 into into IN 40436 7030 19 existence existence NN 40436 7030 20 . . . 40436 7031 1 At at IN 40436 7031 2 the the DT 40436 7031 3 epoch epoch NN 40436 7031 4 prescribed prescribe VBN 40436 7031 5 by by IN 40436 7031 6 Fate Fate NNP 40436 7031 7 , , , 40436 7031 8 the the DT 40436 7031 9 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 7031 10 fabricated fabricate VBD 40436 7031 11 men man NNS 40436 7031 12 and and CC 40436 7031 13 animals animal NNS 40436 7031 14 in in IN 40436 7031 15 the the DT 40436 7031 16 interior interior NN 40436 7031 17 of of IN 40436 7031 18 the the DT 40436 7031 19 earth earth NN 40436 7031 20 , , , 40436 7031 21 out out IN 40436 7031 22 of of IN 40436 7031 23 earth earth NN 40436 7031 24 , , , 40436 7031 25 fire fire NN 40436 7031 26 , , , 40436 7031 27 and and CC 40436 7031 28 other other JJ 40436 7031 29 ingredients ingredient NNS 40436 7031 30 : : : 40436 7031 31 directing direct VBG 40436 7031 32 the the DT 40436 7031 33 brothers brother NNS 40436 7031 34 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 7031 35 and and CC 40436 7031 36 Epimetheus Epimetheus NNP 40436 7031 37 to to TO 40436 7031 38 fit fit VB 40436 7031 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7031 40 out out RP 40436 7031 41 with with IN 40436 7031 42 suitable suitable JJ 40436 7031 43 endowments endowment NNS 40436 7031 44 . . . 40436 7032 1 Epimetheus Epimetheus NNP 40436 7032 2 , , , 40436 7032 3 having have VBG 40436 7032 4 been be VBN 40436 7032 5 allowed allow VBN 40436 7032 6 by by IN 40436 7032 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7032 8 brother brother NN 40436 7032 9 to to TO 40436 7032 10 undertake undertake VB 40436 7032 11 the the DT 40436 7032 12 task task NN 40436 7032 13 of of IN 40436 7032 14 distributing distribute VBG 40436 7032 15 these these DT 40436 7032 16 endowments endowment NNS 40436 7032 17 , , , 40436 7032 18 did do VBD 40436 7032 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7032 20 work work NN 40436 7032 21 very very RB 40436 7032 22 improvidently improvidently RB 40436 7032 23 , , , 40436 7032 24 wasted waste VBD 40436 7032 25 all all PDT 40436 7032 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7032 27 gifts gift NNS 40436 7032 28 upon upon IN 40436 7032 29 the the DT 40436 7032 30 inferior inferior JJ 40436 7032 31 animals animal NNS 40436 7032 32 , , , 40436 7032 33 and and CC 40436 7032 34 left leave VBD 40436 7032 35 nothing nothing NN 40436 7032 36 for for IN 40436 7032 37 man man NN 40436 7032 38 . . . 40436 7033 1 When when WRB 40436 7033 2 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 7033 3 came come VBD 40436 7033 4 to to TO 40436 7033 5 inspect inspect VB 40436 7033 6 what what WP 40436 7033 7 had have VBD 40436 7033 8 been be VBN 40436 7033 9 done do VBN 40436 7033 10 , , , 40436 7033 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7033 12 found find VBD 40436 7033 13 that that IN 40436 7033 14 other other JJ 40436 7033 15 animals animal NNS 40436 7033 16 were be VBD 40436 7033 17 adequately adequately RB 40436 7033 18 equipped equip VBN 40436 7033 19 , , , 40436 7033 20 but but CC 40436 7033 21 that that DT 40436 7033 22 man man NN 40436 7033 23 had have VBD 40436 7033 24 no no DT 40436 7033 25 natural natural JJ 40436 7033 26 provision provision NN 40436 7033 27 for for IN 40436 7033 28 clothing clothing NN 40436 7033 29 , , , 40436 7033 30 shoeing shoe VBG 40436 7033 31 , , , 40436 7033 32 bedding bed VBG 40436 7033 33 , , , 40436 7033 34 or or CC 40436 7033 35 defence defence NN 40436 7033 36 . . . 40436 7034 1 The the DT 40436 7034 2 only only JJ 40436 7034 3 way way NN 40436 7034 4 whereby whereby WRB 40436 7034 5 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 7034 6 could could MD 40436 7034 7 supply supply VB 40436 7034 8 the the DT 40436 7034 9 defect defect NN 40436 7034 10 was be VBD 40436 7034 11 , , , 40436 7034 12 by by IN 40436 7034 13 breaking break VBG 40436 7034 14 into into IN 40436 7034 15 the the DT 40436 7034 16 common common JJ 40436 7034 17 workshop workshop NN 40436 7034 18 of of IN 40436 7034 19 Athênê Athênê NNP 40436 7034 20 and and CC 40436 7034 21 Hephæstus Hephæstus NNP 40436 7034 22 , , , 40436 7034 23 and and CC 40436 7034 24 stealing steal VBG 40436 7034 25 from from IN 40436 7034 26 thence thence NN 40436 7034 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7034 28 artistic artistic JJ 40436 7034 29 skill skill NN 40436 7034 30 , , , 40436 7034 31 together together RB 40436 7034 32 with with IN 40436 7034 33 fire fire NN 40436 7034 34 . . . 40436 7035 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7035 2 29 29 CD 40436 7035 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7035 4 Both both DT 40436 7035 5 of of IN 40436 7035 6 these these DT 40436 7035 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7035 8 presented present VBD 40436 7035 9 to to IN 40436 7035 10 man man NN 40436 7035 11 , , , 40436 7035 12 who who WP 40436 7035 13 was be VBD 40436 7035 14 thus thus RB 40436 7035 15 enabled enable VBN 40436 7035 16 to to TO 40436 7035 17 construct construct VB 40436 7035 18 for for IN 40436 7035 19 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7035 20 , , , 40436 7035 21 by by IN 40436 7035 22 art art NN 40436 7035 23 , , , 40436 7035 24 all all PDT 40436 7035 25 that that WDT 40436 7035 26 other other JJ 40436 7035 27 animals animal NNS 40436 7035 28 received receive VBN 40436 7035 29 from from IN 40436 7035 30 nature nature NN 40436 7035 31 and and CC 40436 7035 32 more more JJR 40436 7035 33 besides besides RB 40436 7035 34 . . . 40436 7036 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7036 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7036 3 29 29 CD 40436 7036 4 : : : 40436 7036 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7036 6 , , , 40436 7036 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7036 8 . . . 40436 7037 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7037 2 . . . 40436 7038 1 321 321 CD 40436 7038 2 - - SYM 40436 7038 3 322 322 CD 40436 7038 4 . . . 40436 7039 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7039 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7039 3 : : : 40436 7039 4 a)pori a)pori NNS 40436 7039 5 / / SYM 40436 7039 6 a| a| NN 40436 7039 7 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 7039 8 e)cho e)cho NNP 40436 7039 9 / / SYM 40436 7039 10 menos menos NNP 40436 7039 11 o o FW 40436 7039 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7039 13 Promêtheu\s Promêtheu\s NNP 40436 7039 14 ê(/ntina ê(/ntina NNP 40436 7039 15 sôtêri sôtêri NN 40436 7039 16 / / , 40436 7039 17 an an DT 40436 7039 18 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 7039 19 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 7039 20 / / SYM 40436 7039 21 pô| pô| NNP 40436 7039 22 eu(/roi eu(/roi NNP 40436 7039 23 , , , 40436 7039 24 kle kle NNP 40436 7039 25 / / SYM 40436 7039 26 ptei ptei NN 40436 7039 27 Ê(phai Ê(phai NNP 40436 7039 28 / / SYM 40436 7039 29 stou stou NNP 40436 7039 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7039 31 A)thêna A)thêna NNP 40436 7039 32 = = SYM 40436 7039 33 s s VBZ 40436 7039 34 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7039 35 e(/ntechnon e(/ntechnon NNP 40436 7039 36 sophi sophi NNS 40436 7039 37 / / , 40436 7039 38 an an DT 40436 7039 39 su\n su\n NNP 40436 7039 40 puri/. puri/. VBN 40436 7040 1 . . . 40436 7041 1 . . . 40436 7042 1 . . . 40436 7043 1 Tê\n Tê\n NNP 40436 7043 2 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7043 3 ou)=n ou)=n XX 40436 7043 4 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 7043 5 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7043 6 bi bi NNP 40436 7043 7 / / SYM 40436 7043 8 on on IN 40436 7043 9 sophi sophi NNP 40436 7043 10 / / , 40436 7043 11 an an DT 40436 7043 12 a)/nthrôpos a)/nthrôpos NNP 40436 7043 13 tau tau NNP 40436 7043 14 / / SYM 40436 7043 15 tê| tê| NNP 40436 7043 16 e)/sche e)/sche NN 40436 7043 17 , , , 40436 7043 18 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7043 19 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7043 20 politikê\n politikê\n VBZ 40436 7043 21 ou)k ou)k NN 40436 7043 22 ei)=chen ei)=chen '' 40436 7043 23 ; ; : 40436 7043 24 ê)=n ê)=n CC 40436 7043 25 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7043 26 para\ para\ NNP 40436 7043 27 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 7043 28 Di Di NNP 40436 7043 29 / / SYM 40436 7043 30 i+ i+ NNP 40436 7043 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7043 32 , , , 40436 7043 33 & & CC 40436 7043 34 c. c. NNP 40436 7043 35 If if IN 40436 7043 36 the the DT 40436 7043 37 reader reader NN 40436 7043 38 will will MD 40436 7043 39 compare compare VB 40436 7043 40 this this DT 40436 7043 41 with with IN 40436 7043 42 the the DT 40436 7043 43 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 7043 44 delivered deliver VBN 40436 7043 45 in in IN 40436 7043 46 the the DT 40436 7043 47 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7043 48 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 7043 49 -- -- : 40436 7043 50 that that IN 40436 7043 51 the the DT 40436 7043 52 inferior inferior JJ 40436 7043 53 animals animal NNS 40436 7043 54 spring spring VBP 40436 7043 55 from from IN 40436 7043 56 degenerate degenerate NN 40436 7043 57 men man NNS 40436 7043 58 -- -- : 40436 7043 59 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7043 60 will will MD 40436 7043 61 perceive perceive VB 40436 7043 62 the the DT 40436 7043 63 entire entire JJ 40436 7043 64 variance variance NN 40436 7043 65 between between IN 40436 7043 66 the the DT 40436 7043 67 two two CD 40436 7043 68 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7043 69 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 7043 70 , , , 40436 7043 71 pp pp NNP 40436 7043 72 . . . 40436 7044 1 91 91 CD 40436 7044 2 - - SYM 40436 7044 3 92 92 CD 40436 7044 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7044 5 . . . 40436 7044 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7045 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7045 2 Side side NN 40436 7045 3 - - HYPH 40436 7045 4 note note NN 40436 7045 5 : : : 40436 7045 6 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 7045 7 gave give VBD 40436 7045 8 to to IN 40436 7045 9 mankind mankind NN 40436 7045 10 skill skill NN 40436 7045 11 for for IN 40436 7045 12 the the DT 40436 7045 13 supply supply NN 40436 7045 14 of of IN 40436 7045 15 individual individual NN 40436 7045 16 wants want VBZ 40436 7045 17 , , , 40436 7045 18 but but CC 40436 7045 19 could could MD 40436 7045 20 not not RB 40436 7045 21 give give VB 40436 7045 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7045 23 the the DT 40436 7045 24 social social JJ 40436 7045 25 art art NN 40436 7045 26 . . . 40436 7046 1 Mankind mankind NN 40436 7046 2 are be VBP 40436 7046 3 on on IN 40436 7046 4 the the DT 40436 7046 5 point point NN 40436 7046 6 of of IN 40436 7046 7 perishing perish VBG 40436 7046 8 , , , 40436 7046 9 when when WRB 40436 7046 10 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 7046 11 sends send VBZ 40436 7046 12 to to IN 40436 7046 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7046 14 the the DT 40436 7046 15 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 7046 16 essential essential JJ 40436 7046 17 for for IN 40436 7046 18 society society NN 40436 7046 19 . . . 40436 7046 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7047 1 Still still RB 40436 7047 2 however however RB 40436 7047 3 , , , 40436 7047 4 mankind mankind NN 40436 7047 5 did do VBD 40436 7047 6 not not RB 40436 7047 7 possess possess VB 40436 7047 8 the the DT 40436 7047 9 political political JJ 40436 7047 10 or or CC 40436 7047 11 social social JJ 40436 7047 12 art art NN 40436 7047 13 ; ; : 40436 7047 14 which which WDT 40436 7047 15 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 7047 16 kept keep VBD 40436 7047 17 in in IN 40436 7047 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7047 19 own own JJ 40436 7047 20 custody custody NN 40436 7047 21 , , , 40436 7047 22 where where WRB 40436 7047 23 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 40436 7047 24 could could MD 40436 7047 25 not not RB 40436 7047 26 reach reach VB 40436 7047 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7047 28 . . . 40436 7048 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 7048 2 , , , 40436 7048 3 though though IN 40436 7048 4 mankind mankind NN 40436 7048 5 could could MD 40436 7048 6 provide provide VB 40436 7048 7 for for IN 40436 7048 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7048 9 as as IN 40436 7048 10 individuals individual NNS 40436 7048 11 , , , 40436 7048 12 yet yet CC 40436 7048 13 when when WRB 40436 7048 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7048 15 attempted attempt VBD 40436 7048 16 to to TO 40436 7048 17 form form VB 40436 7048 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7048 19 into into IN 40436 7048 20 communities community NNS 40436 7048 21 , , , 40436 7048 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7048 23 wronged wrong VBD 40436 7048 24 each each DT 40436 7048 25 other other JJ 40436 7048 26 so so RB 40436 7048 27 much much RB 40436 7048 28 , , , 40436 7048 29 from from IN 40436 7048 30 being be VBG 40436 7048 31 destitute destitute NN 40436 7048 32 of of IN 40436 7048 33 the the DT 40436 7048 34 political political JJ 40436 7048 35 or or CC 40436 7048 36 social social JJ 40436 7048 37 art art NN 40436 7048 38 , , , 40436 7048 39 that that IN 40436 7048 40 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7048 41 were be VBD 40436 7048 42 presently presently RB 40436 7048 43 forced force VBN 40436 7048 44 again again RB 40436 7048 45 into into IN 40436 7048 46 dispersion dispersion NN 40436 7048 47 . . . 40436 7049 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7049 2 30 30 CD 40436 7049 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7049 4 The the DT 40436 7049 5 art art NN 40436 7049 6 of of IN 40436 7049 7 war war NN 40436 7049 8 , , , 40436 7049 9 too too RB 40436 7049 10 , , , 40436 7049 11 being be VBG 40436 7049 12 a a DT 40436 7049 13 part part NN 40436 7049 14 of of IN 40436 7049 15 the the DT 40436 7049 16 political political JJ 40436 7049 17 art art NN 40436 7049 18 , , , 40436 7049 19 which which WDT 40436 7049 20 mankind mankind NN 40436 7049 21 did do VBD 40436 7049 22 not not RB 40436 7049 23 possess possess VB 40436 7049 24 -- -- : 40436 7049 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7049 26 could could MD 40436 7049 27 not not RB 40436 7049 28 get get VB 40436 7049 29 up up RP 40436 7049 30 a a DT 40436 7049 31 common common JJ 40436 7049 32 defence defence NN 40436 7049 33 against against IN 40436 7049 34 hostile hostile JJ 40436 7049 35 animals animal NNS 40436 7049 36 : : : 40436 7049 37 so so IN 40436 7049 38 that that IN 40436 7049 39 the the DT 40436 7049 40 human human JJ 40436 7049 41 race race NN 40436 7049 42 would would MD 40436 7049 43 have have VB 40436 7049 44 been be VBN 40436 7049 45 presently presently RB 40436 7049 46 destroyed destroy VBN 40436 7049 47 , , , 40436 7049 48 had have VBD 40436 7049 49 not not RB 40436 7049 50 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 7049 51 interposed interpose VBN 40436 7049 52 to to TO 40436 7049 53 avert avert VB 40436 7049 54 such such PDT 40436 7049 55 a a DT 40436 7049 56 consummation consummation NN 40436 7049 57 . . . 40436 7050 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7050 2 sent send VBD 40436 7050 3 Hermês Hermês NNP 40436 7050 4 to to IN 40436 7050 5 mankind mankind NN 40436 7050 6 , , , 40436 7050 7 bearing bear VBG 40436 7050 8 with with IN 40436 7050 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7050 10 Justice Justice NNP 40436 7050 11 and and CC 40436 7050 12 the the DT 40436 7050 13 sense sense NN 40436 7050 14 of of IN 40436 7050 15 Shame shame NN 40436 7050 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7050 17 or or CC 40436 7050 18 Moderation Moderation NNP 40436 7050 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7050 20 , , , 40436 7050 21 as as IN 40436 7050 22 the the DT 40436 7050 23 bonds bond NNS 40436 7050 24 and and CC 40436 7050 25 ornaments ornament NNS 40436 7050 26 of of IN 40436 7050 27 civic civic JJ 40436 7050 28 society society NN 40436 7050 29 , , , 40436 7050 30 coupling couple VBG 40436 7050 31 men man NNS 40436 7050 32 in in IN 40436 7050 33 friendship friendship NN 40436 7050 34 . . . 40436 7051 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7051 2 31 31 CD 40436 7051 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7051 4 Hermês Hermês NNP 40436 7051 5 asked ask VBD 40436 7051 6 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 7051 7 -- -- : 40436 7051 8 Upon upon IN 40436 7051 9 what what WDT 40436 7051 10 principle principle NN 40436 7051 11 shall shall MD 40436 7051 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7051 13 distribute distribute VB 40436 7051 14 these these DT 40436 7051 15 gifts gift NNS 40436 7051 16 among among IN 40436 7051 17 mankind mankind NN 40436 7051 18 ? ? . 40436 7052 1 Shall Shall MD 40436 7052 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7052 3 distribute distribute VB 40436 7052 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7052 5 in in IN 40436 7052 6 the the DT 40436 7052 7 same same JJ 40436 7052 8 way way NN 40436 7052 9 as as IN 40436 7052 10 artistic artistic JJ 40436 7052 11 skill skill NN 40436 7052 12 is be VBZ 40436 7052 13 distributed distribute VBN 40436 7052 14 , , , 40436 7052 15 only only RB 40436 7052 16 to to IN 40436 7052 17 a a DT 40436 7052 18 small small JJ 40436 7052 19 number number NN 40436 7052 20 -- -- : 40436 7052 21 a a DT 40436 7052 22 few few JJ 40436 7052 23 accomplished accomplished JJ 40436 7052 24 physicians physician NNS 40436 7052 25 , , , 40436 7052 26 navigators navigator NNS 40436 7052 27 , , , 40436 7052 28 & & CC 40436 7052 29 c. c. NNP 40436 7052 30 , , , 40436 7052 31 being be VBG 40436 7052 32 adequate adequate JJ 40436 7052 33 to to TO 40436 7052 34 supply supply VB 40436 7052 35 the the DT 40436 7052 36 wants want NNS 40436 7052 37 of of IN 40436 7052 38 the the DT 40436 7052 39 entire entire JJ 40436 7052 40 community community NN 40436 7052 41 ? ? . 40436 7053 1 Or or CC 40436 7053 2 are be VBP 40436 7053 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7053 4 to to TO 40436 7053 5 be be VB 40436 7053 6 apportioned apportion VBN 40436 7053 7 in in IN 40436 7053 8 a a DT 40436 7053 9 certain certain JJ 40436 7053 10 dose dose NN 40436 7053 11 to to IN 40436 7053 12 every every DT 40436 7053 13 man man NN 40436 7053 14 ? ? . 40436 7054 1 Undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 7054 2 , , , 40436 7054 3 to to IN 40436 7054 4 every every DT 40436 7054 5 man man NN 40436 7054 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7054 7 was be VBD 40436 7054 8 the the DT 40436 7054 9 command command NN 40436 7054 10 of of IN 40436 7054 11 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 7054 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7054 13 . . . 40436 7055 1 All all DT 40436 7055 2 without without IN 40436 7055 3 exception exception NN 40436 7055 4 must must MD 40436 7055 5 be be VB 40436 7055 6 partakers partaker NNS 40436 7055 7 in in IN 40436 7055 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7055 9 . . . 40436 7056 1 If if IN 40436 7056 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7056 3 are be VBP 40436 7056 4 confined confine VBN 40436 7056 5 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 7056 6 to to IN 40436 7056 7 a a DT 40436 7056 8 few few JJ 40436 7056 9 , , , 40436 7056 10 like like IN 40436 7056 11 artistic artistic JJ 40436 7056 12 or or CC 40436 7056 13 professional professional JJ 40436 7056 14 skill skill NN 40436 7056 15 , , , 40436 7056 16 no no DT 40436 7056 17 community community NN 40436 7056 18 can can MD 40436 7056 19 exist exist VB 40436 7056 20 . . . 40436 7057 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7057 2 32 32 CD 40436 7057 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7057 4 Ordain Ordain NNP 40436 7057 5 , , , 40436 7057 6 by by IN 40436 7057 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7057 8 authority authority NN 40436 7057 9 , , , 40436 7057 10 that that IN 40436 7057 11 every every DT 40436 7057 12 man man NN 40436 7057 13 , , , 40436 7057 14 who who WP 40436 7057 15 can can MD 40436 7057 16 not not RB 40436 7057 17 take take VB 40436 7057 18 a a DT 40436 7057 19 share share NN 40436 7057 20 of of IN 40436 7057 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7057 22 own own JJ 40436 7057 23 in in IN 40436 7057 24 justice justice NN 40436 7057 25 and and CC 40436 7057 26 the the DT 40436 7057 27 sense sense NN 40436 7057 28 of of IN 40436 7057 29 shame shame NN 40436 7057 30 , , , 40436 7057 31 shall shall MD 40436 7057 32 be be VB 40436 7057 33 slain slay VBN 40436 7057 34 , , , 40436 7057 35 as as IN 40436 7057 36 a a DT 40436 7057 37 nuisance nuisance NN 40436 7057 38 to to IN 40436 7057 39 the the DT 40436 7057 40 community community NN 40436 7057 41 . . . 40436 7058 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7058 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7058 3 30 30 CD 40436 7058 4 : : : 40436 7058 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7058 6 , , , 40436 7058 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7058 8 . . . 40436 7059 1 p. p. NN 40436 7059 2 322 322 CD 40436 7059 3 B. B. NNP 40436 7060 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7060 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7060 3 : : : 40436 7060 4 e)zê e)zê NNP 40436 7060 5 / / SYM 40436 7060 6 toun toun NNP 40436 7060 7 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 7060 8 a)throi a)throi , 40436 7060 9 / / SYM 40436 7060 10 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 7060 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7060 12 sô sô NNP 40436 7060 13 / / SYM 40436 7060 14 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 7060 15 kti kti NNP 40436 7060 16 / / SYM 40436 7060 17 zontes zontes NNPS 40436 7060 18 po po NNP 40436 7060 19 / / SYM 40436 7060 20 leis leis NNP 40436 7060 21 ; ; : 40436 7060 22 o(/t o(/t NNP 40436 7060 23 ' ' POS 40436 7060 24 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 7060 25 a)throisthei a)throisthei NNP 40436 7060 26 = = SYM 40436 7060 27 en en FW 40436 7060 28 , , , 40436 7060 29 ê)di ê)di JJ 40436 7060 30 / / SYM 40436 7060 31 koun koun NNP 40436 7060 32 a)llê a)llê NNS 40436 7060 33 / / SYM 40436 7060 34 lous lous JJ 40436 7060 35 , , , 40436 7060 36 a(/te a(/te NNP 40436 7060 37 ou)k ou)k NN 40436 7060 38 e)/chontes e)/chontes . 40436 7060 39 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7060 40 politikê\n politikê\n NNP 40436 7060 41 te te NNP 40436 7060 42 / / SYM 40436 7060 43 chnên chnên NNP 40436 7060 44 , , , 40436 7060 45 ô(/ste ô(/ste NNP 40436 7060 46 pa pa NNP 40436 7060 47 / / SYM 40436 7060 48 lin lin NNP 40436 7060 49 skedannu skedannu NNP 40436 7060 50 / / SYM 40436 7060 51 menoi menoi NNP 40436 7060 52 diephthei diephthei NNP 40436 7060 53 / / SYM 40436 7060 54 ronto ronto NNP 40436 7060 55 . . . 40436 7060 56 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7061 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 7061 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7061 3 , , , 40436 7061 4 Republic Republic NNP 40436 7061 5 , , , 40436 7061 6 i. i. NNP 40436 7061 7 p. p. NN 40436 7061 8 351 351 CD 40436 7061 9 C C NNP 40436 7061 10 , , , 40436 7061 11 p. p. NN 40436 7061 12 352 352 CD 40436 7061 13 B b NN 40436 7061 14 , , , 40436 7061 15 where where WRB 40436 7061 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7061 17 sets set VBZ 40436 7061 18 forth forth RB 40436 7061 19 a a DT 40436 7061 20 similar similar JJ 40436 7061 21 argument argument NN 40436 7061 22 . . . 40436 7061 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7062 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7062 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7062 3 31 31 CD 40436 7062 4 : : : 40436 7062 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7062 6 , , , 40436 7062 7 Protagor Protagor NNP 40436 7062 8 . . . 40436 7063 1 p. p. NN 40436 7063 2 322 322 CD 40436 7063 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7063 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7063 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7063 6 : : : 40436 7063 7 E(rmê e(rmê NN 40436 7063 8 = = SYM 40436 7063 9 n n NNP 40436 7063 10 pe pe NNP 40436 7063 11 / / SYM 40436 7063 12 mpei mpei NNP 40436 7063 13 a)/gonta a)/gonta NNP 40436 7063 14 ei)s ei)s NNP 40436 7063 15 a)nthrô a)nthrô CD 40436 7063 16 / / SYM 40436 7063 17 pous pous JJ 40436 7063 18 ai)dô= ai)dô= NNP 40436 7063 19 te te NNP 40436 7063 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7063 21 di di NNP 40436 7063 22 / / SYM 40436 7063 23 kên kên NNP 40436 7063 24 , , , 40436 7063 25 i(/n i(/n NNP 40436 7063 26 ' ' '' 40436 7063 27 ei)=en ei)=en NNP 40436 7063 28 po po NNP 40436 7063 29 / / SYM 40436 7063 30 leôn leôn NNP 40436 7063 31 ko ko NNP 40436 7063 32 / / SYM 40436 7063 33 smoi smoi NNP 40436 7063 34 te te NNP 40436 7063 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7063 36 desmoi\ desmoi\ NNP 40436 7063 37 phili phili NNP 40436 7063 38 / / SYM 40436 7063 39 as as IN 40436 7063 40 sunagôgoi/. sunagôgoi/. NNP 40436 7063 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7063 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7064 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7064 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7064 3 32 32 CD 40436 7064 4 : : : 40436 7064 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7064 6 , , , 40436 7064 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7064 8 . . . 40436 7065 1 p. p. NN 40436 7065 2 322 322 CD 40436 7065 3 C C NNP 40436 7065 4 - - HYPH 40436 7065 5 D. D. NNP 40436 7065 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7065 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7065 8 : : : 40436 7065 9 ei)=s ei)=s ADD 40436 7065 10 e)/chôn e)/chôn NNP 40436 7065 11 i)atrikê\n i)atrikê\n NNP 40436 7065 12 polloi polloi NNP 40436 7065 13 = = SYM 40436 7065 14 s s NNP 40436 7065 15 i(kano\s i(kano\s NNP 40436 7065 16 i)diô i)diô NNP 40436 7065 17 / / SYM 40436 7065 18 tais tais NNP 40436 7065 19 , , , 40436 7065 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7065 21 oi oi NNP 40436 7065 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7065 23 a)/lloi a)/lloi NNP 40436 7065 24 dêmiourgoi/. dêmiourgoi/. . 40436 7066 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7066 2 di di NNP 40436 7066 3 / / SYM 40436 7066 4 kên kên NNP 40436 7066 5 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 7066 6 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7066 7 ai)dô= ai)dô= NNP 40436 7066 8 ou(/tô ou(/tô IN 40436 7066 9 thô= thô= NNP 40436 7066 10 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7066 11 toi toi NNP 40436 7066 12 = = SYM 40436 7066 13 s s NNP 40436 7066 14 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 7066 15 / / SYM 40436 7066 16 pois pois NN 40436 7066 17 , , , 40436 7066 18 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7066 19 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7066 20 pa pa NNP 40436 7066 21 / / SYM 40436 7066 22 ntas ntas NNP 40436 7066 23 nei nei NNP 40436 7066 24 / / SYM 40436 7066 25 mô mô JJ 40436 7066 26 ? ? . 40436 7067 1 E)pi\ E)pi\ NNP 40436 7067 2 pa pa NNP 40436 7067 3 / / SYM 40436 7067 4 ntas ntas NNP 40436 7067 5 , , , 40436 7067 6 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 7067 7 o o NNP 40436 7067 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7067 9 Zeu Zeu NNP 40436 7067 10 / / SYM 40436 7067 11 s s NNP 40436 7067 12 , , , 40436 7067 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7067 14 pa pa NNP 40436 7067 15 / / SYM 40436 7067 16 ntes ntes NNP 40436 7067 17 metecho metecho NNP 40436 7067 18 / / SYM 40436 7067 19 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 7067 20 ; ; : 40436 7067 21 ou ou NNP 40436 7067 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7067 23 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7067 24 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 7067 25 ge ge NNP 40436 7067 26 / / SYM 40436 7067 27 nointo nointo NNP 40436 7067 28 po po NNP 40436 7067 29 / / SYM 40436 7067 30 leis leis NNP 40436 7067 31 , , , 40436 7067 32 ei ei NNP 40436 7067 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7067 34 o)li o)li NNP 40436 7067 35 / / SYM 40436 7067 36 goi goi NNP 40436 7067 37 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 7067 38 = = SYM 40436 7067 39 n n CC 40436 7067 40 mete mete NNP 40436 7067 41 / / SYM 40436 7067 42 choien choien NNP 40436 7067 43 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 7067 44 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 7067 45 technô technô NNP 40436 7067 46 = = SYM 40436 7067 47 n n XX 40436 7067 48 . . . 40436 7068 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7068 2 no no DT 40436 7068 3 / / SYM 40436 7068 4 mon mon NN 40436 7068 5 ge ge NNP 40436 7068 6 the\s the\s NNP 40436 7068 7 par par NN 40436 7068 8 ' ' '' 40436 7068 9 e)mou= e)mou= NN 40436 7068 10 , , , 40436 7068 11 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7068 12 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 7068 13 duna duna NNS 40436 7068 14 / / SYM 40436 7068 15 menon menon NNP 40436 7068 16 ai)doou ai)doou NNP 40436 7068 17 = = SYM 40436 7068 18 s s NNP 40436 7068 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7068 20 di di NNP 40436 7068 21 / / SYM 40436 7068 22 kês kês NNP 40436 7068 23 mete mete NNP 40436 7068 24 / / SYM 40436 7068 25 chein chein NNP 40436 7068 26 , , , 40436 7068 27 ktei ktei NNP 40436 7068 28 / / SYM 40436 7068 29 nein nein NNP 40436 7068 30 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7068 31 no no NNP 40436 7068 32 / / SYM 40436 7068 33 son son NN 40436 7068 34 po po NNP 40436 7068 35 / / SYM 40436 7068 36 leôs leôs NNP 40436 7068 37 . . . 40436 7068 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7069 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7069 2 see see VBP 40436 7069 3 by by IN 40436 7069 4 p. p. NN 40436 7069 5 323 323 CD 40436 7069 6 A a NN 40436 7069 7 that that WDT 40436 7069 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7069 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7069 10 : : : 40436 7069 11 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 7069 12 / / SYM 40436 7069 13 nê nê NNP 40436 7069 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7069 15 is be VBZ 40436 7069 16 employed employ VBN 40436 7069 17 as as IN 40436 7069 18 substitute substitute NN 40436 7069 19 or or CC 40436 7069 20 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 7069 21 for for IN 40436 7069 22 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7069 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7069 24 : : : 40436 7069 25 ai)dô ai)dô NNP 40436 7069 26 / / SYM 40436 7069 27 s s POS 40436 7069 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7069 29 : : : 40436 7069 30 yet yet CC 40436 7069 31 still still RB 40436 7069 32 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7069 33 Greek greek JJ 40436 7069 34 : : : 40436 7069 35 ai)dô\s ai)dô\s NNP 40436 7069 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7069 37 is be VBZ 40436 7069 38 the the DT 40436 7069 39 proper proper JJ 40436 7069 40 word word NN 40436 7069 41 to to TO 40436 7069 42 express express VB 40436 7069 43 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7069 44 's 's POS 40436 7069 45 meaning meaning NN 40436 7069 46 , , , 40436 7069 47 as as IN 40436 7069 48 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7069 49 denotes denote VBZ 40436 7069 50 a a DT 40436 7069 51 distinct distinct JJ 40436 7069 52 and and CC 40436 7069 53 positive positive JJ 40436 7069 54 regard regard NN 40436 7069 55 to to IN 40436 7069 56 the the DT 40436 7069 57 feelings feeling NNS 40436 7069 58 of of IN 40436 7069 59 others other NNS 40436 7069 60 -- -- : 40436 7069 61 a a DT 40436 7069 62 feeling feeling NN 40436 7069 63 of of IN 40436 7069 64 pain pain NN 40436 7069 65 in in IN 40436 7069 66 each each DT 40436 7069 67 man man NN 40436 7069 68 's 's POS 40436 7069 69 mind mind NN 40436 7069 70 , , , 40436 7069 71 when when WRB 40436 7069 72 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7069 73 discovers discover VBZ 40436 7069 74 or or CC 40436 7069 75 believes believe VBZ 40436 7069 76 that that IN 40436 7069 77 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7069 78 is be VBZ 40436 7069 79 disapproved disapprove VBN 40436 7069 80 by by IN 40436 7069 81 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7069 82 comrades comrade NNS 40436 7069 83 . . . 40436 7070 1 Hom hom UH 40436 7070 2 . . . 40436 7071 1 Il Il NNP 40436 7071 2 . . . 40436 7072 1 O. O. NNP 40436 7073 1 561 561 CD 40436 7073 2 - - HYPH 40436 7073 3 -[Greek -[greek NN 40436 7073 4 : : : 40436 7073 5 ai)dô= ai)dô= VB 40436 7073 6 the the DT 40436 7073 7 / / SYM 40436 7073 8 sth sth NN 40436 7073 9 ' ' '' 40436 7073 10 e)ni\ e)ni\ NNP 40436 7073 11 thumô=| thumô=| NNP 40436 7073 12 A)llê A)llê NNP 40436 7073 13 / / SYM 40436 7073 14 lous lous JJ 40436 7073 15 t t NN 40436 7073 16 ' ' '' 40436 7073 17 ai)dei ai)dei NNP 40436 7073 18 = = NFP 40436 7073 19 sthe sthe NN 40436 7073 20 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 7073 21 kratera\s kratera\s NNP 40436 7073 22 u(smi u(smi NNP 40436 7073 23 / / SYM 40436 7073 24 nas nas NNP 40436 7073 25 . . . 40436 7073 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7073 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7074 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7074 2 Side side NN 40436 7074 3 - - HYPH 40436 7074 4 note note NN 40436 7074 5 : : : 40436 7074 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7074 7 follows follow VBZ 40436 7074 8 up up RP 40436 7074 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7074 10 mythe mythe NN 40436 7074 11 by by IN 40436 7074 12 a a DT 40436 7074 13 discourse discourse NN 40436 7074 14 . . . 40436 7075 1 Justice justice NN 40436 7075 2 and and CC 40436 7075 3 the the DT 40436 7075 4 sense sense NN 40436 7075 5 of of IN 40436 7075 6 shame shame NN 40436 7075 7 are be VBP 40436 7075 8 not not RB 40436 7075 9 professional professional JJ 40436 7075 10 attributes attribute NNS 40436 7075 11 , , , 40436 7075 12 but but CC 40436 7075 13 are be VBP 40436 7075 14 possessed possess VBN 40436 7075 15 by by IN 40436 7075 16 all all DT 40436 7075 17 citizens citizen NNS 40436 7075 18 and and CC 40436 7075 19 taught teach VBN 40436 7075 20 by by IN 40436 7075 21 all all RB 40436 7075 22 to to IN 40436 7075 23 all all DT 40436 7075 24 . . . 40436 7075 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7076 1 This this DT 40436 7076 2 fable fable NN 40436 7076 3 will will MD 40436 7076 4 show show VB 40436 7076 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7076 6 , , , 40436 7076 7 therefore therefore RB 40436 7076 8 , , , 40436 7076 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7076 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7076 11 continues continue VBZ 40436 7076 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7076 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7076 14 , , , 40436 7076 15 that that IN 40436 7076 16 the the DT 40436 7076 17 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 7076 18 have have VBP 40436 7076 19 good good JJ 40436 7076 20 reason reason NN 40436 7076 21 for for IN 40436 7076 22 making make VBG 40436 7076 23 the the DT 40436 7076 24 distinction distinction NN 40436 7076 25 to to TO 40436 7076 26 which which WDT 40436 7076 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7076 28 advert advert VBP 40436 7076 29 . . . 40436 7077 1 When when WRB 40436 7077 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7077 3 are be VBP 40436 7077 4 discussing discuss VBG 40436 7077 5 matters matter NNS 40436 7077 6 of of IN 40436 7077 7 special special JJ 40436 7077 8 art art NN 40436 7077 9 , , , 40436 7077 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7077 11 will will MD 40436 7077 12 hear hear VB 40436 7077 13 only only RB 40436 7077 14 the the DT 40436 7077 15 few few JJ 40436 7077 16 to to TO 40436 7077 17 whom whom WP 40436 7077 18 such such JJ 40436 7077 19 matters matter NNS 40436 7077 20 are be VBP 40436 7077 21 known know VBN 40436 7077 22 . . . 40436 7078 1 But but CC 40436 7078 2 when when WRB 40436 7078 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7078 4 are be VBP 40436 7078 5 taking take VBG 40436 7078 6 counsel counsel NN 40436 7078 7 about about IN 40436 7078 8 social social JJ 40436 7078 9 or or CC 40436 7078 10 political political JJ 40436 7078 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 7078 12 , , , 40436 7078 13 which which WDT 40436 7078 14 consists consist VBZ 40436 7078 15 altogether altogether RB 40436 7078 16 in in IN 40436 7078 17 justice justice NN 40436 7078 18 and and CC 40436 7078 19 moderation moderation NN 40436 7078 20 , , , 40436 7078 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7078 22 naturally naturally RB 40436 7078 23 hear hear VBP 40436 7078 24 every every DT 40436 7078 25 one one NN 40436 7078 26 ; ; : 40436 7078 27 since since IN 40436 7078 28 every every DT 40436 7078 29 one one CD 40436 7078 30 is be VBZ 40436 7078 31 presumed presume VBN 40436 7078 32 , , , 40436 7078 33 as as IN 40436 7078 34 a a DT 40436 7078 35 condition condition NN 40436 7078 36 of of IN 40436 7078 37 the the DT 40436 7078 38 existence existence NN 40436 7078 39 of of IN 40436 7078 40 the the DT 40436 7078 41 commonwealth commonwealth NNP 40436 7078 42 , , , 40436 7078 43 to to TO 40436 7078 44 be be VB 40436 7078 45 a a DT 40436 7078 46 partaker partaker NN 40436 7078 47 therein therein RB 40436 7078 48 . . . 40436 7079 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7079 2 33 33 CD 40436 7079 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7079 4 Moreover moreover RB 40436 7079 5 , , , 40436 7079 6 even even RB 40436 7079 7 though though IN 40436 7079 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7079 9 know know VBP 40436 7079 10 a a DT 40436 7079 11 man man NN 40436 7079 12 not not RB 40436 7079 13 to to TO 40436 7079 14 have have VB 40436 7079 15 these these DT 40436 7079 16 virtues virtue NNS 40436 7079 17 in in IN 40436 7079 18 reality reality NN 40436 7079 19 , , , 40436 7079 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7079 21 treat treat VBP 40436 7079 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7079 23 as as RB 40436 7079 24 insane insane JJ 40436 7079 25 if if IN 40436 7079 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7079 27 does do VBZ 40436 7079 28 not not RB 40436 7079 29 proclaim proclaim VB 40436 7079 30 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7079 31 to to TO 40436 7079 32 have have VB 40436 7079 33 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7079 34 , , , 40436 7079 35 and and CC 40436 7079 36 make make VB 40436 7079 37 profession profession NN 40436 7079 38 of of IN 40436 7079 39 virtue virtue NN 40436 7079 40 : : : 40436 7079 41 whereas whereas IN 40436 7079 42 , , , 40436 7079 43 in in IN 40436 7079 44 the the DT 40436 7079 45 case case NN 40436 7079 46 of of IN 40436 7079 47 the the DT 40436 7079 48 special special JJ 40436 7079 49 arts art NNS 40436 7079 50 , , , 40436 7079 51 if if IN 40436 7079 52 a a DT 40436 7079 53 man man NN 40436 7079 54 makes make VBZ 40436 7079 55 proclamation proclamation NN 40436 7079 56 of of IN 40436 7079 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7079 58 own own JJ 40436 7079 59 skill skill NN 40436 7079 60 as as IN 40436 7079 61 a a DT 40436 7079 62 physician physician NN 40436 7079 63 or or CC 40436 7079 64 musician musician NN 40436 7079 65 , , , 40436 7079 66 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7079 67 censure censure VBP 40436 7079 68 or or CC 40436 7079 69 ridicule ridicule VBP 40436 7079 70 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7079 71 . . . 40436 7080 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7080 2 34 34 CD 40436 7080 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7080 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7080 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7080 6 33 33 CD 40436 7080 7 : : : 40436 7080 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7080 9 . . . 40436 7081 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7081 2 . . . 40436 7082 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7082 2 . . . 40436 7083 1 322 322 CD 40436 7083 2 - - SYM 40436 7083 3 323 323 NNP 40436 7083 4 . . . 40436 7083 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7084 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7084 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7084 3 34 34 CD 40436 7084 4 : : : 40436 7084 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7084 6 , , , 40436 7084 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7084 8 . . . 40436 7085 1 p. p. NN 40436 7085 2 323 323 CD 40436 7085 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7085 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7085 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7085 6 Side side NN 40436 7085 7 - - HYPH 40436 7085 8 note note NN 40436 7085 9 : : : 40436 7085 10 Constant constant JJ 40436 7085 11 teaching teaching NN 40436 7085 12 of of IN 40436 7085 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 7085 14 . . . 40436 7086 1 Theory theory NN 40436 7086 2 of of IN 40436 7086 3 punishment punishment NN 40436 7086 4 . . . 40436 7086 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7087 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 7087 2 , , , 40436 7087 3 though though IN 40436 7087 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7087 5 account account VBP 40436 7087 6 this this DT 40436 7087 7 political political JJ 40436 7087 8 or or CC 40436 7087 9 social social JJ 40436 7087 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 7087 11 an an DT 40436 7087 12 universal universal JJ 40436 7087 13 endowment endowment NN 40436 7087 14 , , , 40436 7087 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7087 16 are be VBP 40436 7087 17 far far RB 40436 7087 18 from from IN 40436 7087 19 thinking think VBG 40436 7087 20 that that IN 40436 7087 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7087 22 comes come VBZ 40436 7087 23 spontaneously spontaneously RB 40436 7087 24 or or CC 40436 7087 25 by by IN 40436 7087 26 nature nature NN 40436 7087 27 . . . 40436 7088 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 7088 2 conceive conceive VBP 40436 7088 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7088 4 to to TO 40436 7088 5 be be VB 40436 7088 6 generated generate VBN 40436 7088 7 by by IN 40436 7088 8 care care NN 40436 7088 9 and and CC 40436 7088 10 teaching teaching NN 40436 7088 11 . . . 40436 7089 1 For for IN 40436 7089 2 in in IN 40436 7089 3 respect respect NN 40436 7089 4 of of IN 40436 7089 5 all all PDT 40436 7089 6 those those DT 40436 7089 7 qualities quality NNS 40436 7089 8 which which WDT 40436 7089 9 come come VBP 40436 7089 10 by by IN 40436 7089 11 nature nature NN 40436 7089 12 or or CC 40436 7089 13 by by IN 40436 7089 14 accident accident NN 40436 7089 15 , , , 40436 7089 16 no no DT 40436 7089 17 one one NN 40436 7089 18 is be VBZ 40436 7089 19 ever ever RB 40436 7089 20 angry angry JJ 40436 7089 21 with with IN 40436 7089 22 another another DT 40436 7089 23 or or CC 40436 7089 24 blames blame VBZ 40436 7089 25 another another DT 40436 7089 26 for for IN 40436 7089 27 being be VBG 40436 7089 28 found find VBN 40436 7089 29 wanting want VBG 40436 7089 30 . . . 40436 7090 1 An an DT 40436 7090 2 ugly ugly JJ 40436 7090 3 , , , 40436 7090 4 dwarfish dwarfish JJ 40436 7090 5 , , , 40436 7090 6 or or CC 40436 7090 7 sickly sickly JJ 40436 7090 8 man man NN 40436 7090 9 is be VBZ 40436 7090 10 looked look VBN 40436 7090 11 upon upon IN 40436 7090 12 simply simply RB 40436 7090 13 with with IN 40436 7090 14 pity pity NN 40436 7090 15 , , , 40436 7090 16 because because IN 40436 7090 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7090 18 defects defect NNS 40436 7090 19 are be VBP 40436 7090 20 such such JJ 40436 7090 21 as as IN 40436 7090 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7090 23 can can MD 40436 7090 24 not not RB 40436 7090 25 help help VB 40436 7090 26 . . . 40436 7091 1 But but CC 40436 7091 2 when when WRB 40436 7091 3 any any DT 40436 7091 4 one one CD 40436 7091 5 manifests manifest VBZ 40436 7091 6 injustice injustice NN 40436 7091 7 or or CC 40436 7091 8 other other JJ 40436 7091 9 qualities quality NNS 40436 7091 10 the the DT 40436 7091 11 opposite opposite NN 40436 7091 12 of of IN 40436 7091 13 political political JJ 40436 7091 14 virtue virtue NN 40436 7091 15 , , , 40436 7091 16 then then RB 40436 7091 17 all all PDT 40436 7091 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7091 19 neighbours neighbour NNS 40436 7091 20 visit visit VBP 40436 7091 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7091 22 with with IN 40436 7091 23 indignation indignation NN 40436 7091 24 , , , 40436 7091 25 censure censure NN 40436 7091 26 , , , 40436 7091 27 and and CC 40436 7091 28 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 7091 29 punishment punishment NN 40436 7091 30 : : : 40436 7091 31 implying imply VBG 40436 7091 32 clearly clearly RB 40436 7091 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7091 34 belief belief NN 40436 7091 35 that that IN 40436 7091 36 this this DT 40436 7091 37 virtue virtue NN 40436 7091 38 is be VBZ 40436 7091 39 an an DT 40436 7091 40 acquirement acquirement NN 40436 7091 41 obtained obtain VBN 40436 7091 42 by by IN 40436 7091 43 care care NN 40436 7091 44 and and CC 40436 7091 45 learning learning NN 40436 7091 46 . . . 40436 7092 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7092 2 35 35 CD 40436 7092 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7092 4 Indeed indeed RB 40436 7092 5 the the DT 40436 7092 6 whole whole JJ 40436 7092 7 institution institution NN 40436 7092 8 of of IN 40436 7092 9 punishment punishment NN 40436 7092 10 has have VBZ 40436 7092 11 no no DT 40436 7092 12 other other JJ 40436 7092 13 meaning meaning NN 40436 7092 14 . . . 40436 7093 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7093 2 is be VBZ 40436 7093 3 in in IN 40436 7093 4 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7093 5 a a DT 40436 7093 6 proof proof NN 40436 7093 7 that that IN 40436 7093 8 men man NNS 40436 7093 9 think think VBP 40436 7093 10 social social JJ 40436 7093 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 7093 12 to to TO 40436 7093 13 be be VB 40436 7093 14 acquirable acquirable JJ 40436 7093 15 and and CC 40436 7093 16 acquired acquire VBN 40436 7093 17 . . . 40436 7094 1 For for IN 40436 7094 2 no no DT 40436 7094 3 rational rational JJ 40436 7094 4 man man NN 40436 7094 5 ever ever RB 40436 7094 6 punishes punish VBZ 40436 7094 7 malefactors malefactor NNS 40436 7094 8 because because IN 40436 7094 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7094 10 _ _ NNP 40436 7094 11 have have VBP 40436 7094 12 _ _ NNP 40436 7094 13 done do VBN 40436 7094 14 wrong wrong NN 40436 7094 15 , , , 40436 7094 16 or or CC 40436 7094 17 simply simply RB 40436 7094 18 with with IN 40436 7094 19 a a DT 40436 7094 20 view view NN 40436 7094 21 to to IN 40436 7094 22 the the DT 40436 7094 23 past:--since past:--since NNP 40436 7094 24 what what WP 40436 7094 25 is be VBZ 40436 7094 26 already already RB 40436 7094 27 done do VBN 40436 7094 28 can can MD 40436 7094 29 not not RB 40436 7094 30 be be VB 40436 7094 31 undone undo VBN 40436 7094 32 . . . 40436 7095 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7095 2 punishes punish VBZ 40436 7095 3 with with IN 40436 7095 4 a a DT 40436 7095 5 view view NN 40436 7095 6 to to IN 40436 7095 7 the the DT 40436 7095 8 future future NN 40436 7095 9 , , , 40436 7095 10 in in IN 40436 7095 11 order order NN 40436 7095 12 that that IN 40436 7095 13 neither neither CC 40436 7095 14 the the DT 40436 7095 15 same same JJ 40436 7095 16 man man NN 40436 7095 17 , , , 40436 7095 18 nor nor CC 40436 7095 19 others other NNS 40436 7095 20 who who WP 40436 7095 21 see see VBP 40436 7095 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7095 23 punished punish VBN 40436 7095 24 , , , 40436 7095 25 may may MD 40436 7095 26 be be VB 40436 7095 27 again again RB 40436 7095 28 guilty guilty JJ 40436 7095 29 of of IN 40436 7095 30 similar similar JJ 40436 7095 31 wrong wrong NN 40436 7095 32 . . . 40436 7096 1 This this DT 40436 7096 2 opinion opinion NN 40436 7096 3 plainly plainly RB 40436 7096 4 implies imply VBZ 40436 7096 5 the the DT 40436 7096 6 belief belief NN 40436 7096 7 , , , 40436 7096 8 that that DT 40436 7096 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 7096 10 is be VBZ 40436 7096 11 producible producible JJ 40436 7096 12 by by IN 40436 7096 13 training training NN 40436 7096 14 , , , 40436 7096 15 since since IN 40436 7096 16 men man NNS 40436 7096 17 punish punish VBP 40436 7096 18 for for IN 40436 7096 19 the the DT 40436 7096 20 purpose purpose NN 40436 7096 21 of of IN 40436 7096 22 prevention prevention NN 40436 7096 23 . . . 40436 7097 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7097 2 36 36 CD 40436 7097 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7097 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7097 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7097 6 35 35 CD 40436 7097 7 : : : 40436 7097 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7097 9 , , , 40436 7097 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7097 11 . . . 40436 7098 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7098 2 . . . 40436 7099 1 323 323 CD 40436 7099 2 - - SYM 40436 7099 3 324 324 CD 40436 7099 4 . . . 40436 7099 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7100 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7100 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7100 3 36 36 CD 40436 7100 4 : : : 40436 7100 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7100 6 , , , 40436 7100 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7100 8 . . . 40436 7101 1 p. p. NN 40436 7101 2 324 324 CD 40436 7101 3 A A NNP 40436 7101 4 - - HYPH 40436 7101 5 B. b. NN 40436 7102 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7102 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7102 3 : : : 40436 7102 4 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 7102 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7102 6 kola kola NNP 40436 7102 7 / / SYM 40436 7102 8 zei zei NNP 40436 7102 9 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 7102 10 a)dikou a)dikou ADD 40436 7102 11 = = SYM 40436 7102 12 ntas ntas FW 40436 7102 13 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7102 14 tou tou NNP 40436 7102 15 / / SYM 40436 7102 16 tô| tô| NNP 40436 7102 17 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7102 18 nou nou NN 40436 7102 19 = = SYM 40436 7102 20 n n NNP 40436 7102 21 e)/chôn e)/chôn NNP 40436 7102 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7102 23 tou tou NNP 40436 7102 24 / / SYM 40436 7102 25 tou tou NNP 40436 7102 26 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 7102 27 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 7102 28 ê)di ê)di NNP 40436 7102 29 / / SYM 40436 7102 30 kêsen kêsen NN 40436 7102 31 , , , 40436 7102 32 o(/stis o(/stis NNP 40436 7102 33 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 7102 34 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 7102 35 thêri thêri NN 40436 7102 36 / / , 40436 7102 37 on on IN 40436 7102 38 a)logi a)logi NNP 40436 7102 39 / / SYM 40436 7102 40 stôs stôs NNP 40436 7102 41 timôrei timôrei NN 40436 7102 42 = = SYM 40436 7102 43 tai tai NN 40436 7102 44 ; ; : 40436 7102 45 o o NN 40436 7102 46 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7102 47 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7102 48 meta\ meta\ NNP 40436 7102 49 lo lo NNP 40436 7102 50 / / SYM 40436 7102 51 gou gou NNP 40436 7102 52 e)picheirô e)picheirô NNP 40436 7102 53 = = SYM 40436 7102 54 n n NNP 40436 7102 55 kola kola NNP 40436 7102 56 / / SYM 40436 7102 57 zein zein NNP 40436 7102 58 ou ou NNP 40436 7102 59 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7102 60 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7102 61 parelêlutho parelêlutho NN 40436 7102 62 / / SYM 40436 7102 63 tos tos NNP 40436 7102 64 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 7102 65 a)dikê a)dikê NNP 40436 7102 66 / / SYM 40436 7102 67 matos matos NNP 40436 7102 68 timôrei timôrei NN 40436 7102 69 = = SYM 40436 7102 70 tai tai NNP 40436 7102 71 -- -- : 40436 7102 72 ou ou NNP 40436 7102 73 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7102 74 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7102 75 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 7102 76 to/ to/ CD 40436 7102 77 ge ge NNP 40436 7102 78 prachthe\n prachthe\n NNP 40436 7102 79 a)ge a)ge NNP 40436 7102 80 / / SYM 40436 7102 81 nêton nêton NNP 40436 7102 82 thei thei NNP 40436 7102 83 / / SYM 40436 7102 84 ê ê NNP 40436 7102 85 -- -- : 40436 7102 86 a)lla\ a)lla\ : 40436 7102 87 tou= tou= VB 40436 7102 88 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7102 89 / / SYM 40436 7102 90 llontos llontos NNP 40436 7102 91 cha cha NN 40436 7102 92 / / SYM 40436 7102 93 rin rin NNP 40436 7102 94 , , , 40436 7102 95 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 7102 96 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 7102 97 au)=this au)=this NNP 40436 7102 98 a)dikê a)dikê NNP 40436 7102 99 / / SYM 40436 7102 100 sê| sê| NNP 40436 7102 101 mê mê NNP 40436 7102 102 / / SYM 40436 7102 103 te te NNP 40436 7102 104 au)to\s au)to\s NNP 40436 7102 105 ou(=tos ou(=tos NN 40436 7102 106 mê mê NNP 40436 7102 107 / / SYM 40436 7102 108 te te NNP 40436 7102 109 a)/llos a)/llos NNP 40436 7102 110 o o NNP 40436 7102 111 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7102 112 tou tou NNP 40436 7102 113 = = SYM 40436 7102 114 ton ton NN 40436 7102 115 i)dô\n i)dô\n NNP 40436 7102 116 kolasthe kolasthe NNP 40436 7102 117 / / SYM 40436 7102 118 nta nta NNP 40436 7102 119 . . . 40436 7103 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7103 2 toiau toiau NNP 40436 7103 3 / / SYM 40436 7103 4 tên tên NNP 40436 7103 5 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 7103 6 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 7103 7 / / SYM 40436 7103 8 n n CD 40436 7103 9 ; ; : 40436 7103 10 _ _ NNP 40436 7103 11 a)potropê a)potropê NNP 40436 7103 12 = = SYM 40436 7103 13 s s NNP 40436 7103 14 gou gou NNP 40436 7103 15 = = SYM 40436 7103 16 n n CC 40436 7103 17 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 7103 18 kola kola NNP 40436 7103 19 / / SYM 40436 7103 20 zei zei NNP 40436 7103 21 _ _ NNP 40436 7103 22 . . . 40436 7103 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7104 1 This this DT 40436 7104 2 clear clear JJ 40436 7104 3 and and CC 40436 7104 4 striking striking JJ 40436 7104 5 exposition exposition NN 40436 7104 6 of of IN 40436 7104 7 the the DT 40436 7104 8 theory theory NN 40436 7104 9 of of IN 40436 7104 10 punishment punishment NN 40436 7104 11 is be VBZ 40436 7104 12 one one CD 40436 7104 13 of of IN 40436 7104 14 the the DT 40436 7104 15 most most RBS 40436 7104 16 memorable memorable JJ 40436 7104 17 passages passage NNS 40436 7104 18 in in IN 40436 7104 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7104 20 , , , 40436 7104 21 or or CC 40436 7104 22 in in IN 40436 7104 23 any any DT 40436 7104 24 ancient ancient JJ 40436 7104 25 author author NN 40436 7104 26 . . . 40436 7105 1 And and CC 40436 7105 2 if if IN 40436 7105 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7105 4 are be VBP 40436 7105 5 to to TO 40436 7105 6 believe believe VB 40436 7105 7 the the DT 40436 7105 8 words word NNS 40436 7105 9 which which WDT 40436 7105 10 immediately immediately RB 40436 7105 11 follow follow VBP 40436 7105 12 , , , 40436 7105 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7105 14 was be VBD 40436 7105 15 the the DT 40436 7105 16 theory theory NN 40436 7105 17 universally universally RB 40436 7105 18 accepted accept VBN 40436 7105 19 at at IN 40436 7105 20 that that DT 40436 7105 21 time--[Greek time--[greek CD 40436 7105 22 : : : 40436 7105 23 tau tau NNP 40436 7105 24 / / SYM 40436 7105 25 tên tên NNP 40436 7105 26 ou)=n ou)=n XX 40436 7105 27 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7105 28 do do VB 40436 7105 29 / / SYM 40436 7105 30 xan xan NNP 40436 7105 31 pa pa NNP 40436 7105 32 / / SYM 40436 7105 33 ntes ntes NNP 40436 7105 34 e)/chousin e)/chousin NNP 40436 7105 35 , , , 40436 7105 36 o(/soi o(/soi NN 40436 7105 37 per per IN 40436 7105 38 timôrou timôrou NNP 40436 7105 39 = = SYM 40436 7105 40 ntai ntai NNP 40436 7105 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7105 42 i)di i)di NNP 40436 7105 43 / / SYM 40436 7105 44 a| a| NN 40436 7105 45 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7105 46 dêmosi dêmosi NNP 40436 7105 47 / / SYM 40436 7105 48 a| a| NN 40436 7105 49 . . . 40436 7105 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7106 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 7106 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7106 3 , , , 40436 7106 4 Legg Legg NNP 40436 7106 5 . . . 40436 7107 1 xi xi NNP 40436 7107 2 . . . 40436 7108 1 p. p. NN 40436 7108 2 933 933 CD 40436 7108 3 , , , 40436 7108 4 where where WRB 40436 7108 5 the the DT 40436 7108 6 same same JJ 40436 7108 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 7108 8 is be VBZ 40436 7108 9 announced announce VBN 40436 7108 10 : : : 40436 7108 11 Seneca Seneca NNP 40436 7108 12 , , , 40436 7108 13 De De NNP 40436 7108 14 Irâ Irâ NNP 40436 7108 15 , , , 40436 7108 16 i. i. NNP 40436 7109 1 16 16 CD 40436 7109 2 . . . 40436 7110 1 " " `` 40436 7110 2 Nam nam JJ 40436 7110 3 , , , 40436 7110 4 ut ut UH 40436 7110 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7110 6 ait ait CC 40436 7110 7 , , , 40436 7110 8 nemo nemo NNP 40436 7110 9 prudens pruden NNS 40436 7110 10 punit punit NN 40436 7110 11 , , , 40436 7110 12 quia quia NNP 40436 7110 13 peccatum peccatum NNP 40436 7110 14 est est NNP 40436 7110 15 , , , 40436 7110 16 sed sed NNP 40436 7110 17 ne ne NNP 40436 7110 18 peccetur peccetur NNP 40436 7110 19 . . . 40436 7111 1 Revocari revocari JJ 40436 7111 2 enim enim NNP 40436 7111 3 præterita præterita NNP 40436 7111 4 non non NNP 40436 7111 5 possunt possunt NNP 40436 7111 6 : : : 40436 7111 7 futura futura NNP 40436 7111 8 prohibentur prohibentur NNP 40436 7111 9 . . . 40436 7111 10 " " '' 40436 7112 1 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 7112 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7112 3 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 7112 4 . . . 40436 7113 1 zum zum NNP 40436 7113 2 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7113 3 . . . 40436 7114 1 p. p. NN 40436 7114 2 423 423 CD 40436 7114 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7114 4 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 7114 5 a a DT 40436 7114 6 just just RB 40436 7114 7 encomium encomium NN 40436 7114 8 upon upon IN 40436 7114 9 this this DT 40436 7114 10 theory theory NN 40436 7114 11 of of IN 40436 7114 12 punishment punishment NN 40436 7114 13 , , , 40436 7114 14 which which WDT 40436 7114 15 , , , 40436 7114 16 as as IN 40436 7114 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7114 18 truly truly RB 40436 7114 19 observes observe VBZ 40436 7114 20 , , , 40436 7114 21 combines combine VBZ 40436 7114 22 together together RB 40436 7114 23 the the DT 40436 7114 24 purposes purpose NNS 40436 7114 25 declared declare VBD 40436 7114 26 in in IN 40436 7114 27 the the DT 40436 7114 28 two two CD 40436 7114 29 modern modern JJ 40436 7114 30 theories theory NNS 40436 7114 31 -- -- : 40436 7114 32 Reforming reform VBG 40436 7114 33 and and CC 40436 7114 34 Deterring Deterring NNP 40436 7114 35 . . . 40436 7115 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7115 2 says say VBZ 40436 7115 3 further far RBR 40436 7115 4 , , , 40436 7115 5 however however RB 40436 7115 6 , , , 40436 7115 7 that that IN 40436 7115 8 the the DT 40436 7115 9 same same JJ 40436 7115 10 theory theory NN 40436 7115 11 of of IN 40436 7115 12 punishment punishment NN 40436 7115 13 reappears reappear NNS 40436 7115 14 in in IN 40436 7115 15 the the DT 40436 7115 16 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 7115 17 , , , 40436 7115 18 which which WDT 40436 7115 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7115 20 do do VBP 40436 7115 21 not not RB 40436 7115 22 think think VB 40436 7115 23 exact exact JJ 40436 7115 24 . . . 40436 7116 1 The the DT 40436 7116 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 7116 3 of of IN 40436 7116 4 punishment punishment NN 40436 7116 5 , , , 40436 7116 6 as as IN 40436 7116 7 given give VBN 40436 7116 8 in in IN 40436 7116 9 the the DT 40436 7116 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 7116 11 , , , 40436 7116 12 is be VBZ 40436 7116 13 simply simply RB 40436 7116 14 to to TO 40436 7116 15 cure cure VB 40436 7116 16 a a DT 40436 7116 17 distempered distemper VBN 40436 7116 18 patient patient NN 40436 7116 19 of of IN 40436 7116 20 a a DT 40436 7116 21 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7116 22 distemper distemper NN 40436 7116 23 , , , 40436 7116 24 and and CC 40436 7116 25 thus thus RB 40436 7116 26 to to TO 40436 7116 27 confer confer VB 40436 7116 28 great great JJ 40436 7116 29 benefit benefit NN 40436 7116 30 on on IN 40436 7116 31 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7116 32 -- -- : 40436 7116 33 but but CC 40436 7116 34 without without IN 40436 7116 35 any any DT 40436 7116 36 allusion allusion NN 40436 7116 37 to to IN 40436 7116 38 tutelary tutelary JJ 40436 7116 39 results result NNS 40436 7116 40 as as IN 40436 7116 41 regards regard VBZ 40436 7116 42 society society NN 40436 7116 43 . . . 40436 7116 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7117 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7117 2 Side side NN 40436 7117 3 - - HYPH 40436 7117 4 note note NN 40436 7117 5 : : : 40436 7117 6 Why why WRB 40436 7117 7 eminent eminent JJ 40436 7117 8 men man NNS 40436 7117 9 can can MD 40436 7117 10 not not RB 40436 7117 11 make make VB 40436 7117 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7117 13 sons son NNS 40436 7117 14 eminent eminent JJ 40436 7117 15 . . . 40436 7117 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7118 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7118 2 come come VBP 40436 7118 3 now now RB 40436 7118 4 to to IN 40436 7118 5 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7118 6 remaining remain VBG 40436 7118 7 argument argument NN 40436 7118 8 , , , 40436 7118 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7118 10 . . . 40436 7119 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 7119 2 urge urge VBP 40436 7119 3 that that IN 40436 7119 4 citizens citizen NNS 40436 7119 5 of of IN 40436 7119 6 eminent eminent JJ 40436 7119 7 civil civil JJ 40436 7119 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 7119 9 can can MD 40436 7119 10 not not RB 40436 7119 11 communicate communicate VB 40436 7119 12 that that DT 40436 7119 13 virtue virtue NN 40436 7119 14 to to IN 40436 7119 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7119 16 own own JJ 40436 7119 17 sons son NNS 40436 7119 18 , , , 40436 7119 19 to to TO 40436 7119 20 whom whom WP 40436 7119 21 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 7119 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7119 23 secure secure VBP 40436 7119 24 all all PDT 40436 7119 25 the the DT 40436 7119 26 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 7119 27 which which WDT 40436 7119 28 masters master NNS 40436 7119 29 can can MD 40436 7119 30 teach teach VB 40436 7119 31 . . . 40436 7120 1 Now now RB 40436 7120 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7120 3 have have VBP 40436 7120 4 already already RB 40436 7120 5 shown show VBN 40436 7120 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7120 7 that that IN 40436 7120 8 civil civil JJ 40436 7120 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 7120 10 is be VBZ 40436 7120 11 the the DT 40436 7120 12 one one CD 40436 7120 13 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 7120 14 needful,[37 needful,[37 CD 40436 7120 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7120 16 which which WDT 40436 7120 17 every every DT 40436 7120 18 man man NN 40436 7120 19 without without IN 40436 7120 20 exception exception NN 40436 7120 21 must must MD 40436 7120 22 possess possess VB 40436 7120 23 , , , 40436 7120 24 on on IN 40436 7120 25 pain pain NN 40436 7120 26 of of IN 40436 7120 27 punishment punishment NN 40436 7120 28 or or CC 40436 7120 29 final final JJ 40436 7120 30 expulsion expulsion NN 40436 7120 31 , , , 40436 7120 32 if if IN 40436 7120 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7120 34 be be VBP 40436 7120 35 without without IN 40436 7120 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7120 37 . . . 40436 7121 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7121 2 have have VBP 40436 7121 3 shown show VBN 40436 7121 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7121 5 , , , 40436 7121 6 moreover moreover RB 40436 7121 7 that that IN 40436 7121 8 every every DT 40436 7121 9 one one NN 40436 7121 10 believes believe VBZ 40436 7121 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7121 12 to to TO 40436 7121 13 be be VB 40436 7121 14 communicable communicable JJ 40436 7121 15 by by IN 40436 7121 16 teaching teaching NN 40436 7121 17 and and CC 40436 7121 18 attention attention NN 40436 7121 19 . . . 40436 7122 1 How how WRB 40436 7122 2 can can MD 40436 7122 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7122 4 believe believe VB 40436 7122 5 then then RB 40436 7122 6 that that IN 40436 7122 7 these these DT 40436 7122 8 excellent excellent JJ 40436 7122 9 fathers father NNS 40436 7122 10 teach teach VBP 40436 7122 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7122 12 sons son NNS 40436 7122 13 other other JJ 40436 7122 14 things thing NNS 40436 7122 15 , , , 40436 7122 16 but but CC 40436 7122 17 do do VBP 40436 7122 18 not not RB 40436 7122 19 teach teach VB 40436 7122 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7122 21 this this DT 40436 7122 22 , , , 40436 7122 23 the the DT 40436 7122 24 want want NN 40436 7122 25 of of IN 40436 7122 26 which which WDT 40436 7122 27 entails entail VBZ 40436 7122 28 such such JJ 40436 7122 29 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7122 30 penalties penalty NNS 40436 7122 31 ? ? . 40436 7123 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7123 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7123 3 37 37 CD 40436 7123 4 : : : 40436 7123 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7123 6 , , , 40436 7123 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7123 8 . . . 40436 7124 1 p. p. NN 40436 7124 2 324 324 CD 40436 7124 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7124 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7124 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7124 6 : : : 40436 7124 7 Po Po NNP 40436 7124 8 / / SYM 40436 7124 9 teron teron NNP 40436 7124 10 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 7124 11 ti ti NNP 40436 7124 12 e(/n e(/n NNP 40436 7124 13 , , , 40436 7124 14 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7124 15 ou)k ou)k -RRB- 40436 7124 16 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 7124 17 , , , 40436 7124 18 ou)= ou)= JJ 40436 7124 19 a)nagkai a)nagkai NNP 40436 7124 20 = = SYM 40436 7124 21 on on IN 40436 7124 22 pa pa NNP 40436 7124 23 / / SYM 40436 7124 24 ntas ntas NNP 40436 7124 25 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 7124 26 poli poli NNP 40436 7124 27 / / SYM 40436 7124 28 tas tas NNP 40436 7124 29 mete mete NNP 40436 7124 30 / / SYM 40436 7124 31 chein chein NNP 40436 7124 32 , , , 40436 7124 33 ei)/per ei)/per RB 40436 7124 34 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7124 35 / / SYM 40436 7124 36 llei llei NNP 40436 7124 37 po po NNP 40436 7124 38 / / SYM 40436 7124 39 lis lis NNP 40436 7124 40 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7124 41 ? ? . 40436 7125 1 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7125 2 tou tou NNP 40436 7125 3 / / SYM 40436 7125 4 tô| tô| NNP 40436 7125 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7125 6 au(/tê au(/tê CD 40436 7125 7 lu lu NNP 40436 7125 8 / / SYM 40436 7125 9 etai etai NNP 40436 7125 10 ê ê NNP 40436 7125 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7125 12 a)pori a)pori NNP 40436 7125 13 / / SYM 40436 7125 14 a a DT 40436 7125 15 ê(\n ê(\n NNP 40436 7125 16 su\ su\ NNP 40436 7125 17 a)porei a)porei NNP 40436 7125 18 = = SYM 40436 7125 19 s s NNP 40436 7125 20 . . . 40436 7125 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7125 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7126 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7126 2 Side side NN 40436 7126 3 - - HYPH 40436 7126 4 note note NN 40436 7126 5 : : : 40436 7126 6 Teaching teaching NN 40436 7126 7 by by IN 40436 7126 8 parents parent NNS 40436 7126 9 , , , 40436 7126 10 schoolmaster schoolmaster NN 40436 7126 11 , , , 40436 7126 12 harpist harpist NN 40436 7126 13 , , , 40436 7126 14 laws law NNS 40436 7126 15 , , , 40436 7126 16 dikastery dikastery NN 40436 7126 17 , , , 40436 7126 18 & & CC 40436 7126 19 c. c. NNP 40436 7126 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7126 21 The the DT 40436 7126 22 fact fact NN 40436 7126 23 is be VBZ 40436 7126 24 , , , 40436 7126 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7126 26 _ _ NNP 40436 7126 27 do do VBP 40436 7126 28 _ _ NNP 40436 7126 29 teach teach VB 40436 7126 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7126 31 : : : 40436 7126 32 and and CC 40436 7126 33 that that IN 40436 7126 34 too too RB 40436 7126 35 with with IN 40436 7126 36 great great JJ 40436 7126 37 pains pain NNS 40436 7126 38 . . . 40436 7127 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7127 2 38 38 CD 40436 7127 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7127 4 They -PRON- PRP 40436 7127 5 begin begin VBP 40436 7127 6 to to TO 40436 7127 7 admonish admonish VB 40436 7127 8 and and CC 40436 7127 9 lecture lecture VB 40436 7127 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7127 11 children child NNS 40436 7127 12 , , , 40436 7127 13 from from IN 40436 7127 14 the the DT 40436 7127 15 earliest early JJS 40436 7127 16 years year NNS 40436 7127 17 . . . 40436 7128 1 Father Father NNP 40436 7128 2 , , , 40436 7128 3 mother mother NN 40436 7128 4 , , , 40436 7128 5 tutor tutor NN 40436 7128 6 , , , 40436 7128 7 nurse nurse NN 40436 7128 8 , , , 40436 7128 9 all all DT 40436 7128 10 vie vie NNP 40436 7128 11 with with IN 40436 7128 12 each each DT 40436 7128 13 other other JJ 40436 7128 14 to to TO 40436 7128 15 make make VB 40436 7128 16 the the DT 40436 7128 17 child child NN 40436 7128 18 as as RB 40436 7128 19 good good JJ 40436 7128 20 as as IN 40436 7128 21 possible possible JJ 40436 7128 22 : : : 40436 7128 23 by by IN 40436 7128 24 constantly constantly RB 40436 7128 25 telling tell VBG 40436 7128 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7128 27 on on IN 40436 7128 28 every every DT 40436 7128 29 occasion occasion NN 40436 7128 30 which which WDT 40436 7128 31 arises arise VBZ 40436 7128 32 , , , 40436 7128 33 This this DT 40436 7128 34 is be VBZ 40436 7128 35 right right JJ 40436 7128 36 -- -- : 40436 7128 37 That that DT 40436 7128 38 is be VBZ 40436 7128 39 wrong wrong JJ 40436 7128 40 -- -- . 40436 7128 41 This this DT 40436 7128 42 is be VBZ 40436 7128 43 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7128 44 -- -- : 40436 7128 45 That that DT 40436 7128 46 is be VBZ 40436 7128 47 mean mean JJ 40436 7128 48 -- -- . 40436 7128 49 This this DT 40436 7128 50 is be VBZ 40436 7128 51 holy holy JJ 40436 7128 52 -- -- . 40436 7128 53 That that DT 40436 7128 54 is be VBZ 40436 7128 55 unholy unholy JJ 40436 7128 56 -- -- : 40436 7128 57 Do do VBP 40436 7128 58 these these DT 40436 7128 59 things thing NNS 40436 7128 60 , , , 40436 7128 61 abstain abstain VBP 40436 7128 62 from from IN 40436 7128 63 those those DT 40436 7128 64 . . . 40436 7129 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7129 2 39 39 CD 40436 7129 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7129 4 If if IN 40436 7129 5 the the DT 40436 7129 6 child child NN 40436 7129 7 obeys obey VBZ 40436 7129 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7129 9 , , , 40436 7129 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7129 11 is be VBZ 40436 7129 12 well well JJ 40436 7129 13 : : : 40436 7129 14 if if IN 40436 7129 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7129 16 do do VBP 40436 7129 17 not not RB 40436 7129 18 , , , 40436 7129 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7129 20 straighten straighten VBP 40436 7129 21 or or CC 40436 7129 22 rectify rectify VBP 40436 7129 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7129 24 , , , 40436 7129 25 like like IN 40436 7129 26 a a DT 40436 7129 27 crooked crooked JJ 40436 7129 28 piece piece NN 40436 7129 29 of of IN 40436 7129 30 wood wood NN 40436 7129 31 , , , 40436 7129 32 by by IN 40436 7129 33 reproof reproof NN 40436 7129 34 and and CC 40436 7129 35 flogging flogging NN 40436 7129 36 . . . 40436 7130 1 Next next RB 40436 7130 2 , , , 40436 7130 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7130 4 send send VBP 40436 7130 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7130 6 to to IN 40436 7130 7 a a DT 40436 7130 8 schoolmaster schoolmaster NN 40436 7130 9 , , , 40436 7130 10 who who WP 40436 7130 11 teaches teach VBZ 40436 7130 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7130 13 letters letter NNS 40436 7130 14 and and CC 40436 7130 15 the the DT 40436 7130 16 harp harp NN 40436 7130 17 ; ; : 40436 7130 18 but but CC 40436 7130 19 who who WP 40436 7130 20 is be VBZ 40436 7130 21 enjoined enjoin VBN 40436 7130 22 to to TO 40436 7130 23 take take VB 40436 7130 24 still still RB 40436 7130 25 greater great JJR 40436 7130 26 pains pain NNS 40436 7130 27 in in IN 40436 7130 28 watching watch VBG 40436 7130 29 over over IN 40436 7130 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7130 31 orderly orderly JJ 40436 7130 32 behaviour behaviour NN 40436 7130 33 . . . 40436 7131 1 Here here RB 40436 7131 2 the the DT 40436 7131 3 youth youth NN 40436 7131 4 is be VBZ 40436 7131 5 put put VBN 40436 7131 6 to to TO 40436 7131 7 read read VB 40436 7131 8 , , , 40436 7131 9 learn learn VB 40436 7131 10 by by IN 40436 7131 11 heart heart NN 40436 7131 12 , , , 40436 7131 13 and and CC 40436 7131 14 recite recite VB 40436 7131 15 , , , 40436 7131 16 the the DT 40436 7131 17 compositions composition NNS 40436 7131 18 of of IN 40436 7131 19 able able JJ 40436 7131 20 poets poet NNS 40436 7131 21 ; ; , 40436 7131 22 full full JJ 40436 7131 23 of of IN 40436 7131 24 exhortations exhortation NNS 40436 7131 25 to to IN 40436 7131 26 excellence excellence NN 40436 7131 27 and and CC 40436 7131 28 of of IN 40436 7131 29 stirring stir VBG 40436 7131 30 examples example NNS 40436 7131 31 from from IN 40436 7131 32 the the DT 40436 7131 33 good good JJ 40436 7131 34 men man NNS 40436 7131 35 of of IN 40436 7131 36 past past JJ 40436 7131 37 times time NNS 40436 7131 38 . . . 40436 7132 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7132 2 40 40 CD 40436 7132 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7132 4 On on IN 40436 7132 5 the the DT 40436 7132 6 harp harp NN 40436 7132 7 also also RB 40436 7132 8 , , , 40436 7132 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7132 10 learns learn VBZ 40436 7132 11 the the DT 40436 7132 12 best good JJS 40436 7132 13 songs song NNS 40436 7132 14 , , , 40436 7132 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7132 16 conduct conduct NN 40436 7132 17 is be VBZ 40436 7132 18 strictly strictly RB 40436 7132 19 watched watch VBN 40436 7132 20 , , , 40436 7132 21 and and CC 40436 7132 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7132 23 emotions emotion NNS 40436 7132 24 are be VBP 40436 7132 25 disciplined discipline VBN 40436 7132 26 by by IN 40436 7132 27 the the DT 40436 7132 28 influence influence NN 40436 7132 29 of of IN 40436 7132 30 rhythmical rhythmical JJ 40436 7132 31 and and CC 40436 7132 32 regular regular JJ 40436 7132 33 measure measure NN 40436 7132 34 . . . 40436 7133 1 While while IN 40436 7133 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7133 3 mind mind NN 40436 7133 4 is be VBZ 40436 7133 5 thus thus RB 40436 7133 6 trained train VBN 40436 7133 7 to to IN 40436 7133 8 good good NN 40436 7133 9 , , , 40436 7133 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7133 11 is be VBZ 40436 7133 12 sent send VBN 40436 7133 13 besides besides RB 40436 7133 14 to to IN 40436 7133 15 the the DT 40436 7133 16 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 7133 17 trainer trainer NN 40436 7133 18 , , , 40436 7133 19 to to TO 40436 7133 20 render render VB 40436 7133 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7133 22 body body NN 40436 7133 23 a a DT 40436 7133 24 suitable suitable JJ 40436 7133 25 instrument instrument NN 40436 7133 26 for for IN 40436 7133 27 it,[41 it,[41 NNP 40436 7133 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7133 29 and and CC 40436 7133 30 to to TO 40436 7133 31 guard guard VB 40436 7133 32 against against IN 40436 7133 33 failure failure NN 40436 7133 34 of of IN 40436 7133 35 energy energy NN 40436 7133 36 under under IN 40436 7133 37 the the DT 40436 7133 38 obligations obligation NNS 40436 7133 39 of of IN 40436 7133 40 military military JJ 40436 7133 41 service service NN 40436 7133 42 . . . 40436 7134 1 If if IN 40436 7134 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7134 3 be be VB 40436 7134 4 the the DT 40436 7134 5 son son NN 40436 7134 6 of of IN 40436 7134 7 a a DT 40436 7134 8 wealthy wealthy JJ 40436 7134 9 man man NN 40436 7134 10 , , , 40436 7134 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7134 12 is be VBZ 40436 7134 13 sent send VBN 40436 7134 14 to to IN 40436 7134 15 such such JJ 40436 7134 16 training training NN 40436 7134 17 sooner soon RBR 40436 7134 18 , , , 40436 7134 19 and and CC 40436 7134 20 remains remain VBZ 40436 7134 21 in in IN 40436 7134 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7134 23 longer long RBR 40436 7134 24 . . . 40436 7135 1 As as RB 40436 7135 2 soon soon RB 40436 7135 3 as as IN 40436 7135 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7135 5 is be VBZ 40436 7135 6 released release VBN 40436 7135 7 from from IN 40436 7135 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7135 9 masters master NNS 40436 7135 10 , , , 40436 7135 11 the the DT 40436 7135 12 city city NN 40436 7135 13 publicly publicly RB 40436 7135 14 takes take VBZ 40436 7135 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7135 16 in in IN 40436 7135 17 hand hand NN 40436 7135 18 , , , 40436 7135 19 compelling compel VBG 40436 7135 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7135 21 to to TO 40436 7135 22 learn learn VB 40436 7135 23 the the DT 40436 7135 24 laws law NNS 40436 7135 25 prescribed prescribe VBN 40436 7135 26 by by IN 40436 7135 27 old old JJ 40436 7135 28 and and CC 40436 7135 29 good good JJ 40436 7135 30 lawgivers,[42 lawgivers,[42 '' 40436 7135 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7135 32 to to TO 40436 7135 33 live live VB 40436 7135 34 according accord VBG 40436 7135 35 to to IN 40436 7135 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7135 37 prescriptions prescription NNS 40436 7135 38 , , , 40436 7135 39 and and CC 40436 7135 40 to to TO 40436 7135 41 learn learn VB 40436 7135 42 both both DT 40436 7135 43 command command NN 40436 7135 44 and and CC 40436 7135 45 obedience obedience NN 40436 7135 46 , , , 40436 7135 47 on on IN 40436 7135 48 pain pain NN 40436 7135 49 of of IN 40436 7135 50 being be VBG 40436 7135 51 punished punish VBN 40436 7135 52 . . . 40436 7136 1 Such such JJ 40436 7136 2 then then RB 40436 7136 3 being be VBG 40436 7136 4 the the DT 40436 7136 5 care care NN 40436 7136 6 bestowed bestow VBN 40436 7136 7 , , , 40436 7136 8 both both CC 40436 7136 9 publicly publicly RB 40436 7136 10 and and CC 40436 7136 11 privately privately RB 40436 7136 12 , , , 40436 7136 13 to to TO 40436 7136 14 foster foster VB 40436 7136 15 virtue virtue NN 40436 7136 16 , , , 40436 7136 17 can can MD 40436 7136 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7136 19 really really RB 40436 7136 20 doubt doubt VB 40436 7136 21 , , , 40436 7136 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7136 23 , , , 40436 7136 24 whether whether IN 40436 7136 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7136 26 be be VB 40436 7136 27 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7136 28 ? ? . 40436 7137 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 7137 2 might may MD 40436 7137 3 much much RB 40436 7137 4 rather rather RB 40436 7137 5 wonder wonder VB 40436 7137 6 if if IN 40436 7137 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7137 8 were be VBD 40436 7137 9 not not RB 40436 7137 10 so so RB 40436 7137 11 . . . 40436 7138 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7138 2 43 43 CD 40436 7138 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7138 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7138 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7138 6 38 38 CD 40436 7138 7 : : : 40436 7138 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7138 9 , , , 40436 7138 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7138 11 . . . 40436 7139 1 p. p. NN 40436 7139 2 325 325 CD 40436 7139 3 B. b. NN 40436 7139 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7140 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7140 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7140 3 39 39 CD 40436 7140 4 : : : 40436 7140 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7140 6 , , , 40436 7140 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7140 8 . . . 40436 7141 1 p. p. NN 40436 7141 2 325 325 CD 40436 7141 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7141 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7141 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7141 6 : : : 40436 7141 7 par par NNP 40436 7141 8 ' ' '' 40436 7141 9 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 7141 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7141 11 e)/rgon e)/rgon NNP 40436 7141 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7141 13 lo lo NNP 40436 7141 14 / / SYM 40436 7141 15 gon gon NNP 40436 7141 16 dida dida NNP 40436 7141 17 / / SYM 40436 7141 18 skontes skonte NNS 40436 7141 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7141 20 e)ndeiknu e)ndeiknu NNP 40436 7141 21 / / SYM 40436 7141 22 menoi menoi NNP 40436 7141 23 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 7141 24 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7141 25 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7141 26 di di NNP 40436 7141 27 / / SYM 40436 7141 28 kaion kaion NN 40436 7141 29 , , , 40436 7141 30 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7141 31 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7141 32 a)/dikon a)/dikon NNP 40436 7141 33 , , , 40436 7141 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7141 35 to to IN 40436 7141 36 / / SYM 40436 7141 37 de de NNP 40436 7141 38 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7141 39 kalo kalo NNP 40436 7141 40 / / SYM 40436 7141 41 n n NNP 40436 7141 42 , , , 40436 7141 43 to to IN 40436 7141 44 / / SYM 40436 7141 45 de de NNP 40436 7141 46 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7141 47 ai)schro ai)schro NNP 40436 7141 48 / / SYM 40436 7141 49 n n NNP 40436 7141 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7141 51 , , , 40436 7141 52 & & CC 40436 7141 53 c. c. NNP 40436 7141 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7141 55 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7141 56 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7141 57 40 40 CD 40436 7141 58 : : : 40436 7141 59 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7141 60 , , , 40436 7141 61 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7141 62 . . . 40436 7142 1 p. p. NN 40436 7142 2 325 325 CD 40436 7142 3 E--326 e--326 NN 40436 7142 4 A. a. NN 40436 7143 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7143 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7143 3 : : : 40436 7143 4 paratithe paratithe JJ 40436 7143 5 / / SYM 40436 7143 6 asin asin NNP 40436 7143 7 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 7143 8 = = SYM 40436 7143 9 s s NNP 40436 7143 10 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7143 11 tô tô NN 40436 7143 12 = = NFP 40436 7143 13 n n NNP 40436 7143 14 ba ba NNP 40436 7143 15 / / SYM 40436 7143 16 thrôn thrôn NNP 40436 7143 17 a)naginô a)naginô NNPS 40436 7143 18 / / SYM 40436 7143 19 skein skein NNP 40436 7143 20 poiêtô poiêtô VBP 40436 7143 21 = = SYM 40436 7143 22 n n CC 40436 7143 23 a)gathô a)gathô CD 40436 7143 24 = = SYM 40436 7143 25 n n NNP 40436 7143 26 poiê poiê NNP 40436 7143 27 / / SYM 40436 7143 28 mata mata NNP 40436 7143 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7143 30 e)kmantha e)kmantha NNP 40436 7143 31 / / SYM 40436 7143 32 nein nein NNP 40436 7143 33 a)nagka a)nagka NNP 40436 7143 34 / / SYM 40436 7143 35 zousin zousin NNP 40436 7143 36 , , , 40436 7143 37 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7143 38 oi(=s oi(=s NN 40436 7143 39 pollai\ pollai\ . 40436 7143 40 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7143 41 nouthetê nouthetê NNP 40436 7143 42 / / SYM 40436 7143 43 seis seis NNP 40436 7143 44 e)/neisi e)/neisi NNP 40436 7143 45 , , , 40436 7143 46 pollai\ pollai\ NNP 40436 7143 47 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7143 48 die die NNP 40436 7143 49 / / SYM 40436 7143 50 xodoi xodoi NNP 40436 7143 51 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7143 52 e)/painoi e)/painoi NNP 40436 7143 53 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7143 54 e)gkô e)gkô NNP 40436 7143 55 / / SYM 40436 7143 56 mia mia NNP 40436 7143 57 palaiô palaiô NNP 40436 7143 58 = = SYM 40436 7143 59 n n CC 40436 7143 60 a)ndrô a)ndrô NNS 40436 7143 61 = = SYM 40436 7143 62 n n NN 40436 7143 63 a)gathô a)gathô CD 40436 7143 64 = = SYM 40436 7143 65 n n CC 40436 7143 66 , , , 40436 7143 67 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 7143 68 o o NNP 40436 7143 69 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7143 70 pai pai NNP 40436 7143 71 = = SYM 40436 7143 72 s s NNP 40436 7143 73 zêlô zêlô NNP 40436 7143 74 = = SYM 40436 7143 75 n n CC 40436 7143 76 mimê mimê NNP 40436 7143 77 = = SYM 40436 7143 78 tai tai NNP 40436 7143 79 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7143 80 o)re o)re NNP 40436 7143 81 / / SYM 40436 7143 82 gêtai gêtai NNP 40436 7143 83 toiou toiou NNP 40436 7143 84 = = SYM 40436 7143 85 tos tos NNP 40436 7143 86 gene gene NNP 40436 7143 87 / / SYM 40436 7143 88 sthai sthai NNP 40436 7143 89 . . . 40436 7143 90 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7143 91 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7144 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7144 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7144 3 41 41 CD 40436 7144 4 : : : 40436 7144 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7144 6 , , , 40436 7144 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7144 8 . . . 40436 7145 1 p. p. NN 40436 7145 2 326 326 CD 40436 7145 3 B. b. NN 40436 7146 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7146 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7146 3 : : : 40436 7146 4 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 7146 5 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 7146 6 sô sô NNP 40436 7146 7 / / SYM 40436 7146 8 mata mata NNP 40436 7146 9 belti belti NNP 40436 7146 10 / / SYM 40436 7146 11 ô ô NNP 40436 7146 12 e)/chontes e)/chontes NNP 40436 7146 13 u(pêretô u(pêretô NNP 40436 7146 14 = = NFP 40436 7146 15 si si VB 40436 7146 16 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 7146 17 dianoi dianoi NN 40436 7146 18 / / SYM 40436 7146 19 a| a| NN 40436 7146 20 chrêstê=| chrêstê=| NNP 40436 7146 21 ou)/sê| ou)/sê| NNP 40436 7146 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7146 23 , , , 40436 7146 24 & & CC 40436 7146 25 c. c. NNP 40436 7146 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7146 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7146 28 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7146 29 42 42 CD 40436 7146 30 : : : 40436 7146 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7146 32 , , , 40436 7146 33 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7146 34 . . . 40436 7147 1 p. p. NN 40436 7147 2 326 326 CD 40436 7147 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7147 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7147 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7147 6 : : : 40436 7147 7 no no UH 40436 7147 8 / / SYM 40436 7147 9 mous mous JJ 40436 7147 10 u(pogra u(pogra NNP 40436 7147 11 / / SYM 40436 7147 12 psasa psasa NNP 40436 7147 13 , , , 40436 7147 14 a)gathô a)gathô NNP 40436 7147 15 = = SYM 40436 7147 16 n n CC 40436 7147 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7147 18 palaiô palaiô NNP 40436 7147 19 = = SYM 40436 7147 20 n n CC 40436 7147 21 nomothetô nomothetô NNP 40436 7147 22 = = SYM 40436 7147 23 n n NNP 40436 7147 24 eu(rê eu(rê NNP 40436 7147 25 / / SYM 40436 7147 26 mata mata NNP 40436 7147 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7147 28 , , , 40436 7147 29 & & CC 40436 7147 30 c. c. NNP 40436 7147 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7147 32 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7147 33 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7147 34 43 43 CD 40436 7147 35 : : : 40436 7147 36 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7147 37 , , , 40436 7147 38 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7147 39 . . . 40436 7148 1 p. p. NN 40436 7148 2 326 326 CD 40436 7148 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7148 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7148 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7148 6 Side side NN 40436 7148 7 - - HYPH 40436 7148 8 note note NN 40436 7148 9 : : : 40436 7148 10 All all DT 40436 7148 11 learn learn VB 40436 7148 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 7148 13 from from IN 40436 7148 14 the the DT 40436 7148 15 same same JJ 40436 7148 16 teaching teaching NN 40436 7148 17 by by RB 40436 7148 18 all all DT 40436 7148 19 . . . 40436 7149 1 Whether whether IN 40436 7149 2 a a DT 40436 7149 3 learner learner NN 40436 7149 4 shall shall MD 40436 7149 5 acquire acquire VB 40436 7149 6 more more RBR 40436 7149 7 or or CC 40436 7149 8 less less JJR 40436 7149 9 of of IN 40436 7149 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7149 11 , , , 40436 7149 12 depends depend VBZ 40436 7149 13 upon upon IN 40436 7149 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7149 15 own own JJ 40436 7149 16 individual individual JJ 40436 7149 17 aptitude aptitude NN 40436 7149 18 . . . 40436 7149 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7150 1 How how WRB 40436 7150 2 does do VBZ 40436 7150 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7150 4 happen happen VB 40436 7150 5 , , , 40436 7150 6 then then RB 40436 7150 7 , , , 40436 7150 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7150 9 ask ask VBP 40436 7150 10 , , , 40436 7150 11 that that IN 40436 7150 12 excellent excellent JJ 40436 7150 13 men man NNS 40436 7150 14 so so RB 40436 7150 15 frequently frequently RB 40436 7150 16 have have VBP 40436 7150 17 worthless worthless JJ 40436 7150 18 sons son NNS 40436 7150 19 , , , 40436 7150 20 to to IN 40436 7150 21 whom whom WP 40436 7150 22 , , , 40436 7150 23 even even RB 40436 7150 24 with with IN 40436 7150 25 all all DT 40436 7150 26 virtue virtue NN 40436 7150 27 from from IN 40436 7150 28 these these DT 40436 7150 29 precautions precaution NNS 40436 7150 30 , , , 40436 7150 31 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7150 32 can can MD 40436 7150 33 not not RB 40436 7150 34 teach teach VB 40436 7150 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7150 36 own own JJ 40436 7150 37 virtue virtue NN 40436 7150 38 ? ? . 40436 7151 1 This this DT 40436 7151 2 is be VBZ 40436 7151 3 not not RB 40436 7151 4 surprising surprising JJ 40436 7151 5 , , , 40436 7151 6 when when WRB 40436 7151 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7151 8 recollect recollect VBP 40436 7151 9 what what WP 40436 7151 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7151 11 have have VBP 40436 7151 12 just just RB 40436 7151 13 said say VBN 40436 7151 14 -- -- : 40436 7151 15 That that IN 40436 7151 16 in in IN 40436 7151 17 regard regard NN 40436 7151 18 to to IN 40436 7151 19 social social JJ 40436 7151 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 7151 21 , , , 40436 7151 22 every every DT 40436 7151 23 man man NN 40436 7151 24 must must MD 40436 7151 25 be be VB 40436 7151 26 a a DT 40436 7151 27 craftsman craftsman NN 40436 7151 28 and and CC 40436 7151 29 producer producer NN 40436 7151 30 ; ; : 40436 7151 31 there there EX 40436 7151 32 must must MD 40436 7151 33 be be VB 40436 7151 34 no no DT 40436 7151 35 non non JJ 40436 7151 36 - - JJ 40436 7151 37 professional professional JJ 40436 7151 38 consumers consumer NNS 40436 7151 39 . . . 40436 7152 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7152 2 44 44 CD 40436 7152 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7152 4 All all DT 40436 7152 5 of of IN 40436 7152 6 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7152 7 are be VBP 40436 7152 8 interested interested JJ 40436 7152 9 in in IN 40436 7152 10 rendering render VBG 40436 7152 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7152 12 neighbours neighbour NNS 40436 7152 13 just just RB 40436 7152 14 and and CC 40436 7152 15 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 7152 16 , , , 40436 7152 17 as as RB 40436 7152 18 well well RB 40436 7152 19 as as IN 40436 7152 20 in in IN 40436 7152 21 keeping keep VBG 40436 7152 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7152 23 so so RB 40436 7152 24 . . . 40436 7153 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 7153 2 , , , 40436 7153 3 every every DT 40436 7153 4 one one NN 40436 7153 5 , , , 40436 7153 6 instead instead RB 40436 7153 7 of of IN 40436 7153 8 being be VBG 40436 7153 9 jealous jealous JJ 40436 7153 10 , , , 40436 7153 11 like like IN 40436 7153 12 a a DT 40436 7153 13 professional professional JJ 40436 7153 14 artist artist NN 40436 7153 15 , , , 40436 7153 16 of of IN 40436 7153 17 seeing see VBG 40436 7153 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7153 19 own own JJ 40436 7153 20 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 7153 21 diffused diffuse VBN 40436 7153 22 , , , 40436 7153 23 stands stand VBZ 40436 7153 24 forward forward RB 40436 7153 25 zealously zealously RB 40436 7153 26 in in IN 40436 7153 27 teaching teach VBG 40436 7153 28 justice justice NN 40436 7153 29 and and CC 40436 7153 30 virtue virtue NN 40436 7153 31 to to IN 40436 7153 32 every every DT 40436 7153 33 one one NN 40436 7153 34 else else RB 40436 7153 35 , , , 40436 7153 36 and and CC 40436 7153 37 in in IN 40436 7153 38 reproving reprove VBG 40436 7153 39 all all DT 40436 7153 40 short short JJ 40436 7153 41 - - HYPH 40436 7153 42 comers comer NNS 40436 7153 43 . . . 40436 7154 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7154 2 45 45 CD 40436 7154 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7154 4 Every every DT 40436 7154 5 man man NN 40436 7154 6 is be VBZ 40436 7154 7 a a DT 40436 7154 8 teacher teacher NN 40436 7154 9 of of IN 40436 7154 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 7154 11 to to IN 40436 7154 12 others other NNS 40436 7154 13 : : : 40436 7154 14 every every DT 40436 7154 15 man man NN 40436 7154 16 learns learn VBZ 40436 7154 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7154 18 virtue virtue NN 40436 7154 19 from from IN 40436 7154 20 such such JJ 40436 7154 21 general general JJ 40436 7154 22 teaching teaching NN 40436 7154 23 , , , 40436 7154 24 public public JJ 40436 7154 25 and and CC 40436 7154 26 private private JJ 40436 7154 27 . . . 40436 7155 1 The the DT 40436 7155 2 sons son NNS 40436 7155 3 of of IN 40436 7155 4 the the DT 40436 7155 5 best good JJS 40436 7155 6 men man NNS 40436 7155 7 learn learn VBP 40436 7155 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7155 9 in in IN 40436 7155 10 this this DT 40436 7155 11 way way NN 40436 7155 12 , , , 40436 7155 13 as as RB 40436 7155 14 well well RB 40436 7155 15 as as IN 40436 7155 16 others other NNS 40436 7155 17 . . . 40436 7156 1 The the DT 40436 7156 2 instruction instruction NN 40436 7156 3 of of IN 40436 7156 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7156 5 fathers father NNS 40436 7156 6 counts count VBZ 40436 7156 7 for for IN 40436 7156 8 comparatively comparatively RB 40436 7156 9 little little JJ 40436 7156 10 , , , 40436 7156 11 amidst amidst IN 40436 7156 12 such such JJ 40436 7156 13 universal universal JJ 40436 7156 14 and and CC 40436 7156 15 paramount paramount JJ 40436 7156 16 extraneous extraneous JJ 40436 7156 17 influence influence NN 40436 7156 18 ; ; : 40436 7156 19 so so IN 40436 7156 20 that that IN 40436 7156 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7156 22 depends depend VBZ 40436 7156 23 upon upon IN 40436 7156 24 the the DT 40436 7156 25 aptitude aptitude NN 40436 7156 26 and and CC 40436 7156 27 predispositions predisposition NNS 40436 7156 28 of of IN 40436 7156 29 the the DT 40436 7156 30 sons son NNS 40436 7156 31 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7156 32 , , , 40436 7156 33 whether whether IN 40436 7156 34 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7156 35 turn turn VBP 40436 7156 36 out out RP 40436 7156 37 better well RBR 40436 7156 38 or or CC 40436 7156 39 worse bad JJR 40436 7156 40 than than IN 40436 7156 41 others other NNS 40436 7156 42 . . . 40436 7157 1 The the DT 40436 7157 2 son son NN 40436 7157 3 of of IN 40436 7157 4 a a DT 40436 7157 5 superior superior JJ 40436 7157 6 man man NN 40436 7157 7 will will MD 40436 7157 8 often often RB 40436 7157 9 turn turn VB 40436 7157 10 out out RP 40436 7157 11 ill ill RB 40436 7157 12 ; ; : 40436 7157 13 while while IN 40436 7157 14 the the DT 40436 7157 15 son son NN 40436 7157 16 of of IN 40436 7157 17 a a DT 40436 7157 18 worthless worthless JJ 40436 7157 19 man man NN 40436 7157 20 will will MD 40436 7157 21 prove prove VB 40436 7157 22 meritorious meritorious JJ 40436 7157 23 . . . 40436 7158 1 So so RB 40436 7158 2 the the DT 40436 7158 3 case case NN 40436 7158 4 would would MD 40436 7158 5 be be VB 40436 7158 6 , , , 40436 7158 7 if if IN 40436 7158 8 playing play VBG 40436 7158 9 on on IN 40436 7158 10 the the DT 40436 7158 11 flute flute NN 40436 7158 12 were be VBD 40436 7158 13 the the DT 40436 7158 14 one one CD 40436 7158 15 thing thing NN 40436 7158 16 needful needful JJ 40436 7158 17 for for IN 40436 7158 18 all all DT 40436 7158 19 citizens citizen NNS 40436 7158 20 ; ; : 40436 7158 21 if if IN 40436 7158 22 every every DT 40436 7158 23 one one CD 40436 7158 24 taught teach VBD 40436 7158 25 and and CC 40436 7158 26 enforced enforce VBN 40436 7158 27 flute flute NN 40436 7158 28 - - HYPH 40436 7158 29 playing playing NN 40436 7158 30 upon upon IN 40436 7158 31 all all DT 40436 7158 32 others other NNS 40436 7158 33 , , , 40436 7158 34 and and CC 40436 7158 35 every every DT 40436 7158 36 one one NN 40436 7158 37 learnt learn VBZ 40436 7158 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7158 39 from from IN 40436 7158 40 the the DT 40436 7158 41 teaching teaching NN 40436 7158 42 of of IN 40436 7158 43 all all DT 40436 7158 44 others other NNS 40436 7158 45 . . . 40436 7159 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7159 2 46 46 CD 40436 7159 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7159 4 You -PRON- PRP 40436 7159 5 would would MD 40436 7159 6 find find VB 40436 7159 7 that that IN 40436 7159 8 the the DT 40436 7159 9 sons son NNS 40436 7159 10 of of IN 40436 7159 11 good good JJ 40436 7159 12 or or CC 40436 7159 13 bad bad JJ 40436 7159 14 flute flute NN 40436 7159 15 - - HYPH 40436 7159 16 players player NNS 40436 7159 17 would would MD 40436 7159 18 turn turn VB 40436 7159 19 out out RP 40436 7159 20 good good JJ 40436 7159 21 or or CC 40436 7159 22 bad bad JJ 40436 7159 23 , , , 40436 7159 24 not not RB 40436 7159 25 in in IN 40436 7159 26 proportion proportion NN 40436 7159 27 to to IN 40436 7159 28 the the DT 40436 7159 29 skill skill NN 40436 7159 30 of of IN 40436 7159 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7159 32 fathers father NNS 40436 7159 33 , , , 40436 7159 34 but but CC 40436 7159 35 according accord VBG 40436 7159 36 to to IN 40436 7159 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7159 38 own own JJ 40436 7159 39 natural natural JJ 40436 7159 40 aptitudes aptitude NNS 40436 7159 41 . . . 40436 7160 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 7160 2 would would MD 40436 7160 3 find find VB 40436 7160 4 however however RB 40436 7160 5 also also RB 40436 7160 6 , , , 40436 7160 7 that that IN 40436 7160 8 all all DT 40436 7160 9 of of IN 40436 7160 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7160 11 , , , 40436 7160 12 even even RB 40436 7160 13 the the DT 40436 7160 14 most most RBS 40436 7160 15 unskilful unskilful JJ 40436 7160 16 , , , 40436 7160 17 would would MD 40436 7160 18 be be VB 40436 7160 19 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 7160 20 flute flute NN 40436 7160 21 - - HYPH 40436 7160 22 players player NNS 40436 7160 23 , , , 40436 7160 24 if if IN 40436 7160 25 compared compare VBN 40436 7160 26 with with IN 40436 7160 27 men man NNS 40436 7160 28 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 7160 29 untaught untaught JJ 40436 7160 30 , , , 40436 7160 31 who who WP 40436 7160 32 had have VBD 40436 7160 33 gone go VBN 40436 7160 34 through through IN 40436 7160 35 no no DT 40436 7160 36 such such JJ 40436 7160 37 social social JJ 40436 7160 38 training training NN 40436 7160 39 . . . 40436 7161 1 So so RB 40436 7161 2 too too RB 40436 7161 3 , , , 40436 7161 4 in in IN 40436 7161 5 regard regard NN 40436 7161 6 to to IN 40436 7161 7 justice justice NN 40436 7161 8 and and CC 40436 7161 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 7161 10 . . . 40436 7162 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7162 2 47 47 CD 40436 7162 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7162 4 The the DT 40436 7162 5 very very RB 40436 7162 6 worst bad JJS 40436 7162 7 man man NN 40436 7162 8 brought bring VBN 40436 7162 9 up up RP 40436 7162 10 in in IN 40436 7162 11 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7162 12 society society NN 40436 7162 13 and and CC 40436 7162 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7162 15 public public JJ 40436 7162 16 and and CC 40436 7162 17 private private JJ 40436 7162 18 training training NN 40436 7162 19 , , , 40436 7162 20 would would MD 40436 7162 21 appear appear VB 40436 7162 22 to to IN 40436 7162 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7162 24 a a DT 40436 7162 25 craftsman craftsman NN 40436 7162 26 in in IN 40436 7162 27 these these DT 40436 7162 28 endowments endowment NNS 40436 7162 29 , , , 40436 7162 30 if if IN 40436 7162 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7162 32 compared compare VBD 40436 7162 33 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7162 34 with with IN 40436 7162 35 men man NNS 40436 7162 36 who who WP 40436 7162 37 had have VBD 40436 7162 38 been be VBN 40436 7162 39 brought bring VBN 40436 7162 40 up up RP 40436 7162 41 without without IN 40436 7162 42 education education NN 40436 7162 43 , , , 40436 7162 44 without without IN 40436 7162 45 laws law NNS 40436 7162 46 , , , 40436 7162 47 without without IN 40436 7162 48 dikasteries dikasterie NNS 40436 7162 49 , , , 40436 7162 50 without without IN 40436 7162 51 any any DT 40436 7162 52 general general JJ 40436 7162 53 social social JJ 40436 7162 54 pressure pressure NN 40436 7162 55 bearing bear VBG 40436 7162 56 on on IN 40436 7162 57 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7162 58 , , , 40436 7162 59 to to TO 40436 7162 60 enforce enforce VB 40436 7162 61 virtue virtue NNP 40436 7162 62 : : : 40436 7162 63 such such JJ 40436 7162 64 men man NNS 40436 7162 65 as as IN 40436 7162 66 the the DT 40436 7162 67 savages savage NNS 40436 7162 68 exhibited exhibit VBD 40436 7162 69 last last JJ 40436 7162 70 year year NN 40436 7162 71 in in IN 40436 7162 72 the the DT 40436 7162 73 comedy comedy NN 40436 7162 74 of of IN 40436 7162 75 Pherekrates Pherekrates NNPS 40436 7162 76 at at IN 40436 7162 77 the the DT 40436 7162 78 Lenæan Lenæan NNP 40436 7162 79 festival festival NN 40436 7162 80 . . . 40436 7163 1 If if IN 40436 7163 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7163 3 were be VBD 40436 7163 4 thrown throw VBN 40436 7163 5 among among IN 40436 7163 6 such such JJ 40436 7163 7 men man NNS 40436 7163 8 , , , 40436 7163 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7163 10 , , , 40436 7163 11 like like IN 40436 7163 12 the the DT 40436 7163 13 chorus chorus NN 40436 7163 14 of of IN 40436 7163 15 misanthropes misanthrope NNS 40436 7163 16 in in IN 40436 7163 17 that that DT 40436 7163 18 play play NN 40436 7163 19 , , , 40436 7163 20 would would MD 40436 7163 21 look look VB 40436 7163 22 back back RB 40436 7163 23 with with IN 40436 7163 24 regret regret NN 40436 7163 25 even even RB 40436 7163 26 upon upon IN 40436 7163 27 the the DT 40436 7163 28 worst bad JJS 40436 7163 29 criminals criminal NNS 40436 7163 30 of of IN 40436 7163 31 the the DT 40436 7163 32 society society NN 40436 7163 33 which which WDT 40436 7163 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7163 35 had have VBD 40436 7163 36 left leave VBN 40436 7163 37 , , , 40436 7163 38 such such JJ 40436 7163 39 as as IN 40436 7163 40 Eurybatus Eurybatus NNP 40436 7163 41 and and CC 40436 7163 42 Phrynondas Phrynondas NNP 40436 7163 43 . . . 40436 7164 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7164 2 48 48 CD 40436 7164 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7164 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7164 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7164 6 44 44 CD 40436 7164 7 : : : 40436 7164 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7164 9 , , , 40436 7164 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7164 11 . . . 40436 7165 1 p. p. NN 40436 7165 2 326 326 CD 40436 7165 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7165 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7165 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7165 6 : : : 40436 7165 7 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 7165 8 tou tou NNP 40436 7165 9 / / SYM 40436 7165 10 tou tou NNP 40436 7165 11 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7165 12 pra pra NNP 40436 7165 13 / / SYM 40436 7165 14 gmatos gmato NNS 40436 7165 15 , , , 40436 7165 16 tê tê NNP 40436 7165 17 = = SYM 40436 7165 18 s s NNP 40436 7165 19 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 7165 20 = = SYM 40436 7165 21 s s NNP 40436 7165 22 , , , 40436 7165 23 ei ei NNP 40436 7165 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7165 25 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7165 26 / / SYM 40436 7165 27 llei llei NNP 40436 7165 28 po po NNP 40436 7165 29 / / SYM 40436 7165 30 lis lis NNP 40436 7165 31 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 7165 32 , , , 40436 7165 33 ou)de ou)de NNPS 40436 7165 34 / / SYM 40436 7165 35 na na IN 40436 7165 36 dei= dei= NNP 40436 7165 37 _ _ NNP 40436 7165 38 i)diôteu i)diôteu , 40436 7165 39 / / SYM 40436 7165 40 ein ein NNP 40436 7165 41 _ _ NNP 40436 7165 42 . . . 40436 7165 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7166 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7166 2 is be VBZ 40436 7166 3 to to TO 40436 7166 4 be be VB 40436 7166 5 regretted regret VBN 40436 7166 6 that that IN 40436 7166 7 there there EX 40436 7166 8 is be VBZ 40436 7166 9 no no DT 40436 7166 10 precise precise JJ 40436 7166 11 word word NN 40436 7166 12 to to TO 40436 7166 13 translate translate VB 40436 7166 14 exactly exactly RB 40436 7166 15 the the DT 40436 7166 16 useful useful JJ 40436 7166 17 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 7166 18 between between IN 40436 7166 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7166 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7166 21 : : : 40436 7166 22 i)diô i)diô NNP 40436 7166 23 / / SYM 40436 7166 24 tês tês NN 40436 7166 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7166 26 and and CC 40436 7166 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7166 28 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7166 29 : : : 40436 7166 30 techni techni NNP 40436 7166 31 / / SYM 40436 7166 32 tês tês NN 40436 7166 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7166 34 or or CC 40436 7166 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7166 36 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7166 37 : : : 40436 7166 38 dêmiourgo dêmiourgo NNP 40436 7166 39 / / SYM 40436 7166 40 s s NNP 40436 7166 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7166 42 . . . 40436 7166 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7167 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7167 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7167 3 45 45 CD 40436 7167 4 : : : 40436 7167 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7167 6 , , , 40436 7167 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7167 8 . . . 40436 7168 1 p. p. NN 40436 7168 2 327 327 CD 40436 7168 3 A. a. NN 40436 7169 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7169 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7169 3 : : : 40436 7169 4 ei ei NNP 40436 7169 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7169 6 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 7 tou tou NNP 40436 7169 8 = = SYM 40436 7169 9 to to IN 40436 7169 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 11 i)di i)di NNP 40436 7169 12 / / SYM 40436 7169 13 a| a| NN 40436 7169 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 15 dêmosi dêmosi NNP 40436 7169 16 / / SYM 40436 7169 17 a| a| NN 40436 7169 18 pa pa NNP 40436 7169 19 = = SYM 40436 7169 20 s s NNP 40436 7169 21 pa pa NNP 40436 7169 22 / / SYM 40436 7169 23 nta nta NNP 40436 7169 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 25 e)di e)di NNP 40436 7169 26 / / SYM 40436 7169 27 daske daske NNP 40436 7169 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 29 e)pe e)pe NNP 40436 7169 30 / / SYM 40436 7169 31 plêtte plêtte NN 40436 7169 32 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7169 33 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 7169 34 kalô kalô NN 40436 7169 35 = = SYM 40436 7169 36 s s NNP 40436 7169 37 au)lou au)lou NNP 40436 7169 38 = = SYM 40436 7169 39 nta nta NNP 40436 7169 40 , , , 40436 7169 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 42 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 7169 43 e)phtho e)phtho NNP 40436 7169 44 / / SYM 40436 7169 45 nei nei NNP 40436 7169 46 tou tou NNP 40436 7169 47 / / SYM 40436 7169 48 tou tou NNP 40436 7169 49 , , , 40436 7169 50 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 7169 51 nu nu NNP 40436 7169 52 = = SYM 40436 7169 53 n n NNP 40436 7169 54 tô tô NNP 40436 7169 55 = = SYM 40436 7169 56 n n CC 40436 7169 57 dikai dikai NNP 40436 7169 58 / / SYM 40436 7169 59 ôn ôn NNP 40436 7169 60 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 61 tô tô NNP 40436 7169 62 = = SYM 40436 7169 63 n n CC 40436 7169 64 nomi nomi NNP 40436 7169 65 / / SYM 40436 7169 66 môn môn NNP 40436 7169 67 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s NNP 40436 7169 68 phthonei= phthonei= NNP 40436 7169 69 ou)d ou)d NNP 40436 7169 70 ' ' '' 40436 7169 71 a)pokru a)pokru , 40436 7169 72 / / SYM 40436 7169 73 ptetai ptetai NNP 40436 7169 74 , , , 40436 7169 75 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 7169 76 tô tô NNP 40436 7169 77 = = SYM 40436 7169 78 n n NN 40436 7169 79 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 7169 80 technêma technêma NNP 40436 7169 81 / / SYM 40436 7169 82 tôn tôn NNP 40436 7169 83 -- -- : 40436 7169 84 lusitelei= lusitelei= NNP 40436 7169 85 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7169 86 , , , 40436 7169 87 oi)=mai oi)=mai NNP 40436 7169 88 , , , 40436 7169 89 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 7169 90 = = SYM 40436 7169 91 n n CC 40436 7169 92 ê ê NNP 40436 7169 93 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7169 94 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 7169 95 / / SYM 40436 7169 96 lôn lôn NN 40436 7169 97 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 7169 98 / / SYM 40436 7169 99 nê nê NNP 40436 7169 100 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 101 a)retê\ a)retê\ NNP 40436 7169 102 ; ; : 40436 7169 103 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 7169 104 tau tau NNP 40436 7169 105 = = SYM 40436 7169 106 ta ta NNP 40436 7169 107 pa pa NNP 40436 7169 108 = = SYM 40436 7169 109 s s NNP 40436 7169 110 panti\ panti\ NNP 40436 7169 111 prothu prothu VB 40436 7169 112 / / SYM 40436 7169 113 môs môs NNP 40436 7169 114 le le NNP 40436 7169 115 / / SYM 40436 7169 116 gei gei NNP 40436 7169 117 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 118 dida dida NNP 40436 7169 119 / / SYM 40436 7169 120 skei skei NNP 40436 7169 121 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 122 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 7169 123 di di NNP 40436 7169 124 / / SYM 40436 7169 125 kaia kaia NNP 40436 7169 126 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7169 127 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 7169 128 no no DT 40436 7169 129 / / SYM 40436 7169 130 mima mima NNP 40436 7169 131 . . . 40436 7169 132 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7169 133 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7170 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7170 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7170 3 46 46 CD 40436 7170 4 : : : 40436 7170 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7170 6 , , , 40436 7170 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7170 8 . . . 40436 7171 1 p. p. NN 40436 7171 2 327 327 CD 40436 7171 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7171 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7171 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7171 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7171 7 47 47 CD 40436 7171 8 : : : 40436 7171 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7171 10 , , , 40436 7171 11 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7171 12 . . . 40436 7172 1 p. p. NN 40436 7172 2 327 327 CD 40436 7172 3 C C NNP 40436 7172 4 - - HYPH 40436 7172 5 D. D. NNP 40436 7172 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7172 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7172 8 : : : 40436 7172 9 O(/stis o(/stis JJ 40436 7172 10 soi soi NN 40436 7172 11 a)dikô a)dikô NNP 40436 7172 12 / / SYM 40436 7172 13 tatos tatos NN 40436 7172 14 phai phai NNP 40436 7172 15 / / SYM 40436 7172 16 netai netai NNP 40436 7172 17 a)/nthrôpos a)/nthrôpos NNPS 40436 7172 18 tô tô NNP 40436 7172 19 = = SYM 40436 7172 20 n n NNP 40436 7172 21 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7172 22 no no NNP 40436 7172 23 / / SYM 40436 7172 24 mois mois NNP 40436 7172 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7172 26 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 7172 27 / / SYM 40436 7172 28 pois pois NNP 40436 7172 29 tethramme tethramme NNP 40436 7172 30 / / SYM 40436 7172 31 nôn nôn NNP 40436 7172 32 , , , 40436 7172 33 di di NNP 40436 7172 34 / / SYM 40436 7172 35 kaion kaion NNP 40436 7172 36 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 7172 37 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7172 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7172 39 _ _ NNP 40436 7172 40 dêmiourgo\n dêmiourgo\n -LRB- 40436 7172 41 tou tou NNP 40436 7172 42 / / SYM 40436 7172 43 tou tou NNP 40436 7172 44 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7172 45 pra pra NNP 40436 7172 46 / / SYM 40436 7172 47 gmatos gmatos NNP 40436 7172 48 _ _ NNP 40436 7172 49 , , , 40436 7172 50 ei ei NNP 40436 7172 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7172 52 de de NNP 40436 7172 53 / / SYM 40436 7172 54 oi oi NNP 40436 7172 55 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 7172 56 kri kri NNP 40436 7172 57 / / SYM 40436 7172 58 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 7172 59 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7172 60 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 7172 61 / / SYM 40436 7172 62 pous pous JJ 40436 7172 63 , , , 40436 7172 64 oi(=s oi(=s JJ 40436 7172 65 mê mê NNP 40436 7172 66 / / SYM 40436 7172 67 te te NNP 40436 7172 68 paidei paidei NNP 40436 7172 69 / / SYM 40436 7172 70 a a DT 40436 7172 71 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 7172 72 mê mê NNP 40436 7172 73 / / SYM 40436 7172 74 te te NNP 40436 7172 75 dikastê dikastê NNP 40436 7172 76 / / SYM 40436 7172 77 ria ria NNP 40436 7172 78 mê mê NNP 40436 7172 79 / / SYM 40436 7172 80 te te NNP 40436 7172 81 no no NNP 40436 7172 82 / / SYM 40436 7172 83 moi moi NNP 40436 7172 84 mê mê NNP 40436 7172 85 / / SYM 40436 7172 86 te te NNP 40436 7172 87 a)na a)na NNP 40436 7172 88 / / SYM 40436 7172 89 gkê gkê NNP 40436 7172 90 mêdemi mêdemi NNP 40436 7172 91 / / , 40436 7172 92 a a DT 40436 7172 93 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 7172 94 panto\s panto\s NNP 40436 7172 95 a)nagka a)nagka NNP 40436 7172 96 / / SYM 40436 7172 97 zoousa zoousa NNP 40436 7172 98 a)retê a)retê NNPS 40436 7172 99 = = SYM 40436 7172 100 s s NNP 40436 7172 101 e)pimelei e)pimelei NNP 40436 7172 102 = = SYM 40436 7172 103 sthai sthai NNP 40436 7172 104 . . . 40436 7172 105 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7172 106 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7173 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7173 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7173 3 48 48 CD 40436 7173 4 : : : 40436 7173 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7173 6 , , , 40436 7173 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7173 8 . . . 40436 7174 1 p. p. NN 40436 7174 2 327 327 CD 40436 7174 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7174 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7174 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7174 6 Side side NN 40436 7174 7 - - HYPH 40436 7174 8 note note NN 40436 7174 9 : : : 40436 7174 10 Analogy analogy NN 40436 7174 11 of of IN 40436 7174 12 learning learn VBG 40436 7174 13 vernacular vernacular JJ 40436 7174 14 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7174 15 . . . 40436 7175 1 No no DT 40436 7175 2 special special JJ 40436 7175 3 teacher teacher NN 40436 7175 4 thereof thereof RB 40436 7175 5 . . . 40436 7176 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7176 2 teaches teach VBZ 40436 7176 3 virtue virtue VBP 40436 7176 4 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 7176 5 better well JJR 40436 7176 6 than than IN 40436 7176 7 others other NNS 40436 7176 8 . . . 40436 7176 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7177 1 But but CC 40436 7177 2 now now RB 40436 7177 3 , , , 40436 7177 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7177 5 , , , 40436 7177 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7177 7 are be VBP 40436 7177 8 over over RB 40436 7177 9 - - HYPH 40436 7177 10 nice nice JJ 40436 7177 11 , , , 40436 7177 12 because because IN 40436 7177 13 all all DT 40436 7177 14 of of IN 40436 7177 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7177 16 are be VBP 40436 7177 17 teachers teacher NNS 40436 7177 18 of of IN 40436 7177 19 virtue virtue NN 40436 7177 20 , , , 40436 7177 21 to to IN 40436 7177 22 the the DT 40436 7177 23 best good JJS 40436 7177 24 of of IN 40436 7177 25 every every DT 40436 7177 26 man man NN 40436 7177 27 's 's POS 40436 7177 28 power power NN 40436 7177 29 ; ; : 40436 7177 30 while while IN 40436 7177 31 no no DT 40436 7177 32 particular particular JJ 40436 7177 33 individual individual NN 40436 7177 34 appears appear VBZ 40436 7177 35 to to TO 40436 7177 36 teach teach VB 40436 7177 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7177 38 specially specially RB 40436 7177 39 and and CC 40436 7177 40 _ _ NNP 40436 7177 41 ex ex NNP 40436 7177 42 professo_[49 professo_[49 NNP 40436 7177 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7177 44 By by IN 40436 7177 45 the the DT 40436 7177 46 same same JJ 40436 7177 47 analogy analogy NN 40436 7177 48 , , , 40436 7177 49 if if IN 40436 7177 50 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7177 51 asked ask VBD 40436 7177 52 who who WP 40436 7177 53 was be VBD 40436 7177 54 the the DT 40436 7177 55 teacher teacher NN 40436 7177 56 for for IN 40436 7177 57 speaking speak VBG 40436 7177 58 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7177 59 vernacular vernacular JJ 40436 7177 60 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7177 61 , , , 40436 7177 62 no no DT 40436 7177 63 one one CD 40436 7177 64 special special JJ 40436 7177 65 person person NN 40436 7177 66 could could MD 40436 7177 67 be be VB 40436 7177 68 pointed point VBN 40436 7177 69 out:[50 out:[50 NN 40436 7177 70 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7177 71 nor nor CC 40436 7177 72 would would MD 40436 7177 73 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7177 74 find find VB 40436 7177 75 out out RP 40436 7177 76 who who WP 40436 7177 77 was be VBD 40436 7177 78 the the DT 40436 7177 79 finishing finish VBG 40436 7177 80 teacher teacher NN 40436 7177 81 for for IN 40436 7177 82 those those DT 40436 7177 83 sons son NNS 40436 7177 84 of of IN 40436 7177 85 craftsmen craftsman NNS 40436 7177 86 who who WP 40436 7177 87 learnt learn VBD 40436 7177 88 the the DT 40436 7177 89 rudiments rudiment NNS 40436 7177 90 of of IN 40436 7177 91 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7177 92 art art NN 40436 7177 93 from from IN 40436 7177 94 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7177 95 own own JJ 40436 7177 96 fathers father NNS 40436 7177 97 -- -- : 40436 7177 98 while while IN 40436 7177 99 if if IN 40436 7177 100 the the DT 40436 7177 101 son son NN 40436 7177 102 of of IN 40436 7177 103 any any DT 40436 7177 104 non non JJ 40436 7177 105 - - JJ 40436 7177 106 professional professional JJ 40436 7177 107 person person NN 40436 7177 108 learns learn VBZ 40436 7177 109 a a DT 40436 7177 110 craft craft NN 40436 7177 111 , , , 40436 7177 112 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7177 113 is be VBZ 40436 7177 114 easy easy JJ 40436 7177 115 to to TO 40436 7177 116 assign assign VB 40436 7177 117 the the DT 40436 7177 118 person person NN 40436 7177 119 by by IN 40436 7177 120 whom whom WP 40436 7177 121 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7177 122 was be VBD 40436 7177 123 taught teach VBN 40436 7177 124 . . . 40436 7178 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7178 2 51 51 CD 40436 7178 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7178 4 So so CC 40436 7178 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7178 6 is be VBZ 40436 7178 7 in in IN 40436 7178 8 respect respect NN 40436 7178 9 to to TO 40436 7178 10 virtue virtue VB 40436 7178 11 . . . 40436 7179 1 All all DT 40436 7179 2 of of IN 40436 7179 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7179 4 teach teach VBP 40436 7179 5 and and CC 40436 7179 6 enforce enforce VB 40436 7179 7 virtue virtue NN 40436 7179 8 to to IN 40436 7179 9 the the DT 40436 7179 10 best good JJS 40436 7179 11 of of IN 40436 7179 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7179 13 power power NN 40436 7179 14 ; ; : 40436 7179 15 and and CC 40436 7179 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7179 17 ought ought MD 40436 7179 18 to to TO 40436 7179 19 be be VB 40436 7179 20 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 7179 21 if if IN 40436 7179 22 there there EX 40436 7179 23 be be VB 40436 7179 24 any any DT 40436 7179 25 one one CD 40436 7179 26 of of IN 40436 7179 27 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7179 28 ever ever RB 40436 7179 29 so so RB 40436 7179 30 little little JJ 40436 7179 31 superior superior JJ 40436 7179 32 to to IN 40436 7179 33 the the DT 40436 7179 34 rest rest NN 40436 7179 35 , , , 40436 7179 36 in in IN 40436 7179 37 the the DT 40436 7179 38 power power NN 40436 7179 39 of of IN 40436 7179 40 teaching teach VBG 40436 7179 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7179 42 . . . 40436 7180 1 Of of IN 40436 7180 2 such such JJ 40436 7180 3 men man NNS 40436 7180 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7180 5 believe believe VBP 40436 7180 6 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 7180 7 to to TO 40436 7180 8 be be VB 40436 7180 9 one one CD 40436 7180 10 . . . 40436 7181 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7181 2 52 52 CD 40436 7181 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7181 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7181 5 can can MD 40436 7181 6 train train VB 40436 7181 7 a a DT 40436 7181 8 man man NN 40436 7181 9 into into IN 40436 7181 10 an an DT 40436 7181 11 excellent excellent JJ 40436 7181 12 citizen citizen NN 40436 7181 13 , , , 40436 7181 14 better well JJR 40436 7181 15 than than IN 40436 7181 16 others other NNS 40436 7181 17 , , , 40436 7181 18 and and CC 40436 7181 19 in in IN 40436 7181 20 a a DT 40436 7181 21 manner manner NN 40436 7181 22 worthy worthy JJ 40436 7181 23 not not RB 40436 7181 24 only only RB 40436 7181 25 of of IN 40436 7181 26 the the DT 40436 7181 27 fee fee NN 40436 7181 28 which which WDT 40436 7181 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7181 30 ask ask VBP 40436 7181 31 , , , 40436 7181 32 but but CC 40436 7181 33 even even RB 40436 7181 34 of of IN 40436 7181 35 a a DT 40436 7181 36 still still RB 40436 7181 37 greater great JJR 40436 7181 38 remuneration remuneration NN 40436 7181 39 , , , 40436 7181 40 in in IN 40436 7181 41 the the DT 40436 7181 42 judgment judgment NN 40436 7181 43 of of IN 40436 7181 44 the the DT 40436 7181 45 pupil pupil NN 40436 7181 46 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7181 47 . . . 40436 7182 1 This this DT 40436 7182 2 is be VBZ 40436 7182 3 the the DT 40436 7182 4 stipulation stipulation NN 40436 7182 5 which which WDT 40436 7182 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 7 make make VBP 40436 7182 8 with with IN 40436 7182 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 10 : : : 40436 7182 11 when when WRB 40436 7182 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 13 has have VBZ 40436 7182 14 completed complete VBN 40436 7182 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7182 16 course course NN 40436 7182 17 , , , 40436 7182 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 19 is be VBZ 40436 7182 20 either either CC 40436 7182 21 to to TO 40436 7182 22 pay pay VB 40436 7182 23 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 24 the the DT 40436 7182 25 fee fee NN 40436 7182 26 which which WDT 40436 7182 27 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 28 shall shall MD 40436 7182 29 demand demand VB 40436 7182 30 -- -- : 40436 7182 31 or or CC 40436 7182 32 if if IN 40436 7182 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 34 prefers prefer VBZ 40436 7182 35 , , , 40436 7182 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 37 may may MD 40436 7182 38 go go VB 40436 7182 39 into into IN 40436 7182 40 a a DT 40436 7182 41 temple temple NN 40436 7182 42 , , , 40436 7182 43 make make VB 40436 7182 44 oath oath NN 40436 7182 45 as as IN 40436 7182 46 to to IN 40436 7182 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7182 48 own own JJ 40436 7182 49 estimate estimate NN 40436 7182 50 of of IN 40436 7182 51 the the DT 40436 7182 52 instruction instruction NN 40436 7182 53 imparted impart VBN 40436 7182 54 to to IN 40436 7182 55 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 56 , , , 40436 7182 57 and and CC 40436 7182 58 pay pay VB 40436 7182 59 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7182 60 according accord VBG 40436 7182 61 to to IN 40436 7182 62 that that DT 40436 7182 63 estimate estimate NN 40436 7182 64 . . . 40436 7183 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7183 2 53 53 CD 40436 7183 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7183 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7183 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7183 6 49 49 CD 40436 7183 7 : : : 40436 7183 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7183 9 , , , 40436 7183 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7183 11 . . . 40436 7184 1 p. p. NN 40436 7184 2 327 327 CD 40436 7184 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7184 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7184 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7184 6 : : : 40436 7184 7 nu nu NNP 40436 7184 8 = = SYM 40436 7184 9 n n NNP 40436 7184 10 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7184 11 trupha=|s trupha=|s NNP 40436 7184 12 , , , 40436 7184 13 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 7184 14 Sô Sô NNP 40436 7184 15 / / SYM 40436 7184 16 krates krate NNS 40436 7184 17 , , , 40436 7184 18 dio dio NNP 40436 7184 19 / / SYM 40436 7184 20 ti ti NNP 40436 7184 21 pa pa NNP 40436 7184 22 / / SYM 40436 7184 23 ntes ntes NNP 40436 7184 24 dida dida NNP 40436 7184 25 / / SYM 40436 7184 26 skaloi/ skaloi/ NNP 40436 7184 27 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 7184 28 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 7184 29 = = SYM 40436 7184 30 s s NNP 40436 7184 31 , , , 40436 7184 32 kath kath NNP 40436 7184 33 ' ' '' 40436 7184 34 o(/son o(/son NNP 40436 7184 35 du du NNP 40436 7184 36 / / SYM 40436 7184 37 natai natai NNP 40436 7184 38 e(/kastos e(/kastos NNP 40436 7184 39 , , , 40436 7184 40 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7184 41 ou)dei ou)dei NNP 40436 7184 42 / / SYM 40436 7184 43 s s NNP 40436 7184 44 soi soi NNP 40436 7184 45 phai phai NNP 40436 7184 46 / / SYM 40436 7184 47 netai netai NN 40436 7184 48 . . . 40436 7184 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7184 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7185 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7185 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7185 3 50 50 CD 40436 7185 4 : : : 40436 7185 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7185 6 , , , 40436 7185 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7185 8 . . . 40436 7186 1 p. p. NN 40436 7186 2 327 327 CD 40436 7186 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7186 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7186 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7186 6 : : : 40436 7186 7 ei)=th ei)=th NNP 40436 7186 8 ' ' POS 40436 7186 9 ô(/s ô(/s NN 40436 7186 10 per per IN 40436 7186 11 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 7186 12 ei ei NNP 40436 7186 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7186 14 zêtoi zêtoi NNP 40436 7186 15 = = SYM 40436 7186 16 s s NNP 40436 7186 17 ti ti NNP 40436 7186 18 / / SYM 40436 7186 19 s s NNP 40436 7186 20 dida dida NNP 40436 7186 21 / / SYM 40436 7186 22 skalos skalos NNP 40436 7186 23 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7186 24 e(llêni e(llêni . 40436 7186 25 / / SYM 40436 7186 26 zein zein NN 40436 7186 27 , , , 40436 7186 28 ou)d ou)d JJ 40436 7186 29 ' ' POS 40436 7186 30 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 7186 31 ei(=s ei(=s NNP 40436 7186 32 phanei phanei NNP 40436 7186 33 / / SYM 40436 7186 34 ê ê NNP 40436 7186 35 . . . 40436 7186 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7186 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7187 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7187 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7187 3 51 51 CD 40436 7187 4 : : : 40436 7187 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7187 6 , , , 40436 7187 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7187 8 . . . 40436 7188 1 p. p. NN 40436 7188 2 328 328 CD 40436 7188 3 A. a. NN 40436 7188 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7189 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7189 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7189 3 52 52 CD 40436 7189 4 : : : 40436 7189 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7189 6 , , , 40436 7189 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7189 8 . . . 40436 7190 1 p. p. NN 40436 7190 2 328 328 CD 40436 7190 3 B. B. NNP 40436 7191 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7191 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7191 3 : : : 40436 7191 4 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 7191 5 ka)\n ka)\n NNPS 40436 7191 6 ei ei NNP 40436 7191 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7191 8 o)li o)li NNP 40436 7191 9 / / SYM 40436 7191 10 gon gon NNP 40436 7191 11 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 7191 12 tis tis NNP 40436 7191 13 o(/stis o(/stis NNP 40436 7191 14 diaphe diaphe NNP 40436 7191 15 / / SYM 40436 7191 16 rei rei NNP 40436 7191 17 ê(mô ê(mô NNP 40436 7191 18 = = SYM 40436 7191 19 n n NNP 40436 7191 20 probiba probiba NNP 40436 7191 21 / / SYM 40436 7191 22 sai sai NNP 40436 7191 23 ei)s ei)s NNP 40436 7191 24 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 7191 25 / / SYM 40436 7191 26 n n NNP 40436 7191 27 , , , 40436 7191 28 a)gapêto a)gapêto NNP 40436 7191 29 / / SYM 40436 7191 30 n n NN 40436 7191 31 . . . 40436 7192 1 Ô(=n Ô(=n NNP 40436 7192 2 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 7192 3 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 7192 4 oi)=mai oi)=mai NNP 40436 7192 5 ei(=s ei(=s XX 40436 7192 6 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7192 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7192 8 , , , 40436 7192 9 & & CC 40436 7192 10 c. c. NNP 40436 7192 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7192 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7192 13 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7192 14 53 53 CD 40436 7192 15 : : : 40436 7192 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7192 17 , , , 40436 7192 18 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7192 19 . . . 40436 7193 1 p. p. NN 40436 7193 2 328 328 CD 40436 7193 3 B. B. NNP 40436 7193 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7194 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7194 2 Side side NN 40436 7194 3 - - HYPH 40436 7194 4 note note NN 40436 7194 5 : : : 40436 7194 6 The the DT 40436 7194 7 sons son NNS 40436 7194 8 of of IN 40436 7194 9 great great JJ 40436 7194 10 artists artist NNS 40436 7194 11 do do VBP 40436 7194 12 not not RB 40436 7194 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7194 14 become become VB 40436 7194 15 great great JJ 40436 7194 16 artists artist NNS 40436 7194 17 . . . 40436 7194 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7195 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7195 2 have have VBP 40436 7195 3 thus thus RB 40436 7195 4 proved prove VBN 40436 7195 5 to to IN 40436 7195 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7195 7 , , , 40436 7195 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7195 9 -- -- : 40436 7195 10 That that DT 40436 7195 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 7195 12 is be VBZ 40436 7195 13 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7195 14 -- -- : 40436 7195 15 That that IN 40436 7195 16 the the DT 40436 7195 17 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 7195 18 account account VBP 40436 7195 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7195 20 to to TO 40436 7195 21 be be VB 40436 7195 22 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7195 23 -- -- : 40436 7195 24 That that IN 40436 7195 25 there there EX 40436 7195 26 is be VBZ 40436 7195 27 nothing nothing NN 40436 7195 28 wonderful wonderful JJ 40436 7195 29 in in IN 40436 7195 30 finding find VBG 40436 7195 31 the the DT 40436 7195 32 sons son NNS 40436 7195 33 of of IN 40436 7195 34 good good JJ 40436 7195 35 men man NNS 40436 7195 36 worthless worthless JJ 40436 7195 37 , , , 40436 7195 38 and and CC 40436 7195 39 the the DT 40436 7195 40 sons son NNS 40436 7195 41 of of IN 40436 7195 42 worthless worthless JJ 40436 7195 43 men man NNS 40436 7195 44 good good JJ 40436 7195 45 . . . 40436 7196 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 7196 2 this this DT 40436 7196 3 is be VBZ 40436 7196 4 true true JJ 40436 7196 5 no no RB 40436 7196 6 less less JJR 40436 7196 7 about about IN 40436 7196 8 the the DT 40436 7196 9 special special JJ 40436 7196 10 professions profession NNS 40436 7196 11 , , , 40436 7196 12 than than IN 40436 7196 13 about about IN 40436 7196 14 the the DT 40436 7196 15 common common JJ 40436 7196 16 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 7196 17 , , , 40436 7196 18 virtue virtue NNP 40436 7196 19 . . . 40436 7197 1 The the DT 40436 7197 2 sons son NNS 40436 7197 3 of of IN 40436 7197 4 Polyklêtus Polyklêtus NNP 40436 7197 5 the the DT 40436 7197 6 statuary statuary NN 40436 7197 7 , , , 40436 7197 8 and and CC 40436 7197 9 of of IN 40436 7197 10 many many JJ 40436 7197 11 other other JJ 40436 7197 12 artists artist NNS 40436 7197 13 , , , 40436 7197 14 are be VBP 40436 7197 15 nothing nothing NN 40436 7197 16 as as IN 40436 7197 17 compared compare VBN 40436 7197 18 with with IN 40436 7197 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7197 20 fathers father NNS 40436 7197 21 . . . 40436 7198 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7198 2 54 54 CD 40436 7198 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7198 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7198 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7198 6 54 54 CD 40436 7198 7 : : : 40436 7198 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7198 9 , , , 40436 7198 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7198 11 . . . 40436 7199 1 p. p. NN 40436 7199 2 328 328 CD 40436 7199 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7199 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7199 5 * * NFP 40436 7199 6 * * NFP 40436 7199 7 * * NFP 40436 7199 8 * * NFP 40436 7199 9 * * NFP 40436 7199 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7199 11 Side side NN 40436 7199 12 - - HYPH 40436 7199 13 note note NN 40436 7199 14 : : : 40436 7199 15 Remarks remark NNS 40436 7199 16 upon upon IN 40436 7199 17 the the DT 40436 7199 18 mythe mythe NN 40436 7199 19 and and CC 40436 7199 20 discourse discourse NN 40436 7199 21 . . . 40436 7200 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 7200 2 explain explain VBP 40436 7200 3 the the DT 40436 7200 4 manner manner NN 40436 7200 5 in in IN 40436 7200 6 which which WDT 40436 7200 7 the the DT 40436 7200 8 established established JJ 40436 7200 9 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 7200 10 of of IN 40436 7200 11 a a DT 40436 7200 12 community community NN 40436 7200 13 propagates propagate VBZ 40436 7200 14 and and CC 40436 7200 15 perpetuates perpetuate VBZ 40436 7200 16 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7200 17 . . . 40436 7200 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7201 1 Such such JJ 40436 7201 2 is be VBZ 40436 7201 3 the the DT 40436 7201 4 discourse discourse NN 40436 7201 5 composed compose VBN 40436 7201 6 by by IN 40436 7201 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7201 8 and and CC 40436 7201 9 attributed attribute VBD 40436 7201 10 to to IN 40436 7201 11 the the DT 40436 7201 12 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7201 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7201 14 -- -- : 40436 7201 15 showing show VBG 40436 7201 16 that that DT 40436 7201 17 virtue virtue NN 40436 7201 18 is be VBZ 40436 7201 19 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7201 20 , , , 40436 7201 21 and and CC 40436 7201 22 intended intend VBD 40436 7201 23 to to TO 40436 7201 24 remove remove VB 40436 7201 25 the the DT 40436 7201 26 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 7201 27 proposed propose VBN 40436 7201 28 by by IN 40436 7201 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7201 30 . . . 40436 7202 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7202 2 is be VBZ 40436 7202 3 an an DT 40436 7202 4 exposition exposition NN 40436 7202 5 of of IN 40436 7202 6 some some DT 40436 7202 7 length length NN 40436 7202 8 : : : 40436 7202 9 and and CC 40436 7202 10 because because IN 40436 7202 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7202 12 is be VBZ 40436 7202 13 put put VBN 40436 7202 14 into into IN 40436 7202 15 the the DT 40436 7202 16 mouth mouth NN 40436 7202 17 of of IN 40436 7202 18 a a DT 40436 7202 19 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7202 20 , , , 40436 7202 21 many many JJ 40436 7202 22 commentators commentator NNS 40436 7202 23 presume presume VBP 40436 7202 24 , , , 40436 7202 25 as as IN 40436 7202 26 a a DT 40436 7202 27 matter matter NN 40436 7202 28 of of IN 40436 7202 29 course course NN 40436 7202 30 , , , 40436 7202 31 that that IN 40436 7202 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7202 33 must must MD 40436 7202 34 be be VB 40436 7202 35 a a DT 40436 7202 36 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 7202 37 of of IN 40436 7202 38 some some DT 40436 7202 39 worthless worthless JJ 40436 7202 40 quality:[55 quality:[55 NNP 40436 7202 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7202 42 that that IN 40436 7202 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7202 44 is be VBZ 40436 7202 45 either either CC 40436 7202 46 empty empty JJ 40436 7202 47 verbiage verbiage NN 40436 7202 48 , , , 40436 7202 49 or or CC 40436 7202 50 ostentatious ostentatious JJ 40436 7202 51 self self NN 40436 7202 52 - - HYPH 40436 7202 53 praise praise NN 40436 7202 54 , , , 40436 7202 55 or or CC 40436 7202 56 low low JJ 40436 7202 57 - - HYPH 40436 7202 58 minded minded JJ 40436 7202 59 immorality immorality NN 40436 7202 60 . . . 40436 7203 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7203 2 am be VBP 40436 7203 3 unable unable JJ 40436 7203 4 to to TO 40436 7203 5 perceive perceive VB 40436 7203 6 in in IN 40436 7203 7 the the DT 40436 7203 8 discourse discourse NN 40436 7203 9 any any DT 40436 7203 10 of of IN 40436 7203 11 these these DT 40436 7203 12 demerits demerit NNS 40436 7203 13 . . . 40436 7204 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7204 2 think think VBP 40436 7204 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7204 4 one one CD 40436 7204 5 of of IN 40436 7204 6 the the DT 40436 7204 7 best good JJS 40436 7204 8 parts part NNS 40436 7204 9 of of IN 40436 7204 10 the the DT 40436 7204 11 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7204 12 writings writing NNS 40436 7204 13 , , , 40436 7204 14 as as IN 40436 7204 15 an an DT 40436 7204 16 exposition exposition NN 40436 7204 17 of of IN 40436 7204 18 the the DT 40436 7204 19 growth growth NN 40436 7204 20 and and CC 40436 7204 21 propagation propagation NN 40436 7204 22 of of IN 40436 7204 23 common common JJ 40436 7204 24 sense sense NN 40436 7204 25 -- -- : 40436 7204 26 the the DT 40436 7204 27 common common JJ 40436 7204 28 , , , 40436 7204 29 established established JJ 40436 7204 30 , , , 40436 7204 31 ethical ethical JJ 40436 7204 32 and and CC 40436 7204 33 social social JJ 40436 7204 34 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 7204 35 , , , 40436 7204 36 among among IN 40436 7204 37 a a DT 40436 7204 38 community community NN 40436 7204 39 : : : 40436 7204 40 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 7204 41 neither neither CC 40436 7204 42 dictated dictate VBN 40436 7204 43 in in IN 40436 7204 44 the the DT 40436 7204 45 beginning beginning NN 40436 7204 46 , , , 40436 7204 47 by by IN 40436 7204 48 any any DT 40436 7204 49 scientific scientific JJ 40436 7204 50 or or CC 40436 7204 51 artistic artistic JJ 40436 7204 52 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 7204 53 , , , 40436 7204 54 nor nor CC 40436 7204 55 personified personify VBN 40436 7204 56 in in IN 40436 7204 57 any any DT 40436 7204 58 special special JJ 40436 7204 59 guild guild NN 40436 7204 60 of of IN 40436 7204 61 craftsmen craftsman NNS 40436 7204 62 apart apart RB 40436 7204 63 from from IN 40436 7204 64 the the DT 40436 7204 65 remaining remain VBG 40436 7204 66 community community NN 40436 7204 67 -- -- : 40436 7204 68 nor nor CC 40436 7204 69 inculcated inculcate VBN 40436 7204 70 by by IN 40436 7204 71 any any DT 40436 7204 72 formal formal JJ 40436 7204 73 professional professional JJ 40436 7204 74 teachers teacher NNS 40436 7204 75 -- -- : 40436 7204 76 nor nor CC 40436 7204 77 tested test VBN 40436 7204 78 by by IN 40436 7204 79 analysis analysis NN 40436 7204 80 -- -- : 40436 7204 81 nor nor CC 40436 7204 82 verified verify VBN 40436 7204 83 by by IN 40436 7204 84 comparison comparison NN 40436 7204 85 with with IN 40436 7204 86 any any DT 40436 7204 87 objective objective JJ 40436 7204 88 standard standard NN 40436 7204 89 : : : 40436 7204 90 but but CC 40436 7204 91 self self NN 40436 7204 92 - - HYPH 40436 7204 93 sown sow VBN 40436 7204 94 and and CC 40436 7204 95 self self NN 40436 7204 96 - - HYPH 40436 7204 97 asserting assert VBG 40436 7204 98 , , , 40436 7204 99 stamped stamp VBD 40436 7204 100 , , , 40436 7204 101 multiplied multiply VBN 40436 7204 102 , , , 40436 7204 103 and and CC 40436 7204 104 kept keep VBD 40436 7204 105 in in IN 40436 7204 106 circulation circulation NN 40436 7204 107 , , , 40436 7204 108 by by IN 40436 7204 109 the the DT 40436 7204 110 unpremeditated unpremeditated JJ 40436 7204 111 conspiracy conspiracy NN 40436 7204 112 of of IN 40436 7204 113 the the DT 40436 7204 114 general[56 general[56 NN 40436 7204 115 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7204 116 public public NN 40436 7204 117 -- -- : 40436 7204 118 the the DT 40436 7204 119 omnipresent omnipresent JJ 40436 7204 120 agency agency NN 40436 7204 121 of of IN 40436 7204 122 King King NNP 40436 7204 123 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 7204 124 and and CC 40436 7204 125 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7204 126 numerous numerous JJ 40436 7204 127 volunteers volunteer NNS 40436 7204 128 . . . 40436 7205 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7205 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7205 3 55 55 CD 40436 7205 4 : : : 40436 7205 5 So so RB 40436 7205 6 Serranus Serranus NNP 40436 7205 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7205 8 ad ad NN 40436 7205 9 326 326 CD 40436 7205 10 E E NNP 40436 7205 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7205 12 , , , 40436 7205 13 who who WP 40436 7205 14 has have VBZ 40436 7205 15 been be VBN 40436 7205 16 followed follow VBN 40436 7205 17 by by IN 40436 7205 18 many many JJ 40436 7205 19 later later JJ 40436 7205 20 critics critic NNS 40436 7205 21 . . . 40436 7206 1 " " `` 40436 7206 2 Quæstio quæstio NN 40436 7206 3 est est RB 40436 7206 4 , , , 40436 7206 5 Virtusne virtusne JJ 40436 7206 6 doceri doceri JJ 40436 7206 7 possit possit NN 40436 7206 8 ? ? . 40436 7207 1 Quod Quod NNP 40436 7207 2 instituit instituit NN 40436 7207 3 demonstrare demonstrare NN 40436 7207 4 Sophista Sophista NNP 40436 7207 5 , , , 40436 7207 6 sed sed NNP 40436 7207 7 ineptissimis ineptissimis NNP 40436 7207 8 argumentis argumentis NNP 40436 7207 9 et et NNP 40436 7207 10 quæ quæ NNP 40436 7207 11 contra contra NNP 40436 7207 12 seipsum seipsum NN 40436 7207 13 faciant faciant NN 40436 7207 14 . . . 40436 7207 15 " " '' 40436 7208 1 To to IN 40436 7208 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7208 3 this this DT 40436 7208 4 appears appear VBZ 40436 7208 5 the the DT 40436 7208 6 reverse reverse NN 40436 7208 7 of of IN 40436 7208 8 the the DT 40436 7208 9 truth truth NN 40436 7208 10 . . . 40436 7209 1 But but CC 40436 7209 2 even even RB 40436 7209 3 if if IN 40436 7209 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7209 5 were be VBD 40436 7209 6 true true JJ 40436 7209 7 , , , 40436 7209 8 no no DT 40436 7209 9 blame blame NN 40436 7209 10 could could MD 40436 7209 11 fall fall VB 40436 7209 12 on on IN 40436 7209 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7209 14 . . . 40436 7210 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7210 2 should should MD 40436 7210 3 only only RB 40436 7210 4 be be VB 40436 7210 5 warranted warrant VBN 40436 7210 6 in in IN 40436 7210 7 concluding conclude VBG 40436 7210 8 that that IN 40436 7210 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7210 10 suited suit VBD 40436 7210 11 the the DT 40436 7210 12 scheme scheme NN 40436 7210 13 of of IN 40436 7210 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7210 15 here here RB 40436 7210 16 to to TO 40436 7210 17 make make VB 40436 7210 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7210 19 talk talk VB 40436 7210 20 nonsense nonsense NN 40436 7210 21 . . . 40436 7210 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7211 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7211 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7211 3 56 56 CD 40436 7211 4 : : : 40436 7211 5 This this DT 40436 7211 6 is be VBZ 40436 7211 7 what what WP 40436 7211 8 the the DT 40436 7211 9 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7211 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7211 11 alludes allude NNS 40436 7211 12 to to IN 40436 7211 13 in in IN 40436 7211 14 the the DT 40436 7211 15 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 7211 16 and and CC 40436 7211 17 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 7211 18 . . . 40436 7212 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7212 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7212 3 : : : 40436 7212 4 oi oi UH 40436 7212 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7212 6 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7212 7 dêmotikê\n dêmotikê\n ADD 40436 7212 8 te te NNP 40436 7212 9 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7212 10 politikê\n politikê\n NNPS 40436 7212 11 a)retê\n a)retê\n NNP 40436 7212 12 e)pitetêdeuko e)pitetêdeuko NNP 40436 7212 13 / / SYM 40436 7212 14 tes tes NNP 40436 7212 15 , , , 40436 7212 16 ê(\n ê(\n NNP 40436 7212 17 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 7212 18 kalou kalou NNP 40436 7212 19 = = SYM 40436 7212 20 si si FW 40436 7212 21 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 7212 22 / / SYM 40436 7212 23 nên nên NNP 40436 7212 24 te te NNP 40436 7212 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7212 26 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 7212 27 / / SYM 40436 7212 28 nêv nêv NNP 40436 7212 29 , , , 40436 7212 30 e)x e)x NNP 40436 7212 31 e)/thous e)/thous JJ 40436 7212 32 te te NNP 40436 7212 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7212 34 mele mele NNP 40436 7212 35 / / SYM 40436 7212 36 tês tês NNP 40436 7212 37 gegonui gegonui NNP 40436 7212 38 = = , 40436 7212 39 an an DT 40436 7212 40 , , , 40436 7212 41 a)/neu a)/neu RB 40436 7212 42 philosophi philosophi LS 40436 7212 43 / / SYM 40436 7212 44 as as IN 40436 7212 45 te te NNP 40436 7212 46 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7212 47 nou=. nou=. NNP 40436 7212 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7213 1 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 7213 2 , , , 40436 7213 3 p. p. NN 40436 7213 4 82 82 CD 40436 7213 5 B b NN 40436 7213 6 ; ; : 40436 7213 7 compare compare VB 40436 7213 8 the the DT 40436 7213 9 same same JJ 40436 7213 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7213 11 , , , 40436 7213 12 p. p. NN 40436 7213 13 68 68 CD 40436 7213 14 C c NN 40436 7213 15 ; ; : 40436 7213 16 also also RB 40436 7213 17 Republic Republic NNP 40436 7213 18 , , , 40436 7213 19 x. x. NNP 40436 7213 20 p. p. NN 40436 7213 21 619 619 CD 40436 7213 22 C--[Greek c--[greek DT 40436 7213 23 : : : 40436 7213 24 e)/thei e)/thei NNP 40436 7213 25 a)/neu a)/neu NNP 40436 7213 26 philosophi philosophi NNS 40436 7213 27 / / SYM 40436 7213 28 as as IN 40436 7213 29 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 7213 30 = = SYM 40436 7213 31 s s NNP 40436 7213 32 meteilêpho meteilêpho NNP 40436 7213 33 / / SYM 40436 7213 34 ta ta NNP 40436 7213 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7213 36 . . . 40436 7213 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7214 1 The the DT 40436 7214 2 account account NN 40436 7214 3 given give VBN 40436 7214 4 by by IN 40436 7214 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 7214 6 James James NNP 40436 7214 7 Mill Mill NNP 40436 7214 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7214 9 Fragment Fragment NNP 40436 7214 10 on on IN 40436 7214 11 Mackintosh Mackintosh NNP 40436 7214 12 , , , 40436 7214 13 p. p. NN 40436 7214 14 259 259 CD 40436 7214 15 - - SYM 40436 7214 16 260 260 CD 40436 7214 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7214 18 of of IN 40436 7214 19 the the DT 40436 7214 20 manner manner NN 40436 7214 21 in in IN 40436 7214 22 which which WDT 40436 7214 23 the the DT 40436 7214 24 established establish VBN 40436 7214 25 morality morality NN 40436 7214 26 of of IN 40436 7214 27 a a DT 40436 7214 28 society society NN 40436 7214 29 is be VBZ 40436 7214 30 transmitted transmit VBN 40436 7214 31 and and CC 40436 7214 32 perpetuated perpetuate VBN 40436 7214 33 , , , 40436 7214 34 coincides coincide VBZ 40436 7214 35 completely completely RB 40436 7214 36 with with IN 40436 7214 37 the the DT 40436 7214 38 discourse discourse NN 40436 7214 39 of of IN 40436 7214 40 the the DT 40436 7214 41 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7214 42 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7214 43 . . . 40436 7215 1 The the DT 40436 7215 2 passage passage NN 40436 7215 3 is be VBZ 40436 7215 4 too too RB 40436 7215 5 long long JJ 40436 7215 6 to to TO 40436 7215 7 be be VB 40436 7215 8 cited cite VBN 40436 7215 9 : : : 40436 7215 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7215 11 give give VBP 40436 7215 12 here here RB 40436 7215 13 only only RB 40436 7215 14 the the DT 40436 7215 15 concluding concluding NN 40436 7215 16 words word NNS 40436 7215 17 , , , 40436 7215 18 which which WDT 40436 7215 19 describe describe VBP 40436 7215 20 the the DT 40436 7215 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7215 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7215 23 : : : 40436 7215 24 dêmotikê\ dêmotikê\ NNP 40436 7215 25 a)retê\ a)retê\ RB 40436 7215 26 a)/neu a)/neu NNP 40436 7215 27 philosophi philosophi JJ 40436 7215 28 / / SYM 40436 7215 29 as]-- as]-- CD 40436 7215 30 " " `` 40436 7215 31 In in IN 40436 7215 32 this this DT 40436 7215 33 manner manner NN 40436 7215 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7215 35 is be VBZ 40436 7215 36 that that IN 40436 7215 37 men man NNS 40436 7215 38 , , , 40436 7215 39 in in IN 40436 7215 40 the the DT 40436 7215 41 social social JJ 40436 7215 42 state state NN 40436 7215 43 , , , 40436 7215 44 acquire acquire VB 40436 7215 45 the the DT 40436 7215 46 habits habit NNS 40436 7215 47 of of IN 40436 7215 48 moral moral JJ 40436 7215 49 acting acting NN 40436 7215 50 , , , 40436 7215 51 and and CC 40436 7215 52 certain certain JJ 40436 7215 53 affections affection NNS 40436 7215 54 connected connect VBN 40436 7215 55 with with IN 40436 7215 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7215 57 , , , 40436 7215 58 before before IN 40436 7215 59 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7215 60 are be VBP 40436 7215 61 capable capable JJ 40436 7215 62 of of IN 40436 7215 63 reflecting reflect VBG 40436 7215 64 upon upon IN 40436 7215 65 the the DT 40436 7215 66 grounds ground NNS 40436 7215 67 which which WDT 40436 7215 68 recommend recommend VBP 40436 7215 69 the the DT 40436 7215 70 acts act NNS 40436 7215 71 either either CC 40436 7215 72 to to TO 40436 7215 73 praise praise VB 40436 7215 74 or or CC 40436 7215 75 blame blame VB 40436 7215 76 . . . 40436 7216 1 Nearly nearly RB 40436 7216 2 at at IN 40436 7216 3 this this DT 40436 7216 4 point point NN 40436 7216 5 the the DT 40436 7216 6 greater great JJR 40436 7216 7 part part NN 40436 7216 8 of of IN 40436 7216 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7216 10 remain remain VBP 40436 7216 11 : : : 40436 7216 12 continuing continue VBG 40436 7216 13 to to TO 40436 7216 14 perform perform VB 40436 7216 15 moral moral JJ 40436 7216 16 acts act NNS 40436 7216 17 and and CC 40436 7216 18 to to TO 40436 7216 19 abstain abstain VB 40436 7216 20 from from IN 40436 7216 21 the the DT 40436 7216 22 contrary contrary NN 40436 7216 23 , , , 40436 7216 24 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 7216 25 from from IN 40436 7216 26 the the DT 40436 7216 27 habits habit NNS 40436 7216 28 which which WDT 40436 7216 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7216 30 have have VBP 40436 7216 31 acquired acquire VBN 40436 7216 32 , , , 40436 7216 33 and and CC 40436 7216 34 the the DT 40436 7216 35 authority authority NN 40436 7216 36 upon upon IN 40436 7216 37 which which WDT 40436 7216 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7216 39 originally originally RB 40436 7216 40 acted act VBD 40436 7216 41 : : : 40436 7216 42 though though IN 40436 7216 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7216 44 is be VBZ 40436 7216 45 not not RB 40436 7216 46 possible possible JJ 40436 7216 47 that that IN 40436 7216 48 any any DT 40436 7216 49 man man NN 40436 7216 50 should should MD 40436 7216 51 come come VB 40436 7216 52 to to IN 40436 7216 53 the the DT 40436 7216 54 years year NNS 40436 7216 55 and and CC 40436 7216 56 blessing blessing NN 40436 7216 57 of of IN 40436 7216 58 reason reason NN 40436 7216 59 , , , 40436 7216 60 without without IN 40436 7216 61 perceiving perceive VBG 40436 7216 62 at at IN 40436 7216 63 least least JJS 40436 7216 64 in in IN 40436 7216 65 an an DT 40436 7216 66 indistinct indistinct JJ 40436 7216 67 and and CC 40436 7216 68 general general JJ 40436 7216 69 way way NN 40436 7216 70 , , , 40436 7216 71 the the DT 40436 7216 72 advantage advantage NN 40436 7216 73 which which WDT 40436 7216 74 mankind mankind NN 40436 7216 75 derive derive VBP 40436 7216 76 from from IN 40436 7216 77 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7216 78 acting acting NN 40436 7216 79 towards towards IN 40436 7216 80 one one CD 40436 7216 81 another another DT 40436 7216 82 in in IN 40436 7216 83 one one CD 40436 7216 84 way way NN 40436 7216 85 rather rather RB 40436 7216 86 than than IN 40436 7216 87 another another DT 40436 7216 88 . . . 40436 7216 89 " " '' 40436 7216 90 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7217 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7217 2 Side side NN 40436 7217 3 - - HYPH 40436 7217 4 note note NN 40436 7217 5 : : : 40436 7217 6 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 7217 7 of of IN 40436 7217 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7217 9 and and CC 40436 7217 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7217 11 . . . 40436 7218 1 Whether whether IN 40436 7218 2 virtue virtue NN 40436 7218 3 is be VBZ 40436 7218 4 to to TO 40436 7218 5 be be VB 40436 7218 6 assimilated assimilate VBN 40436 7218 7 to to IN 40436 7218 8 a a DT 40436 7218 9 special special JJ 40436 7218 10 art art NN 40436 7218 11 . . . 40436 7218 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7219 1 In in IN 40436 7219 2 many many JJ 40436 7219 3 of of IN 40436 7219 4 the the DT 40436 7219 5 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7219 6 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 7219 7 , , , 40436 7219 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7219 9 is be VBZ 40436 7219 10 made make VBN 40436 7219 11 to to TO 40436 7219 12 dwell dwell VB 40436 7219 13 upon upon IN 40436 7219 14 the the DT 40436 7219 15 fact fact NN 40436 7219 16 that that IN 40436 7219 17 there there EX 40436 7219 18 are be VBP 40436 7219 19 no no DT 40436 7219 20 recognised recognised JJ 40436 7219 21 professional professional JJ 40436 7219 22 teachers teacher NNS 40436 7219 23 of of IN 40436 7219 24 virtue virtue NN 40436 7219 25 ; ; , 40436 7219 26 and and CC 40436 7219 27 to to TO 40436 7219 28 ground ground VB 40436 7219 29 upon upon IN 40436 7219 30 this this DT 40436 7219 31 fact fact NN 40436 7219 32 a a DT 40436 7219 33 doubt doubt NN 40436 7219 34 , , , 40436 7219 35 whether whether IN 40436 7219 36 virtue virtue NN 40436 7219 37 be be VBP 40436 7219 38 really really RB 40436 7219 39 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7219 40 . . . 40436 7220 1 But but CC 40436 7220 2 the the DT 40436 7220 3 present present JJ 40436 7220 4 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7220 5 is be VBZ 40436 7220 6 the the DT 40436 7220 7 only only JJ 40436 7220 8 one one CD 40436 7220 9 in in IN 40436 7220 10 which which WDT 40436 7220 11 the the DT 40436 7220 12 fact fact NN 40436 7220 13 is be VBZ 40436 7220 14 accounted account VBN 40436 7220 15 for for IN 40436 7220 16 , , , 40436 7220 17 and and CC 40436 7220 18 the the DT 40436 7220 19 doubt doubt NN 40436 7220 20 formally formally RB 40436 7220 21 answered answer VBD 40436 7220 22 . . . 40436 7221 1 There there EX 40436 7221 2 are be VBP 40436 7221 3 neither neither DT 40436 7221 4 special special JJ 40436 7221 5 teachers teacher NNS 40436 7221 6 , , , 40436 7221 7 nor nor CC 40436 7221 8 professed profess VBD 40436 7221 9 pupils pupil NNS 40436 7221 10 , , , 40436 7221 11 nor nor CC 40436 7221 12 determinate determinate VB 40436 7221 13 periods period NNS 40436 7221 14 of of IN 40436 7221 15 study study NN 40436 7221 16 , , , 40436 7221 17 nor nor CC 40436 7221 18 definite definite JJ 40436 7221 19 lessons lesson NNS 40436 7221 20 or or CC 40436 7221 21 stadia stadia NN 40436 7221 22 , , , 40436 7221 23 for for IN 40436 7221 24 the the DT 40436 7221 25 acquirement acquirement NN 40436 7221 26 of of IN 40436 7221 27 virtue virtue NN 40436 7221 28 , , , 40436 7221 29 as as IN 40436 7221 30 there there EX 40436 7221 31 are be VBP 40436 7221 32 for for IN 40436 7221 33 a a DT 40436 7221 34 particular particular JJ 40436 7221 35 art art NN 40436 7221 36 or or CC 40436 7221 37 craft craft NN 40436 7221 38 : : : 40436 7221 39 the the DT 40436 7221 40 reason reason NN 40436 7221 41 being being NN 40436 7221 42 , , , 40436 7221 43 that that IN 40436 7221 44 in in IN 40436 7221 45 that that DT 40436 7221 46 department department NN 40436 7221 47 every every DT 40436 7221 48 man man NN 40436 7221 49 must must MD 40436 7221 50 of of IN 40436 7221 51 necessity necessity NN 40436 7221 52 be be VB 40436 7221 53 a a DT 40436 7221 54 practitioner practitioner NN 40436 7221 55 , , , 40436 7221 56 more more RBR 40436 7221 57 or or CC 40436 7221 58 less less RBR 40436 7221 59 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 7221 60 : : : 40436 7221 61 every every DT 40436 7221 62 man man NN 40436 7221 63 has have VBZ 40436 7221 64 an an DT 40436 7221 65 interest interest NN 40436 7221 66 in in IN 40436 7221 67 communicating communicate VBG 40436 7221 68 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7221 69 to to IN 40436 7221 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7221 71 neighbour neighbour NN 40436 7221 72 : : : 40436 7221 73 hence hence RB 40436 7221 74 every every DT 40436 7221 75 man man NN 40436 7221 76 is be VBZ 40436 7221 77 constantly constantly RB 40436 7221 78 both both DT 40436 7221 79 teacher teacher NN 40436 7221 80 and and CC 40436 7221 81 learner learner NN 40436 7221 82 . . . 40436 7222 1 Herein Herein NNP 40436 7222 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 7222 3 one one CD 40436 7222 4 main main JJ 40436 7222 5 and and CC 40436 7222 6 real real JJ 40436 7222 7 distinction distinction NN 40436 7222 8 between between IN 40436 7222 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 7222 10 and and CC 40436 7222 11 the the DT 40436 7222 12 special special JJ 40436 7222 13 arts art NNS 40436 7222 14 ; ; : 40436 7222 15 an an DT 40436 7222 16 answer answer NN 40436 7222 17 to to IN 40436 7222 18 the the DT 40436 7222 19 view view NN 40436 7222 20 most most RBS 40436 7222 21 frequently frequently RB 40436 7222 22 espoused espouse VBN 40436 7222 23 by by IN 40436 7222 24 the the DT 40436 7222 25 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7222 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7222 27 , , , 40436 7222 28 assimilating assimilate VBG 40436 7222 29 virtue virtue NN 40436 7222 30 to to IN 40436 7222 31 a a DT 40436 7222 32 professional professional JJ 40436 7222 33 craft craft NN 40436 7222 34 , , , 40436 7222 35 which which WDT 40436 7222 36 ought ought MD 40436 7222 37 to to TO 40436 7222 38 have have VB 40436 7222 39 special special JJ 40436 7222 40 teachers teacher NNS 40436 7222 41 , , , 40436 7222 42 and and CC 40436 7222 43 a a DT 40436 7222 44 special special JJ 40436 7222 45 season season NN 40436 7222 46 of of IN 40436 7222 47 apprenticeship apprenticeship NN 40436 7222 48 , , , 40436 7222 49 if if IN 40436 7222 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7222 51 is be VBZ 40436 7222 52 to to TO 40436 7222 53 be be VB 40436 7222 54 acquired acquire VBN 40436 7222 55 at at RB 40436 7222 56 all all RB 40436 7222 57 . . . 40436 7223 1 The the DT 40436 7223 2 speech speech NN 40436 7223 3 is be VBZ 40436 7223 4 censured censure VBN 40436 7223 5 by by IN 40436 7223 6 some some DT 40436 7223 7 critics critic NNS 40436 7223 8 as as IN 40436 7223 9 prolix prolix JJ 40436 7223 10 . . . 40436 7224 1 But but CC 40436 7224 2 to to IN 40436 7224 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7224 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7224 5 seems seem VBZ 40436 7224 6 full full JJ 40436 7224 7 of of IN 40436 7224 8 matter matter NN 40436 7224 9 and and CC 40436 7224 10 argument argument NN 40436 7224 11 , , , 40436 7224 12 exceedingly exceedingly RB 40436 7224 13 free free JJ 40436 7224 14 from from IN 40436 7224 15 superfluous superfluous JJ 40436 7224 16 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 7224 17 . . . 40436 7225 1 The the DT 40436 7225 2 fable fable JJ 40436 7225 3 with with IN 40436 7225 4 which which WDT 40436 7225 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7225 6 opens open VBZ 40436 7225 7 presents present NNS 40436 7225 8 of of IN 40436 7225 9 course course NN 40436 7225 10 the the DT 40436 7225 11 poetical poetical JJ 40436 7225 12 ornament ornament NN 40436 7225 13 which which WDT 40436 7225 14 belongs belong VBZ 40436 7225 15 to to IN 40436 7225 16 that that DT 40436 7225 17 manner manner NN 40436 7225 18 of of IN 40436 7225 19 handling handling NN 40436 7225 20 . . . 40436 7226 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7226 2 is be VBZ 40436 7226 3 however however RB 40436 7226 4 fully fully RB 40436 7226 5 equal equal JJ 40436 7226 6 , , , 40436 7226 7 in in IN 40436 7226 8 point point NN 40436 7226 9 of of IN 40436 7226 10 perspicuity perspicuity NN 40436 7226 11 as as RB 40436 7226 12 well well RB 40436 7226 13 as as IN 40436 7226 14 charm charm NN 40436 7226 15 -- -- : 40436 7226 16 in in IN 40436 7226 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7226 18 judgment judgment NN 40436 7226 19 , , , 40436 7226 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7226 21 is be VBZ 40436 7226 22 even even RB 40436 7226 23 superior superior JJ 40436 7226 24 to to IN 40436 7226 25 any any DT 40436 7226 26 other other JJ 40436 7226 27 fable fable NN 40436 7226 28 in in IN 40436 7226 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7226 30 . . . 40436 7227 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7227 2 Side side NN 40436 7227 3 - - HYPH 40436 7227 4 note note NN 40436 7227 5 : : : 40436 7227 6 Procedure procedure NN 40436 7227 7 of of IN 40436 7227 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7227 9 in in IN 40436 7227 10 regard regard NN 40436 7227 11 to to IN 40436 7227 12 the the DT 40436 7227 13 discourse discourse NN 40436 7227 14 of of IN 40436 7227 15 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7227 16 -- -- : 40436 7227 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7227 18 compliments compliment VBZ 40436 7227 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7227 20 as as IN 40436 7227 21 an an DT 40436 7227 22 exposition exposition NN 40436 7227 23 , , , 40436 7227 24 and and CC 40436 7227 25 analyses analyse VBZ 40436 7227 26 some some DT 40436 7227 27 of of IN 40436 7227 28 the the DT 40436 7227 29 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 7227 30 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 7227 31 . . . 40436 7227 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7228 1 When when WRB 40436 7228 2 the the DT 40436 7228 3 harangue harangue NN 40436 7228 4 , , , 40436 7228 5 lecture lecture NN 40436 7228 6 , , , 40436 7228 7 or or CC 40436 7228 8 sermon sermon JJ 40436 7228 9 , , , 40436 7228 10 of of IN 40436 7228 11 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7228 12 is be VBZ 40436 7228 13 concluded conclude VBN 40436 7228 14 , , , 40436 7228 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7228 16 both both DT 40436 7228 17 expresses express VBZ 40436 7228 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7228 19 profound profound JJ 40436 7228 20 admiration admiration NN 40436 7228 21 of of IN 40436 7228 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7228 23 , , , 40436 7228 24 and and CC 40436 7228 25 admits admit VBZ 40436 7228 26 the the DT 40436 7228 27 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 7228 28 -- -- : 40436 7228 29 That that DT 40436 7228 30 virtue virtue NN 40436 7228 31 is be VBZ 40436 7228 32 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7228 33 -- -- : 40436 7228 34 to to TO 40436 7228 35 be be VB 40436 7228 36 made make VBN 40436 7228 37 out out RP 40436 7228 38 , , , 40436 7228 39 as as RB 40436 7228 40 well well RB 40436 7228 41 as as IN 40436 7228 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7228 43 can can MD 40436 7228 44 be be VB 40436 7228 45 made make VBN 40436 7228 46 out out RP 40436 7228 47 by by IN 40436 7228 48 any any DT 40436 7228 49 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7228 50 exposition exposition NN 40436 7228 51 . . . 40436 7229 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7229 2 57 57 CD 40436 7229 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7229 4 In in IN 40436 7229 5 fact fact NN 40436 7229 6 , , , 40436 7229 7 the the DT 40436 7229 8 speaker speaker NN 40436 7229 9 has have VBZ 40436 7229 10 done do VBN 40436 7229 11 all all DT 40436 7229 12 that that WDT 40436 7229 13 could could MD 40436 7229 14 be be VB 40436 7229 15 done do VBN 40436 7229 16 by by IN 40436 7229 17 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 7229 18 or or CC 40436 7229 19 the the DT 40436 7229 20 best good JJS 40436 7229 21 orator orator NN 40436 7229 22 of of IN 40436 7229 23 the the DT 40436 7229 24 assembly assembly NN 40436 7229 25 . . . 40436 7230 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7230 2 has have VBZ 40436 7230 3 given give VBN 40436 7230 4 a a DT 40436 7230 5 long long JJ 40436 7230 6 series series NN 40436 7230 7 of of IN 40436 7230 8 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 7230 9 in in IN 40436 7230 10 support support NN 40436 7230 11 of of IN 40436 7230 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7230 13 own own JJ 40436 7230 14 case case NN 40436 7230 15 , , , 40436 7230 16 without without IN 40436 7230 17 stopping stop VBG 40436 7230 18 to to TO 40436 7230 19 hear hear VB 40436 7230 20 the the DT 40436 7230 21 doubts doubt NNS 40436 7230 22 of of IN 40436 7230 23 opponents opponent NNS 40436 7230 24 . . . 40436 7231 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7231 2 has have VBZ 40436 7231 3 sailed sail VBN 40436 7231 4 along along RB 40436 7231 5 triumphantly triumphantly RB 40436 7231 6 upon upon IN 40436 7231 7 the the DT 40436 7231 8 stream stream NN 40436 7231 9 of of IN 40436 7231 10 public public JJ 40436 7231 11 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 7231 12 , , , 40436 7231 13 accepting accept VBG 40436 7231 14 all all PDT 40436 7231 15 the the DT 40436 7231 16 established established JJ 40436 7231 17 beliefs belief NNS 40436 7231 18 -- -- : 40436 7231 19 appealing appeal VBG 40436 7231 20 to to IN 40436 7231 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7231 22 hearers hearer NNS 40436 7231 23 with with IN 40436 7231 24 all all PDT 40436 7231 25 those those DT 40436 7231 26 familiar familiar JJ 40436 7231 27 phrases phrase NNS 40436 7231 28 , , , 40436 7231 29 round round IN 40436 7231 30 which which WDT 40436 7231 31 the the DT 40436 7231 32 most most RBS 40436 7231 33 powerful powerful JJ 40436 7231 34 associations association NNS 40436 7231 35 are be VBP 40436 7231 36 grouped group VBN 40436 7231 37 -- -- : 40436 7231 38 and and CC 40436 7231 39 taking take VBG 40436 7231 40 for for IN 40436 7231 41 granted grant VBN 40436 7231 42 that that DT 40436 7231 43 justice justice NN 40436 7231 44 , , , 40436 7231 45 virtue virtue NN 40436 7231 46 , , , 40436 7231 47 good good JJ 40436 7231 48 , , , 40436 7231 49 evil evil NN 40436 7231 50 , , , 40436 7231 51 & & CC 40436 7231 52 c. c. NNP 40436 7231 53 , , , 40436 7231 54 are be VBP 40436 7231 55 known know VBN 40436 7231 56 , , , 40436 7231 57 indisputable indisputable JJ 40436 7231 58 , , , 40436 7231 59 determinate determinate VB 40436 7231 60 data datum NNS 40436 7231 61 , , , 40436 7231 62 fully fully RB 40436 7231 63 understood understand VBD 40436 7231 64 , , , 40436 7231 65 and and CC 40436 7231 66 unanimously unanimously RB 40436 7231 67 interpreted interpret VBN 40436 7231 68 . . . 40436 7232 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7232 2 has have VBZ 40436 7232 3 shown show VBN 40436 7232 4 that that IN 40436 7232 5 the the DT 40436 7232 6 community community NN 40436 7232 7 take take VBP 40436 7232 8 great great JJ 40436 7232 9 pains pain NNS 40436 7232 10 , , , 40436 7232 11 both both CC 40436 7232 12 publicly publicly RB 40436 7232 13 and and CC 40436 7232 14 privately privately RB 40436 7232 15 , , , 40436 7232 16 to to TO 40436 7232 17 inculcate inculcate VB 40436 7232 18 and and CC 40436 7232 19 enforce enforce VB 40436 7232 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 7232 21 : : : 40436 7232 22 that that RB 40436 7232 23 is is RB 40436 7232 24 , , , 40436 7232 25 what what WP 40436 7232 26 _ _ NNP 40436 7232 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7232 28 _ _ NNP 40436 7232 29 believe believe VBP 40436 7232 30 in in RP 40436 7232 31 and and CC 40436 7232 32 esteem esteem VB 40436 7232 33 as as IN 40436 7232 34 virtue virtue NN 40436 7232 35 . . . 40436 7233 1 But but CC 40436 7233 2 is be VBZ 40436 7233 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7233 4 belief belief NN 40436 7233 5 well well RB 40436 7233 6 founded found VBN 40436 7233 7 ? ? . 40436 7234 1 Is be VBZ 40436 7234 2 that that DT 40436 7234 3 which which WDT 40436 7234 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7234 5 esteem esteem VBP 40436 7234 6 , , , 40436 7234 7 really really RB 40436 7234 8 virtue virtue JJ 40436 7234 9 ? ? . 40436 7235 1 Do do VBP 40436 7235 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7235 3 and and CC 40436 7235 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7235 5 elegant elegant JJ 40436 7235 6 spokesman spokesman NN 40436 7235 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7235 8 , , , 40436 7235 9 know know VB 40436 7235 10 what what WP 40436 7235 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 7235 12 is be VBZ 40436 7235 13 ? ? . 40436 7236 1 If if IN 40436 7236 2 so so RB 40436 7236 3 , , , 40436 7236 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7236 5 how how WRB 40436 7236 6 _ _ NNP 40436 7236 7 do do VBP 40436 7236 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7236 9 know know VB 40436 7236 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7236 11 , , , 40436 7236 12 and and CC 40436 7236 13 can can MD 40436 7236 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7236 15 explain explain VB 40436 7236 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7236 17 ? ? . 40436 7237 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7237 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7237 3 57 57 CD 40436 7237 4 : : : 40436 7237 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7237 6 , , , 40436 7237 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7237 8 . . . 40436 7238 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7238 2 . . . 40436 7239 1 328 328 CD 40436 7239 2 - - SYM 40436 7239 3 329 329 CD 40436 7239 4 . . . 40436 7240 1 Very very RB 40436 7240 2 different different JJ 40436 7240 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 7240 4 is be VBZ 40436 7240 5 the the DT 40436 7240 6 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 7240 7 of of IN 40436 7240 8 the the DT 40436 7240 9 principal principal JJ 40436 7240 10 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7240 11 commentators commentator NNS 40436 7240 12 . . . 40436 7241 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 7241 2 will will MD 40436 7241 3 not not RB 40436 7241 4 allow allow VB 40436 7241 5 the the DT 40436 7241 6 mythus mythus NN 40436 7241 7 of of IN 40436 7241 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7241 9 to to TO 40436 7241 10 be be VB 40436 7241 11 counted count VBN 40436 7241 12 among among IN 40436 7241 13 the the DT 40436 7241 14 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7241 15 mythes mythe NNS 40436 7241 16 : : : 40436 7241 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7241 18 says say VBZ 40436 7241 19 that that IN 40436 7241 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7241 21 is be VBZ 40436 7241 22 composed compose VBN 40436 7241 23 in in IN 40436 7241 24 the the DT 40436 7241 25 style style NN 40436 7241 26 of of IN 40436 7241 27 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7241 28 , , , 40436 7241 29 and and CC 40436 7241 30 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 7241 31 copied copy VBN 40436 7241 32 from from IN 40436 7241 33 some some DT 40436 7241 34 real real JJ 40436 7241 35 composition composition NN 40436 7241 36 of of IN 40436 7241 37 that that DT 40436 7241 38 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7241 39 . . . 40436 7242 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7242 2 finds find VBZ 40436 7242 3 in in IN 40436 7242 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7242 5 nothing nothing NN 40436 7242 6 but but IN 40436 7242 7 a a DT 40436 7242 8 " " `` 40436 7242 9 grobmaterialistiche grobmaterialistiche JJ 40436 7242 10 Denkungsart Denkungsart NNP 40436 7242 11 , , , 40436 7242 12 die die VB 40436 7242 13 über über NN 40436 7242 14 die die VBP 40436 7242 15 sinnliche sinnliche NNP 40436 7242 16 Erfahrung Erfahrung NNP 40436 7242 17 nicht nicht NNP 40436 7242 18 hinaus hinaus NNP 40436 7242 19 philosophirt philosophirt NN 40436 7242 20 " " '' 40436 7242 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7242 22 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 7242 23 zum zum VB 40436 7242 24 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7242 25 , , , 40436 7242 26 vol vol NNP 40436 7242 27 . . . 40436 7243 1 i. i. NNP 40436 7243 2 pp pp NNP 40436 7243 3 . . . 40436 7244 1 233 233 CD 40436 7244 2 - - HYPH 40436 7244 3 234 234 CD 40436 7244 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7244 5 . . . 40436 7245 1 To to IN 40436 7245 2 the the DT 40436 7245 3 like like JJ 40436 7245 4 purpose purpose NN 40436 7245 5 Ast Ast NNP 40436 7245 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7245 7 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7245 8 . . . 40436 7246 1 Leb Leb NNP 40436 7246 2 . . . 40436 7247 1 p. p. NN 40436 7247 2 71)--who 71)--who NNP 40436 7247 3 tells tell VBZ 40436 7247 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7247 5 that that IN 40436 7247 6 what what WP 40436 7247 7 is be VBZ 40436 7247 8 expressed express VBN 40436 7247 9 in in IN 40436 7247 10 the the DT 40436 7247 11 mythus mythus NN 40436 7247 12 is be VBZ 40436 7247 13 , , , 40436 7247 14 " " `` 40436 7247 15 the the DT 40436 7247 16 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 7247 17 and and CC 40436 7247 18 mean mean VB 40436 7247 19 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 7247 20 and and CC 40436 7247 21 manner manner NN 40436 7247 22 of of IN 40436 7247 23 thought thought NN 40436 7247 24 of of IN 40436 7247 25 the the DT 40436 7247 26 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7247 27 : : : 40436 7247 28 for for IN 40436 7247 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7247 30 deduces deduce VBZ 40436 7247 31 every every DT 40436 7247 32 thing thing NN 40436 7247 33 , , , 40436 7247 34 both both CC 40436 7247 35 arts art NNS 40436 7247 36 and and CC 40436 7247 37 the the DT 40436 7247 38 social social NNP 40436 7247 39 union union NNP 40436 7247 40 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7247 41 , , , 40436 7247 42 from from IN 40436 7247 43 human human JJ 40436 7247 44 wants want NNS 40436 7247 45 and and CC 40436 7247 46 necessity necessity NN 40436 7247 47 " " '' 40436 7247 48 . . . 40436 7248 1 Apparently apparently RB 40436 7248 2 these these DT 40436 7248 3 critics critic NNS 40436 7248 4 , , , 40436 7248 5 when when WRB 40436 7248 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7248 7 treat treat VBP 40436 7248 8 this this DT 40436 7248 9 as as IN 40436 7248 10 a a DT 40436 7248 11 proof proof NN 40436 7248 12 of of IN 40436 7248 13 meanness meanness NN 40436 7248 14 and and CC 40436 7248 15 vulgarity vulgarity NN 40436 7248 16 , , , 40436 7248 17 have have VBP 40436 7248 18 forgotten forget VBN 40436 7248 19 that that IN 40436 7248 20 the the DT 40436 7248 21 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7248 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7248 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7248 24 does do VBZ 40436 7248 25 exactly exactly RB 40436 7248 26 the the DT 40436 7248 27 same same JJ 40436 7248 28 thing thing NN 40436 7248 29 in in IN 40436 7248 30 the the DT 40436 7248 31 Republic Republic NNP 40436 7248 32 -- -- : 40436 7248 33 deriving derive VBG 40436 7248 34 the the DT 40436 7248 35 entire entire JJ 40436 7248 36 social social JJ 40436 7248 37 union union NN 40436 7248 38 from from IN 40436 7248 39 human human JJ 40436 7248 40 necessities necessity NNS 40436 7248 41 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7248 42 Republ Republ NNP 40436 7248 43 . . . 40436 7249 1 ii ii LS 40436 7249 2 . . . 40436 7250 1 369 369 CD 40436 7250 2 C C NNP 40436 7250 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7250 4 . . . 40436 7251 1 K. K. NNP 40436 7251 2 F. F. NNP 40436 7251 3 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 7251 4 is be VBZ 40436 7251 5 hardly hardly RB 40436 7251 6 less less RBR 40436 7251 7 severe severe JJ 40436 7251 8 upon upon IN 40436 7251 9 the the DT 40436 7251 10 Protagorean protagorean JJ 40436 7251 11 discourse discourse NN 40436 7251 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7251 13 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 7251 14 . . . 40436 7252 1 und und JJ 40436 7252 2 Syst Syst NNP 40436 7252 3 . . . 40436 7253 1 der der NNP 40436 7253 2 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7253 3 . . . 40436 7254 1 Phil Phil NNP 40436 7254 2 . . . 40436 7255 1 p. p. NN 40436 7255 2 460 460 CD 40436 7255 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7255 4 . . . 40436 7256 1 For for IN 40436 7256 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7256 3 part part NN 40436 7256 4 , , , 40436 7256 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7256 6 take take VBP 40436 7256 7 a a DT 40436 7256 8 view view NN 40436 7256 9 altogether altogether RB 40436 7256 10 opposed oppose VBN 40436 7256 11 to to IN 40436 7256 12 these these DT 40436 7256 13 learned learn VBN 40436 7256 14 persons person NNS 40436 7256 15 . . . 40436 7257 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7257 2 think think VBP 40436 7257 3 the the DT 40436 7257 4 discourse discourse NN 40436 7257 5 one one CD 40436 7257 6 of of IN 40436 7257 7 the the DT 40436 7257 8 most most RBS 40436 7257 9 striking striking JJ 40436 7257 10 and and CC 40436 7257 11 instructive instructive JJ 40436 7257 12 portions portion NNS 40436 7257 13 of of IN 40436 7257 14 the the DT 40436 7257 15 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7257 16 writings writing NNS 40436 7257 17 : : : 40436 7257 18 and and CC 40436 7257 19 if if IN 40436 7257 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7257 21 could could MD 40436 7257 22 believe believe VB 40436 7257 23 that that IN 40436 7257 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7257 25 was be VBD 40436 7257 26 the the DT 40436 7257 27 composition composition NN 40436 7257 28 of of IN 40436 7257 29 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7257 30 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7257 31 , , , 40436 7257 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7257 33 estimation estimation NN 40436 7257 34 of of IN 40436 7257 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7257 36 would would MD 40436 7257 37 be be VB 40436 7257 38 considerably considerably RB 40436 7257 39 raised raise VBN 40436 7257 40 . . . 40436 7258 1 Steinhart steinhart NN 40436 7258 2 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 7258 3 a a DT 40436 7258 4 much much RB 40436 7258 5 more more RBR 40436 7258 6 rational rational JJ 40436 7258 7 and and CC 40436 7258 8 equitable equitable JJ 40436 7258 9 judgment judgment NN 40436 7258 10 than than IN 40436 7258 11 Ast Ast NNP 40436 7258 12 and and CC 40436 7258 13 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 7258 14 , , , 40436 7258 15 upon upon IN 40436 7258 16 the the DT 40436 7258 17 discourse discourse NN 40436 7258 18 of of IN 40436 7258 19 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7258 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7258 21 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 7258 22 zum zum VB 40436 7258 23 Prot Prot NNP 40436 7258 24 . . . 40436 7259 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7259 2 . . . 40436 7260 1 422 422 CD 40436 7260 2 - - SYM 40436 7260 3 423 423 CD 40436 7260 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7260 5 . . . 40436 7260 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7261 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7261 2 Side side NN 40436 7261 3 - - HYPH 40436 7261 4 note note NN 40436 7261 5 : : : 40436 7261 6 One one CD 40436 7261 7 purpose purpose NN 40436 7261 8 of of IN 40436 7261 9 the the DT 40436 7261 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7261 11 . . . 40436 7262 1 To to TO 40436 7262 2 contrast contrast VB 40436 7262 3 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7262 4 discourse discourse NN 40436 7262 5 with with IN 40436 7262 6 short short JJ 40436 7262 7 cross cross NN 40436 7262 8 - - JJ 40436 7262 9 examining examine VBG 40436 7262 10 question question NN 40436 7262 11 and and CC 40436 7262 12 answer answer NN 40436 7262 13 . . . 40436 7262 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7263 1 This this DT 40436 7263 2 is be VBZ 40436 7263 3 the the DT 40436 7263 4 point point NN 40436 7263 5 upon upon IN 40436 7263 6 which which WDT 40436 7263 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7263 8 now now RB 40436 7263 9 brings bring VBZ 40436 7263 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7263 11 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 7263 12 to to TO 40436 7263 13 bear bear VB 40436 7263 14 : : : 40436 7263 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7263 16 method method NN 40436 7263 17 of of IN 40436 7263 18 short short JJ 40436 7263 19 question question NN 40436 7263 20 and and CC 40436 7263 21 answer answer NN 40436 7263 22 . . . 40436 7264 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7264 2 have have VBP 40436 7264 3 seen see VBN 40436 7264 4 what what WP 40436 7264 5 long long JJ 40436 7264 6 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7264 7 speaking speaking NN 40436 7264 8 can can MD 40436 7264 9 do do VB 40436 7264 10 : : : 40436 7264 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7264 12 have have VBP 40436 7264 13 now now RB 40436 7264 14 to to TO 40436 7264 15 see see VB 40436 7264 16 what what WP 40436 7264 17 short short JJ 40436 7264 18 cross cross NN 40436 7264 19 - - NN 40436 7264 20 questioning questioning NN 40436 7264 21 can can MD 40436 7264 22 do do VB 40436 7264 23 . . . 40436 7265 1 The the DT 40436 7265 2 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 7265 3 between between IN 40436 7265 4 the the DT 40436 7265 5 two two CD 40436 7265 6 is be VBZ 40436 7265 7 at at RB 40436 7265 8 least least RBS 40436 7265 9 one one CD 40436 7265 10 main main JJ 40436 7265 11 purpose purpose NN 40436 7265 12 of of IN 40436 7265 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7265 14 -- -- : 40436 7265 15 if if IN 40436 7265 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7265 17 be be VB 40436 7265 18 not not RB 40436 7265 19 even even RB 40436 7265 20 _ _ NNP 40436 7265 21 the the DT 40436 7265 22 _ _ NNP 40436 7265 23 purpose purpose NN 40436 7265 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7265 25 as as IN 40436 7265 26 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 7265 27 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 7265 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7265 29 to to TO 40436 7265 30 be be VB 40436 7265 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7265 32 in in IN 40436 7265 33 this this DT 40436 7265 34 memorable memorable JJ 40436 7265 35 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7265 36 . . . 40436 7266 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7266 2 Side side NN 40436 7266 3 - - HYPH 40436 7266 4 note note NN 40436 7266 5 : : : 40436 7266 6 Questions question NNS 40436 7266 7 by by IN 40436 7266 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7266 9 -- -- : 40436 7266 10 Whether whether IN 40436 7266 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 7266 12 is be VBZ 40436 7266 13 one one CD 40436 7266 14 and and CC 40436 7266 15 indivisible indivisible JJ 40436 7266 16 , , , 40436 7266 17 or or CC 40436 7266 18 composed compose VBN 40436 7266 19 of of IN 40436 7266 20 different different JJ 40436 7266 21 parts part NNS 40436 7266 22 ? ? . 40436 7267 1 Whether whether IN 40436 7267 2 the the DT 40436 7267 3 parts part NNS 40436 7267 4 are be VBP 40436 7267 5 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 40436 7267 6 or or CC 40436 7267 7 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ 40436 7267 8 ? ? . 40436 7267 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7268 1 After after IN 40436 7268 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7268 3 copious copious JJ 40436 7268 4 exposition exposition NN 40436 7268 5 , , , 40436 7268 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7268 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7268 8 says say VBZ 40436 7268 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7268 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7268 11 , , , 40436 7268 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7268 13 have have VBP 40436 7268 14 only only RB 40436 7268 15 one one CD 40436 7268 16 little little JJ 40436 7268 17 doubt doubt NN 40436 7268 18 remaining remain VBG 40436 7268 19 , , , 40436 7268 20 which which WDT 40436 7268 21 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7268 22 will will MD 40436 7268 23 easily easily RB 40436 7268 24 explain explain VB 40436 7268 25 . . . 40436 7269 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7269 2 58 58 CD 40436 7269 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7269 4 You -PRON- PRP 40436 7269 5 have have VBP 40436 7269 6 several several JJ 40436 7269 7 times time NNS 40436 7269 8 spoken speak VBN 40436 7269 9 of of IN 40436 7269 10 justice justice NN 40436 7269 11 , , , 40436 7269 12 moderation moderation NN 40436 7269 13 , , , 40436 7269 14 holiness holiness NNP 40436 7269 15 , , , 40436 7269 16 & & CC 40436 7269 17 c. c. NNP 40436 7269 18 , , , 40436 7269 19 as as IN 40436 7269 20 if if IN 40436 7269 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7269 22 all all DT 40436 7269 23 , , , 40436 7269 24 taken take VBN 40436 7269 25 collectively collectively RB 40436 7269 26 , , , 40436 7269 27 made make VBN 40436 7269 28 up up RP 40436 7269 29 virtue virtue NN 40436 7269 30 . . . 40436 7270 1 Do do VBP 40436 7270 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7270 3 mean mean VB 40436 7270 4 that that DT 40436 7270 5 virtue virtue NN 40436 7270 6 is be VBZ 40436 7270 7 a a DT 40436 7270 8 Whole Whole NNP 40436 7270 9 , , , 40436 7270 10 and and CC 40436 7270 11 that that IN 40436 7270 12 these these DT 40436 7270 13 three three CD 40436 7270 14 names name NNS 40436 7270 15 denote denote VBP 40436 7270 16 distinct distinct JJ 40436 7270 17 parts part NNS 40436 7270 18 of of IN 40436 7270 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7270 20 ? ? . 40436 7271 1 Or or CC 40436 7271 2 are be VBP 40436 7271 3 the the DT 40436 7271 4 three three CD 40436 7271 5 names name NNS 40436 7271 6 all all DT 40436 7271 7 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 7271 8 to to TO 40436 7271 9 virtue virtue JJ 40436 7271 10 , , , 40436 7271 11 different different JJ 40436 7271 12 names name NNS 40436 7271 13 for for IN 40436 7271 14 one one CD 40436 7271 15 and and CC 40436 7271 16 are be VBP 40436 7271 17 the the DT 40436 7271 18 same same JJ 40436 7271 19 thing thing NN 40436 7271 20 ? ? . 40436 7272 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7272 2 Prot._--They Prot._--They NNP 40436 7272 3 are be VBP 40436 7272 4 names name NNS 40436 7272 5 signifying signify VBG 40436 7272 6 distinct distinct JJ 40436 7272 7 parts part NNS 40436 7272 8 of of IN 40436 7272 9 virtue virtue NN 40436 7272 10 . . . 40436 7273 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7273 2 Sokr._--Are Sokr._--Are NNP 40436 7273 3 these these DT 40436 7273 4 parts part NNS 40436 7273 5 like like IN 40436 7273 6 the the DT 40436 7273 7 parts part NNS 40436 7273 8 of of IN 40436 7273 9 the the DT 40436 7273 10 face,--eyes face,--eyes NNP 40436 7273 11 , , , 40436 7273 12 nose nose NN 40436 7273 13 , , , 40436 7273 14 mouth mouth NN 40436 7273 15 , , , 40436 7273 16 ears ear NNS 40436 7273 17 -- -- : 40436 7273 18 each each DT 40436 7273 19 part part NN 40436 7273 20 not not RB 40436 7273 21 only only RB 40436 7273 22 distinct distinct JJ 40436 7273 23 from from IN 40436 7273 24 the the DT 40436 7273 25 rest rest NN 40436 7273 26 , , , 40436 7273 27 but but CC 40436 7273 28 having have VBG 40436 7273 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7273 30 own own JJ 40436 7273 31 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 7273 32 properties property NNS 40436 7273 33 ? ? . 40436 7274 1 Or or CC 40436 7274 2 are be VBP 40436 7274 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7274 4 like like IN 40436 7274 5 the the DT 40436 7274 6 parts part NNS 40436 7274 7 of of IN 40436 7274 8 gold gold NN 40436 7274 9 , , , 40436 7274 10 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 40436 7274 11 with with IN 40436 7274 12 each each DT 40436 7274 13 other other JJ 40436 7274 14 and and CC 40436 7274 15 with with IN 40436 7274 16 the the DT 40436 7274 17 whole whole NN 40436 7274 18 , , , 40436 7274 19 differing differ VBG 40436 7274 20 only only RB 40436 7274 21 in in IN 40436 7274 22 magnitude magnitude NN 40436 7274 23 ? ? . 40436 7275 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7275 2 Prot._--The Prot._--The NNP 40436 7275 3 former former JJ 40436 7275 4 . . . 40436 7276 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7276 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 7276 3 some some DT 40436 7276 4 men man NNS 40436 7276 5 may may MD 40436 7276 6 possess possess VB 40436 7276 7 one one CD 40436 7276 8 part part NN 40436 7276 9 , , , 40436 7276 10 some some DT 40436 7276 11 another another DT 40436 7276 12 . . . 40436 7277 1 Or or CC 40436 7277 2 is be VBZ 40436 7277 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7277 4 necessary necessary JJ 40436 7277 5 that that IN 40436 7277 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7277 7 who who WP 40436 7277 8 possesses possess VBZ 40436 7277 9 one one CD 40436 7277 10 part part NN 40436 7277 11 , , , 40436 7277 12 should should MD 40436 7277 13 possess possess VB 40436 7277 14 all all DT 40436 7277 15 ? ? . 40436 7278 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7278 2 Prot._--By Prot._--By NNP 40436 7278 3 no no DT 40436 7278 4 means means NN 40436 7278 5 necessary necessary JJ 40436 7278 6 . . . 40436 7279 1 Some some DT 40436 7279 2 men man NNS 40436 7279 3 are be VBP 40436 7279 4 courageous courageous JJ 40436 7279 5 , , , 40436 7279 6 but but CC 40436 7279 7 unjust unjust JJ 40436 7279 8 : : : 40436 7279 9 others other NNS 40436 7279 10 are be VBP 40436 7279 11 just just RB 40436 7279 12 , , , 40436 7279 13 but but CC 40436 7279 14 not not RB 40436 7279 15 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 7279 16 . . . 40436 7280 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7280 2 Sokr._--Wisdom Sokr._--Wisdom NNP 40436 7280 3 and and CC 40436 7280 4 courage courage NNP 40436 7280 5 then then RB 40436 7280 6 , , , 40436 7280 7 both both DT 40436 7280 8 of of IN 40436 7280 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7280 10 , , , 40436 7280 11 are be VBP 40436 7280 12 parts part NNS 40436 7280 13 of of IN 40436 7280 14 virtue virtue NN 40436 7280 15 ? ? . 40436 7281 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7281 2 Prot._--They Prot._--They NNP 40436 7281 3 are be VBP 40436 7281 4 so so RB 40436 7281 5 . . . 40436 7282 1 Wisdom wisdom NN 40436 7282 2 is be VBZ 40436 7282 3 the the DT 40436 7282 4 greatest great JJS 40436 7282 5 of of IN 40436 7282 6 the the DT 40436 7282 7 parts part NNS 40436 7282 8 : : : 40436 7282 9 but but CC 40436 7282 10 no no DT 40436 7282 11 one one NN 40436 7282 12 of of IN 40436 7282 13 the the DT 40436 7282 14 parts part NNS 40436 7282 15 is be VBZ 40436 7282 16 the the DT 40436 7282 17 exact exact JJ 40436 7282 18 likeness likeness NN 40436 7282 19 of of IN 40436 7282 20 another another DT 40436 7282 21 : : : 40436 7282 22 each each DT 40436 7282 23 of of IN 40436 7282 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7282 25 has have VBZ 40436 7282 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7282 27 own own JJ 40436 7282 28 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 7282 29 property property NN 40436 7282 30 . . . 40436 7283 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7283 2 59 59 CD 40436 7283 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7283 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7283 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7283 6 58 58 CD 40436 7283 7 : : : 40436 7283 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7283 9 , , , 40436 7283 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7283 11 . . . 40436 7284 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7284 2 . . . 40436 7285 1 328 328 CD 40436 7285 2 E--329 e--329 SYM 40436 7285 3 B. b. NN 40436 7286 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7286 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7286 3 : : : 40436 7286 4 plê\n plê\n NNP 40436 7286 5 smikro smikro NN 40436 7286 6 / / SYM 40436 7286 7 n n NNP 40436 7286 8 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 7286 9 moi moi NNP 40436 7286 10 e)mpodô e)mpodô NNP 40436 7286 11 / / SYM 40436 7286 12 n n NNP 40436 7286 13 , , , 40436 7286 14 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 7286 15 dê dê NNP 40436 7286 16 = = SYM 40436 7286 17 lon lon NN 40436 7286 18 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 7286 19 Prôtago Prôtago NNP 40436 7286 20 / / SYM 40436 7286 21 ras ras NNP 40436 7286 22 r(a|di r(a|di NNP 40436 7286 23 / / SYM 40436 7286 24 ôs ôs NNP 40436 7286 25 e)pekdida e)pekdida NNP 40436 7286 26 / / SYM 40436 7286 27 xei xei NN 40436 7286 28 . . . 40436 7287 1 . . . 40436 7288 1 . . . 40436 7289 1 . . . 40436 7290 1 smikrou= smikrou= NNP 40436 7290 2 tinos tinos NNP 40436 7290 3 e)ndeê e)ndeê NNP 40436 7290 4 / / SYM 40436 7290 5 s s NNP 40436 7290 6 ei)mi ei)mi NNP 40436 7290 7 pa pa NNP 40436 7290 8 / / SYM 40436 7290 9 nt nt RB 40436 7290 10 ' ' '' 40436 7290 11 e)/chein e)/chein NN 40436 7290 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7290 13 , , , 40436 7290 14 & & CC 40436 7290 15 c. c. NNP 40436 7290 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7290 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7290 18 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7290 19 59 59 CD 40436 7290 20 : : : 40436 7290 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7290 22 , , , 40436 7290 23 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7290 24 , , , 40436 7290 25 pp pp NNP 40436 7290 26 . . . 40436 7291 1 329 329 CD 40436 7291 2 - - SYM 40436 7291 3 330 330 CD 40436 7291 4 . . . 40436 7291 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7292 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7292 2 Side side NN 40436 7292 3 - - HYPH 40436 7292 4 note note NN 40436 7292 5 : : : 40436 7292 6 Whether whether IN 40436 7292 7 justice justice NN 40436 7292 8 is be VBZ 40436 7292 9 just just RB 40436 7292 10 , , , 40436 7292 11 and and CC 40436 7292 12 holiness holiness NN 40436 7292 13 holy holy JJ 40436 7292 14 ? ? . 40436 7293 1 How how WRB 40436 7293 2 far far JJ 40436 7293 3 justice justice NN 40436 7293 4 is be VBZ 40436 7293 5 like like IN 40436 7293 6 to to IN 40436 7293 7 holiness holiness NN 40436 7293 8 ? ? . 40436 7294 1 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 7294 2 protests protest NNS 40436 7294 3 against against IN 40436 7294 4 an an DT 40436 7294 5 answer answer NN 40436 7294 6 , , , 40436 7294 7 " " `` 40436 7294 8 If if IN 40436 7294 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7294 10 please please VBP 40436 7294 11 " " '' 40436 7294 12 . . . 40436 7294 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7295 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7295 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 7295 3 let let VB 40436 7295 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7295 5 examine examine VB 40436 7295 6 what what WP 40436 7295 7 sort sort NN 40436 7295 8 of of IN 40436 7295 9 thing thing NN 40436 7295 10 each each DT 40436 7295 11 of of IN 40436 7295 12 these these DT 40436 7295 13 parts part NNS 40436 7295 14 is be VBZ 40436 7295 15 . . . 40436 7296 1 Tell tell VB 40436 7296 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7296 3 -- -- : 40436 7296 4 is be VBZ 40436 7296 5 justice justice NN 40436 7296 6 some some DT 40436 7296 7 thing thing NN 40436 7296 8 , , , 40436 7296 9 or or CC 40436 7296 10 no no DT 40436 7296 11 thing thing NN 40436 7296 12 ? ? . 40436 7297 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7297 2 think think VBP 40436 7297 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7297 4 is be VBZ 40436 7297 5 some some DT 40436 7297 6 thing thing NN 40436 7297 7 : : : 40436 7297 8 are be VBP 40436 7297 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7297 10 of of IN 40436 7297 11 the the DT 40436 7297 12 same same JJ 40436 7297 13 opinion opinion NN 40436 7297 14 ? ? . 40436 7298 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7298 2 60 60 CD 40436 7298 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7298 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7298 5 Prot._--Yes Prot._--Yes NNP 40436 7298 6 . . . 40436 7299 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7299 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 7299 3 this this DT 40436 7299 4 thing thing NN 40436 7299 5 which which WDT 40436 7299 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7299 7 call call VBP 40436 7299 8 _ _ NNP 40436 7299 9 justice justice NN 40436 7299 10 _ _ NNP 40436 7299 11 : : : 40436 7299 12 is be VBZ 40436 7299 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7299 14 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7299 15 just just RB 40436 7299 16 or or CC 40436 7299 17 unjust unjust JJ 40436 7299 18 ? ? . 40436 7300 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7300 2 should should MD 40436 7300 3 say say VB 40436 7300 4 that that IN 40436 7300 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7300 6 was be VBD 40436 7300 7 just just RB 40436 7300 8 : : : 40436 7300 9 what what WP 40436 7300 10 do do VBP 40436 7300 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7300 12 say say VB 40436 7300 13 ? ? . 40436 7301 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7301 2 61 61 CD 40436 7301 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7301 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7301 5 Prot._--I Prot._--I NNS 40436 7301 6 think think VBP 40436 7301 7 so so RB 40436 7301 8 too too RB 40436 7301 9 . . . 40436 7302 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7302 2 Sokr._--Holiness Sokr._--Holiness NNP 40436 7302 3 also also RB 40436 7302 4 is be VBZ 40436 7302 5 some some DT 40436 7302 6 thing thing NN 40436 7302 7 : : : 40436 7302 8 is be VBZ 40436 7302 9 the the DT 40436 7302 10 thing thing NN 40436 7302 11 called call VBN 40436 7302 12 _ _ NNP 40436 7302 13 holiness holiness NN 40436 7302 14 _ _ NNP 40436 7302 15 , , , 40436 7302 16 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7302 17 holy holy JJ 40436 7302 18 or or CC 40436 7302 19 unholy unholy JJ 40436 7302 20 ? ? . 40436 7303 1 As as IN 40436 7303 2 for for IN 40436 7303 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7303 4 , , , 40436 7303 5 if if IN 40436 7303 6 any any DT 40436 7303 7 one one NN 40436 7303 8 were be VBD 40436 7303 9 to to TO 40436 7303 10 ask ask VB 40436 7303 11 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7303 12 the the DT 40436 7303 13 question question NN 40436 7303 14 , , , 40436 7303 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7303 16 should should MD 40436 7303 17 reply reply VB 40436 7303 18 -- -- : 40436 7303 19 Of of RB 40436 7303 20 course course RB 40436 7303 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7303 22 is be VBZ 40436 7303 23 : : : 40436 7303 24 nothing nothing NN 40436 7303 25 else else RB 40436 7303 26 can can MD 40436 7303 27 well well RB 40436 7303 28 be be VB 40436 7303 29 holy holy JJ 40436 7303 30 , , , 40436 7303 31 if if IN 40436 7303 32 holiness holiness NN 40436 7303 33 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7303 34 be be VBP 40436 7303 35 not not RB 40436 7303 36 holy holy JJ 40436 7303 37 . . . 40436 7304 1 Would Would MD 40436 7304 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7304 3 say say VB 40436 7304 4 the the DT 40436 7304 5 same same JJ 40436 7304 6 ? ? . 40436 7305 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7305 2 Prot._--Unquestionably Prot._--Unquestionably NNP 40436 7305 3 . . . 40436 7306 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7306 2 Sokr._--Justice Sokr._--Justice NNP 40436 7306 3 being be VBG 40436 7306 4 admitted admit VBN 40436 7306 5 to to TO 40436 7306 6 be be VB 40436 7306 7 just just RB 40436 7306 8 , , , 40436 7306 9 and and CC 40436 7306 10 holiness holiness NN 40436 7306 11 to to TO 40436 7306 12 be be VB 40436 7306 13 holy holy JJ 40436 7306 14 -- -- : 40436 7306 15 do do VB 40436 7306 16 not not RB 40436 7306 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7306 18 think think VB 40436 7306 19 that that IN 40436 7306 20 justice justice NN 40436 7306 21 also also RB 40436 7306 22 is be VBZ 40436 7306 23 holy holy JJ 40436 7306 24 , , , 40436 7306 25 and and CC 40436 7306 26 that that IN 40436 7306 27 holiness holiness NN 40436 7306 28 is be VBZ 40436 7306 29 just just RB 40436 7306 30 ? ? . 40436 7307 1 If if IN 40436 7307 2 so so RB 40436 7307 3 , , , 40436 7307 4 how how WRB 40436 7307 5 can can MD 40436 7307 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7307 7 reconcile reconcile VB 40436 7307 8 that that DT 40436 7307 9 with with IN 40436 7307 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7307 11 former former JJ 40436 7307 12 declaration declaration NN 40436 7307 13 , , , 40436 7307 14 that that IN 40436 7307 15 no no DT 40436 7307 16 one one CD 40436 7307 17 of of IN 40436 7307 18 the the DT 40436 7307 19 parts part NNS 40436 7307 20 of of IN 40436 7307 21 virtue virtue NN 40436 7307 22 is be VBZ 40436 7307 23 like like IN 40436 7307 24 any any DT 40436 7307 25 other other JJ 40436 7307 26 part part NN 40436 7307 27 ? ? . 40436 7308 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7308 2 Prot._--I Prot._--I NNS 40436 7308 3 do do VBP 40436 7308 4 not not RB 40436 7308 5 altogether altogether RB 40436 7308 6 admit admit VB 40436 7308 7 that that IN 40436 7308 8 justice justice NN 40436 7308 9 is be VBZ 40436 7308 10 holy holy JJ 40436 7308 11 , , , 40436 7308 12 and and CC 40436 7308 13 that that IN 40436 7308 14 holiness holiness NN 40436 7308 15 is be VBZ 40436 7308 16 just just RB 40436 7308 17 . . . 40436 7309 1 But but CC 40436 7309 2 the the DT 40436 7309 3 matter matter NN 40436 7309 4 is be VBZ 40436 7309 5 of of IN 40436 7309 6 little little JJ 40436 7309 7 moment moment NN 40436 7309 8 : : : 40436 7309 9 if if IN 40436 7309 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7309 11 please please VBP 40436 7309 12 , , , 40436 7309 13 let let VB 40436 7309 14 both both DT 40436 7309 15 of of IN 40436 7309 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7309 17 stand stand VBP 40436 7309 18 as as IN 40436 7309 19 admitted admit VBN 40436 7309 20 . . . 40436 7310 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7310 2 Sokr._--Not Sokr._--Not NNP 40436 7310 3 so:[62 so:[62 NN 40436 7310 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7310 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7310 6 do do VBP 40436 7310 7 not not RB 40436 7310 8 want want VB 40436 7310 9 the the DT 40436 7310 10 debate debate NN 40436 7310 11 to to TO 40436 7310 12 turn turn VB 40436 7310 13 upon upon RP 40436 7310 14 an an DT 40436 7310 15 " " `` 40436 7310 16 If if IN 40436 7310 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7310 18 please please VBP 40436 7310 19 " " '' 40436 7310 20 : : : 40436 7310 21 You -PRON- PRP 40436 7310 22 and and CC 40436 7310 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7310 24 are be VBP 40436 7310 25 the the DT 40436 7310 26 debaters debater NNS 40436 7310 27 , , , 40436 7310 28 and and CC 40436 7310 29 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7310 30 shall shall MD 40436 7310 31 determine determine VB 40436 7310 32 the the DT 40436 7310 33 debate debate NN 40436 7310 34 best well RBS 40436 7310 35 without without IN 40436 7310 36 " " `` 40436 7310 37 Ifs Ifs NNP 40436 7310 38 " " '' 40436 7310 39 . . . 40436 7311 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7311 2 Prot._--I Prot._--I NNS 40436 7311 3 say say VBP 40436 7311 4 then then RB 40436 7311 5 that that DT 40436 7311 6 justice justice NN 40436 7311 7 and and CC 40436 7311 8 holiness holiness NN 40436 7311 9 are be VBP 40436 7311 10 indeed indeed RB 40436 7311 11 , , , 40436 7311 12 in in IN 40436 7311 13 a a DT 40436 7311 14 certain certain JJ 40436 7311 15 way way NN 40436 7311 16 , , , 40436 7311 17 like like IN 40436 7311 18 each each DT 40436 7311 19 other other JJ 40436 7311 20 ; ; : 40436 7311 21 so so RB 40436 7311 22 also also RB 40436 7311 23 there there EX 40436 7311 24 is be VBZ 40436 7311 25 a a DT 40436 7311 26 point point NN 40436 7311 27 of of IN 40436 7311 28 analogy analogy NN 40436 7311 29 between between IN 40436 7311 30 white white NNP 40436 7311 31 and and CC 40436 7311 32 black,[63 black,[63 LS 40436 7311 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7311 34 hard hard JJ 40436 7311 35 and and CC 40436 7311 36 soft soft JJ 40436 7311 37 , , , 40436 7311 38 and and CC 40436 7311 39 between between IN 40436 7311 40 many many JJ 40436 7311 41 other other JJ 40436 7311 42 things thing NNS 40436 7311 43 which which WDT 40436 7311 44 no no DT 40436 7311 45 one one NN 40436 7311 46 would would MD 40436 7311 47 pronounce pronounce VB 40436 7311 48 to to TO 40436 7311 49 be be VB 40436 7311 50 like like IN 40436 7311 51 generally generally RB 40436 7311 52 . . . 40436 7312 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7312 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 7312 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7312 4 think think VBP 40436 7312 5 then then RB 40436 7312 6 that that DT 40436 7312 7 justice justice NN 40436 7312 8 and and CC 40436 7312 9 holiness holiness NN 40436 7312 10 have have VBP 40436 7312 11 only only RB 40436 7312 12 a a DT 40436 7312 13 small small JJ 40436 7312 14 point point NN 40436 7312 15 of of IN 40436 7312 16 analogy analogy NN 40436 7312 17 between between IN 40436 7312 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7312 19 ? ? . 40436 7313 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7313 2 Prot._--Not Prot._--Not NNP 40436 7313 3 exactly exactly RB 40436 7313 4 so so RB 40436 7313 5 : : : 40436 7313 6 but but CC 40436 7313 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7313 8 do do VBP 40436 7313 9 not not RB 40436 7313 10 concur concur VB 40436 7313 11 with with IN 40436 7313 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7313 13 when when WRB 40436 7313 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7313 15 declare declare VBP 40436 7313 16 that that IN 40436 7313 17 one one NN 40436 7313 18 is be VBZ 40436 7313 19 like like IN 40436 7313 20 the the DT 40436 7313 21 other other JJ 40436 7313 22 . . . 40436 7314 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7314 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 7314 3 then then RB 40436 7314 4 ! ! . 40436 7315 1 since since IN 40436 7315 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7315 3 seem seem VBP 40436 7315 4 to to TO 40436 7315 5 follow follow VB 40436 7315 6 with with IN 40436 7315 7 some some DT 40436 7315 8 repugnance repugnance NN 40436 7315 9 this this DT 40436 7315 10 line line NN 40436 7315 11 of of IN 40436 7315 12 argument argument NN 40436 7315 13 , , , 40436 7315 14 let let VB 40436 7315 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7315 16 enter enter VB 40436 7315 17 upon upon IN 40436 7315 18 another another DT 40436 7315 19 . . . 40436 7316 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7316 2 64 64 CD 40436 7316 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7316 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7316 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7316 6 60 60 CD 40436 7316 7 : : : 40436 7316 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7316 9 , , , 40436 7316 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7316 11 . . . 40436 7317 1 p. p. NN 40436 7317 2 330 330 CD 40436 7317 3 B. B. NNP 40436 7318 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7318 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7318 3 : : : 40436 7318 4 koinê=| koinê=| NNP 40436 7318 5 skepsô skepsô NNP 40436 7318 6 / / SYM 40436 7318 7 metha metha NNP 40436 7318 8 _ _ NNP 40436 7318 9 poi poi NNP 40436 7318 10 = = SYM 40436 7318 11 o o NN 40436 7318 12 / / SYM 40436 7318 13 n n NN 40436 7318 14 ti ti NNP 40436 7318 15 au)tô au)tô NN 40436 7318 16 = = SYM 40436 7318 17 n n CC 40436 7318 18 e)stin e)stin , 40436 7318 19 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 7318 20 _ _ NNP 40436 7318 21 . . . 40436 7319 1 prô prô NNP 40436 7319 2 = = SYM 40436 7319 3 ton ton NN 40436 7319 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7319 5 to\ to\ NN 40436 7319 6 toio toio NNP 40436 7319 7 / / SYM 40436 7319 8 nde nde NNP 40436 7319 9 ; ; , 40436 7319 10 ê ê NNP 40436 7319 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7319 12 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 7319 13 / / SYM 40436 7319 14 nê nê NNP 40436 7319 15 pra pra NNP 40436 7319 16 = = SYM 40436 7319 17 gma/ gma/ NNP 40436 7319 18 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 7319 19 e)stin e)stin , 40436 7319 20 ? ? . 40436 7320 1 ê)\ ê)\ NFP 40436 7320 2 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 7320 3 pra pra NNP 40436 7320 4 = = SYM 40436 7320 5 gma gma NNP 40436 7320 6 ? ? . 40436 7321 1 e)moi\ e)moi\ VBZ 40436 7321 2 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7321 3 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7321 4 dokei= dokei= NN 40436 7321 5 ; ; : 40436 7321 6 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 7321 7 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7321 8 soi/ soi/ NNP 40436 7321 9 ? ? . 40436 7321 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7321 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7322 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7322 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7322 3 61 61 CD 40436 7322 4 : : : 40436 7322 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7322 6 , , , 40436 7322 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7322 8 . . . 40436 7323 1 p. p. NN 40436 7323 2 330 330 CD 40436 7323 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7323 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7323 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7323 6 : : : 40436 7323 7 tou tou NNP 40436 7323 8 = = SYM 40436 7323 9 to to TO 40436 7323 10 to\ to\ VB 40436 7323 11 pra pra NNP 40436 7323 12 = = SYM 40436 7323 13 gma gma NNP 40436 7323 14 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 7323 15 ô)noma ô)noma , 40436 7323 16 / / SYM 40436 7323 17 sate sate NN 40436 7323 18 a)/rti a)/rti NNP 40436 7323 19 , , , 40436 7323 20 ê ê NNP 40436 7323 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7323 22 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 7323 23 / / SYM 40436 7323 24 nê nê RB 40436 7323 25 , , , 40436 7323 26 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 7323 27 tou tou NNP 40436 7323 28 = = SYM 40436 7323 29 to to IN 40436 7323 30 di di NNP 40436 7323 31 / / SYM 40436 7323 32 kaio kaio NNP 40436 7323 33 / / SYM 40436 7323 34 n n NNP 40436 7323 35 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 7323 36 ê)\ ê)\ SYM 40436 7323 37 a)/dikon a)/dikon IN 40436 7323 38 ? ? . 40436 7323 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7323 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7324 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7324 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7324 3 62 62 CD 40436 7324 4 : : : 40436 7324 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7324 6 , , , 40436 7324 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7324 8 . . . 40436 7325 1 p. p. NN 40436 7325 2 331 331 CD 40436 7325 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7325 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7325 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7325 6 : : : 40436 7325 7 ei ei LS 40436 7325 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7325 9 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7325 10 bou bou NN 40436 7325 11 / / SYM 40436 7325 12 lei lei NN 40436 7325 13 , , , 40436 7325 14 e)/stô e)/stô NN 40436 7325 15 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 7325 16 = = SYM 40436 7325 17 n n NNP 40436 7325 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7325 19 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 7325 20 / / SYM 40436 7325 21 nê nê NNP 40436 7325 22 o(/sion o(/sion NNP 40436 7325 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7325 24 o(sio o(sio NNP 40436 7325 25 / / SYM 40436 7325 26 tês tês NNP 40436 7325 27 di di NNP 40436 7325 28 / / SYM 40436 7325 29 kaion kaion NNP 40436 7325 30 . . . 40436 7326 1 Mê/ Mê/ NNP 40436 7326 2 moi moi NNP 40436 7326 3 , , , 40436 7326 4 ê(=n ê(=n NNP 40436 7326 5 d d NNP 40436 7326 6 ' ' POS 40436 7326 7 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 7326 8 ; ; : 40436 7326 9 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 7326 10 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7326 11 de de NNP 40436 7326 12 / / SYM 40436 7326 13 omai omai NNP 40436 7326 14 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7326 15 " " '' 40436 7326 16 ei/ ei/ NNP 40436 7326 17 bou bou NNP 40436 7326 18 / / SYM 40436 7326 19 lei lei NNP 40436 7326 20 " " `` 40436 7326 21 tou tou NNP 40436 7326 22 = = NNPS 40436 7326 23 to to IN 40436 7326 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7326 25 " " `` 40436 7326 26 _ _ NNP 40436 7326 27 ei ei NNP 40436 7326 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7326 29 soi soi NN 40436 7326 30 dokei= dokei= NN 40436 7326 31 _ _ NNP 40436 7326 32 " " `` 40436 7326 33 e)le e)le NNP 40436 7326 34 / / SYM 40436 7326 35 gchesthai gchesthai NN 40436 7326 36 , , , 40436 7326 37 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 7326 38 ' ' '' 40436 7326 39 e)me/ e)me/ CD 40436 7326 40 te te NNP 40436 7326 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7326 42 se/. se/. NNP 40436 7326 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7327 1 This this DT 40436 7327 2 passage passage NN 40436 7327 3 seems seem VBZ 40436 7327 4 intended intend VBN 40436 7327 5 to to TO 40436 7327 6 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 7327 7 the the DT 40436 7327 8 indifference indifference NN 40436 7327 9 of of IN 40436 7327 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7327 11 for for IN 40436 7327 12 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 7327 13 forms form NNS 40436 7327 14 and and CC 40436 7327 15 strict strict JJ 40436 7327 16 accuracy accuracy NN 40436 7327 17 of of IN 40436 7327 18 discussion discussion NN 40436 7327 19 . . . 40436 7328 1 The the DT 40436 7328 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7328 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7328 4 : : : 40436 7328 5 a)kribologi a)kribologi LS 40436 7328 6 / / SYM 40436 7328 7 a a NN 40436 7328 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7328 9 of of IN 40436 7328 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7328 11 and and CC 40436 7328 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7328 13 was be VBD 40436 7328 14 not not RB 40436 7328 15 merely merely RB 40436 7328 16 unfamiliar unfamiliar JJ 40436 7328 17 but but CC 40436 7328 18 even even RB 40436 7328 19 distasteful distasteful JJ 40436 7328 20 to to IN 40436 7328 21 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 7328 22 and and CC 40436 7328 23 practical practical JJ 40436 7328 24 men man NNS 40436 7328 25 . . . 40436 7329 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7329 2 is be VBZ 40436 7329 3 made make VBN 40436 7329 4 to to TO 40436 7329 5 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 7329 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7329 7 as as IN 40436 7329 8 thinking think VBG 40436 7329 9 the the DT 40436 7329 10 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 7329 11 drawn draw VBN 40436 7329 12 by by IN 40436 7329 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7329 14 too too RB 40436 7329 15 nice nice JJ 40436 7329 16 , , , 40436 7329 17 not not RB 40436 7329 18 worth worth JJ 40436 7329 19 attending attend VBG 40436 7329 20 to to TO 40436 7329 21 . . . 40436 7330 1 Many many JJ 40436 7330 2 of of IN 40436 7330 3 the the DT 40436 7330 4 contemporaries contemporary NNS 40436 7330 5 of of IN 40436 7330 6 both both DT 40436 7330 7 shared share VBD 40436 7330 8 this this DT 40436 7330 9 opinion opinion NN 40436 7330 10 . . . 40436 7331 1 One one CD 40436 7331 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 7331 3 of of IN 40436 7331 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7331 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7331 6 is be VBZ 40436 7331 7 to to TO 40436 7331 8 bring bring VB 40436 7331 9 such such JJ 40436 7331 10 antitheses antithesis NNS 40436 7331 11 into into IN 40436 7331 12 view view NN 40436 7331 13 . . . 40436 7331 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7332 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7332 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7332 3 63 63 CD 40436 7332 4 : : : 40436 7332 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7332 6 . . . 40436 7333 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7333 2 . . . 40436 7334 1 p. p. NN 40436 7334 2 331 331 CD 40436 7334 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7334 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7334 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7334 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7334 7 64 64 CD 40436 7334 8 : : : 40436 7334 9 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7334 10 . . . 40436 7335 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7335 2 . . . 40436 7336 1 p. p. NN 40436 7336 2 332 332 CD 40436 7336 3 A. a. NN 40436 7336 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7337 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7337 2 Side side NN 40436 7337 3 - - HYPH 40436 7337 4 note note NN 40436 7337 5 : : : 40436 7337 6 Intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7337 7 and and CC 40436 7337 8 moderation moderation NN 40436 7337 9 are be VBP 40436 7337 10 identical identical JJ 40436 7337 11 , , , 40436 7337 12 because because IN 40436 7337 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7337 14 have have VBP 40436 7337 15 the the DT 40436 7337 16 same same JJ 40436 7337 17 contrary contrary NN 40436 7337 18 . . . 40436 7337 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7338 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7338 2 then then RB 40436 7338 3 attempts attempt VBZ 40436 7338 4 to to TO 40436 7338 5 show show VB 40436 7338 6 that that DT 40436 7338 7 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7338 8 and and CC 40436 7338 9 moderation moderation NN 40436 7338 10 are be VBP 40436 7338 11 identical identical JJ 40436 7338 12 with with IN 40436 7338 13 each each DT 40436 7338 14 other other JJ 40436 7338 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7338 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7338 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7338 18 : : : 40436 7338 19 sophi sophi NNS 40436 7338 20 / / SYM 40436 7338 21 a a NN 40436 7338 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7338 23 and and CC 40436 7338 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7338 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7338 26 : : : 40436 7338 27 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 7338 28 / / SYM 40436 7338 29 nê nê NNP 40436 7338 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7338 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7338 32 . . . 40436 7339 1 The the DT 40436 7339 2 proof proof NN 40436 7339 3 which which WDT 40436 7339 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7339 5 produces produce VBZ 40436 7339 6 , , , 40436 7339 7 elicited elicit VBN 40436 7339 8 by by IN 40436 7339 9 several several JJ 40436 7339 10 questions question NNS 40436 7339 11 , , , 40436 7339 12 is be VBZ 40436 7339 13 -- -- : 40436 7339 14 that that IN 40436 7339 15 both both CC 40436 7339 16 the the DT 40436 7339 17 one one NN 40436 7339 18 and and CC 40436 7339 19 the the DT 40436 7339 20 other other JJ 40436 7339 21 are be VBP 40436 7339 22 contrary contrary JJ 40436 7339 23 to to IN 40436 7339 24 folly folly VB 40436 7339 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7339 26 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7339 27 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7339 28 : : : 40436 7339 29 a)phrosu a)phrosu NNS 40436 7339 30 / / SYM 40436 7339 31 nê nê NN 40436 7339 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7339 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7339 34 , , , 40436 7339 35 and and CC 40436 7339 36 , , , 40436 7339 37 that that IN 40436 7339 38 as as IN 40436 7339 39 a a DT 40436 7339 40 general general JJ 40436 7339 41 rule rule NN 40436 7339 42 , , , 40436 7339 43 nothing nothing NN 40436 7339 44 can can MD 40436 7339 45 have have VB 40436 7339 46 more more JJR 40436 7339 47 than than IN 40436 7339 48 one one CD 40436 7339 49 single single JJ 40436 7339 50 contrary contrary NN 40436 7339 51 . . . 40436 7340 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7340 2 65 65 CD 40436 7340 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7340 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7340 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7340 6 65 65 CD 40436 7340 7 : : : 40436 7340 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7340 9 . . . 40436 7341 1 Protag protag NN 40436 7341 2 . . . 40436 7342 1 p. p. NN 40436 7343 1 332 332 CD 40436 7343 2 . . . 40436 7343 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7344 1 * * NFP 40436 7344 2 * * NFP 40436 7344 3 * * NFP 40436 7344 4 * * NFP 40436 7344 5 * * NFP 40436 7344 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7344 7 Side side NN 40436 7344 8 - - HYPH 40436 7344 9 note note NN 40436 7344 10 : : : 40436 7344 11 Insufficient insufficient JJ 40436 7344 12 reasons reason NNS 40436 7344 13 given give VBN 40436 7344 14 by by IN 40436 7344 15 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7344 16 . . . 40436 7345 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7345 2 seldom seldom RB 40436 7345 3 cares care VBZ 40436 7345 4 to to TO 40436 7345 5 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 7345 6 different different JJ 40436 7345 7 meanings meaning NNS 40436 7345 8 of of IN 40436 7345 9 the the DT 40436 7345 10 same same JJ 40436 7345 11 term term NN 40436 7345 12 . . . 40436 7345 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7346 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7346 2 thus thus RB 40436 7346 3 seems seem VBZ 40436 7346 4 to to IN 40436 7346 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7346 6 to to TO 40436 7346 7 have have VB 40436 7346 8 made make VBN 40436 7346 9 much much JJ 40436 7346 10 progress progress NN 40436 7346 11 in in IN 40436 7346 12 proving prove VBG 40436 7346 13 all all PDT 40436 7346 14 the the DT 40436 7346 15 names name NNS 40436 7346 16 of of IN 40436 7346 17 different different JJ 40436 7346 18 virtues virtue NNS 40436 7346 19 to to TO 40436 7346 20 be be VB 40436 7346 21 names name NNS 40436 7346 22 of of IN 40436 7346 23 one one CD 40436 7346 24 and and CC 40436 7346 25 the the DT 40436 7346 26 same same JJ 40436 7346 27 thing thing NN 40436 7346 28 . . . 40436 7347 1 Moderation moderation NN 40436 7347 2 and and CC 40436 7347 3 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7347 4 are be VBP 40436 7347 5 shown show VBN 40436 7347 6 to to TO 40436 7347 7 be be VB 40436 7347 8 the the DT 40436 7347 9 same same JJ 40436 7347 10 : : : 40436 7347 11 justice justice NN 40436 7347 12 and and CC 40436 7347 13 holiness holiness NN 40436 7347 14 had have VBD 40436 7347 15 before before RB 40436 7347 16 been be VBN 40436 7347 17 shown show VBN 40436 7347 18 to to TO 40436 7347 19 be be VB 40436 7347 20 nearly nearly RB 40436 7347 21 the the DT 40436 7347 22 same:[66 same:[66 NNPS 40436 7347 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7347 24 though though IN 40436 7347 25 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7347 26 must must MD 40436 7347 27 recollect recollect VB 40436 7347 28 that that IN 40436 7347 29 this this DT 40436 7347 30 last last JJ 40436 7347 31 point point NN 40436 7347 32 had have VBD 40436 7347 33 not not RB 40436 7347 34 been be VBN 40436 7347 35 admitted admit VBN 40436 7347 36 by by IN 40436 7347 37 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7347 38 . . . 40436 7348 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7348 2 must must MD 40436 7348 3 be be VB 40436 7348 4 confessed confess VBN 40436 7348 5 however however RB 40436 7348 6 that that IN 40436 7348 7 neither neither CC 40436 7348 8 the the DT 40436 7348 9 one one CD 40436 7348 10 nor nor CC 40436 7348 11 the the DT 40436 7348 12 other other JJ 40436 7348 13 is be VBZ 40436 7348 14 proved prove VBN 40436 7348 15 by by IN 40436 7348 16 any any DT 40436 7348 17 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 7348 18 reasons reason NNS 40436 7348 19 . . . 40436 7349 1 In in IN 40436 7349 2 laying lay VBG 40436 7349 3 down down RP 40436 7349 4 the the DT 40436 7349 5 maxim maxim NN 40436 7349 6 -- -- : 40436 7349 7 that that IN 40436 7349 8 nothing nothing NN 40436 7349 9 can can MD 40436 7349 10 have have VB 40436 7349 11 more more JJR 40436 7349 12 than than IN 40436 7349 13 one one CD 40436 7349 14 single single JJ 40436 7349 15 contrary contrary NN 40436 7349 16 -- -- : 40436 7349 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7349 18 seems seem VBZ 40436 7349 19 to to TO 40436 7349 20 have have VB 40436 7349 21 forgotten forget VBN 40436 7349 22 that that IN 40436 7349 23 the the DT 40436 7349 24 same same JJ 40436 7349 25 term term NN 40436 7349 26 may may MD 40436 7349 27 be be VB 40436 7349 28 used use VBN 40436 7349 29 in in IN 40436 7349 30 two two CD 40436 7349 31 different different JJ 40436 7349 32 senses sense NNS 40436 7349 33 . . . 40436 7350 1 Because because IN 40436 7350 2 the the DT 40436 7350 3 term term NN 40436 7350 4 folly folly NN 40436 7350 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7350 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7350 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7350 8 : : : 40436 7350 9 a)phrosu a)phrosu NNS 40436 7350 10 / / SYM 40436 7350 11 nê nê NNP 40436 7350 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7350 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7350 14 , , , 40436 7350 15 is be VBZ 40436 7350 16 used use VBN 40436 7350 17 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 7350 18 to to TO 40436 7350 19 denote denote VB 40436 7350 20 the the DT 40436 7350 21 opposite opposite NN 40436 7350 22 of of IN 40436 7350 23 moderation moderation NN 40436 7350 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7350 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7350 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7350 27 : : : 40436 7350 28 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 7350 29 / / SYM 40436 7350 30 nê nê NNP 40436 7350 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7350 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7350 33 , , , 40436 7350 34 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 7350 35 the the DT 40436 7350 36 opposite opposite NN 40436 7350 37 of of IN 40436 7350 38 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7350 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7350 40 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7350 41 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7350 42 : : : 40436 7350 43 sophi sophi NNS 40436 7350 44 / / SYM 40436 7350 45 a a NN 40436 7350 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7350 47 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7350 48 , , , 40436 7350 49 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7350 50 does do VBZ 40436 7350 51 not not RB 40436 7350 52 follow follow VB 40436 7350 53 that that DT 40436 7350 54 moderation moderation NN 40436 7350 55 and and CC 40436 7350 56 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7350 57 are be VBP 40436 7350 58 the the DT 40436 7350 59 same same JJ 40436 7350 60 thing thing NN 40436 7350 61 . . . 40436 7351 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7351 2 67 67 CD 40436 7351 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7351 4 Nor nor CC 40436 7351 5 does do VBZ 40436 7351 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7351 7 furnish furnish VB 40436 7351 8 more more RBR 40436 7351 9 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 7351 10 proof proof NN 40436 7351 11 of of IN 40436 7351 12 the the DT 40436 7351 13 other other JJ 40436 7351 14 point point NN 40436 7351 15 , , , 40436 7351 16 _ _ NNP 40436 7351 17 viz viz NN 40436 7351 18 . . . 40436 7351 19 _ _ NNP 40436 7351 20 : : : 40436 7351 21 That that IN 40436 7351 22 holiness holiness NN 40436 7351 23 and and CC 40436 7351 24 justice justice NN 40436 7351 25 are be VBP 40436 7351 26 the the DT 40436 7351 27 same same JJ 40436 7351 28 , , , 40436 7351 29 or or CC 40436 7351 30 as as RB 40436 7351 31 much much JJ 40436 7351 32 alike alike RB 40436 7351 33 as as IN 40436 7351 34 possible possible JJ 40436 7351 35 . . . 40436 7352 1 The the DT 40436 7352 2 intermediate intermediate JJ 40436 7352 3 position position NN 40436 7352 4 which which WDT 40436 7352 5 is be VBZ 40436 7352 6 assumed assume VBN 40436 7352 7 to to TO 40436 7352 8 form form VB 40436 7352 9 the the DT 40436 7352 10 proof proof NN 40436 7352 11 , , , 40436 7352 12 _ _ NNP 40436 7352 13 viz viz NN 40436 7352 14 . . . 40436 7352 15 _ _ NNP 40436 7352 16 : : : 40436 7352 17 That that IN 40436 7352 18 holiness holiness NN 40436 7352 19 is be VBZ 40436 7352 20 holy holy JJ 40436 7352 21 , , , 40436 7352 22 and and CC 40436 7352 23 that that DT 40436 7352 24 justice justice NN 40436 7352 25 is be VBZ 40436 7352 26 just just RB 40436 7352 27 -- -- : 40436 7352 28 is be VBZ 40436 7352 29 either either DT 40436 7352 30 tautological tautological JJ 40436 7352 31 , , , 40436 7352 32 or or CC 40436 7352 33 unmeaning unmeaning JJ 40436 7352 34 ; ; : 40436 7352 35 and and CC 40436 7352 36 can can MD 40436 7352 37 not not RB 40436 7352 38 serve serve VB 40436 7352 39 as as IN 40436 7352 40 a a DT 40436 7352 41 real real JJ 40436 7352 42 proof proof NN 40436 7352 43 of of IN 40436 7352 44 any any DT 40436 7352 45 thing thing NN 40436 7352 46 . . . 40436 7353 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7353 2 is be VBZ 40436 7353 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 7353 4 so so RB 40436 7353 5 futile futile JJ 40436 7353 6 , , , 40436 7353 7 that that IN 40436 7353 8 if if IN 40436 7353 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7353 10 were be VBD 40436 7353 11 found find VBN 40436 7353 12 in in IN 40436 7353 13 the the DT 40436 7353 14 mouth mouth NN 40436 7353 15 of of IN 40436 7353 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7353 17 and and CC 40436 7353 18 not not RB 40436 7353 19 in in IN 40436 7353 20 that that DT 40436 7353 21 of of IN 40436 7353 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7353 23 , , , 40436 7353 24 commentators commentator NNS 40436 7353 25 would would MD 40436 7353 26 probably probably RB 40436 7353 27 have have VB 40436 7353 28 cited cite VBN 40436 7353 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7353 30 as as IN 40436 7353 31 an an DT 40436 7353 32 illustration illustration NN 40436 7353 33 of of IN 40436 7353 34 the the DT 40436 7353 35 futilities futility NNS 40436 7353 36 of of IN 40436 7353 37 the the DT 40436 7353 38 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 7353 39 . . . 40436 7354 1 As as IN 40436 7354 2 yet yet RB 40436 7354 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 7354 4 little little JJ 40436 7354 5 has have VBZ 40436 7354 6 been be VBN 40436 7354 7 done do VBN 40436 7354 8 to to TO 40436 7354 9 elucidate elucidate VB 40436 7354 10 the the DT 40436 7354 11 important important JJ 40436 7354 12 question question NN 40436 7354 13 to to TO 40436 7354 14 which which WDT 40436 7354 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7354 16 addresses address VBZ 40436 7354 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7354 18 -- -- : 40436 7354 19 What what WP 40436 7354 20 is be VBZ 40436 7354 21 the the DT 40436 7354 22 extent extent NN 40436 7354 23 of of IN 40436 7354 24 analogy analogy NN 40436 7354 25 between between IN 40436 7354 26 the the DT 40436 7354 27 different different JJ 40436 7354 28 virtues virtue NNS 40436 7354 29 ? ? . 40436 7355 1 Are be VBP 40436 7355 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7355 3 at at IN 40436 7355 4 bottom bottom NN 40436 7355 5 one one CD 40436 7355 6 and and CC 40436 7355 7 the the DT 40436 7355 8 same same JJ 40436 7355 9 thing thing NN 40436 7355 10 under under IN 40436 7355 11 different different JJ 40436 7355 12 names name NNS 40436 7355 13 ? ? . 40436 7356 1 In in IN 40436 7356 2 what what WP 40436 7356 3 does do VBZ 40436 7356 4 the the DT 40436 7356 5 analogy analogy NN 40436 7356 6 or or CC 40436 7356 7 the the DT 40436 7356 8 sameness sameness JJ 40436 7356 9 consist consist VB 40436 7356 10 ? ? . 40436 7357 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7357 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7357 3 66 66 CD 40436 7357 4 : : : 40436 7357 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7357 6 , , , 40436 7357 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7357 8 . . . 40436 7358 1 p. p. NN 40436 7358 2 338 338 CD 40436 7358 3 B. b. NN 40436 7359 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7359 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7359 3 : : : 40436 7359 4 sche sche NNP 40436 7359 5 / / SYM 40436 7359 6 don don NNP 40436 7359 7 ti ti NNP 40436 7359 8 tau)to\n tau)to\n NNP 40436 7359 9 o)/n o)/n UH 40436 7359 10 . . . 40436 7359 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7359 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7360 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7360 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7360 3 67 67 CD 40436 7360 4 : : : 40436 7360 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 7360 6 would would MD 40436 7360 7 probably probably RB 40436 7360 8 have have VB 40436 7360 9 avoided avoid VBN 40436 7360 10 such such PDT 40436 7360 11 a a DT 40436 7360 12 mistake mistake NN 40436 7360 13 as as IN 40436 7360 14 this this DT 40436 7360 15 . . . 40436 7361 1 One one CD 40436 7361 2 important important JJ 40436 7361 3 point point NN 40436 7361 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7361 5 as as IN 40436 7361 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7361 7 have have VBP 40436 7361 8 already already RB 40436 7361 9 remarked remark VBN 40436 7361 10 , , , 40436 7361 11 vol vol NNP 40436 7361 12 . . . 40436 7362 1 ii ii LS 40436 7362 2 . . . 40436 7363 1 p. p. NN 40436 7363 2 170 170 CD 40436 7363 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7363 4 in in IN 40436 7363 5 which which WDT 40436 7363 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7363 7 is be VBZ 40436 7363 8 superior superior JJ 40436 7363 9 to to IN 40436 7363 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7363 11 is be VBZ 40436 7363 12 , , , 40436 7363 13 in in IN 40436 7363 14 being be VBG 40436 7363 15 far far RB 40436 7363 16 more more RBR 40436 7363 17 careful careful JJ 40436 7363 18 to to TO 40436 7363 19 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 7363 20 the the DT 40436 7363 21 different different JJ 40436 7363 22 meanings meaning NNS 40436 7363 23 of of IN 40436 7363 24 the the DT 40436 7363 25 same same JJ 40436 7363 26 word--[Greek word--[greek CD 40436 7363 27 : : : 40436 7363 28 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 7363 29 pollachô pollachô NNP 40436 7363 30 = = NFP 40436 7363 31 s s NNP 40436 7363 32 lego lego NNP 40436 7363 33 / / SYM 40436 7363 34 mena mena NNP 40436 7363 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7363 36 . . . 40436 7364 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7364 2 rarely rarely RB 40436 7364 3 troubles trouble VBZ 40436 7364 4 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7364 5 to to TO 40436 7364 6 notice notice VB 40436 7364 7 such such JJ 40436 7364 8 distinction distinction NN 40436 7364 9 , , , 40436 7364 10 and and CC 40436 7364 11 seems seem VBZ 40436 7364 12 indeed indeed RB 40436 7364 13 generally generally RB 40436 7364 14 unaware unaware JJ 40436 7364 15 of of IN 40436 7364 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7364 17 . . . 40436 7365 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7365 2 constantly constantly RB 40436 7365 3 ridicules ridicule VBZ 40436 7365 4 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7365 5 , , , 40436 7365 6 who who WP 40436 7365 7 tried try VBD 40436 7365 8 to to TO 40436 7365 9 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 7365 10 words word NNS 40436 7365 11 apparently apparently RB 40436 7365 12 synonymous synonymous JJ 40436 7365 13 . . . 40436 7365 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7366 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7366 2 Side side NN 40436 7366 3 - - HYPH 40436 7366 4 note note NN 40436 7366 5 : : : 40436 7366 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7366 7 is be VBZ 40436 7366 8 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 7366 9 , , , 40436 7366 10 and and CC 40436 7366 11 becomes become VBZ 40436 7366 12 irritated irritated JJ 40436 7366 13 . . . 40436 7366 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7367 1 But but CC 40436 7367 2 though though IN 40436 7367 3 little little JJ 40436 7367 4 progress progress NN 40436 7367 5 has have VBZ 40436 7367 6 been be VBN 40436 7367 7 made make VBN 40436 7367 8 in in IN 40436 7367 9 determining determine VBG 40436 7367 10 the the DT 40436 7367 11 question question NN 40436 7367 12 mooted moot VBN 40436 7367 13 by by IN 40436 7367 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7367 15 , , , 40436 7367 16 enough enough RB 40436 7367 17 has have VBZ 40436 7367 18 been be VBN 40436 7367 19 done do VBN 40436 7367 20 to to TO 40436 7367 21 discompose discompose VB 40436 7367 22 and and CC 40436 7367 23 mortify mortify VB 40436 7367 24 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7367 25 . . . 40436 7368 1 The the DT 40436 7368 2 general general JJ 40436 7368 3 tenor tenor NN 40436 7368 4 of of IN 40436 7368 5 the the DT 40436 7368 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7368 7 is be VBZ 40436 7368 8 , , , 40436 7368 9 to to TO 40436 7368 10 depict depict VB 40436 7368 11 this this DT 40436 7368 12 man man NN 40436 7368 13 , , , 40436 7368 14 so so RB 40436 7368 15 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 7368 16 in in IN 40436 7368 17 popular popular JJ 40436 7368 18 and and CC 40436 7368 19 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7368 20 exposition exposition NN 40436 7368 21 , , , 40436 7368 22 as as IN 40436 7368 23 destitute destitute NN 40436 7368 24 of of IN 40436 7368 25 the the DT 40436 7368 26 analytical analytical JJ 40436 7368 27 acumen acuman NNS 40436 7368 28 requisite requisite JJ 40436 7368 29 to to TO 40436 7368 30 meet meet VB 40436 7368 31 cross cross NN 40436 7368 32 - - NN 40436 7368 33 examination examination NN 40436 7368 34 , , , 40436 7368 35 and and CC 40436 7368 36 of of IN 40436 7368 37 promptitude promptitude NN 40436 7368 38 for for IN 40436 7368 39 dealing deal VBG 40436 7368 40 with with IN 40436 7368 41 new new JJ 40436 7368 42 aspects aspect NNS 40436 7368 43 of of IN 40436 7368 44 the the DT 40436 7368 45 case case NN 40436 7368 46 , , , 40436 7368 47 on on IN 40436 7368 48 the the DT 40436 7368 49 very very JJ 40436 7368 50 subjects subject NNS 40436 7368 51 which which WDT 40436 7368 52 form form VBP 40436 7368 53 the the DT 40436 7368 54 theme theme NN 40436 7368 55 of of IN 40436 7368 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7368 57 eloquence eloquence NN 40436 7368 58 . . . 40436 7369 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7369 2 finds find VBZ 40436 7369 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7369 4 brought bring VBN 40436 7369 5 round round RB 40436 7369 6 , , , 40436 7369 7 by by IN 40436 7369 8 a a DT 40436 7369 9 series series NN 40436 7369 10 of of IN 40436 7369 11 short short JJ 40436 7369 12 questions question NNS 40436 7369 13 , , , 40436 7369 14 to to IN 40436 7369 15 a a DT 40436 7369 16 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 7369 17 which which WDT 40436 7369 18 -- -- : 40436 7369 19 whether whether IN 40436 7369 20 conclusively conclusively RB 40436 7369 21 proved prove VBN 40436 7369 22 or or CC 40436 7369 23 not not RB 40436 7369 24 -- -- : 40436 7369 25 is be VBZ 40436 7369 26 proved prove VBN 40436 7369 27 in in IN 40436 7369 28 a a DT 40436 7369 29 manner manner NN 40436 7369 30 binding bind VBG 40436 7369 31 upon upon IN 40436 7369 32 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7369 33 , , , 40436 7369 34 since since IN 40436 7369 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7369 36 has have VBZ 40436 7369 37 admitted admit VBN 40436 7369 38 all all PDT 40436 7369 39 the the DT 40436 7369 40 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 7369 41 premisses premiss NNS 40436 7369 42 . . . 40436 7370 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7370 2 becomes become VBZ 40436 7370 3 dissatisfied dissatisfied JJ 40436 7370 4 with with IN 40436 7370 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7370 6 , , , 40436 7370 7 answers answer NNS 40436 7370 8 with with IN 40436 7370 9 increasing increase VBG 40436 7370 10 reluctance,[68 reluctance,[68 NFP 40436 7370 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7370 12 and and CC 40436 7370 13 is be VBZ 40436 7370 14 at at IN 40436 7370 15 last last JJ 40436 7370 16 so so RB 40436 7370 17 provoked provoke VBD 40436 7370 18 as as IN 40436 7370 19 to to TO 40436 7370 20 break break VB 40436 7370 21 out out IN 40436 7370 22 of of IN 40436 7370 23 the the DT 40436 7370 24 limits limit NNS 40436 7370 25 imposed impose VBN 40436 7370 26 upon upon IN 40436 7370 27 a a DT 40436 7370 28 respondent respondent NN 40436 7370 29 . . . 40436 7371 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7371 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7371 3 68 68 CD 40436 7371 4 : : : 40436 7371 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7371 6 , , , 40436 7371 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7371 8 . . . 40436 7372 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7372 2 . . . 40436 7373 1 333 333 CD 40436 7373 2 B b NN 40436 7373 3 , , , 40436 7373 4 335 335 CD 40436 7373 5 A. a. NN 40436 7373 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7374 1 * * NFP 40436 7374 2 * * NFP 40436 7374 3 * * NFP 40436 7374 4 * * NFP 40436 7374 5 * * NFP 40436 7374 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7374 7 Side side NN 40436 7374 8 - - HYPH 40436 7374 9 note note NN 40436 7374 10 : : : 40436 7374 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7374 12 presses press VBZ 40436 7374 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7374 14 farther farther RB 40436 7374 15 . . . 40436 7375 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7375 2 purpose purpose NN 40436 7375 3 is be VBZ 40436 7375 4 , , , 40436 7375 5 to to TO 40436 7375 6 test test VB 40436 7375 7 opinions opinion NNS 40436 7375 8 and and CC 40436 7375 9 not not RB 40436 7375 10 persons person NNS 40436 7375 11 . . . 40436 7376 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7376 2 answers answer VBZ 40436 7376 3 with with IN 40436 7376 4 angry angry JJ 40436 7376 5 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 7376 6 . . . 40436 7376 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7377 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 40436 7377 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7377 3 pursues pursue VBZ 40436 7377 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7377 5 examination examination NN 40436 7377 6 , , , 40436 7377 7 with with IN 40436 7377 8 intent intent NN 40436 7377 9 to to TO 40436 7377 10 prove prove VB 40436 7377 11 that that DT 40436 7377 12 justice justice NN 40436 7377 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7377 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7377 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7377 16 : : : 40436 7377 17 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 7377 18 / / SYM 40436 7377 19 nê nê NNP 40436 7377 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7377 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7377 22 and and CC 40436 7377 23 moderation moderation NN 40436 7377 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7377 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7377 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7377 27 : : : 40436 7377 28 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 7377 29 / / SYM 40436 7377 30 nê nê NNP 40436 7377 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7377 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7377 33 are be VBP 40436 7377 34 identical identical JJ 40436 7377 35 . . . 40436 7378 1 Does do VBZ 40436 7378 2 a a DT 40436 7378 3 man man NN 40436 7378 4 who who WP 40436 7378 5 acts act VBZ 40436 7378 6 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 7378 7 conduct conduct VB 40436 7378 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7378 9 with with IN 40436 7378 10 moderation moderation NN 40436 7378 11 ? ? . 40436 7379 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7379 2 should should MD 40436 7379 3 be be VB 40436 7379 4 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 7379 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7379 6 replies reply VBZ 40436 7379 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7379 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7379 9 to to TO 40436 7379 10 answer answer VB 40436 7379 11 in in IN 40436 7379 12 the the DT 40436 7379 13 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 7379 14 , , , 40436 7379 15 though though IN 40436 7379 16 many many JJ 40436 7379 17 people people NNS 40436 7379 18 say say VBP 40436 7379 19 so so RB 40436 7379 20 . . . 40436 7380 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7380 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 7380 3 is be VBZ 40436 7380 4 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 7380 5 to to IN 40436 7380 6 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7380 7 whether whether IN 40436 7380 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7380 9 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 7380 10 think think VBP 40436 7380 11 so so RB 40436 7380 12 or or CC 40436 7380 13 not not RB 40436 7380 14 , , , 40436 7380 15 provided provide VBN 40436 7380 16 only only RB 40436 7380 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7380 18 consent consent VBP 40436 7380 19 to to TO 40436 7380 20 make make VB 40436 7380 21 answer answer NN 40436 7380 22 . . . 40436 7381 1 What what WP 40436 7381 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7381 3 principally principally RB 40436 7381 4 examine examine VBP 40436 7381 5 is be VBZ 40436 7381 6 the the DT 40436 7381 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 7381 8 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7381 9 : : : 40436 7381 10 though though IN 40436 7381 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7381 12 follows follow VBZ 40436 7381 13 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 7381 14 as as IN 40436 7381 15 a a DT 40436 7381 16 consequence consequence NN 40436 7381 17 , , , 40436 7381 18 that that IN 40436 7381 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7381 20 the the DT 40436 7381 21 questioner questioner NN 40436 7381 22 , , , 40436 7381 23 and and CC 40436 7381 24 the the DT 40436 7381 25 respondent respondent NN 40436 7381 26 along along IN 40436 7381 27 with with IN 40436 7381 28 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7381 29 , , , 40436 7381 30 undergo undergo VB 40436 7381 31 examination examination NN 40436 7381 32 at at IN 40436 7381 33 the the DT 40436 7381 34 same same JJ 40436 7381 35 time time NN 40436 7381 36 . . . 40436 7382 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7382 2 69 69 CD 40436 7382 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7382 4 You -PRON- PRP 40436 7382 5 answer answer VBP 40436 7382 6 then then RB 40436 7382 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7382 8 though though RB 40436 7382 9 without without IN 40436 7382 10 adopting adopt VBG 40436 7382 11 the the DT 40436 7382 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 7382 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7382 14 that that IN 40436 7382 15 men man NNS 40436 7382 16 who who WP 40436 7382 17 act act VBP 40436 7382 18 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 7382 19 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 7382 20 behave behave VBP 40436 7382 21 with with IN 40436 7382 22 moderation moderation NN 40436 7382 23 , , , 40436 7382 24 or or CC 40436 7382 25 with with IN 40436 7382 26 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7382 27 : : : 40436 7382 28 that that RB 40436 7382 29 is is RB 40436 7382 30 , , , 40436 7382 31 that that IN 40436 7382 32 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7382 33 follow follow VBP 40436 7382 34 a a DT 40436 7382 35 wise wise JJ 40436 7382 36 policy policy NN 40436 7382 37 in in IN 40436 7382 38 committing commit VBG 40436 7382 39 injustice injustice NN 40436 7382 40 . . . 40436 7383 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7383 2 Prot._--Be Prot._--Be NNP 40436 7383 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7383 4 so so RB 40436 7383 5 . . . 40436 7384 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7384 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 7384 3 admit admit VBP 40436 7384 4 too too IN 40436 7384 5 that that IN 40436 7384 6 there there EX 40436 7384 7 exist exist VBP 40436 7384 8 certain certain JJ 40436 7384 9 things thing NNS 40436 7384 10 called call VBD 40436 7384 11 good good JJ 40436 7384 12 things thing NNS 40436 7384 13 . . . 40436 7385 1 Are be VBP 40436 7385 2 those those DT 40436 7385 3 things thing NNS 40436 7385 4 good good JJ 40436 7385 5 , , , 40436 7385 6 which which WDT 40436 7385 7 are be VBP 40436 7385 8 profitable profitable JJ 40436 7385 9 to to IN 40436 7385 10 mankind mankind NN 40436 7385 11 ? ? . 40436 7386 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7386 2 Prot._--By Prot._--By NNP 40436 7386 3 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 7386 4 , , , 40436 7386 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7386 6 call call VBP 40436 7386 7 some some DT 40436 7386 8 things thing NNS 40436 7386 9 good good JJ 40436 7386 10 , , , 40436 7386 11 even even RB 40436 7386 12 though though IN 40436 7386 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7386 14 be be VBP 40436 7386 15 not not RB 40436 7386 16 profitable profitable JJ 40436 7386 17 to to IN 40436 7386 18 men man NNS 40436 7386 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7386 20 replies reply VBZ 40436 7386 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7386 22 , , , 40436 7386 23 with with IN 40436 7386 24 increasing increase VBG 40436 7386 25 acrimony acrimony NN 40436 7386 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7386 27 . . . 40436 7387 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7387 2 70 70 CD 40436 7387 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7387 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7387 5 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 7387 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7387 7 mean mean VBP 40436 7387 8 those those DT 40436 7387 9 things thing NNS 40436 7387 10 which which WDT 40436 7387 11 are be VBP 40436 7387 12 not not RB 40436 7387 13 profitable profitable JJ 40436 7387 14 to to IN 40436 7387 15 any any DT 40436 7387 16 _ _ NNP 40436 7387 17 man man NN 40436 7387 18 _ _ NNP 40436 7387 19 , , , 40436 7387 20 or or CC 40436 7387 21 those those DT 40436 7387 22 which which WDT 40436 7387 23 are be VBP 40436 7387 24 not not RB 40436 7387 25 profitable profitable JJ 40436 7387 26 to to IN 40436 7387 27 any any DT 40436 7387 28 creature creature NN 40436 7387 29 whatever whatever WDT 40436 7387 30 ? ? . 40436 7388 1 Do do VBP 40436 7388 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7388 3 call call VB 40436 7388 4 these these DT 40436 7388 5 latter latter JJ 40436 7388 6 _ _ NNP 40436 7388 7 good good JJ 40436 7388 8 _ _ NNP 40436 7388 9 also also RB 40436 7388 10 ? ? . 40436 7389 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7389 2 Prot._--Not Prot._--Not NNP 40436 7389 3 at at RB 40436 7389 4 all all RB 40436 7389 5 : : : 40436 7389 6 but but CC 40436 7389 7 there there EX 40436 7389 8 are be VBP 40436 7389 9 many many JJ 40436 7389 10 things thing NNS 40436 7389 11 profitable profitable JJ 40436 7389 12 to to IN 40436 7389 13 men man NNS 40436 7389 14 , , , 40436 7389 15 yet yet CC 40436 7389 16 unprofitable unprofitable JJ 40436 7389 17 or or CC 40436 7389 18 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 7389 19 to to IN 40436 7389 20 different different JJ 40436 7389 21 animals animal NNS 40436 7389 22 . . . 40436 7390 1 Good good JJ 40436 7390 2 is be VBZ 40436 7390 3 of of IN 40436 7390 4 a a DT 40436 7390 5 character character NN 40436 7390 6 exceedingly exceedingly RB 40436 7390 7 diversified diversified JJ 40436 7390 8 and and CC 40436 7390 9 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ 40436 7390 10 . . . 40436 7391 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7391 2 71 71 CD 40436 7391 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7391 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7391 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7391 6 69 69 CD 40436 7391 7 : : : 40436 7391 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7391 9 , , , 40436 7391 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7391 11 . . . 40436 7392 1 p. p. NN 40436 7392 2 333 333 CD 40436 7392 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7392 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7392 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7392 6 : : : 40436 7392 7 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7392 8 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7392 9 lo lo RB 40436 7392 10 / / SYM 40436 7392 11 gon gon NNP 40436 7392 12 e)/gôge e)/gôge NNP 40436 7392 13 ma ma NNP 40436 7392 14 / / SYM 40436 7392 15 lista lista NNP 40436 7392 16 e)xeta e)xeta , 40436 7392 17 / / SYM 40436 7392 18 zô zô NNP 40436 7392 19 , , , 40436 7392 20 sumbai sumbai NNP 40436 7392 21 / / SYM 40436 7392 22 nei nei NNP 40436 7392 23 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7392 24 / / SYM 40436 7392 25 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 7392 26 i)/sôs i)/sôs NNP 40436 7392 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7392 28 e)me\ e)me\ NNP 40436 7392 29 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7392 30 e)rôtô e)rôtô NNP 40436 7392 31 = = SYM 40436 7392 32 nta nta NNP 40436 7392 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7392 34 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7392 35 e)rôtô e)rôtô NNP 40436 7392 36 / / SYM 40436 7392 37 menon menon NNP 40436 7392 38 e)xeta e)xeta NNP 40436 7392 39 / / SYM 40436 7392 40 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 7392 41 . . . 40436 7392 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7393 1 Here here RB 40436 7393 2 again again RB 40436 7393 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7393 4 find find VBP 40436 7393 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7393 6 drawing draw VBG 40436 7393 7 special special JJ 40436 7393 8 attention attention NN 40436 7393 9 to to IN 40436 7393 10 the the DT 40436 7393 11 conditions condition NNS 40436 7393 12 of of IN 40436 7393 13 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 7393 14 debate debate NN 40436 7393 15 . . . 40436 7393 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7394 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7394 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7394 3 70 70 CD 40436 7394 4 : : : 40436 7394 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7394 6 , , , 40436 7394 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7394 8 . . . 40436 7395 1 p. p. NN 40436 7395 2 333 333 CD 40436 7395 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7395 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7395 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7395 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7395 7 71 71 CD 40436 7395 8 : : : 40436 7395 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7395 10 , , , 40436 7395 11 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7395 12 . . . 40436 7396 1 p. p. NN 40436 7396 2 334 334 CD 40436 7396 3 B. b. NN 40436 7397 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7397 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7397 3 : : : 40436 7397 4 Ou(/tô Ou(/tô NFP 40436 7397 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7397 6 poiki poiki NNP 40436 7397 7 / / SYM 40436 7397 8 lon lon NNP 40436 7397 9 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 7397 10 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 7397 11 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7397 12 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 7397 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7397 14 pantodapo pantodapo NNP 40436 7397 15 / / SYM 40436 7397 16 n n NNP 40436 7397 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7397 18 , , , 40436 7397 19 & & CC 40436 7397 20 c. c. NNP 40436 7397 21 The the DT 40436 7397 22 explanation explanation NN 40436 7397 23 here here RB 40436 7397 24 given give VBN 40436 7397 25 by by IN 40436 7397 26 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7397 27 of of IN 40436 7397 28 _ _ NNP 40436 7397 29 good good JJ 40436 7397 30 _ _ NNP 40436 7397 31 is be VBZ 40436 7397 32 the the DT 40436 7397 33 same same JJ 40436 7397 34 as as IN 40436 7397 35 that that DT 40436 7397 36 which which WDT 40436 7397 37 is be VBZ 40436 7397 38 given give VBN 40436 7397 39 by by IN 40436 7397 40 the the DT 40436 7397 41 historical historical JJ 40436 7397 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7397 43 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7397 44 in in IN 40436 7397 45 the the DT 40436 7397 46 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 7397 47 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 7397 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7397 49 iii iii CD 40436 7397 50 . . . 40436 7398 1 8) 8) CD 40436 7398 2 . . . 40436 7399 1 Things thing NNS 40436 7399 2 called call VBN 40436 7399 3 good good JJ 40436 7399 4 are be VBP 40436 7399 5 diverse diverse JJ 40436 7399 6 in in IN 40436 7399 7 the the DT 40436 7399 8 highest high JJS 40436 7399 9 degree degree NN 40436 7399 10 ; ; : 40436 7399 11 but but CC 40436 7399 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7399 13 are be VBP 40436 7399 14 all all RB 40436 7399 15 called call VBN 40436 7399 16 _ _ NNP 40436 7399 17 good good JJ 40436 7399 18 _ _ NNP 40436 7399 19 because because IN 40436 7399 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7399 21 all all DT 40436 7399 22 contribute contribute VBP 40436 7399 23 in in IN 40436 7399 24 some some DT 40436 7399 25 way way NN 40436 7399 26 to to IN 40436 7399 27 human human JJ 40436 7399 28 security security NN 40436 7399 29 , , , 40436 7399 30 relief relief NN 40436 7399 31 , , , 40436 7399 32 comfort comfort NN 40436 7399 33 , , , 40436 7399 34 or or CC 40436 7399 35 prosperity prosperity NN 40436 7399 36 . . . 40436 7400 1 To to IN 40436 7400 2 one one CD 40436 7400 3 or or CC 40436 7400 4 other other JJ 40436 7400 5 of of IN 40436 7400 6 these these DT 40436 7400 7 ends end NNS 40436 7400 8 _ _ NNP 40436 7400 9 good good JJ 40436 7400 10 _ _ NNP 40436 7400 11 , , , 40436 7400 12 in in IN 40436 7400 13 all all DT 40436 7400 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7400 15 multifarious multifarious JJ 40436 7400 16 forms form NNS 40436 7400 17 , , , 40436 7400 18 is be VBZ 40436 7400 19 relative relative JJ 40436 7400 20 . . . 40436 7400 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7401 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7401 2 Side side NN 40436 7401 3 - - HYPH 40436 7401 4 note note NN 40436 7401 5 : : : 40436 7401 6 Remonstrance remonstrance NN 40436 7401 7 of of IN 40436 7401 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7401 9 against against IN 40436 7401 10 long long JJ 40436 7401 11 answers answer NNS 40436 7401 12 as as IN 40436 7401 13 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 7401 14 with with IN 40436 7401 15 the the DT 40436 7401 16 laws law NNS 40436 7401 17 of of IN 40436 7401 18 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7401 19 . . . 40436 7402 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7402 2 persists persist VBZ 40436 7402 3 . . . 40436 7403 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7403 2 rises rise VBZ 40436 7403 3 to to TO 40436 7403 4 depart depart VB 40436 7403 5 . . . 40436 7403 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7404 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7404 2 is be VBZ 40436 7404 3 represented represent VBN 40436 7404 4 as as IN 40436 7404 5 giving give VBG 40436 7404 6 this this DT 40436 7404 7 answer answer NN 40436 7404 8 at at IN 40436 7404 9 considerable considerable JJ 40436 7404 10 length length NN 40436 7404 11 , , , 40436 7404 12 and and CC 40436 7404 13 in in IN 40436 7404 14 a a DT 40436 7404 15 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 7404 16 manner manner NN 40436 7404 17 , , , 40436 7404 18 so so IN 40436 7404 19 as as IN 40436 7404 20 to to TO 40436 7404 21 elicit elicit VB 40436 7404 22 applause applause NN 40436 7404 23 from from IN 40436 7404 24 the the DT 40436 7404 25 hearers hearer NNS 40436 7404 26 . . . 40436 7405 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7405 2 72 72 CD 40436 7405 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7405 4 Upon upon IN 40436 7405 5 this this DT 40436 7405 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7405 7 replies reply VBZ 40436 7405 8 , , , 40436 7405 9 " " `` 40436 7405 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7405 11 am be VBP 40436 7405 12 a a DT 40436 7405 13 man man NN 40436 7405 14 of of IN 40436 7405 15 short short JJ 40436 7405 16 memory memory NN 40436 7405 17 , , , 40436 7405 18 and and CC 40436 7405 19 if if IN 40436 7405 20 any any DT 40436 7405 21 one one CD 40436 7405 22 speaks speak VBZ 40436 7405 23 at at IN 40436 7405 24 length length NN 40436 7405 25 , , , 40436 7405 26 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7405 27 forget forget VBP 40436 7405 28 what what WP 40436 7405 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7405 30 has have VBZ 40436 7405 31 said say VBN 40436 7405 32 . . . 40436 7406 1 If if IN 40436 7406 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7406 3 wish wish VBP 40436 7406 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7406 5 to to TO 40436 7406 6 follow follow VB 40436 7406 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7406 8 , , , 40436 7406 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7406 10 must must MD 40436 7406 11 entreat entreat VB 40436 7406 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7406 13 to to TO 40436 7406 14 make make VB 40436 7406 15 shorter short JJR 40436 7406 16 answers answer NNS 40436 7406 17 . . . 40436 7406 18 " " '' 40436 7407 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7407 2 Prot._--What Prot._--What NNP 40436 7407 3 do do VBP 40436 7407 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7407 5 mean mean VB 40436 7407 6 by by IN 40436 7407 7 asking ask VBG 40436 7407 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7407 9 to to TO 40436 7407 10 make make VB 40436 7407 11 shorter short JJR 40436 7407 12 answers answer NNS 40436 7407 13 ? ? . 40436 7408 1 Do do VBP 40436 7408 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7408 3 mean mean VB 40436 7408 4 shorter short JJR 40436 7408 5 than than IN 40436 7408 6 the the DT 40436 7408 7 case case NN 40436 7408 8 requires require VBZ 40436 7408 9 ? ? . 40436 7409 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7409 2 Sokr._--No Sokr._--No NNP 40436 7409 3 , , , 40436 7409 4 certainly certainly RB 40436 7409 5 not not RB 40436 7409 6 . . . 40436 7410 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7410 2 Prot._--But Prot._--But NNP 40436 7410 3 who who WP 40436 7410 4 is be VBZ 40436 7410 5 to to TO 40436 7410 6 be be VB 40436 7410 7 judge judge NN 40436 7410 8 of of IN 40436 7410 9 the the DT 40436 7410 10 brevity brevity NN 40436 7410 11 necessary necessary JJ 40436 7410 12 , , , 40436 7410 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7410 14 or or CC 40436 7410 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7410 16 ? ? . 40436 7411 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7411 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 7411 3 have have VBP 40436 7411 4 understood understand VBN 40436 7411 5 that that IN 40436 7411 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7411 7 profess profess VBP 40436 7411 8 to to TO 40436 7411 9 be be VB 40436 7411 10 master master NN 40436 7411 11 and and CC 40436 7411 12 teacher teacher NN 40436 7411 13 both both DT 40436 7411 14 of of IN 40436 7411 15 long long JJ 40436 7411 16 speech speech NN 40436 7411 17 and and CC 40436 7411 18 of of IN 40436 7411 19 short short JJ 40436 7411 20 speech speech NN 40436 7411 21 : : : 40436 7411 22 what what WP 40436 7411 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7411 24 beg beg VBP 40436 7411 25 is be VBZ 40436 7411 26 , , , 40436 7411 27 that that IN 40436 7411 28 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7411 29 will will MD 40436 7411 30 employ employ VB 40436 7411 31 only only JJ 40436 7411 32 short short JJ 40436 7411 33 speech speech NN 40436 7411 34 , , , 40436 7411 35 if if IN 40436 7411 36 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7411 37 expect expect VBP 40436 7411 38 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7411 39 to to TO 40436 7411 40 follow follow VB 40436 7411 41 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7411 42 . . . 40436 7412 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7412 2 Prot._--Why Prot._--Why NNP 40436 7412 3 , , , 40436 7412 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7412 5 , , , 40436 7412 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7412 7 have have VBP 40436 7412 8 carried carry VBN 40436 7412 9 on on IN 40436 7412 10 many many JJ 40436 7412 11 debates debate NNS 40436 7412 12 in in IN 40436 7412 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7412 14 time time NN 40436 7412 15 ; ; : 40436 7412 16 and and CC 40436 7412 17 if if IN 40436 7412 18 , , , 40436 7412 19 as as IN 40436 7412 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7412 21 ask ask VBP 40436 7412 22 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7412 23 now now RB 40436 7412 24 , , , 40436 7412 25 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7412 26 had have VBD 40436 7412 27 always always RB 40436 7412 28 talked talk VBN 40436 7412 29 just just RB 40436 7412 30 as as IN 40436 7412 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7412 32 opponent opponent NN 40436 7412 33 wished wish VBD 40436 7412 34 , , , 40436 7412 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7412 36 should should MD 40436 7412 37 never never RB 40436 7412 38 have have VB 40436 7412 39 acquired acquire VBN 40436 7412 40 any any DT 40436 7412 41 reputation reputation NN 40436 7412 42 at at RB 40436 7412 43 all all RB 40436 7412 44 . . . 40436 7413 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7413 2 Sokr._--Be Sokr._--Be VBD 40436 7413 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7413 4 so so RB 40436 7413 5 : : : 40436 7413 6 in in IN 40436 7413 7 that that DT 40436 7413 8 case case NN 40436 7413 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7413 10 must must MD 40436 7413 11 retire retire VB 40436 7413 12 ; ; : 40436 7413 13 for for IN 40436 7413 14 as as IN 40436 7413 15 to to IN 40436 7413 16 long long JJ 40436 7413 17 speaking speak VBG 40436 7413 18 , , , 40436 7413 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7413 20 am be VBP 40436 7413 21 incompetent incompetent JJ 40436 7413 22 : : : 40436 7413 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7413 24 can can MD 40436 7413 25 neither neither CC 40436 7413 26 make make VB 40436 7413 27 long long JJ 40436 7413 28 speeches speech NNS 40436 7413 29 , , , 40436 7413 30 nor nor CC 40436 7413 31 follow follow VB 40436 7413 32 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7413 33 . . . 40436 7414 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7414 2 73 73 CD 40436 7414 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7414 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7414 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7414 6 72 72 CD 40436 7414 7 : : : 40436 7414 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7414 9 , , , 40436 7414 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7414 11 . . . 40436 7415 1 p. p. NN 40436 7415 2 334 334 CD 40436 7415 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7415 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7415 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7415 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7415 7 73 73 CD 40436 7415 8 : : : 40436 7415 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7415 10 , , , 40436 7415 11 Prot Prot NNP 40436 7415 12 . . . 40436 7416 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7416 2 . . . 40436 7417 1 334 334 CD 40436 7417 2 E e NN 40436 7417 3 , , , 40436 7417 4 335 335 CD 40436 7417 5 A A NNP 40436 7417 6 - - HYPH 40436 7417 7 C. C. NNP 40436 7417 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7417 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7417 10 Side side NN 40436 7417 11 - - HYPH 40436 7417 12 note note NN 40436 7417 13 : : : 40436 7417 14 Interference interference NN 40436 7417 15 of of IN 40436 7417 16 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 7417 17 to to TO 40436 7417 18 get get VB 40436 7417 19 the the DT 40436 7417 20 debate debate NN 40436 7417 21 continued continue VBN 40436 7417 22 . . . 40436 7418 1 Promiscuous promiscuous JJ 40436 7418 2 conversation conversation NN 40436 7418 3 . . . 40436 7419 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 7419 2 declares declare VBZ 40436 7419 3 that that IN 40436 7419 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7419 5 ought ought MD 40436 7419 6 to to TO 40436 7419 7 acknowledge acknowledge VB 40436 7419 8 superiority superiority NN 40436 7419 9 of of IN 40436 7419 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7419 11 in in IN 40436 7419 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7419 13 . . . 40436 7419 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7420 1 Here here RB 40436 7420 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7420 3 rises rise VBZ 40436 7420 4 to to TO 40436 7420 5 depart depart VB 40436 7420 6 ; ; : 40436 7420 7 but but CC 40436 7420 8 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 7420 9 , , , 40436 7420 10 the the DT 40436 7420 11 master master NN 40436 7420 12 of of IN 40436 7420 13 the the DT 40436 7420 14 house house NN 40436 7420 15 , , , 40436 7420 16 detains detain VBZ 40436 7420 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7420 18 , , , 40436 7420 19 and and CC 40436 7420 20 expresses express VBZ 40436 7420 21 an an DT 40436 7420 22 earnest earnest JJ 40436 7420 23 wish wish NN 40436 7420 24 that that IN 40436 7420 25 the the DT 40436 7420 26 debate debate NN 40436 7420 27 may may MD 40436 7420 28 be be VB 40436 7420 29 continued continue VBN 40436 7420 30 . . . 40436 7421 1 A a DT 40436 7421 2 promiscuous promiscuous JJ 40436 7421 3 conversation conversation NN 40436 7421 4 ensues ensue NNS 40436 7421 5 , , , 40436 7421 6 in in IN 40436 7421 7 which which WDT 40436 7421 8 most most JJS 40436 7421 9 persons person NNS 40436 7421 10 present present JJ 40436 7421 11 take take VBP 40436 7421 12 part part NN 40436 7421 13 . . . 40436 7422 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 7422 2 , , , 40436 7422 3 as as IN 40436 7422 4 the the DT 40436 7422 5 champion champion NN 40436 7422 6 of of IN 40436 7422 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7422 8 , , , 40436 7422 9 gives give VBZ 40436 7422 10 , , , 40436 7422 11 what what WP 40436 7422 12 seems seem VBZ 40436 7422 13 really really RB 40436 7422 14 to to TO 40436 7422 15 be be VB 40436 7422 16 the the DT 40436 7422 17 key key NN 40436 7422 18 of of IN 40436 7422 19 the the DT 40436 7422 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7422 21 , , , 40436 7422 22 when when WRB 40436 7422 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7422 24 says--"Sokrates says--"sokrate VBZ 40436 7422 25 admits admit VBZ 40436 7422 26 that that IN 40436 7422 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7422 28 has have VBZ 40436 7422 29 no no DT 40436 7422 30 capacity capacity NN 40436 7422 31 for for IN 40436 7422 32 long long JJ 40436 7422 33 speaking speaking NN 40436 7422 34 , , , 40436 7422 35 and and CC 40436 7422 36 that that IN 40436 7422 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7422 38 is be VBZ 40436 7422 39 no no DT 40436 7422 40 match match NN 40436 7422 41 therein therein RB 40436 7422 42 for for IN 40436 7422 43 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7422 44 . . . 40436 7423 1 But but CC 40436 7423 2 as as IN 40436 7423 3 to to IN 40436 7423 4 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 7423 5 debate debate NN 40436 7423 6 , , , 40436 7423 7 or or CC 40436 7423 8 administering administer VBG 40436 7423 9 and and CC 40436 7423 10 resisting resist VBG 40436 7423 11 cross cross NN 40436 7423 12 - - NN 40436 7423 13 examination examination NN 40436 7423 14 , , , 40436 7423 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7423 16 should should MD 40436 7423 17 be be VB 40436 7423 18 surprised surprised JJ 40436 7423 19 if if IN 40436 7423 20 any any DT 40436 7423 21 one one NN 40436 7423 22 were be VBD 40436 7423 23 a a DT 40436 7423 24 match match NN 40436 7423 25 for for IN 40436 7423 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7423 27 . . . 40436 7424 1 If if IN 40436 7424 2 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7424 3 admits admit VBZ 40436 7424 4 that that IN 40436 7424 5 on on IN 40436 7424 6 this this DT 40436 7424 7 point point NN 40436 7424 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7424 9 is be VBZ 40436 7424 10 inferior inferior JJ 40436 7424 11 , , , 40436 7424 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7424 13 requires require VBZ 40436 7424 14 no no DT 40436 7424 15 more more JJR 40436 7424 16 : : : 40436 7424 17 if if IN 40436 7424 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7424 19 does do VBZ 40436 7424 20 not not RB 40436 7424 21 , , , 40436 7424 22 let let VB 40436 7424 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7424 24 continue continue VB 40436 7424 25 the the DT 40436 7424 26 debate debate NN 40436 7424 27 : : : 40436 7424 28 but but CC 40436 7424 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7424 30 must must MD 40436 7424 31 not not RB 40436 7424 32 lengthen lengthen VB 40436 7424 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7424 34 answers answer NNS 40436 7424 35 so so IN 40436 7424 36 that that IN 40436 7424 37 hearers hearer NNS 40436 7424 38 lose lose VBP 40436 7424 39 the the DT 40436 7424 40 thread thread NN 40436 7424 41 of of IN 40436 7424 42 the the DT 40436 7424 43 subject subject NN 40436 7424 44 . . . 40436 7424 45 " " '' 40436 7425 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7425 2 Side side NN 40436 7425 3 - - HYPH 40436 7425 4 note note NN 40436 7425 5 : : : 40436 7425 6 Claim claim NN 40436 7425 7 of of IN 40436 7425 8 a a DT 40436 7425 9 special special JJ 40436 7425 10 _ _ NNP 40436 7425 11 locus locus NN 40436 7425 12 standi standi NN 40436 7425 13 _ _ NNP 40436 7425 14 and and CC 40436 7425 15 professorship professorship NN 40436 7425 16 for for IN 40436 7425 17 Dialectic Dialectic NNP 40436 7425 18 , , , 40436 7425 19 apart apart RB 40436 7425 20 from from IN 40436 7425 21 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 7425 22 . . . 40436 7425 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7426 1 This this DT 40436 7426 2 remark remark NN 40436 7426 3 of of IN 40436 7426 4 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 7426 5 , , , 40436 7426 6 speaking speak VBG 40436 7426 7 altogether altogether RB 40436 7426 8 as as IN 40436 7426 9 a a DT 40436 7426 10 vehement vehement JJ 40436 7426 11 partisan partisan NN 40436 7426 12 of of IN 40436 7426 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7426 14 , , , 40436 7426 15 brings bring VBZ 40436 7426 16 to to TO 40436 7426 17 view view VB 40436 7426 18 at at RB 40436 7426 19 least least RBS 40436 7426 20 one one CD 40436 7426 21 purpose purpose NN 40436 7426 22 -- -- : 40436 7426 23 if if IN 40436 7426 24 not not RB 40436 7426 25 the the DT 40436 7426 26 main main JJ 40436 7426 27 purpose purpose NN 40436 7426 28 -- -- : 40436 7426 29 of of IN 40436 7426 30 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7426 31 in in IN 40436 7426 32 the the DT 40436 7426 33 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7426 34 . . . 40436 7427 1 " " `` 40436 7427 2 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7427 3 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 40436 7427 4 the the DT 40436 7427 5 superiority superiority NN 40436 7427 6 of of IN 40436 7427 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7427 8 in in IN 40436 7427 9 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 7427 10 : : : 40436 7427 11 if if IN 40436 7427 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7427 13 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 40436 7427 14 the the DT 40436 7427 15 superiority superiority NN 40436 7427 16 of of IN 40436 7427 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7427 18 in in IN 40436 7427 19 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 7427 20 , , , 40436 7427 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7427 22 is be VBZ 40436 7427 23 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 7427 24 . . . 40436 7428 1 " " `` 40436 7428 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7428 3 74 74 CD 40436 7428 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7428 5 An an DT 40436 7428 6 express express JJ 40436 7428 7 _ _ NNP 40436 7428 8 locus locus NN 40436 7428 9 standi standi NN 40436 7428 10 _ _ NNP 40436 7428 11 is be VBZ 40436 7428 12 here here RB 40436 7428 13 claimed claim VBN 40436 7428 14 for for IN 40436 7428 15 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 7428 16 , , , 40436 7428 17 and and CC 40436 7428 18 a a DT 40436 7428 19 recognised recognise VBN 40436 7428 20 superiority superiority NN 40436 7428 21 for for IN 40436 7428 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7428 23 professors professor NNS 40436 7428 24 on on IN 40436 7428 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7428 26 own own JJ 40436 7428 27 ground ground NN 40436 7428 28 . . . 40436 7429 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7429 2 professes profess VBZ 40436 7429 3 to to TO 40436 7429 4 be be VB 40436 7429 5 master master NN 40436 7429 6 both both DT 40436 7429 7 of of IN 40436 7429 8 long long JJ 40436 7429 9 speech speech NN 40436 7429 10 and and CC 40436 7429 11 of of IN 40436 7429 12 short short JJ 40436 7429 13 speech speech NN 40436 7429 14 : : : 40436 7429 15 but but CC 40436 7429 16 in in IN 40436 7429 17 the the DT 40436 7429 18 last last JJ 40436 7429 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7429 20 must must MD 40436 7429 21 recognise recognise VB 40436 7429 22 a a DT 40436 7429 23 superior superior NN 40436 7429 24 . . . 40436 7430 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7430 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7430 3 74 74 CD 40436 7430 4 : : : 40436 7430 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7430 6 . . . 40436 7431 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7431 2 . . . 40436 7432 1 p. p. NN 40436 7432 2 336 336 CD 40436 7432 3 C C NNP 40436 7432 4 - - HYPH 40436 7432 5 D. D. NNP 40436 7432 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7432 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7432 8 Side side NN 40436 7432 9 - - HYPH 40436 7432 10 note note NN 40436 7432 11 : : : 40436 7432 12 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7432 13 is be VBZ 40436 7432 14 prevailed prevail VBN 40436 7432 15 upon upon IN 40436 7432 16 to to TO 40436 7432 17 continue continue VB 40436 7432 18 , , , 40436 7432 19 and and CC 40436 7432 20 invites invite VBZ 40436 7432 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7432 22 to to TO 40436 7432 23 question question VB 40436 7432 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7432 25 . . . 40436 7432 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7433 1 Kritias Kritias NNP 40436 7433 2 , , , 40436 7433 3 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7433 4 , , , 40436 7433 5 and and CC 40436 7433 6 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 7433 7 all all DT 40436 7433 8 speak speak VBP 40436 7433 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7433 10 each each DT 40436 7433 11 in in IN 40436 7433 12 a a DT 40436 7433 13 manner manner NN 40436 7433 14 of of IN 40436 7433 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7433 16 own own JJ 40436 7433 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7433 18 deprecating deprecate VBG 40436 7433 19 marked mark VBN 40436 7433 20 partisanship partisanship NN 40436 7433 21 on on IN 40436 7433 22 either either DT 40436 7433 23 side side NN 40436 7433 24 , , , 40436 7433 25 exhorting exhort VBG 40436 7433 26 both both DT 40436 7433 27 parties party NNS 40436 7433 28 to to IN 40436 7433 29 moderation moderation NN 40436 7433 30 , , , 40436 7433 31 and and CC 40436 7433 32 insisting insist VBG 40436 7433 33 that that IN 40436 7433 34 the the DT 40436 7433 35 conversation conversation NN 40436 7433 36 shall shall MD 40436 7433 37 be be VB 40436 7433 38 continued continue VBN 40436 7433 39 . . . 40436 7434 1 At at IN 40436 7434 2 length length NN 40436 7434 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7434 4 consents consent NNS 40436 7434 5 to to TO 40436 7434 6 remain remain VB 40436 7434 7 , , , 40436 7434 8 yet yet CC 40436 7434 9 on on IN 40436 7434 10 condition condition NN 40436 7434 11 that that IN 40436 7434 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7434 13 shall shall MD 40436 7434 14 confine confine VB 40436 7434 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7434 16 within within IN 40436 7434 17 the the DT 40436 7434 18 limits limit NNS 40436 7434 19 of of IN 40436 7434 20 the the DT 40436 7434 21 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 7434 22 procedure procedure NN 40436 7434 23 . . . 40436 7435 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7435 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7435 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7435 4 says say VBZ 40436 7435 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7435 6 shall shall MD 40436 7435 7 first first RB 40436 7435 8 question question VB 40436 7435 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7435 10 as as RB 40436 7435 11 long long RB 40436 7435 12 as as IN 40436 7435 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7435 14 pleases please VBZ 40436 7435 15 : : : 40436 7435 16 when when WRB 40436 7435 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7435 18 has have VBZ 40436 7435 19 finished finish VBN 40436 7435 20 , , , 40436 7435 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7435 22 will will MD 40436 7435 23 question question VB 40436 7435 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7435 25 . . . 40436 7436 1 The the DT 40436 7436 2 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7436 3 , , , 40436 7436 4 though though IN 40436 7436 5 at at IN 40436 7436 6 first first JJ 40436 7436 7 reluctant reluctant NNP 40436 7436 8 , , , 40436 7436 9 is be VBZ 40436 7436 10 constrained constrain VBN 40436 7436 11 , , , 40436 7436 12 by by IN 40436 7436 13 the the DT 40436 7436 14 instance instance NN 40436 7436 15 of of IN 40436 7436 16 those those DT 40436 7436 17 around around RB 40436 7436 18 , , , 40436 7436 19 to to TO 40436 7436 20 accede accede VB 40436 7436 21 to to IN 40436 7436 22 this this DT 40436 7436 23 proposition proposition NN 40436 7436 24 . . . 40436 7437 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7437 2 75 75 CD 40436 7437 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7437 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7437 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7437 6 75 75 CD 40436 7437 7 : : : 40436 7437 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7437 9 . . . 40436 7438 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7438 2 . . . 40436 7439 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7439 2 . . . 40436 7440 1 337 337 CD 40436 7440 2 - - SYM 40436 7440 3 338 338 CD 40436 7440 4 . . . 40436 7440 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7441 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7441 2 Side side NN 40436 7441 3 - - HYPH 40436 7441 4 note note NN 40436 7441 5 : : : 40436 7441 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7441 7 extols extol VBZ 40436 7441 8 the the DT 40436 7441 9 importance importance NN 40436 7441 10 of of IN 40436 7441 11 knowing know VBG 40436 7441 12 the the DT 40436 7441 13 works work NNS 40436 7441 14 of of IN 40436 7441 15 the the DT 40436 7441 16 poets poet NNS 40436 7441 17 , , , 40436 7441 18 and and CC 40436 7441 19 questions question NNS 40436 7441 20 about about IN 40436 7441 21 parts part NNS 40436 7441 22 of of IN 40436 7441 23 a a DT 40436 7441 24 song song NN 40436 7441 25 of of IN 40436 7441 26 Simonides simonide NNS 40436 7441 27 . . . 40436 7442 1 Dissenting dissent VBG 40436 7442 2 opinions opinion NNS 40436 7442 3 about about IN 40436 7442 4 the the DT 40436 7442 5 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7442 6 of of IN 40436 7442 7 the the DT 40436 7442 8 song song NN 40436 7442 9 . . . 40436 7442 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7443 1 For for IN 40436 7443 2 the the DT 40436 7443 3 purpose purpose NN 40436 7443 4 of of IN 40436 7443 5 questioning questioning NN 40436 7443 6 , , , 40436 7443 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7443 8 selects select VBZ 40436 7443 9 a a DT 40436 7443 10 song song NN 40436 7443 11 of of IN 40436 7443 12 Simonides simonide NNS 40436 7443 13 : : : 40436 7443 14 prefacing preface VBG 40436 7443 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7443 16 with with IN 40436 7443 17 a a DT 40436 7443 18 remark remark NN 40436 7443 19 , , , 40436 7443 20 that that IN 40436 7443 21 the the DT 40436 7443 22 most most RBS 40436 7443 23 important important JJ 40436 7443 24 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 7443 25 of of IN 40436 7443 26 a a DT 40436 7443 27 cultivated cultivated JJ 40436 7443 28 man man NN 40436 7443 29 consists consist VBZ 40436 7443 30 in in IN 40436 7443 31 being be VBG 40436 7443 32 thorough thorough JJ 40436 7443 33 master master NN 40436 7443 34 of of IN 40436 7443 35 the the DT 40436 7443 36 works work NNS 40436 7443 37 of of IN 40436 7443 38 the the DT 40436 7443 39 poets poet NNS 40436 7443 40 , , , 40436 7443 41 so so IN 40436 7443 42 as as IN 40436 7443 43 to to TO 40436 7443 44 understand understand VB 40436 7443 45 and and CC 40436 7443 46 appreciate appreciate VB 40436 7443 47 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7443 48 correctly correctly RB 40436 7443 49 , , , 40436 7443 50 and and CC 40436 7443 51 answer answer VB 40436 7443 52 all all DT 40436 7443 53 questions question NNS 40436 7443 54 respecting respect VBG 40436 7443 55 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7443 56 . . . 40436 7444 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7444 2 76 76 CD 40436 7444 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7444 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7444 5 intimates intimate VBZ 40436 7444 6 that that IN 40436 7444 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7444 8 knows know VBZ 40436 7444 9 and and CC 40436 7444 10 admires admire VBZ 40436 7444 11 the the DT 40436 7444 12 song song NN 40436 7444 13 : : : 40436 7444 14 upon upon IN 40436 7444 15 which which WDT 40436 7444 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7444 17 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 7444 18 to to TO 40436 7444 19 point point VB 40436 7444 20 out out RP 40436 7444 21 two two CD 40436 7444 22 passages passage NNS 40436 7444 23 in in IN 40436 7444 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7444 25 which which WDT 40436 7444 26 contradict contradict VBP 40436 7444 27 each each DT 40436 7444 28 other other JJ 40436 7444 29 , , , 40436 7444 30 and and CC 40436 7444 31 asks ask VBZ 40436 7444 32 how how WRB 40436 7444 33 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7444 34 can can MD 40436 7444 35 explain explain VB 40436 7444 36 or or CC 40436 7444 37 justify justify VB 40436 7444 38 such such JJ 40436 7444 39 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 7444 40 . . . 40436 7445 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7445 2 77 77 CD 40436 7445 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7445 4 The the DT 40436 7445 5 latter latter NN 40436 7445 6 is be VBZ 40436 7445 7 at at IN 40436 7445 8 first first RB 40436 7445 9 embarrassed embarrassed JJ 40436 7445 10 , , , 40436 7445 11 and and CC 40436 7445 12 invokes invoke VBZ 40436 7445 13 the the DT 40436 7445 14 aid aid NN 40436 7445 15 of of IN 40436 7445 16 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7445 17 ; ; : 40436 7445 18 who who WP 40436 7445 19 interferes interfere VBZ 40436 7445 20 to to TO 40436 7445 21 uphold uphold VB 40436 7445 22 the the DT 40436 7445 23 consistency consistency NN 40436 7445 24 of of IN 40436 7445 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7445 26 fellow fellow JJ 40436 7445 27 - - HYPH 40436 7445 28 citizen citizen NN 40436 7445 29 Simonides simonide NNS 40436 7445 30 , , , 40436 7445 31 but but CC 40436 7445 32 is be VBZ 40436 7445 33 made make VBN 40436 7445 34 to to TO 40436 7445 35 speak speak VB 40436 7445 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7445 37 as as RB 40436 7445 38 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 7445 39 by by IN 40436 7445 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7445 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7445 42 in in IN 40436 7445 43 a a DT 40436 7445 44 stupid stupid JJ 40436 7445 45 and and CC 40436 7445 46 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 7445 47 manner manner NN 40436 7445 48 . . . 40436 7446 1 After after IN 40436 7446 2 a a DT 40436 7446 3 desultory desultory JJ 40436 7446 4 string string NN 40436 7446 5 of of IN 40436 7446 6 remarks,[78 remarks,[78 NNP 40436 7446 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7446 8 with with IN 40436 7446 9 disputed dispute VBN 40436 7446 10 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7446 11 of of IN 40436 7446 12 particular particular JJ 40436 7446 13 phrases phrase NNS 40436 7446 14 and and CC 40436 7446 15 passages passage NNS 40436 7446 16 of of IN 40436 7446 17 the the DT 40436 7446 18 song song NN 40436 7446 19 , , , 40436 7446 20 but but CC 40436 7446 21 without without IN 40436 7446 22 promise promise NN 40436 7446 23 of of IN 40436 7446 24 any any DT 40436 7446 25 result result NN 40436 7446 26 -- -- : 40436 7446 27 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7446 28 offers offer VBZ 40436 7446 29 to to TO 40436 7446 30 give give VB 40436 7446 31 an an DT 40436 7446 32 exposition exposition NN 40436 7446 33 of of IN 40436 7446 34 the the DT 40436 7446 35 general general JJ 40436 7446 36 purpose purpose NN 40436 7446 37 of of IN 40436 7446 38 the the DT 40436 7446 39 whole whole JJ 40436 7446 40 song song NN 40436 7446 41 , , , 40436 7446 42 in in IN 40436 7446 43 order order NN 40436 7446 44 that that IN 40436 7446 45 the the DT 40436 7446 46 company company NN 40436 7446 47 may may MD 40436 7446 48 see see VB 40436 7446 49 how how WRB 40436 7446 50 far far RB 40436 7446 51 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7446 52 has have VBZ 40436 7446 53 advanced advance VBN 40436 7446 54 in in IN 40436 7446 55 that that DT 40436 7446 56 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 7446 57 which which WDT 40436 7446 58 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7446 59 had have VBD 40436 7446 60 so so RB 40436 7446 61 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 7446 62 extolled extoll VBN 40436 7446 63 -- -- : 40436 7446 64 complete complete JJ 40436 7446 65 mastery mastery NN 40436 7446 66 of of IN 40436 7446 67 the the DT 40436 7446 68 works work NNS 40436 7446 69 of of IN 40436 7446 70 the the DT 40436 7446 71 poets poet NNS 40436 7446 72 . . . 40436 7447 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7447 2 79 79 CD 40436 7447 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7447 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7447 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7447 6 76 76 CD 40436 7447 7 : : : 40436 7447 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7447 9 . . . 40436 7448 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7448 2 . . . 40436 7449 1 p. p. NN 40436 7449 2 339 339 CD 40436 7449 3 A. a. NN 40436 7450 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7450 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7450 3 : : : 40436 7450 4 ê(gou ê(gou NN 40436 7450 5 = = SYM 40436 7450 6 mai mai NNP 40436 7450 7 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 7450 8 a)ndri\ a)ndri\ NNP 40436 7450 9 paidei paidei NNP 40436 7450 10 / / SYM 40436 7450 11 as as IN 40436 7450 12 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7450 13 / / SYM 40436 7450 14 giston giston NNP 40436 7450 15 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7450 16 / / SYM 40436 7450 17 ros ros NNP 40436 7450 18 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNPS 40436 7450 19 , , , 40436 7450 20 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 7450 21 e)pô e)pô NNP 40436 7450 22 = = SYM 40436 7450 23 n n NNP 40436 7450 24 deino\n deino\n ADD 40436 7450 25 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7450 26 . . . 40436 7450 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7450 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7451 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7451 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7451 3 77 77 CD 40436 7451 4 : : : 40436 7451 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7451 6 . . . 40436 7452 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7452 2 . . . 40436 7453 1 p. p. NN 40436 7453 2 339 339 CD 40436 7453 3 C C NNP 40436 7453 4 - - HYPH 40436 7453 5 D. D. NNP 40436 7453 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7453 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7453 8 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7453 9 78 78 CD 40436 7453 10 : : : 40436 7453 11 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7453 12 . . . 40436 7454 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7454 2 . . . 40436 7455 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7455 2 . . . 40436 7456 1 340 340 CD 40436 7456 2 - - SYM 40436 7456 3 341 341 CD 40436 7456 4 . . . 40436 7456 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7457 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7457 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7457 3 79 79 CD 40436 7457 4 : : : 40436 7457 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7457 6 . . . 40436 7458 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7458 2 . . . 40436 7459 1 p. p. NN 40436 7459 2 342 342 CD 40436 7459 3 A. a. NN 40436 7460 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7460 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7460 3 : : : 40436 7460 4 ei ei NNP 40436 7460 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7460 6 bou bou NNP 40436 7460 7 / / SYM 40436 7460 8 lei lei NNP 40436 7460 9 labei labei NN 40436 7460 10 = = NFP 40436 7460 11 n n CC 40436 7460 12 mou mou NN 40436 7460 13 pei pei NNP 40436 7460 14 = = -RRB- 40436 7460 15 ran run VBD 40436 7460 16 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 7460 17 e)/chô e)/chô NNP 40436 7460 18 , , , 40436 7460 19 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 7460 20 su\ su\ NNP 40436 7460 21 le le NNP 40436 7460 22 / / SYM 40436 7460 23 geis geis NNP 40436 7460 24 tou tou NNP 40436 7460 25 = = NNP 40436 7460 26 to to IN 40436 7460 27 , , , 40436 7460 28 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 7460 29 e)pô e)pô NNP 40436 7460 30 = = SYM 40436 7460 31 n n XX 40436 7460 32 . . . 40436 7460 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7460 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7461 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7461 2 Side side NN 40436 7461 3 - - HYPH 40436 7461 4 note note NN 40436 7461 5 : : : 40436 7461 6 Long long JJ 40436 7461 7 speech speech NN 40436 7461 8 of of IN 40436 7461 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7461 10 , , , 40436 7461 11 expounding expound VBG 40436 7461 12 the the DT 40436 7461 13 purpose purpose NN 40436 7461 14 of of IN 40436 7461 15 the the DT 40436 7461 16 song song NN 40436 7461 17 , , , 40436 7461 18 and and CC 40436 7461 19 laying lay VBG 40436 7461 20 down down RP 40436 7461 21 an an DT 40436 7461 22 ironical ironical JJ 40436 7461 23 theory theory NN 40436 7461 24 about about IN 40436 7461 25 the the DT 40436 7461 26 numerous numerous JJ 40436 7461 27 concealed conceal VBN 40436 7461 28 sophists sophist NNS 40436 7461 29 at at IN 40436 7461 30 Krete Krete NNP 40436 7461 31 and and CC 40436 7461 32 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 7461 33 , , , 40436 7461 34 masters master NNS 40436 7461 35 of of IN 40436 7461 36 short short JJ 40436 7461 37 speech speech NN 40436 7461 38 . . . 40436 7461 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7462 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7462 2 then then RB 40436 7462 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 7462 4 to to TO 40436 7462 5 deliver deliver VB 40436 7462 6 a a DT 40436 7462 7 long long JJ 40436 7462 8 harangue harangue NN 40436 7462 9 , , , 40436 7462 10 the the DT 40436 7462 11 commencement commencement NN 40436 7462 12 of of IN 40436 7462 13 which which WDT 40436 7462 14 appears appear VBZ 40436 7462 15 to to TO 40436 7462 16 be be VB 40436 7462 17 a a DT 40436 7462 18 sort sort NN 40436 7462 19 of of IN 40436 7462 20 counter counter JJ 40436 7462 21 - - NN 40436 7462 22 part part NN 40436 7462 23 and and CC 40436 7462 24 parody parody NN 40436 7462 25 of of IN 40436 7462 26 the the DT 40436 7462 27 first first JJ 40436 7462 28 speech speech NN 40436 7462 29 delivered deliver VBN 40436 7462 30 by by IN 40436 7462 31 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7462 32 in in IN 40436 7462 33 this this DT 40436 7462 34 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7462 35 . . . 40436 7463 1 That that IN 40436 7463 2 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7463 3 had have VBD 40436 7463 4 represented represent VBN 40436 7463 5 that that IN 40436 7463 6 the the DT 40436 7463 7 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 7463 8 art art NN 40436 7463 9 was be VBD 40436 7463 10 ancient:[80 ancient:[80 NNP 40436 7463 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7463 12 and and CC 40436 7463 13 that that IN 40436 7463 14 the the DT 40436 7463 15 poets poet NNS 40436 7463 16 , , , 40436 7463 17 from from IN 40436 7463 18 Homer Homer NNP 40436 7463 19 downward downward RB 40436 7463 20 , , , 40436 7463 21 were be VBD 40436 7463 22 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 7463 23 , , , 40436 7463 24 but but CC 40436 7463 25 dreaded dread VBD 40436 7463 26 the the DT 40436 7463 27 odium odium NN 40436 7463 28 of of IN 40436 7463 29 the the DT 40436 7463 30 name name NN 40436 7463 31 , , , 40436 7463 32 and and CC 40436 7463 33 professed profess VBD 40436 7463 34 a a DT 40436 7463 35 different different JJ 40436 7463 36 avocation avocation NN 40436 7463 37 with with IN 40436 7463 38 another another DT 40436 7463 39 title title NN 40436 7463 40 . . . 40436 7464 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7464 2 here here RB 40436 7464 3 tells tell VBZ 40436 7464 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7464 5 that that DT 40436 7464 6 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 7464 7 was be VBD 40436 7464 8 more more RBR 40436 7464 9 ancient ancient JJ 40436 7464 10 still still RB 40436 7464 11 in in IN 40436 7464 12 Krete Krete NNP 40436 7464 13 and and CC 40436 7464 14 Sparta Sparta NNP 40436 7464 15 , , , 40436 7464 16 and and CC 40436 7464 17 that that IN 40436 7464 18 there there EX 40436 7464 19 were be VBD 40436 7464 20 more more JJR 40436 7464 21 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 7464 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7464 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7464 24 does do VBZ 40436 7464 25 not not RB 40436 7464 26 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 7464 27 between between IN 40436 7464 28 the the DT 40436 7464 29 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7464 30 and and CC 40436 7464 31 the the DT 40436 7464 32 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 7464 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7464 34 , , , 40436 7464 35 female female JJ 40436 7464 36 as as RB 40436 7464 37 well well RB 40436 7464 38 as as IN 40436 7464 39 male male JJ 40436 7464 40 , , , 40436 7464 41 in in IN 40436 7464 42 those those DT 40436 7464 43 regions region NNS 40436 7464 44 , , , 40436 7464 45 than than IN 40436 7464 46 anywhere anywhere RB 40436 7464 47 else else RB 40436 7464 48 : : : 40436 7464 49 but but CC 40436 7464 50 that that IN 40436 7464 51 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7464 52 concealed conceal VBD 40436 7464 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7464 54 name name NN 40436 7464 55 and and CC 40436 7464 56 profession profession NN 40436 7464 57 , , , 40436 7464 58 for for IN 40436 7464 59 fear fear NN 40436 7464 60 that that IN 40436 7464 61 others other NNS 40436 7464 62 should should MD 40436 7464 63 copy copy VB 40436 7464 64 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7464 65 and and CC 40436 7464 66 acquire acquire VB 40436 7464 67 the the DT 40436 7464 68 like like JJ 40436 7464 69 eminence:[81 eminence:[81 NNP 40436 7464 70 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7464 71 that that IN 40436 7464 72 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7464 73 pretended pretend VBD 40436 7464 74 to to TO 40436 7464 75 devote devote VB 40436 7464 76 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7464 77 altogether altogether RB 40436 7464 78 to to IN 40436 7464 79 arms arm NNS 40436 7464 80 and and CC 40436 7464 81 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 7464 82 -- -- : 40436 7464 83 a a DT 40436 7464 84 pretence pretence NN 40436 7464 85 whereby whereby WRB 40436 7464 86 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7464 87 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7464 88 says say VBZ 40436 7464 89 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7464 90 all all PDT 40436 7464 91 the the DT 40436 7464 92 other other JJ 40436 7464 93 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 7464 94 were be VBD 40436 7464 95 really really RB 40436 7464 96 deluded delude VBN 40436 7464 97 . . . 40436 7465 1 The the DT 40436 7465 2 special special JJ 40436 7465 3 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 7465 4 of of IN 40436 7465 5 these these DT 40436 7465 6 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 7465 7 or or CC 40436 7465 8 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 7465 9 was be VBD 40436 7465 10 , , , 40436 7465 11 short short JJ 40436 7465 12 and and CC 40436 7465 13 emphatic emphatic JJ 40436 7465 14 speech speech NN 40436 7465 15 -- -- : 40436 7465 16 epigram epigram NNP 40436 7465 17 shot shoot VBD 40436 7465 18 in in RB 40436 7465 19 at at IN 40436 7465 20 the the DT 40436 7465 21 seasonable seasonable JJ 40436 7465 22 moment moment NN 40436 7465 23 , , , 40436 7465 24 and and CC 40436 7465 25 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 7465 26 prostrating prostrate VBG 40436 7465 27 an an DT 40436 7465 28 opponent opponent NN 40436 7465 29 . . . 40436 7466 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7466 2 82 82 CD 40436 7466 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7466 4 The the DT 40436 7466 5 Seven Seven NNP 40436 7466 6 Wise Wise NNP 40436 7466 7 Men Men NNPS 40436 7466 8 , , , 40436 7466 9 among among IN 40436 7466 10 whom whom WP 40436 7466 11 Pittakus Pittakus NNP 40436 7466 12 was be VBD 40436 7466 13 one one CD 40436 7466 14 , , , 40436 7466 15 were be VBD 40436 7466 16 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 7466 17 on on IN 40436 7466 18 this this DT 40436 7466 19 type type NN 40436 7466 20 , , , 40436 7466 21 of of IN 40436 7466 22 supreme supreme NNP 40436 7466 23 excellence excellence NNP 40436 7466 24 : : : 40436 7466 25 which which WDT 40436 7466 26 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7466 27 showed show VBD 40436 7466 28 by by IN 40436 7466 29 inscribing inscribe VBG 40436 7466 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7466 31 memorable memorable JJ 40436 7466 32 brief brief JJ 40436 7466 33 aphorisms aphorism NNS 40436 7466 34 at at IN 40436 7466 35 Delphi Delphi NNP 40436 7466 36 . . . 40436 7467 1 So so RB 40436 7467 2 great great JJ 40436 7467 3 was be VBD 40436 7467 4 the the DT 40436 7467 5 celebrity celebrity NN 40436 7467 6 which which WDT 40436 7467 7 Pittakus Pittakus NNP 40436 7467 8 acquired acquire VBD 40436 7467 9 by by IN 40436 7467 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7467 11 aphorism aphorism NN 40436 7467 12 , , , 40436 7467 13 that that IN 40436 7467 14 Simonides Simonides NNP 40436 7467 15 the the DT 40436 7467 16 poet poet NN 40436 7467 17 became become VBD 40436 7467 18 jealous jealous JJ 40436 7467 19 , , , 40436 7467 20 and and CC 40436 7467 21 composed compose VBD 40436 7467 22 this this DT 40436 7467 23 song song NN 40436 7467 24 altogether altogether RB 40436 7467 25 for for IN 40436 7467 26 the the DT 40436 7467 27 purpose purpose NN 40436 7467 28 of of IN 40436 7467 29 discrediting discredit VBG 40436 7467 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7467 31 . . . 40436 7468 1 Having have VBG 40436 7468 2 stated state VBN 40436 7468 3 this this DT 40436 7468 4 general general JJ 40436 7468 5 view view NN 40436 7468 6 , , , 40436 7468 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7468 8 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40436 7468 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7468 10 by by IN 40436 7468 11 going go VBG 40436 7468 12 through through IN 40436 7468 13 the the DT 40436 7468 14 song song NN 40436 7468 15 , , , 40436 7468 16 with with IN 40436 7468 17 exposition exposition NN 40436 7468 18 and and CC 40436 7468 19 criticism criticism NN 40436 7468 20 of of IN 40436 7468 21 several several JJ 40436 7468 22 different different JJ 40436 7468 23 passages passage NNS 40436 7468 24 . . . 40436 7469 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7469 2 83 83 CD 40436 7469 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7469 4 As as RB 40436 7469 5 soon soon RB 40436 7469 6 as as IN 40436 7469 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7469 8 has have VBZ 40436 7469 9 concluded conclude VBN 40436 7469 10 , , , 40436 7469 11 Hippias[84 Hippias[84 NNP 40436 7469 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7469 13 compliments compliment VBZ 40436 7469 14 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7469 15 , , , 40436 7469 16 and and CC 40436 7469 17 says say VBZ 40436 7469 18 that that IN 40436 7469 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7469 20 too too RB 40436 7469 21 has have VBZ 40436 7469 22 a a DT 40436 7469 23 lecture lecture NN 40436 7469 24 ready ready JJ 40436 7469 25 prepared prepare VBN 40436 7469 26 on on IN 40436 7469 27 the the DT 40436 7469 28 same same JJ 40436 7469 29 song song NN 40436 7469 30 : : : 40436 7469 31 which which WDT 40436 7469 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7469 33 would would MD 40436 7469 34 willingly willingly RB 40436 7469 35 deliver deliver VB 40436 7469 36 : : : 40436 7469 37 but but CC 40436 7469 38 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNPS 40436 7469 39 and and CC 40436 7469 40 the the DT 40436 7469 41 rest rest NN 40436 7469 42 beg beg VBP 40436 7469 43 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7469 44 to to TO 40436 7469 45 postpone postpone VB 40436 7469 46 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7469 47 . . . 40436 7470 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7470 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7470 3 80 80 CD 40436 7470 4 : : : 40436 7470 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7470 6 . . . 40436 7471 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7471 2 . . . 40436 7472 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7472 2 . . . 40436 7473 1 316 316 CD 40436 7473 2 - - SYM 40436 7473 3 317 317 CD 40436 7473 4 . . . 40436 7473 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7474 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7474 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7474 3 81 81 CD 40436 7474 4 : : : 40436 7474 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7474 6 . . . 40436 7475 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7475 2 . . . 40436 7476 1 p. p. NN 40436 7477 1 342 342 CD 40436 7477 2 . . . 40436 7477 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7478 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7478 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7478 3 82 82 CD 40436 7478 4 : : : 40436 7478 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7478 6 . . . 40436 7479 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7479 2 . . . 40436 7480 1 p. p. NN 40436 7480 2 342 342 CD 40436 7480 3 E e NN 40436 7480 4 , , , 40436 7480 5 343 343 CD 40436 7480 6 B B NNP 40436 7480 7 - - HYPH 40436 7480 8 C. C. NNP 40436 7480 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7480 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7480 11 : : : 40436 7480 12 O(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 7480 13 ou(=tos ou(=tos . 40436 7480 14 o o NNP 40436 7480 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7480 16 tro tro NN 40436 7480 17 / / SYM 40436 7480 18 pos pos NNP 40436 7480 19 ê)=n ê)=n WRB 40436 7480 20 tô tô NNP 40436 7480 21 = = SYM 40436 7480 22 n n CC 40436 7480 23 palaiô palaiô NN 40436 7480 24 = = SYM 40436 7480 25 n n CC 40436 7480 26 tê tê NNP 40436 7480 27 = = SYM 40436 7480 28 s s NNP 40436 7480 29 philosophi philosophi NNP 40436 7480 30 / / SYM 40436 7480 31 as as IN 40436 7480 32 , , , 40436 7480 33 brachulogi brachulogi NNP 40436 7480 34 / / SYM 40436 7480 35 a a DT 40436 7480 36 tis tis NNP 40436 7480 37 Lakônikê/. Lakônikê/. NNP 40436 7480 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7480 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7481 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7481 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7481 3 83 83 CD 40436 7481 4 : : : 40436 7481 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7481 6 . . . 40436 7482 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7482 2 . . . 40436 7483 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7483 2 . . . 40436 7484 1 344 344 CD 40436 7484 2 - - SYM 40436 7484 3 347 347 CD 40436 7484 4 . . . 40436 7484 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7485 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7485 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7485 3 84 84 CD 40436 7485 4 : : : 40436 7485 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7485 6 . . . 40436 7486 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7486 2 . . . 40436 7487 1 p. p. NN 40436 7488 1 347 347 CD 40436 7488 2 . . . 40436 7488 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7489 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7489 2 Side side NN 40436 7489 3 - - HYPH 40436 7489 4 note note NN 40436 7489 5 : : : 40436 7489 6 Character character NN 40436 7489 7 of of IN 40436 7489 8 this this DT 40436 7489 9 speech speech NN 40436 7489 10 -- -- : 40436 7489 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7489 12 connection connection NN 40436 7489 13 with with IN 40436 7489 14 the the DT 40436 7489 15 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7489 16 , , , 40436 7489 17 and and CC 40436 7489 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7489 19 general general JJ 40436 7489 20 purpose purpose NN 40436 7489 21 . . . 40436 7490 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7490 2 inferior inferior JJ 40436 7490 3 to to IN 40436 7490 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7490 5 in in IN 40436 7490 6 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7490 7 speech speech NN 40436 7490 8 . . . 40436 7490 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7491 1 No no DT 40436 7491 2 remark remark NN 40436 7491 3 is be VBZ 40436 7491 4 made make VBN 40436 7491 5 by by IN 40436 7491 6 any any DT 40436 7491 7 one one CD 40436 7491 8 present present NN 40436 7491 9 , , , 40436 7491 10 either either CC 40436 7491 11 upon upon IN 40436 7491 12 the the DT 40436 7491 13 circumstance circumstance NN 40436 7491 14 that that WDT 40436 7491 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7491 16 , , , 40436 7491 17 after after IN 40436 7491 18 protesting protest VBG 40436 7491 19 against against IN 40436 7491 20 long long JJ 40436 7491 21 speeches speech NNS 40436 7491 22 , , , 40436 7491 23 has have VBZ 40436 7491 24 here here RB 40436 7491 25 delivered deliver VBN 40436 7491 26 one one NN 40436 7491 27 longer longer RB 40436 7491 28 by by IN 40436 7491 29 far far RB 40436 7491 30 than than IN 40436 7491 31 the the DT 40436 7491 32 first first JJ 40436 7491 33 speech speech NN 40436 7491 34 of of IN 40436 7491 35 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7491 36 , , , 40436 7491 37 and and CC 40436 7491 38 more more JJR 40436 7491 39 than than IN 40436 7491 40 half half DT 40436 7491 41 as as RB 40436 7491 42 long long RB 40436 7491 43 as as IN 40436 7491 44 the the DT 40436 7491 45 second second JJ 40436 7491 46 , , , 40436 7491 47 which which WDT 40436 7491 48 contains contain VBZ 40436 7491 49 a a DT 40436 7491 50 large large JJ 40436 7491 51 theory theory NN 40436 7491 52 -- -- : 40436 7491 53 nor nor CC 40436 7491 54 upon upon IN 40436 7491 55 the the DT 40436 7491 56 sort sort NN 40436 7491 57 of of IN 40436 7491 58 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7491 59 that that WDT 40436 7491 60 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7491 61 bestows bestow VBZ 40436 7491 62 upon upon IN 40436 7491 63 the the DT 40436 7491 64 Simonidean Simonidean NNP 40436 7491 65 song song NN 40436 7491 66 . . . 40436 7492 1 That that DT 40436 7492 2 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7492 3 is be VBZ 40436 7492 4 so so RB 40436 7492 5 strange strange JJ 40436 7492 6 and and CC 40436 7492 7 forced force VBN 40436 7492 8 -- -- : 40436 7492 9 so so RB 40436 7492 10 violent violent JJ 40436 7492 11 in in IN 40436 7492 12 distorting distort VBG 40436 7492 13 the the DT 40436 7492 14 meaning meaning NN 40436 7492 15 of of IN 40436 7492 16 the the DT 40436 7492 17 poet poet NN 40436 7492 18 -- -- : 40436 7492 19 so so RB 40436 7492 20 evidently evidently RB 40436 7492 21 predetermined predetermine VBN 40436 7492 22 by by IN 40436 7492 23 the the DT 40436 7492 24 resolution resolution NN 40436 7492 25 to to TO 40436 7492 26 find find VB 40436 7492 27 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7492 28 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 40436 7492 29 in in IN 40436 7492 30 a a DT 40436 7492 31 lyric lyric NN 40436 7492 32 effusion effusion NN 40436 7492 33 addressed address VBN 40436 7492 34 to to IN 40436 7492 35 a a DT 40436 7492 36 Thessalian Thessalian NNP 40436 7492 37 prince[85]--that prince[85]--that NNP 40436 7492 38 if if IN 40436 7492 39 such such PDT 40436 7492 40 an an DT 40436 7492 41 exposition exposition NN 40436 7492 42 had have VBD 40436 7492 43 been be VBN 40436 7492 44 found find VBN 40436 7492 45 under under IN 40436 7492 46 the the DT 40436 7492 47 name name NN 40436 7492 48 of of IN 40436 7492 49 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7492 50 , , , 40436 7492 51 critics critic NNS 40436 7492 52 would would MD 40436 7492 53 have have VB 40436 7492 54 dwelt dwell VBN 40436 7492 55 upon upon IN 40436 7492 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7492 57 as as IN 40436 7492 58 an an DT 40436 7492 59 additional additional JJ 40436 7492 60 proof proof NN 40436 7492 61 of of IN 40436 7492 62 dishonest dishonest JJ 40436 7492 63 perversions perversion NNS 40436 7492 64 by by IN 40436 7492 65 the the DT 40436 7492 66 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 7492 67 . . . 40436 7493 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7493 2 86 86 CD 40436 7493 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7493 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7493 5 appears appear VBZ 40436 7493 6 as as IN 40436 7493 7 if if IN 40436 7493 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7493 9 , , , 40436 7493 10 intending intend VBG 40436 7493 11 in in IN 40436 7493 12 this this DT 40436 7493 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7493 14 to to TO 40436 7493 15 set set VB 40436 7493 16 out out RP 40436 7493 17 the the DT 40436 7493 18 contrast contrast NN 40436 7493 19 between between IN 40436 7493 20 long long JJ 40436 7493 21 or or CC 40436 7493 22 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7493 23 speech speech NN 40436 7493 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7493 25 sophistical sophistical JJ 40436 7493 26 , , , 40436 7493 27 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 7493 28 , , , 40436 7493 29 poetical poetical JJ 40436 7493 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7493 31 represented represent VBN 40436 7493 32 by by IN 40436 7493 33 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7493 34 , , , 40436 7493 35 and and CC 40436 7493 36 short short JJ 40436 7493 37 , , , 40436 7493 38 interrogatory interrogatory JJ 40436 7493 39 speech speech NN 40436 7493 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7493 41 dialectical dialectical JJ 40436 7493 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7493 43 represented represent VBN 40436 7493 44 by by IN 40436 7493 45 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7493 46 -- -- : 40436 7493 47 having have VBG 40436 7493 48 moreover moreover RB 40436 7493 49 composed compose VBN 40436 7493 50 for for IN 40436 7493 51 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7493 52 in in IN 40436 7493 53 the the DT 40436 7493 54 earlier early JJR 40436 7493 55 part part NN 40436 7493 56 of of IN 40436 7493 57 the the DT 40436 7493 58 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7493 59 , , , 40436 7493 60 an an DT 40436 7493 61 harangue harangue NN 40436 7493 62 claiming claim VBG 40436 7493 63 venerable venerable JJ 40436 7493 64 antiquity antiquity NN 40436 7493 65 for for IN 40436 7493 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7493 67 own own JJ 40436 7493 68 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 7493 69 -- -- : 40436 7493 70 has have VBZ 40436 7493 71 thought think VBN 40436 7493 72 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7493 73 right right JJ 40436 7493 74 to to TO 40436 7493 75 compose compose VB 40436 7493 76 for for IN 40436 7493 77 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7493 78 a a DT 40436 7493 79 pleading pleading NN 40436 7493 80 with with IN 40436 7493 81 like like JJ 40436 7493 82 purpose purpose NN 40436 7493 83 , , , 40436 7493 84 to to TO 40436 7493 85 put put VB 40436 7493 86 the the DT 40436 7493 87 two two CD 40436 7493 88 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 7493 89 on on IN 40436 7493 90 a a DT 40436 7493 91 par par NN 40436 7493 92 . . . 40436 7494 1 And and CC 40436 7494 2 if if IN 40436 7494 3 that that DT 40436 7494 4 pleading pleading NN 40436 7494 5 includes include VBZ 40436 7494 6 both both DT 40436 7494 7 pointless pointless JJ 40436 7494 8 irony irony NN 40436 7494 9 and and CC 40436 7494 10 misplaced misplaced JJ 40436 7494 11 comparisons comparison NNS 40436 7494 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7494 13 especially especially RB 40436 7494 14 what what WP 40436 7494 15 is be VBZ 40436 7494 16 said say VBN 40436 7494 17 about about IN 40436 7494 18 the the DT 40436 7494 19 Spartans)--we Spartans)--we NNP 40436 7494 20 must must MD 40436 7494 21 remember remember VB 40436 7494 22 that that IN 40436 7494 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7494 24 has have VBZ 40436 7494 25 expressly expressly RB 40436 7494 26 renounced renounce VBN 40436 7494 27 all all DT 40436 7494 28 competition competition NN 40436 7494 29 with with IN 40436 7494 30 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7494 31 in in IN 40436 7494 32 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7494 33 speech speech NN 40436 7494 34 , , , 40436 7494 35 and and CC 40436 7494 36 that that IN 40436 7494 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7494 38 is be VBZ 40436 7494 39 here here RB 40436 7494 40 handling handle VBG 40436 7494 41 the the DT 40436 7494 42 weapon weapon NN 40436 7494 43 in in IN 40436 7494 44 which which WDT 40436 7494 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7494 46 is be VBZ 40436 7494 47 confessedly confessedly RB 40436 7494 48 inferior inferior JJ 40436 7494 49 . . . 40436 7495 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7495 2 secures secure VBZ 40436 7495 3 a a DT 40436 7495 4 decisive decisive JJ 40436 7495 5 triumph triumph NN 40436 7495 6 to to IN 40436 7495 7 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 7495 8 , , , 40436 7495 9 and and CC 40436 7495 10 to to IN 40436 7495 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7495 12 as as IN 40436 7495 13 representing represent VBG 40436 7495 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7495 15 : : : 40436 7495 16 but but CC 40436 7495 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7495 18 seems seem VBZ 40436 7495 19 content content JJ 40436 7495 20 here here RB 40436 7495 21 to to TO 40436 7495 22 leave leave VB 40436 7495 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7495 24 on on IN 40436 7495 25 the the DT 40436 7495 26 lower low JJR 40436 7495 27 ground ground NN 40436 7495 28 as as IN 40436 7495 29 a a DT 40436 7495 30 rhetorician rhetorician NN 40436 7495 31 . . . 40436 7496 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7496 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7496 3 85 85 CD 40436 7496 4 : : : 40436 7496 5 Especially especially RB 40436 7496 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7496 7 explanation explanation NN 40436 7496 8 of of IN 40436 7496 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7496 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7496 11 : : : 40436 7496 12 e(kô\n e(kô\n NNP 40436 7496 13 e)rdê=| e)rdê=| NNPS 40436 7496 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7496 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7496 16 p. p. NN 40436 7496 17 345 345 CD 40436 7496 18 D. D. NNP 40436 7496 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7496 20 . . . 40436 7497 1 Heyne Heyne NNP 40436 7497 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7497 3 Opuscula Opuscula NNP 40436 7497 4 , , , 40436 7497 5 i. i. NN 40436 7497 6 p. p. NN 40436 7497 7 160 160 CD 40436 7497 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7497 9 remarks remark VBZ 40436 7497 10 upon upon IN 40436 7497 11 the the DT 40436 7497 12 strange strange JJ 40436 7497 13 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7497 14 given give VBN 40436 7497 15 by by IN 40436 7497 16 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7497 17 of of IN 40436 7497 18 the the DT 40436 7497 19 Simonidean Simonidean NNP 40436 7497 20 song song NN 40436 7497 21 . . . 40436 7498 1 Compare compare VB 40436 7498 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7498 3 in in IN 40436 7498 4 Lysis lysis NN 40436 7498 5 , , , 40436 7498 6 p. p. NN 40436 7498 7 212 212 CD 40436 7498 8 E e NN 40436 7498 9 , , , 40436 7498 10 and and CC 40436 7498 11 in in IN 40436 7498 12 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 7498 13 . . . 40436 7499 1 ii ii LS 40436 7499 2 . . . 40436 7500 1 p. p. NN 40436 7500 2 147 147 CD 40436 7500 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7500 4 In in IN 40436 7500 5 both both PDT 40436 7500 6 these these DT 40436 7500 7 cases case NNS 40436 7500 8 , , , 40436 7500 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7500 10 cites cite VBZ 40436 7500 11 passages passage NNS 40436 7500 12 of of IN 40436 7500 13 poetry poetry NN 40436 7500 14 , , , 40436 7500 15 assigning assign VBG 40436 7500 16 to to IN 40436 7500 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7500 18 a a DT 40436 7500 19 sense sense NN 40436 7500 20 which which WDT 40436 7500 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7500 22 authors author NNS 40436 7500 23 plainly plainly RB 40436 7500 24 did do VBD 40436 7500 25 not not RB 40436 7500 26 intend intend VB 40436 7500 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7500 28 to to TO 40436 7500 29 bear bear VB 40436 7500 30 . . . 40436 7501 1 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 7501 2 in in IN 40436 7501 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7501 4 note note NN 40436 7501 5 on on IN 40436 7501 6 the the DT 40436 7501 7 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 7501 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7501 9 l. l. NNP 40436 7501 10 c. c. NNP 40436 7501 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7501 12 observes--"Videlicet observes--"Videlicet NNP 40436 7501 13 , , , 40436 7501 14 ut ut UH 40436 7501 15 exeat exeat NNP 40436 7501 16 sententia sententia NNP 40436 7501 17 , , , 40436 7501 18 quam quam NNP 40436 7501 19 Solon Solon NNP 40436 7501 20 ne ne NNP 40436 7501 21 somniavit somniavit NN 40436 7501 22 quidem quidem NNP 40436 7501 23 , , , 40436 7501 24 versuum versuum NNP 40436 7501 25 horum horum NNP 40436 7501 26 structuram structuram NNP 40436 7501 27 , , , 40436 7501 28 neglecto neglecto NNP 40436 7501 29 plané plané NNP 40436 7501 30 sermonis sermonis NNP 40436 7501 31 usu usu NNP 40436 7501 32 , , , 40436 7501 33 hanc hanc NNP 40436 7501 34 statuit.--Cujusmodi statuit.--Cujusmodi NNP 40436 7501 35 interpretationis interpretationis NNP 40436 7501 36 aliud aliud NNP 40436 7501 37 est est NNP 40436 7501 38 luculentum luculentum NN 40436 7501 39 exemplum exemplum NN 40436 7501 40 in in IN 40436 7501 41 Alcib Alcib NNP 40436 7501 42 . . . 40436 7502 1 ii ii LS 40436 7502 2 . . . 40436 7503 1 p. p. NN 40436 7503 2 147 147 CD 40436 7503 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7503 4 " " `` 40436 7503 5 See see VB 40436 7503 6 also also RB 40436 7503 7 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 7503 8 's 's POS 40436 7503 9 notes note NNS 40436 7503 10 on on IN 40436 7503 11 the the DT 40436 7503 12 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 7503 13 , , , 40436 7503 14 p. p. NN 40436 7503 15 163 163 CD 40436 7503 16 B b NN 40436 7503 17 ; ; : 40436 7503 18 Lachês Lachês NNP 40436 7503 19 , , , 40436 7503 20 p. p. NN 40436 7503 21 191 191 CD 40436 7503 22 B b NN 40436 7503 23 ; ; : 40436 7503 24 and and CC 40436 7503 25 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 7503 26 , , , 40436 7503 27 p. p. NN 40436 7503 28 214 214 CD 40436 7503 29 D. D. NNP 40436 7503 30 M. M. NNP 40436 7503 31 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 7503 32 observes observe VBZ 40436 7503 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7503 34 ad ad NN 40436 7503 35 Pindar Pindar NNP 40436 7503 36 . . . 40436 7504 1 Isthm Isthm NNP 40436 7504 2 . . . 40436 7505 1 v. v. NNP 40436 7505 2 p. p. NN 40436 7505 3 528 528 CD 40436 7505 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7505 5 respecting respect VBG 40436 7505 6 an an DT 40436 7505 7 allusion allusion NN 40436 7505 8 made make VBN 40436 7505 9 by by IN 40436 7505 10 Pindar Pindar NNP 40436 7505 11 to to TO 40436 7505 12 Hesiod-- hesiod-- VB 40436 7505 13 " " `` 40436 7505 14 Num Num NNP 40436 7505 15 malé malé NNP 40436 7505 16 intellexit intellexit NNP 40436 7505 17 poeta poeta NNP 40436 7505 18 intelligentissimus intelligentissimus NNP 40436 7505 19 perspicua perspicua NNP 40436 7505 20 verba verba NNP 40436 7505 21 Hesiodi Hesiodi NNP 40436 7505 22 ? ? . 40436 7506 1 Non non JJ 40436 7506 2 credo credo NNP 40436 7506 3 : : : 40436 7506 4 sed sed NNP 40436 7506 5 bene bene NNP 40436 7506 6 sciens sciens NNP 40436 7506 7 , , , 40436 7506 8 consulto consulto NNP 40436 7506 9 alium alium NNP 40436 7506 10 sensum sensum NNP 40436 7506 11 intulit intulit NNP 40436 7506 12 , , , 40436 7506 13 suo suo NNP 40436 7506 14 consilio consilio NNP 40436 7506 15 accommodatum accommodatum NNP 40436 7506 16 ! ! . 40436 7507 1 Simile simile IN 40436 7507 2 exemplum exemplum NNP 40436 7507 3 offert offert NNP 40436 7507 4 gravissimus gravissimus NNP 40436 7507 5 auctor auctor NN 40436 7507 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7507 7 Theætet Theætet NNP 40436 7507 8 . . . 40436 7508 1 p. p. NN 40436 7508 2 155 155 CD 40436 7508 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7508 4 " " `` 40436 7508 5 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 7508 6 in in IN 40436 7508 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7508 8 note note NN 40436 7508 9 on on IN 40436 7508 10 the the DT 40436 7508 11 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 7508 12 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 7508 13 this this DT 40436 7508 14 remark remark NN 40436 7508 15 of of IN 40436 7508 16 Boeckh Boeckh NNP 40436 7508 17 . . . 40436 7509 1 Groen Groen NNP 40436 7509 2 van van NNP 40436 7509 3 Prinsterer Prinsterer NNP 40436 7509 4 gives give VBZ 40436 7509 5 a a DT 40436 7509 6 similar similar JJ 40436 7509 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 7509 8 . . . 40436 7510 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7510 2 Prosopographia Prosopographia NNP 40436 7510 3 Platonica Platonica NNP 40436 7510 4 , , , 40436 7510 5 p. p. NN 40436 7511 1 17 17 CD 40436 7511 2 . . . 40436 7511 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7511 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7512 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7512 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7512 3 86 86 CD 40436 7512 4 : : : 40436 7512 5 K. K. NNP 40436 7512 6 F. F. NNP 40436 7512 7 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 7512 8 observes observe VBZ 40436 7512 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7512 10 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 7512 11 . . . 40436 7513 1 der der NNP 40436 7513 2 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7513 3 . . . 40436 7514 1 Philos Philos NNP 40436 7514 2 , , , 40436 7514 3 p. p. NN 40436 7514 4 460 460 CD 40436 7514 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7514 6 that that IN 40436 7514 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7514 8 , , , 40436 7514 9 in in IN 40436 7514 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7514 11 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7514 12 of of IN 40436 7514 13 the the DT 40436 7514 14 Simonidean Simonidean NNP 40436 7514 15 song song NN 40436 7514 16 , , , 40436 7514 17 shows show VBZ 40436 7514 18 that that IN 40436 7514 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7514 20 can can MD 40436 7514 21 play play VB 40436 7514 22 the the DT 40436 7514 23 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7514 24 as as RB 40436 7514 25 well well RB 40436 7514 26 as as IN 40436 7514 27 other other JJ 40436 7514 28 people people NNS 40436 7514 29 can can MD 40436 7514 30 . . . 40436 7514 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7515 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7515 2 Side side NN 40436 7515 3 - - HYPH 40436 7515 4 note note NN 40436 7515 5 : : : 40436 7515 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7515 7 depreciates depreciate VBZ 40436 7515 8 the the DT 40436 7515 9 value value NN 40436 7515 10 of of IN 40436 7515 11 debates debate NNS 40436 7515 12 on on IN 40436 7515 13 the the DT 40436 7515 14 poets poet NNS 40436 7515 15 . . . 40436 7516 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7516 2 meaning meaning NN 40436 7516 3 is be VBZ 40436 7516 4 always always RB 40436 7516 5 disputed dispute VBN 40436 7516 6 , , , 40436 7516 7 and and CC 40436 7516 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7516 9 can can MD 40436 7516 10 never never RB 40436 7516 11 ask ask VB 40436 7516 12 from from IN 40436 7516 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7516 14 what what WP 40436 7516 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7516 16 is be VBZ 40436 7516 17 . . . 40436 7517 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7517 2 consents consent VBZ 40436 7517 3 reluctantly reluctantly RB 40436 7517 4 to to TO 40436 7517 5 resume resume VB 40436 7517 6 the the DT 40436 7517 7 task task NN 40436 7517 8 of of IN 40436 7517 9 answering answering NN 40436 7517 10 . . . 40436 7517 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7518 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 7518 2 , , , 40436 7518 3 when when WRB 40436 7518 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7518 5 intends intend VBZ 40436 7518 6 to to TO 40436 7518 7 show show VB 40436 7518 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7518 9 off off RP 40436 7518 10 as as IN 40436 7518 11 a a DT 40436 7518 12 master master NN 40436 7518 13 of of IN 40436 7518 14 poetical poetical JJ 40436 7518 15 lore lore NN 40436 7518 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7518 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7518 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7518 19 : : : 40436 7518 20 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 7518 21 e)pô e)pô NNP 40436 7518 22 = = SYM 40436 7518 23 n n NNP 40436 7518 24 deino\s deino\s CD 40436 7518 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7518 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7518 27 , , , 40436 7518 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7518 29 at at IN 40436 7518 30 the the DT 40436 7518 31 same same JJ 40436 7518 32 time time NN 40436 7518 33 claims claim VBZ 40436 7518 34 a a DT 40436 7518 35 right right NN 40436 7518 36 of of IN 40436 7518 37 interpreting interpret VBG 40436 7518 38 the the DT 40436 7518 39 poets poet NNS 40436 7518 40 in in IN 40436 7518 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7518 42 own own JJ 40436 7518 43 way way NN 40436 7518 44 . . . 40436 7519 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7519 2 considers consider VBZ 40436 7519 3 the the DT 40436 7519 4 poets poet NNS 40436 7519 5 either either CC 40436 7519 6 as as IN 40436 7519 7 persons person NNS 40436 7519 8 divinely divinely RB 40436 7519 9 inspired inspire VBN 40436 7519 10 , , , 40436 7519 11 who who WP 40436 7519 12 speak speak VBP 40436 7519 13 fine fine JJ 40436 7519 14 things thing NNS 40436 7519 15 without without IN 40436 7519 16 rational rational JJ 40436 7519 17 understanding understanding NN 40436 7519 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7519 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7519 20 have have VBP 40436 7519 21 seen see VBN 40436 7519 22 this this DT 40436 7519 23 in in IN 40436 7519 24 the the DT 40436 7519 25 Apology Apology NNP 40436 7519 26 and and CC 40436 7519 27 the the DT 40436 7519 28 Ion)--or Ion)--or NNP 40436 7519 29 as as IN 40436 7519 30 men man NNS 40436 7519 31 of of IN 40436 7519 32 superior superior JJ 40436 7519 33 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 7519 34 , , , 40436 7519 35 who who WP 40436 7519 36 deliver deliver VBP 40436 7519 37 valuable valuable JJ 40436 7519 38 truth truth NN 40436 7519 39 lying lie VBG 40436 7519 40 beneath beneath IN 40436 7519 41 the the DT 40436 7519 42 surface surface NN 40436 7519 43 , , , 40436 7519 44 and and CC 40436 7519 45 not not RB 40436 7519 46 discernible discernible JJ 40436 7519 47 by by IN 40436 7519 48 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 7519 49 eyes eye NNS 40436 7519 50 . . . 40436 7520 1 Both both CC 40436 7520 2 these these DT 40436 7520 3 views view NNS 40436 7520 4 differ differ VBP 40436 7520 5 from from IN 40436 7520 6 that that DT 40436 7520 7 of of IN 40436 7520 8 literal literal JJ 40436 7520 9 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7520 10 , , , 40436 7520 11 which which WDT 40436 7520 12 is be VBZ 40436 7520 13 here here RB 40436 7520 14 represented represent VBN 40436 7520 15 by by IN 40436 7520 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7520 17 and and CC 40436 7520 18 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7520 19 . . . 40436 7521 1 And and CC 40436 7521 2 these these DT 40436 7521 3 two two CD 40436 7521 4 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 7521 5 are be VBP 40436 7521 6 here here RB 40436 7521 7 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 7521 8 with with IN 40436 7521 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7521 10 as as IN 40436 7521 11 interpreters interpreter NNS 40436 7521 12 of of IN 40436 7521 13 the the DT 40436 7521 14 poets poet NNS 40436 7521 15 . . . 40436 7522 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7522 2 and and CC 40436 7522 3 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7522 4 look look VB 40436 7522 5 upon upon IN 40436 7522 6 poetical poetical JJ 40436 7522 7 compositions composition NNS 40436 7522 8 as as IN 40436 7522 9 sources source NNS 40436 7522 10 of of IN 40436 7522 11 instruction instruction NN 40436 7522 12 : : : 40436 7522 13 and and CC 40436 7522 14 seek seek VB 40436 7522 15 to to TO 40436 7522 16 interpret interpret VB 40436 7522 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7522 18 literally literally RB 40436 7522 19 , , , 40436 7522 20 as as IN 40436 7522 21 an an DT 40436 7522 22 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 7522 23 hearer hearer NN 40436 7522 24 would would MD 40436 7522 25 have have VB 40436 7522 26 understood understand VBN 40436 7522 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7522 28 when when WRB 40436 7522 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7522 30 were be VBD 40436 7522 31 sung sing VBN 40436 7522 32 or or CC 40436 7522 33 recited recite VBN 40436 7522 34 for for IN 40436 7522 35 the the DT 40436 7522 36 first first JJ 40436 7522 37 time time NN 40436 7522 38 . . . 40436 7523 1 Towards towards IN 40436 7523 2 that that DT 40436 7523 3 end end NN 40436 7523 4 , , , 40436 7523 5 discrimination discrimination NN 40436 7523 6 of of IN 40436 7523 7 the the DT 40436 7523 8 usual usual JJ 40436 7523 9 or or CC 40436 7523 10 grammatical grammatical JJ 40436 7523 11 meaning meaning NN 40436 7523 12 of of IN 40436 7523 13 words word NNS 40436 7523 14 was be VBD 40436 7523 15 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 7523 16 . . . 40436 7524 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7524 2 , , , 40436 7524 3 on on IN 40436 7524 4 the the DT 40436 7524 5 contrary contrary NN 40436 7524 6 , , , 40436 7524 7 disregards disregard VBZ 40436 7524 8 the the DT 40436 7524 9 literal literal JJ 40436 7524 10 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7524 11 , , , 40436 7524 12 derides deride VBZ 40436 7524 13 verbal verbal JJ 40436 7524 14 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 7524 15 as as IN 40436 7524 16 useless useless JJ 40436 7524 17 , , , 40436 7524 18 or or CC 40436 7524 19 twists twist VBZ 40436 7524 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7524 21 into into IN 40436 7524 22 harmony harmony NN 40436 7524 23 with with IN 40436 7524 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7524 25 own own JJ 40436 7524 26 purpose purpose NN 40436 7524 27 : : : 40436 7524 28 Simonides simonide NNS 40436 7524 29 and and CC 40436 7524 30 other other JJ 40436 7524 31 poets poet NNS 40436 7524 32 are be VBP 40436 7524 33 considered consider VBN 40436 7524 34 as as IN 40436 7524 35 superior superior JJ 40436 7524 36 men man NNS 40436 7524 37 , , , 40436 7524 38 and and CC 40436 7524 39 even even RB 40436 7524 40 as as IN 40436 7524 41 inspired inspire VBN 40436 7524 42 men man NNS 40436 7524 43 in in IN 40436 7524 44 whose whose WP$ 40436 7524 45 verses verse NNS 40436 7524 46 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 7524 47 and and CC 40436 7524 48 virtue virtue NN 40436 7524 49 must must MD 40436 7524 50 be be VB 40436 7524 51 embodied embody VBN 40436 7524 52 and and CC 40436 7524 53 discoverable[87]--only discoverable[87]--only RB 40436 7524 54 that that IN 40436 7524 55 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7524 56 are be VBP 40436 7524 57 given give VBN 40436 7524 58 in in IN 40436 7524 59 an an DT 40436 7524 60 obscure obscure JJ 40436 7524 61 and and CC 40436 7524 62 enigmatical enigmatical JJ 40436 7524 63 manner manner NN 40436 7524 64 : : : 40436 7524 65 requiring require VBG 40436 7524 66 to to TO 40436 7524 67 be be VB 40436 7524 68 extracted extract VBN 40436 7524 69 by by IN 40436 7524 70 the the DT 40436 7524 71 divination divination NN 40436 7524 72 of of IN 40436 7524 73 the the DT 40436 7524 74 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 7524 75 , , , 40436 7524 76 who who WP 40436 7524 77 alone alone RB 40436 7524 78 knows know VBZ 40436 7524 79 what what WP 40436 7524 80 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 7524 81 and and CC 40436 7524 82 virtue virtue NN 40436 7524 83 are be VBP 40436 7524 84 . . . 40436 7525 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7525 2 is be VBZ 40436 7525 3 for for IN 40436 7525 4 the the DT 40436 7525 5 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 7525 6 to to TO 40436 7525 7 show show VB 40436 7525 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7525 9 ingenuity ingenuity NN 40436 7525 10 by by IN 40436 7525 11 detecting detect VBG 40436 7525 12 the the DT 40436 7525 13 traces trace NNS 40436 7525 14 of of IN 40436 7525 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7525 16 . . . 40436 7526 1 This this DT 40436 7526 2 is be VBZ 40436 7526 3 what what WP 40436 7526 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7526 5 does do VBZ 40436 7526 6 with with IN 40436 7526 7 the the DT 40436 7526 8 song song NN 40436 7526 9 of of IN 40436 7526 10 Simonides simonide NNS 40436 7526 11 . . . 40436 7527 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7527 2 discovers discover VBZ 40436 7527 3 in in IN 40436 7527 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7527 5 supposed suppose VBD 40436 7527 6 underlying underlying JJ 40436 7527 7 thoughts thought NNS 40436 7527 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7527 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7527 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7527 11 : : : 40436 7527 12 u(ponoi u(ponoi NNP 40436 7527 13 / / SYM 40436 7527 14 as]):[88 as]):[88 NNP 40436 7527 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7527 16 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 7527 17 of of IN 40436 7527 18 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7527 19 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNPS 40436 7527 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7527 21 between between IN 40436 7527 22 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7527 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7527 24 : : : 40436 7527 25 ei)=nai ei)=nai LS 40436 7527 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7527 27 and and CC 40436 7527 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7527 29 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7527 30 : : : 40436 7527 31 gene gene NN 40436 7527 32 / / SYM 40436 7527 33 sthai sthai NNP 40436 7527 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7527 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7527 36 , , , 40436 7527 37 and and CC 40436 7527 38 principles principle NNS 40436 7527 39 of of IN 40436 7527 40 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7527 41 Ethics ethic NNS 40436 7527 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7527 43 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7527 44 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7527 45 : : : 40436 7527 46 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 7527 47 e(/kô e(/kô NNP 40436 7527 48 kako kako NNP 40436 7527 49 / / SYM 40436 7527 50 s])--he s])--he NNP 40436 7527 51 proceeds proceed NNS 40436 7527 52 to to TO 40436 7527 53 point point VB 40436 7527 54 out out RP 40436 7527 55 passages passage NNS 40436 7527 56 in in IN 40436 7527 57 which which WDT 40436 7527 58 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7527 59 are be VBP 40436 7527 60 to to TO 40436 7527 61 be be VB 40436 7527 62 found find VBN 40436 7527 63 , , , 40436 7527 64 and and CC 40436 7527 65 explains explain VBZ 40436 7527 66 the the DT 40436 7527 67 song song NN 40436 7527 68 conformably conformably RB 40436 7527 69 to to IN 40436 7527 70 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7527 71 , , , 40436 7527 72 in in IN 40436 7527 73 spite spite NN 40436 7527 74 of of IN 40436 7527 75 much much JJ 40436 7527 76 violence violence NN 40436 7527 77 to to IN 40436 7527 78 the the DT 40436 7527 79 obvious obvious JJ 40436 7527 80 meaning meaning NN 40436 7527 81 and and CC 40436 7527 82 verbal verbal JJ 40436 7527 83 structure structure NN 40436 7527 84 . . . 40436 7528 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7528 2 89 89 CD 40436 7528 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7528 4 But but CC 40436 7528 5 though though IN 40436 7528 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7528 7 accepts accept VBZ 40436 7528 8 , , , 40436 7528 9 when when WRB 40436 7528 10 required require VBN 40436 7528 11 , , , 40436 7528 12 the the DT 40436 7528 13 task task NN 40436 7528 14 of of IN 40436 7528 15 discussing discuss VBG 40436 7528 16 what what WP 40436 7528 17 is be VBZ 40436 7528 18 said say VBN 40436 7528 19 by by IN 40436 7528 20 the the DT 40436 7528 21 poets poet NNS 40436 7528 22 , , , 40436 7528 23 and and CC 40436 7528 24 deals deal NNS 40436 7528 25 with with IN 40436 7528 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7528 27 according accord VBG 40436 7528 28 to to IN 40436 7528 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7528 30 own own JJ 40436 7528 31 point point NN 40436 7528 32 of of IN 40436 7528 33 view view NN 40436 7528 34 -- -- : 40436 7528 35 yet yet CC 40436 7528 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7528 37 presently presently RB 40436 7528 38 lets let VBZ 40436 7528 39 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7528 40 see see VB 40436 7528 41 that that IN 40436 7528 42 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7528 43 are be VBP 40436 7528 44 witnesses witness NNS 40436 7528 45 called call VBN 40436 7528 46 into into IN 40436 7528 47 court court NN 40436 7528 48 by by IN 40436 7528 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7528 50 opponent opponent NN 40436 7528 51 and and CC 40436 7528 52 not not RB 40436 7528 53 by by IN 40436 7528 54 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7528 55 . . . 40436 7529 1 Alkibiades alkibiade NNS 40436 7529 2 urges urge VBZ 40436 7529 3 that that IN 40436 7529 4 the the DT 40436 7529 5 debate debate NN 40436 7529 6 which which WDT 40436 7529 7 had have VBD 40436 7529 8 been be VBN 40436 7529 9 interrupted interrupt VBN 40436 7529 10 shall shall MD 40436 7529 11 be be VB 40436 7529 12 resumed resume VBN 40436 7529 13 and and CC 40436 7529 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7529 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7529 16 requests request VBZ 40436 7529 17 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7529 18 to to TO 40436 7529 19 consent consent VB 40436 7529 20 . . . 40436 7530 1 " " `` 40436 7530 2 To to TO 40436 7530 3 debate debate VB 40436 7530 4 about about IN 40436 7530 5 the the DT 40436 7530 6 compositions composition NNS 40436 7530 7 of of IN 40436 7530 8 poets poet NNS 40436 7530 9 " " '' 40436 7530 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7530 11 says say VBZ 40436 7530 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7530 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7530 14 , , , 40436 7530 15 " " `` 40436 7530 16 is be VBZ 40436 7530 17 to to TO 40436 7530 18 proceed proceed VB 40436 7530 19 as as RB 40436 7530 20 silly silly JJ 40436 7530 21 and and CC 40436 7530 22 common common JJ 40436 7530 23 - - HYPH 40436 7530 24 place place NN 40436 7530 25 men man NNS 40436 7530 26 do do VBP 40436 7530 27 at at IN 40436 7530 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7530 29 banquets banquet NNS 40436 7530 30 : : : 40436 7530 31 where where WRB 40436 7530 32 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7530 33 can can MD 40436 7530 34 not not RB 40436 7530 35 pass pass VB 40436 7530 36 the the DT 40436 7530 37 time time NN 40436 7530 38 without without IN 40436 7530 39 hiring hire VBG 40436 7530 40 musical musical JJ 40436 7530 41 or or CC 40436 7530 42 dancing dance VBG 40436 7530 43 girls girl NNS 40436 7530 44 . . . 40436 7531 1 Noble noble JJ 40436 7531 2 and and CC 40436 7531 3 well well RB 40436 7531 4 - - HYPH 40436 7531 5 educated educate VBN 40436 7531 6 guests guest NNS 40436 7531 7 , , , 40436 7531 8 on on IN 40436 7531 9 the the DT 40436 7531 10 contrary contrary NN 40436 7531 11 , , , 40436 7531 12 can can MD 40436 7531 13 find find VB 40436 7531 14 enough enough JJ 40436 7531 15 to to TO 40436 7531 16 interest interest VB 40436 7531 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7531 18 in in IN 40436 7531 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7531 20 own own JJ 40436 7531 21 conversation conversation NN 40436 7531 22 , , , 40436 7531 23 even even RB 40436 7531 24 if if IN 40436 7531 25 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7531 26 drink drink VBP 40436 7531 27 ever ever RB 40436 7531 28 so so RB 40436 7531 29 much much JJ 40436 7531 30 wine wine NN 40436 7531 31 . . . 40436 7532 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7532 2 90 90 CD 40436 7532 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7532 4 Men men NN 40436 7532 5 such such JJ 40436 7532 6 as as IN 40436 7532 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7532 8 are be VBP 40436 7532 9 , , , 40436 7532 10 do do VBP 40436 7532 11 not not RB 40436 7532 12 require require VB 40436 7532 13 to to TO 40436 7532 14 be be VB 40436 7532 15 amused amuse VBN 40436 7532 16 by by IN 40436 7532 17 singers singer NNS 40436 7532 18 nor nor CC 40436 7532 19 to to TO 40436 7532 20 talk talk VB 40436 7532 21 about about IN 40436 7532 22 the the DT 40436 7532 23 poets poet NNS 40436 7532 24 , , , 40436 7532 25 whom whom WP 40436 7532 26 no no DT 40436 7532 27 one one NN 40436 7532 28 can can MD 40436 7532 29 ask ask VB 40436 7532 30 what what WP 40436 7532 31 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7532 32 mean mean VBP 40436 7532 33 ; ; : 40436 7532 34 and and CC 40436 7532 35 who who WP 40436 7532 36 , , , 40436 7532 37 when when WRB 40436 7532 38 cited cite VBN 40436 7532 39 by by IN 40436 7532 40 different different JJ 40436 7532 41 speakers speaker NNS 40436 7532 42 , , , 40436 7532 43 are be VBP 40436 7532 44 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 7532 45 by by IN 40436 7532 46 one one CD 40436 7532 47 to to TO 40436 7532 48 mean mean VB 40436 7532 49 one one CD 40436 7532 50 thing thing NN 40436 7532 51 , , , 40436 7532 52 and and CC 40436 7532 53 by by IN 40436 7532 54 another another DT 40436 7532 55 to to TO 40436 7532 56 mean mean VB 40436 7532 57 something something NN 40436 7532 58 else else RB 40436 7532 59 , , , 40436 7532 60 without without IN 40436 7532 61 any any DT 40436 7532 62 decisive decisive JJ 40436 7532 63 authority authority NN 40436 7532 64 to to TO 40436 7532 65 appeal appeal VB 40436 7532 66 to to IN 40436 7532 67 . . . 40436 7533 1 Such such JJ 40436 7533 2 men man NNS 40436 7533 3 as as IN 40436 7533 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7533 5 and and CC 40436 7533 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7533 7 ought ought MD 40436 7533 8 to to TO 40436 7533 9 lay lay VB 40436 7533 10 aside aside RP 40436 7533 11 the the DT 40436 7533 12 poets poet NNS 40436 7533 13 , , , 40436 7533 14 and and CC 40436 7533 15 test test VB 40436 7533 16 each each DT 40436 7533 17 other other JJ 40436 7533 18 by by IN 40436 7533 19 colloquy colloquy NN 40436 7533 20 of of IN 40436 7533 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7533 22 own own JJ 40436 7533 23 . . . 40436 7534 1 If if IN 40436 7534 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7534 3 wish wish VBP 40436 7534 4 to to TO 40436 7534 5 persist persist VB 40436 7534 6 in in IN 40436 7534 7 questioning questioning NN 40436 7534 8 , , , 40436 7534 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7534 10 am be VBP 40436 7534 11 ready ready JJ 40436 7534 12 to to TO 40436 7534 13 answer answer VB 40436 7534 14 : : : 40436 7534 15 if if IN 40436 7534 16 not not RB 40436 7534 17 , , , 40436 7534 18 consent consent NN 40436 7534 19 to to TO 40436 7534 20 answer answer VB 40436 7534 21 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7534 22 , , , 40436 7534 23 and and CC 40436 7534 24 let let VB 40436 7534 25 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7534 26 bring bring VB 40436 7534 27 the the DT 40436 7534 28 interrupted interrupted JJ 40436 7534 29 debate debate NN 40436 7534 30 to to IN 40436 7534 31 a a DT 40436 7534 32 close close NN 40436 7534 33 . . . 40436 7535 1 " " `` 40436 7535 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7535 3 91 91 CD 40436 7535 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7535 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7535 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7535 7 87 87 CD 40436 7535 8 : : : 40436 7535 9 See see VB 40436 7535 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7535 11 , , , 40436 7535 12 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 7535 13 , , , 40436 7535 14 p. p. NN 40436 7535 15 245 245 CD 40436 7535 16 A a NN 40436 7535 17 - - HYPH 40436 7535 18 B b NN 40436 7535 19 ; ; : 40436 7535 20 Apol Apol NNP 40436 7535 21 . . . 40436 7536 1 p. p. NN 40436 7536 2 22 22 CD 40436 7536 3 B B NNP 40436 7536 4 - - HYPH 40436 7536 5 C C NNP 40436 7536 6 ; ; : 40436 7536 7 Ion Ion NNP 40436 7536 8 , , , 40436 7536 9 pp pp NNP 40436 7536 10 . . . 40436 7537 1 533 533 CD 40436 7537 2 - - SYM 40436 7537 3 534 534 CD 40436 7537 4 . . . 40436 7538 1 Compare compare VB 40436 7538 2 the the DT 40436 7538 3 distinction distinction NN 40436 7538 4 drawn draw VBN 40436 7538 5 in in IN 40436 7538 6 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 7538 7 , , , 40436 7538 8 p. p. NN 40436 7538 9 72 72 CD 40436 7538 10 A a NN 40436 7538 11 - - HYPH 40436 7538 12 B b NN 40436 7538 13 , , , 40436 7538 14 between between IN 40436 7538 15 the the DT 40436 7538 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7538 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7538 18 : : : 40436 7538 19 ma ma NNP 40436 7538 20 / / SYM 40436 7538 21 ntis ntis NNP 40436 7538 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7538 23 and and CC 40436 7538 24 the the DT 40436 7538 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7538 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7538 27 : : : 40436 7538 28 prophê prophê NNP 40436 7538 29 / / SYM 40436 7538 30 tês tês NNP 40436 7538 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7538 32 . . . 40436 7538 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7539 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7539 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7539 3 88 88 CD 40436 7539 4 : : : 40436 7539 5 About about IN 40436 7539 6 the the DT 40436 7539 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7539 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7539 9 : : : 40436 7539 10 u(po u(po NNP 40436 7539 11 / / SYM 40436 7539 12 noiai noiai NNP 40436 7539 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7539 14 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 7539 15 to to IN 40436 7539 16 the the DT 40436 7539 17 poets poet NNS 40436 7539 18 , , , 40436 7539 19 see see VB 40436 7539 20 Repub Repub NNP 40436 7539 21 . . . 40436 7540 1 ii ii LS 40436 7540 2 . . . 40436 7541 1 p. p. NN 40436 7541 2 378 378 CD 40436 7541 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7541 4 ; ; : 40436 7541 5 Xen Xen NNP 40436 7541 6 . . . 40436 7542 1 Sympos Sympos NNP 40436 7542 2 . . . 40436 7543 1 iii iii NNP 40436 7543 2 . . . 40436 7544 1 6 6 CD 40436 7544 2 ; ; : 40436 7544 3 and and CC 40436 7544 4 F. F. NNP 40436 7544 5 A. a. NN 40436 7544 6 Wolf Wolf NNP 40436 7544 7 , , , 40436 7544 8 Prolegom Prolegom NNP 40436 7544 9 . . . 40436 7545 1 Homer Homer NNP 40436 7545 2 . . . 40436 7546 1 p. p. NNP 40436 7546 2 clxii.-clxiv clxii.-clxiv NNP 40436 7546 3 . . . 40436 7547 1 F. F. NNP 40436 7547 2 A. a. NN 40436 7547 3 Wolf Wolf NNP 40436 7547 4 remarks remark VBZ 40436 7547 5 , , , 40436 7547 6 respecting respect VBG 40436 7547 7 the the DT 40436 7547 8 various various JJ 40436 7547 9 allegorical allegorical JJ 40436 7547 10 interpretations interpretation NNS 40436 7547 11 of of IN 40436 7547 12 Homer Homer NNP 40436 7547 13 and and CC 40436 7547 14 other other JJ 40436 7547 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7547 16 poets-- poets-- NNP 40436 7547 17 " " '' 40436 7547 18 Sed Sed NNP 40436 7547 19 nec nec NNP 40436 7547 20 prioribus prioribus NNP 40436 7547 21 illis illis NNP 40436 7547 22 , , , 40436 7547 23 sive sive JJ 40436 7547 24 allegorica allegorica NNP 40436 7547 25 et et NNP 40436 7547 26 anagogica anagogica NNP 40436 7547 27 somnia somnia NNP 40436 7547 28 sua sua NNP 40436 7547 29 ipsi ipsi NNP 40436 7547 30 crediderunt crediderunt NNP 40436 7547 31 , , , 40436 7547 32 sive sive JJ 40436 7547 33 ab ab NNP 40436 7547 34 aliis aliis JJ 40436 7547 35 duntaxat duntaxat NN 40436 7547 36 credi credi NN 40436 7547 37 voluerunt voluerunt NN 40436 7547 38 , , , 40436 7547 39 idonea idonea NNP 40436 7547 40 deest deest NNP 40436 7547 41 excusatio excusatio NNP 40436 7547 42 . . . 40436 7548 1 Ita Ita NNP 40436 7548 2 enim enim NNP 40436 7548 3 ratio ratio NN 40436 7548 4 comparata comparata NNP 40436 7548 5 est est NNP 40436 7548 6 , , , 40436 7548 7 ut ut NNP 40436 7548 8 libris libris NNP 40436 7548 9 , , , 40436 7548 10 quos quos NNP 40436 7548 11 a a DT 40436 7548 12 teneris teneris NNP 40436 7548 13 statim statim NNP 40436 7548 14 annis annis NNP 40436 7548 15 cognoscimus cognoscimus NNP 40436 7548 16 , , , 40436 7548 17 omnes omnes NNP 40436 7548 18 propé propé NNP 40436 7548 19 nostras nostras NNP 40436 7548 20 nostræque nostræque NNP 40436 7548 21 ætatis ætatis NNP 40436 7548 22 opiniones opiniones NNP 40436 7548 23 subjiciamus subjiciamus NNP 40436 7548 24 : : : 40436 7548 25 ac ac RB 40436 7548 26 si si NNP 40436 7548 27 illi illi NNP 40436 7548 28 jampridem jampridem NNP 40436 7548 29 populari populari NNP 40436 7548 30 usu usu NNP 40436 7548 31 consecrati consecrati NNP 40436 7548 32 sunt sunt NNP 40436 7548 33 , , , 40436 7548 34 ipsa ipsa NNP 40436 7548 35 obstat obstat NNP 40436 7548 36 veneratio veneratio NNP 40436 7548 37 , , , 40436 7548 38 quominus quominus NN 40436 7548 39 in in IN 40436 7548 40 iis iis NNP 40436 7548 41 absurda absurda NNP 40436 7548 42 et et NNP 40436 7548 43 ridicula ridicula NNP 40436 7548 44 inesse inesse NNP 40436 7548 45 credamus credamus NNP 40436 7548 46 . . . 40436 7549 1 Lenimus Lenimus NNP 40436 7549 2 ergo ergo NNP 40436 7549 3 atque atque NNP 40436 7549 4 adeo adeo NNP 40436 7549 5 ornamus ornamus NNP 40436 7549 6 interpretando interpretando NNP 40436 7549 7 , , , 40436 7549 8 quicquid quicquid NNP 40436 7549 9 proprio proprio NN 40436 7549 10 sensu sensu NN 40436 7549 11 non non NNP 40436 7549 12 ferendum ferendum NNP 40436 7549 13 videtur videtur NNP 40436 7549 14 . . . 40436 7550 1 Atque Atque NNP 40436 7550 2 ita ita NNP 40436 7550 3 factum factum NN 40436 7550 4 est est VBD 40436 7550 5 omni omni NNP 40436 7550 6 tempore tempore VBD 40436 7550 7 in in IN 40436 7550 8 libris libris NNP 40436 7550 9 iis iis NNP 40436 7550 10 , , , 40436 7550 11 qui qui VBD 40436 7550 12 pro pro FW 40436 7550 13 sacris sacris NNP 40436 7550 14 habiti habiti NNP 40436 7550 15 sunt sunt NNP 40436 7550 16 . . . 40436 7550 17 " " '' 40436 7551 1 The the DT 40436 7551 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 7551 3 was be VBD 40436 7551 4 similar similar JJ 40436 7551 5 in in IN 40436 7551 6 character character NN 40436 7551 7 , , , 40436 7551 8 and and CC 40436 7551 9 even even RB 40436 7551 10 more more RBR 40436 7551 11 marked marked JJ 40436 7551 12 in in IN 40436 7551 13 respect respect NN 40436 7551 14 of of IN 40436 7551 15 earnest earnest JJ 40436 7551 16 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 7551 17 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 7551 18 , , , 40436 7551 19 between between IN 40436 7551 20 the the DT 40436 7551 21 different different JJ 40436 7551 22 schools school NNS 40436 7551 23 of of IN 40436 7551 24 the the DT 40436 7551 25 Jews Jews NNPS 40436 7551 26 in in IN 40436 7551 27 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 40436 7551 28 and and CC 40436 7551 29 Palestine Palestine NNP 40436 7551 30 about about IN 40436 7551 31 the the DT 40436 7551 32 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7551 33 of of IN 40436 7551 34 the the DT 40436 7551 35 Pentateuch Pentateuch NNP 40436 7551 36 . . . 40436 7552 1 1 1 LS 40436 7552 2 . . . 40436 7553 1 Those those DT 40436 7553 2 who who WP 40436 7553 3 interpreted interpret VBD 40436 7553 4 literally literally RB 40436 7553 5 , , , 40436 7553 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7553 7 Greek greek NN 40436 7553 8 : : : 40436 7553 9 kata\ kata\ NFP 40436 7553 10 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7553 11 r(êtê\n r(êtê\n NN 40436 7553 12 dia dia NN 40436 7553 13 / / SYM 40436 7553 14 noian noian NNP 40436 7553 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7553 16 . . . 40436 7554 1 2 2 LS 40436 7554 2 . . . 40436 7555 1 Those those DT 40436 7555 2 who who WP 40436 7555 3 set set VBD 40436 7555 4 aside aside RP 40436 7555 5 the the DT 40436 7555 6 literal literal JJ 40436 7555 7 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 7555 8 , , , 40436 7555 9 and and CC 40436 7555 10 explained explain VBD 40436 7555 11 the the DT 40436 7555 12 text text NN 40436 7555 13 upon upon IN 40436 7555 14 a a DT 40436 7555 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 7555 16 of of IN 40436 7555 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7555 18 own own JJ 40436 7555 19 , , , 40436 7555 20 above above IN 40436 7555 21 the the DT 40436 7555 22 reach reach NN 40436 7555 23 of of IN 40436 7555 24 the the DT 40436 7555 25 vulgar vulgar NN 40436 7555 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7555 27 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 40436 7555 28 , , , 40436 7555 29 Præp Præp NNP 40436 7555 30 . . . 40436 7556 1 Ev Ev NNP 40436 7556 2 . . . 40436 7557 1 viii viii RB 40436 7557 2 . . . 40436 7558 1 10 10 LS 40436 7558 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7558 3 . . . 40436 7559 1 Some some DT 40436 7559 2 admitted admit VBD 40436 7559 3 both both DT 40436 7559 4 the the DT 40436 7559 5 two two CD 40436 7559 6 interpretations interpretation NNS 40436 7559 7 , , , 40436 7559 8 side side NN 40436 7559 9 by by IN 40436 7559 10 side side NN 40436 7559 11 . . . 40436 7560 1 Respecting respect VBG 40436 7560 2 these these DT 40436 7560 3 allegorising allegorise VBG 40436 7560 4 schools school NNS 40436 7560 5 of of IN 40436 7560 6 the the DT 40436 7560 7 Hellenistic Hellenistic NNP 40436 7560 8 Jews Jews NNPS 40436 7560 9 , , , 40436 7560 10 from from IN 40436 7560 11 Aristobulus Aristobulus NNP 40436 7560 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7560 13 150 150 CD 40436 7560 14 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 7560 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7561 1 down down IN 40436 7561 2 to to IN 40436 7561 3 Philo Philo NNP 40436 7561 4 , , , 40436 7561 5 see see VB 40436 7561 6 the the DT 40436 7561 7 learned learned JJ 40436 7561 8 and and CC 40436 7561 9 valuable valuable JJ 40436 7561 10 work work NN 40436 7561 11 of of IN 40436 7561 12 Gfrörer--_Philo gfrörer--_philo NN 40436 7561 13 und und NN 40436 7561 14 die die VB 40436 7561 15 Jüdisch.-Alexandr Jüdisch.-Alexandr NNP 40436 7561 16 . . . 40436 7562 1 Theosophie Theosophie NNP 40436 7562 2 _ _ NNP 40436 7562 3 , , , 40436 7562 4 vol vol NNP 40436 7562 5 . . . 40436 7563 1 i. i. NNP 40436 7563 2 pp pp NNP 40436 7563 3 . . . 40436 7564 1 84 84 CD 40436 7564 2 - - SYM 40436 7564 3 86 86 CD 40436 7564 4 , , , 40436 7564 5 ii ii NNP 40436 7564 6 . . . 40436 7565 1 p. p. NN 40436 7565 2 356 356 CD 40436 7565 3 seq seq NN 40436 7565 4 . . . 40436 7565 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7566 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7566 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7566 3 89 89 CD 40436 7566 4 : : : 40436 7566 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7566 6 . . . 40436 7567 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7567 2 . . . 40436 7568 1 p. p. NN 40436 7569 1 345 345 CD 40436 7569 2 . . . 40436 7569 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7570 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7570 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7570 3 90 90 CD 40436 7570 4 : : : 40436 7570 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7570 6 , , , 40436 7570 7 Prot Prot NNP 40436 7570 8 . . . 40436 7571 1 p. p. NN 40436 7571 2 347 347 CD 40436 7571 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7571 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7571 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7571 6 : : : 40436 7571 7 ka)\n ka)\n NNP 40436 7571 8 ma ma NNP 40436 7571 9 / / SYM 40436 7571 10 nu nu NNP 40436 7571 11 polu\n polu\n NNP 40436 7571 12 oi)=non oi)=non NNP 40436 7571 13 pi pi NNP 40436 7571 14 / / SYM 40436 7571 15 ôsin]--a ôsin]--a NNP 40436 7571 16 phrase phrase NN 40436 7571 17 which which WDT 40436 7571 18 will will MD 40436 7571 19 be be VB 40436 7571 20 found find VBN 40436 7571 21 suitably suitably RB 40436 7571 22 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 7571 23 by by IN 40436 7571 24 the the DT 40436 7571 25 persistent persistent JJ 40436 7571 26 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 7571 27 of of IN 40436 7571 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7571 29 , , , 40436 7571 30 even even RB 40436 7571 31 at at IN 40436 7571 32 the the DT 40436 7571 33 close close NN 40436 7571 34 of of IN 40436 7571 35 the the DT 40436 7571 36 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7571 37 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 7571 38 , , , 40436 7571 39 after after IN 40436 7571 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7571 41 has have VBZ 40436 7571 42 swallowed swallow VBN 40436 7571 43 an an DT 40436 7571 44 incredible incredible JJ 40436 7571 45 quantity quantity NN 40436 7571 46 of of IN 40436 7571 47 wine wine NN 40436 7571 48 . . . 40436 7571 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7572 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7572 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7572 3 91 91 CD 40436 7572 4 : : : 40436 7572 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7572 6 . . . 40436 7573 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7573 2 . . . 40436 7574 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7574 2 . . . 40436 7575 1 347 347 CD 40436 7575 2 - - SYM 40436 7575 3 348 348 CD 40436 7575 4 . . . 40436 7576 1 This this DT 40436 7576 2 remark remark NN 40436 7576 3 -- -- : 40436 7576 4 that that IN 40436 7576 5 the the DT 40436 7576 6 poet poet NN 40436 7576 7 may may MD 40436 7576 8 be be VB 40436 7576 9 interpreted interpret VBN 40436 7576 10 in in IN 40436 7576 11 many many JJ 40436 7576 12 different different JJ 40436 7576 13 ways way NNS 40436 7576 14 , , , 40436 7576 15 and and CC 40436 7576 16 that that IN 40436 7576 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7576 18 can can MD 40436 7576 19 not not RB 40436 7576 20 produce produce VB 40436 7576 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7576 22 in in IN 40436 7576 23 court court NN 40436 7576 24 to to TO 40436 7576 25 declare declare VB 40436 7576 26 or or CC 40436 7576 27 defend defend VB 40436 7576 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7576 29 own own JJ 40436 7576 30 meaning meaning NN 40436 7576 31 -- -- : 40436 7576 32 is be VBZ 40436 7576 33 highly highly RB 40436 7576 34 significant significant JJ 40436 7576 35 , , , 40436 7576 36 in in IN 40436 7576 37 regard regard NN 40436 7576 38 to to IN 40436 7576 39 the the DT 40436 7576 40 value value NN 40436 7576 41 set set VBN 40436 7576 42 by by IN 40436 7576 43 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7576 44 on on IN 40436 7576 45 living live VBG 40436 7576 46 conversation conversation NN 40436 7576 47 and and CC 40436 7576 48 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 7576 49 . . . 40436 7576 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7577 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7577 2 Side side NN 40436 7577 3 - - HYPH 40436 7577 4 note note NN 40436 7577 5 : : : 40436 7577 6 Purpose purpose NN 40436 7577 7 of of IN 40436 7577 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7577 9 to to TO 40436 7577 10 sift sift VB 40436 7577 11 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 7577 12 which which WDT 40436 7577 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7577 14 really really RB 40436 7577 15 feels feel VBZ 40436 7577 16 in in IN 40436 7577 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7577 18 own own JJ 40436 7577 19 mind mind NN 40436 7577 20 . . . 40436 7578 1 Importance importance NN 40436 7578 2 of of IN 40436 7578 3 a a DT 40436 7578 4 colloquial colloquial JJ 40436 7578 5 companion companion NN 40436 7578 6 for for IN 40436 7578 7 this this DT 40436 7578 8 purpose purpose NN 40436 7578 9 . . . 40436 7578 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7579 1 In in IN 40436 7579 2 spite spite NN 40436 7579 3 of of IN 40436 7579 4 this this DT 40436 7579 5 appeal appeal NN 40436 7579 6 , , , 40436 7579 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7579 8 is be VBZ 40436 7579 9 still still RB 40436 7579 10 unwilling unwilling JJ 40436 7579 11 to to TO 40436 7579 12 resume resume VB 40436 7579 13 , , , 40436 7579 14 and and CC 40436 7579 15 is be VBZ 40436 7579 16 only only RB 40436 7579 17 forced force VBN 40436 7579 18 to to TO 40436 7579 19 do do VB 40436 7579 20 so so RB 40436 7579 21 by by IN 40436 7579 22 a a DT 40436 7579 23 stinging stinging JJ 40436 7579 24 taunt taunt NN 40436 7579 25 from from IN 40436 7579 26 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 7579 27 , , , 40436 7579 28 enforced enforce VBN 40436 7579 29 by by IN 40436 7579 30 requests request NNS 40436 7579 31 from from IN 40436 7579 32 Kallias Kallias NNP 40436 7579 33 and and CC 40436 7579 34 others other NNS 40436 7579 35 . . . 40436 7580 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7580 2 is be VBZ 40436 7580 3 depicted depict VBN 40436 7580 4 as as IN 40436 7580 5 afraid afraid JJ 40436 7580 6 of of IN 40436 7580 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7580 8 , , , 40436 7580 9 who who WP 40436 7580 10 , , , 40436 7580 11 as as RB 40436 7580 12 soon soon RB 40436 7580 13 as as IN 40436 7580 14 consent consent NN 40436 7580 15 is be VBZ 40436 7580 16 given give VBN 40436 7580 17 , , , 40436 7580 18 recommences recommence VBZ 40436 7580 19 the the DT 40436 7580 20 discussion discussion NN 40436 7580 21 by by IN 40436 7580 22 saying--"Do saying--"Do NNP 40436 7580 23 not not RB 40436 7580 24 think think VBP 40436 7580 25 , , , 40436 7580 26 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7580 27 , , , 40436 7580 28 that that IN 40436 7580 29 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7580 30 have have VBP 40436 7580 31 any any DT 40436 7580 32 other other JJ 40436 7580 33 purpose purpose NN 40436 7580 34 in in IN 40436 7580 35 debating debating NN 40436 7580 36 , , , 40436 7580 37 except except IN 40436 7580 38 to to TO 40436 7580 39 sift sift VB 40436 7580 40 through through IN 40436 7580 41 and and CC 40436 7580 42 through through RB 40436 7580 43 , , , 40436 7580 44 in in IN 40436 7580 45 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 7580 46 with with IN 40436 7580 47 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7580 48 , , , 40436 7580 49 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 7580 50 which which WDT 40436 7580 51 puzzle puzzle VBP 40436 7580 52 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7580 53 own own JJ 40436 7580 54 mind mind NN 40436 7580 55 . . . 40436 7581 1 Two two CD 40436 7581 2 of of IN 40436 7581 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7581 4 together together RB 40436 7581 5 can can MD 40436 7581 6 do do VB 40436 7581 7 more more JJR 40436 7581 8 in in IN 40436 7581 9 this this DT 40436 7581 10 way way NN 40436 7581 11 than than IN 40436 7581 12 any any DT 40436 7581 13 one one NN 40436 7581 14 singly singly RB 40436 7581 15 . . . 40436 7582 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7582 2 92 92 CD 40436 7582 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7582 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7582 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7582 6 92 92 CD 40436 7582 7 : : : 40436 7582 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7582 9 . . . 40436 7583 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7583 2 . . . 40436 7584 1 p. p. NN 40436 7584 2 348 348 CD 40436 7584 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7584 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7584 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7584 6 : : : 40436 7584 7 mê\ mê\ VB 40436 7584 8 oi)/ou oi)/ou CD 40436 7584 9 diale diale NN 40436 7584 10 / / SYM 40436 7584 11 gesthai gesthai NNP 40436 7584 12 me/ me/ NNP 40436 7584 13 soi soi NNP 40436 7584 14 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 7584 15 ti ti IN 40436 7584 16 boulo boulo NNP 40436 7584 17 / / SYM 40436 7584 18 menon menon NNP 40436 7584 19 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 7584 20 a)\ a)\ NNP 40436 7584 21 au)to\s au)to\ NNS 40436 7584 22 a)porô= a)porô= JJ 40436 7584 23 , , , 40436 7584 24 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 7584 25 / / SYM 40436 7584 26 stote stote NNP 40436 7584 27 tau tau NNP 40436 7584 28 = = SYM 40436 7584 29 ta ta NNP 40436 7584 30 diaske diaske NNP 40436 7584 31 / / SYM 40436 7584 32 psasthai psasthai NNP 40436 7584 33 . . . 40436 7584 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7585 1 The the DT 40436 7585 2 remark remark NN 40436 7585 3 here here RB 40436 7585 4 given give VBN 40436 7585 5 should should MD 40436 7585 6 be be VB 40436 7585 7 carefully carefully RB 40436 7585 8 noted note VBN 40436 7585 9 in in IN 40436 7585 10 appreciating appreciate VBG 40436 7585 11 the the DT 40436 7585 12 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 7585 13 frame frame NN 40436 7585 14 of of IN 40436 7585 15 mind mind NN 40436 7585 16 . . . 40436 7586 1 The the DT 40436 7586 2 cross cross NN 40436 7586 3 - - NN 40436 7586 4 examination examination NN 40436 7586 5 which which WDT 40436 7586 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7586 7 bestows bestow VBZ 40436 7586 8 , , , 40436 7586 9 is be VBZ 40436 7586 10 not not RB 40436 7586 11 that that DT 40436 7586 12 of of IN 40436 7586 13 one one CD 40436 7586 14 who who WP 40436 7586 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7586 16 knows know VBZ 40436 7586 17 -- -- : 40436 7586 18 and and CC 40436 7586 19 who who WP 40436 7586 20 only only RB 40436 7586 21 gets get VBZ 40436 7586 22 up up RP 40436 7586 23 artificial artificial JJ 40436 7586 24 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 7586 25 to to TO 40436 7586 26 ascertain ascertain VB 40436 7586 27 whether whether IN 40436 7586 28 others other NNS 40436 7586 29 know know VBP 40436 7586 30 as as RB 40436 7586 31 much much RB 40436 7586 32 as as IN 40436 7586 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7586 34 does do VBZ 40436 7586 35 . . . 40436 7587 1 On on IN 40436 7587 2 the the DT 40436 7587 3 contrary contrary NN 40436 7587 4 , , , 40436 7587 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7587 6 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 7587 7 from from IN 40436 7587 8 one one CD 40436 7587 9 who who WP 40436 7587 10 is be VBZ 40436 7587 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7587 12 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 7587 13 ; ; : 40436 7587 14 and and CC 40436 7587 15 that that IN 40436 7587 16 which which WDT 40436 7587 17 puzzles puzzle VBZ 40436 7587 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7587 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7587 20 states state VBZ 40436 7587 21 to to IN 40436 7587 22 others other NNS 40436 7587 23 , , , 40436 7587 24 and and CC 40436 7587 25 debates debate NNS 40436 7587 26 with with IN 40436 7587 27 others other NNS 40436 7587 28 , , , 40436 7587 29 as as IN 40436 7587 30 affording afford VBG 40436 7587 31 the the DT 40436 7587 32 best good JJS 40436 7587 33 chance chance NN 40436 7587 34 of of IN 40436 7587 35 clearing clear VBG 40436 7587 36 up up RP 40436 7587 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7587 38 own own JJ 40436 7587 39 ideas idea NNS 40436 7587 40 and and CC 40436 7587 41 obtaining obtain VBG 40436 7587 42 a a DT 40436 7587 43 solution solution NN 40436 7587 44 . . . 40436 7588 1 The the DT 40436 7588 2 grand grand JJ 40436 7588 3 purpose purpose NN 40436 7588 4 with with IN 40436 7588 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7588 6 is be VBZ 40436 7588 7 to to TO 40436 7588 8 bring bring VB 40436 7588 9 into into IN 40436 7588 10 clear clear JJ 40436 7588 11 daylight daylight NN 40436 7588 12 the the DT 40436 7588 13 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 7588 14 which which WDT 40436 7588 15 impede impede VBZ 40436 7588 16 the the DT 40436 7588 17 construction construction NN 40436 7588 18 of of IN 40436 7588 19 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 7588 20 or or CC 40436 7588 21 " " `` 40436 7588 22 reasoned reason VBN 40436 7588 23 truth truth NN 40436 7588 24 , , , 40436 7588 25 " " '' 40436 7588 26 and and CC 40436 7588 27 to to TO 40436 7588 28 sift sift VB 40436 7588 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7588 30 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 7588 31 , , , 40436 7588 32 instead instead RB 40436 7588 33 of of IN 40436 7588 34 slurring slur VBG 40436 7588 35 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7588 36 over over RP 40436 7588 37 or or CC 40436 7588 38 hiding hide VBG 40436 7588 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7588 40 . . . 40436 7588 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7589 1 " " `` 40436 7589 2 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7589 3 are be VBP 40436 7589 4 all all RB 40436 7589 5 more more RBR 40436 7589 6 fertile fertile JJ 40436 7589 7 and and CC 40436 7589 8 suggestive suggestive JJ 40436 7589 9 , , , 40436 7589 10 with with IN 40436 7589 11 regard regard NN 40436 7589 12 to to IN 40436 7589 13 thought thought NN 40436 7589 14 , , , 40436 7589 15 word word NN 40436 7589 16 , , , 40436 7589 17 and and CC 40436 7589 18 deed deed NN 40436 7589 19 , , , 40436 7589 20 when when WRB 40436 7589 21 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7589 22 act act VBP 40436 7589 23 in in IN 40436 7589 24 couples couple NNS 40436 7589 25 . . . 40436 7590 1 If if IN 40436 7590 2 a a DT 40436 7590 3 man man NN 40436 7590 4 strikes strike VBZ 40436 7590 5 out out RP 40436 7590 6 anything anything NN 40436 7590 7 new new JJ 40436 7590 8 by by IN 40436 7590 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7590 10 , , , 40436 7590 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7590 12 immediately immediately RB 40436 7590 13 goes go VBZ 40436 7590 14 about about IN 40436 7590 15 looking look VBG 40436 7590 16 for for IN 40436 7590 17 a a DT 40436 7590 18 companion companion NN 40436 7590 19 to to IN 40436 7590 20 whom whom WP 40436 7590 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7590 22 can can MD 40436 7590 23 communicate communicate VB 40436 7590 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7590 25 , , , 40436 7590 26 and and CC 40436 7590 27 with with IN 40436 7590 28 whom whom WP 40436 7590 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7590 30 can can MD 40436 7590 31 jointly jointly RB 40436 7590 32 review review VB 40436 7590 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7590 34 . . . 40436 7591 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 7591 2 , , , 40436 7591 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7591 4 are be VBP 40436 7591 5 the the DT 40436 7591 6 best good JJS 40436 7591 7 man man NN 40436 7591 8 that that WDT 40436 7591 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7591 10 know know VBP 40436 7591 11 for for IN 40436 7591 12 this this DT 40436 7591 13 purpose purpose NN 40436 7591 14 , , , 40436 7591 15 especially especially RB 40436 7591 16 on on IN 40436 7591 17 the the DT 40436 7591 18 subject subject NN 40436 7591 19 of of IN 40436 7591 20 virtue virtue NN 40436 7591 21 : : : 40436 7591 22 for for IN 40436 7591 23 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7591 24 are be VBP 40436 7591 25 not not RB 40436 7591 26 only only RB 40436 7591 27 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 7591 28 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 7591 29 , , , 40436 7591 30 but but CC 40436 7591 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7591 32 can can MD 40436 7591 33 make make VB 40436 7591 34 others other NNS 40436 7591 35 so so RB 40436 7591 36 likewise likewise RB 40436 7591 37 , , , 40436 7591 38 and and CC 40436 7591 39 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7591 40 proclaim proclaim VBP 40436 7591 41 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 7591 42 a a DT 40436 7591 43 teacher teacher NN 40436 7591 44 of of IN 40436 7591 45 virtue virtue NN 40436 7591 46 more more RBR 40436 7591 47 publicly publicly RB 40436 7591 48 than than IN 40436 7591 49 any any DT 40436 7591 50 one one NN 40436 7591 51 has have VBZ 40436 7591 52 ever ever RB 40436 7591 53 done do VBN 40436 7591 54 before before RB 40436 7591 55 . . . 40436 7592 1 Whom whom WP 40436 7592 2 can can MD 40436 7592 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7592 4 find find VB 40436 7592 5 so so RB 40436 7592 6 competent competent JJ 40436 7592 7 as as IN 40436 7592 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7592 9 , , , 40436 7592 10 for for IN 40436 7592 11 questioning questioning NN 40436 7592 12 and and CC 40436 7592 13 communication communication NN 40436 7592 14 on on IN 40436 7592 15 these these DT 40436 7592 16 very very JJ 40436 7592 17 subjects subject NNS 40436 7592 18 ? ? . 40436 7593 1 " " `` 40436 7593 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7593 3 93 93 CD 40436 7593 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7593 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7593 6 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7593 7 93 93 CD 40436 7593 8 : : : 40436 7593 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7593 10 , , , 40436 7593 11 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7593 12 . . . 40436 7594 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7594 2 . . . 40436 7595 1 348 348 CD 40436 7595 2 - - SYM 40436 7595 3 349 349 CD 40436 7595 4 . . . 40436 7595 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7596 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7596 2 Side side NN 40436 7596 3 - - HYPH 40436 7596 4 note note NN 40436 7596 5 : : : 40436 7596 6 The the DT 40436 7596 7 interrupted interrupted JJ 40436 7596 8 debate debate NN 40436 7596 9 is be VBZ 40436 7596 10 resumed resume VBN 40436 7596 11 . . . 40436 7597 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7597 2 says say VBZ 40436 7597 3 that that IN 40436 7597 4 courage courage NN 40436 7597 5 differs differ VBZ 40436 7597 6 materially materially RB 40436 7597 7 from from IN 40436 7597 8 the the DT 40436 7597 9 other other JJ 40436 7597 10 branches branch NNS 40436 7597 11 of of IN 40436 7597 12 virtue virtue NN 40436 7597 13 . . . 40436 7597 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7598 1 After after IN 40436 7598 2 this this DT 40436 7598 3 eulogy eulogy NN 40436 7598 4 on on IN 40436 7598 5 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 7598 6 conversation conversation NN 40436 7598 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7598 8 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 7598 9 still still RB 40436 7598 10 farther far RBR 40436 7598 11 the the DT 40436 7598 12 main main JJ 40436 7598 13 purpose purpose NN 40436 7598 14 of of IN 40436 7598 15 the the DT 40436 7598 16 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7598 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7598 18 , , , 40436 7598 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7598 20 resumes resume VBZ 40436 7598 21 the the DT 40436 7598 22 argument argument NN 40436 7598 23 as as IN 40436 7598 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7598 25 stood stand VBD 40436 7598 26 when when WRB 40436 7598 27 interrupted interrupt VBN 40436 7598 28 . . . 40436 7599 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7599 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 7599 3 , , , 40436 7599 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7599 5 , , , 40436 7599 6 said say VBD 40436 7599 7 that that IN 40436 7599 8 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7599 9 , , , 40436 7599 10 moderation moderation NN 40436 7599 11 , , , 40436 7599 12 justice justice NN 40436 7599 13 , , , 40436 7599 14 holiness holiness NN 40436 7599 15 , , , 40436 7599 16 courage courage NN 40436 7599 17 , , , 40436 7599 18 were be VBD 40436 7599 19 all all DT 40436 7599 20 parts part NNS 40436 7599 21 of of IN 40436 7599 22 virtue virtue NN 40436 7599 23 ; ; : 40436 7599 24 but but CC 40436 7599 25 each each DT 40436 7599 26 different different JJ 40436 7599 27 from from IN 40436 7599 28 the the DT 40436 7599 29 others other NNS 40436 7599 30 , , , 40436 7599 31 and and CC 40436 7599 32 each each DT 40436 7599 33 having have VBG 40436 7599 34 a a DT 40436 7599 35 separate separate JJ 40436 7599 36 essence essence NN 40436 7599 37 and and CC 40436 7599 38 properties property NNS 40436 7599 39 of of IN 40436 7599 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7599 41 own own JJ 40436 7599 42 . . . 40436 7600 1 Do do VBP 40436 7600 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7600 3 still still RB 40436 7600 4 adhere adhere VB 40436 7600 5 to to IN 40436 7600 6 that that DT 40436 7600 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 7600 8 ? ? . 40436 7601 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7601 2 Prot._--I Prot._--I NNS 40436 7601 3 now now RB 40436 7601 4 think think VBP 40436 7601 5 that that IN 40436 7601 6 the the DT 40436 7601 7 first first JJ 40436 7601 8 four four CD 40436 7601 9 are be VBP 40436 7601 10 tolerably tolerably RB 40436 7601 11 like like UH 40436 7601 12 and and CC 40436 7601 13 akin akin JJ 40436 7601 14 to to IN 40436 7601 15 each each DT 40436 7601 16 other other JJ 40436 7601 17 , , , 40436 7601 18 but but CC 40436 7601 19 that that DT 40436 7601 20 courage courage NN 40436 7601 21 is be VBZ 40436 7601 22 very very RB 40436 7601 23 greatly greatly RB 40436 7601 24 different different JJ 40436 7601 25 from from IN 40436 7601 26 all all PDT 40436 7601 27 the the DT 40436 7601 28 four four CD 40436 7601 29 . . . 40436 7602 1 The the DT 40436 7602 2 proof proof NN 40436 7602 3 is be VBZ 40436 7602 4 , , , 40436 7602 5 that that IN 40436 7602 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7602 7 will will MD 40436 7602 8 find find VB 40436 7602 9 many many JJ 40436 7602 10 men man NNS 40436 7602 11 pre pre VB 40436 7602 12 - - JJ 40436 7602 13 eminent eminent JJ 40436 7602 14 for for IN 40436 7602 15 courage courage NN 40436 7602 16 , , , 40436 7602 17 but but CC 40436 7602 18 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 7602 19 unjust unjust JJ 40436 7602 20 , , , 40436 7602 21 unholy unholy JJ 40436 7602 22 , , , 40436 7602 23 intemperate intemperate VB 40436 7602 24 , , , 40436 7602 25 and and CC 40436 7602 26 stupid stupid JJ 40436 7602 27 . . . 40436 7603 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7603 2 94 94 CD 40436 7603 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7603 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7603 5 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 7603 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7603 7 consider consider VBP 40436 7603 8 that that IN 40436 7603 9 all all DT 40436 7603 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 7603 11 , , , 40436 7603 12 and and CC 40436 7603 13 each each DT 40436 7603 14 separate separate JJ 40436 7603 15 part part NN 40436 7603 16 of of IN 40436 7603 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7603 18 , , , 40436 7603 19 is be VBZ 40436 7603 20 fine fine JJ 40436 7603 21 and and CC 40436 7603 22 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7603 23 ? ? . 40436 7604 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7604 2 Prot._--I Prot._--I NNS 40436 7604 3 consider consider VBP 40436 7604 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7604 5 in in IN 40436 7604 6 the the DT 40436 7604 7 highest high JJS 40436 7604 8 degree degree NN 40436 7604 9 fine fine JJ 40436 7604 10 and and CC 40436 7604 11 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7604 12 : : : 40436 7604 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7604 14 must must MD 40436 7604 15 be be VB 40436 7604 16 mad mad JJ 40436 7604 17 to to TO 40436 7604 18 think think VB 40436 7604 19 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 7604 20 . . . 40436 7605 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7605 2 95 95 CD 40436 7605 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7605 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7605 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7605 6 94 94 CD 40436 7605 7 : : : 40436 7605 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7605 9 , , , 40436 7605 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7605 11 . . . 40436 7606 1 p p NNP 40436 7606 2 , , , 40436 7606 3 349 349 CD 40436 7606 4 D. D. NNP 40436 7606 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7606 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7606 7 : : : 40436 7606 8 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 7606 9 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7606 10 te te NNP 40436 7606 11 / / SYM 40436 7606 12 ttara ttara NNP 40436 7606 13 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 7606 14 = = SYM 40436 7606 15 n n CC 40436 7606 16 e)pieikô e)pieikô CD 40436 7606 17 = = SYM 40436 7606 18 s s NNP 40436 7606 19 paraplê paraplê NNP 40436 7606 20 / / SYM 40436 7606 21 sia sia NNP 40436 7606 22 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 7606 23 / / SYM 40436 7606 24 lois lois NNP 40436 7606 25 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 7606 26 / / SYM 40436 7606 27 n n NN 40436 7606 28 , , , 40436 7606 29 ê ê NNP 40436 7606 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7606 31 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7606 32 a)ndrei a)ndrei NNP 40436 7606 33 / / SYM 40436 7606 34 a a DT 40436 7606 35 pa pa NNP 40436 7606 36 / / SYM 40436 7606 37 nu nu NNP 40436 7606 38 polu\ polu\ NNP 40436 7606 39 diaphe diaphe NNP 40436 7606 40 / / SYM 40436 7606 41 ron ron NNP 40436 7606 42 pa pa NNP 40436 7606 43 / / SYM 40436 7606 44 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 7606 45 tou tou NNP 40436 7606 46 / / SYM 40436 7606 47 tôn tôn NNP 40436 7606 48 . . . 40436 7606 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7606 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7607 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7607 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7607 3 95 95 CD 40436 7607 4 : : : 40436 7607 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7607 6 , , , 40436 7607 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7607 8 . . . 40436 7608 1 p. p. NN 40436 7608 2 349 349 CD 40436 7608 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7608 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7608 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7608 6 : : : 40436 7608 7 ka ka NNP 40436 7608 8 / / SYM 40436 7608 9 lliston lliston NNP 40436 7608 10 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7608 11 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 7608 12 , , , 40436 7608 13 ei ei NNP 40436 7608 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7608 15 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 7608 16 mai mai NNP 40436 7608 17 / / SYM 40436 7608 18 nomai/ nomai/ NNP 40436 7608 19 ge ge NNP 40436 7608 20 . . . 40436 7609 1 o(/lon o(/lon NNP 40436 7609 2 pou pou NNP 40436 7609 3 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 7609 4 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7609 5 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 7609 6 / / SYM 40436 7609 7 n n NNP 40436 7609 8 te te NNP 40436 7609 9 ma ma NNP 40436 7609 10 / / SYM 40436 7609 11 lista lista NNP 40436 7609 12 . . . 40436 7609 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7610 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7610 2 is be VBZ 40436 7610 3 not not RB 40436 7610 4 unimportant unimportant JJ 40436 7610 5 to to TO 40436 7610 6 notice notice VB 40436 7610 7 such such JJ 40436 7610 8 declarations declaration NNS 40436 7610 9 as as IN 40436 7610 10 this this DT 40436 7610 11 , , , 40436 7610 12 put put VBN 40436 7610 13 by by IN 40436 7610 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7610 15 into into IN 40436 7610 16 the the DT 40436 7610 17 mouth mouth NN 40436 7610 18 of of IN 40436 7610 19 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7610 20 . . . 40436 7611 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 7611 2 tend tend VBP 40436 7611 3 to to TO 40436 7611 4 show show VB 40436 7611 5 that that IN 40436 7611 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7611 7 did do VBD 40436 7611 8 not not RB 40436 7611 9 seek seek VB 40436 7611 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7611 11 as as RB 40436 7611 12 many many JJ 40436 7611 13 of of IN 40436 7611 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7611 15 commentators commentator NNS 40436 7611 16 do do VBP 40436 7611 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7611 18 to to TO 40436 7611 19 depict depict VB 40436 7611 20 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7611 21 as as IN 40436 7611 22 a a DT 40436 7611 23 corruptor corruptor NN 40436 7611 24 of of IN 40436 7611 25 the the DT 40436 7611 26 public public JJ 40436 7611 27 mind mind NN 40436 7611 28 . . . 40436 7611 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7612 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7612 2 Side side NN 40436 7612 3 - - HYPH 40436 7612 4 note note NN 40436 7612 5 : : : 40436 7612 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7612 7 argues argue VBZ 40436 7612 8 to to TO 40436 7612 9 prove prove VB 40436 7612 10 that that DT 40436 7612 11 courage courage NN 40436 7612 12 consists consist VBZ 40436 7612 13 in in IN 40436 7612 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7612 15 or or CC 40436 7612 16 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7612 17 . . . 40436 7613 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7613 2 does do VBZ 40436 7613 3 not not RB 40436 7613 4 admit admit VB 40436 7613 5 this this DT 40436 7613 6 . . . 40436 7614 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7614 2 changes change VBZ 40436 7614 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7614 4 attack attack NN 40436 7614 5 . . . 40436 7614 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7615 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7615 2 then then RB 40436 7615 3 shows show VBZ 40436 7615 4 that that IN 40436 7615 5 the the DT 40436 7615 6 courageous courageous JJ 40436 7615 7 men man NNS 40436 7615 8 are be VBP 40436 7615 9 confident confident JJ 40436 7615 10 men man NNS 40436 7615 11 , , , 40436 7615 12 forward forward RB 40436 7615 13 in in IN 40436 7615 14 dashing dash VBG 40436 7615 15 at at IN 40436 7615 16 dangers danger NNS 40436 7615 17 , , , 40436 7615 18 which which WDT 40436 7615 19 people people NNS 40436 7615 20 in in IN 40436 7615 21 general general JJ 40436 7615 22 will will MD 40436 7615 23 not not RB 40436 7615 24 affront affront VB 40436 7615 25 : : : 40436 7615 26 that that IN 40436 7615 27 men man NNS 40436 7615 28 who who WP 40436 7615 29 dive dive VBP 40436 7615 30 with with IN 40436 7615 31 confidence confidence NN 40436 7615 32 into into IN 40436 7615 33 the the DT 40436 7615 34 water water NN 40436 7615 35 , , , 40436 7615 36 are be VBP 40436 7615 37 those those DT 40436 7615 38 who who WP 40436 7615 39 know know VBP 40436 7615 40 how how WRB 40436 7615 41 to to TO 40436 7615 42 swim swim VB 40436 7615 43 ; ; : 40436 7615 44 men man NNS 40436 7615 45 who who WP 40436 7615 46 go go VBP 40436 7615 47 into into IN 40436 7615 48 battle battle NN 40436 7615 49 with with IN 40436 7615 50 confidence confidence NN 40436 7615 51 as as IN 40436 7615 52 horse horse NN 40436 7615 53 - - HYPH 40436 7615 54 soldiers soldier NNS 40436 7615 55 or or CC 40436 7615 56 light light NN 40436 7615 57 infantry infantry NN 40436 7615 58 , , , 40436 7615 59 are be VBP 40436 7615 60 those those DT 40436 7615 61 who who WP 40436 7615 62 understand understand VBP 40436 7615 63 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7615 64 profession profession NN 40436 7615 65 as as IN 40436 7615 66 such such JJ 40436 7615 67 . . . 40436 7616 1 If if IN 40436 7616 2 any any DT 40436 7616 3 men man NNS 40436 7616 4 embark embark VBP 40436 7616 5 in in IN 40436 7616 6 these these DT 40436 7616 7 dangers danger NNS 40436 7616 8 , , , 40436 7616 9 without without IN 40436 7616 10 such such JJ 40436 7616 11 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 7616 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7616 13 , , , 40436 7616 14 do do VBP 40436 7616 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7616 16 consider consider VB 40436 7616 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7616 18 men man NNS 40436 7616 19 of of IN 40436 7616 20 courage courage NN 40436 7616 21 ? ? . 40436 7617 1 Not not RB 40436 7617 2 at at RB 40436 7617 3 all all RB 40436 7617 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7617 5 says say VBZ 40436 7617 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7617 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7617 8 , , , 40436 7617 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7617 10 are be VBP 40436 7617 11 madmen madman NNS 40436 7617 12 : : : 40436 7617 13 courage courage NN 40436 7617 14 would would MD 40436 7617 15 be be VB 40436 7617 16 a a DT 40436 7617 17 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 7617 18 thing thing NN 40436 7617 19 , , , 40436 7617 20 if if IN 40436 7617 21 _ _ NNP 40436 7617 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7617 23 _ _ NNP 40436 7617 24 were be VBD 40436 7617 25 reckoned reckon VBN 40436 7617 26 courageous courageous JJ 40436 7617 27 . . . 40436 7618 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7618 2 96 96 CD 40436 7618 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7618 4 Then then RB 40436 7618 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7618 6 replies reply VBZ 40436 7618 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7618 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7618 9 upon upon IN 40436 7618 10 this this DT 40436 7618 11 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 7618 12 , , , 40436 7618 13 those those DT 40436 7618 14 who who WP 40436 7618 15 face face VBP 40436 7618 16 dangers danger NNS 40436 7618 17 confidently confidently RB 40436 7618 18 , , , 40436 7618 19 with with IN 40436 7618 20 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 7618 21 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7618 22 , , , 40436 7618 23 are be VBP 40436 7618 24 courageous courageous JJ 40436 7618 25 : : : 40436 7618 26 those those DT 40436 7618 27 who who WP 40436 7618 28 do do VBP 40436 7618 29 so so RB 40436 7618 30 without without IN 40436 7618 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7618 32 , , , 40436 7618 33 are be VBP 40436 7618 34 madmen madman NNS 40436 7618 35 . . . 40436 7619 1 Courage courage NN 40436 7619 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 7619 3 must must MD 40436 7619 4 consist consist VB 40436 7619 5 in in IN 40436 7619 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7619 7 or or CC 40436 7619 8 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7619 9 ? ? . 40436 7620 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7620 2 97 97 CD 40436 7620 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7620 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7620 5 declines decline VBZ 40436 7620 6 to to TO 40436 7620 7 admit admit VB 40436 7620 8 this this DT 40436 7620 9 , , , 40436 7620 10 drawing draw VBG 40436 7620 11 a a DT 40436 7620 12 distinction distinction NN 40436 7620 13 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 7620 14 confused:[98 confused:[98 '' 40436 7620 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7620 16 upon upon IN 40436 7620 17 which which WDT 40436 7620 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7620 19 approaches approach VBZ 40436 7620 20 the the DT 40436 7620 21 same same JJ 40436 7620 22 argument argument NN 40436 7620 23 from from IN 40436 7620 24 a a DT 40436 7620 25 different different JJ 40436 7620 26 point point NN 40436 7620 27 . . . 40436 7621 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7621 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7621 3 96 96 CD 40436 7621 4 : : : 40436 7621 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7621 6 , , , 40436 7621 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7621 8 . . . 40436 7622 1 p. p. NN 40436 7622 2 350 350 CD 40436 7622 3 B. b. NN 40436 7623 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7623 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7623 3 : : : 40436 7623 4 Ai)schro\n ai)schro\n VB 40436 7623 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7623 6 / / SYM 40436 7623 7 nt nt RB 40436 7623 8 ' ' '' 40436 7623 9 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 7623 10 , , , 40436 7623 11 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 7623 12 , , , 40436 7623 13 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 7623 14 , , , 40436 7623 15 ê ê NNP 40436 7623 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7623 17 a)ndrei a)ndrei NNP 40436 7623 18 / / SYM 40436 7623 19 a a LS 40436 7623 20 ; ; : 40436 7623 21 e)pei\ e)pei\ `` 40436 7623 22 ou(=toi/ ou(=toi/ NNP 40436 7623 23 ge ge NNP 40436 7623 24 maino maino NNP 40436 7623 25 / / SYM 40436 7623 26 menoi/ menoi/ NNP 40436 7623 27 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 7623 28 . . . 40436 7623 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7623 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7624 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7624 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7624 3 97 97 CD 40436 7624 4 : : : 40436 7624 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7624 6 , , , 40436 7624 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7624 8 . . . 40436 7625 1 p. p. NN 40436 7625 2 350 350 CD 40436 7625 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7625 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7625 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7625 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7625 7 98 98 CD 40436 7625 8 : : : 40436 7625 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7625 10 , , , 40436 7625 11 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7625 12 . . . 40436 7626 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7626 2 . . . 40436 7627 1 350 350 CD 40436 7627 2 - - SYM 40436 7627 3 351 351 CD 40436 7627 4 . . . 40436 7627 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7628 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7628 2 Side side NN 40436 7628 3 - - HYPH 40436 7628 4 note note NN 40436 7628 5 : : : 40436 7628 6 Identity identity NN 40436 7628 7 of of IN 40436 7628 8 the the DT 40436 7628 9 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 7628 10 with with IN 40436 7628 11 the the DT 40436 7628 12 good good JJ 40436 7628 13 -- -- : 40436 7628 14 of of IN 40436 7628 15 the the DT 40436 7628 16 painful painful JJ 40436 7628 17 with with IN 40436 7628 18 the the DT 40436 7628 19 evil evil NN 40436 7628 20 . . . 40436 7629 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7629 2 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 7629 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7629 4 . . . 40436 7630 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7630 2 denies deny VBZ 40436 7630 3 . . . 40436 7631 1 Debate debate NN 40436 7631 2 . . . 40436 7631 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7632 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7632 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 7632 3 say say VBP 40436 7632 4 that that IN 40436 7632 5 some some DT 40436 7632 6 men man NNS 40436 7632 7 live live VBP 40436 7632 8 well well RB 40436 7632 9 , , , 40436 7632 10 others other NNS 40436 7632 11 badly badly RB 40436 7632 12 . . . 40436 7633 1 Do do VBP 40436 7633 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7633 3 think think VB 40436 7633 4 that that IN 40436 7633 5 a a DT 40436 7633 6 man man NN 40436 7633 7 lives live VBZ 40436 7633 8 well well RB 40436 7633 9 if if IN 40436 7633 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7633 11 lives live VBZ 40436 7633 12 in in IN 40436 7633 13 pain pain NN 40436 7633 14 and and CC 40436 7633 15 distress distress NN 40436 7633 16 ? ? . 40436 7634 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7634 2 Prot._--No Prot._--No NNP 40436 7634 3 . . . 40436 7635 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7635 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 7635 3 if if IN 40436 7635 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7635 5 passes pass VBZ 40436 7635 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7635 7 life life NN 40436 7635 8 pleasurably pleasurably RB 40436 7635 9 until until IN 40436 7635 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7635 11 close close NN 40436 7635 12 , , , 40436 7635 13 does do VBZ 40436 7635 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7635 15 not not RB 40436 7635 16 then then RB 40436 7635 17 appear appear VB 40436 7635 18 to to IN 40436 7635 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7635 20 to to TO 40436 7635 21 have have VB 40436 7635 22 lived live VBN 40436 7635 23 well well RB 40436 7635 24 ? ? . 40436 7636 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7636 2 Prot._--I Prot._--I NNS 40436 7636 3 think think VBP 40436 7636 4 so so RB 40436 7636 5 . . . 40436 7637 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7637 2 Sokr._--To Sokr._--To NNP 40436 7637 3 live live VBP 40436 7637 4 pleasurably pleasurably RB 40436 7637 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 7637 6 is be VBZ 40436 7637 7 good good JJ 40436 7637 8 : : : 40436 7637 9 to to TO 40436 7637 10 live live VB 40436 7637 11 disagreeably disagreeably RB 40436 7637 12 is be VBZ 40436 7637 13 evil evil JJ 40436 7637 14 . . . 40436 7638 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7638 2 Prot._--Yes Prot._--Yes NNP 40436 7638 3 : : : 40436 7638 4 at at RB 40436 7638 5 least least RBS 40436 7638 6 provided provide VBN 40436 7638 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7638 8 lives live VBZ 40436 7638 9 taking take VBG 40436 7638 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7638 11 in in IN 40436 7638 12 fine fine JJ 40436 7638 13 or or CC 40436 7638 14 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7638 15 things thing NNS 40436 7638 16 . . . 40436 7639 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7639 2 99 99 CD 40436 7639 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7639 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7639 5 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 7639 6 ! ! . 40436 7640 1 do do VBP 40436 7640 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7640 3 concur concur VB 40436 7640 4 with with IN 40436 7640 5 the the DT 40436 7640 6 generality generality NN 40436 7640 7 of of IN 40436 7640 8 people people NNS 40436 7640 9 in in IN 40436 7640 10 calling call VBG 40436 7640 11 some some DT 40436 7640 12 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7640 13 things thing NNS 40436 7640 14 evil evil JJ 40436 7640 15 , , , 40436 7640 16 and and CC 40436 7640 17 some some DT 40436 7640 18 painful painful JJ 40436 7640 19 things thing NNS 40436 7640 20 good good JJ 40436 7640 21 ? ? . 40436 7641 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7641 2 Prot._--That Prot._--That NNP 40436 7641 3 is be VBZ 40436 7641 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7641 5 opinion opinion NN 40436 7641 6 . . . 40436 7642 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7642 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 7642 3 are be VBP 40436 7642 4 not not RB 40436 7642 5 all all DT 40436 7642 6 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7642 7 things thing NNS 40436 7642 8 , , , 40436 7642 9 so so RB 40436 7642 10 far far RB 40436 7642 11 forth forth RB 40436 7642 12 as as IN 40436 7642 13 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7642 14 , , , 40436 7642 15 to to IN 40436 7642 16 that that DT 40436 7642 17 extent extent NN 40436 7642 18 good good JJ 40436 7642 19 , , , 40436 7642 20 unless unless IN 40436 7642 21 some some DT 40436 7642 22 consequences consequence NNS 40436 7642 23 of of IN 40436 7642 24 a a DT 40436 7642 25 different different JJ 40436 7642 26 sort sort NN 40436 7642 27 result result NN 40436 7642 28 from from IN 40436 7642 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7642 30 ? ? . 40436 7643 1 And and CC 40436 7643 2 again again RB 40436 7643 3 , , , 40436 7643 4 subject subject JJ 40436 7643 5 to to IN 40436 7643 6 the the DT 40436 7643 7 like like JJ 40436 7643 8 limitation limitation NN 40436 7643 9 , , , 40436 7643 10 are be VBP 40436 7643 11 not not RB 40436 7643 12 all all DT 40436 7643 13 painful painful JJ 40436 7643 14 things thing NNS 40436 7643 15 evil evil JJ 40436 7643 16 , , , 40436 7643 17 so so RB 40436 7643 18 far far RB 40436 7643 19 forth forth RB 40436 7643 20 as as IN 40436 7643 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7643 22 are be VBP 40436 7643 23 painful painful JJ 40436 7643 24 ? ? . 40436 7644 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7644 2 Prot._--To Prot._--To NNP 40436 7644 3 that that DT 40436 7644 4 question question NN 40436 7644 5 , , , 40436 7644 6 absolutely absolutely RB 40436 7644 7 as as IN 40436 7644 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7644 9 put put VBP 40436 7644 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7644 11 , , , 40436 7644 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7644 13 do do VBP 40436 7644 14 not not RB 40436 7644 15 know know VB 40436 7644 16 whether whether IN 40436 7644 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7644 18 can can MD 40436 7644 19 reply reply VB 40436 7644 20 affirmatively affirmatively RB 40436 7644 21 -- -- : 40436 7644 22 that that IN 40436 7644 23 all all DT 40436 7644 24 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7644 25 things thing NNS 40436 7644 26 are be VBP 40436 7644 27 good good JJ 40436 7644 28 , , , 40436 7644 29 and and CC 40436 7644 30 all all DT 40436 7644 31 painful painful JJ 40436 7644 32 things thing NNS 40436 7644 33 evil evil JJ 40436 7644 34 . . . 40436 7645 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7645 2 think think VBP 40436 7645 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7645 4 safer safe JJR 40436 7645 5 -- -- : 40436 7645 6 with with IN 40436 7645 7 reference reference NN 40436 7645 8 not not RB 40436 7645 9 merely merely RB 40436 7645 10 to to IN 40436 7645 11 the the DT 40436 7645 12 present present JJ 40436 7645 13 answer answer NN 40436 7645 14 , , , 40436 7645 15 but but CC 40436 7645 16 to to IN 40436 7645 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7645 18 manner manner NN 40436 7645 19 of of IN 40436 7645 20 life life NN 40436 7645 21 generally generally RB 40436 7645 22 -- -- : 40436 7645 23 to to TO 40436 7645 24 say say VB 40436 7645 25 , , , 40436 7645 26 that that IN 40436 7645 27 there there EX 40436 7645 28 are be VBP 40436 7645 29 some some DT 40436 7645 30 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7645 31 things thing NNS 40436 7645 32 which which WDT 40436 7645 33 are be VBP 40436 7645 34 good good JJ 40436 7645 35 , , , 40436 7645 36 others other NNS 40436 7645 37 which which WDT 40436 7645 38 are be VBP 40436 7645 39 not not RB 40436 7645 40 good good JJ 40436 7645 41 -- -- : 40436 7645 42 some some DT 40436 7645 43 painful painful JJ 40436 7645 44 things thing NNS 40436 7645 45 which which WDT 40436 7645 46 are be VBP 40436 7645 47 evil evil JJ 40436 7645 48 , , , 40436 7645 49 others other NNS 40436 7645 50 which which WDT 40436 7645 51 are be VBP 40436 7645 52 not not RB 40436 7645 53 evil evil JJ 40436 7645 54 : : : 40436 7645 55 again again RB 40436 7645 56 , , , 40436 7645 57 some some DT 40436 7645 58 which which WDT 40436 7645 59 are be VBP 40436 7645 60 neither neither DT 40436 7645 61 , , , 40436 7645 62 neither neither CC 40436 7645 63 good good JJ 40436 7645 64 nor nor CC 40436 7645 65 evil evil JJ 40436 7645 66 . . . 40436 7646 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7646 2 100 100 CD 40436 7646 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7646 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7646 5 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 7646 6 call call VB 40436 7646 7 those those DT 40436 7646 8 things thing NNS 40436 7646 9 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7646 10 , , , 40436 7646 11 which which WDT 40436 7646 12 either either DT 40436 7646 13 partake partake NN 40436 7646 14 of of IN 40436 7646 15 the the DT 40436 7646 16 nature nature NN 40436 7646 17 of of IN 40436 7646 18 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7646 19 , , , 40436 7646 20 or or CC 40436 7646 21 cause cause VB 40436 7646 22 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7646 23 ? ? . 40436 7647 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7647 2 Prot._--Unquestionably Prot._--Unquestionably NNP 40436 7647 3 . . . 40436 7648 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7648 2 Sokr._--When Sokr._--When NNP 40436 7648 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7648 4 ask ask VBP 40436 7648 5 whether whether IN 40436 7648 6 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7648 7 things thing NNS 40436 7648 8 are be VBP 40436 7648 9 not not RB 40436 7648 10 good good JJ 40436 7648 11 , , , 40436 7648 12 in in IN 40436 7648 13 so so RB 40436 7648 14 far far RB 40436 7648 15 forth forth RB 40436 7648 16 as as IN 40436 7648 17 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7648 18 -- -- : 40436 7648 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7648 20 ask ask VBP 40436 7648 21 in in IN 40436 7648 22 other other JJ 40436 7648 23 words word NNS 40436 7648 24 , , , 40436 7648 25 whether whether IN 40436 7648 26 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7648 27 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7648 28 be be VBP 40436 7648 29 not not RB 40436 7648 30 good good JJ 40436 7648 31 ? ? . 40436 7649 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7649 2 Prot._--As Prot._--As NNP 40436 7649 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7649 4 observed observe VBD 40436 7649 5 before before RB 40436 7649 6 , , , 40436 7649 7 Sokrates,[101 sokrates,[101 CD 40436 7649 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7649 9 let let VB 40436 7649 10 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7649 11 examine examine VB 40436 7649 12 the the DT 40436 7649 13 question question NN 40436 7649 14 on on IN 40436 7649 15 each each DT 40436 7649 16 side side NN 40436 7649 17 , , , 40436 7649 18 to to TO 40436 7649 19 see see VB 40436 7649 20 whether whether IN 40436 7649 21 the the DT 40436 7649 22 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 7649 23 and and CC 40436 7649 24 the the DT 40436 7649 25 good good JJ 40436 7649 26 be be VB 40436 7649 27 really really RB 40436 7649 28 the the DT 40436 7649 29 same same JJ 40436 7649 30 . . . 40436 7650 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7650 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7650 3 99 99 CD 40436 7650 4 : : : 40436 7650 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 7650 6 . . . 40436 7651 1 Prot Prot NNS 40436 7651 2 . . . 40436 7652 1 p. p. NN 40436 7652 2 351 351 CD 40436 7652 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7652 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7652 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7652 6 : : : 40436 7652 7 To\ To\ NNP 40436 7652 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7652 9 a)/ra a)/ra UH 40436 7652 10 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 7652 11 / / SYM 40436 7652 12 ôs ôs NNP 40436 7652 13 zê zê NN 40436 7652 14 = = SYM 40436 7652 15 n n NNP 40436 7652 16 , , , 40436 7652 17 a)gatho a)gatho ADD 40436 7652 18 / / SYM 40436 7652 19 n n NN 40436 7652 20 , , , 40436 7652 21 to\ to\ NN 40436 7652 22 d d NNP 40436 7652 23 ' ' '' 40436 7652 24 a)êdô a)êdô NNP 40436 7652 25 = = SYM 40436 7652 26 s s NNP 40436 7652 27 , , , 40436 7652 28 kako kako NNP 40436 7652 29 / / SYM 40436 7652 30 n n NNP 40436 7652 31 ? ? . 40436 7653 1 Ei)/per Ei)/per NNP 40436 7653 2 toi toi NNP 40436 7653 3 = = SYM 40436 7653 4 s s NNP 40436 7653 5 kaloi kaloi NNP 40436 7653 6 = = SYM 40436 7653 7 s s NNP 40436 7653 8 g g NNP 40436 7653 9 ' ' '' 40436 7653 10 , , , 40436 7653 11 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 7653 12 , , , 40436 7653 13 zô/|ê zô/|ê NNP 40436 7653 14 ê(do ê(do NNP 40436 7653 15 / / SYM 40436 7653 16 menos menos NNP 40436 7653 17 . . . 40436 7653 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7653 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7654 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7654 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7654 3 100 100 CD 40436 7654 4 : : : 40436 7654 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7654 6 , , , 40436 7654 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7654 8 . . . 40436 7655 1 p. p. NN 40436 7655 2 351 351 CD 40436 7655 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7655 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7655 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7655 6 : : : 40436 7655 7 a)lla/ a)lla/ `` 40436 7655 8 moi moi NNP 40436 7655 9 dokei= dokei= NNP 40436 7655 10 ou ou NNP 40436 7655 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7655 12 mo mo NNP 40436 7655 13 / / SYM 40436 7655 14 non non AFX 40436 7655 15 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7655 16 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7655 17 nu nu NNP 40436 7655 18 = = SYM 40436 7655 19 n n CC 40436 7655 20 a)po a)po NNP 40436 7655 21 / / SYM 40436 7655 22 krisin krisin NNP 40436 7655 23 e)moi\ e)moi\ ADD 40436 7655 24 a)sphale a)sphale NNP 40436 7655 25 / / SYM 40436 7655 26 steron steron NNP 40436 7655 27 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 7655 28 a)pokri a)pokri NNS 40436 7655 29 / / SYM 40436 7655 30 nasthtai nasthtai RB 40436 7655 31 , , , 40436 7655 32 _ _ NNP 40436 7655 33 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 7655 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7655 35 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7655 36 pa pa NNP 40436 7655 37 / / SYM 40436 7655 38 nta nta NNP 40436 7655 39 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7655 40 a)/llon a)/llon NN 40436 7655 41 bi bi NNP 40436 7655 42 / / SYM 40436 7655 43 on on IN 40436 7655 44 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7655 45 e)mo e)mo NNP 40436 7655 46 / / SYM 40436 7655 47 n n CC 40436 7655 48 _ _ NNP 40436 7655 49 , , , 40436 7655 50 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 7655 51 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 7655 52 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7655 53 a)\ a)\ NNP 40436 7655 54 tô tô NNP 40436 7655 55 = = SYM 40436 7655 56 n n CC 40436 7655 57 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 7655 58 / / SYM 40436 7655 59 ôn ôn NNP 40436 7655 60 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 7655 61 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 7655 62 a)gatha/ a)gatha/ CD 40436 7655 63 , , , 40436 7655 64 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 7655 65 d d NNP 40436 7655 66 ' ' '' 40436 7655 67 au)= au)= : 40436 7655 68 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7655 69 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 7655 70 tô tô NNP 40436 7655 71 = = SYM 40436 7655 72 n n NNP 40436 7655 73 a)niarô a)niarô CD 40436 7655 74 = = SYM 40436 7655 75 n n NNP 40436 7655 76 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 7655 77 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 7655 78 kaka/ kaka/ NNP 40436 7655 79 , , , 40436 7655 80 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 7655 81 d d NNP 40436 7655 82 ' ' '' 40436 7655 83 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 7655 84 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 7655 85 , , , 40436 7655 86 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7655 87 tri tri NNP 40436 7655 88 / / SYM 40436 7655 89 ton ton NN 40436 7655 90 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 7655 91 ou)de ou)de NNP 40436 7655 92 / / SYM 40436 7655 93 tera tera NN 40436 7655 94 , , , 40436 7655 95 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 7655 96 kaka\ kaka\ NNP 40436 7655 97 ou)/t ou)/t NNP 40436 7655 98 ' ' POS 40436 7655 99 a)gatha/. a)gatha/. CD 40436 7655 100 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7656 1 These these DT 40436 7656 2 words word NNS 40436 7656 3 strengthen strengthen VBP 40436 7656 4 farther far RBR 40436 7656 5 what what WP 40436 7656 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7656 7 remarked remark VBD 40436 7656 8 in in IN 40436 7656 9 a a DT 40436 7656 10 recent recent JJ 40436 7656 11 note note NN 40436 7656 12 , , , 40436 7656 13 about about IN 40436 7656 14 the the DT 40436 7656 15 character character NN 40436 7656 16 which which WDT 40436 7656 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7656 18 wished wish VBD 40436 7656 19 to to TO 40436 7656 20 depict depict VB 40436 7656 21 in in IN 40436 7656 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7656 23 , , , 40436 7656 24 so so RB 40436 7656 25 different different JJ 40436 7656 26 from from IN 40436 7656 27 what what WP 40436 7656 28 is be VBZ 40436 7656 29 imputed impute VBN 40436 7656 30 to to IN 40436 7656 31 that that DT 40436 7656 32 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7656 33 by by IN 40436 7656 34 the the DT 40436 7656 35 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7656 36 commentators commentator NNS 40436 7656 37 . . . 40436 7656 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7657 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7657 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7657 3 101 101 CD 40436 7657 4 : : : 40436 7657 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7657 6 , , , 40436 7657 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7657 8 . . . 40436 7658 1 p. p. NN 40436 7658 2 351 351 CD 40436 7658 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7658 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7658 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7658 6 : : : 40436 7658 7 ô(/sper ô(/sper NN 40436 7658 8 su\ su\ NNP 40436 7658 9 le le NNP 40436 7658 10 / / SYM 40436 7658 11 geis geis NNP 40436 7658 12 , , , 40436 7658 13 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 7658 14 / / SYM 40436 7658 15 stote stote NN 40436 7658 16 , , , 40436 7658 17 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 7658 18 Sô Sô NNP 40436 7658 19 / / SYM 40436 7658 20 krates krate NNS 40436 7658 21 , , , 40436 7658 22 skopô skopô NNP 40436 7658 23 / / SYM 40436 7658 24 metha metha NNP 40436 7658 25 au)to/. au)to/. NN 40436 7658 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7659 1 This this DT 40436 7659 2 is be VBZ 40436 7659 3 an an DT 40436 7659 4 allusion allusion NN 40436 7659 5 to to IN 40436 7659 6 the the DT 40436 7659 7 words word NNS 40436 7659 8 used use VBN 40436 7659 9 by by IN 40436 7659 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7659 11 not not RB 40436 7659 12 long long RB 40436 7659 13 before,--[Greek before,--[Greek '' 40436 7659 14 : : : 40436 7659 15 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 7659 16 au)to\s au)to\s ADD 40436 7659 17 a)porô= a)porô= NNP 40436 7659 18 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 7659 19 / / SYM 40436 7659 20 stote stote NNP 40436 7659 21 tau tau NNP 40436 7659 22 = = SYM 40436 7659 23 ta ta NNP 40436 7659 24 diaske diaske NNP 40436 7659 25 / / SYM 40436 7659 26 psasthai psasthai NNP 40436 7659 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7659 28 , , , 40436 7659 29 p. p. NN 40436 7659 30 348 348 CD 40436 7659 31 C. c. NN 40436 7659 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7659 33 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7659 34 Side side NN 40436 7659 35 - - HYPH 40436 7659 36 note note NN 40436 7659 37 : : : 40436 7659 38 Enquiry enquiry NN 40436 7659 39 about about IN 40436 7659 40 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7659 41 . . . 40436 7660 1 Is be VBZ 40436 7660 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7660 3 the the DT 40436 7660 4 dominant dominant JJ 40436 7660 5 agency agency NN 40436 7660 6 in in IN 40436 7660 7 the the DT 40436 7660 8 mind mind NN 40436 7660 9 ? ? . 40436 7661 1 Or or CC 40436 7661 2 is be VBZ 40436 7661 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7661 4 overcome overcome VBN 40436 7661 5 frequently frequently RB 40436 7661 6 by by IN 40436 7661 7 other other JJ 40436 7661 8 agencies agency NNS 40436 7661 9 , , , 40436 7661 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7661 11 or or CC 40436 7661 12 pain pain NN 40436 7661 13 ? ? . 40436 7662 1 Both both DT 40436 7662 2 agree agree VBP 40436 7662 3 that that IN 40436 7662 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7662 5 is be VBZ 40436 7662 6 dominant dominant JJ 40436 7662 7 . . . 40436 7662 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7663 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7663 2 Sokr._--Let Sokr._--Let NNP 40436 7663 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7663 4 penetrate penetrate VBP 40436 7663 5 from from IN 40436 7663 6 the the DT 40436 7663 7 surface surface NN 40436 7663 8 to to IN 40436 7663 9 the the DT 40436 7663 10 interior interior NN 40436 7663 11 of of IN 40436 7663 12 the the DT 40436 7663 13 question question NN 40436 7663 14 . . . 40436 7664 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7664 2 102 102 CD 40436 7664 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7664 4 What what WP 40436 7664 5 is be VBZ 40436 7664 6 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7664 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 7664 8 about about IN 40436 7664 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7664 10 ? ? . 40436 7665 1 Do do VBP 40436 7665 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7665 3 share share VB 40436 7665 4 the the DT 40436 7665 5 opinion opinion NN 40436 7665 6 of of IN 40436 7665 7 mankind mankind NN 40436 7665 8 generally generally RB 40436 7665 9 about about IN 40436 7665 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7665 11 , , , 40436 7665 12 as as IN 40436 7665 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7665 14 do do VBP 40436 7665 15 about about IN 40436 7665 16 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7665 17 and and CC 40436 7665 18 pain pain NN 40436 7665 19 ? ? . 40436 7666 1 Mankind mankind NN 40436 7666 2 regard regard VBP 40436 7666 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7666 4 as as IN 40436 7666 5 something something NN 40436 7666 6 neither neither CC 40436 7666 7 strong strong JJ 40436 7666 8 nor nor CC 40436 7666 9 directive directive JJ 40436 7666 10 nor nor CC 40436 7666 11 dominant dominant JJ 40436 7666 12 . . . 40436 7667 1 Often often RB 40436 7667 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7667 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7667 4 say say VBP 40436 7667 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7667 6 , , , 40436 7667 7 when when WRB 40436 7667 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7667 9 is be VBZ 40436 7667 10 in in IN 40436 7667 11 a a DT 40436 7667 12 man man NN 40436 7667 13 , , , 40436 7667 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7667 15 is be VBZ 40436 7667 16 not not RB 40436 7667 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7667 18 which which WDT 40436 7667 19 governs govern VBZ 40436 7667 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7667 21 , , , 40436 7667 22 but but CC 40436 7667 23 something something NN 40436 7667 24 else else RB 40436 7667 25 -- -- : 40436 7667 26 passion passion NN 40436 7667 27 , , , 40436 7667 28 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7667 29 , , , 40436 7667 30 pain pain NN 40436 7667 31 , , , 40436 7667 32 love love NN 40436 7667 33 , , , 40436 7667 34 fear fear NN 40436 7667 35 -- -- : 40436 7667 36 all all DT 40436 7667 37 or or CC 40436 7667 38 any any DT 40436 7667 39 of of IN 40436 7667 40 which which WDT 40436 7667 41 overpower overpower NN 40436 7667 42 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7667 43 , , , 40436 7667 44 and and CC 40436 7667 45 drag drag VB 40436 7667 46 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7667 47 round round JJ 40436 7667 48 about about IN 40436 7667 49 in in IN 40436 7667 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7667 51 train train NN 40436 7667 52 like like IN 40436 7667 53 a a DT 40436 7667 54 slave slave NN 40436 7667 55 . . . 40436 7668 1 Are be VBP 40436 7668 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7668 3 of of IN 40436 7668 4 the the DT 40436 7668 5 common common JJ 40436 7668 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 7668 7 on on IN 40436 7668 8 this this DT 40436 7668 9 point point NN 40436 7668 10 also also RB 40436 7668 11 ? ? . 40436 7669 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7669 2 103 103 CD 40436 7669 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7669 4 Or or CC 40436 7669 5 do do VBP 40436 7669 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7669 7 believe believe VB 40436 7669 8 that that IN 40436 7669 9 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7669 10 is be VBZ 40436 7669 11 an an DT 40436 7669 12 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7669 13 thing thing NN 40436 7669 14 , , , 40436 7669 15 and and CC 40436 7669 16 made make VBN 40436 7669 17 to to TO 40436 7669 18 govern govern VB 40436 7669 19 man man NN 40436 7669 20 : : : 40436 7669 21 and and CC 40436 7669 22 that that IN 40436 7669 23 when when WRB 40436 7669 24 once once RB 40436 7669 25 a a DT 40436 7669 26 man man NN 40436 7669 27 knows know VBZ 40436 7669 28 what what WP 40436 7669 29 good good JJ 40436 7669 30 and and CC 40436 7669 31 evil evil JJ 40436 7669 32 things thing NNS 40436 7669 33 are be VBP 40436 7669 34 , , , 40436 7669 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7669 36 will will MD 40436 7669 37 not not RB 40436 7669 38 be be VB 40436 7669 39 over over RB 40436 7669 40 - - HYPH 40436 7669 41 ruled rule VBN 40436 7669 42 by by IN 40436 7669 43 any any DT 40436 7669 44 other other JJ 40436 7669 45 motive motive NN 40436 7669 46 whatever whatever WDT 40436 7669 47 , , , 40436 7669 48 so so IN 40436 7669 49 as as IN 40436 7669 50 to to TO 40436 7669 51 do do VB 40436 7669 52 other other JJ 40436 7669 53 things thing NNS 40436 7669 54 than than IN 40436 7669 55 what what WP 40436 7669 56 are be VBP 40436 7669 57 enjoined enjoin VBN 40436 7669 58 by by IN 40436 7669 59 such such JJ 40436 7669 60 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7669 61 -- -- : 40436 7669 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7669 63 own own JJ 40436 7669 64 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7669 65 being be VBG 40436 7669 66 a a DT 40436 7669 67 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 7669 68 defence defence NN 40436 7669 69 to to IN 40436 7669 70 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7669 71 ? ? . 40436 7670 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7670 2 104 104 CD 40436 7670 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7670 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7670 5 Prot._--The Prot._--The NNP 40436 7670 6 last last JJ 40436 7670 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 7670 8 is be VBZ 40436 7670 9 what what WP 40436 7670 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7670 11 hold hold VBP 40436 7670 12 . . . 40436 7671 1 To to IN 40436 7671 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7671 3 , , , 40436 7671 4 above above IN 40436 7671 5 all all DT 40436 7671 6 others other NNS 40436 7671 7 , , , 40436 7671 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7671 9 would would MD 40436 7671 10 be be VB 40436 7671 11 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 7671 12 not not RB 40436 7671 13 to to TO 40436 7671 14 proclaim proclaim VB 40436 7671 15 that that IN 40436 7671 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7671 17 or or CC 40436 7671 18 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 7671 19 was be VBD 40436 7671 20 the the DT 40436 7671 21 governing govern VBG 40436 7671 22 element element NN 40436 7671 23 of of IN 40436 7671 24 human human JJ 40436 7671 25 affairs affair NNS 40436 7671 26 . . . 40436 7672 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7672 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7672 3 102 102 CD 40436 7672 4 : : : 40436 7672 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7672 6 , , , 40436 7672 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7672 8 . . . 40436 7673 1 p. p. NN 40436 7673 2 352 352 CD 40436 7673 3 A. a. NN 40436 7673 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7674 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7674 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7674 3 103 103 CD 40436 7674 4 : : : 40436 7674 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7674 6 , , , 40436 7674 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7674 8 . . . 40436 7675 1 p. p. NN 40436 7675 2 352 352 CD 40436 7675 3 B B NNP 40436 7675 4 - - HYPH 40436 7675 5 C. C. NNP 40436 7675 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7675 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7675 8 : : : 40436 7675 9 po po NNP 40436 7675 10 / / SYM 40436 7675 11 teron teron NNP 40436 7675 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7675 13 tou tou NNP 40436 7675 14 = = SYM 40436 7675 15 to/ to/ NN 40436 7675 16 soi soi NN 40436 7675 17 dokei= dokei= NNP 40436 7675 18 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 7675 19 toi toi NNP 40436 7675 20 = = SYM 40436 7675 21 s s NNP 40436 7675 22 polloi polloi NNP 40436 7675 23 = = SYM 40436 7675 24 s s NNP 40436 7675 25 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 7675 26 / / SYM 40436 7675 27 pois pois NNP 40436 7675 28 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 7675 29 a)/llôs a)/llôs NNP 40436 7675 30 ? ? . 40436 7676 1 . . . 40436 7677 1 . . . 40436 7678 1 . . . 40436 7679 1 dianoou dianoou NNP 40436 7679 2 / / SYM 40436 7679 3 menoi menoi NNP 40436 7679 4 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 7679 5 tê tê NNP 40436 7679 6 = = SYM 40436 7679 7 s s NNP 40436 7679 8 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 7679 9 / / SYM 40436 7679 10 mês mês NNP 40436 7679 11 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 7679 12 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 7679 13 a)ndrapo a)ndrapo NNP 40436 7679 14 / / SYM 40436 7679 15 don don NN 40436 7679 16 , , , 40436 7679 17 perielkome perielkome NNP 40436 7679 18 / / SYM 40436 7679 19 nês nês NN 40436 7679 20 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 7679 21 tô tô NNP 40436 7679 22 = = SYM 40436 7679 23 n n CC 40436 7679 24 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 7679 25 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 7679 26 / / SYM 40436 7679 27 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 7679 28 . . . 40436 7679 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7680 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 7680 2 in in IN 40436 7680 3 the the DT 40436 7680 4 Nikomachean Nikomachean NNP 40436 7680 5 Ethics Ethics NNP 40436 7680 6 cites cite VBZ 40436 7680 7 and and CC 40436 7680 8 criticises criticise VBZ 40436 7680 9 the the DT 40436 7680 10 opinion opinion NN 40436 7680 11 of of IN 40436 7680 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7680 13 , , , 40436 7680 14 wherein wherein WRB 40436 7680 15 the the DT 40436 7680 16 latter latter JJ 40436 7680 17 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 7680 18 the the DT 40436 7680 19 irresistible irresistible JJ 40436 7680 20 supremacy supremacy NN 40436 7680 21 of of IN 40436 7680 22 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7680 23 , , , 40436 7680 24 when when WRB 40436 7680 25 really really RB 40436 7680 26 possessed possess VBN 40436 7680 27 , , , 40436 7680 28 over over IN 40436 7680 29 all all DT 40436 7680 30 passions passion NNS 40436 7680 31 and and CC 40436 7680 32 desires desire NNS 40436 7680 33 . . . 40436 7681 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 7681 2 cites cite VBZ 40436 7681 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7681 4 with with IN 40436 7681 5 the the DT 40436 7681 6 express express JJ 40436 7681 7 phraseology phraseology NN 40436 7681 8 and and CC 40436 7681 9 illustration illustration NN 40436 7681 10 contained contain VBN 40436 7681 11 in in IN 40436 7681 12 this this DT 40436 7681 13 passage passage NN 40436 7681 14 of of IN 40436 7681 15 the the DT 40436 7681 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 7681 17 . . . 40436 7682 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7682 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7682 3 : : : 40436 7682 4 E)pista E)pista NNP 40436 7682 5 / / SYM 40436 7682 6 menon menon NNP 40436 7682 7 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7682 8 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 7682 9 ou)/ ou)/ NNP 40436 7682 10 phasi/ phasi/ VBZ 40436 7682 11 tines tin VBZ 40436 7682 12 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 7682 13 / / SYM 40436 7682 14 n n NNP 40436 7682 15 te te NNP 40436 7682 16 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 7682 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7682 18 a)krateu a)krateu , 40436 7682 19 / / SYM 40436 7682 20 esthai esthai NNP 40436 7682 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7682 22 . . . 40436 7683 1 deino\n deino\n ADD 40436 7683 2 ga ga NNP 40436 7683 3 / / SYM 40436 7683 4 r r NNP 40436 7683 5 , , , 40436 7683 6 e)pistê e)pistê CD 40436 7683 7 / / SYM 40436 7683 8 mês mês NNP 40436 7683 9 e)nou e)nou NNP 40436 7683 10 / / SYM 40436 7683 11 sês sês NN 40436 7683 12 , , , 40436 7683 13 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7683 14 ô)/|eto ô)/|eto NNP 40436 7683 15 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 7683 16 / / SYM 40436 7683 17 tês tês NN 40436 7683 18 , , , 40436 7683 19 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 7683 20 ti ti NNP 40436 7683 21 kratei kratei NNP 40436 7683 22 = = SYM 40436 7683 23 n n NNP 40436 7683 24 , , , 40436 7683 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7683 26 perie perie NNP 40436 7683 27 / / SYM 40436 7683 28 lkein lkein NNP 40436 7683 29 au)tê\n au)tê\n NNP 40436 7683 30 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 7683 31 a)ndra a)ndra NNP 40436 7683 32 / / SYM 40436 7683 33 podon podon NNP 40436 7683 34 . . . 40436 7684 1 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 7684 2 / / SYM 40436 7684 3 tês tês NN 40436 7684 4 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7684 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7684 6 o(/lôs o(/lôs NNP 40436 7684 7 e)ma e)ma JJ 40436 7684 8 / / SYM 40436 7684 9 cheto cheto NN 40436 7684 10 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7684 11 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7684 12 lo lo NNP 40436 7684 13 / / SYM 40436 7684 14 gon gon NNP 40436 7684 15 , , , 40436 7684 16 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7684 17 ou)k ou)k NN 40436 7684 18 ou)/sês ou)/sês NNP 40436 7684 19 a)krasi a)krasi NNP 40436 7684 20 / / SYM 40436 7684 21 as as IN 40436 7684 22 ; ; : 40436 7684 23 ou)the ou)the DT 40436 7684 24 / / SYM 40436 7684 25 na na IN 40436 7684 26 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7684 27 u(polamba u(polamba . 40436 7684 28 / / SYM 40436 7684 29 nonta nonta NNP 40436 7684 30 , , , 40436 7684 31 pra pra NNP 40436 7684 32 / / SYM 40436 7684 33 ttein ttein NNP 40436 7684 34 para\ para\ NNP 40436 7684 35 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7684 36 be be VB 40436 7684 37 / / SYM 40436 7684 38 ltiston ltiston NNP 40436 7684 39 , , , 40436 7684 40 a)lla\ a)lla\ `` 40436 7684 41 di di NNP 40436 7684 42 ' ' `` 40436 7684 43 a)/gnoian a)/gnoian NNP 40436 7684 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7684 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7684 46 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 7684 47 . . . 40436 7685 1 N. N. NNP 40436 7685 2 vii vii NN 40436 7685 3 . . . 40436 7686 1 2 2 CD 40436 7686 2 , , , 40436 7686 3 vii vii NN 40436 7686 4 . . . 40436 7687 1 3 3 CD 40436 7687 2 , , , 40436 7687 3 p. p. NN 40436 7687 4 1145 1145 CD 40436 7687 5 , , , 40436 7687 6 b. b. NNP 40436 7688 1 24 24 CD 40436 7688 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7688 3 . . . 40436 7689 1 The the DT 40436 7689 2 same same JJ 40436 7689 3 metaphor metaphor NN 40436 7689 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7689 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7689 6 : : : 40436 7689 7 perie perie NNP 40436 7689 8 / / SYM 40436 7689 9 lketai lketai NNP 40436 7689 10 e)pistê e)pistê NNPS 40436 7689 11 / / SYM 40436 7689 12 mê mê NN 40436 7689 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7689 14 is be VBZ 40436 7689 15 again again RB 40436 7689 16 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 7689 17 to to IN 40436 7689 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7689 19 by by IN 40436 7689 20 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 7689 21 , , , 40436 7689 22 a a DT 40436 7689 23 little little JJ 40436 7689 24 farther far RBR 40436 7689 25 on on RB 40436 7689 26 in in IN 40436 7689 27 the the DT 40436 7689 28 same same JJ 40436 7689 29 treatise treatise NN 40436 7689 30 , , , 40436 7689 31 p. p. NN 40436 7689 32 1147 1147 CD 40436 7689 33 , , , 40436 7689 34 b. b. NNP 40436 7690 1 15 15 CD 40436 7690 2 . . . 40436 7691 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7691 2 see see VBP 40436 7691 3 from from IN 40436 7691 4 hence hence RB 40436 7691 5 that that IN 40436 7691 6 when when WRB 40436 7691 7 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 7691 8 comments comment VBZ 40436 7691 9 upon upon IN 40436 7691 10 _ _ NNP 40436 7691 11 the the DT 40436 7691 12 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 7691 13 of of IN 40436 7691 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7691 15 _ _ NNP 40436 7691 16 , , , 40436 7691 17 what what WP 40436 7691 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7691 19 here here RB 40436 7691 20 means mean VBZ 40436 7691 21 is be VBZ 40436 7691 22 , , , 40436 7691 23 the the DT 40436 7691 24 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 7691 25 of of IN 40436 7691 26 the the DT 40436 7691 27 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7691 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7691 29 in in IN 40436 7691 30 the the DT 40436 7691 31 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7691 32 ; ; : 40436 7691 33 the the DT 40436 7691 34 citation citation NN 40436 7691 35 of of IN 40436 7691 36 this this DT 40436 7691 37 particular particular JJ 40436 7691 38 metaphor metaphor NN 40436 7691 39 establishes establish VBZ 40436 7691 40 the the DT 40436 7691 41 identity identity NN 40436 7691 42 . . . 40436 7692 1 In in IN 40436 7692 2 another another DT 40436 7692 3 passage passage NN 40436 7692 4 of of IN 40436 7692 5 the the DT 40436 7692 6 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 7692 7 . . . 40436 7693 1 Eth Eth NNP 40436 7693 2 . . NNP 40436 7693 3 , , , 40436 7693 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 7693 5 also also RB 40436 7693 6 cites cite VBZ 40436 7693 7 a a DT 40436 7693 8 fact fact NN 40436 7693 9 respecting respect VBG 40436 7693 10 the the DT 40436 7693 11 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7693 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7693 13 , , , 40436 7693 14 which which WDT 40436 7693 15 fact fact NN 40436 7693 16 is be VBZ 40436 7693 17 mentioned mention VBN 40436 7693 18 in in IN 40436 7693 19 the the DT 40436 7693 20 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 7693 21 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7693 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7693 23 -- -- : 40436 7693 24 respecting respect VBG 40436 7693 25 the the DT 40436 7693 26 manner manner NN 40436 7693 27 in in IN 40436 7693 28 which which WDT 40436 7693 29 that that IN 40436 7693 30 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7693 31 allowed allow VBD 40436 7693 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7693 33 pupils pupil NNS 40436 7693 34 to to TO 40436 7693 35 assess assess VB 40436 7693 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7693 37 own own JJ 40436 7693 38 fee fee NN 40436 7693 39 for for IN 40436 7693 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7693 41 teaching teaching NN 40436 7693 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7693 43 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 7693 44 . . . 40436 7694 1 Nik Nik NNP 40436 7694 2 . . . 40436 7695 1 ix ix IN 40436 7695 2 . . . 40436 7696 1 1 1 CD 40436 7696 2 , , , 40436 7696 3 1164 1164 CD 40436 7696 4 , , , 40436 7696 5 a. a. NN 40436 7697 1 25 25 CD 40436 7697 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7697 3 . . . 40436 7697 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7698 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7698 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7698 3 104 104 CD 40436 7698 4 : : : 40436 7698 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7698 6 , , , 40436 7698 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7698 8 . . . 40436 7699 1 p. p. NN 40436 7699 2 352 352 CD 40436 7699 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7699 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7699 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7699 6 : : : 40436 7699 7 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 7699 8 ' ' '' 40436 7699 9 i(kanê\n i(kanê\n ADD 40436 7699 10 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7699 11 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7699 12 phro phro NN 40436 7699 13 / / SYM 40436 7699 14 nêsin nêsin NNP 40436 7699 15 boêthei boêthei NNP 40436 7699 16 = = SYM 40436 7699 17 n n CC 40436 7699 18 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 7699 19 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 7699 20 / / SYM 40436 7699 21 pô| pô| NNP 40436 7699 22 . . . 40436 7699 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7699 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7700 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7700 2 Side side NN 40436 7700 3 - - HYPH 40436 7700 4 note note NN 40436 7700 5 : : : 40436 7700 6 Mistake mistake NN 40436 7700 7 of of IN 40436 7700 8 supposing suppose VBG 40436 7700 9 that that IN 40436 7700 10 men man NNS 40436 7700 11 act act VBP 40436 7700 12 contrary contrary RB 40436 7700 13 to to IN 40436 7700 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7700 15 . . . 40436 7701 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7701 2 never never RB 40436 7701 3 call call VBP 40436 7701 4 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7701 5 evils evil NNS 40436 7701 6 , , , 40436 7701 7 except except IN 40436 7701 8 when when WRB 40436 7701 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7701 10 entail entail VBP 40436 7701 11 a a DT 40436 7701 12 preponderance preponderance NN 40436 7701 13 of of IN 40436 7701 14 pain pain NN 40436 7701 15 , , , 40436 7701 16 or or CC 40436 7701 17 a a DT 40436 7701 18 disappointment disappointment NN 40436 7701 19 of of IN 40436 7701 20 greater great JJR 40436 7701 21 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7701 22 . . . 40436 7701 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7702 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7702 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 7702 3 speak speak VBP 40436 7702 4 well well RB 40436 7702 5 and and CC 40436 7702 6 truly truly RB 40436 7702 7 . . . 40436 7703 1 But but CC 40436 7703 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7703 3 are be VBP 40436 7703 4 aware aware JJ 40436 7703 5 that that IN 40436 7703 6 most most JJS 40436 7703 7 men man NNS 40436 7703 8 are be VBP 40436 7703 9 of of IN 40436 7703 10 a a DT 40436 7703 11 different different JJ 40436 7703 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 7703 13 . . . 40436 7704 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 7704 2 affirm affirm VBP 40436 7704 3 that that IN 40436 7704 4 many many JJ 40436 7704 5 who who WP 40436 7704 6 know know VBP 40436 7704 7 what what WP 40436 7704 8 is be VBZ 40436 7704 9 best good JJS 40436 7704 10 , , , 40436 7704 11 act act VB 40436 7704 12 against against IN 40436 7704 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7704 14 own own JJ 40436 7704 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7704 16 , , , 40436 7704 17 overcome overcome VBN 40436 7704 18 by by IN 40436 7704 19 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7704 20 or or CC 40436 7704 21 by by IN 40436 7704 22 pain pain NN 40436 7704 23 . . . 40436 7705 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7705 2 Prot._--Most Prot._--Most NNP 40436 7705 3 men man NNS 40436 7705 4 think think VBP 40436 7705 5 so so RB 40436 7705 6 : : : 40436 7705 7 incorrectly incorrectly RB 40436 7705 8 , , , 40436 7705 9 in in IN 40436 7705 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7705 11 judgment judgment NN 40436 7705 12 , , , 40436 7705 13 as as IN 40436 7705 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7705 15 say say VBP 40436 7705 16 many many JJ 40436 7705 17 other other JJ 40436 7705 18 things thing NNS 40436 7705 19 besides besides RB 40436 7705 20 . . . 40436 7706 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7706 2 105 105 CD 40436 7706 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7706 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7706 5 Sokr._--When Sokr._--When NNP 40436 7706 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7706 7 say say VBP 40436 7706 8 that that IN 40436 7706 9 a a DT 40436 7706 10 man man NN 40436 7706 11 , , , 40436 7706 12 being be VBG 40436 7706 13 overcome overcome VBN 40436 7706 14 by by IN 40436 7706 15 food food NN 40436 7706 16 or or CC 40436 7706 17 drink drink NN 40436 7706 18 or or CC 40436 7706 19 other other JJ 40436 7706 20 temptations temptation NNS 40436 7706 21 , , , 40436 7706 22 will will MD 40436 7706 23 do do VB 40436 7706 24 things thing NNS 40436 7706 25 which which WDT 40436 7706 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7706 27 knows know VBZ 40436 7706 28 to to TO 40436 7706 29 be be VB 40436 7706 30 evil evil JJ 40436 7706 31 , , , 40436 7706 32 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7706 33 must must MD 40436 7706 34 ask ask VB 40436 7706 35 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7706 36 , , , 40436 7706 37 On on IN 40436 7706 38 what what WDT 40436 7706 39 ground ground NN 40436 7706 40 do do VBP 40436 7706 41 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7706 42 call call VB 40436 7706 43 these these DT 40436 7706 44 things thing NNS 40436 7706 45 evil evil JJ 40436 7706 46 ? ? . 40436 7707 1 Is be VBZ 40436 7707 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7707 3 because because IN 40436 7707 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7707 5 impart impart VBP 40436 7707 6 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7707 7 at at IN 40436 7707 8 the the DT 40436 7707 9 moment moment NN 40436 7707 10 , , , 40436 7707 11 or or CC 40436 7707 12 because because IN 40436 7707 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7707 14 prepare prepare VBP 40436 7707 15 disease disease NN 40436 7707 16 , , , 40436 7707 17 poverty poverty NN 40436 7707 18 , , , 40436 7707 19 and and CC 40436 7707 20 other other JJ 40436 7707 21 such such JJ 40436 7707 22 things thing NNS 40436 7707 23 , , , 40436 7707 24 for for IN 40436 7707 25 the the DT 40436 7707 26 future future NN 40436 7707 27 ? ? . 40436 7708 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7708 2 106 106 CD 40436 7708 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7708 4 Most Most JJS 40436 7708 5 men man NNS 40436 7708 6 would would MD 40436 7708 7 reply reply VB 40436 7708 8 , , , 40436 7708 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7708 10 think think VBP 40436 7708 11 , , , 40436 7708 12 that that IN 40436 7708 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7708 14 called call VBD 40436 7708 15 these these DT 40436 7708 16 things thing NNS 40436 7708 17 evil evil JJ 40436 7708 18 not not RB 40436 7708 19 on on IN 40436 7708 20 account account NN 40436 7708 21 of of IN 40436 7708 22 the the DT 40436 7708 23 present present JJ 40436 7708 24 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7708 25 which which WDT 40436 7708 26 the the DT 40436 7708 27 things thing NNS 40436 7708 28 produced produce VBN 40436 7708 29 , , , 40436 7708 30 but but CC 40436 7708 31 on on IN 40436 7708 32 account account NN 40436 7708 33 of of IN 40436 7708 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7708 35 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 7708 36 consequences consequence NNS 40436 7708 37 -- -- : 40436 7708 38 poverty poverty NN 40436 7708 39 and and CC 40436 7708 40 disease disease NN 40436 7708 41 being be VBG 40436 7708 42 both both DT 40436 7708 43 of of IN 40436 7708 44 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7708 45 distressing distress VBG 40436 7708 46 ? ? . 40436 7709 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7709 2 Prot._--Most Prot._--Most NNP 40436 7709 3 men man NNS 40436 7709 4 would would MD 40436 7709 5 say say VB 40436 7709 6 this this DT 40436 7709 7 . . . 40436 7710 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7710 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 7710 3 would would MD 40436 7710 4 be be VB 40436 7710 5 admitted admit VBN 40436 7710 6 then then RB 40436 7710 7 that that IN 40436 7710 8 these these DT 40436 7710 9 things thing NNS 40436 7710 10 were be VBD 40436 7710 11 evil evil JJ 40436 7710 12 for for IN 40436 7710 13 no no DT 40436 7710 14 other other JJ 40436 7710 15 reason reason NN 40436 7710 16 , , , 40436 7710 17 than than IN 40436 7710 18 because because IN 40436 7710 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7710 20 ended end VBD 40436 7710 21 in in IN 40436 7710 22 pain pain NN 40436 7710 23 and and CC 40436 7710 24 in in IN 40436 7710 25 privation privation NN 40436 7710 26 of of IN 40436 7710 27 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7710 28 . . . 40436 7711 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7711 2 107 107 CD 40436 7711 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7711 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7711 5 Prot._--Certainly Prot._--Certainly NNP 40436 7711 6 . . . 40436 7712 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7712 2 Sokr._--Again Sokr._--Again NNP 40436 7712 3 , , , 40436 7712 4 when when WRB 40436 7712 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7712 6 is be VBZ 40436 7712 7 said say VBN 40436 7712 8 that that IN 40436 7712 9 some some DT 40436 7712 10 good good JJ 40436 7712 11 things thing NNS 40436 7712 12 are be VBP 40436 7712 13 painful painful JJ 40436 7712 14 , , , 40436 7712 15 such such JJ 40436 7712 16 things thing NNS 40436 7712 17 are be VBP 40436 7712 18 meant mean VBN 40436 7712 19 as as IN 40436 7712 20 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 7712 21 exercises exercise NNS 40436 7712 22 , , , 40436 7712 23 military military JJ 40436 7712 24 expeditions expedition NNS 40436 7712 25 , , , 40436 7712 26 medical medical JJ 40436 7712 27 treatment treatment NN 40436 7712 28 . . . 40436 7713 1 Now now RB 40436 7713 2 no no DT 40436 7713 3 one one NN 40436 7713 4 will will MD 40436 7713 5 say say VB 40436 7713 6 that that IN 40436 7713 7 these these DT 40436 7713 8 things thing NNS 40436 7713 9 are be VBP 40436 7713 10 good good JJ 40436 7713 11 because because IN 40436 7713 12 of of IN 40436 7713 13 the the DT 40436 7713 14 immediate immediate JJ 40436 7713 15 suffering suffering NN 40436 7713 16 which which WDT 40436 7713 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7713 18 occasion occasion VBP 40436 7713 19 , , , 40436 7713 20 but but CC 40436 7713 21 because because IN 40436 7713 22 of of IN 40436 7713 23 the the DT 40436 7713 24 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 7713 25 results result NNS 40436 7713 26 of of IN 40436 7713 27 health health NN 40436 7713 28 , , , 40436 7713 29 wealth wealth NN 40436 7713 30 , , , 40436 7713 31 and and CC 40436 7713 32 security security NN 40436 7713 33 , , , 40436 7713 34 which which WDT 40436 7713 35 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7713 36 obtain obtain VBP 40436 7713 37 by by IN 40436 7713 38 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7713 39 . . . 40436 7714 1 Thus thus RB 40436 7714 2 , , , 40436 7714 3 these these DT 40436 7714 4 also also RB 40436 7714 5 are be VBP 40436 7714 6 good good JJ 40436 7714 7 for for IN 40436 7714 8 no no DT 40436 7714 9 other other JJ 40436 7714 10 reason reason NN 40436 7714 11 , , , 40436 7714 12 than than IN 40436 7714 13 because because IN 40436 7714 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7714 15 end end VBP 40436 7714 16 in in IN 40436 7714 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7714 18 , , , 40436 7714 19 or or CC 40436 7714 20 in in IN 40436 7714 21 relief relief NN 40436 7714 22 or or CC 40436 7714 23 prevention prevention NN 40436 7714 24 of of IN 40436 7714 25 pain pain NN 40436 7714 26 . . . 40436 7715 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7715 2 108 108 CD 40436 7715 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7715 4 Or or CC 40436 7715 5 can can MD 40436 7715 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7715 7 indicate indicate VB 40436 7715 8 any any DT 40436 7715 9 other other JJ 40436 7715 10 end end NN 40436 7715 11 , , , 40436 7715 12 to to IN 40436 7715 13 which which WDT 40436 7715 14 men man NNS 40436 7715 15 look look VB 40436 7715 16 when when WRB 40436 7715 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7715 18 call call VBP 40436 7715 19 these these DT 40436 7715 20 matters matter NNS 40436 7715 21 evil evil JJ 40436 7715 22 ? ? . 40436 7716 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7716 2 Prot._--No prot._--no JJ 40436 7716 3 other other JJ 40436 7716 4 end end NN 40436 7716 5 can can MD 40436 7716 6 be be VB 40436 7716 7 indicated indicate VBN 40436 7716 8 . . . 40436 7717 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7717 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7717 3 105 105 CD 40436 7717 4 : : : 40436 7717 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7717 6 , , , 40436 7717 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7717 8 . . . 40436 7718 1 pp pp NNP 40436 7718 2 . . . 40436 7719 1 352 352 CD 40436 7719 2 - - SYM 40436 7719 3 353 353 CD 40436 7719 4 . . . 40436 7719 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7720 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7720 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7720 3 106 106 CD 40436 7720 4 : : : 40436 7720 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7720 6 , , , 40436 7720 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7720 8 . . . 40436 7721 1 p. p. NN 40436 7721 2 353 353 CD 40436 7721 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7721 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7721 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7721 6 : : : 40436 7721 7 ponêra\ ponêra\ NNP 40436 7721 8 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7721 9 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 7721 10 pê=| pê=| NN 40436 7721 11 phate phate NN 40436 7721 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7721 13 ? ? . 40436 7722 1 po po NNP 40436 7722 2 / / SYM 40436 7722 3 teron teron NNP 40436 7722 4 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 7722 5 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7722 6 ê(donê\n ê(donê\n NNP 40436 7722 7 tau tau NN 40436 7722 8 / / SYM 40436 7722 9 tên tên NNP 40436 7722 10 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7722 11 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 7722 12 parachrê parachrê NNP 40436 7722 13 = = SYM 40436 7722 14 ma ma NNP 40436 7722 15 pare pare NNP 40436 7722 16 / / SYM 40436 7722 17 chei chei NNP 40436 7722 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7722 19 ê(du/ ê(du/ NNP 40436 7722 20 e)stin e)stin NNP 40436 7722 21 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 7722 22 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 7722 23 = = SYM 40436 7722 24 n n NNP 40436 7722 25 , , , 40436 7722 26 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 7722 27 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 7722 28 ei)s ei)s , 40436 7722 29 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7722 30 u(/steron u(/steron NNP 40436 7722 31 chro chro NN 40436 7722 32 / / SYM 40436 7722 33 non non AFX 40436 7722 34 no no DT 40436 7722 35 / / SYM 40436 7722 36 sous sous JJ 40436 7722 37 te te NNP 40436 7722 38 poiei= poiei= NNP 40436 7722 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7722 40 peni peni NNP 40436 7722 41 / / SYM 40436 7722 42 as as IN 40436 7722 43 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7722 44 a)/lla a)/lla NNP 40436 7722 45 toiau toiau NNP 40436 7722 46 = = SYM 40436 7722 47 ta ta NNP 40436 7722 48 polla\ polla\ NNP 40436 7722 49 paraskeua paraskeua NN 40436 7722 50 / / SYM 40436 7722 51 zei zei NNP 40436 7722 52 ? ? . 40436 7722 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7722 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7723 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7723 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7723 3 107 107 CD 40436 7723 4 : : : 40436 7723 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7723 6 , , , 40436 7723 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7723 8 . . . 40436 7724 1 p. p. NN 40436 7724 2 353 353 CD 40436 7724 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7724 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7724 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7724 6 : : : 40436 7724 7 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 7724 8 = = SYM 40436 7724 9 n n CC 40436 7724 10 phai phai NN 40436 7724 11 / / SYM 40436 7724 12 netai netai NN 40436 7724 13 . . . 40436 7725 1 . . . 40436 7726 1 . . . 40436 7727 1 . . . 40436 7728 1 di di NNP 40436 7728 2 ' ' '' 40436 7728 3 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 7728 4 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 7728 5 tau tau NNP 40436 7728 6 = = SYM 40436 7728 7 ta ta NNP 40436 7728 8 kaka\ kaka\ NNP 40436 7728 9 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 7728 10 , , , 40436 7728 11 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7728 12 dio dio NNP 40436 7728 13 / / SYM 40436 7728 14 ti ti NN 40436 7728 15 ei)s ei)s CD 40436 7728 16 a)ni a)ni NN 40436 7728 17 / / SYM 40436 7728 18 as as IN 40436 7728 19 te te NNP 40436 7728 20 a)poteleuta=| a)poteleuta=| ADD 40436 7728 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7728 22 a)/llôn a)/llôn NNP 40436 7728 23 ê(donô ê(donô NNP 40436 7728 24 = = SYM 40436 7728 25 n n CC 40436 7728 26 a)posterei= a)posterei= NNP 40436 7728 27 ? ? . 40436 7728 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7728 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7729 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7729 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7729 3 108 108 CD 40436 7729 4 : : : 40436 7729 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7729 6 , , , 40436 7729 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7729 8 . . . 40436 7730 1 p. p. NN 40436 7730 2 354 354 CD 40436 7730 3 B B NNP 40436 7730 4 - - HYPH 40436 7730 5 C. C. NNP 40436 7730 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7730 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7730 8 : : : 40436 7730 9 Tau tau NN 40436 7730 10 = = SYM 40436 7730 11 ta ta NNP 40436 7730 12 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7730 13 a)gatha/ a)gatha/ -LRB- 40436 7730 14 e)sti e)sti `` 40436 7730 15 di di NNP 40436 7730 16 ' ' '' 40436 7730 17 a)/llo a)/llo CC 40436 7730 18 ti ti NN 40436 7730 19 ê)\ ê)\ CD 40436 7730 20 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 7730 21 ei)s ei)s , 40436 7730 22 ê(dona\s ê(dona\s NNP 40436 7730 23 a)poteleuta=| a)poteleuta=| ADD 40436 7730 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7730 25 lupô lupô NNP 40436 7730 26 = = SYM 40436 7730 27 n n NNP 40436 7730 28 a)pallaga\s a)pallaga\s NNP 40436 7730 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7730 30 a)potropa a)potropa NNP 40436 7730 31 / / SYM 40436 7730 32 s s NNP 40436 7730 33 ? ? . 40436 7731 1 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7731 2 e)/chete/ e)/chete/ NNP 40436 7731 3 ti ti PRP 40436 7731 4 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 7731 5 te te NNP 40436 7731 6 / / SYM 40436 7731 7 los los NNP 40436 7731 8 le le NNP 40436 7731 9 / / SYM 40436 7731 10 gein gein NNP 40436 7731 11 , , , 40436 7731 12 ei)s ei)s '' 40436 7731 13 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 7731 14 a)poble a)poble NNPS 40436 7731 15 / / SYM 40436 7731 16 psantes psante NNS 40436 7731 17 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 7731 18 a)gatha\ a)gatha\ NNP 40436 7731 19 kalei kalei NN 40436 7731 20 = = SYM 40436 7731 21 te te NNP 40436 7731 22 , , , 40436 7731 23 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 7731 24 ' ' '' 40436 7731 25 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7731 26 ê(dona ê(dona NNP 40436 7731 27 / / SYM 40436 7731 28 s s NNP 40436 7731 29 te te NNP 40436 7731 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7731 31 lu lu NNP 40436 7731 32 / / SYM 40436 7731 33 pas pas NN 40436 7731 34 ? ? . 40436 7732 1 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 7732 2 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 7732 3 phai phai NNP 40436 7732 4 = = SYM 40436 7732 5 en en UH 40436 7732 6 , , , 40436 7732 7 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7732 8 e)gô)=|mai e)gô)=|mai NNP 40436 7732 9 . . . 40436 7733 1 . . . 40436 7734 1 . . . 40436 7735 1 . . . 40436 7736 1 Ou)kou ou)kou CD 40436 7736 2 = = SYM 40436 7736 3 n n CC 40436 7736 4 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7736 5 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7736 6 ê(donê\n ê(donê\n NNP 40436 7736 7 diô diô NNP 40436 7736 8 / / SYM 40436 7736 9 kete kete NNP 40436 7736 10 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7736 11 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 7736 12 o)/n o)/n NNP 40436 7736 13 , , , 40436 7736 14 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7736 15 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7736 16 lu lu NNP 40436 7736 17 / / SYM 40436 7736 18 pên pên NNP 40436 7736 19 pheu pheu NNP 40436 7736 20 / / SYM 40436 7736 21 gete gete NNP 40436 7736 22 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7736 23 kako kako NNP 40436 7736 24 / / SYM 40436 7736 25 n n NNP 40436 7736 26 ? ? . 40436 7736 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7736 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7737 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7737 2 Side side NN 40436 7737 3 - - HYPH 40436 7737 4 note note NN 40436 7737 5 : : : 40436 7737 6 Pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7737 7 is be VBZ 40436 7737 8 the the DT 40436 7737 9 only only JJ 40436 7737 10 good good JJ 40436 7737 11 -- -- : 40436 7737 12 pain pain VB 40436 7737 13 the the DT 40436 7737 14 only only JJ 40436 7737 15 evil evil NN 40436 7737 16 . . . 40436 7738 1 No no DT 40436 7738 2 man man NN 40436 7738 3 does do VBZ 40436 7738 4 evil evil NN 40436 7738 5 voluntarily voluntarily RB 40436 7738 6 , , , 40436 7738 7 knowing know VBG 40436 7738 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7738 9 to to TO 40436 7738 10 be be VB 40436 7738 11 evil evil JJ 40436 7738 12 . . . 40436 7739 1 Difference difference NN 40436 7739 2 between between IN 40436 7739 3 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7739 4 present present JJ 40436 7739 5 and and CC 40436 7739 6 future future JJ 40436 7739 7 -- -- : 40436 7739 8 resolves resolve VBZ 40436 7739 9 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7739 10 into into IN 40436 7739 11 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7739 12 and and CC 40436 7739 13 pain pain NN 40436 7739 14 . . . 40436 7739 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7740 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7740 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 7740 3 thus thus RB 40436 7740 4 appears appear VBZ 40436 7740 5 that that IN 40436 7740 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7740 7 pursue pursue VBP 40436 7740 8 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7740 9 as as IN 40436 7740 10 good good JJ 40436 7740 11 , , , 40436 7740 12 and and CC 40436 7740 13 avoid avoid VB 40436 7740 14 pain pain NN 40436 7740 15 as as IN 40436 7740 16 evil evil NN 40436 7740 17 . . . 40436 7741 1 Pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7741 2 is be VBZ 40436 7741 3 what what WP 40436 7741 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 5 think think VBP 40436 7741 6 good good JJ 40436 7741 7 : : : 40436 7741 8 pain pain NN 40436 7741 9 is be VBZ 40436 7741 10 what what WP 40436 7741 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 12 think think VBP 40436 7741 13 evil evil NN 40436 7741 14 : : : 40436 7741 15 for for IN 40436 7741 16 even even RB 40436 7741 17 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7741 18 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 19 appears appear VBZ 40436 7741 20 to to IN 40436 7741 21 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 22 evil evil NN 40436 7741 23 , , , 40436 7741 24 when when WRB 40436 7741 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 26 either either CC 40436 7741 27 deprives deprive VBZ 40436 7741 28 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 29 of of IN 40436 7741 30 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7741 31 greater great JJR 40436 7741 32 than than IN 40436 7741 33 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 34 , , , 40436 7741 35 or or CC 40436 7741 36 entails entail VBZ 40436 7741 37 upon upon IN 40436 7741 38 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 39 pains pain NNS 40436 7741 40 outweighing outweigh VBG 40436 7741 41 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7741 42 . . . 40436 7742 1 Is be VBZ 40436 7742 2 there there EX 40436 7742 3 any any DT 40436 7742 4 other other JJ 40436 7742 5 reason reason NN 40436 7742 6 , , , 40436 7742 7 or or CC 40436 7742 8 any any DT 40436 7742 9 other other JJ 40436 7742 10 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 7742 11 end end NN 40436 7742 12 , , , 40436 7742 13 to to TO 40436 7742 14 which which WDT 40436 7742 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7742 16 look look VBP 40436 7742 17 when when WRB 40436 7742 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7742 19 pronounce pronounce VBP 40436 7742 20 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7742 21 to to TO 40436 7742 22 be be VB 40436 7742 23 evil evil JJ 40436 7742 24 ? ? . 40436 7743 1 If if IN 40436 7743 2 there there EX 40436 7743 3 be be VBP 40436 7743 4 any any DT 40436 7743 5 other other JJ 40436 7743 6 between between IN 40436 7743 7 reason reason NN 40436 7743 8 , , , 40436 7743 9 or or CC 40436 7743 10 any any DT 40436 7743 11 other other JJ 40436 7743 12 end end NN 40436 7743 13 , , , 40436 7743 14 tell tell VB 40436 7743 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7743 16 what what WP 40436 7743 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7743 18 is be VBZ 40436 7743 19 . . . 40436 7744 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7744 2 109 109 CD 40436 7744 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7744 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7744 5 Prot._--There Prot._--There NNP 40436 7744 6 is be VBZ 40436 7744 7 none none NN 40436 7744 8 whatever whatever WDT 40436 7744 9 . . . 40436 7745 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7745 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 7745 3 case case NN 40436 7745 4 is be VBZ 40436 7745 5 similar similar JJ 40436 7745 6 about about IN 40436 7745 7 pains pain NNS 40436 7745 8 : : : 40436 7745 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7745 10 call call VBP 40436 7745 11 pain pain NN 40436 7745 12 good good JJ 40436 7745 13 , , , 40436 7745 14 when when WRB 40436 7745 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7745 16 preserves preserve VBZ 40436 7745 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7745 18 from from IN 40436 7745 19 greater great JJR 40436 7745 20 pains pain NNS 40436 7745 21 , , , 40436 7745 22 or or CC 40436 7745 23 procures procure NNS 40436 7745 24 for for IN 40436 7745 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7745 26 a a DT 40436 7745 27 future future JJ 40436 7745 28 balance balance NN 40436 7745 29 of of IN 40436 7745 30 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7745 31 . . . 40436 7746 1 If if IN 40436 7746 2 there there EX 40436 7746 3 be be VBP 40436 7746 4 any any DT 40436 7746 5 other other JJ 40436 7746 6 end end NN 40436 7746 7 to to TO 40436 7746 8 which which WDT 40436 7746 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7746 10 look look VBP 40436 7746 11 when when WRB 40436 7746 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7746 13 call call VBP 40436 7746 14 pain pain NN 40436 7746 15 good good JJ 40436 7746 16 , , , 40436 7746 17 tell tell VB 40436 7746 18 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7746 19 what what WP 40436 7746 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7746 21 is be VBZ 40436 7746 22 . . . 40436 7747 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7747 2 Prot._--You Prot._--You NNPS 40436 7747 3 speak speak VBP 40436 7747 4 truly truly RB 40436 7747 5 . . . 40436 7748 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7748 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 7748 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7748 4 am be VBP 40436 7748 5 asked ask VBN 40436 7748 6 why why WRB 40436 7748 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7748 8 insist insist VBP 40436 7748 9 so so RB 40436 7748 10 much much RB 40436 7748 11 on on IN 40436 7748 12 the the DT 40436 7748 13 topic topic NN 40436 7748 14 now now RB 40436 7748 15 before before IN 40436 7748 16 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7748 17 , , , 40436 7748 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7748 19 shall shall MD 40436 7748 20 reply reply VB 40436 7748 21 , , , 40436 7748 22 that that IN 40436 7748 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7748 24 is be VBZ 40436 7748 25 no no DT 40436 7748 26 easy easy JJ 40436 7748 27 matter matter NN 40436 7748 28 to to TO 40436 7748 29 explain explain VB 40436 7748 30 what what WP 40436 7748 31 is be VBZ 40436 7748 32 meant mean VBN 40436 7748 33 by by IN 40436 7748 34 being be VBG 40436 7748 35 overcome overcome VBN 40436 7748 36 by by IN 40436 7748 37 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7748 38 ; ; : 40436 7748 39 and and CC 40436 7748 40 that that IN 40436 7748 41 the the DT 40436 7748 42 whole whole JJ 40436 7748 43 proof proof JJ 40436 7748 44 hinges hinge NNS 40436 7748 45 upon upon IN 40436 7748 46 this this DT 40436 7748 47 point point NN 40436 7748 48 -- -- : 40436 7748 49 whether whether IN 40436 7748 50 there there EX 40436 7748 51 is be VBZ 40436 7748 52 any any DT 40436 7748 53 other other JJ 40436 7748 54 good good NN 40436 7748 55 than than IN 40436 7748 56 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7748 57 , , , 40436 7748 58 or or CC 40436 7748 59 any any DT 40436 7748 60 other other JJ 40436 7748 61 evil evil NN 40436 7748 62 than than IN 40436 7748 63 pain pain NN 40436 7748 64 ; ; : 40436 7748 65 and and CC 40436 7748 66 whether whether IN 40436 7748 67 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7748 68 be be VB 40436 7748 69 not not RB 40436 7748 70 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 7748 71 , , , 40436 7748 72 that that IN 40436 7748 73 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7748 74 should should MD 40436 7748 75 go go VB 40436 7748 76 through through IN 40436 7748 77 life life NN 40436 7748 78 pleasurably pleasurably RB 40436 7748 79 and and CC 40436 7748 80 without without IN 40436 7748 81 pains pain NNS 40436 7748 82 . . . 40436 7749 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7749 2 110 110 CD 40436 7749 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7749 4 If if IN 40436 7749 5 this this DT 40436 7749 6 be be VB 40436 7749 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 7749 8 , , , 40436 7749 9 and and CC 40436 7749 10 if if IN 40436 7749 11 no no DT 40436 7749 12 other other JJ 40436 7749 13 good good NN 40436 7749 14 or or CC 40436 7749 15 evil evil NN 40436 7749 16 can can MD 40436 7749 17 be be VB 40436 7749 18 pointed point VBN 40436 7749 19 out out RP 40436 7749 20 , , , 40436 7749 21 which which WDT 40436 7749 22 does do VBZ 40436 7749 23 not not RB 40436 7749 24 end end VB 40436 7749 25 in in IN 40436 7749 26 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7749 27 and and CC 40436 7749 28 pains pain NNS 40436 7749 29 , , , 40436 7749 30 mark mark VB 40436 7749 31 the the DT 40436 7749 32 consequences consequence NNS 40436 7749 33 . . . 40436 7750 1 Good good JJ 40436 7750 2 and and CC 40436 7750 3 evil evil NN 40436 7750 4 being be VBG 40436 7750 5 identical identical JJ 40436 7750 6 with with IN 40436 7750 7 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7750 8 and and CC 40436 7750 9 painful painful JJ 40436 7750 10 , , , 40436 7750 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7750 12 is be VBZ 40436 7750 13 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 7750 14 to to TO 40436 7750 15 say say VB 40436 7750 16 that that IN 40436 7750 17 a a DT 40436 7750 18 man man NN 40436 7750 19 does do VBZ 40436 7750 20 evil evil NN 40436 7750 21 voluntarily voluntarily RB 40436 7750 22 , , , 40436 7750 23 knowing know VBG 40436 7750 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7750 25 to to TO 40436 7750 26 be be VB 40436 7750 27 evil evil JJ 40436 7750 28 , , , 40436 7750 29 under under IN 40436 7750 30 the the DT 40436 7750 31 overpowering overpowering JJ 40436 7750 32 influence influence NN 40436 7750 33 of of IN 40436 7750 34 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7750 35 : : : 40436 7750 36 that that RB 40436 7750 37 is is RB 40436 7750 38 , , , 40436 7750 39 under under IN 40436 7750 40 the the DT 40436 7750 41 overpowering overpowering JJ 40436 7750 42 influence influence NN 40436 7750 43 of of IN 40436 7750 44 good good JJ 40436 7750 45 . . . 40436 7751 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7751 2 111 111 CD 40436 7751 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7751 4 How how WRB 40436 7751 5 can can MD 40436 7751 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7751 7 be be VB 40436 7751 8 wrong wrong JJ 40436 7751 9 , , , 40436 7751 10 that that IN 40436 7751 11 a a DT 40436 7751 12 man man NN 40436 7751 13 should should MD 40436 7751 14 yield yield VB 40436 7751 15 to to IN 40436 7751 16 the the DT 40436 7751 17 influence influence NN 40436 7751 18 of of IN 40436 7751 19 good good JJ 40436 7751 20 ? ? . 40436 7752 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7752 2 never never RB 40436 7752 3 can can MD 40436 7752 4 be be VB 40436 7752 5 wrong wrong JJ 40436 7752 6 , , , 40436 7752 7 except except IN 40436 7752 8 in in IN 40436 7752 9 this this DT 40436 7752 10 case case NN 40436 7752 11 -- -- : 40436 7752 12 when when WRB 40436 7752 13 the the DT 40436 7752 14 good good NN 40436 7752 15 obtained obtain VBN 40436 7752 16 is be VBZ 40436 7752 17 of of IN 40436 7752 18 smaller small JJR 40436 7752 19 amount amount NN 40436 7752 20 than than IN 40436 7752 21 the the DT 40436 7752 22 consequent consequent JJ 40436 7752 23 good good NN 40436 7752 24 forfeited forfeit VBN 40436 7752 25 or or CC 40436 7752 26 the the DT 40436 7752 27 consequent consequent JJ 40436 7752 28 evil evil NN 40436 7752 29 entailed entail VBD 40436 7752 30 . . . 40436 7753 1 What what WDT 40436 7753 2 other other JJ 40436 7753 3 exchangeable exchangeable JJ 40436 7753 4 value value NN 40436 7753 5 can can MD 40436 7753 6 there there EX 40436 7753 7 be be VB 40436 7753 8 between between IN 40436 7753 9 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7753 10 and and CC 40436 7753 11 pains pain NNS 40436 7753 12 , , , 40436 7753 13 except except IN 40436 7753 14 in in IN 40436 7753 15 the the DT 40436 7753 16 ratio ratio NN 40436 7753 17 of of IN 40436 7753 18 quantity quantity NN 40436 7753 19 -- -- : 40436 7753 20 greater great JJR 40436 7753 21 or or CC 40436 7753 22 less less RBR 40436 7753 23 , , , 40436 7753 24 more more RBR 40436 7753 25 or or CC 40436 7753 26 fewer few JJR 40436 7753 27 ? ? . 40436 7754 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7754 2 112 112 CD 40436 7754 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7754 4 If if IN 40436 7754 5 an an DT 40436 7754 6 objector objector NN 40436 7754 7 tells tell VBZ 40436 7754 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7754 9 that that IN 40436 7754 10 there there EX 40436 7754 11 is be VBZ 40436 7754 12 a a DT 40436 7754 13 material material JJ 40436 7754 14 difference difference NN 40436 7754 15 between between IN 40436 7754 16 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7754 17 and and CC 40436 7754 18 pains pain NNS 40436 7754 19 of of IN 40436 7754 20 the the DT 40436 7754 21 moment moment NN 40436 7754 22 , , , 40436 7754 23 and and CC 40436 7754 24 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7754 25 and and CC 40436 7754 26 pains pain NNS 40436 7754 27 postponed postpone VBD 40436 7754 28 to to IN 40436 7754 29 a a DT 40436 7754 30 future future JJ 40436 7754 31 time time NN 40436 7754 32 , , , 40436 7754 33 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7754 34 ask ask VBP 40436 7754 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7754 36 in in IN 40436 7754 37 reply reply NN 40436 7754 38 , , , 40436 7754 39 Is be VBZ 40436 7754 40 there there EX 40436 7754 41 any any DT 40436 7754 42 other other JJ 40436 7754 43 difference difference NN 40436 7754 44 , , , 40436 7754 45 except except IN 40436 7754 46 in in IN 40436 7754 47 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7754 48 and and CC 40436 7754 49 pain pain NN 40436 7754 50 ? ? . 40436 7755 1 An an DT 40436 7755 2 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 7755 3 man man NN 40436 7755 4 ought ought MD 40436 7755 5 to to TO 40436 7755 6 put put VB 40436 7755 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7755 8 both both DT 40436 7755 9 in in IN 40436 7755 10 the the DT 40436 7755 11 scale scale NN 40436 7755 12 , , , 40436 7755 13 the the DT 40436 7755 14 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7755 15 and and CC 40436 7755 16 the the DT 40436 7755 17 pains pain NNS 40436 7755 18 , , , 40436 7755 19 the the DT 40436 7755 20 present present NN 40436 7755 21 and and CC 40436 7755 22 the the DT 40436 7755 23 future future NN 40436 7755 24 , , , 40436 7755 25 so so IN 40436 7755 26 as as IN 40436 7755 27 to to TO 40436 7755 28 determine determine VB 40436 7755 29 the the DT 40436 7755 30 balance balance NN 40436 7755 31 . . . 40436 7756 1 Weighing weighing NN 40436 7756 2 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7756 3 against against IN 40436 7756 4 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7756 5 , , , 40436 7756 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7756 7 ought ought MD 40436 7756 8 to to TO 40436 7756 9 prefer prefer VB 40436 7756 10 the the DT 40436 7756 11 more more JJR 40436 7756 12 and and CC 40436 7756 13 the the DT 40436 7756 14 greater great JJR 40436 7756 15 : : : 40436 7756 16 weighing weigh VBG 40436 7756 17 pains pain NNS 40436 7756 18 against against IN 40436 7756 19 pains pain NNS 40436 7756 20 , , , 40436 7756 21 the the DT 40436 7756 22 fewer few JJR 40436 7756 23 and and CC 40436 7756 24 the the DT 40436 7756 25 less less RBR 40436 7756 26 . . . 40436 7757 1 If if IN 40436 7757 2 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7757 3 against against IN 40436 7757 4 pains pain NNS 40436 7757 5 , , , 40436 7757 6 then then RB 40436 7757 7 when when WRB 40436 7757 8 the the DT 40436 7757 9 latter latter JJ 40436 7757 10 outweigh outweigh NN 40436 7757 11 the the DT 40436 7757 12 former former JJ 40436 7757 13 , , , 40436 7757 14 reckoning reckon VBG 40436 7757 15 distant distant JJ 40436 7757 16 as as RB 40436 7757 17 well well RB 40436 7757 18 as as IN 40436 7757 19 near near RB 40436 7757 20 , , , 40436 7757 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7757 22 ought ought MD 40436 7757 23 to to TO 40436 7757 24 abstain abstain VB 40436 7757 25 from from IN 40436 7757 26 the the DT 40436 7757 27 act act NN 40436 7757 28 : : : 40436 7757 29 when when WRB 40436 7757 30 the the DT 40436 7757 31 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7757 32 outweigh outweigh VBP 40436 7757 33 , , , 40436 7757 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7757 35 ought ought MD 40436 7757 36 to to TO 40436 7757 37 do do VB 40436 7757 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7757 39 . . . 40436 7758 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7758 2 Prot._--The Prot._--The NNP 40436 7758 3 objectors objector NNS 40436 7758 4 could could MD 40436 7758 5 have have VB 40436 7758 6 nothing nothing NN 40436 7758 7 to to TO 40436 7758 8 say say VB 40436 7758 9 against against IN 40436 7758 10 this this DT 40436 7758 11 . . . 40436 7759 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7759 2 113 113 CD 40436 7759 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7759 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7759 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7759 6 109 109 CD 40436 7759 7 : : : 40436 7759 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7759 9 , , , 40436 7759 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7759 11 , , , 40436 7759 12 p. p. NN 40436 7759 13 354 354 CD 40436 7759 14 D. D. NNP 40436 7759 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7759 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7759 17 : : : 40436 7759 18 e)pei\ e)pei\ '' 40436 7759 19 ei ei NNP 40436 7759 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7759 21 kat kat NNP 40436 7759 22 ' ' '' 40436 7759 23 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 7759 24 ti ti NNP 40436 7759 25 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 7759 26 to\ to\ NN 40436 7759 27 chai chai NN 40436 7759 28 / / SYM 40436 7759 29 rein rein NNP 40436 7759 30 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 7759 31 kalei kalei NNP 40436 7759 32 = = SYM 40436 7759 33 te te NNP 40436 7759 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7759 35 ei)s ei)s , 40436 7759 36 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 7759 37 ti ti NNP 40436 7759 38 te te NNP 40436 7759 39 / / SYM 40436 7759 40 los los NNP 40436 7759 41 a)poble a)poble NNP 40436 7759 42 / / SYM 40436 7759 43 psantes psante NNS 40436 7759 44 , , , 40436 7759 45 e)/choite e)/choite NNP 40436 7759 46 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 7759 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7759 48 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 7759 49 = = SYM 40436 7759 50 n n NNP 40436 7759 51 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 7759 52 = = SYM 40436 7759 53 n n XX 40436 7759 54 ; ; : 40436 7759 55 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 7759 56 ' ' '' 40436 7759 57 ou)ch ou)ch NN 40436 7759 58 e(/xete e(/xete CD 40436 7759 59 . . . 40436 7760 1 Ou)d Ou)d NNP 40436 7760 2 ' ' POS 40436 7760 3 e)moi\ e)moi\ NNS 40436 7760 4 dokou dokou NNP 40436 7760 5 = = SYM 40436 7760 6 sin sin NN 40436 7760 7 , , , 40436 7760 8 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 7760 9 o o UH 40436 7760 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7760 11 Prôtago Prôtago NNP 40436 7760 12 / / SYM 40436 7760 13 ras ras NNP 40436 7760 14 . . . 40436 7760 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7760 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7761 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7761 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7761 3 110 110 CD 40436 7761 4 : : : 40436 7761 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7761 6 , , , 40436 7761 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7761 8 . . . 40436 7762 1 p. p. NN 40436 7762 2 354 354 CD 40436 7762 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7762 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7762 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7762 6 : : : 40436 7762 7 e)/peita e)/peita NNP 40436 7762 8 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7762 9 tou tou NNP 40436 7762 10 / / SYM 40436 7762 11 tô| tô| NNP 40436 7762 12 ei)si\ ei)si\ NNP 40436 7762 13 pa pa NNP 40436 7762 14 = = SYM 40436 7762 15 sai sai NNP 40436 7762 16 ai ai NNP 40436 7762 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7762 18 a)podei a)podei NNP 40436 7762 19 / / SYM 40436 7762 20 xeis xeis NNP 40436 7762 21 ; ; : 40436 7762 22 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 7762 23 ' ' '' 40436 7762 24 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 7762 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7762 26 nu nu NNP 40436 7762 27 = = SYM 40436 7762 28 n n NNP 40436 7762 29 a)nathe a)nathe NNP 40436 7762 30 / / SYM 40436 7762 31 sthai sthai NNP 40436 7762 32 e)/xestin e)/xestin NNP 40436 7762 33 , , , 40436 7762 34 ei ei NNP 40436 7762 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7762 36 pê| pê| NNP 40436 7762 37 e)/chete e)/chete FW 40436 7762 38 a)/llo a)/llo FW 40436 7762 39 ti ti NNP 40436 7762 40 pha pha NNP 40436 7762 41 / / SYM 40436 7762 42 nai nai NNP 40436 7762 43 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 7762 44 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7762 45 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NN 40436 7762 46 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 7762 47 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7762 48 ê(donê ê(donê NNP 40436 7762 49 / / SYM 40436 7762 50 n n NNP 40436 7762 51 , , , 40436 7762 52 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 7762 53 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7762 54 kako\n kako\n ADD 40436 7762 55 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 7762 56 ti ti NNP 40436 7762 57 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7762 58 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7762 59 a)ni a)ni VBZ 40436 7762 60 / / SYM 40436 7762 61 an an DT 40436 7762 62 , , , 40436 7762 63 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7762 64 a)rkei= a)rkei= NNP 40436 7762 65 u(mi u(mi JJ 40436 7762 66 = = SYM 40436 7762 67 n n CC 40436 7762 68 to\ to\ NN 40436 7762 69 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 7762 70 / / SYM 40436 7762 71 ôs ôs NNP 40436 7762 72 katabiô katabiô VBD 40436 7762 73 = = NFP 40436 7762 74 nai nai NNP 40436 7762 75 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7762 76 bi bi NNP 40436 7762 77 / / SYM 40436 7762 78 on on IN 40436 7762 79 a)/neu a)/neu NNP 40436 7762 80 lupô lupô NNP 40436 7762 81 = = SYM 40436 7762 82 n n XX 40436 7762 83 ? ? . 40436 7762 84 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7762 85 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7763 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7763 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7763 3 111 111 CD 40436 7763 4 : : : 40436 7763 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7763 6 , , , 40436 7763 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7763 8 . . . 40436 7764 1 p. p. NN 40436 7764 2 355 355 CD 40436 7764 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7764 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7764 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7764 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7764 7 112 112 CD 40436 7764 8 : : : 40436 7764 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7764 10 , , , 40436 7764 11 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7764 12 . . . 40436 7765 1 p. p. NN 40436 7765 2 356 356 CD 40436 7765 3 A. a. NN 40436 7766 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7766 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7766 3 : : : 40436 7766 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7766 5 ti ti NNP 40436 7766 6 / / SYM 40436 7766 7 s s NNP 40436 7766 8 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 7766 9 a)xi a)xi NNS 40436 7766 10 / / SYM 40436 7766 11 a a DT 40436 7766 12 ê(donê=| ê(donê=| NNP 40436 7766 13 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7766 14 lu lu NNP 40436 7766 15 / / SYM 40436 7766 16 pôn pôn NNP 40436 7766 17 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 7766 18 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 7766 19 ' ' `` 40436 7766 20 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7766 21 u(perbolê\ u(perbolê\ NNP 40436 7766 22 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 7766 23 / / SYM 40436 7766 24 lôn lôn NN 40436 7766 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7766 26 e)/lleipsis e)/lleipsis NNP 40436 7766 27 ? ? . 40436 7767 1 tau tau NNP 40436 7767 2 = = SYM 40436 7767 3 ta ta NNP 40436 7767 4 d d NNP 40436 7767 5 ' ' POS 40436 7767 6 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 7767 7 mei mei NNP 40436 7767 8 / / SYM 40436 7767 9 zô zô NNP 40436 7767 10 te te NNP 40436 7767 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7767 12 smikro smikro NNP 40436 7767 13 / / SYM 40436 7767 14 tera tera NNP 40436 7767 15 gigno gigno NNP 40436 7767 16 / / SYM 40436 7767 17 mena mena NNP 40436 7767 18 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 7767 19 / / SYM 40436 7767 20 lôn lôn NN 40436 7767 21 , , , 40436 7767 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7767 23 plei plei NNP 40436 7767 24 / / SYM 40436 7767 25 ô ô NNP 40436 7767 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7767 27 e)la e)la NNP 40436 7767 28 / / SYM 40436 7767 29 ttô ttô NNP 40436 7767 30 , , , 40436 7767 31 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7767 32 ma ma NNP 40436 7767 33 = = SYM 40436 7767 34 llon llon NNP 40436 7767 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7767 36 ê(=tton ê(=tton NNP 40436 7767 37 . . . 40436 7767 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7767 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7768 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7768 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7768 3 113 113 CD 40436 7768 4 : : : 40436 7768 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7768 6 , , , 40436 7768 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7768 8 . . . 40436 7769 1 p. p. NN 40436 7769 2 356 356 CD 40436 7769 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7769 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7769 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7769 6 Side side NN 40436 7769 7 - - HYPH 40436 7769 8 note note NN 40436 7769 9 : : : 40436 7769 10 Necessary necessary JJ 40436 7769 11 resort resort NN 40436 7769 12 to to IN 40436 7769 13 the the DT 40436 7769 14 measuring measure VBG 40436 7769 15 art art NN 40436 7769 16 for for IN 40436 7769 17 choosing choose VBG 40436 7769 18 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7769 19 rightly rightly RB 40436 7769 20 -- -- : 40436 7769 21 all all PDT 40436 7769 22 the the DT 40436 7769 23 security security NN 40436 7769 24 of of IN 40436 7769 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7769 26 lives life NNS 40436 7769 27 depend depend VBP 40436 7769 28 upon upon IN 40436 7769 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7769 30 . . . 40436 7769 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7770 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7770 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 7770 3 then then RB 40436 7770 4 -- -- : 40436 7770 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7770 6 shall shall MD 40436 7770 7 tell tell VB 40436 7770 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7770 9 farther farther RB 40436 7770 10 -- -- : 40436 7770 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7770 12 know know VBP 40436 7770 13 that that IN 40436 7770 14 the the DT 40436 7770 15 same same JJ 40436 7770 16 magnitude magnitude NN 40436 7770 17 , , , 40436 7770 18 and and CC 40436 7770 19 the the DT 40436 7770 20 same same JJ 40436 7770 21 voice voice NN 40436 7770 22 , , , 40436 7770 23 appears appear VBZ 40436 7770 24 to to IN 40436 7770 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7770 26 greater great JJR 40436 7770 27 when when WRB 40436 7770 28 near near RB 40436 7770 29 than than IN 40436 7770 30 when when WRB 40436 7770 31 distant distant JJ 40436 7770 32 . . . 40436 7771 1 Now now RB 40436 7771 2 , , , 40436 7771 3 if if IN 40436 7771 4 all all DT 40436 7771 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7771 6 well well NN 40436 7771 7 - - HYPH 40436 7771 8 doing doing NN 40436 7771 9 depended depend VBD 40436 7771 10 upon upon IN 40436 7771 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7771 12 choosing choose VBG 40436 7771 13 the the DT 40436 7771 14 magnitudes magnitude NNS 40436 7771 15 really really RB 40436 7771 16 greater great JJR 40436 7771 17 and and CC 40436 7771 18 avoiding avoid VBG 40436 7771 19 those those DT 40436 7771 20 really really RB 40436 7771 21 less less JJR 40436 7771 22 , , , 40436 7771 23 where where WRB 40436 7771 24 would would MD 40436 7771 25 the the DT 40436 7771 26 security security NN 40436 7771 27 of of IN 40436 7771 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7771 29 life life NN 40436 7771 30 be be VB 40436 7771 31 found find VBN 40436 7771 32 ? ? . 40436 7772 1 In in IN 40436 7772 2 the the DT 40436 7772 3 art art NN 40436 7772 4 of of IN 40436 7772 5 mensuration mensuration NN 40436 7772 6 , , , 40436 7772 7 or or CC 40436 7772 8 in in IN 40436 7772 9 the the DT 40436 7772 10 apparent apparent JJ 40436 7772 11 impression impression NN 40436 7772 12 ? ? . 40436 7773 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7773 2 114 114 CD 40436 7773 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7773 4 Would Would MD 40436 7773 5 not not RB 40436 7773 6 the the DT 40436 7773 7 latter latter JJ 40436 7773 8 lead lead NN 40436 7773 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7773 10 astray astray NNP 40436 7773 11 , , , 40436 7773 12 causing cause VBG 40436 7773 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7773 14 to to TO 40436 7773 15 vacillate vacillate VB 40436 7773 16 and and CC 40436 7773 17 judge judge VB 40436 7773 18 badly badly RB 40436 7773 19 in in IN 40436 7773 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7773 21 choice choice NN 40436 7773 22 between between IN 40436 7773 23 great great JJ 40436 7773 24 and and CC 40436 7773 25 little little JJ 40436 7773 26 , , , 40436 7773 27 with with IN 40436 7773 28 frequent frequent JJ 40436 7773 29 repentance repentance NN 40436 7773 30 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 7773 31 ? ? . 40436 7774 1 Would Would MD 40436 7774 2 not not RB 40436 7774 3 the the DT 40436 7774 4 art art NN 40436 7774 5 of of IN 40436 7774 6 mensuration mensuration NN 40436 7774 7 set set VBN 40436 7774 8 aside aside RP 40436 7774 9 these these DT 40436 7774 10 false false JJ 40436 7774 11 appearances appearance NNS 40436 7774 12 , , , 40436 7774 13 and and CC 40436 7774 14 by by IN 40436 7774 15 revealing reveal VBG 40436 7774 16 to to IN 40436 7774 17 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7774 18 the the DT 40436 7774 19 truth truth NN 40436 7774 20 , , , 40436 7774 21 impart impart NN 40436 7774 22 tranquillity tranquillity NN 40436 7774 23 to to IN 40436 7774 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7774 25 minds mind NNS 40436 7774 26 and and CC 40436 7774 27 security security NN 40436 7774 28 to to IN 40436 7774 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7774 30 lives life NNS 40436 7774 31 ? ? . 40436 7775 1 Would Would MD 40436 7775 2 not not RB 40436 7775 3 the the DT 40436 7775 4 objectors objector NNS 40436 7775 5 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7775 6 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 40436 7775 7 that that IN 40436 7775 8 there there EX 40436 7775 9 was be VBD 40436 7775 10 no no DT 40436 7775 11 other other JJ 40436 7775 12 safety safety NN 40436 7775 13 , , , 40436 7775 14 except except IN 40436 7775 15 in in IN 40436 7775 16 the the DT 40436 7775 17 art art NN 40436 7775 18 of of IN 40436 7775 19 mensuration mensuration NN 40436 7775 20 ? ? . 40436 7776 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7776 2 Prot._--They Prot._--They NNP 40436 7776 3 would would MD 40436 7776 4 acknowledge acknowledge VB 40436 7776 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7776 6 . . . 40436 7777 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7777 2 Sokr._--Again Sokr._--Again NNP 40436 7777 3 , , , 40436 7777 4 If if IN 40436 7777 5 the the DT 40436 7777 6 good good JJ 40436 7777 7 conduct conduct NN 40436 7777 8 of of IN 40436 7777 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7777 10 lives life NNS 40436 7777 11 depended depend VBD 40436 7777 12 on on IN 40436 7777 13 the the DT 40436 7777 14 choice choice NN 40436 7777 15 of of IN 40436 7777 16 odd odd JJ 40436 7777 17 and and CC 40436 7777 18 even even RB 40436 7777 19 , , , 40436 7777 20 and and CC 40436 7777 21 in in IN 40436 7777 22 distinguishing distinguish VBG 40436 7777 23 rightly rightly RB 40436 7777 24 the the DT 40436 7777 25 greater great JJR 40436 7777 26 from from IN 40436 7777 27 the the DT 40436 7777 28 less less JJR 40436 7777 29 , , , 40436 7777 30 whether whether IN 40436 7777 31 far far RB 40436 7777 32 or or CC 40436 7777 33 near near RB 40436 7777 34 , , , 40436 7777 35 would would MD 40436 7777 36 not not RB 40436 7777 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7777 38 safety safety NN 40436 7777 39 reside reside NN 40436 7777 40 in in IN 40436 7777 41 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7777 42 , , , 40436 7777 43 and and CC 40436 7777 44 in in IN 40436 7777 45 a a DT 40436 7777 46 certain certain JJ 40436 7777 47 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7777 48 of of IN 40436 7777 49 mensuration mensuration NN 40436 7777 50 too too RB 40436 7777 51 , , , 40436 7777 52 in in IN 40436 7777 53 Arithmetic Arithmetic NNP 40436 7777 54 ? ? . 40436 7778 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7778 2 Prot._--They Prot._--They NNP 40436 7778 3 would would MD 40436 7778 4 concede concede VB 40436 7778 5 to to IN 40436 7778 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7778 7 that that IN 40436 7778 8 also also RB 40436 7778 9 . . . 40436 7779 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7779 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 7779 3 then then RB 40436 7779 4 , , , 40436 7779 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7779 6 friends friend NNS 40436 7779 7 , , , 40436 7779 8 since since IN 40436 7779 9 the the DT 40436 7779 10 security security NN 40436 7779 11 of of IN 40436 7779 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7779 13 lives life NNS 40436 7779 14 has have VBZ 40436 7779 15 been be VBN 40436 7779 16 found find VBN 40436 7779 17 to to TO 40436 7779 18 depend depend VB 40436 7779 19 on on IN 40436 7779 20 the the DT 40436 7779 21 right right JJ 40436 7779 22 choice choice NN 40436 7779 23 of of IN 40436 7779 24 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7779 25 and and CC 40436 7779 26 pain pain NN 40436 7779 27 -- -- : 40436 7779 28 between between IN 40436 7779 29 the the DT 40436 7779 30 more more JJR 40436 7779 31 and and CC 40436 7779 32 fewer few JJR 40436 7779 33 , , , 40436 7779 34 greater great JJR 40436 7779 35 and and CC 40436 7779 36 less less RBR 40436 7779 37 , , , 40436 7779 38 nearer near JJR 40436 7779 39 and and CC 40436 7779 40 farther farther RB 40436 7779 41 -- -- : 40436 7779 42 does do VBZ 40436 7779 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7779 44 not not RB 40436 7779 45 come come VB 40436 7779 46 to to IN 40436 7779 47 a a DT 40436 7779 48 simple simple JJ 40436 7779 49 estimate estimate NN 40436 7779 50 of of IN 40436 7779 51 excess excess NN 40436 7779 52 , , , 40436 7779 53 deficiency deficiency NN 40436 7779 54 , , , 40436 7779 55 and and CC 40436 7779 56 equality equality NN 40436 7779 57 between between IN 40436 7779 58 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7779 59 ? ? . 40436 7780 1 in in IN 40436 7780 2 other other JJ 40436 7780 3 words word NNS 40436 7780 4 , , , 40436 7780 5 to to IN 40436 7780 6 mensuration mensuration NN 40436 7780 7 , , , 40436 7780 8 art art NN 40436 7780 9 , , , 40436 7780 10 or or CC 40436 7780 11 science science NN 40436 7780 12 ? ? . 40436 7781 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7781 2 115 115 CD 40436 7781 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7781 4 What what WP 40436 7781 5 kind kind NN 40436 7781 6 of of IN 40436 7781 7 art art NN 40436 7781 8 or or CC 40436 7781 9 science science NN 40436 7781 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7781 11 is be VBZ 40436 7781 12 , , , 40436 7781 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7781 14 will will MD 40436 7781 15 enquire enquire VB 40436 7781 16 another another DT 40436 7781 17 time time NN 40436 7781 18 : : : 40436 7781 19 for for IN 40436 7781 20 the the DT 40436 7781 21 purpose purpose NN 40436 7781 22 of of IN 40436 7781 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7781 24 argument argument NN 40436 7781 25 , , , 40436 7781 26 enough enough JJ 40436 7781 27 has have VBZ 40436 7781 28 been be VBN 40436 7781 29 done do VBN 40436 7781 30 when when WRB 40436 7781 31 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7781 32 have have VBP 40436 7781 33 shown show VBN 40436 7781 34 that that IN 40436 7781 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7781 36 _ _ NNP 40436 7781 37 is be VBZ 40436 7781 38 _ _ NNP 40436 7781 39 science science NN 40436 7781 40 . . . 40436 7782 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7782 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7782 3 114 114 CD 40436 7782 4 : : : 40436 7782 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7782 6 , , , 40436 7782 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7782 8 . . . 40436 7783 1 p. p. NN 40436 7783 2 356 356 CD 40436 7783 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7783 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7783 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7783 6 : : : 40436 7783 7 ei ei NNP 40436 7783 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7783 9 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 7783 10 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7783 11 tou tou NNP 40436 7783 12 / / SYM 40436 7783 13 tô| tô| NNP 40436 7783 14 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 7783 15 = = SYM 40436 7783 16 n n CC 40436 7783 17 ê)=n ê)=n CC 40436 7783 18 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7783 19 eu)= eu)= JJ 40436 7783 20 pra pra NNP 40436 7783 21 / / SYM 40436 7783 22 ttein ttein NNP 40436 7783 23 , , , 40436 7783 24 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7783 25 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 7783 26 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 7783 27 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7783 28 mega mega NNP 40436 7783 29 / / SYM 40436 7783 30 la la NNP 40436 7783 31 mê mê NNP 40436 7783 32 / / SYM 40436 7783 33 kê kê NNP 40436 7783 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7783 35 pra pra NNP 40436 7783 36 / / SYM 40436 7783 37 ttein ttein NNP 40436 7783 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7783 39 lamba lamba NNP 40436 7783 40 / / SYM 40436 7783 41 nein nein NNP 40436 7783 42 , , , 40436 7783 43 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 7783 44 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7783 45 smikra\ smikra\ NN 40436 7783 46 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7783 47 pheu pheu NNP 40436 7783 48 / / SYM 40436 7783 49 gein gein NNP 40436 7783 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7783 51 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 7783 52 pra pra NNP 40436 7783 53 / / SYM 40436 7783 54 ttein ttein NN 40436 7783 55 , , , 40436 7783 56 ti ti NNP 40436 7783 57 / / SYM 40436 7783 58 s s NNP 40436 7783 59 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 7783 60 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 7783 61 = = SYM 40436 7783 62 n n CC 40436 7783 63 sôtêri sôtêri NN 40436 7783 64 / / SYM 40436 7783 65 a a DT 40436 7783 66 e)pha e)pha NN 40436 7783 67 / / SYM 40436 7783 68 nê nê UH 40436 7783 69 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7783 70 bi bi NNP 40436 7783 71 / / SYM 40436 7783 72 ou ou NN 40436 7783 73 ? ? . 40436 7784 1 a)=ra a)=ra NNP 40436 7784 2 ê ê NNP 40436 7784 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7784 4 metrêtikê\ metrêtikê\ NNP 40436 7784 5 te te NNP 40436 7784 6 / / SYM 40436 7784 7 chnê chnê NNP 40436 7784 8 , , , 40436 7784 9 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7784 10 ê ê NNP 40436 7784 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7784 12 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7784 13 phainome phainome NN 40436 7784 14 / / SYM 40436 7784 15 nou nou NN 40436 7784 16 du du NN 40436 7784 17 / / SYM 40436 7784 18 namis namis NN 40436 7784 19 ? ? . 40436 7785 1 . . . 40436 7786 1 . . . 40436 7787 1 . . . 40436 7788 1 A)=r A)=r NNP 40436 7788 2 ' ' POS 40436 7788 3 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 7788 4 o(mologoi o(mologoi UH 40436 7788 5 = = FW 40436 7788 6 en en FW 40436 7788 7 oi oi FW 40436 7788 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7788 9 a)/nthrôpoi a)/nthrôpoi NNP 40436 7788 10 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7788 11 tau tau NN 40436 7788 12 = = SYM 40436 7788 13 ta ta ADD 40436 7788 14 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 7788 15 = = NFP 40436 7788 16 s s NN 40436 7788 17 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7788 18 metrêtikê\n metrêtikê\n NNP 40436 7788 19 sô sô NNP 40436 7788 20 / / SYM 40436 7788 21 zein zein NNP 40436 7788 22 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 7788 23 te te NNP 40436 7788 24 / / SYM 40436 7788 25 chnên chnên NNP 40436 7788 26 , , , 40436 7788 27 ê)\ ê)\ IN 40436 7788 28 a)/llên a)/llên NN 40436 7788 29 ? ? . 40436 7788 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7788 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7789 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7789 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7789 3 115 115 CD 40436 7789 4 : : : 40436 7789 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7789 6 , , , 40436 7789 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7789 8 . . . 40436 7790 1 p. p. NN 40436 7790 2 357 357 CD 40436 7790 3 A a NN 40436 7790 4 - - HYPH 40436 7790 5 v v NN 40436 7790 6 . . . 40436 7790 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7790 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7790 9 : : : 40436 7790 10 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ JJ 40436 7790 11 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7790 12 ê(donê ê(donê NNP 40436 7790 13 = = NFP 40436 7790 14 s s NNP 40436 7790 15 te te NNP 40436 7790 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7790 17 lu lu NNP 40436 7790 18 / / SYM 40436 7790 19 pês pês NN 40436 7790 20 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7790 21 o)rthê=| o)rthê=| ADD 40436 7790 22 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 7790 23 ai(re ai(re NNP 40436 7790 24 / / SYM 40436 7790 25 sei sei NN 40436 7790 26 e)pha e)pha NNPS 40436 7790 27 / / SYM 40436 7790 28 nê nê NNP 40436 7790 29 _ _ NNP 40436 7790 30 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 7790 31 = = SYM 40436 7790 32 n n CC 40436 7790 33 ê ê NNP 40436 7790 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7790 35 sôtêri sôtêri NNP 40436 7790 36 / / , 40436 7790 37 a a DT 40436 7790 38 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7790 39 bi bi NN 40436 7790 40 / / SYM 40436 7790 41 ou ou NNP 40436 7790 42 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 7790 43 , , , 40436 7790 44 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7790 45 te te NNP 40436 7790 46 ple ple NNP 40436 7790 47 / / SYM 40436 7790 48 onos onos NNP 40436 7790 49 _ _ NNP 40436 7790 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7790 51 e(la e(la NNP 40436 7790 52 / / SYM 40436 7790 53 ttonos ttonos NNP 40436 7790 54 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7790 55 mei mei NNP 40436 7790 56 / / SYM 40436 7790 57 zonos zonos NNP 40436 7790 58 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7790 59 smikrote smikrote NNP 40436 7790 60 / / SYM 40436 7790 61 ron ron NNP 40436 7790 62 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7790 63 por)r(ôte por)r(ôte NNP 40436 7790 64 / / SYM 40436 7790 65 rô rô NNP 40436 7790 66 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7790 67 e)ggute e)ggute , 40436 7790 68 / / SYM 40436 7790 69 rô rô NNP 40436 7790 70 , , , 40436 7790 71 a)=ra a)=ra NNP 40436 7790 72 prô prô NNP 40436 7790 73 = = SYM 40436 7790 74 ton ton NN 40436 7790 75 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7790 76 ou ou NNP 40436 7790 77 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7790 78 metrêtikê\ metrêtikê\ NNP 40436 7790 79 phai phai NNP 40436 7790 80 / / SYM 40436 7790 81 netai netai NNP 40436 7790 82 , , , 40436 7790 83 u(perbolê u(perbolê NNP 40436 7790 84 = = SYM 40436 7790 85 s s NNP 40436 7790 86 te te NNP 40436 7790 87 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7790 88 e)ndei e)ndei NNP 40436 7790 89 / / SYM 40436 7790 90 as as IN 40436 7790 91 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 7790 92 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7790 93 i)so i)so NNP 40436 7790 94 / / SYM 40436 7790 95 têtos têtos NNP 40436 7790 96 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7790 97 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 7790 98 / / SYM 40436 7790 99 las las NNP 40436 7790 100 ske ske NNP 40436 7790 101 / / SYM 40436 7790 102 psis psis NN 40436 7790 103 ? ? . 40436 7791 1 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 7791 2 ' ' POS 40436 7791 3 a)na a)na NNS 40436 7791 4 / / SYM 40436 7791 5 gkê gkê NN 40436 7791 6 . . . 40436 7792 1 E)pei\ E)pei\ NNP 40436 7792 2 de\ de\ NN 40436 7792 3 metrêtikê/ metrêtikê/ NN 40436 7792 4 , , , 40436 7792 5 a)na a)na NNP 40436 7792 6 / / SYM 40436 7792 7 gkê| gkê| NNP 40436 7792 8 dê dê NNP 40436 7792 9 / / SYM 40436 7792 10 pou pou NNP 40436 7792 11 te te NNP 40436 7792 12 / / SYM 40436 7792 13 chnê chnê NNP 40436 7792 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7792 15 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 7792 16 / / SYM 40436 7792 17 mê mê NNP 40436 7792 18 . . . 40436 7792 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7792 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7793 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7793 2 Side side NN 40436 7793 3 - - HYPH 40436 7793 4 note note NN 40436 7793 5 : : : 40436 7793 6 To to TO 40436 7793 7 do do VB 40436 7793 8 wrong wrong NN 40436 7793 9 , , , 40436 7793 10 overcome overcome VBN 40436 7793 11 by by IN 40436 7793 12 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7793 13 , , , 40436 7793 14 is be VBZ 40436 7793 15 only only RB 40436 7793 16 a a DT 40436 7793 17 bad bad JJ 40436 7793 18 phrase phrase NN 40436 7793 19 for for IN 40436 7793 20 describing describe VBG 40436 7793 21 what what WP 40436 7793 22 is be VBZ 40436 7793 23 really really RB 40436 7793 24 a a DT 40436 7793 25 case case NN 40436 7793 26 of of IN 40436 7793 27 grave grave JJ 40436 7793 28 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7793 29 . . . 40436 7793 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7794 1 For for IN 40436 7794 2 when when WRB 40436 7794 3 _ _ NNP 40436 7794 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7794 5 _ _ NNP 40436 7794 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7794 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7794 8 and and CC 40436 7794 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7794 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7794 11 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 7794 12 , , , 40436 7794 13 that that IN 40436 7794 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 7794 15 was be VBD 40436 7794 16 more more RBR 40436 7794 17 powerful powerful JJ 40436 7794 18 than than IN 40436 7794 19 science science NN 40436 7794 20 or or CC 40436 7794 21 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7794 22 , , , 40436 7794 23 and and CC 40436 7794 24 that that IN 40436 7794 25 this this DT 40436 7794 26 , , , 40436 7794 27 in in IN 40436 7794 28 whatsoever whatsoever RB 40436 7794 29 minds mind NNS 40436 7794 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7794 31 existed exist VBD 40436 7794 32 , , , 40436 7794 33 prevailed prevail VBD 40436 7794 34 over over IN 40436 7794 35 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7794 36 and and CC 40436 7794 37 every every DT 40436 7794 38 thing thing NN 40436 7794 39 else--_you else--_you NNP 40436 7794 40 _ _ NNP 40436 7794 41 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7794 42 the the DT 40436 7794 43 supposed suppose VBN 40436 7794 44 objectors objector NNS 40436 7794 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7794 46 maintained maintain VBD 40436 7794 47 , , , 40436 7794 48 on on IN 40436 7794 49 the the DT 40436 7794 50 contrary contrary NN 40436 7794 51 , , , 40436 7794 52 that that DT 40436 7794 53 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7794 54 often often RB 40436 7794 55 prevailed prevail VBD 40436 7794 56 over over IN 40436 7794 57 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7794 58 even even RB 40436 7794 59 in in IN 40436 7794 60 the the DT 40436 7794 61 instructed instructed JJ 40436 7794 62 man man NN 40436 7794 63 : : : 40436 7794 64 and and CC 40436 7794 65 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7794 66 called call VBD 40436 7794 67 upon upon IN 40436 7794 68 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7794 69 to to TO 40436 7794 70 explain explain VB 40436 7794 71 , , , 40436 7794 72 upon upon IN 40436 7794 73 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7794 74 principles principle NNS 40436 7794 75 , , , 40436 7794 76 what what WP 40436 7794 77 that that IN 40436 7794 78 mental mental JJ 40436 7794 79 affection affection NN 40436 7794 80 was be VBD 40436 7794 81 , , , 40436 7794 82 which which WDT 40436 7794 83 people people NNS 40436 7794 84 called call VBD 40436 7794 85 , , , 40436 7794 86 being be VBG 40436 7794 87 overcome overcome VBN 40436 7794 88 by by IN 40436 7794 89 the the DT 40436 7794 90 seduction seduction NN 40436 7794 91 of of IN 40436 7794 92 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7794 93 . . . 40436 7795 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7795 2 have have VBP 40436 7795 3 now now RB 40436 7795 4 shown show VBN 40436 7795 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7795 6 that that IN 40436 7795 7 this this DT 40436 7795 8 mental mental JJ 40436 7795 9 affection affection NN 40436 7795 10 is be VBZ 40436 7795 11 nothing nothing NN 40436 7795 12 else else RB 40436 7795 13 but but CC 40436 7795 14 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7795 15 , , , 40436 7795 16 and and CC 40436 7795 17 the the DT 40436 7795 18 gravest grave JJS 40436 7795 19 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7795 20 . . . 40436 7796 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 7796 2 have have VBP 40436 7796 3 admitted admit VBN 40436 7796 4 that that IN 40436 7796 5 those those DT 40436 7796 6 who who WP 40436 7796 7 go go VBP 40436 7796 8 wrong wrong JJ 40436 7796 9 in in IN 40436 7796 10 the the DT 40436 7796 11 choice choice NN 40436 7796 12 of of IN 40436 7796 13 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7796 14 and and CC 40436 7796 15 pains pain NNS 40436 7796 16 -- -- : 40436 7796 17 that that RB 40436 7796 18 is is RB 40436 7796 19 , , , 40436 7796 20 in in IN 40436 7796 21 the the DT 40436 7796 22 choice choice NN 40436 7796 23 of of IN 40436 7796 24 good good JJ 40436 7796 25 and and CC 40436 7796 26 evil evil JJ 40436 7796 27 things thing NNS 40436 7796 28 -- -- : 40436 7796 29 go go VB 40436 7796 30 wrong wrong JJ 40436 7796 31 from from IN 40436 7796 32 want want NN 40436 7796 33 of of IN 40436 7796 34 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7796 35 , , , 40436 7796 36 of of IN 40436 7796 37 the the DT 40436 7796 38 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7796 39 or or CC 40436 7796 40 science science NN 40436 7796 41 of of IN 40436 7796 42 mensuration mensuration NN 40436 7796 43 . . . 40436 7797 1 The the DT 40436 7797 2 wrong wrong JJ 40436 7797 3 deed deed NN 40436 7797 4 done do VBN 40436 7797 5 from from IN 40436 7797 6 want want NN 40436 7797 7 of of IN 40436 7797 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7797 9 , , , 40436 7797 10 is be VBZ 40436 7797 11 done do VBN 40436 7797 12 through through IN 40436 7797 13 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7797 14 . . . 40436 7798 1 What what WP 40436 7798 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7798 3 call call VBP 40436 7798 4 being be VBG 40436 7798 5 overcome overcome VBN 40436 7798 6 by by IN 40436 7798 7 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7798 8 is be VBZ 40436 7798 9 thus thus RB 40436 7798 10 , , , 40436 7798 11 the the DT 40436 7798 12 gravest grave JJS 40436 7798 13 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7798 14 ; ; : 40436 7798 15 which which WDT 40436 7798 16 these these DT 40436 7798 17 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 7798 18 , , , 40436 7798 19 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7798 20 , , , 40436 7798 21 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7798 22 , , , 40436 7798 23 and and CC 40436 7798 24 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 7798 25 , , , 40436 7798 26 engage engage VB 40436 7798 27 to to TO 40436 7798 28 cure cure VB 40436 7798 29 : : : 40436 7798 30 but but CC 40436 7798 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7798 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7798 33 the the DT 40436 7798 34 objectors objector NNS 40436 7798 35 whom whom WP 40436 7798 36 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7798 37 now now RB 40436 7798 38 address address VBP 40436 7798 39 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7798 40 not not RB 40436 7798 41 believing believe VBG 40436 7798 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7798 43 to to TO 40436 7798 44 be be VB 40436 7798 45 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7798 46 , , , 40436 7798 47 or or CC 40436 7798 48 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 7798 49 unwilling unwilling JJ 40436 7798 50 to to TO 40436 7798 51 pay pay VB 40436 7798 52 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7798 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7798 54 fees fee NNS 40436 7798 55 , , , 40436 7798 56 refuse refuse VBP 40436 7798 57 to to TO 40436 7798 58 visit visit VB 40436 7798 59 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7798 60 , , , 40436 7798 61 and and CC 40436 7798 62 therefore therefore RB 40436 7798 63 go go VB 40436 7798 64 on on RP 40436 7798 65 doing do VBG 40436 7798 66 ill ill JJ 40436 7798 67 , , , 40436 7798 68 both both DT 40436 7798 69 privately privately RB 40436 7798 70 and and CC 40436 7798 71 publicly publicly RB 40436 7798 72 . . . 40436 7799 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7799 2 116 116 CD 40436 7799 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7799 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7799 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7799 6 116 116 CD 40436 7799 7 : : : 40436 7799 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7799 9 , , , 40436 7799 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7799 11 . . . 40436 7800 1 p. p. NN 40436 7800 2 357 357 CD 40436 7800 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7800 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7800 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7800 6 Side side NN 40436 7800 7 - - HYPH 40436 7800 8 note note NN 40436 7800 9 : : : 40436 7800 10 Reasoning reasoning NN 40436 7800 11 of of IN 40436 7800 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7800 13 assented assent VBD 40436 7800 14 to to IN 40436 7800 15 by by RB 40436 7800 16 all all DT 40436 7800 17 . . . 40436 7801 1 Actions action NNS 40436 7801 2 which which WDT 40436 7801 3 conduct conduct VBP 40436 7801 4 to to IN 40436 7801 5 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 7801 6 or or CC 40436 7801 7 freedom freedom NN 40436 7801 8 from from IN 40436 7801 9 pain pain NN 40436 7801 10 , , , 40436 7801 11 are be VBP 40436 7801 12 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7801 13 . . . 40436 7801 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7802 1 Now now RB 40436 7802 2 then then RB 40436 7802 3 , , , 40436 7802 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7802 5 , , , 40436 7802 6 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7802 7 , , , 40436 7802 8 and and CC 40436 7802 9 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 7802 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7802 11 continues continue VBZ 40436 7802 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7802 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7802 14 , , , 40436 7802 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7802 16 turn turn VBP 40436 7802 17 to to IN 40436 7802 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7802 19 , , , 40436 7802 20 and and CC 40436 7802 21 ask ask VB 40436 7802 22 , , , 40436 7802 23 whether whether IN 40436 7802 24 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7802 25 account account VBP 40436 7802 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7802 27 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 7802 28 true true JJ 40436 7802 29 or or CC 40436 7802 30 false false JJ 40436 7802 31 ? ? . 40436 7803 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7803 2 All all DT 40436 7803 3 of of IN 40436 7803 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7803 5 pronounced pronounce VBD 40436 7803 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7803 7 to to TO 40436 7803 8 be be VB 40436 7803 9 surpassingly surpassingly RB 40436 7803 10 true true JJ 40436 7803 11 . . . 40436 7803 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7804 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7804 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 7804 3 all all DT 40436 7804 4 agree agree VBP 40436 7804 5 , , , 40436 7804 6 then then RB 40436 7804 7 , , , 40436 7804 8 all all DT 40436 7804 9 three three CD 40436 7804 10 , , , 40436 7804 11 that that IN 40436 7804 12 the the DT 40436 7804 13 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 7804 14 is be VBZ 40436 7804 15 good good JJ 40436 7804 16 , , , 40436 7804 17 and and CC 40436 7804 18 that that IN 40436 7804 19 the the DT 40436 7804 20 painful painful NN 40436 7804 21 is be VBZ 40436 7804 22 evil:[117 evil:[117 NN 40436 7804 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7804 24 for for IN 40436 7804 25 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7804 26 take take VBP 40436 7804 27 no no DT 40436 7804 28 account account NN 40436 7804 29 at at IN 40436 7804 30 present present NN 40436 7804 31 of of IN 40436 7804 32 the the DT 40436 7804 33 verbal verbal JJ 40436 7804 34 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 7804 35 of of IN 40436 7804 36 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 7804 37 , , , 40436 7804 38 discriminating discriminate VBG 40436 7804 39 between between IN 40436 7804 40 the the DT 40436 7804 41 _ _ NNP 40436 7804 42 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7804 43 _ _ NNP 40436 7804 44 , , , 40436 7804 45 the the DT 40436 7804 46 _ _ NNP 40436 7804 47 delightful delightful JJ 40436 7804 48 _ _ NNP 40436 7804 49 , , , 40436 7804 50 and and CC 40436 7804 51 the the DT 40436 7804 52 _ _ NNP 40436 7804 53 enjoyable enjoyable JJ 40436 7804 54 _ _ NNP 40436 7804 55 . . . 40436 7805 1 If if IN 40436 7805 2 this this DT 40436 7805 3 be be NN 40436 7805 4 so so RB 40436 7805 5 , , , 40436 7805 6 are be VBP 40436 7805 7 not not RB 40436 7805 8 all all PDT 40436 7805 9 those those DT 40436 7805 10 actions action NNS 40436 7805 11 , , , 40436 7805 12 which which WDT 40436 7805 13 conduct conduct VBP 40436 7805 14 to to IN 40436 7805 15 a a DT 40436 7805 16 life life NN 40436 7805 17 of of IN 40436 7805 18 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 7805 19 or or CC 40436 7805 20 to to IN 40436 7805 21 a a DT 40436 7805 22 life life NN 40436 7805 23 free free JJ 40436 7805 24 from from IN 40436 7805 25 pain pain NN 40436 7805 26 , , , 40436 7805 27 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7805 28 ? ? . 40436 7806 1 and and CC 40436 7806 2 is be VBZ 40436 7806 3 not not RB 40436 7806 4 the the DT 40436 7806 5 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7806 6 deed deed NN 40436 7806 7 , , , 40436 7806 8 good good JJ 40436 7806 9 and and CC 40436 7806 10 profitable profitable JJ 40436 7806 11 ? ? . 40436 7807 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7807 2 118 118 CD 40436 7807 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7807 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7807 5 In in IN 40436 7807 6 this this DT 40436 7807 7 , , , 40436 7807 8 all all DT 40436 7807 9 persons person NNS 40436 7807 10 present present VBP 40436 7807 11 concurred concur VBN 40436 7807 12 . . . 40436 7807 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7808 1 If if IN 40436 7808 2 then then RB 40436 7808 3 the the DT 40436 7808 4 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 7808 5 is be VBZ 40436 7808 6 good good JJ 40436 7808 7 , , , 40436 7808 8 no no DT 40436 7808 9 one one NN 40436 7808 10 ever ever RB 40436 7808 11 does do VBZ 40436 7808 12 anything anything NN 40436 7808 13 , , , 40436 7808 14 when when WRB 40436 7808 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7808 16 either either CC 40436 7808 17 knows know VBZ 40436 7808 18 or or CC 40436 7808 19 believes believe VBZ 40436 7808 20 other other JJ 40436 7808 21 things thing NNS 40436 7808 22 in in IN 40436 7808 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7808 24 power power NN 40436 7808 25 to to TO 40436 7808 26 be be VB 40436 7808 27 better well JJR 40436 7808 28 . . . 40436 7809 1 To to TO 40436 7809 2 be be VB 40436 7809 3 inferior inferior JJ 40436 7809 4 to to IN 40436 7809 5 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 7809 6 is be VBZ 40436 7809 7 nothing nothing NN 40436 7809 8 else else RB 40436 7809 9 than than IN 40436 7809 10 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7809 11 : : : 40436 7809 12 to to TO 40436 7809 13 be be VB 40436 7809 14 superior superior JJ 40436 7809 15 to to IN 40436 7809 16 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 7809 17 , , , 40436 7809 18 is be VBZ 40436 7809 19 nothing nothing NN 40436 7809 20 else else RB 40436 7809 21 than than IN 40436 7809 22 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 7809 23 . . . 40436 7810 1 Ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7810 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 7810 3 in in IN 40436 7810 4 holding hold VBG 40436 7810 5 false false JJ 40436 7810 6 opinions opinion NNS 40436 7810 7 , , , 40436 7810 8 and and CC 40436 7810 9 in in IN 40436 7810 10 being be VBG 40436 7810 11 deceived deceive VBN 40436 7810 12 respecting respect VBG 40436 7810 13 matters matter NNS 40436 7810 14 of of IN 40436 7810 15 high high JJ 40436 7810 16 importance importance NN 40436 7810 17 . . . 40436 7811 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7811 2 Agreed agree VBN 40436 7811 3 by by RB 40436 7811 4 all all DT 40436 7811 5 . . . 40436 7811 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7812 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 7812 2 , , , 40436 7812 3 no no DT 40436 7812 4 one one NN 40436 7812 5 willingly willingly RB 40436 7812 6 enters enter VBZ 40436 7812 7 upon upon IN 40436 7812 8 courses course NNS 40436 7812 9 which which WDT 40436 7812 10 are be VBP 40436 7812 11 evil evil JJ 40436 7812 12 , , , 40436 7812 13 or or CC 40436 7812 14 which which WDT 40436 7812 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7812 16 believes believe VBZ 40436 7812 17 to to TO 40436 7812 18 be be VB 40436 7812 19 evil evil JJ 40436 7812 20 ; ; : 40436 7812 21 nor nor CC 40436 7812 22 is be VBZ 40436 7812 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7812 24 in in IN 40436 7812 25 the the DT 40436 7812 26 nature nature NN 40436 7812 27 of of IN 40436 7812 28 man man NN 40436 7812 29 to to TO 40436 7812 30 enter enter VB 40436 7812 31 upon upon IN 40436 7812 32 what what WP 40436 7812 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7812 34 thinks think VBZ 40436 7812 35 evil evil JJ 40436 7812 36 courses course NNS 40436 7812 37 , , , 40436 7812 38 in in IN 40436 7812 39 preference preference NN 40436 7812 40 to to IN 40436 7812 41 good good NN 40436 7812 42 . . . 40436 7813 1 When when WRB 40436 7813 2 a a DT 40436 7813 3 man man NN 40436 7813 4 is be VBZ 40436 7813 5 compelled compel VBN 40436 7813 6 to to TO 40436 7813 7 make make VB 40436 7813 8 choice choice NN 40436 7813 9 between between IN 40436 7813 10 two two CD 40436 7813 11 evils evil NNS 40436 7813 12 , , , 40436 7813 13 no no DT 40436 7813 14 one one NN 40436 7813 15 will will MD 40436 7813 16 take take VB 40436 7813 17 the the DT 40436 7813 18 greater great JJR 40436 7813 19 when when WRB 40436 7813 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7813 21 might may MD 40436 7813 22 take take VB 40436 7813 23 the the DT 40436 7813 24 less less JJR 40436 7813 25 . . . 40436 7814 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7814 2 119 119 CD 40436 7814 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7814 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7814 5 Agreed agree VBN 40436 7814 6 to to IN 40436 7814 7 by by IN 40436 7814 8 all all DT 40436 7814 9 three three CD 40436 7814 10 . . . 40436 7814 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7815 1 Farther farther RB 40436 7815 2 , , , 40436 7815 3 no no DT 40436 7815 4 one one NN 40436 7815 5 will will MD 40436 7815 6 affront affront VB 40436 7815 7 things thing NNS 40436 7815 8 of of IN 40436 7815 9 which which WDT 40436 7815 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7815 11 is be VBZ 40436 7815 12 afraid afraid JJ 40436 7815 13 , , , 40436 7815 14 when when WRB 40436 7815 15 other other JJ 40436 7815 16 things thing NNS 40436 7815 17 are be VBP 40436 7815 18 open open JJ 40436 7815 19 to to IN 40436 7815 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7815 21 , , , 40436 7815 22 of of IN 40436 7815 23 which which WDT 40436 7815 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7815 25 is be VBZ 40436 7815 26 not not RB 40436 7815 27 afraid afraid JJ 40436 7815 28 : : : 40436 7815 29 for for IN 40436 7815 30 fear fear NN 40436 7815 31 is be VBZ 40436 7815 32 an an DT 40436 7815 33 expectation expectation NN 40436 7815 34 of of IN 40436 7815 35 evil evil NN 40436 7815 36 , , , 40436 7815 37 so so IN 40436 7815 38 that that IN 40436 7815 39 what what WP 40436 7815 40 a a DT 40436 7815 41 man man NN 40436 7815 42 fears fear VBZ 40436 7815 43 , , , 40436 7815 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7815 45 of of IN 40436 7815 46 course course NN 40436 7815 47 thinks think VBZ 40436 7815 48 to to TO 40436 7815 49 be be VB 40436 7815 50 an an DT 40436 7815 51 evil,--and evil,--and NNP 40436 7815 52 will will MD 40436 7815 53 not not RB 40436 7815 54 approach approach VB 40436 7815 55 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7815 56 willingly willingly RB 40436 7815 57 . . . 40436 7816 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7816 2 Agreed agree VBN 40436 7816 3 . . . 40436 7817 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7817 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7817 3 120 120 CD 40436 7817 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7817 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7817 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7817 7 117 117 CD 40436 7817 8 : : : 40436 7817 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7817 10 , , , 40436 7817 11 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7817 12 . . . 40436 7818 1 p. p. NN 40436 7818 2 358 358 CD 40436 7818 3 A. a. NN 40436 7819 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7819 2 Greek greek JJ 40436 7819 3 : : : 40436 7819 4 u(perphuô u(perphuô NNP 40436 7819 5 = = SYM 40436 7819 6 s s NNP 40436 7819 7 e)do e)do NNP 40436 7819 8 / / SYM 40436 7819 9 kei kei NNP 40436 7819 10 a(/pasin a(/pasin NNP 40436 7819 11 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 7819 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 7819 13 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 7819 14 ei)rême ei)rême NNP 40436 7819 15 / / , 40436 7819 16 na na NN 40436 7819 17 . . . 40436 7820 1 O(mologei O(mologei NNP 40436 7820 2 = = SYM 40436 7820 3 te te NNP 40436 7820 4 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 7820 5 , , , 40436 7820 6 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 7820 7 d d NNP 40436 7820 8 ' ' '' 40436 7820 9 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 7820 10 , , , 40436 7820 11 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7820 12 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7820 13 ê(du\ ê(du\ NNP 40436 7820 14 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 7820 15 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 7820 16 , , , 40436 7820 17 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7820 18 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7820 19 a)niaro\n a)niaro\n NNP 40436 7820 20 kako kako NNP 40436 7820 21 / / SYM 40436 7820 22 n n NNP 40436 7820 23 . . . 40436 7820 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7820 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7821 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7821 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7821 3 118 118 CD 40436 7821 4 : : : 40436 7821 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7821 6 , , , 40436 7821 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7821 8 . . . 40436 7822 1 p. p. NN 40436 7822 2 358 358 CD 40436 7822 3 B. B. NNP 40436 7823 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7823 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7823 3 : : : 40436 7823 4 ai ai VB 40436 7823 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7823 6 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7823 7 tou tou NNP 40436 7823 8 / / SYM 40436 7823 9 tou tou NNP 40436 7823 10 pra pra NNP 40436 7823 11 / / SYM 40436 7823 12 xeis xeis NNP 40436 7823 13 a(/pasai a(/pasai NNP 40436 7823 14 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7823 15 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7823 16 a)lu a)lu NNP 40436 7823 17 / / SYM 40436 7823 18 pôs pôs NNP 40436 7823 19 zê zê NNP 40436 7823 20 = = SYM 40436 7823 21 n n NNP 40436 7823 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7823 23 ê)de ê)de NNP 40436 7823 24 / / SYM 40436 7823 25 ôs ôs UH 40436 7823 26 , , , 40436 7823 27 a)=r a)=r UH 40436 7823 28 ' ' '' 40436 7823 29 ou ou NNP 40436 7823 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7823 31 kalai/ kalai/ NNP 40436 7823 32 ? ? . 40436 7824 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7824 2 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7824 3 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 7824 4 e)/rgon e)/rgon NNP 40436 7824 5 , , , 40436 7824 6 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 7824 7 / / SYM 40436 7824 8 n n NNP 40436 7824 9 te te NNP 40436 7824 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7824 11 ô)phe ô)phe NNP 40436 7824 12 / / SYM 40436 7824 13 limon limon NNP 40436 7824 14 ? ? . 40436 7824 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7824 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7825 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7825 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7825 3 119 119 CD 40436 7825 4 : : : 40436 7825 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7825 6 , , , 40436 7825 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7825 8 . . . 40436 7826 1 p. p. NN 40436 7826 2 358 358 CD 40436 7826 3 C C NNP 40436 7826 4 - - HYPH 40436 7826 5 D. D. NNP 40436 7826 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7826 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7826 8 : : : 40436 7826 9 e)pi/ e)pi/ NNP 40436 7826 10 ge ge NNP 40436 7826 11 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 7826 12 kaka\ kaka\ NNP 40436 7826 13 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s NNP 40436 7826 14 e(kô\n e(kô\n NNP 40436 7826 15 e)/rchetai e)/rchetai NNP 40436 7826 16 , , , 40436 7826 17 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 7826 18 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7826 19 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 7826 20 oi)/etai oi)/etai NNP 40436 7826 21 kaka\ kaka\ NNP 40436 7826 22 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 7826 23 , , , 40436 7826 24 ou)d ou)d NNP 40436 7826 25 ' ' '' 40436 7826 26 e)sti\ e)sti\ : 40436 7826 27 tou tou NNP 40436 7826 28 = = NNP 40436 7826 29 to to IN 40436 7826 30 , , , 40436 7826 31 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7826 32 e)/oiken e)/oiken NNS 40436 7826 33 , , , 40436 7826 34 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7826 35 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 7826 36 / / SYM 40436 7826 37 pou pou NNP 40436 7826 38 phu phu NNP 40436 7826 39 / / SYM 40436 7826 40 sei sei NNP 40436 7826 41 , , , 40436 7826 42 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7826 43 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 7826 44 oi)/etai oi)/etai NNP 40436 7826 45 kaka\ kaka\ NNP 40436 7826 46 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7826 47 e)the e)the NN 40436 7826 48 / / SYM 40436 7826 49 lein lein NNP 40436 7826 50 i)e i)e NNP 40436 7826 51 / / SYM 40436 7826 52 nai nai NNP 40436 7826 53 a)nti\ a)nti\ NNP 40436 7826 54 tô tô NNP 40436 7826 55 = = SYM 40436 7826 56 n n NNP 40436 7826 57 a)gathô a)gathô CD 40436 7826 58 = = SYM 40436 7826 59 n n CC 40436 7826 60 ; ; : 40436 7826 61 o(/tan o(/tan NNP 40436 7826 62 te te NNP 40436 7826 63 a)nagka a)nagka NNP 40436 7826 64 / / SYM 40436 7826 65 sthê| sthê| NNP 40436 7826 66 duoi duoi NNP 40436 7826 67 = = NFP 40436 7826 68 n n NNP 40436 7826 69 kakoi kakoi NNP 40436 7826 70 = = SYM 40436 7826 71 n n CC 40436 7826 72 to\ to\ NN 40436 7826 73 e(/teron e(/teron NNP 40436 7826 74 ai)rei ai)rei NNP 40436 7826 75 = = SYM 40436 7826 76 sthai sthai NNP 40436 7826 77 , , , 40436 7826 78 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 7826 79 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7826 80 mei mei NNP 40436 7826 81 = = NFP 40436 7826 82 zon zon NNP 40436 7826 83 ai(rê ai(rê NNP 40436 7826 84 / / SYM 40436 7826 85 setai setai NN 40436 7826 86 , , , 40436 7826 87 e)xo\n e)xo\n ADD 40436 7826 88 to\ to\ NN 40436 7826 89 e)/latton e)/latton NNP 40436 7826 90 . . . 40436 7826 91 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7826 92 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7827 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7827 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7827 3 120 120 CD 40436 7827 4 : : : 40436 7827 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7827 6 , , , 40436 7827 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7827 8 . . . 40436 7828 1 p. p. NN 40436 7828 2 358 358 CD 40436 7828 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7828 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7828 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7828 6 Side side NN 40436 7828 7 - - HYPH 40436 7828 8 note note NN 40436 7828 9 : : : 40436 7828 10 Explanation explanation NN 40436 7828 11 of of IN 40436 7828 12 courage courage NN 40436 7828 13 . . . 40436 7829 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7829 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 7829 3 in in IN 40436 7829 4 a a DT 40436 7829 5 wise wise JJ 40436 7829 6 estimate estimate NN 40436 7829 7 of of IN 40436 7829 8 things thing NNS 40436 7829 9 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7829 10 and and CC 40436 7829 11 not not RB 40436 7829 12 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7829 13 . . . 40436 7829 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7830 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7830 2 Sokr._--Let Sokr._--Let NNP 40436 7830 3 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7830 4 now now RB 40436 7830 5 revert revert VBP 40436 7830 6 to to IN 40436 7830 7 the the DT 40436 7830 8 explanation explanation NN 40436 7830 9 of of IN 40436 7830 10 courage courage NN 40436 7830 11 , , , 40436 7830 12 given give VBN 40436 7830 13 by by IN 40436 7830 14 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7830 15 . . . 40436 7831 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7831 2 said say VBD 40436 7831 3 that that IN 40436 7831 4 four four CD 40436 7831 5 out out IN 40436 7831 6 of of IN 40436 7831 7 the the DT 40436 7831 8 five five CD 40436 7831 9 parts part NNS 40436 7831 10 of of IN 40436 7831 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 7831 12 were be VBD 40436 7831 13 tolerably tolerably RB 40436 7831 14 similar similar JJ 40436 7831 15 ; ; : 40436 7831 16 but but CC 40436 7831 17 that that DT 40436 7831 18 courage courage NN 40436 7831 19 differed differ VBD 40436 7831 20 greatly greatly RB 40436 7831 21 from from IN 40436 7831 22 all all DT 40436 7831 23 of of IN 40436 7831 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7831 25 . . . 40436 7832 1 And and CC 40436 7832 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7832 3 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 7832 4 that that IN 40436 7832 5 there there EX 40436 7832 6 were be VBD 40436 7832 7 men man NNS 40436 7832 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 7832 9 for for IN 40436 7832 10 courage courage NN 40436 7832 11 ; ; : 40436 7832 12 yet yet CC 40436 7832 13 at at IN 40436 7832 14 the the DT 40436 7832 15 same same JJ 40436 7832 16 time time NN 40436 7832 17 eminently eminently RB 40436 7832 18 unjust unjust JJ 40436 7832 19 , , , 40436 7832 20 immoderate immoderate VBP 40436 7832 21 , , , 40436 7832 22 unholy unholy JJ 40436 7832 23 , , , 40436 7832 24 and and CC 40436 7832 25 stupid stupid JJ 40436 7832 26 . . . 40436 7833 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7833 2 said say VBD 40436 7833 3 , , , 40436 7833 4 too too RB 40436 7833 5 , , , 40436 7833 6 that that IN 40436 7833 7 the the DT 40436 7833 8 courageous courageous JJ 40436 7833 9 men man NNS 40436 7833 10 were be VBD 40436 7833 11 men man NNS 40436 7833 12 to to TO 40436 7833 13 attempt attempt VB 40436 7833 14 things thing NNS 40436 7833 15 which which WDT 40436 7833 16 timid timid JJ 40436 7833 17 men man NNS 40436 7833 18 would would MD 40436 7833 19 not not RB 40436 7833 20 approach approach VB 40436 7833 21 . . . 40436 7834 1 Now now RB 40436 7834 2 , , , 40436 7834 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7834 4 , , , 40436 7834 5 what what WP 40436 7834 6 are be VBP 40436 7834 7 these these DT 40436 7834 8 things thing NNS 40436 7834 9 which which WDT 40436 7834 10 the the DT 40436 7834 11 courageous courageous JJ 40436 7834 12 men man NNS 40436 7834 13 alone alone RB 40436 7834 14 are be VBP 40436 7834 15 prepared prepared JJ 40436 7834 16 to to TO 40436 7834 17 attempt attempt VB 40436 7834 18 ? ? . 40436 7835 1 Will Will MD 40436 7835 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7835 3 attempt attempt VB 40436 7835 4 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7835 5 things thing NNS 40436 7835 6 , , , 40436 7835 7 believing believe VBG 40436 7835 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7835 9 to to TO 40436 7835 10 be be VB 40436 7835 11 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7835 12 ? ? . 40436 7836 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7836 2 Prot._--That Prot._--That NNP 40436 7836 3 is be VBZ 40436 7836 4 impossible impossible JJ 40436 7836 5 , , , 40436 7836 6 as as IN 40436 7836 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7836 8 have have VBP 40436 7836 9 shown show VBN 40436 7836 10 just just RB 40436 7836 11 now now RB 40436 7836 12 . . . 40436 7837 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7837 2 Sokr._--No Sokr._--No NNP 40436 7837 3 one one PRP 40436 7837 4 will will MD 40436 7837 5 enter enter VB 40436 7837 6 upon upon IN 40436 7837 7 that that DT 40436 7837 8 which which WDT 40436 7837 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7837 10 believes believe VBZ 40436 7837 11 to to TO 40436 7837 12 be be VB 40436 7837 13 terrible,--or terrible,--or NN 40436 7837 14 , , , 40436 7837 15 in in IN 40436 7837 16 other other JJ 40436 7837 17 words word NNS 40436 7837 18 , , , 40436 7837 19 will will MD 40436 7837 20 go go VB 40436 7837 21 into into IN 40436 7837 22 evil evil NN 40436 7837 23 knowing know VBG 40436 7837 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7837 25 to to TO 40436 7837 26 be be VB 40436 7837 27 evil evil JJ 40436 7837 28 : : : 40436 7837 29 a a DT 40436 7837 30 man man NN 40436 7837 31 who who WP 40436 7837 32 does do VBZ 40436 7837 33 so so RB 40436 7837 34 is be VBZ 40436 7837 35 inferior inferior JJ 40436 7837 36 to to IN 40436 7837 37 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7837 38 -- -- : 40436 7837 39 and and CC 40436 7837 40 this this DT 40436 7837 41 , , , 40436 7837 42 as as IN 40436 7837 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7837 44 have have VBP 40436 7837 45 agreed agree VBN 40436 7837 46 , , , 40436 7837 47 is be VBZ 40436 7837 48 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7837 49 , , , 40436 7837 50 or or CC 40436 7837 51 the the DT 40436 7837 52 contrary contrary NN 40436 7837 53 of of IN 40436 7837 54 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7837 55 . . . 40436 7838 1 All all DT 40436 7838 2 men man NNS 40436 7838 3 , , , 40436 7838 4 both both CC 40436 7838 5 timid timid JJ 40436 7838 6 and and CC 40436 7838 7 brave brave JJ 40436 7838 8 , , , 40436 7838 9 attempt attempt VB 40436 7838 10 things thing NNS 40436 7838 11 upon upon IN 40436 7838 12 which which WDT 40436 7838 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7838 14 have have VBP 40436 7838 15 a a DT 40436 7838 16 good good JJ 40436 7838 17 heart heart NN 40436 7838 18 : : : 40436 7838 19 in in IN 40436 7838 20 this this DT 40436 7838 21 respect respect NN 40436 7838 22 , , , 40436 7838 23 the the DT 40436 7838 24 things thing NNS 40436 7838 25 which which WDT 40436 7838 26 the the DT 40436 7838 27 timid timid NN 40436 7838 28 and and CC 40436 7838 29 the the DT 40436 7838 30 brave brave JJ 40436 7838 31 go go VBP 40436 7838 32 at at IN 40436 7838 33 , , , 40436 7838 34 are be VBP 40436 7838 35 the the DT 40436 7838 36 same same JJ 40436 7838 37 . . . 40436 7839 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7839 2 121 121 CD 40436 7839 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7839 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7839 5 Prot._--How Prot._--How NNP 40436 7839 6 can can MD 40436 7839 7 this this DT 40436 7839 8 be be VB 40436 7839 9 ? ? . 40436 7840 1 The the DT 40436 7840 2 things thing NNS 40436 7840 3 which which WDT 40436 7840 4 the the DT 40436 7840 5 timid timid NN 40436 7840 6 and and CC 40436 7840 7 the the DT 40436 7840 8 brave brave JJ 40436 7840 9 go go VBP 40436 7840 10 at at IN 40436 7840 11 or or CC 40436 7840 12 affront affront NN 40436 7840 13 , , , 40436 7840 14 are be VBP 40436 7840 15 quite quite RB 40436 7840 16 contrary contrary JJ 40436 7840 17 : : : 40436 7840 18 for for IN 40436 7840 19 example example NN 40436 7840 20 , , , 40436 7840 21 the the DT 40436 7840 22 latter latter JJ 40436 7840 23 are be VBP 40436 7840 24 willing willing JJ 40436 7840 25 to to TO 40436 7840 26 go go VB 40436 7840 27 to to IN 40436 7840 28 war war NN 40436 7840 29 , , , 40436 7840 30 which which WDT 40436 7840 31 the the DT 40436 7840 32 former former JJ 40436 7840 33 are be VBP 40436 7840 34 not not RB 40436 7840 35 . . . 40436 7841 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7841 2 Sokr._--Is Sokr._--Is NNP 40436 7841 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7841 4 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7841 5 to to TO 40436 7841 6 go go VB 40436 7841 7 to to IN 40436 7841 8 war war NN 40436 7841 9 , , , 40436 7841 10 or or CC 40436 7841 11 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 7841 12 ? ? . 40436 7842 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7842 2 Prot._--Honourable Prot._--Honourable NNP 40436 7842 3 . . . 40436 7843 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7843 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 7843 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7843 4 be be VB 40436 7843 5 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7843 6 , , , 40436 7843 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7843 8 must must MD 40436 7843 9 also also RB 40436 7843 10 be be VB 40436 7843 11 good:[122 good:[122 NNP 40436 7843 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7843 13 for for IN 40436 7843 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7843 15 have have VBP 40436 7843 16 agreed agree VBN 40436 7843 17 , , , 40436 7843 18 in in IN 40436 7843 19 the the DT 40436 7843 20 preceding precede VBG 40436 7843 21 debate debate NN 40436 7843 22 , , , 40436 7843 23 that that IN 40436 7843 24 all all DT 40436 7843 25 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7843 26 things thing NNS 40436 7843 27 were be VBD 40436 7843 28 good good JJ 40436 7843 29 . . . 40436 7844 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7844 2 Prot._--You Prot._--You NNPS 40436 7844 3 speak speak VBP 40436 7844 4 truly truly RB 40436 7844 5 . . . 40436 7845 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7845 2 123 123 CD 40436 7845 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7845 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7845 5 at at IN 40436 7845 6 least least JJS 40436 7845 7 always always RB 40436 7845 8 persist persist VB 40436 7845 9 in in IN 40436 7845 10 thinking thinking NN 40436 7845 11 so so RB 40436 7845 12 . . . 40436 7846 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7846 2 Sokr._--Which Sokr._--Which NNP 40436 7846 3 of of IN 40436 7846 4 the the DT 40436 7846 5 two two CD 40436 7846 6 is be VBZ 40436 7846 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7846 8 , , , 40436 7846 9 who who WP 40436 7846 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7846 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7846 12 say say VBP 40436 7846 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7846 14 are be VBP 40436 7846 15 unwilling unwilling JJ 40436 7846 16 to to TO 40436 7846 17 go go VB 40436 7846 18 into into IN 40436 7846 19 war war NN 40436 7846 20 ; ; : 40436 7846 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7846 22 being be VBG 40436 7846 23 an an DT 40436 7846 24 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7846 25 and and CC 40436 7846 26 good good JJ 40436 7846 27 thing thing NN 40436 7846 28 ? ? . 40436 7847 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7847 2 Prot._--The Prot._--The NNP 40436 7847 3 cowards coward NNS 40436 7847 4 . . . 40436 7848 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7848 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 7848 3 if if IN 40436 7848 4 going go VBG 40436 7848 5 to to IN 40436 7848 6 war war NN 40436 7848 7 be be VB 40436 7848 8 an an DT 40436 7848 9 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7848 10 and and CC 40436 7848 11 good good JJ 40436 7848 12 thing thing NN 40436 7848 13 , , , 40436 7848 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7848 15 is be VBZ 40436 7848 16 also also RB 40436 7848 17 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7848 18 ? ? . 40436 7849 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7849 2 Prot._--Certainly Prot._--Certainly NNP 40436 7849 3 that that WDT 40436 7849 4 has have VBZ 40436 7849 5 been be VBN 40436 7849 6 admitted admit VBN 40436 7849 7 . . . 40436 7850 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7850 2 124 124 CD 40436 7850 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7850 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7850 5 Sokr._--Is Sokr._--Is NNP 40436 7850 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7850 7 then then RB 40436 7850 8 knowingly knowingly RB 40436 7850 9 that that IN 40436 7850 10 cowards coward NNS 40436 7850 11 refuse refuse VBP 40436 7850 12 to to TO 40436 7850 13 go go VB 40436 7850 14 into into IN 40436 7850 15 war war NN 40436 7850 16 , , , 40436 7850 17 which which WDT 40436 7850 18 is be VBZ 40436 7850 19 both both DT 40436 7850 20 more more RBR 40436 7850 21 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7850 22 , , , 40436 7850 23 better well JJR 40436 7850 24 , , , 40436 7850 25 and and CC 40436 7850 26 more more RBR 40436 7850 27 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7850 28 ? ? . 40436 7851 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7851 2 Prot._--We Prot._--We NNP 40436 7851 3 can can MD 40436 7851 4 not not RB 40436 7851 5 say say VB 40436 7851 6 so so RB 40436 7851 7 , , , 40436 7851 8 without without IN 40436 7851 9 contradicting contradict VBG 40436 7851 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7851 11 preceding precede VBG 40436 7851 12 admissions admission NNS 40436 7851 13 . . . 40436 7852 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7852 2 Sokr._--What Sokr._--What NNP 40436 7852 3 about about IN 40436 7852 4 the the DT 40436 7852 5 courageous courageous JJ 40436 7852 6 man man NN 40436 7852 7 ? ? . 40436 7853 1 does do VBZ 40436 7853 2 not not RB 40436 7853 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7853 4 affront affront VB 40436 7853 5 or or CC 40436 7853 6 go go VB 40436 7853 7 at at IN 40436 7853 8 what what WP 40436 7853 9 is be VBZ 40436 7853 10 more more RBR 40436 7853 11 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7853 12 , , , 40436 7853 13 better well JJR 40436 7853 14 , , , 40436 7853 15 and and CC 40436 7853 16 more more RBR 40436 7853 17 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 7853 18 ? ? . 40436 7854 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7854 2 Prot._--It Prot._--It NNP 40436 7854 3 can can MD 40436 7854 4 not not RB 40436 7854 5 be be VB 40436 7854 6 denied deny VBN 40436 7854 7 . . . 40436 7855 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7855 2 Sokr._--Courageous sokr._--courageous JJ 40436 7855 3 men man NNS 40436 7855 4 then then RB 40436 7855 5 , , , 40436 7855 6 generally generally RB 40436 7855 7 , , , 40436 7855 8 are be VBP 40436 7855 9 those those DT 40436 7855 10 whose whose WP$ 40436 7855 11 fears fear NNS 40436 7855 12 , , , 40436 7855 13 when when WRB 40436 7855 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7855 15 are be VBP 40436 7855 16 afraid afraid JJ 40436 7855 17 , , , 40436 7855 18 are be VBP 40436 7855 19 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7855 20 and and CC 40436 7855 21 good good JJ 40436 7855 22 -- -- : 40436 7855 23 not not RB 40436 7855 24 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 7855 25 or or CC 40436 7855 26 bad bad JJ 40436 7855 27 : : : 40436 7855 28 and and CC 40436 7855 29 whose whose WP$ 40436 7855 30 confidence confidence NN 40436 7855 31 , , , 40436 7855 32 when when WRB 40436 7855 33 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7855 34 feel feel VBP 40436 7855 35 confident confident JJ 40436 7855 36 , , , 40436 7855 37 is be VBZ 40436 7855 38 also also RB 40436 7855 39 honourable honourable JJ 40436 7855 40 and and CC 40436 7855 41 good good JJ 40436 7855 42 ? ? . 40436 7856 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7856 2 125 125 CD 40436 7856 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7856 4 On on IN 40436 7856 5 the the DT 40436 7856 6 contrary contrary NN 40436 7856 7 , , , 40436 7856 8 cowards coward NNS 40436 7856 9 , , , 40436 7856 10 impudent impudent JJ 40436 7856 11 men man NNS 40436 7856 12 , , , 40436 7856 13 and and CC 40436 7856 14 madmen madman NNS 40436 7856 15 , , , 40436 7856 16 both both DT 40436 7856 17 fear fear VBP 40436 7856 18 , , , 40436 7856 19 and and CC 40436 7856 20 feel feel VB 40436 7856 21 confidence confidence NN 40436 7856 22 , , , 40436 7856 23 on on IN 40436 7856 24 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 7856 25 occasions occasion NNS 40436 7856 26 ? ? . 40436 7857 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7857 2 Prot._--Agreed Prot._--Agreed NNP 40436 7857 3 . . . 40436 7858 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7858 2 Sokr._--When Sokr._--When NNP 40436 7858 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7858 4 thus thus RB 40436 7858 5 view view VBP 40436 7858 6 with with IN 40436 7858 7 confidence confidence NN 40436 7858 8 things thing NNS 40436 7858 9 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 7858 10 and and CC 40436 7858 11 evil evil NN 40436 7858 12 , , , 40436 7858 13 is be VBZ 40436 7858 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7858 15 from from IN 40436 7858 16 any any DT 40436 7858 17 other other JJ 40436 7858 18 reason reason NN 40436 7858 19 than than IN 40436 7858 20 from from IN 40436 7858 21 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7858 22 and and CC 40436 7858 23 stupidity stupidity NN 40436 7858 24 ? ? . 40436 7859 1 Are be VBP 40436 7859 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7859 3 not not RB 40436 7859 4 cowards coward NNS 40436 7859 5 from from IN 40436 7859 6 stupidity stupidity NN 40436 7859 7 , , , 40436 7859 8 or or CC 40436 7859 9 a a DT 40436 7859 10 stupid stupid JJ 40436 7859 11 estimate estimate NN 40436 7859 12 of of IN 40436 7859 13 things thing NNS 40436 7859 14 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7859 15 ? ? . 40436 7860 1 And and CC 40436 7860 2 is be VBZ 40436 7860 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7860 4 not not RB 40436 7860 5 in in IN 40436 7860 6 this this DT 40436 7860 7 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 7860 8 , , , 40436 7860 9 or or CC 40436 7860 10 stupid stupid JJ 40436 7860 11 estimate estimate NN 40436 7860 12 of of IN 40436 7860 13 things thing NNS 40436 7860 14 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7860 15 , , , 40436 7860 16 and and CC 40436 7860 17 things thing NNS 40436 7860 18 not not RB 40436 7860 19 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7860 20 -- -- : 40436 7860 21 that that DT 40436 7860 22 cowardice cowardice NN 40436 7860 23 consists consist VBZ 40436 7860 24 ? ? . 40436 7861 1 Lastly,[126]--courage lastly,[126]--courage NN 40436 7861 2 being be VBG 40436 7861 3 the the DT 40436 7861 4 opposite opposite NN 40436 7861 5 of of IN 40436 7861 6 cowardice cowardice NN 40436 7861 7 -- -- : 40436 7861 8 is be VBZ 40436 7861 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7861 10 not not RB 40436 7861 11 in in IN 40436 7861 12 the the DT 40436 7861 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7861 14 , , , 40436 7861 15 or or CC 40436 7861 16 wise wise JJ 40436 7861 17 estimate estimate NN 40436 7861 18 , , , 40436 7861 19 of of IN 40436 7861 20 things thing NNS 40436 7861 21 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7861 22 and and CC 40436 7861 23 things thing NNS 40436 7861 24 not not RB 40436 7861 25 terrible terrible JJ 40436 7861 26 , , , 40436 7861 27 that that DT 40436 7861 28 courage courage NN 40436 7861 29 consists consist VBZ 40436 7861 30 ? ? . 40436 7862 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7862 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7862 3 121 121 CD 40436 7862 4 : : : 40436 7862 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7862 6 , , , 40436 7862 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7862 8 . . . 40436 7863 1 p. p. NN 40436 7863 2 359 359 CD 40436 7863 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7863 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7863 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7863 6 : : : 40436 7863 7 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7863 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7863 9 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 7863 10 deina\ deina\ VBP 40436 7863 11 ê(gei ê(gei UH 40436 7863 12 = = SYM 40436 7863 13 tai tai NNP 40436 7863 14 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7863 15 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s NN 40436 7863 16 e)/rchetai e)/rchetai XX 40436 7863 17 , , , 40436 7863 18 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ NNP 40436 7863 19 to\ to\ NN 40436 7863 20 ê(/ttô ê(/ttô NNP 40436 7863 21 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 7863 22 e(autou= e(autou= NNP 40436 7863 23 eu(re eu(re NNP 40436 7863 24 / / SYM 40436 7863 25 thê thê NNP 40436 7863 26 a)mathi a)mathi , 40436 7863 27 / / , 40436 7863 28 a a DT 40436 7863 29 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 7863 30 . . . 40436 7864 1 Ô(molo Ô(molo NNP 40436 7864 2 / / SYM 40436 7864 3 gei gei NNP 40436 7864 4 . . . 40436 7865 1 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 7865 2 mê\n mê\n NNP 40436 7865 3 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7865 4 a(/ a(/ NNP 40436 7865 5 ge ge NNP 40436 7865 6 thar)r(ou thar)r(ou FW 40436 7865 7 = = SYM 40436 7865 8 si si NNP 40436 7865 9 pa pa NNP 40436 7865 10 / / SYM 40436 7865 11 ntes ntes NNP 40436 7865 12 au)= au)= POS 40436 7865 13 e)/rchontai e)/rchontai NNP 40436 7865 14 , , , 40436 7865 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7865 16 deiloi\ deiloi\ NNP 40436 7865 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7865 18 a)ndrei a)ndrei NNP 40436 7865 19 = = SYM 40436 7865 20 oi oi UH 40436 7865 21 , , , 40436 7865 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7865 23 tau tau NNP 40436 7865 24 / / SYM 40436 7865 25 tê| tê| NNP 40436 7865 26 ge ge NNP 40436 7865 27 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7865 28 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 7865 29 au)ta\ au)ta\ JJ 40436 7865 30 e)/rchontai e)/rchontai IN 40436 7865 31 oi oi PRP 40436 7865 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7865 33 deiloi/ deiloi/ NNP 40436 7865 34 te te NNP 40436 7865 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7865 36 oi oi NNP 40436 7865 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7865 38 a)ndrei a)ndrei , 40436 7865 39 = = SYM 40436 7865 40 oi oi UH 40436 7865 41 . . . 40436 7865 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7865 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7866 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7866 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 7866 3 122 122 CD 40436 7866 4 : : : 40436 7866 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7866 6 , , , 40436 7866 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7866 8 . . . 40436 7867 1 p. p. NN 40436 7867 2 359 359 CD 40436 7867 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7867 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7867 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7867 6 : : : 40436 7867 7 po po NNP 40436 7867 8 / / SYM 40436 7867 9 teron teron NNP 40436 7867 10 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 7867 11 o(\n o(\n NNP 40436 7867 12 i)e i)e NNP 40436 7867 13 / / SYM 40436 7867 14 nai nai NNP 40436 7867 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7867 16 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 7867 17 to\n to\n NNP 40436 7867 18 po po NNP 40436 7867 19 / / SYM 40436 7867 20 lemon lemon NN 40436 7867 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7867 22 ê)\ ê)\ ADD 40436 7867 23 ai)schro ai)schro VB 40436 7867 24 / / SYM 40436 7867 25 n n JJ 40436 7867 26 ? ? . 40436 7868 1 Kalo Kalo NNP 40436 7868 2 / / SYM 40436 7868 3 n n NNP 40436 7868 4 , , , 40436 7868 5 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 7868 6 . . . 40436 7869 1 Ou)kou ou)kou CD 40436 7869 2 = = SYM 40436 7869 3 n n CC 40436 7869 4 , , , 40436 7869 5 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 7869 6 kalo kalo NNP 40436 7869 7 / / SYM 40436 7869 8 n n NNP 40436 7869 9 , , , 40436 7869 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7869 11 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 7869 12 ô(mologê ô(mologê NNP 40436 7869 13 / / SYM 40436 7869 14 samen saman NNS 40436 7869 15 e)n e)n NNP 40436 7869 16 toi toi NNP 40436 7869 17 = = SYM 40436 7869 18 s s NN 40436 7869 19 e)/mprosthen e)/mprosthen VBP 40436 7869 20 ; ; : 40436 7869 21 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 7869 22 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7869 23 kala\s kala\s HYPH 40436 7869 24 pra pra NNP 40436 7869 25 / / SYM 40436 7869 26 xeis xeis NNP 40436 7869 27 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 7869 28 / / SYM 40436 7869 29 sas sas NNP 40436 7869 30 a)gatha\s a)gatha\s NNP 40436 7869 31 ô(mologê ô(mologê JJ 40436 7869 32 / / SYM 40436 7869 33 samen saman NNS 40436 7869 34 ? ? . 40436 7869 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7869 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7870 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7870 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7870 3 123 123 CD 40436 7870 4 : : : 40436 7870 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7870 6 , , , 40436 7870 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7870 8 . . . 40436 7871 1 p. p. NN 40436 7871 2 359 359 CD 40436 7871 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7871 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7871 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7871 6 : : : 40436 7871 7 A)lêthê= A)lêthê= NNP 40436 7871 8 le le NNP 40436 7871 9 / / SYM 40436 7871 10 geis geis NNP 40436 7871 11 , , , 40436 7871 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7871 13 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 7871 14 e)/moige e)/moige NNP 40436 7871 15 dokei= dokei= VBP 40436 7871 16 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 7871 17 . . . 40436 7871 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7872 1 This this DT 40436 7872 2 answer answer NN 40436 7872 3 , , , 40436 7872 4 put put VBN 40436 7872 5 into into IN 40436 7872 6 the the DT 40436 7872 7 mouth mouth NN 40436 7872 8 of of IN 40436 7872 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7872 10 , , , 40436 7872 11 affords afford VBZ 40436 7872 12 another another DT 40436 7872 13 proof proof NN 40436 7872 14 that that IN 40436 7872 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7872 16 did do VBD 40436 7872 17 not not RB 40436 7872 18 intend intend VB 40436 7872 19 to to TO 40436 7872 20 impute impute VB 40436 7872 21 to to IN 40436 7872 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7872 23 the the DT 40436 7872 24 character character NN 40436 7872 25 which which WDT 40436 7872 26 many many JJ 40436 7872 27 commentators commentator NNS 40436 7872 28 impute impute VBP 40436 7872 29 . . . 40436 7872 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7873 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7873 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7873 3 124 124 CD 40436 7873 4 : : : 40436 7873 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7873 6 , , , 40436 7873 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7873 8 . . . 40436 7874 1 p. p. NN 40436 7874 2 360 360 CD 40436 7874 3 A. a. NN 40436 7875 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7875 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7875 3 : : : 40436 7875 4 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 7875 5 = = SYM 40436 7875 6 n n NN 40436 7875 7 , , , 40436 7875 8 ê)\n ê)\n CD 40436 7875 9 d d NNP 40436 7875 10 ' ' '' 40436 7875 11 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 7875 12 , , , 40436 7875 13 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 7875 14 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 7875 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7875 16 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 7875 17 / / SYM 40436 7875 18 n n NNP 40436 7875 19 , , , 40436 7875 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7875 21 ê(du/ ê(du/ NNP 40436 7875 22 ? ? . 40436 7876 1 Ô(molo Ô(molo NNP 40436 7876 2 / / SYM 40436 7876 3 gêtai gêtai NNP 40436 7876 4 gou gou NNP 40436 7876 5 = = SYM 40436 7876 6 n n CC 40436 7876 7 , , , 40436 7876 8 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 7876 9 . . . 40436 7876 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7876 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7877 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7877 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7877 3 125 125 CD 40436 7877 4 : : : 40436 7877 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7877 6 , , , 40436 7877 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7877 8 . . . 40436 7878 1 p. p. NN 40436 7878 2 360 360 CD 40436 7878 3 B. B. NNP 40436 7879 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7879 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7879 3 : : : 40436 7879 4 Ou)kou ou)kou ADD 40436 7879 5 = = SYM 40436 7879 6 n n CC 40436 7879 7 o(/lôs o(/lôs NNP 40436 7879 8 oi oi NNP 40436 7879 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7879 10 a)ndrei a)ndrei , 40436 7879 11 = = SYM 40436 7879 12 oi oi UH 40436 7879 13 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 7879 14 ai)schrou\s ai)schrou\s NNP 40436 7879 15 pho pho NN 40436 7879 16 / / SYM 40436 7879 17 bous bous JJ 40436 7879 18 phobou phobou NNS 40436 7879 19 = = SYM 40436 7879 20 ntai ntai NNP 40436 7879 21 , , , 40436 7879 22 o(/tav o(/tav NNP 40436 7879 23 phobô phobô NNP 40436 7879 24 = = SYM 40436 7879 25 ntai ntai NNP 40436 7879 26 , , , 40436 7879 27 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 7879 28 ai)schra\ ai)schra\ NNP 40436 7879 29 tha tha NN 40436 7879 30 / / SYM 40436 7879 31 r)r(ê r)r(ê NNP 40436 7879 32 tha tha NNP 40436 7879 33 / / SYM 40436 7879 34 r)r(ou r)r(ou NN 40436 7879 35 = = SYM 40436 7879 36 sin sin NN 40436 7879 37 ? ? . 40436 7880 1 . . . 40436 7881 1 . . . 40436 7882 1 . . . 40436 7883 1 Ei Ei NNP 40436 7883 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7883 3 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7883 4 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 7883 5 ai)schra/ ai)schra/ NN 40436 7883 6 , , , 40436 7883 7 a)=r a)=r UH 40436 7883 8 ' ' '' 40436 7883 9 ou ou NNP 40436 7883 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7883 11 kala/ kala/ NNP 40436 7883 12 ? ? . 40436 7884 1 . . . 40436 7885 1 . . . 40436 7886 1 . . . 40436 7887 1 Ei Ei NNP 40436 7887 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7887 3 de\ de\ NNP 40436 7887 4 kala/ kala/ NNP 40436 7887 5 , , , 40436 7887 6 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7887 7 a)gatha/ a)gatha/ NNP 40436 7887 8 ? ? . 40436 7887 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7887 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7888 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7888 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7888 3 126 126 CD 40436 7888 4 : : : 40436 7888 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7888 6 , , , 40436 7888 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7888 8 . . . 40436 7889 1 p. p. NN 40436 7889 2 360 360 CD 40436 7889 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7889 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7889 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7889 6 : : : 40436 7889 7 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 7889 8 = = SYM 40436 7889 9 n n CC 40436 7889 10 ê ê NNP 40436 7889 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7889 12 tô tô NNP 40436 7889 13 = = SYM 40436 7889 14 n n NNP 40436 7889 15 deinôn deinôn NNP 40436 7889 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7889 17 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 7889 18 deinô deinô NNP 40436 7889 19 = = SYM 40436 7889 20 n n CC 40436 7889 21 a)mathi a)mathi NNP 40436 7889 22 / / SYM 40436 7889 23 a a DT 40436 7889 24 deili deili NN 40436 7889 25 / / , 40436 7889 26 a a DT 40436 7889 27 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 7889 28 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 7889 29 ? ? . 40436 7890 1 . . . 40436 7891 1 . . . 40436 7892 1 . . . 40436 7893 1 Ê Ê NNP 40436 7893 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7893 3 sophi sophi NNS 40436 7893 4 / / , 40436 7893 5 a a NN 40436 7893 6 a)/ra a)/ra XX 40436 7893 7 tô tô NNP 40436 7893 8 = = SYM 40436 7893 9 n n CC 40436 7893 10 deinô deinô NNP 40436 7893 11 = = SYM 40436 7893 12 n n NNP 40436 7893 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7893 14 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 7893 15 deinô deinô NN 40436 7893 16 = = SYM 40436 7893 17 n n CD 40436 7893 18 , , , 40436 7893 19 a)ndrei a)ndrei , 40436 7893 20 / / SYM 40436 7893 21 a a DT 40436 7893 22 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 7893 23 / / SYM 40436 7893 24 n n NN 40436 7893 25 , , , 40436 7893 26 e)nanti e)nanti CD 40436 7893 27 / / SYM 40436 7893 28 a a DT 40436 7893 29 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 7893 30 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 7893 31 tou tou NNP 40436 7893 32 / / SYM 40436 7893 33 tôn tôn NNP 40436 7893 34 a)mathi a)mathi , 40436 7893 35 / / SYM 40436 7893 36 a| a| NN 40436 7893 37 ? ? . 40436 7893 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7893 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7894 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7894 2 Side side NN 40436 7894 3 - - HYPH 40436 7894 4 note note NN 40436 7894 5 : : : 40436 7894 6 Reluctance Reluctance NNP 40436 7894 7 of of IN 40436 7894 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7894 9 to to TO 40436 7894 10 continue continue VB 40436 7894 11 answering answer VBG 40436 7894 12 . . . 40436 7895 1 Close close NN 40436 7895 2 of of IN 40436 7895 3 the the DT 40436 7895 4 discussion discussion NN 40436 7895 5 . . . 40436 7896 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7896 2 declares declare VBZ 40436 7896 3 that that IN 40436 7896 4 the the DT 40436 7896 5 subject subject NN 40436 7896 6 is be VBZ 40436 7896 7 still still RB 40436 7896 8 in in IN 40436 7896 9 confusion confusion NN 40436 7896 10 , , , 40436 7896 11 and and CC 40436 7896 12 that that IN 40436 7896 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7896 14 wishes wish VBZ 40436 7896 15 to to TO 40436 7896 16 debate debate VB 40436 7896 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7896 18 again again RB 40436 7896 19 with with IN 40436 7896 20 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7896 21 . . . 40436 7897 1 Amicable amicable JJ 40436 7897 2 reply reply NN 40436 7897 3 of of IN 40436 7897 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7897 5 . . . 40436 7897 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7898 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7898 2 is be VBZ 40436 7898 3 described describe VBN 40436 7898 4 as as IN 40436 7898 5 answering answer VBG 40436 7898 6 the the DT 40436 7898 7 last last JJ 40436 7898 8 few few JJ 40436 7898 9 questions question NNS 40436 7898 10 with with IN 40436 7898 11 increasing increase VBG 40436 7898 12 reluctance reluctance NN 40436 7898 13 . . . 40436 7899 1 But but CC 40436 7899 2 at at IN 40436 7899 3 this this DT 40436 7899 4 final final JJ 40436 7899 5 question question NN 40436 7899 6 , , , 40436 7899 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7899 8 declines decline VBZ 40436 7899 9 altogether altogether RB 40436 7899 10 to to TO 40436 7899 11 answer answer VB 40436 7899 12 , , , 40436 7899 13 or or CC 40436 7899 14 even even RB 40436 7899 15 to to TO 40436 7899 16 imply imply VB 40436 7899 17 assent assent NN 40436 7899 18 by by IN 40436 7899 19 a a DT 40436 7899 20 gesture gesture NN 40436 7899 21 . . . 40436 7900 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7900 2 127 127 CD 40436 7900 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7900 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7900 5 Sokr._--Why Sokr._--Why NNP 40436 7900 6 will will MD 40436 7900 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7900 8 not not RB 40436 7900 9 answer answer VB 40436 7900 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7900 11 question question NN 40436 7900 12 , , , 40436 7900 13 either either CC 40436 7900 14 affirmatively affirmatively RB 40436 7900 15 or or CC 40436 7900 16 negatively negatively RB 40436 7900 17 ? ? . 40436 7901 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7901 2 Prot._--Finish Prot._--Finish NNP 40436 7901 3 the the DT 40436 7901 4 exposition exposition NN 40436 7901 5 by by IN 40436 7901 6 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 7901 7 . . . 40436 7902 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7902 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 7902 3 will will MD 40436 7902 4 only only RB 40436 7902 5 ask ask VB 40436 7902 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7902 7 one one CD 40436 7902 8 more more JJR 40436 7902 9 question question NN 40436 7902 10 . . . 40436 7903 1 Do do VBP 40436 7903 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7903 3 still still RB 40436 7903 4 think think VB 40436 7903 5 , , , 40436 7903 6 as as IN 40436 7903 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7903 8 said say VBD 40436 7903 9 before before RB 40436 7903 10 , , , 40436 7903 11 that that IN 40436 7903 12 there there EX 40436 7903 13 are be VBP 40436 7903 14 some some DT 40436 7903 15 men man NNS 40436 7903 16 extremely extremely RB 40436 7903 17 stupid stupid JJ 40436 7903 18 , , , 40436 7903 19 but but CC 40436 7903 20 extremely extremely RB 40436 7903 21 courageous courageous JJ 40436 7903 22 ? ? . 40436 7904 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7904 2 Prot._--You Prot._--You NNP 40436 7904 3 seem seem VBP 40436 7904 4 to to TO 40436 7904 5 be be VB 40436 7904 6 obstinately obstinately RB 40436 7904 7 bent bent JJ 40436 7904 8 on on IN 40436 7904 9 making make VBG 40436 7904 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7904 11 answer answer VB 40436 7904 12 : : : 40436 7904 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7904 14 will will MD 40436 7904 15 therefore therefore RB 40436 7904 16 comply comply VB 40436 7904 17 with with IN 40436 7904 18 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7904 19 wish wish NN 40436 7904 20 : : : 40436 7904 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7904 22 say say VBP 40436 7904 23 that that IN 40436 7904 24 according accord VBG 40436 7904 25 to to IN 40436 7904 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7904 27 previous previous JJ 40436 7904 28 admissions admission NNS 40436 7904 29 , , , 40436 7904 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7904 31 appears appear VBZ 40436 7904 32 to to IN 40436 7904 33 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7904 34 impossible impossible JJ 40436 7904 35 . . . 40436 7905 1 _ _ NNP 40436 7905 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 7905 3 have have VBP 40436 7905 4 no no DT 40436 7905 5 other other JJ 40436 7905 6 motive motive NN 40436 7905 7 for for IN 40436 7905 8 questioning question VBG 40436 7905 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7905 10 thus thus RB 40436 7905 11 , , , 40436 7905 12 except except IN 40436 7905 13 the the DT 40436 7905 14 wish wish NN 40436 7905 15 to to TO 40436 7905 16 investigate investigate VB 40436 7905 17 how how WRB 40436 7905 18 the the DT 40436 7905 19 truth truth NN 40436 7905 20 stands stand VBZ 40436 7905 21 respecting respect VBG 40436 7905 22 virtue virtue NN 40436 7905 23 and and CC 40436 7905 24 what what WDT 40436 7905 25 virtue virtue NN 40436 7905 26 is be VBZ 40436 7905 27 in in IN 40436 7905 28 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 7905 29 . . . 40436 7906 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7906 2 128 128 CD 40436 7906 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7906 4 To to TO 40436 7906 5 determine determine VB 40436 7906 6 this this DT 40436 7906 7 , , , 40436 7906 8 is be VBZ 40436 7906 9 the the DT 40436 7906 10 way way NN 40436 7906 11 to to TO 40436 7906 12 elucidate elucidate VB 40436 7906 13 the the DT 40436 7906 14 question question NN 40436 7906 15 which which WDT 40436 7906 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7906 17 and and CC 40436 7906 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7906 19 first first RB 40436 7906 20 debated debate VBD 40436 7906 21 at at IN 40436 7906 22 length:--I length:--I NNP 40436 7906 23 , , , 40436 7906 24 affirming affirm VBG 40436 7906 25 that that DT 40436 7906 26 virtue virtue NN 40436 7906 27 was be VBD 40436 7906 28 not not RB 40436 7906 29 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7906 30 -- -- : 40436 7906 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7906 32 , , , 40436 7906 33 that that IN 40436 7906 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7906 35 was be VBD 40436 7906 36 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7906 37 . . . 40436 7907 1 The the DT 40436 7907 2 issue issue NN 40436 7907 3 of of IN 40436 7907 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7907 5 conversation conversation NN 40436 7907 6 renders render VBZ 40436 7907 7 both both DT 40436 7907 8 of of IN 40436 7907 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 7907 10 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 40436 7907 11 . . . 40436 7908 1 For for IN 40436 7908 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7908 3 , , , 40436 7908 4 who who WP 40436 7908 5 denied deny VBD 40436 7908 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 7908 7 to to TO 40436 7908 8 be be VB 40436 7908 9 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7908 10 , , , 40436 7908 11 have have VBP 40436 7908 12 shown show VBN 40436 7908 13 that that IN 40436 7908 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7908 15 consists consist VBZ 40436 7908 16 altogether altogether RB 40436 7908 17 in in IN 40436 7908 18 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7908 19 , , , 40436 7908 20 which which WDT 40436 7908 21 is be VBZ 40436 7908 22 the the DT 40436 7908 23 most most RBS 40436 7908 24 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7908 25 of of IN 40436 7908 26 all all DT 40436 7908 27 things thing NNS 40436 7908 28 : : : 40436 7908 29 while while IN 40436 7908 30 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7908 31 , , , 40436 7908 32 who who WP 40436 7908 33 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 7908 34 that that IN 40436 7908 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7908 36 was be VBD 40436 7908 37 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7908 38 , , , 40436 7908 39 has have VBZ 40436 7908 40 tried try VBN 40436 7908 41 to to TO 40436 7908 42 show show VB 40436 7908 43 that that IN 40436 7908 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7908 45 consisted consist VBD 40436 7908 46 in in IN 40436 7908 47 every every DT 40436 7908 48 thing thing NN 40436 7908 49 rather rather RB 40436 7908 50 than than IN 40436 7908 51 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7908 52 : : : 40436 7908 53 on on IN 40436 7908 54 which which WDT 40436 7908 55 supposition supposition NN 40436 7908 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7908 57 would would MD 40436 7908 58 be be VB 40436 7908 59 hardly hardly RB 40436 7908 60 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7908 61 at at RB 40436 7908 62 all all RB 40436 7908 63 . . . 40436 7909 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7909 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 7909 3 , , , 40436 7909 4 seeing see VBG 40436 7909 5 all all PDT 40436 7909 6 these these DT 40436 7909 7 questions question NNS 40436 7909 8 sadly sadly RB 40436 7909 9 confused confused JJ 40436 7909 10 and and CC 40436 7909 11 turned turn VBD 40436 7909 12 upside upside RB 40436 7909 13 down down RB 40436 7909 14 , , , 40436 7909 15 am be VBP 40436 7909 16 beyond beyond IN 40436 7909 17 measure measure NN 40436 7909 18 anxious anxious JJ 40436 7909 19 to to TO 40436 7909 20 clear clear VB 40436 7909 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7909 22 up;[129 up;[129 CD 40436 7909 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7909 24 and and CC 40436 7909 25 should should MD 40436 7909 26 be be VB 40436 7909 27 glad glad JJ 40436 7909 28 , , , 40436 7909 29 conjointly conjointly RB 40436 7909 30 with with IN 40436 7909 31 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7909 32 , , , 40436 7909 33 to to TO 40436 7909 34 go go VB 40436 7909 35 through through IN 40436 7909 36 the the DT 40436 7909 37 whole whole JJ 40436 7909 38 investigation investigation NN 40436 7909 39 -- -- : 40436 7909 40 First first RB 40436 7909 41 , , , 40436 7909 42 what what WP 40436 7909 43 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 7909 44 is,--Next is,--next NN 40436 7909 45 , , , 40436 7909 46 whether whether IN 40436 7909 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7909 48 is be VBZ 40436 7909 49 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7909 50 or or CC 40436 7909 51 not not RB 40436 7909 52 . . . 40436 7910 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7910 2 is be VBZ 40436 7910 3 with with IN 40436 7910 4 a a DT 40436 7910 5 provident provident JJ 40436 7910 6 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 7910 7 for for IN 40436 7910 8 the the DT 40436 7910 9 conduct conduct NN 40436 7910 10 of of IN 40436 7910 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7910 12 own own JJ 40436 7910 13 life life NN 40436 7910 14 that that WDT 40436 7910 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7910 16 undertake undertake VBP 40436 7910 17 this this DT 40436 7910 18 research research NN 40436 7910 19 , , , 40436 7910 20 and and CC 40436 7910 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7910 22 should should MD 40436 7910 23 be be VB 40436 7910 24 delighted delighted JJ 40436 7910 25 to to TO 40436 7910 26 have have VB 40436 7910 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7910 28 as as IN 40436 7910 29 a a DT 40436 7910 30 coadjutor coadjutor NN 40436 7910 31 . . . 40436 7911 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7911 2 130 130 CD 40436 7911 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7911 4 _ _ NNP 40436 7911 5 Prot._--I Prot._--I NNS 40436 7911 6 commend commend VBP 40436 7911 7 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7911 8 earnestness earnestness NN 40436 7911 9 , , , 40436 7911 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7911 11 , , , 40436 7911 12 and and CC 40436 7911 13 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7911 14 manner manner NN 40436 7911 15 of of IN 40436 7911 16 conducting conduct VBG 40436 7911 17 discussion discussion NN 40436 7911 18 . . . 40436 7912 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7912 2 think think VBP 40436 7912 3 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 7912 4 not not RB 40436 7912 5 a a DT 40436 7912 6 bad bad JJ 40436 7912 7 man man NN 40436 7912 8 in in IN 40436 7912 9 other other JJ 40436 7912 10 respects respect NNS 40436 7912 11 : : : 40436 7912 12 and and CC 40436 7912 13 as as IN 40436 7912 14 to to TO 40436 7912 15 jealousy jealousy VB 40436 7912 16 , , , 40436 7912 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7912 18 have have VBP 40436 7912 19 as as RB 40436 7912 20 little little JJ 40436 7912 21 of of IN 40436 7912 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7912 23 as as IN 40436 7912 24 any any DT 40436 7912 25 one one CD 40436 7912 26 . . . 40436 7913 1 For for IN 40436 7913 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7913 3 have have VBP 40436 7913 4 always always RB 40436 7913 5 said say VBN 40436 7913 6 of of IN 40436 7913 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7913 8 , , , 40436 7913 9 that that IN 40436 7913 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7913 11 admire admire VBP 40436 7913 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7913 13 much much RB 40436 7913 14 more more JJR 40436 7913 15 than than IN 40436 7913 16 any any DT 40436 7913 17 man man NN 40436 7913 18 of of IN 40436 7913 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7913 20 acquaintance acquaintance NN 40436 7913 21 -- -- : 40436 7913 22 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 7913 23 more more JJR 40436 7913 24 than than IN 40436 7913 25 any any DT 40436 7913 26 man man NN 40436 7913 27 of of IN 40436 7913 28 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7913 29 own own JJ 40436 7913 30 age age NN 40436 7913 31 . . . 40436 7914 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7914 2 would would MD 40436 7914 3 not not RB 40436 7914 4 surprise surprise VB 40436 7914 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 7914 6 , , , 40436 7914 7 if if IN 40436 7914 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 7914 9 became become VBD 40436 7914 10 one one CD 40436 7914 11 day day NN 40436 7914 12 illustrious illustrious JJ 40436 7914 13 for for IN 40436 7914 14 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 7914 15 . . . 40436 7915 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7915 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7915 3 127 127 CD 40436 7915 4 : : : 40436 7915 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7915 6 , , , 40436 7915 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7915 8 . . . 40436 7916 1 p. p. NN 40436 7916 2 360 360 CD 40436 7916 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7916 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7916 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7916 6 : : : 40436 7916 7 ou)ke ou)ke NNP 40436 7916 8 / / SYM 40436 7916 9 ti ti NNP 40436 7916 10 e)ntau e)ntau NNS 40436 7916 11 = = SYM 40436 7916 12 tha tha NNP 40436 7916 13 ou)/t ou)/t NNP 40436 7916 14 ' ' POS 40436 7916 15 e)pineu e)pineu , 40436 7916 16 = = SYM 40436 7916 17 sai sai NNP 40436 7916 18 ê)the ê)the NNP 40436 7916 19 / / SYM 40436 7916 20 lêsen lêsen NNP 40436 7916 21 , , , 40436 7916 22 e)si e)si NNP 40436 7916 23 / / SYM 40436 7916 24 ga ga NNP 40436 7916 25 te te NNP 40436 7916 26 . . . 40436 7916 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7916 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7917 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7917 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7917 3 128 128 CD 40436 7917 4 : : : 40436 7917 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7917 6 , , , 40436 7917 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7917 8 . . . 40436 7918 1 p. p. NN 40436 7918 2 360 360 CD 40436 7918 3 - - SYM 40436 7918 4 361 361 CD 40436 7918 5 . . . 40436 7919 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7919 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7919 3 : : : 40436 7919 4 Ou)/toi Ou)/toi VBN 40436 7919 5 a)/llou a)/llou NNP 40436 7919 6 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 7919 7 e)rôtô= e)rôtô= NNP 40436 7919 8 pa pa NNP 40436 7919 9 / / SYM 40436 7919 10 nta nta NNP 40436 7919 11 tau tau NNP 40436 7919 12 = = SYM 40436 7919 13 ta ta NNP 40436 7919 14 , , , 40436 7919 15 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 7919 16 ske ske NNP 40436 7919 17 / / SYM 40436 7919 18 psasthai psasthai NNP 40436 7919 19 boulo boulo NNP 40436 7919 20 / / SYM 40436 7919 21 menos menos NNP 40436 7919 22 pô pô NNP 40436 7919 23 = = FW 40436 7919 24 s s NN 40436 7919 25 pot pot NN 40436 7919 26 ' ' '' 40436 7919 27 e)/chei e)/chei NN 40436 7919 28 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 7919 29 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 7919 30 tê tê NNP 40436 7919 31 = = SYM 40436 7919 32 s s NNP 40436 7919 33 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 7919 34 = = SYM 40436 7919 35 s s NNP 40436 7919 36 , , , 40436 7919 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7919 38 _ _ NNP 40436 7919 39 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 7919 40 pot pot NN 40436 7919 41 ' ' '' 40436 7919 42 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 7919 43 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 7919 44 ê ê NN 40436 7919 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7919 46 a)retê/ a)retê/ NNP 40436 7919 47 _ _ NNP 40436 7919 48 . . . 40436 7920 1 Oi)=da Oi)=da `` 40436 7920 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 7920 3 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 7920 4 tou tou NNP 40436 7920 5 / / SYM 40436 7920 6 tou tou NNP 40436 7920 7 phanerou= phanerou= NNP 40436 7920 8 genome genome NNP 40436 7920 9 / / SYM 40436 7920 10 nou nou NNP 40436 7920 11 ma ma NNP 40436 7920 12 / / SYM 40436 7920 13 list list NNP 40436 7920 14 ' ' '' 40436 7920 15 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 7920 16 kata kata NNP 40436 7920 17 / / SYM 40436 7920 18 dêlon dêlon NNP 40436 7920 19 ge ge NNP 40436 7920 20 / / SYM 40436 7920 21 noito noito NNP 40436 7920 22 e)kei e)kei NNPS 40436 7920 23 = = NFP 40436 7920 24 no no UH 40436 7920 25 , , , 40436 7920 26 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 7920 27 ou)= ou)= JJ 40436 7920 28 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 7920 29 te te NNP 40436 7920 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7920 31 su\ su\ NNP 40436 7920 32 makro\n makro\n NNP 40436 7920 33 lo lo NNP 40436 7920 34 / / SYM 40436 7920 35 gon gon NNP 40436 7920 36 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 7920 37 / / SYM 40436 7920 38 teros tero NNS 40436 7920 39 a)petei a)petei CD 40436 7920 40 / / SYM 40436 7920 41 namen naman NNS 40436 7920 42 , , , 40436 7920 43 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 7920 44 me\n me\n NNP 40436 7920 45 le le NNP 40436 7920 46 / / SYM 40436 7920 47 gôn gôn NN 40436 7920 48 , , , 40436 7920 49 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7920 50 ou ou NNP 40436 7920 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7920 52 didakto\n didakto\n -LRB- 40436 7920 53 a)retê/ a)retê/ XX 40436 7920 54 , , , 40436 7920 55 su\ su\ NNP 40436 7920 56 d d NNP 40436 7920 57 ' ' '' 40436 7920 58 , , , 40436 7920 59 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7920 60 didakto didakto NNS 40436 7920 61 / / SYM 40436 7920 62 n n NN 40436 7920 63 . . . 40436 7920 64 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7920 65 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7921 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7921 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7921 3 129 129 CD 40436 7921 4 : : : 40436 7921 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7921 6 , , , 40436 7921 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7921 8 . . . 40436 7922 1 p. p. NN 40436 7922 2 361 361 CD 40436 7922 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7922 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7922 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7922 6 : : : 40436 7922 7 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 7922 8 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 7922 9 pa pa NNP 40436 7922 10 / / SYM 40436 7922 11 nta nta NNP 40436 7922 12 tau tau NNP 40436 7922 13 = = SYM 40436 7922 14 ta ta NNP 40436 7922 15 kathorô kathorô NNP 40436 7922 16 = = SYM 40436 7922 17 n n CC 40436 7922 18 a)/nô a)/nô NNP 40436 7922 19 ka ka NNP 40436 7922 20 / / SYM 40436 7922 21 tô tô NNP 40436 7922 22 taratto taratto NNP 40436 7922 23 / / SYM 40436 7922 24 mena mena NNP 40436 7922 25 deinô deinô NNP 40436 7922 26 = = SYM 40436 7922 27 s s NNP 40436 7922 28 , , , 40436 7922 29 pa pa NNP 40436 7922 30 = = SYM 40436 7922 31 san san NNP 40436 7922 32 prothumi prothumi NNP 40436 7922 33 / / , 40436 7922 34 an an DT 40436 7922 35 e)/chô e)/chô NNP 40436 7922 36 kataphanê= kataphanê= JJ 40436 7922 37 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 7922 38 gene gene NN 40436 7922 39 / / SYM 40436 7922 40 sthai sthai NNP 40436 7922 41 , , , 40436 7922 42 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7922 43 bouloi bouloi NNP 40436 7922 44 / / SYM 40436 7922 45 mên mên NNP 40436 7922 46 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 7922 47 _ _ NNP 40436 7922 48 tau tau NNP 40436 7922 49 = = SYM 40436 7922 50 ta ta NNP 40436 7922 51 diexeltho diexeltho NNP 40436 7922 52 / / SYM 40436 7922 53 ntas ntas FW 40436 7922 54 ê(ma ê(ma NNP 40436 7922 55 = = SYM 40436 7922 56 s s NNP 40436 7922 57 e)xelthei e)xelthei NNP 40436 7922 58 = = SYM 40436 7922 59 n n NN 40436 7922 60 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7922 61 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 7922 62 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 7922 63 a)retê\n a)retê\n JJ 40436 7922 64 o(/ o(/ NNS 40436 7922 65 ti ti IN 40436 7922 66 e)/stin e)/stin NN 40436 7922 67 _ _ NNP 40436 7922 68 . . . 40436 7922 69 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7922 70 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7923 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7923 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7923 3 130 130 CD 40436 7923 4 : : : 40436 7923 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7923 6 , , , 40436 7923 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7923 8 . . . 40436 7924 1 p. p. NN 40436 7924 2 361 361 CD 40436 7924 3 D. D. NNP 40436 7924 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7924 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7924 6 : : : 40436 7924 7 promêthou promêthou NNP 40436 7924 8 / / SYM 40436 7924 9 menos menos NNP 40436 7924 10 u(pe\r u(pe\r NNP 40436 7924 11 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7924 12 bi bi NNP 40436 7924 13 / / SYM 40436 7924 14 ou ou NNP 40436 7924 15 tou= tou= NNP 40436 7924 16 e)mautou= e)mautou= NNP 40436 7924 17 panto panto NNP 40436 7924 18 / / SYM 40436 7924 19 s s NNP 40436 7924 20 . . . 40436 7924 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7924 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7925 1 * * NFP 40436 7925 2 * * NFP 40436 7925 3 * * NFP 40436 7925 4 * * NFP 40436 7925 5 * * NFP 40436 7925 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7925 7 Side side NN 40436 7925 8 - - HYPH 40436 7925 9 note note NN 40436 7925 10 : : : 40436 7925 11 Remarks remark NNS 40436 7925 12 on on IN 40436 7925 13 the the DT 40436 7925 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7925 15 . . . 40436 7926 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7926 2 closes close VBZ 40436 7926 3 without without IN 40436 7926 4 the the DT 40436 7926 5 least least JJS 40436 7926 6 allusion allusion NN 40436 7926 7 to to IN 40436 7926 8 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNP 40436 7926 9 . . . 40436 7926 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7927 1 Such such JJ 40436 7927 2 is be VBZ 40436 7927 3 the the DT 40436 7927 4 end end NN 40436 7927 5 of of IN 40436 7927 6 this this DT 40436 7927 7 long long JJ 40436 7927 8 and and CC 40436 7927 9 interesting interesting JJ 40436 7927 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7927 11 . . . 40436 7928 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7928 2 131 131 CD 40436 7928 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7928 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7928 5 remark remark VBP 40436 7928 6 with with IN 40436 7928 7 some some DT 40436 7928 8 surprise surprise NN 40436 7928 9 that that IN 40436 7928 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7928 11 closes close VBZ 40436 7928 12 without without IN 40436 7928 13 any any DT 40436 7928 14 mention mention NN 40436 7928 15 of of IN 40436 7928 16 Hippokrates Hippokrates NNPS 40436 7928 17 , , , 40436 7928 18 and and CC 40436 7928 19 without without IN 40436 7928 20 a a DT 40436 7928 21 word word NN 40436 7928 22 addressed address VBN 40436 7928 23 to to IN 40436 7928 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7928 25 respecting respect VBG 40436 7928 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7928 27 anxious anxious JJ 40436 7928 28 request request NN 40436 7928 29 for for IN 40436 7928 30 admission admission NN 40436 7928 31 to to IN 40436 7928 32 the the DT 40436 7928 33 society society NN 40436 7928 34 of of IN 40436 7928 35 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7928 36 : : : 40436 7928 37 though though IN 40436 7928 38 such such JJ 40436 7928 39 request request NN 40436 7928 40 had have VBD 40436 7928 41 been be VBN 40436 7928 42 presented present VBN 40436 7928 43 at at IN 40436 7928 44 the the DT 40436 7928 45 beginning beginning NN 40436 7928 46 , , , 40436 7928 47 with with IN 40436 7928 48 much much JJ 40436 7928 49 emphasis emphasis NN 40436 7928 50 , , , 40436 7928 51 as as IN 40436 7928 52 the the DT 40436 7928 53 sole sole JJ 40436 7928 54 motive motive NN 40436 7928 55 for for IN 40436 7928 56 the the DT 40436 7928 57 intervention intervention NN 40436 7928 58 of of IN 40436 7928 59 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7928 60 . . . 40436 7929 1 Upon upon IN 40436 7929 2 this this DT 40436 7929 3 point[132 point[132 NN 40436 7929 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7929 5 the the DT 40436 7929 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7929 7 is be VBZ 40436 7929 8 open open JJ 40436 7929 9 to to IN 40436 7929 10 the the DT 40436 7929 11 same same JJ 40436 7929 12 criticism criticism NN 40436 7929 13 as as IN 40436 7929 14 that that DT 40436 7929 15 which which WDT 40436 7929 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7929 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7929 18 in in IN 40436 7929 19 the the DT 40436 7929 20 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 7929 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7929 22 bestows bestow VBZ 40436 7929 23 on on IN 40436 7929 24 the the DT 40436 7929 25 discourse discourse NN 40436 7929 26 of of IN 40436 7929 27 Lysias Lysias NNP 40436 7929 28 : : : 40436 7929 29 requiring require VBG 40436 7929 30 that that IN 40436 7929 31 every every DT 40436 7929 32 discourse discourse NN 40436 7929 33 shall shall MD 40436 7929 34 be be VB 40436 7929 35 like like IN 40436 7929 36 a a DT 40436 7929 37 living live VBG 40436 7929 38 organism organism NN 40436 7929 39 , , , 40436 7929 40 neither neither CC 40436 7929 41 headless headless NN 40436 7929 42 nor nor CC 40436 7929 43 footless footless NN 40436 7929 44 , , , 40436 7929 45 but but CC 40436 7929 46 having have VBG 40436 7929 47 extremities extremity NNS 40436 7929 48 and and CC 40436 7929 49 a a DT 40436 7929 50 middle middle JJ 40436 7929 51 piece piece NN 40436 7929 52 adapted adapt VBN 40436 7929 53 to to IN 40436 7929 54 each each DT 40436 7929 55 other other JJ 40436 7929 56 . . . 40436 7930 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7930 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7930 3 131 131 CD 40436 7930 4 : : : 40436 7930 5 Most Most JJS 40436 7930 6 critics critic NNS 40436 7930 7 treat treat VBP 40436 7930 8 the the DT 40436 7930 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 7930 10 as as IN 40436 7930 11 a a DT 40436 7930 12 composition composition NN 40436 7930 13 of of IN 40436 7930 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7930 15 's 's POS 40436 7930 16 younger young JJR 40436 7930 17 years year NNS 40436 7930 18 -- -- : 40436 7930 19 what what WP 40436 7930 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7930 21 call call VBP 40436 7930 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7930 23 _ _ NNP 40436 7930 24 first first RB 40436 7930 25 period_--before period_--before VB 40436 7930 26 the the DT 40436 7930 27 death death NN 40436 7930 28 of of IN 40436 7930 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7930 30 . . . 40436 7931 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 7931 2 fix fix VBP 40436 7931 3 different different JJ 40436 7931 4 years year NNS 40436 7931 5 , , , 40436 7931 6 from from IN 40436 7931 7 407 407 CD 40436 7931 8 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 7932 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7932 2 Ast ast NN 40436 7932 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7932 4 down down IN 40436 7932 5 to to IN 40436 7932 6 402 402 CD 40436 7932 7 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 7933 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7933 2 do do VBP 40436 7933 3 not not RB 40436 7933 4 agree agree VB 40436 7933 5 with with IN 40436 7933 6 this this DT 40436 7933 7 view view NN 40436 7933 8 . . . 40436 7934 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7934 2 can can MD 40436 7934 3 admit admit VB 40436 7934 4 no no DT 40436 7934 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7934 6 earlier early RBR 40436 7934 7 than than IN 40436 7934 8 399 399 CD 40436 7934 9 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 7935 1 : : : 40436 7935 2 and and CC 40436 7935 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7935 4 consider consider VBP 40436 7935 5 the the DT 40436 7935 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 7935 7 to to TO 40436 7935 8 belong belong VB 40436 7935 9 to to IN 40436 7935 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7935 11 's 's POS 40436 7935 12 full full JJ 40436 7935 13 maturity maturity NN 40436 7935 14 . . . 40436 7935 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7936 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7936 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7936 3 132 132 CD 40436 7936 4 : : : 40436 7936 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7936 6 , , , 40436 7936 7 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 7936 8 , , , 40436 7936 9 p. p. NN 40436 7936 10 264 264 CD 40436 7936 11 C. C. NNP 40436 7936 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7936 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7936 14 : : : 40436 7936 15 dei dei NNP 40436 7936 16 = = SYM 40436 7936 17 n n NNP 40436 7936 18 pa pa NNP 40436 7936 19 / / SYM 40436 7936 20 nta nta NNP 40436 7936 21 lo lo NNP 40436 7936 22 / / SYM 40436 7936 23 gon gon NNP 40436 7936 24 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 7936 25 zô zô NNP 40436 7936 26 = = NFP 40436 7936 27 on on IN 40436 7936 28 sunesta sunesta NNP 40436 7936 29 / / SYM 40436 7936 30 nai nai NNP 40436 7936 31 , , , 40436 7936 32 sô sô NNP 40436 7936 33 = = SYM 40436 7936 34 ma/ ma/ NNP 40436 7936 35 ti ti NNP 40436 7936 36 e)/chonta e)/chonta NNP 40436 7936 37 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 7936 38 au(tou= au(tou= CD 40436 7936 39 , , , 40436 7936 40 ô ô NNP 40436 7936 41 / / SYM 40436 7936 42 ste ste NNP 40436 7936 43 mê mê NNP 40436 7936 44 / / SYM 40436 7936 45 te te NNP 40436 7936 46 a)ke a)ke NNP 40436 7936 47 / / SYM 40436 7936 48 phalon phalon NNP 40436 7936 49 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 7936 50 mê mê NNP 40436 7936 51 / / SYM 40436 7936 52 te te NNP 40436 7936 53 a)/poun a)/poun NNP 40436 7936 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7936 55 , , , 40436 7936 56 & & CC 40436 7936 57 c. c. NNP 40436 7936 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7936 59 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7936 60 Side side NN 40436 7936 61 - - HYPH 40436 7936 62 note note NN 40436 7936 63 : : : 40436 7936 64 Two two CD 40436 7936 65 distinct distinct JJ 40436 7936 66 aspects aspect NNS 40436 7936 67 of of IN 40436 7936 68 ethics ethic NNS 40436 7936 69 and and CC 40436 7936 70 politics politic NNS 40436 7936 71 exhibited exhibit VBD 40436 7936 72 : : : 40436 7936 73 one one CD 40436 7936 74 under under IN 40436 7936 75 the the DT 40436 7936 76 name name NN 40436 7936 77 of of IN 40436 7936 78 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7936 79 ; ; : 40436 7936 80 the the DT 40436 7936 81 other other JJ 40436 7936 82 , , , 40436 7936 83 under under IN 40436 7936 84 that that DT 40436 7936 85 of of IN 40436 7936 86 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7936 87 . . . 40436 7936 88 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7937 1 In in IN 40436 7937 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7937 3 review review NN 40436 7937 4 of of IN 40436 7937 5 this this DT 40436 7937 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 7937 7 , , , 40436 7937 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7937 9 have have VBP 40436 7937 10 found find VBN 40436 7937 11 first first RB 40436 7937 12 , , , 40436 7937 13 towards towards IN 40436 7937 14 the the DT 40436 7937 15 beginning beginning NN 40436 7937 16 , , , 40436 7937 17 an an DT 40436 7937 18 expository expository NN 40436 7937 19 discourse discourse NN 40436 7937 20 from from IN 40436 7937 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7937 22 , , , 40436 7937 23 describing describe VBG 40436 7937 24 the the DT 40436 7937 25 maintenance maintenance NN 40436 7937 26 and and CC 40436 7937 27 propagation propagation NN 40436 7937 28 of of IN 40436 7937 29 virtue virtue NN 40436 7937 30 in in IN 40436 7937 31 an an DT 40436 7937 32 established establish VBN 40436 7937 33 community community NN 40436 7937 34 : : : 40436 7937 35 next next RB 40436 7937 36 , , , 40436 7937 37 towards towards IN 40436 7937 38 the the DT 40436 7937 39 close close NN 40436 7937 40 , , , 40436 7937 41 an an DT 40436 7937 42 expository expository JJ 40436 7937 43 string string NN 40436 7937 44 of of IN 40436 7937 45 interrogatories interrogatory NNS 40436 7937 46 by by IN 40436 7937 47 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7937 48 , , , 40436 7937 49 destined destine VBN 40436 7937 50 to to TO 40436 7937 51 establish establish VB 40436 7937 52 the the DT 40436 7937 53 identity identity NN 40436 7937 54 of of IN 40436 7937 55 Good good JJ 40436 7937 56 with with IN 40436 7937 57 Pleasurable Pleasurable NNP 40436 7937 58 , , , 40436 7937 59 Evil evil NN 40436 7937 60 with with IN 40436 7937 61 Painful painful JJ 40436 7937 62 ; ; : 40436 7937 63 and and CC 40436 7937 64 the the DT 40436 7937 65 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 7937 66 supremacy supremacy NN 40436 7937 67 of of IN 40436 7937 68 the the DT 40436 7937 69 calculating calculate VBG 40436 7937 70 or or CC 40436 7937 71 measuring measure VBG 40436 7937 72 science science NN 40436 7937 73 , , , 40436 7937 74 as as IN 40436 7937 75 the the DT 40436 7937 76 tutelary tutelary JJ 40436 7937 77 guide guide NN 40436 7937 78 of of IN 40436 7937 79 human human JJ 40436 7937 80 life life NN 40436 7937 81 . . . 40436 7938 1 Of of IN 40436 7938 2 the the DT 40436 7938 3 first first JJ 40436 7938 4 , , , 40436 7938 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7938 6 speak speak VBP 40436 7938 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7938 8 like like IN 40436 7938 9 other other JJ 40436 7938 10 critics critic NNS 40436 7938 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7938 12 as as IN 40436 7938 13 the the DT 40436 7938 14 discourse discourse NN 40436 7938 15 of of IN 40436 7938 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7938 17 : : : 40436 7938 18 of of IN 40436 7938 19 the the DT 40436 7938 20 second second JJ 40436 7938 21 , , , 40436 7938 22 as as IN 40436 7938 23 the the DT 40436 7938 24 theory theory NN 40436 7938 25 of of IN 40436 7938 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7938 27 . . . 40436 7939 1 But but CC 40436 7939 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 7939 3 must must MD 40436 7939 4 again again RB 40436 7939 5 remind remind VB 40436 7939 6 the the DT 40436 7939 7 reader reader NN 40436 7939 8 , , , 40436 7939 9 that that IN 40436 7939 10 both both CC 40436 7939 11 the the DT 40436 7939 12 one one NN 40436 7939 13 and and CC 40436 7939 14 the the DT 40436 7939 15 other other JJ 40436 7939 16 are be VBP 40436 7939 17 compositions composition NNS 40436 7939 18 of of IN 40436 7939 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7939 20 ; ; : 40436 7939 21 both both CC 40436 7939 22 alike alike RB 40436 7939 23 are be VBP 40436 7939 24 offspring offspre VBG 40436 7939 25 of of IN 40436 7939 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7939 27 ingenious ingenious JJ 40436 7939 28 and and CC 40436 7939 29 productive productive JJ 40436 7939 30 imagination imagination NN 40436 7939 31 . . . 40436 7940 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7940 2 is be VBZ 40436 7940 3 not not RB 40436 7940 4 the the DT 40436 7940 5 author author NN 40436 7940 6 of of IN 40436 7940 7 that that DT 40436 7940 8 which which WDT 40436 7940 9 appears appear VBZ 40436 7940 10 here here RB 40436 7940 11 under under IN 40436 7940 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7940 13 name name NN 40436 7940 14 : : : 40436 7940 15 and and CC 40436 7940 16 when when WRB 40436 7940 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7940 18 read read VBP 40436 7940 19 the the DT 40436 7940 20 disparaging disparaging NN 40436 7940 21 epithets epithet NNS 40436 7940 22 which which WDT 40436 7940 23 many many JJ 40436 7940 24 critics critic NNS 40436 7940 25 affix affix VBP 40436 7940 26 to to IN 40436 7940 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7940 28 discourse discourse NN 40436 7940 29 , , , 40436 7940 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7940 31 must must MD 40436 7940 32 recollect recollect VB 40436 7940 33 that that IN 40436 7940 34 these these DT 40436 7940 35 epithets epithet NNS 40436 7940 36 , , , 40436 7940 37 if if IN 40436 7940 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7940 39 were be VBD 40436 7940 40 well well RB 40436 7940 41 - - HYPH 40436 7940 42 founded found VBN 40436 7940 43 , , , 40436 7940 44 would would MD 40436 7940 45 have have VB 40436 7940 46 no no DT 40436 7940 47 real real JJ 40436 7940 48 application application NN 40436 7940 49 to to IN 40436 7940 50 the the DT 40436 7940 51 historical historical JJ 40436 7940 52 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7940 53 , , , 40436 7940 54 but but CC 40436 7940 55 only only RB 40436 7940 56 to to IN 40436 7940 57 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7940 58 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7940 59 . . . 40436 7941 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7941 2 has have VBZ 40436 7941 3 set set VBN 40436 7941 4 forth forth RP 40436 7941 5 two two CD 40436 7941 6 aspects aspect NNS 40436 7941 7 , , , 40436 7941 8 distinct distinct JJ 40436 7941 9 and and CC 40436 7941 10 in in IN 40436 7941 11 part part NN 40436 7941 12 opposing opposing NN 40436 7941 13 , , , 40436 7941 14 of of IN 40436 7941 15 ethics ethic NNS 40436 7941 16 and and CC 40436 7941 17 politics politic NNS 40436 7941 18 : : : 40436 7941 19 and and CC 40436 7941 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7941 21 has have VBZ 40436 7941 22 provided provide VBN 40436 7941 23 a a DT 40436 7941 24 worthy worthy JJ 40436 7941 25 champion champion NN 40436 7941 26 for for IN 40436 7941 27 each each DT 40436 7941 28 . . . 40436 7942 1 Philosophy philosophy NN 40436 7942 2 , , , 40436 7942 3 or or CC 40436 7942 4 " " `` 40436 7942 5 reasoned reason VBN 40436 7942 6 truth truth NN 40436 7942 7 , , , 40436 7942 8 " " '' 40436 7942 9 if if IN 40436 7942 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7942 11 be be VBP 40436 7942 12 attainable attainable JJ 40436 7942 13 at at RB 40436 7942 14 all all RB 40436 7942 15 , , , 40436 7942 16 can can MD 40436 7942 17 not not RB 40436 7942 18 most most RBS 40436 7942 19 certainly certainly RB 40436 7942 20 be be VB 40436 7942 21 attained attain VBN 40436 7942 22 without without IN 40436 7942 23 such such JJ 40436 7942 24 many many JJ 40436 7942 25 - - HYPH 40436 7942 26 sided sided JJ 40436 7942 27 handling handling NN 40436 7942 28 : : : 40436 7942 29 still still RB 40436 7942 30 less less JJR 40436 7942 31 can can MD 40436 7942 32 that that IN 40436 7942 33 which which WDT 40436 7942 34 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7942 35 calls call VBZ 40436 7942 36 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7942 37 be be VB 40436 7942 38 attained attain VBN 40436 7942 39 -- -- : 40436 7942 40 or or CC 40436 7942 41 such such JJ 40436 7942 42 command command NN 40436 7942 43 of of IN 40436 7942 44 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 7942 45 as as IN 40436 7942 46 will will MD 40436 7942 47 enable enable VB 40436 7942 48 a a DT 40436 7942 49 man man NN 40436 7942 50 to to TO 40436 7942 51 stand stand VB 40436 7942 52 a a DT 40436 7942 53 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 7942 54 cross cross NN 40436 7942 55 - - NN 40436 7942 56 examination examination NN 40436 7942 57 in in IN 40436 7942 58 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7942 59 . . . 40436 7943 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7943 2 Side side NN 40436 7943 3 - - HYPH 40436 7943 4 note note NN 40436 7943 5 : : : 40436 7943 6 Order order NN 40436 7943 7 of of IN 40436 7943 8 ethical ethical JJ 40436 7943 9 problems problem NNS 40436 7943 10 , , , 40436 7943 11 as as IN 40436 7943 12 conceived conceive VBN 40436 7943 13 by by IN 40436 7943 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 7943 15 . . . 40436 7943 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7944 1 In in IN 40436 7944 2 the the DT 40436 7944 3 last last JJ 40436 7944 4 speech speech NN 40436 7944 5 of of IN 40436 7944 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7944 7 in in IN 40436 7944 8 the the DT 40436 7944 9 dialogue,[133 dialogue,[133 NN 40436 7944 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7944 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7944 12 find find VBP 40436 7944 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7944 14 proclaiming proclaim VBG 40436 7944 15 , , , 40436 7944 16 that that IN 40436 7944 17 the the DT 40436 7944 18 first first JJ 40436 7944 19 of of IN 40436 7944 20 all all DT 40436 7944 21 problems problem NNS 40436 7944 22 to to TO 40436 7944 23 be be VB 40436 7944 24 solved solve VBN 40436 7944 25 was be VBD 40436 7944 26 , , , 40436 7944 27 What what WDT 40436 7944 28 virtue virtue NN 40436 7944 29 really really RB 40436 7944 30 is be VBZ 40436 7944 31 ? ? . 40436 7945 1 upon upon IN 40436 7945 2 which which WDT 40436 7945 3 there there EX 40436 7945 4 prevails prevail VBZ 40436 7945 5 serious serious JJ 40436 7945 6 confusion confusion NN 40436 7945 7 of of IN 40436 7945 8 opinions opinion NNS 40436 7945 9 . . . 40436 7946 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7946 2 was be VBD 40436 7946 3 a a DT 40436 7946 4 second second JJ 40436 7946 5 question question NN 40436 7946 6 -- -- : 40436 7946 7 important important JJ 40436 7946 8 , , , 40436 7946 9 yet yet CC 40436 7946 10 still still RB 40436 7946 11 second second JJ 40436 7946 12 and and CC 40436 7946 13 presupposing presuppose VBG 40436 7946 14 the the DT 40436 7946 15 solution solution NN 40436 7946 16 of of IN 40436 7946 17 the the DT 40436 7946 18 first first JJ 40436 7946 19 -- -- : 40436 7946 20 Whether whether IN 40436 7946 21 virtue virtue NN 40436 7946 22 is be VBZ 40436 7946 23 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7946 24 ? ? . 40436 7947 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 7947 2 noticed notice VBD 40436 7947 3 the the DT 40436 7947 4 same same JJ 40436 7947 5 judgment judgment NN 40436 7947 6 as as IN 40436 7947 7 to to IN 40436 7947 8 the the DT 40436 7947 9 order order NN 40436 7947 10 of of IN 40436 7947 11 the the DT 40436 7947 12 two two CD 40436 7947 13 questions question NNS 40436 7947 14 delivered deliver VBN 40436 7947 15 by by IN 40436 7947 16 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 7947 17 in in IN 40436 7947 18 the the DT 40436 7947 19 Menon Menon NNP 40436 7947 20 . . . 40436 7948 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7948 2 134 134 CD 40436 7948 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7948 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7948 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7948 6 133 133 CD 40436 7948 7 : : : 40436 7948 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7948 9 , , , 40436 7948 10 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7948 11 . . . 40436 7949 1 p. p. NN 40436 7949 2 361 361 CD 40436 7949 3 C. C. NNP 40436 7949 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7949 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7949 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7949 7 134 134 CD 40436 7949 8 : : : 40436 7949 9 See see VB 40436 7949 10 the the DT 40436 7949 11 last last JJ 40436 7949 12 preceding precede VBG 40436 7949 13 chapter chapter NN 40436 7949 14 of of IN 40436 7949 15 this this DT 40436 7949 16 volume volume NN 40436 7949 17 , , , 40436 7949 18 p. p. NN 40436 7950 1 242 242 CD 40436 7950 2 . . . 40436 7951 1 * * NFP 40436 7951 2 * * NFP 40436 7951 3 Upon upon IN 40436 7951 4 this this DT 40436 7951 5 order order NN 40436 7951 6 , , , 40436 7951 7 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 7951 8 required require VBN 40436 7951 9 , , , 40436 7951 10 of of IN 40436 7951 11 the the DT 40436 7951 12 two two CD 40436 7951 13 questions question NNS 40436 7951 14 , , , 40436 7951 15 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 7951 16 has have VBZ 40436 7951 17 a a DT 40436 7951 18 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 7951 19 remark remark NN 40436 7951 20 in in IN 40436 7951 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7951 22 general general JJ 40436 7951 23 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 7951 24 to to IN 40436 7951 25 the the DT 40436 7951 26 works work NNS 40436 7951 27 of of IN 40436 7951 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7951 29 , , , 40436 7951 30 p. p. NN 40436 7951 31 26 26 CD 40436 7951 32 . . . 40436 7952 1 Eberhard Eberhard NNP 40436 7952 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7952 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7952 4 says say VBZ 40436 7952 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7952 6 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 7952 7 that that IN 40436 7952 8 the the DT 40436 7952 9 end end NN 40436 7952 10 proposed propose VBN 40436 7952 11 by by IN 40436 7952 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7952 13 in in IN 40436 7952 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7952 15 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 7952 16 was be VBD 40436 7952 17 to to TO 40436 7952 18 form form VB 40436 7952 19 the the DT 40436 7952 20 minds mind NNS 40436 7952 21 of of IN 40436 7952 22 the the DT 40436 7952 23 noble noble JJ 40436 7952 24 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 7952 25 youth youth NN 40436 7952 26 , , , 40436 7952 27 so so IN 40436 7952 28 as as IN 40436 7952 29 to to TO 40436 7952 30 make make VB 40436 7952 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7952 32 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 7952 33 citizens citizen NNS 40436 7952 34 . . . 40436 7953 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 7953 2 controverts controvert VBZ 40436 7953 3 the the DT 40436 7953 4 position position NN 40436 7953 5 of of IN 40436 7953 6 Eberhard Eberhard NNP 40436 7953 7 ; ; : 40436 7953 8 maintaining maintain VBG 40436 7953 9 " " `` 40436 7953 10 that that IN 40436 7953 11 this this DT 40436 7953 12 is be VBZ 40436 7953 13 far far RB 40436 7953 14 too too RB 40436 7953 15 subordinate subordinate JJ 40436 7953 16 a a DT 40436 7953 17 standing standing NN 40436 7953 18 - - HYPH 40436 7953 19 point point NN 40436 7953 20 for for IN 40436 7953 21 philosophy,--besides philosophy,--beside NNS 40436 7953 22 that that IN 40436 7953 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7953 24 is be VBZ 40436 7953 25 reasoning reason VBG 40436 7953 26 in in IN 40436 7953 27 a a DT 40436 7953 28 circle circle NN 40436 7953 29 , , , 40436 7953 30 since since IN 40436 7953 31 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 7953 32 has have VBZ 40436 7953 33 first first RB 40436 7953 34 to to TO 40436 7953 35 determine determine VB 40436 7953 36 what what WP 40436 7953 37 the the DT 40436 7953 38 virtue virtue NN 40436 7953 39 of of IN 40436 7953 40 a a DT 40436 7953 41 citizen citizen NN 40436 7953 42 is be VBZ 40436 7953 43 " " `` 40436 7953 44 . . . 40436 7953 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7954 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7954 2 Side side NN 40436 7954 3 - - HYPH 40436 7954 4 note note NN 40436 7954 5 : : : 40436 7954 6 Difference difference NN 40436 7954 7 of of IN 40436 7954 8 method method NN 40436 7954 9 between between IN 40436 7954 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7954 11 and and CC 40436 7954 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7954 13 flows flow VBZ 40436 7954 14 from from IN 40436 7954 15 this this DT 40436 7954 16 difference difference NN 40436 7954 17 of of IN 40436 7954 18 order order NN 40436 7954 19 . . . 40436 7955 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7955 2 assumes assume VBZ 40436 7955 3 what what WP 40436 7955 4 virtue virtue NN 40436 7955 5 is be VBZ 40436 7955 6 , , , 40436 7955 7 without without IN 40436 7955 8 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 7955 9 . . . 40436 7955 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7956 1 Now now RB 40436 7956 2 the the DT 40436 7956 3 conception conception NN 40436 7956 4 of of IN 40436 7956 5 ethical ethical JJ 40436 7956 6 questions question NNS 40436 7956 7 in in IN 40436 7956 8 this this DT 40436 7956 9 order order NN 40436 7956 10 -- -- : 40436 7956 11 the the DT 40436 7956 12 reluctance reluctance NN 40436 7956 13 to to TO 40436 7956 14 deal deal VB 40436 7956 15 with with IN 40436 7956 16 the the DT 40436 7956 17 second second JJ 40436 7956 18 until until IN 40436 7956 19 the the DT 40436 7956 20 first first JJ 40436 7956 21 has have VBZ 40436 7956 22 been be VBN 40436 7956 23 fully fully RB 40436 7956 24 debated debate VBN 40436 7956 25 and and CC 40436 7956 26 settled settle VBN 40436 7956 27 -- -- : 40436 7956 28 is be VBZ 40436 7956 29 one one CD 40436 7956 30 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 7956 31 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 7956 32 of of IN 40436 7956 33 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7956 34 . . . 40436 7957 1 The the DT 40436 7957 2 difference difference NN 40436 7957 3 of of IN 40436 7957 4 method method NN 40436 7957 5 , , , 40436 7957 6 between between IN 40436 7957 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7957 8 and and CC 40436 7957 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7957 10 , , , 40436 7957 11 flows flow VBZ 40436 7957 12 from from IN 40436 7957 13 this this DT 40436 7957 14 prior prior JJ 40436 7957 15 difference difference NN 40436 7957 16 between between IN 40436 7957 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7957 18 in in IN 40436 7957 19 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 7957 20 conception conception NN 40436 7957 21 . . . 40436 7958 1 What what WDT 40436 7958 2 virtue virtue NN 40436 7958 3 is be VBZ 40436 7958 4 , , , 40436 7958 5 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7958 6 neither neither CC 40436 7958 7 defines define NNS 40436 7958 8 nor nor CC 40436 7958 9 analyses analysis NNS 40436 7958 10 , , , 40436 7958 11 nor nor CC 40436 7958 12 submits submit VBZ 40436 7958 13 to to IN 40436 7958 14 debate debate NN 40436 7958 15 . . . 40436 7959 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7959 2 manifests manifest VBZ 40436 7959 3 no no DT 40436 7959 4 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 7959 5 of of IN 40436 7959 6 the the DT 40436 7959 7 necessity necessity NN 40436 7959 8 of of IN 40436 7959 9 analysis analysis NN 40436 7959 10 : : : 40436 7959 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7959 12 accepts accept VBZ 40436 7959 13 the the DT 40436 7959 14 ground ground NN 40436 7959 15 already already RB 40436 7959 16 prepared prepare VBD 40436 7959 17 for for IN 40436 7959 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7959 19 by by IN 40436 7959 20 King King NNP 40436 7959 21 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 7959 22 : : : 40436 7959 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7959 24 thus thus RB 40436 7959 25 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 7959 26 as as IN 40436 7959 27 if if IN 40436 7959 28 the the DT 40436 7959 29 first first JJ 40436 7959 30 step step NN 40436 7959 31 had have VBD 40436 7959 32 been be VBN 40436 7959 33 made make VBN 40436 7959 34 sure sure JJ 40436 7959 35 , , , 40436 7959 36 and and CC 40436 7959 37 takes take VBZ 40436 7959 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7959 39 departure departure NN 40436 7959 40 from from IN 40436 7959 41 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 40436 7959 42 of of IN 40436 7959 43 which which WDT 40436 7959 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7959 45 renders render VBZ 40436 7959 46 no no DT 40436 7959 47 account account NN 40436 7959 48 -- -- : 40436 7959 49 as as IN 40436 7959 50 the the DT 40436 7959 51 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 7959 52 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7959 53 complains complain VBZ 40436 7959 54 of of IN 40436 7959 55 the the DT 40436 7959 56 geometers geometer NNS 40436 7959 57 for for IN 40436 7959 58 doing do VBG 40436 7959 59 . . . 40436 7960 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7960 2 135 135 CD 40436 7960 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7960 4 To to IN 40436 7960 5 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7960 6 , , , 40436 7960 7 social social JJ 40436 7960 8 or or CC 40436 7960 9 political political JJ 40436 7960 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 7960 11 is be VBZ 40436 7960 12 a a DT 40436 7960 13 known known JJ 40436 7960 14 and and CC 40436 7960 15 familiar familiar JJ 40436 7960 16 datum datum NN 40436 7960 17 , , , 40436 7960 18 about about IN 40436 7960 19 which which WDT 40436 7960 20 no no DT 40436 7960 21 one one NN 40436 7960 22 can can MD 40436 7960 23 mistake mistake VB 40436 7960 24 : : : 40436 7960 25 which which WDT 40436 7960 26 must must MD 40436 7960 27 be be VB 40436 7960 28 possessed possess VBN 40436 7960 29 , , , 40436 7960 30 in in IN 40436 7960 31 greater great JJR 40436 7960 32 or or CC 40436 7960 33 less less JJR 40436 7960 34 measure measure NN 40436 7960 35 , , , 40436 7960 36 by by IN 40436 7960 37 every every DT 40436 7960 38 man man NN 40436 7960 39 , , , 40436 7960 40 as as IN 40436 7960 41 a a DT 40436 7960 42 condition condition NN 40436 7960 43 of of IN 40436 7960 44 the the DT 40436 7960 45 existence existence NN 40436 7960 46 of of IN 40436 7960 47 society society NN 40436 7960 48 : : : 40436 7960 49 which which WDT 40436 7960 50 every every DT 40436 7960 51 individual individual NN 40436 7960 52 has have VBZ 40436 7960 53 an an DT 40436 7960 54 interest interest NN 40436 7960 55 in in IN 40436 7960 56 promoting promote VBG 40436 7960 57 in in IN 40436 7960 58 all all DT 40436 7960 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7960 60 neighbours neighbour NNS 40436 7960 61 : : : 40436 7960 62 and and CC 40436 7960 63 which which WDT 40436 7960 64 every every DT 40436 7960 65 one one NN 40436 7960 66 therefore therefore RB 40436 7960 67 teaches teach VBZ 40436 7960 68 and and CC 40436 7960 69 enforces enforce NNS 40436 7960 70 upon upon IN 40436 7960 71 every every DT 40436 7960 72 one one NN 40436 7960 73 else else RB 40436 7960 74 . . . 40436 7961 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 7961 2 is be VBZ 40436 7961 3 a a DT 40436 7961 4 matter matter NN 40436 7961 5 of of IN 40436 7961 6 common common JJ 40436 7961 7 sense sense NN 40436 7961 8 or or CC 40436 7961 9 common common JJ 40436 7961 10 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 7961 11 , , , 40436 7961 12 and and CC 40436 7961 13 thus thus RB 40436 7961 14 stands stand VBZ 40436 7961 15 in in IN 40436 7961 16 contrast contrast NN 40436 7961 17 with with IN 40436 7961 18 the the DT 40436 7961 19 special special JJ 40436 7961 20 professional professional JJ 40436 7961 21 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 7961 22 ; ; : 40436 7961 23 which which WDT 40436 7961 24 are be VBP 40436 7961 25 confined confine VBN 40436 7961 26 only only RB 40436 7961 27 to to IN 40436 7961 28 a a DT 40436 7961 29 few few JJ 40436 7961 30 -- -- : 40436 7961 31 and and CC 40436 7961 32 the the DT 40436 7961 33 possessors possessor NNS 40436 7961 34 , , , 40436 7961 35 teachers teacher NNS 40436 7961 36 , , , 40436 7961 37 and and CC 40436 7961 38 learners learner NNS 40436 7961 39 of of IN 40436 7961 40 which which WDT 40436 7961 41 are be VBP 40436 7961 42 each each DT 40436 7961 43 an an DT 40436 7961 44 assignable assignable JJ 40436 7961 45 section section NN 40436 7961 46 of of IN 40436 7961 47 the the DT 40436 7961 48 society society NN 40436 7961 49 . . . 40436 7962 1 The the DT 40436 7962 2 parts part NNS 40436 7962 3 or or CC 40436 7962 4 branches branch NNS 40436 7962 5 of of IN 40436 7962 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 7962 7 are be VBP 40436 7962 8 , , , 40436 7962 9 in in IN 40436 7962 10 like like NNP 40436 7962 11 manner manner NN 40436 7962 12 , , , 40436 7962 13 assumed assume VBN 40436 7962 14 by by IN 40436 7962 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7962 16 as as IN 40436 7962 17 known know VBN 40436 7962 18 , , , 40436 7962 19 in in IN 40436 7962 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7962 21 relations relation NNS 40436 7962 22 to to IN 40436 7962 23 each each DT 40436 7962 24 other other JJ 40436 7962 25 and and CC 40436 7962 26 to to IN 40436 7962 27 the the DT 40436 7962 28 whole whole NN 40436 7962 29 . . . 40436 7963 1 This this DT 40436 7963 2 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 7963 3 of of IN 40436 7963 4 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 7963 5 , , , 40436 7963 6 without without IN 40436 7963 7 preliminary preliminary JJ 40436 7963 8 investigation investigation NN 40436 7963 9 , , , 40436 7963 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7963 11 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 7963 12 from from IN 40436 7963 13 the the DT 40436 7963 14 general general JJ 40436 7963 15 public public NN 40436 7963 16 , , , 40436 7963 17 with with IN 40436 7963 18 whom whom WP 40436 7963 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7963 20 is be VBZ 40436 7963 21 in in IN 40436 7963 22 communion communion NN 40436 7963 23 of of IN 40436 7963 24 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 7963 25 . . . 40436 7964 1 What what WP 40436 7964 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7964 3 accept accept VBP 40436 7964 4 and and CC 40436 7964 5 enforce enforce VBP 40436 7964 6 as as IN 40436 7964 7 virtue virtue NN 40436 7964 8 , , , 40436 7964 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7964 10 accepts accept VBZ 40436 7964 11 and and CC 40436 7964 12 enforces enforce NNS 40436 7964 13 also also RB 40436 7964 14 . . . 40436 7965 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7965 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7965 3 135 135 CD 40436 7965 4 : : : 40436 7965 5 See see VB 40436 7965 6 suprà suprà NNS 40436 7965 7 , , , 40436 7965 8 vol vol NNP 40436 7965 9 . . . 40436 7966 1 i. i. NNP 40436 7966 2 ch ch NNP 40436 7966 3 . . . 40436 7967 1 viii viii RB 40436 7967 2 . . . 40436 7968 1 p. p. NN 40436 7968 2 358 358 CD 40436 7968 3 and and CC 40436 7968 4 ch ch NN 40436 7968 5 . . . 40436 7969 1 xvii xvii NN 40436 7969 2 . . . 40436 7970 1 * * NFP 40436 7970 2 * * NFP 40436 7970 3 p. p. NN 40436 7970 4 136 136 CD 40436 7970 5 , , , 40436 7970 6 respecting respect VBG 40436 7970 7 these these DT 40436 7970 8 remarks remark NNS 40436 7970 9 of of IN 40436 7970 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7970 11 on on IN 40436 7970 12 the the DT 40436 7970 13 geometers geometer NNS 40436 7970 14 . . . 40436 7970 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7971 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7971 2 Side side NN 40436 7971 3 - - HYPH 40436 7971 4 note note NN 40436 7971 5 : : : 40436 7971 6 Method Method NNP 40436 7971 7 of of IN 40436 7971 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7971 9 . . . 40436 7972 1 Continuous continuous JJ 40436 7972 2 lectures lecture NNS 40436 7972 3 addressed address VBD 40436 7972 4 to to IN 40436 7972 5 established establish VBN 40436 7972 6 public public JJ 40436 7972 7 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 7972 8 with with IN 40436 7972 9 which which WDT 40436 7972 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7972 11 is be VBZ 40436 7972 12 in in IN 40436 7972 13 harmony harmony NN 40436 7972 14 . . . 40436 7972 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7973 1 Again again RB 40436 7973 2 , , , 40436 7973 3 the the DT 40436 7973 4 method method NN 40436 7973 5 pursued pursue VBN 40436 7973 6 by by IN 40436 7973 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7973 8 , , , 40436 7973 9 is be VBZ 40436 7973 10 one one CD 40436 7973 11 suitable suitable JJ 40436 7973 12 to to IN 40436 7973 13 a a DT 40436 7973 14 teacher teacher NN 40436 7973 15 who who WP 40436 7973 16 has have VBZ 40436 7973 17 jumped jump VBN 40436 7973 18 over over IN 40436 7973 19 this this DT 40436 7973 20 first first JJ 40436 7973 21 step step NN 40436 7973 22 ; ; : 40436 7973 23 who who WP 40436 7973 24 assumes assume VBZ 40436 7973 25 virtue virtue NN 40436 7973 26 , , , 40436 7973 27 as as IN 40436 7973 28 something something NN 40436 7973 29 fixed fix VBN 40436 7973 30 in in IN 40436 7973 31 the the DT 40436 7973 32 public public JJ 40436 7973 33 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 7973 34 -- -- : 40436 7973 35 and and CC 40436 7973 36 addresses address VBZ 40436 7973 37 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7973 38 to to IN 40436 7973 39 those those DT 40436 7973 40 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 7973 41 , , , 40436 7973 42 ready ready JJ 40436 7973 43 - - HYPH 40436 7973 44 made make VBN 40436 7973 45 as as IN 40436 7973 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7973 47 finds find VBZ 40436 7973 48 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7973 49 . . . 40436 7974 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7974 2 expands expand VBZ 40436 7974 3 and and CC 40436 7974 4 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40436 7974 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7974 6 in in IN 40436 7974 7 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7974 8 lectures lecture NNS 40436 7974 9 of of IN 40436 7974 10 some some DT 40436 7974 11 length length NN 40436 7974 12 , , , 40436 7974 13 which which WDT 40436 7974 14 fill fill VBP 40436 7974 15 both both CC 40436 7974 16 the the DT 40436 7974 17 ears ear NNS 40436 7974 18 and and CC 40436 7974 19 minds mind NNS 40436 7974 20 of of IN 40436 7974 21 the the DT 40436 7974 22 listener--"Spartam listener--"Spartam NNP 40436 7974 23 nactus nactus NNP 40436 7974 24 es es NNP 40436 7974 25 , , , 40436 7974 26 hanc hanc NNP 40436 7974 27 exorna exorna NNP 40436 7974 28 " " '' 40436 7974 29 : : : 40436 7974 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7974 31 describes describe VBZ 40436 7974 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7974 33 growth growth NN 40436 7974 34 , , , 40436 7974 35 propagation propagation NN 40436 7974 36 , , , 40436 7974 37 and and CC 40436 7974 38 working work VBG 40436 7974 39 in in IN 40436 7974 40 the the DT 40436 7974 41 community community NN 40436 7974 42 : : : 40436 7974 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7974 44 gives give VBZ 40436 7974 45 interesting interesting JJ 40436 7974 46 comments comment NNS 40436 7974 47 on on IN 40436 7974 48 the the DT 40436 7974 49 poets poet NNS 40436 7974 50 , , , 40436 7974 51 eulogising eulogise VBG 40436 7974 52 the the DT 40436 7974 53 admired admired JJ 40436 7974 54 heroes hero NNS 40436 7974 55 who who WP 40436 7974 56 form form VBP 40436 7974 57 the the DT 40436 7974 58 theme theme NN 40436 7974 59 of of IN 40436 7974 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7974 61 verses verse NNS 40436 7974 62 , , , 40436 7974 63 and and CC 40436 7974 64 enlarging enlarge VBG 40436 7974 65 on on IN 40436 7974 66 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7974 67 admonitions admonition NNS 40436 7974 68 . . . 40436 7975 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 7975 2 , , , 40436 7975 3 while while IN 40436 7975 4 resting rest VBG 40436 7975 5 altogether altogether RB 40436 7975 6 upon upon IN 40436 7975 7 the the DT 40436 7975 8 authority authority NN 40436 7975 9 of of IN 40436 7975 10 King King NNP 40436 7975 11 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 7975 12 , , , 40436 7975 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7975 14 points point VBZ 40436 7975 15 out out RP 40436 7975 16 the the DT 40436 7975 17 best good JJS 40436 7975 18 jewel jewel NN 40436 7975 19 in in IN 40436 7975 20 the the DT 40436 7975 21 crown crown NN 40436 7975 22 of of IN 40436 7975 23 that that DT 40436 7975 24 potentate potentate NN 40436 7975 25 ; ; : 40436 7975 26 the the DT 40436 7975 27 great great JJ 40436 7975 28 social social JJ 40436 7975 29 fact fact NN 40436 7975 30 of of IN 40436 7975 31 punishment punishment NN 40436 7975 32 prospective prospective JJ 40436 7975 33 , , , 40436 7975 34 rationally rationally RB 40436 7975 35 apportioned apportion VBN 40436 7975 36 , , , 40436 7975 37 and and CC 40436 7975 38 employed employ VBN 40436 7975 39 altogether altogether RB 40436 7975 40 for for IN 40436 7975 41 preventing prevent VBG 40436 7975 42 and and CC 40436 7975 43 deterring deter VBG 40436 7975 44 -- -- : 40436 7975 45 instead instead RB 40436 7975 46 of of IN 40436 7975 47 being be VBG 40436 7975 48 a a DT 40436 7975 49 mere mere JJ 40436 7975 50 retrospective retrospective JJ 40436 7975 51 impulse impulse NN 40436 7975 52 , , , 40436 7975 53 vindictive vindictive JJ 40436 7975 54 or or CC 40436 7975 55 retributive retributive JJ 40436 7975 56 for for IN 40436 7975 57 the the DT 40436 7975 58 past past NN 40436 7975 59 . . . 40436 7976 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7976 2 describes describe VBZ 40436 7976 3 instructively instructively RB 40436 7976 4 the the DT 40436 7976 5 machinery machinery NN 40436 7976 6 operative operative NN 40436 7976 7 in in IN 40436 7976 8 the the DT 40436 7976 9 community community NN 40436 7976 10 for for IN 40436 7976 11 ensuring ensure VBG 40436 7976 12 obedience obedience NN 40436 7976 13 to to IN 40436 7976 14 what what WP 40436 7976 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7976 16 think think VBP 40436 7976 17 right right RB 40436 7976 18 : : : 40436 7976 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7976 20 teaches teach VBZ 40436 7976 21 , , , 40436 7976 22 in in IN 40436 7976 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7976 24 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 7976 25 expositions exposition NNS 40436 7976 26 and and CC 40436 7976 27 interpretations interpretation NNS 40436 7976 28 , , , 40436 7976 29 the the DT 40436 7976 30 same same JJ 40436 7976 31 morality morality NN 40436 7976 32 , , , 40436 7976 33 public public JJ 40436 7976 34 and and CC 40436 7976 35 private private JJ 40436 7976 36 , , , 40436 7976 37 that that IN 40436 7976 38 every every DT 40436 7976 39 one one CD 40436 7976 40 else else RB 40436 7976 41 teaches teach VBZ 40436 7976 42 : : : 40436 7976 43 while while IN 40436 7976 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7976 45 can can MD 40436 7976 46 perform perform VB 40436 7976 47 the the DT 40436 7976 48 work work NN 40436 7976 49 of of IN 40436 7976 50 teaching teaching NN 40436 7976 51 , , , 40436 7976 52 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 7976 53 more more RBR 40436 7976 54 effectively effectively RB 40436 7976 55 than than IN 40436 7976 56 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7976 57 . . . 40436 7977 1 Lastly lastly RB 40436 7977 2 , , , 40436 7977 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7977 4 method method NN 40436 7977 5 is be VBZ 40436 7977 6 essentially essentially RB 40436 7977 7 showy showy JJ 40436 7977 8 and and CC 40436 7977 9 popular popular JJ 40436 7977 10 ; ; : 40436 7977 11 intended intend VBN 40436 7977 12 for for IN 40436 7977 13 numerous numerous JJ 40436 7977 14 assemblies assembly NNS 40436 7977 15 , , , 40436 7977 16 reproducing reproduce VBG 40436 7977 17 the the DT 40436 7977 18 established established JJ 40436 7977 19 creeds creed NNS 40436 7977 20 and and CC 40436 7977 21 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 7977 22 of of IN 40436 7977 23 those those DT 40436 7977 24 assemblies assembly NNS 40436 7977 25 , , , 40436 7977 26 to to IN 40436 7977 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7977 28 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 7977 29 and and CC 40436 7977 30 admiration admiration NN 40436 7977 31 . . . 40436 7978 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7978 2 is be VBZ 40436 7978 3 prepared prepared JJ 40436 7978 4 to to TO 40436 7978 5 be be VB 40436 7978 6 met meet VBN 40436 7978 7 and and CC 40436 7978 8 answered answer VBN 40436 7978 9 in in IN 40436 7978 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7978 11 own own JJ 40436 7978 12 way way NN 40436 7978 13 , , , 40436 7978 14 by by IN 40436 7978 15 opposing oppose VBG 40436 7978 16 speakers speaker NNS 40436 7978 17 ; ; : 40436 7978 18 and and CC 40436 7978 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7978 20 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 7978 21 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7978 22 more more RBR 40436 7978 23 than than IN 40436 7978 24 a a DT 40436 7978 25 match match NN 40436 7978 26 for for IN 40436 7978 27 such such JJ 40436 7978 28 rivals rival NNS 40436 7978 29 . . . 40436 7979 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7979 2 professes profess VBZ 40436 7979 3 also also RB 40436 7979 4 to to TO 40436 7979 5 possess possess VB 40436 7979 6 the the DT 40436 7979 7 art art NN 40436 7979 8 of of IN 40436 7979 9 short short JJ 40436 7979 10 conversation conversation NN 40436 7979 11 or or CC 40436 7979 12 discussion discussion NN 40436 7979 13 . . . 40436 7980 1 But but CC 40436 7980 2 in in IN 40436 7980 3 the the DT 40436 7980 4 exercise exercise NN 40436 7980 5 of of IN 40436 7980 6 this this DT 40436 7980 7 art art NN 40436 7980 8 , , , 40436 7980 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7980 10 runs run VBZ 40436 7980 11 almost almost RB 40436 7980 12 involuntarily involuntarily RB 40436 7980 13 into into IN 40436 7980 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7980 15 more more RBR 40436 7980 16 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 7980 17 endowment endowment NN 40436 7980 18 of of IN 40436 7980 19 continuous continuous JJ 40436 7980 20 speech speech NN 40436 7980 21 : : : 40436 7980 22 besides besides IN 40436 7980 23 that that IN 40436 7980 24 the the DT 40436 7980 25 points point NNS 40436 7980 26 which which WDT 40436 7980 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7980 28 raises raise VBZ 40436 7980 29 for for IN 40436 7980 30 discussion discussion NN 40436 7980 31 assume assume VBP 40436 7980 32 all all PDT 40436 7980 33 the the DT 40436 7980 34 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 7980 35 principles principle NNS 40436 7980 36 , , , 40436 7980 37 and and CC 40436 7980 38 turn turn VB 40436 7980 39 only only RB 40436 7980 40 upon upon IN 40436 7980 41 such such JJ 40436 7980 42 applications application NNS 40436 7980 43 of of IN 40436 7980 44 those those DT 40436 7980 45 principles principle NNS 40436 7980 46 as as IN 40436 7980 47 are be VBP 40436 7980 48 admitted admit VBN 40436 7980 49 by by IN 40436 7980 50 most most JJS 40436 7980 51 persons person NNS 40436 7980 52 to to TO 40436 7980 53 be be VB 40436 7980 54 open open JJ 40436 7980 55 questions question NNS 40436 7980 56 , , , 40436 7980 57 not not RB 40436 7980 58 foreclosed foreclose VBN 40436 7980 59 by by IN 40436 7980 60 a a DT 40436 7980 61 peremptory peremptory JJ 40436 7980 62 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 40436 7980 63 . . . 40436 7981 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7981 2 Side side NN 40436 7981 3 - - HYPH 40436 7981 4 note note NN 40436 7981 5 : : : 40436 7981 6 Method Method NNP 40436 7981 7 of of IN 40436 7981 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7981 9 . . . 40436 7982 1 Dwells dwell NNS 40436 7982 2 upon upon IN 40436 7982 3 that that DT 40436 7982 4 part part NN 40436 7982 5 of of IN 40436 7982 6 the the DT 40436 7982 7 problem problem NN 40436 7982 8 which which WDT 40436 7982 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7982 10 had have VBD 40436 7982 11 left leave VBN 40436 7982 12 out out RP 40436 7982 13 . . . 40436 7982 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7983 1 Upon upon IN 40436 7983 2 all all PDT 40436 7983 3 these these DT 40436 7983 4 points point NNS 40436 7983 5 , , , 40436 7983 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7983 7 is be VBZ 40436 7983 8 the the DT 40436 7983 9 formal formal JJ 40436 7983 10 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 7983 11 of of IN 40436 7983 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7983 13 . . . 40436 7984 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7984 2 disclaims disclaim VBZ 40436 7984 3 altogether altogether RB 40436 7984 4 the the DT 40436 7984 5 capacities capacity NNS 40436 7984 6 to to TO 40436 7984 7 which which WDT 40436 7984 8 that that IN 40436 7984 9 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 7984 10 lays lay VBZ 40436 7984 11 claim claim NN 40436 7984 12 . . . 40436 7985 1 Not not RB 40436 7985 2 only only RB 40436 7985 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7985 4 can can MD 40436 7985 5 not not RB 40436 7985 6 teach teach VB 40436 7985 7 virtue virtue NN 40436 7985 8 , , , 40436 7985 9 but but CC 40436 7985 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7985 11 professes profess VBZ 40436 7985 12 not not RB 40436 7985 13 to to TO 40436 7985 14 know know VB 40436 7985 15 what what WP 40436 7985 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7985 17 is be VBZ 40436 7985 18 , , , 40436 7985 19 nor nor CC 40436 7985 20 whether whether IN 40436 7985 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7985 22 be be VB 40436 7985 23 teachable teachable JJ 40436 7985 24 at at RB 40436 7985 25 all all RB 40436 7985 26 , , , 40436 7985 27 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7985 28 starts start VBZ 40436 7985 29 from from IN 40436 7985 30 a a DT 40436 7985 31 different different JJ 40436 7985 32 point point NN 40436 7985 33 of of IN 40436 7985 34 view view NN 40436 7985 35 : : : 40436 7985 36 not not RB 40436 7985 37 considering consider VBG 40436 7985 38 virtue virtue NN 40436 7985 39 as as IN 40436 7985 40 a a DT 40436 7985 41 known know VBN 40436 7985 42 datum datum NN 40436 7985 43 , , , 40436 7985 44 or or CC 40436 7985 45 as as IN 40436 7985 46 an an DT 40436 7985 47 universal universal JJ 40436 7985 48 postulate postulate NN 40436 7985 49 , , , 40436 7985 50 but but CC 40436 7985 51 assimilating assimilate VBG 40436 7985 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7985 53 to to IN 40436 7985 54 a a DT 40436 7985 55 special special JJ 40436 7985 56 craft craft NN 40436 7985 57 or or CC 40436 7985 58 accomplishment accomplishment NN 40436 7985 59 , , , 40436 7985 60 in in IN 40436 7985 61 which which WDT 40436 7985 62 a a DT 40436 7985 63 few few JJ 40436 7985 64 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 7985 65 suffice suffice VBP 40436 7985 66 for for IN 40436 7985 67 the the DT 40436 7985 68 entire entire JJ 40436 7985 69 public public NN 40436 7985 70 : : : 40436 7985 71 requiring require VBG 40436 7985 72 that that IN 40436 7985 73 in in IN 40436 7985 74 this this DT 40436 7985 75 capacity capacity NN 40436 7985 76 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7985 77 shall shall MD 40436 7985 78 be be VB 40436 7985 79 defined define VBN 40436 7985 80 , , , 40436 7985 81 and and CC 40436 7985 82 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7985 83 practitioners practitioner NNS 40436 7985 84 and and CC 40436 7985 85 teachers teacher NNS 40436 7985 86 pointed point VBD 40436 7985 87 out out RP 40436 7985 88 . . . 40436 7986 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7986 2 has have VBZ 40436 7986 3 no no DT 40436 7986 4 common common JJ 40436 7986 5 ground ground NN 40436 7986 6 with with IN 40436 7986 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7986 8 ; ; : 40436 7986 9 for for IN 40436 7986 10 the the DT 40436 7986 11 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 7986 12 which which WDT 40436 7986 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7986 14 moots moot NNS 40436 7986 15 are be VBP 40436 7986 16 just just RB 40436 7986 17 such such JJ 40436 7986 18 as as IN 40436 7986 19 the the DT 40436 7986 20 common common JJ 40436 7986 21 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 7986 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7986 23 and and CC 40436 7986 24 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7986 25 along along IN 40436 7986 26 with with IN 40436 7986 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7986 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 7986 29 overleaps overleap NNS 40436 7986 30 or or CC 40436 7986 31 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 7986 32 to to TO 40436 7986 33 be be VB 40436 7986 34 settled settle VBN 40436 7986 35 . . . 40436 7987 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7987 2 first first JJ 40436 7987 3 requirement requirement NN 40436 7987 4 , , , 40436 7987 5 advanced advance VBN 40436 7987 6 under under IN 40436 7987 7 the the DT 40436 7987 8 modest modest JJ 40436 7987 9 guise guise NN 40436 7987 10 of of IN 40436 7987 11 a a DT 40436 7987 12 small small JJ 40436 7987 13 doubt[136 doubt[136 NNS 40436 7987 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7987 15 which which WDT 40436 7987 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7987 17 must must MD 40436 7987 18 certainly certainly RB 40436 7987 19 be be VB 40436 7987 20 competent competent JJ 40436 7987 21 to to TO 40436 7987 22 remove remove VB 40436 7987 23 , , , 40436 7987 24 is be VBZ 40436 7987 25 , , , 40436 7987 26 to to TO 40436 7987 27 know know VB 40436 7987 28 -- -- : 40436 7987 29 What what WDT 40436 7987 30 virtue virtue NN 40436 7987 31 is be VBZ 40436 7987 32 ? ? . 40436 7988 1 What what WP 40436 7988 2 are be VBP 40436 7988 3 the the DT 40436 7988 4 separate separate JJ 40436 7988 5 parts part NNS 40436 7988 6 of of IN 40436 7988 7 virtue virtue NN 40436 7988 8 -- -- : 40436 7988 9 justice justice NN 40436 7988 10 , , , 40436 7988 11 moderation moderation NN 40436 7988 12 , , , 40436 7988 13 holiness holiness NNP 40436 7988 14 , , , 40436 7988 15 & & CC 40436 7988 16 c. c. NNP 40436 7988 17 ? ? . 40436 7989 1 What what WP 40436 7989 2 is be VBZ 40436 7989 3 the the DT 40436 7989 4 relation relation NN 40436 7989 5 which which WDT 40436 7989 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7989 7 bear bear VBP 40436 7989 8 to to IN 40436 7989 9 each each DT 40436 7989 10 other other JJ 40436 7989 11 and and CC 40436 7989 12 to to IN 40436 7989 13 the the DT 40436 7989 14 whole whole JJ 40436 7989 15 -- -- : 40436 7989 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 7989 17 ? ? . 40436 7990 1 Are be VBP 40436 7990 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 7990 3 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 40436 7990 4 , , , 40436 7990 5 differing differ VBG 40436 7990 6 only only RB 40436 7990 7 in in IN 40436 7990 8 quantity quantity NN 40436 7990 9 or or CC 40436 7990 10 has have VBZ 40436 7990 11 each each DT 40436 7990 12 of of IN 40436 7990 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 7990 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7990 15 own own JJ 40436 7990 16 specific specific JJ 40436 7990 17 essence essence NN 40436 7990 18 and and CC 40436 7990 19 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 7990 20 ? ? . 40436 7991 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7991 2 137 137 CD 40436 7991 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7991 4 Respecting respect VBG 40436 7991 5 virtue virtue NN 40436 7991 6 as as IN 40436 7991 7 a a DT 40436 7991 8 whole whole NN 40436 7991 9 , , , 40436 7991 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 7991 11 must must MD 40436 7991 12 recollect recollect VB 40436 7991 13 , , , 40436 7991 14 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 7991 15 had have VBD 40436 7991 16 discoursed discourse VBN 40436 7991 17 eloquently eloquently RB 40436 7991 18 and and CC 40436 7991 19 confidently confidently RB 40436 7991 20 , , , 40436 7991 21 as as IN 40436 7991 22 of of IN 40436 7991 23 a a DT 40436 7991 24 matter matter NN 40436 7991 25 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 7991 26 known know VBN 40436 7991 27 . . . 40436 7992 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 7992 2 is be VBZ 40436 7992 3 now now RB 40436 7992 4 called call VBN 40436 7992 5 back back RB 40436 7992 6 as as IN 40436 7992 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7992 8 were be VBD 40436 7992 9 to to TO 40436 7992 10 meet meet VB 40436 7992 11 an an DT 40436 7992 12 attack attack NN 40436 7992 13 in in IN 40436 7992 14 the the DT 40436 7992 15 rear rear NN 40436 7992 16 : : : 40436 7992 17 to to TO 40436 7992 18 answer answer VB 40436 7992 19 questions question NNS 40436 7992 20 which which WDT 40436 7992 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7992 22 had have VBD 40436 7992 23 never never RB 40436 7992 24 considered consider VBN 40436 7992 25 , , , 40436 7992 26 and and CC 40436 7992 27 which which WDT 40436 7992 28 had have VBD 40436 7992 29 never never RB 40436 7992 30 even even RB 40436 7992 31 presented present VBN 40436 7992 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 7992 33 to to IN 40436 7992 34 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7992 35 as as IN 40436 7992 36 questions question NNS 40436 7992 37 . . . 40436 7993 1 At at IN 40436 7993 2 first first RB 40436 7993 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7993 4 replies reply VBZ 40436 7993 5 as as IN 40436 7993 6 if if IN 40436 7993 7 the the DT 40436 7993 8 questions question NNS 40436 7993 9 offered offer VBD 40436 7993 10 no no DT 40436 7993 11 difficulty;[138 difficulty;[138 NNS 40436 7993 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7993 13 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 7993 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7993 15 does do VBZ 40436 7993 16 not not RB 40436 7993 17 feel feel VB 40436 7993 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 7993 19 importance importance NN 40436 7993 20 , , , 40436 7993 21 so so IN 40436 7993 22 that that IN 40436 7993 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 7993 24 seems seem VBZ 40436 7993 25 to to IN 40436 7993 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 7993 27 a a DT 40436 7993 28 matter matter NN 40436 7993 29 of of IN 40436 7993 30 indifference indifference NN 40436 7993 31 whether whether IN 40436 7993 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7993 33 replies reply VBZ 40436 7993 34 in in IN 40436 7993 35 the the DT 40436 7993 36 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 7993 37 or or CC 40436 7993 38 negative negative JJ 40436 7993 39 . . . 40436 7994 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7994 2 139 139 CD 40436 7994 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7994 4 But but CC 40436 7994 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7994 6 finds find VBZ 40436 7994 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 7994 8 brought bring VBN 40436 7994 9 round round RB 40436 7994 10 , , , 40436 7994 11 by by IN 40436 7994 12 a a DT 40436 7994 13 series series NN 40436 7994 14 of of IN 40436 7994 15 questions question NNS 40436 7994 16 , , , 40436 7994 17 to to TO 40436 7994 18 assent assent VB 40436 7994 19 to to IN 40436 7994 20 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 7994 21 which which WDT 40436 7994 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7994 23 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 7994 24 thinks think VBZ 40436 7994 25 untrue untrue JJ 40436 7994 26 , , , 40436 7994 27 and and CC 40436 7994 28 which which WDT 40436 7994 29 are be VBP 40436 7994 30 certainly certainly RB 40436 7994 31 unwelcome unwelcome JJ 40436 7994 32 . . . 40436 7995 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 7995 2 , , , 40436 7995 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 7995 4 becomes become VBZ 40436 7995 5 more more JJR 40436 7995 6 and and CC 40436 7995 7 more more RBR 40436 7995 8 disgusted disgusted JJ 40436 7995 9 with with IN 40436 7995 10 the the DT 40436 7995 11 process process NN 40436 7995 12 of of IN 40436 7995 13 analytical analytical JJ 40436 7995 14 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 7995 15 : : : 40436 7995 16 and and CC 40436 7995 17 at at IN 40436 7995 18 length length NN 40436 7995 19 answers answer NNS 40436 7995 20 with with IN 40436 7995 21 such such JJ 40436 7995 22 impatience impatience NN 40436 7995 23 and and CC 40436 7995 24 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 7995 25 , , , 40436 7995 26 that that IN 40436 7995 27 the the DT 40436 7995 28 interrogation interrogation NN 40436 7995 29 can can MD 40436 7995 30 no no RB 40436 7995 31 longer longer RB 40436 7995 32 be be VB 40436 7995 33 prosecuted prosecute VBN 40436 7995 34 . . . 40436 7996 1 Here here RB 40436 7996 2 comes come VBZ 40436 7996 3 in in IN 40436 7996 4 the the DT 40436 7996 5 break break NN 40436 7996 6 -- -- : 40436 7996 7 the the DT 40436 7996 8 remonstrance remonstrance NN 40436 7996 9 of of IN 40436 7996 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 7996 11 -- -- : 40436 7996 12 and and CC 40436 7996 13 the the DT 40436 7996 14 mediation mediation NN 40436 7996 15 of of IN 40436 7996 16 the the DT 40436 7996 17 by by NN 40436 7996 18 - - HYPH 40436 7996 19 standers stander NNS 40436 7996 20 . . . 40436 7997 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7997 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7997 3 136 136 CD 40436 7997 4 : : : 40436 7997 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 7997 6 , , , 40436 7997 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 7997 8 . . . 40436 7998 1 p. p. NN 40436 7998 2 328 328 CD 40436 7998 3 E. E. NNP 40436 7998 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7998 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 7998 6 : : : 40436 7998 7 plê\n plê\n NNP 40436 7998 8 smikro smikro NN 40436 7998 9 / / SYM 40436 7998 10 n n NNP 40436 7998 11 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 7998 12 moi moi NNP 40436 7998 13 e)mpodô e)mpodô NNP 40436 7998 14 / / SYM 40436 7998 15 n n CD 40436 7998 16 , , , 40436 7998 17 o(/ o(/ JJ 40436 7998 18 dê dê NN 40436 7998 19 = = SYM 40436 7998 20 lon lon NN 40436 7998 21 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 7998 22 Prôtago Prôtago NNP 40436 7998 23 / / SYM 40436 7998 24 ras ras NNP 40436 7998 25 r(a|di r(a|di NNP 40436 7998 26 / / SYM 40436 7998 27 ôs ôs NNP 40436 7998 28 e)pekdida e)pekdida NNP 40436 7998 29 / / SYM 40436 7998 30 xei xei NNP 40436 7998 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7998 32 , , , 40436 7998 33 & & CC 40436 7998 34 c. c. NNP 40436 7998 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7998 36 [ [ -LRB- 40436 7998 37 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 7998 38 137 137 CD 40436 7998 39 : : : 40436 7998 40 Respecting Respecting NNP 40436 7998 41 Ariston Ariston NNP 40436 7998 42 of of IN 40436 7998 43 Chios Chios NNPS 40436 7998 44 , , , 40436 7998 45 Diogenes Diogenes NNPS 40436 7998 46 Laertius Laertius NNP 40436 7998 47 tells tell VBZ 40436 7998 48 us--[Greek us--[Greek NNP 40436 7998 49 : : : 40436 7998 50 A)reta\s A)reta\s NNP 40436 7998 51 d d NNP 40436 7998 52 ' ' `` 40436 7998 53 ou)/te ou)/te XX 40436 7998 54 polla\s polla\s -LRB- 40436 7998 55 ei)sê ei)sê NNP 40436 7998 56 = = SYM 40436 7998 57 gen gen NNP 40436 7998 58 , , , 40436 7998 59 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 7998 60 o o FW 40436 7998 61 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7998 62 Zê Zê NNP 40436 7998 63 / / SYM 40436 7998 64 nôn nôn NNP 40436 7998 65 , , , 40436 7998 66 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 7998 67 mi mi NNP 40436 7998 68 / / SYM 40436 7998 69 an an DT 40436 7998 70 polloi polloi NN 40436 7998 71 = = SYM 40436 7998 72 s s NN 40436 7998 73 o)no o)no NNP 40436 7998 74 / / SYM 40436 7998 75 masin masin NNP 40436 7998 76 kaloume kaloume NNP 40436 7998 77 / / SYM 40436 7998 78 nên nên NNP 40436 7998 79 -- -- : 40436 7998 80 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 7998 81 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 7998 82 to\ to\ NNP 40436 7998 83 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 7998 84 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 7998 85 pôs pôs NN 40436 7998 86 e)/chein e)/chein NN 40436 7998 87 ] ] -RRB- 40436 7998 88 ( ( -LRB- 40436 7998 89 Diog Diog NNP 40436 7998 90 . . . 40436 7999 1 Laert Laert NNP 40436 7999 2 . . . 40436 8000 1 vii vii NN 40436 8000 2 . . . 40436 8001 1 161 161 CD 40436 8001 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8001 3 . . . 40436 8001 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8002 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8002 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8002 3 138 138 CD 40436 8002 4 : : : 40436 8002 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8002 6 , , , 40436 8002 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8002 8 . . . 40436 8003 1 p. p. NN 40436 8003 2 329 329 CD 40436 8003 3 D. D. NNP 40436 8003 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8003 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8003 6 : : : 40436 8003 7 A)lla\ A)lla\ NNP 40436 8003 8 r(a/|dion r(a/|dion NNP 40436 8003 9 tou tou NN 40436 8003 10 = = SYM 40436 8003 11 to/ to/ CD 40436 8003 12 g g NN 40436 8003 13 ' ' '' 40436 8003 14 , , , 40436 8003 15 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 8003 16 , , , 40436 8003 17 a)pokri a)pokri NNP 40436 8003 18 / / SYM 40436 8003 19 nasthai nasthai NNP 40436 8003 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8003 21 , , , 40436 8003 22 & & CC 40436 8003 23 c. c. NNP 40436 8003 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8003 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8003 26 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8003 27 139 139 CD 40436 8003 28 : : : 40436 8003 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8003 30 , , , 40436 8003 31 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8003 32 . . . 40436 8004 1 p. p. NN 40436 8004 2 321 321 CD 40436 8004 3 D. D. NNP 40436 8004 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8004 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8004 6 : : : 40436 8004 7 ei ei LS 40436 8004 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8004 9 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8004 10 bou bou NN 40436 8004 11 / / SYM 40436 8004 12 lei lei NN 40436 8004 13 , , , 40436 8004 14 e)/stô e)/stô NN 40436 8004 15 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 8004 16 = = SYM 40436 8004 17 n n NNP 40436 8004 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8004 19 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 8004 20 / / SYM 40436 8004 21 nê nê NNP 40436 8004 22 o(/sion o(/sion NNP 40436 8004 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8004 24 o(sio o(sio NNP 40436 8004 25 / / SYM 40436 8004 26 tês tês NNP 40436 8004 27 di di NNP 40436 8004 28 / / SYM 40436 8004 29 kaion kaion NNP 40436 8004 30 . . . 40436 8005 1 Mê/ Mê/ NNP 40436 8005 2 moi moi NNP 40436 8005 3 , , , 40436 8005 4 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 8005 5 d d NNP 40436 8005 6 ' ' POS 40436 8005 7 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 8005 8 ; ; : 40436 8005 9 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 8005 10 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8005 11 de de NNP 40436 8005 12 / / SYM 40436 8005 13 omai omai NNP 40436 8005 14 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8005 15 " " `` 40436 8005 16 _ _ NNP 40436 8005 17 ei ei NNP 40436 8005 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8005 19 bou bou NN 40436 8005 20 / / SYM 40436 8005 21 lei lei NNP 40436 8005 22 _ _ NNP 40436 8005 23 " " `` 40436 8005 24 tou tou NNP 40436 8005 25 = = NNP 40436 8005 26 to to IN 40436 8005 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8005 28 " " `` 40436 8005 29 _ _ NNP 40436 8005 30 ei ei NNP 40436 8005 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8005 32 soi soi NN 40436 8005 33 dokei= dokei= NN 40436 8005 34 _ _ NNP 40436 8005 35 " " `` 40436 8005 36 e)le e)le NNP 40436 8005 37 / / SYM 40436 8005 38 gchesthai gchesthai NN 40436 8005 39 , , , 40436 8005 40 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 8005 41 ' ' '' 40436 8005 42 e)me/ e)me/ CD 40436 8005 43 te te NNP 40436 8005 44 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8005 45 se/. se/. NNP 40436 8005 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8005 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8006 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8006 2 Side side NN 40436 8006 3 - - HYPH 40436 8006 4 note note NN 40436 8006 5 : : : 40436 8006 6 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 8006 7 between between IN 40436 8006 8 the the DT 40436 8006 9 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 8006 10 lecturer lecturer NN 40436 8006 11 and and CC 40436 8006 12 the the DT 40436 8006 13 analytical analytical JJ 40436 8006 14 cross cross JJ 40436 8006 15 - - NN 40436 8006 16 examiner examiner NN 40436 8006 17 . . . 40436 8006 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8007 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8007 2 is be VBZ 40436 8007 3 this this DT 40436 8007 4 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 8007 5 between between IN 40436 8007 6 the the DT 40436 8007 7 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 8007 8 popular popular JJ 40436 8007 9 lecturer lecturer NN 40436 8007 10 , , , 40436 8007 11 and and CC 40436 8007 12 the the DT 40436 8007 13 analytical analytical JJ 40436 8007 14 enquirer enquirer NNP 40436 8007 15 and and CC 40436 8007 16 cross cross NN 40436 8007 17 - - NN 40436 8007 18 examiner examiner NN 40436 8007 19 , , , 40436 8007 20 which which WDT 40436 8007 21 the the DT 40436 8007 22 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8007 23 seems seem VBZ 40436 8007 24 mainly mainly RB 40436 8007 25 intended intend VBN 40436 8007 26 to to TO 40436 8007 27 set set VB 40436 8007 28 forth forth RB 40436 8007 29 . . . 40436 8008 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8008 2 professes profess VBZ 40436 8008 3 to to TO 40436 8008 4 know know VB 40436 8008 5 that that IN 40436 8008 6 which which WDT 40436 8008 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8008 8 neither neither CC 40436 8008 9 knows know VBZ 40436 8008 10 , , , 40436 8008 11 nor nor CC 40436 8008 12 has have VBZ 40436 8008 13 ever ever RB 40436 8008 14 tried try VBN 40436 8008 15 to to TO 40436 8008 16 probe probe VB 40436 8008 17 to to IN 40436 8008 18 the the DT 40436 8008 19 bottom bottom NN 40436 8008 20 . . . 40436 8009 1 Upon upon IN 40436 8009 2 this this DT 40436 8009 3 false false JJ 40436 8009 4 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8009 5 of of IN 40436 8009 6 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8009 7 , , , 40436 8009 8 the the DT 40436 8009 9 Sokratic Sokratic NNP 40436 8009 10 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 8009 11 is be VBZ 40436 8009 12 brought bring VBN 40436 8009 13 to to TO 40436 8009 14 bear bear VB 40436 8009 15 . . . 40436 8010 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8010 2 are be VBP 40436 8010 3 made make VBN 40436 8010 4 to to TO 40436 8010 5 see see VB 40436 8010 6 how how WRB 40436 8010 7 strange strange JJ 40436 8010 8 , , , 40436 8010 9 repugnant repugnant JJ 40436 8010 10 , , , 40436 8010 11 and and CC 40436 8010 12 perplexing perplexing NN 40436 8010 13 , , , 40436 8010 14 is be VBZ 40436 8010 15 the the DT 40436 8010 16 process process NN 40436 8010 17 of of IN 40436 8010 18 analysis analysis NN 40436 8010 19 to to IN 40436 8010 20 this this DT 40436 8010 21 eloquent eloquent JJ 40436 8010 22 expositor expositor NN 40436 8010 23 : : : 40436 8010 24 how how WRB 40436 8010 25 incompetent incompetent JJ 40436 8010 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8010 27 is be VBZ 40436 8010 28 to to TO 40436 8010 29 go go VB 40436 8010 30 through through IN 40436 8010 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8010 32 without without IN 40436 8010 33 confusion confusion NN 40436 8010 34 : : : 40436 8010 35 how how WRB 40436 8010 36 little little JJ 40436 8010 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8010 38 can can MD 40436 8010 39 define define VB 40436 8010 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8010 41 own own JJ 40436 8010 42 terms term NNS 40436 8010 43 , , , 40436 8010 44 or or CC 40436 8010 45 determine determine VB 40436 8010 46 the the DT 40436 8010 47 limits limit NNS 40436 8010 48 of of IN 40436 8010 49 those those DT 40436 8010 50 notions notion NNS 40436 8010 51 on on IN 40436 8010 52 which which WDT 40436 8010 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8010 54 is be VBZ 40436 8010 55 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 8010 56 descanting descant VBG 40436 8010 57 . . . 40436 8011 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8011 2 Side side NN 40436 8011 3 - - HYPH 40436 8011 4 note note NN 40436 8011 5 : : : 40436 8011 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8011 7 not not RB 40436 8011 8 intended intend VBD 40436 8011 9 to to TO 40436 8011 10 be be VB 40436 8011 11 always always RB 40436 8011 12 in in IN 40436 8011 13 the the DT 40436 8011 14 wrong wrong NN 40436 8011 15 , , , 40436 8011 16 though though IN 40436 8011 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8011 18 is be VBZ 40436 8011 19 described describe VBN 40436 8011 20 as as IN 40436 8011 21 brought bring VBN 40436 8011 22 to to IN 40436 8011 23 a a DT 40436 8011 24 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 8011 25 . . . 40436 8011 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8012 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8012 2 is be VBZ 40436 8012 3 not not RB 40436 8012 4 that that IN 40436 8012 5 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8012 6 is be VBZ 40436 8012 7 proved prove VBN 40436 8012 8 to to TO 40436 8012 9 be be VB 40436 8012 10 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8012 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8012 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8012 13 speak speak VBP 40436 8012 14 now now RB 40436 8012 15 of of IN 40436 8012 16 this this DT 40436 8012 17 early early JJ 40436 8012 18 part part NN 40436 8012 19 of of IN 40436 8012 20 the the DT 40436 8012 21 conversation conversation NN 40436 8012 22 , , , 40436 8012 23 between between IN 40436 8012 24 chapters chapter NNS 40436 8012 25 51 51 CD 40436 8012 26 - - HYPH 40436 8012 27 62 62 CD 40436 8012 28 - - HYPH 40436 8012 29 -pp -pp NN 40436 8012 30 . . . 40436 8013 1 329 329 CD 40436 8013 2 - - SYM 40436 8013 3 335 335 CD 40436 8013 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8013 5 in in IN 40436 8013 6 the the DT 40436 8013 7 substantive substantive JJ 40436 8013 8 ground ground NN 40436 8013 9 which which WDT 40436 8013 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8013 11 takes take VBZ 40436 8013 12 . . . 40436 8014 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8014 2 do do VBP 40436 8014 3 not not RB 40436 8014 4 at at RB 40436 8014 5 all all RB 40436 8014 6 believe believe VB 40436 8014 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8014 8 as as IN 40436 8014 9 many many JJ 40436 8014 10 critics critic NNS 40436 8014 11 either either CC 40436 8014 12 affirm affirm VBP 40436 8014 13 or or CC 40436 8014 14 imply imply VB 40436 8014 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8014 16 that that IN 40436 8014 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8014 18 intended intend VBD 40436 8014 19 all all DT 40436 8014 20 which which WDT 40436 8014 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8014 22 in in IN 40436 8014 23 the the DT 40436 8014 24 composed compose VBN 40436 8014 25 under under IN 40436 8014 26 the the DT 40436 8014 27 name name NN 40436 8014 28 of of IN 40436 8014 29 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8014 30 to to TO 40436 8014 31 be be VB 40436 8014 32 vile vile JJ 40436 8014 33 perversion perversion NN 40436 8014 34 of of IN 40436 8014 35 truth truth NN 40436 8014 36 , , , 40436 8014 37 with with IN 40436 8014 38 nothing nothing NN 40436 8014 39 but but IN 40436 8014 40 empty empty JJ 40436 8014 41 words word NNS 40436 8014 42 and and CC 40436 8014 43 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 8014 44 pretensions pretension NNS 40436 8014 45 . . . 40436 8015 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8015 2 do do VBP 40436 8015 3 not not RB 40436 8015 4 even even RB 40436 8015 5 believe believe VB 40436 8015 6 that that IN 40436 8015 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8015 8 intended intend VBD 40436 8015 9 all all PDT 40436 8015 10 those those DT 40436 8015 11 observations observation NNS 40436 8015 12 , , , 40436 8015 13 to to TO 40436 8015 14 which which WDT 40436 8015 15 the the DT 40436 8015 16 name name NN 40436 8015 17 of of IN 40436 8015 18 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8015 19 is be VBZ 40436 8015 20 prefixed prefix VBN 40436 8015 21 , , , 40436 8015 22 to to TO 40436 8015 23 be be VB 40436 8015 24 accounted account VBN 40436 8015 25 silly silly JJ 40436 8015 26 -- -- : 40436 8015 27 while while IN 40436 8015 28 all all DT 40436 8015 29 that that WDT 40436 8015 30 is be VBZ 40436 8015 31 assigned assign VBN 40436 8015 32 to to IN 40436 8015 33 Sokrates,[140 sokrates,[140 CD 40436 8015 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8015 35 is be VBZ 40436 8015 36 admirable admirable JJ 40436 8015 37 sense sense NN 40436 8015 38 and and CC 40436 8015 39 acuteness acuteness NN 40436 8015 40 . . . 40436 8016 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8016 2 is be VBZ 40436 8016 3 by by IN 40436 8016 4 no no DT 40436 8016 5 means mean NNS 40436 8016 6 certain certain JJ 40436 8016 7 that that IN 40436 8016 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8016 9 intended intend VBD 40436 8016 10 to to TO 40436 8016 11 be be VB 40436 8016 12 understood understand VBN 40436 8016 13 as as IN 40436 8016 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8016 15 endorsing endorse VBG 40436 8016 16 the the DT 40436 8016 17 opinions opinion NNS 40436 8016 18 which which WDT 40436 8016 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8016 20 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 8016 21 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 8016 22 to to IN 40436 8016 23 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8016 24 : : : 40436 8016 25 and and CC 40436 8016 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8016 27 is be VBZ 40436 8016 28 quite quite RB 40436 8016 29 certain certain JJ 40436 8016 30 that that IN 40436 8016 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8016 32 does do VBZ 40436 8016 33 not not RB 40436 8016 34 always always RB 40436 8016 35 make make VB 40436 8016 36 the the DT 40436 8016 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8016 38 of of IN 40436 8016 39 one one CD 40436 8016 40 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8016 41 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8016 42 with with IN 40436 8016 43 the the DT 40436 8016 44 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8016 45 of of IN 40436 8016 46 another another DT 40436 8016 47 . . . 40436 8017 1 For for IN 40436 8017 2 the the DT 40436 8017 3 purpose purpose NN 40436 8017 4 of of IN 40436 8017 5 showing show VBG 40436 8017 6 the the DT 40436 8017 7 incapacity incapacity NN 40436 8017 8 of of IN 40436 8017 9 the the DT 40436 8017 10 respondent respondent NN 40436 8017 11 to to TO 40436 8017 12 satisfy satisfy VB 40436 8017 13 the the DT 40436 8017 14 exigencies exigency NNS 40436 8017 15 of of IN 40436 8017 16 analysis analysis NN 40436 8017 17 , , , 40436 8017 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8017 19 need need VBP 40436 8017 20 not not RB 40436 8017 21 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 8017 22 suppose suppose VB 40436 8017 23 that that IN 40436 8017 24 the the DT 40436 8017 25 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 8017 26 to to TO 40436 8017 27 which which WDT 40436 8017 28 the the DT 40436 8017 29 questions question NNS 40436 8017 30 conduct conduct VBP 40436 8017 31 should should MD 40436 8017 32 be be VB 40436 8017 33 a a DT 40436 8017 34 true true JJ 40436 8017 35 one one NN 40436 8017 36 . . . 40436 8018 1 If if IN 40436 8018 2 the the DT 40436 8018 3 respondent respondent NN 40436 8018 4 be be VB 40436 8018 5 brought bring VBN 40436 8018 6 , , , 40436 8018 7 through through IN 40436 8018 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8018 9 own own JJ 40436 8018 10 admissions admission NNS 40436 8018 11 , , , 40436 8018 12 to to IN 40436 8018 13 a a DT 40436 8018 14 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 8018 15 , , , 40436 8018 16 this this DT 40436 8018 17 is be VBZ 40436 8018 18 enough enough JJ 40436 8018 19 to to TO 40436 8018 20 prove prove VB 40436 8018 21 that that IN 40436 8018 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8018 23 did do VBD 40436 8018 24 not not RB 40436 8018 25 know know VB 40436 8018 26 the the DT 40436 8018 27 subject subject NN 40436 8018 28 deeply deeply RB 40436 8018 29 enough enough RB 40436 8018 30 to to TO 40436 8018 31 make make VB 40436 8018 32 the the DT 40436 8018 33 proper proper JJ 40436 8018 34 answers answer NNS 40436 8018 35 and and CC 40436 8018 36 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 8018 37 . . . 40436 8019 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8019 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8019 3 140 140 CD 40436 8019 4 : : : 40436 8019 5 Schöne Schöne NNP 40436 8019 6 , , , 40436 8019 7 in in IN 40436 8019 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8019 9 Commentary Commentary NNP 40436 8019 10 on on IN 40436 8019 11 the the DT 40436 8019 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8019 13 , , , 40436 8019 14 is be VBZ 40436 8019 15 of of IN 40436 8019 16 opinion opinion NN 40436 8019 17 that that IN 40436 8019 18 a a DT 40436 8019 19 good good JJ 40436 8019 20 part part NN 40436 8019 21 of of IN 40436 8019 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8019 23 's 's POS 40436 8019 24 own own JJ 40436 8019 25 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8019 26 is be VBZ 40436 8019 27 given give VBN 40436 8019 28 under under IN 40436 8019 29 the the DT 40436 8019 30 name name NN 40436 8019 31 of of IN 40436 8019 32 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8019 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8019 34 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 8019 35 den den NN 40436 8019 36 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8019 37 . . . 40436 8020 1 von von NNP 40436 8020 2 Platon Platon NNP 40436 8020 3 , , , 40436 8020 4 p. p. NN 40436 8020 5 180 180 CD 40436 8020 6 seq seq NN 40436 8020 7 . . . 40436 8020 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8020 9 . . . 40436 8020 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8021 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8021 2 Side side NN 40436 8021 3 - - HYPH 40436 8021 4 note note NN 40436 8021 5 : : : 40436 8021 6 Affirmation affirmation NN 40436 8021 7 of of IN 40436 8021 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8021 9 about about IN 40436 8021 10 courage courage NN 40436 8021 11 is be VBZ 40436 8021 12 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 8021 13 by by IN 40436 8021 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8021 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8021 16 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 8021 17 . . . 40436 8021 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8022 1 But but CC 40436 8022 2 whatever whatever WDT 40436 8022 3 may may MD 40436 8022 4 have have VB 40436 8022 5 been be VBN 40436 8022 6 the the DT 40436 8022 7 intention intention NN 40436 8022 8 of of IN 40436 8022 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8022 10 , , , 40436 8022 11 if if IN 40436 8022 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8022 13 look look VBP 40436 8022 14 at at IN 40436 8022 15 the the DT 40436 8022 16 fact fact NN 40436 8022 17 , , , 40436 8022 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8022 19 shall shall MD 40436 8022 20 find find VB 40436 8022 21 that that IN 40436 8022 22 what what WP 40436 8022 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8022 24 has have VBZ 40436 8022 25 assigned assign VBN 40436 8022 26 to to IN 40436 8022 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8022 28 is be VBZ 40436 8022 29 not not RB 40436 8022 30 always always RB 40436 8022 31 true true JJ 40436 8022 32 , , , 40436 8022 33 nor nor CC 40436 8022 34 what what WP 40436 8022 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8022 36 has have VBZ 40436 8022 37 given give VBN 40436 8022 38 to to IN 40436 8022 39 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8022 40 , , , 40436 8022 41 always always RB 40436 8022 42 false false JJ 40436 8022 43 . . . 40436 8023 1 The the DT 40436 8023 2 positions position NNS 40436 8023 3 laid lay VBD 40436 8023 4 down down RP 40436 8023 5 by by IN 40436 8023 6 the the DT 40436 8023 7 latter latter JJ 40436 8023 8 -- -- : 40436 8023 9 That that IN 40436 8023 10 many many JJ 40436 8023 11 men man NNS 40436 8023 12 are be VBP 40436 8023 13 courageous courageous JJ 40436 8023 14 , , , 40436 8023 15 but but CC 40436 8023 16 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8023 17 : : : 40436 8023 18 that that IN 40436 8023 19 various various JJ 40436 8023 20 persons person NNS 40436 8023 21 are be VBP 40436 8023 22 just just RB 40436 8023 23 , , , 40436 8023 24 without without IN 40436 8023 25 being be VBG 40436 8023 26 wise wise JJ 40436 8023 27 and and CC 40436 8023 28 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 8023 29 : : : 40436 8023 30 that that IN 40436 8023 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8023 32 who who WP 40436 8023 33 possesses possess VBZ 40436 8023 34 one one CD 40436 8023 35 virtue virtue NN 40436 8023 36 , , , 40436 8023 37 does do VBZ 40436 8023 38 not not RB 40436 8023 39 of of IN 40436 8023 40 necessity necessity NN 40436 8023 41 possess possess NN 40436 8023 42 all:[141]--are all:[141]--are NN 40436 8023 43 not not RB 40436 8023 44 only only RB 40436 8023 45 in in IN 40436 8023 46 conformity conformity NN 40436 8023 47 with with IN 40436 8023 48 the the DT 40436 8023 49 common common JJ 40436 8023 50 opinion opinion NN 40436 8023 51 , , , 40436 8023 52 but but CC 40436 8023 53 are be VBP 40436 8023 54 quite quite RB 40436 8023 55 true true JJ 40436 8023 56 , , , 40436 8023 57 though though IN 40436 8023 58 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8023 59 is be VBZ 40436 8023 60 made make VBN 40436 8023 61 to to TO 40436 8023 62 dispute dispute VB 40436 8023 63 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8023 64 . . . 40436 8024 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 8024 2 , , , 40436 8024 3 the the DT 40436 8024 4 arguments argument NNS 40436 8024 5 employed employ VBN 40436 8024 6 by by IN 40436 8024 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8024 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8024 9 including include VBG 40436 8024 10 in in IN 40436 8024 11 those those DT 40436 8024 12 arguments argument NNS 40436 8024 13 the the DT 40436 8024 14 strange strange JJ 40436 8024 15 propositions proposition NNS 40436 8024 16 that that WDT 40436 8024 17 justice justice NN 40436 8024 18 is be VBZ 40436 8024 19 just just RB 40436 8024 20 , , , 40436 8024 21 and and CC 40436 8024 22 that that IN 40436 8024 23 holiness holiness NN 40436 8024 24 is be VBZ 40436 8024 25 holy holy JJ 40436 8024 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8024 27 are be VBP 40436 8024 28 certainly certainly RB 40436 8024 29 noway noway RB 40436 8024 30 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 8024 31 . . . 40436 8025 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8025 2 142 142 CD 40436 8025 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8025 4 Though Though NNP 40436 8025 5 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8025 6 , , , 40436 8025 7 becoming become VBG 40436 8025 8 entangled entangle VBN 40436 8025 9 in in IN 40436 8025 10 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 8025 11 , , , 40436 8025 12 and and CC 40436 8025 13 incapable incapable JJ 40436 8025 14 of of IN 40436 8025 15 maintaining maintain VBG 40436 8025 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8025 17 consistency consistency NN 40436 8025 18 against against IN 40436 8025 19 an an DT 40436 8025 20 embarrassing embarrassing JJ 40436 8025 21 cross cross NN 40436 8025 22 - - NN 40436 8025 23 examination examination NN 40436 8025 24 , , , 40436 8025 25 is be VBZ 40436 8025 26 of of IN 40436 8025 27 course course NN 40436 8025 28 exhibited exhibit VBN 40436 8025 29 as as IN 40436 8025 30 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 8025 31 of of IN 40436 8025 32 that that DT 40436 8025 33 which which WDT 40436 8025 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8025 35 professes profess VBZ 40436 8025 36 to to TO 40436 8025 37 know know VB 40436 8025 38 -- -- : 40436 8025 39 the the DT 40436 8025 40 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8025 41 which which WDT 40436 8025 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8025 43 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 8025 44 is be VBZ 40436 8025 45 neither neither CC 40436 8025 46 untrue untrue JJ 40436 8025 47 in in IN 40436 8025 48 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8025 49 , , , 40436 8025 50 nor nor CC 40436 8025 51 even even RB 40436 8025 52 shown show VBN 40436 8025 53 to to TO 40436 8025 54 be be VB 40436 8025 55 apparently apparently RB 40436 8025 56 untrue untrue JJ 40436 8025 57 . . . 40436 8026 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8026 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8026 3 141 141 CD 40436 8026 4 : : : 40436 8026 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8026 6 , , , 40436 8026 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8026 8 . . . 40436 8027 1 p. p. NN 40436 8027 2 329 329 CD 40436 8027 3 E. E. NNP 40436 8027 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8027 5 is be VBZ 40436 8027 6 here here RB 40436 8027 7 made make VBN 40436 8027 8 to to TO 40436 8027 9 affirm affirm VB 40436 8027 10 that that IN 40436 8027 11 many many JJ 40436 8027 12 men man NNS 40436 8027 13 are be VBP 40436 8027 14 courageous courageous JJ 40436 8027 15 who who WP 40436 8027 16 are be VBP 40436 8027 17 neither neither DT 40436 8027 18 just just RB 40436 8027 19 , , , 40436 8027 20 nor nor CC 40436 8027 21 temperate temperate VB 40436 8027 22 , , , 40436 8027 23 nor nor CC 40436 8027 24 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 8027 25 in in IN 40436 8027 26 other other JJ 40436 8027 27 respects respect NNS 40436 8027 28 . . . 40436 8028 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8028 2 contradicts contradict VBZ 40436 8028 3 the the DT 40436 8028 4 position position NN 40436 8028 5 . . . 40436 8029 1 But but CC 40436 8029 2 in in IN 40436 8029 3 the the DT 40436 8029 4 Treatise Treatise NNP 40436 8029 5 De De NNP 40436 8029 6 Legibus Legibus NNP 40436 8029 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8029 8 i. i. NNP 40436 8029 9 p. p. NN 40436 8029 10 630 630 CD 40436 8029 11 B B NNP 40436 8029 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8029 13 , , , 40436 8029 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8029 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8029 16 says say VBZ 40436 8029 17 same same JJ 40436 8029 18 thing thing NN 40436 8029 19 as as IN 40436 8029 20 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8029 21 is be VBZ 40436 8029 22 here here RB 40436 8029 23 made make VBN 40436 8029 24 to to TO 40436 8029 25 say say VB 40436 8029 26 : : : 40436 8029 27 at at IN 40436 8029 28 least least JJS 40436 8029 29 assuming assume VBG 40436 8029 30 that that IN 40436 8029 31 the the DT 40436 8029 32 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8029 33 speaker speaker NN 40436 8029 34 in in IN 40436 8029 35 De De NNP 40436 8029 36 Legg Legg NNP 40436 8029 37 . . . 40436 8030 1 represents represent VBZ 40436 8030 2 the the DT 40436 8030 3 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8030 4 of of IN 40436 8030 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8030 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8030 7 at at IN 40436 8030 8 the the DT 40436 8030 9 time time NN 40436 8030 10 when when WRB 40436 8030 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8030 12 composed compose VBD 40436 8030 13 that that DT 40436 8030 14 treatise treatise NN 40436 8030 15 . . . 40436 8030 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8031 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8031 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8031 3 142 142 CD 40436 8031 4 : : : 40436 8031 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8031 6 , , , 40436 8031 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8031 8 . . . 40436 8032 1 p. p. NN 40436 8032 2 330 330 CD 40436 8032 3 C C NNP 40436 8032 4 , , , 40436 8032 5 p. p. NN 40436 8032 6 333 333 CD 40436 8032 7 B. b. NN 40436 8033 1 To to TO 40436 8033 2 say say VB 40436 8033 3 " " `` 40436 8033 4 Justice justice NN 40436 8033 5 is be VBZ 40436 8033 6 just just RB 40436 8033 7 , , , 40436 8033 8 " " '' 40436 8033 9 or or CC 40436 8033 10 " " `` 40436 8033 11 Holiness Holiness NNP 40436 8033 12 is be VBZ 40436 8033 13 holy holy JJ 40436 8033 14 , , , 40436 8033 15 " " '' 40436 8033 16 is be VBZ 40436 8033 17 indeed indeed RB 40436 8033 18 either either CC 40436 8033 19 mere mere JJ 40436 8033 20 tautology tautology NN 40436 8033 21 , , , 40436 8033 22 or or CC 40436 8033 23 else else RB 40436 8033 24 an an DT 40436 8033 25 impropriety impropriety NN 40436 8033 26 of of IN 40436 8033 27 speech speech NN 40436 8033 28 . . . 40436 8034 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 8034 2 Hutcheson Hutcheson NNP 40436 8034 3 observes observe VBZ 40436 8034 4 on on IN 40436 8034 5 an an DT 40436 8034 6 analogous analogous JJ 40436 8034 7 case case NN 40436 8034 8 : : : 40436 8034 9 " " `` 40436 8034 10 None none NN 40436 8034 11 can can MD 40436 8034 12 apply apply VB 40436 8034 13 moral moral JJ 40436 8034 14 attributes attribute NNS 40436 8034 15 to to IN 40436 8034 16 the the DT 40436 8034 17 very very JJ 40436 8034 18 faculty faculty NN 40436 8034 19 of of IN 40436 8034 20 perceiving perceive VBG 40436 8034 21 moral moral JJ 40436 8034 22 qualities quality NNS 40436 8034 23 : : : 40436 8034 24 or or CC 40436 8034 25 call call VB 40436 8034 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8034 27 moral moral JJ 40436 8034 28 Sense Sense NNP 40436 8034 29 morally morally RB 40436 8034 30 Good good JJ 40436 8034 31 or or CC 40436 8034 32 Evil evil JJ 40436 8034 33 , , , 40436 8034 34 any any DT 40436 8034 35 more more RBR 40436 8034 36 than than IN 40436 8034 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8034 38 calls call VBZ 40436 8034 39 the the DT 40436 8034 40 power power NN 40436 8034 41 of of IN 40436 8034 42 tasting taste VBG 40436 8034 43 , , , 40436 8034 44 sweet sweet JJ 40436 8034 45 or or CC 40436 8034 46 bitter bitter JJ 40436 8034 47 -- -- : 40436 8034 48 or or CC 40436 8034 49 the the DT 40436 8034 50 power power NN 40436 8034 51 of of IN 40436 8034 52 seeing see VBG 40436 8034 53 , , , 40436 8034 54 straight straight RB 40436 8034 55 or or CC 40436 8034 56 crooked crooked JJ 40436 8034 57 , , , 40436 8034 58 white white JJ 40436 8034 59 or or CC 40436 8034 60 black black JJ 40436 8034 61 " " '' 40436 8034 62 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8034 63 Hutcheson Hutcheson NNP 40436 8034 64 on on IN 40436 8034 65 the the DT 40436 8034 66 Passions Passions NNPS 40436 8034 67 , , , 40436 8034 68 sect sect NN 40436 8034 69 . . . 40436 8035 1 i. i. NNP 40436 8035 2 p. p. NNP 40436 8036 1 234 234 CD 40436 8036 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8036 3 . . . 40436 8036 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8037 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8037 2 Side side NN 40436 8037 3 - - HYPH 40436 8037 4 note note NN 40436 8037 5 : : : 40436 8037 6 The the DT 40436 8037 7 harsh harsh JJ 40436 8037 8 epithets epithet NNS 40436 8037 9 applied apply VBN 40436 8037 10 by by IN 40436 8037 11 critics critic NNS 40436 8037 12 to to IN 40436 8037 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8037 14 are be VBP 40436 8037 15 not not RB 40436 8037 16 borne bear VBN 40436 8037 17 out out RP 40436 8037 18 by by IN 40436 8037 19 the the DT 40436 8037 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8037 21 . . . 40436 8038 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8038 2 stands stand VBZ 40436 8038 3 on on IN 40436 8038 4 the the DT 40436 8038 5 same same JJ 40436 8038 6 ground ground NN 40436 8038 7 as as IN 40436 8038 8 the the DT 40436 8038 9 common common JJ 40436 8038 10 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 8038 11 . . . 40436 8038 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8039 1 As as IN 40436 8039 2 to to IN 40436 8039 3 the the DT 40436 8039 4 arrogant arrogant JJ 40436 8039 5 and and CC 40436 8039 6 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 8039 7 pretensions pretension NNS 40436 8039 8 which which WDT 40436 8039 9 the the DT 40436 8039 10 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8039 11 commentators commentator NNS 40436 8039 12 ascribe ascribe VBP 40436 8039 13 to to IN 40436 8039 14 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8039 15 , , , 40436 8039 16 more more RBR 40436 8039 17 is be VBZ 40436 8039 18 said say VBN 40436 8039 19 than than IN 40436 8039 20 the the DT 40436 8039 21 reality reality NN 40436 8039 22 justifies justifie NNS 40436 8039 23 . . . 40436 8040 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8040 2 pretends pretend VBZ 40436 8040 3 to to TO 40436 8040 4 know know VB 40436 8040 5 what what WP 40436 8040 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 8040 7 , , , 40436 8040 8 justice justice NN 40436 8040 9 , , , 40436 8040 10 moderation moderation NN 40436 8040 11 , , , 40436 8040 12 courage courage NN 40436 8040 13 , , , 40436 8040 14 & & CC 40436 8040 15 c. c. NNP 40436 8040 16 , , , 40436 8040 17 are be VBP 40436 8040 18 , , , 40436 8040 19 and and CC 40436 8040 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8040 21 is be VBZ 40436 8040 22 proved prove VBN 40436 8040 23 not not RB 40436 8040 24 to to TO 40436 8040 25 know know VB 40436 8040 26 . . . 40436 8041 1 But but CC 40436 8041 2 this this DT 40436 8041 3 is be VBZ 40436 8041 4 what what WP 40436 8041 5 every every DT 40436 8041 6 one one CD 40436 8041 7 else else RB 40436 8041 8 pretends pretend NNS 40436 8041 9 to to TO 40436 8041 10 know know VB 40436 8041 11 also also RB 40436 8041 12 , , , 40436 8041 13 and and CC 40436 8041 14 what what WP 40436 8041 15 every every DT 40436 8041 16 body body NN 40436 8041 17 else else RB 40436 8041 18 teaches teach VBZ 40436 8041 19 as as RB 40436 8041 20 well well RB 40436 8041 21 as as IN 40436 8041 22 he--"_Hæc he--"_Hæc NNP 40436 8041 23 Janus Janus NNP 40436 8041 24 summus summus NN 40436 8041 25 ab ab NNP 40436 8041 26 imo imo NNP 40436 8041 27 Perdocet Perdocet NNP 40436 8041 28 : : : 40436 8041 29 hæc hæc NNP 40436 8041 30 recinunt recinunt NNP 40436 8041 31 juvenes juvenes NNP 40436 8041 32 dictata dictata NNP 40436 8041 33 senesque senesque NNP 40436 8041 34 _ _ NNP 40436 8041 35 " " '' 40436 8041 36 . . . 40436 8042 1 What what WP 40436 8042 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8042 3 pretends pretend VBZ 40436 8042 4 to to TO 40436 8042 5 do do VB 40436 8042 6 , , , 40436 8042 7 beyond beyond IN 40436 8042 8 the the DT 40436 8042 9 general general JJ 40436 8042 10 public public NN 40436 8042 11 , , , 40436 8042 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8042 13 really really RB 40436 8042 14 can can MD 40436 8042 15 do do VB 40436 8042 16 . . . 40436 8043 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8043 2 can can MD 40436 8043 3 discourse discourse VB 40436 8043 4 , , , 40436 8043 5 learnedly learnedly RB 40436 8043 6 and and CC 40436 8043 7 eloquently eloquently RB 40436 8043 8 , , , 40436 8043 9 upon upon IN 40436 8043 10 these these DT 40436 8043 11 received receive VBN 40436 8043 12 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 8043 13 and and CC 40436 8043 14 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8043 15 : : : 40436 8043 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8043 17 can can MD 40436 8043 18 enlist enlist VB 40436 8043 19 the the DT 40436 8043 20 feelings feeling NNS 40436 8043 21 and and CC 40436 8043 22 sympathies sympathy NNS 40436 8043 23 of of IN 40436 8043 24 the the DT 40436 8043 25 public public NN 40436 8043 26 in in IN 40436 8043 27 favour favour NN 40436 8043 28 of of IN 40436 8043 29 that that DT 40436 8043 30 which which WDT 40436 8043 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8043 32 , , , 40436 8043 33 in in IN 40436 8043 34 common common JJ 40436 8043 35 with with IN 40436 8043 36 the the DT 40436 8043 37 public public NN 40436 8043 38 , , , 40436 8043 39 believes believe VBZ 40436 8043 40 to to TO 40436 8043 41 be be VB 40436 8043 42 good good JJ 40436 8043 43 -- -- : 40436 8043 44 and and CC 40436 8043 45 against against IN 40436 8043 46 that that DT 40436 8043 47 which which WDT 40436 8043 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8043 49 and and CC 40436 8043 50 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8043 51 believe believe VBP 40436 8043 52 to to TO 40436 8043 53 be be VB 40436 8043 54 bad bad JJ 40436 8043 55 : : : 40436 8043 56 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8043 57 can can MD 40436 8043 58 thus thus RB 40436 8043 59 teach teach VB 40436 8043 60 virtue virtue NN 40436 8043 61 more more RBR 40436 8043 62 effectively effectively RB 40436 8043 63 than than IN 40436 8043 64 others other NNS 40436 8043 65 . . . 40436 8044 1 But but CC 40436 8044 2 whether whether IN 40436 8044 3 that that DT 40436 8044 4 which which WDT 40436 8044 5 is be VBZ 40436 8044 6 received receive VBN 40436 8044 7 as as IN 40436 8044 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 8044 9 , , , 40436 8044 10 be be VB 40436 8044 11 really really RB 40436 8044 12 such such JJ 40436 8044 13 -- -- : 40436 8044 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8044 15 has have VBZ 40436 8044 16 never never RB 40436 8044 17 analysed analyse VBN 40436 8044 18 or or CC 40436 8044 19 verified verify VBN 40436 8044 20 : : : 40436 8044 21 nor nor CC 40436 8044 22 does do VBZ 40436 8044 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8044 24 willingly willingly RB 40436 8044 25 submit submit VB 40436 8044 26 to to IN 40436 8044 27 the the DT 40436 8044 28 process process NN 40436 8044 29 of of IN 40436 8044 30 analysis analysis NN 40436 8044 31 . . . 40436 8045 1 Here here RB 40436 8045 2 again again RB 40436 8045 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8045 4 is be VBZ 40436 8045 5 in in IN 40436 8045 6 harmony harmony NN 40436 8045 7 with with IN 40436 8045 8 the the DT 40436 8045 9 general general JJ 40436 8045 10 public public NN 40436 8045 11 ; ; : 40436 8045 12 for for IN 40436 8045 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8045 14 hate hate VBP 40436 8045 15 , , , 40436 8045 16 as as RB 40436 8045 17 much much RB 40436 8045 18 as as IN 40436 8045 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8045 20 does do VBZ 40436 8045 21 , , , 40436 8045 22 to to TO 40436 8045 23 be be VB 40436 8045 24 dragged drag VBN 40436 8045 25 back back RB 40436 8045 26 to to IN 40436 8045 27 fundamentals fundamental NNS 40436 8045 28 , , , 40436 8045 29 and and CC 40436 8045 30 forced force VBN 40436 8045 31 to to TO 40436 8045 32 explain explain VB 40436 8045 33 , , , 40436 8045 34 defend defend VB 40436 8045 35 , , , 40436 8045 36 revise revise VB 40436 8045 37 , , , 40436 8045 38 or or CC 40436 8045 39 modify modify NNP 40436 8045 40 , , , 40436 8045 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8045 42 established establish VBN 40436 8045 43 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8045 44 and and CC 40436 8045 45 maxims maxim NNS 40436 8045 46 : : : 40436 8045 47 which which WDT 40436 8045 48 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8045 49 apply apply VBP 40436 8045 50 as as IN 40436 8045 51 _ _ NNP 40436 8045 52 principia principia NN 40436 8045 53 _ _ NNP 40436 8045 54 for for IN 40436 8045 55 deduction deduction NN 40436 8045 56 to to IN 40436 8045 57 particular particular JJ 40436 8045 58 cases case NNS 40436 8045 59 , , , 40436 8045 60 and and CC 40436 8045 61 which which WDT 40436 8045 62 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8045 63 recognise recognise VBP 40436 8045 64 as as IN 40436 8045 65 axioms axiom NNS 40436 8045 66 whereby whereby WRB 40436 8045 67 other other JJ 40436 8045 68 things thing NNS 40436 8045 69 are be VBP 40436 8045 70 to to TO 40436 8045 71 be be VB 40436 8045 72 tried try VBN 40436 8045 73 , , , 40436 8045 74 not not RB 40436 8045 75 as as RB 40436 8045 76 liable liable JJ 40436 8045 77 to to TO 40436 8045 78 be be VB 40436 8045 79 tried try VBN 40436 8045 80 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8045 81 . . . 40436 8046 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8046 2 is be VBZ 40436 8046 3 one one CD 40436 8046 4 of of IN 40436 8046 5 the the DT 40436 8046 6 general general JJ 40436 8046 7 public public NN 40436 8046 8 , , , 40436 8046 9 in in IN 40436 8046 10 dislike dislike NN 40436 8046 11 of of IN 40436 8046 12 , , , 40436 8046 13 and and CC 40436 8046 14 inaptitude inaptitude VB 40436 8046 15 for for IN 40436 8046 16 , , , 40436 8046 17 analysis analysis NN 40436 8046 18 and and CC 40436 8046 19 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 8046 20 discussion discussion NN 40436 8046 21 : : : 40436 8046 22 while while IN 40436 8046 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8046 24 stands stand VBZ 40436 8046 25 above above IN 40436 8046 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8046 27 in in IN 40436 8046 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8046 29 eloquence eloquence NN 40436 8046 30 and and CC 40436 8046 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8046 32 power power NN 40436 8046 33 of of IN 40436 8046 34 combining combine VBG 40436 8046 35 , , , 40436 8046 36 illustrating illustrating NN 40436 8046 37 , , , 40436 8046 38 and and CC 40436 8046 39 adorning adorn VBG 40436 8046 40 , , , 40436 8046 41 received receive VBD 40436 8046 42 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 8046 43 . . . 40436 8047 1 These these DT 40436 8047 2 are be VBP 40436 8047 3 points point NNS 40436 8047 4 of of IN 40436 8047 5 superiority superiority NN 40436 8047 6 , , , 40436 8047 7 not not RB 40436 8047 8 pretended pretend VBN 40436 8047 9 , , , 40436 8047 10 but but CC 40436 8047 11 real real JJ 40436 8047 12 . . . 40436 8048 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8048 2 Side side NN 40436 8048 3 - - HYPH 40436 8048 4 note note NN 40436 8048 5 : : : 40436 8048 6 Aversion aversion NN 40436 8048 7 of of IN 40436 8048 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8048 9 for for IN 40436 8048 10 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 8048 11 . . . 40436 8049 1 Interlude interlude NN 40436 8049 2 about about IN 40436 8049 3 the the DT 40436 8049 4 song song NN 40436 8049 5 of of IN 40436 8049 6 Simonides Simonides NNP 40436 8049 7 . . . 40436 8049 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8050 1 The the DT 40436 8050 2 aversion aversion NN 40436 8050 3 of of IN 40436 8050 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8050 5 for for IN 40436 8050 6 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 8050 7 discussion discussion NN 40436 8050 8 -- -- : 40436 8050 9 after after IN 40436 8050 10 causing cause VBG 40436 8050 11 an an DT 40436 8050 12 interruption interruption NN 40436 8050 13 of of IN 40436 8050 14 the the DT 40436 8050 15 ethical ethical JJ 40436 8050 16 argument argument NN 40436 8050 17 , , , 40436 8050 18 and and CC 40436 8050 19 an an DT 40436 8050 20 interlude interlude NN 40436 8050 21 of of IN 40436 8050 22 comment comment NN 40436 8050 23 on on IN 40436 8050 24 the the DT 40436 8050 25 poet poet NN 40436 8050 26 Simonides simonide NNS 40436 8050 27 -- -- : 40436 8050 28 is be VBZ 40436 8050 29 at at IN 40436 8050 30 length length NN 40436 8050 31 with with IN 40436 8050 32 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 8050 33 overcome overcome NN 40436 8050 34 , , , 40436 8050 35 and and CC 40436 8050 36 the the DT 40436 8050 37 argument argument NN 40436 8050 38 is be VBZ 40436 8050 39 then then RB 40436 8050 40 resumed resume VBN 40436 8050 41 . . . 40436 8051 1 The the DT 40436 8051 2 question question NN 40436 8051 3 still still RB 40436 8051 4 continues continue VBZ 40436 8051 5 , , , 40436 8051 6 What what WP 40436 8051 7 is be VBZ 40436 8051 8 virtue virtue JJ 40436 8051 9 ? ? . 40436 8052 1 What what WP 40436 8052 2 are be VBP 40436 8052 3 the the DT 40436 8052 4 five five CD 40436 8052 5 different different JJ 40436 8052 6 parts part NNS 40436 8052 7 of of IN 40436 8052 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 8052 9 ? ? . 40436 8053 1 Yet yet CC 40436 8053 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8053 3 is be VBZ 40436 8053 4 so so RB 40436 8053 5 far far RB 40436 8053 6 altered alter VBN 40436 8053 7 that that IN 40436 8053 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8053 9 now now RB 40436 8053 10 admits admit VBZ 40436 8053 11 that that IN 40436 8053 12 the the DT 40436 8053 13 four four CD 40436 8053 14 parts part NNS 40436 8053 15 of of IN 40436 8053 16 virtue virtue NN 40436 8053 17 which which WDT 40436 8053 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8053 19 professed profess VBD 40436 8053 20 to to TO 40436 8053 21 have have VB 40436 8053 22 shown show VBN 40436 8053 23 to to TO 40436 8053 24 be be VB 40436 8053 25 nearly nearly RB 40436 8053 26 identical identical JJ 40436 8053 27 , , , 40436 8053 28 really really RB 40436 8053 29 are be VBP 40436 8053 30 tolerably tolerably RB 40436 8053 31 alike alike RB 40436 8053 32 : : : 40436 8053 33 but but CC 40436 8053 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8053 35 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 8053 36 contends contend VBZ 40436 8053 37 that that IN 40436 8053 38 courage courage NN 40436 8053 39 is be VBZ 40436 8053 40 very very RB 40436 8053 41 different different JJ 40436 8053 42 from from IN 40436 8053 43 all all DT 40436 8053 44 of of IN 40436 8053 45 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8053 46 , , , 40436 8053 47 repeating repeat VBG 40436 8053 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8053 49 declaration declaration NN 40436 8053 50 that that IN 40436 8053 51 many many JJ 40436 8053 52 men man NNS 40436 8053 53 are be VBP 40436 8053 54 courageous courageous JJ 40436 8053 55 , , , 40436 8053 56 but but CC 40436 8053 57 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8053 58 and and CC 40436 8053 59 stupid stupid JJ 40436 8053 60 at at IN 40436 8053 61 the the DT 40436 8053 62 same same JJ 40436 8053 63 time time NN 40436 8053 64 . . . 40436 8054 1 This this DT 40436 8054 2 position position NN 40436 8054 3 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 8054 4 undertakes undertake VBZ 40436 8054 5 to to TO 40436 8054 6 refute refute VB 40436 8054 7 . . . 40436 8055 1 In in IN 40436 8055 2 doing do VBG 40436 8055 3 so so RB 40436 8055 4 , , , 40436 8055 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8055 6 lays lay VBZ 40436 8055 7 out out RP 40436 8055 8 one one CD 40436 8055 9 of of IN 40436 8055 10 the the DT 40436 8055 11 largest large JJS 40436 8055 12 , , , 40436 8055 13 most most RBS 40436 8055 14 distinct distinct JJ 40436 8055 15 , , , 40436 8055 16 and and CC 40436 8055 17 most most RBS 40436 8055 18 positive positive JJ 40436 8055 19 theories theory NNS 40436 8055 20 of of IN 40436 8055 21 virtue virtue NN 40436 8055 22 , , , 40436 8055 23 which which WDT 40436 8055 24 can can MD 40436 8055 25 be be VB 40436 8055 26 found find VBN 40436 8055 27 in in IN 40436 8055 28 the the DT 40436 8055 29 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8055 30 writings writing NNS 40436 8055 31 . . . 40436 8056 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8056 2 Side side NN 40436 8056 3 - - HYPH 40436 8056 4 note note NN 40436 8056 5 : : : 40436 8056 6 Ethical ethical JJ 40436 8056 7 view view NN 40436 8056 8 given give VBN 40436 8056 9 by by IN 40436 8056 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8056 11 worked work VBD 40436 8056 12 out out RP 40436 8056 13 at at IN 40436 8056 14 length length NN 40436 8056 15 clearly clearly RB 40436 8056 16 . . . 40436 8057 1 Good good JJ 40436 8057 2 and and CC 40436 8057 3 evil evil NN 40436 8057 4 consist consist VBP 40436 8057 5 in in IN 40436 8057 6 right right NN 40436 8057 7 or or CC 40436 8057 8 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8057 9 calculation calculation NN 40436 8057 10 of of IN 40436 8057 11 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8057 12 and and CC 40436 8057 13 pains pain NNS 40436 8057 14 of of IN 40436 8057 15 the the DT 40436 8057 16 agent agent NN 40436 8057 17 . . . 40436 8057 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8058 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 40436 8058 2 , , , 40436 8058 3 according accord VBG 40436 8058 4 to to IN 40436 8058 5 this this DT 40436 8058 6 theory theory NN 40436 8058 7 , , , 40436 8058 8 consists consist VBZ 40436 8058 9 in in IN 40436 8058 10 a a DT 40436 8058 11 right right JJ 40436 8058 12 measurement measurement NN 40436 8058 13 and and CC 40436 8058 14 choice choice NN 40436 8058 15 of of IN 40436 8058 16 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8058 17 and and CC 40436 8058 18 pains pain NNS 40436 8058 19 : : : 40436 8058 20 in in IN 40436 8058 21 deciding decide VBG 40436 8058 22 correctly correctly RB 40436 8058 23 , , , 40436 8058 24 wherever wherever WRB 40436 8058 25 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8058 26 have have VBP 40436 8058 27 an an DT 40436 8058 28 alternative alternative NN 40436 8058 29 , , , 40436 8058 30 on on IN 40436 8058 31 which which WDT 40436 8058 32 side side NN 40436 8058 33 lies lie VBZ 40436 8058 34 the the DT 40436 8058 35 largest large JJS 40436 8058 36 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8058 37 or or CC 40436 8058 38 the the DT 40436 8058 39 least least JJS 40436 8058 40 pain pain NN 40436 8058 41 -- -- : 40436 8058 42 and and CC 40436 8058 43 choosing choose VBG 40436 8058 44 the the DT 40436 8058 45 side side NN 40436 8058 46 which which WDT 40436 8058 47 presents present VBZ 40436 8058 48 this this DT 40436 8058 49 balance balance NN 40436 8058 50 . . . 40436 8059 1 To to TO 40436 8059 2 live live VB 40436 8059 3 pleasurably pleasurably RB 40436 8059 4 , , , 40436 8059 5 is be VBZ 40436 8059 6 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 8059 7 to to TO 40436 8059 8 be be VB 40436 8059 9 good good JJ 40436 8059 10 : : : 40436 8059 11 to to TO 40436 8059 12 live live VB 40436 8059 13 without without IN 40436 8059 14 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8059 15 or or CC 40436 8059 16 in in IN 40436 8059 17 pain pain NN 40436 8059 18 , , , 40436 8059 19 is be VBZ 40436 8059 20 evil evil JJ 40436 8059 21 . . . 40436 8060 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 8060 2 , , , 40436 8060 3 nothing nothing NN 40436 8060 4 but but IN 40436 8060 5 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8060 6 , , , 40436 8060 7 or or CC 40436 8060 8 comparative comparative JJ 40436 8060 9 mitigation mitigation NN 40436 8060 10 of of IN 40436 8060 11 pain pain NN 40436 8060 12 , , , 40436 8060 13 is be VBZ 40436 8060 14 good good JJ 40436 8060 15 : : : 40436 8060 16 nothing nothing NN 40436 8060 17 but but IN 40436 8060 18 pain pain NN 40436 8060 19 is be VBZ 40436 8060 20 evil evil JJ 40436 8060 21 . . . 40436 8061 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8061 2 143 143 CD 40436 8061 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8061 4 Good good JJ 40436 8061 5 , , , 40436 8061 6 is be VBZ 40436 8061 7 identical identical JJ 40436 8061 8 with with IN 40436 8061 9 the the DT 40436 8061 10 greatest great JJS 40436 8061 11 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8061 12 or or CC 40436 8061 13 least least JJS 40436 8061 14 pain pain NN 40436 8061 15 : : : 40436 8061 16 evil evil NN 40436 8061 17 , , , 40436 8061 18 with with IN 40436 8061 19 greatest great JJS 40436 8061 20 pain pain NN 40436 8061 21 : : : 40436 8061 22 meaning mean VBG 40436 8061 23 thereby thereby RB 40436 8061 24 each each DT 40436 8061 25 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8061 26 and and CC 40436 8061 27 each each DT 40436 8061 28 pain pain NN 40436 8061 29 when when WRB 40436 8061 30 looked look VBD 40436 8061 31 at at IN 40436 8061 32 along along RB 40436 8061 33 with with IN 40436 8061 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8061 35 consequences consequence NNS 40436 8061 36 and and CC 40436 8061 37 concomitants concomitant NNS 40436 8061 38 . . . 40436 8062 1 The the DT 40436 8062 2 grand grand JJ 40436 8062 3 determining determine VBG 40436 8062 4 cause cause NN 40436 8062 5 and and CC 40436 8062 6 condition condition NN 40436 8062 7 of of IN 40436 8062 8 virtue virtue NN 40436 8062 9 is be VBZ 40436 8062 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8062 11 : : : 40436 8062 12 the the DT 40436 8062 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8062 14 , , , 40436 8062 15 science science NN 40436 8062 16 , , , 40436 8062 17 or or CC 40436 8062 18 art art NN 40436 8062 19 , , , 40436 8062 20 of of IN 40436 8062 21 correctly correctly RB 40436 8062 22 measuring measure VBG 40436 8062 23 the the DT 40436 8062 24 comparative comparative JJ 40436 8062 25 value value NN 40436 8062 26 of of IN 40436 8062 27 different different JJ 40436 8062 28 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8062 29 and and CC 40436 8062 30 pains pain NNS 40436 8062 31 . . . 40436 8063 1 Such such JJ 40436 8063 2 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8063 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8063 4 the the DT 40436 8063 5 theory theory NN 40436 8063 6 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 8063 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8063 8 , , , 40436 8063 9 wherever wherever WRB 40436 8063 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8063 11 is be VBZ 40436 8063 12 possessed possess VBN 40436 8063 13 , , , 40436 8063 14 will will MD 40436 8063 15 be be VB 40436 8063 16 sure sure JJ 40436 8063 17 to to TO 40436 8063 18 command command VB 40436 8063 19 the the DT 40436 8063 20 whole whole JJ 40436 8063 21 man man NN 40436 8063 22 , , , 40436 8063 23 to to TO 40436 8063 24 dictate dictate VB 40436 8063 25 all all PDT 40436 8063 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8063 27 conduct conduct NN 40436 8063 28 , , , 40436 8063 29 and and CC 40436 8063 30 to to TO 40436 8063 31 prevail prevail VB 40436 8063 32 over over IN 40436 8063 33 every every DT 40436 8063 34 temptation temptation NN 40436 8063 35 of of IN 40436 8063 36 special special JJ 40436 8063 37 appetite appetite NN 40436 8063 38 or or CC 40436 8063 39 aversion aversion NN 40436 8063 40 . . . 40436 8064 1 To to TO 40436 8064 2 say say VB 40436 8064 3 that that IN 40436 8064 4 a a DT 40436 8064 5 man man NN 40436 8064 6 who who WP 40436 8064 7 knows know VBZ 40436 8064 8 on on IN 40436 8064 9 which which WDT 40436 8064 10 side side NN 40436 8064 11 the the DT 40436 8064 12 greatest great JJS 40436 8064 13 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8064 14 or or CC 40436 8064 15 the the DT 40436 8064 16 least least JJS 40436 8064 17 pain pain NN 40436 8064 18 lies lie NNS 40436 8064 19 , , , 40436 8064 20 will will MD 40436 8064 21 act act VB 40436 8064 22 against against IN 40436 8064 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8064 24 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8064 25 -- -- : 40436 8064 26 is be VBZ 40436 8064 27 a a DT 40436 8064 28 mistake mistake NN 40436 8064 29 . . . 40436 8065 1 If if IN 40436 8065 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8065 3 acts act VBZ 40436 8065 4 in in IN 40436 8065 5 this this DT 40436 8065 6 way way NN 40436 8065 7 , , , 40436 8065 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8065 9 is be VBZ 40436 8065 10 plain plain JJ 40436 8065 11 that that IN 40436 8065 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8065 13 does do VBZ 40436 8065 14 not not RB 40436 8065 15 possess possess VB 40436 8065 16 the the DT 40436 8065 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8065 18 , , , 40436 8065 19 and and CC 40436 8065 20 that that IN 40436 8065 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8065 22 sins sin VBZ 40436 8065 23 through through IN 40436 8065 24 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 8065 25 . . . 40436 8066 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8066 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8066 3 143 143 CD 40436 8066 4 : : : 40436 8066 5 The the DT 40436 8066 6 substantial substantial JJ 40436 8066 7 identity identity NN 40436 8066 8 of of IN 40436 8066 9 Good good JJ 40436 8066 10 with with IN 40436 8066 11 Pleasure Pleasure NNP 40436 8066 12 , , , 40436 8066 13 of of IN 40436 8066 14 Evil evil NN 40436 8066 15 with with IN 40436 8066 16 Pain Pain NNP 40436 8066 17 , , , 40436 8066 18 was be VBD 40436 8066 19 the the DT 40436 8066 20 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8066 21 of of IN 40436 8066 22 the the DT 40436 8066 23 historical historical JJ 40436 8066 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8066 25 as as IN 40436 8066 26 declared declare VBN 40436 8066 27 in in IN 40436 8066 28 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 8066 29 's 's POS 40436 8066 30 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 8066 31 . . . 40436 8067 1 See see VB 40436 8067 2 , , , 40436 8067 3 among among IN 40436 8067 4 other other JJ 40436 8067 5 passages passage NNS 40436 8067 6 , , , 40436 8067 7 i. i. NNP 40436 8068 1 6 6 CD 40436 8068 2 , , , 40436 8068 3 8 8 CD 40436 8068 4 . . . 40436 8069 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8069 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8069 3 : : : 40436 8069 4 Tou= Tou= NNP 40436 8069 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8069 6 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 8069 7 douleu douleu NNP 40436 8069 8 / / SYM 40436 8069 9 ein ein NNP 40436 8069 10 gastri\ gastri\ NNP 40436 8069 11 mêde\ mêde\ NNP 40436 8069 12 u(/pnô| u(/pnô| NNP 40436 8069 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8069 14 lagnei lagnei NNP 40436 8069 15 / / SYM 40436 8069 16 a| a| NN 40436 8069 17 , , , 40436 8069 18 oi)/ei oi)/ei CD 40436 8069 19 ti ti IN 40436 8069 20 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 8069 21 ai)tiô ai)tiô NNP 40436 8069 22 / / SYM 40436 8069 23 teron teron NNP 40436 8069 24 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8069 25 , , , 40436 8069 26 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 8069 27 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8069 28 e(/tera e(/tera NNP 40436 8069 29 e)/chein e)/chein NNP 40436 8069 30 tou tou NNP 40436 8069 31 / / SYM 40436 8069 32 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8069 33 ê(di ê(di NNP 40436 8069 34 / / SYM 40436 8069 35 ô ô NNP 40436 8069 36 , , , 40436 8069 37 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 8069 38 ou ou NNP 40436 8069 39 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8069 40 mo mo NNP 40436 8069 41 / / SYM 40436 8069 42 non non AFX 40436 8069 43 e)n e)n NNP 40436 8069 44 chrei chrei NN 40436 8069 45 / / SYM 40436 8069 46 a| a| NN 40436 8069 47 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 8069 48 eu)phrai eu)phrai NNP 40436 8069 49 / / SYM 40436 8069 50 nei nei NNP 40436 8069 51 , , , 40436 8069 52 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 8069 53 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8069 54 e)lpi e)lpi NNP 40436 8069 55 / / SYM 40436 8069 56 das das NNP 40436 8069 57 pare pare NNP 40436 8069 58 / / SYM 40436 8069 59 chonta chonta NNP 40436 8069 60 ô)phelê ô)phelê NNP 40436 8069 61 / / SYM 40436 8069 62 sein sein NNP 40436 8069 63 a)ei/ a)ei/ CD 40436 8069 64 ? ? . 40436 8070 1 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 8070 2 mê\n mê\n NNP 40436 8070 3 tou tou NNP 40436 8070 4 = = SYM 40436 8070 5 to/ to/ CD 40436 8070 6 ge ge NNP 40436 8070 7 oi)=stha oi)=stha NNP 40436 8070 8 , , , 40436 8070 9 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 8070 10 oi oi NNP 40436 8070 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8070 12 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8070 13 oi)o oi)o NNP 40436 8070 14 / / SYM 40436 8070 15 menoi menoi NNP 40436 8070 16 mêde\n mêde\n . 40436 8070 17 eu)= eu)= JJ 40436 8070 18 pra pra NNP 40436 8070 19 / / SYM 40436 8070 20 ttein ttein NNP 40436 8070 21 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 8070 22 eu)phrai eu)phrai NNP 40436 8070 23 / / SYM 40436 8070 24 nontai nontai NNP 40436 8070 25 , , , 40436 8070 26 oi oi NNP 40436 8070 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8070 28 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8070 29 ê(gou ê(gou NNP 40436 8070 30 / / SYM 40436 8070 31 menoi menoi NNP 40436 8070 32 kalô kalô NNP 40436 8070 33 = = SYM 40436 8070 34 s s NNP 40436 8070 35 prochôrei prochôrei NN 40436 8070 36 = = SYM 40436 8070 37 n n NNP 40436 8070 38 e(autoi e(autoi NNP 40436 8070 39 = = SYM 40436 8070 40 s s NNP 40436 8070 41 , , , 40436 8070 42 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 8070 43 geôrgi geôrgi NNP 40436 8070 44 / / SYM 40436 8070 45 an an DT 40436 8070 46 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 8070 47 nauklêri nauklêri NN 40436 8070 48 / / , 40436 8070 49 an an DT 40436 8070 50 ê)\ ê)\ NN 40436 8070 51 a)/ll a)/ll NNS 40436 8070 52 ' ' POS 40436 8070 53 o(/ o(/ NNS 40436 8070 54 , , , 40436 8070 55 ti ti IN 40436 8070 56 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 8070 57 tugcha tugcha NN 40436 8070 58 / / SYM 40436 8070 59 nôsin nôsin NNP 40436 8070 60 e)rgazo e)rgazo , 40436 8070 61 / / SYM 40436 8070 62 menoi menoi NNS 40436 8070 63 , , , 40436 8070 64 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 8070 65 eu)= eu)= NN 40436 8070 66 pra pra NNP 40436 8070 67 / / SYM 40436 8070 68 ttontes ttontes NNP 40436 8070 69 eu)phrai eu)phrai NNP 40436 8070 70 / / SYM 40436 8070 71 nontai nontai NNP 40436 8070 72 . . . 40436 8071 1 Oi)/ei Oi)/ei NNP 40436 8071 2 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 8071 3 a)po\ a)po\ NNP 40436 8071 4 pa pa NNP 40436 8071 5 / / SYM 40436 8071 6 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 8071 7 tou tou NNP 40436 8071 8 / / SYM 40436 8071 9 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8071 10 tosau tosau NNP 40436 8071 11 / / SYM 40436 8071 12 tên tên NNP 40436 8071 13 ê(donê\n ê(donê\n NNP 40436 8071 14 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8071 15 , , , 40436 8071 16 o(/sên o(/sên RB 40436 8071 17 a)po\ a)po\ NNP 40436 8071 18 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8071 19 e(auto e(auto NNP 40436 8071 20 / / SYM 40436 8071 21 n n NN 40436 8071 22 te te NNP 40436 8071 23 ê(gei ê(gei NNP 40436 8071 24 = = SYM 40436 8071 25 sthai sthai NNP 40436 8071 26 belti belti NNP 40436 8071 27 / / SYM 40436 8071 28 ô ô NNP 40436 8071 29 gi gi NNP 40436 8071 30 / / SYM 40436 8071 31 gnesthai gnesthai NNP 40436 8071 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8071 33 phi phi NNP 40436 8071 34 / / SYM 40436 8071 35 lous lous JJ 40436 8071 36 a)mei a)mei ADD 40436 8071 37 / / SYM 40436 8071 38 nous nous NNP 40436 8071 39 kta kta NNP 40436 8071 40 = = SYM 40436 8071 41 sthai sthai NNP 40436 8071 42 ? ? . 40436 8072 1 E)gô\ E)gô\ NNP 40436 8072 2 toi toi NNP 40436 8072 3 / / SYM 40436 8072 4 nun nun NNP 40436 8072 5 diatelô= diatelô= NNP 40436 8072 6 tau tau NNP 40436 8072 7 = = SYM 40436 8072 8 ta ta NNP 40436 8072 9 nomi nomi NNP 40436 8072 10 / / SYM 40436 8072 11 zôn zôn NNP 40436 8072 12 . . . 40436 8072 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8073 1 Locke Locke NNP 40436 8073 2 says say VBZ 40436 8073 3 , , , 40436 8073 4 ' ' '' 40436 8073 5 Essay Essay NNP 40436 8073 6 on on IN 40436 8073 7 Human Human NNP 40436 8073 8 Understanding Understanding NNP 40436 8073 9 , , , 40436 8073 10 ' ' '' 40436 8073 11 Book Book NNP 40436 8073 12 ii ii NNP 40436 8073 13 . . . 40436 8074 1 ch ch NNP 40436 8074 2 . . . 40436 8075 1 28 28 CD 40436 8075 2 , , , 40436 8075 3 " " `` 40436 8075 4 Good good JJ 40436 8075 5 or or CC 40436 8075 6 Evil Evil NNP 40436 8075 7 is be VBZ 40436 8075 8 nothing nothing NN 40436 8075 9 but but IN 40436 8075 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8075 11 or or CC 40436 8075 12 pain pain NN 40436 8075 13 to to IN 40436 8075 14 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8075 15 -- -- : 40436 8075 16 or or CC 40436 8075 17 that that IN 40436 8075 18 which which WDT 40436 8075 19 procures procure VBZ 40436 8075 20 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8075 21 or or CC 40436 8075 22 pain pain NN 40436 8075 23 to to IN 40436 8075 24 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8075 25 . . . 40436 8076 1 Moral moral JJ 40436 8076 2 good good JJ 40436 8076 3 or or CC 40436 8076 4 evil evil NN 40436 8076 5 then then RB 40436 8076 6 is be VBZ 40436 8076 7 only only RB 40436 8076 8 the the DT 40436 8076 9 conformity conformity NN 40436 8076 10 or or CC 40436 8076 11 disagreement disagreement NN 40436 8076 12 of of IN 40436 8076 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8076 14 voluntary voluntary JJ 40436 8076 15 actions action NNS 40436 8076 16 to to IN 40436 8076 17 some some DT 40436 8076 18 law law NN 40436 8076 19 , , , 40436 8076 20 whereby whereby WRB 40436 8076 21 good good JJ 40436 8076 22 or or CC 40436 8076 23 evil evil NN 40436 8076 24 is be VBZ 40436 8076 25 drawn draw VBN 40436 8076 26 on on IN 40436 8076 27 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8076 28 by by IN 40436 8076 29 the the DT 40436 8076 30 will will NN 40436 8076 31 and and CC 40436 8076 32 power power NN 40436 8076 33 of of IN 40436 8076 34 the the DT 40436 8076 35 law law NN 40436 8076 36 - - HYPH 40436 8076 37 maker maker NN 40436 8076 38 ; ; : 40436 8076 39 which which WDT 40436 8076 40 good good JJ 40436 8076 41 or or CC 40436 8076 42 evil evil JJ 40436 8076 43 , , , 40436 8076 44 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8076 45 or or CC 40436 8076 46 pain pain NN 40436 8076 47 , , , 40436 8076 48 attending attend VBG 40436 8076 49 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8076 50 observance observance NN 40436 8076 51 or or CC 40436 8076 52 breach breach NN 40436 8076 53 of of IN 40436 8076 54 the the DT 40436 8076 55 law law NN 40436 8076 56 , , , 40436 8076 57 is be VBZ 40436 8076 58 that that IN 40436 8076 59 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8076 60 call call VBP 40436 8076 61 reward reward NN 40436 8076 62 or or CC 40436 8076 63 punishment punishment NN 40436 8076 64 . . . 40436 8076 65 " " '' 40436 8077 1 The the DT 40436 8077 2 formal formal JJ 40436 8077 3 distinction distinction NN 40436 8077 4 here here RB 40436 8077 5 taken take VBN 40436 8077 6 by by IN 40436 8077 7 Locke Locke NNP 40436 8077 8 between between IN 40436 8077 9 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8077 10 and and CC 40436 8077 11 that that IN 40436 8077 12 which which WDT 40436 8077 13 procures procure VBZ 40436 8077 14 pleasure pleasure VBP 40436 8077 15 -- -- : 40436 8077 16 both both PDT 40436 8077 17 the the DT 40436 8077 18 one one NN 40436 8077 19 and and CC 40436 8077 20 the the DT 40436 8077 21 other other JJ 40436 8077 22 being being NN 40436 8077 23 called call VBN 40436 8077 24 Good--(the Good--(the NNP 40436 8077 25 like like UH 40436 8077 26 in in IN 40436 8077 27 regard regard NN 40436 8077 28 to to IN 40436 8077 29 pain pain NN 40436 8077 30 and and CC 40436 8077 31 evil evil NN 40436 8077 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8077 33 is be VBZ 40436 8077 34 not not RB 40436 8077 35 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 8077 36 stated state VBN 40436 8077 37 by by IN 40436 8077 38 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8077 39 in in IN 40436 8077 40 the the DT 40436 8077 41 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8077 42 , , , 40436 8077 43 though though IN 40436 8077 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8077 45 says say VBZ 40436 8077 46 nothing nothing NN 40436 8077 47 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 8077 48 with with IN 40436 8077 49 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8077 50 : : : 40436 8077 51 but but CC 40436 8077 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8077 53 is be VBZ 40436 8077 54 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 8077 55 stated state VBN 40436 8077 56 in in IN 40436 8077 57 the the DT 40436 8077 58 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8077 59 , , , 40436 8077 60 ii ii NNP 40436 8077 61 . . . 40436 8078 1 p. p. NN 40436 8078 2 357 357 CD 40436 8078 3 , , , 40436 8078 4 where where WRB 40436 8078 5 Good good JJ 40436 8078 6 is be VBZ 40436 8078 7 distributed distribute VBN 40436 8078 8 under under IN 40436 8078 9 three three CD 40436 8078 10 heads head NNS 40436 8078 11 . . . 40436 8079 1 1 1 LS 40436 8079 2 . . . 40436 8080 1 That that DT 40436 8080 2 which which WDT 40436 8080 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8080 4 desire desire VBP 40436 8080 5 immediately immediately RB 40436 8080 6 and and CC 40436 8080 7 for for IN 40436 8080 8 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8080 9 -- -- : 40436 8080 10 such such JJ 40436 8080 11 as as IN 40436 8080 12 Enjoyment Enjoyment NNP 40436 8080 13 , , , 40436 8080 14 Innocuous innocuous JJ 40436 8080 15 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8080 16 . . . 40436 8081 1 2 2 LS 40436 8081 2 . . . 40436 8082 1 That that DT 40436 8082 2 which which WDT 40436 8082 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8082 4 desire desire VBP 40436 8082 5 both both DT 40436 8082 6 for for IN 40436 8082 7 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8082 8 and and CC 40436 8082 9 for for IN 40436 8082 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8082 11 consequences consequence NNS 40436 8082 12 -- -- : 40436 8082 13 health health NN 40436 8082 14 , , , 40436 8082 15 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 8082 16 , , , 40436 8082 17 good good JJ 40436 8082 18 sight sight NN 40436 8082 19 or or CC 40436 8082 20 hearing hearing NN 40436 8082 21 , , , 40436 8082 22 & & CC 40436 8082 23 c. c. NNP 40436 8082 24 3 3 CD 40436 8082 25 . . . 40436 8083 1 That that DT 40436 8083 2 which which WDT 40436 8083 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8083 4 do do VBP 40436 8083 5 not not RB 40436 8083 6 desire desire VB 40436 8083 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8083 8 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 8083 9 even even RB 40436 8083 10 shun shun NN 40436 8083 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8083 12 for for IN 40436 8083 13 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8083 14 , , , 40436 8083 15 but but CC 40436 8083 16 which which WDT 40436 8083 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8083 18 accept accept VBP 40436 8083 19 by by IN 40436 8083 20 reason reason NN 40436 8083 21 of of IN 40436 8083 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8083 23 consequences consequence NNS 40436 8083 24 in in IN 40436 8083 25 averting avert VBG 40436 8083 26 greater great JJR 40436 8083 27 pains pain NNS 40436 8083 28 or or CC 40436 8083 29 procuring procure VBG 40436 8083 30 greater great JJR 40436 8083 31 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8083 32 . . . 40436 8084 1 This this DT 40436 8084 2 discrimination discrimination NN 40436 8084 3 of of IN 40436 8084 4 the the DT 40436 8084 5 varieties variety NNS 40436 8084 6 of of IN 40436 8084 7 Good Good NNP 40436 8084 8 , , , 40436 8084 9 given give VBN 40436 8084 10 in in IN 40436 8084 11 the the DT 40436 8084 12 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8084 13 , , , 40436 8084 14 is be VBZ 40436 8084 15 quite quite RB 40436 8084 16 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8084 17 with with IN 40436 8084 18 what what WP 40436 8084 19 is be VBZ 40436 8084 20 stated state VBN 40436 8084 21 by by IN 40436 8084 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8084 23 in in IN 40436 8084 24 the the DT 40436 8084 25 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8084 26 , , , 40436 8084 27 though though IN 40436 8084 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8084 29 is be VBZ 40436 8084 30 more more RBR 40436 8084 31 full full JJ 40436 8084 32 and and CC 40436 8084 33 precise precise JJ 40436 8084 34 . . . 40436 8085 1 But but CC 40436 8085 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8085 3 is be VBZ 40436 8085 4 not not RB 40436 8085 5 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8085 6 with with IN 40436 8085 7 what what WP 40436 8085 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8085 9 says say VBZ 40436 8085 10 in in IN 40436 8085 11 the the DT 40436 8085 12 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8085 13 , , , 40436 8085 14 where where WRB 40436 8085 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8085 16 asserts assert VBZ 40436 8085 17 a a DT 40436 8085 18 radical radical JJ 40436 8085 19 dissimilarity dissimilarity NN 40436 8085 20 of of IN 40436 8085 21 nature nature NN 40436 8085 22 between between IN 40436 8085 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8085 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8085 25 : : : 40436 8085 26 ê(du\ ê(du\ NN 40436 8085 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8085 28 and and CC 40436 8085 29 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8085 30 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8085 31 : : : 40436 8085 32 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 8085 33 / / SYM 40436 8085 34 n n NN 40436 8085 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8085 36 . . . 40436 8085 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8086 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8086 2 Side side NN 40436 8086 3 - - HYPH 40436 8086 4 note note NN 40436 8086 5 : : : 40436 8086 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8086 7 is be VBZ 40436 8086 8 at at IN 40436 8086 9 first first RB 40436 8086 10 opposed oppose VBN 40436 8086 11 to to IN 40436 8086 12 this this DT 40436 8086 13 theory theory NN 40436 8086 14 . . . 40436 8086 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8087 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8087 2 agrees agree VBZ 40436 8087 3 with with IN 40436 8087 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8087 5 in in IN 40436 8087 6 the the DT 40436 8087 7 encomiums encomium NNS 40436 8087 8 bestowed bestow VBN 40436 8087 9 on on IN 40436 8087 10 the the DT 40436 8087 11 paramount paramount JJ 40436 8087 12 importance importance NN 40436 8087 13 and and CC 40436 8087 14 ascendancy ascendancy NN 40436 8087 15 of of IN 40436 8087 16 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8087 17 : : : 40436 8087 18 but but CC 40436 8087 19 does do VBZ 40436 8087 20 not not RB 40436 8087 21 at at IN 40436 8087 22 first first RB 40436 8087 23 agree agree VB 40436 8087 24 with with IN 40436 8087 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8087 26 in in IN 40436 8087 27 identifying identify VBG 40436 8087 28 good good NN 40436 8087 29 with with IN 40436 8087 30 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8087 31 , , , 40436 8087 32 and and CC 40436 8087 33 evil evil NN 40436 8087 34 with with IN 40436 8087 35 pain pain NN 40436 8087 36 . . . 40436 8088 1 Upon upon IN 40436 8088 2 this this DT 40436 8088 3 point point NN 40436 8088 4 , , , 40436 8088 5 too too RB 40436 8088 6 , , , 40436 8088 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8088 8 is be VBZ 40436 8088 9 represented represent VBN 40436 8088 10 as as IN 40436 8088 11 agreeing agree VBG 40436 8088 12 in in IN 40436 8088 13 opinion opinion NN 40436 8088 14 with with IN 40436 8088 15 the the DT 40436 8088 16 Many many JJ 40436 8088 17 . . . 40436 8089 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8089 2 does do VBZ 40436 8089 3 not not RB 40436 8089 4 admit admit VB 40436 8089 5 that that IN 40436 8089 6 to to TO 40436 8089 7 live live VB 40436 8089 8 pleasurably pleasurably RB 40436 8089 9 is be VBZ 40436 8089 10 good good JJ 40436 8089 11 , , , 40436 8089 12 unless unless IN 40436 8089 13 where where WRB 40436 8089 14 a a DT 40436 8089 15 man man NN 40436 8089 16 takes take VBZ 40436 8089 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8089 18 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8089 19 in in IN 40436 8089 20 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8089 21 things thing NNS 40436 8089 22 . . . 40436 8090 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8090 2 thinks think VBZ 40436 8090 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8090 4 safer safe JJR 40436 8090 5 , , , 40436 8090 6 and and CC 40436 8090 7 more more RBR 40436 8090 8 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8090 9 with with IN 40436 8090 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8090 11 own own JJ 40436 8090 12 whole whole JJ 40436 8090 13 life life NN 40436 8090 14 , , , 40436 8090 15 to to TO 40436 8090 16 maintain maintain VB 40436 8090 17 -- -- : 40436 8090 18 That that IN 40436 8090 19 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 8090 20 things thing NNS 40436 8090 21 , , , 40436 8090 22 or or CC 40436 8090 23 painful painful JJ 40436 8090 24 things thing NNS 40436 8090 25 , , , 40436 8090 26 may may MD 40436 8090 27 be be VB 40436 8090 28 either either CC 40436 8090 29 good good JJ 40436 8090 30 , , , 40436 8090 31 or or CC 40436 8090 32 evil evil NN 40436 8090 33 , , , 40436 8090 34 or or CC 40436 8090 35 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 8090 36 , , , 40436 8090 37 according accord VBG 40436 8090 38 to to IN 40436 8090 39 the the DT 40436 8090 40 particular particular JJ 40436 8090 41 case case NN 40436 8090 42 . . . 40436 8091 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8091 2 Side side NN 40436 8091 3 - - HYPH 40436 8091 4 note note NN 40436 8091 5 : : : 40436 8091 6 Reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8091 7 of of IN 40436 8091 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8091 9 . . . 40436 8091 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8092 1 This this DT 40436 8092 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8092 3 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8092 4 takes take VBZ 40436 8092 5 much much JJ 40436 8092 6 pains pain NNS 40436 8092 7 to to TO 40436 8092 8 refute refute VB 40436 8092 9 . . . 40436 8093 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8093 2 contends contend VBZ 40436 8093 3 that that IN 40436 8093 4 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 8093 5 things thing NNS 40436 8093 6 , , , 40436 8093 7 so so RB 40436 8093 8 far far RB 40436 8093 9 forth forth RB 40436 8093 10 as as IN 40436 8093 11 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 8093 12 , , , 40436 8093 13 are be VBP 40436 8093 14 always always RB 40436 8093 15 good good JJ 40436 8093 16 -- -- : 40436 8093 17 and and CC 40436 8093 18 painful painful JJ 40436 8093 19 things thing NNS 40436 8093 20 , , , 40436 8093 21 so so RB 40436 8093 22 far far RB 40436 8093 23 forth forth RB 40436 8093 24 as as IN 40436 8093 25 painful painful JJ 40436 8093 26 , , , 40436 8093 27 always always RB 40436 8093 28 evil evil JJ 40436 8093 29 . . . 40436 8094 1 When when WRB 40436 8094 2 some some DT 40436 8094 3 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8094 4 are be VBP 40436 8094 5 called call VBN 40436 8094 6 evil evil NN 40436 8094 7 , , , 40436 8094 8 that that DT 40436 8094 9 is be VBZ 40436 8094 10 not not RB 40436 8094 11 on on IN 40436 8094 12 account account NN 40436 8094 13 of of IN 40436 8094 14 any any DT 40436 8094 15 thing thing NN 40436 8094 16 belonging belong VBG 40436 8094 17 to to IN 40436 8094 18 the the DT 40436 8094 19 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8094 20 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8094 21 , , , 40436 8094 22 but but CC 40436 8094 23 because because IN 40436 8094 24 of of IN 40436 8094 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8094 26 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 8094 27 consequences consequence NNS 40436 8094 28 and and CC 40436 8094 29 concomitants concomitant NNS 40436 8094 30 , , , 40436 8094 31 which which WDT 40436 8094 32 are be VBP 40436 8094 33 painful painful JJ 40436 8094 34 or or CC 40436 8094 35 distressing distress VBG 40436 8094 36 in in IN 40436 8094 37 a a DT 40436 8094 38 degree degree NN 40436 8094 39 more more JJR 40436 8094 40 than than IN 40436 8094 41 countervailing countervail VBG 40436 8094 42 the the DT 40436 8094 43 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8094 44 . . . 40436 8095 1 So so RB 40436 8095 2 too too RB 40436 8095 3 , , , 40436 8095 4 when when WRB 40436 8095 5 some some DT 40436 8095 6 pains pain NNS 40436 8095 7 are be VBP 40436 8095 8 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 8095 9 to to TO 40436 8095 10 be be VB 40436 8095 11 good good JJ 40436 8095 12 , , , 40436 8095 13 this this DT 40436 8095 14 is be VBZ 40436 8095 15 not not RB 40436 8095 16 from from IN 40436 8095 17 any any DT 40436 8095 18 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 8095 19 in in IN 40436 8095 20 the the DT 40436 8095 21 pain pain NN 40436 8095 22 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8095 23 , , , 40436 8095 24 but but CC 40436 8095 25 because because IN 40436 8095 26 of of IN 40436 8095 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8095 28 consequences consequence NNS 40436 8095 29 and and CC 40436 8095 30 concomitants concomitant NNS 40436 8095 31 : : : 40436 8095 32 such such JJ 40436 8095 33 pain pain NN 40436 8095 34 being be VBG 40436 8095 35 required require VBN 40436 8095 36 as as IN 40436 8095 37 a a DT 40436 8095 38 condition condition NN 40436 8095 39 to to IN 40436 8095 40 the the DT 40436 8095 41 attainment attainment NN 40436 8095 42 of of IN 40436 8095 43 health health NN 40436 8095 44 , , , 40436 8095 45 security security NN 40436 8095 46 , , , 40436 8095 47 wealth wealth NN 40436 8095 48 , , , 40436 8095 49 and and CC 40436 8095 50 other other JJ 40436 8095 51 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8095 52 or or CC 40436 8095 53 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 40436 8095 54 more more JJR 40436 8095 55 than than IN 40436 8095 56 counter counter NN 40436 8095 57 - - NN 40436 8095 58 balancing balancing NN 40436 8095 59 . . . 40436 8096 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8096 2 challenges challenge VBZ 40436 8096 3 opponents opponent NNS 40436 8096 4 to to TO 40436 8096 5 name name VB 40436 8096 6 any any DT 40436 8096 7 other other JJ 40436 8096 8 end end NN 40436 8096 9 , , , 40436 8096 10 with with IN 40436 8096 11 reference reference NN 40436 8096 12 to to IN 40436 8096 13 which which WDT 40436 8096 14 things thing NNS 40436 8096 15 are be VBP 40436 8096 16 called call VBN 40436 8096 17 _ _ NNP 40436 8096 18 good good JJ 40436 8096 19 _ _ NNP 40436 8096 20 , , , 40436 8096 21 except except IN 40436 8096 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8096 23 tendency tendency NN 40436 8096 24 to to TO 40436 8096 25 prevent prevent VB 40436 8096 26 or or CC 40436 8096 27 relieve relieve VB 40436 8096 28 pains pain NNS 40436 8096 29 and and CC 40436 8096 30 to to TO 40436 8096 31 ensure ensure VB 40436 8096 32 a a DT 40436 8096 33 balance balance NN 40436 8096 34 of of IN 40436 8096 35 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8096 36 : : : 40436 8096 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8096 38 challenges challenge VBZ 40436 8096 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8096 40 to to TO 40436 8096 41 name name VB 40436 8096 42 any any DT 40436 8096 43 other other JJ 40436 8096 44 end end NN 40436 8096 45 , , , 40436 8096 46 with with IN 40436 8096 47 reference reference NN 40436 8096 48 to to IN 40436 8096 49 which which WDT 40436 8096 50 things thing NNS 40436 8096 51 are be VBP 40436 8096 52 called call VBN 40436 8096 53 _ _ NNP 40436 8096 54 evil evil NN 40436 8096 55 _ _ NNP 40436 8096 56 , , , 40436 8096 57 except except IN 40436 8096 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8096 59 tendency tendency NN 40436 8096 60 to to TO 40436 8096 61 produce produce VB 40436 8096 62 pains pain NNS 40436 8096 63 and and CC 40436 8096 64 to to TO 40436 8096 65 intercept intercept VB 40436 8096 66 or or CC 40436 8096 67 destroy destroy VB 40436 8096 68 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8096 69 . . . 40436 8097 1 In in IN 40436 8097 2 measuring measure VBG 40436 8097 3 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8097 4 and and CC 40436 8097 5 pains pain NNS 40436 8097 6 against against IN 40436 8097 7 each each DT 40436 8097 8 other other JJ 40436 8097 9 , , , 40436 8097 10 there there EX 40436 8097 11 is be VBZ 40436 8097 12 no no DT 40436 8097 13 other other JJ 40436 8097 14 difference difference NN 40436 8097 15 to to TO 40436 8097 16 be be VB 40436 8097 17 reckoned reckon VBN 40436 8097 18 except except IN 40436 8097 19 that that DT 40436 8097 20 of of IN 40436 8097 21 greater great JJR 40436 8097 22 or or CC 40436 8097 23 less less JJR 40436 8097 24 , , , 40436 8097 25 more more RBR 40436 8097 26 or or CC 40436 8097 27 fewer few JJR 40436 8097 28 . . . 40436 8098 1 The the DT 40436 8098 2 difference difference NN 40436 8098 3 between between IN 40436 8098 4 near near JJ 40436 8098 5 and and CC 40436 8098 6 distant distant JJ 40436 8098 7 , , , 40436 8098 8 does do VBZ 40436 8098 9 indeed indeed RB 40436 8098 10 obtrude obtrude VB 40436 8098 11 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8098 12 upon upon IN 40436 8098 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8098 14 as as IN 40436 8098 15 a a DT 40436 8098 16 misleading misleading JJ 40436 8098 17 element element NN 40436 8098 18 . . . 40436 8099 1 But but CC 40436 8099 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8099 3 is be VBZ 40436 8099 4 the the DT 40436 8099 5 special special JJ 40436 8099 6 task task NN 40436 8099 7 of of IN 40436 8099 8 the the DT 40436 8099 9 " " `` 40436 8099 10 measuring measure VBG 40436 8099 11 science science NN 40436 8099 12 " " '' 40436 8099 13 to to TO 40436 8099 14 correct correct VB 40436 8099 15 this this DT 40436 8099 16 illusion illusion NN 40436 8099 17 -- -- : 40436 8099 18 and and CC 40436 8099 19 to to TO 40436 8099 20 compare compare VB 40436 8099 21 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8099 22 or or CC 40436 8099 23 pains pain NNS 40436 8099 24 , , , 40436 8099 25 whether whether IN 40436 8099 26 near near JJ 40436 8099 27 or or CC 40436 8099 28 distant distant JJ 40436 8099 29 , , , 40436 8099 30 according accord VBG 40436 8099 31 to to IN 40436 8099 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8099 33 real real JJ 40436 8099 34 worth worth NN 40436 8099 35 : : : 40436 8099 36 just just RB 40436 8099 37 as as IN 40436 8099 38 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8099 39 learn learn VBP 40436 8099 40 to to TO 40436 8099 41 rectify rectify VB 40436 8099 42 the the DT 40436 8099 43 illusions illusion NNS 40436 8099 44 of of IN 40436 8099 45 the the DT 40436 8099 46 sight sight NN 40436 8099 47 in in IN 40436 8099 48 regard regard NN 40436 8099 49 to to IN 40436 8099 50 near near JJ 40436 8099 51 and and CC 40436 8099 52 distant distant JJ 40436 8099 53 objects object NNS 40436 8099 54 . . . 40436 8100 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8100 2 Side side NN 40436 8100 3 - - HYPH 40436 8100 4 note note NN 40436 8100 5 : : : 40436 8100 6 Application application NN 40436 8100 7 of of IN 40436 8100 8 that that DT 40436 8100 9 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8100 10 to to IN 40436 8100 11 the the DT 40436 8100 12 case case NN 40436 8100 13 of of IN 40436 8100 14 courage courage NN 40436 8100 15 . . . 40436 8100 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8101 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8101 2 proceeds proceed NNS 40436 8101 3 to to TO 40436 8101 4 apply apply VB 40436 8101 5 this this DT 40436 8101 6 general general JJ 40436 8101 7 principle principle NN 40436 8101 8 in in IN 40436 8101 9 correcting correct VBG 40436 8101 10 the the DT 40436 8101 11 explanation explanation NN 40436 8101 12 of of IN 40436 8101 13 courage courage NN 40436 8101 14 given give VBN 40436 8101 15 by by IN 40436 8101 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8101 17 . . . 40436 8102 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8102 2 shows show VBZ 40436 8102 3 , , , 40436 8102 4 or or CC 40436 8102 5 tries try VBZ 40436 8102 6 to to TO 40436 8102 7 show show VB 40436 8102 8 , , , 40436 8102 9 that that DT 40436 8102 10 courage courage NN 40436 8102 11 , , , 40436 8102 12 like like IN 40436 8102 13 all all PDT 40436 8102 14 the the DT 40436 8102 15 other other JJ 40436 8102 16 branches branch NNS 40436 8102 17 of of IN 40436 8102 18 virtue virtue NN 40436 8102 19 , , , 40436 8102 20 consists consist VBZ 40436 8102 21 in in IN 40436 8102 22 acting act VBG 40436 8102 23 on on IN 40436 8102 24 a a DT 40436 8102 25 just just JJ 40436 8102 26 estimate estimate NN 40436 8102 27 of of IN 40436 8102 28 comparative comparative JJ 40436 8102 29 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8102 30 and and CC 40436 8102 31 pains pain NNS 40436 8102 32 . . . 40436 8103 1 No no DT 40436 8103 2 man man NN 40436 8103 3 affronts affront VBZ 40436 8103 4 evil evil JJ 40436 8103 5 , , , 40436 8103 6 or or CC 40436 8103 7 the the DT 40436 8103 8 alternative alternative NN 40436 8103 9 of of IN 40436 8103 10 greater great JJR 40436 8103 11 pain pain NN 40436 8103 12 , , , 40436 8103 13 knowing know VBG 40436 8103 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8103 15 to to TO 40436 8103 16 be be VB 40436 8103 17 such such JJ 40436 8103 18 : : : 40436 8103 19 no no DT 40436 8103 20 man man NN 40436 8103 21 therefore therefore RB 40436 8103 22 adventures adventure VBZ 40436 8103 23 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8103 24 in in IN 40436 8103 25 any any DT 40436 8103 26 terrible terrible JJ 40436 8103 27 enterprise enterprise NN 40436 8103 28 , , , 40436 8103 29 knowing know VBG 40436 8103 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8103 31 to to TO 40436 8103 32 be be VB 40436 8103 33 so so RB 40436 8103 34 : : : 40436 8103 35 neither neither CC 40436 8103 36 the the DT 40436 8103 37 brave brave JJ 40436 8103 38 nor nor CC 40436 8103 39 the the DT 40436 8103 40 timid timid NN 40436 8103 41 do do VB 40436 8103 42 this this DT 40436 8103 43 . . . 40436 8104 1 Both both DT 40436 8104 2 the the DT 40436 8104 3 brave brave NN 40436 8104 4 and and CC 40436 8104 5 the the DT 40436 8104 6 timid timid JJ 40436 8104 7 affront affront NN 40436 8104 8 that that IN 40436 8104 9 which which WDT 40436 8104 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8104 11 think think VBP 40436 8104 12 not not RB 40436 8104 13 terrible terrible JJ 40436 8104 14 , , , 40436 8104 15 or or CC 40436 8104 16 the the DT 40436 8104 17 least least JJS 40436 8104 18 terrible terrible JJ 40436 8104 19 of of IN 40436 8104 20 two two CD 40436 8104 21 alternatives alternative NNS 40436 8104 22 : : : 40436 8104 23 but but CC 40436 8104 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8104 25 estimate estimate VBP 40436 8104 26 differently differently RB 40436 8104 27 what what WP 40436 8104 28 is be VBZ 40436 8104 29 such such JJ 40436 8104 30 . . . 40436 8105 1 The the DT 40436 8105 2 former former JJ 40436 8105 3 go go NN 40436 8105 4 readily readily RB 40436 8105 5 to to IN 40436 8105 6 war war NN 40436 8105 7 when when WRB 40436 8105 8 required require VBN 40436 8105 9 , , , 40436 8105 10 the the DT 40436 8105 11 latter latter JJ 40436 8105 12 evade evade NN 40436 8105 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8105 14 . . . 40436 8106 1 Now now RB 40436 8106 2 to to TO 40436 8106 3 go go VB 40436 8106 4 into into IN 40436 8106 5 war war NN 40436 8106 6 when when WRB 40436 8106 7 required require VBN 40436 8106 8 , , , 40436 8106 9 is be VBZ 40436 8106 10 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8106 11 : : : 40436 8106 12 being be VBG 40436 8106 13 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8106 14 , , , 40436 8106 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8106 16 is be VBZ 40436 8106 17 good good JJ 40436 8106 18 : : : 40436 8106 19 being be VBG 40436 8106 20 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8106 21 and and CC 40436 8106 22 good good JJ 40436 8106 23 , , , 40436 8106 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8106 25 is be VBZ 40436 8106 26 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 8106 27 . . . 40436 8107 1 The the DT 40436 8107 2 brave brave JJ 40436 8107 3 know know VBP 40436 8107 4 this this DT 40436 8107 5 , , , 40436 8107 6 and and CC 40436 8107 7 enter enter VB 40436 8107 8 upon upon IN 40436 8107 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8107 10 willingly willingly RB 40436 8107 11 : : : 40436 8107 12 the the DT 40436 8107 13 timid timid NN 40436 8107 14 not not RB 40436 8107 15 only only RB 40436 8107 16 do do VBP 40436 8107 17 not not RB 40436 8107 18 know know VB 40436 8107 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8107 20 , , , 40436 8107 21 but but CC 40436 8107 22 entertain entertain VB 40436 8107 23 the the DT 40436 8107 24 contrary contrary JJ 40436 8107 25 opinion opinion NN 40436 8107 26 , , , 40436 8107 27 looking look VBG 40436 8107 28 upon upon IN 40436 8107 29 war war NN 40436 8107 30 as as IN 40436 8107 31 painful painful JJ 40436 8107 32 and and CC 40436 8107 33 terrible terrible JJ 40436 8107 34 , , , 40436 8107 35 and and CC 40436 8107 36 therefore therefore RB 40436 8107 37 keeping keep VBG 40436 8107 38 aloof aloof NN 40436 8107 39 . . . 40436 8108 1 The the DT 40436 8108 2 brave brave JJ 40436 8108 3 men man NNS 40436 8108 4 fear fear VBP 40436 8108 5 what what WP 40436 8108 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8108 7 is be VBZ 40436 8108 8 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8108 9 to to TO 40436 8108 10 fear fear VB 40436 8108 11 , , , 40436 8108 12 the the DT 40436 8108 13 cowards coward NNS 40436 8108 14 what what WP 40436 8108 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8108 16 is be VBZ 40436 8108 17 dishonourable dishonourable JJ 40436 8108 18 to to TO 40436 8108 19 fear fear VB 40436 8108 20 : : : 40436 8108 21 the the DT 40436 8108 22 former former JJ 40436 8108 23 act act NN 40436 8108 24 upon upon IN 40436 8108 25 the the DT 40436 8108 26 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8108 27 of of IN 40436 8108 28 what what WP 40436 8108 29 is be VBZ 40436 8108 30 really really RB 40436 8108 31 terrible terrible JJ 40436 8108 32 , , , 40436 8108 33 the the DT 40436 8108 34 latter latter JJ 40436 8108 35 are be VBP 40436 8108 36 misled mislead VBN 40436 8108 37 by by IN 40436 8108 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8108 39 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 8108 40 of of IN 40436 8108 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8108 42 . . . 40436 8109 1 Courage courage NN 40436 8109 2 is be VBZ 40436 8109 3 thus thus RB 40436 8109 4 , , , 40436 8109 5 like like IN 40436 8109 6 the the DT 40436 8109 7 other other JJ 40436 8109 8 virtues virtue NNS 40436 8109 9 , , , 40436 8109 10 a a DT 40436 8109 11 case case NN 40436 8109 12 of of IN 40436 8109 13 accurate accurate JJ 40436 8109 14 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8109 15 of of IN 40436 8109 16 comparative comparative JJ 40436 8109 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8109 18 and and CC 40436 8109 19 pains pain NNS 40436 8109 20 , , , 40436 8109 21 or or CC 40436 8109 22 of of IN 40436 8109 23 good good NN 40436 8109 24 and and CC 40436 8109 25 evil evil NN 40436 8109 26 . . . 40436 8110 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8110 2 144 144 CD 40436 8110 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8110 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8110 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8110 6 144 144 CD 40436 8110 7 : : : 40436 8110 8 Compare compare VB 40436 8110 9 , , , 40436 8110 10 respecting respect VBG 40436 8110 11 Courage Courage NNP 40436 8110 12 , , , 40436 8110 13 a a DT 40436 8110 14 passage passage NN 40436 8110 15 in in IN 40436 8110 16 the the DT 40436 8110 17 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8110 18 , , , 40436 8110 19 iv iv NNP 40436 8110 20 . . . 40436 8111 1 pp pp NNP 40436 8111 2 . . . 40436 8112 1 429 429 CD 40436 8112 2 C C NNP 40436 8112 3 , , , 40436 8112 4 430 430 CD 40436 8112 5 B B NNP 40436 8112 6 , , , 40436 8112 7 which which WDT 40436 8112 8 is be VBZ 40436 8112 9 better well RBR 40436 8112 10 stated state VBN 40436 8112 11 there there RB 40436 8112 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8112 13 though though IN 40436 8112 14 substantially substantially RB 40436 8112 15 the the DT 40436 8112 16 same same JJ 40436 8112 17 opinion opinion NN 40436 8112 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8112 19 than than IN 40436 8112 20 here here RB 40436 8112 21 in in IN 40436 8112 22 the the DT 40436 8112 23 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8112 24 . . . 40436 8113 1 The the DT 40436 8113 2 opinion opinion NN 40436 8113 3 of of IN 40436 8113 4 the the DT 40436 8113 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8113 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8113 7 may may MD 40436 8113 8 be be VB 40436 8113 9 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 8113 10 by by IN 40436 8113 11 a a DT 40436 8113 12 sentence sentence NN 40436 8113 13 from from IN 40436 8113 14 the the DT 40436 8113 15 funeral funeral JJ 40436 8113 16 oration oration NN 40436 8113 17 delivered deliver VBN 40436 8113 18 by by IN 40436 8113 19 Periklês Periklês NNP 40436 8113 20 , , , 40436 8113 21 Thucyd Thucyd NNP 40436 8113 22 . . . 40436 8114 1 ii ii LS 40436 8114 2 . . . 40436 8115 1 43 43 CD 40436 8115 2 , , , 40436 8115 3 fin fin NNP 40436 8115 4 . . . 40436 8116 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8116 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8116 3 : : : 40436 8116 4 A)lgeinote A)lgeinote NNP 40436 8116 5 / / SYM 40436 8116 6 ra ra NNP 40436 8116 7 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8116 8 a)ndri/ a)ndri/ NNP 40436 8116 9 ge ge NNP 40436 8116 10 phro phro NNP 40436 8116 11 / / SYM 40436 8116 12 nêma nêma JJ 40436 8116 13 e)/chonti e)/chonti NNP 40436 8116 14 ê ê NNP 40436 8116 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8116 16 e)n e)n NNP 40436 8116 17 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 8116 18 meta\ meta\ NNP 40436 8116 19 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8116 20 malakisthê malakisthê NN 40436 8116 21 = = SYM 40436 8116 22 nai nai NNP 40436 8116 23 ka ka NNP 40436 8116 24 / / SYM 40436 8116 25 kôsis kôsis NNP 40436 8116 26 , , , 40436 8116 27 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 8116 28 o o NN 40436 8116 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8116 30 meta\ meta\ NNP 40436 8116 31 r(ô r(ô NNP 40436 8116 32 / / SYM 40436 8116 33 mês mês NNP 40436 8116 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8116 35 koinê koinê NNP 40436 8116 36 = = SYM 40436 8116 37 s s NNP 40436 8116 38 e)lpi e)lpi NNP 40436 8116 39 / / SYM 40436 8116 40 dos dos NNP 40436 8116 41 a(/ma a(/ma NNP 40436 8116 42 gigno gigno NNP 40436 8116 43 / / SYM 40436 8116 44 menos menos NNP 40436 8116 45 a)nai a)nai NNP 40436 8116 46 / / SYM 40436 8116 47 sthêtos sthêtos NN 40436 8116 48 tha tha NN 40436 8116 49 / / SYM 40436 8116 50 natos]--which natos]--which NNP 40436 8116 51 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 8116 52 Arnold Arnold NNP 40436 8116 53 thus thus RB 40436 8116 54 translates translate VBZ 40436 8116 55 in in IN 40436 8116 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8116 57 note note NN 40436 8116 58 : : : 40436 8116 59 " " `` 40436 8116 60 For for IN 40436 8116 61 more more RBR 40436 8116 62 grievous grievous JJ 40436 8116 63 to to IN 40436 8116 64 a a DT 40436 8116 65 man man NN 40436 8116 66 of of IN 40436 8116 67 noble noble JJ 40436 8116 68 mind mind NN 40436 8116 69 is be VBZ 40436 8116 70 the the DT 40436 8116 71 misery misery NN 40436 8116 72 which which WDT 40436 8116 73 comes come VBZ 40436 8116 74 together together RB 40436 8116 75 with with IN 40436 8116 76 cowardice cowardice NN 40436 8116 77 , , , 40436 8116 78 than than IN 40436 8116 79 the the DT 40436 8116 80 unfelt unfelt JJ 40436 8116 81 death death NN 40436 8116 82 which which WDT 40436 8116 83 befalls befall VBZ 40436 8116 84 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8116 85 in in IN 40436 8116 86 the the DT 40436 8116 87 midst midst NN 40436 8116 88 of of IN 40436 8116 89 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8116 90 strength strength NN 40436 8116 91 and and CC 40436 8116 92 hopes hope NNS 40436 8116 93 for for IN 40436 8116 94 the the DT 40436 8116 95 common common JJ 40436 8116 96 welfare welfare NN 40436 8116 97 . . . 40436 8116 98 " " '' 40436 8117 1 So so RB 40436 8117 2 again again RB 40436 8117 3 in in IN 40436 8117 4 the the DT 40436 8117 5 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 8117 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8117 7 p. p. NN 40436 8117 8 68 68 CD 40436 8117 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8117 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8117 11 describes describe VBZ 40436 8117 12 the the DT 40436 8117 13 courage courage NN 40436 8117 14 of of IN 40436 8117 15 the the DT 40436 8117 16 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 8117 17 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 40436 8117 18 citizen citizen NN 40436 8117 19 to to TO 40436 8117 20 consist consist VB 40436 8117 21 in in IN 40436 8117 22 braving brave VBG 40436 8117 23 death death NN 40436 8117 24 from from IN 40436 8117 25 fear fear NN 40436 8117 26 of of IN 40436 8117 27 greater great JJR 40436 8117 28 evils evil NNS 40436 8117 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8117 30 which which WDT 40436 8117 31 is be VBZ 40436 8117 32 the the DT 40436 8117 33 same same JJ 40436 8117 34 view view NN 40436 8117 35 as as IN 40436 8117 36 that that DT 40436 8117 37 of of IN 40436 8117 38 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8117 39 in in IN 40436 8117 40 the the DT 40436 8117 41 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8117 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8117 43 , , , 40436 8117 44 while while IN 40436 8117 45 the the DT 40436 8117 46 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 8117 47 is be VBZ 40436 8117 48 courageous courageous JJ 40436 8117 49 on on IN 40436 8117 50 a a DT 40436 8117 51 different different JJ 40436 8117 52 principle principle NN 40436 8117 53 ; ; : 40436 8117 54 aspiring aspire VBG 40436 8117 55 only only RB 40436 8117 56 to to IN 40436 8117 57 reason reason NN 40436 8117 58 and and CC 40436 8117 59 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 8117 60 , , , 40436 8117 61 with with IN 40436 8117 62 the the DT 40436 8117 63 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8117 64 attending attend VBG 40436 8117 65 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8117 66 , , , 40436 8117 67 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8117 68 welcomes welcome VBZ 40436 8117 69 death death NN 40436 8117 70 as as IN 40436 8117 71 releasing release VBG 40436 8117 72 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8117 73 mind mind NN 40436 8117 74 from from IN 40436 8117 75 the the DT 40436 8117 76 obstructive obstructive JJ 40436 8117 77 companionship companionship NN 40436 8117 78 of of IN 40436 8117 79 the the DT 40436 8117 80 body body NN 40436 8117 81 . . . 40436 8118 1 The the DT 40436 8118 2 fear fear NN 40436 8118 3 of of IN 40436 8118 4 disgrace disgrace NN 40436 8118 5 and and CC 40436 8118 6 dishonour dishonour NN 40436 8118 7 , , , 40436 8118 8 in in IN 40436 8118 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8118 10 own own JJ 40436 8118 11 eyes eye NNS 40436 8118 12 and and CC 40436 8118 13 in in IN 40436 8118 14 those those DT 40436 8118 15 of of IN 40436 8118 16 others other NNS 40436 8118 17 , , , 40436 8118 18 is be VBZ 40436 8118 19 more more RBR 40436 8118 20 intolerable intolerable JJ 40436 8118 21 to to IN 40436 8118 22 the the DT 40436 8118 23 brave brave JJ 40436 8118 24 man man NN 40436 8118 25 than than IN 40436 8118 26 the the DT 40436 8118 27 fear fear NN 40436 8118 28 of of IN 40436 8118 29 wounds wound NNS 40436 8118 30 and and CC 40436 8118 31 death death NN 40436 8118 32 in in IN 40436 8118 33 the the DT 40436 8118 34 service service NN 40436 8118 35 of of IN 40436 8118 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8118 37 country country NN 40436 8118 38 . . . 40436 8119 1 See see VB 40436 8119 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8119 3 , , , 40436 8119 4 Leg Leg NNP 40436 8119 5 . . . 40436 8120 1 i. i. NNP 40436 8120 2 pp pp NNP 40436 8120 3 . . . 40436 8121 1 646 646 CD 40436 8121 2 - - SYM 40436 8121 3 647 647 CD 40436 8121 4 . . . 40436 8122 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8122 2 is be VBZ 40436 8122 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8122 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8122 5 : : : 40436 8122 6 phobero\s phobero\s NNP 40436 8122 7 meta\ meta\ NFP 40436 8122 8 no no DT 40436 8122 9 / / SYM 40436 8122 10 mou mou NN 40436 8122 11 , , , 40436 8122 12 meta\ meta\ . 40436 8122 13 di di NNP 40436 8122 14 / / SYM 40436 8122 15 kês kês NNP 40436 8122 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8122 17 , , , 40436 8122 18 p. p. NN 40436 8122 19 647 647 CD 40436 8122 20 E. E. NNP 40436 8122 21 Such Such NNP 40436 8122 22 is be VBZ 40436 8122 23 the the DT 40436 8122 24 way way NN 40436 8122 25 in in IN 40436 8122 26 which which WDT 40436 8122 27 both both DT 40436 8122 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8122 29 and and CC 40436 8122 30 Thucydides thucydide NNS 40436 8122 31 conceive conceive VBP 40436 8122 32 the the DT 40436 8122 33 character character NN 40436 8122 34 of of IN 40436 8122 35 the the DT 40436 8122 36 brave brave JJ 40436 8122 37 citizen citizen NN 40436 8122 38 as as IN 40436 8122 39 compared compare VBN 40436 8122 40 with with IN 40436 8122 41 the the DT 40436 8122 42 coward coward NN 40436 8122 43 . . . 40436 8123 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8123 2 is be VBZ 40436 8123 3 plain plain JJ 40436 8123 4 that that IN 40436 8123 5 this this DT 40436 8123 6 resolves resolve VBZ 40436 8123 7 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8123 8 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 8123 9 into into IN 40436 8123 10 a a DT 40436 8123 11 different different JJ 40436 8123 12 estimate estimate NN 40436 8123 13 of of IN 40436 8123 14 prospective prospective JJ 40436 8123 15 pains pain NNS 40436 8123 16 ; ; : 40436 8123 17 the the DT 40436 8123 18 case case NN 40436 8123 19 being be VBG 40436 8123 20 one one CD 40436 8123 21 in in IN 40436 8123 22 which which WDT 40436 8123 23 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8123 24 is be VBZ 40436 8123 25 not not RB 40436 8123 26 concerned concern VBN 40436 8123 27 . . . 40436 8124 1 That that IN 40436 8124 2 the the DT 40436 8124 3 pains pain NNS 40436 8124 4 of of IN 40436 8124 5 self self NN 40436 8124 6 - - HYPH 40436 8124 7 reproach reproach NN 40436 8124 8 and and CC 40436 8124 9 infamy infamy NN 40436 8124 10 in in IN 40436 8124 11 the the DT 40436 8124 12 eyes eye NNS 40436 8124 13 of of IN 40436 8124 14 others other NNS 40436 8124 15 are be VBP 40436 8124 16 among among IN 40436 8124 17 the the DT 40436 8124 18 most most RBS 40436 8124 19 agonising agonising JJ 40436 8124 20 in in IN 40436 8124 21 the the DT 40436 8124 22 human human JJ 40436 8124 23 bosom bosom NN 40436 8124 24 , , , 40436 8124 25 need nee MD 40436 8124 26 hardly hardly RB 40436 8124 27 be be VB 40436 8124 28 remarked remark VBN 40436 8124 29 . . . 40436 8125 1 At at IN 40436 8125 2 the the DT 40436 8125 3 same same JJ 40436 8125 4 time time NN 40436 8125 5 the the DT 40436 8125 6 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8125 7 here here RB 40436 8125 8 conceived conceive VBD 40436 8125 9 embrace embrace NN 40436 8125 10 a a DT 40436 8125 11 wide wide JJ 40436 8125 12 field field NN 40436 8125 13 of of IN 40436 8125 14 sympathy sympathy NN 40436 8125 15 , , , 40436 8125 16 comprising comprise VBG 40436 8125 17 the the DT 40436 8125 18 interests interest NNS 40436 8125 19 , , , 40436 8125 20 honour honour NN 40436 8125 21 , , , 40436 8125 22 and and CC 40436 8125 23 security security NN 40436 8125 24 , , , 40436 8125 25 of of IN 40436 8125 26 others other NNS 40436 8125 27 as as RB 40436 8125 28 well well RB 40436 8125 29 as as IN 40436 8125 30 of of IN 40436 8125 31 the the DT 40436 8125 32 individual individual JJ 40436 8125 33 agent agent NN 40436 8125 34 . . . 40436 8125 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8126 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8126 2 Side side NN 40436 8126 3 - - HYPH 40436 8126 4 note note NN 40436 8126 5 : : : 40436 8126 6 The the DT 40436 8126 7 theory theory NN 40436 8126 8 which which WDT 40436 8126 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8126 10 here here RB 40436 8126 11 lays lay VBZ 40436 8126 12 down down RB 40436 8126 13 is be VBZ 40436 8126 14 more more RBR 40436 8126 15 distinct distinct JJ 40436 8126 16 and and CC 40436 8126 17 specific specific JJ 40436 8126 18 than than IN 40436 8126 19 any any DT 40436 8126 20 theory theory NN 40436 8126 21 laid lay VBN 40436 8126 22 down down RP 40436 8126 23 in in IN 40436 8126 24 other other JJ 40436 8126 25 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8126 26 . . . 40436 8126 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8127 1 Such such JJ 40436 8127 2 is be VBZ 40436 8127 3 the the DT 40436 8127 4 ethical ethical JJ 40436 8127 5 theory theory NN 40436 8127 6 which which WDT 40436 8127 7 the the DT 40436 8127 8 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8127 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8127 10 enunciates enunciate VBZ 40436 8127 11 in in IN 40436 8127 12 this this DT 40436 8127 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8127 14 , , , 40436 8127 15 and and CC 40436 8127 16 which which WDT 40436 8127 17 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8127 18 and and CC 40436 8127 19 others other NNS 40436 8127 20 accept accept VBP 40436 8127 21 . . . 40436 8128 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8128 2 is be VBZ 40436 8128 3 positive positive JJ 40436 8128 4 and and CC 40436 8128 5 distinct distinct JJ 40436 8128 6 , , , 40436 8128 7 to to IN 40436 8128 8 a a DT 40436 8128 9 degree degree NN 40436 8128 10 very very RB 40436 8128 11 unusual unusual JJ 40436 8128 12 with with IN 40436 8128 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8128 14 . . . 40436 8129 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8129 2 shall shall MD 40436 8129 3 find find VB 40436 8129 4 that that IN 40436 8129 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8129 6 theorises theorise VBZ 40436 8129 7 differently differently RB 40436 8129 8 in in IN 40436 8129 9 other other JJ 40436 8129 10 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8129 11 ; ; : 40436 8129 12 whether whether IN 40436 8129 13 for for IN 40436 8129 14 the the DT 40436 8129 15 better well JJR 40436 8129 16 or or CC 40436 8129 17 the the DT 40436 8129 18 worse bad JJR 40436 8129 19 , , , 40436 8129 20 will will MD 40436 8129 21 be be VB 40436 8129 22 hereafter hereafter RB 40436 8129 23 seen see VBN 40436 8129 24 . . . 40436 8130 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8130 2 declares declare VBZ 40436 8130 3 here here RB 40436 8130 4 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 8130 5 that that IN 40436 8130 6 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8130 7 , , , 40436 8130 8 or or CC 40436 8130 9 happiness happiness NN 40436 8130 10 , , , 40436 8130 11 is be VBZ 40436 8130 12 the the DT 40436 8130 13 end end NN 40436 8130 14 to to TO 40436 8130 15 be be VB 40436 8130 16 pursued pursue VBN 40436 8130 17 ; ; : 40436 8130 18 and and CC 40436 8130 19 pain pain NN 40436 8130 20 , , , 40436 8130 21 or or CC 40436 8130 22 misery misery NN 40436 8130 23 , , , 40436 8130 24 the the DT 40436 8130 25 end end NN 40436 8130 26 to to TO 40436 8130 27 be be VB 40436 8130 28 avoided avoid VBN 40436 8130 29 : : : 40436 8130 30 and and CC 40436 8130 31 that that IN 40436 8130 32 there there EX 40436 8130 33 is be VBZ 40436 8130 34 no no DT 40436 8130 35 other other JJ 40436 8130 36 end end NN 40436 8130 37 , , , 40436 8130 38 in in IN 40436 8130 39 reference reference NN 40436 8130 40 to to IN 40436 8130 41 which which WDT 40436 8130 42 things thing NNS 40436 8130 43 can can MD 40436 8130 44 be be VB 40436 8130 45 called call VBN 40436 8130 46 good good JJ 40436 8130 47 or or CC 40436 8130 48 evil evil JJ 40436 8130 49 , , , 40436 8130 50 except except IN 40436 8130 51 as as IN 40436 8130 52 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8130 53 tend tend VBP 40436 8130 54 to to TO 40436 8130 55 promote promote VB 40436 8130 56 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8130 57 or or CC 40436 8130 58 mitigate mitigate VB 40436 8130 59 suffering suffering NN 40436 8130 60 , , , 40436 8130 61 on on IN 40436 8130 62 the the DT 40436 8130 63 one one CD 40436 8130 64 side side NN 40436 8130 65 -- -- : 40436 8130 66 to to TO 40436 8130 67 entail entail VB 40436 8130 68 pain pain NN 40436 8130 69 or or CC 40436 8130 70 suffering suffering NN 40436 8130 71 on on IN 40436 8130 72 the the DT 40436 8130 73 other other JJ 40436 8130 74 . . . 40436 8131 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8131 2 challenges challenge VBZ 40436 8131 3 objectors objector NNS 40436 8131 4 to to TO 40436 8131 5 assign assign VB 40436 8131 6 any any DT 40436 8131 7 other other JJ 40436 8131 8 end end NN 40436 8131 9 . . . 40436 8132 1 And and CC 40436 8132 2 thus thus RB 40436 8132 3 much much JJ 40436 8132 4 is be VBZ 40436 8132 5 certain certain JJ 40436 8132 6 -- -- : 40436 8132 7 that that IN 40436 8132 8 in in IN 40436 8132 9 those those DT 40436 8132 10 other other JJ 40436 8132 11 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8132 12 where where WRB 40436 8132 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8132 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8132 15 departs depart VBZ 40436 8132 16 from from IN 40436 8132 17 the the DT 40436 8132 18 present present JJ 40436 8132 19 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8132 20 , , , 40436 8132 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8132 22 has have VBZ 40436 8132 23 not not RB 40436 8132 24 complied comply VBN 40436 8132 25 with with IN 40436 8132 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8132 27 own own JJ 40436 8132 28 challenge challenge NN 40436 8132 29 . . . 40436 8133 1 Nowhere nowhere RB 40436 8133 2 has have VBZ 40436 8133 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8133 4 specified specify VBD 40436 8133 5 a a DT 40436 8133 6 different different JJ 40436 8133 7 end end NN 40436 8133 8 . . . 40436 8134 1 In in IN 40436 8134 2 other other JJ 40436 8134 3 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8134 4 , , , 40436 8134 5 as as RB 40436 8134 6 well well RB 40436 8134 7 as as IN 40436 8134 8 in in IN 40436 8134 9 the the DT 40436 8134 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8134 11 , , , 40436 8134 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8134 13 has have VBZ 40436 8134 14 insisted insist VBN 40436 8134 15 on on IN 40436 8134 16 the the DT 40436 8134 17 necessity necessity NN 40436 8134 18 of of IN 40436 8134 19 a a DT 40436 8134 20 science science NN 40436 8134 21 or or CC 40436 8134 22 art art NN 40436 8134 23 of of IN 40436 8134 24 calculation calculation NN 40436 8134 25 : : : 40436 8134 26 but but CC 40436 8134 27 in in IN 40436 8134 28 no no DT 40436 8134 29 other other JJ 40436 8134 30 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8134 31 has have VBZ 40436 8134 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8134 33 told tell VBD 40436 8134 34 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8134 35 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 8134 36 what what WP 40436 8134 37 are be VBP 40436 8134 38 the the DT 40436 8134 39 items item NNS 40436 8134 40 to to TO 40436 8134 41 be be VB 40436 8134 42 calculated calculate VBN 40436 8134 43 . . . 40436 8135 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8135 2 Side side NN 40436 8135 3 - - HYPH 40436 8135 4 note note NN 40436 8135 5 : : : 40436 8135 6 Remarks remark NNS 40436 8135 7 on on IN 40436 8135 8 the the DT 40436 8135 9 theory theory NN 40436 8135 10 here here RB 40436 8135 11 laid lay VBN 40436 8135 12 down down RP 40436 8135 13 by by IN 40436 8135 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8135 15 . . . 40436 8136 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8136 2 is be VBZ 40436 8136 3 too too RB 40436 8136 4 narrow narrow JJ 40436 8136 5 , , , 40436 8136 6 and and CC 40436 8136 7 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 8136 8 prudential prudential JJ 40436 8136 9 . . . 40436 8136 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8137 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8137 2 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 8137 3 agree agree VBP 40436 8137 4 with with IN 40436 8137 5 the the DT 40436 8137 6 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8137 7 laid lay VBN 40436 8137 8 down down RP 40436 8137 9 by by IN 40436 8137 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8137 11 in in IN 40436 8137 12 the the DT 40436 8137 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8137 14 , , , 40436 8137 15 that that DT 40436 8137 16 pain pain NN 40436 8137 17 or or CC 40436 8137 18 suffering suffering NN 40436 8137 19 is be VBZ 40436 8137 20 the the DT 40436 8137 21 End end NN 40436 8137 22 to to TO 40436 8137 23 be be VB 40436 8137 24 avoided avoid VBN 40436 8137 25 or or CC 40436 8137 26 lessened lessen VBN 40436 8137 27 as as RB 40436 8137 28 far far RB 40436 8137 29 as as IN 40436 8137 30 possible possible JJ 40436 8137 31 -- -- : 40436 8137 32 and and CC 40436 8137 33 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8137 34 or or CC 40436 8137 35 happiness happiness VB 40436 8137 36 the the DT 40436 8137 37 End end NN 40436 8137 38 to to TO 40436 8137 39 be be VB 40436 8137 40 pursued pursue VBN 40436 8137 41 as as RB 40436 8137 42 far far RB 40436 8137 43 as as IN 40436 8137 44 attainable attainable JJ 40436 8137 45 -- -- : 40436 8137 46 by by IN 40436 8137 47 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 8137 48 forethought forethought NN 40436 8137 49 and and CC 40436 8137 50 comparison comparison NN 40436 8137 51 : : : 40436 8137 52 that that IN 40436 8137 53 there there EX 40436 8137 54 is be VBZ 40436 8137 55 no no DT 40436 8137 56 other other JJ 40436 8137 57 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 8137 58 standard standard NN 40436 8137 59 of of IN 40436 8137 60 reference reference NN 40436 8137 61 , , , 40436 8137 62 for for IN 40436 8137 63 application application NN 40436 8137 64 of of IN 40436 8137 65 the the DT 40436 8137 66 terms term NNS 40436 8137 67 Good Good NNP 40436 8137 68 and and CC 40436 8137 69 Evil Evil NNP 40436 8137 70 , , , 40436 8137 71 except except IN 40436 8137 72 the the DT 40436 8137 73 tendency tendency NN 40436 8137 74 to to TO 40436 8137 75 produce produce VB 40436 8137 76 happiness happiness NN 40436 8137 77 or or CC 40436 8137 78 misery misery NN 40436 8137 79 : : : 40436 8137 80 and and CC 40436 8137 81 that that IN 40436 8137 82 if if IN 40436 8137 83 this this DT 40436 8137 84 standard standard NN 40436 8137 85 be be VB 40436 8137 86 rejected reject VBN 40436 8137 87 , , , 40436 8137 88 ethical ethical JJ 40436 8137 89 debate debate NN 40436 8137 90 loses lose VBZ 40436 8137 91 all all DT 40436 8137 92 standard standard NN 40436 8137 93 for for IN 40436 8137 94 rational rational JJ 40436 8137 95 discussion discussion NN 40436 8137 96 , , , 40436 8137 97 and and CC 40436 8137 98 becomes become VBZ 40436 8137 99 only only RB 40436 8137 100 an an DT 40436 8137 101 enunciation enunciation NN 40436 8137 102 of of IN 40436 8137 103 the the DT 40436 8137 104 different different JJ 40436 8137 105 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8137 106 , , , 40436 8137 107 authoritative authoritative JJ 40436 8137 108 and and CC 40436 8137 109 self self NN 40436 8137 110 - - HYPH 40436 8137 111 justifying justify VBG 40436 8137 112 , , , 40436 8137 113 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 8137 114 in in IN 40436 8137 115 each each DT 40436 8137 116 community community NN 40436 8137 117 . . . 40436 8138 1 But but CC 40436 8138 2 the the DT 40436 8138 3 End end NN 40436 8138 4 just just RB 40436 8138 5 mentioned mention VBN 40436 8138 6 is be VBZ 40436 8138 7 highly highly RB 40436 8138 8 complex complex JJ 40436 8138 9 , , , 40436 8138 10 and and CC 40436 8138 11 care care NN 40436 8138 12 must must MD 40436 8138 13 be be VB 40436 8138 14 taken take VBN 40436 8138 15 to to TO 40436 8138 16 conceive conceive VB 40436 8138 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8138 18 in in IN 40436 8138 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8138 20 full full JJ 40436 8138 21 comprehension comprehension NN 40436 8138 22 . . . 40436 8139 1 Herein Herein NNP 40436 8139 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8139 3 conceive conceive VBP 40436 8139 4 the the DT 40436 8139 5 argument argument NN 40436 8139 6 of of IN 40436 8139 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8139 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8139 9 in in IN 40436 8139 10 the the DT 40436 8139 11 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8139 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8139 13 to to TO 40436 8139 14 be be VB 40436 8139 15 incomplete incomplete JJ 40436 8139 16 . . . 40436 8140 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8140 2 carries carry VBZ 40436 8140 3 attention attention NN 40436 8140 4 only only RB 40436 8140 5 to to IN 40436 8140 6 a a DT 40436 8140 7 part part NN 40436 8140 8 of of IN 40436 8140 9 the the DT 40436 8140 10 truth truth NN 40436 8140 11 , , , 40436 8140 12 keeping keep VBG 40436 8140 13 out out IN 40436 8140 14 of of IN 40436 8140 15 sight sight NN 40436 8140 16 , , , 40436 8140 17 though though IN 40436 8140 18 not not RB 40436 8140 19 excluding exclude VBG 40436 8140 20 , , , 40436 8140 21 the the DT 40436 8140 22 remainder remainder NN 40436 8140 23 . . . 40436 8141 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8141 2 considers consider VBZ 40436 8141 3 each each DT 40436 8141 4 man man NN 40436 8141 5 as as IN 40436 8141 6 an an DT 40436 8141 7 individual individual NN 40436 8141 8 , , , 40436 8141 9 determining determine VBG 40436 8141 10 good good JJ 40436 8141 11 or or CC 40436 8141 12 evil evil NN 40436 8141 13 for for IN 40436 8141 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8141 15 by by IN 40436 8141 16 calculating calculate VBG 40436 8141 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8141 18 own own JJ 40436 8141 19 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8141 20 and and CC 40436 8141 21 pains pain NNS 40436 8141 22 : : : 40436 8141 23 as as IN 40436 8141 24 a a DT 40436 8141 25 prudent prudent NN 40436 8141 26 , , , 40436 8141 27 temperate temperate NN 40436 8141 28 , , , 40436 8141 29 and and CC 40436 8141 30 courageous courageous JJ 40436 8141 31 agent agent NN 40436 8141 32 , , , 40436 8141 33 but but CC 40436 8141 34 neither neither CC 40436 8141 35 as as RB 40436 8141 36 just just RB 40436 8141 37 nor nor CC 40436 8141 38 beneficent beneficent JJ 40436 8141 39 . . . 40436 8142 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8142 2 omits omit VBZ 40436 8142 3 to to TO 40436 8142 4 take take VB 40436 8142 5 account account NN 40436 8142 6 of of IN 40436 8142 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8142 8 as as IN 40436 8142 9 a a DT 40436 8142 10 member member NN 40436 8142 11 of of IN 40436 8142 12 a a DT 40436 8142 13 society society NN 40436 8142 14 , , , 40436 8142 15 composed compose VBN 40436 8142 16 of of IN 40436 8142 17 many many JJ 40436 8142 18 others other NNS 40436 8142 19 akin akin JJ 40436 8142 20 or or CC 40436 8142 21 co co JJ 40436 8142 22 - - NN 40436 8142 23 ordinate ordinate VB 40436 8142 24 with with IN 40436 8142 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8142 26 . . . 40436 8143 1 Now now RB 40436 8143 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8143 3 is be VBZ 40436 8143 4 the the DT 40436 8143 5 purpose purpose NN 40436 8143 6 of of IN 40436 8143 7 an an DT 40436 8143 8 ethical ethical JJ 40436 8143 9 or or CC 40436 8143 10 political political JJ 40436 8143 11 reasoner reasoner NN 40436 8143 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8143 13 such such JJ 40436 8143 14 as as IN 40436 8143 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8143 16 both both DT 40436 8143 17 professes profess VBZ 40436 8143 18 to to TO 40436 8143 19 be be VB 40436 8143 20 and and CC 40436 8143 21 really really RB 40436 8143 22 is be VBZ 40436 8143 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8143 24 to to TO 40436 8143 25 study study VB 40436 8143 26 the the DT 40436 8143 27 means mean NNS 40436 8143 28 of of IN 40436 8143 29 happiness happiness NN 40436 8143 30 , , , 40436 8143 31 not not RB 40436 8143 32 simply simply RB 40436 8143 33 for for IN 40436 8143 34 the the DT 40436 8143 35 agent agent NN 40436 8143 36 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8143 37 , , , 40436 8143 38 but but CC 40436 8143 39 for for IN 40436 8143 40 that that DT 40436 8143 41 agent agent NN 40436 8143 42 together together RB 40436 8143 43 with with IN 40436 8143 44 others other NNS 40436 8143 45 around around IN 40436 8143 46 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8143 47 -- -- : 40436 8143 48 for for IN 40436 8143 49 the the DT 40436 8143 50 members member NNS 40436 8143 51 of of IN 40436 8143 52 the the DT 40436 8143 53 community community NN 40436 8143 54 generally generally RB 40436 8143 55 . . . 40436 8144 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8144 2 145 145 CD 40436 8144 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8144 4 The the DT 40436 8144 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8144 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8144 7 says say VBZ 40436 8144 8 this this DT 40436 8144 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8144 10 in in IN 40436 8144 11 the the DT 40436 8144 12 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8144 13 : : : 40436 8144 14 and and CC 40436 8144 15 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 8144 16 , , , 40436 8144 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8144 18 there there RB 40436 8144 19 treats treat VBZ 40436 8144 20 of of IN 40436 8144 21 other other JJ 40436 8144 22 points point NNS 40436 8144 23 which which WDT 40436 8144 24 are be VBP 40436 8144 25 not not RB 40436 8144 26 touched touch VBN 40436 8144 27 upon upon IN 40436 8144 28 by by IN 40436 8144 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8144 30 in in IN 40436 8144 31 the the DT 40436 8144 32 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8144 33 . . . 40436 8145 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8145 2 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 8145 3 that that IN 40436 8145 4 the the DT 40436 8145 5 happiness happiness NN 40436 8145 6 of of IN 40436 8145 7 each each DT 40436 8145 8 citizen citizen NN 40436 8145 9 must must MD 40436 8145 10 be be VB 40436 8145 11 sought seek VBN 40436 8145 12 only only RB 40436 8145 13 by by IN 40436 8145 14 means mean NNS 40436 8145 15 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8145 16 with with IN 40436 8145 17 the the DT 40436 8145 18 security security NN 40436 8145 19 , , , 40436 8145 20 and and CC 40436 8145 21 to to IN 40436 8145 22 a a DT 40436 8145 23 certain certain JJ 40436 8145 24 extent extent NN 40436 8145 25 with with IN 40436 8145 26 the the DT 40436 8145 27 happiness happiness NN 40436 8145 28 , , , 40436 8145 29 of of IN 40436 8145 30 others other NNS 40436 8145 31 : : : 40436 8145 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8145 33 provides provide VBZ 40436 8145 34 as as RB 40436 8145 35 far far RB 40436 8145 36 as as IN 40436 8145 37 practicable practicable JJ 40436 8145 38 that that IN 40436 8145 39 all all DT 40436 8145 40 shall shall MD 40436 8145 41 derive derive VB 40436 8145 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8145 43 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8145 44 and and CC 40436 8145 45 pains pain NNS 40436 8145 46 from from IN 40436 8145 47 the the DT 40436 8145 48 same same JJ 40436 8145 49 causes cause NNS 40436 8145 50 : : : 40436 8145 51 common common JJ 40436 8145 52 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8145 53 , , , 40436 8145 54 and and CC 40436 8145 55 common common JJ 40436 8145 56 pains pain NNS 40436 8145 57 , , , 40436 8145 58 to to IN 40436 8145 59 all all DT 40436 8145 60 . . . 40436 8146 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8146 2 146 146 CD 40436 8146 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8146 4 The the DT 40436 8146 5 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8146 6 of of IN 40436 8146 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8146 8 in in IN 40436 8146 9 the the DT 40436 8146 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8146 11 requires require VBZ 40436 8146 12 to to TO 40436 8146 13 be be VB 40436 8146 14 enlarged enlarge VBN 40436 8146 15 so so IN 40436 8146 16 as as IN 40436 8146 17 to to TO 40436 8146 18 comprehend comprehend VB 40436 8146 19 these these DT 40436 8146 20 other other JJ 40436 8146 21 important important JJ 40436 8146 22 elements element NNS 40436 8146 23 . . . 40436 8147 1 Since since IN 40436 8147 2 the the DT 40436 8147 3 conduct conduct NN 40436 8147 4 of of IN 40436 8147 5 every every DT 40436 8147 6 agent agent NN 40436 8147 7 affects affect VBZ 40436 8147 8 the the DT 40436 8147 9 happiness happiness NN 40436 8147 10 of of IN 40436 8147 11 others other NNS 40436 8147 12 , , , 40436 8147 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8147 14 must must MD 40436 8147 15 be be VB 40436 8147 16 called call VBN 40436 8147 17 upon upon IN 40436 8147 18 to to TO 40436 8147 19 take take VB 40436 8147 20 account account NN 40436 8147 21 of of IN 40436 8147 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8147 23 consequences consequence NNS 40436 8147 24 under under IN 40436 8147 25 both both DT 40436 8147 26 aspects aspect NNS 40436 8147 27 , , , 40436 8147 28 especially especially RB 40436 8147 29 where where WRB 40436 8147 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8147 31 goes go VBZ 40436 8147 32 to to TO 40436 8147 33 inflict inflict VB 40436 8147 34 hurt hurt NN 40436 8147 35 or or CC 40436 8147 36 privation privation NN 40436 8147 37 upon upon IN 40436 8147 38 others other NNS 40436 8147 39 . . . 40436 8148 1 Good good JJ 40436 8148 2 and and CC 40436 8148 3 evil evil NN 40436 8148 4 depend depend VBP 40436 8148 5 upon upon IN 40436 8148 6 that that DT 40436 8148 7 scientific scientific JJ 40436 8148 8 computation computation NN 40436 8148 9 and and CC 40436 8148 10 comparison comparison NN 40436 8148 11 of of IN 40436 8148 12 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8148 13 and and CC 40436 8148 14 pains pain NNS 40436 8148 15 which which WDT 40436 8148 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8148 17 in in IN 40436 8148 18 the the DT 40436 8148 19 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8148 20 prescribes prescribe NNS 40436 8148 21 : : : 40436 8148 22 but but CC 40436 8148 23 the the DT 40436 8148 24 computation computation NN 40436 8148 25 must must MD 40436 8148 26 include include VB 40436 8148 27 , , , 40436 8148 28 to to IN 40436 8148 29 a a DT 40436 8148 30 certain certain JJ 40436 8148 31 extent extent NN 40436 8148 32 , , , 40436 8148 33 the the DT 40436 8148 34 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8148 35 and and CC 40436 8148 36 pains pain NNS 40436 8148 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8148 38 security security NN 40436 8148 39 and and CC 40436 8148 40 rightful rightful JJ 40436 8148 41 expectations expectation NNS 40436 8148 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8148 43 of of IN 40436 8148 44 others other NNS 40436 8148 45 besides besides IN 40436 8148 46 the the DT 40436 8148 47 agent agent NN 40436 8148 48 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8148 49 , , , 40436 8148 50 implicated implicate VBN 40436 8148 51 in in IN 40436 8148 52 the the DT 40436 8148 53 consequences consequence NNS 40436 8148 54 of of IN 40436 8148 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8148 56 acts act NNS 40436 8148 57 . . . 40436 8149 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8149 2 147 147 CD 40436 8149 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8149 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8149 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8149 6 145 145 CD 40436 8149 7 : : : 40436 8149 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8149 9 , , , 40436 8149 10 Republ Republ NNP 40436 8149 11 . . . 40436 8150 1 iv iv XX 40436 8150 2 . . . 40436 8151 1 pp pp NNP 40436 8151 2 . . . 40436 8152 1 420 420 CD 40436 8152 2 - - SYM 40436 8152 3 421 421 CD 40436 8152 4 , , , 40436 8152 5 v. v. CC 40436 8152 6 p. p. NN 40436 8152 7 466 466 CD 40436 8152 8 A. a. NN 40436 8152 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8153 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8153 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8153 3 146 146 CD 40436 8153 4 : : : 40436 8153 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8153 6 , , , 40436 8153 7 Republ Republ NNP 40436 8153 8 . . . 40436 8154 1 v. v. NNP 40436 8154 2 pp pp NNP 40436 8154 3 . . . 40436 8155 1 462 462 CD 40436 8155 2 A A NNP 40436 8155 3 - - HYPH 40436 8155 4 B b NN 40436 8155 5 - - HYPH 40436 8155 6 D d NN 40436 8155 7 , , , 40436 8155 8 464 464 CD 40436 8155 9 A A NNP 40436 8155 10 - - HYPH 40436 8155 11 D. D. NNP 40436 8156 1 Throughout throughout IN 40436 8156 2 the the DT 40436 8156 3 first first JJ 40436 8156 4 of of IN 40436 8156 5 these these DT 40436 8156 6 passages passage NNS 40436 8156 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8156 8 see see VBP 40436 8156 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8156 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8156 11 : : : 40436 8156 12 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 8156 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8156 14 used use VBN 40436 8156 15 as as IN 40436 8156 16 the the DT 40436 8156 17 equivalent equivalent NN 40436 8156 18 of of IN 40436 8156 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8156 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8156 21 : : : 40436 8156 22 ê(donê/ ê(donê/ NNP 40436 8156 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8156 24 , , , 40436 8156 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8156 26 Greek greek JJ 40436 8156 27 : : : 40436 8156 28 kako\n kako\n ADD 40436 8156 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8156 30 as as IN 40436 8156 31 the the DT 40436 8156 32 equivalent equivalent NN 40436 8156 33 of of IN 40436 8156 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8156 35 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8156 36 : : : 40436 8156 37 lu lu NNP 40436 8156 38 / / SYM 40436 8156 39 pê pê NNP 40436 8156 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8156 41 . . . 40436 8156 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8157 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8157 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8157 3 147 147 CD 40436 8157 4 : : : 40436 8157 5 See see VB 40436 8157 6 , , , 40436 8157 7 especially especially RB 40436 8157 8 on on IN 40436 8157 9 this this DT 40436 8157 10 point point NN 40436 8157 11 , , , 40436 8157 12 the the DT 40436 8157 13 brief brief JJ 40436 8157 14 but but CC 40436 8157 15 valuable valuable JJ 40436 8157 16 Tract Tract NNP 40436 8157 17 on on IN 40436 8157 18 Utilitarianism Utilitarianism NNP 40436 8157 19 by by IN 40436 8157 20 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 8157 21 John John NNP 40436 8157 22 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 8157 23 Mill Mill NNP 40436 8157 24 . . . 40436 8158 1 In in IN 40436 8158 2 page page NN 40436 8158 3 16 16 CD 40436 8158 4 of of IN 40436 8158 5 that that DT 40436 8158 6 work work NN 40436 8158 7 attention attention NN 40436 8158 8 is be VBZ 40436 8158 9 called call VBN 40436 8158 10 to to IN 40436 8158 11 the the DT 40436 8158 12 fact fact NN 40436 8158 13 , , , 40436 8158 14 that that IN 40436 8158 15 in in IN 40436 8158 16 Utilitarianism Utilitarianism NNP 40436 8158 17 the the DT 40436 8158 18 standard standard NN 40436 8158 19 is be VBZ 40436 8158 20 not not RB 40436 8158 21 the the DT 40436 8158 22 greatest great JJS 40436 8158 23 happiness happiness NN 40436 8158 24 of of IN 40436 8158 25 the the DT 40436 8158 26 agent agent NN 40436 8158 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8158 28 alone alone RB 40436 8158 29 , , , 40436 8158 30 but but CC 40436 8158 31 the the DT 40436 8158 32 greatest great JJS 40436 8158 33 amount amount NN 40436 8158 34 of of IN 40436 8158 35 happiness happiness NN 40436 8158 36 altogether altogether RB 40436 8158 37 . . . 40436 8159 1 So so IN 40436 8159 2 that that IN 40436 8159 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8159 4 can can MD 40436 8159 5 not not RB 40436 8159 6 with with IN 40436 8159 7 exactness exactness NN 40436 8159 8 call call VB 40436 8159 9 the the DT 40436 8159 10 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8159 11 of of IN 40436 8159 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8159 13 , , , 40436 8159 14 in in IN 40436 8159 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8159 16 conversation conversation NN 40436 8159 17 with with IN 40436 8159 18 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8159 19 , , , 40436 8159 20 " " '' 40436 8159 21 the the DT 40436 8159 22 theory theory NN 40436 8159 23 of of IN 40436 8159 24 Utilitarianism Utilitarianism NNP 40436 8159 25 , , , 40436 8159 26 " " '' 40436 8159 27 as as IN 40436 8159 28 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 8159 29 Mill Mill NNP 40436 8159 30 calls call VBZ 40436 8159 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8159 32 in in IN 40436 8159 33 page page NN 40436 8159 34 1 1 CD 40436 8159 35 . . . 40436 8159 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8160 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8160 2 Side side NN 40436 8160 3 - - HYPH 40436 8160 4 note note NN 40436 8160 5 : : : 40436 8160 6 Comparison comparison NN 40436 8160 7 with with IN 40436 8160 8 the the DT 40436 8160 9 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8160 10 . . . 40436 8160 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8161 1 As as IN 40436 8161 2 to to IN 40436 8161 3 this this DT 40436 8161 4 point point NN 40436 8161 5 , , , 40436 8161 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8161 7 shall shall MD 40436 8161 8 find find VB 40436 8161 9 the the DT 40436 8161 10 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8161 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8161 12 not not RB 40436 8161 13 always always RB 40436 8161 14 correct correct JJ 40436 8161 15 , , , 40436 8161 16 nor nor CC 40436 8161 17 even even RB 40436 8161 18 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8161 19 with with IN 40436 8161 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8161 21 . . . 40436 8162 1 This this DT 40436 8162 2 will will MD 40436 8162 3 appear appear VB 40436 8162 4 especially especially RB 40436 8162 5 when when WRB 40436 8162 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8162 7 come come VBP 40436 8162 8 to to TO 40436 8162 9 see see VB 40436 8162 10 the the DT 40436 8162 11 account account NN 40436 8162 12 which which WDT 40436 8162 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8162 14 gives give VBZ 40436 8162 15 of of IN 40436 8162 16 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8162 17 in in IN 40436 8162 18 the the DT 40436 8162 19 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8162 20 . . . 40436 8163 1 In in IN 40436 8163 2 that that DT 40436 8163 3 branch branch NN 40436 8163 4 of of IN 40436 8163 5 the the DT 40436 8163 6 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 8163 7 End End NNP 40436 8163 8 , , , 40436 8163 9 a a DT 40436 8163 10 direct direct JJ 40436 8163 11 regard regard NN 40436 8163 12 to to IN 40436 8163 13 the the DT 40436 8163 14 security security NN 40436 8163 15 of of IN 40436 8163 16 others other NNS 40436 8163 17 comes come VBZ 40436 8163 18 into into IN 40436 8163 19 the the DT 40436 8163 20 foreground foreground NN 40436 8163 21 . . . 40436 8164 1 For for IN 40436 8164 2 in in IN 40436 8164 3 an an DT 40436 8164 4 act act NN 40436 8164 5 of of IN 40436 8164 6 injustice injustice NN 40436 8164 7 , , , 40436 8164 8 the the DT 40436 8164 9 prominent prominent JJ 40436 8164 10 characteristic characteristic NN 40436 8164 11 is be VBZ 40436 8164 12 that that DT 40436 8164 13 of of IN 40436 8164 14 harm harm NN 40436 8164 15 , , , 40436 8164 16 done do VBN 40436 8164 17 to to IN 40436 8164 18 others other NNS 40436 8164 19 -- -- : 40436 8164 20 though though IN 40436 8164 21 that that DT 40436 8164 22 is be VBZ 40436 8164 23 not not RB 40436 8164 24 the the DT 40436 8164 25 whole whole NN 40436 8164 26 , , , 40436 8164 27 since since IN 40436 8164 28 the the DT 40436 8164 29 security security NN 40436 8164 30 of of IN 40436 8164 31 the the DT 40436 8164 32 agent agent NN 40436 8164 33 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8164 34 is be VBZ 40436 8164 35 implicated implicate VBN 40436 8164 36 with with IN 40436 8164 37 that that DT 40436 8164 38 of of IN 40436 8164 39 others other NNS 40436 8164 40 in in IN 40436 8164 41 the the DT 40436 8164 42 general general JJ 40436 8164 43 fulfilment fulfilment NN 40436 8164 44 of of IN 40436 8164 45 these these DT 40436 8164 46 obligations obligation NNS 40436 8164 47 . . . 40436 8165 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8165 2 is be VBZ 40436 8165 3 this this DT 40436 8165 4 primary primary JJ 40436 8165 5 regard regard NN 40436 8165 6 to to IN 40436 8165 7 others other NNS 40436 8165 8 , , , 40436 8165 9 and and CC 40436 8165 10 secondary secondary JJ 40436 8165 11 regard regard NN 40436 8165 12 to to IN 40436 8165 13 self self NN 40436 8165 14 , , , 40436 8165 15 implicated implicate VBN 40436 8165 16 in in IN 40436 8165 17 one one CD 40436 8165 18 complex complex JJ 40436 8165 19 feeling feeling NN 40436 8165 20 -- -- : 40436 8165 21 which which WDT 40436 8165 22 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 40436 8165 23 justice justice NN 40436 8165 24 from from IN 40436 8165 25 prudence prudence NN 40436 8165 26 . . . 40436 8166 1 The the DT 40436 8166 2 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8166 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8166 4 in in IN 40436 8166 5 the the DT 40436 8166 6 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8166 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8166 8 though though IN 40436 8166 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8166 10 language language NN 40436 8166 11 is be VBZ 40436 8166 12 not not RB 40436 8166 13 always always RB 40436 8166 14 clear clear JJ 40436 8166 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8166 16 does do VBZ 40436 8166 17 not not RB 40436 8166 18 admit admit VB 40436 8166 19 this this DT 40436 8166 20 ; ; : 40436 8166 21 but but CC 40436 8166 22 considers consider VBZ 40436 8166 23 justice justice NN 40436 8166 24 as as IN 40436 8166 25 a a DT 40436 8166 26 branch branch NN 40436 8166 27 of of IN 40436 8166 28 prudence prudence NN 40436 8166 29 , , , 40436 8166 30 necessary necessary JJ 40436 8166 31 to to TO 40436 8166 32 ensure ensure VB 40436 8166 33 the the DT 40436 8166 34 happiness happiness NN 40436 8166 35 of of IN 40436 8166 36 the the DT 40436 8166 37 individual individual JJ 40436 8166 38 agent agent NN 40436 8166 39 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8166 40 . . . 40436 8167 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8167 2 Side side NN 40436 8167 3 - - HYPH 40436 8167 4 note note NN 40436 8167 5 : : : 40436 8167 6 The the DT 40436 8167 7 discourse discourse NN 40436 8167 8 of of IN 40436 8167 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8167 10 brings bring VBZ 40436 8167 11 out out RP 40436 8167 12 an an DT 40436 8167 13 important important JJ 40436 8167 14 part part NN 40436 8167 15 of of IN 40436 8167 16 the the DT 40436 8167 17 whole whole JJ 40436 8167 18 case case NN 40436 8167 19 , , , 40436 8167 20 which which WDT 40436 8167 21 is be VBZ 40436 8167 22 omitted omit VBN 40436 8167 23 in in IN 40436 8167 24 the the DT 40436 8167 25 analysis analysis NN 40436 8167 26 by by IN 40436 8167 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8167 28 . . . 40436 8167 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8168 1 Now now RB 40436 8168 2 in in IN 40436 8168 3 the the DT 40436 8168 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8168 5 , , , 40436 8168 6 what what WP 40436 8168 7 the the DT 40436 8168 8 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8168 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8168 10 dwells dwell NNS 40436 8168 11 upon upon IN 40436 8168 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8168 13 in in IN 40436 8168 14 the the DT 40436 8168 15 argument argument NN 40436 8168 16 which which WDT 40436 8168 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8168 18 have have VBP 40436 8168 19 been be VBN 40436 8168 20 considering consider VBG 40436 8168 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8168 22 is be VBZ 40436 8168 23 prudence prudence NN 40436 8168 24 , , , 40436 8168 25 temperance temperance NN 40436 8168 26 , , , 40436 8168 27 courage courage NN 40436 8168 28 : : : 40436 8168 29 little little JJ 40436 8168 30 or or CC 40436 8168 31 nothing nothing NN 40436 8168 32 is be VBZ 40436 8168 33 said say VBN 40436 8168 34 about about IN 40436 8168 35 justice justice NN 40436 8168 36 : : : 40436 8168 37 there there EX 40436 8168 38 was be VBD 40436 8168 39 therefore therefore RB 40436 8168 40 the the DT 40436 8168 41 less less JJR 40436 8168 42 necessity necessity NN 40436 8168 43 for for IN 40436 8168 44 insisting insist VBG 40436 8168 45 on on IN 40436 8168 46 that that DT 40436 8168 47 prominent prominent JJ 40436 8168 48 reference reference NN 40436 8168 49 to to IN 40436 8168 50 the the DT 40436 8168 51 security security NN 40436 8168 52 of of IN 40436 8168 53 others other NNS 40436 8168 54 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8168 55 besides besides IN 40436 8168 56 the the DT 40436 8168 57 agent agent NN 40436 8168 58 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8168 59 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8168 60 which which WDT 40436 8168 61 justice justice NN 40436 8168 62 involves involve VBZ 40436 8168 63 . . . 40436 8169 1 If if IN 40436 8169 2 , , , 40436 8169 3 however however RB 40436 8169 4 , , , 40436 8169 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8169 6 turn turn VBP 40436 8169 7 back back RB 40436 8169 8 to to IN 40436 8169 9 the the DT 40436 8169 10 earlier early JJR 40436 8169 11 part part NN 40436 8169 12 of of IN 40436 8169 13 the the DT 40436 8169 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8169 15 , , , 40436 8169 16 to to IN 40436 8169 17 the the DT 40436 8169 18 speech speech NN 40436 8169 19 delivered deliver VBN 40436 8169 20 by by IN 40436 8169 21 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8169 22 , , , 40436 8169 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8169 24 see see VBP 40436 8169 25 justice justice NN 40436 8169 26 brought bring VBD 40436 8169 27 into into IN 40436 8169 28 the the DT 40436 8169 29 foreground foreground NN 40436 8169 30 . . . 40436 8170 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8170 2 is be VBZ 40436 8170 3 not not RB 40436 8170 4 indeed indeed RB 40436 8170 5 handled handle VBN 40436 8170 6 analytically analytically RB 40436 8170 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8170 8 which which WDT 40436 8170 9 is be VBZ 40436 8170 10 not not RB 40436 8170 11 the the DT 40436 8170 12 manner manner NN 40436 8170 13 of of IN 40436 8170 14 that that DT 40436 8170 15 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8170 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8170 17 , , , 40436 8170 18 nor nor CC 40436 8170 19 is be VBZ 40436 8170 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8170 21 resolved resolve VBN 40436 8170 22 into into IN 40436 8170 23 regard regard NN 40436 8170 24 to to IN 40436 8170 25 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8170 26 and and CC 40436 8170 27 pain pain NN 40436 8170 28 , , , 40436 8170 29 happiness happiness NN 40436 8170 30 and and CC 40436 8170 31 misery misery NN 40436 8170 32 : : : 40436 8170 33 but but CC 40436 8170 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8170 35 is be VBZ 40436 8170 36 announced announce VBN 40436 8170 37 as as IN 40436 8170 38 a a DT 40436 8170 39 social social JJ 40436 8170 40 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8170 41 indispensably indispensably RB 40436 8170 42 and and CC 40436 8170 43 reciprocally reciprocally RB 40436 8170 44 necessary necessary JJ 40436 8170 45 from from IN 40436 8170 46 every every DT 40436 8170 47 man man NN 40436 8170 48 towards towards IN 40436 8170 49 every every DT 40436 8170 50 other other JJ 40436 8170 51 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8170 52 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8170 53 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8170 54 : : : 40436 8170 55 di di NNP 40436 8170 56 / / SYM 40436 8170 57 kê kê UH 40436 8170 58 -- -- : 40436 8170 59 ai)dô\s ai)dô\s NNP 40436 8170 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8170 61 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8170 62 , , , 40436 8170 63 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 40436 8170 64 from from IN 40436 8170 65 those those DT 40436 8170 66 endowments endowment NNS 40436 8170 67 which which WDT 40436 8170 68 supply supply VBP 40436 8170 69 the the DT 40436 8170 70 wants want NNS 40436 8170 71 and and CC 40436 8170 72 multiply multiply VB 40436 8170 73 the the DT 40436 8170 74 comforts comfort NNS 40436 8170 75 of of IN 40436 8170 76 the the DT 40436 8170 77 individual individual NN 40436 8170 78 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8170 79 . . . 40436 8171 1 The the DT 40436 8171 2 very very JJ 40436 8171 3 existence existence NN 40436 8171 4 of of IN 40436 8171 5 the the DT 40436 8171 6 social social NNP 40436 8171 7 union union NNP 40436 8171 8 requires require VBZ 40436 8171 9 , , , 40436 8171 10 that that IN 40436 8171 11 each each DT 40436 8171 12 man man NN 40436 8171 13 should should MD 40436 8171 14 feel feel VB 40436 8171 15 a a DT 40436 8171 16 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8171 17 of of IN 40436 8171 18 duties duty NNS 40436 8171 19 on on IN 40436 8171 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8171 21 part part NN 40436 8171 22 towards towards IN 40436 8171 23 others other NNS 40436 8171 24 , , , 40436 8171 25 and and CC 40436 8171 26 duties duty NNS 40436 8171 27 on on IN 40436 8171 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8171 29 parts part NNS 40436 8171 30 towards towards IN 40436 8171 31 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8171 32 : : : 40436 8171 33 or or CC 40436 8171 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8171 35 in in IN 40436 8171 36 other other JJ 40436 8171 37 words word NNS 40436 8171 38 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8171 39 of of IN 40436 8171 40 rights right NNS 40436 8171 41 on on IN 40436 8171 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8171 43 part part NN 40436 8171 44 to to TO 40436 8171 45 have have VB 40436 8171 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8171 47 interests interest NNS 40436 8171 48 considered consider VBN 40436 8171 49 by by IN 40436 8171 50 others other NNS 40436 8171 51 , , , 40436 8171 52 and and CC 40436 8171 53 rights right NNS 40436 8171 54 on on IN 40436 8171 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8171 56 parts part NNS 40436 8171 57 to to TO 40436 8171 58 have have VB 40436 8171 59 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8171 60 interests interest NNS 40436 8171 61 considered consider VBN 40436 8171 62 by by IN 40436 8171 63 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8171 64 . . . 40436 8172 1 Unless unless IN 40436 8172 2 this this DT 40436 8172 3 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8172 4 of of IN 40436 8172 5 reciprocity reciprocity NN 40436 8172 6 -- -- : 40436 8172 7 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 8172 8 duty duty NN 40436 8172 9 and and CC 40436 8172 10 right right NN 40436 8172 11 -- -- : 40436 8172 12 exist exist VB 40436 8172 13 in in IN 40436 8172 14 the the DT 40436 8172 15 bosom bosom NN 40436 8172 16 of of IN 40436 8172 17 each each DT 40436 8172 18 individual individual JJ 40436 8172 19 citizen citizen NN 40436 8172 20 , , , 40436 8172 21 or or CC 40436 8172 22 at at IN 40436 8172 23 least least JJS 40436 8172 24 in in IN 40436 8172 25 the the DT 40436 8172 26 large large JJ 40436 8172 27 majority majority NN 40436 8172 28 -- -- : 40436 8172 29 no no DT 40436 8172 30 social social JJ 40436 8172 31 union union NN 40436 8172 32 could could MD 40436 8172 33 subsist subsist VB 40436 8172 34 . . . 40436 8173 1 There there EX 40436 8173 2 are be VBP 40436 8173 3 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 8173 4 different different JJ 40436 8173 5 degrees degree NNS 40436 8173 6 of of IN 40436 8173 7 the the DT 40436 8173 8 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8173 9 : : : 40436 8173 10 moreover moreover CC 40436 8173 11 the the DT 40436 8173 12 rights right NNS 40436 8173 13 and and CC 40436 8173 14 duties duty NNS 40436 8173 15 may may MD 40436 8173 16 be be VB 40436 8173 17 apportioned apportion VBN 40436 8173 18 better well JJR 40436 8173 19 or or CC 40436 8173 20 worse bad JJR 40436 8173 21 , , , 40436 8173 22 more more RBR 40436 8173 23 or or CC 40436 8173 24 less less RBR 40436 8173 25 fairly fairly RB 40436 8173 26 , , , 40436 8173 27 among among IN 40436 8173 28 the the DT 40436 8173 29 individuals individual NNS 40436 8173 30 of of IN 40436 8173 31 a a DT 40436 8173 32 society society NN 40436 8173 33 ; ; : 40436 8173 34 thus thus RB 40436 8173 35 rendering render VBG 40436 8173 36 the the DT 40436 8173 37 society society NN 40436 8173 38 more more RBR 40436 8173 39 or or CC 40436 8173 40 less less RBR 40436 8173 41 estimable estimable JJ 40436 8173 42 and and CC 40436 8173 43 comfortable comfortable JJ 40436 8173 44 . . . 40436 8174 1 But but CC 40436 8174 2 without without IN 40436 8174 3 a a DT 40436 8174 4 certain certain JJ 40436 8174 5 minimum minimum NN 40436 8174 6 of of IN 40436 8174 7 the the DT 40436 8174 8 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8174 9 in in IN 40436 8174 10 each each DT 40436 8174 11 individual individual JJ 40436 8174 12 bosom bosom NN 40436 8174 13 , , , 40436 8174 14 even even RB 40436 8174 15 the the DT 40436 8174 16 worst bad JJS 40436 8174 17 constituted constituted JJ 40436 8174 18 society society NN 40436 8174 19 could could MD 40436 8174 20 not not RB 40436 8174 21 hold hold VB 40436 8174 22 together together RB 40436 8174 23 . . . 40436 8175 1 And and CC 40436 8175 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8175 3 is be VBZ 40436 8175 4 this this DT 40436 8175 5 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8175 6 of of IN 40436 8175 7 reciprocity reciprocity NN 40436 8175 8 which which WDT 40436 8175 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8175 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8175 11 in in IN 40436 8175 12 the the DT 40436 8175 13 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8175 14 before before IN 40436 8175 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8175 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8175 17 is be VBZ 40436 8175 18 introduced introduce VBN 40436 8175 19 as as IN 40436 8175 20 postulating postulate VBG 40436 8175 21 in in RP 40436 8175 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8175 23 declaration declaration NN 40436 8175 24 , , , 40436 8175 25 that that DT 40436 8175 26 justice justice NN 40436 8175 27 and and CC 40436 8175 28 the the DT 40436 8175 29 sense sense NN 40436 8175 30 of of IN 40436 8175 31 shame shame NN 40436 8175 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8175 33 unlike unlike JJ 40436 8175 34 to to IN 40436 8175 35 professional professional JJ 40436 8175 36 aptitudes aptitude NNS 40436 8175 37 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8175 38 must must MD 40436 8175 39 be be VB 40436 8175 40 distributed distribute VBN 40436 8175 41 universally universally RB 40436 8175 42 and and CC 40436 8175 43 without without IN 40436 8175 44 exception exception NN 40436 8175 45 among among IN 40436 8175 46 all all PDT 40436 8175 47 the the DT 40436 8175 48 members member NNS 40436 8175 49 of of IN 40436 8175 50 a a DT 40436 8175 51 community community NN 40436 8175 52 . . . 40436 8176 1 Each each DT 40436 8176 2 man man NN 40436 8176 3 must must MD 40436 8176 4 feel feel VB 40436 8176 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8176 6 , , , 40436 8176 7 in in IN 40436 8176 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8176 9 conduct conduct NN 40436 8176 10 towards towards IN 40436 8176 11 others other NNS 40436 8176 12 : : : 40436 8176 13 each each DT 40436 8176 14 man man NN 40436 8176 15 must must MD 40436 8176 16 also also RB 40436 8176 17 be be VB 40436 8176 18 able able JJ 40436 8176 19 to to TO 40436 8176 20 reckon reckon VB 40436 8176 21 that that IN 40436 8176 22 others other NNS 40436 8176 23 will will MD 40436 8176 24 feel feel VB 40436 8176 25 the the DT 40436 8176 26 like like JJ 40436 8176 27 , , , 40436 8176 28 in in IN 40436 8176 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8176 30 behaviour behaviour NN 40436 8176 31 towards towards IN 40436 8176 32 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8176 33 . . . 40436 8177 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8177 2 148 148 CD 40436 8177 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8177 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8177 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8177 6 148 148 CD 40436 8177 7 : : : 40436 8177 8 Professor Professor NNP 40436 8177 9 Bain Bain NNP 40436 8177 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8177 11 in in IN 40436 8177 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8177 13 work work NN 40436 8177 14 on on IN 40436 8177 15 the the DT 40436 8177 16 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 8177 17 and and CC 40436 8177 18 the the DT 40436 8177 19 Will Will NNP 40436 8177 20 , , , 40436 8177 21 ch ch NN 40436 8177 22 . . . 40436 8178 1 xv xv NNP 40436 8178 2 . . . 40436 8179 1 On on IN 40436 8179 2 the the DT 40436 8179 3 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 8179 4 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 8179 5 , , , 40436 8179 6 pp pp NNP 40436 8179 7 . . . 40436 8180 1 271 271 CD 40436 8180 2 - - SYM 40436 8180 3 3 3 CD 40436 8180 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8180 5 has have VBZ 40436 8180 6 given give VBN 40436 8180 7 remarks remark NNS 40436 8180 8 extremely extremely RB 40436 8180 9 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 8180 10 to to IN 40436 8180 11 the the DT 40436 8180 12 illustration illustration NN 40436 8180 13 of of IN 40436 8180 14 that that DT 40436 8180 15 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8180 16 which which WDT 40436 8180 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8180 18 has have VBZ 40436 8180 19 here here RB 40436 8180 20 placed place VBN 40436 8180 21 under under IN 40436 8180 22 the the DT 40436 8180 23 name name NN 40436 8180 24 of of IN 40436 8180 25 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8180 26 . . . 40436 8181 1 " " `` 40436 8181 2 The the DT 40436 8181 3 supposed suppose VBN 40436 8181 4 uniformity uniformity NN 40436 8181 5 of of IN 40436 8181 6 moral moral JJ 40436 8181 7 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 8181 8 resolves resolve VBZ 40436 8181 9 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8181 10 into into IN 40436 8181 11 the the DT 40436 8181 12 two two CD 40436 8181 13 following follow VBG 40436 8181 14 particulars particular NNS 40436 8181 15 . . . 40436 8182 1 First first RB 40436 8182 2 , , , 40436 8182 3 the the DT 40436 8182 4 common common JJ 40436 8182 5 end end NN 40436 8182 6 of of IN 40436 8182 7 _ _ NNP 40436 8182 8 public public JJ 40436 8182 9 security security NN 40436 8182 10 _ _ NNP 40436 8182 11 , , , 40436 8182 12 which which WDT 40436 8182 13 is be VBZ 40436 8182 14 also also RB 40436 8182 15 individual individual JJ 40436 8182 16 preservation preservation NN 40436 8182 17 , , , 40436 8182 18 demands demand VBZ 40436 8182 19 certain certain JJ 40436 8182 20 precautions precaution NNS 40436 8182 21 that that WDT 40436 8182 22 are be VBP 40436 8182 23 everywhere everywhere RB 40436 8182 24 very very RB 40436 8182 25 much much RB 40436 8182 26 alike alike RB 40436 8182 27 , , , 40436 8182 28 and and CC 40436 8182 29 can can MD 40436 8182 30 in in IN 40436 8182 31 no no DT 40436 8182 32 case case NN 40436 8182 33 be be VB 40436 8182 34 dispensed dispense VBN 40436 8182 35 with with IN 40436 8182 36 . . . 40436 8183 1 Some some DT 40436 8183 2 sort sort NN 40436 8183 3 of of IN 40436 8183 4 constituted constituted JJ 40436 8183 5 authority authority NN 40436 8183 6 to to TO 40436 8183 7 control control VB 40436 8183 8 the the DT 40436 8183 9 individual individual JJ 40436 8183 10 impulses impulse NNS 40436 8183 11 and and CC 40436 8183 12 to to TO 40436 8183 13 protect protect VB 40436 8183 14 each each DT 40436 8183 15 man man NN 40436 8183 16 's 's POS 40436 8183 17 person person NN 40436 8183 18 and and CC 40436 8183 19 property property NN 40436 8183 20 , , , 40436 8183 21 must must MD 40436 8183 22 exist exist VB 40436 8183 23 wherever wherever WRB 40436 8183 24 a a DT 40436 8183 25 number number NN 40436 8183 26 of of IN 40436 8183 27 human human JJ 40436 8183 28 beings being NNS 40436 8183 29 live live VBP 40436 8183 30 together together RB 40436 8183 31 . . . 40436 8184 1 The the DT 40436 8184 2 duties duty NNS 40436 8184 3 springing spring VBG 40436 8184 4 out out IN 40436 8184 5 of of IN 40436 8184 6 this this DT 40436 8184 7 necessary necessary JJ 40436 8184 8 arrangement arrangement NN 40436 8184 9 are be VBP 40436 8184 10 essentially essentially RB 40436 8184 11 the the DT 40436 8184 12 same same JJ 40436 8184 13 in in IN 40436 8184 14 all all DT 40436 8184 15 societies society NNS 40436 8184 16 . . . 40436 8185 1 . . . 40436 8186 1 . . . 40436 8187 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 8187 2 have have VBP 40436 8187 3 a a DT 40436 8187 4 pretty pretty JJ 40436 8187 5 uniform uniform JJ 40436 8187 6 character character NN 40436 8187 7 all all RB 40436 8187 8 over over IN 40436 8187 9 the the DT 40436 8187 10 globe globe NN 40436 8187 11 . . . 40436 8188 1 If if IN 40436 8188 2 the the DT 40436 8188 3 sense sense NN 40436 8188 4 of of IN 40436 8188 5 the the DT 40436 8188 6 common common JJ 40436 8188 7 safety safety NN 40436 8188 8 were be VBD 40436 8188 9 not not RB 40436 8188 10 sufficiently sufficiently RB 40436 8188 11 strong strong JJ 40436 8188 12 to to TO 40436 8188 13 constitute constitute VB 40436 8188 14 the the DT 40436 8188 15 social social JJ 40436 8188 16 tie tie NN 40436 8188 17 of of IN 40436 8188 18 obedience obedience NN 40436 8188 19 to to IN 40436 8188 20 some some DT 40436 8188 21 common common JJ 40436 8188 22 regulations regulation NNS 40436 8188 23 , , , 40436 8188 24 society society NN 40436 8188 25 could could MD 40436 8188 26 not not RB 40436 8188 27 exist exist VB 40436 8188 28 . . . 40436 8189 1 . . . 40436 8190 1 . . . 40436 8191 1 . . . 40436 8192 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8192 2 is be VBZ 40436 8192 3 no no DT 40436 8192 4 proof proof NN 40436 8192 5 of of IN 40436 8192 6 the the DT 40436 8192 7 universal universal JJ 40436 8192 8 spread spread NN 40436 8192 9 of of IN 40436 8192 10 a a DT 40436 8192 11 special special JJ 40436 8192 12 innate innate NN 40436 8192 13 faculty faculty NN 40436 8192 14 of of IN 40436 8192 15 moral moral JJ 40436 8192 16 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 8192 17 , , , 40436 8192 18 but but CC 40436 8192 19 of of IN 40436 8192 20 a a DT 40436 8192 21 certain certain JJ 40436 8192 22 rational rational JJ 40436 8192 23 appreciation appreciation NN 40436 8192 24 of of IN 40436 8192 25 what what WP 40436 8192 26 is be VBZ 40436 8192 27 necessary necessary JJ 40436 8192 28 for for IN 40436 8192 29 the the DT 40436 8192 30 very very JJ 40436 8192 31 existence existence NN 40436 8192 32 of of IN 40436 8192 33 every every DT 40436 8192 34 human human NN 40436 8192 35 being being NN 40436 8192 36 living live VBG 40436 8192 37 in in IN 40436 8192 38 the the DT 40436 8192 39 company company NN 40436 8192 40 of of IN 40436 8192 41 others other NNS 40436 8192 42 : : : 40436 8192 43 Doubtless doubtless RB 40436 8192 44 , , , 40436 8192 45 if if IN 40436 8192 46 the the DT 40436 8192 47 sad sad JJ 40436 8192 48 history history NN 40436 8192 49 of of IN 40436 8192 50 the the DT 40436 8192 51 human human JJ 40436 8192 52 race race NN 40436 8192 53 had have VBD 40436 8192 54 been be VBN 40436 8192 55 preserved preserve VBN 40436 8192 56 in in IN 40436 8192 57 all all DT 40436 8192 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8192 59 details detail NNS 40436 8192 60 , , , 40436 8192 61 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8192 62 _ _ NNP 40436 8192 63 should should MD 40436 8192 64 have have VB 40436 8192 65 many many JJ 40436 8192 66 examples example NNS 40436 8192 67 of of IN 40436 8192 68 tribes tribe NNS 40436 8192 69 that that WDT 40436 8192 70 perished perish VBD 40436 8192 71 from from IN 40436 8192 72 being be VBG 40436 8192 73 unequal unequal JJ 40436 8192 74 to to IN 40436 8192 75 the the DT 40436 8192 76 conception conception NN 40436 8192 77 of of IN 40436 8192 78 a a DT 40436 8192 79 social social JJ 40436 8192 80 system system NN 40436 8192 81 , , , 40436 8192 82 or or CC 40436 8192 83 to to IN 40436 8192 84 the the DT 40436 8192 85 restraints restraint NNS 40436 8192 86 imposed impose VBN 40436 8192 87 by by IN 40436 8192 88 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8192 89 _ _ NNP 40436 8192 90 . . . 40436 8193 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8193 2 know know VBP 40436 8193 3 enough enough JJ 40436 8193 4 of of IN 40436 8193 5 the the DT 40436 8193 6 records record NNS 40436 8193 7 of of IN 40436 8193 8 anarchy anarchy NN 40436 8193 9 , , , 40436 8193 10 to to TO 40436 8193 11 see see VB 40436 8193 12 how how WRB 40436 8193 13 difficult difficult JJ 40436 8193 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8193 15 is be VBZ 40436 8193 16 for for IN 40436 8193 17 human human JJ 40436 8193 18 nature nature NN 40436 8193 19 to to TO 40436 8193 20 comply comply VB 40436 8193 21 in in IN 40436 8193 22 full full JJ 40436 8193 23 with with IN 40436 8193 24 the the DT 40436 8193 25 social social JJ 40436 8193 26 conditions condition NNS 40436 8193 27 of of IN 40436 8193 28 security security NN 40436 8193 29 ; ; : 40436 8193 30 but but CC 40436 8193 31 if if IN 40436 8193 32 this this DT 40436 8193 33 were be VBD 40436 8193 34 not not RB 40436 8193 35 complied comply VBN 40436 8193 36 with with IN 40436 8193 37 at at RB 40436 8193 38 all all RB 40436 8193 39 , , , 40436 8193 40 the the DT 40436 8193 41 result result NN 40436 8193 42 would would MD 40436 8193 43 be be VB 40436 8193 44 mutual mutual JJ 40436 8193 45 and and CC 40436 8193 46 swift swift JJ 40436 8193 47 destruction destruction NN 40436 8193 48 . . . 40436 8194 1 . . . 40436 8195 1 . . . 40436 8196 1 . . . 40436 8197 1 In in IN 40436 8197 2 the the DT 40436 8197 3 second second JJ 40436 8197 4 place place NN 40436 8197 5 , , , 40436 8197 6 mankind mankind NN 40436 8197 7 have have VBP 40436 8197 8 been be VBN 40436 8197 9 singularly singularly RB 40436 8197 10 unanimous unanimous JJ 40436 8197 11 in in IN 40436 8197 12 the the DT 40436 8197 13 practice practice NN 40436 8197 14 of of IN 40436 8197 15 imposing impose VBG 40436 8197 16 upon upon IN 40436 8197 17 individual individual JJ 40436 8197 18 members member NNS 40436 8197 19 of of IN 40436 8197 20 societies society NNS 40436 8197 21 some some DT 40436 8197 22 observances observance NNS 40436 8197 23 or or CC 40436 8197 24 restraints restraint NNS 40436 8197 25 of of IN 40436 8197 26 purely purely RB 40436 8197 27 _ _ NNP 40436 8197 28 sentimental sentimental NN 40436 8197 29 _ _ NNP 40436 8197 30 origin origin NN 40436 8197 31 , , , 40436 8197 32 having have VBG 40436 8197 33 no no DT 40436 8197 34 reference reference NN 40436 8197 35 , , , 40436 8197 36 direct direct JJ 40436 8197 37 or or CC 40436 8197 38 indirect indirect JJ 40436 8197 39 , , , 40436 8197 40 to to IN 40436 8197 41 the the DT 40436 8197 42 maintenance maintenance NN 40436 8197 43 of of IN 40436 8197 44 the the DT 40436 8197 45 social social JJ 40436 8197 46 tie tie NN 40436 8197 47 , , , 40436 8197 48 with with IN 40436 8197 49 all all PDT 40436 8197 50 the the DT 40436 8197 51 safeguards safeguard NNS 40436 8197 52 implied imply VBN 40436 8197 53 in in IN 40436 8197 54 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8197 55 . . . 40436 8198 1 Certain certain JJ 40436 8198 2 maxims maxim NNS 40436 8198 3 founded found VBN 40436 8198 4 in in IN 40436 8198 5 taste taste NN 40436 8198 6 , , , 40436 8198 7 liking liking NN 40436 8198 8 , , , 40436 8198 9 aversion aversion NN 40436 8198 10 , , , 40436 8198 11 or or CC 40436 8198 12 fancy fancy JJ 40436 8198 13 , , , 40436 8198 14 have have VBP 40436 8198 15 , , , 40436 8198 16 in in IN 40436 8198 17 every every DT 40436 8198 18 community community NN 40436 8198 19 known know VBN 40436 8198 20 to to IN 40436 8198 21 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8198 22 , , , 40436 8198 23 been be VBN 40436 8198 24 raised raise VBN 40436 8198 25 to to IN 40436 8198 26 the the DT 40436 8198 27 dignity dignity NN 40436 8198 28 of of IN 40436 8198 29 authoritative authoritative JJ 40436 8198 30 morality morality NN 40436 8198 31 ; ; : 40436 8198 32 being be VBG 40436 8198 33 rendered render VBN 40436 8198 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8198 35 so so RB 40436 8198 36 to to TO 40436 8198 37 speak speak VB 40436 8198 38 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8198 39 ' ' POS 40436 8198 40 terms term NNS 40436 8198 41 of of IN 40436 8198 42 communion communion NN 40436 8198 43 , , , 40436 8198 44 ' ' '' 40436 8198 45 and and CC 40436 8198 46 have have VBP 40436 8198 47 been be VBN 40436 8198 48 enforced enforce VBN 40436 8198 49 by by IN 40436 8198 50 punishment punishment NN 40436 8198 51 . . . 40436 8199 1 . . . 40436 8200 1 . . . 40436 8201 1 . . . 40436 8202 1 In in IN 40436 8202 2 the the DT 40436 8202 3 rules rule NNS 40436 8202 4 , , , 40436 8202 5 founded found VBN 40436 8202 6 on on IN 40436 8202 7 men man NNS 40436 8202 8 's 's POS 40436 8202 9 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8202 10 , , , 40436 8202 11 likings liking NNS 40436 8202 12 , , , 40436 8202 13 aversions aversion NNS 40436 8202 14 , , , 40436 8202 15 and and CC 40436 8202 16 antipathies antipathy NNS 40436 8202 17 , , , 40436 8202 18 there there EX 40436 8202 19 is be VBZ 40436 8202 20 nothing nothing NN 40436 8202 21 common common JJ 40436 8202 22 but but CC 40436 8202 23 the the DT 40436 8202 24 fact fact NN 40436 8202 25 that that IN 40436 8202 26 some some DT 40436 8202 27 one one CD 40436 8202 28 or or CC 40436 8202 29 other other JJ 40436 8202 30 of of IN 40436 8202 31 these these DT 40436 8202 32 are be VBP 40436 8202 33 carried carry VBN 40436 8202 34 to to IN 40436 8202 35 the the DT 40436 8202 36 length length NN 40436 8202 37 of of IN 40436 8202 38 public public JJ 40436 8202 39 requirement requirement NN 40436 8202 40 , , , 40436 8202 41 and and CC 40436 8202 42 mixed mix VBN 40436 8202 43 up up RP 40436 8202 44 in in IN 40436 8202 45 one one CD 40436 8202 46 code code NN 40436 8202 47 with with IN 40436 8202 48 the the DT 40436 8202 49 imperative imperative JJ 40436 8202 50 duties duty NNS 40436 8202 51 that that WDT 40436 8202 52 hold hold VBP 40436 8202 53 society society NN 40436 8202 54 together together RB 40436 8202 55 . . . 40436 8202 56 " " '' 40436 8203 1 The the DT 40436 8203 2 postulate postulate NN 40436 8203 3 of of IN 40436 8203 4 the the DT 40436 8203 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8203 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8203 7 -- -- : 40436 8203 8 that that IN 40436 8203 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8203 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8203 11 : : : 40436 8203 12 di di NNP 40436 8203 13 / / SYM 40436 8203 14 kê kê VBP 40436 8203 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8203 16 and and CC 40436 8203 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8203 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8203 19 : : : 40436 8203 20 ai)dô\s ai)dô\s NNP 40436 8203 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8203 22 must must MD 40436 8203 23 be be VB 40436 8203 24 felt feel VBN 40436 8203 25 to to IN 40436 8203 26 a a DT 40436 8203 27 certain certain JJ 40436 8203 28 extent extent NN 40436 8203 29 in in IN 40436 8203 30 each each DT 40436 8203 31 man man NN 40436 8203 32 's 's POS 40436 8203 33 bosom bosom NN 40436 8203 34 , , , 40436 8203 35 as as IN 40436 8203 36 a a DT 40436 8203 37 condition condition NN 40436 8203 38 to to IN 40436 8203 39 the the DT 40436 8203 40 very very JJ 40436 8203 41 existence existence NN 40436 8203 42 of of IN 40436 8203 43 society society NN 40436 8203 44 -- -- : 40436 8203 45 agrees agree VBZ 40436 8203 46 with with IN 40436 8203 47 the the DT 40436 8203 48 first first JJ 40436 8203 49 of of IN 40436 8203 50 the the DT 40436 8203 51 two two CD 40436 8203 52 elements element NNS 40436 8203 53 here here RB 40436 8203 54 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 8203 55 by by IN 40436 8203 56 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 8203 57 Bain Bain NNP 40436 8203 58 , , , 40436 8203 59 and and CC 40436 8203 60 does do VBZ 40436 8203 61 not not RB 40436 8203 62 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 8203 63 go go VB 40436 8203 64 beyond beyond IN 40436 8203 65 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8203 66 . . . 40436 8204 1 But but CC 40436 8204 2 the the DT 40436 8204 3 unsystematic unsystematic JJ 40436 8204 4 teaching teaching NN 40436 8204 5 and and CC 40436 8204 6 universal universal JJ 40436 8204 7 propagandism propagandism NN 40436 8204 8 , , , 40436 8204 9 which which WDT 40436 8204 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8204 11 describes describe VBZ 40436 8204 12 as as IN 40436 8204 13 the the DT 40436 8204 14 agency agency NN 40436 8204 15 whereby whereby WRB 40436 8204 16 virtue virtue NNP 40436 8204 17 is be VBZ 40436 8204 18 communicated communicate VBN 40436 8204 19 , , , 40436 8204 20 applies apply VBZ 40436 8204 21 alike alike RB 40436 8204 22 to to IN 40436 8204 23 both both DT 40436 8204 24 the the DT 40436 8204 25 two two CD 40436 8204 26 elements element NNS 40436 8204 27 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 8204 28 by by IN 40436 8204 29 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 8204 30 Bain Bain NNP 40436 8204 31 : : : 40436 8204 32 to to IN 40436 8204 33 the the DT 40436 8204 34 factitious factitious JJ 40436 8204 35 exigencies exigency NNS 40436 8204 36 of of IN 40436 8204 37 King King NNP 40436 8204 38 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 8204 39 , , , 40436 8204 40 as as RB 40436 8204 41 well well RB 40436 8204 42 as as IN 40436 8204 43 to to IN 40436 8204 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8204 45 tutelary tutelary JJ 40436 8204 46 control control NN 40436 8204 47 . . . 40436 8205 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8205 2 is be VBZ 40436 8205 3 this this DT 40436 8205 4 mixed mixed JJ 40436 8205 5 mass mass NN 40436 8205 6 that that IN 40436 8205 7 the the DT 40436 8205 8 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 8205 9 analysis analysis NN 40436 8205 10 is be VBZ 40436 8205 11 brought bring VBN 40436 8205 12 to to TO 40436 8205 13 examine examine VB 40436 8205 14 . . . 40436 8205 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8206 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8206 2 Side side NN 40436 8206 3 - - HYPH 40436 8206 4 note note NN 40436 8206 5 : : : 40436 8206 6 The the DT 40436 8206 7 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 8206 8 End End NNP 40436 8206 9 , , , 40436 8206 10 as as IN 40436 8206 11 implied imply VBN 40436 8206 12 in in IN 40436 8206 13 the the DT 40436 8206 14 discourse discourse NN 40436 8206 15 of of IN 40436 8206 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8206 17 , , , 40436 8206 18 involves involve VBZ 40436 8206 19 a a DT 40436 8206 20 direct direct JJ 40436 8206 21 regard regard NN 40436 8206 22 to to IN 40436 8206 23 the the DT 40436 8206 24 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8206 25 and and CC 40436 8206 26 pains pain NNS 40436 8206 27 of of IN 40436 8206 28 other other JJ 40436 8206 29 persons person NNS 40436 8206 30 besides besides IN 40436 8206 31 the the DT 40436 8206 32 agent agent NN 40436 8206 33 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8206 34 . . . 40436 8206 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8207 1 If if IN 40436 8207 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8207 3 thus thus RB 40436 8207 4 compare compare VBP 40436 8207 5 the the DT 40436 8207 6 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 8207 7 End End NNP 40436 8207 8 , , , 40436 8207 9 as as IN 40436 8207 10 implied imply VBN 40436 8207 11 , , , 40436 8207 12 though though IN 40436 8207 13 not not RB 40436 8207 14 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 8207 15 laid lay VBN 40436 8207 16 down down RP 40436 8207 17 , , , 40436 8207 18 by by IN 40436 8207 19 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8207 20 in in IN 40436 8207 21 the the DT 40436 8207 22 earlier early JJR 40436 8207 23 part part NN 40436 8207 24 of of IN 40436 8207 25 the the DT 40436 8207 26 dialogue,--and dialogue,--and XX 40436 8207 27 as as RB 40436 8207 28 laid lay VBN 40436 8207 29 down down RP 40436 8207 30 by by IN 40436 8207 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8207 32 in in IN 40436 8207 33 the the DT 40436 8207 34 later later JJ 40436 8207 35 part part NN 40436 8207 36 -- -- : 40436 8207 37 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8207 38 shall shall MD 40436 8207 39 see see VB 40436 8207 40 that that IN 40436 8207 41 while while IN 40436 8207 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8207 43 restricts restrict VBZ 40436 8207 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8207 45 to to IN 40436 8207 46 a a DT 40436 8207 47 true true JJ 40436 8207 48 comparative comparative JJ 40436 8207 49 estimate estimate NN 40436 8207 50 of of IN 40436 8207 51 the the DT 40436 8207 52 pains pain NNS 40436 8207 53 and and CC 40436 8207 54 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8207 55 of of IN 40436 8207 56 the the DT 40436 8207 57 agent agent NN 40436 8207 58 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8207 59 , , , 40436 8207 60 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8207 61 enlarges enlarge VBZ 40436 8207 62 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8207 63 so so IN 40436 8207 64 as as IN 40436 8207 65 to to TO 40436 8207 66 include include VB 40436 8207 67 a a DT 40436 8207 68 direct direct JJ 40436 8207 69 reference reference NN 40436 8207 70 to to IN 40436 8207 71 those those DT 40436 8207 72 of of IN 40436 8207 73 others other NNS 40436 8207 74 also also RB 40436 8207 75 , , , 40436 8207 76 coupled couple VBN 40436 8207 77 with with IN 40436 8207 78 an an DT 40436 8207 79 expectation expectation NN 40436 8207 80 of of IN 40436 8207 81 the the DT 40436 8207 82 like like JJ 40436 8207 83 reference reference NN 40436 8207 84 on on IN 40436 8207 85 the the DT 40436 8207 86 part part NN 40436 8207 87 of of IN 40436 8207 88 others other NNS 40436 8207 89 . . . 40436 8208 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8208 2 149 149 CD 40436 8208 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8208 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8208 5 is be VBZ 40436 8208 6 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 8208 7 with with IN 40436 8208 8 requiring require VBG 40436 8208 9 from from IN 40436 8208 10 each each DT 40436 8208 11 person person NN 40436 8208 12 calculating calculate VBG 40436 8208 13 prudence prudence NN 40436 8208 14 for for IN 40436 8208 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8208 16 own own JJ 40436 8208 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8208 18 and and CC 40436 8208 19 pains pain NNS 40436 8208 20 : : : 40436 8208 21 while while IN 40436 8208 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8208 23 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 8208 24 that that IN 40436 8208 25 after after IN 40436 8208 26 this this DT 40436 8208 27 attribute attribute NN 40436 8208 28 had have VBD 40436 8208 29 been be VBN 40436 8208 30 obtained obtain VBN 40436 8208 31 by by IN 40436 8208 32 man man NN 40436 8208 33 , , , 40436 8208 34 and and CC 40436 8208 35 individual individual JJ 40436 8208 36 wants want VBZ 40436 8208 37 supplied supply VBN 40436 8208 38 , , , 40436 8208 39 still still RB 40436 8208 40 there there EX 40436 8208 41 was be VBD 40436 8208 42 a a DT 40436 8208 43 farther farther JJ 40436 8208 44 element element NN 40436 8208 45 necessary necessary JJ 40436 8208 46 in in IN 40436 8208 47 the the DT 40436 8208 48 calculation calculation NN 40436 8208 49 -- -- : 40436 8208 50 the the DT 40436 8208 51 social social JJ 40436 8208 52 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8208 53 or or CC 40436 8208 54 reciprocity reciprocity NN 40436 8208 55 of of IN 40436 8208 56 regard regard NN 40436 8208 57 implanted implant VBN 40436 8208 58 in in IN 40436 8208 59 every every DT 40436 8208 60 one one NN 40436 8208 61 's 's POS 40436 8208 62 bosom bosom NN 40436 8208 63 : : : 40436 8208 64 without without IN 40436 8208 65 this this DT 40436 8208 66 the the DT 40436 8208 67 human human JJ 40436 8208 68 race race NN 40436 8208 69 would would MD 40436 8208 70 have have VB 40436 8208 71 perished perish VBN 40436 8208 72 . . . 40436 8209 1 Prudence prudence NN 40436 8209 2 and and CC 40436 8209 3 skill skill NN 40436 8209 4 will will MD 40436 8209 5 suffice suffice VB 40436 8209 6 for for IN 40436 8209 7 an an DT 40436 8209 8 isolated isolated JJ 40436 8209 9 existence existence NN 40436 8209 10 ; ; : 40436 8209 11 but but CC 40436 8209 12 if if IN 40436 8209 13 men man NNS 40436 8209 14 are be VBP 40436 8209 15 to to TO 40436 8209 16 live live VB 40436 8209 17 and and CC 40436 8209 18 act act VB 40436 8209 19 in in IN 40436 8209 20 social social JJ 40436 8209 21 communion communion NN 40436 8209 22 , , , 40436 8209 23 the the DT 40436 8209 24 services service NNS 40436 8209 25 as as RB 40436 8209 26 well well RB 40436 8209 27 as as IN 40436 8209 28 the the DT 40436 8209 29 requirements requirement NNS 40436 8209 30 of of IN 40436 8209 31 each each DT 40436 8209 32 man man NN 40436 8209 33 must must MD 40436 8209 34 be be VB 40436 8209 35 shaped shape VBN 40436 8209 36 , , , 40436 8209 37 in in IN 40436 8209 38 a a DT 40436 8209 39 certain certain JJ 40436 8209 40 measure measure NN 40436 8209 41 , , , 40436 8209 42 with with IN 40436 8209 43 a a DT 40436 8209 44 direct direct JJ 40436 8209 45 view view NN 40436 8209 46 to to IN 40436 8209 47 the the DT 40436 8209 48 security security NN 40436 8209 49 of of IN 40436 8209 50 others other NNS 40436 8209 51 as as RB 40436 8209 52 well well RB 40436 8209 53 as as IN 40436 8209 54 to to IN 40436 8209 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8209 56 own own JJ 40436 8209 57 . . . 40436 8210 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8210 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8210 3 149 149 CD 40436 8210 4 : : : 40436 8210 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8210 6 , , , 40436 8210 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8210 8 . . . 40436 8211 1 pp pp NNP 40436 8211 2 . . . 40436 8212 1 321 321 CD 40436 8212 2 - - SYM 40436 8212 3 322 322 CD 40436 8212 4 . . . 40436 8212 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8213 1 In in IN 40436 8213 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8213 3 judgment judgment NN 40436 8213 4 , , , 40436 8213 5 the the DT 40436 8213 6 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 8213 7 End End NNP 40436 8213 8 , , , 40436 8213 9 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 8213 10 self self NN 40436 8213 11 - - HYPH 40436 8213 12 regarding regard VBG 40436 8213 13 , , , 40436 8213 14 here here RB 40436 8213 15 laid lay VBN 40436 8213 16 down down RP 40436 8213 17 by by IN 40436 8213 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8213 19 , , , 40436 8213 20 is be VBZ 40436 8213 21 too too RB 40436 8213 22 narrow narrow JJ 40436 8213 23 . . . 40436 8214 1 And and CC 40436 8214 2 if if IN 40436 8214 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8214 4 turn turn VBP 40436 8214 5 to to IN 40436 8214 6 other other JJ 40436 8214 7 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8214 8 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8214 9 , , , 40436 8214 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8214 11 shall shall MD 40436 8214 12 find find VB 40436 8214 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8214 14 still still RB 40436 8214 15 represented represent VBN 40436 8214 16 as as IN 40436 8214 17 proclaiming proclaim VBG 40436 8214 18 a a DT 40436 8214 19 self self NN 40436 8214 20 - - HYPH 40436 8214 21 regarding regard VBG 40436 8214 22 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 8214 23 End End NNP 40436 8214 24 , , , 40436 8214 25 though though IN 40436 8214 26 not not RB 40436 8214 27 the the DT 40436 8214 28 same same JJ 40436 8214 29 as as IN 40436 8214 30 what what WP 40436 8214 31 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8214 32 read read VBP 40436 8214 33 in in IN 40436 8214 34 the the DT 40436 8214 35 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8214 36 . . . 40436 8215 1 In in IN 40436 8215 2 the the DT 40436 8215 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8215 4 , , , 40436 8215 5 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8215 6 , , , 40436 8215 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 8215 8 , , , 40436 8215 9 & & CC 40436 8215 10 c. c. NNP 40436 8215 11 , , , 40436 8215 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8215 13 shall shall MD 40436 8215 14 find find VB 40436 8215 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8215 16 discountenancing discountenance VBG 40436 8215 17 the the DT 40436 8215 18 calculation calculation NN 40436 8215 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8215 20 recommended recommend VBN 40436 8215 21 in in IN 40436 8215 22 the the DT 40436 8215 23 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8215 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8215 25 of of IN 40436 8215 26 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8215 27 and and CC 40436 8215 28 pains pain NNS 40436 8215 29 against against IN 40436 8215 30 each each DT 40436 8215 31 other other JJ 40436 8215 32 , , , 40436 8215 33 as as IN 40436 8215 34 greater great JJR 40436 8215 35 , , , 40436 8215 36 more more RBR 40436 8215 37 certain certain JJ 40436 8215 38 , , , 40436 8215 39 durable durable JJ 40436 8215 40 , , , 40436 8215 41 & & CC 40436 8215 42 c. c. NNP 40436 8215 43 , , , 40436 8215 44 and and CC 40436 8215 45 insisting insist VBG 40436 8215 46 that that IN 40436 8215 47 all all DT 40436 8215 48 shall shall MD 40436 8215 49 be be VB 40436 8215 50 estimated estimate VBN 40436 8215 51 according accord VBG 40436 8215 52 as as IN 40436 8215 53 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8215 54 bear bear VBP 40436 8215 55 on on IN 40436 8215 56 the the DT 40436 8215 57 general general JJ 40436 8215 58 condition condition NN 40436 8215 59 or or CC 40436 8215 60 health health NN 40436 8215 61 of of IN 40436 8215 62 the the DT 40436 8215 63 mind mind NN 40436 8215 64 , , , 40436 8215 65 which which WDT 40436 8215 66 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8215 67 assimilates assimilate VBZ 40436 8215 68 to to IN 40436 8215 69 the the DT 40436 8215 70 general general JJ 40436 8215 71 condition condition NN 40436 8215 72 or or CC 40436 8215 73 health health NN 40436 8215 74 of of IN 40436 8215 75 the the DT 40436 8215 76 body body NN 40436 8215 77 . . . 40436 8216 1 The the DT 40436 8216 2 health health NN 40436 8216 3 of of IN 40436 8216 4 the the DT 40436 8216 5 body body NN 40436 8216 6 , , , 40436 8216 7 considered consider VBN 40436 8216 8 as as IN 40436 8216 9 an an DT 40436 8216 10 End end NN 40436 8216 11 to to TO 40436 8216 12 be be VB 40436 8216 13 pursued pursue VBN 40436 8216 14 , , , 40436 8216 15 is be VBZ 40436 8216 16 essentially essentially RB 40436 8216 17 self self NN 40436 8216 18 - - HYPH 40436 8216 19 regarding regard VBG 40436 8216 20 : : : 40436 8216 21 so so RB 40436 8216 22 also also RB 40436 8216 23 is be VBZ 40436 8216 24 the the DT 40436 8216 25 health health NN 40436 8216 26 of of IN 40436 8216 27 the the DT 40436 8216 28 mind mind NN 40436 8216 29 . . . 40436 8217 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8217 2 shall shall MD 40436 8217 3 touch touch VB 40436 8217 4 upon upon IN 40436 8217 5 this this DT 40436 8217 6 farther farther RB 40436 8217 7 when when WRB 40436 8217 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8217 9 consider consider VBP 40436 8217 10 the the DT 40436 8217 11 above above RB 40436 8217 12 - - HYPH 40436 8217 13 mentioned mention VBN 40436 8217 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8217 15 : : : 40436 8217 16 at at IN 40436 8217 17 present present NN 40436 8217 18 , , , 40436 8217 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8217 20 only only RB 40436 8217 21 remark remark VBP 40436 8217 22 that that IN 40436 8217 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8217 24 agree agree VBP 40436 8217 25 with with IN 40436 8217 26 the the DT 40436 8217 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8217 28 of of IN 40436 8217 29 the the DT 40436 8217 30 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8217 31 in in IN 40436 8217 32 assuming assume VBG 40436 8217 33 a a DT 40436 8217 34 self self NN 40436 8217 35 - - HYPH 40436 8217 36 regarding regard VBG 40436 8217 37 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 8217 38 End End NNP 40436 8217 39 , , , 40436 8217 40 though though IN 40436 8217 41 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8217 42 do do VBP 40436 8217 43 not not RB 40436 8217 44 agree agree VB 40436 8217 45 with with IN 40436 8217 46 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8217 47 in in IN 40436 8217 48 describing describe VBG 40436 8217 49 what what WP 40436 8217 50 that that DT 40436 8217 51 End end NN 40436 8217 52 should should MD 40436 8217 53 be be VB 40436 8217 54 . . . 40436 8218 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8218 2 Side side NN 40436 8218 3 - - HYPH 40436 8218 4 note note NN 40436 8218 5 : : : 40436 8218 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8218 7 's 's POS 40436 8218 8 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8218 9 in in IN 40436 8218 10 the the DT 40436 8218 11 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8218 12 is be VBZ 40436 8218 13 not not RB 40436 8218 14 clear clear JJ 40436 8218 15 or or CC 40436 8218 16 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 8218 17 , , , 40436 8218 18 especially especially RB 40436 8218 19 about about IN 40436 8218 20 courage courage NN 40436 8218 21 . . . 40436 8218 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8219 1 The the DT 40436 8219 2 application application NN 40436 8219 3 which which WDT 40436 8219 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8219 5 makes make VBZ 40436 8219 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8219 7 in in IN 40436 8219 8 the the DT 40436 8219 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8219 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8219 11 of of IN 40436 8219 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8219 13 own own JJ 40436 8219 14 assumed assume VBN 40436 8219 15 Ethical Ethical NNP 40436 8219 16 End End NNP 40436 8219 17 to to IN 40436 8219 18 the the DT 40436 8219 19 explanation explanation NN 40436 8219 20 of of IN 40436 8219 21 courage courage NN 40436 8219 22 , , , 40436 8219 23 is be VBZ 40436 8219 24 certainly certainly RB 40436 8219 25 confused confused JJ 40436 8219 26 and and CC 40436 8219 27 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 8219 28 . . . 40436 8220 1 And and CC 40436 8220 2 indeed indeed RB 40436 8220 3 , , , 40436 8220 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8220 5 may may MD 40436 8220 6 farther farther RB 40436 8220 7 remark remark VB 40436 8220 8 that that IN 40436 8220 9 the the DT 40436 8220 10 general general JJ 40436 8220 11 result result NN 40436 8220 12 at at IN 40436 8220 13 which which WDT 40436 8220 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8220 15 seems seem VBZ 40436 8220 16 to to TO 40436 8220 17 be be VB 40436 8220 18 aiming aim VBG 40436 8220 19 in in IN 40436 8220 20 this this DT 40436 8220 21 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8220 22 , , , 40436 8220 23 viz viz NN 40436 8220 24 . . . 40436 8221 1 : : : 40436 8221 2 That that IN 40436 8221 3 all all PDT 40436 8221 4 the the DT 40436 8221 5 different different JJ 40436 8221 6 virtues virtue NNS 40436 8221 7 are be VBP 40436 8221 8 at at IN 40436 8221 9 the the DT 40436 8221 10 bottom bottom JJ 40436 8221 11 one one CD 40436 8221 12 and and CC 40436 8221 13 the the DT 40436 8221 14 same same JJ 40436 8221 15 , , , 40436 8221 16 and and CC 40436 8221 17 that that IN 40436 8221 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8221 19 who who WP 40436 8221 20 possesses possess VBZ 40436 8221 21 one one CD 40436 8221 22 of of IN 40436 8221 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8221 24 must must MD 40436 8221 25 also also RB 40436 8221 26 possess possess VB 40436 8221 27 the the DT 40436 8221 28 remainder remainder NN 40436 8221 29 -- -- : 40436 8221 30 cannot cannot NN 40436 8221 31 be be VB 40436 8221 32 made make VBN 40436 8221 33 out out RP 40436 8221 34 even even RB 40436 8221 35 upon upon IN 40436 8221 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8221 37 own own JJ 40436 8221 38 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 8221 39 . . . 40436 8222 1 Though though IN 40436 8222 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8222 3 be be VB 40436 8222 4 true true JJ 40436 8222 5 that that IN 40436 8222 6 all all PDT 40436 8222 7 the the DT 40436 8222 8 virtues virtue NNS 40436 8222 9 depend depend VBP 40436 8222 10 upon upon IN 40436 8222 11 correct correct JJ 40436 8222 12 calculation calculation NN 40436 8222 13 , , , 40436 8222 14 yet yet CC 40436 8222 15 as as IN 40436 8222 16 each each DT 40436 8222 17 of of IN 40436 8222 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8222 19 applies apply VBZ 40436 8222 20 to to IN 40436 8222 21 a a DT 40436 8222 22 different different JJ 40436 8222 23 set set NN 40436 8222 24 of of IN 40436 8222 25 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 8222 26 and and CC 40436 8222 27 different different JJ 40436 8222 28 disturbing disturbing JJ 40436 8222 29 and and CC 40436 8222 30 misleading misleading JJ 40436 8222 31 causes cause NNS 40436 8222 32 , , , 40436 8222 33 the the DT 40436 8222 34 same same JJ 40436 8222 35 man man NN 40436 8222 36 who who WP 40436 8222 37 calculates calculate VBZ 40436 8222 38 well well RB 40436 8222 39 under under IN 40436 8222 40 one one CD 40436 8222 41 set set NN 40436 8222 42 of of IN 40436 8222 43 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 8222 44 , , , 40436 8222 45 may may MD 40436 8222 46 calculate calculate VB 40436 8222 47 badly badly RB 40436 8222 48 under under IN 40436 8222 49 others other NNS 40436 8222 50 . . . 40436 8223 1 The the DT 40436 8223 2 position position NN 40436 8223 3 laid lay VBD 40436 8223 4 down down RP 40436 8223 5 by by IN 40436 8223 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8223 7 , , , 40436 8223 8 that that IN 40436 8223 9 men man NNS 40436 8223 10 are be VBP 40436 8223 11 often often RB 40436 8223 12 courageous courageous JJ 40436 8223 13 but but CC 40436 8223 14 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8223 15 -- -- : 40436 8223 16 just just RB 40436 8223 17 , , , 40436 8223 18 but but CC 40436 8223 19 not not RB 40436 8223 20 wise wise JJ 40436 8223 21 -- -- : 40436 8223 22 is be VBZ 40436 8223 23 noway noway RB 40436 8223 24 refuted refute VBN 40436 8223 25 by by IN 40436 8223 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8223 27 . . . 40436 8224 1 Nor nor CC 40436 8224 2 is be VBZ 40436 8224 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8224 4 even even RB 40436 8224 5 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 8224 6 with with IN 40436 8224 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8224 8 's 's POS 40436 8224 9 own own JJ 40436 8224 10 theory theory NN 40436 8224 11 , , , 40436 8224 12 though though IN 40436 8224 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8224 14 seems seem VBZ 40436 8224 15 to to TO 40436 8224 16 think think VB 40436 8224 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8224 18 so so RB 40436 8224 19 . . . 40436 8225 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8225 2 Side side NN 40436 8225 3 - - HYPH 40436 8225 4 note note NN 40436 8225 5 : : : 40436 8225 6 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 40436 8225 7 of of IN 40436 8225 8 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 8225 9 and and CC 40436 8225 10 other other JJ 40436 8225 11 critics critic NNS 40436 8225 12 is be VBZ 40436 8225 13 not not RB 40436 8225 14 correct correct JJ 40436 8225 15 . . . 40436 8226 1 That that IN 40436 8226 2 the the DT 40436 8226 3 analysis analysis NN 40436 8226 4 here here RB 40436 8226 5 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 8226 6 to to IN 40436 8226 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8226 8 is be VBZ 40436 8226 9 not not RB 40436 8226 10 intended intend VBN 40436 8226 11 by by IN 40436 8226 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8226 13 as as IN 40436 8226 14 serious serious JJ 40436 8226 15 , , , 40436 8226 16 but but CC 40436 8226 17 as as IN 40436 8226 18 a a DT 40436 8226 19 mockery mockery NN 40436 8226 20 of of IN 40436 8226 21 the the DT 40436 8226 22 sophists sophist NNS 40436 8226 23 . . . 40436 8226 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8227 1 Some some DT 40436 8227 2 of of IN 40436 8227 3 the the DT 40436 8227 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8227 5 commentators commentator NNS 40436 8227 6 maintain,[150 maintain,[150 NNP 40436 8227 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8227 8 that that IN 40436 8227 9 the the DT 40436 8227 10 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8227 11 here here RB 40436 8227 12 explicitly explicitly RB 40436 8227 13 laid lay VBD 40436 8227 14 down down RP 40436 8227 15 and and CC 40436 8227 16 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 8227 17 by by IN 40436 8227 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8227 19 , , , 40436 8227 20 _ _ NNP 40436 8227 21 viz viz NN 40436 8227 22 . . . 40436 8227 23 _ _ IN 40436 8227 24 : : : 40436 8227 25 the the DT 40436 8227 26 essential essential JJ 40436 8227 27 identity identity NN 40436 8227 28 of of IN 40436 8227 29 the the DT 40436 8227 30 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 8227 31 with with IN 40436 8227 32 the the DT 40436 8227 33 good good JJ 40436 8227 34 , , , 40436 8227 35 of of IN 40436 8227 36 the the DT 40436 8227 37 painful painful JJ 40436 8227 38 with with IN 40436 8227 39 the the DT 40436 8227 40 evil evil NN 40436 8227 41 -- -- : 40436 8227 42 is be VBZ 40436 8227 43 to to TO 40436 8227 44 be be VB 40436 8227 45 regarded regard VBN 40436 8227 46 as as IN 40436 8227 47 not not RB 40436 8227 48 serious serious JJ 40436 8227 49 , , , 40436 8227 50 but but CC 40436 8227 51 as as IN 40436 8227 52 taken take VBN 40436 8227 53 up up RP 40436 8227 54 in in IN 40436 8227 55 jest jest NN 40436 8227 56 for for IN 40436 8227 57 the the DT 40436 8227 58 purpose purpose NN 40436 8227 59 of of IN 40436 8227 60 mocking mock VBG 40436 8227 61 and and CC 40436 8227 62 humiliating humiliating JJ 40436 8227 63 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8227 64 . . . 40436 8228 1 Such such PDT 40436 8228 2 an an DT 40436 8228 3 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 8228 4 appears appear VBZ 40436 8228 5 to to IN 40436 8228 6 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8228 7 untenable untenable JJ 40436 8228 8 ; ; , 40436 8228 9 contradicted contradict VBN 40436 8228 10 by by IN 40436 8228 11 the the DT 40436 8228 12 whole whole JJ 40436 8228 13 tenor tenor NN 40436 8228 14 of of IN 40436 8228 15 the the DT 40436 8228 16 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8228 17 . . . 40436 8229 1 Throughout throughout IN 40436 8229 2 all all PDT 40436 8229 3 the the DT 40436 8229 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8229 5 compositions composition NNS 40436 8229 6 , , , 40436 8229 7 there there EX 40436 8229 8 is be VBZ 40436 8229 9 nowhere nowhere RB 40436 8229 10 to to TO 40436 8229 11 be be VB 40436 8229 12 found find VBN 40436 8229 13 any any DT 40436 8229 14 train train NN 40436 8229 15 of of IN 40436 8229 16 argument argument NN 40436 8229 17 more more RBR 40436 8229 18 direct direct JJ 40436 8229 19 , , , 40436 8229 20 more more RBR 40436 8229 21 serious serious JJ 40436 8229 22 , , , 40436 8229 23 and and CC 40436 8229 24 more more RBR 40436 8229 25 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 8229 26 , , , 40436 8229 27 than than IN 40436 8229 28 that that DT 40436 8229 29 by by IN 40436 8229 30 which which WDT 40436 8229 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8229 32 here here RB 40436 8229 33 proves prove VBZ 40436 8229 34 the the DT 40436 8229 35 identity identity NN 40436 8229 36 of of IN 40436 8229 37 good good JJ 40436 8229 38 with with IN 40436 8229 39 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8229 40 , , , 40436 8229 41 of of IN 40436 8229 42 pain pain NN 40436 8229 43 with with IN 40436 8229 44 evil evil NN 40436 8229 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8229 46 p. p. NN 40436 8229 47 351 351 CD 40436 8229 48 to to TO 40436 8229 49 end end VB 40436 8229 50 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8229 51 . . . 40436 8230 1 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8230 2 begins begin VBZ 40436 8230 3 by by IN 40436 8230 4 denying deny VBG 40436 8230 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8230 6 , , , 40436 8230 7 and and CC 40436 8230 8 is be VBZ 40436 8230 9 only only RB 40436 8230 10 compelled compel VBN 40436 8230 11 to to TO 40436 8230 12 accept accept VB 40436 8230 13 the the DT 40436 8230 14 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 8230 15 against against IN 40436 8230 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8230 17 own own JJ 40436 8230 18 will will NN 40436 8230 19 , , , 40436 8230 20 by by IN 40436 8230 21 the the DT 40436 8230 22 series series NN 40436 8230 23 of of IN 40436 8230 24 questions question NNS 40436 8230 25 which which WDT 40436 8230 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8230 27 can can MD 40436 8230 28 not not RB 40436 8230 29 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 8230 30 answer answer VB 40436 8230 31 . . . 40436 8231 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8231 2 151 151 CD 40436 8231 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8231 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8231 5 admits admit VBZ 40436 8231 6 that that IN 40436 8231 7 the the DT 40436 8231 8 bulk bulk NN 40436 8231 9 of of IN 40436 8231 10 mankind mankind NN 40436 8231 11 are be VBP 40436 8231 12 also also RB 40436 8231 13 opposed opposed JJ 40436 8231 14 to to IN 40436 8231 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8231 16 : : : 40436 8231 17 but but CC 40436 8231 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8231 19 establishes establish VBZ 40436 8231 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8231 21 with with IN 40436 8231 22 an an DT 40436 8231 23 ingenuity ingenuity NN 40436 8231 24 which which WDT 40436 8231 25 is be VBZ 40436 8231 26 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 8231 27 to to TO 40436 8231 28 be be VB 40436 8231 29 triumphant triumphant JJ 40436 8231 30 by by IN 40436 8231 31 all all PDT 40436 8231 32 the the DT 40436 8231 33 hearers hearer NNS 40436 8231 34 around around RB 40436 8231 35 . . . 40436 8232 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8232 2 152 152 CD 40436 8232 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8232 4 The the DT 40436 8232 5 commentators commentator NNS 40436 8232 6 are be VBP 40436 8232 7 at at IN 40436 8232 8 liberty liberty NN 40436 8232 9 to to TO 40436 8232 10 impeach impeach VB 40436 8232 11 the the DT 40436 8232 12 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8232 13 as as IN 40436 8232 14 unsound unsound JJ 40436 8232 15 ; ; : 40436 8232 16 but but CC 40436 8232 17 to to TO 40436 8232 18 set set VB 40436 8232 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8232 20 aside aside RB 40436 8232 21 as as IN 40436 8232 22 mere mere JJ 40436 8232 23 banter banter NN 40436 8232 24 and and CC 40436 8232 25 mockery mockery NN 40436 8232 26 , , , 40436 8232 27 is be VBZ 40436 8232 28 preposterous preposterous JJ 40436 8232 29 . . . 40436 8233 1 Assume assume VB 40436 8233 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8233 3 even even RB 40436 8233 4 to to TO 40436 8233 5 be be VB 40436 8233 6 intended intend VBN 40436 8233 7 as as IN 40436 8233 8 mockery mockery NN 40436 8233 9 -- -- : 40436 8233 10 assume assume VBP 40436 8233 11 that that IN 40436 8233 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8233 13 is be VBZ 40436 8233 14 mystifying mystify VBG 40436 8233 15 the the DT 40436 8233 16 hearers hearer NNS 40436 8233 17 , , , 40436 8233 18 by by IN 40436 8233 19 a a DT 40436 8233 20 string string NN 40436 8233 21 of of IN 40436 8233 22 delusive delusive JJ 40436 8233 23 queries query NNS 40436 8233 24 , , , 40436 8233 25 to to TO 40436 8233 26 make make VB 40436 8233 27 out out RP 40436 8233 28 a a DT 40436 8233 29 thesis thesis NN 40436 8233 30 which which WDT 40436 8233 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8233 32 knows know VBZ 40436 8233 33 to to TO 40436 8233 34 be be VB 40436 8233 35 untrue untrue JJ 40436 8233 36 and and CC 40436 8233 37 silly silly JJ 40436 8233 38 -- -- : 40436 8233 39 how how WRB 40436 8233 40 can can MD 40436 8233 41 the the DT 40436 8233 42 mockery mockery NN 40436 8233 43 fall fall NN 40436 8233 44 upon upon IN 40436 8233 45 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8233 46 , , , 40436 8233 47 who who WP 40436 8233 48 denies deny VBZ 40436 8233 49 the the DT 40436 8233 50 thesis thesis NN 40436 8233 51 from from IN 40436 8233 52 the the DT 40436 8233 53 beginning beginning NN 40436 8233 54 ? ? . 40436 8234 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8234 2 153 153 CD 40436 8234 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8234 4 The the DT 40436 8234 5 irony irony NN 40436 8234 6 , , , 40436 8234 7 if if IN 40436 8234 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8234 9 were be VBD 40436 8234 10 irony irony JJ 40436 8234 11 , , , 40436 8234 12 would would MD 40436 8234 13 be be VB 40436 8234 14 misplaced misplace VBN 40436 8234 15 and and CC 40436 8234 16 absurd absurd JJ 40436 8234 17 . . . 40436 8235 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8235 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8235 3 150 150 CD 40436 8235 4 : : : 40436 8235 5 See See NNP 40436 8235 6 Brandis Brandis NNP 40436 8235 7 , , , 40436 8235 8 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 8235 9 . . . 40436 8236 1 d. d. NNP 40436 8237 1 Griech.-Röm Griech.-Röm NNP 40436 8237 2 . . . 40436 8237 3 , , , 40436 8237 4 Phil Phil NNP 40436 8237 5 . . . 40436 8238 1 Part Part NNP 40436 8238 2 ii ii NNP 40436 8238 3 . . . 40436 8239 1 sect sect NNP 40436 8239 2 . . . 40436 8240 1 114 114 CD 40436 8240 2 , , , 40436 8240 3 note note VB 40436 8240 4 3 3 CD 40436 8240 5 p. p. NN 40436 8240 6 458 458 CD 40436 8240 7 ; ; : 40436 8240 8 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 8240 9 , , , 40436 8240 10 Prolegom Prolegom NNP 40436 8240 11 . . . 40436 8241 1 ad ad FW 40436 8241 2 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8241 3 . . . 40436 8242 1 pp pp NNP 40436 8242 2 . . . 40436 8243 1 15 15 CD 40436 8243 2 - - SYM 40436 8243 3 33 33 CD 40436 8243 4 - - HYPH 40436 8243 5 34 34 CD 40436 8243 6 . . . 40436 8244 1 So so RB 40436 8244 2 too too RB 40436 8244 3 Ficinus Ficinus NNP 40436 8244 4 says say VBZ 40436 8244 5 in in IN 40436 8244 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8244 7 Argumentum Argumentum NNP 40436 8244 8 to to IN 40436 8244 9 the the DT 40436 8244 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8244 11 : : : 40436 8244 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8244 13 p. p. NN 40436 8244 14 765 765 CD 40436 8244 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8244 16 " " `` 40436 8244 17 Tum tum NN 40436 8244 18 vero vero NN 40436 8244 19 de de FW 40436 8244 20 bono bono FW 40436 8244 21 et et NNP 40436 8244 22 malo malo NNP 40436 8244 23 multa multa NNP 40436 8244 24 tractantur tractantur NNP 40436 8244 25 . . . 40436 8245 1 Siquidem Siquidem NNP 40436 8245 2 prudentia prudentia NNP 40436 8245 3 est est NNP 40436 8245 4 scientia scientia NN 40436 8245 5 eligendi eligendi NNP 40436 8245 6 boni boni NNP 40436 8245 7 , , , 40436 8245 8 malique malique NN 40436 8245 9 vitandi vitandi NN 40436 8245 10 . . . 40436 8246 1 Ambigitur ambigitur JJ 40436 8246 2 autem autem NN 40436 8246 3 utrum utrum NNP 40436 8246 4 bonum bonum NNP 40436 8246 5 malumque malumque NNP 40436 8246 6 idem idem NNP 40436 8246 7 sit sit NNP 40436 8246 8 penitus penitus NNP 40436 8246 9 quod quod NNP 40436 8246 10 et et NNP 40436 8246 11 voluptas voluptas NNP 40436 8246 12 et et NNP 40436 8246 13 dolor dolor NN 40436 8246 14 . . . 40436 8247 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8247 2 Neque Neque NNP 40436 8247 3 affirmatur affirmatur NNP 40436 8247 4 i -PRON- PRP 40436 8247 5 d d NNP 40436 8247 6 quidem quidem NNP 40436 8247 7 omnino omnino NNP 40436 8247 8 , , , 40436 8247 9 neque neque NNP 40436 8247 10 manifesté manifesté NNP 40436 8247 11 omnino omnino NNP 40436 8247 12 negatur negatur NNP 40436 8247 13 . . . 40436 8247 14 _ _ NNP 40436 8247 15 De De NNP 40436 8247 16 hoc hoc FW 40436 8247 17 enim enim NN 40436 8247 18 in in IN 40436 8247 19 Gorgiâ Gorgiâ NNP 40436 8247 20 Phileboque Phileboque NNP 40436 8247 21 et et NNP 40436 8247 22 alibi alibi NN 40436 8247 23 , , , 40436 8247 24 " " '' 40436 8247 25 & & CC 40436 8247 26 c. c. NNP 40436 8247 27 When when WRB 40436 8247 28 a a DT 40436 8247 29 critic critic NN 40436 8247 30 composes compose VBZ 40436 8247 31 an an DT 40436 8247 32 Argument argument NN 40436 8247 33 to to IN 40436 8247 34 the the DT 40436 8247 35 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 8247 36 , , , 40436 8247 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8247 38 is be VBZ 40436 8247 39 surely surely RB 40436 8247 40 under under IN 40436 8247 41 obligation obligation NN 40436 8247 42 to to TO 40436 8247 43 report report VB 40436 8247 44 faithfully faithfully RB 40436 8247 45 and and CC 40436 8247 46 exactly exactly RB 40436 8247 47 what what WP 40436 8247 48 is be VBZ 40436 8247 49 declared declare VBN 40436 8247 50 by by IN 40436 8247 51 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8247 52 _ _ NNP 40436 8247 53 in in IN 40436 8247 54 the the DT 40436 8247 55 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8247 56 _ _ NNP 40436 8247 57 , , , 40436 8247 58 whether whether IN 40436 8247 59 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8247 60 be be VB 40436 8247 61 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8247 62 or or CC 40436 8247 63 not not RB 40436 8247 64 with with IN 40436 8247 65 the the DT 40436 8247 66 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8247 67 and and CC 40436 8247 68 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 8247 69 . . . 40436 8248 1 Yet yet CC 40436 8248 2 here here RB 40436 8248 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8248 4 find find VBP 40436 8248 5 Ficinus Ficinus NNP 40436 8248 6 misrepresenting misrepresent VBG 40436 8248 7 the the DT 40436 8248 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 8248 9 , , , 40436 8248 10 in in IN 40436 8248 11 order order NN 40436 8248 12 to to TO 40436 8248 13 force force VB 40436 8248 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8248 15 into into IN 40436 8248 16 harmony harmony NN 40436 8248 17 with with IN 40436 8248 18 the the DT 40436 8248 19 other other JJ 40436 8248 20 two two CD 40436 8248 21 . . . 40436 8248 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8249 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8249 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8249 3 151 151 CD 40436 8249 4 : : : 40436 8249 5 This this DT 40436 8249 6 is be VBZ 40436 8249 7 so so RB 40436 8249 8 directly directly RB 40436 8249 9 stated state VBN 40436 8249 10 that that IN 40436 8249 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8249 12 am be VBP 40436 8249 13 surprised surprised JJ 40436 8249 14 to to TO 40436 8249 15 find find VB 40436 8249 16 Zeller Zeller NNP 40436 8249 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8249 18 among among IN 40436 8249 19 many many JJ 40436 8249 20 other other JJ 40436 8249 21 critics critic NNS 40436 8249 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8249 23 announcing announce VBG 40436 8249 24 that that IN 40436 8249 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8249 26 here here RB 40436 8249 27 accepts accept VBZ 40436 8249 28 for for IN 40436 8249 29 the the DT 40436 8249 30 occasion occasion NN 40436 8249 31 the the DT 40436 8249 32 _ _ NNP 40436 8249 33 Standpunkt Standpunkt NNP 40436 8249 34 _ _ NNP 40436 8249 35 of of IN 40436 8249 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8249 37 enemies enemy NNS 40436 8249 38 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8249 39 Philos Philos NNP 40436 8249 40 . . . 40436 8250 1 der der NNP 40436 8250 2 Griech Griech NNP 40436 8250 3 . . . 40436 8251 1 vol vol NNP 40436 8251 2 . . . 40436 8252 1 ii ii LS 40436 8252 2 . . . 40436 8253 1 p. p. NN 40436 8253 2 380 380 CD 40436 8253 3 , , , 40436 8253 4 ed ed NNP 40436 8253 5 . . . 40436 8254 1 2nd 2nd NNP 40436 8254 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8254 3 . . . 40436 8254 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8255 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8255 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8255 3 152 152 CD 40436 8255 4 : : : 40436 8255 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8255 6 , , , 40436 8255 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8255 8 . . . 40436 8256 1 p. p. NN 40436 8256 2 358 358 CD 40436 8256 3 A. a. NN 40436 8257 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8257 2 Greek greek JJ 40436 8257 3 : : : 40436 8257 4 u(perphuô u(perphuô NNP 40436 8257 5 = = SYM 40436 8257 6 s s NNP 40436 8257 7 e)do e)do NNP 40436 8257 8 / / SYM 40436 8257 9 kei kei NNP 40436 8257 10 a(/pasin a(/pasin NNP 40436 8257 11 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 8257 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 8257 13 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 8257 14 ei)rême ei)rême NN 40436 8257 15 / / , 40436 8257 16 na na NN 40436 8257 17 . . . 40436 8257 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8257 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8258 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8258 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8258 3 153 153 CD 40436 8258 4 : : : 40436 8258 5 When when WRB 40436 8258 6 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 8258 7 asserts assert VBZ 40436 8258 8 that that IN 40436 8258 9 the the DT 40436 8258 10 thesis thesis NN 40436 8258 11 is be VBZ 40436 8258 12 taken take VBN 40436 8258 13 up up RP 40436 8258 14 by by IN 40436 8258 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8258 16 as as IN 40436 8258 17 one one CD 40436 8258 18 which which WDT 40436 8258 19 was be VBD 40436 8258 20 maintained maintain VBN 40436 8258 21 by by IN 40436 8258 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8258 23 and and CC 40436 8258 24 the the DT 40436 8258 25 other other JJ 40436 8258 26 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 8258 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8258 28 Proleg Proleg NNP 40436 8258 29 . . . 40436 8259 1 p. p. NN 40436 8259 2 33 33 CD 40436 8259 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8259 4 , , , 40436 8259 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8259 6 says say VBZ 40436 8259 7 what what WP 40436 8259 8 is be VBZ 40436 8259 9 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 8259 10 at at IN 40436 8259 11 variance variance NN 40436 8259 12 with with IN 40436 8259 13 the the DT 40436 8259 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8259 15 , , , 40436 8259 16 p. p. NN 40436 8259 17 351 351 CD 40436 8259 18 . . . 40436 8260 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 8260 2 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 8260 3 that that IN 40436 8260 4 this this DT 40436 8260 5 same same JJ 40436 8260 6 thesis thesis NN 40436 8260 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8260 8 the the DT 40436 8260 9 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 8260 10 identity identity NN 40436 8260 11 of of IN 40436 8260 12 good good JJ 40436 8260 13 with with IN 40436 8260 14 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8260 15 , , , 40436 8260 16 evil evil NN 40436 8260 17 with with IN 40436 8260 18 pain pain NN 40436 8260 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8260 20 is be VBZ 40436 8260 21 altogether altogether RB 40436 8260 22 " " `` 40436 8260 23 unsokratic unsokratic JJ 40436 8260 24 and and CC 40436 8260 25 unplatonic unplatonic JJ 40436 8260 26 " " '' 40436 8260 27 ; ; : 40436 8260 28 that that IN 40436 8260 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8260 30 is be VBZ 40436 8260 31 handled handle VBN 40436 8260 32 here here RB 40436 8260 33 by by IN 40436 8260 34 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8260 35 in in IN 40436 8260 36 a a DT 40436 8260 37 manner manner NN 40436 8260 38 visibly visibly RB 40436 8260 39 ironical ironical JJ 40436 8260 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8260 41 sichtbar sichtbar NN 40436 8260 42 ironisch ironisch NNP 40436 8260 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8260 44 ; ; : 40436 8260 45 that that IN 40436 8260 46 the the DT 40436 8260 47 purpose purpose NN 40436 8260 48 of of IN 40436 8260 49 the the DT 40436 8260 50 argument argument NN 40436 8260 51 is be VBZ 40436 8260 52 to to TO 40436 8260 53 show show VB 40436 8260 54 the the DT 40436 8260 55 stupidity stupidity NN 40436 8260 56 of of IN 40436 8260 57 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8260 58 , , , 40436 8260 59 who who WP 40436 8260 60 is be VBZ 40436 8260 61 puzzled puzzle VBN 40436 8260 62 and and CC 40436 8260 63 imposed impose VBN 40436 8260 64 upon upon IN 40436 8260 65 by by IN 40436 8260 66 such such JJ 40436 8260 67 obvious obvious JJ 40436 8260 68 fallacies fallacy NNS 40436 8260 69 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8260 70 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 8260 71 zum zum VB 40436 8260 72 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8260 73 . . . 40436 8261 1 230 230 CD 40436 8261 2 , , , 40436 8261 3 bottom bottom NN 40436 8261 4 of of IN 40436 8261 5 p. p. NN 40436 8261 6 232 232 CD 40436 8261 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8261 8 , , , 40436 8261 9 and and CC 40436 8261 10 who who WP 40436 8261 11 is be VBZ 40436 8261 12 made make VBN 40436 8261 13 to to TO 40436 8261 14 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 8261 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8261 16 so so RB 40436 8261 17 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 8261 18 says say VBZ 40436 8261 19 , , , 40436 8261 20 Einl Einl NNP 40436 8261 21 . . . 40436 8262 1 zum zum NNP 40436 8262 2 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8262 3 , , , 40436 8262 4 p. p. NN 40436 8262 5 14 14 CD 40436 8262 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8262 7 a a DT 40436 8262 8 string string NN 40436 8262 9 of of IN 40436 8262 10 ludicrous ludicrous JJ 40436 8262 11 absurdities absurdity NNS 40436 8262 12 . . . 40436 8263 1 Upon upon IN 40436 8263 2 this this DT 40436 8263 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8263 4 have have VBP 40436 8263 5 to to TO 40436 8263 6 remark remark VB 40436 8263 7 first first RB 40436 8263 8 , , , 40436 8263 9 that that IN 40436 8263 10 if if IN 40436 8263 11 the the DT 40436 8263 12 stupidity stupidity NN 40436 8263 13 of of IN 40436 8263 14 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8263 15 is be VBZ 40436 8263 16 intended intend VBN 40436 8263 17 to to TO 40436 8263 18 be be VB 40436 8263 19 shown show VBN 40436 8263 20 up up RP 40436 8263 21 , , , 40436 8263 22 that that DT 40436 8263 23 of of IN 40436 8263 24 all all PDT 40436 8263 25 the the DT 40436 8263 26 other other JJ 40436 8263 27 persons person NNS 40436 8263 28 present present JJ 40436 8263 29 must must MD 40436 8263 30 be be VB 40436 8263 31 equally equally RB 40436 8263 32 manifested manifest VBN 40436 8263 33 ; ; : 40436 8263 34 for for IN 40436 8263 35 all all DT 40436 8263 36 of of IN 40436 8263 37 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8263 38 assent assent VBP 40436 8263 39 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 8263 40 , , , 40436 8263 41 at at IN 40436 8263 42 the the DT 40436 8263 43 close close NN 40436 8263 44 , , , 40436 8263 45 to to IN 40436 8263 46 the the DT 40436 8263 47 thesis thesis NN 40436 8263 48 as as IN 40436 8263 49 having have VBG 40436 8263 50 been be VBN 40436 8263 51 proved prove VBN 40436 8263 52 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8263 53 Prot Prot NNS 40436 8263 54 . . . 40436 8264 1 p. p. NN 40436 8264 2 358 358 CD 40436 8264 3 A a NN 40436 8264 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8264 5 : : : 40436 8264 6 next next RB 40436 8264 7 , , , 40436 8264 8 that that IN 40436 8264 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8264 10 am be VBP 40436 8264 11 unable unable JJ 40436 8264 12 to to TO 40436 8264 13 see see VB 40436 8264 14 either either CC 40436 8264 15 the the DT 40436 8264 16 absurdities absurdity NNS 40436 8264 17 of of IN 40436 8264 18 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8264 19 or or CC 40436 8264 20 the the DT 40436 8264 21 irony irony NN 40436 8264 22 of of IN 40436 8264 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8264 24 , , , 40436 8264 25 which which WDT 40436 8264 26 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 8264 27 asserts assert VBZ 40436 8264 28 to to TO 40436 8264 29 be be VB 40436 8264 30 so so RB 40436 8264 31 visible visible JJ 40436 8264 32 . . . 40436 8265 1 The the DT 40436 8265 2 argument argument NN 40436 8265 3 of of IN 40436 8265 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8265 5 is be VBZ 40436 8265 6 as as RB 40436 8265 7 serious serious JJ 40436 8265 8 and and CC 40436 8265 9 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 8265 10 as as IN 40436 8265 11 any any DT 40436 8265 12 thing thing NN 40436 8265 13 which which WDT 40436 8265 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8265 15 read read VBP 40436 8265 16 in in IN 40436 8265 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8265 18 . . . 40436 8266 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 8266 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 8266 3 to to IN 40436 8266 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8266 5 to to IN 40436 8266 6 misconceive misconceive NNP 40436 8266 7 altogether altogether RB 40436 8266 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8266 9 not not RB 40436 8266 10 only only RB 40436 8266 11 here here RB 40436 8266 12 but but CC 40436 8266 13 also also RB 40436 8266 14 in in IN 40436 8266 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8266 16 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 8266 17 zum zum VB 40436 8266 18 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8266 19 , , , 40436 8266 20 p. p. NN 40436 8266 21 10 10 CD 40436 8266 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8266 23 the the DT 40436 8266 24 concluding concluding NN 40436 8266 25 argument argument NN 40436 8266 26 of of IN 40436 8266 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8266 28 in in IN 40436 8266 29 the the DT 40436 8266 30 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8266 31 . . . 40436 8267 1 To to TO 40436 8267 2 describe describe VB 40436 8267 3 the the DT 40436 8267 4 identity identity NN 40436 8267 5 between between IN 40436 8267 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8267 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8267 8 : : : 40436 8267 9 ê(du\ ê(du\ NN 40436 8267 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8267 11 and and CC 40436 8267 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8267 13 Greek greek JJ 40436 8267 14 : : : 40436 8267 15 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 8267 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8267 17 as as IN 40436 8267 18 a a DT 40436 8267 19 " " `` 40436 8267 20 scheinbare scheinbare NN 40436 8267 21 Voraussetzung Voraussetzung NNP 40436 8267 22 " " '' 40436 8267 23 is be VBZ 40436 8267 24 to to TO 40436 8267 25 depart depart VB 40436 8267 26 from from IN 40436 8267 27 the the DT 40436 8267 28 plain plain JJ 40436 8267 29 meaning meaning NN 40436 8267 30 of of IN 40436 8267 31 words word NNS 40436 8267 32 . . . 40436 8268 1 Again again RB 40436 8268 2 , , , 40436 8268 3 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 8268 4 contends contend VBZ 40436 8268 5 that that IN 40436 8268 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8268 7 assumes assume VBZ 40436 8268 8 this this DT 40436 8268 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8268 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8268 11 identity identity NN 40436 8268 12 of of IN 40436 8268 13 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8268 14 with with IN 40436 8268 15 good good JJ 40436 8268 16 , , , 40436 8268 17 pain pain NN 40436 8268 18 with with IN 40436 8268 19 evil evil NN 40436 8268 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8268 21 , , , 40436 8268 22 " " '' 40436 8268 23 not not RB 40436 8268 24 as as IN 40436 8268 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8268 26 own own JJ 40436 8268 27 opinion opinion NN 40436 8268 28 , , , 40436 8268 29 but but CC 40436 8268 30 only only RB 40436 8268 31 hypothetically hypothetically RB 40436 8268 32 , , , 40436 8268 33 with with IN 40436 8268 34 a a DT 40436 8268 35 sarcastic sarcastic JJ 40436 8268 36 side side NN 40436 8268 37 - - HYPH 40436 8268 38 glance glance NN 40436 8268 39 at at IN 40436 8268 40 the the DT 40436 8268 41 absurd absurd JJ 40436 8268 42 consequences consequence NNS 40436 8268 43 which which WDT 40436 8268 44 many many JJ 40436 8268 45 deduced deduce VBD 40436 8268 46 from from IN 40436 8268 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8268 48 -- -- : 40436 8268 49 only only RB 40436 8268 50 as as IN 40436 8268 51 the the DT 40436 8268 52 received receive VBN 40436 8268 53 world world NN 40436 8268 54 - - HYPH 40436 8268 55 morality morality NN 40436 8268 56 , , , 40436 8268 57 as as IN 40436 8268 58 the the DT 40436 8268 59 opinion opinion NN 40436 8268 60 of of IN 40436 8268 61 the the DT 40436 8268 62 majority majority NN 40436 8268 63 " " '' 40436 8268 64 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8268 65 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 8268 66 . . . 40436 8269 1 zum zum NNP 40436 8269 2 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8269 3 . . . 40436 8270 1 p. p. NN 40436 8270 2 419 419 CD 40436 8270 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8270 4 . . . 40436 8271 1 How how WRB 40436 8271 2 Steinhart Steinhart NNP 40436 8271 3 can can MD 40436 8271 4 find find VB 40436 8271 5 proof proof NN 40436 8271 6 of of IN 40436 8271 7 this this DT 40436 8271 8 in in IN 40436 8271 9 the the DT 40436 8271 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8271 11 , , , 40436 8271 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8271 13 am be VBP 40436 8271 14 at at IN 40436 8271 15 a a DT 40436 8271 16 loss loss NN 40436 8271 17 to to TO 40436 8271 18 understand understand VB 40436 8271 19 . . . 40436 8272 1 The the DT 40436 8272 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8272 3 presents present VBZ 40436 8272 4 to to IN 40436 8272 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8272 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8272 7 introducing introduce VBG 40436 8272 8 the the DT 40436 8272 9 opinion opinion NN 40436 8272 10 as as IN 40436 8272 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8272 12 own own JJ 40436 8272 13 , , , 40436 8272 14 against against IN 40436 8272 15 that that DT 40436 8272 16 of of IN 40436 8272 17 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8272 18 and and CC 40436 8272 19 against against IN 40436 8272 20 that that DT 40436 8272 21 of of IN 40436 8272 22 the the DT 40436 8272 23 multitude multitude NNP 40436 8272 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8272 25 p. p. NN 40436 8272 26 351 351 CD 40436 8272 27 C C NNP 40436 8272 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8272 29 . . . 40436 8273 1 On on IN 40436 8273 2 hearing hear VBG 40436 8273 3 this this DT 40436 8273 4 opposition opposition NN 40436 8273 5 from from IN 40436 8273 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8273 7 , , , 40436 8273 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8273 9 invites invite VBZ 40436 8273 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8273 11 to to IN 40436 8273 12 an an DT 40436 8273 13 investigation investigation NN 40436 8273 14 , , , 40436 8273 15 whether whether IN 40436 8273 16 the the DT 40436 8273 17 opinion opinion NN 40436 8273 18 be be VBP 40436 8273 19 just just RB 40436 8273 20 ; ; : 40436 8273 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8273 22 then then RB 40436 8273 23 conducts conduct VBZ 40436 8273 24 the the DT 40436 8273 25 investigation investigation NN 40436 8273 26 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8273 27 , , , 40436 8273 28 along along IN 40436 8273 29 with with IN 40436 8273 30 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8273 31 , , , 40436 8273 32 at at IN 40436 8273 33 considerable considerable JJ 40436 8273 34 length length NN 40436 8273 35 , , , 40436 8273 36 and and CC 40436 8273 37 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 8273 38 brings bring VBZ 40436 8273 39 out out RP 40436 8273 40 the the DT 40436 8273 41 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8273 42 as as IN 40436 8273 43 proved prove VBN 40436 8273 44 , , , 40436 8273 45 with with IN 40436 8273 46 the the DT 40436 8273 47 assent assent NN 40436 8273 48 of of IN 40436 8273 49 all all DT 40436 8273 50 present present JJ 40436 8273 51 . . . 40436 8274 1 These these DT 40436 8274 2 forced force VBN 40436 8274 3 interpretations interpretation NNS 40436 8274 4 are be VBP 40436 8274 5 resorted resort VBN 40436 8274 6 to to IN 40436 8274 7 , , , 40436 8274 8 because because IN 40436 8274 9 the the DT 40436 8274 10 critics critic NNS 40436 8274 11 can can MD 40436 8274 12 not not RB 40436 8274 13 bear bear VB 40436 8274 14 to to TO 40436 8274 15 see see VB 40436 8274 16 the the DT 40436 8274 17 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8274 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8274 19 maintaining maintain VBG 40436 8274 20 a a DT 40436 8274 21 thesis thesis NN 40436 8274 22 substantially substantially RB 40436 8274 23 the the DT 40436 8274 24 same same JJ 40436 8274 25 as as IN 40436 8274 26 that that DT 40436 8274 27 of of IN 40436 8274 28 Eudoxus Eudoxus NNP 40436 8274 29 and and CC 40436 8274 30 Epikurus Epikurus NNP 40436 8274 31 . . . 40436 8275 1 Upon upon IN 40436 8275 2 this this DT 40436 8275 3 point point NN 40436 8275 4 , , , 40436 8275 5 K. K. NNP 40436 8275 6 F. F. NNP 40436 8275 7 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 8275 8 is be VBZ 40436 8275 9 more more RBR 40436 8275 10 moderate moderate JJ 40436 8275 11 than than IN 40436 8275 12 the the DT 40436 8275 13 others other NNS 40436 8275 14 ; ; : 40436 8275 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8275 16 admits admit VBZ 40436 8275 17 the the DT 40436 8275 18 thesis thesis NN 40436 8275 19 to to TO 40436 8275 20 be be VB 40436 8275 21 seriously seriously RB 40436 8275 22 maintained maintain VBN 40436 8275 23 in in IN 40436 8275 24 the the DT 40436 8275 25 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8275 26 -- -- : 40436 8275 27 states state VBZ 40436 8275 28 that that IN 40436 8275 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8275 30 was be VBD 40436 8275 31 really really RB 40436 8275 32 the the DT 40436 8275 33 opinion opinion NN 40436 8275 34 of of IN 40436 8275 35 the the DT 40436 8275 36 historical historical JJ 40436 8275 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8275 38 -- -- : 40436 8275 39 and and CC 40436 8275 40 adds add VBZ 40436 8275 41 that that IN 40436 8275 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8275 43 was be VBD 40436 8275 44 also also RB 40436 8275 45 the the DT 40436 8275 46 opinion opinion NN 40436 8275 47 of of IN 40436 8275 48 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8275 49 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8275 50 during during IN 40436 8275 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8275 52 early early JJ 40436 8275 53 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 8275 54 stadium stadium NN 40436 8275 55 , , , 40436 8275 56 when when WRB 40436 8275 57 the the DT 40436 8275 58 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8275 59 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8275 60 as as IN 40436 8275 61 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8275 62 thinks think VBZ 40436 8275 63 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8275 64 was be VBD 40436 8275 65 composed compose VBN 40436 8275 66 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8275 67 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 8275 68 . . . 40436 8276 1 und und JJ 40436 8276 2 Syst Syst NNP 40436 8276 3 . . . 40436 8277 1 der der NNP 40436 8277 2 Plat Plat NNP 40436 8277 3 . . . 40436 8278 1 Phil Phil NNP 40436 8278 2 . . . 40436 8279 1 pp pp NNP 40436 8279 2 . . . 40436 8280 1 462 462 CD 40436 8280 2 - - SYM 40436 8280 3 463 463 CD 40436 8280 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8280 5 . . . 40436 8281 1 Most Most JJS 40436 8281 2 of of IN 40436 8281 3 the the DT 40436 8281 4 critics critic NNS 40436 8281 5 agree agree VBP 40436 8281 6 in in IN 40436 8281 7 considering consider VBG 40436 8281 8 the the DT 40436 8281 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8281 10 to to TO 40436 8281 11 be be VB 40436 8281 12 one one CD 40436 8281 13 of of IN 40436 8281 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8281 15 's 's POS 40436 8281 16 earlier early JJR 40436 8281 17 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8281 18 , , , 40436 8281 19 about about RB 40436 8281 20 403 403 CD 40436 8281 21 B.C. B.C. NNS 40436 8282 1 Ast Ast NNP 40436 8282 2 even even RB 40436 8282 3 refers refer VBZ 40436 8282 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8282 5 to to IN 40436 8282 6 407 407 CD 40436 8282 7 B.C. B.C. NNS 40436 8283 1 when when WRB 40436 8283 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8283 3 was be VBD 40436 8283 4 about about RB 40436 8283 5 twenty twenty CD 40436 8283 6 - - HYPH 40436 8283 7 one one CD 40436 8283 8 years year NNS 40436 8283 9 of of IN 40436 8283 10 age age NN 40436 8283 11 . . . 40436 8284 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8284 2 have have VBP 40436 8284 3 already already RB 40436 8284 4 given give VBN 40436 8284 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8284 6 reasons reason NNS 40436 8284 7 for for IN 40436 8284 8 believing believe VBG 40436 8284 9 that that IN 40436 8284 10 none none NN 40436 8284 11 of of IN 40436 8284 12 the the DT 40436 8284 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8284 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8284 15 were be VBD 40436 8284 16 composed compose VBN 40436 8284 17 before before IN 40436 8284 18 399 399 CD 40436 8284 19 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 8285 1 The the DT 40436 8285 2 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8285 3 belongs belong VBZ 40436 8285 4 , , , 40436 8285 5 in in IN 40436 8285 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8285 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 8285 8 , , , 40436 8285 9 to to IN 40436 8285 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8285 11 's 's POS 40436 8285 12 most most RBS 40436 8285 13 perfect perfect JJ 40436 8285 14 and and CC 40436 8285 15 mature mature JJ 40436 8285 16 period period NN 40436 8285 17 . . . 40436 8285 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8286 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8286 2 Side side NN 40436 8286 3 - - HYPH 40436 8286 4 note note NN 40436 8286 5 : : : 40436 8286 6 Grounds ground NNS 40436 8286 7 of of IN 40436 8286 8 that that DT 40436 8286 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8286 10 . . . 40436 8287 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8287 2 insufficiency insufficiency NN 40436 8287 3 . . . 40436 8287 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8288 1 The the DT 40436 8288 2 commentators commentator NNS 40436 8288 3 resort resort VBP 40436 8288 4 to to IN 40436 8288 5 this this DT 40436 8288 6 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 8288 7 , , , 40436 8288 8 partly partly RB 40436 8288 9 because because IN 40436 8288 10 the the DT 40436 8288 11 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8288 12 in in IN 40436 8288 13 question question NN 40436 8288 14 is be VBZ 40436 8288 15 one one CD 40436 8288 16 which which WDT 40436 8288 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8288 18 disapprove disapprove VBP 40436 8288 19 -- -- : 40436 8288 20 partly partly RB 40436 8288 21 because because IN 40436 8288 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 8288 23 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 8288 24 with with IN 40436 8288 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8288 26 are be VBP 40436 8288 27 maintained maintain VBN 40436 8288 28 in in IN 40436 8288 29 other other JJ 40436 8288 30 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8288 31 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8288 32 . . . 40436 8289 1 These these DT 40436 8289 2 are be VBP 40436 8289 3 the the DT 40436 8289 4 same same JJ 40436 8289 5 two two CD 40436 8289 6 reasons reason NNS 40436 8289 7 upon upon IN 40436 8289 8 which which WDT 40436 8289 9 , , , 40436 8289 10 in in IN 40436 8289 11 other other JJ 40436 8289 12 cases case NNS 40436 8289 13 , , , 40436 8289 14 various various JJ 40436 8289 15 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8289 16 have have VBP 40436 8289 17 been be VBN 40436 8289 18 rejected reject VBN 40436 8289 19 as as IN 40436 8289 20 not not RB 40436 8289 21 genuine genuine JJ 40436 8289 22 works work NNS 40436 8289 23 of of IN 40436 8289 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8289 25 . . . 40436 8290 1 The the DT 40436 8290 2 first first JJ 40436 8290 3 of of IN 40436 8290 4 the the DT 40436 8290 5 two two CD 40436 8290 6 reasons reason NNS 40436 8290 7 is be VBZ 40436 8290 8 plainly plainly RB 40436 8290 9 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 40436 8290 10 : : : 40436 8290 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8290 12 must must MD 40436 8290 13 accept accept VB 40436 8290 14 what what WP 40436 8290 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8290 16 gives give VBZ 40436 8290 17 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8290 18 , , , 40436 8290 19 whether whether IN 40436 8290 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8290 21 assent assent VBP 40436 8290 22 to to IN 40436 8290 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8290 24 or or CC 40436 8290 25 not not RB 40436 8290 26 . . . 40436 8291 1 The the DT 40436 8291 2 second second JJ 40436 8291 3 reason reason NN 40436 8291 4 also also RB 40436 8291 5 , , , 40436 8291 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8291 7 think think VBP 40436 8291 8 , , , 40436 8291 9 proves prove VBZ 40436 8291 10 little little JJ 40436 8291 11 . . . 40436 8292 1 The the DT 40436 8292 2 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8292 3 are be VBP 40436 8292 4 distinct distinct JJ 40436 8292 5 compositions composition NNS 40436 8292 6 , , , 40436 8292 7 written write VBN 40436 8292 8 each each DT 40436 8292 9 with with IN 40436 8292 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8292 11 own own JJ 40436 8292 12 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 8292 13 and and CC 40436 8292 14 purpose purpose NN 40436 8292 15 : : : 40436 8292 16 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8292 17 have have VBP 40436 8292 18 no no DT 40436 8292 19 right right NN 40436 8292 20 to to TO 40436 8292 21 require require VB 40436 8292 22 that that IN 40436 8292 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8292 24 shall shall MD 40436 8292 25 be be VB 40436 8292 26 all all RB 40436 8292 27 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8292 28 with with IN 40436 8292 29 each each DT 40436 8292 30 other other JJ 40436 8292 31 in in IN 40436 8292 32 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8292 33 , , , 40436 8292 34 especially especially RB 40436 8292 35 when when WRB 40436 8292 36 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8292 37 look look VBP 40436 8292 38 to to IN 40436 8292 39 the the DT 40436 8292 40 long long JJ 40436 8292 41 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 8292 42 career career NN 40436 8292 43 of of IN 40436 8292 44 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8292 45 . . . 40436 8293 1 To to TO 40436 8293 2 suppose suppose VB 40436 8293 3 that that IN 40436 8293 4 the the DT 40436 8293 5 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 8293 6 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8293 7 of of IN 40436 8293 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8293 9 in in IN 40436 8293 10 the the DT 40436 8293 11 latter latter JJ 40436 8293 12 portion portion NN 40436 8293 13 of of IN 40436 8293 14 the the DT 40436 8293 15 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8293 16 is be VBZ 40436 8293 17 mere mere JJ 40436 8293 18 irony irony NN 40436 8293 19 , , , 40436 8293 20 intended intend VBN 40436 8293 21 to to TO 40436 8293 22 mystify mystify VB 40436 8293 23 both both CC 40436 8293 24 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8293 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8293 26 and and CC 40436 8293 27 all all PDT 40436 8293 28 the the DT 40436 8293 29 by by NN 40436 8293 30 - - HYPH 40436 8293 31 standers stander NNS 40436 8293 32 , , , 40436 8293 33 who who WP 40436 8293 34 accept accept VBP 40436 8293 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8293 36 as as IN 40436 8293 37 earnest earnest JJ 40436 8293 38 and and CC 40436 8293 39 convincing convincing JJ 40436 8293 40 -- -- : 40436 8293 41 appears appear VBZ 40436 8293 42 to to IN 40436 8293 43 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8293 44 far far RB 40436 8293 45 less less RBR 40436 8293 46 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 8293 47 than than IN 40436 8293 48 the the DT 40436 8293 49 admission admission NN 40436 8293 50 , , , 40436 8293 51 that that IN 40436 8293 52 the the DT 40436 8293 53 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 8293 54 pleading pleading NN 40436 8293 55 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 8293 56 to to IN 40436 8293 57 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8293 58 in in IN 40436 8293 59 one one CD 40436 8293 60 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8293 61 is be VBZ 40436 8293 62 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 8293 63 with with IN 40436 8293 64 that that DT 40436 8293 65 assigned assign VBN 40436 8293 66 to to IN 40436 8293 67 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8293 68 in in IN 40436 8293 69 another another DT 40436 8293 70 . . . 40436 8294 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8294 2 Side side NN 40436 8294 3 - - HYPH 40436 8294 4 note note NN 40436 8294 5 : : : 40436 8294 6 Subject subject NN 40436 8294 7 is be VBZ 40436 8294 8 professedly professedly RB 40436 8294 9 still still RB 40436 8294 10 left leave VBN 40436 8294 11 unsettled unsettle VBN 40436 8294 12 at at IN 40436 8294 13 the the DT 40436 8294 14 close close NN 40436 8294 15 of of IN 40436 8294 16 the the DT 40436 8294 17 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8294 18 . . . 40436 8294 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8295 1 Though though IN 40436 8295 2 there there EX 40436 8295 3 is be VBZ 40436 8295 4 every every DT 40436 8295 5 mark mark NN 40436 8295 6 of of IN 40436 8295 7 seriousness seriousness NN 40436 8295 8 , , , 40436 8295 9 and and CC 40436 8295 10 no no DT 40436 8295 11 mark mark NN 40436 8295 12 of of IN 40436 8295 13 irony irony NN 40436 8295 14 , , , 40436 8295 15 in in IN 40436 8295 16 this this DT 40436 8295 17 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8295 18 of of IN 40436 8295 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8295 20 , , , 40436 8295 21 yet yet CC 40436 8295 22 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8295 23 must must MD 40436 8295 24 remember remember VB 40436 8295 25 that that IN 40436 8295 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8295 27 does do VBZ 40436 8295 28 not not RB 40436 8295 29 profess profess JJ 40436 8295 30 to to TO 40436 8295 31 leave leave VB 40436 8295 32 the the DT 40436 8295 33 subject subject NN 40436 8295 34 settled settle VBN 40436 8295 35 at at IN 40436 8295 36 the the DT 40436 8295 37 close close NN 40436 8295 38 of of IN 40436 8295 39 the the DT 40436 8295 40 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8295 41 . . . 40436 8296 1 On on IN 40436 8296 2 the the DT 40436 8296 3 contrary contrary NN 40436 8296 4 , , , 40436 8296 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8296 6 declares declare VBZ 40436 8296 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8296 8 to to TO 40436 8296 9 be be VB 40436 8296 10 in in IN 40436 8296 11 a a DT 40436 8296 12 state state NN 40436 8296 13 of of IN 40436 8296 14 puzzle puzzle NN 40436 8296 15 and and CC 40436 8296 16 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 8296 17 . . . 40436 8297 1 The the DT 40436 8297 2 question question NN 40436 8297 3 , , , 40436 8297 4 proposed propose VBD 40436 8297 5 at at IN 40436 8297 6 the the DT 40436 8297 7 outset outset NN 40436 8297 8 , , , 40436 8297 9 Whether Whether NNP 40436 8297 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 8297 11 is be VBZ 40436 8297 12 teachable teachable JJ 40436 8297 13 ? ? . 40436 8298 1 remains remain VBZ 40436 8298 2 undecided undecided JJ 40436 8298 3 . . . 40436 8299 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 8299 2 XXIV XXIV NNP 40436 8299 3 . . . 40436 8300 1 GORGIAS GORGIAS NNP 40436 8300 2 . . . 40436 8301 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8301 2 Side side NN 40436 8301 3 - - HYPH 40436 8301 4 note note NN 40436 8301 5 : : : 40436 8301 6 Persons person NNS 40436 8301 7 who who WP 40436 8301 8 debate debate VBP 40436 8301 9 in in IN 40436 8301 10 the the DT 40436 8301 11 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8301 12 . . . 40436 8302 1 Celebrity celebrity NN 40436 8302 2 of of IN 40436 8302 3 the the DT 40436 8302 4 historical historical JJ 40436 8302 5 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8302 6 . . . 40436 8302 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8303 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8303 2 , , , 40436 8303 3 in in IN 40436 8303 4 one one CD 40436 8303 5 of of IN 40436 8303 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8303 7 lost lost JJ 40436 8303 8 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8303 9 , , , 40436 8303 10 made make VBN 40436 8303 11 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8303 12 mention mention NN 40436 8303 13 of of IN 40436 8303 14 a a DT 40436 8303 15 Corinthian corinthian JJ 40436 8303 16 cultivator cultivator NN 40436 8303 17 , , , 40436 8303 18 who who WP 40436 8303 19 , , , 40436 8303 20 on on IN 40436 8303 21 reading read VBG 40436 8303 22 the the DT 40436 8303 23 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8303 24 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8303 25 , , , 40436 8303 26 was be VBD 40436 8303 27 smitten smite VBN 40436 8303 28 with with IN 40436 8303 29 such such JJ 40436 8303 30 vehement vehement NN 40436 8303 31 admiration admiration NN 40436 8303 32 , , , 40436 8303 33 that that IN 40436 8303 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8303 35 abandoned abandon VBD 40436 8303 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8303 37 fields field NNS 40436 8303 38 and and CC 40436 8303 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8303 40 vines vine NNS 40436 8303 41 , , , 40436 8303 42 came come VBD 40436 8303 43 to to IN 40436 8303 44 Athens Athens NNP 40436 8303 45 forthwith forthwith NN 40436 8303 46 , , , 40436 8303 47 and and CC 40436 8303 48 committed commit VBD 40436 8303 49 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8303 50 to to IN 40436 8303 51 the the DT 40436 8303 52 tuition tuition NN 40436 8303 53 of of IN 40436 8303 54 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8303 55 . . . 40436 8304 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8304 2 1 1 LS 40436 8304 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8304 4 How how WRB 40436 8304 5 much much JJ 40436 8304 6 of of IN 40436 8304 7 reality reality NN 40436 8304 8 there there EX 40436 8304 9 may may MD 40436 8304 10 be be VB 40436 8304 11 in in IN 40436 8304 12 this this DT 40436 8304 13 anecdote anecdote NN 40436 8304 14 , , , 40436 8304 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8304 16 can can MD 40436 8304 17 not not RB 40436 8304 18 say say VB 40436 8304 19 : : : 40436 8304 20 but but CC 40436 8304 21 the the DT 40436 8304 22 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8304 23 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8304 24 is be VBZ 40436 8304 25 well well RB 40436 8304 26 calculated calculate VBN 40436 8304 27 to to TO 40436 8304 28 justify justify VB 40436 8304 29 such such JJ 40436 8304 30 warm warm JJ 40436 8304 31 admiration admiration NN 40436 8304 32 . . . 40436 8305 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8305 2 opens open VBZ 40436 8305 3 with with IN 40436 8305 4 a a DT 40436 8305 5 discussion discussion NN 40436 8305 6 on on IN 40436 8305 7 the the DT 40436 8305 8 nature nature NN 40436 8305 9 and and CC 40436 8305 10 purpose purpose NN 40436 8305 11 of of IN 40436 8305 12 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8305 13 , , , 40436 8305 14 but but CC 40436 8305 15 is be VBZ 40436 8305 16 gradually gradually RB 40436 8305 17 enlarged enlarge VBN 40436 8305 18 so so IN 40436 8305 19 as as IN 40436 8305 20 to to TO 40436 8305 21 include include VB 40436 8305 22 a a DT 40436 8305 23 comparison comparison NN 40436 8305 24 of of IN 40436 8305 25 the the DT 40436 8305 26 various various JJ 40436 8305 27 schemes scheme NNS 40436 8305 28 of of IN 40436 8305 29 life life NN 40436 8305 30 , , , 40436 8305 31 and and CC 40436 8305 32 an an DT 40436 8305 33 outline outline NN 40436 8305 34 of of IN 40436 8305 35 positive positive JJ 40436 8305 36 ethical ethical JJ 40436 8305 37 theory theory NN 40436 8305 38 . . . 40436 8306 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8306 2 is be VBZ 40436 8306 3 carried carry VBN 40436 8306 4 on on RP 40436 8306 5 by by IN 40436 8306 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8306 7 with with IN 40436 8306 8 three three CD 40436 8306 9 distinct distinct JJ 40436 8306 10 interlocutors interlocutor NNS 40436 8306 11 -- -- : 40436 8306 12 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8306 13 , , , 40436 8306 14 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8306 15 , , , 40436 8306 16 and and CC 40436 8306 17 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8306 18 ; ; : 40436 8306 19 but but CC 40436 8306 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8306 21 must must MD 40436 8306 22 again again RB 40436 8306 23 remind remind VB 40436 8306 24 the the DT 40436 8306 25 reader reader NN 40436 8306 26 that that IN 40436 8306 27 all all PDT 40436 8306 28 the the DT 40436 8306 29 four four CD 40436 8306 30 are be VBP 40436 8306 31 only only RB 40436 8306 32 spokesmen spokesman NNS 40436 8306 33 prompted prompt VBN 40436 8306 34 by by IN 40436 8306 35 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8306 36 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8306 37 . . . 40436 8307 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8307 2 2 2 LS 40436 8307 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8307 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8307 5 may may MD 40436 8307 6 indeed indeed RB 40436 8307 7 be be VB 40436 8307 8 considered consider VBN 40436 8307 9 almost almost RB 40436 8307 10 as as IN 40436 8307 11 three three CD 40436 8307 12 distinct distinct JJ 40436 8307 13 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8307 14 , , , 40436 8307 15 connected connect VBN 40436 8307 16 by by IN 40436 8307 17 a a DT 40436 8307 18 loose loose JJ 40436 8307 19 thread thread NN 40436 8307 20 . . . 40436 8308 1 The the DT 40436 8308 2 historical historical JJ 40436 8308 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8308 4 , , , 40436 8308 5 a a DT 40436 8308 6 native native NN 40436 8308 7 of of IN 40436 8308 8 Leontini Leontini NNP 40436 8308 9 in in IN 40436 8308 10 Sicily Sicily NNP 40436 8308 11 , , , 40436 8308 12 was be VBD 40436 8308 13 the the DT 40436 8308 14 most most RBS 40436 8308 15 celebrated celebrated JJ 40436 8308 16 of of IN 40436 8308 17 the the DT 40436 8308 18 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 8308 19 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 8308 20 ; ; : 40436 8308 21 an an DT 40436 8308 22 elderly elderly JJ 40436 8308 23 man man NN 40436 8308 24 during during IN 40436 8308 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8308 26 's 's POS 40436 8308 27 youth youth NN 40436 8308 28 . . . 40436 8309 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8309 2 paid pay VBD 40436 8309 3 visits visit NNS 40436 8309 4 to to IN 40436 8309 5 different different JJ 40436 8309 6 cities city NNS 40436 8309 7 in in IN 40436 8309 8 all all DT 40436 8309 9 parts part NNS 40436 8309 10 of of IN 40436 8309 11 Greece Greece NNP 40436 8309 12 , , , 40436 8309 13 and and CC 40436 8309 14 gave give VBD 40436 8309 15 lessons lesson NNS 40436 8309 16 in in IN 40436 8309 17 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8309 18 to to IN 40436 8309 19 numerous numerous JJ 40436 8309 20 pupils pupil NNS 40436 8309 21 , , , 40436 8309 22 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 8309 23 young young JJ 40436 8309 24 men man NNS 40436 8309 25 of of IN 40436 8309 26 ambitious ambitious JJ 40436 8309 27 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 8309 28 . . . 40436 8310 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8310 2 3 3 CD 40436 8310 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8310 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8310 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8310 6 1 1 CD 40436 8310 7 : : : 40436 8310 8 Themistius Themistius NNP 40436 8310 9 , , , 40436 8310 10 Or or CC 40436 8310 11 . . . 40436 8311 1 xxiii xxiii NNP 40436 8311 2 . . . 40436 8312 1 p. p. NN 40436 8312 2 356 356 CD 40436 8312 3 , , , 40436 8312 4 Dindorf Dindorf NNP 40436 8312 5 . . . 40436 8313 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8313 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8313 3 : : : 40436 8313 4 O o NN 40436 8313 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8313 6 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8313 7 geôrgo\s geôrgo\s NNP 40436 8313 8 o o XX 40436 8313 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8313 10 Kori Kori NNP 40436 8313 11 / / SYM 40436 8313 12 nthios nthio NNS 40436 8313 13 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 8313 14 Gorgi Gorgi NNP 40436 8313 15 / / SYM 40436 8313 16 a| a| NN 40436 8313 17 xuggeno xuggeno NNP 40436 8313 18 / / SYM 40436 8313 19 menos menos NNP 40436 8313 20 -- -- : 40436 8313 21 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 8313 22 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 8313 23 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 8313 24 / / SYM 40436 8313 25 nô| nô| NNP 40436 8313 26 Gorgi Gorgi NNP 40436 8313 27 / / SYM 40436 8313 28 a| a| NN 40436 8313 29 , , , 40436 8313 30 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 8313 31 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 8313 32 lo lo NNP 40436 8313 33 / / SYM 40436 8313 34 gô| gô| NNP 40436 8313 35 o(\n o(\n NNP 40436 8313 36 Pla Pla NNP 40436 8313 37 / / SYM 40436 8313 38 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8313 39 e)/grapsen e)/grapsen NNP 40436 8313 40 e)p e)p NNP 40436 8313 41 ' ' POS 40436 8313 42 e)le e)le NN 40436 8313 43 / / SYM 40436 8313 44 gchô| gchô| NNP 40436 8313 45 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8313 46 sophistou=--au)ti sophistou=--au)ti NNP 40436 8313 47 / / SYM 40436 8313 48 ka ka NNP 40436 8313 49 a)phei\s a)phei\s NNP 40436 8313 50 to\n to\n NNP 40436 8313 51 a)/gron a)/gron NNP 40436 8313 52 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8313 53 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8313 54 a)mpe a)mpe NNP 40436 8313 55 / / SYM 40436 8313 56 lous lous JJ 40436 8313 57 , , , 40436 8313 58 Pla Pla NNP 40436 8313 59 / / SYM 40436 8313 60 tôni tôni NNP 40436 8313 61 u(pe u(pe NNP 40436 8313 62 / / SYM 40436 8313 63 thêke thêke NNS 40436 8313 64 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 8313 65 psuchê\n psuchê\n NNP 40436 8313 66 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8313 67 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 8313 68 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 8313 69 / / SYM 40436 8313 70 nou nou NNP 40436 8313 71 e)spei e)spei NNS 40436 8313 72 / / SYM 40436 8313 73 reto reto NNP 40436 8313 74 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8313 75 e)phuteu e)phuteu , 40436 8313 76 / / SYM 40436 8313 77 eto eto NNP 40436 8313 78 ; ; : 40436 8313 79 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8313 80 ou(=to ou(=to NNP 40436 8313 81 / / SYM 40436 8313 82 s s NNP 40436 8313 83 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 8313 84 o(\n o(\n CD 40436 8313 85 tima=| tima=| NNP 40436 8313 86 A)ristote A)ristote NNP 40436 8313 87 / / SYM 40436 8313 88 lês lê NNS 40436 8313 89 e)n e)n NNP 40436 8313 90 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 8313 91 dialo dialo NNS 40436 8313 92 / / , 40436 8313 93 gô| gô| NNP 40436 8313 94 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 8313 95 Korinthi Korinthi NNP 40436 8313 96 / / SYM 40436 8313 97 ô| ô| NNP 40436 8313 98 . . . 40436 8313 99 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8313 100 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8314 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8314 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8314 3 2 2 CD 40436 8314 4 : : : 40436 8314 5 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 8314 6 , , , 40436 8314 7 Orat Orat NNP 40436 8314 8 . . . 40436 8315 1 xlvi xlvi NNP 40436 8315 2 . . . 40436 8316 1 p. p. NN 40436 8316 2 387 387 CD 40436 8316 3 , , , 40436 8316 4 Dindorf Dindorf NNP 40436 8316 5 . . . 40436 8317 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8317 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8317 3 : : : 40436 8317 4 Ti Ti NNP 40436 8317 5 / / SYM 40436 8317 6 s s NNP 40436 8317 7 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8317 8 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 8317 9 oi)=den oi)=den CD 40436 8317 10 , , , 40436 8317 11 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 8317 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8317 13 o o NNP 40436 8317 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8317 15 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 8317 16 / / SYM 40436 8317 17 tês tês NNP 40436 8317 18 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8317 19 o o NNP 40436 8317 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8317 21 Kalliklê Kalliklê NNP 40436 8317 22 = = SYM 40436 8317 23 s s NNP 40436 8317 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8317 25 o o NNP 40436 8317 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8317 27 Gorgi Gorgi NNP 40436 8317 28 / / SYM 40436 8317 29 as as IN 40436 8317 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8317 31 o o NNP 40436 8317 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8317 33 Pô Pô NNP 40436 8317 34 = = SYM 40436 8317 35 los los NNP 40436 8317 36 , , , 40436 8317 37 pa pa NNP 40436 8317 38 / / SYM 40436 8317 39 nta nta NNP 40436 8317 40 tau tau NNP 40436 8317 41 = = SYM 40436 8317 42 t t NNP 40436 8317 43 ' ' '' 40436 8317 44 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 8317 45 Pla Pla NNP 40436 8317 46 / / SYM 40436 8317 47 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8317 48 , , , 40436 8317 49 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 8317 50 to\ to\ NN 40436 8317 51 dokou dokou NN 40436 8317 52 = = SYM 40436 8317 53 n n NNP 40436 8317 54 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 8317 55 tre tre NNP 40436 8317 56 / / SYM 40436 8317 57 pôn pôn NNP 40436 8317 58 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8317 59 lo lo NNP 40436 8317 60 / / SYM 40436 8317 61 gous gous JJ 40436 8317 62 ? ? . 40436 8317 63 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8318 1 Though though IN 40436 8318 2 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 8318 3 asks ask VBZ 40436 8318 4 reasonably reasonably RB 40436 8318 5 enough enough RB 40436 8318 6 , , , 40436 8318 7 Who who WP 40436 8318 8 is be VBZ 40436 8318 9 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 8318 10 of of IN 40436 8318 11 this?--the this?--the JJ 40436 8318 12 remarks remark NNS 40436 8318 13 of of IN 40436 8318 14 Stallbaum Stallbaum NNP 40436 8318 15 and and CC 40436 8318 16 others other NNS 40436 8318 17 often often RB 40436 8318 18 imply imply VBP 40436 8318 19 forgetfulness forgetfulness NN 40436 8318 20 of of IN 40436 8318 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8318 22 . . . 40436 8318 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8319 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8319 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8319 3 3 3 CD 40436 8319 4 : : : 40436 8319 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 8319 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8319 7 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 8319 8 zum zum VB 40436 8319 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8319 10 , , , 40436 8319 11 vol vol NNP 40436 8319 12 . . . 40436 8320 1 iii iii NNP 40436 8320 2 . . . 40436 8321 1 p. p. NN 40436 8321 2 22 22 CD 40436 8321 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8321 4 is be VBZ 40436 8321 5 of of IN 40436 8321 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 8321 7 that that IN 40436 8321 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8321 9 composed compose VBD 40436 8321 10 the the DT 40436 8321 11 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8321 12 shortly shortly RB 40436 8321 13 after after IN 40436 8321 14 returning return VBG 40436 8321 15 from from IN 40436 8321 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8321 17 first first JJ 40436 8321 18 voyage voyage NN 40436 8321 19 to to IN 40436 8321 20 Sicily Sicily NNP 40436 8321 21 , , , 40436 8321 22 387 387 CD 40436 8321 23 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 8322 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8322 2 shall shall MD 40436 8322 3 not not RB 40436 8322 4 contradict contradict VB 40436 8322 5 this this DT 40436 8322 6 : : : 40436 8322 7 but but CC 40436 8322 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8322 9 see see VBP 40436 8322 10 nothing nothing NN 40436 8322 11 to to TO 40436 8322 12 prove prove VB 40436 8322 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8322 14 . . . 40436 8323 1 At at IN 40436 8323 2 the the DT 40436 8323 3 same same JJ 40436 8323 4 time time NN 40436 8323 5 , , , 40436 8323 6 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 8323 7 assumes assume VBZ 40436 8323 8 as as RB 40436 8323 9 certain certain JJ 40436 8323 10 that that IN 40436 8323 11 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40436 8323 12 in in IN 40436 8323 13 the the DT 40436 8323 14 Ekklesiazusæ Ekklesiazusæ NNP 40436 8323 15 alludes allude NNS 40436 8323 16 to to IN 40436 8323 17 the the DT 40436 8323 18 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 8323 19 published publish VBN 40436 8323 20 by by IN 40436 8323 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8323 22 in in IN 40436 8323 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8323 24 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8323 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8323 26 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 8323 27 zum zum VBP 40436 8323 28 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8323 29 , , , 40436 8323 30 p. p. NN 40436 8323 31 20 20 CD 40436 8323 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8323 33 . . . 40436 8324 1 Putting put VBG 40436 8324 2 these these DT 40436 8324 3 two two CD 40436 8324 4 statements statement NNS 40436 8324 5 together together RB 40436 8324 6 , , , 40436 8324 7 the the DT 40436 8324 8 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8324 9 would would MD 40436 8324 10 be be VB 40436 8324 11 later later RB 40436 8324 12 in in IN 40436 8324 13 date date NN 40436 8324 14 of of IN 40436 8324 15 composition composition NN 40436 8324 16 than than IN 40436 8324 17 the the DT 40436 8324 18 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8324 19 , , , 40436 8324 20 which which WDT 40436 8324 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8324 22 hardly hardly RB 40436 8324 23 think think VBP 40436 8324 24 probable probable JJ 40436 8324 25 . . . 40436 8325 1 However however RB 40436 8325 2 , , , 40436 8325 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8325 4 do do VBP 40436 8325 5 not not RB 40436 8325 6 at at RB 40436 8325 7 all all RB 40436 8325 8 believe believe VB 40436 8325 9 that that IN 40436 8325 10 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40436 8325 11 in in IN 40436 8325 12 the the DT 40436 8325 13 Ekklesiazusæ Ekklesiazusæ NNP 40436 8325 14 makes make VBZ 40436 8325 15 any any DT 40436 8325 16 allusion allusion NN 40436 8325 17 to to IN 40436 8325 18 the the DT 40436 8325 19 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8325 20 of of IN 40436 8325 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8325 22 . . . 40436 8326 1 Nor nor CC 40436 8326 2 shall shall MD 40436 8326 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8326 4 believe believe VB 40436 8326 5 , , , 40436 8326 6 until until IN 40436 8326 7 some some DT 40436 8326 8 evidence evidence NN 40436 8326 9 is be VBZ 40436 8326 10 produced produce VBN 40436 8326 11 , , , 40436 8326 12 that that IN 40436 8326 13 the the DT 40436 8326 14 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8326 15 was be VBD 40436 8326 16 composed compose VBN 40436 8326 17 at at IN 40436 8326 18 so so RB 40436 8326 19 early early RB 40436 8326 20 a a DT 40436 8326 21 date date NN 40436 8326 22 as as IN 40436 8326 23 390 390 CD 40436 8326 24 B.C. B.C. NNP 40436 8326 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8327 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8327 2 Side side NN 40436 8327 3 - - HYPH 40436 8327 4 note note NN 40436 8327 5 : : : 40436 8327 6 Introductory introductory JJ 40436 8327 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 8327 8 of of IN 40436 8327 9 the the DT 40436 8327 10 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8327 11 . . . 40436 8328 1 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8328 2 and and CC 40436 8328 3 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8328 4 . . . 40436 8328 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8329 1 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8329 2 and and CC 40436 8329 3 Chærephon Chærephon NNP 40436 8329 4 are be VBP 40436 8329 5 described describe VBN 40436 8329 6 as as IN 40436 8329 7 intending intend VBG 40436 8329 8 to to TO 40436 8329 9 come come VB 40436 8329 10 to to IN 40436 8329 11 a a DT 40436 8329 12 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 8329 13 lecture lecture NN 40436 8329 14 of of IN 40436 8329 15 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8329 16 , , , 40436 8329 17 but but CC 40436 8329 18 as as IN 40436 8329 19 having have VBG 40436 8329 20 been be VBN 40436 8329 21 accidentally accidentally RB 40436 8329 22 detained detain VBN 40436 8329 23 so so RB 40436 8329 24 as as IN 40436 8329 25 not not RB 40436 8329 26 to to TO 40436 8329 27 arrive arrive VB 40436 8329 28 until until IN 40436 8329 29 just just RB 40436 8329 30 after after IN 40436 8329 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8329 32 has have VBZ 40436 8329 33 been be VBN 40436 8329 34 finished finish VBN 40436 8329 35 , , , 40436 8329 36 with with IN 40436 8329 37 brilliant brilliant JJ 40436 8329 38 success success NN 40436 8329 39 . . . 40436 8330 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 8330 2 , , , 40436 8330 3 however however RB 40436 8330 4 , , , 40436 8330 5 the the DT 40436 8330 6 host host NN 40436 8330 7 and and CC 40436 8330 8 friend friend NN 40436 8330 9 of of IN 40436 8330 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8330 11 , , , 40436 8330 12 promises promise VBZ 40436 8330 13 that that IN 40436 8330 14 the the DT 40436 8330 15 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 8330 16 will will MD 40436 8330 17 readily readily RB 40436 8330 18 answer answer VB 40436 8330 19 any any DT 40436 8330 20 questions question NNS 40436 8330 21 put put VBN 40436 8330 22 by by IN 40436 8330 23 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8330 24 ; ; : 40436 8330 25 which which WDT 40436 8330 26 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8330 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8330 28 confirms confirm VBZ 40436 8330 29 , , , 40436 8330 30 observing observe VBG 40436 8330 31 at at IN 40436 8330 32 the the DT 40436 8330 33 same same JJ 40436 8330 34 time time NN 40436 8330 35 that that WDT 40436 8330 36 no no DT 40436 8330 37 one one NN 40436 8330 38 had have VBD 40436 8330 39 asked ask VBN 40436 8330 40 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8330 41 any any DT 40436 8330 42 new new JJ 40436 8330 43 question question NN 40436 8330 44 for for IN 40436 8330 45 many many JJ 40436 8330 46 years year NNS 40436 8330 47 past past JJ 40436 8330 48 . . . 40436 8331 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8331 2 4 4 LS 40436 8331 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8331 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8331 5 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 8331 6 asks ask VBZ 40436 8331 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8331 8 what what WP 40436 8331 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8331 10 profession profession NN 40436 8331 11 is be VBZ 40436 8331 12 ? ? . 40436 8332 1 what what WP 40436 8332 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8332 3 is be VBZ 40436 8332 4 that that IN 40436 8332 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8332 6 teaches teach VBZ 40436 8332 7 ? ? . 40436 8333 1 what what WP 40436 8333 2 is be VBZ 40436 8333 3 the the DT 40436 8333 4 definition definition NN 40436 8333 5 of of IN 40436 8333 6 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8333 7 ? ? . 40436 8334 1 Not not RB 40436 8334 2 receiving receive VBG 40436 8334 3 a a DT 40436 8334 4 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 8334 5 answer answer NN 40436 8334 6 , , , 40436 8334 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8334 8 furnishes furnish VBZ 40436 8334 9 a a DT 40436 8334 10 definition definition NN 40436 8334 11 of of IN 40436 8334 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8334 13 own own JJ 40436 8334 14 : : : 40436 8334 15 out out IN 40436 8334 16 of of IN 40436 8334 17 which which WDT 40436 8334 18 grow grow VBP 40436 8334 19 two two CD 40436 8334 20 arguments argument NNS 40436 8334 21 of of IN 40436 8334 22 wide wide JJ 40436 8334 23 ethical ethical JJ 40436 8334 24 bearing bearing NN 40436 8334 25 : : : 40436 8334 26 carried carry VBN 40436 8334 27 on on RP 40436 8334 28 by by IN 40436 8334 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8334 30 , , , 40436 8334 31 the the DT 40436 8334 32 first first JJ 40436 8334 33 against against IN 40436 8334 34 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8334 35 , , , 40436 8334 36 the the DT 40436 8334 37 second second JJ 40436 8334 38 against against IN 40436 8334 39 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8334 40 . . . 40436 8335 1 Both both DT 40436 8335 2 these these DT 40436 8335 3 two two CD 40436 8335 4 are be VBP 40436 8335 5 represented represent VBN 40436 8335 6 as as IN 40436 8335 7 voluble voluble JJ 40436 8335 8 speakers speaker NNS 40436 8335 9 , , , 40436 8335 10 of of IN 40436 8335 11 confident confident JJ 40436 8335 12 temper temper NN 40436 8335 13 , , , 40436 8335 14 regarding regard VBG 40436 8335 15 the the DT 40436 8335 16 acquisition acquisition NN 40436 8335 17 of of IN 40436 8335 18 political political JJ 40436 8335 19 power power NN 40436 8335 20 and and CC 40436 8335 21 oratorical oratorical JJ 40436 8335 22 celebrity celebrity NN 40436 8335 23 as as IN 40436 8335 24 the the DT 40436 8335 25 grand grand JJ 40436 8335 26 objects object NNS 40436 8335 27 of of IN 40436 8335 28 life life NN 40436 8335 29 . . . 40436 8336 1 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8336 2 had have VBD 40436 8336 3 even even RB 40436 8336 4 composed compose VBN 40436 8336 5 a a DT 40436 8336 6 work work NN 40436 8336 7 on on IN 40436 8336 8 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8336 9 , , , 40436 8336 10 of of IN 40436 8336 11 which which WDT 40436 8336 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8336 13 know know VBP 40436 8336 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 8336 15 : : : 40436 8336 16 but but CC 40436 8336 17 the the DT 40436 8336 18 tone tone NN 40436 8336 19 of of IN 40436 8336 20 this this DT 40436 8336 21 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8336 22 would would MD 40436 8336 23 seem seem VB 40436 8336 24 to to TO 40436 8336 25 indicate indicate VB 40436 8336 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8336 27 as as RB 40436 8336 28 far far RB 40436 8336 29 as as IN 40436 8336 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8336 31 can can MD 40436 8336 32 judge judge VB 40436 8336 33 from from IN 40436 8336 34 such such JJ 40436 8336 35 evidence evidence NN 40436 8336 36 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8336 37 that that IN 40436 8336 38 the the DT 40436 8336 39 style style NN 40436 8336 40 of of IN 40436 8336 41 the the DT 40436 8336 42 work work NN 40436 8336 43 was be VBD 40436 8336 44 affected affect VBN 40436 8336 45 , , , 40436 8336 46 and and CC 40436 8336 47 the the DT 40436 8336 48 temper temper NN 40436 8336 49 of of IN 40436 8336 50 the the DT 40436 8336 51 author author NN 40436 8336 52 flippant flippant NN 40436 8336 53 . . . 40436 8337 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8337 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8337 3 4 4 CD 40436 8337 4 : : : 40436 8337 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8337 6 , , , 40436 8337 7 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 8337 8 . . . 40436 8338 1 pp pp NNP 40436 8338 2 . . . 40436 8339 1 447 447 CD 40436 8339 2 - - SYM 40436 8339 3 448 448 CD 40436 8339 4 A. a. NN 40436 8340 1 The the DT 40436 8340 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8340 3 is be VBZ 40436 8340 4 supposed suppose VBN 40436 8340 5 to to TO 40436 8340 6 be be VB 40436 8340 7 carried carry VBN 40436 8340 8 on on RP 40436 8340 9 in in IN 40436 8340 10 the the DT 40436 8340 11 presence presence NN 40436 8340 12 of of IN 40436 8340 13 many many JJ 40436 8340 14 persons person NNS 40436 8340 15 , , , 40436 8340 16 seemingly seemingly RB 40436 8340 17 belonging belong VBG 40436 8340 18 to to IN 40436 8340 19 the the DT 40436 8340 20 auditory auditory NN 40436 8340 21 of of IN 40436 8340 22 the the DT 40436 8340 23 lecture lecture NN 40436 8340 24 which which WDT 40436 8340 25 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8340 26 has have VBZ 40436 8340 27 just just RB 40436 8340 28 finished finish VBN 40436 8340 29 , , , 40436 8340 30 p. p. NN 40436 8340 31 455 455 CD 40436 8340 32 C. C. NNP 40436 8340 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8340 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8340 35 Side side NN 40436 8340 36 - - HYPH 40436 8340 37 note note NN 40436 8340 38 : : : 40436 8340 39 Purpose purpose NN 40436 8340 40 of of IN 40436 8340 41 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8340 42 in in IN 40436 8340 43 questioning questioning NN 40436 8340 44 . . . 40436 8341 1 Conditions condition NNS 40436 8341 2 of of IN 40436 8341 3 a a DT 40436 8341 4 good good JJ 40436 8341 5 definition definition NN 40436 8341 6 . . . 40436 8341 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8342 1 Here here RB 40436 8342 2 , , , 40436 8342 3 as as IN 40436 8342 4 in in IN 40436 8342 5 the the DT 40436 8342 6 other other JJ 40436 8342 7 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8342 8 above above IN 40436 8342 9 noticed notice VBD 40436 8342 10 , , , 40436 8342 11 the the DT 40436 8342 12 avowed avowed JJ 40436 8342 13 aim aim NN 40436 8342 14 of of IN 40436 8342 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8342 16 is be VBZ 40436 8342 17 -- -- : 40436 8342 18 first first RB 40436 8342 19 , , , 40436 8342 20 to to TO 40436 8342 21 exclude exclude VB 40436 8342 22 long long JJ 40436 8342 23 speaking speaking NN 40436 8342 24 -- -- : 40436 8342 25 next next RB 40436 8342 26 , , , 40436 8342 27 to to TO 40436 8342 28 get get VB 40436 8342 29 the the DT 40436 8342 30 question question NN 40436 8342 31 accurately accurately RB 40436 8342 32 conceived conceive VBN 40436 8342 33 , , , 40436 8342 34 and and CC 40436 8342 35 answered answer VBD 40436 8342 36 in in IN 40436 8342 37 an an DT 40436 8342 38 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 8342 39 manner manner NN 40436 8342 40 . . . 40436 8343 1 Specimens specimen NNS 40436 8343 2 are be VBP 40436 8343 3 given give VBN 40436 8343 4 of of IN 40436 8343 5 unsuitable unsuitable JJ 40436 8343 6 and and CC 40436 8343 7 inaccurate inaccurate JJ 40436 8343 8 answers answer NNS 40436 8343 9 , , , 40436 8343 10 which which WDT 40436 8343 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8343 12 corrects correct VBZ 40436 8343 13 . . . 40436 8344 1 The the DT 40436 8344 2 conditions condition NNS 40436 8344 3 of of IN 40436 8344 4 a a DT 40436 8344 5 good good JJ 40436 8344 6 definition definition NN 40436 8344 7 are be VBP 40436 8344 8 made make VBN 40436 8344 9 plain plain JJ 40436 8344 10 by by IN 40436 8344 11 contrast contrast NN 40436 8344 12 with with IN 40436 8344 13 bad bad JJ 40436 8344 14 ones one NNS 40436 8344 15 ; ; : 40436 8344 16 which which WDT 40436 8344 17 either either CC 40436 8344 18 include include VBP 40436 8344 19 much much RB 40436 8344 20 more more JJR 40436 8344 21 than than IN 40436 8344 22 the the DT 40436 8344 23 thing thing NN 40436 8344 24 defined define VBN 40436 8344 25 , , , 40436 8344 26 or or CC 40436 8344 27 set set VBD 40436 8344 28 forth forth RP 40436 8344 29 what what WP 40436 8344 30 is be VBZ 40436 8344 31 accessory accessory JJ 40436 8344 32 and and CC 40436 8344 33 occasional occasional JJ 40436 8344 34 in in IN 40436 8344 35 place place NN 40436 8344 36 of of IN 40436 8344 37 what what WP 40436 8344 38 is be VBZ 40436 8344 39 essential essential JJ 40436 8344 40 and and CC 40436 8344 41 constant constant JJ 40436 8344 42 . . . 40436 8345 1 These these DT 40436 8345 2 tentatives tentative NNS 40436 8345 3 and and CC 40436 8345 4 gropings groping NNS 40436 8345 5 to to TO 40436 8345 6 find find VB 40436 8345 7 a a DT 40436 8345 8 definition definition NN 40436 8345 9 are be VBP 40436 8345 10 always always RB 40436 8345 11 instructive instructive JJ 40436 8345 12 , , , 40436 8345 13 and and CC 40436 8345 14 must must MD 40436 8345 15 have have VB 40436 8345 16 been be VBN 40436 8345 17 especially especially RB 40436 8345 18 so so RB 40436 8345 19 in in IN 40436 8345 20 the the DT 40436 8345 21 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8345 22 age age NN 40436 8345 23 , , , 40436 8345 24 when when WRB 40436 8345 25 logical logical JJ 40436 8345 26 distinctions distinction NNS 40436 8345 27 had have VBD 40436 8345 28 never never RB 40436 8345 29 yet yet RB 40436 8345 30 been be VBN 40436 8345 31 made make VBN 40436 8345 32 a a DT 40436 8345 33 subject subject NN 40436 8345 34 of of IN 40436 8345 35 separate separate JJ 40436 8345 36 attention attention NN 40436 8345 37 or or CC 40436 8345 38 analysis analysis NN 40436 8345 39 . . . 40436 8346 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8346 2 Side side NN 40436 8346 3 - - HYPH 40436 8346 4 note note NN 40436 8346 5 : : : 40436 8346 6 Questions question NNS 40436 8346 7 about about IN 40436 8346 8 the the DT 40436 8346 9 definition definition NN 40436 8346 10 of of IN 40436 8346 11 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8346 12 . . . 40436 8347 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8347 2 is be VBZ 40436 8347 3 the the DT 40436 8347 4 artisan artisan NNP 40436 8347 5 of of IN 40436 8347 6 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8347 7 . . . 40436 8347 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8348 1 About about IN 40436 8348 2 what what WP 40436 8348 3 is be VBZ 40436 8348 4 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8348 5 as as IN 40436 8348 6 a a DT 40436 8348 7 cognition cognition NN 40436 8348 8 concerned concern VBN 40436 8348 9 , , , 40436 8348 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8348 11 ? ? . 40436 8349 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8349 2 Gorg._--About Gorg._--About NNP 40436 8349 3 words word NNS 40436 8349 4 or or CC 40436 8349 5 discourses discourse NNS 40436 8349 6 . . . 40436 8350 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8350 2 Sokr._--About Sokr._--About NNP 40436 8350 3 what what WP 40436 8350 4 discourses discourse VBZ 40436 8350 5 ? ? . 40436 8351 1 such such JJ 40436 8351 2 as as IN 40436 8351 3 inform inform JJ 40436 8351 4 sick sick JJ 40436 8351 5 men man NNS 40436 8351 6 how how WRB 40436 8351 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8351 8 are be VBP 40436 8351 9 to to TO 40436 8351 10 get get VB 40436 8351 11 well well JJ 40436 8351 12 ? ? . 40436 8352 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8352 2 Gorg._--No Gorg._--No NNP 40436 8352 3 . . . 40436 8353 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8353 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 8353 3 is be VBZ 40436 8353 4 not not RB 40436 8353 5 about about IN 40436 8353 6 all all DT 40436 8353 7 discourses discourse NNS 40436 8353 8 ? ? . 40436 8354 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8354 2 Gorg._--It Gorg._--It NNP 40436 8354 3 makes make VBZ 40436 8354 4 men man NNS 40436 8354 5 competent competent JJ 40436 8354 6 to to TO 40436 8354 7 speak speak VB 40436 8354 8 : : : 40436 8354 9 of of RB 40436 8354 10 course course NN 40436 8354 11 therefore therefore RB 40436 8354 12 also also RB 40436 8354 13 to to TO 40436 8354 14 think think VB 40436 8354 15 , , , 40436 8354 16 upon upon IN 40436 8354 17 the the DT 40436 8354 18 matters matter NNS 40436 8354 19 on on IN 40436 8354 20 which which WDT 40436 8354 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8354 22 speak speak VBP 40436 8354 23 . . . 40436 8355 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8355 2 5 5 CD 40436 8355 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8355 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8355 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 8355 6 the the DT 40436 8355 7 medical medical JJ 40436 8355 8 and and CC 40436 8355 9 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 8355 10 arts art NNS 40436 8355 11 do do VBP 40436 8355 12 this this DT 40436 8355 13 likewise likewise RB 40436 8355 14 , , , 40436 8355 15 each each DT 40436 8355 16 with with IN 40436 8355 17 reference reference NN 40436 8355 18 to to IN 40436 8355 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8355 20 respective respective JJ 40436 8355 21 subject subject NN 40436 8355 22 : : : 40436 8355 23 what what WP 40436 8355 24 then then RB 40436 8355 25 is be VBZ 40436 8355 26 the the DT 40436 8355 27 difference difference NN 40436 8355 28 between between IN 40436 8355 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8355 30 and and CC 40436 8355 31 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8355 32 ? ? . 40436 8356 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8356 2 Gorg._--The Gorg._--The NNP 40436 8356 3 difference difference NN 40436 8356 4 is be VBZ 40436 8356 5 , , , 40436 8356 6 that that IN 40436 8356 7 each each DT 40436 8356 8 of of IN 40436 8356 9 these these DT 40436 8356 10 other other JJ 40436 8356 11 arts art NNS 40436 8356 12 tends tend VBZ 40436 8356 13 mainly mainly RB 40436 8356 14 towards towards IN 40436 8356 15 some some DT 40436 8356 16 actual actual JJ 40436 8356 17 work work NN 40436 8356 18 or or CC 40436 8356 19 performance performance NN 40436 8356 20 , , , 40436 8356 21 to to TO 40436 8356 22 which which WDT 40436 8356 23 the the DT 40436 8356 24 discourses discourse NNS 40436 8356 25 , , , 40436 8356 26 when when WRB 40436 8356 27 required require VBN 40436 8356 28 at at RB 40436 8356 29 all all RB 40436 8356 30 , , , 40436 8356 31 are be VBP 40436 8356 32 subsidiary subsidiary NN 40436 8356 33 : : : 40436 8356 34 but but CC 40436 8356 35 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8356 36 accomplishes accomplish VBZ 40436 8356 37 every every DT 40436 8356 38 thing thing NN 40436 8356 39 by by IN 40436 8356 40 discourses discourse NNS 40436 8356 41 alone alone RB 40436 8356 42 . . . 40436 8357 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8357 2 6 6 CD 40436 8357 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8357 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8357 5 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 8357 6 the the DT 40436 8357 7 same same JJ 40436 8357 8 may may MD 40436 8357 9 be be VB 40436 8357 10 said say VBN 40436 8357 11 about about IN 40436 8357 12 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 8357 13 , , , 40436 8357 14 geometry geometry NN 40436 8357 15 , , , 40436 8357 16 and and CC 40436 8357 17 other other JJ 40436 8357 18 sciences science NNS 40436 8357 19 . . . 40436 8358 1 How how WRB 40436 8358 2 are be VBP 40436 8358 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8358 4 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 8358 5 from from IN 40436 8358 6 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8358 7 ? ? . 40436 8359 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 8359 2 must must MD 40436 8359 3 tell tell VB 40436 8359 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8359 5 upon upon IN 40436 8359 6 what what WP 40436 8359 7 matters matter VBZ 40436 8359 8 the the DT 40436 8359 9 discourses discourse NNS 40436 8359 10 with with IN 40436 8359 11 which which WDT 40436 8359 12 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8359 13 is be VBZ 40436 8359 14 conversant conversant JJ 40436 8359 15 turn turn NN 40436 8359 16 ; ; : 40436 8359 17 just just RB 40436 8359 18 as as IN 40436 8359 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8359 20 would would MD 40436 8359 21 tell tell VB 40436 8359 22 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8359 23 , , , 40436 8359 24 if if IN 40436 8359 25 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8359 26 asked ask VBD 40436 8359 27 the the DT 40436 8359 28 like like JJ 40436 8359 29 question question NN 40436 8359 30 about about IN 40436 8359 31 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 40436 8359 32 or or CC 40436 8359 33 astronomy astronomy NN 40436 8359 34 . . . 40436 8360 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8360 2 Gorg._--The Gorg._--The NNP 40436 8360 3 discourses discourse NNS 40436 8360 4 , , , 40436 8360 5 with with IN 40436 8360 6 which which WDT 40436 8360 7 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8360 8 is be VBZ 40436 8360 9 conversant conversant JJ 40436 8360 10 , , , 40436 8360 11 turn turn VB 40436 8360 12 upon upon IN 40436 8360 13 the the DT 40436 8360 14 greatest great JJS 40436 8360 15 of of IN 40436 8360 16 all all DT 40436 8360 17 human human JJ 40436 8360 18 affairs affair NNS 40436 8360 19 . . . 40436 8361 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8361 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 8361 3 this this DT 40436 8361 4 too too RB 40436 8361 5 , , , 40436 8361 6 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8361 7 , , , 40436 8361 8 is be VBZ 40436 8361 9 indistinct indistinct JJ 40436 8361 10 and and CC 40436 8361 11 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 8361 12 . . . 40436 8362 1 Every every DT 40436 8362 2 man man NN 40436 8362 3 , , , 40436 8362 4 the the DT 40436 8362 5 physician physician NN 40436 8362 6 , , , 40436 8362 7 the the DT 40436 8362 8 gymnast gymnast NN 40436 8362 9 , , , 40436 8362 10 the the DT 40436 8362 11 money money NN 40436 8362 12 - - HYPH 40436 8362 13 maker maker NN 40436 8362 14 , , , 40436 8362 15 thinks think VBZ 40436 8362 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8362 17 own own JJ 40436 8362 18 object object NN 40436 8362 19 and and CC 40436 8362 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8362 21 own own JJ 40436 8362 22 affairs affair NNS 40436 8362 23 the the DT 40436 8362 24 greatest great JJS 40436 8362 25 of of IN 40436 8362 26 all all DT 40436 8362 27 . . . 40436 8363 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8363 2 7 7 CD 40436 8363 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8363 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8363 5 Gorg._--The Gorg._--The NNP 40436 8363 6 function function NN 40436 8363 7 of of IN 40436 8363 8 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8363 9 , , , 40436 8363 10 is be VBZ 40436 8363 11 to to TO 40436 8363 12 persuade persuade VB 40436 8363 13 assembled assemble VBN 40436 8363 14 multitudes multitude NNS 40436 8363 15 , , , 40436 8363 16 and and CC 40436 8363 17 thus thus RB 40436 8363 18 to to TO 40436 8363 19 secure secure VB 40436 8363 20 what what WP 40436 8363 21 are be VBP 40436 8363 22 in in IN 40436 8363 23 truth truth NN 40436 8363 24 the the DT 40436 8363 25 greatest great JJS 40436 8363 26 benefits benefit NNS 40436 8363 27 : : : 40436 8363 28 freedom freedom NN 40436 8363 29 to to IN 40436 8363 30 the the DT 40436 8363 31 city city NN 40436 8363 32 , , , 40436 8363 33 political political JJ 40436 8363 34 command command NN 40436 8363 35 to to IN 40436 8363 36 the the DT 40436 8363 37 speaker speaker NN 40436 8363 38 . . . 40436 8364 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8364 2 8 8 CD 40436 8364 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8364 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8364 5 Sokr._--Rhetoric Sokr._--Rhetoric NNP 40436 8364 6 is be VBZ 40436 8364 7 then then RB 40436 8364 8 the the DT 40436 8364 9 artisan artisan NNP 40436 8364 10 of of IN 40436 8364 11 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8364 12 . . . 40436 8365 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8365 2 single single JJ 40436 8365 3 purpose purpose NN 40436 8365 4 is be VBZ 40436 8365 5 to to TO 40436 8365 6 produce produce VB 40436 8365 7 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8365 8 in in IN 40436 8365 9 the the DT 40436 8365 10 minds mind NNS 40436 8365 11 of of IN 40436 8365 12 hearers hearer NNS 40436 8365 13 ? ? . 40436 8366 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8366 2 Gorg._--It Gorg._--It NNP 40436 8366 3 is be VBZ 40436 8366 4 so so RB 40436 8366 5 . . . 40436 8367 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8367 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8367 3 5 5 CD 40436 8367 4 : : : 40436 8367 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8367 6 , , , 40436 8367 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8367 8 , , , 40436 8367 9 p. p. NN 40436 8367 10 449 449 CD 40436 8367 11 E. E. NNP 40436 8367 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8367 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8367 14 : : : 40436 8367 15 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 8367 16 = = SYM 40436 8367 17 n n CC 40436 8367 18 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 8367 19 ô(=nper ô(=nper NNP 40436 8367 20 le le NNP 40436 8367 21 / / SYM 40436 8367 22 gein gein NNP 40436 8367 23 , , , 40436 8367 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8367 25 phronei phronei NNP 40436 8367 26 = = SYM 40436 8367 27 n n NNP 40436 8367 28 ? ? . 40436 8368 1 Pô Pô NNP 40436 8368 2 = = NFP 40436 8368 3 s s NNP 40436 8368 4 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8368 5 ou)/ ou)/ RB 40436 8368 6 ? ? . 40436 8368 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8368 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8369 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8369 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8369 3 6 6 CD 40436 8369 4 : : : 40436 8369 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8369 6 , , , 40436 8369 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8369 8 , , , 40436 8369 9 p. p. NN 40436 8369 10 450 450 CD 40436 8369 11 B B NNP 40436 8369 12 - - HYPH 40436 8369 13 C. C. NNP 40436 8369 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8369 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8369 16 : : : 40436 8369 17 tê tê NNP 40436 8369 18 = = SYM 40436 8369 19 s s NNP 40436 8369 20 r(êtorikê r(êtorikê NNP 40436 8369 21 = = SYM 40436 8369 22 s s NN 40436 8369 23 . . . 40436 8370 1 . . . 40436 8371 1 . . . 40436 8372 1 . . . 40436 8373 1 pa pa NNP 40436 8373 2 = = SYM 40436 8373 3 sa sa NNP 40436 8373 4 ê ê NNP 40436 8373 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8373 6 pra pra NNP 40436 8373 7 = = SYM 40436 8373 8 xis xis NNP 40436 8373 9 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8373 10 ê ê NNP 40436 8373 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8373 12 ku ku NNP 40436 8373 13 / / SYM 40436 8373 14 rôsis rôsis NNP 40436 8373 15 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 8373 16 lo lo NNP 40436 8373 17 / / SYM 40436 8373 18 gôn gôn NNP 40436 8373 19 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 8373 20 / / SYM 40436 8373 21 n n NN 40436 8373 22 . . . 40436 8374 1 . . . 40436 8375 1 . . . 40436 8376 1 . . . 40436 8376 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8376 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8377 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8377 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8377 3 7 7 CD 40436 8377 4 : : : 40436 8377 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8377 6 , , , 40436 8377 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8377 8 , , , 40436 8377 9 pp pp NNP 40436 8377 10 . . . 40436 8378 1 451 451 CD 40436 8378 2 - - SYM 40436 8378 3 452 452 CD 40436 8378 4 . . . 40436 8378 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8379 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8379 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8379 3 8 8 CD 40436 8379 4 : : : 40436 8379 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8379 6 , , , 40436 8379 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8379 8 , , , 40436 8379 9 p. p. NN 40436 8379 10 452 452 CD 40436 8379 11 D. D. NNP 40436 8379 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8379 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8379 14 : : : 40436 8379 15 O(/per o(/per LS 40436 8379 16 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 8379 17 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 8379 18 a)lêthei a)lêthei NNS 40436 8379 19 / / SYM 40436 8379 20 a| a| VBP 40436 8379 21 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8379 22 / / SYM 40436 8379 23 giston giston NNP 40436 8379 24 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 8379 25 / / SYM 40436 8379 26 n n NNP 40436 8379 27 , , , 40436 8379 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8379 29 ai)/tion ai)/tion NNP 40436 8379 30 , , , 40436 8379 31 a)/ma a)/ma NNP 40436 8379 32 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8379 33 e)leutheri e)leutheri NNP 40436 8379 34 / / SYM 40436 8379 35 as as IN 40436 8379 36 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 8379 37 = = SYM 40436 8379 38 s s NNP 40436 8379 39 toi toi NNP 40436 8379 40 = = SYM 40436 8379 41 s s NNP 40436 8379 42 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 8379 43 / / SYM 40436 8379 44 pois pois NN 40436 8379 45 , , , 40436 8379 46 a)/ma a)/ma NNP 40436 8379 47 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8379 48 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8379 49 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 8379 50 a)/rchein a)/rchein NNP 40436 8379 51 e)n e)n NNP 40436 8379 52 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 8379 53 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 8379 54 po po NN 40436 8379 55 / / SYM 40436 8379 56 lei lei NN 40436 8379 57 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 8379 58 / / SYM 40436 8379 59 stô| stô| ADD 40436 8379 60 . . . 40436 8379 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8379 62 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8380 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8380 2 Side side NN 40436 8380 3 - - HYPH 40436 8380 4 note note NN 40436 8380 5 : : : 40436 8380 6 The the DT 40436 8380 7 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8380 8 produces produce VBZ 40436 8380 9 belief belief NN 40436 8380 10 without without IN 40436 8380 11 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8380 12 . . . 40436 8381 1 Upon upon IN 40436 8381 2 what what WP 40436 8381 3 matters matter NNS 40436 8381 4 is be VBZ 40436 8381 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8381 6 competent competent JJ 40436 8381 7 to to TO 40436 8381 8 advise advise VB 40436 8381 9 ? ? . 40436 8381 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8382 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8382 2 Sokr._--But Sokr._--But NNP 40436 8382 3 are be VBP 40436 8382 4 there there EX 40436 8382 5 not not RB 40436 8382 6 other other JJ 40436 8382 7 persons person NNS 40436 8382 8 besides besides IN 40436 8382 9 the the DT 40436 8382 10 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8382 11 , , , 40436 8382 12 who who WP 40436 8382 13 produce produce VBP 40436 8382 14 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8382 15 ? ? . 40436 8383 1 Does do VBZ 40436 8383 2 not not RB 40436 8383 3 the the DT 40436 8383 4 arithmetical arithmetical JJ 40436 8383 5 teacher teacher NN 40436 8383 6 , , , 40436 8383 7 and and CC 40436 8383 8 every every DT 40436 8383 9 other other JJ 40436 8383 10 teacher teacher NN 40436 8383 11 , , , 40436 8383 12 produce produce VB 40436 8383 13 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8383 14 ? ? . 40436 8384 1 How how WRB 40436 8384 2 does do VBZ 40436 8384 3 the the DT 40436 8384 4 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8384 5 differ differ VB 40436 8384 6 from from IN 40436 8384 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8384 8 ? ? . 40436 8385 1 What what WDT 40436 8385 2 mode mode NN 40436 8385 3 of of IN 40436 8385 4 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8385 5 does do VBZ 40436 8385 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8385 7 bring bring VB 40436 8385 8 about about RP 40436 8385 9 ? ? . 40436 8386 1 Persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8386 2 about about IN 40436 8386 3 what what WP 40436 8386 4 ? ? . 40436 8387 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8387 2 Gorg._--I Gorg._--I NNP 40436 8387 3 reply reply NN 40436 8387 4 -- -- : 40436 8387 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8387 6 is be VBZ 40436 8387 7 that that DT 40436 8387 8 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8387 9 which which WDT 40436 8387 10 is be VBZ 40436 8387 11 brought bring VBN 40436 8387 12 about about RP 40436 8387 13 in in IN 40436 8387 14 Dikasteries dikasterie NNS 40436 8387 15 , , , 40436 8387 16 and and CC 40436 8387 17 other other JJ 40436 8387 18 assembled assemble VBN 40436 8387 19 multitudes multitude NNS 40436 8387 20 -- -- : 40436 8387 21 and and CC 40436 8387 22 which which WDT 40436 8387 23 relates relate VBZ 40436 8387 24 to to IN 40436 8387 25 just just RB 40436 8387 26 and and CC 40436 8387 27 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8387 28 . . . 40436 8388 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8388 2 9 9 CD 40436 8388 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8388 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8388 5 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 8388 6 recognise recognise NN 40436 8388 7 that that DT 40436 8388 8 to to TO 40436 8388 9 have have VB 40436 8388 10 learnt learn VBN 40436 8388 11 and and CC 40436 8388 12 to to TO 40436 8388 13 know know VB 40436 8388 14 any any DT 40436 8388 15 matter matter NN 40436 8388 16 , , , 40436 8388 17 is be VBZ 40436 8388 18 one one CD 40436 8388 19 thing thing NN 40436 8388 20 -- -- : 40436 8388 21 to to TO 40436 8388 22 believe believe VB 40436 8388 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8388 24 , , , 40436 8388 25 is be VBZ 40436 8388 26 another another DT 40436 8388 27 : : : 40436 8388 28 that that IN 40436 8388 29 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8388 30 and and CC 40436 8388 31 belief belief NN 40436 8388 32 are be VBP 40436 8388 33 different different JJ 40436 8388 34 -- -- : 40436 8388 35 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8388 36 being be VBG 40436 8388 37 always always RB 40436 8388 38 true true JJ 40436 8388 39 , , , 40436 8388 40 belief belief NN 40436 8388 41 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 8388 42 false false JJ 40436 8388 43 ? ? . 40436 8389 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8389 2 Gorg._--Yes Gorg._--Yes NNP 40436 8389 3 . . . 40436 8390 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8390 2 Sokr._--We Sokr._--We NNP 40436 8390 3 must must MD 40436 8390 4 then then RB 40436 8390 5 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 8390 6 two two CD 40436 8390 7 sorts sort NNS 40436 8390 8 of of IN 40436 8390 9 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8390 10 : : : 40436 8390 11 one one CD 40436 8390 12 carrying carry VBG 40436 8390 13 with with IN 40436 8390 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8390 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8390 16 -- -- : 40436 8390 17 the the DT 40436 8390 18 other other JJ 40436 8390 19 belief belief NN 40436 8390 20 without without IN 40436 8390 21 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8390 22 . . . 40436 8391 1 Which which WDT 40436 8391 2 of of IN 40436 8391 3 the the DT 40436 8391 4 two two CD 40436 8391 5 does do VBZ 40436 8391 6 the the DT 40436 8391 7 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8391 8 bring bring VB 40436 8391 9 about about RP 40436 8391 10 ? ? . 40436 8392 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8392 2 Gorg._--That Gorg._--That NNP 40436 8392 3 which which WDT 40436 8392 4 produces produce VBZ 40436 8392 5 belief belief NN 40436 8392 6 without without IN 40436 8392 7 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8392 8 . . . 40436 8393 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8393 2 can can MD 40436 8393 3 teach teach VB 40436 8393 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 8393 5 . . . 40436 8394 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8394 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 8394 3 , , , 40436 8394 4 then then RB 40436 8394 5 , , , 40436 8394 6 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8394 7 , , , 40436 8394 8 on on IN 40436 8394 9 what what WDT 40436 8394 10 matters matter NNS 40436 8394 11 will will MD 40436 8394 12 the the DT 40436 8394 13 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8394 14 be be VB 40436 8394 15 competent competent JJ 40436 8394 16 to to TO 40436 8394 17 advise advise VB 40436 8394 18 ? ? . 40436 8395 1 When when WRB 40436 8395 2 the the DT 40436 8395 3 people people NNS 40436 8395 4 are be VBP 40436 8395 5 deliberating deliberate VBG 40436 8395 6 about about IN 40436 8395 7 the the DT 40436 8395 8 choice choice NN 40436 8395 9 of of IN 40436 8395 10 generals general NNS 40436 8395 11 or or CC 40436 8395 12 physicians physician NNS 40436 8395 13 , , , 40436 8395 14 about about IN 40436 8395 15 the the DT 40436 8395 16 construction construction NN 40436 8395 17 of of IN 40436 8395 18 docks dock NNS 40436 8395 19 , , , 40436 8395 20 about about IN 40436 8395 21 practical practical JJ 40436 8395 22 questions question NNS 40436 8395 23 of of IN 40436 8395 24 any any DT 40436 8395 25 kind kind NN 40436 8395 26 -- -- : 40436 8395 27 there there EX 40436 8395 28 will will MD 40436 8395 29 be be VB 40436 8395 30 in in IN 40436 8395 31 each each DT 40436 8395 32 case case NN 40436 8395 33 a a DT 40436 8395 34 special special JJ 40436 8395 35 man man NN 40436 8395 36 informed inform VBN 40436 8395 37 and and CC 40436 8395 38 competent competent JJ 40436 8395 39 to to TO 40436 8395 40 teach teach VB 40436 8395 41 or or CC 40436 8395 42 give give VB 40436 8395 43 counsel counsel NN 40436 8395 44 , , , 40436 8395 45 while while IN 40436 8395 46 the the DT 40436 8395 47 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8395 48 is be VBZ 40436 8395 49 not not RB 40436 8395 50 competent competent JJ 40436 8395 51 . . . 40436 8396 1 Upon upon IN 40436 8396 2 what what WP 40436 8396 3 then then RB 40436 8396 4 can can MD 40436 8396 5 the the DT 40436 8396 6 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8396 7 advise advise VB 40436 8396 8 -- -- : 40436 8396 9 upon upon IN 40436 8396 10 just just JJ 40436 8396 11 and and CC 40436 8396 12 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8396 13 -- -- : 40436 8396 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 8396 15 else else RB 40436 8396 16 ? ? . 40436 8397 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8397 2 10 10 CD 40436 8397 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8397 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8397 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8397 6 9 9 CD 40436 8397 7 : : : 40436 8397 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8397 9 , , , 40436 8397 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8397 11 , , , 40436 8397 12 p. p. NN 40436 8397 13 454 454 CD 40436 8397 14 B. B. NNP 40436 8397 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8398 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8398 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8398 3 10 10 CD 40436 8398 4 : : : 40436 8398 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8398 6 , , , 40436 8398 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8398 8 , , , 40436 8398 9 p. p. NN 40436 8398 10 455 455 CD 40436 8398 11 D. D. NNP 40436 8398 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8398 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8398 14 Side side NN 40436 8398 15 - - HYPH 40436 8398 16 note note NN 40436 8398 17 : : : 40436 8398 18 The the DT 40436 8398 19 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8398 20 can can MD 40436 8398 21 persuade persuade VB 40436 8398 22 the the DT 40436 8398 23 people people NNS 40436 8398 24 upon upon IN 40436 8398 25 any any DT 40436 8398 26 matter matter NN 40436 8398 27 , , , 40436 8398 28 even even RB 40436 8398 29 against against IN 40436 8398 30 the the DT 40436 8398 31 opinion opinion NN 40436 8398 32 of of IN 40436 8398 33 the the DT 40436 8398 34 special special JJ 40436 8398 35 expert expert NN 40436 8398 36 . . . 40436 8399 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8399 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 8399 3 to to TO 40436 8399 4 know know VB 40436 8399 5 , , , 40436 8399 6 among among IN 40436 8399 7 the the DT 40436 8399 8 ignorant ignorant NN 40436 8399 9 . . . 40436 8399 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8400 1 The the DT 40436 8400 2 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8400 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8400 4 says say VBZ 40436 8400 5 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8400 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8400 7 or or CC 40436 8400 8 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 8400 9 public public JJ 40436 8400 10 speaker speaker NN 40436 8400 11 , , , 40436 8400 12 will will MD 40436 8400 13 give give VB 40436 8400 14 advice advice NN 40436 8400 15 about about IN 40436 8400 16 all all PDT 40436 8400 17 the the DT 40436 8400 18 matters matter NNS 40436 8400 19 that that WDT 40436 8400 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8400 21 name name VBP 40436 8400 22 , , , 40436 8400 23 and and CC 40436 8400 24 others other NNS 40436 8400 25 besides besides RB 40436 8400 26 . . . 40436 8401 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8401 2 will will MD 40436 8401 3 persuade persuade VB 40436 8401 4 the the DT 40436 8401 5 people people NNS 40436 8401 6 and and CC 40436 8401 7 carry carry VB 40436 8401 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8401 9 along along RB 40436 8401 10 with with IN 40436 8401 11 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8401 12 , , , 40436 8401 13 even even RB 40436 8401 14 against against IN 40436 8401 15 the the DT 40436 8401 16 opinion opinion NN 40436 8401 17 of of IN 40436 8401 18 the the DT 40436 8401 19 special special JJ 40436 8401 20 _ _ NNP 40436 8401 21 Expert Expert NNP 40436 8401 22 _ _ NNP 40436 8401 23 . . . 40436 8402 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8402 2 will will MD 40436 8402 3 talk talk VB 40436 8402 4 more more RBR 40436 8402 5 persuasively persuasively RB 40436 8402 6 than than IN 40436 8402 7 the the DT 40436 8402 8 craftsman craftsman NN 40436 8402 9 about about IN 40436 8402 10 matters matter NNS 40436 8402 11 of of IN 40436 8402 12 the the DT 40436 8402 13 craftsman craftsman NN 40436 8402 14 's 's POS 40436 8402 15 own own JJ 40436 8402 16 business business NN 40436 8402 17 . . . 40436 8403 1 The the DT 40436 8403 2 power power NN 40436 8403 3 of of IN 40436 8403 4 the the DT 40436 8403 5 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8403 6 is be VBZ 40436 8403 7 thus thus RB 40436 8403 8 very very RB 40436 8403 9 great great JJ 40436 8403 10 : : : 40436 8403 11 but but CC 40436 8403 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8403 13 ought ought MD 40436 8403 14 to to TO 40436 8403 15 use use VB 40436 8403 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8403 17 , , , 40436 8403 18 like like IN 40436 8403 19 all all DT 40436 8403 20 other other JJ 40436 8403 21 powers power NNS 40436 8403 22 , , , 40436 8403 23 for for IN 40436 8403 24 just just RB 40436 8403 25 and and CC 40436 8403 26 honest honest JJ 40436 8403 27 purposes purpose NNS 40436 8403 28 ; ; : 40436 8403 29 not not RB 40436 8403 30 to to TO 40436 8403 31 abuse abuse VB 40436 8403 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8403 33 for for IN 40436 8403 34 wrong wrong NN 40436 8403 35 and and CC 40436 8403 36 oppression oppression NN 40436 8403 37 . . . 40436 8404 1 If if IN 40436 8404 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8404 3 does do VBZ 40436 8404 4 the the DT 40436 8404 5 latter latter JJ 40436 8404 6 , , , 40436 8404 7 the the DT 40436 8404 8 misdeed misdeed NN 40436 8404 9 is be VBZ 40436 8404 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8404 11 own own JJ 40436 8404 12 , , , 40436 8404 13 and and CC 40436 8404 14 not not RB 40436 8404 15 the the DT 40436 8404 16 fault fault NN 40436 8404 17 of of IN 40436 8404 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8404 19 teacher teacher NN 40436 8404 20 , , , 40436 8404 21 who who WP 40436 8404 22 gave give VBD 40436 8404 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8404 24 lessons lesson NNS 40436 8404 25 with with IN 40436 8404 26 a a DT 40436 8404 27 view view NN 40436 8404 28 that that IN 40436 8404 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8404 30 should should MD 40436 8404 31 be be VB 40436 8404 32 turned turn VBN 40436 8404 33 to to IN 40436 8404 34 proper proper JJ 40436 8404 35 use use NN 40436 8404 36 . . . 40436 8405 1 If if IN 40436 8405 2 a a DT 40436 8405 3 man man NN 40436 8405 4 , , , 40436 8405 5 who who WP 40436 8405 6 has have VBZ 40436 8405 7 learnt learn VBN 40436 8405 8 the the DT 40436 8405 9 use use NN 40436 8405 10 of of IN 40436 8405 11 arms arm NNS 40436 8405 12 , , , 40436 8405 13 employs employ VBZ 40436 8405 14 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8405 15 to to TO 40436 8405 16 commit commit VB 40436 8405 17 murder murder NN 40436 8405 18 , , , 40436 8405 19 this this DT 40436 8405 20 abuse abuse NN 40436 8405 21 ought ought MD 40436 8405 22 not not RB 40436 8405 23 to to TO 40436 8405 24 be be VB 40436 8405 25 imputed impute VBN 40436 8405 26 to to IN 40436 8405 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8405 28 master master NN 40436 8405 29 of of IN 40436 8405 30 arms arm NNS 40436 8405 31 . . . 40436 8406 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8406 2 11 11 CD 40436 8406 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8406 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8406 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8406 6 11 11 CD 40436 8406 7 : : : 40436 8406 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8406 9 , , , 40436 8406 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8406 11 , , , 40436 8406 12 pp pp NNP 40436 8406 13 . . . 40436 8407 1 456 456 CD 40436 8407 2 - - SYM 40436 8407 3 457 457 CD 40436 8407 4 . . . 40436 8407 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8408 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 8408 2 mean mean VBP 40436 8408 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8408 4 replies reply VBZ 40436 8408 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8408 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8408 7 that that IN 40436 8408 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8408 9 , , , 40436 8408 10 who who WP 40436 8408 11 has have VBZ 40436 8408 12 learnt learn VBN 40436 8408 13 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8408 14 from from IN 40436 8408 15 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8408 16 , , , 40436 8408 17 will will MD 40436 8408 18 become become VB 40436 8408 19 competent competent JJ 40436 8408 20 not not RB 40436 8408 21 to to TO 40436 8408 22 teach teach VB 40436 8408 23 , , , 40436 8408 24 but but CC 40436 8408 25 to to TO 40436 8408 26 persuade persuade VB 40436 8408 27 the the DT 40436 8408 28 multitude:--that multitude:--that NNP 40436 8408 29 is be VBZ 40436 8408 30 , , , 40436 8408 31 competent competent JJ 40436 8408 32 among among IN 40436 8408 33 the the DT 40436 8408 34 ignorant ignorant NN 40436 8408 35 . . . 40436 8409 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8409 2 has have VBZ 40436 8409 3 acquired acquire VBN 40436 8409 4 an an DT 40436 8409 5 engine engine NN 40436 8409 6 of of IN 40436 8409 7 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 8409 8 ; ; : 40436 8409 9 so so IN 40436 8409 10 that that IN 40436 8409 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8409 12 will will MD 40436 8409 13 appear appear VB 40436 8409 14 , , , 40436 8409 15 when when WRB 40436 8409 16 addressing address VBG 40436 8409 17 the the DT 40436 8409 18 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 8409 19 , , , 40436 8409 20 to to TO 40436 8409 21 know know VB 40436 8409 22 more more JJR 40436 8409 23 than than IN 40436 8409 24 those those DT 40436 8409 25 who who WP 40436 8409 26 really really RB 40436 8409 27 do do VBP 40436 8409 28 know know VB 40436 8409 29 . . . 40436 8410 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8410 2 12 12 CD 40436 8410 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8410 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8410 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8410 6 12 12 CD 40436 8410 7 : : : 40436 8410 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8410 9 , , , 40436 8410 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8410 11 , , , 40436 8410 12 p. p. NN 40436 8410 13 459 459 CD 40436 8410 14 B. B. NNP 40436 8411 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8411 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8411 3 : : : 40436 8411 4 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 8411 5 = = SYM 40436 8411 6 n n NN 40436 8411 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8411 8 peri\ peri\ . 40436 8411 9 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 8411 10 a)/llas a)/llas NNP 40436 8411 11 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 8411 12 / / SYM 40436 8411 13 sas sas NNP 40436 8411 14 te te NNP 40436 8411 15 / / SYM 40436 8411 16 chnas chnas NNP 40436 8411 17 ô(sau ô(sau NNP 40436 8411 18 / / SYM 40436 8411 19 tôs tôs NNP 40436 8411 20 e)/chei e)/chei NNP 40436 8411 21 o o XX 40436 8411 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8411 23 r(ê r(ê NNP 40436 8411 24 / / SYM 40436 8411 25 tôr tôr NNP 40436 8411 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8411 27 ê ê NNP 40436 8411 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8411 29 r(êtorikê/ r(êtorikê/ NNP 40436 8411 30 ; ; : 40436 8411 31 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 8411 32 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8411 33 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 8411 34 pra pra NNP 40436 8411 35 / / SYM 40436 8411 36 gmata gmata NN 40436 8411 37 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 8411 38 dei= dei= JJ 40436 8411 39 au)tê\n au)tê\n NN 40436 8411 40 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 8411 41 / / SYM 40436 8411 42 nai nai NNP 40436 8411 43 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 8411 44 e)/chei e)/chei NNP 40436 8411 45 , , , 40436 8411 46 mêchanê\n mêchanê\n NNP 40436 8411 47 de/ de/ NNP 40436 8411 48 tina tina NNP 40436 8411 49 peithou peithou NNP 40436 8411 50 = = SYM 40436 8411 51 s s NNP 40436 8411 52 eu(rêke eu(rêke NNP 40436 8411 53 / / SYM 40436 8411 54 nai nai NNP 40436 8411 55 , , , 40436 8411 56 ô(/ste ô(/ste NNP 40436 8411 57 phai phai NNP 40436 8411 58 / / SYM 40436 8411 59 nesthai nesthai NNP 40436 8411 60 toi toi NNP 40436 8411 61 = = SYM 40436 8411 62 s s NNP 40436 8411 63 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 8411 64 ei)do ei)do NNP 40436 8411 65 / / SYM 40436 8411 66 si si NNP 40436 8411 67 ma ma NNP 40436 8411 68 = = SYM 40436 8411 69 llon llon NNP 40436 8411 70 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 8411 71 / / SYM 40436 8411 72 nai nai NNP 40436 8411 73 tô tô NNP 40436 8411 74 = = SYM 40436 8411 75 n n CC 40436 8411 76 ei)do ei)do NNP 40436 8411 77 / / SYM 40436 8411 78 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8411 79 . . . 40436 8411 80 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8411 81 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8412 1 * * NFP 40436 8412 2 * * NFP 40436 8412 3 * * NFP 40436 8412 4 * * NFP 40436 8412 5 * * NFP 40436 8412 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8412 7 Side side NN 40436 8412 8 - - HYPH 40436 8412 9 note note NN 40436 8412 10 : : : 40436 8412 11 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8412 12 is be VBZ 40436 8412 13 now now RB 40436 8412 14 made make VBN 40436 8412 15 to to TO 40436 8412 16 contradict contradict VB 40436 8412 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8412 18 . . . 40436 8413 1 Polus polus NN 40436 8413 2 takes take VBZ 40436 8413 3 up up RP 40436 8413 4 the the DT 40436 8413 5 debate debate NN 40436 8413 6 with with IN 40436 8413 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8413 8 . . . 40436 8413 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8414 1 Thus thus RB 40436 8414 2 far far RB 40436 8414 3 , , , 40436 8414 4 the the DT 40436 8414 5 conversation conversation NN 40436 8414 6 is be VBZ 40436 8414 7 carried carry VBN 40436 8414 8 on on RP 40436 8414 9 between between IN 40436 8414 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8414 11 and and CC 40436 8414 12 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8414 13 . . . 40436 8415 1 But but CC 40436 8415 2 the the DT 40436 8415 3 latter latter NN 40436 8415 4 is be VBZ 40436 8415 5 now now RB 40436 8415 6 made make VBN 40436 8415 7 to to TO 40436 8415 8 contradict contradict VB 40436 8415 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8415 10 -- -- : 40436 8415 11 apparently apparently RB 40436 8415 12 rather rather RB 40436 8415 13 than than IN 40436 8415 14 really really RB 40436 8415 15 -- -- : 40436 8415 16 for for IN 40436 8415 17 the the DT 40436 8415 18 argument argument NN 40436 8415 19 whereby whereby WRB 40436 8415 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8415 21 reduces reduce VBZ 40436 8415 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8415 23 to to IN 40436 8415 24 a a DT 40436 8415 25 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 8415 26 , , , 40436 8415 27 is be VBZ 40436 8415 28 not not RB 40436 8415 29 tenable tenable JJ 40436 8415 30 , , , 40436 8415 31 unless unless IN 40436 8415 32 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8415 33 admit admit VBP 40436 8415 34 the the DT 40436 8415 35 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8415 36 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8415 37 that that IN 40436 8415 38 the the DT 40436 8415 39 man man NN 40436 8415 40 who who WP 40436 8415 41 has have VBZ 40436 8415 42 learnt learn VBN 40436 8415 43 just just RB 40436 8415 44 and and CC 40436 8415 45 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8415 46 , , , 40436 8415 47 may may MD 40436 8415 48 be be VB 40436 8415 49 relied rely VBN 40436 8415 50 on on RP 40436 8415 51 to to TO 40436 8415 52 act act VB 40436 8415 53 as as IN 40436 8415 54 a a DT 40436 8415 55 just just RB 40436 8415 56 man;[13 man;[13 NNS 40436 8415 57 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8415 58 in in IN 40436 8415 59 other other JJ 40436 8415 60 words word NNS 40436 8415 61 , , , 40436 8415 62 that that DT 40436 8415 63 virtue virtue NN 40436 8415 64 consists consist VBZ 40436 8415 65 in in IN 40436 8415 66 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 8415 67 . . . 40436 8416 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8416 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8416 3 13 13 CD 40436 8416 4 : : : 40436 8416 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8416 6 , , , 40436 8416 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8416 8 , , , 40436 8416 9 p. p. NN 40436 8416 10 460 460 CD 40436 8416 11 B. b. NN 40436 8417 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8417 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8417 3 : : : 40436 8417 4 o o NN 40436 8417 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8417 6 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 8417 7 di di NNP 40436 8417 8 / / SYM 40436 8417 9 kaia kaia NNP 40436 8417 10 memathêkô memathêkô NNP 40436 8417 11 / / SYM 40436 8417 12 s s NNP 40436 8417 13 , , , 40436 8417 14 di di NNP 40436 8417 15 / / SYM 40436 8417 16 kaios kaios NNP 40436 8417 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8417 18 . . . 40436 8418 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8418 2 notices notice VBZ 40436 8418 3 this this DT 40436 8418 4 confusion confusion NN 40436 8418 5 of of IN 40436 8418 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8418 7 , , , 40436 8418 8 who who WP 40436 8418 9 falls fall VBZ 40436 8418 10 into into IN 40436 8418 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8418 12 also also RB 40436 8418 13 in in IN 40436 8418 14 the the DT 40436 8418 15 conversation conversation NN 40436 8418 16 with with IN 40436 8418 17 Euthydemus Euthydemus NNP 40436 8418 18 , , , 40436 8418 19 Xenoph Xenoph NNP 40436 8418 20 . . . 40436 8419 1 Memorab Memorab NNP 40436 8419 2 . . . 40436 8420 1 iv iv XX 40436 8420 2 . . . 40436 8421 1 2 2 CD 40436 8421 2 , , , 40436 8421 3 20 20 CD 40436 8421 4 , , , 40436 8421 5 iii iii CD 40436 8421 6 . . . 40436 8422 1 9 9 CD 40436 8422 2 , , , 40436 8422 3 5 5 CD 40436 8422 4 . . . 40436 8422 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8423 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8423 2 Side side NN 40436 8423 3 - - HYPH 40436 8423 4 note note NN 40436 8423 5 : : : 40436 8423 6 Polemical polemical JJ 40436 8423 7 tone tone NN 40436 8423 8 of of IN 40436 8423 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8423 10 . . . 40436 8424 1 At at IN 40436 8424 2 the the DT 40436 8424 3 instance instance NN 40436 8424 4 of of IN 40436 8424 5 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8424 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8424 7 gives give VBZ 40436 8424 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8424 9 own own JJ 40436 8424 10 definition definition NN 40436 8424 11 of of IN 40436 8424 12 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8424 13 . . . 40436 8425 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8425 2 is be VBZ 40436 8425 3 no no DT 40436 8425 4 art art NN 40436 8425 5 , , , 40436 8425 6 but but CC 40436 8425 7 an an DT 40436 8425 8 empirical empirical JJ 40436 8425 9 knack knack NN 40436 8425 10 of of IN 40436 8425 11 catering catering NN 40436 8425 12 for for IN 40436 8425 13 the the DT 40436 8425 14 immediate immediate JJ 40436 8425 15 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8425 16 of of IN 40436 8425 17 hearers hearer NNS 40436 8425 18 , , , 40436 8425 19 analogous analogous JJ 40436 8425 20 to to IN 40436 8425 21 cookery cookery NN 40436 8425 22 . . . 40436 8426 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8426 2 is be VBZ 40436 8426 3 a a DT 40436 8426 4 branch branch NN 40436 8426 5 under under IN 40436 8426 6 the the DT 40436 8426 7 general general JJ 40436 8426 8 head head NN 40436 8426 9 flattery flattery NN 40436 8426 10 . . . 40436 8426 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8427 1 Polus polus NN 40436 8427 2 now now RB 40436 8427 3 interferes interfere VBZ 40436 8427 4 and and CC 40436 8427 5 takes take VBZ 40436 8427 6 up up RP 40436 8427 7 the the DT 40436 8427 8 conversation conversation NN 40436 8427 9 : : : 40436 8427 10 challenging challenge VBG 40436 8427 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8427 12 to to TO 40436 8427 13 furnish furnish VB 40436 8427 14 what what WP 40436 8427 15 _ _ NNP 40436 8427 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8427 17 _ _ NNP 40436 8427 18 thinks think VBZ 40436 8427 19 the the DT 40436 8427 20 proper proper JJ 40436 8427 21 definition definition NN 40436 8427 22 of of IN 40436 8427 23 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8427 24 . . . 40436 8428 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8428 2 obeys obey NNS 40436 8428 3 , , , 40436 8428 4 in in IN 40436 8428 5 a a DT 40436 8428 6 tone tone NN 40436 8428 7 of of IN 40436 8428 8 pungent pungent JJ 40436 8428 9 polemic polemic NN 40436 8428 10 . . . 40436 8429 1 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8429 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8429 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8429 4 says say VBZ 40436 8429 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8429 6 is be VBZ 40436 8429 7 no no DT 40436 8429 8 art art NN 40436 8429 9 at at RB 40436 8429 10 all all RB 40436 8429 11 , , , 40436 8429 12 but but CC 40436 8429 13 an an DT 40436 8429 14 empirical empirical JJ 40436 8429 15 knack knack NN 40436 8429 16 of of IN 40436 8429 17 catering catering NN 40436 8429 18 for for IN 40436 8429 19 the the DT 40436 8429 20 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8429 21 and and CC 40436 8429 22 favour favour NN 40436 8429 23 of of IN 40436 8429 24 hearers hearer NNS 40436 8429 25 ; ; , 40436 8429 26 analogous analogous JJ 40436 8429 27 to to IN 40436 8429 28 cookery cookery NN 40436 8429 29 . . . 40436 8430 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8430 2 14 14 CD 40436 8430 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8430 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8430 5 is be VBZ 40436 8430 6 a a DT 40436 8430 7 talent talent NN 40436 8430 8 falling fall VBG 40436 8430 9 under under IN 40436 8430 10 the the DT 40436 8430 11 general general JJ 40436 8430 12 aptitude aptitude NN 40436 8430 13 called call VBN 40436 8430 14 Flattery Flattery NNP 40436 8430 15 ; ; , 40436 8430 16 possessed possess VBN 40436 8430 17 by by IN 40436 8430 18 some some DT 40436 8430 19 bold bold JJ 40436 8430 20 spirits spirit NNS 40436 8430 21 , , , 40436 8430 22 who who WP 40436 8430 23 are be VBP 40436 8430 24 forward forward RB 40436 8430 25 in in IN 40436 8430 26 divining divining NN 40436 8430 27 and and CC 40436 8430 28 adapting adapt VBG 40436 8430 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8430 30 to to IN 40436 8430 31 the the DT 40436 8430 32 temper temper NN 40436 8430 33 of of IN 40436 8430 34 the the DT 40436 8430 35 public public NN 40436 8430 36 . . . 40436 8431 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8431 2 15 15 CD 40436 8431 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8431 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8431 5 is be VBZ 40436 8431 6 not not RB 40436 8431 7 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8431 8 , , , 40436 8431 9 but but CC 40436 8431 10 a a DT 40436 8431 11 mean mean JJ 40436 8431 12 pursuit pursuit NN 40436 8431 13 , , , 40436 8431 14 like like IN 40436 8431 15 cookery cookery NN 40436 8431 16 . . . 40436 8432 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8432 2 is be VBZ 40436 8432 3 the the DT 40436 8432 4 shadow shadow NN 40436 8432 5 or or CC 40436 8432 6 false false JJ 40436 8432 7 imitation imitation NN 40436 8432 8 of of IN 40436 8432 9 a a DT 40436 8432 10 branch branch NN 40436 8432 11 of of IN 40436 8432 12 the the DT 40436 8432 13 political political JJ 40436 8432 14 art art NN 40436 8432 15 . . . 40436 8433 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8433 2 16 16 CD 40436 8433 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8433 4 In in IN 40436 8433 5 reference reference NN 40436 8433 6 both both CC 40436 8433 7 to to IN 40436 8433 8 the the DT 40436 8433 9 body body NN 40436 8433 10 and and CC 40436 8433 11 the the DT 40436 8433 12 mind mind NN 40436 8433 13 , , , 40436 8433 14 there there EX 40436 8433 15 are be VBP 40436 8433 16 two two CD 40436 8433 17 different different JJ 40436 8433 18 conditions condition NNS 40436 8433 19 : : : 40436 8433 20 one one CD 40436 8433 21 , , , 40436 8433 22 a a DT 40436 8433 23 condition condition NN 40436 8433 24 really really RB 40436 8433 25 and and CC 40436 8433 26 truly truly RB 40436 8433 27 good good JJ 40436 8433 28 -- -- : 40436 8433 29 the the DT 40436 8433 30 other other JJ 40436 8433 31 , , , 40436 8433 32 good good JJ 40436 8433 33 only only RB 40436 8433 34 in in IN 40436 8433 35 fallacious fallacious JJ 40436 8433 36 appearance appearance NN 40436 8433 37 , , , 40436 8433 38 and and CC 40436 8433 39 not not RB 40436 8433 40 so so RB 40436 8433 41 in in IN 40436 8433 42 reality reality NN 40436 8433 43 . . . 40436 8434 1 To to TO 40436 8434 2 produce produce VB 40436 8434 3 , , , 40436 8434 4 and and CC 40436 8434 5 to to TO 40436 8434 6 verify verify VB 40436 8434 7 , , , 40436 8434 8 the the DT 40436 8434 9 really really RB 40436 8434 10 good good JJ 40436 8434 11 condition condition NN 40436 8434 12 of of IN 40436 8434 13 the the DT 40436 8434 14 body body NN 40436 8434 15 , , , 40436 8434 16 there there EX 40436 8434 17 are be VBP 40436 8434 18 two two CD 40436 8434 19 specially specially RB 40436 8434 20 qualified qualified JJ 40436 8434 21 professions profession NNS 40436 8434 22 , , , 40436 8434 23 the the DT 40436 8434 24 gymnast gymnast NN 40436 8434 25 or or CC 40436 8434 26 trainer trainer NN 40436 8434 27 and and CC 40436 8434 28 the the DT 40436 8434 29 physician physician NN 40436 8434 30 : : : 40436 8434 31 in in IN 40436 8434 32 regard regard NN 40436 8434 33 to to IN 40436 8434 34 the the DT 40436 8434 35 mind mind NN 40436 8434 36 , , , 40436 8434 37 the the DT 40436 8434 38 function function NN 40436 8434 39 of of IN 40436 8434 40 the the DT 40436 8434 41 trainer trainer NN 40436 8434 42 is be VBZ 40436 8434 43 performed perform VBN 40436 8434 44 by by IN 40436 8434 45 the the DT 40436 8434 46 law law NN 40436 8434 47 - - HYPH 40436 8434 48 giving give VBG 40436 8434 49 power power NN 40436 8434 50 , , , 40436 8434 51 that that DT 40436 8434 52 of of IN 40436 8434 53 the the DT 40436 8434 54 physician physician NN 40436 8434 55 by by IN 40436 8434 56 the the DT 40436 8434 57 judicial judicial JJ 40436 8434 58 power power NN 40436 8434 59 . . . 40436 8435 1 Law law NN 40436 8435 2 - - HYPH 40436 8435 3 making making NN 40436 8435 4 , , , 40436 8435 5 and and CC 40436 8435 6 adjudicating adjudicating NN 40436 8435 7 , , , 40436 8435 8 are be VBP 40436 8435 9 both both DT 40436 8435 10 branches branch NNS 40436 8435 11 of of IN 40436 8435 12 the the DT 40436 8435 13 political political JJ 40436 8435 14 art art NN 40436 8435 15 , , , 40436 8435 16 and and CC 40436 8435 17 when when WRB 40436 8435 18 put put VB 40436 8435 19 together together RB 40436 8435 20 make make VBP 40436 8435 21 up up RP 40436 8435 22 the the DT 40436 8435 23 whole whole NN 40436 8435 24 of of IN 40436 8435 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8435 26 . . . 40436 8436 1 Gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 8436 2 and and CC 40436 8436 3 medicine medicine NN 40436 8436 4 train train NN 40436 8436 5 and and CC 40436 8436 6 doctor doctor VB 40436 8436 7 the the DT 40436 8436 8 body body NN 40436 8436 9 towards towards IN 40436 8436 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8436 11 really really RB 40436 8436 12 best good JJS 40436 8436 13 condition condition NN 40436 8436 14 : : : 40436 8436 15 law law NN 40436 8436 16 - - HYPH 40436 8436 17 making making NN 40436 8436 18 and and CC 40436 8436 19 adjudicating adjudicate VBG 40436 8436 20 do do VBP 40436 8436 21 the the DT 40436 8436 22 same same JJ 40436 8436 23 in in IN 40436 8436 24 regard regard NN 40436 8436 25 to to IN 40436 8436 26 the the DT 40436 8436 27 mind mind NN 40436 8436 28 . . . 40436 8437 1 To to IN 40436 8437 2 each each DT 40436 8437 3 of of IN 40436 8437 4 the the DT 40436 8437 5 four four CD 40436 8437 6 , , , 40436 8437 7 there there EX 40436 8437 8 corresponds correspond VBZ 40436 8437 9 a a DT 40436 8437 10 sham sham JJ 40436 8437 11 counterpart counterpart NN 40436 8437 12 or or CC 40436 8437 13 mimic mimic NNP 40436 8437 14 , , , 40436 8437 15 a a DT 40436 8437 16 branch branch NN 40436 8437 17 under under IN 40436 8437 18 the the DT 40436 8437 19 general general JJ 40436 8437 20 head head NN 40436 8437 21 _ _ NNP 40436 8437 22 flattery_--taking flattery_--take VBG 40436 8437 23 no no DT 40436 8437 24 account account NN 40436 8437 25 of of IN 40436 8437 26 what what WP 40436 8437 27 is be VBZ 40436 8437 28 really really RB 40436 8437 29 best good JJS 40436 8437 30 , , , 40436 8437 31 but but CC 40436 8437 32 only only RB 40436 8437 33 of of IN 40436 8437 34 that that DT 40436 8437 35 which which WDT 40436 8437 36 is be VBZ 40436 8437 37 most most RBS 40436 8437 38 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8437 39 for for IN 40436 8437 40 the the DT 40436 8437 41 moment moment NN 40436 8437 42 , , , 40436 8437 43 and and CC 40436 8437 44 by by IN 40436 8437 45 this this DT 40436 8437 46 trick trick NN 40436 8437 47 recommending recommend VBG 40436 8437 48 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8437 49 to to IN 40436 8437 50 a a DT 40436 8437 51 fallacious fallacious JJ 40436 8437 52 esteem esteem NN 40436 8437 53 . . . 40436 8438 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8438 2 17 17 CD 40436 8438 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8438 4 Thus thus RB 40436 8438 5 Cosmetic Cosmetic NNP 40436 8438 6 , , , 40436 8438 7 or or CC 40436 8438 8 Ornamental Ornamental NNP 40436 8438 9 Trickery Trickery NNP 40436 8438 10 , , , 40436 8438 11 is be VBZ 40436 8438 12 the the DT 40436 8438 13 counterfeit counterfeit NN 40436 8438 14 of of IN 40436 8438 15 Gymnastic Gymnastic NNP 40436 8438 16 ; ; : 40436 8438 17 and and CC 40436 8438 18 Cookery cookery VB 40436 8438 19 the the DT 40436 8438 20 counterfeit counterfeit NN 40436 8438 21 of of IN 40436 8438 22 Medicine Medicine NNP 40436 8438 23 . . . 40436 8439 1 Cookery cookery NN 40436 8439 2 studies study NNS 40436 8439 3 only only RB 40436 8439 4 what what WP 40436 8439 5 is be VBZ 40436 8439 6 immediately immediately RB 40436 8439 7 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8439 8 to to IN 40436 8439 9 the the DT 40436 8439 10 body body NN 40436 8439 11 , , , 40436 8439 12 without without IN 40436 8439 13 considering consider VBG 40436 8439 14 whether whether IN 40436 8439 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8439 16 be be VB 40436 8439 17 good good JJ 40436 8439 18 or or CC 40436 8439 19 wholesome wholesome JJ 40436 8439 20 : : : 40436 8439 21 and and CC 40436 8439 22 does do VBZ 40436 8439 23 this this DT 40436 8439 24 moreover moreover RB 40436 8439 25 , , , 40436 8439 26 without without IN 40436 8439 27 any any DT 40436 8439 28 truly truly RB 40436 8439 29 scientific scientific JJ 40436 8439 30 process process NN 40436 8439 31 of of IN 40436 8439 32 observation observation NN 40436 8439 33 or or CC 40436 8439 34 inference inference NN 40436 8439 35 , , , 40436 8439 36 but but CC 40436 8439 37 simply simply RB 40436 8439 38 by by IN 40436 8439 39 an an DT 40436 8439 40 empirical empirical JJ 40436 8439 41 process process NN 40436 8439 42 of of IN 40436 8439 43 memory memory NN 40436 8439 44 or or CC 40436 8439 45 analogy analogy NN 40436 8439 46 . . . 40436 8440 1 But but CC 40436 8440 2 Medicine medicine NN 40436 8440 3 examines examine NNS 40436 8440 4 , , , 40436 8440 5 and and CC 40436 8440 6 that that IN 40436 8440 7 too too RB 40436 8440 8 by by IN 40436 8440 9 scientific scientific JJ 40436 8440 10 method method NN 40436 8440 11 , , , 40436 8440 12 only only RB 40436 8440 13 what what WP 40436 8440 14 is be VBZ 40436 8440 15 good good JJ 40436 8440 16 and and CC 40436 8440 17 wholesome wholesome JJ 40436 8440 18 for for IN 40436 8440 19 the the DT 40436 8440 20 body body NN 40436 8440 21 , , , 40436 8440 22 whether whether IN 40436 8440 23 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8440 24 or or CC 40436 8440 25 not not RB 40436 8440 26 . . . 40436 8441 1 Amidst amidst IN 40436 8441 2 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 8441 3 men man NNS 40436 8441 4 , , , 40436 8441 5 Cookery cookery NN 40436 8441 6 slips slip VBZ 40436 8441 7 in in RP 40436 8441 8 as as IN 40436 8441 9 the the DT 40436 8441 10 counterfeit counterfeit NN 40436 8441 11 of of IN 40436 8441 12 medicine medicine NN 40436 8441 13 ; ; , 40436 8441 14 pretending pretend VBG 40436 8441 15 to to TO 40436 8441 16 know know VB 40436 8441 17 what what WP 40436 8441 18 food food NN 40436 8441 19 is be VBZ 40436 8441 20 _ _ NNP 40436 8441 21 good good JJ 40436 8441 22 _ _ NNP 40436 8441 23 for for IN 40436 8441 24 the the DT 40436 8441 25 body body NN 40436 8441 26 , , , 40436 8441 27 while while IN 40436 8441 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8441 29 really really RB 40436 8441 30 knows know VBZ 40436 8441 31 only only RB 40436 8441 32 what what WP 40436 8441 33 food food NN 40436 8441 34 is be VBZ 40436 8441 35 _ _ NNP 40436 8441 36 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8441 37 _ _ NNP 40436 8441 38 . . . 40436 8442 1 In in IN 40436 8442 2 like like JJ 40436 8442 3 manner manner NN 40436 8442 4 , , , 40436 8442 5 the the DT 40436 8442 6 artifices artifice NNS 40436 8442 7 of of IN 40436 8442 8 ornament ornament JJ 40436 8442 9 dress dress VBP 40436 8442 10 up up RP 40436 8442 11 the the DT 40436 8442 12 body body NN 40436 8442 13 to to IN 40436 8442 14 a a DT 40436 8442 15 false false JJ 40436 8442 16 appearance appearance NN 40436 8442 17 of of IN 40436 8442 18 that that DT 40436 8442 19 vigour vigour NN 40436 8442 20 and and CC 40436 8442 21 symmetry symmetry NN 40436 8442 22 , , , 40436 8442 23 which which WDT 40436 8442 24 Gymnastics Gymnastics NNPS 40436 8442 25 impart impart NN 40436 8442 26 to to IN 40436 8442 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8442 28 really really RB 40436 8442 29 and and CC 40436 8442 30 intrinsically intrinsically RB 40436 8442 31 . . . 40436 8443 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8443 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8443 3 14 14 CD 40436 8443 4 : : : 40436 8443 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8443 6 , , , 40436 8443 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8443 8 , , , 40436 8443 9 p. p. NN 40436 8443 10 462 462 CD 40436 8443 11 C. C. NNP 40436 8443 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8443 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8443 14 : : : 40436 8443 15 e)mpeiri e)mpeiri LS 40436 8443 16 / / SYM 40436 8443 17 a a NN 40436 8443 18 . . . 40436 8444 1 . . . 40436 8445 1 . . . 40436 8446 1 . . . 40436 8447 1 cha cha NNP 40436 8447 2 / / SYM 40436 8447 3 rito rito NNP 40436 8447 4 / / SYM 40436 8447 5 s s NNP 40436 8447 6 tinos tinos NNP 40436 8447 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8447 8 ê(donê ê(donê NNP 40436 8447 9 = = NNP 40436 8447 10 s s NNP 40436 8447 11 a)pergasi a)pergasi NNP 40436 8447 12 / / SYM 40436 8447 13 as as IN 40436 8447 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8447 15 . . . 40436 8448 1 In in IN 40436 8448 2 the the DT 40436 8448 3 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 8448 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8448 5 pp pp NNP 40436 8448 6 . . . 40436 8449 1 55 55 CD 40436 8449 2 - - SYM 40436 8449 3 56 56 CD 40436 8449 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8449 5 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 8449 6 treats treat NNS 40436 8449 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8449 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8449 9 : : : 40436 8449 10 i)atrikê\ i)atrikê\ NN 40436 8449 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8449 12 differently differently RB 40436 8449 13 , , , 40436 8449 14 as as IN 40436 8449 15 falling fall VBG 40436 8449 16 short short RB 40436 8449 17 of of IN 40436 8449 18 the the DT 40436 8449 19 idea idea NN 40436 8449 20 of of IN 40436 8449 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8449 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8449 23 : : : 40436 8449 24 te te NNP 40436 8449 25 / / SYM 40436 8449 26 chnê chnê NNP 40436 8449 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8449 28 , , , 40436 8449 29 and and CC 40436 8449 30 coming come VBG 40436 8449 31 much much JJ 40436 8449 32 nearer nearer RB 40436 8449 33 to to IN 40436 8449 34 what what WP 40436 8449 35 is be VBZ 40436 8449 36 here here RB 40436 8449 37 called call VBN 40436 8449 38 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8449 39 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8449 40 : : : 40436 8449 41 e)mpeiri e)mpeiri LS 40436 8449 42 / / SYM 40436 8449 43 a a NN 40436 8449 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8449 45 or or CC 40436 8449 46 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8449 47 Greek greek JJ 40436 8449 48 : : : 40436 8449 49 stochastikê/ stochastikê/ NN 40436 8449 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8449 51 . . . 40436 8450 1 Asklepiades Asklepiades NNP 40436 8450 2 was be VBD 40436 8450 3 displeased displeased JJ 40436 8450 4 with with IN 40436 8450 5 the the DT 40436 8450 6 Thracian Thracian NNP 40436 8450 7 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 40436 8450 8 for for IN 40436 8450 9 calling call VBG 40436 8450 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8450 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8450 12 : : : 40436 8450 13 grammatikê\ grammatikê\ NN 40436 8450 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8450 15 by by IN 40436 8450 16 the the DT 40436 8450 17 name name NN 40436 8450 18 of of IN 40436 8450 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8450 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8450 21 : : : 40436 8450 22 e)mpeiri e)mpeiri LS 40436 8450 23 / / SYM 40436 8450 24 a a LS 40436 8450 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8450 26 instead instead RB 40436 8450 27 of of IN 40436 8450 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8450 29 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8450 30 : : : 40436 8450 31 te te NNP 40436 8450 32 / / SYM 40436 8450 33 chnê chnê NNP 40436 8450 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8450 35 : : : 40436 8450 36 see see VB 40436 8450 37 Sextus Sextus NNP 40436 8450 38 Empiric Empiric NNP 40436 8450 39 . . . 40436 8451 1 adv adv NNP 40436 8451 2 . . . 40436 8452 1 Grammat Grammat NNP 40436 8452 2 . . . 40436 8453 1 s. s. NNP 40436 8453 2 57 57 CD 40436 8453 3 - - SYM 40436 8453 4 72 72 CD 40436 8453 5 , , , 40436 8453 6 p. p. NN 40436 8453 7 615 615 CD 40436 8453 8 , , , 40436 8453 9 Bekk Bekk NNP 40436 8453 10 . . . 40436 8453 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8454 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8454 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8454 3 15 15 CD 40436 8454 4 : : : 40436 8454 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8454 6 , , , 40436 8454 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8454 8 , , , 40436 8454 9 p. p. NN 40436 8454 10 463 463 CD 40436 8454 11 A. a. NN 40436 8455 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8455 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8455 3 : : : 40436 8455 4 dokei= dokei= VB 40436 8455 5 moi moi FW 40436 8455 6 ei)=nai/ ei)=nai/ FW 40436 8455 7 ti ti NNP 40436 8455 8 e)pitê e)pitê NNP 40436 8455 9 / / SYM 40436 8455 10 deuma deuma NNP 40436 8455 11 , , , 40436 8455 12 techniko\n techniko\n ADD 40436 8455 13 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8455 14 ou)/ ou)/ NNP 40436 8455 15 , , , 40436 8455 16 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 8455 17 = = SYM 40436 8455 18 s s NNP 40436 8455 19 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8455 20 stochastikê stochastikê NNP 40436 8455 21 = = SYM 40436 8455 22 s s NNP 40436 8455 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8455 24 a)ndrei a)ndrei NNP 40436 8455 25 / / SYM 40436 8455 26 as as IN 40436 8455 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8455 28 phu phu NNP 40436 8455 29 / / SYM 40436 8455 30 sei sei NNP 40436 8455 31 deinê deinê NNPS 40436 8455 32 = = SYM 40436 8455 33 s s NN 40436 8455 34 prosomilei prosomilei NNP 40436 8455 35 = = SYM 40436 8455 36 n n CC 40436 8455 37 toi toi NNP 40436 8455 38 = = SYM 40436 8455 39 s s NNP 40436 8455 40 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 8455 41 / / SYM 40436 8455 42 pois pois NNP 40436 8455 43 ; ; : 40436 8455 44 kalô= kalô= NNP 40436 8455 45 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8455 46 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 8455 47 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 8455 48 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8455 49 kepha kepha NN 40436 8455 50 / / SYM 40436 8455 51 laion laion NN 40436 8455 52 _ _ NNP 40436 8455 53 kolakei kolakei NNP 40436 8455 54 / / SYM 40436 8455 55 an an DT 40436 8455 56 _ _ NNP 40436 8455 57 . . . 40436 8455 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8455 59 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8456 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8456 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8456 3 16 16 CD 40436 8456 4 : : : 40436 8456 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8456 6 , , , 40436 8456 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8456 8 , , , 40436 8456 9 p. p. NN 40436 8456 10 463 463 CD 40436 8456 11 D. D. NNP 40436 8456 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8456 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8456 14 : : : 40436 8456 15 politikê politikê NNP 40436 8456 16 = = NFP 40436 8456 17 s s NNP 40436 8456 18 mori mori NNP 40436 8456 19 / / SYM 40436 8456 20 ou ou NNP 40436 8456 21 ei)/dôlon ei)/dôlon NNP 40436 8456 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8456 23 . . . 40436 8456 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8457 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8457 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8457 3 17 17 CD 40436 8457 4 : : : 40436 8457 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8457 6 , , , 40436 8457 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8457 8 , , , 40436 8457 9 p. p. NN 40436 8457 10 464 464 CD 40436 8457 11 C. C. NNP 40436 8457 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8457 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8457 14 : : : 40436 8457 15 tetta tetta NNP 40436 8457 16 / / SYM 40436 8457 17 rôn rôn NNP 40436 8457 18 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 8457 19 tou tou NNP 40436 8457 20 / / SYM 40436 8457 21 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8457 22 ou)sô ou)sô NNP 40436 8457 23 = = SYM 40436 8457 24 n n NNP 40436 8457 25 , , , 40436 8457 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8457 27 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 8457 28 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 8457 29 to\ to\ NN 40436 8457 30 be be VB 40436 8457 31 / / SYM 40436 8457 32 ltiston ltiston NNP 40436 8457 33 therapeuousô therapeuousô NNP 40436 8457 34 = = SYM 40436 8457 35 n n CC 40436 8457 36 , , , 40436 8457 37 tô tô NNP 40436 8457 38 = = NFP 40436 8457 39 n n NNP 40436 8457 40 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8457 41 to\ to\ NN 40436 8457 42 sô sô NNP 40436 8457 43 = = SYM 40436 8457 44 ma ma NNP 40436 8457 45 , , , 40436 8457 46 tô tô NNP 40436 8457 47 = = SYM 40436 8457 48 n n CC 40436 8457 49 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8457 50 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 8457 51 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 8457 52 / / SYM 40436 8457 53 n n NN 40436 8457 54 , , , 40436 8457 55 ê ê NNP 40436 8457 56 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8457 57 kolakeutikê\ kolakeutikê\ NNP 40436 8457 58 ai)sthome ai)sthome NNP 40436 8457 59 / / SYM 40436 8457 60 nê nê NNP 40436 8457 61 , , , 40436 8457 62 ou ou NNP 40436 8457 63 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8457 64 gnou gnou NNP 40436 8457 65 = = : 40436 8457 66 sa sa NNP 40436 8457 67 le le NNP 40436 8457 68 / / SYM 40436 8457 69 gô gô NNP 40436 8457 70 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNS 40436 8457 71 stochasame stochasame JJ 40436 8457 72 / / SYM 40436 8457 73 nê nê NNP 40436 8457 74 , , , 40436 8457 75 te te NNP 40436 8457 76 / / SYM 40436 8457 77 tracha tracha NNP 40436 8457 78 e(autê\n e(autê\n NNP 40436 8457 79 dianei dianei NNP 40436 8457 80 / / SYM 40436 8457 81 masa masa NNP 40436 8457 82 , , , 40436 8457 83 u(podu u(podu UH 40436 8457 84 = = SYM 40436 8457 85 sa sa NNP 40436 8457 86 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 8457 87 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 8457 88 tô tô NNP 40436 8457 89 = = SYM 40436 8457 90 n n CC 40436 8457 91 mori mori NNP 40436 8457 92 / / SYM 40436 8457 93 ôn ôn NNP 40436 8457 94 , , , 40436 8457 95 prospoiei prospoiei NNP 40436 8457 96 = = SYM 40436 8457 97 tai tai NNP 40436 8457 98 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8457 99 tou tou NNP 40436 8457 100 = = SYM 40436 8457 101 to to IN 40436 8457 102 o(/per o(/per NNP 40436 8457 103 u(pe u(pe NNP 40436 8457 104 / / SYM 40436 8457 105 du du NNP 40436 8457 106 ; ; : 40436 8457 107 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8457 108 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8457 109 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8457 110 belti belti NNP 40436 8457 111 / / SYM 40436 8457 112 stou stou NNP 40436 8457 113 ou)de\n ou)de\n NNP 40436 8457 114 phronti phronti NNP 40436 8457 115 / / SYM 40436 8457 116 zei zei NNP 40436 8457 117 , , , 40436 8457 118 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 8457 119 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8457 120 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 8457 121 ê(di ê(di NNP 40436 8457 122 / / SYM 40436 8457 123 stô| stô| NNP 40436 8457 124 thêreu thêreu NN 40436 8457 125 / / SYM 40436 8457 126 etai etai NNP 40436 8457 127 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 8457 128 a)/noian a)/noian NNP 40436 8457 129 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8457 130 e)xapata=| e)xapata=| NNP 40436 8457 131 , , , 40436 8457 132 ô(/ste ô(/ste NNP 40436 8457 133 dokei= dokei= NNP 40436 8457 134 plei plei NNS 40436 8457 135 / / SYM 40436 8457 136 stou stou NNP 40436 8457 137 a)xi a)xi NNP 40436 8457 138 / / SYM 40436 8457 139 a a NNP 40436 8457 140 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8457 141 . . . 40436 8457 142 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8457 143 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8458 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8458 2 Side side NN 40436 8458 3 - - HYPH 40436 8458 4 note note NN 40436 8458 5 : : : 40436 8458 6 Distinction distinction NN 40436 8458 7 between between IN 40436 8458 8 the the DT 40436 8458 9 true true JJ 40436 8458 10 arts art NNS 40436 8458 11 which which WDT 40436 8458 12 aim aim VBP 40436 8458 13 at at IN 40436 8458 14 the the DT 40436 8458 15 good good NN 40436 8458 16 of of IN 40436 8458 17 the the DT 40436 8458 18 body body NN 40436 8458 19 and and CC 40436 8458 20 mind mind NN 40436 8458 21 -- -- : 40436 8458 22 and and CC 40436 8458 23 the the DT 40436 8458 24 counterfeit counterfeit JJ 40436 8458 25 arts art NNS 40436 8458 26 , , , 40436 8458 27 which which WDT 40436 8458 28 pretend pretend VBP 40436 8458 29 to to IN 40436 8458 30 the the DT 40436 8458 31 same same JJ 40436 8458 32 , , , 40436 8458 33 but but CC 40436 8458 34 in in IN 40436 8458 35 reality reality NN 40436 8458 36 aim aim NN 40436 8458 37 at at IN 40436 8458 38 immediate immediate JJ 40436 8458 39 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8458 40 . . . 40436 8458 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8459 1 The the DT 40436 8459 2 same same JJ 40436 8459 3 analogies analogy NNS 40436 8459 4 hold hold VBP 40436 8459 5 in in IN 40436 8459 6 regard regard NN 40436 8459 7 to to IN 40436 8459 8 the the DT 40436 8459 9 mind mind NN 40436 8459 10 . . . 40436 8460 1 Sophistic Sophistic NNP 40436 8460 2 is be VBZ 40436 8460 3 the the DT 40436 8460 4 shadow shadow NN 40436 8460 5 or or CC 40436 8460 6 counterfeit counterfeit NN 40436 8460 7 of of IN 40436 8460 8 law law NN 40436 8460 9 - - HYPH 40436 8460 10 giving give VBG 40436 8460 11 : : : 40436 8460 12 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8460 13 , , , 40436 8460 14 of of IN 40436 8460 15 judging judging NN 40436 8460 16 or or CC 40436 8460 17 adjudicating adjudicating NN 40436 8460 18 . . . 40436 8461 1 The the DT 40436 8461 2 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 8461 3 and and CC 40436 8461 4 the the DT 40436 8461 5 judge judge NN 40436 8461 6 aim aim VBP 40436 8461 7 at at IN 40436 8461 8 what what WP 40436 8461 9 is be VBZ 40436 8461 10 good good JJ 40436 8461 11 for for IN 40436 8461 12 the the DT 40436 8461 13 mind mind NN 40436 8461 14 : : : 40436 8461 15 the the DT 40436 8461 16 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8461 17 and and CC 40436 8461 18 the the DT 40436 8461 19 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8461 20 aim aim VBP 40436 8461 21 at at IN 40436 8461 22 what what WP 40436 8461 23 is be VBZ 40436 8461 24 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8461 25 to to IN 40436 8461 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8461 27 . . . 40436 8462 1 This this DT 40436 8462 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 8462 3 between between IN 40436 8462 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8462 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8462 6 continues continue VBZ 40436 8462 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8462 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8462 9 is be VBZ 40436 8462 10 true true JJ 40436 8462 11 and and CC 40436 8462 12 real real JJ 40436 8462 13 : : : 40436 8462 14 though though IN 40436 8462 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8462 16 often often RB 40436 8462 17 happens happen VBZ 40436 8462 18 that that IN 40436 8462 19 the the DT 40436 8462 20 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8462 21 is be VBZ 40436 8462 22 , , , 40436 8462 23 both both CC 40436 8462 24 by by IN 40436 8462 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8462 26 and and CC 40436 8462 27 by by IN 40436 8462 28 others other NNS 40436 8462 29 , , , 40436 8462 30 confounded confound VBD 40436 8462 31 with with IN 40436 8462 32 and and CC 40436 8462 33 mistaken mistake VBN 40436 8462 34 for for IN 40436 8462 35 the the DT 40436 8462 36 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 8462 37 , , , 40436 8462 38 because because IN 40436 8462 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8462 40 deals deal VBZ 40436 8462 41 with with IN 40436 8462 42 the the DT 40436 8462 43 same same JJ 40436 8462 44 topics topic NNS 40436 8462 45 and and CC 40436 8462 46 occurrences occurrence NNS 40436 8462 47 : : : 40436 8462 48 and and CC 40436 8462 49 the the DT 40436 8462 50 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8462 51 , , , 40436 8462 52 in in IN 40436 8462 53 the the DT 40436 8462 54 same same JJ 40436 8462 55 manner manner NN 40436 8462 56 , , , 40436 8462 57 is be VBZ 40436 8462 58 confounded confound VBN 40436 8462 59 with with IN 40436 8462 60 the the DT 40436 8462 61 judge judge NN 40436 8462 62 . . . 40436 8463 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8463 2 18 18 CD 40436 8463 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8463 4 The the DT 40436 8463 5 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8463 6 and and CC 40436 8463 7 the the DT 40436 8463 8 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8463 9 , , , 40436 8463 10 addressing address VBG 40436 8463 11 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8463 12 to to IN 40436 8463 13 the the DT 40436 8463 14 present present JJ 40436 8463 15 relish relish NN 40436 8463 16 of of IN 40436 8463 17 an an DT 40436 8463 18 undiscerning undiscerne VBG 40436 8463 19 public public NN 40436 8463 20 , , , 40436 8463 21 are be VBP 40436 8463 22 enabled enable VBN 40436 8463 23 to to TO 40436 8463 24 usurp usurp VB 40436 8463 25 the the DT 40436 8463 26 functions function NNS 40436 8463 27 and and CC 40436 8463 28 the the DT 40436 8463 29 credit credit NN 40436 8463 30 of of IN 40436 8463 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8463 32 more more RBR 40436 8463 33 severe severe JJ 40436 8463 34 and and CC 40436 8463 35 far far JJ 40436 8463 36 - - HYPH 40436 8463 37 sighted sighted JJ 40436 8463 38 rivals rival NNS 40436 8463 39 . . . 40436 8464 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8464 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8464 3 18 18 CD 40436 8464 4 : : : 40436 8464 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8464 6 , , , 40436 8464 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8464 8 , , , 40436 8464 9 p. p. NN 40436 8464 10 465 465 CD 40436 8464 11 C. C. NNP 40436 8464 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8464 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8464 14 : : : 40436 8464 15 die die VB 40436 8464 16 / / SYM 40436 8464 17 stêke stêke NNP 40436 8464 18 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8464 19 ou(/tô ou(/tô IN 40436 8464 20 phu phu NNP 40436 8464 21 / / SYM 40436 8464 22 sei sei NN 40436 8464 23 ; ; : 40436 8464 24 a(/te a(/te NNP 40436 8464 25 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8464 26 e)ggu\s e)ggu\s NNP 40436 8464 27 o)/ntôn o)/ntôn NN 40436 8464 28 , , , 40436 8464 29 phu phu NN 40436 8464 30 / / SYM 40436 8464 31 rontai rontai NNP 40436 8464 32 e)n e)n NNP 40436 8464 33 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 8464 34 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 8464 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8464 36 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 8464 37 tau)ta\ tau)ta\ NNP 40436 8464 38 sophistai\ sophistai\ NNP 40436 8464 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8464 40 r(ê r(ê NNP 40436 8464 41 / / SYM 40436 8464 42 tores tore NNS 40436 8464 43 , , , 40436 8464 44 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8464 45 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 8464 46 e)/chousin e)/chousin NNP 40436 8464 47 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 8464 48 , , , 40436 8464 49 ti ti NNP 40436 8464 50 chrê chrê NNP 40436 8464 51 / / SYM 40436 8464 52 sôntai sôntai NNP 40436 8464 53 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 8464 54 au)toi\ au)toi\ NNP 40436 8464 55 e(autoi e(autoi NNP 40436 8464 56 = = SYM 40436 8464 57 s s NNP 40436 8464 58 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 8464 59 oi oi NNP 40436 8464 60 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8464 61 a)/lloi a)/lloi NNP 40436 8464 62 a)/nthrôpoi a)/nthrôpoi NNP 40436 8464 63 tou tou NNP 40436 8464 64 / / SYM 40436 8464 65 tois tois NNP 40436 8464 66 . . . 40436 8464 67 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8465 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8465 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 8465 3 to to IN 40436 8465 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8465 5 that that IN 40436 8465 6 the the DT 40436 8465 7 persons person NNS 40436 8465 8 whom whom WP 40436 8465 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8465 10 here here RB 40436 8465 11 designates designate VBZ 40436 8465 12 as as IN 40436 8465 13 being be VBG 40436 8465 14 confounded confound VBN 40436 8465 15 together together RB 40436 8465 16 are be VBP 40436 8465 17 , , , 40436 8465 18 the the DT 40436 8465 19 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8465 20 with with IN 40436 8465 21 the the DT 40436 8465 22 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 8465 23 , , , 40436 8465 24 the the DT 40436 8465 25 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8465 26 with with IN 40436 8465 27 the the DT 40436 8465 28 judge judge NN 40436 8465 29 or or CC 40436 8465 30 dikast dikast NN 40436 8465 31 ; ; : 40436 8465 32 which which WDT 40436 8465 33 is be VBZ 40436 8465 34 shown show VBN 40436 8465 35 by by IN 40436 8465 36 the the DT 40436 8465 37 allusion allusion NN 40436 8465 38 , , , 40436 8465 39 three three CD 40436 8465 40 lines line NNS 40436 8465 41 farther farther RB 40436 8465 42 on on RB 40436 8465 43 , , , 40436 8465 44 to to IN 40436 8465 45 the the DT 40436 8465 46 confusion confusion NN 40436 8465 47 between between IN 40436 8465 48 the the DT 40436 8465 49 cook cook NN 40436 8465 50 and and CC 40436 8465 51 the the DT 40436 8465 52 physician physician NN 40436 8465 53 . . . 40436 8466 1 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 8466 2 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 8466 3 that that IN 40436 8466 4 the the DT 40436 8466 5 persons person NNS 40436 8466 6 designated designate VBN 40436 8466 7 as as IN 40436 8466 8 being be VBG 40436 8466 9 confounded confound VBN 40436 8466 10 are be VBP 40436 8466 11 , , , 40436 8466 12 the the DT 40436 8466 13 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8466 14 with with IN 40436 8466 15 the the DT 40436 8466 16 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8466 17 ; ; : 40436 8466 18 which which WDT 40436 8466 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8466 20 can can MD 40436 8466 21 not not RB 40436 8466 22 think think VB 40436 8466 23 to to TO 40436 8466 24 be be VB 40436 8466 25 the the DT 40436 8466 26 meaning meaning NN 40436 8466 27 of of IN 40436 8466 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8466 29 . . . 40436 8466 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8467 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8467 2 Side side NN 40436 8467 3 - - HYPH 40436 8467 4 note note NN 40436 8467 5 : : : 40436 8467 6 Questions question NNS 40436 8467 7 of of IN 40436 8467 8 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8467 9 . . . 40436 8468 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8468 2 denies deny VBZ 40436 8468 3 that that IN 40436 8468 4 the the DT 40436 8468 5 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 8468 6 have have VBP 40436 8468 7 any any DT 40436 8468 8 real real JJ 40436 8468 9 power power NN 40436 8468 10 , , , 40436 8468 11 because because IN 40436 8468 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8468 13 do do VBP 40436 8468 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 8468 15 which which WDT 40436 8468 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8468 17 really really RB 40436 8468 18 wish wish VBP 40436 8468 19 . . . 40436 8468 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8469 1 This this DT 40436 8469 2 is be VBZ 40436 8469 3 the the DT 40436 8469 4 definition definition NN 40436 8469 5 given give VBN 40436 8469 6 by by IN 40436 8469 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8469 8 of of IN 40436 8469 9 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8469 10 and and CC 40436 8469 11 of of IN 40436 8469 12 the the DT 40436 8469 13 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8469 14 . . . 40436 8470 1 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8470 2 then then RB 40436 8470 3 asks ask VBZ 40436 8470 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8470 5 : : : 40436 8470 6 You -PRON- PRP 40436 8470 7 say say VBP 40436 8470 8 that that IN 40436 8470 9 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8470 10 is be VBZ 40436 8470 11 a a DT 40436 8470 12 branch branch NN 40436 8470 13 of of IN 40436 8470 14 Flattery Flattery NNP 40436 8470 15 : : : 40436 8470 16 Do do VBP 40436 8470 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8470 18 think think VB 40436 8470 19 that that IN 40436 8470 20 good good JJ 40436 8470 21 Rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 8470 22 are be VBP 40436 8470 23 considered consider VBN 40436 8470 24 as as IN 40436 8470 25 flatterers flatterer NNS 40436 8470 26 in in IN 40436 8470 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8470 28 respective respective JJ 40436 8470 29 cities city NNS 40436 8470 30 ? ? . 40436 8471 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8471 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 8471 3 do do VBP 40436 8471 4 not not RB 40436 8471 5 think think VB 40436 8471 6 that[19 that[19 NNP 40436 8471 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8471 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8471 9 are be VBP 40436 8471 10 considered consider VBN 40436 8471 11 at at RB 40436 8471 12 all all RB 40436 8471 13 . . . 40436 8472 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8472 2 Polus._--How Polus._--How NNP 40436 8472 3 ! ! . 40436 8473 1 not not RB 40436 8473 2 considered consider VBN 40436 8473 3 ? ? . 40436 8474 1 Do do VBP 40436 8474 2 not not RB 40436 8474 3 good good JJ 40436 8474 4 Rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 8474 5 possess possess VBP 40436 8474 6 great great JJ 40436 8474 7 power power NN 40436 8474 8 in in IN 40436 8474 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8474 10 respective respective JJ 40436 8474 11 cities city NNS 40436 8474 12 ? ? . 40436 8475 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8475 2 Sokr._--No Sokr._--No NNP 40436 8475 3 : : : 40436 8475 4 if if IN 40436 8475 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8475 6 understand understand VBP 40436 8475 7 the the DT 40436 8475 8 possession possession NN 40436 8475 9 of of IN 40436 8475 10 power power NN 40436 8475 11 as as IN 40436 8475 12 a a DT 40436 8475 13 good good JJ 40436 8475 14 thing thing NN 40436 8475 15 for for IN 40436 8475 16 the the DT 40436 8475 17 possessor possessor NN 40436 8475 18 . . . 40436 8476 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8476 2 Polus._--I Polus._--I NNP 40436 8476 3 do do VBP 40436 8476 4 understand understand VB 40436 8476 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8476 6 so so RB 40436 8476 7 . . . 40436 8477 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8477 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 8477 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8477 4 say say VBP 40436 8477 5 that that IN 40436 8477 6 the the DT 40436 8477 7 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 8477 8 possess possess VBP 40436 8477 9 nothing nothing NN 40436 8477 10 beyond beyond IN 40436 8477 11 the the DT 40436 8477 12 very very RB 40436 8477 13 minimum minimum NN 40436 8477 14 of of IN 40436 8477 15 power power NN 40436 8477 16 . . . 40436 8478 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8478 2 Polus._--How Polus._--How NNP 40436 8478 3 can can MD 40436 8478 4 that that DT 40436 8478 5 be be VB 40436 8478 6 ? ? . 40436 8479 1 Do do VBP 40436 8479 2 not not RB 40436 8479 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8479 4 , , , 40436 8479 5 like like IN 40436 8479 6 despots despot NNS 40436 8479 7 , , , 40436 8479 8 kill kill VB 40436 8479 9 , , , 40436 8479 10 impoverish impoverish JJ 40436 8479 11 , , , 40436 8479 12 and and CC 40436 8479 13 expel expel VB 40436 8479 14 any any DT 40436 8479 15 one one NN 40436 8479 16 whom whom WP 40436 8479 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8479 18 please please VBP 40436 8479 19 ? ? . 40436 8480 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8480 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 8480 3 admit admit VBP 40436 8480 4 that that IN 40436 8480 5 both both CC 40436 8480 6 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 8480 7 and and CC 40436 8480 8 Despots despot NNS 40436 8480 9 can can MD 40436 8480 10 do do VB 40436 8480 11 what what WP 40436 8480 12 seems seem VBZ 40436 8480 13 good good JJ 40436 8480 14 to to IN 40436 8480 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8480 16 , , , 40436 8480 17 and and CC 40436 8480 18 can can MD 40436 8480 19 bring bring VB 40436 8480 20 penalties penalty NNS 40436 8480 21 of of IN 40436 8480 22 death death NN 40436 8480 23 , , , 40436 8480 24 poverty poverty NN 40436 8480 25 , , , 40436 8480 26 or or CC 40436 8480 27 exile exile NN 40436 8480 28 upon upon IN 40436 8480 29 others other NNS 40436 8480 30 : : : 40436 8480 31 but but CC 40436 8480 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8480 33 say say VBP 40436 8480 34 that that IN 40436 8480 35 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 8480 36 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8480 37 have have VBP 40436 8480 38 no no DT 40436 8480 39 power power NN 40436 8480 40 , , , 40436 8480 41 because because IN 40436 8480 42 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8480 43 can can MD 40436 8480 44 do do VB 40436 8480 45 nothing nothing NN 40436 8480 46 which which WDT 40436 8480 47 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8480 48 really really RB 40436 8480 49 wish wish VBP 40436 8480 50 . . . 40436 8481 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8481 2 20 20 CD 40436 8481 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8481 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8481 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8481 6 19 19 CD 40436 8481 7 : : : 40436 8481 8 Plat Plat NNP 40436 8481 9 . . . 40436 8482 1 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 8482 2 . . . 40436 8483 1 p. p. NN 40436 8483 2 466 466 CD 40436 8483 3 B. b. NN 40436 8484 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8484 2 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8484 3 . . . 40436 8484 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8484 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8484 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8484 7 : : : 40436 8484 8 A)=r A)=r NNP 40436 8484 9 ' ' POS 40436 8484 10 ou)=n ou)=n NN 40436 8484 11 dokou dokou NN 40436 8484 12 = = SYM 40436 8484 13 si/ si/ NNP 40436 8484 14 soi soi NNP 40436 8484 15 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 8484 16 ko ko NNP 40436 8484 17 / / SYM 40436 8484 18 lakes lakes NNP 40436 8484 19 e)n e)n NNP 40436 8484 20 tai tai NNP 40436 8484 21 = = SYM 40436 8484 22 s s NNP 40436 8484 23 po po NN 40436 8484 24 / / SYM 40436 8484 25 lesi lesi NNP 40436 8484 26 phau phau NNP 40436 8484 27 = = SYM 40436 8484 28 loi loi NNP 40436 8484 29 nomi nomi NNP 40436 8484 30 / / SYM 40436 8484 31 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 8484 32 oi oi NNP 40436 8484 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8484 34 a)gathoi\ a)gathoi\ NNP 40436 8484 35 r(ê r(ê NNP 40436 8484 36 / / SYM 40436 8484 37 tores tore NNS 40436 8484 38 ? ? . 40436 8485 1 . . . 40436 8486 1 . . . 40436 8487 1 . . . 40436 8488 1 . . . 40436 8488 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8489 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8489 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 8489 3 . . . 40436 8489 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8489 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8489 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8489 7 : : : 40436 8489 8 Ou)de\ Ou)de\ NNP 40436 8489 9 nomi nomi NNP 40436 8489 10 / / SYM 40436 8489 11 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 8489 12 e)/moige e)/moige NNP 40436 8489 13 dokou dokou NNP 40436 8489 14 = = SYM 40436 8489 15 sin sin NN 40436 8489 16 . . . 40436 8489 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8490 1 The the DT 40436 8490 2 play play NN 40436 8490 3 on on IN 40436 8490 4 words word NNS 40436 8490 5 here here RB 40436 8490 6 -- -- : 40436 8490 7 for for IN 40436 8490 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8490 9 see see VBP 40436 8490 10 nothing nothing NN 40436 8490 11 else else RB 40436 8490 12 in in IN 40436 8490 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8490 14 -- -- : 40436 8490 15 can can MD 40436 8490 16 be be VB 40436 8490 17 expressed express VBN 40436 8490 18 in in IN 40436 8490 19 English English NNP 40436 8490 20 as as RB 40436 8490 21 well well RB 40436 8490 22 as as IN 40436 8490 23 in in IN 40436 8490 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8490 25 . . . 40436 8491 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8491 2 has have VBZ 40436 8491 3 very very RB 40436 8491 4 little little JJ 40436 8491 5 pertinence pertinence NN 40436 8491 6 ; ; : 40436 8491 7 because because IN 40436 8491 8 , , , 40436 8491 9 as as IN 40436 8491 10 a a DT 40436 8491 11 matter matter NN 40436 8491 12 of of IN 40436 8491 13 fact fact NN 40436 8491 14 , , , 40436 8491 15 the the DT 40436 8491 16 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 8491 17 certainly certainly RB 40436 8491 18 had have VBD 40436 8491 19 considerable considerable JJ 40436 8491 20 importance importance NN 40436 8491 21 , , , 40436 8491 22 whether whether IN 40436 8491 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8491 24 deserved deserve VBD 40436 8491 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8491 26 or or CC 40436 8491 27 not not RB 40436 8491 28 . . . 40436 8492 1 How how WRB 40436 8492 2 little little JJ 40436 8492 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8492 4 cared care VBD 40436 8492 5 to to TO 40436 8492 6 make make VB 40436 8492 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8492 8 comparisons comparison NNS 40436 8492 9 harmonise harmonise VB 40436 8492 10 with with IN 40436 8492 11 the the DT 40436 8492 12 fact fact NN 40436 8492 13 , , , 40436 8492 14 may may MD 40436 8492 15 be be VB 40436 8492 16 seen see VBN 40436 8492 17 by by IN 40436 8492 18 what what WP 40436 8492 19 immediately immediately RB 40436 8492 20 follows follow VBZ 40436 8492 21 -- -- : 40436 8492 22 where where WRB 40436 8492 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8492 24 compares compare VBZ 40436 8492 25 the the DT 40436 8492 26 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 8492 27 to to IN 40436 8492 28 Despots despot NNS 40436 8492 29 ? ? . 40436 8493 1 and and CC 40436 8493 2 puts put VBZ 40436 8493 3 in in IN 40436 8493 4 the the DT 40436 8493 5 mouth mouth NN 40436 8493 6 of of IN 40436 8493 7 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8493 8 the the DT 40436 8493 9 assertion assertion NN 40436 8493 10 that that IN 40436 8493 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8493 12 kill kill VBP 40436 8493 13 or or CC 40436 8493 14 banish banish VBP 40436 8493 15 any any DT 40436 8493 16 one one NN 40436 8493 17 whom whom WP 40436 8493 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8493 19 choose choose VBP 40436 8493 20 . . . 40436 8493 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8494 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8494 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8494 3 20 20 CD 40436 8494 4 : : : 40436 8494 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8494 6 , , , 40436 8494 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8494 8 , , , 40436 8494 9 p. p. NN 40436 8494 10 466 466 CD 40436 8494 11 E. E. NNP 40436 8494 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8494 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8494 14 : : : 40436 8494 15 ou)de\n ou)de\n ADD 40436 8494 16 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8494 17 poiei poiei NN 40436 8494 18 = = SYM 40436 8494 19 n n CC 40436 8494 20 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 8494 21 bou bou NN 40436 8494 22 / / SYM 40436 8494 23 lontai lontai JJ 40436 8494 24 , , , 40436 8494 25 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 8494 26 e)/pos e)/pos ADD 40436 8494 27 ei)pei ei)pei NN 40436 8494 28 = = SYM 40436 8494 29 n n XX 40436 8494 30 ; ; : 40436 8494 31 poiei poiei NN 40436 8494 32 = = SYM 40436 8494 33 n n CC 40436 8494 34 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8494 35 / / SYM 40436 8494 36 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 8494 37 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 8494 38 , , , 40436 8494 39 ti ti NNP 40436 8494 40 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 8494 41 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 8494 42 = = SYM 40436 8494 43 s s NNP 40436 8494 44 do do VB 40436 8494 45 / / SYM 40436 8494 46 xê| xê| NNP 40436 8494 47 be be VB 40436 8494 48 / / SYM 40436 8494 49 ltiston ltiston NNP 40436 8494 50 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8494 51 . . . 40436 8494 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8494 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8495 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8495 2 Side side NN 40436 8495 3 - - HYPH 40436 8495 4 note note NN 40436 8495 5 : : : 40436 8495 6 All all DT 40436 8495 7 men man NNS 40436 8495 8 wish wish VBP 40436 8495 9 for for IN 40436 8495 10 what what WP 40436 8495 11 is be VBZ 40436 8495 12 good good JJ 40436 8495 13 for for IN 40436 8495 14 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8495 15 . . . 40436 8496 1 Despots despot NNS 40436 8496 2 and and CC 40436 8496 3 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 8496 4 , , , 40436 8496 5 when when WRB 40436 8496 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8496 7 kill kill VBP 40436 8496 8 any any DT 40436 8496 9 one one NN 40436 8496 10 , , , 40436 8496 11 do do VB 40436 8496 12 so so RB 40436 8496 13 because because IN 40436 8496 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8496 15 think think VBP 40436 8496 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8496 17 good good JJ 40436 8496 18 for for IN 40436 8496 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8496 20 . . . 40436 8497 1 If if IN 40436 8497 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8497 3 be be VB 40436 8497 4 really really RB 40436 8497 5 not not RB 40436 8497 6 good good JJ 40436 8497 7 , , , 40436 8497 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8497 9 do do VBP 40436 8497 10 not not RB 40436 8497 11 do do VB 40436 8497 12 what what WP 40436 8497 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8497 14 will will MD 40436 8497 15 , , , 40436 8497 16 and and CC 40436 8497 17 therefore therefore RB 40436 8497 18 have have VB 40436 8497 19 no no DT 40436 8497 20 real real JJ 40436 8497 21 power power NN 40436 8497 22 . . . 40436 8497 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8498 1 That that DT 40436 8498 2 which which WDT 40436 8498 3 men man NNS 40436 8498 4 wish wish VBP 40436 8498 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8498 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8498 7 lays lay VBZ 40436 8498 8 down down RP 40436 8498 9 as as IN 40436 8498 10 a a DT 40436 8498 11 general general JJ 40436 8498 12 proposition proposition NN 40436 8498 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8498 14 is be VBZ 40436 8498 15 to to TO 40436 8498 16 obtain obtain VB 40436 8498 17 good good JJ 40436 8498 18 , , , 40436 8498 19 and and CC 40436 8498 20 to to TO 40436 8498 21 escape escape VB 40436 8498 22 evil evil NN 40436 8498 23 . . . 40436 8499 1 Each each DT 40436 8499 2 separate separate JJ 40436 8499 3 act act NN 40436 8499 4 which which WDT 40436 8499 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8499 6 perform perform VBP 40436 8499 7 , , , 40436 8499 8 is be VBZ 40436 8499 9 performed perform VBN 40436 8499 10 not not RB 40436 8499 11 with with IN 40436 8499 12 a a DT 40436 8499 13 view view NN 40436 8499 14 to to IN 40436 8499 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8499 16 own own JJ 40436 8499 17 special special JJ 40436 8499 18 result result NN 40436 8499 19 , , , 40436 8499 20 but but CC 40436 8499 21 with with IN 40436 8499 22 a a DT 40436 8499 23 view view NN 40436 8499 24 to to IN 40436 8499 25 these these DT 40436 8499 26 constant constant JJ 40436 8499 27 and and CC 40436 8499 28 paramount paramount JJ 40436 8499 29 ends end NNS 40436 8499 30 . . . 40436 8500 1 Good good JJ 40436 8500 2 things thing NNS 40436 8500 3 , , , 40436 8500 4 or or CC 40436 8500 5 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8500 6 things thing NNS 40436 8500 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8500 8 for for IN 40436 8500 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8500 10 alternates alternate NNS 40436 8500 11 the the DT 40436 8500 12 phrases phrase NNS 40436 8500 13 as as IN 40436 8500 14 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 8500 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8500 16 , , , 40436 8500 17 are be VBP 40436 8500 18 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 8500 19 , , , 40436 8500 20 health health NN 40436 8500 21 , , , 40436 8500 22 wealth wealth NN 40436 8500 23 , , , 40436 8500 24 and and CC 40436 8500 25 other other JJ 40436 8500 26 such such JJ 40436 8500 27 things thing NNS 40436 8500 28 . . . 40436 8501 1 Evil evil JJ 40436 8501 2 things thing NNS 40436 8501 3 are be VBP 40436 8501 4 the the DT 40436 8501 5 contraries contrary NNS 40436 8501 6 of of IN 40436 8501 7 these these DT 40436 8501 8 . . . 40436 8502 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8502 2 21 21 CD 40436 8502 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8502 4 Many many JJ 40436 8502 5 things thing NNS 40436 8502 6 are be VBP 40436 8502 7 in in IN 40436 8502 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8502 9 neither neither CC 40436 8502 10 good good JJ 40436 8502 11 nor nor CC 40436 8502 12 evil evil JJ 40436 8502 13 , , , 40436 8502 14 but but CC 40436 8502 15 may may MD 40436 8502 16 become become VB 40436 8502 17 one one CD 40436 8502 18 or or CC 40436 8502 19 the the DT 40436 8502 20 other other JJ 40436 8502 21 , , , 40436 8502 22 according accord VBG 40436 8502 23 to to IN 40436 8502 24 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 8502 25 -- -- : 40436 8502 26 such such JJ 40436 8502 27 as as IN 40436 8502 28 stones stone NNS 40436 8502 29 , , , 40436 8502 30 wood wood NN 40436 8502 31 , , , 40436 8502 32 the the DT 40436 8502 33 acts act NNS 40436 8502 34 of of IN 40436 8502 35 sitting sit VBG 40436 8502 36 still still RB 40436 8502 37 or or CC 40436 8502 38 moving move VBG 40436 8502 39 , , , 40436 8502 40 & & CC 40436 8502 41 c. c. NN 40436 8502 42 When when WRB 40436 8502 43 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8502 44 do do VBP 40436 8502 45 any any DT 40436 8502 46 of of IN 40436 8502 47 these these DT 40436 8502 48 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 8502 49 acts act NNS 40436 8502 50 , , , 40436 8502 51 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8502 52 is be VBZ 40436 8502 53 with with IN 40436 8502 54 a a DT 40436 8502 55 view view NN 40436 8502 56 to to IN 40436 8502 57 the the DT 40436 8502 58 pursuit pursuit NN 40436 8502 59 of of IN 40436 8502 60 good good JJ 40436 8502 61 , , , 40436 8502 62 or or CC 40436 8502 63 to to IN 40436 8502 64 the the DT 40436 8502 65 avoidance avoidance NN 40436 8502 66 of of IN 40436 8502 67 evil evil NN 40436 8502 68 : : : 40436 8502 69 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8502 70 do do VBP 40436 8502 71 not not RB 40436 8502 72 wish wish VB 40436 8502 73 for for IN 40436 8502 74 the the DT 40436 8502 75 act act NN 40436 8502 76 , , , 40436 8502 77 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8502 78 wish wish VBP 40436 8502 79 for for IN 40436 8502 80 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8502 81 good good JJ 40436 8502 82 or or CC 40436 8502 83 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8502 84 results result NNS 40436 8502 85 . . . 40436 8503 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8503 2 do do VBP 40436 8503 3 every every DT 40436 8503 4 thing thing NN 40436 8503 5 for for IN 40436 8503 6 the the DT 40436 8503 7 sake sake NN 40436 8503 8 of of IN 40436 8503 9 good good NN 40436 8503 10 : : : 40436 8503 11 and and CC 40436 8503 12 if if IN 40436 8503 13 the the DT 40436 8503 14 results result NNS 40436 8503 15 are be VBP 40436 8503 16 really really RB 40436 8503 17 good good JJ 40436 8503 18 or or CC 40436 8503 19 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8503 20 , , , 40436 8503 21 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8503 22 accomplish accomplish VBP 40436 8503 23 what what WP 40436 8503 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8503 25 wish wish VBP 40436 8503 26 : : : 40436 8503 27 if if IN 40436 8503 28 the the DT 40436 8503 29 contrary contrary NN 40436 8503 30 , , , 40436 8503 31 not not RB 40436 8503 32 . . . 40436 8504 1 Now now RB 40436 8504 2 , , , 40436 8504 3 Despots Despots NNPS 40436 8504 4 and and CC 40436 8504 5 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 8504 6 , , , 40436 8504 7 when when WRB 40436 8504 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8504 9 kill kill VBP 40436 8504 10 or or CC 40436 8504 11 banish banish VBP 40436 8504 12 or or CC 40436 8504 13 impoverish impoverish VB 40436 8504 14 any any DT 40436 8504 15 one one NN 40436 8504 16 , , , 40436 8504 17 do do VB 40436 8504 18 so so RB 40436 8504 19 because because IN 40436 8504 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8504 21 think think VBP 40436 8504 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8504 23 will will MD 40436 8504 24 be be VB 40436 8504 25 better well JJR 40436 8504 26 for for IN 40436 8504 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8504 28 , , , 40436 8504 29 or or CC 40436 8504 30 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8504 31 . . . 40436 8505 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8505 2 22 22 CD 40436 8505 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8505 4 If if IN 40436 8505 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8505 6 be be VB 40436 8505 7 good good JJ 40436 8505 8 for for IN 40436 8505 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8505 10 , , , 40436 8505 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8505 12 do do VBP 40436 8505 13 what what WP 40436 8505 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8505 15 wish wish VBP 40436 8505 16 : : : 40436 8505 17 if if IN 40436 8505 18 evil evil NN 40436 8505 19 for for IN 40436 8505 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8505 21 , , , 40436 8505 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8505 23 do do VBP 40436 8505 24 the the DT 40436 8505 25 contrary contrary NN 40436 8505 26 of of IN 40436 8505 27 what what WP 40436 8505 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8505 29 wish wish VBP 40436 8505 30 and and CC 40436 8505 31 therefore therefore RB 40436 8505 32 have have VBP 40436 8505 33 no no DT 40436 8505 34 power power NN 40436 8505 35 . . . 40436 8506 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8506 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8506 3 21 21 CD 40436 8506 4 : : : 40436 8506 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8506 6 , , , 40436 8506 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8506 8 , , , 40436 8506 9 p. p. NN 40436 8506 10 467 467 CD 40436 8506 11 E. E. NNP 40436 8506 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8506 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8506 14 : : : 40436 8506 15 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 8506 16 = = SYM 40436 8506 17 n n CC 40436 8506 18 le le NNP 40436 8506 19 / / SYM 40436 8506 20 geis geis NNP 40436 8506 21 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8506 22 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 8506 23 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8506 24 sophi sophi NNP 40436 8506 25 / / , 40436 8506 26 an an DT 40436 8506 27 te te NNP 40436 8506 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8506 29 u(gi u(gi NNP 40436 8506 30 / / SYM 40436 8506 31 eian eian NNP 40436 8506 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8506 33 plou plou NNP 40436 8506 34 = = SYM 40436 8506 35 ton ton NN 40436 8506 36 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8506 37 ta)/lla ta)/lla NNP 40436 8506 38 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 8506 39 toiau toiau NNP 40436 8506 40 = = SYM 40436 8506 41 ta ta NNP 40436 8506 42 , , , 40436 8506 43 kaka\ kaka\ NNP 40436 8506 44 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8506 45 ta)nanti ta)nanti NNP 40436 8506 46 / / SYM 40436 8506 47 a a DT 40436 8506 48 tou tou NNP 40436 8506 49 / / SYM 40436 8506 50 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8506 51 ? ? . 40436 8507 1 E)/gôge E)/gôge NNP 40436 8507 2 . . . 40436 8507 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8507 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8508 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8508 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8508 3 22 22 CD 40436 8508 4 : : : 40436 8508 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8508 6 , , , 40436 8508 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8508 8 , , , 40436 8508 9 p. p. NN 40436 8508 10 468 468 CD 40436 8508 11 B B NNP 40436 8508 12 - - HYPH 40436 8508 13 C. C. NNP 40436 8508 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8508 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8508 16 : : : 40436 8508 17 ou)kou ou)kou NNP 40436 8508 18 = = SYM 40436 8508 19 n n NNP 40436 8508 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8508 21 a)pokti a)pokti NNPS 40436 8508 22 / / SYM 40436 8508 23 nnumen nnumen NNP 40436 8508 24 , , , 40436 8508 25 ei)/ ei)/ NNP 40436 8508 26 tin tin NNP 40436 8508 27 ' ' '' 40436 8508 28 a)pokti a)pokti NNS 40436 8508 29 / / SYM 40436 8508 30 nnumen nnuman NNS 40436 8508 31 , , , 40436 8508 32 . . . 40436 8509 1 . . . 40436 8510 1 . . . 40436 8511 1 . . . 40436 8512 1 oi)o oi)o NNP 40436 8512 2 / / SYM 40436 8512 3 menoi menoi NNP 40436 8512 4 a)/meinon a)/meinon NNP 40436 8512 5 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8512 6 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 8512 7 = = SYM 40436 8512 8 n n CC 40436 8512 9 tau tau NNP 40436 8512 10 = = SYM 40436 8512 11 ta ta NNP 40436 8512 12 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 8512 13 mê/ mê/ NN 40436 8512 14 ? ? . 40436 8513 1 . . . 40436 8514 1 . . . 40436 8515 1 . . . 40436 8516 1 e(/nek e(/nek NNP 40436 8516 2 ' ' POS 40436 8516 3 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 8516 4 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8516 5 a)gathou= a)gathou= NN 40436 8516 6 a(/panta a(/panta NNP 40436 8516 7 tau tau NNP 40436 8516 8 = = SYM 40436 8516 9 ta ta NNP 40436 8516 10 poiou poiou NNP 40436 8516 11 = = SYM 40436 8516 12 sin sin NN 40436 8516 13 oi oi NNP 40436 8516 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8516 15 poiou poiou NNP 40436 8516 16 = = SYM 40436 8516 17 ntes nte NNS 40436 8516 18 . . . 40436 8517 1 . . . 40436 8518 1 . . . 40436 8519 1 . . . 40436 8520 1 e)a\n e)a\n NFP 40436 8520 2 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8520 3 ô)phe ô)phe NNP 40436 8520 4 / / SYM 40436 8520 5 lima lima NNP 40436 8520 6 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 8520 7 tau tau NNP 40436 8520 8 = = SYM 40436 8520 9 ta ta NNP 40436 8520 10 , , , 40436 8520 11 boulo boulo NNP 40436 8520 12 / / SYM 40436 8520 13 metha metha NNP 40436 8520 14 pra pra NNP 40436 8520 15 / / SYM 40436 8520 16 ttein ttein NN 40436 8520 17 au)ta/ au)ta/ NNP 40436 8520 18 ; ; : 40436 8520 19 blabera\ blabera\ NNP 40436 8520 20 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8520 21 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 8520 22 , , , 40436 8520 23 ou ou NNP 40436 8520 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8520 25 boulo boulo NNP 40436 8520 26 / / SYM 40436 8520 27 metha metha NNP 40436 8520 28 . . . 40436 8521 1 . . . 40436 8522 1 . . . 40436 8523 1 . . . 40436 8524 1 . . . 40436 8525 1 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 8525 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8525 3 a)gatha\ a)gatha\ NNP 40436 8525 4 boulo boulo NN 40436 8525 5 / / SYM 40436 8525 6 metha metha NN 40436 8525 7 , , , 40436 8525 8 ô(=s ô(=s NNP 40436 8525 9 phê\|s phê\|s NNP 40436 8525 10 su/ su/ NN 40436 8525 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8525 12 , , , 40436 8525 13 & & CC 40436 8525 14 c. c. NNP 40436 8525 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8525 16 To to TO 40436 8525 17 do do VB 40436 8525 18 evil evil NN 40436 8525 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8525 20 continues continue VBZ 40436 8525 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8525 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8525 23 , , , 40436 8525 24 is be VBZ 40436 8525 25 the the DT 40436 8525 26 worst bad JJS 40436 8525 27 thing thing NN 40436 8525 28 that that WDT 40436 8525 29 can can MD 40436 8525 30 happen happen VB 40436 8525 31 to to IN 40436 8525 32 any any DT 40436 8525 33 one one CD 40436 8525 34 ; ; : 40436 8525 35 the the DT 40436 8525 36 evil evil NNP 40436 8525 37 - - HYPH 40436 8525 38 doer doer NNP 40436 8525 39 is be VBZ 40436 8525 40 the the DT 40436 8525 41 most most RBS 40436 8525 42 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8525 43 and and CC 40436 8525 44 pitiable pitiable JJ 40436 8525 45 of of IN 40436 8525 46 men man NNS 40436 8525 47 . . . 40436 8526 1 The the DT 40436 8526 2 person person NN 40436 8526 3 who who WP 40436 8526 4 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8526 5 evil evil NN 40436 8526 6 is be VBZ 40436 8526 7 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 40436 8526 8 , , , 40436 8526 9 and and CC 40436 8526 10 is be VBZ 40436 8526 11 to to TO 40436 8526 12 be be VB 40436 8526 13 pitied pity VBN 40436 8526 14 ; ; : 40436 8526 15 but but CC 40436 8526 16 much much RB 40436 8526 17 less less RBR 40436 8526 18 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 40436 8526 19 and and CC 40436 8526 20 less less JJR 40436 8526 21 to to TO 40436 8526 22 be be VB 40436 8526 23 pitied pity VBN 40436 8526 24 than than IN 40436 8526 25 the the DT 40436 8526 26 evil evil NN 40436 8526 27 - - HYPH 40436 8526 28 doer doer NN 40436 8526 29 . . . 40436 8527 1 If if IN 40436 8527 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8527 3 have have VBP 40436 8527 4 a a DT 40436 8527 5 concealed conceal VBN 40436 8527 6 dagger dagger NN 40436 8527 7 in in IN 40436 8527 8 the the DT 40436 8527 9 public public JJ 40436 8527 10 market market NN 40436 8527 11 - - HYPH 40436 8527 12 place place NN 40436 8527 13 , , , 40436 8527 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8527 15 can can MD 40436 8527 16 kill kill VB 40436 8527 17 any any DT 40436 8527 18 one one NN 40436 8527 19 whom whom WP 40436 8527 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8527 21 choose choose VBP 40436 8527 22 : : : 40436 8527 23 but but CC 40436 8527 24 this this DT 40436 8527 25 is be VBZ 40436 8527 26 no no DT 40436 8527 27 good good JJ 40436 8527 28 to to IN 40436 8527 29 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8527 30 , , , 40436 8527 31 nor nor CC 40436 8527 32 is be VBZ 40436 8527 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8527 34 a a DT 40436 8527 35 proof proof NN 40436 8527 36 of of IN 40436 8527 37 great great JJ 40436 8527 38 power power NN 40436 8527 39 , , , 40436 8527 40 because because IN 40436 8527 41 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8527 42 shall shall MD 40436 8527 43 be be VB 40436 8527 44 forthwith forthwith NNP 40436 8527 45 taken take VBN 40436 8527 46 up up RP 40436 8527 47 and and CC 40436 8527 48 punished punish VBN 40436 8527 49 . . . 40436 8528 1 The the DT 40436 8528 2 result result NN 40436 8528 3 is be VBZ 40436 8528 4 not not RB 40436 8528 5 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8528 6 , , , 40436 8528 7 but but CC 40436 8528 8 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 8528 9 : : : 40436 8528 10 therefore therefore RB 40436 8528 11 the the DT 40436 8528 12 act act NN 40436 8528 13 is be VBZ 40436 8528 14 not not RB 40436 8528 15 good good JJ 40436 8528 16 , , , 40436 8528 17 nor nor CC 40436 8528 18 is be VBZ 40436 8528 19 the the DT 40436 8528 20 power power NN 40436 8528 21 to to TO 40436 8528 22 do do VB 40436 8528 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8528 24 either either CC 40436 8528 25 good good JJ 40436 8528 26 or or CC 40436 8528 27 desirable desirable JJ 40436 8528 28 . . . 40436 8529 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8529 2 23 23 CD 40436 8529 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8529 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8529 5 is be VBZ 40436 8529 6 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 8529 7 good good JJ 40436 8529 8 to to TO 40436 8529 9 kill kill VB 40436 8529 10 , , , 40436 8529 11 banish banish VB 40436 8529 12 , , , 40436 8529 13 or or CC 40436 8529 14 impoverish impoverish JJ 40436 8529 15 -- -- : 40436 8529 16 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 8529 17 bad bad JJ 40436 8529 18 . . . 40436 8530 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8530 2 is be VBZ 40436 8530 3 good good JJ 40436 8530 4 when when WRB 40436 8530 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8530 6 do do VBP 40436 8530 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8530 8 justly justly RB 40436 8530 9 : : : 40436 8530 10 bad bad JJ 40436 8530 11 , , , 40436 8530 12 when when WRB 40436 8530 13 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8530 14 do do VBP 40436 8530 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8530 16 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 8530 17 . . . 40436 8531 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8531 2 24 24 CD 40436 8531 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8531 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8531 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8531 6 23 23 CD 40436 8531 7 : : : 40436 8531 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8531 9 , , , 40436 8531 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8531 11 , , , 40436 8531 12 p. p. NN 40436 8532 1 469 469 CD 40436 8532 2 - - SYM 40436 8532 3 470 470 CD 40436 8532 4 . . . 40436 8532 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8533 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8533 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8533 3 24 24 CD 40436 8533 4 : : : 40436 8533 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8533 6 , , , 40436 8533 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8533 8 , , , 40436 8533 9 p. p. NN 40436 8533 10 470 470 CD 40436 8533 11 C. c. NN 40436 8533 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8533 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8533 14 Side side NN 40436 8533 15 - - HYPH 40436 8533 16 note note NN 40436 8533 17 : : : 40436 8533 18 Comparison comparison NN 40436 8533 19 of of IN 40436 8533 20 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8533 21 , , , 40436 8533 22 usurping usurping NN 40436 8533 23 despot despot NN 40436 8533 24 of of IN 40436 8533 25 Macedonia Macedonia NNP 40436 8533 26 -- -- : 40436 8533 27 Polus polus JJ 40436 8533 28 affirms affirm NNS 40436 8533 29 that that IN 40436 8533 30 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8533 31 is be VBZ 40436 8533 32 happy happy JJ 40436 8533 33 , , , 40436 8533 34 and and CC 40436 8533 35 that that IN 40436 8533 36 every every DT 40436 8533 37 one one NN 40436 8533 38 thinks think VBZ 40436 8533 39 so so RB 40436 8533 40 -- -- : 40436 8533 41 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8533 42 admits admit VBZ 40436 8533 43 that that IN 40436 8533 44 every every DT 40436 8533 45 one one NN 40436 8533 46 thinks think VBZ 40436 8533 47 so so RB 40436 8533 48 , , , 40436 8533 49 but but CC 40436 8533 50 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 8533 51 denies deny VBZ 40436 8533 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8533 53 . . . 40436 8533 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8534 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8534 2 Polus._--A Polus._--A NNP 40436 8534 3 child child NN 40436 8534 4 can can MD 40436 8534 5 refute refute VB 40436 8534 6 such such JJ 40436 8534 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8534 8 . . . 40436 8535 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 8535 2 have have VBP 40436 8535 3 heard hear VBN 40436 8535 4 of of IN 40436 8535 5 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8535 6 King King NNP 40436 8535 7 of of IN 40436 8535 8 Macedonia Macedonia NNP 40436 8535 9 . . . 40436 8536 1 Is be VBZ 40436 8536 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8536 3 , , , 40436 8536 4 in in IN 40436 8536 5 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8536 6 opinion opinion NN 40436 8536 7 , , , 40436 8536 8 happy happy JJ 40436 8536 9 or or CC 40436 8536 10 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8536 11 ? ? . 40436 8537 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8537 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 8537 3 do do VBP 40436 8537 4 not not RB 40436 8537 5 know know VB 40436 8537 6 : : : 40436 8537 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8537 8 have have VBP 40436 8537 9 never never RB 40436 8537 10 been be VBN 40436 8537 11 in in IN 40436 8537 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8537 13 society society NN 40436 8537 14 . . . 40436 8538 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8538 2 Polus._--Cannot polus._--cannot XX 40436 8538 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8538 4 tell tell VBP 40436 8538 5 without without IN 40436 8538 6 that that DT 40436 8538 7 , , , 40436 8538 8 whether whether IN 40436 8538 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8538 10 is be VBZ 40436 8538 11 happy happy JJ 40436 8538 12 or or CC 40436 8538 13 not not RB 40436 8538 14 ? ? . 40436 8539 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8539 2 Sokr._--No Sokr._--No NNP 40436 8539 3 , , , 40436 8539 4 certainly certainly RB 40436 8539 5 not not RB 40436 8539 6 . . . 40436 8540 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8540 2 Polus._--Then Polus._--Then NNP 40436 8540 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8540 4 will will MD 40436 8540 5 not not RB 40436 8540 6 call call VB 40436 8540 7 even even RB 40436 8540 8 the the DT 40436 8540 9 Great Great NNP 40436 8540 10 King King NNP 40436 8540 11 happy happy JJ 40436 8540 12 ? ? . 40436 8541 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8541 2 Sokr._--No Sokr._--No NNP 40436 8541 3 : : : 40436 8541 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8541 5 do do VBP 40436 8541 6 not not RB 40436 8541 7 know know VB 40436 8541 8 how how WRB 40436 8541 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8541 10 stands stand VBZ 40436 8541 11 in in IN 40436 8541 12 respect respect NN 40436 8541 13 to to IN 40436 8541 14 education education NN 40436 8541 15 and and CC 40436 8541 16 justice justice NN 40436 8541 17 . . . 40436 8542 1 _ _ IN 40436 8542 2 Polus._--What polus._--what CD 40436 8542 3 ! ! . 40436 8543 1 does do VBZ 40436 8543 2 all all DT 40436 8543 3 happiness happiness NN 40436 8543 4 consist consist VB 40436 8543 5 in in IN 40436 8543 6 that that DT 40436 8543 7 ? ? . 40436 8544 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8544 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNS 40436 8544 3 say say VBP 40436 8544 4 that that IN 40436 8544 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8544 6 does do VBZ 40436 8544 7 . . . 40436 8545 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8545 2 maintain maintain VBP 40436 8545 3 that that IN 40436 8545 4 the the DT 40436 8545 5 good good JJ 40436 8545 6 and and CC 40436 8545 7 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8545 8 man man NN 40436 8545 9 or or CC 40436 8545 10 woman woman NN 40436 8545 11 is be VBZ 40436 8545 12 happy happy JJ 40436 8545 13 : : : 40436 8545 14 the the DT 40436 8545 15 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8545 16 and and CC 40436 8545 17 wicked wicked JJ 40436 8545 18 , , , 40436 8545 19 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8545 20 . . . 40436 8546 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8546 2 25 25 CD 40436 8546 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8546 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8546 5 Polus._--Then Polus._--Then NNP 40436 8546 6 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8546 7 is be VBZ 40436 8546 8 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8546 9 , , , 40436 8546 10 according accord VBG 40436 8546 11 to to IN 40436 8546 12 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8546 13 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8546 14 ? ? . 40436 8547 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8547 2 Sokr._--Assuredly sokr._--assuredly RB 40436 8547 3 , , , 40436 8547 4 if if IN 40436 8547 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8547 6 is be VBZ 40436 8547 7 wicked wicked JJ 40436 8547 8 . . . 40436 8548 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8548 2 Polus._--Wicked Polus._--Wicked NNP 40436 8548 3 , , , 40436 8548 4 of of IN 40436 8548 5 course course NN 40436 8548 6 ; ; : 40436 8548 7 since since IN 40436 8548 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8548 9 has have VBZ 40436 8548 10 committed commit VBN 40436 8548 11 enormous enormous JJ 40436 8548 12 crimes crime NNS 40436 8548 13 : : : 40436 8548 14 but but CC 40436 8548 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8548 16 has have VBZ 40436 8548 17 obtained obtain VBN 40436 8548 18 complete complete JJ 40436 8548 19 kingly kingly NNP 40436 8548 20 power power NN 40436 8548 21 in in IN 40436 8548 22 Macedonia Macedonia NNP 40436 8548 23 . . . 40436 8549 1 Is be VBZ 40436 8549 2 there there EX 40436 8549 3 any any DT 40436 8549 4 Athenian Athenian NNP 40436 8549 5 , , , 40436 8549 6 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 8549 7 included include VBD 40436 8549 8 , , , 40436 8549 9 who who WP 40436 8549 10 would would MD 40436 8549 11 not not RB 40436 8549 12 rather rather RB 40436 8549 13 be be VB 40436 8549 14 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8549 15 than than IN 40436 8549 16 any any DT 40436 8549 17 other other JJ 40436 8549 18 man man NN 40436 8549 19 in in IN 40436 8549 20 Macedonia Macedonia NNP 40436 8549 21 ? ? . 40436 8550 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8550 2 26 26 CD 40436 8550 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8550 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8550 5 Sokr._--All Sokr._--All NNP 40436 8550 6 the the DT 40436 8550 7 public public NN 40436 8550 8 , , , 40436 8550 9 with with IN 40436 8550 10 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 8550 11 , , , 40436 8550 12 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 8550 13 , , , 40436 8550 14 and and CC 40436 8550 15 the the DT 40436 8550 16 most most RBS 40436 8550 17 eminent eminent JJ 40436 8550 18 men man NNS 40436 8550 19 among among IN 40436 8550 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8550 21 , , , 40436 8550 22 will will MD 40436 8550 23 agree agree VB 40436 8550 24 with with IN 40436 8550 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8550 26 in in IN 40436 8550 27 declaring declare VBG 40436 8550 28 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8550 29 to to TO 40436 8550 30 be be VB 40436 8550 31 happy happy JJ 40436 8550 32 . . . 40436 8551 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8551 2 alone alone RB 40436 8551 3 do do VBP 40436 8551 4 not not RB 40436 8551 5 agree agree VB 40436 8551 6 with with IN 40436 8551 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8551 8 . . . 40436 8552 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 8552 2 , , , 40436 8552 3 like like IN 40436 8552 4 a a DT 40436 8552 5 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8552 6 , , , 40436 8552 7 intend intend VBP 40436 8552 8 to to TO 40436 8552 9 overwhelm overwhelm VB 40436 8552 10 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8552 11 and and CC 40436 8552 12 gain gain VB 40436 8552 13 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8552 14 cause cause NN 40436 8552 15 , , , 40436 8552 16 by by IN 40436 8552 17 calling call VBG 40436 8552 18 a a DT 40436 8552 19 multitude multitude NN 40436 8552 20 of of IN 40436 8552 21 witnesses witness NNS 40436 8552 22 : : : 40436 8552 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8552 24 shall shall MD 40436 8552 25 prove prove VB 40436 8552 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8552 27 case case NN 40436 8552 28 without without IN 40436 8552 29 calling call VBG 40436 8552 30 any any DT 40436 8552 31 other other JJ 40436 8552 32 witness witness NN 40436 8552 33 than than IN 40436 8552 34 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 8552 35 . . . 40436 8553 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8553 2 27 27 CD 40436 8553 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8553 4 Do do VBP 40436 8553 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8553 6 think think VB 40436 8553 7 that that IN 40436 8553 8 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8553 9 would would MD 40436 8553 10 have have VB 40436 8553 11 been be VBN 40436 8553 12 a a DT 40436 8553 13 happy happy JJ 40436 8553 14 man man NN 40436 8553 15 , , , 40436 8553 16 if if IN 40436 8553 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8553 18 had have VBD 40436 8553 19 been be VBN 40436 8553 20 defeated defeat VBN 40436 8553 21 in in IN 40436 8553 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8553 23 conspiracy conspiracy NN 40436 8553 24 and and CC 40436 8553 25 punished punish VBN 40436 8553 26 ? ? . 40436 8554 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8554 2 Polus._--Certainly polus._--certainly RB 40436 8554 3 not not RB 40436 8554 4 : : : 40436 8554 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8554 6 would would MD 40436 8554 7 then then RB 40436 8554 8 have have VB 40436 8554 9 been be VBN 40436 8554 10 very very RB 40436 8554 11 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8554 12 . . . 40436 8555 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8555 2 Sokr._--Here Sokr._--Here NNP 40436 8555 3 again again RB 40436 8555 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8555 5 differ differ VBP 40436 8555 6 from from IN 40436 8555 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8555 8 : : : 40436 8555 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8555 10 think think VBP 40436 8555 11 that that IN 40436 8555 12 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8555 13 , , , 40436 8555 14 or or CC 40436 8555 15 any any DT 40436 8555 16 other other JJ 40436 8555 17 wicked wicked JJ 40436 8555 18 man man NN 40436 8555 19 , , , 40436 8555 20 is be VBZ 40436 8555 21 under under IN 40436 8555 22 all all DT 40436 8555 23 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 8555 24 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8555 25 ; ; : 40436 8555 26 but but CC 40436 8555 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8555 28 is be VBZ 40436 8555 29 less less RBR 40436 8555 30 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8555 31 , , , 40436 8555 32 if if IN 40436 8555 33 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 8555 34 punished punish VBN 40436 8555 35 , , , 40436 8555 36 than than IN 40436 8555 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8555 38 would would MD 40436 8555 39 be be VB 40436 8555 40 if if IN 40436 8555 41 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 8555 42 and and CC 40436 8555 43 successful successful JJ 40436 8555 44 . . . 40436 8556 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8556 2 28 28 CD 40436 8556 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8556 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8556 5 Polus._--How Polus._--How NNP 40436 8556 6 say say VB 40436 8556 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8556 8 ? ? . 40436 8557 1 If if IN 40436 8557 2 a a DT 40436 8557 3 man man NN 40436 8557 4 , , , 40436 8557 5 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 8557 6 conspiring conspire VBG 40436 8557 7 to to TO 40436 8557 8 become become VB 40436 8557 9 despot despot NN 40436 8557 10 , , , 40436 8557 11 be be VB 40436 8557 12 captured capture VBN 40436 8557 13 , , , 40436 8557 14 subjected subject VBN 40436 8557 15 to to IN 40436 8557 16 torture torture NN 40436 8557 17 , , , 40436 8557 18 mutilated mutilated JJ 40436 8557 19 , , , 40436 8557 20 with with IN 40436 8557 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8557 22 eyes eye NNS 40436 8557 23 burnt burn VBN 40436 8557 24 out out RP 40436 8557 25 and and CC 40436 8557 26 with with IN 40436 8557 27 many many JJ 40436 8557 28 other other JJ 40436 8557 29 outrages outrage NNS 40436 8557 30 inflicted inflict VBN 40436 8557 31 , , , 40436 8557 32 not not RB 40436 8557 33 only only RB 40436 8557 34 upon upon IN 40436 8557 35 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8557 36 but but CC 40436 8557 37 upon upon IN 40436 8557 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8557 39 wife wife NN 40436 8557 40 and and CC 40436 8557 41 children child NNS 40436 8557 42 -- -- : 40436 8557 43 do do VBP 40436 8557 44 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8557 45 say say VB 40436 8557 46 that that IN 40436 8557 47 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8557 48 will will MD 40436 8557 49 be be VB 40436 8557 50 more more RBR 40436 8557 51 happy happy JJ 40436 8557 52 than than IN 40436 8557 53 if if IN 40436 8557 54 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8557 55 succeeded succeed VBD 40436 8557 56 in in IN 40436 8557 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8557 58 enterprise enterprise NN 40436 8557 59 , , , 40436 8557 60 and and CC 40436 8557 61 passed pass VBD 40436 8557 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8557 63 life life NN 40436 8557 64 in in IN 40436 8557 65 possession possession NN 40436 8557 66 of of IN 40436 8557 67 undisputed undisputed JJ 40436 8557 68 authority authority NN 40436 8557 69 over over IN 40436 8557 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8557 71 city city NN 40436 8557 72 -- -- : 40436 8557 73 envied envy VBN 40436 8557 74 and and CC 40436 8557 75 extolled extoll VBD 40436 8557 76 as as IN 40436 8557 77 happy happy JJ 40436 8557 78 , , , 40436 8557 79 by by IN 40436 8557 80 citizens citizen NNS 40436 8557 81 and and CC 40436 8557 82 strangers stranger NNS 40436 8557 83 alike alike RB 40436 8557 84 ? ? . 40436 8558 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8558 2 29 29 CD 40436 8558 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8558 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8558 5 Sokr._--More Sokr._--More NNP 40436 8558 6 happy happy JJ 40436 8558 7 , , , 40436 8558 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8558 9 shall shall MD 40436 8558 10 not not RB 40436 8558 11 say say VB 40436 8558 12 : : : 40436 8558 13 for for IN 40436 8558 14 in in IN 40436 8558 15 both both DT 40436 8558 16 cases case NNS 40436 8558 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8558 18 will will MD 40436 8558 19 be be VB 40436 8558 20 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8558 21 ; ; : 40436 8558 22 but but CC 40436 8558 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8558 24 will will MD 40436 8558 25 be be VB 40436 8558 26 less less RBR 40436 8558 27 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8558 28 on on IN 40436 8558 29 the the DT 40436 8558 30 former former JJ 40436 8558 31 supposition supposition NN 40436 8558 32 . . . 40436 8559 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8559 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8559 3 25 25 CD 40436 8559 4 : : : 40436 8559 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8559 6 , , , 40436 8559 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8559 8 , , , 40436 8559 9 p. p. NN 40436 8559 10 470 470 CD 40436 8559 11 E. E. NNP 40436 8559 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8559 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8559 14 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8559 15 26 26 CD 40436 8559 16 : : : 40436 8559 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8559 18 , , , 40436 8559 19 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8559 20 , , , 40436 8559 21 p. p. NN 40436 8559 22 471 471 CD 40436 8559 23 B B NNP 40436 8559 24 - - HYPH 40436 8559 25 C. C. NNP 40436 8559 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8559 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8559 28 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8559 29 27 27 CD 40436 8559 30 : : : 40436 8559 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8559 32 , , , 40436 8559 33 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8559 34 , , , 40436 8559 35 p. p. NN 40436 8559 36 472 472 CD 40436 8559 37 B. b. NN 40436 8560 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8560 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8560 3 : : : 40436 8560 4 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 8560 5 ' ' `` 40436 8560 6 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 8560 7 soi soi NN 40436 8560 8 ei)=s ei)=s : 40436 8560 9 ô)\n ô)\n NNP 40436 8560 10 ou)ch ou)ch NNP 40436 8560 11 o(mologô=. o(mologô=. NNP 40436 8561 1 . . . 40436 8562 1 . . . 40436 8563 1 . . . 40436 8564 1 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 8564 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8564 3 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 8564 4 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 8564 5 se\ se\ NNP 40436 8564 6 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 8564 7 e(/na e(/na NNP 40436 8564 8 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 8564 9 ma ma NNP 40436 8564 10 / / NNP 40436 8564 11 rtura rtura NNP 40436 8564 12 para para NNP 40436 8564 13 / / SYM 40436 8564 14 schômai schômai NNP 40436 8564 15 o(mologou o(mologou NNP 40436 8564 16 = = SYM 40436 8564 17 nta nta NNP 40436 8564 18 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 8564 19 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 8564 20 le le NNP 40436 8564 21 / / SYM 40436 8564 22 gô gô UH 40436 8564 23 , , , 40436 8564 24 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 8564 25 oi)=mai oi)=mai CD 40436 8564 26 a)/xion a)/xion NNP 40436 8564 27 lo lo NNP 40436 8564 28 / / SYM 40436 8564 29 gou gou NNP 40436 8564 30 pepera pepera NNP 40436 8564 31 / / SYM 40436 8564 32 nthai nthai NNP 40436 8564 33 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 8564 34 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 8564 35 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 8564 36 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 8564 37 = = SYM 40436 8564 38 n n CC 40436 8564 39 o o NN 40436 8564 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8564 41 lo lo NNP 40436 8564 42 / / SYM 40436 8564 43 gos gos NNP 40436 8564 44 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 8564 45 ; ; : 40436 8564 46 oi)=mai oi)=mai ADD 40436 8564 47 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8564 48 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 8564 49 soi/ soi/ NNP 40436 8564 50 , , , 40436 8564 51 e)a\n e)a\n -RRB- 40436 8564 52 mê\ mê\ VB 40436 8564 53 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 8564 54 soi soi NN 40436 8564 55 marturô= marturô= NNP 40436 8564 56 ei(=s ei(=s NNP 40436 8564 57 ô)\n ô)\n NNP 40436 8564 58 mo mo NNP 40436 8564 59 / / SYM 40436 8564 60 nos nos NNP 40436 8564 61 , , , 40436 8564 62 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8564 63 d d NNP 40436 8564 64 ' ' `` 40436 8564 65 a)/llous a)/llous JJ 40436 8564 66 pa pa NNP 40436 8564 67 / / SYM 40436 8564 68 ntas ntas NNP 40436 8564 69 tou tou NNP 40436 8564 70 / / SYM 40436 8564 71 tous tous JJ 40436 8564 72 chai chai NNP 40436 8564 73 / / SYM 40436 8564 74 rein rein NNP 40436 8564 75 e)a=|s e)a=|s HYPH 40436 8564 76 . . . 40436 8564 77 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8564 78 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8565 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8565 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8565 3 28 28 CD 40436 8565 4 : : : 40436 8565 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8565 6 , , , 40436 8565 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8565 8 , , , 40436 8565 9 p. p. NN 40436 8565 10 473 473 CD 40436 8565 11 C. C. NNP 40436 8565 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8565 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8565 14 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8565 15 29 29 CD 40436 8565 16 : : : 40436 8565 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8565 18 , , , 40436 8565 19 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8565 20 , , , 40436 8565 21 p. p. NN 40436 8565 22 473 473 CD 40436 8565 23 D. D. NNP 40436 8565 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8565 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8565 26 Side side NN 40436 8565 27 - - HYPH 40436 8565 28 note note NN 40436 8565 29 : : : 40436 8565 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8565 31 maintains--1 maintains--1 NNP 40436 8565 32 . . . 40436 8566 1 That that IN 40436 8566 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8566 3 is be VBZ 40436 8566 4 a a DT 40436 8566 5 greater great JJR 40436 8566 6 evil evil NN 40436 8566 7 to to TO 40436 8566 8 do do VB 40436 8566 9 wrong wrong NN 40436 8566 10 , , , 40436 8566 11 than than IN 40436 8566 12 to to TO 40436 8566 13 suffer suffer VB 40436 8566 14 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8566 15 . . . 40436 8567 1 2 2 LS 40436 8567 2 . . . 40436 8568 1 That that IN 40436 8568 2 if if IN 40436 8568 3 a a DT 40436 8568 4 man man NN 40436 8568 5 has have VBZ 40436 8568 6 done do VBN 40436 8568 7 wrong wrong NN 40436 8568 8 , , , 40436 8568 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8568 10 is be VBZ 40436 8568 11 better well JJR 40436 8568 12 for for IN 40436 8568 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8568 14 to to TO 40436 8568 15 be be VB 40436 8568 16 punished punish VBN 40436 8568 17 than than IN 40436 8568 18 to to TO 40436 8568 19 remain remain VB 40436 8568 20 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 8568 21 . . . 40436 8568 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8569 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8569 2 Sokr._--Which Sokr._--Which NNP 40436 8569 3 of of IN 40436 8569 4 the the DT 40436 8569 5 two two CD 40436 8569 6 is be VBZ 40436 8569 7 worst bad JJS 40436 8569 8 : : : 40436 8569 9 to to TO 40436 8569 10 do do VB 40436 8569 11 wrong wrong NN 40436 8569 12 , , , 40436 8569 13 or or CC 40436 8569 14 to to TO 40436 8569 15 suffer suffer VB 40436 8569 16 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8569 17 ? ? . 40436 8570 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8570 2 Polus._--To polus._--to NN 40436 8570 3 suffer suffer VB 40436 8570 4 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8570 5 . . . 40436 8571 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8571 2 Sokr._--Which Sokr._--Which NNP 40436 8571 3 of of IN 40436 8571 4 the the DT 40436 8571 5 two two CD 40436 8571 6 is be VBZ 40436 8571 7 the the DT 40436 8571 8 most most RBS 40436 8571 9 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8571 10 ? ? . 40436 8572 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8572 2 Polus._--To polus._--to NN 40436 8572 3 do do VBP 40436 8572 4 wrong wrong NN 40436 8572 5 . . . 40436 8573 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8573 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 8573 3 more more RBR 40436 8573 4 ugly ugly JJ 40436 8573 5 and and CC 40436 8573 6 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8573 7 , , , 40436 8573 8 is be VBZ 40436 8573 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8573 10 not not RB 40436 8573 11 then then RB 40436 8573 12 worse bad JJR 40436 8573 13 ? ? . 40436 8574 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8574 2 Polus._--By polus._--by NN 40436 8574 3 no no DT 40436 8574 4 means mean VBZ 40436 8574 5 . . . 40436 8575 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8575 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 8575 3 do do VBP 40436 8575 4 not not RB 40436 8575 5 think think VB 40436 8575 6 then then RB 40436 8575 7 that that IN 40436 8575 8 the the DT 40436 8575 9 good good JJ 40436 8575 10 -- -- : 40436 8575 11 and and CC 40436 8575 12 the the DT 40436 8575 13 fine fine JJ 40436 8575 14 or or CC 40436 8575 15 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8575 16 -- -- : 40436 8575 17 are be VBP 40436 8575 18 one one CD 40436 8575 19 and and CC 40436 8575 20 the the DT 40436 8575 21 same same JJ 40436 8575 22 ; ; : 40436 8575 23 nor nor CC 40436 8575 24 the the DT 40436 8575 25 bad bad JJ 40436 8575 26 -- -- : 40436 8575 27 and and CC 40436 8575 28 the the DT 40436 8575 29 ugly ugly JJ 40436 8575 30 or or CC 40436 8575 31 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8575 32 ? ? . 40436 8576 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8576 2 Polus._--No polus._--no NN 40436 8576 3 : : : 40436 8576 4 certainly certainly RB 40436 8576 5 not not RB 40436 8576 6 . . . 40436 8577 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8577 2 Sokr._--How Sokr._--How NNP 40436 8577 3 is be VBZ 40436 8577 4 this this DT 40436 8577 5 ? ? . 40436 8578 1 Are be VBP 40436 8578 2 not not RB 40436 8578 3 all all RB 40436 8578 4 fine fine JJ 40436 8578 5 or or CC 40436 8578 6 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8578 7 things thing NNS 40436 8578 8 , , , 40436 8578 9 such such JJ 40436 8578 10 as as IN 40436 8578 11 bodies body NNS 40436 8578 12 , , , 40436 8578 13 colours colour NNS 40436 8578 14 , , , 40436 8578 15 figures figure NNS 40436 8578 16 , , , 40436 8578 17 voices voice NNS 40436 8578 18 , , , 40436 8578 19 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 8578 20 , , , 40436 8578 21 & & CC 40436 8578 22 c. c. NNP 40436 8578 23 , , , 40436 8578 24 so so RB 40436 8578 25 denominated denominated JJ 40436 8578 26 from from IN 40436 8578 27 some some DT 40436 8578 28 common common JJ 40436 8578 29 property property NN 40436 8578 30 ? ? . 40436 8579 1 Are be VBP 40436 8579 2 not not RB 40436 8579 3 fine fine JJ 40436 8579 4 bodies body NNS 40436 8579 5 said say VBD 40436 8579 6 to to TO 40436 8579 7 be be VB 40436 8579 8 fine fine JJ 40436 8579 9 , , , 40436 8579 10 either either CC 40436 8579 11 from from IN 40436 8579 12 rendering render VBG 40436 8579 13 some some DT 40436 8579 14 useful useful JJ 40436 8579 15 service service NN 40436 8579 16 , , , 40436 8579 17 or or CC 40436 8579 18 from from IN 40436 8579 19 affording afford VBG 40436 8579 20 some some DT 40436 8579 21 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8579 22 to to IN 40436 8579 23 the the DT 40436 8579 24 spectator spectator NN 40436 8579 25 who who WP 40436 8579 26 contemplates contemplate VBZ 40436 8579 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8579 28 ? ? . 40436 8580 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8580 2 30 30 CD 40436 8580 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8580 4 And and CC 40436 8580 5 are be VBP 40436 8580 6 not not RB 40436 8580 7 figures figure NNS 40436 8580 8 , , , 40436 8580 9 colours colour NNS 40436 8580 10 , , , 40436 8580 11 voices voice NNS 40436 8580 12 , , , 40436 8580 13 laws law NNS 40436 8580 14 , , , 40436 8580 15 sciences sciences NNPS 40436 8580 16 , , , 40436 8580 17 & & CC 40436 8580 18 c. c. NNP 40436 8580 19 , , , 40436 8580 20 called call VBD 40436 8580 21 fine fine JJ 40436 8580 22 or or CC 40436 8580 23 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8580 24 for for IN 40436 8580 25 the the DT 40436 8580 26 same same JJ 40436 8580 27 reason reason NN 40436 8580 28 , , , 40436 8580 29 either either CC 40436 8580 30 for for IN 40436 8580 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8580 32 agreeableness agreeableness NN 40436 8580 33 or or CC 40436 8580 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8580 35 usefulness usefulness NN 40436 8580 36 , , , 40436 8580 37 or or CC 40436 8580 38 both both DT 40436 8580 39 ? ? . 40436 8581 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8581 2 Polus._--Certainly polus._--certainly RB 40436 8581 3 : : : 40436 8581 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8581 5 definition definition NN 40436 8581 6 of of IN 40436 8581 7 the the DT 40436 8581 8 fine fine JJ 40436 8581 9 or or CC 40436 8581 10 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8581 11 , , , 40436 8581 12 by by IN 40436 8581 13 reference reference NN 40436 8581 14 to to IN 40436 8581 15 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8581 16 , , , 40436 8581 17 or or CC 40436 8581 18 to to IN 40436 8581 19 good good NN 40436 8581 20 , , , 40436 8581 21 is be VBZ 40436 8581 22 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 8581 23 . . . 40436 8582 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8582 2 Sokr._--Of Sokr._--Of NNP 40436 8582 3 course course RB 40436 8582 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 8582 5 the the DT 40436 8582 6 ugly ugly JJ 40436 8582 7 or or CC 40436 8582 8 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8582 9 must must MD 40436 8582 10 be be VB 40436 8582 11 defined define VBN 40436 8582 12 by by IN 40436 8582 13 the the DT 40436 8582 14 contrary contrary NN 40436 8582 15 , , , 40436 8582 16 by by IN 40436 8582 17 reference reference NN 40436 8582 18 to to IN 40436 8582 19 pain pain NN 40436 8582 20 or or CC 40436 8582 21 to to IN 40436 8582 22 evil evil NN 40436 8582 23 ? ? . 40436 8583 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8583 2 Polus._--Doubtless Polus._--Doubtless NNP 40436 8583 3 . . . 40436 8584 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8584 2 31 31 CD 40436 8584 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8584 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8584 5 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 8584 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 8584 7 one one CD 40436 8584 8 thing thing NN 40436 8584 9 be be VB 40436 8584 10 finer fine JJR 40436 8584 11 or or CC 40436 8584 12 more more RBR 40436 8584 13 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8584 14 than than IN 40436 8584 15 another another DT 40436 8584 16 , , , 40436 8584 17 this this DT 40436 8584 18 is be VBZ 40436 8584 19 because because IN 40436 8584 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8584 21 surpasses surpass VBZ 40436 8584 22 the the DT 40436 8584 23 other other JJ 40436 8584 24 either either CC 40436 8584 25 in in IN 40436 8584 26 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8584 27 , , , 40436 8584 28 or or CC 40436 8584 29 in in IN 40436 8584 30 profit profit NN 40436 8584 31 : : : 40436 8584 32 if if IN 40436 8584 33 one one CD 40436 8584 34 thing thing NN 40436 8584 35 be be VBP 40436 8584 36 more more RBR 40436 8584 37 ugly ugly JJ 40436 8584 38 or or CC 40436 8584 39 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8584 40 than than IN 40436 8584 41 another another DT 40436 8584 42 , , , 40436 8584 43 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8584 44 must must MD 40436 8584 45 surpass surpass VB 40436 8584 46 that that IN 40436 8584 47 other other JJ 40436 8584 48 either either CC 40436 8584 49 in in IN 40436 8584 50 pain pain NN 40436 8584 51 , , , 40436 8584 52 or or CC 40436 8584 53 in in IN 40436 8584 54 evil evil NN 40436 8584 55 ? ? . 40436 8585 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8585 2 Polus._--Yes Polus._--Yes NNP 40436 8585 3 . . . 40436 8586 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8586 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8586 3 30 30 CD 40436 8586 4 : : : 40436 8586 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 8586 6 . . . 40436 8587 1 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 8587 2 . . . 40436 8588 1 p. p. NN 40436 8588 2 474 474 CD 40436 8588 3 D. D. NNP 40436 8588 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8588 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8588 6 : : : 40436 8588 7 e)a\n e)a\n -RRB- 40436 8588 8 e)n e)n NNP 40436 8588 9 tô=| tô=| RB 40436 8588 10 theôrei theôrei NN 40436 8588 11 = = SYM 40436 8588 12 sthai sthai NNP 40436 8588 13 chai chai NNP 40436 8588 14 / / SYM 40436 8588 15 rein rein NNP 40436 8588 16 poiê=| poiê=| NNP 40436 8588 17 tou\s tou\s JJ 40436 8588 18 theôrou theôrou NN 40436 8588 19 = = NFP 40436 8588 20 ntas ntas FW 40436 8588 21 ? ? . 40436 8588 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8588 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8589 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8589 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8589 3 31 31 CD 40436 8589 4 : : : 40436 8589 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8589 6 , , , 40436 8589 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8589 8 , , , 40436 8589 9 p. p. NN 40436 8589 10 474 474 CD 40436 8589 11 E. E. NNP 40436 8589 12 _ _ NNP 40436 8589 13 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 8589 14 . . . 40436 8589 15 _ _ NNP 40436 8589 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8589 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8589 18 : : : 40436 8589 19 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 8589 20 mê\n mê\n NNP 40436 8589 21 ta/ ta/ NN 40436 8589 22 ge ge NNP 40436 8589 23 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 8589 24 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8589 25 no no DT 40436 8589 26 / / SYM 40436 8589 27 mous mous JJ 40436 8589 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8589 29 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 8589 30 e)pitêdeu e)pitêdeu NNP 40436 8589 31 / / SYM 40436 8589 32 mata mata NNP 40436 8589 33 , , , 40436 8589 34 ou ou NNP 40436 8589 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8589 36 dê dê NNP 40436 8589 37 / / SYM 40436 8589 38 pou pou NNP 40436 8589 39 e)kto\s e)kto\s NNP 40436 8589 40 tou tou NNP 40436 8589 41 / / SYM 40436 8589 42 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8589 43 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 8589 44 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 8589 45 kala/ kala/ NNP 40436 8589 46 , , , 40436 8589 47 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8589 48 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 8589 49 _ _ NNP 40436 8589 50 ô)phe ô)phe NNP 40436 8589 51 / / SYM 40436 8589 52 lima lima NNP 40436 8589 53 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8589 54 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 8589 55 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 8589 56 / / SYM 40436 8589 57 a a NN 40436 8589 58 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 8589 59 _ _ NNP 40436 8589 60 a)mpho a)mpho NNP 40436 8589 61 / / SYM 40436 8589 62 tera tera NN 40436 8589 63 . . . 40436 8589 64 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8590 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8590 2 Pol Pol NNP 40436 8590 3 . . . 40436 8590 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8590 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8590 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8590 7 : : : 40436 8590 8 Ou)k ou)k XX 40436 8590 9 e)/moige e)/moige NNP 40436 8590 10 dokei=. dokei=. XX 40436 8590 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8591 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8591 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 8591 3 . . . 40436 8591 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8591 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8591 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8591 7 : : : 40436 8591 8 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 8591 9 = = SYM 40436 8591 10 n n CC 40436 8591 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8591 12 tô tô NNP 40436 8591 13 = = SYM 40436 8591 14 n n NNP 40436 8591 15 mathêma mathêma NNP 40436 8591 16 / / SYM 40436 8591 17 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8591 18 ka ka NNP 40436 8591 19 / / SYM 40436 8591 20 llos llos NNP 40436 8591 21 ô(sau ô(sau NNP 40436 8591 22 / / SYM 40436 8591 23 tôs tôs NN 40436 8591 24 ? ? . 40436 8591 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8592 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8592 2 Pol Pol NNP 40436 8592 3 . . . 40436 8592 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8592 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8592 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8592 7 : : : 40436 8592 8 Pa Pa NNP 40436 8592 9 / / SYM 40436 8592 10 nu nu NNP 40436 8592 11 ge ge NNP 40436 8592 12 ; ; : 40436 8592 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8592 14 kalô kalô NNP 40436 8592 15 = = SYM 40436 8592 16 s s NNP 40436 8592 17 ge ge NNP 40436 8592 18 nu nu NNP 40436 8592 19 = = SYM 40436 8592 20 n n NNP 40436 8592 21 o(rizei o(rizei NNP 40436 8592 22 , , , 40436 8592 23 _ _ NNP 40436 8592 24 ê(donê=| ê(donê=| CD 40436 8592 25 te te NNP 40436 8592 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8592 27 a)gathô=| a)gathô=| NNP 40436 8592 28 _ _ NNP 40436 8592 29 o(rizo o(rizo NNP 40436 8592 30 / / SYM 40436 8592 31 menos menos NNP 40436 8592 32 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8592 33 kalo kalo NNP 40436 8592 34 / / SYM 40436 8592 35 n n NNP 40436 8592 36 . . . 40436 8592 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8593 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8593 2 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 8593 3 . . . 40436 8593 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8593 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8593 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8593 7 : : : 40436 8593 8 Ou)kou ou)kou CD 40436 8593 9 = = SYM 40436 8593 10 n n CC 40436 8593 11 to\ to\ NN 40436 8593 12 ai)schro\n ai)schro\n NNP 40436 8593 13 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 8593 14 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 8593 15 / / SYM 40436 8593 16 ô| ô| NNP 40436 8593 17 , , , 40436 8593 18 _ _ NNP 40436 8593 19 lu lu NNP 40436 8593 20 / / SYM 40436 8593 21 pê| pê| NNP 40436 8593 22 te te NNP 40436 8593 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8593 24 kakô=| kakô=| NNP 40436 8593 25 _ _ NNP 40436 8593 26 ? ? . 40436 8593 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8594 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8594 2 Pol Pol NNP 40436 8594 3 . . . 40436 8594 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8594 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8594 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8594 7 : : : 40436 8594 8 A)na A)na NNP 40436 8594 9 / / SYM 40436 8594 10 gkê gkê NN 40436 8594 11 . . . 40436 8594 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8595 1 A a DT 40436 8595 2 little little JJ 40436 8595 3 farther far RBR 40436 8595 4 on on IN 40436 8595 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8595 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8595 7 : : : 40436 8595 8 blabê\ blabê\ NN 40436 8595 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8595 10 is be VBZ 40436 8595 11 used use VBN 40436 8595 12 as as IN 40436 8595 13 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 8595 14 to to IN 40436 8595 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8595 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8595 17 : : : 40436 8595 18 kako kako NNP 40436 8595 19 / / SYM 40436 8595 20 n n NNP 40436 8595 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8595 22 . . . 40436 8596 1 These these DT 40436 8596 2 words--[Greek words--[greek CD 40436 8596 3 : : : 40436 8596 4 kalo kalo NNP 40436 8596 5 / / SYM 40436 8596 6 n n CC 40436 8596 7 , , , 40436 8596 8 ai)schro ai)schro NNP 40436 8596 9 / / SYM 40436 8596 10 n]--(very n]--(very NN 40436 8596 11 difficult difficult JJ 40436 8596 12 to to TO 40436 8596 13 translate translate VB 40436 8596 14 properly properly RB 40436 8596 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8596 16 introduce introduce VB 40436 8596 17 a a DT 40436 8596 18 reference reference NN 40436 8596 19 to to IN 40436 8596 20 the the DT 40436 8596 21 feeling feeling NN 40436 8596 22 or or CC 40436 8596 23 judgment judgment NN 40436 8596 24 of of IN 40436 8596 25 spectators spectator NNS 40436 8596 26 , , , 40436 8596 27 or or CC 40436 8596 28 of of IN 40436 8596 29 an an DT 40436 8596 30 undefined undefined JJ 40436 8596 31 public public NN 40436 8596 32 , , , 40436 8596 33 not not RB 40436 8596 34 concerned concerned JJ 40436 8596 35 either either RB 40436 8596 36 as as IN 40436 8596 37 agents agent NNS 40436 8596 38 or or CC 40436 8596 39 sufferers sufferer NNS 40436 8596 40 . . . 40436 8596 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8597 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8597 2 Side side NN 40436 8597 3 - - HYPH 40436 8597 4 note note NN 40436 8597 5 : : : 40436 8597 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8597 7 offers offer VBZ 40436 8597 8 proof proof NN 40436 8597 9 -- -- : 40436 8597 10 Definition Definition NNP 40436 8597 11 of of IN 40436 8597 12 Pulchrum Pulchrum NNP 40436 8597 13 and and CC 40436 8597 14 Turpe Turpe NNP 40436 8597 15 -- -- : 40436 8597 16 Proof Proof NNP 40436 8597 17 of of IN 40436 8597 18 the the DT 40436 8597 19 first first JJ 40436 8597 20 point point NN 40436 8597 21 . . . 40436 8597 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8598 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8598 2 Sokr._--Well Sokr._--Well NNP 40436 8598 3 , , , 40436 8598 4 then then RB 40436 8598 5 ! ! . 40436 8599 1 what what WP 40436 8599 2 did do VBD 40436 8599 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8599 4 say say VB 40436 8599 5 about about IN 40436 8599 6 doing do VBG 40436 8599 7 wrong wrong NN 40436 8599 8 and and CC 40436 8599 9 suffering suffering NN 40436 8599 10 wrong wrong RB 40436 8599 11 ? ? . 40436 8600 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 8600 2 said say VBD 40436 8600 3 that that DT 40436 8600 4 to to TO 40436 8600 5 suffer suffer VB 40436 8600 6 wrong wrong NN 40436 8600 7 was be VBD 40436 8600 8 the the DT 40436 8600 9 worst bad JJS 40436 8600 10 of of IN 40436 8600 11 the the DT 40436 8600 12 two two CD 40436 8600 13 , , , 40436 8600 14 but but CC 40436 8600 15 to to TO 40436 8600 16 do do VB 40436 8600 17 wrong wrong NN 40436 8600 18 was be VBD 40436 8600 19 the the DT 40436 8600 20 most most RBS 40436 8600 21 ugly ugly JJ 40436 8600 22 or or CC 40436 8600 23 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8600 24 . . . 40436 8601 1 Now now RB 40436 8601 2 , , , 40436 8601 3 if if IN 40436 8601 4 to to TO 40436 8601 5 do do VB 40436 8601 6 wrong wrong NN 40436 8601 7 be be VB 40436 8601 8 more more RBR 40436 8601 9 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8601 10 than than IN 40436 8601 11 to to TO 40436 8601 12 suffer suffer VB 40436 8601 13 wrong wrong NN 40436 8601 14 , , , 40436 8601 15 this this DT 40436 8601 16 must must MD 40436 8601 17 be be VB 40436 8601 18 because because IN 40436 8601 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8601 20 has have VBZ 40436 8601 21 a a DT 40436 8601 22 preponderance preponderance NN 40436 8601 23 either either CC 40436 8601 24 of of IN 40436 8601 25 pain pain NN 40436 8601 26 or or CC 40436 8601 27 of of IN 40436 8601 28 evil evil NN 40436 8601 29 ? ? . 40436 8602 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8602 2 Polus._--Undoubtedly polus._--undoubtedly RB 40436 8602 3 . . . 40436 8603 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8603 2 Sokr._--Has Sokr._--Has NNP 40436 8603 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8603 4 a a DT 40436 8603 5 preponderance preponderance NN 40436 8603 6 of of IN 40436 8603 7 pain pain NN 40436 8603 8 ? ? . 40436 8604 1 Does do VBZ 40436 8604 2 the the DT 40436 8604 3 doer doer NN 40436 8604 4 of of IN 40436 8604 5 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8604 6 endure endure VBP 40436 8604 7 more more JJR 40436 8604 8 pain pain NN 40436 8604 9 than than IN 40436 8604 10 the the DT 40436 8604 11 sufferer sufferer NN 40436 8604 12 ? ? . 40436 8605 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8605 2 Polus._--Certainly polus._--certainly RB 40436 8605 3 not not RB 40436 8605 4 . . . 40436 8606 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8606 2 Sokr._--Then Sokr._--Then NNP 40436 8606 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8606 4 must must MD 40436 8606 5 have have VB 40436 8606 6 a a DT 40436 8606 7 preponderance preponderance NN 40436 8606 8 of of IN 40436 8606 9 evil evil NN 40436 8606 10 ? ? . 40436 8607 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8607 2 Polus._--Yes Polus._--Yes NNP 40436 8607 3 . . . 40436 8608 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8608 2 Sokr._--To Sokr._--To NNS 40436 8608 3 do do VBP 40436 8608 4 wrong wrong NN 40436 8608 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 8608 6 is be VBZ 40436 8608 7 worse bad JJR 40436 8608 8 than than IN 40436 8608 9 to to TO 40436 8608 10 suffer suffer VB 40436 8608 11 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8608 12 , , , 40436 8608 13 as as RB 40436 8608 14 well well RB 40436 8608 15 as as IN 40436 8608 16 more more RBR 40436 8608 17 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8608 18 ? ? . 40436 8609 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8609 2 Polus._--It Polus._--It NNP 40436 8609 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 8609 4 so so RB 40436 8609 5 . . . 40436 8610 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8610 2 Sokr._--Since Sokr._--Since NNP 40436 8610 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 8610 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8610 5 is be VBZ 40436 8610 6 both both CC 40436 8610 7 worse bad JJR 40436 8610 8 and and CC 40436 8610 9 more more RBR 40436 8610 10 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8610 11 , , , 40436 8610 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8610 13 was be VBD 40436 8610 14 right right JJ 40436 8610 15 in in IN 40436 8610 16 affirming affirm VBG 40436 8610 17 that that IN 40436 8610 18 neither neither CC 40436 8610 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8610 20 , , , 40436 8610 21 nor nor CC 40436 8610 22 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8610 23 , , , 40436 8610 24 nor nor CC 40436 8610 25 any any DT 40436 8610 26 one one NN 40436 8610 27 else else RB 40436 8610 28 , , , 40436 8610 29 would would MD 40436 8610 30 choose choose VB 40436 8610 31 to to TO 40436 8610 32 do do VB 40436 8610 33 wrong wrong NN 40436 8610 34 in in IN 40436 8610 35 preference preference NN 40436 8610 36 to to IN 40436 8610 37 suffering suffer VBG 40436 8610 38 wrong wrong RB 40436 8610 39 . . . 40436 8611 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8611 2 Polus._--So polus._--so NN 40436 8611 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8611 4 seems seem VBZ 40436 8611 5 . . . 40436 8612 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8612 2 32 32 CD 40436 8612 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8612 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8612 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8612 6 32 32 CD 40436 8612 7 : : : 40436 8612 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8612 9 , , , 40436 8612 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8612 11 , , , 40436 8612 12 p. p. NN 40436 8612 13 475 475 CD 40436 8612 14 C C NNP 40436 8612 15 - - HYPH 40436 8612 16 D. D. NNP 40436 8612 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8612 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8612 19 Side side NN 40436 8612 20 - - HYPH 40436 8612 21 note note NN 40436 8612 22 : : : 40436 8612 23 Proof proof NN 40436 8612 24 of of IN 40436 8612 25 the the DT 40436 8612 26 second second JJ 40436 8612 27 point point NN 40436 8612 28 . . . 40436 8612 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8613 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8613 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 8613 3 let let VB 40436 8613 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8613 5 take take VB 40436 8613 6 the the DT 40436 8613 7 second second JJ 40436 8613 8 point point NN 40436 8613 9 -- -- : 40436 8613 10 Whether whether IN 40436 8613 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8613 12 be be VB 40436 8613 13 the the DT 40436 8613 14 greatest great JJS 40436 8613 15 evil evil NN 40436 8613 16 for for IN 40436 8613 17 the the DT 40436 8613 18 wrong wrong NN 40436 8613 19 - - HYPH 40436 8613 20 doer doer NN 40436 8613 21 to to TO 40436 8613 22 be be VB 40436 8613 23 punished punish VBN 40436 8613 24 , , , 40436 8613 25 or or CC 40436 8613 26 whether whether IN 40436 8613 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8613 28 be be VB 40436 8613 29 not not RB 40436 8613 30 a a DT 40436 8613 31 still still RB 40436 8613 32 greater great JJR 40436 8613 33 evil evil NN 40436 8613 34 for for IN 40436 8613 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8613 36 to to TO 40436 8613 37 remain remain VB 40436 8613 38 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 8613 39 . . . 40436 8614 1 If if IN 40436 8614 2 punished punish VBN 40436 8614 3 , , , 40436 8614 4 the the DT 40436 8614 5 wrong wrong NN 40436 8614 6 - - HYPH 40436 8614 7 doer doer NN 40436 8614 8 is be VBZ 40436 8614 9 of of IN 40436 8614 10 course course NN 40436 8614 11 punished punish VBN 40436 8614 12 justly justly RB 40436 8614 13 ; ; : 40436 8614 14 and and CC 40436 8614 15 are be VBP 40436 8614 16 not not RB 40436 8614 17 all all DT 40436 8614 18 just just RB 40436 8614 19 things thing NNS 40436 8614 20 fine fine JJ 40436 8614 21 or or CC 40436 8614 22 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8614 23 , , , 40436 8614 24 in in IN 40436 8614 25 so so RB 40436 8614 26 far far RB 40436 8614 27 as as IN 40436 8614 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8614 29 are be VBP 40436 8614 30 just just RB 40436 8614 31 ? ? . 40436 8615 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8615 2 Polus._--I Polus._--I NNP 40436 8615 3 think think VBP 40436 8615 4 so so RB 40436 8615 5 . . . 40436 8616 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8616 2 Sokr._--When Sokr._--When NNP 40436 8616 3 a a DT 40436 8616 4 man man NN 40436 8616 5 does do VBZ 40436 8616 6 anything anything NN 40436 8616 7 , , , 40436 8616 8 must must MD 40436 8616 9 there there EX 40436 8616 10 not not RB 40436 8616 11 be be VB 40436 8616 12 some some DT 40436 8616 13 correlate correlate JJ 40436 8616 14 which which WDT 40436 8616 15 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8616 16 ; ; : 40436 8616 17 and and CC 40436 8616 18 must must MD 40436 8616 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8616 20 not not RB 40436 8616 21 suffer suffer VB 40436 8616 22 in in IN 40436 8616 23 a a DT 40436 8616 24 way way NN 40436 8616 25 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 8616 26 to to IN 40436 8616 27 what what WP 40436 8616 28 the the DT 40436 8616 29 doer doer NNP 40436 8616 30 does do VBZ 40436 8616 31 ? ? . 40436 8617 1 Thus thus RB 40436 8617 2 if if IN 40436 8617 3 any any DT 40436 8617 4 one one CD 40436 8617 5 strikes strike NNS 40436 8617 6 , , , 40436 8617 7 there there EX 40436 8617 8 must must MD 40436 8617 9 also also RB 40436 8617 10 be be VB 40436 8617 11 something something NN 40436 8617 12 stricken stricken VBN 40436 8617 13 : : : 40436 8617 14 and and CC 40436 8617 15 if if IN 40436 8617 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8617 17 strikes strike VBZ 40436 8617 18 quickly quickly RB 40436 8617 19 or or CC 40436 8617 20 violently violently RB 40436 8617 21 , , , 40436 8617 22 there there EX 40436 8617 23 must must MD 40436 8617 24 be be VB 40436 8617 25 something something NN 40436 8617 26 which which WDT 40436 8617 27 is be VBZ 40436 8617 28 stricken stricken VBN 40436 8617 29 quickly quickly RB 40436 8617 30 or or CC 40436 8617 31 violently violently RB 40436 8617 32 . . . 40436 8618 1 And and CC 40436 8618 2 so so RB 40436 8618 3 , , , 40436 8618 4 if if IN 40436 8618 5 any any DT 40436 8618 6 one one CD 40436 8618 7 burns burn NNS 40436 8618 8 or or CC 40436 8618 9 cuts cut NNS 40436 8618 10 , , , 40436 8618 11 there there EX 40436 8618 12 must must MD 40436 8618 13 be be VB 40436 8618 14 something something NN 40436 8618 15 burnt burn VBN 40436 8618 16 or or CC 40436 8618 17 cut cut VBN 40436 8618 18 . . . 40436 8619 1 As as IN 40436 8619 2 the the DT 40436 8619 3 agent agent NN 40436 8619 4 acts act VBZ 40436 8619 5 , , , 40436 8619 6 so so CC 40436 8619 7 the the DT 40436 8619 8 patient patient NN 40436 8619 9 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8619 10 . . . 40436 8620 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8620 2 Polus._--Yes Polus._--Yes NNP 40436 8620 3 . . . 40436 8621 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8621 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 8621 3 if if IN 40436 8621 4 a a DT 40436 8621 5 man man NN 40436 8621 6 be be VB 40436 8621 7 punished punish VBN 40436 8621 8 for for IN 40436 8621 9 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8621 10 doing doing NN 40436 8621 11 , , , 40436 8621 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8621 13 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8621 14 what what WP 40436 8621 15 is be VBZ 40436 8621 16 just just RB 40436 8621 17 , , , 40436 8621 18 and and CC 40436 8621 19 the the DT 40436 8621 20 punisher punisher NN 40436 8621 21 does do VBZ 40436 8621 22 what what WP 40436 8621 23 is be VBZ 40436 8621 24 just just RB 40436 8621 25 ? ? . 40436 8622 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8622 2 Polus._--He polus._--he NN 40436 8622 3 does do VBZ 40436 8622 4 . . . 40436 8623 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8623 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 8623 3 admitted admit VBD 40436 8623 4 that that IN 40436 8623 5 all all DT 40436 8623 6 just just RB 40436 8623 7 things thing NNS 40436 8623 8 were be VBD 40436 8623 9 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8623 10 : : : 40436 8623 11 therefore therefore RB 40436 8623 12 the the DT 40436 8623 13 agent agent NN 40436 8623 14 does do VBZ 40436 8623 15 what what WP 40436 8623 16 is be VBZ 40436 8623 17 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8623 18 , , , 40436 8623 19 the the DT 40436 8623 20 patient patient NN 40436 8623 21 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8623 22 what what WP 40436 8623 23 is be VBZ 40436 8623 24 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8623 25 . . . 40436 8624 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8624 2 33 33 CD 40436 8624 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8624 4 But but CC 40436 8624 5 if if IN 40436 8624 6 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8624 7 , , , 40436 8624 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8624 9 must must MD 40436 8624 10 be be VB 40436 8624 11 either either CC 40436 8624 12 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8624 13 -- -- : 40436 8624 14 or or CC 40436 8624 15 good good JJ 40436 8624 16 and and CC 40436 8624 17 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8624 18 . . . 40436 8625 1 In in IN 40436 8625 2 this this DT 40436 8625 3 case case NN 40436 8625 4 , , , 40436 8625 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8625 6 is be VBZ 40436 8625 7 certainly certainly RB 40436 8625 8 not not RB 40436 8625 9 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8625 10 : : : 40436 8625 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8625 12 must must MD 40436 8625 13 therefore therefore RB 40436 8625 14 be be VB 40436 8625 15 good good JJ 40436 8625 16 and and CC 40436 8625 17 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8625 18 . . . 40436 8626 1 The the DT 40436 8626 2 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8626 3 - - HYPH 40436 8626 4 doer doer NN 40436 8626 5 therefore therefore RB 40436 8626 6 , , , 40436 8626 7 when when WRB 40436 8626 8 punished punish VBN 40436 8626 9 , , , 40436 8626 10 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8626 11 what what WP 40436 8626 12 is be VBZ 40436 8626 13 good good JJ 40436 8626 14 and and CC 40436 8626 15 is be VBZ 40436 8626 16 profited profit VBN 40436 8626 17 . . . 40436 8627 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8627 2 Polus._--Yes Polus._--Yes NNP 40436 8627 3 . . . 40436 8628 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8628 2 34 34 CD 40436 8628 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8628 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8628 5 Sokr._--In Sokr._--In NNP 40436 8628 6 what what WP 40436 8628 7 manner manner NN 40436 8628 8 is be VBZ 40436 8628 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8628 10 profited profit VBN 40436 8628 11 ? ? . 40436 8629 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8629 2 is be VBZ 40436 8629 3 , , , 40436 8629 4 as as IN 40436 8629 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8629 6 presume presume VBP 40436 8629 7 , , , 40436 8629 8 by by IN 40436 8629 9 becoming become VBG 40436 8629 10 better well RBR 40436 8629 11 in in IN 40436 8629 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8629 13 mind mind NN 40436 8629 14 -- -- : 40436 8629 15 by by IN 40436 8629 16 being be VBG 40436 8629 17 relieved relieve VBN 40436 8629 18 from from IN 40436 8629 19 badness badness NN 40436 8629 20 of of IN 40436 8629 21 mind mind NN 40436 8629 22 . . . 40436 8630 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8630 2 Polus._--Probably polus._--probably RB 40436 8630 3 . . . 40436 8631 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8631 2 Sokr._--Is Sokr._--Is NNP 40436 8631 3 not not RB 40436 8631 4 this this DT 40436 8631 5 badness badness NN 40436 8631 6 of of IN 40436 8631 7 mind mind NN 40436 8631 8 the the DT 40436 8631 9 greatest great JJS 40436 8631 10 evil evil NN 40436 8631 11 ? ? . 40436 8632 1 In in IN 40436 8632 2 regard regard NN 40436 8632 3 to to IN 40436 8632 4 wealth wealth NN 40436 8632 5 , , , 40436 8632 6 the the DT 40436 8632 7 special special JJ 40436 8632 8 badness badness NN 40436 8632 9 is be VBZ 40436 8632 10 poverty poverty NN 40436 8632 11 : : : 40436 8632 12 in in IN 40436 8632 13 regard regard NN 40436 8632 14 to to IN 40436 8632 15 the the DT 40436 8632 16 body body NN 40436 8632 17 , , , 40436 8632 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8632 19 is be VBZ 40436 8632 20 weakness weakness NN 40436 8632 21 , , , 40436 8632 22 sickness sickness NN 40436 8632 23 , , , 40436 8632 24 deformity deformity NN 40436 8632 25 , , , 40436 8632 26 & & CC 40436 8632 27 c. c. NNP 40436 8632 28 : : : 40436 8632 29 in in IN 40436 8632 30 regard regard NN 40436 8632 31 to to IN 40436 8632 32 the the DT 40436 8632 33 mind mind NN 40436 8632 34 , , , 40436 8632 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8632 36 is be VBZ 40436 8632 37 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 8632 38 , , , 40436 8632 39 injustice injustice NN 40436 8632 40 , , , 40436 8632 41 cowardice cowardice NN 40436 8632 42 , , , 40436 8632 43 & & CC 40436 8632 44 c. c. NNP 40436 8632 45 Is be VBZ 40436 8632 46 not not RB 40436 8632 47 injustice injustice JJ 40436 8632 48 , , , 40436 8632 49 and and CC 40436 8632 50 other other JJ 40436 8632 51 badness badness NN 40436 8632 52 of of IN 40436 8632 53 mind mind NN 40436 8632 54 , , , 40436 8632 55 the the DT 40436 8632 56 most most RBS 40436 8632 57 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8632 58 of of IN 40436 8632 59 the the DT 40436 8632 60 three three CD 40436 8632 61 ? ? . 40436 8633 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8633 2 Polus._--Decidedly polus._--decidedly RB 40436 8633 3 . . . 40436 8634 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8634 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 8634 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8634 4 be be VB 40436 8634 5 most most RBS 40436 8634 6 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8634 7 , , , 40436 8634 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8634 9 must must MD 40436 8634 10 therefore therefore RB 40436 8634 11 be be VB 40436 8634 12 the the DT 40436 8634 13 worst bad JJS 40436 8634 14 . . . 40436 8635 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8635 2 Polus._--How Polus._--How NNP 40436 8635 3 ? ? . 40436 8636 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8636 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 8636 3 must must MD 40436 8636 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8636 5 as as IN 40436 8636 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8636 7 before before IN 40436 8636 8 agreed agree VBD 40436 8636 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8636 10 have have VB 40436 8636 11 the the DT 40436 8636 12 greatest great JJS 40436 8636 13 preponderance preponderance NN 40436 8636 14 either either CC 40436 8636 15 of of IN 40436 8636 16 pain pain NN 40436 8636 17 , , , 40436 8636 18 or or CC 40436 8636 19 of of IN 40436 8636 20 hurt hurt NN 40436 8636 21 and and CC 40436 8636 22 evil evil NN 40436 8636 23 . . . 40436 8637 1 But but CC 40436 8637 2 the the DT 40436 8637 3 preponderance preponderance NN 40436 8637 4 is be VBZ 40436 8637 5 not not RB 40436 8637 6 in in IN 40436 8637 7 pain pain NN 40436 8637 8 : : : 40436 8637 9 for for IN 40436 8637 10 no no DT 40436 8637 11 one one NN 40436 8637 12 will will MD 40436 8637 13 say say VB 40436 8637 14 that that IN 40436 8637 15 the the DT 40436 8637 16 being be VBG 40436 8637 17 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8637 18 and and CC 40436 8637 19 intemperate intemperate VB 40436 8637 20 and and CC 40436 8637 21 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 8637 22 , , , 40436 8637 23 is be VBZ 40436 8637 24 more more RBR 40436 8637 25 painful painful JJ 40436 8637 26 than than IN 40436 8637 27 being be VBG 40436 8637 28 poor poor JJ 40436 8637 29 and and CC 40436 8637 30 sick sick JJ 40436 8637 31 . . . 40436 8638 1 The the DT 40436 8638 2 preponderance preponderance NN 40436 8638 3 must must MD 40436 8638 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 8638 5 be be VB 40436 8638 6 great great JJ 40436 8638 7 in in IN 40436 8638 8 hurt hurt NN 40436 8638 9 and and CC 40436 8638 10 evil evil NN 40436 8638 11 . . . 40436 8639 1 Mental mental JJ 40436 8639 2 badness badness NN 40436 8639 3 is be VBZ 40436 8639 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 8639 5 a a DT 40436 8639 6 greater great JJR 40436 8639 7 evil evil NN 40436 8639 8 than than IN 40436 8639 9 either either DT 40436 8639 10 poverty poverty NN 40436 8639 11 , , , 40436 8639 12 or or CC 40436 8639 13 disease disease NN 40436 8639 14 and and CC 40436 8639 15 bodily bodily NNP 40436 8639 16 deformity deformity NN 40436 8639 17 . . . 40436 8640 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8640 2 is be VBZ 40436 8640 3 the the DT 40436 8640 4 greatest great JJS 40436 8640 5 of of IN 40436 8640 6 human human JJ 40436 8640 7 evils evil NNS 40436 8640 8 . . . 40436 8641 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8641 2 Polus._--It Polus._--It NNP 40436 8641 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 8641 4 so so RB 40436 8641 5 . . . 40436 8642 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8642 2 35 35 CD 40436 8642 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8642 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8642 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8642 6 33 33 CD 40436 8642 7 : : : 40436 8642 8 See see VB 40436 8642 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8642 10 , , , 40436 8642 11 Rhet Rhet NNP 40436 8642 12 . . . 40436 8643 1 i. i. NNP 40436 8644 1 9 9 CD 40436 8644 2 , , , 40436 8644 3 p. p. NN 40436 8644 4 1366 1366 CD 40436 8644 5 , , , 40436 8644 6 b. b. NNP 40436 8645 1 30 30 CD 40436 8645 2 , , , 40436 8645 3 where where WRB 40436 8645 4 the the DT 40436 8645 5 contrary contrary NN 40436 8645 6 of of IN 40436 8645 7 this this DT 40436 8645 8 opinion opinion NN 40436 8645 9 is be VBZ 40436 8645 10 maintained maintain VBN 40436 8645 11 , , , 40436 8645 12 and and CC 40436 8645 13 maintained maintain VBN 40436 8645 14 with with IN 40436 8645 15 truth truth NN 40436 8645 16 . . . 40436 8645 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8646 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8646 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8646 3 34 34 CD 40436 8646 4 : : : 40436 8646 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8646 6 , , , 40436 8646 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8646 8 , , , 40436 8646 9 p. p. NN 40436 8646 10 476 476 CD 40436 8646 11 D D NNP 40436 8646 12 - - HYPH 40436 8646 13 E. e. NN 40436 8646 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8646 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8646 16 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8646 17 35 35 CD 40436 8646 18 : : : 40436 8646 19 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8646 20 , , , 40436 8646 21 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8646 22 , , , 40436 8646 23 p. p. NN 40436 8646 24 477 477 CD 40436 8646 25 E. E. NNP 40436 8646 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8646 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8646 28 Side side NN 40436 8646 29 - - HYPH 40436 8646 30 note note NN 40436 8646 31 : : : 40436 8646 32 The the DT 40436 8646 33 criminal criminal JJ 40436 8646 34 labours labour VBZ 40436 8646 35 under under IN 40436 8646 36 a a DT 40436 8646 37 mental mental JJ 40436 8646 38 distemper distemper NN 40436 8646 39 , , , 40436 8646 40 which which WDT 40436 8646 41 though though IN 40436 8646 42 not not RB 40436 8646 43 painful painful JJ 40436 8646 44 , , , 40436 8646 45 is be VBZ 40436 8646 46 a a DT 40436 8646 47 capital capital NN 40436 8646 48 evil evil NN 40436 8646 49 . . . 40436 8647 1 Punishment punishment NN 40436 8647 2 is be VBZ 40436 8647 3 the the DT 40436 8647 4 only only JJ 40436 8647 5 cure cure NN 40436 8647 6 for for IN 40436 8647 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8647 8 . . . 40436 8648 1 To to TO 40436 8648 2 be be VB 40436 8648 3 punished punish VBN 40436 8648 4 is be VBZ 40436 8648 5 best good JJS 40436 8648 6 for for IN 40436 8648 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8648 8 . . . 40436 8648 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8649 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8649 2 Sokr._--The Sokr._--The NNP 40436 8649 3 money money NN 40436 8649 4 - - HYPH 40436 8649 5 making make VBG 40436 8649 6 art art NN 40436 8649 7 is be VBZ 40436 8649 8 , , , 40436 8649 9 that that WDT 40436 8649 10 which which WDT 40436 8649 11 relieves relieve VBZ 40436 8649 12 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8649 13 from from IN 40436 8649 14 poverty poverty NN 40436 8649 15 : : : 40436 8649 16 the the DT 40436 8649 17 medical medical JJ 40436 8649 18 art art NN 40436 8649 19 , , , 40436 8649 20 from from IN 40436 8649 21 sickness sickness NN 40436 8649 22 and and CC 40436 8649 23 weakness weakness NN 40436 8649 24 : : : 40436 8649 25 the the DT 40436 8649 26 judicial judicial JJ 40436 8649 27 or or CC 40436 8649 28 punitory punitory NN 40436 8649 29 , , , 40436 8649 30 from from IN 40436 8649 31 injustice injustice NN 40436 8649 32 and and CC 40436 8649 33 wickedness wickedness NN 40436 8649 34 of of IN 40436 8649 35 mind mind NN 40436 8649 36 . . . 40436 8650 1 Of of IN 40436 8650 2 these these DT 40436 8650 3 three three CD 40436 8650 4 relieving relieve VBG 40436 8650 5 forces force NNS 40436 8650 6 , , , 40436 8650 7 which which WDT 40436 8650 8 is be VBZ 40436 8650 9 the the DT 40436 8650 10 most most RBS 40436 8650 11 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8650 12 ? ? . 40436 8651 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8651 2 Polus._--The Polus._--The NNP 40436 8651 3 last last JJ 40436 8651 4 , , , 40436 8651 5 by by IN 40436 8651 6 far far RB 40436 8651 7 . . . 40436 8652 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8652 2 Sokr._--If Sokr._--If NNP 40436 8652 3 most most RBS 40436 8652 4 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8652 5 , , , 40436 8652 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8652 7 confers confer VBZ 40436 8652 8 either either CC 40436 8652 9 most most JJS 40436 8652 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8652 11 or or CC 40436 8652 12 most most JJS 40436 8652 13 profit profit NN 40436 8652 14 ? ? . 40436 8653 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8653 2 Polus._--Yes Polus._--Yes NNP 40436 8653 3 . . . 40436 8654 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8654 2 Sokr._--Now Sokr._--Now NNP 40436 8654 3 , , , 40436 8654 4 to to TO 40436 8654 5 go go VB 40436 8654 6 through through IN 40436 8654 7 medical medical JJ 40436 8654 8 treatment treatment NN 40436 8654 9 is be VBZ 40436 8654 10 not not RB 40436 8654 11 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8654 12 ; ; : 40436 8654 13 but but CC 40436 8654 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8654 15 answers answer VBZ 40436 8654 16 to to IN 40436 8654 17 a a DT 40436 8654 18 man man NN 40436 8654 19 to to TO 40436 8654 20 undergo undergo VB 40436 8654 21 the the DT 40436 8654 22 pain pain NN 40436 8654 23 , , , 40436 8654 24 in in IN 40436 8654 25 order order NN 40436 8654 26 to to TO 40436 8654 27 get get VB 40436 8654 28 rid rid VBN 40436 8654 29 of of IN 40436 8654 30 a a DT 40436 8654 31 great great JJ 40436 8654 32 evil evil NN 40436 8654 33 , , , 40436 8654 34 and and CC 40436 8654 35 to to TO 40436 8654 36 become become VB 40436 8654 37 well well RB 40436 8654 38 . . . 40436 8655 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8655 2 would would MD 40436 8655 3 be be VB 40436 8655 4 a a DT 40436 8655 5 happier happy JJR 40436 8655 6 man man NN 40436 8655 7 , , , 40436 8655 8 if if IN 40436 8655 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8655 10 were be VBD 40436 8655 11 never never RB 40436 8655 12 sick sick JJ 40436 8655 13 : : : 40436 8655 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8655 15 is be VBZ 40436 8655 16 less less RBR 40436 8655 17 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8655 18 by by IN 40436 8655 19 undergoing undergo VBG 40436 8655 20 the the DT 40436 8655 21 painful painful JJ 40436 8655 22 treatment treatment NN 40436 8655 23 and and CC 40436 8655 24 becoming become VBG 40436 8655 25 well well RB 40436 8655 26 , , , 40436 8655 27 than than IN 40436 8655 28 if if IN 40436 8655 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8655 30 underwent undergo VBD 40436 8655 31 no no DT 40436 8655 32 treatment treatment NN 40436 8655 33 and and CC 40436 8655 34 remained remain VBD 40436 8655 35 sick sick JJ 40436 8655 36 . . . 40436 8656 1 Just just RB 40436 8656 2 so so RB 40436 8656 3 the the DT 40436 8656 4 man man NN 40436 8656 5 who who WP 40436 8656 6 is be VBZ 40436 8656 7 mentally mentally RB 40436 8656 8 bad bad JJ 40436 8656 9 : : : 40436 8656 10 the the DT 40436 8656 11 happiest happy JJS 40436 8656 12 man man NN 40436 8656 13 is be VBZ 40436 8656 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8656 15 who who WP 40436 8656 16 never never RB 40436 8656 17 becomes become VBZ 40436 8656 18 so so RB 40436 8656 19 ; ; : 40436 8656 20 but but CC 40436 8656 21 if if IN 40436 8656 22 a a DT 40436 8656 23 man man NN 40436 8656 24 has have VBZ 40436 8656 25 become become VBN 40436 8656 26 so so RB 40436 8656 27 , , , 40436 8656 28 the the DT 40436 8656 29 next next JJ 40436 8656 30 best good JJS 40436 8656 31 course course NN 40436 8656 32 for for IN 40436 8656 33 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8656 34 is be VBZ 40436 8656 35 , , , 40436 8656 36 to to TO 40436 8656 37 undergo undergo VB 40436 8656 38 punishment punishment NN 40436 8656 39 and and CC 40436 8656 40 to to TO 40436 8656 41 get get VB 40436 8656 42 rid rid VBN 40436 8656 43 of of IN 40436 8656 44 the the DT 40436 8656 45 evil evil NN 40436 8656 46 . . . 40436 8657 1 The the DT 40436 8657 2 worst bad JJS 40436 8657 3 lot lot NN 40436 8657 4 of of IN 40436 8657 5 all all DT 40436 8657 6 is be VBZ 40436 8657 7 , , , 40436 8657 8 that that DT 40436 8657 9 of of IN 40436 8657 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8657 11 who who WP 40436 8657 12 remains remain VBZ 40436 8657 13 mentally mentally RB 40436 8657 14 bad bad JJ 40436 8657 15 , , , 40436 8657 16 without without IN 40436 8657 17 ever ever RB 40436 8657 18 getting get VBG 40436 8657 19 rid rid VBN 40436 8657 20 of of IN 40436 8657 21 badness badness NN 40436 8657 22 . . . 40436 8658 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8658 2 36 36 CD 40436 8658 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8658 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8658 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8658 6 36 36 CD 40436 8658 7 : : : 40436 8658 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8658 9 , , , 40436 8658 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8658 11 , , , 40436 8658 12 p. p. NN 40436 8658 13 478 478 CD 40436 8658 14 D D NNP 40436 8658 15 - - HYPH 40436 8658 16 E. e. NN 40436 8658 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8658 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8658 19 Side side NN 40436 8658 20 - - HYPH 40436 8658 21 note note NN 40436 8658 22 : : : 40436 8658 23 Misery misery NN 40436 8658 24 of of IN 40436 8658 25 the the DT 40436 8658 26 Despot Despot NNP 40436 8658 27 who who WP 40436 8658 28 is be VBZ 40436 8658 29 never never RB 40436 8658 30 punished punish VBN 40436 8658 31 . . . 40436 8659 1 If if IN 40436 8659 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8659 3 friend friend NN 40436 8659 4 has have VBZ 40436 8659 5 done do VBN 40436 8659 6 wrong wrong NN 40436 8659 7 , , , 40436 8659 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8659 9 ought ought MD 40436 8659 10 to to TO 40436 8659 11 get get VB 40436 8659 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8659 13 punished punish VBN 40436 8659 14 : : : 40436 8659 15 if if IN 40436 8659 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8659 17 enemy enemy NN 40436 8659 18 , , , 40436 8659 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8659 20 ought ought MD 40436 8659 21 to to TO 40436 8659 22 keep keep VB 40436 8659 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8659 24 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 8659 25 . . . 40436 8659 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8660 1 This this DT 40436 8660 2 last last JJ 40436 8660 3 , , , 40436 8660 4 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8660 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8660 6 continues continue VBZ 40436 8660 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8660 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8660 9 , , , 40436 8660 10 is be VBZ 40436 8660 11 the the DT 40436 8660 12 condition condition NN 40436 8660 13 of of IN 40436 8660 14 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8660 15 , , , 40436 8660 16 and and CC 40436 8660 17 of of IN 40436 8660 18 despots despot NNS 40436 8660 19 and and CC 40436 8660 20 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 8660 21 generally generally RB 40436 8660 22 . . . 40436 8661 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 8661 2 possess possess VBP 40436 8661 3 power power NN 40436 8661 4 which which WDT 40436 8661 5 enables enable VBZ 40436 8661 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8661 7 , , , 40436 8661 8 after after IN 40436 8661 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8661 10 have have VBP 40436 8661 11 committed commit VBN 40436 8661 12 injustice injustice NN 40436 8661 13 , , , 40436 8661 14 to to TO 40436 8661 15 guard guard VB 40436 8661 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8661 17 against against IN 40436 8661 18 being be VBG 40436 8661 19 punished punish VBN 40436 8661 20 : : : 40436 8661 21 which which WDT 40436 8661 22 is be VBZ 40436 8661 23 just just RB 40436 8661 24 as as IN 40436 8661 25 if if IN 40436 8661 26 a a DT 40436 8661 27 sick sick JJ 40436 8661 28 man man NN 40436 8661 29 were be VBD 40436 8661 30 to to TO 40436 8661 31 pride pride VB 40436 8661 32 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8661 33 upon upon IN 40436 8661 34 having have VBG 40436 8661 35 taken take VBN 40436 8661 36 precautions precaution NNS 40436 8661 37 against against IN 40436 8661 38 being be VBG 40436 8661 39 cured cure VBN 40436 8661 40 . . . 40436 8662 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 8662 2 see see VBP 40436 8662 3 the the DT 40436 8662 4 pain pain NN 40436 8662 5 of of IN 40436 8662 6 the the DT 40436 8662 7 cure cure NN 40436 8662 8 , , , 40436 8662 9 but but CC 40436 8662 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8662 11 are be VBP 40436 8662 12 blind blind JJ 40436 8662 13 to to IN 40436 8662 14 the the DT 40436 8662 15 profit profit NN 40436 8662 16 of of IN 40436 8662 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8662 18 ; ; : 40436 8662 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8662 20 are be VBP 40436 8662 21 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 8662 22 how how WRB 40436 8662 23 much much RB 40436 8662 24 more more RBR 40436 8662 25 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8662 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8662 27 is be VBZ 40436 8662 28 to to TO 40436 8662 29 have have VB 40436 8662 30 an an DT 40436 8662 31 unhealthy unhealthy JJ 40436 8662 32 and and CC 40436 8662 33 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8662 34 mind mind NN 40436 8662 35 than than IN 40436 8662 36 an an DT 40436 8662 37 unhealthy unhealthy JJ 40436 8662 38 body body NN 40436 8662 39 . . . 40436 8663 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8663 2 37 37 CD 40436 8663 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8663 4 There there EX 40436 8663 5 is be VBZ 40436 8663 6 therefore therefore RB 40436 8663 7 little little JJ 40436 8663 8 use use NN 40436 8663 9 in in IN 40436 8663 10 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8663 11 : : : 40436 8663 12 for for IN 40436 8663 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8663 14 first first JJ 40436 8663 15 object object NN 40436 8663 16 ought ought MD 40436 8663 17 to to TO 40436 8663 18 be be VB 40436 8663 19 , , , 40436 8663 20 to to TO 40436 8663 21 avoid avoid VB 40436 8663 22 doing do VBG 40436 8663 23 wrong wrong NN 40436 8663 24 : : : 40436 8663 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8663 26 next next JJ 40436 8663 27 object object NN 40436 8663 28 , , , 40436 8663 29 if if IN 40436 8663 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8663 31 have have VBP 40436 8663 32 done do VBN 40436 8663 33 wrong wrong NN 40436 8663 34 , , , 40436 8663 35 not not RB 40436 8663 36 to to TO 40436 8663 37 resist resist VB 40436 8663 38 or or CC 40436 8663 39 elude elude VB 40436 8663 40 punishment punishment NN 40436 8663 41 by by IN 40436 8663 42 skilful skilful JJ 40436 8663 43 defence defence NN 40436 8663 44 , , , 40436 8663 45 but but CC 40436 8663 46 to to TO 40436 8663 47 present present VB 40436 8663 48 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8663 49 voluntarily voluntarily RB 40436 8663 50 and and CC 40436 8663 51 invite invite VB 40436 8663 52 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8663 53 : : : 40436 8663 54 and and CC 40436 8663 55 if if IN 40436 8663 56 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8663 57 friends friend NNS 40436 8663 58 or or CC 40436 8663 59 relatives relative NNS 40436 8663 60 have have VBP 40436 8663 61 done do VBN 40436 8663 62 wrong wrong NN 40436 8663 63 , , , 40436 8663 64 far far RB 40436 8663 65 from from IN 40436 8663 66 helping help VBG 40436 8663 67 to to TO 40436 8663 68 defend defend VB 40436 8663 69 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8663 70 , , , 40436 8663 71 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8663 72 ought ought MD 40436 8663 73 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8663 74 to to TO 40436 8663 75 accuse accuse VB 40436 8663 76 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8663 77 , , , 40436 8663 78 and and CC 40436 8663 79 to to TO 40436 8663 80 invoke invoke VB 40436 8663 81 punishment punishment NN 40436 8663 82 upon upon IN 40436 8663 83 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8663 84 also also RB 40436 8663 85 . . . 40436 8664 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8664 2 38 38 CD 40436 8664 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8664 4 On on IN 40436 8664 5 the the DT 40436 8664 6 other other JJ 40436 8664 7 hand hand NN 40436 8664 8 , , , 40436 8664 9 as as IN 40436 8664 10 to to IN 40436 8664 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8664 12 enemy enemy NN 40436 8664 13 , , , 40436 8664 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 15 ought ought MD 40436 8664 16 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 8664 17 to to TO 40436 8664 18 take take VB 40436 8664 19 precautions precaution NNS 40436 8664 20 against against IN 40436 8664 21 suffering suffer VBG 40436 8664 22 any any DT 40436 8664 23 wrong wrong NN 40436 8664 24 from from IN 40436 8664 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 26 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 27 : : : 40436 8664 28 but but CC 40436 8664 29 if if IN 40436 8664 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 31 has have VBZ 40436 8664 32 done do VBN 40436 8664 33 wrong wrong NN 40436 8664 34 to to IN 40436 8664 35 others other NNS 40436 8664 36 , , , 40436 8664 37 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 38 ought ought MD 40436 8664 39 to to TO 40436 8664 40 do do VB 40436 8664 41 all all DT 40436 8664 42 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 43 can can MD 40436 8664 44 , , , 40436 8664 45 by by IN 40436 8664 46 word word NN 40436 8664 47 or or CC 40436 8664 48 deed deed NN 40436 8664 49 , , , 40436 8664 50 not not RB 40436 8664 51 to to TO 40436 8664 52 bring bring VB 40436 8664 53 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 54 to to IN 40436 8664 55 punishment punishment NN 40436 8664 56 , , , 40436 8664 57 but but CC 40436 8664 58 to to TO 40436 8664 59 prevent prevent VB 40436 8664 60 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 61 from from IN 40436 8664 62 suffering suffer VBG 40436 8664 63 punishment punishment NN 40436 8664 64 or or CC 40436 8664 65 making make VBG 40436 8664 66 compensation compensation NN 40436 8664 67 : : : 40436 8664 68 so so IN 40436 8664 69 that that IN 40436 8664 70 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8664 71 may may MD 40436 8664 72 live live VB 40436 8664 73 as as RB 40436 8664 74 long long RB 40436 8664 75 as as IN 40436 8664 76 possible possible JJ 40436 8664 77 in in IN 40436 8664 78 impunity impunity NN 40436 8664 79 . . . 40436 8665 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8665 2 39 39 CD 40436 8665 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8665 4 These these DT 40436 8665 5 are be VBP 40436 8665 6 the the DT 40436 8665 7 purposes purpose NNS 40436 8665 8 towards towards IN 40436 8665 9 which which WDT 40436 8665 10 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8665 11 is be VBZ 40436 8665 12 serviceable serviceable JJ 40436 8665 13 . . . 40436 8666 1 For for IN 40436 8666 2 one one CD 40436 8666 3 who who WP 40436 8666 4 intends intend VBZ 40436 8666 5 to to TO 40436 8666 6 do do VB 40436 8666 7 no no DT 40436 8666 8 wrong wrong NN 40436 8666 9 , , , 40436 8666 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8666 11 seems seem VBZ 40436 8666 12 of of IN 40436 8666 13 no no DT 40436 8666 14 great great JJ 40436 8666 15 use use NN 40436 8666 16 . . . 40436 8667 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8667 2 40 40 CD 40436 8667 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8667 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8667 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8667 6 37 37 CD 40436 8667 7 : : : 40436 8667 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8667 9 , , , 40436 8667 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8667 11 , , , 40436 8667 12 p. p. NN 40436 8667 13 479 479 CD 40436 8667 14 B. b. NN 40436 8668 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8668 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8668 3 : : : 40436 8668 4 to\ to\ NN 40436 8668 5 a)lgeino\n a)lgeino\n NN 40436 8668 6 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 8668 7 kathora=|n kathora=|n NNP 40436 8668 8 , , , 40436 8668 9 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 8668 10 de\ de\ NN 40436 8668 11 to\ to\ NN 40436 8668 12 ô)phe ô)phe NNP 40436 8668 13 / / SYM 40436 8668 14 limon limon NNP 40436 8668 15 tuphlô tuphlô NNP 40436 8668 16 = = SYM 40436 8668 17 s s NNP 40436 8668 18 e)/chein e)/chein NNP 40436 8668 19 , , , 40436 8668 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8668 21 a)gnoei a)gnoei NNP 40436 8668 22 = = SYM 40436 8668 23 n n NNP 40436 8668 24 o(/sô| o(/sô| NNP 40436 8668 25 a)thliô a)thliô NNP 40436 8668 26 / / SYM 40436 8668 27 tero tero NNP 40436 8668 28 / / SYM 40436 8668 29 n n NNP 40436 8668 30 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 8668 31 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 8668 32 u(giou u(giou NNP 40436 8668 33 = = SYM 40436 8668 34 s s NNP 40436 8668 35 sô sô NNP 40436 8668 36 / / SYM 40436 8668 37 matos matos NNP 40436 8668 38 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 8668 39 u(giei= u(giei= NNP 40436 8668 40 psuchê=| psuchê=| NNP 40436 8668 41 sunoikei sunoikei VBZ 40436 8668 42 = = SYM 40436 8668 43 n n NN 40436 8668 44 , , , 40436 8668 45 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 8668 46 sathra=| sathra=| NNP 40436 8668 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8668 48 a)di a)di NNP 40436 8668 49 / / SYM 40436 8668 50 kô| kô| NNP 40436 8668 51 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8668 52 a)nosi a)nosi NNP 40436 8668 53 / / SYM 40436 8668 54 ô| ô| NNP 40436 8668 55 . . . 40436 8668 56 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8668 57 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8669 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8669 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8669 3 38 38 CD 40436 8669 4 : : : 40436 8669 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8669 6 , , , 40436 8669 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8669 8 , , , 40436 8669 9 pp pp NNP 40436 8669 10 . . . 40436 8670 1 480 480 CD 40436 8670 2 C c NN 40436 8670 3 , , , 40436 8670 4 508 508 CD 40436 8670 5 B. b. NN 40436 8671 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8671 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8671 3 : : : 40436 8671 4 katêgorête katêgorête NNP 40436 8671 5 / / , 40436 8671 6 on on IN 40436 8671 7 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 8671 8 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8671 9 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 8671 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8671 11 ui(e ui(e NNP 40436 8671 12 / / SYM 40436 8671 13 os os NNP 40436 8671 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8671 15 e(tai e(tai NNP 40436 8671 16 / / SYM 40436 8671 17 ron ron NNP 40436 8671 18 , , , 40436 8671 19 e)a e)a NNP 40436 8671 20 / / SYM 40436 8671 21 n n NN 40436 8671 22 ti ti NN 40436 8671 23 a)dikê=| a)dikê=| ADD 40436 8671 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8671 25 , , , 40436 8671 26 & & CC 40436 8671 27 c. c. NNP 40436 8671 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8671 29 might may MD 40436 8671 30 have have VB 40436 8671 31 put put VBN 40436 8671 32 this this DT 40436 8671 33 argument argument NN 40436 8671 34 into into IN 40436 8671 35 the the DT 40436 8671 36 mouth mouth NN 40436 8671 37 of of IN 40436 8671 38 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 8671 39 as as IN 40436 8671 40 a a DT 40436 8671 41 reason reason NN 40436 8671 42 for for IN 40436 8671 43 indicting indict VBG 40436 8671 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8671 45 own own JJ 40436 8671 46 father father NN 40436 8671 47 on on IN 40436 8671 48 the the DT 40436 8671 49 charge charge NN 40436 8671 50 of of IN 40436 8671 51 murder murder NN 40436 8671 52 : : : 40436 8671 53 as as IN 40436 8671 54 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8671 55 have have VBP 40436 8671 56 already already RB 40436 8671 57 observed observe VBN 40436 8671 58 in in IN 40436 8671 59 reviewing review VBG 40436 8671 60 the the DT 40436 8671 61 Euthyphron Euthyphron NNP 40436 8671 62 , , , 40436 8671 63 which which WDT 40436 8671 64 see see VBP 40436 8671 65 above above RB 40436 8671 66 , , , 40436 8671 67 vol vol NNP 40436 8671 68 . . . 40436 8672 1 i. i. NNP 40436 8672 2 ch ch NNP 40436 8672 3 . . . 40436 8673 1 xi xi NNP 40436 8673 2 . . NNP 40436 8673 3 , , , 40436 8673 4 p. p. NN 40436 8674 1 442 442 CD 40436 8674 2 . . . 40436 8674 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8675 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8675 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8675 3 39 39 CD 40436 8675 4 : : : 40436 8675 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8675 6 , , , 40436 8675 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8675 8 , , , 40436 8675 9 p. p. NN 40436 8675 10 481 481 CD 40436 8675 11 A. a. NN 40436 8676 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8676 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8676 3 : : : 40436 8676 4 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 8676 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8676 6 a)/llon a)/llon NNP 40436 8676 7 a)dikê=| a)dikê=| ADD 40436 8676 8 o o NN 40436 8676 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8676 10 e)chthro e)chthro , 40436 8676 11 / / SYM 40436 8676 12 s s NNPS 40436 8676 13 , , , 40436 8676 14 panti\ panti\ NNP 40436 8676 15 tro tro NNP 40436 8676 16 / / SYM 40436 8676 17 pô| pô| NNP 40436 8676 18 paraskeuaste paraskeuaste NN 40436 8676 19 / / , 40436 8676 20 on on IN 40436 8676 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8676 22 pra pra NNP 40436 8676 23 / / SYM 40436 8676 24 ttonta ttonta NNP 40436 8676 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8676 26 le le NNP 40436 8676 27 / / SYM 40436 8676 28 gonta gonta NNP 40436 8676 29 , , , 40436 8676 30 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 8676 31 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 8676 32 dô=| dô=| NNP 40436 8676 33 di di FW 40436 8676 34 / / SYM 40436 8676 35 kên kên NNP 40436 8676 36 . . . 40436 8677 1 . . . 40436 8678 1 . . . 40436 8679 1 . . . 40436 8680 1 e)a e)a NNP 40436 8680 2 / / SYM 40436 8680 3 n n CD 40436 8680 4 te te NNP 40436 8680 5 chrusi chrusi NNP 40436 8680 6 / / , 40436 8680 7 on on IN 40436 8680 8 ê(rpakô\s ê(rpakô\s NNP 40436 8680 9 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 8680 10 polu/ polu/ NN 40436 8680 11 , , , 40436 8680 12 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 8680 13 a)podidô=| a)podidô=| ADD 40436 8680 14 tou tou FW 40436 8680 15 = = SYM 40436 8680 16 to to TO 40436 8680 17 , , , 40436 8680 18 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 8680 19 ' ' POS 40436 8680 20 e)/chôn e)/chôn CD 40436 8680 21 a)nali a)nali , 40436 8680 22 / / SYM 40436 8680 23 skêtai skêtai NN 40436 8680 24 . . . 40436 8681 1 . . . 40436 8682 1 . . . 40436 8683 1 a)di a)di NNP 40436 8683 2 / / SYM 40436 8683 3 kôs kôs NNP 40436 8683 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8683 5 a)the a)the NNP 40436 8683 6 / / SYM 40436 8683 7 ôs ôs NNP 40436 8683 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8683 9 , , , 40436 8683 10 & & CC 40436 8683 11 c. c. NNP 40436 8683 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8683 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8683 14 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8683 15 40 40 CD 40436 8683 16 : : : 40436 8683 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8683 18 , , , 40436 8683 19 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8683 20 , , , 40436 8683 21 p. p. NN 40436 8684 1 481 481 CD 40436 8684 2 . . . 40436 8684 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8685 1 * * NFP 40436 8685 2 * * NFP 40436 8685 3 * * NFP 40436 8685 4 * * NFP 40436 8685 5 * * NFP 40436 8685 6 This this DT 40436 8685 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8685 8 between between IN 40436 8685 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8685 10 and and CC 40436 8685 11 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8685 12 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 8685 13 a a DT 40436 8685 14 representation representation NN 40436 8685 15 of of IN 40436 8685 16 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 8685 17 Ethics Ethics NNPS 40436 8685 18 longer long RBR 40436 8685 19 and and CC 40436 8685 20 more more RBR 40436 8685 21 continuous continuous JJ 40436 8685 22 than than IN 40436 8685 23 is be VBZ 40436 8685 24 usual usual JJ 40436 8685 25 in in IN 40436 8685 26 the the DT 40436 8685 27 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 8685 28 . . . 40436 8686 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8686 2 have have VBP 40436 8686 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 8686 4 given give VBN 40436 8686 5 a a DT 40436 8686 6 tolerably tolerably RB 40436 8686 7 copious copious JJ 40436 8686 8 abridgment abridgment NN 40436 8686 9 of of IN 40436 8686 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8686 11 , , , 40436 8686 12 and and CC 40436 8686 13 shall shall MD 40436 8686 14 now now RB 40436 8686 15 proceed proceed VB 40436 8686 16 to to TO 40436 8686 17 comment comment VB 40436 8686 18 upon upon IN 40436 8686 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8686 20 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8686 21 . . . 40436 8687 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8687 2 Side side NN 40436 8687 3 - - HYPH 40436 8687 4 note note NN 40436 8687 5 : : : 40436 8687 6 Argument argument NN 40436 8687 7 of of IN 40436 8687 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8687 9 paradoxical paradoxical JJ 40436 8687 10 -- -- : 40436 8687 11 Doubt Doubt NNP 40436 8687 12 expressed express VBN 40436 8687 13 by by IN 40436 8687 14 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8687 15 whether whether IN 40436 8687 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8687 17 means mean VBZ 40436 8687 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8687 19 seriously seriously RB 40436 8687 20 . . . 40436 8687 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8688 1 The the DT 40436 8688 2 whole whole JJ 40436 8688 3 tenor tenor NN 40436 8688 4 of of IN 40436 8688 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8688 6 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 8688 7 , , , 40436 8688 8 as as RB 40436 8688 9 well well RB 40436 8688 10 as as IN 40436 8688 11 the the DT 40436 8688 12 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 8688 13 in in IN 40436 8688 14 which which WDT 40436 8688 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8688 16 ends end VBZ 40436 8688 17 , , , 40436 8688 18 are be VBP 40436 8688 19 so so RB 40436 8688 20 repugnant repugnant JJ 40436 8688 21 to to IN 40436 8688 22 received receive VBN 40436 8688 23 opinions opinion NNS 40436 8688 24 , , , 40436 8688 25 that that IN 40436 8688 26 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8688 27 , , , 40436 8688 28 even even RB 40436 8688 29 while while IN 40436 8688 30 compelled compel VBN 40436 8688 31 to to TO 40436 8688 32 assent assent VB 40436 8688 33 , , , 40436 8688 34 treats treat VBZ 40436 8688 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8688 36 as as IN 40436 8688 37 a a DT 40436 8688 38 paradox paradox NN 40436 8688 39 : : : 40436 8688 40 while while IN 40436 8688 41 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8688 42 , , , 40436 8688 43 who who WP 40436 8688 44 now now RB 40436 8688 45 takes take VBZ 40436 8688 46 up up RP 40436 8688 47 the the DT 40436 8688 48 argument argument NN 40436 8688 49 , , , 40436 8688 50 begins begin VBZ 40436 8688 51 by by IN 40436 8688 52 asking ask VBG 40436 8688 53 from from IN 40436 8688 54 Chærephon--"Is Chærephon--"Is NNP 40436 8688 55 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8688 56 really really RB 40436 8688 57 in in IN 40436 8688 58 earnest earnest JJ 40436 8688 59 , , , 40436 8688 60 or or CC 40436 8688 61 is be VBZ 40436 8688 62 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8688 63 only only RB 40436 8688 64 jesting jest VBG 40436 8688 65 ? ? . 40436 8689 1 " " `` 40436 8689 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8689 3 41 41 CD 40436 8689 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8689 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8689 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8689 7 admits admit VBZ 40436 8689 8 that that IN 40436 8689 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8689 10 stands stand VBZ 40436 8689 11 almost almost RB 40436 8689 12 alone alone JJ 40436 8689 13 . . . 40436 8690 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8690 2 has have VBZ 40436 8690 3 nothing nothing NN 40436 8690 4 to to TO 40436 8690 5 rely rely VB 40436 8690 6 upon upon IN 40436 8690 7 , , , 40436 8690 8 except except IN 40436 8690 9 the the DT 40436 8690 10 consistency consistency NN 40436 8690 11 of of IN 40436 8690 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8690 13 dialectics dialectic NNS 40436 8690 14 -- -- : 40436 8690 15 and and CC 40436 8690 16 the the DT 40436 8690 17 verdict verdict NN 40436 8690 18 of of IN 40436 8690 19 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 8690 20 . . . 40436 8691 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8691 2 42 42 CD 40436 8691 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8691 4 This this DT 40436 8691 5 however however RB 40436 8691 6 is be VBZ 40436 8691 7 a a DT 40436 8691 8 matter matter NN 40436 8691 9 of of IN 40436 8691 10 little little JJ 40436 8691 11 moment moment NN 40436 8691 12 , , , 40436 8691 13 in in IN 40436 8691 14 discussing discuss VBG 40436 8691 15 the the DT 40436 8691 16 truth truth NN 40436 8691 17 and and CC 40436 8691 18 value value NN 40436 8691 19 of of IN 40436 8691 20 the the DT 40436 8691 21 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8691 22 , , , 40436 8691 23 except except IN 40436 8691 24 in in IN 40436 8691 25 so so RB 40436 8691 26 far far RB 40436 8691 27 as as IN 40436 8691 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8691 29 involves involve VBZ 40436 8691 30 an an DT 40436 8691 31 appeal appeal NN 40436 8691 32 to to IN 40436 8691 33 the the DT 40436 8691 34 judgment judgment NN 40436 8691 35 of of IN 40436 8691 36 the the DT 40436 8691 37 public public NN 40436 8691 38 as as IN 40436 8691 39 a a DT 40436 8691 40 matter matter NN 40436 8691 41 of of IN 40436 8691 42 fact fact NN 40436 8691 43 . . . 40436 8692 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8692 2 follows follow VBZ 40436 8692 3 out out RP 40436 8692 4 the the DT 40436 8692 5 train train NN 40436 8692 6 of of IN 40436 8692 7 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8692 8 -- -- : 40436 8692 9 which which WDT 40436 8692 10 at at IN 40436 8692 11 the the DT 40436 8692 12 time time NN 40436 8692 13 presents present VBZ 40436 8692 14 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8692 15 to to IN 40436 8692 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8692 17 mind mind NN 40436 8692 18 as as IN 40436 8692 19 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 8692 20 , , , 40436 8692 21 or or CC 40436 8692 22 at at IN 40436 8692 23 least least JJS 40436 8692 24 as as RB 40436 8692 25 plausible plausible JJ 40436 8692 26 -- -- : 40436 8692 27 whether whether IN 40436 8692 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8692 29 may may MD 40436 8692 30 agree agree VB 40436 8692 31 or or CC 40436 8692 32 disagree disagree VB 40436 8692 33 with with IN 40436 8692 34 others other NNS 40436 8692 35 . . . 40436 8693 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8693 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8693 3 41 41 CD 40436 8693 4 : : : 40436 8693 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8693 6 , , , 40436 8693 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8693 8 , , , 40436 8693 9 p. p. NN 40436 8694 1 481 481 CD 40436 8694 2 . . . 40436 8694 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8695 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8695 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8695 3 42 42 CD 40436 8695 4 : : : 40436 8695 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8695 6 , , , 40436 8695 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8695 8 , , , 40436 8695 9 p. p. NN 40436 8696 1 482 482 CD 40436 8696 2 . . . 40436 8696 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8697 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8697 2 Side side NN 40436 8697 3 - - HYPH 40436 8697 4 note note NN 40436 8697 5 : : : 40436 8697 6 Principle principle NN 40436 8697 7 laid lay VBD 40436 8697 8 down down RP 40436 8697 9 by by IN 40436 8697 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8697 11 -- -- : 40436 8697 12 That that IN 40436 8697 13 every every DT 40436 8697 14 one one CD 40436 8697 15 acts act VBZ 40436 8697 16 with with IN 40436 8697 17 a a DT 40436 8697 18 view view NN 40436 8697 19 to to IN 40436 8697 20 the the DT 40436 8697 21 attainment attainment NN 40436 8697 22 of of IN 40436 8697 23 happiness happiness NN 40436 8697 24 and and CC 40436 8697 25 avoidance avoidance NN 40436 8697 26 of of IN 40436 8697 27 misery misery NN 40436 8697 28 . . . 40436 8697 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8698 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8698 2 has have VBZ 40436 8698 3 ranked rank VBN 40436 8698 4 the the DT 40436 8698 5 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8698 6 in in IN 40436 8698 7 the the DT 40436 8698 8 same same JJ 40436 8698 9 category category NN 40436 8698 10 as as IN 40436 8698 11 the the DT 40436 8698 12 Despot Despot NNP 40436 8698 13 : : : 40436 8698 14 a a DT 40436 8698 15 classification classification NN 40436 8698 16 upon upon IN 40436 8698 17 which which WDT 40436 8698 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8698 19 shall shall MD 40436 8698 20 say say VB 40436 8698 21 something something NN 40436 8698 22 presently presently RB 40436 8698 23 . . . 40436 8699 1 But but CC 40436 8699 2 throughout throughout IN 40436 8699 3 the the DT 40436 8699 4 part part NN 40436 8699 5 of of IN 40436 8699 6 the the DT 40436 8699 7 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8699 8 just just RB 40436 8699 9 extracted extract VBD 40436 8699 10 , , , 40436 8699 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8699 12 treats treat VBZ 40436 8699 13 the the DT 40436 8699 14 original original JJ 40436 8699 15 question question NN 40436 8699 16 about about IN 40436 8699 17 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 40436 8699 18 as as IN 40436 8699 19 part part NN 40436 8699 20 of of IN 40436 8699 21 a a DT 40436 8699 22 much much RB 40436 8699 23 larger large JJR 40436 8699 24 ethical ethical JJ 40436 8699 25 question question NN 40436 8699 26 . . . 40436 8700 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8700 2 43 43 CD 40436 8700 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8700 4 Every every DT 40436 8700 5 one one NN 40436 8700 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8700 7 argues argue VBZ 40436 8700 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8700 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8700 10 wishes wish VBZ 40436 8700 11 for for IN 40436 8700 12 the the DT 40436 8700 13 attainment attainment NN 40436 8700 14 of of IN 40436 8700 15 good good JJ 40436 8700 16 and and CC 40436 8700 17 for for IN 40436 8700 18 the the DT 40436 8700 19 avoidance avoidance NN 40436 8700 20 of of IN 40436 8700 21 evil evil NN 40436 8700 22 . . . 40436 8701 1 Every every DT 40436 8701 2 one one NN 40436 8701 3 performs perform VBZ 40436 8701 4 each each DT 40436 8701 5 separate separate JJ 40436 8701 6 act act NN 40436 8701 7 with with IN 40436 8701 8 a a DT 40436 8701 9 view view NN 40436 8701 10 not not RB 40436 8701 11 to to IN 40436 8701 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8701 13 own own JJ 40436 8701 14 immediate immediate JJ 40436 8701 15 end end NN 40436 8701 16 , , , 40436 8701 17 but but CC 40436 8701 18 to to IN 40436 8701 19 one one CD 40436 8701 20 or or CC 40436 8701 21 other other JJ 40436 8701 22 of of IN 40436 8701 23 these these DT 40436 8701 24 permanent permanent JJ 40436 8701 25 ends end NNS 40436 8701 26 . . . 40436 8702 1 In in IN 40436 8702 2 so so RB 40436 8702 3 far far RB 40436 8702 4 as as IN 40436 8702 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8702 6 attains attain VBZ 40436 8702 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8702 8 , , , 40436 8702 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8702 10 is be VBZ 40436 8702 11 happy happy JJ 40436 8702 12 : : : 40436 8702 13 in in IN 40436 8702 14 so so RB 40436 8702 15 far far RB 40436 8702 16 as as IN 40436 8702 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8702 18 either either CC 40436 8702 19 fails fail VBZ 40436 8702 20 in in IN 40436 8702 21 attaining attain VBG 40436 8702 22 the the DT 40436 8702 23 good good JJ 40436 8702 24 , , , 40436 8702 25 or or CC 40436 8702 26 incurs incur VBZ 40436 8702 27 the the DT 40436 8702 28 evil evil NN 40436 8702 29 , , , 40436 8702 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8702 31 is be VBZ 40436 8702 32 unhappy unhappy JJ 40436 8702 33 or or CC 40436 8702 34 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8702 35 . . . 40436 8703 1 The the DT 40436 8703 2 good good JJ 40436 8703 3 and and CC 40436 8703 4 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8703 5 man man NN 40436 8703 6 or or CC 40436 8703 7 woman woman NN 40436 8703 8 is be VBZ 40436 8703 9 happy happy JJ 40436 8703 10 , , , 40436 8703 11 the the DT 40436 8703 12 unjust unjust JJ 40436 8703 13 and and CC 40436 8703 14 wicked wicked JJ 40436 8703 15 is be VBZ 40436 8703 16 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8703 17 . . . 40436 8704 1 Power power NN 40436 8704 2 acquired acquire VBD 40436 8704 3 or or CC 40436 8704 4 employed employ VBN 40436 8704 5 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 8704 6 , , , 40436 8704 7 is be VBZ 40436 8704 8 no no DT 40436 8704 9 boon boon NN 40436 8704 10 to to IN 40436 8704 11 the the DT 40436 8704 12 possessor possessor NN 40436 8704 13 : : : 40436 8704 14 for for IN 40436 8704 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8704 16 does do VBZ 40436 8704 17 not not RB 40436 8704 18 thereby thereby RB 40436 8704 19 obtain obtain VB 40436 8704 20 what what WP 40436 8704 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8704 22 really really RB 40436 8704 23 wishes wish VBZ 40436 8704 24 , , , 40436 8704 25 good good JJ 40436 8704 26 or or CC 40436 8704 27 happiness happiness NN 40436 8704 28 ; ; : 40436 8704 29 but but CC 40436 8704 30 incurs incur VBZ 40436 8704 31 the the DT 40436 8704 32 contrary contrary JJ 40436 8704 33 , , , 40436 8704 34 evil evil NN 40436 8704 35 and and CC 40436 8704 36 misery misery NN 40436 8704 37 . . . 40436 8705 1 The the DT 40436 8705 2 man man NN 40436 8705 3 who who WP 40436 8705 4 does do VBZ 40436 8705 5 wrong wrong NN 40436 8705 6 is be VBZ 40436 8705 7 more more RBR 40436 8705 8 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8705 9 than than IN 40436 8705 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8705 11 who who WP 40436 8705 12 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8705 13 wrong wrong RB 40436 8705 14 : : : 40436 8705 15 but but CC 40436 8705 16 the the DT 40436 8705 17 most most RBS 40436 8705 18 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8705 19 of of IN 40436 8705 20 all all DT 40436 8705 21 is be VBZ 40436 8705 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8705 23 who who WP 40436 8705 24 does do VBZ 40436 8705 25 wrong wrong NN 40436 8705 26 and and CC 40436 8705 27 then then RB 40436 8705 28 remains remain VBZ 40436 8705 29 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 8705 30 for for IN 40436 8705 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8705 32 . . . 40436 8706 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8706 2 44 44 CD 40436 8706 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8706 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8706 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8706 6 43 43 CD 40436 8706 7 : : : 40436 8706 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8706 9 may may MD 40436 8706 10 be be VB 40436 8706 11 told tell VBN 40436 8706 12 that that IN 40436 8706 13 this this DT 40436 8706 14 comparison comparison NN 40436 8706 15 is be VBZ 40436 8706 16 first first RB 40436 8706 17 made make VBN 40436 8706 18 by by IN 40436 8706 19 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8706 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8706 21 p. p. NN 40436 8706 22 466 466 CD 40436 8706 23 C C NNP 40436 8706 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8706 25 , , , 40436 8706 26 and and CC 40436 8706 27 that that IN 40436 8706 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8706 29 only only RB 40436 8706 30 takes take VBZ 40436 8706 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8706 32 up up RP 40436 8706 33 from from IN 40436 8706 34 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8706 35 to to TO 40436 8706 36 comment comment VB 40436 8706 37 upon upon IN 40436 8706 38 . . . 40436 8707 1 True true JJ 40436 8707 2 , , , 40436 8707 3 but but CC 40436 8707 4 the the DT 40436 8707 5 speech speech NN 40436 8707 6 of of IN 40436 8707 7 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8707 8 is be VBZ 40436 8707 9 just just RB 40436 8707 10 as as RB 40436 8707 11 much much JJ 40436 8707 12 the the DT 40436 8707 13 composition composition NN 40436 8707 14 of of IN 40436 8707 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8707 16 as as IN 40436 8707 17 that that DT 40436 8707 18 of of IN 40436 8707 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8707 20 . . . 40436 8708 1 Many many JJ 40436 8708 2 readers reader NNS 40436 8708 3 of of IN 40436 8708 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8708 5 are be VBP 40436 8708 6 apt apt JJ 40436 8708 7 to to TO 40436 8708 8 forget forget VB 40436 8708 9 this this DT 40436 8708 10 . . . 40436 8708 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8709 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8709 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8709 3 44 44 CD 40436 8709 4 : : : 40436 8709 5 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 8709 6 , , , 40436 8709 7 in in IN 40436 8709 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8709 9 Panathenaic Panathenaic NNP 40436 8709 10 Oration Oration NNP 40436 8709 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8709 12 Or or CC 40436 8709 13 . . . 40436 8710 1 xii xii NNP 40436 8710 2 . . . 40436 8711 1 sect sect NNP 40436 8711 2 . . . 40436 8712 1 126 126 CD 40436 8712 2 , , , 40436 8712 3 pp pp ADD 40436 8712 4 . . . 40436 8713 1 257 257 CD 40436 8713 2 - - SYM 40436 8713 3 347 347 CD 40436 8713 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8713 5 , , , 40436 8713 6 alludes allude NNS 40436 8713 7 to to IN 40436 8713 8 the the DT 40436 8713 9 same same JJ 40436 8713 10 thesis thesis NN 40436 8713 11 as as IN 40436 8713 12 this this DT 40436 8713 13 here here RB 40436 8713 14 advanced advance VBN 40436 8713 15 by by IN 40436 8713 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8713 17 , , , 40436 8713 18 treating treat VBG 40436 8713 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8713 20 as as IN 40436 8713 21 one one CD 40436 8713 22 which which WDT 40436 8713 23 all all DT 40436 8713 24 men man NNS 40436 8713 25 of of IN 40436 8713 26 sense sense NN 40436 8713 27 would would MD 40436 8713 28 reject reject VB 40436 8713 29 , , , 40436 8713 30 and and CC 40436 8713 31 which which WDT 40436 8713 32 none none NN 40436 8713 33 but but IN 40436 8713 34 a a DT 40436 8713 35 few few JJ 40436 8713 36 men man NNS 40436 8713 37 pretending pretend VBG 40436 8713 38 to to TO 40436 8713 39 be be VB 40436 8713 40 wise wise JJ 40436 8713 41 would would MD 40436 8713 42 proclaim--[Greek proclaim--[greek CD 40436 8713 43 : : : 40436 8713 44 a(/per a(/per NNP 40436 8713 45 a(/pantes a(/pantes NNP 40436 8713 46 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8713 47 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 8713 48 oi oi NNP 40436 8713 49 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8713 50 nou nou NNP 40436 8713 51 = = SYM 40436 8713 52 n n CC 40436 8713 53 e)/chontes e)/chontes NNP 40436 8713 54 e)/lointo e)/lointo NNP 40436 8713 55 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8713 56 boulêthei boulêthei NNP 40436 8713 57 = = SYM 40436 8713 58 en en FW 40436 8713 59 , , , 40436 8713 60 o)li o)li NNP 40436 8713 61 / / SYM 40436 8713 62 goi goi NNP 40436 8713 63 de/ de/ NNP 40436 8713 64 tines tines NNPS 40436 8713 65 tô tô NNP 40436 8713 66 = = SYM 40436 8713 67 n n CC 40436 8713 68 prospoioume prospoioume NN 40436 8713 69 / / SYM 40436 8713 70 nôn nôn NNP 40436 8713 71 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 8713 72 sophô sophô NNP 40436 8713 73 = = SYM 40436 8713 74 n n CC 40436 8713 75 , , , 40436 8713 76 e)rôtêthe e)rôtêthe NFP 40436 8713 77 / / SYM 40436 8713 78 ntes ntes NNP 40436 8713 79 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 8713 80 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 8713 81 phê phê NNP 40436 8713 82 / / SYM 40436 8713 83 saien saien NNP 40436 8713 84 . . . 40436 8713 85 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8714 1 In in IN 40436 8714 2 this this DT 40436 8714 3 last last JJ 40436 8714 4 phrase phrase NN 40436 8714 5 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 8714 6 probably probably RB 40436 8714 7 has have VBZ 40436 8714 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8714 9 in in IN 40436 8714 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8714 11 mind mind NN 40436 8714 12 , , , 40436 8714 13 though though IN 40436 8714 14 without without IN 40436 8714 15 pronouncing pronounce VBG 40436 8714 16 the the DT 40436 8714 17 name name NN 40436 8714 18 . . . 40436 8714 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8715 1 Polus polus JJ 40436 8715 2 , , , 40436 8715 3 on on IN 40436 8715 4 the the DT 40436 8715 5 other other JJ 40436 8715 6 hand hand NN 40436 8715 7 , , , 40436 8715 8 contends contend VBZ 40436 8715 9 , , , 40436 8715 10 that that IN 40436 8715 11 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8715 12 , , , 40436 8715 13 who who WP 40436 8715 14 has have VBZ 40436 8715 15 " " `` 40436 8715 16 waded wade VBN 40436 8715 17 through through IN 40436 8715 18 slaughter slaughter NN 40436 8715 19 " " '' 40436 8715 20 to to IN 40436 8715 21 the the DT 40436 8715 22 throne throne NN 40436 8715 23 of of IN 40436 8715 24 Macedonia Macedonia NNP 40436 8715 25 , , , 40436 8715 26 is be VBZ 40436 8715 27 a a DT 40436 8715 28 happy happy JJ 40436 8715 29 man man NN 40436 8715 30 both both DT 40436 8715 31 in in IN 40436 8715 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8715 33 own own JJ 40436 8715 34 feelings feeling NNS 40436 8715 35 and and CC 40436 8715 36 in in IN 40436 8715 37 those those DT 40436 8715 38 of of IN 40436 8715 39 every every DT 40436 8715 40 one one CD 40436 8715 41 else else RB 40436 8715 42 , , , 40436 8715 43 envied envy VBN 40436 8715 44 and and CC 40436 8715 45 admired admire VBN 40436 8715 46 by by IN 40436 8715 47 the the DT 40436 8715 48 world world NN 40436 8715 49 generally generally RB 40436 8715 50 : : : 40436 8715 51 That that DT 40436 8715 52 to to TO 40436 8715 53 say say VB 40436 8715 54 -- -- : 40436 8715 55 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8715 56 would would MD 40436 8715 57 have have VB 40436 8715 58 been be VBN 40436 8715 59 more more RBR 40436 8715 60 happy happy JJ 40436 8715 61 , , , 40436 8715 62 or or CC 40436 8715 63 less less RBR 40436 8715 64 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8715 65 , , , 40436 8715 66 if if IN 40436 8715 67 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8715 68 had have VBD 40436 8715 69 failed fail VBN 40436 8715 70 in in IN 40436 8715 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8715 72 enterprise enterprise NN 40436 8715 73 and and CC 40436 8715 74 had have VBD 40436 8715 75 been be VBN 40436 8715 76 put put VBN 40436 8715 77 to to IN 40436 8715 78 death death NN 40436 8715 79 under under IN 40436 8715 80 cruel cruel JJ 40436 8715 81 torture torture NN 40436 8715 82 -- -- : 40436 8715 83 is be VBZ 40436 8715 84 an an DT 40436 8715 85 untenable untenable JJ 40436 8715 86 paradox paradox NN 40436 8715 87 . . . 40436 8716 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8716 2 Side side NN 40436 8716 3 - - HYPH 40436 8716 4 note note NN 40436 8716 5 : : : 40436 8716 6 Peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 8716 7 view view NN 40436 8716 8 taken take VBN 40436 8716 9 by by IN 40436 8716 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8716 11 of of IN 40436 8716 12 Good good JJ 40436 8716 13 -- -- : 40436 8716 14 Evil evil JJ 40436 8716 15 -- -- : 40436 8716 16 Happiness happiness NN 40436 8716 17 . . . 40436 8716 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8717 1 The the DT 40436 8717 2 issue issue NN 40436 8717 3 here here RB 40436 8717 4 turns turn VBZ 40436 8717 5 , , , 40436 8717 6 and and CC 40436 8717 7 the the DT 40436 8717 8 force force NN 40436 8717 9 of of IN 40436 8717 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8717 11 's 's POS 40436 8717 12 argument argument NN 40436 8717 13 rests rest NNS 40436 8717 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8717 15 assuming assume VBG 40436 8717 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8717 17 to to TO 40436 8717 18 speak speak VB 40436 8717 19 the the DT 40436 8717 20 real real JJ 40436 8717 21 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8717 22 of of IN 40436 8717 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8717 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8717 25 , , , 40436 8717 26 upon upon IN 40436 8717 27 the the DT 40436 8717 28 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 8717 29 sense sense NN 40436 8717 30 which which WDT 40436 8717 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8717 32 gives give VBZ 40436 8717 33 to to IN 40436 8717 34 the the DT 40436 8717 35 words word NNS 40436 8717 36 Good good JJ 40436 8717 37 -- -- : 40436 8717 38 Evil evil JJ 40436 8717 39 -- -- : 40436 8717 40 Happiness:--different happiness:--different NN 40436 8717 41 from from IN 40436 8717 42 the the DT 40436 8717 43 sense sense NN 40436 8717 44 in in IN 40436 8717 45 which which WDT 40436 8717 46 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8717 47 are be VBP 40436 8717 48 conceived conceive VBN 40436 8717 49 by by IN 40436 8717 50 mankind mankind NN 40436 8717 51 generally generally RB 40436 8717 52 , , , 40436 8717 53 and and CC 40436 8717 54 which which WDT 40436 8717 55 is be VBZ 40436 8717 56 here here RB 40436 8717 57 followed follow VBN 40436 8717 58 by by IN 40436 8717 59 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8717 60 . . . 40436 8718 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8718 2 is be VBZ 40436 8718 3 possible possible JJ 40436 8718 4 that that IN 40436 8718 5 to to IN 40436 8718 6 minds mind NNS 40436 8718 7 like like IN 40436 8718 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8718 9 and and CC 40436 8718 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8718 11 , , , 40436 8718 12 the the DT 40436 8718 13 idea idea NN 40436 8718 14 of of IN 40436 8718 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8718 16 committing commit VBG 40436 8718 17 enormous enormous JJ 40436 8718 18 crimes crime NNS 40436 8718 19 for for IN 40436 8718 20 ambitious ambitious JJ 40436 8718 21 purposes purpose NNS 40436 8718 22 might may MD 40436 8718 23 be be VB 40436 8718 24 the the DT 40436 8718 25 most most RBS 40436 8718 26 intolerable intolerable JJ 40436 8718 27 of of IN 40436 8718 28 all all DT 40436 8718 29 ideas idea NNS 40436 8718 30 , , , 40436 8718 31 worse bad JJR 40436 8718 32 to to TO 40436 8718 33 contemplate contemplate VB 40436 8718 34 than than IN 40436 8718 35 any any DT 40436 8718 36 amount amount NN 40436 8718 37 of of IN 40436 8718 38 suffering suffering NN 40436 8718 39 : : : 40436 8718 40 moreover moreover RB 40436 8718 41 , , , 40436 8718 42 that that IN 40436 8718 43 if if IN 40436 8718 44 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8718 45 could could MD 40436 8718 46 conceive conceive VB 40436 8718 47 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8718 48 as as IN 40436 8718 49 having have VBG 40436 8718 50 been be VBN 40436 8718 51 thus thus RB 40436 8718 52 guilty guilty JJ 40436 8718 53 , , , 40436 8718 54 the the DT 40436 8718 55 sequel sequel NN 40436 8718 56 the the DT 40436 8718 57 least least JJS 40436 8718 58 intolerable intolerable JJ 40436 8718 59 for for IN 40436 8718 60 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8718 61 to to TO 40436 8718 62 imagine imagine VB 40436 8718 63 would would MD 40436 8718 64 be be VB 40436 8718 65 one one CD 40436 8718 66 of of IN 40436 8718 67 expiatory expiatory NN 40436 8718 68 pain pain NN 40436 8718 69 . . . 40436 8719 1 This this DT 40436 8719 2 , , , 40436 8719 3 taken take VBN 40436 8719 4 as as IN 40436 8719 5 the the DT 40436 8719 6 personal personal JJ 40436 8719 7 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8719 8 of of IN 40436 8719 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8719 10 , , , 40436 8719 11 admits admit NNS 40436 8719 12 of of IN 40436 8719 13 no no DT 40436 8719 14 reply reply NN 40436 8719 15 . . . 40436 8720 1 But but CC 40436 8720 2 when when WRB 40436 8720 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8720 4 attempts attempt VBZ 40436 8720 5 to to TO 40436 8720 6 convert convert VB 40436 8720 7 this this DT 40436 8720 8 subjective subjective JJ 40436 8720 9 judgment judgment NN 40436 8720 10 into into IN 40436 8720 11 an an DT 40436 8720 12 objective objective JJ 40436 8720 13 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 8720 14 binding bind VBG 40436 8720 15 on on IN 40436 8720 16 all all DT 40436 8720 17 , , , 40436 8720 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8720 19 fails fail VBZ 40436 8720 20 of of IN 40436 8720 21 success success NN 40436 8720 22 , , , 40436 8720 23 and and CC 40436 8720 24 misleads mislead VBZ 40436 8720 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8720 26 by by IN 40436 8720 27 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 8720 28 language language NN 40436 8720 29 . . . 40436 8721 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8721 2 Side side NN 40436 8721 3 - - HYPH 40436 8721 4 note note NN 40436 8721 5 : : : 40436 8721 6 Contrast contrast NN 40436 8721 7 of of IN 40436 8721 8 the the DT 40436 8721 9 usual usual JJ 40436 8721 10 meaning meaning NN 40436 8721 11 of of IN 40436 8721 12 these these DT 40436 8721 13 words word NNS 40436 8721 14 , , , 40436 8721 15 with with IN 40436 8721 16 the the DT 40436 8721 17 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8721 18 meaning meaning NN 40436 8721 19 . . . 40436 8721 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8722 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8722 2 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 40436 8722 3 two two CD 40436 8722 4 general general JJ 40436 8722 5 objects object NNS 40436 8722 6 of of IN 40436 8722 7 human human JJ 40436 8722 8 desire desire NN 40436 8722 9 , , , 40436 8722 10 and and CC 40436 8722 11 two two CD 40436 8722 12 of of IN 40436 8722 13 human human JJ 40436 8722 14 aversion aversion NN 40436 8722 15 . . . 40436 8723 1 1 1 LS 40436 8723 2 . . . 40436 8724 1 The the DT 40436 8724 2 immediate immediate JJ 40436 8724 3 , , , 40436 8724 4 and and CC 40436 8724 5 generally generally RB 40436 8724 6 transient transient JJ 40436 8724 7 , , , 40436 8724 8 object object VBP 40436 8724 9 -- -- : 40436 8724 10 Pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8724 11 or or CC 40436 8724 12 the the DT 40436 8724 13 Pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 8724 14 -- -- : 40436 8724 15 Pain pain NN 40436 8724 16 or or CC 40436 8724 17 the the DT 40436 8724 18 Painful Painful NNP 40436 8724 19 . . . 40436 8725 1 2 2 LS 40436 8725 2 . . . 40436 8726 1 The the DT 40436 8726 2 distant distant JJ 40436 8726 3 , , , 40436 8726 4 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 8726 5 , , , 40436 8726 6 and and CC 40436 8726 7 more more RBR 40436 8726 8 permanent permanent JJ 40436 8726 9 object object NN 40436 8726 10 -- -- : 40436 8726 11 Good good JJ 40436 8726 12 or or CC 40436 8726 13 the the DT 40436 8726 14 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8726 15 -- -- : 40436 8726 16 Evil evil JJ 40436 8726 17 or or CC 40436 8726 18 the the DT 40436 8726 19 hurtful.--In hurtful.--in NN 40436 8726 20 the the DT 40436 8726 21 attainment attainment JJ 40436 8726 22 of of IN 40436 8726 23 Good good NN 40436 8726 24 and and CC 40436 8726 25 avoidance avoidance NN 40436 8726 26 of of IN 40436 8726 27 Evil evil JJ 40436 8726 28 consists consist VBZ 40436 8726 29 happiness happiness NN 40436 8726 30 . . . 40436 8727 1 But but CC 40436 8727 2 now now RB 40436 8727 3 comes come VBZ 40436 8727 4 the the DT 40436 8727 5 important important JJ 40436 8727 6 question question NN 40436 8727 7 -- -- : 40436 8727 8 In in IN 40436 8727 9 what what WDT 40436 8727 10 sense sense NN 40436 8727 11 are be VBP 40436 8727 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8727 13 to to TO 40436 8727 14 understand understand VB 40436 8727 15 the the DT 40436 8727 16 words word NNS 40436 8727 17 Good Good NNP 40436 8727 18 and and CC 40436 8727 19 Evil evil JJ 40436 8727 20 ? ? . 40436 8728 1 What what WP 40436 8728 2 did do VBD 40436 8728 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8728 4 mean mean VB 40436 8728 5 by by IN 40436 8728 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8728 7 ? ? . 40436 8729 1 Did do VBD 40436 8729 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8729 3 mean mean VB 40436 8729 4 the the DT 40436 8729 5 same same JJ 40436 8729 6 as as IN 40436 8729 7 mankind mankind NN 40436 8729 8 generally generally RB 40436 8729 9 ? ? . 40436 8730 1 Have have VB 40436 8730 2 mankind mankind NN 40436 8730 3 generally generally RB 40436 8730 4 one one CD 40436 8730 5 uniform uniform JJ 40436 8730 6 meaning meaning NN 40436 8730 7 ? ? . 40436 8731 1 In in IN 40436 8731 2 answer answer NN 40436 8731 3 to to IN 40436 8731 4 this this DT 40436 8731 5 question question NN 40436 8731 6 , , , 40436 8731 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8731 8 must must MD 40436 8731 9 say say VB 40436 8731 10 , , , 40436 8731 11 that that IN 40436 8731 12 neither neither DT 40436 8731 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8731 14 , , , 40436 8731 15 nor nor CC 40436 8731 16 mankind mankind NN 40436 8731 17 generally generally RB 40436 8731 18 , , , 40436 8731 19 are be VBP 40436 8731 20 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8731 21 or or CC 40436 8731 22 unanimous unanimous JJ 40436 8731 23 in in IN 40436 8731 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8731 25 use use NN 40436 8731 26 of of IN 40436 8731 27 the the DT 40436 8731 28 words word NNS 40436 8731 29 : : : 40436 8731 30 and and CC 40436 8731 31 that that IN 40436 8731 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8731 33 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 8731 34 approximates approximate VBZ 40436 8731 35 to to TO 40436 8731 36 , , , 40436 8731 37 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 8731 38 diverges diverge VBZ 40436 8731 39 from from IN 40436 8731 40 , , , 40436 8731 41 the the DT 40436 8731 42 more more RBR 40436 8731 43 usual usual JJ 40436 8731 44 meaning meaning NN 40436 8731 45 . . . 40436 8732 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8732 2 does do VBZ 40436 8732 3 not not RB 40436 8732 4 here here RB 40436 8732 5 tell tell VB 40436 8732 6 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8732 7 clearly clearly RB 40436 8732 8 what what WP 40436 8732 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8732 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8732 11 means mean VBZ 40436 8732 12 by by IN 40436 8732 13 Good Good NNP 40436 8732 14 and and CC 40436 8732 15 Evil Evil NNP 40436 8732 16 : : : 40436 8732 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8732 18 specifies specify VBZ 40436 8732 19 no no DT 40436 8732 20 objective objective JJ 40436 8732 21 or or CC 40436 8732 22 external external JJ 40436 8732 23 mark mark NN 40436 8732 24 by by IN 40436 8732 25 which which WDT 40436 8732 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8732 27 may may MD 40436 8732 28 know know VB 40436 8732 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8732 30 : : : 40436 8732 31 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8732 32 learn learn VBP 40436 8732 33 only only RB 40436 8732 34 , , , 40436 8732 35 that that IN 40436 8732 36 Good good JJ 40436 8732 37 is be VBZ 40436 8732 38 a a DT 40436 8732 39 mental mental JJ 40436 8732 40 perfection perfection NN 40436 8732 41 -- -- : 40436 8732 42 Evil evil VB 40436 8732 43 a a DT 40436 8732 44 mental mental JJ 40436 8732 45 taint taint NN 40436 8732 46 -- -- : 40436 8732 47 answering answer VBG 40436 8732 48 to to TO 40436 8732 49 indescribable indescribable JJ 40436 8732 50 but but CC 40436 8732 51 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 8732 52 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8732 53 in in IN 40436 8732 54 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8732 55 's 's POS 40436 8732 56 own own JJ 40436 8732 57 mind mind NN 40436 8732 58 , , , 40436 8732 59 and and CC 40436 8732 60 only only RB 40436 8732 61 negatively negatively RB 40436 8732 62 determined determine VBN 40436 8732 63 by by IN 40436 8732 64 this this DT 40436 8732 65 circumstance circumstance NN 40436 8732 66 -- -- : 40436 8732 67 That that IN 40436 8732 68 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8732 69 have have VBP 40436 8732 70 no no DT 40436 8732 71 reference reference NN 40436 8732 72 either either RB 40436 8732 73 to to TO 40436 8732 74 pleasure pleasure VB 40436 8732 75 or or CC 40436 8732 76 pain pain VB 40436 8732 77 . . . 40436 8733 1 In in IN 40436 8733 2 the the DT 40436 8733 3 vulgar vulgar JJ 40436 8733 4 sense sense NN 40436 8733 5 , , , 40436 8733 6 Good Good NNP 40436 8733 7 stands stand VBZ 40436 8733 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 8733 9 from from IN 40436 8733 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8733 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8733 12 or or CC 40436 8733 13 relief relief NN 40436 8733 14 from from IN 40436 8733 15 pain pain NN 40436 8733 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8733 17 , , , 40436 8733 18 and and CC 40436 8733 19 Evil evil NN 40436 8733 20 from from IN 40436 8733 21 pain pain NN 40436 8733 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8733 23 or or CC 40436 8733 24 loss loss NN 40436 8733 25 of of IN 40436 8733 26 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 8733 27 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8733 28 , , , 40436 8733 29 as as IN 40436 8733 30 the the DT 40436 8733 31 remote remote NN 40436 8733 32 , , , 40436 8733 33 the the DT 40436 8733 34 causal causal NN 40436 8733 35 , , , 40436 8733 36 the the DT 40436 8733 37 lasting lasting JJ 40436 8733 38 from from IN 40436 8733 39 the the DT 40436 8733 40 present present NN 40436 8733 41 , , , 40436 8733 42 the the DT 40436 8733 43 product product NN 40436 8733 44 , , , 40436 8733 45 the the DT 40436 8733 46 transient transient NN 40436 8733 47 . . . 40436 8734 1 Good good JJ 40436 8734 2 and and CC 40436 8734 3 Evil Evil NNP 40436 8734 4 are be VBP 40436 8734 5 explained explain VBN 40436 8734 6 by by IN 40436 8734 7 enumerating enumerate VBG 40436 8734 8 all all PDT 40436 8734 9 the the DT 40436 8734 10 things thing NNS 40436 8734 11 so so RB 40436 8734 12 called call VBN 40436 8734 13 , , , 40436 8734 14 of of IN 40436 8734 15 which which WDT 40436 8734 16 enumeration enumeration NN 40436 8734 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8734 18 gives give VBZ 40436 8734 19 a a DT 40436 8734 20 partial partial JJ 40436 8734 21 specimen speciman NNS 40436 8734 22 in in IN 40436 8734 23 this this DT 40436 8734 24 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8734 25 : : : 40436 8734 26 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 8734 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8734 28 dwells dwell VBZ 40436 8734 29 upon upon IN 40436 8734 30 what what WP 40436 8734 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8734 32 calls call VBZ 40436 8734 33 the the DT 40436 8734 34 Idea Idea NNP 40436 8734 35 of of IN 40436 8734 36 Good good JJ 40436 8734 37 , , , 40436 8734 38 of of IN 40436 8734 39 which which WDT 40436 8734 40 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8734 41 shall shall MD 40436 8734 42 speak speak VB 40436 8734 43 more more RBR 40436 8734 44 fully fully RB 40436 8734 45 hereafter hereaft JJR 40436 8734 46 . . . 40436 8735 1 Having have VBG 40436 8735 2 said say VBN 40436 8735 3 that that IN 40436 8735 4 all all DT 40436 8735 5 men man NNS 40436 8735 6 aim aim VBP 40436 8735 7 at at IN 40436 8735 8 good good NN 40436 8735 9 , , , 40436 8735 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8735 11 gives give VBZ 40436 8735 12 , , , 40436 8735 13 as as IN 40436 8735 14 examples example NNS 40436 8735 15 of of IN 40436 8735 16 good good JJ 40436 8735 17 things thing NNS 40436 8735 18 -- -- : 40436 8735 19 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 40436 8735 20 , , , 40436 8735 21 Health Health NNP 40436 8735 22 , , , 40436 8735 23 Wealth Wealth NNP 40436 8735 24 , , , 40436 8735 25 and and CC 40436 8735 26 other other JJ 40436 8735 27 such such JJ 40436 8735 28 things thing NNS 40436 8735 29 : : : 40436 8735 30 while while IN 40436 8735 31 the the DT 40436 8735 32 contrary contrary NN 40436 8735 33 of of IN 40436 8735 34 these these DT 40436 8735 35 , , , 40436 8735 36 Stupidity Stupidity NNP 40436 8735 37 , , , 40436 8735 38 Sickness Sickness NNP 40436 8735 39 , , , 40436 8735 40 Poverty Poverty NNP 40436 8735 41 , , , 40436 8735 42 are be VBP 40436 8735 43 evil evil JJ 40436 8735 44 things thing NNS 40436 8735 45 : : : 40436 8735 46 the the DT 40436 8735 47 list list NN 40436 8735 48 of of IN 40436 8735 49 course course NN 40436 8735 50 might may MD 40436 8735 51 be be VB 40436 8735 52 much much RB 40436 8735 53 enlarged enlarge VBN 40436 8735 54 . . . 40436 8736 1 Taking take VBG 40436 8736 2 Good Good NNP 40436 8736 3 and and CC 40436 8736 4 Evil Evil NNP 40436 8736 5 generally generally RB 40436 8736 6 to to TO 40436 8736 7 denote denote VB 40436 8736 8 the the DT 40436 8736 9 common common JJ 40436 8736 10 property property NN 40436 8736 11 of of IN 40436 8736 12 each each DT 40436 8736 13 of of IN 40436 8736 14 these these DT 40436 8736 15 lists list NNS 40436 8736 16 , , , 40436 8736 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8736 18 is be VBZ 40436 8736 19 true true JJ 40436 8736 20 that that IN 40436 8736 21 men man NNS 40436 8736 22 perform perform VBP 40436 8736 23 a a DT 40436 8736 24 large large JJ 40436 8736 25 portion portion NN 40436 8736 26 of of IN 40436 8736 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8736 28 acts act NNS 40436 8736 29 with with IN 40436 8736 30 a a DT 40436 8736 31 view view NN 40436 8736 32 to to TO 40436 8736 33 attain attain VB 40436 8736 34 the the DT 40436 8736 35 former former JJ 40436 8736 36 and and CC 40436 8736 37 avoid avoid VB 40436 8736 38 the the DT 40436 8736 39 latter:--that latter:--that CD 40436 8736 40 the the DT 40436 8736 41 approach approach NN 40436 8736 42 which which WDT 40436 8736 43 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8736 44 make make VBP 40436 8736 45 to to TO 40436 8736 46 happiness happiness VB 40436 8736 47 depends depend VBZ 40436 8736 48 , , , 40436 8736 49 speaking speak VBG 40436 8736 50 generally generally RB 40436 8736 51 , , , 40436 8736 52 upon upon IN 40436 8736 53 the the DT 40436 8736 54 success success NN 40436 8736 55 which which WDT 40436 8736 56 attends attend VBZ 40436 8736 57 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8736 58 exertions exertion NNS 40436 8736 59 for for IN 40436 8736 60 the the DT 40436 8736 61 attainment attainment NN 40436 8736 62 of of IN 40436 8736 63 and and CC 40436 8736 64 avoidance avoidance NN 40436 8736 65 of of IN 40436 8736 66 these these DT 40436 8736 67 permanent permanent JJ 40436 8736 68 ends end NNS 40436 8736 69 : : : 40436 8736 70 and and CC 40436 8736 71 moreover moreover RB 40436 8736 72 that that IN 40436 8736 73 these these DT 40436 8736 74 ends end NNS 40436 8736 75 have have VBP 40436 8736 76 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8736 77 ultimate ultimate JJ 40436 8736 78 reference reference NN 40436 8736 79 to to IN 40436 8736 80 each each DT 40436 8736 81 man man NN 40436 8736 82 's 's POS 40436 8736 83 own own JJ 40436 8736 84 feelings feeling NNS 40436 8736 85 . . . 40436 8737 1 But but CC 40436 8737 2 this this DT 40436 8737 3 meaning meaning NN 40436 8737 4 of of IN 40436 8737 5 Good good JJ 40436 8737 6 is be VBZ 40436 8737 7 no no RB 40436 8737 8 longer long RBR 40436 8737 9 preserved preserve VBN 40436 8737 10 , , , 40436 8737 11 when when WRB 40436 8737 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8737 13 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 8737 14 to to TO 40436 8737 15 prove prove VB 40436 8737 16 that that IN 40436 8737 17 the the DT 40436 8737 18 triumphant triumphant NN 40436 8737 19 usurper usurper NN 40436 8737 20 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8737 21 is be VBZ 40436 8737 22 the the DT 40436 8737 23 most most RBS 40436 8737 24 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8737 25 of of IN 40436 8737 26 men man NNS 40436 8737 27 , , , 40436 8737 28 and and CC 40436 8737 29 that that DT 40436 8737 30 to to TO 40436 8737 31 do do VB 40436 8737 32 wrong wrong NN 40436 8737 33 with with IN 40436 8737 34 impunity impunity NN 40436 8737 35 is be VBZ 40436 8737 36 the the DT 40436 8737 37 greatest great JJS 40436 8737 38 of of IN 40436 8737 39 all all DT 40436 8737 40 evils evil NNS 40436 8737 41 . . . 40436 8738 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8738 2 Side side NN 40436 8738 3 - - HYPH 40436 8738 4 note note NN 40436 8738 5 : : : 40436 8738 6 Examination examination NN 40436 8738 7 of of IN 40436 8738 8 the the DT 40436 8738 9 proof proof NN 40436 8738 10 given give VBN 40436 8738 11 by by IN 40436 8738 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8738 13 -- -- : 40436 8738 14 Inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 8738 15 between between IN 40436 8738 16 the the DT 40436 8738 17 general general JJ 40436 8738 18 answer answer NN 40436 8738 19 of of IN 40436 8738 20 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8738 21 and and CC 40436 8738 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8738 23 previous previous JJ 40436 8738 24 declarations declaration NNS 40436 8738 25 -- -- : 40436 8738 26 Law Law NNP 40436 8738 27 and and CC 40436 8738 28 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8738 29 . . . 40436 8738 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8739 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8739 2 provides provide VBZ 40436 8739 3 a a DT 40436 8739 4 basis basis NN 40436 8739 5 for for IN 40436 8739 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8739 7 intended intend VBN 40436 8739 8 proof proof NN 40436 8739 9 by by IN 40436 8739 10 asking ask VBG 40436 8739 11 Polus,[45 Polus,[45 NNP 40436 8739 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8739 13 which which WDT 40436 8739 14 of of IN 40436 8739 15 the the DT 40436 8739 16 two two CD 40436 8739 17 is be VBZ 40436 8739 18 most most RBS 40436 8739 19 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8739 20 -- -- : 40436 8739 21 To to TO 40436 8739 22 do do VB 40436 8739 23 wrong wrong NN 40436 8739 24 -- -- : 40436 8739 25 or or CC 40436 8739 26 to to TO 40436 8739 27 suffer suffer VB 40436 8739 28 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8739 29 ? ? . 40436 8740 1 Polus polus JJ 40436 8740 2 answers answer NNS 40436 8740 3 -- -- : 40436 8740 4 To to TO 40436 8740 5 do do VB 40436 8740 6 wrong wrong NN 40436 8740 7 : : : 40436 8740 8 and and CC 40436 8740 9 this this DT 40436 8740 10 answer answer NN 40436 8740 11 is be VBZ 40436 8740 12 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 8740 13 with with IN 40436 8740 14 what what WP 40436 8740 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8740 16 had have VBD 40436 8740 17 previously previously RB 40436 8740 18 said say VBN 40436 8740 19 about about IN 40436 8740 20 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8740 21 . . . 40436 8741 1 That that DT 40436 8741 2 prince prince NN 40436 8741 3 , , , 40436 8741 4 though though IN 40436 8741 5 a a DT 40436 8741 6 wrong wrong NN 40436 8741 7 - - HYPH 40436 8741 8 doer doer NN 40436 8741 9 on on IN 40436 8741 10 the the DT 40436 8741 11 largest large JJS 40436 8741 12 scale scale NN 40436 8741 13 , , , 40436 8741 14 has have VBZ 40436 8741 15 been be VBN 40436 8741 16 declared declare VBN 40436 8741 17 by by IN 40436 8741 18 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8741 19 to to TO 40436 8741 20 be be VB 40436 8741 21 an an DT 40436 8741 22 object object NN 40436 8741 23 of of IN 40436 8741 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8741 25 supreme supreme NNP 40436 8741 26 envy envy NNP 40436 8741 27 and and CC 40436 8741 28 admiration admiration NN 40436 8741 29 : : : 40436 8741 30 while while IN 40436 8741 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8741 32 also also RB 40436 8741 33 admits admit VBZ 40436 8741 34 that that IN 40436 8741 35 this this DT 40436 8741 36 is be VBZ 40436 8741 37 the the DT 40436 8741 38 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8741 39 of of IN 40436 8741 40 almost almost RB 40436 8741 41 all all DT 40436 8741 42 mankind mankind NN 40436 8741 43 , , , 40436 8741 44 except except IN 40436 8741 45 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8741 46 . . . 40436 8742 1 To to TO 40436 8742 2 be be VB 40436 8742 3 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8742 4 with with IN 40436 8742 5 such such PDT 40436 8742 6 an an DT 40436 8742 7 assertion assertion NN 40436 8742 8 , , , 40436 8742 9 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8742 10 ought ought MD 40436 8742 11 to to TO 40436 8742 12 have have VB 40436 8742 13 answered answer VBN 40436 8742 14 the the DT 40436 8742 15 contrary contrary NN 40436 8742 16 of of IN 40436 8742 17 what what WP 40436 8742 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8742 19 does do VBZ 40436 8742 20 answer answer VB 40436 8742 21 , , , 40436 8742 22 when when WRB 40436 8742 23 the the DT 40436 8742 24 general general JJ 40436 8742 25 question question NN 40436 8742 26 is be VBZ 40436 8742 27 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 8742 28 put put VBN 40436 8742 29 to to IN 40436 8742 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8742 31 : : : 40436 8742 32 or or CC 40436 8742 33 at at IN 40436 8742 34 least least JJS 40436 8742 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8742 36 ought ought MD 40436 8742 37 to to TO 40436 8742 38 have have VB 40436 8742 39 said--"Sometimes said--"sometime NNS 40436 8742 40 the the DT 40436 8742 41 one one NN 40436 8742 42 , , , 40436 8742 43 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 8742 44 the the DT 40436 8742 45 other other JJ 40436 8742 46 " " '' 40436 8742 47 . . . 40436 8743 1 But but CC 40436 8743 2 this this DT 40436 8743 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8743 4 is be VBZ 40436 8743 5 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 8743 6 to to TO 40436 8743 7 do do VB 40436 8743 8 , , , 40436 8743 9 as as IN 40436 8743 10 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8743 11 shall shall MD 40436 8743 12 find find VB 40436 8743 13 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8743 14 intimating intimate VBG 40436 8743 15 at at IN 40436 8743 16 a a DT 40436 8743 17 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 8743 18 stage stage NN 40436 8743 19 of of IN 40436 8743 20 the the DT 40436 8743 21 dialogue:[46 dialogue:[46 NNP 40436 8743 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8743 23 because because IN 40436 8743 24 of of IN 40436 8743 25 King King NNP 40436 8743 26 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 8743 27 , , , 40436 8743 28 or or CC 40436 8743 29 the the DT 40436 8743 30 established establish VBN 40436 8743 31 habit habit NN 40436 8743 32 of of IN 40436 8743 33 the the DT 40436 8743 34 community community NN 40436 8743 35 -- -- : 40436 8743 36 who who WP 40436 8743 37 feel feel VBP 40436 8743 38 that that IN 40436 8743 39 society society NN 40436 8743 40 rests rest VBZ 40436 8743 41 upon upon IN 40436 8743 42 a a DT 40436 8743 43 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8743 44 of of IN 40436 8743 45 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 8743 46 right right NN 40436 8743 47 and and CC 40436 8743 48 obligation obligation NN 40436 8743 49 animating animate VBG 40436 8743 50 every every DT 40436 8743 51 one one CD 40436 8743 52 , , , 40436 8743 53 and and CC 40436 8743 54 require require VBP 40436 8743 55 that that IN 40436 8743 56 violations violation NNS 40436 8743 57 of of IN 40436 8743 58 that that DT 40436 8743 59 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8743 60 shall shall MD 40436 8743 61 be be VB 40436 8743 62 marked mark VBN 40436 8743 63 with with IN 40436 8743 64 censure censure NN 40436 8743 65 in in IN 40436 8743 66 general general JJ 40436 8743 67 words word NNS 40436 8743 68 , , , 40436 8743 69 however however RB 40436 8743 70 widely widely RB 40436 8743 71 the the DT 40436 8743 72 critical critical JJ 40436 8743 73 feeling feeling NN 40436 8743 74 may may MD 40436 8743 75 depart depart VB 40436 8743 76 from from IN 40436 8743 77 such such JJ 40436 8743 78 censure censure NN 40436 8743 79 in in IN 40436 8743 80 particular particular JJ 40436 8743 81 cases case NNS 40436 8743 82 . . . 40436 8744 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8744 2 47 47 CD 40436 8744 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8744 4 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8744 5 is be VBZ 40436 8744 6 forced force VBN 40436 8744 7 to to TO 40436 8744 8 make make VB 40436 8744 9 profession profession NN 40436 8744 10 of of IN 40436 8744 11 a a DT 40436 8744 12 faith faith NN 40436 8744 13 , , , 40436 8744 14 which which WDT 40436 8744 15 neither neither CC 40436 8744 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8744 17 nor nor CC 40436 8744 18 others other NNS 40436 8744 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8744 20 except except IN 40436 8744 21 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8744 22 with with IN 40436 8744 23 a a DT 40436 8744 24 few few JJ 40436 8744 25 companions companion NNS 40436 8744 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8744 27 universally universally RB 40436 8744 28 or or CC 40436 8744 29 consistently consistently RB 40436 8744 30 apply apply VB 40436 8744 31 . . . 40436 8745 1 To to TO 40436 8745 2 bring bring VB 40436 8745 3 such such PDT 40436 8745 4 a a DT 40436 8745 5 force force NN 40436 8745 6 to to TO 40436 8745 7 bear bear VB 40436 8745 8 upon upon IN 40436 8745 9 the the DT 40436 8745 10 opponent opponent NN 40436 8745 11 , , , 40436 8745 12 was be VBD 40436 8745 13 one one CD 40436 8745 14 of of IN 40436 8745 15 the the DT 40436 8745 16 known know VBN 40436 8745 17 artifices artifice NNS 40436 8745 18 of of IN 40436 8745 19 dialecticians:[48 dialecticians:[48 NN 40436 8745 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8745 21 and and CC 40436 8745 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8745 23 makes make VBZ 40436 8745 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8745 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8745 26 point point NN 40436 8745 27 of of IN 40436 8745 28 departure departure NN 40436 8745 29 , , , 40436 8745 30 to to TO 40436 8745 31 prove prove VB 40436 8745 32 the the DT 40436 8745 33 unparalleled unparalleled JJ 40436 8745 34 misery misery NN 40436 8745 35 of of IN 40436 8745 36 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8745 37 . . . 40436 8746 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8746 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8746 3 45 45 CD 40436 8746 4 : : : 40436 8746 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 8746 6 . . . 40436 8747 1 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 8747 2 . . . 40436 8748 1 p. p. NN 40436 8748 2 474 474 CD 40436 8748 3 C. C. NNP 40436 8748 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8748 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8748 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8748 7 46 46 CD 40436 8748 8 : : : 40436 8748 9 Plat Plat NNP 40436 8748 10 . . . 40436 8749 1 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 8749 2 . . . 40436 8750 1 p. p. NN 40436 8750 2 482 482 CD 40436 8750 3 C. C. NNP 40436 8750 4 To to TO 40436 8750 5 maintain maintain VB 40436 8750 6 that that IN 40436 8750 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8750 8 Greek greek JJ 40436 8750 9 : : : 40436 8750 10 to\ to\ NN 40436 8750 11 a)dikei a)dikei NNS 40436 8750 12 = = NFP 40436 8750 13 n n CC 40436 8750 14 be be VB 40436 8750 15 / / SYM 40436 8750 16 ltion ltion NN 40436 8750 17 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8750 18 a)dikei a)dikei NNP 40436 8750 19 = = SYM 40436 8750 20 sthai sthai NNP 40436 8750 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8750 22 was be VBD 40436 8750 23 an an DT 40436 8750 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8750 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8750 26 : : : 40436 8750 27 a)/doxos a)/doxos NNP 40436 8750 28 u(po u(po NNP 40436 8750 29 / / SYM 40436 8750 30 thesis]--one thesis]--one NN 40436 8750 31 which which WDT 40436 8750 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8750 33 was be VBD 40436 8750 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8750 35 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8750 36 : : : 40436 8750 37 chei chei NN 40436 8750 38 / / SYM 40436 8750 39 ronos ronos NN 40436 8750 40 ê)/thous ê)/thous JJ 40436 8750 41 e(le e(le NNP 40436 8750 42 / / SYM 40436 8750 43 sthai sthai NNP 40436 8750 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8750 45 : : : 40436 8750 46 which which WDT 40436 8750 47 therefore therefore RB 40436 8750 48 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8750 49 advises advise VBZ 40436 8750 50 the the DT 40436 8750 51 dialectician dialectician NN 40436 8750 52 not not RB 40436 8750 53 to to TO 40436 8750 54 defend defend VB 40436 8750 55 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8750 56 Aristot Aristot NNP 40436 8750 57 . . . 40436 8751 1 Topic topic NN 40436 8751 2 . . . 40436 8752 1 viii viii RB 40436 8752 2 . . . 40436 8753 1 156 156 CD 40436 8753 2 , , , 40436 8753 3 6 6 CD 40436 8753 4 - - SYM 40436 8753 5 15 15 CD 40436 8753 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8753 7 . . . 40436 8753 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8754 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8754 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8754 3 47 47 CD 40436 8754 4 : : : 40436 8754 5 This this DT 40436 8754 6 portion portion NN 40436 8754 7 of of IN 40436 8754 8 the the DT 40436 8754 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8754 10 may may MD 40436 8754 11 receive receive VB 40436 8754 12 illustration illustration NN 40436 8754 13 from from IN 40436 8754 14 the the DT 40436 8754 15 third third JJ 40436 8754 16 chapter chapter NN 40436 8754 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8754 18 pp pp NNP 40436 8754 19 . . . 40436 8755 1 99 99 CD 40436 8755 2 - - SYM 40436 8755 3 101 101 CD 40436 8755 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8755 5 of of IN 40436 8755 6 Adam Adam NNP 40436 8755 7 Smith Smith NNP 40436 8755 8 's 's POS 40436 8755 9 Theory Theory NNP 40436 8755 10 of of IN 40436 8755 11 Moral Moral NNP 40436 8755 12 Sentiments Sentiments NNPS 40436 8755 13 , , , 40436 8755 14 entitled entitle VBN 40436 8755 15 , , , 40436 8755 16 " " `` 40436 8755 17 Of of IN 40436 8755 18 the the DT 40436 8755 19 corruption corruption NN 40436 8755 20 of of IN 40436 8755 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8755 22 moral moral JJ 40436 8755 23 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8755 24 , , , 40436 8755 25 which which WDT 40436 8755 26 is be VBZ 40436 8755 27 occasioned occasion VBN 40436 8755 28 by by IN 40436 8755 29 the the DT 40436 8755 30 disposition disposition NN 40436 8755 31 to to TO 40436 8755 32 admire admire VB 40436 8755 33 the the DT 40436 8755 34 rich rich JJ 40436 8755 35 and and CC 40436 8755 36 great great JJ 40436 8755 37 , , , 40436 8755 38 and and CC 40436 8755 39 to to TO 40436 8755 40 neglect neglect VB 40436 8755 41 or or CC 40436 8755 42 despise despise VB 40436 8755 43 persons person NNS 40436 8755 44 of of IN 40436 8755 45 poor poor JJ 40436 8755 46 and and CC 40436 8755 47 mean mean VB 40436 8755 48 condition condition NN 40436 8755 49 " " '' 40436 8755 50 . . . 40436 8756 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8756 2 says--"The says--"The VBZ 40436 8756 3 disposition disposition NN 40436 8756 4 to to TO 40436 8756 5 admire admire NN 40436 8756 6 and and CC 40436 8756 7 almost almost RB 40436 8756 8 to to TO 40436 8756 9 worship worship VB 40436 8756 10 the the DT 40436 8756 11 rich rich JJ 40436 8756 12 and and CC 40436 8756 13 the the DT 40436 8756 14 powerful powerful JJ 40436 8756 15 , , , 40436 8756 16 and and CC 40436 8756 17 to to TO 40436 8756 18 despise despise VB 40436 8756 19 , , , 40436 8756 20 or or CC 40436 8756 21 at at IN 40436 8756 22 least least JJS 40436 8756 23 to to TO 40436 8756 24 neglect neglect VB 40436 8756 25 , , , 40436 8756 26 persons person NNS 40436 8756 27 of of IN 40436 8756 28 poor poor JJ 40436 8756 29 and and CC 40436 8756 30 mean mean JJ 40436 8756 31 condition condition NN 40436 8756 32 , , , 40436 8756 33 though though IN 40436 8756 34 necessary necessary JJ 40436 8756 35 both both DT 40436 8756 36 to to TO 40436 8756 37 establish establish VB 40436 8756 38 and and CC 40436 8756 39 maintain maintain VB 40436 8756 40 the the DT 40436 8756 41 distinction distinction NN 40436 8756 42 of of IN 40436 8756 43 ranks rank NNS 40436 8756 44 and and CC 40436 8756 45 the the DT 40436 8756 46 order order NN 40436 8756 47 of of IN 40436 8756 48 society society NN 40436 8756 49 , , , 40436 8756 50 is be VBZ 40436 8756 51 , , , 40436 8756 52 at at IN 40436 8756 53 the the DT 40436 8756 54 same same JJ 40436 8756 55 time time NN 40436 8756 56 , , , 40436 8756 57 the the DT 40436 8756 58 great great JJ 40436 8756 59 and and CC 40436 8756 60 most most RBS 40436 8756 61 universal universal JJ 40436 8756 62 cause cause NN 40436 8756 63 of of IN 40436 8756 64 the the DT 40436 8756 65 corruption corruption NN 40436 8756 66 of of IN 40436 8756 67 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8756 68 moral moral JJ 40436 8756 69 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8756 70 . . . 40436 8757 1 . . . 40436 8758 1 . . . 40436 8759 1 . . . 40436 8760 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 8760 2 are be VBP 40436 8760 3 the the DT 40436 8760 4 wise wise JJ 40436 8760 5 and and CC 40436 8760 6 the the DT 40436 8760 7 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 8760 8 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 8760 9 -- -- : 40436 8760 10 a a DT 40436 8760 11 select select NN 40436 8760 12 , , , 40436 8760 13 though though IN 40436 8760 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8760 15 am be VBP 40436 8760 16 afraid afraid JJ 40436 8760 17 , , , 40436 8760 18 a a DT 40436 8760 19 small small JJ 40436 8760 20 party party NN 40436 8760 21 -- -- : 40436 8760 22 who who WP 40436 8760 23 are be VBP 40436 8760 24 the the DT 40436 8760 25 real real JJ 40436 8760 26 and and CC 40436 8760 27 steady steady JJ 40436 8760 28 admirers admirer NNS 40436 8760 29 of of IN 40436 8760 30 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 8760 31 and and CC 40436 8760 32 virtue virtue NN 40436 8760 33 . . . 40436 8761 1 The the DT 40436 8761 2 great great JJ 40436 8761 3 mob mob NN 40436 8761 4 of of IN 40436 8761 5 mankind mankind NN 40436 8761 6 are be VBP 40436 8761 7 the the DT 40436 8761 8 admirers admirer NNS 40436 8761 9 and and CC 40436 8761 10 worshippers worshipper NNS 40436 8761 11 -- -- : 40436 8761 12 and and CC 40436 8761 13 what what WP 40436 8761 14 may may MD 40436 8761 15 seem seem VB 40436 8761 16 more more RBR 40436 8761 17 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 40436 8761 18 , , , 40436 8761 19 most most RBS 40436 8761 20 frequently frequently RB 40436 8761 21 the the DT 40436 8761 22 disinterested disintereste VBN 40436 8761 23 admirers admirer NNS 40436 8761 24 and and CC 40436 8761 25 worshippers worshipper NNS 40436 8761 26 -- -- : 40436 8761 27 of of IN 40436 8761 28 wealth wealth NN 40436 8761 29 and and CC 40436 8761 30 greatness greatness NN 40436 8761 31 . . . 40436 8762 1 . . . 40436 8763 1 . . . 40436 8764 1 . . . 40436 8765 1 . . . 40436 8766 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8766 2 is be VBZ 40436 8766 3 scarce scarce JJ 40436 8766 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8766 5 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8766 6 to to IN 40436 8766 7 good good JJ 40436 8766 8 morals moral NNS 40436 8766 9 _ _ NNP 40436 8766 10 , , , 40436 8766 11 or or CC 40436 8766 12 even even RB 40436 8766 13 to to IN 40436 8766 14 good good JJ 40436 8766 15 language language NN 40436 8766 16 , , , 40436 8766 17 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 8766 18 , , , 40436 8766 19 to to TO 40436 8766 20 say say VB 40436 8766 21 that that IN 40436 8766 22 mere mere JJ 40436 8766 23 wealth wealth NN 40436 8766 24 and and CC 40436 8766 25 greatness greatness NN 40436 8766 26 , , , 40436 8766 27 abstracted abstract VBN 40436 8766 28 from from IN 40436 8766 29 merit merit NN 40436 8766 30 and and CC 40436 8766 31 virtue virtue NN 40436 8766 32 , , , 40436 8766 33 deserve deserve VBP 40436 8766 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8766 35 respect respect NN 40436 8766 36 . . . 40436 8767 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8767 2 must must MD 40436 8767 3 acknowledge acknowledge VB 40436 8767 4 , , , 40436 8767 5 however however RB 40436 8767 6 , , , 40436 8767 7 that that IN 40436 8767 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8767 9 _ _ VBP 40436 8767 10 almost almost RB 40436 8767 11 constantly constantly RB 40436 8767 12 obtain obtain VBP 40436 8767 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8767 14 _ _ NNP 40436 8767 15 : : : 40436 8767 16 and and CC 40436 8767 17 _ _ NNP 40436 8767 18 that that IN 40436 8767 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8767 20 may may MD 40436 8767 21 therefore therefore RB 40436 8767 22 in in IN 40436 8767 23 a a DT 40436 8767 24 certain certain JJ 40436 8767 25 sense sense NN 40436 8767 26 be be VB 40436 8767 27 considered consider VBN 40436 8767 28 as as IN 40436 8767 29 the the DT 40436 8767 30 natural natural JJ 40436 8767 31 objects object NNS 40436 8767 32 of of IN 40436 8767 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8767 34 _ _ NNP 40436 8767 35 . . . 40436 8767 36 " " '' 40436 8768 1 Now now RB 40436 8768 2 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8768 3 is be VBZ 40436 8768 4 a a DT 40436 8768 5 most most RBS 40436 8768 6 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 8768 7 example example NN 40436 8768 8 of of IN 40436 8768 9 this this DT 40436 8768 10 disposition disposition NN 40436 8768 11 of of IN 40436 8768 12 the the DT 40436 8768 13 mass mass NN 40436 8768 14 of of IN 40436 8768 15 mankind mankind NN 40436 8768 16 to to TO 40436 8768 17 worship worship VB 40436 8768 18 and and CC 40436 8768 19 admire admire VB 40436 8768 20 , , , 40436 8768 21 disinterestedly disinterestedly RB 40436 8768 22 , , , 40436 8768 23 power power NN 40436 8768 24 and and CC 40436 8768 25 greatness greatness NN 40436 8768 26 : : : 40436 8768 27 and and CC 40436 8768 28 the the DT 40436 8768 29 language language NN 40436 8768 30 used use VBN 40436 8768 31 by by IN 40436 8768 32 Adam Adam NNP 40436 8768 33 Smith Smith NNP 40436 8768 34 in in IN 40436 8768 35 the the DT 40436 8768 36 last last JJ 40436 8768 37 sentence sentence NN 40436 8768 38 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40436 8768 39 the the DT 40436 8768 40 conversation conversation NN 40436 8768 41 of of IN 40436 8768 42 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8768 43 , , , 40436 8768 44 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8768 45 , , , 40436 8768 46 and and CC 40436 8768 47 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8768 48 . . . 40436 8769 1 Adam Adam NNP 40436 8769 2 Smith Smith NNP 40436 8769 3 admits admit VBZ 40436 8769 4 that that IN 40436 8769 5 energetic energetic JJ 40436 8769 6 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 8769 7 , , , 40436 8769 8 ending end VBG 40436 8769 9 in in IN 40436 8769 10 great great JJ 40436 8769 11 power power NN 40436 8769 12 , , , 40436 8769 13 such such JJ 40436 8769 14 as as IN 40436 8769 15 those those DT 40436 8769 16 of of IN 40436 8769 17 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8769 18 , , , 40436 8769 19 obtain obtain VB 40436 8769 20 honour honour NN 40436 8769 21 and and CC 40436 8769 22 worship worship VB 40436 8769 23 from from IN 40436 8769 24 the the DT 40436 8769 25 vast vast JJ 40436 8769 26 majority majority NN 40436 8769 27 of of IN 40436 8769 28 disinterested disintereste VBN 40436 8769 29 spectators spectator NNS 40436 8769 30 : : : 40436 8769 31 and and CC 40436 8769 32 that that IN 40436 8769 33 , , , 40436 8769 34 therefore therefore RB 40436 8769 35 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8769 36 are be VBP 40436 8769 37 in in IN 40436 8769 38 a a DT 40436 8769 39 certain certain JJ 40436 8769 40 sense sense NN 40436 8769 41 the the DT 40436 8769 42 _ _ NNP 40436 8769 43 natural natural JJ 40436 8769 44 objects object NNS 40436 8769 45 _ _ NNP 40436 8769 46 of of IN 40436 8769 47 such such PDT 40436 8769 48 a a DT 40436 8769 49 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8769 50 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8769 51 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8769 52 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8769 53 : : : 40436 8769 54 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 8769 55 phu phu NNP 40436 8769 56 / / SYM 40436 8769 57 sin sin NN 40436 8769 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8769 59 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8769 60 . . . 40436 8770 1 But but CC 40436 8770 2 if if IN 40436 8770 3 the the DT 40436 8770 4 question question NN 40436 8770 5 be be VB 40436 8770 6 put put VBN 40436 8770 7 to to IN 40436 8770 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8770 9 , , , 40436 8770 10 Whether whether IN 40436 8770 11 such such JJ 40436 8770 12 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 8770 13 , , , 40436 8770 14 with with IN 40436 8770 15 such such PDT 40436 8770 16 a a DT 40436 8770 17 position position NN 40436 8770 18 , , , 40436 8770 19 are be VBP 40436 8770 20 _ _ NNP 40436 8770 21 worthy worthy JJ 40436 8770 22 of of IN 40436 8770 23 honour honour NN 40436 8770 24 _ _ NNP 40436 8770 25 , , , 40436 8770 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8770 27 is be VBZ 40436 8770 28 constrained constrain VBN 40436 8770 29 by by IN 40436 8770 30 good good JJ 40436 8770 31 morals moral NNS 40436 8770 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8770 33 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8770 34 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8770 35 : : : 40436 8770 36 kata\ kata\ NFP 40436 8770 37 no no DT 40436 8770 38 / / SYM 40436 8770 39 mon mon NN 40436 8770 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8770 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8770 42 to to TO 40436 8770 43 reply reply VB 40436 8770 44 in in IN 40436 8770 45 the the DT 40436 8770 46 negative negative NN 40436 8770 47 . . . 40436 8771 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8771 2 is be VBZ 40436 8771 3 true true JJ 40436 8771 4 that that IN 40436 8771 5 Adam Adam NNP 40436 8771 6 Smith Smith NNP 40436 8771 7 numbers number VBZ 40436 8771 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8771 9 with with IN 40436 8771 10 the the DT 40436 8771 11 small small JJ 40436 8771 12 minority minority NN 40436 8771 13 , , , 40436 8771 14 while while IN 40436 8771 15 Polus polus JJ 40436 8771 16 shares share VBZ 40436 8771 17 the the DT 40436 8771 18 opinion opinion NN 40436 8771 19 of of IN 40436 8771 20 the the DT 40436 8771 21 large large JJ 40436 8771 22 majority majority NN 40436 8771 23 . . . 40436 8772 1 But but CC 40436 8772 2 what what WP 40436 8772 3 is be VBZ 40436 8772 4 required require VBN 40436 8772 5 by by IN 40436 8772 6 King King NNP 40436 8772 7 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 8772 8 must must MD 40436 8772 9 be be VB 40436 8772 10 professed profess VBN 40436 8772 11 even even RB 40436 8772 12 by by IN 40436 8772 13 dissentients dissentient NNS 40436 8772 14 , , , 40436 8772 15 unless unless IN 40436 8772 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8772 17 possess possess VBP 40436 8772 18 the the DT 40436 8772 19 unbending unbend VBG 40436 8772 20 resolution resolution NN 40436 8772 21 of of IN 40436 8772 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8772 23 . . . 40436 8772 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8773 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8773 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8773 3 48 48 CD 40436 8773 4 : : : 40436 8773 5 Aristot aristot NN 40436 8773 6 . . . 40436 8774 1 De De NNP 40436 8774 2 Soph Soph NNP 40436 8774 3 . . . 40436 8775 1 Elench elench NN 40436 8775 2 . . . 40436 8776 1 pp pp NNP 40436 8776 2 . . . 40436 8777 1 172 172 CD 40436 8777 2 - - SYM 40436 8777 3 173 173 CD 40436 8777 4 , , , 40436 8777 5 where where WRB 40436 8777 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8777 7 contrasts contrast VBZ 40436 8777 8 the the DT 40436 8777 9 opinions opinion NNS 40436 8777 10 which which WDT 40436 8777 11 men man NNS 40436 8777 12 must must MD 40436 8777 13 make make VB 40436 8777 14 a a DT 40436 8777 15 show show NN 40436 8777 16 of of IN 40436 8777 17 holding holding NN 40436 8777 18 , , , 40436 8777 19 with with IN 40436 8777 20 those those DT 40436 8777 21 which which WDT 40436 8777 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8777 23 really really RB 40436 8777 24 do--[Greek do--[greek VBP 40436 8777 25 : : : 40436 8777 26 ai ai VB 40436 8777 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8777 28 phanerai\ phanerai\ NNP 40436 8777 29 do do VB 40436 8777 30 / / SYM 40436 8777 31 xai xai NNP 40436 8777 32 -- -- : 40436 8777 33 ai ai NNP 40436 8777 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8777 35 a)phanei a)phanei NNP 40436 8777 36 = = SYM 40436 8777 37 s s NNP 40436 8777 38 , , , 40436 8777 39 a)pokekrumme a)pokekrumme NNP 40436 8777 40 / / SYM 40436 8777 41 nai nai NNP 40436 8777 42 , , , 40436 8777 43 do do VB 40436 8777 44 / / SYM 40436 8777 45 xai xai NNP 40436 8777 46 . . . 40436 8777 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8777 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8778 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8778 2 Side side NN 40436 8778 3 - - HYPH 40436 8778 4 note note NN 40436 8778 5 : : : 40436 8778 6 The the DT 40436 8778 7 definition definition NN 40436 8778 8 of of IN 40436 8778 9 Pulchrum Pulchrum NNP 40436 8778 10 and and CC 40436 8778 11 Turpe Turpe NNP 40436 8778 12 , , , 40436 8778 13 given give VBN 40436 8778 14 by by IN 40436 8778 15 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8778 16 , , , 40436 8778 17 will will MD 40436 8778 18 not not RB 40436 8778 19 hold hold VB 40436 8778 20 . . . 40436 8778 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8779 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8779 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 8779 3 to to TO 40436 8779 4 define define VB 40436 8779 5 Pulchrum Pulchrum NNP 40436 8779 6 and and CC 40436 8779 7 Turpe Turpe NNP 40436 8779 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8779 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8779 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8779 11 : : : 40436 8779 12 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 8779 13 - - HYPH 40436 8779 14 ai)schro ai)schro NNP 40436 8779 15 / / SYM 40436 8779 16 n n NN 40436 8779 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8779 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8779 19 . . . 40436 8780 1 When when WRB 40436 8780 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8780 3 recollect recollect VBP 40436 8780 4 the the DT 40436 8780 5 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 8780 6 Major Major NNP 40436 8780 7 , , , 40436 8780 8 in in IN 40436 8780 9 which which WDT 40436 8780 10 dialogue dialogue VBP 40436 8780 11 many many JJ 40436 8780 12 definitions definition NNS 40436 8780 13 of of IN 40436 8780 14 Pulchrum Pulchrum NNP 40436 8780 15 were be VBD 40436 8780 16 canvassed canvass VBN 40436 8780 17 and and CC 40436 8780 18 all all DT 40436 8780 19 rejected reject VBN 40436 8780 20 , , , 40436 8780 21 so so IN 40436 8780 22 that that IN 40436 8780 23 the the DT 40436 8780 24 search search NN 40436 8780 25 ended end VBD 40436 8780 26 in in IN 40436 8780 27 total total JJ 40436 8780 28 disappointment disappointment NN 40436 8780 29 -- -- : 40436 8780 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8780 31 are be VBP 40436 8780 32 surprised surprised JJ 40436 8780 33 to to TO 40436 8780 34 see see VB 40436 8780 35 that that IN 40436 8780 36 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8780 37 hits hit VBZ 40436 8780 38 off off RP 40436 8780 39 at at IN 40436 8780 40 once once RB 40436 8780 41 a a DT 40436 8780 42 definition definition NN 40436 8780 43 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 8780 44 both both CC 40436 8780 45 to to IN 40436 8780 46 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8780 47 and and CC 40436 8780 48 Polus polus NN 40436 8780 49 : : : 40436 8780 50 and and CC 40436 8780 51 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8780 52 are be VBP 40436 8780 53 the the DT 40436 8780 54 more more RBR 40436 8780 55 surprised surprised JJ 40436 8780 56 , , , 40436 8780 57 because because IN 40436 8780 58 the the DT 40436 8780 59 definition definition NN 40436 8780 60 here here RB 40436 8780 61 admitted admit VBD 40436 8780 62 without without IN 40436 8780 63 a a DT 40436 8780 64 remark remark NN 40436 8780 65 , , , 40436 8780 66 is be VBZ 40436 8780 67 in in IN 40436 8780 68 substance substance NN 40436 8780 69 one one CD 40436 8780 70 of of IN 40436 8780 71 those those DT 40436 8780 72 shown show VBN 40436 8780 73 to to TO 40436 8780 74 be be VB 40436 8780 75 untenable untenable JJ 40436 8780 76 in in IN 40436 8780 77 the the DT 40436 8780 78 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 8780 79 Major Major NNP 40436 8780 80 . . . 40436 8781 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8781 2 49 49 CD 40436 8781 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8781 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8781 5 depends depend VBZ 40436 8781 6 upon upon IN 40436 8781 7 the the DT 40436 8781 8 actual actual JJ 40436 8781 9 argumentative argumentative JJ 40436 8781 10 purpose purpose NN 40436 8781 11 which which WDT 40436 8781 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8781 13 has have VBZ 40436 8781 14 in in IN 40436 8781 15 hand hand NN 40436 8781 16 , , , 40436 8781 17 whether whether IN 40436 8781 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8781 19 chooses choose VBZ 40436 8781 20 to to TO 40436 8781 21 multiply multiply VB 40436 8781 22 objections objection NNS 40436 8781 23 and and CC 40436 8781 24 give give VB 40436 8781 25 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8781 26 effect effect NN 40436 8781 27 -- -- : 40436 8781 28 or or CC 40436 8781 29 to to TO 40436 8781 30 ignore ignore VB 40436 8781 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8781 32 altogether altogether RB 40436 8781 33 . . . 40436 8782 1 But but CC 40436 8782 2 the the DT 40436 8782 3 definition definition NN 40436 8782 4 which which WDT 40436 8782 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8782 6 here here RB 40436 8782 7 proposes propose VBZ 40436 8782 8 , , , 40436 8782 9 even even RB 40436 8782 10 if if IN 40436 8782 11 assumed assume VBN 40436 8782 12 as as IN 40436 8782 13 incontestable incontestable JJ 40436 8782 14 , , , 40436 8782 15 fails fail VBZ 40436 8782 16 altogether altogether RB 40436 8782 17 to to TO 40436 8782 18 sustain sustain VB 40436 8782 19 the the DT 40436 8782 20 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 8782 21 that that IN 40436 8782 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8782 23 draws draw VBZ 40436 8782 24 from from IN 40436 8782 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8782 26 . . . 40436 8783 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8783 2 defines define VBZ 40436 8783 3 Pulchrum Pulchrum NNP 40436 8783 4 to to TO 40436 8783 5 be be VB 40436 8783 6 that that IN 40436 8783 7 which which WDT 40436 8783 8 either either DT 40436 8783 9 confers confer NNS 40436 8783 10 pleasure pleasure VBP 40436 8783 11 upon upon IN 40436 8783 12 the the DT 40436 8783 13 spectator spectator NN 40436 8783 14 when when WRB 40436 8783 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8783 16 contemplates contemplate VBZ 40436 8783 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8783 18 , , , 40436 8783 19 or or CC 40436 8783 20 produces produce VBZ 40436 8783 21 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 8783 22 profit profit NN 40436 8783 23 or or CC 40436 8783 24 good good NN 40436 8783 25 -- -- : 40436 8783 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8783 27 must must MD 40436 8783 28 presume presume VB 40436 8783 29 profit profit NN 40436 8783 30 to to IN 40436 8783 31 the the DT 40436 8783 32 spectator spectator NN 40436 8783 33 , , , 40436 8783 34 or or CC 40436 8783 35 to to IN 40436 8783 36 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8783 37 along along RP 40436 8783 38 with with IN 40436 8783 39 others other NNS 40436 8783 40 -- -- : 40436 8783 41 at at IN 40436 8783 42 any any DT 40436 8783 43 rate rate NN 40436 8783 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8783 45 is be VBZ 40436 8783 46 not not RB 40436 8783 47 said say VBN 40436 8783 48 _ _ NNP 40436 8783 49 to to IN 40436 8783 50 whom whom WP 40436 8783 51 _ _ NNP 40436 8783 52 . . . 40436 8784 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8784 2 next next RB 40436 8784 3 defines define VBZ 40436 8784 4 the the DT 40436 8784 5 ugly ugly JJ 40436 8784 6 and and CC 40436 8784 7 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8784 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8784 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8784 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8784 11 : : : 40436 8784 12 to\ to\ NN 40436 8784 13 ai)schro\n ai)schro\n NNP 40436 8784 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8784 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8784 16 as as IN 40436 8784 17 comprehending comprehend VBG 40436 8784 18 both both CC 40436 8784 19 the the DT 40436 8784 20 painful painful JJ 40436 8784 21 and and CC 40436 8784 22 the the DT 40436 8784 23 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 8784 24 or or CC 40436 8784 25 evil evil JJ 40436 8784 26 . . . 40436 8785 1 If if IN 40436 8785 2 then then RB 40436 8785 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8785 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8785 5 argues argue VBZ 40436 8785 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8785 7 to to TO 40436 8785 8 do do VB 40436 8785 9 wrong wrong NN 40436 8785 10 is be VBZ 40436 8785 11 more more RBR 40436 8785 12 ugly ugly JJ 40436 8785 13 and and CC 40436 8785 14 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8785 15 than than IN 40436 8785 16 to to TO 40436 8785 17 suffer suffer VB 40436 8785 18 wrong wrong NN 40436 8785 19 , , , 40436 8785 20 this this DT 40436 8785 21 must must MD 40436 8785 22 be be VB 40436 8785 23 either either CC 40436 8785 24 because because IN 40436 8785 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8785 26 is be VBZ 40436 8785 27 more more RBR 40436 8785 28 painful painful JJ 40436 8785 29 -- -- : 40436 8785 30 or or CC 40436 8785 31 because because IN 40436 8785 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8785 33 is be VBZ 40436 8785 34 more more RBR 40436 8785 35 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 8785 36 , , , 40436 8785 37 more more JJR 40436 8785 38 evil evil JJ 40436 8785 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8785 40 worse bad JJR 40436 8785 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8785 42 . . . 40436 8786 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8786 2 certainly certainly RB 40436 8786 3 is be VBZ 40436 8786 4 not not RB 40436 8786 5 more more RBR 40436 8786 6 painful painful JJ 40436 8786 7 : : : 40436 8786 8 therefore therefore RB 40436 8786 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8786 10 must must MD 40436 8786 11 be be VB 40436 8786 12 worse bad JJR 40436 8786 13 . . . 40436 8787 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8787 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8787 3 49 49 CD 40436 8787 4 : : : 40436 8787 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 8787 6 . . . 40436 8788 1 Hipp hipp UH 40436 8788 2 . . . 40436 8789 1 Maj Maj NNP 40436 8789 2 . . NNP 40436 8789 3 pp pp NNP 40436 8789 4 . . . 40436 8790 1 45 45 CD 40436 8790 2 - - SYM 40436 8790 3 46 46 CD 40436 8790 4 . . . 40436 8791 1 See see VB 40436 8791 2 above above RB 40436 8791 3 , , , 40436 8791 4 vol vol NNP 40436 8791 5 . . . 40436 8792 1 ii ii LS 40436 8792 2 . . . 40436 8793 1 ch ch NNP 40436 8793 2 . . . 40436 8794 1 xiii xiii NNP 40436 8794 2 . . . 40436 8794 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8795 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8795 2 Side side NN 40436 8795 3 - - HYPH 40436 8795 4 note note NN 40436 8795 5 : : : 40436 8795 6 Worse bad JJR 40436 8795 7 or or CC 40436 8795 8 better well RBR 40436 8795 9 -- -- : 40436 8795 10 for for IN 40436 8795 11 whom whom WP 40436 8795 12 ? ? . 40436 8796 1 The the DT 40436 8796 2 argument argument NN 40436 8796 3 of of IN 40436 8796 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8796 5 does do VBZ 40436 8796 6 not not RB 40436 8796 7 specify specify VB 40436 8796 8 . . . 40436 8797 1 If if IN 40436 8797 2 understood understand VBN 40436 8797 3 in in IN 40436 8797 4 the the DT 40436 8797 5 sense sense NN 40436 8797 6 necessary necessary JJ 40436 8797 7 for for IN 40436 8797 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8797 9 inference inference NN 40436 8797 10 , , , 40436 8797 11 the the DT 40436 8797 12 definition definition NN 40436 8797 13 would would MD 40436 8797 14 be be VB 40436 8797 15 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 8797 16 . . . 40436 8797 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8798 1 But but CC 40436 8798 2 worse worse RBR 40436 8798 3 , , , 40436 8798 4 for for IN 40436 8798 5 whom whom WP 40436 8798 6 ? ? . 40436 8799 1 For for IN 40436 8799 2 the the DT 40436 8799 3 spectators spectator NNS 40436 8799 4 , , , 40436 8799 5 who who WP 40436 8799 6 declare declare VBP 40436 8799 7 the the DT 40436 8799 8 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 8799 9 of of IN 40436 8799 10 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8799 11 to to TO 40436 8799 12 be be VB 40436 8799 13 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8799 14 ? ? . 40436 8800 1 For for IN 40436 8800 2 the the DT 40436 8800 3 persons person NNS 40436 8800 4 who who WP 40436 8800 5 suffer suffer VBP 40436 8800 6 by by IN 40436 8800 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8800 8 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 8800 9 ? ? . 40436 8801 1 Or or CC 40436 8801 2 for for IN 40436 8801 3 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8801 4 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8801 5 ? ? . 40436 8802 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8802 2 is be VBZ 40436 8802 3 the the DT 40436 8802 4 last last JJ 40436 8802 5 of of IN 40436 8802 6 the the DT 40436 8802 7 three three CD 40436 8802 8 which which WDT 40436 8802 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8802 10 undertakes undertake NNS 40436 8802 11 to to TO 40436 8802 12 prove prove VB 40436 8802 13 : : : 40436 8802 14 but but CC 40436 8802 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8802 16 definition definition NN 40436 8802 17 does do VBZ 40436 8802 18 not not RB 40436 8802 19 help help VB 40436 8802 20 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8802 21 to to IN 40436 8802 22 the the DT 40436 8802 23 proof proof NN 40436 8802 24 . . . 40436 8803 1 Turpe Turpe NNP 40436 8803 2 is be VBZ 40436 8803 3 defined define VBN 40436 8803 4 to to TO 40436 8803 5 be be VB 40436 8803 6 either either CC 40436 8803 7 what what WP 40436 8803 8 causes cause VBZ 40436 8803 9 immediate immediate JJ 40436 8803 10 pain pain NN 40436 8803 11 to to IN 40436 8803 12 the the DT 40436 8803 13 spectator spectator NN 40436 8803 14 , , , 40436 8803 15 or or CC 40436 8803 16 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 8803 17 hurt hurt NN 40436 8803 18 -- -- : 40436 8803 19 to to IN 40436 8803 20 whom whom WP 40436 8803 21 ? ? . 40436 8804 1 If if IN 40436 8804 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8804 3 say say VBP 40436 8804 4 to to IN 40436 8804 5 the the DT 40436 8804 6 spectator spectator NN 40436 8804 7 -- -- : 40436 8804 8 the the DT 40436 8804 9 definition definition NN 40436 8804 10 will will MD 40436 8804 11 not not RB 40436 8804 12 serve serve VB 40436 8804 13 as as IN 40436 8804 14 a a DT 40436 8804 15 ground ground NN 40436 8804 16 of of IN 40436 8804 17 inference inference NN 40436 8804 18 to to IN 40436 8804 19 the the DT 40436 8804 20 condition condition NN 40436 8804 21 of of IN 40436 8804 22 the the DT 40436 8804 23 agent agent NN 40436 8804 24 contemplated contemplate VBD 40436 8804 25 . . . 40436 8805 1 If if IN 40436 8805 2 on on IN 40436 8805 3 the the DT 40436 8805 4 other other JJ 40436 8805 5 hand hand NN 40436 8805 6 , , , 40436 8805 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8805 8 say say VBP 40436 8805 9 -- -- : 40436 8805 10 to to IN 40436 8805 11 the the DT 40436 8805 12 agent agent NN 40436 8805 13 -- -- : 40436 8805 14 the the DT 40436 8805 15 definition definition NN 40436 8805 16 so so RB 40436 8805 17 understood understand VBD 40436 8805 18 becomes become VBZ 40436 8805 19 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 8805 20 : : : 40436 8805 21 as as RB 40436 8805 22 well well RB 40436 8805 23 for for IN 40436 8805 24 other other JJ 40436 8805 25 reasons reason NNS 40436 8805 26 , , , 40436 8805 27 as as IN 40436 8805 28 because because IN 40436 8805 29 there there EX 40436 8805 30 are be VBP 40436 8805 31 a a DT 40436 8805 32 great great JJ 40436 8805 33 many many JJ 40436 8805 34 Turpia Turpia NNP 40436 8805 35 which which WDT 40436 8805 36 are be VBP 40436 8805 37 not not RB 40436 8805 38 agents agent NNS 40436 8805 39 at at RB 40436 8805 40 all all RB 40436 8805 41 , , , 40436 8805 42 and and CC 40436 8805 43 which which WDT 40436 8805 44 the the DT 40436 8805 45 definition definition NN 40436 8805 46 therefore therefore RB 40436 8805 47 would would MD 40436 8805 48 not not RB 40436 8805 49 include include VB 40436 8805 50 . . . 40436 8806 1 Either either CC 40436 8806 2 therefore therefore RB 40436 8806 3 the the DT 40436 8806 4 definition definition NN 40436 8806 5 given give VBN 40436 8806 6 by by IN 40436 8806 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8806 8 is be VBZ 40436 8806 9 a a DT 40436 8806 10 bad bad JJ 40436 8806 11 one one CD 40436 8806 12 -- -- : 40436 8806 13 or or CC 40436 8806 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8806 15 will will MD 40436 8806 16 not not RB 40436 8806 17 sustain sustain VB 40436 8806 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8806 19 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 8806 20 . . . 40436 8807 1 And and CC 40436 8807 2 thus thus RB 40436 8807 3 , , , 40436 8807 4 on on IN 40436 8807 5 this this DT 40436 8807 6 very very RB 40436 8807 7 important important JJ 40436 8807 8 argument argument NN 40436 8807 9 , , , 40436 8807 10 where where WRB 40436 8807 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8807 12 admits admit VBZ 40436 8807 13 that that IN 40436 8807 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8807 15 stands stand VBZ 40436 8807 16 alone alone JJ 40436 8807 17 , , , 40436 8807 18 and and CC 40436 8807 19 where where WRB 40436 8807 20 therefore therefore RB 40436 8807 21 the the DT 40436 8807 22 proof proof NN 40436 8807 23 would would MD 40436 8807 24 need need VB 40436 8807 25 to to TO 40436 8807 26 be be VB 40436 8807 27 doubly doubly RB 40436 8807 28 cogent cogent JJ 40436 8807 29 -- -- : 40436 8807 30 an an DT 40436 8807 31 argument argument NN 40436 8807 32 too too RB 40436 8807 33 where where WRB 40436 8807 34 the the DT 40436 8807 35 great great JJ 40436 8807 36 cause cause NN 40436 8807 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8807 38 so so RB 40436 8807 39 Adam Adam NNP 40436 8807 40 Smith Smith NNP 40436 8807 41 terms term VBZ 40436 8807 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8807 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8807 44 of of IN 40436 8807 45 the the DT 40436 8807 46 corruption corruption NN 40436 8807 47 of of IN 40436 8807 48 men man NNS 40436 8807 49 's 's POS 40436 8807 50 moral moral JJ 40436 8807 51 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8807 52 has have VBZ 40436 8807 53 to to TO 40436 8807 54 be be VB 40436 8807 55 combated combat VBN 40436 8807 56 -- -- : 40436 8807 57 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8807 58 has have VBZ 40436 8807 59 nothing nothing NN 40436 8807 60 to to TO 40436 8807 61 produce produce VB 40436 8807 62 except except IN 40436 8807 63 premisses premiss NNS 40436 8807 64 alike alike RB 40436 8807 65 far far RB 40436 8807 66 - - HYPH 40436 8807 67 fetched fetched JJ 40436 8807 68 and and CC 40436 8807 69 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 40436 8807 70 . . . 40436 8808 1 What what WP 40436 8808 2 increases increase VBZ 40436 8808 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8808 4 regret regret NN 40436 8808 5 is be VBZ 40436 8808 6 , , , 40436 8808 7 that that IN 40436 8808 8 the the DT 40436 8808 9 real real JJ 40436 8808 10 arguments argument NNS 40436 8808 11 establishing establish VBG 40436 8808 12 the the DT 40436 8808 13 turpitude turpitude NN 40436 8808 14 of of IN 40436 8808 15 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8808 16 and and CC 40436 8808 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8808 18 acts act NNS 40436 8808 19 are be VBP 40436 8808 20 obvious obvious JJ 40436 8808 21 enough enough RB 40436 8808 22 , , , 40436 8808 23 if if IN 40436 8808 24 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8808 25 look look VBP 40436 8808 26 for for IN 40436 8808 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8808 28 in in IN 40436 8808 29 the the DT 40436 8808 30 right right JJ 40436 8808 31 direction direction NN 40436 8808 32 . . . 40436 8809 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 8809 2 discover discover VBP 40436 8809 3 nothing nothing NN 40436 8809 4 while while IN 40436 8809 5 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8809 6 eye eye NN 40436 8809 7 is be VBZ 40436 8809 8 fixed fix VBN 40436 8809 9 on on IN 40436 8809 10 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8809 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8809 12 : : : 40436 8809 13 far far RB 40436 8809 14 from from IN 40436 8809 15 presenting present VBG 40436 8809 16 any any DT 40436 8809 17 indications indication NNS 40436 8809 18 of of IN 40436 8809 19 misery misery NN 40436 8809 20 , , , 40436 8809 21 which which WDT 40436 8809 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8809 23 professes profess VBZ 40436 8809 24 to to TO 40436 8809 25 discover discover VB 40436 8809 26 , , , 40436 8809 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8809 28 has have VBZ 40436 8809 29 gained gain VBN 40436 8809 30 much much JJ 40436 8809 31 of of IN 40436 8809 32 what what WP 40436 8809 33 men man NNS 40436 8809 34 admire admire VBP 40436 8809 35 as as IN 40436 8809 36 good good JJ 40436 8809 37 wherever wherever WRB 40436 8809 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8809 39 see see VBP 40436 8809 40 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8809 41 . . . 40436 8810 1 But but CC 40436 8810 2 when when WRB 40436 8810 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8810 4 turn turn VBP 40436 8810 5 to to IN 40436 8810 6 the the DT 40436 8810 7 persons person NNS 40436 8810 8 whom whom WP 40436 8810 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8810 10 has have VBZ 40436 8810 11 killed kill VBN 40436 8810 12 , , , 40436 8810 13 banished banish VBN 40436 8810 14 , , , 40436 8810 15 or or CC 40436 8810 16 ruined ruin VBN 40436 8810 17 -- -- : 40436 8810 18 to to IN 40436 8810 19 the the DT 40436 8810 20 mass mass NN 40436 8810 21 of of IN 40436 8810 22 suffering suffering NN 40436 8810 23 which which WDT 40436 8810 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8810 25 has have VBZ 40436 8810 26 inflicted inflict VBN 40436 8810 27 -- -- : 40436 8810 28 and and CC 40436 8810 29 to to IN 40436 8810 30 the the DT 40436 8810 31 widespread widespread JJ 40436 8810 32 insecurity insecurity NN 40436 8810 33 which which WDT 40436 8810 34 such such JJ 40436 8810 35 acts act NNS 40436 8810 36 of of IN 40436 8810 37 successful successful JJ 40436 8810 38 iniquity iniquity NN 40436 8810 39 spread spread VBD 40436 8810 40 through through IN 40436 8810 41 all all DT 40436 8810 42 societies society NNS 40436 8810 43 where where WRB 40436 8810 44 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8810 45 become become VBP 40436 8810 46 known known JJ 40436 8810 47 -- -- : 40436 8810 48 there there EX 40436 8810 49 is be VBZ 40436 8810 50 no no DT 40436 8810 51 lack lack NN 40436 8810 52 of of IN 40436 8810 53 argument argument NN 40436 8810 54 to to TO 40436 8810 55 justify justify VB 40436 8810 56 that that IN 40436 8810 57 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8810 58 which which WDT 40436 8810 59 prompts prompt VBZ 40436 8810 60 a a DT 40436 8810 61 reflecting reflect VBG 40436 8810 62 spectator spectator NN 40436 8810 63 to to TO 40436 8810 64 brand brand VB 40436 8810 65 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8810 66 as as IN 40436 8810 67 a a DT 40436 8810 68 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8810 69 man man NN 40436 8810 70 . . . 40436 8811 1 This this DT 40436 8811 2 argument argument NN 40436 8811 3 however however RB 40436 8811 4 is be VBZ 40436 8811 5 here here RB 40436 8811 6 altogether altogether RB 40436 8811 7 neglected neglect VBN 40436 8811 8 by by IN 40436 8811 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8811 10 . . . 40436 8812 1 Here here RB 40436 8812 2 , , , 40436 8812 3 as as IN 40436 8812 4 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 8812 5 , , , 40436 8812 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8812 7 looks look VBZ 40436 8812 8 only only RB 40436 8812 9 at at IN 40436 8812 10 the the DT 40436 8812 11 self self NN 40436 8812 12 - - HYPH 40436 8812 13 regarding regard VBG 40436 8812 14 side side NN 40436 8812 15 of of IN 40436 8812 16 Ethics Ethics NNP 40436 8812 17 . . . 40436 8813 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8813 2 Side side NN 40436 8813 3 - - HYPH 40436 8813 4 note note NN 40436 8813 5 : : : 40436 8813 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8813 7 applies apply VBZ 40436 8813 8 to to IN 40436 8813 9 every every DT 40436 8813 10 one one CD 40436 8813 11 a a DT 40436 8813 12 standard standard NN 40436 8813 13 of of IN 40436 8813 14 happiness happiness NN 40436 8813 15 and and CC 40436 8813 16 misery misery NN 40436 8813 17 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 8813 18 to to IN 40436 8813 19 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8813 20 . . . 40436 8814 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8814 2 view view NN 40436 8814 3 about about IN 40436 8814 4 the the DT 40436 8814 5 conduct conduct NN 40436 8814 6 of of IN 40436 8814 7 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8814 8 is be VBZ 40436 8814 9 just just RB 40436 8814 10 , , , 40436 8814 11 but but CC 40436 8814 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8814 13 does do VBZ 40436 8814 14 not not RB 40436 8814 15 give give VB 40436 8814 16 the the DT 40436 8814 17 true true JJ 40436 8814 18 reasons reason NNS 40436 8814 19 for for IN 40436 8814 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8814 21 . . . 40436 8814 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8815 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8815 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 8815 3 next next RB 40436 8815 4 to to TO 40436 8815 5 prove prove VB 40436 8815 6 -- -- : 40436 8815 7 That that IN 40436 8815 8 the the DT 40436 8815 9 wrong wrong NN 40436 8815 10 - - HYPH 40436 8815 11 doer doer NN 40436 8815 12 who who WP 40436 8815 13 remains remain VBZ 40436 8815 14 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 8815 15 is be VBZ 40436 8815 16 more more RBR 40436 8815 17 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8815 18 than than IN 40436 8815 19 if if IN 40436 8815 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8815 21 were be VBD 40436 8815 22 punished punish VBN 40436 8815 23 . . . 40436 8816 1 The the DT 40436 8816 2 wrong wrong NN 40436 8816 3 - - HYPH 40436 8816 4 doer doer NN 40436 8816 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8816 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8816 7 argues argue VBZ 40436 8816 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8816 9 when when WRB 40436 8816 10 punished punish VBD 40436 8816 11 suffers suffer NNS 40436 8816 12 what what WP 40436 8816 13 is be VBZ 40436 8816 14 just just RB 40436 8816 15 : : : 40436 8816 16 but but CC 40436 8816 17 all all DT 40436 8816 18 just just RB 40436 8816 19 things thing NNS 40436 8816 20 are be VBP 40436 8816 21 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8816 22 : : : 40436 8816 23 therefore therefore RB 40436 8816 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8816 25 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8816 26 what what WP 40436 8816 27 is be VBZ 40436 8816 28 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8816 29 . . . 40436 8817 1 But but CC 40436 8817 2 all all DT 40436 8817 3 honourable honourable JJ 40436 8817 4 things thing NNS 40436 8817 5 are be VBP 40436 8817 6 so so RB 40436 8817 7 called call VBN 40436 8817 8 because because IN 40436 8817 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8817 10 are be VBP 40436 8817 11 either either CC 40436 8817 12 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8817 13 , , , 40436 8817 14 or or CC 40436 8817 15 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8817 16 , , , 40436 8817 17 or or CC 40436 8817 18 both both CC 40436 8817 19 together together RB 40436 8817 20 . . . 40436 8818 1 Punishment punishment NN 40436 8818 2 is be VBZ 40436 8818 3 certainly certainly RB 40436 8818 4 not not RB 40436 8818 5 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 8818 6 : : : 40436 8818 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8818 8 must must MD 40436 8818 9 therefore therefore RB 40436 8818 10 be be VB 40436 8818 11 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8818 12 or or CC 40436 8818 13 good good JJ 40436 8818 14 . . . 40436 8819 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 8819 2 the the DT 40436 8819 3 wrong wrong NN 40436 8819 4 - - HYPH 40436 8819 5 doer doer NN 40436 8819 6 when when WRB 40436 8819 7 justly justly RB 40436 8819 8 punished punish VBD 40436 8819 9 suffers suffer NNS 40436 8819 10 what what WP 40436 8819 11 is be VBZ 40436 8819 12 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8819 13 or or CC 40436 8819 14 good good JJ 40436 8819 15 . . . 40436 8820 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8820 2 is be VBZ 40436 8820 3 benefited benefit VBN 40436 8820 4 , , , 40436 8820 5 by by IN 40436 8820 6 being be VBG 40436 8820 7 relieved relieve VBN 40436 8820 8 of of IN 40436 8820 9 mental mental JJ 40436 8820 10 evil evil NN 40436 8820 11 or or CC 40436 8820 12 wickedness wickedness NN 40436 8820 13 , , , 40436 8820 14 which which WDT 40436 8820 15 is be VBZ 40436 8820 16 a a DT 40436 8820 17 worse bad JJR 40436 8820 18 evil evil NN 40436 8820 19 than than IN 40436 8820 20 either either DT 40436 8820 21 bodily bodily RB 40436 8820 22 sickness sickness NN 40436 8820 23 or or CC 40436 8820 24 poverty poverty NN 40436 8820 25 . . . 40436 8821 1 In in IN 40436 8821 2 proportion proportion NN 40436 8821 3 to to IN 40436 8821 4 the the DT 40436 8821 5 magnitude magnitude NN 40436 8821 6 of of IN 40436 8821 7 this this DT 40436 8821 8 evil evil NN 40436 8821 9 , , , 40436 8821 10 is be VBZ 40436 8821 11 the the DT 40436 8821 12 value value NN 40436 8821 13 of of IN 40436 8821 14 the the DT 40436 8821 15 relief relief NN 40436 8821 16 which which WDT 40436 8821 17 removes remove VBZ 40436 8821 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8821 19 , , , 40436 8821 20 and and CC 40436 8821 21 the the DT 40436 8821 22 superior superior JJ 40436 8821 23 misery misery NN 40436 8821 24 of of IN 40436 8821 25 the the DT 40436 8821 26 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 8821 27 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8821 28 - - HYPH 40436 8821 29 doer doer NN 40436 8821 30 who who WP 40436 8821 31 continues continue VBZ 40436 8821 32 to to TO 40436 8821 33 live live VB 40436 8821 34 under under IN 40436 8821 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8821 36 . . . 40436 8822 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8822 2 50 50 CD 40436 8822 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8822 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8822 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8822 6 50 50 CD 40436 8822 7 : : : 40436 8822 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8822 9 , , , 40436 8822 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8822 11 , , , 40436 8822 12 pp pp NNP 40436 8822 13 . . . 40436 8823 1 477 477 CD 40436 8823 2 - - SYM 40436 8823 3 478 478 CD 40436 8823 4 . . . 40436 8823 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8824 1 Upon upon IN 40436 8824 2 this this DT 40436 8824 3 argument argument NN 40436 8824 4 , , , 40436 8824 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8824 6 make make VBP 40436 8824 7 the the DT 40436 8824 8 same same JJ 40436 8824 9 remark remark NN 40436 8824 10 as as IN 40436 8824 11 upon upon IN 40436 8824 12 that that IN 40436 8824 13 immediately immediately RB 40436 8824 14 preceding precede VBG 40436 8824 15 . . . 40436 8825 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8825 2 are be VBP 40436 8825 3 not not RB 40436 8825 4 expressly expressly RB 40436 8825 5 told tell VBN 40436 8825 6 , , , 40436 8825 7 whether whether IN 40436 8825 8 good good JJ 40436 8825 9 , , , 40436 8825 10 evil evil JJ 40436 8825 11 , , , 40436 8825 12 happiness happiness NN 40436 8825 13 , , , 40436 8825 14 misery misery NN 40436 8825 15 , , , 40436 8825 16 & & CC 40436 8825 17 c. c. NNP 40436 8825 18 , , , 40436 8825 19 refer refer VBP 40436 8825 20 to to IN 40436 8825 21 the the DT 40436 8825 22 agent agent NN 40436 8825 23 alone alone RB 40436 8825 24 or or CC 40436 8825 25 to to IN 40436 8825 26 others other NNS 40436 8825 27 also also RB 40436 8825 28 : : : 40436 8825 29 but but CC 40436 8825 30 the the DT 40436 8825 31 general general JJ 40436 8825 32 tenor tenor NN 40436 8825 33 implies imply VBZ 40436 8825 34 that that IN 40436 8825 35 the the DT 40436 8825 36 agent agent NN 40436 8825 37 alone alone RB 40436 8825 38 is be VBZ 40436 8825 39 meant mean VBN 40436 8825 40 . . . 40436 8826 1 And and CC 40436 8826 2 in in IN 40436 8826 3 this this DT 40436 8826 4 sense sense NN 40436 8826 5 , , , 40436 8826 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8826 7 does do VBZ 40436 8826 8 not not RB 40436 8826 9 make make VB 40436 8826 10 out out RP 40436 8826 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8826 12 case case NN 40436 8826 13 . . . 40436 8827 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8827 2 establishes establish VBZ 40436 8827 3 an an DT 40436 8827 4 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 40436 8827 5 standard standard NN 40436 8827 6 of of IN 40436 8827 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8827 8 own own JJ 40436 8827 9 , , , 40436 8827 10 recognised recognise VBN 40436 8827 11 only only RB 40436 8827 12 by by IN 40436 8827 13 a a DT 40436 8827 14 few few JJ 40436 8827 15 followers follower NNS 40436 8827 16 , , , 40436 8827 17 and and CC 40436 8827 18 altogether altogether RB 40436 8827 19 differing differ VBG 40436 8827 20 from from IN 40436 8827 21 the the DT 40436 8827 22 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 8827 23 standard standard NN 40436 8827 24 , , , 40436 8827 25 to to TO 40436 8827 26 test test VB 40436 8827 27 and and CC 40436 8827 28 compare compare VB 40436 8827 29 happiness happiness NN 40436 8827 30 and and CC 40436 8827 31 misery misery NN 40436 8827 32 . . . 40436 8828 1 The the DT 40436 8828 2 successful successful JJ 40436 8828 3 criminal criminal NN 40436 8828 4 , , , 40436 8828 5 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8828 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8828 7 , , , 40436 8828 8 far far RB 40436 8828 9 from from IN 40436 8828 10 feeling feel VBG 40436 8828 11 any any DT 40436 8828 12 such such JJ 40436 8828 13 intense intense JJ 40436 8828 14 misery misery NN 40436 8828 15 as as IN 40436 8828 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8828 17 describes describe VBZ 40436 8828 18 , , , 40436 8828 19 is be VBZ 40436 8828 20 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 8828 21 and and CC 40436 8828 22 proud proud JJ 40436 8828 23 of of IN 40436 8828 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8828 25 position position NN 40436 8828 26 , , , 40436 8828 27 which which WDT 40436 8828 28 most most JJS 40436 8828 29 others other NNS 40436 8828 30 also also RB 40436 8828 31 account account VBP 40436 8828 32 an an DT 40436 8828 33 object object NN 40436 8828 34 of of IN 40436 8828 35 envy envy NN 40436 8828 36 . . . 40436 8829 1 This this DT 40436 8829 2 is be VBZ 40436 8829 3 not not RB 40436 8829 4 disputed dispute VBN 40436 8829 5 by by IN 40436 8829 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8829 7 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8829 8 . . . 40436 8830 1 And and CC 40436 8830 2 in in IN 40436 8830 3 the the DT 40436 8830 4 face face NN 40436 8830 5 of of IN 40436 8830 6 this this DT 40436 8830 7 fact fact NN 40436 8830 8 , , , 40436 8830 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8830 10 is be VBZ 40436 8830 11 fruitless fruitless JJ 40436 8830 12 as as RB 40436 8830 13 well well RB 40436 8830 14 as as IN 40436 8830 15 illogical illogical JJ 40436 8830 16 to to TO 40436 8830 17 attempt attempt VB 40436 8830 18 to to TO 40436 8830 19 prove prove VB 40436 8830 20 , , , 40436 8830 21 by by IN 40436 8830 22 an an DT 40436 8830 23 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 8830 24 process process NN 40436 8830 25 of of IN 40436 8830 26 deductive deductive JJ 40436 8830 27 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8830 28 , , , 40436 8830 29 that that IN 40436 8830 30 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8830 31 _ _ NNP 40436 8830 32 must must MD 40436 8830 33 _ _ NNP 40436 8830 34 be be VB 40436 8830 35 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8830 36 . . . 40436 8831 1 That that DT 40436 8831 2 step step NN 40436 8831 3 of of IN 40436 8831 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8831 5 's 's POS 40436 8831 6 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8831 7 , , , 40436 8831 8 in in IN 40436 8831 9 which which WDT 40436 8831 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8831 11 asserts assert VBZ 40436 8831 12 , , , 40436 8831 13 that that IN 40436 8831 14 the the DT 40436 8831 15 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8831 16 - - HYPH 40436 8831 17 doer doer NN 40436 8831 18 when when WRB 40436 8831 19 justly justly RB 40436 8831 20 punished punish VBD 40436 8831 21 suffers suffer NNS 40436 8831 22 what what WP 40436 8831 23 is be VBZ 40436 8831 24 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8831 25 or or CC 40436 8831 26 good good JJ 40436 8831 27 -- -- : 40436 8831 28 is be VBZ 40436 8831 29 only only RB 40436 8831 30 true true JJ 40436 8831 31 if if IN 40436 8831 32 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8831 33 take take VBP 40436 8831 34 in in RP 40436 8831 35 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8831 36 what what WP 40436 8831 37 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8831 38 omits omit NNS 40436 8831 39 to to TO 40436 8831 40 mention mention VB 40436 8831 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8831 42 the the DT 40436 8831 43 interests interest NNS 40436 8831 44 of of IN 40436 8831 45 society society NN 40436 8831 46 as as RB 40436 8831 47 well well RB 40436 8831 48 as as IN 40436 8831 49 those those DT 40436 8831 50 of of IN 40436 8831 51 the the DT 40436 8831 52 agent agent NN 40436 8831 53 . . . 40436 8832 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8832 2 punishment punishment NN 40436 8832 3 is be VBZ 40436 8832 4 certainly certainly RB 40436 8832 5 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8832 6 to to IN 40436 8832 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8832 8 conducive conducive JJ 40436 8832 9 to to IN 40436 8832 10 the the DT 40436 8832 11 security security NN 40436 8832 12 and and CC 40436 8832 13 well well UH 40436 8832 14 being be VBG 40436 8832 15 of of IN 40436 8832 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8832 17 society society NN 40436 8832 18 : : : 40436 8832 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8832 20 may may MD 40436 8832 21 possibly possibly RB 40436 8832 22 be be VB 40436 8832 23 also also RB 40436 8832 24 profitable profitable JJ 40436 8832 25 to to IN 40436 8832 26 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8832 27 , , , 40436 8832 28 but but CC 40436 8832 29 very very RB 40436 8832 30 frequently frequently RB 40436 8832 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8832 32 is be VBZ 40436 8832 33 not not RB 40436 8832 34 so so RB 40436 8832 35 . . . 40436 8833 1 The the DT 40436 8833 2 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 8833 3 brought bring VBD 40436 8833 4 out out RP 40436 8833 5 by by IN 40436 8833 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8833 7 , , , 40436 8833 8 therefore therefore RB 40436 8833 9 , , , 40436 8833 10 while while IN 40436 8833 11 contradicted contradict VBN 40436 8833 12 by by IN 40436 8833 13 the the DT 40436 8833 14 fact fact NN 40436 8833 15 , , , 40436 8833 16 involves involve VBZ 40436 8833 17 also also RB 40436 8833 18 a a DT 40436 8833 19 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 8833 20 in in IN 40436 8833 21 the the DT 40436 8833 22 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8833 23 process process NN 40436 8833 24 . . . 40436 8834 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8834 2 Side side NN 40436 8834 3 - - HYPH 40436 8834 4 note note NN 40436 8834 5 : : : 40436 8834 6 If if IN 40436 8834 7 the the DT 40436 8834 8 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 8834 9 of of IN 40436 8834 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8834 11 were be VBD 40436 8834 12 true true JJ 40436 8834 13 , , , 40436 8834 14 the the DT 40436 8834 15 point point NN 40436 8834 16 of of IN 40436 8834 17 view view NN 40436 8834 18 in in IN 40436 8834 19 which which WDT 40436 8834 20 punishment punishment NN 40436 8834 21 is be VBZ 40436 8834 22 considered consider VBN 40436 8834 23 would would MD 40436 8834 24 be be VB 40436 8834 25 reversed reverse VBN 40436 8834 26 . . . 40436 8834 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8835 1 Throughout throughout IN 40436 8835 2 the the DT 40436 8835 3 whole whole NN 40436 8835 4 of of IN 40436 8835 5 this this DT 40436 8835 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 8835 7 , , , 40436 8835 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8835 9 intimates intimate VBZ 40436 8835 10 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 8835 11 how how WRB 40436 8835 12 great great JJ 40436 8835 13 a a DT 40436 8835 14 paradox paradox NN 40436 8835 15 the the DT 40436 8835 16 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8835 17 maintained maintain VBN 40436 8835 18 by by IN 40436 8835 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8835 20 must must MD 40436 8835 21 appear appear VB 40436 8835 22 : : : 40436 8835 23 how how WRB 40436 8835 24 diametrically diametrically RB 40436 8835 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8835 26 was be VBD 40436 8835 27 opposed opposed JJ 40436 8835 28 to to IN 40436 8835 29 the the DT 40436 8835 30 opinion opinion NN 40436 8835 31 not not RB 40436 8835 32 merely merely RB 40436 8835 33 of of IN 40436 8835 34 the the DT 40436 8835 35 less less RBR 40436 8835 36 informed informed JJ 40436 8835 37 multitude multitude NNP 40436 8835 38 , , , 40436 8835 39 but but CC 40436 8835 40 of of IN 40436 8835 41 the the DT 40436 8835 42 wiser wise JJR 40436 8835 43 and and CC 40436 8835 44 more more RBR 40436 8835 45 reflecting reflect VBG 40436 8835 46 citizen citizen NN 40436 8835 47 -- -- : 40436 8835 48 even even RB 40436 8835 49 such such PDT 40436 8835 50 a a DT 40436 8835 51 man man NN 40436 8835 52 as as IN 40436 8835 53 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 8835 54 . . . 40436 8836 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 8836 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8836 3 is be VBZ 40436 8836 4 literally literally RB 40436 8836 5 exact exact JJ 40436 8836 6 -- -- : 40436 8836 7 what what WP 40436 8836 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8836 9 here here RB 40436 8836 10 puts put VBZ 40436 8836 11 into into IN 40436 8836 12 the the DT 40436 8836 13 mouth mouth NN 40436 8836 14 of of IN 40436 8836 15 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8836 16 -- -- : 40436 8836 17 that that IN 40436 8836 18 if if IN 40436 8836 19 the the DT 40436 8836 20 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8836 21 here here RB 40436 8836 22 advocated advocate VBN 40436 8836 23 by by IN 40436 8836 24 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8836 25 were be VBD 40436 8836 26 true true JJ 40436 8836 27 , , , 40436 8836 28 the the DT 40436 8836 29 whole whole NN 40436 8836 30 of of IN 40436 8836 31 social social JJ 40436 8836 32 life life NN 40436 8836 33 would would MD 40436 8836 34 be be VB 40436 8836 35 turned turn VBN 40436 8836 36 upside upside RB 40436 8836 37 down down RB 40436 8836 38 . . . 40436 8837 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8837 2 51 51 CD 40436 8837 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8837 4 If if IN 40436 8837 5 , , , 40436 8837 6 for for IN 40436 8837 7 example example NN 40436 8837 8 , , , 40436 8837 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8837 10 were be VBD 40436 8837 11 true true JJ 40436 8837 12 , , , 40436 8837 13 as as IN 40436 8837 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8837 15 contends,--That contends,--that IN 40436 8837 16 every every DT 40436 8837 17 man man NN 40436 8837 18 who who WP 40436 8837 19 commits commit VBZ 40436 8837 20 a a DT 40436 8837 21 crime crime NN 40436 8837 22 , , , 40436 8837 23 takes take VBZ 40436 8837 24 upon upon IN 40436 8837 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8837 26 thereby thereby RB 40436 8837 27 a a DT 40436 8837 28 terrible terrible JJ 40436 8837 29 and and CC 40436 8837 30 lasting lasting JJ 40436 8837 31 distemper distemper NN 40436 8837 32 , , , 40436 8837 33 incurable incurable JJ 40436 8837 34 except except IN 40436 8837 35 by by IN 40436 8837 36 the the DT 40436 8837 37 application application NN 40436 8837 38 of of IN 40436 8837 39 punishment punishment NN 40436 8837 40 , , , 40436 8837 41 which which WDT 40436 8837 42 is be VBZ 40436 8837 43 the the DT 40436 8837 44 specific specific JJ 40436 8837 45 remedy remedy NN 40436 8837 46 in in IN 40436 8837 47 the the DT 40436 8837 48 case case NN 40436 8837 49 -- -- : 40436 8837 50 every every DT 40436 8837 51 theory theory NN 40436 8837 52 of of IN 40436 8837 53 punishment punishment NN 40436 8837 54 would would MD 40436 8837 55 , , , 40436 8837 56 literally literally RB 40436 8837 57 speaking speak VBG 40436 8837 58 , , , 40436 8837 59 be be VB 40436 8837 60 turned turn VBN 40436 8837 61 upside upside RB 40436 8837 62 down down RB 40436 8837 63 . . . 40436 8838 1 The the DT 40436 8838 2 great great JJ 40436 8838 3 discouragement discouragement NN 40436 8838 4 from from IN 40436 8838 5 crime crime NN 40436 8838 6 would would MD 40436 8838 7 then then RB 40436 8838 8 consist consist VB 40436 8838 9 in in IN 40436 8838 10 the the DT 40436 8838 11 fear fear NN 40436 8838 12 of of IN 40436 8838 13 that that DT 40436 8838 14 formidable formidable JJ 40436 8838 15 distemper distemper NN 40436 8838 16 with with IN 40436 8838 17 which which WDT 40436 8838 18 the the DT 40436 8838 19 criminal criminal NN 40436 8838 20 was be VBD 40436 8838 21 sure sure JJ 40436 8838 22 to to TO 40436 8838 23 inoculate inoculate VB 40436 8838 24 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8838 25 : : : 40436 8838 26 and and CC 40436 8838 27 punishment punishment NN 40436 8838 28 , , , 40436 8838 29 instead instead RB 40436 8838 30 of of IN 40436 8838 31 being be VBG 40436 8838 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8838 33 as as IN 40436 8838 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8838 35 is be VBZ 40436 8838 36 now now RB 40436 8838 37 considered consider VBN 40436 8838 38 , , , 40436 8838 39 and and CC 40436 8838 40 as as IN 40436 8838 41 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8838 42 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8838 43 represents represent VBZ 40436 8838 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8838 45 in in IN 40436 8838 46 the the DT 40436 8838 47 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8838 48 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8838 49 the the DT 40436 8838 50 great great JJ 40436 8838 51 discouragement discouragement NN 40436 8838 52 to to IN 40436 8838 53 the the DT 40436 8838 54 commission commission NN 40436 8838 55 of of IN 40436 8838 56 crime crime NNP 40436 8838 57 , , , 40436 8838 58 would would MD 40436 8838 59 operate operate VB 40436 8838 60 in in IN 40436 8838 61 the the DT 40436 8838 62 contrary contrary JJ 40436 8838 63 direction direction NN 40436 8838 64 . . . 40436 8839 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8839 2 would would MD 40436 8839 3 be be VB 40436 8839 4 the the DT 40436 8839 5 means mean NNS 40436 8839 6 of of IN 40436 8839 7 removing remove VBG 40436 8839 8 or or CC 40436 8839 9 impairing impair VBG 40436 8839 10 the the DT 40436 8839 11 great great JJ 40436 8839 12 real real JJ 40436 8839 13 discouragement discouragement NN 40436 8839 14 to to IN 40436 8839 15 crime crime NN 40436 8839 16 : : : 40436 8839 17 and and CC 40436 8839 18 a a DT 40436 8839 19 wise wise JJ 40436 8839 20 legislator legislator NN 40436 8839 21 would would MD 40436 8839 22 hesitate hesitate VB 40436 8839 23 to to TO 40436 8839 24 inflict inflict VB 40436 8839 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8839 26 . . . 40436 8840 1 This this DT 40436 8840 2 would would MD 40436 8840 3 be be VB 40436 8840 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 8840 5 less less JJR 40436 8840 6 than than IN 40436 8840 7 a a DT 40436 8840 8 reversal reversal NN 40436 8840 9 of of IN 40436 8840 10 the the DT 40436 8840 11 most most RBS 40436 8840 12 universally universally RB 40436 8840 13 accepted accept VBN 40436 8840 14 political political JJ 40436 8840 15 or or CC 40436 8840 16 social social JJ 40436 8840 17 precepts precept NNS 40436 8840 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8840 19 as as IN 40436 8840 20 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8840 21 is be VBZ 40436 8840 22 made make VBN 40436 8840 23 to to TO 40436 8840 24 express express VB 40436 8840 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8840 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8840 27 . . . 40436 8841 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8841 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8841 3 51 51 CD 40436 8841 4 : : : 40436 8841 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8841 6 , , , 40436 8841 7 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 8841 8 . . . 40436 8842 1 p. p. NN 40436 8842 2 481 481 CD 40436 8842 3 C. C. NNP 40436 8842 4 _ _ NNP 40436 8842 5 Kall._--[Greek kall._--[greek NN 40436 8842 6 : : : 40436 8842 7 ei ei LS 40436 8842 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8842 9 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8842 10 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8842 11 spouda spouda NNP 40436 8842 12 / / SYM 40436 8842 13 zeis zeis NNP 40436 8842 14 te te NNP 40436 8842 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8842 16 tugcha tugcha NNP 40436 8842 17 / / SYM 40436 8842 18 nei nei NNP 40436 8842 19 tau tau NNP 40436 8842 20 = = SYM 40436 8842 21 ta ta NNP 40436 8842 22 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 8842 23 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 8842 24 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 8842 25 le le NNP 40436 8842 26 / / SYM 40436 8842 27 geis geis NNP 40436 8842 28 , , , 40436 8842 29 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 8842 30 ti ti NNP 40436 8842 31 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 8842 32 ê(mô ê(mô NNP 40436 8842 33 = = NFP 40436 8842 34 n n CC 40436 8842 35 o o NN 40436 8842 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8842 37 bi bi NNP 40436 8842 38 / / SYM 40436 8842 39 os os NNP 40436 8842 40 a)natetramme a)natetramme , 40436 8842 41 / / SYM 40436 8842 42 nos nos NNP 40436 8842 43 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 8842 44 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 8842 45 tô tô NNP 40436 8842 46 = = NFP 40436 8842 47 n n NNP 40436 8842 48 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 8842 49 / / SYM 40436 8842 50 pôn pôn NNP 40436 8842 51 , , , 40436 8842 52 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8842 53 pa pa NNP 40436 8842 54 / / SYM 40436 8842 55 nta nta NNP 40436 8842 56 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 8842 57 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 8842 58 / / SYM 40436 8842 59 a a DT 40436 8842 60 pra pra NNP 40436 8842 61 / / SYM 40436 8842 62 ttomen ttomen NNP 40436 8842 63 , , , 40436 8842 64 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 8842 65 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 8842 66 dei= dei= NNP 40436 8842 67 ? ? . 40436 8842 68 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8842 69 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8843 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8843 2 Side side NN 40436 8843 3 - - HYPH 40436 8843 4 note note NN 40436 8843 5 : : : 40436 8843 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8843 7 pushes push VBZ 40436 8843 8 too too RB 40436 8843 9 far far RB 40436 8843 10 the the DT 40436 8843 11 analogy analogy NN 40436 8843 12 between between IN 40436 8843 13 mental mental JJ 40436 8843 14 distemper distemper NN 40436 8843 15 and and CC 40436 8843 16 bodily bodily JJ 40436 8843 17 distemper distemper NN 40436 8843 18 -- -- : 40436 8843 19 Material material NN 40436 8843 20 difference difference NN 40436 8843 21 between between IN 40436 8843 22 the the DT 40436 8843 23 two two CD 40436 8843 24 -- -- : 40436 8843 25 Distemper Distemper NNP 40436 8843 26 must must MD 40436 8843 27 be be VB 40436 8843 28 felt feel VBN 40436 8843 29 by by IN 40436 8843 30 the the DT 40436 8843 31 distempered distemper VBN 40436 8843 32 persons person NNS 40436 8843 33 . . . 40436 8843 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8844 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8844 2 will will MD 40436 8844 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 8844 4 be be VB 40436 8844 5 at at IN 40436 8844 6 once once RB 40436 8844 7 seen see VBN 40436 8844 8 , , , 40436 8844 9 that that IN 40436 8844 10 the the DT 40436 8844 11 taint taint NN 40436 8844 12 or or CC 40436 8844 13 distemper distemper NN 40436 8844 14 with with IN 40436 8844 15 which which WDT 40436 8844 16 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8844 17 is be VBZ 40436 8844 18 supposed suppose VBN 40436 8844 19 to to TO 40436 8844 20 inoculate inoculate VB 40436 8844 21 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8844 22 , , , 40436 8844 23 when when WRB 40436 8844 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8844 25 commits commit VBZ 40436 8844 26 signal signal NN 40436 8844 27 crime crime NN 40436 8844 28 -- -- : 40436 8844 29 is be VBZ 40436 8844 30 a a DT 40436 8844 31 pure pure JJ 40436 8844 32 fancy fancy JJ 40436 8844 33 or or CC 40436 8844 34 poetical poetical JJ 40436 8844 35 metaphor metaphor NN 40436 8844 36 on on IN 40436 8844 37 the the DT 40436 8844 38 part part NN 40436 8844 39 of of IN 40436 8844 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8844 41 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8844 42 . . . 40436 8845 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8845 2 52 52 CD 40436 8845 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8845 4 A a DT 40436 8845 5 distemper distemper NN 40436 8845 6 must must MD 40436 8845 7 imply imply VB 40436 8845 8 something something NN 40436 8845 9 painful painful JJ 40436 8845 10 , , , 40436 8845 11 enfeebling enfeeble VBG 40436 8845 12 , , , 40436 8845 13 disabling disable VBG 40436 8845 14 , , , 40436 8845 15 to to IN 40436 8845 16 the the DT 40436 8845 17 individual individual NN 40436 8845 18 who who WP 40436 8845 19 feels feel VBZ 40436 8845 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8845 21 : : : 40436 8845 22 there there EX 40436 8845 23 is be VBZ 40436 8845 24 no no DT 40436 8845 25 other other JJ 40436 8845 26 meaning meaning NN 40436 8845 27 : : : 40436 8845 28 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8845 29 can can MD 40436 8845 30 not not RB 40436 8845 31 recognise recognise VB 40436 8845 32 a a DT 40436 8845 33 distemper distemper NN 40436 8845 34 , , , 40436 8845 35 which which WDT 40436 8845 36 does do VBZ 40436 8845 37 not not RB 40436 8845 38 make make VB 40436 8845 39 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 8845 40 felt feel VBN 40436 8845 41 in in IN 40436 8845 42 any any DT 40436 8845 43 way way NN 40436 8845 44 by by IN 40436 8845 45 the the DT 40436 8845 46 distempered distemper VBN 40436 8845 47 person person NN 40436 8845 48 . . . 40436 8846 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8846 2 is be VBZ 40436 8846 3 misled mislead VBN 40436 8846 4 by by IN 40436 8846 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8846 6 ever ever RB 40436 8846 7 - - HYPH 40436 8846 8 repeated repeat VBN 40436 8846 9 analogy analogy NN 40436 8846 10 between between IN 40436 8846 11 bodily bodily NNP 40436 8846 12 health health NNP 40436 8846 13 and and CC 40436 8846 14 mental mental JJ 40436 8846 15 health health NN 40436 8846 16 : : : 40436 8846 17 real real JJ 40436 8846 18 , , , 40436 8846 19 on on IN 40436 8846 20 some some DT 40436 8846 21 points point NNS 40436 8846 22 -- -- : 40436 8846 23 not not RB 40436 8846 24 real real JJ 40436 8846 25 on on IN 40436 8846 26 others other NNS 40436 8846 27 . . . 40436 8847 1 When when WRB 40436 8847 2 a a DT 40436 8847 3 man man NN 40436 8847 4 is be VBZ 40436 8847 5 in in IN 40436 8847 6 bad bad JJ 40436 8847 7 bodily bodily JJ 40436 8847 8 health health NN 40436 8847 9 , , , 40436 8847 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8847 11 sensations sensation NNS 40436 8847 12 warn warn VBP 40436 8847 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8847 14 of of IN 40436 8847 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8847 16 at at IN 40436 8847 17 once once RB 40436 8847 18 . . . 40436 8848 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8848 2 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 8848 3 pain pain NN 40436 8848 4 , , , 40436 8848 5 discomfort discomfort NN 40436 8848 6 , , , 40436 8848 7 or or CC 40436 8848 8 disabilities disability NNS 40436 8848 9 , , , 40436 8848 10 which which WDT 40436 8848 11 leave leave VBP 40436 8848 12 no no DT 40436 8848 13 doubt doubt NN 40436 8848 14 as as IN 40436 8848 15 to to IN 40436 8848 16 the the DT 40436 8848 17 fact fact NN 40436 8848 18 : : : 40436 8848 19 though though IN 40436 8848 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8848 21 may may MD 40436 8848 22 not not RB 40436 8848 23 know know VB 40436 8848 24 either either CC 40436 8848 25 the the DT 40436 8848 26 precise precise JJ 40436 8848 27 cause cause NN 40436 8848 28 , , , 40436 8848 29 or or CC 40436 8848 30 the the DT 40436 8848 31 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 8848 32 remedy remedy NN 40436 8848 33 . . . 40436 8849 1 Conversely conversely RB 40436 8849 2 , , , 40436 8849 3 in in IN 40436 8849 4 the the DT 40436 8849 5 absence absence NN 40436 8849 6 of of IN 40436 8849 7 any any DT 40436 8849 8 such such JJ 40436 8849 9 warnings warning NNS 40436 8849 10 , , , 40436 8849 11 and and CC 40436 8849 12 in in IN 40436 8849 13 the the DT 40436 8849 14 presence presence NN 40436 8849 15 of of IN 40436 8849 16 certain certain JJ 40436 8849 17 positive positive JJ 40436 8849 18 sensations sensation NNS 40436 8849 19 , , , 40436 8849 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8849 21 knows know VBZ 40436 8849 22 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8849 23 to to TO 40436 8849 24 be be VB 40436 8849 25 in in IN 40436 8849 26 tolerable tolerable JJ 40436 8849 27 or or CC 40436 8849 28 good good JJ 40436 8849 29 health health NN 40436 8849 30 . . . 40436 8850 1 If if IN 40436 8850 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8850 3 and and CC 40436 8850 4 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8850 5 were be VBD 40436 8850 6 both both DT 40436 8850 7 in in IN 40436 8850 8 good good JJ 40436 8850 9 bodily bodily JJ 40436 8850 10 health health NN 40436 8850 11 , , , 40436 8850 12 or or CC 40436 8850 13 both both DT 40436 8850 14 in in IN 40436 8850 15 bad bad JJ 40436 8850 16 bodily bodily JJ 40436 8850 17 health health NN 40436 8850 18 , , , 40436 8850 19 each each DT 40436 8850 20 would would MD 40436 8850 21 be be VB 40436 8850 22 made make VBN 40436 8850 23 aware aware JJ 40436 8850 24 of of IN 40436 8850 25 the the DT 40436 8850 26 fact fact NN 40436 8850 27 by by IN 40436 8850 28 analogous analogous JJ 40436 8850 29 evidences evidence NNS 40436 8850 30 . . . 40436 8851 1 But but CC 40436 8851 2 by by IN 40436 8851 3 what what WDT 40436 8851 4 measure measure NN 40436 8851 5 are be VBP 40436 8851 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8851 7 to to TO 40436 8851 8 determine determine VB 40436 8851 9 _ _ NNP 40436 8851 10 when when WRB 40436 8851 11 _ _ NNP 40436 8851 12 a a DT 40436 8851 13 man man NN 40436 8851 14 is be VBZ 40436 8851 15 in in IN 40436 8851 16 a a DT 40436 8851 17 good good JJ 40436 8851 18 or or CC 40436 8851 19 bad bad JJ 40436 8851 20 mental mental JJ 40436 8851 21 state state NN 40436 8851 22 ? ? . 40436 8852 1 By by IN 40436 8852 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8852 3 own own JJ 40436 8852 4 feelings feeling NNS 40436 8852 5 ? ? . 40436 8853 1 In in IN 40436 8853 2 that that DT 40436 8853 3 case case NN 40436 8853 4 , , , 40436 8853 5 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8853 6 and and CC 40436 8853 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8853 8 are be VBP 40436 8853 9 in in IN 40436 8853 10 a a DT 40436 8853 11 mental mental JJ 40436 8853 12 state state NN 40436 8853 13 equally equally RB 40436 8853 14 good good JJ 40436 8853 15 : : : 40436 8853 16 each each DT 40436 8853 17 is be VBZ 40436 8853 18 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 8853 19 with with IN 40436 8853 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8853 21 own own JJ 40436 8853 22 . . . 40436 8854 1 By by IN 40436 8854 2 the the DT 40436 8854 3 judgment judgment NN 40436 8854 4 of of IN 40436 8854 5 by by NN 40436 8854 6 - - HYPH 40436 8854 7 standers stander NNS 40436 8854 8 ? ? . 40436 8855 1 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8855 2 will will MD 40436 8855 3 then then RB 40436 8855 4 be be VB 40436 8855 5 the the DT 40436 8855 6 better well JJR 40436 8855 7 of of IN 40436 8855 8 the the DT 40436 8855 9 two two CD 40436 8855 10 : : : 40436 8855 11 at at IN 40436 8855 12 least least JJS 40436 8855 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8855 14 admirers admirer NNS 40436 8855 15 and and CC 40436 8855 16 enviers envier NNS 40436 8855 17 will will MD 40436 8855 18 outnumber outnumber VB 40436 8855 19 those those DT 40436 8855 20 of of IN 40436 8855 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8855 22 . . . 40436 8856 1 By by IN 40436 8856 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8856 3 judgment judgment NN 40436 8856 4 ? ? . 40436 8857 1 If if IN 40436 8857 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8857 3 opinion opinion NN 40436 8857 4 is be VBZ 40436 8857 5 asked ask VBN 40436 8857 6 , , , 40436 8857 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8857 8 agree agree VBP 40436 8857 9 with with IN 40436 8857 10 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8857 11 : : : 40436 8857 12 though though IN 40436 8857 13 not not RB 40436 8857 14 on on IN 40436 8857 15 the the DT 40436 8857 16 grounds ground NNS 40436 8857 17 which which WDT 40436 8857 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8857 19 here here RB 40436 8857 20 urges urge VBZ 40436 8857 21 , , , 40436 8857 22 but but CC 40436 8857 23 on on IN 40436 8857 24 other other JJ 40436 8857 25 grounds ground NNS 40436 8857 26 . . . 40436 8858 1 Who who WP 40436 8858 2 is be VBZ 40436 8858 3 to to TO 40436 8858 4 be be VB 40436 8858 5 the the DT 40436 8858 6 ultimate ultimate JJ 40436 8858 7 referee referee NN 40436 8858 8 -- -- : 40436 8858 9 the the DT 40436 8858 10 interests interest NNS 40436 8858 11 or or CC 40436 8858 12 security security NN 40436 8858 13 of of IN 40436 8858 14 other other JJ 40436 8858 15 persons person NNS 40436 8858 16 , , , 40436 8858 17 who who WP 40436 8858 18 have have VBP 40436 8858 19 suffered suffer VBN 40436 8858 20 or or CC 40436 8858 21 are be VBP 40436 8858 22 likely likely JJ 40436 8858 23 to to TO 40436 8858 24 suffer suffer VB 40436 8858 25 by by IN 40436 8858 26 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8858 27 , , , 40436 8858 28 being be VBG 40436 8858 29 by by IN 40436 8858 30 the the DT 40436 8858 31 supposition supposition NN 40436 8858 32 left leave VBD 40436 8858 33 out out IN 40436 8858 34 of of IN 40436 8858 35 view view NN 40436 8858 36 ? ? . 40436 8859 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8859 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8859 3 52 52 CD 40436 8859 4 : : : 40436 8859 5 The the DT 40436 8859 6 disposition disposition NN 40436 8859 7 of of IN 40436 8859 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8859 9 to to TO 40436 8859 10 build build VB 40436 8859 11 argument argument NN 40436 8859 12 on on IN 40436 8859 13 a a DT 40436 8859 14 metaphor metaphor NN 40436 8859 15 is be VBZ 40436 8859 16 often often RB 40436 8859 17 shown show VBN 40436 8859 18 . . . 40436 8860 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8860 2 remarks remark VBZ 40436 8860 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8860 4 of of IN 40436 8860 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8860 6 in in IN 40436 8860 7 respect respect NN 40436 8860 8 to to IN 40436 8860 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8860 10 theory theory NN 40436 8860 11 of of IN 40436 8860 12 Ideas idea NNS 40436 8860 13 ; ; : 40436 8860 14 and and CC 40436 8860 15 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8860 16 in in IN 40436 8860 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8860 18 Topica Topica NNP 40436 8860 19 gives give VBZ 40436 8860 20 several several JJ 40436 8860 21 precepts precept NNS 40436 8860 22 in in IN 40436 8860 23 regard regard NN 40436 8860 24 to to IN 40436 8860 25 the the DT 40436 8860 26 general general JJ 40436 8860 27 tendency tendency NN 40436 8860 28 -- -- : 40436 8860 29 precepts precept NNS 40436 8860 30 enjoining enjoin VBG 40436 8860 31 disputants disputant NNS 40436 8860 32 to to TO 40436 8860 33 be be VB 40436 8860 34 on on IN 40436 8860 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8860 36 guard guard NN 40436 8860 37 against against IN 40436 8860 38 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8860 39 in in IN 40436 8860 40 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 8860 41 discussion discussion NN 40436 8860 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8860 43 Topica Topica NNP 40436 8860 44 , , , 40436 8860 45 iv iv NNP 40436 8860 46 . . . 40436 8861 1 123 123 CD 40436 8861 2 , , , 40436 8861 3 a. a. NN 40436 8862 1 33 33 CD 40436 8862 2 , , , 40436 8862 3 vi vi NNP 40436 8862 4 . . . 40436 8863 1 139 139 CD 40436 8863 2 - - SYM 40436 8863 3 140)--[Greek 140)--[greek CD 40436 8863 4 : : : 40436 8863 5 pa pa NNP 40436 8863 6 = = SYM 40436 8863 7 n n CC 40436 8863 8 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8863 9 a)saphe\s a)saphe\s NN 40436 8863 10 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8863 11 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 8863 12 metaphora\n metaphora\n : 40436 8863 13 lego lego NNP 40436 8863 14 / / SYM 40436 8863 15 menon menon NNP 40436 8863 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8863 17 , , , 40436 8863 18 & & CC 40436 8863 19 c. c. NNP 40436 8863 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8863 21 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8863 22 is be VBZ 40436 8863 23 now now RB 40436 8863 24 dismissed dismiss VBN 40436 8863 25 as as IN 40436 8863 26 vanquished vanquish VBN 40436 8863 27 , , , 40436 8863 28 after after IN 40436 8863 29 having have VBG 40436 8863 30 been be VBN 40436 8863 31 forced force VBN 40436 8863 32 , , , 40436 8863 33 against against IN 40436 8863 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8863 35 will will NN 40436 8863 36 , , , 40436 8863 37 to to TO 40436 8863 38 concede concede VB 40436 8863 39 -- -- : 40436 8863 40 That that IN 40436 8863 41 the the DT 40436 8863 42 doer doer NN 40436 8863 43 of of IN 40436 8863 44 wrong wrong NN 40436 8863 45 is be VBZ 40436 8863 46 more more RBR 40436 8863 47 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8863 48 than than IN 40436 8863 49 the the DT 40436 8863 50 sufferer sufferer NN 40436 8863 51 : : : 40436 8863 52 That that IN 40436 8863 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8863 54 is be VBZ 40436 8863 55 more more RBR 40436 8863 56 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8863 57 , , , 40436 8863 58 if if IN 40436 8863 59 unpunished,--less unpunished,--less NNP 40436 8863 60 so so CC 40436 8863 61 , , , 40436 8863 62 if if IN 40436 8863 63 punished punish VBN 40436 8863 64 : : : 40436 8863 65 That that IN 40436 8863 66 a a DT 40436 8863 67 triumphant triumphant JJ 40436 8863 68 criminal criminal NN 40436 8863 69 on on IN 40436 8863 70 a a DT 40436 8863 71 great great JJ 40436 8863 72 scale scale NN 40436 8863 73 , , , 40436 8863 74 like like IN 40436 8863 75 Archelaus Archelaus NNP 40436 8863 76 , , , 40436 8863 77 is be VBZ 40436 8863 78 the the DT 40436 8863 79 most most RBS 40436 8863 80 miserable miserable JJ 40436 8863 81 of of IN 40436 8863 82 men man NNS 40436 8863 83 . . . 40436 8864 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8864 2 Side side NN 40436 8864 3 - - HYPH 40436 8864 4 note note NN 40436 8864 5 : : : 40436 8864 6 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8864 7 begins begin VBZ 40436 8864 8 to to TO 40436 8864 9 argue argue VB 40436 8864 10 against against IN 40436 8864 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8864 12 -- -- : 40436 8864 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8864 14 takes take VBZ 40436 8864 15 a a DT 40436 8864 16 distinction distinction NN 40436 8864 17 between between IN 40436 8864 18 Just just RB 40436 8864 19 by by IN 40436 8864 20 Law Law NNP 40436 8864 21 and and CC 40436 8864 22 Just just RB 40436 8864 23 by by IN 40436 8864 24 nature nature NN 40436 8864 25 -- -- : 40436 8864 26 Reply Reply NNP 40436 8864 27 of of IN 40436 8864 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8864 29 , , , 40436 8864 30 that that IN 40436 8864 31 there there EX 40436 8864 32 is be VBZ 40436 8864 33 no no DT 40436 8864 34 variance variance NN 40436 8864 35 between between IN 40436 8864 36 the the DT 40436 8864 37 two two CD 40436 8864 38 , , , 40436 8864 39 properly properly RB 40436 8864 40 understood understand VBN 40436 8864 41 . . . 40436 8864 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8865 1 Here here RB 40436 8865 2 , , , 40436 8865 3 then then RB 40436 8865 4 , , , 40436 8865 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8865 6 commence commence VBP 40436 8865 7 with with IN 40436 8865 8 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8865 9 : : : 40436 8865 10 who who WP 40436 8865 11 interposes interpose VBZ 40436 8865 12 , , , 40436 8865 13 to to TO 40436 8865 14 take take VB 40436 8865 15 up up RP 40436 8865 16 the the DT 40436 8865 17 debate debate NN 40436 8865 18 with with IN 40436 8865 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8865 20 . . . 40436 8866 1 Polus polus NN 40436 8866 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8866 3 says say VBZ 40436 8866 4 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8866 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8866 6 , , , 40436 8866 7 from from IN 40436 8866 8 deference deference NN 40436 8866 9 to to IN 40436 8866 10 the the DT 40436 8866 11 opinions opinion NNS 40436 8866 12 of of IN 40436 8866 13 mankind mankind NN 40436 8866 14 , , , 40436 8866 15 has have VBZ 40436 8866 16 erroneously erroneously RB 40436 8866 17 conceded concede VBN 40436 8866 18 the the DT 40436 8866 19 point point NN 40436 8866 20 -- -- : 40436 8866 21 That that IN 40436 8866 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8866 23 is be VBZ 40436 8866 24 more more RBR 40436 8866 25 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8866 26 to to TO 40436 8866 27 do do VB 40436 8866 28 wrong wrong NN 40436 8866 29 , , , 40436 8866 30 than than IN 40436 8866 31 to to TO 40436 8866 32 suffer suffer VB 40436 8866 33 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8866 34 . . . 40436 8867 1 This this DT 40436 8867 2 is be VBZ 40436 8867 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 8867 4 true true JJ 40436 8867 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8867 6 continues continue VBZ 40436 8867 7 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8867 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8867 9 , , , 40436 8867 10 according accord VBG 40436 8867 11 to to IN 40436 8867 12 what what WP 40436 8867 13 is be VBZ 40436 8867 14 just just RB 40436 8867 15 by by IN 40436 8867 16 law law NN 40436 8867 17 or or CC 40436 8867 18 convention convention NN 40436 8867 19 , , , 40436 8867 20 that that RB 40436 8867 21 is is RB 40436 8867 22 , , , 40436 8867 23 according accord VBG 40436 8867 24 to to IN 40436 8867 25 the the DT 40436 8867 26 general general JJ 40436 8867 27 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8867 28 of of IN 40436 8867 29 mankind mankind NN 40436 8867 30 : : : 40436 8867 31 but but CC 40436 8867 32 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8867 33 is be VBZ 40436 8867 34 not not RB 40436 8867 35 true true JJ 40436 8867 36 , , , 40436 8867 37 according accord VBG 40436 8867 38 to to IN 40436 8867 39 justice justice NN 40436 8867 40 by by IN 40436 8867 41 nature nature NN 40436 8867 42 , , , 40436 8867 43 or or CC 40436 8867 44 natural natural JJ 40436 8867 45 justice justice NN 40436 8867 46 . . . 40436 8868 1 Nature nature NN 40436 8868 2 and and CC 40436 8868 3 Law Law NNP 40436 8868 4 are be VBP 40436 8868 5 here here RB 40436 8868 6 opposed opposed JJ 40436 8868 7 . . . 40436 8869 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8869 2 53 53 CD 40436 8869 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8869 4 The the DT 40436 8869 5 justice justice NN 40436 8869 6 of of IN 40436 8869 7 Nature nature NN 40436 8869 8 is be VBZ 40436 8869 9 , , , 40436 8869 10 that that IN 40436 8869 11 among among IN 40436 8869 12 men man NNS 40436 8869 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8869 14 as as IN 40436 8869 15 among among IN 40436 8869 16 other other JJ 40436 8869 17 animals animal NNS 40436 8869 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8869 19 the the DT 40436 8869 20 strong strong JJ 40436 8869 21 individual individual NN 40436 8869 22 should should MD 40436 8869 23 govern govern VB 40436 8869 24 and and CC 40436 8869 25 strip strip VB 40436 8869 26 the the DT 40436 8869 27 weak weak JJ 40436 8869 28 , , , 40436 8869 29 taking take VBG 40436 8869 30 and and CC 40436 8869 31 keeping keep VBG 40436 8869 32 as as RB 40436 8869 33 much much RB 40436 8869 34 as as IN 40436 8869 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8869 36 can can MD 40436 8869 37 grasp grasp VB 40436 8869 38 . . . 40436 8870 1 But but CC 40436 8870 2 this this DT 40436 8870 3 justice justice NN 40436 8870 4 will will MD 40436 8870 5 not not RB 40436 8870 6 suit suit VB 40436 8870 7 the the DT 40436 8870 8 weak weak JJ 40436 8870 9 , , , 40436 8870 10 who who WP 40436 8870 11 are be VBP 40436 8870 12 the the DT 40436 8870 13 many many JJ 40436 8870 14 , , , 40436 8870 15 and and CC 40436 8870 16 who who WP 40436 8870 17 defeat defeat VBP 40436 8870 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8870 19 by by IN 40436 8870 20 establishing establish VBG 40436 8870 21 a a DT 40436 8870 22 different different JJ 40436 8870 23 justice justice NN 40436 8870 24 -- -- : 40436 8870 25 justice justice NN 40436 8870 26 according accord VBG 40436 8870 27 to to IN 40436 8870 28 law law NN 40436 8870 29 -- -- : 40436 8870 30 to to TO 40436 8870 31 curb curb VB 40436 8870 32 the the DT 40436 8870 33 strong strong JJ 40436 8870 34 man man NN 40436 8870 35 , , , 40436 8870 36 and and CC 40436 8870 37 prevent prevent VB 40436 8870 38 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8870 39 from from IN 40436 8870 40 having have VBG 40436 8870 41 more more JJR 40436 8870 42 than than IN 40436 8870 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8870 44 fair fair JJ 40436 8870 45 share share NN 40436 8870 46 . . . 40436 8871 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8871 2 54 54 CD 40436 8871 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8871 4 The the DT 40436 8871 5 many many JJ 40436 8871 6 , , , 40436 8871 7 feeling feel VBG 40436 8871 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8871 9 own own JJ 40436 8871 10 weakness weakness NN 40436 8871 11 , , , 40436 8871 12 and and CC 40436 8871 13 thankful thankful JJ 40436 8871 14 if if IN 40436 8871 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8871 16 can can MD 40436 8871 17 only only RB 40436 8871 18 secure secure VB 40436 8871 19 a a DT 40436 8871 20 fair fair JJ 40436 8871 21 and and CC 40436 8871 22 equal equal JJ 40436 8871 23 division division NN 40436 8871 24 , , , 40436 8871 25 make make VB 40436 8871 26 laws law NNS 40436 8871 27 and and CC 40436 8871 28 turn turn VB 40436 8871 29 the the DT 40436 8871 30 current current NN 40436 8871 31 of of IN 40436 8871 32 praise praise NN 40436 8871 33 and and CC 40436 8871 34 blame blame NN 40436 8871 35 for for IN 40436 8871 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8871 37 own own JJ 40436 8871 38 protection protection NN 40436 8871 39 , , , 40436 8871 40 in in IN 40436 8871 41 order order NN 40436 8871 42 to to TO 40436 8871 43 deter deter VB 40436 8871 44 the the DT 40436 8871 45 strong strong JJ 40436 8871 46 man man NN 40436 8871 47 from from IN 40436 8871 48 that that DT 40436 8871 49 encroachment encroachment NN 40436 8871 50 and and CC 40436 8871 51 oppression oppression NN 40436 8871 52 to to TO 40436 8871 53 which which WDT 40436 8871 54 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8871 55 is be VBZ 40436 8871 56 disposed disposed JJ 40436 8871 57 . . . 40436 8872 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8872 2 The the DT 40436 8872 3 just just RB 40436 8872 4 according accord VBG 40436 8872 5 to to IN 40436 8872 6 law law NN 40436 8872 7 _ _ NNP 40436 8872 8 is be VBZ 40436 8872 9 thus thus RB 40436 8872 10 a a DT 40436 8872 11 tutelary tutelary JJ 40436 8872 12 institution institution NN 40436 8872 13 , , , 40436 8872 14 established establish VBN 40436 8872 15 by by IN 40436 8872 16 the the DT 40436 8872 17 weak weak JJ 40436 8872 18 to to TO 40436 8872 19 defend defend VB 40436 8872 20 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8872 21 against against IN 40436 8872 22 _ _ NNP 40436 8872 23 the the DT 40436 8872 24 just just RB 40436 8872 25 according accord VBG 40436 8872 26 to to IN 40436 8872 27 nature nature NN 40436 8872 28 _ _ NNP 40436 8872 29 . . . 40436 8873 1 Nature nature NN 40436 8873 2 measures measure NNS 40436 8873 3 right right RB 40436 8873 4 by by IN 40436 8873 5 might might NN 40436 8873 6 , , , 40436 8873 7 and and CC 40436 8873 8 by by IN 40436 8873 9 nothing nothing NN 40436 8873 10 else else RB 40436 8873 11 : : : 40436 8873 12 so so IN 40436 8873 13 that that IN 40436 8873 14 according accord VBG 40436 8873 15 to to IN 40436 8873 16 the the DT 40436 8873 17 right right NN 40436 8873 18 of of IN 40436 8873 19 nature nature NN 40436 8873 20 , , , 40436 8873 21 suffering suffer VBG 40436 8873 22 wrong wrong NN 40436 8873 23 is be VBZ 40436 8873 24 more more RBR 40436 8873 25 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8873 26 than than IN 40436 8873 27 doing do VBG 40436 8873 28 wrong wrong NN 40436 8873 29 . . . 40436 8874 1 Hêraklês hêraklê NNS 40436 8874 2 takes take VBZ 40436 8874 3 from from IN 40436 8874 4 Geryon Geryon NNP 40436 8874 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8874 6 cattle cattle NNS 40436 8874 7 , , , 40436 8874 8 by by IN 40436 8874 9 the the DT 40436 8874 10 right right NN 40436 8874 11 of of IN 40436 8874 12 nature nature NN 40436 8874 13 or or CC 40436 8874 14 of of IN 40436 8874 15 the the DT 40436 8874 16 strongest strong JJS 40436 8874 17 , , , 40436 8874 18 without without IN 40436 8874 19 either either DT 40436 8874 20 sale sale NN 40436 8874 21 or or CC 40436 8874 22 gift gift NN 40436 8874 23 . . . 40436 8875 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8875 2 55 55 CD 40436 8875 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8875 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8875 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8875 6 53 53 CD 40436 8875 7 : : : 40436 8875 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8875 9 , , , 40436 8875 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8875 11 , , , 40436 8875 12 p. p. NN 40436 8875 13 482 482 CD 40436 8875 14 E. E. NNP 40436 8875 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8875 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8875 17 : : : 40436 8875 18 ô(s ô(s NN 40436 8875 19 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 8875 20 polla\ polla\ NNP 40436 8875 21 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8875 22 tau tau NNP 40436 8875 23 = = SYM 40436 8875 24 ta ta NNP 40436 8875 25 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 8875 26 / / SYM 40436 8875 27 a a DT 40436 8875 28 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 8875 29 / / SYM 40436 8875 30 lois lois NNP 40436 8875 31 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 8875 32 / / SYM 40436 8875 33 n n NNP 40436 8875 34 , , , 40436 8875 35 ê(/ ê(/ NNP 40436 8875 36 te te NNP 40436 8875 37 phu phu NNP 40436 8875 38 / / SYM 40436 8875 39 sis sis NNP 40436 8875 40 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8875 41 o o NNP 40436 8875 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8875 43 no no UH 40436 8875 44 / / SYM 40436 8875 45 mos mos NN 40436 8875 46 . . . 40436 8875 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8875 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8876 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8876 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8876 3 54 54 CD 40436 8876 4 : : : 40436 8876 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8876 6 , , , 40436 8876 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8876 8 , , , 40436 8876 9 p. p. NN 40436 8876 10 483 483 CD 40436 8876 11 B. b. NN 40436 8877 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8877 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8877 3 : : : 40436 8877 4 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 8877 5 ' ' '' 40436 8877 6 , , , 40436 8877 7 oi)=mai oi)=mai CD 40436 8877 8 , , , 40436 8877 9 oi oi NNP 40436 8877 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8877 11 tithe tithe NNP 40436 8877 12 / / SYM 40436 8877 13 menoi menoi NNS 40436 8877 14 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8877 15 no no DT 40436 8877 16 / / SYM 40436 8877 17 mous mous JJ 40436 8877 18 oi oi NN 40436 8877 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8877 20 a)sthenei a)sthenei NNP 40436 8877 21 = = SYM 40436 8877 22 s s NNP 40436 8877 23 a)/nthrôpoi/ a)/nthrôpoi/ NNP 40436 8877 24 ei)si ei)si NNP 40436 8877 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8877 26 oi oi NNP 40436 8877 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8877 28 polloi\. polloi\. NNP 40436 8878 1 Pro\s Pro\s NNP 40436 8878 2 au(tou\s au(tou\s NNP 40436 8878 3 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 8878 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8878 5 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8878 6 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 8878 7 = = SYM 40436 8878 8 s s NNP 40436 8878 9 sumphe sumphe NNP 40436 8878 10 / / SYM 40436 8878 11 ron ron NNP 40436 8878 12 tou tou NNP 40436 8878 13 / / SYM 40436 8878 14 s s NNP 40436 8878 15 te te NNP 40436 8878 16 no no DT 40436 8878 17 / / SYM 40436 8878 18 mous mous JJ 40436 8878 19 ti ti NN 40436 8878 20 / / SYM 40436 8878 21 thentai thentai NN 40436 8878 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8878 23 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8878 24 e)pai e)pai NNP 40436 8878 25 / / SYM 40436 8878 26 nous nous JJ 40436 8878 27 e)painou e)painou , 40436 8878 28 = = SYM 40436 8878 29 si si NNP 40436 8878 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8878 31 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8878 32 pso pso NNP 40436 8878 33 / / SYM 40436 8878 34 gous gous NNP 40436 8878 35 pse pse NN 40436 8878 36 / / SYM 40436 8878 37 gousin gousin NN 40436 8878 38 , , , 40436 8878 39 e)kphobou e)kphobou , 40436 8878 40 = = SYM 40436 8878 41 nte nte NNP 40436 8878 42 / / SYM 40436 8878 43 s s NNP 40436 8878 44 te te NNP 40436 8878 45 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8878 46 e)r)r(ômeneste e)r)r(ômeneste NNP 40436 8878 47 / / SYM 40436 8878 48 rous rous JJ 40436 8878 49 tô tô NN 40436 8878 50 = = NFP 40436 8878 51 n n NNP 40436 8878 52 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 8878 53 / / SYM 40436 8878 54 pôn pôn NNP 40436 8878 55 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8878 56 dunatou\s dunatou\s ADD 40436 8878 57 o)/ntas o)/ntas NNP 40436 8878 58 ple ple NNP 40436 8878 59 / / SYM 40436 8878 60 on on IN 40436 8878 61 e)/chein e)/chein NNP 40436 8878 62 , , , 40436 8878 63 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 8878 64 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 8878 65 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 8878 66 = = SYM 40436 8878 67 n n CC 40436 8878 68 ple ple NN 40436 8878 69 / / SYM 40436 8878 70 on on IN 40436 8878 71 e)/chôsin e)/chôsin NNP 40436 8878 72 , , , 40436 8878 73 le le NNP 40436 8878 74 / / SYM 40436 8878 75 gousin gousin NNP 40436 8878 76 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 8878 77 ai)schro\n ai)schro\n NNP 40436 8878 78 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8878 79 a)/dikon a)/dikon NNP 40436 8878 80 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8878 81 pleonektei pleonektei NNP 40436 8878 82 = = SYM 40436 8878 83 n n NNP 40436 8878 84 , , , 40436 8878 85 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8878 86 tou tou NNP 40436 8878 87 = = SYM 40436 8878 88 to to IN 40436 8878 89 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 8878 90 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8878 91 a)dikei a)dikei NNP 40436 8878 92 = = SYM 40436 8878 93 n n NN 40436 8878 94 , , , 40436 8878 95 to\ to\ NN 40436 8878 96 zêtei zêtei NNP 40436 8878 97 = = SYM 40436 8878 98 n n CC 40436 8878 99 tô tô NNP 40436 8878 100 = = SYM 40436 8878 101 n n NN 40436 8878 102 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 8878 103 ple ple NN 40436 8878 104 / / SYM 40436 8878 105 on on IN 40436 8878 106 e)/chein e)/chein NNS 40436 8878 107 ; ; : 40436 8878 108 a)gapô a)gapô ADD 40436 8878 109 = = SYM 40436 8878 110 si si NNP 40436 8878 111 ga ga NNP 40436 8878 112 / / SYM 40436 8878 113 r r NNP 40436 8878 114 , , , 40436 8878 115 oi)=mai oi)=mai CD 40436 8878 116 , , , 40436 8878 117 au)toi\ au)toi\ NNP 40436 8878 118 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 8878 119 to\ to\ NN 40436 8878 120 i)/son i)/son NNP 40436 8878 121 e)/chôsi e)/chôsi VB 40436 8878 122 phaulo phaulo NN 40436 8878 123 / / SYM 40436 8878 124 teroi teroi JJ 40436 8878 125 o)/ntes o)/nte NNS 40436 8878 126 . . . 40436 8878 127 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8878 128 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8879 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8879 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8879 3 55 55 CD 40436 8879 4 : : : 40436 8879 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8879 6 , , , 40436 8879 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8879 8 , , , 40436 8879 9 pp pp NNP 40436 8879 10 . . . 40436 8880 1 484 484 CD 40436 8880 2 - - SYM 40436 8880 3 488 488 CD 40436 8880 4 . . . 40436 8880 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8881 1 But but CC 40436 8881 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8881 3 rejoins rejoin VBZ 40436 8881 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8881 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8881 6 the the DT 40436 8881 7 many many JJ 40436 8881 8 are be VBP 40436 8881 9 by by IN 40436 8881 10 nature nature NN 40436 8881 11 stronger strong JJR 40436 8881 12 than than IN 40436 8881 13 the the DT 40436 8881 14 one one NN 40436 8881 15 ; ; : 40436 8881 16 since since IN 40436 8881 17 , , , 40436 8881 18 as as IN 40436 8881 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8881 20 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 8881 21 say say VBP 40436 8881 22 , , , 40436 8881 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8881 24 make make VBP 40436 8881 25 and and CC 40436 8881 26 enforce enforce VB 40436 8881 27 laws law NNS 40436 8881 28 to to TO 40436 8881 29 restrain restrain VB 40436 8881 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8881 31 and and CC 40436 8881 32 defeat defeat VB 40436 8881 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8881 34 projects project NNS 40436 8881 35 . . . 40436 8882 1 Therefore therefore RB 40436 8882 2 , , , 40436 8882 3 since since IN 40436 8882 4 the the DT 40436 8882 5 many many JJ 40436 8882 6 are be VBP 40436 8882 7 the the DT 40436 8882 8 strongest strong JJS 40436 8882 9 , , , 40436 8882 10 the the DT 40436 8882 11 right right NN 40436 8882 12 which which WDT 40436 8882 13 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8882 14 establish establish VBP 40436 8882 15 is be VBZ 40436 8882 16 the the DT 40436 8882 17 right right NN 40436 8882 18 of of IN 40436 8882 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8882 20 or or CC 40436 8882 21 by by IN 40436 8882 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8882 23 nature nature NN 40436 8882 24 . . . 40436 8883 1 And and CC 40436 8883 2 the the DT 40436 8883 3 many many JJ 40436 8883 4 , , , 40436 8883 5 as as IN 40436 8883 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 8883 7 admit admit VBP 40436 8883 8 , , , 40436 8883 9 declare declare VB 40436 8883 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8883 11 in in IN 40436 8883 12 favour favour NN 40436 8883 13 of of IN 40436 8883 14 the the DT 40436 8883 15 answer answer NN 40436 8883 16 given give VBN 40436 8883 17 by by IN 40436 8883 18 Polus Polus NNP 40436 8883 19 -- -- : 40436 8883 20 That that DT 40436 8883 21 to to TO 40436 8883 22 do do VB 40436 8883 23 wrong wrong NN 40436 8883 24 is be VBZ 40436 8883 25 more more RBR 40436 8883 26 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 8883 27 than than IN 40436 8883 28 to to TO 40436 8883 29 suffer suffer VB 40436 8883 30 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8883 31 . . . 40436 8884 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8884 2 56 56 CD 40436 8884 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8884 4 Right right RB 40436 8884 5 by by IN 40436 8884 6 nature nature NN 40436 8884 7 , , , 40436 8884 8 and and CC 40436 8884 9 right right RB 40436 8884 10 by by IN 40436 8884 11 institution institution NN 40436 8884 12 , , , 40436 8884 13 sanction sanction NN 40436 8884 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8884 15 alike alike RB 40436 8884 16 . . . 40436 8885 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8885 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8885 3 56 56 CD 40436 8885 4 : : : 40436 8885 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8885 6 , , , 40436 8885 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8885 8 , , , 40436 8885 9 p. p. NN 40436 8885 10 488 488 CD 40436 8885 11 D D NNP 40436 8885 12 - - HYPH 40436 8885 13 E. e. NN 40436 8885 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8885 15 * * NFP 40436 8885 16 * * NFP 40436 8885 17 * * NFP 40436 8885 18 * * NFP 40436 8885 19 * * NFP 40436 8885 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8885 21 Side side NN 40436 8885 22 - - HYPH 40436 8885 23 note note NN 40436 8885 24 : : : 40436 8885 25 What what WP 40436 8885 26 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNP 40436 8885 27 says say VBZ 40436 8885 28 is be VBZ 40436 8885 29 not not RB 40436 8885 30 to to TO 40436 8885 31 be be VB 40436 8885 32 taken take VBN 40436 8885 33 as as IN 40436 8885 34 a a DT 40436 8885 35 sample sample NN 40436 8885 36 of of IN 40436 8885 37 the the DT 40436 8885 38 teachings teaching NNS 40436 8885 39 of of IN 40436 8885 40 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8885 41 sophists sophist NNS 40436 8885 42 . . . 40436 8886 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 8886 2 -- -- : 40436 8886 3 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 8886 4 and and CC 40436 8886 5 politician politician NN 40436 8886 6 . . . 40436 8886 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8887 1 Several several JJ 40436 8887 2 commentators commentator NNS 40436 8887 3 have have VBP 40436 8887 4 contended contend VBN 40436 8887 5 , , , 40436 8887 6 that that IN 40436 8887 7 the the DT 40436 8887 8 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8887 9 which which WDT 40436 8887 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8887 11 here here RB 40436 8887 12 puts put VBZ 40436 8887 13 into into IN 40436 8887 14 the the DT 40436 8887 15 mouth mouth NN 40436 8887 16 of of IN 40436 8887 17 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8887 18 was be VBD 40436 8887 19 taught teach VBN 40436 8887 20 by by IN 40436 8887 21 the the DT 40436 8887 22 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 8887 23 at at IN 40436 8887 24 Athens Athens NNP 40436 8887 25 : : : 40436 8887 26 who who WP 40436 8887 27 are be VBP 40436 8887 28 said say VBN 40436 8887 29 to to TO 40436 8887 30 have have VB 40436 8887 31 inculcated inculcate VBN 40436 8887 32 on on IN 40436 8887 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8887 34 hearers hearer NNS 40436 8887 35 that that IN 40436 8887 36 true true JJ 40436 8887 37 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 8887 38 and and CC 40436 8887 39 morality morality NN 40436 8887 40 consisted consist VBD 40436 8887 41 in in IN 40436 8887 42 acting act VBG 40436 8887 43 upon upon IN 40436 8887 44 the the DT 40436 8887 45 right right NN 40436 8887 46 of of IN 40436 8887 47 the the DT 40436 8887 48 strongest strong JJS 40436 8887 49 and and CC 40436 8887 50 taking take VBG 40436 8887 51 whatever whatever WDT 40436 8887 52 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8887 53 could could MD 40436 8887 54 get get VB 40436 8887 55 , , , 40436 8887 56 without without IN 40436 8887 57 any any DT 40436 8887 58 regard regard NN 40436 8887 59 to to IN 40436 8887 60 law law NN 40436 8887 61 or or CC 40436 8887 62 justice justice NN 40436 8887 63 . . . 40436 8888 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8888 2 have have VBP 40436 8888 3 already already RB 40436 8888 4 endeavoured endeavour VBN 40436 8888 5 to to TO 40436 8888 6 show show VB 40436 8888 7 , , , 40436 8888 8 in in IN 40436 8888 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8888 10 History history NN 40436 8888 11 of of IN 40436 8888 12 Greece Greece NNP 40436 8888 13 , , , 40436 8888 14 that that IN 40436 8888 15 the the DT 40436 8888 16 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 8888 17 can can MD 40436 8888 18 not not RB 40436 8888 19 be be VB 40436 8888 20 shown show VBN 40436 8888 21 to to TO 40436 8888 22 have have VB 40436 8888 23 taught teach VBN 40436 8888 24 either either CC 40436 8888 25 this this DT 40436 8888 26 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8888 27 , , , 40436 8888 28 or or CC 40436 8888 29 any any DT 40436 8888 30 other other JJ 40436 8888 31 common common JJ 40436 8888 32 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8888 33 : : : 40436 8888 34 that that IN 40436 8888 35 one one CD 40436 8888 36 at at IN 40436 8888 37 least least JJS 40436 8888 38 among among IN 40436 8888 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8888 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8888 41 Prodikus Prodikus NNP 40436 8888 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8888 43 taught teach VBD 40436 8888 44 a a DT 40436 8888 45 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8888 46 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 8888 47 with with IN 40436 8888 48 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8888 49 : : : 40436 8888 50 and and CC 40436 8888 51 that that IN 40436 8888 52 while while IN 40436 8888 53 all all DT 40436 8888 54 of of IN 40436 8888 55 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8888 56 agreed agree VBD 40436 8888 57 in in RP 40436 8888 58 trying try VBG 40436 8888 59 to to TO 40436 8888 60 impart impart VB 40436 8888 61 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 8888 62 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 8888 63 , , , 40436 8888 64 or or CC 40436 8888 65 the the DT 40436 8888 66 power power NN 40436 8888 67 of of IN 40436 8888 68 handling handle VBG 40436 8888 69 political political JJ 40436 8888 70 , , , 40436 8888 71 ethical ethical JJ 40436 8888 72 , , , 40436 8888 73 judicial judicial JJ 40436 8888 74 , , , 40436 8888 75 matters matter NNS 40436 8888 76 in in IN 40436 8888 77 a a DT 40436 8888 78 manner manner NN 40436 8888 79 suitable suitable JJ 40436 8888 80 for for IN 40436 8888 81 the the DT 40436 8888 82 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8888 83 public public NN 40436 8888 84 -- -- : 40436 8888 85 each each DT 40436 8888 86 had have VBD 40436 8888 87 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8888 88 own own JJ 40436 8888 89 way way NN 40436 8888 90 of of IN 40436 8888 91 doing do VBG 40436 8888 92 this this DT 40436 8888 93 . . . 40436 8889 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 8889 2 is be VBZ 40436 8889 3 not not RB 40436 8889 4 presented present VBN 40436 8889 5 by by IN 40436 8889 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8889 7 as as IN 40436 8889 8 a a DT 40436 8889 9 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8889 10 , , , 40436 8889 11 but but CC 40436 8889 12 as as IN 40436 8889 13 a a DT 40436 8889 14 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 8889 15 aspiring aspire VBG 40436 8889 16 to to IN 40436 8889 17 active active JJ 40436 8889 18 political political JJ 40436 8889 19 influence influence NN 40436 8889 20 ; ; , 40436 8889 21 and and CC 40436 8889 22 taking take VBG 40436 8889 23 a a DT 40436 8889 24 small small JJ 40436 8889 25 dose dose NN 40436 8889 26 of of IN 40436 8889 27 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 8889 28 , , , 40436 8889 29 among among IN 40436 8889 30 the the DT 40436 8889 31 preparations preparation NNS 40436 8889 32 for for IN 40436 8889 33 that that DT 40436 8889 34 end end NN 40436 8889 35 . . . 40436 8890 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8890 2 57 57 CD 40436 8890 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8890 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8890 5 depreciates depreciate VBZ 40436 8890 6 the the DT 40436 8890 7 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 8890 8 as as RB 40436 8890 9 much much RB 40436 8890 10 as as IN 40436 8890 11 the the DT 40436 8890 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 8890 13 , , , 40436 8890 14 and and CC 40436 8890 15 in in IN 40436 8890 16 fact fact NN 40436 8890 17 rather rather RB 40436 8890 18 more more JJR 40436 8890 19 . . . 40436 8891 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8891 2 58 58 CD 40436 8891 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8891 4 Moreover moreover RB 40436 8891 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8891 6 represents represent VBZ 40436 8891 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8891 8 as as IN 40436 8891 9 adapting adapt VBG 40436 8891 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8891 11 , , , 40436 8891 12 with with IN 40436 8891 13 accommodating accommodate VBG 40436 8891 14 subservience subservience NN 40436 8891 15 , , , 40436 8891 16 to to IN 40436 8891 17 the the DT 40436 8891 18 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8891 19 public public JJ 40436 8891 20 assembly assembly NN 40436 8891 21 , , , 40436 8891 22 and and CC 40436 8891 23 saying say VBG 40436 8891 24 or or CC 40436 8891 25 unsaying unsay VBG 40436 8891 26 exactly exactly RB 40436 8891 27 as as IN 40436 8891 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8891 29 manifested manifest VBD 40436 8891 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8891 31 opinion opinion NN 40436 8891 32 . . . 40436 8892 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8892 2 59 59 CD 40436 8892 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8892 4 Now now RB 40436 8892 5 the the DT 40436 8892 6 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8892 7 public public JJ 40436 8892 8 assembly assembly NN 40436 8892 9 would would MD 40436 8892 10 repudiate repudiate VB 40436 8892 11 indignantly indignantly RB 40436 8892 12 all all PDT 40436 8892 13 this this DT 40436 8892 14 pretended pretend VBD 40436 8892 15 right right NN 40436 8892 16 of of IN 40436 8892 17 the the DT 40436 8892 18 strongest strong JJS 40436 8892 19 , , , 40436 8892 20 if if IN 40436 8892 21 any any DT 40436 8892 22 orator orator NN 40436 8892 23 thought think VBD 40436 8892 24 fit fit JJ 40436 8892 25 to to TO 40436 8892 26 put put VB 40436 8892 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8892 28 forward forward RB 40436 8892 29 as as IN 40436 8892 30 over over RB 40436 8892 31 - - HYPH 40436 8892 32 ruling rule VBG 40436 8892 33 established establish VBN 40436 8892 34 right right NN 40436 8892 35 and and CC 40436 8892 36 law law NN 40436 8892 37 . . . 40436 8893 1 Any any DT 40436 8893 2 aspiring aspire VBG 40436 8893 3 or or CC 40436 8893 4 subservient subservient NN 40436 8893 5 orator orator NN 40436 8893 6 , , , 40436 8893 7 such such JJ 40436 8893 8 as as IN 40436 8893 9 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNP 40436 8893 10 is be VBZ 40436 8893 11 described describe VBN 40436 8893 12 , , , 40436 8893 13 would would MD 40436 8893 14 know know VB 40436 8893 15 better well RBR 40436 8893 16 than than IN 40436 8893 17 to to TO 40436 8893 18 address address VB 40436 8893 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8893 20 in in IN 40436 8893 21 this this DT 40436 8893 22 strain strain NN 40436 8893 23 . . . 40436 8894 1 The the DT 40436 8894 2 language language NN 40436 8894 3 which which WDT 40436 8894 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8894 5 puts put VBZ 40436 8894 6 into into IN 40436 8894 7 the the DT 40436 8894 8 mouth mouth NN 40436 8894 9 of of IN 40436 8894 10 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8894 11 is be VBZ 40436 8894 12 noway noway RB 40436 8894 13 consistent consistent JJ 40436 8894 14 with with IN 40436 8894 15 the the DT 40436 8894 16 attribute attribute NN 40436 8894 17 which which WDT 40436 8894 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8894 19 also also RB 40436 8894 20 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 8894 21 to to IN 40436 8894 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8894 23 -- -- : 40436 8894 24 slavish slavish JJ 40436 8894 25 deference deference NN 40436 8894 26 to to IN 40436 8894 27 the the DT 40436 8894 28 judgments judgment NNS 40436 8894 29 of of IN 40436 8894 30 the the DT 40436 8894 31 Athenian Athenian NNP 40436 8894 32 Dêmos Dêmos NNP 40436 8894 33 . . . 40436 8895 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8895 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8895 3 57 57 CD 40436 8895 4 : : : 40436 8895 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8895 6 , , , 40436 8895 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8895 8 , , , 40436 8895 9 p. p. NN 40436 8895 10 487 487 CD 40436 8895 11 C c NN 40436 8895 12 , , , 40436 8895 13 485 485 CD 40436 8895 14 . . . 40436 8895 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8896 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8896 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8896 3 58 58 CD 40436 8896 4 : : : 40436 8896 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8896 6 , , , 40436 8896 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8896 8 , , , 40436 8896 9 p. p. NN 40436 8896 10 520 520 CD 40436 8896 11 A. a. NN 40436 8896 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8897 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8897 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 8897 3 59 59 CD 40436 8897 4 : : : 40436 8897 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8897 6 , , , 40436 8897 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8897 8 , , , 40436 8897 9 p. p. NN 40436 8898 1 481 481 CD 40436 8898 2 - - SYM 40436 8898 3 482 482 CD 40436 8898 4 . . . 40436 8898 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8899 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8899 2 Side side NN 40436 8899 3 - - HYPH 40436 8899 4 note note NN 40436 8899 5 : : : 40436 8899 6 Uncertainty uncertainty NN 40436 8899 7 of of IN 40436 8899 8 referring refer VBG 40436 8899 9 to to IN 40436 8899 10 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8899 11 as as IN 40436 8899 12 an an DT 40436 8899 13 authority authority NN 40436 8899 14 . . . 40436 8900 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8900 2 may may MD 40436 8900 3 be be VB 40436 8900 4 pleaded plead VBN 40436 8900 5 in in IN 40436 8900 6 favour favour NN 40436 8900 7 of of IN 40436 8900 8 opposite opposite JJ 40436 8900 9 theories theory NNS 40436 8900 10 . . . 40436 8901 1 The the DT 40436 8901 2 theory theory NN 40436 8901 3 of of IN 40436 8901 4 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8901 5 is be VBZ 40436 8901 6 made make VBN 40436 8901 7 to to TO 40436 8901 8 appear appear VB 40436 8901 9 repulsive repulsive JJ 40436 8901 10 by by IN 40436 8901 11 the the DT 40436 8901 12 language language NN 40436 8901 13 in in IN 40436 8901 14 which which WDT 40436 8901 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8901 16 expresses express VBZ 40436 8901 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8901 18 . . . 40436 8901 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8902 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 8902 2 is be VBZ 40436 8902 3 made make VBN 40436 8902 4 to to TO 40436 8902 5 speak speak VB 40436 8902 6 like like IN 40436 8902 7 one one CD 40436 8902 8 who who WP 40436 8902 9 sympathises sympathise VBZ 40436 8902 10 with with IN 40436 8902 11 the the DT 40436 8902 12 right right NN 40436 8902 13 of of IN 40436 8902 14 the the DT 40436 8902 15 strongest strong JJS 40436 8902 16 , , , 40436 8902 17 and and CC 40436 8902 18 who who WP 40436 8902 19 decorates decorate VBZ 40436 8902 20 such such JJ 40436 8902 21 iniquity iniquity NN 40436 8902 22 with with IN 40436 8902 23 the the DT 40436 8902 24 name name NN 40436 8902 25 and and CC 40436 8902 26 authority authority NN 40436 8902 27 of of IN 40436 8902 28 that that DT 40436 8902 29 which which WDT 40436 8902 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8902 31 calls call VBZ 40436 8902 32 Nature nature NN 40436 8902 33 . . . 40436 8903 1 But but CC 40436 8903 2 this this DT 40436 8903 3 only only RB 40436 8903 4 shows show VBZ 40436 8903 5 the the DT 40436 8903 6 uncertainty uncertainty NN 40436 8903 7 of of IN 40436 8903 8 referring refer VBG 40436 8903 9 to to IN 40436 8903 10 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8903 11 as as IN 40436 8903 12 an an DT 40436 8903 13 authority authority NN 40436 8903 14 . . . 40436 8904 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8904 2 60 60 CD 40436 8904 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8904 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8904 5 may may MD 40436 8904 6 be be VB 40436 8904 7 pleaded plead VBN 40436 8904 8 in in IN 40436 8904 9 favour favour NN 40436 8904 10 of of IN 40436 8904 11 different different JJ 40436 8904 12 and and CC 40436 8904 13 opposite opposite JJ 40436 8904 14 theories theory NNS 40436 8904 15 . . . 40436 8905 1 Nature nature NN 40436 8905 2 prompts prompt VBZ 40436 8905 3 the the DT 40436 8905 4 strong strong JJ 40436 8905 5 man man NN 40436 8905 6 to to TO 40436 8905 7 take take VB 40436 8905 8 from from IN 40436 8905 9 weaker weak JJR 40436 8905 10 men man NNS 40436 8905 11 what what WP 40436 8905 12 will will MD 40436 8905 13 gratify gratify VB 40436 8905 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8905 15 desires desire NNS 40436 8905 16 : : : 40436 8905 17 Nature nature NN 40436 8905 18 also also RB 40436 8905 19 prompts prompt VBZ 40436 8905 20 these these DT 40436 8905 21 weaker weak JJR 40436 8905 22 men man NNS 40436 8905 23 to to TO 40436 8905 24 defeat defeat VB 40436 8905 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8905 26 and and CC 40436 8905 27 protect protect VB 40436 8905 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8905 29 by by IN 40436 8905 30 the the DT 40436 8905 31 best good JJS 40436 8905 32 means mean NNS 40436 8905 33 in in IN 40436 8905 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8905 35 power power NN 40436 8905 36 . . . 40436 8906 1 The the DT 40436 8906 2 many many JJ 40436 8906 3 are be VBP 40436 8906 4 weaker weak JJR 40436 8906 5 , , , 40436 8906 6 taken take VBN 40436 8906 7 individually individually RB 40436 8906 8 -- -- : 40436 8906 9 stronger strong JJR 40436 8906 10 taken take VBN 40436 8906 11 collectively collectively RB 40436 8906 12 : : : 40436 8906 13 hence hence RB 40436 8906 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8906 15 resort resort VBP 40436 8906 16 to to IN 40436 8906 17 defensive defensive JJ 40436 8906 18 combination combination NN 40436 8906 19 , , , 40436 8906 20 established establish VBN 40436 8906 21 rules rule NNS 40436 8906 22 , , , 40436 8906 23 and and CC 40436 8906 24 collective collective JJ 40436 8906 25 authority authority NN 40436 8906 26 . . . 40436 8907 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8907 2 61 61 CD 40436 8907 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8907 4 The the DT 40436 8907 5 right right NN 40436 8907 6 created create VBD 40436 8907 7 on on IN 40436 8907 8 one one CD 40436 8907 9 side side NN 40436 8907 10 , , , 40436 8907 11 and and CC 40436 8907 12 the the DT 40436 8907 13 opposite opposite JJ 40436 8907 14 right right RB 40436 8907 15 created create VBN 40436 8907 16 on on IN 40436 8907 17 the the DT 40436 8907 18 other other JJ 40436 8907 19 , , , 40436 8907 20 flow flow VB 40436 8907 21 alike alike RB 40436 8907 22 from from IN 40436 8907 23 Nature nature NN 40436 8907 24 : : : 40436 8907 25 that that RB 40436 8907 26 is is RB 40436 8907 27 , , , 40436 8907 28 from from IN 40436 8907 29 propensities propensity NNS 40436 8907 30 and and CC 40436 8907 31 principles principle NNS 40436 8907 32 natural natural JJ 40436 8907 33 , , , 40436 8907 34 and and CC 40436 8907 35 deeply deeply RB 40436 8907 36 seated seat VBN 40436 8907 37 , , , 40436 8907 38 in in IN 40436 8907 39 the the DT 40436 8907 40 human human JJ 40436 8907 41 mind mind NN 40436 8907 42 . . . 40436 8908 1 The the DT 40436 8908 2 authority authority NN 40436 8908 3 of of IN 40436 8908 4 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8908 5 , , , 40436 8908 6 considered consider VBN 40436 8908 7 as as IN 40436 8908 8 an an DT 40436 8908 9 enunciation enunciation NN 40436 8908 10 of of IN 40436 8908 11 actual actual JJ 40436 8908 12 and and CC 40436 8908 13 wide wide JJ 40436 8908 14 - - HYPH 40436 8908 15 spread spread VBN 40436 8908 16 facts fact NNS 40436 8908 17 , , , 40436 8908 18 may may MD 40436 8908 19 be be VB 40436 8908 20 pleaded plead VBN 40436 8908 21 for for IN 40436 8908 22 both both DT 40436 8908 23 alike alike RB 40436 8908 24 . . . 40436 8909 1 But but CC 40436 8909 2 a a DT 40436 8909 3 man man NN 40436 8909 4 's 's POS 40436 8909 5 sympathy sympathy NN 40436 8909 6 and and CC 40436 8909 7 approbation approbation NN 40436 8909 8 may may MD 40436 8909 9 go go VB 40436 8909 10 either either CC 40436 8909 11 with with IN 40436 8909 12 the the DT 40436 8909 13 one one CD 40436 8909 14 or or CC 40436 8909 15 the the DT 40436 8909 16 other other JJ 40436 8909 17 ; ; : 40436 8909 18 and and CC 40436 8909 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8909 20 may may MD 40436 8909 21 choose choose VB 40436 8909 22 to to TO 40436 8909 23 stamp stamp VB 40436 8909 24 that that IN 40436 8909 25 which which WDT 40436 8909 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8909 27 approves approve VBZ 40436 8909 28 , , , 40436 8909 29 with with IN 40436 8909 30 the the DT 40436 8909 31 name name NN 40436 8909 32 of of IN 40436 8909 33 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8909 34 as as IN 40436 8909 35 a a DT 40436 8909 36 personified personified JJ 40436 8909 37 law law NN 40436 8909 38 - - HYPH 40436 8909 39 maker maker NN 40436 8909 40 . . . 40436 8910 1 This this DT 40436 8910 2 is be VBZ 40436 8910 3 what what WP 40436 8910 4 is be VBZ 40436 8910 5 here here RB 40436 8910 6 done do VBN 40436 8910 7 by by IN 40436 8910 8 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8910 9 as as IN 40436 8910 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8910 11 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 8910 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8910 13 . . . 40436 8911 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8911 2 62 62 CD 40436 8911 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8911 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8911 5 sympathises sympathise VBZ 40436 8911 6 with with IN 40436 8911 7 , , , 40436 8911 8 and and CC 40436 8911 9 approves approve NNS 40436 8911 10 , , , 40436 8911 11 the the DT 40436 8911 12 powerful powerful JJ 40436 8911 13 individual individual NN 40436 8911 14 . . . 40436 8912 1 Now now RB 40436 8912 2 the the DT 40436 8912 3 greater great JJR 40436 8912 4 portion portion NN 40436 8912 5 of of IN 40436 8912 6 mankind mankind NN 40436 8912 7 are be VBP 40436 8912 8 , , , 40436 8912 9 and and CC 40436 8912 10 always always RB 40436 8912 11 have have VBP 40436 8912 12 been be VBN 40436 8912 13 , , , 40436 8912 14 governed govern VBN 40436 8912 15 upon upon IN 40436 8912 16 this this DT 40436 8912 17 despotic despotic JJ 40436 8912 18 principle principle NN 40436 8912 19 , , , 40436 8912 20 and and CC 40436 8912 21 brought bring VBD 40436 8912 22 up up RP 40436 8912 23 to to TO 40436 8912 24 respect respect VB 40436 8912 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8912 26 : : : 40436 8912 27 while while IN 40436 8912 28 many many JJ 40436 8912 29 , , , 40436 8912 30 even even RB 40436 8912 31 of of IN 40436 8912 32 those those DT 40436 8912 33 who who WP 40436 8912 34 dislike dislike VBP 40436 8912 35 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8912 36 because because IN 40436 8912 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8912 38 regard regard VBP 40436 8912 39 him -PRON- PRP 40436 8912 40 as as IN 40436 8912 41 the the DT 40436 8912 42 representative representative NN 40436 8912 43 of of IN 40436 8912 44 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8912 45 democracy democracy NN 40436 8912 46 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8912 47 to to TO 40436 8912 48 which which WDT 40436 8912 49 however however RB 40436 8912 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8912 51 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 8912 52 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 8912 53 stand stand VBP 40436 8912 54 pointedly pointedly RB 40436 8912 55 opposed opposed JJ 40436 8912 56 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8912 57 , , , 40436 8912 58 when when WRB 40436 8912 59 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8912 60 come come VBP 40436 8912 61 across across IN 40436 8912 62 a a DT 40436 8912 63 great great JJ 40436 8912 64 man man NN 40436 8912 65 or or CC 40436 8912 66 so so RB 40436 8912 67 - - HYPH 40436 8912 68 called call VBN 40436 8912 69 hero hero NN 40436 8912 70 , , , 40436 8912 71 such such JJ 40436 8912 72 as as IN 40436 8912 73 Alexander Alexander NNP 40436 8912 74 or or CC 40436 8912 75 Napoleon Napoleon NNP 40436 8912 76 , , , 40436 8912 77 applaud applaud VB 40436 8912 78 the the DT 40436 8912 79 most most RBS 40436 8912 80 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 8912 81 ambition ambition NN 40436 8912 82 if if IN 40436 8912 83 successful successful JJ 40436 8912 84 , , , 40436 8912 85 and and CC 40436 8912 86 if if IN 40436 8912 87 accompanied accompany VBN 40436 8912 88 by by IN 40436 8912 89 military military JJ 40436 8912 90 genius genius NN 40436 8912 91 and and CC 40436 8912 92 energy energy NN 40436 8912 93 -- -- : 40436 8912 94 regarding regard VBG 40436 8912 95 communities community NNS 40436 8912 96 as as IN 40436 8912 97 made make VBN 40436 8912 98 for for IN 40436 8912 99 little little JJ 40436 8912 100 else else RB 40436 8912 101 except except IN 40436 8912 102 to to TO 40436 8912 103 serve serve VB 40436 8912 104 as as IN 40436 8912 105 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8912 106 instruments instrument NNS 40436 8912 107 , , , 40436 8912 108 subjects subject NNS 40436 8912 109 , , , 40436 8912 110 and and CC 40436 8912 111 worshippers worshipper NNS 40436 8912 112 . . . 40436 8913 1 Such such JJ 40436 8913 2 are be VBP 40436 8913 3 represented represent VBN 40436 8913 4 as as IN 40436 8913 5 the the DT 40436 8913 6 sympathies sympathy NNS 40436 8913 7 of of IN 40436 8913 8 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8913 9 : : : 40436 8913 10 but but CC 40436 8913 11 those those DT 40436 8913 12 of of IN 40436 8913 13 the the DT 40436 8913 14 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 8913 15 went go VBD 40436 8913 16 with with IN 40436 8913 17 the the DT 40436 8913 18 second second JJ 40436 8913 19 of of IN 40436 8913 20 the the DT 40436 8913 21 two two CD 40436 8913 22 rights right NNS 40436 8913 23 -- -- : 40436 8913 24 and and CC 40436 8913 25 mine -PRON- PRP 40436 8913 26 go go VBP 40436 8913 27 with with IN 40436 8913 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8913 29 also also RB 40436 8913 30 . . . 40436 8914 1 And and CC 40436 8914 2 though though IN 40436 8914 3 the the DT 40436 8914 4 language language NN 40436 8914 5 which which WDT 40436 8914 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8914 7 puts put VBZ 40436 8914 8 into into IN 40436 8914 9 the the DT 40436 8914 10 mouth mouth NN 40436 8914 11 of of IN 40436 8914 12 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8914 13 , , , 40436 8914 14 in in IN 40436 8914 15 describing describe VBG 40436 8914 16 this this DT 40436 8914 17 second second JJ 40436 8914 18 right right NN 40436 8914 19 , , , 40436 8914 20 abounds abound VBZ 40436 8914 21 in in IN 40436 8914 22 contemptuous contemptuous JJ 40436 8914 23 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 8914 24 , , , 40436 8914 25 proclaiming proclaim VBG 40436 8914 26 offensively offensively RB 40436 8914 27 the the DT 40436 8914 28 individual individual JJ 40436 8914 29 weakness weakness NN 40436 8914 30 of of IN 40436 8914 31 the the DT 40436 8914 32 multitude[63]--yet multitude[63]--yet NNS 40436 8914 33 this this DT 40436 8914 34 very very JJ 40436 8914 35 fact fact NN 40436 8914 36 is be VBZ 40436 8914 37 at at IN 40436 8914 38 once once RB 40436 8914 39 the the DT 40436 8914 40 most most RBS 40436 8914 41 solid solid JJ 40436 8914 42 and and CC 40436 8914 43 most most RBS 40436 8914 44 respectable respectable JJ 40436 8914 45 foundation foundation NN 40436 8914 46 on on IN 40436 8914 47 which which WDT 40436 8914 48 rights right NNS 40436 8914 49 and and CC 40436 8914 50 obligations obligation NNS 40436 8914 51 can can MD 40436 8914 52 be be VB 40436 8914 53 based base VBN 40436 8914 54 . . . 40436 8915 1 The the DT 40436 8915 2 establishment establishment NN 40436 8915 3 of of IN 40436 8915 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8915 5 is be VBZ 40436 8915 6 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 8915 7 , , , 40436 8915 8 and and CC 40436 8915 9 is be VBZ 40436 8915 10 felt feel VBN 40436 8915 11 as as IN 40436 8915 12 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 8915 13 , , , 40436 8915 14 to to TO 40436 8915 15 procure procure VB 40436 8915 16 security security NN 40436 8915 17 for for IN 40436 8915 18 the the DT 40436 8915 19 community community NN 40436 8915 20 : : : 40436 8915 21 whereby whereby WRB 40436 8915 22 the the DT 40436 8915 23 strong strong JJ 40436 8915 24 man man NN 40436 8915 25 whom whom WP 40436 8915 26 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8915 27 extols extol VBZ 40436 8915 28 as as IN 40436 8915 29 the the DT 40436 8915 30 favourite favourite NN 40436 8915 31 of of IN 40436 8915 32 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8915 33 , , , 40436 8915 34 may may MD 40436 8915 35 be be VB 40436 8915 36 tamed tame VBN 40436 8915 37 by by IN 40436 8915 38 discipline discipline NN 40436 8915 39 and and CC 40436 8915 40 censure censure NN 40436 8915 41 , , , 40436 8915 42 so so IN 40436 8915 43 as as IN 40436 8915 44 to to TO 40436 8915 45 accommodate accommodate VB 40436 8915 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8915 47 own own JJ 40436 8915 48 behaviour behaviour NN 40436 8915 49 to to IN 40436 8915 50 this this DT 40436 8915 51 equitable equitable JJ 40436 8915 52 arrangement arrangement NN 40436 8915 53 . . . 40436 8916 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8916 2 64 64 CD 40436 8916 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8916 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8916 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8916 6 , , , 40436 8916 7 in in IN 40436 8916 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8916 9 Republic,[65 republic,[65 NN 40436 8916 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8916 11 traces trace VBZ 40436 8916 12 the the DT 40436 8916 13 generation generation NN 40436 8916 14 of of IN 40436 8916 15 a a DT 40436 8916 16 city city NN 40436 8916 17 to to IN 40436 8916 18 the the DT 40436 8916 19 fact fact NN 40436 8916 20 that that IN 40436 8916 21 each each DT 40436 8916 22 man man NN 40436 8916 23 individually individually RB 40436 8916 24 taken take VBN 40436 8916 25 is be VBZ 40436 8916 26 not not RB 40436 8916 27 self self NN 40436 8916 28 - - HYPH 40436 8916 29 sufficing suffice VBG 40436 8916 30 , , , 40436 8916 31 but but CC 40436 8916 32 stands stand VBZ 40436 8916 33 in in IN 40436 8916 34 need need NN 40436 8916 35 of of IN 40436 8916 36 many many JJ 40436 8916 37 things thing NNS 40436 8916 38 : : : 40436 8916 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8916 40 is be VBZ 40436 8916 41 no no DT 40436 8916 42 less less RBR 40436 8916 43 true true JJ 40436 8916 44 , , , 40436 8916 45 that that IN 40436 8916 46 each each DT 40436 8916 47 man man NN 40436 8916 48 stands stand VBZ 40436 8916 49 also also RB 40436 8916 50 in in IN 40436 8916 51 fear fear NN 40436 8916 52 of of IN 40436 8916 53 many many JJ 40436 8916 54 things thing NNS 40436 8916 55 , , , 40436 8916 56 especially especially RB 40436 8916 57 of of IN 40436 8916 58 depredations depredation NNS 40436 8916 59 from from IN 40436 8916 60 animals animal NNS 40436 8916 61 , , , 40436 8916 62 and and CC 40436 8916 63 depredations depredation NNS 40436 8916 64 from from IN 40436 8916 65 powerful powerful JJ 40436 8916 66 individuals individual NNS 40436 8916 67 of of IN 40436 8916 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8916 69 own own JJ 40436 8916 70 species specie NNS 40436 8916 71 . . . 40436 8917 1 In in IN 40436 8917 2 the the DT 40436 8917 3 mythe mythe NN 40436 8917 4 of of IN 40436 8917 5 Protagoras,[66 protagoras,[66 NN 40436 8917 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8917 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8917 8 have have VBP 40436 8917 9 fears fear NNS 40436 8917 10 from from IN 40436 8917 11 hostile hostile JJ 40436 8917 12 animals animal NNS 40436 8917 13 -- -- : 40436 8917 14 in in IN 40436 8917 15 the the DT 40436 8917 16 speech speech NN 40436 8917 17 here here RB 40436 8917 18 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 8917 19 to to IN 40436 8917 20 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8917 21 , , , 40436 8917 22 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8917 23 have have VBP 40436 8917 24 fears fear NNS 40436 8917 25 from from IN 40436 8917 26 hostile hostile JJ 40436 8917 27 strong strong JJ 40436 8917 28 men man NNS 40436 8917 29 -- -- : 40436 8917 30 assigned assign VBN 40436 8917 31 as as IN 40436 8917 32 the the DT 40436 8917 33 generating generating NN 40436 8917 34 cause cause NN 40436 8917 35 , , , 40436 8917 36 both both DT 40436 8917 37 of of IN 40436 8917 38 political political JJ 40436 8917 39 communion communion NN 40436 8917 40 and and CC 40436 8917 41 of of IN 40436 8917 42 established establish VBN 40436 8917 43 rights right NNS 40436 8917 44 and and CC 40436 8917 45 obligations obligation NNS 40436 8917 46 to to TO 40436 8917 47 protect protect VB 40436 8917 48 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8917 49 . . . 40436 8918 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8918 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8918 3 60 60 CD 40436 8918 4 : : : 40436 8918 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8918 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8918 7 Sophist sophist JJ 40436 8918 8 . . . 40436 8919 1 Elench elench NN 40436 8919 2 . . . 40436 8920 1 12 12 CD 40436 8920 2 , , , 40436 8920 3 p. p. NN 40436 8920 4 173 173 CD 40436 8920 5 , , , 40436 8920 6 a. a. NN 40436 8921 1 10 10 LS 40436 8921 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8921 3 makes make VBZ 40436 8921 4 allusion allusion NN 40436 8921 5 to to IN 40436 8921 6 this this DT 40436 8921 7 argument argument NN 40436 8921 8 of of IN 40436 8921 9 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8921 10 in in IN 40436 8921 11 the the DT 40436 8921 12 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8921 13 , , , 40436 8921 14 and and CC 40436 8921 15 notices notice VBZ 40436 8921 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8921 17 as as IN 40436 8921 18 a a DT 40436 8921 19 frequent frequent JJ 40436 8921 20 point point NN 40436 8921 21 made make VBN 40436 8921 22 by by IN 40436 8921 23 disputants disputant NNS 40436 8921 24 in in IN 40436 8921 25 Dialectics dialectic NNS 40436 8921 26 -- -- : 40436 8921 27 to to TO 40436 8921 28 insist insist VB 40436 8921 29 on on IN 40436 8921 30 the the DT 40436 8921 31 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 8921 32 between between IN 40436 8921 33 the the DT 40436 8921 34 Just just RB 40436 8921 35 according accord VBG 40436 8921 36 to to IN 40436 8921 37 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8921 38 and and CC 40436 8921 39 the the DT 40436 8921 40 Just just RB 40436 8921 41 according accord VBG 40436 8921 42 to to IN 40436 8921 43 Law Law NNP 40436 8921 44 : : : 40436 8921 45 which which WDT 40436 8921 46 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 8921 47 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8921 48 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8921 49 says say VBZ 40436 8921 50 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8921 51 all all PDT 40436 8921 52 the the DT 40436 8921 53 ancients ancient NNS 40436 8921 54 recognised recognise VBD 40436 8921 55 as as IN 40436 8921 56 a a DT 40436 8921 57 real real JJ 40436 8921 58 one one NN 40436 8921 59 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8921 60 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8921 61 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8921 62 : : : 40436 8921 63 oi oi NNP 40436 8921 64 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8921 65 a)rchai a)rchai NNP 40436 8921 66 = = SYM 40436 8921 67 oi oi NNP 40436 8921 68 pa pa NNP 40436 8921 69 / / SYM 40436 8921 70 ntes ntes NNP 40436 8921 71 ô)/|onto ô)/|onto NNP 40436 8921 72 sumbai sumbai NNP 40436 8921 73 / / SYM 40436 8921 74 nein nein NNP 40436 8921 75 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8921 76 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8921 77 . . . 40436 8922 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8922 2 was be VBD 40436 8922 3 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 8922 4 a a DT 40436 8922 5 point point NN 40436 8922 6 on on IN 40436 8922 7 which which WDT 40436 8922 8 the the DT 40436 8922 9 Dialectician Dialectician NNP 40436 8922 10 might may MD 40436 8922 11 find find VB 40436 8922 12 much much JJ 40436 8922 13 to to TO 40436 8922 14 say say VB 40436 8922 15 on on IN 40436 8922 16 either either DT 40436 8922 17 side side NN 40436 8922 18 . . . 40436 8922 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8923 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8923 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8923 3 61 61 CD 40436 8923 4 : : : 40436 8923 5 In in IN 40436 8923 6 the the DT 40436 8923 7 conversation conversation NN 40436 8923 8 between between IN 40436 8923 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 8923 10 and and CC 40436 8923 11 Kritobulus Kritobulus NNP 40436 8923 12 , , , 40436 8923 13 one one CD 40436 8923 14 of of IN 40436 8923 15 the the DT 40436 8923 16 best good JJS 40436 8923 17 in in IN 40436 8923 18 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 8923 19 's 's POS 40436 8923 20 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 8923 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8923 22 ii ii NNP 40436 8923 23 . . . 40436 8924 1 6 6 CD 40436 8924 2 , , , 40436 8924 3 21 21 CD 40436 8924 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8924 5 , , , 40436 8924 6 respecting respect VBG 40436 8924 7 the the DT 40436 8924 8 conditions condition NNS 40436 8924 9 on on IN 40436 8924 10 which which WDT 40436 8924 11 friendship friendship NN 40436 8924 12 depends depend VBZ 40436 8924 13 , , , 40436 8924 14 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8924 15 find find VBP 40436 8924 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8924 17 clearly clearly RB 40436 8924 18 stating state VBG 40436 8924 19 that that IN 40436 8924 20 the the DT 40436 8924 21 causes cause NNS 40436 8924 22 of of IN 40436 8924 23 friendship friendship NN 40436 8924 24 and and CC 40436 8924 25 the the DT 40436 8924 26 causes cause NNS 40436 8924 27 of of IN 40436 8924 28 enmity enmity NN 40436 8924 29 , , , 40436 8924 30 though though IN 40436 8924 31 different different JJ 40436 8924 32 and and CC 40436 8924 33 opposite opposite JJ 40436 8924 34 , , , 40436 8924 35 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 8924 36 both both DT 40436 8924 37 exist exist VBP 40436 8924 38 _ _ NNP 40436 8924 39 by by IN 40436 8924 40 nature nature NN 40436 8924 41 _ _ NNP 40436 8924 42 . . . 40436 8925 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8925 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8925 3 : : : 40436 8925 4 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 8925 5 ' ' '' 40436 8925 6 e)/chei e)/chei XX 40436 8925 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8925 8 / / SYM 40436 8925 9 n n CC 40436 8925 10 , , , 40436 8925 11 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 8925 12 o o UH 40436 8925 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8925 14 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 8925 15 / / SYM 40436 8925 16 tês tês NN 40436 8925 17 , , , 40436 8925 18 poiki poiki NNP 40436 8925 19 / / SYM 40436 8925 20 lôs lôs NNP 40436 8925 21 pôs pôs NNP 40436 8925 22 tau tau NNP 40436 8925 23 = = SYM 40436 8925 24 ta ta NNP 40436 8925 25 : : : 40436 8925 26 Phu Phu NNP 40436 8925 27 / / SYM 40436 8925 28 sei sei NN 40436 8925 29 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8925 30 e)/chousin e)/chousin NN 40436 8925 31 oi oi PRP 40436 8925 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8925 33 a)/nthrôpoi a)/nthrôpoi NNP 40436 8925 34 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 8925 35 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8925 36 philika/--de philika/--de NNP 40436 8925 37 / / SYM 40436 8925 38 ontai/ ontai/ NN 40436 8925 39 te te NNP 40436 8925 40 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8925 41 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 8925 42 / / SYM 40436 8925 43 lôn lôn NN 40436 8925 44 , , , 40436 8925 45 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8925 46 e)leou e)leou ADD 40436 8925 47 = = SYM 40436 8925 48 si si NNP 40436 8925 49 , , , 40436 8925 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8925 51 sunergou sunergou NNP 40436 8925 52 = = SYM 40436 8925 53 ntes ntes NNP 40436 8925 54 ô)phelou ô)phelou , 40436 8925 55 = = SYM 40436 8925 56 ntai ntai NNP 40436 8925 57 , , , 40436 8925 58 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8925 59 tou tou NNP 40436 8925 60 = = SYM 40436 8925 61 to to TO 40436 8925 62 sunie sunie VB 40436 8925 63 / / SYM 40436 8925 64 ntes ntes NNPS 40436 8925 65 cha cha NNP 40436 8925 66 / / SYM 40436 8925 67 rin rin VB 40436 8925 68 e)/chousin e)/chousin NNP 40436 8925 69 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 8925 70 / / SYM 40436 8925 71 lois lois JJ 40436 8925 72 -- -- : 40436 8925 73 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 8925 74 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8925 75 polemika/--ta/ polemika/--ta/ NNP 40436 8925 76 te te NN 40436 8925 77 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8925 78 au)ta\ au)ta\ NNP 40436 8925 79 kala\ kala\ NNP 40436 8925 80 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8925 81 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 8925 82 / / SYM 40436 8925 83 a a DT 40436 8925 84 nomi nomi NN 40436 8925 85 / / SYM 40436 8925 86 zontes zontes NNPS 40436 8925 87 u(pe\r u(pe\r NNP 40436 8925 88 tou tou NNP 40436 8925 89 / / SYM 40436 8925 90 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8925 91 ma ma NNP 40436 8925 92 / / SYM 40436 8925 93 chontai chontai NNP 40436 8925 94 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8925 95 dichognômonou dichognômonou NNP 40436 8925 96 = = SYM 40436 8925 97 ntes ntes NNP 40436 8925 98 e)nantiou e)nantiou , 40436 8925 99 = = SYM 40436 8925 100 ntai ntai NNP 40436 8925 101 ; ; : 40436 8925 102 polemiko\n polemiko\n ADD 40436 8925 103 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8925 104 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8925 105 e)/ris e)/ris NNP 40436 8925 106 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8925 107 o)rgê/ o)rgê/ NNP 40436 8925 108 , , , 40436 8925 109 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8925 110 dusmene\s dusmene\s . 40436 8925 111 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8925 112 o o XX 40436 8925 113 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8925 114 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8925 115 pleonektei pleonektei NN 40436 8925 116 = = SYM 40436 8925 117 n n NN 40436 8925 118 e)/rôs e)/rô NNS 40436 8925 119 , , , 40436 8925 120 misêto\n misêto\n ADD 40436 8925 121 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8925 122 o o NNP 40436 8925 123 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8925 124 phtho phtho NNP 40436 8925 125 / / SYM 40436 8925 126 nos nos NNP 40436 8925 127 . . . 40436 8926 1 A)ll A)ll NNP 40436 8926 2 ' ' `` 40436 8926 3 o(/môs o(/môs NNP 40436 8926 4 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 8926 5 tou tou NNP 40436 8926 6 / / SYM 40436 8926 7 tôn tôn NNP 40436 8926 8 pa pa NNP 40436 8926 9 / / SYM 40436 8926 10 ntôn ntôn NNP 40436 8926 11 ê ê NNP 40436 8926 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8926 13 phili phili NNP 40436 8926 14 / / SYM 40436 8926 15 a a DT 40436 8926 16 diaduome diaduome JJ 40436 8926 17 / / SYM 40436 8926 18 nê nê NN 40436 8926 19 suna suna NNP 40436 8926 20 / / SYM 40436 8926 21 ptei ptei NN 40436 8926 22 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8926 23 kalou kalou NNP 40436 8926 24 / / SYM 40436 8926 25 s s NNP 40436 8926 26 te te NNP 40436 8926 27 ka)gathou ka)gathou NNP 40436 8926 28 / / SYM 40436 8926 29 s s NNP 40436 8926 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8926 31 , , , 40436 8926 32 & & CC 40436 8926 33 c. c. NNP 40436 8926 34 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8926 35 read read VBD 40436 8926 36 in in IN 40436 8926 37 the the DT 40436 8926 38 speech speech NN 40436 8926 39 of of IN 40436 8926 40 Hermokrates Hermokrates NNP 40436 8926 41 the the DT 40436 8926 42 Syracusan Syracusan NNP 40436 8926 43 , , , 40436 8926 44 at at IN 40436 8926 45 the the DT 40436 8926 46 congress congress NNP 40436 8926 47 of of IN 40436 8926 48 Gela Gela NNP 40436 8926 49 in in IN 40436 8926 50 Sicily Sicily NNP 40436 8926 51 , , , 40436 8926 52 when when WRB 40436 8926 53 exhorting exhort VBG 40436 8926 54 the the DT 40436 8926 55 Sicilians Sicilians NNPS 40436 8926 56 to to TO 40436 8926 57 unite unite VB 40436 8926 58 for for IN 40436 8926 59 the the DT 40436 8926 60 purpose purpose NN 40436 8926 61 of of IN 40436 8926 62 repelling repel VBG 40436 8926 63 the the DT 40436 8926 64 ambitious ambitious JJ 40436 8926 65 schemes scheme NNS 40436 8926 66 of of IN 40436 8926 67 Athens Athens NNP 40436 8926 68 , , , 40436 8926 69 Thucyd Thucyd NNP 40436 8926 70 . . . 40436 8927 1 iv iv XX 40436 8927 2 . . . 40436 8928 1 61 61 CD 40436 8928 2 : : : 40436 8928 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8928 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8928 5 : : : 40436 8928 6 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8928 7 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 8928 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8928 9 A)thênai A)thênai NNP 40436 8928 10 / / SYM 40436 8928 11 ous ous NNP 40436 8928 12 tau tau NNP 40436 8928 13 = = SYM 40436 8928 14 ta ta NNP 40436 8928 15 pleonektei pleonektei NNP 40436 8928 16 = = SYM 40436 8928 17 n n CC 40436 8928 18 te te NNP 40436 8928 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8928 20 pronoei pronoei NNP 40436 8928 21 = = SYM 40436 8928 22 sthai sthai NNP 40436 8928 23 pollê\ pollê\ NNP 40436 8928 24 xuggnô xuggnô NNP 40436 8928 25 / / SYM 40436 8928 26 mê mê NNP 40436 8928 27 , , , 40436 8928 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8928 29 ou ou NNP 40436 8928 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8928 31 toi toi NNP 40436 8928 32 = = SYM 40436 8928 33 s s NNP 40436 8928 34 a)/rchein a)/rchein NNP 40436 8928 35 boulome boulome NNP 40436 8928 36 / / SYM 40436 8928 37 nois nois NNP 40436 8928 38 me -PRON- PRP 40436 8928 39 / / SYM 40436 8928 40 mphomai mphomai NNP 40436 8928 41 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 8928 42 toi toi NNP 40436 8928 43 = = SYM 40436 8928 44 s s NNP 40436 8928 45 u(pakou u(pakou NNP 40436 8928 46 / / SYM 40436 8928 47 ein ein NNP 40436 8928 48 e(toimote e(toimote NN 40436 8928 49 / / SYM 40436 8928 50 rois rois NNP 40436 8928 51 ou)=si ou)=si NNP 40436 8928 52 ; ; : 40436 8928 53 _ _ NNP 40436 8928 54 pe pe NNP 40436 8928 55 / / SYM 40436 8928 56 phuke phuke NN 40436 8928 57 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8928 58 to\ to\ NN 40436 8928 59 a)nthrô a)nthrô CD 40436 8928 60 / / SYM 40436 8928 61 peion peion NN 40436 8928 62 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 8928 63 panto\s panto\s -LRB- 40436 8928 64 a)/rchein a)/rchein NNP 40436 8928 65 me\n me\n NNP 40436 8928 66 tou= tou= NNP 40436 8928 67 ei)/kontos ei)/kontos NNP 40436 8928 68 , , , 40436 8928 69 phula phula NNP 40436 8928 70 / / SYM 40436 8928 71 ssesthai ssesthai NNP 40436 8928 72 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8928 73 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8928 74 e)pio e)pio NNP 40436 8928 75 / / SYM 40436 8928 76 n n NNP 40436 8928 77 _ _ NNP 40436 8928 78 . . . 40436 8929 1 o(/soi o(/soi DT 40436 8929 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 8929 3 gignô gignô NNP 40436 8929 4 / / SYM 40436 8929 5 skontes skonte NNS 40436 8929 6 au)ta\ au)ta\ JJ 40436 8929 7 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 8929 8 o)rthô o)rthô NNS 40436 8929 9 = = SYM 40436 8929 10 s s NNP 40436 8929 11 proskopou proskopou NN 40436 8929 12 = = SYM 40436 8929 13 men man NNS 40436 8929 14 , , , 40436 8929 15 mêde\ mêde\ NNP 40436 8929 16 tou tou NNP 40436 8929 17 = = SYM 40436 8929 18 to/ to/ CD 40436 8929 19 tis tis NNP 40436 8929 20 presbu presbu NNP 40436 8929 21 / / SYM 40436 8929 22 taton taton NNP 40436 8929 23 ê(/kei ê(/kei NNP 40436 8929 24 kri kri NNP 40436 8929 25 / / SYM 40436 8929 26 nas nas NNP 40436 8929 27 , , , 40436 8929 28 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8929 29 koinô koinô NNP 40436 8929 30 = = SYM 40436 8929 31 s s NNP 40436 8929 32 phobero\n phobero\n NNP 40436 8929 33 a(/pantas a(/pantas NNP 40436 8929 34 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 8929 35 the the NNP 40436 8929 36 / / SYM 40436 8929 37 sthai sthai NNP 40436 8929 38 , , , 40436 8929 39 a(marta a(marta NNP 40436 8929 40 / / SYM 40436 8929 41 nomen noman NNS 40436 8929 42 . . . 40436 8929 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8930 1 A a DT 40436 8930 2 like like JJ 40436 8930 3 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8930 4 is be VBZ 40436 8930 5 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 8930 6 by by IN 40436 8930 7 the the DT 40436 8930 8 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8930 9 envoys envoy NNS 40436 8930 10 in in IN 40436 8930 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8930 12 debate debate NN 40436 8930 13 with with IN 40436 8930 14 the the DT 40436 8930 15 Melians Melians NNPS 40436 8930 16 , , , 40436 8930 17 Thuc Thuc NNP 40436 8930 18 . . . 40436 8931 1 v. v. CC 40436 8931 2 105 105 CD 40436 8931 3 : : : 40436 8931 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8931 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8931 6 : : : 40436 8931 7 ê(gou ê(gou NN 40436 8931 8 / / SYM 40436 8931 9 metha metha NNP 40436 8931 10 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 8931 11 to/ to/ PRP 40436 8931 12 te te NNP 40436 8931 13 thei thei NNP 40436 8931 14 = = SYM 40436 8931 15 on on IN 40436 8931 16 do do NNP 40436 8931 17 / / SYM 40436 8931 18 xê| xê| NNP 40436 8931 19 , , , 40436 8931 20 to\ to\ NN 40436 8931 21 a)nthrô a)nthrô CD 40436 8931 22 / / SYM 40436 8931 23 peio peio NNP 40436 8931 24 / / SYM 40436 8931 25 n n NN 40436 8931 26 te te NNP 40436 8931 27 saphô saphô NNP 40436 8931 28 = = SYM 40436 8931 29 s s NNP 40436 8931 30 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 8931 31 panto panto NNP 40436 8931 32 / / SYM 40436 8931 33 s s NNPS 40436 8931 34 , , , 40436 8931 35 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 8931 36 _ _ NNP 40436 8931 37 phu phu NNP 40436 8931 38 / / SYM 40436 8931 39 seôs seôs NNP 40436 8931 40 a)nagkai a)nagkai , 40436 8931 41 / / SYM 40436 8931 42 as as IN 40436 8931 43 _ _ NNP 40436 8931 44 , , , 40436 8931 45 ou)= ou)= JJ 40436 8931 46 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 8931 47 kratê=| kratê=| NNP 40436 8931 48 , , , 40436 8931 49 a)/rchein a)/rchein NNP 40436 8931 50 . . . 40436 8931 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8932 1 Some some DT 40436 8932 2 of of IN 40436 8932 3 the the DT 40436 8932 4 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8932 5 critics critic NNS 40436 8932 6 would would MD 40436 8932 7 have have VB 40436 8932 8 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8932 9 believe believe VB 40436 8932 10 that that IN 40436 8932 11 this this DT 40436 8932 12 last last RB 40436 8932 13 - - HYPH 40436 8932 14 cited cite VBN 40436 8932 15 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8932 16 emanates emanate VBZ 40436 8932 17 from from IN 40436 8932 18 the the DT 40436 8932 19 corrupt corrupt JJ 40436 8932 20 teaching teaching NN 40436 8932 21 of of IN 40436 8932 22 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8932 23 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 8932 24 : : : 40436 8932 25 but but CC 40436 8932 26 Hermokrates Hermokrates NNPS 40436 8932 27 the the DT 40436 8932 28 Syracusan Syracusan NNP 40436 8932 29 had have VBD 40436 8932 30 nothing nothing NN 40436 8932 31 to to TO 40436 8932 32 do do VB 40436 8932 33 with with IN 40436 8932 34 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 8932 35 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 8932 36 . . . 40436 8932 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8933 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8933 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8933 3 62 62 CD 40436 8933 4 : : : 40436 8933 5 Respecting respect VBG 40436 8933 6 the the DT 40436 8933 7 vague vague JJ 40436 8933 8 and and CC 40436 8933 9 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 40436 8933 10 phrases phrase NNS 40436 8933 11 -- -- : 40436 8933 12 Natural Natural NNP 40436 8933 13 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8933 14 , , , 40436 8933 15 Natural Natural NNP 40436 8933 16 Right Right NNP 40436 8933 17 , , , 40436 8933 18 Law Law NNP 40436 8933 19 of of IN 40436 8933 20 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8933 21 -- -- : 40436 8933 22 see see VB 40436 8933 23 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 8933 24 Austin Austin NNP 40436 8933 25 's 's POS 40436 8933 26 Province Province NNP 40436 8933 27 of of IN 40436 8933 28 Jurisprudence Jurisprudence NNP 40436 8933 29 Determined Determined NNP 40436 8933 30 , , , 40436 8933 31 p. p. NN 40436 8933 32 160 160 CD 40436 8933 33 , , , 40436 8933 34 ed ed NN 40436 8933 35 . . . 40436 8934 1 2nd 2nd NNP 40436 8934 2 . . . 40436 8935 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8935 2 Jurisp Jurisp NNP 40436 8935 3 . . . 40436 8935 4 , , , 40436 8935 5 4th 4th NNP 40436 8935 6 ed ed NNP 40436 8935 7 , , , 40436 8935 8 pp pp NNP 40436 8935 9 . . . 40436 8936 1 179 179 CD 40436 8936 2 , , , 40436 8936 3 591 591 CD 40436 8936 4 - - HYPH 40436 8936 5 2 2 CD 40436 8936 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8936 7 , , , 40436 8936 8 and and CC 40436 8936 9 Sir Sir NNP 40436 8936 10 H. H. NNP 40436 8936 11 S. S. NNP 40436 8936 12 Maine Maine NNP 40436 8936 13 's 's POS 40436 8936 14 Ancient Ancient NNP 40436 8936 15 Law Law NNP 40436 8936 16 , , , 40436 8936 17 chapters chapter NNS 40436 8936 18 iii iii CD 40436 8936 19 . . . 40436 8937 1 and and CC 40436 8937 2 iv iv IN 40436 8937 3 . . . 40436 8938 1 Among among IN 40436 8938 2 the the DT 40436 8938 3 assertions assertion NNS 40436 8938 4 made make VBN 40436 8938 5 about about IN 40436 8938 6 the the DT 40436 8938 7 Athenian Athenian NNP 40436 8938 8 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 8938 9 , , , 40436 8938 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8938 11 is be VBZ 40436 8938 12 said say VBN 40436 8938 13 by by IN 40436 8938 14 some some DT 40436 8938 15 commentators commentator NNS 40436 8938 16 that that IN 40436 8938 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8938 18 denied deny VBD 40436 8938 19 altogether altogether RB 40436 8938 20 any any DT 40436 8938 21 Just just RB 40436 8938 22 or or CC 40436 8938 23 Unjust Unjust NNP 40436 8938 24 by by IN 40436 8938 25 _ _ NNP 40436 8938 26 nature_--that nature_--that -LRB- 40436 8938 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8938 28 recognised recognise VBD 40436 8938 29 no no DT 40436 8938 30 Just just RB 40436 8938 31 or or CC 40436 8938 32 Unjust Unjust NNP 40436 8938 33 , , , 40436 8938 34 except except IN 40436 8938 35 by by IN 40436 8938 36 _ _ NNP 40436 8938 37 law law NN 40436 8938 38 or or CC 40436 8938 39 convention convention NN 40436 8938 40 _ _ NNP 40436 8938 41 . . . 40436 8939 1 To to TO 40436 8939 2 say say VB 40436 8939 3 that that IN 40436 8939 4 the the DT 40436 8939 5 _ _ NNP 40436 8939 6 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 8939 7 _ _ NNP 40436 8939 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8939 9 speaking speak VBG 40436 8939 10 of of IN 40436 8939 11 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8939 12 collectively collectively RB 40436 8939 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8939 14 either either CC 40436 8939 15 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 8939 16 or or CC 40436 8939 17 denied deny VBD 40436 8939 18 anything anything NN 40436 8939 19 , , , 40436 8939 20 is be VBZ 40436 8939 21 , , , 40436 8939 22 in in IN 40436 8939 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8939 24 judgment judgment NN 40436 8939 25 , , , 40436 8939 26 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 8939 27 . . . 40436 8940 1 Certain certain JJ 40436 8940 2 persons person NNS 40436 8940 3 are be VBP 40436 8940 4 alluded allude VBN 40436 8940 5 to to IN 40436 8940 6 by by IN 40436 8940 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8940 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8940 9 Theætêt theætêt NN 40436 8940 10 . . . 40436 8941 1 172 172 CD 40436 8941 2 B B NNP 40436 8941 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8941 4 as as IN 40436 8941 5 adopting adopt VBG 40436 8941 6 partially partially RB 40436 8941 7 the the DT 40436 8941 8 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 8941 9 of of IN 40436 8941 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8941 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8941 12 _ _ NNP 40436 8941 13 Homo Homo NNP 40436 8941 14 Mensura Mensura NNP 40436 8941 15 _ _ NNP 40436 8941 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8941 17 and and CC 40436 8941 18 as as IN 40436 8941 19 denying deny VBG 40436 8941 20 altogether altogether RB 40436 8941 21 the the DT 40436 8941 22 Just just RB 40436 8941 23 by by IN 40436 8941 24 _ _ NNP 40436 8941 25 nature nature NN 40436 8941 26 _ _ NNP 40436 8941 27 . . . 40436 8942 1 In in IN 40436 8942 2 another another DT 40436 8942 3 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8942 4 passage passage NN 40436 8942 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8942 6 Protagor Protagor NNP 40436 8942 7 . . . 40436 8943 1 337 337 CD 40436 8943 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8943 3 which which WDT 40436 8943 4 is be VBZ 40436 8943 5 also also RB 40436 8943 6 cited cite VBN 40436 8943 7 as as IN 40436 8943 8 contributing contribute VBG 40436 8943 9 to to TO 40436 8943 10 prove prove VB 40436 8943 11 that that IN 40436 8943 12 the the DT 40436 8943 13 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 8943 14 denied deny VBD 40436 8943 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8943 16 Greek greek NN 40436 8943 17 : : : 40436 8943 18 to\ to\ NNP 40436 8943 19 di di NNP 40436 8943 20 / / SYM 40436 8943 21 kaion kaion NNP 40436 8943 22 phu phu NN 40436 8943 23 / / SYM 40436 8943 24 sei]--nothing sei]--nothe VBG 40436 8943 25 at at RB 40436 8943 26 all all RB 40436 8943 27 is be VBZ 40436 8943 28 said say VBN 40436 8943 29 about about IN 40436 8943 30 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8943 31 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8943 32 : : : 40436 8943 33 to\ to\ NN 40436 8943 34 di di NNP 40436 8943 35 / / SYM 40436 8943 36 kaion kaion NNP 40436 8943 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8943 38 . . . 40436 8944 1 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 8944 2 the the DT 40436 8944 3 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8944 4 is be VBZ 40436 8944 5 there there EX 40436 8944 6 introduced introduce VBN 40436 8944 7 as as IN 40436 8944 8 endeavouring endeavour VBG 40436 8944 9 to to TO 40436 8944 10 appease appease VB 40436 8944 11 the the DT 40436 8944 12 angry angry JJ 40436 8944 13 feeling feeling NN 40436 8944 14 between between IN 40436 8944 15 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 8944 16 and and CC 40436 8944 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 8944 18 by by IN 40436 8944 19 reminding remind VBG 40436 8944 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8944 21 , , , 40436 8944 22 " " `` 40436 8944 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8944 24 am be VBP 40436 8944 25 of of IN 40436 8944 26 opinion opinion NN 40436 8944 27 that that IN 40436 8944 28 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8944 29 all all DT 40436 8944 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8944 31 _ _ NNP 40436 8944 32 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 8944 33 _ _ NNP 40436 8944 34 men man NNS 40436 8944 35 of of IN 40436 8944 36 literature literature NN 40436 8944 37 and and CC 40436 8944 38 study study NN 40436 8944 39 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8944 40 are be VBP 40436 8944 41 kinsmen kinsman NNS 40436 8944 42 , , , 40436 8944 43 friends friend NNS 40436 8944 44 , , , 40436 8944 45 and and CC 40436 8944 46 fellow fellow NN 40436 8944 47 - - HYPH 40436 8944 48 citizens citizen NNS 40436 8944 49 by by IN 40436 8944 50 _ _ NNP 40436 8944 51 nature nature NN 40436 8944 52 _ _ NNP 40436 8944 53 though though IN 40436 8944 54 not not RB 40436 8944 55 by by IN 40436 8944 56 _ _ NNP 40436 8944 57 law law NN 40436 8944 58 _ _ NNP 40436 8944 59 : : : 40436 8944 60 for for IN 40436 8944 61 law law NN 40436 8944 62 , , , 40436 8944 63 the the DT 40436 8944 64 despot despot NN 40436 8944 65 of of IN 40436 8944 66 mankind mankind NN 40436 8944 67 , , , 40436 8944 68 carries carry VBZ 40436 8944 69 many many JJ 40436 8944 70 things thing NNS 40436 8944 71 by by IN 40436 8944 72 force force NN 40436 8944 73 , , , 40436 8944 74 contrary contrary JJ 40436 8944 75 to to IN 40436 8944 76 nature nature NN 40436 8944 77 " " '' 40436 8944 78 . . . 40436 8945 1 The the DT 40436 8945 2 remark remark NN 40436 8945 3 is be VBZ 40436 8945 4 very very RB 40436 8945 5 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 8945 6 from from IN 40436 8945 7 one one CD 40436 8945 8 who who WP 40436 8945 9 is be VBZ 40436 8945 10 trying try VBG 40436 8945 11 to to TO 40436 8945 12 restore restore VB 40436 8945 13 good good JJ 40436 8945 14 feeling feeling NN 40436 8945 15 between between IN 40436 8945 16 literary literary JJ 40436 8945 17 disputants disputant NNS 40436 8945 18 : : : 40436 8945 19 and and CC 40436 8945 20 the the DT 40436 8945 21 cosmopolitan cosmopolitan JJ 40436 8945 22 character character NN 40436 8945 23 of of IN 40436 8945 24 literature literature NN 40436 8945 25 is be VBZ 40436 8945 26 now now RB 40436 8945 27 so so RB 40436 8945 28 familiar familiar JJ 40436 8945 29 a a DT 40436 8945 30 theme theme NN 40436 8945 31 , , , 40436 8945 32 that that IN 40436 8945 33 I -PRON- PRP 40436 8945 34 am be VBP 40436 8945 35 surprised surprised JJ 40436 8945 36 to to TO 40436 8945 37 find find VB 40436 8945 38 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 8945 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8945 40 in in IN 40436 8945 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8945 42 note note NN 40436 8945 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8945 44 making make VBG 40436 8945 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8945 46 an an DT 40436 8945 47 occasion occasion NN 40436 8945 48 for for IN 40436 8945 49 throwing throw VBG 40436 8945 50 the the DT 40436 8945 51 usual usual JJ 40436 8945 52 censure censure NN 40436 8945 53 upon upon IN 40436 8945 54 the the DT 40436 8945 55 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 8945 56 , , , 40436 8945 57 because because IN 40436 8945 58 some some DT 40436 8945 59 of of IN 40436 8945 60 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8945 61 distinguished distinguish VBD 40436 8945 62 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8945 63 from from IN 40436 8945 64 the the DT 40436 8945 65 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 8945 66 , , , 40436 8945 67 and and CC 40436 8945 68 despised despise VBD 40436 8945 69 the the DT 40436 8945 70 latter latter JJ 40436 8945 71 in in IN 40436 8945 72 comparison comparison NN 40436 8945 73 with with IN 40436 8945 74 the the DT 40436 8945 75 former former JJ 40436 8945 76 . . . 40436 8946 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 8946 2 here here RB 40436 8946 3 , , , 40436 8946 4 in in IN 40436 8946 5 the the DT 40436 8946 6 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8946 7 , , , 40436 8946 8 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 8946 9 an an DT 40436 8946 10 opinion opinion NN 40436 8946 11 not not RB 40436 8946 12 only only RB 40436 8946 13 different different JJ 40436 8946 14 from from IN 40436 8946 15 , , , 40436 8946 16 but but CC 40436 8946 17 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 8946 18 with with IN 40436 8946 19 , , , 40436 8946 20 the the DT 40436 8946 21 opinion opinion NN 40436 8946 22 alluded allude VBD 40436 8946 23 to to IN 40436 8946 24 above above RB 40436 8946 25 in in IN 40436 8946 26 the the DT 40436 8946 27 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 8946 28 , , , 40436 8946 29 172 172 CD 40436 8946 30 B. b. NN 40436 8947 1 The the DT 40436 8947 2 persons person NNS 40436 8947 3 noticed notice VBN 40436 8947 4 in in IN 40436 8947 5 the the DT 40436 8947 6 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 8947 7 said say VBD 40436 8947 8 -- -- : 40436 8947 9 There there EX 40436 8947 10 is be VBZ 40436 8947 11 no no DT 40436 8947 12 Natural Natural NNP 40436 8947 13 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8947 14 : : : 40436 8947 15 no no DT 40436 8947 16 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8947 17 , , , 40436 8947 18 except except IN 40436 8947 19 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8947 20 by by IN 40436 8947 21 Law Law NNP 40436 8947 22 . . . 40436 8948 1 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNP 40436 8948 2 says say VBZ 40436 8948 3 -- -- : 40436 8948 4 There there EX 40436 8948 5 is be VBZ 40436 8948 6 a a DT 40436 8948 7 Natural Natural NNP 40436 8948 8 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8948 9 quite quite RB 40436 8948 10 distinct distinct JJ 40436 8948 11 from from IN 40436 8948 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8948 13 and and CC 40436 8948 14 which which WDT 40436 8948 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8948 16 esteems esteem VBZ 40436 8948 17 more more JJR 40436 8948 18 than than IN 40436 8948 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8948 20 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8948 21 by by IN 40436 8948 22 Law Law NNP 40436 8948 23 : : : 40436 8948 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8948 25 then then RB 40436 8948 26 explains explain VBZ 40436 8948 27 what what WP 40436 8948 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8948 29 believes believe VBZ 40436 8948 30 Natural Natural NNP 40436 8948 31 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8948 32 to to TO 40436 8948 33 be be VB 40436 8948 34 -- -- : 40436 8948 35 That that IN 40436 8948 36 the the DT 40436 8948 37 strong strong JJ 40436 8948 38 man man NN 40436 8948 39 should should MD 40436 8948 40 take take VB 40436 8948 41 what what WP 40436 8948 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8948 43 pleases please VBZ 40436 8948 44 from from IN 40436 8948 45 the the DT 40436 8948 46 weak weak JJ 40436 8948 47 . . . 40436 8949 1 Though though IN 40436 8949 2 these these DT 40436 8949 3 two two CD 40436 8949 4 opinions opinion NNS 40436 8949 5 are be VBP 40436 8949 6 really really RB 40436 8949 7 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 8949 8 with with IN 40436 8949 9 each each DT 40436 8949 10 other other JJ 40436 8949 11 , , , 40436 8949 12 yet yet CC 40436 8949 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8949 14 see see VBP 40436 8949 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8949 16 in in IN 40436 8949 17 the the DT 40436 8949 18 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 8949 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8949 20 x. x. NNP 40436 8950 1 889 889 CD 40436 8950 2 E e NN 40436 8950 3 , , , 40436 8950 4 890 890 CD 40436 8950 5 A a DT 40436 8950 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8950 7 alluding allude VBG 40436 8950 8 to to IN 40436 8950 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8950 10 both both DT 40436 8950 11 as as IN 40436 8950 12 the the DT 40436 8950 13 same same JJ 40436 8950 14 creed creed NN 40436 8950 15 , , , 40436 8950 16 held hold VBN 40436 8950 17 and and CC 40436 8950 18 defended defend VBN 40436 8950 19 by by IN 40436 8950 20 the the DT 40436 8950 21 same same JJ 40436 8950 22 men man NNS 40436 8950 23 ; ; : 40436 8950 24 whom whom WP 40436 8950 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8950 26 denounces denounce VBZ 40436 8950 27 with with IN 40436 8950 28 extreme extreme JJ 40436 8950 29 acrimony acrimony NN 40436 8950 30 . . . 40436 8951 1 Who who WP 40436 8951 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8951 3 were be VBD 40436 8951 4 , , , 40436 8951 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8951 6 does do VBZ 40436 8951 7 not not RB 40436 8951 8 name name VB 40436 8951 9 ; ; : 40436 8951 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8951 11 does do VBZ 40436 8951 12 not not RB 40436 8951 13 mention mention VB 40436 8951 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8951 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8951 16 : : : 40436 8951 17 sophistai/ sophistai/ NN 40436 8951 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8951 19 , , , 40436 8951 20 but but CC 40436 8951 21 calls call VBZ 40436 8951 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8951 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8951 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8951 25 : : : 40436 8951 26 a)ndrô a)ndrô NFP 40436 8951 27 = = SYM 40436 8951 28 n n NNP 40436 8951 29 sophô sophô NNP 40436 8951 30 = = SYM 40436 8951 31 n n NNP 40436 8951 32 , , , 40436 8951 33 i)diôtô i)diôtô NNP 40436 8951 34 = = SYM 40436 8951 35 n n CC 40436 8951 36 te te NNP 40436 8951 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 8951 38 poiêtô poiêtô NNP 40436 8951 39 = = SYM 40436 8951 40 n n IN 40436 8951 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8951 42 . . . 40436 8952 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8952 2 see see VBP 40436 8952 3 , , , 40436 8952 4 in in IN 40436 8952 5 the the DT 40436 8952 6 third third JJ 40436 8952 7 chapter chapter NN 40436 8952 8 of of IN 40436 8952 9 Sir Sir NNP 40436 8952 10 H. H. NNP 40436 8952 11 S. S. NNP 40436 8952 12 Maine Maine NNP 40436 8952 13 's 's POS 40436 8952 14 excellent excellent JJ 40436 8952 15 work work NN 40436 8952 16 on on IN 40436 8952 17 Ancient Ancient NNP 40436 8952 18 Law Law NNP 40436 8952 19 , , , 40436 8952 20 the the DT 40436 8952 21 meaning meaning NN 40436 8952 22 of of IN 40436 8952 23 these these DT 40436 8952 24 phrases phrase NNS 40436 8952 25 -- -- : 40436 8952 26 Natural Natural NNP 40436 8952 27 Justice Justice NNP 40436 8952 28 , , , 40436 8952 29 Law Law NNP 40436 8952 30 of of IN 40436 8952 31 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8952 32 . . . 40436 8953 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8953 2 designated designate VBD 40436 8953 3 or or CC 40436 8953 4 included include VBD 40436 8953 5 " " `` 40436 8953 6 a a DT 40436 8953 7 set set NN 40436 8953 8 of of IN 40436 8953 9 legal legal JJ 40436 8953 10 principles principle NNS 40436 8953 11 entitled entitle VBN 40436 8953 12 to to TO 40436 8953 13 supersede supersede VB 40436 8953 14 the the DT 40436 8953 15 existing exist VBG 40436 8953 16 laws law NNS 40436 8953 17 , , , 40436 8953 18 on on IN 40436 8953 19 the the DT 40436 8953 20 ground ground NN 40436 8953 21 of of IN 40436 8953 22 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 40436 8953 23 superiority superiority NN 40436 8953 24 " " '' 40436 8953 25 . . . 40436 8954 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8954 2 denoted denote VBD 40436 8954 3 an an DT 40436 8954 4 ideal ideal JJ 40436 8954 5 condition condition NN 40436 8954 6 of of IN 40436 8954 7 society society NN 40436 8954 8 , , , 40436 8954 9 supposed suppose VBN 40436 8954 10 to to TO 40436 8954 11 be be VB 40436 8954 12 much much RB 40436 8954 13 better well JJR 40436 8954 14 than than IN 40436 8954 15 what what WP 40436 8954 16 actually actually RB 40436 8954 17 prevailed prevail VBD 40436 8954 18 . . . 40436 8955 1 This this DT 40436 8955 2 at at IN 40436 8955 3 least least JJS 40436 8955 4 seems seem VBZ 40436 8955 5 to to TO 40436 8955 6 have have VB 40436 8955 7 been be VBN 40436 8955 8 the the DT 40436 8955 9 meaning meaning NN 40436 8955 10 which which WDT 40436 8955 11 began begin VBD 40436 8955 12 to to TO 40436 8955 13 attach attach VB 40436 8955 14 to to IN 40436 8955 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8955 16 in in IN 40436 8955 17 the the DT 40436 8955 18 time time NN 40436 8955 19 of of IN 40436 8955 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8955 21 and and CC 40436 8955 22 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 8955 23 . . . 40436 8956 1 What what WP 40436 8956 2 this this DT 40436 8956 3 ideal ideal JJ 40436 8956 4 perfection perfection NN 40436 8956 5 of of IN 40436 8956 6 human human JJ 40436 8956 7 society society NN 40436 8956 8 was be VBD 40436 8956 9 , , , 40436 8956 10 varied varied JJ 40436 8956 11 in in IN 40436 8956 12 the the DT 40436 8956 13 minds mind NNS 40436 8956 14 of of IN 40436 8956 15 different different JJ 40436 8956 16 speakers speaker NNS 40436 8956 17 . . . 40436 8957 1 In in IN 40436 8957 2 each each DT 40436 8957 3 speaker speaker NN 40436 8957 4 's 's POS 40436 8957 5 mind mind NN 40436 8957 6 the the DT 40436 8957 7 word word NN 40436 8957 8 and and CC 40436 8957 9 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8957 10 was be VBD 40436 8957 11 much much RB 40436 8957 12 the the DT 40436 8957 13 same same JJ 40436 8957 14 , , , 40436 8957 15 though though IN 40436 8957 16 the the DT 40436 8957 17 objects object NNS 40436 8957 18 to to TO 40436 8957 19 which which WDT 40436 8957 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8957 21 attached attach VBN 40436 8957 22 were be VBD 40436 8957 23 often often RB 40436 8957 24 different different JJ 40436 8957 25 . . . 40436 8958 1 Empedokles empedokle NNS 40436 8958 2 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 8958 3 in in IN 40436 8958 4 solemn solemn JJ 40436 8958 5 and and CC 40436 8958 6 emphatic emphatic JJ 40436 8958 7 language language NN 40436 8958 8 that that WDT 40436 8958 9 the the DT 40436 8958 10 Law Law NNP 40436 8958 11 of of IN 40436 8958 12 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8958 13 peremptorily peremptorily RB 40436 8958 14 forbids forbid VBZ 40436 8958 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 8958 16 to to TO 40436 8958 17 kill kill VB 40436 8958 18 any any DT 40436 8958 19 animal animal NN 40436 8958 20 . . . 40436 8959 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8959 2 Aristot aristot NN 40436 8959 3 . . . 40436 8960 1 Rhetor rhetor NN 40436 8960 2 . . . 40436 8961 1 i. i. NNP 40436 8962 1 13 13 CD 40436 8962 2 , , , 40436 8962 3 1373 1373 CD 40436 8962 4 b. b. NN 40436 8963 1 15 15 CD 40436 8963 2 . . . 40436 8963 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8964 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8964 2 makes make VBZ 40436 8964 3 out out RP 40436 8964 4 to to IN 40436 8964 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8964 6 own own JJ 40436 8964 7 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 8964 8 , , , 40436 8964 9 that that IN 40436 8964 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8964 11 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8964 12 is be VBZ 40436 8964 13 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 8964 14 in in IN 40436 8964 15 harmony harmony NN 40436 8964 16 with with IN 40436 8964 17 the the DT 40436 8964 18 Law Law NNP 40436 8964 19 of of IN 40436 8964 20 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8964 21 : : : 40436 8964 22 and and CC 40436 8964 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8964 24 insists insist VBZ 40436 8964 25 especially especially RB 40436 8964 26 on on IN 40436 8964 27 this this DT 40436 8964 28 harmony harmony NN 40436 8964 29 , , , 40436 8964 30 in in IN 40436 8964 31 the the DT 40436 8964 32 very very JJ 40436 8964 33 point point NN 40436 8964 34 which which WDT 40436 8964 35 even even RB 40436 8964 36 the the DT 40436 8964 37 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 8964 38 critics critic NNS 40436 8964 39 admit admit VBP 40436 8964 40 to to TO 40436 8964 41 be be VB 40436 8964 42 wrong wrong JJ 40436 8964 43 -- -- : 40436 8964 44 that that RB 40436 8964 45 is is RB 40436 8964 46 , , , 40436 8964 47 in in IN 40436 8964 48 regard regard NN 40436 8964 49 to to IN 40436 8964 50 the the DT 40436 8964 51 training training NN 40436 8964 52 of of IN 40436 8964 53 women woman NNS 40436 8964 54 and and CC 40436 8964 55 the the DT 40436 8964 56 relations relation NNS 40436 8964 57 of of IN 40436 8964 58 the the DT 40436 8964 59 sexes sex NNS 40436 8964 60 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8964 61 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8964 62 , , , 40436 8964 63 v. v. CC 40436 8964 64 456 456 CD 40436 8964 65 C c NN 40436 8964 66 , , , 40436 8964 67 466 466 CD 40436 8964 68 D d NN 40436 8964 69 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8964 70 . . . 40436 8965 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 8965 2 learn learn VBP 40436 8965 3 from from IN 40436 8965 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8965 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8965 6 that that IN 40436 8965 7 the the DT 40436 8965 8 propositions proposition NNS 40436 8965 9 of of IN 40436 8965 10 the the DT 40436 8965 11 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8965 12 were be VBD 40436 8965 13 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 8965 14 adverse adverse JJ 40436 8965 15 to to IN 40436 8965 16 what what WP 40436 8965 17 other other JJ 40436 8965 18 persons person NNS 40436 8965 19 reverenced reverence VBD 40436 8965 20 as as IN 40436 8965 21 the the DT 40436 8965 22 Law Law NNP 40436 8965 23 of of IN 40436 8965 24 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8965 25 . . . 40436 8966 1 In in IN 40436 8966 2 the the DT 40436 8966 3 notes note NNS 40436 8966 4 of of IN 40436 8966 5 Beck Beck NNP 40436 8966 6 and and CC 40436 8966 7 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 8966 8 on on IN 40436 8966 9 Protagor Protagor NNP 40436 8966 10 . . . 40436 8967 1 p. p. NN 40436 8967 2 337 337 CD 40436 8967 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 8967 4 read read VBP 40436 8967 5 , , , 40436 8967 6 " " '' 40436 8967 7 Hippias Hippias NNP 40436 8967 8 præ præ NNP 40436 8967 9 cæteris cæteris NNP 40436 8967 10 Sophistis Sophistis NNP 40436 8967 11 contempsit contempsit NN 40436 8967 12 leges lex NNS 40436 8967 13 , , , 40436 8967 14 iisque iisque JJ 40436 8967 15 opposuit opposuit NN 40436 8967 16 Naturam Naturam NNP 40436 8967 17 . . . 40436 8968 1 Naturam Naturam NNP 40436 8968 2 legibus legibus NN 40436 8968 3 plures plure VBZ 40436 8968 4 certé certé VBP 40436 8968 5 Sophistarum Sophistarum NNP 40436 8968 6 opposuisse opposuisse NNP 40436 8968 7 , , , 40436 8968 8 easque easque NNP 40436 8968 9 præ præ NNP 40436 8968 10 illâ illâ NNP 40436 8968 11 contempsisse contempsisse NNP 40436 8968 12 , , , 40436 8968 13 multis multis NNP 40436 8968 14 veterum veterum JJ 40436 8968 15 locis locis NNP 40436 8968 16 constat constat NN 40436 8968 17 . . . 40436 8968 18 " " '' 40436 8969 1 Now now RB 40436 8969 2 this this DT 40436 8969 3 allegation allegation NN 40436 8969 4 is be VBZ 40436 8969 5 more more RBR 40436 8969 6 applicable applicable JJ 40436 8969 7 to to IN 40436 8969 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8969 9 than than IN 40436 8969 10 to to IN 40436 8969 11 the the DT 40436 8969 12 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 8969 13 . . . 40436 8970 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8970 2 speaks speak VBZ 40436 8970 3 with with IN 40436 8970 4 the the DT 40436 8970 5 most most RBS 40436 8970 6 unmeasured unmeasured JJ 40436 8970 7 contempt contempt NN 40436 8970 8 of of IN 40436 8970 9 existing exist VBG 40436 8970 10 communities community NNS 40436 8970 11 and and CC 40436 8970 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8970 13 laws law NNS 40436 8970 14 : : : 40436 8970 15 the the DT 40436 8970 16 scheme scheme NN 40436 8970 17 of of IN 40436 8970 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8970 19 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8970 20 , , , 40436 8970 21 radically radically RB 40436 8970 22 departing depart VBG 40436 8970 23 from from IN 40436 8970 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8970 25 as as IN 40436 8970 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8970 27 does do VBZ 40436 8970 28 , , , 40436 8970 29 shows show VBZ 40436 8970 30 what what WP 40436 8970 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8970 32 considered consider VBD 40436 8970 33 as as IN 40436 8970 34 required require VBN 40436 8970 35 by by IN 40436 8970 36 the the DT 40436 8970 37 exigencies exigency NNS 40436 8970 38 of of IN 40436 8970 39 human human JJ 40436 8970 40 nature nature NN 40436 8970 41 . . . 40436 8971 1 Both both CC 40436 8971 2 the the DT 40436 8971 3 Stoics Stoics NNPS 40436 8971 4 and and CC 40436 8971 5 the the DT 40436 8971 6 Epikureans Epikureans NNPS 40436 8971 7 extolled extoll VBD 40436 8971 8 what what WP 40436 8971 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8971 10 called call VBD 40436 8971 11 the the DT 40436 8971 12 Law Law NNP 40436 8971 13 of of IN 40436 8971 14 Nature Nature NNP 40436 8971 15 above above IN 40436 8971 16 any any DT 40436 8971 17 laws law NNS 40436 8971 18 actually actually RB 40436 8971 19 existing exist VBG 40436 8971 20 . . . 40436 8972 1 The the DT 40436 8972 2 other other JJ 40436 8972 3 charge charge NN 40436 8972 4 made make VBN 40436 8972 5 against against IN 40436 8972 6 the the DT 40436 8972 7 Sophists Sophists NNPS 40436 8972 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8972 9 quite quite RB 40436 8972 10 opposite opposite RB 40436 8972 11 , , , 40436 8972 12 yet yet CC 40436 8972 13 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 8972 14 advanced advance VBN 40436 8972 15 by by IN 40436 8972 16 the the DT 40436 8972 17 same same JJ 40436 8972 18 critics critic NNS 40436 8972 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8972 20 is be VBZ 40436 8972 21 , , , 40436 8972 22 that that IN 40436 8972 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8972 24 recognised recognise VBD 40436 8972 25 no no DT 40436 8972 26 Just just RB 40436 8972 27 by by IN 40436 8972 28 Nature nature NN 40436 8972 29 , , , 40436 8972 30 but but CC 40436 8972 31 only only RB 40436 8972 32 Just just RB 40436 8972 33 by by IN 40436 8972 34 Law Law NNP 40436 8972 35 : : : 40436 8972 36 _ _ NNP 40436 8972 37 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 8972 38 _ _ NNP 40436 8972 39 all all PDT 40436 8972 40 the the DT 40436 8972 41 actual actual JJ 40436 8972 42 laws law NNS 40436 8972 43 and and CC 40436 8972 44 customs custom NNS 40436 8972 45 considered consider VBN 40436 8972 46 as as IN 40436 8972 47 binding bind VBG 40436 8972 48 in in IN 40436 8972 49 each each DT 40436 8972 50 different different JJ 40436 8972 51 community community NN 40436 8972 52 . . . 40436 8973 1 This this DT 40436 8973 2 is be VBZ 40436 8973 3 what what WP 40436 8973 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8973 5 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 8973 6 to to IN 40436 8973 7 some some DT 40436 8973 8 persons person NNS 40436 8973 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8973 10 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 8973 11 or or CC 40436 8973 12 not not RB 40436 8973 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8973 14 in in IN 40436 8973 15 the the DT 40436 8973 16 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 8973 17 , , , 40436 8973 18 p. p. NN 40436 8973 19 172 172 CD 40436 8973 20 . . . 40436 8974 1 But but CC 40436 8974 2 in in IN 40436 8974 3 this this DT 40436 8974 4 sense sense NN 40436 8974 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8974 6 is be VBZ 40436 8974 7 not not RB 40436 8974 8 exact exact JJ 40436 8974 9 to to TO 40436 8974 10 call call VB 40436 8974 11 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 8974 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8974 13 as as IN 40436 8974 14 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 8974 15 does do VBZ 40436 8974 16 , , , 40436 8974 17 Protagor Protagor NNP 40436 8974 18 . . . 40436 8975 1 p. p. NN 40436 8975 2 337 337 CD 40436 8975 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8975 4 " " `` 40436 8975 5 germanus germanus NN 40436 8975 6 ille ille NNP 40436 8975 7 Sophistarum Sophistarum NNP 40436 8975 8 alumnus alumnus NN 40436 8975 9 in in IN 40436 8975 10 Gorgià Gorgià NNP 40436 8975 11 Callicles Callicles NNP 40436 8975 12 , , , 40436 8975 13 " " '' 40436 8975 14 nor nor CC 40436 8975 15 to to TO 40436 8975 16 affirm affirm VB 40436 8975 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8975 18 with with IN 40436 8975 19 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 8975 20 , , , 40436 8975 21 Einleit Einleit NNP 40436 8975 22 . . . 40436 8976 1 zum zum NNP 40436 8976 2 Theætêt Theætêt NNP 40436 8976 3 . . . 40436 8977 1 p. p. NN 40436 8977 2 183 183 CD 40436 8977 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8977 4 that that IN 40436 8977 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8977 6 meant mean VBD 40436 8977 7 to to TO 40436 8977 8 refute refute VB 40436 8977 9 Aristippus Aristippus NNP 40436 8977 10 under under IN 40436 8977 11 the the DT 40436 8977 12 name name NN 40436 8977 13 of of IN 40436 8977 14 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 8977 15 , , , 40436 8977 16 Aristippus Aristippus NNP 40436 8977 17 maintaining maintain VBG 40436 8977 18 that that IN 40436 8977 19 there there EX 40436 8977 20 was be VBD 40436 8977 21 no no DT 40436 8977 22 Just just RB 40436 8977 23 by by IN 40436 8977 24 Nature nature NN 40436 8977 25 , , , 40436 8977 26 but but CC 40436 8977 27 only only RB 40436 8977 28 Just just RB 40436 8977 29 by by IN 40436 8977 30 Law Law NNP 40436 8977 31 or or CC 40436 8977 32 Convention Convention NNP 40436 8977 33 . . . 40436 8977 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8978 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8978 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8978 3 63 63 CD 40436 8978 4 : : : 40436 8978 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8978 6 , , , 40436 8978 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8978 8 , , , 40436 8978 9 p. p. NN 40436 8978 10 483 483 CD 40436 8978 11 B b NN 40436 8978 12 , , , 40436 8978 13 p. p. NN 40436 8978 14 492 492 CD 40436 8978 15 A. a. NN 40436 8979 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8979 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8979 3 : : : 40436 8979 4 oi oi NNP 40436 8979 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8979 6 polloi\ polloi\ NNP 40436 8979 7 , , , 40436 8979 8 a)pokrupto a)pokrupto CD 40436 8979 9 / / SYM 40436 8979 10 menoi menoi NNS 40436 8979 11 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 8979 12 e(autô e(autô NNP 40436 8979 13 = = SYM 40436 8979 14 n n CC 40436 8979 15 a)dunami a)dunami CD 40436 8979 16 / / SYM 40436 8979 17 an an DT 40436 8979 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8979 19 , , , 40436 8979 20 & & CC 40436 8979 21 c. c. NNP 40436 8979 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8979 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8979 24 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8979 25 64 64 CD 40436 8979 26 : : : 40436 8979 27 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8979 28 , , , 40436 8979 29 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8979 30 , , , 40436 8979 31 p. p. NN 40436 8979 32 483 483 CD 40436 8979 33 E. E. NNP 40436 8979 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8979 35 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8979 36 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8979 37 65 65 CD 40436 8979 38 : : : 40436 8979 39 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8979 40 , , , 40436 8979 41 Republic Republic NNP 40436 8979 42 , , , 40436 8979 43 ii ii NNP 40436 8979 44 . . . 40436 8980 1 p. p. NN 40436 8980 2 369 369 CD 40436 8980 3 B. B. NNP 40436 8981 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8981 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 8981 3 : : : 40436 8981 4 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 8981 5 tugcha tugcha NNP 40436 8981 6 / / SYM 40436 8981 7 nei nei NNP 40436 8981 8 ê(mô ê(mô NNP 40436 8981 9 = = SYM 40436 8981 10 n n CC 40436 8981 11 e(/kastos e(/kastos NN 40436 8981 12 ou)k ou)k NN 40436 8981 13 au)tarkê\s au)tarkê\s NNP 40436 8981 14 ô)/n ô)/n NNP 40436 8981 15 , , , 40436 8981 16 a)lla\ a)lla\ VBZ 40436 8981 17 pollô pollô NN 40436 8981 18 = = SYM 40436 8981 19 n n NNP 40436 8981 20 e)ndeê e)ndeê NNP 40436 8981 21 / / SYM 40436 8981 22 s s NNP 40436 8981 23 . . . 40436 8981 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8981 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8982 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8982 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8982 3 66 66 CD 40436 8982 4 : : : 40436 8982 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8982 6 , , , 40436 8982 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 8982 8 . . . 40436 8983 1 p. p. NN 40436 8983 2 322 322 CD 40436 8983 3 B. B. NNP 40436 8983 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8984 1 * * NFP 40436 8984 2 * * NFP 40436 8984 3 * * NFP 40436 8984 4 * * NFP 40436 8984 5 * * NFP 40436 8984 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8984 7 Side side NN 40436 8984 8 - - HYPH 40436 8984 9 note note NN 40436 8984 10 : : : 40436 8984 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 8984 12 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 8984 13 that that IN 40436 8984 14 self self NN 40436 8984 15 - - HYPH 40436 8984 16 command command NN 40436 8984 17 and and CC 40436 8984 18 moderation moderation NN 40436 8984 19 is be VBZ 40436 8984 20 requisite requisite JJ 40436 8984 21 for for IN 40436 8984 22 the the DT 40436 8984 23 strong strong JJ 40436 8984 24 man man NN 40436 8984 25 as as RB 40436 8984 26 well well RB 40436 8984 27 as as IN 40436 8984 28 for for IN 40436 8984 29 others other NNS 40436 8984 30 . . . 40436 8985 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 8985 2 defends defend VBZ 40436 8985 3 the the DT 40436 8985 4 negative negative NN 40436 8985 5 . . . 40436 8985 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8986 1 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 8986 2 now now RB 40436 8986 3 explains explain VBZ 40436 8986 4 , , , 40436 8986 5 that that IN 40436 8986 6 by by IN 40436 8986 7 _ _ NNP 40436 8986 8 stronger strong JJR 40436 8986 9 _ _ NNP 40436 8986 10 men man NNS 40436 8986 11 , , , 40436 8986 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8986 13 means mean VBZ 40436 8986 14 better well JJR 40436 8986 15 , , , 40436 8986 16 wiser wise JJR 40436 8986 17 , , , 40436 8986 18 braver braver NN 40436 8986 19 men man NNS 40436 8986 20 . . . 40436 8987 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8987 2 is be VBZ 40436 8987 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8987 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 8987 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8987 6 says say VBZ 40436 8987 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 8987 8 who who WP 40436 8987 9 ought ought MD 40436 8987 10 , , , 40436 8987 11 according accord VBG 40436 8987 12 to to IN 40436 8987 13 right right NN 40436 8987 14 by by IN 40436 8987 15 nature nature NN 40436 8987 16 , , , 40436 8987 17 to to TO 40436 8987 18 rule rule VB 40436 8987 19 over over IN 40436 8987 20 others other NNS 40436 8987 21 and and CC 40436 8987 22 to to TO 40436 8987 23 have have VB 40436 8987 24 larger large JJR 40436 8987 25 shares share NNS 40436 8987 26 than than IN 40436 8987 27 others other NNS 40436 8987 28 . . . 40436 8988 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8988 2 Sokr._--Ought Sokr._--Ought NNP 40436 8988 3 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8988 4 not not RB 40436 8988 5 to to TO 40436 8988 6 rule rule VB 40436 8988 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 8988 8 as as RB 40436 8988 9 well well RB 40436 8988 10 as as IN 40436 8988 11 others:[67 others:[67 -LRB- 40436 8988 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8988 13 to to TO 40436 8988 14 control control VB 40436 8988 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8988 16 own own JJ 40436 8988 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 8988 18 and and CC 40436 8988 19 desires desire NNS 40436 8988 20 : : : 40436 8988 21 to to TO 40436 8988 22 be be VB 40436 8988 23 sober sober JJ 40436 8988 24 and and CC 40436 8988 25 temperate temperate VB 40436 8988 26 ? ? . 40436 8989 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8989 2 Kall._--No Kall._--No NNP 40436 8989 3 , , , 40436 8989 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8989 5 would would MD 40436 8989 6 be be VB 40436 8989 7 foolish foolish JJ 40436 8989 8 if if IN 40436 8989 9 they -PRON- PRP 40436 8989 10 did do VBD 40436 8989 11 . . . 40436 8990 1 The the DT 40436 8990 2 weak weak JJ 40436 8990 3 multitude multitude NN 40436 8990 4 must must MD 40436 8990 5 do do VB 40436 8990 6 so so RB 40436 8990 7 ; ; : 40436 8990 8 and and CC 40436 8990 9 there there EX 40436 8990 10 grows grow VBZ 40436 8990 11 up up RP 40436 8990 12 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 8990 13 among among IN 40436 8990 14 _ _ NNP 40436 8990 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8990 16 _ _ IN 40436 8990 17 a a DT 40436 8990 18 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 8990 19 which which WDT 40436 8990 20 requires require VBZ 40436 8990 21 such such JJ 40436 8990 22 self self NN 40436 8990 23 - - HYPH 40436 8990 24 restraint restraint NN 40436 8990 25 from from IN 40436 8990 26 all all DT 40436 8990 27 . . . 40436 8991 1 But but CC 40436 8991 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8991 3 is be VBZ 40436 8991 4 the the DT 40436 8991 5 privilege privilege NN 40436 8991 6 of of IN 40436 8991 7 the the DT 40436 8991 8 superior superior JJ 40436 8991 9 few few JJ 40436 8991 10 to to TO 40436 8991 11 be be VB 40436 8991 12 exempt exempt JJ 40436 8991 13 from from IN 40436 8991 14 this this DT 40436 8991 15 necessity necessity NN 40436 8991 16 . . . 40436 8992 1 The the DT 40436 8992 2 right right NN 40436 8992 3 of of IN 40436 8992 4 nature nature NN 40436 8992 5 authorises authorise VBZ 40436 8992 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8992 7 to to TO 40436 8992 8 have have VB 40436 8992 9 the the DT 40436 8992 10 largest large JJS 40436 8992 11 desires desire NNS 40436 8992 12 , , , 40436 8992 13 since since IN 40436 8992 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8992 15 courage courage NN 40436 8992 16 and and CC 40436 8992 17 ability ability NN 40436 8992 18 furnish furnish NN 40436 8992 19 means mean VBZ 40436 8992 20 to to TO 40436 8992 21 satisfy satisfy VB 40436 8992 22 the the DT 40436 8992 23 desires desire NNS 40436 8992 24 . . . 40436 8993 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 8993 2 would would MD 40436 8993 3 be be VB 40436 8993 4 silly silly JJ 40436 8993 5 if if IN 40436 8993 6 a a DT 40436 8993 7 king king NN 40436 8993 8 's 's POS 40436 8993 9 son son NN 40436 8993 10 or or CC 40436 8993 11 a a DT 40436 8993 12 despot despot NN 40436 8993 13 were be VBD 40436 8993 14 to to TO 40436 8993 15 limit limit VB 40436 8993 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 8993 17 to to IN 40436 8993 18 the the DT 40436 8993 19 same same JJ 40436 8993 20 measure measure NN 40436 8993 21 of of IN 40436 8993 22 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 8993 23 with with IN 40436 8993 24 which which WDT 40436 8993 25 a a DT 40436 8993 26 poor poor JJ 40436 8993 27 citizen citizen NN 40436 8993 28 must must MD 40436 8993 29 be be VB 40436 8993 30 content content JJ 40436 8993 31 ; ; : 40436 8993 32 and and CC 40436 8993 33 worse bad JJR 40436 8993 34 than than IN 40436 8993 35 silly silly JJ 40436 8993 36 if if IN 40436 8993 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8993 38 did do VBD 40436 8993 39 not not RB 40436 8993 40 enrich enrich VB 40436 8993 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8993 42 friends friend NNS 40436 8993 43 in in IN 40436 8993 44 preference preference NN 40436 8993 45 to to IN 40436 8993 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 8993 47 enemies enemy NNS 40436 8993 48 . . . 40436 8994 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 8994 2 need nee MD 40436 8994 3 not not RB 40436 8994 4 care care VB 40436 8994 5 for for IN 40436 8994 6 that that DT 40436 8994 7 public public JJ 40436 8994 8 law law NN 40436 8994 9 and and CC 40436 8994 10 censure censure NN 40436 8994 11 which which WDT 40436 8994 12 must must MD 40436 8994 13 reign reign VB 40436 8994 14 paramount paramount NNP 40436 8994 15 over over IN 40436 8994 16 each each DT 40436 8994 17 man man NN 40436 8994 18 among among IN 40436 8994 19 the the DT 40436 8994 20 many many JJ 40436 8994 21 . . . 40436 8995 1 A a DT 40436 8995 2 full full JJ 40436 8995 3 swing swing NN 40436 8995 4 of of IN 40436 8995 5 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 8995 6 , , , 40436 8995 7 if if IN 40436 8995 8 a a DT 40436 8995 9 man man NN 40436 8995 10 has have VBZ 40436 8995 11 power power NN 40436 8995 12 to to TO 40436 8995 13 procure procure VB 40436 8995 14 and and CC 40436 8995 15 maintain maintain VB 40436 8995 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 8995 17 , , , 40436 8995 18 is be VBZ 40436 8995 19 virtue virtue JJ 40436 8995 20 as as RB 40436 8995 21 well well RB 40436 8995 22 as as IN 40436 8995 23 happiness happiness NN 40436 8995 24 . . . 40436 8996 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8996 2 68 68 CD 40436 8996 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8996 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8996 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8996 6 67 67 CD 40436 8996 7 : : : 40436 8996 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8996 9 , , , 40436 8996 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8996 11 , , , 40436 8996 12 p. p. NN 40436 8996 13 491 491 CD 40436 8996 14 D. d. NN 40436 8996 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8996 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8996 17 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 8996 18 68 68 CD 40436 8996 19 : : : 40436 8996 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 8996 21 , , , 40436 8996 22 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 8996 23 , , , 40436 8996 24 p. p. NN 40436 8996 25 492 492 CD 40436 8996 26 A A NNP 40436 8996 27 - - HYPH 40436 8996 28 C. c. NN 40436 8996 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8996 30 [ [ -LRB- 40436 8996 31 Side side NN 40436 8996 32 - - HYPH 40436 8996 33 note note NN 40436 8996 34 : : : 40436 8996 35 Whether whether IN 40436 8996 36 the the DT 40436 8996 37 largest large JJS 40436 8996 38 measure measure NN 40436 8996 39 of of IN 40436 8996 40 desires desire NNS 40436 8996 41 is be VBZ 40436 8996 42 good good JJ 40436 8996 43 for for IN 40436 8996 44 a a DT 40436 8996 45 man man NN 40436 8996 46 , , , 40436 8996 47 provided provide VBN 40436 8996 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 8996 49 has have VBZ 40436 8996 50 the the DT 40436 8996 51 means mean NNS 40436 8996 52 of of IN 40436 8996 53 satisfying satisfy VBG 40436 8996 54 them -PRON- PRP 40436 8996 55 ? ? . 40436 8997 1 Whether whether IN 40436 8997 2 all all DT 40436 8997 3 varieties variety NNS 40436 8997 4 of of IN 40436 8997 5 desire desire NN 40436 8997 6 are be VBP 40436 8997 7 good good JJ 40436 8997 8 ? ? . 40436 8998 1 Whether whether IN 40436 8998 2 the the DT 40436 8998 3 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 8998 4 and and CC 40436 8998 5 the the DT 40436 8998 6 good good JJ 40436 8998 7 are be VBP 40436 8998 8 identical identical JJ 40436 8998 9 ? ? . 40436 8998 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 8999 1 _ _ NNP 40436 8999 2 Sokr._--I Sokr._--I NNP 40436 8999 3 think think VBP 40436 8999 4 on on IN 40436 8999 5 the the DT 40436 8999 6 contrary contrary NN 40436 8999 7 that that IN 40436 8999 8 a a DT 40436 8999 9 sober sober JJ 40436 8999 10 and and CC 40436 8999 11 moderate moderate JJ 40436 8999 12 life life NN 40436 8999 13 , , , 40436 8999 14 regulated regulate VBN 40436 8999 15 according accord VBG 40436 8999 16 to to IN 40436 8999 17 present present JJ 40436 8999 18 means mean NNS 40436 8999 19 and and CC 40436 8999 20 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 8999 21 , , , 40436 8999 22 is be VBZ 40436 8999 23 better well JJR 40436 8999 24 than than IN 40436 8999 25 a a DT 40436 8999 26 life life NN 40436 8999 27 of of IN 40436 8999 28 immoderate immoderate JJ 40436 8999 29 indulgence indulgence NN 40436 8999 30 . . . 40436 9000 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9000 2 69 69 CD 40436 9000 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9000 4 _ _ NNP 40436 9000 5 Kall._--The Kall._--The NNP 40436 9000 6 man man NN 40436 9000 7 who who WP 40436 9000 8 has have VBZ 40436 9000 9 no no DT 40436 9000 10 desires desire NNS 40436 9000 11 will will MD 40436 9000 12 have have VB 40436 9000 13 no no DT 40436 9000 14 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9000 15 , , , 40436 9000 16 and and CC 40436 9000 17 will will MD 40436 9000 18 live live VB 40436 9000 19 like like IN 40436 9000 20 a a DT 40436 9000 21 stone stone NN 40436 9000 22 . . . 40436 9001 1 The the DT 40436 9001 2 more more RBR 40436 9001 3 the the DT 40436 9001 4 desires desire NNS 40436 9001 5 , , , 40436 9001 6 provided provide VBN 40436 9001 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9001 8 can can MD 40436 9001 9 all all DT 40436 9001 10 be be VB 40436 9001 11 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 9001 12 , , , 40436 9001 13 the the DT 40436 9001 14 happier happy JJR 40436 9001 15 a a DT 40436 9001 16 man man NN 40436 9001 17 will will MD 40436 9001 18 be be VB 40436 9001 19 . . . 40436 9002 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9002 2 Sokr._--You Sokr._--You NNP 40436 9002 3 mean mean VBP 40436 9002 4 that that IN 40436 9002 5 a a DT 40436 9002 6 man man NN 40436 9002 7 shall shall MD 40436 9002 8 be be VB 40436 9002 9 continually continually RB 40436 9002 10 hungry hungry JJ 40436 9002 11 , , , 40436 9002 12 and and CC 40436 9002 13 continually continually RB 40436 9002 14 satisfying satisfy VBG 40436 9002 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9002 16 hunger hunger NN 40436 9002 17 : : : 40436 9002 18 continually continually RB 40436 9002 19 thirsty thirsty JJ 40436 9002 20 , , , 40436 9002 21 and and CC 40436 9002 22 satisfying satisfy VBG 40436 9002 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9002 24 thirst thirst NN 40436 9002 25 ; ; : 40436 9002 26 and and CC 40436 9002 27 so so RB 40436 9002 28 forth forth RB 40436 9002 29 . . . 40436 9003 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9003 2 Kall._--By Kall._--By NNP 40436 9003 3 having have VBG 40436 9003 4 and and CC 40436 9003 5 by by IN 40436 9003 6 satisfying satisfy VBG 40436 9003 7 those those DT 40436 9003 8 and and CC 40436 9003 9 all all DT 40436 9003 10 other other JJ 40436 9003 11 desires desire NNS 40436 9003 12 , , , 40436 9003 13 a a DT 40436 9003 14 man man NN 40436 9003 15 will will MD 40436 9003 16 enjoy enjoy VB 40436 9003 17 happiness happiness NN 40436 9003 18 . . . 40436 9004 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9004 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 9004 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9004 4 mean mean VBP 40436 9004 5 to to TO 40436 9004 6 include include VB 40436 9004 7 all all DT 40436 9004 8 varieties variety NNS 40436 9004 9 of of IN 40436 9004 10 desire desire NN 40436 9004 11 and and CC 40436 9004 12 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9004 13 of of IN 40436 9004 14 desire desire NN 40436 9004 15 : : : 40436 9004 16 such such JJ 40436 9004 17 for for IN 40436 9004 18 example example NN 40436 9004 19 as as IN 40436 9004 20 itching itching NN 40436 9004 21 and and CC 40436 9004 22 scratching scratching NN 40436 9004 23 yourself:[70 yourself:[70 NNS 40436 9004 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9004 25 and and CC 40436 9004 26 other other JJ 40436 9004 27 bodily bodily JJ 40436 9004 28 appetites appetite NNS 40436 9004 29 which which WDT 40436 9004 30 might may MD 40436 9004 31 be be VB 40436 9004 32 named name VBN 40436 9004 33 ? ? . 40436 9005 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9005 2 Kall._--Such Kall._--Such NNP 40436 9005 3 things thing NNS 40436 9005 4 are be VBP 40436 9005 5 not not RB 40436 9005 6 fit fit JJ 40436 9005 7 for for IN 40436 9005 8 discussion discussion NN 40436 9005 9 . . . 40436 9006 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9006 2 Sokr._--It Sokr._--It NNP 40436 9006 3 is be VBZ 40436 9006 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9006 5 who who WP 40436 9006 6 drive drive VBP 40436 9006 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9006 8 to to TO 40436 9006 9 mention mention VB 40436 9006 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9006 11 , , , 40436 9006 12 by by IN 40436 9006 13 laying lay VBG 40436 9006 14 down down RP 40436 9006 15 the the DT 40436 9006 16 principle principle NN 40436 9006 17 , , , 40436 9006 18 that that IN 40436 9006 19 men man NNS 40436 9006 20 who who WP 40436 9006 21 enjoy enjoy VBP 40436 9006 22 , , , 40436 9006 23 be be VB 40436 9006 24 the the DT 40436 9006 25 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9006 26 of of IN 40436 9006 27 what what WP 40436 9006 28 sort sort NN 40436 9006 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9006 30 may may MD 40436 9006 31 , , , 40436 9006 32 are be VBP 40436 9006 33 happy happy JJ 40436 9006 34 ; ; : 40436 9006 35 and and CC 40436 9006 36 by by IN 40436 9006 37 not not RB 40436 9006 38 distinguishing distinguish VBG 40436 9006 39 what what WDT 40436 9006 40 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9006 41 are be VBP 40436 9006 42 good good JJ 40436 9006 43 and and CC 40436 9006 44 what what WP 40436 9006 45 are be VBP 40436 9006 46 evil evil JJ 40436 9006 47 . . . 40436 9007 1 Tell tell VB 40436 9007 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9007 3 again again RB 40436 9007 4 , , , 40436 9007 5 do do VBP 40436 9007 6 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9007 7 think think VB 40436 9007 8 that that IN 40436 9007 9 the the DT 40436 9007 10 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 9007 11 and and CC 40436 9007 12 the the DT 40436 9007 13 good good JJ 40436 9007 14 are be VBP 40436 9007 15 identical identical JJ 40436 9007 16 ? ? . 40436 9008 1 Or or CC 40436 9008 2 are be VBP 40436 9008 3 there there EX 40436 9008 4 any any DT 40436 9008 5 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9008 6 things thing NNS 40436 9008 7 which which WDT 40436 9008 8 are be VBP 40436 9008 9 not not RB 40436 9008 10 good good JJ 40436 9008 11 ? ? . 40436 9009 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9009 2 71 71 CD 40436 9009 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9009 4 _ _ NNP 40436 9009 5 Kall._--I Kall._--I NNP 40436 9009 6 think think VBP 40436 9009 7 that that IN 40436 9009 8 the the DT 40436 9009 9 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 9009 10 and and CC 40436 9009 11 the the DT 40436 9009 12 good good JJ 40436 9009 13 are be VBP 40436 9009 14 the the DT 40436 9009 15 same same JJ 40436 9009 16 . . . 40436 9010 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9010 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9010 3 69 69 CD 40436 9010 4 : : : 40436 9010 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9010 6 , , , 40436 9010 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9010 8 , , , 40436 9010 9 p. p. NN 40436 9010 10 493 493 CD 40436 9010 11 C. C. NNP 40436 9010 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9010 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9010 14 : : : 40436 9010 15 e)a e)a NNP 40436 9010 16 / / SYM 40436 9010 17 n n CC 40436 9010 18 pôs pôs NNP 40436 9010 19 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 9010 20 / / SYM 40436 9010 21 s s NNP 40436 9010 22 t t NNP 40436 9010 23 ' ' '' 40436 9010 24 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 9010 25 pei pei NNP 40436 9010 26 = = FW 40436 9010 27 sai sai NNP 40436 9010 28 metathe metathe NNP 40436 9010 29 / / SYM 40436 9010 30 sthai sthai NNP 40436 9010 31 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9010 32 a)nti\ a)nti\ NNP 40436 9010 33 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9010 34 a)plê a)plê NNP 40436 9010 35 / / SYM 40436 9010 36 stôs stôs NNP 40436 9010 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9010 38 a)kola a)kola NNP 40436 9010 39 / / SYM 40436 9010 40 stôs stôs NNP 40436 9010 41 e)/chontos e)/chontos NNP 40436 9010 42 bi bi NNP 40436 9010 43 / / SYM 40436 9010 44 ou ou NNP 40436 9010 45 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9010 46 kosmi kosmi NNP 40436 9010 47 / / SYM 40436 9010 48 ôs ôs NNP 40436 9010 49 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9010 50 toi toi NNP 40436 9010 51 = = SYM 40436 9010 52 s s NNP 40436 9010 53 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 9010 54 parou parou NN 40436 9010 55 = = SYM 40436 9010 56 sin sin NN 40436 9010 57 i(kanô i(kanô VBZ 40436 9010 58 = = NFP 40436 9010 59 s s NNP 40436 9010 60 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9010 61 e)xarkou e)xarkou NNP 40436 9010 62 / / SYM 40436 9010 63 ntôs ntôs NNP 40436 9010 64 e)/chonta e)/chonta NNP 40436 9010 65 bi bi NNP 40436 9010 66 / / SYM 40436 9010 67 on on IN 40436 9010 68 e(le e(le NNP 40436 9010 69 / / SYM 40436 9010 70 sthai sthai NNP 40436 9010 71 . . . 40436 9010 72 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9010 73 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9011 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9011 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9011 3 70 70 CD 40436 9011 4 : : : 40436 9011 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9011 6 , , , 40436 9011 7 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 9011 8 . . . 40436 9012 1 p. p. NN 40436 9012 2 494 494 CD 40436 9012 3 E. E. NNP 40436 9012 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9012 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9012 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9012 7 71 71 CD 40436 9012 8 : : : 40436 9012 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9012 10 , , , 40436 9012 11 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 9012 12 . . . 40436 9013 1 pp pp NNP 40436 9013 2 . . . 40436 9014 1 494 494 CD 40436 9014 2 - - SYM 40436 9014 3 495 495 CD 40436 9014 4 . . . 40436 9015 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9015 2 Greek greek JJ 40436 9015 3 : : : 40436 9015 4 ê)= ê)= . 40436 9015 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9015 6 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 9015 7 a)/gô a)/gô NNP 40436 9015 8 e)ntau e)ntau NNS 40436 9015 9 = = SYM 40436 9015 10 tha tha NNP 40436 9015 11 , , , 40436 9015 12 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 9015 13 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 9015 14 = = NFP 40436 9015 15 nos nos NNP 40436 9015 16 o(\s o(\s NNP 40436 9015 17 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9015 18 phê=| phê=| NNP 40436 9015 19 a)ne a)ne NNP 40436 9015 20 / / SYM 40436 9015 21 dên dên NN 40436 9015 22 ou(/tô ou(/tô IN 40436 9015 23 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 9015 24 chai chai NNP 40436 9015 25 / / SYM 40436 9015 26 rontas rontas NNP 40436 9015 27 , , , 40436 9015 28 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 9015 29 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9015 30 chairôsin chairôsin NN 40436 9015 31 , , , 40436 9015 32 eu)dai eu)dai NNP 40436 9015 33 / / SYM 40436 9015 34 monas monas NNP 40436 9015 35 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 9015 36 , , , 40436 9015 37 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9015 38 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9015 39 diori diori NNP 40436 9015 40 / / SYM 40436 9015 41 zêtai zêtai NNP 40436 9015 42 tô tô NNP 40436 9015 43 = = SYM 40436 9015 44 n n CC 40436 9015 45 ê(donô ê(donô NNP 40436 9015 46 = = SYM 40436 9015 47 n n IN 40436 9015 48 o(poi o(poi NNP 40436 9015 49 = = SYM 40436 9015 50 ai ai NNP 40436 9015 51 a)gathai\ a)gathai\ NNP 40436 9015 52 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9015 53 kakai/ kakai/ NNP 40436 9015 54 ? ? . 40436 9016 1 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9016 2 ' ' POS 40436 9016 3 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 9016 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9016 5 nu nu NNP 40436 9016 6 = = SYM 40436 9016 7 n n NNP 40436 9016 8 le le NNP 40436 9016 9 / / SYM 40436 9016 10 ge ge NNP 40436 9016 11 , , , 40436 9016 12 po po NNP 40436 9016 13 / / SYM 40436 9016 14 teron teron NNP 40436 9016 15 phê\| phê\| NN 40436 9016 16 ei)=nai ei)=nai CC 40436 9016 17 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9016 18 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 9016 19 ê(du\ ê(du\ NNP 40436 9016 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9016 21 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 9016 22 / / SYM 40436 9016 23 n n NNP 40436 9016 24 , , , 40436 9016 25 ê)\ ê)\ ADD 40436 9016 26 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 9016 27 ti ti FW 40436 9016 28 tô tô NN 40436 9016 29 = = SYM 40436 9016 30 n n CC 40436 9016 31 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 9016 32 / / SYM 40436 9016 33 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9016 34 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 9016 35 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 9016 36 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 9016 37 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 9016 38 / / SYM 40436 9016 39 n n NN 40436 9016 40 ? ? . 40436 9016 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9016 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9017 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9017 2 Side side NN 40436 9017 3 - - HYPH 40436 9017 4 note note NN 40436 9017 5 : : : 40436 9017 6 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 9017 7 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 9017 8 that that DT 40436 9017 9 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9017 10 and and CC 40436 9017 11 good good JJ 40436 9017 12 are be VBP 40436 9017 13 identical identical JJ 40436 9017 14 . . . 40436 9018 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9018 2 refutes refute VBZ 40436 9018 3 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9018 4 . . . 40436 9019 1 Some some DT 40436 9019 2 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9019 3 are be VBP 40436 9019 4 good good JJ 40436 9019 5 , , , 40436 9019 6 others other NNS 40436 9019 7 bad bad JJ 40436 9019 8 . . . 40436 9020 1 A a DT 40436 9020 2 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9020 3 adviser adviser NN 40436 9020 4 is be VBZ 40436 9020 5 required require VBN 40436 9020 6 to to TO 40436 9020 7 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 9020 8 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9020 9 . . . 40436 9020 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9021 1 Upon upon IN 40436 9021 2 this this DT 40436 9021 3 question question NN 40436 9021 4 the the DT 40436 9021 5 discussion discussion NN 40436 9021 6 now now RB 40436 9021 7 turns turn VBZ 40436 9021 8 : : : 40436 9021 9 whether whether IN 40436 9021 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9021 11 and and CC 40436 9021 12 good good NN 40436 9021 13 are be VBP 40436 9021 14 the the DT 40436 9021 15 same same JJ 40436 9021 16 , , , 40436 9021 17 or or CC 40436 9021 18 whether whether IN 40436 9021 19 there there EX 40436 9021 20 are be VBP 40436 9021 21 not not RB 40436 9021 22 some some DT 40436 9021 23 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9021 24 good good JJ 40436 9021 25 , , , 40436 9021 26 others other NNS 40436 9021 27 bad bad JJ 40436 9021 28 . . . 40436 9022 1 By by IN 40436 9022 2 a a DT 40436 9022 3 string string NN 40436 9022 4 of of IN 40436 9022 5 questions question NNS 40436 9022 6 much much RB 40436 9022 7 protracted protract VBN 40436 9022 8 , , , 40436 9022 9 but but CC 40436 9022 10 subtle subtle JJ 40436 9022 11 rather rather RB 40436 9022 12 than than IN 40436 9022 13 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 9022 14 , , , 40436 9022 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9022 16 proves prove VBZ 40436 9022 17 that that IN 40436 9022 18 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9022 19 is be VBZ 40436 9022 20 not not RB 40436 9022 21 the the DT 40436 9022 22 same same JJ 40436 9022 23 as as IN 40436 9022 24 good good JJ 40436 9022 25 -- -- : 40436 9022 26 that that IN 40436 9022 27 there there EX 40436 9022 28 are be VBP 40436 9022 29 such such JJ 40436 9022 30 things thing NNS 40436 9022 31 as as IN 40436 9022 32 bad bad JJ 40436 9022 33 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9022 34 and and CC 40436 9022 35 good good JJ 40436 9022 36 pains pain NNS 40436 9022 37 . . . 40436 9023 1 And and CC 40436 9023 2 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9023 3 admits admit VBZ 40436 9023 4 that that IN 40436 9023 5 some some DT 40436 9023 6 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9023 7 are be VBP 40436 9023 8 better well JJR 40436 9023 9 , , , 40436 9023 10 others other NNS 40436 9023 11 worse worse RBR 40436 9023 12 . . . 40436 9024 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9024 2 72 72 CD 40436 9024 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9024 4 Profitable profitable JJ 40436 9024 5 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9024 6 are be VBP 40436 9024 7 good good JJ 40436 9024 8 : : : 40436 9024 9 hurtful hurtful JJ 40436 9024 10 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9024 11 are be VBP 40436 9024 12 bad bad JJ 40436 9024 13 . . . 40436 9025 1 Thus thus RB 40436 9025 2 the the DT 40436 9025 3 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9025 4 of of IN 40436 9025 5 eating eating NN 40436 9025 6 and and CC 40436 9025 7 drinking drinking NN 40436 9025 8 are be VBP 40436 9025 9 good good JJ 40436 9025 10 , , , 40436 9025 11 if if IN 40436 9025 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9025 13 impart impart VBP 40436 9025 14 to to IN 40436 9025 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9025 16 health health NN 40436 9025 17 and and CC 40436 9025 18 strength strength NN 40436 9025 19 -- -- : 40436 9025 20 bad bad JJ 40436 9025 21 , , , 40436 9025 22 if if IN 40436 9025 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9025 24 produce produce VBP 40436 9025 25 sickness sickness NN 40436 9025 26 and and CC 40436 9025 27 weakness weakness NN 40436 9025 28 . . . 40436 9026 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9026 2 ought ought MD 40436 9026 3 to to TO 40436 9026 4 choose choose VB 40436 9026 5 the the DT 40436 9026 6 good good JJ 40436 9026 7 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9026 8 and and CC 40436 9026 9 pains pain NNS 40436 9026 10 , , , 40436 9026 11 and and CC 40436 9026 12 avoid avoid VB 40436 9026 13 the the DT 40436 9026 14 bad bad JJ 40436 9026 15 ones one NNS 40436 9026 16 . . . 40436 9027 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9027 2 is be VBZ 40436 9027 3 not not RB 40436 9027 4 every every DT 40436 9027 5 man man NN 40436 9027 6 who who WP 40436 9027 7 is be VBZ 40436 9027 8 competent competent JJ 40436 9027 9 to to TO 40436 9027 10 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 9027 11 what what WDT 40436 9027 12 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9027 13 are be VBP 40436 9027 14 good good JJ 40436 9027 15 , , , 40436 9027 16 and and CC 40436 9027 17 what what WP 40436 9027 18 are be VBP 40436 9027 19 bad bad JJ 40436 9027 20 . . . 40436 9028 1 A a DT 40436 9028 2 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9028 3 and and CC 40436 9028 4 skilful skilful JJ 40436 9028 5 adviser adviser NN 40436 9028 6 , , , 40436 9028 7 judging judge VBG 40436 9028 8 upon upon IN 40436 9028 9 general general JJ 40436 9028 10 principles principle NNS 40436 9028 11 , , , 40436 9028 12 is be VBZ 40436 9028 13 required require VBN 40436 9028 14 to to TO 40436 9028 15 make make VB 40436 9028 16 this this DT 40436 9028 17 distinction distinction NN 40436 9028 18 . . . 40436 9029 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9029 2 73 73 CD 40436 9029 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9029 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9029 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9029 6 72 72 CD 40436 9029 7 : : : 40436 9029 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9029 9 , , , 40436 9029 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9029 11 , , , 40436 9029 12 pp pp NNP 40436 9029 13 . . . 40436 9030 1 496 496 CD 40436 9030 2 - - SYM 40436 9030 3 499 499 CD 40436 9030 4 . . . 40436 9030 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9031 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9031 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9031 3 73 73 CD 40436 9031 4 : : : 40436 9031 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9031 6 , , , 40436 9031 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9031 8 , , , 40436 9031 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9031 10 . . . 40436 9032 1 499 499 CD 40436 9032 2 - - SYM 40436 9032 3 500 500 CD 40436 9032 4 . . . 40436 9033 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9033 2 Greek greek JJ 40436 9033 3 : : : 40436 9033 4 A)=r A)=r NNP 40436 9033 5 ' ' POS 40436 9033 6 ou)=n ou)=n NN 40436 9033 7 panto\s panto\s -LRB- 40436 9033 8 a)ndro a)ndro NNP 40436 9033 9 / / SYM 40436 9033 10 s s NNP 40436 9033 11 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 9033 12 e)kle e)kle NNP 40436 9033 13 / / SYM 40436 9033 14 xasthai xasthai NNP 40436 9033 15 poi poi NNP 40436 9033 16 = = SYM 40436 9033 17 a a DT 40436 9033 18 a)gatha\ a)gatha\ NNP 40436 9033 19 tô tô NNP 40436 9033 20 = = SYM 40436 9033 21 n n CC 40436 9033 22 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 9033 23 / / SYM 40436 9033 24 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9033 25 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 9033 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9033 27 o(poi o(poi NNP 40436 9033 28 = = SYM 40436 9033 29 a a DT 40436 9033 30 kaka/ kaka/ NN 40436 9033 31 , , , 40436 9033 32 ê)= ê)= FW 40436 9033 33 technikou= technikou= JJ 40436 9033 34 dei= dei= NNP 40436 9033 35 ei)s ei)s , 40436 9033 36 e(/kaston e(/kaston NN 40436 9033 37 ? ? . 40436 9034 1 Technikou=. technikou=. LS 40436 9034 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9034 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9035 1 * * NFP 40436 9035 2 * * NFP 40436 9035 3 * * NFP 40436 9035 4 * * NFP 40436 9035 5 * * NFP 40436 9035 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9035 7 Side side NN 40436 9035 8 - - HYPH 40436 9035 9 note note NN 40436 9035 10 : : : 40436 9035 11 Contradiction contradiction NN 40436 9035 12 between between IN 40436 9035 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9035 14 in in IN 40436 9035 15 the the DT 40436 9035 16 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9035 17 , , , 40436 9035 18 and and CC 40436 9035 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9035 20 in in IN 40436 9035 21 the the DT 40436 9035 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9035 23 . . . 40436 9035 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9036 1 This this DT 40436 9036 2 debate debate NN 40436 9036 3 between between IN 40436 9036 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9036 5 and and CC 40436 9036 6 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9036 7 , , , 40436 9036 8 respecting respect VBG 40436 9036 9 the the DT 40436 9036 10 " " `` 40436 9036 11 Quomodo quomodo JJ 40436 9036 12 vivendum vivendum NN 40436 9036 13 est,"[74 est,"[74 '' 40436 9036 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9036 15 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 9036 16 attention attention NN 40436 9036 17 on on IN 40436 9036 18 more more JJR 40436 9036 19 than than IN 40436 9036 20 one one CD 40436 9036 21 account account NN 40436 9036 22 . . . 40436 9037 1 In in IN 40436 9037 2 the the DT 40436 9037 3 first first JJ 40436 9037 4 place place NN 40436 9037 5 , , , 40436 9037 6 the the DT 40436 9037 7 relation relation NN 40436 9037 8 which which WDT 40436 9037 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9037 10 is be VBZ 40436 9037 11 here here RB 40436 9037 12 made make VBN 40436 9037 13 to to TO 40436 9037 14 declare declare VB 40436 9037 15 between between IN 40436 9037 16 the the DT 40436 9037 17 two two CD 40436 9037 18 pairs pair NNS 40436 9037 19 of of IN 40436 9037 20 general general JJ 40436 9037 21 terms term NNS 40436 9037 22 , , , 40436 9037 23 Pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9037 24 -- -- : 40436 9037 25 Good good JJ 40436 9037 26 : : : 40436 9037 27 Painful painful JJ 40436 9037 28 -- -- : 40436 9037 29 Evil evil NN 40436 9037 30 : : : 40436 9037 31 is be VBZ 40436 9037 32 the the DT 40436 9037 33 direct direct JJ 40436 9037 34 reverse reverse NN 40436 9037 35 of of IN 40436 9037 36 that that DT 40436 9037 37 which which WDT 40436 9037 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9037 39 both both CC 40436 9037 40 declares declare VBZ 40436 9037 41 and and CC 40436 9037 42 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 40436 9037 43 in in IN 40436 9037 44 the the DT 40436 9037 45 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9037 46 . . . 40436 9038 1 In in IN 40436 9038 2 that that DT 40436 9038 3 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9038 4 , , , 40436 9038 5 the the DT 40436 9038 6 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 9038 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9038 8 is be VBZ 40436 9038 9 represented represent VBN 40436 9038 10 as as IN 40436 9038 11 holding hold VBG 40436 9038 12 an an DT 40436 9038 13 opinion opinion NN 40436 9038 14 very very RB 40436 9038 15 like like IN 40436 9038 16 that that DT 40436 9038 17 which which WDT 40436 9038 18 is be VBZ 40436 9038 19 maintained maintain VBN 40436 9038 20 by by IN 40436 9038 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9038 22 in in IN 40436 9038 23 the the DT 40436 9038 24 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9038 25 . . . 40436 9039 1 But but CC 40436 9039 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9039 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9039 4 in in IN 40436 9039 5 the the DT 40436 9039 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9039 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9039 8 refutes refute VBZ 40436 9039 9 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9039 10 by by IN 40436 9039 11 an an DT 40436 9039 12 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 9039 13 argument argument NN 40436 9039 14 ; ; : 40436 9039 15 and and CC 40436 9039 16 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 40436 9039 17 that that IN 40436 9039 18 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9039 19 and and CC 40436 9039 20 good good NN 40436 9039 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9039 22 also also RB 40436 9039 23 pain pain NN 40436 9039 24 and and CC 40436 9039 25 evil evil NN 40436 9039 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9039 27 are be VBP 40436 9039 28 names name NNS 40436 9039 29 for for IN 40436 9039 30 the the DT 40436 9039 31 same same JJ 40436 9039 32 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 9039 33 ideas idea NNS 40436 9039 34 under under IN 40436 9039 35 different different JJ 40436 9039 36 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 9039 37 : : : 40436 9039 38 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9039 39 and and CC 40436 9039 40 painful painful JJ 40436 9039 41 referring refer VBG 40436 9039 42 only only RB 40436 9039 43 to to IN 40436 9039 44 the the DT 40436 9039 45 sensation sensation NN 40436 9039 46 of of IN 40436 9039 47 the the DT 40436 9039 48 present present JJ 40436 9039 49 moment moment NN 40436 9039 50 -- -- : 40436 9039 51 while while IN 40436 9039 52 good good JJ 40436 9039 53 and and CC 40436 9039 54 evil evil NN 40436 9039 55 include include VBP 40436 9039 56 , , , 40436 9039 57 besides besides RB 40436 9039 58 , , , 40436 9039 59 an an DT 40436 9039 60 estimate estimate NN 40436 9039 61 of of IN 40436 9039 62 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9039 63 future future JJ 40436 9039 64 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9039 65 and and CC 40436 9039 66 accompaniments accompaniment NNS 40436 9039 67 , , , 40436 9039 68 both both DT 40436 9039 69 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9039 70 and and CC 40436 9039 71 painful painful JJ 40436 9039 72 , , , 40436 9039 73 and and CC 40436 9039 74 represent represent VB 40436 9039 75 the the DT 40436 9039 76 result result NN 40436 9039 77 of of IN 40436 9039 78 such such JJ 40436 9039 79 calculation calculation NN 40436 9039 80 . . . 40436 9040 1 In in IN 40436 9040 2 the the DT 40436 9040 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9040 4 , , , 40436 9040 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9040 6 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 40436 9040 7 the the DT 40436 9040 8 contrary contrary NN 40436 9040 9 , , , 40436 9040 10 by by IN 40436 9040 11 an an DT 40436 9040 12 argument argument NN 40436 9040 13 equally equally RB 40436 9040 14 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 9040 15 but but CC 40436 9040 16 not not RB 40436 9040 17 equally equally RB 40436 9040 18 convincing convincing JJ 40436 9040 19 . . . 40436 9041 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9041 2 impugns impugn VBZ 40436 9041 3 a a DT 40436 9041 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9041 5 advocated advocate VBN 40436 9041 6 by by IN 40436 9041 7 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9041 8 , , , 40436 9041 9 and and CC 40436 9041 10 in in IN 40436 9041 11 impugning impugn VBG 40436 9041 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9041 13 , , , 40436 9041 14 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 9041 15 a a DT 40436 9041 16 marked marked JJ 40436 9041 17 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9041 18 and and CC 40436 9041 19 even even RB 40436 9041 20 repugnance repugnance NN 40436 9041 21 between between IN 40436 9041 22 the the DT 40436 9041 23 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 9041 24 and and CC 40436 9041 25 the the DT 40436 9041 26 good good JJ 40436 9041 27 , , , 40436 9041 28 the the DT 40436 9041 29 painful painful JJ 40436 9041 30 and and CC 40436 9041 31 the the DT 40436 9041 32 evil evil NN 40436 9041 33 : : : 40436 9041 34 rejecting reject VBG 40436 9041 35 the the DT 40436 9041 36 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 9041 37 identity identity NN 40436 9041 38 of of IN 40436 9041 39 the the DT 40436 9041 40 two two CD 40436 9041 41 , , , 40436 9041 42 which which WDT 40436 9041 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9041 44 advocates advocate VBZ 40436 9041 45 in in IN 40436 9041 46 the the DT 40436 9041 47 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9041 48 , , , 40436 9041 49 as as IN 40436 9041 50 if if IN 40436 9041 51 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9041 52 were be VBD 40436 9041 53 a a DT 40436 9041 54 disgraceful disgraceful JJ 40436 9041 55 heresy heresy NN 40436 9041 56 . . . 40436 9042 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9042 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9042 3 74 74 CD 40436 9042 4 : : : 40436 9042 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9042 6 , , , 40436 9042 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9042 8 , , , 40436 9042 9 p. p. NN 40436 9042 10 492 492 CD 40436 9042 11 D. D. NNP 40436 9042 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9042 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9042 14 : : : 40436 9042 15 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 9042 16 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9042 17 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 9042 18 kata kata NNP 40436 9042 19 / / SYM 40436 9042 20 dêlon dêlon NNP 40436 9042 21 ge ge NNP 40436 9042 22 / / SYM 40436 9042 23 nêtai nêtai NNP 40436 9042 24 , , , 40436 9042 25 pô pô NNP 40436 9042 26 = = SYM 40436 9042 27 s s NNP 40436 9042 28 biôte biôte NN 40436 9042 29 / / SYM 40436 9042 30 on on RB 40436 9042 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9042 32 , , , 40436 9042 33 & & CC 40436 9042 34 c. c. NNP 40436 9042 35 500 500 CD 40436 9042 36 C C NNP 40436 9042 37 : : : 40436 9042 38 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9042 39 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9042 40 : : : 40436 9042 41 o(/ntina o(/ntina NNP 40436 9042 42 chrê\ chrê\ NNP 40436 9042 43 tro tro NN 40436 9042 44 / / SYM 40436 9042 45 pon pon NNP 40436 9042 46 zê=|n zê=|n CD 40436 9042 47 . . . 40436 9042 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9042 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9043 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9043 2 Side side NN 40436 9043 3 - - HYPH 40436 9043 4 note note NN 40436 9043 5 : : : 40436 9043 6 Views view NNS 40436 9043 7 of of IN 40436 9043 8 critics critic NNS 40436 9043 9 about about IN 40436 9043 10 this this DT 40436 9043 11 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 9043 12 . . . 40436 9043 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9044 1 The the DT 40436 9044 2 subject subject NN 40436 9044 3 evidently evidently RB 40436 9044 4 presented present VBD 40436 9044 5 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9044 6 to to IN 40436 9044 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9044 8 in in IN 40436 9044 9 two two CD 40436 9044 10 different different JJ 40436 9044 11 ways way NNS 40436 9044 12 at at IN 40436 9044 13 different different JJ 40436 9044 14 times time NNS 40436 9044 15 . . . 40436 9045 1 Which which WDT 40436 9045 2 of of IN 40436 9045 3 the the DT 40436 9045 4 two two CD 40436 9045 5 is be VBZ 40436 9045 6 earliest early JJS 40436 9045 7 , , , 40436 9045 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9045 9 have have VBP 40436 9045 10 no no DT 40436 9045 11 means means NN 40436 9045 12 of of IN 40436 9045 13 deciding decide VBG 40436 9045 14 . . . 40436 9046 1 The the DT 40436 9046 2 commentators commentator NNS 40436 9046 3 , , , 40436 9046 4 who who WP 40436 9046 5 favour favour VBP 40436 9046 6 generally generally RB 40436 9046 7 the the DT 40436 9046 8 view view NN 40436 9046 9 taken take VBN 40436 9046 10 in in IN 40436 9046 11 the the DT 40436 9046 12 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9046 13 , , , 40436 9046 14 treat treat VB 40436 9046 15 the the DT 40436 9046 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9046 17 as as IN 40436 9046 18 a a DT 40436 9046 19 juvenile juvenile JJ 40436 9046 20 and and CC 40436 9046 21 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 9046 22 production production NN 40436 9046 23 : : : 40436 9046 24 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 9046 25 , , , 40436 9046 26 with with IN 40436 9046 27 still still RB 40436 9046 28 less less JJR 40436 9046 29 reason reason NN 40436 9046 30 , , , 40436 9046 31 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9046 32 represent represent VBP 40436 9046 33 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9046 34 as as IN 40436 9046 35 arguing argue VBG 40436 9046 36 in in IN 40436 9046 37 that that DT 40436 9046 38 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9046 39 , , , 40436 9046 40 from from IN 40436 9046 41 the the DT 40436 9046 42 principles principle NNS 40436 9046 43 of of IN 40436 9046 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9046 45 opponents opponent NNS 40436 9046 46 , , , 40436 9046 47 not not RB 40436 9046 48 from from IN 40436 9046 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9046 50 own own JJ 40436 9046 51 . . . 40436 9047 1 For for IN 40436 9047 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9047 3 part part NN 40436 9047 4 , , , 40436 9047 5 without without IN 40436 9047 6 knowing know VBG 40436 9047 7 whether whether IN 40436 9047 8 the the DT 40436 9047 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9047 10 or or CC 40436 9047 11 the the DT 40436 9047 12 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9047 13 is be VBZ 40436 9047 14 the the DT 40436 9047 15 earliest early JJS 40436 9047 16 , , , 40436 9047 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9047 18 think think VBP 40436 9047 19 the the DT 40436 9047 20 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9047 21 an an DT 40436 9047 22 equally equally RB 40436 9047 23 finished finish VBN 40436 9047 24 composition composition NN 40436 9047 25 , , , 40436 9047 26 and and CC 40436 9047 27 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9047 28 consider consider VBP 40436 9047 29 that that IN 40436 9047 30 the the DT 40436 9047 31 views view NNS 40436 9047 32 which which WDT 40436 9047 33 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9047 34 is be VBZ 40436 9047 35 made make VBN 40436 9047 36 to to TO 40436 9047 37 propound propound VB 40436 9047 38 in in IN 40436 9047 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9047 40 , , , 40436 9047 41 respecting respect VBG 40436 9047 42 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9047 43 and and CC 40436 9047 44 good good JJ 40436 9047 45 , , , 40436 9047 46 are be VBP 40436 9047 47 decidedly decidedly RB 40436 9047 48 nearer nearer JJ 40436 9047 49 to to IN 40436 9047 50 the the DT 40436 9047 51 truth truth NN 40436 9047 52 . . . 40436 9048 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9048 2 Side side NN 40436 9048 3 - - HYPH 40436 9048 4 note note NN 40436 9048 5 : : : 40436 9048 6 Comparison comparison NN 40436 9048 7 and and CC 40436 9048 8 appreciation appreciation NN 40436 9048 9 of of IN 40436 9048 10 the the DT 40436 9048 11 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 9048 12 of of IN 40436 9048 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9048 14 in in IN 40436 9048 15 both both DT 40436 9048 16 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9048 17 . . . 40436 9048 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9049 1 That that IN 40436 9049 2 in in IN 40436 9049 3 the the DT 40436 9049 4 list list NN 40436 9049 5 of of IN 40436 9049 6 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9049 7 there there EX 40436 9049 8 are be VBP 40436 9049 9 some some DT 40436 9049 10 which which WDT 40436 9049 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9049 12 is be VBZ 40436 9049 13 proper proper JJ 40436 9049 14 to to IN 40436 9049 15 avoid,--and avoid,--and NNP 40436 9049 16 in in IN 40436 9049 17 the the DT 40436 9049 18 list list NN 40436 9049 19 of of IN 40436 9049 20 pains pain NNS 40436 9049 21 , , , 40436 9049 22 some some DT 40436 9049 23 which which WDT 40436 9049 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9049 25 is be VBZ 40436 9049 26 proper proper JJ 40436 9049 27 to to TO 40436 9049 28 accept accept VB 40436 9049 29 or or CC 40436 9049 30 invite invite VB 40436 9049 31 -- -- : 40436 9049 32 is be VBZ 40436 9049 33 a a DT 40436 9049 34 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9049 35 maintained maintain VBN 40436 9049 36 by by IN 40436 9049 37 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9049 38 alike alike RB 40436 9049 39 in in IN 40436 9049 40 both both PDT 40436 9049 41 the the DT 40436 9049 42 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9049 43 . . . 40436 9050 1 Why why WRB 40436 9050 2 ? ? . 40436 9051 1 Because because IN 40436 9051 2 some some DT 40436 9051 3 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9051 4 are be VBP 40436 9051 5 good good JJ 40436 9051 6 , , , 40436 9051 7 others other NNS 40436 9051 8 bad bad JJ 40436 9051 9 : : : 40436 9051 10 some some DT 40436 9051 11 pains pain NNS 40436 9051 12 bad bad JJ 40436 9051 13 , , , 40436 9051 14 others other NNS 40436 9051 15 good good JJ 40436 9051 16 -- -- : 40436 9051 17 says say VBZ 40436 9051 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9051 19 in in IN 40436 9051 20 the the DT 40436 9051 21 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9051 22 . . . 40436 9052 1 The the DT 40436 9052 2 same same JJ 40436 9052 3 too too RB 40436 9052 4 is be VBZ 40436 9052 5 said say VBN 40436 9052 6 by by IN 40436 9052 7 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9052 8 in in IN 40436 9052 9 the the DT 40436 9052 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9052 11 ; ; : 40436 9052 12 but but CC 40436 9052 13 then then RB 40436 9052 14 , , , 40436 9052 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9052 16 there there RB 40436 9052 17 explains explain VBZ 40436 9052 18 what what WP 40436 9052 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9052 20 means mean VBZ 40436 9052 21 by by IN 40436 9052 22 the the DT 40436 9052 23 appellation appellation NN 40436 9052 24 . . . 40436 9053 1 All all DT 40436 9053 2 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9053 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9053 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9053 5 there there RB 40436 9053 6 says say VBZ 40436 9053 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9053 8 , , , 40436 9053 9 so so RB 40436 9053 10 far far RB 40436 9053 11 as as IN 40436 9053 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9053 13 goes go VBZ 40436 9053 14 , , , 40436 9053 15 is be VBZ 40436 9053 16 good good JJ 40436 9053 17 -- -- : 40436 9053 18 all all DT 40436 9053 19 pain pain NN 40436 9053 20 is be VBZ 40436 9053 21 bad bad JJ 40436 9053 22 . . . 40436 9054 1 But but CC 40436 9054 2 there there EX 40436 9054 3 are be VBP 40436 9054 4 some some DT 40436 9054 5 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9054 6 which which WDT 40436 9054 7 can can MD 40436 9054 8 not not RB 40436 9054 9 be be VB 40436 9054 10 enjoyed enjoy VBN 40436 9054 11 without without IN 40436 9054 12 debarring debar VBG 40436 9054 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9054 14 from from IN 40436 9054 15 greater great JJR 40436 9054 16 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9054 17 or or CC 40436 9054 18 entailing entail VBG 40436 9054 19 upon upon IN 40436 9054 20 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9054 21 greater great JJR 40436 9054 22 pains pain NNS 40436 9054 23 : : : 40436 9054 24 on on IN 40436 9054 25 that that DT 40436 9054 26 ground ground NN 40436 9054 27 therefore therefore RB 40436 9054 28 , , , 40436 9054 29 such such JJ 40436 9054 30 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9054 31 are be VBP 40436 9054 32 bad bad JJ 40436 9054 33 . . . 40436 9055 1 So so RB 40436 9055 2 again again RB 40436 9055 3 , , , 40436 9055 4 there there EX 40436 9055 5 are be VBP 40436 9055 6 some some DT 40436 9055 7 pains pain NNS 40436 9055 8 , , , 40436 9055 9 the the DT 40436 9055 10 suffering suffering NN 40436 9055 11 of of IN 40436 9055 12 which which WDT 40436 9055 13 is be VBZ 40436 9055 14 a a DT 40436 9055 15 condition condition NN 40436 9055 16 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 9055 17 to to IN 40436 9055 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9055 19 escaping escape VBG 40436 9055 20 greater great JJR 40436 9055 21 pains pain NNS 40436 9055 22 , , , 40436 9055 23 or or CC 40436 9055 24 to to IN 40436 9055 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9055 26 enjoying enjoy VBG 40436 9055 27 greater great JJR 40436 9055 28 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9055 29 : : : 40436 9055 30 such such JJ 40436 9055 31 pains pain NNS 40436 9055 32 therefore therefore RB 40436 9055 33 are be VBP 40436 9055 34 good good JJ 40436 9055 35 . . . 40436 9056 1 Thus thus RB 40436 9056 2 this this DT 40436 9056 3 apparent apparent JJ 40436 9056 4 exception exception NN 40436 9056 5 does do VBZ 40436 9056 6 not not RB 40436 9056 7 really really RB 40436 9056 8 contradict contradict VB 40436 9056 9 , , , 40436 9056 10 but but CC 40436 9056 11 confirms confirm VBZ 40436 9056 12 , , , 40436 9056 13 the the DT 40436 9056 14 general general JJ 40436 9056 15 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9056 16 -- -- : 40436 9056 17 That that IN 40436 9056 18 there there EX 40436 9056 19 is be VBZ 40436 9056 20 no no DT 40436 9056 21 good good JJ 40436 9056 22 but but CC 40436 9056 23 the the DT 40436 9056 24 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 9056 25 , , , 40436 9056 26 and and CC 40436 9056 27 the the DT 40436 9056 28 elimination elimination NN 40436 9056 29 of of IN 40436 9056 30 pain pain NN 40436 9056 31 -- -- : 40436 9056 32 and and CC 40436 9056 33 no no DT 40436 9056 34 evil evil NN 40436 9056 35 except except IN 40436 9056 36 the the DT 40436 9056 37 painful painful JJ 40436 9056 38 , , , 40436 9056 39 or or CC 40436 9056 40 the the DT 40436 9056 41 privation privation NN 40436 9056 42 of of IN 40436 9056 43 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9056 44 . . . 40436 9057 1 Good good JJ 40436 9057 2 and and CC 40436 9057 3 evil evil NN 40436 9057 4 have have VBP 40436 9057 5 no no DT 40436 9057 6 reference reference NN 40436 9057 7 except except IN 40436 9057 8 to to IN 40436 9057 9 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9057 10 and and CC 40436 9057 11 pains pain NNS 40436 9057 12 ; ; : 40436 9057 13 but but CC 40436 9057 14 the the DT 40436 9057 15 terms term NNS 40436 9057 16 imply imply VBP 40436 9057 17 , , , 40436 9057 18 in in IN 40436 9057 19 each each DT 40436 9057 20 particular particular JJ 40436 9057 21 case case NN 40436 9057 22 , , , 40436 9057 23 an an DT 40436 9057 24 estimate estimate NN 40436 9057 25 and and CC 40436 9057 26 comparison comparison NN 40436 9057 27 of of IN 40436 9057 28 future future JJ 40436 9057 29 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9057 30 and and CC 40436 9057 31 painful painful JJ 40436 9057 32 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9057 33 , , , 40436 9057 34 and and CC 40436 9057 35 express express VB 40436 9057 36 the the DT 40436 9057 37 result result NN 40436 9057 38 of of IN 40436 9057 39 such such JJ 40436 9057 40 comparison comparison NN 40436 9057 41 . . . 40436 9058 1 " " `` 40436 9058 2 You -PRON- PRP 40436 9058 3 call call VBP 40436 9058 4 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9058 5 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9058 6 evil evil JJ 40436 9058 7 " " '' 40436 9058 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9058 9 says say VBZ 40436 9058 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9058 11 in in IN 40436 9058 12 the the DT 40436 9058 13 Protagoras),[75 protagoras),[75 NN 40436 9058 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9058 15 " " `` 40436 9058 16 when when WRB 40436 9058 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9058 18 deprives deprive VBZ 40436 9058 19 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9058 20 of of IN 40436 9058 21 greater great JJR 40436 9058 22 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9058 23 or or CC 40436 9058 24 entails entail NNS 40436 9058 25 upon upon IN 40436 9058 26 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9058 27 greater great JJR 40436 9058 28 pains pain NNS 40436 9058 29 . . . 40436 9059 1 If if IN 40436 9059 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9059 3 have have VBP 40436 9059 4 any any DT 40436 9059 5 other other JJ 40436 9059 6 ground ground NN 40436 9059 7 , , , 40436 9059 8 or or CC 40436 9059 9 look look VB 40436 9059 10 to to IN 40436 9059 11 any any DT 40436 9059 12 other other JJ 40436 9059 13 end end NN 40436 9059 14 , , , 40436 9059 15 in in IN 40436 9059 16 calling call VBG 40436 9059 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9059 18 evil evil NN 40436 9059 19 , , , 40436 9059 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9059 21 may may MD 40436 9059 22 tell tell VB 40436 9059 23 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9059 24 what what WP 40436 9059 25 that that DT 40436 9059 26 end end NN 40436 9059 27 is be VBZ 40436 9059 28 ; ; : 40436 9059 29 but but CC 40436 9059 30 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9059 31 will will MD 40436 9059 32 not not RB 40436 9059 33 be be VB 40436 9059 34 able able JJ 40436 9059 35 to to TO 40436 9059 36 tell tell VB 40436 9059 37 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9059 38 . . . 40436 9060 1 So so RB 40436 9060 2 too too RB 40436 9060 3 , , , 40436 9060 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9060 5 say say VBP 40436 9060 6 that that IN 40436 9060 7 pain pain NN 40436 9060 8 is be VBZ 40436 9060 9 a a DT 40436 9060 10 good good JJ 40436 9060 11 , , , 40436 9060 12 when when WRB 40436 9060 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9060 14 relieves relieve VBZ 40436 9060 15 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9060 16 from from IN 40436 9060 17 greater great JJR 40436 9060 18 pains pain NNS 40436 9060 19 , , , 40436 9060 20 or or CC 40436 9060 21 when when WRB 40436 9060 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9060 23 is be VBZ 40436 9060 24 necessary necessary JJ 40436 9060 25 as as IN 40436 9060 26 the the DT 40436 9060 27 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 9060 28 cause cause NN 40436 9060 29 of of IN 40436 9060 30 greater great JJR 40436 9060 31 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9060 32 . . . 40436 9061 1 If if IN 40436 9061 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9061 3 have have VBP 40436 9061 4 any any DT 40436 9061 5 other other JJ 40436 9061 6 end end NN 40436 9061 7 in in IN 40436 9061 8 view view NN 40436 9061 9 , , , 40436 9061 10 when when WRB 40436 9061 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9061 12 call call VBP 40436 9061 13 pain pain NN 40436 9061 14 good good JJ 40436 9061 15 , , , 40436 9061 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9061 17 may may MD 40436 9061 18 tell tell VB 40436 9061 19 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9061 20 what what WP 40436 9061 21 that that DT 40436 9061 22 end end NN 40436 9061 23 is be VBZ 40436 9061 24 ; ; : 40436 9061 25 but but CC 40436 9061 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9061 27 will will MD 40436 9061 28 not not RB 40436 9061 29 be be VB 40436 9061 30 able able JJ 40436 9061 31 to to TO 40436 9061 32 tell tell VB 40436 9061 33 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9061 34 . . . 40436 9062 1 " " `` 40436 9062 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9062 3 76 76 CD 40436 9062 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9062 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9062 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9062 7 75 75 CD 40436 9062 8 : : : 40436 9062 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9062 10 , , , 40436 9062 11 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9062 12 , , , 40436 9062 13 * * NFP 40436 9062 14 * * NFP 40436 9062 15 p. p. NN 40436 9062 16 354 354 CD 40436 9062 17 D. D. NNP 40436 9062 18 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9062 19 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9062 20 : : : 40436 9062 21 e)pei/ e)pei/ NN 40436 9062 22 , , , 40436 9062 23 ei ei NNP 40436 9062 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9062 25 kat kat NNP 40436 9062 26 ' ' '' 40436 9062 27 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 9062 28 ti ti NNP 40436 9062 29 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 9062 30 to\ to\ NN 40436 9062 31 chai chai NN 40436 9062 32 / / SYM 40436 9062 33 rein rein NNP 40436 9062 34 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 9062 35 kalei kalei NNP 40436 9062 36 = = SYM 40436 9062 37 te te NNP 40436 9062 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9062 39 ei)s ei)s , 40436 9062 40 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 9062 41 ti ti NNP 40436 9062 42 te te NNP 40436 9062 43 / / SYM 40436 9062 44 los los NNP 40436 9062 45 a)poble a)poble NNP 40436 9062 46 / / SYM 40436 9062 47 psantes psante NNS 40436 9062 48 , , , 40436 9062 49 e)/choite e)/choite NNP 40436 9062 50 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9062 51 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9062 52 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 9062 53 = = SYM 40436 9062 54 n n NNP 40436 9062 55 ei)pei ei)pei NNP 40436 9062 56 = = SYM 40436 9062 57 n n XX 40436 9062 58 ; ; : 40436 9062 59 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9062 60 ' ' '' 40436 9062 61 ou)ch ou)ch NN 40436 9062 62 e(/xete e(/xete CD 40436 9062 63 . . . 40436 9063 1 . . . 40436 9064 1 . . . 40436 9065 1 . . . 40436 9066 1 e)pei\ e)pei\ VBZ 40436 9066 2 ei ei NNP 40436 9066 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9066 4 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 9066 5 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 9066 6 ti ti NNP 40436 9066 7 te te NNP 40436 9066 8 / / SYM 40436 9066 9 los los NNP 40436 9066 10 a)poble a)poble NNP 40436 9066 11 / / SYM 40436 9066 12 pete pete NNP 40436 9066 13 , , , 40436 9066 14 o(/tan o(/tan NNP 40436 9066 15 kalê kalê NNP 40436 9066 16 = = SYM 40436 9066 17 te te NNP 40436 9066 18 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 9066 19 to\ to\ NN 40436 9066 20 lupei lupei NNP 40436 9066 21 = = SYM 40436 9066 22 sthai sthai NNP 40436 9066 23 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 9066 24 / / SYM 40436 9066 25 n n NNP 40436 9066 26 , , , 40436 9066 27 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 9066 28 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 9066 29 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 9066 30 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 9066 31 le le NNP 40436 9066 32 / / SYM 40436 9066 33 gô gô NNP 40436 9066 34 , , , 40436 9066 35 e)/chete e)/chete CD 40436 9066 36 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 9066 37 = = SYM 40436 9066 38 n n NNP 40436 9066 39 ei)pein ei)pein NN 40436 9066 40 ; ; : 40436 9066 41 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9066 42 ' ' '' 40436 9066 43 ou)ch ou)ch NN 40436 9066 44 e(/xete e(/xete CD 40436 9066 45 . . . 40436 9066 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9066 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9067 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9067 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9067 3 76 76 CD 40436 9067 4 : : : 40436 9067 5 In in IN 40436 9067 6 a a DT 40436 9067 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 9067 8 passage passage NN 40436 9067 9 of of IN 40436 9067 10 the the DT 40436 9067 11 De De NNP 40436 9067 12 Legibus Legibus NNP 40436 9067 13 , , , 40436 9067 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9067 15 denies deny VBZ 40436 9067 16 all all DT 40436 9067 17 essential essential JJ 40436 9067 18 distinction distinction NN 40436 9067 19 between between IN 40436 9067 20 Good Good NNP 40436 9067 21 and and CC 40436 9067 22 Pleasure Pleasure NNP 40436 9067 23 , , , 40436 9067 24 and and CC 40436 9067 25 all all DT 40436 9067 26 reality reality NN 40436 9067 27 of of IN 40436 9067 28 Good good JJ 40436 9067 29 apart apart RB 40436 9067 30 from from IN 40436 9067 31 Pleasure Pleasure NNP 40436 9067 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9067 33 Legg Legg NNP 40436 9067 34 . . . 40436 9068 1 ii ii LS 40436 9068 2 . . . 40436 9069 1 pp pp NNP 40436 9069 2 . . . 40436 9070 1 662 662 CD 40436 9070 2 - - SYM 40436 9070 3 663 663 CD 40436 9070 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9070 5 . . . 40436 9071 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9071 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9071 3 : : : 40436 9071 4 ei ei NN 40436 9071 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9071 6 d d NN 40436 9071 7 ' ' '' 40436 9071 8 au)= au)= : 40436 9071 9 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9071 10 dikaio dikaio NN 40436 9071 11 / / SYM 40436 9071 12 taton taton NNP 40436 9071 13 eu)daimone eu)daimone NNP 40436 9071 14 / / SYM 40436 9071 15 staton staton NNP 40436 9071 16 a)pophai a)pophai NNP 40436 9071 17 / / SYM 40436 9071 18 noito noito NNP 40436 9071 19 bi bi NNP 40436 9071 20 / / SYM 40436 9071 21 on on IN 40436 9071 22 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 9071 23 , , , 40436 9071 24 zêtoi= zêtoi= NNP 40436 9071 25 pou pou NNP 40436 9071 26 pa pa NNP 40436 9071 27 = = NNP 40436 9071 28 s s NNP 40436 9071 29 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 9071 30 o o NNP 40436 9071 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9071 32 a)kou a)kou NNP 40436 9071 33 / / SYM 40436 9071 34 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9071 35 , , , 40436 9071 36 oi)=mai oi)=mai NNP 40436 9071 37 , , , 40436 9071 38 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 9071 39 pot pot NN 40436 9071 40 ' ' `` 40436 9071 41 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9071 42 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 9071 43 to\ to\ NN 40436 9071 44 tê tê NNP 40436 9071 45 = = SYM 40436 9071 46 s s NNP 40436 9071 47 ê(donê ê(donê NNP 40436 9071 48 = = NNP 40436 9071 49 s s NNP 40436 9071 50 krei krei NNP 40436 9071 51 = = SYM 40436 9071 52 tton tton NNP 40436 9071 53 a)gatho a)gatho NNP 40436 9071 54 / / SYM 40436 9071 55 n n NNP 40436 9071 56 te te NNP 40436 9071 57 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9071 58 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 9071 59 o o NNP 40436 9071 60 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9071 61 no no UH 40436 9071 62 / / SYM 40436 9071 63 mos mos NN 40436 9071 64 e)no\n e)no\n NNP 40436 9071 65 e)painei= e)painei= NNP 40436 9071 66 ? ? . 40436 9072 1 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 9072 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9072 3 dê\ dê\ NN 40436 9072 4 dikai dikai NNP 40436 9072 5 / / SYM 40436 9072 6 ô| ô| NNP 40436 9072 7 chôrizo chôrizo NNP 40436 9072 8 / / SYM 40436 9072 9 menon menon NNP 40436 9072 10 ê(donê ê(donê NNP 40436 9072 11 = = SYM 40436 9072 12 s s NNP 40436 9072 13 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 9072 14 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9072 15 ge ge NNP 40436 9072 16 / / SYM 40436 9072 17 noito noito NNP 40436 9072 18 ? ? . 40436 9072 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9073 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9073 2 goes go VBZ 40436 9073 3 on on RP 40436 9073 4 to to TO 40436 9073 5 argue argue VB 40436 9073 6 as as IN 40436 9073 7 follows follow VBZ 40436 9073 8 : : : 40436 9073 9 Even even RB 40436 9073 10 though though IN 40436 9073 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9073 12 were be VBD 40436 9073 13 not not RB 40436 9073 14 true true JJ 40436 9073 15 , , , 40436 9073 16 as as IN 40436 9073 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9073 18 affirm affirm VBP 40436 9073 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9073 20 to to TO 40436 9073 21 be be VB 40436 9073 22 , , , 40436 9073 23 that that IN 40436 9073 24 the the DT 40436 9073 25 life life NN 40436 9073 26 of of IN 40436 9073 27 justice justice NN 40436 9073 28 is be VBZ 40436 9073 29 a a DT 40436 9073 30 life life NN 40436 9073 31 of of IN 40436 9073 32 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9073 33 , , , 40436 9073 34 and and CC 40436 9073 35 the the DT 40436 9073 36 life life NN 40436 9073 37 of of IN 40436 9073 38 injustice injustice NN 40436 9073 39 a a DT 40436 9073 40 life life NN 40436 9073 41 of of IN 40436 9073 42 pain pain NN 40436 9073 43 -- -- : 40436 9073 44 still still RB 40436 9073 45 the the DT 40436 9073 46 law law NN 40436 9073 47 - - HYPH 40436 9073 48 giver giver NN 40436 9073 49 must must MD 40436 9073 50 proclaim proclaim VB 40436 9073 51 this this DT 40436 9073 52 proposition proposition NN 40436 9073 53 as as IN 40436 9073 54 a a DT 40436 9073 55 useful useful JJ 40436 9073 56 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 9073 57 , , , 40436 9073 58 and and CC 40436 9073 59 compel compel VB 40436 9073 60 every every DT 40436 9073 61 one one NN 40436 9073 62 to to IN 40436 9073 63 chime chime NN 40436 9073 64 in in RP 40436 9073 65 with with IN 40436 9073 66 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9073 67 . . . 40436 9074 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 40436 9074 2 the the DT 40436 9074 3 youth youth NN 40436 9074 4 will will MD 40436 9074 5 have have VB 40436 9074 6 no no DT 40436 9074 7 motive motive NN 40436 9074 8 to to IN 40436 9074 9 just just RB 40436 9074 10 conduct conduct VB 40436 9074 11 . . . 40436 9075 1 For for IN 40436 9075 2 no no DT 40436 9075 3 one one NN 40436 9075 4 will will MD 40436 9075 5 willingly willingly RB 40436 9075 6 consent consent VB 40436 9075 7 to to TO 40436 9075 8 obey obey VB 40436 9075 9 any any DT 40436 9075 10 recommendation recommendation NN 40436 9075 11 from from IN 40436 9075 12 which which WDT 40436 9075 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9075 14 does do VBZ 40436 9075 15 not not RB 40436 9075 16 expect expect VB 40436 9075 17 more more JJR 40436 9075 18 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9075 19 than than IN 40436 9075 20 pain pain NN 40436 9075 21 ; ; : 40436 9075 22 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9075 23 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9075 24 : : : 40436 9075 25 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 9075 26 ga\r ga\r VB 40436 9075 27 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9075 28 e(/kôn e(/kôn NNP 40436 9075 29 e)/theloi e)/theloi FW 40436 9075 30 pei pei NN 40436 9075 31 / / SYM 40436 9075 32 thesthai thesthai NN 40436 9075 33 pra pra NNP 40436 9075 34 / / SYM 40436 9075 35 ttein ttein NNP 40436 9075 36 tou tou NNP 40436 9075 37 = = SYM 40436 9075 38 to to IN 40436 9075 39 o(/ o(/ NNS 40436 9075 40 , , , 40436 9075 41 tô| tô| NNP 40436 9075 42 mê\ mê\ JJ 40436 9075 43 to\ to\ NN 40436 9075 44 chai chai NN 40436 9075 45 / / SYM 40436 9075 46 rein rein NNP 40436 9075 47 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9075 48 lupei lupei NNP 40436 9075 49 = = SYM 40436 9075 50 sthai sthai NNP 40436 9075 51 ple ple NNP 40436 9075 52 / / SYM 40436 9075 53 on on IN 40436 9075 54 e(/petai e(/petai NN 40436 9075 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9075 56 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9075 57 663 663 CD 40436 9075 58 B b NN 40436 9075 59 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9075 60 . . . 40436 9075 61 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9076 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9076 2 Side side NN 40436 9076 3 - - HYPH 40436 9076 4 note note NN 40436 9076 5 : : : 40436 9076 6 Distinct distinct JJ 40436 9076 7 statement statement NN 40436 9076 8 in in IN 40436 9076 9 the the DT 40436 9076 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9076 11 . . . 40436 9077 1 What what WP 40436 9077 2 are be VBP 40436 9077 3 good good JJ 40436 9077 4 and and CC 40436 9077 5 evil evil JJ 40436 9077 6 , , , 40436 9077 7 and and CC 40436 9077 8 upon upon IN 40436 9077 9 what what WP 40436 9077 10 principles principle NNS 40436 9077 11 the the DT 40436 9077 12 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9077 13 adviser adviser NN 40436 9077 14 is be VBZ 40436 9077 15 to to TO 40436 9077 16 proceed proceed VB 40436 9077 17 in in IN 40436 9077 18 discriminating discriminate VBG 40436 9077 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9077 20 . . . 40436 9078 1 No no DT 40436 9078 2 such such JJ 40436 9078 3 distinct distinct JJ 40436 9078 4 statement statement NN 40436 9078 5 in in IN 40436 9078 6 the the DT 40436 9078 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9078 8 . . . 40436 9078 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9079 1 In in IN 40436 9079 2 the the DT 40436 9079 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9079 4 , , , 40436 9079 5 too too RB 40436 9079 6 , , , 40436 9079 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9079 8 declares declare VBZ 40436 9079 9 that that IN 40436 9079 10 some some DT 40436 9079 11 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9079 12 are be VBP 40436 9079 13 good good JJ 40436 9079 14 , , , 40436 9079 15 others other NNS 40436 9079 16 bad bad JJ 40436 9079 17 -- -- : 40436 9079 18 some some DT 40436 9079 19 pains pain NNS 40436 9079 20 bad bad JJ 40436 9079 21 , , , 40436 9079 22 others other NNS 40436 9079 23 good good JJ 40436 9079 24 . . . 40436 9080 1 But but CC 40436 9080 2 here here RB 40436 9080 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9080 4 stops stop VBZ 40436 9080 5 . . . 40436 9081 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9081 2 does do VBZ 40436 9081 3 not not RB 40436 9081 4 fulfil fulfil VB 40436 9081 5 the the DT 40436 9081 6 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 9081 7 demand demand NN 40436 9081 8 urged urge VBN 40436 9081 9 by by IN 40436 9081 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9081 11 in in IN 40436 9081 12 the the DT 40436 9081 13 Protagoras--"If protagoras--"if NN 40436 9081 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9081 15 make make VBP 40436 9081 16 such such PDT 40436 9081 17 a a DT 40436 9081 18 distinction distinction NN 40436 9081 19 , , , 40436 9081 20 explain explain VB 40436 9081 21 the the DT 40436 9081 22 ground ground NN 40436 9081 23 on on IN 40436 9081 24 which which WDT 40436 9081 25 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9081 26 make make VBP 40436 9081 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9081 28 , , , 40436 9081 29 and and CC 40436 9081 30 the the DT 40436 9081 31 end end NN 40436 9081 32 to to TO 40436 9081 33 which which WDT 40436 9081 34 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9081 35 look look VBP 40436 9081 36 " " '' 40436 9081 37 . . . 40436 9082 1 The the DT 40436 9082 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 9082 3 in in IN 40436 9082 4 the the DT 40436 9082 5 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9082 6 stands stand VBZ 40436 9082 7 without without IN 40436 9082 8 any any DT 40436 9082 9 assigned assigned JJ 40436 9082 10 ground ground NN 40436 9082 11 or or CC 40436 9082 12 end end NN 40436 9082 13 to to TO 40436 9082 14 rest rest VB 40436 9082 15 upon upon IN 40436 9082 16 . . . 40436 9083 1 And and CC 40436 9083 2 this this DT 40436 9083 3 want want NN 40436 9083 4 is be VBZ 40436 9083 5 the the DT 40436 9083 6 more more RBR 40436 9083 7 sensibly sensibly RB 40436 9083 8 felt feel VBN 40436 9083 9 , , , 40436 9083 10 when when WRB 40436 9083 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9083 12 read read VBP 40436 9083 13 in in IN 40436 9083 14 the the DT 40436 9083 15 same same JJ 40436 9083 16 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9083 17 , , , 40436 9083 18 that--"It that--"It NNP 40436 9083 19 is be VBZ 40436 9083 20 not not RB 40436 9083 21 every every DT 40436 9083 22 man man NN 40436 9083 23 who who WP 40436 9083 24 can can MD 40436 9083 25 distinguish distinguish VB 40436 9083 26 the the DT 40436 9083 27 good good JJ 40436 9083 28 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9083 29 from from IN 40436 9083 30 the the DT 40436 9083 31 bad bad JJ 40436 9083 32 : : : 40436 9083 33 a a DT 40436 9083 34 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9083 35 man man NN 40436 9083 36 , , , 40436 9083 37 proceeding proceed VBG 40436 9083 38 on on IN 40436 9083 39 principle principle NN 40436 9083 40 , , , 40436 9083 41 is be VBZ 40436 9083 42 needed need VBN 40436 9083 43 for for IN 40436 9083 44 the the DT 40436 9083 45 purpose purpose NN 40436 9083 46 " " '' 40436 9083 47 . . . 40436 9084 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9084 2 77 77 CD 40436 9084 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9084 4 But but CC 40436 9084 5 upon upon IN 40436 9084 6 what what WDT 40436 9084 7 criterion criterion NN 40436 9084 8 is be VBZ 40436 9084 9 the the DT 40436 9084 10 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9084 11 man man NN 40436 9084 12 to to TO 40436 9084 13 proceed proceed VB 40436 9084 14 ? ? . 40436 9085 1 Of of IN 40436 9085 2 what what WP 40436 9085 3 properties property NNS 40436 9085 4 is be VBZ 40436 9085 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9085 6 to to TO 40436 9085 7 take take VB 40436 9085 8 account account NN 40436 9085 9 , , , 40436 9085 10 in in IN 40436 9085 11 pronouncing pronounce VBG 40436 9085 12 one one CD 40436 9085 13 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9085 14 to to TO 40436 9085 15 be be VB 40436 9085 16 bad bad JJ 40436 9085 17 , , , 40436 9085 18 another another DT 40436 9085 19 good good JJ 40436 9085 20 -- -- : 40436 9085 21 or or CC 40436 9085 22 one one CD 40436 9085 23 pain pain NN 40436 9085 24 to to TO 40436 9085 25 be be VB 40436 9085 26 bad bad JJ 40436 9085 27 and and CC 40436 9085 28 another another DT 40436 9085 29 good good JJ 40436 9085 30 -- -- : 40436 9085 31 the the DT 40436 9085 32 estimate estimate NN 40436 9085 33 of of IN 40436 9085 34 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9085 35 , , , 40436 9085 36 measured measure VBN 40436 9085 37 in in IN 40436 9085 38 future future JJ 40436 9085 39 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9085 40 and and CC 40436 9085 41 pains pain NNS 40436 9085 42 , , , 40436 9085 43 being be VBG 40436 9085 44 by by IN 40436 9085 45 the the DT 40436 9085 46 supposition supposition NN 40436 9085 47 excluded exclude VBN 40436 9085 48 ? ? . 40436 9086 1 No no DT 40436 9086 2 information information NN 40436 9086 3 is be VBZ 40436 9086 4 given give VBN 40436 9086 5 . . . 40436 9087 1 The the DT 40436 9087 2 problem problem NN 40436 9087 3 set set VBD 40436 9087 4 to to IN 40436 9087 5 the the DT 40436 9087 6 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9087 7 man man NN 40436 9087 8 is be VBZ 40436 9087 9 one one CD 40436 9087 10 of of IN 40436 9087 11 which which WDT 40436 9087 12 all all PDT 40436 9087 13 the the DT 40436 9087 14 quantities quantity NNS 40436 9087 15 are be VBP 40436 9087 16 unknown unknown JJ 40436 9087 17 . . . 40436 9088 1 Now now RB 40436 9088 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9088 3 in in IN 40436 9088 4 the the DT 40436 9088 5 Protagoras[78 protagoras[78 CD 40436 9088 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9088 7 also also RB 40436 9088 8 lays lay VBZ 40436 9088 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9088 10 down down RP 40436 9088 11 , , , 40436 9088 12 that that IN 40436 9088 13 a a DT 40436 9088 14 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9088 15 or or CC 40436 9088 16 rational rational JJ 40436 9088 17 calculation calculation NN 40436 9088 18 must must MD 40436 9088 19 be be VB 40436 9088 20 had have VBN 40436 9088 21 , , , 40436 9088 22 and and CC 40436 9088 23 a a DT 40436 9088 24 mind mind NN 40436 9088 25 competent competent JJ 40436 9088 26 to to IN 40436 9088 27 such such JJ 40436 9088 28 calculation calculation NN 40436 9088 29 must must MD 40436 9088 30 be be VB 40436 9088 31 postulated postulate VBN 40436 9088 32 , , , 40436 9088 33 to to TO 40436 9088 34 decide decide VB 40436 9088 35 which which WDT 40436 9088 36 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9088 37 are be VBP 40436 9088 38 bad bad JJ 40436 9088 39 or or CC 40436 9088 40 fit fit JJ 40436 9088 41 to to TO 40436 9088 42 be be VB 40436 9088 43 rejected reject VBN 40436 9088 44 -- -- : 40436 9088 45 which which WDT 40436 9088 46 pains pain NNS 40436 9088 47 are be VBP 40436 9088 48 good good JJ 40436 9088 49 , , , 40436 9088 50 or or CC 40436 9088 51 proper proper JJ 40436 9088 52 to to TO 40436 9088 53 be be VB 40436 9088 54 endured endure VBN 40436 9088 55 . . . 40436 9089 1 But but CC 40436 9089 2 then then RB 40436 9089 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9089 4 clearly clearly RB 40436 9089 5 specifies specify VBZ 40436 9089 6 the the DT 40436 9089 7 elements element NNS 40436 9089 8 which which WDT 40436 9089 9 alone alone RB 40436 9089 10 are be VBP 40436 9089 11 to to TO 40436 9089 12 be be VB 40436 9089 13 taken take VBN 40436 9089 14 into into IN 40436 9089 15 the the DT 40436 9089 16 calculation--_viz calculation--_viz NNP 40436 9089 17 . . . 40436 9089 18 _ _ NNP 40436 9089 19 , , , 40436 9089 20 the the DT 40436 9089 21 future future JJ 40436 9089 22 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9089 23 and and CC 40436 9089 24 pains pain NNS 40436 9089 25 accompanying accompany VBG 40436 9089 26 or or CC 40436 9089 27 dependent dependent JJ 40436 9089 28 upon upon IN 40436 9089 29 each each DT 40436 9089 30 with with IN 40436 9089 31 the the DT 40436 9089 32 estimate estimate NN 40436 9089 33 of of IN 40436 9089 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9089 35 comparative comparative JJ 40436 9089 36 magnitude magnitude NN 40436 9089 37 and and CC 40436 9089 38 durability durability NN 40436 9089 39 . . . 40436 9090 1 The the DT 40436 9090 2 theory theory NN 40436 9090 3 of of IN 40436 9090 4 this this DT 40436 9090 5 calculation calculation NN 40436 9090 6 is be VBZ 40436 9090 7 clear clear JJ 40436 9090 8 and and CC 40436 9090 9 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 9090 10 : : : 40436 9090 11 though though IN 40436 9090 12 in in IN 40436 9090 13 many many JJ 40436 9090 14 particular particular JJ 40436 9090 15 cases case NNS 40436 9090 16 , , , 40436 9090 17 the the DT 40436 9090 18 data datum NNS 40436 9090 19 necessary necessary JJ 40436 9090 20 for for IN 40436 9090 21 making make VBG 40436 9090 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9090 23 , , , 40436 9090 24 and and CC 40436 9090 25 the the DT 40436 9090 26 means mean NNS 40436 9090 27 of of IN 40436 9090 28 comparing compare VBG 40436 9090 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9090 30 , , , 40436 9090 31 may may MD 40436 9090 32 be be VB 40436 9090 33 very very RB 40436 9090 34 imperfectly imperfectly RB 40436 9090 35 accessible accessible JJ 40436 9090 36 . . . 40436 9091 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9091 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9091 3 77 77 CD 40436 9091 4 : : : 40436 9091 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9091 6 , , , 40436 9091 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9091 8 , , , 40436 9091 9 p. p. NN 40436 9091 10 500 500 CD 40436 9091 11 A. a. NN 40436 9092 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9092 2 Greek greek JJ 40436 9092 3 : : : 40436 9092 4 A)=r A)=r NNP 40436 9092 5 ' ' POS 40436 9092 6 ou)=n ou)=n NN 40436 9092 7 panto\s panto\s -LRB- 40436 9092 8 a)ndro a)ndro NNP 40436 9092 9 / / SYM 40436 9092 10 s s NN 40436 9092 11 * * NFP 40436 9092 12 * * NFP 40436 9092 13 e)stin e)stin NFP 40436 9092 14 e)kle e)kle NNP 40436 9092 15 / / SYM 40436 9092 16 xasthai xasthai NNP 40436 9092 17 poi poi NNP 40436 9092 18 = = SYM 40436 9092 19 a a FW 40436 9092 20 a)/gatha\ a)/gatha\ NNP 40436 9092 21 tô tô NNP 40436 9092 22 = = SYM 40436 9092 23 n n CC 40436 9092 24 ê(de ê(de NNP 40436 9092 25 / / SYM 40436 9092 26 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9092 27 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 9092 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9092 29 o(poi o(poi NNP 40436 9092 30 = = SYM 40436 9092 31 a a DT 40436 9092 32 kaka/ kaka/ NN 40436 9092 33 ? ? . 40436 9093 1 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 9093 2 technikou= technikou= JJ 40436 9093 3 dei= dei= NNP 40436 9093 4 ei)s ei)s , 40436 9093 5 e(/kaston e(/kaston NN 40436 9093 6 ? ? . 40436 9094 1 Technikou=. technikou=. LS 40436 9094 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9094 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9095 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9095 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9095 3 78 78 CD 40436 9095 4 : : : 40436 9095 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9095 6 , , , 40436 9095 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9095 8 , , , 40436 9095 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9095 10 . . . 40436 9096 1 357 357 CD 40436 9096 2 B B NNP 40436 9096 3 , , , 40436 9096 4 356 356 CD 40436 9096 5 E. E. NNP 40436 9096 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9096 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9096 8 Side side NN 40436 9096 9 - - HYPH 40436 9096 10 note note NN 40436 9096 11 : : : 40436 9096 12 Modern modern JJ 40436 9096 13 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9096 14 theories theory NNS 40436 9096 15 . . . 40436 9097 1 Intuition intuition NN 40436 9097 2 . . . 40436 9098 1 Moral moral JJ 40436 9098 2 sense sense NN 40436 9098 3 -- -- : 40436 9098 4 not not RB 40436 9098 5 recognised recognise VBN 40436 9098 6 by by IN 40436 9098 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9098 8 in in IN 40436 9098 9 either either DT 40436 9098 10 of of IN 40436 9098 11 the the DT 40436 9098 12 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9098 13 . . . 40436 9098 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9099 1 According accord VBG 40436 9099 2 to to IN 40436 9099 3 various various JJ 40436 9099 4 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9099 5 theories theory NNS 40436 9099 6 , , , 40436 9099 7 which which WDT 40436 9099 8 have have VBP 40436 9099 9 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 9099 10 obtained obtain VBN 40436 9099 11 currency currency NN 40436 9099 12 in in IN 40436 9099 13 modern modern JJ 40436 9099 14 times time NNS 40436 9099 15 , , , 40436 9099 16 the the DT 40436 9099 17 distinction distinction NN 40436 9099 18 -- -- : 40436 9099 19 between between IN 40436 9099 20 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9099 21 good good JJ 40436 9099 22 or or CC 40436 9099 23 fit fit JJ 40436 9099 24 to to TO 40436 9099 25 be be VB 40436 9099 26 enjoyed enjoy VBN 40436 9099 27 , , , 40436 9099 28 and and CC 40436 9099 29 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9099 30 bad bad JJ 40436 9099 31 or or CC 40436 9099 32 unfit unfit JJ 40436 9099 33 to to TO 40436 9099 34 be be VB 40436 9099 35 enjoyed enjoy VBN 40436 9099 36 -- -- : 40436 9099 37 is be VBZ 40436 9099 38 determined determine VBN 40436 9099 39 for for IN 40436 9099 40 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9099 41 by by IN 40436 9099 42 a a DT 40436 9099 43 moral moral JJ 40436 9099 44 sense sense NN 40436 9099 45 or or CC 40436 9099 46 intuition intuition NN 40436 9099 47 : : : 40436 9099 48 by by IN 40436 9099 49 a a DT 40436 9099 50 simple simple JJ 40436 9099 51 , , , 40436 9099 52 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 9099 53 , , , 40436 9099 54 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 9099 55 of of IN 40436 9099 56 right right NN 40436 9099 57 and and CC 40436 9099 58 wrong wrong NN 40436 9099 59 , , , 40436 9099 60 or or CC 40436 9099 61 a a DT 40436 9099 62 conscience conscience NN 40436 9099 63 , , , 40436 9099 64 which which WDT 40436 9099 65 springs spring VBZ 40436 9099 66 up up RP 40436 9099 67 within within IN 40436 9099 68 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9099 69 ready ready JJ 40436 9099 70 - - HYPH 40436 9099 71 made make VBN 40436 9099 72 , , , 40436 9099 73 and and CC 40436 9099 74 decides decide VBZ 40436 9099 75 on on IN 40436 9099 76 such such JJ 40436 9099 77 matters matter NNS 40436 9099 78 without without IN 40436 9099 79 appeal appeal NN 40436 9099 80 ; ; : 40436 9099 81 so so CC 40436 9099 82 that that IN 40436 9099 83 a a DT 40436 9099 84 man man NN 40436 9099 85 has have VBZ 40436 9099 86 only only RB 40436 9099 87 to to TO 40436 9099 88 look look VB 40436 9099 89 into into IN 40436 9099 90 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9099 91 own own JJ 40436 9099 92 heart heart NN 40436 9099 93 for for IN 40436 9099 94 a a DT 40436 9099 95 solution solution NN 40436 9099 96 . . . 40436 9100 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9100 2 need need VBP 40436 9100 3 not not RB 40436 9100 4 take take VB 40436 9100 5 account account NN 40436 9100 6 of of IN 40436 9100 7 this this DT 40436 9100 8 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 9100 9 , , , 40436 9100 10 in in IN 40436 9100 11 reviewing review VBG 40436 9100 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9100 13 's 's POS 40436 9100 14 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9100 15 : : : 40436 9100 16 for for IN 40436 9100 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9100 18 evidently evidently RB 40436 9100 19 does do VBZ 40436 9100 20 not not RB 40436 9100 21 proceed proceed VB 40436 9100 22 upon upon IN 40436 9100 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9100 24 . . . 40436 9101 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9101 2 expressly expressly RB 40436 9101 3 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 9101 4 , , , 40436 9101 5 in in IN 40436 9101 6 the the DT 40436 9101 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9101 8 as as RB 40436 9101 9 well well RB 40436 9101 10 as as IN 40436 9101 11 in in IN 40436 9101 12 the the DT 40436 9101 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9101 14 , , , 40436 9101 15 that that IN 40436 9101 16 the the DT 40436 9101 17 question question NN 40436 9101 18 is be VBZ 40436 9101 19 one one CD 40436 9101 20 requiring require VBG 40436 9101 21 science science NN 40436 9101 22 or or CC 40436 9101 23 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9101 24 to to TO 40436 9101 25 determine determine VB 40436 9101 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9101 27 , , , 40436 9101 28 and and CC 40436 9101 29 upon upon IN 40436 9101 30 which which WDT 40436 9101 31 none none NN 40436 9101 32 but but CC 40436 9101 33 the the DT 40436 9101 34 man man NN 40436 9101 35 of of IN 40436 9101 36 science science NNP 40436 9101 37 or or CC 40436 9101 38 _ _ NNP 40436 9101 39 expert expert NN 40436 9101 40 _ _ NN 40436 9101 41 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9101 42 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9101 43 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9101 44 : : : 40436 9101 45 techniko\s techniko\s ADD 40436 9101 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9101 47 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9101 48 is be VBZ 40436 9101 49 a a DT 40436 9101 50 competent competent JJ 40436 9101 51 judge judge NN 40436 9101 52 . . . 40436 9102 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9102 2 Side side NN 40436 9102 3 - - HYPH 40436 9102 4 note note NN 40436 9102 5 : : : 40436 9102 6 In in IN 40436 9102 7 both both DT 40436 9102 8 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9102 9 the the DT 40436 9102 10 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9102 11 of of IN 40436 9102 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9102 13 is be VBZ 40436 9102 14 self self NN 40436 9102 15 - - HYPH 40436 9102 16 regarding regard VBG 40436 9102 17 as as IN 40436 9102 18 respects respect VBZ 40436 9102 19 the the DT 40436 9102 20 agent agent NN 40436 9102 21 : : : 40436 9102 22 not not RB 40436 9102 23 considering consider VBG 40436 9102 24 the the DT 40436 9102 25 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9102 26 and and CC 40436 9102 27 pains pain NNS 40436 9102 28 of of IN 40436 9102 29 other other JJ 40436 9102 30 persons person NNS 40436 9102 31 , , , 40436 9102 32 so so RB 40436 9102 33 far far RB 40436 9102 34 as as IN 40436 9102 35 affected affect VBN 40436 9102 36 by by IN 40436 9102 37 the the DT 40436 9102 38 agent agent NN 40436 9102 39 . . . 40436 9102 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9103 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 9103 2 , , , 40436 9103 3 there there EX 40436 9103 4 is be VBZ 40436 9103 5 another another DT 40436 9103 6 point point NN 40436 9103 7 common common JJ 40436 9103 8 to to IN 40436 9103 9 both both DT 40436 9103 10 the the DT 40436 9103 11 two two CD 40436 9103 12 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9103 13 , , , 40436 9103 14 deserving deserving NN 40436 9103 15 of of IN 40436 9103 16 notice notice NN 40436 9103 17 . . . 40436 9104 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9104 2 have have VBP 40436 9104 3 already already RB 40436 9104 4 remarked remark VBN 40436 9104 5 when when WRB 40436 9104 6 reviewing review VBG 40436 9104 7 the the DT 40436 9104 8 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9104 9 of of IN 40436 9104 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9104 11 in in IN 40436 9104 12 the the DT 40436 9104 13 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9104 14 , , , 40436 9104 15 that that IN 40436 9104 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9104 17 appears appear VBZ 40436 9104 18 to to IN 40436 9104 19 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9104 20 seriously seriously RB 40436 9104 21 defective defective JJ 40436 9104 22 , , , 40436 9104 23 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 40436 9104 24 as as IN 40436 9104 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9104 26 takes take VBZ 40436 9104 27 into into IN 40436 9104 28 account account NN 40436 9104 29 the the DT 40436 9104 30 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9104 31 and and CC 40436 9104 32 pains pain NNS 40436 9104 33 of of IN 40436 9104 34 the the DT 40436 9104 35 agent agent NN 40436 9104 36 only only RB 40436 9104 37 , , , 40436 9104 38 and and CC 40436 9104 39 omits omit VBZ 40436 9104 40 the the DT 40436 9104 41 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9104 42 and and CC 40436 9104 43 pains pain NNS 40436 9104 44 of of IN 40436 9104 45 other other JJ 40436 9104 46 persons person NNS 40436 9104 47 affected affect VBN 40436 9104 48 by by IN 40436 9104 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9104 50 conduct conduct NN 40436 9104 51 . . . 40436 9105 1 But but CC 40436 9105 2 this this DT 40436 9105 3 is be VBZ 40436 9105 4 not not RB 40436 9105 5 less less RBR 40436 9105 6 true true JJ 40436 9105 7 respecting respect VBG 40436 9105 8 the the DT 40436 9105 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9105 10 of of IN 40436 9105 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9105 12 in in IN 40436 9105 13 the the DT 40436 9105 14 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9105 15 : : : 40436 9105 16 for for IN 40436 9105 17 whatever whatever WDT 40436 9105 18 criterion criterion NN 40436 9105 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9105 20 may may MD 40436 9105 21 there there EX 40436 9105 22 have have VB 40436 9105 23 in in IN 40436 9105 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9105 25 mind mind NN 40436 9105 26 to to TO 40436 9105 27 determine determine VB 40436 9105 28 which which WDT 40436 9105 29 among among IN 40436 9105 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9105 31 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9105 32 are be VBP 40436 9105 33 bad bad JJ 40436 9105 34 , , , 40436 9105 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9105 36 is be VBZ 40436 9105 37 certainly certainly RB 40436 9105 38 not not RB 40436 9105 39 this this DT 40436 9105 40 -- -- : 40436 9105 41 that that IN 40436 9105 42 the the DT 40436 9105 43 agent agent NN 40436 9105 44 in in IN 40436 9105 45 procuring procure VBG 40436 9105 46 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9105 47 is be VBZ 40436 9105 48 obliged oblige VBN 40436 9105 49 to to TO 40436 9105 50 hurt hurt VB 40436 9105 51 others other NNS 40436 9105 52 . . . 40436 9106 1 For for IN 40436 9106 2 the the DT 40436 9106 3 example example NN 40436 9106 4 which which WDT 40436 9106 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9106 6 cites cite VBZ 40436 9106 7 as as RB 40436 9106 8 specially specially RB 40436 9106 9 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 9106 10 the the DT 40436 9106 11 class class NN 40436 9106 12 of of IN 40436 9106 13 bad bad JJ 40436 9106 14 pleasures--_viz pleasures--_viz NN 40436 9106 15 . . . 40436 9106 16 _ _ NNP 40436 9106 17 , , , 40436 9106 18 the the DT 40436 9106 19 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9106 20 of of IN 40436 9106 21 scratching scratch VBG 40436 9106 22 an an DT 40436 9106 23 itching itch VBG 40436 9106 24 part part NN 40436 9106 25 of of IN 40436 9106 26 the the DT 40436 9106 27 body[79]--is body[79]--is NNP 40436 9106 28 one one CD 40436 9106 29 in in IN 40436 9106 30 which which WDT 40436 9106 31 no no DT 40436 9106 32 others other NNS 40436 9106 33 besides besides IN 40436 9106 34 the the DT 40436 9106 35 agent agent NN 40436 9106 36 are be VBP 40436 9106 37 concerned concern VBN 40436 9106 38 . . . 40436 9107 1 As as IN 40436 9107 2 in in IN 40436 9107 3 the the DT 40436 9107 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9107 5 , , , 40436 9107 6 so so IN 40436 9107 7 in in IN 40436 9107 8 the the DT 40436 9107 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9107 10 -- -- : 40436 9107 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9107 12 in in IN 40436 9107 13 laying lay VBG 40436 9107 14 down down RP 40436 9107 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9107 16 rule rule NN 40436 9107 17 of of IN 40436 9107 18 life life NN 40436 9107 19 , , , 40436 9107 20 admits admit VBZ 40436 9107 21 into into IN 40436 9107 22 the the DT 40436 9107 23 theory theory NN 40436 9107 24 only only RB 40436 9107 25 what what WP 40436 9107 26 concerns concern VBZ 40436 9107 27 the the DT 40436 9107 28 agent agent NN 40436 9107 29 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9107 30 , , , 40436 9107 31 and and CC 40436 9107 32 makes make VBZ 40436 9107 33 no no DT 40436 9107 34 direct direct JJ 40436 9107 35 reference reference NN 40436 9107 36 to to IN 40436 9107 37 the the DT 40436 9107 38 happiness happiness NN 40436 9107 39 of of IN 40436 9107 40 others other NNS 40436 9107 41 as as IN 40436 9107 42 affected affect VBN 40436 9107 43 by by IN 40436 9107 44 the the DT 40436 9107 45 agent agent NN 40436 9107 46 's 's POS 40436 9107 47 behaviour behaviour NN 40436 9107 48 . . . 40436 9108 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9108 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9108 3 79 79 CD 40436 9108 4 : : : 40436 9108 5 The the DT 40436 9108 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9108 7 of of IN 40436 9108 8 the the DT 40436 9108 9 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9108 10 would would MD 40436 9108 11 have have VB 40436 9108 12 reckoned reckon VBN 40436 9108 13 this this DT 40436 9108 14 among among IN 40436 9108 15 the the DT 40436 9108 16 bad bad JJ 40436 9108 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9108 18 , , , 40436 9108 19 because because IN 40436 9108 20 the the DT 40436 9108 21 discomfort discomfort NN 40436 9108 22 and and CC 40436 9108 23 distress distress NN 40436 9108 24 of of IN 40436 9108 25 body body NN 40436 9108 26 out out IN 40436 9108 27 of of IN 40436 9108 28 which which WDT 40436 9108 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9108 30 arises arise VBZ 40436 9108 31 more more JJR 40436 9108 32 than than IN 40436 9108 33 countervail countervail VB 40436 9108 34 the the DT 40436 9108 35 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9108 36 . . . 40436 9108 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9109 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9109 2 Side side NN 40436 9109 3 - - HYPH 40436 9109 4 note note NN 40436 9109 5 : : : 40436 9109 6 Points point NNS 40436 9109 7 wherein wherein WRB 40436 9109 8 the the DT 40436 9109 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9109 10 of of IN 40436 9109 11 the the DT 40436 9109 12 two two CD 40436 9109 13 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9109 14 is be VBZ 40436 9109 15 in in IN 40436 9109 16 substance substance NN 40436 9109 17 the the DT 40436 9109 18 same same JJ 40436 9109 19 , , , 40436 9109 20 but but CC 40436 9109 21 differing differ VBG 40436 9109 22 in in IN 40436 9109 23 classification classification NN 40436 9109 24 . . . 40436 9109 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9110 1 There there EX 40436 9110 2 are be VBP 40436 9110 3 however however RB 40436 9110 4 various various JJ 40436 9110 5 points point NNS 40436 9110 6 of of IN 40436 9110 7 analogy analogy NN 40436 9110 8 between between IN 40436 9110 9 the the DT 40436 9110 10 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9110 11 and and CC 40436 9110 12 the the DT 40436 9110 13 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9110 14 , , , 40436 9110 15 which which WDT 40436 9110 16 will will MD 40436 9110 17 enable enable VB 40436 9110 18 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9110 19 , , , 40436 9110 20 after after IN 40436 9110 21 tracing trace VBG 40436 9110 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9110 23 out out RP 40436 9110 24 , , , 40436 9110 25 to to TO 40436 9110 26 measure measure VB 40436 9110 27 the the DT 40436 9110 28 amount amount NN 40436 9110 29 of of IN 40436 9110 30 substantial substantial JJ 40436 9110 31 difference difference NN 40436 9110 32 between between IN 40436 9110 33 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9110 34 ; ; : 40436 9110 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9110 36 speak speak VBP 40436 9110 37 of of IN 40436 9110 38 the the DT 40436 9110 39 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 9110 40 of of IN 40436 9110 41 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9110 42 in in IN 40436 9110 43 each each DT 40436 9110 44 . . . 40436 9111 1 Thus thus RB 40436 9111 2 , , , 40436 9111 3 in in IN 40436 9111 4 the the DT 40436 9111 5 Protagoras,[80 protagoras,[80 NN 40436 9111 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9111 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9111 8 ranks rank VBZ 40436 9111 9 health health NN 40436 9111 10 , , , 40436 9111 11 strength strength NN 40436 9111 12 , , , 40436 9111 13 preservation preservation NN 40436 9111 14 of of IN 40436 9111 15 the the DT 40436 9111 16 community community NN 40436 9111 17 , , , 40436 9111 18 wealth wealth NN 40436 9111 19 , , , 40436 9111 20 command command NN 40436 9111 21 , , , 40436 9111 22 & & CC 40436 9111 23 c. c. NNP 40436 9111 24 , , , 40436 9111 25 under under IN 40436 9111 26 the the DT 40436 9111 27 general general JJ 40436 9111 28 head head NN 40436 9111 29 of of IN 40436 9111 30 Good good JJ 40436 9111 31 things thing NNS 40436 9111 32 , , , 40436 9111 33 but but CC 40436 9111 34 expressly expressly RB 40436 9111 35 on on IN 40436 9111 36 the the DT 40436 9111 37 ground ground NN 40436 9111 38 that that IN 40436 9111 39 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9111 40 are be VBP 40436 9111 41 the the DT 40436 9111 42 producing produce VBG 40436 9111 43 causes cause NNS 40436 9111 44 and and CC 40436 9111 45 conditions condition NNS 40436 9111 46 of of IN 40436 9111 47 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9111 48 and and CC 40436 9111 49 of of IN 40436 9111 50 exemption exemption NN 40436 9111 51 from from IN 40436 9111 52 pains pain NNS 40436 9111 53 : : : 40436 9111 54 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9111 55 also also RB 40436 9111 56 ranks rank VBZ 40436 9111 57 sickness sickness NN 40436 9111 58 and and CC 40436 9111 59 poverty poverty NN 40436 9111 60 under under IN 40436 9111 61 the the DT 40436 9111 62 head head NN 40436 9111 63 of of IN 40436 9111 64 Evil evil JJ 40436 9111 65 things thing NNS 40436 9111 66 , , , 40436 9111 67 as as IN 40436 9111 68 productive productive JJ 40436 9111 69 causes cause NNS 40436 9111 70 of of IN 40436 9111 71 pain pain NN 40436 9111 72 and and CC 40436 9111 73 suffering suffering NN 40436 9111 74 . . . 40436 9112 1 In in IN 40436 9112 2 the the DT 40436 9112 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9112 4 also also RB 40436 9112 5 , , , 40436 9112 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9112 7 numbers number VBZ 40436 9112 8 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 9112 9 , , , 40436 9112 10 health health NN 40436 9112 11 , , , 40436 9112 12 strength strength NN 40436 9112 13 , , , 40436 9112 14 perfection perfection NN 40436 9112 15 of of IN 40436 9112 16 body body NN 40436 9112 17 , , , 40436 9112 18 riches rich NNS 40436 9112 19 , , , 40436 9112 20 & & CC 40436 9112 21 c. c. NNP 40436 9112 22 , , , 40436 9112 23 among among IN 40436 9112 24 Good good JJ 40436 9112 25 things thing NNS 40436 9112 26 or or CC 40436 9112 27 profitable profitable JJ 40436 9112 28 things[81]--(which things[81]--(which CD 40436 9112 29 two two CD 40436 9112 30 words word NNS 40436 9112 31 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9112 32 treats treat VBZ 40436 9112 33 as as IN 40436 9112 34 equivalent)--and equivalent)--and CC 40436 9112 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9112 36 contraries contrary NNS 40436 9112 37 as as IN 40436 9112 38 Evil evil JJ 40436 9112 39 things thing NNS 40436 9112 40 . . . 40436 9113 1 Now now RB 40436 9113 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9113 3 does do VBZ 40436 9113 4 not not RB 40436 9113 5 expressly expressly RB 40436 9113 6 say say VB 40436 9113 7 here here RB 40436 9113 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9113 9 as as IN 40436 9113 10 in in IN 40436 9113 11 the the DT 40436 9113 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9113 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9113 14 that that IN 40436 9113 15 these these DT 40436 9113 16 things thing NNS 40436 9113 17 are be VBP 40436 9113 18 _ _ NNP 40436 9113 19 good good JJ 40436 9113 20 _ _ NNP 40436 9113 21 , , , 40436 9113 22 because because IN 40436 9113 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9113 24 are be VBP 40436 9113 25 productive productive JJ 40436 9113 26 causes cause NNS 40436 9113 27 of of IN 40436 9113 28 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9113 29 or or CC 40436 9113 30 exemption exemption NN 40436 9113 31 from from IN 40436 9113 32 pain pain NN 40436 9113 33 : : : 40436 9113 34 but but CC 40436 9113 35 such such JJ 40436 9113 36 assumption assumption NN 40436 9113 37 must must MD 40436 9113 38 evidently evidently RB 40436 9113 39 be be VB 40436 9113 40 supplied supply VBN 40436 9113 41 in in IN 40436 9113 42 order order NN 40436 9113 43 to to TO 40436 9113 44 make make VB 40436 9113 45 the the DT 40436 9113 46 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 9113 47 valid valid JJ 40436 9113 48 . . . 40436 9114 1 For for IN 40436 9114 2 upon upon IN 40436 9114 3 what what WDT 40436 9114 4 pretence pretence NN 40436 9114 5 can can MD 40436 9114 6 any any DT 40436 9114 7 one one CD 40436 9114 8 pronounce pronounce NN 40436 9114 9 strength strength NN 40436 9114 10 , , , 40436 9114 11 health health NN 40436 9114 12 , , , 40436 9114 13 riches rich NNS 40436 9114 14 , , , 40436 9114 15 to to TO 40436 9114 16 be be VB 40436 9114 17 _ _ NNP 40436 9114 18 good_--and good_--and NNP 40436 9114 19 helplessness helplessness NN 40436 9114 20 , , , 40436 9114 21 sickness sickness NN 40436 9114 22 , , , 40436 9114 23 poverty poverty NN 40436 9114 24 , , , 40436 9114 25 to to TO 40436 9114 26 be be VB 40436 9114 27 _ _ NNP 40436 9114 28 evil_--if evil_--if NNP 40436 9114 29 no no DT 40436 9114 30 reference reference NN 40436 9114 31 be be VB 40436 9114 32 admitted admit VBN 40436 9114 33 to to IN 40436 9114 34 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9114 35 and and CC 40436 9114 36 pains pain NNS 40436 9114 37 ? ? . 40436 9115 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9115 2 in in IN 40436 9115 3 the the DT 40436 9115 4 Gorgias[82 Gorgias[82 NNS 40436 9115 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9115 6 declares declare VBZ 40436 9115 7 that that IN 40436 9115 8 the the DT 40436 9115 9 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9115 10 of of IN 40436 9115 11 eating eating NN 40436 9115 12 and and CC 40436 9115 13 drinking drinking NN 40436 9115 14 are be VBP 40436 9115 15 good good JJ 40436 9115 16 , , , 40436 9115 17 in in IN 40436 9115 18 so so RB 40436 9115 19 far far RB 40436 9115 20 as as IN 40436 9115 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9115 22 impart impart VBP 40436 9115 23 health health NN 40436 9115 24 and and CC 40436 9115 25 strength strength NN 40436 9115 26 to to IN 40436 9115 27 the the DT 40436 9115 28 body body NN 40436 9115 29 -- -- : 40436 9115 30 evil evil NN 40436 9115 31 , , , 40436 9115 32 in in IN 40436 9115 33 so so RB 40436 9115 34 far far RB 40436 9115 35 as as IN 40436 9115 36 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9115 37 produce produce VBP 40436 9115 38 a a DT 40436 9115 39 contrary contrary JJ 40436 9115 40 effect effect NN 40436 9115 41 . . . 40436 9116 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9116 2 in in IN 40436 9116 3 the the DT 40436 9116 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9116 5 reasons reason NNS 40436 9116 6 in in IN 40436 9116 7 the the DT 40436 9116 8 same same JJ 40436 9116 9 way way NN 40436 9116 10 -- -- : 40436 9116 11 but but CC 40436 9116 12 with with IN 40436 9116 13 this this DT 40436 9116 14 difference difference NN 40436 9116 15 -- -- : 40436 9116 16 that that IN 40436 9116 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9116 18 would would MD 40436 9116 19 count count VB 40436 9116 20 the the DT 40436 9116 21 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9116 22 of of IN 40436 9116 23 the the DT 40436 9116 24 repast repast NN 40436 9116 25 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9116 26 as as IN 40436 9116 27 one one CD 40436 9116 28 item item NN 40436 9116 29 of of IN 40436 9116 30 good good NN 40436 9116 31 : : : 40436 9116 32 enhancing enhance VBG 40436 9116 33 the the DT 40436 9116 34 amount amount NN 40436 9116 35 of of IN 40436 9116 36 good good JJ 40436 9116 37 where where WRB 40436 9116 38 the the DT 40436 9116 39 future future JJ 40436 9116 40 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9116 41 are be VBP 40436 9116 42 beneficial beneficial JJ 40436 9116 43 , , , 40436 9116 44 diminishing diminish VBG 40436 9116 45 the the DT 40436 9116 46 amount amount NN 40436 9116 47 of of IN 40436 9116 48 evil evil NN 40436 9116 49 where where WRB 40436 9116 50 the the DT 40436 9116 51 future future JJ 40436 9116 52 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9116 53 are be VBP 40436 9116 54 Unfavourable unfavourable JJ 40436 9116 55 : : : 40436 9116 56 while while IN 40436 9116 57 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9116 58 in in IN 40436 9116 59 the the DT 40436 9116 60 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9116 61 excludes exclude VBZ 40436 9116 62 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9116 63 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9116 64 from from IN 40436 9116 65 the the DT 40436 9116 66 list list NN 40436 9116 67 of of IN 40436 9116 68 good good JJ 40436 9116 69 things thing NNS 40436 9116 70 , , , 40436 9116 71 and and CC 40436 9116 72 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9116 73 pain pain NN 40436 9116 74 from from IN 40436 9116 75 the the DT 40436 9116 76 list list NN 40436 9116 77 of of IN 40436 9116 78 evil evil JJ 40436 9116 79 things thing NNS 40436 9116 80 . . . 40436 9117 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9117 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9117 3 80 80 CD 40436 9117 4 : : : 40436 9117 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9117 6 , , , 40436 9117 7 Protagor Protagor NNP 40436 9117 8 . . . 40436 9118 1 pp pp NNP 40436 9118 2 . . . 40436 9119 1 353 353 CD 40436 9119 2 D d NN 40436 9119 3 , , , 40436 9119 4 354 354 CD 40436 9119 5 A. a. NN 40436 9119 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9120 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9120 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9120 3 81 81 CD 40436 9120 4 : : : 40436 9120 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9120 6 , , , 40436 9120 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9120 8 , , , 40436 9120 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9120 10 . . . 40436 9121 1 467 467 CD 40436 9121 2 - - HYPH 40436 9121 3 468 468 CD 40436 9121 4 - - HYPH 40436 9121 5 499 499 CD 40436 9121 6 . . . 40436 9121 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9122 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9122 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9122 3 82 82 CD 40436 9122 4 : : : 40436 9122 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9122 6 , , , 40436 9122 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9122 8 , , , 40436 9122 9 p. p. NN 40436 9122 10 499 499 CD 40436 9122 11 D. D. NNP 40436 9122 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9122 13 This this DT 40436 9122 14 last last JJ 40436 9122 15 exclusion exclusion NN 40436 9122 16 renders render VBZ 40436 9122 17 the the DT 40436 9122 18 theory theory NN 40436 9122 19 in in IN 40436 9122 20 the the DT 40436 9122 21 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9122 22 untenable untenable JJ 40436 9122 23 and and CC 40436 9122 24 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 9122 25 . . . 40436 9123 1 If if IN 40436 9123 2 present present JJ 40436 9123 3 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9123 4 be be VBP 40436 9123 5 not not RB 40436 9123 6 admitted admit VBN 40436 9123 7 as as IN 40436 9123 8 an an DT 40436 9123 9 item item NN 40436 9123 10 of of IN 40436 9123 11 good good JJ 40436 9123 12 so so RB 40436 9123 13 far far RB 40436 9123 14 as as IN 40436 9123 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9123 16 goes go VBZ 40436 9123 17 -- -- : 40436 9123 18 then then RB 40436 9123 19 neither neither CC 40436 9123 20 can can MD 40436 9123 21 the the DT 40436 9123 22 future future NN 40436 9123 23 and and CC 40436 9123 24 consequent consequent JJ 40436 9123 25 aggregates aggregate NNS 40436 9123 26 of of IN 40436 9123 27 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9123 28 , , , 40436 9123 29 nor nor CC 40436 9123 30 the the DT 40436 9123 31 causes cause NNS 40436 9123 32 of of IN 40436 9123 33 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9123 34 , , , 40436 9123 35 be be VB 40436 9123 36 admitted admit VBN 40436 9123 37 as as IN 40436 9123 38 good good JJ 40436 9123 39 . . . 40436 9124 1 So so RB 40436 9124 2 likewise likewise RB 40436 9124 3 , , , 40436 9124 4 if if IN 40436 9124 5 present present JJ 40436 9124 6 pain pain NN 40436 9124 7 be be VB 40436 9124 8 no no DT 40436 9124 9 evil evil JJ 40436 9124 10 , , , 40436 9124 11 future future JJ 40436 9124 12 pain pain NN 40436 9124 13 can can MD 40436 9124 14 not not RB 40436 9124 15 be be VB 40436 9124 16 allowed allow VBN 40436 9124 17 to to TO 40436 9124 18 rank rank VB 40436 9124 19 as as IN 40436 9124 20 an an DT 40436 9124 21 evil evil NN 40436 9124 22 . . . 40436 9125 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9125 2 83 83 CD 40436 9125 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9125 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9125 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9125 6 83 83 CD 40436 9125 7 : : : 40436 9125 8 Compare compare VB 40436 9125 9 a a DT 40436 9125 10 passage passage NN 40436 9125 11 in in IN 40436 9125 12 the the DT 40436 9125 13 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9125 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9125 15 ii ii NNP 40436 9125 16 . . . 40436 9126 1 p. p. NN 40436 9126 2 357 357 CD 40436 9126 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9126 4 where where WRB 40436 9126 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9126 6 gives give VBZ 40436 9126 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9126 8 or or CC 40436 9126 9 accepts accept VBZ 40436 9126 10 , , , 40436 9126 11 as as IN 40436 9126 12 given give VBN 40436 9126 13 by by IN 40436 9126 14 Glaukon Glaukon NNP 40436 9126 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9126 16 a a DT 40436 9126 17 description description NN 40436 9126 18 of of IN 40436 9126 19 Good Good NNP 40436 9126 20 much much RB 40436 9126 21 more more JJR 40436 9126 22 coincident coincident NN 40436 9126 23 with with IN 40436 9126 24 the the DT 40436 9126 25 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9126 26 than than IN 40436 9126 27 with with IN 40436 9126 28 the the DT 40436 9126 29 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9126 30 . . . 40436 9127 1 The the DT 40436 9127 2 common common JJ 40436 9127 3 property property NN 40436 9127 4 of of IN 40436 9127 5 all all DT 40436 9127 6 Good good JJ 40436 9127 7 is be VBZ 40436 9127 8 to to TO 40436 9127 9 be be VB 40436 9127 10 desired desire VBN 40436 9127 11 or or CC 40436 9127 12 loved love VBN 40436 9127 13 ; ; : 40436 9127 14 and and CC 40436 9127 15 there there EX 40436 9127 16 are be VBP 40436 9127 17 three three CD 40436 9127 18 varieties variety NNS 40436 9127 19 of of IN 40436 9127 20 it--1 it--1 CD 40436 9127 21 . . . 40436 9128 1 That that DT 40436 9128 2 which which WDT 40436 9128 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9128 4 desire desire VBP 40436 9128 5 for for IN 40436 9128 6 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9128 7 , , , 40436 9128 8 and and CC 40436 9128 9 for for IN 40436 9128 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9128 11 own own JJ 40436 9128 12 sake sake NN 40436 9128 13 , , , 40436 9128 14 apart apart RB 40436 9128 15 from from IN 40436 9128 16 all all DT 40436 9128 17 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 9128 18 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9128 19 , , , 40436 9128 20 such such JJ 40436 9128 21 as as IN 40436 9128 22 innocuous innocuous JJ 40436 9128 23 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9128 24 or or CC 40436 9128 25 enjoyments enjoyment NNS 40436 9128 26 . . . 40436 9129 1 2 2 LS 40436 9129 2 . . . 40436 9130 1 That that DT 40436 9130 2 which which WDT 40436 9130 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9130 4 desire desire VBP 40436 9130 5 both both DT 40436 9130 6 for for IN 40436 9130 7 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9130 8 and and CC 40436 9130 9 for for IN 40436 9130 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9130 11 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 9130 12 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9130 13 , , , 40436 9130 14 such such JJ 40436 9130 15 as as IN 40436 9130 16 good good JJ 40436 9130 17 health health NN 40436 9130 18 , , , 40436 9130 19 good good JJ 40436 9130 20 vision vision NN 40436 9130 21 , , , 40436 9130 22 good good JJ 40436 9130 23 sense sense NN 40436 9130 24 , , , 40436 9130 25 & & CC 40436 9130 26 c. c. NNP 40436 9130 27 3 3 CD 40436 9130 28 . . . 40436 9131 1 That that DT 40436 9131 2 which which WDT 40436 9131 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9131 4 do do VBP 40436 9131 5 not not RB 40436 9131 6 desire desire VB 40436 9131 7 -- -- : 40436 9131 8 nay nay NNP 40436 9131 9 , , , 40436 9131 10 which which WDT 40436 9131 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9131 12 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 9131 13 hate hate VBP 40436 9131 14 or or CC 40436 9131 15 shun shun VBP 40436 9131 16 , , , 40436 9131 17 _ _ NNP 40436 9131 18 per per FW 40436 9131 19 se se FW 40436 9131 20 _ _ NNP 40436 9131 21 : : : 40436 9131 22 but but CC 40436 9131 23 which which WDT 40436 9131 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9131 25 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 9131 26 desire desire VBP 40436 9131 27 and and CC 40436 9131 28 invite invite VB 40436 9131 29 , , , 40436 9131 30 in in IN 40436 9131 31 connection connection NN 40436 9131 32 with with IN 40436 9131 33 and and CC 40436 9131 34 for for IN 40436 9131 35 the the DT 40436 9131 36 sake sake NN 40436 9131 37 of of IN 40436 9131 38 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 9131 39 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9131 40 : : : 40436 9131 41 such such JJ 40436 9131 42 as as IN 40436 9131 43 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 9131 44 training training NN 40436 9131 45 , , , 40436 9131 46 medical medical JJ 40436 9131 47 treatment treatment NN 40436 9131 48 when when WRB 40436 9131 49 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9131 50 are be VBP 40436 9131 51 sick sick JJ 40436 9131 52 , , , 40436 9131 53 labour labour JJ 40436 9131 54 in in IN 40436 9131 55 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9131 56 trade trade NN 40436 9131 57 or or CC 40436 9131 58 profession profession NN 40436 9131 59 . . . 40436 9132 1 Here here RB 40436 9132 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9132 3 admits admit VBZ 40436 9132 4 the the DT 40436 9132 5 immediately immediately RB 40436 9132 6 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9132 7 _ _ NNP 40436 9132 8 per per FW 40436 9132 9 se se FW 40436 9132 10 _ _ NNP 40436 9132 11 as as IN 40436 9132 12 one one CD 40436 9132 13 variety variety NN 40436 9132 14 of of IN 40436 9132 15 good good JJ 40436 9132 16 , , , 40436 9132 17 always always RB 40436 9132 18 assuming assume VBG 40436 9132 19 that that IN 40436 9132 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9132 21 is be VBZ 40436 9132 22 not not RB 40436 9132 23 countervailed countervail VBN 40436 9132 24 by by IN 40436 9132 25 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9132 26 or or CC 40436 9132 27 accompaniments accompaniment NNS 40436 9132 28 of of IN 40436 9132 29 a a DT 40436 9132 30 painful painful JJ 40436 9132 31 character character NN 40436 9132 32 . . . 40436 9133 1 This this DT 40436 9133 2 is be VBZ 40436 9133 3 the the DT 40436 9133 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9133 5 of of IN 40436 9133 6 the the DT 40436 9133 7 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9133 8 , , , 40436 9133 9 as as IN 40436 9133 10 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 9133 11 from from IN 40436 9133 12 the the DT 40436 9133 13 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9133 14 , , , 40436 9133 15 where where WRB 40436 9133 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9133 17 sets set VBZ 40436 9133 18 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9133 19 in in IN 40436 9133 20 marked mark VBN 40436 9133 21 opposition opposition NN 40436 9133 22 to to IN 40436 9133 23 good good NN 40436 9133 24 . . . 40436 9133 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9134 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9134 2 Side side NN 40436 9134 3 - - HYPH 40436 9134 4 note note NN 40436 9134 5 : : : 40436 9134 6 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 9134 7 , , , 40436 9134 8 whom whom WP 40436 9134 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9134 10 refutes refute VBZ 40436 9134 11 in in IN 40436 9134 12 the the DT 40436 9134 13 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9134 14 , , , 40436 9134 15 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 9134 16 a a DT 40436 9134 17 different different JJ 40436 9134 18 argument argument NN 40436 9134 19 from from IN 40436 9134 20 that that DT 40436 9134 21 which which WDT 40436 9134 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9134 23 combats combat VBZ 40436 9134 24 in in IN 40436 9134 25 the the DT 40436 9134 26 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9134 27 . . . 40436 9134 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9135 1 Each each DT 40436 9135 2 of of IN 40436 9135 3 the the DT 40436 9135 4 two two CD 40436 9135 5 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9135 6 , , , 40436 9135 7 which which WDT 40436 9135 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9135 9 am be VBP 40436 9135 10 now now RB 40436 9135 11 comparing compare VBG 40436 9135 12 , , , 40436 9135 13 is be VBZ 40436 9135 14 in in IN 40436 9135 15 truth truth NN 40436 9135 16 an an DT 40436 9135 17 independent independent JJ 40436 9135 18 composition composition NN 40436 9135 19 : : : 40436 9135 20 in in IN 40436 9135 21 each each DT 40436 9135 22 , , , 40436 9135 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9135 24 has have VBZ 40436 9135 25 a a DT 40436 9135 26 distinct distinct JJ 40436 9135 27 argument argument NN 40436 9135 28 to to TO 40436 9135 29 combat combat VB 40436 9135 30 ; ; : 40436 9135 31 and and CC 40436 9135 32 in in IN 40436 9135 33 the the DT 40436 9135 34 latest late JJS 40436 9135 35 of of IN 40436 9135 36 the the DT 40436 9135 37 two two CD 40436 9135 38 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9135 39 whichever whichever WDT 40436 9135 40 that that DT 40436 9135 41 was be VBD 40436 9135 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9135 43 , , , 40436 9135 44 no no DT 40436 9135 45 heed heed NN 40436 9135 46 is be VBZ 40436 9135 47 taken take VBN 40436 9135 48 of of IN 40436 9135 49 the the DT 40436 9135 50 argumentation argumentation NN 40436 9135 51 in in IN 40436 9135 52 the the DT 40436 9135 53 earlier early RBR 40436 9135 54 . . . 40436 9136 1 In in IN 40436 9136 2 the the DT 40436 9136 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9136 4 , , , 40436 9136 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9136 6 exalts exalt VBZ 40436 9136 7 the the DT 40436 9136 8 dignity dignity NN 40436 9136 9 and and CC 40436 9136 10 paramount paramount JJ 40436 9136 11 force force NN 40436 9136 12 of of IN 40436 9136 13 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9136 14 or or CC 40436 9136 15 prudence prudence NN 40436 9136 16 : : : 40436 9136 17 if if IN 40436 9136 18 a a DT 40436 9136 19 man man NN 40436 9136 20 knows know VBZ 40436 9136 21 how how WRB 40436 9136 22 to to TO 40436 9136 23 calculate calculate VB 40436 9136 24 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9136 25 and and CC 40436 9136 26 pains pain NNS 40436 9136 27 , , , 40436 9136 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9136 29 will will MD 40436 9136 30 be be VB 40436 9136 31 sure sure JJ 40436 9136 32 to to TO 40436 9136 33 choose choose VB 40436 9136 34 the the DT 40436 9136 35 result result NN 40436 9136 36 which which WDT 40436 9136 37 involves involve VBZ 40436 9136 38 the the DT 40436 9136 39 greater great JJR 40436 9136 40 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9136 41 or or CC 40436 9136 42 the the DT 40436 9136 43 less less JJR 40436 9136 44 pain pain NN 40436 9136 45 , , , 40436 9136 46 on on IN 40436 9136 47 the the DT 40436 9136 48 whole whole NN 40436 9136 49 : : : 40436 9136 50 to to TO 40436 9136 51 say say VB 40436 9136 52 that that IN 40436 9136 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9136 54 is be VBZ 40436 9136 55 overpowered overpower VBN 40436 9136 56 by by IN 40436 9136 57 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9136 58 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9136 59 or or CC 40436 9136 60 pain pain NN 40436 9136 61 into into IN 40436 9136 62 making make VBG 40436 9136 63 a a DT 40436 9136 64 bad bad JJ 40436 9136 65 choice choice NN 40436 9136 66 , , , 40436 9136 67 is be VBZ 40436 9136 68 a a DT 40436 9136 69 wrong wrong JJ 40436 9136 70 description description NN 40436 9136 71 -- -- : 40436 9136 72 the the DT 40436 9136 73 real real JJ 40436 9136 74 fact fact NN 40436 9136 75 being being NN 40436 9136 76 , , , 40436 9136 77 that that IN 40436 9136 78 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9136 79 is be VBZ 40436 9136 80 deficient deficient JJ 40436 9136 81 in in IN 40436 9136 82 the the DT 40436 9136 83 proper proper JJ 40436 9136 84 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9136 85 how how WRB 40436 9136 86 to to TO 40436 9136 87 choose choose VB 40436 9136 88 . . . 40436 9137 1 In in IN 40436 9137 2 the the DT 40436 9137 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9137 4 , , , 40436 9137 5 the the DT 40436 9137 6 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9137 7 assigned assign VBN 40436 9137 8 to to IN 40436 9137 9 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9137 10 and and CC 40436 9137 11 impugned impugn VBN 40436 9137 12 by by IN 40436 9137 13 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9137 14 is be VBZ 40436 9137 15 something something NN 40436 9137 16 very very RB 40436 9137 17 different different JJ 40436 9137 18 . . . 40436 9138 1 That that DT 40436 9138 2 justice justice NN 40436 9138 3 , , , 40436 9138 4 temperance temperance NN 40436 9138 5 , , , 40436 9138 6 self self NN 40436 9138 7 - - HYPH 40436 9138 8 restraint restraint NN 40436 9138 9 , , , 40436 9138 10 are be VBP 40436 9138 11 indeed indeed RB 40436 9138 12 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 9138 13 to to IN 40436 9138 14 the the DT 40436 9138 15 happiness happiness NN 40436 9138 16 of of IN 40436 9138 17 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 9138 18 men man NNS 40436 9138 19 ; ; : 40436 9138 20 but but CC 40436 9138 21 if if IN 40436 9138 22 there there EX 40436 9138 23 be be VBP 40436 9138 24 any any DT 40436 9138 25 one one CD 40436 9138 26 individual individual NN 40436 9138 27 , , , 40436 9138 28 so so RB 40436 9138 29 immensely immensely RB 40436 9138 30 superior superior JJ 40436 9138 31 in in IN 40436 9138 32 force force NN 40436 9138 33 as as IN 40436 9138 34 to to TO 40436 9138 35 trample trample VB 40436 9138 36 down down RP 40436 9138 37 and and CC 40436 9138 38 make make VB 40436 9138 39 slaves slave NNS 40436 9138 40 of of IN 40436 9138 41 the the DT 40436 9138 42 rest rest NN 40436 9138 43 , , , 40436 9138 44 this this DT 40436 9138 45 one one CD 40436 9138 46 man man NN 40436 9138 47 would would MD 40436 9138 48 be be VB 40436 9138 49 a a DT 40436 9138 50 fool fool NN 40436 9138 51 if if IN 40436 9138 52 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9138 53 restrained restrain VBD 40436 9138 54 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9138 55 : : : 40436 9138 56 having have VBG 40436 9138 57 the the DT 40436 9138 58 means mean NNS 40436 9138 59 of of IN 40436 9138 60 gratifying gratify VBG 40436 9138 61 all all PDT 40436 9138 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9138 63 appetites appetite NNS 40436 9138 64 , , , 40436 9138 65 the the DT 40436 9138 66 more more RBR 40436 9138 67 appetites appetite NNS 40436 9138 68 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9138 69 has have VBZ 40436 9138 70 , , , 40436 9138 71 the the DT 40436 9138 72 more more JJR 40436 9138 73 enjoyments enjoyment NNS 40436 9138 74 will will MD 40436 9138 75 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9138 76 have have VB 40436 9138 77 and and CC 40436 9138 78 the the DT 40436 9138 79 greater great JJR 40436 9138 80 happiness happiness NN 40436 9138 81 . . . 40436 9139 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9139 2 84 84 CD 40436 9139 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9139 4 Observe observe VB 40436 9139 5 -- -- : 40436 9139 6 that that IN 40436 9139 7 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9139 8 applies apply VBZ 40436 9139 9 this this DT 40436 9139 10 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9139 11 only only RB 40436 9139 12 to to IN 40436 9139 13 the the DT 40436 9139 14 one one CD 40436 9139 15 omnipotent omnipotent NN 40436 9139 16 despot despot NN 40436 9139 17 : : : 40436 9139 18 to to IN 40436 9139 19 all all DT 40436 9139 20 other other JJ 40436 9139 21 members member NNS 40436 9139 22 of of IN 40436 9139 23 society society NN 40436 9139 24 , , , 40436 9139 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9139 26 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 9139 27 that that IN 40436 9139 28 self self NN 40436 9139 29 - - HYPH 40436 9139 30 restraint restraint NN 40436 9139 31 is be VBZ 40436 9139 32 essential essential JJ 40436 9139 33 . . . 40436 9140 1 This this DT 40436 9140 2 is be VBZ 40436 9140 3 the the DT 40436 9140 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9140 5 which which WDT 40436 9140 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9140 7 in in IN 40436 9140 8 the the DT 40436 9140 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9140 10 undertakes undertake NNS 40436 9140 11 to to TO 40436 9140 12 refute refute VB 40436 9140 13 , , , 40436 9140 14 by by IN 40436 9140 15 denying deny VBG 40436 9140 16 community community NN 40436 9140 17 of of IN 40436 9140 18 nature nature NN 40436 9140 19 between between IN 40436 9140 20 the the DT 40436 9140 21 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 9140 22 and and CC 40436 9140 23 the the DT 40436 9140 24 good good JJ 40436 9140 25 -- -- : 40436 9140 26 between between IN 40436 9140 27 the the DT 40436 9140 28 painful painful JJ 40436 9140 29 and and CC 40436 9140 30 the the DT 40436 9140 31 evil evil NN 40436 9140 32 . . . 40436 9141 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9141 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9141 3 84 84 CD 40436 9141 4 : : : 40436 9141 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9141 6 , , , 40436 9141 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9141 8 , , , 40436 9141 9 p. p. NN 40436 9141 10 492 492 CD 40436 9141 11 B. B. NNP 40436 9141 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9142 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9142 2 Side side NN 40436 9142 3 - - HYPH 40436 9142 4 note note NN 40436 9142 5 : : : 40436 9142 6 The the DT 40436 9142 7 refutation refutation NN 40436 9142 8 of of IN 40436 9142 9 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9142 10 by by IN 40436 9142 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9142 12 in in IN 40436 9142 13 the the DT 40436 9142 14 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9142 15 , , , 40436 9142 16 is be VBZ 40436 9142 17 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 40436 9142 18 -- -- : 40436 9142 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9142 20 is be VBZ 40436 9142 21 only only RB 40436 9142 22 so so RB 40436 9142 23 far far RB 40436 9142 24 successful successful JJ 40436 9142 25 as as IN 40436 9142 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9142 27 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 9142 28 unintentionally unintentionally RB 40436 9142 29 the the DT 40436 9142 30 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9142 31 of of IN 40436 9142 32 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9142 33 in in IN 40436 9142 34 the the DT 40436 9142 35 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9142 36 . . . 40436 9142 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9143 1 To to IN 40436 9143 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9143 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9143 4 refutation refutation NN 40436 9143 5 appears appear VBZ 40436 9143 6 altogether altogether RB 40436 9143 7 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 40436 9143 8 , , , 40436 9143 9 and and CC 40436 9143 10 the the DT 40436 9143 11 position position NN 40436 9143 12 upon upon IN 40436 9143 13 which which WDT 40436 9143 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9143 15 rests rest VBZ 40436 9143 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9143 17 incorrect incorrect JJ 40436 9143 18 . . . 40436 9144 1 The the DT 40436 9144 2 only only JJ 40436 9144 3 parts part NNS 40436 9144 4 of of IN 40436 9144 5 the the DT 40436 9144 6 refutation refutation NN 40436 9144 7 really really RB 40436 9144 8 forcible forcible JJ 40436 9144 9 , , , 40436 9144 10 are be VBP 40436 9144 11 those those DT 40436 9144 12 in in IN 40436 9144 13 which which WDT 40436 9144 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9144 15 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 9144 16 relinquishes relinquish VBZ 40436 9144 17 this this DT 40436 9144 18 position position NN 40436 9144 19 , , , 40436 9144 20 and and CC 40436 9144 21 slides slide VBZ 40436 9144 22 into into IN 40436 9144 23 the the DT 40436 9144 24 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9144 25 of of IN 40436 9144 26 the the DT 40436 9144 27 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9144 28 . . . 40436 9145 1 Upon upon IN 40436 9145 2 this this DT 40436 9145 3 latter latter JJ 40436 9145 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9145 5 , , , 40436 9145 6 a a DT 40436 9145 7 refutation refutation NN 40436 9145 8 might may MD 40436 9145 9 be be VB 40436 9145 10 grounded ground VBN 40436 9145 11 : : : 40436 9145 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9145 13 may may MD 40436 9145 14 show show VB 40436 9145 15 that that IN 40436 9145 16 even even RB 40436 9145 17 an an DT 40436 9145 18 omnipotent omnipotent NN 40436 9145 19 despot despot NN 40436 9145 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9145 21 regard regard NN 40436 9145 22 for for IN 40436 9145 23 the the DT 40436 9145 24 comfort comfort NN 40436 9145 25 of of IN 40436 9145 26 others other NNS 40436 9145 27 being be VBG 40436 9145 28 excluded exclude VBN 40436 9145 29 by by IN 40436 9145 30 the the DT 40436 9145 31 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 9145 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9145 33 will will MD 40436 9145 34 gain gain VB 40436 9145 35 by by IN 40436 9145 36 limiting limit VBG 40436 9145 37 the the DT 40436 9145 38 gratification gratification NN 40436 9145 39 of of IN 40436 9145 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9145 41 appetites appetite NNS 40436 9145 42 to to IN 40436 9145 43 - - HYPH 40436 9145 44 day day NN 40436 9145 45 so so IN 40436 9145 46 as as IN 40436 9145 47 not not RB 40436 9145 48 to to TO 40436 9145 49 spoil spoil VB 40436 9145 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9145 51 appetites appetite NNS 40436 9145 52 of of IN 40436 9145 53 tomorrow tomorrow NN 40436 9145 54 . . . 40436 9146 1 Even even RB 40436 9146 2 in in IN 40436 9146 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9146 4 case case NN 40436 9146 5 , , , 40436 9146 6 prudential prudential JJ 40436 9146 7 restraint restraint NN 40436 9146 8 is be VBZ 40436 9146 9 required require VBN 40436 9146 10 , , , 40436 9146 11 though though IN 40436 9146 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9146 13 motives motive NNS 40436 9146 14 for for IN 40436 9146 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9146 16 would would MD 40436 9146 17 be be VB 40436 9146 18 much much RB 40436 9146 19 less less JJR 40436 9146 20 than than IN 40436 9146 21 in in IN 40436 9146 22 the the DT 40436 9146 23 case case NN 40436 9146 24 of of IN 40436 9146 25 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 9146 26 social social JJ 40436 9146 27 men man NNS 40436 9146 28 . . . 40436 9147 1 But but CC 40436 9147 2 Good good JJ 40436 9147 3 , , , 40436 9147 4 as as IN 40436 9147 5 laid lay VBN 40436 9147 6 down down RP 40436 9147 7 by by IN 40436 9147 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9147 9 in in IN 40436 9147 10 the the DT 40436 9147 11 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9147 12 , , , 40436 9147 13 entirely entirely RB 40436 9147 14 disconnected disconnect VBD 40436 9147 15 from from IN 40436 9147 16 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9147 17 -- -- : 40436 9147 18 and and CC 40436 9147 19 Evil evil JJ 40436 9147 20 , , , 40436 9147 21 entirely entirely RB 40436 9147 22 disconnected disconnect VBD 40436 9147 23 from from IN 40436 9147 24 pain pain NN 40436 9147 25 -- -- : 40436 9147 26 have have VBP 40436 9147 27 no no DT 40436 9147 28 application application NN 40436 9147 29 to to IN 40436 9147 30 this this DT 40436 9147 31 supposed suppose VBN 40436 9147 32 despot despot NN 40436 9147 33 . . . 40436 9148 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9148 2 has have VBZ 40436 9148 3 no no DT 40436 9148 4 desire desire NN 40436 9148 5 for for IN 40436 9148 6 such such JJ 40436 9148 7 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9148 8 Good Good NNP 40436 9148 9 -- -- : 40436 9148 10 no no DT 40436 9148 11 aversion aversion NN 40436 9148 12 for for IN 40436 9148 13 such such JJ 40436 9148 14 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9148 15 Evil Evil NNP 40436 9148 16 . . . 40436 9149 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9149 2 happiness happiness NN 40436 9149 3 is be VBZ 40436 9149 4 not not RB 40436 9149 5 diminished diminish VBN 40436 9149 6 by by IN 40436 9149 7 missing miss VBG 40436 9149 8 the the DT 40436 9149 9 former former JJ 40436 9149 10 or or CC 40436 9149 11 incurring incur VBG 40436 9149 12 the the DT 40436 9149 13 latter latter JJ 40436 9149 14 . . . 40436 9150 1 In in IN 40436 9150 2 fact fact NN 40436 9150 3 , , , 40436 9150 4 one one CD 40436 9150 5 of of IN 40436 9150 6 the the DT 40436 9150 7 cardinal cardinal JJ 40436 9150 8 principles principle NNS 40436 9150 9 of of IN 40436 9150 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9150 11 's 's POS 40436 9150 12 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9150 13 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9150 14 , , , 40436 9150 15 which which WDT 40436 9150 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9150 17 frequently frequently RB 40436 9150 18 asserts assert VBZ 40436 9150 19 both both DT 40436 9150 20 in in IN 40436 9150 21 this this DT 40436 9150 22 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9150 23 and and CC 40436 9150 24 elsewhere,[85]--That elsewhere,[85]--That NNP 40436 9150 25 every every DT 40436 9150 26 man man NN 40436 9150 27 desires desire VBZ 40436 9150 28 Good good JJ 40436 9150 29 , , , 40436 9150 30 and and CC 40436 9150 31 acts act NNS 40436 9150 32 for for IN 40436 9150 33 the the DT 40436 9150 34 sake sake NN 40436 9150 35 of of IN 40436 9150 36 obtaining obtain VBG 40436 9150 37 Good good NN 40436 9150 38 , , , 40436 9150 39 and and CC 40436 9150 40 avoiding avoid VBG 40436 9150 41 Evil evil JJ 40436 9150 42 -- -- : 40436 9150 43 becomes become VBZ 40436 9150 44 untrue untrue JJ 40436 9150 45 , , , 40436 9150 46 if if IN 40436 9150 47 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9150 48 conceive conceive VBP 40436 9150 49 Good Good NNP 40436 9150 50 and and CC 40436 9150 51 Evil Evil NNP 40436 9150 52 according accord VBG 40436 9150 53 to to IN 40436 9150 54 the the DT 40436 9150 55 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9150 56 , , , 40436 9150 57 as as IN 40436 9150 58 having have VBG 40436 9150 59 no no DT 40436 9150 60 reference reference NN 40436 9150 61 to to TO 40436 9150 62 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9150 63 or or CC 40436 9150 64 the the DT 40436 9150 65 avoidance avoidance NN 40436 9150 66 of of IN 40436 9150 67 pain pain NN 40436 9150 68 : : : 40436 9150 69 untrue untrue JJ 40436 9150 70 , , , 40436 9150 71 not not RB 40436 9150 72 merely merely RB 40436 9150 73 in in IN 40436 9150 74 regard regard NN 40436 9150 75 to to IN 40436 9150 76 a a DT 40436 9150 77 despot despot NN 40436 9150 78 under under IN 40436 9150 79 these these DT 40436 9150 80 exceptional exceptional JJ 40436 9150 81 conditions condition NNS 40436 9150 82 , , , 40436 9150 83 but but CC 40436 9150 84 in in IN 40436 9150 85 regard regard NN 40436 9150 86 to to IN 40436 9150 87 the the DT 40436 9150 88 large large JJ 40436 9150 89 majority majority NN 40436 9150 90 of of IN 40436 9150 91 social social JJ 40436 9150 92 men man NNS 40436 9150 93 . . . 40436 9151 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9151 2 desire desire VBP 40436 9151 3 to to TO 40436 9151 4 obtain obtain VB 40436 9151 5 Good good JJ 40436 9151 6 and and CC 40436 9151 7 avoid avoid VB 40436 9151 8 Evil Evil NNP 40436 9151 9 , , , 40436 9151 10 in in IN 40436 9151 11 the the DT 40436 9151 12 sense sense NN 40436 9151 13 of of IN 40436 9151 14 the the DT 40436 9151 15 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9151 16 : : : 40436 9151 17 but but CC 40436 9151 18 not not RB 40436 9151 19 in in IN 40436 9151 20 the the DT 40436 9151 21 sense sense NN 40436 9151 22 of of IN 40436 9151 23 the the DT 40436 9151 24 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9151 25 . . . 40436 9152 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9152 2 86 86 CD 40436 9152 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9152 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9152 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9152 6 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 9152 7 in in IN 40436 9152 8 this this DT 40436 9152 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9152 10 : : : 40436 9152 11 " " `` 40436 9152 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9152 13 and and CC 40436 9152 14 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9152 15 stand stand VB 40436 9152 16 opposed oppose VBN 40436 9152 17 to to IN 40436 9152 18 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9152 19 and and CC 40436 9152 20 the the DT 40436 9152 21 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9152 22 public public NN 40436 9152 23 . . . 40436 9153 1 What what WP 40436 9153 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9153 3 desire desire VBP 40436 9153 4 is be VBZ 40436 9153 5 , , , 40436 9153 6 to to TO 40436 9153 7 reason reason VB 40436 9153 8 consistently consistently RB 40436 9153 9 with with IN 40436 9153 10 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9153 11 . . . 40436 9153 12 " " '' 40436 9154 1 That that RB 40436 9154 2 is is RB 40436 9154 3 , , , 40436 9154 4 to to TO 40436 9154 5 speak speak VB 40436 9154 6 the the DT 40436 9154 7 language language NN 40436 9154 8 of of IN 40436 9154 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9154 10 in in IN 40436 9154 11 the the DT 40436 9154 12 Protagoras--"To Protagoras--"To NNP 40436 9154 13 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9154 14 , , , 40436 9154 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9154 16 , , , 40436 9154 17 the the DT 40436 9154 18 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 9154 19 of of IN 40436 9154 20 inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 9154 21 with with IN 40436 9154 22 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9154 23 and and CC 40436 9154 24 of of IN 40436 9154 25 an an DT 40436 9154 26 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 9154 27 character character NN 40436 9154 28 , , , 40436 9154 29 the the DT 40436 9154 30 loss loss NN 40436 9154 31 of of IN 40436 9154 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9154 33 own own JJ 40436 9154 34 self self NN 40436 9154 35 - - HYPH 40436 9154 36 esteem esteem NN 40436 9154 37 and and CC 40436 9154 38 the the DT 40436 9154 39 pungency pungency NN 40436 9154 40 of of IN 40436 9154 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9154 42 own own JJ 40436 9154 43 self self NN 40436 9154 44 - - HYPH 40436 9154 45 reproach reproach NN 40436 9154 46 , , , 40436 9154 47 are be VBP 40436 9154 48 the the DT 40436 9154 49 greatest great JJS 40436 9154 50 of of IN 40436 9154 51 all all DT 40436 9154 52 pains pain NNS 40436 9154 53 : : : 40436 9154 54 greater great JJR 40436 9154 55 than than IN 40436 9154 56 those those DT 40436 9154 57 which which WDT 40436 9154 58 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9154 59 , , , 40436 9154 60 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9154 61 , , , 40436 9154 62 and and CC 40436 9154 63 the the DT 40436 9154 64 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 9154 65 generally generally RB 40436 9154 66 , , , 40436 9154 67 seek seek VBP 40436 9154 68 to to TO 40436 9154 69 avoid avoid VB 40436 9154 70 at at RB 40436 9154 71 all all DT 40436 9154 72 price price NN 40436 9154 73 and and CC 40436 9154 74 urge urge VB 40436 9154 75 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9154 76 also also RB 40436 9154 77 to to TO 40436 9154 78 avoid avoid VB 40436 9154 79 at at RB 40436 9154 80 all all DT 40436 9154 81 price price NN 40436 9154 82 -- -- : 40436 9154 83 poverty poverty NN 40436 9154 84 , , , 40436 9154 85 political political JJ 40436 9154 86 nullity nullity NN 40436 9154 87 , , , 40436 9154 88 exposure exposure NN 40436 9154 89 to to IN 40436 9154 90 false false JJ 40436 9154 91 accusation accusation NN 40436 9154 92 , , , 40436 9154 93 & & CC 40436 9154 94 c c NNP 40436 9154 95 . . . 40436 9154 96 "[87 "[87 NFP 40436 9154 97 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9154 98 The the DT 40436 9154 99 noble noble JJ 40436 9154 100 scheme scheme NN 40436 9154 101 of of IN 40436 9154 102 life life NN 40436 9154 103 , , , 40436 9154 104 here here RB 40436 9154 105 recommended recommend VBN 40436 9154 106 by by IN 40436 9154 107 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9154 108 , , , 40436 9154 109 may may MD 40436 9154 110 be be VB 40436 9154 111 correctly correctly RB 40436 9154 112 described describe VBN 40436 9154 113 according accord VBG 40436 9154 114 to to IN 40436 9154 115 the the DT 40436 9154 116 theory theory NN 40436 9154 117 of of IN 40436 9154 118 the the DT 40436 9154 119 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9154 120 : : : 40436 9154 121 without without IN 40436 9154 122 any any DT 40436 9154 123 resort resort NN 40436 9154 124 to to IN 40436 9154 125 the the DT 40436 9154 126 paradox paradox NN 40436 9154 127 of of IN 40436 9154 128 the the DT 40436 9154 129 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9154 130 , , , 40436 9154 131 that that IN 40436 9154 132 Good Good NNP 40436 9154 133 has have VBZ 40436 9154 134 no no DT 40436 9154 135 kindred kindred JJ 40436 9154 136 or or CC 40436 9154 137 reference reference NN 40436 9154 138 to to IN 40436 9154 139 Pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9154 140 , , , 40436 9154 141 nor nor CC 40436 9154 142 Evil evil JJ 40436 9154 143 to to IN 40436 9154 144 Pain Pain NNP 40436 9154 145 . . . 40436 9155 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9155 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9155 3 85 85 CD 40436 9155 4 : : : 40436 9155 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9155 6 , , , 40436 9155 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9155 8 , , , 40436 9155 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9155 10 . . . 40436 9156 1 467 467 CD 40436 9156 2 C C NNP 40436 9156 3 , , , 40436 9156 4 499 499 CD 40436 9156 5 E. E. NNP 40436 9156 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9156 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9156 8 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9156 9 86 86 CD 40436 9156 10 : : : 40436 9156 11 The the DT 40436 9156 12 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 9156 13 of of IN 40436 9156 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9156 15 in in IN 40436 9156 16 the the DT 40436 9156 17 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9156 18 , , , 40436 9156 19 respecting respect VBG 40436 9156 20 this this DT 40436 9156 21 matter matter NN 40436 9156 22 , , , 40436 9156 23 rests rest VBZ 40436 9156 24 upon upon IN 40436 9156 25 an an DT 40436 9156 26 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 9156 27 phrase phrase NN 40436 9156 28 . . . 40436 9157 1 The the DT 40436 9157 2 Greek greek JJ 40436 9157 3 phrase phrase NN 40436 9157 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9157 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9157 6 : : : 40436 9157 7 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 9157 8 pra pra NNP 40436 9157 9 / / SYM 40436 9157 10 ttein ttein NNP 40436 9157 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9157 12 has have VBZ 40436 9157 13 two two CD 40436 9157 14 meanings meaning NNS 40436 9157 15 ; ; : 40436 9157 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9157 17 means mean VBZ 40436 9157 18 _ _ NNP 40436 9157 19 recté recté NN 40436 9157 20 agere agere JJ 40436 9157 21 _ _ NNP 40436 9157 22 , , , 40436 9157 23 to to TO 40436 9157 24 act act VB 40436 9157 25 rightly rightly RB 40436 9157 26 ; ; : 40436 9157 27 and and CC 40436 9157 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9157 29 also also RB 40436 9157 30 means mean VBZ 40436 9157 31 _ _ NNP 40436 9157 32 felicem felicem NNP 40436 9157 33 esse esse NNP 40436 9157 34 _ _ NNP 40436 9157 35 , , , 40436 9157 36 to to TO 40436 9157 37 be be VB 40436 9157 38 happy happy JJ 40436 9157 39 . . . 40436 9158 1 There there EX 40436 9158 2 is be VBZ 40436 9158 3 a a DT 40436 9158 4 corresponding corresponding JJ 40436 9158 5 double double JJ 40436 9158 6 sense sense NN 40436 9158 7 in in IN 40436 9158 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9158 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9158 10 : : : 40436 9158 11 kakô kakô NNP 40436 9158 12 = = SYM 40436 9158 13 s s NNP 40436 9158 14 pra pra NNP 40436 9158 15 / / SYM 40436 9158 16 ttein ttein NNP 40436 9158 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9158 18 . . . 40436 9159 1 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 9159 2 has have VBZ 40436 9159 3 well well RB 40436 9159 4 noticed notice VBN 40436 9159 5 the the DT 40436 9159 6 fallacious fallacious JJ 40436 9159 7 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 9159 8 founded found VBN 40436 9159 9 by by IN 40436 9159 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9159 11 on on IN 40436 9159 12 this this DT 40436 9159 13 double double JJ 40436 9159 14 sense sense NN 40436 9159 15 . . . 40436 9160 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9160 2 read read VBP 40436 9160 3 in in IN 40436 9160 4 the the DT 40436 9160 5 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9160 6 , , , 40436 9160 7 p. p. NN 40436 9160 8 507 507 CD 40436 9160 9 C c NN 40436 9160 10 : : : 40436 9160 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9160 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9160 13 : : : 40436 9160 14 a)na a)na NNS 40436 9160 15 / / SYM 40436 9160 16 gkê gkê NN 40436 9160 17 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9160 18 sô sô NNP 40436 9160 19 / / SYM 40436 9160 20 phrona phrona NNP 40436 9160 21 , , , 40436 9160 22 di di NNP 40436 9160 23 / / SYM 40436 9160 24 kaion kaion NNP 40436 9160 25 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 9160 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9160 27 a)ndrei a)ndrei NNP 40436 9160 28 = = SYM 40436 9160 29 on on IN 40436 9160 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9160 31 o(/sion o(/sion NNP 40436 9160 32 , , , 40436 9160 33 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 9160 34 a)/ndra a)/ndra NNP 40436 9160 35 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 9160 36 tele tele NNP 40436 9160 37 / / SYM 40436 9160 38 ôs ôs NNP 40436 9160 39 , , , 40436 9160 40 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9160 41 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9160 42 a)gatho\n a)gatho\n NNP 40436 9160 43 ei)= ei)= VBZ 40436 9160 44 te te NNP 40436 9160 45 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9160 46 kalô kalô NNP 40436 9160 47 = = SYM 40436 9160 48 s s NNP 40436 9160 49 pra pra NNP 40436 9160 50 / / SYM 40436 9160 51 ttein ttein NNP 40436 9160 52 a)\ a)\ XX 40436 9160 53 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 9160 54 pra pra NNP 40436 9160 55 / / SYM 40436 9160 56 ttê| ttê| NN 40436 9160 57 , , , 40436 9160 58 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9160 59 d d NNP 40436 9160 60 ' ' '' 40436 9160 61 eu)= eu)= NN 40436 9160 62 pra pra NNP 40436 9160 63 / / SYM 40436 9160 64 ttonta ttonta NNP 40436 9160 65 maka maka NNP 40436 9160 66 / / SYM 40436 9160 67 rio rio NNP 40436 9160 68 / / SYM 40436 9160 69 n n NNP 40436 9160 70 te te NNP 40436 9160 71 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9160 72 eu)dai eu)dai NNP 40436 9160 73 / / SYM 40436 9160 74 mona mona NNP 40436 9160 75 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 9160 76 , , , 40436 9160 77 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9160 78 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9160 79 ponêro\n ponêro\n -LRB- 40436 9160 80 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9160 81 kakô kakô NNP 40436 9160 82 = = SYM 40436 9160 83 s s NNP 40436 9160 84 pra pra NNP 40436 9160 85 / / SYM 40436 9160 86 ttonta ttonta NNP 40436 9160 87 a)/thlion a)/thlion NNP 40436 9160 88 . . . 40436 9160 89 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9161 1 Upon upon IN 40436 9161 2 which which WDT 40436 9161 3 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 9161 4 remarks remark NNS 40436 9161 5 , , , 40436 9161 6 citing cite VBG 40436 9161 7 a a DT 40436 9161 8 note note NN 40436 9161 9 of of IN 40436 9161 10 Routh Routh NNP 40436 9161 11 , , , 40436 9161 12 who who WP 40436 9161 13 says say VBZ 40436 9161 14 , , , 40436 9161 15 " " `` 40436 9161 16 Vix Vix NNP 40436 9161 17 enim enim NNP 40436 9161 18 potest potest NNP 40436 9161 19 credi credi NNP 40436 9161 20 , , , 40436 9161 21 Platonem Platonem NNP 40436 9161 22 duplici duplici VBD 40436 9161 23 sensu sensu NN 40436 9161 24 verborum verborum NN 40436 9161 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9161 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9161 27 : : : 40436 9161 28 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 9161 29 pra pra NNP 40436 9161 30 / / SYM 40436 9161 31 ttein ttein NN 40436 9161 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9161 33 ad ad NN 40436 9161 34 argumentum argumentum NN 40436 9161 35 probandum probandum NNP 40436 9161 36 abuti abuti NNP 40436 9161 37 voluisse voluisse NNP 40436 9161 38 , , , 40436 9161 39 quæ quæ NNP 40436 9161 40 fallacia fallacia NNP 40436 9161 41 esset esset NNP 40436 9161 42 amphiboliæ amphiboliæ NNP 40436 9161 43 " " '' 40436 9161 44 . . . 40436 9162 1 " " `` 40436 9162 2 Non non JJ 40436 9162 3 meminerat meminerat FW 40436 9162 4 " " '' 40436 9162 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9162 6 says say VBZ 40436 9162 7 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 9162 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9162 9 " " `` 40436 9162 10 vir vir NNP 40436 9162 11 doctus doctus NN 40436 9162 12 ceteros cetero NNS 40436 9162 13 in in IN 40436 9162 14 Platone Platone NNP 40436 9162 15 locos locos NNP 40436 9162 16 , , , 40436 9162 17 ubi ubi NNP 40436 9162 18 eodem eodem NNP 40436 9162 19 modo modo NNP 40436 9162 20 ex ex NNP 40436 9162 21 duplici duplici VBD 40436 9162 22 illâ illâ JJ 40436 9162 23 potestate potestate NNP 40436 9162 24 argumentatio argumentatio NNP 40436 9162 25 ducitur ducitur NNP 40436 9162 26 , , , 40436 9162 27 cujusmodi cujusmodi NNP 40436 9162 28 plura plura NNP 40436 9162 29 attulimus attulimus NNP 40436 9162 30 ad ad NN 40436 9162 31 Charmidem Charmidem NNP 40436 9162 32 , , , 40436 9162 33 42 42 CD 40436 9162 34 , , , 40436 9162 35 p. p. NN 40436 9162 36 172 172 CD 40436 9162 37 A. a. NN 40436 9162 38 " " '' 40436 9163 1 Heindorf heindorf NN 40436 9163 2 observes observe VBZ 40436 9163 3 , , , 40436 9163 4 on on IN 40436 9163 5 the the DT 40436 9163 6 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 9163 7 l. l. NNP 40436 9163 8 c. c. NNP 40436 9163 9 : : : 40436 9163 10 " " `` 40436 9163 11 Argumenti Argumenti NNP 40436 9163 12 hujus hujus NNP 40436 9163 13 vim vim JJ 40436 9163 14 positam positam NNP 40436 9163 15 apparet apparet NNP 40436 9163 16 in in IN 40436 9163 17 duplici duplici NNP 40436 9163 18 dictionis dictionis NNP 40436 9163 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9163 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9163 21 : : : 40436 9163 22 eu)= eu)= NNP 40436 9163 23 pra pra NNP 40436 9163 24 / / SYM 40436 9163 25 ttein ttein NNP 40436 9163 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9163 27 significatu significatu NNP 40436 9163 28 : : : 40436 9163 29 quum quum NNP 40436 9163 30 vulgo vulgo NNP 40436 9163 31 sit sit NNP 40436 9163 32 _ _ NNP 40436 9163 33 felicem felicem NNP 40436 9163 34 esse esse NNP 40436 9163 35 _ _ NNP 40436 9163 36 , , , 40436 9163 37 non non AFX 40436 9163 38 _ _ NNP 40436 9163 39 recté recté NN 40436 9163 40 facere facere RB 40436 9163 41 _ _ NNP 40436 9163 42 . . . 40436 9164 1 Hoc hoc JJ 40436 9164 2 aliaque aliaque NN 40436 9164 3 ejusdem ejusdem NNP 40436 9164 4 generis generis NNP 40436 9164 5 sæpius sæpius NNP 40436 9164 6 sic sic NN 40436 9164 7 ansam ansam NNP 40436 9164 8 præbuerunt præbuerunt VBP 40436 9164 9 sophismatis sophismatis NNP 40436 9164 10 magis magis NNP 40436 9164 11 quam quam NNP 40436 9164 12 justi justi NNP 40436 9164 13 syllogismi syllogismi NNP 40436 9164 14 . . . 40436 9164 15 " " '' 40436 9165 1 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 9165 2 then then RB 40436 9165 3 refers refer VBZ 40436 9165 4 to to IN 40436 9165 5 analogous analogous JJ 40436 9165 6 passages passage NNS 40436 9165 7 in in IN 40436 9165 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9165 9 , , , 40436 9165 10 Repub Repub NNP 40436 9165 11 . . . 40436 9166 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9166 2 p. p. NN 40436 9166 3 354 354 CD 40436 9166 4 A a NN 40436 9166 5 : : : 40436 9166 6 Alkib Alkib NNP 40436 9166 7 . . . 40436 9167 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9167 2 p. p. NN 40436 9167 3 116 116 CD 40436 9167 4 B B NNP 40436 9167 5 , , , 40436 9167 6 p. p. NN 40436 9167 7 134 134 CD 40436 9167 8 A. a. NN 40436 9168 1 A a DT 40436 9168 2 similar similar JJ 40436 9168 3 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 9168 4 is be VBZ 40436 9168 5 found find VBN 40436 9168 6 in in IN 40436 9168 7 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 9168 8 , , , 40436 9168 9 Politic Politic NNP 40436 9168 10 . . . 40436 9169 1 vii vii NN 40436 9169 2 . . . 40436 9170 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9170 2 p. p. NNP 40436 9170 3 1323 1323 CD 40436 9170 4 , , , 40436 9170 5 a. a. NN 40436 9171 1 17 17 CD 40436 9171 2 , , , 40436 9171 3 b. b. NNP 40436 9172 1 32 32 CD 40436 9172 2 - - HYPH 40436 9172 3 -[Greek -[greek NN 40436 9172 4 : : : 40436 9172 5 a)/rista a)/rista NFP 40436 9172 6 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9172 7 pra pra NNP 40436 9172 8 / / SYM 40436 9172 9 ttein ttein NNP 40436 9172 10 prosê prosê NNP 40436 9172 11 / / SYM 40436 9172 12 kei kei NNP 40436 9172 13 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 9172 14 a)/rista a)/rista CD 40436 9172 15 politeuome politeuome JJ 40436 9172 16 / / SYM 40436 9172 17 nous nous JJ 40436 9172 18 -- -- : 40436 9172 19 a)du a)du JJ 40436 9172 20 / / SYM 40436 9172 21 naton naton NNP 40436 9172 22 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9172 23 kalô kalô NNP 40436 9172 24 = = SYM 40436 9172 25 s s NNP 40436 9172 26 pra pra NNP 40436 9172 27 / / SYM 40436 9172 28 ttein ttein NNP 40436 9172 29 toi toi NNP 40436 9172 30 = = SYM 40436 9172 31 s s NNP 40436 9172 32 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 9172 33 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 9172 34 kala\ kala\ NNP 40436 9172 35 pra pra NNP 40436 9172 36 / / SYM 40436 9172 37 ttousin ttousin NNP 40436 9172 38 . . . 40436 9172 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9173 1 This this DT 40436 9173 2 fallacy fallacy NN 40436 9173 3 is be VBZ 40436 9173 4 recognised recognise VBN 40436 9173 5 and and CC 40436 9173 6 properly properly RB 40436 9173 7 commented comment VBN 40436 9173 8 on on IN 40436 9173 9 as as IN 40436 9173 10 a a DT 40436 9173 11 " " `` 40436 9173 12 logisches logische VBZ 40436 9173 13 Wortspiel Wortspiel NNP 40436 9173 14 , , , 40436 9173 15 " " '' 40436 9173 16 by by IN 40436 9173 17 Bernays Bernays NNP 40436 9173 18 , , , 40436 9173 19 in in IN 40436 9173 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9173 21 instructive instructive JJ 40436 9173 22 volume volume NN 40436 9173 23 , , , 40436 9173 24 _ _ NNP 40436 9173 25 Die Die NNP 40436 9173 26 * * NFP 40436 9173 27 * * NFP 40436 9173 28 Dialoge Dialoge NNP 40436 9173 29 des des NNP 40436 9173 30 Aristoteles Aristoteles NNP 40436 9173 31 _ _ NNP 40436 9173 32 , , , 40436 9173 33 pp pp NNP 40436 9173 34 . . . 40436 9174 1 80 80 CD 40436 9174 2 - - SYM 40436 9174 3 81 81 CD 40436 9174 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9174 5 Berlin Berlin NNP 40436 9174 6 , , , 40436 9174 7 1863 1863 CD 40436 9174 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9174 9 . . . 40436 9174 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9175 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9175 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9175 3 87 87 CD 40436 9175 4 : : : 40436 9175 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9175 6 , , , 40436 9175 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9175 8 , , , 40436 9175 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9175 10 . . . 40436 9176 1 481 481 CD 40436 9176 2 D d NN 40436 9176 3 , , , 40436 9176 4 482 482 CD 40436 9176 5 B. b. NN 40436 9176 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9177 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9177 2 Side side NN 40436 9177 3 - - HYPH 40436 9177 4 note note NN 40436 9177 5 : : : 40436 9177 6 Permanent permanent JJ 40436 9177 7 elements element NNS 40436 9177 8 -- -- : 40436 9177 9 and and CC 40436 9177 10 transient transient JJ 40436 9177 11 elements element NNS 40436 9177 12 -- -- : 40436 9177 13 of of IN 40436 9177 14 human human JJ 40436 9177 15 agency agency NN 40436 9177 16 -- -- : 40436 9177 17 how how WRB 40436 9177 18 each each DT 40436 9177 19 of of IN 40436 9177 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9177 21 is be VBZ 40436 9177 22 appreciated appreciate VBN 40436 9177 23 in in IN 40436 9177 24 the the DT 40436 9177 25 two two CD 40436 9177 26 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9177 27 . . . 40436 9177 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9178 1 Lastly lastly RB 40436 9178 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9178 3 will will MD 40436 9178 4 compare compare VB 40436 9178 5 the the DT 40436 9178 6 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9178 7 and and CC 40436 9178 8 the the DT 40436 9178 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9178 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9178 11 meaning mean VBG 40436 9178 12 always always RB 40436 9178 13 , , , 40436 9178 14 the the DT 40436 9178 15 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 9178 16 of of IN 40436 9178 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9178 18 in in IN 40436 9178 19 each each DT 40436 9178 20 of of IN 40436 9178 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9178 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9178 23 under under IN 40436 9178 24 one one CD 40436 9178 25 more more JJR 40436 9178 26 point point NN 40436 9178 27 of of IN 40436 9178 28 view view NN 40436 9178 29 . . . 40436 9179 1 How how WRB 40436 9179 2 does do VBZ 40436 9179 3 each each DT 40436 9179 4 of of IN 40436 9179 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9179 6 describe describe VBP 40436 9179 7 and and CC 40436 9179 8 distinguish distinguish VBP 40436 9179 9 the the DT 40436 9179 10 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9179 11 elements element NNS 40436 9179 12 , , , 40436 9179 13 and and CC 40436 9179 14 the the DT 40436 9179 15 transient transient JJ 40436 9179 16 elements element NNS 40436 9179 17 , , , 40436 9179 18 involved involve VBN 40436 9179 19 in in IN 40436 9179 20 human human JJ 40436 9179 21 agency agency NN 40436 9179 22 ? ? . 40436 9180 1 What what WDT 40436 9180 2 function function NN 40436 9180 3 does do VBZ 40436 9180 4 each each DT 40436 9180 5 of of IN 40436 9180 6 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9180 7 assign assign VBP 40436 9180 8 to to IN 40436 9180 9 the the DT 40436 9180 10 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9180 11 element element NN 40436 9180 12 ? ? . 40436 9181 1 The the DT 40436 9181 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 9181 3 of of IN 40436 9181 4 these these DT 40436 9181 5 two two CD 40436 9181 6 is be VBZ 40436 9181 7 important important JJ 40436 9181 8 in in IN 40436 9181 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9181 10 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9181 11 bearing bearing NN 40436 9181 12 . . . 40436 9182 1 The the DT 40436 9182 2 whole whole JJ 40436 9182 3 life life NN 40436 9182 4 both both DT 40436 9182 5 of of IN 40436 9182 6 the the DT 40436 9182 7 individual individual NN 40436 9182 8 and and CC 40436 9182 9 of of IN 40436 9182 10 society society NN 40436 9182 11 consists consist VBZ 40436 9182 12 of of IN 40436 9182 13 successive successive JJ 40436 9182 14 moments moment NNS 40436 9182 15 of of IN 40436 9182 16 action action NN 40436 9182 17 or or CC 40436 9182 18 feeling feeling NN 40436 9182 19 . . . 40436 9183 1 But but CC 40436 9183 2 each each DT 40436 9183 3 individual individual NN 40436 9183 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9183 5 and and CC 40436 9183 6 the the DT 40436 9183 7 society society NN 40436 9183 8 as as IN 40436 9183 9 an an DT 40436 9183 10 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 9183 11 of of IN 40436 9183 12 individuals individual NNS 40436 9183 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9183 14 has have VBZ 40436 9183 15 within within IN 40436 9183 16 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9183 17 embodied embody VBN 40436 9183 18 and and CC 40436 9183 19 realised realise VBD 40436 9183 20 an an DT 40436 9183 21 element element NN 40436 9183 22 more more RBR 40436 9183 23 or or CC 40436 9183 24 less less RBR 40436 9183 25 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9183 26 -- -- : 40436 9183 27 an an DT 40436 9183 28 established establish VBN 40436 9183 29 character character NN 40436 9183 30 , , , 40436 9183 31 habits habit NNS 40436 9183 32 , , , 40436 9183 33 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 9183 34 , , , 40436 9183 35 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9183 36 acquirements acquirement NNS 40436 9183 37 , , , 40436 9183 38 & & CC 40436 9183 39 c.--a c.--a NNP 40436 9183 40 sort sort RB 40436 9183 41 of of IN 40436 9183 42 capital capital NN 40436 9183 43 accumulated accumulate VBN 40436 9183 44 from from IN 40436 9183 45 the the DT 40436 9183 46 past past NN 40436 9183 47 . . . 40436 9184 1 This this DT 40436 9184 2 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9184 3 element element NN 40436 9184 4 is be VBZ 40436 9184 5 of of IN 40436 9184 6 extreme extreme JJ 40436 9184 7 importance importance NN 40436 9184 8 . . . 40436 9185 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9185 2 stands stand VBZ 40436 9185 3 to to IN 40436 9185 4 the the DT 40436 9185 5 transient transient JJ 40436 9185 6 element element NN 40436 9185 7 in in IN 40436 9185 8 the the DT 40436 9185 9 same same JJ 40436 9185 10 relation relation NN 40436 9185 11 as as IN 40436 9185 12 the the DT 40436 9185 13 fixed fix VBN 40436 9185 14 capital capital NN 40436 9185 15 of of IN 40436 9185 16 a a DT 40436 9185 17 trader trader NN 40436 9185 18 or or CC 40436 9185 19 manufacturer manufacturer NN 40436 9185 20 to to IN 40436 9185 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9185 22 annual annual JJ 40436 9185 23 produce produce NN 40436 9185 24 . . . 40436 9186 1 The the DT 40436 9186 2 whole whole JJ 40436 9186 3 use use NN 40436 9186 4 and and CC 40436 9186 5 value value NN 40436 9186 6 of of IN 40436 9186 7 the the DT 40436 9186 8 fixed fix VBN 40436 9186 9 capital capital NN 40436 9186 10 , , , 40436 9186 11 of of IN 40436 9186 12 which which WDT 40436 9186 13 the the DT 40436 9186 14 skill skill NN 40436 9186 15 and and CC 40436 9186 16 energy energy NN 40436 9186 17 of of IN 40436 9186 18 the the DT 40436 9186 19 trader trader NN 40436 9186 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9186 21 make make VBP 40436 9186 22 an an DT 40436 9186 23 important important JJ 40436 9186 24 part part NN 40436 9186 25 , , , 40436 9186 26 consists consist VBZ 40436 9186 27 in in IN 40436 9186 28 the the DT 40436 9186 29 amount amount NN 40436 9186 30 of of IN 40436 9186 31 produce produce NN 40436 9186 32 which which WDT 40436 9186 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9186 34 will will MD 40436 9186 35 yield yield VB 40436 9186 36 : : : 40436 9186 37 but but CC 40436 9186 38 at at IN 40436 9186 39 the the DT 40436 9186 40 same same JJ 40436 9186 41 time time NN 40436 9186 42 the the DT 40436 9186 43 trader trader NN 40436 9186 44 must must MD 40436 9186 45 keep keep VB 40436 9186 46 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9186 47 up up RP 40436 9186 48 in in IN 40436 9186 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9186 50 condition condition NN 40436 9186 51 of of IN 40436 9186 52 fixed fix VBN 40436 9186 53 capital capital NN 40436 9186 54 , , , 40436 9186 55 in in IN 40436 9186 56 order order NN 40436 9186 57 to to TO 40436 9186 58 obtain obtain VB 40436 9186 59 such such JJ 40436 9186 60 amount amount NN 40436 9186 61 : : : 40436 9186 62 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9186 63 must must MD 40436 9186 64 set set VB 40436 9186 65 apart apart RB 40436 9186 66 , , , 40436 9186 67 and and CC 40436 9186 68 abstain abstain VB 40436 9186 69 from from IN 40436 9186 70 devoting devote VBG 40436 9186 71 to to IN 40436 9186 72 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9186 73 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9186 74 , , , 40436 9186 75 as as IN 40436 9186 76 much much JJ 40436 9186 77 of of IN 40436 9186 78 the the DT 40436 9186 79 annual annual JJ 40436 9186 80 produce produce NN 40436 9186 81 as as IN 40436 9186 82 will will MD 40436 9186 83 suffice suffice VB 40436 9186 84 to to TO 40436 9186 85 maintain maintain VB 40436 9186 86 the the DT 40436 9186 87 fixed fix VBN 40436 9186 88 capital capital NN 40436 9186 89 unimpaired unimpaired JJ 40436 9186 90 -- -- : 40436 9186 91 and and CC 40436 9186 92 more more JJR 40436 9186 93 , , , 40436 9186 94 if if IN 40436 9186 95 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9186 96 desires desire VBZ 40436 9186 97 to to TO 40436 9186 98 improve improve VB 40436 9186 99 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9186 100 condition condition NN 40436 9186 101 . . . 40436 9187 1 The the DT 40436 9187 2 capital capital NN 40436 9187 3 can can MD 40436 9187 4 not not RB 40436 9187 5 be be VB 40436 9187 6 commuted commute VBN 40436 9187 7 into into IN 40436 9187 8 interest interest NN 40436 9187 9 ; ; : 40436 9187 10 yet yet CC 40436 9187 11 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 9187 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9187 13 whole whole JJ 40436 9187 14 value value NN 40436 9187 15 depends depend VBZ 40436 9187 16 upon upon IN 40436 9187 17 , , , 40436 9187 18 and and CC 40436 9187 19 is be VBZ 40436 9187 20 measured measure VBN 40436 9187 21 by by IN 40436 9187 22 , , , 40436 9187 23 the the DT 40436 9187 24 interest interest NN 40436 9187 25 which which WDT 40436 9187 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9187 27 yields yield VBZ 40436 9187 28 . . . 40436 9188 1 Doubtless doubtless RB 40436 9188 2 the the DT 40436 9188 3 mere mere JJ 40436 9188 4 idea idea NN 40436 9188 5 of of IN 40436 9188 6 possessing possess VBG 40436 9188 7 the the DT 40436 9188 8 capital capital NN 40436 9188 9 is be VBZ 40436 9188 10 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9188 11 to to IN 40436 9188 12 the the DT 40436 9188 13 possessor possessor NN 40436 9188 14 , , , 40436 9188 15 because because IN 40436 9188 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9188 17 knows know VBZ 40436 9188 18 that that IN 40436 9188 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9188 20 can can MD 40436 9188 21 and and CC 40436 9188 22 will will MD 40436 9188 23 be be VB 40436 9188 24 profitably profitably RB 40436 9188 25 employed employ VBN 40436 9188 26 , , , 40436 9188 27 so so RB 40436 9188 28 long long RB 40436 9188 29 as as IN 40436 9188 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9188 31 chooses choose VBZ 40436 9188 32 . . . 40436 9189 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9189 2 Side side NN 40436 9189 3 - - HYPH 40436 9189 4 note note NN 40436 9189 5 : : : 40436 9189 6 In in IN 40436 9189 7 the the DT 40436 9189 8 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9189 9 . . . 40436 9189 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9190 1 Now now RB 40436 9190 2 in in IN 40436 9190 3 the the DT 40436 9190 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9190 5 , , , 40436 9190 6 the the DT 40436 9190 7 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9190 8 element element NN 40436 9190 9 is be VBZ 40436 9190 10 very very RB 40436 9190 11 pointedly pointedly RB 40436 9190 12 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 9190 13 from from IN 40436 9190 14 the the DT 40436 9190 15 transient transient NN 40436 9190 16 , , , 40436 9190 17 and and CC 40436 9190 18 is be VBZ 40436 9190 19 called call VBN 40436 9190 20 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9190 21 -- -- : 40436 9190 22 the the DT 40436 9190 23 Science science NN 40436 9190 24 or or CC 40436 9190 25 Art Art NNP 40436 9190 26 of of IN 40436 9190 27 Calculation Calculation NNP 40436 9190 28 . . . 40436 9191 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9191 2 function function NN 40436 9191 3 also also RB 40436 9191 4 is be VBZ 40436 9191 5 clearly clearly RB 40436 9191 6 announced announce VBN 40436 9191 7 -- -- : 40436 9191 8 to to TO 40436 9191 9 take take VB 40436 9191 10 comparative comparative JJ 40436 9191 11 estimate estimate NN 40436 9191 12 and and CC 40436 9191 13 measurement measurement NN 40436 9191 14 of of IN 40436 9191 15 the the DT 40436 9191 16 transient transient JJ 40436 9191 17 elements element NNS 40436 9191 18 ; ; : 40436 9191 19 which which WDT 40436 9191 20 are be VBP 40436 9191 21 stated state VBN 40436 9191 22 to to TO 40436 9191 23 consist consist VB 40436 9191 24 of of IN 40436 9191 25 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9191 26 and and CC 40436 9191 27 pains pain NNS 40436 9191 28 , , , 40436 9191 29 present present JJ 40436 9191 30 and and CC 40436 9191 31 future future NN 40436 9191 32 -- -- : 40436 9191 33 near near JJ 40436 9191 34 and and CC 40436 9191 35 distant distant JJ 40436 9191 36 -- -- : 40436 9191 37 certain certain JJ 40436 9191 38 and and CC 40436 9191 39 uncertain uncertain JJ 40436 9191 40 -- -- : 40436 9191 41 faint faint JJ 40436 9191 42 and and CC 40436 9191 43 strong strong JJ 40436 9191 44 . . . 40436 9192 1 To to IN 40436 9192 2 these these DT 40436 9192 3 elements element NNS 40436 9192 4 , , , 40436 9192 5 manifold manifold JJ 40436 9192 6 yet yet CC 40436 9192 7 commensurable commensurable JJ 40436 9192 8 , , , 40436 9192 9 the the DT 40436 9192 10 calculation calculation NN 40436 9192 11 is be VBZ 40436 9192 12 to to TO 40436 9192 13 apply apply VB 40436 9192 14 . . . 40436 9193 1 " " `` 40436 9193 2 The the DT 40436 9193 3 safety safety NN 40436 9193 4 of of IN 40436 9193 5 life life NN 40436 9193 6 " " '' 40436 9193 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9193 8 says say VBZ 40436 9193 9 Sokrates[88 sokrates[88 ADD 40436 9193 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9193 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9193 12 " " `` 40436 9193 13 resides reside VBZ 40436 9193 14 in in IN 40436 9193 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9193 16 keeping keep VBG 40436 9193 17 up up RP 40436 9193 18 this this DT 40436 9193 19 science science NN 40436 9193 20 or or CC 40436 9193 21 art art NN 40436 9193 22 of of IN 40436 9193 23 calculation calculation NN 40436 9193 24 . . . 40436 9193 25 " " '' 40436 9194 1 No no DT 40436 9194 2 present present JJ 40436 9194 3 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9194 4 must must MD 40436 9194 5 be be VB 40436 9194 6 admitted admit VBN 40436 9194 7 , , , 40436 9194 8 which which WDT 40436 9194 9 would would MD 40436 9194 10 impair impair VB 40436 9194 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9194 12 ; ; : 40436 9194 13 no no DT 40436 9194 14 present present JJ 40436 9194 15 pain pain NN 40436 9194 16 must must MD 40436 9194 17 be be VB 40436 9194 18 shunned shun VBN 40436 9194 19 , , , 40436 9194 20 which which WDT 40436 9194 21 is be VBZ 40436 9194 22 essential essential JJ 40436 9194 23 to to TO 40436 9194 24 uphold uphold VB 40436 9194 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9194 26 . . . 40436 9195 1 Yet yet CC 40436 9195 2 the the DT 40436 9195 3 whole whole NN 40436 9195 4 of of IN 40436 9195 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9195 6 value value NN 40436 9195 7 resides reside VBZ 40436 9195 8 in in IN 40436 9195 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9195 10 application application NN 40436 9195 11 to to IN 40436 9195 12 the the DT 40436 9195 13 comparison comparison NN 40436 9195 14 of of IN 40436 9195 15 the the DT 40436 9195 16 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9195 17 and and CC 40436 9195 18 pains pain NNS 40436 9195 19 . . . 40436 9196 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9196 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9196 3 88 88 CD 40436 9196 4 : : : 40436 9196 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9196 6 , , , 40436 9196 7 Protag Protag NNP 40436 9196 8 . . . 40436 9197 1 p. p. NN 40436 9197 2 357 357 CD 40436 9197 3 A. a. NN 40436 9198 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9198 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9198 3 : : : 40436 9198 4 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ JJ 40436 9198 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9198 6 ê(donê ê(donê NNP 40436 9198 7 = = NFP 40436 9198 8 s s NNP 40436 9198 9 te te NNP 40436 9198 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9198 11 lu lu NNP 40436 9198 12 / / SYM 40436 9198 13 pês pês NN 40436 9198 14 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9198 15 o)rthê=| o)rthê=| ADD 40436 9198 16 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 9198 17 ai(re ai(re NNP 40436 9198 18 / / SYM 40436 9198 19 sei sei NN 40436 9198 20 e)pha e)pha NNPS 40436 9198 21 / / SYM 40436 9198 22 nê nê RB 40436 9198 23 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 9198 24 = = SYM 40436 9198 25 n n CC 40436 9198 26 ê ê NNP 40436 9198 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9198 28 sôtêri sôtêri NNP 40436 9198 29 / / , 40436 9198 30 a a DT 40436 9198 31 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9198 32 bi bi NN 40436 9198 33 / / SYM 40436 9198 34 ou ou NNP 40436 9198 35 ou)=sa ou)=sa NNP 40436 9198 36 , , , 40436 9198 37 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9198 38 te te NNP 40436 9198 39 ple ple NNP 40436 9198 40 / / SYM 40436 9198 41 onos onos NNP 40436 9198 42 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9198 43 e)lattonos e)lattonos CD 40436 9198 44 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9198 45 mei mei NNP 40436 9198 46 / / SYM 40436 9198 47 zonos zonos NNP 40436 9198 48 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9198 49 smikrote smikrote NNP 40436 9198 50 / / SYM 40436 9198 51 rou rou NNP 40436 9198 52 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9198 53 por)r(ôte por)r(ôte , 40436 9198 54 / / SYM 40436 9198 55 rô rô NNP 40436 9198 56 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9198 57 e)ggute e)ggute , 40436 9198 58 / / SYM 40436 9198 59 rô rô NNP 40436 9198 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9198 61 , , , 40436 9198 62 & & CC 40436 9198 63 c. c. NNP 40436 9198 64 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9198 65 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9198 66 Side side NN 40436 9198 67 - - HYPH 40436 9198 68 note note NN 40436 9198 69 : : : 40436 9198 70 In in IN 40436 9198 71 the the DT 40436 9198 72 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9198 73 . . . 40436 9198 74 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9199 1 In in IN 40436 9199 2 the the DT 40436 9199 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9199 4 the the DT 40436 9199 5 same same JJ 40436 9199 6 two two CD 40436 9199 7 elements element NNS 40436 9199 8 are be VBP 40436 9199 9 differently differently RB 40436 9199 10 described describe VBN 40436 9199 11 , , , 40436 9199 12 and and CC 40436 9199 13 less less RBR 40436 9199 14 clearly clearly RB 40436 9199 15 explained explain VBN 40436 9199 16 . . . 40436 9200 1 The the DT 40436 9200 2 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9200 3 is be VBZ 40436 9200 4 termed term VBN 40436 9200 5 , , , 40436 9200 6 Order order NN 40436 9200 7 , , , 40436 9200 8 arrangement arrangement NN 40436 9200 9 , , , 40436 9200 10 discipline discipline NN 40436 9200 11 , , , 40436 9200 12 a a DT 40436 9200 13 lawful lawful JJ 40436 9200 14 , , , 40436 9200 15 just just RB 40436 9200 16 , , , 40436 9200 17 and and CC 40436 9200 18 temperate temperate VB 40436 9200 19 , , , 40436 9200 20 cast cast VBN 40436 9200 21 of of IN 40436 9200 22 mind mind NN 40436 9200 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9200 24 opposed opposed JJ 40436 9200 25 to to IN 40436 9200 26 the the DT 40436 9200 27 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9200 28 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 9200 29 to to IN 40436 9200 30 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNP 40436 9200 31 , , , 40436 9200 32 which which WDT 40436 9200 33 negatived negative VBD 40436 9200 34 this this DT 40436 9200 35 element element NN 40436 9200 36 altogether altogether RB 40436 9200 37 , , , 40436 9200 38 in in IN 40436 9200 39 the the DT 40436 9200 40 mind mind NN 40436 9200 41 of of IN 40436 9200 42 the the DT 40436 9200 43 despot despot NN 40436 9200 44 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9200 45 , , , 40436 9200 46 parallel parallel JJ 40436 9200 47 to to IN 40436 9200 48 health health NN 40436 9200 49 and and CC 40436 9200 50 strength strength NN 40436 9200 51 of of IN 40436 9200 52 body body NN 40436 9200 53 : : : 40436 9200 54 the the DT 40436 9200 55 unordered unordered JJ 40436 9200 56 mind mind NN 40436 9200 57 is be VBZ 40436 9200 58 again again RB 40436 9200 59 the the DT 40436 9200 60 parallel parallel NN 40436 9200 61 of of IN 40436 9200 62 the the DT 40436 9200 63 corrupt corrupt JJ 40436 9200 64 , , , 40436 9200 65 distempered distemper VBN 40436 9200 66 , , , 40436 9200 67 helpless helpless JJ 40436 9200 68 , , , 40436 9200 69 body body NN 40436 9200 70 ; ; : 40436 9200 71 life life NN 40436 9200 72 is be VBZ 40436 9200 73 not not RB 40436 9200 74 worth worth JJ 40436 9200 75 having have VBG 40436 9200 76 until until IN 40436 9200 77 this this DT 40436 9200 78 is be VBZ 40436 9200 79 cured cure VBN 40436 9200 80 . . . 40436 9201 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9201 2 89 89 CD 40436 9201 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9201 4 This this DT 40436 9201 5 corresponds correspond VBZ 40436 9201 6 to to IN 40436 9201 7 the the DT 40436 9201 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9201 9 or or CC 40436 9201 10 Calculating Calculating NNP 40436 9201 11 Science Science NNP 40436 9201 12 in in IN 40436 9201 13 the the DT 40436 9201 14 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9201 15 ; ; : 40436 9201 16 but but CC 40436 9201 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9201 18 can can MD 40436 9201 19 not not RB 40436 9201 20 understand understand VB 40436 9201 21 what what WP 40436 9201 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9201 23 function function NN 40436 9201 24 is be VBZ 40436 9201 25 , , , 40436 9201 26 in in IN 40436 9201 27 the the DT 40436 9201 28 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9201 29 , , , 40436 9201 30 because because IN 40436 9201 31 the the DT 40436 9201 32 calculable calculable JJ 40436 9201 33 elements element NNS 40436 9201 34 are be VBP 40436 9201 35 incompletely incompletely RB 40436 9201 36 enumerated enumerate VBN 40436 9201 37 . . . 40436 9202 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9202 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9202 3 89 89 CD 40436 9202 4 : : : 40436 9202 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9202 6 , , , 40436 9202 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9202 8 , , , 40436 9202 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9202 10 . . . 40436 9203 1 504 504 CD 40436 9203 2 B B NNP 40436 9203 3 - - HYPH 40436 9203 4 C C NNP 40436 9203 5 , , , 40436 9203 6 506 506 CD 40436 9203 7 D D NNP 40436 9203 8 - - HYPH 40436 9203 9 E. e. NN 40436 9203 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9203 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9203 12 : : : 40436 9203 13 Ta Ta NNP 40436 9203 14 / / SYM 40436 9203 15 xis xis NNP 40436 9203 16 -- -- : 40436 9203 17 ko ko NNP 40436 9203 18 / / SYM 40436 9203 19 smos smos NNP 40436 9203 20 -- -- : 40436 9203 21 psuchê\ psuchê\ NNP 40436 9203 22 kosmi kosmi NNP 40436 9203 23 / / , 40436 9203 24 a a DT 40436 9203 25 a)mei a)mei ADD 40436 9203 26 / / SYM 40436 9203 27 nôn nôn NNP 40436 9203 28 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9203 29 a)kosmê a)kosmê NNP 40436 9203 30 / / SYM 40436 9203 31 tou tou NNP 40436 9203 32 . . . 40436 9203 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9203 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9204 1 In in IN 40436 9204 2 the the DT 40436 9204 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9204 4 , , , 40436 9204 5 these these DT 40436 9204 6 calculable calculable JJ 40436 9204 7 elements element NNS 40436 9204 8 are be VBP 40436 9204 9 two two CD 40436 9204 10 - - HYPH 40436 9204 11 fold fold JJ 40436 9204 12 -- -- : 40436 9204 13 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9204 14 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9204 15 and and CC 40436 9204 16 pains pain NNS 40436 9204 17 -- -- : 40436 9204 18 and and CC 40436 9204 19 future future JJ 40436 9204 20 or or CC 40436 9204 21 distant distant JJ 40436 9204 22 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9204 23 and and CC 40436 9204 24 pains pain NNS 40436 9204 25 . . . 40436 9205 1 Between between IN 40436 9205 2 these these DT 40436 9205 3 two two CD 40436 9205 4 there there EX 40436 9205 5 is be VBZ 40436 9205 6 intercommunity intercommunity NN 40436 9205 7 of of IN 40436 9205 8 nature nature NN 40436 9205 9 , , , 40436 9205 10 so so IN 40436 9205 11 that that IN 40436 9205 12 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9205 13 are be VBP 40436 9205 14 quite quite RB 40436 9205 15 commensurable commensurable JJ 40436 9205 16 ; ; : 40436 9205 17 and and CC 40436 9205 18 the the DT 40436 9205 19 function function NN 40436 9205 20 of of IN 40436 9205 21 the the DT 40436 9205 22 calculating calculate VBG 40436 9205 23 reason reason NN 40436 9205 24 is be VBZ 40436 9205 25 , , , 40436 9205 26 to to TO 40436 9205 27 make make VB 40436 9205 28 a a DT 40436 9205 29 right right JJ 40436 9205 30 estimate estimate NN 40436 9205 31 of of IN 40436 9205 32 the the DT 40436 9205 33 one one NN 40436 9205 34 against against IN 40436 9205 35 the the DT 40436 9205 36 other other JJ 40436 9205 37 . . . 40436 9206 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9206 2 90 90 CD 40436 9206 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9206 4 But but CC 40436 9206 5 in in IN 40436 9206 6 the the DT 40436 9206 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9206 8 , , , 40436 9206 9 no no DT 40436 9206 10 mention mention NN 40436 9206 11 is be VBZ 40436 9206 12 made make VBN 40436 9206 13 of of IN 40436 9206 14 future future JJ 40436 9206 15 or or CC 40436 9206 16 distant distant JJ 40436 9206 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9206 18 and and CC 40436 9206 19 pains pain NNS 40436 9206 20 : : : 40436 9206 21 the the DT 40436 9206 22 calculable calculable JJ 40436 9206 23 element element NN 40436 9206 24 is be VBZ 40436 9206 25 represented represent VBN 40436 9206 26 only only RB 40436 9206 27 by by IN 40436 9206 28 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9206 29 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9206 30 or or CC 40436 9206 31 pain pain NN 40436 9206 32 -- -- : 40436 9206 33 and and CC 40436 9206 34 from from IN 40436 9206 35 thence thence NN 40436 9206 36 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9206 37 pass pass VBP 40436 9206 38 at at IN 40436 9206 39 once once RB 40436 9206 40 to to IN 40436 9206 41 the the DT 40436 9206 42 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9206 43 calculator calculator NN 40436 9206 44 -- -- : 40436 9206 45 the the DT 40436 9206 46 mind mind NN 40436 9206 47 , , , 40436 9206 48 sound sound JJ 40436 9206 49 or or CC 40436 9206 50 corrupt corrupt JJ 40436 9206 51 . . . 40436 9207 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 9207 2 must must MD 40436 9207 3 abstain abstain VB 40436 9207 4 from from IN 40436 9207 5 a a DT 40436 9207 6 particular particular JJ 40436 9207 7 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9207 8 , , , 40436 9207 9 because because IN 40436 9207 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9207 11 will will MD 40436 9207 12 taint taint VB 40436 9207 13 the the DT 40436 9207 14 soundness soundness NN 40436 9207 15 of of IN 40436 9207 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9207 17 mind mind NN 40436 9207 18 : : : 40436 9207 19 this this DT 40436 9207 20 is be VBZ 40436 9207 21 a a DT 40436 9207 22 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 9207 23 reason reason NN 40436 9207 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9207 25 and and CC 40436 9207 26 would would MD 40436 9207 27 be be VB 40436 9207 28 admitted admit VBN 40436 9207 29 as as IN 40436 9207 30 such such JJ 40436 9207 31 by by IN 40436 9207 32 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9207 33 in in IN 40436 9207 34 the the DT 40436 9207 35 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9207 36 , , , 40436 9207 37 who who WP 40436 9207 38 instead instead RB 40436 9207 39 of of IN 40436 9207 40 sound sound JJ 40436 9207 41 mind mind NN 40436 9207 42 would would MD 40436 9207 43 say say VB 40436 9207 44 , , , 40436 9207 45 calculating calculate VBG 40436 9207 46 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 9207 47 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9207 48 , , , 40436 9207 49 but but CC 40436 9207 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9207 51 is be VBZ 40436 9207 52 neither neither CC 40436 9207 53 the the DT 40436 9207 54 ultimate ultimate JJ 40436 9207 55 reason reason NN 40436 9207 56 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9207 57 since since IN 40436 9207 58 this this DT 40436 9207 59 soundness soundness NN 40436 9207 60 of of IN 40436 9207 61 mind mind NN 40436 9207 62 is be VBZ 40436 9207 63 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9207 64 valuable valuable JJ 40436 9207 65 with with IN 40436 9207 66 a a DT 40436 9207 67 view view NN 40436 9207 68 to to IN 40436 9207 69 future future JJ 40436 9207 70 calculations calculation NNS 40436 9207 71 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9207 72 , , , 40436 9207 73 nor nor CC 40436 9207 74 the the DT 40436 9207 75 only only JJ 40436 9207 76 reason reason NN 40436 9207 77 : : : 40436 9207 78 for for IN 40436 9207 79 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9207 80 must must MD 40436 9207 81 also also RB 40436 9207 82 abstain abstain VB 40436 9207 83 , , , 40436 9207 84 if if IN 40436 9207 85 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9207 86 will will MD 40436 9207 87 bring bring VB 40436 9207 88 upon upon IN 40436 9207 89 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 9207 90 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9207 91 or or CC 40436 9207 92 upon upon IN 40436 9207 93 others other NNS 40436 9207 94 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9207 95 preponderating preponderating NN 40436 9207 96 pains pain NNS 40436 9207 97 in in IN 40436 9207 98 the the DT 40436 9207 99 particular particular JJ 40436 9207 100 case case NN 40436 9207 101 -- -- : 40436 9207 102 if if IN 40436 9207 103 the the DT 40436 9207 104 future future JJ 40436 9207 105 pains pain NNS 40436 9207 106 would would MD 40436 9207 107 preponderate preponderate VB 40436 9207 108 over over IN 40436 9207 109 the the DT 40436 9207 110 present present JJ 40436 9207 111 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9207 112 . . . 40436 9208 1 Of of IN 40436 9208 2 this this DT 40436 9208 3 last last JJ 40436 9208 4 calculation calculation NN 40436 9208 5 no no DT 40436 9208 6 notice notice NN 40436 9208 7 is be VBZ 40436 9208 8 taken take VBN 40436 9208 9 in in IN 40436 9208 10 the the DT 40436 9208 11 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9208 12 : : : 40436 9208 13 which which WDT 40436 9208 14 exhibits exhibit VBZ 40436 9208 15 only only RB 40436 9208 16 the the DT 40436 9208 17 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9208 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9208 19 not not RB 40436 9208 20 merely merely RB 40436 9208 21 marked mark VBN 40436 9208 22 but but CC 40436 9208 23 even even RB 40436 9208 24 over over IN 40436 9208 25 - - HYPH 40436 9208 26 done[91 done[91 NN 40436 9208 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9208 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9208 29 between between IN 40436 9208 30 the the DT 40436 9208 31 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9208 32 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9208 33 or or CC 40436 9208 34 pain pain NN 40436 9208 35 and and CC 40436 9208 36 the the DT 40436 9208 37 calculating calculate VBG 40436 9208 38 efficacy efficacy NN 40436 9208 39 of of IN 40436 9208 40 mind mind NN 40436 9208 41 , , , 40436 9208 42 but but CC 40436 9208 43 leaves leave VBZ 40436 9208 44 out out RP 40436 9208 45 the the DT 40436 9208 46 true true JJ 40436 9208 47 function function NN 40436 9208 48 which which WDT 40436 9208 49 gives give VBZ 40436 9208 50 value value NN 40436 9208 51 to to IN 40436 9208 52 the the DT 40436 9208 53 sound sound JJ 40436 9208 54 mind mind NN 40436 9208 55 as as IN 40436 9208 56 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 9208 57 from from IN 40436 9208 58 the the DT 40436 9208 59 unsound unsound JJ 40436 9208 60 and and CC 40436 9208 61 corrupt corrupt JJ 40436 9208 62 . . . 40436 9209 1 That that DT 40436 9209 2 function function NN 40436 9209 3 consists consist VBZ 40436 9209 4 in in IN 40436 9209 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9209 6 application application NN 40436 9209 7 to to IN 40436 9209 8 particular particular JJ 40436 9209 9 cases case NNS 40436 9209 10 : : : 40436 9209 11 in in IN 40436 9209 12 right right JJ 40436 9209 13 dealing deal VBG 40436 9209 14 with with IN 40436 9209 15 actual actual JJ 40436 9209 16 life life NN 40436 9209 17 , , , 40436 9209 18 as as IN 40436 9209 19 regards regard VBZ 40436 9209 20 the the DT 40436 9209 21 agent agent NN 40436 9209 22 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9209 23 and and CC 40436 9209 24 others other NNS 40436 9209 25 : : : 40436 9209 26 in in IN 40436 9209 27 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9209 28 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9209 29 : : : 40436 9209 30 e)nergei e)nergei NNS 40436 9209 31 / / SYM 40436 9209 32 a a NN 40436 9209 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9209 34 , , , 40436 9209 35 as as IN 40436 9209 36 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 9209 37 from from IN 40436 9209 38 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9209 39 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9209 40 : : : 40436 9209 41 e(/xis e(/xis NNP 40436 9209 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9209 43 , , , 40436 9209 44 to to TO 40436 9209 45 use use VB 40436 9209 46 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40436 9209 47 language language NN 40436 9209 48 . . . 40436 9210 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9210 2 92 92 CD 40436 9210 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9210 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9210 5 am be VBP 40436 9210 6 far far RB 40436 9210 7 from from IN 40436 9210 8 supposing suppose VBG 40436 9210 9 that that IN 40436 9210 10 this this DT 40436 9210 11 part part NN 40436 9210 12 of of IN 40436 9210 13 the the DT 40436 9210 14 case case NN 40436 9210 15 was be VBD 40436 9210 16 absent absent JJ 40436 9210 17 from from IN 40436 9210 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9210 19 's 's POS 40436 9210 20 mind mind NN 40436 9210 21 . . . 40436 9211 1 But but CC 40436 9211 2 the the DT 40436 9211 3 theory theory NN 40436 9211 4 laid lay VBD 40436 9211 5 out out RP 40436 9211 6 in in IN 40436 9211 7 the the DT 40436 9211 8 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9211 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9211 10 as as IN 40436 9211 11 compared compare VBN 40436 9211 12 with with IN 40436 9211 13 that that DT 40436 9211 14 in in IN 40436 9211 15 the the DT 40436 9211 16 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9211 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9211 18 leaves leave VBZ 40436 9211 19 no no DT 40436 9211 20 room room NN 40436 9211 21 for for IN 40436 9211 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9211 23 ; ; : 40436 9211 24 giving give VBG 40436 9211 25 exclusive exclusive JJ 40436 9211 26 prominence prominence NN 40436 9211 27 to to IN 40436 9211 28 the the DT 40436 9211 29 other other JJ 40436 9211 30 elements element NNS 40436 9211 31 , , , 40436 9211 32 and and CC 40436 9211 33 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 40436 9211 34 only only RB 40436 9211 35 the the DT 40436 9211 36 present present JJ 40436 9211 37 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9211 38 or or CC 40436 9211 39 pain pain NN 40436 9211 40 , , , 40436 9211 41 to to TO 40436 9211 42 be be VB 40436 9211 43 set set VBN 40436 9211 44 against against IN 40436 9211 45 the the DT 40436 9211 46 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9211 47 condition condition NN 40436 9211 48 of of IN 40436 9211 49 mind mind NN 40436 9211 50 , , , 40436 9211 51 bad bad JJ 40436 9211 52 or or CC 40436 9211 53 good good JJ 40436 9211 54 as as IN 40436 9211 55 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9211 56 may may MD 40436 9211 57 be be VB 40436 9211 58 . . . 40436 9212 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9212 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9212 3 90 90 CD 40436 9212 4 : : : 40436 9212 5 There there EX 40436 9212 6 would would MD 40436 9212 7 be be VB 40436 9212 8 also also RB 40436 9212 9 the the DT 40436 9212 10 like like JJ 40436 9212 11 intercommunity intercommunity NN 40436 9212 12 of of IN 40436 9212 13 nature nature NN 40436 9212 14 , , , 40436 9212 15 if if IN 40436 9212 16 along along IN 40436 9212 17 with with IN 40436 9212 18 the the DT 40436 9212 19 pains pain NNS 40436 9212 20 and and CC 40436 9212 21 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9212 22 of of IN 40436 9212 23 the the DT 40436 9212 24 agent agent NN 40436 9212 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9212 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9212 27 which which WDT 40436 9212 28 alone alone RB 40436 9212 29 are be VBP 40436 9212 30 regarded regard VBN 40436 9212 31 in in IN 40436 9212 32 the the DT 40436 9212 33 calculation calculation NN 40436 9212 34 of of IN 40436 9212 35 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9212 36 in in IN 40436 9212 37 the the DT 40436 9212 38 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9212 39 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9212 40 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9212 41 admit admit VBP 40436 9212 42 into into IN 40436 9212 43 the the DT 40436 9212 44 calculation calculation NN 40436 9212 45 the the DT 40436 9212 46 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9212 47 and and CC 40436 9212 48 pains pain NNS 40436 9212 49 of of IN 40436 9212 50 others other NNS 40436 9212 51 concerned concern VBN 40436 9212 52 , , , 40436 9212 53 and and CC 40436 9212 54 the the DT 40436 9212 55 rules rule NNS 40436 9212 56 established establish VBN 40436 9212 57 with with IN 40436 9212 58 a a DT 40436 9212 59 view view NN 40436 9212 60 to to IN 40436 9212 61 both both DT 40436 9212 62 the the DT 40436 9212 63 two two CD 40436 9212 64 together together RB 40436 9212 65 with with IN 40436 9212 66 a a DT 40436 9212 67 view view NN 40436 9212 68 to to IN 40436 9212 69 the the DT 40436 9212 70 joint joint JJ 40436 9212 71 interest interest NN 40436 9212 72 both both DT 40436 9212 73 of of IN 40436 9212 74 the the DT 40436 9212 75 agent agent NN 40436 9212 76 and and CC 40436 9212 77 of of IN 40436 9212 78 others other NNS 40436 9212 79 . . . 40436 9212 80 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9213 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9213 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9213 3 91 91 CD 40436 9213 4 : : : 40436 9213 5 Epikurus Epikurus NNP 40436 9213 6 and and CC 40436 9213 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9213 8 followers follower NNS 40436 9213 9 assigned assign VBD 40436 9213 10 the the DT 40436 9213 11 greatest great JJS 40436 9213 12 value value NN 40436 9213 13 , , , 40436 9213 14 in in IN 40436 9213 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9213 16 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9213 17 theory theory NN 40436 9213 18 , , , 40436 9213 19 to to IN 40436 9213 20 the the DT 40436 9213 21 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9213 22 element element NN 40436 9213 23 , , , 40436 9213 24 or or CC 40436 9213 25 established establish VBN 40436 9213 26 character character NN 40436 9213 27 of of IN 40436 9213 28 the the DT 40436 9213 29 agent agent NN 40436 9213 30 , , , 40436 9213 31 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9213 32 and and CC 40436 9213 33 emotional emotional JJ 40436 9213 34 . . . 40436 9214 1 But but CC 40436 9214 2 great great JJ 40436 9214 3 as as IN 40436 9214 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9214 5 reckoned reckon VBD 40436 9214 6 this this DT 40436 9214 7 value value NN 40436 9214 8 to to TO 40436 9214 9 be be VB 40436 9214 10 , , , 40436 9214 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9214 12 resolved resolve VBD 40436 9214 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9214 14 all all DT 40436 9214 15 into into IN 40436 9214 16 the the DT 40436 9214 17 diminution diminution NN 40436 9214 18 or or CC 40436 9214 19 mitigation mitigation NN 40436 9214 20 of of IN 40436 9214 21 pains pain NNS 40436 9214 22 , , , 40436 9214 23 and and CC 40436 9214 24 , , , 40436 9214 25 in in IN 40436 9214 26 a a DT 40436 9214 27 certain certain JJ 40436 9214 28 though though IN 40436 9214 29 inferior inferior JJ 40436 9214 30 degree degree NN 40436 9214 31 , , , 40436 9214 32 the the DT 40436 9214 33 multiplication multiplication NN 40436 9214 34 of of IN 40436 9214 35 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9214 36 . . . 40436 9215 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9215 2 did do VBD 40436 9215 3 not not RB 40436 9215 4 put put VB 40436 9215 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9215 6 in in IN 40436 9215 7 a a DT 40436 9215 8 separate separate JJ 40436 9215 9 category category NN 40436 9215 10 of of IN 40436 9215 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9215 12 own own JJ 40436 9215 13 , , , 40436 9215 14 altogether altogether RB 40436 9215 15 disparate disparate JJ 40436 9215 16 and and CC 40436 9215 17 foreign foreign JJ 40436 9215 18 to to IN 40436 9215 19 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9215 20 and and CC 40436 9215 21 pains pain NNS 40436 9215 22 . . . 40436 9216 1 See see VB 40436 9216 2 the the DT 40436 9216 3 letter letter NN 40436 9216 4 of of IN 40436 9216 5 Epikurus Epikurus NNP 40436 9216 6 to to IN 40436 9216 7 Menoekeus Menoekeus NNP 40436 9216 8 , , , 40436 9216 9 Diog Diog NNP 40436 9216 10 . . . 40436 9217 1 L. L. NNP 40436 9217 2 x. x. NNP 40436 9218 1 128 128 CD 40436 9218 2 - - SYM 40436 9218 3 132 132 CD 40436 9218 4 ; ; : 40436 9218 5 Lucretius Lucretius NNP 40436 9218 6 , , , 40436 9218 7 v. v. CC 40436 9218 8 18 18 CD 40436 9218 9 - - SYM 40436 9218 10 45 45 CD 40436 9218 11 , , , 40436 9218 12 vi vi NNP 40436 9218 13 . . . 40436 9219 1 12 12 CD 40436 9219 2 - - SYM 40436 9219 3 25 25 CD 40436 9219 4 ; ; : 40436 9219 5 Horat Horat NNP 40436 9219 6 . . . 40436 9220 1 Epist epist UH 40436 9220 2 . . . 40436 9221 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9222 1 2 2 CD 40436 9222 2 , , , 40436 9222 3 48 48 CD 40436 9222 4 - - SYM 40436 9222 5 60 60 CD 40436 9222 6 . . . 40436 9222 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9223 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9223 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9223 3 92 92 CD 40436 9223 4 : : : 40436 9223 5 Aristot aristot NN 40436 9223 6 . . . 40436 9224 1 Ethic ethic NN 40436 9224 2 . . . 40436 9225 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 9225 2 . . . 40436 9226 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9227 1 7 7 LS 40436 9227 2 . . . 40436 9228 1 The the DT 40436 9228 2 remark remark NN 40436 9228 3 of of IN 40436 9228 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 9228 5 in in IN 40436 9228 6 the the DT 40436 9228 7 same same JJ 40436 9228 8 treatise treatise NN 40436 9228 9 , , , 40436 9228 10 i. i. NNP 40436 9229 1 5 5 LS 40436 9229 2 - - HYPH 40436 9229 3 -[Greek -[greek RB 40436 9229 4 : : : 40436 9229 5 dokei= dokei= NN 40436 9229 6 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9229 7 e)nde e)nde NNP 40436 9229 8 / / SYM 40436 9229 9 chesthai chesthai NNP 40436 9229 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9229 11 katheu katheu NNP 40436 9229 12 / / SYM 40436 9229 13 dein dein NNP 40436 9229 14 e)/chonta e)/chonta NNP 40436 9229 15 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9229 16 a)retê a)retê NNP 40436 9229 17 / / SYM 40436 9229 18 n n NN 40436 9229 19 , , , 40436 9229 20 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 9229 21 a)praktei a)praktei CD 40436 9229 22 = = SYM 40436 9229 23 n n NNP 40436 9229 24 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 9229 25 bi bi NN 40436 9229 26 / / SYM 40436 9229 27 ou]--might ou]--might NN 40436 9229 28 be be VB 40436 9229 29 applied apply VBN 40436 9229 30 to to IN 40436 9229 31 the the DT 40436 9229 32 theory theory NN 40436 9229 33 of of IN 40436 9229 34 the the DT 40436 9229 35 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9229 36 . . . 40436 9230 1 Compare compare VB 40436 9230 2 also also RB 40436 9230 3 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 9230 4 . . . 40436 9231 1 Nik Nik NNP 40436 9231 2 . . . 40436 9232 1 vii vii NN 40436 9232 2 . . . 40436 9233 1 3 3 LS 40436 9233 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9233 3 vii vii NN 40436 9233 4 . . . 40436 9234 1 4 4 CD 40436 9234 2 , , , 40436 9234 3 p. p. NN 40436 9234 4 1146 1146 CD 40436 9234 5 , , , 40436 9234 6 b. b. NNP 40436 9235 1 31 31 CD 40436 9235 2 , , , 40436 9235 3 p. p. NN 40436 9235 4 1147 1147 CD 40436 9235 5 , , , 40436 9235 6 a. a. NN 40436 9236 1 12 12 CD 40436 9236 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9236 3 . . . 40436 9236 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9237 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9237 2 Side side NN 40436 9237 3 - - HYPH 40436 9237 4 note note NN 40436 9237 5 : : : 40436 9237 6 Character character NN 40436 9237 7 of of IN 40436 9237 8 the the DT 40436 9237 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9237 10 generally generally RB 40436 9237 11 -- -- : 40436 9237 12 discrediting discredit VBG 40436 9237 13 all all PDT 40436 9237 14 the the DT 40436 9237 15 actualities actuality NNS 40436 9237 16 of of IN 40436 9237 17 life life NN 40436 9237 18 . . . 40436 9237 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9238 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 9238 2 there there EX 40436 9238 3 is be VBZ 40436 9238 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 9238 5 more more RBR 40436 9238 6 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 9238 7 in in IN 40436 9238 8 the the DT 40436 9238 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9238 10 , , , 40436 9238 11 than than IN 40436 9238 12 the the DT 40436 9238 13 manner manner NN 40436 9238 14 in in IN 40436 9238 15 which which WDT 40436 9238 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9238 17 not not RB 40436 9238 18 only only RB 40436 9238 19 condemns condemn VBZ 40436 9238 20 the the DT 40436 9238 21 unmeasured unmeasured JJ 40436 9238 22 , , , 40436 9238 23 exorbitant exorbitant JJ 40436 9238 24 , , , 40436 9238 25 maleficent maleficent JJ 40436 9238 26 desires desire NNS 40436 9238 27 , , , 40436 9238 28 but but CC 40436 9238 29 also also RB 40436 9238 30 depreciates depreciate NNS 40436 9238 31 and and CC 40436 9238 32 degrades degrade NNS 40436 9238 33 all all PDT 40436 9238 34 the the DT 40436 9238 35 actualities actuality NNS 40436 9238 36 of of IN 40436 9238 37 life life NN 40436 9238 38 -- -- : 40436 9238 39 all all PDT 40436 9238 40 the the DT 40436 9238 41 recreative recreative JJ 40436 9238 42 and and CC 40436 9238 43 elegant elegant JJ 40436 9238 44 arts art NNS 40436 9238 45 , , , 40436 9238 46 including include VBG 40436 9238 47 music music NN 40436 9238 48 and and CC 40436 9238 49 poetry poetry NN 40436 9238 50 , , , 40436 9238 51 tragic tragic JJ 40436 9238 52 as as RB 40436 9238 53 well well RB 40436 9238 54 as as IN 40436 9238 55 dithyrambic dithyrambic JJ 40436 9238 56 -- -- : 40436 9238 57 all all DT 40436 9238 58 provision provision NN 40436 9238 59 for for IN 40436 9238 60 the the DT 40436 9238 61 most most RBS 40436 9238 62 essential essential JJ 40436 9238 63 wants want VBZ 40436 9238 64 , , , 40436 9238 65 all all DT 40436 9238 66 protection protection NN 40436 9238 67 against against IN 40436 9238 68 particular particular JJ 40436 9238 69 sufferings suffering NNS 40436 9238 70 and and CC 40436 9238 71 dangers danger NNS 40436 9238 72 , , , 40436 9238 73 even even RB 40436 9238 74 all all DT 40436 9238 75 service service NN 40436 9238 76 rendered render VBN 40436 9238 77 to to IN 40436 9238 78 another another DT 40436 9238 79 person person NN 40436 9238 80 in in IN 40436 9238 81 the the DT 40436 9238 82 way way NN 40436 9238 83 of of IN 40436 9238 84 relief relief NN 40436 9238 85 or or CC 40436 9238 86 of of IN 40436 9238 87 rescue[93]--all rescue[93]--all NN 40436 9238 88 the the DT 40436 9238 89 effective effective JJ 40436 9238 90 maintenance maintenance NN 40436 9238 91 of of IN 40436 9238 92 public public JJ 40436 9238 93 organised organise VBN 40436 9238 94 force force NN 40436 9238 95 , , , 40436 9238 96 such such JJ 40436 9238 97 as as IN 40436 9238 98 ships ship NNS 40436 9238 99 , , , 40436 9238 100 docks dock NNS 40436 9238 101 , , , 40436 9238 102 walls wall NNS 40436 9238 103 , , , 40436 9238 104 arms arm NNS 40436 9238 105 , , , 40436 9238 106 & & CC 40436 9238 107 c. c. NNP 40436 9238 108 Immediate Immediate NNP 40436 9238 109 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9238 110 or or CC 40436 9238 111 relief relief NN 40436 9238 112 , , , 40436 9238 113 and and CC 40436 9238 114 those those DT 40436 9238 115 who who WP 40436 9238 116 confer confer VBP 40436 9238 117 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9238 118 , , , 40436 9238 119 are be VBP 40436 9238 120 treated treat VBN 40436 9238 121 with with IN 40436 9238 122 contempt contempt NN 40436 9238 123 , , , 40436 9238 124 and and CC 40436 9238 125 presented present VBD 40436 9238 126 as as IN 40436 9238 127 in in IN 40436 9238 128 hostility hostility NN 40436 9238 129 to to IN 40436 9238 130 the the DT 40436 9238 131 perfection perfection NN 40436 9238 132 of of IN 40436 9238 133 the the DT 40436 9238 134 mental mental JJ 40436 9238 135 structure structure NN 40436 9238 136 . . . 40436 9239 1 And and CC 40436 9239 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9239 3 is be VBZ 40436 9239 4 in in IN 40436 9239 5 this this DT 40436 9239 6 point point NN 40436 9239 7 of of IN 40436 9239 8 view view NN 40436 9239 9 that that IN 40436 9239 10 various various JJ 40436 9239 11 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9239 12 commentators commentator NNS 40436 9239 13 extol extol VBP 40436 9239 14 in in IN 40436 9239 15 an an DT 40436 9239 16 especial especial JJ 40436 9239 17 manner manner NN 40436 9239 18 the the DT 40436 9239 19 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9239 20 : : : 40436 9239 21 as as IN 40436 9239 22 recognising recognise VBG 40436 9239 23 an an DT 40436 9239 24 Idea Idea NNP 40436 9239 25 of of IN 40436 9239 26 Good good JJ 40436 9239 27 superhuman superhuman NN 40436 9239 28 and and CC 40436 9239 29 supernatural supernatural JJ 40436 9239 30 , , , 40436 9239 31 radically radically RB 40436 9239 32 disparate disparate JJ 40436 9239 33 from from IN 40436 9239 34 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9239 35 and and CC 40436 9239 36 pains pain NNS 40436 9239 37 of of IN 40436 9239 38 any any DT 40436 9239 39 human human JJ 40436 9239 40 being being NN 40436 9239 41 , , , 40436 9239 42 and and CC 40436 9239 43 incommensurable incommensurable JJ 40436 9239 44 with with IN 40436 9239 45 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9239 46 : : : 40436 9239 47 an an DT 40436 9239 48 Universal Universal NNP 40436 9239 49 Idea Idea NNP 40436 9239 50 , , , 40436 9239 51 which which WDT 40436 9239 52 , , , 40436 9239 53 though though IN 40436 9239 54 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9239 55 is be VBZ 40436 9239 56 supposed suppose VBN 40436 9239 57 to to TO 40436 9239 58 cast cast VB 40436 9239 59 a a DT 40436 9239 60 distant distant JJ 40436 9239 61 light light NN 40436 9239 62 upon upon IN 40436 9239 63 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9239 64 particulars particular NNS 40436 9239 65 , , , 40436 9239 66 is be VBZ 40436 9239 67 separated separate VBN 40436 9239 68 from from IN 40436 9239 69 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9239 70 by by IN 40436 9239 71 an an DT 40436 9239 72 incalculable incalculable JJ 40436 9239 73 space space NN 40436 9239 74 , , , 40436 9239 75 and and CC 40436 9239 76 is be VBZ 40436 9239 77 discernible discernible JJ 40436 9239 78 only only RB 40436 9239 79 by by IN 40436 9239 80 the the DT 40436 9239 81 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9239 82 telescope telescope NN 40436 9239 83 . . . 40436 9240 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9240 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9240 3 93 93 CD 40436 9240 4 : : : 40436 9240 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9240 6 , , , 40436 9240 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9240 8 , , , 40436 9240 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9240 10 . . . 40436 9241 1 501 501 CD 40436 9241 2 - - HYPH 40436 9241 3 502 502 CD 40436 9241 4 - - HYPH 40436 9241 5 511 511 CD 40436 9241 6 - - HYPH 40436 9241 7 512 512 CD 40436 9241 8 - - HYPH 40436 9241 9 517 517 CD 40436 9241 10 - - HYPH 40436 9241 11 519 519 CD 40436 9241 12 . . . 40436 9242 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9242 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9242 3 : : : 40436 9242 4 a)/neu a)/neu XX 40436 9242 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9242 6 dikaiosu dikaiosu NN 40436 9242 7 / / SYM 40436 9242 8 nês nês NNP 40436 9242 9 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9242 10 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 9242 11 / / SYM 40436 9242 12 nês nês NNP 40436 9242 13 lime lime NNP 40436 9242 14 / / SYM 40436 9242 15 nôn nôn NNP 40436 9242 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9242 17 neôri neôri NNP 40436 9242 18 / / SYM 40436 9242 19 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9242 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9242 21 teichô teichô NNP 40436 9242 22 = = SYM 40436 9242 23 n n NNP 40436 9242 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9242 25 pho pho NNP 40436 9242 26 / / SYM 40436 9242 27 rôn rôn NNP 40436 9242 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9242 29 toiou toiou NNP 40436 9242 30 / / SYM 40436 9242 31 tôn tôn NNP 40436 9242 32 phluariô phluariô NNP 40436 9242 33 = = SYM 40436 9242 34 n n NNP 40436 9242 35 e)mpeplê e)mpeplê NNP 40436 9242 36 / / SYM 40436 9242 37 kasi kasi NNP 40436 9242 38 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9242 39 po po NNP 40436 9242 40 / / SYM 40436 9242 41 lin lin NNP 40436 9242 42 . . . 40436 9242 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9243 1 This this DT 40436 9243 2 is be VBZ 40436 9243 3 applied apply VBN 40436 9243 4 to to IN 40436 9243 5 the the DT 40436 9243 6 provision provision NN 40436 9243 7 of of IN 40436 9243 8 food food NN 40436 9243 9 , , , 40436 9243 10 drink drink NN 40436 9243 11 , , , 40436 9243 12 clothing clothing NN 40436 9243 13 , , , 40436 9243 14 bedding bedding NN 40436 9243 15 , , , 40436 9243 16 for for IN 40436 9243 17 the the DT 40436 9243 18 hunger hunger NN 40436 9243 19 , , , 40436 9243 20 thirst thirst NNP 40436 9243 21 , , , 40436 9243 22 & & CC 40436 9243 23 c. c. NNP 40436 9243 24 , , , 40436 9243 25 of of IN 40436 9243 26 the the DT 40436 9243 27 community community NN 40436 9243 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9243 29 p. p. NN 40436 9243 30 517 517 CD 40436 9243 31 D d NN 40436 9243 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9243 33 , , , 40436 9243 34 to to IN 40436 9243 35 the the DT 40436 9243 36 saving saving NN 40436 9243 37 of of IN 40436 9243 38 life life NN 40436 9243 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9243 40 p. p. NN 40436 9243 41 511 511 CD 40436 9243 42 D d NN 40436 9243 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9243 44 . . . 40436 9244 1 The the DT 40436 9244 2 boatman boatman NN 40436 9244 3 between between IN 40436 9244 4 Ægina Ægina NNP 40436 9244 5 and and CC 40436 9244 6 Peiræus Peiræus NNP 40436 9244 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9244 8 says say VBZ 40436 9244 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9244 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9244 11 brings bring VBZ 40436 9244 12 over over RP 40436 9244 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9244 14 passengers passenger NNS 40436 9244 15 in in IN 40436 9244 16 safety safety NN 40436 9244 17 , , , 40436 9244 18 together together RB 40436 9244 19 with with IN 40436 9244 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9244 21 families family NNS 40436 9244 22 and and CC 40436 9244 23 property property NN 40436 9244 24 , , , 40436 9244 25 preserving preserve VBG 40436 9244 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9244 27 from from IN 40436 9244 28 all all PDT 40436 9244 29 the the DT 40436 9244 30 dangers danger NNS 40436 9244 31 of of IN 40436 9244 32 the the DT 40436 9244 33 sea sea NN 40436 9244 34 . . . 40436 9245 1 The the DT 40436 9245 2 engineer engineer NN 40436 9245 3 , , , 40436 9245 4 who who WP 40436 9245 5 constructs construct VBZ 40436 9245 6 good good JJ 40436 9245 7 fortifications fortification NNS 40436 9245 8 , , , 40436 9245 9 preserves preserve NNS 40436 9245 10 from from IN 40436 9245 11 danger danger NN 40436 9245 12 and and CC 40436 9245 13 destruction destruction NN 40436 9245 14 all all PDT 40436 9245 15 the the DT 40436 9245 16 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9245 17 with with IN 40436 9245 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9245 19 families family NNS 40436 9245 20 and and CC 40436 9245 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9245 22 property property NN 40436 9245 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9245 24 p. p. NN 40436 9245 25 512 512 CD 40436 9245 26 B b NN 40436 9245 27 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9245 28 . . . 40436 9246 1 But but CC 40436 9246 2 neither neither DT 40436 9246 3 of of IN 40436 9246 4 these these DT 40436 9246 5 persons person NNS 40436 9246 6 takes take VBZ 40436 9246 7 credit credit NN 40436 9246 8 for for IN 40436 9246 9 this this DT 40436 9246 10 service service NN 40436 9246 11 : : : 40436 9246 12 because because IN 40436 9246 13 both both DT 40436 9246 14 of of IN 40436 9246 15 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9246 16 know know VBP 40436 9246 17 that that IN 40436 9246 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9246 19 is be VBZ 40436 9246 20 doubtful doubtful JJ 40436 9246 21 whether whether IN 40436 9246 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9246 23 have have VBP 40436 9246 24 done do VBN 40436 9246 25 any any DT 40436 9246 26 real real JJ 40436 9246 27 service service NN 40436 9246 28 to to IN 40436 9246 29 the the DT 40436 9246 30 persons person NNS 40436 9246 31 preserved preserve VBN 40436 9246 32 , , , 40436 9246 33 since since IN 40436 9246 34 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9246 35 have have VBP 40436 9246 36 not not RB 40436 9246 37 rendered render VBN 40436 9246 38 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9246 39 any any DT 40436 9246 40 better better RB 40436 9246 41 ; ; : 40436 9246 42 and and CC 40436 9246 43 that that IN 40436 9246 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9246 45 is be VBZ 40436 9246 46 even even RB 40436 9246 47 doubtful doubtful JJ 40436 9246 48 whether whether IN 40436 9246 49 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9246 50 may may MD 40436 9246 51 not not RB 40436 9246 52 have have VB 40436 9246 53 done do VBN 40436 9246 54 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9246 55 an an DT 40436 9246 56 actual actual JJ 40436 9246 57 mischief mischief NN 40436 9246 58 . . . 40436 9247 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 40436 9247 2 these these DT 40436 9247 3 persons person NNS 40436 9247 4 may may MD 40436 9247 5 be be VB 40436 9247 6 wicked wicked JJ 40436 9247 7 and and CC 40436 9247 8 corrupt corrupt JJ 40436 9247 9 ; ; : 40436 9247 10 in in IN 40436 9247 11 that that DT 40436 9247 12 case case NN 40436 9247 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9247 14 is be VBZ 40436 9247 15 a a DT 40436 9247 16 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 9247 17 to to IN 40436 9247 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9247 19 that that IN 40436 9247 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9247 21 lives life NNS 40436 9247 22 should should MD 40436 9247 23 be be VB 40436 9247 24 prolonged prolong VBN 40436 9247 25 ; ; : 40436 9247 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9247 27 would would MD 40436 9247 28 be be VB 40436 9247 29 better well JJR 40436 9247 30 for for IN 40436 9247 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9247 32 to to TO 40436 9247 33 die die VB 40436 9247 34 . . . 40436 9248 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9248 2 is be VBZ 40436 9248 3 under under IN 40436 9248 4 this this DT 40436 9248 5 conviction conviction NN 40436 9248 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9248 7 says say VBZ 40436 9248 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9248 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9248 10 that that IN 40436 9248 11 the the DT 40436 9248 12 boatman boatman NNP 40436 9248 13 and and CC 40436 9248 14 the the DT 40436 9248 15 engineer engineer NN 40436 9248 16 , , , 40436 9248 17 though though IN 40436 9248 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9248 19 do do VBP 40436 9248 20 preserve preserve VB 40436 9248 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9248 22 lives life NNS 40436 9248 23 , , , 40436 9248 24 take take VBP 40436 9248 25 to to IN 40436 9248 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9248 27 no no DT 40436 9248 28 credit credit NN 40436 9248 29 for for IN 40436 9248 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9248 31 . . . 40436 9249 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9249 2 shall shall MD 40436 9249 3 hardly hardly RB 40436 9249 4 find find VB 40436 9249 5 any any DT 40436 9249 6 greater great JJR 40436 9249 7 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 9249 8 exaggeration exaggeration NN 40436 9249 9 than than IN 40436 9249 10 this this DT 40436 9249 11 , , , 40436 9249 12 among among IN 40436 9249 13 all all PDT 40436 9249 14 the the DT 40436 9249 15 compositions composition NNS 40436 9249 16 of of IN 40436 9249 17 the the DT 40436 9249 18 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 9249 19 against against IN 40436 9249 20 whom whom WP 40436 9249 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9249 22 declares declare VBZ 40436 9249 23 war war NN 40436 9249 24 in in IN 40436 9249 25 the the DT 40436 9249 26 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9249 27 . . . 40436 9250 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 9250 2 , , , 40436 9250 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9250 4 is be VBZ 40436 9250 5 a a DT 40436 9250 6 specimen speciman NNS 40436 9250 7 of of IN 40436 9250 8 the the DT 40436 9250 9 way way NN 40436 9250 10 in in IN 40436 9250 11 which which WDT 40436 9250 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9250 13 colours colour NNS 40436 9250 14 and and CC 40436 9250 15 misinterprets misinterpret VBZ 40436 9250 16 the the DT 40436 9250 17 facts fact NNS 40436 9250 18 of of IN 40436 9250 19 social social JJ 40436 9250 20 life life NN 40436 9250 21 , , , 40436 9250 22 in in IN 40436 9250 23 order order NN 40436 9250 24 to to TO 40436 9250 25 serve serve VB 40436 9250 26 the the DT 40436 9250 27 purpose purpose NN 40436 9250 28 of of IN 40436 9250 29 the the DT 40436 9250 30 argument argument NN 40436 9250 31 of of IN 40436 9250 32 the the DT 40436 9250 33 moment moment NN 40436 9250 34 . . . 40436 9251 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9251 2 says say VBZ 40436 9251 3 truly truly RB 40436 9251 4 that that IN 40436 9251 5 when when WRB 40436 9251 6 the the DT 40436 9251 7 passage passage NN 40436 9251 8 boat boat NN 40436 9251 9 from from IN 40436 9251 10 Ægina Ægina NNP 40436 9251 11 to to IN 40436 9251 12 Peiræus Peiræus NNP 40436 9251 13 has have VBZ 40436 9251 14 reached reach VBN 40436 9251 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9251 16 destination destination NN 40436 9251 17 , , , 40436 9251 18 the the DT 40436 9251 19 steersman steersman NN 40436 9251 20 receives receive VBZ 40436 9251 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9251 22 fare fare NN 40436 9251 23 and and CC 40436 9251 24 walks walk VBZ 40436 9251 25 about about IN 40436 9251 26 on on IN 40436 9251 27 the the DT 40436 9251 28 shore shore NN 40436 9251 29 , , , 40436 9251 30 without without IN 40436 9251 31 taking take VBG 40436 9251 32 any any DT 40436 9251 33 great great JJ 40436 9251 34 credit credit NN 40436 9251 35 to to IN 40436 9251 36 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9251 37 , , , 40436 9251 38 as as IN 40436 9251 39 if if IN 40436 9251 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9251 41 had have VBD 40436 9251 42 performed perform VBN 40436 9251 43 a a DT 40436 9251 44 brilliant brilliant JJ 40436 9251 45 deed deed NN 40436 9251 46 or or CC 40436 9251 47 conferred confer VBD 40436 9251 48 an an DT 40436 9251 49 important important JJ 40436 9251 50 service service NN 40436 9251 51 . . . 40436 9252 1 But but CC 40436 9252 2 how how WRB 40436 9252 3 does do VBZ 40436 9252 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9252 5 explain explain VB 40436 9252 6 this this DT 40436 9252 7 ? ? . 40436 9253 1 By by IN 40436 9253 2 supposing suppose VBG 40436 9253 3 in in IN 40436 9253 4 the the DT 40436 9253 5 steersman steersman NN 40436 9253 6 's 's POS 40436 9253 7 mind mind NN 40436 9253 8 feelings feeling NNS 40436 9253 9 which which WDT 40436 9253 10 never never RB 40436 9253 11 enter enter VBP 40436 9253 12 into into IN 40436 9253 13 the the DT 40436 9253 14 mind mind NN 40436 9253 15 of of IN 40436 9253 16 a a DT 40436 9253 17 real real JJ 40436 9253 18 agent agent NN 40436 9253 19 ; ; : 40436 9253 20 feelings feeling NNS 40436 9253 21 which which WDT 40436 9253 22 are be VBP 40436 9253 23 put put VBN 40436 9253 24 into into IN 40436 9253 25 words word NNS 40436 9253 26 only only RB 40436 9253 27 when when WRB 40436 9253 28 a a DT 40436 9253 29 moralist moralist NN 40436 9253 30 or or CC 40436 9253 31 a a DT 40436 9253 32 satirist satirist NN 40436 9253 33 is be VBZ 40436 9253 34 anxious anxious JJ 40436 9253 35 to to TO 40436 9253 36 enforce enforce VB 40436 9253 37 a a DT 40436 9253 38 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 9253 39 . . . 40436 9254 1 The the DT 40436 9254 2 service service NN 40436 9254 3 which which WDT 40436 9254 4 the the DT 40436 9254 5 steersman steersman NN 40436 9254 6 performs perform VBZ 40436 9254 7 is be VBZ 40436 9254 8 not not RB 40436 9254 9 only only RB 40436 9254 10 adequately adequately RB 40436 9254 11 remunerated remunerate VBN 40436 9254 12 , , , 40436 9254 13 but but CC 40436 9254 14 is be VBZ 40436 9254 15 , , , 40436 9254 16 on on IN 40436 9254 17 most most JJS 40436 9254 18 days day NNS 40436 9254 19 , , , 40436 9254 20 a a DT 40436 9254 21 regular regular JJ 40436 9254 22 and and CC 40436 9254 23 easy easy JJ 40436 9254 24 one one CD 40436 9254 25 , , , 40436 9254 26 such such JJ 40436 9254 27 as as IN 40436 9254 28 every every DT 40436 9254 29 man man NN 40436 9254 30 who who WP 40436 9254 31 has have VBZ 40436 9254 32 gone go VBN 40436 9254 33 through through IN 40436 9254 34 a a DT 40436 9254 35 decent decent JJ 40436 9254 36 apprenticeship apprenticeship NN 40436 9254 37 can can MD 40436 9254 38 perform perform VB 40436 9254 39 . . . 40436 9255 1 But but CC 40436 9255 2 suppose suppose VB 40436 9255 3 an an DT 40436 9255 4 exceptional exceptional JJ 40436 9255 5 day day NN 40436 9255 6 -- -- : 40436 9255 7 suppose suppose VB 40436 9255 8 a a DT 40436 9255 9 sudden sudden JJ 40436 9255 10 and and CC 40436 9255 11 terrible terrible JJ 40436 9255 12 storm storm NN 40436 9255 13 to to TO 40436 9255 14 supervene supervene VB 40436 9255 15 on on IN 40436 9255 16 the the DT 40436 9255 17 passage passage NN 40436 9255 18 -- -- : 40436 9255 19 suppose suppose VB 40436 9255 20 the the DT 40436 9255 21 boat boat NN 40436 9255 22 full full JJ 40436 9255 23 of of IN 40436 9255 24 passengers passenger NNS 40436 9255 25 , , , 40436 9255 26 with with IN 40436 9255 27 every every DT 40436 9255 28 prospect prospect NN 40436 9255 29 of of IN 40436 9255 30 all all DT 40436 9255 31 on on IN 40436 9255 32 board board NN 40436 9255 33 being be VBG 40436 9255 34 drowned drown VBN 40436 9255 35 -- -- : 40436 9255 36 suppose suppose VB 40436 9255 37 she -PRON- PRP 40436 9255 38 is be VBZ 40436 9255 39 only only RB 40436 9255 40 saved save VBN 40436 9255 41 by by IN 40436 9255 42 the the DT 40436 9255 43 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 40436 9255 44 skill skill NN 40436 9255 45 , , , 40436 9255 46 vigilance vigilance NN 40436 9255 47 , , , 40436 9255 48 and and CC 40436 9255 49 efforts effort NNS 40436 9255 50 of of IN 40436 9255 51 the the DT 40436 9255 52 steersman steersman NN 40436 9255 53 . . . 40436 9256 1 In in IN 40436 9256 2 that that DT 40436 9256 3 case case NN 40436 9256 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9256 5 will will MD 40436 9256 6 , , , 40436 9256 7 on on IN 40436 9256 8 reaching reach VBG 40436 9256 9 the the DT 40436 9256 10 land land NN 40436 9256 11 , , , 40436 9256 12 walk walk VBP 40436 9256 13 about about IN 40436 9256 14 full full JJ 40436 9256 15 of of IN 40436 9256 16 elate elate JJ 40436 9256 17 self self NN 40436 9256 18 - - HYPH 40436 9256 19 congratulation congratulation NN 40436 9256 20 and and CC 40436 9256 21 pride pride NN 40436 9256 22 : : : 40436 9256 23 the the DT 40436 9256 24 passengers passenger NNS 40436 9256 25 will will MD 40436 9256 26 encourage encourage VB 40436 9256 27 this this DT 40436 9256 28 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 9256 29 by by IN 40436 9256 30 expressions expression NNS 40436 9256 31 of of IN 40436 9256 32 the the DT 40436 9256 33 deepest deep JJS 40436 9256 34 gratitude gratitude NN 40436 9256 35 ; ; : 40436 9256 36 while while IN 40436 9256 37 friends friend NNS 40436 9256 38 as as RB 40436 9256 39 well well RB 40436 9256 40 as as IN 40436 9256 41 competitors competitor NNS 40436 9256 42 will will MD 40436 9256 43 praise praise VB 40436 9256 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9256 45 successful successful JJ 40436 9256 46 exploit exploit NN 40436 9256 47 . . . 40436 9257 1 How how WRB 40436 9257 2 many many JJ 40436 9257 3 of of IN 40436 9257 4 the the DT 40436 9257 5 passengers passenger NNS 40436 9257 6 there there EX 40436 9257 7 are be VBP 40436 9257 8 for for IN 40436 9257 9 whom whom WP 40436 9257 10 the the DT 40436 9257 11 preservation preservation NN 40436 9257 12 of of IN 40436 9257 13 life life NN 40436 9257 14 may may MD 40436 9257 15 be be VB 40436 9257 16 a a DT 40436 9257 17 curse curse NN 40436 9257 18 rather rather RB 40436 9257 19 than than IN 40436 9257 20 a a DT 40436 9257 21 blessing blessing NN 40436 9257 22 -- -- : 40436 9257 23 is be VBZ 40436 9257 24 a a DT 40436 9257 25 question question NN 40436 9257 26 which which WDT 40436 9257 27 neither neither CC 40436 9257 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9257 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9257 30 , , , 40436 9257 31 nor nor CC 40436 9257 32 the the DT 40436 9257 33 steersman steersman NN 40436 9257 34 , , , 40436 9257 35 nor nor CC 40436 9257 36 the the DT 40436 9257 37 public public NN 40436 9257 38 , , , 40436 9257 39 will will MD 40436 9257 40 ever ever RB 40436 9257 41 dream dream VB 40436 9257 42 of of IN 40436 9257 43 asking ask VBG 40436 9257 44 . . . 40436 9257 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9258 1 * * NFP 40436 9258 2 * * NFP 40436 9258 3 * * NFP 40436 9258 4 * * NFP 40436 9258 5 * * NFP 40436 9258 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9258 7 Side side NN 40436 9258 8 - - HYPH 40436 9258 9 note note NN 40436 9258 10 : : : 40436 9258 11 Argument argument NN 40436 9258 12 of of IN 40436 9258 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9258 14 resumed resume VBD 40436 9258 15 -- -- : 40436 9258 16 multifarious multifarious JJ 40436 9258 17 arts art NNS 40436 9258 18 of of IN 40436 9258 19 flattery flattery NN 40436 9258 20 , , , 40436 9258 21 aiming aim VBG 40436 9258 22 at at IN 40436 9258 23 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9258 24 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9258 25 . . . 40436 9258 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9259 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9259 2 have have VBP 40436 9259 3 now now RB 40436 9259 4 established establish VBN 40436 9259 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9259 6 continues continue VBZ 40436 9259 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9259 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9259 9 that that IN 40436 9259 10 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9259 11 is be VBZ 40436 9259 12 essentially essentially RB 40436 9259 13 different different JJ 40436 9259 14 from from IN 40436 9259 15 good good JJ 40436 9259 16 , , , 40436 9259 17 and and CC 40436 9259 18 pain pain NN 40436 9259 19 from from IN 40436 9259 20 evil evil NN 40436 9259 21 : : : 40436 9259 22 also also RB 40436 9259 23 , , , 40436 9259 24 that that DT 40436 9259 25 to to TO 40436 9259 26 obtain obtain VB 40436 9259 27 good good JJ 40436 9259 28 and and CC 40436 9259 29 avoid avoid VB 40436 9259 30 evil evil NN 40436 9259 31 , , , 40436 9259 32 a a DT 40436 9259 33 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9259 34 choice choice NN 40436 9259 35 is be VBZ 40436 9259 36 required require VBN 40436 9259 37 -- -- : 40436 9259 38 while while IN 40436 9259 39 to to TO 40436 9259 40 obtain obtain VB 40436 9259 41 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9259 42 and and CC 40436 9259 43 avoid avoid VB 40436 9259 44 pain pain NN 40436 9259 45 , , , 40436 9259 46 is be VBZ 40436 9259 47 nothing nothing NN 40436 9259 48 more more JJR 40436 9259 49 than than IN 40436 9259 50 blind blind JJ 40436 9259 51 imitation imitation NN 40436 9259 52 or or CC 40436 9259 53 irrational irrational JJ 40436 9259 54 knack knack NN 40436 9259 55 . . . 40436 9260 1 There there EX 40436 9260 2 are be VBP 40436 9260 3 some some DT 40436 9260 4 arts art NNS 40436 9260 5 and and CC 40436 9260 6 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 9260 7 which which WDT 40436 9260 8 aim aim VBP 40436 9260 9 only only RB 40436 9260 10 at at IN 40436 9260 11 procuring procure VBG 40436 9260 12 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9260 13 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9260 14 -- -- : 40436 9260 15 others other NNS 40436 9260 16 which which WDT 40436 9260 17 aim aim VBP 40436 9260 18 at at IN 40436 9260 19 attaining attain VBG 40436 9260 20 good good NN 40436 9260 21 or or CC 40436 9260 22 the the DT 40436 9260 23 best;[94 best;[94 NNP 40436 9260 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9260 25 some some DT 40436 9260 26 arts art NNS 40436 9260 27 , , , 40436 9260 28 for for IN 40436 9260 29 a a DT 40436 9260 30 single single JJ 40436 9260 31 person,--others person,--other NNS 40436 9260 32 for for IN 40436 9260 33 a a DT 40436 9260 34 multitude multitude NN 40436 9260 35 . . . 40436 9261 1 Arts art NNS 40436 9261 2 and and CC 40436 9261 3 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 9261 4 which which WDT 40436 9261 5 aim aim VBP 40436 9261 6 only only RB 40436 9261 7 at at IN 40436 9261 8 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9261 9 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9261 10 , , , 40436 9261 11 either either CC 40436 9261 12 of of IN 40436 9261 13 one one CD 40436 9261 14 or or CC 40436 9261 15 of of IN 40436 9261 16 a a DT 40436 9261 17 multitude multitude NN 40436 9261 18 , , , 40436 9261 19 belong belong VB 40436 9261 20 to to IN 40436 9261 21 the the DT 40436 9261 22 general general JJ 40436 9261 23 head head NN 40436 9261 24 of of IN 40436 9261 25 Flattery Flattery NNP 40436 9261 26 . . . 40436 9262 1 Among among IN 40436 9262 2 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9262 3 are be VBP 40436 9262 4 all all PDT 40436 9262 5 the the DT 40436 9262 6 musical musical JJ 40436 9262 7 , , , 40436 9262 8 choric choric JJ 40436 9262 9 , , , 40436 9262 10 and and CC 40436 9262 11 dithyrambic dithyrambic JJ 40436 9262 12 representations representation NNS 40436 9262 13 at at IN 40436 9262 14 the the DT 40436 9262 15 festivals festival NNS 40436 9262 16 -- -- : 40436 9262 17 tragedy tragedy NN 40436 9262 18 as as RB 40436 9262 19 well well RB 40436 9262 20 as as IN 40436 9262 21 comedy comedy NN 40436 9262 22 -- -- : 40436 9262 23 also also RB 40436 9262 24 political political JJ 40436 9262 25 and and CC 40436 9262 26 judicial judicial JJ 40436 9262 27 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9262 28 . . . 40436 9263 1 None none NN 40436 9263 2 of of IN 40436 9263 3 these these DT 40436 9263 4 arts art NNS 40436 9263 5 aim aim VBP 40436 9263 6 at at IN 40436 9263 7 any any DT 40436 9263 8 thing thing NN 40436 9263 9 except except IN 40436 9263 10 to to TO 40436 9263 11 gratify gratify VB 40436 9263 12 the the DT 40436 9263 13 public public NN 40436 9263 14 to to IN 40436 9263 15 whom whom WP 40436 9263 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9263 17 are be VBP 40436 9263 18 addressed address VBN 40436 9263 19 : : : 40436 9263 20 none none NN 40436 9263 21 of of IN 40436 9263 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9263 23 aim aim VBP 40436 9263 24 at at IN 40436 9263 25 the the DT 40436 9263 26 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9263 27 good good NN 40436 9263 28 : : : 40436 9263 29 none none NN 40436 9263 30 seek seek VB 40436 9263 31 to to TO 40436 9263 32 better better VB 40436 9263 33 the the DT 40436 9263 34 character character NN 40436 9263 35 of of IN 40436 9263 36 the the DT 40436 9263 37 public public NN 40436 9263 38 . . . 40436 9264 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9264 2 adapt adapt VBP 40436 9264 3 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9264 4 to to IN 40436 9264 5 the the DT 40436 9264 6 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 9264 7 desires desire NNS 40436 9264 8 : : : 40436 9264 9 but but CC 40436 9264 10 whether whether IN 40436 9264 11 those those DT 40436 9264 12 desires desire NNS 40436 9264 13 are be VBP 40436 9264 14 such such JJ 40436 9264 15 as as IN 40436 9264 16 , , , 40436 9264 17 if if IN 40436 9264 18 realised realise VBN 40436 9264 19 , , , 40436 9264 20 will will MD 40436 9264 21 make make VB 40436 9264 22 the the DT 40436 9264 23 public public NN 40436 9264 24 worse worse RBR 40436 9264 25 or or CC 40436 9264 26 better well RBR 40436 9264 27 , , , 40436 9264 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9264 29 never never RB 40436 9264 30 enquire enquire VBP 40436 9264 31 . . . 40436 9265 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9265 2 95 95 CD 40436 9265 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9265 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9265 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9265 6 94 94 CD 40436 9265 7 : : : 40436 9265 8 The the DT 40436 9265 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9265 10 of of IN 40436 9265 11 the the DT 40436 9265 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9265 13 would would MD 40436 9265 14 have have VB 40436 9265 15 admitted admit VBN 40436 9265 16 a a DT 40436 9265 17 twofold twofold JJ 40436 9265 18 distinction distinction NN 40436 9265 19 of of IN 40436 9265 20 aims aim NNS 40436 9265 21 , , , 40436 9265 22 but but CC 40436 9265 23 would would MD 40436 9265 24 have have VB 40436 9265 25 stated state VBN 40436 9265 26 the the DT 40436 9265 27 distinction distinction NN 40436 9265 28 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 9265 29 . . . 40436 9266 1 Two two CD 40436 9266 2 things thing NNS 40436 9266 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9266 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9266 5 would would MD 40436 9266 6 say say VB 40436 9266 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9266 8 may may MD 40436 9266 9 be be VB 40436 9266 10 looked look VBN 40436 9266 11 at at IN 40436 9266 12 in in IN 40436 9266 13 regard regard NN 40436 9266 14 to to IN 40436 9266 15 any any DT 40436 9266 16 course course NN 40436 9266 17 of of IN 40436 9266 18 conduct conduct NN 40436 9266 19 : : : 40436 9266 20 first first RB 40436 9266 21 , , , 40436 9266 22 the the DT 40436 9266 23 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9266 24 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9266 25 or or CC 40436 9266 26 pain pain NN 40436 9266 27 which which WDT 40436 9266 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9266 29 yields yield VBZ 40436 9266 30 ; ; : 40436 9266 31 secondly secondly RB 40436 9266 32 , , , 40436 9266 33 this this DT 40436 9266 34 item item NN 40436 9266 35 , , , 40436 9266 36 not not RB 40436 9266 37 alone alone JJ 40436 9266 38 , , , 40436 9266 39 but but CC 40436 9266 40 combined combine VBN 40436 9266 41 with with IN 40436 9266 42 all all PDT 40436 9266 43 the the DT 40436 9266 44 other other JJ 40436 9266 45 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9266 46 and and CC 40436 9266 47 pains pain NNS 40436 9266 48 which which WDT 40436 9266 49 can can MD 40436 9266 50 be be VB 40436 9266 51 foreseen foresee VBN 40436 9266 52 as as IN 40436 9266 53 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9266 54 conditions condition NNS 40436 9266 55 , , , 40436 9266 56 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9266 57 , , , 40436 9266 58 or or CC 40436 9266 59 concomitants concomitant NNS 40436 9266 60 . . . 40436 9267 1 To to TO 40436 9267 2 obey obey VB 40436 9267 3 the the DT 40436 9267 4 desire desire NN 40436 9267 5 of of IN 40436 9267 6 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9267 7 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9267 8 , , , 40436 9267 9 or or CC 40436 9267 10 the the DT 40436 9267 11 fear fear NN 40436 9267 12 of of IN 40436 9267 13 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9267 14 pain pain NN 40436 9267 15 , , , 40436 9267 16 requires require VBZ 40436 9267 17 no no DT 40436 9267 18 science science NN 40436 9267 19 ; ; : 40436 9267 20 to to TO 40436 9267 21 foresee foresee VB 40436 9267 22 , , , 40436 9267 23 estimate estimate VB 40436 9267 24 , , , 40436 9267 25 and and CC 40436 9267 26 compare compare VB 40436 9267 27 the the DT 40436 9267 28 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9267 29 , , , 40436 9267 30 requires require VBZ 40436 9267 31 a a DT 40436 9267 32 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9267 33 calculation calculation NN 40436 9267 34 often often RB 40436 9267 35 very very RB 40436 9267 36 difficult difficult JJ 40436 9267 37 and and CC 40436 9267 38 complicated complicated JJ 40436 9267 39 -- -- : 40436 9267 40 a a DT 40436 9267 41 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9267 42 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9267 43 : : : 40436 9267 44 te te NNP 40436 9267 45 / / SYM 40436 9267 46 chnê chnê NNP 40436 9267 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9267 48 or or CC 40436 9267 49 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9267 50 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9267 51 : : : 40436 9267 52 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 9267 53 / / SYM 40436 9267 54 mê mê NNP 40436 9267 55 metrêtikê/ metrêtikê/ NNP 40436 9267 56 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9267 57 . . . 40436 9268 1 Thus thus RB 40436 9268 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9268 3 are be VBP 40436 9268 4 told tell VBN 40436 9268 5 not not RB 40436 9268 6 only only RB 40436 9268 7 in in IN 40436 9268 8 what what WP 40436 9268 9 cases case NNS 40436 9268 10 the the DT 40436 9268 11 calculation calculation NN 40436 9268 12 is be VBZ 40436 9268 13 required require VBN 40436 9268 14 , , , 40436 9268 15 but but CC 40436 9268 16 what what WP 40436 9268 17 are be VBP 40436 9268 18 the the DT 40436 9268 19 elements element NNS 40436 9268 20 to to TO 40436 9268 21 be be VB 40436 9268 22 taken take VBN 40436 9268 23 into into IN 40436 9268 24 the the DT 40436 9268 25 calculation calculation NN 40436 9268 26 . . . 40436 9269 1 In in IN 40436 9269 2 the the DT 40436 9269 3 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9269 4 , , , 40436 9269 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9269 6 are be VBP 40436 9269 7 not not RB 40436 9269 8 told tell VBN 40436 9269 9 on on IN 40436 9269 10 what what WP 40436 9269 11 elements element VBZ 40436 9269 12 the the DT 40436 9269 13 calculation calculation NN 40436 9269 14 of of IN 40436 9269 15 good good JJ 40436 9269 16 and and CC 40436 9269 17 evil evil NN 40436 9269 18 is be VBZ 40436 9269 19 to to TO 40436 9269 20 be be VB 40436 9269 21 based base VBN 40436 9269 22 : : : 40436 9269 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9269 24 are be VBP 40436 9269 25 told tell VBN 40436 9269 26 that that IN 40436 9269 27 there there EX 40436 9269 28 _ _ NNP 40436 9269 29 must must MD 40436 9269 30 be be VB 40436 9269 31 science science NN 40436 9269 32 _ _ NNP 40436 9269 33 , , , 40436 9269 34 but but CC 40436 9269 35 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9269 36 learn learn VBP 40436 9269 37 nothing nothing NN 40436 9269 38 more more JJR 40436 9269 39 . . . 40436 9269 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9270 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9270 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9270 3 95 95 CD 40436 9270 4 : : : 40436 9270 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9270 6 , , , 40436 9270 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9270 8 , , , 40436 9270 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9270 10 . . . 40436 9271 1 502 502 CD 40436 9271 2 - - SYM 40436 9271 3 503 503 CD 40436 9271 4 . . . 40436 9271 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9272 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9272 2 Side side NN 40436 9272 3 - - HYPH 40436 9272 4 note note NN 40436 9272 5 : : : 40436 9272 6 The the DT 40436 9272 7 Rhetors Rhetors NNPS 40436 9272 8 aim aim VBP 40436 9272 9 at at IN 40436 9272 10 only only RB 40436 9272 11 flattering flatter VBG 40436 9272 12 the the DT 40436 9272 13 public public NN 40436 9272 14 -- -- : 40436 9272 15 even even RB 40436 9272 16 the the DT 40436 9272 17 best good JJS 40436 9272 18 past past JJ 40436 9272 19 Rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 9272 20 have have VBP 40436 9272 21 done do VBN 40436 9272 22 nothing nothing NN 40436 9272 23 else else RB 40436 9272 24 -- -- : 40436 9272 25 citation citation NN 40436 9272 26 of of IN 40436 9272 27 the the DT 40436 9272 28 four four CD 40436 9272 29 great great JJ 40436 9272 30 Rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 9272 31 by by IN 40436 9272 32 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 9272 33 . . . 40436 9272 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9273 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9273 2 Sokr._--Do Sokr._--Do NNP 40436 9273 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9273 4 know know VBP 40436 9273 5 any any DT 40436 9273 6 public public JJ 40436 9273 7 speakers speaker NNS 40436 9273 8 who who WP 40436 9273 9 aim aim VBP 40436 9273 10 at at IN 40436 9273 11 anything anything NN 40436 9273 12 more more JJR 40436 9273 13 than than IN 40436 9273 14 gratifying gratify VBG 40436 9273 15 the the DT 40436 9273 16 public public NN 40436 9273 17 , , , 40436 9273 18 or or CC 40436 9273 19 who who WP 40436 9273 20 care care VBP 40436 9273 21 to to TO 40436 9273 22 make make VB 40436 9273 23 the the DT 40436 9273 24 public public NN 40436 9273 25 better well RBR 40436 9273 26 ? ? . 40436 9274 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9274 2 Kall._--There Kall._--There NNP 40436 9274 3 are be VBP 40436 9274 4 some some DT 40436 9274 5 who who WP 40436 9274 6 do do VBP 40436 9274 7 , , , 40436 9274 8 and and CC 40436 9274 9 others other NNS 40436 9274 10 who who WP 40436 9274 11 do do VBP 40436 9274 12 not not RB 40436 9274 13 . . . 40436 9275 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9275 2 Sokr._--Which Sokr._--Which NNP 40436 9275 3 are be VBP 40436 9275 4 those those DT 40436 9275 5 who who WP 40436 9275 6 do do VBP 40436 9275 7 ? ? . 40436 9276 1 and and CC 40436 9276 2 which which WDT 40436 9276 3 of of IN 40436 9276 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9276 5 has have VBZ 40436 9276 6 ever ever RB 40436 9276 7 made make VBN 40436 9276 8 the the DT 40436 9276 9 public public NN 40436 9276 10 better better RB 40436 9276 11 ? ? . 40436 9277 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9277 2 96 96 CD 40436 9277 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9277 4 _ _ NNP 40436 9277 5 Kall._--At Kall._--At NNP 40436 9277 6 any any DT 40436 9277 7 rate rate NN 40436 9277 8 , , , 40436 9277 9 former former JJ 40436 9277 10 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 9277 11 did do VBD 40436 9277 12 so so RB 40436 9277 13 ; ; : 40436 9277 14 such such JJ 40436 9277 15 as as IN 40436 9277 16 Miltiades Miltiades NNP 40436 9277 17 , , , 40436 9277 18 Themistokles Themistokles NNP 40436 9277 19 , , , 40436 9277 20 Kimon Kimon NNP 40436 9277 21 , , , 40436 9277 22 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9277 23 . . . 40436 9278 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9278 2 Sokr._--None Sokr._--None NNP 40436 9278 3 of of IN 40436 9278 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9278 5 . . . 40436 9279 1 If if IN 40436 9279 2 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9279 3 had have VBD 40436 9279 4 , , , 40436 9279 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9279 6 would would MD 40436 9279 7 have have VB 40436 9279 8 seen see VBN 40436 9279 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9279 10 devoting devote VBG 40436 9279 11 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9279 12 systematically systematically RB 40436 9279 13 and and CC 40436 9279 14 obviously obviously RB 40436 9279 15 to to IN 40436 9279 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9279 17 one one CD 40436 9279 18 end end NN 40436 9279 19 . . . 40436 9280 1 As as IN 40436 9280 2 a a DT 40436 9280 3 builder builder NN 40436 9280 4 labours labour VBZ 40436 9280 5 to to TO 40436 9280 6 construct construct VB 40436 9280 7 a a DT 40436 9280 8 ship ship NN 40436 9280 9 or or CC 40436 9280 10 a a DT 40436 9280 11 house house NN 40436 9280 12 , , , 40436 9280 13 by by IN 40436 9280 14 putting put VBG 40436 9280 15 together together RB 40436 9280 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9280 17 various various JJ 40436 9280 18 parts part NNS 40436 9280 19 with with IN 40436 9280 20 order order NN 40436 9280 21 and and CC 40436 9280 22 symmetry symmetry NN 40436 9280 23 -- -- : 40436 9280 24 so so IN 40436 9280 25 these these DT 40436 9280 26 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 9280 27 would would MD 40436 9280 28 have have VB 40436 9280 29 laboured labour VBN 40436 9280 30 to to TO 40436 9280 31 implant implant VB 40436 9280 32 order order NN 40436 9280 33 and and CC 40436 9280 34 symmetry symmetry VB 40436 9280 35 in in IN 40436 9280 36 the the DT 40436 9280 37 minds mind NNS 40436 9280 38 and and CC 40436 9280 39 bodies body NNS 40436 9280 40 of of IN 40436 9280 41 the the DT 40436 9280 42 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9280 43 : : : 40436 9280 44 that that RB 40436 9280 45 is is RB 40436 9280 46 , , , 40436 9280 47 justice justice NN 40436 9280 48 and and CC 40436 9280 49 temperance temperance NN 40436 9280 50 in in IN 40436 9280 51 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9280 52 minds mind NNS 40436 9280 53 , , , 40436 9280 54 health health NN 40436 9280 55 and and CC 40436 9280 56 strength strength NN 40436 9280 57 in in IN 40436 9280 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9280 59 bodies body NNS 40436 9280 60 . . . 40436 9281 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9281 2 97 97 CD 40436 9281 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9281 4 Unless unless IN 40436 9281 5 the the DT 40436 9281 6 statesman statesman NN 40436 9281 7 can can MD 40436 9281 8 do do VB 40436 9281 9 this this DT 40436 9281 10 , , , 40436 9281 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9281 12 is be VBZ 40436 9281 13 fruitless fruitless JJ 40436 9281 14 to to TO 40436 9281 15 supply supply VB 40436 9281 16 the the DT 40436 9281 17 wants want NNS 40436 9281 18 , , , 40436 9281 19 to to TO 40436 9281 20 fulfil fulfil VB 40436 9281 21 the the DT 40436 9281 22 desires desire NNS 40436 9281 23 and and CC 40436 9281 24 requirements requirement NNS 40436 9281 25 , , , 40436 9281 26 to to TO 40436 9281 27 uphold uphold VB 40436 9281 28 or or CC 40436 9281 29 enlarge enlarge VB 40436 9281 30 the the DT 40436 9281 31 power power NN 40436 9281 32 , , , 40436 9281 33 of of IN 40436 9281 34 the the DT 40436 9281 35 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9281 36 . . . 40436 9282 1 This this DT 40436 9282 2 is be VBZ 40436 9282 3 like like IN 40436 9282 4 supplying supply VBG 40436 9282 5 ample ample JJ 40436 9282 6 nourishment nourishment NN 40436 9282 7 to to IN 40436 9282 8 a a DT 40436 9282 9 distempered distemper VBN 40436 9282 10 body body NN 40436 9282 11 : : : 40436 9282 12 the the DT 40436 9282 13 more more RBR 40436 9282 14 such such PDT 40436 9282 15 a a DT 40436 9282 16 body body NN 40436 9282 17 takes take VBZ 40436 9282 18 in in RP 40436 9282 19 , , , 40436 9282 20 the the DT 40436 9282 21 worse bad JJR 40436 9282 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9282 23 becomes become VBZ 40436 9282 24 . . . 40436 9283 1 The the DT 40436 9283 2 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9283 3 must must MD 40436 9283 4 be be VB 40436 9283 5 treated treat VBN 40436 9283 6 with with IN 40436 9283 7 refusal refusal NN 40436 9283 8 of of IN 40436 9283 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9283 10 wishes wish NNS 40436 9283 11 and and CC 40436 9283 12 with with IN 40436 9283 13 punishment punishment NN 40436 9283 14 , , , 40436 9283 15 until until IN 40436 9283 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9283 17 vices vice NNS 40436 9283 18 are be VBP 40436 9283 19 healed heal VBN 40436 9283 20 , , , 40436 9283 21 and and CC 40436 9283 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9283 23 become become VBP 40436 9283 24 good good JJ 40436 9283 25 . . . 40436 9284 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9284 2 98 98 CD 40436 9284 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9284 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9284 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9284 6 96 96 CD 40436 9284 7 : : : 40436 9284 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9284 9 , , , 40436 9284 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9284 11 , , , 40436 9284 12 p. p. NN 40436 9284 13 503 503 CD 40436 9284 14 C. C. NNP 40436 9284 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9284 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9284 17 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9284 18 97 97 CD 40436 9284 19 : : : 40436 9284 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9284 21 , , , 40436 9284 22 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9284 23 , , , 40436 9284 24 p. p. NN 40436 9284 25 504 504 CD 40436 9284 26 D. D. NNP 40436 9284 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9284 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9284 29 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9284 30 98 98 CD 40436 9284 31 : : : 40436 9284 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9284 33 , , , 40436 9284 34 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9284 35 , , , 40436 9284 36 p. p. NN 40436 9284 37 505 505 CD 40436 9284 38 B. b. NN 40436 9284 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9285 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9285 2 Side side NN 40436 9285 3 - - HYPH 40436 9285 4 note note NN 40436 9285 5 : : : 40436 9285 6 Necessity necessity NN 40436 9285 7 for for IN 40436 9285 8 temperance temperance NN 40436 9285 9 , , , 40436 9285 10 regulation regulation NN 40436 9285 11 , , , 40436 9285 12 order order NN 40436 9285 13 . . . 40436 9286 1 This this DT 40436 9286 2 is be VBZ 40436 9286 3 the the DT 40436 9286 4 condition condition NN 40436 9286 5 of of IN 40436 9286 6 virtue virtue NN 40436 9286 7 and and CC 40436 9286 8 happiness happiness NN 40436 9286 9 . . . 40436 9286 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9287 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9287 2 ought ought MD 40436 9287 3 to to TO 40436 9287 4 do do VB 40436 9287 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9287 6 continues continue VBZ 40436 9287 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9287 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9287 9 what what WP 40436 9287 10 is be VBZ 40436 9287 11 pleasing pleasing JJ 40436 9287 12 for for IN 40436 9287 13 the the DT 40436 9287 14 sake sake NN 40436 9287 15 of of IN 40436 9287 16 what what WP 40436 9287 17 is be VBZ 40436 9287 18 good good JJ 40436 9287 19 : : : 40436 9287 20 not not RB 40436 9287 21 _ _ NNP 40436 9287 22 vice vice NN 40436 9287 23 versà versà NN 40436 9287 24 _ _ NNP 40436 9287 25 . . . 40436 9288 1 But but CC 40436 9288 2 every every DT 40436 9288 3 thing thing NN 40436 9288 4 becomes become VBZ 40436 9288 5 good good JJ 40436 9288 6 by by IN 40436 9288 7 possessing possess VBG 40436 9288 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9288 9 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 9288 10 virtue virtue NN 40436 9288 11 or or CC 40436 9288 12 regulation regulation NN 40436 9288 13 . . . 40436 9289 1 The the DT 40436 9289 2 regulation regulation NN 40436 9289 3 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 9289 4 to to IN 40436 9289 5 the the DT 40436 9289 6 mind mind NN 40436 9289 7 is be VBZ 40436 9289 8 to to TO 40436 9289 9 be be VB 40436 9289 10 temperate temperate NN 40436 9289 11 . . . 40436 9290 1 The the DT 40436 9290 2 temperate temperate NN 40436 9290 3 man man NN 40436 9290 4 will will MD 40436 9290 5 do do VB 40436 9290 6 what what WP 40436 9290 7 is be VBZ 40436 9290 8 just just RB 40436 9290 9 -- -- : 40436 9290 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9290 11 duty duty NN 40436 9290 12 towards towards IN 40436 9290 13 men man NNS 40436 9290 14 : : : 40436 9290 15 and and CC 40436 9290 16 what what WP 40436 9290 17 is be VBZ 40436 9290 18 holy holy JJ 40436 9290 19 -- -- : 40436 9290 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9290 21 duty duty NN 40436 9290 22 towards towards IN 40436 9290 23 the the DT 40436 9290 24 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 9290 25 . . . 40436 9291 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9291 2 will will MD 40436 9291 3 be be VB 40436 9291 4 just just RB 40436 9291 5 and and CC 40436 9291 6 holy holy JJ 40436 9291 7 . . . 40436 9292 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9292 2 will will MD 40436 9292 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 9292 4 also also RB 40436 9292 5 be be VB 40436 9292 6 courageous courageous JJ 40436 9292 7 : : : 40436 9292 8 for for IN 40436 9292 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9292 10 will will MD 40436 9292 11 seek seek VB 40436 9292 12 only only RB 40436 9292 13 such such JJ 40436 9292 14 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9292 15 as as IN 40436 9292 16 duty duty NN 40436 9292 17 permits permit NNS 40436 9292 18 , , , 40436 9292 19 and and CC 40436 9292 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9292 21 will will MD 40436 9292 22 endure endure VB 40436 9292 23 all all DT 40436 9292 24 such such JJ 40436 9292 25 pains pain NNS 40436 9292 26 as as IN 40436 9292 27 duty duty NN 40436 9292 28 requires require VBZ 40436 9292 29 . . . 40436 9293 1 Being be VBG 40436 9293 2 thus thus RB 40436 9293 3 temperate temperate NN 40436 9293 4 , , , 40436 9293 5 just just RB 40436 9293 6 , , , 40436 9293 7 brave brave JJ 40436 9293 8 , , , 40436 9293 9 holy holy JJ 40436 9293 10 , , , 40436 9293 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9293 12 will will MD 40436 9293 13 be be VB 40436 9293 14 a a DT 40436 9293 15 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 9293 16 good good JJ 40436 9293 17 man man NN 40436 9293 18 , , , 40436 9293 19 doing do VBG 40436 9293 20 well well RB 40436 9293 21 and and CC 40436 9293 22 honourably honourably RB 40436 9293 23 throughout throughout IN 40436 9293 24 . . . 40436 9294 1 The the DT 40436 9294 2 man man NN 40436 9294 3 who who WP 40436 9294 4 does do VBZ 40436 9294 5 well well RB 40436 9294 6 , , , 40436 9294 7 will will MD 40436 9294 8 be be VB 40436 9294 9 happy happy JJ 40436 9294 10 : : : 40436 9294 11 the the DT 40436 9294 12 man man NN 40436 9294 13 who who WP 40436 9294 14 does do VBZ 40436 9294 15 ill ill RB 40436 9294 16 and and CC 40436 9294 17 is be VBZ 40436 9294 18 wicked wicked JJ 40436 9294 19 , , , 40436 9294 20 will will MD 40436 9294 21 be be VB 40436 9294 22 miserable miserable JJ 40436 9294 23 . . . 40436 9295 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9295 2 99 99 CD 40436 9295 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9295 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9295 5 ought ought MD 40436 9295 6 to to TO 40436 9295 7 be be VB 40436 9295 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9295 9 principal principal JJ 40436 9295 10 aim aim NN 40436 9295 11 , , , 40436 9295 12 both both DT 40436 9295 13 for for IN 40436 9295 14 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9295 15 individually individually RB 40436 9295 16 and and CC 40436 9295 17 for for IN 40436 9295 18 the the DT 40436 9295 19 city city NN 40436 9295 20 , , , 40436 9295 21 to to TO 40436 9295 22 attain attain VB 40436 9295 23 temperance temperance NN 40436 9295 24 and and CC 40436 9295 25 to to TO 40436 9295 26 keep keep VB 40436 9295 27 clear clear JJ 40436 9295 28 of of IN 40436 9295 29 intemperance intemperance NN 40436 9295 30 : : : 40436 9295 31 not not RB 40436 9295 32 to to TO 40436 9295 33 let let VB 40436 9295 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9295 35 desires desire NNS 40436 9295 36 run run VB 40436 9295 37 immoderately immoderately RB 40436 9295 38 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9295 39 as as IN 40436 9295 40 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9295 41 , , , 40436 9295 42 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 9295 43 , , , 40436 9295 44 advise advise VBP 40436 9295 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9295 46 , , , 40436 9295 47 and and CC 40436 9295 48 then then RB 40436 9295 49 seek seek VB 40436 9295 50 repletion repletion NN 40436 9295 51 for for IN 40436 9295 52 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9295 53 : : : 40436 9295 54 which which WDT 40436 9295 55 is be VBZ 40436 9295 56 an an DT 40436 9295 57 endless endless JJ 40436 9295 58 mischief mischief NN 40436 9295 59 , , , 40436 9295 60 the the DT 40436 9295 61 life life NN 40436 9295 62 of of IN 40436 9295 63 a a DT 40436 9295 64 pirate pirate NN 40436 9295 65 . . . 40436 9296 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9296 2 who who WP 40436 9296 3 pursues pursue VBZ 40436 9296 4 this this DT 40436 9296 5 plan plan NN 40436 9296 6 can can MD 40436 9296 7 neither neither CC 40436 9296 8 be be VB 40436 9296 9 the the DT 40436 9296 10 friend friend NN 40436 9296 11 of of IN 40436 9296 12 any any DT 40436 9296 13 other other JJ 40436 9296 14 man man NN 40436 9296 15 , , , 40436 9296 16 nor nor CC 40436 9296 17 of of IN 40436 9296 18 the the DT 40436 9296 19 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 9296 20 : : : 40436 9296 21 for for IN 40436 9296 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9296 23 is be VBZ 40436 9296 24 incapable incapable JJ 40436 9296 25 of of IN 40436 9296 26 communion communion NN 40436 9296 27 , , , 40436 9296 28 and and CC 40436 9296 29 therefore therefore RB 40436 9296 30 of of IN 40436 9296 31 friendship friendship NN 40436 9296 32 . . . 40436 9297 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9297 2 100 100 CD 40436 9297 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9297 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9297 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9297 6 99 99 CD 40436 9297 7 : : : 40436 9297 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9297 9 , , , 40436 9297 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9297 11 , , , 40436 9297 12 p p NN 40436 9297 13 , , , 40436 9297 14 507 507 CD 40436 9297 15 D d NN 40436 9297 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9297 17 with with IN 40436 9297 18 Routh Routh NNP 40436 9297 19 and and CC 40436 9297 20 Heindorf Heindorf NNP 40436 9297 21 's 's POS 40436 9297 22 notes note NNS 40436 9297 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9297 24 . . . 40436 9297 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9298 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9298 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9298 3 100 100 CD 40436 9298 4 : : : 40436 9298 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9298 6 , , , 40436 9298 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9298 8 , , , 40436 9298 9 p. p. NN 40436 9298 10 507 507 CD 40436 9298 11 E. E. NNP 40436 9298 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9298 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9298 14 : : : 40436 9298 15 koinônei koinônei NNP 40436 9298 16 = = SYM 40436 9298 17 n n CC 40436 9298 18 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9298 19 a)du a)du NN 40436 9298 20 / / SYM 40436 9298 21 natos nato NNS 40436 9298 22 ; ; : 40436 9298 23 o(/tô| o(/tô| NNP 40436 9298 24 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9298 25 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 9298 26 e(/ni e(/ni NN 40436 9298 27 koinôni koinôni NNP 40436 9298 28 / / SYM 40436 9298 29 a a DT 40436 9298 30 , , , 40436 9298 31 phili phili NNP 40436 9298 32 / / SYM 40436 9298 33 a a DT 40436 9298 34 ou)k ou)k JJ 40436 9298 35 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9298 36 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 9298 37 . . . 40436 9298 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9298 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9299 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9299 2 Side side NN 40436 9299 3 - - HYPH 40436 9299 4 note note NN 40436 9299 5 : : : 40436 9299 6 Impossible impossible JJ 40436 9299 7 to to TO 40436 9299 8 succeed succeed VB 40436 9299 9 in in IN 40436 9299 10 public public JJ 40436 9299 11 life life NN 40436 9299 12 , , , 40436 9299 13 unless unless IN 40436 9299 14 a a DT 40436 9299 15 man man NN 40436 9299 16 be be VB 40436 9299 17 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 9299 18 akin akin JJ 40436 9299 19 to to IN 40436 9299 20 and and CC 40436 9299 21 in in IN 40436 9299 22 harmony harmony NN 40436 9299 23 with with IN 40436 9299 24 the the DT 40436 9299 25 ruling rule VBG 40436 9299 26 force force NN 40436 9299 27 . . . 40436 9299 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9300 1 Now now RB 40436 9300 2 , , , 40436 9300 3 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 9300 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9300 5 pursues pursue VBZ 40436 9300 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9300 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9300 8 , , , 40436 9300 9 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9300 10 have have VBP 40436 9300 11 reproached reproach VBN 40436 9300 12 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9300 13 with with IN 40436 9300 14 standing stand VBG 40436 9300 15 aloof aloof NN 40436 9300 16 from from IN 40436 9300 17 public public JJ 40436 9300 18 life life NN 40436 9300 19 in in IN 40436 9300 20 order order NN 40436 9300 21 to to TO 40436 9300 22 pursue pursue VB 40436 9300 23 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9300 24 . . . 40436 9301 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 9301 2 tell tell VBP 40436 9301 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9301 4 that that IN 40436 9301 5 by by IN 40436 9301 6 not not RB 40436 9301 7 cultivating cultivate VBG 40436 9301 8 public public JJ 40436 9301 9 speaking speaking NN 40436 9301 10 and and CC 40436 9301 11 public public JJ 40436 9301 12 action action NN 40436 9301 13 , , , 40436 9301 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9301 15 am be VBP 40436 9301 16 at at IN 40436 9301 17 the the DT 40436 9301 18 mercy mercy NN 40436 9301 19 of of IN 40436 9301 20 any any DT 40436 9301 21 one one NN 40436 9301 22 who who WP 40436 9301 23 chooses choose VBZ 40436 9301 24 to to TO 40436 9301 25 accuse accuse VB 40436 9301 26 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9301 27 unjustly unjustly RB 40436 9301 28 and and CC 40436 9301 29 to to TO 40436 9301 30 bring bring VB 40436 9301 31 upon upon IN 40436 9301 32 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9301 33 severe severe JJ 40436 9301 34 penalties penalty NNS 40436 9301 35 . . . 40436 9302 1 But but CC 40436 9302 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9302 3 tell tell VBP 40436 9302 4 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9302 5 , , , 40436 9302 6 that that IN 40436 9302 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9302 8 is be VBZ 40436 9302 9 a a DT 40436 9302 10 greater great JJR 40436 9302 11 evil evil NN 40436 9302 12 to to TO 40436 9302 13 do do VB 40436 9302 14 wrong wrong NN 40436 9302 15 than than IN 40436 9302 16 to to TO 40436 9302 17 suffer suffer VB 40436 9302 18 wrong wrong JJ 40436 9302 19 ; ; : 40436 9302 20 and and CC 40436 9302 21 that that IN 40436 9302 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9302 23 first first JJ 40436 9302 24 business business NN 40436 9302 25 is be VBZ 40436 9302 26 , , , 40436 9302 27 to to TO 40436 9302 28 provide provide VB 40436 9302 29 for for IN 40436 9302 30 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9302 31 such such JJ 40436 9302 32 power power NN 40436 9302 33 and and CC 40436 9302 34 such such JJ 40436 9302 35 skill skill NN 40436 9302 36 as as IN 40436 9302 37 shall shall MD 40436 9302 38 guard guard VB 40436 9302 39 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9302 40 against against IN 40436 9302 41 doing do VBG 40436 9302 42 wrong wrong NN 40436 9302 43 . . . 40436 9303 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9303 2 101 101 CD 40436 9303 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9303 4 Next next RB 40436 9303 5 , , , 40436 9303 6 as as IN 40436 9303 7 to to IN 40436 9303 8 suffering suffer VBG 40436 9303 9 wrong wrong RB 40436 9303 10 , , , 40436 9303 11 there there EX 40436 9303 12 is be VBZ 40436 9303 13 only only RB 40436 9303 14 one one CD 40436 9303 15 way way NN 40436 9303 16 of of IN 40436 9303 17 taking take VBG 40436 9303 18 precautions precaution NNS 40436 9303 19 against against IN 40436 9303 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9303 21 . . . 40436 9304 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 9304 2 must must MD 40436 9304 3 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 9304 4 rule rule VB 40436 9304 5 in in IN 40436 9304 6 the the DT 40436 9304 7 city city NN 40436 9304 8 : : : 40436 9304 9 or or CC 40436 9304 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9304 11 must must MD 40436 9304 12 be be VB 40436 9304 13 a a DT 40436 9304 14 friend friend NN 40436 9304 15 of of IN 40436 9304 16 the the DT 40436 9304 17 ruling rule VBG 40436 9304 18 power power NN 40436 9304 19 . . . 40436 9305 1 Like like UH 40436 9305 2 is be VBZ 40436 9305 3 the the DT 40436 9305 4 friend friend NN 40436 9305 5 of of IN 40436 9305 6 like:[102 like:[102 NN 40436 9305 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9305 8 a a DT 40436 9305 9 cruel cruel JJ 40436 9305 10 despot despot NN 40436 9305 11 on on IN 40436 9305 12 the the DT 40436 9305 13 throne throne NN 40436 9305 14 will will MD 40436 9305 15 hate hate VB 40436 9305 16 and and CC 40436 9305 17 destroy destroy VB 40436 9305 18 any any DT 40436 9305 19 one one NN 40436 9305 20 who who WP 40436 9305 21 is be VBZ 40436 9305 22 better well JJR 40436 9305 23 than than IN 40436 9305 24 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9305 25 , , , 40436 9305 26 and and CC 40436 9305 27 will will MD 40436 9305 28 despise despise VB 40436 9305 29 any any DT 40436 9305 30 one one NN 40436 9305 31 worse bad JJR 40436 9305 32 than than IN 40436 9305 33 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9305 34 . . . 40436 9306 1 The the DT 40436 9306 2 only only JJ 40436 9306 3 person person NN 40436 9306 4 who who WP 40436 9306 5 will will MD 40436 9306 6 have have VB 40436 9306 7 influence influence NN 40436 9306 8 is be VBZ 40436 9306 9 , , , 40436 9306 10 one one CD 40436 9306 11 of of IN 40436 9306 12 the the DT 40436 9306 13 same same JJ 40436 9306 14 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 9306 15 as as IN 40436 9306 16 the the DT 40436 9306 17 despot despot NN 40436 9306 18 : : : 40436 9306 19 not not RB 40436 9306 20 only only RB 40436 9306 21 submitting submit VBG 40436 9306 22 to to IN 40436 9306 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9306 24 with with IN 40436 9306 25 good good JJ 40436 9306 26 will will NN 40436 9306 27 , , , 40436 9306 28 but but CC 40436 9306 29 praising praise VBG 40436 9306 30 and and CC 40436 9306 31 blaming blame VBG 40436 9306 32 the the DT 40436 9306 33 same same JJ 40436 9306 34 things thing NNS 40436 9306 35 as as IN 40436 9306 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9306 37 does do VBZ 40436 9306 38 -- -- : 40436 9306 39 accustomed accustom VBN 40436 9306 40 from from IN 40436 9306 41 youth youth NN 40436 9306 42 upwards upwards RB 40436 9306 43 to to TO 40436 9306 44 share share VB 40436 9306 45 in in IN 40436 9306 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9306 47 preferences preference NNS 40436 9306 48 and and CC 40436 9306 49 aversions aversion NNS 40436 9306 50 , , , 40436 9306 51 and and CC 40436 9306 52 assimilated assimilate VBD 40436 9306 53 to to IN 40436 9306 54 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9306 55 as as RB 40436 9306 56 much much RB 40436 9306 57 as as IN 40436 9306 58 possible possible JJ 40436 9306 59 . . . 40436 9307 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9307 2 103 103 CD 40436 9307 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9307 4 Now now RB 40436 9307 5 if if IN 40436 9307 6 the the DT 40436 9307 7 despot despot NN 40436 9307 8 be be VBP 40436 9307 9 a a DT 40436 9307 10 wrong wrong NN 40436 9307 11 - - HYPH 40436 9307 12 doer doer NN 40436 9307 13 , , , 40436 9307 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9307 15 who who WP 40436 9307 16 likens liken VBZ 40436 9307 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9307 18 to to IN 40436 9307 19 the the DT 40436 9307 20 despot despot NN 40436 9307 21 will will MD 40436 9307 22 become become VB 40436 9307 23 a a DT 40436 9307 24 wrong wrong NN 40436 9307 25 - - HYPH 40436 9307 26 doer doer NN 40436 9307 27 also also RB 40436 9307 28 . . . 40436 9308 1 And and CC 40436 9308 2 thus thus RB 40436 9308 3 , , , 40436 9308 4 in in IN 40436 9308 5 taking take VBG 40436 9308 6 precautions precaution NNS 40436 9308 7 against against IN 40436 9308 8 suffering suffer VBG 40436 9308 9 wrong wrong RB 40436 9308 10 , , , 40436 9308 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9308 12 will will MD 40436 9308 13 incur incur VB 40436 9308 14 the the DT 40436 9308 15 still still RB 40436 9308 16 greater great JJR 40436 9308 17 mischief mischief NN 40436 9308 18 and and CC 40436 9308 19 corruption corruption NN 40436 9308 20 of of IN 40436 9308 21 doing do VBG 40436 9308 22 wrong wrong NN 40436 9308 23 , , , 40436 9308 24 and and CC 40436 9308 25 will will MD 40436 9308 26 be be VB 40436 9308 27 worse bad JJR 40436 9308 28 off off RP 40436 9308 29 instead instead RB 40436 9308 30 of of IN 40436 9308 31 better well JJR 40436 9308 32 . . . 40436 9309 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9309 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9309 3 101 101 CD 40436 9309 4 : : : 40436 9309 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9309 6 , , , 40436 9309 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9309 8 , , , 40436 9309 9 p. p. NN 40436 9309 10 509 509 CD 40436 9309 11 C. C. NNP 40436 9309 12 Compare Compare NNP 40436 9309 13 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 9309 14 , , , 40436 9309 15 viii viii RB 40436 9309 16 . . . 40436 9310 1 829 829 CD 40436 9310 2 A a DT 40436 9310 3 , , , 40436 9310 4 where where WRB 40436 9310 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9310 6 Greek greek JJ 40436 9310 7 : : : 40436 9310 8 to\ to\ NN 40436 9310 9 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 9310 10 a)dikei a)dikei NNS 40436 9310 11 = = SYM 40436 9310 12 n n NN 40436 9310 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9310 14 is be VBZ 40436 9310 15 described describe VBN 40436 9310 16 as as IN 40436 9310 17 easy easy JJ 40436 9310 18 of of IN 40436 9310 19 attainment attainment JJ 40436 9310 20 ; ; : 40436 9310 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9310 22 Greek greek JJ 40436 9310 23 : : : 40436 9310 24 to\ to\ NN 40436 9310 25 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 9310 26 a)dikei a)dikei NNS 40436 9310 27 = = SYM 40436 9310 28 sthai sthai NNP 40436 9310 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9310 30 , , , 40436 9310 31 as as IN 40436 9310 32 being be VBG 40436 9310 33 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9310 34 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9310 35 : : : 40436 9310 36 pagcha pagcha NN 40436 9310 37 / / SYM 40436 9310 38 lepon lepon NNP 40436 9310 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9310 40 : : : 40436 9310 41 and and CC 40436 9310 42 both both DT 40436 9310 43 equally equally RB 40436 9310 44 necessary necessary JJ 40436 9310 45 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9310 46 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9310 47 : : : 40436 9310 48 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 9310 49 to\ to\ NN 40436 9310 50 eu)daimo eu)daimo NNP 40436 9310 51 / / SYM 40436 9310 52 nôs nôs NNP 40436 9310 53 zê=|n zê=|n CD 40436 9310 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9310 55 . . . 40436 9310 56 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9311 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9311 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9311 3 102 102 CD 40436 9311 4 : : : 40436 9311 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 9311 6 . . . 40436 9312 1 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 9312 2 . . . 40436 9313 1 510 510 CD 40436 9313 2 B. B. NNP 40436 9314 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9314 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9314 3 : : : 40436 9314 4 phi phi NNP 40436 9314 5 / / SYM 40436 9314 6 los los NNP 40436 9314 7 -- -- : 40436 9314 8 o o NNP 40436 9314 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9314 10 o(/moios o(/moios NNP 40436 9314 11 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9314 12 o(moi o(moi NNP 40436 9314 13 / / SYM 40436 9314 14 ô| ô| NNP 40436 9314 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9314 16 . . . 40436 9315 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9315 2 have have VBP 40436 9315 3 already already RB 40436 9315 4 seen see VBN 40436 9315 5 this this DT 40436 9315 6 principle principle NN 40436 9315 7 discussed discuss VBD 40436 9315 8 and and CC 40436 9315 9 rejected reject VBD 40436 9315 10 in in IN 40436 9315 11 the the DT 40436 9315 12 Lysis Lysis NNP 40436 9315 13 , , , 40436 9315 14 p. p. NN 40436 9315 15 214 214 CD 40436 9315 16 . . . 40436 9316 1 See see VB 40436 9316 2 above above RB 40436 9316 3 , , , 40436 9316 4 ch ch NN 40436 9316 5 . . . 40436 9317 1 xx xx NNP 40436 9317 2 . . NNP 40436 9317 3 , , , 40436 9317 4 p. p. NN 40436 9318 1 179 179 CD 40436 9318 2 . . . 40436 9318 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9319 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9319 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9319 3 103 103 CD 40436 9319 4 : : : 40436 9319 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9319 6 , , , 40436 9319 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9319 8 , , , 40436 9319 9 p. p. NN 40436 9319 10 510 510 CD 40436 9319 11 C. C. NNP 40436 9319 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9319 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9319 14 : : : 40436 9319 15 lei lei NNP 40436 9319 16 / / SYM 40436 9319 17 petai petai NNP 40436 9319 18 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 9319 19 e)kei e)kei ADD 40436 9319 20 = = NFP 40436 9319 21 nos nos NNP 40436 9319 22 mo mo NNP 40436 9319 23 / / SYM 40436 9319 24 nos nos NNP 40436 9319 25 a)/xios a)/xios NNP 40436 9319 26 lo lo NNP 40436 9319 27 / / SYM 40436 9319 28 gou gou NNP 40436 9319 29 phi phi NNP 40436 9319 30 / / SYM 40436 9319 31 los los NNP 40436 9319 32 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9319 33 toiou toiou NNP 40436 9319 34 / / SYM 40436 9319 35 tô| tô| NNP 40436 9319 36 , , , 40436 9319 37 o(\s o(\s NN 40436 9319 38 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9319 39 , , , 40436 9319 40 o(moê o(moê JJ 40436 9319 41 / / SYM 40436 9319 42 thês thês JJ 40436 9319 43 ô)/n ô)/n NNP 40436 9319 44 , , , 40436 9319 45 tau)ta\ tau)ta\ NNP 40436 9319 46 pse pse NNP 40436 9319 47 / / SYM 40436 9319 48 gôn gôn NNP 40436 9319 49 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9319 50 e)painô e)painô NNP 40436 9319 51 = = SYM 40436 9319 52 n n NN 40436 9319 53 , , , 40436 9319 54 e)the e)the NNP 40436 9319 55 / / SYM 40436 9319 56 lê| lê| NNP 40436 9319 57 a)/rchesthai a)/rchesthai IN 40436 9319 58 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9319 59 u(pokei u(pokei NNP 40436 9319 60 = = SYM 40436 9319 61 sthai sthai NNP 40436 9319 62 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9319 63 a)/rchonti a)/rchonti NNP 40436 9319 64 . . . 40436 9320 1 Ou(=tos ou(=tos RB 40436 9320 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9320 3 / / SYM 40436 9320 4 ga ga NNP 40436 9320 5 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9320 6 tau tau NNP 40436 9320 7 / / SYM 40436 9320 8 tê| tê| NNP 40436 9320 9 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 9320 10 po po NNP 40436 9320 11 / / SYM 40436 9320 12 lei lei NNP 40436 9320 13 dunê dunê NNP 40436 9320 14 / / SYM 40436 9320 15 setai setai NNP 40436 9320 16 , , , 40436 9320 17 tou tou NNP 40436 9320 18 = = SYM 40436 9320 19 ton ton NN 40436 9320 20 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s NNP 40436 9320 21 chai chai NNP 40436 9320 22 / / SYM 40436 9320 23 rôn rôn NNP 40436 9320 24 a)dikê a)dikê NNP 40436 9320 25 / / SYM 40436 9320 26 sei sei NN 40436 9320 27 . . . 40436 9321 1 . . . 40436 9322 1 . . . 40436 9323 1 . . . 40436 9324 1 Au(/tê Au(/tê NFP 40436 9324 2 o(do o(do NNP 40436 9324 3 / / SYM 40436 9324 4 s s NNP 40436 9324 5 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 9324 6 , , , 40436 9324 7 eu)thu\s eu)thu\s . 40436 9324 8 e)k e)k NNP 40436 9324 9 ve ve NNP 40436 9324 10 / / SYM 40436 9324 11 ou ou NNP 40436 9324 12 e)thi e)thi NNP 40436 9324 13 / / SYM 40436 9324 14 zein zein NNP 40436 9324 15 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 9324 16 toi toi NNP 40436 9324 17 = = SYM 40436 9324 18 s s NNP 40436 9324 19 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 9324 20 = = SYM 40436 9324 21 s s NNP 40436 9324 22 chai chai NNP 40436 9324 23 / / SYM 40436 9324 24 rein rein NNP 40436 9324 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9324 26 a)/chthesthtai a)/chthesthtai NNP 40436 9324 27 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9324 28 despo despo NNP 40436 9324 29 / / SYM 40436 9324 30 tê| tê| NNP 40436 9324 31 , , , 40436 9324 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9324 33 paraskeua paraskeua NNP 40436 9324 34 / / SYM 40436 9324 35 zein zein NNP 40436 9324 36 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 9324 37 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 9324 38 ti ti NNP 40436 9324 39 ma ma NNP 40436 9324 40 / / SYM 40436 9324 41 lista lista NNP 40436 9324 42 o(/moios o(/moios NNP 40436 9324 43 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 9324 44 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 9324 45 / / SYM 40436 9324 46 nô| nô| NNP 40436 9324 47 . . . 40436 9324 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9324 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9325 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9325 2 Side side NN 40436 9325 3 - - HYPH 40436 9325 4 note note NN 40436 9325 5 : : : 40436 9325 6 Danger danger NN 40436 9325 7 of of IN 40436 9325 8 one one CD 40436 9325 9 who who WP 40436 9325 10 dissents dissent VBZ 40436 9325 11 from from IN 40436 9325 12 the the DT 40436 9325 13 public public NN 40436 9325 14 , , , 40436 9325 15 either either CC 40436 9325 16 for for IN 40436 9325 17 better well JJR 40436 9325 18 or or CC 40436 9325 19 for for IN 40436 9325 20 worse bad JJR 40436 9325 21 . . . 40436 9325 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9326 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9326 2 Kall._--But Kall._--But NNP 40436 9326 3 if if IN 40436 9326 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9326 5 does do VBZ 40436 9326 6 not not RB 40436 9326 7 liken liken VB 40436 9326 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9326 9 to to IN 40436 9326 10 the the DT 40436 9326 11 despot despot NN 40436 9326 12 , , , 40436 9326 13 the the DT 40436 9326 14 despot despot NN 40436 9326 15 may may MD 40436 9326 16 put put VB 40436 9326 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9326 18 to to IN 40436 9326 19 death death NN 40436 9326 20 , , , 40436 9326 21 if if IN 40436 9326 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9326 23 chooses choose VBZ 40436 9326 24 ? ? . 40436 9327 1 _ _ NNP 40436 9327 2 Sokr._--Perhaps Sokr._--Perhaps NNP 40436 9327 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9327 4 may may MD 40436 9327 5 : : : 40436 9327 6 but but CC 40436 9327 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9327 8 will will MD 40436 9327 9 be be VB 40436 9327 10 death death NN 40436 9327 11 inflicted inflict VBN 40436 9327 12 by by IN 40436 9327 13 a a DT 40436 9327 14 bad bad JJ 40436 9327 15 man man NN 40436 9327 16 upon upon IN 40436 9327 17 a a DT 40436 9327 18 good good JJ 40436 9327 19 man man NN 40436 9327 20 . . . 40436 9328 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9328 2 104 104 CD 40436 9328 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9328 4 To to TO 40436 9328 5 prolong prolong JJ 40436 9328 6 life life NN 40436 9328 7 is be VBZ 40436 9328 8 not not RB 40436 9328 9 the the DT 40436 9328 10 foremost foremost JJ 40436 9328 11 consideration consideration NN 40436 9328 12 , , , 40436 9328 13 but but CC 40436 9328 14 to to TO 40436 9328 15 decide decide VB 40436 9328 16 by by IN 40436 9328 17 rational rational JJ 40436 9328 18 thought thought NN 40436 9328 19 what what WP 40436 9328 20 is be VBZ 40436 9328 21 the the DT 40436 9328 22 best good JJS 40436 9328 23 way way NN 40436 9328 24 of of IN 40436 9328 25 passing pass VBG 40436 9328 26 that that DT 40436 9328 27 length length NN 40436 9328 28 of of IN 40436 9328 29 life life NN 40436 9328 30 which which WDT 40436 9328 31 the the DT 40436 9328 32 Fates Fates NNPS 40436 9328 33 allot allot VBP 40436 9328 34 . . . 40436 9329 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9329 2 105 105 CD 40436 9329 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9329 4 Is be VBZ 40436 9329 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9329 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9329 7 best good JJS 40436 9329 8 plan plan NN 40436 9329 9 to to TO 40436 9329 10 do do VB 40436 9329 11 as as IN 40436 9329 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9329 13 recommend recommend VBP 40436 9329 14 , , , 40436 9329 15 and and CC 40436 9329 16 to to TO 40436 9329 17 liken liken VB 40436 9329 18 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9329 19 as as RB 40436 9329 20 much much RB 40436 9329 21 as as IN 40436 9329 22 possible possible JJ 40436 9329 23 to to IN 40436 9329 24 the the DT 40436 9329 25 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9329 26 people people NNS 40436 9329 27 -- -- : 40436 9329 28 in in IN 40436 9329 29 order order NN 40436 9329 30 that that IN 40436 9329 31 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9329 32 may may MD 40436 9329 33 become become VB 40436 9329 34 popular popular JJ 40436 9329 35 and and CC 40436 9329 36 may may MD 40436 9329 37 acquire acquire VB 40436 9329 38 power power NN 40436 9329 39 in in IN 40436 9329 40 the the DT 40436 9329 41 city city NN 40436 9329 42 ? ? . 40436 9330 1 For for IN 40436 9330 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9330 3 will will MD 40436 9330 4 be be VB 40436 9330 5 impossible impossible JJ 40436 9330 6 for for IN 40436 9330 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9330 8 to to TO 40436 9330 9 acquire acquire VB 40436 9330 10 power power NN 40436 9330 11 in in IN 40436 9330 12 the the DT 40436 9330 13 city city NN 40436 9330 14 , , , 40436 9330 15 if if IN 40436 9330 16 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9330 17 dissent dissent VBP 40436 9330 18 from from IN 40436 9330 19 the the DT 40436 9330 20 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 9330 21 political political JJ 40436 9330 22 character character NN 40436 9330 23 and and CC 40436 9330 24 practice practice NN 40436 9330 25 , , , 40436 9330 26 be be VB 40436 9330 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9330 28 for for IN 40436 9330 29 the the DT 40436 9330 30 better well JJR 40436 9330 31 or or CC 40436 9330 32 for for IN 40436 9330 33 the the DT 40436 9330 34 worse bad JJR 40436 9330 35 . . . 40436 9331 1 Even even RB 40436 9331 2 imitation imitation NN 40436 9331 3 will will MD 40436 9331 4 not not RB 40436 9331 5 be be VB 40436 9331 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 9331 7 : : : 40436 9331 8 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9331 9 must must MD 40436 9331 10 be be VB 40436 9331 11 , , , 40436 9331 12 by by IN 40436 9331 13 natural natural JJ 40436 9331 14 disposition disposition NN 40436 9331 15 , , , 40436 9331 16 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 40436 9331 17 with with IN 40436 9331 18 the the DT 40436 9331 19 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 9331 20 , , , 40436 9331 21 if if IN 40436 9331 22 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9331 23 intend intend VBP 40436 9331 24 to to TO 40436 9331 25 acquire acquire VB 40436 9331 26 much much JJ 40436 9331 27 favour favour NN 40436 9331 28 with with IN 40436 9331 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9331 30 . . . 40436 9332 1 Whoever whoever WP 40436 9332 2 makes make VBZ 40436 9332 3 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9332 4 most most RBS 40436 9332 5 like like VB 40436 9332 6 to to IN 40436 9332 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9332 8 , , , 40436 9332 9 will will MD 40436 9332 10 help help VB 40436 9332 11 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9332 12 forward forward RB 40436 9332 13 most most RBS 40436 9332 14 towards towards IN 40436 9332 15 becoming become VBG 40436 9332 16 an an DT 40436 9332 17 effective effective JJ 40436 9332 18 statesman statesman NN 40436 9332 19 and and CC 40436 9332 20 speaker speaker NN 40436 9332 21 : : : 40436 9332 22 for for IN 40436 9332 23 every every DT 40436 9332 24 assembly assembly NN 40436 9332 25 delight delight NN 40436 9332 26 in in IN 40436 9332 27 speeches speech NNS 40436 9332 28 suited suit VBN 40436 9332 29 to to IN 40436 9332 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9332 31 own own JJ 40436 9332 32 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 9332 33 , , , 40436 9332 34 and and CC 40436 9332 35 reject reject VBP 40436 9332 36 speeches speech NNS 40436 9332 37 of of IN 40436 9332 38 an an DT 40436 9332 39 opposite opposite JJ 40436 9332 40 tenor tenor NN 40436 9332 41 . . . 40436 9333 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9333 2 106 106 CD 40436 9333 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9333 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9333 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9333 6 104 104 CD 40436 9333 7 : : : 40436 9333 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9333 9 , , , 40436 9333 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9333 11 , , , 40436 9333 12 p. p. NN 40436 9333 13 511 511 CD 40436 9333 14 B. B. NNP 40436 9333 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9334 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9334 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9334 3 105 105 CD 40436 9334 4 : : : 40436 9334 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9334 6 , , , 40436 9334 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9334 8 , , , 40436 9334 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9334 10 . . . 40436 9335 1 511 511 CD 40436 9335 2 B b NN 40436 9335 3 , , , 40436 9335 4 512 512 CD 40436 9335 5 E. E. NNP 40436 9335 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9335 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9335 8 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9335 9 106 106 CD 40436 9335 10 : : : 40436 9335 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9335 12 , , , 40436 9335 13 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9335 14 , , , 40436 9335 15 p. p. NN 40436 9335 16 513 513 CD 40436 9335 17 A. a. NN 40436 9336 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9336 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9336 3 : : : 40436 9336 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9336 5 nu nu NNP 40436 9336 6 = = SYM 40436 9336 7 n n NNP 40436 9336 8 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9336 9 a)/ra a)/ra NFP 40436 9336 10 dei= dei= NNP 40436 9336 11 se se FW 40436 9336 12 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 9336 13 o(moio o(moio NNS 40436 9336 14 / / SYM 40436 9336 15 taton taton NNP 40436 9336 16 gi gi NNP 40436 9336 17 / / SYM 40436 9336 18 gnesthai gnesthai NNP 40436 9336 19 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9336 20 dêmô| dêmô| NNP 40436 9336 21 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9336 22 A)thênai A)thênai NNP 40436 9336 23 / / SYM 40436 9336 24 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9336 25 , , , 40436 9336 26 ei ei NNP 40436 9336 27 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9336 28 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9336 29 / / SYM 40436 9336 30 lleis lleis NNP 40436 9336 31 tou tou NNP 40436 9336 32 / / SYM 40436 9336 33 tô| tô| NNP 40436 9336 34 prosphilê\s prosphilê\s NNP 40436 9336 35 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 9336 36 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9336 37 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9336 38 / / SYM 40436 9336 39 ga ga NNP 40436 9336 40 du du NNP 40436 9336 41 / / SYM 40436 9336 42 nasthai nasthai NNP 40436 9336 43 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9336 44 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 9336 45 po po NNP 40436 9336 46 / / SYM 40436 9336 47 lei lei NN 40436 9336 48 . . . 40436 9337 1 . . . 40436 9338 1 . . . 40436 9339 1 . . . 40436 9340 1 ei ei NNP 40436 9340 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9340 3 de/ de/ NNP 40436 9340 4 soi soi NNP 40436 9340 5 oi)/ei oi)/ei NNP 40436 9340 6 o(ntinou o(ntinou NNP 40436 9340 7 = = SYM 40436 9340 8 n n NNP 40436 9340 9 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 9340 10 / / SYM 40436 9340 11 pôn pôn NNP 40436 9340 12 paradô paradô NNP 40436 9340 13 / / SYM 40436 9340 14 sein sein NNP 40436 9340 15 te te NNP 40436 9340 16 / / SYM 40436 9340 17 chnên chnên NNP 40436 9340 18 tina\ tina\ NNP 40436 9340 19 toiau toiau NNP 40436 9340 20 / / SYM 40436 9340 21 tên tên NNP 40436 9340 22 , , , 40436 9340 23 ê(/ ê(/ NNP 40436 9340 24 ti ti NNP 40436 9340 25 / / SYM 40436 9340 26 s s NNP 40436 9340 27 se se NNP 40436 9340 28 poiê poiê NNP 40436 9340 29 / / SYM 40436 9340 30 sei sei NNP 40436 9340 31 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9340 32 / / SYM 40436 9340 33 ga ga NNP 40436 9340 34 du du NNP 40436 9340 35 / / SYM 40436 9340 36 nasthai nasthai NNP 40436 9340 37 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9340 38 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 9340 39 po po NNP 40436 9340 40 / / SYM 40436 9340 41 lei lei NN 40436 9340 42 tê=|de tê=|de NNP 40436 9340 43 , , , 40436 9340 44 _ _ NNP 40436 9340 45 a)no a)no NNP 40436 9340 46 / / SYM 40436 9340 47 moion moion NN 40436 9340 48 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 9340 49 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 9340 50 politei politei NN 40436 9340 51 / / SYM 40436 9340 52 a| a| NN 40436 9340 53 ei)/t ei)/t NNP 40436 9340 54 ' ' POS 40436 9340 55 e)pi\ e)pi\ NN 40436 9340 56 to\ to\ NN 40436 9340 57 be be VB 40436 9340 58 / / SYM 40436 9340 59 ltion ltion NN 40436 9340 60 ei)/t ei)/t NNP 40436 9340 61 ' ' POS 40436 9340 62 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 9340 63 to\ to\ NN 40436 9340 64 chei chei NN 40436 9340 65 = = NFP 40436 9340 66 ron ron NNP 40436 9340 67 _ _ NNP 40436 9340 68 , , , 40436 9340 69 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 9340 70 o)rthô o)rthô NNP 40436 9340 71 = = SYM 40436 9340 72 s s NNP 40436 9340 73 bouleu bouleu NN 40436 9340 74 / / SYM 40436 9340 75 ei ei NNP 40436 9340 76 ; ; : 40436 9340 77 ou ou NNP 40436 9340 78 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9340 79 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9340 80 mimêtê\n mimêtê\n NNP 40436 9340 81 dei= dei= NNP 40436 9340 82 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 9340 83 , , , 40436 9340 84 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9340 85 ' ' `` 40436 9340 86 au)tophuô au)tophuô NNP 40436 9340 87 = = SYM 40436 9340 88 s s NNP 40436 9340 89 o(/moion o(/moion NNP 40436 9340 90 toou toou NN 40436 9340 91 / / SYM 40436 9340 92 tois tois NN 40436 9340 93 , , , 40436 9340 94 ei ei NNP 40436 9340 95 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9340 96 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9340 97 / / SYM 40436 9340 98 lleis lleis NNP 40436 9340 99 ti ti NNP 40436 9340 100 gnê gnê NNP 40436 9340 101 / / SYM 40436 9340 102 sion sion NNP 40436 9340 103 a)perga a)perga NNP 40436 9340 104 / / SYM 40436 9340 105 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 9340 106 ei)s ei)s NNP 40436 9340 107 phili phili NNP 40436 9340 108 / / SYM 40436 9340 109 an an DT 40436 9340 110 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9340 111 A)thênai A)thênai NNP 40436 9340 112 / / SYM 40436 9340 113 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9340 114 dê dê NNP 40436 9340 115 / / SYM 40436 9340 116 mô| mô| NNP 40436 9340 117 . . . 40436 9340 118 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9340 119 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9341 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9341 2 Side side NN 40436 9341 3 - - HYPH 40436 9341 4 note note NN 40436 9341 5 : : : 40436 9341 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9341 7 resolves resolve NNS 40436 9341 8 upon upon IN 40436 9341 9 a a DT 40436 9341 10 scheme scheme NN 40436 9341 11 of of IN 40436 9341 12 life life NN 40436 9341 13 for for IN 40436 9341 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9341 15 -- -- : 40436 9341 16 to to TO 40436 9341 17 study study VB 40436 9341 18 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9341 19 good good NN 40436 9341 20 , , , 40436 9341 21 and and CC 40436 9341 22 not not RB 40436 9341 23 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9341 24 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9341 25 . . . 40436 9341 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9342 1 Such such JJ 40436 9342 2 are be VBP 40436 9342 3 the the DT 40436 9342 4 essential essential JJ 40436 9342 5 conditions condition NNS 40436 9342 6 of of IN 40436 9342 7 political political JJ 40436 9342 8 success success NN 40436 9342 9 and and CC 40436 9342 10 popularity popularity NN 40436 9342 11 . . . 40436 9343 1 But but CC 40436 9343 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9343 3 , , , 40436 9343 4 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNP 40436 9343 5 , , , 40436 9343 6 have have VBP 40436 9343 7 already already RB 40436 9343 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 9343 9 two two CD 40436 9343 10 schemes scheme NNS 40436 9343 11 of of IN 40436 9343 12 life life NN 40436 9343 13 ; ; : 40436 9343 14 one one CD 40436 9343 15 aiming aim VBG 40436 9343 16 at at IN 40436 9343 17 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9343 18 , , , 40436 9343 19 the the DT 40436 9343 20 other other JJ 40436 9343 21 aiming aim VBG 40436 9343 22 at at IN 40436 9343 23 good good NN 40436 9343 24 : : : 40436 9343 25 one one CD 40436 9343 26 , , , 40436 9343 27 that that DT 40436 9343 28 of of IN 40436 9343 29 the the DT 40436 9343 30 statesman statesman NN 40436 9343 31 who who WP 40436 9343 32 studies study VBZ 40436 9343 33 the the DT 40436 9343 34 felt feel VBN 40436 9343 35 wants want VBZ 40436 9343 36 , , , 40436 9343 37 wishes wish NNS 40436 9343 38 , , , 40436 9343 39 and and CC 40436 9343 40 impulses impulse NNS 40436 9343 41 of of IN 40436 9343 42 the the DT 40436 9343 43 people people NNS 40436 9343 44 , , , 40436 9343 45 displaying display VBG 40436 9343 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9343 47 genius genius NN 40436 9343 48 in in IN 40436 9343 49 providing provide VBG 40436 9343 50 for for IN 40436 9343 51 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9343 52 effective effective JJ 40436 9343 53 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9343 54 -- -- : 40436 9343 55 the the DT 40436 9343 56 other other JJ 40436 9343 57 , , , 40436 9343 58 the the DT 40436 9343 59 statesman statesman NN 40436 9343 60 who who WP 40436 9343 61 makes make VBZ 40436 9343 62 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9343 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9343 64 chief chief JJ 40436 9343 65 or or CC 40436 9343 66 sole sole JJ 40436 9343 67 object object NN 40436 9343 68 to to TO 40436 9343 69 amend amend VB 40436 9343 70 the the DT 40436 9343 71 character character NN 40436 9343 72 and and CC 40436 9343 73 disposition disposition NN 40436 9343 74 of of IN 40436 9343 75 the the DT 40436 9343 76 people people NNS 40436 9343 77 . . . 40436 9344 1 The the DT 40436 9344 2 last last JJ 40436 9344 3 scheme scheme NN 40436 9344 4 is be VBZ 40436 9344 5 the the DT 40436 9344 6 only only JJ 40436 9344 7 one one CD 40436 9344 8 which which WDT 40436 9344 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9344 10 approve approve VBP 40436 9344 11 : : : 40436 9344 12 and and CC 40436 9344 13 if if IN 40436 9344 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9344 15 be be VBP 40436 9344 16 that that IN 40436 9344 17 to to TO 40436 9344 18 which which WDT 40436 9344 19 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9344 20 invite invite VBP 40436 9344 21 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9344 22 , , , 40436 9344 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9344 24 must must MD 40436 9344 25 examine examine VB 40436 9344 26 whether whether IN 40436 9344 27 either either CC 40436 9344 28 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9344 29 , , , 40436 9344 30 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 9344 31 , , , 40436 9344 32 or or CC 40436 9344 33 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9344 34 , , , 40436 9344 35 have have VBP 40436 9344 36 ever ever RB 40436 9344 37 yet yet RB 40436 9344 38 succeeded succeed VBN 40436 9344 39 in in IN 40436 9344 40 amending amend VBG 40436 9344 41 or or CC 40436 9344 42 improving improve VBG 40436 9344 43 the the DT 40436 9344 44 character character NN 40436 9344 45 of of IN 40436 9344 46 any any DT 40436 9344 47 individuals individual NNS 40436 9344 48 privately privately RB 40436 9344 49 , , , 40436 9344 50 before before IN 40436 9344 51 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9344 52 undertake undertake VBP 40436 9344 53 the the DT 40436 9344 54 task task NN 40436 9344 55 of of IN 40436 9344 56 amending amend VBG 40436 9344 57 the the DT 40436 9344 58 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9344 59 collectively collectively RB 40436 9344 60 . . . 40436 9345 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9345 2 107 107 CD 40436 9345 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9345 4 None none NN 40436 9345 5 of of IN 40436 9345 6 the the DT 40436 9345 7 past past JJ 40436 9345 8 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 9345 9 whom whom WP 40436 9345 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9345 11 extol extol VBP 40436 9345 12 , , , 40436 9345 13 Miltiades Miltiades NNP 40436 9345 14 , , , 40436 9345 15 Kimon Kimon NNP 40436 9345 16 , , , 40436 9345 17 Themistokles Themistokles NNP 40436 9345 18 , , , 40436 9345 19 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9345 20 , , , 40436 9345 21 has have VBZ 40436 9345 22 produced produce VBN 40436 9345 23 any any DT 40436 9345 24 such such JJ 40436 9345 25 amendment amendment NN 40436 9345 26 . . . 40436 9346 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9346 2 108 108 CD 40436 9346 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9346 4 Considered consider VBN 40436 9346 5 as as IN 40436 9346 6 ministers minister NNS 40436 9346 7 , , , 40436 9346 8 indeed indeed RB 40436 9346 9 , , , 40436 9346 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9346 11 were be VBD 40436 9346 12 skilful skilful JJ 40436 9346 13 and and CC 40436 9346 14 effective effective JJ 40436 9346 15 ; ; : 40436 9346 16 better well JJR 40436 9346 17 than than IN 40436 9346 18 the the DT 40436 9346 19 present present JJ 40436 9346 20 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 9346 21 . . . 40436 9347 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9347 2 were be VBD 40436 9347 3 successful successful JJ 40436 9347 4 in in IN 40436 9347 5 furnishing furnish VBG 40436 9347 6 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9347 7 to to IN 40436 9347 8 the the DT 40436 9347 9 prevalent prevalent NN 40436 9347 10 wants want VBZ 40436 9347 11 and and CC 40436 9347 12 desires desire NNS 40436 9347 13 of of IN 40436 9347 14 the the DT 40436 9347 15 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9347 16 : : : 40436 9347 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9347 18 provided provide VBD 40436 9347 19 docks dock NNS 40436 9347 20 , , , 40436 9347 21 walls wall NNS 40436 9347 22 , , , 40436 9347 23 ships ship NNS 40436 9347 24 , , , 40436 9347 25 tribute tribute NN 40436 9347 26 , , , 40436 9347 27 and and CC 40436 9347 28 other other JJ 40436 9347 29 such such JJ 40436 9347 30 follies folly NNS 40436 9347 31 , , , 40436 9347 32 abundantly:[109 abundantly:[109 NNP 40436 9347 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9347 34 but but CC 40436 9347 35 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9347 36 did do VBD 40436 9347 37 nothing nothing NN 40436 9347 38 to to TO 40436 9347 39 amend amend VB 40436 9347 40 the the DT 40436 9347 41 character character NN 40436 9347 42 of of IN 40436 9347 43 the the DT 40436 9347 44 people people NNS 40436 9347 45 -- -- : 40436 9347 46 to to TO 40436 9347 47 transfer transfer VB 40436 9347 48 the the DT 40436 9347 49 desires desire NNS 40436 9347 50 of of IN 40436 9347 51 the the DT 40436 9347 52 people people NNS 40436 9347 53 from from IN 40436 9347 54 worse bad JJR 40436 9347 55 things thing NNS 40436 9347 56 to to IN 40436 9347 57 better well JJR 40436 9347 58 things thing NNS 40436 9347 59 -- -- : 40436 9347 60 or or CC 40436 9347 61 to to TO 40436 9347 62 create create VB 40436 9347 63 in in IN 40436 9347 64 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9347 65 justice justice NN 40436 9347 66 and and CC 40436 9347 67 temperance temperance NN 40436 9347 68 . . . 40436 9348 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9348 2 thus thus RB 40436 9348 3 did do VBD 40436 9348 4 no no DT 40436 9348 5 real real RB 40436 9348 6 good good RB 40436 9348 7 by by IN 40436 9348 8 feeding feed VBG 40436 9348 9 the the DT 40436 9348 10 desires desire NNS 40436 9348 11 of of IN 40436 9348 12 the the DT 40436 9348 13 people people NNS 40436 9348 14 : : : 40436 9348 15 no no DT 40436 9348 16 more more RBR 40436 9348 17 good good JJ 40436 9348 18 than than IN 40436 9348 19 would would MD 40436 9348 20 be be VB 40436 9348 21 done do VBN 40436 9348 22 by by IN 40436 9348 23 a a DT 40436 9348 24 skilful skilful JJ 40436 9348 25 cook cook NN 40436 9348 26 for for IN 40436 9348 27 a a DT 40436 9348 28 sick sick JJ 40436 9348 29 man man NN 40436 9348 30 , , , 40436 9348 31 in in IN 40436 9348 32 cooking cooking NN 40436 9348 33 for for IN 40436 9348 34 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9348 35 a a DT 40436 9348 36 sumptuous sumptuous JJ 40436 9348 37 meal meal NN 40436 9348 38 before before IN 40436 9348 39 the the DT 40436 9348 40 physician physician NN 40436 9348 41 had have VBD 40436 9348 42 cured cure VBN 40436 9348 43 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9348 44 . . . 40436 9349 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9349 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9349 3 107 107 CD 40436 9349 4 : : : 40436 9349 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9349 6 , , , 40436 9349 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9349 8 , , , 40436 9349 9 p. p. NN 40436 9349 10 515 515 CD 40436 9349 11 A. a. NN 40436 9349 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9350 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9350 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9350 3 108 108 CD 40436 9350 4 : : : 40436 9350 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9350 6 , , , 40436 9350 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9350 8 , , , 40436 9350 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9350 10 . . . 40436 9351 1 516 516 CD 40436 9351 2 , , , 40436 9351 3 517 517 CD 40436 9351 4 . . . 40436 9351 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9352 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9352 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9352 3 109 109 CD 40436 9352 4 : : : 40436 9352 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9352 6 , , , 40436 9352 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9352 8 , , , 40436 9352 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9352 10 . . . 40436 9353 1 517 517 CD 40436 9353 2 , , , 40436 9353 3 519 519 CD 40436 9353 4 . . . 40436 9354 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9354 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9354 3 : : : 40436 9354 4 a)/neu a)/neu XX 40436 9354 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9354 6 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 9354 7 / / SYM 40436 9354 8 nês nês NNP 40436 9354 9 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9354 10 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 9354 11 / / SYM 40436 9354 12 nês nês NNP 40436 9354 13 lime lime NNP 40436 9354 14 / / SYM 40436 9354 15 nôn nôn NNP 40436 9354 16 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9354 17 neôri neôri NNP 40436 9354 18 / / SYM 40436 9354 19 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9354 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9354 21 teichô teichô NNP 40436 9354 22 = = SYM 40436 9354 23 n n NNP 40436 9354 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9354 25 pho pho NNP 40436 9354 26 / / SYM 40436 9354 27 rôn rôn NNP 40436 9354 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9354 29 toiou toiou NNP 40436 9354 30 / / SYM 40436 9354 31 tôn tôn NNP 40436 9354 32 phluariô phluariô NNP 40436 9354 33 = = SYM 40436 9354 34 n n NNP 40436 9354 35 e)mpeplê e)mpeplê NNP 40436 9354 36 / / SYM 40436 9354 37 kasi kasi NNP 40436 9354 38 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9354 39 po po NNP 40436 9354 40 / / SYM 40436 9354 41 lin lin NNP 40436 9354 42 . . . 40436 9354 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9354 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9355 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9355 2 Side side NN 40436 9355 3 - - HYPH 40436 9355 4 note note NN 40436 9355 5 : : : 40436 9355 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9355 7 announces announce VBZ 40436 9355 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9355 9 as as IN 40436 9355 10 almost almost RB 40436 9355 11 the the DT 40436 9355 12 only only JJ 40436 9355 13 man man NN 40436 9355 14 at at IN 40436 9355 15 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9355 16 , , , 40436 9355 17 who who WP 40436 9355 18 follows follow VBZ 40436 9355 19 out out RP 40436 9355 20 the the DT 40436 9355 21 true true JJ 40436 9355 22 political political JJ 40436 9355 23 art art NN 40436 9355 24 . . . 40436 9356 1 Danger danger NN 40436 9356 2 of of IN 40436 9356 3 doing do VBG 40436 9356 4 this this DT 40436 9356 5 . . . 40436 9356 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9357 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9357 2 believe believe VBP 40436 9357 3 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9357 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9357 5 continues continue VBZ 40436 9357 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9357 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9357 8 to to TO 40436 9357 9 be be VB 40436 9357 10 the the DT 40436 9357 11 only only JJ 40436 9357 12 man man NN 40436 9357 13 in in IN 40436 9357 14 Athens,--or athens,--or NN 40436 9357 15 certainly certainly RB 40436 9357 16 one one CD 40436 9357 17 among among IN 40436 9357 18 a a DT 40436 9357 19 very very RB 40436 9357 20 few,--who few,--who JJR 40436 9357 21 am am NN 40436 9357 22 a a DT 40436 9357 23 true true JJ 40436 9357 24 statesman statesman NN 40436 9357 25 , , , 40436 9357 26 following follow VBG 40436 9357 27 out out RP 40436 9357 28 the the DT 40436 9357 29 genuine genuine JJ 40436 9357 30 purposes purpose NNS 40436 9357 31 of of IN 40436 9357 32 the the DT 40436 9357 33 political political JJ 40436 9357 34 art art NN 40436 9357 35 . . . 40436 9358 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9358 2 110 110 CD 40436 9358 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9358 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9358 5 aim aim VBP 40436 9358 6 at at IN 40436 9358 7 what what WP 40436 9358 8 is be VBZ 40436 9358 9 best good JJS 40436 9358 10 for for IN 40436 9358 11 the the DT 40436 9358 12 people people NNS 40436 9358 13 , , , 40436 9358 14 not not RB 40436 9358 15 at at IN 40436 9358 16 what what WP 40436 9358 17 is be VBZ 40436 9358 18 most most RBS 40436 9358 19 agreeable agreeable JJ 40436 9358 20 . . . 40436 9359 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9359 2 do do VBP 40436 9359 3 not not RB 40436 9359 4 value value VB 40436 9359 5 those those DT 40436 9359 6 captivating captivate VBG 40436 9359 7 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 40436 9359 8 which which WDT 40436 9359 9 tell tell VBP 40436 9359 10 in in IN 40436 9359 11 the the DT 40436 9359 12 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 9359 13 . . . 40436 9360 1 If if IN 40436 9360 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9360 3 am be VBP 40436 9360 4 tried try VBN 40436 9360 5 , , , 40436 9360 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9360 7 shall shall MD 40436 9360 8 be be VB 40436 9360 9 like like IN 40436 9360 10 a a DT 40436 9360 11 physician physician NN 40436 9360 12 arraigned arraign VBN 40436 9360 13 by by IN 40436 9360 14 the the DT 40436 9360 15 confectioner confectioner NN 40436 9360 16 before before IN 40436 9360 17 a a DT 40436 9360 18 jury jury NN 40436 9360 19 of of IN 40436 9360 20 children child NNS 40436 9360 21 . . . 40436 9361 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9361 2 shall shall MD 40436 9361 3 not not RB 40436 9361 4 be be VB 40436 9361 5 able able JJ 40436 9361 6 to to TO 40436 9361 7 refer refer VB 40436 9361 8 to to IN 40436 9361 9 any any DT 40436 9361 10 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9361 11 provided provide VBN 40436 9361 12 for for IN 40436 9361 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9361 14 by by IN 40436 9361 15 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9361 16 : : : 40436 9361 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9361 18 which which WDT 40436 9361 19 _ _ NNP 40436 9361 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9361 21 _ _ IN 40436 9361 22 call call VBP 40436 9361 23 benefits benefit NNS 40436 9361 24 , , , 40436 9361 25 but but CC 40436 9361 26 which which WDT 40436 9361 27 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9361 28 regard regard VBP 40436 9361 29 as as IN 40436 9361 30 worthless worthless JJ 40436 9361 31 . . . 40436 9362 1 If if IN 40436 9362 2 any any DT 40436 9362 3 one one NN 40436 9362 4 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 9362 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9362 6 of of IN 40436 9362 7 corrupting corrupt VBG 40436 9362 8 the the DT 40436 9362 9 youth youth NN 40436 9362 10 by by IN 40436 9362 11 making make VBG 40436 9362 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9362 13 sceptical sceptical JJ 40436 9362 14 , , , 40436 9362 15 or or CC 40436 9362 16 of of IN 40436 9362 17 libelling libel VBG 40436 9362 18 the the DT 40436 9362 19 older old JJR 40436 9362 20 men man NNS 40436 9362 21 in in IN 40436 9362 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9362 23 private private JJ 40436 9362 24 and and CC 40436 9362 25 public public JJ 40436 9362 26 talk talk NN 40436 9362 27 -- -- : 40436 9362 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9362 29 will will MD 40436 9362 30 be be VB 40436 9362 31 in in IN 40436 9362 32 vain vain JJ 40436 9362 33 for for IN 40436 9362 34 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9362 35 to to TO 40436 9362 36 justify justify VB 40436 9362 37 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9362 38 by by IN 40436 9362 39 saying say VBG 40436 9362 40 the the DT 40436 9362 41 real real JJ 40436 9362 42 truth.--Dikasts truth.--dikasts NN 40436 9362 43 , , , 40436 9362 44 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9362 45 do do VBP 40436 9362 46 and and CC 40436 9362 47 say say VB 40436 9362 48 all all PDT 40436 9362 49 these these DT 40436 9362 50 things thing NNS 40436 9362 51 justly justly RB 40436 9362 52 , , , 40436 9362 53 for for IN 40436 9362 54 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9362 55 real real JJ 40436 9362 56 benefit benefit NN 40436 9362 57 . . . 40436 9363 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9363 2 shall shall MD 40436 9363 3 not not RB 40436 9363 4 be be VB 40436 9363 5 believed believe VBN 40436 9363 6 when when WRB 40436 9363 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9363 8 say say VBP 40436 9363 9 this this DT 40436 9363 10 , , , 40436 9363 11 and and CC 40436 9363 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9363 13 have have VBP 40436 9363 14 nothing nothing NN 40436 9363 15 else else RB 40436 9363 16 to to TO 40436 9363 17 say say VB 40436 9363 18 : : : 40436 9363 19 so so CC 40436 9363 20 that that IN 40436 9363 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9363 22 do do VBP 40436 9363 23 not not RB 40436 9363 24 know know VB 40436 9363 25 what what WDT 40436 9363 26 sentence sentence NN 40436 9363 27 may may MD 40436 9363 28 be be VB 40436 9363 29 passed pass VBN 40436 9363 30 on on IN 40436 9363 31 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9363 32 . . . 40436 9364 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9364 2 111 111 CD 40436 9364 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9364 4 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9364 5 only only JJ 40436 9364 6 refuge refuge NN 40436 9364 7 and and CC 40436 9364 8 defence defence NN 40436 9364 9 will will MD 40436 9364 10 be be VB 40436 9364 11 , , , 40436 9364 12 the the DT 40436 9364 13 innocence innocence NN 40436 9364 14 of of IN 40436 9364 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9364 16 life life NN 40436 9364 17 . . . 40436 9365 1 As as IN 40436 9365 2 for for IN 40436 9365 3 death death NN 40436 9365 4 , , , 40436 9365 5 no no DT 40436 9365 6 one one NN 40436 9365 7 except except IN 40436 9365 8 a a DT 40436 9365 9 fool fool NN 40436 9365 10 or or CC 40436 9365 11 a a DT 40436 9365 12 coward coward NN 40436 9365 13 fears fear NNS 40436 9365 14 _ _ NNP 40436 9365 15 that that IN 40436 9365 16 _ _ NNP 40436 9365 17 : : : 40436 9365 18 the the DT 40436 9365 19 real real JJ 40436 9365 20 evil evil NN 40436 9365 21 , , , 40436 9365 22 and and CC 40436 9365 23 the the DT 40436 9365 24 greatest great JJS 40436 9365 25 of of IN 40436 9365 26 all all DT 40436 9365 27 evils evil NNS 40436 9365 28 , , , 40436 9365 29 is be VBZ 40436 9365 30 to to TO 40436 9365 31 pass pass VB 40436 9365 32 into into IN 40436 9365 33 Hades Hades NNP 40436 9365 34 with with IN 40436 9365 35 a a DT 40436 9365 36 corrupt corrupt JJ 40436 9365 37 and and CC 40436 9365 38 polluted polluted JJ 40436 9365 39 mind mind NN 40436 9365 40 . . . 40436 9366 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9366 2 112 112 CD 40436 9366 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9366 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9366 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9366 6 110 110 CD 40436 9366 7 : : : 40436 9366 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9366 9 , , , 40436 9366 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9366 11 , , , 40436 9366 12 p. p. NN 40436 9366 13 521 521 CD 40436 9366 14 D. D. NNP 40436 9366 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9366 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9366 17 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9366 18 111 111 CD 40436 9366 19 : : : 40436 9366 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9366 21 , , , 40436 9366 22 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9366 23 , , , 40436 9366 24 pp pp NNP 40436 9366 25 . . . 40436 9367 1 521 521 CD 40436 9367 2 - - SYM 40436 9367 3 522 522 CD 40436 9367 4 . . . 40436 9367 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9368 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9368 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9368 3 112 112 CD 40436 9368 4 : : : 40436 9368 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9368 6 , , , 40436 9368 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9368 8 , , , 40436 9368 9 p. p. NN 40436 9368 10 522 522 CD 40436 9368 11 E. E. NNP 40436 9368 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9368 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9368 14 : : : 40436 9368 15 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 9368 16 me\n me\n NNP 40436 9368 17 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9368 18 to\ to\ NN 40436 9368 19 a)pothnê a)pothnê CD 40436 9368 20 / / SYM 40436 9368 21 skein skein NN 40436 9368 22 ou)dei\s ou)dei\s . 40436 9368 23 phobei phobei NNP 40436 9368 24 = = SYM 40436 9368 25 tai tai NN 40436 9368 26 , , , 40436 9368 27 o(/stis o(/stis NNP 40436 9368 28 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9368 29 panta panta NN 40436 9368 30 / / SYM 40436 9368 31 pasin pasin NN 40436 9368 32 a)lo a)lo NNP 40436 9368 33 / / SYM 40436 9368 34 gisto gisto NNP 40436 9368 35 / / SYM 40436 9368 36 s s NNP 40436 9368 37 te te NNP 40436 9368 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9368 39 a)/nandro a)/nandro NNP 40436 9368 40 / / SYM 40436 9368 41 s s NNP 40436 9368 42 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 9368 43 , , , 40436 9368 44 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9368 45 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9368 46 a)dikei a)dikei NNS 40436 9368 47 = = SYM 40436 9368 48 n n CC 40436 9368 49 phobei phobei NNP 40436 9368 50 = = SYM 40436 9368 51 tai tai NN 40436 9368 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9368 53 , , , 40436 9368 54 & & CC 40436 9368 55 c. c. NNP 40436 9368 56 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9368 57 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9368 58 Side side NN 40436 9368 59 - - HYPH 40436 9368 60 note note NN 40436 9368 61 : : : 40436 9368 62 Mythe mythe NN 40436 9368 63 respecting respect VBG 40436 9368 64 Hades Hades NNP 40436 9368 65 , , , 40436 9368 66 and and CC 40436 9368 67 the the DT 40436 9368 68 treatment treatment NN 40436 9368 69 of of IN 40436 9368 70 deceased deceased JJ 40436 9368 71 persons person NNS 40436 9368 72 therein therein RB 40436 9368 73 , , , 40436 9368 74 according accord VBG 40436 9368 75 to to IN 40436 9368 76 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9368 77 merits merit NNS 40436 9368 78 during during IN 40436 9368 79 life life NN 40436 9368 80 -- -- : 40436 9368 81 the the DT 40436 9368 82 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9368 83 who who WP 40436 9368 84 stood stand VBD 40436 9368 85 aloof aloof JJ 40436 9368 86 from from IN 40436 9368 87 public public JJ 40436 9368 88 affairs affair NNS 40436 9368 89 , , , 40436 9368 90 will will MD 40436 9368 91 then then RB 40436 9368 92 be be VB 40436 9368 93 rewarded reward VBN 40436 9368 94 . . . 40436 9368 95 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9369 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9369 2 then then RB 40436 9369 3 winds wind VBZ 40436 9369 4 up up RP 40436 9369 5 the the DT 40436 9369 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9369 7 , , , 40436 9369 8 by by IN 40436 9369 9 reciting recite VBG 40436 9369 10 a a DT 40436 9369 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9369 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9369 13 : : : 40436 9369 14 Ne Ne NNP 40436 9369 15 / / SYM 40436 9369 16 kuia kuia NN 40436 9369 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9369 18 , , , 40436 9369 19 a a DT 40436 9369 20 mythe mythe NN 40436 9369 21 or or CC 40436 9369 22 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 9369 23 about about IN 40436 9369 24 judgment judgment NN 40436 9369 25 in in IN 40436 9369 26 Hades Hades NNP 40436 9369 27 after after IN 40436 9369 28 death death NN 40436 9369 29 , , , 40436 9369 30 and and CC 40436 9369 31 rewards reward NNS 40436 9369 32 and and CC 40436 9369 33 punishments punishment NNS 40436 9369 34 to to TO 40436 9369 35 be be VB 40436 9369 36 apportioned apportion VBN 40436 9369 37 to to IN 40436 9369 38 deceased deceased JJ 40436 9369 39 men man NNS 40436 9369 40 , , , 40436 9369 41 according accord VBG 40436 9369 42 to to IN 40436 9369 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9369 44 merits merit NNS 40436 9369 45 during during IN 40436 9369 46 life life NN 40436 9369 47 , , , 40436 9369 48 by by IN 40436 9369 49 Rhadamanthus Rhadamanthus NNP 40436 9369 50 and and CC 40436 9369 51 Minos Minos NNP 40436 9369 52 . . . 40436 9370 1 The the DT 40436 9370 2 greatest great JJS 40436 9370 3 sufferers sufferer NNS 40436 9370 4 by by IN 40436 9370 5 these these DT 40436 9370 6 judgments judgment NNS 40436 9370 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9370 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9370 9 says say VBZ 40436 9370 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9370 11 will will MD 40436 9370 12 be be VB 40436 9370 13 the the DT 40436 9370 14 kings king NNS 40436 9370 15 , , , 40436 9370 16 despots despot NNS 40436 9370 17 , , , 40436 9370 18 and and CC 40436 9370 19 men man NNS 40436 9370 20 politically politically RB 40436 9370 21 powerful powerful JJ 40436 9370 22 , , , 40436 9370 23 who who WP 40436 9370 24 have have VBP 40436 9370 25 during during IN 40436 9370 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9370 27 lives life NNS 40436 9370 28 committed commit VBD 40436 9370 29 the the DT 40436 9370 30 greatest great JJS 40436 9370 31 injustices,--which injustices,--which NN 40436 9370 32 indeed indeed RB 40436 9370 33 few few JJ 40436 9370 34 of of IN 40436 9370 35 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9370 36 avoid avoid VBP 40436 9370 37 . . . 40436 9371 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9371 2 113 113 CD 40436 9371 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9371 4 The the DT 40436 9371 5 man man NN 40436 9371 6 most most RBS 40436 9371 7 likely likely JJ 40436 9371 8 to to TO 40436 9371 9 fare fare VB 40436 9371 10 well well RB 40436 9371 11 and and CC 40436 9371 12 to to TO 40436 9371 13 be be VB 40436 9371 14 rewarded reward VBN 40436 9371 15 , , , 40436 9371 16 will will MD 40436 9371 17 be be VB 40436 9371 18 the the DT 40436 9371 19 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9371 20 , , , 40436 9371 21 " " `` 40436 9371 22 who who WP 40436 9371 23 has have VBZ 40436 9371 24 passed pass VBN 40436 9371 25 through through IN 40436 9371 26 life life NN 40436 9371 27 minding mind VBG 40436 9371 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9371 29 own own JJ 40436 9371 30 business business NN 40436 9371 31 , , , 40436 9371 32 and and CC 40436 9371 33 not not RB 40436 9371 34 meddling meddle VBG 40436 9371 35 with with IN 40436 9371 36 the the DT 40436 9371 37 affairs affair NNS 40436 9371 38 of of IN 40436 9371 39 others other NNS 40436 9371 40 " " '' 40436 9371 41 . . . 40436 9372 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9372 2 114 114 CD 40436 9372 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9372 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9372 5 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9372 6 113 113 CD 40436 9372 7 : : : 40436 9372 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9372 9 , , , 40436 9372 10 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9372 11 , , , 40436 9372 12 pp pp NNP 40436 9372 13 . . . 40436 9373 1 525 525 CD 40436 9373 2 - - SYM 40436 9373 3 526 526 CD 40436 9373 4 . . . 40436 9373 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9374 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9374 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9374 3 114 114 CD 40436 9374 4 : : : 40436 9374 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9374 6 , , , 40436 9374 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9374 8 , , , 40436 9374 9 p. p. NN 40436 9374 10 526 526 CD 40436 9374 11 C. C. NNP 40436 9374 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9374 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9374 14 : : : 40436 9374 15 philoso philoso NNP 40436 9374 16 / / SYM 40436 9374 17 phou phou NNP 40436 9374 18 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 9374 19 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 9374 20 pra pra NNP 40436 9374 21 / / SYM 40436 9374 22 xantos xantos NNP 40436 9374 23 , , , 40436 9374 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9374 25 ou ou NNP 40436 9374 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9374 27 polupragmonê polupragmonê NNP 40436 9374 28 / / SYM 40436 9374 29 santos santo NNS 40436 9374 30 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9374 31 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9374 32 bi bi NN 40436 9374 33 / / SYM 40436 9374 34 ô| ô| NNP 40436 9374 35 . . . 40436 9374 36 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9375 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9375 2 must must MD 40436 9375 3 be be VB 40436 9375 4 confessed confess VBN 40436 9375 5 that that IN 40436 9375 6 these these DT 40436 9375 7 terms term NNS 40436 9375 8 do do VBP 40436 9375 9 not not RB 40436 9375 10 correspond correspond VB 40436 9375 11 to to IN 40436 9375 12 the the DT 40436 9375 13 life life NN 40436 9375 14 of of IN 40436 9375 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9375 16 , , , 40436 9375 17 as as IN 40436 9375 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9375 19 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9375 20 describes describe VBZ 40436 9375 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9375 22 in in IN 40436 9375 23 the the DT 40436 9375 24 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9375 25 Apology Apology NNP 40436 9375 26 . . . 40436 9376 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9376 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 9376 3 to to TO 40436 9376 4 have have VB 40436 9376 5 fancied fancy VBN 40436 9376 6 that that IN 40436 9376 7 no no DT 40436 9376 8 one one NN 40436 9376 9 was be VBD 40436 9376 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9376 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9376 12 : : : 40436 9376 13 polupra polupra NNP 40436 9376 14 / / SYM 40436 9376 15 gmôn gmôn NNP 40436 9376 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9376 17 except except IN 40436 9376 18 those those DT 40436 9376 19 who who WP 40436 9376 20 spoke speak VBD 40436 9376 21 habitually habitually RB 40436 9376 22 in in IN 40436 9376 23 the the DT 40436 9376 24 Ekklesia Ekklesia NNP 40436 9376 25 and and CC 40436 9376 26 the the DT 40436 9376 27 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 9376 28 . . . 40436 9376 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9377 1 * * NFP 40436 9377 2 * * NFP 40436 9377 3 * * NFP 40436 9377 4 * * NFP 40436 9377 5 * * NFP 40436 9377 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9377 7 Side side NN 40436 9377 8 - - HYPH 40436 9377 9 note note NN 40436 9377 10 : : : 40436 9377 11 Peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 9377 12 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9377 13 views view NNS 40436 9377 14 of of IN 40436 9377 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9377 16 -- -- : 40436 9377 17 Rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 9377 18 or or CC 40436 9377 19 dogmatical dogmatical JJ 40436 9377 20 character character NN 40436 9377 21 of of IN 40436 9377 22 the the DT 40436 9377 23 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9377 24 . . . 40436 9377 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9378 1 " " `` 40436 9378 2 Dicuntur dicuntur JJ 40436 9378 3 ista ista NN 40436 9378 4 magnifice,"[115]--we magnifice,"[115]--we NNP 40436 9378 5 may may MD 40436 9378 6 exclaim exclaim VB 40436 9378 7 , , , 40436 9378 8 in in IN 40436 9378 9 Ciceronian ciceronian JJ 40436 9378 10 words word NNS 40436 9378 11 , , , 40436 9378 12 on on IN 40436 9378 13 reaching reach VBG 40436 9378 14 the the DT 40436 9378 15 close close NN 40436 9378 16 of of IN 40436 9378 17 the the DT 40436 9378 18 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9378 19 . . . 40436 9379 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9379 2 is be VBZ 40436 9379 3 pre pre JJ 40436 9379 4 - - JJ 40436 9379 5 eminently eminently RB 40436 9379 6 solemn solemn JJ 40436 9379 7 and and CC 40436 9379 8 impressive impressive JJ 40436 9379 9 ; ; : 40436 9379 10 all all PDT 40436 9379 11 the the DT 40436 9379 12 more more RBR 40436 9379 13 so so RB 40436 9379 14 , , , 40436 9379 15 from from IN 40436 9379 16 the the DT 40436 9379 17 emphasis emphasis NN 40436 9379 18 of of IN 40436 9379 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9379 20 , , , 40436 9379 21 when when WRB 40436 9379 22 proclaiming proclaim VBG 40436 9379 23 the the DT 40436 9379 24 isolation isolation NN 40436 9379 25 in in IN 40436 9379 26 which which WDT 40436 9379 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9379 28 stands stand VBZ 40436 9379 29 at at IN 40436 9379 30 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9379 31 , , , 40436 9379 32 and and CC 40436 9379 33 the the DT 40436 9379 34 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 9379 35 between between IN 40436 9379 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9379 37 ethico ethico JJ 40436 9379 38 - - HYPH 40436 9379 39 political political JJ 40436 9379 40 views view NNS 40436 9379 41 and and CC 40436 9379 42 those those DT 40436 9379 43 of of IN 40436 9379 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9379 45 fellow fellow JJ 40436 9379 46 - - HYPH 40436 9379 47 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9379 48 . . . 40436 9380 1 In in IN 40436 9380 2 this this DT 40436 9380 3 respect respect NN 40436 9380 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9380 5 harmonises harmonise VBZ 40436 9380 6 with with IN 40436 9380 7 the the DT 40436 9380 8 Apology Apology NNP 40436 9380 9 , , , 40436 9380 10 the the DT 40436 9380 11 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9380 12 , , , 40436 9380 13 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9380 14 , , , 40436 9380 15 and and CC 40436 9380 16 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 9380 17 : : : 40436 9380 18 in in IN 40436 9380 19 all all DT 40436 9380 20 which which WDT 40436 9380 21 , , , 40436 9380 22 the the DT 40436 9380 23 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 9380 24 of of IN 40436 9380 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9380 26 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9380 27 points point NNS 40436 9380 28 of of IN 40436 9380 29 view view NN 40436 9380 30 stands stand VBZ 40436 9380 31 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 9380 32 -- -- : 40436 9380 33 especially especially RB 40436 9380 34 in in IN 40436 9380 35 the the DT 40436 9380 36 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9380 37 , , , 40436 9380 38 where where WRB 40436 9380 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9380 40 declares declare VBZ 40436 9380 41 that that IN 40436 9380 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9380 43 difference difference NN 40436 9380 44 with with IN 40436 9380 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9380 46 opponents opponent NNS 40436 9380 47 is be VBZ 40436 9380 48 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 9380 49 , , , 40436 9380 50 and and CC 40436 9380 51 that that IN 40436 9380 52 there there EX 40436 9380 53 can can MD 40436 9380 54 be be VB 40436 9380 55 between between IN 40436 9380 56 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9380 57 no no DT 40436 9380 58 common common JJ 40436 9380 59 ground ground NN 40436 9380 60 for for IN 40436 9380 61 debate debate NN 40436 9380 62 -- -- : 40436 9380 63 nothing nothing NN 40436 9380 64 but but IN 40436 9380 65 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 9380 66 contempt contempt NN 40436 9380 67 . . . 40436 9381 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9381 2 116 116 CD 40436 9381 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9381 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9381 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9381 6 115 115 CD 40436 9381 7 : : : 40436 9381 8 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 9381 9 , , , 40436 9381 10 De De NNP 40436 9381 11 Finib Finib NNP 40436 9381 12 . . . 40436 9382 1 iii iii NNP 40436 9382 2 . . . 40436 9383 1 3 3 CD 40436 9383 2 , , , 40436 9383 3 11 11 CD 40436 9383 4 . . . 40436 9383 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9384 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9384 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9384 3 116 116 CD 40436 9384 4 : : : 40436 9384 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9384 6 , , , 40436 9384 7 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9384 8 , , , 40436 9384 9 p. p. NN 40436 9384 10 49 49 CD 40436 9384 11 D. D. NNP 40436 9384 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9384 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9384 14 Side side NN 40436 9384 15 - - HYPH 40436 9384 16 note note NN 40436 9384 17 : : : 40436 9384 18 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9384 19 merges merge VBZ 40436 9384 20 politics politic NNS 40436 9384 21 in in IN 40436 9384 22 Ethics Ethics NNP 40436 9384 23 -- -- : 40436 9384 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9384 25 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 9384 26 the the DT 40436 9384 27 rulers ruler NNS 40436 9384 28 as as IN 40436 9384 29 spiritual spiritual JJ 40436 9384 30 teachers teacher NNS 40436 9384 31 and and CC 40436 9384 32 trainers trainer NNS 40436 9384 33 of of IN 40436 9384 34 the the DT 40436 9384 35 community community NN 40436 9384 36 . . . 40436 9384 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9385 1 The the DT 40436 9385 2 argument argument NN 40436 9385 3 of of IN 40436 9385 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9385 5 in in IN 40436 9385 6 the the DT 40436 9385 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9385 8 is be VBZ 40436 9385 9 interesting interesting JJ 40436 9385 10 , , , 40436 9385 11 not not RB 40436 9385 12 merely merely RB 40436 9385 13 as as IN 40436 9385 14 extolling extoll VBG 40436 9385 15 the the DT 40436 9385 16 value value NN 40436 9385 17 of of IN 40436 9385 18 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9385 19 self self NN 40436 9385 20 - - HYPH 40436 9385 21 restraint restraint NN 40436 9385 22 , , , 40436 9385 23 but but CC 40436 9385 24 also also RB 40436 9385 25 as as IN 40436 9385 26 considering consider VBG 40436 9385 27 political political JJ 40436 9385 28 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 9385 29 under under IN 40436 9385 30 this this DT 40436 9385 31 point point NN 40436 9385 32 of of IN 40436 9385 33 view view NN 40436 9385 34 : : : 40436 9385 35 that that RB 40436 9385 36 is be VBZ 40436 9385 37 , , , 40436 9385 38 merging merge VBG 40436 9385 39 politics politic NNS 40436 9385 40 in in IN 40436 9385 41 ethics ethic NNS 40436 9385 42 . . . 40436 9386 1 The the DT 40436 9386 2 proper proper JJ 40436 9386 3 and and CC 40436 9386 4 paramount paramount JJ 40436 9386 5 function function NN 40436 9386 6 of of IN 40436 9386 7 statesmen statesman NNS 40436 9386 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9386 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9386 10 find find VBP 40436 9386 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9386 12 eloquently eloquently RB 40436 9386 13 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 9386 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9386 15 is be VBZ 40436 9386 16 to to TO 40436 9386 17 serve serve VB 40436 9386 18 as as IN 40436 9386 19 spiritual spiritual JJ 40436 9386 20 teachers teacher NNS 40436 9386 21 in in IN 40436 9386 22 the the DT 40436 9386 23 community community NN 40436 9386 24 : : : 40436 9386 25 for for IN 40436 9386 26 the the DT 40436 9386 27 purpose purpose NN 40436 9386 28 of of IN 40436 9386 29 amending amend VBG 40436 9386 30 the the DT 40436 9386 31 lives life NNS 40436 9386 32 and and CC 40436 9386 33 characters character NNS 40436 9386 34 of of IN 40436 9386 35 the the DT 40436 9386 36 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9386 37 , , , 40436 9386 38 and and CC 40436 9386 39 of of IN 40436 9386 40 converting convert VBG 40436 9386 41 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9386 42 from from IN 40436 9386 43 bad bad JJ 40436 9386 44 dispositions disposition NNS 40436 9386 45 to to IN 40436 9386 46 good good NN 40436 9386 47 . . . 40436 9387 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9387 2 are be VBP 40436 9387 3 admonished admonish VBN 40436 9387 4 that that IN 40436 9387 5 until until IN 40436 9387 6 this this DT 40436 9387 7 is be VBZ 40436 9387 8 effected effect VBN 40436 9387 9 , , , 40436 9387 10 more more RBR 40436 9387 11 is be VBZ 40436 9387 12 lost lose VBN 40436 9387 13 than than IN 40436 9387 14 gained gain VBN 40436 9387 15 by by IN 40436 9387 16 realising realise VBG 40436 9387 17 the the DT 40436 9387 18 actual actual JJ 40436 9387 19 wants want VBZ 40436 9387 20 and and CC 40436 9387 21 wishes wish VBZ 40436 9387 22 of of IN 40436 9387 23 the the DT 40436 9387 24 community community NN 40436 9387 25 , , , 40436 9387 26 which which WDT 40436 9387 27 are be VBP 40436 9387 28 disorderly disorderly JJ 40436 9387 29 and and CC 40436 9387 30 distempered distemper VBN 40436 9387 31 : : : 40436 9387 32 like like IN 40436 9387 33 the the DT 40436 9387 34 state state NN 40436 9387 35 of of IN 40436 9387 36 a a DT 40436 9387 37 sick sick JJ 40436 9387 38 man man NN 40436 9387 39 , , , 40436 9387 40 who who WP 40436 9387 41 would would MD 40436 9387 42 receive receive VB 40436 9387 43 harm harm NN 40436 9387 44 and and CC 40436 9387 45 not not RB 40436 9387 46 benefit benefit VB 40436 9387 47 from from IN 40436 9387 48 a a DT 40436 9387 49 sumptuous sumptuous JJ 40436 9387 50 banquet banquet NN 40436 9387 51 . . . 40436 9388 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9388 2 Side side NN 40436 9388 3 - - HYPH 40436 9388 4 note note NN 40436 9388 5 : : : 40436 9388 6 _ _ NNP 40436 9388 7 Idéal Idéal NNP 40436 9388 8 _ _ NNP 40436 9388 9 of of IN 40436 9388 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9388 11 -- -- : 40436 9388 12 a a DT 40436 9388 13 despotic despotic JJ 40436 9388 14 lawgiver lawgiver NN 40436 9388 15 or or CC 40436 9388 16 man man NN 40436 9388 17 - - HYPH 40436 9388 18 trainer trainer NN 40436 9388 19 , , , 40436 9388 20 on on IN 40436 9388 21 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9388 22 principles principle NNS 40436 9388 23 , , , 40436 9388 24 fashioning fashion VBG 40436 9388 25 all all DT 40436 9388 26 characters character NNS 40436 9388 27 pursuant pursuant JJ 40436 9388 28 to to IN 40436 9388 29 certain certain JJ 40436 9388 30 types type NNS 40436 9388 31 of of IN 40436 9388 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9388 33 own own JJ 40436 9388 34 . . . 40436 9388 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9389 1 This this DT 40436 9389 2 is be VBZ 40436 9389 3 the the DT 40436 9389 4 conception conception NN 40436 9389 5 of of IN 40436 9389 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9389 7 in in IN 40436 9389 8 the the DT 40436 9389 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9389 10 , , , 40436 9389 11 speaking speak VBG 40436 9389 12 through through IN 40436 9389 13 the the DT 40436 9389 14 person person NN 40436 9389 15 of of IN 40436 9389 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9389 17 , , , 40436 9389 18 respecting respect VBG 40436 9389 19 the the DT 40436 9389 20 ends end NNS 40436 9389 21 for for IN 40436 9389 22 which which WDT 40436 9389 23 the the DT 40436 9389 24 political political JJ 40436 9389 25 magistrate magistrate NN 40436 9389 26 ought ought MD 40436 9389 27 to to TO 40436 9389 28 employ employ VB 40436 9389 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9389 30 power power NN 40436 9389 31 . . . 40436 9390 1 The the DT 40436 9390 2 magistrate magistrate NN 40436 9390 3 , , , 40436 9390 4 as as IN 40436 9390 5 administering administer VBG 40436 9390 6 law law NN 40436 9390 7 and and CC 40436 9390 8 justice justice NN 40436 9390 9 , , , 40436 9390 10 is be VBZ 40436 9390 11 to to IN 40436 9390 12 the the DT 40436 9390 13 minds mind NNS 40436 9390 14 of of IN 40436 9390 15 the the DT 40436 9390 16 community community NN 40436 9390 17 what what WP 40436 9390 18 the the DT 40436 9390 19 trainer trainer NN 40436 9390 20 and and CC 40436 9390 21 the the DT 40436 9390 22 physician physician NN 40436 9390 23 are be VBP 40436 9390 24 to to IN 40436 9390 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9390 26 bodies body NNS 40436 9390 27 : : : 40436 9390 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9390 29 produces produce VBZ 40436 9390 30 goodness goodness NN 40436 9390 31 of of IN 40436 9390 32 mind mind NN 40436 9390 33 , , , 40436 9390 34 as as IN 40436 9390 35 the the DT 40436 9390 36 two two CD 40436 9390 37 latter latter JJ 40436 9390 38 produce produce VBP 40436 9390 39 health health NN 40436 9390 40 and and CC 40436 9390 41 strength strength NN 40436 9390 42 of of IN 40436 9390 43 body body NN 40436 9390 44 . . . 40436 9391 1 The the DT 40436 9391 2 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9391 3 _ _ NNP 40436 9391 4 idéal idéal NN 40436 9391 5 _ _ NNP 40436 9391 6 is be VBZ 40436 9391 7 that that DT 40436 9391 8 of of IN 40436 9391 9 a a DT 40436 9391 10 despotic despotic JJ 40436 9391 11 law law NN 40436 9391 12 - - HYPH 40436 9391 13 giver giver NN 40436 9391 14 and and CC 40436 9391 15 man man NN 40436 9391 16 - - HYPH 40436 9391 17 trainer trainer NN 40436 9391 18 , , , 40436 9391 19 wielding wield VBG 40436 9391 20 the the DT 40436 9391 21 compulsory compulsory JJ 40436 9391 22 force force NN 40436 9391 23 of of IN 40436 9391 24 the the DT 40436 9391 25 secular secular JJ 40436 9391 26 arm arm NN 40436 9391 27 for for IN 40436 9391 28 what what WP 40436 9391 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9391 30 believes believe VBZ 40436 9391 31 to to TO 40436 9391 32 be be VB 40436 9391 33 spiritual spiritual JJ 40436 9391 34 improvement improvement NN 40436 9391 35 . . . 40436 9392 1 However however WRB 40436 9392 2 instructive instructive JJ 40436 9392 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9392 4 is be VBZ 40436 9392 5 to to TO 40436 9392 6 study study VB 40436 9392 7 the the DT 40436 9392 8 manner manner NN 40436 9392 9 in in IN 40436 9392 10 which which WDT 40436 9392 11 a a DT 40436 9392 12 mind mind NN 40436 9392 13 like like IN 40436 9392 14 that that DT 40436 9392 15 of of IN 40436 9392 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9392 17 works work VBZ 40436 9392 18 out out RP 40436 9392 19 such such PDT 40436 9392 20 a a DT 40436 9392 21 purpose purpose NN 40436 9392 22 in in IN 40436 9392 23 theory theory NN 40436 9392 24 , , , 40436 9392 25 there there EX 40436 9392 26 is be VBZ 40436 9392 27 no no DT 40436 9392 28 reason reason NN 40436 9392 29 for for IN 40436 9392 30 regret regret NN 40436 9392 31 that that IN 40436 9392 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9392 33 never never RB 40436 9392 34 had have VBD 40436 9392 35 an an DT 40436 9392 36 opportunity opportunity NN 40436 9392 37 of of IN 40436 9392 38 carrying carry VBG 40436 9392 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9392 40 into into IN 40436 9392 41 practice practice NN 40436 9392 42 . . . 40436 9393 1 The the DT 40436 9393 2 manner manner NN 40436 9393 3 in in IN 40436 9393 4 which which WDT 40436 9393 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9393 6 always always RB 40436 9393 7 keeps keep VBZ 40436 9393 8 in in IN 40436 9393 9 view view NN 40436 9393 10 the the DT 40436 9393 11 standing stand VBG 40436 9393 12 mental mental JJ 40436 9393 13 character character NN 40436 9393 14 , , , 40436 9393 15 as as IN 40436 9393 16 an an DT 40436 9393 17 object object NN 40436 9393 18 of of IN 40436 9393 19 capital capital NN 40436 9393 20 importance importance NN 40436 9393 21 to to TO 40436 9393 22 be be VB 40436 9393 23 attended attend VBN 40436 9393 24 to to TO 40436 9393 25 , , , 40436 9393 26 and and CC 40436 9393 27 as as IN 40436 9393 28 the the DT 40436 9393 29 analogon analogon NN 40436 9393 30 of of IN 40436 9393 31 health health NN 40436 9393 32 in in IN 40436 9393 33 the the DT 40436 9393 34 body body NN 40436 9393 35 -- -- : 40436 9393 36 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 9393 37 all all DT 40436 9393 38 esteem esteem NN 40436 9393 39 . . . 40436 9394 1 But but CC 40436 9394 2 when when WRB 40436 9394 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9394 4 assumes assume VBZ 40436 9394 5 the the DT 40436 9394 6 sceptre sceptre NN 40436 9394 7 of of IN 40436 9394 8 King King NNP 40436 9394 9 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 9394 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9394 11 as as IN 40436 9394 12 in in IN 40436 9394 13 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9394 14 and and CC 40436 9394 15 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 9394 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9394 17 to to TO 40436 9394 18 fix fix VB 40436 9394 19 by by IN 40436 9394 20 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 40436 9394 21 authority authority NN 40436 9394 22 what what WP 40436 9394 23 shall shall MD 40436 9394 24 be be VB 40436 9394 25 the the DT 40436 9394 26 orthodox orthodox JJ 40436 9394 27 type type NN 40436 9394 28 of of IN 40436 9394 29 character character NN 40436 9394 30 , , , 40436 9394 31 and and CC 40436 9394 32 to to TO 40436 9394 33 suppress suppress VB 40436 9394 34 all all PDT 40436 9394 35 the the DT 40436 9394 36 varieties variety NNS 40436 9394 37 of of IN 40436 9394 38 emotion emotion NN 40436 9394 39 and and CC 40436 9394 40 intellect intellect NN 40436 9394 41 , , , 40436 9394 42 except except IN 40436 9394 43 such such JJ 40436 9394 44 as as IN 40436 9394 45 will will MD 40436 9394 46 run run VB 40436 9394 47 into into IN 40436 9394 48 a a DT 40436 9394 49 few few JJ 40436 9394 50 predetermined predetermine VBN 40436 9394 51 moulds mould NNS 40436 9394 52 -- -- : 40436 9394 53 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9394 54 oversteps overstep VBZ 40436 9394 55 all all PDT 40436 9394 56 the the DT 40436 9394 57 reasonable reasonable JJ 40436 9394 58 aims aim NNS 40436 9394 59 and and CC 40436 9394 60 boundaries boundary NNS 40436 9394 61 of of IN 40436 9394 62 the the DT 40436 9394 63 political political JJ 40436 9394 64 office office NN 40436 9394 65 . . . 40436 9395 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9395 2 Side side NN 40436 9395 3 - - HYPH 40436 9395 4 note note NN 40436 9395 5 : : : 40436 9395 6 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9395 7 analogy analogy NN 40436 9395 8 between between IN 40436 9395 9 mental mental JJ 40436 9395 10 goodness goodness NN 40436 9395 11 and and CC 40436 9395 12 bodily bodily JJ 40436 9395 13 health health NN 40436 9395 14 -- -- : 40436 9395 15 incomplete incomplete JJ 40436 9395 16 analogy analogy NN 40436 9395 17 -- -- : 40436 9395 18 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 9395 19 of of IN 40436 9395 20 difference difference NN 40436 9395 21 . . . 40436 9395 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9396 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9396 2 forgets forget VBZ 40436 9396 3 two two CD 40436 9396 4 important important JJ 40436 9396 5 points point NNS 40436 9396 6 of of IN 40436 9396 7 difference difference NN 40436 9396 8 , , , 40436 9396 9 in in IN 40436 9396 10 that that DT 40436 9396 11 favourite favourite JJ 40436 9396 12 and and CC 40436 9396 13 very very RB 40436 9396 14 instructive instructive JJ 40436 9396 15 analogy analogy NN 40436 9396 16 which which WDT 40436 9396 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9396 18 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 9396 19 reproduces reproduce VBZ 40436 9396 20 , , , 40436 9396 21 between between IN 40436 9396 22 mental mental JJ 40436 9396 23 goodness goodness NN 40436 9396 24 and and CC 40436 9396 25 bodily bodily JJ 40436 9396 26 health health NN 40436 9396 27 . . . 40436 9397 1 First first JJ 40436 9397 2 , , , 40436 9397 3 good good JJ 40436 9397 4 health health NN 40436 9397 5 and and CC 40436 9397 6 strength strength NN 40436 9397 7 of of IN 40436 9397 8 the the DT 40436 9397 9 body body NN 40436 9397 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9397 11 as as IN 40436 9397 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9397 13 have have VBP 40436 9397 14 observed observe VBN 40436 9397 15 already already RB 40436 9397 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9397 17 are be VBP 40436 9397 18 states state NNS 40436 9397 19 which which WDT 40436 9397 20 every every DT 40436 9397 21 man man NN 40436 9397 22 knows know VBZ 40436 9397 23 when when WRB 40436 9397 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9397 25 has have VBZ 40436 9397 26 got get VBN 40436 9397 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9397 28 . . . 40436 9398 1 Though though IN 40436 9398 2 there there EX 40436 9398 3 is be VBZ 40436 9398 4 much much RB 40436 9398 5 doubt doubt NN 40436 9398 6 and and CC 40436 9398 7 dispute dispute VBP 40436 9398 8 about about IN 40436 9398 9 causes cause NNS 40436 9398 10 , , , 40436 9398 11 preservative preservative JJ 40436 9398 12 , , , 40436 9398 13 destructive destructive JJ 40436 9398 14 , , , 40436 9398 15 and and CC 40436 9398 16 restorative restorative JJ 40436 9398 17 , , , 40436 9398 18 there there EX 40436 9398 19 is be VBZ 40436 9398 20 none none NN 40436 9398 21 about about IN 40436 9398 22 the the DT 40436 9398 23 present present JJ 40436 9398 24 fact fact NN 40436 9398 25 . . . 40436 9399 1 Every every DT 40436 9399 2 sick sick JJ 40436 9399 3 man man NN 40436 9399 4 derives derive VBZ 40436 9399 5 from from IN 40436 9399 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9399 7 own own JJ 40436 9399 8 sensations sensation NNS 40436 9399 9 an an DT 40436 9399 10 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 9399 11 to to TO 40436 9399 12 get get VB 40436 9399 13 well well JJ 40436 9399 14 . . . 40436 9400 1 But but CC 40436 9400 2 virtue virtue NN 40436 9400 3 is be VBZ 40436 9400 4 not not RB 40436 9400 5 a a DT 40436 9400 6 point point NN 40436 9400 7 thus thus RB 40436 9400 8 fixed fix VBN 40436 9400 9 , , , 40436 9400 10 undisputed undisputed JJ 40436 9400 11 , , , 40436 9400 12 indubitable indubitable JJ 40436 9400 13 : : : 40436 9400 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9400 15 is be VBZ 40436 9400 16 differently differently RB 40436 9400 17 conceived conceive VBN 40436 9400 18 by by IN 40436 9400 19 different different JJ 40436 9400 20 persons person NNS 40436 9400 21 , , , 40436 9400 22 and and CC 40436 9400 23 must must MD 40436 9400 24 first first RB 40436 9400 25 be be VB 40436 9400 26 discovered discover VBN 40436 9400 27 and and CC 40436 9400 28 settled settle VBN 40436 9400 29 by by IN 40436 9400 30 a a DT 40436 9400 31 process process NN 40436 9400 32 of of IN 40436 9400 33 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 9400 34 ; ; : 40436 9400 35 the the DT 40436 9400 36 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9400 37 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9400 38 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9400 39 , , , 40436 9400 40 in in IN 40436 9400 41 many many JJ 40436 9400 42 of of IN 40436 9400 43 the the DT 40436 9400 44 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9400 45 -- -- : 40436 9400 46 after after IN 40436 9400 47 declaring declare VBG 40436 9400 48 that that IN 40436 9400 49 neither neither CC 40436 9400 50 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9400 51 nor nor CC 40436 9400 52 any any DT 40436 9400 53 one one NN 40436 9400 54 else else RB 40436 9400 55 within within IN 40436 9400 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9400 57 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9400 58 , , , 40436 9400 59 knows know VBZ 40436 9400 60 what what WP 40436 9400 61 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9400 62 is be VBZ 40436 9400 63 -- -- : 40436 9400 64 tries try VBZ 40436 9400 65 to to TO 40436 9400 66 find find VB 40436 9400 67 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9400 68 out out RP 40436 9400 69 without without IN 40436 9400 70 success success NN 40436 9400 71 . . . 40436 9401 1 Next next RB 40436 9401 2 , , , 40436 9401 3 the the DT 40436 9401 4 physician physician NN 40436 9401 5 , , , 40436 9401 6 who who WP 40436 9401 7 is be VBZ 40436 9401 8 the the DT 40436 9401 9 person person NN 40436 9401 10 actively actively RB 40436 9401 11 concerned concern VBN 40436 9401 12 in in IN 40436 9401 13 imparting impart VBG 40436 9401 14 health health NN 40436 9401 15 and and CC 40436 9401 16 strength strength NN 40436 9401 17 , , , 40436 9401 18 exercises exercise VBZ 40436 9401 19 no no DT 40436 9401 20 coercive coercive JJ 40436 9401 21 power power NN 40436 9401 22 over over IN 40436 9401 23 any any DT 40436 9401 24 one one NN 40436 9401 25 : : : 40436 9401 26 those those DT 40436 9401 27 who who WP 40436 9401 28 consult consult VBP 40436 9401 29 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9401 30 have have VBP 40436 9401 31 the the DT 40436 9401 32 option option NN 40436 9401 33 whether whether IN 40436 9401 34 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9401 35 will will MD 40436 9401 36 follow follow VB 40436 9401 37 the the DT 40436 9401 38 advice advice NN 40436 9401 39 given give VBN 40436 9401 40 , , , 40436 9401 41 or or CC 40436 9401 42 not not RB 40436 9401 43 . . . 40436 9402 1 To to TO 40436 9402 2 put put VB 40436 9402 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9402 4 upon upon IN 40436 9402 5 the the DT 40436 9402 6 same same JJ 40436 9402 7 footing footing NN 40436 9402 8 with with IN 40436 9402 9 the the DT 40436 9402 10 physician physician NN 40436 9402 11 , , , 40436 9402 12 the the DT 40436 9402 13 political political JJ 40436 9402 14 magistrate magistrate NN 40436 9402 15 ought ought MD 40436 9402 16 to to TO 40436 9402 17 confine confine VB 40436 9402 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9402 19 to to IN 40436 9402 20 the the DT 40436 9402 21 function function NN 40436 9402 22 of of IN 40436 9402 23 advice advice NN 40436 9402 24 ; ; : 40436 9402 25 a a DT 40436 9402 26 function function NN 40436 9402 27 highly highly RB 40436 9402 28 useful useful JJ 40436 9402 29 , , , 40436 9402 30 but but CC 40436 9402 31 in in IN 40436 9402 32 which which WDT 40436 9402 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9402 34 will will MD 40436 9402 35 be be VB 40436 9402 36 called call VBN 40436 9402 37 upon upon IN 40436 9402 38 to to TO 40436 9402 39 meet meet VB 40436 9402 40 argumentative argumentative JJ 40436 9402 41 opposition opposition NN 40436 9402 42 , , , 40436 9402 43 and and CC 40436 9402 44 frequent frequent JJ 40436 9402 45 failure failure NN 40436 9402 46 , , , 40436 9402 47 together together RB 40436 9402 48 with with IN 40436 9402 49 the the DT 40436 9402 50 mortification mortification NN 40436 9402 51 of of IN 40436 9402 52 leaving leave VBG 40436 9402 53 those those DT 40436 9402 54 whom whom WP 40436 9402 55 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9402 56 can can MD 40436 9402 57 not not RB 40436 9402 58 convince convince VB 40436 9402 59 , , , 40436 9402 60 to to TO 40436 9402 61 follow follow VB 40436 9402 62 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9402 63 own own JJ 40436 9402 64 mode mode NN 40436 9402 65 of of IN 40436 9402 66 life life NN 40436 9402 67 . . . 40436 9403 1 Here here RB 40436 9403 2 are be VBP 40436 9403 3 two two CD 40436 9403 4 material material NN 40436 9403 5 differences difference NNS 40436 9403 6 , , , 40436 9403 7 modifying modify VBG 40436 9403 8 the the DT 40436 9403 9 applicability applicability NN 40436 9403 10 of of IN 40436 9403 11 that that DT 40436 9403 12 very very JJ 40436 9403 13 analogy analogy NN 40436 9403 14 on on IN 40436 9403 15 which which WDT 40436 9403 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9403 17 so so RB 40436 9403 18 frequently frequently RB 40436 9403 19 rests rest VBZ 40436 9403 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9403 21 proof proof NN 40436 9403 22 . . . 40436 9404 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9404 2 Side side NN 40436 9404 3 - - HYPH 40436 9404 4 note note NN 40436 9404 5 : : : 40436 9404 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9404 7 in in IN 40436 9404 8 the the DT 40436 9404 9 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9404 10 speaks speak VBZ 40436 9404 11 like like IN 40436 9404 12 a a DT 40436 9404 13 dissenter dissenter NN 40436 9404 14 among among IN 40436 9404 15 a a DT 40436 9404 16 community community NN 40436 9404 17 of of IN 40436 9404 18 fixed fix VBN 40436 9404 19 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9404 20 and and CC 40436 9404 21 habits habit NNS 40436 9404 22 . . . 40436 9405 1 Impossible impossible JJ 40436 9405 2 that that IN 40436 9405 3 a a DT 40436 9405 4 dissenter dissenter NN 40436 9405 5 , , , 40436 9405 6 on on IN 40436 9405 7 important important JJ 40436 9405 8 points point NNS 40436 9405 9 , , , 40436 9405 10 should should MD 40436 9405 11 acquire acquire VB 40436 9405 12 any any DT 40436 9405 13 public public JJ 40436 9405 14 influence influence NN 40436 9405 15 . . . 40436 9405 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9406 1 In in IN 40436 9406 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9406 3 's 's POS 40436 9406 4 two two CD 40436 9406 5 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 9406 6 commonwealths commonwealth NNS 40436 9406 7 , , , 40436 9406 8 where where WRB 40436 9406 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9406 10 is be VBZ 40436 9406 11 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9406 12 despotic despotic JJ 40436 9406 13 law law NN 40436 9406 14 - - HYPH 40436 9406 15 giver giver NN 40436 9406 16 , , , 40436 9406 17 there there EX 40436 9406 18 would would MD 40436 9406 19 have have VB 40436 9406 20 been be VBN 40436 9406 21 no no DT 40436 9406 22 tolerable tolerable JJ 40436 9406 23 existence existence NN 40436 9406 24 possible possible JJ 40436 9406 25 for for IN 40436 9406 26 any any DT 40436 9406 27 one one NN 40436 9406 28 not not RB 40436 9406 29 shaped shape VBN 40436 9406 30 upon upon IN 40436 9406 31 the the DT 40436 9406 32 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9406 33 spiritual spiritual JJ 40436 9406 34 model model NN 40436 9406 35 . . . 40436 9407 1 But but CC 40436 9407 2 in in IN 40436 9407 3 the the DT 40436 9407 4 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9407 5 , , , 40436 9407 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9407 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9407 8 speaking speak VBG 40436 9407 9 in in IN 40436 9407 10 the the DT 40436 9407 11 person person NN 40436 9407 12 of of IN 40436 9407 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9407 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9407 15 is be VBZ 40436 9407 16 called call VBN 40436 9407 17 upon upon IN 40436 9407 18 to to TO 40436 9407 19 define define VB 40436 9407 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9407 21 plan plan NN 40436 9407 22 of of IN 40436 9407 23 life life NN 40436 9407 24 in in IN 40436 9407 25 a a DT 40436 9407 26 free free JJ 40436 9407 27 state state NN 40436 9407 28 , , , 40436 9407 29 where where WRB 40436 9407 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9407 31 was be VBD 40436 9407 32 merely merely RB 40436 9407 33 a a DT 40436 9407 34 private private JJ 40436 9407 35 citizen citizen NN 40436 9407 36 . . . 40436 9408 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9408 2 receives receive VBZ 40436 9408 3 from from IN 40436 9408 4 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 9408 5 the the DT 40436 9408 6 advice advice NN 40436 9408 7 , , , 40436 9408 8 to to IN 40436 9408 9 forego forego JJ 40436 9408 10 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9408 11 and and CC 40436 9408 12 to to TO 40436 9408 13 aspire aspire VB 40436 9408 14 to to IN 40436 9408 15 the the DT 40436 9408 16 influence influence NN 40436 9408 17 and and CC 40436 9408 18 celebrity celebrity NN 40436 9408 19 of of IN 40436 9408 20 an an DT 40436 9408 21 active active JJ 40436 9408 22 public public JJ 40436 9408 23 speaker speaker NN 40436 9408 24 . . . 40436 9409 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9409 2 reply reply NN 40436 9409 3 is be VBZ 40436 9409 4 instructive instructive JJ 40436 9409 5 , , , 40436 9409 6 as as IN 40436 9409 7 revealing reveal VBG 40436 9409 8 the the DT 40436 9409 9 interior interior JJ 40436 9409 10 workings working NNS 40436 9409 11 of of IN 40436 9409 12 every every DT 40436 9409 13 political political JJ 40436 9409 14 society society NN 40436 9409 15 . . . 40436 9410 1 No no DT 40436 9410 2 man man NN 40436 9410 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9410 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9410 5 says say VBZ 40436 9410 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9410 7 can can MD 40436 9410 8 find find VB 40436 9410 9 favour favour NN 40436 9410 10 as as IN 40436 9410 11 an an DT 40436 9410 12 adviser adviser NN 40436 9410 13 -- -- : 40436 9410 14 either either CC 40436 9410 15 of of IN 40436 9410 16 a a DT 40436 9410 17 despot despot NN 40436 9410 18 , , , 40436 9410 19 where where WRB 40436 9410 20 there there EX 40436 9410 21 is be VBZ 40436 9410 22 one one CD 40436 9410 23 , , , 40436 9410 24 or or CC 40436 9410 25 of of IN 40436 9410 26 a a DT 40436 9410 27 people people NNS 40436 9410 28 where where WRB 40436 9410 29 there there EX 40436 9410 30 is be VBZ 40436 9410 31 free free JJ 40436 9410 32 government government NN 40436 9410 33 -- -- : 40436 9410 34 unless unless IN 40436 9410 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9410 36 be be VBP 40436 9410 37 in in IN 40436 9410 38 harmony harmony NN 40436 9410 39 with with IN 40436 9410 40 the the DT 40436 9410 41 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 9410 42 and and CC 40436 9410 43 ideas idea NNS 40436 9410 44 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 9410 45 , , , 40436 9410 46 either either CC 40436 9410 47 with with IN 40436 9410 48 the the DT 40436 9410 49 ruling rule VBG 40436 9410 50 Many many JJ 40436 9410 51 or or CC 40436 9410 52 the the DT 40436 9410 53 ruling rule VBG 40436 9410 54 One one CD 40436 9410 55 . . . 40436 9411 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9411 2 must must MD 40436 9411 3 be be VB 40436 9411 4 moulded mould VBN 40436 9411 5 , , , 40436 9411 6 from from IN 40436 9411 7 youth youth NN 40436 9411 8 upwards upwards NNPS 40436 9411 9 , , , 40436 9411 10 on on IN 40436 9411 11 the the DT 40436 9411 12 same same JJ 40436 9411 13 spiritual spiritual JJ 40436 9411 14 pattern pattern NN 40436 9411 15 as as IN 40436 9411 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9411 17 are:[117 are:[117 : 40436 9411 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9411 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9411 20 love love NN 40436 9411 21 and and CC 40436 9411 22 hate hate NN 40436 9411 23 , , , 40436 9411 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9411 25 praise praise NN 40436 9411 26 and and CC 40436 9411 27 blame blame NN 40436 9411 28 , , , 40436 9411 29 must must MD 40436 9411 30 turn turn VB 40436 9411 31 towards towards IN 40436 9411 32 the the DT 40436 9411 33 same same JJ 40436 9411 34 things thing NNS 40436 9411 35 : : : 40436 9411 36 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9411 37 must must MD 40436 9411 38 have have VB 40436 9411 39 the the DT 40436 9411 40 same same JJ 40436 9411 41 tastes taste NNS 40436 9411 42 , , , 40436 9411 43 the the DT 40436 9411 44 same same JJ 40436 9411 45 morality morality NN 40436 9411 46 , , , 40436 9411 47 the the DT 40436 9411 48 same same JJ 40436 9411 49 _ _ NNP 40436 9411 50 idéal idéal NNP 40436 9411 51 _ _ NNP 40436 9411 52 , , , 40436 9411 53 as as IN 40436 9411 54 theirs -PRON- PRP 40436 9411 55 : : : 40436 9411 56 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9411 57 must must MD 40436 9411 58 be be VB 40436 9411 59 no no DT 40436 9411 60 imitator imitator NN 40436 9411 61 , , , 40436 9411 62 but but CC 40436 9411 63 a a DT 40436 9411 64 chip chip NN 40436 9411 65 of of IN 40436 9411 66 the the DT 40436 9411 67 same same JJ 40436 9411 68 block block NN 40436 9411 69 . . . 40436 9412 1 If if IN 40436 9412 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9412 3 be be VB 40436 9412 4 either either RB 40436 9412 5 better well JJR 40436 9412 6 than than IN 40436 9412 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9412 8 or or CC 40436 9412 9 worse bad JJR 40436 9412 10 than than IN 40436 9412 11 they,[118 they,[118 JJ 40436 9412 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9412 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9412 14 will will MD 40436 9412 15 fail fail VB 40436 9412 16 in in IN 40436 9412 17 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 9412 18 popularity popularity NN 40436 9412 19 , , , 40436 9412 20 and and CC 40436 9412 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9412 22 efforts effort NNS 40436 9412 23 as as IN 40436 9412 24 a a DT 40436 9412 25 competitor competitor NN 40436 9412 26 for for IN 40436 9412 27 public public JJ 40436 9412 28 influence influence NN 40436 9412 29 will will MD 40436 9412 30 be be VB 40436 9412 31 not not RB 40436 9412 32 only only RB 40436 9412 33 abortive abortive JJ 40436 9412 34 , , , 40436 9412 35 but but CC 40436 9412 36 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 9412 37 dangerous dangerous JJ 40436 9412 38 to to IN 40436 9412 39 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9412 40 . . . 40436 9413 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9413 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9413 3 117 117 CD 40436 9413 4 : : : 40436 9413 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9413 6 , , , 40436 9413 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9413 8 , , , 40436 9413 9 p. p. NN 40436 9413 10 510 510 CD 40436 9413 11 C C NNP 40436 9413 12 - - HYPH 40436 9413 13 D. D. NNP 40436 9413 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9413 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9413 16 : : : 40436 9413 17 o(moê o(moê NN 40436 9413 18 / / SYM 40436 9413 19 thês thês JJ 40436 9413 20 ô)/n ô)/n NNP 40436 9413 21 , , , 40436 9413 22 tau)ta\ tau)ta\ NNP 40436 9413 23 pse pse NNP 40436 9413 24 / / SYM 40436 9413 25 gôn gôn NNP 40436 9413 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9413 27 e)painô e)painô NNP 40436 9413 28 = = SYM 40436 9413 29 n n CC 40436 9413 30 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9413 31 a)/rchonti a)/rchonti NN 40436 9413 32 . . . 40436 9414 1 . . . 40436 9415 1 . . . 40436 9416 1 . . . 40436 9417 1 eu)thu\s eu)thu\s `` 40436 9417 2 e)k e)k NNP 40436 9417 3 ne ne NNP 40436 9417 4 / / SYM 40436 9417 5 ou ou NNP 40436 9417 6 e)thi e)thi NNP 40436 9417 7 / / SYM 40436 9417 8 zein zein NNP 40436 9417 9 au(to\n au(to\n NNP 40436 9417 10 toi toi NNP 40436 9417 11 = = SYM 40436 9417 12 s s NNP 40436 9417 13 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 9417 14 = = SYM 40436 9417 15 s s NNP 40436 9417 16 chai chai NNP 40436 9417 17 / / SYM 40436 9417 18 rein rein NNP 40436 9417 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9417 20 a)/chthesthai a)/chthesthai NNP 40436 9417 21 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9417 22 despo despo NNP 40436 9417 23 / / SYM 40436 9417 24 tê| tê| NNP 40436 9417 25 , , , 40436 9417 26 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9417 27 paraskeua paraskeua NNP 40436 9417 28 / / SYM 40436 9417 29 zein zein NNP 40436 9417 30 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 9417 31 o(/ o(/ NNP 40436 9417 32 ti ti NNP 40436 9417 33 ma ma NNP 40436 9417 34 / / SYM 40436 9417 35 lista lista NNP 40436 9417 36 o(/moios o(/moios NNP 40436 9417 37 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 9417 38 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 9417 39 / / SYM 40436 9417 40 nô| nô| NNP 40436 9417 41 . . . 40436 9417 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9418 1 513 513 CD 40436 9418 2 B b NN 40436 9418 3 : : : 40436 9418 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9418 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9418 6 : : : 40436 9418 7 ou ou NNP 40436 9418 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9418 9 mimêtê\n mimêtê\n NFP 40436 9418 10 dei= dei= NNP 40436 9418 11 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 9418 12 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9418 13 ' ' `` 40436 9418 14 au)tophuô au)tophuô NNP 40436 9418 15 = = SYM 40436 9418 16 s s NNP 40436 9418 17 o(/moion o(/moion NNP 40436 9418 18 tou tou NNP 40436 9418 19 / / SYM 40436 9418 20 tois tois NNP 40436 9418 21 . . . 40436 9418 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9418 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9419 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9419 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9419 3 118 118 CD 40436 9419 4 : : : 40436 9419 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9419 6 , , , 40436 9419 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9419 8 , , , 40436 9419 9 p. p. NN 40436 9419 10 513 513 CD 40436 9419 11 A. a. NN 40436 9420 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9420 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9420 3 : : : 40436 9420 4 ei)/t ei)/t NNP 40436 9420 5 ' ' POS 40436 9420 6 e)pi\ e)pi\ NN 40436 9420 7 to\ to\ NN 40436 9420 8 be be VB 40436 9420 9 / / SYM 40436 9420 10 ltion ltion NN 40436 9420 11 ei)/t ei)/t NNP 40436 9420 12 ' ' POS 40436 9420 13 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 9420 14 to\ to\ NN 40436 9420 15 chei chei NN 40436 9420 16 = = NFP 40436 9420 17 ron ron XX 40436 9420 18 . . . 40436 9420 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9420 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9421 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9421 2 Side side NN 40436 9421 3 - - HYPH 40436 9421 4 note note NN 40436 9421 5 : : : 40436 9421 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9421 7 feels feel VBZ 40436 9421 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9421 9 own own JJ 40436 9421 10 isolation isolation NN 40436 9421 11 from from IN 40436 9421 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9421 13 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 9421 14 . . . 40436 9422 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9422 2 is be VBZ 40436 9422 3 thrown throw VBN 40436 9422 4 upon upon IN 40436 9422 5 individual individual JJ 40436 9422 6 speculation speculation NN 40436 9422 7 and and CC 40436 9422 8 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 9422 9 . . . 40436 9422 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9423 1 The the DT 40436 9423 2 reasons reason NNS 40436 9423 3 which which WDT 40436 9423 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9423 5 gives give VBZ 40436 9423 6 here here RB 40436 9423 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9423 8 as as RB 40436 9423 9 well well RB 40436 9423 10 as as IN 40436 9423 11 in in IN 40436 9423 12 the the DT 40436 9423 13 Apology Apology NNP 40436 9423 14 , , , 40436 9423 15 and and CC 40436 9423 16 partly partly RB 40436 9423 17 also also RB 40436 9423 18 in in IN 40436 9423 19 the the DT 40436 9423 20 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9423 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9423 22 for for IN 40436 9423 23 not not RB 40436 9423 24 embarking embark VBG 40436 9423 25 in in IN 40436 9423 26 the the DT 40436 9423 27 competition competition NN 40436 9423 28 of of IN 40436 9423 29 political political JJ 40436 9423 30 aspirants aspirant NNS 40436 9423 31 , , , 40436 9423 32 are be VBP 40436 9423 33 of of IN 40436 9423 34 very very RB 40436 9423 35 general general JJ 40436 9423 36 application application NN 40436 9423 37 . . . 40436 9424 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9424 2 is be VBZ 40436 9424 3 an an DT 40436 9424 4 innovator innovator NN 40436 9424 5 in in IN 40436 9424 6 religion religion NN 40436 9424 7 ; ; : 40436 9424 8 and and CC 40436 9424 9 a a DT 40436 9424 10 dissenter dissenter NN 40436 9424 11 from from IN 40436 9424 12 the the DT 40436 9424 13 received receive VBN 40436 9424 14 ethics ethic NNS 40436 9424 15 , , , 40436 9424 16 politics politic NNS 40436 9424 17 , , , 40436 9424 18 social social JJ 40436 9424 19 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 9424 20 , , , 40436 9424 21 and and CC 40436 9424 22 estimate estimate NN 40436 9424 23 of of IN 40436 9424 24 life life NN 40436 9424 25 and and CC 40436 9424 26 conduct conduct NN 40436 9424 27 . . . 40436 9425 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9425 2 119 119 CD 40436 9425 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9425 4 Whoever whoever WP 40436 9425 5 dissents dissent VBZ 40436 9425 6 upon upon IN 40436 9425 7 these these DT 40436 9425 8 matters matter NNS 40436 9425 9 from from IN 40436 9425 10 the the DT 40436 9425 11 governing govern VBG 40436 9425 12 force force NN 40436 9425 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9425 14 in in IN 40436 9425 15 whatever whatever WDT 40436 9425 16 hands hand NNS 40436 9425 17 that that WDT 40436 9425 18 may may MD 40436 9425 19 happen happen VB 40436 9425 20 to to TO 40436 9425 21 reside reside VB 40436 9425 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9425 23 has have VBZ 40436 9425 24 no no DT 40436 9425 25 chance chance NN 40436 9425 26 of of IN 40436 9425 27 being be VBG 40436 9425 28 listened listen VBN 40436 9425 29 to to IN 40436 9425 30 as as IN 40436 9425 31 a a DT 40436 9425 32 political political JJ 40436 9425 33 counsellor counsellor NN 40436 9425 34 , , , 40436 9425 35 and and CC 40436 9425 36 may may MD 40436 9425 37 think think VB 40436 9425 38 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9425 39 fortunate fortunate JJ 40436 9425 40 if if IN 40436 9425 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9425 42 escapes escape VBZ 40436 9425 43 without without IN 40436 9425 44 personal personal JJ 40436 9425 45 hurt hurt NN 40436 9425 46 or or CC 40436 9425 47 loss loss NN 40436 9425 48 . . . 40436 9426 1 Whether whether IN 40436 9426 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9426 3 dissent dissent NN 40436 9426 4 be be VB 40436 9426 5 for for IN 40436 9426 6 the the DT 40436 9426 7 better well JJR 40436 9426 8 or or CC 40436 9426 9 for for IN 40436 9426 10 the the DT 40436 9426 11 worse bad JJR 40436 9426 12 , , , 40436 9426 13 is be VBZ 40436 9426 14 a a DT 40436 9426 15 matter matter NN 40436 9426 16 of of IN 40436 9426 17 little little JJ 40436 9426 18 moment moment NN 40436 9426 19 : : : 40436 9426 20 the the DT 40436 9426 21 ruling rule VBG 40436 9426 22 body body NN 40436 9426 23 always always RB 40436 9426 24 think think VBP 40436 9426 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9426 26 worse worse RBR 40436 9426 27 , , , 40436 9426 28 and and CC 40436 9426 29 the the DT 40436 9426 30 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9426 31 to to IN 40436 9426 32 the the DT 40436 9426 33 dissenter dissenter NN 40436 9426 34 are be VBP 40436 9426 35 the the DT 40436 9426 36 same same JJ 40436 9426 37 . . . 40436 9427 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9427 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9427 3 119 119 CD 40436 9427 4 : : : 40436 9427 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9427 6 , , , 40436 9427 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9427 8 , , , 40436 9427 9 p. p. NN 40436 9427 10 522 522 CD 40436 9427 11 B b NN 40436 9427 12 ; ; : 40436 9427 13 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 9427 14 , , , 40436 9427 15 p. p. NN 40436 9427 16 179 179 CD 40436 9427 17 ; ; : 40436 9427 18 Menon Menon NNP 40436 9427 19 , , , 40436 9427 20 p. p. NN 40436 9428 1 79 79 CD 40436 9428 2 . . . 40436 9428 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9429 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9429 2 Side side NN 40436 9429 3 - - HYPH 40436 9429 4 note note NN 40436 9429 5 : : : 40436 9429 6 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9429 7 between between IN 40436 9429 8 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9429 9 and and CC 40436 9429 10 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9429 11 . . . 40436 9429 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9430 1 Herein Herein NNP 40436 9430 2 consists consist VBZ 40436 9430 3 the the DT 40436 9430 4 real real JJ 40436 9430 5 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9430 6 between between IN 40436 9430 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9430 8 , , , 40436 9430 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9430 10 , , , 40436 9430 11 and and CC 40436 9430 12 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9430 13 , , , 40436 9430 14 on on IN 40436 9430 15 the the DT 40436 9430 16 one one CD 40436 9430 17 side side NN 40436 9430 18 -- -- : 40436 9430 19 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9430 20 , , , 40436 9430 21 Nikias Nikias NNP 40436 9430 22 , , , 40436 9430 23 Kleon Kleon NNP 40436 9430 24 , , , 40436 9430 25 Demosthenes Demosthenes NNP 40436 9430 26 , , , 40436 9430 27 and and CC 40436 9430 28 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9430 29 , , , 40436 9430 30 on on IN 40436 9430 31 the the DT 40436 9430 32 other other JJ 40436 9430 33 . . . 40436 9431 1 " " `` 40436 9431 2 You -PRON- PRP 40436 9431 3 , , , 40436 9431 4 " " '' 40436 9431 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9431 6 says say VBZ 40436 9431 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9431 8 to to IN 40436 9431 9 Kalliklês),[120 Kalliklês),[120 NNP 40436 9431 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9431 11 " " `` 40436 9431 12 are be VBP 40436 9431 13 in in IN 40436 9431 14 love love NN 40436 9431 15 with with IN 40436 9431 16 the the DT 40436 9431 17 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9431 18 people people NNS 40436 9431 19 , , , 40436 9431 20 and and CC 40436 9431 21 take take VB 40436 9431 22 up up RP 40436 9431 23 or or CC 40436 9431 24 renounce renounce VB 40436 9431 25 such such JJ 40436 9431 26 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9431 27 as as IN 40436 9431 28 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9431 29 approve approve VBP 40436 9431 30 or or CC 40436 9431 31 discountenance discountenance NN 40436 9431 32 : : : 40436 9431 33 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9431 34 am be VBP 40436 9431 35 in in IN 40436 9431 36 love love NN 40436 9431 37 with with IN 40436 9431 38 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9431 39 , , , 40436 9431 40 and and CC 40436 9431 41 follow follow VB 40436 9431 42 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9431 43 guidance guidance NN 40436 9431 44 . . . 40436 9432 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 9432 2 and and CC 40436 9432 3 other other JJ 40436 9432 4 active active JJ 40436 9432 5 politicians politician NNS 40436 9432 6 do do VBP 40436 9432 7 not not RB 40436 9432 8 wish wish VB 40436 9432 9 to to TO 40436 9432 10 have have VB 40436 9432 11 more more JJR 40436 9432 12 than than IN 40436 9432 13 a a DT 40436 9432 14 smattering smattering NN 40436 9432 15 of of IN 40436 9432 16 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9432 17 ; ; : 40436 9432 18 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9432 19 are be VBP 40436 9432 20 afraid afraid JJ 40436 9432 21 of of IN 40436 9432 22 becoming become VBG 40436 9432 23 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 9432 24 corrupted corrupt VBN 40436 9432 25 , , , 40436 9432 26 if if IN 40436 9432 27 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9432 28 carry carry VBP 40436 9432 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9432 30 beyond beyond IN 40436 9432 31 such such JJ 40436 9432 32 elementary elementary JJ 40436 9432 33 stage stage NN 40436 9432 34 . . . 40436 9433 1 " " `` 40436 9433 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9433 3 121 121 CD 40436 9433 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9433 5 Each each DT 40436 9433 6 of of IN 40436 9433 7 these these DT 40436 9433 8 orators orator NNS 40436 9433 9 , , , 40436 9433 10 discussing discuss VBG 40436 9433 11 political political JJ 40436 9433 12 measures measure NNS 40436 9433 13 before before IN 40436 9433 14 the the DT 40436 9433 15 public public NNP 40436 9433 16 assembly assembly NN 40436 9433 17 , , , 40436 9433 18 appealed appeal VBD 40436 9433 19 to to IN 40436 9433 20 general general JJ 40436 9433 21 maxims maxim NNS 40436 9433 22 borrowed borrow VBN 40436 9433 23 from from IN 40436 9433 24 the the DT 40436 9433 25 received received JJ 40436 9433 26 creed creed NN 40436 9433 27 of of IN 40436 9433 28 morality morality NN 40436 9433 29 , , , 40436 9433 30 religion religion NN 40436 9433 31 , , , 40436 9433 32 taste taste NN 40436 9433 33 , , , 40436 9433 34 politics politic NNS 40436 9433 35 , , , 40436 9433 36 & & CC 40436 9433 37 c. c. NNP 40436 9433 38 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9433 39 success success NN 40436 9433 40 depended depend VBD 40436 9433 41 mainly mainly RB 40436 9433 42 on on IN 40436 9433 43 the the DT 40436 9433 44 emphasis emphasis NN 40436 9433 45 which which WDT 40436 9433 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9433 47 eloquence eloquence NN 40436 9433 48 could could MD 40436 9433 49 lend lend VB 40436 9433 50 to to IN 40436 9433 51 such such JJ 40436 9433 52 maxims maxim NNS 40436 9433 53 , , , 40436 9433 54 and and CC 40436 9433 55 on on IN 40436 9433 56 the the DT 40436 9433 57 skill skill NN 40436 9433 58 with with IN 40436 9433 59 which which WDT 40436 9433 60 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9433 61 could could MD 40436 9433 62 apply apply VB 40436 9433 63 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9433 64 to to IN 40436 9433 65 the the DT 40436 9433 66 case case NN 40436 9433 67 in in IN 40436 9433 68 hand hand NN 40436 9433 69 . . . 40436 9434 1 But but CC 40436 9434 2 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9434 3 could could MD 40436 9434 4 not not RB 40436 9434 5 follow follow VB 40436 9434 6 such such PDT 40436 9434 7 an an DT 40436 9434 8 example example NN 40436 9434 9 . . . 40436 9435 1 Anxious anxious JJ 40436 9435 2 in in IN 40436 9435 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9435 4 research research NN 40436 9435 5 after after IN 40436 9435 6 truth truth NN 40436 9435 7 , , , 40436 9435 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9435 9 applied apply VBD 40436 9435 10 the the DT 40436 9435 11 test test NN 40436 9435 12 of of IN 40436 9435 13 analysis analysis NN 40436 9435 14 to to IN 40436 9435 15 the the DT 40436 9435 16 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 9435 17 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9435 18 -- -- : 40436 9435 19 found find VBD 40436 9435 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9435 21 , , , 40436 9435 22 in in IN 40436 9435 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9435 24 judgment judgment NN 40436 9435 25 , , , 40436 9435 26 neither neither CC 40436 9435 27 consistent consistent JJ 40436 9435 28 nor nor CC 40436 9435 29 rational rational JJ 40436 9435 30 -- -- : 40436 9435 31 constrained constrain VBD 40436 9435 32 many many JJ 40436 9435 33 persons person NNS 40436 9435 34 to to TO 40436 9435 35 feel feel VB 40436 9435 36 this this DT 40436 9435 37 , , , 40436 9435 38 by by IN 40436 9435 39 an an DT 40436 9435 40 humiliating humiliating JJ 40436 9435 41 cross cross NN 40436 9435 42 - - NN 40436 9435 43 examination examination NN 40436 9435 44 -- -- : 40436 9435 45 but but CC 40436 9435 46 became become VBD 40436 9435 47 disqualified disqualify VBN 40436 9435 48 from from IN 40436 9435 49 addressing address VBG 40436 9435 50 , , , 40436 9435 51 with with IN 40436 9435 52 any any DT 40436 9435 53 chance chance NN 40436 9435 54 of of IN 40436 9435 55 assent assent NN 40436 9435 56 , , , 40436 9435 57 the the DT 40436 9435 58 assembled assemble VBN 40436 9435 59 public public NN 40436 9435 60 . . . 40436 9436 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9436 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9436 3 120 120 CD 40436 9436 4 : : : 40436 9436 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9436 6 , , , 40436 9436 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9436 8 , , , 40436 9436 9 p p NNP 40436 9436 10 , , , 40436 9436 11 481 481 CD 40436 9436 12 E. e. NN 40436 9436 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9436 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9436 15 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9436 16 121 121 CD 40436 9436 17 : : : 40436 9436 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9436 19 , , , 40436 9436 20 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9436 21 , , , 40436 9436 22 p. p. NN 40436 9436 23 487 487 CD 40436 9436 24 C. C. NNP 40436 9436 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9436 26 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9436 27 : : : 40436 9436 28 e)ni e)ni NN 40436 9436 29 / / , 40436 9436 30 ka ka UH 40436 9436 31 e)s e)s NNP 40436 9436 32 u(mi u(mi NNP 40436 9436 33 = = SYM 40436 9436 34 n n CC 40436 9436 35 toia toia NN 40436 9436 36 / / SYM 40436 9436 37 de de NNP 40436 9436 38 tis tis NNP 40436 9436 39 do do VB 40436 9436 40 / / SYM 40436 9436 41 xa xa NNP 40436 9436 42 , , , 40436 9436 43 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9436 44 prothumei prothumei NN 40436 9436 45 = = SYM 40436 9436 46 sthai sthai NN 40436 9436 47 ei)s ei)s `` 40436 9436 48 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9436 49 a)kribei a)kribei NNP 40436 9436 50 / / SYM 40436 9436 51 an an DT 40436 9436 52 philosophei philosophei NN 40436 9436 53 = = SYM 40436 9436 54 n n XX 40436 9436 55 , , , 40436 9436 56 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 9436 57 eu)labei eu)labei NNP 40436 9436 58 = = SYM 40436 9436 59 sthai sthai NNP 40436 9436 60 . . . 40436 9437 1 . . . 40436 9438 1 . . . 40436 9439 1 . . . 40436 9440 1 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 9440 2 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9440 3 pe pe NNP 40436 9440 4 / / SYM 40436 9440 5 ra ra NNP 40436 9440 6 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9440 7 de de NNP 40436 9440 8 / / SYM 40436 9440 9 ontos ontos NNP 40436 9440 10 sophô sophô NNP 40436 9440 11 / / SYM 40436 9440 12 teroi teroi NNP 40436 9440 13 geno geno NNP 40436 9440 14 / / SYM 40436 9440 15 menoi menoi NNP 40436 9440 16 lê lê NNP 40436 9440 17 / / SYM 40436 9440 18 sete sete NNP 40436 9440 19 diaphthare diaphthare NN 40436 9440 20 / / SYM 40436 9440 21 ntes nte NNS 40436 9440 22 . . . 40436 9440 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9441 1 The the DT 40436 9441 2 view view NN 40436 9441 3 here here RB 40436 9441 4 advocated advocate VBN 40436 9441 5 by by IN 40436 9441 6 Kallikles:--That Kallikles:--That NNP 40436 9441 7 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9441 8 is be VBZ 40436 9441 9 good good JJ 40436 9441 10 and and CC 40436 9441 11 useful useful JJ 40436 9441 12 , , , 40436 9441 13 to to TO 40436 9441 14 be be VB 40436 9441 15 studied study VBN 40436 9441 16 up up RP 40436 9441 17 to to IN 40436 9441 18 a a DT 40436 9441 19 point point NN 40436 9441 20 in in IN 40436 9441 21 the the DT 40436 9441 22 earlier early JJR 40436 9441 23 years year NNS 40436 9441 24 of of IN 40436 9441 25 life life NN 40436 9441 26 , , , 40436 9441 27 in in IN 40436 9441 28 order order NN 40436 9441 29 to to TO 40436 9441 30 qualify qualify VB 40436 9441 31 persons person NNS 40436 9441 32 for for IN 40436 9441 33 effective effective JJ 40436 9441 34 discharge discharge NN 40436 9441 35 of of IN 40436 9441 36 the the DT 40436 9441 37 duties duty NNS 40436 9441 38 of of IN 40436 9441 39 active active JJ 40436 9441 40 citizenship citizenship NN 40436 9441 41 , , , 40436 9441 42 but but CC 40436 9441 43 that that IN 40436 9441 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9441 45 ought ought MD 40436 9441 46 not not RB 40436 9441 47 to to TO 40436 9441 48 be be VB 40436 9441 49 made make VBN 40436 9441 50 the the DT 40436 9441 51 main main JJ 40436 9441 52 occupation occupation NN 40436 9441 53 of of IN 40436 9441 54 mature mature JJ 40436 9441 55 life life NN 40436 9441 56 , , , 40436 9441 57 nor nor CC 40436 9441 58 be be VB 40436 9441 59 prosecuted prosecute VBN 40436 9441 60 up up RP 40436 9441 61 to to IN 40436 9441 62 the the DT 40436 9441 63 pitch pitch NN 40436 9441 64 of of IN 40436 9441 65 accurate accurate JJ 40436 9441 66 theorising theorising NN 40436 9441 67 : : : 40436 9441 68 this this DT 40436 9441 69 view view NN 40436 9441 70 , , , 40436 9441 71 since since IN 40436 9441 72 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9441 73 here here RB 40436 9441 74 assigns assign VBZ 40436 9441 75 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9441 76 to to IN 40436 9441 77 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 9441 78 , , , 40436 9441 79 is be VBZ 40436 9441 80 denounced denounce VBN 40436 9441 81 by by IN 40436 9441 82 most most JJS 40436 9441 83 of of IN 40436 9441 84 the the DT 40436 9441 85 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9441 86 critics critic NNS 40436 9441 87 as as IN 40436 9441 88 if if IN 40436 9441 89 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9441 90 were be VBD 40436 9441 91 low low JJ 40436 9441 92 and and CC 40436 9441 93 worthless worthless JJ 40436 9441 94 . . . 40436 9442 1 Yet yet CC 40436 9442 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9442 3 was be VBD 40436 9442 4 held hold VBN 40436 9442 5 by by IN 40436 9442 6 many many JJ 40436 9442 7 of of IN 40436 9442 8 the the DT 40436 9442 9 most most RBS 40436 9442 10 respectable respectable JJ 40436 9442 11 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9442 12 of of IN 40436 9442 13 antiquity antiquity NN 40436 9442 14 ; ; : 40436 9442 15 and and CC 40436 9442 16 the the DT 40436 9442 17 question question NN 40436 9442 18 is be VBZ 40436 9442 19 , , , 40436 9442 20 in in IN 40436 9442 21 point point NN 40436 9442 22 of of IN 40436 9442 23 fact fact NN 40436 9442 24 , , , 40436 9442 25 that that IN 40436 9442 26 which which WDT 40436 9442 27 has have VBZ 40436 9442 28 always always RB 40436 9442 29 been be VBN 40436 9442 30 in in IN 40436 9442 31 debate debate NN 40436 9442 32 between between IN 40436 9442 33 the the DT 40436 9442 34 life life NN 40436 9442 35 of of IN 40436 9442 36 theoretical theoretical JJ 40436 9442 37 speculation speculation NN 40436 9442 38 and and CC 40436 9442 39 the the DT 40436 9442 40 life life NN 40436 9442 41 of of IN 40436 9442 42 action action NN 40436 9442 43 . . . 40436 9443 1 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 9443 2 urges urge VBZ 40436 9443 3 the the DT 40436 9443 4 same same JJ 40436 9443 5 view view NN 40436 9443 6 both both DT 40436 9443 7 in in IN 40436 9443 8 Orat Orat NNP 40436 9443 9 . . . 40436 9444 1 xv xv NNP 40436 9444 2 . . . 40436 9445 1 De De NNP 40436 9445 2 Permutatione Permutatione NNP 40436 9445 3 , , , 40436 9445 4 sect sect NN 40436 9445 5 . . . 40436 9446 1 282 282 CD 40436 9446 2 - - SYM 40436 9446 3 287 287 CD 40436 9446 4 , , , 40436 9446 5 pp pp NNP 40436 9446 6 . . . 40436 9447 1 485 485 CD 40436 9447 2 - - SYM 40436 9447 3 486 486 CD 40436 9447 4 , , , 40436 9447 5 Bekker Bekker NNP 40436 9447 6 ; ; : 40436 9447 7 and and CC 40436 9447 8 Orat Orat NNP 40436 9447 9 . . . 40436 9448 1 xii xii NNP 40436 9448 2 . . . 40436 9449 1 Panathenaic Panathenaic NNP 40436 9449 2 . . . 40436 9450 1 sect sect NNP 40436 9450 2 . . . 40436 9451 1 29 29 CD 40436 9451 2 - - SYM 40436 9451 3 32 32 CD 40436 9451 4 , , , 40436 9451 5 p. p. NN 40436 9451 6 321 321 CD 40436 9451 7 , , , 40436 9451 8 Bekker Bekker NNP 40436 9451 9 . . . 40436 9452 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9452 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9452 3 : : : 40436 9452 4 diatri diatri NNP 40436 9452 5 / / SYM 40436 9452 6 psai psai NNP 40436 9452 7 me\n me\n NNP 40436 9452 8 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 9452 9 peri\ peri\ . 40436 9452 10 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 9452 11 paidei paidei NNP 40436 9452 12 / / SYM 40436 9452 13 as as IN 40436 9452 14 tau tau NNP 40436 9452 15 / / SYM 40436 9452 16 tas tas NNP 40436 9452 17 chro chro NN 40436 9452 18 / / SYM 40436 9452 19 non non NNP 40436 9452 20 tina\ tina\ NNP 40436 9452 21 sumbouleu sumbouleu NNP 40436 9452 22 / / SYM 40436 9452 23 saim saim NNP 40436 9452 24 ' ' POS 40436 9452 25 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 9452 26 toi toi NNP 40436 9452 27 = = SYM 40436 9452 28 s s NNP 40436 9452 29 neôte neôte NNP 40436 9452 30 / / SYM 40436 9452 31 rois rois NNP 40436 9452 32 , , , 40436 9452 33 mê\ mê\ VBP 40436 9452 34 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9452 35 / / SYM 40436 9452 36 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 9452 37 perii+dei perii+dei NNP 40436 9452 38 = = SYM 40436 9452 39 n n CC 40436 9452 40 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9452 41 phu phu NN 40436 9452 42 / / SYM 40436 9452 43 sin sin NN 40436 9452 44 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9452 45 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 9452 46 = = SYM 40436 9452 47 n n CC 40436 9452 48 kataskeleteuthei kataskeleteuthei NN 40436 9452 49 = = SYM 40436 9452 50 san san NNP 40436 9452 51 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 9452 52 tou tou NNP 40436 9452 53 / / SYM 40436 9452 54 tois tois NNP 40436 9452 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9452 56 , , , 40436 9452 57 & & CC 40436 9452 58 c. c. NNP 40436 9452 59 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 9452 60 quotes quote VBZ 40436 9452 61 a a DT 40436 9452 62 similar similar JJ 40436 9452 63 opinion opinion NN 40436 9452 64 put put VBN 40436 9452 65 by by IN 40436 9452 66 Ennius ennius NN 40436 9452 67 the the DT 40436 9452 68 poet poet NN 40436 9452 69 into into IN 40436 9452 70 the the DT 40436 9452 71 mouth mouth NN 40436 9452 72 of of IN 40436 9452 73 Neoptolemus Neoptolemus NNP 40436 9452 74 , , , 40436 9452 75 Tusc Tusc NNP 40436 9452 76 . . . 40436 9453 1 D. D. NNP 40436 9453 2 ii ii NNP 40436 9453 3 . . . 40436 9454 1 1 1 CD 40436 9454 2 , , , 40436 9454 3 1 1 CD 40436 9454 4 ; ; : 40436 9454 5 Aulus Aulus NNP 40436 9454 6 Gell Gell NNP 40436 9454 7 . . . 40436 9455 1 v. v. CC 40436 9455 2 16 16 CD 40436 9455 3 - - HYPH 40436 9455 4 -"degustandum -"degustandum NNP 40436 9455 5 ex ex NNP 40436 9455 6 philosophiâ philosophiâ NN 40436 9455 7 censet censet NNP 40436 9455 8 , , , 40436 9455 9 non non JJ 40436 9455 10 in in IN 40436 9455 11 eam eam NNP 40436 9455 12 ingurgitandum ingurgitandum NN 40436 9455 13 " " '' 40436 9455 14 . . . 40436 9456 1 Tacitus Tacitus NNP 40436 9456 2 , , , 40436 9456 3 in in IN 40436 9456 4 describing describe VBG 40436 9456 5 the the DT 40436 9456 6 education education NN 40436 9456 7 of of IN 40436 9456 8 Agricola Agricola NNP 40436 9456 9 , , , 40436 9456 10 who who WP 40436 9456 11 was be VBD 40436 9456 12 taken take VBN 40436 9456 13 by by IN 40436 9456 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9456 15 mother mother NN 40436 9456 16 in in IN 40436 9456 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9456 18 earlier early JJR 40436 9456 19 years year NNS 40436 9456 20 to to TO 40436 9456 21 study study VB 40436 9456 22 at at IN 40436 9456 23 Massilia Massilia NNP 40436 9456 24 , , , 40436 9456 25 says say VBZ 40436 9456 26 , , , 40436 9456 27 c. c. NNP 40436 9456 28 4:--"Memoriâ 4:--"memoriâ CD 40436 9456 29 teneo teneo NN 40436 9456 30 , , , 40436 9456 31 solitum solitum RB 40436 9456 32 ipsum ipsum NNP 40436 9456 33 narrare narrare NNP 40436 9456 34 , , , 40436 9456 35 se se NNP 40436 9456 36 in in IN 40436 9456 37 primâ primâ NNP 40436 9456 38 juventâ juventâ NNP 40436 9456 39 studium studium NNP 40436 9456 40 philosophiæ philosophiæ NNP 40436 9456 41 , , , 40436 9456 42 _ _ NNP 40436 9456 43 ultra ultra NNP 40436 9456 44 quam quam NNP 40436 9456 45 concessum concessum NNP 40436 9456 46 Romano Romano NNP 40436 9456 47 et et NN 40436 9456 48 senatori senatori NN 40436 9456 49 _ _ NNP 40436 9456 50 , , , 40436 9456 51 hausisse hausisse NNP 40436 9456 52 ; ; : 40436 9456 53 ni ni NNP 40436 9456 54 prudentia prudentia NNP 40436 9456 55 matris matris NNP 40436 9456 56 incensum incensum NNP 40436 9456 57 ac ac IN 40436 9456 58 flagrantem flagrantem NNP 40436 9456 59 animum animum NN 40436 9456 60 coercuisset coercuisset NN 40436 9456 61 " " '' 40436 9456 62 . . . 40436 9457 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9457 2 have have VBP 40436 9457 3 already already RB 40436 9457 4 cited cite VBN 40436 9457 5 this this DT 40436 9457 6 last last JJ 40436 9457 7 passage passage NN 40436 9457 8 , , , 40436 9457 9 and and CC 40436 9457 10 commented comment VBN 40436 9457 11 upon upon IN 40436 9457 12 the the DT 40436 9457 13 same same JJ 40436 9457 14 point point NN 40436 9457 15 , , , 40436 9457 16 in in IN 40436 9457 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9457 18 notes note NNS 40436 9457 19 at at IN 40436 9457 20 the the DT 40436 9457 21 end end NN 40436 9457 22 of of IN 40436 9457 23 the the DT 40436 9457 24 Euthydêmus Euthydêmus NNP 40436 9457 25 , , , 40436 9457 26 p. p. NN 40436 9458 1 230 230 CD 40436 9458 2 . . . 40436 9458 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9459 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9459 2 Side side NN 40436 9459 3 - - HYPH 40436 9459 4 note note NN 40436 9459 5 : : : 40436 9459 6 Position position NN 40436 9459 7 of of IN 40436 9459 8 one one NN 40436 9459 9 who who WP 40436 9459 10 dissents dissent VBZ 40436 9459 11 , , , 40436 9459 12 upon upon IN 40436 9459 13 material material JJ 40436 9459 14 points point NNS 40436 9459 15 , , , 40436 9459 16 from from IN 40436 9459 17 the the DT 40436 9459 18 fixed fix VBN 40436 9459 19 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9459 20 and and CC 40436 9459 21 creed creed NN 40436 9459 22 of of IN 40436 9459 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9459 24 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 9459 25 . . . 40436 9459 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9460 1 That that IN 40436 9460 2 in in IN 40436 9460 3 order order NN 40436 9460 4 to to TO 40436 9460 5 succeed succeed VB 40436 9460 6 politically politically RB 40436 9460 7 , , , 40436 9460 8 a a DT 40436 9460 9 man man NN 40436 9460 10 must must MD 40436 9460 11 be be VB 40436 9460 12 a a DT 40436 9460 13 genuine genuine JJ 40436 9460 14 believer believer NN 40436 9460 15 in in IN 40436 9460 16 the the DT 40436 9460 17 creed creed NN 40436 9460 18 of of IN 40436 9460 19 King King NNP 40436 9460 20 Nomos Nomos NNP 40436 9460 21 or or CC 40436 9460 22 the the DT 40436 9460 23 ruling rule VBG 40436 9460 24 force force NN 40436 9460 25 -- -- : 40436 9460 26 cast cast VBN 40436 9460 27 in in IN 40436 9460 28 the the DT 40436 9460 29 same same JJ 40436 9460 30 spiritual spiritual JJ 40436 9460 31 mould--(I mould--(I NNP 40436 9460 32 here here RB 40436 9460 33 take take VBP 40436 9460 34 the the DT 40436 9460 35 word word NN 40436 9460 36 _ _ NNP 40436 9460 37 creed creed NN 40436 9460 38 _ _ NNP 40436 9460 39 not not RB 40436 9460 40 as as IN 40436 9460 41 confined confine VBN 40436 9460 42 to to IN 40436 9460 43 religion religion NN 40436 9460 44 , , , 40436 9460 45 but but CC 40436 9460 46 as as IN 40436 9460 47 embracing embrace VBG 40436 9460 48 the the DT 40436 9460 49 whole whole NN 40436 9460 50 of of IN 40436 9460 51 a a DT 40436 9460 52 man man NN 40436 9460 53 's 's POS 40436 9460 54 critical critical JJ 40436 9460 55 _ _ NNP 40436 9460 56 idéal idéal NNP 40436 9460 57 _ _ NNP 40436 9460 58 , , , 40436 9460 59 on on IN 40436 9460 60 moral moral JJ 40436 9460 61 or or CC 40436 9460 62 social social JJ 40436 9460 63 practice practice NN 40436 9460 64 , , , 40436 9460 65 politics politic NNS 40436 9460 66 , , , 40436 9460 67 or or CC 40436 9460 68 taste taste NN 40436 9460 69 -- -- : 40436 9460 70 the the DT 40436 9460 71 ends end NNS 40436 9460 72 which which WDT 40436 9460 73 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9460 74 deems deem VBZ 40436 9460 75 worthy worthy JJ 40436 9460 76 of of IN 40436 9460 77 being be VBG 40436 9460 78 aspired aspire VBN 40436 9460 79 to to IN 40436 9460 80 , , , 40436 9460 81 or or CC 40436 9460 82 proper proper JJ 40436 9460 83 to to TO 40436 9460 84 be be VB 40436 9460 85 shunned shun VBN 40436 9460 86 , , , 40436 9460 87 by by IN 40436 9460 88 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9460 89 or or CC 40436 9460 90 others other NNS 40436 9460 91 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9460 92 is be VBZ 40436 9460 93 laid lay VBN 40436 9460 94 down down RP 40436 9460 95 by by IN 40436 9460 96 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9460 97 as as IN 40436 9460 98 a a DT 40436 9460 99 general general JJ 40436 9460 100 position position NN 40436 9460 101 : : : 40436 9460 102 and and CC 40436 9460 103 with with IN 40436 9460 104 perfect perfect JJ 40436 9460 105 truth truth NN 40436 9460 106 . . . 40436 9461 1 In in IN 40436 9461 2 disposing dispose VBG 40436 9461 3 of of IN 40436 9461 4 the the DT 40436 9461 5 force force NN 40436 9461 6 or or CC 40436 9461 7 influence influence NN 40436 9461 8 of of IN 40436 9461 9 government government NN 40436 9461 10 , , , 40436 9461 11 whoever whoever WP 40436 9461 12 possesses possess VBZ 40436 9461 13 that that DT 40436 9461 14 force force NN 40436 9461 15 will will MD 40436 9461 16 use use VB 40436 9461 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9461 18 conformably conformably RB 40436 9461 19 to to IN 40436 9461 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9461 21 own own JJ 40436 9461 22 maxims maxim NNS 40436 9461 23 . . . 40436 9462 1 A a DT 40436 9462 2 man man NN 40436 9462 3 who who WP 40436 9462 4 dissents dissent VBZ 40436 9462 5 from from IN 40436 9462 6 these these DT 40436 9462 7 maxims maxim NNS 40436 9462 8 will will MD 40436 9462 9 find find VB 40436 9462 10 no no DT 40436 9462 11 favour favour NN 40436 9462 12 in in IN 40436 9462 13 the the DT 40436 9462 14 public public JJ 40436 9462 15 assembly assembly NN 40436 9462 16 ; ; : 40436 9462 17 nor nor CC 40436 9462 18 , , , 40436 9462 19 probably probably RB 40436 9462 20 , , , 40436 9462 21 if if IN 40436 9462 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9462 23 dissent dissent NN 40436 9462 24 be be VB 40436 9462 25 grave grave JJ 40436 9462 26 and and CC 40436 9462 27 wide wide RB 40436 9462 28 , , , 40436 9462 29 will will MD 40436 9462 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9462 31 ever ever RB 40436 9462 32 be be VB 40436 9462 33 able able JJ 40436 9462 34 to to TO 40436 9462 35 speak speak VB 40436 9462 36 out out RP 40436 9462 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9462 38 convictions conviction NNS 40436 9462 39 aloud aloud RB 40436 9462 40 in in IN 40436 9462 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9462 42 , , , 40436 9462 43 without without IN 40436 9462 44 incurring incur VBG 40436 9462 45 dangerous dangerous JJ 40436 9462 46 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 9462 47 . . . 40436 9463 1 But but CC 40436 9463 2 what what WP 40436 9463 3 is be VBZ 40436 9463 4 to to TO 40436 9463 5 become become VB 40436 9463 6 of of IN 40436 9463 7 such such PDT 40436 9463 8 a a DT 40436 9463 9 dissenter[122]--the dissenter[122]--the JJ 40436 9463 10 man man NN 40436 9463 11 who who WP 40436 9463 12 frequents frequent VBZ 40436 9463 13 the the DT 40436 9463 14 same same JJ 40436 9463 15 porticos porticos NN 40436 9463 16 with with IN 40436 9463 17 the the DT 40436 9463 18 people people NNS 40436 9463 19 , , , 40436 9463 20 but but CC 40436 9463 21 does do VBZ 40436 9463 22 not not RB 40436 9463 23 hold hold VB 40436 9463 24 the the DT 40436 9463 25 same same JJ 40436 9463 26 creed creed NN 40436 9463 27 , , , 40436 9463 28 nor nor CC 40436 9463 29 share share VB 40436 9463 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9463 31 judgments judgment NNS 40436 9463 32 respecting respect VBG 40436 9463 33 social social NNP 40436 9463 34 _ _ NNP 40436 9463 35 expetenda expetenda NNP 40436 9463 36 _ _ NNP 40436 9463 37 and and CC 40436 9463 38 _ _ NNP 40436 9463 39 fugienda fugienda NN 40436 9463 40 _ _ NNP 40436 9463 41 ? ? . 40436 9464 1 How how WRB 40436 9464 2 is be VBZ 40436 9464 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9464 4 to to TO 40436 9464 5 be be VB 40436 9464 6 treated treat VBN 40436 9464 7 by by IN 40436 9464 8 the the DT 40436 9464 9 government government NN 40436 9464 10 , , , 40436 9464 11 or or CC 40436 9464 12 by by IN 40436 9464 13 the the DT 40436 9464 14 orthodox orthodox JJ 40436 9464 15 majority majority NN 40436 9464 16 of of IN 40436 9464 17 society society NN 40436 9464 18 in in IN 40436 9464 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9464 20 individual individual JJ 40436 9464 21 capacity capacity NN 40436 9464 22 ? ? . 40436 9465 1 Debarred debar VBN 40436 9465 2 , , , 40436 9465 3 by by IN 40436 9465 4 the the DT 40436 9465 5 necessity necessity NN 40436 9465 6 of of IN 40436 9465 7 the the DT 40436 9465 8 case case NN 40436 9465 9 , , , 40436 9465 10 from from IN 40436 9465 11 influence influence NN 40436 9465 12 over over IN 40436 9465 13 the the DT 40436 9465 14 public public JJ 40436 9465 15 councils council NNS 40436 9465 16 -- -- : 40436 9465 17 what what WDT 40436 9465 18 latitude latitude NN 40436 9465 19 of of IN 40436 9465 20 pursuit pursuit NN 40436 9465 21 , , , 40436 9465 22 profession profession NN 40436 9465 23 , , , 40436 9465 24 or or CC 40436 9465 25 conduct conduct NN 40436 9465 26 , , , 40436 9465 27 is be VBZ 40436 9465 28 to to TO 40436 9465 29 be be VB 40436 9465 30 left leave VBN 40436 9465 31 to to IN 40436 9465 32 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9465 33 as as IN 40436 9465 34 a a DT 40436 9465 35 citizen citizen NN 40436 9465 36 ? ? . 40436 9466 1 How how WRB 40436 9466 2 far far RB 40436 9466 3 is be VBZ 40436 9466 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9466 5 to to TO 40436 9466 6 question question VB 40436 9466 7 , , , 40436 9466 8 or or CC 40436 9466 9 expose expose VB 40436 9466 10 , , , 40436 9466 11 or or CC 40436 9466 12 require require VB 40436 9466 13 to to TO 40436 9466 14 be be VB 40436 9466 15 proved prove VBN 40436 9466 16 , , , 40436 9466 17 that that IN 40436 9466 18 which which WDT 40436 9466 19 the the DT 40436 9466 20 majority majority NN 40436 9466 21 believe believe VBP 40436 9466 22 without without IN 40436 9466 23 proof proof NN 40436 9466 24 ? ? . 40436 9467 1 Shall Shall MD 40436 9467 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9467 3 be be VB 40436 9467 4 required require VBN 40436 9467 5 to to IN 40436 9467 6 profess profess JJ 40436 9467 7 , , , 40436 9467 8 or or CC 40436 9467 9 to to TO 40436 9467 10 obey obey VB 40436 9467 11 , , , 40436 9467 12 or or CC 40436 9467 13 to to TO 40436 9467 14 refrain refrain VB 40436 9467 15 from from IN 40436 9467 16 contradicting contradicting JJ 40436 9467 17 , , , 40436 9467 18 religious religious JJ 40436 9467 19 or or CC 40436 9467 20 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9467 21 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 9467 22 which which WDT 40436 9467 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9467 24 has have VBZ 40436 9467 25 examined examine VBN 40436 9467 26 and and CC 40436 9467 27 rejected reject VBN 40436 9467 28 ? ? . 40436 9468 1 Shall shall VB 40436 9468 2 such such JJ 40436 9468 3 requirement requirement NN 40436 9468 4 be be VB 40436 9468 5 enforced enforce VBN 40436 9468 6 by by IN 40436 9468 7 threat threat NN 40436 9468 8 of of IN 40436 9468 9 legal legal JJ 40436 9468 10 penalties penalty NNS 40436 9468 11 , , , 40436 9468 12 or or CC 40436 9468 13 of of IN 40436 9468 14 ill ill JJ 40436 9468 15 - - HYPH 40436 9468 16 treatment treatment NN 40436 9468 17 from from IN 40436 9468 18 individuals individual NNS 40436 9468 19 , , , 40436 9468 20 which which WDT 40436 9468 21 is be VBZ 40436 9468 22 not not RB 40436 9468 23 less less RBR 40436 9468 24 intolerable intolerable JJ 40436 9468 25 than than IN 40436 9468 26 legal legal JJ 40436 9468 27 penalties penalty NNS 40436 9468 28 ? ? . 40436 9469 1 What what WP 40436 9469 2 is be VBZ 40436 9469 3 likely likely JJ 40436 9469 4 to to TO 40436 9469 5 be be VB 40436 9469 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9469 7 character character NN 40436 9469 8 , , , 40436 9469 9 if if IN 40436 9469 10 compelled compel VBN 40436 9469 11 to to TO 40436 9469 12 suppress suppress VB 40436 9469 13 all all DT 40436 9469 14 declaration declaration NN 40436 9469 15 of of IN 40436 9469 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9469 17 own own JJ 40436 9469 18 creed creed NN 40436 9469 19 , , , 40436 9469 20 and and CC 40436 9469 21 to to TO 40436 9469 22 act act VB 40436 9469 23 and and CC 40436 9469 24 speak speak VB 40436 9469 25 as as IN 40436 9469 26 if if IN 40436 9469 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9469 28 were be VBD 40436 9469 29 believer believer NN 40436 9469 30 in in IN 40436 9469 31 another another DT 40436 9469 32 ? ? . 40436 9470 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9470 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9470 3 122 122 CD 40436 9470 4 : : : 40436 9470 5 Horat Horat NNP 40436 9470 6 . . . 40436 9471 1 Epist epist UH 40436 9471 2 . . . 40436 9472 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9473 1 1 1 CD 40436 9473 2 , , , 40436 9473 3 70 70 CD 40436 9473 4 - - HYPH 40436 9473 5 - - : 40436 9473 6 " " `` 40436 9473 7 Quod quod NN 40436 9473 8 si si VBP 40436 9473 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9473 10 populus populus JJ 40436 9473 11 Romanus Romanus NNP 40436 9473 12 forté forté NN 40436 9473 13 roget roget NN 40436 9473 14 , , , 40436 9473 15 cur cur NNP 40436 9473 16 Non Non NNP 40436 9473 17 ut ut UH 40436 9473 18 porticibus porticibus NNP 40436 9473 19 , , , 40436 9473 20 sic sic NNP 40436 9473 21 judiciis judiciis NNP 40436 9473 22 fruar fruar NNP 40436 9473 23 iisdem iisdem NNP 40436 9473 24 , , , 40436 9473 25 Nec Nec NNP 40436 9473 26 sequar sequar NN 40436 9473 27 aut aut NNP 40436 9473 28 fugiam fugiam NNP 40436 9473 29 quæ quæ NNP 40436 9473 30 diligit diligit NNP 40436 9473 31 ipse ipse NNP 40436 9473 32 vel vel NNP 40436 9473 33 odit odit NN 40436 9473 34 : : : 40436 9473 35 Olim Olim NNP 40436 9473 36 quod quod NN 40436 9473 37 vulpes vulpe NNS 40436 9473 38 ægroto ægroto RB 40436 9473 39 cauta cauta VBP 40436 9473 40 leoni leoni NNP 40436 9473 41 Respondit Respondit NNP 40436 9473 42 , , , 40436 9473 43 referam referam NN 40436 9473 44 : : : 40436 9473 45 Quia quia VB 40436 9473 46 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9473 47 vestigia vestigia NN 40436 9473 48 terrent terrent JJ 40436 9473 49 Omnia Omnia NNP 40436 9473 50 te te NNP 40436 9473 51 adversum adversum NN 40436 9473 52 spectantia spectantia NNP 40436 9473 53 , , , 40436 9473 54 nulla nulla NNP 40436 9473 55 retrorsum retrorsum NNP 40436 9473 56 . . . 40436 9473 57 " " '' 40436 9473 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9474 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9474 2 Side side NN 40436 9474 3 - - HYPH 40436 9474 4 note note NN 40436 9474 5 : : : 40436 9474 6 Probable probable JJ 40436 9474 7 feelings feeling NNS 40436 9474 8 of of IN 40436 9474 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9474 10 on on IN 40436 9474 11 this this DT 40436 9474 12 subject subject NN 40436 9474 13 . . . 40436 9475 1 Claim claim NN 40436 9475 2 put put VBN 40436 9475 3 forward forward RB 40436 9475 4 in in IN 40436 9475 5 the the DT 40436 9475 6 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9475 7 of of IN 40436 9475 8 an an DT 40436 9475 9 independent independent JJ 40436 9475 10 _ _ NNP 40436 9475 11 locus locus NN 40436 9475 12 standi standi NN 40436 9475 13 _ _ NNP 40436 9475 14 for for IN 40436 9475 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9475 16 , , , 40436 9475 17 but but CC 40436 9475 18 without without IN 40436 9475 19 the the DT 40436 9475 20 indiscriminate indiscriminate NNP 40436 9475 21 cross cross NN 40436 9475 22 - - NN 40436 9475 23 examination examination NN 40436 9475 24 pursued pursue VBN 40436 9475 25 by by IN 40436 9475 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9475 27 . . . 40436 9475 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9476 1 The the DT 40436 9476 2 questions question NNS 40436 9476 3 here here RB 40436 9476 4 suggested suggest VBD 40436 9476 5 must must MD 40436 9476 6 have have VB 40436 9476 7 impressed impress VBN 40436 9476 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9476 9 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 9476 10 on on IN 40436 9476 11 the the DT 40436 9476 12 mind mind NN 40436 9476 13 of of IN 40436 9476 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9476 15 when when WRB 40436 9476 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9476 17 recollected recollect VBD 40436 9476 18 the the DT 40436 9476 19 fate fate NN 40436 9476 20 of of IN 40436 9476 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9476 22 . . . 40436 9477 1 In in IN 40436 9477 2 spite spite NN 40436 9477 3 of of IN 40436 9477 4 a a DT 40436 9477 5 blameless blameless JJ 40436 9477 6 life life NN 40436 9477 7 , , , 40436 9477 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9477 9 had have VBD 40436 9477 10 been be VBN 40436 9477 11 judicially judicially RB 40436 9477 12 condemned condemn VBN 40436 9477 13 and and CC 40436 9477 14 executed execute VBN 40436 9477 15 for for IN 40436 9477 16 publicly publicly RB 40436 9477 17 questioning question VBG 40436 9477 18 received receive VBN 40436 9477 19 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9477 20 , , , 40436 9477 21 innovating innovate VBG 40436 9477 22 upon upon IN 40436 9477 23 the the DT 40436 9477 24 established established JJ 40436 9477 25 religion religion NN 40436 9477 26 , , , 40436 9477 27 and and CC 40436 9477 28 instilling instill VBG 40436 9477 29 into into IN 40436 9477 30 young young JJ 40436 9477 31 persons person NNS 40436 9477 32 habits habit NNS 40436 9477 33 of of IN 40436 9477 34 doubt doubt NN 40436 9477 35 . . . 40436 9478 1 To to IN 40436 9478 2 dissent dissent NN 40436 9478 3 only only RB 40436 9478 4 for for IN 40436 9478 5 the the DT 40436 9478 6 better well JJR 40436 9478 7 , , , 40436 9478 8 afforded afford VBD 40436 9478 9 no no DT 40436 9478 10 assurance assurance NN 40436 9478 11 of of IN 40436 9478 12 safety safety NN 40436 9478 13 : : : 40436 9478 14 and and CC 40436 9478 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9478 16 knew know VBD 40436 9478 17 well well RB 40436 9478 18 that that IN 40436 9478 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9478 20 own own JJ 40436 9478 21 dissent dissent NN 40436 9478 22 from from IN 40436 9478 23 the the DT 40436 9478 24 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9478 25 public public NN 40436 9478 26 was be VBD 40436 9478 27 even even RB 40436 9478 28 wider wide JJR 40436 9478 29 and and CC 40436 9478 30 more more RBR 40436 9478 31 systematic systematic JJ 40436 9478 32 than than IN 40436 9478 33 that that DT 40436 9478 34 of of IN 40436 9478 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9478 36 master master NN 40436 9478 37 . . . 40436 9479 1 The the DT 40436 9479 2 position position NN 40436 9479 3 and and CC 40436 9479 4 plan plan NN 40436 9479 5 of of IN 40436 9479 6 life life NN 40436 9479 7 for for IN 40436 9479 8 an an DT 40436 9479 9 active active JJ 40436 9479 10 - - HYPH 40436 9479 11 minded minded JJ 40436 9479 12 reasoner reasoner NN 40436 9479 13 , , , 40436 9479 14 dissenting dissent VBG 40436 9479 15 from from IN 40436 9479 16 the the DT 40436 9479 17 established established JJ 40436 9479 18 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9479 19 of of IN 40436 9479 20 the the DT 40436 9479 21 public public NN 40436 9479 22 , , , 40436 9479 23 could could MD 40436 9479 24 not not RB 40436 9479 25 but but CC 40436 9479 26 be be VB 40436 9479 27 an an DT 40436 9479 28 object object NN 40436 9479 29 of of IN 40436 9479 30 interesting interesting JJ 40436 9479 31 reflection reflection NN 40436 9479 32 to to IN 40436 9479 33 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9479 34 . . . 40436 9480 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9480 2 123 123 CD 40436 9480 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9480 4 The the DT 40436 9480 5 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9480 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9480 7 written write VBN 40436 9480 8 , , , 40436 9480 9 in in IN 40436 9480 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9480 11 judgment judgment NN 40436 9480 12 , , , 40436 9480 13 long long RB 40436 9480 14 after after IN 40436 9480 15 the the DT 40436 9480 16 death death NN 40436 9480 17 of of IN 40436 9480 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9480 19 , , , 40436 9480 20 probably probably RB 40436 9480 21 after after IN 40436 9480 22 the the DT 40436 9480 23 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9480 24 school school NN 40436 9480 25 was be VBD 40436 9480 26 established establish VBN 40436 9480 27 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9480 28 announces announce VBZ 40436 9480 29 the the DT 40436 9480 30 vocation vocation NN 40436 9480 31 of of IN 40436 9480 32 the the DT 40436 9480 33 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9480 34 , , , 40436 9480 35 and and CC 40436 9480 36 claims claim VBZ 40436 9480 37 an an DT 40436 9480 38 open open JJ 40436 9480 39 field field NN 40436 9480 40 for for IN 40436 9480 41 speculation speculation NN 40436 9480 42 , , , 40436 9480 43 apart apart RB 40436 9480 44 from from IN 40436 9480 45 the the DT 40436 9480 46 actualities actuality NNS 40436 9480 47 of of IN 40436 9480 48 politics politic NNS 40436 9480 49 -- -- : 40436 9480 50 for for IN 40436 9480 51 the the DT 40436 9480 52 self self NN 40436 9480 53 - - HYPH 40436 9480 54 acting act VBG 40436 9480 55 reason reason NN 40436 9480 56 of of IN 40436 9480 57 the the DT 40436 9480 58 individual individual JJ 40436 9480 59 doubter doubter NN 40436 9480 60 and and CC 40436 9480 61 investigator investigator NN 40436 9480 62 , , , 40436 9480 63 against against IN 40436 9480 64 the the DT 40436 9480 65 authority authority NN 40436 9480 66 of of IN 40436 9480 67 numbers number NNS 40436 9480 68 and and CC 40436 9480 69 the the DT 40436 9480 70 pressure pressure NN 40436 9480 71 of of IN 40436 9480 72 inherited inherit VBN 40436 9480 73 tradition tradition NN 40436 9480 74 . . . 40436 9481 1 A a DT 40436 9481 2 formal formal JJ 40436 9481 3 assertion assertion NN 40436 9481 4 to to IN 40436 9481 5 this this DT 40436 9481 6 effect effect NN 40436 9481 7 was be VBD 40436 9481 8 worthy worthy JJ 40436 9481 9 of of IN 40436 9481 10 the the DT 40436 9481 11 founder founder NN 40436 9481 12 of of IN 40436 9481 13 the the DT 40436 9481 14 Academy Academy NNP 40436 9481 15 -- -- : 40436 9481 16 the the DT 40436 9481 17 earliest early JJS 40436 9481 18 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 9481 19 school school NN 40436 9481 20 at at IN 40436 9481 21 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9481 22 . . . 40436 9482 1 Yet yet CC 40436 9482 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9482 3 may may MD 40436 9482 4 observe observe VB 40436 9482 5 that that IN 40436 9482 6 while while IN 40436 9482 7 the the DT 40436 9482 8 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9482 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9482 10 in in IN 40436 9482 11 the the DT 40436 9482 12 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9482 13 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 9482 14 the the DT 40436 9482 15 life life NN 40436 9482 16 of of IN 40436 9482 17 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9482 18 , , , 40436 9482 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9482 20 does do VBZ 40436 9482 21 not not RB 40436 9482 22 renew renew VB 40436 9482 23 that that IN 40436 9482 24 farther farther JJ 40436 9482 25 demand demand NN 40436 9482 26 with with IN 40436 9482 27 which which WDT 40436 9482 28 the the DT 40436 9482 29 historical historical JJ 40436 9482 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9482 31 had have VBD 40436 9482 32 coupled couple VBN 40436 9482 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9482 34 in in IN 40436 9482 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9482 36 Apology Apology NNP 40436 9482 37 -- -- : 40436 9482 38 the the DT 40436 9482 39 liberty liberty NN 40436 9482 40 of of IN 40436 9482 41 oral oral JJ 40436 9482 42 and and CC 40436 9482 43 aggressive aggressive JJ 40436 9482 44 cross cross NN 40436 9482 45 - - NN 40436 9482 46 examination examination NN 40436 9482 47 , , , 40436 9482 48 addressed address VBN 40436 9482 49 to to IN 40436 9482 50 individuals individual NNS 40436 9482 51 personally personally RB 40436 9482 52 and and CC 40436 9482 53 indiscriminately[124]--to indiscriminately[124]--to VB 40436 9482 54 the the DT 40436 9482 55 _ _ NNP 40436 9482 56 primores primore NNS 40436 9482 57 populi populi NNP 40436 9482 58 _ _ NNP 40436 9482 59 as as RB 40436 9482 60 well well RB 40436 9482 61 as as IN 40436 9482 62 to to IN 40436 9482 63 the the DT 40436 9482 64 _ _ NNP 40436 9482 65 populum populum NN 40436 9482 66 tributim tributim NNP 40436 9482 67 _ _ NNP 40436 9482 68 . . . 40436 9483 1 The the DT 40436 9483 2 fate fate NN 40436 9483 3 of of IN 40436 9483 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9483 5 rendered render VBN 40436 9483 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9483 7 more more RBR 40436 9483 8 cautious cautious JJ 40436 9483 9 , , , 40436 9483 10 and and CC 40436 9483 11 induced induce VBD 40436 9483 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9483 13 to to TO 40436 9483 14 utter utter VB 40436 9483 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9483 16 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9483 17 interrogations interrogation NNS 40436 9483 18 and and CC 40436 9483 19 novelties novelty NNS 40436 9483 20 of of IN 40436 9483 21 opinion opinion NN 40436 9483 22 in in IN 40436 9483 23 no no DT 40436 9483 24 other other JJ 40436 9483 25 way way NN 40436 9483 26 except except IN 40436 9483 27 that that DT 40436 9483 28 of of IN 40436 9483 29 lectures lecture NNS 40436 9483 30 to to IN 40436 9483 31 chosen chosen VB 40436 9483 32 hearers hearer NNS 40436 9483 33 and and CC 40436 9483 34 written write VBN 40436 9483 35 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9483 36 : : : 40436 9483 37 borrowing borrow VBG 40436 9483 38 the the DT 40436 9483 39 name name NN 40436 9483 40 of of IN 40436 9483 41 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9483 42 or or CC 40436 9483 43 some some DT 40436 9483 44 other other JJ 40436 9483 45 speaker speaker NN 40436 9483 46 , , , 40436 9483 47 and and CC 40436 9483 48 refraining refrain VBG 40436 9483 49 upon upon IN 40436 9483 50 system system NN 40436 9483 51 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9483 52 as as IN 40436 9483 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9483 54 letters[125 letters[125 NN 40436 9483 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9483 56 tell tell VB 40436 9483 57 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9483 58 that that IN 40436 9483 59 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9483 60 did do VBD 40436 9483 61 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9483 62 from from IN 40436 9483 63 publishing publish VBG 40436 9483 64 any any DT 40436 9483 65 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 9483 66 in in IN 40436 9483 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9483 68 own own JJ 40436 9483 69 name name NN 40436 9483 70 . . . 40436 9484 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9484 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9484 3 123 123 CD 40436 9484 4 : : : 40436 9484 5 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9484 6 have have VBP 40436 9484 7 already already RB 40436 9484 8 referred refer VBN 40436 9484 9 to to IN 40436 9484 10 the the DT 40436 9484 11 treatise treatise NN 40436 9484 12 of of IN 40436 9484 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 9484 14 John John NNP 40436 9484 15 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 9484 16 Mill Mill NNP 40436 9484 17 " " '' 40436 9484 18 On on IN 40436 9484 19 Liberty Liberty NNP 40436 9484 20 , , , 40436 9484 21 " " '' 40436 9484 22 where where WRB 40436 9484 23 this this DT 40436 9484 24 important important JJ 40436 9484 25 topic topic NN 40436 9484 26 is be VBZ 40436 9484 27 discussed discuss VBN 40436 9484 28 in in IN 40436 9484 29 a a DT 40436 9484 30 manner manner NN 40436 9484 31 equally equally RB 40436 9484 32 profound profound JJ 40436 9484 33 and and CC 40436 9484 34 enlightened enlighten VBN 40436 9484 35 . . . 40436 9485 1 The the DT 40436 9485 2 co co NN 40436 9485 3 - - NN 40436 9485 4 existence existence NN 40436 9485 5 of of IN 40436 9485 6 individual individual JJ 40436 9485 7 reasoners reasoner NNS 40436 9485 8 enquiring enquire VBG 40436 9485 9 and and CC 40436 9485 10 philosophising philosophise VBG 40436 9485 11 for for IN 40436 9485 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9485 13 , , , 40436 9485 14 with with IN 40436 9485 15 the the DT 40436 9485 16 fixed fix VBN 40436 9485 17 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9485 18 of of IN 40436 9485 19 the the DT 40436 9485 20 majority majority NN 40436 9485 21 , , , 40436 9485 22 is be VBZ 40436 9485 23 one one CD 40436 9485 24 of of IN 40436 9485 25 the the DT 40436 9485 26 main main JJ 40436 9485 27 conditions condition NNS 40436 9485 28 which which WDT 40436 9485 29 distinguish distinguish VBP 40436 9485 30 a a DT 40436 9485 31 progressive progressive NN 40436 9485 32 from from IN 40436 9485 33 a a DT 40436 9485 34 stationary stationary JJ 40436 9485 35 community community NN 40436 9485 36 . . . 40436 9485 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9486 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9486 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9486 3 124 124 CD 40436 9486 4 : : : 40436 9486 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 9486 6 . . . 40436 9487 1 Apol Apol NNP 40436 9487 2 . . . 40436 9488 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 9488 2 . . . 40436 9489 1 pp pp NNP 40436 9489 2 . . . 40436 9490 1 21 21 CD 40436 9490 2 - - HYPH 40436 9490 3 22 22 CD 40436 9490 4 - - HYPH 40436 9490 5 23 23 CD 40436 9490 6 - - HYPH 40436 9490 7 28 28 CD 40436 9490 8 E. E. NNP 40436 9490 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9490 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9490 11 : : : 40436 9490 12 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9490 13 de\ de\ NN 40436 9490 14 theou= theou= NN 40436 9490 15 ta ta NNP 40436 9490 16 / / SYM 40436 9490 17 ttontos ttonto NNS 40436 9490 18 , , , 40436 9490 19 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 9490 20 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 9490 21 ô)|ê ô)|ê NNP 40436 9490 22 / / SYM 40436 9490 23 thên thên NNP 40436 9490 24 te te NNP 40436 9490 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9490 26 u(pe u(pe NNP 40436 9490 27 / / SYM 40436 9490 28 labon labon NNP 40436 9490 29 , , , 40436 9490 30 philophou philophou NNP 40436 9490 31 = = SYM 40436 9490 32 nta nta NNP 40436 9490 33 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9490 34 dei dei NNP 40436 9490 35 = = SYM 40436 9490 36 n n NNP 40436 9490 37 zê=|n zê=|n CD 40436 9490 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9490 39 _ _ NNP 40436 9490 40 e)xeta e)xeta NNP 40436 9490 41 / / SYM 40436 9490 42 zonta zonta NNP 40436 9490 43 e)mauto e)mauto CD 40436 9490 44 / / SYM 40436 9490 45 n n NN 40436 9490 46 te te NNP 40436 9490 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9490 48 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 9490 49 a)/llous a)/llous JJ 40436 9490 50 _ _ NNP 40436 9490 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9490 52 , , , 40436 9490 53 & & CC 40436 9490 54 c. c. NNP 40436 9490 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9490 56 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9490 57 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9490 58 125 125 CD 40436 9490 59 : : : 40436 9490 60 Plat Plat NNP 40436 9490 61 . . . 40436 9491 1 Epist epist UH 40436 9491 2 . . . 40436 9492 1 ii ii LS 40436 9492 2 . . . 40436 9493 1 314 314 CD 40436 9493 2 B. B. NNP 40436 9493 3 K. K. NNP 40436 9493 4 F. F. NNP 40436 9493 5 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 9493 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9493 7 Ueber Ueber NNP 40436 9493 8 Platon Platon NNP 40436 9493 9 's 's POS 40436 9493 10 Schriftstellerische Schriftstellerische NNP 40436 9493 11 Motive Motive NNP 40436 9493 12 , , , 40436 9493 13 p. p. NN 40436 9493 14 290 290 CD 40436 9493 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9493 16 treats treat VBZ 40436 9493 17 any any DT 40436 9493 18 such such JJ 40436 9493 19 prudential prudential JJ 40436 9493 20 discretion discretion NN 40436 9493 21 , , , 40436 9493 22 in in IN 40436 9493 23 respect respect NN 40436 9493 24 to to IN 40436 9493 25 the the DT 40436 9493 26 form form NN 40436 9493 27 and and CC 40436 9493 28 mode mode NN 40436 9493 29 of of IN 40436 9493 30 putting put VBG 40436 9493 31 forward forward RB 40436 9493 32 unpopular unpopular JJ 40436 9493 33 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9493 34 , , , 40436 9493 35 as as IN 40436 9493 36 unworthy unworthy JJ 40436 9493 37 of of IN 40436 9493 38 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9493 39 , , , 40436 9493 40 and and CC 40436 9493 41 worthy worthy JJ 40436 9493 42 only only RB 40436 9493 43 of of IN 40436 9493 44 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9493 45 and and CC 40436 9493 46 other other JJ 40436 9493 47 Sophists sophist NNS 40436 9493 48 . . . 40436 9494 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9494 2 dissent dissent VBP 40436 9494 3 from from IN 40436 9494 4 this this DT 40436 9494 5 opinion opinion NN 40436 9494 6 altogether altogether RB 40436 9494 7 . . . 40436 9495 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9495 2 know know VBP 40436 9495 3 that that IN 40436 9495 4 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9495 5 was be VBD 40436 9495 6 very very RB 40436 9495 7 circumspect circumspect JJ 40436 9495 8 as as IN 40436 9495 9 to to TO 40436 9495 10 form form VB 40436 9495 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9495 12 Timon Timon NNP 40436 9495 13 ap ap NNP 40436 9495 14 . . . 40436 9496 1 Sext sext JJ 40436 9496 2 . . . 40436 9497 1 Emp Emp NNP 40436 9497 2 . . . 40436 9498 1 adv adv NNP 40436 9498 2 . . . 40436 9499 1 Mathemat mathemat NN 40436 9499 2 . . . 40436 9500 1 ix ix IN 40436 9500 2 . . . 40436 9501 1 s. s. NNP 40436 9501 2 57 57 CD 40436 9501 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9501 4 ; ; : 40436 9501 5 but but CC 40436 9501 6 the the DT 40436 9501 7 passage passage NN 40436 9501 8 of of IN 40436 9501 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9501 10 cited cite VBN 40436 9501 11 by by IN 40436 9501 12 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 9501 13 does do VBZ 40436 9501 14 not not RB 40436 9501 15 prove prove VB 40436 9501 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9501 17 . . . 40436 9501 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9502 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9502 2 Side side NN 40436 9502 3 - - HYPH 40436 9502 4 note note NN 40436 9502 5 : : : 40436 9502 6 Importance importance NN 40436 9502 7 of of IN 40436 9502 8 maintaining maintain VBG 40436 9502 9 the the DT 40436 9502 10 utmost utmost JJ 40436 9502 11 liberty liberty NN 40436 9502 12 of of IN 40436 9502 13 discussion discussion NN 40436 9502 14 . . . 40436 9503 1 Tendency tendency NN 40436 9503 2 of of IN 40436 9503 3 all all DT 40436 9503 4 ruling rule VBG 40436 9503 5 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 40436 9503 6 towards towards IN 40436 9503 7 intolerance intolerance NN 40436 9503 8 . . . 40436 9503 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9504 1 As as IN 40436 9504 2 a a DT 40436 9504 3 man man NN 40436 9504 4 dissenting dissent VBG 40436 9504 5 from from IN 40436 9504 6 received received JJ 40436 9504 7 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9504 8 , , , 40436 9504 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9504 10 had have VBD 40436 9504 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9504 12 path path NN 40436 9504 13 marked mark VBN 40436 9504 14 out out RP 40436 9504 15 in in IN 40436 9504 16 the the DT 40436 9504 17 field field NN 40436 9504 18 of of IN 40436 9504 19 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9504 20 or or CC 40436 9504 21 individual individual JJ 40436 9504 22 speculation speculation NN 40436 9504 23 . . . 40436 9505 1 To to IN 40436 9505 2 such such PDT 40436 9505 3 a a DT 40436 9505 4 mind mind NN 40436 9505 5 as as IN 40436 9505 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9505 7 , , , 40436 9505 8 the the DT 40436 9505 9 fullest full JJS 40436 9505 10 liberty liberty NN 40436 9505 11 ought ought MD 40436 9505 12 to to TO 40436 9505 13 be be VB 40436 9505 14 left leave VBN 40436 9505 15 , , , 40436 9505 16 of of IN 40436 9505 17 professing profess VBG 40436 9505 18 and and CC 40436 9505 19 defending defend VBG 40436 9505 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9505 21 own own JJ 40436 9505 22 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9505 23 , , , 40436 9505 24 as as RB 40436 9505 25 well well RB 40436 9505 26 as as IN 40436 9505 27 of of IN 40436 9505 28 combating combat VBG 40436 9505 29 other other JJ 40436 9505 30 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9505 31 , , , 40436 9505 32 accredited accredit VBD 40436 9505 33 or or CC 40436 9505 34 not not RB 40436 9505 35 , , , 40436 9505 36 which which WDT 40436 9505 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9505 38 may may MD 40436 9505 39 consider consider VB 40436 9505 40 false false JJ 40436 9505 41 or or CC 40436 9505 42 uncertified uncertified JJ 40436 9505 43 . . . 40436 9506 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9506 2 126 126 CD 40436 9506 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9506 4 The the DT 40436 9506 5 public public JJ 40436 9506 6 guidance guidance NN 40436 9506 7 of of IN 40436 9506 8 the the DT 40436 9506 9 state state NN 40436 9506 10 thus thus RB 40436 9506 11 falls fall VBZ 40436 9506 12 to to IN 40436 9506 13 one one CD 40436 9506 14 class class NN 40436 9506 15 of of IN 40436 9506 16 minds mind NNS 40436 9506 17 , , , 40436 9506 18 the the DT 40436 9506 19 activity activity NN 40436 9506 20 of of IN 40436 9506 21 speculative speculative JJ 40436 9506 22 discussion discussion NN 40436 9506 23 to to IN 40436 9506 24 another another DT 40436 9506 25 ; ; : 40436 9506 26 though though IN 40436 9506 27 accident accident NN 40436 9506 28 may may MD 40436 9506 29 produce produce VB 40436 9506 30 , , , 40436 9506 31 here here RB 40436 9506 32 and and CC 40436 9506 33 there there RB 40436 9506 34 , , , 40436 9506 35 a a DT 40436 9506 36 superior superior JJ 40436 9506 37 individual individual NN 40436 9506 38 , , , 40436 9506 39 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 9506 40 or or CC 40436 9506 41 dexterous dexterous JJ 40436 9506 42 enough enough RB 40436 9506 43 to to TO 40436 9506 44 suffice suffice VB 40436 9506 45 for for IN 40436 9506 46 both both DT 40436 9506 47 . . . 40436 9507 1 But but CC 40436 9507 2 the the DT 40436 9507 3 main main JJ 40436 9507 4 desideratum desideratum NN 40436 9507 5 is be VBZ 40436 9507 6 that that IN 40436 9507 7 this this DT 40436 9507 8 freedom freedom NN 40436 9507 9 of of IN 40436 9507 10 discussion discussion NN 40436 9507 11 should should MD 40436 9507 12 exist exist VB 40436 9507 13 : : : 40436 9507 14 that that DT 40436 9507 15 room room NN 40436 9507 16 shall shall MD 40436 9507 17 be be VB 40436 9507 18 made make VBN 40436 9507 19 , , , 40436 9507 20 and and CC 40436 9507 21 encouragement encouragement NN 40436 9507 22 held hold VBN 40436 9507 23 out out RP 40436 9507 24 , , , 40436 9507 25 to to IN 40436 9507 26 the the DT 40436 9507 27 claims claim NNS 40436 9507 28 of of IN 40436 9507 29 individual individual JJ 40436 9507 30 reason reason NN 40436 9507 31 , , , 40436 9507 32 and and CC 40436 9507 33 to to IN 40436 9507 34 the the DT 40436 9507 35 full full JJ 40436 9507 36 publication publication NN 40436 9507 37 of of IN 40436 9507 38 all all DT 40436 9507 39 doubts doubt NNS 40436 9507 40 or or CC 40436 9507 41 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9507 42 , , , 40436 9507 43 be be VB 40436 9507 44 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9507 45 what what WP 40436 9507 46 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9507 47 may may MD 40436 9507 48 : : : 40436 9507 49 that that IN 40436 9507 50 the the DT 40436 9507 51 natural natural JJ 40436 9507 52 tendency tendency NN 40436 9507 53 of of IN 40436 9507 54 all all DT 40436 9507 55 ruling rule VBG 40436 9507 56 force force NN 40436 9507 57 , , , 40436 9507 58 whether whether IN 40436 9507 59 in in IN 40436 9507 60 few few JJ 40436 9507 61 or or CC 40436 9507 62 in in IN 40436 9507 63 many many JJ 40436 9507 64 hands hand NNS 40436 9507 65 , , , 40436 9507 66 to to TO 40436 9507 67 perpetuate perpetuate VB 40436 9507 68 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9507 69 own own JJ 40436 9507 70 dogmas dogma NNS 40436 9507 71 by by IN 40436 9507 72 proscribing proscribe VBG 40436 9507 73 or or CC 40436 9507 74 silencing silence VBG 40436 9507 75 all all DT 40436 9507 76 heretics heretic NNS 40436 9507 77 and and CC 40436 9507 78 questioners questioner NNS 40436 9507 79 , , , 40436 9507 80 may may MD 40436 9507 81 be be VB 40436 9507 82 neutralised neutralise VBN 40436 9507 83 as as RB 40436 9507 84 far far RB 40436 9507 85 as as IN 40436 9507 86 possible possible JJ 40436 9507 87 . . . 40436 9508 1 The the DT 40436 9508 2 great great JJ 40436 9508 3 expansive expansive JJ 40436 9508 4 vigour vigour NN 40436 9508 5 of of IN 40436 9508 6 the the DT 40436 9508 7 Greek greek JJ 40436 9508 8 mind mind NN 40436 9508 9 -- -- : 40436 9508 10 the the DT 40436 9508 11 sympathy sympathy NN 40436 9508 12 felt feel VBD 40436 9508 13 among among IN 40436 9508 14 the the DT 40436 9508 15 best good JJS 40436 9508 16 varieties variety NNS 40436 9508 17 of of IN 40436 9508 18 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 9508 19 for for IN 40436 9508 20 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9508 21 superiority superiority NN 40436 9508 22 in in IN 40436 9508 23 all all DT 40436 9508 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9508 25 forms form NNS 40436 9508 26 -- -- : 40436 9508 27 and and CC 40436 9508 28 the the DT 40436 9508 29 privilege privilege NN 40436 9508 30 of of IN 40436 9508 31 free free JJ 40436 9508 32 speech speech NN 40436 9508 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9508 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9508 35 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9508 36 : : : 40436 9508 37 par)r(êsi par)r(êsi NFP 40436 9508 38 / / SYM 40436 9508 39 a a NN 40436 9508 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9508 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9508 42 , , , 40436 9508 43 on on IN 40436 9508 44 which which WDT 40436 9508 45 the the DT 40436 9508 46 democratical democratical JJ 40436 9508 47 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9508 48 of of IN 40436 9508 49 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9508 50 prided pride VBD 40436 9508 51 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9508 52 -- -- : 40436 9508 53 did do VBD 40436 9508 54 in in IN 40436 9508 55 fact fact NN 40436 9508 56 neutralise neutralise NN 40436 9508 57 very very RB 40436 9508 58 considerably considerably RB 40436 9508 59 these these DT 40436 9508 60 tendencies tendency NNS 40436 9508 61 in in IN 40436 9508 62 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9508 63 . . . 40436 9509 1 A a DT 40436 9509 2 greater great JJR 40436 9509 3 and and CC 40436 9509 4 more more RBR 40436 9509 5 durable durable JJ 40436 9509 6 liberty liberty NN 40436 9509 7 of of IN 40436 9509 8 philosophising philosophising NN 40436 9509 9 was be VBD 40436 9509 10 procured procure VBN 40436 9509 11 for for IN 40436 9509 12 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9509 13 , , , 40436 9509 14 and and CC 40436 9509 15 through through IN 40436 9509 16 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9509 17 for for IN 40436 9509 18 Greece Greece NNP 40436 9509 19 generally generally RB 40436 9509 20 , , , 40436 9509 21 than than IN 40436 9509 22 had have VBD 40436 9509 23 ever ever RB 40436 9509 24 been be VBN 40436 9509 25 known know VBN 40436 9509 26 before before IN 40436 9509 27 in in IN 40436 9509 28 the the DT 40436 9509 29 history history NN 40436 9509 30 of of IN 40436 9509 31 mankind mankind NN 40436 9509 32 . . . 40436 9510 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9510 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9510 3 126 126 CD 40436 9510 4 : : : 40436 9510 5 So so RB 40436 9510 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9510 7 also also RB 40436 9510 8 says say VBZ 40436 9510 9 in in IN 40436 9510 10 the the DT 40436 9510 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9510 12 Apology Apology NNP 40436 9510 13 , , , 40436 9510 14 pp pp NNP 40436 9510 15 . . . 40436 9511 1 31 31 CD 40436 9511 2 - - SYM 40436 9511 3 32 32 CD 40436 9511 4 . . . 40436 9512 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9512 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9512 3 : : : 40436 9512 4 Ou Ou NNP 40436 9512 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9512 6 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9512 7 e)/stin e)/stin NN 40436 9512 8 o(/stis o(/stis NNP 40436 9512 9 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 9512 10 / / SYM 40436 9512 11 pôn pôn NNP 40436 9512 12 sôthê sôthê NNP 40436 9512 13 / / SYM 40436 9512 14 setai setai NNP 40436 9512 15 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 9512 16 u(mi u(mi NNP 40436 9512 17 = = SYM 40436 9512 18 n n CC 40436 9512 19 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 9512 20 a)/llô| a)/llô| IN 40436 9512 21 plê plê NNP 40436 9512 22 / / SYM 40436 9512 23 thei thei NN 40436 9512 24 ou)deni\ ou)deni\ NNP 40436 9512 25 gnêsi gnêsi NNP 40436 9512 26 / / SYM 40436 9512 27 ôs ôs NNP 40436 9512 28 e)nantiou e)nantiou , 40436 9512 29 / / SYM 40436 9512 30 menos menos NNP 40436 9512 31 , , , 40436 9512 32 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9512 33 diakôlu diakôlu NNP 40436 9512 34 / / SYM 40436 9512 35 ôn ôn NNP 40436 9512 36 polla\ polla\ NNP 40436 9512 37 a)/dika a)/dika NNP 40436 9512 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9512 39 para para NNP 40436 9512 40 / / SYM 40436 9512 41 noma noma NNP 40436 9512 42 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9512 43 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 9512 44 po po NNP 40436 9512 45 / / SYM 40436 9512 46 lei lei NNP 40436 9512 47 gi gi NNP 40436 9512 48 / / SYM 40436 9512 49 gnesthai gnesthai NNP 40436 9512 50 ; ; : 40436 9512 51 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9512 52 ' ' POS 40436 9512 53 a)nagkai a)nagkai NNS 40436 9512 54 = = SYM 40436 9512 55 o o NN 40436 9512 56 / / SYM 40436 9512 57 n n NN 40436 9512 58 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 9512 59 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9512 60 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9512 61 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 9512 62 machou machou NNP 40436 9512 63 / / SYM 40436 9512 64 menon menon NNP 40436 9512 65 u(pe\r u(pe\r NNP 40436 9512 66 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9512 67 dikai dikai NNP 40436 9512 68 / / SYM 40436 9512 69 ou ou NNP 40436 9512 70 , , , 40436 9512 71 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9512 72 ei ei NNP 40436 9512 73 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9512 74 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9512 75 / / SYM 40436 9512 76 llei llei NN 40436 9512 77 o)li o)li NNP 40436 9512 78 / / SYM 40436 9512 79 gon gon NNP 40436 9512 80 chro chro NNP 40436 9512 81 / / SYM 40436 9512 82 non non AFX 40436 9512 83 sôthê sôthê NN 40436 9512 84 / / SYM 40436 9512 85 sesthai sesthai NN 40436 9512 86 , , , 40436 9512 87 _ _ NNP 40436 9512 88 i)diôteu i)diôteu , 40436 9512 89 / / SYM 40436 9512 90 ein ein NNP 40436 9512 91 a)lla\ a)lla\ `` 40436 9512 92 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 9512 93 dêmosieu dêmosieu NN 40436 9512 94 / / SYM 40436 9512 95 ein ein NNP 40436 9512 96 _ _ NNP 40436 9512 97 . . . 40436 9512 98 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9513 1 The the DT 40436 9513 2 reader reader NN 40436 9513 3 will will MD 40436 9513 4 find find VB 40436 9513 5 the the DT 40436 9513 6 speculative speculative JJ 40436 9513 7 individuality individuality NN 40436 9513 8 of of IN 40436 9513 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9513 10 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 9513 11 in in IN 40436 9513 12 the the DT 40436 9513 13 sixty sixty CD 40436 9513 14 - - HYPH 40436 9513 15 eighth eighth JJ 40436 9513 16 chapter chapter NN 40436 9513 17 of of IN 40436 9513 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9513 19 History history NN 40436 9513 20 of of IN 40436 9513 21 Greece Greece NNP 40436 9513 22 . . . 40436 9514 1 The the DT 40436 9514 2 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9514 3 of of IN 40436 9514 4 the the DT 40436 9514 5 philosophising philosophising NN 40436 9514 6 or or CC 40436 9514 7 speculative speculative JJ 40436 9514 8 life life NN 40436 9514 9 , , , 40436 9514 10 against against IN 40436 9514 11 the the DT 40436 9514 12 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 9514 13 , , , 40436 9514 14 political political JJ 40436 9514 15 , , , 40436 9514 16 forensic forensic JJ 40436 9514 17 life life NN 40436 9514 18 -- -- : 40436 9514 19 which which WDT 40436 9514 20 is be VBZ 40436 9514 21 put put VBN 40436 9514 22 so so RB 40436 9514 23 much much JJ 40436 9514 24 to to IN 40436 9514 25 the the DT 40436 9514 26 advantage advantage NN 40436 9514 27 of of IN 40436 9514 28 the the DT 40436 9514 29 former former JJ 40436 9514 30 by by IN 40436 9514 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9514 32 in in IN 40436 9514 33 the the DT 40436 9514 34 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9514 35 , , , 40436 9514 36 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 9514 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9514 38 p. p. NN 40436 9514 39 173 173 CD 40436 9514 40 , , , 40436 9514 41 seq seq NN 40436 9514 42 . . . 40436 9515 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9515 2 , , , 40436 9515 3 and and CC 40436 9515 4 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 9515 5 was be VBD 40436 9515 6 the the DT 40436 9515 7 theme theme NN 40436 9515 8 of of IN 40436 9515 9 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 9515 10 's 's POS 40436 9515 11 lost lose VBN 40436 9515 12 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9515 13 called call VBN 40436 9515 14 Hortensius Hortensius NNP 40436 9515 15 : : : 40436 9515 16 wherein wherein WRB 40436 9515 17 Hortensius Hortensius NNP 40436 9515 18 was be VBD 40436 9515 19 introduced introduce VBN 40436 9515 20 pleading plead VBG 40436 9515 21 the the DT 40436 9515 22 cause cause NN 40436 9515 23 against against IN 40436 9515 24 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9515 25 , , , 40436 9515 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9515 27 see see VB 40436 9515 28 Orelli Orelli NNP 40436 9515 29 , , , 40436 9515 30 Fragm Fragm NNP 40436 9515 31 . . . 40436 9516 1 Ciceron Ciceron NNP 40436 9516 2 . . . 40436 9517 1 pp pp NNP 40436 9517 2 . . . 40436 9518 1 479 479 CD 40436 9518 2 - - SYM 40436 9518 3 480 480 CD 40436 9518 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9518 5 , , , 40436 9518 6 while while IN 40436 9518 7 the the DT 40436 9518 8 other other JJ 40436 9518 9 speakers speaker NNS 40436 9518 10 were be VBD 40436 9518 11 provided provide VBN 40436 9518 12 by by IN 40436 9518 13 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 9518 14 with with IN 40436 9518 15 arguments argument NNS 40436 9518 16 mainly mainly RB 40436 9518 17 in in IN 40436 9518 18 defence defence NN 40436 9518 19 of of IN 40436 9518 20 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9518 21 , , , 40436 9518 22 partly partly RB 40436 9518 23 also also RB 40436 9518 24 against against IN 40436 9518 25 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9518 26 . . . 40436 9519 1 The the DT 40436 9519 2 competition competition NN 40436 9519 3 between between IN 40436 9519 4 the the DT 40436 9519 5 teachers teacher NNS 40436 9519 6 of of IN 40436 9519 7 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9519 8 and and CC 40436 9519 9 the the DT 40436 9519 10 teachers teacher NNS 40436 9519 11 of of IN 40436 9519 12 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9519 13 continued continue VBD 40436 9519 14 to to TO 40436 9519 15 be be VB 40436 9519 16 not not RB 40436 9519 17 merely merely RB 40436 9519 18 animated animate VBN 40436 9519 19 but but CC 40436 9519 20 bitter bitter JJ 40436 9519 21 , , , 40436 9519 22 from from IN 40436 9519 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9519 24 downward downward RB 40436 9519 25 throughout throughout IN 40436 9519 26 the the DT 40436 9519 27 Ciceronian ciceronian JJ 40436 9519 28 age age NN 40436 9519 29 . . . 40436 9520 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9520 2 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 9520 3 , , , 40436 9520 4 De De NNP 40436 9520 5 Orat Orat NNP 40436 9520 6 . . . 40436 9521 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9522 1 45 45 CD 40436 9522 2 - - HYPH 40436 9522 3 46 46 CD 40436 9522 4 - - HYPH 40436 9522 5 47 47 CD 40436 9522 6 - - SYM 40436 9522 7 75 75 CD 40436 9522 8 , , , 40436 9522 9 & & CC 40436 9522 10 c. c. NNP 40436 9522 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9522 12 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9522 13 read read VBP 40436 9522 14 in in IN 40436 9522 15 the the DT 40436 9522 16 treatise treatise NN 40436 9522 17 of of IN 40436 9522 18 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40436 9522 19 against against IN 40436 9522 20 the the DT 40436 9522 21 Epikurean Epikurean NNP 40436 9522 22 Kolôtes Kolôtes NNPS 40436 9522 23 , , , 40436 9522 24 an an DT 40436 9522 25 acrimonious acrimonious JJ 40436 9522 26 invective invective NN 40436 9522 27 against against IN 40436 9522 28 Epikurus Epikurus NNP 40436 9522 29 and and CC 40436 9522 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9522 31 followers follower NNS 40436 9522 32 , , , 40436 9522 33 for for IN 40436 9522 34 recommending recommend VBG 40436 9522 35 a a DT 40436 9522 36 scheme scheme NN 40436 9522 37 of of IN 40436 9522 38 life life NN 40436 9522 39 such such JJ 40436 9522 40 as as IN 40436 9522 41 to to TO 40436 9522 42 withdraw withdraw VB 40436 9522 43 men man NNS 40436 9522 44 from from IN 40436 9522 45 active active JJ 40436 9522 46 political political JJ 40436 9522 47 functions function NNS 40436 9522 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9522 49 Plutarch plutarch NN 40436 9522 50 , , , 40436 9522 51 adv adv NN 40436 9522 52 . . . 40436 9523 1 Kolôt Kolôt NNP 40436 9523 2 . . . 40436 9524 1 pp pp NNP 40436 9524 2 . . . 40436 9525 1 1125 1125 CD 40436 9525 2 C C NNP 40436 9525 3 , , , 40436 9525 4 1127 1127 CD 40436 9525 5 - - SYM 40436 9525 6 1128 1128 CD 40436 9525 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9525 8 ; ; : 40436 9525 9 the the DT 40436 9525 10 like like UH 40436 9525 11 also also RB 40436 9525 12 in in IN 40436 9525 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9525 14 other other JJ 40436 9525 15 treatise treatise NN 40436 9525 16 , , , 40436 9525 17 Non Non NNP 40436 9525 18 Posse Posse NNP 40436 9525 19 Suaviter Suaviter NNP 40436 9525 20 Vivi Vivi NNP 40436 9525 21 secundum secundum NN 40436 9525 22 Epicurum Epicurum NNP 40436 9525 23 . . . 40436 9526 1 But but CC 40436 9526 2 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40436 9526 3 at at IN 40436 9526 4 the the DT 40436 9526 5 same same JJ 40436 9526 6 time time NN 40436 9526 7 speaks speak VBZ 40436 9526 8 as as IN 40436 9526 9 if if IN 40436 9526 10 Epikurus Epikurus NNP 40436 9526 11 were be VBD 40436 9526 12 the the DT 40436 9526 13 only only JJ 40436 9526 14 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9526 15 who who WP 40436 9526 16 had have VBD 40436 9526 17 recommended recommend VBN 40436 9526 18 this this DT 40436 9526 19 , , , 40436 9526 20 and and CC 40436 9526 21 as as IN 40436 9526 22 if if IN 40436 9526 23 all all PDT 40436 9526 24 the the DT 40436 9526 25 other other JJ 40436 9526 26 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 9526 27 had have VBD 40436 9526 28 recommended recommend VBN 40436 9526 29 an an DT 40436 9526 30 active active JJ 40436 9526 31 life life NN 40436 9526 32 ; ; : 40436 9526 33 nay nay NN 40436 9526 34 , , , 40436 9526 35 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9526 36 talks talk VBZ 40436 9526 37 of of IN 40436 9526 38 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9526 39 among among IN 40436 9526 40 the the DT 40436 9526 41 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 9526 42 actively actively RB 40436 9526 43 engaged engage VBD 40436 9526 44 in in IN 40436 9526 45 practical practical JJ 40436 9526 46 reformatory reformatory JJ 40436 9526 47 legislation legislation NN 40436 9526 48 , , , 40436 9526 49 through through IN 40436 9526 50 Dion Dion NNP 40436 9526 51 and and CC 40436 9526 52 the the DT 40436 9526 53 pupils pupil NNS 40436 9526 54 of of IN 40436 9526 55 the the DT 40436 9526 56 Academy Academy NNP 40436 9526 57 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9526 58 p. p. NN 40436 9526 59 1126 1126 CD 40436 9526 60 , , , 40436 9526 61 B B NNP 40436 9526 62 , , , 40436 9526 63 C C NNP 40436 9526 64 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9526 65 . . . 40436 9527 1 Here here RB 40436 9527 2 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40436 9527 3 mistakes mistake VBZ 40436 9527 4 : : : 40436 9527 5 the the DT 40436 9527 6 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9527 7 tendencies tendency NNS 40436 9527 8 were be VBD 40436 9527 9 quite quite RB 40436 9527 10 different different JJ 40436 9527 11 from from IN 40436 9527 12 what what WP 40436 9527 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9527 14 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 9527 15 . . . 40436 9528 1 The the DT 40436 9528 2 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9528 3 and and CC 40436 9528 4 Theætêtus Theætêtus NNP 40436 9528 5 enforce enforce VBP 40436 9528 6 upon upon IN 40436 9528 7 the the DT 40436 9528 8 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9528 9 a a DT 40436 9528 10 life life NN 40436 9528 11 quite quite RB 40436 9528 12 apart apart RB 40436 9528 13 from from IN 40436 9528 14 politics politic NNS 40436 9528 15 , , , 40436 9528 16 pursuing pursue VBG 40436 9528 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9528 18 own own JJ 40436 9528 19 course course NN 40436 9528 20 , , , 40436 9528 21 and and CC 40436 9528 22 not not RB 40436 9528 23 meddling meddle VBG 40436 9528 24 with with IN 40436 9528 25 others--[Greek others--[greek CD 40436 9528 26 : : : 40436 9528 27 philoso philoso NNP 40436 9528 28 / / SYM 40436 9528 29 phou phou NNP 40436 9528 30 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 9528 31 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 9528 32 pra pra NNP 40436 9528 33 / / SYM 40436 9528 34 xantos xantos NNP 40436 9528 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9528 36 ou ou NNP 40436 9528 37 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9528 38 polupragmonê polupragmonê NNP 40436 9528 39 / / SYM 40436 9528 40 santos santo NNS 40436 9528 41 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9528 42 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9528 43 bi bi NN 40436 9528 44 / / SYM 40436 9528 45 ô| ô| NN 40436 9528 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9528 47 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9528 48 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 9528 49 . . . 40436 9529 1 526 526 CD 40436 9529 2 C C NNP 40436 9529 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9529 4 ; ; : 40436 9529 5 which which WDT 40436 9529 6 is be VBZ 40436 9529 7 the the DT 40436 9529 8 same same JJ 40436 9529 9 advice advice NN 40436 9529 10 as as IN 40436 9529 11 Epikurus Epikurus NNP 40436 9529 12 gave give VBD 40436 9529 13 . . . 40436 9530 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9530 2 is be VBZ 40436 9530 3 set set VBN 40436 9530 4 forth forth RP 40436 9530 5 eloquently eloquently RB 40436 9530 6 in in IN 40436 9530 7 the the DT 40436 9530 8 poetry poetry NN 40436 9530 9 of of IN 40436 9530 10 Lucretius Lucretius NNP 40436 9530 11 , , , 40436 9530 12 but but CC 40436 9530 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9530 14 had have VBD 40436 9530 15 been be VBN 40436 9530 16 set set VBN 40436 9530 17 forth forth RP 40436 9530 18 previously previously RB 40436 9530 19 , , , 40436 9530 20 not not RB 40436 9530 21 less less RBR 40436 9530 22 eloquently eloquently RB 40436 9530 23 , , , 40436 9530 24 in in IN 40436 9530 25 the the DT 40436 9530 26 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9530 27 of of IN 40436 9530 28 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9530 29 . . . 40436 9530 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9531 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9531 2 Side side NN 40436 9531 3 - - HYPH 40436 9531 4 note note NN 40436 9531 5 : : : 40436 9531 6 Issue issue NN 40436 9531 7 between between IN 40436 9531 8 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9531 9 and and CC 40436 9531 10 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9531 11 -- -- : 40436 9531 12 not not RB 40436 9531 13 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 40436 9531 14 handled handle VBN 40436 9531 15 by by IN 40436 9531 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9531 17 . . . 40436 9532 1 Injustice Injustice NNP 40436 9532 2 done do VBN 40436 9532 3 to to TO 40436 9532 4 rhetoric rhetoric VB 40436 9532 5 . . . 40436 9533 1 Ignoble ignoble JJ 40436 9533 2 manner manner NN 40436 9533 3 in in IN 40436 9533 4 which which WDT 40436 9533 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9533 6 is be VBZ 40436 9533 7 presented present VBN 40436 9533 8 by by IN 40436 9533 9 Polus Polus NNP 40436 9533 10 and and CC 40436 9533 11 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9533 12 . . . 40436 9533 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9534 1 This this DT 40436 9534 2 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9534 3 of of IN 40436 9534 4 the the DT 40436 9534 5 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 9534 6 life life NN 40436 9534 7 to to IN 40436 9534 8 the the DT 40436 9534 9 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 9534 10 or or CC 40436 9534 11 political political JJ 40436 9534 12 , , , 40436 9534 13 constitutes constitute VBZ 40436 9534 14 one one CD 40436 9534 15 of of IN 40436 9534 16 the the DT 40436 9534 17 most most RBS 40436 9534 18 interesting interesting JJ 40436 9534 19 features feature NNS 40436 9534 20 of of IN 40436 9534 21 the the DT 40436 9534 22 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9534 23 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9534 24 . . . 40436 9535 1 But but CC 40436 9535 2 when when WRB 40436 9535 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9535 4 follow follow VBP 40436 9535 5 the the DT 40436 9535 6 pleadings pleading NNS 40436 9535 7 upon upon IN 40436 9535 8 which which WDT 40436 9535 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9535 10 rests rest VBZ 40436 9535 11 this this DT 40436 9535 12 grand grand JJ 40436 9535 13 issue issue NN 40436 9535 14 , , , 40436 9535 15 and and CC 40436 9535 16 the the DT 40436 9535 17 line line NN 40436 9535 18 which which WDT 40436 9535 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9535 20 draws draw VBZ 40436 9535 21 between between IN 40436 9535 22 the the DT 40436 9535 23 two two CD 40436 9535 24 functions function NNS 40436 9535 25 , , , 40436 9535 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9535 27 find find VBP 40436 9535 28 much much JJ 40436 9535 29 that that WDT 40436 9535 30 is be VBZ 40436 9535 31 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 9535 32 . . . 40436 9536 1 Since since IN 40436 9536 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9536 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9536 4 pleads plead VBZ 40436 9536 5 both both DT 40436 9536 6 sides side NNS 40436 9536 7 of of IN 40436 9536 8 the the DT 40436 9536 9 case case NN 40436 9536 10 , , , 40436 9536 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9536 12 is be VBZ 40436 9536 13 bound bind VBN 40436 9536 14 in in IN 40436 9536 15 fairness fairness NN 40436 9536 16 to to TO 40436 9536 17 set set VB 40436 9536 18 forth forth RP 40436 9536 19 the the DT 40436 9536 20 case case NN 40436 9536 21 which which WDT 40436 9536 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9536 23 attacks attack VBZ 40436 9536 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9536 25 that that DT 40436 9536 26 of of IN 40436 9536 27 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9536 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9536 29 , , , 40436 9536 30 as as IN 40436 9536 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9536 32 would would MD 40436 9536 33 be be VB 40436 9536 34 put put VBN 40436 9536 35 by by IN 40436 9536 36 competent competent JJ 40436 9536 37 and and CC 40436 9536 38 honourable honourable JJ 40436 9536 39 advocates advocate NNS 40436 9536 40 -- -- : 40436 9536 41 by by IN 40436 9536 42 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9536 43 , , , 40436 9536 44 for for IN 40436 9536 45 example example NN 40436 9536 46 , , , 40436 9536 47 or or CC 40436 9536 48 Demosthenes Demosthenes NNPS 40436 9536 49 , , , 40436 9536 50 or or CC 40436 9536 51 Isokrates Isokrates NNPS 40436 9536 52 , , , 40436 9536 53 or or CC 40436 9536 54 Quintilian quintilian JJ 40436 9536 55 . . . 40436 9537 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9537 2 does do VBZ 40436 9537 3 this this DT 40436 9537 4 , , , 40436 9537 5 to to IN 40436 9537 6 a a DT 40436 9537 7 certain certain JJ 40436 9537 8 extent extent NN 40436 9537 9 , , , 40436 9537 10 in in IN 40436 9537 11 the the DT 40436 9537 12 first first JJ 40436 9537 13 part part NN 40436 9537 14 of of IN 40436 9537 15 the the DT 40436 9537 16 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9537 17 , , , 40436 9537 18 carried carry VBN 40436 9537 19 on on RP 40436 9537 20 by by IN 40436 9537 21 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9537 22 with with IN 40436 9537 23 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9537 24 . . . 40436 9538 1 But but CC 40436 9538 2 in in IN 40436 9538 3 the the DT 40436 9538 4 succeeding succeed VBG 40436 9538 5 portions portion NNS 40436 9538 6 -- -- : 40436 9538 7 carried carry VBN 40436 9538 8 on on RP 40436 9538 9 with with IN 40436 9538 10 Pôlus Pôlus NNP 40436 9538 11 and and CC 40436 9538 12 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9538 13 , , , 40436 9538 14 and and CC 40436 9538 15 occupying occupy VBG 40436 9538 16 three three CD 40436 9538 17 - - HYPH 40436 9538 18 fourths fourth NNS 40436 9538 19 of of IN 40436 9538 20 the the DT 40436 9538 21 whole whole NN 40436 9538 22 -- -- : 40436 9538 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9538 24 alters alter VBZ 40436 9538 25 the the DT 40436 9538 26 character character NN 40436 9538 27 of of IN 40436 9538 28 the the DT 40436 9538 29 defence defence NN 40436 9538 30 , , , 40436 9538 31 and and CC 40436 9538 32 merges merge VBZ 40436 9538 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9538 34 in in IN 40436 9538 35 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9538 36 theories theory NNS 40436 9538 37 which which WDT 40436 9538 38 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9538 39 , , , 40436 9538 40 had have VBD 40436 9538 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9538 42 been be VBN 40436 9538 43 the the DT 40436 9538 44 defender defender NN 40436 9538 45 , , , 40436 9538 46 would would MD 40436 9538 47 not not RB 40436 9538 48 only only RB 40436 9538 49 have have VB 40436 9538 50 put put VBN 40436 9538 51 aside aside RB 40436 9538 52 as as IN 40436 9538 53 misplaced misplace VBN 40436 9538 54 , , , 40436 9538 55 but but CC 40436 9538 56 disavowed disavow VBD 40436 9538 57 as as RB 40436 9538 58 untrue untrue JJ 40436 9538 59 . . . 40436 9539 1 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9539 2 would would MD 40436 9539 3 have have VB 40436 9539 4 listened listen VBN 40436 9539 5 with with IN 40436 9539 6 mixed mixed JJ 40436 9539 7 surprise surprise NN 40436 9539 8 and and CC 40436 9539 9 anger anger NN 40436 9539 10 , , , 40436 9539 11 if if IN 40436 9539 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9539 13 had have VBD 40436 9539 14 heard hear VBN 40436 9539 15 any any DT 40436 9539 16 one one NN 40436 9539 17 utter utter VB 40436 9539 18 the the DT 40436 9539 19 monstrous monstrous JJ 40436 9539 20 assertion assertion NN 40436 9539 21 which which WDT 40436 9539 22 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9539 23 puts put VBZ 40436 9539 24 into into IN 40436 9539 25 the the DT 40436 9539 26 mouth mouth NN 40436 9539 27 of of IN 40436 9539 28 Polus Polus NNP 40436 9539 29 -- -- : 40436 9539 30 That that IN 40436 9539 31 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 9539 32 , , , 40436 9539 33 like like IN 40436 9539 34 despots despot NNS 40436 9539 35 , , , 40436 9539 36 kill kill VB 40436 9539 37 , , , 40436 9539 38 impoverish impoverish JJ 40436 9539 39 , , , 40436 9539 40 or or CC 40436 9539 41 expel expel VB 40436 9539 42 any any DT 40436 9539 43 citizen citizen NN 40436 9539 44 at at IN 40436 9539 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9539 46 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 9539 47 . . . 40436 9540 1 Though though IN 40436 9540 2 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9540 3 was be VBD 40436 9540 4 the the DT 40436 9540 5 most most RBS 40436 9540 6 powerful powerful JJ 40436 9540 7 of of IN 40436 9540 8 all all DT 40436 9540 9 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9540 10 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 9540 11 , , , 40436 9540 12 yet yet CC 40436 9540 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9540 14 had have VBD 40436 9540 15 to to TO 40436 9540 16 contend contend VB 40436 9540 17 all all PDT 40436 9540 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9540 19 life life NN 40436 9540 20 against against IN 40436 9540 21 fierce fierce JJ 40436 9540 22 opposition opposition NN 40436 9540 23 from from IN 40436 9540 24 others other NNS 40436 9540 25 , , , 40436 9540 26 and and CC 40436 9540 27 was be VBD 40436 9540 28 even even RB 40436 9540 29 fined fine VBN 40436 9540 30 during during IN 40436 9540 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9540 32 last last JJ 40436 9540 33 years year NNS 40436 9540 34 . . . 40436 9541 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9541 2 would would MD 40436 9541 3 hardly hardly RB 40436 9541 4 have have VB 40436 9541 5 understood understand VBN 40436 9541 6 how how WRB 40436 9541 7 an an DT 40436 9541 8 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9541 9 citizen citizen NN 40436 9541 10 could could MD 40436 9541 11 have have VB 40436 9541 12 made make VBN 40436 9541 13 any any DT 40436 9541 14 assertion assertion NN 40436 9541 15 so so RB 40436 9541 16 completely completely RB 40436 9541 17 falsified falsify VBN 40436 9541 18 by by IN 40436 9541 19 all all PDT 40436 9541 20 the the DT 40436 9541 21 history history NN 40436 9541 22 of of IN 40436 9541 23 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9541 24 , , , 40436 9541 25 respecting respect VBG 40436 9541 26 the the DT 40436 9541 27 omnipotence omnipotence NN 40436 9541 28 of of IN 40436 9541 29 the the DT 40436 9541 30 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 9541 31 . . . 40436 9542 1 Again again RB 40436 9542 2 , , , 40436 9542 3 if if IN 40436 9542 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9542 5 had have VBD 40436 9542 6 heard hear VBN 40436 9542 7 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 9542 8 proclaiming proclaim VBG 40436 9542 9 that that IN 40436 9542 10 the the DT 40436 9542 11 strong strong JJ 40436 9542 12 giant giant NN 40436 9542 13 had have VBD 40436 9542 14 a a DT 40436 9542 15 natural natural JJ 40436 9542 16 right right NN 40436 9542 17 to to TO 40436 9542 18 satiate satiate VB 40436 9542 19 all all PDT 40436 9542 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9542 21 desires desire NNS 40436 9542 22 at at IN 40436 9542 23 the the DT 40436 9542 24 cost cost NN 40436 9542 25 of of IN 40436 9542 26 the the DT 40436 9542 27 weaker weak JJR 40436 9542 28 Many many JJ 40436 9542 29 -- -- : 40436 9542 30 and and CC 40436 9542 31 that that IN 40436 9542 32 these these DT 40436 9542 33 latter latter JJ 40436 9542 34 sinned sin VBD 40436 9542 35 against against IN 40436 9542 36 Nature Nature NNP 40436 9542 37 when when WRB 40436 9542 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9542 39 took take VBD 40436 9542 40 precautions precaution NNS 40436 9542 41 to to TO 40436 9542 42 prevent prevent VB 40436 9542 43 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9542 44 -- -- : 40436 9542 45 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9542 46 would would MD 40436 9542 47 have have VB 40436 9542 48 protested protest VBN 40436 9542 49 against against IN 40436 9542 50 the the DT 40436 9542 51 proclamation proclamation NN 40436 9542 52 as as RB 40436 9542 53 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 9542 54 as as IN 40436 9542 55 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9542 56 . . . 40436 9543 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9543 2 127 127 CD 40436 9543 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9543 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9543 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9543 6 127 127 CD 40436 9543 7 : : : 40436 9543 8 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9543 9 might may MD 40436 9543 10 indeed indeed RB 40436 9543 11 have have VB 40436 9543 12 referred refer VBN 40436 9543 13 to to IN 40436 9543 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9543 15 own own JJ 40436 9543 16 panegyrical panegyrical JJ 40436 9543 17 oration oration NN 40436 9543 18 in in IN 40436 9543 19 Thucydides Thucydides NNP 40436 9543 20 , , , 40436 9543 21 ii ii NNP 40436 9543 22 . . . 40436 9544 1 37 37 CD 40436 9544 2 . . . 40436 9544 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9545 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9545 2 Side side NN 40436 9545 3 - - HYPH 40436 9545 4 note note NN 40436 9545 5 : : : 40436 9545 6 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9545 7 would would MD 40436 9545 8 have have VB 40436 9545 9 accepted accept VBN 40436 9545 10 the the DT 40436 9545 11 defence defence NN 40436 9545 12 of of IN 40436 9545 13 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9545 14 , , , 40436 9545 15 as as IN 40436 9545 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9545 17 has have VBZ 40436 9545 18 put put VBN 40436 9545 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9545 20 into into IN 40436 9545 21 the the DT 40436 9545 22 mouth mouth NN 40436 9545 23 of of IN 40436 9545 24 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9545 25 . . . 40436 9545 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9546 1 If if IN 40436 9546 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9546 3 suppose suppose VBP 40436 9546 4 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9546 5 to to TO 40436 9546 6 have have VB 40436 9546 7 undertaken undertake VBN 40436 9546 8 the the DT 40436 9546 9 defence defence NN 40436 9546 10 of of IN 40436 9546 11 the the DT 40436 9546 12 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 9546 13 element element NN 40436 9546 14 at at IN 40436 9546 15 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9546 16 , , , 40436 9546 17 against against IN 40436 9546 18 the the DT 40436 9546 19 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 9546 20 element element NN 40436 9546 21 represented represent VBN 40436 9546 22 by by IN 40436 9546 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9546 24 , , , 40436 9546 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9546 26 would would MD 40436 9546 27 have have VB 40436 9546 28 accepted accept VBN 40436 9546 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9546 30 , , , 40436 9546 31 though though IN 40436 9546 32 not not RB 40436 9546 33 a a DT 40436 9546 34 position position NN 40436 9546 35 of of IN 40436 9546 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9546 37 own own JJ 40436 9546 38 choosing choosing NN 40436 9546 39 , , , 40436 9546 40 on on IN 40436 9546 41 the the DT 40436 9546 42 footing footing NN 40436 9546 43 on on IN 40436 9546 44 which which WDT 40436 9546 45 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9546 46 places place VBZ 40436 9546 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9546 48 in in IN 40436 9546 49 the the DT 40436 9546 50 mouth mouth NN 40436 9546 51 of of IN 40436 9546 52 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9546 53 : : : 40436 9546 54 " " `` 40436 9546 55 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9546 56 is be VBZ 40436 9546 57 an an DT 40436 9546 58 engine engine NN 40436 9546 59 of of IN 40436 9546 60 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 9546 61 addressed address VBN 40436 9546 62 to to IN 40436 9546 63 numerous numerous JJ 40436 9546 64 assembled assemble VBN 40436 9546 65 auditors auditor NNS 40436 9546 66 : : : 40436 9546 67 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9546 68 ensures ensure VBZ 40436 9546 69 freedom freedom NN 40436 9546 70 to to IN 40436 9546 71 the the DT 40436 9546 72 city city NN 40436 9546 73 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9546 74 through through IN 40436 9546 75 the the DT 40436 9546 76 free free JJ 40436 9546 77 exercise exercise NN 40436 9546 78 of of IN 40436 9546 79 such such PDT 40436 9546 80 a a DT 40436 9546 81 gift gift NN 40436 9546 82 by by IN 40436 9546 83 many many JJ 40436 9546 84 competing compete VBG 40436 9546 85 orators orator NNS 40436 9546 86 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9546 87 and and CC 40436 9546 88 political political JJ 40436 9546 89 ascendency ascendency NN 40436 9546 90 or or CC 40436 9546 91 command command NN 40436 9546 92 to to IN 40436 9546 93 the the DT 40436 9546 94 ablest able JJS 40436 9546 95 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 9546 96 . . . 40436 9547 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9547 2 thus thus RB 40436 9547 3 confers confer VBZ 40436 9547 4 great great JJ 40436 9547 5 power power NN 40436 9547 6 on on IN 40436 9547 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9547 8 who who WP 40436 9547 9 possesses possess VBZ 40436 9547 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9547 11 in in IN 40436 9547 12 the the DT 40436 9547 13 highest high JJS 40436 9547 14 measure measure NN 40436 9547 15 : : : 40436 9547 16 but but CC 40436 9547 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9547 18 ought ought MD 40436 9547 19 by by IN 40436 9547 20 no no DT 40436 9547 21 means means NN 40436 9547 22 to to TO 40436 9547 23 employ employ VB 40436 9547 24 that that DT 40436 9547 25 power power NN 40436 9547 26 for for IN 40436 9547 27 unjust unjust JJ 40436 9547 28 purposes purpose NNS 40436 9547 29 . . . 40436 9547 30 " " '' 40436 9548 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9548 2 is be VBZ 40436 9548 3 very very RB 40436 9548 4 probable probable JJ 40436 9548 5 that that IN 40436 9548 6 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9548 7 might may MD 40436 9548 8 have have VB 40436 9548 9 recommended recommend VBN 40436 9548 10 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 40436 9548 11 study study NN 40436 9548 12 to to IN 40436 9548 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9548 14 , , , 40436 9548 15 as as IN 40436 9548 16 a a DT 40436 9548 17 means means NN 40436 9548 18 of of IN 40436 9548 19 defending defend VBG 40436 9548 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9548 21 against against IN 40436 9548 22 unjust unjust JJ 40436 9548 23 accusations accusation NNS 40436 9548 24 , , , 40436 9548 25 and and CC 40436 9548 26 of of IN 40436 9548 27 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 9548 28 a a DT 40436 9548 29 certain certain JJ 40436 9548 30 measure measure NN 40436 9548 31 of of IN 40436 9548 32 influence influence NN 40436 9548 33 on on IN 40436 9548 34 public public JJ 40436 9548 35 affairs affair NNS 40436 9548 36 . . . 40436 9549 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9549 2 128 128 CD 40436 9549 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9549 4 But but CC 40436 9549 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9549 6 would would MD 40436 9549 7 have have VB 40436 9549 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 9549 9 carefully carefully RB 40436 9549 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9549 11 as as IN 40436 9549 12 Horace Horace NNP 40436 9549 13 does do VBZ 40436 9549 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9549 15 between between IN 40436 9549 16 defending defend VBG 40436 9549 17 yourself -PRON- PRP 40436 9549 18 against against IN 40436 9549 19 unjust unjust JJ 40436 9549 20 attacks attack NNS 40436 9549 21 , , , 40436 9549 22 and and CC 40436 9549 23 making make VBG 40436 9549 24 unjust unjust JJ 40436 9549 25 attacks attack NNS 40436 9549 26 upon upon IN 40436 9549 27 others other NNS 40436 9549 28 : : : 40436 9549 29 though though IN 40436 9549 30 the the DT 40436 9549 31 same same JJ 40436 9549 32 weapon weapon NN 40436 9549 33 may may MD 40436 9549 34 suit suit VB 40436 9549 35 for for IN 40436 9549 36 both both DT 40436 9549 37 . . . 40436 9550 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9550 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9550 3 128 128 CD 40436 9550 4 : : : 40436 9550 5 Horat Horat NNP 40436 9550 6 . . . 40436 9551 1 Satir Satir NNP 40436 9551 2 . . . 40436 9552 1 ii ii LS 40436 9552 2 . . . 40436 9553 1 1 1 CD 40436 9553 2 , , , 40436 9553 3 39 39 CD 40436 9553 4 - - HYPH 40436 9553 5 - - : 40436 9553 6 " " `` 40436 9553 7 Hic hic NN 40436 9553 8 stilus stilus NN 40436 9553 9 haud haud NN 40436 9553 10 petet petet NN 40436 9553 11 ultro ultro NNP 40436 9553 12 Quemquam Quemquam NNP 40436 9553 13 animantem animantem NNP 40436 9553 14 ; ; : 40436 9553 15 et et NN 40436 9553 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9553 17 veluti veluti NN 40436 9553 18 custodiet custodiet JJ 40436 9553 19 ensis ensis NN 40436 9553 20 Vaginâ Vaginâ NNP 40436 9553 21 tectus tectus NNP 40436 9553 22 ; ; : 40436 9553 23 quem quem NNP 40436 9553 24 cur cur NNP 40436 9553 25 destringere destringere NNP 40436 9553 26 coner coner NN 40436 9553 27 , , , 40436 9553 28 Tutus Tutus NNP 40436 9553 29 ab ab NNP 40436 9553 30 infestis infestis NN 40436 9553 31 latronibus latronibus NNP 40436 9553 32 ? ? . 40436 9554 1 Oh oh UH 40436 9554 2 pater pater RBR 40436 9554 3 et et FW 40436 9554 4 rex rex NNP 40436 9554 5 Jupiter Jupiter NNP 40436 9554 6 ! ! . 40436 9555 1 ut ut UH 40436 9555 2 pereat pereat VB 40436 9555 3 positum positum NN 40436 9555 4 rubigine rubigine NN 40436 9555 5 telum telum NN 40436 9555 6 , , , 40436 9555 7 Nec Nec NNP 40436 9555 8 quisquam quisquam NNP 40436 9555 9 noceat noceat NNP 40436 9555 10 cupido cupido NNP 40436 9555 11 mihi mihi NN 40436 9555 12 pacis pacis NNP 40436 9555 13 ! ! . 40436 9556 1 At at IN 40436 9556 2 ille ille NNP 40436 9556 3 Qui Qui NNP 40436 9556 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9556 5 commôrit commôrit NN 40436 9556 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9556 7 melius melius NNP 40436 9556 8 non non NNP 40436 9556 9 tangere tangere RB 40436 9556 10 ! ! . 40436 9557 1 clamo clamo NNP 40436 9557 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9557 3 Flebit Flebit NNP 40436 9557 4 , , , 40436 9557 5 et et NNP 40436 9557 6 insignis insignis NNP 40436 9557 7 totâ totâ NNP 40436 9557 8 cantabitur cantabitur NNP 40436 9557 9 urbe urbe NNP 40436 9557 10 . . . 40436 9557 11 " " '' 40436 9558 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9558 2 need need VBP 40436 9558 3 only only RB 40436 9558 4 read read VB 40436 9558 5 the the DT 40436 9558 6 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 40436 9558 7 of of IN 40436 9558 8 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 9558 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9558 10 ii ii NNP 40436 9558 11 . . . 40436 9559 1 9 9 LS 40436 9559 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9559 3 , , , 40436 9559 4 to to TO 40436 9559 5 see see VB 40436 9559 6 that that IN 40436 9559 7 the the DT 40436 9559 8 historical historical JJ 40436 9559 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9559 10 judged judge VBN 40436 9559 11 of of IN 40436 9559 12 these these DT 40436 9559 13 matters matter NNS 40436 9559 14 differently differently RB 40436 9559 15 from from IN 40436 9559 16 the the DT 40436 9559 17 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9559 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9559 19 of of IN 40436 9559 20 the the DT 40436 9559 21 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9559 22 . . . 40436 9560 1 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9560 2 complained complain VBD 40436 9560 3 to to IN 40436 9560 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9560 5 that that DT 40436 9560 6 life life NN 40436 9560 7 was be VBD 40436 9560 8 difficult difficult JJ 40436 9560 9 at at IN 40436 9560 10 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9560 11 for for IN 40436 9560 12 a a DT 40436 9560 13 quiet quiet JJ 40436 9560 14 man man NN 40436 9560 15 who who WP 40436 9560 16 wished wish VBD 40436 9560 17 only only RB 40436 9560 18 to to TO 40436 9560 19 mind mind VB 40436 9560 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9560 21 own own JJ 40436 9560 22 business business NN 40436 9560 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9560 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9560 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9560 26 : : : 40436 9560 27 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 9560 28 e(autou= e(autou= NNP 40436 9560 29 pra pra NNP 40436 9560 30 / / SYM 40436 9560 31 ttein ttein NN 40436 9560 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9560 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9560 34 ; ; : 40436 9560 35 because because IN 40436 9560 36 there there EX 40436 9560 37 were be VBD 40436 9560 38 persons person NNS 40436 9560 39 who who WP 40436 9560 40 brought bring VBD 40436 9560 41 unjust unjust JJ 40436 9560 42 actions action NNS 40436 9560 43 at at IN 40436 9560 44 law law NN 40436 9560 45 against against IN 40436 9560 46 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9560 47 , , , 40436 9560 48 for for IN 40436 9560 49 the the DT 40436 9560 50 purpose purpose NN 40436 9560 51 of of IN 40436 9560 52 extorting extort VBG 40436 9560 53 money money NN 40436 9560 54 to to TO 40436 9560 55 buy buy VB 40436 9560 56 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9560 57 off off RP 40436 9560 58 . . . 40436 9561 1 The the DT 40436 9561 2 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9561 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9561 4 of of IN 40436 9561 5 the the DT 40436 9561 6 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9561 7 would would MD 40436 9561 8 have have VB 40436 9561 9 replied reply VBN 40436 9561 10 to to IN 40436 9561 11 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 12 : : : 40436 9561 13 " " `` 40436 9561 14 Never never RB 40436 9561 15 mind mind VB 40436 9561 16 : : : 40436 9561 17 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 18 are be VBP 40436 9561 19 just just RB 40436 9561 20 , , , 40436 9561 21 and and CC 40436 9561 22 these these DT 40436 9561 23 assailants assailant NNS 40436 9561 24 are be VBP 40436 9561 25 unjust unjust JJ 40436 9561 26 : : : 40436 9561 27 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 28 are be VBP 40436 9561 29 by by IN 40436 9561 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9561 31 own own JJ 40436 9561 32 conduct conduct NN 40436 9561 33 entailing entail VBG 40436 9561 34 upon upon IN 40436 9561 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 36 a a DT 40436 9561 37 terrible terrible JJ 40436 9561 38 distemper distemper NN 40436 9561 39 , , , 40436 9561 40 from from IN 40436 9561 41 which which WDT 40436 9561 42 , , , 40436 9561 43 if if IN 40436 9561 44 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 45 leave leave VBP 40436 9561 46 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 47 unpunished unpunished JJ 40436 9561 48 , , , 40436 9561 49 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 50 will will MD 40436 9561 51 suffer suffer VB 40436 9561 52 all all PDT 40436 9561 53 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9561 54 lives life NNS 40436 9561 55 : : : 40436 9561 56 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 57 injure injure VBP 40436 9561 58 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 59 more more RBR 40436 9561 60 than than IN 40436 9561 61 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 62 injure injure VBP 40436 9561 63 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9561 64 " " '' 40436 9561 65 . . . 40436 9562 1 But but CC 40436 9562 2 the the DT 40436 9562 3 historical historical JJ 40436 9562 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9562 5 in in IN 40436 9562 6 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 9562 7 replies reply VBZ 40436 9562 8 in in IN 40436 9562 9 quite quite PDT 40436 9562 10 another another DT 40436 9562 11 spirit spirit NN 40436 9562 12 . . . 40436 9563 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9563 2 advises advise VBZ 40436 9563 3 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9563 4 to to TO 40436 9563 5 look look VB 40436 9563 6 out out RP 40436 9563 7 for for IN 40436 9563 8 a a DT 40436 9563 9 clever clever JJ 40436 9563 10 and and CC 40436 9563 11 active active JJ 40436 9563 12 friend friend NN 40436 9563 13 , , , 40436 9563 14 to to TO 40436 9563 15 attach attach VB 40436 9563 16 this this DT 40436 9563 17 person person NN 40436 9563 18 to to IN 40436 9563 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9563 20 interest interest NN 40436 9563 21 by by IN 40436 9563 22 attention attention NN 40436 9563 23 and and CC 40436 9563 24 favours favour NNS 40436 9563 25 , , , 40436 9563 26 and and CC 40436 9563 27 to to TO 40436 9563 28 trust trust VB 40436 9563 29 to to IN 40436 9563 30 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9563 31 for for IN 40436 9563 32 keeping keep VBG 40436 9563 33 off off RP 40436 9563 34 the the DT 40436 9563 35 assailants assailant NNS 40436 9563 36 . . . 40436 9564 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 9564 2 , , , 40436 9564 3 a a DT 40436 9564 4 poor poor JJ 40436 9564 5 but but CC 40436 9564 6 energetic energetic JJ 40436 9564 7 man man NN 40436 9564 8 named name VBN 40436 9564 9 Archedemus Archedemus NNP 40436 9564 10 is be VBZ 40436 9564 11 found find VBN 40436 9564 12 , , , 40436 9564 13 who who WP 40436 9564 14 takes take VBZ 40436 9564 15 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9564 16 's 's POS 40436 9564 17 part part NN 40436 9564 18 against against IN 40436 9564 19 the the DT 40436 9564 20 assailants assailant NNS 40436 9564 21 , , , 40436 9564 22 and and CC 40436 9564 23 even even RB 40436 9564 24 brings bring VBZ 40436 9564 25 counterattacks counterattack NNS 40436 9564 26 against against IN 40436 9564 27 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9564 28 , , , 40436 9564 29 which which WDT 40436 9564 30 force force VBP 40436 9564 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9564 32 to to TO 40436 9564 33 leave leave VB 40436 9564 34 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9564 35 alone alone RB 40436 9564 36 , , , 40436 9564 37 and and CC 40436 9564 38 to to TO 40436 9564 39 give give VB 40436 9564 40 money money NN 40436 9564 41 to to IN 40436 9564 42 Archedemus Archedemus NNP 40436 9564 43 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9564 44 . . . 40436 9565 1 The the DT 40436 9565 2 advice advice NN 40436 9565 3 given give VBN 40436 9565 4 by by IN 40436 9565 5 the the DT 40436 9565 6 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 9565 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9565 8 to to IN 40436 9565 9 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9565 10 is be VBZ 40436 9565 11 the the DT 40436 9565 12 same same JJ 40436 9565 13 in in IN 40436 9565 14 principle principle NN 40436 9565 15 as as IN 40436 9565 16 the the DT 40436 9565 17 advice advice NN 40436 9565 18 given give VBN 40436 9565 19 by by IN 40436 9565 20 Kallikles Kallikles NNP 40436 9565 21 to to IN 40436 9565 22 the the DT 40436 9565 23 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9565 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9565 25 . . . 40436 9565 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9566 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9566 2 Side side NN 40436 9566 3 - - HYPH 40436 9566 4 note note NN 40436 9566 5 : : : 40436 9566 6 The the DT 40436 9566 7 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9566 8 people people NNS 40436 9566 9 recognise recognise VBP 40436 9566 10 a a DT 40436 9566 11 distinction distinction NN 40436 9566 12 between between IN 40436 9566 13 the the DT 40436 9566 14 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 9566 15 and and CC 40436 9566 16 the the DT 40436 9566 17 good good JJ 40436 9566 18 : : : 40436 9566 19 but but CC 40436 9566 20 not not RB 40436 9566 21 the the DT 40436 9566 22 same same JJ 40436 9566 23 as as IN 40436 9566 24 that that DT 40436 9566 25 which which WDT 40436 9566 26 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9566 27 conceived conceive VBD 40436 9566 28 . . . 40436 9566 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9567 1 Farther farther RB 40436 9567 2 , , , 40436 9567 3 neither neither DT 40436 9567 4 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9567 5 , , , 40436 9567 6 nor nor CC 40436 9567 7 any any DT 40436 9567 8 defender defender NN 40436 9567 9 of of IN 40436 9567 10 free free JJ 40436 9567 11 speech speech NN 40436 9567 12 , , , 40436 9567 13 would would MD 40436 9567 14 assent assent VB 40436 9567 15 to to IN 40436 9567 16 the the DT 40436 9567 17 definition definition NN 40436 9567 18 of of IN 40436 9567 19 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9567 20 -- -- : 40436 9567 21 That that IN 40436 9567 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9567 23 is be VBZ 40436 9567 24 a a DT 40436 9567 25 branch branch NN 40436 9567 26 of of IN 40436 9567 27 the the DT 40436 9567 28 art art NN 40436 9567 29 of of IN 40436 9567 30 flattery flattery NN 40436 9567 31 , , , 40436 9567 32 studying study VBG 40436 9567 33 the the DT 40436 9567 34 immediately immediately RB 40436 9567 35 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9567 36 , , , 40436 9567 37 and and CC 40436 9567 38 disregarding disregard VBG 40436 9567 39 the the DT 40436 9567 40 good good NN 40436 9567 41 . . . 40436 9568 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9568 2 129 129 CD 40436 9568 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9568 4 This this DT 40436 9568 5 indeed indeed RB 40436 9568 6 represents represent VBZ 40436 9568 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9568 8 's 's POS 40436 9568 9 own own JJ 40436 9568 10 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 9568 11 , , , 40436 9568 12 and and CC 40436 9568 13 was be VBD 40436 9568 14 true true JJ 40436 9568 15 in in IN 40436 9568 16 the the DT 40436 9568 17 sense sense NN 40436 9568 18 which which WDT 40436 9568 19 the the DT 40436 9568 20 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9568 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9568 22 assigns assign NNS 40436 9568 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9568 24 in in IN 40436 9568 25 the the DT 40436 9568 26 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9568 27 , , , 40436 9568 28 though though IN 40436 9568 29 not not RB 40436 9568 30 in in IN 40436 9568 31 the the DT 40436 9568 32 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 9568 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9568 34 to to IN 40436 9568 35 the the DT 40436 9568 36 words word NNS 40436 9568 37 _ _ NNP 40436 9568 38 good good JJ 40436 9568 39 _ _ NNP 40436 9568 40 and and CC 40436 9568 41 _ _ NNP 40436 9568 42 evil evil NN 40436 9568 43 _ _ NNP 40436 9568 44 . . . 40436 9569 1 But but CC 40436 9569 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9569 3 is be VBZ 40436 9569 4 not not RB 40436 9569 5 true true JJ 40436 9569 6 in in IN 40436 9569 7 the the DT 40436 9569 8 sense sense NN 40436 9569 9 which which WDT 40436 9569 10 the the DT 40436 9569 11 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9569 12 people people NNS 40436 9569 13 and and CC 40436 9569 14 the the DT 40436 9569 15 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9569 16 public public JJ 40436 9569 17 men man NNS 40436 9569 18 assigned assign VBN 40436 9569 19 to to IN 40436 9569 20 those those DT 40436 9569 21 words word NNS 40436 9569 22 . . . 40436 9570 1 Both both DT 40436 9570 2 the the DT 40436 9570 3 one one NN 40436 9570 4 and and CC 40436 9570 5 the the DT 40436 9570 6 other other JJ 40436 9570 7 used use VBD 40436 9570 8 the the DT 40436 9570 9 words word NNS 40436 9570 10 _ _ NNP 40436 9570 11 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9570 12 _ _ NNP 40436 9570 13 and and CC 40436 9570 14 _ _ NNP 40436 9570 15 good good JJ 40436 9570 16 _ _ NNP 40436 9570 17 as as RB 40436 9570 18 familiarly familiarly RB 40436 9570 19 as as IN 40436 9570 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9570 21 , , , 40436 9570 22 and and CC 40436 9570 23 had have VBD 40436 9570 24 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 9570 25 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 9570 26 to to IN 40436 9570 27 both both DT 40436 9570 28 of of IN 40436 9570 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9570 30 . . . 40436 9571 1 The the DT 40436 9571 2 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9571 3 and and CC 40436 9571 4 painful painful JJ 40436 9571 5 referred refer VBD 40436 9571 6 to to TO 40436 9571 7 present present JJ 40436 9571 8 and and CC 40436 9571 9 temporary temporary JJ 40436 9571 10 causes cause NNS 40436 9571 11 : : : 40436 9571 12 the the DT 40436 9571 13 Good Good NNP 40436 9571 14 and and CC 40436 9571 15 Evil Evil NNP 40436 9571 16 to to TO 40436 9571 17 prospective prospective JJ 40436 9571 18 causes cause NNS 40436 9571 19 and and CC 40436 9571 20 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9571 21 situations situation NNS 40436 9571 22 , , , 40436 9571 23 involving involve VBG 40436 9571 24 security security NN 40436 9571 25 against against IN 40436 9571 26 indefinite indefinite JJ 40436 9571 27 future future JJ 40436 9571 28 suffering suffering NN 40436 9571 29 , , , 40436 9571 30 combined combine VBN 40436 9571 31 with with IN 40436 9571 32 love love NN 40436 9571 33 of of IN 40436 9571 34 national national JJ 40436 9571 35 dignity dignity NN 40436 9571 36 and and CC 40436 9571 37 repugnance repugnance NN 40436 9571 38 to to IN 40436 9571 39 degradation degradation NN 40436 9571 40 , , , 40436 9571 41 as as RB 40436 9571 42 well well RB 40436 9571 43 as as IN 40436 9571 44 with with IN 40436 9571 45 a a DT 40436 9571 46 strong strong JJ 40436 9571 47 sense sense NN 40436 9571 48 of of IN 40436 9571 49 common common JJ 40436 9571 50 interests interest NNS 40436 9571 51 and and CC 40436 9571 52 common common JJ 40436 9571 53 obligations obligation NNS 40436 9571 54 to to IN 40436 9571 55 each each DT 40436 9571 56 other other JJ 40436 9571 57 . . . 40436 9572 1 To to TO 40436 9572 2 provide provide VB 40436 9572 3 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9572 4 for for IN 40436 9572 5 these these DT 40436 9572 6 common common JJ 40436 9572 7 patriotic patriotic JJ 40436 9572 8 feelings feeling NNS 40436 9572 9 -- -- : 40436 9572 10 to to TO 40436 9572 11 sustain sustain VB 40436 9572 12 the the DT 40436 9572 13 dignity dignity NN 40436 9572 14 of of IN 40436 9572 15 the the DT 40436 9572 16 city city NN 40436 9572 17 by by IN 40436 9572 18 effective effective JJ 40436 9572 19 and and CC 40436 9572 20 even even RB 40436 9572 21 imposing impose VBG 40436 9572 22 public public JJ 40436 9572 23 establishments establishment NNS 40436 9572 24 , , , 40436 9572 25 against against IN 40436 9572 26 foreign foreign JJ 40436 9572 27 enemies enemy NNS 40436 9572 28 -- -- : 40436 9572 29 to to TO 40436 9572 30 protect protect VB 40436 9572 31 the the DT 40436 9572 32 individual individual JJ 40436 9572 33 rights right NNS 40436 9572 34 of of IN 40436 9572 35 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9572 36 by by IN 40436 9572 37 an an DT 40436 9572 38 equitable equitable JJ 40436 9572 39 administration administration NN 40436 9572 40 of of IN 40436 9572 41 justice justice NN 40436 9572 42 -- -- : 40436 9572 43 counted count VBN 40436 9572 44 in in IN 40436 9572 45 the the DT 40436 9572 46 view view NN 40436 9572 47 of of IN 40436 9572 48 the the DT 40436 9572 49 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 9572 50 as as IN 40436 9572 51 objects object NNS 40436 9572 52 _ _ NNP 40436 9572 53 good good JJ 40436 9572 54 _ _ NNP 40436 9572 55 and and CC 40436 9572 56 _ _ NNP 40436 9572 57 honourable honourable JJ 40436 9572 58 _ _ NNP 40436 9572 59 : : : 40436 9572 60 while while IN 40436 9572 61 the the DT 40436 9572 62 efforts effort NNS 40436 9572 63 and and CC 40436 9572 64 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 40436 9572 65 necessary necessary JJ 40436 9572 66 for for IN 40436 9572 67 these these DT 40436 9572 68 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9572 69 ends end NNS 40436 9572 70 , , , 40436 9572 71 were be VBD 40436 9572 72 , , , 40436 9572 73 so so RB 40436 9572 74 far far RB 40436 9572 75 as as IN 40436 9572 76 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9572 77 went go VBD 40436 9572 78 , , , 40436 9572 79 a a DT 40436 9572 80 renunciation renunciation NN 40436 9572 81 of of IN 40436 9572 82 what what WP 40436 9572 83 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9572 84 would would MD 40436 9572 85 call call VB 40436 9572 86 the the DT 40436 9572 87 _ _ NNP 40436 9572 88 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9572 89 _ _ NNP 40436 9572 90 . . . 40436 9573 1 When when WRB 40436 9573 2 , , , 40436 9573 3 at at IN 40436 9573 4 the the DT 40436 9573 5 beginning beginning NN 40436 9573 6 of of IN 40436 9573 7 the the DT 40436 9573 8 Peloponnesian peloponnesian JJ 40436 9573 9 war war NN 40436 9573 10 , , , 40436 9573 11 the the DT 40436 9573 12 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 9573 13 , , , 40436 9573 14 acting act VBG 40436 9573 15 on on IN 40436 9573 16 the the DT 40436 9573 17 advice advice NN 40436 9573 18 of of IN 40436 9573 19 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9573 20 , , , 40436 9573 21 allowed allow VBD 40436 9573 22 all all DT 40436 9573 23 Attica Attica NNP 40436 9573 24 to to TO 40436 9573 25 be be VB 40436 9573 26 ravaged ravage VBN 40436 9573 27 , , , 40436 9573 28 and and CC 40436 9573 29 submitted submit VBN 40436 9573 30 to to IN 40436 9573 31 the the DT 40436 9573 32 distress distress NN 40436 9573 33 of of IN 40436 9573 34 cooping coope VBG 40436 9573 35 the the DT 40436 9573 36 whole whole JJ 40436 9573 37 population population NN 40436 9573 38 within within IN 40436 9573 39 the the DT 40436 9573 40 long long JJ 40436 9573 41 walls wall NNS 40436 9573 42 , , , 40436 9573 43 rather rather RB 40436 9573 44 than than IN 40436 9573 45 purchase purchase VB 40436 9573 46 peace peace NN 40436 9573 47 by by IN 40436 9573 48 abnegating abnegate VBG 40436 9573 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9573 50 Hellenic hellenic JJ 40436 9573 51 dignity dignity NN 40436 9573 52 , , , 40436 9573 53 independence independence NN 40436 9573 54 , , , 40436 9573 55 and and CC 40436 9573 56 security security NN 40436 9573 57 -- -- : 40436 9573 58 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9573 59 not not RB 40436 9573 60 only only RB 40436 9573 61 renounced renounce VBD 40436 9573 62 much much RB 40436 9573 63 that that WDT 40436 9573 64 was be VBD 40436 9573 65 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9573 66 , , , 40436 9573 67 but but CC 40436 9573 68 endured endure VBD 40436 9573 69 great great JJ 40436 9573 70 immediate immediate JJ 40436 9573 71 distress distress NN 40436 9573 72 , , , 40436 9573 73 for for IN 40436 9573 74 the the DT 40436 9573 75 sake sake NN 40436 9573 76 of of IN 40436 9573 77 what what WP 40436 9573 78 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9573 79 regarded regard VBD 40436 9573 80 as as IN 40436 9573 81 a a DT 40436 9573 82 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9573 83 good good NN 40436 9573 84 . . . 40436 9574 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9574 2 130 130 CD 40436 9574 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9574 4 Eighty eighty CD 40436 9574 5 years year NNS 40436 9574 6 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 9574 7 , , , 40436 9574 8 when when WRB 40436 9574 9 Demosthenes demosthene NNS 40436 9574 10 pointed point VBD 40436 9574 11 out out RP 40436 9574 12 to to IN 40436 9574 13 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9574 14 the the DT 40436 9574 15 growing grow VBG 40436 9574 16 power power NN 40436 9574 17 and and CC 40436 9574 18 encroachments encroachment NNS 40436 9574 19 of of IN 40436 9574 20 the the DT 40436 9574 21 Macedonian Macedonian NNP 40436 9574 22 Philip Philip NNP 40436 9574 23 , , , 40436 9574 24 and and CC 40436 9574 25 exhorted exhort VBD 40436 9574 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9574 27 to to IN 40436 9574 28 the the DT 40436 9574 29 efforts effort NNS 40436 9574 30 requisite requisite JJ 40436 9574 31 for for IN 40436 9574 32 keeping keep VBG 40436 9574 33 back back RP 40436 9574 34 that that DT 40436 9574 35 formidable formidable JJ 40436 9574 36 enemy enemy NN 40436 9574 37 , , , 40436 9574 38 while while IN 40436 9574 39 there there EX 40436 9574 40 was be VBD 40436 9574 41 yet yet CC 40436 9574 42 time time NN 40436 9574 43 -- -- : 40436 9574 44 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9574 45 could could MD 40436 9574 46 not not RB 40436 9574 47 be be VB 40436 9574 48 wound wind VBN 40436 9574 49 up up IN 40436 9574 50 to to IN 40436 9574 51 the the DT 40436 9574 52 pitch pitch NN 40436 9574 53 requisite requisite JJ 40436 9574 54 for for IN 40436 9574 55 affronting affront VBG 40436 9574 56 so so RB 40436 9574 57 serious serious JJ 40436 9574 58 an an DT 40436 9574 59 amount amount NN 40436 9574 60 of of IN 40436 9574 61 danger danger NN 40436 9574 62 and and CC 40436 9574 63 suffering suffering NN 40436 9574 64 . . . 40436 9575 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9575 2 had have VBD 40436 9575 3 lost lose VBN 40436 9575 4 that that DT 40436 9575 5 sense sense NN 40436 9575 6 of of IN 40436 9575 7 Hellenic hellenic JJ 40436 9575 8 dignity dignity NN 40436 9575 9 , , , 40436 9575 10 and and CC 40436 9575 11 that that DT 40436 9575 12 association association NN 40436 9575 13 of of IN 40436 9575 14 self self NN 40436 9575 15 - - HYPH 40436 9575 16 respect respect NN 40436 9575 17 with with IN 40436 9575 18 active active JJ 40436 9575 19 personal personal JJ 40436 9575 20 soldiership soldiership NN 40436 9575 21 and and CC 40436 9575 22 sailorship sailorship NN 40436 9575 23 , , , 40436 9575 24 which which WDT 40436 9575 25 rendered render VBD 40436 9575 26 submission submission NN 40436 9575 27 to to IN 40436 9575 28 an an DT 40436 9575 29 enemy enemy NN 40436 9575 30 the the DT 40436 9575 31 most most RBS 40436 9575 32 intolerable intolerable JJ 40436 9575 33 of of IN 40436 9575 34 all all DT 40436 9575 35 pains pain NNS 40436 9575 36 , , , 40436 9575 37 at at IN 40436 9575 38 the the DT 40436 9575 39 time time NN 40436 9575 40 when when WRB 40436 9575 41 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9575 42 had have VBD 40436 9575 43 addressed address VBN 40436 9575 44 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9575 45 . . . 40436 9576 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9576 2 shut shut VBD 40436 9576 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9576 4 eyes eye NNS 40436 9576 5 to to IN 40436 9576 6 an an DT 40436 9576 7 impending impending JJ 40436 9576 8 danger danger NN 40436 9576 9 , , , 40436 9576 10 which which WDT 40436 9576 11 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 9576 12 proved prove VBD 40436 9576 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9576 14 ruin ruin NN 40436 9576 15 . . . 40436 9577 1 On on IN 40436 9577 2 both both PDT 40436 9577 3 these these DT 40436 9577 4 occasions occasion NNS 40436 9577 5 , , , 40436 9577 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9577 7 have have VBP 40436 9577 8 the the DT 40436 9577 9 _ _ NNP 40436 9577 10 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9577 11 _ _ NNP 40436 9577 12 and and CC 40436 9577 13 the the DT 40436 9577 14 _ _ NNP 40436 9577 15 good good JJ 40436 9577 16 _ _ NNP 40436 9577 17 brought bring VBD 40436 9577 18 into into IN 40436 9577 19 contrast contrast NN 40436 9577 20 in in IN 40436 9577 21 the the DT 40436 9577 22 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9577 23 mind mind NN 40436 9577 24 ; ; : 40436 9577 25 in in IN 40436 9577 26 both both DT 40436 9577 27 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9577 28 have have VBP 40436 9577 29 the the DT 40436 9577 30 two two CD 40436 9577 31 most most RBS 40436 9577 32 eminent eminent JJ 40436 9577 33 orators orator NNS 40436 9577 34 of of IN 40436 9577 35 Grecian grecian JJ 40436 9577 36 antiquity antiquity NN 40436 9577 37 enforcing enforce VBG 40436 9577 38 the the DT 40436 9577 39 _ _ NNP 40436 9577 40 good good JJ 40436 9577 41 _ _ NNP 40436 9577 42 in in IN 40436 9577 43 opposition opposition NN 40436 9577 44 to to IN 40436 9577 45 the the DT 40436 9577 46 _ _ NNP 40436 9577 47 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9577 48 _ _ NNP 40436 9577 49 : : : 40436 9577 50 the the DT 40436 9577 51 first first JJ 40436 9577 52 successfully successfully RB 40436 9577 53 , , , 40436 9577 54 the the DT 40436 9577 55 last last JJ 40436 9577 56 vainly vainly RB 40436 9577 57 , , , 40436 9577 58 in in IN 40436 9577 59 opposition opposition NN 40436 9577 60 to to IN 40436 9577 61 other other JJ 40436 9577 62 orators orator NNS 40436 9577 63 . . . 40436 9578 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9578 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9578 3 129 129 CD 40436 9578 4 : : : 40436 9578 5 The the DT 40436 9578 6 reply reply NN 40436 9578 7 composed compose VBN 40436 9578 8 by by IN 40436 9578 9 the the DT 40436 9578 10 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 9578 11 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 9578 12 to to IN 40436 9578 13 the the DT 40436 9578 14 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9578 15 of of IN 40436 9578 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9578 17 is be VBZ 40436 9578 18 well well RB 40436 9578 19 deserving deserve VBG 40436 9578 20 of of IN 40436 9578 21 perusal perusal NN 40436 9578 22 , , , 40436 9578 23 though though RB 40436 9578 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9578 25 like like IN 40436 9578 26 all all DT 40436 9578 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9578 28 compositions composition NNS 40436 9578 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9578 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9578 31 is be VBZ 40436 9578 32 very very RB 40436 9578 33 prolix prolix JJ 40436 9578 34 and and CC 40436 9578 35 wordy wordy JJ 40436 9578 36 . . . 40436 9579 1 See see VB 40436 9579 2 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 9579 3 , , , 40436 9579 4 Orationes Orationes NNPS 40436 9579 5 xlv xlv NN 40436 9579 6 . . . 40436 9580 1 and and CC 40436 9580 2 xlvi.--[Greek xlvi.--[Greek NNP 40436 9580 3 : : : 40436 9580 4 Perei\ Perei\ NNP 40436 9580 5 R(êtorikê R(êtorikê NNP 40436 9580 6 = = SYM 40436 9580 7 s s NNP 40436 9580 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9580 9 , , , 40436 9580 10 and and CC 40436 9580 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9580 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9580 13 : : : 40436 9580 14 U(pe\r U(pe\r NNP 40436 9580 15 tô tô NNP 40436 9580 16 = = NFP 40436 9580 17 n n CC 40436 9580 18 Tetta Tetta NNP 40436 9580 19 / / SYM 40436 9580 20 rôn rôn NN 40436 9580 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9580 22 . . . 40436 9581 1 In in IN 40436 9581 2 the the DT 40436 9581 3 last last JJ 40436 9581 4 of of IN 40436 9581 5 the the DT 40436 9581 6 two two CD 40436 9581 7 orations oration NNS 40436 9581 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9581 9 defends defend VBZ 40436 9581 10 the the DT 40436 9581 11 four four CD 40436 9581 12 eminent eminent JJ 40436 9581 13 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 9581 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9581 15 Miltiades Miltiades NNPS 40436 9581 16 , , , 40436 9581 17 Themistoklês Themistoklês NNPS 40436 9581 18 , , , 40436 9581 19 Periklês Periklês NNP 40436 9581 20 , , , 40436 9581 21 Kimon Kimon NNP 40436 9581 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9581 23 whom whom WP 40436 9581 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9581 25 disparages disparage VBZ 40436 9581 26 in in IN 40436 9581 27 the the DT 40436 9581 28 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9581 29 . . . 40436 9582 1 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 9582 2 insists insist VBZ 40436 9582 3 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 9582 4 on on IN 40436 9582 5 the the DT 40436 9582 6 partial partial JJ 40436 9582 7 and and CC 40436 9582 8 narrow narrow JJ 40436 9582 9 view view NN 40436 9582 10 here here RB 40436 9582 11 taken take VBN 40436 9582 12 by by IN 40436 9582 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9582 14 of of IN 40436 9582 15 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 9582 16 , , , 40436 9582 17 as as IN 40436 9582 18 a a DT 40436 9582 19 working work VBG 40436 9582 20 force force NN 40436 9582 21 both both CC 40436 9582 22 for for IN 40436 9582 23 establishing establish VBG 40436 9582 24 laws law NNS 40436 9582 25 and and CC 40436 9582 26 carrying carry VBG 40436 9582 27 on on IN 40436 9582 28 government government NN 40436 9582 29 . . . 40436 9583 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9583 2 remarks remark VBZ 40436 9583 3 truly truly RB 40436 9583 4 that that IN 40436 9583 5 there there EX 40436 9583 6 are be VBP 40436 9583 7 only only RB 40436 9583 8 two two CD 40436 9583 9 forces force NNS 40436 9583 10 between between IN 40436 9583 11 which which WDT 40436 9583 12 the the DT 40436 9583 13 choice choice NN 40436 9583 14 must must MD 40436 9583 15 be be VB 40436 9583 16 made make VBN 40436 9583 17 , , , 40436 9583 18 intimidation intimidation NN 40436 9583 19 and and CC 40436 9583 20 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 9583 21 : : : 40436 9583 22 that that IN 40436 9583 23 the the DT 40436 9583 24 substitution substitution NN 40436 9583 25 of of IN 40436 9583 26 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 9583 27 in in IN 40436 9583 28 place place NN 40436 9583 29 of of IN 40436 9583 30 force force NN 40436 9583 31 is be VBZ 40436 9583 32 the the DT 40436 9583 33 great great JJ 40436 9583 34 improvement improvement NN 40436 9583 35 which which WDT 40436 9583 36 has have VBZ 40436 9583 37 made make VBN 40436 9583 38 public public JJ 40436 9583 39 and and CC 40436 9583 40 private private JJ 40436 9583 41 life life NN 40436 9583 42 worth worth JJ 40436 9583 43 having have VBG 40436 9583 44 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9583 45 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9583 46 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9583 47 : : : 40436 9583 48 mo mo NNP 40436 9583 49 / / SYM 40436 9583 50 nê nê NN 40436 9583 51 biôto\n biôto\n ADD 40436 9583 52 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 9583 53 = = SYM 40436 9583 54 n n NNP 40436 9583 55 pepoi pepoi NNP 40436 9583 56 / / , 40436 9583 57 êke êke NNP 40436 9583 58 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9583 59 bi bi NNP 40436 9583 60 / / SYM 40436 9583 61 on on RB 40436 9583 62 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9583 63 , , , 40436 9583 64 Orat Orat NNP 40436 9583 65 . . . 40436 9584 1 xlv xlv NNP 40436 9584 2 . . . 40436 9585 1 p. p. NN 40436 9585 2 64 64 CD 40436 9585 3 , , , 40436 9585 4 Dindorf Dindorf NNP 40436 9585 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9585 6 ; ; : 40436 9585 7 that that IN 40436 9585 8 neither neither DT 40436 9585 9 laws law NNS 40436 9585 10 could could MD 40436 9585 11 be be VB 40436 9585 12 discussed discuss VBN 40436 9585 13 and and CC 40436 9585 14 passed pass VBN 40436 9585 15 , , , 40436 9585 16 nor nor CC 40436 9585 17 judicial judicial JJ 40436 9585 18 trial trial NN 40436 9585 19 held hold VBN 40436 9585 20 under under IN 40436 9585 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9585 22 , , , 40436 9585 23 without without IN 40436 9585 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9585 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9585 26 : : : 40436 9585 27 r(êtorikê\ r(êtorikê\ ADD 40436 9585 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9585 29 as as IN 40436 9585 30 the the DT 40436 9585 31 engine engine NN 40436 9585 32 of of IN 40436 9585 33 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 9585 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9585 35 pp pp NNP 40436 9585 36 . . . 40436 9586 1 66 66 CD 40436 9586 2 - - HYPH 40436 9586 3 67 67 CD 40436 9586 4 - - HYPH 40436 9586 5 136 136 CD 40436 9586 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9586 7 ; ; : 40436 9586 8 that that IN 40436 9586 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9586 10 in in IN 40436 9586 11 attacking attack VBG 40436 9586 12 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9586 13 had have VBD 40436 9586 14 no no DT 40436 9586 15 right right NN 40436 9586 16 to to TO 40436 9586 17 single single VB 40436 9586 18 out out RP 40436 9586 19 despots despot NNS 40436 9586 20 and and CC 40436 9586 21 violent violent JJ 40436 9586 22 conspirators conspirator NNS 40436 9586 23 as as IN 40436 9586 24 illustrations illustration NNS 40436 9586 25 of of IN 40436 9586 26 it--[Greek it--[greek JJ 40436 9586 27 : : : 40436 9586 28 ei)=t ei)=t : 40436 9586 29 ' ' '' 40436 9586 30 e)le e)le NNP 40436 9586 31 / / SYM 40436 9586 32 gchein gchein NNP 40436 9586 33 me\n me\n NNP 40436 9586 34 bou bou NN 40436 9586 35 / / SYM 40436 9586 36 letai letai JJ 40436 9586 37 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9586 38 r(êtorikê r(êtorikê NNP 40436 9586 39 / / SYM 40436 9586 40 n n CC 40436 9586 41 , , , 40436 9586 42 katêgorei= katêgorei= NNP 40436 9586 43 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9586 44 tô tô NNP 40436 9586 45 = = SYM 40436 9586 46 n n CC 40436 9586 47 tura tura NNP 40436 9586 48 / / SYM 40436 9586 49 nnôn nnôn NNP 40436 9586 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9586 51 dunastô dunastô NNP 40436 9586 52 = = SYM 40436 9586 53 n n NNP 40436 9586 54 , , , 40436 9586 55 _ _ NNP 40436 9586 56 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 9586 57 a)/mikta a)/mikta NNP 40436 9586 58 mignu mignu NNP 40436 9586 59 / / SYM 40436 9586 60 s s NNPS 40436 9586 61 -- -- : 40436 9586 62 ti ti NNP 40436 9586 63 / / SYM 40436 9586 64 s s NNPS 40436 9586 65 _ _ NNP 40436 9586 66 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9586 67 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 9586 68 oi)=den oi)=den CD 40436 9586 69 , , , 40436 9586 70 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 9586 71 r(êtorikê\ r(êtorikê\ NNP 40436 9586 72 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9586 73 turanni\s turanni\s NNP 40436 9586 74 tosou tosou NNP 40436 9586 75 = = SYM 40436 9586 76 ton ton NN 40436 9586 77 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 9586 78 / / SYM 40436 9586 79 lôn lôn NNP 40436 9586 80 kechôri kechôri NNP 40436 9586 81 / / SYM 40436 9586 82 stai stai NNP 40436 9586 83 , , , 40436 9586 84 o(/son o(/son NNP 40436 9586 85 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9586 86 pei pei NNP 40436 9586 87 / / SYM 40436 9586 88 thein thein NNP 40436 9586 89 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9586 90 bia bia NNP 40436 9586 91 / / SYM 40436 9586 92 zesthai zesthai NNP 40436 9586 93 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9586 94 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9586 95 p. p. NN 40436 9586 96 99 99 CD 40436 9586 97 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9586 98 . . . 40436 9587 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9587 2 impugns impugn VBZ 40436 9587 3 the the DT 40436 9587 4 distinction distinction NN 40436 9587 5 which which WDT 40436 9587 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9587 7 has have VBZ 40436 9587 8 drawn draw VBN 40436 9587 9 between between IN 40436 9587 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9587 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9587 12 : : : 40436 9587 13 i)atrikê/ i)atrikê/ CD 40436 9587 14 , , , 40436 9587 15 gumnastikê/ gumnastikê/ NNP 40436 9587 16 , , , 40436 9587 17 kubernêtikê/ kubernêtikê/ NN 40436 9587 18 , , , 40436 9587 19 nomothetikê/ nomothetikê/ NN 40436 9587 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9587 21 , , , 40436 9587 22 & & CC 40436 9587 23 c. c. NNP 40436 9587 24 , , , 40436 9587 25 on on IN 40436 9587 26 the the DT 40436 9587 27 one one CD 40436 9587 28 side side NN 40436 9587 29 , , , 40436 9587 30 which which WDT 40436 9587 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9587 32 calls call VBZ 40436 9587 33 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9587 34 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9587 35 : : : 40436 9587 36 te te NNP 40436 9587 37 / / SYM 40436 9587 38 chnai chnai NNP 40436 9587 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9587 40 , , , 40436 9587 41 arts art NNS 40436 9587 42 or or CC 40436 9587 43 sciences science NNS 40436 9587 44 , , , 40436 9587 45 and and CC 40436 9587 46 affirms affirm NNS 40436 9587 47 to to TO 40436 9587 48 rest rest VB 40436 9587 49 on on IN 40436 9587 50 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9587 51 principles principle NNS 40436 9587 52 -- -- : 40436 9587 53 and and CC 40436 9587 54 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9587 55 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9587 56 : : : 40436 9587 57 r(êtorikê/ r(êtorikê/ NNP 40436 9587 58 , , , 40436 9587 59 mageirikê/ mageirikê/ NN 40436 9587 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9587 61 , , , 40436 9587 62 & & CC 40436 9587 63 c. c. NNP 40436 9587 64 , , , 40436 9587 65 on on IN 40436 9587 66 the the DT 40436 9587 67 other other JJ 40436 9587 68 side side NN 40436 9587 69 , , , 40436 9587 70 which which WDT 40436 9587 71 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9587 72 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 9587 73 to to TO 40436 9587 74 be be VB 40436 9587 75 only only RB 40436 9587 76 guess guess VB 40436 9587 77 work work NN 40436 9587 78 or or CC 40436 9587 79 groping grope VBG 40436 9587 80 , , , 40436 9587 81 resting rest VBG 40436 9587 82 on on IN 40436 9587 83 empirical empirical JJ 40436 9587 84 analogies analogy NNS 40436 9587 85 . . . 40436 9588 1 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 9588 2 says say VBZ 40436 9588 3 that that IN 40436 9588 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9588 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9588 6 : : : 40436 9588 7 i)atrikê\ i)atrikê\ NN 40436 9588 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9588 9 and and CC 40436 9588 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9588 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9588 12 : : : 40436 9588 13 r(êtorikê\ r(êtorikê\ NNS 40436 9588 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9588 15 are be VBP 40436 9588 16 in in IN 40436 9588 17 this this DT 40436 9588 18 respect respect NN 40436 9588 19 both both DT 40436 9588 20 on on IN 40436 9588 21 a a DT 40436 9588 22 par par NN 40436 9588 23 ; ; : 40436 9588 24 that that IN 40436 9588 25 both both DT 40436 9588 26 are be VBP 40436 9588 27 partly partly RB 40436 9588 28 reducible reducible JJ 40436 9588 29 to to TO 40436 9588 30 rule rule VB 40436 9588 31 , , , 40436 9588 32 but but CC 40436 9588 33 partly partly RB 40436 9588 34 also also RB 40436 9588 35 driven drive VBN 40436 9588 36 by by IN 40436 9588 37 necessity necessity NN 40436 9588 38 to to IN 40436 9588 39 conjectures conjecture NNS 40436 9588 40 and and CC 40436 9588 41 analogies analogy NNS 40436 9588 42 , , , 40436 9588 43 and and CC 40436 9588 44 the the DT 40436 9588 45 physician physician NN 40436 9588 46 not not RB 40436 9588 47 less less JJR 40436 9588 48 than than IN 40436 9588 49 the the DT 40436 9588 50 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 9588 51 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9588 52 pp pp NNP 40436 9588 53 . . . 40436 9589 1 45 45 CD 40436 9589 2 - - SYM 40436 9589 3 48 48 CD 40436 9589 4 - - HYPH 40436 9589 5 49 49 CD 40436 9589 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9589 7 ; ; : 40436 9589 8 which which WDT 40436 9589 9 the the DT 40436 9589 10 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9589 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9589 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9589 13 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 9589 14 in in IN 40436 9589 15 another another DT 40436 9589 16 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9589 17 , , , 40436 9589 18 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 9589 19 , , , 40436 9589 20 p. p. NN 40436 9589 21 56 56 CD 40436 9589 22 A. a. NN 40436 9590 1 The the DT 40436 9590 2 most most RBS 40436 9590 3 curious curious JJ 40436 9590 4 part part NN 40436 9590 5 of of IN 40436 9590 6 the the DT 40436 9590 7 argument argument NN 40436 9590 8 of of IN 40436 9590 9 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 9590 10 is be VBZ 40436 9590 11 where where WRB 40436 9590 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9590 13 disputes dispute VBZ 40436 9590 14 the the DT 40436 9590 15 prerogative prerogative NN 40436 9590 16 which which WDT 40436 9590 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9590 18 had have VBD 40436 9590 19 claimed claim VBN 40436 9590 20 for for IN 40436 9590 21 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9590 22 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9590 23 : : : 40436 9590 24 i)atrikê/ i)atrikê/ CD 40436 9590 25 , , , 40436 9590 26 gumnastikê/ gumnastikê/ LS 40436 9590 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9590 28 & & CC 40436 9590 29 c. c. NNP 40436 9590 30 , , , 40436 9590 31 on on IN 40436 9590 32 the the DT 40436 9590 33 ground ground NN 40436 9590 34 of of IN 40436 9590 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9590 36 being be VBG 40436 9590 37 arts art NNS 40436 9590 38 or or CC 40436 9590 39 reducible reducible JJ 40436 9590 40 to to IN 40436 9590 41 rules rule NNS 40436 9590 42 . . . 40436 9591 1 The the DT 40436 9591 2 effects effect NNS 40436 9591 3 of of IN 40436 9591 4 human human JJ 40436 9591 5 art art NN 40436 9591 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9591 7 says say VBZ 40436 9591 8 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 9591 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9591 10 are be VBP 40436 9591 11 much much RB 40436 9591 12 inferior inferior JJ 40436 9591 13 to to IN 40436 9591 14 those those DT 40436 9591 15 of of IN 40436 9591 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9591 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9591 18 : : : 40436 9591 19 thei thei NNP 40436 9591 20 / / , 40436 9591 21 a a DT 40436 9591 22 moi moi NNP 40436 9591 23 = = SYM 40436 9591 24 ra ra NN 40436 9591 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9591 26 or or CC 40436 9591 27 divine divine JJ 40436 9591 28 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 9591 29 . . . 40436 9592 1 Many many JJ 40436 9592 2 patients patient NNS 40436 9592 3 are be VBP 40436 9592 4 cured cure VBN 40436 9592 5 of of IN 40436 9592 6 disease disease NN 40436 9592 7 by by IN 40436 9592 8 human human JJ 40436 9592 9 art art NN 40436 9592 10 ; ; : 40436 9592 11 but but CC 40436 9592 12 many many JJ 40436 9592 13 more more JJR 40436 9592 14 are be VBP 40436 9592 15 cured cure VBN 40436 9592 16 by by IN 40436 9592 17 the the DT 40436 9592 18 responses response NNS 40436 9592 19 and and CC 40436 9592 20 directions direction NNS 40436 9592 21 of of IN 40436 9592 22 the the DT 40436 9592 23 Delphian delphian JJ 40436 9592 24 oracle oracle NN 40436 9592 25 , , , 40436 9592 26 by by IN 40436 9592 27 the the DT 40436 9592 28 suggestion suggestion NN 40436 9592 29 of of IN 40436 9592 30 dreams dream NNS 40436 9592 31 , , , 40436 9592 32 and and CC 40436 9592 33 by by IN 40436 9592 34 other other JJ 40436 9592 35 varieties variety NNS 40436 9592 36 of of IN 40436 9592 37 the the DT 40436 9592 38 divine divine JJ 40436 9592 39 prompting prompting NN 40436 9592 40 , , , 40436 9592 41 delivered deliver VBN 40436 9592 42 through through IN 40436 9592 43 the the DT 40436 9592 44 Pythian pythian JJ 40436 9592 45 priestess priestess NN 40436 9592 46 , , , 40436 9592 47 a a DT 40436 9592 48 woman woman NN 40436 9592 49 altogether altogether RB 40436 9592 50 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 9592 51 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9592 52 p. p. NN 40436 9592 53 11 11 CD 40436 9592 54 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9592 55 . . . 40436 9593 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9593 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9593 3 : : : 40436 9593 4 kai kai NNP 40436 9593 5 / / SYM 40436 9593 6 toi toi NNP 40436 9593 7 mikra\ mikra\ IN 40436 9593 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 9593 9 ê ê NNP 40436 9593 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9593 11 pa pa NNP 40436 9593 12 / / SYM 40436 9593 13 ntas ntas NNP 40436 9593 14 ei)dui ei)dui NNP 40436 9593 15 = = SYM 40436 9593 16 a a DT 40436 9593 17 lo lo NNP 40436 9593 18 / / SYM 40436 9593 19 gous gous JJ 40436 9593 20 i)atrikê\ i)atrikê\ NNP 40436 9593 21 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 9593 22 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 9593 23 e)k e)k NNP 40436 9593 24 Delphô Delphô NNP 40436 9593 25 = = SYM 40436 9593 26 n n CC 40436 9593 27 du du NNP 40436 9593 28 / / SYM 40436 9593 29 natai natai NNP 40436 9593 30 lu lu NNP 40436 9593 31 / / SYM 40436 9593 32 seis seis NNP 40436 9593 33 , , , 40436 9593 34 o(/sai o(/sai NNP 40436 9593 35 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9593 36 i)di i)di NNP 40436 9593 37 / / SYM 40436 9593 38 a| a| NN 40436 9593 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9593 40 koinê=| koinê=| NNP 40436 9593 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9593 42 no no NNP 40436 9593 43 / / SYM 40436 9593 44 sôn sôn NNP 40436 9593 45 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9593 46 pathêma pathêma NNP 40436 9593 47 / / SYM 40436 9593 48 tôn tôn NNP 40436 9593 49 a(pantôn a(pantôn NNP 40436 9593 50 a)nthrôpi a)nthrôpi , 40436 9593 51 / / SYM 40436 9593 52 nôn nôn NNP 40436 9593 53 e)pha e)pha NNP 40436 9593 54 / / SYM 40436 9593 55 nthêsan nthêsan NNP 40436 9593 56 . . . 40436 9593 57 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9594 1 Patients patient NNS 40436 9594 2 who who WP 40436 9594 3 are be VBP 40436 9594 4 cured cure VBN 40436 9594 5 in in IN 40436 9594 6 this this DT 40436 9594 7 way way NN 40436 9594 8 by by IN 40436 9594 9 the the DT 40436 9594 10 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 9594 11 without without IN 40436 9594 12 medical medical JJ 40436 9594 13 art art NN 40436 9594 14 , , , 40436 9594 15 acquire acquire VB 40436 9594 16 a a DT 40436 9594 17 natural natural JJ 40436 9594 18 impulse impulse NN 40436 9594 19 which which WDT 40436 9594 20 leads lead VBZ 40436 9594 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9594 22 to to IN 40436 9594 23 the the DT 40436 9594 24 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 9594 25 remedy--[Greek remedy--[greek CD 40436 9594 26 : : : 40436 9594 27 e)pithumi e)pithumi CD 40436 9594 28 / / SYM 40436 9594 29 a a DT 40436 9594 30 au)tou\s au)tou\s NN 40436 9594 31 a)/gei a)/gei RB 40436 9594 32 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 9594 33 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9594 34 o)/nêson o)/nêson NN 40436 9594 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9594 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9594 37 p. p. NN 40436 9594 38 20 20 CD 40436 9594 39 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9594 40 . . . 40436 9595 1 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 9595 2 says say VBZ 40436 9595 3 that that IN 40436 9595 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9595 5 can can MD 40436 9595 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9595 7 depose depose VB 40436 9595 8 -- -- : 40436 9595 9 from from IN 40436 9595 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9595 11 own own JJ 40436 9595 12 personal personal JJ 40436 9595 13 experience experience NN 40436 9595 14 as as IN 40436 9595 15 a a DT 40436 9595 16 sick sick JJ 40436 9595 17 man man NN 40436 9595 18 seeking seek VBG 40436 9595 19 cure cure NN 40436 9595 20 , , , 40436 9595 21 and and CC 40436 9595 22 from from IN 40436 9595 23 personal personal JJ 40436 9595 24 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9595 25 of of IN 40436 9595 26 many many JJ 40436 9595 27 other other JJ 40436 9595 28 such such JJ 40436 9595 29 -- -- : 40436 9595 30 how how WRB 40436 9595 31 much much RB 40436 9595 32 more more RBR 40436 9595 33 efficacious efficacious JJ 40436 9595 34 in in IN 40436 9595 35 healing healing NN 40436 9595 36 is be VBZ 40436 9595 37 aid aid NN 40436 9595 38 from from IN 40436 9595 39 the the DT 40436 9595 40 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 9595 41 , , , 40436 9595 42 given give VBN 40436 9595 43 in in IN 40436 9595 44 dreams dream NNS 40436 9595 45 and and CC 40436 9595 46 other other JJ 40436 9595 47 ways way NNS 40436 9595 48 , , , 40436 9595 49 than than IN 40436 9595 50 advice advice NN 40436 9595 51 from from IN 40436 9595 52 physicians physician NNS 40436 9595 53 ; ; : 40436 9595 54 who who WP 40436 9595 55 might may MD 40436 9595 56 well well RB 40436 9595 57 shudder shudder VB 40436 9595 58 when when WRB 40436 9595 59 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9595 60 heard hear VBD 40436 9595 61 the the DT 40436 9595 62 stories story NNS 40436 9595 63 which which WDT 40436 9595 64 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9595 65 could could MD 40436 9595 66 tell tell VB 40436 9595 67 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9595 68 pp pp NNP 40436 9595 69 . . . 40436 9596 1 21 21 CD 40436 9596 2 - - SYM 40436 9596 3 22 22 CD 40436 9596 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9596 5 . . . 40436 9597 1 To to IN 40436 9597 2 undervalue undervalue JJ 40436 9597 3 science science NN 40436 9597 4 and and CC 40436 9597 5 art art NN 40436 9597 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9597 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9597 8 says say VBZ 40436 9597 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9597 10 is be VBZ 40436 9597 11 the the DT 40436 9597 12 principle principle NN 40436 9597 13 from from IN 40436 9597 14 which which WDT 40436 9597 15 men man NNS 40436 9597 16 start start VBP 40436 9597 17 , , , 40436 9597 18 when when WRB 40436 9597 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9597 20 flee flee VBP 40436 9597 21 to to IN 40436 9597 22 the the DT 40436 9597 23 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 9597 24 for for IN 40436 9597 25 help--[Greek help--[greek CD 40436 9597 26 : : : 40436 9597 27 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9597 28 kataphugei kataphugei NN 40436 9597 29 = = NNS 40436 9597 30 n n NN 40436 9597 31 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 9597 32 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 9597 33 theou\s theou\s CD 40436 9597 34 schedo\n schedo\n NNP 40436 9597 35 a)rchê/ a)rchê/ NNS 40436 9597 36 , , , 40436 9597 37 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9597 38 tê tê NNP 40436 9597 39 = = SYM 40436 9597 40 s s NNP 40436 9597 41 te te NNP 40436 9597 42 / / SYM 40436 9597 43 chnês chnês NNP 40436 9597 44 u(peridei u(peridei NNP 40436 9597 45 = = SYM 40436 9597 46 n n NNP 40436 9597 47 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 9597 48 . . . 40436 9597 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9597 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9598 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9598 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9598 3 130 130 CD 40436 9598 4 : : : 40436 9598 5 Nothing nothing NN 40436 9598 6 can can MD 40436 9598 7 be be VB 40436 9598 8 more more JJR 40436 9598 9 at at IN 40436 9598 10 variance variance NN 40436 9598 11 with with IN 40436 9598 12 the the DT 40436 9598 13 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9598 14 which which WDT 40436 9598 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9598 16 assigns assign VBZ 40436 9598 17 to to IN 40436 9598 18 Kalliklês kalliklê NNS 40436 9598 19 in in IN 40436 9598 20 the the DT 40436 9598 21 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9598 22 , , , 40436 9598 23 than than IN 40436 9598 24 the the DT 40436 9598 25 three three CD 40436 9598 26 memorable memorable JJ 40436 9598 27 speeches speech NNS 40436 9598 28 of of IN 40436 9598 29 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9598 30 in in IN 40436 9598 31 Thucydides Thucydides NNP 40436 9598 32 , , , 40436 9598 33 i. i. NNP 40436 9599 1 144 144 CD 40436 9599 2 , , , 40436 9599 3 ii ii NNP 40436 9599 4 . . . 40436 9600 1 35 35 CD 40436 9600 2 , , , 40436 9600 3 ii ii NNP 40436 9600 4 . . . 40436 9601 1 60 60 CD 40436 9601 2 , , , 40436 9601 3 seq seq NN 40436 9601 4 . . . 40436 9602 1 All all PDT 40436 9602 2 these these DT 40436 9602 3 speeches speech NNS 40436 9602 4 are be VBP 40436 9602 5 penetrated penetrate VBN 40436 9602 6 with with IN 40436 9602 7 the the DT 40436 9602 8 deepest deep JJS 40436 9602 9 sense sense NN 40436 9602 10 of of IN 40436 9602 11 that that DT 40436 9602 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9602 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9602 14 : : : 40436 9602 15 koinôni koinôni NNP 40436 9602 16 / / SYM 40436 9602 17 a a NN 40436 9602 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9602 19 and and CC 40436 9602 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9602 21 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9602 22 : : : 40436 9602 23 phili phili NN 40436 9602 24 / / SYM 40436 9602 25 a a LS 40436 9602 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9602 27 which which WDT 40436 9602 28 the the DT 40436 9602 29 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9602 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9602 31 extols extol NNS 40436 9602 32 : : : 40436 9602 33 not not RB 40436 9602 34 one one CD 40436 9602 35 of of IN 40436 9602 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9602 37 countenances countenance NNS 40436 9602 38 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9602 39 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9602 40 : : : 40436 9602 41 pleonexi pleonexi NNP 40436 9602 42 / / SYM 40436 9602 43 an an NN 40436 9602 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9602 45 , , , 40436 9602 46 which which WDT 40436 9602 47 the the DT 40436 9602 48 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9602 49 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9602 50 forbids forbid NNS 40436 9602 51 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9602 52 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 9602 53 . . . 40436 9603 1 508 508 CD 40436 9603 2 E E NNS 40436 9603 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9603 4 . . . 40436 9604 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9604 2 Greek greek JJ 40436 9604 3 : : : 40436 9604 4 To\ to\ NN 40436 9604 5 prostalaipôrei prostalaipôrei NN 40436 9604 6 = = SYM 40436 9604 7 n n CC 40436 9604 8 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 9604 9 do do VBP 40436 9604 10 / / SYM 40436 9604 11 xanti xanti NNP 40436 9604 12 kalô=| kalô=| NNP 40436 9604 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9604 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9604 15 to to TO 40436 9604 16 use use VB 40436 9604 17 the the DT 40436 9604 18 expressive expressive JJ 40436 9604 19 phrase phrase NN 40436 9604 20 of of IN 40436 9604 21 Thucydides Thucydides NNP 40436 9604 22 , , , 40436 9604 23 ii ii NNP 40436 9604 24 . . . 40436 9605 1 53 53 LS 40436 9605 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9605 3 was be VBD 40436 9605 4 a a DT 40436 9605 5 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 9605 6 feature feature NN 40436 9605 7 in in IN 40436 9605 8 the the DT 40436 9605 9 character character NN 40436 9605 10 of of IN 40436 9605 11 the the DT 40436 9605 12 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 9605 13 of of IN 40436 9605 14 that that DT 40436 9605 15 day day NN 40436 9605 16 : : : 40436 9605 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9605 18 was be VBD 40436 9605 19 subdued subdue VBN 40436 9605 20 for for IN 40436 9605 21 the the DT 40436 9605 22 moment moment NN 40436 9605 23 by by IN 40436 9605 24 the the DT 40436 9605 25 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 40436 9605 26 misery misery NN 40436 9605 27 of of IN 40436 9605 28 pestilence pestilence NN 40436 9605 29 and and CC 40436 9605 30 war war NN 40436 9605 31 combined combine VBN 40436 9605 32 . . . 40436 9605 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9606 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9606 2 Side side NN 40436 9606 3 - - HYPH 40436 9606 4 note note NN 40436 9606 5 : : : 40436 9606 6 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9606 7 was be VBD 40436 9606 8 employed employ VBN 40436 9606 9 at at IN 40436 9606 10 Athens Athens NNP 40436 9606 11 in in IN 40436 9606 12 appealing appeal VBG 40436 9606 13 to to IN 40436 9606 14 all all PDT 40436 9606 15 the the DT 40436 9606 16 various various JJ 40436 9606 17 established established JJ 40436 9606 18 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 9606 19 and and CC 40436 9606 20 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9606 21 . . . 40436 9607 1 Erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 9607 2 inferences inference NNS 40436 9607 3 raised raise VBN 40436 9607 4 by by IN 40436 9607 5 the the DT 40436 9607 6 Kalliklês Kalliklês NNPS 40436 9607 7 of of IN 40436 9607 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9607 9 . . . 40436 9607 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9608 1 Lastly lastly RB 40436 9608 2 , , , 40436 9608 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9608 4 is be VBZ 40436 9608 5 not not RB 40436 9608 6 merely merely RB 40436 9608 7 the the DT 40436 9608 8 political political JJ 40436 9608 9 power power NN 40436 9608 10 of of IN 40436 9608 11 the the DT 40436 9608 12 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 9608 13 that that WDT 40436 9608 14 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9608 15 employs employ VBZ 40436 9608 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9608 17 eloquence eloquence NN 40436 9608 18 to to TO 40436 9608 19 uphold uphold VB 40436 9608 20 . . . 40436 9609 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9609 2 dwells dwell VBZ 40436 9609 3 also also RB 40436 9609 4 with with IN 40436 9609 5 emphasis emphasis NN 40436 9609 6 on on IN 40436 9609 7 the the DT 40436 9609 8 elegance elegance NN 40436 9609 9 of of IN 40436 9609 10 taste taste NN 40436 9609 11 , , , 40436 9609 12 on on IN 40436 9609 13 the the DT 40436 9609 14 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9609 15 force force NN 40436 9609 16 and and CC 40436 9609 17 activity activity NN 40436 9609 18 , , , 40436 9609 19 which which WDT 40436 9609 20 warranted warrant VBD 40436 9609 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9609 22 in in IN 40436 9609 23 decorating decorate VBG 40436 9609 24 the the DT 40436 9609 25 city city NN 40436 9609 26 with with IN 40436 9609 27 the the DT 40436 9609 28 title title NN 40436 9609 29 of of IN 40436 9609 30 Preceptress Preceptress NNP 40436 9609 31 of of IN 40436 9609 32 Hellas Hellas NNP 40436 9609 33 . . . 40436 9610 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9610 2 131 131 CD 40436 9610 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9610 4 All all PDT 40436 9610 5 this this DT 40436 9610 6 belongs belong VBZ 40436 9610 7 , , , 40436 9610 8 not not RB 40436 9610 9 to to IN 40436 9610 10 the the DT 40436 9610 11 pleasurable pleasurable NN 40436 9610 12 as as IN 40436 9610 13 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 9610 14 from from IN 40436 9610 15 the the DT 40436 9610 16 good good JJ 40436 9610 17 , , , 40436 9610 18 but but CC 40436 9610 19 to to IN 40436 9610 20 good good NN 40436 9610 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9610 22 whether whether IN 40436 9610 23 immediately immediately RB 40436 9610 24 pleasurable pleasurable JJ 40436 9610 25 or or CC 40436 9610 26 not not RB 40436 9610 27 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9610 28 in in IN 40436 9610 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9610 30 most most RBS 40436 9610 31 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 9610 32 sense sense NN 40436 9610 33 , , , 40436 9610 34 embracing embrace VBG 40436 9610 35 the the DT 40436 9610 36 improvement improvement NN 40436 9610 37 and and CC 40436 9610 38 refinement refinement NN 40436 9610 39 of of IN 40436 9610 40 the the DT 40436 9610 41 collective collective JJ 40436 9610 42 mind mind NN 40436 9610 43 . . . 40436 9611 1 If if IN 40436 9611 2 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 9611 3 , , , 40436 9611 4 in in IN 40436 9611 5 this this DT 40436 9611 6 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 9611 7 funeral funeral NN 40436 9611 8 harangue harangue NN 40436 9611 9 , , , 40436 9611 10 flattered flatter VBD 40436 9611 11 the the DT 40436 9611 12 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 9611 13 of of IN 40436 9611 14 the the DT 40436 9611 15 people people NNS 40436 9611 16 -- -- : 40436 9611 17 as as IN 40436 9611 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9611 19 doubtless doubtless RB 40436 9611 20 did do VBD 40436 9611 21 -- -- : 40436 9611 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9611 23 flattered flatter VBD 40436 9611 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9611 25 by by IN 40436 9611 26 kindling kindle VBG 40436 9611 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9611 28 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 9611 29 towards towards IN 40436 9611 30 good good NN 40436 9611 31 . . . 40436 9612 1 And and CC 40436 9612 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9612 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9612 4 does do VBZ 40436 9612 5 the the DT 40436 9612 6 same same JJ 40436 9612 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9612 8 though though IN 40436 9612 9 less less RBR 40436 9612 10 nobly nobly RB 40436 9612 11 and and CC 40436 9612 12 powerfully powerfully RB 40436 9612 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9612 14 , , , 40436 9612 15 adopting adopt VBG 40436 9612 16 the the DT 40436 9612 17 received received JJ 40436 9612 18 framework framework NN 40436 9612 19 of of IN 40436 9612 20 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9612 21 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 9612 22 , , , 40436 9612 23 in in IN 40436 9612 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9612 25 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9612 26 called call VBN 40436 9612 27 Menexenus Menexenus NNP 40436 9612 28 , , , 40436 9612 29 which which WDT 40436 9612 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9612 31 shall shall MD 40436 9612 32 come come VB 40436 9612 33 to to IN 40436 9612 34 in in IN 40436 9612 35 a a DT 40436 9612 36 future future JJ 40436 9612 37 chapter chapter NN 40436 9612 38 . . . 40436 9613 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9613 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9613 3 131 131 CD 40436 9613 4 : : : 40436 9613 5 Thucyd Thucyd NNP 40436 9613 6 . . . 40436 9614 1 ii ii LS 40436 9614 2 . . . 40436 9615 1 41 41 CD 40436 9615 2 - - SYM 40436 9615 3 42 42 CD 40436 9615 4 . . . 40436 9616 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9616 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9616 3 : : : 40436 9616 4 xunelô xunelô NNP 40436 9616 5 / / SYM 40436 9616 6 n n NNP 40436 9616 7 te te NNP 40436 9616 8 le le NNP 40436 9616 9 / / SYM 40436 9616 10 gô gô NNP 40436 9616 11 tê tê NNP 40436 9616 12 / / SYM 40436 9616 13 n n NNP 40436 9616 14 te te NNP 40436 9616 15 pa pa NNP 40436 9616 16 = = SYM 40436 9616 17 san san NNP 40436 9616 18 po po NNP 40436 9616 19 / / SYM 40436 9616 20 lin lin NNP 40436 9616 21 tê tê NNP 40436 9616 22 = = SYM 40436 9616 23 s s NNP 40436 9616 24 E(lla E(lla NNP 40436 9616 25 / / SYM 40436 9616 26 dos dos NNP 40436 9616 27 pai pai NNP 40436 9616 28 / / SYM 40436 9616 29 deusin deusin NNP 40436 9616 30 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 9616 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9616 32 , , , 40436 9616 33 & & CC 40436 9616 34 c. c. NNP 40436 9616 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9616 36 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9616 37 Side side NN 40436 9616 38 - - HYPH 40436 9616 39 note note NN 40436 9616 40 : : : 40436 9616 41 The the DT 40436 9616 42 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9616 43 Idéal Idéal NNP 40436 9616 44 exacts exact NNS 40436 9616 45 , , , 40436 9616 46 as as IN 40436 9616 47 good good JJ 40436 9616 48 , , , 40436 9616 49 some some DT 40436 9616 50 order order NN 40436 9616 51 , , , 40436 9616 52 system system NN 40436 9616 53 , , , 40436 9616 54 discipline discipline NN 40436 9616 55 . . . 40436 9617 1 But but CC 40436 9617 2 order order NN 40436 9617 3 may may MD 40436 9617 4 be be VB 40436 9617 5 directed direct VBN 40436 9617 6 to to IN 40436 9617 7 bad bad JJ 40436 9617 8 ends end NNS 40436 9617 9 as as RB 40436 9617 10 well well RB 40436 9617 11 as as IN 40436 9617 12 to to IN 40436 9617 13 good good NN 40436 9617 14 . . . 40436 9618 1 Divergent divergent JJ 40436 9618 2 ideas idea NNS 40436 9618 3 about about IN 40436 9618 4 virtue virtue NN 40436 9618 5 . . . 40436 9618 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9619 1 The the DT 40436 9619 2 issue issue NN 40436 9619 3 , , , 40436 9619 4 therefore therefore RB 40436 9619 5 , , , 40436 9619 6 which which WDT 40436 9619 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9619 8 here here RB 40436 9619 9 takes take VBZ 40436 9619 10 against against IN 40436 9619 11 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 9619 12 , , , 40436 9619 13 must must MD 40436 9619 14 stand stand VB 40436 9619 15 or or CC 40436 9619 16 fall fall VB 40436 9619 17 with with IN 40436 9619 18 the the DT 40436 9619 19 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 9619 20 Idéal Idéal NNP 40436 9619 21 of of IN 40436 9619 22 Good Good NNP 40436 9619 23 and and CC 40436 9619 24 Evil Evil NNP 40436 9619 25 . . . 40436 9620 1 But but CC 40436 9620 2 when when WRB 40436 9620 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9620 4 thus thus RB 40436 9620 5 denounces denounce VBZ 40436 9620 6 both both CC 40436 9620 7 the the DT 40436 9620 8 general general JJ 40436 9620 9 public public NN 40436 9620 10 and and CC 40436 9620 11 the the DT 40436 9620 12 most most RBS 40436 9620 13 patriotic patriotic JJ 40436 9620 14 rhetors rhetor NNS 40436 9620 15 , , , 40436 9620 16 to to TO 40436 9620 17 ensure ensure VB 40436 9620 18 exclusive exclusive JJ 40436 9620 19 worship worship NN 40436 9620 20 for for IN 40436 9620 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9620 22 own own JJ 40436 9620 23 Idéal Idéal NNP 40436 9620 24 of of IN 40436 9620 25 Good Good NNP 40436 9620 26 -- -- : 40436 9620 27 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9620 28 may may MD 40436 9620 29 at at IN 40436 9620 30 least least JJS 40436 9620 31 require require VB 40436 9620 32 that that IN 40436 9620 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9620 34 shall shall MD 40436 9620 35 explain explain VB 40436 9620 36 , , , 40436 9620 37 wherein wherein WRB 40436 9620 38 consists consist VBZ 40436 9620 39 that that IN 40436 9620 40 Good good JJ 40436 9620 41 -- -- : 40436 9620 42 by by IN 40436 9620 43 what what WDT 40436 9620 44 mark mark NN 40436 9620 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9620 46 is be VBZ 40436 9620 47 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 40436 9620 48 -- -- : 40436 9620 49 and and CC 40436 9620 50 on on IN 40436 9620 51 what what WDT 40436 9620 52 authority authority NN 40436 9620 53 pre pre NN 40436 9620 54 - - NN 40436 9620 55 eminence eminence NN 40436 9620 56 is be VBZ 40436 9620 57 claimed claim VBN 40436 9620 58 for for IN 40436 9620 59 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9620 60 . . . 40436 9621 1 So so RB 40436 9621 2 far far RB 40436 9621 3 , , , 40436 9621 4 indeed indeed RB 40436 9621 5 , , , 40436 9621 6 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9621 7 advance advance VBP 40436 9621 8 by by IN 40436 9621 9 the the DT 40436 9621 10 help help NN 40436 9621 11 of of IN 40436 9621 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9621 13 's 's POS 40436 9621 14 similes[132]--order similes[132]--order NN 40436 9621 15 , , , 40436 9621 16 discipline discipline NN 40436 9621 17 , , , 40436 9621 18 health health NN 40436 9621 19 and and CC 40436 9621 20 strength strength NN 40436 9621 21 of of IN 40436 9621 22 body body NN 40436 9621 23 -- -- : 40436 9621 24 that that IN 40436 9621 25 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9621 26 are be VBP 40436 9621 27 called call VBN 40436 9621 28 upon upon IN 40436 9621 29 to to TO 40436 9621 30 recognise recognise VB 40436 9621 31 , , , 40436 9621 32 apart apart RB 40436 9621 33 from from IN 40436 9621 34 all all DT 40436 9621 35 particular particular JJ 40436 9621 36 moments moment NNS 40436 9621 37 of of IN 40436 9621 38 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9621 39 or or CC 40436 9621 40 suffering suffering NN 40436 9621 41 , , , 40436 9621 42 of of IN 40436 9621 43 action action NN 40436 9621 44 or or CC 40436 9621 45 quiescence quiescence NN 40436 9621 46 , , , 40436 9621 47 a a DT 40436 9621 48 certain certain JJ 40436 9621 49 permanent permanent JJ 40436 9621 50 mental mental JJ 40436 9621 51 condition condition NN 40436 9621 52 and and CC 40436 9621 53 habit habit NN 40436 9621 54 -- -- : 40436 9621 55 a a DT 40436 9621 56 certain certain JJ 40436 9621 57 order order NN 40436 9621 58 , , , 40436 9621 59 regulation regulation NN 40436 9621 60 , , , 40436 9621 61 discipline discipline NN 40436 9621 62 -- -- : 40436 9621 63 as as IN 40436 9621 64 an an DT 40436 9621 65 object object NN 40436 9621 66 of of IN 40436 9621 67 high high JJ 40436 9621 68 importance importance NN 40436 9621 69 to to TO 40436 9621 70 be be VB 40436 9621 71 attained attain VBN 40436 9621 72 . . . 40436 9622 1 This this DT 40436 9622 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9622 3 as as IN 40436 9622 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9622 5 have have VBP 40436 9622 6 before before RB 40436 9622 7 remarked remark VBN 40436 9622 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9622 9 is be VBZ 40436 9622 10 a a DT 40436 9622 11 valuable valuable JJ 40436 9622 12 idea idea NN 40436 9622 13 which which WDT 40436 9622 14 pervades pervade VBZ 40436 9622 15 , , , 40436 9622 16 in in IN 40436 9622 17 one one CD 40436 9622 18 form form NN 40436 9622 19 or or CC 40436 9622 20 another another DT 40436 9622 21 , , , 40436 9622 22 all all PDT 40436 9622 23 the the DT 40436 9622 24 Hellenic hellenic JJ 40436 9622 25 social social JJ 40436 9622 26 views view NNS 40436 9622 27 , , , 40436 9622 28 from from IN 40436 9622 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9622 30 downward downward RB 40436 9622 31 , , , 40436 9622 32 and and CC 40436 9622 33 even even RB 40436 9622 34 before before IN 40436 9622 35 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9622 36 ; ; : 40436 9622 37 an an DT 40436 9622 38 idea idea NN 40436 9622 39 , , , 40436 9622 40 moreover moreover RB 40436 9622 41 , , , 40436 9622 42 which which WDT 40436 9622 43 was be VBD 40436 9622 44 common common JJ 40436 9622 45 to to IN 40436 9622 46 Peripatetics Peripatetics NNPS 40436 9622 47 , , , 40436 9622 48 Stoics Stoics NNPS 40436 9622 49 , , , 40436 9622 50 Epikureans Epikureans NNPS 40436 9622 51 . . . 40436 9623 1 But but CC 40436 9623 2 mental mental JJ 40436 9623 3 order order NN 40436 9623 4 and and CC 40436 9623 5 discipline discipline NN 40436 9623 6 is be VBZ 40436 9623 7 not not RB 40436 9623 8 in in IN 40436 9623 9 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9623 10 an an DT 40436 9623 11 end end NN 40436 9623 12 : : : 40436 9623 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9623 14 may may MD 40436 9623 15 be be VB 40436 9623 16 differently differently RB 40436 9623 17 cast cast VBN 40436 9623 18 , , , 40436 9623 19 and and CC 40436 9623 20 may may MD 40436 9623 21 subserve subserve VB 40436 9623 22 many many JJ 40436 9623 23 different different JJ 40436 9623 24 purposes purpose NNS 40436 9623 25 . . . 40436 9624 1 The the DT 40436 9624 2 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40436 9624 3 brotherhood brotherhood NN 40436 9624 4 was be VBD 40436 9624 5 intensely intensely RB 40436 9624 6 restrictive restrictive JJ 40436 9624 7 in in IN 40436 9624 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9624 9 canons canon NNS 40436 9624 10 . . . 40436 9625 1 The the DT 40436 9625 2 Spartan Spartan NNP 40436 9625 3 system system NN 40436 9625 4 exhibited exhibit VBD 40436 9625 5 the the DT 40436 9625 6 strictest strictest NN 40436 9625 7 order order NN 40436 9625 8 and and CC 40436 9625 9 discipline discipline NN 40436 9625 10 -- -- : 40436 9625 11 an an DT 40436 9625 12 assemblage assemblage NN 40436 9625 13 of of IN 40436 9625 14 principles principle NNS 40436 9625 15 and and CC 40436 9625 16 habits habit NNS 40436 9625 17 predetermined predetermine VBN 40436 9625 18 by by IN 40436 9625 19 authority authority NN 40436 9625 20 and and CC 40436 9625 21 enforced enforce VBN 40436 9625 22 upon upon IN 40436 9625 23 all all DT 40436 9625 24 -- -- : 40436 9625 25 yet yet CC 40436 9625 26 neither neither DT 40436 9625 27 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9625 28 nor nor CC 40436 9625 29 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 9625 30 approve approve VBP 40436 9625 31 of of IN 40436 9625 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9625 33 results result NNS 40436 9625 34 . . . 40436 9626 1 Order order NN 40436 9626 2 and and CC 40436 9626 3 discipline discipline NN 40436 9626 4 attained attain VBD 40436 9626 5 full full JJ 40436 9626 6 perfection perfection NN 40436 9626 7 in in IN 40436 9626 8 the the DT 40436 9626 9 armies army NNS 40436 9626 10 of of IN 40436 9626 11 Julius Julius NNP 40436 9626 12 Caesar Caesar NNP 40436 9626 13 and and CC 40436 9626 14 the the DT 40436 9626 15 French French NNP 40436 9626 16 Emperor Emperor NNP 40436 9626 17 Napoleon Napoleon NNP 40436 9626 18 ; ; : 40436 9626 19 in in IN 40436 9626 20 the the DT 40436 9626 21 middle middle JJ 40436 9626 22 ages age NNS 40436 9626 23 , , , 40436 9626 24 also also RB 40436 9626 25 , , , 40436 9626 26 several several JJ 40436 9626 27 of of IN 40436 9626 28 the the DT 40436 9626 29 monastic monastic JJ 40436 9626 30 orders order NNS 40436 9626 31 stood stand VBD 40436 9626 32 high high JJ 40436 9626 33 in in IN 40436 9626 34 respect respect NN 40436 9626 35 to to IN 40436 9626 36 finished finished JJ 40436 9626 37 discipline discipline NN 40436 9626 38 pervading pervade VBG 40436 9626 39 the the DT 40436 9626 40 whole whole JJ 40436 9626 41 character character NN 40436 9626 42 : : : 40436 9626 43 and and CC 40436 9626 44 the the DT 40436 9626 45 Jesuits Jesuits NNPS 40436 9626 46 stood stand VBD 40436 9626 47 higher high JJR 40436 9626 48 than than IN 40436 9626 49 any any DT 40436 9626 50 . . . 40436 9627 1 Each each DT 40436 9627 2 of of IN 40436 9627 3 these these DT 40436 9627 4 systems system NNS 40436 9627 5 has have VBZ 40436 9627 6 included include VBN 40436 9627 7 terms term NNS 40436 9627 8 equivalent equivalent JJ 40436 9627 9 to to IN 40436 9627 10 justice justice NN 40436 9627 11 , , , 40436 9627 12 temperance temperance NN 40436 9627 13 , , , 40436 9627 14 virtue virtue NN 40436 9627 15 , , , 40436 9627 16 vice vice NN 40436 9627 17 , , , 40436 9627 18 & & CC 40436 9627 19 c. c. NNP 40436 9627 20 , , , 40436 9627 21 with with IN 40436 9627 22 sentiments sentiment NNS 40436 9627 23 associated associate VBN 40436 9627 24 therewith therewith NNP 40436 9627 25 , , , 40436 9627 26 yet yet CC 40436 9627 27 very very RB 40436 9627 28 different different JJ 40436 9627 29 from from IN 40436 9627 30 what what WP 40436 9627 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9627 32 would would MD 40436 9627 33 have have VB 40436 9627 34 approved approve VBN 40436 9627 35 . . . 40436 9628 1 The the DT 40436 9628 2 question question NN 40436 9628 3 -- -- : 40436 9628 4 What what WP 40436 9628 5 is be VBZ 40436 9628 6 Virtue?--_Vir Virtue?--_Vir NNP 40436 9628 7 bonus bonus NN 40436 9628 8 est est NNP 40436 9628 9 quis?_--will quis?_--will NNP 40436 9628 10 be be VB 40436 9628 11 answered answer VBN 40436 9628 12 differently differently RB 40436 9628 13 in in IN 40436 9628 14 each each DT 40436 9628 15 . . . 40436 9629 1 The the DT 40436 9629 2 Spartans Spartans NNPS 40436 9629 3 -- -- : 40436 9629 4 when when WRB 40436 9629 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9629 6 entrapped entrap VBD 40436 9629 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9629 8 by by IN 40436 9629 9 a a DT 40436 9629 10 delusive delusive JJ 40436 9629 11 pretence pretence NN 40436 9629 12 of of IN 40436 9629 13 liberation liberation NN 40436 9629 14 and and CC 40436 9629 15 military military JJ 40436 9629 16 decoration decoration NN 40436 9629 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9629 18 two two CD 40436 9629 19 thousand thousand CD 40436 9629 20 of of IN 40436 9629 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9629 22 bravest brave JJS 40436 9629 23 Helot Helot NNP 40436 9629 24 warriors warrior NNS 40436 9629 25 , , , 40436 9629 26 and and CC 40436 9629 27 took take VBD 40436 9629 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9629 29 off off RP 40436 9629 30 by by IN 40436 9629 31 private private JJ 40436 9629 32 assassinations,[133]--did assassinations,[133]--did NNS 40436 9629 33 not not RB 40436 9629 34 offend offend VB 40436 9629 35 against against IN 40436 9629 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9629 37 own own JJ 40436 9629 38 idea idea NN 40436 9629 39 of of IN 40436 9629 40 virtue virtue NN 40436 9629 41 , , , 40436 9629 42 or or CC 40436 9629 43 against against IN 40436 9629 44 the the DT 40436 9629 45 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9629 46 exigency exigency NN 40436 9629 47 of of IN 40436 9629 48 Order order NN 40436 9629 49 -- -- : 40436 9629 50 Measure measure NN 40436 9629 51 -- -- : 40436 9629 52 System system NN 40436 9629 53 . . . 40436 9630 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9630 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9630 3 132 132 CD 40436 9630 4 : : : 40436 9630 5 Plat Plat NNP 40436 9630 6 . . . 40436 9631 1 Gorg Gorg NNP 40436 9631 2 . . . 40436 9632 1 p. p. NN 40436 9633 1 504 504 CD 40436 9633 2 . . . 40436 9633 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9634 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9634 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9634 3 133 133 CD 40436 9634 4 : : : 40436 9634 5 Thucydid Thucydid NNP 40436 9634 6 . . . 40436 9635 1 iv iv XX 40436 9635 2 . . . 40436 9636 1 80 80 CD 40436 9636 2 . . . 40436 9636 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9637 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9637 2 Side side NN 40436 9637 3 - - HYPH 40436 9637 4 note note NN 40436 9637 5 : : : 40436 9637 6 How how WRB 40436 9637 7 to to TO 40436 9637 8 discriminate discriminate VB 40436 9637 9 the the DT 40436 9637 10 right right JJ 40436 9637 11 order order NN 40436 9637 12 from from IN 40436 9637 13 the the DT 40436 9637 14 wrong wrong NN 40436 9637 15 . . . 40436 9638 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9638 2 does do VBZ 40436 9638 3 not not RB 40436 9638 4 advise advise VB 40436 9638 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9638 6 . . . 40436 9638 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9639 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9639 2 is be VBZ 40436 9639 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 9639 4 altogether altogether RB 40436 9639 5 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 9639 6 , , , 40436 9639 7 when when WRB 40436 9639 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9639 9 -- -- : 40436 9639 10 professing profess VBG 40436 9639 11 to to TO 40436 9639 12 teach teach VB 40436 9639 13 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9639 14 how how WRB 40436 9639 15 to to TO 40436 9639 16 determine determine VB 40436 9639 17 scientifically scientifically RB 40436 9639 18 , , , 40436 9639 19 which which WDT 40436 9639 20 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9639 21 are be VBP 40436 9639 22 bad bad JJ 40436 9639 23 , , , 40436 9639 24 and and CC 40436 9639 25 which which WDT 40436 9639 26 pains pain NNS 40436 9639 27 are be VBP 40436 9639 28 good good JJ 40436 9639 29 -- -- : 40436 9639 30 refers refer VBZ 40436 9639 31 to to IN 40436 9639 32 a a DT 40436 9639 33 durable durable JJ 40436 9639 34 mental mental JJ 40436 9639 35 order order NN 40436 9639 36 and and CC 40436 9639 37 discipline discipline NN 40436 9639 38 . . . 40436 9640 1 Of of IN 40436 9640 2 such such JJ 40436 9640 3 order order NN 40436 9640 4 there there EX 40436 9640 5 existed exist VBD 40436 9640 6 historically historically RB 40436 9640 7 many many JJ 40436 9640 8 varieties variety NNS 40436 9640 9 ; ; : 40436 9640 10 and and CC 40436 9640 11 many many JJ 40436 9640 12 more more JJR 40436 9640 13 are be VBP 40436 9640 14 conceivable conceivable JJ 40436 9640 15 , , , 40436 9640 16 as as IN 40436 9640 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9640 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9640 19 has have VBZ 40436 9640 20 shown show VBN 40436 9640 21 in in IN 40436 9640 22 the the DT 40436 9640 23 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9640 24 and and CC 40436 9640 25 Leges Leges NNPS 40436 9640 26 . . . 40436 9641 1 By by IN 40436 9641 2 what what WP 40436 9641 3 tests test NNS 40436 9641 4 is be VBZ 40436 9641 5 the the DT 40436 9641 6 right right JJ 40436 9641 7 order order NN 40436 9641 8 to to TO 40436 9641 9 be be VB 40436 9641 10 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 9641 11 from from IN 40436 9641 12 the the DT 40436 9641 13 wrong wrong NN 40436 9641 14 ? ? . 40436 9642 1 If if IN 40436 9642 2 by by IN 40436 9642 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9642 4 results result NNS 40436 9642 5 , , , 40436 9642 6 by by IN 40436 9642 7 _ _ NNP 40436 9642 8 what what WP 40436 9642 9 _ _ NNP 40436 9642 10 results?--calculations results?--calculations NNPS 40436 9642 11 for for IN 40436 9642 12 minimising minimise VBG 40436 9642 13 pains pain NNS 40436 9642 14 , , , 40436 9642 15 and and CC 40436 9642 16 maximising maximise VBG 40436 9642 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9642 18 , , , 40436 9642 19 being be VBG 40436 9642 20 excluded exclude VBN 40436 9642 21 by by IN 40436 9642 22 the the DT 40436 9642 23 supposition supposition NN 40436 9642 24 ? ? . 40436 9643 1 Here here RB 40436 9643 2 the the DT 40436 9643 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9643 4 of of IN 40436 9643 5 the the DT 40436 9643 6 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9643 7 is be VBZ 40436 9643 8 at at IN 40436 9643 9 fault fault NN 40436 9643 10 . . . 40436 9644 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9644 2 has have VBZ 40436 9644 3 not not RB 40436 9644 4 told tell VBN 40436 9644 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 9644 6 by by IN 40436 9644 7 what what WDT 40436 9644 8 scientific scientific JJ 40436 9644 9 test test NN 40436 9644 10 the the DT 40436 9644 11 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 9644 12 Expert expert NN 40436 9644 13 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 9644 14 in in IN 40436 9644 15 determining determine VBG 40436 9644 16 what what WDT 40436 9644 17 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9644 18 are be VBP 40436 9644 19 bad bad JJ 40436 9644 20 , , , 40436 9644 21 and and CC 40436 9644 22 what what WDT 40436 9644 23 pains pain NNS 40436 9644 24 are be VBP 40436 9644 25 good good JJ 40436 9644 26 . . . 40436 9645 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9645 2 leaves leave VBZ 40436 9645 3 such such JJ 40436 9645 4 determination determination NN 40436 9645 5 to to IN 40436 9645 6 the the DT 40436 9645 7 unscientific unscientific JJ 40436 9645 8 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 9645 9 of of IN 40436 9645 10 each each DT 40436 9645 11 society society NN 40436 9645 12 and and CC 40436 9645 13 each each DT 40436 9645 14 individual individual JJ 40436 9645 15 . . . 40436 9646 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9646 2 has have VBZ 40436 9646 3 not not RB 40436 9646 4 , , , 40436 9646 5 in in IN 40436 9646 6 fact fact NN 40436 9646 7 , , , 40436 9646 8 responded respond VBD 40436 9646 9 to to IN 40436 9646 10 the the DT 40436 9646 11 clear clear JJ 40436 9646 12 and and CC 40436 9646 13 pertinent pertinent JJ 40436 9646 14 challenge challenge NN 40436 9646 15 thrown throw VBN 40436 9646 16 out out RP 40436 9646 17 by by IN 40436 9646 18 the the DT 40436 9646 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9646 20 of of IN 40436 9646 21 the the DT 40436 9646 22 Protagoras Protagoras NNPS 40436 9646 23 . . . 40436 9647 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9647 2 Side side NN 40436 9647 3 - - HYPH 40436 9647 4 note note NN 40436 9647 5 : : : 40436 9647 6 The the DT 40436 9647 7 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9647 8 upholds uphold VBZ 40436 9647 9 the the DT 40436 9647 10 independence independence NN 40436 9647 11 and and CC 40436 9647 12 dignity dignity NN 40436 9647 13 of of IN 40436 9647 14 the the DT 40436 9647 15 dissenting dissent VBG 40436 9647 16 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9647 17 . . . 40436 9647 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9648 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9648 2 think think VBP 40436 9648 3 , , , 40436 9648 4 for for IN 40436 9648 5 these these DT 40436 9648 6 reasons reason NNS 40436 9648 7 , , , 40436 9648 8 that that IN 40436 9648 9 the the DT 40436 9648 10 logic logic NN 40436 9648 11 of of IN 40436 9648 12 the the DT 40436 9648 13 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 9648 14 is be VBZ 40436 9648 15 not not RB 40436 9648 16 at at RB 40436 9648 17 all all RB 40436 9648 18 on on IN 40436 9648 19 a a DT 40436 9648 20 par par NN 40436 9648 21 with with IN 40436 9648 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9648 23 eloquence eloquence NN 40436 9648 24 . . . 40436 9649 1 But but CC 40436 9649 2 there there EX 40436 9649 3 is be VBZ 40436 9649 4 one one CD 40436 9649 5 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 9649 6 feature feature NN 40436 9649 7 which which WDT 40436 9649 8 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 40436 9649 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9649 10 among among IN 40436 9649 11 all all PDT 40436 9649 12 the the DT 40436 9649 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9649 14 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9649 15 . . . 40436 9650 1 Nowhere nowhere RB 40436 9650 2 in in IN 40436 9650 3 ancient ancient JJ 40436 9650 4 literature literature NN 40436 9650 5 is be VBZ 40436 9650 6 the the DT 40436 9650 7 title title NN 40436 9650 8 , , , 40436 9650 9 position position NN 40436 9650 10 , , , 40436 9650 11 and and CC 40436 9650 12 dignity dignity NN 40436 9650 13 of of IN 40436 9650 14 individual individual JJ 40436 9650 15 dissenting dissent VBG 40436 9650 16 opinion opinion NN 40436 9650 17 , , , 40436 9650 18 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9650 19 and and CC 40436 9650 20 political political JJ 40436 9650 21 -- -- : 40436 9650 22 against against IN 40436 9650 23 established establish VBN 40436 9650 24 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9650 25 and and CC 40436 9650 26 political political JJ 40436 9650 27 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 40436 9650 28 -- -- : 40436 9650 29 so so RB 40436 9650 30 clearly clearly RB 40436 9650 31 marked mark VBN 40436 9650 32 out out RP 40436 9650 33 and and CC 40436 9650 34 so so RB 40436 9650 35 boldly boldly RB 40436 9650 36 asserted assert VBN 40436 9650 37 . . . 40436 9651 1 " " `` 40436 9651 2 The the DT 40436 9651 3 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 9651 4 will will MD 40436 9651 5 judge judge VB 40436 9651 6 as as IN 40436 9651 7 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9651 8 think think VBP 40436 9651 9 right right RB 40436 9651 10 : : : 40436 9651 11 none none NN 40436 9651 12 but but CC 40436 9651 13 those those DT 40436 9651 14 speakers speaker NNS 40436 9651 15 who who WP 40436 9651 16 are be VBP 40436 9651 17 in in IN 40436 9651 18 harmony harmony NN 40436 9651 19 with with IN 40436 9651 20 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9651 21 , , , 40436 9651 22 have have VBP 40436 9651 23 any any DT 40436 9651 24 chance chance NN 40436 9651 25 of of IN 40436 9651 26 addressing address VBG 40436 9651 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9651 28 public public JJ 40436 9651 29 assemblies assembly NNS 40436 9651 30 with with IN 40436 9651 31 effect effect NN 40436 9651 32 , , , 40436 9651 33 and and CC 40436 9651 34 acquiring acquire VBG 40436 9651 35 political political JJ 40436 9651 36 influence influence NN 40436 9651 37 . . . 40436 9652 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9652 2 , , , 40436 9652 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9652 4 , , , 40436 9652 5 dissent dissent NN 40436 9652 6 from from IN 40436 9652 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9652 8 , , , 40436 9652 9 and and CC 40436 9652 10 have have VBP 40436 9652 11 no no DT 40436 9652 12 chance chance NN 40436 9652 13 of of IN 40436 9652 14 political political JJ 40436 9652 15 influence influence NN 40436 9652 16 : : : 40436 9652 17 but but CC 40436 9652 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9652 19 claim claim VBP 40436 9652 20 the the DT 40436 9652 21 right right NN 40436 9652 22 of of IN 40436 9652 23 following follow VBG 40436 9652 24 out out RB 40436 9652 25 , , , 40436 9652 26 proclaiming proclaim VBG 40436 9652 27 , , , 40436 9652 28 and and CC 40436 9652 29 defending defend VBG 40436 9652 30 , , , 40436 9652 31 the the DT 40436 9652 32 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 9652 33 of of IN 40436 9652 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9652 35 own own JJ 40436 9652 36 individual individual JJ 40436 9652 37 reason reason NN 40436 9652 38 , , , 40436 9652 39 until until IN 40436 9652 40 debate debate NN 40436 9652 41 satisfies satisfy VBZ 40436 9652 42 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9652 43 that that IN 40436 9652 44 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9652 45 am be VBP 40436 9652 46 wrong wrong JJ 40436 9652 47 . . . 40436 9652 48 " " '' 40436 9653 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 40436 9653 2 XXV XXV NNP 40436 9653 3 . . . 40436 9654 1 PHÆDON PHÆDON NNP 40436 9654 2 . . . 40436 9655 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9655 2 Side side NN 40436 9655 3 - - HYPH 40436 9655 4 note note NN 40436 9655 5 : : : 40436 9655 6 The the DT 40436 9655 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9655 8 is be VBZ 40436 9655 9 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 9655 10 and and CC 40436 9655 11 expository expository JJ 40436 9655 12 . . . 40436 9655 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9656 1 The the DT 40436 9656 2 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9656 3 is be VBZ 40436 9656 4 characterised characterise VBN 40436 9656 5 by by IN 40436 9656 6 Proklus Proklus NNP 40436 9656 7 as as IN 40436 9656 8 a a DT 40436 9656 9 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9656 10 wherein wherein WRB 40436 9656 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9656 12 unfolds unfold VBZ 40436 9656 13 fully fully RB 40436 9656 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9656 15 own own JJ 40436 9656 16 mental mental JJ 40436 9656 17 history history NN 40436 9656 18 , , , 40436 9656 19 and and CC 40436 9656 20 communicates communicate VBZ 40436 9656 21 to to IN 40436 9656 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9656 23 admirers admirer NNS 40436 9656 24 the the DT 40436 9656 25 complete complete JJ 40436 9656 26 range range NN 40436 9656 27 of of IN 40436 9656 28 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 9656 29 cognition cognition NN 40436 9656 30 . . . 40436 9657 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9657 2 1 1 LS 40436 9657 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9657 4 This this DT 40436 9657 5 criticism criticism NN 40436 9657 6 is be VBZ 40436 9657 7 partly partly RB 40436 9657 8 well well RB 40436 9657 9 founded found VBN 40436 9657 10 . . . 40436 9658 1 The the DT 40436 9658 2 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9658 3 generally generally RB 40436 9658 4 is be VBZ 40436 9658 5 among among IN 40436 9658 6 the the DT 40436 9658 7 most most RBS 40436 9658 8 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 9658 9 and and CC 40436 9658 10 expository expository NN 40436 9658 11 in in IN 40436 9658 12 the the DT 40436 9658 13 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9658 14 list list NN 40436 9658 15 . . . 40436 9659 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9659 2 undertakes undertake NNS 40436 9659 3 to to TO 40436 9659 4 prove prove VB 40436 9659 5 the the DT 40436 9659 6 immortality immortality NN 40436 9659 7 of of IN 40436 9659 8 the the DT 40436 9659 9 soul soul NN 40436 9659 10 , , , 40436 9659 11 delivers deliver VBZ 40436 9659 12 the the DT 40436 9659 13 various various JJ 40436 9659 14 reasons reason NNS 40436 9659 15 which which WDT 40436 9659 16 establish establish VBP 40436 9659 17 the the DT 40436 9659 18 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9659 19 to to IN 40436 9659 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9659 21 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9659 22 , , , 40436 9659 23 and and CC 40436 9659 24 confutes confute VBZ 40436 9659 25 some some DT 40436 9659 26 dissentient dissentient JJ 40436 9659 27 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9659 28 entertained entertain VBN 40436 9659 29 by by IN 40436 9659 30 others other NNS 40436 9659 31 . . . 40436 9660 1 In in IN 40436 9660 2 regard regard NN 40436 9660 3 to to IN 40436 9660 4 the the DT 40436 9660 5 exposition exposition NN 40436 9660 6 , , , 40436 9660 7 however however RB 40436 9660 8 , , , 40436 9660 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9660 10 must must MD 40436 9660 11 consider consider VB 40436 9660 12 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9660 13 as as IN 40436 9660 14 listening listen VBG 40436 9660 15 to to IN 40436 9660 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9660 17 under under IN 40436 9660 18 the the DT 40436 9660 19 name name NN 40436 9660 20 of of IN 40436 9660 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9660 22 : : : 40436 9660 23 and and CC 40436 9660 24 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9660 25 find find VBP 40436 9660 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9660 27 so so RB 40436 9660 28 conducted conduct VBN 40436 9660 29 as as IN 40436 9660 30 to to TO 40436 9660 31 specify specify VB 40436 9660 32 both both DT 40436 9660 33 certain certain JJ 40436 9660 34 stages stage NNS 40436 9660 35 through through IN 40436 9660 36 which which WDT 40436 9660 37 the the DT 40436 9660 38 mind mind NN 40436 9660 39 of of IN 40436 9660 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9660 41 had have VBD 40436 9660 42 passed pass VBN 40436 9660 43 , , , 40436 9660 44 and and CC 40436 9660 45 the the DT 40436 9660 46 logical logical JJ 40436 9660 47 process process NN 40436 9660 48 which which WDT 40436 9660 49 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9660 50 at at IN 40436 9660 51 that that DT 40436 9660 52 time time NN 40436 9660 53 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9660 54 appeared appear VBD 40436 9660 55 to to IN 40436 9660 56 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9660 57 to to TO 40436 9660 58 carry carry VB 40436 9660 59 conviction conviction NN 40436 9660 60 . . . 40436 9661 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9661 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9661 3 1 1 CD 40436 9661 4 : : : 40436 9661 5 Proklus proklus NN 40436 9661 6 , , , 40436 9661 7 in in IN 40436 9661 8 Platon Platon NNP 40436 9661 9 . . . 40436 9662 1 Republ Republ NNS 40436 9662 2 . . . 40436 9663 1 p. p. NN 40436 9663 2 392 392 CD 40436 9663 3 . . . 40436 9664 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9664 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9664 3 : : : 40436 9664 4 e)n e)n NNP 40436 9664 5 Phai Phai NNP 40436 9664 6 / / SYM 40436 9664 7 dôni dôni NNP 40436 9664 8 me\n me\n NNP 40436 9664 9 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9664 10 o(/pou o(/pou PRP 40436 9664 11 diaphero diaphero NNP 40436 9664 12 / / SYM 40436 9664 13 ntôs ntôs NNP 40436 9664 14 o o NNP 40436 9664 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9664 16 Sôkra sôkra NN 40436 9664 17 / / SYM 40436 9664 18 tês tês NN 40436 9664 19 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9664 20 e(autou= e(autou= NNP 40436 9664 21 zôê\n zôê\n NNP 40436 9664 22 a)naploi= a)naploi= NN 40436 9664 23 , , , 40436 9664 24 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9664 25 pa pa NNP 40436 9664 26 = = SYM 40436 9664 27 n n CC 40436 9664 28 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9664 29 tê tê NNP 40436 9664 30 = = SYM 40436 9664 31 s s NNP 40436 9664 32 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 9664 33 / / SYM 40436 9664 34 mês mês NNP 40436 9664 35 plê plê NNP 40436 9664 36 = = SYM 40436 9664 37 thos thos NNP 40436 9664 38 a)noi a)noi NNP 40436 9664 39 / / SYM 40436 9664 40 gei gei NNP 40436 9664 41 toi toi NNP 40436 9664 42 = = SYM 40436 9664 43 s s NNP 40436 9664 44 e(autou= e(autou= CD 40436 9664 45 zêlôtai zêlôtai NN 40436 9664 46 = = NFP 40436 9664 47 s s NN 40436 9664 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9664 49 , , , 40436 9664 50 & & CC 40436 9664 51 c. c. NNP 40436 9664 52 Wyttenbach Wyttenbach NNP 40436 9664 53 thinks think VBZ 40436 9664 54 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9664 55 note note NN 40436 9664 56 , , , 40436 9664 57 ad ad NN 40436 9664 58 p. p. NN 40436 9664 59 108 108 CD 40436 9664 60 E E NNS 40436 9664 61 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9664 62 that that IN 40436 9664 63 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9664 64 was be VBD 40436 9664 65 young young JJ 40436 9664 66 when when WRB 40436 9664 67 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9664 68 composed compose VBD 40436 9664 69 the the DT 40436 9664 70 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9664 71 . . . 40436 9665 1 But but CC 40436 9665 2 no no DT 40436 9665 3 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 9665 4 grounds ground NNS 40436 9665 5 are be VBP 40436 9665 6 given give VBN 40436 9665 7 for for IN 40436 9665 8 this this DT 40436 9665 9 : : : 40436 9665 10 and and CC 40436 9665 11 the the DT 40436 9665 12 concluding conclude VBG 40436 9665 13 sentence sentence NN 40436 9665 14 of of IN 40436 9665 15 the the DT 40436 9665 16 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9665 17 affords afford VBZ 40436 9665 18 good good JJ 40436 9665 19 presumption presumption NN 40436 9665 20 that that IN 40436 9665 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9665 22 was be VBD 40436 9665 23 composed compose VBN 40436 9665 24 many many JJ 40436 9665 25 years year NNS 40436 9665 26 after after IN 40436 9665 27 the the DT 40436 9665 28 death death NN 40436 9665 29 of of IN 40436 9665 30 Sokrates--[Greek sokrates--[greek NN 40436 9665 31 : : : 40436 9665 32 ê)/de ê)/de ADD 40436 9665 33 ê ê NNP 40436 9665 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9665 35 teleutê/ teleutê/ NN 40436 9665 36 , , , 40436 9665 37 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 9665 38 E)che e)che NN 40436 9665 39 / / SYM 40436 9665 40 krates krate NNS 40436 9665 41 , , , 40436 9665 42 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9665 43 e(tai e(tai NNP 40436 9665 44 / / SYM 40436 9665 45 rou rou NN 40436 9665 46 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 9665 47 = = SYM 40436 9665 48 n n CC 40436 9665 49 e)ge e)ge NNP 40436 9665 50 / / SYM 40436 9665 51 neto neto NN 40436 9665 52 , , , 40436 9665 53 a)ndro a)ndro NNP 40436 9665 54 / / SYM 40436 9665 55 s s NN 40436 9665 56 , , , 40436 9665 57 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 9665 58 ê(mei ê(mei NN 40436 9665 59 = = NFP 40436 9665 60 s s NNP 40436 9665 61 phai phai NN 40436 9665 62 = = SYM 40436 9665 63 men man NNS 40436 9665 64 a)/n a)/n UH 40436 9665 65 , , , 40436 9665 66 _ _ NNP 40436 9665 67 tô tô NNP 40436 9665 68 = = SYM 40436 9665 69 n n CC 40436 9665 70 to to IN 40436 9665 71 / / SYM 40436 9665 72 te te NNP 40436 9665 73 _ _ NNP 40436 9665 74 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 9665 75 e)peira e)peira , 40436 9665 76 / / SYM 40436 9665 77 thêmen thêmen NNP 40436 9665 78 a)ri a)ri NNP 40436 9665 79 / / SYM 40436 9665 80 stou stou NNP 40436 9665 81 , , , 40436 9665 82 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9665 83 a)/llôs a)/llôs NNP 40436 9665 84 phronimôta phronimôta NNP 40436 9665 85 / / SYM 40436 9665 86 tou tou NNP 40436 9665 87 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9665 88 dikaiota dikaiota NNP 40436 9665 89 / / SYM 40436 9665 90 tou tou NNP 40436 9665 91 . . . 40436 9665 92 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9666 1 The the DT 40436 9666 2 phrase phrase NN 40436 9666 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9666 4 Greek greek NN 40436 9666 5 : : : 40436 9666 6 tô tô NNP 40436 9666 7 = = SYM 40436 9666 8 n n CC 40436 9666 9 to to IN 40436 9666 10 / / SYM 40436 9666 11 te te NNP 40436 9666 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9666 13 which which WDT 40436 9666 14 may may MD 40436 9666 15 probably probably RB 40436 9666 16 have have VB 40436 9666 17 slipped slip VBN 40436 9666 18 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 9666 19 from from IN 40436 9666 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9666 21 , , , 40436 9666 22 implies imply VBZ 40436 9666 23 that that IN 40436 9666 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9666 25 belonged belong VBD 40436 9666 26 to to IN 40436 9666 27 the the DT 40436 9666 28 past past JJ 40436 9666 29 generation generation NN 40436 9666 30 . . . 40436 9667 1 The the DT 40436 9667 2 beginning beginning NN 40436 9667 3 of of IN 40436 9667 4 the the DT 40436 9667 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9667 6 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 40436 9667 7 shows show VBZ 40436 9667 8 that that IN 40436 9667 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9667 10 intended intend VBD 40436 9667 11 to to TO 40436 9667 12 place place VB 40436 9667 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9667 14 shortly shortly RB 40436 9667 15 after after IN 40436 9667 16 the the DT 40436 9667 17 death death NN 40436 9667 18 of of IN 40436 9667 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9667 20 ; ; : 40436 9667 21 but but CC 40436 9667 22 the the DT 40436 9667 23 word word NN 40436 9667 24 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9667 25 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9667 26 : : : 40436 9667 27 to to TO 40436 9667 28 / / SYM 40436 9667 29 te te NNP 40436 9667 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9667 31 at at IN 40436 9667 32 the the DT 40436 9667 33 end end NN 40436 9667 34 is be VBZ 40436 9667 35 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 9667 36 with with IN 40436 9667 37 this this DT 40436 9667 38 supposition supposition NN 40436 9667 39 , , , 40436 9667 40 and and CC 40436 9667 41 comes come VBZ 40436 9667 42 out out RP 40436 9667 43 unconsciously unconsciously RB 40436 9667 44 as as IN 40436 9667 45 a a DT 40436 9667 46 mark mark NN 40436 9667 47 of of IN 40436 9667 48 the the DT 40436 9667 49 real real JJ 40436 9667 50 time time NN 40436 9667 51 . . . 40436 9667 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9668 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9668 2 Side side NN 40436 9668 3 - - HYPH 40436 9668 4 note note NN 40436 9668 5 : : : 40436 9668 6 Situation situation NN 40436 9668 7 and and CC 40436 9668 8 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 9668 9 assumed assume VBN 40436 9668 10 in in IN 40436 9668 11 the the DT 40436 9668 12 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9668 13 . . . 40436 9669 1 Pathetic pathetic JJ 40436 9669 2 interest interest NN 40436 9669 3 which which WDT 40436 9669 4 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9669 5 inspire inspire VBP 40436 9669 6 . . . 40436 9669 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9670 1 The the DT 40436 9670 2 interest interest NN 40436 9670 3 felt feel VBD 40436 9670 4 by by IN 40436 9670 5 most most JJS 40436 9670 6 readers reader NNS 40436 9670 7 in in IN 40436 9670 8 the the DT 40436 9670 9 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9670 10 , , , 40436 9670 11 however however RB 40436 9670 12 , , , 40436 9670 13 depends depend VBZ 40436 9670 14 , , , 40436 9670 15 not not RB 40436 9670 16 so so RB 40436 9670 17 much much RB 40436 9670 18 on on IN 40436 9670 19 the the DT 40436 9670 20 argumentative argumentative JJ 40436 9670 21 exposition exposition NN 40436 9670 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9670 23 which which WDT 40436 9670 24 Wyttenbach[2 Wyttenbach[2 NNP 40436 9670 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9670 26 justly justly RB 40436 9670 27 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 9670 28 to to TO 40436 9670 29 be be VB 40436 9670 30 obscure obscure JJ 40436 9670 31 and and CC 40436 9670 32 difficult difficult JJ 40436 9670 33 as as RB 40436 9670 34 well well RB 40436 9670 35 as as IN 40436 9670 36 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 9670 37 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9670 38 as as IN 40436 9670 39 on on IN 40436 9670 40 the the DT 40436 9670 41 personality personality NN 40436 9670 42 of of IN 40436 9670 43 the the DT 40436 9670 44 expounding expounding NN 40436 9670 45 speaker speaker NN 40436 9670 46 , , , 40436 9670 47 and and CC 40436 9670 48 the the DT 40436 9670 49 irresistible irresistible JJ 40436 9670 50 pathos pathos NN 40436 9670 51 of of IN 40436 9670 52 the the DT 40436 9670 53 situation situation NN 40436 9670 54 . . . 40436 9671 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9671 2 had have VBD 40436 9671 3 been be VBN 40436 9671 4 condemned condemn VBN 40436 9671 5 to to IN 40436 9671 6 death death NN 40436 9671 7 by by IN 40436 9671 8 the the DT 40436 9671 9 Dikastery Dikastery NNP 40436 9671 10 on on IN 40436 9671 11 the the DT 40436 9671 12 day day NN 40436 9671 13 after after IN 40436 9671 14 the the DT 40436 9671 15 sacred sacred JJ 40436 9671 16 ship ship NN 40436 9671 17 , , , 40436 9671 18 memorable memorable JJ 40436 9671 19 in in IN 40436 9671 20 connection connection NN 40436 9671 21 with with IN 40436 9671 22 the the DT 40436 9671 23 legendary legendary JJ 40436 9671 24 voyage voyage NN 40436 9671 25 of of IN 40436 9671 26 Theseus Theseus NNP 40436 9671 27 to to IN 40436 9671 28 Krete Krete NNP 40436 9671 29 , , , 40436 9671 30 had have VBD 40436 9671 31 been be VBN 40436 9671 32 dispatched dispatch VBN 40436 9671 33 on on IN 40436 9671 34 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9671 35 annual annual JJ 40436 9671 36 mission mission NN 40436 9671 37 of of IN 40436 9671 38 religious religious JJ 40436 9671 39 sacrifice sacrifice NN 40436 9671 40 at at IN 40436 9671 41 the the DT 40436 9671 42 island island NN 40436 9671 43 of of IN 40436 9671 44 Delos Delos NNP 40436 9671 45 . . . 40436 9672 1 The the DT 40436 9672 2 Athenian athenian JJ 40436 9672 3 magistrates magistrate NNS 40436 9672 4 considered consider VBD 40436 9672 5 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9672 6 as as IN 40436 9672 7 precluded preclude VBN 40436 9672 8 from from IN 40436 9672 9 putting put VBG 40436 9672 10 any any DT 40436 9672 11 one one CD 40436 9672 12 to to IN 40436 9672 13 death death NN 40436 9672 14 by by IN 40436 9672 15 public public JJ 40436 9672 16 authority authority NN 40436 9672 17 , , , 40436 9672 18 during during IN 40436 9672 19 the the DT 40436 9672 20 absence absence NN 40436 9672 21 of of IN 40436 9672 22 the the DT 40436 9672 23 ship ship NN 40436 9672 24 on on IN 40436 9672 25 this this DT 40436 9672 26 mission mission NN 40436 9672 27 . . . 40436 9673 1 Thirty thirty CD 40436 9673 2 days day NNS 40436 9673 3 elapsed elapse VBD 40436 9673 4 between between IN 40436 9673 5 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9673 6 departure departure NN 40436 9673 7 and and CC 40436 9673 8 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9673 9 return return NN 40436 9673 10 : : : 40436 9673 11 during during IN 40436 9673 12 all all DT 40436 9673 13 which which WDT 40436 9673 14 interval interval NN 40436 9673 15 , , , 40436 9673 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9673 17 remained remain VBD 40436 9673 18 in in IN 40436 9673 19 the the DT 40436 9673 20 prison prison NN 40436 9673 21 , , , 40436 9673 22 yet yet CC 40436 9673 23 with with IN 40436 9673 24 full full JJ 40436 9673 25 permission permission NN 40436 9673 26 to to IN 40436 9673 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9673 28 friends friend NNS 40436 9673 29 to to TO 40436 9673 30 visit visit VB 40436 9673 31 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9673 32 . . . 40436 9674 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9674 2 passed pass VBD 40436 9674 3 most most JJS 40436 9674 4 of of IN 40436 9674 5 every every DT 40436 9674 6 day day NN 40436 9674 7 in in IN 40436 9674 8 the the DT 40436 9674 9 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9674 10 of of IN 40436 9674 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9674 12 conversation conversation NN 40436 9674 13 . . . 40436 9675 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9675 2 3 3 CD 40436 9675 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9675 4 In in IN 40436 9675 5 the the DT 40436 9675 6 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9675 7 , , , 40436 9675 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9675 9 read read VBP 40436 9675 10 the the DT 40436 9675 11 last last JJ 40436 9675 12 of of IN 40436 9675 13 these these DT 40436 9675 14 conversations conversation NNS 40436 9675 15 , , , 40436 9675 16 after after IN 40436 9675 17 the the DT 40436 9675 18 sacred sacred JJ 40436 9675 19 vessel vessel NN 40436 9675 20 had have VBD 40436 9675 21 returned return VBN 40436 9675 22 , , , 40436 9675 23 and and CC 40436 9675 24 after after IN 40436 9675 25 the the DT 40436 9675 26 Eleven eleven CD 40436 9675 27 magistrates magistrate NNS 40436 9675 28 had have VBD 40436 9675 29 announced announce VBN 40436 9675 30 to to IN 40436 9675 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9675 32 that that IN 40436 9675 33 the the DT 40436 9675 34 draught draught NN 40436 9675 35 of of IN 40436 9675 36 hemlock hemlock NNP 40436 9675 37 would would MD 40436 9675 38 be be VB 40436 9675 39 administered administer VBN 40436 9675 40 to to IN 40436 9675 41 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9675 42 before before IN 40436 9675 43 sunset sunset NN 40436 9675 44 . . . 40436 9676 1 On on IN 40436 9676 2 communicating communicate VBG 40436 9676 3 this this DT 40436 9676 4 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 9676 5 , , , 40436 9676 6 the the DT 40436 9676 7 magistrates magistrate NNS 40436 9676 8 released release VBD 40436 9676 9 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9676 10 from from IN 40436 9676 11 the the DT 40436 9676 12 fetters fetter NNS 40436 9676 13 with with IN 40436 9676 14 which which WDT 40436 9676 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9676 16 had have VBD 40436 9676 17 hitherto hitherto VBN 40436 9676 18 been be VBN 40436 9676 19 bound bind VBN 40436 9676 20 . . . 40436 9677 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9677 2 is be VBZ 40436 9677 3 shortly shortly RB 40436 9677 4 after after IN 40436 9677 5 such such JJ 40436 9677 6 release release NN 40436 9677 7 that that IN 40436 9677 8 the the DT 40436 9677 9 friends friend NNS 40436 9677 10 enter enter VBP 40436 9677 11 the the DT 40436 9677 12 prison prison NN 40436 9677 13 to to TO 40436 9677 14 see see VB 40436 9677 15 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9677 16 for for IN 40436 9677 17 the the DT 40436 9677 18 last last JJ 40436 9677 19 time time NN 40436 9677 20 . . . 40436 9678 1 One one CD 40436 9678 2 of of IN 40436 9678 3 the the DT 40436 9678 4 number number NN 40436 9678 5 , , , 40436 9678 6 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9678 7 , , , 40436 9678 8 recounts recount VBZ 40436 9678 9 to to IN 40436 9678 10 Echekratês Echekratês NNP 40436 9678 11 not not RB 40436 9678 12 only only RB 40436 9678 13 the the DT 40436 9678 14 conduct conduct NN 40436 9678 15 and and CC 40436 9678 16 discourse discourse NN 40436 9678 17 of of IN 40436 9678 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9678 19 during during IN 40436 9678 20 the the DT 40436 9678 21 closing closing NN 40436 9678 22 hours hour NNS 40436 9678 23 of of IN 40436 9678 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9678 25 life life NN 40436 9678 26 , , , 40436 9678 27 but but CC 40436 9678 28 also also RB 40436 9678 29 the the DT 40436 9678 30 swallowing swallowing NN 40436 9678 31 of of IN 40436 9678 32 the the DT 40436 9678 33 poison poison NN 40436 9678 34 , , , 40436 9678 35 and and CC 40436 9678 36 the the DT 40436 9678 37 manner manner NN 40436 9678 38 of of IN 40436 9678 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9678 40 death death NN 40436 9678 41 . . . 40436 9679 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9679 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9679 3 2 2 CD 40436 9679 4 : : : 40436 9679 5 See see VB 40436 9679 6 the the DT 40436 9679 7 Prolegomena Prolegomena NNP 40436 9679 8 prefixed prefix VBN 40436 9679 9 to to IN 40436 9679 10 Wyttenbach Wyttenbach NNP 40436 9679 11 's 's POS 40436 9679 12 edition edition NN 40436 9679 13 of of IN 40436 9679 14 the the DT 40436 9679 15 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9679 16 , , , 40436 9679 17 p. p. NN 40436 9679 18 xxi xxi NNP 40436 9679 19 . . . 40436 9680 1 p. p. NN 40436 9681 1 10 10 CD 40436 9681 2 . . . 40436 9681 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9682 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9682 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9682 3 3 3 CD 40436 9682 4 : : : 40436 9682 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9682 6 , , , 40436 9682 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9682 8 , , , 40436 9682 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9682 10 . . . 40436 9683 1 58 58 CD 40436 9683 2 - - SYM 40436 9683 3 50 50 CD 40436 9683 4 . . . 40436 9684 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9684 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 9684 3 that that IN 40436 9684 4 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9684 5 became become VBD 40436 9684 6 bail bail NN 40436 9684 7 before before IN 40436 9684 8 the the DT 40436 9684 9 Dikasts Dikasts NNPS 40436 9684 10 , , , 40436 9684 11 in in IN 40436 9684 12 a a DT 40436 9684 13 certain certain JJ 40436 9684 14 sum sum NN 40436 9684 15 of of IN 40436 9684 16 money money NN 40436 9684 17 , , , 40436 9684 18 that that IN 40436 9684 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9684 20 should should MD 40436 9684 21 remain remain VB 40436 9684 22 in in IN 40436 9684 23 prison prison NN 40436 9684 24 and and CC 40436 9684 25 not not RB 40436 9684 26 escape escape VB 40436 9684 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9684 28 Plat Plat NNP 40436 9684 29 . . . 40436 9685 1 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9685 2 , , , 40436 9685 3 p. p. NN 40436 9685 4 115 115 CD 40436 9685 5 D D NNP 40436 9685 6 ; ; : 40436 9685 7 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9685 8 , , , 40436 9685 9 45 45 CD 40436 9685 10 B b NN 40436 9685 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9685 12 . . . 40436 9686 1 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9686 2 would would MD 40436 9686 3 have have VB 40436 9686 4 been be VBN 40436 9686 5 obliged oblige VBN 40436 9686 6 to to TO 40436 9686 7 pay pay VB 40436 9686 8 this this DT 40436 9686 9 money money NN 40436 9686 10 if if IN 40436 9686 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9686 12 had have VBD 40436 9686 13 accepted accept VBN 40436 9686 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9686 15 proposition proposition NN 40436 9686 16 to to TO 40436 9686 17 escape escape VB 40436 9686 18 , , , 40436 9686 19 noticed notice VBD 40436 9686 20 already already RB 40436 9686 21 in in IN 40436 9686 22 chap chap NNP 40436 9686 23 . . . 40436 9687 1 x. x. NNP 40436 9687 2 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9688 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9688 2 Side side NN 40436 9688 3 - - HYPH 40436 9688 4 note note NN 40436 9688 5 : : : 40436 9688 6 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9688 7 and and CC 40436 9688 8 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9688 9 , , , 40436 9688 10 the the DT 40436 9688 11 two two CD 40436 9688 12 collocutors collocutor NNS 40436 9688 13 with with IN 40436 9688 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9688 15 . . . 40436 9689 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9689 2 feelings feeling NNS 40436 9689 3 and and CC 40436 9689 4 those those DT 40436 9689 5 of of IN 40436 9689 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9689 7 . . . 40436 9689 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9690 1 More More JJR 40436 9690 2 than than IN 40436 9690 3 fifteen fifteen CD 40436 9690 4 friends friend NNS 40436 9690 5 of of IN 40436 9690 6 the the DT 40436 9690 7 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9690 8 are be VBP 40436 9690 9 noted note VBN 40436 9690 10 as as IN 40436 9690 11 present present JJ 40436 9690 12 at at IN 40436 9690 13 this this DT 40436 9690 14 last last JJ 40436 9690 15 scene scene NN 40436 9690 16 : : : 40436 9690 17 but but CC 40436 9690 18 the the DT 40436 9690 19 only only JJ 40436 9690 20 two two CD 40436 9690 21 who who WP 40436 9690 22 take take VBP 40436 9690 23 an an DT 40436 9690 24 active active JJ 40436 9690 25 part part NN 40436 9690 26 in in IN 40436 9690 27 the the DT 40436 9690 28 debate debate NN 40436 9690 29 , , , 40436 9690 30 are be VBP 40436 9690 31 , , , 40436 9690 32 two two CD 40436 9690 33 young young JJ 40436 9690 34 Thebans Thebans NNPS 40436 9690 35 named name VBN 40436 9690 36 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9690 37 and and CC 40436 9690 38 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9690 39 . . . 40436 9691 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9691 2 4 4 LS 40436 9691 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9691 4 These these DT 40436 9691 5 friends friend NNS 40436 9691 6 , , , 40436 9691 7 though though IN 40436 9691 8 deeply deeply RB 40436 9691 9 attached attach VBN 40436 9691 10 to to IN 40436 9691 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9691 12 , , , 40436 9691 13 and and CC 40436 9691 14 full full JJ 40436 9691 15 of of IN 40436 9691 16 sorrow sorrow NN 40436 9691 17 at at IN 40436 9691 18 the the DT 40436 9691 19 irreparable irreparable JJ 40436 9691 20 loss loss NN 40436 9691 21 impending impend VBG 40436 9691 22 over over IN 40436 9691 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9691 24 , , , 40436 9691 25 are be VBP 40436 9691 26 represented represent VBN 40436 9691 27 as as IN 40436 9691 28 overawed overawe VBN 40436 9691 29 and and CC 40436 9691 30 fascinated fascinate VBN 40436 9691 31 by by IN 40436 9691 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9691 33 perfect perfect JJ 40436 9691 34 fearlessness fearlessness NN 40436 9691 35 , , , 40436 9691 36 serenity serenity NN 40436 9691 37 and and CC 40436 9691 38 dignity dignity NN 40436 9691 39 . . . 40436 9692 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9692 2 5 5 CD 40436 9692 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9692 4 They -PRON- PRP 40436 9692 5 are be VBP 40436 9692 6 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 9692 7 to to TO 40436 9692 8 give give VB 40436 9692 9 vent vent NN 40436 9692 10 to to IN 40436 9692 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9692 12 grief grief NN 40436 9692 13 , , , 40436 9692 14 when when WRB 40436 9692 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9692 16 master master NN 40436 9692 17 is be VBZ 40436 9692 18 seen see VBN 40436 9692 19 to to TO 40436 9692 20 maintain maintain VB 40436 9692 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9692 22 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 9692 23 frame frame NN 40436 9692 24 of of IN 40436 9692 25 mind mind NN 40436 9692 26 , , , 40436 9692 27 neither neither CC 40436 9692 28 disquieted disquiet VBN 40436 9692 29 nor nor CC 40436 9692 30 dissatisfied dissatisfied JJ 40436 9692 31 . . . 40436 9693 1 The the DT 40436 9693 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 9693 3 conception conception NN 40436 9693 4 of of IN 40436 9693 5 the the DT 40436 9693 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9693 7 is be VBZ 40436 9693 8 , , , 40436 9693 9 to to TO 40436 9693 10 represent represent VB 40436 9693 11 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9693 12 as as IN 40436 9693 13 the the DT 40436 9693 14 same same JJ 40436 9693 15 man man NN 40436 9693 16 that that IN 40436 9693 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9693 18 was be VBD 40436 9693 19 before before IN 40436 9693 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9693 21 trial trial NN 40436 9693 22 ; ; : 40436 9693 23 unmoved unmove VBN 40436 9693 24 by by IN 40436 9693 25 the the DT 40436 9693 26 situation situation NN 40436 9693 27 -- -- : 40436 9693 28 not not RB 40436 9693 29 feeling feel VBG 40436 9693 30 that that IN 40436 9693 31 any any DT 40436 9693 32 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 9693 33 is be VBZ 40436 9693 34 about about JJ 40436 9693 35 to to TO 40436 9693 36 happen happen VB 40436 9693 37 to to IN 40436 9693 38 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9693 39 -- -- : 40436 9693 40 equally equally RB 40436 9693 41 delighting delight VBG 40436 9693 42 in in IN 40436 9693 43 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9693 44 debate debate NN 40436 9693 45 -- -- : 40436 9693 46 equally equally RB 40436 9693 47 fertile fertile JJ 40436 9693 48 in in IN 40436 9693 49 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 9693 50 invention invention NN 40436 9693 51 . . . 40436 9694 1 So so RB 40436 9694 2 much much JJ 40436 9694 3 does do VBZ 40436 9694 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9694 5 care care VB 40436 9694 6 for for IN 40436 9694 7 debate debate NN 40436 9694 8 , , , 40436 9694 9 and and CC 40436 9694 10 so so RB 40436 9694 11 little little JJ 40436 9694 12 for for IN 40436 9694 13 the the DT 40436 9694 14 impending impending JJ 40436 9694 15 catastrophe catastrophe NN 40436 9694 16 , , , 40436 9694 17 that that IN 40436 9694 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9694 19 persists persist VBZ 40436 9694 20 in in IN 40436 9694 21 a a DT 40436 9694 22 great great JJ 40436 9694 23 argumentative argumentative JJ 40436 9694 24 effort effort NN 40436 9694 25 , , , 40436 9694 26 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 40436 9694 27 the the DT 40436 9694 28 intimation intimation NN 40436 9694 29 conveyed convey VBN 40436 9694 30 by by IN 40436 9694 31 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 9694 32 from from IN 40436 9694 33 the the DT 40436 9694 34 gaoler gaoler NN 40436 9694 35 , , , 40436 9694 36 that that IN 40436 9694 37 if if IN 40436 9694 38 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9694 39 heated heat VBD 40436 9694 40 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9694 41 with with IN 40436 9694 42 talking talk VBG 40436 9694 43 , , , 40436 9694 44 the the DT 40436 9694 45 poison poison NN 40436 9694 46 might may MD 40436 9694 47 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 9694 48 be be VB 40436 9694 49 languid languid JJ 40436 9694 50 in in IN 40436 9694 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9694 52 operation operation NN 40436 9694 53 , , , 40436 9694 54 so so IN 40436 9694 55 that that IN 40436 9694 56 two two CD 40436 9694 57 or or CC 40436 9694 58 three three CD 40436 9694 59 draughts draught NNS 40436 9694 60 of of IN 40436 9694 61 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9694 62 would would MD 40436 9694 63 be be VB 40436 9694 64 necessary necessary JJ 40436 9694 65 instead instead RB 40436 9694 66 of of IN 40436 9694 67 one one CD 40436 9694 68 . . . 40436 9695 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9695 2 6 6 CD 40436 9695 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9695 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9695 5 even even RB 40436 9695 6 advances advance VBZ 40436 9695 7 the the DT 40436 9695 8 position position NN 40436 9695 9 that that IN 40436 9695 10 death death NN 40436 9695 11 appears appear VBZ 40436 9695 12 to to IN 40436 9695 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9695 14 as as IN 40436 9695 15 a a DT 40436 9695 16 benefit benefit NN 40436 9695 17 rather rather RB 40436 9695 18 than than IN 40436 9695 19 a a DT 40436 9695 20 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 9695 21 , , , 40436 9695 22 and and CC 40436 9695 23 that that IN 40436 9695 24 every every DT 40436 9695 25 true true JJ 40436 9695 26 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9695 27 ought ought MD 40436 9695 28 to to TO 40436 9695 29 prefer prefer VB 40436 9695 30 death death NN 40436 9695 31 to to IN 40436 9695 32 life life NN 40436 9695 33 , , , 40436 9695 34 assuming assume VBG 40436 9695 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9695 36 to to TO 40436 9695 37 supervene supervene VB 40436 9695 38 without without IN 40436 9695 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9695 40 own own JJ 40436 9695 41 act act NN 40436 9695 42 -- -- : 40436 9695 43 suicide suicide NN 40436 9695 44 being be VBG 40436 9695 45 forbidden forbid VBN 40436 9695 46 by by IN 40436 9695 47 the the DT 40436 9695 48 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 9695 49 . . . 40436 9696 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9696 2 is be VBZ 40436 9696 3 represented represent VBN 40436 9696 4 as as IN 40436 9696 5 " " `` 40436 9696 6 placidus placidus NNP 40436 9696 7 ore ore NNP 40436 9696 8 , , , 40436 9696 9 intrepidus intrepidus NNP 40436 9696 10 verbis verbis NNP 40436 9696 11 ; ; : 40436 9696 12 intempestivas intempestivas NNP 40436 9696 13 suorum suorum NNP 40436 9696 14 lacrimas lacrimas NNP 40436 9696 15 coercens"--to coercens"--to NNP 40436 9696 16 borrow borrow VBP 40436 9696 17 a a DT 40436 9696 18 phrase phrase NN 40436 9696 19 from from IN 40436 9696 20 Tacitus Tacitus NNP 40436 9696 21 's 's POS 40436 9696 22 striking striking JJ 40436 9696 23 picture picture NN 40436 9696 24 of of IN 40436 9696 25 the the DT 40436 9696 26 last last JJ 40436 9696 27 hours hour NNS 40436 9696 28 of of IN 40436 9696 29 the the DT 40436 9696 30 Emperor Emperor NNP 40436 9696 31 Otho Otho NNP 40436 9696 32 . . . 40436 9697 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9697 2 7 7 LS 40436 9697 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9697 4 To to TO 40436 9697 5 see see VB 40436 9697 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9697 7 thus thus RB 40436 9697 8 undisturbed undisturbed JJ 40436 9697 9 , , , 40436 9697 10 and and CC 40436 9697 11 even even RB 40436 9697 12 welcoming welcome VBG 40436 9697 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9697 14 approaching approaching JJ 40436 9697 15 end end NN 40436 9697 16 , , , 40436 9697 17 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 9697 18 hurts hurt VBZ 40436 9697 19 the the DT 40436 9697 20 feelings feeling NNS 40436 9697 21 of of IN 40436 9697 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9697 23 assembled assembled JJ 40436 9697 24 friends friend NNS 40436 9697 25 , , , 40436 9697 26 who who WP 40436 9697 27 are be VBP 40436 9697 28 in in IN 40436 9697 29 the the DT 40436 9697 30 deepest deep JJS 40436 9697 31 affliction affliction NN 40436 9697 32 at at IN 40436 9697 33 the the DT 40436 9697 34 certainty certainty NN 40436 9697 35 of of IN 40436 9697 36 so so RB 40436 9697 37 soon soon RB 40436 9697 38 losing lose VBG 40436 9697 39 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9697 40 . . . 40436 9698 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9698 2 undertakes undertake NNS 40436 9698 3 to to TO 40436 9698 4 defend defend VB 40436 9698 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9698 6 before before IN 40436 9698 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9698 8 as as IN 40436 9698 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9698 10 had have VBD 40436 9698 11 done do VBN 40436 9698 12 before before IN 40436 9698 13 the the DT 40436 9698 14 Dikasts Dikasts NNPS 40436 9698 15 ; ; : 40436 9698 16 and and CC 40436 9698 17 to to TO 40436 9698 18 show show VB 40436 9698 19 good good JJ 40436 9698 20 grounds ground NNS 40436 9698 21 for for IN 40436 9698 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9698 23 belief belief NN 40436 9698 24 , , , 40436 9698 25 that that DT 40436 9698 26 death death NN 40436 9698 27 is be VBZ 40436 9698 28 not not RB 40436 9698 29 a a DT 40436 9698 30 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 9698 31 , , , 40436 9698 32 but but CC 40436 9698 33 a a DT 40436 9698 34 benefit benefit NN 40436 9698 35 , , , 40436 9698 36 to to IN 40436 9698 37 the the DT 40436 9698 38 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9698 39 . . . 40436 9699 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9699 2 8 8 CD 40436 9699 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9699 4 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9699 5 and and CC 40436 9699 6 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9699 7 , , , 40436 9699 8 though though IN 40436 9699 9 at at IN 40436 9699 10 first first RB 40436 9699 11 not not RB 40436 9699 12 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 9699 13 with with IN 40436 9699 14 the the DT 40436 9699 15 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 9699 16 , , , 40436 9699 17 are be VBP 40436 9699 18 nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 9699 19 reluctant reluctant JJ 40436 9699 20 to to TO 40436 9699 21 produce produce VB 40436 9699 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9699 23 doubts doubt NNS 40436 9699 24 , , , 40436 9699 25 from from IN 40436 9699 26 fear fear NN 40436 9699 27 of of IN 40436 9699 28 mortifying mortify VBG 40436 9699 29 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9699 30 in in IN 40436 9699 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9699 32 last last JJ 40436 9699 33 moments moment NNS 40436 9699 34 : : : 40436 9699 35 but but CC 40436 9699 36 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9699 37 protests protest NNS 40436 9699 38 against against IN 40436 9699 39 such such JJ 40436 9699 40 reluctance reluctance NN 40436 9699 41 as as IN 40436 9699 42 founded found VBN 40436 9699 43 on on IN 40436 9699 44 a a DT 40436 9699 45 misconception misconception NN 40436 9699 46 of of IN 40436 9699 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9699 48 existing exist VBG 40436 9699 49 frame frame NN 40436 9699 50 of of IN 40436 9699 51 mind mind NN 40436 9699 52 . . . 40436 9700 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9700 2 9 9 CD 40436 9700 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9700 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9700 5 is be VBZ 40436 9700 6 now now RB 40436 9700 7 the the DT 40436 9700 8 same same JJ 40436 9700 9 man man NN 40436 9700 10 as as IN 40436 9700 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9700 12 was be VBD 40436 9700 13 before before RB 40436 9700 14 , , , 40436 9700 15 and and CC 40436 9700 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9700 17 calls call VBZ 40436 9700 18 upon upon IN 40436 9700 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9700 20 to to TO 40436 9700 21 keep keep VB 40436 9700 22 up up RP 40436 9700 23 the the DT 40436 9700 24 freedom freedom NN 40436 9700 25 of of IN 40436 9700 26 debate debate NN 40436 9700 27 unimpaired unimpaired JJ 40436 9700 28 . . . 40436 9701 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9701 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9701 3 4 4 CD 40436 9701 4 : : : 40436 9701 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9701 6 , , , 40436 9701 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9701 8 , , , 40436 9701 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9701 10 . . . 40436 9702 1 59 59 CD 40436 9702 2 B b NN 40436 9702 3 , , , 40436 9702 4 89 89 CD 40436 9702 5 A. a. NN 40436 9703 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9703 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9703 3 : : : 40436 9703 4 tô tô NNP 40436 9703 5 = = SYM 40436 9703 6 n n CC 40436 9703 7 neani neani NNP 40436 9703 8 / / SYM 40436 9703 9 skôn skôn NN 40436 9703 10 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9703 11 lo lo NNP 40436 9703 12 / / SYM 40436 9703 13 gon gon NNP 40436 9703 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9703 15 , , , 40436 9703 16 & & CC 40436 9703 17 c. c. NNP 40436 9703 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9703 19 p. p. NN 40436 9703 20 89 89 CD 40436 9703 21 A a NN 40436 9703 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9703 23 . . . 40436 9703 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9704 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9704 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9704 3 5 5 CD 40436 9704 4 : : : 40436 9704 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9704 6 , , , 40436 9704 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9704 8 , , , 40436 9704 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9704 10 . . . 40436 9705 1 58 58 CD 40436 9705 2 - - SYM 40436 9705 3 59 59 CD 40436 9705 4 . . . 40436 9705 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9706 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9706 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9706 3 6 6 CD 40436 9706 4 : : : 40436 9706 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9706 6 , , , 40436 9706 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9706 8 , , , 40436 9706 9 p. p. NN 40436 9706 10 63 63 CD 40436 9706 11 D. D. NNP 40436 9706 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9706 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9706 14 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9706 15 7 7 CD 40436 9706 16 : : : 40436 9706 17 Tacitus Tacitus NNP 40436 9706 18 , , , 40436 9706 19 Hist Hist NNP 40436 9706 20 . . . 40436 9707 1 ii ii LS 40436 9707 2 . . . 40436 9708 1 48 48 CD 40436 9708 2 . . . 40436 9708 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9709 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9709 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9709 3 8 8 CD 40436 9709 4 : : : 40436 9709 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9709 6 , , , 40436 9709 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9709 8 , , , 40436 9709 9 p. p. NN 40436 9710 1 63 63 CD 40436 9710 2 . . . 40436 9710 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9711 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9711 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9711 3 9 9 CD 40436 9711 4 : : : 40436 9711 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9711 6 , , , 40436 9711 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9711 8 , , , 40436 9711 9 p. p. NN 40436 9711 10 84 84 CD 40436 9711 11 D D NNP 40436 9711 12 - - HYPH 40436 9711 13 E. e. NN 40436 9711 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9711 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9711 16 Side side NN 40436 9711 17 - - HYPH 40436 9711 18 note note NN 40436 9711 19 : : : 40436 9711 20 Emphasis emphasis NN 40436 9711 21 of of IN 40436 9711 22 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9711 23 in in IN 40436 9711 24 insisting insist VBG 40436 9711 25 on on IN 40436 9711 26 freedom freedom NN 40436 9711 27 of of IN 40436 9711 28 debate debate NN 40436 9711 29 , , , 40436 9711 30 active active JJ 40436 9711 31 exercise exercise NN 40436 9711 32 of of IN 40436 9711 33 reason reason NN 40436 9711 34 , , , 40436 9711 35 and and CC 40436 9711 36 independent independent JJ 40436 9711 37 judgment judgment NN 40436 9711 38 for for IN 40436 9711 39 each each DT 40436 9711 40 reasoner reasoner NN 40436 9711 41 . . . 40436 9711 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9712 1 Indeed indeed RB 40436 9712 2 this this DT 40436 9712 3 freedom freedom NN 40436 9712 4 of of IN 40436 9712 5 debate debate NN 40436 9712 6 and and CC 40436 9712 7 fulness fulness NN 40436 9712 8 of of IN 40436 9712 9 search search NN 40436 9712 10 -- -- : 40436 9712 11 the the DT 40436 9712 12 paramount paramount JJ 40436 9712 13 value value NN 40436 9712 14 of of IN 40436 9712 15 " " `` 40436 9712 16 reasoned reason VBN 40436 9712 17 truth"--the truth"--the DT 40436 9712 18 necessity necessity NN 40436 9712 19 of of IN 40436 9712 20 keeping keep VBG 40436 9712 21 up up RP 40436 9712 22 the the DT 40436 9712 23 force force NN 40436 9712 24 of of IN 40436 9712 25 individual individual JJ 40436 9712 26 reason reason NN 40436 9712 27 by by IN 40436 9712 28 constant constant JJ 40436 9712 29 argumentative argumentative JJ 40436 9712 30 exercise exercise NN 40436 9712 31 -- -- : 40436 9712 32 and and CC 40436 9712 33 the the DT 40436 9712 34 right right NN 40436 9712 35 of of IN 40436 9712 36 independent independent JJ 40436 9712 37 judgment judgment NN 40436 9712 38 for for IN 40436 9712 39 hearer hearer NN 40436 9712 40 as as RB 40436 9712 41 well well RB 40436 9712 42 as as IN 40436 9712 43 speaker speaker NN 40436 9712 44 -- -- : 40436 9712 45 stand stand VB 40436 9712 46 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 9712 47 proclaimed proclaim VBN 40436 9712 48 in in IN 40436 9712 49 these these DT 40436 9712 50 last last JJ 40436 9712 51 words word NNS 40436 9712 52 of of IN 40436 9712 53 the the DT 40436 9712 54 dying die VBG 40436 9712 55 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9712 56 . . . 40436 9713 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9713 2 does do VBZ 40436 9713 3 not not RB 40436 9713 4 announce announce VB 40436 9713 5 the the DT 40436 9713 6 immortality immortality NN 40436 9713 7 of of IN 40436 9713 8 the the DT 40436 9713 9 soul soul NN 40436 9713 10 as as IN 40436 9713 11 a a DT 40436 9713 12 dogma dogma NN 40436 9713 13 of of IN 40436 9713 14 imperative imperative JJ 40436 9713 15 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 40436 9713 16 ; ; : 40436 9713 17 which which WDT 40436 9713 18 men man NNS 40436 9713 19 , , , 40436 9713 20 whether whether IN 40436 9713 21 satisfied satisfy VBN 40436 9713 22 with with IN 40436 9713 23 the the DT 40436 9713 24 proofs proof NNS 40436 9713 25 or or CC 40436 9713 26 not not RB 40436 9713 27 , , , 40436 9713 28 must must MD 40436 9713 29 believe believe VB 40436 9713 30 , , , 40436 9713 31 or or CC 40436 9713 32 must must MD 40436 9713 33 make make VB 40436 9713 34 profession profession NN 40436 9713 35 of of IN 40436 9713 36 believing believe VBG 40436 9713 37 , , , 40436 9713 38 on on IN 40436 9713 39 pain pain NN 40436 9713 40 of of IN 40436 9713 41 being be VBG 40436 9713 42 shunned shun VBN 40436 9713 43 as as IN 40436 9713 44 a a DT 40436 9713 45 moral moral JJ 40436 9713 46 pestilence pestilence NN 40436 9713 47 , , , 40436 9713 48 and and CC 40436 9713 49 disqualified disqualify VBN 40436 9713 50 from from IN 40436 9713 51 giving give VBG 40436 9713 52 testimony testimony NN 40436 9713 53 in in IN 40436 9713 54 a a DT 40436 9713 55 court court NN 40436 9713 56 of of IN 40436 9713 57 justice justice NN 40436 9713 58 . . . 40436 9714 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9714 2 sets set VBZ 40436 9714 3 forth forth RB 40436 9714 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9714 5 own own JJ 40436 9714 6 conviction conviction NN 40436 9714 7 , , , 40436 9714 8 with with IN 40436 9714 9 the the DT 40436 9714 10 grounds ground NNS 40436 9714 11 on on IN 40436 9714 12 which which WDT 40436 9714 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9714 14 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 9714 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9714 16 . . . 40436 9715 1 But but CC 40436 9715 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9715 3 expressly expressly RB 40436 9715 4 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 9715 5 the the DT 40436 9715 6 existence existence NN 40436 9715 7 of of IN 40436 9715 8 dissentient dissentient JJ 40436 9715 9 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9715 10 : : : 40436 9715 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9715 12 invites invite VBZ 40436 9715 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9715 14 companions companion NNS 40436 9715 15 to to TO 40436 9715 16 bring bring VB 40436 9715 17 forward forward RB 40436 9715 18 every every DT 40436 9715 19 objection objection NN 40436 9715 20 : : : 40436 9715 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9715 22 disclaims disclaim VBZ 40436 9715 23 all all DT 40436 9715 24 special special JJ 40436 9715 25 purpose purpose NN 40436 9715 26 of of IN 40436 9715 27 impressing impress VBG 40436 9715 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9715 29 own own JJ 40436 9715 30 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 9715 31 upon upon IN 40436 9715 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9715 33 minds mind NNS 40436 9715 34 : : : 40436 9715 35 nay nay NNP 40436 9715 36 , , , 40436 9715 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9715 38 expressly expressly RB 40436 9715 39 warns warn VBZ 40436 9715 40 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9715 41 not not RB 40436 9715 42 to to TO 40436 9715 43 be be VB 40436 9715 44 biassed bias VBN 40436 9715 45 by by IN 40436 9715 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9715 47 personal personal JJ 40436 9715 48 sympathies sympathy NNS 40436 9715 49 , , , 40436 9715 50 then then RB 40436 9715 51 wound wind VBD 40436 9715 52 up up RP 40436 9715 53 to to IN 40436 9715 54 the the DT 40436 9715 55 highest high JJS 40436 9715 56 pitch pitch NN 40436 9715 57 , , , 40436 9715 58 towards towards IN 40436 9715 59 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9715 60 . . . 40436 9716 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9716 2 entreats entreat VBZ 40436 9716 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9716 4 to to TO 40436 9716 5 preserve preserve VB 40436 9716 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9716 7 from from IN 40436 9716 8 becoming become VBG 40436 9716 9 tinged tinge VBN 40436 9716 10 with with IN 40436 9716 11 _ _ NNP 40436 9716 12 misology misology NN 40436 9716 13 _ _ NNP 40436 9716 14 , , , 40436 9716 15 or or CC 40436 9716 16 the the DT 40436 9716 17 hatred hatred NN 40436 9716 18 of of IN 40436 9716 19 free free JJ 40436 9716 20 argumentative argumentative JJ 40436 9716 21 discussion discussion NN 40436 9716 22 : : : 40436 9716 23 and and CC 40436 9716 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9716 25 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 9716 26 this this DT 40436 9716 27 mental mental JJ 40436 9716 28 vice vice NN 40436 9716 29 to to IN 40436 9716 30 the the DT 40436 9716 31 early early JJ 40436 9716 32 habit habit NN 40436 9716 33 of of IN 40436 9716 34 easy easy JJ 40436 9716 35 , , , 40436 9716 36 uninquiring uninquiring JJ 40436 9716 37 , , , 40436 9716 38 implicit implicit JJ 40436 9716 39 , , , 40436 9716 40 belief belief NN 40436 9716 41 : : : 40436 9716 42 since since IN 40436 9716 43 a a DT 40436 9716 44 man man NN 40436 9716 45 thus thus RB 40436 9716 46 ready ready JJ 40436 9716 47 of of IN 40436 9716 48 faith faith NN 40436 9716 49 , , , 40436 9716 50 embracing embrace VBG 40436 9716 51 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9716 52 without without IN 40436 9716 53 any any DT 40436 9716 54 discriminative discriminative JJ 40436 9716 55 test test NN 40436 9716 56 , , , 40436 9716 57 presently presently RB 40436 9716 58 finds find VBZ 40436 9716 59 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9716 60 driven drive VBN 40436 9716 61 to to TO 40436 9716 62 abandon abandon VB 40436 9716 63 one one CD 40436 9716 64 opinion opinion NN 40436 9716 65 after after IN 40436 9716 66 another another DT 40436 9716 67 , , , 40436 9716 68 until until IN 40436 9716 69 at at IN 40436 9716 70 last last JJ 40436 9716 71 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9716 72 mistrusts mistrust VBZ 40436 9716 73 all all DT 40436 9716 74 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9716 75 , , , 40436 9716 76 and and CC 40436 9716 77 hates hate VBZ 40436 9716 78 the the DT 40436 9716 79 process process NN 40436 9716 80 of of IN 40436 9716 81 discussing discuss VBG 40436 9716 82 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9716 83 , , , 40436 9716 84 laying lay VBG 40436 9716 85 the the DT 40436 9716 86 blame blame NN 40436 9716 87 upon upon IN 40436 9716 88 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9716 89 instead instead RB 40436 9716 90 of of IN 40436 9716 91 upon upon IN 40436 9716 92 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9716 93 own own JJ 40436 9716 94 intellect intellect NN 40436 9716 95 . . . 40436 9717 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9717 2 10 10 CD 40436 9717 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9717 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9717 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9717 6 10 10 CD 40436 9717 7 : : : 40436 9717 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9717 9 , , , 40436 9717 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9717 11 , , , 40436 9717 12 pp pp NNP 40436 9717 13 . . . 40436 9718 1 89 89 CD 40436 9718 2 C C NNP 40436 9718 3 - - HYPH 40436 9718 4 D D NNP 40436 9718 5 , , , 40436 9718 6 90 90 CD 40436 9718 7 . . . 40436 9719 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9719 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9719 3 : : : 40436 9719 4 Prô Prô NNP 40436 9719 5 = = SYM 40436 9719 6 ton ton NN 40436 9719 7 eu)labêthô eu)labêthô NNP 40436 9719 8 = = NFP 40436 9719 9 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9719 10 / / SYM 40436 9719 11 n n CC 40436 9719 12 ti ti NNP 40436 9719 13 pa pa NNP 40436 9719 14 / / , 40436 9719 15 thos thos NNP 40436 9719 16 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9719 17 pa pa NNP 40436 9719 18 / / SYM 40436 9719 19 thômen thôman NNS 40436 9719 20 . . . 40436 9720 1 To\ To\ NNP 40436 9720 2 poi poi NNP 40436 9720 3 = = NFP 40436 9720 4 on on RB 40436 9720 5 , , , 40436 9720 6 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 9720 7 d d NNP 40436 9720 8 ' ' `` 40436 9720 9 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 9720 10 ? ? . 40436 9721 1 Mê\ Mê\ NNP 40436 9721 2 genô genô NNP 40436 9721 3 / / SYM 40436 9721 4 metha metha NNP 40436 9721 5 , , , 40436 9721 6 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 9721 7 d d NNP 40436 9721 8 ' ' '' 40436 9721 9 o(/s o(/s NNP 40436 9721 10 , , , 40436 9721 11 miso miso NNP 40436 9721 12 / / SYM 40436 9721 13 logoi logoi NNP 40436 9721 14 , , , 40436 9721 15 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 9721 16 oi oi NNP 40436 9721 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9721 18 misa misa NNP 40436 9721 19 / / SYM 40436 9721 20 nthrôpoi nthrôpoi NNP 40436 9721 21 gigno gigno NNP 40436 9721 22 / / SYM 40436 9721 23 menoi menoi NNP 40436 9721 24 ; ; : 40436 9721 25 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 9721 26 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 9721 27 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 9721 28 , , , 40436 9721 29 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 9721 30 , , , 40436 9721 31 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 9721 32 , , , 40436 9721 33 ti ti NN 40436 9721 34 a)/n a)/n UH 40436 9721 35 tis tis NNP 40436 9721 36 mei mei NNP 40436 9721 37 = = SYM 40436 9721 38 zon zon NNP 40436 9721 39 tou tou NNP 40436 9721 40 / / SYM 40436 9721 41 tou tou NNP 40436 9721 42 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 9721 43 pa pa NNP 40436 9721 44 / / SYM 40436 9721 45 thoi thoi IN 40436 9721 46 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 9721 47 lo lo NNP 40436 9721 48 / / SYM 40436 9721 49 gous gous JJ 40436 9721 50 misê misê NNP 40436 9721 51 / / SYM 40436 9721 52 sas sas NNP 40436 9721 53 . . . 40436 9721 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9722 1 p. p. NN 40436 9722 2 90 90 CD 40436 9722 3 B. b. NN 40436 9723 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9723 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9723 3 : : : 40436 9723 4 e)peida e)peida NNP 40436 9723 5 / / SYM 40436 9723 6 n n NN 40436 9723 7 tis tis NNP 40436 9723 8 pisteu pisteu NN 40436 9723 9 / / SYM 40436 9723 10 sê| sê| NNP 40436 9723 11 lo lo NNP 40436 9723 12 / / SYM 40436 9723 13 gô| gô| NNP 40436 9723 14 tini\ tini\ FW 40436 9723 15 a)lêthei= a)lêthei= FW 40436 9723 16 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 9723 17 , , , 40436 9723 18 a)/neu a)/neu RB 40436 9723 19 tê tê NN 40436 9723 20 = = SYM 40436 9723 21 s s NN 40436 9723 22 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 9723 23 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 9723 24 lo lo NNP 40436 9723 25 / / SYM 40436 9723 26 gous gous NNP 40436 9723 27 te te NNP 40436 9723 28 / / SYM 40436 9723 29 chnês chnês NNP 40436 9723 30 , , , 40436 9723 31 ka)/peita ka)/peita NNP 40436 9723 32 o)li o)li NNP 40436 9723 33 / / SYM 40436 9723 34 gon gon NNP 40436 9723 35 u(/steron u(/steron NNP 40436 9723 36 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 9723 37 do do VB 40436 9723 38 / / SYM 40436 9723 39 xê| xê| NN 40436 9723 40 pseudê\s pseudê\s CD 40436 9723 41 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 9723 42 , , , 40436 9723 43 e)ni e)ni NNS 40436 9723 44 / / SYM 40436 9723 45 ote ote NNP 40436 9723 46 me\n me\n NNP 40436 9723 47 ô)/n ô)/n NNP 40436 9723 48 , , , 40436 9723 49 e)ni e)ni NNP 40436 9723 50 / / SYM 40436 9723 51 ote ote NNP 40436 9723 52 d d NNP 40436 9723 53 ' ' POS 40436 9723 54 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 9723 55 ô)/n ô)/n NNP 40436 9723 56 , , , 40436 9723 57 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9723 58 au)=this au)=this NNP 40436 9723 59 e(/teros e(/teros NNP 40436 9723 60 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9723 61 e(/teros e(/teros NNP 40436 9723 62 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9723 63 , , , 40436 9723 64 & & CC 40436 9723 65 c. c. NNP 40436 9723 66 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9723 67 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9723 68 Side side NN 40436 9723 69 - - HYPH 40436 9723 70 note note NN 40436 9723 71 : : : 40436 9723 72 Anxiety anxiety NN 40436 9723 73 of of IN 40436 9723 74 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9723 75 that that IN 40436 9723 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9723 77 friends friend NNS 40436 9723 78 shall shall MD 40436 9723 79 be be VB 40436 9723 80 on on IN 40436 9723 81 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9723 82 guard guard NN 40436 9723 83 against against IN 40436 9723 84 being be VBG 40436 9723 85 influenced influence VBN 40436 9723 86 by by IN 40436 9723 87 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9723 88 authority authority NN 40436 9723 89 -- -- : 40436 9723 90 that that IN 40436 9723 91 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9723 92 shall shall MD 40436 9723 93 follow follow VB 40436 9723 94 only only RB 40436 9723 95 the the DT 40436 9723 96 convictions conviction NNS 40436 9723 97 of of IN 40436 9723 98 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9723 99 own own JJ 40436 9723 100 reason reason NN 40436 9723 101 . . . 40436 9723 102 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9724 1 " " `` 40436 9724 2 For for IN 40436 9724 3 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9724 4 " " '' 40436 9724 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9724 6 says say VBZ 40436 9724 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9724 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9724 9 " " `` 40436 9724 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9724 11 fear fear VBP 40436 9724 12 that that IN 40436 9724 13 in in IN 40436 9724 14 these these DT 40436 9724 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9724 16 last last JJ 40436 9724 17 hours hour NNS 40436 9724 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9724 19 depart depart VBP 40436 9724 20 from from IN 40436 9724 21 the the DT 40436 9724 22 true true JJ 40436 9724 23 spirit spirit NN 40436 9724 24 of of IN 40436 9724 25 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9724 26 -- -- : 40436 9724 27 like like IN 40436 9724 28 unschooled unschooled JJ 40436 9724 29 men man NNS 40436 9724 30 , , , 40436 9724 31 who who WP 40436 9724 32 , , , 40436 9724 33 when when WRB 40436 9724 34 in in IN 40436 9724 35 debate debate NN 40436 9724 36 , , , 40436 9724 37 think think VB 40436 9724 38 scarcely scarcely RB 40436 9724 39 at at RB 40436 9724 40 all all RB 40436 9724 41 how how WRB 40436 9724 42 the the DT 40436 9724 43 real real JJ 40436 9724 44 question question NN 40436 9724 45 stands stand VBZ 40436 9724 46 , , , 40436 9724 47 but but CC 40436 9724 48 care care VB 40436 9724 49 only only RB 40436 9724 50 to to TO 40436 9724 51 make make VB 40436 9724 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9724 53 own own JJ 40436 9724 54 views view NNS 40436 9724 55 triumphant triumphant JJ 40436 9724 56 in in IN 40436 9724 57 the the DT 40436 9724 58 minds mind NNS 40436 9724 59 of of IN 40436 9724 60 the the DT 40436 9724 61 auditors auditor NNS 40436 9724 62 . . . 40436 9725 1 Between between IN 40436 9725 2 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9725 3 and and CC 40436 9725 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9725 5 there there EX 40436 9725 6 is be VBZ 40436 9725 7 only only RB 40436 9725 8 thus thus RB 40436 9725 9 much much JJ 40436 9725 10 of of IN 40436 9725 11 difference difference NN 40436 9725 12 . . . 40436 9726 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9726 2 regard regard VBP 40436 9726 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9726 4 as as IN 40436 9726 5 a a DT 40436 9726 6 matter matter NN 40436 9726 7 of of IN 40436 9726 8 secondary secondary JJ 40436 9726 9 consequence consequence NN 40436 9726 10 , , , 40436 9726 11 whether whether IN 40436 9726 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9726 13 conclusions conclusion NNS 40436 9726 14 appear appear VBP 40436 9726 15 true true JJ 40436 9726 16 to to IN 40436 9726 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9726 18 hearers hearer NNS 40436 9726 19 ; ; : 40436 9726 20 but but CC 40436 9726 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9726 22 shall shall MD 40436 9726 23 do do VB 40436 9726 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9726 25 best good JJS 40436 9726 26 to to TO 40436 9726 27 make make VB 40436 9726 28 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9726 29 appear appear VB 40436 9726 30 as as RB 40436 9726 31 much much RB 40436 9726 32 as as IN 40436 9726 33 possible possible JJ 40436 9726 34 true true JJ 40436 9726 35 to to IN 40436 9726 36 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9726 37 . . . 40436 9727 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9727 2 11 11 CD 40436 9727 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9727 4 My -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9727 5 calculation calculation NN 40436 9727 6 is be VBZ 40436 9727 7 as as IN 40436 9727 8 follows follow VBZ 40436 9727 9 : : : 40436 9727 10 mark mark VB 40436 9727 11 how how WRB 40436 9727 12 selfish selfish JJ 40436 9727 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9727 14 is be VBZ 40436 9727 15 . . . 40436 9728 1 If if IN 40436 9728 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9728 3 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 9728 4 as as IN 40436 9728 5 to to IN 40436 9728 6 the the DT 40436 9728 7 immortality immortality NN 40436 9728 8 of of IN 40436 9728 9 the the DT 40436 9728 10 soul soul NN 40436 9728 11 is be VBZ 40436 9728 12 true true JJ 40436 9728 13 , , , 40436 9728 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9728 15 am be VBP 40436 9728 16 better well JJR 40436 9728 17 off off RP 40436 9728 18 by by IN 40436 9728 19 believing believe VBG 40436 9728 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9728 21 : : : 40436 9728 22 if if IN 40436 9728 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9728 24 am be VBP 40436 9728 25 in in IN 40436 9728 26 error error NN 40436 9728 27 , , , 40436 9728 28 and and CC 40436 9728 29 death death NN 40436 9728 30 be be VBP 40436 9728 31 the the DT 40436 9728 32 end end NN 40436 9728 33 of of IN 40436 9728 34 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9728 35 , , , 40436 9728 36 even even RB 40436 9728 37 then then RB 40436 9728 38 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9728 39 shall shall MD 40436 9728 40 avoid avoid VB 40436 9728 41 importuning importune VBG 40436 9728 42 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9728 43 friends friend NNS 40436 9728 44 with with IN 40436 9728 45 grief grief NN 40436 9728 46 , , , 40436 9728 47 during during IN 40436 9728 48 these these DT 40436 9728 49 few few JJ 40436 9728 50 remaining remain VBG 40436 9728 51 hours hour NNS 40436 9728 52 : : : 40436 9728 53 moreover moreover CC 40436 9728 54 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9728 55 error error NN 40436 9728 56 will will MD 40436 9728 57 not not RB 40436 9728 58 continue continue VB 40436 9728 59 with with IN 40436 9728 60 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9728 61 -- -- : 40436 9728 62 which which WDT 40436 9728 63 would would MD 40436 9728 64 have have VB 40436 9728 65 been be VBN 40436 9728 66 a a DT 40436 9728 67 real real JJ 40436 9728 68 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 9728 69 -- -- : 40436 9728 70 but but CC 40436 9728 71 will will MD 40436 9728 72 be be VB 40436 9728 73 extinguished extinguish VBN 40436 9728 74 very very RB 40436 9728 75 shortly shortly RB 40436 9728 76 . . . 40436 9729 1 Such such JJ 40436 9729 2 is be VBZ 40436 9729 3 the the DT 40436 9729 4 frame frame NN 40436 9729 5 of of IN 40436 9729 6 mind mind NN 40436 9729 7 , , , 40436 9729 8 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9729 9 and and CC 40436 9729 10 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9729 11 , , , 40436 9729 12 with with IN 40436 9729 13 which which WDT 40436 9729 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9729 15 approach approach VBP 40436 9729 16 the the DT 40436 9729 17 debate debate NN 40436 9729 18 . . . 40436 9730 1 Do do VBP 40436 9730 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9730 3 follow follow VB 40436 9730 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9730 5 advice advice NN 40436 9730 6 : : : 40436 9730 7 take take VB 40436 9730 8 little little JJ 40436 9730 9 thought thought NN 40436 9730 10 of of IN 40436 9730 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9730 12 , , , 40436 9730 13 but but CC 40436 9730 14 take take VB 40436 9730 15 much much RB 40436 9730 16 more more JJR 40436 9730 17 thought thought NN 40436 9730 18 of of IN 40436 9730 19 the the DT 40436 9730 20 truth truth NN 40436 9730 21 . . . 40436 9731 1 If if IN 40436 9731 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9731 3 appear appear VBP 40436 9731 4 to to IN 40436 9731 5 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9731 6 to to TO 40436 9731 7 affirm affirm VB 40436 9731 8 any any DT 40436 9731 9 thing thing NN 40436 9731 10 truly truly RB 40436 9731 11 , , , 40436 9731 12 assent assent VBP 40436 9731 13 to to IN 40436 9731 14 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9731 15 : : : 40436 9731 16 but but CC 40436 9731 17 if if IN 40436 9731 18 not not RB 40436 9731 19 , , , 40436 9731 20 oppose oppose VB 40436 9731 21 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9731 22 with with IN 40436 9731 23 all all DT 40436 9731 24 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9731 25 powers power NNS 40436 9731 26 of of IN 40436 9731 27 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 9731 28 : : : 40436 9731 29 Be be VB 40436 9731 30 on on IN 40436 9731 31 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9731 32 guard guard NN 40436 9731 33 lest lest RB 40436 9731 34 , , , 40436 9731 35 through through IN 40436 9731 36 earnest earnest JJ 40436 9731 37 zeal zeal NN 40436 9731 38 , , , 40436 9731 39 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9731 40 should should MD 40436 9731 41 deceive deceive VB 40436 9731 42 alike alike RB 40436 9731 43 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9731 44 and and CC 40436 9731 45 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9731 46 , , , 40436 9731 47 and and CC 40436 9731 48 should should MD 40436 9731 49 leave leave VB 40436 9731 50 the the DT 40436 9731 51 sting sting NN 40436 9731 52 in in IN 40436 9731 53 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9731 54 , , , 40436 9731 55 like like IN 40436 9731 56 a a DT 40436 9731 57 bee bee NN 40436 9731 58 , , , 40436 9731 59 at at IN 40436 9731 60 this this DT 40436 9731 61 hour hour NN 40436 9731 62 of of IN 40436 9731 63 departure departure NN 40436 9731 64 . . . 40436 9731 65 " " '' 40436 9732 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9732 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9732 3 11 11 CD 40436 9732 4 : : : 40436 9732 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9732 6 , , , 40436 9732 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9732 8 , , , 40436 9732 9 p. p. NN 40436 9732 10 91 91 CD 40436 9732 11 A A NNP 40436 9732 12 - - HYPH 40436 9732 13 C. C. NNP 40436 9732 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9732 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9732 16 : : : 40436 9732 17 Ou Ou NNP 40436 9732 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9732 19 ga\r ga\r VB 40436 9732 20 o(/pôs o(/pôs NN 40436 9732 21 toi toi NNP 40436 9732 22 = = SYM 40436 9732 23 s s NNP 40436 9732 24 parou parou NNP 40436 9732 25 = = -RRB- 40436 9732 26 sin sin NN 40436 9732 27 a)\ a)\ NNP 40436 9732 28 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 9732 29 le le NNP 40436 9732 30 / / SYM 40436 9732 31 gô gô NNP 40436 9732 32 do do VB 40436 9732 33 / / SYM 40436 9732 34 xei xei NNP 40436 9732 35 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 9732 36 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 9732 37 , , , 40436 9732 38 prothumê prothumê NNP 40436 9732 39 / / SYM 40436 9732 40 somai somai NNP 40436 9732 41 , , , 40436 9732 42 ei ei NNP 40436 9732 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9732 44 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9732 45 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 9732 46 pa pa NNP 40436 9732 47 / / , 40436 9732 48 rergon rergon NNP 40436 9732 49 , , , 40436 9732 50 a)/ll a)/ll : 40436 9732 51 ' ' POS 40436 9732 52 o(/pôs o(/pôs JJ 40436 9732 53 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNS 40436 9732 54 e)moi\ e)moi\ ADD 40436 9732 55 o(/ o(/ JJ 40436 9732 56 ti ti NNP 40436 9732 57 ma ma NNP 40436 9732 58 / / SYM 40436 9732 59 lista lista NNP 40436 9732 60 do do VBP 40436 9732 61 / / SYM 40436 9732 62 zei zei NNP 40436 9732 63 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 9732 64 e)/chein e)/chein RB 40436 9732 65 . . . 40436 9733 1 logi logi NNP 40436 9733 2 / / SYM 40436 9733 3 zomai zomai NNP 40436 9733 4 ga ga NNP 40436 9733 5 / / SYM 40436 9733 6 r r NNP 40436 9733 7 , , , 40436 9733 8 ô)= ô)= NNP 40436 9733 9 phi phi NNP 40436 9733 10 / / SYM 40436 9733 11 le le NNP 40436 9733 12 e(/taire e(/taire NNP 40436 9733 13 -- -- : 40436 9733 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9733 15 the the DT 40436 9733 16 / / SYM 40436 9733 17 asai asai NNP 40436 9733 18 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 9733 19 pleonektikô pleonektikô NNP 40436 9733 20 = = SYM 40436 9733 21 s s NN 40436 9733 22 -- -- : 40436 9733 23 ei ei NNP 40436 9733 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9733 25 me\n me\n NNP 40436 9733 26 tugcha tugcha NNP 40436 9733 27 / / SYM 40436 9733 28 nei nei NNP 40436 9733 29 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 9733 30 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 9733 31 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 9733 32 le le NNP 40436 9733 33 / / SYM 40436 9733 34 gô gô UH 40436 9733 35 , , , 40436 9733 36 kalô kalô NNP 40436 9733 37 = = SYM 40436 9733 38 s s NNP 40436 9733 39 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 9733 40 e)/chei e)/chei XX 40436 9733 41 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9733 42 peisthê peisthê NNP 40436 9733 43 = = SYM 40436 9733 44 nai nai NNP 40436 9733 45 ; ; : 40436 9733 46 ei ei NNP 40436 9733 47 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9733 48 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9733 49 mêde mêde NNP 40436 9733 50 / / SYM 40436 9733 51 n n NNP 40436 9733 52 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 9733 53 teleutê teleutê NNP 40436 9733 54 / / SYM 40436 9733 55 santi santi NN 40436 9733 56 , , , 40436 9733 57 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9733 58 ' ' '' 40436 9733 59 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 9733 60 tou tou NNP 40436 9733 61 = = SYM 40436 9733 62 to to NNP 40436 9733 63 / / SYM 40436 9733 64 n n NN 40436 9733 65 ge ge NNP 40436 9733 66 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9733 67 chro chro NN 40436 9733 68 / / SYM 40436 9733 69 non non JJ 40436 9733 70 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 9733 71 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9733 72 pro\ pro\ NNP 40436 9733 73 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9733 74 thana thana NNP 40436 9733 75 / / SYM 40436 9733 76 tou tou NNP 40436 9733 77 ê(=tton ê(=tton NNP 40436 9733 78 toi toi NNP 40436 9733 79 = = SYM 40436 9733 80 s s NNP 40436 9733 81 parou parou NNP 40436 9733 82 = = -RRB- 40436 9733 83 sin sin NN 40436 9733 84 a)êdê\s a)êdê\s NNP 40436 9733 85 e)/somai e)/somai NNP 40436 9733 86 o)duro o)duro CD 40436 9733 87 / / SYM 40436 9733 88 menos menos NNP 40436 9733 89 . . . 40436 9734 1 . . . 40436 9735 1 . . . 40436 9736 1 u(mei u(mei NNP 40436 9736 2 = = SYM 40436 9736 3 s s POS 40436 9736 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9736 5 / / SYM 40436 9736 6 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 9736 7 , , , 40436 9736 8 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9736 9 e)moi\ e)moi\ NNP 40436 9736 10 pei pei NNP 40436 9736 11 / / SYM 40436 9736 12 thêsthe thêsthe DT 40436 9736 13 , , , 40436 9736 14 _ _ NNP 40436 9736 15 smikro\n smikro\n ADD 40436 9736 16 phronti phronti NN 40436 9736 17 / / SYM 40436 9736 18 santes sante NNS 40436 9736 19 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 9736 20 / / SYM 40436 9736 21 tous tous JJ 40436 9736 22 , , , 40436 9736 23 tê tê NNP 40436 9736 24 = = SYM 40436 9736 25 s s NNP 40436 9736 26 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9736 27 a)lêthei a)lêthei NFP 40436 9736 28 / / SYM 40436 9736 29 as as IN 40436 9736 30 polu\ polu\ NNP 40436 9736 31 ma ma NNP 40436 9736 32 = = SYM 40436 9736 33 llon llon NNP 40436 9736 34 , , , 40436 9736 35 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 9736 36 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9736 37 / / SYM 40436 9736 38 n n CC 40436 9736 39 ti ti NNP 40436 9736 40 u(mi u(mi NN 40436 9736 41 = = SYM 40436 9736 42 n n CC 40436 9736 43 dokô= dokô= JJ 40436 9736 44 a)lêthe\s a)lêthe\s NNP 40436 9736 45 le le NNP 40436 9736 46 / / SYM 40436 9736 47 gein gein NNP 40436 9736 48 , , , 40436 9736 49 xunomologê xunomologê NNP 40436 9736 50 / / SYM 40436 9736 51 sate sate NN 40436 9736 52 ; ; : 40436 9736 53 ei ei NNP 40436 9736 54 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9736 55 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9736 56 mê/ mê/ NNP 40436 9736 57 , , , 40436 9736 58 panti\ panti\ NNP 40436 9736 59 lo lo NNP 40436 9736 60 / / SYM 40436 9736 61 gô| gô| NNP 40436 9736 62 a)ntitei a)ntitei NNP 40436 9736 63 / / SYM 40436 9736 64 nete nete JJ 40436 9736 65 _ _ NNP 40436 9736 66 , , , 40436 9736 67 eu)labou eu)labou NNP 40436 9736 68 / / SYM 40436 9736 69 menoi menoi NNP 40436 9736 70 o(/pôs o(/pôs NNP 40436 9736 71 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9736 72 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 9736 73 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 9736 74 prothumi prothumi NN 40436 9736 75 / / , 40436 9736 76 as as IN 40436 9736 77 a(/ma a(/ma NNP 40436 9736 78 e)mauto e)mauto NNP 40436 9736 79 / / SYM 40436 9736 80 n n NN 40436 9736 81 te te NNP 40436 9736 82 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9736 83 u(ma u(ma NNP 40436 9736 84 = = SYM 40436 9736 85 s s NNP 40436 9736 86 e)xapatê e)xapatê NNP 40436 9736 87 / / SYM 40436 9736 88 sas sas NNP 40436 9736 89 , , , 40436 9736 90 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 9736 91 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9736 92 / / SYM 40436 9736 93 litta litta NN 40436 9736 94 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9736 95 ke ke NNP 40436 9736 96 / / SYM 40436 9736 97 ntron ntron NNP 40436 9736 98 e)gkatalipô\n e)gkatalipô\n NNP 40436 9736 99 oi)chê oi)chê NNP 40436 9736 100 / / SYM 40436 9736 101 somai somai NNP 40436 9736 102 . . . 40436 9736 103 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9736 104 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9737 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9737 2 Side side NN 40436 9737 3 - - HYPH 40436 9737 4 note note NN 40436 9737 5 : : : 40436 9737 6 Remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 9737 7 manifestation manifestation NN 40436 9737 8 of of IN 40436 9737 9 earnest earnest JJ 40436 9737 10 interest interest NN 40436 9737 11 for for IN 40436 9737 12 reasoned reason VBN 40436 9737 13 truth truth NN 40436 9737 14 and and CC 40436 9737 15 the the DT 40436 9737 16 liberty liberty NN 40436 9737 17 of of IN 40436 9737 18 individual individual JJ 40436 9737 19 dissent dissent NN 40436 9737 20 . . . 40436 9737 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9738 1 This this DT 40436 9738 2 is be VBZ 40436 9738 3 a a DT 40436 9738 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 9738 5 passage passage NN 40436 9738 6 , , , 40436 9738 7 as as IN 40436 9738 8 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 9738 9 the the DT 40436 9738 10 spirit spirit NN 40436 9738 11 and and CC 40436 9738 12 purpose purpose NN 40436 9738 13 of of IN 40436 9738 14 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9738 15 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9738 16 . . . 40436 9739 1 In in IN 40436 9739 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9739 3 preceding precede VBG 40436 9739 4 Chapters Chapters NNPS 40436 9739 5 , , , 40436 9739 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9739 7 have have VBP 40436 9739 8 already already RB 40436 9739 9 shown show VBN 40436 9739 10 , , , 40436 9739 11 that that IN 40436 9739 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9739 13 is be VBZ 40436 9739 14 no no DT 40436 9739 15 part part NN 40436 9739 16 of of IN 40436 9739 17 the the DT 40436 9739 18 aim aim NN 40436 9739 19 of of IN 40436 9739 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9739 21 to to TO 40436 9739 22 thrust thrust VB 40436 9739 23 dogmas dogmas NN 40436 9739 24 of of IN 40436 9739 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9739 26 own own JJ 40436 9739 27 into into IN 40436 9739 28 other other JJ 40436 9739 29 men man NNS 40436 9739 30 's 's POS 40436 9739 31 minds mind NNS 40436 9739 32 as as IN 40436 9739 33 articles article NNS 40436 9739 34 of of IN 40436 9739 35 faith faith NN 40436 9739 36 . . . 40436 9740 1 But but CC 40436 9740 2 then then RB 40436 9740 3 , , , 40436 9740 4 most most JJS 40436 9740 5 of of IN 40436 9740 6 these these DT 40436 9740 7 Chapters chapter NNS 40436 9740 8 have have VBP 40436 9740 9 dwelt dwell VBN 40436 9740 10 upon upon IN 40436 9740 11 Dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9740 12 of of IN 40436 9740 13 Search Search NNP 40436 9740 14 , , , 40436 9740 15 in in IN 40436 9740 16 which which WDT 40436 9740 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9740 18 has have VBZ 40436 9740 19 appeared appear VBN 40436 9740 20 as as IN 40436 9740 21 an an DT 40436 9740 22 interrogator interrogator NN 40436 9740 23 , , , 40436 9740 24 or or CC 40436 9740 25 enquirer enquirer VB 40436 9740 26 jointly jointly RB 40436 9740 27 with with IN 40436 9740 28 others other NNS 40436 9740 29 : : : 40436 9740 30 scrutinising scrutinise VBG 40436 9740 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9740 32 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9740 33 , , , 40436 9740 34 but but CC 40436 9740 35 disclaiming disclaim VBG 40436 9740 36 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9740 37 or or CC 40436 9740 38 opinions opinion NNS 40436 9740 39 of of IN 40436 9740 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9740 41 own own JJ 40436 9740 42 . . . 40436 9741 1 Here here RB 40436 9741 2 , , , 40436 9741 3 however however RB 40436 9741 4 , , , 40436 9741 5 in in IN 40436 9741 6 the the DT 40436 9741 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9741 8 , , , 40436 9741 9 the the DT 40436 9741 10 case case NN 40436 9741 11 is be VBZ 40436 9741 12 altogether altogether RB 40436 9741 13 different different JJ 40436 9741 14 . . . 40436 9742 1 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9742 2 is be VBZ 40436 9742 3 depicted depict VBN 40436 9742 4 as as IN 40436 9742 5 having have VBG 40436 9742 6 not not RB 40436 9742 7 only only RB 40436 9742 8 an an DT 40436 9742 9 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 9742 10 opinion opinion NN 40436 9742 11 , , , 40436 9742 12 but but CC 40436 9742 13 even even RB 40436 9742 14 strong strong JJ 40436 9742 15 conviction conviction NN 40436 9742 16 , , , 40436 9742 17 on on IN 40436 9742 18 a a DT 40436 9742 19 subject subject NN 40436 9742 20 of of IN 40436 9742 21 great great JJ 40436 9742 22 moment moment NN 40436 9742 23 : : : 40436 9742 24 which which WDT 40436 9742 25 conviction conviction NN 40436 9742 26 , , , 40436 9742 27 moreover moreover RB 40436 9742 28 , , , 40436 9742 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9742 30 is be VBZ 40436 9742 31 especially especially RB 40436 9742 32 desirous desirous JJ 40436 9742 33 of of IN 40436 9742 34 preserving preserve VBG 40436 9742 35 unimpaired unimpaired JJ 40436 9742 36 , , , 40436 9742 37 during during IN 40436 9742 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9742 39 few few JJ 40436 9742 40 remaining remain VBG 40436 9742 41 hours hour NNS 40436 9742 42 of of IN 40436 9742 43 life life NN 40436 9742 44 . . . 40436 9743 1 Yet yet RB 40436 9743 2 even even RB 40436 9743 3 here here RB 40436 9743 4 , , , 40436 9743 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9743 6 manifests manifest VBZ 40436 9743 7 no no DT 40436 9743 8 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 9743 9 to to TO 40436 9743 10 get get VB 40436 9743 11 that that DT 40436 9743 12 conviction conviction NN 40436 9743 13 into into IN 40436 9743 14 the the DT 40436 9743 15 minds mind NNS 40436 9743 16 of of IN 40436 9743 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9743 18 friends friend NNS 40436 9743 19 , , , 40436 9743 20 except except IN 40436 9743 21 as as IN 40436 9743 22 a a DT 40436 9743 23 result result NN 40436 9743 24 of of IN 40436 9743 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9743 26 own own JJ 40436 9743 27 independent independent JJ 40436 9743 28 scrutiny scrutiny NN 40436 9743 29 and and CC 40436 9743 30 self self NN 40436 9743 31 - - HYPH 40436 9743 32 working work VBG 40436 9743 33 reason reason NN 40436 9743 34 . . . 40436 9744 1 Not not RB 40436 9744 2 only only RB 40436 9744 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9744 4 does do VBZ 40436 9744 5 not not RB 40436 9744 6 attempt attempt VB 40436 9744 7 to to TO 40436 9744 8 terrify terrify VB 40436 9744 9 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9744 10 into into IN 40436 9744 11 believing believe VBG 40436 9744 12 , , , 40436 9744 13 by by IN 40436 9744 14 menace menace NN 40436 9744 15 of of IN 40436 9744 16 evil evil JJ 40436 9744 17 consequences consequence NNS 40436 9744 18 if if IN 40436 9744 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9744 20 do do VBP 40436 9744 21 not not RB 40436 9744 22 -- -- : 40436 9744 23 but but CC 40436 9744 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9744 25 repudiates repudiate VBZ 40436 9744 26 pointedly pointedly RB 40436 9744 27 even even RB 40436 9744 28 the the DT 40436 9744 29 gentler gentle JJR 40436 9744 30 machinery machinery NN 40436 9744 31 of of IN 40436 9744 32 conversion conversion NN 40436 9744 33 , , , 40436 9744 34 which which WDT 40436 9744 35 might may MD 40436 9744 36 work work VB 40436 9744 37 upon upon IN 40436 9744 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9744 39 minds mind NNS 40436 9744 40 through through IN 40436 9744 41 attachment attachment NN 40436 9744 42 to to IN 40436 9744 43 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9744 44 and and CC 40436 9744 45 reverence reverence NN 40436 9744 46 for for IN 40436 9744 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9744 48 authority authority NN 40436 9744 49 . . . 40436 9745 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9745 2 devotion devotion NN 40436 9745 3 is be VBZ 40436 9745 4 to to TO 40436 9745 5 " " `` 40436 9745 6 reasoned reason VBN 40436 9745 7 truth truth NN 40436 9745 8 " " '' 40436 9745 9 : : : 40436 9745 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9745 11 challenges challenge VBZ 40436 9745 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9745 13 friends friend NNS 40436 9745 14 to to IN 40436 9745 15 the the DT 40436 9745 16 fullest full JJS 40436 9745 17 scrutiny scrutiny NN 40436 9745 18 by by IN 40436 9745 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9745 20 own own JJ 40436 9745 21 independent independent JJ 40436 9745 22 reason reason NN 40436 9745 23 : : : 40436 9745 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9745 25 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 9745 26 the the DT 40436 9745 27 sentence sentence NN 40436 9745 28 which which WDT 40436 9745 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9745 30 pronounce pronounce VBP 40436 9745 31 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 9745 32 as as IN 40436 9745 33 valid valid JJ 40436 9745 34 _ _ NNP 40436 9745 35 for for IN 40436 9745 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9745 37 _ _ NNP 40436 9745 38 , , , 40436 9745 39 whether whether IN 40436 9745 40 concurrent concurrent JJ 40436 9745 41 with with IN 40436 9745 42 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9745 43 or or CC 40436 9745 44 adverse adverse RB 40436 9745 45 . . . 40436 9746 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9746 2 reason reason NN 40436 9746 3 is be VBZ 40436 9746 4 for for IN 40436 9746 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9746 6 , , , 40436 9746 7 what what WP 40436 9746 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9746 9 reason reason NN 40436 9746 10 is be VBZ 40436 9746 11 for for IN 40436 9746 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9746 13 : : : 40436 9746 14 requiring require VBG 40436 9746 15 , , , 40436 9746 16 both both CC 40436 9746 17 alike alike RB 40436 9746 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9746 19 as as IN 40436 9746 20 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9746 21 here here RB 40436 9746 22 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 9746 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9746 24 , , , 40436 9746 25 to to TO 40436 9746 26 be be VB 40436 9746 27 stimulated stimulate VBN 40436 9746 28 as as RB 40436 9746 29 well well RB 40436 9746 30 as as IN 40436 9746 31 controlled control VBN 40436 9746 32 by by IN 40436 9746 33 all all RB 40436 9746 34 - - HYPH 40436 9746 35 searching search VBG 40436 9746 36 debate debate NN 40436 9746 37 -- -- : 40436 9746 38 but but CC 40436 9746 39 postulating postulate VBG 40436 9746 40 equal equal JJ 40436 9746 41 liberty liberty NN 40436 9746 42 of of IN 40436 9746 43 final final JJ 40436 9746 44 decision decision NN 40436 9746 45 for for IN 40436 9746 46 each each DT 40436 9746 47 one one CD 40436 9746 48 of of IN 40436 9746 49 the the DT 40436 9746 50 debaters debater NNS 40436 9746 51 . . . 40436 9747 1 The the DT 40436 9747 2 stress stress NN 40436 9747 3 laid lay VBN 40436 9747 4 by by IN 40436 9747 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9747 6 upon upon IN 40436 9747 7 the the DT 40436 9747 8 full full JJ 40436 9747 9 liberty liberty NN 40436 9747 10 of of IN 40436 9747 11 dissenting dissent VBG 40436 9747 12 reason reason NN 40436 9747 13 , , , 40436 9747 14 essential essential JJ 40436 9747 15 to to IN 40436 9747 16 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 9747 17 debate debate NN 40436 9747 18 -- -- : 40436 9747 19 is be VBZ 40436 9747 20 one one CD 40436 9747 21 of of IN 40436 9747 22 the the DT 40436 9747 23 most most RBS 40436 9747 24 memorable memorable JJ 40436 9747 25 characteristics characteristic NNS 40436 9747 26 of of IN 40436 9747 27 the the DT 40436 9747 28 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9747 29 . . . 40436 9748 1 When when WRB 40436 9748 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9748 3 come come VBP 40436 9748 4 to to IN 40436 9748 5 the the DT 40436 9748 6 treatise treatise NN 40436 9748 7 De De NNP 40436 9748 8 Legibus Legibus NNP 40436 9748 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9748 10 where where WRB 40436 9748 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9748 12 does do VBZ 40436 9748 13 not not RB 40436 9748 14 appear appear VB 40436 9748 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9748 16 , , , 40436 9748 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9748 18 shall shall MD 40436 9748 19 find find VB 40436 9748 20 a a DT 40436 9748 21 totally totally RB 40436 9748 22 opposite opposite JJ 40436 9748 23 view view NN 40436 9748 24 of of IN 40436 9748 25 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 9748 26 . . . 40436 9749 1 In in IN 40436 9749 2 the the DT 40436 9749 3 tenth tenth JJ 40436 9749 4 book book NN 40436 9749 5 of of IN 40436 9749 6 that that DT 40436 9749 7 treatise treatise NN 40436 9749 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9749 9 enforces enforce VBZ 40436 9749 10 the the DT 40436 9749 11 rigid rigid JJ 40436 9749 12 censorship censorship NN 40436 9749 13 of of IN 40436 9749 14 an an DT 40436 9749 15 orthodox orthodox JJ 40436 9749 16 persecutor persecutor NN 40436 9749 17 , , , 40436 9749 18 who who WP 40436 9749 19 makes make VBZ 40436 9749 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9749 21 own own JJ 40436 9749 22 reason reason NN 40436 9749 23 binding binding NN 40436 9749 24 and and CC 40436 9749 25 compulsory compulsory NN 40436 9749 26 on on IN 40436 9749 27 all all DT 40436 9749 28 . . . 40436 9750 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9750 2 Side side NN 40436 9750 3 - - HYPH 40436 9750 4 note note NN 40436 9750 5 : : : 40436 9750 6 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9750 7 and and CC 40436 9750 8 Symposion symposion NN 40436 9750 9 -- -- : 40436 9750 10 points point NNS 40436 9750 11 of of IN 40436 9750 12 analogy analogy NN 40436 9750 13 and and CC 40436 9750 14 contrast contrast NN 40436 9750 15 . . . 40436 9750 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9751 1 The the DT 40436 9751 2 natural natural JJ 40436 9751 3 counterpart counterpart NN 40436 9751 4 and and CC 40436 9751 5 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9751 6 to to IN 40436 9751 7 the the DT 40436 9751 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9751 9 , , , 40436 9751 10 is be VBZ 40436 9751 11 found find VBN 40436 9751 12 in in IN 40436 9751 13 the the DT 40436 9751 14 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 9751 15 . . . 40436 9752 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9752 2 12 12 CD 40436 9752 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9752 4 In in IN 40436 9752 5 both both DT 40436 9752 6 , , , 40436 9752 7 the the DT 40436 9752 8 personality personality NN 40436 9752 9 of of IN 40436 9752 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9752 11 stands stand VBZ 40436 9752 12 out out RP 40436 9752 13 with with IN 40436 9752 14 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 9752 15 force force NN 40436 9752 16 : : : 40436 9752 17 in in IN 40436 9752 18 the the DT 40436 9752 19 one one NN 40436 9752 20 , , , 40436 9752 21 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9752 22 is be VBZ 40436 9752 23 in in IN 40436 9752 24 the the DT 40436 9752 25 fulness fulness NN 40436 9752 26 of of IN 40436 9752 27 life life NN 40436 9752 28 and and CC 40436 9752 29 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9752 30 , , , 40436 9752 31 along along IN 40436 9752 32 with with IN 40436 9752 33 festive festive JJ 40436 9752 34 comrades comrade NNS 40436 9752 35 -- -- : 40436 9752 36 in in IN 40436 9752 37 the the DT 40436 9752 38 other other JJ 40436 9752 39 , , , 40436 9752 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9752 41 is be VBZ 40436 9752 42 on on IN 40436 9752 43 the the DT 40436 9752 44 verge verge NN 40436 9752 45 of of IN 40436 9752 46 approaching approach VBG 40436 9752 47 death death NN 40436 9752 48 , , , 40436 9752 49 surrounded surround VBN 40436 9752 50 by by IN 40436 9752 51 companions companion NNS 40436 9752 52 in in IN 40436 9752 53 deep deep JJ 40436 9752 54 affliction affliction NN 40436 9752 55 . . . 40436 9753 1 The the DT 40436 9753 2 point point NN 40436 9753 3 common common JJ 40436 9753 4 to to IN 40436 9753 5 both both DT 40436 9753 6 , , , 40436 9753 7 is be VBZ 40436 9753 8 , , , 40436 9753 9 the the DT 40436 9753 10 perfect perfect JJ 40436 9753 11 self self NN 40436 9753 12 - - HYPH 40436 9753 13 command command NN 40436 9753 14 of of IN 40436 9753 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9753 16 under under IN 40436 9753 17 a a DT 40436 9753 18 diversity diversity NN 40436 9753 19 of of IN 40436 9753 20 trying try VBG 40436 9753 21 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 9753 22 . . . 40436 9754 1 In in IN 40436 9754 2 the the DT 40436 9754 3 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 9754 4 , , , 40436 9754 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9754 6 read read VBD 40436 9754 7 of of IN 40436 9754 8 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9754 9 as as IN 40436 9754 10 triumphing triumph VBG 40436 9754 11 over over IN 40436 9754 12 heat heat NN 40436 9754 13 , , , 40436 9754 14 cold cold JJ 40436 9754 15 , , , 40436 9754 16 fatigue fatigue NN 40436 9754 17 , , , 40436 9754 18 danger danger NN 40436 9754 19 , , , 40436 9754 20 amorous amorous JJ 40436 9754 21 temptation temptation NN 40436 9754 22 , , , 40436 9754 23 unmeasured unmeasured JJ 40436 9754 24 potations potation NNS 40436 9754 25 of of IN 40436 9754 26 wine wine NN 40436 9754 27 , , , 40436 9754 28 & & CC 40436 9754 29 c.:[13 c.:[13 NNP 40436 9754 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9754 31 in in IN 40436 9754 32 the the DT 40436 9754 33 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9754 34 , , , 40436 9754 35 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9754 36 discover discover VBP 40436 9754 37 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9754 38 rising rise VBG 40436 9754 39 superior superior JJ 40436 9754 40 to to IN 40436 9754 41 the the DT 40436 9754 42 fear fear NN 40436 9754 43 of of IN 40436 9754 44 death death NN 40436 9754 45 , , , 40436 9754 46 and and CC 40436 9754 47 to to IN 40436 9754 48 the the DT 40436 9754 49 contagion contagion NN 40436 9754 50 of of IN 40436 9754 51 an an DT 40436 9754 52 afflicted afflict VBN 40436 9754 53 company company NN 40436 9754 54 around around IN 40436 9754 55 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9754 56 . . . 40436 9755 1 Still still RB 40436 9755 2 , , , 40436 9755 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9755 4 resolute resolute JJ 40436 9755 5 volition volition NN 40436 9755 6 is be VBZ 40436 9755 7 occasionally occasionally RB 40436 9755 8 overpowered overpower VBN 40436 9755 9 by by IN 40436 9755 10 fits fit NNS 40436 9755 11 of of IN 40436 9755 12 absorbing absorb VBG 40436 9755 13 meditation meditation NN 40436 9755 14 , , , 40436 9755 15 which which WDT 40436 9755 16 seize seize VBP 40436 9755 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9755 18 at at IN 40436 9755 19 moments moment NNS 40436 9755 20 sudden sudden JJ 40436 9755 21 and and CC 40436 9755 22 unaccountable unaccountable JJ 40436 9755 23 , , , 40436 9755 24 and and CC 40436 9755 25 chain chain VB 40436 9755 26 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9755 27 to to IN 40436 9755 28 the the DT 40436 9755 29 spot spot NN 40436 9755 30 for for IN 40436 9755 31 a a DT 40436 9755 32 long long JJ 40436 9755 33 time time NN 40436 9755 34 . . . 40436 9756 1 There there EX 40436 9756 2 is be VBZ 40436 9756 3 moreover moreover RB 40436 9756 4 , , , 40436 9756 5 in in IN 40436 9756 6 both both DT 40436 9756 7 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9756 8 , , , 40436 9756 9 a a DT 40436 9756 10 streak streak NN 40436 9756 11 of of IN 40436 9756 12 eccentricity eccentricity NN 40436 9756 13 in in IN 40436 9756 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9756 15 character character NN 40436 9756 16 , , , 40436 9756 17 which which WDT 40436 9756 18 belongs belong VBZ 40436 9756 19 to to IN 40436 9756 20 what what WP 40436 9756 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9756 22 calls call VBZ 40436 9756 23 the the DT 40436 9756 24 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 9756 25 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 9756 26 and and CC 40436 9756 27 madness madness NN 40436 9756 28 , , , 40436 9756 29 rising rise VBG 40436 9756 30 above above IN 40436 9756 31 the the DT 40436 9756 32 measure measure NN 40436 9756 33 of of IN 40436 9756 34 human human JJ 40436 9756 35 temperance temperance NN 40436 9756 36 and and CC 40436 9756 37 prudence prudence NN 40436 9756 38 . . . 40436 9757 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9757 2 14 14 CD 40436 9757 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9757 4 The the DT 40436 9757 5 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9757 6 depicts depict VBZ 40436 9757 7 in in IN 40436 9757 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9757 9 the the DT 40436 9757 10 same same JJ 40436 9757 11 intense intense JJ 40436 9757 12 love love NN 40436 9757 13 of of IN 40436 9757 14 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9757 15 and and CC 40436 9757 16 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 9757 17 debate debate NN 40436 9757 18 , , , 40436 9757 19 as as IN 40436 9757 20 the the DT 40436 9757 21 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 9757 22 and and CC 40436 9757 23 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 9757 24 : : : 40436 9757 25 but but CC 40436 9757 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9757 27 makes make VBZ 40436 9757 28 no no DT 40436 9757 29 allusion allusion NN 40436 9757 30 to to IN 40436 9757 31 that that DT 40436 9757 32 personal personal JJ 40436 9757 33 attachment attachment NN 40436 9757 34 , , , 40436 9757 35 and and CC 40436 9757 36 passionate passionate JJ 40436 9757 37 admiration admiration NN 40436 9757 38 of of IN 40436 9757 39 youthful youthful JJ 40436 9757 40 beauty beauty NN 40436 9757 41 , , , 40436 9757 42 with with IN 40436 9757 43 which which WDT 40436 9757 44 , , , 40436 9757 45 according accord VBG 40436 9757 46 to to IN 40436 9757 47 those those DT 40436 9757 48 two two CD 40436 9757 49 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9757 50 , , , 40436 9757 51 the the DT 40436 9757 52 mental mental JJ 40436 9757 53 fermentation fermentation NN 40436 9757 54 of of IN 40436 9757 55 the the DT 40436 9757 56 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 9757 57 aspirant aspirant NN 40436 9757 58 is be VBZ 40436 9757 59 asserted assert VBN 40436 9757 60 to to TO 40436 9757 61 begin begin VB 40436 9757 62 . . . 40436 9758 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9758 2 15 15 CD 40436 9758 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9758 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9758 5 in in IN 40436 9758 6 the the DT 40436 9758 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9758 8 describes describe VBZ 40436 9758 9 the the DT 40436 9758 10 initial initial JJ 40436 9758 11 steps step NNS 40436 9758 12 whereby whereby WRB 40436 9758 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9758 14 had have VBD 40436 9758 15 been be VBN 40436 9758 16 led lead VBN 40436 9758 17 to to IN 40436 9758 18 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 9758 19 study:[16 study:[16 , 40436 9758 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9758 21 but but CC 40436 9758 22 the the DT 40436 9758 23 process process NN 40436 9758 24 is be VBZ 40436 9758 25 one one CD 40436 9758 26 purely purely RB 40436 9758 27 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9758 28 , , , 40436 9758 29 without without IN 40436 9758 30 reference reference NN 40436 9758 31 to to IN 40436 9758 32 personal personal JJ 40436 9758 33 converse converse NN 40436 9758 34 with with IN 40436 9758 35 beloved beloved JJ 40436 9758 36 companions companion NNS 40436 9758 37 , , , 40436 9758 38 as as IN 40436 9758 39 a a DT 40436 9758 40 necessity necessity NN 40436 9758 41 of of IN 40436 9758 42 the the DT 40436 9758 43 case case NN 40436 9758 44 . . . 40436 9759 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9759 2 discourse discourse NN 40436 9759 3 is be VBZ 40436 9759 4 that that DT 40436 9759 5 of of IN 40436 9759 6 a a DT 40436 9759 7 man man NN 40436 9759 8 on on IN 40436 9759 9 the the DT 40436 9759 10 point point NN 40436 9759 11 of of IN 40436 9759 12 death--"abruptis death--"abruptis : 40436 9759 13 vitæ vitæ NN 40436 9759 14 blandimentis"[17]--and blandimentis"[17]--and RB 40436 9759 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9759 16 already already RB 40436 9759 17 looks look VBZ 40436 9759 18 upon upon IN 40436 9759 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9759 20 body body NN 40436 9759 21 , , , 40436 9759 22 not not RB 40436 9759 23 as as IN 40436 9759 24 furnishing furnish VBG 40436 9759 25 the the DT 40436 9759 26 means mean NNS 40436 9759 27 of of IN 40436 9759 28 action action NN 40436 9759 29 and and CC 40436 9759 30 as as IN 40436 9759 31 requiring require VBG 40436 9759 32 only only RB 40436 9759 33 to to TO 40436 9759 34 be be VB 40436 9759 35 trained train VBN 40436 9759 36 by by IN 40436 9759 37 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 9759 38 discipline discipline NN 40436 9759 39 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9759 40 as as IN 40436 9759 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9759 42 appears appear VBZ 40436 9759 43 in in IN 40436 9759 44 the the DT 40436 9759 45 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9759 46 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9759 47 , , , 40436 9759 48 but but CC 40436 9759 49 as as IN 40436 9759 50 an an DT 40436 9759 51 importunate importunate NN 40436 9759 52 and and CC 40436 9759 53 depraving deprave VBG 40436 9759 54 companion companion NN 40436 9759 55 , , , 40436 9759 56 of of IN 40436 9759 57 which which WDT 40436 9759 58 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9759 59 is be VBZ 40436 9759 60 glad glad JJ 40436 9759 61 to to TO 40436 9759 62 get get VB 40436 9759 63 rid rid VBN 40436 9759 64 : : : 40436 9759 65 so so IN 40436 9759 66 that that IN 40436 9759 67 the the DT 40436 9759 68 ethereal ethereal JJ 40436 9759 69 substance substance NN 40436 9759 70 of of IN 40436 9759 71 the the DT 40436 9759 72 soul soul NN 40436 9759 73 may may MD 40436 9759 74 be be VB 40436 9759 75 left leave VBN 40436 9759 76 to to IN 40436 9759 77 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9759 78 free free JJ 40436 9759 79 expansion expansion NN 40436 9759 80 and and CC 40436 9759 81 fellowship fellowship NN 40436 9759 82 with with IN 40436 9759 83 the the DT 40436 9759 84 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 9759 85 world world NN 40436 9759 86 , , , 40436 9759 87 apart apart RB 40436 9759 88 from from IN 40436 9759 89 sense sense NN 40436 9759 90 and and CC 40436 9759 91 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9759 92 solicitations solicitation NNS 40436 9759 93 . . . 40436 9760 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9760 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9760 3 12 12 CD 40436 9760 4 : : : 40436 9760 5 Thus thus RB 40436 9760 6 far far RB 40436 9760 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9760 8 agree agree VBP 40436 9760 9 with with IN 40436 9760 10 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 40436 9760 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9760 12 Einleitung Einleitung NNP 40436 9760 13 zum zum NN 40436 9760 14 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9760 15 , , , 40436 9760 16 p. p. NN 40436 9760 17 9 9 CD 40436 9760 18 , , , 40436 9760 19 & & CC 40436 9760 20 c. c. NNP 40436 9760 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9760 22 ; ; : 40436 9760 23 though though IN 40436 9760 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9760 25 do do VBP 40436 9760 26 not not RB 40436 9760 27 think think VB 40436 9760 28 that that IN 40436 9760 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9760 30 has have VBZ 40436 9760 31 shown show VBN 40436 9760 32 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 9760 33 ground ground NN 40436 9760 34 for for IN 40436 9760 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9760 36 theory theory NN 40436 9760 37 regarding regard VBG 40436 9760 38 the the DT 40436 9760 39 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 9760 40 and and CC 40436 9760 41 the the DT 40436 9760 42 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9760 43 , , , 40436 9760 44 as as RB 40436 9760 45 jointly jointly RB 40436 9760 46 intended intend VBN 40436 9760 47 to to TO 40436 9760 48 depict depict VB 40436 9760 49 the the DT 40436 9760 50 character character NN 40436 9760 51 of of IN 40436 9760 52 the the DT 40436 9760 53 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9760 54 , , , 40436 9760 55 promised promise VBN 40436 9760 56 by by IN 40436 9760 57 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9760 58 as as IN 40436 9760 59 a a DT 40436 9760 60 sequel sequel NN 40436 9760 61 to to IN 40436 9760 62 the the DT 40436 9760 63 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 9760 64 and and CC 40436 9760 65 the the DT 40436 9760 66 Statesman Statesman NNP 40436 9760 67 . . . 40436 9761 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9761 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9761 3 , , , 40436 9761 4 Sophist Sophist NNP 40436 9761 5 . . . 40436 9762 1 p. p. NN 40436 9762 2 217 217 CD 40436 9762 3 ; ; : 40436 9762 4 Politic politic JJ 40436 9762 5 . . . 40436 9763 1 p. p. NN 40436 9764 1 257 257 CD 40436 9764 2 . . . 40436 9764 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9764 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9765 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9765 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9765 3 13 13 CD 40436 9765 4 : : : 40436 9765 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9765 6 , , , 40436 9765 7 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 9765 8 , , , 40436 9765 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9765 10 . . . 40436 9766 1 214 214 CD 40436 9766 2 A a DT 40436 9766 3 , , , 40436 9766 4 219 219 CD 40436 9766 5 D d NN 40436 9766 6 , , , 40436 9766 7 220 220 CD 40436 9766 8 - - HYPH 40436 9766 9 221 221 CD 40436 9766 10 - - HYPH 40436 9766 11 223 223 CD 40436 9766 12 D d NN 40436 9766 13 : : : 40436 9766 14 compare compare NNP 40436 9766 15 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9766 16 , , , 40436 9766 17 p. p. NN 40436 9766 18 116 116 CD 40436 9766 19 , , , 40436 9766 20 c. c. NN 40436 9766 21 117 117 CD 40436 9766 22 . . . 40436 9767 1 Marcus Marcus NNP 40436 9767 2 Antoninus Antoninus NNP 40436 9767 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9767 4 i. i. NNP 40436 9768 1 16 16 LS 40436 9768 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9768 3 compares compare VBZ 40436 9768 4 on on IN 40436 9768 5 this this DT 40436 9768 6 point point NN 40436 9768 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9768 8 father father NN 40436 9768 9 Antoninus Antoninus NNP 40436 9768 10 Pius Pius NNP 40436 9768 11 to to IN 40436 9768 12 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9768 13 : : : 40436 9768 14 both both DT 40436 9768 15 were be VBD 40436 9768 16 capable capable JJ 40436 9768 17 of of IN 40436 9768 18 enjoyment enjoyment NN 40436 9768 19 as as RB 40436 9768 20 well well RB 40436 9768 21 as as IN 40436 9768 22 of of IN 40436 9768 23 abstinence abstinence NN 40436 9768 24 , , , 40436 9768 25 without without IN 40436 9768 26 ever ever RB 40436 9768 27 losing lose VBG 40436 9768 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9768 29 self self NN 40436 9768 30 - - HYPH 40436 9768 31 command command NN 40436 9768 32 . . . 40436 9769 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9769 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9769 3 : : : 40436 9769 4 E)pharmo e)pharmo NN 40436 9769 5 / / SYM 40436 9769 6 seie seie NN 40436 9769 7 d d NN 40436 9769 8 ' ' `` 40436 9769 9 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 9769 10 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 9769 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9769 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9769 13 Antoninus Antoninus NNP 40436 9769 14 P. P. NNP 40436 9769 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9769 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9769 17 Greek greek NN 40436 9769 18 : : : 40436 9769 19 to\ to\ NN 40436 9769 20 peri\ peri\ . 40436 9769 21 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9769 22 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 9769 23 / / SYM 40436 9769 24 tous tous JJ 40436 9769 25 mnêmoneuo mnêmoneuo NNP 40436 9769 26 / / SYM 40436 9769 27 menon menon NNP 40436 9769 28 , , , 40436 9769 29 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 9769 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9769 31 a)pe a)pe NNP 40436 9769 32 / / SYM 40436 9769 33 chesthai chesthai NNP 40436 9769 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9769 35 a)polau a)polau NNP 40436 9769 36 / / SYM 40436 9769 37 ein ein NNP 40436 9769 38 e)du e)du NNP 40436 9769 39 / / SYM 40436 9769 40 nato nato NNP 40436 9769 41 tou tou NNP 40436 9769 42 / / SYM 40436 9769 43 tôn tôn NNP 40436 9769 44 , , , 40436 9769 45 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 9769 46 polloi\ polloi\ NN 40436 9769 47 pro pro FW 40436 9769 48 / / SYM 40436 9769 49 s s JJ 40436 9769 50 te te NNP 40436 9769 51 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 9769 52 a)pocha\s a)pocha\s NN 40436 9769 53 a)sthenô a)sthenô , 40436 9769 54 = = SYM 40436 9769 55 s s NNP 40436 9769 56 , , , 40436 9769 57 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9769 58 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 9769 59 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 9769 60 a)polau a)polau NNP 40436 9769 61 / / SYM 40436 9769 62 seis seis NNP 40436 9769 63 e)ndotikô e)ndotikô NNPS 40436 9769 64 = = SYM 40436 9769 65 s s NNP 40436 9769 66 , , , 40436 9769 67 e)/chousin e)/chousin NNP 40436 9769 68 . . . 40436 9770 1 To\ To\ NNP 40436 9770 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9770 3 i)schu i)schu NNP 40436 9770 4 / / SYM 40436 9770 5 ein ein NNP 40436 9770 6 , , , 40436 9770 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9770 8 e)/ti e)/ti NNP 40436 9770 9 karterei karterei NNP 40436 9770 10 = = SYM 40436 9770 11 n n NNP 40436 9770 12 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9770 13 e)nnê e)nnê NNP 40436 9770 14 / / SYM 40436 9770 15 phein phein NNP 40436 9770 16 e(kate e(kate NNP 40436 9770 17 / / SYM 40436 9770 18 rô| rô| NNP 40436 9770 19 , , , 40436 9770 20 a)ndro\s a)ndro\s NNP 40436 9770 21 e)/stin e)/stin NNP 40436 9770 22 a)/rtion a)/rtion NNP 40436 9770 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9770 24 a)êttêton a)êttêton NNPS 40436 9770 25 psuchê\n psuchê\n NNP 40436 9770 26 e)/chontos e)/chonto NNS 40436 9770 27 . . . 40436 9770 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9770 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9771 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9771 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9771 3 14 14 CD 40436 9771 4 : : : 40436 9771 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9771 6 , , , 40436 9771 7 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 9771 8 , , , 40436 9771 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9771 10 . . . 40436 9772 1 174 174 CD 40436 9772 2 - - HYPH 40436 9772 3 175 175 CD 40436 9772 4 - - HYPH 40436 9772 5 220 220 CD 40436 9772 6 C C NNP 40436 9772 7 - - HYPH 40436 9772 8 D. D. NNP 40436 9773 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 9773 2 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9773 3 , , , 40436 9773 4 pp pp NNP 40436 9773 5 . . . 40436 9774 1 84 84 CD 40436 9774 2 C C NNP 40436 9774 3 , , , 40436 9774 4 95 95 CD 40436 9774 5 E. E. NNP 40436 9774 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9774 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9774 8 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9774 9 15 15 CD 40436 9774 10 : : : 40436 9774 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9774 12 , , , 40436 9774 13 Sympos Sympos NNP 40436 9774 14 . . . 40436 9775 1 p. p. NN 40436 9775 2 215 215 CD 40436 9775 3 A a NN 40436 9775 4 , , , 40436 9775 5 p. p. NN 40436 9775 6 221 221 CD 40436 9775 7 D. D. NNP 40436 9775 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9775 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9775 10 : : : 40436 9775 11 oi(=os oi(=os NNP 40436 9775 12 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9775 13 ou(tosi\ ou(tosi\ NNP 40436 9775 14 ge ge NNP 40436 9775 15 / / , 40436 9775 16 gone go VBN 40436 9775 17 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9775 18 _ _ NNP 40436 9775 19 a)topi a)topi NNP 40436 9775 20 / / SYM 40436 9775 21 an an DT 40436 9775 22 _ _ NNP 40436 9775 23 a)/nthrôpos a)/nthrôpo NNS 40436 9775 24 , , , 40436 9775 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9775 26 au)to\s au)to\s NNP 40436 9775 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9775 28 oi oi NNP 40436 9775 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9775 30 lo lo NNP 40436 9775 31 / / SYM 40436 9775 32 goi goi NNP 40436 9775 33 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 9775 34 , , , 40436 9775 35 ou)d ou)d JJ 40436 9775 36 ' ' `` 40436 9775 37 e)ggu\s e)ggu\s NNP 40436 9775 38 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 9775 39 eu(/roi eu(/roi NNP 40436 9775 40 tis tis NNP 40436 9775 41 zêtô zêtô NNP 40436 9775 42 = = SYM 40436 9775 43 n n NNP 40436 9775 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9775 45 , , , 40436 9775 46 & & CC 40436 9775 47 c. c. NNP 40436 9775 48 p. p. NN 40436 9775 49 218 218 CD 40436 9775 50 B b NN 40436 9775 51 : : : 40436 9775 52 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9775 53 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9775 54 : : : 40436 9775 55 pa pa NNP 40436 9775 56 / / SYM 40436 9775 57 ntes ntes NNP 40436 9775 58 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9775 59 kekoinônê kekoinônê NNP 40436 9775 60 / / SYM 40436 9775 61 kate kate NNP 40436 9775 62 tê tê NNP 40436 9775 63 = = SYM 40436 9775 64 s s NNP 40436 9775 65 philoso philoso NNP 40436 9775 66 / / SYM 40436 9775 67 phou phou NNP 40436 9775 68 mani mani NNP 40436 9775 69 / / SYM 40436 9775 70 as as IN 40436 9775 71 te te NNP 40436 9775 72 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9775 73 bakchei bakchei NNP 40436 9775 74 / / SYM 40436 9775 75 as as IN 40436 9775 76 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9775 77 , , , 40436 9775 78 & & CC 40436 9775 79 c. c. NNP 40436 9775 80 About about IN 40436 9775 81 the the DT 40436 9775 82 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9775 83 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9775 84 : : : 40436 9775 85 philo philo JJ 40436 9775 86 / / SYM 40436 9775 87 sophos sophos NNP 40436 9775 88 mani mani NNP 40436 9775 89 / / SYM 40436 9775 90 a a LS 40436 9775 91 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9775 92 , , , 40436 9775 93 compare compare VB 40436 9775 94 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9775 95 , , , 40436 9775 96 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 9775 97 , , , 40436 9775 98 pp pp NNP 40436 9775 99 . . . 40436 9776 1 245 245 CD 40436 9776 2 - - SYM 40436 9776 3 250 250 CD 40436 9776 4 . . . 40436 9777 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9777 2 , , , 40436 9777 3 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 9777 4 , , , 40436 9777 5 pp pp NNP 40436 9777 6 . . . 40436 9778 1 251 251 CD 40436 9778 2 - - SYM 40436 9778 3 253 253 CD 40436 9778 4 . . . 40436 9779 1 Symposion symposion NN 40436 9779 2 , , , 40436 9779 3 pp pp NNP 40436 9779 4 . . . 40436 9780 1 210 210 CD 40436 9780 2 - - SYM 40436 9780 3 211 211 CD 40436 9780 4 . . . 40436 9781 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9781 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9781 3 : : : 40436 9781 4 o(/tan o(/tan NNP 40436 9781 5 tis tis RB 40436 9781 6 a)po\ a)po\ NNP 40436 9781 7 tô tô NNP 40436 9781 8 = = SYM 40436 9781 9 nde nde NNP 40436 9781 10 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 9781 11 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9781 12 o)rthô o)rthô NNP 40436 9781 13 = = SYM 40436 9781 14 s s POS 40436 9781 15 paiderastei paiderastei NN 40436 9781 16 = = SYM 40436 9781 17 n n NNP 40436 9781 18 e)paniô\n e)paniô\n NNP 40436 9781 19 e)kei e)kei NNPS 40436 9781 20 = = NFP 40436 9781 21 no no DT 40436 9781 22 to\ to\ NN 40436 9781 23 kalo\n kalo\n NNP 40436 9781 24 a)/rchêtai a)/rchêtai NNP 40436 9781 25 kathora=|n kathora=|n NNP 40436 9781 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9781 27 , , , 40436 9781 28 & & CC 40436 9781 29 c. c. NNP 40436 9781 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9781 31 211 211 CD 40436 9781 32 B B NNP 40436 9781 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9781 34 . . . 40436 9781 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9782 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9782 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9782 3 16 16 CD 40436 9782 4 : : : 40436 9782 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9782 6 , , , 40436 9782 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9782 8 , , , 40436 9782 9 p. p. NN 40436 9782 10 96 96 CD 40436 9782 11 A. a. NN 40436 9783 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9783 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9783 3 : : : 40436 9783 4 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 9783 5 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 9783 6 soi\ soi\ NNP 40436 9783 7 di di NNP 40436 9783 8 / / SYM 40436 9783 9 eimi eimi NN 40436 9783 10 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 9783 11 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 9783 12 = = SYM 40436 9783 13 n n NN 40436 9783 14 ta/ ta/ NNP 40436 9783 15 g g NNP 40436 9783 16 ' ' '' 40436 9783 17 e)ma\ e)ma\ NNP 40436 9783 18 pa pa NNP 40436 9783 19 / / SYM 40436 9783 20 thê thê NNP 40436 9783 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9783 22 , , , 40436 9783 23 & & CC 40436 9783 24 c. c. NNP 40436 9783 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9783 26 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9783 27 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9783 28 17 17 CD 40436 9783 29 : : : 40436 9783 30 Tacitus Tacitus NNP 40436 9783 31 , , , 40436 9783 32 Hist Hist NNP 40436 9783 33 . . . 40436 9784 1 ii ii LS 40436 9784 2 . . . 40436 9785 1 53 53 CD 40436 9785 2 . . . 40436 9786 1 " " `` 40436 9786 2 Othonis othonis JJ 40436 9786 3 libertus libertus NN 40436 9786 4 , , , 40436 9786 5 habere habere NNP 40436 9786 6 se se NNP 40436 9786 7 suprema suprema NNP 40436 9786 8 ejus ejus NNP 40436 9786 9 mandata mandata NNP 40436 9786 10 respondit respondit NNP 40436 9786 11 : : : 40436 9786 12 ipsum ipsum NNP 40436 9786 13 viventem viventem NNP 40436 9786 14 quidem quidem NNP 40436 9786 15 relictum relictum NNP 40436 9786 16 , , , 40436 9786 17 sed sed NNP 40436 9786 18 solâ solâ NNP 40436 9786 19 posteritatis posteritatis NNP 40436 9786 20 curâ curâ NNP 40436 9786 21 , , , 40436 9786 22 et et NNP 40436 9786 23 abruptis abruptis NNP 40436 9786 24 vitæ vitæ NNP 40436 9786 25 blandimentis blandimentis NN 40436 9786 26 . . . 40436 9786 27 " " '' 40436 9786 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9787 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9787 2 Side side NN 40436 9787 3 - - HYPH 40436 9787 4 note note NN 40436 9787 5 : : : 40436 9787 6 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9787 7 -- -- : 40436 9787 8 compared compare VBN 40436 9787 9 with with IN 40436 9787 10 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9787 11 and and CC 40436 9787 12 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 9787 13 . . . 40436 9788 1 No no DT 40436 9788 2 recognition recognition NN 40436 9788 3 of of IN 40436 9788 4 the the DT 40436 9788 5 triple triple JJ 40436 9788 6 or or CC 40436 9788 7 lower low JJR 40436 9788 8 souls soul NNS 40436 9788 9 . . . 40436 9789 1 Antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9789 2 between between IN 40436 9789 3 soul soul NN 40436 9789 4 and and CC 40436 9789 5 body body NN 40436 9789 6 . . . 40436 9789 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9790 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9790 2 have have VBP 40436 9790 3 here here RB 40436 9790 4 one one CD 40436 9790 5 peculiarity peculiarity NN 40436 9790 6 of of IN 40436 9790 7 the the DT 40436 9790 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9790 9 , , , 40436 9790 10 whereby whereby WRB 40436 9790 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9790 12 stands stand VBZ 40436 9790 13 distinguished distinguished JJ 40436 9790 14 both both DT 40436 9790 15 from from IN 40436 9790 16 the the DT 40436 9790 17 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9790 18 and and CC 40436 9790 19 the the DT 40436 9790 20 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 9790 21 . . . 40436 9791 1 The the DT 40436 9791 2 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9791 3 on on IN 40436 9791 4 which which WDT 40436 9791 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9791 6 dwells dwell VBZ 40436 9791 7 is be VBZ 40436 9791 8 that that DT 40436 9791 9 of of IN 40436 9791 10 the the DT 40436 9791 11 soul soul NN 40436 9791 12 or or CC 40436 9791 13 mind mind NN 40436 9791 14 , , , 40436 9791 15 on on IN 40436 9791 16 one one CD 40436 9791 17 hand hand NN 40436 9791 18 -- -- : 40436 9791 19 the the DT 40436 9791 20 body body NN 40436 9791 21 on on IN 40436 9791 22 the the DT 40436 9791 23 other other JJ 40436 9791 24 . . . 40436 9792 1 The the DT 40436 9792 2 soul soul NN 40436 9792 3 or or CC 40436 9792 4 mind mind NN 40436 9792 5 is be VBZ 40436 9792 6 spoken speak VBN 40436 9792 7 of of IN 40436 9792 8 as as IN 40436 9792 9 one one CD 40436 9792 10 and and CC 40436 9792 11 indivisible indivisible JJ 40436 9792 12 : : : 40436 9792 13 as as IN 40436 9792 14 if if IN 40436 9792 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9792 16 were be VBD 40436 9792 17 an an DT 40436 9792 18 inmate inmate NN 40436 9792 19 unworthily unworthily RB 40436 9792 20 lodged lodge VBN 40436 9792 21 or or CC 40436 9792 22 imprisoned imprison VBN 40436 9792 23 in in IN 40436 9792 24 the the DT 40436 9792 25 body body NN 40436 9792 26 . . . 40436 9793 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9793 2 is be VBZ 40436 9793 3 not not RB 40436 9793 4 distributed distribute VBN 40436 9793 5 into into IN 40436 9793 6 distinct distinct JJ 40436 9793 7 parts part NNS 40436 9793 8 , , , 40436 9793 9 kinds kind NNS 40436 9793 10 , , , 40436 9793 11 or or CC 40436 9793 12 varieties variety NNS 40436 9793 13 : : : 40436 9793 14 no no DT 40436 9793 15 mention mention NN 40436 9793 16 is be VBZ 40436 9793 17 made make VBN 40436 9793 18 of of IN 40436 9793 19 that that DT 40436 9793 20 tripartite tripartite JJ 40436 9793 21 distribution distribution NN 40436 9793 22 which which WDT 40436 9793 23 is be VBZ 40436 9793 24 so so RB 40436 9793 25 much much RB 40436 9793 26 insisted insist VBN 40436 9793 27 on on IN 40436 9793 28 in in IN 40436 9793 29 the the DT 40436 9793 30 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9793 31 and and CC 40436 9793 32 Timæus:--the timæus:--the DT 40436 9793 33 rational rational JJ 40436 9793 34 or or CC 40436 9793 35 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9793 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9793 37 encephalic encephalic NN 40436 9793 38 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9793 39 soul soul NN 40436 9793 40 , , , 40436 9793 41 located locate VBN 40436 9793 42 in in IN 40436 9793 43 the the DT 40436 9793 44 head head NN 40436 9793 45 -- -- : 40436 9793 46 the the DT 40436 9793 47 courageous courageous JJ 40436 9793 48 or or CC 40436 9793 49 passionate passionate JJ 40436 9793 50 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9793 51 thoracic thoracic NNP 40436 9793 52 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9793 53 , , , 40436 9793 54 between between IN 40436 9793 55 the the DT 40436 9793 56 neck neck NN 40436 9793 57 and and CC 40436 9793 58 the the DT 40436 9793 59 diaphragm diaphragm NN 40436 9793 60 -- -- : 40436 9793 61 the the DT 40436 9793 62 appetitive appetitive JJ 40436 9793 63 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9793 64 abdominal abdominal JJ 40436 9793 65 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9793 66 , , , 40436 9793 67 between between IN 40436 9793 68 the the DT 40436 9793 69 diaphragm diaphragm NN 40436 9793 70 and and CC 40436 9793 71 the the DT 40436 9793 72 navel navel NN 40436 9793 73 . . . 40436 9794 1 In in IN 40436 9794 2 the the DT 40436 9794 3 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9794 4 , , , 40436 9794 5 the the DT 40436 9794 6 soul soul NN 40436 9794 7 is be VBZ 40436 9794 8 noted note VBN 40436 9794 9 as as IN 40436 9794 10 the the DT 40436 9794 11 seat seat NN 40436 9794 12 of of IN 40436 9794 13 reason reason NN 40436 9794 14 , , , 40436 9794 15 intellect intellect NN 40436 9794 16 , , , 40436 9794 17 the the DT 40436 9794 18 love love NN 40436 9794 19 of of IN 40436 9794 20 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 9794 21 or or CC 40436 9794 22 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9794 23 , , , 40436 9794 24 exclusively exclusively RB 40436 9794 25 : : : 40436 9794 26 all all DT 40436 9794 27 that that WDT 40436 9794 28 belongs belong VBZ 40436 9794 29 to to TO 40436 9794 30 passion passion NN 40436 9794 31 and and CC 40436 9794 32 appetite appetite NN 40436 9794 33 , , , 40436 9794 34 is be VBZ 40436 9794 35 put put VBN 40436 9794 36 to to IN 40436 9794 37 account account NN 40436 9794 38 of of IN 40436 9794 39 the the DT 40436 9794 40 body:[18 body:[18 '' 40436 9794 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9794 42 this this DT 40436 9794 43 is be VBZ 40436 9794 44 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 9794 45 contrary contrary JJ 40436 9794 46 to to IN 40436 9794 47 the the DT 40436 9794 48 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 9794 49 , , , 40436 9794 50 in in IN 40436 9794 51 which which WDT 40436 9794 52 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9794 53 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9794 54 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 9794 55 that that DT 40436 9794 56 desire desire NN 40436 9794 57 or or CC 40436 9794 58 appetite appetite NN 40436 9794 59 can can MD 40436 9794 60 not not RB 40436 9794 61 belong belong VB 40436 9794 62 to to IN 40436 9794 63 the the DT 40436 9794 64 body body NN 40436 9794 65 , , , 40436 9794 66 but but CC 40436 9794 67 belongs belong VBZ 40436 9794 68 only only RB 40436 9794 69 to to IN 40436 9794 70 the the DT 40436 9794 71 soul soul NN 40436 9794 72 . . . 40436 9795 1 In in IN 40436 9795 2 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9795 3 , , , 40436 9795 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 9795 5 is be VBZ 40436 9795 6 said say VBN 40436 9795 7 about about IN 40436 9795 8 the the DT 40436 9795 9 location location NN 40436 9795 10 of of IN 40436 9795 11 the the DT 40436 9795 12 rational rational JJ 40436 9795 13 soul soul NN 40436 9795 14 , , , 40436 9795 15 in in IN 40436 9795 16 the the DT 40436 9795 17 head,--nor head,--nor NNP 40436 9795 18 about about IN 40436 9795 19 the the DT 40436 9795 20 analogy analogy NN 40436 9795 21 between between IN 40436 9795 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9795 23 rotations rotation NNS 40436 9795 24 in in IN 40436 9795 25 the the DT 40436 9795 26 cranium cranium NN 40436 9795 27 and and CC 40436 9795 28 the the DT 40436 9795 29 celestial celestial JJ 40436 9795 30 rotations rotation NNS 40436 9795 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9795 32 a a DT 40436 9795 33 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9795 34 which which WDT 40436 9795 35 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9795 36 read read VBP 40436 9795 37 both both DT 40436 9795 38 in in IN 40436 9795 39 the the DT 40436 9795 40 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 9795 41 and and CC 40436 9795 42 in in IN 40436 9795 43 the the DT 40436 9795 44 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9795 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9795 46 : : : 40436 9795 47 on on IN 40436 9795 48 the the DT 40436 9795 49 contrary contrary NN 40436 9795 50 , , , 40436 9795 51 the the DT 40436 9795 52 soul soul NN 40436 9795 53 is be VBZ 40436 9795 54 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 9795 55 to to TO 40436 9795 56 have have VB 40436 9795 57 lost lose VBN 40436 9795 58 , , , 40436 9795 59 through through IN 40436 9795 60 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9795 61 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 9795 62 with with IN 40436 9795 63 the the DT 40436 9795 64 body body NN 40436 9795 65 , , , 40436 9795 66 that that DT 40436 9795 67 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 9795 68 or or CC 40436 9795 69 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9795 70 which which WDT 40436 9795 71 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9795 72 possessed possess VBD 40436 9795 73 during during IN 40436 9795 74 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9795 75 state state NN 40436 9795 76 of of IN 40436 9795 77 pre pre NN 40436 9795 78 - - NN 40436 9795 79 existence existence NN 40436 9795 80 , , , 40436 9795 81 while while IN 40436 9795 82 completely completely RB 40436 9795 83 apart apart RB 40436 9795 84 from from IN 40436 9795 85 the the DT 40436 9795 86 body body NN 40436 9795 87 , , , 40436 9795 88 and and CC 40436 9795 89 while while IN 40436 9795 90 in in IN 40436 9795 91 commerce commerce NN 40436 9795 92 with with IN 40436 9795 93 those those DT 40436 9795 94 invisible invisible JJ 40436 9795 95 Ideas idea NNS 40436 9795 96 to to TO 40436 9795 97 which which WDT 40436 9795 98 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9795 99 own own JJ 40436 9795 100 separate separate JJ 40436 9795 101 nature nature NN 40436 9795 102 was be VBD 40436 9795 103 cognate cognate VB 40436 9795 104 . . . 40436 9796 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9796 2 19 19 CD 40436 9796 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9796 4 That that IN 40436 9796 5 controul controul NN 40436 9796 6 which which WDT 40436 9796 7 in in IN 40436 9796 8 the the DT 40436 9796 9 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9796 10 is be VBZ 40436 9796 11 exercised exercise VBN 40436 9796 12 by by IN 40436 9796 13 the the DT 40436 9796 14 rational rational JJ 40436 9796 15 soul soul NN 40436 9796 16 over over IN 40436 9796 17 the the DT 40436 9796 18 passionate passionate JJ 40436 9796 19 and and CC 40436 9796 20 appetitive appetitive JJ 40436 9796 21 souls soul NNS 40436 9796 22 , , , 40436 9796 23 is be VBZ 40436 9796 24 in in IN 40436 9796 25 the the DT 40436 9796 26 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9796 27 exercised exercise VBN 40436 9796 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9796 29 though though IN 40436 9796 30 imperfectly imperfectly RB 40436 9796 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9796 32 by by IN 40436 9796 33 the the DT 40436 9796 34 one one NN 40436 9796 35 and and CC 40436 9796 36 only only RB 40436 9796 37 soul soul NN 40436 9796 38 over over IN 40436 9796 39 the the DT 40436 9796 40 body body NN 40436 9796 41 . . . 40436 9797 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9797 2 20 20 CD 40436 9797 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9797 4 In in IN 40436 9797 5 the the DT 40436 9797 6 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9797 7 and and CC 40436 9797 8 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 9797 9 , , , 40436 9797 10 the the DT 40436 9797 11 soul soul NN 40436 9797 12 is be VBZ 40436 9797 13 a a DT 40436 9797 14 tripartite tripartite JJ 40436 9797 15 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 9797 16 , , , 40436 9797 17 a a DT 40436 9797 18 community community NN 40436 9797 19 of of IN 40436 9797 20 parts part NNS 40436 9797 21 , , , 40436 9797 22 a a DT 40436 9797 23 compound compound NN 40436 9797 24 : : : 40436 9797 25 in in IN 40436 9797 26 the the DT 40436 9797 27 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9797 28 , , , 40436 9797 29 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9797 30 asserts assert VBZ 40436 9797 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9797 32 to to TO 40436 9797 33 be be VB 40436 9797 34 uncompounded uncompounded JJ 40436 9797 35 , , , 40436 9797 36 making make VBG 40436 9797 37 this this DT 40436 9797 38 fact fact NN 40436 9797 39 a a DT 40436 9797 40 point point NN 40436 9797 41 in in IN 40436 9797 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9797 43 argument argument NN 40436 9797 44 . . . 40436 9798 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9798 2 21 21 CD 40436 9798 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9798 4 Again again RB 40436 9798 5 , , , 40436 9798 6 in in IN 40436 9798 7 the the DT 40436 9798 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9798 9 , , , 40436 9798 10 the the DT 40436 9798 11 soul soul NN 40436 9798 12 is be VBZ 40436 9798 13 pronounced pronounce VBN 40436 9798 14 to to TO 40436 9798 15 be be VB 40436 9798 16 essentially essentially RB 40436 9798 17 uniform uniform JJ 40436 9798 18 and and CC 40436 9798 19 incapable incapable JJ 40436 9798 20 of of IN 40436 9798 21 change change NN 40436 9798 22 : : : 40436 9798 23 as as IN 40436 9798 24 such such JJ 40436 9798 25 , , , 40436 9798 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9798 27 is be VBZ 40436 9798 28 placed place VBN 40436 9798 29 in in IN 40436 9798 30 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9798 31 with with IN 40436 9798 32 the the DT 40436 9798 33 body body NN 40436 9798 34 , , , 40436 9798 35 which which WDT 40436 9798 36 is be VBZ 40436 9798 37 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 9798 38 changing change VBG 40436 9798 39 : : : 40436 9798 40 while while IN 40436 9798 41 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9798 42 read read VBP 40436 9798 43 , , , 40436 9798 44 on on IN 40436 9798 45 the the DT 40436 9798 46 contrary contrary NN 40436 9798 47 , , , 40436 9798 48 in in IN 40436 9798 49 the the DT 40436 9798 50 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 9798 51 , , , 40436 9798 52 that that IN 40436 9798 53 soul soul NN 40436 9798 54 and and CC 40436 9798 55 body body NN 40436 9798 56 alike alike RB 40436 9798 57 are be VBP 40436 9798 58 in in IN 40436 9798 59 a a DT 40436 9798 60 constant constant JJ 40436 9798 61 and and CC 40436 9798 62 unremitting unremitting JJ 40436 9798 63 variation variation NN 40436 9798 64 , , , 40436 9798 65 neither neither CC 40436 9798 66 one one CD 40436 9798 67 nor nor CC 40436 9798 68 the the DT 40436 9798 69 other other JJ 40436 9798 70 ever ever RB 40436 9798 71 continuing continue VBG 40436 9798 72 in in IN 40436 9798 73 the the DT 40436 9798 74 same same JJ 40436 9798 75 condition condition NN 40436 9798 76 . . . 40436 9799 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9799 2 22 22 CD 40436 9799 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9799 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9799 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9799 6 18 18 CD 40436 9799 7 : : : 40436 9799 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9799 9 , , , 40436 9799 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9799 11 , , , 40436 9799 12 p. p. NN 40436 9799 13 66 66 CD 40436 9799 14 . . . 40436 9800 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 9800 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9800 3 , , , 40436 9800 4 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 9800 5 , , , 40436 9800 6 p. p. NN 40436 9800 7 35 35 CD 40436 9800 8 , , , 40436 9800 9 C C NNP 40436 9800 10 - - HYPH 40436 9800 11 D. D. NNP 40436 9800 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9800 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9800 14 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9800 15 19 19 CD 40436 9800 16 : : : 40436 9800 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9800 18 , , , 40436 9800 19 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9800 20 , , , 40436 9800 21 p. p. NN 40436 9801 1 76 76 CD 40436 9801 2 . . . 40436 9801 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9802 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9802 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9802 3 20 20 CD 40436 9802 4 : : : 40436 9802 5 Compare Compare NNP 40436 9802 6 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9802 7 , , , 40436 9802 8 p. p. NN 40436 9802 9 94 94 CD 40436 9802 10 C C NNP 40436 9802 11 - - HYPH 40436 9802 12 E E NNP 40436 9802 13 , , , 40436 9802 14 with with IN 40436 9802 15 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9802 16 , , , 40436 9802 17 iv iv NNP 40436 9802 18 . . . 40436 9803 1 pp pp NNP 40436 9803 2 . . . 40436 9804 1 439 439 CD 40436 9804 2 C c NN 40436 9804 3 , , , 40436 9804 4 440 440 CD 40436 9804 5 A A NNP 40436 9804 6 , , , 40436 9804 7 441 441 CD 40436 9804 8 E e NN 40436 9804 9 , , , 40436 9804 10 442 442 CD 40436 9804 11 C. c. NN 40436 9804 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9804 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9804 14 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9804 15 21 21 CD 40436 9804 16 : : : 40436 9804 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9804 18 , , , 40436 9804 19 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9804 20 , , , 40436 9804 21 p. p. NN 40436 9804 22 78 78 CD 40436 9804 23 . . . 40436 9805 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9805 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9805 3 : : : 40436 9805 4 a)xu a)xu NNP 40436 9805 5 / / SYM 40436 9805 6 ntheton ntheton NNP 40436 9805 7 , , , 40436 9805 8 monoeide\s monoeide\s ADD 40436 9805 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9805 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9805 11 p. p. NN 40436 9805 12 80 80 CD 40436 9805 13 B b NN 40436 9805 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9805 15 , , , 40436 9805 16 contrasted contrast VBN 40436 9805 17 with with IN 40436 9805 18 the the DT 40436 9805 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9805 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9805 21 : : : 40436 9805 22 tri tri NNP 40436 9805 23 / / SYM 40436 9805 24 a a DT 40436 9805 25 ei)dê ei)dê NNP 40436 9805 26 tê tê NN 40436 9805 27 = = SYM 40436 9805 28 s s NNP 40436 9805 29 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 9805 30 = = SYM 40436 9805 31 s s NNP 40436 9805 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9805 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9805 34 Republic Republic NNP 40436 9805 35 , , , 40436 9805 36 p. p. NN 40436 9805 37 439 439 CD 40436 9805 38 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9805 39 . . . 40436 9806 1 In in IN 40436 9806 2 the the DT 40436 9806 3 abstract abstract NN 40436 9806 4 given give VBN 40436 9806 5 by by IN 40436 9806 6 Alkinous Alkinous NNP 40436 9806 7 of of IN 40436 9806 8 the the DT 40436 9806 9 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 9806 10 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9806 11 , , , 40436 9806 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9806 13 read read VBP 40436 9806 14 in in IN 40436 9806 15 cap cap NN 40436 9806 16 . . . 40436 9807 1 24 24 CD 40436 9807 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9807 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9807 4 : : : 40436 9807 5 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 9807 6 trimerê trimerê NNP 40436 9807 7 / / SYM 40436 9807 8 s s NNP 40436 9807 9 e)stin e)stin , 40436 9807 10 ê ê NNP 40436 9807 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9807 12 psuchê\ psuchê\ NN 40436 9807 13 kata\ kata\ . 40436 9807 14 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 9807 15 duna duna NNP 40436 9807 16 / / SYM 40436 9807 17 meis meis NNP 40436 9807 18 , , , 40436 9807 19 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9807 20 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 9807 21 lo lo NNP 40436 9807 22 / / SYM 40436 9807 23 gon gon NNP 40436 9807 24 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 9807 25 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9807 26 / / SYM 40436 9807 27 rê rê NNP 40436 9807 28 au)tê au)tê NNP 40436 9807 29 = = SYM 40436 9807 30 s s NN 40436 9807 31 to to NN 40436 9807 32 / / SYM 40436 9807 33 pois pois NNP 40436 9807 34 i)di i)di NNP 40436 9807 35 / / SYM 40436 9807 36 ois ois NNP 40436 9807 37 dianene dianene NNP 40436 9807 38 / / SYM 40436 9807 39 mêtai mêtai NNP 40436 9807 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9807 41 : : : 40436 9807 42 in in IN 40436 9807 43 cap cap NN 40436 9807 44 . . . 40436 9808 1 25 25 CD 40436 9808 2 that that IN 40436 9808 3 the the DT 40436 9808 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9808 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9808 6 : : : 40436 9808 7 psuchê\ psuchê\ LS 40436 9808 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9808 9 is be VBZ 40436 9808 10 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9808 11 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9808 12 : : : 40436 9808 13 a)su a)su JJ 40436 9808 14 / / SYM 40436 9808 15 nthetos ntheto NNS 40436 9808 16 , , , 40436 9808 17 a)dia a)dia NNP 40436 9808 18 / / SYM 40436 9808 19 lutos lutos NNP 40436 9808 20 , , , 40436 9808 21 a)ske a)ske NNP 40436 9808 22 / / SYM 40436 9808 23 dastos dastos NNP 40436 9808 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9808 25 . . . 40436 9808 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9809 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9809 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9809 3 22 22 CD 40436 9809 4 : : : 40436 9809 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9809 6 , , , 40436 9809 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9809 8 , , , 40436 9809 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9809 10 . . . 40436 9810 1 79 79 CD 40436 9810 2 - - SYM 40436 9810 3 80 80 CD 40436 9810 4 ; ; : 40436 9810 5 Symposion symposion NN 40436 9810 6 , , , 40436 9810 7 pp pp NNP 40436 9810 8 . . . 40436 9811 1 207 207 CD 40436 9811 2 - - SYM 40436 9811 3 208 208 CD 40436 9811 4 . . . 40436 9811 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9812 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9812 2 Side side NN 40436 9812 3 - - HYPH 40436 9812 4 note note NN 40436 9812 5 : : : 40436 9812 6 Different different JJ 40436 9812 7 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 9812 8 of of IN 40436 9812 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9812 10 about about IN 40436 9812 11 the the DT 40436 9812 12 soul soul NN 40436 9812 13 . . . 40436 9813 1 Whether whether IN 40436 9813 2 all all PDT 40436 9813 3 the the DT 40436 9813 4 three three CD 40436 9813 5 souls soul NNS 40436 9813 6 are be VBP 40436 9813 7 immortal immortal JJ 40436 9813 8 , , , 40436 9813 9 or or CC 40436 9813 10 the the DT 40436 9813 11 rational rational JJ 40436 9813 12 soul soul NN 40436 9813 13 alone alone RB 40436 9813 14 . . . 40436 9813 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9814 1 The the DT 40436 9814 2 difference difference NN 40436 9814 3 which which WDT 40436 9814 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9814 5 have have VBP 40436 9814 6 here here RB 40436 9814 7 noted note VBN 40436 9814 8 shows show VBZ 40436 9814 9 how how WRB 40436 9814 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9814 11 modified modify VBD 40436 9814 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9814 13 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9814 14 to to TO 40436 9814 15 suit suit VB 40436 9814 16 the the DT 40436 9814 17 purpose purpose NN 40436 9814 18 of of IN 40436 9814 19 each each DT 40436 9814 20 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9814 21 . . . 40436 9815 1 The the DT 40436 9815 2 tripartite tripartite JJ 40436 9815 3 soul soul NN 40436 9815 4 would would MD 40436 9815 5 have have VB 40436 9815 6 been be VBN 40436 9815 7 found find VBN 40436 9815 8 inconvenient inconvenient JJ 40436 9815 9 in in IN 40436 9815 10 the the DT 40436 9815 11 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9815 12 , , , 40436 9815 13 where where WRB 40436 9815 14 the the DT 40436 9815 15 argument argument NN 40436 9815 16 required require VBD 40436 9815 17 that that IN 40436 9815 18 soul soul NN 40436 9815 19 and and CC 40436 9815 20 body body NN 40436 9815 21 should should MD 40436 9815 22 be be VB 40436 9815 23 as as RB 40436 9815 24 sharply sharply RB 40436 9815 25 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 9815 26 as as IN 40436 9815 27 possible possible JJ 40436 9815 28 . . . 40436 9816 1 Assuming assume VBG 40436 9816 2 passion passion NN 40436 9816 3 and and CC 40436 9816 4 appetite appetite NN 40436 9816 5 to to TO 40436 9816 6 be be VB 40436 9816 7 attributes attribute NNS 40436 9816 8 belonging belong VBG 40436 9816 9 to to IN 40436 9816 10 the the DT 40436 9816 11 soul soul NN 40436 9816 12 , , , 40436 9816 13 as as RB 40436 9816 14 well well RB 40436 9816 15 as as IN 40436 9816 16 reason reason NN 40436 9816 17 -- -- : 40436 9816 18 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9816 19 will will MD 40436 9816 20 not not RB 40436 9816 21 shake shake VB 40436 9816 22 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9816 23 off off RP 40436 9816 24 when when WRB 40436 9816 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9816 26 becomes become VBZ 40436 9816 27 divorced divorce VBN 40436 9816 28 from from IN 40436 9816 29 the the DT 40436 9816 30 body body NN 40436 9816 31 . . . 40436 9817 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9817 2 believes believe VBZ 40436 9817 3 and and CC 40436 9817 4 expects expect VBZ 40436 9817 5 that that IN 40436 9817 6 the the DT 40436 9817 7 post post NN 40436 9817 8 - - NN 40436 9817 9 existence existence NN 40436 9817 10 of of IN 40436 9817 11 the the DT 40436 9817 12 soul soul NN 40436 9817 13 will will MD 40436 9817 14 be be VB 40436 9817 15 , , , 40436 9817 16 as as IN 40436 9817 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9817 18 pre pre NN 40436 9817 19 - - NN 40436 9817 20 existence existence NN 40436 9817 21 has have VBZ 40436 9817 22 been be VBN 40436 9817 23 , , , 40436 9817 24 a a DT 40436 9817 25 rational rational JJ 40436 9817 26 existence existence NN 40436 9817 27 -- -- : 40436 9817 28 a a DT 40436 9817 29 life life NN 40436 9817 30 of of IN 40436 9817 31 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9817 32 contemplation contemplation NN 40436 9817 33 and and CC 40436 9817 34 commerce commerce NN 40436 9817 35 with with IN 40436 9817 36 the the DT 40436 9817 37 eternal eternal JJ 40436 9817 38 Ideas idea NNS 40436 9817 39 : : : 40436 9817 40 in in IN 40436 9817 41 this this DT 40436 9817 42 there there EX 40436 9817 43 is be VBZ 40436 9817 44 no no DT 40436 9817 45 place place NN 40436 9817 46 for for IN 40436 9817 47 passion passion NN 40436 9817 48 and and CC 40436 9817 49 appetite appetite NN 40436 9817 50 , , , 40436 9817 51 which which WDT 40436 9817 52 grow grow VBP 40436 9817 53 out out IN 40436 9817 54 of of IN 40436 9817 55 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9817 56 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 9817 57 with with IN 40436 9817 58 the the DT 40436 9817 59 body body NN 40436 9817 60 . . . 40436 9818 1 The the DT 40436 9818 2 soul soul NN 40436 9818 3 here here RB 40436 9818 4 represents represent VBZ 40436 9818 5 Reason Reason NNP 40436 9818 6 and and CC 40436 9818 7 Intellect Intellect NNP 40436 9818 8 , , , 40436 9818 9 in in IN 40436 9818 10 commerce commerce NN 40436 9818 11 with with IN 40436 9818 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9818 13 correlates correlate NNS 40436 9818 14 , , , 40436 9818 15 the the DT 40436 9818 16 objective objective JJ 40436 9818 17 Entia Entia NNP 40436 9818 18 Rationis Rationis NNP 40436 9818 19 : : : 40436 9818 20 the the DT 40436 9818 21 body body NN 40436 9818 22 represents represent VBZ 40436 9818 23 passion passion NN 40436 9818 24 and and CC 40436 9818 25 appetite appetite NN 40436 9818 26 as as RB 40436 9818 27 well well RB 40436 9818 28 as as IN 40436 9818 29 sense sense NN 40436 9818 30 , , , 40436 9818 31 in in IN 40436 9818 32 implication implication NN 40436 9818 33 with with IN 40436 9818 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9818 35 correlates correlate NNS 40436 9818 36 , , , 40436 9818 37 the the DT 40436 9818 38 objects object NNS 40436 9818 39 of of IN 40436 9818 40 sensible sensible JJ 40436 9818 41 perception perception NN 40436 9818 42 . . . 40436 9819 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9819 2 23 23 CD 40436 9819 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9819 4 Such such JJ 40436 9819 5 is be VBZ 40436 9819 6 the the DT 40436 9819 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9819 8 of of IN 40436 9819 9 the the DT 40436 9819 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9819 11 ; ; : 40436 9819 12 but but CC 40436 9819 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9819 14 is be VBZ 40436 9819 15 not not RB 40436 9819 16 always always RB 40436 9819 17 consistent consistent JJ 40436 9819 18 with with IN 40436 9819 19 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9819 20 on on IN 40436 9819 21 the the DT 40436 9819 22 point point NN 40436 9819 23 . . . 40436 9820 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9820 2 ancient ancient NN 40436 9820 3 as as RB 40436 9820 4 well well RB 40436 9820 5 as as IN 40436 9820 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9820 7 modern modern JJ 40436 9820 8 commentators commentator NNS 40436 9820 9 are be VBP 40436 9820 10 not not RB 40436 9820 11 agreed agree VBN 40436 9820 12 , , , 40436 9820 13 whether whether IN 40436 9820 14 , , , 40436 9820 15 when when WRB 40436 9820 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9820 17 vindicated vindicate VBD 40436 9820 18 the the DT 40436 9820 19 immortality immortality NN 40436 9820 20 of of IN 40436 9820 21 the the DT 40436 9820 22 soul soul NN 40436 9820 23 , , , 40436 9820 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9820 25 meant mean VBD 40436 9820 26 to to TO 40436 9820 27 speak speak VB 40436 9820 28 of of IN 40436 9820 29 the the DT 40436 9820 30 rational rational JJ 40436 9820 31 soul soul NN 40436 9820 32 only only RB 40436 9820 33 , , , 40436 9820 34 or or CC 40436 9820 35 of of IN 40436 9820 36 the the DT 40436 9820 37 aggregate aggregate JJ 40436 9820 38 soul soul NN 40436 9820 39 with with IN 40436 9820 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9820 41 three three CD 40436 9820 42 parts part NNS 40436 9820 43 as as IN 40436 9820 44 above above IN 40436 9820 45 described describe VBN 40436 9820 46 . . . 40436 9821 1 There there EX 40436 9821 2 are be VBP 40436 9821 3 passages passage NNS 40436 9821 4 which which WDT 40436 9821 5 countenance countenance VBP 40436 9821 6 both both DT 40436 9821 7 suppositions supposition NNS 40436 9821 8 . . . 40436 9822 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9822 2 24 24 CD 40436 9822 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9822 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9822 5 seems seem VBZ 40436 9822 6 to to TO 40436 9822 7 have have VB 40436 9822 8 leaned lean VBN 40436 9822 9 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 9822 10 to to IN 40436 9822 11 the the DT 40436 9822 12 one one CD 40436 9822 13 view view NN 40436 9822 14 , , , 40436 9822 15 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 9822 16 to to IN 40436 9822 17 the the DT 40436 9822 18 other other JJ 40436 9822 19 : : : 40436 9822 20 besides besides IN 40436 9822 21 which which WDT 40436 9822 22 , , , 40436 9822 23 the the DT 40436 9822 24 view view NN 40436 9822 25 taken take VBN 40436 9822 26 in in IN 40436 9822 27 the the DT 40436 9822 28 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9822 29 is be VBZ 40436 9822 30 a a DT 40436 9822 31 third third JJ 40436 9822 32 , , , 40436 9822 33 different different JJ 40436 9822 34 from from IN 40436 9822 35 both--_viz both--_viz NNP 40436 9822 36 . . . 40436 9822 37 _ _ IN 40436 9822 38 : : : 40436 9822 39 That that IN 40436 9822 40 the the DT 40436 9822 41 two two CD 40436 9822 42 non non JJ 40436 9822 43 - - JJ 40436 9822 44 rational rational JJ 40436 9822 45 souls soul NNS 40436 9822 46 , , , 40436 9822 47 the the DT 40436 9822 48 passionate passionate NN 40436 9822 49 and and CC 40436 9822 50 appetitive appetitive JJ 40436 9822 51 , , , 40436 9822 52 are be VBP 40436 9822 53 not not RB 40436 9822 54 recognised recognise VBN 40436 9822 55 as as IN 40436 9822 56 existing exist VBG 40436 9822 57 . . . 40436 9823 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9823 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9823 3 23 23 CD 40436 9823 4 : : : 40436 9823 5 This this DT 40436 9823 6 is be VBZ 40436 9823 7 the the DT 40436 9823 8 same same JJ 40436 9823 9 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9823 10 as as IN 40436 9823 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9823 12 read read VBP 40436 9823 13 in in IN 40436 9823 14 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 9823 15 , , , 40436 9823 16 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 9823 17 to to IN 40436 9823 18 Cyrus Cyrus NNP 40436 9823 19 in in IN 40436 9823 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9823 21 dying die VBG 40436 9823 22 address address NN 40436 9823 23 to to IN 40436 9823 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9823 25 sons--[Greek sons--[greek CD 40436 9823 26 : : : 40436 9823 27 o o NN 40436 9823 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9823 29 a)/kratos a)/kratos NNP 40436 9823 30 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9823 31 katharo\s katharo\s NNP 40436 9823 32 nou nou NNP 40436 9823 33 = = SYM 40436 9823 34 s s NN 40436 9823 35 -- -- : 40436 9823 36 to\ to\ NN 40436 9823 37 a)/phron a)/phron NNP 40436 9823 38 sô sô NNP 40436 9823 39 = = SYM 40436 9823 40 ma ma NNP 40436 9823 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9823 42 , , , 40436 9823 43 Cyropæd Cyropæd NNP 40436 9823 44 . . . 40436 9824 1 viii viii RB 40436 9824 2 . . . 40436 9825 1 7 7 CD 40436 9825 2 , , , 40436 9825 3 20 20 CD 40436 9825 4 . . . 40436 9825 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9826 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9826 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9826 3 24 24 CD 40436 9826 4 : : : 40436 9826 5 Alkinous alkinous JJ 40436 9826 6 , , , 40436 9826 7 Introduct Introduct NNP 40436 9826 8 . . . 40436 9827 1 c. c. NNP 40436 9827 2 25 25 CD 40436 9827 3 . . . 40436 9828 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9828 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9828 3 : : : 40436 9828 4 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 9828 5 me\n me\n NNP 40436 9828 6 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 9828 7 ai ai NNP 40436 9828 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9828 9 logikai\ logikai\ NNP 40436 9828 10 psuchai\ psuchai\ NNP 40436 9828 11 a)tha a)tha NNP 40436 9828 12 / / SYM 40436 9828 13 natoi natoi NNP 40436 9828 14 u(pa u(pa NNP 40436 9828 15 / / SYM 40436 9828 16 rchousi rchousi NN 40436 9828 17 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 9828 18 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9828 19 a)/ndra a)/ndra NNP 40436 9828 20 tou tou NNP 40436 9828 21 = = SYM 40436 9828 22 ton ton NN 40436 9828 23 , , , 40436 9828 24 bebaiô bebaiô NNP 40436 9828 25 / / SYM 40436 9828 26 sait sait NNP 40436 9828 27 ' ' '' 40436 9828 28 a)/n a)/n UH 40436 9828 29 tis tis UH 40436 9828 30 ; ; : 40436 9828 31 ei ei NNP 40436 9828 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9828 33 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9828 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9828 35 ai ai NNP 40436 9828 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9828 37 a)/logoi a)/logoi NNP 40436 9828 38 , , , 40436 9828 39 tou tou NNP 40436 9828 40 = = SYM 40436 9828 41 to to IN 40436 9828 42 tô tô NNP 40436 9828 43 = = SYM 40436 9828 44 n n NNP 40436 9828 45 a)mphisbêtoume a)mphisbêtoume NNP 40436 9828 46 / / SYM 40436 9828 47 nôn nôn NN 40436 9828 48 u(pa u(pa NNP 40436 9828 49 / / SYM 40436 9828 50 rchei rchei NNP 40436 9828 51 . . . 40436 9828 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9829 1 Galen Galen NNP 40436 9829 2 considers consider VBZ 40436 9829 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9829 4 as as IN 40436 9829 5 affirming affirming NN 40436 9829 6 that that IN 40436 9829 7 the the DT 40436 9829 8 two two CD 40436 9829 9 inferior inferior JJ 40436 9829 10 souls soul NNS 40436 9829 11 are be VBP 40436 9829 12 mortal--[Greek mortal--[greek CD 40436 9829 13 : : : 40436 9829 14 Peri\ peri\ NN 40436 9829 15 tô tô NNP 40436 9829 16 = = NFP 40436 9829 17 n n NNP 40436 9829 18 tê tê NNP 40436 9829 19 = = SYM 40436 9829 20 s s NNP 40436 9829 21 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 9829 22 = = SYM 40436 9829 23 s s NNP 40436 9829 24 ê)thô ê)thô NNP 40436 9829 25 = = SYM 40436 9829 26 n n NN 40436 9829 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9829 28 , , , 40436 9829 29 T. T. NNP 40436 9829 30 iv iv NN 40436 9829 31 . . . 40436 9830 1 p. p. NN 40436 9830 2 773 773 CD 40436 9830 3 , , , 40436 9830 4 Kühn Kühn NNP 40436 9830 5 . . . 40436 9831 1 This this DT 40436 9831 2 subject subject NN 40436 9831 3 is be VBZ 40436 9831 4 handled handle VBN 40436 9831 5 in in IN 40436 9831 6 an an DT 40436 9831 7 instructive instructive JJ 40436 9831 8 Dissertation dissertation NN 40436 9831 9 of of IN 40436 9831 10 K. K. NNP 40436 9831 11 F. F. NNP 40436 9831 12 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 9831 13 -- -- : 40436 9831 14 De De NNP 40436 9831 15 Partibus Partibus NNP 40436 9831 16 Animæ Animæ NNP 40436 9831 17 Immortalibus Immortalibus NNP 40436 9831 18 secundum secundum NN 40436 9831 19 Platonem Platonem NNP 40436 9831 20 -- -- : 40436 9831 21 delivered deliver VBN 40436 9831 22 at at IN 40436 9831 23 Göttingen Göttingen NNP 40436 9831 24 in in IN 40436 9831 25 the the DT 40436 9831 26 winter winter NN 40436 9831 27 Session Session NNP 40436 9831 28 , , , 40436 9831 29 1850 1850 CD 40436 9831 30 - - SYM 40436 9831 31 1851 1851 CD 40436 9831 32 . . . 40436 9832 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9832 2 inclines incline VBZ 40436 9832 3 to to IN 40436 9832 4 the the DT 40436 9832 5 belief belief NN 40436 9832 6 that that IN 40436 9832 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9832 8 intended intend VBD 40436 9832 9 to to TO 40436 9832 10 represent represent VB 40436 9832 11 only only RB 40436 9832 12 the the DT 40436 9832 13 rational rational JJ 40436 9832 14 soul soul NN 40436 9832 15 as as IN 40436 9832 16 immortal immortal JJ 40436 9832 17 , , , 40436 9832 18 and and CC 40436 9832 19 the the DT 40436 9832 20 other other JJ 40436 9832 21 two two CD 40436 9832 22 souls soul NNS 40436 9832 23 as as IN 40436 9832 24 mortal mortal JJ 40436 9832 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9832 26 p. p. NN 40436 9832 27 9 9 CD 40436 9832 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9832 29 . . . 40436 9833 1 But but CC 40436 9833 2 the the DT 40436 9833 3 passages passage NNS 40436 9833 4 which which WDT 40436 9833 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9833 6 produces produce VBZ 40436 9833 7 are be VBP 40436 9833 8 quite quite RB 40436 9833 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 9833 10 to to TO 40436 9833 11 show show VB 40436 9833 12 , , , 40436 9833 13 that that IN 40436 9833 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9833 15 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 9833 16 held hold VBD 40436 9833 17 one one CD 40436 9833 18 language language NN 40436 9833 19 , , , 40436 9833 20 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 9833 21 the the DT 40436 9833 22 other other JJ 40436 9833 23 ; ; : 40436 9833 24 and and CC 40436 9833 25 that that DT 40436 9833 26 Galen Galen NNP 40436 9833 27 , , , 40436 9833 28 who who WP 40436 9833 29 wrote write VBD 40436 9833 30 an an DT 40436 9833 31 express express JJ 40436 9833 32 treatise treatise NN 40436 9833 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9833 34 now now RB 40436 9833 35 lost lose VBN 40436 9833 36 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9833 37 to to TO 40436 9833 38 prove prove VB 40436 9833 39 that that IN 40436 9833 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9833 41 was be VBD 40436 9833 42 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 9833 43 with with IN 40436 9833 44 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9833 45 in in IN 40436 9833 46 respect respect NN 40436 9833 47 to to IN 40436 9833 48 the the DT 40436 9833 49 soul soul NN 40436 9833 50 , , , 40436 9833 51 might may MD 40436 9833 52 have have VB 40436 9833 53 produced produce VBN 40436 9833 54 good good JJ 40436 9833 55 reasons reason NNS 40436 9833 56 for for IN 40436 9833 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9833 58 opinion opinion NN 40436 9833 59 . . . 40436 9834 1 The the DT 40436 9834 2 " " `` 40436 9834 3 inconstantia inconstantia NN 40436 9834 4 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 9834 5 " " '' 40436 9834 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9834 7 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 9834 8 , , , 40436 9834 9 Nat Nat NNP 40436 9834 10 . . . 40436 9835 1 Deor deor JJ 40436 9835 2 . . . 40436 9836 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9837 1 12 12 CD 40436 9837 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9837 3 must must MD 40436 9837 4 be be VB 40436 9837 5 admitted admit VBN 40436 9837 6 here here RB 40436 9837 7 as as IN 40436 9837 8 on on IN 40436 9837 9 other other JJ 40436 9837 10 matters matter NNS 40436 9837 11 . . . 40436 9838 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9838 2 must must MD 40436 9838 3 take take VB 40436 9838 4 the the DT 40436 9838 5 different different JJ 40436 9838 6 arguments argument NNS 40436 9838 7 and and CC 40436 9838 8 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 9838 9 of of IN 40436 9838 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9838 11 as as IN 40436 9838 12 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9838 13 find find VBP 40436 9838 14 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9838 15 in in IN 40436 9838 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9838 17 respective respective JJ 40436 9838 18 places place NNS 40436 9838 19 . . . 40436 9839 1 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 9839 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9839 3 p. p. NN 40436 9839 4 4 4 CD 40436 9839 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9839 6 says say VBZ 40436 9839 7 about about IN 40436 9839 8 the the DT 40436 9839 9 commentators--"De commentators--"De NNP 40436 9839 10 irrationali irrationali NNP 40436 9839 11 animâ animâ RB 40436 9839 12 , , , 40436 9839 13 alii alii NNP 40436 9839 14 ancipites ancipites NNP 40436 9839 15 hæserunt hæserunt NNP 40436 9839 16 , , , 40436 9839 17 alii alii NNP 40436 9839 18 claris claris NNP 40436 9839 19 verbis verbis NNP 40436 9839 20 mortalem mortalem NNP 40436 9839 21 prædicarunt prædicarunt NNP 40436 9839 22 : : : 40436 9839 23 quumque quumque NNP 40436 9839 24 Neoplatonicæ Neoplatonicæ NNP 40436 9839 25 sectæ sectæ NN 40436 9839 26 principes principe NNS 40436 9839 27 , , , 40436 9839 28 Numenius Numenius NNP 40436 9839 29 et et FW 40436 9839 30 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 40436 9839 31 , , , 40436 9839 32 non non JJ 40436 9839 33 modo modo NNP 40436 9839 34 brutorum brutorum NNP 40436 9839 35 , , , 40436 9839 36 sed sed NNP 40436 9839 37 ne ne NNP 40436 9839 38 plantarum plantarum NNP 40436 9839 39 quidem quidem NNP 40436 9839 40 , , , 40436 9839 41 animas anima NNS 40436 9839 42 immortalitate immortalitate VBP 40436 9839 43 privare privare NNP 40436 9839 44 ausi ausi NNP 40436 9839 45 sunt,--mox sunt,--mox NNP 40436 9839 46 insequentes insequentes NNPS 40436 9839 47 in in IN 40436 9839 48 alia alia NNP 40436 9839 49 omnia omnia NNP 40436 9839 50 digressi digressi NNP 40436 9839 51 aut aut NNP 40436 9839 52 plane plane NN 40436 9839 53 perire perire NNP 40436 9839 54 irrationales irrationale VBZ 40436 9839 55 partes parte NNS 40436 9839 56 affirmarunt affirmarunt VBP 40436 9839 57 , , , 40436 9839 58 aut aut NNP 40436 9839 59 mediâ mediâ NNP 40436 9839 60 quâdam quâdam NNP 40436 9839 61 viâ viâ NNP 40436 9839 62 ingressi ingressi NNP 40436 9839 63 , , , 40436 9839 64 quamvis quamvis NNP 40436 9839 65 corporum corporum NNP 40436 9839 66 fato fato NNP 40436 9839 67 exemptis exemptis NNP 40436 9839 68 , , , 40436 9839 69 mortalitatem mortalitatem NNP 40436 9839 70 tamen taman NNS 40436 9839 71 et et NNP 40436 9839 72 ipsi ipsi NNP 40436 9839 73 tribuerunt tribuerunt NNP 40436 9839 74 . . . 40436 9839 75 " " '' 40436 9840 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9840 2 appears appear VBZ 40436 9840 3 that that IN 40436 9840 4 the the DT 40436 9840 5 divergence divergence NN 40436 9840 6 of of IN 40436 9840 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 9840 8 on on IN 40436 9840 9 this this DT 40436 9840 10 subject subject NN 40436 9840 11 began begin VBD 40436 9840 12 as as RB 40436 9840 13 early early RB 40436 9840 14 as as IN 40436 9840 15 Xenokrates Xenokrates NNP 40436 9840 16 and and CC 40436 9840 17 Speusippus Speusippus NNP 40436 9840 18 -- -- : 40436 9840 19 see see VB 40436 9840 20 Olympiodorus Olympiodorus NNP 40436 9840 21 , , , 40436 9840 22 Scholia Scholia NNP 40436 9840 23 in in IN 40436 9840 24 Phædonem Phædonem NNP 40436 9840 25 , , , 40436 9840 26 § § -LRB- 40436 9840 27 175 175 CD 40436 9840 28 . . . 40436 9841 1 The the DT 40436 9841 2 large large JJ 40436 9841 3 construction construction NN 40436 9841 4 adopted adopt VBN 40436 9841 5 by by IN 40436 9841 6 Numenius Numenius NNP 40436 9841 7 and and CC 40436 9841 8 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 40436 9841 9 is be VBZ 40436 9841 10 completely completely RB 40436 9841 11 borne bear VBN 40436 9841 12 out out RP 40436 9841 13 by by IN 40436 9841 14 a a DT 40436 9841 15 passage passage NN 40436 9841 16 in in IN 40436 9841 17 the the DT 40436 9841 18 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9841 19 , , , 40436 9841 20 p. p. NN 40436 9841 21 70 70 CD 40436 9841 22 E. E. NNP 40436 9841 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9841 24 must must MD 40436 9841 25 here here RB 40436 9841 26 remark remark VB 40436 9841 27 that that IN 40436 9841 28 Hermann Hermann NNP 40436 9841 29 does do VBZ 40436 9841 30 not not RB 40436 9841 31 note note VB 40436 9841 32 the the DT 40436 9841 33 full full JJ 40436 9841 34 extent extent NN 40436 9841 35 of of IN 40436 9841 36 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40436 9841 37 between between IN 40436 9841 38 the the DT 40436 9841 39 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9841 40 and and CC 40436 9841 41 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9841 42 's 's POS 40436 9841 43 other other JJ 40436 9841 44 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 9841 45 , , , 40436 9841 46 consisting consist VBG 40436 9841 47 in in IN 40436 9841 48 this this DT 40436 9841 49 -- -- : 40436 9841 50 That that IN 40436 9841 51 in in IN 40436 9841 52 the the DT 40436 9841 53 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9841 54 , , , 40436 9841 55 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9841 56 suppresses suppress VBZ 40436 9841 57 all all DT 40436 9841 58 mention mention NN 40436 9841 59 of of IN 40436 9841 60 the the DT 40436 9841 61 two two CD 40436 9841 62 non non JJ 40436 9841 63 - - JJ 40436 9841 64 rational rational JJ 40436 9841 65 souls soul NNS 40436 9841 66 , , , 40436 9841 67 the the DT 40436 9841 68 passionate passionate NN 40436 9841 69 and and CC 40436 9841 70 appetitive appetitive JJ 40436 9841 71 : : : 40436 9841 72 insomuch insomuch NN 40436 9841 73 that that IN 40436 9841 74 if if IN 40436 9841 75 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9841 76 had have VBD 40436 9841 77 only only RB 40436 9841 78 the the DT 40436 9841 79 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9841 80 remaining remain VBG 40436 9841 81 , , , 40436 9841 82 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9841 83 should should MD 40436 9841 84 not not RB 40436 9841 85 have have VB 40436 9841 86 known know VBN 40436 9841 87 that that IN 40436 9841 88 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9841 89 had have VBD 40436 9841 90 ever ever RB 40436 9841 91 affirmed affirm VBN 40436 9841 92 the the DT 40436 9841 93 triple triple JJ 40436 9841 94 partition partition NN 40436 9841 95 of of IN 40436 9841 96 the the DT 40436 9841 97 soul soul NN 40436 9841 98 , , , 40436 9841 99 or or CC 40436 9841 100 the the DT 40436 9841 101 co co NN 40436 9841 102 - - NN 40436 9841 103 existence existence NN 40436 9841 104 of of IN 40436 9841 105 the the DT 40436 9841 106 three three CD 40436 9841 107 souls soul NNS 40436 9841 108 . . . 40436 9842 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9842 2 transcribe transcribe VBP 40436 9842 3 an an DT 40436 9842 4 interesting interesting JJ 40436 9842 5 passage passage NN 40436 9842 6 from from IN 40436 9842 7 M. M. NNP 40436 9842 8 Degérando Degérando NNP 40436 9842 9 , , , 40436 9842 10 respecting respect VBG 40436 9842 11 the the DT 40436 9842 12 belief belief NN 40436 9842 13 in in IN 40436 9842 14 different different JJ 40436 9842 15 varieties variety NNS 40436 9842 16 of of IN 40436 9842 17 soul soul NN 40436 9842 18 , , , 40436 9842 19 and and CC 40436 9842 20 partial partial JJ 40436 9842 21 immortality immortality NN 40436 9842 22 . . . 40436 9843 1 Degérando Degérando NNP 40436 9843 2 -- -- : 40436 9843 3 Histoire Histoire NNP 40436 9843 4 Comparée Comparée NNP 40436 9843 5 des des FW 40436 9843 6 Systèmes Systèmes NNP 40436 9843 7 de de NNP 40436 9843 8 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 40436 9843 9 , , , 40436 9843 10 vol vol NNP 40436 9843 11 . . . 40436 9844 1 i. i. NNP 40436 9844 2 p. p. NNP 40436 9844 3 213 213 CD 40436 9844 4 . . . 40436 9845 1 " " `` 40436 9845 2 Les Les NNP 40436 9845 3 habitans habitans NNPS 40436 9845 4 du du . 40436 9845 5 Thibet Thibet NNP 40436 9845 6 , , , 40436 9845 7 du du NNP 40436 9845 8 Gröenland Gröenland NNP 40436 9845 9 , , , 40436 9845 10 du du NNP 40436 9845 11 nord nord NNP 40436 9845 12 de de IN 40436 9845 13 l'Amérique l'Amérique NNP 40436 9845 14 admettent admettent NN 40436 9845 15 deux deux NN 40436 9845 16 âmes âme NNS 40436 9845 17 : : : 40436 9845 18 les les NNP 40436 9845 19 Caräibes Caräibes NNP 40436 9845 20 en en IN 40436 9845 21 admettent admettent NN 40436 9845 22 trois trois NN 40436 9845 23 , , , 40436 9845 24 do do VBP 40436 9845 25 nt not RB 40436 9845 26 une une VB 40436 9845 27 , , , 40436 9845 28 disent disent NN 40436 9845 29 - - HYPH 40436 9845 30 ils ils NNP 40436 9845 31 , , , 40436 9845 32 celle celle NNP 40436 9845 33 qui qui NNP 40436 9845 34 habite habite NNP 40436 9845 35 dans dans NNPS 40436 9845 36 la la NNP 40436 9845 37 tête tête NNP 40436 9845 38 , , , 40436 9845 39 remonte remonte NNP 40436 9845 40 seule seule NNP 40436 9845 41 au au NNP 40436 9845 42 pays pay VBZ 40436 9845 43 des des NNP 40436 9845 44 âmes âme NNS 40436 9845 45 . . . 40436 9846 1 Les Les NNP 40436 9846 2 habitans habitans NNPS 40436 9846 3 du du NNP 40436 9846 4 Gröenland Gröenland NNP 40436 9846 5 croient croient NNP 40436 9846 6 d'ailleurs d'ailleurs FW 40436 9846 7 les les FW 40436 9846 8 âmes âmes NNP 40436 9846 9 des des NNP 40436 9846 10 hommes hommes NNP 40436 9846 11 semblables semblable NNS 40436 9846 12 au au NNP 40436 9846 13 principe principe NN 40436 9846 14 de de NNP 40436 9846 15 la la NNP 40436 9846 16 vie vie NNP 40436 9846 17 des des NNP 40436 9846 18 animaux animaux NNP 40436 9846 19 : : : 40436 9846 20 ils ils NNP 40436 9846 21 supposent supposent NNP 40436 9846 22 que que NNP 40436 9846 23 les les NNP 40436 9846 24 divers divers NNP 40436 9846 25 individus individus NNP 40436 9846 26 peuvent peuvent NNP 40436 9846 27 changer changer NN 40436 9846 28 d'âmes d'âmes NNP 40436 9846 29 entre entre NNP 40436 9846 30 eux eux NNP 40436 9846 31 pendant pendant NNP 40436 9846 32 la la NNP 40436 9846 33 vie vie NNP 40436 9846 34 , , , 40436 9846 35 et et NN 40436 9846 36 qu'après qu'après NNP 40436 9846 37 la la NNP 40436 9846 38 vie vie NNP 40436 9846 39 ces ces NNP 40436 9846 40 âmes âme NNS 40436 9846 41 exécutent exécutent VBP 40436 9846 42 de de FW 40436 9846 43 grands grands NNP 40436 9846 44 voyages voyage NNS 40436 9846 45 , , , 40436 9846 46 avec avec FW 40436 9846 47 toutes toute NNS 40436 9846 48 sortes sort VBZ 40436 9846 49 de de NNP 40436 9846 50 fatigues fatigues NNP 40436 9846 51 et et FW 40436 9846 52 de de FW 40436 9846 53 périls péril NNS 40436 9846 54 . . . 40436 9847 1 Les Les NNP 40436 9847 2 peuples peuple NNS 40436 9847 3 du du VBP 40436 9847 4 Canada Canada NNP 40436 9847 5 se se NNP 40436 9847 6 représentent représentent NN 40436 9847 7 les les NNP 40436 9847 8 âmes âme NNS 40436 9847 9 sous sous JJ 40436 9847 10 la la NNP 40436 9847 11 forme forme NNP 40436 9847 12 d'ombres d'ombres FW 40436 9847 13 errantes errantes NNPS 40436 9847 14 : : : 40436 9847 15 les les NNP 40436 9847 16 Patagons Patagons NNP 40436 9847 17 , , , 40436 9847 18 les les NNP 40436 9847 19 habitans habitans NNPS 40436 9847 20 du du NNP 40436 9847 21 Sud Sud NNP 40436 9847 22 de de NNP 40436 9847 23 l'Asie l'Asie NNP 40436 9847 24 , , , 40436 9847 25 croient croient NNP 40436 9847 26 entendre entendre NNP 40436 9847 27 leurs leurs NNP 40436 9847 28 voix voix NNP 40436 9847 29 dans dans NNPS 40436 9847 30 l'écho l'écho NNP 40436 9847 31 : : : 40436 9847 32 et et NNP 40436 9847 33 les les FW 40436 9847 34 anciens anciens NNP 40436 9847 35 Romains Romains NNP 40436 9847 36 eux eux NNP 40436 9847 37 - - HYPH 40436 9847 38 mêmes même NNS 40436 9847 39 n'étaient n'étaient NNP 40436 9847 40 pas pas NNP 40436 9847 41 étrangers étranger NNS 40436 9847 42 à à NNP 40436 9847 43 cette cette NN 40436 9847 44 opinion opinion NN 40436 9847 45 . . . 40436 9848 1 Les Les NNP 40436 9848 2 Négres Négres NNP 40436 9848 3 s'imaginent s'imaginent NN 40436 9848 4 que que NNP 40436 9848 5 la la NNP 40436 9848 6 destinée destinée NNP 40436 9848 7 de de IN 40436 9848 8 l'âme l'âme NNP 40436 9848 9 après après NNP 40436 9848 10 la la NNP 40436 9848 11 vie vie NNP 40436 9848 12 est est NNP 40436 9848 13 encore encore NNP 40436 9848 14 liée liée NNP 40436 9848 15 à à NNP 40436 9848 16 celle celle NNP 40436 9848 17 du du NNP 40436 9848 18 corps corps NNP 40436 9848 19 , , , 40436 9848 20 et et FW 40436 9848 21 fondent fondent JJ 40436 9848 22 sur sur NNP 40436 9848 23 cette cette NNP 40436 9848 24 idée idée NNP 40436 9848 25 une une NNP 40436 9848 26 foule foule NNP 40436 9848 27 de de FW 40436 9848 28 pratiques pratique NNS 40436 9848 29 . . . 40436 9848 30 " " '' 40436 9848 31 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9849 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9849 2 Side side NN 40436 9849 3 - - HYPH 40436 9849 4 note note NN 40436 9849 5 : : : 40436 9849 6 The the DT 40436 9849 7 life life NN 40436 9849 8 and and CC 40436 9849 9 character character NN 40436 9849 10 of of IN 40436 9849 11 a a DT 40436 9849 12 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9849 13 is be VBZ 40436 9849 14 a a DT 40436 9849 15 constant constant JJ 40436 9849 16 struggle struggle NN 40436 9849 17 to to TO 40436 9849 18 emancipate emancipate VB 40436 9849 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9849 20 soul soul NN 40436 9849 21 from from IN 40436 9849 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9849 23 body body NN 40436 9849 24 . . . 40436 9850 1 Death death NN 40436 9850 2 alone alone RB 40436 9850 3 enables enable VBZ 40436 9850 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9850 5 to to TO 40436 9850 6 do do VB 40436 9850 7 this this DT 40436 9850 8 completely completely RB 40436 9850 9 . . . 40436 9850 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9851 1 The the DT 40436 9851 2 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9851 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9851 4 contends contend VBZ 40436 9851 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9851 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9851 7 ought ought MD 40436 9851 8 to to TO 40436 9851 9 rejoice rejoice VB 40436 9851 10 when when WRB 40436 9851 11 death death NN 40436 9851 12 comes come VBZ 40436 9851 13 to to TO 40436 9851 14 sever sever VB 40436 9851 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9851 16 soul soul NN 40436 9851 17 altogether altogether RB 40436 9851 18 from from IN 40436 9851 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9851 20 body body NN 40436 9851 21 : : : 40436 9851 22 because because IN 40436 9851 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9851 24 is be VBZ 40436 9851 25 , , , 40436 9851 26 throughout throughout IN 40436 9851 27 all all PDT 40436 9851 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9851 29 life life NN 40436 9851 30 , , , 40436 9851 31 struggling struggle VBG 40436 9851 32 to to TO 40436 9851 33 sever sever VB 40436 9851 34 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9851 35 from from IN 40436 9851 36 the the DT 40436 9851 37 passions passion NNS 40436 9851 38 , , , 40436 9851 39 appetites appetite NNS 40436 9851 40 , , , 40436 9851 41 impulses impulse NNS 40436 9851 42 and and CC 40436 9851 43 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 9851 44 , , , 40436 9851 45 which which WDT 40436 9851 46 grow grow VBP 40436 9851 47 out out IN 40436 9851 48 of of IN 40436 9851 49 the the DT 40436 9851 50 body body NN 40436 9851 51 ; ; : 40436 9851 52 and and CC 40436 9851 53 to to TO 40436 9851 54 withdraw withdraw VB 40436 9851 55 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9851 56 from from IN 40436 9851 57 the the DT 40436 9851 58 perceptions perception NNS 40436 9851 59 of of IN 40436 9851 60 the the DT 40436 9851 61 corporeal corporeal JJ 40436 9851 62 senses sense NNS 40436 9851 63 , , , 40436 9851 64 which which WDT 40436 9851 65 teach teach VBP 40436 9851 66 no no DT 40436 9851 67 truth truth NN 40436 9851 68 , , , 40436 9851 69 and and CC 40436 9851 70 lead lead VBP 40436 9851 71 only only RB 40436 9851 72 to to IN 40436 9851 73 deceit deceit NN 40436 9851 74 or or CC 40436 9851 75 confusion confusion NN 40436 9851 76 : : : 40436 9851 77 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9851 78 is be VBZ 40436 9851 79 constantly constantly RB 40436 9851 80 attempting attempt VBG 40436 9851 81 to to TO 40436 9851 82 do do VB 40436 9851 83 what what WP 40436 9851 84 the the DT 40436 9851 85 body body NN 40436 9851 86 hinders hinder VBZ 40436 9851 87 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9851 88 from from IN 40436 9851 89 doing do VBG 40436 9851 90 completely completely RB 40436 9851 91 -- -- : 40436 9851 92 to to TO 40436 9851 93 prosecute prosecute VB 40436 9851 94 pure pure JJ 40436 9851 95 mental mental JJ 40436 9851 96 contemplation contemplation NN 40436 9851 97 , , , 40436 9851 98 as as IN 40436 9851 99 the the DT 40436 9851 100 only only JJ 40436 9851 101 way way NN 40436 9851 102 of of IN 40436 9851 103 arriving arrive VBG 40436 9851 104 at at IN 40436 9851 105 truth truth NN 40436 9851 106 : : : 40436 9851 107 to to TO 40436 9851 108 look look VB 40436 9851 109 at at IN 40436 9851 110 essences essence NNS 40436 9851 111 or or CC 40436 9851 112 things thing NNS 40436 9851 113 in in IN 40436 9851 114 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9851 115 , , , 40436 9851 116 by by IN 40436 9851 117 means mean NNS 40436 9851 118 of of IN 40436 9851 119 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9851 120 mind mind NN 40436 9851 121 or or CC 40436 9851 122 soul soul NN 40436 9851 123 in in IN 40436 9851 124 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9851 125 apart apart RB 40436 9851 126 from from IN 40436 9851 127 the the DT 40436 9851 128 body body NN 40436 9851 129 . . . 40436 9852 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9852 2 25 25 CD 40436 9852 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9852 4 Until until IN 40436 9852 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9852 6 mind mind NN 40436 9852 7 be be VB 40436 9852 8 purified purify VBN 40436 9852 9 from from IN 40436 9852 10 all all DT 40436 9852 11 association association NN 40436 9852 12 with with IN 40436 9852 13 the the DT 40436 9852 14 body body NN 40436 9852 15 , , , 40436 9852 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9852 17 can can MD 40436 9852 18 not not RB 40436 9852 19 be be VB 40436 9852 20 brought bring VBN 40436 9852 21 into into IN 40436 9852 22 contact contact NN 40436 9852 23 with with IN 40436 9852 24 pure pure JJ 40436 9852 25 essence essence NN 40436 9852 26 , , , 40436 9852 27 nor nor CC 40436 9852 28 can can MD 40436 9852 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9852 30 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 9852 31 for for IN 40436 9852 32 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9852 33 be be VB 40436 9852 34 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 9852 35 . . . 40436 9853 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9853 2 26 26 CD 40436 9853 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9853 4 Hence hence RB 40436 9853 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9853 6 whole whole JJ 40436 9853 7 life life NN 40436 9853 8 is be VBZ 40436 9853 9 really really RB 40436 9853 10 a a DT 40436 9853 11 training training NN 40436 9853 12 or or CC 40436 9853 13 approximative approximative JJ 40436 9853 14 practice practice NN 40436 9853 15 for for IN 40436 9853 16 death death NN 40436 9853 17 , , , 40436 9853 18 which which WDT 40436 9853 19 alone alone RB 40436 9853 20 will will MD 40436 9853 21 enable enable VB 40436 9853 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9853 23 to to TO 40436 9853 24 realise realise VB 40436 9853 25 such such JJ 40436 9853 26 aspirations aspiration NNS 40436 9853 27 . . . 40436 9854 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9854 2 27 27 CD 40436 9854 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9854 4 Knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9854 5 or or CC 40436 9854 6 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 9854 7 is be VBZ 40436 9854 8 the the DT 40436 9854 9 only only JJ 40436 9854 10 money money NN 40436 9854 11 in in IN 40436 9854 12 which which WDT 40436 9854 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9854 14 computes compute VBZ 40436 9854 15 , , , 40436 9854 16 and and CC 40436 9854 17 which which WDT 40436 9854 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9854 19 seeks seek VBZ 40436 9854 20 to to TO 40436 9854 21 receive receive VB 40436 9854 22 in in IN 40436 9854 23 payment payment NN 40436 9854 24 . . . 40436 9855 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9855 2 28 28 CD 40436 9855 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9855 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9855 5 is be VBZ 40436 9855 6 not not RB 40436 9855 7 courageous courageous JJ 40436 9855 8 or or CC 40436 9855 9 temperate temperate VB 40436 9855 10 in in IN 40436 9855 11 the the DT 40436 9855 12 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 9855 13 sense sense NN 40436 9855 14 : : : 40436 9855 15 for for IN 40436 9855 16 the the DT 40436 9855 17 courageous courageous JJ 40436 9855 18 man man NN 40436 9855 19 , , , 40436 9855 20 while while IN 40436 9855 21 holding hold VBG 40436 9855 22 death death NN 40436 9855 23 to to TO 40436 9855 24 be be VB 40436 9855 25 a a DT 40436 9855 26 great great JJ 40436 9855 27 evil evil NN 40436 9855 28 , , , 40436 9855 29 braves brave VBZ 40436 9855 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9855 31 from from IN 40436 9855 32 fear fear NN 40436 9855 33 of of IN 40436 9855 34 greater great JJR 40436 9855 35 evils evil NNS 40436 9855 36 -- -- : 40436 9855 37 and and CC 40436 9855 38 the the DT 40436 9855 39 temperate temperate NN 40436 9855 40 man man NN 40436 9855 41 abstains abstain VBZ 40436 9855 42 from from IN 40436 9855 43 various various JJ 40436 9855 44 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9855 45 , , , 40436 9855 46 because because IN 40436 9855 47 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9855 48 either either CC 40436 9855 49 shut shut VBD 40436 9855 50 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9855 51 out out RP 40436 9855 52 from from IN 40436 9855 53 greater great JJR 40436 9855 54 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9855 55 , , , 40436 9855 56 or or CC 40436 9855 57 entail entail NN 40436 9855 58 upon upon IN 40436 9855 59 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9855 60 disease disease NN 40436 9855 61 and and CC 40436 9855 62 poverty poverty NN 40436 9855 63 . . . 40436 9856 1 The the DT 40436 9856 2 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9856 3 is be VBZ 40436 9856 4 courageous courageous JJ 40436 9856 5 and and CC 40436 9856 6 temperate temperate VB 40436 9856 7 , , , 40436 9856 8 but but CC 40436 9856 9 from from IN 40436 9856 10 a a DT 40436 9856 11 different different JJ 40436 9856 12 motive motive NN 40436 9856 13 : : : 40436 9856 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9856 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9856 16 purifies purify VBZ 40436 9856 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9856 18 from from IN 40436 9856 19 all all PDT 40436 9856 20 these these DT 40436 9856 21 sensibilities sensibility NNS 40436 9856 22 , , , 40436 9856 23 and and CC 40436 9856 24 makes make VBZ 40436 9856 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9856 26 indifferent indifferent JJ 40436 9856 27 to to IN 40436 9856 28 all all PDT 40436 9856 29 the the DT 40436 9856 30 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9856 31 and and CC 40436 9856 32 pains pain NNS 40436 9856 33 arising arise VBG 40436 9856 34 from from IN 40436 9856 35 the the DT 40436 9856 36 body body NN 40436 9856 37 : : : 40436 9856 38 each each DT 40436 9856 39 of of IN 40436 9856 40 which which WDT 40436 9856 41 , , , 40436 9856 42 in in IN 40436 9856 43 proportion proportion NN 40436 9856 44 to to IN 40436 9856 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9856 46 intensity intensity NN 40436 9856 47 , , , 40436 9856 48 corrupts corrupt VBZ 40436 9856 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9856 50 perception perception NN 40436 9856 51 of of IN 40436 9856 52 truth truth NN 40436 9856 53 and and CC 40436 9856 54 falsehood falsehood NN 40436 9856 55 , , , 40436 9856 56 and and CC 40436 9856 57 misguides misguide VBZ 40436 9856 58 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9856 59 in in IN 40436 9856 60 the the DT 40436 9856 61 search search NN 40436 9856 62 for for IN 40436 9856 63 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 9856 64 or or CC 40436 9856 65 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9856 66 . . . 40436 9857 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9857 2 29 29 CD 40436 9857 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9857 4 While while IN 40436 9857 5 in in IN 40436 9857 6 the the DT 40436 9857 7 body body NN 40436 9857 8 , , , 40436 9857 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9857 10 feels feel VBZ 40436 9857 11 imprisoned imprison VBN 40436 9857 12 , , , 40436 9857 13 unable unable JJ 40436 9857 14 to to TO 40436 9857 15 look look VB 40436 9857 16 for for IN 40436 9857 17 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9857 18 except except IN 40436 9857 19 through through IN 40436 9857 20 a a DT 40436 9857 21 narrow narrow JJ 40436 9857 22 grating grating NN 40436 9857 23 and and CC 40436 9857 24 by by IN 40436 9857 25 the the DT 40436 9857 26 deceptive deceptive JJ 40436 9857 27 media medium NNS 40436 9857 28 of of IN 40436 9857 29 sense sense NN 40436 9857 30 . . . 40436 9858 1 From from IN 40436 9858 2 this this DT 40436 9858 3 durance durance NN 40436 9858 4 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9858 5 partially partially RB 40436 9858 6 liberates liberate VBZ 40436 9858 7 him,--purifying him,--purifye VBG 40436 9858 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9858 9 mind mind NN 40436 9858 10 , , , 40436 9858 11 like like IN 40436 9858 12 the the DT 40436 9858 13 Orphic orphic JJ 40436 9858 14 or or CC 40436 9858 15 Dionysiac Dionysiac NNP 40436 9858 16 religious religious JJ 40436 9858 17 mysteries mystery NNS 40436 9858 18 , , , 40436 9858 19 from from IN 40436 9858 20 the the DT 40436 9858 21 contagion contagion NN 40436 9858 22 of of IN 40436 9858 23 body[30 body[30 NNP 40436 9858 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9858 25 and and CC 40436 9858 26 sense sense NN 40436 9858 27 : : : 40436 9858 28 disengaging disengage VBG 40436 9858 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9858 30 , , , 40436 9858 31 as as RB 40436 9858 32 far far RB 40436 9858 33 as as IN 40436 9858 34 may may MD 40436 9858 35 be be VB 40436 9858 36 during during IN 40436 9858 37 life life NN 40436 9858 38 , , , 40436 9858 39 from from IN 40436 9858 40 sympathy sympathy NN 40436 9858 41 with with IN 40436 9858 42 the the DT 40436 9858 43 body body NN 40436 9858 44 : : : 40436 9858 45 and and CC 40436 9858 46 translating translate VBG 40436 9858 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9858 48 out out IN 40436 9858 49 of of IN 40436 9858 50 the the DT 40436 9858 51 world world NN 40436 9858 52 of of IN 40436 9858 53 sense sense NN 40436 9858 54 , , , 40436 9858 55 uncertainty uncertainty NN 40436 9858 56 , , , 40436 9858 57 and and CC 40436 9858 58 mere mere JJ 40436 9858 59 opinion opinion NN 40436 9858 60 , , , 40436 9858 61 into into IN 40436 9858 62 the the DT 40436 9858 63 invisible invisible JJ 40436 9858 64 region region NN 40436 9858 65 of of IN 40436 9858 66 truth truth NN 40436 9858 67 and and CC 40436 9858 68 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9858 69 . . . 40436 9859 1 If if IN 40436 9859 2 such such JJ 40436 9859 3 purification purification NN 40436 9859 4 has have VBZ 40436 9859 5 been be VBN 40436 9859 6 fully fully RB 40436 9859 7 achieved achieve VBN 40436 9859 8 , , , 40436 9859 9 the the DT 40436 9859 10 mind mind NN 40436 9859 11 of of IN 40436 9859 12 the the DT 40436 9859 13 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9859 14 is be VBZ 40436 9859 15 at at IN 40436 9859 16 the the DT 40436 9859 17 moment moment NN 40436 9859 18 of of IN 40436 9859 19 death death NN 40436 9859 20 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 9859 21 severed sever VBD 40436 9859 22 from from IN 40436 9859 23 the the DT 40436 9859 24 body body NN 40436 9859 25 , , , 40436 9859 26 and and CC 40436 9859 27 passes pass VBZ 40436 9859 28 clean clean JJ 40436 9859 29 away away RP 40436 9859 30 by by IN 40436 9859 31 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9859 32 , , , 40436 9859 33 into into IN 40436 9859 34 commerce commerce NN 40436 9859 35 with with IN 40436 9859 36 the the DT 40436 9859 37 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 9859 38 Entities entity NNS 40436 9859 39 or or CC 40436 9859 40 realities reality NNS 40436 9859 41 . . . 40436 9860 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9860 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9860 3 25 25 CD 40436 9860 4 : : : 40436 9860 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9860 6 , , , 40436 9860 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9860 8 , , , 40436 9860 9 p. p. NN 40436 9860 10 66 66 CD 40436 9860 11 E. E. NNP 40436 9860 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9860 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9860 14 : : : 40436 9860 15 ei ei UH 40436 9860 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9860 17 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9860 18 / / SYM 40436 9860 19 llome llome NN 40436 9860 20 / / SYM 40436 9860 21 n n CC 40436 9860 22 pote pote NNP 40436 9860 23 katharô katharô NNP 40436 9860 24 = = SYM 40436 9860 25 s s NNP 40436 9860 26 ti ti NNP 40436 9860 27 ei)/sesthai ei)/sesthai NNP 40436 9860 28 , , , 40436 9860 29 a)pallakte a)pallakte CD 40436 9860 30 / / SYM 40436 9860 31 on on IN 40436 9860 32 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 9860 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9860 34 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9860 35 sô sô NNP 40436 9860 36 / / SYM 40436 9860 37 matos matos NN 40436 9860 38 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9860 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9860 40 au)tê=| au)tê=| NNP 40436 9860 41 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 9860 42 psuchê=| psuchê=| NNP 40436 9860 43 theate theate NN 40436 9860 44 / / SYM 40436 9860 45 on on IN 40436 9860 46 au)ta\ au)ta\ JJ 40436 9860 47 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 9860 48 pra pra NNP 40436 9860 49 / / SYM 40436 9860 50 gmata gmata NNS 40436 9860 51 . . . 40436 9860 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9860 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9861 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9861 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9861 3 26 26 CD 40436 9861 4 : : : 40436 9861 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9861 6 , , , 40436 9861 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9861 8 , , , 40436 9861 9 p. p. NN 40436 9861 10 67 67 CD 40436 9861 11 B. b. NN 40436 9862 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9862 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9862 3 : : : 40436 9862 4 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 9862 5 katharô=| katharô=| NNP 40436 9862 6 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9862 7 katharou= katharou= NN 40436 9862 8 e)pha e)pha NNP 40436 9862 9 / / SYM 40436 9862 10 ptesthai ptesthai NNP 40436 9862 11 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9862 12 ou ou NNP 40436 9862 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9862 14 themito\n themito\n ADD 40436 9862 15 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 9862 16 . . . 40436 9862 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9862 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9863 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9863 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9863 3 27 27 CD 40436 9863 4 : : : 40436 9863 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9863 6 , , , 40436 9863 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9863 8 , , , 40436 9863 9 p. p. NN 40436 9863 10 64 64 CD 40436 9863 11 A. a. NN 40436 9864 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9864 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9864 3 : : : 40436 9864 4 kinduneu kinduneu NNP 40436 9864 5 / / SYM 40436 9864 6 ousi ousi NN 40436 9864 7 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9864 8 o(/soi o(/soi PRP 40436 9864 9 tugcha tugcha IN 40436 9864 10 / / SYM 40436 9864 11 nousin nousin NNP 40436 9864 12 o)rthô o)rthô NNP 40436 9864 13 = = SYM 40436 9864 14 s s NNP 40436 9864 15 a)pto a)pto NNP 40436 9864 16 / / SYM 40436 9864 17 menoi menoi NNP 40436 9864 18 philosophi philosophi NNP 40436 9864 19 / / SYM 40436 9864 20 as as IN 40436 9864 21 lelêthe lelêthe NNP 40436 9864 22 / / SYM 40436 9864 23 nai nai NNP 40436 9864 24 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 9864 25 a)/llous a)/llous JJ 40436 9864 26 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 9864 27 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 9864 28 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 9864 29 au)toi\ au)toi\ NNP 40436 9864 30 e)pitêdeu e)pitêdeu NNP 40436 9864 31 / / SYM 40436 9864 32 ousin ousin NN 40436 9864 33 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 9864 34 a)pothnê a)pothnê NNP 40436 9864 35 / / SYM 40436 9864 36 skein skein NN 40436 9864 37 te te NNP 40436 9864 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9864 39 tethna tethna NNP 40436 9864 40 / / SYM 40436 9864 41 nai nai NNP 40436 9864 42 . . . 40436 9864 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9865 1 P. p. NN 40436 9865 2 67 67 CD 40436 9865 3 E E NNS 40436 9865 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9865 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9865 6 : : : 40436 9865 7 oi oi NNP 40436 9865 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9865 9 o)rthô o)rthô NNS 40436 9865 10 = = SYM 40436 9865 11 s s NNP 40436 9865 12 philosophou philosophou NNP 40436 9865 13 = = SYM 40436 9865 14 ntes ntes NNP 40436 9865 15 a)pothnê a)pothnê NNP 40436 9865 16 / / SYM 40436 9865 17 skein skein NN 40436 9865 18 meletô meletô NN 40436 9865 19 = = SYM 40436 9865 20 sin sin NN 40436 9865 21 . . . 40436 9865 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9865 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9866 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9866 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9866 3 28 28 CD 40436 9866 4 : : : 40436 9866 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9866 6 , , , 40436 9866 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9866 8 , , , 40436 9866 9 p. p. NN 40436 9866 10 69 69 CD 40436 9866 11 A. a. NN 40436 9867 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9867 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9867 3 : : : 40436 9867 4 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9867 5 ' ' '' 40436 9867 6 ê)=| ê)=| NNP 40436 9867 7 e)kei e)kei NNPS 40436 9867 8 = = NFP 40436 9867 9 no no DT 40436 9867 10 mo mo NN 40436 9867 11 / / SYM 40436 9867 12 non non AFX 40436 9867 13 to\ to\ NN 40436 9867 14 no no DT 40436 9867 15 / / SYM 40436 9867 16 misma misma NN 40436 9867 17 o)rtho o)rtho CD 40436 9867 18 / / SYM 40436 9867 19 n n CD 40436 9867 20 , , , 40436 9867 21 a)nth a)nth . 40436 9867 22 ' ' '' 40436 9867 23 ou(= ou(= ADD 40436 9867 24 dei= dei= NNP 40436 9867 25 a(/panta a(/panta NNP 40436 9867 26 tau tau NNP 40436 9867 27 = = SYM 40436 9867 28 ta ta NNP 40436 9867 29 katalla katalla NNP 40436 9867 30 / / SYM 40436 9867 31 ttesthai ttesthai NNP 40436 9867 32 , , , 40436 9867 33 phro phro NN 40436 9867 34 / / SYM 40436 9867 35 nêsis nêsis NN 40436 9867 36 . . . 40436 9867 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9867 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9868 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9868 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9868 3 29 29 CD 40436 9868 4 : : : 40436 9868 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9868 6 , , , 40436 9868 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9868 8 , , , 40436 9868 9 p. p. NN 40436 9869 1 69 69 CD 40436 9869 2 - - HYPH 40436 9869 3 83 83 CD 40436 9869 4 - - HYPH 40436 9869 5 84 84 CD 40436 9869 6 . . . 40436 9869 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9870 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9870 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9870 3 30 30 CD 40436 9870 4 : : : 40436 9870 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9870 6 , , , 40436 9870 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9870 8 , , , 40436 9870 9 p. p. NN 40436 9870 10 82 82 CD 40436 9870 11 E. E. NNP 40436 9870 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9870 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9870 14 Side side NN 40436 9870 15 - - HYPH 40436 9870 16 note note NN 40436 9870 17 : : : 40436 9870 18 Souls soul NNS 40436 9870 19 of of IN 40436 9870 20 the the DT 40436 9870 21 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 9870 22 or or CC 40436 9870 23 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 40436 9870 24 men man NNS 40436 9870 25 pass pass VBP 40436 9870 26 after after IN 40436 9870 27 death death NN 40436 9870 28 into into IN 40436 9870 29 the the DT 40436 9870 30 bodies body NNS 40436 9870 31 of of IN 40436 9870 32 different different JJ 40436 9870 33 animals animal NNS 40436 9870 34 . . . 40436 9871 1 The the DT 40436 9871 2 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9871 3 alone alone RB 40436 9871 4 is be VBZ 40436 9871 5 relieved relieve VBN 40436 9871 6 from from IN 40436 9871 7 all all DT 40436 9871 8 communion communion NN 40436 9871 9 with with IN 40436 9871 10 body body NN 40436 9871 11 . . . 40436 9871 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9872 1 On on IN 40436 9872 2 the the DT 40436 9872 3 contrary contrary NN 40436 9872 4 , , , 40436 9872 5 the the DT 40436 9872 6 soul soul NN 40436 9872 7 or or CC 40436 9872 8 mind mind NN 40436 9872 9 of of IN 40436 9872 10 the the DT 40436 9872 11 ordinary ordinary JJ 40436 9872 12 man man NN 40436 9872 13 , , , 40436 9872 14 which which WDT 40436 9872 15 has have VBZ 40436 9872 16 undergone undergo VBN 40436 9872 17 no no DT 40436 9872 18 purification purification NN 40436 9872 19 and and CC 40436 9872 20 remains remain VBZ 40436 9872 21 in in IN 40436 9872 22 close close JJ 40436 9872 23 implication implication NN 40436 9872 24 with with IN 40436 9872 25 the the DT 40436 9872 26 body body NN 40436 9872 27 , , , 40436 9872 28 can can MD 40436 9872 29 not not RB 40436 9872 30 get get VB 40436 9872 31 completely completely RB 40436 9872 32 separated separate VBN 40436 9872 33 even even RB 40436 9872 34 at at IN 40436 9872 35 the the DT 40436 9872 36 moment moment NN 40436 9872 37 of of IN 40436 9872 38 death death NN 40436 9872 39 , , , 40436 9872 40 but but CC 40436 9872 41 remains remain VBZ 40436 9872 42 encrusted encrusted JJ 40436 9872 43 and and CC 40436 9872 44 weighed weigh VBD 40436 9872 45 down down RP 40436 9872 46 by by IN 40436 9872 47 bodily bodily JJ 40436 9872 48 accompaniments accompaniment NNS 40436 9872 49 , , , 40436 9872 50 so so IN 40436 9872 51 as as IN 40436 9872 52 to to TO 40436 9872 53 be be VB 40436 9872 54 unfit unfit JJ 40436 9872 55 for for IN 40436 9872 56 those those DT 40436 9872 57 regions region NNS 40436 9872 58 to to TO 40436 9872 59 which which WDT 40436 9872 60 mind mind VB 40436 9872 61 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9872 62 naturally naturally RB 40436 9872 63 belongs belong VBZ 40436 9872 64 . . . 40436 9873 1 Such such JJ 40436 9873 2 impure impure NN 40436 9873 3 minds mind NNS 40436 9873 4 or or CC 40436 9873 5 souls soul NNS 40436 9873 6 are be VBP 40436 9873 7 the the DT 40436 9873 8 ghosts ghost NNS 40436 9873 9 or or CC 40436 9873 10 shadows shadow NNS 40436 9873 11 which which WDT 40436 9873 12 haunt haunt VBP 40436 9873 13 tombs tomb NNS 40436 9873 14 ; ; , 40436 9873 15 and and CC 40436 9873 16 which which WDT 40436 9873 17 become become VBP 40436 9873 18 visible visible JJ 40436 9873 19 , , , 40436 9873 20 because because IN 40436 9873 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9873 22 cling cling VBP 40436 9873 23 to to IN 40436 9873 24 the the DT 40436 9873 25 visible visible JJ 40436 9873 26 world world NN 40436 9873 27 , , , 40436 9873 28 and and CC 40436 9873 29 hate hate VB 40436 9873 30 the the DT 40436 9873 31 invisible invisible JJ 40436 9873 32 . . . 40436 9874 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9874 2 31 31 CD 40436 9874 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9874 4 Not not RB 40436 9874 5 being be VBG 40436 9874 6 fit fit JJ 40436 9874 7 for for IN 40436 9874 8 separate separate JJ 40436 9874 9 existence existence NN 40436 9874 10 , , , 40436 9874 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9874 12 return return VBP 40436 9874 13 in in IN 40436 9874 14 process process NN 40436 9874 15 of of IN 40436 9874 16 time time NN 40436 9874 17 into into IN 40436 9874 18 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 9874 19 with with IN 40436 9874 20 fresh fresh JJ 40436 9874 21 bodies body NNS 40436 9874 22 , , , 40436 9874 23 of of IN 40436 9874 24 different different JJ 40436 9874 25 species specie NNS 40436 9874 26 of of IN 40436 9874 27 men man NNS 40436 9874 28 or or CC 40436 9874 29 animals animal NNS 40436 9874 30 , , , 40436 9874 31 according accord VBG 40436 9874 32 to to IN 40436 9874 33 the the DT 40436 9874 34 particular particular JJ 40436 9874 35 temperament temperament NN 40436 9874 36 which which WDT 40436 9874 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9874 38 carry carry VBP 40436 9874 39 away away RP 40436 9874 40 with with IN 40436 9874 41 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9874 42 . . . 40436 9875 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9875 2 32 32 CD 40436 9875 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9875 4 The the DT 40436 9875 5 souls soul NNS 40436 9875 6 of of IN 40436 9875 7 despots despot NNS 40436 9875 8 , , , 40436 9875 9 or or CC 40436 9875 10 of of IN 40436 9875 11 violent violent JJ 40436 9875 12 and and CC 40436 9875 13 rapacious rapacious JJ 40436 9875 14 men man NNS 40436 9875 15 , , , 40436 9875 16 will will MD 40436 9875 17 pass pass VB 40436 9875 18 into into IN 40436 9875 19 the the DT 40436 9875 20 bodies body NNS 40436 9875 21 of of IN 40436 9875 22 wolves wolf NNS 40436 9875 23 or or CC 40436 9875 24 kites kite NNS 40436 9875 25 : : : 40436 9875 26 those those DT 40436 9875 27 of of IN 40436 9875 28 the the DT 40436 9875 29 gluttonous gluttonous JJ 40436 9875 30 and and CC 40436 9875 31 drunkards drunkard NNS 40436 9875 32 , , , 40436 9875 33 into into IN 40436 9875 34 asses ass NNS 40436 9875 35 and and CC 40436 9875 36 such such JJ 40436 9875 37 - - HYPH 40436 9875 38 like like JJ 40436 9875 39 animals animal NNS 40436 9875 40 . . . 40436 9876 1 A a DT 40436 9876 2 better well JJR 40436 9876 3 fate fate NN 40436 9876 4 will will MD 40436 9876 5 be be VB 40436 9876 6 reserved reserve VBN 40436 9876 7 for for IN 40436 9876 8 the the DT 40436 9876 9 just just JJ 40436 9876 10 and and CC 40436 9876 11 temperate temperate NN 40436 9876 12 men man NNS 40436 9876 13 , , , 40436 9876 14 who who WP 40436 9876 15 have have VBP 40436 9876 16 been be VBN 40436 9876 17 socially socially RB 40436 9876 18 and and CC 40436 9876 19 politically politically RB 40436 9876 20 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 9876 21 , , , 40436 9876 22 but but CC 40436 9876 23 simply simply RB 40436 9876 24 by by IN 40436 9876 25 habit habit NN 40436 9876 26 and and CC 40436 9876 27 disposition disposition NN 40436 9876 28 , , , 40436 9876 29 without without IN 40436 9876 30 any any DT 40436 9876 31 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9876 32 or or CC 40436 9876 33 pure pure JJ 40436 9876 34 intellect intellect NN 40436 9876 35 : : : 40436 9876 36 for for IN 40436 9876 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9876 38 souls soul NNS 40436 9876 39 will will MD 40436 9876 40 pass pass VB 40436 9876 41 into into IN 40436 9876 42 the the DT 40436 9876 43 bodies body NNS 40436 9876 44 of of IN 40436 9876 45 other other JJ 40436 9876 46 gentle gentle JJ 40436 9876 47 and and CC 40436 9876 48 social social JJ 40436 9876 49 animals animal NNS 40436 9876 50 , , , 40436 9876 51 such such JJ 40436 9876 52 as as IN 40436 9876 53 bees bee NNS 40436 9876 54 , , , 40436 9876 55 ants ant NNS 40436 9876 56 , , , 40436 9876 57 wasps,[33 wasps,[33 NNP 40436 9876 58 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9876 59 & & CC 40436 9876 60 c. c. NNP 40436 9876 61 , , , 40436 9876 62 or or CC 40436 9876 63 perhaps perhaps RB 40436 9876 64 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9876 65 may may MD 40436 9876 66 again again RB 40436 9876 67 return return VB 40436 9876 68 into into IN 40436 9876 69 the the DT 40436 9876 70 human human JJ 40436 9876 71 form form NN 40436 9876 72 , , , 40436 9876 73 and and CC 40436 9876 74 may may MD 40436 9876 75 become become VB 40436 9876 76 moderate moderate JJ 40436 9876 77 men man NNS 40436 9876 78 . . . 40436 9877 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9877 2 is be VBZ 40436 9877 3 the the DT 40436 9877 4 privilege privilege NN 40436 9877 5 only only RB 40436 9877 6 of of IN 40436 9877 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9877 8 who who WP 40436 9877 9 has have VBZ 40436 9877 10 undergone undergo VBN 40436 9877 11 the the DT 40436 9877 12 purifying purifying NN 40436 9877 13 influence influence NN 40436 9877 14 of of IN 40436 9877 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9877 16 , , , 40436 9877 17 and and CC 40436 9877 18 who who WP 40436 9877 19 has have VBZ 40436 9877 20 spent spend VBN 40436 9877 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9877 22 life life NN 40436 9877 23 in in IN 40436 9877 24 trying try VBG 40436 9877 25 to to TO 40436 9877 26 detach detach VB 40436 9877 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9877 28 as as RB 40436 9877 29 much much RB 40436 9877 30 as as IN 40436 9877 31 possible possible JJ 40436 9877 32 from from IN 40436 9877 33 communion communion NN 40436 9877 34 with with IN 40436 9877 35 the the DT 40436 9877 36 body body NN 40436 9877 37 -- -- : 40436 9877 38 to to TO 40436 9877 39 be be VB 40436 9877 40 relieved relieve VBN 40436 9877 41 after after IN 40436 9877 42 death death NN 40436 9877 43 from from IN 40436 9877 44 the the DT 40436 9877 45 obligation obligation NN 40436 9877 46 of of IN 40436 9877 47 fresh fresh JJ 40436 9877 48 embodiment embodiment NN 40436 9877 49 , , , 40436 9877 50 that that IN 40436 9877 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9877 52 soul soul NN 40436 9877 53 may may MD 40436 9877 54 dwell dwell VB 40436 9877 55 by by IN 40436 9877 56 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 9877 57 in in IN 40436 9877 58 a a DT 40436 9877 59 region region NN 40436 9877 60 akin akin JJ 40436 9877 61 to to IN 40436 9877 62 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9877 63 own own JJ 40436 9877 64 separate separate JJ 40436 9877 65 nature nature NN 40436 9877 66 : : : 40436 9877 67 passing pass VBG 40436 9877 68 out out IN 40436 9877 69 of of IN 40436 9877 70 the the DT 40436 9877 71 world world NN 40436 9877 72 of of IN 40436 9877 73 sense sense NN 40436 9877 74 , , , 40436 9877 75 of of IN 40436 9877 76 transient transient JJ 40436 9877 77 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 9877 78 , , , 40436 9877 79 and and CC 40436 9877 80 of of IN 40436 9877 81 mere mere JJ 40436 9877 82 opinion opinion NN 40436 9877 83 , , , 40436 9877 84 into into IN 40436 9877 85 a a DT 40436 9877 86 distinct distinct JJ 40436 9877 87 world world NN 40436 9877 88 where where WRB 40436 9877 89 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9877 90 will will MD 40436 9877 91 be be VB 40436 9877 92 in in IN 40436 9877 93 full full JJ 40436 9877 94 presence presence NN 40436 9877 95 of of IN 40436 9877 96 the the DT 40436 9877 97 eternal eternal JJ 40436 9877 98 Ideas Ideas NNPS 40436 9877 99 , , , 40436 9877 100 essences essence NNS 40436 9877 101 , , , 40436 9877 102 and and CC 40436 9877 103 truth truth NN 40436 9877 104 ; ; : 40436 9877 105 in in IN 40436 9877 106 companionship companionship NN 40436 9877 107 with with IN 40436 9877 108 the the DT 40436 9877 109 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 9877 110 , , , 40436 9877 111 and and CC 40436 9877 112 far far RB 40436 9877 113 away away RB 40436 9877 114 from from IN 40436 9877 115 the the DT 40436 9877 116 miseries misery NNS 40436 9877 117 of of IN 40436 9877 118 humanity humanity NN 40436 9877 119 . . . 40436 9878 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9878 2 34 34 CD 40436 9878 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9878 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9878 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9878 6 31 31 CD 40436 9878 7 : : : 40436 9878 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9878 9 , , , 40436 9878 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9878 11 , , , 40436 9878 12 p. p. NN 40436 9878 13 81 81 CD 40436 9878 14 C C NNP 40436 9878 15 - - HYPH 40436 9878 16 D. D. NNP 40436 9878 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9878 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9878 19 : : : 40436 9878 20 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 9878 21 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 9878 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9878 23 e)/chousa e)/chousa NNP 40436 9878 24 ê ê NNP 40436 9878 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9878 26 toiau toiau NNP 40436 9878 27 / / SYM 40436 9878 28 tê tê NNP 40436 9878 29 psuchê\ psuchê\ NNP 40436 9878 30 baru baru NNP 40436 9878 31 / / SYM 40436 9878 32 netai/ netai/ NNP 40436 9878 33 te te NNP 40436 9878 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9878 35 e(/lketai e(/lketai NNP 40436 9878 36 pa pa NNP 40436 9878 37 / / SYM 40436 9878 38 lin lin NNP 40436 9878 39 ei)s ei) VBZ 40436 9878 40 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9878 41 o(rato\n o(rato\n NNP 40436 9878 42 to to IN 40436 9878 43 / / SYM 40436 9878 44 pon pon NNP 40436 9878 45 , , , 40436 9878 46 pho pho NNP 40436 9878 47 / / SYM 40436 9878 48 bô| bô| NNP 40436 9878 49 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9878 50 a)eidou a)eidou NNP 40436 9878 51 = = SYM 40436 9878 52 s s NNP 40436 9878 53 te te NNP 40436 9878 54 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9878 55 A(/idou A(/idou NNP 40436 9878 56 , , , 40436 9878 57 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 9878 58 le le NNP 40436 9878 59 / / SYM 40436 9878 60 getai getai NNP 40436 9878 61 , , , 40436 9878 62 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 9878 63 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 9878 64 mnê mnê NNP 40436 9878 65 / / SYM 40436 9878 66 mata/ mata/ NNP 40436 9878 67 te te NNP 40436 9878 68 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9878 69 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 9878 70 ta ta NNP 40436 9878 71 / / SYM 40436 9878 72 phous phous JJ 40436 9878 73 kulindoume kulindoume NN 40436 9878 74 / / SYM 40436 9878 75 nê nê NNP 40436 9878 76 , , , 40436 9878 77 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 9878 78 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 9878 79 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 9878 80 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9878 81 ô)/phthê ô)/phthê NNP 40436 9878 82 a)/tta a)/tta NNP 40436 9878 83 psuchô psuchô NNP 40436 9878 84 = = SYM 40436 9878 85 n n CC 40436 9878 86 skotoeidê= skotoeidê= JJ 40436 9878 87 pha pha NN 40436 9878 88 / / SYM 40436 9878 89 smata smata NN 40436 9878 90 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9878 91 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9878 92 al al NNP 40436 9878 93 . . . 40436 9879 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9879 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9879 3 : : : 40436 9879 4 skioeodê= skioeodê= NN 40436 9879 5 phanta phanta NN 40436 9879 6 / / SYM 40436 9879 7 smata smata NN 40436 9879 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9879 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9879 10 , , , 40436 9879 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9879 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9879 13 : : : 40436 9879 14 oi(=a oi(=a NN 40436 9879 15 pare pare NN 40436 9879 16 / / SYM 40436 9879 17 chontai chontai NNP 40436 9879 18 ai ai NNP 40436 9879 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9879 20 toiau toiau NNP 40436 9879 21 = = SYM 40436 9879 22 tai tai NNP 40436 9879 23 psuchai\ psuchai\ NNP 40436 9879 24 ei)/dôla ei)/dôla NNP 40436 9879 25 , , , 40436 9879 26 ai ai VBP 40436 9879 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9879 28 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 9879 29 katharô katharô NNP 40436 9879 30 = = SYM 40436 9879 31 s s NNP 40436 9879 32 a)poluthei a)poluthei NNP 40436 9879 33 = = SYM 40436 9879 34 sai sai NNP 40436 9879 35 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 9879 36 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9879 37 o(ratou= o(ratou= NNP 40436 9879 38 mete mete NN 40436 9879 39 / / SYM 40436 9879 40 chousai chousai NNS 40436 9879 41 , , , 40436 9879 42 dio\ dio\ NNP 40436 9879 43 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9879 44 o(rô o(rô NNP 40436 9879 45 = = SYM 40436 9879 46 ntai ntai NNP 40436 9879 47 . . . 40436 9879 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9879 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9880 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9880 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9880 3 32 32 CD 40436 9880 4 : : : 40436 9880 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9880 6 , , , 40436 9880 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9880 8 , , , 40436 9880 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9880 10 . . . 40436 9881 1 82 82 CD 40436 9881 2 - - SYM 40436 9881 3 84 84 CD 40436 9881 4 . . . 40436 9881 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9882 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9882 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9882 3 33 33 CD 40436 9882 4 : : : 40436 9882 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9882 6 , , , 40436 9882 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9882 8 , , , 40436 9882 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9882 10 . . . 40436 9883 1 82 82 CD 40436 9883 2 A. a. NN 40436 9884 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9884 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9884 3 : : : 40436 9884 4 Ou)kou ou)kou CD 40436 9884 5 = = SYM 40436 9884 6 n n CC 40436 9884 7 eu)daimone eu)daimone NNP 40436 9884 8 / / SYM 40436 9884 9 statoi statoi NNP 40436 9884 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9884 11 tou tou NNP 40436 9884 12 / / SYM 40436 9884 13 tôn tôn NNP 40436 9884 14 ei)si\ ei)si\ NNP 40436 9884 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9884 16 ei)s ei)s NNP 40436 9884 17 be be VB 40436 9884 18 / / SYM 40436 9884 19 ltiston ltiston NNS 40436 9884 20 to to TO 40436 9884 21 / / SYM 40436 9884 22 pon pon NN 40436 9884 23 i)o i)o NNP 40436 9884 24 / / SYM 40436 9884 25 ntes nte NNS 40436 9884 26 oi oi UH 40436 9884 27 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9884 28 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9884 29 dêmotikê\n dêmotikê\n ADD 40436 9884 30 te te NNP 40436 9884 31 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9884 32 politikê\n politikê\n NNPS 40436 9884 33 a)retê\n a)retê\n NNP 40436 9884 34 e)pitetêdeuko e)pitetêdeuko NNP 40436 9884 35 / / SYM 40436 9884 36 tes tes NNP 40436 9884 37 , , , 40436 9884 38 ê(\n ê(\n NNP 40436 9884 39 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 9884 40 kalou kalou NNP 40436 9884 41 = = SYM 40436 9884 42 si si FW 40436 9884 43 sôphrosu sôphrosu NNP 40436 9884 44 / / SYM 40436 9884 45 nên nên NNP 40436 9884 46 te te NNP 40436 9884 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9884 48 dikaiosu dikaiosu NNP 40436 9884 49 / / SYM 40436 9884 50 nên nên NNP 40436 9884 51 , , , 40436 9884 52 e)x e)x NNP 40436 9884 53 e)/thous e)/thous JJ 40436 9884 54 te te NNP 40436 9884 55 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9884 56 mele mele NNP 40436 9884 57 / / SYM 40436 9884 58 tês tês NNP 40436 9884 59 gegonui gegonui NNP 40436 9884 60 = = NFP 40436 9884 61 an an DT 40436 9884 62 a)/neu a)/neu XX 40436 9884 63 philosophi philosophi NNS 40436 9884 64 / / SYM 40436 9884 65 as as IN 40436 9884 66 te te NNP 40436 9884 67 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9884 68 nou= nou= NNP 40436 9884 69 ? ? . 40436 9885 1 . . . 40436 9886 1 . . . 40436 9887 1 . . . 40436 9888 1 O(/ti O(/ti NNP 40436 9888 2 tou tou NNP 40436 9888 3 / / SYM 40436 9888 4 tous tous JJ 40436 9888 5 ei)ko ei)ko NNP 40436 9888 6 / / SYM 40436 9888 7 s s NNP 40436 9888 8 e)stin e)stin , 40436 9888 9 ei)s ei)s , 40436 9888 10 toiou toiou NNP 40436 9888 11 = = SYM 40436 9888 12 ton ton NNP 40436 9888 13 pa pa NNP 40436 9888 14 / / SYM 40436 9888 15 lin lin NNP 40436 9888 16 a)phiknei a)phiknei NNP 40436 9888 17 = = SYM 40436 9888 18 sthai sthai NNP 40436 9888 19 politiko politiko NNP 40436 9888 20 / / SYM 40436 9888 21 n n NNP 40436 9888 22 te te NNP 40436 9888 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9888 24 ê(/meron ê(/meron NNP 40436 9888 25 ge ge NNP 40436 9888 26 / / SYM 40436 9888 27 nos nos NNP 40436 9888 28 , , , 40436 9888 29 ê)/pou ê)/pou NNP 40436 9888 30 melittô melittô NNP 40436 9888 31 = = SYM 40436 9888 32 n n CC 40436 9888 33 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 9888 34 sphêkô sphêkô NNS 40436 9888 35 = = SYM 40436 9888 36 n n CC 40436 9888 37 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 9888 38 murmê murmê NNP 40436 9888 39 / / SYM 40436 9888 40 kôn kôn NNP 40436 9888 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9888 42 , , , 40436 9888 43 & & CC 40436 9888 44 c. c. NNP 40436 9888 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9888 46 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9888 47 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9888 48 34 34 CD 40436 9888 49 : : : 40436 9888 50 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9888 51 , , , 40436 9888 52 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9888 53 , , , 40436 9888 54 pp pp NNP 40436 9888 55 . . . 40436 9889 1 82 82 CD 40436 9889 2 B b NN 40436 9889 3 , , , 40436 9889 4 83 83 CD 40436 9889 5 B b NN 40436 9889 6 , , , 40436 9889 7 84 84 CD 40436 9889 8 B. b. NN 40436 9890 1 Compare compare VB 40436 9890 2 p. p. NN 40436 9890 3 114 114 CD 40436 9890 4 C c NN 40436 9890 5 : : : 40436 9890 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9890 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9890 8 : : : 40436 9890 9 tou tou NNP 40436 9890 10 / / SYM 40436 9890 11 tôn tôn NNP 40436 9890 12 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9890 13 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 9890 14 = = SYM 40436 9890 15 n n CC 40436 9890 16 oi oi NNP 40436 9890 17 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9890 18 philosophi philosophi NNS 40436 9890 19 / / SYM 40436 9890 20 a| a| NN 40436 9890 21 i(kanô i(kanô NNS 40436 9890 22 = = NFP 40436 9890 23 s s NNP 40436 9890 24 kathêra kathêra NNP 40436 9890 25 / / SYM 40436 9890 26 menoi menoi NNP 40436 9890 27 a)/neu a)/neu RB 40436 9890 28 te te NNP 40436 9890 29 sôma sôma NNP 40436 9890 30 / / SYM 40436 9890 31 tôn tôn NNP 40436 9890 32 zô zô NNP 40436 9890 33 = = SYM 40436 9890 34 si si IN 40436 9890 35 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9890 36 para para NNP 40436 9890 37 / / SYM 40436 9890 38 pan pan NN 40436 9890 39 ei)s ei)s JJ 40436 9890 40 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9890 41 e)/peita e)/peita VBZ 40436 9890 42 chro chro NN 40436 9890 43 / / SYM 40436 9890 44 non non JJ 40436 9890 45 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9890 46 , , , 40436 9890 47 & & CC 40436 9890 48 c. c. NNP 40436 9890 49 Also also RB 40436 9890 50 p. p. NN 40436 9890 51 115 115 CD 40436 9890 52 D. D. NNP 40436 9890 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9890 54 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9890 55 Side side NN 40436 9890 56 - - HYPH 40436 9890 57 note note NN 40436 9890 58 : : : 40436 9890 59 Special special JJ 40436 9890 60 privilege privilege NN 40436 9890 61 claimed claim VBD 40436 9890 62 for for IN 40436 9890 63 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 9890 64 in in IN 40436 9890 65 the the DT 40436 9890 66 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9890 67 apart apart RB 40436 9890 68 from from IN 40436 9890 69 the the DT 40436 9890 70 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 9890 71 men man NNS 40436 9890 72 who who WP 40436 9890 73 are be VBP 40436 9890 74 not not RB 40436 9890 75 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 9890 76 . . . 40436 9890 77 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9891 1 Such such JJ 40436 9891 2 is be VBZ 40436 9891 3 the the DT 40436 9891 4 creed creed NN 40436 9891 5 which which WDT 40436 9891 6 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 9891 7 announces announce VBZ 40436 9891 8 to to IN 40436 9891 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9891 10 friends friend NNS 40436 9891 11 in in IN 40436 9891 12 the the DT 40436 9891 13 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9891 14 , , , 40436 9891 15 as as IN 40436 9891 16 supplying supply VBG 40436 9891 17 good good JJ 40436 9891 18 reason reason NN 40436 9891 19 for for IN 40436 9891 20 the the DT 40436 9891 21 readiness readiness NN 40436 9891 22 and and CC 40436 9891 23 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9891 24 with with IN 40436 9891 25 which which WDT 40436 9891 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9891 27 welcomes welcome VBZ 40436 9891 28 death death NN 40436 9891 29 . . . 40436 9892 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9892 2 is be VBZ 40436 9892 3 upon upon IN 40436 9892 4 the the DT 40436 9892 5 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 9892 6 between between IN 40436 9892 7 soul soul NN 40436 9892 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9892 9 or or CC 40436 9892 10 mind mind NN 40436 9892 11 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9892 12 and and CC 40436 9892 13 body body NN 40436 9892 14 , , , 40436 9892 15 that that IN 40436 9892 16 the the DT 40436 9892 17 main main JJ 40436 9892 18 stress stress NN 40436 9892 19 is be VBZ 40436 9892 20 laid lay VBN 40436 9892 21 . . . 40436 9893 1 The the DT 40436 9893 2 partnership partnership NN 40436 9893 3 between between IN 40436 9893 4 the the DT 40436 9893 5 two two CD 40436 9893 6 is be VBZ 40436 9893 7 represented represent VBN 40436 9893 8 as as IN 40436 9893 9 the the DT 40436 9893 10 radical radical JJ 40436 9893 11 cause cause NN 40436 9893 12 of of IN 40436 9893 13 mischief mischief NN 40436 9893 14 : : : 40436 9893 15 and and CC 40436 9893 16 the the DT 40436 9893 17 only only JJ 40436 9893 18 true true JJ 40436 9893 19 relief relief NN 40436 9893 20 to to IN 40436 9893 21 the the DT 40436 9893 22 soul soul NN 40436 9893 23 consists consist VBZ 40436 9893 24 in in IN 40436 9893 25 breaking break VBG 40436 9893 26 up up RP 40436 9893 27 the the DT 40436 9893 28 partnership partnership NN 40436 9893 29 altogether altogether RB 40436 9893 30 , , , 40436 9893 31 so so IN 40436 9893 32 as as IN 40436 9893 33 to to TO 40436 9893 34 attain attain VB 40436 9893 35 a a DT 40436 9893 36 distinct distinct JJ 40436 9893 37 , , , 40436 9893 38 disembodied disembodied JJ 40436 9893 39 , , , 40436 9893 40 existence existence NN 40436 9893 41 . . . 40436 9894 1 Conformably conformably RB 40436 9894 2 to to IN 40436 9894 3 this this DT 40436 9894 4 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9894 5 , , , 40436 9894 6 the the DT 40436 9894 7 line line NN 40436 9894 8 is be VBZ 40436 9894 9 chiefly chiefly RB 40436 9894 10 drawn draw VBN 40436 9894 11 between between IN 40436 9894 12 the the DT 40436 9894 13 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 9894 14 , , , 40436 9894 15 and and CC 40436 9894 16 the the DT 40436 9894 17 multitude multitude NN 40436 9894 18 who who WP 40436 9894 19 are be VBP 40436 9894 20 not not RB 40436 9894 21 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 9894 22 -- -- : 40436 9894 23 not not RB 40436 9894 24 between between IN 40436 9894 25 good good JJ 40436 9894 26 and and CC 40436 9894 27 bad bad JJ 40436 9894 28 agents agent NNS 40436 9894 29 , , , 40436 9894 30 when when WRB 40436 9894 31 the the DT 40436 9894 32 good good JJ 40436 9894 33 agents agent NNS 40436 9894 34 are be VBP 40436 9894 35 not not RB 40436 9894 36 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 9894 37 . . . 40436 9895 1 This this DT 40436 9895 2 last last JJ 40436 9895 3 distinction distinction NN 40436 9895 4 is be VBZ 40436 9895 5 indeed indeed RB 40436 9895 6 noticed notice VBN 40436 9895 7 , , , 40436 9895 8 but but CC 40436 9895 9 is be VBZ 40436 9895 10 kept keep VBN 40436 9895 11 subordinate subordinate JJ 40436 9895 12 . . . 40436 9896 1 The the DT 40436 9896 2 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 40436 9896 3 man man NN 40436 9896 4 of of IN 40436 9896 5 social social JJ 40436 9896 6 goodness goodness NN 40436 9896 7 is be VBZ 40436 9896 8 allowed allow VBN 40436 9896 9 to to TO 40436 9896 10 pass pass VB 40436 9896 11 after after IN 40436 9896 12 death death NN 40436 9896 13 into into IN 40436 9896 14 the the DT 40436 9896 15 body body NN 40436 9896 16 of of IN 40436 9896 17 a a DT 40436 9896 18 bee bee NN 40436 9896 19 , , , 40436 9896 20 or or CC 40436 9896 21 an an DT 40436 9896 22 ant ant NN 40436 9896 23 , , , 40436 9896 24 instead instead RB 40436 9896 25 of of IN 40436 9896 26 that that DT 40436 9896 27 of of IN 40436 9896 28 a a DT 40436 9896 29 kite kite NN 40436 9896 30 or or CC 40436 9896 31 ass;[35 ass;[35 NN 40436 9896 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9896 33 but but CC 40436 9896 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9896 35 does do VBZ 40436 9896 36 not not RB 40436 9896 37 attain attain VB 40436 9896 38 the the DT 40436 9896 39 privilege privilege NN 40436 9896 40 of of IN 40436 9896 41 dissolving dissolve VBG 40436 9896 42 connection connection NN 40436 9896 43 altogether altogether RB 40436 9896 44 with with IN 40436 9896 45 body body NN 40436 9896 46 . . . 40436 9897 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 9897 2 the the DT 40436 9897 3 distinction distinction NN 40436 9897 4 is be VBZ 40436 9897 5 one one CD 40436 9897 6 not not RB 40436 9897 7 easily easily RB 40436 9897 8 traceable traceable JJ 40436 9897 9 : : : 40436 9897 10 since since IN 40436 9897 11 Sokrates[36 sokrates[36 ADD 40436 9897 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9897 13 expressly expressly RB 40436 9897 14 remarks remark VBZ 40436 9897 15 that that IN 40436 9897 16 the the DT 40436 9897 17 large large JJ 40436 9897 18 majority majority NN 40436 9897 19 of of IN 40436 9897 20 mankind mankind NN 40436 9897 21 are be VBP 40436 9897 22 middling middling JJ 40436 9897 23 persons person NNS 40436 9897 24 , , , 40436 9897 25 neither neither CC 40436 9897 26 good good JJ 40436 9897 27 nor nor CC 40436 9897 28 bad bad JJ 40436 9897 29 in in IN 40436 9897 30 any any DT 40436 9897 31 marked marked JJ 40436 9897 32 degree degree NN 40436 9897 33 . . . 40436 9898 1 Philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 9898 2 stand stand VBP 40436 9898 3 in in IN 40436 9898 4 a a DT 40436 9898 5 category category NN 40436 9898 6 by by IN 40436 9898 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9898 8 : : : 40436 9898 9 apart apart RB 40436 9898 10 from from IN 40436 9898 11 the the DT 40436 9898 12 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 9898 13 citizens citizen NNS 40436 9898 14 , , , 40436 9898 15 as as RB 40436 9898 16 well well RB 40436 9898 17 as as IN 40436 9898 18 from from IN 40436 9898 19 the the DT 40436 9898 20 middling middling NN 40436 9898 21 and and CC 40436 9898 22 the the DT 40436 9898 23 vicious vicious JJ 40436 9898 24 . . . 40436 9899 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9899 2 appetites appetite NNS 40436 9899 3 and and CC 40436 9899 4 ambition ambition NN 40436 9899 5 are be VBP 40436 9899 6 indeed indeed RB 40436 9899 7 deadened deaden VBN 40436 9899 8 , , , 40436 9899 9 so so IN 40436 9899 10 that that IN 40436 9899 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9899 12 agree agree VBP 40436 9899 13 with with IN 40436 9899 14 the the DT 40436 9899 15 virtuous virtuous JJ 40436 9899 16 in in IN 40436 9899 17 abstaining abstain VBG 40436 9899 18 from from IN 40436 9899 19 injustice injustice NN 40436 9899 20 : : : 40436 9899 21 but but CC 40436 9899 22 this this DT 40436 9899 23 is be VBZ 40436 9899 24 not not RB 40436 9899 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9899 26 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 9899 27 feature feature NN 40436 9899 28 . . . 40436 9900 1 Philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9900 2 is be VBZ 40436 9900 3 asserted assert VBN 40436 9900 4 to to TO 40436 9900 5 impart impart VB 40436 9900 6 to to IN 40436 9900 7 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9900 8 a a DT 40436 9900 9 special special JJ 40436 9900 10 purification purification NN 40436 9900 11 , , , 40436 9900 12 like like IN 40436 9900 13 that that DT 40436 9900 14 of of IN 40436 9900 15 the the DT 40436 9900 16 Orphic orphic JJ 40436 9900 17 mysteries mystery NNS 40436 9900 18 to to IN 40436 9900 19 the the DT 40436 9900 20 initiated initiate VBN 40436 9900 21 : : : 40436 9900 22 detaching detach VBG 40436 9900 23 the the DT 40436 9900 24 soul soul NN 40436 9900 25 from from IN 40436 9900 26 both both CC 40436 9900 27 the the DT 40436 9900 28 body body NN 40436 9900 29 and and CC 40436 9900 30 the the DT 40436 9900 31 world world NN 40436 9900 32 of of IN 40436 9900 33 sense sense NN 40436 9900 34 , , , 40436 9900 35 except except IN 40436 9900 36 in in IN 40436 9900 37 so so RB 40436 9900 38 far far RB 40436 9900 39 as as IN 40436 9900 40 is be VBZ 40436 9900 41 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 9900 42 for for IN 40436 9900 43 purposes purpose NNS 40436 9900 44 of of IN 40436 9900 45 life life NN 40436 9900 46 : : : 40436 9900 47 replunging replunge VBG 40436 9900 48 the the DT 40436 9900 49 soul soul NN 40436 9900 50 , , , 40436 9900 51 as as RB 40436 9900 52 much much RB 40436 9900 53 as as IN 40436 9900 54 possible possible JJ 40436 9900 55 , , , 40436 9900 56 in in IN 40436 9900 57 the the DT 40436 9900 58 other other JJ 40436 9900 59 world world NN 40436 9900 60 of of IN 40436 9900 61 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 9900 62 essences essence NNS 40436 9900 63 , , , 40436 9900 64 real real JJ 40436 9900 65 forms form NNS 40436 9900 66 or or CC 40436 9900 67 Ideas idea NNS 40436 9900 68 , , , 40436 9900 69 which which WDT 40436 9900 70 are be VBP 40436 9900 71 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9900 72 own own JJ 40436 9900 73 natural natural JJ 40436 9900 74 kindred kindred JJ 40436 9900 75 and and CC 40436 9900 76 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 9900 77 companions companion NNS 40436 9900 78 . . . 40436 9901 1 The the DT 40436 9901 2 process process NN 40436 9901 3 whereby whereby WRB 40436 9901 4 this this DT 40436 9901 5 is be VBZ 40436 9901 6 accomplished accomplish VBN 40436 9901 7 is be VBZ 40436 9901 8 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9901 9 rather rather RB 40436 9901 10 than than IN 40436 9901 11 ethical ethical JJ 40436 9901 12 . . . 40436 9902 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9902 2 is be VBZ 40436 9902 3 the the DT 40436 9902 4 process process NN 40436 9902 5 of of IN 40436 9902 6 learning learning NN 40436 9902 7 , , , 40436 9902 8 or or CC 40436 9902 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9902 10 in in IN 40436 9902 11 the the DT 40436 9902 12 sense sense NN 40436 9902 13 of of IN 40436 9902 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9902 15 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9902 16 the the DT 40436 9902 17 revival revival NN 40436 9902 18 in in IN 40436 9902 19 the the DT 40436 9902 20 mind mind NN 40436 9902 21 of of IN 40436 9902 22 those those DT 40436 9902 23 essences essence NNS 40436 9902 24 or or CC 40436 9902 25 Ideas idea NNS 40436 9902 26 with with IN 40436 9902 27 which which WDT 40436 9902 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9902 29 had have VBD 40436 9902 30 been be VBN 40436 9902 31 familiar familiar JJ 40436 9902 32 during during IN 40436 9902 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9902 34 anterior anterior NN 40436 9902 35 and and CC 40436 9902 36 separate separate JJ 40436 9902 37 life life NN 40436 9902 38 : : : 40436 9902 39 accompanied accompany VBN 40436 9902 40 by by IN 40436 9902 41 the the DT 40436 9902 42 total total JJ 40436 9902 43 abstinence abstinence NN 40436 9902 44 from from IN 40436 9902 45 all all DT 40436 9902 46 other other JJ 40436 9902 47 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 9902 48 and and CC 40436 9902 49 temptations temptation NNS 40436 9902 50 . . . 40436 9903 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9903 2 37 37 CD 40436 9903 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9903 4 Only only RB 40436 9903 5 by by IN 40436 9903 6 such such JJ 40436 9903 7 love love NN 40436 9903 8 of of IN 40436 9903 9 learning learning NN 40436 9903 10 , , , 40436 9903 11 which which WDT 40436 9903 12 is be VBZ 40436 9903 13 identical identical JJ 40436 9903 14 with with IN 40436 9903 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9903 16 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9903 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9903 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9903 19 : : : 40436 9903 20 philo philo JJ 40436 9903 21 / / SYM 40436 9903 22 sophon sophon NN 40436 9903 23 , , , 40436 9903 24 philomathe\s philomathe\s XX 40436 9903 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9903 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9903 27 , , , 40436 9903 28 is be VBZ 40436 9903 29 the the DT 40436 9903 30 mind mind NN 40436 9903 31 rescued rescue VBN 40436 9903 32 from from IN 40436 9903 33 the the DT 40436 9903 34 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 9903 35 and and CC 40436 9903 36 illusions illusion NNS 40436 9903 37 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 40436 9903 38 in in IN 40436 9903 39 the the DT 40436 9903 40 world world NN 40436 9903 41 of of IN 40436 9903 42 sense sense NN 40436 9903 43 . . . 40436 9904 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9904 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9904 3 35 35 CD 40436 9904 4 : : : 40436 9904 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9904 6 , , , 40436 9904 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9904 8 , , , 40436 9904 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9904 10 . . . 40436 9905 1 81 81 CD 40436 9905 2 - - SYM 40436 9905 3 82 82 CD 40436 9905 4 . . . 40436 9905 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9906 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9906 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 9906 3 36 36 CD 40436 9906 4 : : : 40436 9906 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9906 6 , , , 40436 9906 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9906 8 , , , 40436 9906 9 p. p. NN 40436 9906 10 90 90 CD 40436 9906 11 A. a. NN 40436 9906 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9907 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9907 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9907 3 37 37 CD 40436 9907 4 : : : 40436 9907 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9907 6 , , , 40436 9907 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9907 8 , , , 40436 9907 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9907 10 . . . 40436 9908 1 82 82 CD 40436 9908 2 - - SYM 40436 9908 3 115.--[Greek 115.--[greek CD 40436 9908 4 : : : 40436 9908 5 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 9908 6 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9908 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9908 8 ê(dona\s ê(dona\s NNP 40436 9908 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9908 10 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 9908 11 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9908 12 mantha mantha NN 40436 9908 13 / / SYM 40436 9908 14 nein nein NNP 40436 9908 15 e)spou e)spou CD 40436 9908 16 / / SYM 40436 9908 17 dase dase NNP 40436 9908 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9908 19 , , , 40436 9908 20 & & CC 40436 9908 21 c. c. NNP 40436 9908 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9908 23 p. p. NN 40436 9908 24 114 114 CD 40436 9908 25 E e NN 40436 9908 26 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9908 27 . . . 40436 9909 1 These these DT 40436 9909 2 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 9909 3 , , , 40436 9909 4 laid lay VBN 40436 9909 5 down down RP 40436 9909 6 by by IN 40436 9909 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9909 8 in in IN 40436 9909 9 the the DT 40436 9909 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9909 11 , , , 40436 9909 12 bear bear VB 40436 9909 13 great great JJ 40436 9909 14 analogy analogy NN 40436 9909 15 to to IN 40436 9909 16 the the DT 40436 9909 17 Sanskrit Sanskrit NNP 40436 9909 18 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 9909 19 called call VBD 40436 9909 20 _ _ NNP 40436 9909 21 Sankhyâ Sankhyâ NNP 40436 9909 22 _ _ NNP 40436 9909 23 , , , 40436 9909 24 founded found VBN 40436 9909 25 by by IN 40436 9909 26 Kapila Kapila NNP 40436 9909 27 , , , 40436 9909 28 as as IN 40436 9909 29 expounded expound VBN 40436 9909 30 and and CC 40436 9909 31 criticised criticise VBN 40436 9909 32 in in IN 40436 9909 33 the the DT 40436 9909 34 treatise treatise NN 40436 9909 35 of of IN 40436 9909 36 M. M. NNP 40436 9909 37 Barthélemy Barthélemy NNP 40436 9909 38 St. St. NNP 40436 9909 39 Hilaire Hilaire NNP 40436 9909 40 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9909 41 Mémoire mémoire JJ 40436 9909 42 sur sur FW 40436 9909 43 le le NNP 40436 9909 44 Sankhyâ Sankhyâ NNP 40436 9909 45 , , , 40436 9909 46 Paris Paris NNP 40436 9909 47 , , , 40436 9909 48 1852 1852 CD 40436 9909 49 , , , 40436 9909 50 pp pp NNP 40436 9909 51 . . . 40436 9910 1 273 273 CD 40436 9910 2 - - SYM 40436 9910 3 278)--and 278)--and CD 40436 9910 4 the the DT 40436 9910 5 other other JJ 40436 9910 6 work work NN 40436 9910 7 , , , 40436 9910 8 Du Du NNP 40436 9910 9 Bouddhisme Bouddhisme NNP 40436 9910 10 , , , 40436 9910 11 by by IN 40436 9910 12 the the DT 40436 9910 13 same same JJ 40436 9910 14 author author NN 40436 9910 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9910 16 Paris Paris NNP 40436 9910 17 , , , 40436 9910 18 1855 1855 CD 40436 9910 19 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9910 20 , , , 40436 9910 21 pp pp NNP 40436 9910 22 . . . 40436 9911 1 116 116 CD 40436 9911 2 - - SYM 40436 9911 3 137 137 CD 40436 9911 4 , , , 40436 9911 5 187 187 CD 40436 9911 6 - - SYM 40436 9911 7 194 194 CD 40436 9911 8 , , , 40436 9911 9 & & CC 40436 9911 10 c. c. NNP 40436 9911 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9911 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9911 13 Side side NN 40436 9911 14 - - HYPH 40436 9911 15 note note NN 40436 9911 16 : : : 40436 9911 17 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9911 18 and and CC 40436 9911 19 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9911 20 do do VBP 40436 9911 21 not not RB 40436 9911 22 admit admit VB 40436 9911 23 readily readily RB 40436 9911 24 the the DT 40436 9911 25 immortality immortality NN 40436 9911 26 of of IN 40436 9911 27 the the DT 40436 9911 28 soul soul NN 40436 9911 29 , , , 40436 9911 30 but but CC 40436 9911 31 are be VBP 40436 9911 32 unwilling unwilling JJ 40436 9911 33 to to TO 40436 9911 34 trouble trouble NN 40436 9911 35 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9911 36 by by IN 40436 9911 37 asking ask VBG 40436 9911 38 for for IN 40436 9911 39 proof proof NN 40436 9911 40 . . . 40436 9912 1 Unabated unabated JJ 40436 9912 2 interest interest NN 40436 9912 3 of of IN 40436 9912 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9912 5 in in IN 40436 9912 6 rational rational JJ 40436 9912 7 debate debate NN 40436 9912 8 . . . 40436 9912 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9913 1 In in IN 40436 9913 2 thus thus RB 40436 9913 3 explaining explain VBG 40436 9913 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9913 5 own own JJ 40436 9913 6 creed creed NN 40436 9913 7 , , , 40436 9913 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9913 9 announces announce VBZ 40436 9913 10 a a DT 40436 9913 11 full full JJ 40436 9913 12 conviction conviction NN 40436 9913 13 that that IN 40436 9913 14 the the DT 40436 9913 15 soul soul NN 40436 9913 16 or or CC 40436 9913 17 mind mind NN 40436 9913 18 is be VBZ 40436 9913 19 immortal immortal JJ 40436 9913 20 , , , 40436 9913 21 but but CC 40436 9913 22 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9913 23 has have VBZ 40436 9913 24 not not RB 40436 9913 25 yet yet RB 40436 9913 26 offered offer VBN 40436 9913 27 any any DT 40436 9913 28 proof proof NN 40436 9913 29 of of IN 40436 9913 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9913 31 : : : 40436 9913 32 and and CC 40436 9913 33 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9913 34 as as RB 40436 9913 35 well well RB 40436 9913 36 as as IN 40436 9913 37 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9913 38 declare declare VBP 40436 9913 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 9913 40 to to TO 40436 9913 41 stand stand VB 40436 9913 42 in in IN 40436 9913 43 need need NN 40436 9913 44 of of IN 40436 9913 45 proof proof NN 40436 9913 46 . . . 40436 9914 1 Both both DT 40436 9914 2 of of IN 40436 9914 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9914 4 however however RB 40436 9914 5 are be VBP 40436 9914 6 reluctant reluctant JJ 40436 9914 7 to to TO 40436 9914 8 obtrude obtrude VB 40436 9914 9 upon upon IN 40436 9914 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 9914 11 any any DT 40436 9914 12 doubts doubt NNS 40436 9914 13 . . . 40436 9915 1 An an DT 40436 9915 2 opportunity opportunity NN 40436 9915 3 is be VBZ 40436 9915 4 thus thus RB 40436 9915 5 provided provide VBN 40436 9915 6 , , , 40436 9915 7 that that IN 40436 9915 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9915 9 may may MD 40436 9915 10 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 9915 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9915 12 undisturbed undisturbed JJ 40436 9915 13 equanimity equanimity NN 40436 9915 14 -- -- : 40436 9915 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9915 16 unimpaired unimpaired JJ 40436 9915 17 argumentative argumentative JJ 40436 9915 18 readiness readiness NN 40436 9915 19 -- -- : 40436 9915 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9915 21 keen keen JJ 40436 9915 22 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 9915 23 not not RB 40436 9915 24 to to TO 40436 9915 25 relax relax VB 40436 9915 26 the the DT 40436 9915 27 grasp grasp NN 40436 9915 28 of of IN 40436 9915 29 a a DT 40436 9915 30 subject subject NN 40436 9915 31 until until IN 40436 9915 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9915 33 has have VBZ 40436 9915 34 brought bring VBN 40436 9915 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9915 36 to to IN 40436 9915 37 a a DT 40436 9915 38 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 9915 39 close close NN 40436 9915 40 -- -- : 40436 9915 41 without without IN 40436 9915 42 the the DT 40436 9915 43 least least JJS 40436 9915 44 reference reference NN 40436 9915 45 to to IN 40436 9915 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9915 47 speedily speedily RB 40436 9915 48 approaching approaching JJ 40436 9915 49 death death NN 40436 9915 50 . . . 40436 9916 1 This this DT 40436 9916 2 last last RB 40436 9916 3 - - HYPH 40436 9916 4 mentioned mention VBN 40436 9916 5 anxiety anxiety NN 40436 9916 6 is be VBZ 40436 9916 7 made make VBN 40436 9916 8 manifest manif JJS 40436 9916 9 in in IN 40436 9916 10 a a DT 40436 9916 11 turn turn NN 40436 9916 12 of of IN 40436 9916 13 the the DT 40436 9916 14 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 9916 15 , , , 40436 9916 16 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 9916 17 both both DT 40436 9916 18 for for IN 40436 9916 19 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 9916 20 pathos pathos NN 40436 9916 21 and and CC 40436 9916 22 for for IN 40436 9916 23 originality originality NN 40436 9916 24 . . . 40436 9917 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9917 2 38 38 CD 40436 9917 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9917 4 We -PRON- PRP 40436 9917 5 are be VBP 40436 9917 6 thus thus RB 40436 9917 7 brought bring VBN 40436 9917 8 to to IN 40436 9917 9 the the DT 40436 9917 10 more more RBR 40436 9917 11 explicit explicit JJ 40436 9917 12 statement statement NN 40436 9917 13 of of IN 40436 9917 14 those those DT 40436 9917 15 reasons reason NNS 40436 9917 16 upon upon IN 40436 9917 17 which which WDT 40436 9917 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9917 19 relies rely VBZ 40436 9917 20 . . . 40436 9918 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9918 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9918 3 38 38 CD 40436 9918 4 : : : 40436 9918 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9918 6 , , , 40436 9918 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9918 8 , , , 40436 9918 9 p. p. NN 40436 9918 10 89 89 CD 40436 9918 11 B b NN 40436 9918 12 - - HYPH 40436 9918 13 C,--the C,--the VBG 40436 9918 14 remark remark NN 40436 9918 15 made make VBN 40436 9918 16 by by IN 40436 9918 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9918 18 , , , 40436 9918 19 when when WRB 40436 9918 20 stroking stroke VBG 40436 9918 21 down down RP 40436 9918 22 the the DT 40436 9918 23 head head NN 40436 9918 24 and and CC 40436 9918 25 handling handle VBG 40436 9918 26 the the DT 40436 9918 27 abundant abundant JJ 40436 9918 28 hair hair NN 40436 9918 29 of of IN 40436 9918 30 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9918 31 , , , 40436 9918 32 in in IN 40436 9918 33 allusion allusion NN 40436 9918 34 to to IN 40436 9918 35 the the DT 40436 9918 36 cutting cutting NN 40436 9918 37 off off RP 40436 9918 38 of of IN 40436 9918 39 all all PDT 40436 9918 40 this this DT 40436 9918 41 hair hair NN 40436 9918 42 , , , 40436 9918 43 which which WDT 40436 9918 44 would would MD 40436 9918 45 be be VB 40436 9918 46 among among IN 40436 9918 47 the the DT 40436 9918 48 acts act NNS 40436 9918 49 of of IN 40436 9918 50 mourning mourning NN 40436 9918 51 performed perform VBN 40436 9918 52 by by IN 40436 9918 53 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9918 54 on on IN 40436 9918 55 the the DT 40436 9918 56 morrow morrow NN 40436 9918 57 , , , 40436 9918 58 after after IN 40436 9918 59 the the DT 40436 9918 60 death death NN 40436 9918 61 of of IN 40436 9918 62 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9918 63 : : : 40436 9918 64 and and CC 40436 9918 65 the the DT 40436 9918 66 impressive impressive JJ 40436 9918 67 turn turn NN 40436 9918 68 given give VBN 40436 9918 69 to to IN 40436 9918 70 this this DT 40436 9918 71 remark remark NN 40436 9918 72 , , , 40436 9918 73 in in IN 40436 9918 74 reference reference NN 40436 9918 75 to to IN 40436 9918 76 the the DT 40436 9918 77 solution solution NN 40436 9918 78 of of IN 40436 9918 79 the the DT 40436 9918 80 problem problem NN 40436 9918 81 then then RB 40436 9918 82 in in IN 40436 9918 83 debate debate NN 40436 9918 84 . . . 40436 9918 85 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9919 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9919 2 Side side NN 40436 9919 3 - - HYPH 40436 9919 4 note note NN 40436 9919 5 : : : 40436 9919 6 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9919 7 and and CC 40436 9919 8 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9919 9 believe believe VBP 40436 9919 10 fully fully RB 40436 9919 11 in in IN 40436 9919 12 the the DT 40436 9919 13 pre pre NN 40436 9919 14 - - NN 40436 9919 15 existence existence NN 40436 9919 16 of of IN 40436 9919 17 the the DT 40436 9919 18 soul soul NN 40436 9919 19 , , , 40436 9919 20 but but CC 40436 9919 21 not not RB 40436 9919 22 in in IN 40436 9919 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9919 24 post post NN 40436 9919 25 - - NN 40436 9919 26 existence existence NN 40436 9919 27 . . . 40436 9920 1 Doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9920 2 -- -- : 40436 9920 3 That that IN 40436 9920 4 the the DT 40436 9920 5 soul soul NN 40436 9920 6 is be VBZ 40436 9920 7 a a DT 40436 9920 8 sort sort NN 40436 9920 9 of of IN 40436 9920 10 harmony harmony NN 40436 9920 11 -- -- : 40436 9920 12 refuted refute VBN 40436 9920 13 by by IN 40436 9920 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9920 15 . . . 40436 9920 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9921 1 If if IN 40436 9921 2 the the DT 40436 9921 3 arguments argument NNS 40436 9921 4 whereby whereby WRB 40436 9921 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9921 6 proves prove VBZ 40436 9921 7 the the DT 40436 9921 8 immortality immortality NN 40436 9921 9 of of IN 40436 9921 10 the the DT 40436 9921 11 soul soul NN 40436 9921 12 are be VBP 40436 9921 13 neither neither CC 40436 9921 14 forcible forcible JJ 40436 9921 15 nor nor CC 40436 9921 16 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 9921 17 , , , 40436 9921 18 not not RB 40436 9921 19 fully fully RB 40436 9921 20 satisfying satisfy VBG 40436 9921 21 even even RB 40436 9921 22 Simmias[39 Simmias[39 NNP 40436 9921 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9921 24 to to IN 40436 9921 25 whom whom WP 40436 9921 26 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9921 27 are be VBP 40436 9921 28 addressed address VBN 40436 9921 29 -- -- : 40436 9921 30 the the DT 40436 9921 31 adverse adverse JJ 40436 9921 32 arguments argument NNS 40436 9921 33 , , , 40436 9921 34 upon upon IN 40436 9921 35 the the DT 40436 9921 36 faith faith NN 40436 9921 37 of of IN 40436 9921 38 which which WDT 40436 9921 39 the the DT 40436 9921 40 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9921 41 was be VBD 40436 9921 42 denied deny VBN 40436 9921 43 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9921 44 as as IN 40436 9921 45 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9921 46 know know VBP 40436 9921 47 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9921 48 to to TO 40436 9921 49 have have VB 40436 9921 50 been be VBN 40436 9921 51 by by IN 40436 9921 52 many many JJ 40436 9921 53 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 9921 54 of of IN 40436 9921 55 antiquity antiquity NN 40436 9921 56 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9921 57 , , , 40436 9921 58 can can MD 40436 9921 59 not not RB 40436 9921 60 be be VB 40436 9921 61 said say VBN 40436 9921 62 to to TO 40436 9921 63 be be VB 40436 9921 64 produced produce VBN 40436 9921 65 at at RB 40436 9921 66 all all RB 40436 9921 67 . . . 40436 9922 1 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9922 2 and and CC 40436 9922 3 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9922 4 are be VBP 40436 9922 5 represented represent VBN 40436 9922 6 as as IN 40436 9922 7 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 9922 8 companions companion NNS 40436 9922 9 , , , 40436 9922 10 partly partly RB 40436 9922 11 Pythagoreans Pythagoreans NNPS 40436 9922 12 ; ; , 40436 9922 13 desirous desirous JJ 40436 9922 14 to to TO 40436 9922 15 find find VB 40436 9922 16 the the DT 40436 9922 17 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9922 18 true true JJ 40436 9922 19 , , , 40436 9922 20 yet yet CC 40436 9922 21 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 9922 22 of of IN 40436 9922 23 the the DT 40436 9922 24 proofs proof NNS 40436 9922 25 . . . 40436 9923 1 Both both DT 40436 9923 2 of of IN 40436 9923 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9923 4 are be VBP 40436 9923 5 earnest earnest JJ 40436 9923 6 believers believer NNS 40436 9923 7 in in IN 40436 9923 8 the the DT 40436 9923 9 pre pre NN 40436 9923 10 - - NN 40436 9923 11 existence existence NN 40436 9923 12 of of IN 40436 9923 13 the the DT 40436 9923 14 soul soul NN 40436 9923 15 , , , 40436 9923 16 and and CC 40436 9923 17 in in IN 40436 9923 18 the the DT 40436 9923 19 objective objective JJ 40436 9923 20 reality reality NN 40436 9923 21 of of IN 40436 9923 22 Ideas idea NNS 40436 9923 23 or or CC 40436 9923 24 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 9923 25 essences essence NNS 40436 9923 26 . . . 40436 9924 1 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9924 2 however however RB 40436 9924 3 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 9924 4 in in IN 40436 9924 5 part part NN 40436 9924 6 the the DT 40436 9924 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 9924 8 , , , 40436 9924 9 not not RB 40436 9924 10 very very RB 40436 9924 11 clearly clearly RB 40436 9924 12 explained explain VBN 40436 9924 13 , , , 40436 9924 14 " " `` 40436 9924 15 That that IN 40436 9924 16 the the DT 40436 9924 17 soul soul NN 40436 9924 18 is be VBZ 40436 9924 19 a a DT 40436 9924 20 harmony harmony NN 40436 9924 21 or or CC 40436 9924 22 mixture mixture NN 40436 9924 23 " " '' 40436 9924 24 : : : 40436 9924 25 which which WDT 40436 9924 26 opinion opinion NN 40436 9924 27 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9924 28 refutes refute VBZ 40436 9924 29 , , , 40436 9924 30 partly partly RB 40436 9924 31 by by IN 40436 9924 32 some some DT 40436 9924 33 other other JJ 40436 9924 34 arguments argument NNS 40436 9924 35 , , , 40436 9924 36 partly partly RB 40436 9924 37 by by IN 40436 9924 38 pointing point VBG 40436 9924 39 out out RP 40436 9924 40 that that IN 40436 9924 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9924 42 is be VBZ 40436 9924 43 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 9924 44 with with IN 40436 9924 45 the the DT 40436 9924 46 supposition supposition NN 40436 9924 47 of of IN 40436 9924 48 the the DT 40436 9924 49 soul soul NN 40436 9924 50 as as IN 40436 9924 51 pre pre JJ 40436 9924 52 - - NN 40436 9924 53 existent existent NN 40436 9924 54 to to IN 40436 9924 55 the the DT 40436 9924 56 body body NN 40436 9924 57 , , , 40436 9924 58 and and CC 40436 9924 59 that that IN 40436 9924 60 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9924 61 must must MD 40436 9924 62 make make VB 40436 9924 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9924 64 election election NN 40436 9924 65 between between IN 40436 9924 66 the the DT 40436 9924 67 two two CD 40436 9924 68 . . . 40436 9925 1 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9925 2 elects elect VBZ 40436 9925 3 without without IN 40436 9925 4 hesitation hesitation NN 40436 9925 5 , , , 40436 9925 6 in in IN 40436 9925 7 favour favour NN 40436 9925 8 of of IN 40436 9925 9 the the DT 40436 9925 10 pre pre NN 40436 9925 11 - - NN 40436 9925 12 existence existence NN 40436 9925 13 : : : 40436 9925 14 which which WDT 40436 9925 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9925 16 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 9925 17 to to TO 40436 9925 18 be be VB 40436 9925 19 demonstrable demonstrable JJ 40436 9925 20 upon upon IN 40436 9925 21 premisses premiss NNS 40436 9925 22 or or CC 40436 9925 23 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 9925 24 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 9925 25 worthy worthy JJ 40436 9925 26 of of IN 40436 9925 27 trust trust NN 40436 9925 28 : : : 40436 9925 29 while while IN 40436 9925 30 the the DT 40436 9925 31 alleged alleged JJ 40436 9925 32 harmony harmony NN 40436 9925 33 is be VBZ 40436 9925 34 at at IN 40436 9925 35 best good JJS 40436 9925 36 only only RB 40436 9925 37 a a DT 40436 9925 38 probable probable JJ 40436 9925 39 analogy analogy NN 40436 9925 40 , , , 40436 9925 41 not not RB 40436 9925 42 certified certify VBN 40436 9925 43 by by IN 40436 9925 44 conclusive conclusive JJ 40436 9925 45 reasons reason NNS 40436 9925 46 . . . 40436 9926 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9926 2 40 40 CD 40436 9926 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9926 4 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9926 5 again again RB 40436 9926 6 , , , 40436 9926 7 while while IN 40436 9926 8 admitting admit VBG 40436 9926 9 that that IN 40436 9926 10 the the DT 40436 9926 11 soul soul NN 40436 9926 12 existed exist VBD 40436 9926 13 before before IN 40436 9926 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9926 15 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 9926 16 with with IN 40436 9926 17 the the DT 40436 9926 18 present present JJ 40436 9926 19 body body NN 40436 9926 20 , , , 40436 9926 21 and and CC 40436 9926 22 that that IN 40436 9926 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9926 24 is be VBZ 40436 9926 25 sufficiently sufficiently RB 40436 9926 26 durable durable JJ 40436 9926 27 to to TO 40436 9926 28 last last JJ 40436 9926 29 through through IN 40436 9926 30 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 9926 31 with with IN 40436 9926 32 many many JJ 40436 9926 33 different different JJ 40436 9926 34 bodies body NNS 40436 9926 35 -- -- : 40436 9926 36 still still RB 40436 9926 37 expresses express VBZ 40436 9926 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9926 39 apprehension apprehension NN 40436 9926 40 that that IN 40436 9926 41 though though IN 40436 9926 42 durable durable JJ 40436 9926 43 , , , 40436 9926 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9926 45 is be VBZ 40436 9926 46 not not RB 40436 9926 47 eternal eternal JJ 40436 9926 48 . . . 40436 9927 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 9927 2 , , , 40436 9927 3 no no DT 40436 9927 4 man man NN 40436 9927 5 can can MD 40436 9927 6 be be VB 40436 9927 7 sure sure JJ 40436 9927 8 that that IN 40436 9927 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9927 10 present present JJ 40436 9927 11 body body NN 40436 9927 12 is be VBZ 40436 9927 13 not not RB 40436 9927 14 the the DT 40436 9927 15 last last JJ 40436 9927 16 with with IN 40436 9927 17 which which WDT 40436 9927 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9927 19 soul soul NN 40436 9927 20 is be VBZ 40436 9927 21 destined destine VBN 40436 9927 22 to to TO 40436 9927 23 be be VB 40436 9927 24 linked link VBN 40436 9927 25 ; ; : 40436 9927 26 so so IN 40436 9927 27 that that IN 40436 9927 28 immediately immediately RB 40436 9927 29 on on IN 40436 9927 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9927 31 death death NN 40436 9927 32 , , , 40436 9927 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9927 34 will will MD 40436 9927 35 pass pass VB 40436 9927 36 away away RB 40436 9927 37 into into IN 40436 9927 38 nothing nothing NN 40436 9927 39 . . . 40436 9928 1 The the DT 40436 9928 2 opinion opinion NN 40436 9928 3 of of IN 40436 9928 4 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9928 5 is be VBZ 40436 9928 6 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 9928 7 , , , 40436 9928 8 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 40436 9928 9 as as IN 40436 9928 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9928 11 shows show VBZ 40436 9928 12 how how WRB 40436 9928 13 constantly constantly RB 40436 9928 14 the the DT 40436 9928 15 metempsychosis metempsychosis NN 40436 9928 16 , , , 40436 9928 17 or or CC 40436 9928 18 transition transition NN 40436 9928 19 of of IN 40436 9928 20 the the DT 40436 9928 21 soul soul NN 40436 9928 22 from from IN 40436 9928 23 one one CD 40436 9928 24 body body NN 40436 9928 25 to to IN 40436 9928 26 another another DT 40436 9928 27 , , , 40436 9928 28 was be VBD 40436 9928 29 included include VBN 40436 9928 30 in in IN 40436 9928 31 all all PDT 40436 9928 32 the the DT 40436 9928 33 varieties variety NNS 40436 9928 34 of of IN 40436 9928 35 ancient ancient JJ 40436 9928 36 speculation speculation NN 40436 9928 37 on on IN 40436 9928 38 this this DT 40436 9928 39 subject subject NN 40436 9928 40 . . . 40436 9929 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9929 2 41 41 CD 40436 9929 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9929 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9929 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9929 6 39 39 CD 40436 9929 7 : : : 40436 9929 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9929 9 , , , 40436 9929 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9929 11 , , , 40436 9929 12 p. p. NN 40436 9929 13 107 107 CD 40436 9929 14 B. b. NN 40436 9929 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9930 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9930 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9930 3 40 40 CD 40436 9930 4 : : : 40436 9930 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9930 6 , , , 40436 9930 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9930 8 , , , 40436 9930 9 p. p. NN 40436 9931 1 92 92 CD 40436 9931 2 . . . 40436 9931 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9932 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9932 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9932 3 41 41 CD 40436 9932 4 : : : 40436 9932 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9932 6 , , , 40436 9932 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9932 8 , , , 40436 9932 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9932 10 . . . 40436 9933 1 86 86 CD 40436 9933 2 - - SYM 40436 9933 3 95 95 CD 40436 9933 4 . . . 40436 9934 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9934 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9934 3 : : : 40436 9934 4 kra kra NNP 40436 9934 5 = = SYM 40436 9934 6 sin sin NN 40436 9934 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9934 8 a(rmoni a(rmoni NNP 40436 9934 9 / / SYM 40436 9934 10 an an DT 40436 9934 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9934 12 , , , 40436 9934 13 & & CC 40436 9934 14 c. c. NNP 40436 9934 15 " " `` 40436 9934 16 Animam Animam NNP 40436 9934 17 esse esse NN 40436 9934 18 harmoniam harmoniam NN 40436 9934 19 complures complure NNS 40436 9934 20 quidem quidem VBP 40436 9934 21 statuerant statuerant NNP 40436 9934 22 , , , 40436 9934 23 sed sed NNP 40436 9934 24 aliam aliam NNP 40436 9934 25 alii alii NNP 40436 9934 26 , , , 40436 9934 27 et et NNP 40436 9934 28 diversâ diversâ NNP 40436 9934 29 ratione ratione JJ 40436 9934 30 , , , 40436 9934 31 " " '' 40436 9934 32 says say VBZ 40436 9934 33 Wyttenbach Wyttenbach NNP 40436 9934 34 ad ad NN 40436 9934 35 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9934 36 . . . 40436 9935 1 p. p. NN 40436 9935 2 86 86 CD 40436 9935 3 . . . 40436 9936 1 Lucretius Lucretius NNP 40436 9936 2 as as RB 40436 9936 3 well well RB 40436 9936 4 as as IN 40436 9936 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9936 6 impugns impugn VBZ 40436 9936 7 the the DT 40436 9936 8 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9936 9 , , , 40436 9936 10 iii iii CD 40436 9936 11 . . . 40436 9937 1 97 97 CD 40436 9937 2 . . . 40436 9938 1 Galen Galen NNP 40436 9938 2 , , , 40436 9938 3 a a DT 40436 9938 4 great great JJ 40436 9938 5 admirer admirer NN 40436 9938 6 of of IN 40436 9938 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9938 8 , , , 40436 9938 9 though though IN 40436 9938 10 not not RB 40436 9938 11 pretending pretend VBG 40436 9938 12 to to TO 40436 9938 13 determine determine VB 40436 9938 14 positively positively RB 40436 9938 15 wherein wherein WRB 40436 9938 16 the the DT 40436 9938 17 essence essence NN 40436 9938 18 of of IN 40436 9938 19 the the DT 40436 9938 20 soul soul NN 40436 9938 21 consists consist VBZ 40436 9938 22 , , , 40436 9938 23 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 9938 24 a a DT 40436 9938 25 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9938 26 substantially substantially RB 40436 9938 27 the the DT 40436 9938 28 same same JJ 40436 9938 29 as as IN 40436 9938 30 what what WP 40436 9938 31 is be VBZ 40436 9938 32 here here RB 40436 9938 33 impugned impugn VBN 40436 9938 34 -- -- : 40436 9938 35 that that IN 40436 9938 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9938 37 depends depend VBZ 40436 9938 38 upon upon IN 40436 9938 39 a a DT 40436 9938 40 certain certain JJ 40436 9938 41 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9938 42 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9938 43 : : : 40436 9938 44 kra kra NNP 40436 9938 45 = = SYM 40436 9938 46 sis sis NN 40436 9938 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9938 48 of of IN 40436 9938 49 the the DT 40436 9938 50 elements element NNS 40436 9938 51 and and CC 40436 9938 52 properties property NNS 40436 9938 53 in in IN 40436 9938 54 the the DT 40436 9938 55 bodily bodily JJ 40436 9938 56 organism--[Greek organism--[greek CD 40436 9938 57 : : : 40436 9938 58 Peri\ peri\ NN 40436 9938 59 tô tô NNP 40436 9938 60 = = NFP 40436 9938 61 n n NNP 40436 9938 62 tê tê NNP 40436 9938 63 = = SYM 40436 9938 64 s s NNP 40436 9938 65 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 9938 66 = = SYM 40436 9938 67 s s NNP 40436 9938 68 ê)thô ê)thô NNP 40436 9938 69 = = SYM 40436 9938 70 n n NNP 40436 9938 71 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9938 72 , , , 40436 9938 73 vol vol NNP 40436 9938 74 . . . 40436 9939 1 iv iv XX 40436 9939 2 . . . 40436 9940 1 pp pp NNP 40436 9940 2 . . . 40436 9941 1 774 774 CD 40436 9941 2 - - SYM 40436 9941 3 775 775 CD 40436 9941 4 , , , 40436 9941 5 779 779 CD 40436 9941 6 - - HYPH 40436 9941 7 782 782 NNP 40436 9941 8 , , , 40436 9941 9 ed ed NN 40436 9941 10 . . . 40436 9942 1 Kühn Kühn NNP 40436 9942 2 . . . 40436 9943 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9943 2 complains complain VBZ 40436 9943 3 much much JJ 40436 9943 4 of of IN 40436 9943 5 the the DT 40436 9943 6 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 9943 7 explanations explanation NNS 40436 9943 8 of of IN 40436 9943 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9943 10 on on IN 40436 9943 11 this this DT 40436 9943 12 point point NN 40436 9943 13 . . . 40436 9943 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9944 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9944 2 Side side NN 40436 9944 3 - - HYPH 40436 9944 4 note note NN 40436 9944 5 : : : 40436 9944 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9944 7 unfolds unfold VBZ 40436 9944 8 the the DT 40436 9944 9 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9944 10 changes change NNS 40436 9944 11 or or CC 40436 9944 12 wanderings wandering NNS 40436 9944 13 through through IN 40436 9944 14 which which WDT 40436 9944 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9944 16 mind mind NN 40436 9944 17 had have VBD 40436 9944 18 passed pass VBN 40436 9944 19 . . . 40436 9944 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9945 1 Before before IN 40436 9945 2 replying reply VBG 40436 9945 3 to to IN 40436 9945 4 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 9945 5 and and CC 40436 9945 6 Kebês Kebês NNP 40436 9945 7 , , , 40436 9945 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9945 9 is be VBZ 40436 9945 10 described describe VBN 40436 9945 11 as as IN 40436 9945 12 hesitating hesitate VBG 40436 9945 13 and and CC 40436 9945 14 reflecting reflect VBG 40436 9945 15 for for IN 40436 9945 16 a a DT 40436 9945 17 long long JJ 40436 9945 18 time time NN 40436 9945 19 . . . 40436 9946 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 9946 2 then then RB 40436 9946 3 enters enter VBZ 40436 9946 4 into into IN 40436 9946 5 a a DT 40436 9946 6 sketch sketch JJ 40436 9946 7 of[42 of[42 NNP 40436 9946 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9946 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9946 10 own own JJ 40436 9946 11 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 9946 12 history history NN 40436 9946 13 . . . 40436 9947 1 How how WRB 40436 9947 2 far far RB 40436 9947 3 the the DT 40436 9947 4 sketch sketch NN 40436 9947 5 as as IN 40436 9947 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9947 7 stands stand VBZ 40436 9947 8 depicts depict VBZ 40436 9947 9 the the DT 40436 9947 10 real real JJ 40436 9947 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9947 12 , , , 40436 9947 13 or or CC 40436 9947 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9947 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9947 16 , , , 40436 9947 17 or or CC 40436 9947 18 a a DT 40436 9947 19 supposed suppose VBN 40436 9947 20 mind mind NN 40436 9947 21 not not RB 40436 9947 22 exactly exactly RB 40436 9947 23 coincident coincident JJ 40436 9947 24 with with IN 40436 9947 25 either either DT 40436 9947 26 -- -- : 40436 9947 27 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9947 28 can can MD 40436 9947 29 not not RB 40436 9947 30 be be VB 40436 9947 31 certain certain JJ 40436 9947 32 : : : 40436 9947 33 the the DT 40436 9947 34 final final JJ 40436 9947 35 stage stage NN 40436 9947 36 however however RB 40436 9947 37 must must MD 40436 9947 38 belong belong VB 40436 9947 39 to to IN 40436 9947 40 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9947 41 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9947 42 . . . 40436 9948 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9948 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9948 3 42 42 CD 40436 9948 4 : : : 40436 9948 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9948 6 , , , 40436 9948 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9948 8 , , , 40436 9948 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9948 10 . . . 40436 9949 1 96 96 CD 40436 9949 2 - - SYM 40436 9949 3 102 102 CD 40436 9949 4 . . . 40436 9950 1 The the DT 40436 9950 2 following follow VBG 40436 9950 3 abstract abstract JJ 40436 9950 4 is be VBZ 40436 9950 5 intended intend VBN 40436 9950 6 only only RB 40436 9950 7 to to TO 40436 9950 8 exhibit exhibit VB 40436 9950 9 the the DT 40436 9950 10 train train NN 40436 9950 11 of of IN 40436 9950 12 thought thought NN 40436 9950 13 and and CC 40436 9950 14 argument argument NN 40436 9950 15 pursued pursue VBN 40436 9950 16 by by IN 40436 9950 17 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 9950 18 ; ; : 40436 9950 19 not not RB 40436 9950 20 adhering adhere VBG 40436 9950 21 to to IN 40436 9950 22 the the DT 40436 9950 23 exact exact JJ 40436 9950 24 words word NNS 40436 9950 25 , , , 40436 9950 26 nor nor CC 40436 9950 27 even even RB 40436 9950 28 preserving preserve VBG 40436 9950 29 the the DT 40436 9950 30 interlocutory interlocutory JJ 40436 9950 31 form form NN 40436 9950 32 . . . 40436 9951 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9951 2 could could MD 40436 9951 3 not not RB 40436 9951 4 have have VB 40436 9951 5 provided provide VBN 40436 9951 6 room room NN 40436 9951 7 for for IN 40436 9951 8 a a DT 40436 9951 9 literal literal JJ 40436 9951 10 translation translation NN 40436 9951 11 . . . 40436 9951 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9952 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9952 2 Side side NN 40436 9952 3 - - HYPH 40436 9952 4 note note NN 40436 9952 5 : : : 40436 9952 6 First first JJ 40436 9952 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9952 8 of of IN 40436 9952 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 9952 10 as as IN 40436 9952 11 to to TO 40436 9952 12 cause cause VB 40436 9952 13 . . . 40436 9953 1 Reasons reason NNS 40436 9953 2 why why WRB 40436 9953 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9953 4 rejected reject VBD 40436 9953 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9953 6 . . . 40436 9953 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9954 1 " " `` 40436 9954 2 You -PRON- PRP 40436 9954 3 compel compel VBP 40436 9954 4 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9954 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9954 6 says say VBZ 40436 9954 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9954 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9954 9 to to TO 40436 9954 10 discuss discuss VB 40436 9954 11 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 9954 12 the the DT 40436 9954 13 cause cause NN 40436 9954 14 of of IN 40436 9954 15 generation generation NN 40436 9954 16 and and CC 40436 9954 17 destruction destruction NN 40436 9954 18 . . . 40436 9955 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9955 2 43 43 CD 40436 9955 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9955 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9955 5 will will MD 40436 9955 6 tell tell VB 40436 9955 7 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9955 8 , , , 40436 9955 9 if if IN 40436 9955 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 9955 11 like like VBP 40436 9955 12 , , , 40436 9955 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9955 14 own own JJ 40436 9955 15 successive successive JJ 40436 9955 16 impressions impression NNS 40436 9955 17 on on IN 40436 9955 18 these these DT 40436 9955 19 subjects subject NNS 40436 9955 20 . . . 40436 9956 1 When when WRB 40436 9956 2 young young JJ 40436 9956 3 , , , 40436 9956 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9956 5 was be VBD 40436 9956 6 amazingly amazingly RB 40436 9956 7 eager eager JJ 40436 9956 8 for for IN 40436 9956 9 that that DT 40436 9956 10 kind kind NN 40436 9956 11 of of IN 40436 9956 12 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9956 13 which which WDT 40436 9956 14 people people NNS 40436 9956 15 call call VBP 40436 9956 16 the the DT 40436 9956 17 investigation investigation NN 40436 9956 18 of of IN 40436 9956 19 Nature Nature NNP 40436 9956 20 . . . 40436 9957 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9957 2 thought think VBD 40436 9957 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9957 4 matter matter RB 40436 9957 5 of of IN 40436 9957 6 pride pride NN 40436 9957 7 to to TO 40436 9957 8 know know VB 40436 9957 9 the the DT 40436 9957 10 causes cause NNS 40436 9957 11 of of IN 40436 9957 12 every every DT 40436 9957 13 thing thing NN 40436 9957 14 -- -- : 40436 9957 15 through through IN 40436 9957 16 what what WP 40436 9957 17 every every DT 40436 9957 18 thing thing NN 40436 9957 19 is be VBZ 40436 9957 20 either either CC 40436 9957 21 generated generate VBN 40436 9957 22 , , , 40436 9957 23 or or CC 40436 9957 24 destroyed destroy VBN 40436 9957 25 , , , 40436 9957 26 or or CC 40436 9957 27 continues continue VBZ 40436 9957 28 to to TO 40436 9957 29 exist exist VB 40436 9957 30 . . . 40436 9958 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9958 2 puzzled puzzle VBD 40436 9958 3 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9958 4 much much RB 40436 9958 5 to to TO 40436 9958 6 discover discover VB 40436 9958 7 first first RB 40436 9958 8 of of IN 40436 9958 9 all all DT 40436 9958 10 such such JJ 40436 9958 11 matters matter NNS 40436 9958 12 as as IN 40436 9958 13 these these DT 40436 9958 14 -- -- : 40436 9958 15 Is be VBZ 40436 9958 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9958 17 a a DT 40436 9958 18 certain certain JJ 40436 9958 19 putrefaction putrefaction NN 40436 9958 20 of of IN 40436 9958 21 the the DT 40436 9958 22 Hot Hot NNP 40436 9958 23 and and CC 40436 9958 24 the the DT 40436 9958 25 Cold Cold NNP 40436 9958 26 in in IN 40436 9958 27 the the DT 40436 9958 28 system system NN 40436 9958 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9958 30 as as IN 40436 9958 31 some some DT 40436 9958 32 say say VBP 40436 9958 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9958 34 , , , 40436 9958 35 which which WDT 40436 9958 36 brings bring VBZ 40436 9958 37 about about RP 40436 9958 38 the the DT 40436 9958 39 nourishment nourishment NN 40436 9958 40 of of IN 40436 9958 41 animals animal NNS 40436 9958 42 ? ? . 40436 9959 1 Is be VBZ 40436 9959 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9959 3 the the DT 40436 9959 4 blood blood NN 40436 9959 5 through through IN 40436 9959 6 which which WDT 40436 9959 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 9959 8 think think VBP 40436 9959 9 -- -- : 40436 9959 10 or or CC 40436 9959 11 air air NN 40436 9959 12 , , , 40436 9959 13 or or CC 40436 9959 14 fire fire NN 40436 9959 15 ? ? . 40436 9960 1 Or or CC 40436 9960 2 is be VBZ 40436 9960 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9960 4 neither neither CC 40436 9960 5 one one CD 40436 9960 6 nor nor CC 40436 9960 7 the the DT 40436 9960 8 other other JJ 40436 9960 9 , , , 40436 9960 10 but but CC 40436 9960 11 the the DT 40436 9960 12 brain brain NN 40436 9960 13 , , , 40436 9960 14 which which WDT 40436 9960 15 affords afford VBZ 40436 9960 16 to to IN 40436 9960 17 us us NNP 40436 9960 18 sensations sensation NNS 40436 9960 19 of of IN 40436 9960 20 sight sight NN 40436 9960 21 , , , 40436 9960 22 hearing hearing NN 40436 9960 23 , , , 40436 9960 24 and and CC 40436 9960 25 smell smell NN 40436 9960 26 , , , 40436 9960 27 out out IN 40436 9960 28 of of IN 40436 9960 29 which which WDT 40436 9960 30 memory memory NN 40436 9960 31 and and CC 40436 9960 32 opinion opinion NN 40436 9960 33 are be VBP 40436 9960 34 generated generate VBN 40436 9960 35 : : : 40436 9960 36 then then RB 40436 9960 37 , , , 40436 9960 38 by by IN 40436 9960 39 a a DT 40436 9960 40 like like JJ 40436 9960 41 process process NN 40436 9960 42 , , , 40436 9960 43 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9960 44 is be VBZ 40436 9960 45 generated generate VBN 40436 9960 46 out out IN 40436 9960 47 of of IN 40436 9960 48 opinion opinion NN 40436 9960 49 and and CC 40436 9960 50 memory memory NN 40436 9960 51 when when WRB 40436 9960 52 permanently permanently RB 40436 9960 53 fixed fix VBN 40436 9960 54 ? ? . 40436 9961 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9961 2 44 44 CD 40436 9961 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9961 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9961 5 tried try VBD 40436 9961 6 to to TO 40436 9961 7 understand understand VB 40436 9961 8 destructions destruction NNS 40436 9961 9 as as RB 40436 9961 10 well well RB 40436 9961 11 as as IN 40436 9961 12 generations generation NNS 40436 9961 13 , , , 40436 9961 14 celestial celestial JJ 40436 9961 15 as as RB 40436 9961 16 well well RB 40436 9961 17 as as IN 40436 9961 18 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 40436 9961 19 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 9961 20 . . . 40436 9962 1 But but CC 40436 9962 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9962 3 accomplished accomplish VBD 40436 9962 4 nothing nothing NN 40436 9962 5 , , , 40436 9962 6 and and CC 40436 9962 7 ended end VBD 40436 9962 8 by by IN 40436 9962 9 fancying fancy VBG 40436 9962 10 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9962 11 utterly utterly RB 40436 9962 12 unfit unfit JJ 40436 9962 13 for for IN 40436 9962 14 the the DT 40436 9962 15 enquiry enquiry NN 40436 9962 16 . . . 40436 9963 1 Nay nay UH 40436 9963 2 -- -- : 40436 9963 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9963 4 even even RB 40436 9963 5 lost lose VBD 40436 9963 6 all all PDT 40436 9963 7 the the DT 40436 9963 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9963 9 of of IN 40436 9963 10 that that DT 40436 9963 11 which which WDT 40436 9963 12 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9963 13 had have VBD 40436 9963 14 before before RB 40436 9963 15 believed believe VBN 40436 9963 16 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9963 17 to to TO 40436 9963 18 understand understand VB 40436 9963 19 . . . 40436 9964 1 For for IN 40436 9964 2 example example NN 40436 9964 3 -- -- : 40436 9964 4 From from IN 40436 9964 5 what what WP 40436 9964 6 cause cause NN 40436 9964 7 does do VBZ 40436 9964 8 a a DT 40436 9964 9 man man NN 40436 9964 10 grow grow VB 40436 9964 11 ? ? . 40436 9965 1 At at IN 40436 9965 2 first first RB 40436 9965 3 , , , 40436 9965 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9965 5 had have VBD 40436 9965 6 looked look VBN 40436 9965 7 upon upon IN 40436 9965 8 this this DT 40436 9965 9 as as IN 40436 9965 10 evident evident JJ 40436 9965 11 -- -- : 40436 9965 12 that that IN 40436 9965 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9965 14 was be VBD 40436 9965 15 through through IN 40436 9965 16 eating eating NN 40436 9965 17 and and CC 40436 9965 18 drinking drink VBG 40436 9965 19 : : : 40436 9965 20 flesh flesh NN 40436 9965 21 being be VBG 40436 9965 22 thereby thereby RB 40436 9965 23 added add VBN 40436 9965 24 to to IN 40436 9965 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9965 26 flesh flesh NN 40436 9965 27 , , , 40436 9965 28 bone bone NN 40436 9965 29 to to IN 40436 9965 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9965 31 bone bone NN 40436 9965 32 , , , 40436 9965 33 & & CC 40436 9965 34 c. c. NNP 40436 9965 35 So so RB 40436 9965 36 too too RB 40436 9965 37 , , , 40436 9965 38 when when WRB 40436 9965 39 a a DT 40436 9965 40 tall tall JJ 40436 9965 41 and and CC 40436 9965 42 a a DT 40436 9965 43 short short JJ 40436 9965 44 man man NN 40436 9965 45 were be VBD 40436 9965 46 standing stand VBG 40436 9965 47 together together RB 40436 9965 48 , , , 40436 9965 49 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9965 50 appeared appear VBD 40436 9965 51 to to IN 40436 9965 52 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9965 53 that that IN 40436 9965 54 the the DT 40436 9965 55 former former JJ 40436 9965 56 was be VBD 40436 9965 57 taller tall JJR 40436 9965 58 than than IN 40436 9965 59 the the DT 40436 9965 60 latter latter JJ 40436 9965 61 by by IN 40436 9965 62 the the DT 40436 9965 63 head head NN 40436 9965 64 -- -- : 40436 9965 65 that that IN 40436 9965 66 ten ten CD 40436 9965 67 were be VBD 40436 9965 68 more more JJR 40436 9965 69 than than IN 40436 9965 70 eight eight CD 40436 9965 71 because because IN 40436 9965 72 two two CD 40436 9965 73 were be VBD 40436 9965 74 added add VBN 40436 9965 75 to to IN 40436 9965 76 them[45]--that them[45]--that ADD 40436 9965 77 a a DT 40436 9965 78 rod rod NN 40436 9965 79 of of IN 40436 9965 80 two two CD 40436 9965 81 cubits cubit NNS 40436 9965 82 was be VBD 40436 9965 83 greater great JJR 40436 9965 84 than than IN 40436 9965 85 a a DT 40436 9965 86 rod rod NN 40436 9965 87 of of IN 40436 9965 88 one one CD 40436 9965 89 cubit cubit NN 40436 9965 90 , , , 40436 9965 91 because because IN 40436 9965 92 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9965 93 projected project VBD 40436 9965 94 beyond beyond IN 40436 9965 95 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9965 96 by by IN 40436 9965 97 a a DT 40436 9965 98 half half NN 40436 9965 99 . . . 40436 9966 1 Now now RB 40436 9966 2 -- -- : 40436 9966 3 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9966 4 am be VBP 40436 9966 5 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 9966 6 that that IN 40436 9966 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9966 8 do do VBP 40436 9966 9 not not RB 40436 9966 10 know know VB 40436 9966 11 the the DT 40436 9966 12 cause cause NN 40436 9966 13 of of IN 40436 9966 14 any any DT 40436 9966 15 of of IN 40436 9966 16 these these DT 40436 9966 17 matters matter NNS 40436 9966 18 . . . 40436 9967 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9967 2 can can MD 40436 9967 3 not not RB 40436 9967 4 explain explain VB 40436 9967 5 why why WRB 40436 9967 6 , , , 40436 9967 7 when when WRB 40436 9967 8 one one PRP 40436 9967 9 is be VBZ 40436 9967 10 added add VBN 40436 9967 11 to to IN 40436 9967 12 one one CD 40436 9967 13 , , , 40436 9967 14 such such JJ 40436 9967 15 addition addition NN 40436 9967 16 makes make VBZ 40436 9967 17 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9967 18 two two CD 40436 9967 19 ; ; : 40436 9967 20 since since IN 40436 9967 21 in in IN 40436 9967 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9967 23 separated separated JJ 40436 9967 24 state state NN 40436 9967 25 each each DT 40436 9967 26 was be VBD 40436 9967 27 one one CD 40436 9967 28 . . . 40436 9968 1 In in IN 40436 9968 2 this this DT 40436 9968 3 case case NN 40436 9968 4 , , , 40436 9968 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9968 6 is be VBZ 40436 9968 7 approximation approximation NN 40436 9968 8 or or CC 40436 9968 9 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 9968 10 which which WDT 40436 9968 11 is be VBZ 40436 9968 12 said say VBN 40436 9968 13 to to TO 40436 9968 14 make make VB 40436 9968 15 the the DT 40436 9968 16 two two CD 40436 9968 17 : : : 40436 9968 18 in in IN 40436 9968 19 another another DT 40436 9968 20 case case NN 40436 9968 21 , , , 40436 9968 22 the the DT 40436 9968 23 opposite opposite JJ 40436 9968 24 cause cause NN 40436 9968 25 , , , 40436 9968 26 _ _ NNP 40436 9968 27 disjunction disjunction NN 40436 9968 28 _ _ NNP 40436 9968 29 , , , 40436 9968 30 is be VBZ 40436 9968 31 said say VBN 40436 9968 32 also also RB 40436 9968 33 to to TO 40436 9968 34 make make VB 40436 9968 35 two two CD 40436 9968 36 -- -- : 40436 9968 37 when when WRB 40436 9968 38 one one CD 40436 9968 39 body body NN 40436 9968 40 is be VBZ 40436 9968 41 bisected bisect VBN 40436 9968 42 . . . 40436 9969 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9969 2 46 46 CD 40436 9969 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9969 4 How how WRB 40436 9969 5 two two CD 40436 9969 6 opposite opposite JJ 40436 9969 7 causes cause NNS 40436 9969 8 can can MD 40436 9969 9 produce produce VB 40436 9969 10 the the DT 40436 9969 11 same same JJ 40436 9969 12 effect effect NN 40436 9969 13 -- -- : 40436 9969 14 and and CC 40436 9969 15 how how WRB 40436 9969 16 either either DT 40436 9969 17 conjunction conjunction NN 40436 9969 18 or or CC 40436 9969 19 disjunction disjunction NN 40436 9969 20 can can MD 40436 9969 21 produce produce VB 40436 9969 22 two two CD 40436 9969 23 , , , 40436 9969 24 where where WRB 40436 9969 25 there there EX 40436 9969 26 were be VBD 40436 9969 27 not not RB 40436 9969 28 two two CD 40436 9969 29 before before RB 40436 9969 30 -- -- : 40436 9969 31 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9969 32 do do VBP 40436 9969 33 not not RB 40436 9969 34 understand understand VB 40436 9969 35 . . . 40436 9970 1 In in IN 40436 9970 2 fact fact NN 40436 9970 3 , , , 40436 9970 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9970 5 could could MD 40436 9970 6 not not RB 40436 9970 7 explain explain VB 40436 9970 8 to to IN 40436 9970 9 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 9970 10 , , , 40436 9970 11 by by IN 40436 9970 12 this this DT 40436 9970 13 method method NN 40436 9970 14 of of IN 40436 9970 15 research research NN 40436 9970 16 , , , 40436 9970 17 the the DT 40436 9970 18 generation generation NN 40436 9970 19 , , , 40436 9970 20 or or CC 40436 9970 21 destruction destruction NN 40436 9970 22 , , , 40436 9970 23 or or CC 40436 9970 24 existence existence NN 40436 9970 25 , , , 40436 9970 26 of of IN 40436 9970 27 any any DT 40436 9970 28 thing thing NN 40436 9970 29 ; ; : 40436 9970 30 and and CC 40436 9970 31 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9970 32 looked look VBD 40436 9970 33 out out RP 40436 9970 34 for for IN 40436 9970 35 some some DT 40436 9970 36 other other JJ 40436 9970 37 method method NN 40436 9970 38 . . . 40436 9971 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9971 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9971 3 43 43 CD 40436 9971 4 : : : 40436 9971 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9971 6 , , , 40436 9971 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9971 8 , , , 40436 9971 9 pp pp NNP 40436 9971 10 . . . 40436 9972 1 95 95 CD 40436 9972 2 E--96 E--96 NNP 40436 9972 3 . . . 40436 9973 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9973 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9973 3 : : : 40436 9973 4 Ou Ou NNP 40436 9973 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9973 6 phau phau NN 40436 9973 7 = = SYM 40436 9973 8 lon lon NN 40436 9973 9 pra pra NNP 40436 9973 10 = = SYM 40436 9973 11 gma gma NNP 40436 9973 12 zêtei zêtei NNP 40436 9973 13 = = SYM 40436 9973 14 s s XX 40436 9973 15 ; ; : 40436 9973 16 o(/lôs o(/lôs NNP 40436 9973 17 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9973 18 dei= dei= NNP 40436 9973 19 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 9973 20 gene gene NN 40436 9973 21 / / SYM 40436 9973 22 seôs seôs NNP 40436 9973 23 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9973 24 phthora phthora NNP 40436 9973 25 = = SYM 40436 9973 26 s s LS 40436 9973 27 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9973 28 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 9973 29 / / , 40436 9973 30 an an DT 40436 9973 31 diapragmateu diapragmateu NN 40436 9973 32 / / SYM 40436 9973 33 sasthai sasthai NN 40436 9973 34 . . . 40436 9974 1 e)gô\ e)gô\ NNP 40436 9974 2 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 9974 3 soi\ soi\ NNP 40436 9974 4 di di NNP 40436 9974 5 / / SYM 40436 9974 6 eimi eimi NN 40436 9974 7 , , , 40436 9974 8 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 9974 9 bou bou NN 40436 9974 10 / / SYM 40436 9974 11 lê| lê| NNP 40436 9974 12 , , , 40436 9974 13 ta/ ta/ NNP 40436 9974 14 g g NNP 40436 9974 15 ' ' '' 40436 9974 16 e)ma\ e)ma\ NNP 40436 9974 17 pa pa NNP 40436 9974 18 / / SYM 40436 9974 19 thê thê NNP 40436 9974 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9974 21 , , , 40436 9974 22 & & CC 40436 9974 23 c. c. NNP 40436 9974 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9974 25 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9974 26 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9974 27 44 44 CD 40436 9974 28 : : : 40436 9974 29 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9974 30 , , , 40436 9974 31 p. p. NN 40436 9974 32 96 96 CD 40436 9974 33 B. B. NNP 40436 9975 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9975 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9975 3 : : : 40436 9975 4 e)k e)k NNP 40436 9975 5 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9975 6 mnê mnê NNP 40436 9975 7 / / SYM 40436 9975 8 mês mês NNP 40436 9975 9 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9975 10 do do NNP 40436 9975 11 / / SYM 40436 9975 12 xês xês NNP 40436 9975 13 , , , 40436 9975 14 labou labou NNP 40436 9975 15 / / SYM 40436 9975 16 sês sês NN 40436 9975 17 to\ to\ NN 40436 9975 18 ê)remei ê)remei NNP 40436 9975 19 = = SYM 40436 9975 20 n n XX 40436 9975 21 , , , 40436 9975 22 kata\ kata\ NNP 40436 9975 23 tau tau NNP 40436 9975 24 = = SYM 40436 9975 25 ta ta NNP 40436 9975 26 gi gi NNP 40436 9975 27 / / SYM 40436 9975 28 gnesthai gnesthai NNP 40436 9975 29 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 9975 30 / / SYM 40436 9975 31 mên mên NN 40436 9975 32 . . . 40436 9975 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9976 1 This this DT 40436 9976 2 is be VBZ 40436 9976 3 the the DT 40436 9976 4 same same JJ 40436 9976 5 distinction distinction NN 40436 9976 6 between between IN 40436 9976 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9976 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9976 9 : : : 40436 9976 10 do do VB 40436 9976 11 / / SYM 40436 9976 12 xa xa NN 40436 9976 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9976 14 and and CC 40436 9976 15 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9976 16 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9976 17 : : : 40436 9976 18 e)pistê e)pistê NNP 40436 9976 19 / / SYM 40436 9976 20 mê mê NN 40436 9976 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9976 22 , , , 40436 9976 23 as as IN 40436 9976 24 that that DT 40436 9976 25 which which WDT 40436 9976 26 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 9976 27 gives give VBZ 40436 9976 28 in in IN 40436 9976 29 the the DT 40436 9976 30 Menon Menon NNP 40436 9976 31 , , , 40436 9976 32 though though IN 40436 9976 33 not not RB 40436 9976 34 with with IN 40436 9976 35 full full JJ 40436 9976 36 confidence confidence NN 40436 9976 37 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9976 38 Menon Menon NNP 40436 9976 39 , , , 40436 9976 40 pp pp NNP 40436 9976 41 . . . 40436 9977 1 97 97 CD 40436 9977 2 - - SYM 40436 9977 3 98 98 CD 40436 9977 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9977 5 . . . 40436 9978 1 See see VB 40436 9978 2 suprà suprà NNS 40436 9978 3 , , , 40436 9978 4 chap chap NNP 40436 9978 5 . . . 40436 9979 1 xxii xxii NNP 40436 9979 2 . . . 40436 9980 1 p. p. NN 40436 9981 1 241 241 CD 40436 9981 2 . . . 40436 9981 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9982 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9982 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9982 3 45 45 CD 40436 9982 4 : : : 40436 9982 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9982 6 , , , 40436 9982 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9982 8 , , , 40436 9982 9 p. p. NN 40436 9982 10 96 96 CD 40436 9982 11 E. E. NNP 40436 9982 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9982 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9982 14 : : : 40436 9982 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9982 16 e)/ti e)/ti NNP 40436 9982 17 ge ge NNP 40436 9982 18 tou tou NNP 40436 9982 19 / / SYM 40436 9982 20 tôn tôn NNP 40436 9982 21 e)narge e)narge NNP 40436 9982 22 / / SYM 40436 9982 23 stera stera NNP 40436 9982 24 , , , 40436 9982 25 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 9982 26 de de NNP 40436 9982 27 / / SYM 40436 9982 28 ka ka NNP 40436 9982 29 moi moi NNP 40436 9982 30 e)do e)do NNP 40436 9982 31 / / SYM 40436 9982 32 kei kei NNP 40436 9982 33 tô tô NNP 40436 9982 34 = = SYM 40436 9982 35 n n NN 40436 9982 36 o)ktô\ o)ktô\ NNP 40436 9982 37 plei plei NN 40436 9982 38 / / SYM 40436 9982 39 ona ona NNP 40436 9982 40 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 9982 41 , , , 40436 9982 42 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 9982 43 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9982 44 du du NNP 40436 9982 45 / / SYM 40436 9982 46 o o NN 40436 9982 47 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 9982 48 = = NNP 40436 9982 49 s s NNP 40436 9982 50 prosei prosei NNP 40436 9982 51 = = SYM 40436 9982 52 nai nai NNP 40436 9982 53 , , , 40436 9982 54 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9982 55 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9982 56 di di NNP 40436 9982 57 / / SYM 40436 9982 58 pêchu pêchu VBZ 40436 9982 59 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9982 60 pêchuai pêchuai NNP 40436 9982 61 / / SYM 40436 9982 62 ou ou NNP 40436 9982 63 mei mei NNP 40436 9982 64 = = SYM 40436 9982 65 zon zon NNP 40436 9982 66 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 9982 67 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 9982 68 to\ to\ NN 40436 9982 69 ê(mi ê(mi NN 40436 9982 70 / / SYM 40436 9982 71 sei sei NN 40436 9982 72 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 9982 73 u(pere u(pere NNP 40436 9982 74 / / SYM 40436 9982 75 chein chein NN 40436 9982 76 . . . 40436 9982 77 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9982 78 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9983 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9983 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9983 3 46 46 CD 40436 9983 4 : : : 40436 9983 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9983 6 , , , 40436 9983 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9983 8 , , , 40436 9983 9 p. p. NN 40436 9983 10 97 97 CD 40436 9983 11 B. B. NNP 40436 9983 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9984 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9984 2 Side side NN 40436 9984 3 - - HYPH 40436 9984 4 note note NN 40436 9984 5 : : : 40436 9984 6 Second second JJ 40436 9984 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 9984 8 . . . 40436 9985 1 Hopes hope NNS 40436 9985 2 raised raise VBN 40436 9985 3 by by IN 40436 9985 4 the the DT 40436 9985 5 treatise treatise NN 40436 9985 6 of of IN 40436 9985 7 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 9985 8 . . . 40436 9985 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9986 1 " " `` 40436 9986 2 It -PRON- PRP 40436 9986 3 was be VBD 40436 9986 4 at at IN 40436 9986 5 this this DT 40436 9986 6 time time NN 40436 9986 7 that that WDT 40436 9986 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9986 9 heard hear VBD 40436 9986 10 a a DT 40436 9986 11 man man NN 40436 9986 12 reading read VBG 40436 9986 13 out out IN 40436 9986 14 of of IN 40436 9986 15 a a DT 40436 9986 16 book book NN 40436 9986 17 , , , 40436 9986 18 which which WDT 40436 9986 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9986 20 told tell VBD 40436 9986 21 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9986 22 was be VBD 40436 9986 23 the the DT 40436 9986 24 work work NN 40436 9986 25 of of IN 40436 9986 26 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 9986 27 , , , 40436 9986 28 the the DT 40436 9986 29 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 9986 30 that that IN 40436 9986 31 Nous Nous NNP 40436 9986 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 9986 33 Reason Reason NNP 40436 9986 34 , , , 40436 9986 35 Intelligence Intelligence NNP 40436 9986 36 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9986 37 was be VBD 40436 9986 38 the the DT 40436 9986 39 regulator regulator NN 40436 9986 40 and and CC 40436 9986 41 cause cause NN 40436 9986 42 of of IN 40436 9986 43 all all DT 40436 9986 44 things thing NNS 40436 9986 45 . . . 40436 9987 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9987 2 felt feel VBD 40436 9987 3 great great JJ 40436 9987 4 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 9987 5 in in IN 40436 9987 6 this this DT 40436 9987 7 cause cause NN 40436 9987 8 ; ; : 40436 9987 9 and and CC 40436 9987 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9987 11 was be VBD 40436 9987 12 convinced convince VBN 40436 9987 13 , , , 40436 9987 14 that that IN 40436 9987 15 if if IN 40436 9987 16 such such JJ 40436 9987 17 were be VBD 40436 9987 18 the the DT 40436 9987 19 fact fact NN 40436 9987 20 , , , 40436 9987 21 Reason reason NN 40436 9987 22 would would MD 40436 9987 23 ordain ordain VB 40436 9987 24 every every DT 40436 9987 25 thing thing NN 40436 9987 26 for for IN 40436 9987 27 the the DT 40436 9987 28 best good JJS 40436 9987 29 : : : 40436 9987 30 so so IN 40436 9987 31 that that IN 40436 9987 32 if if IN 40436 9987 33 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9987 34 wanted want VBD 40436 9987 35 to to TO 40436 9987 36 find find VB 40436 9987 37 out out RP 40436 9987 38 the the DT 40436 9987 39 cause cause NN 40436 9987 40 of of IN 40436 9987 41 any any DT 40436 9987 42 generation generation NN 40436 9987 43 , , , 40436 9987 44 or or CC 40436 9987 45 destruction destruction NN 40436 9987 46 , , , 40436 9987 47 or or CC 40436 9987 48 existence existence NN 40436 9987 49 , , , 40436 9987 50 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9987 51 had have VBD 40436 9987 52 only only RB 40436 9987 53 to to TO 40436 9987 54 enquire enquire VB 40436 9987 55 in in IN 40436 9987 56 what what WDT 40436 9987 57 manner manner NN 40436 9987 58 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9987 59 was be VBD 40436 9987 60 best best JJ 40436 9987 61 that that IN 40436 9987 62 such such JJ 40436 9987 63 generation generation NN 40436 9987 64 or or CC 40436 9987 65 destruction destruction NN 40436 9987 66 should should MD 40436 9987 67 take take VB 40436 9987 68 place place NN 40436 9987 69 . . . 40436 9988 1 Thus thus RB 40436 9988 2 a a DT 40436 9988 3 man man NN 40436 9988 4 was be VBD 40436 9988 5 only only RB 40436 9988 6 required require VBN 40436 9988 7 to to TO 40436 9988 8 know know VB 40436 9988 9 , , , 40436 9988 10 both both DT 40436 9988 11 respecting respect VBG 40436 9988 12 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 9988 13 and and CC 40436 9988 14 respecting respect VBG 40436 9988 15 other other JJ 40436 9988 16 things thing NNS 40436 9988 17 , , , 40436 9988 18 what what WP 40436 9988 19 was be VBD 40436 9988 20 the the DT 40436 9988 21 best good JJS 40436 9988 22 : : : 40436 9988 23 which which WDT 40436 9988 24 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9988 25 , , , 40436 9988 26 however however RB 40436 9988 27 , , , 40436 9988 28 implied imply VBD 40436 9988 29 that that IN 40436 9988 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9988 31 must must MD 40436 9988 32 also also RB 40436 9988 33 know know VB 40436 9988 34 what what WP 40436 9988 35 was be VBD 40436 9988 36 worse bad JJR 40436 9988 37 -- -- : 40436 9988 38 the the DT 40436 9988 39 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9988 40 of of IN 40436 9988 41 the the DT 40436 9988 42 one one NN 40436 9988 43 and and CC 40436 9988 44 of of IN 40436 9988 45 the the DT 40436 9988 46 other other JJ 40436 9988 47 going go VBG 40436 9988 48 together together RB 40436 9988 49 . . . 40436 9989 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9989 2 47 47 CD 40436 9989 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9989 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9989 5 thought think VBD 40436 9989 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9989 7 had have VBD 40436 9989 8 thus thus RB 40436 9989 9 found find VBN 40436 9989 10 a a DT 40436 9989 11 master master NN 40436 9989 12 quite quite RB 40436 9989 13 to to IN 40436 9989 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9989 15 taste taste NN 40436 9989 16 , , , 40436 9989 17 who who WP 40436 9989 18 would would MD 40436 9989 19 tell tell VB 40436 9989 20 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9989 21 , , , 40436 9989 22 first first RB 40436 9989 23 whether whether IN 40436 9989 24 the the DT 40436 9989 25 earth earth NN 40436 9989 26 was be VBD 40436 9989 27 a a DT 40436 9989 28 disk disk NN 40436 9989 29 or or CC 40436 9989 30 a a DT 40436 9989 31 sphere sphere NN 40436 9989 32 , , , 40436 9989 33 and and CC 40436 9989 34 would would MD 40436 9989 35 proceed proceed VB 40436 9989 36 to to TO 40436 9989 37 explain explain VB 40436 9989 38 the the DT 40436 9989 39 cause cause NN 40436 9989 40 and and CC 40436 9989 41 the the DT 40436 9989 42 necessity necessity NN 40436 9989 43 why why WRB 40436 9989 44 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9989 45 must must MD 40436 9989 46 be be VB 40436 9989 47 so so RB 40436 9989 48 , , , 40436 9989 49 by by IN 40436 9989 50 showing show VBG 40436 9989 51 me -PRON- PRP 40436 9989 52 how how WRB 40436 9989 53 such such JJ 40436 9989 54 arrangement arrangement NN 40436 9989 55 was be VBD 40436 9989 56 the the DT 40436 9989 57 best good JJS 40436 9989 58 : : : 40436 9989 59 next next RB 40436 9989 60 , , , 40436 9989 61 if if IN 40436 9989 62 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9989 63 said say VBD 40436 9989 64 that that IN 40436 9989 65 the the DT 40436 9989 66 earth earth NN 40436 9989 67 was be VBD 40436 9989 68 in in IN 40436 9989 69 the the DT 40436 9989 70 centre centre NN 40436 9989 71 , , , 40436 9989 72 would would MD 40436 9989 73 proceed proceed VB 40436 9989 74 to to TO 40436 9989 75 show show VB 40436 9989 76 that that IN 40436 9989 77 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9989 78 was be VBD 40436 9989 79 best best JJ 40436 9989 80 that that IN 40436 9989 81 the the DT 40436 9989 82 earth earth NN 40436 9989 83 should should MD 40436 9989 84 be be VB 40436 9989 85 in in IN 40436 9989 86 the the DT 40436 9989 87 centre centre NN 40436 9989 88 . . . 40436 9990 1 Respecting respect VBG 40436 9990 2 the the DT 40436 9990 3 Sun Sun NNP 40436 9990 4 , , , 40436 9990 5 Moon Moon NNP 40436 9990 6 , , , 40436 9990 7 and and CC 40436 9990 8 Stars Stars NNPS 40436 9990 9 , , , 40436 9990 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9990 11 expected expect VBD 40436 9990 12 to to TO 40436 9990 13 hear hear VB 40436 9990 14 the the DT 40436 9990 15 like like JJ 40436 9990 16 explanation explanation NN 40436 9990 17 of of IN 40436 9990 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9990 19 movements movement NNS 40436 9990 20 , , , 40436 9990 21 rotations rotation NNS 40436 9990 22 , , , 40436 9990 23 and and CC 40436 9990 24 other other JJ 40436 9990 25 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 9990 26 : : : 40436 9990 27 that that RB 40436 9990 28 is is RB 40436 9990 29 , , , 40436 9990 30 how how WRB 40436 9990 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9990 32 was be VBD 40436 9990 33 better well JJR 40436 9990 34 that that IN 40436 9990 35 each each DT 40436 9990 36 should should MD 40436 9990 37 do do VB 40436 9990 38 and and CC 40436 9990 39 suffer suffer VB 40436 9990 40 exactly exactly RB 40436 9990 41 what what WP 40436 9990 42 the the DT 40436 9990 43 facts fact NNS 40436 9990 44 show show VBP 40436 9990 45 . . . 40436 9991 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9991 2 never never RB 40436 9991 3 imagined imagine VBD 40436 9991 4 that that IN 40436 9991 5 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 9991 6 , , , 40436 9991 7 while while IN 40436 9991 8 affirming affirm VBG 40436 9991 9 that that IN 40436 9991 10 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9991 11 were be VBD 40436 9991 12 regulated regulate VBN 40436 9991 13 by by IN 40436 9991 14 Reason reason NN 40436 9991 15 , , , 40436 9991 16 would would MD 40436 9991 17 put put VB 40436 9991 18 upon upon IN 40436 9991 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9991 20 any any DT 40436 9991 21 other other JJ 40436 9991 22 cause cause NN 40436 9991 23 than than IN 40436 9991 24 this this DT 40436 9991 25 -- -- : 40436 9991 26 that that IN 40436 9991 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9991 28 was be VBD 40436 9991 29 best good JJS 40436 9991 30 for for IN 40436 9991 31 them -PRON- PRP 40436 9991 32 to to TO 40436 9991 33 be be VB 40436 9991 34 exactly exactly RB 40436 9991 35 as as IN 40436 9991 36 they -PRON- PRP 40436 9991 37 are be VBP 40436 9991 38 . . . 40436 9992 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9992 2 presumed presume VBD 40436 9992 3 that that IN 40436 9992 4 , , , 40436 9992 5 when when WRB 40436 9992 6 giving give VBG 40436 9992 7 account account NN 40436 9992 8 of of IN 40436 9992 9 the the DT 40436 9992 10 cause cause NN 40436 9992 11 , , , 40436 9992 12 both both DT 40436 9992 13 of of IN 40436 9992 14 each each DT 40436 9992 15 severally severally RB 40436 9992 16 and and CC 40436 9992 17 all all RB 40436 9992 18 collectively collectively RB 40436 9992 19 , , , 40436 9992 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 9992 21 would would MD 40436 9992 22 do do VB 40436 9992 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9992 24 by by IN 40436 9992 25 setting set VBG 40436 9992 26 forth forth RP 40436 9992 27 what what WP 40436 9992 28 was be VBD 40436 9992 29 best good JJS 40436 9992 30 for for IN 40436 9992 31 each each DT 40436 9992 32 severally severally RB 40436 9992 33 and and CC 40436 9992 34 for for IN 40436 9992 35 all all DT 40436 9992 36 in in IN 40436 9992 37 common common JJ 40436 9992 38 . . . 40436 9993 1 Such such JJ 40436 9993 2 was be VBD 40436 9993 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 9993 4 hope hope NN 40436 9993 5 , , , 40436 9993 6 and and CC 40436 9993 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9993 8 would would MD 40436 9993 9 not not RB 40436 9993 10 have have VB 40436 9993 11 sold sell VBN 40436 9993 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9993 13 for for IN 40436 9993 14 a a DT 40436 9993 15 large large JJ 40436 9993 16 price price NN 40436 9993 17 . . . 40436 9994 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9994 2 48 48 CD 40436 9994 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9994 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9994 5 took take VBD 40436 9994 6 up up RP 40436 9994 7 eagerly eagerly RB 40436 9994 8 the the DT 40436 9994 9 book book NN 40436 9994 10 of of IN 40436 9994 11 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 9994 12 , , , 40436 9994 13 and and CC 40436 9994 14 read read VBD 40436 9994 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 9994 16 as as RB 40436 9994 17 quickly quickly RB 40436 9994 18 as as IN 40436 9994 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9994 20 could could MD 40436 9994 21 , , , 40436 9994 22 that that IN 40436 9994 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 9994 24 might may MD 40436 9994 25 at at RB 40436 9994 26 once once RB 40436 9994 27 come come VB 40436 9994 28 to to IN 40436 9994 29 the the DT 40436 9994 30 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 9994 31 of of IN 40436 9994 32 the the DT 40436 9994 33 better well JJR 40436 9994 34 and and CC 40436 9994 35 worse bad JJR 40436 9994 36 . . . 40436 9995 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9995 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9995 3 47 47 CD 40436 9995 4 : : : 40436 9995 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9995 6 , , , 40436 9995 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9995 8 , , , 40436 9995 9 p. p. NN 40436 9995 10 97 97 CD 40436 9995 11 C C NNP 40436 9995 12 - - HYPH 40436 9995 13 D. D. NNP 40436 9995 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9995 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9995 16 : : : 40436 9995 17 ei ei NNP 40436 9995 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 9995 19 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 9995 20 tis tis NNP 40436 9995 21 bou bou NNP 40436 9995 22 / / SYM 40436 9995 23 loito loito NNP 40436 9995 24 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9995 25 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 9995 26 / / NFP 40436 9995 27 an an DT 40436 9995 28 eu(rei eu(rei NN 40436 9995 29 = = SYM 40436 9995 30 n n CC 40436 9995 31 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 9995 32 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 9995 33 / / SYM 40436 9995 34 stou stou NNP 40436 9995 35 , , , 40436 9995 36 o(/pê| o(/pê| NNP 40436 9995 37 gi gi NNP 40436 9995 38 / / SYM 40436 9995 39 gnetai gnetai NNP 40436 9995 40 ê)\ ê)\ ADD 40436 9995 41 a)po a)po NNS 40436 9995 42 / / SYM 40436 9995 43 llutai llutai NN 40436 9995 44 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 9995 45 e)/sti e)/sti NNP 40436 9995 46 , , , 40436 9995 47 tou tou NNP 40436 9995 48 = = SYM 40436 9995 49 to to IN 40436 9995 50 dei dei NNP 40436 9995 51 = = SYM 40436 9995 52 n n CC 40436 9995 53 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 9995 54 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 9995 55 eu(rei eu(rei NNP 40436 9995 56 = = SYM 40436 9995 57 n n CC 40436 9995 58 , , , 40436 9995 59 o(/pê| o(/pê| CC 40436 9995 60 be be VB 40436 9995 61 / / SYM 40436 9995 62 ltiston ltiston NNP 40436 9995 63 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 9995 64 e)stin e)stin CD 40436 9995 65 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 9995 66 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 9995 67 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 9995 68 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 9995 69 o(tiou o(tiou NNP 40436 9995 70 = = SYM 40436 9995 71 n n NNP 40436 9995 72 pa pa NNP 40436 9995 73 / / SYM 40436 9995 74 schein schein NNP 40436 9995 75 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 9995 76 poiei poiei NN 40436 9995 77 = = SYM 40436 9995 78 n n LS 40436 9995 79 ; ; : 40436 9995 80 e)k e)k NNP 40436 9995 81 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9995 82 dê\ dê\ NN 40436 9995 83 tou= tou= NNP 40436 9995 84 lo lo NNP 40436 9995 85 / / SYM 40436 9995 86 gou gou NNP 40436 9995 87 tou tou NNP 40436 9995 88 / / SYM 40436 9995 89 tou tou NNP 40436 9995 90 ou)de\n ou)de\n NNPS 40436 9995 91 a)/llo a)/llo NNP 40436 9995 92 skopei skopei NNP 40436 9995 93 = = SYM 40436 9995 94 n n CC 40436 9995 95 prosê prosê NNP 40436 9995 96 / / SYM 40436 9995 97 kein kein NNP 40436 9995 98 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 9995 99 / / SYM 40436 9995 100 pô| pô| NNP 40436 9995 101 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9995 102 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 9995 103 au(tou= au(tou= NNP 40436 9995 104 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9995 105 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 9995 106 tô tô NNP 40436 9995 107 = = SYM 40436 9995 108 n n NN 40436 9995 109 a)/llôn a)/llôn UH 40436 9995 110 , , , 40436 9995 111 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 9995 112 ' ' '' 40436 9995 113 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 9995 114 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9995 115 a)/riston a)/riston NNP 40436 9995 116 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9995 117 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9995 118 be be VB 40436 9995 119 / / SYM 40436 9995 120 ltiston ltiston NNS 40436 9995 121 ; ; : 40436 9995 122 a)nagkai a)nagkai , 40436 9995 123 = = SYM 40436 9995 124 on on IN 40436 9995 125 de\ de\ NNP 40436 9995 126 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 9995 127 to\n to\n NNP 40436 9995 128 au)to\n au)to\n NNP 40436 9995 129 tou tou NNP 40436 9995 130 = = SYM 40436 9995 131 ton ton NN 40436 9995 132 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9995 133 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9995 134 chei chei NNP 40436 9995 135 = = NFP 40436 9995 136 ron ron NNP 40436 9995 137 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 9995 138 / / SYM 40436 9995 139 nai nai NN 40436 9995 140 ; ; : 40436 9995 141 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 9995 142 au)tê\n au)tê\n NN 40436 9995 143 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 9995 144 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 9995 145 e)pistê e)pistê CD 40436 9995 146 / / SYM 40436 9995 147 mên mên NN 40436 9995 148 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 9995 149 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 9995 150 = = SYM 40436 9995 151 n n NN 40436 9995 152 . . . 40436 9995 153 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9995 154 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9996 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9996 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 9996 3 48 48 CD 40436 9996 4 : : : 40436 9996 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 9996 6 , , , 40436 9996 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 9996 8 , , , 40436 9996 9 p. p. NN 40436 9996 10 98 98 CD 40436 9996 11 B. b. NN 40436 9997 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9997 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 9997 3 : : : 40436 9997 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9997 5 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 9997 6 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 9997 7 a)pedo a)pedo NNP 40436 9997 8 / / SYM 40436 9997 9 mên mên NN 40436 9997 10 pollou= pollou= NN 40436 9997 11 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 9997 12 e)lpi e)lpi NNP 40436 9997 13 / / SYM 40436 9997 14 das das NNP 40436 9997 15 , , , 40436 9997 16 a)lla\ a)lla\ NNP 40436 9997 17 pa pa NNP 40436 9997 18 / / SYM 40436 9997 19 nu nu NNP 40436 9997 20 spoudê=| spoudê=| NNP 40436 9997 21 labô\n labô\n . 40436 9997 22 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 9997 23 bi bi NN 40436 9997 24 / / SYM 40436 9997 25 blous blous JJ 40436 9997 26 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 9997 27 ta ta NNP 40436 9997 28 / / SYM 40436 9997 29 chista chista NNP 40436 9997 30 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 9997 31 / / SYM 40436 9997 32 s s NNP 40436 9997 33 t t NNP 40436 9997 34 ' ' '' 40436 9997 35 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 9997 36 a)negi a)negi NNP 40436 9997 37 / / SYM 40436 9997 38 gnôskon gnôskon NNP 40436 9997 39 , , , 40436 9997 40 i(/n i(/n NNP 40436 9997 41 ' ' `` 40436 9997 42 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 9997 43 ta ta NNP 40436 9997 44 / / SYM 40436 9997 45 chista chista NNP 40436 9997 46 ei)dei ei)dei NNP 40436 9997 47 / / SYM 40436 9997 48 ên ên NNP 40436 9997 49 to\ to\ NN 40436 9997 50 be be VB 40436 9997 51 / / SYM 40436 9997 52 ltiston ltiston NNP 40436 9997 53 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 9997 54 to\ to\ NNP 40436 9997 55 chei chei NNP 40436 9997 56 = = SYM 40436 9997 57 ron ron XX 40436 9997 58 . . . 40436 9997 59 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9997 60 ] ] -RRB- 40436 9998 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 9998 2 Side side NN 40436 9998 3 - - HYPH 40436 9998 4 note note NN 40436 9998 5 : : : 40436 9998 6 Disappointment disappointment NN 40436 9998 7 because because IN 40436 9998 8 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 9998 9 did do VBD 40436 9998 10 not not RB 40436 9998 11 follow follow VB 40436 9998 12 out out RP 40436 9998 13 the the DT 40436 9998 14 optimistic optimistic JJ 40436 9998 15 principle principle NN 40436 9998 16 into into IN 40436 9998 17 detail detail NN 40436 9998 18 . . . 40436 9999 1 Distinction distinction NN 40436 9999 2 between between IN 40436 9999 3 causes cause VBZ 40436 9999 4 efficient efficient JJ 40436 9999 5 and and CC 40436 9999 6 causes cause VBZ 40436 9999 7 co co JJ 40436 9999 8 - - JJ 40436 9999 9 efficient efficient JJ 40436 9999 10 . . . 40436 9999 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10000 1 " " `` 40436 10000 2 Great great JJ 40436 10000 3 indeed indeed RB 40436 10000 4 was be VBD 40436 10000 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10000 6 disappointment disappointment NN 40436 10000 7 when when WRB 40436 10000 8 , , , 40436 10000 9 as as IN 40436 10000 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10000 11 proceeded proceed VBD 40436 10000 12 with with IN 40436 10000 13 the the DT 40436 10000 14 perusal perusal NN 40436 10000 15 , , , 40436 10000 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10000 17 discovered discover VBD 40436 10000 18 that that IN 40436 10000 19 the the DT 40436 10000 20 author author NN 40436 10000 21 never never RB 40436 10000 22 employed employ VBD 40436 10000 23 Reason reason NN 40436 10000 24 at at RB 40436 10000 25 all all RB 40436 10000 26 , , , 40436 10000 27 nor nor CC 40436 10000 28 assigned assign VBD 40436 10000 29 any any DT 40436 10000 30 causes cause NNS 40436 10000 31 calculated calculate VBN 40436 10000 32 to to TO 40436 10000 33 regulate regulate VB 40436 10000 34 things thing NNS 40436 10000 35 generally generally RB 40436 10000 36 : : : 40436 10000 37 that that IN 40436 10000 38 the the DT 40436 10000 39 causes cause NNS 40436 10000 40 which which WDT 40436 10000 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10000 42 indicated indicate VBD 40436 10000 43 were be VBD 40436 10000 44 , , , 40436 10000 45 air air NN 40436 10000 46 , , , 40436 10000 47 æther æther NN 40436 10000 48 , , , 40436 10000 49 water water NN 40436 10000 50 , , , 40436 10000 51 and and CC 40436 10000 52 many many JJ 40436 10000 53 other other JJ 40436 10000 54 strange strange JJ 40436 10000 55 agencies agency NNS 40436 10000 56 . . . 40436 10001 1 The the DT 40436 10001 2 case case NN 40436 10001 3 seemed seem VBD 40436 10001 4 to to IN 40436 10001 5 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 6 the the DT 40436 10001 7 same same JJ 40436 10001 8 as as IN 40436 10001 9 if if IN 40436 10001 10 any any DT 40436 10001 11 one one CD 40436 10001 12 , , , 40436 10001 13 while while IN 40436 10001 14 announcing announce VBG 40436 10001 15 that that IN 40436 10001 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10001 17 acts act NNS 40436 10001 18 in in IN 40436 10001 19 all all DT 40436 10001 20 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 10001 21 by by IN 40436 10001 22 reason reason NN 40436 10001 23 , , , 40436 10001 24 should should MD 40436 10001 25 next next JJ 40436 10001 26 attempt attempt NN 40436 10001 27 to to TO 40436 10001 28 assign assign VB 40436 10001 29 the the DT 40436 10001 30 causes cause NNS 40436 10001 31 of of IN 40436 10001 32 each each DT 40436 10001 33 of of IN 40436 10001 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10001 35 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 10001 36 severally:[49 severally:[49 NNS 40436 10001 37 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10001 38 As as IN 40436 10001 39 if if IN 40436 10001 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 41 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 10001 42 , , , 40436 10001 43 for for IN 40436 10001 44 example example NN 40436 10001 45 , , , 40436 10001 46 that that IN 40436 10001 47 the the DT 40436 10001 48 cause cause NN 40436 10001 49 why why WRB 40436 10001 50 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 51 am be VBP 40436 10001 52 now now RB 40436 10001 53 sitting sit VBG 40436 10001 54 here here RB 40436 10001 55 is be VBZ 40436 10001 56 , , , 40436 10001 57 that that IN 40436 10001 58 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10001 59 body body NN 40436 10001 60 is be VBZ 40436 10001 61 composed compose VBN 40436 10001 62 of of IN 40436 10001 63 bones bone NNS 40436 10001 64 and and CC 40436 10001 65 ligaments ligament NNS 40436 10001 66 -- -- : 40436 10001 67 that that IN 40436 10001 68 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10001 69 bones bone NNS 40436 10001 70 are be VBP 40436 10001 71 hard hard JJ 40436 10001 72 , , , 40436 10001 73 and and CC 40436 10001 74 are be VBP 40436 10001 75 held hold VBN 40436 10001 76 apart apart RB 40436 10001 77 by by IN 40436 10001 78 commissures commissure NNS 40436 10001 79 , , , 40436 10001 80 and and CC 40436 10001 81 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10001 82 ligaments ligament NNS 40436 10001 83 such such JJ 40436 10001 84 as as IN 40436 10001 85 to to TO 40436 10001 86 contract contract VB 40436 10001 87 and and CC 40436 10001 88 relax relax VB 40436 10001 89 , , , 40436 10001 90 clothing clothe VBG 40436 10001 91 the the DT 40436 10001 92 bones bone NNS 40436 10001 93 along along IN 40436 10001 94 with with IN 40436 10001 95 the the DT 40436 10001 96 flesh flesh NN 40436 10001 97 and and CC 40436 10001 98 the the DT 40436 10001 99 skin skin NN 40436 10001 100 which which WDT 40436 10001 101 keeps keep VBZ 40436 10001 102 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 103 together together RB 40436 10001 104 -- -- : 40436 10001 105 that that IN 40436 10001 106 when when WRB 40436 10001 107 the the DT 40436 10001 108 bones bone NNS 40436 10001 109 are be VBP 40436 10001 110 lifted lift VBN 40436 10001 111 up up RP 40436 10001 112 at at IN 40436 10001 113 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10001 114 points point NNS 40436 10001 115 of of IN 40436 10001 116 junction junction NN 40436 10001 117 , , , 40436 10001 118 the the DT 40436 10001 119 contraction contraction NN 40436 10001 120 and and CC 40436 10001 121 relaxation relaxation NN 40436 10001 122 of of IN 40436 10001 123 the the DT 40436 10001 124 ligaments ligament NNS 40436 10001 125 makes make VBZ 40436 10001 126 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 127 able able JJ 40436 10001 128 to to TO 40436 10001 129 bend bend VB 40436 10001 130 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10001 131 limbs limb NNS 40436 10001 132 -- -- : 40436 10001 133 and and CC 40436 10001 134 that that IN 40436 10001 135 this this DT 40436 10001 136 is be VBZ 40436 10001 137 the the DT 40436 10001 138 reason reason NN 40436 10001 139 why why WRB 40436 10001 140 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 141 am be VBP 40436 10001 142 now now RB 40436 10001 143 seated seat VBN 40436 10001 144 here here RB 40436 10001 145 in in IN 40436 10001 146 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10001 147 present present NN 40436 10001 148 crumpled crumple VBN 40436 10001 149 attitude attitude NN 40436 10001 150 : : : 40436 10001 151 or or CC 40436 10001 152 again again RB 40436 10001 153 -- -- : 40436 10001 154 as as IN 40436 10001 155 if if IN 40436 10001 156 , , , 40436 10001 157 concerning concern VBG 40436 10001 158 the the DT 40436 10001 159 fact fact NN 40436 10001 160 of of IN 40436 10001 161 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10001 162 present present JJ 40436 10001 163 conversation conversation NN 40436 10001 164 with with IN 40436 10001 165 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 166 , , , 40436 10001 167 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 168 were be VBD 40436 10001 169 to to TO 40436 10001 170 point point VB 40436 10001 171 to to IN 40436 10001 172 other other JJ 40436 10001 173 causes cause NNS 40436 10001 174 of of IN 40436 10001 175 a a DT 40436 10001 176 like like JJ 40436 10001 177 character character NN 40436 10001 178 -- -- : 40436 10001 179 varieties variety NNS 40436 10001 180 of of IN 40436 10001 181 speech speech NN 40436 10001 182 , , , 40436 10001 183 air air NN 40436 10001 184 , , , 40436 10001 185 and and CC 40436 10001 186 hearing hearing NN 40436 10001 187 , , , 40436 10001 188 with with IN 40436 10001 189 numerous numerous JJ 40436 10001 190 other other JJ 40436 10001 191 similar similar JJ 40436 10001 192 facts fact NNS 40436 10001 193 -- -- : 40436 10001 194 omitting omit VBG 40436 10001 195 all all PDT 40436 10001 196 the the DT 40436 10001 197 while while NN 40436 10001 198 to to TO 40436 10001 199 notice notice VB 40436 10001 200 the the DT 40436 10001 201 true true JJ 40436 10001 202 causes cause NNS 40436 10001 203 , , , 40436 10001 204 _ _ NNP 40436 10001 205 viz._[50]--That viz._[50]--That NNP 40436 10001 206 inasmuch inasmuch NN 40436 10001 207 as as IN 40436 10001 208 the the DT 40436 10001 209 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 10001 210 have have VBP 40436 10001 211 deemed deem VBN 40436 10001 212 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 213 best well RBS 40436 10001 214 to to TO 40436 10001 215 condemn condemn VB 40436 10001 216 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 217 , , , 40436 10001 218 for for IN 40436 10001 219 that that DT 40436 10001 220 reason reason NN 40436 10001 221 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 222 too too RB 40436 10001 223 have have VBP 40436 10001 224 deemed deem VBN 40436 10001 225 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 226 best well RBS 40436 10001 227 and and CC 40436 10001 228 most most RBS 40436 10001 229 righteous righteous JJ 40436 10001 230 to to TO 40436 10001 231 remain remain VB 40436 10001 232 sitting sit VBG 40436 10001 233 here here RB 40436 10001 234 and and CC 40436 10001 235 to to TO 40436 10001 236 undergo undergo VB 40436 10001 237 the the DT 40436 10001 238 sentence sentence NN 40436 10001 239 which which WDT 40436 10001 240 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10001 241 impose impose VBP 40436 10001 242 . . . 40436 10002 1 For for IN 40436 10002 2 , , , 40436 10002 3 by by IN 40436 10002 4 the the DT 40436 10002 5 Dog Dog NNP 40436 10002 6 , , , 40436 10002 7 these these DT 40436 10002 8 bones bone NNS 40436 10002 9 and and CC 40436 10002 10 ligaments ligament NNS 40436 10002 11 would would MD 40436 10002 12 have have VB 40436 10002 13 been be VBN 40436 10002 14 long long RB 40436 10002 15 ago ago RB 40436 10002 16 carried carry VBN 40436 10002 17 away away RB 40436 10002 18 to to IN 40436 10002 19 Thebes Thebes NNP 40436 10002 20 or or CC 40436 10002 21 Megara Megara NNP 40436 10002 22 , , , 40436 10002 23 by by IN 40436 10002 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10002 25 judgment judgment NN 40436 10002 26 of of IN 40436 10002 27 what what WP 40436 10002 28 is be VBZ 40436 10002 29 best good JJS 40436 10002 30 -- -- : 40436 10002 31 if if IN 40436 10002 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10002 33 had have VBD 40436 10002 34 not not RB 40436 10002 35 deemed deem VBN 40436 10002 36 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10002 37 more more RBR 40436 10002 38 righteous righteous JJ 40436 10002 39 and and CC 40436 10002 40 honourable honourable JJ 40436 10002 41 to to TO 40436 10002 42 stay stay VB 40436 10002 43 and and CC 40436 10002 44 affront affront VB 40436 10002 45 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10002 46 imposed impose VBN 40436 10002 47 sentence sentence NN 40436 10002 48 , , , 40436 10002 49 rather rather RB 40436 10002 50 than than IN 40436 10002 51 to to TO 40436 10002 52 run run VB 40436 10002 53 away away RB 40436 10002 54 . . . 40436 10003 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10003 2 is be VBZ 40436 10003 3 altogether altogether RB 40436 10003 4 absurd absurd JJ 40436 10003 5 to to TO 40436 10003 6 call call VB 40436 10003 7 such such JJ 40436 10003 8 agencies agency NNS 40436 10003 9 by by IN 40436 10003 10 the the DT 40436 10003 11 name name NN 40436 10003 12 of of IN 40436 10003 13 _ _ NNP 40436 10003 14 causes cause VBZ 40436 10003 15 _ _ NNP 40436 10003 16 . . . 40436 10004 1 Certainly certainly RB 40436 10004 2 , , , 40436 10004 3 if if IN 40436 10004 4 a a DT 40436 10004 5 man man NN 40436 10004 6 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 10004 7 that that IN 40436 10004 8 unless unless IN 40436 10004 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10004 10 possessed possess VBD 40436 10004 11 such such JJ 40436 10004 12 joints joint NNS 40436 10004 13 and and CC 40436 10004 14 ligaments ligament NNS 40436 10004 15 and and CC 40436 10004 16 other other JJ 40436 10004 17 members member NNS 40436 10004 18 as as RB 40436 10004 19 now now RB 40436 10004 20 belong belong VBP 40436 10004 21 to to IN 40436 10004 22 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10004 23 , , , 40436 10004 24 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10004 25 should should MD 40436 10004 26 not not RB 40436 10004 27 be be VB 40436 10004 28 able able JJ 40436 10004 29 to to TO 40436 10004 30 execute execute VB 40436 10004 31 what what WP 40436 10004 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10004 33 have have VBP 40436 10004 34 determined determine VBN 40436 10004 35 on on RP 40436 10004 36 , , , 40436 10004 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10004 38 will will MD 40436 10004 39 state state VB 40436 10004 40 no no RB 40436 10004 41 more more JJR 40436 10004 42 than than IN 40436 10004 43 the the DT 40436 10004 44 truth truth NN 40436 10004 45 . . . 40436 10005 1 But but CC 40436 10005 2 to to TO 40436 10005 3 say say VB 40436 10005 4 that that IN 40436 10005 5 these these DT 40436 10005 6 are be VBP 40436 10005 7 the the DT 40436 10005 8 causes cause NNS 40436 10005 9 why why WRB 40436 10005 10 I I NNP 40436 10005 11 , , , 40436 10005 12 a a DT 40436 10005 13 rational rational JJ 40436 10005 14 agent agent NN 40436 10005 15 , , , 40436 10005 16 do do VB 40436 10005 17 what what WP 40436 10005 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10005 19 am be VBP 40436 10005 20 now now RB 40436 10005 21 doing do VBG 40436 10005 22 , , , 40436 10005 23 instead instead RB 40436 10005 24 of of IN 40436 10005 25 saying say VBG 40436 10005 26 that that IN 40436 10005 27 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10005 28 do do VBP 40436 10005 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10005 30 from from IN 40436 10005 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10005 32 choice choice NN 40436 10005 33 of of IN 40436 10005 34 what what WP 40436 10005 35 is be VBZ 40436 10005 36 best good JJS 40436 10005 37 -- -- : 40436 10005 38 this this DT 40436 10005 39 would would MD 40436 10005 40 be be VB 40436 10005 41 great great JJ 40436 10005 42 carelessness carelessness NN 40436 10005 43 of of IN 40436 10005 44 speech speech NN 40436 10005 45 : : : 40436 10005 46 implying imply VBG 40436 10005 47 that that IN 40436 10005 48 a a DT 40436 10005 49 man man NN 40436 10005 50 can can MD 40436 10005 51 not not RB 40436 10005 52 see see VB 40436 10005 53 the the DT 40436 10005 54 distinction distinction NN 40436 10005 55 between between IN 40436 10005 56 that that DT 40436 10005 57 which which WDT 40436 10005 58 is be VBZ 40436 10005 59 the the DT 40436 10005 60 cause cause NN 40436 10005 61 in in IN 40436 10005 62 reality reality NN 40436 10005 63 , , , 40436 10005 64 and and CC 40436 10005 65 that that IN 40436 10005 66 without without IN 40436 10005 67 which which WDT 40436 10005 68 the the DT 40436 10005 69 cause cause NN 40436 10005 70 can can MD 40436 10005 71 never never RB 40436 10005 72 be be VB 40436 10005 73 a a DT 40436 10005 74 cause cause NN 40436 10005 75 . . . 40436 10006 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10006 2 51 51 CD 40436 10006 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10006 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10006 5 is be VBZ 40436 10006 6 this this DT 40436 10006 7 last last JJ 40436 10006 8 which which WDT 40436 10006 9 most most JJS 40436 10006 10 men man NNS 40436 10006 11 , , , 40436 10006 12 groping grope VBG 40436 10006 13 as as IN 40436 10006 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10006 15 were be VBD 40436 10006 16 in in IN 40436 10006 17 the the DT 40436 10006 18 dark dark JJ 40436 10006 19 , , , 40436 10006 20 call call VB 40436 10006 21 by by IN 40436 10006 22 a a DT 40436 10006 23 wrong wrong JJ 40436 10006 24 name name NN 40436 10006 25 , , , 40436 10006 26 as as IN 40436 10006 27 if if IN 40436 10006 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10006 29 were be VBD 40436 10006 30 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10006 31 the the DT 40436 10006 32 cause cause NN 40436 10006 33 . . . 40436 10007 1 Thus thus RB 40436 10007 2 one one CD 40436 10007 3 man man NN 40436 10007 4 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 10007 5 that that IN 40436 10007 6 the the DT 40436 10007 7 earth earth NN 40436 10007 8 is be VBZ 40436 10007 9 kept keep VBN 40436 10007 10 stationary stationary JJ 40436 10007 11 in in IN 40436 10007 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10007 13 place place NN 40436 10007 14 by by IN 40436 10007 15 the the DT 40436 10007 16 rotation rotation NN 40436 10007 17 of of IN 40436 10007 18 the the DT 40436 10007 19 heaven heaven NNP 40436 10007 20 around around IN 40436 10007 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10007 22 : : : 40436 10007 23 another another DT 40436 10007 24 contends contend VBZ 40436 10007 25 that that IN 40436 10007 26 the the DT 40436 10007 27 air air NN 40436 10007 28 underneath underneath RB 40436 10007 29 supports support VBZ 40436 10007 30 the the DT 40436 10007 31 earth earth NN 40436 10007 32 , , , 40436 10007 33 like like IN 40436 10007 34 a a DT 40436 10007 35 pedestal pedestal JJ 40436 10007 36 sustaining sustain VBG 40436 10007 37 a a DT 40436 10007 38 broad broad JJ 40436 10007 39 kneading kneading NN 40436 10007 40 - - HYPH 40436 10007 41 trough trough NN 40436 10007 42 : : : 40436 10007 43 but but CC 40436 10007 44 none none NN 40436 10007 45 of of IN 40436 10007 46 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10007 47 ever ever RB 40436 10007 48 look look VBP 40436 10007 49 out out RP 40436 10007 50 for for IN 40436 10007 51 a a DT 40436 10007 52 force force NN 40436 10007 53 such such JJ 40436 10007 54 as as IN 40436 10007 55 this this DT 40436 10007 56 -- -- : 40436 10007 57 That that IN 40436 10007 58 all all PDT 40436 10007 59 these these DT 40436 10007 60 things thing NNS 40436 10007 61 now now RB 40436 10007 62 occupy occupy VBP 40436 10007 63 that that DT 40436 10007 64 position position NN 40436 10007 65 which which WDT 40436 10007 66 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10007 67 is be VBZ 40436 10007 68 best good JJS 40436 10007 69 that that IN 40436 10007 70 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10007 71 should should MD 40436 10007 72 occupy occupy VB 40436 10007 73 . . . 40436 10008 1 These these DT 40436 10008 2 enquirers enquirer NNS 40436 10008 3 set set VBP 40436 10008 4 no no DT 40436 10008 5 great great JJ 40436 10008 6 value value NN 40436 10008 7 upon upon IN 40436 10008 8 this this DT 40436 10008 9 last last RB 40436 10008 10 - - HYPH 40436 10008 11 mentioned mention VBN 40436 10008 12 force force NN 40436 10008 13 , , , 40436 10008 14 believing believe VBG 40436 10008 15 that that IN 40436 10008 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10008 17 can can MD 40436 10008 18 find find VB 40436 10008 19 some some DT 40436 10008 20 other other JJ 40436 10008 21 Atlas Atlas NNP 40436 10008 22 stronger strong JJR 40436 10008 23 , , , 40436 10008 24 more more RBR 40436 10008 25 everlasting everlasting JJ 40436 10008 26 , , , 40436 10008 27 and and CC 40436 10008 28 more more RBR 40436 10008 29 capable capable JJ 40436 10008 30 of of IN 40436 10008 31 holding hold VBG 40436 10008 32 all all DT 40436 10008 33 things thing NNS 40436 10008 34 together together RB 40436 10008 35 : : : 40436 10008 36 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10008 37 think think VBP 40436 10008 38 that that IN 40436 10008 39 the the DT 40436 10008 40 Good good JJ 40436 10008 41 and and CC 40436 10008 42 the the DT 40436 10008 43 Becoming become VBG 40436 10008 44 have have VBP 40436 10008 45 no no DT 40436 10008 46 power power NN 40436 10008 47 of of IN 40436 10008 48 binding bind VBG 40436 10008 49 or or CC 40436 10008 50 holding hold VBG 40436 10008 51 together together RB 40436 10008 52 any any DT 40436 10008 53 thing thing NN 40436 10008 54 . . . 40436 10009 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10009 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10009 3 49 49 CD 40436 10009 4 : : : 40436 10009 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10009 6 , , , 40436 10009 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10009 8 , , , 40436 10009 9 p. p. NN 40436 10009 10 98 98 CD 40436 10009 11 C. C. NNP 40436 10009 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10009 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10009 14 : : : 40436 10009 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10009 16 moi\ moi\ NNP 40436 10009 17 e)/doxen e)/doxen NNP 40436 10009 18 o(moio o(moio NNP 40436 10009 19 / / SYM 40436 10009 20 taton taton NNP 40436 10009 21 peponthe peponthe NNP 40436 10009 22 / / SYM 40436 10009 23 nai nai NNP 40436 10009 24 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 10009 25 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10009 26 ei)/ ei)/ NNP 40436 10009 27 tis tis NNP 40436 10009 28 le le NNP 40436 10009 29 / / SYM 40436 10009 30 gôn gôn NNP 40436 10009 31 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10009 32 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 10009 33 / / SYM 40436 10009 34 tês tês NNP 40436 10009 35 pa pa NNP 40436 10009 36 / / SYM 40436 10009 37 nta nta NNP 40436 10009 38 o(/sa o(/sa NNP 40436 10009 39 pra pra NNP 40436 10009 40 / / SYM 40436 10009 41 ttei ttei NNP 40436 10009 42 nô=| nô=| NNP 40436 10009 43 pra pra NNP 40436 10009 44 / / SYM 40436 10009 45 ttei ttei NNP 40436 10009 46 , , , 40436 10009 47 ka)/peita ka)/peita NNP 40436 10009 48 e)picheirê e)picheirê NNP 40436 10009 49 / / SYM 40436 10009 50 sas sas NNP 40436 10009 51 le le NNP 40436 10009 52 / / SYM 40436 10009 53 gein gein JJ 40436 10009 54 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 10009 55 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10009 56 / / SYM 40436 10009 57 as as IN 40436 10009 58 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 10009 59 / / SYM 40436 10009 60 stôn stôn VBZ 40436 10009 61 ô(=n ô(=n NNP 40436 10009 62 pra pra NNP 40436 10009 63 / / SYM 40436 10009 64 ttô ttô NNP 40436 10009 65 , , , 40436 10009 66 le le NNP 40436 10009 67 / / SYM 40436 10009 68 goi goi NNP 40436 10009 69 prô prô NNP 40436 10009 70 = = SYM 40436 10009 71 ton ton NN 40436 10009 72 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10009 73 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10009 74 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 10009 75 tau tau NNP 40436 10009 76 = = SYM 40436 10009 77 ta ta NNP 40436 10009 78 nu nu NNP 40436 10009 79 = = SYM 40436 10009 80 n n NNP 40436 10009 81 e)ntha e)ntha NNP 40436 10009 82 / / SYM 40436 10009 83 de de NNP 40436 10009 84 ka ka NNP 40436 10009 85 / / SYM 40436 10009 86 thêmai thêmai NNP 40436 10009 87 , , , 40436 10009 88 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10009 89 xugkeitai/ xugkeitai/ NNP 40436 10009 90 mou mou NNP 40436 10009 91 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10009 92 sô sô NNP 40436 10009 93 = = SYM 40436 10009 94 ma ma NNP 40436 10009 95 e)x e)x NNP 40436 10009 96 o)stô o)stô NNP 40436 10009 97 = = SYM 40436 10009 98 n n NNP 40436 10009 99 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10009 100 neu neu NNP 40436 10009 101 / / SYM 40436 10009 102 rôn rôn NNP 40436 10009 103 , , , 40436 10009 104 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10009 105 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 10009 106 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10009 107 o)sta= o)sta= PRP$ 40436 10009 108 e)sti e)sti -RRB- 40436 10009 109 sterea\ sterea\ NNP 40436 10009 110 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10009 111 diaphua\s diaphua\s NNP 40436 10009 112 e)/chei e)/chei NNP 40436 10009 113 chôri\s chôri\s XX 40436 10009 114 a)p a)p NNP 40436 10009 115 ' ' POS 40436 10009 116 a)llê a)llê NNP 40436 10009 117 / / SYM 40436 10009 118 lôn lôn NN 40436 10009 119 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10009 120 , , , 40436 10009 121 & & CC 40436 10009 122 c. c. NNP 40436 10009 123 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10009 124 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10009 125 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10009 126 50 50 CD 40436 10009 127 : : : 40436 10009 128 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10009 129 , , , 40436 10009 130 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10009 131 , , , 40436 10009 132 p. p. NN 40436 10009 133 98 98 CD 40436 10009 134 E. E. NNP 40436 10009 135 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10009 136 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10009 137 : : : 40436 10009 138 a)melê a)melê NNS 40436 10009 139 / / SYM 40436 10009 140 sas sas NNP 40436 10009 141 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 10009 142 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10009 143 a)lêthô a)lêthô CD 40436 10009 144 = = NFP 40436 10009 145 s s NNP 40436 10009 146 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10009 147 / / SYM 40436 10009 148 as as IN 40436 10009 149 le le NNP 40436 10009 150 / / SYM 40436 10009 151 gein gein NNP 40436 10009 152 , , , 40436 10009 153 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10009 154 e)pei e)pei NNP 40436 10009 155 / / SYM 40436 10009 156 dê dê NNP 40436 10009 157 A)thênai A)thênai NNP 40436 10009 158 / / SYM 40436 10009 159 ois ois NNP 40436 10009 160 e)/doxe e)/doxe NNP 40436 10009 161 be be VB 40436 10009 162 / / SYM 40436 10009 163 ltion ltion NN 40436 10009 164 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 10009 165 e)mou= e)mou= NNP 40436 10009 166 katapsêphi katapsêphi NNS 40436 10009 167 / / SYM 40436 10009 168 sasthai sasthai NNP 40436 10009 169 , , , 40436 10009 170 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 10009 171 tau tau NNP 40436 10009 172 = = SYM 40436 10009 173 ta ta NNP 40436 10009 174 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 10009 175 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10009 176 e)moi\ e)moi\ NNP 40436 10009 177 be be VB 40436 10009 178 / / SYM 40436 10009 179 ltion ltion NN 40436 10009 180 au)= au)= JJ 40436 10009 181 de de NNP 40436 10009 182 / / SYM 40436 10009 183 doktai doktai NNP 40436 10009 184 e)ntha e)ntha NNP 40436 10009 185 / / SYM 40436 10009 186 de de NNP 40436 10009 187 kathê kathê NNP 40436 10009 188 = = SYM 40436 10009 189 sthai sthai NNP 40436 10009 190 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10009 191 , , , 40436 10009 192 & & CC 40436 10009 193 c. c. NNP 40436 10009 194 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10009 195 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10009 196 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10009 197 51 51 CD 40436 10009 198 : : : 40436 10009 199 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10009 200 , , , 40436 10009 201 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10009 202 , , , 40436 10009 203 p. p. NN 40436 10009 204 99 99 CD 40436 10009 205 A. a. NN 40436 10010 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10010 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10010 3 : : : 40436 10010 4 a)ll a)ll NN 40436 10010 5 ' ' '' 40436 10010 6 ai)/tia ai)/tia NNP 40436 10010 7 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10010 8 ta\ ta\ VB 40436 10010 9 toiau toiau NNP 40436 10010 10 = = SYM 40436 10010 11 ta ta NNP 40436 10010 12 kalei kalei NNP 40436 10010 13 = = SYM 40436 10010 14 n n NNP 40436 10010 15 li li NNP 40436 10010 16 / / SYM 40436 10010 17 an an DT 40436 10010 18 a)/topon a)/topon NN 40436 10010 19 ; ; : 40436 10010 20 ei ei NNP 40436 10010 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10010 22 de/ de/ NNP 40436 10010 23 tis tis NNP 40436 10010 24 le le NNP 40436 10010 25 / / SYM 40436 10010 26 goi goi NNP 40436 10010 27 , , , 40436 10010 28 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 10010 29 a)/neu a)/neu IN 40436 10010 30 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10010 31 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 10010 32 toiau toiau NNP 40436 10010 33 = = SYM 40436 10010 34 ta ta NNP 40436 10010 35 e)/chein e)/chein NNP 40436 10010 36 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10010 37 o(sta= o(sta= NNP 40436 10010 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10010 39 neu neu NNP 40436 10010 40 = = SYM 40436 10010 41 ra ra NNP 40436 10010 42 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10010 43 o(/sa o(/sa NNP 40436 10010 44 a)/lla a)/lla NNP 40436 10010 45 e)/chô e)/chô NNP 40436 10010 46 , , , 40436 10010 47 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10010 48 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10010 49 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 10010 50 / / SYM 40436 10010 51 s s NNP 40436 10010 52 t t NNP 40436 10010 53 ' ' '' 40436 10010 54 ê)=n ê)=n NNP 40436 10010 55 poiei poiei NNP 40436 10010 56 = = SYM 40436 10010 57 n n CC 40436 10010 58 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 10010 59 do do VB 40436 10010 60 / / SYM 40436 10010 61 xanta/ xanta/ NNP 40436 10010 62 moi moi NNP 40436 10010 63 , , , 40436 10010 64 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 10010 65 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 10010 66 le le NNP 40436 10010 67 / / SYM 40436 10010 68 goi goi NNP 40436 10010 69 ; ; : 40436 10010 70 ô(s ô(s VB 40436 10010 71 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10010 72 / / SYM 40436 10010 73 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 10010 74 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 10010 75 tau tau NNP 40436 10010 76 = = SYM 40436 10010 77 ta ta NNP 40436 10010 78 poiô= poiô= NNP 40436 10010 79 , , , 40436 10010 80 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10010 81 tau tau NNP 40436 10010 82 / / SYM 40436 10010 83 tê| tê| NNP 40436 10010 84 nô=| nô=| NNP 40436 10010 85 pra pra NNP 40436 10010 86 / / SYM 40436 10010 87 ttô ttô NNP 40436 10010 88 , , , 40436 10010 89 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 10010 90 ' ' '' 40436 10010 91 ou ou NN 40436 10010 92 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10010 93 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 10010 94 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10010 95 belti belti NN 40436 10010 96 / / SYM 40436 10010 97 stou stou NNP 40436 10010 98 ai(re ai(re NNP 40436 10010 99 / / SYM 40436 10010 100 sei sei NNP 40436 10010 101 , , , 40436 10010 102 pollê\ pollê\ NNP 40436 10010 103 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10010 104 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10010 105 makra\ makra\ NNP 40436 10010 106 r(athumi r(athumi NNP 40436 10010 107 / / SYM 40436 10010 108 a a DT 40436 10010 109 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 10010 110 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10010 111 lo lo NN 40436 10010 112 / / SYM 40436 10010 113 gou gou NN 40436 10010 114 . . . 40436 10011 1 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10011 2 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10011 3 mê\ mê\ NN 40436 10011 4 diele diele NN 40436 10011 5 / / SYM 40436 10011 6 sthai sthai NNP 40436 10011 7 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 10011 8 / / SYM 40436 10011 9 n n NNP 40436 10011 10 t t NNP 40436 10011 11 ' ' NNP 40436 10011 12 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 10011 13 , , , 40436 10011 14 o(/ti o(/ti NN 40436 10011 15 a)/llo a)/llo IN 40436 10011 16 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10011 17 / / SYM 40436 10011 18 n n CC 40436 10011 19 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 10011 20 e)sti e)sti NNP 40436 10011 21 to\ to\ NN 40436 10011 22 ai)/tion ai)/tion NN 40436 10011 23 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 10011 24 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 10011 25 , , , 40436 10011 26 a)/llo a)/llo NN 40436 10011 27 d d LS 40436 10011 28 ' ' '' 40436 10011 29 e)kei e)kei NN 40436 10011 30 = = NFP 40436 10011 31 no no UH 40436 10011 32 a)/neu a)/neu RB 40436 10011 33 ou)= ou)= DT 40436 10011 34 to\ to\ NN 40436 10011 35 ai)/tion ai)/tion NN 40436 10011 36 ou)k ou)k -RRB- 40436 10011 37 a)/n a)/n UH 40436 10011 38 pot pot NN 40436 10011 39 ' ' '' 40436 10011 40 ei)/ê ei)/ê NNP 40436 10011 41 ai)/tion ai)/tion NN 40436 10011 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10011 43 , , , 40436 10011 44 & & CC 40436 10011 45 c. c. NNP 40436 10011 46 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10011 47 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10011 48 Side side NN 40436 10011 49 - - HYPH 40436 10011 50 note note NN 40436 10011 51 : : : 40436 10011 52 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10011 53 could could MD 40436 10011 54 neither neither CC 40436 10011 55 trace trace VB 40436 10011 56 out out IN 40436 10011 57 the the DT 40436 10011 58 optimistic optimistic JJ 40436 10011 59 principle principle NN 40436 10011 60 for for IN 40436 10011 61 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10011 62 , , , 40436 10011 63 nor nor CC 40436 10011 64 find find VB 40436 10011 65 any any DT 40436 10011 66 teacher teacher NN 40436 10011 67 thereof thereof RB 40436 10011 68 . . . 40436 10012 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10012 2 renounced renounce VBD 40436 10012 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10012 4 , , , 40436 10012 5 and and CC 40436 10012 6 embraced embrace VBD 40436 10012 7 a a DT 40436 10012 8 third third JJ 40436 10012 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10012 10 about about IN 40436 10012 11 cause cause NN 40436 10012 12 . . . 40436 10012 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10013 1 " " `` 40436 10013 2 Now now RB 40436 10013 3 , , , 40436 10013 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10013 5 is be VBZ 40436 10013 6 this this DT 40436 10013 7 sort sort NN 40436 10013 8 of of RB 40436 10013 9 cause cause NN 40436 10013 10 which which WDT 40436 10013 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10013 12 would would MD 40436 10013 13 gladly gladly RB 40436 10013 14 put put VB 40436 10013 15 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 10013 16 under under IN 40436 10013 17 any any DT 40436 10013 18 one one NN 40436 10013 19 's 's POS 40436 10013 20 teaching teaching NN 40436 10013 21 to to TO 40436 10013 22 learn learn VB 40436 10013 23 . . . 40436 10014 1 But but CC 40436 10014 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10014 3 could could MD 40436 10014 4 neither neither CC 40436 10014 5 find find VB 40436 10014 6 any any DT 40436 10014 7 teacher teacher NN 40436 10014 8 , , , 40436 10014 9 nor nor CC 40436 10014 10 make make VB 40436 10014 11 any any DT 40436 10014 12 way way NN 40436 10014 13 by by IN 40436 10014 14 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 10014 15 . . . 40436 10015 1 Having have VBG 40436 10015 2 failed fail VBN 40436 10015 3 in in IN 40436 10015 4 this this DT 40436 10015 5 quarter quarter NN 40436 10015 6 , , , 40436 10015 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10015 8 took take VBD 40436 10015 9 the the DT 40436 10015 10 second second JJ 40436 10015 11 best good JJS 40436 10015 12 course course NN 40436 10015 13 , , , 40436 10015 14 and and CC 40436 10015 15 struck strike VBD 40436 10015 16 into into IN 40436 10015 17 a a DT 40436 10015 18 new new JJ 40436 10015 19 path path NN 40436 10015 20 in in IN 40436 10015 21 search search NN 40436 10015 22 of of IN 40436 10015 23 causes cause NNS 40436 10015 24 . . . 40436 10016 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10016 2 52 52 CD 40436 10016 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10016 4 Fatigued fatigue VBN 40436 10016 5 with with IN 40436 10016 6 studying study VBG 40436 10016 7 objects object NNS 40436 10016 8 through through IN 40436 10016 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10016 10 eyes eye NNS 40436 10016 11 and and CC 40436 10016 12 perceptions perception NNS 40436 10016 13 of of IN 40436 10016 14 sense sense NN 40436 10016 15 , , , 40436 10016 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10016 17 looked look VBD 40436 10016 18 out out RP 40436 10016 19 for for IN 40436 10016 20 images image NNS 40436 10016 21 or or CC 40436 10016 22 reflections reflection NNS 40436 10016 23 of of IN 40436 10016 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10016 25 , , , 40436 10016 26 and and CC 40436 10016 27 turned turn VBD 40436 10016 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10016 29 attention attention NN 40436 10016 30 to to IN 40436 10016 31 words word NNS 40436 10016 32 or or CC 40436 10016 33 discourses discourse NNS 40436 10016 34 . . . 40436 10017 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10017 2 53 53 CD 40436 10017 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10017 4 This this DT 40436 10017 5 comparison comparison NN 40436 10017 6 is be VBZ 40436 10017 7 indeed indeed RB 40436 10017 8 not not RB 40436 10017 9 altogether altogether RB 40436 10017 10 suitable suitable JJ 40436 10017 11 : : : 40436 10017 12 for for IN 40436 10017 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10017 14 do do VBP 40436 10017 15 not not RB 40436 10017 16 admit admit VB 40436 10017 17 that that IN 40436 10017 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10017 19 who who WP 40436 10017 20 investigates investigate VBZ 40436 10017 21 things thing NNS 40436 10017 22 through through IN 40436 10017 23 general general JJ 40436 10017 24 words word NNS 40436 10017 25 , , , 40436 10017 26 has have VBZ 40436 10017 27 recourse recourse VBN 40436 10017 28 to to IN 40436 10017 29 images image NNS 40436 10017 30 , , , 40436 10017 31 more more JJR 40436 10017 32 than than IN 40436 10017 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10017 34 who who WP 40436 10017 35 investigates investigate VBZ 40436 10017 36 sensible sensible JJ 40436 10017 37 facts fact NNS 40436 10017 38 : : : 40436 10017 39 but but CC 40436 10017 40 such such JJ 40436 10017 41 , , , 40436 10017 42 at at IN 40436 10017 43 all all DT 40436 10017 44 events event NNS 40436 10017 45 , , , 40436 10017 46 was be VBD 40436 10017 47 the the DT 40436 10017 48 turn turn NN 40436 10017 49 which which WDT 40436 10017 50 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10017 51 mind mind NN 40436 10017 52 took take VBD 40436 10017 53 . . . 40436 10018 1 Laying lay VBG 40436 10018 2 down down RP 40436 10018 3 such such JJ 40436 10018 4 general general JJ 40436 10018 5 assumption assumption NN 40436 10018 6 or or CC 40436 10018 7 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10018 8 as as IN 40436 10018 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10018 10 considered consider VBD 40436 10018 11 to to TO 40436 10018 12 be be VB 40436 10018 13 the the DT 40436 10018 14 strongest strong JJS 40436 10018 15 , , , 40436 10018 16 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10018 17 accepted accept VBD 40436 10018 18 as as IN 40436 10018 19 truth truth NN 40436 10018 20 whatever whatever WDT 40436 10018 21 squared square VBD 40436 10018 22 with with IN 40436 10018 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10018 24 , , , 40436 10018 25 respecting respect VBG 40436 10018 26 cause cause VB 40436 10018 27 as as RB 40436 10018 28 well well RB 40436 10018 29 as as IN 40436 10018 30 all all DT 40436 10018 31 other other JJ 40436 10018 32 matters matter NNS 40436 10018 33 . . . 40436 10019 1 In in IN 40436 10019 2 this this DT 40436 10019 3 way way NN 40436 10019 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10019 5 came come VBD 40436 10019 6 upon upon IN 40436 10019 7 the the DT 40436 10019 8 investigation investigation NN 40436 10019 9 of of IN 40436 10019 10 another another DT 40436 10019 11 sort sort NN 40436 10019 12 of of IN 40436 10019 13 cause cause NN 40436 10019 14 . . . 40436 10020 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10020 2 54 54 CD 40436 10020 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10020 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10020 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10020 6 52 52 CD 40436 10020 7 : : : 40436 10020 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10020 9 , , , 40436 10020 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10020 11 , , , 40436 10020 12 p. p. NN 40436 10020 13 99 99 CD 40436 10020 14 C C NNP 40436 10020 15 - - HYPH 40436 10020 16 D. D. NNP 40436 10020 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10020 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10020 19 : : : 40436 10020 20 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ NNP 40436 10020 21 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10020 22 tau tau NN 40436 10020 23 / / SYM 40436 10020 24 tês tês NNP 40436 10020 25 e)sterê e)sterê NNP 40436 10020 26 / / SYM 40436 10020 27 thên thên NNP 40436 10020 28 , , , 40436 10020 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10020 30 ou)/t ou)/t NNP 40436 10020 31 ' ' POS 40436 10020 32 au)to\s au)to\s NN 40436 10020 33 eu(rei eu(rei NNP 40436 10020 34 = = SYM 40436 10020 35 n n CC 40436 10020 36 ou)/te ou)/te NNP 40436 10020 37 par par NNP 40436 10020 38 ' ' '' 40436 10020 39 a)/llou a)/llou NNP 40436 10020 40 mathei mathei NNP 40436 10020 41 = = SYM 40436 10020 42 n n CC 40436 10020 43 oi(=o oi(=o NNP 40436 10020 44 / / SYM 40436 10020 45 s s NNP 40436 10020 46 te te NNP 40436 10020 47 e)geno e)geno NNP 40436 10020 48 / / SYM 40436 10020 49 mên mên NN 40436 10020 50 , , , 40436 10020 51 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10020 52 deu deu NNP 40436 10020 53 / / SYM 40436 10020 54 teron teron NNP 40436 10020 55 plou plou NN 40436 10020 56 = = SYM 40436 10020 57 n n NN 40436 10020 58 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 10020 59 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10020 60 tê tê XX 40436 10020 61 = = SYM 40436 10020 62 s s NNP 40436 10020 63 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10020 64 / / SYM 40436 10020 65 as as IN 40436 10020 66 zê zê NNP 40436 10020 67 / / SYM 40436 10020 68 têsin têsin NNP 40436 10020 69 ê(=| ê(=| NNP 40436 10020 70 pepragma pepragma NNP 40436 10020 71 / / SYM 40436 10020 72 teumai teumai NNP 40436 10020 73 , , , 40436 10020 74 bou bou NN 40436 10020 75 / / SYM 40436 10020 76 lei lei NN 40436 10020 77 soi\ soi\ NNP 40436 10020 78 e)pi e)pi NNP 40436 10020 79 / / SYM 40436 10020 80 deixin deixin NNP 40436 10020 81 poiê poiê NNP 40436 10020 82 / / SYM 40436 10020 83 sômai sômai NNP 40436 10020 84 ? ? . 40436 10020 85 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10020 86 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10021 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10021 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10021 3 53 53 CD 40436 10021 4 : : : 40436 10021 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10021 6 , , , 40436 10021 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10021 8 , , , 40436 10021 9 p. p. NN 40436 10021 10 99 99 CD 40436 10021 11 E. E. NNP 40436 10021 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10021 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10021 14 : : : 40436 10021 15 i)/sôs i)/sôs NNP 40436 10021 16 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10021 17 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 10021 18 ô(=| ô(=| NNP 40436 10021 19 ei)ka ei)ka NNP 40436 10021 20 / / SYM 40436 10021 21 zô zô NNP 40436 10021 22 , , , 40436 10021 23 tro tro NN 40436 10021 24 / / SYM 40436 10021 25 pon pon NNP 40436 10021 26 tina\ tina\ , 40436 10021 27 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10021 28 e)/oiken e)/oiken NNP 40436 10021 29 ; ; : 40436 10021 30 ou ou NNP 40436 10021 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10021 32 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10021 33 pa pa NNP 40436 10021 34 / / SYM 40436 10021 35 nu nu NNP 40436 10021 36 xugchôrô= xugchôrô= NN 40436 10021 37 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10021 38 e)n e)n NNP 40436 10021 39 toi toi NNP 40436 10021 40 = = SYM 40436 10021 41 s s NNP 40436 10021 42 lo lo NNP 40436 10021 43 / / SYM 40436 10021 44 gois gois NNP 40436 10021 45 skopou skopou NNP 40436 10021 46 / / SYM 40436 10021 47 menon menon NNP 40436 10021 48 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 10021 49 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 10021 50 e)n e)n NNP 40436 10021 51 ei)ko ei)ko NNP 40436 10021 52 / / SYM 40436 10021 53 si si NNP 40436 10021 54 ma ma NNP 40436 10021 55 = = SYM 40436 10021 56 llon llon NNP 40436 10021 57 skopei skopei NNP 40436 10021 58 = = SYM 40436 10021 59 n n CC 40436 10021 60 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 10021 61 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10021 62 e)n e)n NNP 40436 10021 63 toi toi NNP 40436 10021 64 = = SYM 40436 10021 65 s s NNP 40436 10021 66 e)/rgois e)/rgois NNP 40436 10021 67 . . . 40436 10021 68 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10021 69 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10022 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10022 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10022 3 54 54 CD 40436 10022 4 : : : 40436 10022 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10022 6 , , , 40436 10022 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10022 8 , , , 40436 10022 9 p. p. NN 40436 10022 10 100 100 CD 40436 10022 11 B. b. NN 40436 10023 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10023 2 Greek greek NN 40436 10023 3 : : : 40436 10023 4 e)/rchomai e)/rchomai NNP 40436 10023 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10023 6 dê\ dê\ JJ 40436 10023 7 e)picheirô e)picheirô NN 40436 10023 8 = = SYM 40436 10023 9 n n CC 40436 10023 10 soi\ soi\ NNP 40436 10023 11 e)pidei e)pidei NNP 40436 10023 12 / / SYM 40436 10023 13 xasthai xasthai NNP 40436 10023 14 tê tê NNP 40436 10023 15 = = SYM 40436 10023 16 s s NNP 40436 10023 17 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10023 18 / / SYM 40436 10023 19 as as IN 40436 10023 20 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10023 21 ei)=dos ei)=dos CD 40436 10023 22 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 10023 23 pepragma pepragma NNP 40436 10023 24 / / SYM 40436 10023 25 teumai teumai NNP 40436 10023 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10023 27 , , , 40436 10023 28 & & CC 40436 10023 29 c. c. NNP 40436 10023 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10023 31 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10023 32 Side side NN 40436 10023 33 - - HYPH 40436 10023 34 note note NN 40436 10023 35 : : : 40436 10023 36 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10023 37 now now RB 40436 10023 38 assumes assume VBZ 40436 10023 39 the the DT 40436 10023 40 separate separate JJ 40436 10023 41 existence existence NN 40436 10023 42 of of IN 40436 10023 43 ideas idea NNS 40436 10023 44 . . . 40436 10024 1 These these DT 40436 10024 2 ideas idea NNS 40436 10024 3 are be VBP 40436 10024 4 the the DT 40436 10024 5 causes cause NNS 40436 10024 6 why why WRB 40436 10024 7 particular particular JJ 40436 10024 8 objects object NNS 40436 10024 9 manifest manifest VBP 40436 10024 10 certain certain JJ 40436 10024 11 attributes attribute NNS 40436 10024 12 . . . 40436 10024 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10025 1 " " `` 40436 10025 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10025 3 now now RB 40436 10025 4 assumed assume VBD 40436 10025 5 the the DT 40436 10025 6 separate separate JJ 40436 10025 7 and and CC 40436 10025 8 real real JJ 40436 10025 9 existence existence NN 40436 10025 10 of of IN 40436 10025 11 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10025 12 by by IN 40436 10025 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10025 14 -- -- : 40436 10025 15 The the DT 40436 10025 16 Good good JJ 40436 10025 17 in in IN 40436 10025 18 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10025 19 or or CC 40436 10025 20 the the DT 40436 10025 21 Self self NN 40436 10025 22 - - HYPH 40436 10025 23 Good good JJ 40436 10025 24 , , , 40436 10025 25 Self self NN 40436 10025 26 - - HYPH 40436 10025 27 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10025 28 , , , 40436 10025 29 Great great JJ 40436 10025 30 , , , 40436 10025 31 and and CC 40436 10025 32 all all DT 40436 10025 33 such such JJ 40436 10025 34 others other NNS 40436 10025 35 . . . 40436 10026 1 Look look VB 40436 10026 2 what what WP 40436 10026 3 follows follow VBZ 40436 10026 4 next next JJ 40436 10026 5 upon upon IN 40436 10026 6 this this DT 40436 10026 7 assumption assumption NN 40436 10026 8 . . . 40436 10027 1 If if IN 40436 10027 2 any any DT 40436 10027 3 thing thing NN 40436 10027 4 else else RB 40436 10027 5 be be VB 40436 10027 6 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10027 7 , , , 40436 10027 8 besides besides IN 40436 10027 9 the the DT 40436 10027 10 Self Self NNP 40436 10027 11 - - HYPH 40436 10027 12 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10027 13 , , , 40436 10027 14 that that DT 40436 10027 15 other other JJ 40436 10027 16 thing thing NN 40436 10027 17 can can MD 40436 10027 18 only only RB 40436 10027 19 be be VB 40436 10027 20 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10027 21 because because IN 40436 10027 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10027 23 partakes partake VBZ 40436 10027 24 of of IN 40436 10027 25 the the DT 40436 10027 26 Self self NN 40436 10027 27 - - HYPH 40436 10027 28 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10027 29 : : : 40436 10027 30 and and CC 40436 10027 31 the the DT 40436 10027 32 same same JJ 40436 10027 33 with with IN 40436 10027 34 regard regard NN 40436 10027 35 to to IN 40436 10027 36 other other JJ 40436 10027 37 similar similar JJ 40436 10027 38 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10027 39 . . . 40436 10028 1 This this DT 40436 10028 2 is be VBZ 40436 10028 3 the the DT 40436 10028 4 only only JJ 40436 10028 5 cause cause NN 40436 10028 6 that that IN 40436 10028 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10028 8 can can MD 40436 10028 9 accept accept VB 40436 10028 10 : : : 40436 10028 11 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10028 12 do do VBP 40436 10028 13 not not RB 40436 10028 14 understand understand VB 40436 10028 15 those those DT 40436 10028 16 other other JJ 40436 10028 17 ingenious ingenious JJ 40436 10028 18 causes cause NNS 40436 10028 19 which which WDT 40436 10028 20 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10028 21 hear hear VBP 40436 10028 22 mentioned mention VBN 40436 10028 23 . . . 40436 10029 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10029 2 55 55 CD 40436 10029 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10029 4 When when WRB 40436 10029 5 any any DT 40436 10029 6 one one NN 40436 10029 7 tells tell VBZ 40436 10029 8 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10029 9 that that IN 40436 10029 10 a a DT 40436 10029 11 thing thing NN 40436 10029 12 is be VBZ 40436 10029 13 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10029 14 because because IN 40436 10029 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10029 16 has have VBZ 40436 10029 17 a a DT 40436 10029 18 showy showy JJ 40436 10029 19 colour colour NN 40436 10029 20 or or CC 40436 10029 21 figure figure NN 40436 10029 22 , , , 40436 10029 23 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10029 24 pay pay VBP 40436 10029 25 no no DT 40436 10029 26 attention attention NN 40436 10029 27 to to IN 40436 10029 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10029 29 , , , 40436 10029 30 but but CC 40436 10029 31 adhere adhere VB 40436 10029 32 simply simply RB 40436 10029 33 to to IN 40436 10029 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10029 35 own own JJ 40436 10029 36 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 10029 37 , , , 40436 10029 38 that that IN 40436 10029 39 nothing nothing NN 40436 10029 40 else else RB 40436 10029 41 causes cause VBZ 40436 10029 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10029 43 to to TO 40436 10029 44 be be VB 40436 10029 45 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10029 46 , , , 40436 10029 47 except except IN 40436 10029 48 the the DT 40436 10029 49 presence presence NN 40436 10029 50 or or CC 40436 10029 51 participation participation NN 40436 10029 52 of of IN 40436 10029 53 the the DT 40436 10029 54 Self Self NNP 40436 10029 55 - - HYPH 40436 10029 56 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10029 57 . . . 40436 10030 1 In in IN 40436 10030 2 what what WDT 40436 10030 3 way way NN 40436 10030 4 such such JJ 40436 10030 5 participation participation NN 40436 10030 6 may may MD 40436 10030 7 take take VB 40436 10030 8 place place NN 40436 10030 9 , , , 40436 10030 10 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10030 11 can can MD 40436 10030 12 not not RB 40436 10030 13 positively positively RB 40436 10030 14 determine determine VB 40436 10030 15 . . . 40436 10031 1 But but CC 40436 10031 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10031 3 feel feel VBP 40436 10031 4 confident confident JJ 40436 10031 5 in in IN 40436 10031 6 affirming affirm VBG 40436 10031 7 that that IN 40436 10031 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10031 9 does do VBZ 40436 10031 10 take take VB 40436 10031 11 place place NN 40436 10031 12 : : : 40436 10031 13 that that IN 40436 10031 14 things thing NNS 40436 10031 15 which which WDT 40436 10031 16 are be VBP 40436 10031 17 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10031 18 , , , 40436 10031 19 become become VBN 40436 10031 20 so so RB 40436 10031 21 by by IN 40436 10031 22 partaking partake VBG 40436 10031 23 in in IN 40436 10031 24 the the DT 40436 10031 25 Self self NN 40436 10031 26 - - HYPH 40436 10031 27 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10031 28 ; ; : 40436 10031 29 things thing NNS 40436 10031 30 which which WDT 40436 10031 31 are be VBP 40436 10031 32 great great JJ 40436 10031 33 or or CC 40436 10031 34 little little JJ 40436 10031 35 , , , 40436 10031 36 by by IN 40436 10031 37 partaking partake VBG 40436 10031 38 in in IN 40436 10031 39 Greatness Greatness NNP 40436 10031 40 or or CC 40436 10031 41 Littleness Littleness NNP 40436 10031 42 . . . 40436 10032 1 If if IN 40436 10032 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10032 3 am be VBP 40436 10032 4 told tell VBN 40436 10032 5 that that IN 40436 10032 6 one one CD 40436 10032 7 man man NN 40436 10032 8 is be VBZ 40436 10032 9 taller tall JJR 40436 10032 10 than than IN 40436 10032 11 another another DT 40436 10032 12 by by IN 40436 10032 13 the the DT 40436 10032 14 head head NN 40436 10032 15 , , , 40436 10032 16 and and CC 40436 10032 17 that that IN 40436 10032 18 this this DT 40436 10032 19 other other JJ 40436 10032 20 is be VBZ 40436 10032 21 shorter short JJR 40436 10032 22 than than IN 40436 10032 23 the the DT 40436 10032 24 first first JJ 40436 10032 25 by by IN 40436 10032 26 the the DT 40436 10032 27 very very RB 40436 10032 28 same same JJ 40436 10032 29 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10032 30 by by IN 40436 10032 31 the the DT 40436 10032 32 head head NN 40436 10032 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10032 34 , , , 40436 10032 35 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10032 36 should should MD 40436 10032 37 not not RB 40436 10032 38 admit admit VB 40436 10032 39 the the DT 40436 10032 40 proposition proposition NN 40436 10032 41 , , , 40436 10032 42 but but CC 40436 10032 43 should should MD 40436 10032 44 repeat repeat VB 40436 10032 45 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 10032 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10032 47 own own JJ 40436 10032 48 creed,--That creed,--That . 40436 10032 49 whatever whatever WDT 40436 10032 50 is be VBZ 40436 10032 51 greater great JJR 40436 10032 52 than than IN 40436 10032 53 another another DT 40436 10032 54 is be VBZ 40436 10032 55 greater great JJR 40436 10032 56 by by IN 40436 10032 57 nothing nothing NN 40436 10032 58 else else RB 40436 10032 59 except except IN 40436 10032 60 by by IN 40436 10032 61 Greatness Greatness NNP 40436 10032 62 and and CC 40436 10032 63 through through IN 40436 10032 64 Greatness Greatness NNP 40436 10032 65 -- -- : 40436 10032 66 whatever whatever WDT 40436 10032 67 is be VBZ 40436 10032 68 less less JJR 40436 10032 69 than than IN 40436 10032 70 another another DT 40436 10032 71 is be VBZ 40436 10032 72 less less RBR 40436 10032 73 only only RB 40436 10032 74 by by IN 40436 10032 75 Littleness Littleness NNP 40436 10032 76 and and CC 40436 10032 77 through through IN 40436 10032 78 Littleness Littleness NNP 40436 10032 79 . . . 40436 10033 1 For for IN 40436 10033 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10033 3 should should MD 40436 10033 4 fear fear VB 40436 10033 5 to to TO 40436 10033 6 be be VB 40436 10033 7 entangled entangle VBN 40436 10033 8 in in IN 40436 10033 9 a a DT 40436 10033 10 contradiction contradiction NN 40436 10033 11 , , , 40436 10033 12 if if IN 40436 10033 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10033 14 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 10033 15 that that IN 40436 10033 16 the the DT 40436 10033 17 greater great JJR 40436 10033 18 man man NN 40436 10033 19 was be VBD 40436 10033 20 greater great JJR 40436 10033 21 and and CC 40436 10033 22 the the DT 40436 10033 23 lesser less JJR 40436 10033 24 man man NN 40436 10033 25 less less JJR 40436 10033 26 by by IN 40436 10033 27 the the DT 40436 10033 28 head head NN 40436 10033 29 -- -- : 40436 10033 30 First first RB 40436 10033 31 , , , 40436 10033 32 in in IN 40436 10033 33 saying say VBG 40436 10033 34 that that IN 40436 10033 35 the the DT 40436 10033 36 greater great JJR 40436 10033 37 was be VBD 40436 10033 38 greater great JJR 40436 10033 39 and and CC 40436 10033 40 that that IN 40436 10033 41 the the DT 40436 10033 42 lesser less JJR 40436 10033 43 was be VBD 40436 10033 44 less less JJR 40436 10033 45 , , , 40436 10033 46 by by IN 40436 10033 47 the the DT 40436 10033 48 very very RB 40436 10033 49 same same JJ 40436 10033 50 -- -- : 40436 10033 51 Next next RB 40436 10033 52 , , , 40436 10033 53 in in IN 40436 10033 54 saying say VBG 40436 10033 55 that that IN 40436 10033 56 the the DT 40436 10033 57 greater great JJR 40436 10033 58 man man NN 40436 10033 59 was be VBD 40436 10033 60 greater great JJR 40436 10033 61 by by IN 40436 10033 62 the the DT 40436 10033 63 head head NN 40436 10033 64 , , , 40436 10033 65 which which WDT 40436 10033 66 is be VBZ 40436 10033 67 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10033 68 small small JJ 40436 10033 69 : : : 40436 10033 70 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10033 71 being be VBG 40436 10033 72 absurd absurd JJ 40436 10033 73 to to TO 40436 10033 74 maintain maintain VB 40436 10033 75 that that IN 40436 10033 76 a a DT 40436 10033 77 man man NN 40436 10033 78 is be VBZ 40436 10033 79 great great JJ 40436 10033 80 by by IN 40436 10033 81 something something NN 40436 10033 82 small small JJ 40436 10033 83 . . . 40436 10034 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10034 2 56 56 CD 40436 10034 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10034 4 Again again RB 40436 10034 5 , , , 40436 10034 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10034 7 should should MD 40436 10034 8 not not RB 40436 10034 9 say say VB 40436 10034 10 that that IN 40436 10034 11 ten ten CD 40436 10034 12 is be VBZ 40436 10034 13 more more JJR 40436 10034 14 than than IN 40436 10034 15 eight eight CD 40436 10034 16 by by IN 40436 10034 17 two two CD 40436 10034 18 , , , 40436 10034 19 and and CC 40436 10034 20 that that IN 40436 10034 21 this this DT 40436 10034 22 was be VBD 40436 10034 23 the the DT 40436 10034 24 cause cause NN 40436 10034 25 of of IN 40436 10034 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10034 27 excess;[57 excess;[57 NNP 40436 10034 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10034 29 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10034 30 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10034 31 is be VBZ 40436 10034 32 , , , 40436 10034 33 that that IN 40436 10034 34 ten ten NN 40436 10034 35 is be VBZ 40436 10034 36 more more JJR 40436 10034 37 than than IN 40436 10034 38 eight eight CD 40436 10034 39 by by IN 40436 10034 40 Multitude Multitude NNP 40436 10034 41 and and CC 40436 10034 42 through through IN 40436 10034 43 Multitude Multitude NNP 40436 10034 44 : : : 40436 10034 45 so so RB 40436 10034 46 the the DT 40436 10034 47 rod rod NN 40436 10034 48 of of IN 40436 10034 49 two two CD 40436 10034 50 cubits cubit NNS 40436 10034 51 is be VBZ 40436 10034 52 greater great JJR 40436 10034 53 than than IN 40436 10034 54 that that DT 40436 10034 55 of of IN 40436 10034 56 one one CD 40436 10034 57 , , , 40436 10034 58 not not RB 40436 10034 59 by by IN 40436 10034 60 half half NN 40436 10034 61 , , , 40436 10034 62 but but CC 40436 10034 63 by by IN 40436 10034 64 Greatness Greatness NNP 40436 10034 65 . . . 40436 10035 1 Again again RB 40436 10035 2 , , , 40436 10035 3 when when WRB 40436 10035 4 One one CD 40436 10035 5 is be VBZ 40436 10035 6 placed place VBN 40436 10035 7 alongside alongside RB 40436 10035 8 of of IN 40436 10035 9 One,--or one,--or CD 40436 10035 10 when when WRB 40436 10035 11 one one CD 40436 10035 12 is be VBZ 40436 10035 13 bisected bisect VBN 40436 10035 14 -- -- : 40436 10035 15 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10035 16 should should MD 40436 10035 17 take take VB 40436 10035 18 care care NN 40436 10035 19 not not RB 40436 10035 20 to to TO 40436 10035 21 affirm affirm VB 40436 10035 22 , , , 40436 10035 23 that that IN 40436 10035 24 in in IN 40436 10035 25 the the DT 40436 10035 26 first first JJ 40436 10035 27 case case NN 40436 10035 28 the the DT 40436 10035 29 juxtaposition juxtaposition NN 40436 10035 30 , , , 40436 10035 31 in in IN 40436 10035 32 the the DT 40436 10035 33 last last JJ 40436 10035 34 case case NN 40436 10035 35 the the DT 40436 10035 36 bisection bisection NN 40436 10035 37 , , , 40436 10035 38 was be VBD 40436 10035 39 the the DT 40436 10035 40 cause cause NN 40436 10035 41 why why WRB 40436 10035 42 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10035 43 became become VBD 40436 10035 44 two two CD 40436 10035 45 . . . 40436 10036 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10036 2 58 58 CD 40436 10036 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10036 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10036 5 proclaim proclaim VBP 40436 10036 6 loudly loudly RB 40436 10036 7 that that IN 40436 10036 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10036 9 know know VBP 40436 10036 10 no no DT 40436 10036 11 other other JJ 40436 10036 12 cause cause NN 40436 10036 13 for for IN 40436 10036 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10036 15 becoming become VBG 40436 10036 16 two two CD 40436 10036 17 except except IN 40436 10036 18 participation participation NN 40436 10036 19 in in IN 40436 10036 20 the the DT 40436 10036 21 essence essence NN 40436 10036 22 of of IN 40436 10036 23 the the DT 40436 10036 24 Dyad Dyad NNP 40436 10036 25 . . . 40436 10037 1 What what WP 40436 10037 2 is be VBZ 40436 10037 3 to to TO 40436 10037 4 become become VB 40436 10037 5 two two CD 40436 10037 6 , , , 40436 10037 7 must must MD 40436 10037 8 partake partake VB 40436 10037 9 of of IN 40436 10037 10 the the DT 40436 10037 11 Dyad Dyad NNP 40436 10037 12 : : : 40436 10037 13 what what WP 40436 10037 14 is be VBZ 40436 10037 15 to to TO 40436 10037 16 become become VB 40436 10037 17 one one CD 40436 10037 18 , , , 40436 10037 19 of of IN 40436 10037 20 the the DT 40436 10037 21 Monad Monad NNP 40436 10037 22 . . . 40436 10038 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10038 2 leave leave VBP 40436 10038 3 to to TO 40436 10038 4 wiser wise JJR 40436 10038 5 men man NNS 40436 10038 6 than than IN 40436 10038 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10038 8 these these DT 40436 10038 9 juxtapositions juxtaposition NNS 40436 10038 10 and and CC 40436 10038 11 bisections bisection NNS 40436 10038 12 and and CC 40436 10038 13 other other JJ 40436 10038 14 such such JJ 40436 10038 15 refinements refinement NNS 40436 10038 16 : : : 40436 10038 17 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10038 18 remain remain VBP 40436 10038 19 entrenched entrenched JJ 40436 10038 20 within within IN 40436 10038 21 the the DT 40436 10038 22 safe safe JJ 40436 10038 23 ground ground NN 40436 10038 24 of of IN 40436 10038 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10038 26 own own JJ 40436 10038 27 assumption assumption NN 40436 10038 28 or or CC 40436 10038 29 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10038 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10038 31 the the DT 40436 10038 32 reality reality NN 40436 10038 33 of of IN 40436 10038 34 these these DT 40436 10038 35 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 10038 36 * * NFP 40436 10038 37 * * NFP 40436 10038 38 and and CC 40436 10038 39 eternal eternal JJ 40436 10038 40 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10038 41 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10038 42 . . . 40436 10039 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10039 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10039 3 55 55 CD 40436 10039 4 : : : 40436 10039 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10039 6 , , , 40436 10039 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10039 8 , , , 40436 10039 9 p. p. NN 40436 10039 10 100 100 CD 40436 10039 11 C. C. NNP 40436 10039 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10039 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10039 14 : : : 40436 10039 15 ou ou NNP 40436 10039 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10039 17 toi toi NNP 40436 10039 18 / / SYM 40436 10039 19 nun nun NNP 40436 10039 20 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 10039 21 mantha mantha NN 40436 10039 22 / / SYM 40436 10039 23 nô nô NNP 40436 10039 24 , , , 40436 10039 25 ou)de\ ou)de\ NNP 40436 10039 26 du du NNP 40436 10039 27 / / SYM 40436 10039 28 namai namai NNP 40436 10039 29 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 10039 30 a)/llas a)/llas NNP 40436 10039 31 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10039 32 / / SYM 40436 10039 33 as as IN 40436 10039 34 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 10039 35 sopha\s sopha\s CD 40436 10039 36 tau tau NNP 40436 10039 37 / / SYM 40436 10039 38 tas tas NNP 40436 10039 39 gignô gignô NNP 40436 10039 40 / / , 40436 10039 41 skein skein NNP 40436 10039 42 . . . 40436 10039 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10039 44 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10040 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10040 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10040 3 56 56 CD 40436 10040 4 : : : 40436 10040 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10040 6 , , , 40436 10040 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10040 8 , , , 40436 10040 9 p. p. NN 40436 10040 10 101 101 CD 40436 10040 11 A. a. NN 40436 10041 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10041 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10041 3 : : : 40436 10041 4 phobou phobou NNS 40436 10041 5 / / SYM 40436 10041 6 menos menos NNP 40436 10041 7 mê/ mê/ NNP 40436 10041 8 ti ti NNP 40436 10041 9 / / SYM 40436 10041 10 s s NNP 40436 10041 11 soi soi NNP 40436 10041 12 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 10041 13 / / SYM 40436 10041 14 os os NNP 40436 10041 15 lo lo NNP 40436 10041 16 / / SYM 40436 10041 17 gos gos NNP 40436 10041 18 a)pantê a)pantê NNP 40436 10041 19 / / SYM 40436 10041 20 sê| sê| NNP 40436 10041 21 , , , 40436 10041 22 e)a\n e)a\n VB 40436 10041 23 tê=| tê=| NN 40436 10041 24 kephalê=| kephalê=| NNP 40436 10041 25 mei mei NNP 40436 10041 26 / / SYM 40436 10041 27 zona/ zona/ NNP 40436 10041 28 tina tina NNP 40436 10041 29 phê=|s phê=| VBD 40436 10041 30 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 10041 31 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10041 32 e)la e)la NNP 40436 10041 33 / / SYM 40436 10041 34 ttô ttô NNP 40436 10041 35 , , , 40436 10041 36 prô prô NNP 40436 10041 37 = = SYM 40436 10041 38 ton ton NN 40436 10041 39 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10041 40 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 10041 41 au)tô=| au)tô=| NNP 40436 10041 42 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10041 43 mei mei NNP 40436 10041 44 = = NFP 40436 10041 45 zon zon NNP 40436 10041 46 mei mei NNP 40436 10041 47 = = SYM 40436 10041 48 zon zon NNP 40436 10041 49 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 10041 50 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10041 51 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10041 52 e)/latton e)/latton NNP 40436 10041 53 e)/latton e)/latton NNP 40436 10041 54 , , , 40436 10041 55 e)/peita e)/peita VBZ 40436 10041 56 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 10041 57 kephalê=| kephalê=| NNP 40436 10041 58 smikra=| smikra=| NNP 40436 10041 59 ou)/sê| ou)/sê| NNP 40436 10041 60 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10041 61 mei mei NNP 40436 10041 62 / / SYM 40436 10041 63 zô zô NNP 40436 10041 64 mei mei NNP 40436 10041 65 / / SYM 40436 10041 66 zô zô NNP 40436 10041 67 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 10041 68 , , , 40436 10041 69 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10041 70 tou tou NNP 40436 10041 71 = = SYM 40436 10041 72 to to IN 40436 10041 73 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 10041 74 te te NNP 40436 10041 75 / / SYM 40436 10041 76 ras ras NNP 40436 10041 77 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 10041 78 , , , 40436 10041 79 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10041 80 smikrô=| smikrô=| NNP 40436 10041 81 tini\ tini\ NNP 40436 10041 82 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10041 83 / / SYM 40436 10041 84 gan gan NNP 40436 10041 85 tina\ tina\ . 40436 10041 86 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 10041 87 . . . 40436 10041 88 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10041 89 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10042 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10042 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10042 3 57 57 CD 40436 10042 4 : : : 40436 10042 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10042 6 , , , 40436 10042 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10042 8 , , , 40436 10042 9 p. p. NN 40436 10042 10 101 101 CD 40436 10042 11 B. b. NN 40436 10043 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10043 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10043 3 : : : 40436 10043 4 Ou)/koun ou)/koun JJ 40436 10043 5 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 10043 6 de de IN 40436 10043 7 / / SYM 40436 10043 8 ka ka NNP 40436 10043 9 tô tô NNP 40436 10043 10 = = SYM 40436 10043 11 n n LS 40436 10043 12 o)ktô\ o)ktô\ NNP 40436 10043 13 duoi duoi NN 40436 10043 14 = = SYM 40436 10043 15 n n CC 40436 10043 16 plei plei NNP 40436 10043 17 / / SYM 40436 10043 18 ô ô NNP 40436 10043 19 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 10043 20 , , , 40436 10043 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10043 22 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 10043 23 tau tau NNP 40436 10043 24 / / SYM 40436 10043 25 tên tên NN 40436 10043 26 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10043 27 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10043 28 / / , 40436 10043 29 an an DT 40436 10043 30 u(perba u(perba NNP 40436 10043 31 / / SYM 40436 10043 32 llein llein NN 40436 10043 33 , , , 40436 10043 34 phoboi phoboi NNP 40436 10043 35 = = SYM 40436 10043 36 o o NN 40436 10043 37 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 10043 38 le le NNP 40436 10043 39 / / SYM 40436 10043 40 gein gein NNP 40436 10043 41 , , , 40436 10043 42 a)lla\ a)lla\ '' 40436 10043 43 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 10043 44 plê plê NNP 40436 10043 45 / / SYM 40436 10043 46 thei thei NNP 40436 10043 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10043 48 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 10043 49 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10043 50 plê plê NNP 40436 10043 51 = = NFP 40436 10043 52 thos thos NN 40436 10043 53 ? ? . 40436 10044 1 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10044 2 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10044 3 di di NNP 40436 10044 4 / / SYM 40436 10044 5 pêchu pêchu VBZ 40436 10044 6 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10044 7 pêchuai pêchuai NNP 40436 10044 8 / / SYM 40436 10044 9 ou ou NNP 40436 10044 10 ê(mi ê(mi NNP 40436 10044 11 / / SYM 40436 10044 12 sei sei NNP 40436 10044 13 mei mei NNP 40436 10044 14 = = SYM 40436 10044 15 zon zon NNP 40436 10044 16 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNPS 40436 10044 17 , , , 40436 10044 18 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 10044 19 ' ' '' 40436 10044 20 ou ou NNP 40436 10044 21 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10044 22 mege mege NNP 40436 10044 23 / / SYM 40436 10044 24 thei thei NN 40436 10044 25 ? ? . 40436 10044 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10044 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10045 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10045 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10045 3 58 58 CD 40436 10045 4 : : : 40436 10045 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10045 6 , , , 40436 10045 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10045 8 , , , 40436 10045 9 p. p. NN 40436 10045 10 101 101 CD 40436 10045 11 B B NNP 40436 10045 12 - - HYPH 40436 10045 13 C. C. NNP 40436 10045 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10045 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10045 16 : : : 40436 10045 17 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 10045 18 de/ de/ NNP 40436 10045 19 ? ? . 40436 10046 1 e(ni\ e(ni\ NNP 40436 10046 2 e(no\s e(no\s NNP 40436 10046 3 prostethe prostethe NNP 40436 10046 4 / / SYM 40436 10046 5 ntos ntos NN 40436 10046 6 , , , 40436 10046 7 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10046 8 pro pro JJ 40436 10046 9 / / SYM 40436 10046 10 sthesin sthesin NNS 40436 10046 11 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10046 12 / / NFP 40436 10046 13 an an DT 40436 10046 14 ei)=nai ei)=nai NNP 40436 10046 15 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10046 16 du du NN 40436 10046 17 / / SYM 40436 10046 18 o o NNP 40436 10046 19 gene gene NN 40436 10046 20 / / SYM 40436 10046 21 sthai sthai NNP 40436 10046 22 , , , 40436 10046 23 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 10046 24 diaschisthe diaschisthe NNP 40436 10046 25 / / SYM 40436 10046 26 ntos ntos NN 40436 10046 27 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10046 28 schi schi NN 40436 10046 29 / / SYM 40436 10046 30 sin sin NN 40436 10046 31 , , , 40436 10046 32 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10046 33 eu)laboi eu)laboi NN 40436 10046 34 = = SYM 40436 10046 35 o o NN 40436 10046 36 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 10046 37 le le NNP 40436 10046 38 / / SYM 40436 10046 39 gein gein NNP 40436 10046 40 , , , 40436 10046 41 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10046 42 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10046 43 / / SYM 40436 10046 44 ga ga NNP 40436 10046 45 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10046 46 boô/|ês boô/|ês , 40436 10046 47 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10046 48 ou)k ou)k . 40436 10046 49 oi)=stha oi)=stha '' 40436 10046 50 a)/llôs a)/llôs NNP 40436 10046 51 pôs pôs NNP 40436 10046 52 e(/kaston e(/kaston NNP 40436 10046 53 gigno gigno NNP 40436 10046 54 / / SYM 40436 10046 55 menon menon NNP 40436 10046 56 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 10046 57 metascho\n metascho\n NNP 40436 10046 58 tê tê NN 40436 10046 59 = = SYM 40436 10046 60 s s NNP 40436 10046 61 i)di i)di JJ 40436 10046 62 / / SYM 40436 10046 63 as as IN 40436 10046 64 ou)si ou)si NNP 40436 10046 65 / / SYM 40436 10046 66 as as IN 40436 10046 67 e(kastou e(kastou NNP 40436 10046 68 ou)= ou)= NNP 40436 10046 69 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10046 70 meta meta NNP 40436 10046 71 / / SYM 40436 10046 72 schê| schê| NNP 40436 10046 73 ; ; : 40436 10046 74 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10046 75 e)n e)n NNP 40436 10046 76 tou tou NNP 40436 10046 77 / / SYM 40436 10046 78 tois tois NNP 40436 10046 79 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10046 80 e)/cheis e)/cheis NNP 40436 10046 81 a)/llên a)/llên NNP 40436 10046 82 tina\ tina\ , 40436 10046 83 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10046 84 / / SYM 40436 10046 85 an an DT 40436 10046 86 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10046 87 du du NN 40436 10046 88 / / SYM 40436 10046 89 o o NNP 40436 10046 90 gene gene NN 40436 10046 91 / / SYM 40436 10046 92 sthai sthai NNP 40436 10046 93 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 10046 94 ' ' '' 40436 10046 95 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 10046 96 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10046 97 tê tê NNP 40436 10046 98 = = SYM 40436 10046 99 s s NNP 40436 10046 100 dua dua NNP 40436 10046 101 / / SYM 40436 10046 102 dos dos NNP 40436 10046 103 meta meta NNP 40436 10046 104 / / SYM 40436 10046 105 schesin schesin NNP 40436 10046 106 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10046 107 , , , 40436 10046 108 & & CC 40436 10046 109 c. c. NNP 40436 10046 110 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10046 111 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10046 112 Side side NN 40436 10046 113 - - HYPH 40436 10046 114 note note NN 40436 10046 115 : : : 40436 10046 116 Procedure procedure NN 40436 10046 117 of of IN 40436 10046 118 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10046 119 if if IN 40436 10046 120 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10046 121 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10046 122 were be VBD 40436 10046 123 impugned impugn VBN 40436 10046 124 . . . 40436 10047 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10047 2 insists insist VBZ 40436 10047 3 upon upon IN 40436 10047 4 keeping keep VBG 40436 10047 5 apart apart RB 40436 10047 6 the the DT 40436 10047 7 discussion discussion NN 40436 10047 8 of of IN 40436 10047 9 the the DT 40436 10047 10 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10047 11 and and CC 40436 10047 12 the the DT 40436 10047 13 discussion discussion NN 40436 10047 14 of of IN 40436 10047 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10047 16 consequences consequence NNS 40436 10047 17 . . . 40436 10047 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10048 1 " " `` 40436 10048 2 Suppose suppose VB 40436 10048 3 however however RB 40436 10048 4 that that IN 40436 10048 5 any any DT 40436 10048 6 one one NN 40436 10048 7 impugned impugn VBD 40436 10048 8 this this DT 40436 10048 9 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10048 10 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10048 11 ? ? . 40436 10049 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10049 2 should should MD 40436 10049 3 make make VB 40436 10049 4 no no DT 40436 10049 5 reply reply NN 40436 10049 6 to to IN 40436 10049 7 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10049 8 until until IN 40436 10049 9 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10049 10 had have VBD 40436 10049 11 followed follow VBN 40436 10049 12 out out RP 40436 10049 13 fully fully RB 40436 10049 14 the the DT 40436 10049 15 consequences consequence NNS 40436 10049 16 of of IN 40436 10049 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10049 18 : : : 40436 10049 19 in in IN 40436 10049 20 order order NN 40436 10049 21 to to TO 40436 10049 22 ascertain ascertain VB 40436 10049 23 whether whether IN 40436 10049 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10049 25 were be VBD 40436 10049 26 consistent consistent JJ 40436 10049 27 with with IN 40436 10049 28 , , , 40436 10049 29 or or CC 40436 10049 30 contradictory contradictory JJ 40436 10049 31 to to TO 40436 10049 32 , , , 40436 10049 33 each each DT 40436 10049 34 other other JJ 40436 10049 35 . . . 40436 10050 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10050 2 should should MD 40436 10050 3 , , , 40436 10050 4 when when WRB 40436 10050 5 the the DT 40436 10050 6 proper proper JJ 40436 10050 7 time time NN 40436 10050 8 came come VBD 40436 10050 9 , , , 40436 10050 10 defend defend VB 40436 10050 11 the the DT 40436 10050 12 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10050 13 by by IN 40436 10050 14 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10050 15 , , , 40436 10050 16 assuming assume VBG 40436 10050 17 some some DT 40436 10050 18 other other JJ 40436 10050 19 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10050 20 yet yet CC 40436 10050 21 more more RBR 40436 10050 22 universal universal JJ 40436 10050 23 , , , 40436 10050 24 such such JJ 40436 10050 25 as as IN 40436 10050 26 appeared appear VBD 40436 10050 27 to to IN 40436 10050 28 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10050 29 best well RBS 40436 10050 30 , , , 40436 10050 31 until until IN 40436 10050 32 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10050 33 came come VBD 40436 10050 34 to to IN 40436 10050 35 some some DT 40436 10050 36 thing thing NN 40436 10050 37 fully fully RB 40436 10050 38 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 10050 39 . . . 40436 10051 1 But but CC 40436 10051 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10051 3 would would MD 40436 10051 4 not not RB 40436 10051 5 permit permit VB 40436 10051 6 myself -PRON- PRP 40436 10051 7 to to TO 40436 10051 8 confound confound VB 40436 10051 9 together together RB 40436 10051 10 the the DT 40436 10051 11 discussion discussion NN 40436 10051 12 of of IN 40436 10051 13 the the DT 40436 10051 14 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10051 15 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10051 16 , , , 40436 10051 17 and and CC 40436 10051 18 the the DT 40436 10051 19 discussion discussion NN 40436 10051 20 of of IN 40436 10051 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10051 22 consequences consequence NNS 40436 10051 23 . . . 40436 10052 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10052 2 59 59 CD 40436 10052 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10052 4 This this DT 40436 10052 5 is be VBZ 40436 10052 6 a a DT 40436 10052 7 method method NN 40436 10052 8 which which WDT 40436 10052 9 can can MD 40436 10052 10 not not RB 40436 10052 11 lead lead VB 40436 10052 12 to to IN 40436 10052 13 truth truth NN 40436 10052 14 : : : 40436 10052 15 though though IN 40436 10052 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10052 17 is be VBZ 40436 10052 18 much much RB 40436 10052 19 practised practise VBN 40436 10052 20 by by IN 40436 10052 21 litigious litigious JJ 40436 10052 22 disputants disputant NNS 40436 10052 23 , , , 40436 10052 24 who who WP 40436 10052 25 care care VBP 40436 10052 26 little little JJ 40436 10052 27 about about IN 40436 10052 28 truth truth NN 40436 10052 29 , , , 40436 10052 30 and and CC 40436 10052 31 pride pride VB 40436 10052 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10052 33 upon upon IN 40436 10052 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10052 35 ingenuity ingenuity NN 40436 10052 36 when when WRB 40436 10052 37 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10052 38 throw throw VBP 40436 10052 39 all all DT 40436 10052 40 things thing NNS 40436 10052 41 into into IN 40436 10052 42 confusion confusion NN 40436 10052 43 . . . 40436 10052 44 " " '' 40436 10053 1 -- -- : 40436 10053 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10053 3 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10053 4 59 59 CD 40436 10053 5 : : : 40436 10053 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10053 7 , , , 40436 10053 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10053 9 , , , 40436 10053 10 p. p. NN 40436 10053 11 101 101 CD 40436 10053 12 E. E. NNP 40436 10053 13 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10053 14 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10053 15 : : : 40436 10053 16 e)peidê\ e)peidê\ JJ 40436 10053 17 de\ de\ JJ 40436 10053 18 e)kei e)kei NNS 40436 10053 19 / / SYM 40436 10053 20 nês nês NNP 40436 10053 21 au)tê au)tê NNP 40436 10053 22 = = SYM 40436 10053 23 s s FW 40436 10053 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10053 25 tê tê NNP 40436 10053 26 = = SYM 40436 10053 27 s s NNP 40436 10053 28 u(pothe u(pothe NNP 40436 10053 29 / / SYM 40436 10053 30 seôs seôs JJ 40436 10053 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10053 32 de de NNP 40436 10053 33 / / SYM 40436 10053 34 oi oi NNP 40436 10053 35 se se NNP 40436 10053 36 dido dido NNP 40436 10053 37 / / SYM 40436 10053 38 nai nai NNP 40436 10053 39 lo lo NNP 40436 10053 40 / / SYM 40436 10053 41 gon gon NNP 40436 10053 42 , , , 40436 10053 43 ô(sau ô(sau NNP 40436 10053 44 / / SYM 40436 10053 45 tôs tôs NNP 40436 10053 46 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10053 47 didoi didoi NNP 40436 10053 48 / / SYM 40436 10053 49 ês ês NNP 40436 10053 50 , , , 40436 10053 51 a)/llên a)/llên JJ 40436 10053 52 au)= au)= : 40436 10053 53 u(po u(po CD 40436 10053 54 / / SYM 40436 10053 55 thesin thesin VB 40436 10053 56 u(pothe u(pothe NN 40436 10053 57 / / SYM 40436 10053 58 menos menos NNP 40436 10053 59 , , , 40436 10053 60 ê(/tis ê(/tis NNP 40436 10053 61 tô tô NNP 40436 10053 62 = = SYM 40436 10053 63 n n NN 40436 10053 64 a)/nôthen a)/nôthen NNP 40436 10053 65 belti belti NNP 40436 10053 66 / / SYM 40436 10053 67 stê stê NNP 40436 10053 68 phai phai NNP 40436 10053 69 / / SYM 40436 10053 70 noito noito NNP 40436 10053 71 . . . 40436 10054 1 . . . 40436 10055 1 . . . 40436 10056 1 . . . 40436 10057 1 a)/ma a)/ma NNP 40436 10057 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10057 3 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10057 4 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10057 5 phu phu NNP 40436 10057 6 / / SYM 40436 10057 7 roio roio NNP 40436 10057 8 , , , 40436 10057 9 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 10057 10 oi oi FW 40436 10057 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10057 12 a)ntilogikoi/ a)ntilogikoi/ NNP 40436 10057 13 , , , 40436 10057 14 peri/ peri/ NNP 40436 10057 15 te te NNP 40436 10057 16 tê tê NNP 40436 10057 17 = = SYM 40436 10057 18 s s NNP 40436 10057 19 a)rchê a)rchê NNP 40436 10057 20 = = SYM 40436 10057 21 s s NNP 40436 10057 22 dialego dialego NNP 40436 10057 23 / / SYM 40436 10057 24 menos menos NNP 40436 10057 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10057 26 tô tô NNP 40436 10057 27 = = SYM 40436 10057 28 n n NNP 40436 10057 29 e)x e)x NNP 40436 10057 30 e)kei e)kei NNPS 40436 10057 31 / / SYM 40436 10057 32 nês nês NNP 40436 10057 33 ô(rmême ô(rmême NNP 40436 10057 34 / / SYM 40436 10057 35 nôn nôn NN 40436 10057 36 , , , 40436 10057 37 ei)/per ei)/per NNP 40436 10057 38 bou bou NN 40436 10057 39 / / SYM 40436 10057 40 loio/ loio/ NNS 40436 10057 41 ti ti NNP 40436 10057 42 tô tô NNP 40436 10057 43 = = SYM 40436 10057 44 n n NN 40436 10057 45 o)/ntôn o)/ntôn NNP 40436 10057 46 eu(rei eu(rei NNP 40436 10057 47 = = SYM 40436 10057 48 n n XX 40436 10057 49 . . . 40436 10057 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10057 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10058 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10058 2 Side side NN 40436 10058 3 - - HYPH 40436 10058 4 note note NN 40436 10058 5 : : : 40436 10058 6 Exposition exposition NN 40436 10058 7 of of IN 40436 10058 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10058 9 welcomed welcome VBN 40436 10058 10 by by IN 40436 10058 11 the the DT 40436 10058 12 hearers hearer NNS 40436 10058 13 . . . 40436 10059 1 Remarks remark NNS 40436 10059 2 upon upon IN 40436 10059 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10059 4 . . . 40436 10059 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10060 1 The the DT 40436 10060 2 exposition exposition NN 40436 10060 3 here here RB 40436 10060 4 given give VBN 40436 10060 5 by by IN 40436 10060 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10060 7 of of IN 40436 10060 8 successive successive JJ 40436 10060 9 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 10060 10 tentatives tentative NNS 40436 10060 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10060 12 whether whether IN 40436 10060 13 of of IN 40436 10060 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10060 15 or or CC 40436 10060 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10060 17 , , , 40436 10060 18 or or CC 40436 10060 19 partly partly RB 40436 10060 20 one one CD 40436 10060 21 , , , 40436 10060 22 partly partly RB 40436 10060 23 the the DT 40436 10060 24 other other JJ 40436 10060 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10060 26 , , , 40436 10060 27 and and CC 40436 10060 28 the the DT 40436 10060 29 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 10060 30 embodied embody VBD 40436 10060 31 therein therein RB 40436 10060 32 , , , 40436 10060 33 is be VBZ 40436 10060 34 represented represent VBN 40436 10060 35 as as IN 40436 10060 36 welcomed welcome VBN 40436 10060 37 with with IN 40436 10060 38 emphatic emphatic JJ 40436 10060 39 assent assent NN 40436 10060 40 and and CC 40436 10060 41 approbation approbation NN 40436 10060 42 by by IN 40436 10060 43 all all DT 40436 10060 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10060 45 fellow fellow NN 40436 10060 46 - - HYPH 40436 10060 47 dialogists dialogist NNS 40436 10060 48 . . . 40436 10061 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10061 2 60 60 CD 40436 10061 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10061 4 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10061 5 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 10061 6 attention attention NN 40436 10061 7 on on IN 40436 10061 8 many many JJ 40436 10061 9 grounds ground NNS 40436 10061 10 . . . 40436 10062 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10062 2 illustrates illustrate VBZ 40436 10062 3 instructively instructively RB 40436 10062 4 some some DT 40436 10062 5 of of IN 40436 10062 6 the the DT 40436 10062 7 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10062 8 points point NNS 40436 10062 9 of of IN 40436 10062 10 view view NN 40436 10062 11 , , , 40436 10062 12 and and CC 40436 10062 13 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10062 14 transitions transition NNS 40436 10062 15 , , , 40436 10062 16 suggesting suggest VBG 40436 10062 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10062 18 to to IN 40436 10062 19 an an DT 40436 10062 20 inquisitive inquisitive JJ 40436 10062 21 intellect intellect NN 40436 10062 22 of of IN 40436 10062 23 that that DT 40436 10062 24 day day NN 40436 10062 25 . . . 40436 10063 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10063 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10063 3 60 60 CD 40436 10063 4 : : : 40436 10063 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10063 6 , , , 40436 10063 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10063 8 , , , 40436 10063 9 p. p. NN 40436 10063 10 102 102 CD 40436 10063 11 A. a. NN 40436 10064 1 Such such JJ 40436 10064 2 approbation approbation NN 40436 10064 3 is be VBZ 40436 10064 4 peculiarly peculiarly RB 40436 10064 5 signified signify VBN 40436 10064 6 by by IN 40436 10064 7 the the DT 40436 10064 8 intervention intervention NN 40436 10064 9 of of IN 40436 10064 10 Echekrates Echekrates NNPS 40436 10064 11 . . . 40436 10064 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10065 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10065 2 Side side NN 40436 10065 3 - - HYPH 40436 10065 4 note note NN 40436 10065 5 : : : 40436 10065 6 The the DT 40436 10065 7 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 10065 8 changes change NNS 40436 10065 9 in in IN 40436 10065 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10065 11 all all DT 40436 10065 12 turned turn VBD 40436 10065 13 upon upon RP 40436 10065 14 different different JJ 40436 10065 15 views view NNS 40436 10065 16 as as IN 40436 10065 17 to to IN 40436 10065 18 a a DT 40436 10065 19 true true JJ 40436 10065 20 cause cause NN 40436 10065 21 . . . 40436 10065 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10066 1 If if IN 40436 10066 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10066 3 are be VBP 40436 10066 4 to to TO 40436 10066 5 take take VB 40436 10066 6 that that DT 40436 10066 7 which which WDT 40436 10066 8 precedes precede NNS 40436 10066 9 as as IN 40436 10066 10 a a DT 40436 10066 11 description description NN 40436 10066 12 of of IN 40436 10066 13 the the DT 40436 10066 14 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 10066 15 changes change NNS 40436 10066 16 of of IN 40436 10066 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10066 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10066 19 , , , 40436 10066 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10066 21 differs differ VBZ 40436 10066 22 materially materially RB 40436 10066 23 from from IN 40436 10066 24 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10066 25 : : : 40436 10066 26 for for IN 40436 10066 27 no no DT 40436 10066 28 allusion allusion NN 40436 10066 29 is be VBZ 40436 10066 30 here here RB 40436 10066 31 made make VBN 40436 10066 32 to to IN 40436 10066 33 the the DT 40436 10066 34 intercourse intercourse NN 40436 10066 35 of of IN 40436 10066 36 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10066 37 with with IN 40436 10066 38 Kratylus Kratylus NNP 40436 10066 39 and and CC 40436 10066 40 other other JJ 40436 10066 41 advocates advocate NNS 40436 10066 42 of of IN 40436 10066 43 the the DT 40436 10066 44 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 10066 45 of of IN 40436 10066 46 Herakleitus Herakleitus NNP 40436 10066 47 : : : 40436 10066 48 which which WDT 40436 10066 49 intercourse intercourse NN 40436 10066 50 is be VBZ 40436 10066 51 mentioned mention VBN 40436 10066 52 by by IN 40436 10066 53 Aristotle[61 aristotle[61 CD 40436 10066 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10066 55 as as IN 40436 10066 56 having have VBG 40436 10066 57 greatly greatly RB 40436 10066 58 influenced influence VBN 40436 10066 59 the the DT 40436 10066 60 early early JJ 40436 10066 61 speculations speculation NNS 40436 10066 62 of of IN 40436 10066 63 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10066 64 . . . 40436 10067 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10067 2 describes describe VBZ 40436 10067 3 three three CD 40436 10067 4 different different JJ 40436 10067 5 phases phase NNS 40436 10067 6 of of IN 40436 10067 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10067 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10067 9 or or CC 40436 10067 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10067 11 's 's POS 40436 10067 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10067 13 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10067 14 point point NN 40436 10067 15 of of IN 40436 10067 16 view view NN 40436 10067 17 : : : 40436 10067 18 all all DT 40436 10067 19 turning turn VBG 40436 10067 20 upon upon IN 40436 10067 21 different different JJ 40436 10067 22 conceptions conception NNS 40436 10067 23 of of IN 40436 10067 24 what what WP 40436 10067 25 constituted constitute VBD 40436 10067 26 a a DT 40436 10067 27 true true JJ 40436 10067 28 Cause cause NN 40436 10067 29 . . . 40436 10068 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10068 2 first first JJ 40436 10068 3 belief belief NN 40436 10068 4 on on IN 40436 10068 5 the the DT 40436 10068 6 subject subject NN 40436 10068 7 was be VBD 40436 10068 8 , , , 40436 10068 9 that that IN 40436 10068 10 which which WDT 40436 10068 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10068 12 entertained entertain VBD 40436 10068 13 before before IN 40436 10068 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10068 15 entered enter VBD 40436 10068 16 on on IN 40436 10068 17 physical physical JJ 40436 10068 18 and and CC 40436 10068 19 physiological physiological JJ 40436 10068 20 investigations investigation NNS 40436 10068 21 . . . 40436 10069 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10069 2 seemed seem VBD 40436 10069 3 natural natural JJ 40436 10069 4 to to IN 40436 10069 5 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10069 6 that that IN 40436 10069 7 eating eat VBG 40436 10069 8 and and CC 40436 10069 9 drinking drinking NN 40436 10069 10 should should MD 40436 10069 11 be be VB 40436 10069 12 the the DT 40436 10069 13 cause cause NN 40436 10069 14 why why WRB 40436 10069 15 a a DT 40436 10069 16 young young JJ 40436 10069 17 man man NN 40436 10069 18 grew grow VBD 40436 10069 19 taller tall JJR 40436 10069 20 : : : 40436 10069 21 new new JJ 40436 10069 22 bone bone NN 40436 10069 23 and and CC 40436 10069 24 new new JJ 40436 10069 25 flesh flesh NN 40436 10069 26 was be VBD 40436 10069 27 added add VBN 40436 10069 28 out out IN 40436 10069 29 of of IN 40436 10069 30 the the DT 40436 10069 31 food food NN 40436 10069 32 . . . 40436 10070 1 So so RB 40436 10070 2 again again RB 40436 10070 3 , , , 40436 10070 4 when when WRB 40436 10070 5 a a DT 40436 10070 6 tall tall JJ 40436 10070 7 man man NN 40436 10070 8 appeared appear VBD 40436 10070 9 standing stand VBG 40436 10070 10 near near RB 40436 10070 11 to to IN 40436 10070 12 a a DT 40436 10070 13 short short JJ 40436 10070 14 man man NN 40436 10070 15 , , , 40436 10070 16 the the DT 40436 10070 17 former former JJ 40436 10070 18 was be VBD 40436 10070 19 tall tall JJ 40436 10070 20 by by IN 40436 10070 21 the the DT 40436 10070 22 head head NN 40436 10070 23 , , , 40436 10070 24 or or CC 40436 10070 25 because because IN 40436 10070 26 of of IN 40436 10070 27 the the DT 40436 10070 28 head head NN 40436 10070 29 : : : 40436 10070 30 ten ten CD 40436 10070 31 were be VBD 40436 10070 32 more more JJR 40436 10070 33 than than IN 40436 10070 34 eight eight CD 40436 10070 35 , , , 40436 10070 36 because because IN 40436 10070 37 two two CD 40436 10070 38 were be VBD 40436 10070 39 added add VBN 40436 10070 40 on on IN 40436 10070 41 : : : 40436 10070 42 the the DT 40436 10070 43 measure measure NN 40436 10070 44 of of IN 40436 10070 45 two two CD 40436 10070 46 cubits cubit NNS 40436 10070 47 was be VBD 40436 10070 48 greater great JJR 40436 10070 49 than than IN 40436 10070 50 that that DT 40436 10070 51 of of IN 40436 10070 52 one one CD 40436 10070 53 cubit cubit NN 40436 10070 54 , , , 40436 10070 55 because because IN 40436 10070 56 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10070 57 stretched stretch VBD 40436 10070 58 beyond beyond IN 40436 10070 59 by by IN 40436 10070 60 one one CD 40436 10070 61 half half NN 40436 10070 62 . . . 40436 10071 1 When when WRB 40436 10071 2 one one CD 40436 10071 3 object object NN 40436 10071 4 was be VBD 40436 10071 5 added add VBN 40436 10071 6 on on IN 40436 10071 7 to to IN 40436 10071 8 another another DT 40436 10071 9 , , , 40436 10071 10 the the DT 40436 10071 11 addition addition NN 40436 10071 12 was be VBD 40436 10071 13 the the DT 40436 10071 14 cause cause NN 40436 10071 15 why why WRB 40436 10071 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10071 17 became become VBD 40436 10071 18 two two CD 40436 10071 19 : : : 40436 10071 20 when when WRB 40436 10071 21 one one CD 40436 10071 22 object object NN 40436 10071 23 was be VBD 40436 10071 24 bisected bisect VBN 40436 10071 25 , , , 40436 10071 26 this this DT 40436 10071 27 bisection bisection NN 40436 10071 28 was be VBD 40436 10071 29 the the DT 40436 10071 30 cause cause NN 40436 10071 31 why why WRB 40436 10071 32 the the DT 40436 10071 33 one one NN 40436 10071 34 became become VBD 40436 10071 35 two two CD 40436 10071 36 . . . 40436 10072 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10072 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10072 3 61 61 CD 40436 10072 4 : : : 40436 10072 5 Aristotel Aristotel NNP 40436 10072 6 . . . 40436 10073 1 Metaphys metaphys RB 40436 10073 2 . . . 40436 10074 1 A. A. NNP 40436 10075 1 987 987 CD 40436 10075 2 , , , 40436 10075 3 a. a. NN 40436 10076 1 32 32 CD 40436 10076 2 . . . 40436 10076 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10077 1 This this DT 40436 10077 2 was be VBD 40436 10077 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10077 4 first first JJ 40436 10077 5 conception conception NN 40436 10077 6 of of IN 40436 10077 7 a a DT 40436 10077 8 true true JJ 40436 10077 9 Cause cause NN 40436 10077 10 , , , 40436 10077 11 which which WDT 40436 10077 12 for for IN 40436 10077 13 the the DT 40436 10077 14 time time NN 40436 10077 15 thoroughly thoroughly RB 40436 10077 16 satisfied satisfy VBD 40436 10077 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10077 18 . . . 40436 10078 1 But but CC 40436 10078 2 when when WRB 40436 10078 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10078 4 came come VBD 40436 10078 5 to to TO 40436 10078 6 investigate investigate VB 40436 10078 7 physiology physiology NN 40436 10078 8 , , , 40436 10078 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10078 10 could could MD 40436 10078 11 not not RB 40436 10078 12 follow follow VB 40436 10078 13 out out RP 40436 10078 14 the the DT 40436 10078 15 same same JJ 40436 10078 16 conception conception NN 40436 10078 17 of of IN 40436 10078 18 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10078 19 , , , 40436 10078 20 so so IN 40436 10078 21 as as IN 40436 10078 22 to to TO 40436 10078 23 apply apply VB 40436 10078 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10078 25 to to IN 40436 10078 26 more more JJR 40436 10078 27 novel novel JJ 40436 10078 28 and and CC 40436 10078 29 complicated complicated JJ 40436 10078 30 problems problem NNS 40436 10078 31 ; ; : 40436 10078 32 and and CC 40436 10078 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10078 34 became become VBD 40436 10078 35 dissatisfied dissatisfied JJ 40436 10078 36 with with IN 40436 10078 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10078 38 altogether altogether RB 40436 10078 39 , , , 40436 10078 40 even even RB 40436 10078 41 in in IN 40436 10078 42 regard regard NN 40436 10078 43 to to IN 40436 10078 44 questions question NNS 40436 10078 45 on on IN 40436 10078 46 which which WDT 40436 10078 47 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10078 48 had have VBD 40436 10078 49 before before RB 40436 10078 50 been be VBN 40436 10078 51 convinced convince VBN 40436 10078 52 . . . 40436 10079 1 New new JJ 40436 10079 2 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 10079 3 suggested suggest VBD 40436 10079 4 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10079 5 to to IN 40436 10079 6 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10079 7 . . . 40436 10080 1 How how WRB 40436 10080 2 can can MD 40436 10080 3 the the DT 40436 10080 4 two two CD 40436 10080 5 objects object NNS 40436 10080 6 , , , 40436 10080 7 which which WDT 40436 10080 8 when when WRB 40436 10080 9 separate separate JJ 40436 10080 10 were be VBD 40436 10080 11 each each DT 40436 10080 12 one one CD 40436 10080 13 , , , 40436 10080 14 be be VB 40436 10080 15 made make VBN 40436 10080 16 _ _ NNP 40436 10080 17 two two CD 40436 10080 18 _ _ NNP 40436 10080 19 , , , 40436 10080 20 by by IN 40436 10080 21 the the DT 40436 10080 22 fact fact NN 40436 10080 23 that that IN 40436 10080 24 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10080 25 are be VBP 40436 10080 26 brought bring VBN 40436 10080 27 together together RB 40436 10080 28 ? ? . 40436 10081 1 What what WDT 40436 10081 2 alteration alteration NN 40436 10081 3 has have VBZ 40436 10081 4 happened happen VBN 40436 10081 5 in in IN 40436 10081 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10081 7 nature nature NN 40436 10081 8 ? ? . 40436 10082 1 Then then RB 40436 10082 2 again again RB 40436 10082 3 , , , 40436 10082 4 how how WRB 40436 10082 5 can can MD 40436 10082 6 the the DT 40436 10082 7 very very RB 40436 10082 8 same same JJ 40436 10082 9 fact fact NN 40436 10082 10 , , , 40436 10082 11 the the DT 40436 10082 12 change change NN 40436 10082 13 from from IN 40436 10082 14 one one CD 40436 10082 15 to to IN 40436 10082 16 two two CD 40436 10082 17 , , , 40436 10082 18 be be VB 40436 10082 19 produced produce VBN 40436 10082 20 by by IN 40436 10082 21 two two CD 40436 10082 22 causes cause NNS 40436 10082 23 perfectly perfectly RB 40436 10082 24 contrary contrary JJ 40436 10082 25 to to IN 40436 10082 26 each each DT 40436 10082 27 other other JJ 40436 10082 28 -- -- : 40436 10082 29 in in IN 40436 10082 30 the the DT 40436 10082 31 first first JJ 40436 10082 32 case case NN 40436 10082 33 , , , 40436 10082 34 by by IN 40436 10082 35 juxtaposition juxtaposition NN 40436 10082 36 -- -- : 40436 10082 37 in in IN 40436 10082 38 the the DT 40436 10082 39 last last JJ 40436 10082 40 case case NN 40436 10082 41 , , , 40436 10082 42 by by IN 40436 10082 43 bisection bisection NN 40436 10082 44 ? ? . 40436 10083 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10083 2 62 62 CD 40436 10083 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10083 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10083 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10083 6 62 62 CD 40436 10083 7 : : : 40436 10083 8 Sextus Sextus NNP 40436 10083 9 Empiricus Empiricus NNP 40436 10083 10 embodies embody VBZ 40436 10083 11 this this DT 40436 10083 12 argument argument NN 40436 10083 13 of of IN 40436 10083 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10083 15 among among IN 40436 10083 16 the the DT 40436 10083 17 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 10083 18 which which WDT 40436 10083 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10083 20 starts start VBZ 40436 10083 21 against against IN 40436 10083 22 the the DT 40436 10083 23 Dogmatists Dogmatists NNPS 40436 10083 24 , , , 40436 10083 25 adv adv NN 40436 10083 26 . . . 40436 10084 1 Mathematicos Mathematicos NNP 40436 10084 2 , , , 40436 10084 3 x. x. NNP 40436 10084 4 s. s. NNP 40436 10085 1 302 302 CD 40436 10085 2 - - HYPH 40436 10085 3 308 308 CD 40436 10085 4 . . . 40436 10085 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10086 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10086 2 Side side NN 40436 10086 3 - - HYPH 40436 10086 4 note note NN 40436 10086 5 : : : 40436 10086 6 Problems problem NNS 40436 10086 7 and and CC 40436 10086 8 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 10086 9 of of IN 40436 10086 10 which which WDT 40436 10086 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10086 12 first first RB 40436 10086 13 sought seek VBD 40436 10086 14 solution solution NN 40436 10086 15 . . . 40436 10086 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10087 1 That that DT 40436 10087 2 which which WDT 40436 10087 3 is be VBZ 40436 10087 4 interesting interesting JJ 40436 10087 5 here here RB 40436 10087 6 to to TO 40436 10087 7 note note VB 40436 10087 8 , , , 40436 10087 9 is be VBZ 40436 10087 10 the the DT 40436 10087 11 sort sort NN 40436 10087 12 of of IN 40436 10087 13 Cause cause NN 40436 10087 14 which which WDT 40436 10087 15 first first RB 40436 10087 16 gave give VBD 40436 10087 17 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10087 18 to to IN 40436 10087 19 the the DT 40436 10087 20 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10087 21 mind mind NN 40436 10087 22 of of IN 40436 10087 23 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10087 24 . . . 40436 10088 1 In in IN 40436 10088 2 the the DT 40436 10088 3 instance instance NN 40436 10088 4 of of IN 40436 10088 5 the the DT 40436 10088 6 growing grow VBG 40436 10088 7 youth youth NN 40436 10088 8 , , , 40436 10088 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10088 10 notes note VBZ 40436 10088 11 two two CD 40436 10088 12 distinct distinct JJ 40436 10088 13 facts fact NNS 40436 10088 14 , , , 40436 10088 15 the the DT 40436 10088 16 earliest early JJS 40436 10088 17 of of IN 40436 10088 18 which which WDT 40436 10088 19 is be VBZ 40436 10088 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10088 21 assuming assume VBG 40436 10088 22 certain certain JJ 40436 10088 23 other other JJ 40436 10088 24 facts fact NNS 40436 10088 25 as as IN 40436 10088 26 accompanying accompany VBG 40436 10088 27 conditions condition NNS 40436 10088 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10088 29 the the DT 40436 10088 30 cause cause NN 40436 10088 31 of of IN 40436 10088 32 the the DT 40436 10088 33 latest late JJS 40436 10088 34 . . . 40436 10089 1 But but CC 40436 10089 2 in in IN 40436 10089 3 most most JJS 40436 10089 4 of of IN 40436 10089 5 the the DT 40436 10089 6 other other JJ 40436 10089 7 instances instance NNS 40436 10089 8 , , , 40436 10089 9 the the DT 40436 10089 10 fact fact NN 40436 10089 11 is be VBZ 40436 10089 12 one one CD 40436 10089 13 which which WDT 40436 10089 14 does do VBZ 40436 10089 15 not not RB 40436 10089 16 admit admit VB 40436 10089 17 of of IN 40436 10089 18 explanation explanation NN 40436 10089 19 . . . 40436 10090 1 Comparisons comparison NNS 40436 10090 2 of of IN 40436 10090 3 eight eight CD 40436 10090 4 men man NNS 40436 10090 5 with with IN 40436 10090 6 ten ten CD 40436 10090 7 men man NNS 40436 10090 8 , , , 40436 10090 9 of of IN 40436 10090 10 a a DT 40436 10090 11 yard yard NN 40436 10090 12 with with IN 40436 10090 13 half half PDT 40436 10090 14 a a DT 40436 10090 15 yard yard NN 40436 10090 16 , , , 40436 10090 17 of of IN 40436 10090 18 a a DT 40436 10090 19 tall tall JJ 40436 10090 20 man man NN 40436 10090 21 with with IN 40436 10090 22 a a DT 40436 10090 23 short short JJ 40436 10090 24 man man NN 40436 10090 25 , , , 40436 10090 26 are be VBP 40436 10090 27 mental mental JJ 40436 10090 28 appreciations appreciation NNS 40436 10090 29 , , , 40436 10090 30 beliefs belief NNS 40436 10090 31 , , , 40436 10090 32 affirmations affirmation NNS 40436 10090 33 , , , 40436 10090 34 not not RB 40436 10090 35 capable capable JJ 40436 10090 36 of of IN 40436 10090 37 being be VBG 40436 10090 38 farther far RBR 40436 10090 39 explained explain VBN 40436 10090 40 or or CC 40436 10090 41 accounted account VBN 40436 10090 42 for for IN 40436 10090 43 : : : 40436 10090 44 if if IN 40436 10090 45 any any DT 40436 10090 46 one one CD 40436 10090 47 disputes dispute VBZ 40436 10090 48 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10090 49 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 10090 50 , , , 40436 10090 51 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10090 52 prove prove VBP 40436 10090 53 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10090 54 to to IN 40436 10090 55 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10090 56 , , , 40436 10090 57 by by IN 40436 10090 58 placing place VBG 40436 10090 59 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10090 60 in in IN 40436 10090 61 a a DT 40436 10090 62 situation situation NN 40436 10090 63 to to TO 40436 10090 64 make make VB 40436 10090 65 the the DT 40436 10090 66 comparison comparison NN 40436 10090 67 for for IN 40436 10090 68 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10090 69 , , , 40436 10090 70 or or CC 40436 10090 71 to to TO 40436 10090 72 go go VB 40436 10090 73 through through IN 40436 10090 74 the the DT 40436 10090 75 computation computation NN 40436 10090 76 which which WDT 40436 10090 77 establishes establish VBZ 40436 10090 78 the the DT 40436 10090 79 truth truth NN 40436 10090 80 of of IN 40436 10090 81 what what WP 40436 10090 82 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10090 83 affirm affirm VBP 40436 10090 84 . . . 40436 10091 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10091 2 is be VBZ 40436 10091 3 not not RB 40436 10091 4 the the DT 40436 10091 5 juxtaposition juxtaposition NN 40436 10091 6 of of IN 40436 10091 7 eight eight CD 40436 10091 8 men man NNS 40436 10091 9 which which WDT 40436 10091 10 makes make VBZ 40436 10091 11 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10091 12 to to TO 40436 10091 13 be be VB 40436 10091 14 eight eight CD 40436 10091 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10091 16 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10091 17 were be VBD 40436 10091 18 so so RB 40436 10091 19 just just RB 40436 10091 20 as as RB 40436 10091 21 much much RB 40436 10091 22 when when WRB 40436 10091 23 separated separate VBN 40436 10091 24 by by IN 40436 10091 25 ever ever RB 40436 10091 26 so so RB 40436 10091 27 wide wide RB 40436 10091 28 an an DT 40436 10091 29 interval interval NN 40436 10091 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10091 31 : : : 40436 10091 32 though though IN 40436 10091 33 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10091 34 may may MD 40436 10091 35 dispose dispose VB 40436 10091 36 or or CC 40436 10091 37 enable enable VB 40436 10091 38 the the DT 40436 10091 39 spectator spectator NN 40436 10091 40 to to TO 40436 10091 41 count count VB 40436 10091 42 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10091 43 as as IN 40436 10091 44 eight eight CD 40436 10091 45 . . . 40436 10092 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10092 2 may may MD 40436 10092 3 count count VB 40436 10092 4 the the DT 40436 10092 5 yard yard NN 40436 10092 6 measure measure NN 40436 10092 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10092 8 whether whether IN 40436 10092 9 actually actually RB 40436 10092 10 bisected bisect VBN 40436 10092 11 or or CC 40436 10092 12 not not RB 40436 10092 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10092 14 , , , 40436 10092 15 either either CC 40436 10092 16 as as IN 40436 10092 17 one one CD 40436 10092 18 yard yard NN 40436 10092 19 , , , 40436 10092 20 or or CC 40436 10092 21 as as IN 40436 10092 22 two two CD 40436 10092 23 half half NN 40436 10092 24 yards yard NNS 40436 10092 25 , , , 40436 10092 26 or or CC 40436 10092 27 as as IN 40436 10092 28 three three CD 40436 10092 29 feet foot NNS 40436 10092 30 , , , 40436 10092 31 or or CC 40436 10092 32 thirty thirty CD 40436 10092 33 - - HYPH 40436 10092 34 six six CD 40436 10092 35 inches inch NNS 40436 10092 36 . . . 40436 10093 1 Whether whether IN 40436 10093 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10093 3 be be VB 40436 10093 4 one one CD 40436 10093 5 , , , 40436 10093 6 or or CC 40436 10093 7 two two CD 40436 10093 8 , , , 40436 10093 9 or or CC 40436 10093 10 three three CD 40436 10093 11 , , , 40436 10093 12 depends depend VBZ 40436 10093 13 upon upon IN 40436 10093 14 the the DT 40436 10093 15 substantive substantive NN 40436 10093 16 which which WDT 40436 10093 17 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10093 18 choose choose VBP 40436 10093 19 to to TO 40436 10093 20 attach attach VB 40436 10093 21 to to IN 40436 10093 22 the the DT 40436 10093 23 numeral numeral JJ 40436 10093 24 , , , 40436 10093 25 or or CC 40436 10093 26 upon upon IN 40436 10093 27 the the DT 40436 10093 28 comparison comparison NN 40436 10093 29 which which WDT 40436 10093 30 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10093 31 make make VBP 40436 10093 32 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10093 33 the the DT 40436 10093 34 unit unit NN 40436 10093 35 which which WDT 40436 10093 36 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10093 37 select select VBP 40436 10093 38 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10093 39 on on IN 40436 10093 40 the the DT 40436 10093 41 particular particular JJ 40436 10093 42 occasion occasion NN 40436 10093 43 . . . 40436 10094 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10094 2 Side side NN 40436 10094 3 - - HYPH 40436 10094 4 note note NN 40436 10094 5 : : : 40436 10094 6 Expectations expectation NNS 40436 10094 7 entertained entertain VBN 40436 10094 8 by by IN 40436 10094 9 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10094 10 from from IN 40436 10094 11 the the DT 40436 10094 12 treatise treatise NN 40436 10094 13 of of IN 40436 10094 14 Anaxagoras anaxagora NNS 40436 10094 15 . . . 40436 10095 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10095 2 disappointment disappointment NN 40436 10095 3 . . . 40436 10096 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10096 2 distinction distinction NN 40436 10096 3 between between IN 40436 10096 4 causes cause NNS 40436 10096 5 and and CC 40436 10096 6 co co NNS 40436 10096 7 - - NNS 40436 10096 8 efficients efficient NNS 40436 10096 9 . . . 40436 10096 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10097 1 With with IN 40436 10097 2 this this DT 40436 10097 3 description description NN 40436 10097 4 of of IN 40436 10097 5 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10097 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10097 7 grew grow VBD 40436 10097 8 dissatisfied dissatisfy VBN 40436 10097 9 when when WRB 40436 10097 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10097 11 extended extend VBD 40436 10097 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10097 13 enquiries enquiry NNS 40436 10097 14 into into IN 40436 10097 15 physical physical JJ 40436 10097 16 and and CC 40436 10097 17 physiological physiological JJ 40436 10097 18 problems problem NNS 40436 10097 19 . . . 40436 10098 1 Is be VBZ 40436 10098 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10098 3 the the DT 40436 10098 4 blood blood NN 40436 10098 5 , , , 40436 10098 6 or or CC 40436 10098 7 air air NN 40436 10098 8 , , , 40436 10098 9 or or CC 40436 10098 10 fire fire NN 40436 10098 11 , , , 40436 10098 12 whereby whereby WRB 40436 10098 13 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10098 14 think think VBP 40436 10098 15 ? ? . 40436 10099 1 and and CC 40436 10099 2 such such JJ 40436 10099 3 like like JJ 40436 10099 4 questions question NNS 40436 10099 5 . . . 40436 10100 1 Such such JJ 40436 10100 2 enquiries enquiry NNS 40436 10100 3 -- -- : 40436 10100 4 into into IN 40436 10100 5 the the DT 40436 10100 6 physical physical JJ 40436 10100 7 conditions condition NNS 40436 10100 8 of of IN 40436 10100 9 mental mental JJ 40436 10100 10 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10100 11 -- -- : 40436 10100 12 did do VBD 40436 10100 13 really really RB 40436 10100 14 admit admit VB 40436 10100 15 of of IN 40436 10100 16 some some DT 40436 10100 17 answer answer NN 40436 10100 18 , , , 40436 10100 19 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 10100 20 , , , 40436 10100 21 or or CC 40436 10100 22 negative negative JJ 40436 10100 23 . . . 40436 10101 1 But but CC 40436 10101 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10101 3 does do VBZ 40436 10101 4 not not RB 40436 10101 5 tell tell VB 40436 10101 6 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10101 7 how how WRB 40436 10101 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10101 9 proceeded proceed VBD 40436 10101 10 in in IN 40436 10101 11 seeking seek VBG 40436 10101 12 for for IN 40436 10101 13 an an DT 40436 10101 14 answer answer NN 40436 10101 15 : : : 40436 10101 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10101 17 only only RB 40436 10101 18 says say VBZ 40436 10101 19 that that IN 40436 10101 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10101 21 failed fail VBD 40436 10101 22 so so RB 40436 10101 23 completely completely RB 40436 10101 24 , , , 40436 10101 25 as as IN 40436 10101 26 even even RB 40436 10101 27 to to TO 40436 10101 28 be be VB 40436 10101 29 disabused disabuse VBN 40436 10101 30 of of IN 40436 10101 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10101 32 supposed suppose VBN 40436 10101 33 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 10101 34 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10101 35 . . . 40436 10102 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10102 2 was be VBD 40436 10102 3 in in IN 40436 10102 4 this this DT 40436 10102 5 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 10102 6 when when WRB 40436 10102 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10102 8 first first RB 40436 10102 9 heard hear VBD 40436 10102 10 of of IN 40436 10102 11 the the DT 40436 10102 12 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10102 13 of of IN 40436 10102 14 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10102 15 . . . 40436 10103 1 " " `` 40436 10103 2 _ _ NNP 40436 10103 3 Nous Nous NNP 40436 10103 4 _ _ NNP 40436 10103 5 or or CC 40436 10103 6 Reason Reason NNP 40436 10103 7 is be VBZ 40436 10103 8 the the DT 40436 10103 9 regulator regulator NN 40436 10103 10 and and CC 40436 10103 11 the the DT 40436 10103 12 cause cause NN 40436 10103 13 of of IN 40436 10103 14 all all DT 40436 10103 15 things thing NNS 40436 10103 16 . . . 40436 10103 17 " " '' 40436 10104 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10104 2 interpreted interpret VBD 40436 10104 3 this this DT 40436 10104 4 to to TO 40436 10104 5 mean mean VB 40436 10104 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10104 7 what what WP 40436 10104 8 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10104 9 does do VBZ 40436 10104 10 not not RB 40436 10104 11 appear appear VB 40436 10104 12 that that IN 40436 10104 13 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10104 14 intended intend VBD 40436 10104 15 to to IN 40436 10104 16 assert)[63 assert)[63 NNP 40436 10104 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10104 18 that that IN 40436 10104 19 the the DT 40436 10104 20 Kosmos Kosmos NNP 40436 10104 21 was be VBD 40436 10104 22 an an DT 40436 10104 23 animal animal NN 40436 10104 24 or or CC 40436 10104 25 person[64 person[64 NN 40436 10104 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10104 27 having have VBG 40436 10104 28 mind mind NN 40436 10104 29 or or CC 40436 10104 30 Reason reason NN 40436 10104 31 analogous analogous JJ 40436 10104 32 to to IN 40436 10104 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10104 34 own own JJ 40436 10104 35 : : : 40436 10104 36 that that IN 40436 10104 37 this this DT 40436 10104 38 Reason reason NN 40436 10104 39 was be VBD 40436 10104 40 an an DT 40436 10104 41 agent agent NN 40436 10104 42 invested invest VBN 40436 10104 43 with with IN 40436 10104 44 full full JJ 40436 10104 45 power power NN 40436 10104 46 and and CC 40436 10104 47 perpetually perpetually RB 40436 10104 48 operative operative JJ 40436 10104 49 , , , 40436 10104 50 so so IN 40436 10104 51 as as IN 40436 10104 52 to to TO 40436 10104 53 regulate regulate VB 40436 10104 54 in in IN 40436 10104 55 the the DT 40436 10104 56 best good JJS 40436 10104 57 manner manner NN 40436 10104 58 all all PDT 40436 10104 59 the the DT 40436 10104 60 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10104 61 of of IN 40436 10104 62 the the DT 40436 10104 63 Kosmos Kosmos NNP 40436 10104 64 ; ; : 40436 10104 65 and and CC 40436 10104 66 that that IN 40436 10104 67 the the DT 40436 10104 68 general general JJ 40436 10104 69 cause cause NN 40436 10104 70 to to TO 40436 10104 71 be be VB 40436 10104 72 assigned assign VBN 40436 10104 73 for for IN 40436 10104 74 every every DT 40436 10104 75 thing thing NN 40436 10104 76 was be VBD 40436 10104 77 one one CD 40436 10104 78 and and CC 40436 10104 79 the the DT 40436 10104 80 same--"It same--"it NN 40436 10104 81 is be VBZ 40436 10104 82 best good JJS 40436 10104 83 thus thus RB 40436 10104 84 " " '' 40436 10104 85 ; ; : 40436 10104 86 requiring require VBG 40436 10104 87 that that IN 40436 10104 88 in in IN 40436 10104 89 each each DT 40436 10104 90 particular particular JJ 40436 10104 91 case case NN 40436 10104 92 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10104 93 should should MD 40436 10104 94 show show VB 40436 10104 95 _ _ NNP 40436 10104 96 how how WRB 40436 10104 97 _ _ NNP 40436 10104 98 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10104 99 was be VBD 40436 10104 100 for for IN 40436 10104 101 the the DT 40436 10104 102 best good JJS 40436 10104 103 . . . 40436 10105 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10105 2 took take VBD 40436 10105 3 the the DT 40436 10105 4 type type NN 40436 10105 5 of of IN 40436 10105 6 Reason reason NN 40436 10105 7 from from IN 40436 10105 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10105 9 own own JJ 40436 10105 10 volition volition NN 40436 10105 11 and and CC 40436 10105 12 movements movement NNS 40436 10105 13 ; ; , 40436 10105 14 supposing suppose VBG 40436 10105 15 that that IN 40436 10105 16 all all PDT 40436 10105 17 the the DT 40436 10105 18 agencies agency NNS 40436 10105 19 in in IN 40436 10105 20 the the DT 40436 10105 21 Kosmos Kosmos NNPS 40436 10105 22 were be VBD 40436 10105 23 stimulated stimulate VBN 40436 10105 24 or or CC 40436 10105 25 checked check VBN 40436 10105 26 by by IN 40436 10105 27 cosmical cosmical JJ 40436 10105 28 Reason Reason NNP 40436 10105 29 for for IN 40436 10105 30 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10105 31 purposes purpose NNS 40436 10105 32 , , , 40436 10105 33 as as IN 40436 10105 34 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10105 35 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10105 36 put put VBD 40436 10105 37 in in IN 40436 10105 38 motion motion NN 40436 10105 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10105 40 own own JJ 40436 10105 41 bodily bodily JJ 40436 10105 42 members member NNS 40436 10105 43 . . . 40436 10106 1 This this DT 40436 10106 2 conception conception NN 40436 10106 3 of of IN 40436 10106 4 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10106 5 , , , 40436 10106 6 borrowed borrow VBN 40436 10106 7 from from IN 40436 10106 8 the the DT 40436 10106 9 analogy analogy NN 40436 10106 10 of of IN 40436 10106 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10106 12 own own JJ 40436 10106 13 rational rational JJ 40436 10106 14 volition volition NN 40436 10106 15 , , , 40436 10106 16 appeared appear VBD 40436 10106 17 to to IN 40436 10106 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10106 19 very very RB 40436 10106 20 captivating captivating NN 40436 10106 21 , , , 40436 10106 22 though though IN 40436 10106 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10106 24 had have VBD 40436 10106 25 not not RB 40436 10106 26 been be VBN 40436 10106 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10106 28 own own JJ 40436 10106 29 first first JJ 40436 10106 30 conception conception NN 40436 10106 31 . . . 40436 10107 1 But but CC 40436 10107 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10107 3 found find VBD 40436 10107 4 that that IN 40436 10107 5 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10107 6 , , , 40436 10107 7 though though IN 40436 10107 8 proclaiming proclaim VBG 40436 10107 9 the the DT 40436 10107 10 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10107 11 as as IN 40436 10107 12 a a DT 40436 10107 13 principium principium NN 40436 10107 14 or or CC 40436 10107 15 initiatory initiatory JJ 40436 10107 16 influence influence NN 40436 10107 17 , , , 40436 10107 18 did do VBD 40436 10107 19 not not RB 40436 10107 20 make make VB 40436 10107 21 applications application NNS 40436 10107 22 of of IN 40436 10107 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10107 24 in in IN 40436 10107 25 detail detail NN 40436 10107 26 ; ; : 40436 10107 27 but but CC 40436 10107 28 assigned assign VBN 40436 10107 29 as as IN 40436 10107 30 causes cause NNS 40436 10107 31 , , , 40436 10107 32 in in IN 40436 10107 33 most most JJS 40436 10107 34 of of IN 40436 10107 35 the the DT 40436 10107 36 particular particular JJ 40436 10107 37 cases case NNS 40436 10107 38 , , , 40436 10107 39 those those DT 40436 10107 40 agencies agency NNS 40436 10107 41 which which WDT 40436 10107 42 Sokrates sokrate VBZ 40436 10107 43 considered consider VBD 40436 10107 44 to to TO 40436 10107 45 be be VB 40436 10107 46 subordinate subordinate JJ 40436 10107 47 and and CC 40436 10107 48 instrumental instrumental JJ 40436 10107 49 , , , 40436 10107 50 as as IN 40436 10107 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10107 52 own own JJ 40436 10107 53 muscles muscle NNS 40436 10107 54 were be VBD 40436 10107 55 to to IN 40436 10107 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10107 57 own own JJ 40436 10107 58 volition volition NN 40436 10107 59 . . . 40436 10108 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10108 2 will will MD 40436 10108 3 not not RB 40436 10108 4 allow allow VB 40436 10108 5 such such JJ 40436 10108 6 agencies agency NNS 40436 10108 7 to to TO 40436 10108 8 be be VB 40436 10108 9 called call VBN 40436 10108 10 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10108 11 : : : 40436 10108 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10108 13 says say VBZ 40436 10108 14 that that IN 40436 10108 15 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10108 16 are be VBP 40436 10108 17 only only RB 40436 10108 18 co co NNS 40436 10108 19 - - NNS 40436 10108 20 efficients efficient NNS 40436 10108 21 indispensable indispensable JJ 40436 10108 22 to to IN 40436 10108 23 the the DT 40436 10108 24 efficacy efficacy NN 40436 10108 25 of of IN 40436 10108 26 the the DT 40436 10108 27 single single JJ 40436 10108 28 and and CC 40436 10108 29 exclusive exclusive JJ 40436 10108 30 Cause cause NN 40436 10108 31 -- -- : 40436 10108 32 Reason reason NN 40436 10108 33 . . . 40436 10109 1 But but CC 40436 10109 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10109 3 tells tell VBZ 40436 10109 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10109 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10109 6 that that IN 40436 10109 7 most most JJS 40436 10109 8 enquirers enquirer NNS 40436 10109 9 considered consider VBD 40436 10109 10 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10109 11 as as IN 40436 10109 12 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10109 13 ; ; : 40436 10109 14 and and CC 40436 10109 15 that that IN 40436 10109 16 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10109 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10109 18 produced produce VBD 40436 10109 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10109 20 as as IN 40436 10109 21 such such JJ 40436 10109 22 . . . 40436 10110 1 Moreover moreover RB 40436 10110 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10110 3 shall shall MD 40436 10110 4 see see VB 40436 10110 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10110 6 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10110 7 in in IN 40436 10110 8 the the DT 40436 10110 9 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10110 10 , , , 40436 10110 11 while while IN 40436 10110 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10110 13 repeats repeat VBZ 40436 10110 14 this this DT 40436 10110 15 same same JJ 40436 10110 16 distinction distinction NN 40436 10110 17 between between IN 40436 10110 18 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10110 19 Efficient Efficient NNP 40436 10110 20 and and CC 40436 10110 21 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10110 22 Co co JJ 40436 10110 23 - - JJ 40436 10110 24 efficient efficient JJ 40436 10110 25 -- -- : 40436 10110 26 yet yet CC 40436 10110 27 treats treat VBZ 40436 10110 28 these these DT 40436 10110 29 latter latter JJ 40436 10110 30 as as IN 40436 10110 31 Causes cause NNS 40436 10110 32 also also RB 40436 10110 33 , , , 40436 10110 34 though though IN 40436 10110 35 inferior inferior JJ 40436 10110 36 in in IN 40436 10110 37 regularity regularity NN 40436 10110 38 and and CC 40436 10110 39 precision precision NN 40436 10110 40 to to IN 40436 10110 41 the the DT 40436 10110 42 Demiurgic Demiurgic NNP 40436 10110 43 Nous Nous NNP 40436 10110 44 . . . 40436 10111 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10111 2 65 65 CD 40436 10111 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10111 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10111 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10111 6 63 63 CD 40436 10111 7 : : : 40436 10111 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10111 9 have have VBP 40436 10111 10 given give VBN 40436 10111 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10111 12 in in IN 40436 10111 13 chap chap NNP 40436 10111 14 . . . 40436 10112 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10112 2 p. p. NN 40436 10112 3 48 48 CD 40436 10112 4 seq seq NN 40436 10112 5 . . . 40436 10112 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10113 1 an an DT 40436 10113 2 abridgment abridgment NN 40436 10113 3 and and CC 40436 10113 4 explanation explanation NN 40436 10113 5 of of IN 40436 10113 6 what what WP 40436 10113 7 seems seem VBZ 40436 10113 8 to to TO 40436 10113 9 have have VB 40436 10113 10 been be VBN 40436 10113 11 the the DT 40436 10113 12 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10113 13 of of IN 40436 10113 14 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10113 15 . . . 40436 10113 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10114 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10114 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10114 3 64 64 CD 40436 10114 4 : : : 40436 10114 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10114 6 , , , 40436 10114 7 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10114 8 , , , 40436 10114 9 p. p. NN 40436 10114 10 30 30 CD 40436 10114 11 D. D. NNP 40436 10114 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10114 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10114 14 : : : 40436 10114 15 to to TO 40436 10114 16 / / SYM 40436 10114 17 nde nde NNP 40436 10114 18 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10114 19 ko ko NNP 40436 10114 20 / / SYM 40436 10114 21 smon smon NNP 40436 10114 22 , , , 40436 10114 23 zô zô NNP 40436 10114 24 = = NFP 40436 10114 25 on on IN 40436 10114 26 e)/mpsuchon e)/mpsuchon NNP 40436 10114 27 e)/nnoun e)/nnoun NNP 40436 10114 28 te te NNP 40436 10114 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10114 30 , , , 40436 10114 31 & & CC 40436 10114 32 c. c. NNP 40436 10114 33 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10114 34 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10114 35 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10114 36 65 65 CD 40436 10114 37 : : : 40436 10114 38 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10114 39 , , , 40436 10114 40 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10114 41 , , , 40436 10114 42 p. p. NN 40436 10114 43 46 46 CD 40436 10114 44 C C NNP 40436 10114 45 - - HYPH 40436 10114 46 D. D. NNP 40436 10114 47 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10114 48 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10114 49 : : : 40436 10114 50 ai)/tia ai)/tia NNP 40436 10114 51 -- -- : 40436 10114 52 xunai xunai NNP 40436 10114 53 / / SYM 40436 10114 54 tia tia NNP 40436 10114 55 -- -- : 40436 10114 56 xummetai xummetai NNP 40436 10114 57 / / SYM 40436 10114 58 tia tia NNP 40436 10114 59 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10114 60 . . . 40436 10115 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10115 2 says say VBZ 40436 10115 3 that that IN 40436 10115 4 most most JJS 40436 10115 5 persons person NNS 40436 10115 6 considered consider VBD 40436 10115 7 the the DT 40436 10115 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10115 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10115 10 : : : 40436 10115 11 xunai xunai NNP 40436 10115 12 / / SYM 40436 10115 13 tia tia NNP 40436 10115 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10115 15 as as IN 40436 10115 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10115 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10115 18 : : : 40436 10115 19 ai)/tia ai)/tia NNP 40436 10115 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10115 21 . . . 40436 10116 1 And and CC 40436 10116 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10116 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10116 4 registers register VBZ 40436 10116 5 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10116 6 as as IN 40436 10116 7 such such JJ 40436 10116 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10116 9 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10116 10 , , , 40436 10116 11 p. p. NN 40436 10116 12 68 68 CD 40436 10116 13 E e NN 40436 10116 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10116 15 . . . 40436 10117 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10117 2 there there RB 40436 10117 3 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 40436 10117 4 the the DT 40436 10117 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10117 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10117 7 : : : 40436 10117 8 ai)/tia ai)/tia NNP 40436 10117 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10117 10 and and CC 40436 10117 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10117 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10117 13 : : : 40436 10117 14 xunai xunai NNP 40436 10117 15 / / SYM 40436 10117 16 tia tia NNP 40436 10117 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10117 18 as as IN 40436 10117 19 two two CD 40436 10117 20 different different JJ 40436 10117 21 sorts sort NNS 40436 10117 22 of of IN 40436 10117 23 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10117 24 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10117 25 : : : 40436 10117 26 ai)/tia ai)/tia NNP 40436 10117 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10117 28 , , , 40436 10117 29 the the DT 40436 10117 30 _ _ NNP 40436 10117 31 divine divine JJ 40436 10117 32 _ _ NNP 40436 10117 33 and and CC 40436 10117 34 the the DT 40436 10117 35 _ _ NNP 40436 10117 36 necessary necessary JJ 40436 10117 37 _ _ NNP 40436 10117 38 , , , 40436 10117 39 in in IN 40436 10117 40 a a DT 40436 10117 41 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 10117 42 passage passage NN 40436 10117 43 : : : 40436 10117 44 where where WRB 40436 10117 45 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10117 46 tells tell VBZ 40436 10117 47 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10117 48 that that IN 40436 10117 49 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10117 50 ought ought MD 40436 10117 51 to to TO 40436 10117 52 study study VB 40436 10117 53 the the DT 40436 10117 54 divine divine JJ 40436 10117 55 causes cause NNS 40436 10117 56 , , , 40436 10117 57 with with IN 40436 10117 58 a a DT 40436 10117 59 view view NN 40436 10117 60 to to IN 40436 10117 61 the the DT 40436 10117 62 happiness happiness NN 40436 10117 63 of of IN 40436 10117 64 life life NN 40436 10117 65 , , , 40436 10117 66 as as RB 40436 10117 67 far far RB 40436 10117 68 as as IN 40436 10117 69 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10117 70 nature nature NN 40436 10117 71 permits permit VBZ 40436 10117 72 -- -- : 40436 10117 73 and and CC 40436 10117 74 the the DT 40436 10117 75 necessary necessary JJ 40436 10117 76 causes cause NNS 40436 10117 77 for for IN 40436 10117 78 the the DT 40436 10117 79 sake sake NN 40436 10117 80 of of IN 40436 10117 81 the the DT 40436 10117 82 divine divine JJ 40436 10117 83 : : : 40436 10117 84 for for IN 40436 10117 85 that that DT 40436 10117 86 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10117 87 can can MD 40436 10117 88 not not RB 40436 10117 89 in in IN 40436 10117 90 any any DT 40436 10117 91 way way NN 40436 10117 92 apprehend apprehend NN 40436 10117 93 , , , 40436 10117 94 or or CC 40436 10117 95 understand understand VB 40436 10117 96 , , , 40436 10117 97 or or CC 40436 10117 98 get get VB 40436 10117 99 sight sight NN 40436 10117 100 of of IN 40436 10117 101 the the DT 40436 10117 102 divine divine JJ 40436 10117 103 causes cause NNS 40436 10117 104 alone alone RB 40436 10117 105 , , , 40436 10117 106 without without IN 40436 10117 107 the the DT 40436 10117 108 necessary necessary JJ 40436 10117 109 causes cause NNS 40436 10117 110 along along IN 40436 10117 111 with with IN 40436 10117 112 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10117 113 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10117 114 69 69 CD 40436 10117 115 A a NN 40436 10117 116 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10117 117 . . . 40436 10118 1 In in IN 40436 10118 2 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10118 3 , , , 40436 10118 4 pp pp NNP 40436 10118 5 . . . 40436 10119 1 47 47 CD 40436 10119 2 - - SYM 40436 10119 3 48 48 CD 40436 10119 4 , , , 40436 10119 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10119 6 find find VBP 40436 10119 7 again again RB 40436 10119 8 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10119 9 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10119 10 : : : 40436 10119 11 nou nou NNP 40436 10119 12 = = SYM 40436 10119 13 s s NN 40436 10119 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10119 15 and and CC 40436 10119 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10119 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10119 18 : : : 40436 10119 19 a)na a)na NNS 40436 10119 20 / / SYM 40436 10119 21 gkê gkê NNP 40436 10119 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10119 23 noted note VBD 40436 10119 24 as as IN 40436 10119 25 two two CD 40436 10119 26 distinct distinct JJ 40436 10119 27 sorts sort NNS 40436 10119 28 of of IN 40436 10119 29 causes cause NNS 40436 10119 30 co co JJ 40436 10119 31 - - NN 40436 10119 32 operating operate VBG 40436 10119 33 to to TO 40436 10119 34 produce produce VB 40436 10119 35 the the DT 40436 10119 36 four four CD 40436 10119 37 elements element NNS 40436 10119 38 . . . 40436 10120 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10120 2 is be VBZ 40436 10120 3 farther far RBR 40436 10120 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 10120 5 that that IN 40436 10120 6 Necessity Necessity NNP 40436 10120 7 is be VBZ 40436 10120 8 described describe VBN 40436 10120 9 as as IN 40436 10120 10 " " `` 40436 10120 11 the the DT 40436 10120 12 wandering wandering NN 40436 10120 13 or or CC 40436 10120 14 irregular irregular JJ 40436 10120 15 description description NN 40436 10120 16 of of IN 40436 10120 17 Cause"--[Greek Cause"--[Greek NNP 40436 10120 18 : : : 40436 10120 19 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10120 20 tê tê NNP 40436 10120 21 = = SYM 40436 10120 22 s s NNP 40436 10120 23 planôme planôme NN 40436 10120 24 / / SYM 40436 10120 25 nês nês NNP 40436 10120 26 ei)=dos ei)=dos CD 40436 10120 27 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10120 28 / / SYM 40436 10120 29 as as IN 40436 10120 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10120 31 . . . 40436 10121 1 Eros ero NNS 40436 10121 2 and and CC 40436 10121 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10121 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10121 5 : : : 40436 10121 6 A)na A)na NNP 40436 10121 7 / / SYM 40436 10121 8 gkê gkê NNP 40436 10121 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10121 10 are be VBP 40436 10121 11 joined join VBN 40436 10121 12 as as IN 40436 10121 13 co co NN 40436 10121 14 - - NN 40436 10121 15 operating operate VBG 40436 10121 16 -- -- : 40436 10121 17 in in IN 40436 10121 18 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 10121 19 , , , 40436 10121 20 pp pp NNP 40436 10121 21 . . . 40436 10122 1 195 195 CD 40436 10122 2 C C NNP 40436 10122 3 , , , 40436 10122 4 197 197 CD 40436 10122 5 B. B. NNP 40436 10122 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10123 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10123 2 Side side NN 40436 10123 3 - - HYPH 40436 10123 4 note note NN 40436 10123 5 : : : 40436 10123 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10123 7 imputes impute NNS 40436 10123 8 to to IN 40436 10123 9 Anaxagoras anaxagora NNS 40436 10123 10 the the DT 40436 10123 11 mistake mistake NN 40436 10123 12 of of IN 40436 10123 13 substituting substitute VBG 40436 10123 14 physical physical JJ 40436 10123 15 agencies agency NNS 40436 10123 16 in in IN 40436 10123 17 place place NN 40436 10123 18 of of IN 40436 10123 19 mental mental NN 40436 10123 20 . . . 40436 10124 1 This this DT 40436 10124 2 is be VBZ 40436 10124 3 the the DT 40436 10124 4 same same JJ 40436 10124 5 which which WDT 40436 10124 6 Aristophanes Aristophanes NNPS 40436 10124 7 and and CC 40436 10124 8 others other NNS 40436 10124 9 imputed impute VBD 40436 10124 10 to to IN 40436 10124 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10124 12 . . . 40436 10124 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10125 1 In in IN 40436 10125 2 truth truth NN 40436 10125 3 , , , 40436 10125 4 the the DT 40436 10125 5 complaint complaint NN 40436 10125 6 which which WDT 40436 10125 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10125 8 here here RB 40436 10125 9 raises raise VBZ 40436 10125 10 against against IN 40436 10125 11 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 10125 12 -- -- : 40436 10125 13 that that IN 40436 10125 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10125 15 assigned assign VBD 40436 10125 16 celestial celestial JJ 40436 10125 17 Rotation Rotation NNP 40436 10125 18 as as IN 40436 10125 19 the the DT 40436 10125 20 cause cause NN 40436 10125 21 of of IN 40436 10125 22 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10125 23 , , , 40436 10125 24 in in IN 40436 10125 25 place place NN 40436 10125 26 of of IN 40436 10125 27 a a DT 40436 10125 28 quasi quasi JJ 40436 10125 29 - - JJ 40436 10125 30 human human JJ 40436 10125 31 Reason reason NN 40436 10125 32 -- -- : 40436 10125 33 is be VBZ 40436 10125 34 just just RB 40436 10125 35 the the DT 40436 10125 36 same same JJ 40436 10125 37 as as IN 40436 10125 38 that that DT 40436 10125 39 which which WDT 40436 10125 40 Aristophanes aristophane NNS 40436 10125 41 in in IN 40436 10125 42 the the DT 40436 10125 43 Clouds Clouds NNPS 40436 10125 44 advances advance VBZ 40436 10125 45 against against IN 40436 10125 46 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10125 47 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10125 48 . . . 40436 10126 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10126 2 66 66 CD 40436 10126 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10126 4 The the DT 40436 10126 5 comic comic JJ 40436 10126 6 poet poet NN 40436 10126 7 accuses accuse VBZ 40436 10126 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10126 9 of of IN 40436 10126 10 displacing displace VBG 40436 10126 11 Zeus Zeus NNP 40436 10126 12 to to TO 40436 10126 13 make make VB 40436 10126 14 room room NN 40436 10126 15 for for IN 40436 10126 16 Dinos Dinos NNP 40436 10126 17 or or CC 40436 10126 18 Rotation Rotation NNP 40436 10126 19 . . . 40436 10127 1 According accord VBG 40436 10127 2 to to IN 40436 10127 3 the the DT 40436 10127 4 popular popular JJ 40436 10127 5 religious religious JJ 40436 10127 6 belief belief NN 40436 10127 7 , , , 40436 10127 8 all all DT 40436 10127 9 or or CC 40436 10127 10 most most JJS 40436 10127 11 of of IN 40436 10127 12 the the DT 40436 10127 13 agencies agency NNS 40436 10127 14 in in IN 40436 10127 15 Nature Nature NNP 40436 10127 16 were be VBD 40436 10127 17 personified personify VBN 40436 10127 18 , , , 40436 10127 19 or or CC 40436 10127 20 supposed suppose VBN 40436 10127 21 to to TO 40436 10127 22 be be VB 40436 10127 23 carried carry VBN 40436 10127 24 on on RP 40436 10127 25 by by IN 40436 10127 26 persons person NNS 40436 10127 27 -- -- : 40436 10127 28 Gods Gods NNP 40436 10127 29 , , , 40436 10127 30 Goddesses Goddesses NNPS 40436 10127 31 , , , 40436 10127 32 Dæmons Dæmons NNPS 40436 10127 33 , , , 40436 10127 34 Nymphs Nymphs NNP 40436 10127 35 , , , 40436 10127 36 & & CC 40436 10127 37 c. c. NNP 40436 10127 38 , , , 40436 10127 39 which which WDT 40436 10127 40 army army NN 40436 10127 41 of of IN 40436 10127 42 independent independent JJ 40436 10127 43 agents agent NNS 40436 10127 44 were be VBD 40436 10127 45 conceived conceive VBN 40436 10127 46 , , , 40436 10127 47 by by IN 40436 10127 48 some some DT 40436 10127 49 thinkers thinker NNS 40436 10127 50 , , , 40436 10127 51 as as IN 40436 10127 52 more more RBR 40436 10127 53 or or CC 40436 10127 54 less less RBR 40436 10127 55 systematised systematised JJ 40436 10127 56 and and CC 40436 10127 57 consolidated consolidate VBN 40436 10127 58 under under IN 40436 10127 59 the the DT 40436 10127 60 central central NNP 40436 10127 61 authority authority NN 40436 10127 62 of of IN 40436 10127 63 the the DT 40436 10127 64 Kosmos Kosmos NNP 40436 10127 65 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10127 66 . . . 40436 10128 1 The the DT 40436 10128 2 causes cause NNS 40436 10128 3 of of IN 40436 10128 4 natural natural JJ 40436 10128 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10128 6 , , , 40436 10128 7 especially especially RB 40436 10128 8 of of IN 40436 10128 9 the the DT 40436 10128 10 grand grand JJ 40436 10128 11 and and CC 40436 10128 12 terrible terrible JJ 40436 10128 13 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10128 14 , , , 40436 10128 15 were be VBD 40436 10128 16 supposed suppose VBN 40436 10128 17 agents agent NNS 40436 10128 18 , , , 40436 10128 19 conceived conceive VBN 40436 10128 20 after after IN 40436 10128 21 the the DT 40436 10128 22 model model NN 40436 10128 23 of of IN 40436 10128 24 man man NN 40436 10128 25 , , , 40436 10128 26 and and CC 40436 10128 27 assumed assume VBN 40436 10128 28 to to TO 40436 10128 29 be be VB 40436 10128 30 endowed endow VBN 40436 10128 31 with with IN 40436 10128 32 volition volition NN 40436 10128 33 , , , 40436 10128 34 force force NN 40436 10128 35 , , , 40436 10128 36 affections affection NNS 40436 10128 37 , , , 40436 10128 38 antipathies antipathy NNS 40436 10128 39 , , , 40436 10128 40 & & CC 40436 10128 41 c. c. NNP 40436 10128 42 : : : 40436 10128 43 some some DT 40436 10128 44 of of IN 40436 10128 45 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10128 46 visible visible JJ 40436 10128 47 , , , 40436 10128 48 such such JJ 40436 10128 49 as as IN 40436 10128 50 Helios Helios NNP 40436 10128 51 , , , 40436 10128 52 Selênê Selênê NNP 40436 10128 53 , , , 40436 10128 54 the the DT 40436 10128 55 Stars star NNS 40436 10128 56 ; ; : 40436 10128 57 others other NNS 40436 10128 58 generally generally RB 40436 10128 59 invisible invisible JJ 40436 10128 60 , , , 40436 10128 61 though though IN 40436 10128 62 showing show VBG 40436 10128 63 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10128 64 whenever whenever WRB 40436 10128 65 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10128 66 specially specially RB 40436 10128 67 pleased please VBD 40436 10128 68 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10128 69 . . . 40436 10129 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10129 2 67 67 CD 40436 10129 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10129 4 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10129 5 , , , 40436 10129 6 as as IN 40436 10129 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10129 8 see see VBP 40436 10129 9 by by IN 40436 10129 10 the the DT 40436 10129 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 10129 12 Apology Apology NNP 40436 10129 13 , , , 40436 10129 14 was be VBD 40436 10129 15 believed believe VBN 40436 10129 16 by by IN 40436 10129 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10129 18 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 10129 19 to to TO 40436 10129 20 deny deny VB 40436 10129 21 these these DT 40436 10129 22 animated animate VBN 40436 10129 23 agencies agency NNS 40436 10129 24 , , , 40436 10129 25 and and CC 40436 10129 26 to to TO 40436 10129 27 substitute substitute VB 40436 10129 28 instead instead RB 40436 10129 29 of of IN 40436 10129 30 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10129 31 inanimate inanimate VBP 40436 10129 32 forces force NNS 40436 10129 33 , , , 40436 10129 34 not not RB 40436 10129 35 put put VBN 40436 10129 36 in in IN 40436 10129 37 motion motion NN 40436 10129 38 by by IN 40436 10129 39 the the DT 40436 10129 40 quasi quasi JJ 40436 10129 41 - - JJ 40436 10129 42 human human JJ 40436 10129 43 attributes attribute NNS 40436 10129 44 of of IN 40436 10129 45 reason reason NN 40436 10129 46 , , , 40436 10129 47 feeling feeling NN 40436 10129 48 and and CC 40436 10129 49 volition volition NN 40436 10129 50 . . . 40436 10130 1 The the DT 40436 10130 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10130 3 in in IN 40436 10130 4 the the DT 40436 10130 5 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 10130 6 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10130 7 , , , 40436 10130 8 taken take VBN 40436 10130 9 at at IN 40436 10130 10 this this DT 40436 10130 11 second second JJ 40436 10130 12 stage stage NN 40436 10130 13 of of IN 40436 10130 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10130 15 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10130 16 wanderings wandering NNS 40436 10130 17 , , , 40436 10130 18 not not RB 40436 10130 19 only only RB 40436 10130 20 disclaims disclaim VBZ 40436 10130 21 such such PDT 40436 10130 22 a a DT 40436 10130 23 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10130 24 , , , 40436 10130 25 but but CC 40436 10130 26 protests protest NNS 40436 10130 27 against against IN 40436 10130 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10130 29 . . . 40436 10131 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10131 2 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 10131 3 no no DT 40436 10131 4 cause cause NN 40436 10131 5 except except IN 40436 10131 6 a a DT 40436 10131 7 Nous Nous NNP 40436 10131 8 or or CC 40436 10131 9 Reason reason NN 40436 10131 10 borrowed borrow VBN 40436 10131 11 by by IN 40436 10131 12 analogy analogy NN 40436 10131 13 from from IN 40436 10131 14 that that DT 40436 10131 15 of of IN 40436 10131 16 which which WDT 40436 10131 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10131 18 was be VBD 40436 10131 19 conscious conscious JJ 40436 10131 20 within within IN 40436 10131 21 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10131 22 , , , 40436 10131 23 choosing choose VBG 40436 10131 24 what what WP 40436 10131 25 was be VBD 40436 10131 26 best good JJS 40436 10131 27 for for IN 40436 10131 28 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10131 29 in in IN 40436 10131 30 every every DT 40436 10131 31 special special JJ 40436 10131 32 situation situation NN 40436 10131 33 . . . 40436 10132 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10132 2 68 68 CD 40436 10132 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10132 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10132 5 tells tell VBZ 40436 10132 6 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10132 7 however however RB 40436 10132 8 that that IN 40436 10132 9 most most JJS 40436 10132 10 of of IN 40436 10132 11 the the DT 40436 10132 12 contemporary contemporary JJ 40436 10132 13 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10132 14 dissented dissent VBD 40436 10132 15 from from IN 40436 10132 16 this this DT 40436 10132 17 point point NN 40436 10132 18 of of IN 40436 10132 19 view view NN 40436 10132 20 . . . 40436 10133 1 To to IN 40436 10133 2 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10133 3 , , , 40436 10133 4 such such JJ 40436 10133 5 inanimate inanimate JJ 40436 10133 6 agencies agency NNS 40436 10133 7 were be VBD 40436 10133 8 the the DT 40436 10133 9 sole sole JJ 40436 10133 10 and and CC 40436 10133 11 real real JJ 40436 10133 12 causes cause NNS 40436 10133 13 , , , 40436 10133 14 in in IN 40436 10133 15 one one CD 40436 10133 16 or or CC 40436 10133 17 other other JJ 40436 10133 18 of of IN 40436 10133 19 which which WDT 40436 10133 20 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10133 21 found find VBD 40436 10133 22 what what WP 40436 10133 23 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10133 24 thought think VBD 40436 10133 25 a a DT 40436 10133 26 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 10133 27 explanation explanation NN 40436 10133 28 . . . 40436 10134 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10134 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10134 3 66 66 CD 40436 10134 4 : : : 40436 10134 5 Aristophan Aristophan NNP 40436 10134 6 . . . 40436 10135 1 Nubes Nubes NNP 40436 10135 2 , , , 40436 10135 3 379 379 CD 40436 10135 4 - - SYM 40436 10135 5 815 815 CD 40436 10135 6 . . . 40436 10136 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10136 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10136 3 : : : 40436 10136 4 Di Di NNP 40436 10136 5 = = SYM 40436 10136 6 nos nos NNP 40436 10136 7 basileu basileu NNP 40436 10136 8 / / SYM 40436 10136 9 ei ei NNP 40436 10136 10 , , , 40436 10136 11 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10136 12 Di/ Di/ NNP 40436 10136 13 ' ' POS 40436 10136 14 e)xelêlakô e)xelêlakô NNP 40436 10136 15 / / SYM 40436 10136 16 s s NNP 40436 10136 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10136 18 . . . 40436 10137 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10137 2 find find VBP 40436 10137 3 Proklus proklus NN 40436 10137 4 making make VBG 40436 10137 5 this this DT 40436 10137 6 same same JJ 40436 10137 7 complaint complaint NN 40436 10137 8 against against IN 40436 10137 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10137 10 , , , 40436 10137 11 " " '' 40436 10137 12 that that IN 40436 10137 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10137 14 deserted desert VBD 40436 10137 15 theological theological JJ 40436 10137 16 _ _ NNP 40436 10137 17 principia principia NN 40436 10137 18 _ _ NNP 40436 10137 19 , , , 40436 10137 20 and and CC 40436 10137 21 indulged indulge VBD 40436 10137 22 too too RB 40436 10137 23 much much JJ 40436 10137 24 in in IN 40436 10137 25 physical physical NNP 40436 10137 26 reasonings"--[Greek reasonings"--[greek NN 40436 10137 27 : : : 40436 10137 28 tô tô NNP 40436 10137 29 = = SYM 40436 10137 30 n n NNP 40436 10137 31 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10137 32 theologikô theologikô NNP 40436 10137 33 = = SYM 40436 10137 34 n n NN 40436 10137 35 a)rchô a)rchô NNS 40436 10137 36 = = SYM 40436 10137 37 n n CC 40436 10137 38 a)phista a)phista NNP 40436 10137 39 / / SYM 40436 10137 40 menos menos NNP 40436 10137 41 , , , 40436 10137 42 toi toi NNP 40436 10137 43 = = SYM 40436 10137 44 s s NNP 40436 10137 45 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10137 46 phusikoi phusikoi NNP 40436 10137 47 = = SYM 40436 10137 48 s s NNP 40436 10137 49 lo lo NNP 40436 10137 50 / / SYM 40436 10137 51 gois gois NNP 40436 10137 52 pe pe NNP 40436 10137 53 / / SYM 40436 10137 54 ra ra NNP 40436 10137 55 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10137 56 de de NNP 40436 10137 57 / / SYM 40436 10137 58 ontos ontos NNP 40436 10137 59 e)ndiatri e)ndiatri NNP 40436 10137 60 / / SYM 40436 10137 61 bôn bôn NN 40436 10137 62 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10137 63 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10137 64 Proklus proklus JJ 40436 10137 65 ad ad NN 40436 10137 66 Timæum Timæum NNP 40436 10137 67 , , , 40436 10137 68 ii ii NNP 40436 10137 69 . . . 40436 10138 1 90 90 CD 40436 10138 2 E e NN 40436 10138 3 , , , 40436 10138 4 p. p. NN 40436 10138 5 212 212 CD 40436 10138 6 , , , 40436 10138 7 Schneider Schneider NNP 40436 10138 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10138 9 . . . 40436 10139 1 Pascal Pascal NNP 40436 10139 2 also also RB 40436 10139 3 expresses express VBZ 40436 10139 4 the the DT 40436 10139 5 like like JJ 40436 10139 6 displeasure displeasure NN 40436 10139 7 against against IN 40436 10139 8 the the DT 40436 10139 9 Cartesian cartesian JJ 40436 10139 10 theory theory NN 40436 10139 11 of of IN 40436 10139 12 the the DT 40436 10139 13 vortices vortex NNS 40436 10139 14 . . . 40436 10140 1 Descartes descarte NNS 40436 10140 2 recognised recognise VBD 40436 10140 3 God God NNP 40436 10140 4 as as IN 40436 10140 5 having have VBG 40436 10140 6 originally originally RB 40436 10140 7 established establish VBN 40436 10140 8 rotatory rotatory JJ 40436 10140 9 motion motion NN 40436 10140 10 among among IN 40436 10140 11 the the DT 40436 10140 12 atoms atom NNS 40436 10140 13 , , , 40436 10140 14 together together RB 40436 10140 15 with with IN 40436 10140 16 an an DT 40436 10140 17 equal equal JJ 40436 10140 18 , , , 40436 10140 19 unvarying unvarye VBG 40436 10140 20 quantity quantity NN 40436 10140 21 of of IN 40436 10140 22 motion motion NN 40436 10140 23 : : : 40436 10140 24 these these DT 40436 10140 25 two two CD 40436 10140 26 points point NNS 40436 10140 27 being be VBG 40436 10140 28 granted grant VBN 40436 10140 29 , , , 40436 10140 30 Descartes Descartes NNPS 40436 10140 31 considered consider VBD 40436 10140 32 that that IN 40436 10140 33 all all DT 40436 10140 34 cosmical cosmical JJ 40436 10140 35 facts fact NNS 40436 10140 36 and and CC 40436 10140 37 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10140 38 might may MD 40436 10140 39 be be VB 40436 10140 40 deduced deduce VBN 40436 10140 41 from from IN 40436 10140 42 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10140 43 . . . 40436 10141 1 " " `` 40436 10141 2 Sur Sur NNP 40436 10141 3 la la NNP 40436 10141 4 philosophie philosophie NN 40436 10141 5 de de NNP 40436 10141 6 Descartes Descartes NNP 40436 10141 7 , , , 40436 10141 8 Pascal Pascal NNP 40436 10141 9 était était NN 40436 10141 10 de de FW 40436 10141 11 son son NN 40436 10141 12 sentiment sentiment NNP 40436 10141 13 sur sur NNP 40436 10141 14 l'automate l'automate NNP 40436 10141 15 ; ; : 40436 10141 16 et et NN 40436 10141 17 n'en n'en NN 40436 10141 18 était était VBD 40436 10141 19 point point NN 40436 10141 20 sur sur NNP 40436 10141 21 la la FW 40436 10141 22 matière matière NNP 40436 10141 23 subtile subtile NN 40436 10141 24 , , , 40436 10141 25 do do VBP 40436 10141 26 nt not RB 40436 10141 27 il il NNP 40436 10141 28 se se NNP 40436 10141 29 moquait moquait NNP 40436 10141 30 fort fort NNP 40436 10141 31 . . . 40436 10142 1 Mais Mais NNP 40436 10142 2 il il NNP 40436 10142 3 ne ne NNP 40436 10142 4 pouvait pouvait NNP 40436 10142 5 souffrir souffrir NNP 40436 10142 6 sa sa NNP 40436 10142 7 manière manière NNP 40436 10142 8 d'expliquer d'expliquer NNP 40436 10142 9 la la NNP 40436 10142 10 formation formation NN 40436 10142 11 de de IN 40436 10142 12 toutes toute NNS 40436 10142 13 choses chose NNS 40436 10142 14 ; ; : 40436 10142 15 et et NNP 40436 10142 16 il il NNP 40436 10142 17 disait disait NNP 40436 10142 18 très très NNP 40436 10142 19 souvent,--Je souvent,--je ADD 40436 10142 20 ne ne NNP 40436 10142 21 puis puis NNP 40436 10142 22 pardonner pardonner NN 40436 10142 23 à à NNP 40436 10142 24 Descartes Descartes NNPS 40436 10142 25 : : : 40436 10142 26 il il NNP 40436 10142 27 voudrait voudrait NNP 40436 10142 28 bien bien NNP 40436 10142 29 , , , 40436 10142 30 dans dan NNS 40436 10142 31 toute toute VBP 40436 10142 32 sa sa NNP 40436 10142 33 philosophie philosophie NNP 40436 10142 34 , , , 40436 10142 35 pouvoir pouvoir NNP 40436 10142 36 se se FW 40436 10142 37 passer passer NNP 40436 10142 38 de de FW 40436 10142 39 Dieu Dieu NNP 40436 10142 40 : : : 40436 10142 41 mais mais NNP 40436 10142 42 il il NNP 40436 10142 43 n'a n'a NNP 40436 10142 44 pu pu NNP 40436 10142 45 s'empêcher s'empêcher NNP 40436 10142 46 de de NNP 40436 10142 47 lui lui NNP 40436 10142 48 accorder accorder NNP 40436 10142 49 une une NNP 40436 10142 50 chiquenaude chiquenaude NNP 40436 10142 51 pour pour NNP 40436 10142 52 mettre mettre NNP 40436 10142 53 le le NNP 40436 10142 54 monde monde NNP 40436 10142 55 en en NNP 40436 10142 56 mouvement mouvement NNP 40436 10142 57 : : : 40436 10142 58 après après NNP 40436 10142 59 cela cela NNP 40436 10142 60 , , , 40436 10142 61 il il NNP 40436 10142 62 n'a n'a RB 40436 10142 63 que que NNP 40436 10142 64 faire faire FW 40436 10142 65 de de FW 40436 10142 66 Dieu Dieu NNP 40436 10142 67 . . . 40436 10142 68 " " '' 40436 10143 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10143 2 Pascal Pascal NNP 40436 10143 3 , , , 40436 10143 4 Pensées Pensées NNP 40436 10143 5 , , , 40436 10143 6 ch ch NN 40436 10143 7 . . . 40436 10144 1 xi xi NNP 40436 10144 2 . . . 40436 10145 1 p. p. NN 40436 10145 2 237 237 CD 40436 10145 3 , , , 40436 10145 4 edition edition NN 40436 10145 5 de de IN 40436 10145 6 Louandre Louandre NNP 40436 10145 7 , , , 40436 10145 8 citation citation NN 40436 10145 9 from from IN 40436 10145 10 Mademoiselle Mademoiselle NNP 40436 10145 11 Périer Périer NNP 40436 10145 12 , , , 40436 10145 13 Paris Paris NNP 40436 10145 14 , , , 40436 10145 15 1854 1854 CD 40436 10145 16 . . . 40436 10145 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10146 1 Again again RB 40436 10146 2 , , , 40436 10146 3 Lord Lord NNP 40436 10146 4 Monboddo Monboddo NNP 40436 10146 5 , , , 40436 10146 6 in in IN 40436 10146 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10146 8 Ancient Ancient NNP 40436 10146 9 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 40436 10146 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10146 11 bk bk NNP 40436 10146 12 . . . 40436 10147 1 ii ii LS 40436 10147 2 . . . 40436 10148 1 ch ch NNP 40436 10148 2 . . . 40436 10149 1 19 19 CD 40436 10149 2 , , , 40436 10149 3 p. p. NN 40436 10149 4 276 276 CD 40436 10149 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10149 6 , , , 40436 10149 7 cites cite VBZ 40436 10149 8 these these DT 40436 10149 9 remarks remark NNS 40436 10149 10 of of IN 40436 10149 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10149 12 and and CC 40436 10149 13 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10149 14 on on IN 40436 10149 15 the the DT 40436 10149 16 deficiencies deficiency NNS 40436 10149 17 of of IN 40436 10149 18 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 10149 19 , , , 40436 10149 20 and and CC 40436 10149 21 expresses express VBZ 40436 10149 22 the the DT 40436 10149 23 like like JJ 40436 10149 24 censure censure NN 40436 10149 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10149 26 against against IN 40436 10149 27 the the DT 40436 10149 28 cosmical cosmical JJ 40436 10149 29 theories theory NNS 40436 10149 30 of of IN 40436 10149 31 Newton:--"Sir Newton:--"Sir NNP 40436 10149 32 Isaac Isaac NNP 40436 10149 33 puts put VBZ 40436 10149 34 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10149 35 in in IN 40436 10149 36 mind mind NN 40436 10149 37 of of IN 40436 10149 38 an an DT 40436 10149 39 ancient ancient JJ 40436 10149 40 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 10149 41 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10149 42 , , , 40436 10149 43 who who WP 40436 10149 44 maintained maintain VBD 40436 10149 45 , , , 40436 10149 46 as as IN 40436 10149 47 Sir Sir NNP 40436 10149 48 Isaac Isaac NNP 40436 10149 49 does do VBZ 40436 10149 50 , , , 40436 10149 51 that that DT 40436 10149 52 mind mind NN 40436 10149 53 was be VBD 40436 10149 54 the the DT 40436 10149 55 cause cause NN 40436 10149 56 of of IN 40436 10149 57 all all DT 40436 10149 58 things thing NNS 40436 10149 59 ; ; : 40436 10149 60 but but CC 40436 10149 61 when when WRB 40436 10149 62 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10149 63 came come VBD 40436 10149 64 to to TO 40436 10149 65 explain explain VB 40436 10149 66 the the DT 40436 10149 67 particular particular JJ 40436 10149 68 phænomena phænomena NN 40436 10149 69 of of IN 40436 10149 70 nature nature NN 40436 10149 71 , , , 40436 10149 72 instead instead RB 40436 10149 73 of of IN 40436 10149 74 having have VBG 40436 10149 75 recourse recourse NN 40436 10149 76 to to IN 40436 10149 77 mind mind NN 40436 10149 78 , , , 40436 10149 79 employed employ VBN 40436 10149 80 airs air NNS 40436 10149 81 and and CC 40436 10149 82 æthers æther NNS 40436 10149 83 , , , 40436 10149 84 subtle subtle JJ 40436 10149 85 spirits spirit NNS 40436 10149 86 and and CC 40436 10149 87 fluids fluid NNS 40436 10149 88 , , , 40436 10149 89 and and CC 40436 10149 90 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10149 91 know know VBP 40436 10149 92 not not RB 40436 10149 93 what what WP 40436 10149 94 -- -- : 40436 10149 95 in in IN 40436 10149 96 short short JJ 40436 10149 97 , , , 40436 10149 98 any any DT 40436 10149 99 thing thing NN 40436 10149 100 rather rather RB 40436 10149 101 than than IN 40436 10149 102 mind mind NN 40436 10149 103 : : : 40436 10149 104 a a DT 40436 10149 105 cause cause NN 40436 10149 106 which which WDT 40436 10149 107 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10149 108 admitted admit VBD 40436 10149 109 to to TO 40436 10149 110 exist exist VB 40436 10149 111 in in IN 40436 10149 112 the the DT 40436 10149 113 universe universe NN 40436 10149 114 ; ; , 40436 10149 115 but but CC 40436 10149 116 rather rather RB 40436 10149 117 than than IN 40436 10149 118 employ employ VB 40436 10149 119 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10149 120 , , , 40436 10149 121 had have VBD 40436 10149 122 recourse recourse VBN 40436 10149 123 to to IN 40436 10149 124 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 10149 125 causes cause NNS 40436 10149 126 , , , 40436 10149 127 of of IN 40436 10149 128 the the DT 40436 10149 129 existence existence NN 40436 10149 130 of of IN 40436 10149 131 which which WDT 40436 10149 132 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10149 133 could could MD 40436 10149 134 give give VB 40436 10149 135 no no DT 40436 10149 136 proof proof NN 40436 10149 137 . . . 40436 10150 1 The the DT 40436 10150 2 Tragic tragic JJ 40436 10150 3 poets poet NNS 40436 10150 4 of of IN 40436 10150 5 old old JJ 40436 10150 6 , , , 40436 10150 7 when when WRB 40436 10150 8 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10150 9 could could MD 40436 10150 10 not not RB 40436 10150 11 otherwise otherwise RB 40436 10150 12 untie untie VB 40436 10150 13 the the DT 40436 10150 14 knot knot NN 40436 10150 15 of of IN 40436 10150 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10150 17 fable fable JJ 40436 10150 18 , , , 40436 10150 19 brought bring VBD 40436 10150 20 down down RP 40436 10150 21 a a DT 40436 10150 22 god god NN 40436 10150 23 in in IN 40436 10150 24 a a DT 40436 10150 25 machine machine NN 40436 10150 26 , , , 40436 10150 27 who who WP 40436 10150 28 solved solve VBD 40436 10150 29 all all DT 40436 10150 30 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 10150 31 : : : 40436 10150 32 but but CC 40436 10150 33 such such JJ 40436 10150 34 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10150 35 as as IN 40436 10150 36 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10150 37 will will MD 40436 10150 38 not not RB 40436 10150 39 , , , 40436 10150 40 even even RB 40436 10150 41 when when WRB 40436 10150 42 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10150 43 can can MD 40436 10150 44 not not RB 40436 10150 45 do do VB 40436 10150 46 better well JJR 40436 10150 47 , , , 40436 10150 48 employ employ VB 40436 10150 49 _ _ NNP 40436 10150 50 mind mind NN 40436 10150 51 _ _ NNP 40436 10150 52 or or CC 40436 10150 53 divinity divinity NN 40436 10150 54 . . . 40436 10151 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10151 2 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10151 3 , , , 40436 10151 4 since since IN 40436 10151 5 Sir Sir NNP 40436 10151 6 Isaac Isaac NNP 40436 10151 7 's 's POS 40436 10151 8 time time NN 40436 10151 9 , , , 40436 10151 10 have have VBP 40436 10151 11 gone go VBN 40436 10151 12 on on RP 40436 10151 13 in in IN 40436 10151 14 the the DT 40436 10151 15 same same JJ 40436 10151 16 track track NN 40436 10151 17 , , , 40436 10151 18 and and CC 40436 10151 19 still still RB 40436 10151 20 , , , 40436 10151 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10151 22 think think VBP 40436 10151 23 , , , 40436 10151 24 farther farther RB 40436 10151 25 . . . 40436 10151 26 " " '' 40436 10152 1 Lord Lord NNP 40436 10152 2 Monboddo Monboddo NNP 40436 10152 3 speaks speak VBZ 40436 10152 4 with with IN 40436 10152 5 still still RB 40436 10152 6 greater great JJR 40436 10152 7 asperity asperity NN 40436 10152 8 about about IN 40436 10152 9 the the DT 40436 10152 10 Cartesian cartesian JJ 40436 10152 11 theory theory NN 40436 10152 12 , , , 40436 10152 13 making make VBG 40436 10152 14 a a DT 40436 10152 15 remark remark NN 40436 10152 16 on on IN 40436 10152 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10152 18 similar similar JJ 40436 10152 19 to to IN 40436 10152 20 what what WP 40436 10152 21 has have VBZ 40436 10152 22 been be VBN 40436 10152 23 above above RB 40436 10152 24 cited cite VBN 40436 10152 25 from from IN 40436 10152 26 Pascal Pascal NNP 40436 10152 27 . . . 40436 10153 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10153 2 See see VB 40436 10153 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10153 4 Dissertation dissertation NN 40436 10153 5 on on IN 40436 10153 6 the the DT 40436 10153 7 Newtonian Newtonian NNP 40436 10153 8 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 40436 10153 9 , , , 40436 10153 10 Appendix Appendix NNP 40436 10153 11 to to IN 40436 10153 12 Ancient Ancient NNP 40436 10153 13 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 40436 10153 14 , , , 40436 10153 15 pp pp NNP 40436 10153 16 . . . 40436 10154 1 498 498 CD 40436 10154 2 - - SYM 40436 10154 3 499 499 CD 40436 10154 4 . . . 40436 10154 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10154 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10155 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10155 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10155 3 67 67 CD 40436 10155 4 : : : 40436 10155 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10155 6 , , , 40436 10155 7 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10155 8 , , , 40436 10155 9 p. p. NN 40436 10155 10 41 41 CD 40436 10155 11 A. a. NN 40436 10156 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10156 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10156 3 : : : 40436 10156 4 pa pa NNP 40436 10156 5 / / SYM 40436 10156 6 ntes ntes NNP 40436 10156 7 o(/soi o(/soi NNP 40436 10156 8 te te NNP 40436 10156 9 peripolou peripolou NNP 40436 10156 10 = = SYM 40436 10156 11 si si NNP 40436 10156 12 phanerô phanerô NNP 40436 10156 13 = = SYM 40436 10156 14 s s NNP 40436 10156 15 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10156 16 o(/soi o(/soi NNP 40436 10156 17 phai phai NNP 40436 10156 18 / / SYM 40436 10156 19 nontai nontai NNP 40436 10156 20 kath kath NNP 40436 10156 21 ' ' '' 40436 10156 22 o(/son o(/son NNP 40436 10156 23 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10156 24 e)the e)the NNP 40436 10156 25 / / SYM 40436 10156 26 lôsi lôsi NNP 40436 10156 27 theoi\ theoi\ NNP 40436 10156 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10156 29 , , , 40436 10156 30 & & CC 40436 10156 31 c. c. NNP 40436 10156 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10156 33 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10156 34 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10156 35 68 68 CD 40436 10156 36 : : : 40436 10156 37 What what WP 40436 10156 38 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10156 39 understands understand VBZ 40436 10156 40 by by IN 40436 10156 41 the the DT 40436 10156 42 theory theory NN 40436 10156 43 of of IN 40436 10156 44 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10156 45 , , , 40436 10156 46 is be VBZ 40436 10156 47 evident evident JJ 40436 10156 48 from from IN 40436 10156 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10156 50 language language NN 40436 10156 51 -- -- : 40436 10156 52 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10156 53 , , , 40436 10156 54 pp pp NNP 40436 10156 55 . . . 40436 10157 1 98 98 CD 40436 10157 2 - - SYM 40436 10157 3 99 99 CD 40436 10157 4 . . . 40436 10158 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10158 2 understands understand VBZ 40436 10158 3 an an DT 40436 10158 4 indwelling indwell VBG 40436 10158 5 cosmical cosmical JJ 40436 10158 6 Reason Reason NNP 40436 10158 7 or or CC 40436 10158 8 Intelligence Intelligence NNP 40436 10158 9 , , , 40436 10158 10 deliberating deliberating NN 40436 10158 11 and and CC 40436 10158 12 choosing choosing NN 40436 10158 13 , , , 40436 10158 14 in in IN 40436 10158 15 each each DT 40436 10158 16 particular particular JJ 40436 10158 17 conjuncture conjuncture NN 40436 10158 18 , , , 40436 10158 19 what what WP 40436 10158 20 was be VBD 40436 10158 21 best good JJS 40436 10158 22 for for IN 40436 10158 23 the the DT 40436 10158 24 Kosmos Kosmos NNPS 40436 10158 25 ; ; : 40436 10158 26 just just RB 40436 10158 27 as as IN 40436 10158 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10158 29 own own JJ 40436 10158 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10158 31 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10158 32 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10158 33 Reason reason NN 40436 10158 34 deliberated deliberate VBD 40436 10158 35 and and CC 40436 10158 36 chose choose VBD 40436 10158 37 what what WP 40436 10158 38 was be VBD 40436 10158 39 best good JJS 40436 10158 40 for for IN 40436 10158 41 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10158 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10158 43 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10158 44 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10158 45 : : : 40436 10158 46 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 10158 47 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10158 48 belti belti NN 40436 10158 49 / / SYM 40436 10158 50 stou stou NNP 40436 10158 51 ai(re ai(re NNP 40436 10158 52 / / SYM 40436 10158 53 sei sei NNP 40436 10158 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10158 55 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10158 56 , , , 40436 10158 57 in in IN 40436 10158 58 consequence consequence NN 40436 10158 59 of of IN 40436 10158 60 the the DT 40436 10158 61 previous previous JJ 40436 10158 62 determination determination NN 40436 10158 63 of of IN 40436 10158 64 the the DT 40436 10158 65 Athenians Athenians NNPS 40436 10158 66 to to TO 40436 10158 67 condemn condemn VB 40436 10158 68 and and CC 40436 10158 69 punish punish VB 40436 10158 70 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10158 71 . . . 40436 10159 1 This this DT 40436 10159 2 point point NN 40436 10159 3 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 10159 4 attention attention NN 40436 10159 5 , , , 40436 10159 6 because because IN 40436 10159 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10159 8 is be VBZ 40436 10159 9 altogether altogether RB 40436 10159 10 different different JJ 40436 10159 11 from from IN 40436 10159 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10159 13 's 's POS 40436 10159 14 conception conception NN 40436 10159 15 of of IN 40436 10159 16 Nous Nous NNP 40436 10159 17 or or CC 40436 10159 18 Reason Reason NNP 40436 10159 19 in in IN 40436 10159 20 the the DT 40436 10159 21 Kosmos Kosmos NNP 40436 10159 22 : : : 40436 10159 23 in in IN 40436 10159 24 which which WDT 40436 10159 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10159 26 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 10159 27 no no DT 40436 10159 28 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 10159 29 , , , 40436 10159 30 no no DT 40436 10159 31 deliberation deliberation NN 40436 10159 32 , , , 40436 10159 33 no no DT 40436 10159 34 choice choice NN 40436 10159 35 , , , 40436 10159 36 no no DT 40436 10159 37 reference reference NN 40436 10159 38 to to IN 40436 10159 39 any any DT 40436 10159 40 special special JJ 40436 10159 41 situation situation NN 40436 10159 42 : : : 40436 10159 43 but but CC 40436 10159 44 a a DT 40436 10159 45 constant constant JJ 40436 10159 46 , , , 40436 10159 47 instinctive instinctive JJ 40436 10159 48 , , , 40436 10159 49 undeliberating undeliberating JJ 40436 10159 50 , , , 40436 10159 51 movement movement NN 40436 10159 52 towards towards IN 40436 10159 53 Good good JJ 40436 10159 54 as as IN 40436 10159 55 a a DT 40436 10159 56 determining determine VBG 40436 10159 57 End--_i.e End--_i.e NNP 40436 10159 58 . . . 40436 10159 59 _ _ IN 40436 10159 60 towards towards IN 40436 10159 61 the the DT 40436 10159 62 reproduction reproduction NN 40436 10159 63 and and CC 40436 10159 64 perpetuation perpetuation NN 40436 10159 65 of of IN 40436 10159 66 regular regular JJ 40436 10159 67 Forms form NNS 40436 10159 68 . . . 40436 10160 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 40436 10160 2 , , , 40436 10160 3 in in IN 40436 10160 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10160 5 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 40436 10160 6 der der IN 40436 10160 7 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 40436 10160 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10160 9 Part Part NNP 40436 10160 10 i. i. NNP 40436 10160 11 pp pp NN 40436 10160 12 . . . 40436 10161 1 355 355 CD 40436 10161 2 , , , 40436 10161 3 368 368 CD 40436 10161 4 - - SYM 40436 10161 5 369 369 CD 40436 10161 6 , , , 40436 10161 7 2nd 2nd JJ 40436 10161 8 edit edit NN 40436 10161 9 . . . 40436 10162 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10162 2 , , , 40436 10162 3 has have VBZ 40436 10162 4 given give VBN 40436 10162 5 very very RB 40436 10162 6 instructive instructive JJ 40436 10162 7 remarks remark NNS 40436 10162 8 , , , 40436 10162 9 in in IN 40436 10162 10 the the DT 40436 10162 11 spirit spirit NN 40436 10162 12 of of IN 40436 10162 13 the the DT 40436 10162 14 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP 40436 10162 15 Realism Realism NNP 40436 10162 16 , , , 40436 10162 17 both both CC 40436 10162 18 upon upon IN 40436 10162 19 the the DT 40436 10162 20 principle principle NN 40436 10162 21 announced announce VBN 40436 10162 22 by by IN 40436 10162 23 Anaxagoras anaxagora NNS 40436 10162 24 , , , 40436 10162 25 and and CC 40436 10162 26 upon upon IN 40436 10162 27 the the DT 40436 10162 28 manner manner NN 40436 10162 29 in in IN 40436 10162 30 which which WDT 40436 10162 31 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10162 32 is be VBZ 40436 10162 33 criticised criticise VBN 40436 10162 34 by by IN 40436 10162 35 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10162 36 in in IN 40436 10162 37 the the DT 40436 10162 38 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 10162 39 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10162 40 . . . 40436 10163 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 40436 10163 2 observes:-- observes:-- : 40436 10163 3 " " `` 40436 10163 4 Along along IN 40436 10163 5 with with IN 40436 10163 6 this this DT 40436 10163 7 principle principle NN 40436 10163 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10163 9 that that IN 40436 10163 10 of of IN 40436 10163 11 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 10163 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10163 13 there there EX 40436 10163 14 comes come VBZ 40436 10163 15 in in IN 40436 10163 16 the the DT 40436 10163 17 recognition recognition NN 40436 10163 18 of of IN 40436 10163 19 an an DT 40436 10163 20 Intelligence Intelligence NNP 40436 10163 21 , , , 40436 10163 22 or or CC 40436 10163 23 of of IN 40436 10163 24 a a DT 40436 10163 25 self self NN 40436 10163 26 - - HYPH 40436 10163 27 determining determine VBG 40436 10163 28 agency agency NN 40436 10163 29 which which WDT 40436 10163 30 was be VBD 40436 10163 31 wanting want VBG 40436 10163 32 before before RB 40436 10163 33 . . . 40436 10164 1 Herein Herein NNP 40436 10164 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10164 3 are be VBP 40436 10164 4 not not RB 40436 10164 5 to to TO 40436 10164 6 imagine imagine VB 40436 10164 7 thought thought NN 40436 10164 8 , , , 40436 10164 9 subjectively subjectively RB 40436 10164 10 considered consider VBN 40436 10164 11 : : : 40436 10164 12 when when WRB 40436 10164 13 thought thought NN 40436 10164 14 is be VBZ 40436 10164 15 spoken speak VBN 40436 10164 16 of of IN 40436 10164 17 , , , 40436 10164 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10164 19 are be VBP 40436 10164 20 apt apt JJ 40436 10164 21 to to IN 40436 10164 22 revert revert VB 40436 10164 23 to to IN 40436 10164 24 thought thought NN 40436 10164 25 as as IN 40436 10164 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10164 27 passes pass VBZ 40436 10164 28 in in IN 40436 10164 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10164 30 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 10164 31 : : : 40436 10164 32 but but CC 40436 10164 33 here here RB 40436 10164 34 , , , 40436 10164 35 on on IN 40436 10164 36 the the DT 40436 10164 37 contrary contrary NN 40436 10164 38 , , , 40436 10164 39 what what WP 40436 10164 40 is be VBZ 40436 10164 41 meant mean VBN 40436 10164 42 is be VBZ 40436 10164 43 , , , 40436 10164 44 the the DT 40436 10164 45 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10164 46 , , , 40436 10164 47 considered consider VBN 40436 10164 48 altogether altogether RB 40436 10164 49 objectively objectively RB 40436 10164 50 , , , 40436 10164 51 or or CC 40436 10164 52 Intelligence Intelligence NNP 40436 10164 53 as as IN 40436 10164 54 an an DT 40436 10164 55 effective effective JJ 40436 10164 56 agent agent NN 40436 10164 57 : : : 40436 10164 58 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10164 59 N.B. N.B. NNP 40436 10165 1 _ _ NNP 40436 10165 2 Intellectum Intellectum NNP 40436 10165 3 _ _ NNP 40436 10165 4 , , , 40436 10165 5 or or CC 40436 10165 6 _ _ NNP 40436 10165 7 Cogitatum_--not Cogitatum_--not NNP 40436 10165 8 _ _ NNP 40436 10165 9 Intellectio Intellectio NNP 40436 10165 10 _ _ NNP 40436 10165 11 , , , 40436 10165 12 or or CC 40436 10165 13 _ _ NNP 40436 10165 14 Cogitatio Cogitatio NNP 40436 10165 15 _ _ NNP 40436 10165 16 , , , 40436 10165 17 which which WDT 40436 10165 18 would would MD 40436 10165 19 mean mean VB 40436 10165 20 the the DT 40436 10165 21 conscious conscious JJ 40436 10165 22 process process NN 40436 10165 23 -- -- : 40436 10165 24 see see VB 40436 10165 25 this this DT 40436 10165 26 distinction distinction NN 40436 10165 27 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 10165 28 by by IN 40436 10165 29 Trendelenburg Trendelenburg NNP 40436 10165 30 ad ad NN 40436 10165 31 Aristot Aristot NNP 40436 10165 32 . . . 40436 10166 1 De De NNP 40436 10166 2 Animâ Animâ NNP 40436 10166 3 , , , 40436 10166 4 i. i. NNP 40436 10167 1 2 2 CD 40436 10167 2 , , , 40436 10167 3 5 5 CD 40436 10167 4 , , , 40436 10167 5 p. p. NN 40436 10167 6 219 219 CD 40436 10167 7 : : : 40436 10167 8 also also RB 40436 10167 9 Marbach Marbach NNP 40436 10167 10 , , , 40436 10167 11 Gesch Gesch NNP 40436 10167 12 . . . 40436 10168 1 der der NNP 40436 10168 2 Phil Phil NNP 40436 10168 3 . . . 40436 10169 1 s. s. NNP 40436 10169 2 54 54 CD 40436 10169 3 , , , 40436 10169 4 99 99 CD 40436 10169 5 not not RB 40436 10169 6 . . . 40436 10170 1 2 2 LS 40436 10170 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10170 3 : : : 40436 10170 4 as as IN 40436 10170 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10170 6 say say VBP 40436 10170 7 , , , 40436 10170 8 that that IN 40436 10170 9 there there EX 40436 10170 10 is be VBZ 40436 10170 11 reason reason NN 40436 10170 12 in in IN 40436 10170 13 the the DT 40436 10170 14 world world NN 40436 10170 15 , , , 40436 10170 16 or or CC 40436 10170 17 as as IN 40436 10170 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10170 19 speak speak VBP 40436 10170 20 of of IN 40436 10170 21 Genera Genera NNP 40436 10170 22 in in IN 40436 10170 23 nature nature NN 40436 10170 24 , , , 40436 10170 25 which which WDT 40436 10170 26 are be VBP 40436 10170 27 the the DT 40436 10170 28 Universal Universal NNP 40436 10170 29 . . . 40436 10171 1 The the DT 40436 10171 2 Genus Genus NNP 40436 10171 3 Animal Animal NNP 40436 10171 4 is be VBZ 40436 10171 5 the the DT 40436 10171 6 Essential Essential NNP 40436 10171 7 of of IN 40436 10171 8 the the DT 40436 10171 9 Dog Dog NNP 40436 10171 10 -- -- : 40436 10171 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10171 12 is be VBZ 40436 10171 13 the the DT 40436 10171 14 Dog Dog NNP 40436 10171 15 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10171 16 : : : 40436 10171 17 the the DT 40436 10171 18 laws law NNS 40436 10171 19 of of IN 40436 10171 20 nature nature NN 40436 10171 21 are be VBP 40436 10171 22 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10171 23 immanent immanent NN 40436 10171 24 Essence Essence NNP 40436 10171 25 . . . 40436 10172 1 Nature nature NN 40436 10172 2 is be VBZ 40436 10172 3 not not RB 40436 10172 4 formed form VBN 40436 10172 5 from from IN 40436 10172 6 without without IN 40436 10172 7 , , , 40436 10172 8 as as IN 40436 10172 9 men man NNS 40436 10172 10 construct construct VBP 40436 10172 11 a a DT 40436 10172 12 table table NN 40436 10172 13 : : : 40436 10172 14 the the DT 40436 10172 15 table table NN 40436 10172 16 is be VBZ 40436 10172 17 indeed indeed RB 40436 10172 18 constructed construct VBN 40436 10172 19 intelligently intelligently RB 40436 10172 20 , , , 40436 10172 21 but but CC 40436 10172 22 by by IN 40436 10172 23 an an DT 40436 10172 24 Intelligence Intelligence NNP 40436 10172 25 extraneous extraneous JJ 40436 10172 26 to to IN 40436 10172 27 this this DT 40436 10172 28 wooden wooden JJ 40436 10172 29 material material NN 40436 10172 30 . . . 40436 10173 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10173 2 is be VBZ 40436 10173 3 this this DT 40436 10173 4 extraneous extraneous JJ 40436 10173 5 form form NN 40436 10173 6 which which WDT 40436 10173 7 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10173 8 are be VBP 40436 10173 9 apt apt JJ 40436 10173 10 to to TO 40436 10173 11 think think VB 40436 10173 12 of of IN 40436 10173 13 as as IN 40436 10173 14 representing represent VBG 40436 10173 15 Intelligence Intelligence NNP 40436 10173 16 , , , 40436 10173 17 when when WRB 40436 10173 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10173 19 hear hear VBP 40436 10173 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10173 21 talked talk VBD 40436 10173 22 of of IN 40436 10173 23 : : : 40436 10173 24 but but CC 40436 10173 25 what what WP 40436 10173 26 is be VBZ 40436 10173 27 really really RB 40436 10173 28 meant mean VBN 40436 10173 29 is be VBZ 40436 10173 30 , , , 40436 10173 31 the the DT 40436 10173 32 Universal Universal NNP 40436 10173 33 -- -- : 40436 10173 34 the the DT 40436 10173 35 immanent immanent NN 40436 10173 36 nature nature NN 40436 10173 37 of of IN 40436 10173 38 the the DT 40436 10173 39 object object NN 40436 10173 40 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10173 41 . . . 40436 10174 1 The the DT 40436 10174 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10174 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10174 4 : : : 40436 10174 5 Nou Nou NNP 40436 10174 6 = = SYM 40436 10174 7 s s NN 40436 10174 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10174 9 is be VBZ 40436 10174 10 not not RB 40436 10174 11 a a DT 40436 10174 12 thinking thinking NN 40436 10174 13 Being be VBG 40436 10174 14 without without IN 40436 10174 15 , , , 40436 10174 16 which which WDT 40436 10174 17 has have VBZ 40436 10174 18 arranged arrange VBN 40436 10174 19 the the DT 40436 10174 20 world world NN 40436 10174 21 : : : 40436 10174 22 by by IN 40436 10174 23 such such PDT 40436 10174 24 an an DT 40436 10174 25 interpretation interpretation NN 40436 10174 26 the the DT 40436 10174 27 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10174 28 of of IN 40436 10174 29 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 10174 30 would would MD 40436 10174 31 be be VB 40436 10174 32 quite quite RB 40436 10174 33 perverted pervert VBN 40436 10174 34 and and CC 40436 10174 35 deprived deprive VBN 40436 10174 36 of of IN 40436 10174 37 all all DT 40436 10174 38 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 10174 39 value value NN 40436 10174 40 . . . 40436 10175 1 For for IN 40436 10175 2 to to TO 40436 10175 3 suppose suppose VB 40436 10175 4 an an DT 40436 10175 5 individual individual NN 40436 10175 6 , , , 40436 10175 7 particular particular JJ 40436 10175 8 , , , 40436 10175 9 Something something NN 40436 10175 10 without without IN 40436 10175 11 , , , 40436 10175 12 is be VBZ 40436 10175 13 to to TO 40436 10175 14 descend descend VB 40436 10175 15 into into IN 40436 10175 16 the the DT 40436 10175 17 region region NN 40436 10175 18 of of IN 40436 10175 19 phantasms phantasm NNS 40436 10175 20 and and CC 40436 10175 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10175 22 dualism dualism NN 40436 10175 23 : : : 40436 10175 24 what what WP 40436 10175 25 is be VBZ 40436 10175 26 called call VBN 40436 10175 27 , , , 40436 10175 28 a a DT 40436 10175 29 thinking thinking NN 40436 10175 30 Being being NN 40436 10175 31 , , , 40436 10175 32 is be VBZ 40436 10175 33 not not RB 40436 10175 34 an an DT 40436 10175 35 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10175 36 , , , 40436 10175 37 but but CC 40436 10175 38 a a DT 40436 10175 39 Subject subject NN 40436 10175 40 . . . 40436 10176 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 40436 10176 2 , , , 40436 10176 3 what what WP 40436 10176 4 is be VBZ 40436 10176 5 really really RB 40436 10176 6 and and CC 40436 10176 7 truly truly RB 40436 10176 8 Universal universal JJ 40436 10176 9 is be VBZ 40436 10176 10 not not RB 40436 10176 11 for for IN 40436 10176 12 that that DT 40436 10176 13 reason reason NN 40436 10176 14 Abstract Abstract NNP 40436 10176 15 : : : 40436 10176 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10176 17 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 10176 18 property property NN 40436 10176 19 , , , 40436 10176 20 quâ quâ NNP 40436 10176 21 Universal Universal NNP 40436 10176 22 , , , 40436 10176 23 is be VBZ 40436 10176 24 to to TO 40436 10176 25 determine determine VB 40436 10176 26 in in IN 40436 10176 27 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10176 28 , , , 40436 10176 29 by by IN 40436 10176 30 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10176 31 , , , 40436 10176 32 and and CC 40436 10176 33 for for IN 40436 10176 34 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10176 35 , , , 40436 10176 36 the the DT 40436 10176 37 particular particular JJ 40436 10176 38 accompaniments accompaniment NNS 40436 10176 39 . . . 40436 10177 1 While while IN 40436 10177 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10177 3 carries carry VBZ 40436 10177 4 on on IN 40436 10177 5 this this DT 40436 10177 6 process process NN 40436 10177 7 of of IN 40436 10177 8 change change NN 40436 10177 9 , , , 40436 10177 10 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10177 11 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 10177 12 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10177 13 at at IN 40436 10177 14 the the DT 40436 10177 15 same same JJ 40436 10177 16 time time NN 40436 10177 17 as as IN 40436 10177 18 the the DT 40436 10177 19 Universal Universal NNP 40436 10177 20 , , , 40436 10177 21 always always RB 40436 10177 22 the the DT 40436 10177 23 same same JJ 40436 10177 24 ; ; : 40436 10177 25 this this DT 40436 10177 26 is be VBZ 40436 10177 27 a a DT 40436 10177 28 portion portion NN 40436 10177 29 of of IN 40436 10177 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10177 31 self self NN 40436 10177 32 - - HYPH 40436 10177 33 determining determine VBG 40436 10177 34 efficiency efficiency NN 40436 10177 35 . . . 40436 10177 36 " " '' 40436 10178 1 --What --What NNP 40436 10178 2 Hegel Hegel NNP 40436 10178 3 here here RB 40436 10178 4 adverts advert VBZ 40436 10178 5 to to TO 40436 10178 6 seems seem VBZ 40436 10178 7 identical identical JJ 40436 10178 8 with with IN 40436 10178 9 that that DT 40436 10178 10 which which WDT 40436 10178 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 10178 12 Henry Henry NNP 40436 10178 13 More More JJR 40436 10178 14 calls call VBZ 40436 10178 15 an an DT 40436 10178 16 Emanative Emanative NNP 40436 10178 17 Cause cause NN 40436 10178 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10178 19 Immortality immortality NN 40436 10178 20 of of IN 40436 10178 21 the the DT 40436 10178 22 Soul Soul NNP 40436 10178 23 , , , 40436 10178 24 ch ch NN 40436 10178 25 . . . 40436 10179 1 vi vi NNP 40436 10179 2 . . . 40436 10180 1 p. p. NN 40436 10180 2 18 18 CD 40436 10180 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10180 4 , , , 40436 10180 5 " " '' 40436 10180 6 the the DT 40436 10180 7 notion notion NN 40436 10180 8 of of IN 40436 10180 9 a a DT 40436 10180 10 thing thing NN 40436 10180 11 possible possible JJ 40436 10180 12 . . . 40436 10181 1 An an DT 40436 10181 2 Emanative Emanative NNP 40436 10181 3 Effect Effect NNP 40436 10181 4 is be VBZ 40436 10181 5 co co JJ 40436 10181 6 - - NN 40436 10181 7 existent existent NN 40436 10181 8 with with IN 40436 10181 9 the the DT 40436 10181 10 very very JJ 40436 10181 11 substance substance NN 40436 10181 12 of of IN 40436 10181 13 that that DT 40436 10181 14 which which WDT 40436 10181 15 is be VBZ 40436 10181 16 said say VBN 40436 10181 17 to to TO 40436 10181 18 be be VB 40436 10181 19 the the DT 40436 10181 20 Cause cause NN 40436 10181 21 thereof thereof RB 40436 10181 22 . . . 40436 10182 1 That that DT 40436 10182 2 which which WDT 40436 10182 3 _ _ NNP 40436 10182 4 emanes emane VBZ 40436 10182 5 _ _ NNP 40436 10182 6 , , , 40436 10182 7 if if IN 40436 10182 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10182 9 may may MD 40436 10182 10 so so RB 40436 10182 11 speak speak VB 40436 10182 12 , , , 40436 10182 13 is be VBZ 40436 10182 14 the the DT 40436 10182 15 same same JJ 40436 10182 16 in in IN 40436 10182 17 reality reality NN 40436 10182 18 with with IN 40436 10182 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10182 20 Emanative Emanative NNP 40436 10182 21 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10182 22 . . . 40436 10182 23 " " '' 40436 10183 1 Respecting respect VBG 40436 10183 2 the the DT 40436 10183 3 criticism criticism NN 40436 10183 4 of of IN 40436 10183 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10183 6 upon upon IN 40436 10183 7 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 10183 8 , , , 40436 10183 9 Hegel Hegel NNP 40436 10183 10 has have VBZ 40436 10183 11 further further JJ 40436 10183 12 acute acute JJ 40436 10183 13 remarks remark NNS 40436 10183 14 which which WDT 40436 10183 15 are be VBP 40436 10183 16 too too RB 40436 10183 17 long long JJ 40436 10183 18 to to TO 40436 10183 19 cite cite VB 40436 10183 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10183 21 p. p. NN 40436 10183 22 368 368 CD 40436 10183 23 seq seq NN 40436 10183 24 . . . 40436 10183 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10183 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10184 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10184 2 Side side NN 40436 10184 3 - - HYPH 40436 10184 4 note note NN 40436 10184 5 : : : 40436 10184 6 The the DT 40436 10184 7 supposed suppose VBN 40436 10184 8 theory theory NN 40436 10184 9 of of IN 40436 10184 10 Anaxagoras anaxagora NNS 40436 10184 11 can can MD 40436 10184 12 not not RB 40436 10184 13 be be VB 40436 10184 14 carried carry VBN 40436 10184 15 out out RP 40436 10184 16 , , , 40436 10184 17 either either CC 40436 10184 18 by by IN 40436 10184 19 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10184 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10184 21 or or CC 40436 10184 22 any any DT 40436 10184 23 one one NN 40436 10184 24 else else RB 40436 10184 25 . . . 40436 10185 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10185 2 turns turn VBZ 40436 10185 3 to to IN 40436 10185 4 general general JJ 40436 10185 5 words word NNS 40436 10185 6 , , , 40436 10185 7 and and CC 40436 10185 8 adopts adopt VBZ 40436 10185 9 the the DT 40436 10185 10 theory theory NN 40436 10185 11 of of IN 40436 10185 12 ideas idea NNS 40436 10185 13 . . . 40436 10185 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10186 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10186 2 is be VBZ 40436 10186 3 however however RB 40436 10186 4 singular singular JJ 40436 10186 5 , , , 40436 10186 6 that that IN 40436 10186 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10186 8 , , , 40436 10186 9 after after IN 40436 10186 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10186 11 has have VBZ 40436 10186 12 extolled extoll VBN 40436 10186 13 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10186 14 for for IN 40436 10186 15 enunciating enunciate VBG 40436 10186 16 a a DT 40436 10186 17 grand grand JJ 40436 10186 18 general general JJ 40436 10186 19 cause cause NN 40436 10186 20 , , , 40436 10186 21 and and CC 40436 10186 22 has have VBZ 40436 10186 23 blamed blame VBN 40436 10186 24 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10186 25 only only RB 40436 10186 26 for for IN 40436 10186 27 not not RB 40436 10186 28 making make VBG 40436 10186 29 application application NN 40436 10186 30 of of IN 40436 10186 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10186 32 in in IN 40436 10186 33 detail detail NN 40436 10186 34 , , , 40436 10186 35 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 10186 36 to to IN 40436 10186 37 state state NN 40436 10186 38 that that IN 40436 10186 39 neither neither CC 40436 10186 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10186 41 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10186 42 , , , 40436 10186 43 nor nor CC 40436 10186 44 any any DT 40436 10186 45 one one NN 40436 10186 46 else else RB 40436 10186 47 within within IN 40436 10186 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10186 49 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10186 50 , , , 40436 10186 51 could could MD 40436 10186 52 find find VB 40436 10186 53 the the DT 40436 10186 54 way way NN 40436 10186 55 of of IN 40436 10186 56 applying apply VBG 40436 10186 57 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10186 58 , , , 40436 10186 59 any any DT 40436 10186 60 more more RBR 40436 10186 61 than than IN 40436 10186 62 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10186 63 had have VBD 40436 10186 64 done do VBN 40436 10186 65 . . . 40436 10187 1 If if IN 40436 10187 2 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10187 3 had have VBD 40436 10187 4 failed fail VBN 40436 10187 5 , , , 40436 10187 6 no no DT 40436 10187 7 one one NN 40436 10187 8 else else RB 40436 10187 9 could could MD 40436 10187 10 do do VB 40436 10187 11 better well RBR 40436 10187 12 . . . 40436 10188 1 The the DT 40436 10188 2 facts fact NNS 40436 10188 3 before before IN 40436 10188 4 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10188 5 could could MD 40436 10188 6 not not RB 40436 10188 7 be be VB 40436 10188 8 reconciled reconcile VBN 40436 10188 9 , , , 40436 10188 10 by by IN 40436 10188 11 any any DT 40436 10188 12 way way NN 40436 10188 13 that that WDT 40436 10188 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10188 15 could could MD 40436 10188 16 devise devise VB 40436 10188 17 , , , 40436 10188 18 with with IN 40436 10188 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10188 20 assumed assumed JJ 40436 10188 21 principle principle NN 40436 10188 22 of of IN 40436 10188 23 rational rational JJ 40436 10188 24 directing directing NN 40436 10188 25 force force NN 40436 10188 26 , , , 40436 10188 27 or or CC 40436 10188 28 constant constant JJ 40436 10188 29 optimistic optimistic JJ 40436 10188 30 purpose purpose NN 40436 10188 31 , , , 40436 10188 32 inherent inherent JJ 40436 10188 33 in in IN 40436 10188 34 the the DT 40436 10188 35 Kosmos Kosmos NNP 40436 10188 36 . . . 40436 10189 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 10189 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10189 3 abandoned abandon VBD 40436 10189 4 this this DT 40436 10189 5 track track NN 40436 10189 6 , , , 40436 10189 7 and and CC 40436 10189 8 entered enter VBN 40436 10189 9 upon upon IN 40436 10189 10 another another DT 40436 10189 11 : : : 40436 10189 12 seeking seek VBG 40436 10189 13 a a DT 40436 10189 14 different different JJ 40436 10189 15 sort sort NN 40436 10189 16 of of RB 40436 10189 17 cause cause NN 40436 10189 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10189 19 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10189 20 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10189 21 : : : 40436 10189 22 tê tê NNP 40436 10189 23 = = SYM 40436 10189 24 s s NNP 40436 10189 25 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10189 26 / / SYM 40436 10189 27 as as IN 40436 10189 28 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10189 29 ei)=dos ei)=dos NFP 40436 10189 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10189 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10189 32 , , , 40436 10189 33 not not RB 40436 10189 34 by by IN 40436 10189 35 contemplation contemplation NN 40436 10189 36 of of IN 40436 10189 37 things thing NNS 40436 10189 38 , , , 40436 10189 39 but but CC 40436 10189 40 by by IN 40436 10189 41 propositions proposition NNS 40436 10189 42 and and CC 40436 10189 43 ratiocinative ratiocinative JJ 40436 10189 44 discourse discourse NN 40436 10189 45 . . . 40436 10190 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10190 2 now now RB 40436 10190 3 assumed assume VBD 40436 10190 4 as as IN 40436 10190 5 a a DT 40436 10190 6 principle principle NN 40436 10190 7 an an DT 40436 10190 8 universal universal JJ 40436 10190 9 axiom axiom NN 40436 10190 10 or or CC 40436 10190 11 proposition proposition NN 40436 10190 12 , , , 40436 10190 13 from from IN 40436 10190 14 which which WDT 40436 10190 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10190 16 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 10190 17 to to TO 40436 10190 18 deduce deduce VB 40436 10190 19 consequences consequence NNS 40436 10190 20 . . . 40436 10191 1 The the DT 40436 10191 2 principle principle NN 40436 10191 3 thus thus RB 40436 10191 4 laid lay VBD 40436 10191 5 down down RP 40436 10191 6 is be VBZ 40436 10191 7 , , , 40436 10191 8 That that IN 40436 10191 9 there there EX 40436 10191 10 exist exist VBP 40436 10191 11 substantial substantial JJ 40436 10191 12 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10191 13 -- -- : 40436 10191 14 universal universal JJ 40436 10191 15 Entia Entia NNP 40436 10191 16 . . . 40436 10192 1 Each each DT 40436 10192 2 of of IN 40436 10192 3 these these DT 40436 10192 4 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 10192 5 communicates communicate VBZ 40436 10192 6 or or CC 40436 10192 7 imparts impart VBZ 40436 10192 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10192 9 own own JJ 40436 10192 10 nature nature NN 40436 10192 11 to to IN 40436 10192 12 the the DT 40436 10192 13 particulars particular NNS 40436 10192 14 which which WDT 40436 10192 15 bear bear VBP 40436 10192 16 the the DT 40436 10192 17 same same JJ 40436 10192 18 name name NN 40436 10192 19 : : : 40436 10192 20 and and CC 40436 10192 21 such such JJ 40436 10192 22 communion communion NN 40436 10192 23 or or CC 40436 10192 24 participation participation NN 40436 10192 25 is be VBZ 40436 10192 26 the the DT 40436 10192 27 cause cause NN 40436 10192 28 why why WRB 40436 10192 29 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10192 30 are be VBP 40436 10192 31 what what WP 40436 10192 32 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10192 33 are be VBP 40436 10192 34 . . . 40436 10193 1 The the DT 40436 10193 2 cause cause NN 40436 10193 3 why why WRB 40436 10193 4 various various JJ 40436 10193 5 objects object NNS 40436 10193 6 are be VBP 40436 10193 7 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10193 8 or or CC 40436 10193 9 great great JJ 40436 10193 10 , , , 40436 10193 11 is be VBZ 40436 10193 12 , , , 40436 10193 13 because because IN 40436 10193 14 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10193 15 partake partake VBP 40436 10193 16 of of IN 40436 10193 17 the the DT 40436 10193 18 Self Self NNP 40436 10193 19 - - HYPH 40436 10193 20 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10193 21 or or CC 40436 10193 22 the the DT 40436 10193 23 Self self NN 40436 10193 24 - - HYPH 40436 10193 25 Great great JJ 40436 10193 26 : : : 40436 10193 27 the the DT 40436 10193 28 cause cause NN 40436 10193 29 why why WRB 40436 10193 30 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10193 31 are be VBP 40436 10193 32 two two CD 40436 10193 33 or or CC 40436 10193 34 three three CD 40436 10193 35 is be VBZ 40436 10193 36 , , , 40436 10193 37 because because IN 40436 10193 38 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10193 39 partake partake VBP 40436 10193 40 of of IN 40436 10193 41 the the DT 40436 10193 42 Dyad Dyad NNP 40436 10193 43 or or CC 40436 10193 44 the the DT 40436 10193 45 Triad Triad NNP 40436 10193 46 . . . 40436 10194 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10194 2 Side side NN 40436 10194 3 - - HYPH 40436 10194 4 note note NN 40436 10194 5 : : : 40436 10194 6 Vague vague JJ 40436 10194 7 and and CC 40436 10194 8 dissentient dissentient JJ 40436 10194 9 meanings meaning NNS 40436 10194 10 attached attach VBN 40436 10194 11 to to IN 40436 10194 12 the the DT 40436 10194 13 word word NN 40436 10194 14 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10194 15 . . . 40436 10195 1 That that DT 40436 10195 2 is be VBZ 40436 10195 3 a a DT 40436 10195 4 cause cause NN 40436 10195 5 , , , 40436 10195 6 to to IN 40436 10195 7 each each DT 40436 10195 8 man man NN 40436 10195 9 , , , 40436 10195 10 which which WDT 40436 10195 11 gives give VBZ 40436 10195 12 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10195 13 to to IN 40436 10195 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10195 15 inquisitive inquisitive JJ 40436 10195 16 feelings feeling NNS 40436 10195 17 . . . 40436 10195 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10196 1 Here here RB 40436 10196 2 then then RB 40436 10196 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10196 4 have have VBP 40436 10196 5 a a DT 40436 10196 6 third third JJ 40436 10196 7 stage stage NN 40436 10196 8 or or CC 40436 10196 9 variety variety NN 40436 10196 10 of of IN 40436 10196 11 belief belief NN 40436 10196 12 , , , 40436 10196 13 in in IN 40436 10196 14 the the DT 40436 10196 15 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10196 16 mind mind NN 40436 10196 17 of of IN 40436 10196 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10196 19 , , , 40436 10196 20 respecting respect VBG 40436 10196 21 Causes cause NNS 40436 10196 22 . . . 40436 10197 1 The the DT 40436 10197 2 self self NN 40436 10197 3 - - HYPH 40436 10197 4 existent existent NN 40436 10197 5 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10197 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10197 7 " " `` 40436 10197 8 propria propria NN 40436 10197 9 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 10197 10 supellex supellex NN 40436 10197 11 , , , 40436 10197 12 " " '' 40436 10197 13 to to TO 40436 10197 14 use use VB 40436 10197 15 the the DT 40436 10197 16 words word NNS 40436 10197 17 of of IN 40436 10197 18 Seneca[69 Seneca[69 NNP 40436 10197 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10197 20 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10197 21 are be VBP 40436 10197 22 postulated postulate VBN 40436 10197 23 as as IN 40436 10197 24 Causes cause NNS 40436 10197 25 : : : 40436 10197 26 and and CC 40436 10197 27 in in IN 40436 10197 28 this this DT 40436 10197 29 belief belief NN 40436 10197 30 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10197 31 at at IN 40436 10197 32 last last JJ 40436 10197 33 finds find NNS 40436 10197 34 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10197 35 . . . 40436 10198 1 But but CC 40436 10198 2 these these DT 40436 10198 3 Causative Causative NNP 40436 10198 4 Ideas Ideas NNPS 40436 10198 5 , , , 40436 10198 6 or or CC 40436 10198 7 Ideal Ideal NNP 40436 10198 8 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10198 9 , , , 40436 10198 10 though though IN 40436 10198 11 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 10198 12 to to IN 40436 10198 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10198 14 , , , 40436 10198 15 were be VBD 40436 10198 16 accepted accept VBN 40436 10198 17 by by IN 40436 10198 18 scarcely scarcely RB 40436 10198 19 any any DT 40436 10198 20 one one NN 40436 10198 21 else else RB 40436 10198 22 . . . 40436 10199 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 10199 2 were be VBD 40436 10199 3 transformed transform VBN 40436 10199 4 -- -- : 40436 10199 5 seemingly seemingly RB 40436 10199 6 even even RB 40436 10199 7 by by IN 40436 10199 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10199 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10199 10 before before IN 40436 10199 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10199 12 death death NN 40436 10199 13 , , , 40436 10199 14 into into IN 40436 10199 15 Ideal Ideal NNP 40436 10199 16 Numbers Numbers NNPS 40436 10199 17 , , , 40436 10199 18 products product NNS 40436 10199 19 of of IN 40436 10199 20 the the DT 40436 10199 21 One one NN 40436 10199 22 implicated implicate VBN 40436 10199 23 with with IN 40436 10199 24 Great great JJ 40436 10199 25 and and CC 40436 10199 26 Little little JJ 40436 10199 27 or or CC 40436 10199 28 the the DT 40436 10199 29 undefined undefined JJ 40436 10199 30 Dyad Dyad NNP 40436 10199 31 -- -- : 40436 10199 32 and and CC 40436 10199 33 still still RB 40436 10199 34 farther farther RB 40436 10199 35 transformed transform VBN 40436 10199 36 by by IN 40436 10199 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10199 38 successors successor NNS 40436 10199 39 Speusippus Speusippus NNP 40436 10199 40 and and CC 40436 10199 41 Xenokrates Xenokrates NNP 40436 10199 42 : : : 40436 10199 43 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10199 44 were be VBD 40436 10199 45 impugned impugn VBN 40436 10199 46 in in IN 40436 10199 47 every every DT 40436 10199 48 way way NN 40436 10199 49 , , , 40436 10199 50 and and CC 40436 10199 51 emphatically emphatically RB 40436 10199 52 rejected reject VBN 40436 10199 53 , , , 40436 10199 54 by by IN 40436 10199 55 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10199 56 . . . 40436 10200 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10200 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10200 3 69 69 CD 40436 10200 4 : : : 40436 10200 5 Seneca Seneca NNP 40436 10200 6 , , , 40436 10200 7 Epistol Epistol NNP 40436 10200 8 . . . 40436 10201 1 About about IN 40436 10201 2 this this DT 40436 10201 3 disposition disposition NN 40436 10201 4 , , , 40436 10201 5 manifested manifest VBN 40436 10201 6 by by IN 40436 10201 7 many many JJ 40436 10201 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10201 9 , , , 40436 10201 10 and and CC 40436 10201 11 in in IN 40436 10201 12 a a DT 40436 10201 13 particular particular JJ 40436 10201 14 manner manner NN 40436 10201 15 by by IN 40436 10201 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10201 17 , , , 40436 10201 18 to to TO 40436 10201 19 " " `` 40436 10201 20 embrace embrace VB 40436 10201 21 logical logical JJ 40436 10201 22 phantoms phantom NNS 40436 10201 23 as as IN 40436 10201 24 real real JJ 40436 10201 25 causes cause NNS 40436 10201 26 , , , 40436 10201 27 " " `` 40436 10201 28 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10201 29 transcribe transcribe VBP 40436 10201 30 a a DT 40436 10201 31 good good JJ 40436 10201 32 passage passage NN 40436 10201 33 from from IN 40436 10201 34 Malebranche Malebranche NNP 40436 10201 35 . . . 40436 10202 1 " " `` 40436 10202 2 Je je PRP 40436 10202 3 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10202 4 sens sen VBZ 40436 10202 5 encore encore NN 40436 10202 6 extrêmement extrêmement NN 40436 10202 7 porté porté NNP 40436 10202 8 à à NNP 40436 10202 9 dire dire JJ 40436 10202 10 que que NNP 40436 10202 11 cette cette NNP 40436 10202 12 colonne colonne NNP 40436 10202 13 est est NNP 40436 10202 14 dure dure VB 40436 10202 15 _ _ NNP 40436 10202 16 par par NN 40436 10202 17 sa sa NNP 40436 10202 18 nature nature NNP 40436 10202 19 _ _ NNP 40436 10202 20 ; ; : 40436 10202 21 ou ou NNP 40436 10202 22 bien bien NNP 40436 10202 23 que que NNP 40436 10202 24 les les NNP 40436 10202 25 petits petit NNS 40436 10202 26 liens lien NNS 40436 10202 27 do do VBP 40436 10202 28 nt not RB 40436 10202 29 sont sont VB 40436 10202 30 composés composés NNP 40436 10202 31 les les NNP 40436 10202 32 corps corps NNP 40436 10202 33 durs durs NNP 40436 10202 34 , , , 40436 10202 35 sont sont NNP 40436 10202 36 des des NNP 40436 10202 37 atômes atômes NNP 40436 10202 38 , , , 40436 10202 39 do do VBP 40436 10202 40 nt not RB 40436 10202 41 les les VB 40436 10202 42 parties party NNS 40436 10202 43 ne ne NNP 40436 10202 44 se se NNP 40436 10202 45 peuvent peuvent NNP 40436 10202 46 diviser diviser NNP 40436 10202 47 , , , 40436 10202 48 comme comme FW 40436 10202 49 étant étant JJ 40436 10202 50 les les FW 40436 10202 51 parties party NNS 40436 10202 52 _ _ NNP 40436 10202 53 essentieles essentiele NNS 40436 10202 54 _ _ NNP 40436 10202 55 et et NNP 40436 10202 56 dernières dernière VBZ 40436 10202 57 des des FW 40436 10202 58 corps corps FW 40436 10202 59 -- -- : 40436 10202 60 et et FW 40436 10202 61 qui qui NNP 40436 10202 62 sont sont NNP 40436 10202 63 _ _ NNP 40436 10202 64 essentiellement essentiellement NN 40436 10202 65 _ _ NNP 40436 10202 66 crochues crochue NNS 40436 10202 67 ou ou NNP 40436 10202 68 branchues branchue NNS 40436 10202 69 . . . 40436 10203 1 Mais Mais NNP 40436 10203 2 je je NNP 40436 10203 3 reconnois reconnois NNP 40436 10203 4 franchement franchement NNP 40436 10203 5 , , , 40436 10203 6 que que NNP 40436 10203 7 ce ce NNP 40436 10203 8 n'est n'est DT 40436 10203 9 point point NN 40436 10203 10 expliquer expliqu JJR 40436 10203 11 la la NNP 40436 10203 12 difficulté difficulté NNP 40436 10203 13 ; ; : 40436 10203 14 et et NNP 40436 10203 15 que que UH 40436 10203 16 , , , 40436 10203 17 quittant quittant JJ 40436 10203 18 les les NNP 40436 10203 19 préoccupations préoccupation NNS 40436 10203 20 et et FW 40436 10203 21 les les NNP 40436 10203 22 illusions illusions NNP 40436 10203 23 de de NNP 40436 10203 24 mes mes NNP 40436 10203 25 sens sens NNP 40436 10203 26 , , , 40436 10203 27 j'aurais j'aurais NNP 40436 10203 28 tort tort NNP 40436 10203 29 de de NNP 40436 10203 30 recourir recourir NNP 40436 10203 31 à à NNP 40436 10203 32 une une NNP 40436 10203 33 forme forme NN 40436 10203 34 abstraite abstraite NNP 40436 10203 35 , , , 40436 10203 36 et et NNP 40436 10203 37 d'_embrasser d'_embrasser . 40436 10203 38 un un NNP 40436 10203 39 fantôme fantôme NNP 40436 10203 40 de de NNP 40436 10203 41 logique logique NNP 40436 10203 42 _ _ NNP 40436 10203 43 pour pour NN 40436 10203 44 la la NNP 40436 10203 45 cause cause NNP 40436 10203 46 que que NNP 40436 10203 47 je je NNP 40436 10203 48 cherche cherche NNP 40436 10203 49 . . . 40436 10204 1 Je je PRP 40436 10204 2 veux veux NN 40436 10204 3 dire dire JJ 40436 10204 4 , , , 40436 10204 5 que que NNP 40436 10204 6 j'aurois j'aurois NNP 40436 10204 7 tort tort NNP 40436 10204 8 de de FW 40436 10204 9 conçevoir conçevoir NNP 40436 10204 10 , , , 40436 10204 11 comme comme NNP 40436 10204 12 quelque quelque NNP 40436 10204 13 chose choose VBD 40436 10204 14 de de FW 40436 10204 15 réel réel NNP 40436 10204 16 et et NNP 40436 10204 17 de de FW 40436 10204 18 distinct distinct NNP 40436 10204 19 , , , 40436 10204 20 l'idée l'idée NNP 40436 10204 21 vague vague FW 40436 10204 22 de de FW 40436 10204 23 _ _ NNP 40436 10204 24 nature nature NN 40436 10204 25 _ _ NNP 40436 10204 26 et et NNP 40436 10204 27 d'_essence d'_essence NNP 40436 10204 28 _ _ NNP 40436 10204 29 , , , 40436 10204 30 qui qui NNP 40436 10204 31 n'exprime n'exprime NNP 40436 10204 32 que que NNP 40436 10204 33 ce ce NNP 40436 10204 34 que que NNP 40436 10204 35 l'on l'on NNP 40436 10204 36 sait sait NN 40436 10204 37 : : : 40436 10204 38 et et NNP 40436 10204 39 de de NNP 40436 10204 40 prendre prendre NNP 40436 10204 41 ainsi ainsi NNP 40436 10204 42 une une NNP 40436 10204 43 forme forme NNP 40436 10204 44 abstraite abstraite NNP 40436 10204 45 et et NNP 40436 10204 46 universelle universelle NNP 40436 10204 47 , , , 40436 10204 48 comme comme VB 40436 10204 49 une une NNP 40436 10204 50 cause cause NNP 40436 10204 51 physique physique NNP 40436 10204 52 d'un d'un NNP 40436 10204 53 effet effet NNP 40436 10204 54 très très NNP 40436 10204 55 réel réel NNP 40436 10204 56 . . . 40436 10205 1 Car car NN 40436 10205 2 il il NNP 40436 10205 3 y y NNP 40436 10205 4 a a DT 40436 10205 5 deux deux JJ 40436 10205 6 choses chose NNS 40436 10205 7 do do VBP 40436 10205 8 nt not RB 40436 10205 9 je je PRP 40436 10205 10 ne ne NNP 40436 10205 11 saurais saurais IN 40436 10205 12 trop trop NNP 40436 10205 13 défier défier RBR 40436 10205 14 . . . 40436 10206 1 La La NNP 40436 10206 2 première première JJ 40436 10206 3 est est NNP 40436 10206 4 , , , 40436 10206 5 l'impression l'impression NNP 40436 10206 6 de de NNP 40436 10206 7 mes mes NNP 40436 10206 8 sens sens NNPS 40436 10206 9 : : : 40436 10206 10 et et NNP 40436 10206 11 l'autre l'autre FW 40436 10206 12 est est NNP 40436 10206 13 , , , 40436 10206 14 la la NNP 40436 10206 15 facilité facilité NNP 40436 10206 16 que que NNP 40436 10206 17 j'ai j'ai NNP 40436 10206 18 de de NNP 40436 10206 19 prendre prendre NNP 40436 10206 20 les les NNP 40436 10206 21 natures natures NNP 40436 10206 22 abstraites abstraite VBZ 40436 10206 23 et et FW 40436 10206 24 les les FW 40436 10206 25 idées idées NNP 40436 10206 26 générales générales NNP 40436 10206 27 de de NNP 40436 10206 28 logique logique NNP 40436 10206 29 , , , 40436 10206 30 pour pour VBP 40436 10206 31 celles celle NNS 40436 10206 32 qui qui VBP 40436 10206 33 sont sont NNP 40436 10206 34 réelles réelle VBZ 40436 10206 35 et et NNP 40436 10206 36 particulières particulière NNS 40436 10206 37 : : : 40436 10206 38 et et NN 40436 10206 39 je je UH 40436 10206 40 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10206 41 souviens souvien VBZ 40436 10206 42 d'avoir d'avoir NNP 40436 10206 43 été été NNP 40436 10206 44 plusieurs plusieurs NNP 40436 10206 45 fois fois NNP 40436 10206 46 séduit séduit NNP 40436 10206 47 par par NNP 40436 10206 48 ces ces NNP 40436 10206 49 deux deux FW 40436 10206 50 principes principe VBZ 40436 10206 51 d'erreur d'erreur NNP 40436 10206 52 . . . 40436 10206 53 " " '' 40436 10207 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10207 2 Malebranche Malebranche NNP 40436 10207 3 -- -- : 40436 10207 4 Recherche Recherche NNP 40436 10207 5 de de NNP 40436 10207 6 la la NNP 40436 10207 7 Vérité Vérité NNP 40436 10207 8 , , , 40436 10207 9 vol vol NNP 40436 10207 10 . . . 40436 10208 1 iii iii NNP 40436 10208 2 . . NNP 40436 10208 3 , , , 40436 10208 4 liv liv NNP 40436 10208 5 . . . 40436 10209 1 vi vi NNP 40436 10209 2 . . NNP 40436 10209 3 , , , 40436 10209 4 ch ch NNP 40436 10209 5 . . . 40436 10210 1 8 8 CD 40436 10210 2 , , , 40436 10210 3 p. p. NN 40436 10210 4 245 245 CD 40436 10210 5 , , , 40436 10210 6 ed ed NN 40436 10210 7 . . . 40436 10211 1 1772 1772 CD 40436 10211 2 . . . 40436 10211 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10211 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10212 1 The the DT 40436 10212 2 foregoing foregoing JJ 40436 10212 3 picture picture NN 40436 10212 4 given give VBN 40436 10212 5 by by IN 40436 10212 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10212 7 of of IN 40436 10212 8 the the DT 40436 10212 9 wanderings wandering NNS 40436 10212 10 of of IN 40436 10212 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10212 12 mind mind NN 40436 10212 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10212 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10212 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10212 16 : : : 40436 10212 17 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 10212 18 e)ma\s e)ma\s NNP 40436 10212 19 pla pla NNP 40436 10212 20 / / SYM 40436 10212 21 nas nas NNP 40436 10212 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10212 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10212 24 in in IN 40436 10212 25 search search NN 40436 10212 26 of of IN 40436 10212 27 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10212 28 , , , 40436 10212 29 is be VBZ 40436 10212 30 interesting interesting JJ 40436 10212 31 , , , 40436 10212 32 not not RB 40436 10212 33 only only RB 40436 10212 34 in in IN 40436 10212 35 reference reference NN 40436 10212 36 to to IN 40436 10212 37 the the DT 40436 10212 38 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10212 39 age age NN 40436 10212 40 , , , 40436 10212 41 but but CC 40436 10212 42 also also RB 40436 10212 43 to to IN 40436 10212 44 the the DT 40436 10212 45 process process NN 40436 10212 46 of of IN 40436 10212 47 speculation speculation NN 40436 10212 48 generally generally RB 40436 10212 49 . . . 40436 10213 1 Almost almost RB 40436 10213 2 every every DT 40436 10213 3 one one CD 40436 10213 4 talks talk NNS 40436 10213 5 of of IN 40436 10213 6 a a DT 40436 10213 7 Cause cause NN 40436 10213 8 as as IN 40436 10213 9 a a DT 40436 10213 10 word word NN 40436 10213 11 of of IN 40436 10213 12 the the DT 40436 10213 13 clearest clear JJS 40436 10213 14 meaning meaning NN 40436 10213 15 , , , 40436 10213 16 familiar familiar JJ 40436 10213 17 and and CC 40436 10213 18 understood understand VBN 40436 10213 19 by by IN 40436 10213 20 all all DT 40436 10213 21 hearers hearer NNS 40436 10213 22 . . . 40436 10214 1 There there EX 40436 10214 2 are be VBP 40436 10214 3 many many JJ 40436 10214 4 who who WP 40436 10214 5 represent represent VBP 40436 10214 6 the the DT 40436 10214 7 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10214 8 of of IN 40436 10214 9 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10214 10 as as IN 40436 10214 11 simple simple JJ 40436 10214 12 , , , 40436 10214 13 intuitive intuitive JJ 40436 10214 14 , , , 40436 10214 15 self self NN 40436 10214 16 - - HYPH 40436 10214 17 originated originate VBN 40436 10214 18 , , , 40436 10214 19 universal universal JJ 40436 10214 20 ; ; : 40436 10214 21 one one CD 40436 10214 22 and and CC 40436 10214 23 the the DT 40436 10214 24 same same JJ 40436 10214 25 in in IN 40436 10214 26 all all DT 40436 10214 27 minds mind NNS 40436 10214 28 . . . 40436 10215 1 These these DT 40436 10215 2 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10215 3 consider consider VBP 40436 10215 4 the the DT 40436 10215 5 maxim maxim NN 40436 10215 6 that that IN 40436 10215 7 every every DT 40436 10215 8 phenomenon phenomenon NN 40436 10215 9 must must MD 40436 10215 10 have have VB 40436 10215 11 a a DT 40436 10215 12 Cause cause NN 40436 10215 13 -- -- : 40436 10215 14 as as IN 40436 10215 15 self self NN 40436 10215 16 - - HYPH 40436 10215 17 evident evident JJ 40436 10215 18 , , , 40436 10215 19 known know VBN 40436 10215 20 _ _ NNP 40436 10215 21 à à NNP 40436 10215 22 priori priori VBP 40436 10215 23 _ _ NNP 40436 10215 24 apart apart RB 40436 10215 25 from from IN 40436 10215 26 experience experience NN 40436 10215 27 : : : 40436 10215 28 as as IN 40436 10215 29 something something NN 40436 10215 30 which which WDT 40436 10215 31 no no DT 40436 10215 32 one one NN 40436 10215 33 can can MD 40436 10215 34 help help VB 40436 10215 35 believing believe VBG 40436 10215 36 as as RB 40436 10215 37 soon soon RB 40436 10215 38 as as IN 40436 10215 39 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10215 40 is be VBZ 40436 10215 41 stated state VBN 40436 10215 42 to to IN 40436 10215 43 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10215 44 . . . 40436 10216 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10216 2 70 70 CD 40436 10216 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10216 4 The the DT 40436 10216 5 gropings groping NNS 40436 10216 6 of of IN 40436 10216 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10216 8 are be VBP 40436 10216 9 among among IN 40436 10216 10 the the DT 40436 10216 11 numerous numerous JJ 40436 10216 12 facts fact NNS 40436 10216 13 which which WDT 40436 10216 14 go go VBP 40436 10216 15 to to TO 40436 10216 16 refute refute VB 40436 10216 17 such such PDT 40436 10216 18 a a DT 40436 10216 19 theory theory NN 40436 10216 20 : : : 40436 10216 21 or or CC 40436 10216 22 at at IN 40436 10216 23 least least RBS 40436 10216 24 to to TO 40436 10216 25 show show VB 40436 10216 26 in in IN 40436 10216 27 what what WDT 40436 10216 28 sense sense NN 40436 10216 29 alone alone JJ 40436 10216 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10216 31 can can MD 40436 10216 32 be be VB 40436 10216 33 partially partially RB 40436 10216 34 admitted admit VBN 40436 10216 35 . . . 40436 10217 1 There there EX 40436 10217 2 is be VBZ 40436 10217 3 no no DT 40436 10217 4 fixed fixed JJ 40436 10217 5 , , , 40436 10217 6 positive positive JJ 40436 10217 7 , , , 40436 10217 8 universal universal JJ 40436 10217 9 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10217 10 , , , 40436 10217 11 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 10217 12 to to IN 40436 10217 13 the the DT 40436 10217 14 word word NN 40436 10217 15 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10217 16 . . . 40436 10218 1 There there EX 40436 10218 2 is be VBZ 40436 10218 3 a a DT 40436 10218 4 wide wide JJ 40436 10218 5 divergence divergence NN 40436 10218 6 , , , 40436 10218 7 as as IN 40436 10218 8 to to IN 40436 10218 9 the the DT 40436 10218 10 question question NN 40436 10218 11 what what WDT 40436 10218 12 a a DT 40436 10218 13 Cause cause NN 40436 10218 14 really really RB 40436 10218 15 is be VBZ 40436 10218 16 , , , 40436 10218 17 between between IN 40436 10218 18 different different JJ 40436 10218 19 ages age NNS 40436 10218 20 of of IN 40436 10218 21 the the DT 40436 10218 22 same same JJ 40436 10218 23 man man NN 40436 10218 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10218 25 exemplified exemplify VBN 40436 10218 26 in in IN 40436 10218 27 the the DT 40436 10218 28 case case NN 40436 10218 29 of of IN 40436 10218 30 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10218 31 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10218 32 : : : 40436 10218 33 much much RB 40436 10218 34 more more JJR 40436 10218 35 between between IN 40436 10218 36 different different JJ 40436 10218 37 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10218 38 at at IN 40436 10218 39 one one CD 40436 10218 40 time time NN 40436 10218 41 and and CC 40436 10218 42 another another DT 40436 10218 43 . . . 40436 10219 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10219 2 complains complain NNS 40436 10219 3 of of IN 40436 10219 4 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 10219 5 and and CC 40436 10219 6 other other JJ 40436 10219 7 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10219 8 for for IN 40436 10219 9 assigning assigning NN 40436 10219 10 as as IN 40436 10219 11 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10219 12 that that WDT 40436 10219 13 which which WDT 40436 10219 14 did do VBD 40436 10219 15 not not RB 40436 10219 16 truly truly RB 40436 10219 17 deserve deserve VB 40436 10219 18 the the DT 40436 10219 19 name name NN 40436 10219 20 : : : 40436 10219 21 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10219 22 also also RB 40436 10219 23 blames blame VBZ 40436 10219 24 the the DT 40436 10219 25 defective defective JJ 40436 10219 26 conceptions conception NNS 40436 10219 27 of of IN 40436 10219 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10219 29 predecessors predecessor NNS 40436 10219 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10219 31 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10219 32 included include VBD 40436 10219 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10219 34 on on IN 40436 10219 35 the the DT 40436 10219 36 same same JJ 40436 10219 37 subject subject NN 40436 10219 38 . . . 40436 10220 1 If if IN 40436 10220 2 there there EX 40436 10220 3 be be VB 40436 10220 4 an an DT 40436 10220 5 intuitive intuitive JJ 40436 10220 6 idea idea NN 40436 10220 7 corresponding correspond VBG 40436 10220 8 to to IN 40436 10220 9 the the DT 40436 10220 10 word word NN 40436 10220 11 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10220 12 , , , 40436 10220 13 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10220 14 must must MD 40436 10220 15 be be VB 40436 10220 16 a a DT 40436 10220 17 different different JJ 40436 10220 18 intuition intuition NN 40436 10220 19 in in IN 40436 10220 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10220 21 and and CC 40436 10220 22 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10220 23 -- -- : 40436 10220 24 in in IN 40436 10220 25 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10220 26 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10220 27 at at IN 40436 10220 28 one one CD 40436 10220 29 age age NN 40436 10220 30 and and CC 40436 10220 31 at at IN 40436 10220 32 another another DT 40436 10220 33 age age NN 40436 10220 34 : : : 40436 10220 35 in in IN 40436 10220 36 other other JJ 40436 10220 37 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10220 38 , , , 40436 10220 39 different different JJ 40436 10220 40 from from IN 40436 10220 41 both both DT 40436 10220 42 and and CC 40436 10220 43 from from IN 40436 10220 44 each each DT 40436 10220 45 other other JJ 40436 10220 46 . . . 40436 10221 1 The the DT 40436 10221 2 word word NN 40436 10221 3 is be VBZ 40436 10221 4 equivocal--[Greek equivocal--[greek CD 40436 10221 5 : : : 40436 10221 6 pollachô pollachô NNP 40436 10221 7 = = SYM 40436 10221 8 s s NNP 40436 10221 9 lego lego NNP 40436 10221 10 / / SYM 40436 10221 11 menon menon NNP 40436 10221 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10221 13 , , , 40436 10221 14 in in IN 40436 10221 15 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40436 10221 16 phrase phrase NN 40436 10221 17 -- -- : 40436 10221 18 men man NNS 40436 10221 19 use use VBP 40436 10221 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10221 21 familiarly familiarly RB 40436 10221 22 , , , 40436 10221 23 but but CC 40436 10221 24 vary vary VBP 40436 10221 25 much much JJ 40436 10221 26 in in IN 40436 10221 27 the the DT 40436 10221 28 thing thing NN 40436 10221 29 signified signify VBD 40436 10221 30 . . . 40436 10222 1 _ _ NNP 40436 10222 2 That that DT 40436 10222 3 _ _ NNP 40436 10222 4 is be VBZ 40436 10222 5 a a DT 40436 10222 6 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10222 7 , , , 40436 10222 8 to to IN 40436 10222 9 each each DT 40436 10222 10 man man NN 40436 10222 11 , , , 40436 10222 12 which which WDT 40436 10222 13 gives give VBZ 40436 10222 14 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10222 15 to to IN 40436 10222 16 the the DT 40436 10222 17 inquisitive inquisitive JJ 40436 10222 18 feelings feeling NNS 40436 10222 19 -- -- : 40436 10222 20 curiosity curiosity NN 40436 10222 21 , , , 40436 10222 22 anxious anxious JJ 40436 10222 23 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 10222 24 , , , 40436 10222 25 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10222 26 embarrassment embarrassment NN 40436 10222 27 of of IN 40436 10222 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10222 29 own own JJ 40436 10222 30 mind mind NN 40436 10222 31 . . . 40436 10223 1 Now now RB 40436 10223 2 doubtless doubtless VB 40436 10223 3 these these DT 40436 10223 4 inquisitive inquisitive JJ 40436 10223 5 feelings feeling NNS 40436 10223 6 are be VBP 40436 10223 7 natural natural JJ 40436 10223 8 and and CC 40436 10223 9 widespread widespread JJ 40436 10223 10 : : : 40436 10223 11 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10223 12 are be VBP 40436 10223 13 emotions emotion NNS 40436 10223 14 of of IN 40436 10223 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10223 16 nature nature NN 40436 10223 17 , , , 40436 10223 18 which which WDT 40436 10223 19 men man NNS 40436 10223 20 seek seek VBP 40436 10223 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10223 22 in in IN 40436 10223 23 some some DT 40436 10223 24 cases case NNS 40436 10223 25 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10223 26 to to TO 40436 10223 27 appease appease VB 40436 10223 28 by by IN 40436 10223 29 some some DT 40436 10223 30 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 10223 31 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10223 32 . . . 40436 10224 1 That that DT 40436 10224 2 answer answer NN 40436 10224 3 which which WDT 40436 10224 4 affords afford VBZ 40436 10224 5 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10224 6 , , , 40436 10224 7 looked look VBD 40436 10224 8 at at IN 40436 10224 9 in in IN 40436 10224 10 one one CD 40436 10224 11 of of IN 40436 10224 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10224 13 aspects aspect NNS 40436 10224 14 , , , 40436 10224 15 is be VBZ 40436 10224 16 called call VBN 40436 10224 17 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10224 18 ; ; : 40436 10224 19 Beginning beginning NN 40436 10224 20 or or CC 40436 10224 21 Principle principle NN 40436 10224 22 -- -- : 40436 10224 23 Element element NN 40436 10224 24 -- -- : 40436 10224 25 represent represent VBP 40436 10224 26 other other JJ 40436 10224 27 aspects aspect NNS 40436 10224 28 of of IN 40436 10224 29 the the DT 40436 10224 30 same same JJ 40436 10224 31 Quæsitum:-- quæsitum:-- NN 40436 10224 32 " " `` 40436 10224 33 Felix Felix NNP 40436 10224 34 , , , 40436 10224 35 qui qui NNP 40436 10224 36 potuit potuit NNP 40436 10224 37 rerum rerum NNP 40436 10224 38 cognoscere cognoscere NNP 40436 10224 39 causas causas NNP 40436 10224 40 , , , 40436 10224 41 Atque Atque NNP 40436 10224 42 metus metus NN 40436 10224 43 omnes omne VBZ 40436 10224 44 et et NN 40436 10224 45 inexorabile inexorabile NN 40436 10224 46 Fatum Fatum NNP 40436 10224 47 Subjecit Subjecit NNP 40436 10224 48 pedibus pedibus NN 40436 10224 49 strepitumque strepitumque NN 40436 10224 50 Acherontis Acherontis NNP 40436 10224 51 avari avari RB 40436 10224 52 , , , 40436 10224 53 " " `` 40436 10224 54 is be VBZ 40436 10224 55 the the DT 40436 10224 56 exclamation exclamation NN 40436 10224 57 of of IN 40436 10224 58 that that DT 40436 10224 59 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 10224 60 of of IN 40436 10224 61 wonder wonder NN 40436 10224 62 and and CC 40436 10224 63 uneasiness uneasiness NN 40436 10224 64 out out IN 40436 10224 65 of of IN 40436 10224 66 which which WDT 40436 10224 67 , , , 40436 10224 68 according accord VBG 40436 10224 69 to to IN 40436 10224 70 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10224 71 and and CC 40436 10224 72 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10224 73 , , , 40436 10224 74 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10224 75 springs spring NNS 40436 10224 76 . . . 40436 10225 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10225 2 71 71 CD 40436 10225 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10225 4 But but CC 40436 10225 5 though though IN 40436 10225 6 the the DT 40436 10225 7 appetite appetite NN 40436 10225 8 or or CC 40436 10225 9 craving craving NN 40436 10225 10 is be VBZ 40436 10225 11 common common JJ 40436 10225 12 , , , 40436 10225 13 in in IN 40436 10225 14 greater great JJR 40436 10225 15 or or CC 40436 10225 16 less less JJR 40436 10225 17 degree degree NN 40436 10225 18 , , , 40436 10225 19 to to IN 40436 10225 20 most most JJS 40436 10225 21 persons person NNS 40436 10225 22 -- -- : 40436 10225 23 the the DT 40436 10225 24 nourishment nourishment NN 40436 10225 25 calculated calculate VBD 40436 10225 26 to to TO 40436 10225 27 allay allay VB 40436 10225 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10225 29 is be VBZ 40436 10225 30 by by IN 40436 10225 31 no no DT 40436 10225 32 means means NN 40436 10225 33 the the DT 40436 10225 34 same same JJ 40436 10225 35 to to IN 40436 10225 36 all all DT 40436 10225 37 . . . 40436 10226 1 Good good JJ 40436 10226 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10226 3 says say VBZ 40436 10226 4 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10226 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10226 6 is be VBZ 40436 10226 7 that that DT 40436 10226 8 which which WDT 40436 10226 9 all all DT 40436 10226 10 men man NNS 40436 10226 11 desire:[72 desire:[72 VBP 40436 10226 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10226 13 but but CC 40436 10226 14 all all DT 40436 10226 15 men man NNS 40436 10226 16 do do VBP 40436 10226 17 not not RB 40436 10226 18 agree agree VB 40436 10226 19 in in IN 40436 10226 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10226 21 judgment judgment NN 40436 10226 22 , , , 40436 10226 23 what what WP 40436 10226 24 Good Good NNP 40436 10226 25 is be VBZ 40436 10226 26 . . . 40436 10227 1 The the DT 40436 10227 2 point point NN 40436 10227 3 of of IN 40436 10227 4 communion communion NN 40436 10227 5 between between IN 40436 10227 6 mankind mankind NN 40436 10227 7 is be VBZ 40436 10227 8 here here RB 40436 10227 9 emotional emotional JJ 40436 10227 10 rather rather RB 40436 10227 11 than than IN 40436 10227 12 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 10227 13 : : : 40436 10227 14 in in IN 40436 10227 15 the the DT 40436 10227 16 painful painful JJ 40436 10227 17 feeling feeling NN 40436 10227 18 of of IN 40436 10227 19 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 10227 20 to to TO 40436 10227 21 be be VB 40436 10227 22 solved solve VBN 40436 10227 23 , , , 40436 10227 24 not not RB 40436 10227 25 in in IN 40436 10227 26 the the DT 40436 10227 27 manner manner NN 40436 10227 28 of of IN 40436 10227 29 conceiving conceive VBG 40436 10227 30 what what WP 40436 10227 31 the the DT 40436 10227 32 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 10227 33 is be VBZ 40436 10227 34 , , , 40436 10227 35 nor nor CC 40436 10227 36 in in IN 40436 10227 37 the the DT 40436 10227 38 direction direction NN 40436 10227 39 where where WRB 40436 10227 40 solution solution NN 40436 10227 41 is be VBZ 40436 10227 42 to to TO 40436 10227 43 be be VB 40436 10227 44 sought seek VBN 40436 10227 45 , , , 40436 10227 46 nor nor CC 40436 10227 47 in in IN 40436 10227 48 the the DT 40436 10227 49 solution solution NN 40436 10227 50 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10227 51 when when WRB 40436 10227 52 suggested suggest VBN 40436 10227 53 . . . 40436 10228 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10228 2 73 73 CD 40436 10228 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10228 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10228 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10228 6 70 70 CD 40436 10228 7 : : : 40436 10228 8 Dugald Dugald NNP 40436 10228 9 Stewart Stewart NNP 40436 10228 10 , , , 40436 10228 11 Elem Elem NNP 40436 10228 12 . . . 40436 10229 1 Philos Philos NNP 40436 10229 2 . . . 40436 10230 1 Hum hum UH 40436 10230 2 . . . 40436 10231 1 Mind mind NN 40436 10231 2 , , , 40436 10231 3 vol vol NNP 40436 10231 4 . . . 40436 10232 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10232 2 ch ch NNP 40436 10232 3 . . . 40436 10233 1 1 1 CD 40436 10233 2 , , , 40436 10233 3 sect sect JJ 40436 10233 4 . . . 40436 10234 1 2 2 CD 40436 10234 2 , , , 40436 10234 3 pp pp NNP 40436 10234 4 . . . 40436 10235 1 98 98 CD 40436 10235 2 - - SYM 40436 10235 3 99 99 CD 40436 10235 4 , , , 40436 10235 5 ed ed NN 40436 10235 6 . . . 40436 10236 1 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 40436 10236 2 , , , 40436 10236 3 also also RB 40436 10236 4 note note VB 40436 10236 5 c c NNP 40436 10236 6 same same JJ 40436 10236 7 volume volume NN 40436 10236 8 . . . 40436 10237 1 " " `` 40436 10237 2 Several several JJ 40436 10237 3 modern modern JJ 40436 10237 4 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10237 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10237 6 especially especially RB 40436 10237 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 10237 8 Reid Reid NNP 40436 10237 9 , , , 40436 10237 10 On on IN 40436 10237 11 the the DT 40436 10237 12 Intell Intell NNP 40436 10237 13 . . . 40436 10238 1 Powers power NNS 40436 10238 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10238 3 have have VBP 40436 10238 4 been be VBN 40436 10238 5 at at IN 40436 10238 6 pains pain NNS 40436 10238 7 to to TO 40436 10238 8 illustrate illustrate VB 40436 10238 9 that that DT 40436 10238 10 law law NN 40436 10238 11 of of IN 40436 10238 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10238 13 nature nature NN 40436 10238 14 which which WDT 40436 10238 15 leads lead VBZ 40436 10238 16 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10238 17 to to TO 40436 10238 18 refer refer VB 40436 10238 19 every every DT 40436 10238 20 change change NN 40436 10238 21 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10238 22 perceive perceive VBP 40436 10238 23 in in IN 40436 10238 24 the the DT 40436 10238 25 universe universe NN 40436 10238 26 to to IN 40436 10238 27 the the DT 40436 10238 28 operation operation NN 40436 10238 29 of of IN 40436 10238 30 an an DT 40436 10238 31 efficient efficient JJ 40436 10238 32 cause cause NN 40436 10238 33 . . . 40436 10239 1 This this DT 40436 10239 2 reference reference NN 40436 10239 3 is be VBZ 40436 10239 4 not not RB 40436 10239 5 the the DT 40436 10239 6 result result NN 40436 10239 7 of of IN 40436 10239 8 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 10239 9 , , , 40436 10239 10 but but CC 40436 10239 11 necessarily necessarily RB 40436 10239 12 accompanies accompany VBZ 40436 10239 13 the the DT 40436 10239 14 perception perception NN 40436 10239 15 , , , 40436 10239 16 so so IN 40436 10239 17 as as IN 40436 10239 18 to to TO 40436 10239 19 render render VB 40436 10239 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10239 21 impossible impossible JJ 40436 10239 22 for for IN 40436 10239 23 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10239 24 to to TO 40436 10239 25 see see VB 40436 10239 26 the the DT 40436 10239 27 change change NN 40436 10239 28 , , , 40436 10239 29 without without IN 40436 10239 30 feeling feel VBG 40436 10239 31 a a DT 40436 10239 32 conviction conviction NN 40436 10239 33 of of IN 40436 10239 34 the the DT 40436 10239 35 operation operation NN 40436 10239 36 of of IN 40436 10239 37 some some DT 40436 10239 38 cause cause NN 40436 10239 39 by by IN 40436 10239 40 which which WDT 40436 10239 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10239 42 is be VBZ 40436 10239 43 produced produce VBN 40436 10239 44 ; ; : 40436 10239 45 much much RB 40436 10239 46 in in IN 40436 10239 47 the the DT 40436 10239 48 same same JJ 40436 10239 49 manner manner NN 40436 10239 50 in in IN 40436 10239 51 which which WDT 40436 10239 52 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10239 53 find find VBP 40436 10239 54 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10239 55 impossible impossible JJ 40436 10239 56 to to TO 40436 10239 57 conceive conceive VB 40436 10239 58 a a DT 40436 10239 59 sensation sensation NN 40436 10239 60 , , , 40436 10239 61 without without IN 40436 10239 62 being be VBG 40436 10239 63 impressed impress VBN 40436 10239 64 with with IN 40436 10239 65 a a DT 40436 10239 66 belief belief NN 40436 10239 67 of of IN 40436 10239 68 the the DT 40436 10239 69 existence existence NN 40436 10239 70 of of IN 40436 10239 71 a a DT 40436 10239 72 sentient sentient NN 40436 10239 73 being be VBG 40436 10239 74 . . . 40436 10240 1 Hence hence RB 40436 10240 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10240 3 conceive conceive VBP 40436 10240 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10240 5 is be VBZ 40436 10240 6 that that IN 40436 10240 7 when when WRB 40436 10240 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10240 9 see see VBP 40436 10240 10 two two CD 40436 10240 11 events event NNS 40436 10240 12 constantly constantly RB 40436 10240 13 conjoined conjoin VBN 40436 10240 14 , , , 40436 10240 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10240 16 are be VBP 40436 10240 17 led lead VBN 40436 10240 18 to to TO 40436 10240 19 associate associate VB 40436 10240 20 the the DT 40436 10240 21 idea idea NN 40436 10240 22 of of IN 40436 10240 23 causation causation NN 40436 10240 24 or or CC 40436 10240 25 efficiency efficiency NN 40436 10240 26 with with IN 40436 10240 27 the the DT 40436 10240 28 former former JJ 40436 10240 29 , , , 40436 10240 30 and and CC 40436 10240 31 to to TO 40436 10240 32 refer refer VB 40436 10240 33 to to IN 40436 10240 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10240 35 that that DT 40436 10240 36 power power NN 40436 10240 37 or or CC 40436 10240 38 energy energy NN 40436 10240 39 by by IN 40436 10240 40 which which WDT 40436 10240 41 the the DT 40436 10240 42 change change NN 40436 10240 43 is be VBZ 40436 10240 44 produced produce VBN 40436 10240 45 ; ; : 40436 10240 46 in in IN 40436 10240 47 consequence consequence NN 40436 10240 48 of of IN 40436 10240 49 which which WDT 40436 10240 50 association association NN 40436 10240 51 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10240 52 come come VBP 40436 10240 53 to to TO 40436 10240 54 consider consider VB 40436 10240 55 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10240 56 as as IN 40436 10240 57 the the DT 40436 10240 58 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10240 59 of of IN 40436 10240 60 efficient efficient JJ 40436 10240 61 causes cause NNS 40436 10240 62 , , , 40436 10240 63 and and CC 40436 10240 64 lose lose VB 40436 10240 65 sight sight NN 40436 10240 66 of of IN 40436 10240 67 the the DT 40436 10240 68 operation operation NN 40436 10240 69 of of IN 40436 10240 70 mind mind NN 40436 10240 71 in in IN 40436 10240 72 producing produce VBG 40436 10240 73 the the DT 40436 10240 74 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10240 75 of of IN 40436 10240 76 nature nature NN 40436 10240 77 . . . 40436 10241 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10241 2 is be VBZ 40436 10241 3 by by IN 40436 10241 4 an an DT 40436 10241 5 association association NN 40436 10241 6 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 10241 7 similar similar JJ 40436 10241 8 that that IN 40436 10241 9 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10241 10 connect connect VBP 40436 10241 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10241 12 sensations sensation NNS 40436 10241 13 of of IN 40436 10241 14 colour colour NN 40436 10241 15 with with IN 40436 10241 16 the the DT 40436 10241 17 primary primary JJ 40436 10241 18 qualities quality NNS 40436 10241 19 of of IN 40436 10241 20 body body NN 40436 10241 21 . . . 40436 10242 1 A a DT 40436 10242 2 moment moment NN 40436 10242 3 's 's POS 40436 10242 4 reflection reflection NN 40436 10242 5 must must MD 40436 10242 6 satisfy satisfy VB 40436 10242 7 any any DT 40436 10242 8 one one NN 40436 10242 9 that that WDT 40436 10242 10 the the DT 40436 10242 11 sensation sensation NN 40436 10242 12 of of IN 40436 10242 13 colour colour NN 40436 10242 14 can can MD 40436 10242 15 only only RB 40436 10242 16 reside reside VB 40436 10242 17 in in IN 40436 10242 18 a a DT 40436 10242 19 mind mind NN 40436 10242 20 . . . 40436 10243 1 . . . 40436 10244 1 . . . 40436 10245 1 . . . 40436 10246 1 In in IN 40436 10246 2 the the DT 40436 10246 3 same same JJ 40436 10246 4 way way NN 40436 10246 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10246 6 are be VBP 40436 10246 7 led lead VBN 40436 10246 8 to to TO 40436 10246 9 associate associate VB 40436 10246 10 with with IN 40436 10246 11 inanimate inanimate JJ 40436 10246 12 matter matter NN 40436 10246 13 the the DT 40436 10246 14 ideas idea NNS 40436 10246 15 of of IN 40436 10246 16 power power NN 40436 10246 17 , , , 40436 10246 18 force force NN 40436 10246 19 , , , 40436 10246 20 energy energy NN 40436 10246 21 , , , 40436 10246 22 causation causation NN 40436 10246 23 , , , 40436 10246 24 which which WDT 40436 10246 25 are be VBP 40436 10246 26 all all DT 40436 10246 27 attributes attribute NNS 40436 10246 28 of of IN 40436 10246 29 mind mind NN 40436 10246 30 , , , 40436 10246 31 and and CC 40436 10246 32 can can MD 40436 10246 33 exist exist VB 40436 10246 34 in in IN 40436 10246 35 a a DT 40436 10246 36 mind mind NN 40436 10246 37 only only RB 40436 10246 38 . . . 40436 10246 39 " " '' 40436 10246 40 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10247 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10247 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10247 3 71 71 CD 40436 10247 4 : : : 40436 10247 5 Virgil Virgil NNP 40436 10247 6 , , , 40436 10247 7 Georg Georg NNP 40436 10247 8 . . . 40436 10248 1 ii ii LS 40436 10248 2 . . . 40436 10249 1 490 490 CD 40436 10249 2 - - SYM 40436 10249 3 92 92 CD 40436 10249 4 . . . 40436 10250 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 10250 2 Lucretius Lucretius NNP 40436 10250 3 , , , 40436 10250 4 vi vi NNP 40436 10250 5 . . . 40436 10251 1 50 50 CD 40436 10251 2 - - SYM 40436 10251 3 65 65 CD 40436 10251 4 , , , 40436 10251 5 and and CC 40436 10251 6 the the DT 40436 10251 7 letter letter NN 40436 10251 8 of of IN 40436 10251 9 Epikurus Epikurus NNP 40436 10251 10 to to IN 40436 10251 11 Herodotus Herodotus NNP 40436 10251 12 , , , 40436 10251 13 p. p. NN 40436 10251 14 25 25 CD 40436 10251 15 , , , 40436 10251 16 ed ed NN 40436 10251 17 . . . 40436 10252 1 Orelli orelli RB 40436 10252 2 . . . 40436 10253 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10253 2 , , , 40436 10253 3 Theætêt Theætêt NNP 40436 10253 4 . . . 40436 10254 1 p. p. NN 40436 10254 2 155 155 CD 40436 10254 3 D. D. NNP 40436 10254 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10254 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10254 6 : : : 40436 10254 7 ma ma NNP 40436 10254 8 / / SYM 40436 10254 9 la la NNP 40436 10254 10 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10254 11 philoso philoso NNP 40436 10254 12 / / SYM 40436 10254 13 phou phou NNP 40436 10254 14 tou tou NNP 40436 10254 15 = = NNP 40436 10254 16 to to TO 40436 10254 17 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10254 18 pa pa NNP 40436 10254 19 / / , 40436 10254 20 thos thos NNP 40436 10254 21 , , , 40436 10254 22 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10254 23 thauma thauma NNP 40436 10254 24 / / SYM 40436 10254 25 zein zein NNP 40436 10254 26 ; ; : 40436 10254 27 ou ou NNP 40436 10254 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10254 29 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10254 30 a)rchê\ a)rchê\ NNP 40436 10254 31 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 10254 32 philosophi philosophi VBZ 40436 10254 33 / / SYM 40436 10254 34 as as IN 40436 10254 35 , , , 40436 10254 36 ê)\ ê)\ UH 40436 10254 37 au(/tê]:--Aristotel au(/tê]:--aristotel UH 40436 10254 38 . . . 40436 10255 1 Metaphys metaphys RB 40436 10255 2 . . . 40436 10256 1 A. A. NNP 40436 10256 2 p. p. NNP 40436 10256 3 982 982 CD 40436 10256 4 , , , 40436 10256 5 b. b. NNP 40436 10257 1 10 10 CD 40436 10257 2 - - SYM 40436 10257 3 20 20 CD 40436 10257 4 . . . 40436 10258 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10258 2 Greek greek JJ 40436 10258 3 : : : 40436 10258 4 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 10258 5 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10258 6 to\ to\ NN 40436 10258 7 thauma thauma NNP 40436 10258 8 / / SYM 40436 10258 9 zein zein NNP 40436 10258 10 oi oi NNP 40436 10258 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10258 12 a)/nthrôpoi a)/nthrôpoi NNP 40436 10258 13 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10258 14 nu nu NNP 40436 10258 15 = = SYM 40436 10258 16 n n NNP 40436 10258 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10258 18 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10258 19 prô prô NNP 40436 10258 20 = = SYM 40436 10258 21 ton ton NN 40436 10258 22 ê)rxanto ê)rxanto CD 40436 10258 23 philosophei philosophei NN 40436 10258 24 = = SYM 40436 10258 25 n n NN 40436 10258 26 , , , 40436 10258 27 o o NN 40436 10258 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10258 29 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10258 30 a)porô a)porô NNPS 40436 10258 31 = = SYM 40436 10258 32 n n NNP 40436 10258 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10258 34 thauma thauma NNP 40436 10258 35 / / SYM 40436 10258 36 zôn zôn NNP 40436 10258 37 oi)/etai oi)/etai NNP 40436 10258 38 a)gnoei a)gnoei NNP 40436 10258 39 = = SYM 40436 10258 40 n n NN 40436 10258 41 . . . 40436 10258 42 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10258 43 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10259 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10259 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10259 3 72 72 CD 40436 10259 4 : : : 40436 10259 5 Aristotel Aristotel NNP 40436 10259 6 . . . 40436 10260 1 Ethic ethic NN 40436 10260 2 . . . 40436 10261 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 10261 2 . . . 40436 10262 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10263 1 1 1 LS 40436 10263 2 . . . 40436 10264 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10264 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10264 3 : : : 40436 10264 4 dio\ dio\ NN 40436 10264 5 kalô kalô NN 40436 10264 6 = = SYM 40436 10264 7 s s NNP 40436 10264 8 a)pephê/|nanto a)pephê/|nanto NNP 40436 10264 9 ta)gatho ta)gatho NNP 40436 10264 10 / / SYM 40436 10264 11 n n NN 40436 10264 12 , , , 40436 10264 13 ou)= ou)= JJ 40436 10264 14 pa pa NNP 40436 10264 15 / / SYM 40436 10264 16 ntes ntes NNP 40436 10264 17 e)phi e)phi NNP 40436 10264 18 / / SYM 40436 10264 19 entai entai NNP 40436 10264 20 . . . 40436 10264 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10265 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10265 2 , , , 40436 10265 3 Republ Republ NNP 40436 10265 4 . . . 40436 10266 1 vi vi NNP 40436 10266 2 . . . 40436 10267 1 p. p. NN 40436 10267 2 505 505 CD 40436 10267 3 E. E. NNP 40436 10267 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10267 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10267 6 : : : 40436 10267 7 O(/ O(/ `` 40436 10267 8 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 10267 9 diô diô NNP 40436 10267 10 / / SYM 40436 10267 11 kei kei NNP 40436 10267 12 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10267 13 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 10267 14 = = SYM 40436 10267 15 sa sa NNP 40436 10267 16 psuchê\ psuchê\ NNP 40436 10267 17 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10267 18 tou tou NNP 40436 10267 19 / / SYM 40436 10267 20 tou tou NNP 40436 10267 21 e(/neka e(/neka NNP 40436 10267 22 pa pa NNP 40436 10267 23 / / SYM 40436 10267 24 nta nta NNP 40436 10267 25 pra pra NNP 40436 10267 26 / / SYM 40436 10267 27 ttei ttei NNP 40436 10267 28 , , , 40436 10267 29 a)pomanteuome a)pomanteuome LS 40436 10267 30 / / SYM 40436 10267 31 nê nê NN 40436 10267 32 ti ti NNP 40436 10267 33 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 10267 34 , , , 40436 10267 35 a)porou a)porou ADD 40436 10267 36 = = SYM 40436 10267 37 sa sa NNP 40436 10267 38 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10267 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10267 40 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10267 41 e)/chousa e)/chousa NNP 40436 10267 42 labei labei NNP 40436 10267 43 = = SYM 40436 10267 44 n n NN 40436 10267 45 i(kanô i(kanô NNP 40436 10267 46 = = NFP 40436 10267 47 s s NNP 40436 10267 48 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 10267 49 pot pot NN 40436 10267 50 ' ' '' 40436 10267 51 e)sti e)sti NNS 40436 10267 52 / / SYM 40436 10267 53 n n NN 40436 10267 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10267 55 , , , 40436 10267 56 & & CC 40436 10267 57 c. c. NNP 40436 10267 58 Seneca Seneca NNP 40436 10267 59 , , , 40436 10267 60 Epistol Epistol NNP 40436 10267 61 . . . 40436 10268 1 118 118 CD 40436 10268 2 . . . 40436 10269 1 " " `` 40436 10269 2 Bonum Bonum NNP 40436 10269 3 est est NNP 40436 10269 4 , , , 40436 10269 5 quod quod NNP 40436 10269 6 ad ad NNP 40436 10269 7 se se NNP 40436 10269 8 impetum impetum NNP 40436 10269 9 animi animi NNP 40436 10269 10 secundum secundum NNP 40436 10269 11 naturam naturam NNP 40436 10269 12 movet movet NNP 40436 10269 13 . . . 40436 10269 14 " " '' 40436 10269 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10270 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10270 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10270 3 73 73 CD 40436 10270 4 : : : 40436 10270 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10270 6 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 10270 7 the the DT 40436 10270 8 different different JJ 40436 10270 9 nature nature NN 40436 10270 10 of of IN 40436 10270 11 the the DT 40436 10270 12 difficulties difficulty NNS 40436 10270 13 and and CC 40436 10270 14 problems problem NNS 40436 10270 15 which which WDT 40436 10270 16 present present VBP 40436 10270 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10270 18 to to IN 40436 10270 19 the the DT 40436 10270 20 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10270 21 mind mind NN 40436 10270 22 : : : 40436 10270 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10270 24 looks look VBZ 40436 10270 25 back back RB 40436 10270 26 upon upon IN 40436 10270 27 the the DT 40436 10270 28 embarrassments embarrassment NNS 40436 10270 29 of of IN 40436 10270 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10270 31 predecessors predecessor NNS 40436 10270 32 as as IN 40436 10270 33 antiquated antiquated JJ 40436 10270 34 and and CC 40436 10270 35 even even RB 40436 10270 36 silly silly JJ 40436 10270 37 , , , 40436 10270 38 Metaphysic metaphysic JJ 40436 10270 39 . . . 40436 10271 1 N. N. NNP 40436 10271 2 1089 1089 CD 40436 10271 3 , , , 40436 10271 4 a. a. NN 40436 10272 1 2 2 LS 40436 10272 2 . . . 40436 10273 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10273 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10273 3 : : : 40436 10273 4 Polla\ Polla\ NNP 40436 10273 5 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10273 6 ou)=n ou)=n RB 40436 10273 7 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 10273 8 ai)/tia ai)/tia NNP 40436 10273 9 tê tê NNP 40436 10273 10 = = SYM 40436 10273 11 s s NNP 40436 10273 12 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 10273 13 tau tau NN 40436 10273 14 / / SYM 40436 10273 15 tas tas NN 40436 10273 16 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 10273 17 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10273 18 / / SYM 40436 10273 19 as as IN 40436 10273 20 e)ktropê e)ktropê NNPS 40436 10273 21 = = SYM 40436 10273 22 s s NNP 40436 10273 23 , , , 40436 10273 24 ma ma NNP 40436 10273 25 / / SYM 40436 10273 26 lista lista NNP 40436 10273 27 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10273 28 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10273 29 a)porê a)porê NNP 40436 10273 30 = = NFP 40436 10273 31 sai sai FW 40436 10273 32 a)rchai+kô a)rchai+kô NNP 40436 10273 33 = = SYM 40436 10273 34 s s NN 40436 10273 35 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10273 36 , , , 40436 10273 37 which which WDT 40436 10273 38 Alexander Alexander NNP 40436 10273 39 of of IN 40436 10273 40 Aphrodisias Aphrodisias NNP 40436 10273 41 paraphrases paraphrase NNS 40436 10273 42 by by IN 40436 10273 43 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10273 44 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10273 45 : : : 40436 10273 46 a)rchai+kô a)rchai+kô NNP 40436 10273 47 = = SYM 40436 10273 48 s s NNP 40436 10273 49 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10273 50 eu)êthô eu)êthô NNP 40436 10273 51 = = SYM 40436 10273 52 s s NNP 40436 10273 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10273 54 . . . 40436 10274 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10274 2 A a DT 40436 10274 3 993 993 CD 40436 10274 4 , , , 40436 10274 5 a. a. NN 40436 10275 1 15 15 CD 40436 10275 2 . . . 40436 10276 1 In in IN 40436 10276 2 another another DT 40436 10276 3 passage passage NN 40436 10276 4 of of IN 40436 10276 5 the the DT 40436 10276 6 same same JJ 40436 10276 7 book book NN 40436 10276 8 , , , 40436 10276 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10276 10 notes note VBZ 40436 10276 11 and and CC 40436 10276 12 characterises characterise VBZ 40436 10276 13 the the DT 40436 10276 14 emotion emotion NN 40436 10276 15 experienced experience VBN 40436 10276 16 by by IN 40436 10276 17 the the DT 40436 10276 18 mind mind NN 40436 10276 19 in in IN 40436 10276 20 possessing possess VBG 40436 10276 21 what what WP 40436 10276 22 is be VBZ 40436 10276 23 regarded regard VBN 40436 10276 24 as as IN 40436 10276 25 truth truth NN 40436 10276 26 -- -- : 40436 10276 27 the the DT 40436 10276 28 mental mental JJ 40436 10276 29 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10276 30 obtained obtain VBD 40436 10276 31 when when WRB 40436 10276 32 a a DT 40436 10276 33 difficulty difficulty NN 40436 10276 34 is be VBZ 40436 10276 35 solved solve VBN 40436 10276 36 , , , 40436 10276 37 1090 1090 CD 40436 10276 38 , , , 40436 10276 39 a. a. NN 40436 10277 1 38 38 CD 40436 10277 2 . . . 40436 10278 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10278 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10278 3 : : : 40436 10278 4 Oi oi VB 40436 10278 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10278 6 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10278 7 chôristo\n chôristo\n -LRB- 40436 10278 8 poiou poiou NNP 40436 10278 9 = = SYM 40436 10278 10 ntes ntes NNP 40436 10278 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10278 12 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10278 13 a)rithmo a)rithmo NNP 40436 10278 14 / / SYM 40436 10278 15 n n NNP 40436 10278 16 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10278 17 , , , 40436 10278 18 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10278 19 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 10278 20 tô tô IN 40436 10278 21 = = SYM 40436 10278 22 n n NN 40436 10278 23 ai)sthêtô ai)sthêtô CC 40436 10278 24 = = SYM 40436 10278 25 n n IN 40436 10278 26 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10278 27 e)/stai e)/stai NN 40436 10278 28 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 10278 29 a)xiô a)xiô NNP 40436 10278 30 / / SYM 40436 10278 31 mata mata NNP 40436 10278 32 , , , 40436 10278 33 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 10278 34 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10278 35 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 10278 36 lego lego NNP 40436 10278 37 / / SYM 40436 10278 38 mena mena NNP 40436 10278 39 _ _ NNP 40436 10278 40 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10278 41 sai sai NNP 40436 10278 42 / / SYM 40436 10278 43 nei nei NNP 40436 10278 44 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10278 45 psuchê psuchê NNP 40436 10278 46 / / SYM 40436 10278 47 n n CC 40436 10278 48 _ _ NNP 40436 10278 49 , , , 40436 10278 50 ei)=nai/ ei)=nai/ NNP 40436 10278 51 te te NNP 40436 10278 52 u(polamba u(polamba NNP 40436 10278 53 / / SYM 40436 10278 54 nousi nousi NNP 40436 10278 55 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10278 56 chôrista\ chôrista\ NNP 40436 10278 57 ei)=nai ei)=nai XX 40436 10278 58 ; ; : 40436 10278 59 o(moi o(moi NNP 40436 10278 60 / / SYM 40436 10278 61 ôs ôs NNP 40436 10278 62 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10278 63 ta\ ta\ VBD 40436 10278 64 mege mege NNP 40436 10278 65 / / SYM 40436 10278 66 thê thê NNP 40436 10278 67 ta\ ta\ JJ 40436 10278 68 mathêmatika/. mathêmatika/. NNP 40436 10278 69 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10279 1 The the DT 40436 10279 2 subjective subjective JJ 40436 10279 3 origin origin NN 40436 10279 4 of of IN 40436 10279 5 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10279 6 -- -- : 40436 10279 7 the the DT 40436 10279 8 feelings feeling NNS 40436 10279 9 which which WDT 40436 10279 10 prompt prompt VBP 40436 10279 11 to to IN 40436 10279 12 the the DT 40436 10279 13 theorising theorising JJ 40436 10279 14 process process NN 40436 10279 15 , , , 40436 10279 16 striking strike VBG 40436 10279 17 out out RP 40436 10279 18 different different JJ 40436 10279 19 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 40436 10279 20 and and CC 40436 10279 21 analogies analogy NNS 40436 10279 22 -- -- : 40436 10279 23 are be VBP 40436 10279 24 well well RB 40436 10279 25 stated state VBN 40436 10279 26 by by IN 40436 10279 27 Adam Adam NNP 40436 10279 28 Smith Smith NNP 40436 10279 29 , , , 40436 10279 30 ' ' '' 40436 10279 31 History history NN 40436 10279 32 of of IN 40436 10279 33 Astronomy Astronomy NNP 40436 10279 34 , , , 40436 10279 35 ' ' '' 40436 10279 36 sect sect NN 40436 10279 37 . . . 40436 10280 1 ii ii LS 40436 10280 2 . . . 40436 10281 1 and and CC 40436 10281 2 iii iii NNP 40436 10281 3 . . . 40436 10281 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10282 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10282 2 Side side NN 40436 10282 3 - - HYPH 40436 10282 4 note note NN 40436 10282 5 : : : 40436 10282 6 Dissension dissension NN 40436 10282 7 and and CC 40436 10282 8 perplexity perplexity NN 40436 10282 9 on on IN 40436 10282 10 the the DT 40436 10282 11 question.--What question.--what CD 40436 10282 12 is be VBZ 40436 10282 13 a a DT 40436 10282 14 cause cause NN 40436 10282 15 ? ? . 40436 10283 1 revealed reveal VBN 40436 10283 2 by by IN 40436 10283 3 the the DT 40436 10283 4 picture picture NN 40436 10283 5 of of IN 40436 10283 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10283 7 -- -- : 40436 10283 8 no no DT 40436 10283 9 intuition intuition NN 40436 10283 10 to to TO 40436 10283 11 guide guide VB 40436 10283 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10283 13 . . . 40436 10283 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10284 1 When when WRB 40436 10284 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10284 3 here here RB 40436 10284 4 tells tell VBZ 40436 10284 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10284 6 that that IN 40436 10284 7 as as IN 40436 10284 8 a a DT 40436 10284 9 young young JJ 40436 10284 10 man man NN 40436 10284 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10284 12 felt feel VBD 40436 10284 13 anxious anxious JJ 40436 10284 14 curiosity curiosity NN 40436 10284 15 to to TO 40436 10284 16 know know VB 40436 10284 17 what what WP 40436 10284 18 the the DT 40436 10284 19 cause cause NN 40436 10284 20 of of IN 40436 10284 21 every every DT 40436 10284 22 phenomenon phenomenon NN 40436 10284 23 was be VBD 40436 10284 24 , , , 40436 10284 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10284 26 is be VBZ 40436 10284 27 plain plain JJ 40436 10284 28 that that IN 40436 10284 29 at at IN 40436 10284 30 this this DT 40436 10284 31 time time NN 40436 10284 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10284 33 did do VBD 40436 10284 34 not not RB 40436 10284 35 know know VB 40436 10284 36 what what WP 40436 10284 37 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10284 38 was be VBD 40436 10284 39 looking look VBG 40436 10284 40 for for IN 40436 10284 41 : : : 40436 10284 42 that that IN 40436 10284 43 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10284 44 proceeded proceed VBD 40436 10284 45 only only RB 40436 10284 46 by by IN 40436 10284 47 successive successive JJ 40436 10284 48 steps step NNS 40436 10284 49 of of IN 40436 10284 50 trial trial NN 40436 10284 51 , , , 40436 10284 52 doubt doubt NN 40436 10284 53 , , , 40436 10284 54 discovered discover VBN 40436 10284 55 error error NN 40436 10284 56 , , , 40436 10284 57 rejection rejection NN 40436 10284 58 : : : 40436 10284 59 and and CC 40436 10284 60 that that IN 40436 10284 61 each each DT 40436 10284 62 trial trial NN 40436 10284 63 was be VBD 40436 10284 64 adapted adapt VBN 40436 10284 65 to to IN 40436 10284 66 the the DT 40436 10284 67 then then RB 40436 10284 68 existing exist VBG 40436 10284 69 state state NN 40436 10284 70 of of IN 40436 10284 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10284 72 own own JJ 40436 10284 73 mind mind NN 40436 10284 74 . . . 40436 10285 1 The the DT 40436 10285 2 views view NNS 40436 10285 3 of of IN 40436 10285 4 Anaxagoras anaxagora NNS 40436 10285 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10285 6 affirms affirm VBZ 40436 10285 7 to to TO 40436 10285 8 have have VB 40436 10285 9 presented present VBN 40436 10285 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10285 11 to to IN 40436 10285 12 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10285 13 as as IN 40436 10285 14 a a DT 40436 10285 15 new new JJ 40436 10285 16 revelation revelation NN 40436 10285 17 : : : 40436 10285 18 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10285 19 then then RB 40436 10285 20 came come VBD 40436 10285 21 to to TO 40436 10285 22 believe believe VB 40436 10285 23 that that IN 40436 10285 24 the the DT 40436 10285 25 only only JJ 40436 10285 26 true true JJ 40436 10285 27 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10285 28 was be VBD 40436 10285 29 , , , 40436 10285 30 a a DT 40436 10285 31 cosmical cosmical JJ 40436 10285 32 reason reason NN 40436 10285 33 and and CC 40436 10285 34 volition volition NN 40436 10285 35 like like IN 40436 10285 36 to to IN 40436 10285 37 that that DT 40436 10285 38 of of IN 40436 10285 39 which which WDT 40436 10285 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10285 41 was be VBD 40436 10285 42 conscious conscious JJ 40436 10285 43 in in IN 40436 10285 44 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10285 45 . . . 40436 10286 1 Yet yet CC 40436 10286 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10286 3 farther farther RB 40436 10286 4 tells tell VBZ 40436 10286 5 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10286 6 , , , 40436 10286 7 that that IN 40436 10286 8 others other NNS 40436 10286 9 did do VBD 40436 10286 10 not not RB 40436 10286 11 admit admit VB 40436 10286 12 this this DT 40436 10286 13 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10286 14 , , , 40436 10286 15 but but CC 40436 10286 16 found find VBD 40436 10286 17 other other JJ 40436 10286 18 causes cause NNS 40436 10286 19 to to TO 40436 10286 20 satisfy satisfy VB 40436 10286 21 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10286 22 : : : 40436 10286 23 that that IN 40436 10286 24 even even RB 40436 10286 25 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNP 40436 10286 26 did do VBD 40436 10286 27 not not RB 40436 10286 28 follow follow VB 40436 10286 29 out out RP 40436 10286 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10286 31 own own JJ 40436 10286 32 general general JJ 40436 10286 33 conception conception NN 40436 10286 34 , , , 40436 10286 35 but but CC 40436 10286 36 recognised recognise VBD 40436 10286 37 Causes cause NNS 40436 10286 38 quite quite RB 40436 10286 39 unconnected unconnected JJ 40436 10286 40 with with IN 40436 10286 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10286 42 : : : 40436 10286 43 lastly lastly RB 40436 10286 44 , , , 40436 10286 45 that that IN 40436 10286 46 neither neither DT 40436 10286 47 could could MD 40436 10286 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10286 49 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10286 50 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10286 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10286 52 trace trace VBP 40436 10286 53 out out IN 40436 10286 54 the the DT 40436 10286 55 conception conception NN 40436 10286 56 for for IN 40436 10286 57 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10286 58 . . . 40436 10287 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10287 2 74 74 CD 40436 10287 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10287 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10287 5 was be VBD 40436 10287 6 driven drive VBN 40436 10287 7 to to TO 40436 10287 8 renounce renounce VB 40436 10287 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10287 10 , , , 40436 10287 11 and and CC 40436 10287 12 to to TO 40436 10287 13 turn turn VB 40436 10287 14 to to IN 40436 10287 15 another another DT 40436 10287 16 sort sort NN 40436 10287 17 of of IN 40436 10287 18 Cause cause NN 40436 10287 19 -- -- : 40436 10287 20 the the DT 40436 10287 21 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10287 22 of of IN 40436 10287 23 self self NN 40436 10287 24 - - HYPH 40436 10287 25 existent existent NN 40436 10287 26 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10287 27 , , , 40436 10287 28 in in IN 40436 10287 29 which which WDT 40436 10287 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10287 31 then then RB 40436 10287 32 acquiesced acquiesce VBD 40436 10287 33 . . . 40436 10288 1 And and CC 40436 10288 2 this this DT 40436 10288 3 last last JJ 40436 10288 4 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10288 5 , , , 40436 10288 6 again again RB 40436 10288 7 , , , 40436 10288 8 was be VBD 40436 10288 9 ultimately ultimately RB 40436 10288 10 much much RB 40436 10288 11 modified modify VBN 40436 10288 12 in in IN 40436 10288 13 the the DT 40436 10288 14 mind mind NN 40436 10288 15 of of IN 40436 10288 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10288 17 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10288 18 , , , 40436 10288 19 as as IN 40436 10288 20 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10288 21 know know VBP 40436 10288 22 from from IN 40436 10288 23 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10288 24 . . . 40436 10289 1 All all PDT 40436 10289 2 this this DT 40436 10289 3 shows show VBZ 40436 10289 4 that that IN 40436 10289 5 the the DT 40436 10289 6 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10289 7 of of IN 40436 10289 8 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10289 9 -- -- : 40436 10289 10 far far RB 40436 10289 11 from from IN 40436 10289 12 being be VBG 40436 10289 13 one one CD 40436 10289 14 and and CC 40436 10289 15 the the DT 40436 10289 16 same same JJ 40436 10289 17 to to IN 40436 10289 18 all all DT 40436 10289 19 , , , 40436 10289 20 like like IN 40436 10289 21 the the DT 40436 10289 22 feeling feeling NN 40436 10289 23 of of IN 40436 10289 24 uneasiness uneasiness NN 40436 10289 25 which which WDT 40436 10289 26 prompts prompt VBZ 40436 10289 27 the the DT 40436 10289 28 search search NN 40436 10289 29 for for IN 40436 10289 30 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10289 31 -- -- : 40436 10289 32 is be VBZ 40436 10289 33 complicated complicate VBN 40436 10289 34 , , , 40436 10289 35 diverse diverse JJ 40436 10289 36 , , , 40436 10289 37 relative relative JJ 40436 10289 38 , , , 40436 10289 39 and and CC 40436 10289 40 modifiable modifiable JJ 40436 10289 41 . . . 40436 10290 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10290 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10290 3 74 74 CD 40436 10290 4 : : : 40436 10290 5 The the DT 40436 10290 6 view view NN 40436 10290 7 of of IN 40436 10290 8 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10290 9 , , , 40436 10290 10 which which WDT 40436 10290 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10290 12 here here RB 40436 10290 13 declares declare VBZ 40436 10290 14 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10290 15 to to TO 40436 10290 16 renounce renounce VB 40436 10290 17 from from IN 40436 10290 18 inability inability NN 40436 10290 19 to to TO 40436 10290 20 pursue pursue VB 40436 10290 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10290 22 , , , 40436 10290 23 is be VBZ 40436 10290 24 substantially substantially RB 40436 10290 25 the the DT 40436 10290 26 same same JJ 40436 10290 27 as as IN 40436 10290 28 what what WP 40436 10290 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10290 30 lays lay VBZ 40436 10290 31 down down RP 40436 10290 32 in in IN 40436 10290 33 the the DT 40436 10290 34 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 10290 35 , , , 40436 10290 36 pp pp NNP 40436 10290 37 . . . 40436 10291 1 23 23 CD 40436 10291 2 D d NN 40436 10291 3 , , , 40436 10291 4 27 27 CD 40436 10291 5 A a NN 40436 10291 6 , , , 40436 10291 7 30 30 CD 40436 10291 8 E. E. NNP 40436 10291 9 In in IN 40436 10291 10 the the DT 40436 10291 11 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10291 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10291 13 assigns assign NNS 40436 10291 14 to to IN 40436 10291 15 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10291 16 the the DT 40436 10291 17 task task NN 40436 10291 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10291 19 to to TO 40436 10291 20 which which WDT 40436 10291 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10291 22 in in IN 40436 10291 23 the the DT 40436 10291 24 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10291 25 had have VBD 40436 10291 26 confessed confess VBN 40436 10291 27 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10291 28 incompetent incompetent JJ 40436 10291 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10291 30 of of IN 40436 10291 31 following follow VBG 40436 10291 32 into into IN 40436 10291 33 detail detail NN 40436 10291 34 the the DT 40436 10291 35 schemes scheme NNS 40436 10291 36 and and CC 40436 10291 37 proceedings proceeding NNS 40436 10291 38 of of IN 40436 10291 39 the the DT 40436 10291 40 Demiurgic demiurgic JJ 40436 10291 41 or or CC 40436 10291 42 optimising optimise VBG 40436 10291 43 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10291 44 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10291 45 : : : 40436 10291 46 Nou Nou NNP 40436 10291 47 = = SYM 40436 10291 48 s s NN 40436 10291 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10291 50 . . . 40436 10292 1 But but CC 40436 10292 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10292 3 also also RB 40436 10292 4 assumes assume VBZ 40436 10292 5 the the DT 40436 10292 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10292 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10292 8 : : : 40436 10292 9 ei)/dê ei)/dê NN 40436 10292 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10292 11 or or CC 40436 10292 12 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10292 13 as as IN 40436 10292 14 co co JJ 40436 10292 15 - - NN 40436 10292 16 ordinate ordinate JJ 40436 10292 17 and and CC 40436 10292 18 essential essential JJ 40436 10292 19 conditions condition NNS 40436 10292 20 . . . 40436 10292 21 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10293 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10293 2 Side side NN 40436 10293 3 - - HYPH 40436 10293 4 note note NN 40436 10293 5 : : : 40436 10293 6 Different different JJ 40436 10293 7 notions notion NNS 40436 10293 8 of of IN 40436 10293 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10293 10 and and CC 40436 10293 11 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10293 12 about about IN 40436 10293 13 causation causation NN 40436 10293 14 , , , 40436 10293 15 causes cause VBZ 40436 10293 16 regular regular JJ 40436 10293 17 and and CC 40436 10293 18 irregular irregular JJ 40436 10293 19 . . . 40436 10294 1 Inductive inductive JJ 40436 10294 2 theory theory NN 40436 10294 3 of of IN 40436 10294 4 causation causation NN 40436 10294 5 , , , 40436 10294 6 elaborated elaborate VBN 40436 10294 7 in in IN 40436 10294 8 modern modern JJ 40436 10294 9 times time NNS 40436 10294 10 . . . 40436 10294 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10295 1 The the DT 40436 10295 2 last last JJ 40436 10295 3 among among IN 40436 10295 4 the the DT 40436 10295 5 various various JJ 40436 10295 6 revolutions revolution NNS 40436 10295 7 which which WDT 40436 10295 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10295 9 represents represent VBZ 40436 10295 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10295 11 to to TO 40436 10295 12 have have VB 40436 10295 13 undergone undergo VBN 40436 10295 14 -- -- : 40436 10295 15 the the DT 40436 10295 16 transition transition NN 40436 10295 17 from from IN 40436 10295 18 designing designing NN 40436 10295 19 and and CC 40436 10295 20 volitional volitional JJ 40436 10295 21 agency agency NN 40436 10295 22 of of IN 40436 10295 23 the the DT 40436 10295 24 Kosmos Kosmos NNP 40436 10295 25 conceived conceive VBD 40436 10295 26 as as IN 40436 10295 27 an an DT 40436 10295 28 animated animated JJ 40436 10295 29 system system NN 40436 10295 30 , , , 40436 10295 31 to to IN 40436 10295 32 the the DT 40436 10295 33 sovereignty sovereignty NN 40436 10295 34 of of IN 40436 10295 35 universal universal JJ 40436 10295 36 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10295 37 -- -- : 40436 10295 38 is be VBZ 40436 10295 39 analogous analogous JJ 40436 10295 40 to to IN 40436 10295 41 that that DT 40436 10295 42 transition transition NN 40436 10295 43 which which WDT 40436 10295 44 Auguste Auguste NNP 40436 10295 45 Comte Comte NNP 40436 10295 46 considers consider VBZ 40436 10295 47 to to TO 40436 10295 48 be be VB 40436 10295 49 the the DT 40436 10295 50 natural natural JJ 40436 10295 51 progress progress NN 40436 10295 52 of of IN 40436 10295 53 the the DT 40436 10295 54 human human JJ 40436 10295 55 mind mind NN 40436 10295 56 : : : 40436 10295 57 to to TO 40436 10295 58 explain explain VB 40436 10295 59 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10295 60 at at IN 40436 10295 61 first first RB 40436 10295 62 by by IN 40436 10295 63 reference reference NN 40436 10295 64 to to IN 40436 10295 65 some some DT 40436 10295 66 personal personal JJ 40436 10295 67 agency agency NN 40436 10295 68 , , , 40436 10295 69 and and CC 40436 10295 70 to to TO 40436 10295 71 pass pass VB 40436 10295 72 from from IN 40436 10295 73 this this DT 40436 10295 74 mode mode NN 40436 10295 75 of of IN 40436 10295 76 explanation explanation NN 40436 10295 77 to to IN 40436 10295 78 that that DT 40436 10295 79 by by IN 40436 10295 80 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 40436 10295 81 abstractions abstraction NNS 40436 10295 82 . . . 40436 10296 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10296 2 is be VBZ 40436 10296 3 true true JJ 40436 10296 4 that that IN 40436 10296 5 these these DT 40436 10296 6 are be VBP 40436 10296 7 two two CD 40436 10296 8 distinct distinct JJ 40436 10296 9 modes mode NNS 40436 10296 10 of of IN 40436 10296 11 conceiving conceive VBG 40436 10296 12 Causation Causation NNP 40436 10296 13 ; ; : 40436 10296 14 and and CC 40436 10296 15 that that IN 40436 10296 16 in in IN 40436 10296 17 each each DT 40436 10296 18 of of IN 40436 10296 19 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10296 20 the the DT 40436 10296 21 human human JJ 40436 10296 22 mind mind NN 40436 10296 23 , , , 40436 10296 24 under under IN 40436 10296 25 different different JJ 40436 10296 26 states state NNS 40436 10296 27 of of IN 40436 10296 28 social social JJ 40436 10296 29 and and CC 40436 10296 30 individual individual JJ 40436 10296 31 instruction instruction NN 40436 10296 32 , , , 40436 10296 33 finds find VBZ 40436 10296 34 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10296 35 . . . 40436 10297 1 But but CC 40436 10297 2 each each DT 40436 10297 3 of of IN 40436 10297 4 the the DT 40436 10297 5 two two CD 40436 10297 6 theories theory NNS 40436 10297 7 admits admit VBZ 40436 10297 8 of of IN 40436 10297 9 much much JJ 40436 10297 10 diversity diversity NN 40436 10297 11 in in IN 40436 10297 12 the the DT 40436 10297 13 mode mode NN 40436 10297 14 of of IN 40436 10297 15 conception conception NN 40436 10297 16 . . . 40436 10298 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10298 2 seems seem VBZ 40436 10298 3 to to TO 40436 10298 4 have have VB 40436 10298 5 first first RB 40436 10298 6 given give VBN 40436 10298 7 prominence prominence NN 40436 10298 8 to to IN 40436 10298 9 these these DT 40436 10298 10 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 40436 10298 11 causes cause NNS 40436 10298 12 ; ; : 40436 10298 13 and and CC 40436 10298 14 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10298 15 in in IN 40436 10298 16 this this DT 40436 10298 17 respect respect NN 40436 10298 18 follows follow VBZ 40436 10298 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10298 20 example example NN 40436 10298 21 : : : 40436 10298 22 though though IN 40436 10298 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10298 24 greatly greatly RB 40436 10298 25 censures censure VBZ 40436 10298 26 the the DT 40436 10298 27 incomplete incomplete JJ 40436 10298 28 and and CC 40436 10298 29 erroneous erroneous JJ 40436 10298 30 theories theory NNS 40436 10298 31 of of IN 40436 10298 32 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10298 33 . . . 40436 10299 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10299 2 is be VBZ 40436 10299 3 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 10299 4 that that IN 40436 10299 5 both both CC 40436 10299 6 these these DT 40436 10299 7 two two CD 40436 10299 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10299 9 recognised recognise VBD 40436 10299 10 Causes cause NNS 40436 10299 11 irregular irregular JJ 40436 10299 12 and and CC 40436 10299 13 unpredictable unpredictable JJ 40436 10299 14 , , , 40436 10299 15 as as RB 40436 10299 16 well well RB 40436 10299 17 as as IN 40436 10299 18 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10299 19 regular regular JJ 40436 10299 20 and and CC 40436 10299 21 predictable predictable JJ 40436 10299 22 . . . 40436 10300 1 Neither neither DT 40436 10300 2 of of IN 40436 10300 3 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10300 4 included include VBD 40436 10300 5 even even RB 40436 10300 6 the the DT 40436 10300 7 idea idea NN 40436 10300 8 of of IN 40436 10300 9 regularity regularity NN 40436 10300 10 , , , 40436 10300 11 as as IN 40436 10300 12 an an DT 40436 10300 13 essential essential JJ 40436 10300 14 part part NN 40436 10300 15 of of IN 40436 10300 16 the the DT 40436 10300 17 meaning meaning NN 40436 10300 18 of of IN 40436 10300 19 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10300 20 . . . 40436 10301 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10301 2 75 75 CD 40436 10301 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10301 4 Lastly lastly RB 40436 10301 5 , , , 40436 10301 6 there there EX 40436 10301 7 has have VBZ 40436 10301 8 been be VBN 40436 10301 9 elaborated elaborate VBN 40436 10301 10 in in IN 40436 10301 11 modern modern JJ 40436 10301 12 times time NNS 40436 10301 13 , , , 40436 10301 14 owing owe VBG 40436 10301 15 to to IN 40436 10301 16 the the DT 40436 10301 17 great great JJ 40436 10301 18 extension extension NN 40436 10301 19 of of IN 40436 10301 20 inductive inductive JJ 40436 10301 21 science science NN 40436 10301 22 , , , 40436 10301 23 another another DT 40436 10301 24 theory theory NN 40436 10301 25 of of IN 40436 10301 26 Causation Causation NNP 40436 10301 27 , , , 40436 10301 28 in in IN 40436 10301 29 which which WDT 40436 10301 30 unconditional unconditional JJ 40436 10301 31 regularity regularity NN 40436 10301 32 is be VBZ 40436 10301 33 the the DT 40436 10301 34 essential essential JJ 40436 10301 35 constituent constituent NN 40436 10301 36 : : : 40436 10301 37 recognising recognise VBG 40436 10301 38 no no DT 40436 10301 39 true true JJ 40436 10301 40 Causes cause NNS 40436 10301 41 except except IN 40436 10301 42 the the DT 40436 10301 43 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 40436 10301 44 causes cause NNS 40436 10301 45 certified certify VBN 40436 10301 46 by by IN 40436 10301 47 experience experience NN 40436 10301 48 , , , 40436 10301 49 as as IN 40436 10301 50 interpreted interpret VBN 40436 10301 51 inductively inductively RB 40436 10301 52 and and CC 40436 10301 53 deductively deductively RB 40436 10301 54 -- -- : 40436 10301 55 the the DT 40436 10301 56 assemblage assemblage NN 40436 10301 57 of of IN 40436 10301 58 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 40436 10301 59 antecedents antecedent NNS 40436 10301 60 , , , 40436 10301 61 uniform uniform JJ 40436 10301 62 and and CC 40436 10301 63 unconditional unconditional JJ 40436 10301 64 , , , 40436 10301 65 so so RB 40436 10301 66 far far RB 40436 10301 67 as as IN 40436 10301 68 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10301 69 can can MD 40436 10301 70 be be VB 40436 10301 71 discovered discover VBN 40436 10301 72 and and CC 40436 10301 73 verified verify VBN 40436 10301 74 . . . 40436 10302 1 Certain certain JJ 40436 10302 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10302 3 is be VBZ 40436 10302 4 that that IN 40436 10302 5 these these DT 40436 10302 6 are be VBP 40436 10302 7 the the DT 40436 10302 8 only only JJ 40436 10302 9 causes cause NNS 40436 10302 10 obtainable obtainable JJ 40436 10302 11 by by IN 40436 10302 12 induction induction NN 40436 10302 13 and and CC 40436 10302 14 experience experience NN 40436 10302 15 : : : 40436 10302 16 though though IN 40436 10302 17 many many JJ 40436 10302 18 persons person NNS 40436 10302 19 are be VBP 40436 10302 20 not not RB 40436 10302 21 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 10302 22 without without IN 40436 10302 23 looking look VBG 40436 10302 24 elsewhere elsewhere RB 40436 10302 25 for for IN 40436 10302 26 transcendental transcendental JJ 40436 10302 27 or or CC 40436 10302 28 ontological ontological JJ 40436 10302 29 causes cause NNS 40436 10302 30 of of IN 40436 10302 31 a a DT 40436 10302 32 totally totally RB 40436 10302 33 different different JJ 40436 10302 34 nature nature NN 40436 10302 35 . . . 40436 10303 1 All all PDT 40436 10303 2 these these DT 40436 10303 3 theories theory NNS 40436 10303 4 imply imply VBP 40436 10303 5 -- -- : 40436 10303 6 what what WP 40436 10303 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10303 8 announces announce VBZ 40436 10303 9 in in IN 40436 10303 10 the the DT 40436 10303 11 passage passage NN 40436 10303 12 just just RB 40436 10303 13 cited cite VBD 40436 10303 14 -- -- : 40436 10303 15 the the DT 40436 10303 16 deep deep RB 40436 10303 17 - - HYPH 40436 10303 18 seated seated JJ 40436 10303 19 influence influence NN 40436 10303 20 of of IN 40436 10303 21 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10303 22 curiosity curiosity NN 40436 10303 23 , , , 40436 10303 24 or or CC 40436 10303 25 the the DT 40436 10303 26 thirst thirst NN 40436 10303 27 for for IN 40436 10303 28 finding find VBG 40436 10303 29 the the DT 40436 10303 30 Why why WRB 40436 10303 31 of of IN 40436 10303 32 things thing NNS 40436 10303 33 and and CC 40436 10303 34 events event NNS 40436 10303 35 , , , 40436 10303 36 as as IN 40436 10303 37 a a DT 40436 10303 38 feeling feeling NN 40436 10303 39 of of IN 40436 10303 40 the the DT 40436 10303 41 human human JJ 40436 10303 42 mind mind NN 40436 10303 43 : : : 40436 10303 44 but but CC 40436 10303 45 all all DT 40436 10303 46 of of IN 40436 10303 47 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10303 48 indicate indicate VBP 40436 10303 49 the the DT 40436 10303 50 discrepant discrepant JJ 40436 10303 51 answers answer NNS 40436 10303 52 with with IN 40436 10303 53 which which WDT 40436 10303 54 , , , 40436 10303 55 in in IN 40436 10303 56 different different JJ 40436 10303 57 enquirers enquirer NNS 40436 10303 58 , , , 40436 10303 59 this this DT 40436 10303 60 feeling feeling NN 40436 10303 61 is be VBZ 40436 10303 62 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 10303 63 , , , 40436 10303 64 though though IN 40436 10303 65 under under IN 40436 10303 66 the the DT 40436 10303 67 same same JJ 40436 10303 68 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 10303 69 name name NN 40436 10303 70 _ _ NNP 40436 10303 71 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10303 72 _ _ NNP 40436 10303 73 . . . 40436 10304 1 And and CC 40436 10304 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10304 3 would would MD 40436 10304 4 have have VB 40436 10304 5 been be VBN 40436 10304 6 a a DT 40436 10304 7 proceeding proceeding NN 40436 10304 8 worthy worthy JJ 40436 10304 9 of of IN 40436 10304 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10304 11 's 's POS 40436 10304 12 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 10304 13 , , , 40436 10304 14 if if IN 40436 10304 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10304 16 had have VBD 40436 10304 17 applied apply VBN 40436 10304 18 to to IN 40436 10304 19 the the DT 40436 10304 20 word word NN 40436 10304 21 Cause cause VB 40436 10304 22 the the DT 40436 10304 23 same same JJ 40436 10304 24 cross cross NN 40436 10304 25 - - HYPH 40436 10304 26 examining examine VBG 40436 10304 27 analysis analysis NN 40436 10304 28 which which WDT 40436 10304 29 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10304 30 have have VBP 40436 10304 31 seen see VBN 40436 10304 32 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10304 33 applying apply VBG 40436 10304 34 to to IN 40436 10304 35 the the DT 40436 10304 36 equally equally RB 40436 10304 37 familiar familiar JJ 40436 10304 38 words word NNS 40436 10304 39 -- -- : 40436 10304 40 Virtue virtue NN 40436 10304 41 -- -- : 40436 10304 42 Courage courage NN 40436 10304 43 -- -- . 40436 10304 44 Temperance temperance NN 40436 10304 45 -- -- : 40436 10304 46 Friendship friendship NN 40436 10304 47 , , , 40436 10304 48 & & CC 40436 10304 49 c. c. NNP 40436 10304 50 " " `` 40436 10304 51 First first RB 40436 10304 52 , , , 40436 10304 53 let let VB 40436 10304 54 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10304 55 settle settle VB 40436 10304 56 what what WP 40436 10304 57 a a DT 40436 10304 58 Cause cause NN 40436 10304 59 really really RB 40436 10304 60 is be VBZ 40436 10304 61 : : : 40436 10304 62 then then RB 40436 10304 63 , , , 40436 10304 64 and and CC 40436 10304 65 not not RB 40436 10304 66 till till IN 40436 10304 67 then then RB 40436 10304 68 , , , 40436 10304 69 can can MD 40436 10304 70 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10304 71 succeed succeed VB 40436 10304 72 in in IN 40436 10304 73 ulterior ulterior JJ 40436 10304 74 enquiries enquiry NNS 40436 10304 75 respecting respect VBG 40436 10304 76 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10304 77 . . . 40436 10305 1 " " `` 40436 10305 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10305 3 76 76 CD 40436 10305 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10305 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10305 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10305 7 75 75 CD 40436 10305 8 : : : 40436 10305 9 Monboddo Monboddo NNP 40436 10305 10 , , , 40436 10305 11 Ancient Ancient NNP 40436 10305 12 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 40436 10305 13 , , , 40436 10305 14 B. B. NNP 40436 10306 1 1 1 LS 40436 10306 2 . . . 40436 10306 3 ch ch NN 40436 10306 4 . . . 40436 10307 1 iv iv XX 40436 10307 2 . . . 40436 10308 1 p. p. NN 40436 10308 2 32 32 CD 40436 10308 3 . . . 40436 10309 1 " " `` 40436 10309 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10309 3 appears appear VBZ 40436 10309 4 to to TO 40436 10309 5 have have VB 40436 10309 6 been be VBN 40436 10309 7 the the DT 40436 10309 8 first first JJ 40436 10309 9 of of IN 40436 10309 10 the the DT 40436 10309 11 Ionic Ionic NNP 40436 10309 12 School School NNP 40436 10309 13 that that WDT 40436 10309 14 introduced introduce VBD 40436 10309 15 _ _ NNP 40436 10309 16 formal formal JJ 40436 10309 17 causes cause NNS 40436 10309 18 _ _ NNP 40436 10309 19 into into IN 40436 10309 20 natural natural JJ 40436 10309 21 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10309 22 . . . 40436 10310 1 These these DT 40436 10310 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10310 3 called call VBD 40436 10310 4 _ _ NNP 40436 10310 5 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 10310 6 _ _ NNP 40436 10310 7 , , , 40436 10310 8 and and CC 40436 10310 9 made make VBD 40436 10310 10 the the DT 40436 10310 11 principles principle NNS 40436 10310 12 of of IN 40436 10310 13 all all DT 40436 10310 14 things thing NNS 40436 10310 15 . . . 40436 10311 1 And and CC 40436 10311 2 the the DT 40436 10311 3 reason reason NN 40436 10311 4 why why WRB 40436 10311 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10311 6 insists insist VBZ 40436 10311 7 so so RB 40436 10311 8 much much JJ 40436 10311 9 upon upon IN 40436 10311 10 this this DT 40436 10311 11 kind kind NN 40436 10311 12 of of IN 40436 10311 13 cause cause NN 40436 10311 14 , , , 40436 10311 15 and and CC 40436 10311 16 so so RB 40436 10311 17 little little JJ 40436 10311 18 upon upon IN 40436 10311 19 the the DT 40436 10311 20 other other JJ 40436 10311 21 three three CD 40436 10311 22 , , , 40436 10311 23 is be VBZ 40436 10311 24 given give VBN 40436 10311 25 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10311 26 by by IN 40436 10311 27 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10311 28 in in IN 40436 10311 29 the the DT 40436 10311 30 end end NN 40436 10311 31 of of IN 40436 10311 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10311 33 first first JJ 40436 10311 34 book book NN 40436 10311 35 of of IN 40436 10311 36 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 40436 10311 37 , , , 40436 10311 38 _ _ NNP 40436 10311 39 viz viz NN 40436 10311 40 . . . 40436 10311 41 _ _ NNP 40436 10311 42 , , , 40436 10311 43 that that IN 40436 10311 44 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10311 45 studied study VBD 40436 10311 46 mathematics mathematic NNS 40436 10311 47 too too RB 40436 10311 48 much much RB 40436 10311 49 , , , 40436 10311 50 and and CC 40436 10311 51 instead instead RB 40436 10311 52 of of IN 40436 10311 53 using use VBG 40436 10311 54 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10311 55 as as IN 40436 10311 56 the the DT 40436 10311 57 handmaid handmaid NN 40436 10311 58 of of IN 40436 10311 59 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10311 60 , , , 40436 10311 61 made make VBD 40436 10311 62 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10311 63 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10311 64 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10311 65 . . . 40436 10312 1 . . . 40436 10313 1 . . . 40436 10314 1 . . . 40436 10315 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10315 2 , , , 40436 10315 3 however however RB 40436 10315 4 , , , 40436 10315 5 in in IN 40436 10315 6 the the DT 40436 10315 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10315 8 says say VBZ 40436 10315 9 a a DT 40436 10315 10 good good JJ 40436 10315 11 deal deal NN 40436 10315 12 about about IN 40436 10315 13 final final JJ 40436 10315 14 causes cause NNS 40436 10315 15 ; ; : 40436 10315 16 but but CC 40436 10315 17 in in IN 40436 10315 18 the the DT 40436 10315 19 system system NN 40436 10315 20 of of IN 40436 10315 21 natural natural JJ 40436 10315 22 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10315 23 which which WDT 40436 10315 24 is be VBZ 40436 10315 25 in in IN 40436 10315 26 the the DT 40436 10315 27 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10315 28 , , , 40436 10315 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10315 30 says say VBZ 40436 10315 31 very very RB 40436 10315 32 little little JJ 40436 10315 33 of of IN 40436 10315 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10315 35 . . . 40436 10315 36 " " '' 40436 10316 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10316 2 have have VBP 40436 10316 3 already already RB 40436 10316 4 observed observe VBN 40436 10316 5 that that IN 40436 10316 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10316 7 in in IN 40436 10316 8 the the DT 40436 10316 9 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10316 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10316 11 48 48 CD 40436 10316 12 A a DT 40436 10316 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10316 14 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 10316 15 erratic erratic JJ 40436 10316 16 or or CC 40436 10316 17 irregular irregular JJ 40436 10316 18 Causation--[Greek causation--[greek NN 40436 10316 19 : : : 40436 10316 20 ê ê NNP 40436 10316 21 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10316 22 planôme planôme NNP 40436 10316 23 / / SYM 40436 10316 24 nê nê NNP 40436 10316 25 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10316 26 / / SYM 40436 10316 27 a a NNP 40436 10316 28 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10316 29 . . . 40436 10317 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10317 2 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 10317 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10317 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10317 5 : : : 40436 10317 6 Ai)ti ai)ti NN 40436 10317 7 / / SYM 40436 10317 8 a a NN 40436 10317 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10317 10 among among IN 40436 10317 11 the the DT 40436 10317 12 equivocal equivocal JJ 40436 10317 13 words word NNS 40436 10317 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10317 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10317 16 : : : 40436 10317 17 pollachô pollachô NNP 40436 10317 18 = = NFP 40436 10317 19 s s NNP 40436 10317 20 lego lego NNP 40436 10317 21 / / SYM 40436 10317 22 mena mena NNP 40436 10317 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10317 24 ; ; : 40436 10317 25 and and CC 40436 10317 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10317 27 enumerates enumerate VBZ 40436 10317 28 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10317 29 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10317 30 : : : 40436 10317 31 Tu Tu NNP 40436 10317 32 / / SYM 40436 10317 33 chê chê NNP 40436 10317 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10317 35 and and CC 40436 10317 36 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10317 37 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10317 38 : : : 40436 10317 39 Au)to Au)to NNP 40436 10317 40 / / SYM 40436 10317 41 maton]--irregular maton]--irregular NNP 40436 10317 42 causes cause NNS 40436 10317 43 or or CC 40436 10317 44 causes cause NNS 40436 10317 45 by by IN 40436 10317 46 accident accident NN 40436 10317 47 -- -- : 40436 10317 48 among among IN 40436 10317 49 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10317 50 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10317 51 Physic Physic NNP 40436 10317 52 . . . 40436 10318 1 ii ii LS 40436 10318 2 . . . 40436 10319 1 195 195 CD 40436 10319 2 - - SYM 40436 10319 3 198 198 CD 40436 10319 4 ; ; : 40436 10319 5 Metaphys Metaphys NNP 40436 10319 6 . . . 40436 10320 1 K. K. NNP 40436 10320 2 1065 1065 CD 40436 10320 3 , , , 40436 10320 4 a. a. NN 40436 10320 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10321 1 Schwegler Schwegler NNP 40436 10321 2 , , , 40436 10321 3 ad ad NN 40436 10321 4 Aristot Aristot NNP 40436 10321 5 . . . 40436 10322 1 Metaphys metaphys RB 40436 10322 2 . . . 40436 10323 1 vi vi NNP 40436 10323 2 . . . 40436 10324 1 4 4 CD 40436 10324 2 , , , 40436 10324 3 3 3 CD 40436 10324 4 , , , 40436 10324 5 " " `` 40436 10324 6 Das Das NNP 40436 10324 7 Zufällige Zufällige NNP 40436 10324 8 ist ist NN 40436 10324 9 ein ein NN 40436 10324 10 nothwendiges nothwendige NNS 40436 10324 11 Element Element NNP 40436 10324 12 alles alle VBZ 40436 10324 13 Geschehens Geschehens NNPS 40436 10324 14 " " '' 40436 10324 15 . . . 40436 10325 1 Alexander Alexander NNP 40436 10325 2 of of IN 40436 10325 3 Aphrodisias Aphrodisias NNP 40436 10325 4 , , , 40436 10325 5 the the DT 40436 10325 6 best good JJS 40436 10325 7 of of IN 40436 10325 8 the the DT 40436 10325 9 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40436 10325 10 commentators commentator NNS 40436 10325 11 , , , 40436 10325 12 is be VBZ 40436 10325 13 at at IN 40436 10325 14 pains pain NNS 40436 10325 15 to to TO 40436 10325 16 defend defend VB 40436 10325 17 this this DT 40436 10325 18 view view NN 40436 10325 19 of of IN 40436 10325 20 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10325 21 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10325 22 : : : 40436 10325 23 Tu Tu NNP 40436 10325 24 / / SYM 40436 10325 25 chê]--Causation chê]--causation NN 40436 10325 26 by by IN 40436 10325 27 accident accident NN 40436 10325 28 , , , 40436 10325 29 or or CC 40436 10325 30 irregular irregular JJ 40436 10325 31 . . . 40436 10326 1 Proklus proklus NN 40436 10326 2 , , , 40436 10326 3 in in IN 40436 10326 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10326 5 Commentary Commentary NNP 40436 10326 6 on on IN 40436 10326 7 the the DT 40436 10326 8 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10326 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10326 10 ii ii NN 40436 10326 11 . . . 40436 10327 1 80 80 CD 40436 10327 2 - - SYM 40436 10327 3 81 81 CD 40436 10327 4 , , , 40436 10327 5 p. p. NN 40436 10327 6 188 188 CD 40436 10327 7 , , , 40436 10327 8 Schneider Schneider NNP 40436 10327 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10327 10 , , , 40436 10327 11 notices notice VBZ 40436 10327 12 the the DT 40436 10327 13 labour labour NN 40436 10327 14 and and CC 40436 10327 15 prolixity prolixity NN 40436 10327 16 with with IN 40436 10327 17 which which WDT 40436 10327 18 the the DT 40436 10327 19 commentators commentator NNS 40436 10327 20 before before IN 40436 10327 21 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10327 22 set set VBD 40436 10327 23 out out RP 40436 10327 24 the the DT 40436 10327 25 different different JJ 40436 10327 26 varieties variety NNS 40436 10327 27 of of IN 40436 10327 28 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10327 29 ; ; : 40436 10327 30 distinguishing distinguish VBG 40436 10327 31 sixty sixty CD 40436 10327 32 - - HYPH 40436 10327 33 four four CD 40436 10327 34 according accord VBG 40436 10327 35 to to IN 40436 10327 36 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10327 37 , , , 40436 10327 38 and and CC 40436 10327 39 forty forty CD 40436 10327 40 - - HYPH 40436 10327 41 eight eight CD 40436 10327 42 according accord VBG 40436 10327 43 to to IN 40436 10327 44 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10327 45 . . . 40436 10328 1 Proklus proklus JJ 40436 10328 2 adverts advert NNS 40436 10328 3 also also RB 40436 10328 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10328 5 ad ad NN 40436 10328 6 Timæum Timæum NNP 40436 10328 7 , , , 40436 10328 8 iii iii NNP 40436 10328 9 . . . 40436 10329 1 p. p. NN 40436 10329 2 176 176 CD 40436 10329 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10329 4 to to IN 40436 10329 5 an an DT 40436 10329 6 animated animate VBN 40436 10329 7 controversy controversy NN 40436 10329 8 raised raise VBN 40436 10329 9 by by IN 40436 10329 10 Theophrastus Theophrastus NNP 40436 10329 11 against against IN 40436 10329 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10329 13 , , , 40436 10329 14 about about IN 40436 10329 15 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10329 16 and and CC 40436 10329 17 the the DT 40436 10329 18 speculations speculation NNS 40436 10329 19 thereupon thereupon RB 40436 10329 20 . . . 40436 10330 1 An an DT 40436 10330 2 enumeration enumeration NN 40436 10330 3 , , , 40436 10330 4 though though IN 40436 10330 5 very very RB 40436 10330 6 incomplete incomplete JJ 40436 10330 7 , , , 40436 10330 8 of of IN 40436 10330 9 the the DT 40436 10330 10 different different JJ 40436 10330 11 meanings meaning NNS 40436 10330 12 assigned assign VBN 40436 10330 13 to to IN 40436 10330 14 the the DT 40436 10330 15 word word NN 40436 10330 16 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10330 17 , , , 40436 10330 18 may may MD 40436 10330 19 be be VB 40436 10330 20 seen see VBN 40436 10330 21 in in IN 40436 10330 22 Professor Professor NNP 40436 10330 23 Fleming Fleming NNP 40436 10330 24 's 's POS 40436 10330 25 Vocabulary Vocabulary NNP 40436 10330 26 of of IN 40436 10330 27 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 40436 10330 28 . . . 40436 10330 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10331 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10331 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10331 3 76 76 CD 40436 10331 4 : : : 40436 10331 5 See see VB 40436 10331 6 Sir Sir NNP 40436 10331 7 William William NNP 40436 10331 8 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 40436 10331 9 , , , 40436 10331 10 Discussions Discussions NNP 40436 10331 11 on on IN 40436 10331 12 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 40436 10331 13 , , , 40436 10331 14 Appendix Appendix NNP 40436 10331 15 , , , 40436 10331 16 p. p. NN 40436 10331 17 585 585 CD 40436 10331 18 . . . 40436 10332 1 The the DT 40436 10332 2 debates debate NNS 40436 10332 3 about about IN 40436 10332 4 what what WP 40436 10332 5 was be VBD 40436 10332 6 meant mean VBN 40436 10332 7 in in IN 40436 10332 8 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10332 9 by by IN 40436 10332 10 the the DT 40436 10332 11 word word NN 40436 10332 12 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10332 13 are be VBP 40436 10332 14 certainly certainly RB 40436 10332 15 older old JJR 40436 10332 16 than than IN 40436 10332 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10332 18 . . . 40436 10333 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10333 2 read read VBP 40436 10333 3 that that IN 40436 10333 4 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10333 5 was be VBD 40436 10333 6 discussed discuss VBN 40436 10333 7 among among IN 40436 10333 8 the the DT 40436 10333 9 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10333 10 who who WP 40436 10333 11 frequented frequent VBD 40436 10333 12 the the DT 40436 10333 13 house house NN 40436 10333 14 of of IN 40436 10333 15 Perikles Perikles NNPS 40436 10333 16 ; ; : 40436 10333 17 and and CC 40436 10333 18 that that IN 40436 10333 19 that that DT 40436 10333 20 eminent eminent NNP 40436 10333 21 statesman statesman NN 40436 10333 22 was be VBD 40436 10333 23 ridiculed ridicule VBN 40436 10333 24 by by IN 40436 10333 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10333 26 dissolute dissolute NN 40436 10333 27 son son NN 40436 10333 28 Xanthippus Xanthippus NNP 40436 10333 29 for for IN 40436 10333 30 taking take VBG 40436 10333 31 part part NN 40436 10333 32 in in IN 40436 10333 33 such such JJ 40436 10333 34 useless useless JJ 40436 10333 35 refinements refinement NNS 40436 10333 36 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10333 37 Plutarch Plutarch NNP 40436 10333 38 , , , 40436 10333 39 Perikles Perikles NNP 40436 10333 40 , , , 40436 10333 41 c. c. NN 40436 10333 42 36 36 CD 40436 10333 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10333 44 . . . 40436 10334 1 But but CC 40436 10334 2 the the DT 40436 10334 3 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10334 4 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 10334 5 are be VBP 40436 10334 6 the the DT 40436 10334 7 oldest old JJS 40436 10334 8 compositions composition NNS 40436 10334 9 in in IN 40436 10334 10 which which WDT 40436 10334 11 any any DT 40436 10334 12 attempts attempt NNS 40436 10334 13 to to TO 40436 10334 14 analyse analyse VB 40436 10334 15 the the DT 40436 10334 16 meaning meaning NN 40436 10334 17 of of IN 40436 10334 18 the the DT 40436 10334 19 word word NN 40436 10334 20 are be VBP 40436 10334 21 preserved preserve VBN 40436 10334 22 to to IN 40436 10334 23 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10334 24 . . . 40436 10335 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10335 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10335 3 : : : 40436 10335 4 Ai)/tiai Ai)/tiai NNP 40436 10335 5 , , , 40436 10335 6 A)rchai/ A)rchai/ NNP 40436 10335 7 , , , 40436 10335 8 Stoichei Stoichei NNP 40436 10335 9 = = NFP 40436 10335 10 a a LS 40436 10335 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10335 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10335 13 Aristot Aristot NNP 40436 10335 14 . . . 40436 10336 1 Metaph Metaph NNP 40436 10336 2 . . . 40436 10337 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10337 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10337 3 : : : 40436 10337 4 D d NN 40436 10337 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10337 6 . . . 40436 10338 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10338 2 , , , 40436 10338 3 were be VBD 40436 10338 4 the the DT 40436 10338 5 main main JJ 40436 10338 6 objects object NNS 40436 10338 7 of of IN 40436 10338 8 search search NN 40436 10338 9 with with IN 40436 10338 10 the the DT 40436 10338 11 ancient ancient JJ 40436 10338 12 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10338 13 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10338 14 . . . 40436 10339 1 While while IN 40436 10339 2 all all DT 40436 10339 3 of of IN 40436 10339 4 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10339 5 set set VBP 40436 10339 6 to to IN 40436 10339 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10339 8 the the DT 40436 10339 9 same same JJ 40436 10339 10 problem problem NN 40436 10339 11 , , , 40436 10339 12 each each DT 40436 10339 13 of of IN 40436 10339 14 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10339 15 hit hit VBP 40436 10339 16 upon upon IN 40436 10339 17 a a DT 40436 10339 18 different different JJ 40436 10339 19 solution solution NN 40436 10339 20 . . . 40436 10340 1 That that DT 40436 10340 2 which which WDT 40436 10340 3 gave give VBD 40436 10340 4 mental mental JJ 40436 10340 5 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10340 6 to to IN 40436 10340 7 one one CD 40436 10340 8 , , , 40436 10340 9 appeared appear VBD 40436 10340 10 unsatisfactory unsatisfactory JJ 40436 10340 11 and and CC 40436 10340 12 even even RB 40436 10340 13 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 40436 10340 14 to to IN 40436 10340 15 the the DT 40436 10340 16 rest rest NN 40436 10340 17 . . . 40436 10341 1 The the DT 40436 10341 2 first first JJ 40436 10341 3 book book NN 40436 10341 4 of of IN 40436 10341 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10341 6 's 's POS 40436 10341 7 Metaphysica Metaphysica NNP 40436 10341 8 gives give VBZ 40436 10341 9 an an DT 40436 10341 10 instructive instructive JJ 40436 10341 11 view view NN 40436 10341 12 of of IN 40436 10341 13 this this DT 40436 10341 14 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40436 10341 15 . . . 40436 10342 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10342 2 own own JJ 40436 10342 3 analysis analysis NN 40436 10342 4 of of IN 40436 10342 5 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10342 6 will will MD 40436 10342 7 come come VB 40436 10342 8 before before IN 40436 10342 9 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10342 10 hereafter hereafter RB 40436 10342 11 . . . 40436 10343 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10343 2 the the DT 40436 10343 3 long long JJ 40436 10343 4 discussions discussion NNS 40436 10343 5 on on IN 40436 10343 6 the the DT 40436 10343 7 subject subject NN 40436 10343 8 in in IN 40436 10343 9 Sextus Sextus NNP 40436 10343 10 Empiricus Empiricus NNP 40436 10343 11 , , , 40436 10343 12 Pyrrhon Pyrrhon NNP 40436 10343 13 . . . 40436 10344 1 Hypo Hypo NNP 40436 10344 2 . . . 40436 10345 1 iii iii NNP 40436 10345 2 . . . 40436 10346 1 13 13 CD 40436 10346 2 - - SYM 40436 10346 3 30 30 CD 40436 10346 4 ; ; : 40436 10346 5 and and CC 40436 10346 6 adv adv NNP 40436 10346 7 . . . 40436 10347 1 Mathemat mathemat NN 40436 10347 2 . . . 40436 10348 1 ix ix IN 40436 10348 2 . . . 40436 10349 1 195 195 CD 40436 10349 2 - - HYPH 40436 10349 3 250 250 CD 40436 10349 4 . . . 40436 10350 1 The the DT 40436 10350 2 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40436 10350 3 was be VBD 40436 10350 4 so so RB 40436 10350 5 great great JJ 40436 10350 6 among among IN 40436 10350 7 the the DT 40436 10350 8 dogmatical dogmatical JJ 40436 10350 9 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10350 10 , , , 40436 10350 11 that that IN 40436 10350 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10350 13 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 10350 14 the the DT 40436 10350 15 reality reality NN 40436 10350 16 of of IN 40436 10350 17 the the DT 40436 10350 18 causal causal JJ 40436 10350 19 sequence sequence NN 40436 10350 20 to to TO 40436 10350 21 be be VB 40436 10350 22 indeterminable--[Greek indeterminable--[greek CD 40436 10350 23 : : : 40436 10350 24 o(/son o(/son NNP 40436 10350 25 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10350 26 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 10350 27 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 10350 28 toi toi NNP 40436 10350 29 = = SYM 40436 10350 30 s s NNP 40436 10350 31 legome legome NNP 40436 10350 32 / / SYM 40436 10350 33 nois nois NNP 40436 10350 34 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 10350 35 tô tô NNP 40436 10350 36 = = SYM 40436 10350 37 n n NN 40436 10350 38 dogmatikô dogmatikô NN 40436 10350 39 = = SYM 40436 10350 40 n n JJ 40436 10350 41 , , , 40436 10350 42 ou)d ou)d JJ 40436 10350 43 ' ' POS 40436 10350 44 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 10350 45 e)nnoê e)nnoê ADD 40436 10350 46 = = -RRB- 40436 10350 47 sai/ sai/ NNP 40436 10350 48 tis tis NNP 40436 10350 49 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10350 50 ai)/tion ai)/tion NNP 40436 10350 51 du du NNP 40436 10350 52 / / SYM 40436 10350 53 naito naito NNP 40436 10350 54 , , , 40436 10350 55 ei)/ ei)/ NNP 40436 10350 56 ge ge NNP 40436 10350 57 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 10350 58 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 10350 59 diaphô diaphô NNP 40436 10350 60 / / SYM 40436 10350 61 nous nous NNP 40436 10350 62 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10350 63 a)lloko a)lloko NNP 40436 10350 64 / / SYM 40436 10350 65 tous tous JJ 40436 10350 66 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10350 67 a)podido a)podido NNP 40436 10350 68 / / SYM 40436 10350 69 nai nai NNP 40436 10350 70 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10350 71 e)nnoi e)nnoi NNP 40436 10350 72 / / SYM 40436 10350 73 as as IN 40436 10350 74 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10350 75 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10350 76 / / SYM 40436 10350 77 ou ou NNP 40436 10350 78 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 10350 79 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10350 80 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10350 81 u(po u(po NNP 40436 10350 82 / / SYM 40436 10350 83 stasin stasin NNP 40436 10350 84 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 10350 85 pepoiê pepoiê NNP 40436 10350 86 / / SYM 40436 10350 87 kasin kasin NNP 40436 10350 88 a)neu a)neu NNP 40436 10350 89 / / SYM 40436 10350 90 reton reton NNP 40436 10350 91 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 10350 92 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10350 93 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 10350 94 au)to\ au)to\ NNP 40436 10350 95 diaphôni diaphôni NNP 40436 10350 96 / / SYM 40436 10350 97 an an DT 40436 10350 98 . . . 40436 10350 99 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10351 1 Seneca Seneca NNP 40436 10351 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10351 3 Epist epist UH 40436 10351 4 . . . 40436 10352 1 65 65 LS 40436 10352 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10352 3 blends blend NNS 40436 10352 4 together together RB 40436 10352 5 the the DT 40436 10352 6 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10352 7 and and CC 40436 10352 8 the the DT 40436 10352 9 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40436 10352 10 views view NNS 40436 10352 11 , , , 40436 10352 12 when when WRB 40436 10352 13 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10352 14 ascribes ascribe VBZ 40436 10352 15 to to IN 40436 10352 16 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10352 17 a a DT 40436 10352 18 quintuple quintuple JJ 40436 10352 19 variety variety NN 40436 10352 20 of of IN 40436 10352 21 Causa Causa NNP 40436 10352 22 . . . 40436 10353 1 The the DT 40436 10353 2 quadruple quadruple JJ 40436 10353 3 variety variety NN 40436 10353 4 of of IN 40436 10353 5 Causation Causation NNP 40436 10353 6 established establish VBN 40436 10353 7 by by IN 40436 10353 8 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10353 9 governed govern VBD 40436 10353 10 the the DT 40436 10353 11 speculations speculation NNS 40436 10353 12 of of IN 40436 10353 13 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10353 14 during during IN 40436 10353 15 the the DT 40436 10353 16 middle middle JJ 40436 10353 17 ages age NNS 40436 10353 18 . . . 40436 10354 1 But but CC 40436 10354 2 since since IN 40436 10354 3 the the DT 40436 10354 4 decline decline NN 40436 10354 5 of of IN 40436 10354 6 the the DT 40436 10354 7 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 40436 10354 8 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10354 9 , , , 40436 10354 10 there there EX 40436 10354 11 are be VBP 40436 10354 12 few few JJ 40436 10354 13 subjects subject NNS 40436 10354 14 which which WDT 40436 10354 15 have have VBP 40436 10354 16 been be VBN 40436 10354 17 more more RBR 40436 10354 18 keenly keenly RB 40436 10354 19 debated debate VBN 40436 10354 20 among among IN 40436 10354 21 metaphysicians metaphysician NNS 40436 10354 22 than than IN 40436 10354 23 the the DT 40436 10354 24 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10354 25 of of IN 40436 10354 26 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10354 27 . . . 40436 10355 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10355 2 is be VBZ 40436 10355 3 one one CD 40436 10355 4 of of IN 40436 10355 5 the the DT 40436 10355 6 principal principal JJ 40436 10355 7 points point NNS 40436 10355 8 of of IN 40436 10355 9 divergence divergence NN 40436 10355 10 among among IN 40436 10355 11 the the DT 40436 10355 12 different different JJ 40436 10355 13 schools school NNS 40436 10355 14 of of IN 40436 10355 15 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10355 16 now now RB 40436 10355 17 existing exist VBG 40436 10355 18 . . . 40436 10356 1 A a DT 40436 10356 2 volume volume NN 40436 10356 3 , , , 40436 10356 4 and and CC 40436 10356 5 a a DT 40436 10356 6 very very RB 40436 10356 7 instructive instructive JJ 40436 10356 8 volume volume NN 40436 10356 9 , , , 40436 10356 10 might may MD 40436 10356 11 be be VB 40436 10356 12 filled fill VBN 40436 10356 13 with with IN 40436 10356 14 the the DT 40436 10356 15 enumeration enumeration NN 40436 10356 16 and and CC 40436 10356 17 contrast contrast NN 40436 10356 18 of of IN 40436 10356 19 the the DT 40436 10356 20 different different JJ 40436 10356 21 theories theory NNS 40436 10356 22 on on IN 40436 10356 23 the the DT 40436 10356 24 subject subject NN 40436 10356 25 . . . 40436 10357 1 Upon upon IN 40436 10357 2 the the DT 40436 10357 3 view view NN 40436 10357 4 which which WDT 40436 10357 5 a a DT 40436 10357 6 man man NN 40436 10357 7 takes take VBZ 40436 10357 8 on on RP 40436 10357 9 this this DT 40436 10357 10 point point NN 40436 10357 11 will will MD 40436 10357 12 depend depend VB 40436 10357 13 mainly mainly RB 40436 10357 14 the the DT 40436 10357 15 scope scope NN 40436 10357 16 or or CC 40436 10357 17 purpose purpose NN 40436 10357 18 which which WDT 40436 10357 19 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10357 20 sets set VBZ 40436 10357 21 before before IN 40436 10357 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10357 23 in in IN 40436 10357 24 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10357 25 . . . 40436 10358 1 Many many JJ 40436 10358 2 seek seek VBP 40436 10358 3 the the DT 40436 10358 4 solution solution NN 40436 10358 5 of of IN 40436 10358 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10358 7 problem problem NN 40436 10358 8 in in IN 40436 10358 9 transcendental transcendental JJ 40436 10358 10 , , , 40436 10358 11 ontological ontological JJ 40436 10358 12 , , , 40436 10358 13 extra extra JJ 40436 10358 14 - - HYPH 40436 10358 15 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 40436 10358 16 causes cause NNS 40436 10358 17 , , , 40436 10358 18 lying lie VBG 40436 10358 19 apart apart RB 40436 10358 20 from from IN 40436 10358 21 and and CC 40436 10358 22 above above IN 40436 10358 23 the the DT 40436 10358 24 world world NN 40436 10358 25 of of IN 40436 10358 26 fact fact NN 40436 10358 27 and and CC 40436 10358 28 experience experience NN 40436 10358 29 ; ; : 40436 10358 30 Reid Reid NNP 40436 10358 31 and and CC 40436 10358 32 Stewart Stewart NNP 40436 10358 33 , , , 40436 10358 34 while while IN 40436 10358 35 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 40436 10358 36 the the DT 40436 10358 37 existence existence NN 40436 10358 38 of of IN 40436 10358 39 such such JJ 40436 10358 40 causes cause NNS 40436 10358 41 as as IN 40436 10358 42 the the DT 40436 10358 43 true true JJ 40436 10358 44 efficient efficient JJ 40436 10358 45 causes cause NNS 40436 10358 46 , , , 40436 10358 47 consider consider VB 40436 10358 48 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10358 49 as as IN 40436 10358 50 being be VBG 40436 10358 51 out out IN 40436 10358 52 of of IN 40436 10358 53 the the DT 40436 10358 54 reach reach NN 40436 10358 55 of of IN 40436 10358 56 human human JJ 40436 10358 57 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10358 58 ; ; : 40436 10358 59 others other NNS 40436 10358 60 recognise recognise VBP 40436 10358 61 no no DT 40436 10358 62 true true JJ 40436 10358 63 cause cause NN 40436 10358 64 except except IN 40436 10358 65 personal personal JJ 40436 10358 66 , , , 40436 10358 67 quasi quasi JJ 40436 10358 68 - - JJ 40436 10358 69 human human JJ 40436 10358 70 , , , 40436 10358 71 voluntary voluntary JJ 40436 10358 72 , , , 40436 10358 73 agency agency NN 40436 10358 74 , , , 40436 10358 75 grounded ground VBN 40436 10358 76 on on IN 40436 10358 77 the the DT 40436 10358 78 type type NN 40436 10358 79 of of IN 40436 10358 80 human human JJ 40436 10358 81 volition volition NN 40436 10358 82 . . . 40436 10359 1 Others other NNS 40436 10359 2 , , , 40436 10359 3 again again RB 40436 10359 4 , , , 40436 10359 5 with with IN 40436 10359 6 whom whom WP 40436 10359 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10359 8 own own JJ 40436 10359 9 opinion opinion NN 40436 10359 10 coincides coincide NNS 40436 10359 11 , , , 40436 10359 12 following follow VBG 40436 10359 13 out out RP 40436 10359 14 the the DT 40436 10359 15 analysis analysis NN 40436 10359 16 of of IN 40436 10359 17 Hume Hume NNP 40436 10359 18 and and CC 40436 10359 19 Brown Brown NNP 40436 10359 20 , , , 40436 10359 21 understand understand VBP 40436 10359 22 by by IN 40436 10359 23 causes cause VBZ 40436 10359 24 nothing nothing NN 40436 10359 25 more more JJR 40436 10359 26 than than IN 40436 10359 27 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 40436 10359 28 antecedents antecedent NNS 40436 10359 29 constant constant JJ 40436 10359 30 and and CC 40436 10359 31 unconditional unconditional JJ 40436 10359 32 , , , 40436 10359 33 ascertainable ascertainable JJ 40436 10359 34 by by IN 40436 10359 35 experience experience NN 40436 10359 36 and and CC 40436 10359 37 induction induction NN 40436 10359 38 . . . 40436 10360 1 See see VB 40436 10360 2 the the DT 40436 10360 3 copious copious JJ 40436 10360 4 and and CC 40436 10360 5 elaborate elaborate JJ 40436 10360 6 chapter chapter NN 40436 10360 7 on on IN 40436 10360 8 this this DT 40436 10360 9 subject subject NN 40436 10360 10 in in IN 40436 10360 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 40436 10360 12 John John NNP 40436 10360 13 Stuart Stuart NNP 40436 10360 14 Mill Mill NNP 40436 10360 15 's 's POS 40436 10360 16 ' ' '' 40436 10360 17 System System NNP 40436 10360 18 of of IN 40436 10360 19 Logic Logic NNP 40436 10360 20 , , , 40436 10360 21 ' ' '' 40436 10360 22 Book book NN 40436 10360 23 iii iii NNP 40436 10360 24 . . . 40436 10361 1 ch ch NNP 40436 10361 2 . . . 40436 10362 1 5 5 CD 40436 10362 2 , , , 40436 10362 3 especially especially RB 40436 10362 4 as as IN 40436 10362 5 enlarged enlarge VBN 40436 10362 6 in in IN 40436 10362 7 the the DT 40436 10362 8 fourth fourth JJ 40436 10362 9 , , , 40436 10362 10 fifth fifth JJ 40436 10362 11 , , , 40436 10362 12 and and CC 40436 10362 13 sixth sixth JJ 40436 10362 14 editions edition NNS 40436 10362 15 of of IN 40436 10362 16 that that DT 40436 10362 17 work work NN 40436 10362 18 , , , 40436 10362 19 including include VBG 40436 10362 20 the the DT 40436 10362 21 criticism criticism NN 40436 10362 22 on on IN 40436 10362 23 the the DT 40436 10362 24 opposite opposite JJ 40436 10362 25 or or CC 40436 10362 26 volitional volitional JJ 40436 10362 27 theory theory NN 40436 10362 28 of of IN 40436 10362 29 Causation causation NN 40436 10362 30 ; ; : 40436 10362 31 also also RB 40436 10362 32 the the DT 40436 10362 33 work work NN 40436 10362 34 of of IN 40436 10362 35 Professor Professor NNP 40436 10362 36 Bain Bain NNP 40436 10362 37 , , , 40436 10362 38 ' ' '' 40436 10362 39 The the DT 40436 10362 40 Emotions Emotions NNPS 40436 10362 41 and and CC 40436 10362 42 the the DT 40436 10362 43 Will Will NNP 40436 10362 44 , , , 40436 10362 45 ' ' '' 40436 10362 46 pp pp XX 40436 10362 47 . . . 40436 10363 1 472 472 CD 40436 10363 2 - - SYM 40436 10363 3 584 584 CD 40436 10363 4 . . . 40436 10364 1 The the DT 40436 10364 2 opposite opposite JJ 40436 10364 3 view view NN 40436 10364 4 , , , 40436 10364 5 in in IN 40436 10364 6 which which WDT 40436 10364 7 Causes cause NNS 40436 10364 8 are be VBP 40436 10364 9 treated treat VBN 40436 10364 10 as as IN 40436 10364 11 something something NN 40436 10364 12 essentially essentially RB 40436 10364 13 distinct distinct JJ 40436 10364 14 from from IN 40436 10364 15 Laws Laws NNPS 40436 10364 16 , , , 40436 10364 17 and and CC 40436 10364 18 as as IN 40436 10364 19 ultra ultra JJ 40436 10364 20 - - JJ 40436 10364 21 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 40436 10364 22 , , , 40436 10364 23 is be VBZ 40436 10364 24 set set VBN 40436 10364 25 forth forth RP 40436 10364 26 by by IN 40436 10364 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 10364 28 Whewell Whewell NNP 40436 10364 29 , , , 40436 10364 30 ' ' '' 40436 10364 31 Novum Novum NNP 40436 10364 32 Organon Organon NNP 40436 10364 33 Renovatum Renovatum NNP 40436 10364 34 , , , 40436 10364 35 ' ' '' 40436 10364 36 ch ch NN 40436 10364 37 . . . 40436 10365 1 vii vii NN 40436 10365 2 . . . 40436 10366 1 p. p. NN 40436 10366 2 118 118 CD 40436 10366 3 seq seq NN 40436 10366 4 . . . 40436 10366 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10367 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10367 2 Side side NN 40436 10367 3 - - HYPH 40436 10367 4 note note NN 40436 10367 5 : : : 40436 10367 6 Last last JJ 40436 10367 7 transition transition NN 40436 10367 8 of of IN 40436 10367 9 the the DT 40436 10367 10 mind mind NN 40436 10367 11 of of IN 40436 10367 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10367 13 from from IN 40436 10367 14 things thing NNS 40436 10367 15 to to IN 40436 10367 16 words word NNS 40436 10367 17 -- -- : 40436 10367 18 to to IN 40436 10367 19 the the DT 40436 10367 20 adoption adoption NN 40436 10367 21 of of IN 40436 10367 22 the the DT 40436 10367 23 theory theory NN 40436 10367 24 of of IN 40436 10367 25 ideas idea NNS 40436 10367 26 . . . 40436 10368 1 Great great JJ 40436 10368 2 multitude multitude NN 40436 10368 3 of of IN 40436 10368 4 ideas idea NNS 40436 10368 5 assumed assume VBN 40436 10368 6 , , , 40436 10368 7 each each DT 40436 10368 8 fitting fit VBG 40436 10368 9 a a DT 40436 10368 10 certain certain JJ 40436 10368 11 number number NN 40436 10368 12 of of IN 40436 10368 13 particulars particular NNS 40436 10368 14 . . . 40436 10368 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10369 1 There there EX 40436 10369 2 is be VBZ 40436 10369 3 yet yet RB 40436 10369 4 another another DT 40436 10369 5 point point NN 40436 10369 6 which which WDT 40436 10369 7 deserves deserve VBZ 40436 10369 8 attention attention NN 40436 10369 9 in in IN 40436 10369 10 this this DT 40436 10369 11 history history NN 40436 10369 12 given give VBN 40436 10369 13 by by IN 40436 10369 14 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10369 15 of of IN 40436 10369 16 the the DT 40436 10369 17 transitions transition NNS 40436 10369 18 of of IN 40436 10369 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10369 20 own own JJ 40436 10369 21 mind mind NN 40436 10369 22 . . . 40436 10370 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10370 2 last last JJ 40436 10370 3 transition transition NN 40436 10370 4 is be VBZ 40436 10370 5 represented represent VBN 40436 10370 6 as as IN 40436 10370 7 one one CD 40436 10370 8 from from IN 40436 10370 9 things thing NNS 40436 10370 10 to to IN 40436 10370 11 words word NNS 40436 10370 12 , , , 40436 10370 13 that that RB 40436 10370 14 is is RB 40436 10370 15 , , , 40436 10370 16 to to IN 40436 10370 17 general general JJ 40436 10370 18 propositions:[77 propositions:[77 NNP 40436 10370 19 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10370 20 to to IN 40436 10370 21 the the DT 40436 10370 22 assumption assumption NN 40436 10370 23 in in IN 40436 10370 24 each each DT 40436 10370 25 case case NN 40436 10370 26 of of IN 40436 10370 27 an an DT 40436 10370 28 universal universal JJ 40436 10370 29 proposition proposition NN 40436 10370 30 or or CC 40436 10370 31 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10370 32 calculated calculate VBN 40436 10370 33 to to TO 40436 10370 34 fit fit VB 40436 10370 35 that that DT 40436 10370 36 case case NN 40436 10370 37 . . . 40436 10371 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10371 2 does do VBZ 40436 10371 3 not not RB 40436 10371 4 seem seem VB 40436 10371 5 to to TO 40436 10371 6 consider consider VB 40436 10371 7 the the DT 40436 10371 8 optimistic optimistic JJ 40436 10371 9 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10371 10 , , , 40436 10371 11 which which WDT 40436 10371 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10371 13 had have VBD 40436 10371 14 before before IN 40436 10371 15 vainly vainly RB 40436 10371 16 endeavoured endeavour VBN 40436 10371 17 to to TO 40436 10371 18 follow follow VB 40436 10371 19 out out RP 40436 10371 20 , , , 40436 10371 21 as as IN 40436 10371 22 having have VBG 40436 10371 23 been be VBN 40436 10371 24 an an DT 40436 10371 25 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10371 26 , , , 40436 10371 27 or or CC 40436 10371 28 universal universal JJ 40436 10371 29 proposition proposition NN 40436 10371 30 assumed assume VBD 40436 10371 31 as as IN 40436 10371 32 true true JJ 40436 10371 33 and and CC 40436 10371 34 as as IN 40436 10371 35 a a DT 40436 10371 36 principle principle NN 40436 10371 37 from from IN 40436 10371 38 which which WDT 40436 10371 39 to to TO 40436 10371 40 deduce deduce VB 40436 10371 41 consequences consequence NNS 40436 10371 42 . . . 40436 10372 1 Even even RB 40436 10372 2 if if IN 40436 10372 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10372 4 were be VBD 40436 10372 5 so so RB 40436 10372 6 , , , 40436 10372 7 however however RB 40436 10372 8 , , , 40436 10372 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10372 10 was be VBD 40436 10372 11 one one CD 40436 10372 12 and and CC 40436 10372 13 the the DT 40436 10372 14 same same JJ 40436 10372 15 assumption assumption NN 40436 10372 16 intended intend VBN 40436 10372 17 to to TO 40436 10372 18 suit suit VB 40436 10372 19 all all DT 40436 10372 20 cases case NNS 40436 10372 21 : : : 40436 10372 22 whereas whereas IN 40436 10372 23 the the DT 40436 10372 24 new new JJ 40436 10372 25 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10372 26 to to TO 40436 10372 27 which which WDT 40436 10372 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10372 29 passed pass VBD 40436 10372 30 included include VBD 40436 10372 31 many many JJ 40436 10372 32 distinct distinct JJ 40436 10372 33 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 10372 34 , , , 40436 10372 35 each each DT 40436 10372 36 adapted adapt VBD 40436 10372 37 to to IN 40436 10372 38 a a DT 40436 10372 39 certain certain JJ 40436 10372 40 number number NN 40436 10372 41 of of IN 40436 10372 42 cases case NNS 40436 10372 43 and and CC 40436 10372 44 not not RB 40436 10372 45 to to IN 40436 10372 46 the the DT 40436 10372 47 rest rest NN 40436 10372 48 . . . 40436 10373 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10373 2 78 78 CD 40436 10373 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10373 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10373 5 assumed assume VBD 40436 10373 6 an an DT 40436 10373 7 untold untold JJ 40436 10373 8 multitude multitude NN 40436 10373 9 of of IN 40436 10373 10 self self NN 40436 10373 11 - - HYPH 40436 10373 12 existent existent NN 40436 10373 13 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10373 14 -- -- : 40436 10373 15 The the DT 40436 10373 16 Self self NN 40436 10373 17 - - HYPH 40436 10373 18 Beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10373 19 , , , 40436 10373 20 Self self NN 40436 10373 21 - - HYPH 40436 10373 22 Just just RB 40436 10373 23 , , , 40436 10373 24 Self self NN 40436 10373 25 - - HYPH 40436 10373 26 Great great JJ 40436 10373 27 , , , 40436 10373 28 Self self NN 40436 10373 29 - - HYPH 40436 10373 30 Equal equal JJ 40436 10373 31 , , , 40436 10373 32 Self Self NNP 40436 10373 33 - - HYPH 40436 10373 34 Unequal Unequal NNP 40436 10373 35 , , , 40436 10373 36 & & CC 40436 10373 37 c.--each c.--each CD 40436 10373 38 of of IN 40436 10373 39 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10373 40 adapted adapt VBD 40436 10373 41 to to IN 40436 10373 42 a a DT 40436 10373 43 certain certain JJ 40436 10373 44 number number NN 40436 10373 45 of of IN 40436 10373 46 particular particular JJ 40436 10373 47 cases case NNS 40436 10373 48 : : : 40436 10373 49 the the DT 40436 10373 50 Self Self NNP 40436 10373 51 - - HYPH 40436 10373 52 Beautiful Beautiful NNP 40436 10373 53 was be VBD 40436 10373 54 assumed assume VBN 40436 10373 55 as as IN 40436 10373 56 the the DT 40436 10373 57 cause cause NN 40436 10373 58 why why WRB 40436 10373 59 all all DT 40436 10373 60 particular particular JJ 40436 10373 61 things thing NNS 40436 10373 62 were be VBD 40436 10373 63 beautiful beautiful JJ 40436 10373 64 -- -- : 40436 10373 65 as as IN 40436 10373 66 that that DT 40436 10373 67 , , , 40436 10373 68 of of IN 40436 10373 69 which which WDT 40436 10373 70 all all DT 40436 10373 71 and and CC 40436 10373 72 each each DT 40436 10373 73 of of IN 40436 10373 74 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10373 75 partakes partake VBZ 40436 10373 76 -- -- : 40436 10373 77 and and CC 40436 10373 78 so so RB 40436 10373 79 of of IN 40436 10373 80 the the DT 40436 10373 81 rest rest NN 40436 10373 82 . . . 40436 10374 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10374 2 79 79 CD 40436 10374 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10374 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10374 5 then then RB 40436 10374 6 explains explain VBZ 40436 10374 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10374 8 procedure procedure NN 40436 10374 9 . . . 40436 10375 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10375 2 first first RB 40436 10375 3 deduced deduce VBD 40436 10375 4 various various JJ 40436 10375 5 consequences consequence NNS 40436 10375 6 from from IN 40436 10375 7 this this DT 40436 10375 8 assumed assumed JJ 40436 10375 9 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10375 10 , , , 40436 10375 11 and and CC 40436 10375 12 examined examine VBD 40436 10375 13 whether whether IN 40436 10375 14 all all DT 40436 10375 15 of of IN 40436 10375 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10375 17 were be VBD 40436 10375 18 consistent consistent JJ 40436 10375 19 or or CC 40436 10375 20 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 40436 10375 21 with with IN 40436 10375 22 each each DT 40436 10375 23 other other JJ 40436 10375 24 . . . 40436 10376 1 If if IN 40436 10376 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10376 3 detected detect VBD 40436 10376 4 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 40436 10376 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10376 6 as as IN 40436 10376 7 _ _ NNP 40436 10376 8 e.g. e.g. RB 40436 10376 9 _ _ NNP 40436 10376 10 in in IN 40436 10376 11 the the DT 40436 10376 12 last last JJ 40436 10376 13 half half NN 40436 10376 14 of of IN 40436 10376 15 the the DT 40436 10376 16 Parmenidês Parmenidês NNP 40436 10376 17 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10376 18 , , , 40436 10376 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10376 20 must must MD 40436 10376 21 suppose suppose VB 40436 10376 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10376 23 though though IN 40436 10376 24 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10376 25 does do VBZ 40436 10376 26 not not RB 40436 10376 27 expressly expressly RB 40436 10376 28 say say VB 40436 10376 29 so so RB 40436 10376 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10376 31 that that IN 40436 10376 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10376 33 would would MD 40436 10376 34 reject reject VB 40436 10376 35 or or CC 40436 10376 36 modify modify VB 40436 10376 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10376 38 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 10376 39 assumption assumption NN 40436 10376 40 : : : 40436 10376 41 if if IN 40436 10376 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10376 43 found find VBD 40436 10376 44 none none NN 40436 10376 45 , , , 40436 10376 46 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10376 47 would would MD 40436 10376 48 retain retain VB 40436 10376 49 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10376 50 . . . 40436 10377 1 The the DT 40436 10377 2 point point NN 40436 10377 3 would would MD 40436 10377 4 have have VB 40436 10377 5 to to TO 40436 10377 6 be be VB 40436 10377 7 tried try VBN 40436 10377 8 by by IN 40436 10377 9 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 10377 10 debate debate NN 40436 10377 11 with with IN 40436 10377 12 an an DT 40436 10377 13 opponent opponent NN 40436 10377 14 : : : 40436 10377 15 the the DT 40436 10377 16 logical logical JJ 40436 10377 17 process process NN 40436 10377 18 of of IN 40436 10377 19 inference inference NN 40436 10377 20 and and CC 40436 10377 21 counter counter NN 40436 10377 22 - - NN 40436 10377 23 inference inference NN 40436 10377 24 is be VBZ 40436 10377 25 here here RB 40436 10377 26 assumed assume VBN 40436 10377 27 to to TO 40436 10377 28 be be VB 40436 10377 29 trustworthy trustworthy JJ 40436 10377 30 . . . 40436 10378 1 But but CC 40436 10378 2 during during IN 40436 10378 3 this this DT 40436 10378 4 debate debate NN 40436 10378 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10378 6 would would MD 40436 10378 7 require require VB 40436 10378 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10378 9 opponent opponent NN 40436 10378 10 to to TO 40436 10378 11 admit admit VB 40436 10378 12 the the DT 40436 10378 13 truth truth NN 40436 10378 14 of of IN 40436 10378 15 the the DT 40436 10378 16 fundamental fundamental JJ 40436 10378 17 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10378 18 provisionally provisionally RB 40436 10378 19 . . . 40436 10379 1 If if IN 40436 10379 2 the the DT 40436 10379 3 opponent opponent NN 40436 10379 4 chose choose VBD 40436 10379 5 to to TO 40436 10379 6 impugn impugn VB 40436 10379 7 the the DT 40436 10379 8 latter latter JJ 40436 10379 9 , , , 40436 10379 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10379 11 must must MD 40436 10379 12 open open VB 40436 10379 13 a a DT 40436 10379 14 distinct distinct JJ 40436 10379 15 debate debate NN 40436 10379 16 on on IN 40436 10379 17 that that DT 40436 10379 18 express express JJ 40436 10379 19 subject subject NN 40436 10379 20 . . . 40436 10380 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10380 2 insists insist VBZ 40436 10380 3 that that IN 40436 10380 4 the the DT 40436 10380 5 discussion discussion NN 40436 10380 6 of of IN 40436 10380 7 the the DT 40436 10380 8 consequences consequence NNS 40436 10380 9 flowing flow VBG 40436 10380 10 from from IN 40436 10380 11 the the DT 40436 10380 12 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10380 13 , , , 40436 10380 14 shall shall MD 40436 10380 15 be be VB 40436 10380 16 kept keep VBN 40436 10380 17 quite quite RB 40436 10380 18 apart apart RB 40436 10380 19 from from IN 40436 10380 20 the the DT 40436 10380 21 discussion discussion NN 40436 10380 22 on on IN 40436 10380 23 the the DT 40436 10380 24 credibility credibility NN 40436 10380 25 of of IN 40436 10380 26 the the DT 40436 10380 27 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10380 28 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10380 29 . . . 40436 10381 1 From from IN 40436 10381 2 the the DT 40436 10381 3 language language NN 40436 10381 4 employed employ VBN 40436 10381 5 , , , 40436 10381 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10381 7 seems seem VBZ 40436 10381 8 to to TO 40436 10381 9 have have VB 40436 10381 10 had have VBN 40436 10381 11 in in IN 40436 10381 12 view view NN 40436 10381 13 certain certain JJ 40436 10381 14 disputants disputant NNS 40436 10381 15 known know VBN 40436 10381 16 to to IN 40436 10381 17 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10381 18 , , , 40436 10381 19 by by IN 40436 10381 20 whom whom WP 40436 10381 21 the the DT 40436 10381 22 two two CD 40436 10381 23 were be VBD 40436 10381 24 so so RB 40436 10381 25 blended blended JJ 40436 10381 26 together together RB 40436 10381 27 as as IN 40436 10381 28 to to TO 40436 10381 29 produce produce VB 40436 10381 30 much much JJ 40436 10381 31 confusion confusion NN 40436 10381 32 in in IN 40436 10381 33 the the DT 40436 10381 34 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 10381 35 . . . 40436 10382 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10382 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10382 3 77 77 CD 40436 10382 4 : : : 40436 10382 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10382 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10382 7 Metaphysic Metaphysic NNP 40436 10382 8 . . . 40436 10383 1 A. A. NNP 40436 10384 1 987 987 CD 40436 10384 2 , , , 40436 10384 3 b. b. NN 40436 10385 1 31 31 CD 40436 10385 2 , , , 40436 10385 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10385 4 Greek greek JJ 40436 10385 5 : : : 40436 10385 6 Th Th NNP 40436 10385 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10385 8 . . . 40436 10386 1 1050 1050 CD 40436 10386 2 , , , 40436 10386 3 b. b. NNP 40436 10387 1 35 35 CD 40436 10387 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10387 3 calls call VBZ 40436 10387 4 the the DT 40436 10387 5 Platonici Platonici NNP 40436 10387 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10387 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10387 8 : : : 40436 10387 9 oi oi NNP 40436 10387 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10387 11 e)n e)n NNP 40436 10387 12 toi toi NNP 40436 10387 13 = = SYM 40436 10387 14 s s NNP 40436 10387 15 lo lo NNP 40436 10387 16 / / SYM 40436 10387 17 gois gois NNP 40436 10387 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10387 19 : : : 40436 10387 20 see see VB 40436 10387 21 the the DT 40436 10387 22 note note NN 40436 10387 23 of of IN 40436 10387 24 Bonitz Bonitz NNP 40436 10387 25 . . . 40436 10387 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10388 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10388 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10388 3 78 78 CD 40436 10388 4 : : : 40436 10388 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10388 6 , , , 40436 10388 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10388 8 , , , 40436 10388 9 p. p. NN 40436 10388 10 100 100 CD 40436 10388 11 A. a. NN 40436 10389 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10389 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10389 3 : : : 40436 10389 4 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 10389 5 ' ' '' 40436 10389 6 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 10389 7 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 10389 8 tau tau NNP 40436 10389 9 / / SYM 40436 10389 10 tê| tê| NNP 40436 10389 11 ge ge NNP 40436 10389 12 ô(/rmêsa ô(/rmêsa NNP 40436 10389 13 , , , 40436 10389 14 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10389 15 u(pothe u(pothe NNP 40436 10389 16 / / SYM 40436 10389 17 menos menos NNP 40436 10389 18 e(ka e(ka NNP 40436 10389 19 / / SYM 40436 10389 20 stote stote NNP 40436 10389 21 lo lo NNP 40436 10389 22 / / SYM 40436 10389 23 gon gon NNP 40436 10389 24 o(\n o(\n NNP 40436 10389 25 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10389 26 kri kri NNP 40436 10389 27 / / SYM 40436 10389 28 nô nô NNP 40436 10389 29 e)r)r(ômene e)r)r(ômene NNP 40436 10389 30 / / SYM 40436 10389 31 staton staton NNP 40436 10389 32 ei)=nai ei)=nai CD 40436 10389 33 , , , 40436 10389 34 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 10389 35 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10389 36 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10389 37 moi moi NNP 40436 10389 38 dokê=| dokê=| NNP 40436 10389 39 tou tou NNP 40436 10389 40 / / SYM 40436 10389 41 tô| tô| NNP 40436 10389 42 xumphônei xumphônei NNP 40436 10389 43 = = SYM 40436 10389 44 n n CC 40436 10389 45 , , , 40436 10389 46 ti ti NN 40436 10389 47 / / SYM 40436 10389 48 thêmi thêmi NNP 40436 10389 49 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10389 50 a)lêthê= a)lêthê= NNP 40436 10389 51 o)/nta o)/nta NNP 40436 10389 52 , , , 40436 10389 53 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10389 54 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 10389 55 ai)ti ai)ti NNP 40436 10389 56 / / SYM 40436 10389 57 as as IN 40436 10389 58 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10389 59 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 10389 60 tô tô NNP 40436 10389 61 = = SYM 40436 10389 62 n n CC 40436 10389 63 a)/llôn a)/llôn CC 40436 10389 64 a(pa a(pa NNP 40436 10389 65 / / SYM 40436 10389 66 ntôn ntôn NNS 40436 10389 67 ; ; : 40436 10389 68 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 10389 69 d d NNP 40436 10389 70 ' ' POS 40436 10389 71 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 10389 72 mê/ mê/ NN 40436 10389 73 , , , 40436 10389 74 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10389 75 ou)k ou)k NN 40436 10389 76 a)lêthê=. a)lêthê=. NNP 40436 10389 77 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10389 78 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10390 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10390 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10390 3 79 79 CD 40436 10390 4 : : : 40436 10390 5 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10390 6 controverts controvert VBZ 40436 10390 7 this this DT 40436 10390 8 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10390 9 of of IN 40436 10390 10 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10390 11 in in IN 40436 10390 12 a a DT 40436 10390 13 pointed pointed JJ 40436 10390 14 manner manner NN 40436 10390 15 , , , 40436 10390 16 De De NNP 40436 10390 17 Gen. Gen. NNP 40436 10390 18 et et NNP 40436 10390 19 Corrupt corrupt JJ 40436 10390 20 . . . 40436 10391 1 ii ii LS 40436 10391 2 . . . 40436 10392 1 9 9 CD 40436 10392 2 , , , 40436 10392 3 p. p. NN 40436 10392 4 335 335 CD 40436 10392 5 , , , 40436 10392 6 b. b. NNP 40436 10393 1 10 10 CD 40436 10393 2 , , , 40436 10393 3 also also RB 40436 10393 4 Metaphys Metaphys NNP 40436 10393 5 . . . 40436 10394 1 A. A. NNP 40436 10395 1 991 991 CD 40436 10395 2 , , , 40436 10395 3 b. b. NN 40436 10396 1 3 3 LS 40436 10396 2 . . . 40436 10397 1 The the DT 40436 10397 2 former former JJ 40436 10397 3 passage passage NN 40436 10397 4 is be VBZ 40436 10397 5 the the DT 40436 10397 6 most most RBS 40436 10397 7 animated animate VBN 40436 10397 8 in in IN 40436 10397 9 point point NN 40436 10397 10 of of IN 40436 10397 11 expression expression NN 40436 10397 12 , , , 40436 10397 13 where where WRB 40436 10397 14 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10397 15 says--[Greek says--[greek CD 40436 10397 16 : : : 40436 10397 17 ô(/sper ô(/sper NN 40436 10397 18 o o NN 40436 10397 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10397 20 e)n e)n NNP 40436 10397 21 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 10397 22 Phai Phai NNP 40436 10397 23 / / SYM 40436 10397 24 dôni dôni NNP 40436 10397 25 Sôkra Sôkra NNP 40436 10397 26 / / SYM 40436 10397 27 tês tês NN 40436 10397 28 ; ; : 40436 10397 29 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10397 30 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10397 31 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 10397 32 = = NFP 40436 10397 33 nos nos NNP 40436 10397 34 , , , 40436 10397 35 e)pitimê e)pitimê NNP 40436 10397 36 / / SYM 40436 10397 37 sas sas NNP 40436 10397 38 toi toi NNP 40436 10397 39 = = SYM 40436 10397 40 s s NNP 40436 10397 41 a)/llois a)/llois NNP 40436 10397 42 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10397 43 ou)de\n ou)de\n RB 40436 10397 44 ei)rêko ei)rêko NN 40436 10397 45 / / SYM 40436 10397 46 sin sin NN 40436 10397 47 , , , 40436 10397 48 u(poti u(poti CC 40436 10397 49 / / SYM 40436 10397 50 thetai]--which thetai]--which ADD 40436 10397 51 is be VBZ 40436 10397 52 very very RB 40436 10397 53 true true JJ 40436 10397 54 about about IN 40436 10397 55 the the DT 40436 10397 56 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10397 57 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 10397 58 _ _ NNP 40436 10397 59 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10397 60 _ _ NNP 40436 10397 61 , , , 40436 10397 62 & & CC 40436 10397 63 c. c. NNP 40436 10397 64 But but CC 40436 10397 65 in in IN 40436 10397 66 both both DT 40436 10397 67 the the DT 40436 10397 68 two two CD 40436 10397 69 passages passage NNS 40436 10397 70 , , , 40436 10397 71 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10397 72 distinctly distinctly RB 40436 10397 73 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 10397 74 that that IN 40436 10397 75 the the DT 40436 10397 76 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10397 77 can can MD 40436 10397 78 not not RB 40436 10397 79 be be VB 40436 10397 80 _ _ NNP 40436 10397 81 Causes Causes NNPS 40436 10397 82 _ _ NNP 40436 10397 83 of of IN 40436 10397 84 any any DT 40436 10397 85 thing thing NN 40436 10397 86 . . . 40436 10398 1 This this DT 40436 10398 2 is be VBZ 40436 10398 3 another another DT 40436 10398 4 illustration illustration NN 40436 10398 5 of of IN 40436 10398 6 what what WP 40436 10398 7 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10398 8 have have VBP 40436 10398 9 observed observe VBN 40436 10398 10 above above RB 40436 10398 11 , , , 40436 10398 12 that that IN 40436 10398 13 the the DT 40436 10398 14 meaning meaning NN 40436 10398 15 of of IN 40436 10398 16 the the DT 40436 10398 17 word word NN 40436 10398 18 _ _ NNP 40436 10398 19 Cause Cause NNP 40436 10398 20 _ _ NNP 40436 10398 21 has have VBZ 40436 10398 22 been be VBN 40436 10398 23 always always RB 40436 10398 24 fluctuating fluctuate VBG 40436 10398 25 and and CC 40436 10398 26 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 10398 27 . . . 40436 10399 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10399 2 see see VBP 40436 10399 3 that that IN 40436 10399 4 , , , 40436 10399 5 while while IN 40436 10399 6 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10399 7 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 10399 8 that that IN 40436 10399 9 the the DT 40436 10399 10 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10399 11 could could MD 40436 10399 12 not not RB 40436 10399 13 be be VB 40436 10399 14 Causes cause NNS 40436 10399 15 of of IN 40436 10399 16 anything anything NN 40436 10399 17 , , , 40436 10399 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10399 19 here here RB 40436 10399 20 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 10399 21 that that IN 40436 10399 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10399 23 are be VBP 40436 10399 24 the the DT 40436 10399 25 only only JJ 40436 10399 26 true true JJ 40436 10399 27 Causes cause NNS 40436 10399 28 . . . 40436 10399 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10400 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10400 2 Side side NN 40436 10400 3 - - HYPH 40436 10400 4 note note NN 40436 10400 5 : : : 40436 10400 6 Ultimate ultimate JJ 40436 10400 7 appeal appeal NN 40436 10400 8 to to IN 40436 10400 9 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10400 10 of of IN 40436 10400 11 extreme extreme JJ 40436 10400 12 generality generality NN 40436 10400 13 . . . 40436 10400 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10401 1 But but CC 40436 10401 2 if if IN 40436 10401 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10401 4 opponent opponent NN 40436 10401 5 impugns impugn VBZ 40436 10401 6 the the DT 40436 10401 7 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10401 8 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10401 9 , , , 40436 10401 10 how how WRB 40436 10401 11 are be VBP 40436 10401 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10401 13 to to TO 40436 10401 14 defend defend VB 40436 10401 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10401 16 ? ? . 40436 10402 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10402 2 here here RB 40436 10402 3 tells tell VBZ 40436 10402 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10402 5 : : : 40436 10402 6 by by IN 40436 10402 7 means mean NNS 40436 10402 8 of of IN 40436 10402 9 some some DT 40436 10402 10 other other JJ 40436 10402 11 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10402 12 or or CC 40436 10402 13 assumption assumption NN 40436 10402 14 , , , 40436 10402 15 yet yet CC 40436 10402 16 more more RBR 40436 10402 17 universal universal JJ 40436 10402 18 than than IN 40436 10402 19 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10402 20 . . . 40436 10403 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 10403 2 must must MD 40436 10403 3 ascend ascend VB 40436 10403 4 upwards upward NNS 40436 10403 5 in in IN 40436 10403 6 the the DT 40436 10403 7 scale scale NN 40436 10403 8 of of IN 40436 10403 9 generality generality NN 40436 10403 10 , , , 40436 10403 11 until until IN 40436 10403 12 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10403 13 find find VBP 40436 10403 14 an an DT 40436 10403 15 assumption assumption NN 40436 10403 16 suitable suitable JJ 40436 10403 17 and and CC 40436 10403 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 10403 19 . . . 40436 10404 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10404 2 80 80 CD 40436 10404 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10404 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10404 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10404 6 80 80 CD 40436 10404 7 : : : 40436 10404 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10404 9 , , , 40436 10404 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10404 11 , , , 40436 10404 12 p. p. NN 40436 10404 13 101 101 CD 40436 10404 14 E. E. NNP 40436 10404 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10404 16 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10404 17 here here RB 40436 10404 18 see see VBP 40436 10404 19 where where WRB 40436 10404 20 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10404 21 was be VBD 40436 10404 22 that that IN 40436 10404 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10404 24 looked look VBD 40436 10404 25 for for IN 40436 10404 26 full full JJ 40436 10404 27 , , , 40436 10404 28 indisputable indisputable JJ 40436 10404 29 , , , 40436 10404 30 self self NN 40436 10404 31 - - HYPH 40436 10404 32 recommending recommend VBG 40436 10404 33 and and CC 40436 10404 34 self self NN 40436 10404 35 - - HYPH 40436 10404 36 assuring assure VBG 40436 10404 37 , , , 40436 10404 38 certainty certainty NN 40436 10404 39 and and CC 40436 10404 40 truth truth NN 40436 10404 41 . . . 40436 10405 1 Among among IN 40436 10405 2 the the DT 40436 10405 3 most most RBS 40436 10405 4 universal universal JJ 40436 10405 5 propositions proposition NNS 40436 10405 6 . . . 40436 10406 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10406 2 states state VBZ 40436 10406 3 the the DT 40436 10406 4 matter matter NN 40436 10406 5 here here RB 40436 10406 6 as as IN 40436 10406 7 if if IN 40436 10406 8 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10406 9 were be VBD 40436 10406 10 to to TO 40436 10406 11 provide provide VB 40436 10406 12 defence defence NN 40436 10406 13 for for IN 40436 10406 14 an an DT 40436 10406 15 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10406 16 less less RBR 40436 10406 17 universal universal JJ 40436 10406 18 by by IN 40436 10406 19 ascending ascend VBG 40436 10406 20 to to IN 40436 10406 21 another another DT 40436 10406 22 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10406 23 more more RBR 40436 10406 24 universal universal JJ 40436 10406 25 . . . 40436 10407 1 This this DT 40436 10407 2 is be VBZ 40436 10407 3 illustrated illustrate VBN 40436 10407 4 by by IN 40436 10407 5 what what WP 40436 10407 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10407 7 says say VBZ 40436 10407 8 in in IN 40436 10407 9 the the DT 40436 10407 10 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10407 11 -- -- : 40436 10407 12 Propositions proposition NNS 40436 10407 13 are be VBP 40436 10407 14 cognate cognate JJ 40436 10407 15 with with IN 40436 10407 16 the the DT 40436 10407 17 matter matter NN 40436 10407 18 which which WDT 40436 10407 19 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10407 20 affirm affirm VBP 40436 10407 21 : : : 40436 10407 22 those those DT 40436 10407 23 whose whose WP$ 40436 10407 24 affirmation affirmation NN 40436 10407 25 is be VBZ 40436 10407 26 purely purely RB 40436 10407 27 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 10407 28 , , , 40436 10407 29 comprising comprise VBG 40436 10407 30 only only JJ 40436 10407 31 matter matter NN 40436 10407 32 of of IN 40436 10407 33 the the DT 40436 10407 34 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 10407 35 world world NN 40436 10407 36 , , , 40436 10407 37 or or CC 40436 10407 38 of of IN 40436 10407 39 genuine genuine JJ 40436 10407 40 Essence Essence NNP 40436 10407 41 , , , 40436 10407 42 are be VBP 40436 10407 43 solid solid JJ 40436 10407 44 and and CC 40436 10407 45 inexpugnable inexpugnable JJ 40436 10407 46 : : : 40436 10407 47 those those DT 40436 10407 48 which which WDT 40436 10407 49 take take VBP 40436 10407 50 in in RP 40436 10407 51 more more RBR 40436 10407 52 or or CC 40436 10407 53 less less JJR 40436 10407 54 of of IN 40436 10407 55 the the DT 40436 10407 56 sensible sensible JJ 40436 10407 57 world world NN 40436 10407 58 , , , 40436 10407 59 which which WDT 40436 10407 60 is be VBZ 40436 10407 61 a a DT 40436 10407 62 mere mere JJ 40436 10407 63 copy copy NN 40436 10407 64 of of IN 40436 10407 65 the the DT 40436 10407 66 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 10407 67 exemplar exemplar NNP 40436 10407 68 , , , 40436 10407 69 become become VB 40436 10407 70 less less RBR 40436 10407 71 and and CC 40436 10407 72 less less RBR 40436 10407 73 trustworthy trustworthy JJ 40436 10407 74 -- -- : 40436 10407 75 mere mere JJ 40436 10407 76 probabilities probability NNS 40436 10407 77 . . . 40436 10408 1 Here here RB 40436 10408 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10408 3 have have VBP 40436 10408 4 the the DT 40436 10408 5 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10408 6 worship worship NN 40436 10408 7 of of IN 40436 10408 8 the the DT 40436 10408 9 most most RBS 40436 10408 10 universal universal JJ 40436 10408 11 propositions proposition NNS 40436 10408 12 , , , 40436 10408 13 as as IN 40436 10408 14 the the DT 40436 10408 15 only only JJ 40436 10408 16 primary primary JJ 40436 10408 17 and and CC 40436 10408 18 evident evident JJ 40436 10408 19 truths truth NNS 40436 10408 20 . . . 40436 10409 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10409 2 81 81 CD 40436 10409 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10409 4 But but CC 40436 10409 5 in in IN 40436 10409 6 the the DT 40436 10409 7 sixth sixth JJ 40436 10409 8 and and CC 40436 10409 9 seventh seventh JJ 40436 10409 10 books book NNS 40436 10409 11 of of IN 40436 10409 12 the the DT 40436 10409 13 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10409 14 , , , 40436 10409 15 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10409 16 delivers deliver VBZ 40436 10409 17 a a DT 40436 10409 18 precept precept NN 40436 10409 19 somewhat somewhat RB 40436 10409 20 different different JJ 40436 10409 21 , , , 40436 10409 22 requiring require VBG 40436 10409 23 the the DT 40436 10409 24 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 10409 25 not not RB 40436 10409 26 to to TO 40436 10409 27 rest rest VB 40436 10409 28 in in IN 40436 10409 29 any any DT 40436 10409 30 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10409 31 as as IN 40436 10409 32 an an DT 40436 10409 33 ultimatum ultimatum NN 40436 10409 34 , , , 40436 10409 35 but but CC 40436 10409 36 to to TO 40436 10409 37 consider consider VB 40436 10409 38 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10409 39 all all DT 40436 10409 40 as as IN 40436 10409 41 stepping stepping JJ 40436 10409 42 - - : 40436 10409 43 stones stone NNS 40436 10409 44 for for IN 40436 10409 45 enabling enable VBG 40436 10409 46 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10409 47 to to TO 40436 10409 48 ascend ascend VB 40436 10409 49 into into IN 40436 10409 50 a a DT 40436 10409 51 higher high JJR 40436 10409 52 region region NN 40436 10409 53 , , , 40436 10409 54 above above IN 40436 10409 55 all all DT 40436 10409 56 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10409 57 -- -- : 40436 10409 58 to to IN 40436 10409 59 the the DT 40436 10409 60 first first JJ 40436 10409 61 principle principle NN 40436 10409 62 of of IN 40436 10409 63 every every DT 40436 10409 64 thing thing NN 40436 10409 65 : : : 40436 10409 66 and and CC 40436 10409 67 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10409 68 considers consider VBZ 40436 10409 69 geometrical geometrical JJ 40436 10409 70 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 10409 71 as as IN 40436 10409 72 defective defective JJ 40436 10409 73 because because IN 40436 10409 74 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10409 75 takes take VBZ 40436 10409 76 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10409 77 departure departure NN 40436 10409 78 from from IN 40436 10409 79 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10409 80 or or CC 40436 10409 81 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 10409 82 of of IN 40436 10409 83 which which WDT 40436 10409 84 no no DT 40436 10409 85 account account NN 40436 10409 86 is be VBZ 40436 10409 87 rendered render VBN 40436 10409 88 . . . 40436 10410 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10410 2 82 82 CD 40436 10410 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10410 4 In in IN 40436 10410 5 the the DT 40436 10410 6 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10410 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10410 8 thus thus RB 40436 10410 9 contemplates contemplate VBZ 40436 10410 10 an an DT 40436 10410 11 intuition intuition NN 40436 10410 12 by by IN 40436 10410 13 the the DT 40436 10410 14 mind mind NN 40436 10410 15 of of IN 40436 10410 16 some some DT 40436 10410 17 primary primary JJ 40436 10410 18 , , , 40436 10410 19 clear clear JJ 40436 10410 20 , , , 40436 10410 21 self self NN 40436 10410 22 - - HYPH 40436 10410 23 evident evident JJ 40436 10410 24 truth truth NN 40436 10410 25 , , , 40436 10410 26 above above IN 40436 10410 27 all all DT 40436 10410 28 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 40436 10410 29 or or CC 40436 10410 30 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 10410 31 even even RB 40436 10410 32 the the DT 40436 10410 33 most most RBS 40436 10410 34 universal universal JJ 40436 10410 35 , , , 40436 10410 36 and and CC 40436 10410 37 transmitting transmit VBG 40436 10410 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10410 39 own own JJ 40436 10410 40 certainty certainty NN 40436 10410 41 to to IN 40436 10410 42 every every DT 40436 10410 43 thing thing NN 40436 10410 44 which which WDT 40436 10410 45 could could MD 40436 10410 46 be be VB 40436 10410 47 logically logically RB 40436 10410 48 deduced deduce VBN 40436 10410 49 from from IN 40436 10410 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10410 51 : : : 40436 10410 52 while while IN 40436 10410 53 in in IN 40436 10410 54 the the DT 40436 10410 55 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10410 56 , , , 40436 10410 57 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10410 58 does do VBZ 40436 10410 59 not not RB 40436 10410 60 recognise recognise VB 40436 10410 61 any any DT 40436 10410 62 thing thing NN 40436 10410 63 higher higher RBR 40436 10410 64 or or CC 40436 10410 65 more more RBR 40436 10410 66 certain certain JJ 40436 10410 67 than than IN 40436 10410 68 the the DT 40436 10410 69 most most RBS 40436 10410 70 universal universal JJ 40436 10410 71 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10410 72 -- -- : 40436 10410 73 and and CC 40436 10410 74 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10410 75 even even RB 40436 10410 76 presents present VBZ 40436 10410 77 the the DT 40436 10410 78 theory theory NN 40436 10410 79 of of IN 40436 10410 80 self self NN 40436 10410 81 - - HYPH 40436 10410 82 existent existent NN 40436 10410 83 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10410 84 as as IN 40436 10410 85 nothing nothing NN 40436 10410 86 more more JJR 40436 10410 87 than than IN 40436 10410 88 an an DT 40436 10410 89 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10410 90 , , , 40436 10410 91 though though IN 40436 10410 92 a a DT 40436 10410 93 very very RB 40436 10410 94 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 10410 95 one one CD 40436 10410 96 . . . 40436 10411 1 In in IN 40436 10411 2 the the DT 40436 10411 3 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10411 4 , , , 40436 10411 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10411 6 has have VBZ 40436 10411 7 come come VBN 40436 10411 8 to to TO 40436 10411 9 imagine imagine VB 40436 10411 10 the the DT 40436 10411 11 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10411 12 of of IN 40436 10411 13 Good good JJ 40436 10411 14 as as IN 40436 10411 15 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 10411 16 from from IN 40436 10411 17 and and CC 40436 10411 18 illuminating illuminate VBG 40436 10411 19 all all PDT 40436 10411 20 the the DT 40436 10411 21 other other JJ 40436 10411 22 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10411 23 : : : 40436 10411 24 in in IN 40436 10411 25 the the DT 40436 10411 26 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10411 27 , , , 40436 10411 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10411 29 seems seem VBZ 40436 10411 30 personified personified JJ 40436 10411 31 in in IN 40436 10411 32 the the DT 40436 10411 33 Demiurgus Demiurgus NNP 40436 10411 34 ; ; : 40436 10411 35 in in IN 40436 10411 36 the the DT 40436 10411 37 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10411 38 , , , 40436 10411 39 that that DT 40436 10411 40 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10411 41 of of IN 40436 10411 42 Good good JJ 40436 10411 43 appears appear VBZ 40436 10411 44 to to TO 40436 10411 45 be be VB 40436 10411 46 represented represent VBN 40436 10411 47 by by IN 40436 10411 48 the the DT 40436 10411 49 Nous Nous NNP 40436 10411 50 or or CC 40436 10411 51 Reason Reason NNP 40436 10411 52 of of IN 40436 10411 53 Anaxagoras Anaxagoras NNPS 40436 10411 54 . . . 40436 10412 1 But but CC 40436 10412 2 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10412 3 is be VBZ 40436 10412 4 unable unable JJ 40436 10412 5 to to TO 40436 10412 6 follow follow VB 40436 10412 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10412 8 out out RP 40436 10412 9 , , , 40436 10412 10 so so IN 40436 10412 11 that that IN 40436 10412 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10412 13 becomes become VBZ 40436 10412 14 included include VBN 40436 10412 15 , , , 40436 10412 16 without without IN 40436 10412 17 any any DT 40436 10412 18 pre pre NN 40436 10412 19 - - NN 40436 10412 20 eminence eminence NN 40436 10412 21 , , , 40436 10412 22 among among IN 40436 10412 23 the the DT 40436 10412 24 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 10412 25 generally generally RB 40436 10412 26 : : : 40436 10412 27 all all DT 40436 10412 28 of of IN 40436 10412 29 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10412 30 transcendental transcendental JJ 40436 10412 31 , , , 40436 10412 32 co co NN 40436 10412 33 - - NN 40436 10412 34 ordinate ordinate JJ 40436 10412 35 , , , 40436 10412 36 and and CC 40436 10412 37 primary primary JJ 40436 10412 38 sources source NNS 40436 10412 39 of of IN 40436 10412 40 truth truth NN 40436 10412 41 to to IN 40436 10412 42 the the DT 40436 10412 43 intelligent intelligent JJ 40436 10412 44 mind mind NN 40436 10412 45 -- -- : 40436 10412 46 yet yet CC 40436 10412 47 each each DT 40436 10412 48 of of IN 40436 10412 49 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10412 50 exercising exercise VBG 40436 10412 51 a a DT 40436 10412 52 causative causative JJ 40436 10412 53 influence influence NN 40436 10412 54 in in IN 40436 10412 55 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10412 56 own own JJ 40436 10412 57 department department NN 40436 10412 58 , , , 40436 10412 59 and and CC 40436 10412 60 bestowing bestow VBG 40436 10412 61 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10412 62 own own JJ 40436 10412 63 special special JJ 40436 10412 64 character character NN 40436 10412 65 on on IN 40436 10412 66 various various JJ 40436 10412 67 particulars particular NNS 40436 10412 68 . . . 40436 10413 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10413 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10413 3 81 81 CD 40436 10413 4 : : : 40436 10413 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10413 6 , , , 40436 10413 7 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10413 8 , , , 40436 10413 9 p. p. NN 40436 10413 10 29 29 CD 40436 10413 11 B. b. NN 40436 10414 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10414 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10414 3 : : : 40436 10414 4 ô(=de ô(=de NNP 40436 10414 5 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 10414 6 peri/ peri/ NNP 40436 10414 7 te te NNP 40436 10414 8 ei)ko ei)ko NNP 40436 10414 9 / / SYM 40436 10414 10 nos nos NNP 40436 10414 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10414 12 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10414 13 paradei paradei NN 40436 10414 14 / / SYM 40436 10414 15 gmatos gmatos NNP 40436 10414 16 dioriste dioriste NNP 40436 10414 17 / / SYM 40436 10414 18 on on RB 40436 10414 19 , , , 40436 10414 20 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10414 21 a)/ra a)/ra FW 40436 10414 22 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 10414 23 lo lo NNP 40436 10414 24 / / SYM 40436 10414 25 gous gous JJ 40436 10414 26 , , , 40436 10414 27 ô(=npe ô(=npe ADD 40436 10414 28 / / SYM 40436 10414 29 r r NNP 40436 10414 30 ei)sin ei)sin NNP 40436 10414 31 e)xêgêtai/ e)xêgêtai/ CD 40436 10414 32 , , , 40436 10414 33 tou tou NNP 40436 10414 34 / / SYM 40436 10414 35 tôn tôn NNP 40436 10414 36 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 10414 37 = = SYM 40436 10414 38 n n NNP 40436 10414 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10414 40 xuggenei xuggenei NNP 40436 10414 41 = = SYM 40436 10414 42 s s NNP 40436 10414 43 o)/ntas o)/ntas NNP 40436 10414 44 . . . 40436 10415 1 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10415 2 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10415 3 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 10415 4 moni moni NNP 40436 10415 5 / / SYM 40436 10415 6 mou mou NNP 40436 10415 7 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10415 8 bebai bebai NNP 40436 10415 9 / / SYM 40436 10415 10 ou ou NNP 40436 10415 11 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10415 12 meta\ meta\ . 40436 10415 13 nou= nou= NNP 40436 10415 14 kataphanou kataphanou NN 40436 10415 15 = = SYM 40436 10415 16 s s FW 40436 10415 17 , , , 40436 10415 18 moni moni NNP 40436 10415 19 / / SYM 40436 10415 20 mous mous JJ 40436 10415 21 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10415 22 a)metaptô a)metaptô NNP 40436 10415 23 / / SYM 40436 10415 24 tous tous JJ 40436 10415 25 . . . 40436 10416 1 . . . 40436 10417 1 . . . 40436 10418 1 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 10418 2 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10418 3 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10418 4 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 10418 5 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10418 6 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 10418 7 = = NFP 40436 10418 8 no no UH 40436 10418 9 a)peikasthe a)peikasthe NN 40436 10418 10 / / SYM 40436 10418 11 ntos ntos NN 40436 10418 12 , , , 40436 10418 13 o)/ntos o)/ntos NFP 40436 10418 14 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10418 15 ei)ko ei)ko NNP 40436 10418 16 / / SYM 40436 10418 17 nos nos NNP 40436 10418 18 , , , 40436 10418 19 ei)ko ei)ko NN 40436 10418 20 / / SYM 40436 10418 21 tas tas NN 40436 10418 22 a)na\ a)na\ NNP 40436 10418 23 lo lo NNP 40436 10418 24 / / SYM 40436 10418 25 gon gon NNP 40436 10418 26 te te NNP 40436 10418 27 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 10418 28 / / SYM 40436 10418 29 nôn nôn NN 40436 10418 30 o)/ntas o)/nta NNS 40436 10418 31 ; ; : 40436 10418 32 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 10418 33 , , , 40436 10418 34 tiper tiper VBG 40436 10418 35 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 10418 36 ge ge NNP 40436 10418 37 / / SYM 40436 10418 38 nesin nesin NNP 40436 10418 39 ou)si ou)si NNP 40436 10418 40 / / SYM 40436 10418 41 a a DT 40436 10418 42 , , , 40436 10418 43 tou tou NNP 40436 10418 44 = = SYM 40436 10418 45 to to IN 40436 10418 46 pro\s pro\s NNP 40436 10418 47 pi pi NN 40436 10418 48 / / SYM 40436 10418 49 stin stin NNP 40436 10418 50 a)lêthei a)lêthei : 40436 10418 51 / / SYM 40436 10418 52 a a NN 40436 10418 53 . . . 40436 10418 54 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10418 55 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10419 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10419 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10419 3 82 82 CD 40436 10419 4 : : : 40436 10419 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10419 6 , , , 40436 10419 7 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10419 8 , , , 40436 10419 9 vi vi NNP 40436 10419 10 . . . 40436 10420 1 p. p. NN 40436 10420 2 511 511 CD 40436 10420 3 . . . 40436 10421 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10421 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10421 3 : : : 40436 10421 4 _ _ NNP 40436 10421 5 tô tô NNP 40436 10421 6 = = SYM 40436 10421 7 n n CC 40436 10421 8 u(pothe u(pothe NNP 40436 10421 9 / / SYM 40436 10421 10 seôn seôn NNP 40436 10421 11 a)nôte a)nôte NNP 40436 10421 12 / / SYM 40436 10421 13 rô rô NNP 40436 10421 14 e)kbai e)kbai NNP 40436 10421 15 / / SYM 40436 10421 16 nein nein NNP 40436 10421 17 _ _ NNP 40436 10421 18 . . . 40436 10422 1 . . . 40436 10423 1 . . . 40436 10424 1 . . . 40436 10425 1 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10425 2 e(/teron e(/teron NNP 40436 10425 3 tmê tmê NN 40436 10425 4 = = SYM 40436 10425 5 ma ma NNP 40436 10425 6 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10425 7 noêtou= noêtou= NN 40436 10425 8 , , , 40436 10425 9 ou)= ou)= JJ 40436 10425 10 au)to\s au)to\s ADD 40436 10425 11 o o NN 40436 10425 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10425 13 lo lo NNP 40436 10425 14 / / SYM 40436 10425 15 gos gos NN 40436 10425 16 a)/ptetai a)/ptetai NNP 40436 10425 17 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 10425 18 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10425 19 diale diale NN 40436 10425 20 / / SYM 40436 10425 21 gesthai gesthai NNP 40436 10425 22 duna duna NNP 40436 10425 23 / / SYM 40436 10425 24 mei mei NNP 40436 10425 25 , , , 40436 10425 26 ta\s ta\s NNP 40436 10425 27 u(pothe u(pothe NNP 40436 10425 28 / / SYM 40436 10425 29 seis seis NNP 40436 10425 30 poiou poiou NNP 40436 10425 31 / / SYM 40436 10425 32 menos menos NNP 40436 10425 33 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10425 34 a)rcha\s a)rcha\s NNP 40436 10425 35 a)lla\ a)lla\ NN 40436 10425 36 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 10425 37 o)/nti o)/nti NNP 40436 10425 38 u(pothe u(pothe NNP 40436 10425 39 / / SYM 40436 10425 40 seis seis NNP 40436 10425 41 , , , 40436 10425 42 oi(=on oi(=on NNP 40436 10425 43 e)piba e)piba NNP 40436 10425 44 / / SYM 40436 10425 45 seis seis NNP 40436 10425 46 te te NNP 40436 10425 47 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10425 48 o(rma o(rma NNP 40436 10425 49 / / SYM 40436 10425 50 s s NNP 40436 10425 51 , , , 40436 10425 52 i(/na i(/na NNP 40436 10425 53 _ _ NNP 40436 10425 54 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10425 55 / / SYM 40436 10425 56 chri chri JJ 40436 10425 57 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10425 58 a)nupothe a)nupothe NNP 40436 10425 59 / / SYM 40436 10425 60 tou tou NN 40436 10425 61 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 10425 62 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10425 63 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10425 64 panto\s panto\s CC 40436 10425 65 a)rchê\n a)rchê\n NN 40436 10425 66 i)ô i)ô NNP 40436 10425 67 / / SYM 40436 10425 68 n n NNP 40436 10425 69 _ _ NNP 40436 10425 70 , , , 40436 10425 71 a(psa a(psa NNP 40436 10425 72 / / SYM 40436 10425 73 menos menos NNP 40436 10425 74 au)tê au)tê NNP 40436 10425 75 = = SYM 40436 10425 76 s s NNP 40436 10425 77 , , , 40436 10425 78 pa pa NNP 40436 10425 79 / / SYM 40436 10425 80 lin lin NNP 40436 10425 81 au)= au)= POS 40436 10425 82 e)cho e)cho NNP 40436 10425 83 / / SYM 40436 10425 84 menos menos NNP 40436 10425 85 tô tô NNP 40436 10425 86 = = SYM 40436 10425 87 n n CC 40436 10425 88 e)kei e)kei NNP 40436 10425 89 / / SYM 40436 10425 90 nês nês NNP 40436 10425 91 e)chome e)chome NNP 40436 10425 92 / / SYM 40436 10425 93 nôn nôn NN 40436 10425 94 , , , 40436 10425 95 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 10425 96 e)pi\ e)pi\ NNP 40436 10425 97 teleutê\n teleutê\n '' 40436 10425 98 katabai katabai NNP 40436 10425 99 / / SYM 40436 10425 100 nê| nê| NNP 40436 10425 101 , , , 40436 10425 102 ai)sthêtô=| ai)sthêtô=| NNP 40436 10425 103 panta panta NNP 40436 10425 104 / / SYM 40436 10425 105 pasin pasin NNP 40436 10425 106 ou)deni\ ou)deni\ NNP 40436 10425 107 proschrô proschrô NNP 40436 10425 108 / / SYM 40436 10425 109 menos meno NNS 40436 10425 110 , , , 40436 10425 111 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 10425 112 ' ' POS 40436 10425 113 ei)/desin ei)/desin NNP 40436 10425 114 au)toi au)toi NNP 40436 10425 115 = = SYM 40436 10425 116 s s FW 40436 10425 117 di di FW 40436 10425 118 ' ' '' 40436 10425 119 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 10425 120 = = SYM 40436 10425 121 n n CC 40436 10425 122 ei)s ei)s NNP 40436 10425 123 au)ta/ au)ta/ NNP 40436 10425 124 , , , 40436 10425 125 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10425 126 teleuta=| teleuta=| NNP 40436 10425 127 ei)s ei)s , 40436 10425 128 ei)/dê ei)/dê NNP 40436 10425 129 . . . 40436 10425 130 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10426 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10426 2 vii vii NN 40436 10426 3 . . . 40436 10427 1 p. p. NN 40436 10428 1 533 533 CD 40436 10428 2 . . . 40436 10428 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10429 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10429 2 Side side NN 40436 10429 3 - - HYPH 40436 10429 4 note note NN 40436 10429 5 : : : 40436 10429 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10429 7 's 's POS 40436 10429 8 demonstration demonstration NN 40436 10429 9 of of IN 40436 10429 10 the the DT 40436 10429 11 immortality immortality NN 40436 10429 12 of of IN 40436 10429 13 the the DT 40436 10429 14 soul soul NN 40436 10429 15 rests rest NNS 40436 10429 16 upon upon IN 40436 10429 17 the the DT 40436 10429 18 assumption assumption NN 40436 10429 19 of of IN 40436 10429 20 the the DT 40436 10429 21 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10429 22 ideas idea NNS 40436 10429 23 . . . 40436 10430 1 Reasoning reason VBG 40436 10430 2 to to TO 40436 10430 3 prove prove VB 40436 10430 4 this this DT 40436 10430 5 . . . 40436 10430 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10431 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10431 2 is be VBZ 40436 10431 3 from from IN 40436 10431 4 the the DT 40436 10431 5 assumption assumption NN 40436 10431 6 of of IN 40436 10431 7 these these DT 40436 10431 8 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10431 9 as as IN 40436 10431 10 eternal eternal JJ 40436 10431 11 Essences Essences NNPS 40436 10431 12 , , , 40436 10431 13 that that IN 40436 10431 14 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10431 15 undertakes undertake VBZ 40436 10431 16 to to TO 40436 10431 17 demonstrate demonstrate VB 40436 10431 18 the the DT 40436 10431 19 immortality immortality NN 40436 10431 20 of of IN 40436 10431 21 the the DT 40436 10431 22 soul soul NN 40436 10431 23 . . . 40436 10432 1 One one CD 40436 10432 2 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10432 3 or or CC 40436 10432 4 Form Form NNP 40436 10432 5 will will MD 40436 10432 6 not not RB 40436 10432 7 admit admit VB 40436 10432 8 , , , 40436 10432 9 but but CC 40436 10432 10 peremptorily peremptorily RB 40436 10432 11 excludes exclude NNS 40436 10432 12 , , , 40436 10432 13 the the DT 40436 10432 14 approach approach NN 40436 10432 15 of of IN 40436 10432 16 that that DT 40436 10432 17 other other JJ 40436 10432 18 Form form NN 40436 10432 19 which which WDT 40436 10432 20 is be VBZ 40436 10432 21 opposite opposite JJ 40436 10432 22 to to IN 40436 10432 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10432 24 . . . 40436 10433 1 Greatness greatness NN 40436 10433 2 will will MD 40436 10433 3 not not RB 40436 10433 4 receive receive VB 40436 10433 5 the the DT 40436 10433 6 form form NN 40436 10433 7 of of IN 40436 10433 8 littleness littleness NN 40436 10433 9 : : : 40436 10433 10 nor nor CC 40436 10433 11 will will MD 40436 10433 12 the the DT 40436 10433 13 greatness greatness NN 40436 10433 14 which which WDT 40436 10433 15 is be VBZ 40436 10433 16 in in IN 40436 10433 17 any any DT 40436 10433 18 particular particular JJ 40436 10433 19 subject subject NN 40436 10433 20 receive receive VBP 40436 10433 21 the the DT 40436 10433 22 form form NN 40436 10433 23 of of IN 40436 10433 24 littleness littleness NN 40436 10433 25 . . . 40436 10434 1 If if IN 40436 10434 2 the the DT 40436 10434 3 form form NN 40436 10434 4 of of IN 40436 10434 5 littleness littleness NN 40436 10434 6 be be VB 40436 10434 7 brought bring VBN 40436 10434 8 to to TO 40436 10434 9 bear bear VB 40436 10434 10 , , , 40436 10434 11 greatness greatness NN 40436 10434 12 will will MD 40436 10434 13 not not RB 40436 10434 14 stay stay VB 40436 10434 15 to to TO 40436 10434 16 receive receive VB 40436 10434 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10434 18 , , , 40436 10434 19 but but CC 40436 10434 20 will will MD 40436 10434 21 either either CC 40436 10434 22 retire retire VB 40436 10434 23 or or CC 40436 10434 24 be be VB 40436 10434 25 destroyed destroy VBN 40436 10434 26 . . . 40436 10435 1 The the DT 40436 10435 2 same same JJ 40436 10435 3 is be VBZ 40436 10435 4 true true JJ 40436 10435 5 likewise likewise RB 40436 10435 6 respecting respect VBG 40436 10435 7 that that IN 40436 10435 8 which which WDT 40436 10435 9 essentially essentially RB 40436 10435 10 has have VBZ 40436 10435 11 the the DT 40436 10435 12 form form NN 40436 10435 13 : : : 40436 10435 14 thus thus RB 40436 10435 15 fire fire NN 40436 10435 16 has have VBZ 40436 10435 17 essentially essentially RB 40436 10435 18 the the DT 40436 10435 19 form form NN 40436 10435 20 of of IN 40436 10435 21 heat heat NN 40436 10435 22 , , , 40436 10435 23 and and CC 40436 10435 24 snow snow NN 40436 10435 25 has have VBZ 40436 10435 26 essentially essentially RB 40436 10435 27 the the DT 40436 10435 28 form form NN 40436 10435 29 of of IN 40436 10435 30 cold cold NN 40436 10435 31 . . . 40436 10436 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 10436 2 fire fire NN 40436 10436 3 , , , 40436 10436 4 as as IN 40436 10436 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10436 6 will will MD 40436 10436 7 not not RB 40436 10436 8 receive receive VB 40436 10436 9 the the DT 40436 10436 10 form form NN 40436 10436 11 of of IN 40436 10436 12 cold cold NN 40436 10436 13 , , , 40436 10436 14 so so RB 40436 10436 15 neither neither RB 40436 10436 16 will will MD 40436 10436 17 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10436 18 receive receive VB 40436 10436 19 snow snow NN 40436 10436 20 : : : 40436 10436 21 and and CC 40436 10436 22 snow snow NN 40436 10436 23 , , , 40436 10436 24 as as IN 40436 10436 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10436 26 will will MD 40436 10436 27 not not RB 40436 10436 28 receive receive VB 40436 10436 29 the the DT 40436 10436 30 form form NN 40436 10436 31 of of IN 40436 10436 32 heat heat NN 40436 10436 33 , , , 40436 10436 34 so so CC 40436 10436 35 neither neither RB 40436 10436 36 will will MD 40436 10436 37 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10436 38 receive receive VB 40436 10436 39 fire fire NN 40436 10436 40 . . . 40436 10437 1 If if IN 40436 10437 2 fire fire NN 40436 10437 3 comes come VBZ 40436 10437 4 , , , 40436 10437 5 snow snow NN 40436 10437 6 will will MD 40436 10437 7 either either CC 40436 10437 8 retire retire VB 40436 10437 9 or or CC 40436 10437 10 will will MD 40436 10437 11 be be VB 40436 10437 12 destroyed destroy VBN 40436 10437 13 . . . 40436 10438 1 The the DT 40436 10438 2 Triad Triad NNP 40436 10438 3 has have VBZ 40436 10438 4 always always RB 40436 10438 5 the the DT 40436 10438 6 Form Form NNP 40436 10438 7 of of IN 40436 10438 8 Oddness Oddness NNP 40436 10438 9 , , , 40436 10438 10 and and CC 40436 10438 11 will will MD 40436 10438 12 never never RB 40436 10438 13 receive receive VB 40436 10438 14 that that DT 40436 10438 15 of of IN 40436 10438 16 Evenness evenness NN 40436 10438 17 : : : 40436 10438 18 the the DT 40436 10438 19 Dyad Dyad NNP 40436 10438 20 has have VBZ 40436 10438 21 always always RB 40436 10438 22 the the DT 40436 10438 23 Form Form NNP 40436 10438 24 of of IN 40436 10438 25 Evenness Evenness NNP 40436 10438 26 , , , 40436 10438 27 and and CC 40436 10438 28 will will MD 40436 10438 29 never never RB 40436 10438 30 receive receive VB 40436 10438 31 that that DT 40436 10438 32 of of IN 40436 10438 33 Oddness oddness NN 40436 10438 34 -- -- : 40436 10438 35 upon upon IN 40436 10438 36 the the DT 40436 10438 37 approach approach NN 40436 10438 38 of of IN 40436 10438 39 this this DT 40436 10438 40 latter latter JJ 40436 10438 41 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10438 42 will will MD 40436 10438 43 either either CC 40436 10438 44 disappear disappear VB 40436 10438 45 or or CC 40436 10438 46 will will MD 40436 10438 47 be be VB 40436 10438 48 destroyed destroy VBN 40436 10438 49 : : : 40436 10438 50 moreover moreover CC 40436 10438 51 the the DT 40436 10438 52 Dyad Dyad NNP 40436 10438 53 , , , 40436 10438 54 while while IN 40436 10438 55 refusing refuse VBG 40436 10438 56 to to TO 40436 10438 57 receive receive VB 40436 10438 58 the the DT 40436 10438 59 Form Form NNP 40436 10438 60 of of IN 40436 10438 61 Oddness Oddness NNP 40436 10438 62 , , , 40436 10438 63 will will MD 40436 10438 64 refuse refuse VB 40436 10438 65 also also RB 40436 10438 66 to to TO 40436 10438 67 receive receive VB 40436 10438 68 that that DT 40436 10438 69 of of IN 40436 10438 70 the the DT 40436 10438 71 Triad Triad NNP 40436 10438 72 , , , 40436 10438 73 which which WDT 40436 10438 74 always always RB 40436 10438 75 embodies embody VBZ 40436 10438 76 that that IN 40436 10438 77 Form Form NNP 40436 10438 78 -- -- : 40436 10438 79 although although IN 40436 10438 80 three three CD 40436 10438 81 is be VBZ 40436 10438 82 not not RB 40436 10438 83 in in IN 40436 10438 84 direct direct JJ 40436 10438 85 contrariety contrariety NN 40436 10438 86 with with IN 40436 10438 87 two two CD 40436 10438 88 . . . 40436 10439 1 If if IN 40436 10439 2 then then RB 40436 10439 3 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10439 4 are be VBP 40436 10439 5 asked ask VBN 40436 10439 6 , , , 40436 10439 7 What what WP 40436 10439 8 is be VBZ 40436 10439 9 that that DT 40436 10439 10 , , , 40436 10439 11 the the DT 40436 10439 12 presence presence NN 40436 10439 13 of of IN 40436 10439 14 which which WDT 40436 10439 15 makes make VBZ 40436 10439 16 a a DT 40436 10439 17 body body NN 40436 10439 18 hot hot JJ 40436 10439 19 ? ? . 40436 10440 1 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10440 2 need need VBP 40436 10440 3 not not RB 40436 10440 4 confine confine VB 40436 10440 5 ourselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10440 6 to to IN 40436 10440 7 the the DT 40436 10440 8 answer answer NN 40436 10440 9 -- -- . 40436 10440 10 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10440 11 is be VBZ 40436 10440 12 the the DT 40436 10440 13 Form Form NNP 40436 10440 14 of of IN 40436 10440 15 Heat Heat NNP 40436 10440 16 -- -- : 40436 10440 17 which which WDT 40436 10440 18 , , , 40436 10440 19 though though IN 40436 10440 20 correct correct JJ 40436 10440 21 , , , 40436 10440 22 gives give VBZ 40436 10440 23 no no DT 40436 10440 24 new new JJ 40436 10440 25 information information NN 40436 10440 26 : : : 40436 10440 27 but but CC 40436 10440 28 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10440 29 may may MD 40436 10440 30 farther farther RB 40436 10440 31 say say VB 40436 10440 32 -- -- : 40436 10440 33 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10440 34 is be VBZ 40436 10440 35 Fire Fire NNP 40436 10440 36 , , , 40436 10440 37 which which WDT 40436 10440 38 involves involve VBZ 40436 10440 39 the the DT 40436 10440 40 Form Form NNP 40436 10440 41 of of IN 40436 10440 42 Heat Heat NNP 40436 10440 43 . . . 40436 10441 1 If if IN 40436 10441 2 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10441 3 are be VBP 40436 10441 4 asked ask VBN 40436 10441 5 , , , 40436 10441 6 What what WP 40436 10441 7 is be VBZ 40436 10441 8 that that DT 40436 10441 9 , , , 40436 10441 10 the the DT 40436 10441 11 presence presence NN 40436 10441 12 of of IN 40436 10441 13 which which WDT 40436 10441 14 makes make VBZ 40436 10441 15 a a DT 40436 10441 16 number number NN 40436 10441 17 odd odd JJ 40436 10441 18 , , , 40436 10441 19 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10441 20 shall shall MD 40436 10441 21 not not RB 40436 10441 22 say say VB 40436 10441 23 -- -- : 40436 10441 24 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10441 25 is be VBZ 40436 10441 26 Oddness oddness NN 40436 10441 27 : : : 40436 10441 28 but but CC 40436 10441 29 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10441 30 shall shall MD 40436 10441 31 say say VB 40436 10441 32 -- -- : 40436 10441 33 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10441 34 is be VBZ 40436 10441 35 the the DT 40436 10441 36 Triad Triad NNP 40436 10441 37 or or CC 40436 10441 38 the the DT 40436 10441 39 Pentad Pentad NNP 40436 10441 40 -- -- : 40436 10441 41 both both DT 40436 10441 42 of of IN 40436 10441 43 which which WDT 40436 10441 44 involve involve VBP 40436 10441 45 Oddness oddness NN 40436 10441 46 . . . 40436 10442 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10442 2 Side side NN 40436 10442 3 - - HYPH 40436 10442 4 note note NN 40436 10442 5 : : : 40436 10442 6 The the DT 40436 10442 7 soul soul NN 40436 10442 8 always always RB 40436 10442 9 brings bring VBZ 40436 10442 10 life life NN 40436 10442 11 , , , 40436 10442 12 and and CC 40436 10442 13 is be VBZ 40436 10442 14 essentially essentially RB 40436 10442 15 living live VBG 40436 10442 16 . . . 40436 10443 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10443 2 can can MD 40436 10443 3 not not RB 40436 10443 4 receive receive VB 40436 10443 5 death death NN 40436 10443 6 : : : 40436 10443 7 in in IN 40436 10443 8 other other JJ 40436 10443 9 words word NNS 40436 10443 10 , , , 40436 10443 11 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10443 12 is be VBZ 40436 10443 13 immortal immortal JJ 40436 10443 14 . . . 40436 10443 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10444 1 In in IN 40436 10444 2 like like JJ 40436 10444 3 manner manner NN 40436 10444 4 , , , 40436 10444 5 the the DT 40436 10444 6 question question NN 40436 10444 7 being be VBG 40436 10444 8 asked ask VBN 40436 10444 9 , , , 40436 10444 10 What what WP 40436 10444 11 is be VBZ 40436 10444 12 that that DT 40436 10444 13 , , , 40436 10444 14 which which WDT 40436 10444 15 , , , 40436 10444 16 being be VBG 40436 10444 17 in in IN 40436 10444 18 the the DT 40436 10444 19 body body NN 40436 10444 20 , , , 40436 10444 21 will will MD 40436 10444 22 give give VB 40436 10444 23 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10444 24 life life NN 40436 10444 25 ? ? . 40436 10445 1 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10445 2 must must MD 40436 10445 3 answer answer VB 40436 10445 4 -- -- . 40436 10445 5 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10445 6 is be VBZ 40436 10445 7 the the DT 40436 10445 8 soul soul NN 40436 10445 9 . . . 40436 10446 1 The the DT 40436 10446 2 soul soul NN 40436 10446 3 , , , 40436 10446 4 when when WRB 40436 10446 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10446 6 lays lay VBZ 40436 10446 7 hold hold NN 40436 10446 8 of of IN 40436 10446 9 any any DT 40436 10446 10 body body NN 40436 10446 11 , , , 40436 10446 12 always always RB 40436 10446 13 arrives arrive VBZ 40436 10446 14 bringing bring VBG 40436 10446 15 with with IN 40436 10446 16 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10446 17 life life NN 40436 10446 18 . . . 40436 10447 1 Now now RB 40436 10447 2 death death NN 40436 10447 3 is be VBZ 40436 10447 4 the the DT 40436 10447 5 contrary contrary NN 40436 10447 6 of of IN 40436 10447 7 life life NN 40436 10447 8 . . . 40436 10448 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 40436 10448 2 the the DT 40436 10448 3 soul soul NN 40436 10448 4 , , , 40436 10448 5 which which WDT 40436 10448 6 always always RB 40436 10448 7 brings bring VBZ 40436 10448 8 with with IN 40436 10448 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10448 10 life life NN 40436 10448 11 , , , 40436 10448 12 will will MD 40436 10448 13 never never RB 40436 10448 14 receive receive VB 40436 10448 15 the the DT 40436 10448 16 contrary contrary NN 40436 10448 17 of of IN 40436 10448 18 life life NN 40436 10448 19 . . . 40436 10449 1 In in IN 40436 10449 2 other other JJ 40436 10449 3 words word NNS 40436 10449 4 , , , 40436 10449 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10449 6 is be VBZ 40436 10449 7 deathless deathless JJ 40436 10449 8 or or CC 40436 10449 9 immortal immortal JJ 40436 10449 10 . . . 40436 10450 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10450 2 83 83 CD 40436 10450 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10450 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10450 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10450 6 83 83 CD 40436 10450 7 : : : 40436 10450 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10450 9 , , , 40436 10450 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10450 11 , , , 40436 10450 12 p. p. NN 40436 10450 13 105 105 CD 40436 10450 14 C C NNP 40436 10450 15 - - HYPH 40436 10450 16 E. E. NNP 40436 10450 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10450 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10450 19 : : : 40436 10450 20 A)pokri A)pokri NNP 40436 10450 21 / / SYM 40436 10450 22 nou nou NNP 40436 10450 23 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 10450 24 , , , 40436 10450 25 ô(=| ô(=| JJ 40436 10450 26 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10450 27 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 10450 28 e)gge e)gge NNP 40436 10450 29 / / SYM 40436 10450 30 nêtai nêtai NNP 40436 10450 31 sô sô NNP 40436 10450 32 / / SYM 40436 10450 33 mati mati NNS 40436 10450 34 , , , 40436 10450 35 zô zô NNP 40436 10450 36 = = SYM 40436 10450 37 n n CD 40436 10450 38 e)/stai e)/stai NNP 40436 10450 39 ? ? . 40436 10451 1 Ô(=i Ô(=i NNP 40436 10451 2 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10451 3 psuchê/ psuchê/ NNP 40436 10451 4 , , , 40436 10451 5 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 10451 6 . . . 40436 10452 1 Ou)kou Ou)kou NNP 40436 10452 2 = = SYM 40436 10452 3 n n CC 40436 10452 4 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 10452 5 tou tou NNP 40436 10452 6 = = SYM 40436 10452 7 to to IN 40436 10452 8 ou(/tôs ou(/tôs NNP 40436 10452 9 e)/chei e)/chei . 40436 10452 10 ? ? . 40436 10453 1 Pô Pô NNP 40436 10453 2 = = NFP 40436 10453 3 s s NN 40436 10453 4 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10453 5 ou)chi/ ou)chi/ IN 40436 10453 6 ? ? . 40436 10454 1 ê)= ê)= NNP 40436 10454 2 d d NNP 40436 10454 3 ' ' '' 40436 10454 4 o(/s o(/s NNP 40436 10454 5 . . . 40436 10455 1 Ê Ê NNP 40436 10455 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10455 3 psuchê\ psuchê\ PRP 40436 10455 4 a)/ra a)/ra FW 40436 10455 5 o(/ o(/ UH 40436 10455 6 , , , 40436 10455 7 ti ti NN 40436 10455 8 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 10455 9 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 10455 10 kata kata NNP 40436 10455 11 / / SYM 40436 10455 12 schê| schê| NNP 40436 10455 13 , , , 40436 10455 14 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 10455 15 ê(/kei ê(/kei NNP 40436 10455 16 e)p e)p NNP 40436 10455 17 ' ' POS 40436 10455 18 e)kei e)kei NN 40436 10455 19 = = NFP 40436 10455 20 no no DT 40436 10455 21 phe phe NN 40436 10455 22 / / NFP 40436 10455 23 rousa rousa NNP 40436 10455 24 zôê zôê NNP 40436 10455 25 / / SYM 40436 10455 26 n n JJ 40436 10455 27 ? ? . 40436 10456 1 Ê(/kei Ê(/kei : 40436 10456 2 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10456 3 / / SYM 40436 10456 4 ntoi ntoi NNP 40436 10456 5 , , , 40436 10456 6 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 10456 7 . . . 40436 10457 1 Po Po NNP 40436 10457 2 / / SYM 40436 10457 3 teron teron NNP 40436 10457 4 d d NNP 40436 10457 5 ' ' '' 40436 10457 6 e)/sti e)/sti . 40436 10457 7 ti ti NNP 40436 10457 8 zôê=| zôê=| NNP 40436 10457 9 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 10457 10 / / SYM 40436 10457 11 on on IN 40436 10457 12 , , , 40436 10457 13 ê)\ ê)\ NNP 40436 10457 14 ou)de ou)de NNP 40436 10457 15 / / SYM 40436 10457 16 n n JJ 40436 10457 17 ? ? . 40436 10458 1 E)/stin E)/stin NNP 40436 10458 2 , , , 40436 10458 3 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 10458 4 . . . 40436 10459 1 Ti/ Ti/ NNP 40436 10459 2 ? ? . 40436 10460 1 Tha Tha NNP 40436 10460 2 / / SYM 40436 10460 3 natos nato NNS 40436 10460 4 . . . 40436 10461 1 ou)kou ou)kou NNP 40436 10461 2 = = SYM 40436 10461 3 n n CC 40436 10461 4 ê ê NNP 40436 10461 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10461 6 psuchê\ psuchê\ NNP 40436 10461 7 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10461 8 e)nanti e)nanti NNP 40436 10461 9 / / SYM 40436 10461 10 on on IN 40436 10461 11 ô(=| ô(=| JJ 40436 10461 12 au)tê\ au)tê\ NNP 40436 10461 13 e)piphe e)piphe CD 40436 10461 14 / / SYM 40436 10461 15 rei rei NN 40436 10461 16 a)ei\ a)ei\ NNP 40436 10461 17 ou ou NNP 40436 10461 18 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10461 19 mê/ mê/ NNP 40436 10461 20 pote pote NNP 40436 10461 21 de de NNP 40436 10461 22 / / SYM 40436 10461 23 xêtai xêtai NNP 40436 10461 24 , , , 40436 10461 25 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10461 26 e)k e)k NNP 40436 10461 27 tô tô NNP 40436 10461 28 = = SYM 40436 10461 29 n n CC 40436 10461 30 pro pro NNP 40436 10461 31 / / SYM 40436 10461 32 sthen sthen NNP 40436 10461 33 ô(molo ô(molo NNP 40436 10461 34 / / SYM 40436 10461 35 gêtai gêtai NNP 40436 10461 36 ? ? . 40436 10462 1 Kai\ Kai\ NNP 40436 10462 2 ma ma NNP 40436 10462 3 / / SYM 40436 10462 4 la la NNP 40436 10462 5 spho spho NNP 40436 10462 6 / / SYM 40436 10462 7 dra dra NNP 40436 10462 8 , , , 40436 10462 9 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 10462 10 o o UH 40436 10462 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10462 12 Ke Ke NNP 40436 10462 13 / / SYM 40436 10462 14 bês bês NNP 40436 10462 15 . . . 40436 10463 1 . . . 40436 10464 1 . . . 40436 10465 1 . . . 40436 10466 1 O(\ O(\ NNP 40436 10466 2 d d NNP 40436 10466 3 ' ' POS 40436 10466 4 a)\n a)\n NNP 40436 10466 5 tha tha NNP 40436 10466 6 / / SYM 40436 10466 7 naton naton NNP 40436 10466 8 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 10466 9 de de NNP 40436 10466 10 / / SYM 40436 10466 11 chêtai chêtai NNP 40436 10466 12 , , , 40436 10466 13 ti/ ti/ NNP 40436 10466 14 kalou kalou NNP 40436 10466 15 = = SYM 40436 10466 16 men man NNS 40436 10466 17 ? ? . 40436 10467 1 A)tha A)tha NNP 40436 10467 2 / / SYM 40436 10467 3 naton naton NNP 40436 10467 4 , , , 40436 10467 5 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 10467 6 . . . 40436 10468 1 A)tha A)tha NNP 40436 10468 2 / / SYM 40436 10468 3 naton naton NNP 40436 10468 4 a)/ra a)/ra NNP 40436 10468 5 ê ê NNP 40436 10468 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10468 7 psuchê/ psuchê/ NNP 40436 10468 8 ? ? . 40436 10469 1 A)tha A)tha NNP 40436 10469 2 / / SYM 40436 10469 3 naton naton NNP 40436 10469 4 . . . 40436 10469 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10470 1 Nemesius Nemesius NNP 40436 10470 2 , , , 40436 10470 3 the the DT 40436 10470 4 Christian christian JJ 40436 10470 5 bishop bishop NN 40436 10470 6 of of IN 40436 10470 7 Emesa Emesa NNP 40436 10470 8 , , , 40436 10470 9 declares declare VBZ 40436 10470 10 that that IN 40436 10470 11 the the DT 40436 10470 12 proofs proof NNS 40436 10470 13 given give VBN 40436 10470 14 by by IN 40436 10470 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10470 16 of of IN 40436 10470 17 the the DT 40436 10470 18 immortality immortality NN 40436 10470 19 of of IN 40436 10470 20 the the DT 40436 10470 21 soul soul NN 40436 10470 22 are be VBP 40436 10470 23 knotty knotty JJ 40436 10470 24 and and CC 40436 10470 25 difficult difficult JJ 40436 10470 26 to to TO 40436 10470 27 understand understand VB 40436 10470 28 , , , 40436 10470 29 such such JJ 40436 10470 30 as as IN 40436 10470 31 even even RB 40436 10470 32 adepts adept NNS 40436 10470 33 in in IN 40436 10470 34 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 10470 35 study study NN 40436 10470 36 can can MD 40436 10470 37 hardly hardly RB 40436 10470 38 follow follow VB 40436 10470 39 . . . 40436 10471 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10471 2 own own JJ 40436 10471 3 belief belief NN 40436 10471 4 in in IN 40436 10471 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10471 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10471 7 rests rest VBZ 40436 10471 8 upon upon IN 40436 10471 9 the the DT 40436 10471 10 inspiration inspiration NN 40436 10471 11 of of IN 40436 10471 12 the the DT 40436 10471 13 Christian Christian NNP 40436 10471 14 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 40436 10471 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10471 16 Nemesius Nemesius NNP 40436 10471 17 de de IN 40436 10471 18 Nat Nat NNP 40436 10471 19 . . . 40436 10472 1 Homin homin NN 40436 10472 2 . . . 40436 10473 1 c. c. NNP 40436 10473 2 2 2 CD 40436 10473 3 . . . 40436 10473 4 p. p. NN 40436 10473 5 55 55 CD 40436 10473 6 , , , 40436 10473 7 ed ed NN 40436 10473 8 . . . 40436 10474 1 1565 1565 CD 40436 10474 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10474 3 . . . 40436 10474 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10475 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10475 2 Side side NN 40436 10475 3 - - HYPH 40436 10475 4 note note NN 40436 10475 5 : : : 40436 10475 6 The the DT 40436 10475 7 proof proof NN 40436 10475 8 of of IN 40436 10475 9 immortality immortality NN 40436 10475 10 includes include VBZ 40436 10475 11 pre pre JJ 40436 10475 12 - - NN 40436 10475 13 existence existence NN 40436 10475 14 as as RB 40436 10475 15 well well RB 40436 10475 16 as as IN 40436 10475 17 post post JJ 40436 10475 18 - - JJ 40436 10475 19 existence existence NN 40436 10475 20 -- -- : 40436 10475 21 animals animal NNS 40436 10475 22 as as RB 40436 10475 23 well well RB 40436 10475 24 as as IN 40436 10475 25 man man NN 40436 10475 26 -- -- : 40436 10475 27 also also RB 40436 10475 28 the the DT 40436 10475 29 metempsychosis metempsychosis NN 40436 10475 30 or or CC 40436 10475 31 translation translation NN 40436 10475 32 of of IN 40436 10475 33 the the DT 40436 10475 34 soul soul NN 40436 10475 35 from from IN 40436 10475 36 one one CD 40436 10475 37 body body NN 40436 10475 38 to to IN 40436 10475 39 another another DT 40436 10475 40 . . . 40436 10475 41 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10476 1 Such such JJ 40436 10476 2 is be VBZ 40436 10476 3 the the DT 40436 10476 4 ground ground NN 40436 10476 5 upon upon IN 40436 10476 6 which which WDT 40436 10476 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10476 8 rests rest VBZ 40436 10476 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10476 10 belief belief NN 40436 10476 11 in in IN 40436 10476 12 the the DT 40436 10476 13 immortality immortality NN 40436 10476 14 of of IN 40436 10476 15 the the DT 40436 10476 16 soul soul NN 40436 10476 17 . . . 40436 10477 1 The the DT 40436 10477 2 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10477 3 reposes repose VBZ 40436 10477 4 , , , 40436 10477 5 in in IN 40436 10477 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10477 7 's 's POS 40436 10477 8 view view NN 40436 10477 9 , , , 40436 10477 10 upon upon IN 40436 10477 11 the the DT 40436 10477 12 assumption assumption NN 40436 10477 13 of of IN 40436 10477 14 eternal eternal JJ 40436 10477 15 , , , 40436 10477 16 self self NN 40436 10477 17 - - HYPH 40436 10477 18 existent existent NN 40436 10477 19 , , , 40436 10477 20 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 40436 10477 21 , , , 40436 10477 22 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 10477 23 or or CC 40436 10477 24 Forms:[84 Forms:[84 NNP 40436 10477 25 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10477 26 upon upon IN 40436 10477 27 the the DT 40436 10477 28 congeniality congeniality NN 40436 10477 29 of of IN 40436 10477 30 nature nature NN 40436 10477 31 , , , 40436 10477 32 and and CC 40436 10477 33 inherent inherent JJ 40436 10477 34 correlation correlation NN 40436 10477 35 , , , 40436 10477 36 between between IN 40436 10477 37 these these DT 40436 10477 38 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10477 39 and and CC 40436 10477 40 the the DT 40436 10477 41 Soul soul NN 40436 10477 42 : : : 40436 10477 43 upon upon IN 40436 10477 44 the the DT 40436 10477 45 fact fact NN 40436 10477 46 , , , 40436 10477 47 that that IN 40436 10477 48 the the DT 40436 10477 49 soul soul NN 40436 10477 50 knows know VBZ 40436 10477 51 these these DT 40436 10477 52 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10477 53 , , , 40436 10477 54 which which WDT 40436 10477 55 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10477 56 must must MD 40436 10477 57 have have VB 40436 10477 58 been be VBN 40436 10477 59 acquired acquire VBN 40436 10477 60 in in IN 40436 10477 61 a a DT 40436 10477 62 prior prior JJ 40436 10477 63 state state NN 40436 10477 64 of of IN 40436 10477 65 existence existence NN 40436 10477 66 : : : 40436 10477 67 and and CC 40436 10477 68 upon upon IN 40436 10477 69 the the DT 40436 10477 70 essential essential JJ 40436 10477 71 participation participation NN 40436 10477 72 of of IN 40436 10477 73 the the DT 40436 10477 74 soul soul NN 40436 10477 75 in in IN 40436 10477 76 the the DT 40436 10477 77 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10477 78 of of IN 40436 10477 79 life life NN 40436 10477 80 , , , 40436 10477 81 so so IN 40436 10477 82 that that IN 40436 10477 83 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10477 84 can can MD 40436 10477 85 not not RB 40436 10477 86 be be VB 40436 10477 87 conceived conceive VBN 40436 10477 88 as as IN 40436 10477 89 without without IN 40436 10477 90 life life NN 40436 10477 91 , , , 40436 10477 92 or or CC 40436 10477 93 as as IN 40436 10477 94 dead dead JJ 40436 10477 95 . . . 40436 10478 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10478 2 85 85 CD 40436 10478 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10478 4 The the DT 40436 10478 5 immortality immortality NN 40436 10478 6 of of IN 40436 10478 7 the the DT 40436 10478 8 soul soul NN 40436 10478 9 is be VBZ 40436 10478 10 conceived conceive VBN 40436 10478 11 as as RB 40436 10478 12 necessary necessary JJ 40436 10478 13 and and CC 40436 10478 14 entire entire JJ 40436 10478 15 , , , 40436 10478 16 including include VBG 40436 10478 17 not not RB 40436 10478 18 merely merely RB 40436 10478 19 post post JJ 40436 10478 20 - - JJ 40436 10478 21 existence existence NN 40436 10478 22 , , , 40436 10478 23 but but CC 40436 10478 24 also also RB 40436 10478 25 pre pre VB 40436 10478 26 - - NN 40436 10478 27 existence existence NN 40436 10478 28 . . . 40436 10479 1 In in IN 40436 10479 2 fact fact NN 40436 10479 3 the the DT 40436 10479 4 reference reference NN 40436 10479 5 to to IN 40436 10479 6 an an DT 40436 10479 7 anterior anterior JJ 40436 10479 8 time time NN 40436 10479 9 is be VBZ 40436 10479 10 more more RBR 40436 10479 11 essential essential JJ 40436 10479 12 to to IN 40436 10479 13 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10479 14 's 's POS 40436 10479 15 theory theory NN 40436 10479 16 than than IN 40436 10479 17 that that DT 40436 10479 18 to to IN 40436 10479 19 a a DT 40436 10479 20 posterior posterior NN 40436 10479 21 time time NN 40436 10479 22 ; ; : 40436 10479 23 because because IN 40436 10479 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10479 25 is be VBZ 40436 10479 26 employed employ VBN 40436 10479 27 to to TO 40436 10479 28 explain explain VB 40436 10479 29 the the DT 40436 10479 30 cognitions cognition NNS 40436 10479 31 of of IN 40436 10479 32 the the DT 40436 10479 33 mind mind NN 40436 10479 34 , , , 40436 10479 35 and and CC 40436 10479 36 the the DT 40436 10479 37 identity identity NN 40436 10479 38 of of IN 40436 10479 39 learning learn VBG 40436 10479 40 with with IN 40436 10479 41 reminiscence reminiscence NN 40436 10479 42 : : : 40436 10479 43 while while IN 40436 10479 44 Simmias Simmias NNP 40436 10479 45 , , , 40436 10479 46 who who WP 40436 10479 47 even even RB 40436 10479 48 at at IN 40436 10479 49 the the DT 40436 10479 50 close close NN 40436 10479 51 is be VBZ 40436 10479 52 not not RB 40436 10479 53 without without IN 40436 10479 54 reserve reserve NN 40436 10479 55 on on IN 40436 10479 56 the the DT 40436 10479 57 subject subject NN 40436 10479 58 of of IN 40436 10479 59 the the DT 40436 10479 60 post post NN 40436 10479 61 - - NN 40436 10479 62 existence existence NN 40436 10479 63 , , , 40436 10479 64 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 10479 65 an an DT 40436 10479 66 emphatic emphatic JJ 40436 10479 67 adhesion adhesion NN 40436 10479 68 on on IN 40436 10479 69 that that DT 40436 10479 70 of of IN 40436 10479 71 the the DT 40436 10479 72 pre pre NN 40436 10479 73 - - NN 40436 10479 74 existence existence NN 40436 10479 75 . . . 40436 10480 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10480 2 86 86 CD 40436 10480 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10480 4 The the DT 40436 10480 5 proof proof NN 40436 10480 6 , , , 40436 10480 7 moreover moreover RB 40436 10480 8 , , , 40436 10480 9 being be VBG 40436 10480 10 founded found VBN 40436 10480 11 in in IN 40436 10480 12 great great JJ 40436 10480 13 part part NN 40436 10480 14 on on IN 40436 10480 15 the the DT 40436 10480 16 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10480 17 of of IN 40436 10480 18 Life Life NNP 40436 10480 19 , , , 40436 10480 20 embraces embrace VBZ 40436 10480 21 every every DT 40436 10480 22 thing thing NN 40436 10480 23 living live VBG 40436 10480 24 , , , 40436 10480 25 and and CC 40436 10480 26 is be VBZ 40436 10480 27 common common JJ 40436 10480 28 to to IN 40436 10480 29 animals[87 animals[87 LS 40436 10480 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10480 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10480 32 if if IN 40436 10480 33 not not RB 40436 10480 34 to to TO 40436 10480 35 plants plant NNS 40436 10480 36 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10480 37 as as RB 40436 10480 38 well well RB 40436 10480 39 as as IN 40436 10480 40 to to IN 40436 10480 41 men man NNS 40436 10480 42 : : : 40436 10480 43 and and CC 40436 10480 44 the the DT 40436 10480 45 metempsychosis metempsychosis NN 40436 10480 46 -- -- : 40436 10480 47 or or CC 40436 10480 48 transition transition NN 40436 10480 49 of of IN 40436 10480 50 souls soul NNS 40436 10480 51 not not RB 40436 10480 52 merely merely RB 40436 10480 53 from from IN 40436 10480 54 one one CD 40436 10480 55 human human JJ 40436 10480 56 body body NN 40436 10480 57 to to IN 40436 10480 58 another another DT 40436 10480 59 , , , 40436 10480 60 but but CC 40436 10480 61 also also RB 40436 10480 62 from from IN 40436 10480 63 the the DT 40436 10480 64 human human NN 40436 10480 65 to to IN 40436 10480 66 the the DT 40436 10480 67 animal animal NN 40436 10480 68 body body NN 40436 10480 69 , , , 40436 10480 70 and and CC 40436 10480 71 _ _ NNP 40436 10480 72 vice vice NN 40436 10480 73 versâ_--is versâ_--is NNP 40436 10480 74 a a DT 40436 10480 75 portion portion NN 40436 10480 76 of of IN 40436 10480 77 the the DT 40436 10480 78 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10480 79 creed creed NN 40436 10480 80 . . . 40436 10481 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10481 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10481 3 84 84 CD 40436 10481 4 : : : 40436 10481 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10481 6 , , , 40436 10481 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10481 8 , , , 40436 10481 9 pp pp NNP 40436 10481 10 . . . 40436 10482 1 76 76 CD 40436 10482 2 D d NN 40436 10482 3 - - HYPH 40436 10482 4 E e NN 40436 10482 5 , , , 40436 10482 6 100 100 CD 40436 10482 7 B B NNP 40436 10482 8 - - HYPH 40436 10482 9 C. C. NNP 40436 10483 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10483 2 is be VBZ 40436 10483 3 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 10483 4 that that IN 40436 10483 5 in in IN 40436 10483 6 the the DT 40436 10483 7 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10483 8 also also RB 40436 10483 9 , , , 40436 10483 10 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10483 11 undertakes undertake VBZ 40436 10483 12 to to TO 40436 10483 13 demonstrate demonstrate VB 40436 10483 14 the the DT 40436 10483 15 immortality immortality NN 40436 10483 16 of of IN 40436 10483 17 the the DT 40436 10483 18 soul soul NN 40436 10483 19 : : : 40436 10483 20 and and CC 40436 10483 21 that that IN 40436 10483 22 in in IN 40436 10483 23 doing do VBG 40436 10483 24 so so RB 40436 10483 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10483 26 does do VBZ 40436 10483 27 not not RB 40436 10483 28 make make VB 40436 10483 29 any any DT 40436 10483 30 reference reference NN 40436 10483 31 or or CC 40436 10483 32 allusion allusion NN 40436 10483 33 to to IN 40436 10483 34 the the DT 40436 10483 35 arguments argument NNS 40436 10483 36 used use VBN 40436 10483 37 in in IN 40436 10483 38 the the DT 40436 10483 39 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10483 40 , , , 40436 10483 41 but but CC 40436 10483 42 produces produce VBZ 40436 10483 43 another another DT 40436 10483 44 argument argument NN 40436 10483 45 totally totally RB 40436 10483 46 distinct distinct JJ 40436 10483 47 and and CC 40436 10483 48 novel novel JJ 40436 10483 49 : : : 40436 10483 50 an an DT 40436 10483 51 argument argument NN 40436 10483 52 which which WDT 40436 10483 53 Meiners Meiners NNP 40436 10483 54 remarks remark VBZ 40436 10483 55 truly truly RB 40436 10483 56 to to TO 40436 10483 57 be be VB 40436 10483 58 quite quite RB 40436 10483 59 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 10483 60 to to IN 40436 10483 61 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10483 62 , , , 40436 10483 63 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10483 64 , , , 40436 10483 65 x. x. NNP 40436 10483 66 pp pp NNP 40436 10483 67 . . . 40436 10484 1 609 609 CD 40436 10484 2 E e NN 40436 10484 3 , , , 40436 10484 4 611 611 CD 40436 10484 5 C c NN 40436 10484 6 ; ; : 40436 10484 7 Meiners Meiners NNP 40436 10484 8 , , , 40436 10484 9 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 40436 10484 10 der der XX 40436 10484 11 Wissenschaften Wissenschaften NNP 40436 10484 12 , , , 40436 10484 13 vol vol NNP 40436 10484 14 . . . 40436 10485 1 ii ii LS 40436 10485 2 . . . 40436 10486 1 p. p. NN 40436 10487 1 780 780 CD 40436 10487 2 . . . 40436 10487 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10488 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10488 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10488 3 85 85 CD 40436 10488 4 : : : 40436 10488 5 Zeller Zeller NNP 40436 10488 6 , , , 40436 10488 7 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 40436 10488 8 der der VBD 40436 10488 9 Griech Griech NNP 40436 10488 10 . . . 40436 10489 1 Part Part NNP 40436 10489 2 ii ii NNP 40436 10489 3 . . . 40436 10490 1 p. p. NN 40436 10490 2 267 267 CD 40436 10490 3 . . . 40436 10491 1 " " `` 40436 10491 2 Die Die NNP 40436 10491 3 Seele Seele NNP 40436 10491 4 ist ist NN 40436 10491 5 ihrem ihrem NN 40436 10491 6 Begriffe Begriffe NNP 40436 10491 7 nach nach NNP 40436 10491 8 dasjenige dasjenige NNP 40436 10491 9 , , , 40436 10491 10 zu zu NNP 40436 10491 11 dessen dessen NNP 40436 10491 12 Wesen Wesen NNP 40436 10491 13 es es NNP 40436 10491 14 gehört gehört NNS 40436 10491 15 zu zu NNP 40436 10491 16 leben leben NNP 40436 10491 17 -- -- : 40436 10491 18 sie sie NNP 40436 10491 19 kann kann NNP 40436 10491 20 also also RB 40436 10491 21 in in IN 40436 10491 22 keinem keinem NNP 40436 10491 23 Augenblicke Augenblicke NNP 40436 10491 24 als als NNP 40436 10491 25 nicht nicht NNP 40436 10491 26 lebend lebend NNP 40436 10491 27 gedacht gedacht NNP 40436 10491 28 werden werden NNP 40436 10491 29 : : : 40436 10491 30 In in IN 40436 10491 31 diesem diesem NN 40436 10491 32 ontologischen ontologischen NNP 40436 10491 33 Beweis Beweis NNP 40436 10491 34 für für NN 40436 10491 35 die die VBP 40436 10491 36 Unsterblichkeit Unsterblichkeit NNP 40436 10491 37 , , , 40436 10491 38 laufen laufen NN 40436 10491 39 nicht nicht NNP 40436 10491 40 bloss bloss NNP 40436 10491 41 alle alle NNP 40436 10491 42 die die VBP 40436 10491 43 einzelnen einzelnen NNP 40436 10491 44 Beweise Beweise NNP 40436 10491 45 des des FW 40436 10491 46 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10491 47 zusammen zusammen NNP 40436 10491 48 , , , 40436 10491 49 sondern sondern NNP 40436 10491 50 derselbe derselbe NNP 40436 10491 51 wird wird NNP 40436 10491 52 auch auch NNP 40436 10491 53 schon schon NNP 40436 10491 54 i -PRON- PRP 40436 10491 55 m be VBP 40436 10491 56 Phaedrus Phaedrus NNP 40436 10491 57 vorgetragen vorgetragen NN 40436 10491 58 , , , 40436 10491 59 " " '' 40436 10491 60 & & CC 40436 10491 61 c. c. NNP 40436 10491 62 Compare Compare NNP 40436 10491 63 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 10491 64 , , , 40436 10491 65 p. p. NN 40436 10491 66 245 245 CD 40436 10491 67 . . . 40436 10492 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 40436 10492 2 , , , 40436 10492 3 in in IN 40436 10492 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10492 5 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 40436 10492 6 der der IN 40436 10492 7 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 40436 10492 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10492 9 Part Part NNP 40436 10492 10 ii ii NNP 40436 10492 11 . . . 40436 10493 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10493 2 . . . 40436 10494 1 186 186 CD 40436 10494 2 - - HYPH 40436 10494 3 187 187 CD 40436 10494 4 - - HYPH 40436 10494 5 189 189 CD 40436 10494 6 , , , 40436 10494 7 ed ed NN 40436 10494 8 . . . 40436 10495 1 2 2 LS 40436 10495 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10495 3 , , , 40436 10495 4 maintains maintain VBZ 40436 10495 5 that that IN 40436 10495 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10495 7 did do VBD 40436 10495 8 not not RB 40436 10495 9 conceive conceive VB 40436 10495 10 the the DT 40436 10495 11 soul soul NN 40436 10495 12 as as IN 40436 10495 13 a a DT 40436 10495 14 separate separate JJ 40436 10495 15 thing thing NN 40436 10495 16 or or CC 40436 10495 17 reality reality NN 40436 10495 18 -- -- : 40436 10495 19 that that IN 40436 10495 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10495 21 did do VBD 40436 10495 22 not not RB 40436 10495 23 mean mean VB 40436 10495 24 to to TO 40436 10495 25 affirm affirm VB 40436 10495 26 , , , 40436 10495 27 in in IN 40436 10495 28 the the DT 40436 10495 29 literal literal JJ 40436 10495 30 sense sense NN 40436 10495 31 of of IN 40436 10495 32 the the DT 40436 10495 33 words word NNS 40436 10495 34 , , , 40436 10495 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10495 36 separate separate JJ 40436 10495 37 existence existence NN 40436 10495 38 either either CC 40436 10495 39 before before IN 40436 10495 40 or or CC 40436 10495 41 after after IN 40436 10495 42 the the DT 40436 10495 43 present present JJ 40436 10495 44 life life NN 40436 10495 45 -- -- : 40436 10495 46 that that IN 40436 10495 47 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10495 48 did do VBD 40436 10495 49 not not RB 40436 10495 50 descend descend VB 40436 10495 51 to to TO 40436 10495 52 so so RB 40436 10495 53 crude crude VB 40436 10495 54 a a DT 40436 10495 55 conception conception NN 40436 10495 56 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10495 57 zu zu NNP 40436 10495 58 dieser dieser NN 40436 10495 59 Rohheit Rohheit NNP 40436 10495 60 herabzusinken herabzusinken VBN 40436 10495 61 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10495 62 as as IN 40436 10495 63 to to TO 40436 10495 64 represent represent VB 40436 10495 65 to to IN 40436 10495 66 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10495 67 the the DT 40436 10495 68 soul soul NN 40436 10495 69 as as IN 40436 10495 70 a a DT 40436 10495 71 thing thing NN 40436 10495 72 , , , 40436 10495 73 or or CC 40436 10495 74 to to TO 40436 10495 75 enquire enquire VB 40436 10495 76 into into IN 40436 10495 77 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10495 78 duration duration NN 40436 10495 79 or or CC 40436 10495 80 continuance continuance NN 40436 10495 81 after after IN 40436 10495 82 the the DT 40436 10495 83 manner manner NN 40436 10495 84 of of IN 40436 10495 85 a a DT 40436 10495 86 thing thing NN 40436 10495 87 -- -- : 40436 10495 88 that that IN 40436 10495 89 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10495 90 understood understand VBD 40436 10495 91 the the DT 40436 10495 92 soul soul NN 40436 10495 93 to to TO 40436 10495 94 exist exist VB 40436 10495 95 essentially essentially RB 40436 10495 96 as as IN 40436 10495 97 the the DT 40436 10495 98 Universal Universal NNP 40436 10495 99 Notion Notion NNP 40436 10495 100 or or CC 40436 10495 101 Idea Idea NNP 40436 10495 102 , , , 40436 10495 103 the the DT 40436 10495 104 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 40436 10495 105 aggregate aggregate NN 40436 10495 106 of of IN 40436 10495 107 all all DT 40436 10495 108 other other JJ 40436 10495 109 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10495 110 , , , 40436 10495 111 in in IN 40436 10495 112 which which WDT 40436 10495 113 sense sense NN 40436 10495 114 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10495 115 affirmed affirm VBD 40436 10495 116 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10495 117 to to TO 40436 10495 118 be be VB 40436 10495 119 immortal immortal JJ 40436 10495 120 -- -- : 40436 10495 121 that that IN 40436 10495 122 the the DT 40436 10495 123 descriptions description NNS 40436 10495 124 which which WDT 40436 10495 125 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10495 126 gives give VBZ 40436 10495 127 of of IN 40436 10495 128 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10495 129 condition condition NN 40436 10495 130 , , , 40436 10495 131 either either CC 40436 10495 132 before before IN 40436 10495 133 life life NN 40436 10495 134 or or CC 40436 10495 135 after after IN 40436 10495 136 death death NN 40436 10495 137 , , , 40436 10495 138 are be VBP 40436 10495 139 to to TO 40436 10495 140 be be VB 40436 10495 141 treated treat VBN 40436 10495 142 only only RB 40436 10495 143 as as IN 40436 10495 144 poetical poetical JJ 40436 10495 145 metaphors metaphor NNS 40436 10495 146 . . . 40436 10496 1 There there EX 40436 10496 2 is be VBZ 40436 10496 3 ingenuity ingenuity NN 40436 10496 4 in in IN 40436 10496 5 this this DT 40436 10496 6 view view NN 40436 10496 7 of of IN 40436 10496 8 Hegel Hegel NNP 40436 10496 9 , , , 40436 10496 10 and and CC 40436 10496 11 many many JJ 40436 10496 12 separate separate JJ 40436 10496 13 expressions expression NNS 40436 10496 14 of of IN 40436 10496 15 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10496 16 receive receive VBP 40436 10496 17 light light NN 40436 10496 18 from from IN 40436 10496 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10496 20 : : : 40436 10496 21 but but CC 40436 10496 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10496 23 appears appear VBZ 40436 10496 24 to to IN 40436 10496 25 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10496 26 to to TO 40436 10496 27 refine refine VB 40436 10496 28 away away RB 40436 10496 29 too too RB 40436 10496 30 much much RB 40436 10496 31 . . . 40436 10497 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10497 2 had have VBD 40436 10497 3 in in IN 40436 10497 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10497 5 own own JJ 40436 10497 6 mind mind NN 40436 10497 7 and and CC 40436 10497 8 belief belief NN 40436 10497 9 both both CC 40436 10497 10 the the DT 40436 10497 11 soul soul NN 40436 10497 12 as as IN 40436 10497 13 a a DT 40436 10497 14 particular particular JJ 40436 10497 15 thing thing NN 40436 10497 16 -- -- : 40436 10497 17 and and CC 40436 10497 18 the the DT 40436 10497 19 soul soul NN 40436 10497 20 as as IN 40436 10497 21 an an DT 40436 10497 22 universal universal NN 40436 10497 23 . . . 40436 10498 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10498 2 language language NN 40436 10498 3 implies imply VBZ 40436 10498 4 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 10498 5 the the DT 40436 10498 6 one one NN 40436 10498 7 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 10498 8 the the DT 40436 10498 9 other other JJ 40436 10498 10 . . . 40436 10498 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10499 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10499 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10499 3 86 86 CD 40436 10499 4 : : : 40436 10499 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10499 6 , , , 40436 10499 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10499 8 , , , 40436 10499 9 pp pp NNP 40436 10499 10 . . . 40436 10500 1 92 92 CD 40436 10500 2 , , , 40436 10500 3 107 107 CD 40436 10500 4 B. B. NNP 40436 10500 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10501 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10501 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10501 3 87 87 CD 40436 10501 4 : : : 40436 10501 5 See see VB 40436 10501 6 what what WP 40436 10501 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10501 8 says say VBZ 40436 10501 9 about about IN 40436 10501 10 the the DT 40436 10501 11 swans swan NNS 40436 10501 12 , , , 40436 10501 13 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10501 14 , , , 40436 10501 15 p. p. NN 40436 10501 16 85 85 CD 40436 10501 17 A A NNP 40436 10501 18 - - HYPH 40436 10501 19 B. b. NN 40436 10501 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10502 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10502 2 Side side NN 40436 10502 3 - - HYPH 40436 10502 4 note note NN 40436 10502 5 : : : 40436 10502 6 After after IN 40436 10502 7 finishing finish VBG 40436 10502 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10502 9 proof proof NN 40436 10502 10 that that IN 40436 10502 11 the the DT 40436 10502 12 soul soul NN 40436 10502 13 is be VBZ 40436 10502 14 immortal immortal JJ 40436 10502 15 , , , 40436 10502 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10502 17 enters enter VBZ 40436 10502 18 into into IN 40436 10502 19 a a DT 40436 10502 20 description description NN 40436 10502 21 , , , 40436 10502 22 what what WP 40436 10502 23 will will MD 40436 10502 24 become become VB 40436 10502 25 of of IN 40436 10502 26 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10502 27 after after IN 40436 10502 28 the the DT 40436 10502 29 death death NN 40436 10502 30 of of IN 40436 10502 31 the the DT 40436 10502 32 body body NN 40436 10502 33 . . . 40436 10503 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10503 2 describes describe VBZ 40436 10503 3 a a DT 40436 10503 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10503 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10503 6 : : : 40436 10503 7 Nekui Nekui NNP 40436 10503 8 / / SYM 40436 10503 9 a a NN 40436 10503 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10503 11 . . . 40436 10503 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10504 1 Having have VBG 40436 10504 2 completed complete VBN 40436 10504 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10504 4 demonstration demonstration NN 40436 10504 5 of of IN 40436 10504 6 the the DT 40436 10504 7 immortality immortality NN 40436 10504 8 of of IN 40436 10504 9 the the DT 40436 10504 10 soul soul NN 40436 10504 11 , , , 40436 10504 12 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10504 13 proceeds proceed VBZ 40436 10504 14 to to TO 40436 10504 15 give give VB 40436 10504 16 a a DT 40436 10504 17 sketch sketch NN 40436 10504 18 of of IN 40436 10504 19 the the DT 40436 10504 20 condition condition NN 40436 10504 21 and and CC 40436 10504 22 treatment treatment NN 40436 10504 23 which which WDT 40436 10504 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10504 25 experiences experience VBZ 40436 10504 26 after after IN 40436 10504 27 death death NN 40436 10504 28 . . . 40436 10505 1 The the DT 40436 10505 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10505 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10505 4 : : : 40436 10505 5 Nekui Nekui NNP 40436 10505 6 / / SYM 40436 10505 7 a a LS 40436 10505 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10505 9 here here RB 40436 10505 10 following follow VBG 40436 10505 11 is be VBZ 40436 10505 12 analogous analogous JJ 40436 10505 13 , , , 40436 10505 14 in in IN 40436 10505 15 general general JJ 40436 10505 16 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 40436 10505 17 scope scope NN 40436 10505 18 , , , 40436 10505 19 to to IN 40436 10505 20 those those DT 40436 10505 21 others other NNS 40436 10505 22 which which WDT 40436 10505 23 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10505 24 read read VBP 40436 10505 25 in in IN 40436 10505 26 the the DT 40436 10505 27 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10505 28 and and CC 40436 10505 29 in in IN 40436 10505 30 the the DT 40436 10505 31 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 10505 32 : : : 40436 10505 33 but but CC 40436 10505 34 all all DT 40436 10505 35 of of IN 40436 10505 36 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10505 37 are be VBP 40436 10505 38 different different JJ 40436 10505 39 in in IN 40436 10505 40 particular particular JJ 40436 10505 41 incidents incident NNS 40436 10505 42 , , , 40436 10505 43 illustrative illustrative JJ 40436 10505 44 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 10505 45 , , , 40436 10505 46 and and CC 40436 10505 47 scenery scenery NN 40436 10505 48 . . . 40436 10506 1 The the DT 40436 10506 2 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 10506 3 of of IN 40436 10506 4 belief belief NN 40436 10506 5 in in IN 40436 10506 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10506 7 's 's POS 40436 10506 8 mind mind NN 40436 10506 9 attaches attach VBZ 40436 10506 10 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10506 11 to to IN 40436 10506 12 general general JJ 40436 10506 13 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 10506 14 , , , 40436 10506 15 which which WDT 40436 10506 16 appear appear VBP 40436 10506 17 to to IN 40436 10506 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10506 19 to to TO 40436 10506 20 possess possess VB 40436 10506 21 an an DT 40436 10506 22 evidence evidence NN 40436 10506 23 independent independent JJ 40436 10506 24 of of IN 40436 10506 25 particulars particular NNS 40436 10506 26 . . . 40436 10507 1 When when WRB 40436 10507 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10507 3 applies apply VBZ 40436 10507 4 these these DT 40436 10507 5 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 10507 6 to to IN 40436 10507 7 particulars particular NNS 40436 10507 8 , , , 40436 10507 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10507 10 makes make VBZ 40436 10507 11 little little JJ 40436 10507 12 distinction distinction NN 40436 10507 13 between between IN 40436 10507 14 such such JJ 40436 10507 15 as as IN 40436 10507 16 are be VBP 40436 10507 17 true true JJ 40436 10507 18 , , , 40436 10507 19 or or CC 40436 10507 20 problematical problematical JJ 40436 10507 21 , , , 40436 10507 22 or or CC 40436 10507 23 fictitious fictitious JJ 40436 10507 24 : : : 40436 10507 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10507 26 varies vary VBZ 40436 10507 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10507 28 mythes mythe NNS 40436 10507 29 at at IN 40436 10507 30 pleasure pleasure NN 40436 10507 31 , , , 40436 10507 32 provided provide VBN 40436 10507 33 that that IN 40436 10507 34 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10507 35 serve serve VBP 40436 10507 36 the the DT 40436 10507 37 purpose purpose NN 40436 10507 38 of of IN 40436 10507 39 illustrating illustrate VBG 40436 10507 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10507 41 general general JJ 40436 10507 42 view view NN 40436 10507 43 . . . 40436 10508 1 The the DT 40436 10508 2 mythe mythe NN 40436 10508 3 which which WDT 40436 10508 4 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10508 5 read read VBP 40436 10508 6 in in IN 40436 10508 7 the the DT 40436 10508 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10508 9 includes include VBZ 40436 10508 10 a a DT 40436 10508 11 description description NN 40436 10508 12 of of IN 40436 10508 13 the the DT 40436 10508 14 Earth Earth NNP 40436 10508 15 which which WDT 40436 10508 16 to to IN 40436 10508 17 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10508 18 appears appear VBZ 40436 10508 19 altogether altogether RB 40436 10508 20 imaginative imaginative JJ 40436 10508 21 and and CC 40436 10508 22 poetical poetical JJ 40436 10508 23 : : : 40436 10508 24 yet yet CC 40436 10508 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10508 26 is be VBZ 40436 10508 27 hardly hardly RB 40436 10508 28 more more RBR 40436 10508 29 so so RB 40436 10508 30 than than IN 40436 10508 31 several several JJ 40436 10508 32 other other JJ 40436 10508 33 current current JJ 40436 10508 34 theories theory NNS 40436 10508 35 , , , 40436 10508 36 proposed propose VBN 40436 10508 37 by by IN 40436 10508 38 various various JJ 40436 10508 39 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10508 40 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 10508 41 and and CC 40436 10508 42 contemporary contemporary NN 40436 10508 43 , , , 40436 10508 44 respecting respect VBG 40436 10508 45 Earth Earth NNP 40436 10508 46 and and CC 40436 10508 47 Sea Sea NNP 40436 10508 48 . . . 40436 10509 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10509 2 criticises criticise VBZ 40436 10509 3 the the DT 40436 10509 4 views view NNS 40436 10509 5 expressed express VBN 40436 10509 6 in in IN 40436 10509 7 the the DT 40436 10509 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10509 9 , , , 40436 10509 10 as as IN 40436 10509 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10509 12 criticises criticise VBZ 40436 10509 13 those those DT 40436 10509 14 of of IN 40436 10509 15 Demokritus Demokritus NNP 40436 10509 16 and and CC 40436 10509 17 Empedokles Empedokles NNP 40436 10509 18 . . . 40436 10510 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10510 2 88 88 CD 40436 10510 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10510 4 Each each DT 40436 10510 5 soul soul NN 40436 10510 6 of of IN 40436 10510 7 a a DT 40436 10510 8 deceased deceased JJ 40436 10510 9 person person NN 40436 10510 10 is be VBZ 40436 10510 11 conducted conduct VBN 40436 10510 12 by by IN 40436 10510 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10510 14 Genius Genius NNP 40436 10510 15 to to IN 40436 10510 16 the the DT 40436 10510 17 proper proper JJ 40436 10510 18 place place NN 40436 10510 19 , , , 40436 10510 20 and and CC 40436 10510 21 there there EX 40436 10510 22 receives receive VBZ 40436 10510 23 sentence sentence NN 40436 10510 24 of of IN 40436 10510 25 condemnation condemnation NN 40436 10510 26 to to IN 40436 10510 27 suffering suffering NN 40436 10510 28 , , , 40436 10510 29 greater great JJR 40436 10510 30 or or CC 40436 10510 31 less less RBR 40436 10510 32 according accord VBG 40436 10510 33 to to IN 40436 10510 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10510 35 conduct conduct NN 40436 10510 36 in in IN 40436 10510 37 life life NN 40436 10510 38 , , , 40436 10510 39 in in IN 40436 10510 40 the the DT 40436 10510 41 deep deep JJ 40436 10510 42 chasm chasm NN 40436 10510 43 called call VBN 40436 10510 44 Tartarus Tartarus NNP 40436 10510 45 , , , 40436 10510 46 and and CC 40436 10510 47 in in IN 40436 10510 48 the the DT 40436 10510 49 rivers river NNS 40436 10510 50 of of IN 40436 10510 51 mud mud NN 40436 10510 52 and and CC 40436 10510 53 fire fire NN 40436 10510 54 , , , 40436 10510 55 Styx Styx NNP 40436 10510 56 , , , 40436 10510 57 Kokytus Kokytus NNP 40436 10510 58 , , , 40436 10510 59 Pyriphlegethon Pyriphlegethon NNP 40436 10510 60 . . . 40436 10511 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10511 2 89 89 CD 40436 10511 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10511 4 To to IN 40436 10511 5 those those DT 40436 10511 6 who who WP 40436 10511 7 have have VBP 40436 10511 8 passed pass VBN 40436 10511 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10511 10 lives life NNS 40436 10511 11 in in IN 40436 10511 12 learning learning NN 40436 10511 13 , , , 40436 10511 14 and and CC 40436 10511 15 who who WP 40436 10511 16 have have VBP 40436 10511 17 detached detach VBN 40436 10511 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10511 19 as as RB 40436 10511 20 much much RB 40436 10511 21 as as IN 40436 10511 22 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10511 23 possibly possibly RB 40436 10511 24 could could MD 40436 10511 25 from from IN 40436 10511 26 all all DT 40436 10511 27 pleasures pleasure NNS 40436 10511 28 and and CC 40436 10511 29 all all DT 40436 10511 30 pursuits pursuit NNS 40436 10511 31 connected connect VBN 40436 10511 32 with with IN 40436 10511 33 the the DT 40436 10511 34 body body NN 40436 10511 35 -- -- : 40436 10511 36 in in IN 40436 10511 37 order order NN 40436 10511 38 to to TO 40436 10511 39 pursue pursue VB 40436 10511 40 wisdom wisdom NN 40436 10511 41 and and CC 40436 10511 42 virtue virtue NN 40436 10511 43 -- -- : 40436 10511 44 a a DT 40436 10511 45 full full JJ 40436 10511 46 reward reward NN 40436 10511 47 is be VBZ 40436 10511 48 given give VBN 40436 10511 49 . . . 40436 10512 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 10512 2 are be VBP 40436 10512 3 emancipated emancipate VBN 40436 10512 4 from from IN 40436 10512 5 the the DT 40436 10512 6 obligation obligation NN 40436 10512 7 of of IN 40436 10512 8 entering enter VBG 40436 10512 9 another another DT 40436 10512 10 body body NN 40436 10512 11 , , , 40436 10512 12 and and CC 40436 10512 13 are be VBP 40436 10512 14 allowed allow VBN 40436 10512 15 to to TO 40436 10512 16 live live VB 40436 10512 17 ever ever RB 40436 10512 18 afterwards afterwards RB 40436 10512 19 disembodied disembody VBN 40436 10512 20 in in IN 40436 10512 21 the the DT 40436 10512 22 pure pure JJ 40436 10512 23 regions region NNS 40436 10512 24 of of IN 40436 10512 25 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10512 26 . . . 40436 10513 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10513 2 90 90 CD 40436 10513 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10513 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10513 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10513 6 88 88 CD 40436 10513 7 : : : 40436 10513 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10513 9 , , , 40436 10513 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10513 11 , , , 40436 10513 12 pp pp NNP 40436 10513 13 . . . 40436 10514 1 107 107 CD 40436 10514 2 - - SYM 40436 10514 3 111 111 CD 40436 10514 4 . . . 40436 10515 1 Olympiodorus Olympiodorus NNP 40436 10515 2 pronounces pronounce VBZ 40436 10515 3 the the DT 40436 10515 4 mythe mythe NN 40436 10515 5 to to TO 40436 10515 6 be be VB 40436 10515 7 a a DT 40436 10515 8 good good JJ 40436 10515 9 imitation imitation NN 40436 10515 10 of of IN 40436 10515 11 the the DT 40436 10515 12 truth truth NN 40436 10515 13 , , , 40436 10515 14 Republ Republ NNP 40436 10515 15 . . . 40436 10516 1 x. x. NNP 40436 10517 1 620 620 CD 40436 10517 2 seq seq NN 40436 10517 3 . . . 40436 10518 1 ; ; : 40436 10518 2 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 10518 3 , , , 40436 10518 4 p. p. NN 40436 10518 5 520 520 CD 40436 10518 6 ; ; : 40436 10518 7 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10518 8 , , , 40436 10518 9 Meteorol Meteorol NNP 40436 10518 10 . . . 40436 10519 1 ii ii LS 40436 10519 2 . . . 40436 10520 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10520 2 . . . 40436 10521 1 355 355 CD 40436 10521 2 - - SYM 40436 10521 3 356 356 CD 40436 10521 4 . . . 40436 10522 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10522 2 also also RB 40436 10522 3 356 356 CD 40436 10522 4 , , , 40436 10522 5 b. b. NN 40436 10523 1 10 10 CD 40436 10523 2 , , , 40436 10523 3 357 357 CD 40436 10523 4 , , , 40436 10523 5 a. a. NN 40436 10524 1 25 25 CD 40436 10524 2 , , , 40436 10524 3 where where WRB 40436 10524 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10524 5 states state VBZ 40436 10524 6 and and CC 40436 10524 7 canvasses canvass VBZ 40436 10524 8 the the DT 40436 10524 9 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 10524 10 of of IN 40436 10524 11 Demokritus Demokritus NNP 40436 10524 12 and and CC 40436 10524 13 Empedokles Empedokles NNPS 40436 10524 14 ; ; : 40436 10524 15 also also RB 40436 10524 16 352 352 CD 40436 10524 17 , , , 40436 10524 18 a. a. NN 40436 10525 1 35 35 CD 40436 10525 2 , , , 40436 10525 3 about about IN 40436 10525 4 the the DT 40436 10525 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10525 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10525 7 : : : 40436 10525 8 a)rchai a)rchai NNS 40436 10525 9 = = SYM 40436 10525 10 oi oi UH 40436 10525 11 theo theo NN 40436 10525 12 / / SYM 40436 10525 13 logoi logoi NN 40436 10525 14 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10525 15 . . . 40436 10526 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10526 2 is be VBZ 40436 10526 3 rather rather RB 40436 10526 4 more more RBR 40436 10526 5 severe severe JJ 40436 10526 6 upon upon IN 40436 10526 7 these these DT 40436 10526 8 others other NNS 40436 10526 9 than than IN 40436 10526 10 upon upon IN 40436 10526 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10526 12 . . . 40436 10527 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10527 2 too too RB 40436 10527 3 considers consider VBZ 40436 10527 4 , , , 40436 10527 5 like like IN 40436 10527 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10527 7 , , , 40436 10527 8 that that IN 40436 10527 9 the the DT 40436 10527 10 amount amount NN 40436 10527 11 of of IN 40436 10527 12 evidence evidence NN 40436 10527 13 which which WDT 40436 10527 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10527 15 ought ought MD 40436 10527 16 to to TO 40436 10527 17 require require VB 40436 10527 18 for for IN 40436 10527 19 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10527 20 belief belief NN 40436 10527 21 depends depend VBZ 40436 10527 22 upon upon IN 40436 10527 23 the the DT 40436 10527 24 nature nature NN 40436 10527 25 of of IN 40436 10527 26 the the DT 40436 10527 27 subject subject NN 40436 10527 28 ; ; : 40436 10527 29 and and CC 40436 10527 30 that that IN 40436 10527 31 there there EX 40436 10527 32 are be VBP 40436 10527 33 various various JJ 40436 10527 34 subjects subject NNS 40436 10527 35 on on IN 40436 10527 36 which which WDT 40436 10527 37 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10527 38 ought ought MD 40436 10527 39 to to TO 40436 10527 40 believe believe VB 40436 10527 41 on on IN 40436 10527 42 slighter slighter JJ 40436 10527 43 evidence evidence NN 40436 10527 44 : : : 40436 10527 45 see see VB 40436 10527 46 Metaphysic Metaphysic NNP 40436 10527 47 . . . 40436 10528 1 A. A. NNP 40436 10529 1 995 995 CD 40436 10529 2 , , , 40436 10529 3 a. a. NN 40436 10530 1 2 2 CD 40436 10530 2 - - SYM 40436 10530 3 16 16 CD 40436 10530 4 : : : 40436 10530 5 Ethic Ethic NNP 40436 10530 6 . . . 40436 10531 1 Nikom Nikom NNP 40436 10531 2 . . . 40436 10532 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10533 1 1 1 CD 40436 10533 2 , , , 40436 10533 3 1094 1094 CD 40436 10533 4 , , , 40436 10533 5 b. b. NNP 40436 10534 1 12 12 CD 40436 10534 2 - - SYM 40436 10534 3 14 14 CD 40436 10534 4 . . . 40436 10534 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10535 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10535 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10535 3 89 89 CD 40436 10535 4 : : : 40436 10535 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10535 6 , , , 40436 10535 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10535 8 , , , 40436 10535 9 pp pp NNP 40436 10535 10 . . . 40436 10536 1 111 111 CD 40436 10536 2 - - SYM 40436 10536 3 112 112 CD 40436 10536 4 . . . 40436 10537 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10537 2 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 40436 10537 3 , , , 40436 10537 4 Præp Præp NNP 40436 10537 5 . . . 40436 10538 1 Ev Ev NNP 40436 10538 2 . . . 40436 10539 1 xiii xiii NNP 40436 10539 2 . . . 40436 10540 1 13 13 CD 40436 10540 2 , , , 40436 10540 3 and and CC 40436 10540 4 Arnobius Arnobius NNP 40436 10540 5 adv adv NN 40436 10540 6 . . . 40436 10541 1 Gentes Gentes NNP 40436 10541 2 , , , 40436 10541 3 ii ii NNP 40436 10541 4 . . . 40436 10542 1 14 14 CD 40436 10542 2 . . . 40436 10543 1 Arnobius Arnobius NNP 40436 10543 2 blames blame VBZ 40436 10543 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10543 4 for for IN 40436 10543 5 inconsistency inconsistency NN 40436 10543 6 in in IN 40436 10543 7 saying say VBG 40436 10543 8 that that IN 40436 10543 9 the the DT 40436 10543 10 soul soul NN 40436 10543 11 is be VBZ 40436 10543 12 immortal immortal JJ 40436 10543 13 in in IN 40436 10543 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10543 15 own own JJ 40436 10543 16 nature nature NN 40436 10543 17 , , , 40436 10543 18 and and CC 40436 10543 19 yet yet RB 40436 10543 20 that that IN 40436 10543 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10543 22 suffers suffer VBZ 40436 10543 23 pain pain NN 40436 10543 24 after after IN 40436 10543 25 death--"Rem death--"Rem NNP 40436 10543 26 inenodabilem inenodabilem NNP 40436 10543 27 suscipit suscipit NN 40436 10543 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10543 29 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10543 30 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10543 31 ut ut NNP 40436 10543 32 cum cum NNP 40436 10543 33 animas animas NNP 40436 10543 34 dicat dicat VBP 40436 10543 35 immortales immortale NNS 40436 10543 36 , , , 40436 10543 37 perpetuas perpetuas NNP 40436 10543 38 , , , 40436 10543 39 et et FW 40436 10543 40 ex ex FW 40436 10543 41 corporali corporali NNP 40436 10543 42 soliditate soliditate VBP 40436 10543 43 privatas privatas NNP 40436 10543 44 , , , 40436 10543 45 puniri puniri NNP 40436 10543 46 eas eas NNP 40436 10543 47 dicat dicat NNP 40436 10543 48 tamen tamen NNP 40436 10543 49 et et NNP 40436 10543 50 doloris doloris NNP 40436 10543 51 afficiat afficiat NNP 40436 10543 52 sensu sensu NN 40436 10543 53 . . . 40436 10544 1 Quis Quis NNP 40436 10544 2 autem autem NNP 40436 10544 3 hominum hominum NNP 40436 10544 4 non non AFX 40436 10544 5 videt videt NNP 40436 10544 6 quod quod NN 40436 10544 7 sit sit VBP 40436 10544 8 immortale immortale NNP 40436 10544 9 , , , 40436 10544 10 quod quod NN 40436 10544 11 simplex simplex NNP 40436 10544 12 , , , 40436 10544 13 nullum nullum NNP 40436 10544 14 posse posse NNP 40436 10544 15 dolorem dolorem NN 40436 10544 16 admittere admittere RB 40436 10544 17 ; ; : 40436 10544 18 quod quod NN 40436 10544 19 autem autem NNP 40436 10544 20 sentiat sentiat NNP 40436 10544 21 dolorem dolorem NNP 40436 10544 22 , , , 40436 10544 23 immortalitatem immortalitatem NNP 40436 10544 24 habere habere RB 40436 10544 25 non non NNP 40436 10544 26 posse posse NN 40436 10544 27 ? ? . 40436 10544 28 " " '' 40436 10544 29 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10545 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10545 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10545 3 90 90 CD 40436 10545 4 : : : 40436 10545 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10545 6 , , , 40436 10545 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10545 8 , , , 40436 10545 9 p. p. NN 40436 10545 10 114 114 CD 40436 10545 11 C C NNP 40436 10545 12 - - HYPH 40436 10545 13 E. E. NNP 40436 10545 14 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10545 15 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10545 16 : : : 40436 10545 17 tou tou NNP 40436 10545 18 = = SYM 40436 10545 19 tôn tôn NNP 40436 10545 20 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10545 21 au)tô au)tô NNP 40436 10545 22 = = SYM 40436 10545 23 n n CC 40436 10545 24 oi oi NNP 40436 10545 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10545 26 philosophi philosophi NNS 40436 10545 27 / / SYM 40436 10545 28 a| a| NN 40436 10545 29 i(kanô i(kanô NNS 40436 10545 30 = = NFP 40436 10545 31 s s NNP 40436 10545 32 kathêra kathêra NNP 40436 10545 33 / / SYM 40436 10545 34 menoi menoi NNP 40436 10545 35 a)/neu a)/neu RB 40436 10545 36 te te NNP 40436 10545 37 sôma sôma NNP 40436 10545 38 / / SYM 40436 10545 39 tôn tôn NNP 40436 10545 40 zô zô NNP 40436 10545 41 = = SYM 40436 10545 42 si si IN 40436 10545 43 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10545 44 para para NNP 40436 10545 45 / / SYM 40436 10545 46 pan pan NN 40436 10545 47 ei)s ei)s JJ 40436 10545 48 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10545 49 e)/peita e)/peita VBZ 40436 10545 50 chro chro NN 40436 10545 51 / / SYM 40436 10545 52 non non JJ 40436 10545 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10545 54 , , , 40436 10545 55 & & CC 40436 10545 56 c. c. NNP 40436 10545 57 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10545 58 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10545 59 Side side NN 40436 10545 60 - - HYPH 40436 10545 61 note note NN 40436 10545 62 : : : 40436 10545 63 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10545 64 expects expect VBZ 40436 10545 65 that that IN 40436 10545 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10545 67 soul soul NN 40436 10545 68 is be VBZ 40436 10545 69 going go VBG 40436 10545 70 to to IN 40436 10545 71 the the DT 40436 10545 72 islands island NNS 40436 10545 73 of of IN 40436 10545 74 the the DT 40436 10545 75 blest blest NN 40436 10545 76 . . . 40436 10546 1 Reply reply NN 40436 10546 2 to to IN 40436 10546 3 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10546 4 about about IN 40436 10546 5 burying bury VBG 40436 10546 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10546 7 body body NN 40436 10546 8 . . . 40436 10546 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10547 1 Such such JJ 40436 10547 2 , , , 40436 10547 3 or or CC 40436 10547 4 something something NN 40436 10547 5 like like IN 40436 10547 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10547 7 , , , 40436 10547 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10547 9 confidently confidently RB 40436 10547 10 expects expect VBZ 40436 10547 11 will will MD 40436 10547 12 be be VB 40436 10547 13 the the DT 40436 10547 14 fate fate NN 40436 10547 15 awaiting await VBG 40436 10547 16 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10547 17 . . . 40436 10548 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10548 2 91 91 CD 40436 10548 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10548 4 When when WRB 40436 10548 5 asked ask VBN 40436 10548 6 by by IN 40436 10548 7 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10548 8 , , , 40436 10548 9 among among IN 40436 10548 10 other other JJ 40436 10548 11 questions question NNS 40436 10548 12 , , , 40436 10548 13 how how WRB 40436 10548 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10548 15 desired desire VBD 40436 10548 16 to to TO 40436 10548 17 be be VB 40436 10548 18 buried bury VBN 40436 10548 19 , , , 40436 10548 20 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10548 21 replies reply VBZ 40436 10548 22 with with IN 40436 10548 23 a a DT 40436 10548 24 smile--"You smile--"You NNP 40436 10548 25 may may MD 40436 10548 26 bury bury VB 40436 10548 27 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10548 28 as as IN 40436 10548 29 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10548 30 choose choose VBP 40436 10548 31 , , , 40436 10548 32 if if IN 40436 10548 33 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10548 34 can can MD 40436 10548 35 only only RB 40436 10548 36 catch catch VB 40436 10548 37 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10548 38 . . . 40436 10549 1 But but CC 40436 10549 2 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10549 3 will will MD 40436 10549 4 not not RB 40436 10549 5 understand understand VB 40436 10549 6 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10549 7 when when WRB 40436 10549 8 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10549 9 tell tell VBP 40436 10549 10 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10549 11 , , , 40436 10549 12 that that IN 40436 10549 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10549 14 , , , 40436 10549 15 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10549 16 , , , 40436 10549 17 who who WP 40436 10549 18 am be VBP 40436 10549 19 now now RB 40436 10549 20 speaking speak VBG 40436 10549 21 , , , 40436 10549 22 shall shall MD 40436 10549 23 not not RB 40436 10549 24 remain remain VB 40436 10549 25 with with IN 40436 10549 26 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10549 27 after after IN 40436 10549 28 having have VBG 40436 10549 29 drunk drunk JJ 40436 10549 30 the the DT 40436 10549 31 poison poison NN 40436 10549 32 , , , 40436 10549 33 but but CC 40436 10549 34 shall shall MD 40436 10549 35 depart depart VB 40436 10549 36 to to IN 40436 10549 37 some some DT 40436 10549 38 of of IN 40436 10549 39 the the DT 40436 10549 40 enjoyments enjoyment NNS 40436 10549 41 of of IN 40436 10549 42 the the DT 40436 10549 43 blest bl JJS 40436 10549 44 . . . 40436 10550 1 You -PRON- PRP 40436 10550 2 must must MD 40436 10550 3 not not RB 40436 10550 4 talk talk VB 40436 10550 5 about about IN 40436 10550 6 burying bury VBG 40436 10550 7 or or CC 40436 10550 8 burning burn VBG 40436 10550 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10550 10 , , , 40436 10550 11 as as IN 40436 10550 12 if if IN 40436 10550 13 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10550 14 were be VBD 40436 10550 15 suffering suffer VBG 40436 10550 16 some some DT 40436 10550 17 terrible terrible JJ 40436 10550 18 operation operation NN 40436 10550 19 . . . 40436 10551 1 Such such JJ 40436 10551 2 language language NN 40436 10551 3 is be VBZ 40436 10551 4 inauspicious inauspicious JJ 40436 10551 5 and and CC 40436 10551 6 depressing depressing JJ 40436 10551 7 to to IN 40436 10551 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10551 9 minds mind NNS 40436 10551 10 . . . 40436 10552 1 Keep keep VB 40436 10552 2 up up RP 40436 10552 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10552 4 courage courage NN 40436 10552 5 , , , 40436 10552 6 and and CC 40436 10552 7 talk talk VB 40436 10552 8 only only RB 40436 10552 9 of of IN 40436 10552 10 burying bury VBG 40436 10552 11 the the DT 40436 10552 12 body body NN 40436 10552 13 of of IN 40436 10552 14 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10552 15 : : : 40436 10552 16 conduct conduct VB 40436 10552 17 the the DT 40436 10552 18 burial burial NN 40436 10552 19 as as IN 40436 10552 20 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10552 21 think think VBP 40436 10552 22 best best RB 40436 10552 23 and and CC 40436 10552 24 most most RBS 40436 10552 25 decent decent JJ 40436 10552 26 . . . 40436 10553 1 " " `` 40436 10553 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10553 3 92 92 CD 40436 10553 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10553 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10553 6 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10553 7 91 91 CD 40436 10553 8 : : : 40436 10553 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10553 10 , , , 40436 10553 11 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10553 12 , , , 40436 10553 13 p. p. NN 40436 10553 14 115 115 CD 40436 10553 15 A. a. NN 40436 10553 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10554 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10554 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10554 3 92 92 CD 40436 10554 4 : : : 40436 10554 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10554 6 , , , 40436 10554 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10554 8 , , , 40436 10554 9 p. p. NN 40436 10554 10 115 115 CD 40436 10554 11 D. D. NNP 40436 10554 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10554 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10554 14 : : : 40436 10554 15 ô(s ô(s VB 40436 10554 16 e)peida\n e)peida\n JJ 40436 10554 17 pi pi NN 40436 10554 18 / / SYM 40436 10554 19 ô ô NN 40436 10554 20 to\ to\ NNP 40436 10554 21 pha pha NNP 40436 10554 22 / / SYM 40436 10554 23 rmakon rmakon NNP 40436 10554 24 ou)ke ou)ke NNP 40436 10554 25 / / SYM 40436 10554 26 ti ti NN 40436 10554 27 u(mi u(mi NN 40436 10554 28 = = SYM 40436 10554 29 n n NN 40436 10554 30 paramenô= paramenô= NN 40436 10554 31 , , , 40436 10554 32 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 10554 33 ' ' `` 40436 10554 34 oi)chê oi)chê NNP 40436 10554 35 / / SYM 40436 10554 36 somai somai NNP 40436 10554 37 a)piô\n a)piô\n NNP 40436 10554 38 ei)s ei)s NNP 40436 10554 39 maka maka NNP 40436 10554 40 / / SYM 40436 10554 41 rôn rôn NNP 40436 10554 42 dê/ dê/ NNP 40436 10554 43 tinas tinas NNP 40436 10554 44 eu)daimoni eu)daimoni NNP 40436 10554 45 / / SYM 40436 10554 46 as as IN 40436 10554 47 . . . 40436 10554 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10554 49 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10555 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10555 2 Side side NN 40436 10555 3 - - HYPH 40436 10555 4 note note NN 40436 10555 5 : : : 40436 10555 6 Preparations preparation NNS 40436 10555 7 for for IN 40436 10555 8 administering administer VBG 40436 10555 9 the the DT 40436 10555 10 hemlock hemlock NN 40436 10555 11 . . . 40436 10556 1 Sympathy Sympathy NNP 40436 10556 2 of of IN 40436 10556 3 the the DT 40436 10556 4 gaoler gaoler NN 40436 10556 5 . . . 40436 10557 1 Equanimity equanimity NN 40436 10557 2 of of IN 40436 10557 3 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10557 4 . . . 40436 10557 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10558 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10558 2 then then RB 40436 10558 3 retires retire VBZ 40436 10558 4 with with IN 40436 10558 5 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10558 6 into into IN 40436 10558 7 an an DT 40436 10558 8 interior interior JJ 40436 10558 9 chamber chamber NN 40436 10558 10 to to IN 40436 10558 11 bathe bathe NNP 40436 10558 12 , , , 40436 10558 13 desiring desire VBG 40436 10558 14 that that IN 40436 10558 15 the the DT 40436 10558 16 women woman NNS 40436 10558 17 may may MD 40436 10558 18 be be VB 40436 10558 19 spared spare VBN 40436 10558 20 the the DT 40436 10558 21 task task NN 40436 10558 22 of of IN 40436 10558 23 washing wash VBG 40436 10558 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10558 25 body body NN 40436 10558 26 after after IN 40436 10558 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10558 28 decease decease NN 40436 10558 29 . . . 40436 10559 1 Having have VBG 40436 10559 2 taken take VBN 40436 10559 3 final final JJ 40436 10559 4 leave leave NN 40436 10559 5 of of IN 40436 10559 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10559 7 wife wife NN 40436 10559 8 and and CC 40436 10559 9 children child NNS 40436 10559 10 , , , 40436 10559 11 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10559 12 returns return VBZ 40436 10559 13 to to IN 40436 10559 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10559 15 friends friend NNS 40436 10559 16 as as IN 40436 10559 17 sunset sunset NN 40436 10559 18 is be VBZ 40436 10559 19 approaching approach VBG 40436 10559 20 . . . 40436 10560 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10560 2 are be VBP 40436 10560 3 here here RB 40436 10560 4 made make VBN 40436 10560 5 to to TO 40436 10560 6 see see VB 40436 10560 7 the the DT 40436 10560 8 contrast contrast NN 40436 10560 9 between between IN 40436 10560 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10560 11 and and CC 40436 10560 12 other other JJ 40436 10560 13 prisoners prisoner NNS 40436 10560 14 under under IN 40436 10560 15 like like JJ 40436 10560 16 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 10560 17 . . . 40436 10561 1 The the DT 40436 10561 2 attendant attendant NN 40436 10561 3 of of IN 40436 10561 4 the the DT 40436 10561 5 Eleven Eleven NNP 40436 10561 6 Magistrates Magistrates NNPS 40436 10561 7 comes come VBZ 40436 10561 8 to to TO 40436 10561 9 warn warn VB 40436 10561 10 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10561 11 that that IN 40436 10561 12 the the DT 40436 10561 13 hour hour NN 40436 10561 14 has have VBZ 40436 10561 15 come come VBN 40436 10561 16 for for IN 40436 10561 17 swallowing swallow VBG 40436 10561 18 the the DT 40436 10561 19 poison poison NN 40436 10561 20 ; ; : 40436 10561 21 expressing express VBG 40436 10561 22 sympathy sympathy NN 40436 10561 23 and and CC 40436 10561 24 regret regret NN 40436 10561 25 for for IN 40436 10561 26 the the DT 40436 10561 27 necessity necessity NN 40436 10561 28 of of IN 40436 10561 29 delivering deliver VBG 40436 10561 30 so so RB 40436 10561 31 painful painful JJ 40436 10561 32 a a DT 40436 10561 33 message message NN 40436 10561 34 , , , 40436 10561 35 together together RB 40436 10561 36 with with IN 40436 10561 37 admiration admiration NN 40436 10561 38 for for IN 40436 10561 39 the the DT 40436 10561 40 equanimity equanimity NN 40436 10561 41 and and CC 40436 10561 42 rational rational JJ 40436 10561 43 judgment judgment NN 40436 10561 44 of of IN 40436 10561 45 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10561 46 , , , 40436 10561 47 which which WDT 40436 10561 48 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10561 49 contrasts contrast VBZ 40436 10561 50 forcibly forcibly RB 40436 10561 51 with with IN 40436 10561 52 the the DT 40436 10561 53 discontent discontent NN 40436 10561 54 and and CC 40436 10561 55 wrath wrath NN 40436 10561 56 of of IN 40436 10561 57 other other JJ 40436 10561 58 prisoners prisoner NNS 40436 10561 59 under under IN 40436 10561 60 similar similar JJ 40436 10561 61 circumstances circumstance NNS 40436 10561 62 . . . 40436 10562 1 As as IN 40436 10562 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10562 3 turned turn VBD 40436 10562 4 away away RB 40436 10562 5 with with IN 40436 10562 6 tears tear NNS 40436 10562 7 in in IN 40436 10562 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10562 9 eyes eye NNS 40436 10562 10 , , , 40436 10562 11 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10562 12 exclaimed--"How exclaimed--"How NNP 40436 10562 13 courteous courteous JJ 40436 10562 14 the the DT 40436 10562 15 man man NN 40436 10562 16 is be VBZ 40436 10562 17 to to IN 40436 10562 18 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10562 19 and and CC 40436 10562 20 has have VBZ 40436 10562 21 been be VBN 40436 10562 22 from from IN 40436 10562 23 the the DT 40436 10562 24 beginning beginning NN 40436 10562 25 ! ! . 40436 10563 1 how how WRB 40436 10563 2 generously generously RB 40436 10563 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10563 4 now now RB 40436 10563 5 weeps weep VBZ 40436 10563 6 for for IN 40436 10563 7 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10563 8 ! ! . 40436 10564 1 Let let VB 40436 10564 2 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10564 3 obey obey VB 40436 10564 4 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10564 5 , , , 40436 10564 6 and and CC 40436 10564 7 let let VB 40436 10564 8 the the DT 40436 10564 9 poison poison NN 40436 10564 10 be be VB 40436 10564 11 brought bring VBN 40436 10564 12 forthwith forthwith NNP 40436 10564 13 , , , 40436 10564 14 if if IN 40436 10564 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10564 16 be be VB 40436 10564 17 prepared prepare VBN 40436 10564 18 : : : 40436 10564 19 if if IN 40436 10564 20 not not RB 40436 10564 21 , , , 40436 10564 22 let let VB 40436 10564 23 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10564 24 prepare prepare VB 40436 10564 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10564 26 . . . 40436 10564 27 " " '' 40436 10565 1 " " `` 40436 10565 2 Do do VB 40436 10565 3 not not RB 40436 10565 4 hurry hurry VB 40436 10565 5 " " '' 40436 10565 6 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10565 7 interposed interpose VBN 40436 10565 8 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10565 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10565 10 : : : 40436 10565 11 " " `` 40436 10565 12 there there EX 40436 10565 13 is be VBZ 40436 10565 14 still still RB 40436 10565 15 time time NN 40436 10565 16 , , , 40436 10565 17 for for IN 40436 10565 18 the the DT 40436 10565 19 sun sun NN 40436 10565 20 is be VBZ 40436 10565 21 not not RB 40436 10565 22 quite quite RB 40436 10565 23 set set VBN 40436 10565 24 . . . 40436 10566 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10566 2 have have VBP 40436 10566 3 known know VBN 40436 10566 4 others other NNS 40436 10566 5 who who WP 40436 10566 6 , , , 40436 10566 7 even even RB 40436 10566 8 after after IN 40436 10566 9 receiving receive VBG 40436 10566 10 the the DT 40436 10566 11 order order NN 40436 10566 12 , , , 40436 10566 13 deferred defer VBN 40436 10566 14 drinking drink VBG 40436 10566 15 the the DT 40436 10566 16 poison poison NN 40436 10566 17 until until IN 40436 10566 18 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10566 19 had have VBD 40436 10566 20 had have VBN 40436 10566 21 a a DT 40436 10566 22 good good JJ 40436 10566 23 supper supper NN 40436 10566 24 and and CC 40436 10566 25 other other JJ 40436 10566 26 enjoyments enjoyment NNS 40436 10566 27 . . . 40436 10566 28 " " '' 40436 10567 1 " " `` 40436 10567 2 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10567 3 is be VBZ 40436 10567 4 natural natural JJ 40436 10567 5 that that IN 40436 10567 6 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10567 7 should should MD 40436 10567 8 do do VB 40436 10567 9 so so RB 40436 10567 10 " " '' 40436 10567 11 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10567 12 replied replied JJ 40436 10567 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10567 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10567 15 . . . 40436 10568 1 " " `` 40436 10568 2 They -PRON- PRP 40436 10568 3 think think VBP 40436 10568 4 that that IN 40436 10568 5 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10568 6 are be VBP 40436 10568 7 gainers gainer NNS 40436 10568 8 by by IN 40436 10568 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10568 10 : : : 40436 10568 11 for for IN 40436 10568 12 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10568 13 , , , 40436 10568 14 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10568 15 is be VBZ 40436 10568 16 natural natural JJ 40436 10568 17 that that IN 40436 10568 18 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10568 19 should should MD 40436 10568 20 not not RB 40436 10568 21 do do VB 40436 10568 22 so so RB 40436 10568 23 -- -- : 40436 10568 24 for for IN 40436 10568 25 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10568 26 shall shall MD 40436 10568 27 gain gain VB 40436 10568 28 nothing nothing NN 40436 10568 29 but but IN 40436 10568 30 contempt contempt NN 40436 10568 31 in in IN 40436 10568 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10568 33 own own JJ 40436 10568 34 eyes eye NNS 40436 10568 35 , , , 40436 10568 36 by by IN 40436 10568 37 thus thus RB 40436 10568 38 clinging cling VBG 40436 10568 39 to to IN 40436 10568 40 life life NN 40436 10568 41 , , , 40436 10568 42 and and CC 40436 10568 43 saving save VBG 40436 10568 44 up up RP 40436 10568 45 when when WRB 40436 10568 46 there there EX 40436 10568 47 is be VBZ 40436 10568 48 nothing nothing NN 40436 10568 49 left leave VBN 40436 10568 50 . . . 40436 10569 1 " " `` 40436 10569 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10569 3 93 93 CD 40436 10569 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10569 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10569 6 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10569 7 93 93 CD 40436 10569 8 : : : 40436 10569 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10569 10 , , , 40436 10569 11 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10569 12 , , , 40436 10569 13 p. p. NN 40436 10569 14 117 117 CD 40436 10569 15 A. a. NN 40436 10570 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10570 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10570 3 : : : 40436 10570 4 glicho glicho NN 40436 10570 5 / / SYM 40436 10570 6 menos menos NNP 40436 10570 7 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10570 8 zê=|n zê=|n CD 40436 10570 9 , , , 40436 10570 10 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10570 11 pheido pheido NNP 40436 10570 12 / / SYM 40436 10570 13 menos menos JJ 40436 10570 14 ou)deno\s ou)deno\s NNP 40436 10570 15 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 10570 16 e)no e)no NN 40436 10570 17 / / SYM 40436 10570 18 ntos ntos NNP 40436 10570 19 . . . 40436 10570 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10571 1 Hesiod hesiod NN 40436 10571 2 . . . 40436 10572 1 Opp Opp NNP 40436 10572 2 . . . 40436 10573 1 et et NN 40436 10573 2 Dies Dies NNP 40436 10573 3 , , , 40436 10573 4 367 367 CD 40436 10573 5 . . . 40436 10574 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10574 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10574 3 : : : 40436 10574 4 deilê\ deilê\ NNP 40436 10574 5 d d NNP 40436 10574 6 ' ' `` 40436 10574 7 e)ni\ e)ni\ NNP 40436 10574 8 puthme puthme NNP 40436 10574 9 / / SYM 40436 10574 10 ni ni NNP 40436 10574 11 pheidô/. pheidô/. NNP 40436 10574 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10574 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10575 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10575 2 Side side NN 40436 10575 3 - - HYPH 40436 10575 4 note note NN 40436 10575 5 : : : 40436 10575 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10575 7 swallows swallow VBZ 40436 10575 8 the the DT 40436 10575 9 poison poison NN 40436 10575 10 . . . 40436 10576 1 Conversation conversation NN 40436 10576 2 with with IN 40436 10576 3 the the DT 40436 10576 4 gaoler gaoler NN 40436 10576 5 . . . 40436 10576 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10577 1 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10577 2 accordingly accordingly RB 40436 10577 3 gave give VBD 40436 10577 4 orders order NNS 40436 10577 5 , , , 40436 10577 6 and and CC 40436 10577 7 the the DT 40436 10577 8 poison poison NN 40436 10577 9 , , , 40436 10577 10 after after IN 40436 10577 11 a a DT 40436 10577 12 certain certain JJ 40436 10577 13 interval interval NN 40436 10577 14 , , , 40436 10577 15 was be VBD 40436 10577 16 brought bring VBN 40436 10577 17 in in RP 40436 10577 18 . . . 40436 10578 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10578 2 , , , 40436 10578 3 on on IN 40436 10578 4 asking ask VBG 40436 10578 5 for for IN 40436 10578 6 directions direction NNS 40436 10578 7 , , , 40436 10578 8 was be VBD 40436 10578 9 informed inform VBN 40436 10578 10 , , , 40436 10578 11 that that IN 40436 10578 12 after after IN 40436 10578 13 having have VBG 40436 10578 14 swallowed swallow VBN 40436 10578 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10578 16 , , , 40436 10578 17 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10578 18 must must MD 40436 10578 19 walk walk VB 40436 10578 20 about about IN 40436 10578 21 until until IN 40436 10578 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10578 23 legs leg NNS 40436 10578 24 felt feel VBD 40436 10578 25 heavy heavy JJ 40436 10578 26 : : : 40436 10578 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10578 28 must must MD 40436 10578 29 then then RB 40436 10578 30 lie lie VB 40436 10578 31 down down RP 40436 10578 32 and and CC 40436 10578 33 cover cover VB 40436 10578 34 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10578 35 up up RP 40436 10578 36 : : : 40436 10578 37 the the DT 40436 10578 38 poison poison NN 40436 10578 39 would would MD 40436 10578 40 do do VB 40436 10578 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10578 42 work work NN 40436 10578 43 . . . 40436 10579 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10579 2 took take VBD 40436 10579 3 the the DT 40436 10579 4 cup cup NN 40436 10579 5 without without IN 40436 10579 6 any any DT 40436 10579 7 symptom symptom NN 40436 10579 8 of of IN 40436 10579 9 alarm alarm NN 40436 10579 10 or or CC 40436 10579 11 change change NN 40436 10579 12 of of IN 40436 10579 13 countenance countenance NN 40436 10579 14 : : : 40436 10579 15 then then RB 40436 10579 16 looking look VBG 40436 10579 17 at at IN 40436 10579 18 the the DT 40436 10579 19 attendant attendant NN 40436 10579 20 with with IN 40436 10579 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10579 22 usual usual JJ 40436 10579 23 full full JJ 40436 10579 24 and and CC 40436 10579 25 fixed fixed JJ 40436 10579 26 gaze gaze NN 40436 10579 27 , , , 40436 10579 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10579 29 asked ask VBD 40436 10579 30 whether whether IN 40436 10579 31 there there EX 40436 10579 32 was be VBD 40436 10579 33 enough enough JJ 40436 10579 34 to to TO 40436 10579 35 allow allow VB 40436 10579 36 of of IN 40436 10579 37 a a DT 40436 10579 38 libation libation NN 40436 10579 39 . . . 40436 10580 1 " " `` 40436 10580 2 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10580 3 prepare prepare VBP 40436 10580 4 as as RB 40436 10580 5 much much RB 40436 10580 6 as as IN 40436 10580 7 is be VBZ 40436 10580 8 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 10580 9 " " '' 40436 10580 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10580 11 was be VBD 40436 10580 12 the the DT 40436 10580 13 answer answer NN 40436 10580 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10580 15 , , , 40436 10580 16 " " '' 40436 10580 17 but but CC 40436 10580 18 no no RB 40436 10580 19 more more JJR 40436 10580 20 . . . 40436 10580 21 " " '' 40436 10581 1 " " `` 40436 10581 2 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10581 3 understand understand VBP 40436 10581 4 " " '' 40436 10581 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10581 6 said say VBD 40436 10581 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10581 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10581 9 : : : 40436 10581 10 " " `` 40436 10581 11 but but CC 40436 10581 12 at at IN 40436 10581 13 least least JJS 40436 10581 14 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10581 15 may may MD 40436 10581 16 pray pray VB 40436 10581 17 , , , 40436 10581 18 and and CC 40436 10581 19 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10581 20 must must MD 40436 10581 21 pray pray VB 40436 10581 22 , , , 40436 10581 23 to to IN 40436 10581 24 the the DT 40436 10581 25 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 10581 26 , , , 40436 10581 27 that that IN 40436 10581 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10581 29 change change NN 40436 10581 30 of of IN 40436 10581 31 abode abode NN 40436 10581 32 from from IN 40436 10581 33 here here RB 40436 10581 34 to to IN 40436 10581 35 there there EX 40436 10581 36 may may MD 40436 10581 37 be be VB 40436 10581 38 fortunate fortunate JJ 40436 10581 39 . . . 40436 10581 40 " " '' 40436 10582 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10582 2 then then RB 40436 10582 3 put put VBD 40436 10582 4 the the DT 40436 10582 5 cup cup NN 40436 10582 6 to to IN 40436 10582 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10582 8 lips lip NNS 40436 10582 9 , , , 40436 10582 10 and and CC 40436 10582 11 drank drink VBD 40436 10582 12 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10582 13 off off RP 40436 10582 14 with with IN 40436 10582 15 perfect perfect JJ 40436 10582 16 ease ease NN 40436 10582 17 and and CC 40436 10582 18 tranquillity tranquillity NN 40436 10582 19 . . . 40436 10583 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10583 2 94 94 CD 40436 10583 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10583 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10583 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10583 6 94 94 CD 40436 10583 7 : : : 40436 10583 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10583 9 , , , 40436 10583 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10583 11 , , , 40436 10583 12 p. p. NN 40436 10583 13 117 117 CD 40436 10583 14 C. c. NN 40436 10583 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10583 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10583 17 Side side NN 40436 10583 18 - - HYPH 40436 10583 19 note note NN 40436 10583 20 : : : 40436 10583 21 Ungovernable ungovernable JJ 40436 10583 22 sorrow sorrow NN 40436 10583 23 of of IN 40436 10583 24 the the DT 40436 10583 25 friends friend NNS 40436 10583 26 present present JJ 40436 10583 27 . . . 40436 10584 1 Self self NN 40436 10584 2 - - HYPH 40436 10584 3 command command NN 40436 10584 4 of of IN 40436 10584 5 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10584 6 . . . 40436 10585 1 Last last JJ 40436 10585 2 words word NNS 40436 10585 3 to to IN 40436 10585 4 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10585 5 , , , 40436 10585 6 and and CC 40436 10585 7 death death NN 40436 10585 8 . . . 40436 10585 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10586 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10586 2 friends friend NNS 40436 10586 3 , , , 40436 10586 4 who who WP 40436 10586 5 had have VBD 40436 10586 6 hitherto hitherto VBN 40436 10586 7 maintained maintain VBN 40436 10586 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10586 9 self self NN 40436 10586 10 - - HYPH 40436 10586 11 control control NN 40436 10586 12 , , , 40436 10586 13 were be VBD 40436 10586 14 overpowered overpower VBN 40436 10586 15 by by IN 40436 10586 16 emotion emotion NN 40436 10586 17 on on IN 40436 10586 18 seeing see VBG 40436 10586 19 the the DT 40436 10586 20 cup cup NN 40436 10586 21 swallowed swallow VBN 40436 10586 22 , , , 40436 10586 23 and and CC 40436 10586 24 broke break VBD 40436 10586 25 out out RP 40436 10586 26 into into IN 40436 10586 27 violent violent JJ 40436 10586 28 tears tear NNS 40436 10586 29 and and CC 40436 10586 30 lamentation lamentation NN 40436 10586 31 . . . 40436 10587 1 No no DT 40436 10587 2 one one NN 40436 10587 3 was be VBD 40436 10587 4 unmoved unmoved JJ 40436 10587 5 , , , 40436 10587 6 except except IN 40436 10587 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10587 8 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10587 9 : : : 40436 10587 10 who who WP 40436 10587 11 gently gently RB 40436 10587 12 remonstrated remonstrate VBD 40436 10587 13 with with IN 40436 10587 14 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10587 15 , , , 40436 10587 16 and and CC 40436 10587 17 exhorted exhort VBD 40436 10587 18 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10587 19 to to IN 40436 10587 20 tranquil tranquil JJ 40436 10587 21 resignation resignation NN 40436 10587 22 : : : 40436 10587 23 reminding remind VBG 40436 10587 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10587 25 that that IN 40436 10587 26 nothing nothing NN 40436 10587 27 but but IN 40436 10587 28 good good JJ 40436 10587 29 words word NNS 40436 10587 30 was be VBD 40436 10587 31 admissible admissible JJ 40436 10587 32 at at IN 40436 10587 33 the the DT 40436 10587 34 hour hour NN 40436 10587 35 of of IN 40436 10587 36 death death NN 40436 10587 37 . . . 40436 10588 1 The the DT 40436 10588 2 friends friend NNS 40436 10588 3 , , , 40436 10588 4 ashamed ashamed JJ 40436 10588 5 of of IN 40436 10588 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10588 7 , , , 40436 10588 8 found find VBD 40436 10588 9 means mean NNS 40436 10588 10 to to TO 40436 10588 11 repress repress VB 40436 10588 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10588 13 tears tear NNS 40436 10588 14 . . . 40436 10589 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10589 2 walked walk VBD 40436 10589 3 about about IN 40436 10589 4 until until IN 40436 10589 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10589 6 felt feel VBD 40436 10589 7 heavy heavy JJ 40436 10589 8 in in IN 40436 10589 9 the the DT 40436 10589 10 legs leg NNS 40436 10589 11 , , , 40436 10589 12 and and CC 40436 10589 13 then then RB 40436 10589 14 lay lie VBD 40436 10589 15 down down RP 40436 10589 16 in in IN 40436 10589 17 bed bed NN 40436 10589 18 . . . 40436 10590 1 After after IN 40436 10590 2 some some DT 40436 10590 3 interval interval NN 40436 10590 4 , , , 40436 10590 5 the the DT 40436 10590 6 attendant attendant NN 40436 10590 7 of of IN 40436 10590 8 the the DT 40436 10590 9 prison prison NN 40436 10590 10 came come VBD 40436 10590 11 to to TO 40436 10590 12 examine examine VB 40436 10590 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10590 14 feet foot NNS 40436 10590 15 and and CC 40436 10590 16 legs leg NNS 40436 10590 17 , , , 40436 10590 18 pinched pinch VBD 40436 10590 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10590 20 foot foot NN 40436 10590 21 with with IN 40436 10590 22 force force NN 40436 10590 23 , , , 40436 10590 24 and and CC 40436 10590 25 enquired enquire VBD 40436 10590 26 whether whether IN 40436 10590 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10590 28 felt feel VBD 40436 10590 29 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10590 30 . . . 40436 10591 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10591 2 replied reply VBD 40436 10591 3 in in IN 40436 10591 4 the the DT 40436 10591 5 negative negative NN 40436 10591 6 . . . 40436 10592 1 Presently presently RB 40436 10592 2 the the DT 40436 10592 3 man man NN 40436 10592 4 pinched pinch VBD 40436 10592 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10592 6 legs leg NNS 40436 10592 7 with with IN 40436 10592 8 similar similar JJ 40436 10592 9 result result NN 40436 10592 10 , , , 40436 10592 11 and and CC 40436 10592 12 showed show VBD 40436 10592 13 to to IN 40436 10592 14 the the DT 40436 10592 15 friends friend NNS 40436 10592 16 in in IN 40436 10592 17 that that DT 40436 10592 18 way way NN 40436 10592 19 that that IN 40436 10592 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10592 21 body body NN 40436 10592 22 was be VBD 40436 10592 23 gradually gradually RB 40436 10592 24 becoming become VBG 40436 10592 25 chill chill NN 40436 10592 26 and and CC 40436 10592 27 benumbed benumb VBD 40436 10592 28 : : : 40436 10592 29 adding add VBG 40436 10592 30 that that IN 40436 10592 31 as as RB 40436 10592 32 soon soon RB 40436 10592 33 as as IN 40436 10592 34 this this DT 40436 10592 35 should should MD 40436 10592 36 get get VB 40436 10592 37 to to IN 40436 10592 38 the the DT 40436 10592 39 heart heart NN 40436 10592 40 , , , 40436 10592 41 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10592 42 would would MD 40436 10592 43 die die VB 40436 10592 44 . . . 40436 10593 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10593 2 95 95 CD 40436 10593 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10593 4 The the DT 40436 10593 5 chill chill NN 40436 10593 6 had have VBD 40436 10593 7 already already RB 40436 10593 8 reached reach VBN 40436 10593 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10593 10 belly belly NN 40436 10593 11 , , , 40436 10593 12 when when WRB 40436 10593 13 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10593 14 uncovered uncover VBD 40436 10593 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10593 16 face face NN 40436 10593 17 , , , 40436 10593 18 which which WDT 40436 10593 19 had have VBD 40436 10593 20 been be VBN 40436 10593 21 hitherto hitherto VBN 40436 10593 22 concealed conceal VBN 40436 10593 23 by by IN 40436 10593 24 the the DT 40436 10593 25 bed bed NN 40436 10593 26 - - HYPH 40436 10593 27 clothes clothe NNS 40436 10593 28 , , , 40436 10593 29 and and CC 40436 10593 30 spoke speak VBD 40436 10593 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10593 32 last last JJ 40436 10593 33 words:[96 words:[96 FW 40436 10593 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10593 35 " " `` 40436 10593 36 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10593 37 , , , 40436 10593 38 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10593 39 owe owe VBP 40436 10593 40 a a DT 40436 10593 41 cock cock NN 40436 10593 42 to to IN 40436 10593 43 Æsculapius Æsculapius NNP 40436 10593 44 : : : 40436 10593 45 pay pay VB 40436 10593 46 the the DT 40436 10593 47 debt debt NN 40436 10593 48 without without IN 40436 10593 49 fail fail NN 40436 10593 50 . . . 40436 10593 51 " " '' 40436 10594 1 " " `` 40436 10594 2 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10594 3 shall shall MD 40436 10594 4 be be VB 40436 10594 5 done do VBN 40436 10594 6 " " '' 40436 10594 7 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10594 8 answered answer VBN 40436 10594 9 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10594 10 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10594 11 ; ; : 40436 10594 12 " " `` 40436 10594 13 have have VBP 40436 10594 14 you -PRON- PRP 40436 10594 15 any any DT 40436 10594 16 other other JJ 40436 10594 17 injunctions injunction NNS 40436 10594 18 ? ? . 40436 10594 19 " " '' 40436 10595 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10595 2 made make VBD 40436 10595 3 no no DT 40436 10595 4 reply reply NN 40436 10595 5 , , , 40436 10595 6 but but CC 40436 10595 7 again again RB 40436 10595 8 covered cover VBD 40436 10595 9 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10595 10 up up RP 40436 10595 11 . . . 40436 10596 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10596 2 97 97 CD 40436 10596 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10596 4 After after IN 40436 10596 5 a a DT 40436 10596 6 short short JJ 40436 10596 7 interval interval NN 40436 10596 8 , , , 40436 10596 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10596 10 made make VBD 40436 10596 11 some some DT 40436 10596 12 movement movement NN 40436 10596 13 : : : 40436 10596 14 the the DT 40436 10596 15 attendant attendant NN 40436 10596 16 presently presently RB 40436 10596 17 uncovered uncover VBD 40436 10596 18 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10596 19 , , , 40436 10596 20 and and CC 40436 10596 21 found find VBD 40436 10596 22 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10596 23 dead dead JJ 40436 10596 24 , , , 40436 10596 25 with with IN 40436 10596 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10596 27 eyes eye NNS 40436 10596 28 stiff stiff JJ 40436 10596 29 and and CC 40436 10596 30 fixed fix VBN 40436 10596 31 . . . 40436 10597 1 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10597 2 performed perform VBD 40436 10597 3 the the DT 40436 10597 4 last last JJ 40436 10597 5 duty duty NN 40436 10597 6 of of IN 40436 10597 7 closing close VBG 40436 10597 8 both both CC 40436 10597 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10597 10 eyes eye NNS 40436 10597 11 and and CC 40436 10597 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10597 13 mouth mouth NN 40436 10597 14 . . . 40436 10598 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10598 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10598 3 95 95 CD 40436 10598 4 : : : 40436 10598 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10598 6 , , , 40436 10598 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10598 8 , , , 40436 10598 9 p. p. NN 40436 10598 10 118 118 CD 40436 10598 11 . . . 40436 10599 1 These these DT 40436 10599 2 details detail NNS 40436 10599 3 receive receive VBP 40436 10599 4 interesting interesting JJ 40436 10599 5 confirmation confirmation NN 40436 10599 6 from from IN 40436 10599 7 the the DT 40436 10599 8 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 10599 9 scene scene NN 40436 10599 10 described describe VBN 40436 10599 11 by by IN 40436 10599 12 Valerius Valerius NNP 40436 10599 13 Maximus Maximus NNP 40436 10599 14 , , , 40436 10599 15 as as IN 40436 10599 16 witnessed witness VBN 40436 10599 17 by by IN 40436 10599 18 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10599 19 at at IN 40436 10599 20 Julis Julis NNP 40436 10599 21 in in IN 40436 10599 22 the the DT 40436 10599 23 island island NN 40436 10599 24 of of IN 40436 10599 25 Keos Keos NNP 40436 10599 26 , , , 40436 10599 27 when when WRB 40436 10599 28 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10599 29 accompanied accompany VBD 40436 10599 30 Sextus Sextus NNP 40436 10599 31 Pompeius Pompeius NNP 40436 10599 32 into into IN 40436 10599 33 Asia Asia NNP 40436 10599 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10599 35 Val Val NNP 40436 10599 36 . . . 40436 10600 1 M. M. NNP 40436 10600 2 ii ii NNP 40436 10600 3 . . . 40436 10601 1 6 6 CD 40436 10601 2 , , , 40436 10601 3 8) 8) CD 40436 10601 4 . . . 40436 10602 1 A a DT 40436 10602 2 Keian keian JJ 40436 10602 3 lady lady NN 40436 10602 4 of of IN 40436 10602 5 rank rank NN 40436 10602 6 , , , 40436 10602 7 ninety ninety CD 40436 10602 8 years year NNS 40436 10602 9 of of IN 40436 10602 10 age age NN 40436 10602 11 , , , 40436 10602 12 well well RB 40436 10602 13 in in IN 40436 10602 14 health health NN 40436 10602 15 , , , 40436 10602 16 comfortable comfortable JJ 40436 10602 17 , , , 40436 10602 18 and and CC 40436 10602 19 in in IN 40436 10602 20 full full JJ 40436 10602 21 possession possession NN 40436 10602 22 of of IN 40436 10602 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10602 24 intelligence intelligence NN 40436 10602 25 , , , 40436 10602 26 but but CC 40436 10602 27 deeming deem VBG 40436 10602 28 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10602 29 prudent prudent JJ 40436 10602 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10602 31 according accord VBG 40436 10602 32 to to IN 40436 10602 33 the the DT 40436 10602 34 custom custom NN 40436 10602 35 in in IN 40436 10602 36 Keos Keos NNP 40436 10602 37 , , , 40436 10602 38 Strabo Strabo NNP 40436 10602 39 , , , 40436 10602 40 x. x. NN 40436 10602 41 p. p. NN 40436 10602 42 486 486 CD 40436 10602 43 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10602 44 to to TO 40436 10602 45 retire retire VB 40436 10602 46 from from IN 40436 10602 47 life life NN 40436 10602 48 while while IN 40436 10602 49 she -PRON- PRP 40436 10602 50 had have VBD 40436 10602 51 as as RB 40436 10602 52 yet yet RB 40436 10602 53 nothing nothing NN 40436 10602 54 to to TO 40436 10602 55 complain complain VB 40436 10602 56 of of IN 40436 10602 57 -- -- : 40436 10602 58 took take VBD 40436 10602 59 poison poison NN 40436 10602 60 , , , 40436 10602 61 by by IN 40436 10602 62 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10602 63 own own JJ 40436 10602 64 deliberate deliberate JJ 40436 10602 65 act act NN 40436 10602 66 , , , 40436 10602 67 in in IN 40436 10602 68 the the DT 40436 10602 69 presence presence NN 40436 10602 70 of of IN 40436 10602 71 her -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10602 72 relatives relative NNS 40436 10602 73 and and CC 40436 10602 74 of of IN 40436 10602 75 Sextus Sextus NNP 40436 10602 76 Pompeius Pompeius NNP 40436 10602 77 , , , 40436 10602 78 who who WP 40436 10602 79 vainly vainly RB 40436 10602 80 endeavoured endeavour VBD 40436 10602 81 to to TO 40436 10602 82 dissuade dissuade VB 40436 10602 83 her -PRON- PRP 40436 10602 84 . . . 40436 10603 1 " " `` 40436 10603 2 Cupido Cupido NNP 40436 10603 3 haustu haustu VBZ 40436 10603 4 mortiferam mortiferam NNP 40436 10603 5 traxit traxit NNP 40436 10603 6 potionem potionem NNP 40436 10603 7 , , , 40436 10603 8 ac ac IN 40436 10603 9 sermone sermone NN 40436 10603 10 significans significans NNPS 40436 10603 11 quasnam quasnam NNP 40436 10603 12 subindè subindè NNP 40436 10603 13 partes part VBZ 40436 10603 14 corporis corporis NNP 40436 10603 15 sui sui NNP 40436 10603 16 rigor rigor NNP 40436 10603 17 occupâret occupâret NNP 40436 10603 18 , , , 40436 10603 19 cum cum NNP 40436 10603 20 jam jam NNP 40436 10603 21 visceribus visceribus NNP 40436 10603 22 eum eum NNP 40436 10603 23 et et NNP 40436 10603 24 cordi cordi NNP 40436 10603 25 imminere imminere NNP 40436 10603 26 esset esset NNP 40436 10603 27 elocuta elocuta NNP 40436 10603 28 , , , 40436 10603 29 filiarum filiarum NNP 40436 10603 30 manus manus NNP 40436 10603 31 ad ad NNP 40436 10603 32 supremum supremum NN 40436 10603 33 opprimendorum opprimendorum NNP 40436 10603 34 oculorum oculorum NNP 40436 10603 35 officium officium NNP 40436 10603 36 advocavit advocavit NNP 40436 10603 37 . . . 40436 10604 1 Nostros nostro NNS 40436 10604 2 autem autem JJ 40436 10604 3 , , , 40436 10604 4 tametsi tametsi NNP 40436 10604 5 novo novo NNP 40436 10604 6 spectaculo spectaculo NNP 40436 10604 7 obstupefacti obstupefacti NNP 40436 10604 8 erant erant NNP 40436 10604 9 , , , 40436 10604 10 suffusos suffusos NNP 40436 10604 11 tamen tamen NNP 40436 10604 12 lacrimis lacrimis NNP 40436 10604 13 dimisit dimisit NNP 40436 10604 14 . . . 40436 10604 15 " " '' 40436 10604 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10605 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10605 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10605 3 96 96 CD 40436 10605 4 : : : 40436 10605 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10605 6 , , , 40436 10605 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10605 8 , , , 40436 10605 9 p. p. NN 40436 10605 10 118 118 CD 40436 10605 11 . . . 40436 10606 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10606 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10606 3 : : : 40436 10606 4 ê)/dê ê)/dê ADD 40436 10606 5 ou)=n ou)=n IN 40436 10606 6 schedo schedo NNP 40436 10606 7 / / SYM 40436 10606 8 n n CC 40436 10606 9 ti ti IN 40436 10606 10 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 10606 11 ê)=n ê)=n RB 40436 10606 12 ta\ ta\ VBP 40436 10606 13 peri\ peri\ NN 40436 10606 14 to\ to\ NN 40436 10606 15 ê)=tron ê)=tron NNP 40436 10606 16 psucho psucho NNP 40436 10606 17 / / SYM 40436 10606 18 mena mena NNP 40436 10606 19 , , , 40436 10606 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10606 21 e)kkalupsa e)kkalupsa NNP 40436 10606 22 / / SYM 40436 10606 23 menos menos NNP 40436 10606 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10606 25 e)nekeka e)nekeka NNS 40436 10606 26 / / SYM 40436 10606 27 lupto lupto NN 40436 10606 28 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10606 29 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10606 30 ei)=pen ei)=pen NNP 40436 10606 31 , , , 40436 10606 32 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 10606 33 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 10606 34 teleutai teleutai NNP 40436 10606 35 = = NFP 40436 10606 36 on on IN 40436 10606 37 e)phthe e)phthe NNP 40436 10606 38 / / SYM 40436 10606 39 gxato gxato NNP 40436 10606 40 , , , 40436 10606 41 Ô)= Ô)= NNP 40436 10606 42 Kri Kri NNP 40436 10606 43 / / SYM 40436 10606 44 tôn tôn NNP 40436 10606 45 , , , 40436 10606 46 e)/phê e)/phê NNP 40436 10606 47 , , , 40436 10606 48 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 10606 49 A)sklêpiô=| A)sklêpiô=| NNP 40436 10606 50 o)phei o)phei NNP 40436 10606 51 / / SYM 40436 10606 52 lomen lomen NNP 40436 10606 53 a)lektru a)lektru CD 40436 10606 54 / / SYM 40436 10606 55 ona ona NN 40436 10606 56 ; ; : 40436 10606 57 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 10606 58 ' ' '' 40436 10606 59 a)po a)po NNS 40436 10606 60 / / SYM 40436 10606 61 dote dote NN 40436 10606 62 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10606 63 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 10606 64 a)melê a)melê NNP 40436 10606 65 / / SYM 40436 10606 66 sête sête NN 40436 10606 67 . . . 40436 10606 68 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10607 1 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 10607 2 , , , 40436 10607 3 after after IN 40436 10607 4 recovering recover VBG 40436 10607 5 from from IN 40436 10607 6 a a DT 40436 10607 7 bilious bilious JJ 40436 10607 8 attack attack NN 40436 10607 9 , , , 40436 10607 10 writes write VBZ 40436 10607 11 to to IN 40436 10607 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10607 13 wife wife NN 40436 10607 14 Terentia Terentia NNP 40436 10607 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10607 16 Epist epist UH 40436 10607 17 . . . 40436 10608 1 Famil Famil NNP 40436 10608 2 . . . 40436 10609 1 xiv xiv NNP 40436 10609 2 . . . 40436 10610 1 7 7 LS 40436 10610 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10610 3 : : : 40436 10610 4 " " `` 40436 10610 5 Omnes omne NNS 40436 10610 6 molestias molestia NNS 40436 10610 7 et et NNP 40436 10610 8 solicitudines solicitudine NNS 40436 10610 9 deposui deposui NNPS 40436 10610 10 et et NNP 40436 10610 11 ejeci ejeci NNP 40436 10610 12 . . . 40436 10611 1 Quid quid JJ 40436 10611 2 causæ causæ NN 40436 10611 3 autem autem NN 40436 10611 4 fuerit fuerit NN 40436 10611 5 , , , 40436 10611 6 postridié postridié NNP 40436 10611 7 intellexi intellexi NNP 40436 10611 8 quam quam NNP 40436 10611 9 à à NNP 40436 10611 10 vobis vobis NNP 40436 10611 11 discessi discessi NNP 40436 10611 12 . . . 40436 10612 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10612 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10612 3 : : : 40436 10612 4 Cholê\n Cholê\n NNP 40436 10612 5 a)/kraton a)/kraton NN 40436 10612 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10612 7 noctu noctu NNP 40436 10612 8 ejeci ejeci NNS 40436 10612 9 : : : 40436 10612 10 statim statim NNP 40436 10612 11 ita ita NNP 40436 10612 12 sum sum NNP 40436 10612 13 levatus levatus NNP 40436 10612 14 , , , 40436 10612 15 ut ut UH 40436 10612 16 mihi mihi NN 40436 10612 17 Deus Deus NNP 40436 10612 18 aliquis aliquis NNP 40436 10612 19 medicinam medicinam NNP 40436 10612 20 fecisse fecisse NNP 40436 10612 21 videatur videatur NNP 40436 10612 22 . . . 40436 10613 1 Cui Cui NNP 40436 10613 2 quidem quidem NNP 40436 10613 3 Deo Deo NNP 40436 10613 4 , , , 40436 10613 5 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 40436 10613 6 tu tu NNP 40436 10613 7 soles sol NNS 40436 10613 8 , , , 40436 10613 9 pié pié NNP 40436 10613 10 et et NNP 40436 10613 11 casté casté NN 40436 10613 12 satisfacies satisfacie NNS 40436 10613 13 : : : 40436 10613 14 i -PRON- PRP 40436 10613 15 d d XX 40436 10613 16 est est NNP 40436 10613 17 , , , 40436 10613 18 Apollini Apollini NNP 40436 10613 19 et et NNP 40436 10613 20 Æsculapio Æsculapio NNP 40436 10613 21 . . . 40436 10613 22 " " '' 40436 10614 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10614 2 the the DT 40436 10614 3 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 10614 4 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 10614 5 , , , 40436 10614 6 Orat Orat NNP 40436 10614 7 . . . 40436 10615 1 xlv xlv NNP 40436 10615 2 . . . 40436 10616 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10616 2 . . . 40436 10617 1 22 22 CD 40436 10617 2 - - HYPH 40436 10617 3 23 23 CD 40436 10617 4 - - HYPH 40436 10617 5 155 155 CD 40436 10617 6 , , , 40436 10617 7 ed ed NN 40436 10617 8 . . . 40436 10618 1 Dindorf Dindorf NNP 40436 10618 2 . . . 40436 10619 1 About about RB 40436 10619 2 the the DT 40436 10619 3 habit habit NN 40436 10619 4 of of IN 40436 10619 5 sacrificing sacrifice VBG 40436 10619 6 a a DT 40436 10619 7 cock cock NN 40436 10619 8 to to IN 40436 10619 9 Æsculapius Æsculapius NNP 40436 10619 10 , , , 40436 10619 11 see see VB 40436 10619 12 also also RB 40436 10619 13 a a DT 40436 10619 14 passage passage NN 40436 10619 15 in in IN 40436 10619 16 the the DT 40436 10619 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10619 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10619 19 : : : 40436 10619 20 I(erô I(erô NNP 40436 10619 21 = = SYM 40436 10619 22 n n CC 40436 10619 23 Lo Lo NNP 40436 10619 24 / / SYM 40436 10619 25 goi goi NNP 40436 10619 26 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10619 27 of of IN 40436 10619 28 the the DT 40436 10619 29 rhetor rhetor NN 40436 10619 30 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 10619 31 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10619 32 Orat Orat NNP 40436 10619 33 . . . 40436 10620 1 xxvii xxvii NNP 40436 10620 2 . . . 40436 10621 1 p. p. NN 40436 10621 2 545 545 CD 40436 10621 3 , , , 40436 10621 4 ed ed NN 40436 10621 5 . . . 40436 10622 1 Dindorf Dindorf NNP 40436 10622 2 , , , 40436 10622 3 at at IN 40436 10622 4 the the DT 40436 10622 5 top top NN 40436 10622 6 of of IN 40436 10622 7 the the DT 40436 10622 8 page page NN 40436 10622 9 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10622 10 . . . 40436 10623 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10623 2 will will MD 40436 10623 3 add add VB 40436 10623 4 that that IN 40436 10623 5 the the DT 40436 10623 6 five five CD 40436 10623 7 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10623 8 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10623 9 : : : 40436 10623 10 I(erô I(erô NNP 40436 10623 11 = = SYM 40436 10623 12 n n CC 40436 10623 13 Lo Lo NNP 40436 10623 14 / / SYM 40436 10623 15 goi goi NNP 40436 10623 16 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10623 17 of of IN 40436 10623 18 that that DT 40436 10623 19 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 10623 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10623 21 Oratt Oratt NNP 40436 10623 22 . . . 40436 10624 1 xxiii.-xxvii xxiii.-xxvii NNP 40436 10624 2 . . . 40436 10624 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10625 1 are be VBP 40436 10625 2 curious curious JJ 40436 10625 3 as as IN 40436 10625 4 testifying testify VBG 40436 10625 5 the the DT 40436 10625 6 multitude multitude NN 40436 10625 7 of of IN 40436 10625 8 dreams dream NNS 40436 10625 9 and and CC 40436 10625 10 revelations revelation NNS 40436 10625 11 vouchsafed vouchsafe VBD 40436 10625 12 to to IN 40436 10625 13 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10625 14 by by IN 40436 10625 15 Æsculapius Æsculapius NNP 40436 10625 16 ; ; : 40436 10625 17 also also RB 40436 10625 18 the the DT 40436 10625 19 implicit implicit JJ 40436 10625 20 faith faith NN 40436 10625 21 with with IN 40436 10625 22 which which WDT 40436 10625 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10625 24 acted act VBD 40436 10625 25 upon upon IN 40436 10625 26 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10625 27 in in IN 40436 10625 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10625 29 maladies malady NNS 40436 10625 30 , , , 40436 10625 31 and and CC 40436 10625 32 the the DT 40436 10625 33 success success NN 40436 10625 34 which which WDT 40436 10625 35 attended attend VBD 40436 10625 36 the the DT 40436 10625 37 curative curative JJ 40436 10625 38 prescriptions prescription NNS 40436 10625 39 thus thus RB 40436 10625 40 made make VBD 40436 10625 41 known known JJ 40436 10625 42 to to IN 40436 10625 43 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10625 44 . . . 40436 10626 1 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 10626 2 declares declare VBZ 40436 10626 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10626 4 to to TO 40436 10626 5 place place VB 40436 10626 6 more more JJR 40436 10626 7 confidence confidence NN 40436 10626 8 in in IN 40436 10626 9 these these DT 40436 10626 10 revelations revelation NNS 40436 10626 11 than than IN 40436 10626 12 in in IN 40436 10626 13 the the DT 40436 10626 14 advice advice NN 40436 10626 15 of of IN 40436 10626 16 physicians physician NNS 40436 10626 17 , , , 40436 10626 18 and and CC 40436 10626 19 to to TO 40436 10626 20 have have VB 40436 10626 21 often often RB 40436 10626 22 acted act VBN 40436 10626 23 on on IN 40436 10626 24 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10626 25 in in IN 40436 10626 26 preference preference NN 40436 10626 27 to to IN 40436 10626 28 such such JJ 40436 10626 29 advice advice NN 40436 10626 30 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10626 31 Orat Orat NNP 40436 10626 32 . . . 40436 10627 1 xlv xlv NNP 40436 10627 2 . . . 40436 10628 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10628 2 . . . 40436 10629 1 20 20 CD 40436 10629 2 - - SYM 40436 10629 3 22 22 CD 40436 10629 4 , , , 40436 10629 5 Dind Dind NNP 40436 10629 6 . . . 40436 10629 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10629 8 . . . 40436 10630 1 The the DT 40436 10630 2 direction direction NN 40436 10630 3 here here RB 40436 10630 4 given give VBN 40436 10630 5 by by IN 40436 10630 6 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10630 7 to to IN 40436 10630 8 Kriton Kriton NNP 40436 10630 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10630 10 though though IN 40436 10630 11 some some DT 40436 10630 12 critics critic NNS 40436 10630 13 , , , 40436 10630 14 even even RB 40436 10630 15 the the DT 40436 10630 16 most most RBS 40436 10630 17 recent recent JJ 40436 10630 18 , , , 40436 10630 19 see see VB 40436 10630 20 Krische Krische NNP 40436 10630 21 , , , 40436 10630 22 Lehren Lehren NNP 40436 10630 23 der der VBP 40436 10630 24 Griechischen Griechischen NNP 40436 10630 25 Denker Denker NNP 40436 10630 26 , , , 40436 10630 27 p. p. NN 40436 10630 28 227 227 CD 40436 10630 29 , , , 40436 10630 30 interpret interpret VB 40436 10630 31 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10630 32 in in IN 40436 10630 33 a a DT 40436 10630 34 mystical mystical JJ 40436 10630 35 sense sense NN 40436 10630 36 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10630 37 is be VBZ 40436 10630 38 to to TO 40436 10630 39 be be VB 40436 10630 40 understood understand VBN 40436 10630 41 simply simply RB 40436 10630 42 and and CC 40436 10630 43 literally literally RB 40436 10630 44 , , , 40436 10630 45 in in IN 40436 10630 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10630 47 judgment judgment NN 40436 10630 48 . . . 40436 10631 1 On on IN 40436 10631 2 what what WDT 40436 10631 3 occasion occasion NN 40436 10631 4 , , , 40436 10631 5 or or CC 40436 10631 6 for for IN 40436 10631 7 what what WP 40436 10631 8 , , , 40436 10631 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10631 10 had have VBD 40436 10631 11 made make VBN 40436 10631 12 the the DT 40436 10631 13 vow vow NN 40436 10631 14 of of IN 40436 10631 15 the the DT 40436 10631 16 cock cock NN 40436 10631 17 , , , 40436 10631 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10631 19 are be VBP 40436 10631 20 not not RB 40436 10631 21 told tell VBN 40436 10631 22 . . . 40436 10632 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10632 2 was be VBD 40436 10632 3 a a DT 40436 10632 4 very very RB 40436 10632 5 religious religious JJ 40436 10632 6 man man NN 40436 10632 7 , , , 40436 10632 8 much much RB 40436 10632 9 influenced influence VBN 40436 10632 10 by by IN 40436 10632 11 prophecies prophecy NNS 40436 10632 12 , , , 40436 10632 13 oracles oracle NNS 40436 10632 14 , , , 40436 10632 15 dreams dream NNS 40436 10632 16 , , , 40436 10632 17 and and CC 40436 10632 18 special special JJ 40436 10632 19 revelations revelation NNS 40436 10632 20 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10632 21 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10632 22 , , , 40436 10632 23 Apol Apol NNP 40436 10632 24 . . . 40436 10633 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 10633 2 . . . 40436 10634 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10634 2 . . . 40436 10635 1 21 21 CD 40436 10635 2 - - HYPH 40436 10635 3 29 29 CD 40436 10635 4 - - HYPH 40436 10635 5 33 33 CD 40436 10635 6 ; ; : 40436 10635 7 also also RB 40436 10635 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10635 9 , , , 40436 10635 10 p. p. NN 40436 10636 1 60 60 CD 40436 10636 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10636 3 . . . 40436 10636 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10637 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10637 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10637 3 97 97 CD 40436 10637 4 : : : 40436 10637 5 Euripid Euripid NNP 40436 10637 6 . . . 40436 10638 1 Hippol hippol NN 40436 10638 2 . . . 40436 10639 1 1455 1455 CD 40436 10639 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10639 3 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10639 4 : : : 40436 10639 5 Kekarte Kekarte NNP 40436 10639 6 / / SYM 40436 10639 7 rêtai rêtai NN 40436 10639 8 ta)/m ta)/m NNS 40436 10639 9 ' ' POS 40436 10639 10 ; ; : 40436 10639 11 o)/lêla o)/lêla NNP 40436 10639 12 ga ga NNP 40436 10639 13 / / SYM 40436 10639 14 r r NNP 40436 10639 15 , , , 40436 10639 16 pate pate NNP 40436 10639 17 / / SYM 40436 10639 18 r r NN 40436 10639 19 . . . 40436 10640 1 Kru Kru NNP 40436 10640 2 = = SYM 40436 10640 3 pson pson NNP 40436 10640 4 de/ de/ NNP 40436 10640 5 mou mou NNP 40436 10640 6 pro pro JJ 40436 10640 7 / / SYM 40436 10640 8 sôpon sôpon IN 40436 10640 9 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10640 10 ta ta NNP 40436 10640 11 / / NNP 40436 10640 12 chos chos NNP 40436 10640 13 pe pe NNP 40436 10640 14 / / SYM 40436 10640 15 plois plois NNP 40436 10640 16 . . . 40436 10640 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10640 18 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10641 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10641 2 Side side NN 40436 10641 3 - - HYPH 40436 10641 4 note note NN 40436 10641 5 : : : 40436 10641 6 Extreme extreme JJ 40436 10641 7 pathos pathos NN 40436 10641 8 , , , 40436 10641 9 and and CC 40436 10641 10 probable probable JJ 40436 10641 11 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 40436 10641 12 of of IN 40436 10641 13 these these DT 40436 10641 14 personal personal JJ 40436 10641 15 details detail NNS 40436 10641 16 . . . 40436 10641 17 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10642 1 The the DT 40436 10642 2 pathetic pathetic JJ 40436 10642 3 details detail NNS 40436 10642 4 of of IN 40436 10642 5 this this DT 40436 10642 6 scene scene NN 40436 10642 7 -- -- : 40436 10642 8 arranged arrange VBD 40436 10642 9 with with IN 40436 10642 10 so so RB 40436 10642 11 much much JJ 40436 10642 12 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 10642 13 beauty beauty NN 40436 10642 14 , , , 40436 10642 15 and and CC 40436 10642 16 lending lend VBG 40436 10642 17 imperishable imperishable JJ 40436 10642 18 interest interest NN 40436 10642 19 to to IN 40436 10642 20 the the DT 40436 10642 21 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10642 22 of of IN 40436 10642 23 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10642 24 -- -- : 40436 10642 25 may may MD 40436 10642 26 be be VB 40436 10642 27 regarded regard VBN 40436 10642 28 as as IN 40436 10642 29 real real JJ 40436 10642 30 facts fact NNS 40436 10642 31 , , , 40436 10642 32 described describe VBN 40436 10642 33 from from IN 40436 10642 34 the the DT 40436 10642 35 recollection recollection NN 40436 10642 36 of of IN 40436 10642 37 an an DT 40436 10642 38 eye eye NN 40436 10642 39 - - HYPH 40436 10642 40 witness witness NN 40436 10642 41 , , , 40436 10642 42 though though IN 40436 10642 43 many many JJ 40436 10642 44 years year NNS 40436 10642 45 after after IN 40436 10642 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10642 47 occurrence occurrence NN 40436 10642 48 . . . 40436 10643 1 They -PRON- PRP 40436 10643 2 present present VBP 40436 10643 3 to to IN 40436 10643 4 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10643 5 the the DT 40436 10643 6 personality personality NN 40436 10643 7 of of IN 40436 10643 8 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10643 9 in in IN 40436 10643 10 full full JJ 40436 10643 11 harmony harmony NN 40436 10643 12 with with IN 40436 10643 13 that that DT 40436 10643 14 which which WDT 40436 10643 15 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10643 16 read read VBP 40436 10643 17 in in IN 40436 10643 18 the the DT 40436 10643 19 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 10643 20 Apology Apology NNP 40436 10643 21 . . . 40436 10644 1 The the DT 40436 10644 2 tranquil tranquil JJ 40436 10644 3 ascendancy ascendancy NN 40436 10644 4 of of IN 40436 10644 5 resolute resolute JJ 40436 10644 6 and and CC 40436 10644 7 rational rational JJ 40436 10644 8 conviction conviction NN 40436 10644 9 , , , 40436 10644 10 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 10644 11 with with IN 40436 10644 12 the the DT 40436 10644 13 past past NN 40436 10644 14 , , , 40436 10644 15 and and CC 40436 10644 16 welcoming welcome VBG 40436 10644 17 instead instead RB 40436 10644 18 of of IN 40436 10644 19 fearing fear VBG 40436 10644 20 the the DT 40436 10644 21 close close NN 40436 10644 22 of of IN 40436 10644 23 life life NN 40436 10644 24 -- -- : 40436 10644 25 is be VBZ 40436 10644 26 exhibited exhibit VBN 40436 10644 27 as as IN 40436 10644 28 triumphing triumph VBG 40436 10644 29 in in IN 40436 10644 30 the the DT 40436 10644 31 one one CD 40436 10644 32 case case NN 40436 10644 33 over over IN 40436 10644 34 adverse adverse JJ 40436 10644 35 accusers accuser NNS 40436 10644 36 and and CC 40436 10644 37 judges judge NNS 40436 10644 38 , , , 40436 10644 39 in in IN 40436 10644 40 the the DT 40436 10644 41 other other JJ 40436 10644 42 case case NN 40436 10644 43 over over IN 40436 10644 44 the the DT 40436 10644 45 unnerving unnerving JJ 40436 10644 46 manifestations manifestation NNS 40436 10644 47 of of IN 40436 10644 48 afflicted afflict VBN 40436 10644 49 friends friend NNS 40436 10644 50 . . . 40436 10645 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10645 2 Side side NN 40436 10645 3 - - HYPH 40436 10645 4 note note NN 40436 10645 5 : : : 40436 10645 6 Contrast contrast NN 40436 10645 7 between between IN 40436 10645 8 the the DT 40436 10645 9 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 10645 10 Apology Apology NNP 40436 10645 11 and and CC 40436 10645 12 the the DT 40436 10645 13 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10645 14 . . . 40436 10645 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10646 1 But but CC 40436 10646 2 though though IN 40436 10646 3 the the DT 40436 10646 4 personal personal JJ 40436 10646 5 incidents incident NNS 40436 10646 6 of of IN 40436 10646 7 this this DT 40436 10646 8 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 10646 9 are be VBP 40436 10646 10 truly truly RB 40436 10646 11 Sokratic sokratic JJ 40436 10646 12 -- -- : 40436 10646 13 the the DT 40436 10646 14 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 40436 10646 15 emphasis emphasis NN 40436 10646 16 , , , 40436 10646 17 and and CC 40436 10646 18 the the DT 40436 10646 19 apparatus apparatus NN 40436 10646 20 of of IN 40436 10646 21 argument argument NN 40436 10646 22 and and CC 40436 10646 23 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10646 24 , , , 40436 10646 25 are be VBP 40436 10646 26 essentially essentially RB 40436 10646 27 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10646 28 . . . 40436 10647 1 In in IN 40436 10647 2 these these DT 40436 10647 3 respects respect NNS 40436 10647 4 , , , 40436 10647 5 the the DT 40436 10647 6 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 10647 7 contrasts contrast VBZ 40436 10647 8 remarkably remarkably RB 40436 10647 9 with with IN 40436 10647 10 the the DT 40436 10647 11 Apology Apology NNP 40436 10647 12 . . . 40436 10648 1 When when WRB 40436 10648 2 addressing address VBG 40436 10648 3 the the DT 40436 10648 4 Dikasts Dikasts NNPS 40436 10648 5 , , , 40436 10648 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10648 7 not not RB 40436 10648 8 only only RB 40436 10648 9 makes make VBZ 40436 10648 10 no no DT 40436 10648 11 profession profession NN 40436 10648 12 of of IN 40436 10648 13 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 40436 10648 14 certainty certainty NN 40436 10648 15 , , , 40436 10648 16 but but CC 40436 10648 17 expressly expressly RB 40436 10648 18 disclaims disclaim VBZ 40436 10648 19 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10648 20 . . . 40436 10649 1 Nay nay UH 40436 10649 2 more more RBR 40436 10649 3 -- -- : 40436 10649 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10649 5 considers consider VBZ 40436 10649 6 that that IN 40436 10649 7 the the DT 40436 10649 8 false false JJ 40436 10649 9 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 10649 10 of of IN 40436 10649 11 such such JJ 40436 10649 12 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 40436 10649 13 certainty certainty NN 40436 10649 14 , , , 40436 10649 15 universally universally RB 40436 10649 16 prevalent prevalent JJ 40436 10649 17 among among IN 40436 10649 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10649 19 countrymen countryman NNS 40436 10649 20 , , , 40436 10649 21 is be VBZ 40436 10649 22 as as RB 40436 10649 23 pernicious pernicious JJ 40436 10649 24 as as IN 40436 10649 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10649 26 is be VBZ 40436 10649 27 illusory illusory JJ 40436 10649 28 : : : 40436 10649 29 and and CC 40436 10649 30 that that IN 40436 10649 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10649 32 own own JJ 40436 10649 33 superiority superiority NN 40436 10649 34 over over IN 40436 10649 35 others other NNS 40436 10649 36 consists consist VBZ 40436 10649 37 merely merely RB 40436 10649 38 in in IN 40436 10649 39 consciousness consciousness NN 40436 10649 40 of of IN 40436 10649 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10649 42 own own JJ 40436 10649 43 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 10649 44 , , , 40436 10649 45 while while IN 40436 10649 46 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10649 47 are be VBP 40436 10649 48 unconscious unconscious JJ 40436 10649 49 of of IN 40436 10649 50 theirs -PRON- PRP 40436 10649 51 . . . 40436 10650 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10650 2 98 98 CD 40436 10650 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10650 4 To to TO 40436 10650 5 dissipate dissipate VB 40436 10650 6 such such JJ 40436 10650 7 false false JJ 40436 10650 8 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 10650 9 of of IN 40436 10650 10 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10650 11 , , , 40436 10650 12 by by IN 40436 10650 13 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 10650 14 cross cross NN 40436 10650 15 - - NN 40436 10650 16 examination examination NN 40436 10650 17 of of IN 40436 10650 18 every every DT 40436 10650 19 one one CD 40436 10650 20 around around RB 40436 10650 21 , , , 40436 10650 22 is be VBZ 40436 10650 23 the the DT 40436 10650 24 special special JJ 40436 10650 25 mission mission NN 40436 10650 26 imposed impose VBN 40436 10650 27 upon upon IN 40436 10650 28 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10650 29 by by IN 40436 10650 30 the the DT 40436 10650 31 Gods god NNS 40436 10650 32 : : : 40436 10650 33 in in IN 40436 10650 34 which which WDT 40436 10650 35 mission mission NN 40436 10650 36 , , , 40436 10650 37 indeed indeed RB 40436 10650 38 , , , 40436 10650 39 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10650 40 has have VBZ 40436 10650 41 the the DT 40436 10650 42 firmest firm JJS 40436 10650 43 belief belief NN 40436 10650 44 -- -- : 40436 10650 45 but but CC 40436 10650 46 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10650 47 is be VBZ 40436 10650 48 a a DT 40436 10650 49 belief belief NN 40436 10650 50 , , , 40436 10650 51 like like IN 40436 10650 52 that that DT 40436 10650 53 in in IN 40436 10650 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10650 55 Dæmon Dæmon NNP 40436 10650 56 or or CC 40436 10650 57 divine divine JJ 40436 10650 58 sign sign NN 40436 10650 59 , , , 40436 10650 60 depending depend VBG 40436 10650 61 upon upon IN 40436 10650 62 oracles oracle NNS 40436 10650 63 , , , 40436 10650 64 dreams dream NNS 40436 10650 65 , , , 40436 10650 66 and and CC 40436 10650 67 other other JJ 40436 10650 68 revelations revelation NNS 40436 10650 69 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 10650 70 to to IN 40436 10650 71 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10650 72 , , , 40436 10650 73 which which WDT 40436 10650 74 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10650 75 does do VBZ 40436 10650 76 not not RB 40436 10650 77 expect expect VB 40436 10650 78 that that IN 40436 10650 79 the the DT 40436 10650 80 Dikasts Dikasts NNPS 40436 10650 81 will will MD 40436 10650 82 admit admit VB 40436 10650 83 as as IN 40436 10650 84 genuine genuine JJ 40436 10650 85 evidence evidence NN 40436 10650 86 . . . 40436 10651 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10651 2 99 99 CD 40436 10651 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10651 4 One one CD 40436 10651 5 peculiar peculiar JJ 40436 10651 6 example example NN 40436 10651 7 , , , 40436 10651 8 whereby whereby WRB 40436 10651 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10651 10 exemplifies exemplify VBZ 40436 10651 11 the the DT 40436 10651 12 false false JJ 40436 10651 13 persuasion persuasion NN 40436 10651 14 of of IN 40436 10651 15 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10651 16 where where WRB 40436 10651 17 men man NNS 40436 10651 18 have have VBP 40436 10651 19 no no DT 40436 10651 20 real real JJ 40436 10651 21 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10651 22 , , , 40436 10651 23 is be VBZ 40436 10651 24 borrowed borrow VBN 40436 10651 25 from from IN 40436 10651 26 the the DT 40436 10651 27 fear fear NN 40436 10651 28 of of IN 40436 10651 29 death death NN 40436 10651 30 . . . 40436 10652 1 No no DT 40436 10652 2 man man NN 40436 10652 3 knows know VBZ 40436 10652 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10652 5 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10652 6 says say VBZ 40436 10652 7 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10652 8 what what WP 40436 10652 9 death death NN 40436 10652 10 is be VBZ 40436 10652 11 , , , 40436 10652 12 not not RB 40436 10652 13 even even RB 40436 10652 14 whether whether IN 40436 10652 15 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10652 16 may may MD 40436 10652 17 not not RB 40436 10652 18 be be VB 40436 10652 19 a a DT 40436 10652 20 signal signal JJ 40436 10652 21 benefit benefit NN 40436 10652 22 : : : 40436 10652 23 yet yet CC 40436 10652 24 every every DT 40436 10652 25 man man NN 40436 10652 26 fears fear VBZ 40436 10652 27 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10652 28 as as IN 40436 10652 29 if if IN 40436 10652 30 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10652 31 well well RB 40436 10652 32 knew know VBD 40436 10652 33 that that IN 40436 10652 34 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10652 35 was be VBD 40436 10652 36 the the DT 40436 10652 37 greatest great JJS 40436 10652 38 evil evil NN 40436 10652 39 . . . 40436 10653 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10653 2 100 100 CD 40436 10653 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10653 4 Death death NN 40436 10653 5 must must MD 40436 10653 6 be be VB 40436 10653 7 one one CD 40436 10653 8 of of IN 40436 10653 9 two two CD 40436 10653 10 things thing NNS 40436 10653 11 : : : 40436 10653 12 either either CC 40436 10653 13 a a DT 40436 10653 14 final final JJ 40436 10653 15 extinction extinction NN 40436 10653 16 -- -- : 40436 10653 17 a a DT 40436 10653 18 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 10653 19 and and CC 40436 10653 20 dreamless dreamless NN 40436 10653 21 sleep sleep NN 40436 10653 22 -- -- : 40436 10653 23 or or CC 40436 10653 24 else else RB 40436 10653 25 a a DT 40436 10653 26 transference transference NN 40436 10653 27 of of IN 40436 10653 28 the the DT 40436 10653 29 soul soul NN 40436 10653 30 to to IN 40436 10653 31 some some DT 40436 10653 32 other other JJ 40436 10653 33 place place NN 40436 10653 34 . . . 40436 10654 1 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10654 2 is be VBZ 40436 10654 3 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 10654 4 that that IN 40436 10654 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10654 6 will will MD 40436 10654 7 be be VB 40436 10654 8 in in IN 40436 10654 9 either either DT 40436 10654 10 case case NN 40436 10654 11 a a DT 40436 10654 12 benefit benefit NN 40436 10654 13 to to IN 40436 10654 14 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10654 15 , , , 40436 10654 16 and and CC 40436 10654 17 that that IN 40436 10654 18 the the DT 40436 10654 19 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 10654 20 will will MD 40436 10654 21 take take VB 40436 10654 22 care care NN 40436 10654 23 that that IN 40436 10654 24 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10654 25 , , , 40436 10654 26 a a DT 40436 10654 27 good good JJ 40436 10654 28 man man NN 40436 10654 29 , , , 40436 10654 30 shall shall MD 40436 10654 31 suffer suffer VB 40436 10654 32 no no DT 40436 10654 33 evil evil NN 40436 10654 34 , , , 40436 10654 35 either either CC 40436 10654 36 living living JJ 40436 10654 37 or or CC 40436 10654 38 dead dead JJ 40436 10654 39 : : : 40436 10654 40 the the DT 40436 10654 41 proof proof NN 40436 10654 42 of of IN 40436 10654 43 which which WDT 40436 10654 44 is be VBZ 40436 10654 45 , , , 40436 10654 46 to to IN 40436 10654 47 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10654 48 , , , 40436 10654 49 that that IN 40436 10654 50 the the DT 40436 10654 51 divine divine JJ 40436 10654 52 sign sign NN 40436 10654 53 has have VBZ 40436 10654 54 never never RB 40436 10654 55 interposed interpose VBN 40436 10654 56 any any DT 40436 10654 57 obstruction obstruction NN 40436 10654 58 in in IN 40436 10654 59 regard regard NN 40436 10654 60 to to IN 40436 10654 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10654 62 trial trial NN 40436 10654 63 and and CC 40436 10654 64 sentence sentence NN 40436 10654 65 . . . 40436 10655 1 If if IN 40436 10655 2 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10655 3 says say VBZ 40436 10655 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10655 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10655 6 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10655 7 am be VBP 40436 10655 8 transferred transfer VBN 40436 10655 9 to to IN 40436 10655 10 some some DT 40436 10655 11 other other JJ 40436 10655 12 abode abode NN 40436 10655 13 , , , 40436 10655 14 among among IN 40436 10655 15 those those DT 40436 10655 16 who who WP 40436 10655 17 have have VBP 40436 10655 18 died die VBN 40436 10655 19 before before IN 40436 10655 20 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10655 21 , , , 40436 10655 22 how how WRB 40436 10655 23 delightful delightful JJ 40436 10655 24 will will MD 40436 10655 25 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10655 26 be be VB 40436 10655 27 to to TO 40436 10655 28 see see VB 40436 10655 29 Homer Homer NNP 40436 10655 30 and and CC 40436 10655 31 Hesiod Hesiod NNP 40436 10655 32 , , , 40436 10655 33 Orpheus Orpheus NNP 40436 10655 34 and and CC 40436 10655 35 Musæus Musæus NNP 40436 10655 36 , , , 40436 10655 37 Agamemnon Agamemnon NNP 40436 10655 38 , , , 40436 10655 39 Ajax Ajax NNP 40436 10655 40 or or CC 40436 10655 41 Palamêdes Palamêdes NNPS 40436 10655 42 -- -- : 40436 10655 43 and and CC 40436 10655 44 to to TO 40436 10655 45 pass pass VB 40436 10655 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10655 47 time time NN 40436 10655 48 in in IN 40436 10655 49 cross cross NN 40436 10655 50 - - JJ 40436 10655 51 examining examine VBG 40436 10655 52 each each DT 40436 10655 53 as as IN 40436 10655 54 to to IN 40436 10655 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10655 56 true true JJ 40436 10655 57 or or CC 40436 10655 58 false false JJ 40436 10655 59 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10655 60 ! ! . 40436 10656 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10656 2 101 101 CD 40436 10656 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10656 4 Lastly lastly RB 40436 10656 5 , , , 40436 10656 6 so so RB 40436 10656 7 far far RB 40436 10656 8 as as IN 40436 10656 9 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10656 10 professes profess VBZ 40436 10656 11 to to TO 40436 10656 12 aim aim VB 40436 10656 13 at at IN 40436 10656 14 any any DT 40436 10656 15 positive positive JJ 40436 10656 16 end end NN 40436 10656 17 , , , 40436 10656 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10656 19 is be VBZ 40436 10656 20 the the DT 40436 10656 21 diffusion diffusion NN 40436 10656 22 of of IN 40436 10656 23 political political JJ 40436 10656 24 , , , 40436 10656 25 social social JJ 40436 10656 26 , , , 40436 10656 27 human human JJ 40436 10656 28 virtue virtue NN 40436 10656 29 , , , 40436 10656 30 as as IN 40436 10656 31 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 10656 32 from from IN 40436 10656 33 acquisitions acquisition NNS 40436 10656 34 above above IN 40436 10656 35 the the DT 40436 10656 36 measure measure NN 40436 10656 37 of of IN 40436 10656 38 humanity humanity NN 40436 10656 39 . . . 40436 10657 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10657 2 tells tell VBZ 40436 10657 3 men man NNS 40436 10657 4 that that IN 40436 10657 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10657 6 is be VBZ 40436 10657 7 not not RB 40436 10657 8 wealth wealth NN 40436 10657 9 which which WDT 40436 10657 10 produces produce VBZ 40436 10657 11 virtue virtue NN 40436 10657 12 , , , 40436 10657 13 but but CC 40436 10657 14 virtue virtue NN 40436 10657 15 which which WDT 40436 10657 16 produces produce VBZ 40436 10657 17 wealth wealth NN 40436 10657 18 and and CC 40436 10657 19 other other JJ 40436 10657 20 advantages advantage NNS 40436 10657 21 , , , 40436 10657 22 both both CC 40436 10657 23 public public JJ 40436 10657 24 and and CC 40436 10657 25 private private JJ 40436 10657 26 . . . 40436 10658 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10658 2 102 102 CD 40436 10658 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10658 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10658 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10658 6 98 98 CD 40436 10658 7 : : : 40436 10658 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10658 9 , , , 40436 10658 10 Apol Apol NNP 40436 10658 11 . . . 40436 10659 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 10659 2 . . . 40436 10660 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10660 2 . . . 40436 10661 1 21 21 CD 40436 10661 2 - - SYM 40436 10661 3 29 29 CD 40436 10661 4 . . . 40436 10662 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10662 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10662 3 : : : 40436 10662 4 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10662 5 tou tou NNP 40436 10662 6 = = SYM 40436 10662 7 to to TO 40436 10662 8 pô pô NNP 40436 10662 9 = = SYM 40436 10662 10 s s NNP 40436 10662 11 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10662 12 a)mathi a)mathi , 40436 10662 13 / / SYM 40436 10662 14 a a DT 40436 10662 15 e)sti\n e)sti\n NNP 40436 10662 16 au(/tê au(/tê CD 40436 10662 17 ê ê NNP 40436 10662 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10662 19 e)ponei e)ponei NNP 40436 10662 20 / / SYM 40436 10662 21 distos disto NNS 40436 10662 22 , , , 40436 10662 23 ê ê NNP 40436 10662 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10662 25 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10662 26 oi)/esthai oi)/esthai NNP 40436 10662 27 ei)de ei)de NNP 40436 10662 28 / / SYM 40436 10662 29 nai nai NNP 40436 10662 30 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 10662 31 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10662 32 oi)=den oi)=den CD 40436 10662 33 ? ? . 40436 10662 34 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10663 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10663 2 29 29 CD 40436 10663 3 A a NN 40436 10663 4 - - HYPH 40436 10663 5 B b NN 40436 10663 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10663 7 . . . 40436 10663 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10664 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10664 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10664 3 99 99 CD 40436 10664 4 : : : 40436 10664 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10664 6 , , , 40436 10664 7 Apol Apol NNP 40436 10664 8 . . . 40436 10665 1 Sokr Sokr NNP 40436 10665 2 . . . 40436 10666 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10666 2 . . . 40436 10667 1 21 21 CD 40436 10667 2 - - SYM 40436 10667 3 23 23 CD 40436 10667 4 , , , 40436 10667 5 31 31 CD 40436 10667 6 D d NN 40436 10667 7 ; ; : 40436 10667 8 33 33 CD 40436 10667 9 C c NN 40436 10667 10 : : : 40436 10667 11 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10667 12 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10667 13 : : : 40436 10667 14 e)moi\ e)moi\ NNP 40436 10667 15 de\ de\ NNP 40436 10667 16 tou tou NNP 40436 10667 17 = = NNP 40436 10667 18 to to IN 40436 10667 19 , , , 40436 10667 20 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10667 21 e)gô/ e)gô/ CD 40436 10667 22 phêmi phêmi VBD 40436 10667 23 , , , 40436 10667 24 proste proste VBP 40436 10667 25 / / SYM 40436 10667 26 taktai taktai NN 40436 10667 27 u(po\ u(po\ NNP 40436 10667 28 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10667 29 theou= theou= NN 40436 10667 30 pra pra NNP 40436 10667 31 / / SYM 40436 10667 32 ttein ttein NNP 40436 10667 33 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10667 34 e)k e)k NNP 40436 10667 35 manteiô manteiô NNP 40436 10667 36 = = SYM 40436 10667 37 n n NNP 40436 10667 38 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10667 39 e)x e)x NNP 40436 10667 40 e)nupni e)nupni NNP 40436 10667 41 / / SYM 40436 10667 42 ôn ôn NNP 40436 10667 43 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10667 44 panti\ panti\ NNP 40436 10667 45 tro tro NNP 40436 10667 46 / / SYM 40436 10667 47 pô| pô| NNP 40436 10667 48 , , , 40436 10667 49 ô(=|pe ô(=|pe NN 40436 10667 50 / / SYM 40436 10667 51 r r NNP 40436 10667 52 ti ti NNP 40436 10667 53 / / SYM 40436 10667 54 s s NNP 40436 10667 55 pote pote NNP 40436 10667 56 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10667 57 a)/llê a)/llê NNP 40436 10667 58 thei thei NNP 40436 10667 59 / / SYM 40436 10667 60 a a DT 40436 10667 61 moi moi NNP 40436 10667 62 = = SYM 40436 10667 63 ra ra NNP 40436 10667 64 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 10667 65 / / SYM 40436 10667 66 pô| pô| NNP 40436 10667 67 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10667 68 o(tiou o(tiou NNP 40436 10667 69 = = SYM 40436 10667 70 n n CC 40436 10667 71 prose prose NNP 40436 10667 72 / / SYM 40436 10667 73 taxe taxe NN 40436 10667 74 pra pra NNP 40436 10667 75 / / SYM 40436 10667 76 ttein ttein NN 40436 10667 77 . . . 40436 10667 78 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10668 1 p. p. NN 40436 10668 2 37 37 CD 40436 10668 3 E e NN 40436 10668 4 : : : 40436 10668 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10668 6 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10668 7 : : : 40436 10668 8 e)a e)a NNP 40436 10668 9 / / SYM 40436 10668 10 n n CD 40436 10668 11 te te NNP 40436 10668 12 ga\r ga\r NNP 40436 10668 13 le le NNP 40436 10668 14 / / SYM 40436 10668 15 gô gô UH 40436 10668 16 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10668 17 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 10668 18 theô=| theô=| NNP 40436 10668 19 a)peithei a)peithei NNP 40436 10668 20 = = SYM 40436 10668 21 n n NNP 40436 10668 22 tou tou NNP 40436 10668 23 = = SYM 40436 10668 24 t t NNP 40436 10668 25 ' ' '' 40436 10668 26 e)sti\ e)sti\ NNP 40436 10668 27 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10668 28 dia\ dia\ NNP 40436 10668 29 tou tou NNP 40436 10668 30 = = SYM 40436 10668 31 t t NNP 40436 10668 32 ' ' '' 40436 10668 33 a)du a)du NNP 40436 10668 34 / / SYM 40436 10668 35 naton naton NNP 40436 10668 36 ê(suchi ê(suchi NNP 40436 10668 37 / / SYM 40436 10668 38 an an DT 40436 10668 39 a)/gein a)/gein NNP 40436 10668 40 , , , 40436 10668 41 ou ou NNP 40436 10668 42 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10668 43 pei pei NNP 40436 10668 44 / / SYM 40436 10668 45 sesthe/ sesthe/ NNP 40436 10668 46 moi moi NNP 40436 10668 47 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10668 48 ei)rôneuome ei)rôneuome NNP 40436 10668 49 / / SYM 40436 10668 50 nô| nô| NNP 40436 10668 51 . . . 40436 10668 52 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10668 53 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10669 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10669 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10669 3 100 100 CD 40436 10669 4 : : : 40436 10669 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10669 6 , , , 40436 10669 7 Apol Apol NNP 40436 10669 8 . . . 40436 10670 1 S. S. NNP 40436 10670 2 p. p. NN 40436 10670 3 29 29 CD 40436 10670 4 B. b. NN 40436 10671 1 In in IN 40436 10671 2 the the DT 40436 10671 3 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 10671 4 Apology Apology NNP 40436 10671 5 of of IN 40436 10671 6 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10671 7 , , , 40436 10671 8 no no DT 40436 10671 9 allusion allusion NN 40436 10671 10 is be VBZ 40436 10671 11 made make VBN 40436 10671 12 to to IN 40436 10671 13 the the DT 40436 10671 14 immortality immortality NN 40436 10671 15 of of IN 40436 10671 16 the the DT 40436 10671 17 soul soul NN 40436 10671 18 . . . 40436 10672 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10672 2 is be VBZ 40436 10672 3 there there RB 40436 10672 4 described describe VBN 40436 10672 5 as as IN 40436 10672 6 having have VBG 40436 10672 7 shaped shape VBN 40436 10672 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10672 9 defence defence NN 40436 10672 10 under under IN 40436 10672 11 a a DT 40436 10672 12 belief belief NN 40436 10672 13 that that IN 40436 10672 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10672 15 had have VBD 40436 10672 16 arrived arrive VBN 40436 10672 17 at at IN 40436 10672 18 a a DT 40436 10672 19 term term NN 40436 10672 20 when when WRB 40436 10672 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10672 22 was be VBD 40436 10672 23 better well JJR 40436 10672 24 for for IN 40436 10672 25 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10672 26 to to TO 40436 10672 27 die die VB 40436 10672 28 than than IN 40436 10672 29 to to TO 40436 10672 30 live live VB 40436 10672 31 , , , 40436 10672 32 and and CC 40436 10672 33 that that DT 40436 10672 34 prolonged prolong VBD 40436 10672 35 life life NN 40436 10672 36 would would MD 40436 10672 37 only only RB 40436 10672 38 expose expose VB 40436 10672 39 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10672 40 to to IN 40436 10672 41 the the DT 40436 10672 42 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 40436 10672 43 weaknesses weakness NNS 40436 10672 44 and and CC 40436 10672 45 disabilities disability NNS 40436 10672 46 of of IN 40436 10672 47 senility senility NN 40436 10672 48 . . . 40436 10673 1 It -PRON- PRP 40436 10673 2 is be VBZ 40436 10673 3 a a DT 40436 10673 4 proof proof NN 40436 10673 5 of of IN 40436 10673 6 the the DT 40436 10673 7 benevolence benevolence NN 40436 10673 8 of of IN 40436 10673 9 the the DT 40436 10673 10 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 10673 11 that that IN 40436 10673 12 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10673 13 is be VBZ 40436 10673 14 withdrawn withdraw VBN 40436 10673 15 from from IN 40436 10673 16 life life NN 40436 10673 17 at at IN 40436 10673 18 so so RB 40436 10673 19 opportune opportune VB 40436 10673 20 a a DT 40436 10673 21 moment moment NN 40436 10673 22 . . . 40436 10674 1 This this DT 40436 10674 2 is be VBZ 40436 10674 3 the the DT 40436 10674 4 explanation explanation NN 40436 10674 5 which which WDT 40436 10674 6 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 10674 7 gives give VBZ 40436 10674 8 of of IN 40436 10674 9 the the DT 40436 10674 10 haughty haughty JJ 40436 10674 11 tone tone NN 40436 10674 12 of of IN 40436 10674 13 the the DT 40436 10674 14 defence defence NN 40436 10674 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10674 16 sects sect NNS 40436 10674 17 . . . 40436 10675 1 6 6 CD 40436 10675 2 - - HYPH 40436 10675 3 15 15 CD 40436 10675 4 - - HYPH 40436 10675 5 23 23 CD 40436 10675 6 - - HYPH 40436 10675 7 27 27 CD 40436 10675 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10675 9 . . . 40436 10676 1 In in IN 40436 10676 2 the the DT 40436 10676 3 Xenophontic Xenophontic NNP 40436 10676 4 Cyropædia Cyropædia NNP 40436 10676 5 , , , 40436 10676 6 Cyrus Cyrus NNP 40436 10676 7 , , , 40436 10676 8 on on IN 40436 10676 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10676 10 death death NN 40436 10676 11 - - HYPH 40436 10676 12 bed bed NN 40436 10676 13 , , , 40436 10676 14 addresses address VBZ 40436 10676 15 earnest earnest JJ 40436 10676 16 exhortations exhortation NNS 40436 10676 17 to to IN 40436 10676 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10676 19 two two CD 40436 10676 20 sons son NNS 40436 10676 21 : : : 40436 10676 22 and and CC 40436 10676 23 to to TO 40436 10676 24 give give VB 40436 10676 25 greater great JJR 40436 10676 26 force force NN 40436 10676 27 to to IN 40436 10676 28 such such JJ 40436 10676 29 exhortations exhortation NNS 40436 10676 30 , , , 40436 10676 31 reminds remind VBZ 40436 10676 32 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10676 33 that that IN 40436 10676 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10676 35 own own JJ 40436 10676 36 soul soul NN 40436 10676 37 will will MD 40436 10676 38 still still RB 40436 10676 39 survive survive VB 40436 10676 40 and and CC 40436 10676 41 will will MD 40436 10676 42 still still RB 40436 10676 43 exercise exercise VB 40436 10676 44 a a DT 40436 10676 45 certain certain JJ 40436 10676 46 authority authority NN 40436 10676 47 after after IN 40436 10676 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10676 49 death death NN 40436 10676 50 . . . 40436 10677 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10677 2 expresses express VBZ 40436 10677 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10677 4 own own JJ 40436 10677 5 belief belief NN 40436 10677 6 not not RB 40436 10677 7 only only RB 40436 10677 8 that that IN 40436 10677 9 the the DT 40436 10677 10 soul soul NN 40436 10677 11 survives survive VBZ 40436 10677 12 the the DT 40436 10677 13 body body NN 40436 10677 14 , , , 40436 10677 15 but but CC 40436 10677 16 also also RB 40436 10677 17 that that IN 40436 10677 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10677 19 becomes become VBZ 40436 10677 20 more more RBR 40436 10677 21 rational rational JJ 40436 10677 22 when when WRB 40436 10677 23 disembodied disembody VBD 40436 10677 24 ; ; : 40436 10677 25 because--1 because--1 FW 40436 10677 26 . . . 40436 10678 1 Murderers murderer NNS 40436 10678 2 are be VBP 40436 10678 3 disturbed disturb VBN 40436 10678 4 by by IN 40436 10678 5 the the DT 40436 10678 6 souls soul NNS 40436 10678 7 of of IN 40436 10678 8 murdered murder VBN 40436 10678 9 men man NNS 40436 10678 10 . . . 40436 10679 1 2 2 LS 40436 10679 2 . . . 40436 10680 1 Honours honour NNS 40436 10680 2 are be VBP 40436 10680 3 paid pay VBN 40436 10680 4 to to IN 40436 10680 5 deceased deceased JJ 40436 10680 6 persons person NNS 40436 10680 7 , , , 40436 10680 8 which which WDT 40436 10680 9 practice practice NN 40436 10680 10 would would MD 40436 10680 11 not not RB 40436 10680 12 continue continue VB 40436 10680 13 , , , 40436 10680 14 unless unless IN 40436 10680 15 the the DT 40436 10680 16 souls soul NNS 40436 10680 17 of of IN 40436 10680 18 the the DT 40436 10680 19 deceased deceased JJ 40436 10680 20 had have VBD 40436 10680 21 efficacy efficacy NN 40436 10680 22 to to TO 40436 10680 23 enforce enforce VB 40436 10680 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10680 25 . . . 40436 10681 1 3 3 LS 40436 10681 2 . . . 40436 10682 1 The the DT 40436 10682 2 souls soul NNS 40436 10682 3 of of IN 40436 10682 4 living living NN 40436 10682 5 men man NNS 40436 10682 6 are be VBP 40436 10682 7 more more RBR 40436 10682 8 rational rational JJ 40436 10682 9 during during IN 40436 10682 10 sleep sleep NN 40436 10682 11 than than IN 40436 10682 12 when when WRB 40436 10682 13 awake awake JJ 40436 10682 14 , , , 40436 10682 15 and and CC 40436 10682 16 sleep sleep VB 40436 10682 17 affords afford NNS 40436 10682 18 the the DT 40436 10682 19 nearest near JJS 40436 10682 20 analogy analogy NN 40436 10682 21 to to IN 40436 10682 22 death death NN 40436 10682 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10682 24 viii viii RB 40436 10682 25 . . . 40436 10683 1 7 7 CD 40436 10683 2 , , , 40436 10683 3 17 17 CD 40436 10683 4 - - SYM 40436 10683 5 21 21 CD 40436 10683 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10683 7 . . . 40436 10684 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10684 2 Much much RB 40436 10684 3 the the DT 40436 10684 4 same same JJ 40436 10684 5 arguments argument NNS 40436 10684 6 were be VBD 40436 10684 7 urged urge VBN 40436 10684 8 in in IN 40436 10684 9 the the DT 40436 10684 10 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 10684 11 of of IN 40436 10684 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10684 13 . . . 40436 10685 1 Bernays Bernays NNP 40436 10685 2 , , , 40436 10685 3 Dialog Dialog NNP 40436 10685 4 . . . 40436 10686 1 Aristot aristot NN 40436 10686 2 . . . 40436 10687 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10687 2 . . . 40436 10688 1 23 23 CD 40436 10688 2 - - SYM 40436 10688 3 105 105 CD 40436 10688 4 . . . 40436 10688 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10689 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10689 2 however however RB 40436 10689 3 adds add VBZ 40436 10689 4 , , , 40436 10689 5 that that IN 40436 10689 6 even even RB 40436 10689 7 if if IN 40436 10689 8 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10689 9 be be VBP 40436 10689 10 mistaken mistake VBN 40436 10689 11 in in IN 40436 10689 12 this this DT 40436 10689 13 point point NN 40436 10689 14 , , , 40436 10689 15 and and CC 40436 10689 16 if if IN 40436 10689 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10689 18 soul soul NN 40436 10689 19 perish perish VBP 40436 10689 20 with with IN 40436 10689 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10689 22 body body NN 40436 10689 23 , , , 40436 10689 24 still still RB 40436 10689 25 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10689 26 conjures conjure VBZ 40436 10689 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10689 28 sons son NNS 40436 10689 29 , , , 40436 10689 30 in in IN 40436 10689 31 the the DT 40436 10689 32 name name NN 40436 10689 33 of of IN 40436 10689 34 the the DT 40436 10689 35 gods god NNS 40436 10689 36 , , , 40436 10689 37 to to TO 40436 10689 38 obey obey VB 40436 10689 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10689 40 dying die VBG 40436 10689 41 injunctions injunction NNS 40436 10689 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10689 43 s. s. NNP 40436 10689 44 22 22 CD 40436 10689 45 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10689 46 . . . 40436 10690 1 Again again RB 40436 10690 2 , , , 40436 10690 3 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10690 4 says say VBZ 40436 10690 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10690 6 s. s. NNP 40436 10690 7 27 27 CD 40436 10690 8 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10690 9 , , , 40436 10690 10 " " `` 40436 10690 11 Invite invite VB 40436 10690 12 all all PDT 40436 10690 13 the the DT 40436 10690 14 Persians Persians NNPS 40436 10690 15 to to IN 40436 10690 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10690 17 tomb tomb NN 40436 10690 18 , , , 40436 10690 19 to to TO 40436 10690 20 join join VB 40436 10690 21 with with IN 40436 10690 22 me -PRON- PRP 40436 10690 23 in in IN 40436 10690 24 satisfaction satisfaction NN 40436 10690 25 that that IN 40436 10690 26 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10690 27 shall shall MD 40436 10690 28 now now RB 40436 10690 29 be be VB 40436 10690 30 in in IN 40436 10690 31 safety safety NN 40436 10690 32 , , , 40436 10690 33 so so IN 40436 10690 34 as as IN 40436 10690 35 to to TO 40436 10690 36 suffer suffer VB 40436 10690 37 no no DT 40436 10690 38 farther farth JJR 40436 10690 39 harm harm NN 40436 10690 40 , , , 40436 10690 41 whether whether IN 40436 10690 42 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10690 43 am be VBP 40436 10690 44 united united JJ 40436 10690 45 to to IN 40436 10690 46 the the DT 40436 10690 47 divine divine JJ 40436 10690 48 element element NN 40436 10690 49 , , , 40436 10690 50 or or CC 40436 10690 51 perish perish VB 40436 10690 52 altogether altogether RB 40436 10690 53 " " '' 40436 10690 54 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10690 55 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10690 56 Greek greek JJ 40436 10690 57 : : : 40436 10690 58 sunêsthêsome sunêsthêsome JJ 40436 10690 59 / / SYM 40436 10690 60 nous nous JJ 40436 10690 61 e)moi/ e)moi/ NNS 40436 10690 62 , , , 40436 10690 63 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10690 64 e)n e)n NNP 40436 10690 65 tô=| tô=| NNP 40436 10690 66 a)sphalei= a)sphalei= JJ 40436 10690 67 ê)/dê ê)/dê NNS 40436 10690 68 e)/somai e)/somai NNP 40436 10690 69 , , , 40436 10690 70 ô(s ô(s NNP 40436 10690 71 mêde\n mêde\n , 40436 10690 72 a)\n a)\n NN 40436 10690 73 e)/ti e)/ti NN 40436 10690 74 kako\n kako\n NNP 40436 10690 75 pathei pathei NNP 40436 10690 76 = = SYM 40436 10690 77 n n NNP 40436 10690 78 , , , 40436 10690 79 mê mê NNP 40436 10690 80 / / SYM 40436 10690 81 te te NNP 40436 10690 82 ê)\n ê)\n NNP 40436 10690 83 meta\ meta\ NNP 40436 10690 84 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10690 85 thei thei NN 40436 10690 86 / / SYM 40436 10690 87 ou ou NNP 40436 10690 88 ge ge NNP 40436 10690 89 / / SYM 40436 10690 90 nômai nômai NNP 40436 10690 91 , , , 40436 10690 92 mê mê NNP 40436 10690 93 / / SYM 40436 10690 94 te te NNP 40436 10690 95 ê)\n ê)\n NNP 40436 10690 96 mêde\n mêde\n , 40436 10690 97 e)/ti e)/ti DT 40436 10690 98 ô)=| ô)=| NNP 40436 10690 99 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10690 100 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10690 101 . . . 40436 10691 1 The the DT 40436 10691 2 view view NN 40436 10691 3 taken take VBN 40436 10691 4 here here RB 40436 10691 5 by by IN 40436 10691 6 Cyrus Cyrus NNP 40436 10691 7 , , , 40436 10691 8 of of IN 40436 10691 9 death death NN 40436 10691 10 in in IN 40436 10691 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10691 12 analogy analogy NN 40436 10691 13 with with IN 40436 10691 14 sleep sleep NN 40436 10691 15 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10691 16 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10691 17 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10691 18 : : : 40436 10691 19 u(/pnô| u(/pnô| NNP 40436 10691 20 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10691 21 thana thana NNP 40436 10691 22 / / SYM 40436 10691 23 tô| tô| NNP 40436 10691 24 diduma diduma NNP 40436 10691 25 / / SYM 40436 10691 26 osin osin NN 40436 10691 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10691 28 , , , 40436 10691 29 Iliad Iliad NNP 40436 10691 30 , , , 40436 10691 31 xvi xvi NNP 40436 10691 32 . . . 40436 10692 1 672 672 CD 40436 10692 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10692 3 as as IN 40436 10692 4 a a DT 40436 10692 5 refuge refuge NN 40436 10692 6 against against IN 40436 10692 7 impending impending JJ 40436 10692 8 evil evil NN 40436 10692 9 for for IN 40436 10692 10 the the DT 40436 10692 11 future future NN 40436 10692 12 , , , 40436 10692 13 is be VBZ 40436 10692 14 much much RB 40436 10692 15 the the DT 40436 10692 16 same same JJ 40436 10692 17 as as IN 40436 10692 18 that that DT 40436 10692 19 taken take VBN 40436 10692 20 by by IN 40436 10692 21 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10692 22 in in IN 40436 10692 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10692 24 Apology apology NN 40436 10692 25 . . . 40436 10693 1 Sokrates sokrate NNS 40436 10693 2 is be VBZ 40436 10693 3 not not RB 40436 10693 4 less less RBR 40436 10693 5 proud proud JJ 40436 10693 6 of of IN 40436 10693 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10693 8 past past JJ 40436 10693 9 life life NN 40436 10693 10 , , , 40436 10693 11 spent spend VBN 40436 10693 12 in in IN 40436 10693 13 dialectic dialectic JJ 40436 10693 14 debate debate NN 40436 10693 15 , , , 40436 10693 16 than than IN 40436 10693 17 Cyrus Cyrus NNP 40436 10693 18 of of IN 40436 10693 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10693 20 glorious glorious JJ 40436 10693 21 exploits exploit NNS 40436 10693 22 . . . 40436 10694 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10694 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10694 3 : : : 40436 10694 4 O o NN 40436 10694 5 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10694 6 tha tha NNP 40436 10694 7 / / SYM 40436 10694 8 natos natos NNP 40436 10694 9 , , , 40436 10694 10 limê\n limê\n NNP 40436 10694 11 kakô kakô NNP 40436 10694 12 = = SYM 40436 10694 13 n n NNP 40436 10694 14 toi toi NNP 40436 10694 15 = = SYM 40436 10694 16 s s FW 40436 10694 17 dusdaimonou dusdaimonou VBP 40436 10694 18 = = SYM 40436 10694 19 sin sin NN 40436 10694 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10694 21 , , , 40436 10694 22 Longinus Longinus NNP 40436 10694 23 , , , 40436 10694 24 de de NNP 40436 10694 25 Subl Subl NNP 40436 10694 26 . . . 40436 10695 1 c. c. NNP 40436 10695 2 9 9 CD 40436 10695 3 , , , 40436 10695 4 p. p. NN 40436 10695 5 23 23 CD 40436 10695 6 . . . 40436 10696 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10696 2 also also RB 40436 10696 3 the the DT 40436 10696 4 Oration Oration NNP 40436 10696 5 of of IN 40436 10696 6 Julius Julius NNP 40436 10696 7 Cæsar Cæsar NNP 40436 10696 8 in in IN 40436 10696 9 Sallust Sallust NNP 40436 10696 10 , , , 40436 10696 11 Bell Bell NNP 40436 10696 12 . . . 40436 10697 1 Catilin Catilin NNP 40436 10697 2 . . . 40436 10698 1 c. c. NNP 40436 10698 2 51 51 CD 40436 10698 3 - - HYPH 40436 10698 4 -"in -"in NN 40436 10698 5 luctu luctu NNP 40436 10698 6 atque atque NNP 40436 10698 7 miseriis miseriis NNP 40436 10698 8 , , , 40436 10698 9 mortem mortem NNP 40436 10698 10 ærumnarum ærumnarum NNP 40436 10698 11 requiem requiem NNP 40436 10698 12 , , , 40436 10698 13 non non AFX 40436 10698 14 cruciatum cruciatum NNP 40436 10698 15 esse esse NNP 40436 10698 16 : : : 40436 10698 17 illam illam NNP 40436 10698 18 cuncta cuncta NNP 40436 10698 19 mortalium mortalium NNP 40436 10698 20 mala mala NNP 40436 10698 21 dissolvere dissolvere NNP 40436 10698 22 : : : 40436 10698 23 ultra ultra NNP 40436 10698 24 neque neque NNP 40436 10698 25 curæ curæ NNP 40436 10698 26 neque neque NNP 40436 10698 27 gaudio gaudio NNP 40436 10698 28 locum locum NNP 40436 10698 29 esse esse NNP 40436 10698 30 " " '' 40436 10698 31 . . . 40436 10698 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10699 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10699 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10699 3 101 101 CD 40436 10699 4 : : : 40436 10699 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10699 6 , , , 40436 10699 7 Apol Apol NNP 40436 10699 8 . . . 40436 10700 1 S. S. NNP 40436 10700 2 pp pp NNP 40436 10700 3 . . . 40436 10701 1 40 40 CD 40436 10701 2 - - SYM 40436 10701 3 41 41 CD 40436 10701 4 . . . 40436 10701 5 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10702 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10702 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10702 3 102 102 CD 40436 10702 4 : : : 40436 10702 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10702 6 , , , 40436 10702 7 Apol Apol NNP 40436 10702 8 . . . 40436 10703 1 S. S. NNP 40436 10703 2 pp pp NNP 40436 10703 3 . . . 40436 10704 1 20 20 CD 40436 10704 2 C c NN 40436 10704 3 , , , 40436 10704 4 29 29 CD 40436 10704 5 - - SYM 40436 10704 6 30 30 CD 40436 10704 7 . . . 40436 10705 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10705 2 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10705 3 : : : 40436 10705 4 le le NNP 40436 10705 5 / / SYM 40436 10705 6 gôn gôn NNP 40436 10705 7 o(/ti o(/ti NNP 40436 10705 8 ou)k ou)k NNP 40436 10705 9 e)k e)k NNP 40436 10705 10 chrêma chrêma NNP 40436 10705 11 / / SYM 40436 10705 12 tôn tôn NNP 40436 10705 13 a)retê\ a)retê\ NNP 40436 10705 14 gi gi NNP 40436 10705 15 / / SYM 40436 10705 16 gnetai gnetai NN 40436 10705 17 , , , 40436 10705 18 a)ll a)ll NNP 40436 10705 19 ' ' '' 40436 10705 20 e)x e)x NNP 40436 10705 21 a)retê a)retê : 40436 10705 22 = = SYM 40436 10705 23 s s NNP 40436 10705 24 chrê chrê NNP 40436 10705 25 / / SYM 40436 10705 26 mata mata NNP 40436 10705 27 , , , 40436 10705 28 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10705 29 ta)=lla ta)=lla NNP 40436 10705 30 a)gatha\ a)gatha\ NNP 40436 10705 31 toi toi NNP 40436 10705 32 = = SYM 40436 10705 33 s s NNP 40436 10705 34 a)nthrô a)nthrô NNP 40436 10705 35 / / SYM 40436 10705 36 pois pois NNP 40436 10705 37 a(/panta a(/panta NNP 40436 10705 38 , , , 40436 10705 39 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10705 40 i)di i)di NNP 40436 10705 41 / / SYM 40436 10705 42 a| a| NN 40436 10705 43 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10705 44 dêmosi dêmosi NNP 40436 10705 45 / / SYM 40436 10705 46 a| a| NN 40436 10705 47 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10705 48 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10705 49 30 30 CD 40436 10705 50 B b NN 40436 10705 51 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10705 52 . . . 40436 10706 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 10706 2 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 10706 3 , , , 40436 10706 4 Memorab Memorab NNP 40436 10706 5 . . . 40436 10707 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10708 1 2 2 CD 40436 10708 2 , , , 40436 10708 3 8 8 CD 40436 10708 4 - - SYM 40436 10708 5 9 9 CD 40436 10708 6 . . . 40436 10708 7 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10709 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10709 2 Side side NN 40436 10709 3 - - HYPH 40436 10709 4 note note NN 40436 10709 5 : : : 40436 10709 6 Abundant abundant JJ 40436 10709 7 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 40436 10709 8 and and CC 40436 10709 9 poetical poetical JJ 40436 10709 10 invention invention NN 40436 10709 11 of of IN 40436 10709 12 the the DT 40436 10709 13 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10709 14 compared compare VBN 40436 10709 15 with with IN 40436 10709 16 the the DT 40436 10709 17 profession profession NN 40436 10709 18 of of IN 40436 10709 19 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 10709 20 which which WDT 40436 10709 21 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10709 22 read read VBP 40436 10709 23 in in IN 40436 10709 24 the the DT 40436 10709 25 Apology Apology NNP 40436 10709 26 . . . 40436 10709 27 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10710 1 If if IN 40436 10710 2 from from IN 40436 10710 3 the the DT 40436 10710 4 Apology apology NN 40436 10710 5 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10710 6 turn turn VBP 40436 10710 7 to to IN 40436 10710 8 the the DT 40436 10710 9 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10710 10 , , , 40436 10710 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10710 12 seem seem VBP 40436 10710 13 to to TO 40436 10710 14 pass pass VB 40436 10710 15 , , , 40436 10710 16 not not RB 40436 10710 17 merely merely RB 40436 10710 18 to to IN 40436 10710 19 the the DT 40436 10710 20 same same JJ 40436 10710 21 speaker speaker NN 40436 10710 22 after after IN 40436 10710 23 the the DT 40436 10710 24 interval interval NN 40436 10710 25 of of IN 40436 10710 26 one one CD 40436 10710 27 month month NN 40436 10710 28 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10710 29 the the DT 40436 10710 30 ostensible ostensible JJ 40436 10710 31 interval interval NN 40436 10710 32 indicated indicate VBD 40436 10710 33 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10710 34 but but CC 40436 10710 35 to to IN 40436 10710 36 a a DT 40436 10710 37 different different JJ 40436 10710 38 speaker speaker NN 40436 10710 39 and and CC 40436 10710 40 over over IN 40436 10710 41 a a DT 40436 10710 42 long long JJ 40436 10710 43 period period NN 40436 10710 44 . . . 40436 10711 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10711 2 have have VBP 40436 10711 3 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10711 4 speaking speak VBG 40436 10711 5 through through IN 40436 10711 6 the the DT 40436 10711 7 mouth mouth NN 40436 10711 8 of of IN 40436 10711 9 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10711 10 , , , 40436 10711 11 and and CC 40436 10711 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10711 13 too too RB 40436 10711 14 at at IN 40436 10711 15 a a DT 40436 10711 16 much much RB 40436 10711 17 later later JJ 40436 10711 18 time time NN 40436 10711 19 . . . 40436 10712 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10712 2 103 103 CD 40436 10712 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10712 4 Though though IN 40436 10712 5 the the DT 40436 10712 6 moral moral JJ 40436 10712 7 character character NN 40436 10712 8 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10712 9 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10712 10 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10712 11 : : : 40436 10712 12 ê)=thos ê)=thos NNP 40436 10712 13 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10712 14 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10712 15 of of IN 40436 10712 16 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10712 17 is be VBZ 40436 10712 18 fully fully RB 40436 10712 19 maintained maintain VBN 40436 10712 20 and and CC 40436 10712 21 even even RB 40436 10712 22 strikingly strikingly RB 40436 10712 23 dramatised dramatise VBN 40436 10712 24 -- -- : 40436 10712 25 the the DT 40436 10712 26 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 10712 27 personality personality NN 40436 10712 28 is be VBZ 40436 10712 29 altogether altogether RB 40436 10712 30 transformed transform VBN 40436 10712 31 . . . 40436 10713 1 Instead instead RB 40436 10713 2 of of IN 40436 10713 3 a a DT 40436 10713 4 speaker speaker NN 40436 10713 5 who who WP 40436 10713 6 avows avow VBZ 40436 10713 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10713 8 own own JJ 40436 10713 9 ignorance ignorance NN 40436 10713 10 , , , 40436 10713 11 and and CC 40436 10713 12 blames blame VBZ 40436 10713 13 others other NNS 40436 10713 14 only only RB 40436 10713 15 for for IN 40436 10713 16 believing believe VBG 40436 10713 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10713 18 to to TO 40436 10713 19 know know VB 40436 10713 20 when when WRB 40436 10713 21 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10713 22 are be VBP 40436 10713 23 equally equally RB 40436 10713 24 ignorant ignorant JJ 40436 10713 25 -- -- : 40436 10713 26 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10713 27 have have VBP 40436 10713 28 one one CD 40436 10713 29 who who WP 40436 10713 30 indulges indulge VBZ 40436 10713 31 in in IN 40436 10713 32 the the DT 40436 10713 33 widest wide JJS 40436 10713 34 range range NN 40436 10713 35 of of IN 40436 10713 36 theory theory NN 40436 10713 37 and and CC 40436 10713 38 the the DT 40436 10713 39 boldest bold JJS 40436 10713 40 employment employment NN 40436 10713 41 of of IN 40436 10713 42 hypothesis hypothesis NN 40436 10713 43 . . . 40436 10714 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10714 2 introduces introduce VBZ 40436 10714 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10714 4 own own JJ 40436 10714 5 dogmatical dogmatical JJ 40436 10714 6 and and CC 40436 10714 7 mystical mystical JJ 40436 10714 8 views view NNS 40436 10714 9 , , , 40436 10714 10 leaning lean VBG 40436 10714 11 in in IN 40436 10714 12 part part NN 40436 10714 13 on on IN 40436 10714 14 the the DT 40436 10714 15 Orphic orphic JJ 40436 10714 16 and and CC 40436 10714 17 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40436 10714 18 creeds creed NNS 40436 10714 19 . . . 40436 10715 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10715 2 104 104 CD 40436 10715 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10715 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10715 5 declares declare VBZ 40436 10715 6 the the DT 40436 10715 7 distinctness distinctness NN 40436 10715 8 of of IN 40436 10715 9 nature nature NN 40436 10715 10 , , , 40436 10715 11 the the DT 40436 10715 12 incompatibility incompatibility NN 40436 10715 13 , , , 40436 10715 14 the the DT 40436 10715 15 forced force VBN 40436 10715 16 temporary temporary JJ 40436 10715 17 union union NN 40436 10715 18 and and CC 40436 10715 19 active active JJ 40436 10715 20 conflict conflict NN 40436 10715 21 , , , 40436 10715 22 between between IN 40436 10715 23 the the DT 40436 10715 24 soul soul NN 40436 10715 25 and and CC 40436 10715 26 the the DT 40436 10715 27 body body NN 40436 10715 28 . . . 40436 10716 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10716 2 includes include VBZ 40436 10716 3 this this DT 40436 10716 4 in in IN 40436 10716 5 the the DT 40436 10716 6 still still RB 40436 10716 7 wider wide JJR 40436 10716 8 and and CC 40436 10716 9 more more RBR 40436 10716 10 general general JJ 40436 10716 11 declaration declaration NN 40436 10716 12 , , , 40436 10716 13 which which WDT 40436 10716 14 recognises recognise VBZ 40436 10716 15 antithesis antithesis NN 40436 10716 16 between between IN 40436 10716 17 the the DT 40436 10716 18 two two CD 40436 10716 19 worlds world NNS 40436 10716 20 : : : 40436 10716 21 the the DT 40436 10716 22 world world NN 40436 10716 23 of of IN 40436 10716 24 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 10716 25 , , , 40436 10716 26 Forms Forms NNPS 40436 10716 27 , , , 40436 10716 28 Essences Essences NNPS 40436 10716 29 , , , 40436 10716 30 not not RB 40436 10716 31 perceivable perceivable JJ 40436 10716 32 but but CC 40436 10716 33 only only RB 40436 10716 34 cogitable cogitable JJ 40436 10716 35 , , , 40436 10716 36 eternal eternal JJ 40436 10716 37 , , , 40436 10716 38 and and CC 40436 10716 39 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 40436 10716 40 , , , 40436 10716 41 with with IN 40436 10716 42 which which WDT 40436 10716 43 the the DT 40436 10716 44 soul soul NN 40436 10716 45 or or CC 40436 10716 46 mind mind NN 40436 10716 47 was be VBD 40436 10716 48 in in IN 40436 10716 49 kindred kindred JJ 40436 10716 50 and and CC 40436 10716 51 communion communion NN 40436 10716 52 -- -- : 40436 10716 53 the the DT 40436 10716 54 world world NN 40436 10716 55 of of IN 40436 10716 56 sense sense NN 40436 10716 57 , , , 40436 10716 58 or or CC 40436 10716 59 of of IN 40436 10716 60 transient transient NN 40436 10716 61 and and CC 40436 10716 62 ever ever RB 40436 10716 63 - - HYPH 40436 10716 64 changing change VBG 40436 10716 65 appearances appearance NNS 40436 10716 66 or or CC 40436 10716 67 phenomena phenomenon NNS 40436 10716 68 , , , 40436 10716 69 never never RB 40436 10716 70 arriving arrive VBG 40436 10716 71 at at IN 40436 10716 72 permanent permanent JJ 40436 10716 73 existence existence NN 40436 10716 74 , , , 40436 10716 75 but but CC 40436 10716 76 always always RB 40436 10716 77 coming come VBG 40436 10716 78 and and CC 40436 10716 79 going go VBG 40436 10716 80 , , , 40436 10716 81 with with IN 40436 10716 82 which which WDT 40436 10716 83 the the DT 40436 10716 84 body body NN 40436 10716 85 was be VBD 40436 10716 86 in in IN 40436 10716 87 commerce commerce NN 40436 10716 88 and and CC 40436 10716 89 harmony harmony NN 40436 10716 90 . . . 40436 10717 1 The the DT 40436 10717 2 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 10717 3 , , , 40436 10717 4 who who WP 40436 10717 5 thirsts thirst VBZ 40436 10717 6 only only RB 40436 10717 7 after after IN 40436 10717 8 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10717 9 and and CC 40436 10717 10 desires desire NNS 40436 10717 11 to to TO 40436 10717 12 look look VB 40436 10717 13 at at IN 40436 10717 14 things[105 things[105 LS 40436 10717 15 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10717 16 as as IN 40436 10717 17 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10717 18 are be VBP 40436 10717 19 in in IN 40436 10717 20 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10717 21 , , , 40436 10717 22 with with IN 40436 10717 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10717 24 mind mind NN 40436 10717 25 by by IN 40436 10717 26 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10717 27 -- -- : 40436 10717 28 is be VBZ 40436 10717 29 represented represent VBN 40436 10717 30 as as IN 40436 10717 31 desiring desire VBG 40436 10717 32 , , , 40436 10717 33 throughout throughout IN 40436 10717 34 all all PDT 40436 10717 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10717 36 life life NN 40436 10717 37 , , , 40436 10717 38 to to TO 40436 10717 39 loosen loosen VB 40436 10717 40 as as RB 40436 10717 41 much much RB 40436 10717 42 as as IN 40436 10717 43 possible possible JJ 40436 10717 44 the the DT 40436 10717 45 implication implication NN 40436 10717 46 of of IN 40436 10717 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10717 48 soul soul NN 40436 10717 49 with with IN 40436 10717 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10717 51 body body NN 40436 10717 52 , , , 40436 10717 53 and and CC 40436 10717 54 as as IN 40436 10717 55 rejoicing rejoice VBG 40436 10717 56 when when WRB 40436 10717 57 the the DT 40436 10717 58 hour hour NN 40436 10717 59 of of IN 40436 10717 60 death death NN 40436 10717 61 arrives arrive VBZ 40436 10717 62 to to TO 40436 10717 63 divorce divorce VB 40436 10717 64 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10717 65 altogether altogether RB 40436 10717 66 . . . 40436 10718 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10718 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10718 3 103 103 CD 40436 10718 4 : : : 40436 10718 5 In in IN 40436 10718 6 reviewing review VBG 40436 10718 7 the the DT 40436 10718 8 Apology Apology NNP 40436 10718 9 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10718 10 supra supra NNP 40436 10718 11 , , , 40436 10718 12 vol vol NNP 40436 10718 13 . . . 40436 10719 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10719 2 ch ch NNP 40436 10719 3 . . . 40436 10720 1 ix ix IN 40436 10720 2 . . . 40436 10721 1 p. p. NN 40436 10721 2 410 410 CD 40436 10721 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10721 4 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10721 5 have have VBP 40436 10721 6 already already RB 40436 10721 7 noticed notice VBN 40436 10721 8 this this DT 40436 10721 9 very very RB 40436 10721 10 material material JJ 40436 10721 11 discrepancy discrepancy NN 40436 10721 12 , , , 40436 10721 13 which which WDT 40436 10721 14 is be VBZ 40436 10721 15 insisted insist VBN 40436 10721 16 upon upon IN 40436 10721 17 by by IN 40436 10721 18 Ast Ast NNP 40436 10721 19 as as IN 40436 10721 20 an an DT 40436 10721 21 argument argument NN 40436 10721 22 for for IN 40436 10721 23 disallowing disallow VBG 40436 10721 24 the the DT 40436 10721 25 genuineness genuineness NN 40436 10721 26 of of IN 40436 10721 27 the the DT 40436 10721 28 Apology Apology NNP 40436 10721 29 . . . 40436 10721 30 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10722 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10722 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10722 3 104 104 CD 40436 10722 4 : : : 40436 10722 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10722 6 , , , 40436 10722 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10722 8 , , , 40436 10722 9 pp pp NNP 40436 10722 10 . . . 40436 10723 1 69 69 CD 40436 10723 2 C C NNP 40436 10723 3 , , , 40436 10723 4 70 70 CD 40436 10723 5 C C NNP 40436 10723 6 , , , 40436 10723 7 81 81 CD 40436 10723 8 C c NN 40436 10723 9 , , , 40436 10723 10 62 62 CD 40436 10723 11 B. b. NN 40436 10723 12 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10724 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10724 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10724 3 105 105 CD 40436 10724 4 : : : 40436 10724 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10724 6 , , , 40436 10724 7 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10724 8 , , , 40436 10724 9 p. p. NN 40436 10724 10 66 66 CD 40436 10724 11 E. E. NNP 40436 10724 12 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10724 13 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10724 14 : : : 40436 10724 15 a)pallakte a)pallakte CD 40436 10724 16 / / SYM 40436 10724 17 on on IN 40436 10724 18 au)tou= au)tou= NNP 40436 10724 19 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10724 20 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10724 21 sô sô NNP 40436 10724 22 / / SYM 40436 10724 23 matos matos NN 40436 10724 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10724 25 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10724 26 au)tê=| au)tê=| NNP 40436 10724 27 tê=| tê=| NNP 40436 10724 28 psuchê=| psuchê=| NNP 40436 10724 29 theate theate NN 40436 10724 30 / / SYM 40436 10724 31 on on IN 40436 10724 32 au)ta\ au)ta\ JJ 40436 10724 33 ta\ ta\ NNS 40436 10724 34 pra pra NNP 40436 10724 35 / / SYM 40436 10724 36 gmata gmata NNS 40436 10724 37 . . . 40436 10724 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10724 39 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10725 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10725 2 Side side NN 40436 10725 3 - - HYPH 40436 10725 4 note note NN 40436 10725 5 : : : 40436 10725 6 Total total JJ 40436 10725 7 renunciation renunciation NN 40436 10725 8 and and CC 40436 10725 9 discredit discredit NN 40436 10725 10 of of IN 40436 10725 11 the the DT 40436 10725 12 body body NN 40436 10725 13 in in IN 40436 10725 14 the the DT 40436 10725 15 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10725 16 . . . 40436 10726 1 Different different JJ 40436 10726 2 feeling feeling NN 40436 10726 3 about about IN 40436 10726 4 the the DT 40436 10726 5 body body NN 40436 10726 6 in in IN 40436 10726 7 other other JJ 40436 10726 8 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10726 9 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 10726 10 . . . 40436 10726 11 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10727 1 Such such JJ 40436 10727 2 total total JJ 40436 10727 3 renunciation renunciation NN 40436 10727 4 of of IN 40436 10727 5 the the DT 40436 10727 6 body body NN 40436 10727 7 is be VBZ 40436 10727 8 put put VBN 40436 10727 9 , , , 40436 10727 10 with with IN 40436 10727 11 dramatic dramatic JJ 40436 10727 12 propriety propriety NN 40436 10727 13 , , , 40436 10727 14 into into IN 40436 10727 15 the the DT 40436 10727 16 mouth mouth NN 40436 10727 17 of of IN 40436 10727 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10727 19 during during IN 40436 10727 20 the the DT 40436 10727 21 last last JJ 40436 10727 22 hour hour NN 40436 10727 23 of of IN 40436 10727 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10727 25 life life NN 40436 10727 26 . . . 40436 10728 1 But but CC 40436 10728 2 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10728 3 would would MD 40436 10728 4 not not RB 40436 10728 5 have have VB 40436 10728 6 been be VBN 40436 10728 7 in in IN 40436 10728 8 harmony harmony NN 40436 10728 9 with with IN 40436 10728 10 the the DT 40436 10728 11 character character NN 40436 10728 12 of of IN 40436 10728 13 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10728 14 as as IN 40436 10728 15 other other JJ 40436 10728 16 Platonic platonic JJ 40436 10728 17 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 10728 18 present present VBP 40436 10728 19 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10728 20 -- -- : 40436 10728 21 in in IN 40436 10728 22 the the DT 40436 10728 23 plenitude plenitude NN 40436 10728 24 of of IN 40436 10728 25 life life NN 40436 10728 26 -- -- : 40436 10728 27 manifesting manifest VBG 40436 10728 28 distinguished distinguish VBN 40436 10728 29 bodily bodily JJ 40436 10728 30 strength strength NN 40436 10728 31 and and CC 40436 10728 32 soldierly soldierly JJ 40436 10728 33 efficiency efficiency NN 40436 10728 34 , , , 40436 10728 35 proclaiming proclaim VBG 40436 10728 36 gymnastic gymnastic JJ 40436 10728 37 training training NN 40436 10728 38 for for IN 40436 10728 39 the the DT 40436 10728 40 body body NN 40436 10728 41 to to TO 40436 10728 42 be be VB 40436 10728 43 co co VBN 40436 10728 44 - - NN 40436 10728 45 ordinate ordinate VB 40436 10728 46 with with IN 40436 10728 47 musical musical JJ 40436 10728 48 training training NN 40436 10728 49 for for IN 40436 10728 50 the the DT 40436 10728 51 mind mind NN 40436 10728 52 , , , 40436 10728 53 and and CC 40436 10728 54 impressed impress VBN 40436 10728 55 with with IN 40436 10728 56 the the DT 40436 10728 57 most most RBS 40436 10728 58 intense intense JJ 40436 10728 59 admiration admiration NN 40436 10728 60 for for IN 40436 10728 61 the the DT 40436 10728 62 personal personal JJ 40436 10728 63 beauty beauty NN 40436 10728 64 of of IN 40436 10728 65 youth youth NN 40436 10728 66 . . . 40436 10729 1 The the DT 40436 10729 2 human human JJ 40436 10729 3 body body NN 40436 10729 4 , , , 40436 10729 5 which which WDT 40436 10729 6 in in IN 40436 10729 7 the the DT 40436 10729 8 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10729 9 is be VBZ 40436 10729 10 discredited discredit VBN 40436 10729 11 as as IN 40436 10729 12 a a DT 40436 10729 13 morbid morbid NN 40436 10729 14 incumbrance incumbrance NN 40436 10729 15 corrupting corrupt VBG 40436 10729 16 the the DT 40436 10729 17 purity purity NN 40436 10729 18 of of IN 40436 10729 19 the the DT 40436 10729 20 soul soul NN 40436 10729 21 , , , 40436 10729 22 is be VBZ 40436 10729 23 presented present VBN 40436 10729 24 to to IN 40436 10729 25 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10729 26 by by IN 40436 10729 27 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10729 28 in in IN 40436 10729 29 the the DT 40436 10729 30 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 10729 31 as as IN 40436 10729 32 the the DT 40436 10729 33 only only JJ 40436 10729 34 sensible sensible JJ 40436 10729 35 object object NN 40436 10729 36 which which WDT 40436 10729 37 serves serve VBZ 40436 10729 38 as as IN 40436 10729 39 a a DT 40436 10729 40 mirror mirror NN 40436 10729 41 and and CC 40436 10729 42 reflection reflection NN 40436 10729 43 of of IN 40436 10729 44 the the DT 40436 10729 45 beauty beauty NN 40436 10729 46 of of IN 40436 10729 47 the the DT 40436 10729 48 ideal ideal JJ 40436 10729 49 world:[106 world:[106 NNP 40436 10729 50 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10729 51 while while IN 40436 10729 52 the the DT 40436 10729 53 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 10729 54 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10729 55 proclaims proclaim VBZ 40436 10729 56 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10729 57 in in IN 40436 10729 58 language language NN 40436 10729 59 not not RB 40436 10729 60 unsuitable unsuitable JJ 40436 10729 61 to to IN 40436 10729 62 Locke Locke NNP 40436 10729 63 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10729 64 that that DT 40436 10729 65 sight sight NN 40436 10729 66 , , , 40436 10729 67 hearing hearing NN 40436 10729 68 , , , 40436 10729 69 and and CC 40436 10729 70 speech speech NN 40436 10729 71 are be VBP 40436 10729 72 the the DT 40436 10729 73 sources source NNS 40436 10729 74 of of IN 40436 10729 75 our -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10729 76 abstract abstract JJ 40436 10729 77 Ideas idea NNS 40436 10729 78 , , , 40436 10729 79 and and CC 40436 10729 80 the the DT 40436 10729 81 generating generate VBG 40436 10729 82 causes cause NNS 40436 10729 83 of of IN 40436 10729 84 speculative speculative JJ 40436 10729 85 intellect intellect NN 40436 10729 86 and and CC 40436 10729 87 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10729 88 . . . 40436 10730 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10730 2 107 107 CD 40436 10730 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10730 4 Of of IN 40436 10730 5 these these DT 40436 10730 6 , , , 40436 10730 7 and and CC 40436 10730 8 of of IN 40436 10730 9 the the DT 40436 10730 10 world world NN 40436 10730 11 of of IN 40436 10730 12 sense sense NN 40436 10730 13 generally generally RB 40436 10730 14 , , , 40436 10730 15 an an DT 40436 10730 16 opposite opposite JJ 40436 10730 17 view view NN 40436 10730 18 was be VBD 40436 10730 19 appropriate appropriate JJ 40436 10730 20 in in IN 40436 10730 21 the the DT 40436 10730 22 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10730 23 ; ; : 40436 10730 24 where where WRB 40436 10730 25 the the DT 40436 10730 26 purpose purpose NN 40436 10730 27 of of IN 40436 10730 28 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10730 29 is be VBZ 40436 10730 30 to to TO 40436 10730 31 console console VB 40436 10730 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10730 33 distressed distressed JJ 40436 10730 34 friends friend NNS 40436 10730 35 by by IN 40436 10730 36 showing show VBG 40436 10730 37 that that DT 40436 10730 38 death death NN 40436 10730 39 was be VBD 40436 10730 40 no no DT 40436 10730 41 misfortune misfortune NN 40436 10730 42 , , , 40436 10730 43 but but CC 40436 10730 44 relief relief NN 40436 10730 45 from from IN 40436 10730 46 a a DT 40436 10730 47 burthen burthen NN 40436 10730 48 . . . 40436 10731 1 And and CC 40436 10731 2 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10731 3 has have VBZ 40436 10731 4 availed avail VBN 40436 10731 5 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10731 6 of of IN 40436 10731 7 this this DT 40436 10731 8 impressive impressive JJ 40436 10731 9 situation,[108 situation,[108 NN 40436 10731 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10731 11 to to TO 40436 10731 12 recommend recommend VB 40436 10731 13 , , , 40436 10731 14 with with IN 40436 10731 15 every every DT 40436 10731 16 charm charm NN 40436 10731 17 of of IN 40436 10731 18 poetical poetical JJ 40436 10731 19 expression expression NN 40436 10731 20 , , , 40436 10731 21 various various JJ 40436 10731 22 characteristic characteristic JJ 40436 10731 23 dogmas dogma NNS 40436 10731 24 respecting respect VBG 40436 10731 25 the the DT 40436 10731 26 essential essential JJ 40436 10731 27 distinction distinction NN 40436 10731 28 between between IN 40436 10731 29 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 10731 30 and and CC 40436 10731 31 the the DT 40436 10731 32 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 10731 33 world world NN 40436 10731 34 on on IN 40436 10731 35 one one CD 40436 10731 36 side side NN 40436 10731 37 -- -- : 40436 10731 38 Perceptions perception NNS 40436 10731 39 and and CC 40436 10731 40 the the DT 40436 10731 41 sensible sensible JJ 40436 10731 42 world world NN 40436 10731 43 on on IN 40436 10731 44 the the DT 40436 10731 45 other other JJ 40436 10731 46 : : : 40436 10731 47 respecting respect VBG 40436 10731 48 the the DT 40436 10731 49 soul soul NN 40436 10731 50 , , , 40436 10731 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10731 52 nature nature NN 40436 10731 53 akin akin JJ 40436 10731 54 to to IN 40436 10731 55 the the DT 40436 10731 56 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 10731 57 world world NN 40436 10731 58 , , , 40436 10731 59 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10731 60 pre pre NN 40436 10731 61 - - NN 40436 10731 62 existence existence NN 40436 10731 63 anterior anterior NN 40436 10731 64 to to IN 40436 10731 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10731 66 present present JJ 40436 10731 67 body body NN 40436 10731 68 , , , 40436 10731 69 and and CC 40436 10731 70 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10731 71 continued continue VBN 40436 10731 72 existence existence NN 40436 10731 73 after after IN 40436 10731 74 the the DT 40436 10731 75 death death NN 40436 10731 76 of of IN 40436 10731 77 the the DT 40436 10731 78 latter latter JJ 40436 10731 79 : : : 40436 10731 80 respecting respect VBG 40436 10731 81 the the DT 40436 10731 82 condition condition NN 40436 10731 83 of of IN 40436 10731 84 the the DT 40436 10731 85 soul soul NN 40436 10731 86 before before IN 40436 10731 87 birth birth NN 40436 10731 88 and and CC 40436 10731 89 after after IN 40436 10731 90 death death NN 40436 10731 91 , , , 40436 10731 92 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10731 93 transition transition NN 40436 10731 94 , , , 40436 10731 95 in in IN 40436 10731 96 the the DT 40436 10731 97 case case NN 40436 10731 98 of of IN 40436 10731 99 most most JJS 40436 10731 100 men man NNS 40436 10731 101 , , , 40436 10731 102 into into IN 40436 10731 103 other other JJ 40436 10731 104 bodies body NNS 40436 10731 105 , , , 40436 10731 106 either either CC 40436 10731 107 human human NN 40436 10731 108 or or CC 40436 10731 109 animal animal NN 40436 10731 110 , , , 40436 10731 111 with with IN 40436 10731 112 the the DT 40436 10731 113 condition condition NN 40436 10731 114 of of IN 40436 10731 115 suffering suffer VBG 40436 10731 116 penalties penalty NNS 40436 10731 117 commensurate commensurate JJ 40436 10731 118 to to IN 40436 10731 119 the the DT 40436 10731 120 wrongs wrong NNS 40436 10731 121 committed commit VBN 40436 10731 122 in in IN 40436 10731 123 this this DT 40436 10731 124 life life NN 40436 10731 125 : : : 40436 10731 126 finally finally RB 40436 10731 127 , , , 40436 10731 128 respecting respect VBG 40436 10731 129 the the DT 40436 10731 130 privilege privilege NN 40436 10731 131 accorded accord VBN 40436 10731 132 to to IN 40436 10731 133 the the DT 40436 10731 134 souls soul NNS 40436 10731 135 of of IN 40436 10731 136 such such JJ 40436 10731 137 as as IN 40436 10731 138 have have VBP 40436 10731 139 passed pass VBN 40436 10731 140 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10731 141 lives life NNS 40436 10731 142 in in IN 40436 10731 143 intellectual intellectual JJ 40436 10731 144 and and CC 40436 10731 145 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 10731 146 occupation occupation NN 40436 10731 147 , , , 40436 10731 148 that that IN 40436 10731 149 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10731 150 shall shall MD 40436 10731 151 after after IN 40436 10731 152 death death NN 40436 10731 153 remain remain VBP 40436 10731 154 for for IN 40436 10731 155 ever ever RB 40436 10731 156 disembodied disembody VBN 40436 10731 157 , , , 40436 10731 158 in in IN 40436 10731 159 direct direct JJ 40436 10731 160 communion communion NN 40436 10731 161 with with IN 40436 10731 162 the the DT 40436 10731 163 world world NN 40436 10731 164 of of IN 40436 10731 165 Ideas Ideas NNP 40436 10731 166 . . . 40436 10732 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10732 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10732 3 106 106 CD 40436 10732 4 : : : 40436 10732 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10732 6 , , , 40436 10732 7 Charmidês Charmidês NNP 40436 10732 8 , , , 40436 10732 9 p. p. NN 40436 10732 10 155 155 CD 40436 10732 11 D. D. NNP 40436 10732 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 10732 13 , , , 40436 10732 14 init init NN 40436 10732 15 . . . 40436 10733 1 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 10733 2 , , , 40436 10733 3 p. p. NN 40436 10733 4 250 250 CD 40436 10733 5 D. D. NNP 40436 10733 6 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 10733 7 , , , 40436 10733 8 pp pp NNP 40436 10733 9 . . . 40436 10734 1 177 177 CD 40436 10734 2 C C NNP 40436 10734 3 , , , 40436 10734 4 210 210 CD 40436 10734 5 A. a. NN 40436 10734 6 Æschines Æschines NNPS 40436 10734 7 , , , 40436 10734 8 one one CD 40436 10734 9 of of IN 40436 10734 10 the the DT 40436 10734 11 Socratici Socratici NNP 40436 10734 12 viri viri NN 40436 10734 13 or or CC 40436 10734 14 fellow fellow JJ 40436 10734 15 disciples disciple NNS 40436 10734 16 of of IN 40436 10734 17 Sokrates Sokrates NNPS 40436 10734 18 along along IN 40436 10734 19 with with IN 40436 10734 20 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10734 21 , , , 40436 10734 22 composed composed JJ 40436 10734 23 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 10734 24 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10734 25 of of IN 40436 10734 26 the the DT 40436 10734 27 same same JJ 40436 10734 28 general general JJ 40436 10734 29 nature nature NN 40436 10734 30 as as IN 40436 10734 31 those those DT 40436 10734 32 of of IN 40436 10734 33 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10734 34 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10734 35 wherein wherein WRB 40436 10734 36 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10734 37 was be VBD 40436 10734 38 introduced introduce VBN 40436 10734 39 conversing converse VBG 40436 10734 40 or or CC 40436 10734 41 arguing argue VBG 40436 10734 42 . . . 40436 10735 1 Æschines æschine NNS 40436 10735 2 placed place VBN 40436 10735 3 in in IN 40436 10735 4 the the DT 40436 10735 5 mouth mouth NN 40436 10735 6 of of IN 40436 10735 7 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10735 8 the the DT 40436 10735 9 most most RBS 40436 10735 10 intense intense JJ 40436 10735 11 expressions expression NNS 40436 10735 12 of of IN 40436 10735 13 passionate passionate JJ 40436 10735 14 admiration admiration NN 40436 10735 15 towards towards IN 40436 10735 16 the the DT 40436 10735 17 person person NN 40436 10735 18 of of IN 40436 10735 19 Alkibiades Alkibiades NNP 40436 10735 20 . . . 40436 10736 1 See see VB 40436 10736 2 the the DT 40436 10736 3 Fragments Fragments NNPS 40436 10736 4 cited cite VBN 40436 10736 5 by by IN 40436 10736 6 the the DT 40436 10736 7 Rhetor Rhetor NNP 40436 10736 8 Aristeides Aristeides NNP 40436 10736 9 , , , 40436 10736 10 Orat Orat NNP 40436 10736 11 . . . 40436 10737 1 xlv xlv NNP 40436 10737 2 . . . 40436 10738 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10738 2 . . . 40436 10739 1 20 20 CD 40436 10739 2 - - SYM 40436 10739 3 23 23 CD 40436 10739 4 , , , 40436 10739 5 ed ed NN 40436 10739 6 . . . 40436 10740 1 Dindorf Dindorf NNP 40436 10740 2 . . . 40436 10741 1 Aristeides aristeide NNS 40436 10741 2 mentions mention NNS 40436 10741 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10741 4 p. p. NN 40436 10741 5 24 24 CD 40436 10741 6 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10741 7 that that IN 40436 10741 8 various various JJ 40436 10741 9 persons person NNS 40436 10741 10 in in IN 40436 10741 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10741 12 time time NN 40436 10741 13 mistook mistake VBD 40436 10741 14 these these DT 40436 10741 15 expressions expression NNS 40436 10741 16 ascribed ascribe VBN 40436 10741 17 to to IN 40436 10741 18 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10741 19 for for IN 40436 10741 20 the the DT 40436 10741 21 real real JJ 40436 10741 22 talk talk NN 40436 10741 23 of of IN 40436 10741 24 Sokrates Sokrates NNP 40436 10741 25 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10741 26 . . . 40436 10742 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10742 2 also also RB 40436 10742 3 the the DT 40436 10742 4 Symposion Symposion NNP 40436 10742 5 of of IN 40436 10742 6 Xenophon Xenophon NNP 40436 10742 7 , , , 40436 10742 8 iv iv NNP 40436 10742 9 . . . 40436 10743 1 27 27 CD 40436 10743 2 . . . 40436 10743 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10744 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10744 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10744 3 107 107 CD 40436 10744 4 : : : 40436 10744 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10744 6 , , , 40436 10744 7 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10744 8 , , , 40436 10744 9 p. p. NN 40436 10744 10 47 47 CD 40436 10744 11 , , , 40436 10744 12 A A NNP 40436 10744 13 - - HYPH 40436 10744 14 D. D. NNP 40436 10745 1 Consult Consult NNP 40436 10745 2 also also RB 40436 10745 3 the the DT 40436 10745 4 same same JJ 40436 10745 5 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 10745 6 , , , 40436 10745 7 pp pp NNP 40436 10745 8 . . . 40436 10746 1 87 87 CD 40436 10746 2 - - SYM 40436 10746 3 88 88 CD 40436 10746 4 , , , 40436 10746 5 where where WRB 40436 10746 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10746 7 insists insist VBZ 40436 10746 8 on on IN 40436 10746 9 the the DT 40436 10746 10 necessity necessity NN 40436 10746 11 of of IN 40436 10746 12 co co JJ 40436 10746 13 - - NN 40436 10746 14 ordinate ordinate JJ 40436 10746 15 attention attention NN 40436 10746 16 both both DT 40436 10746 17 to to IN 40436 10746 18 mind mind NN 40436 10746 19 and and CC 40436 10746 20 to to IN 40436 10746 21 body body NN 40436 10746 22 , , , 40436 10746 23 and and CC 40436 10746 24 on on IN 40436 10746 25 the the DT 40436 10746 26 mischiefs mischief NNS 40436 10746 27 of of IN 40436 10746 28 highly highly RB 40436 10746 29 developed develop VBN 40436 10746 30 force force NN 40436 10746 31 in in IN 40436 10746 32 the the DT 40436 10746 33 mind mind NN 40436 10746 34 unless unless IN 40436 10746 35 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10746 36 be be VB 40436 10746 37 accompanied accompany VBN 40436 10746 38 by by IN 40436 10746 39 a a DT 40436 10746 40 corresponding corresponding JJ 40436 10746 41 development development NN 40436 10746 42 of of IN 40436 10746 43 force force NN 40436 10746 44 in in IN 40436 10746 45 the the DT 40436 10746 46 body body NN 40436 10746 47 . . . 40436 10746 48 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10747 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10747 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10747 3 108 108 CD 40436 10747 4 : : : 40436 10747 5 Compare compare VB 40436 10747 6 the the DT 40436 10747 7 description description NN 40436 10747 8 of of IN 40436 10747 9 the the DT 40436 10747 10 last last JJ 40436 10747 11 discourse discourse NN 40436 10747 12 of of IN 40436 10747 13 Pætus Pætus NNP 40436 10747 14 Thrasea Thrasea NNP 40436 10747 15 . . . 40436 10748 1 Tacitus Tacitus NNP 40436 10748 2 , , , 40436 10748 3 Annal Annal NNP 40436 10748 4 . . . 40436 10749 1 xvi xvi NNP 40436 10749 2 . . . 40436 10750 1 34 34 CD 40436 10750 2 . . . 40436 10750 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10751 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10751 2 Side side NN 40436 10751 3 - - HYPH 40436 10751 4 note note NN 40436 10751 5 : : : 40436 10751 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10751 7 's 's POS 40436 10751 8 argument argument NN 40436 10751 9 does do VBZ 40436 10751 10 not not RB 40436 10751 11 prove prove VB 40436 10751 12 the the DT 40436 10751 13 immortality immortality NN 40436 10751 14 of of IN 40436 10751 15 the the DT 40436 10751 16 soul soul NN 40436 10751 17 . . . 40436 10752 1 Even even RB 40436 10752 2 if if IN 40436 10752 3 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10752 4 did do VBD 40436 10752 5 prove prove VB 40436 10752 6 that that DT 40436 10752 7 , , , 40436 10752 8 yet yet CC 40436 10752 9 the the DT 40436 10752 10 mode mode NN 40436 10752 11 of of IN 40436 10752 12 pre pre NN 40436 10752 13 - - NN 40436 10752 14 existence existence NN 40436 10752 15 and and CC 40436 10752 16 the the DT 40436 10752 17 mode mode NN 40436 10752 18 of of IN 40436 10752 19 post post JJ 40436 10752 20 - - NN 40436 10752 21 existence existence NN 40436 10752 22 , , , 40436 10752 23 of of IN 40436 10752 24 the the DT 40436 10752 25 soul soul NN 40436 10752 26 , , , 40436 10752 27 would would MD 40436 10752 28 be be VB 40436 10752 29 quite quite RB 40436 10752 30 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 10752 31 . . . 40436 10752 32 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10753 1 The the DT 40436 10753 2 main main JJ 40436 10753 3 part part NN 40436 10753 4 of of IN 40436 10753 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10753 6 's 's POS 40436 10753 7 argumentation argumentation NN 40436 10753 8 , , , 40436 10753 9 drawn draw VBN 40436 10753 10 from from IN 40436 10753 11 the the DT 40436 10753 12 general general JJ 40436 10753 13 assumptions assumption NNS 40436 10753 14 of of IN 40436 10753 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10753 16 philosophy philosophy NN 40436 10753 17 , , , 40436 10753 18 is be VBZ 40436 10753 19 directed direct VBN 40436 10753 20 to to TO 40436 10753 21 prove prove VB 40436 10753 22 the the DT 40436 10753 23 separate separate JJ 40436 10753 24 and and CC 40436 10753 25 perpetual perpetual JJ 40436 10753 26 existence existence NN 40436 10753 27 of of IN 40436 10753 28 the the DT 40436 10753 29 soul soul NN 40436 10753 30 , , , 40436 10753 31 before before IN 40436 10753 32 as as RB 40436 10753 33 well well RB 40436 10753 34 as as IN 40436 10753 35 after after IN 40436 10753 36 the the DT 40436 10753 37 body body NN 40436 10753 38 . . . 40436 10754 1 These these DT 40436 10754 2 arguments argument NNS 40436 10754 3 , , , 40436 10754 4 interesting interesting JJ 40436 10754 5 as as IN 40436 10754 6 specimens specimen NNS 40436 10754 7 of of IN 40436 10754 8 the the DT 40436 10754 9 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 10754 10 which which WDT 40436 10754 11 satisfied satisfy VBD 40436 10754 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10754 13 , , , 40436 10754 14 do do VBP 40436 10754 15 not not RB 40436 10754 16 prove prove VB 40436 10754 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10754 18 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 10754 19 . . . 40436 10755 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10755 2 109 109 CD 40436 10755 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10755 4 But but CC 40436 10755 5 even even RB 40436 10755 6 if if IN 40436 10755 7 that that DT 40436 10755 8 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 10755 9 were be VBD 40436 10755 10 admitted admit VBN 40436 10755 11 to to TO 40436 10755 12 be be VB 40436 10755 13 proved prove VBN 40436 10755 14 , , , 40436 10755 15 the the DT 40436 10755 16 condition condition NN 40436 10755 17 of of IN 40436 10755 18 the the DT 40436 10755 19 soul soul NN 40436 10755 20 , , , 40436 10755 21 during during IN 40436 10755 22 such such JJ 40436 10755 23 anterior anterior NN 40436 10755 24 and and CC 40436 10755 25 posterior posterior NNP 40436 10755 26 existence existence NN 40436 10755 27 , , , 40436 10755 28 would would MD 40436 10755 29 be be VB 40436 10755 30 altogether altogether RB 40436 10755 31 undetermined undetermined JJ 40436 10755 32 , , , 40436 10755 33 and and CC 40436 10755 34 would would MD 40436 10755 35 be be VB 40436 10755 36 left leave VBN 40436 10755 37 to to IN 40436 10755 38 the the DT 40436 10755 39 free free JJ 40436 10755 40 play play NN 40436 10755 41 of of IN 40436 10755 42 sentiment sentiment NN 40436 10755 43 and and CC 40436 10755 44 imagination imagination NN 40436 10755 45 . . . 40436 10756 1 There there EX 40436 10756 2 is be VBZ 40436 10756 3 no no DT 40436 10756 4 subject subject NN 40436 10756 5 upon upon IN 40436 10756 6 which which WDT 40436 10756 7 the the DT 40436 10756 8 poetical poetical JJ 40436 10756 9 genius genius NN 40436 10756 10 of of IN 40436 10756 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10756 12 has have VBZ 40436 10756 13 been be VBN 40436 10756 14 more more RBR 40436 10756 15 abundantly abundantly RB 40436 10756 16 exercised exercise VBN 40436 10756 17 . . . 40436 10757 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10757 2 110 110 CD 40436 10757 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10757 4 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10757 5 has have VBZ 40436 10757 6 given give VBN 40436 10757 7 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10757 8 two two CD 40436 10757 9 different different JJ 40436 10757 10 descriptions description NNS 40436 10757 11 of of IN 40436 10757 12 the the DT 40436 10757 13 state state NN 40436 10757 14 of of IN 40436 10757 15 the the DT 40436 10757 16 soul soul NN 40436 10757 17 before before IN 40436 10757 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10757 19 junction junction NN 40436 10757 20 with with IN 40436 10757 21 the the DT 40436 10757 22 body body NN 40436 10757 23 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10757 24 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10757 25 , , , 40436 10757 26 and and CC 40436 10757 27 Phædrus Phædrus NNP 40436 10757 28 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10757 29 , , , 40436 10757 30 and and CC 40436 10757 31 three three CD 40436 10757 32 different different JJ 40436 10757 33 descriptions description NNS 40436 10757 34 of of IN 40436 10757 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10757 36 destiny destiny NN 40436 10757 37 after after IN 40436 10757 38 separation separation NN 40436 10757 39 from from IN 40436 10757 40 the the DT 40436 10757 41 body body NN 40436 10757 42 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10757 43 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10757 44 , , , 40436 10757 45 Gorgias Gorgias NNP 40436 10757 46 , , , 40436 10757 47 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10757 48 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10757 49 . . . 40436 10758 1 In in IN 40436 10758 2 all all PDT 40436 10758 3 the the DT 40436 10758 4 three three CD 40436 10758 5 , , , 40436 10758 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10758 7 supposes suppose VBZ 40436 10758 8 an an DT 40436 10758 9 adjudication adjudication NN 40436 10758 10 and and CC 40436 10758 11 classification classification NN 40436 10758 12 of of IN 40436 10758 13 the the DT 40436 10758 14 departed depart VBN 40436 10758 15 souls soul NNS 40436 10758 16 , , , 40436 10758 17 and and CC 40436 10758 18 a a DT 40436 10758 19 better well JJR 40436 10758 20 or or CC 40436 10758 21 worse bad JJR 40436 10758 22 fate fate NN 40436 10758 23 allotted allot VBN 40436 10758 24 * * NFP 40436 10758 25 * * NFP 40436 10758 26 to to IN 40436 10758 27 each each DT 40436 10758 28 according accord VBG 40436 10758 29 to to IN 40436 10758 30 the the DT 40436 10758 31 estimate estimate NN 40436 10758 32 which which WDT 40436 10758 33 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10758 34 forms form VBZ 40436 10758 35 of of IN 40436 10758 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10758 37 merits merit NNS 40436 10758 38 or or CC 40436 10758 39 demerits demerit NNS 40436 10758 40 during during IN 40436 10758 41 life life NN 40436 10758 42 : : : 40436 10758 43 but but CC 40436 10758 44 in in IN 40436 10758 45 each each DT 40436 10758 46 of of IN 40436 10758 47 the the DT 40436 10758 48 three three CD 40436 10758 49 , , , 40436 10758 50 this this DT 40436 10758 51 general general JJ 40436 10758 52 idea idea NN 40436 10758 53 is be VBZ 40436 10758 54 carried carry VBN 40436 10758 55 out out RP 40436 10758 56 by by IN 40436 10758 57 a a DT 40436 10758 58 different different JJ 40436 10758 59 machinery machinery NN 40436 10758 60 . . . 40436 10759 1 The the DT 40436 10759 2 Hades Hades NNP 40436 10759 3 of of IN 40436 10759 4 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10759 5 is be VBZ 40436 10759 6 not not RB 40436 10759 7 announced announce VBN 40436 10759 8 even even RB 40436 10759 9 by by IN 40436 10759 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10759 11 as as IN 40436 10759 12 anything anything NN 40436 10759 13 more more JJR 40436 10759 14 than than IN 40436 10759 15 approximation approximation NN 40436 10759 16 to to IN 40436 10759 17 the the DT 40436 10759 18 truth truth NN 40436 10759 19 : : : 40436 10759 20 but but CC 40436 10759 21 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10759 22 embodies embody VBZ 40436 10759 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10759 24 own own JJ 40436 10759 25 ethical ethical JJ 40436 10759 26 and and CC 40436 10759 27 judicial judicial JJ 40436 10759 28 sentence sentence NN 40436 10759 29 on on IN 40436 10759 30 the the DT 40436 10759 31 classes class NNS 40436 10759 32 of of IN 40436 10759 33 men man NNS 40436 10759 34 around around IN 40436 10759 35 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10759 36 -- -- : 40436 10759 37 as as IN 40436 10759 38 the the DT 40436 10759 39 Divina Divina NNP 40436 10759 40 Commedia Commedia NNP 40436 10759 41 embodies embody VBZ 40436 10759 42 that that DT 40436 10759 43 of of IN 40436 10759 44 Dante Dante NNP 40436 10759 45 on on IN 40436 10759 46 antecedent antecedent NN 40436 10759 47 individual individual JJ 40436 10759 48 persons person NNS 40436 10759 49 . . . 40436 10760 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10760 2 distributes distribute VBZ 40436 10760 3 rewards reward NNS 40436 10760 4 and and CC 40436 10760 5 penalties penalty NNS 40436 10760 6 in in IN 40436 10760 7 the the DT 40436 10760 8 measure measure NN 40436 10760 9 which which WDT 40436 10760 10 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10760 11 conceives conceive VBZ 40436 10760 12 to to TO 40436 10760 13 be be VB 40436 10760 14 deserved deserve VBN 40436 10760 15 : : : 40436 10760 16 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10760 17 erects erect VBZ 40436 10760 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10760 19 own own JJ 40436 10760 20 approbation approbation NN 40436 10760 21 and and CC 40436 10760 22 disapprobation disapprobation NN 40436 10760 23 , , , 40436 10760 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10760 25 own own JJ 40436 10760 26 sympathy sympathy NN 40436 10760 27 and and CC 40436 10760 28 antipathy antipathy NN 40436 10760 29 , , , 40436 10760 30 into into IN 40436 10760 31 laws law NNS 40436 10760 32 of of IN 40436 10760 33 the the DT 40436 10760 34 unknown unknown JJ 40436 10760 35 future future JJ 40436 10760 36 state state NN 40436 10760 37 : : : 40436 10760 38 the the DT 40436 10760 39 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 10760 40 , , , 40436 10760 41 whom whom WP 40436 10760 42 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10760 43 postulates postulate VBZ 40436 10760 44 , , , 40436 10760 45 are be VBP 40436 10760 46 imaginary imaginary JJ 40436 10760 47 agents agent NNS 40436 10760 48 introduced introduce VBN 40436 10760 49 to to TO 40436 10760 50 execute execute VB 40436 10760 51 the the DT 40436 10760 52 sentences sentence NNS 40436 10760 53 which which WDT 40436 10760 54 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10760 55 dictates dictate VBZ 40436 10760 56 . . . 40436 10761 1 While while IN 40436 10761 2 others other NNS 40436 10761 3 , , , 40436 10761 4 in in IN 40436 10761 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10761 6 conceptions conception NNS 40436 10761 7 of of IN 40436 10761 8 posthumous posthumous JJ 40436 10761 9 existence existence NN 40436 10761 10 , , , 40436 10761 11 assured assure VBD 40436 10761 12 the the DT 40436 10761 13 happiest happy JJS 40436 10761 14 fate fate NN 40436 10761 15 , , , 40436 10761 16 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 10761 17 even even RB 40436 10761 18 divinity divinity NN 40436 10761 19 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10761 20 , , , 40436 10761 21 to to IN 40436 10761 22 great great JJ 40436 10761 23 warriors warrior NNS 40436 10761 24 and and CC 40436 10761 25 law law NN 40436 10761 26 - - HYPH 40436 10761 27 givers giver NNS 40436 10761 28 -- -- : 40436 10761 29 to to IN 40436 10761 30 devoted devoted JJ 40436 10761 31 friends friend NNS 40436 10761 32 and and CC 40436 10761 33 patriots patriot NNS 40436 10761 34 like like IN 40436 10761 35 Harmodius Harmodius NNP 40436 10761 36 and and CC 40436 10761 37 Aristogeiton Aristogeiton NNP 40436 10761 38 -- -- : 40436 10761 39 to to IN 40436 10761 40 the the DT 40436 10761 41 exquisite exquisite JJ 40436 10761 42 beauty beauty NN 40436 10761 43 of of IN 40436 10761 44 Helen Helen NNP 40436 10761 45 -- -- : 40436 10761 46 or or CC 40436 10761 47 to to IN 40436 10761 48 favourites favourite NNS 40436 10761 49 of of IN 40436 10761 50 the the DT 40436 10761 51 Gods Gods NNPS 40436 10761 52 like like IN 40436 10761 53 Ganymêdes ganymêde NNS 40436 10761 54 or or CC 40436 10761 55 Pelops[111]--Plato pelops[111]--plato JJ 40436 10761 56 claims claim NNS 40436 10761 57 that that IN 40436 10761 58 supreme supreme NNP 40436 10761 59 distinction distinction NNP 40436 10761 60 for for IN 40436 10761 61 the the DT 40436 10761 62 departed depart VBN 40436 10761 63 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 10761 64 . . . 40436 10762 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10762 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10762 3 109 109 CD 40436 10762 4 : : : 40436 10762 5 Wyttenbach Wyttenbach NNP 40436 10762 6 has have VBZ 40436 10762 7 annexed annex VBN 40436 10762 8 to to IN 40436 10762 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10762 10 edition edition NN 40436 10762 11 of of IN 40436 10762 12 the the DT 40436 10762 13 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10762 14 an an DT 40436 10762 15 instructive instructive JJ 40436 10762 16 review review NN 40436 10762 17 of of IN 40436 10762 18 the the DT 40436 10762 19 argumentation argumentation NN 40436 10762 20 contained contain VBN 40436 10762 21 in in IN 40436 10762 22 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10762 23 respecting respect VBG 40436 10762 24 the the DT 40436 10762 25 Immortality immortality NN 40436 10762 26 of of IN 40436 10762 27 the the DT 40436 10762 28 soul soul NN 40436 10762 29 . . . 40436 10763 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10763 2 observes observe VBZ 40436 10763 3 justly--"Videamus justly--"Videamus NNP 40436 10763 4 jam jam NNP 40436 10763 5 de de NNP 40436 10763 6 Phædone Phædone NNP 40436 10763 7 , , , 40436 10763 8 qui qui NNP 40436 10763 9 ab ab NNP 40436 10763 10 omni omni NNP 40436 10763 11 antiquitate antiquitate NNP 40436 10763 12 is be VBZ 40436 10763 13 habitus habitus NN 40436 10763 14 est est NNP 40436 10763 15 liber liber NNP 40436 10763 16 , , , 40436 10763 17 in in IN 40436 10763 18 quo quo NNP 40436 10763 19 rationes ratione NNS 40436 10763 20 immortalitatis immortalitatis NN 40436 10763 21 animarum animarum NN 40436 10763 22 gravissimé gravissimé VBZ 40436 10763 23 luculentissiméque luculentissiméque NNP 40436 10763 24 exposita exposita NNP 40436 10763 25 essent essent NNP 40436 10763 26 . . . 40436 10764 1 Quæ Quæ NNP 40436 10764 2 quidem quidem VB 40436 10764 3 libro libro NNP 40436 10764 4 laus laus NNP 40436 10764 5 et et NNP 40436 10764 6 auctoritas auctoritas NNP 40436 10764 7 conciliata conciliata NNP 40436 10764 8 est est NNP 40436 10764 9 , , , 40436 10764 10 non non NNP 40436 10764 11 tam tam NNP 40436 10764 12 firmitate firmitate NNP 40436 10764 13 argumentorum argumentorum NNP 40436 10764 14 , , , 40436 10764 15 quam quam NNP 40436 10764 16 eloquentiâ eloquentiâ VBD 40436 10764 17 Platonis Platonis NNP 40436 10764 18 , , , 40436 10764 19 " " '' 40436 10764 20 & & CC 40436 10764 21 c. c. NNP 40436 10764 22 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10764 23 Disputat disputat NN 40436 10764 24 . . . 40436 10765 1 De De NNP 40436 10765 2 Placit Placit NNP 40436 10765 3 . . . 40436 10766 1 Immort immort NN 40436 10766 2 . . . 40436 10767 1 Anim Anim NNP 40436 10767 2 . . . 40436 10768 1 p. p. NN 40436 10768 2 10 10 CD 40436 10768 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10768 4 . . . 40436 10769 1 The the DT 40436 10769 2 same same JJ 40436 10769 3 feeling feeling NN 40436 10769 4 , , , 40436 10769 5 substantially substantially RB 40436 10769 6 , , , 40436 10769 7 is be VBZ 40436 10769 8 expressed express VBN 40436 10769 9 by by IN 40436 10769 10 one one CD 40436 10769 11 of of IN 40436 10769 12 the the DT 40436 10769 13 disputants disputant NNS 40436 10769 14 in in IN 40436 10769 15 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 10769 16 's 's POS 40436 10769 17 Tusculan Tusculan NNP 40436 10769 18 Disputations Disputations NNPS 40436 10769 19 , , , 40436 10769 20 who who WP 40436 10769 21 states state VBZ 40436 10769 22 that that IN 40436 10769 23 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10769 24 assented assent VBD 40436 10769 25 to to IN 40436 10769 26 the the DT 40436 10769 27 reasoning reasoning NN 40436 10769 28 while while IN 40436 10769 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10769 30 was be VBD 40436 10769 31 reading read VBG 40436 10769 32 the the DT 40436 10769 33 dialogue dialogue NN 40436 10769 34 , , , 40436 10769 35 but but CC 40436 10769 36 that that IN 40436 10769 37 as as RB 40436 10769 38 soon soon RB 40436 10769 39 as as IN 40436 10769 40 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10769 41 had have VBD 40436 10769 42 laid lay VBN 40436 10769 43 down down RP 40436 10769 44 the the DT 40436 10769 45 book book NN 40436 10769 46 , , , 40436 10769 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10769 48 assent assent NN 40436 10769 49 all all DT 40436 10769 50 slipped slip VBD 40436 10769 51 away away RB 40436 10769 52 from from IN 40436 10769 53 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10769 54 . . . 40436 10770 1 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10770 2 have have VBP 40436 10770 3 already already RB 40436 10770 4 mentioned mention VBN 40436 10770 5 that that IN 40436 10770 6 Panætius Panætius NNP 40436 10770 7 , , , 40436 10770 8 an an DT 40436 10770 9 extreme extreme JJ 40436 10770 10 admirer admirer NN 40436 10770 11 of of IN 40436 10770 12 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10770 13 on on IN 40436 10770 14 most most JJS 40436 10770 15 points point NNS 40436 10770 16 , , , 40436 10770 17 dissented dissent VBN 40436 10770 18 from from IN 40436 10770 19 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10770 20 about about IN 40436 10770 21 the the DT 40436 10770 22 immortality immortality NN 40436 10770 23 of of IN 40436 10770 24 the the DT 40436 10770 25 soul soul NN 40436 10770 26 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10770 27 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 10770 28 , , , 40436 10770 29 Tusc tusc JJ 40436 10770 30 . . . 40436 10771 1 Disp disp RB 40436 10771 2 . . . 40436 10772 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10773 1 11 11 CD 40436 10773 2 , , , 40436 10773 3 24 24 CD 40436 10773 4 - - HYPH 40436 10773 5 -i -i : 40436 10773 6 . . . 40436 10774 1 32 32 CD 40436 10774 2 , , , 40436 10774 3 79 79 CD 40436 10774 4 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10774 5 , , , 40436 10774 6 and and CC 40436 10774 7 declared declare VBD 40436 10774 8 the the DT 40436 10774 9 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10774 10 to to TO 40436 10774 11 be be VB 40436 10774 12 spurious spurious JJ 40436 10774 13 . . . 40436 10775 1 Galen Galen NNP 40436 10775 2 also also RB 40436 10775 3 mentions mention VBZ 40436 10775 4 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10775 5 De De NNP 40436 10775 6 Format Format NNP 40436 10775 7 . . . 40436 10776 1 Foetûs Foetûs NNP 40436 10776 2 , , , 40436 10776 3 vol vol NNP 40436 10776 4 . . . 40436 10777 1 iv iv XX 40436 10777 2 . . . 40436 10778 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10778 2 . . . 40436 10779 1 700 700 CD 40436 10779 2 - - SYM 40436 10779 3 702 702 CD 40436 10779 4 . . . 40436 10780 1 Kühn Kühn NNP 40436 10780 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10780 3 that that IN 40436 10780 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10780 5 had have VBD 40436 10780 6 written write VBN 40436 10780 7 a a DT 40436 10780 8 special special JJ 40436 10780 9 treatise treatise NN 40436 10780 10 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10780 11 now now RB 40436 10780 12 lost lose VBN 40436 10780 13 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10780 14 to to TO 40436 10780 15 prove prove VB 40436 10780 16 that that IN 40436 10780 17 the the DT 40436 10780 18 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 10780 19 in in IN 40436 10780 20 the the DT 40436 10780 21 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10780 22 were be VBD 40436 10780 23 self self NN 40436 10780 24 - - HYPH 40436 10780 25 contradictory contradictory JJ 40436 10780 26 , , , 40436 10780 27 and and CC 40436 10780 28 that that IN 40436 10780 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10780 30 could could MD 40436 10780 31 not not RB 40436 10780 32 satisfy satisfy VB 40436 10780 33 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10780 34 , , , 40436 10780 35 either either CC 40436 10780 36 about about IN 40436 10780 37 the the DT 40436 10780 38 essence essence NN 40436 10780 39 of of IN 40436 10780 40 the the DT 40436 10780 41 soul soul NN 40436 10780 42 , , , 40436 10780 43 or or CC 40436 10780 44 whether whether IN 40436 10780 45 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10780 46 was be VBD 40436 10780 47 mortal mortal JJ 40436 10780 48 or or CC 40436 10780 49 immortal immortal JJ 40436 10780 50 . . . 40436 10781 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10781 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10781 3 treatise treatise NN 40436 10781 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10781 5 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10781 6 : : : 40436 10781 7 Peri\ Peri\ NNS 40436 10781 8 Ou)si Ou)si NNS 40436 10781 9 / / SYM 40436 10781 10 as as IN 40436 10781 11 tô tô NNP 40436 10781 12 = = SYM 40436 10781 13 n n NN 40436 10781 14 phusikô phusikô NNP 40436 10781 15 = = SYM 40436 10781 16 n n CC 40436 10781 17 duna duna NNP 40436 10781 18 / / SYM 40436 10781 19 meôn]--iv meôn]--iv JJ 40436 10781 20 . . . 40436 10782 1 pp pp NNP 40436 10782 2 . . . 40436 10783 1 762 762 CD 40436 10783 2 - - HYPH 40436 10783 3 763 763 CD 40436 10783 4 - - HYPH 40436 10783 5 -and -and NN 40436 10783 6 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10783 7 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10783 8 : : : 40436 10783 9 Peri\ peri\ NN 40436 10783 10 tô tô NNP 40436 10783 11 = = NFP 40436 10783 12 n n CC 40436 10783 13 tê tê NNP 40436 10783 14 = = SYM 40436 10783 15 s s NN 40436 10783 16 Psuchê Psuchê NNP 40436 10783 17 = = SYM 40436 10783 18 s s NNP 40436 10783 19 ê)thô ê)thô NNP 40436 10783 20 = = SYM 40436 10783 21 n n NN 40436 10783 22 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10783 23 , , , 40436 10783 24 iv iv NNP 40436 10783 25 . . . 40436 10784 1 773 773 CD 40436 10784 2 . . . 40436 10785 1 In in IN 40436 10785 2 this this DT 40436 10785 3 last last JJ 40436 10785 4 passage passage NN 40436 10785 5 , , , 40436 10785 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10785 7 represents represent VBZ 40436 10785 8 the the DT 40436 10785 9 opinion opinion NN 40436 10785 10 of of IN 40436 10785 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10785 12 to to TO 40436 10785 13 be be VB 40436 10785 14 -- -- : 40436 10785 15 That that IN 40436 10785 16 the the DT 40436 10785 17 two two CD 40436 10785 18 inferior inferior JJ 40436 10785 19 souls soul NNS 40436 10785 20 , , , 40436 10785 21 the the DT 40436 10785 22 courageous courageous JJ 40436 10785 23 and and CC 40436 10785 24 the the DT 40436 10785 25 appetitive appetitive NN 40436 10785 26 , , , 40436 10785 27 are be VBP 40436 10785 28 mortal mortal JJ 40436 10785 29 , , , 40436 10785 30 in in IN 40436 10785 31 which which WDT 40436 10785 32 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10785 33 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10785 34 Galen Galen NNP 40436 10785 35 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10785 36 agrees agree VBZ 40436 10785 37 , , , 40436 10785 38 and and CC 40436 10785 39 that that IN 40436 10785 40 the the DT 40436 10785 41 rational rational JJ 40436 10785 42 soul soul NN 40436 10785 43 alone alone RB 40436 10785 44 is be VBZ 40436 10785 45 immortal immortal JJ 40436 10785 46 , , , 40436 10785 47 of of IN 40436 10785 48 which which WDT 40436 10785 49 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10785 50 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10785 51 Galen Galen NNP 40436 10785 52 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10785 53 is be VBZ 40436 10785 54 not not RB 40436 10785 55 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 10785 56 . . . 40436 10786 1 Now now RB 40436 10786 2 this this DT 40436 10786 3 view view NN 40436 10786 4 of of IN 40436 10786 5 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10786 6 's 's POS 40436 10786 7 opinion opinion NN 40436 10786 8 is be VBZ 40436 10786 9 derived derive VBN 40436 10786 10 from from IN 40436 10786 11 the the DT 40436 10786 12 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10786 13 and and CC 40436 10786 14 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10786 15 , , , 40436 10786 16 not not RB 40436 10786 17 from from IN 40436 10786 18 the the DT 40436 10786 19 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10786 20 , , , 40436 10786 21 in in IN 40436 10786 22 which which WDT 40436 10786 23 last last JJ 40436 10786 24 the the DT 40436 10786 25 triple triple JJ 40436 10786 26 soul soul NN 40436 10786 27 is be VBZ 40436 10786 28 not not RB 40436 10786 29 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 40436 10786 30 . . . 40436 10787 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10787 2 may may MD 40436 10787 3 thus thus RB 40436 10787 4 partly partly RB 40436 10787 5 understand understand VB 40436 10787 6 the the DT 40436 10787 7 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 40436 10787 8 , , , 40436 10787 9 which which WDT 40436 10787 10 Galen Galen NNP 40436 10787 11 pointed point VBD 40436 10787 12 out out RP 40436 10787 13 in in IN 40436 10787 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10787 15 lost lose VBN 40436 10787 16 Treatise Treatise NNP 40436 10787 17 , , , 40436 10787 18 in in IN 40436 10787 19 the the DT 40436 10787 20 argumentation argumentation NN 40436 10787 21 of of IN 40436 10787 22 the the DT 40436 10787 23 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10787 24 : : : 40436 10787 25 wherein wherein WRB 40436 10787 26 one one CD 40436 10787 27 of of IN 40436 10787 28 the the DT 40436 10787 29 proofs proofs NNP 40436 10787 30 presented present VBN 40436 10787 31 to to TO 40436 10787 32 establish establish VB 40436 10787 33 the the DT 40436 10787 34 immortality immortality NN 40436 10787 35 of of IN 40436 10787 36 the the DT 40436 10787 37 soul soul NN 40436 10787 38 is be VBZ 40436 10787 39 -- -- : 40436 10787 40 That that IN 40436 10787 41 the the DT 40436 10787 42 soul soul NN 40436 10787 43 is be VBZ 40436 10787 44 inseparably inseparably RB 40436 10787 45 and and CC 40436 10787 46 essentially essentially RB 40436 10787 47 identified identify VBN 40436 10787 48 with with IN 40436 10787 49 life life NN 40436 10787 50 , , , 40436 10787 51 and and CC 40436 10787 52 can can MD 40436 10787 53 not not RB 40436 10787 54 admit admit VB 40436 10787 55 death death NN 40436 10787 56 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10787 57 p. p. NN 40436 10787 58 105 105 CD 40436 10787 59 D d NN 40436 10787 60 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10787 61 . . . 40436 10788 1 This this DT 40436 10788 2 argument argument NN 40436 10788 3 , , , 40436 10788 4 if if IN 40436 10788 5 good good JJ 40436 10788 6 at at RB 40436 10788 7 all all RB 40436 10788 8 , , , 40436 10788 9 is be VBZ 40436 10788 10 just just RB 40436 10788 11 as as RB 40436 10788 12 good good JJ 40436 10788 13 to to TO 40436 10788 14 prove prove VB 40436 10788 15 the the DT 40436 10788 16 immortality immortality NN 40436 10788 17 of of IN 40436 10788 18 the the DT 40436 10788 19 two two CD 40436 10788 20 inferior inferior JJ 40436 10788 21 souls soul NNS 40436 10788 22 , , , 40436 10788 23 as as IN 40436 10788 24 of of IN 40436 10788 25 the the DT 40436 10788 26 superior superior JJ 40436 10788 27 and and CC 40436 10788 28 rational rational JJ 40436 10788 29 soul soul NN 40436 10788 30 . . . 40436 10789 1 Galen Galen NNP 40436 10789 2 might may MD 40436 10789 3 therefore therefore RB 40436 10789 4 remark remark VB 40436 10789 5 that that IN 40436 10789 6 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10789 7 did do VBD 40436 10789 8 not not RB 40436 10789 9 consist consist VB 40436 10789 10 with with IN 40436 10789 11 the the DT 40436 10789 12 conclusion conclusion NN 40436 10789 13 which which WDT 40436 10789 14 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10789 15 drew draw VBD 40436 10789 16 from from IN 40436 10789 17 the the DT 40436 10789 18 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10789 19 and and CC 40436 10789 20 the the DT 40436 10789 21 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10789 22 . . . 40436 10789 23 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10790 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10790 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10790 3 110 110 CD 40436 10790 4 : : : 40436 10790 5 Wyttenbach Wyttenbach NNP 40436 10790 6 , , , 40436 10790 7 l. l. NNP 40436 10790 8 c. c. NNP 40436 10790 9 p. p. NNP 40436 10790 10 19 19 CD 40436 10790 11 . . . 40436 10791 1 " " `` 40436 10791 2 Vidimus Vidimus NNP 40436 10791 3 de de NNP 40436 10791 4 philosophâ philosophâ NNP 40436 10791 5 hujus hujus NNP 40436 10791 6 loci loci NNP 40436 10791 7 parte parte NNP 40436 10791 8 , , , 40436 10791 9 quâ quâ NNP 40436 10791 10 demonstratur demonstratur NNP 40436 10791 11 , , , 40436 10791 12 Animos Animos NNP 40436 10791 13 esse esse NN 40436 10791 14 immortales immortale NNS 40436 10791 15 . . . 40436 10792 1 Altera Altera NNP 40436 10792 2 pars par NNS 40436 10792 3 , , , 40436 10792 4 quâ quâ NNP 40436 10792 5 ostenditur ostenditur NNP 40436 10792 6 , , , 40436 10792 7 qualis qualis NNP 40436 10792 8 sit sit VB 40436 10792 9 ille ille NNP 40436 10792 10 post post NNP 40436 10792 11 hanc hanc NNP 40436 10792 12 vitam vitam NNP 40436 10792 13 status status NNP 40436 10792 14 , , , 40436 10792 15 fabulosé fabulosé NNP 40436 10792 16 et et NN 40436 10792 17 poeticé poeticé NN 40436 10792 18 à à DT 40436 10792 19 Platone Platone NNP 40436 10792 20 tractata tractata NN 40436 10792 21 est est NNP 40436 10792 22 . . . 40436 10792 23 " " '' 40436 10793 1 & & CC 40436 10793 2 c. c. NNP 40436 10793 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10793 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10793 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10793 6 111 111 CD 40436 10793 7 : : : 40436 10793 8 Skolion Skolion NNP 40436 10793 9 of of IN 40436 10793 10 Kallistratus Kallistratus NNP 40436 10793 11 , , , 40436 10793 12 Antholog Antholog NNP 40436 10793 13 . . . 40436 10794 1 Græc Græc NNP 40436 10794 2 . . . 40436 10795 1 p. p. NN 40436 10795 2 155 155 CD 40436 10795 3 . . . 40436 10796 1 Isokrates isokrate NNS 40436 10796 2 , , , 40436 10796 3 Encomium Encomium NNP 40436 10796 4 Helenæ Helenæ NNP 40436 10796 5 , , , 40436 10796 6 Or or CC 40436 10796 7 . . . 40436 10797 1 x. x. NNP 40436 10797 2 s. s. NNP 40436 10797 3 70 70 CD 40436 10797 4 - - SYM 40436 10797 5 72 72 CD 40436 10797 6 . . . 40436 10798 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10798 2 the the DT 40436 10798 3 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10798 4 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10798 5 : : : 40436 10798 6 Ne Ne NNP 40436 10798 7 / / SYM 40436 10798 8 kuia kuia NN 40436 10798 9 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10798 10 of of IN 40436 10798 11 the the DT 40436 10798 12 Odyssey Odyssey NNP 40436 10798 13 and and CC 40436 10798 14 that that DT 40436 10798 15 of of IN 40436 10798 16 the the DT 40436 10798 17 Æneid Æneid NNP 40436 10798 18 , , , 40436 10798 19 respecting respect VBG 40436 10798 20 the the DT 40436 10798 21 heroes-- heroes-- JJ 40436 10798 22 " " `` 40436 10798 23 Quæ Quæ NNP 40436 10798 24 gratia gratia NN 40436 10798 25 currûm currûm NN 40436 10798 26 Armorumque Armorumque NNP 40436 10798 27 fuit fuit NN 40436 10798 28 vivis vivis NN 40436 10798 29 , , , 40436 10798 30 quæ quæ NNP 40436 10798 31 cura cura NNP 40436 10798 32 nitentes nitente NNS 40436 10798 33 Pascere Pascere NNP 40436 10798 34 equos equos NN 40436 10798 35 , , , 40436 10798 36 eadem eadem NN 40436 10798 37 sequitur sequitur NNP 40436 10798 38 tellure tellure NN 40436 10798 39 repostos reposto NNS 40436 10798 40 . . . 40436 10798 41 " " '' 40436 10799 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10799 2 Æn æn UH 40436 10799 3 . . . 40436 10800 1 vi vi NNP 40436 10800 2 . . . 40436 10801 1 653 653 CD 40436 10801 2 - - SYM 40436 10801 3 5 5 CD 40436 10801 4 . . . 40436 10801 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10801 6 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10802 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10802 2 Side side NN 40436 10802 3 - - HYPH 40436 10802 4 note note NN 40436 10802 5 : : : 40436 10802 6 The the DT 40436 10802 7 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 10802 8 will will MD 40436 10802 9 enjoy enjoy VB 40436 10802 10 an an DT 40436 10802 11 existence existence NN 40436 10802 12 of of IN 40436 10802 13 pure pure JJ 40436 10802 14 soul soul NN 40436 10802 15 unattached unattache VBD 40436 10802 16 to to IN 40436 10802 17 any any DT 40436 10802 18 body body NN 40436 10802 19 . . . 40436 10802 20 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10803 1 The the DT 40436 10803 2 Philosopher Philosopher NNP 40436 10803 3 , , , 40436 10803 4 as as IN 40436 10803 5 a a DT 40436 10803 6 recompense recompense NN 40436 10803 7 for for IN 40436 10803 8 having have VBG 40436 10803 9 detached detach VBN 40436 10803 10 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10803 11 during during IN 40436 10803 12 life life NN 40436 10803 13 as as RB 40436 10803 14 much much RB 40436 10803 15 as as IN 40436 10803 16 possible possible JJ 40436 10803 17 from from IN 40436 10803 18 the the DT 40436 10803 19 body body NN 40436 10803 20 and and CC 40436 10803 21 all all DT 40436 10803 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10803 23 functions function NNS 40436 10803 24 , , , 40436 10803 25 will will MD 40436 10803 26 be be VB 40436 10803 27 admitted admit VBN 40436 10803 28 after after IN 40436 10803 29 death death NN 40436 10803 30 to to TO 40436 10803 31 existence existence VB 40436 10803 32 as as IN 40436 10803 33 a a DT 40436 10803 34 soul soul NN 40436 10803 35 pure pure JJ 40436 10803 36 and and CC 40436 10803 37 simple simple JJ 40436 10803 38 , , , 40436 10803 39 unattached unattache VBD 40436 10803 40 to to IN 40436 10803 41 any any DT 40436 10803 42 body body NN 40436 10803 43 . . . 40436 10804 1 The the DT 40436 10804 2 souls soul NNS 40436 10804 3 of of IN 40436 10804 4 all all DT 40436 10804 5 other other JJ 40436 10804 6 persons person NNS 40436 10804 7 , , , 40436 10804 8 dying die VBG 40436 10804 9 with with IN 40436 10804 10 more more RBR 40436 10804 11 or or CC 40436 10804 12 less less JJR 40436 10804 13 of of IN 40436 10804 14 the the DT 40436 10804 15 taint taint NN 40436 10804 16 of of IN 40436 10804 17 the the DT 40436 10804 18 body body NN 40436 10804 19 attached attach VBN 40436 10804 20 to to IN 40436 10804 21 each each DT 40436 10804 22 of of IN 40436 10804 23 them,[112 them,[112 NN 40436 10804 24 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10804 25 and and CC 40436 10804 26 for for IN 40436 10804 27 that that DT 40436 10804 28 reason reason NN 40436 10804 29 haunting haunt VBG 40436 10804 30 the the DT 40436 10804 31 tombs tomb NNS 40436 10804 32 in in IN 40436 10804 33 which which WDT 40436 10804 34 the the DT 40436 10804 35 bodies body NNS 40436 10804 36 are be VBP 40436 10804 37 buried bury VBN 40436 10804 38 , , , 40436 10804 39 so so IN 40436 10804 40 as as IN 40436 10804 41 to to TO 40436 10804 42 become become VB 40436 10804 43 visible visible JJ 40436 10804 44 there there RB 40436 10804 45 as as IN 40436 10804 46 ghosts ghost NNS 40436 10804 47 -- -- : 40436 10804 48 are be VBP 40436 10804 49 made make VBN 40436 10804 50 subject subject JJ 40436 10804 51 , , , 40436 10804 52 in in IN 40436 10804 53 the the DT 40436 10804 54 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 10804 55 Hades Hades NNPS 40436 10804 56 , , , 40436 10804 57 to to TO 40436 10804 58 penalty penalty NN 40436 10804 59 and and CC 40436 10804 60 purification purification NN 40436 10804 61 suitable suitable JJ 40436 10804 62 to to IN 40436 10804 63 the the DT 40436 10804 64 respective respective JJ 40436 10804 65 condition condition NN 40436 10804 66 of of IN 40436 10804 67 each each DT 40436 10804 68 ; ; : 40436 10804 69 after after IN 40436 10804 70 which which WDT 40436 10804 71 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10804 72 become become VBP 40436 10804 73 attached attach VBN 40436 10804 74 to to IN 40436 10804 75 new new JJ 40436 10804 76 bodies body NNS 40436 10804 77 , , , 40436 10804 78 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 10804 79 of of IN 40436 10804 80 men man NNS 40436 10804 81 , , , 40436 10804 82 sometimes sometimes RB 40436 10804 83 of of IN 40436 10804 84 other other JJ 40436 10804 85 animals animal NNS 40436 10804 86 . . . 40436 10805 1 Of of IN 40436 10805 2 this this DT 40436 10805 3 distributive distributive JJ 40436 10805 4 scheme scheme NN 40436 10805 5 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10805 6 is be VBZ 40436 10805 7 not not RB 40436 10805 8 possible possible JJ 40436 10805 9 to to TO 40436 10805 10 frame frame VB 40436 10805 11 any any DT 40436 10805 12 clear clear JJ 40436 10805 13 idea idea NN 40436 10805 14 , , , 40436 10805 15 nor nor CC 40436 10805 16 is be VBZ 40436 10805 17 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10805 18 consistent consistent JJ 40436 10805 19 with with IN 40436 10805 20 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10805 21 except except IN 40436 10805 22 in in IN 40436 10805 23 a a DT 40436 10805 24 few few JJ 40436 10805 25 material material NN 40436 10805 26 features feature NNS 40436 10805 27 . . . 40436 10806 1 But but CC 40436 10806 2 one one CD 40436 10806 3 feature feature NN 40436 10806 4 there there EX 40436 10806 5 is be VBZ 40436 10806 6 in in IN 40436 10806 7 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10806 8 which which WDT 40436 10806 9 stands stand VBZ 40436 10806 10 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 40436 10806 11 -- -- : 40436 10806 12 the the DT 40436 10806 13 belief belief NN 40436 10806 14 in in IN 40436 10806 15 the the DT 40436 10806 16 metempsychosis metempsychosis NN 40436 10806 17 , , , 40436 10806 18 or or CC 40436 10806 19 transfer transfer NN 40436 10806 20 of of IN 40436 10806 21 the the DT 40436 10806 22 same same JJ 40436 10806 23 soul soul NN 40436 10806 24 from from IN 40436 10806 25 one one CD 40436 10806 26 animal animal NN 40436 10806 27 body body NN 40436 10806 28 to to IN 40436 10806 29 another another DT 40436 10806 30 : : : 40436 10806 31 a a DT 40436 10806 32 belief belief NN 40436 10806 33 very very RB 40436 10806 34 widely widely RB 40436 10806 35 diffused diffuse VBN 40436 10806 36 throughout throughout IN 40436 10806 37 the the DT 40436 10806 38 ancient ancient JJ 40436 10806 39 world world NN 40436 10806 40 , , , 40436 10806 41 associated associate VBN 40436 10806 42 with with IN 40436 10806 43 the the DT 40436 10806 44 immortality immortality NN 40436 10806 45 of of IN 40436 10806 46 the the DT 40436 10806 47 soul soul NN 40436 10806 48 , , , 40436 10806 49 pervading pervade VBG 40436 10806 50 the the DT 40436 10806 51 Orphic orphic JJ 40436 10806 52 and and CC 40436 10806 53 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40436 10806 54 creeds creed NNS 40436 10806 55 , , , 40436 10806 56 and and CC 40436 10806 57 having have VBG 40436 10806 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10806 59 root root NN 40436 10806 60 in in IN 40436 10806 61 the the DT 40436 10806 62 Egyptian egyptian JJ 40436 10806 63 and and CC 40436 10806 64 Oriental oriental JJ 40436 10806 65 religions religion NNS 40436 10806 66 . . . 40436 10807 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10807 2 113 113 CD 40436 10807 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10807 4 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10807 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10807 6 112 112 CD 40436 10807 7 : : : 40436 10807 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10807 9 , , , 40436 10807 10 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10807 11 , , , 40436 10807 12 p. p. NN 40436 10807 13 81 81 CD 40436 10807 14 C C NNP 40436 10807 15 - - HYPH 40436 10807 16 D. D. NNP 40436 10807 17 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10807 18 Greek Greek NNP 40436 10807 19 : : : 40436 10807 20 o(\ o(\ NNP 40436 10807 21 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 10807 22 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10807 23 e)/chousa e)/chousa NNP 40436 10807 24 ê ê NNP 40436 10807 25 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10807 26 toiau toiau NNP 40436 10807 27 / / SYM 40436 10807 28 tê tê NNP 40436 10807 29 psuchê\ psuchê\ NNP 40436 10807 30 baru baru NNP 40436 10807 31 / / SYM 40436 10807 32 netai netai NNP 40436 10807 33 te te NNP 40436 10807 34 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10807 35 e(/lketai e(/lketai NNP 40436 10807 36 pa pa NNP 40436 10807 37 / / SYM 40436 10807 38 lin lin NNP 40436 10807 39 ei)s ei) VBZ 40436 10807 40 to\n to\n NNP 40436 10807 41 o(rato\n o(rato\n NNP 40436 10807 42 to to IN 40436 10807 43 / / SYM 40436 10807 44 pon pon NNP 40436 10807 45 , , , 40436 10807 46 pho pho NNP 40436 10807 47 / / SYM 40436 10807 48 bô| bô| NNP 40436 10807 49 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10807 50 a)eidou a)eidou NNP 40436 10807 51 = = SYM 40436 10807 52 s s NNP 40436 10807 53 te te NNP 40436 10807 54 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10807 55 A(/idou A(/idou NNP 40436 10807 56 , , , 40436 10807 57 ô(/sper ô(/sper NNP 40436 10807 58 le le NNP 40436 10807 59 / / SYM 40436 10807 60 getai getai NNP 40436 10807 61 , , , 40436 10807 62 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 10807 63 ta\ ta\ NNP 40436 10807 64 mnê mnê NNP 40436 10807 65 / / SYM 40436 10807 66 mata/ mata/ NNP 40436 10807 67 te te NNP 40436 10807 68 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10807 69 tou\s tou\s NNP 40436 10807 70 ta ta NNP 40436 10807 71 / / SYM 40436 10807 72 phous phous JJ 40436 10807 73 kalindoume kalindoume NN 40436 10807 74 / / SYM 40436 10807 75 nê nê NNP 40436 10807 76 ; ; : 40436 10807 77 peri\ peri\ NNP 40436 10807 78 a(\ a(\ NNP 40436 10807 79 dê\ dê\ NNP 40436 10807 80 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10807 81 ô)/phthê ô)/phthê NNP 40436 10807 82 a(/tta a(/tta NNP 40436 10807 83 psuchô psuchô NNP 40436 10807 84 = = SYM 40436 10807 85 n n CC 40436 10807 86 skioeidê= skioeidê= NNP 40436 10807 87 phanta phanta NNP 40436 10807 88 / / SYM 40436 10807 89 smata smata NNP 40436 10807 90 oi(=a oi(=a NNP 40436 10807 91 pare pare NNP 40436 10807 92 / / SYM 40436 10807 93 chontai chontai NNP 40436 10807 94 ai ai NNP 40436 10807 95 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10807 96 toiau toiau NNP 40436 10807 97 = = SYM 40436 10807 98 tai tai NNP 40436 10807 99 psuchai\ psuchai\ NNP 40436 10807 100 ei)/dôla ei)/dôla NNP 40436 10807 101 , , , 40436 10807 102 ai ai VBP 40436 10807 103 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10807 104 mê\ mê\ NNP 40436 10807 105 katharô katharô NNP 40436 10807 106 = = SYM 40436 10807 107 s s NNP 40436 10807 108 a)poluthei a)poluthei NNP 40436 10807 109 = = SYM 40436 10807 110 sai sai NNP 40436 10807 111 , , , 40436 10807 112 a)lla\ a)lla\ `` 40436 10807 113 _ _ NNP 40436 10807 114 tou= tou= NNP 40436 10807 115 o(ratou= o(ratou= NNP 40436 10807 116 mete mete NN 40436 10807 117 / / SYM 40436 10807 118 chousai chousai NNS 40436 10807 119 , , , 40436 10807 120 dio\ dio\ NNP 40436 10807 121 kai\ kai\ NNP 40436 10807 122 o(rô o(rô NNP 40436 10807 123 = = SYM 40436 10807 124 ntai ntai NNP 40436 10807 125 _ _ NNP 40436 10807 126 . . . 40436 10807 127 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10808 1 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 40436 10808 2 -- -- : 40436 10808 3 in in IN 40436 10808 4 replying reply VBG 40436 10808 5 to to IN 40436 10808 6 the the DT 40436 10808 7 arguments argument NNS 40436 10808 8 of of IN 40436 10808 9 Demokritus Demokritus NNP 40436 10808 10 , , , 40436 10808 11 Epikurus Epikurus NNP 40436 10808 12 , , , 40436 10808 13 and and CC 40436 10808 14 Dikæarchus dikæarchus VB 40436 10808 15 against against IN 40436 10808 16 the the DT 40436 10808 17 immortality immortality NN 40436 10808 18 of of IN 40436 10808 19 the the DT 40436 10808 20 soul soul NN 40436 10808 21 -- -- : 40436 10808 22 reminded remind VBD 40436 10808 23 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10808 24 that that IN 40436 10808 25 any any DT 40436 10808 26 _ _ NNP 40436 10808 27 Magus Magus NNP 40436 10808 28 _ _ NNP 40436 10808 29 would would MD 40436 10808 30 produce produce VB 40436 10808 31 visible visible JJ 40436 10808 32 evidence evidence NN 40436 10808 33 to to TO 40436 10808 34 refute refute VB 40436 10808 35 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10808 36 ; ; : 40436 10808 37 by by IN 40436 10808 38 calling call VBG 40436 10808 39 up up RP 40436 10808 40 before before IN 40436 10808 41 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10808 42 the the DT 40436 10808 43 soul soul NN 40436 10808 44 of of IN 40436 10808 45 any any DT 40436 10808 46 deceased deceased JJ 40436 10808 47 person person NN 40436 10808 48 to to TO 40436 10808 49 give give VB 40436 10808 50 information information NN 40436 10808 51 and and CC 40436 10808 52 predict predict VB 40436 10808 53 the the DT 40436 10808 54 future--"qui future--"qui JJ 40436 10808 55 profecto profecto NN 40436 10808 56 non non AFX 40436 10808 57 auderent auderent NNP 40436 10808 58 de de NNP 40436 10808 59 animarum animarum NNP 40436 10808 60 interitu interitu NNP 40436 10808 61 mago mago NNP 40436 10808 62 praesente praesente NNP 40436 10808 63 disserere disserere RB 40436 10808 64 , , , 40436 10808 65 qui qui NNP 40436 10808 66 sciret sciret JJ 40436 10808 67 certis certis NN 40436 10808 68 carminibus carminibus NNP 40436 10808 69 cieri cieri NNP 40436 10808 70 ab ab NNP 40436 10808 71 infernis infernis NNP 40436 10808 72 animas animas NNPS 40436 10808 73 et et NNP 40436 10808 74 adesse adesse NNP 40436 10808 75 et et NNP 40436 10808 76 præbere præbere NNP 40436 10808 77 se se NNP 40436 10808 78 videndas videndas NNP 40436 10808 79 et et NNP 40436 10808 80 loqui loqui NNP 40436 10808 81 et et NNP 40436 10808 82 futura futura NNP 40436 10808 83 prædicere prædicere NNP 40436 10808 84 : : : 40436 10808 85 et et NN 40436 10808 86 si si NN 40436 10808 87 auderent auderent NN 40436 10808 88 , , , 40436 10808 89 re re VBD 40436 10808 90 ipsâ ipsâ NNP 40436 10808 91 et et NNP 40436 10808 92 documentis documentis NNP 40436 10808 93 præsentibus præsentibus NNP 40436 10808 94 vincerentur vincerentur NNP 40436 10808 95 " " '' 40436 10808 96 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10808 97 Lactant lactant JJ 40436 10808 98 . . . 40436 10809 1 Inst inst RB 40436 10809 2 . . . 40436 10810 1 vii vii NN 40436 10810 2 . . . 40436 10811 1 13 13 CD 40436 10811 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10811 3 . . . 40436 10812 1 See see VB 40436 10812 2 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 10812 3 , , , 40436 10812 4 Tusc tusc JJ 40436 10812 5 . . . 40436 10813 1 Disp disp RB 40436 10813 2 . . . 40436 10814 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10815 1 31 31 CD 40436 10815 2 . . . 40436 10815 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10816 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10816 2 Footnote footnote NN 40436 10816 3 113 113 CD 40436 10816 4 : : : 40436 10816 5 Compare compare VB 40436 10816 6 the the DT 40436 10816 7 closing closing NN 40436 10816 8 paragraph paragraph NN 40436 10816 9 of of IN 40436 10816 10 the the DT 40436 10816 11 Platonic Platonic NNP 40436 10816 12 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10816 13 : : : 40436 10816 14 Virgil Virgil NNP 40436 10816 15 , , , 40436 10816 16 Æneid Æneid NNP 40436 10816 17 vi vi NNP 40436 10816 18 . . . 40436 10817 1 713 713 CD 40436 10817 2 , , , 40436 10817 3 Herodot Herodot NNP 40436 10817 4 . . . 40436 10818 1 ii ii LS 40436 10818 2 . . . 40436 10819 1 123 123 CD 40436 10819 2 , , , 40436 10819 3 Pausanias Pausanias NNP 40436 10819 4 , , , 40436 10819 5 iv iv NNP 40436 10819 6 . . . 40436 10820 1 32 32 CD 40436 10820 2 , , , 40436 10820 3 4 4 CD 40436 10820 4 , , , 40436 10820 5 Sextus Sextus NNP 40436 10820 6 Empiric Empiric NNP 40436 10820 7 . . . 40436 10821 1 adv adv NNP 40436 10821 2 . . . 40436 10822 1 Math math NN 40436 10822 2 . . . 40436 10823 1 ix ix IN 40436 10823 2 . . . 40436 10824 1 127 127 CD 40436 10824 2 , , , 40436 10824 3 with with IN 40436 10824 4 the the DT 40436 10824 5 citation citation NN 40436 10824 6 from from IN 40436 10824 7 Empedokles:-- Empedokles:-- NNP 40436 10824 8 " " `` 40436 10824 9 Tum tum NN 40436 10824 10 pater pater NN 40436 10824 11 Anchises anchise NNS 40436 10824 12 : : : 40436 10824 13 ' ' '' 40436 10824 14 Animæ Animæ NNP 40436 10824 15 quibus quibus NNP 40436 10824 16 altera altera NNP 40436 10824 17 fato fato NN 40436 10824 18 Corpora Corpora NNP 40436 10824 19 debentur debentur NNP 40436 10824 20 , , , 40436 10824 21 Lethæi Lethæi NNP 40436 10824 22 ad ad NN 40436 10824 23 fluminis fluminis NN 40436 10824 24 undam undam NNP 40436 10824 25 Securos Securos NNP 40436 10824 26 latices latice VBZ 40436 10824 27 et et NNP 40436 10824 28 longa longa NNP 40436 10824 29 oblivia oblivia NNP 40436 10824 30 potant potant NNP 40436 10824 31 ' ' '' 40436 10824 32 . . . 40436 10824 33 " " '' 40436 10825 1 The the DT 40436 10825 2 general general JJ 40436 10825 3 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10825 4 , , , 40436 10825 5 upon upon IN 40436 10825 6 which which WDT 40436 10825 7 the the DT 40436 10825 8 Metempsychosis Metempsychosis NNP 40436 10825 9 rests rest NNS 40436 10825 10 , , , 40436 10825 11 is be VBZ 40436 10825 12 set set VBN 40436 10825 13 forth forth RP 40436 10825 14 by by IN 40436 10825 15 Virgil Virgil NNP 40436 10825 16 in in IN 40436 10825 17 the the DT 40436 10825 18 fine fine JJ 40436 10825 19 lines line NNS 40436 10825 20 which which WDT 40436 10825 21 follow follow VBP 40436 10825 22 , , , 40436 10825 23 723 723 CD 40436 10825 24 - - SYM 40436 10825 25 751 751 CD 40436 10825 26 ; ; : 40436 10825 27 compare compare VBP 40436 10825 28 Georgic Georgic NNP 40436 10825 29 iv iv NNP 40436 10825 30 . . . 40436 10826 1 218 218 CD 40436 10826 2 . . . 40436 10827 1 The the DT 40436 10827 2 souls soul NNS 40436 10827 3 of of IN 40436 10827 4 men man NNS 40436 10827 5 , , , 40436 10827 6 beasts beast NNS 40436 10827 7 , , , 40436 10827 8 birds bird NNS 40436 10827 9 , , , 40436 10827 10 and and CC 40436 10827 11 fishes fish NNS 40436 10827 12 , , , 40436 10827 13 are be VBP 40436 10827 14 all all DT 40436 10827 15 of of IN 40436 10827 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10827 17 detached detach VBN 40436 10827 18 fragments fragment NNS 40436 10827 19 or or CC 40436 10827 20 portions portion NNS 40436 10827 21 from from IN 40436 10827 22 the the DT 40436 10827 23 universal universal JJ 40436 10827 24 soul soul NN 40436 10827 25 , , , 40436 10827 26 mind mind NN 40436 10827 27 , , , 40436 10827 28 or or CC 40436 10827 29 life life NN 40436 10827 30 , , , 40436 10827 31 ætherial ætherial JJ 40436 10827 32 or or CC 40436 10827 33 igneous igneous JJ 40436 10827 34 , , , 40436 10827 35 which which WDT 40436 10827 36 pervades pervade VBZ 40436 10827 37 the the DT 40436 10827 38 whole whole JJ 40436 10827 39 Kosmos Kosmos NNP 40436 10827 40 . . . 40436 10828 1 The the DT 40436 10828 2 soul soul NN 40436 10828 3 of of IN 40436 10828 4 each each DT 40436 10828 5 individual individual NN 40436 10828 6 thus thus RB 40436 10828 7 detached detach VBD 40436 10828 8 to to TO 40436 10828 9 be be VB 40436 10828 10 conjoined conjoin VBN 40436 10828 11 with with IN 40436 10828 12 a a DT 40436 10828 13 distinct distinct JJ 40436 10828 14 body body NN 40436 10828 15 , , , 40436 10828 16 becomes become VBZ 40436 10828 17 tainted taint VBN 40436 10828 18 by by IN 40436 10828 19 such such JJ 40436 10828 20 communion communion NN 40436 10828 21 ; ; : 40436 10828 22 after after IN 40436 10828 23 death death NN 40436 10828 24 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10828 25 is be VBZ 40436 10828 26 purified purify VBN 40436 10828 27 by by IN 40436 10828 28 penalties penalty NNS 40436 10828 29 , , , 40436 10828 30 measured measure VBN 40436 10828 31 according accord VBG 40436 10828 32 to to IN 40436 10828 33 the the DT 40436 10828 34 greater great JJR 40436 10828 35 or or CC 40436 10828 36 less less RBR 40436 10828 37 taint taint JJ 40436 10828 38 , , , 40436 10828 39 and and CC 40436 10828 40 becomes become VBZ 40436 10828 41 then then RB 40436 10828 42 fit fit JJ 40436 10828 43 to to TO 40436 10828 44 be be VB 40436 10828 45 attached attach VBN 40436 10828 46 to to IN 40436 10828 47 a a DT 40436 10828 48 new new JJ 40436 10828 49 body body NN 40436 10828 50 , , , 40436 10828 51 yet yet CC 40436 10828 52 not not RB 40436 10828 53 until until IN 40436 10828 54 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10828 55 has have VBZ 40436 10828 56 drunk drink VBN 40436 10828 57 the the DT 40436 10828 58 water water NN 40436 10828 59 of of IN 40436 10828 60 Lêthê Lêthê NNP 40436 10828 61 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10828 62 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10828 63 , , , 40436 10828 64 Philêbus Philêbus NNP 40436 10828 65 , , , 40436 10828 66 p. p. NN 40436 10828 67 30 30 CD 40436 10828 68 A a NN 40436 10828 69 ; ; : 40436 10828 70 Timæus Timæus NNP 40436 10828 71 , , , 40436 10828 72 p. p. NN 40436 10828 73 30 30 CD 40436 10828 74 B b NN 40436 10828 75 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10828 76 . . . 40436 10829 1 The the DT 40436 10829 2 statement statement NN 40436 10829 3 of of IN 40436 10829 4 Nemesius Nemesius NNP 40436 10829 5 is be VBZ 40436 10829 6 remarkable remarkable JJ 40436 10829 7 , , , 40436 10829 8 that that IN 40436 10829 9 all all DT 40436 10829 10 Greeks Greeks NNPS 40436 10829 11 who who WP 40436 10829 12 believed believe VBD 40436 10829 13 the the DT 40436 10829 14 immortality immortality NN 40436 10829 15 of of IN 40436 10829 16 the the DT 40436 10829 17 soul soul NN 40436 10829 18 , , , 40436 10829 19 believed believe VBN 40436 10829 20 also also RB 40436 10829 21 in in IN 40436 10829 22 the the DT 40436 10829 23 metempsychosis--[Greek metempsychosis--[greek CD 40436 10829 24 : : : 40436 10829 25 Koinê=| Koinê=| NNP 40436 10829 26 me\n me\n NNP 40436 10829 27 ou)=n ou)=n NNP 40436 10829 28 pa pa NNP 40436 10829 29 / / SYM 40436 10829 30 ntes ntes NNP 40436 10829 31 E)/llênes e)/llêne NNS 40436 10829 32 , , , 40436 10829 33 oi oi PRP 40436 10829 34 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10829 35 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10829 36 psuchê\n psuchê\n NNP 40436 10829 37 a)tha a)tha NNP 40436 10829 38 / / SYM 40436 10829 39 naton naton NNP 40436 10829 40 a)pophê|na a)pophê|na NNP 40436 10829 41 / / SYM 40436 10829 42 menoi menoi NNS 40436 10829 43 , , , 40436 10829 44 tê\n tê\n NNP 40436 10829 45 metensôma metensôma NNP 40436 10829 46 / / SYM 40436 10829 47 tôsin tôsin NNP 40436 10829 48 dogmati dogmati NNP 40436 10829 49 / / SYM 40436 10829 50 zousin zousin NN 40436 10829 51 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10829 52 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10829 53 De De NNP 40436 10829 54 Naturâ Naturâ NNP 40436 10829 55 Hominis Hominis NNP 40436 10829 56 , , , 40436 10829 57 cap cap NN 40436 10829 58 . . . 40436 10830 1 ii ii LS 40436 10830 2 . . . 40436 10831 1 p. p. NN 40436 10831 2 50 50 CD 40436 10831 3 , , , 40436 10831 4 ed ed NN 40436 10831 5 . . . 40436 10832 1 1565 1565 CD 40436 10832 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10832 3 . . . 40436 10833 1 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10833 2 accepted accept VBD 40436 10833 3 the the DT 40436 10833 4 Egyptian egyptian JJ 40436 10833 5 and and CC 40436 10833 6 Pythagorean pythagorean JJ 40436 10833 7 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10833 8 , , , 40436 10833 9 continued continue VBD 40436 10833 10 in in IN 40436 10833 11 the the DT 40436 10833 12 Orphic orphic JJ 40436 10833 13 mysteries mystery NNS 40436 10833 14 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10833 15 Arnob Arnob NNP 40436 10833 16 . . . 40436 10834 1 adv adv NNP 40436 10834 2 . . . 40436 10835 1 Gentes Gentes NNP 40436 10835 2 , , , 40436 10835 3 ii ii NNP 40436 10835 4 . . . 40436 10836 1 16 16 CD 40436 10836 2 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10836 3 , , , 40436 10836 4 making make VBG 40436 10836 5 no no DT 40436 10836 6 essential essential JJ 40436 10836 7 distinction distinction NN 40436 10836 8 between between IN 40436 10836 9 the the DT 40436 10836 10 souls soul NNS 40436 10836 11 of of IN 40436 10836 12 men man NNS 40436 10836 13 and and CC 40436 10836 14 those those DT 40436 10836 15 of of IN 40436 10836 16 animals animal NNS 40436 10836 17 , , , 40436 10836 18 and and CC 40436 10836 19 recognising recognise VBG 40436 10836 20 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 40436 10836 21 interchange interchange NN 40436 10836 22 from from IN 40436 10836 23 the the DT 40436 10836 24 one one CD 40436 10836 25 to to IN 40436 10836 26 the the DT 40436 10836 27 other other JJ 40436 10836 28 . . . 40436 10837 1 The the DT 40436 10837 2 Platonists Platonists NNPS 40436 10837 3 adhered adhere VBD 40436 10837 4 to to IN 40436 10837 5 this this DT 40436 10837 6 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10837 7 fully fully RB 40436 10837 8 , , , 40436 10837 9 down down IN 40436 10837 10 to to IN 40436 10837 11 the the DT 40436 10837 12 third third JJ 40436 10837 13 century century NN 40436 10837 14 A.D. A.D. NNP 40436 10837 15 , , , 40436 10837 16 including include VBG 40436 10837 17 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 40436 10837 18 , , , 40436 10837 19 Numenius Numenius NNP 40436 10837 20 , , , 40436 10837 21 and and CC 40436 10837 22 others other NNS 40436 10837 23 . . . 40436 10838 1 But but CC 40436 10838 2 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 40436 10838 3 , , , 40436 10838 4 followed follow VBN 40436 10838 5 by by IN 40436 10838 6 Jamblichus Jamblichus NNP 40436 10838 7 , , , 40436 10838 8 introduced introduce VBD 40436 10838 9 a a DT 40436 10838 10 modification modification NN 40436 10838 11 of of IN 40436 10838 12 this this DT 40436 10838 13 creed creed NN 40436 10838 14 , , , 40436 10838 15 denying deny VBG 40436 10838 16 the the DT 40436 10838 17 possibility possibility NN 40436 10838 18 of of IN 40436 10838 19 transition transition NN 40436 10838 20 of of IN 40436 10838 21 a a DT 40436 10838 22 human human JJ 40436 10838 23 soul soul NN 40436 10838 24 into into IN 40436 10838 25 the the DT 40436 10838 26 body body NN 40436 10838 27 of of IN 40436 10838 28 another another DT 40436 10838 29 animal animal NN 40436 10838 30 , , , 40436 10838 31 or or CC 40436 10838 32 of of IN 40436 10838 33 the the DT 40436 10838 34 soul soul NN 40436 10838 35 of of IN 40436 10838 36 any any DT 40436 10838 37 other other JJ 40436 10838 38 animal animal NN 40436 10838 39 into into IN 40436 10838 40 the the DT 40436 10838 41 body body NN 40436 10838 42 of of IN 40436 10838 43 a a DT 40436 10838 44 man,--yet man,--yet NNP 40436 10838 45 still still RB 40436 10838 46 recognising recognise VBG 40436 10838 47 the the DT 40436 10838 48 transition transition NN 40436 10838 49 from from IN 40436 10838 50 one one CD 40436 10838 51 human human JJ 40436 10838 52 body body NN 40436 10838 53 to to IN 40436 10838 54 another another DT 40436 10838 55 , , , 40436 10838 56 and and CC 40436 10838 57 from from IN 40436 10838 58 one one CD 40436 10838 59 animal animal NN 40436 10838 60 body body NN 40436 10838 61 to to IN 40436 10838 62 another another DT 40436 10838 63 . . . 40436 10839 1 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10839 2 See see VB 40436 10839 3 Alkinous Alkinous NNP 40436 10839 4 , , , 40436 10839 5 Introd Introd NNP 40436 10839 6 . . . 40436 10840 1 in in IN 40436 10840 2 Platon Platon NNP 40436 10840 3 . . . 40436 10841 1 c. c. NNP 40436 10842 1 25 25 CD 40436 10842 2 . . . 40436 10842 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10843 1 This this DT 40436 10843 2 subject subject NN 40436 10843 3 is be VBZ 40436 10843 4 well well RB 40436 10843 5 handled handle VBN 40436 10843 6 in in IN 40436 10843 7 a a DT 40436 10843 8 learned learned JJ 40436 10843 9 work work NN 40436 10843 10 published publish VBN 40436 10843 11 in in IN 40436 10843 12 1712 1712 CD 40436 10843 13 by by IN 40436 10843 14 a a DT 40436 10843 15 Jesuit Jesuit NNP 40436 10843 16 of of IN 40436 10843 17 Toulouse Toulouse NNP 40436 10843 18 , , , 40436 10843 19 Michel Michel NNP 40436 10843 20 Mourgues Mourgues NNP 40436 10843 21 . . . 40436 10844 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10844 2 shows show VBZ 40436 10844 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10844 4 in in IN 40436 10844 5 opposition opposition NN 40436 10844 6 to to IN 40436 10844 7 Dacier Dacier NNP 40436 10844 8 and and CC 40436 10844 9 others other NNS 40436 10844 10 , , , 40436 10844 11 who who WP 40436 10844 12 interpreted interpret VBD 40436 10844 13 the the DT 40436 10844 14 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10844 15 in in IN 40436 10844 16 a a DT 40436 10844 17 sense sense NN 40436 10844 18 merely merely RB 40436 10844 19 spiritual spiritual JJ 40436 10844 20 and and CC 40436 10844 21 figurative figurative JJ 40436 10844 22 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10844 23 that that IN 40436 10844 24 the the DT 40436 10844 25 metempsychosis metempsychosis NN 40436 10844 26 was be VBD 40436 10844 27 a a DT 40436 10844 28 literal literal JJ 40436 10844 29 belief belief NN 40436 10844 30 of of IN 40436 10844 31 the the DT 40436 10844 32 Platonists Platonists NNPS 40436 10844 33 down down IN 40436 10844 34 to to IN 40436 10844 35 the the DT 40436 10844 36 time time NN 40436 10844 37 of of IN 40436 10844 38 Proklus Proklus NNP 40436 10844 39 . . . 40436 10845 1 " " `` 40436 10845 2 Les Les NNP 40436 10845 3 quatre quatre NNP 40436 10845 4 Platoniciens Platoniciens NNP 40436 10845 5 qui qui NNP 40436 10845 6 ont ont RB 40436 10845 7 tenu tenu FW 40436 10845 8 la la NNP 40436 10845 9 Transmigration Transmigration NNP 40436 10845 10 bornée bornée NNP 40436 10845 11 " " '' 40436 10845 12 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10845 13 _ _ NNP 40436 10845 14 i.e. i.e. FW 40436 10845 15 _ _ NNP 40436 10845 16 from from IN 40436 10845 17 one one CD 40436 10845 18 human human JJ 40436 10845 19 body body NN 40436 10845 20 into into IN 40436 10845 21 another another DT 40436 10845 22 human human JJ 40436 10845 23 body body NN 40436 10845 24 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10845 25 " " '' 40436 10845 26 n'ont n'ont NNP 40436 10845 27 pas pas NNP 40436 10845 28 laissé laissé NNP 40436 10845 29 d'admettre d'admettre NNP 40436 10845 30 la la NNP 40436 10845 31 pluralité pluralité NNP 40436 10845 32 d'animations d'animations NNP 40436 10845 33 ou ou NNP 40436 10845 34 de de NNP 40436 10845 35 vies vies NNP 40436 10845 36 d'une d'une VBP 40436 10845 37 même même NNP 40436 10845 38 âme âme NNP 40436 10845 39 : : : 40436 10845 40 et et NNP 40436 10845 41 cela cela NNP 40436 10845 42 sans sans NNP 40436 10845 43 figure figure VBP 40436 10845 44 et et FW 40436 10845 45 sans san NNS 40436 10845 46 métaphore métaphore JJ 40436 10845 47 . . . 40436 10846 1 Cet Cet NNP 40436 10846 2 article article NN 40436 10846 3 , , , 40436 10846 4 qui qui NNP 40436 10846 5 est est NNP 40436 10846 6 l'essentiel l'essentiel NNP 40436 10846 7 , , , 40436 10846 8 n'a n'a RB 40436 10846 9 jamais jamais NNP 40436 10846 10 trouvé trouvé NNP 40436 10846 11 un un NNP 40436 10846 12 seul seul NNP 40436 10846 13 contradicteur contradicteur NNP 40436 10846 14 dans dans NNPS 40436 10846 15 les les NNP 40436 10846 16 sectes sectes NNP 40436 10846 17 qui qui NNP 40436 10846 18 ont ont NNP 40436 10846 19 cru cru NNP 40436 10846 20 l'âme l'âme NNP 40436 10846 21 immortelle immortelle NNP 40436 10846 22 : : : 40436 10846 23 ni ni NNP 40436 10846 24 Porphyre Porphyre NNP 40436 10846 25 , , , 40436 10846 26 ni ni NNP 40436 10846 27 Hiérocle Hiérocle NNP 40436 10846 28 , , , 40436 10846 29 ni ni NNP 40436 10846 30 Procle Procle NNP 40436 10846 31 , , , 40436 10846 32 ni ni NNP 40436 10846 33 Salluste Salluste NNP 40436 10846 34 , , , 40436 10846 35 n'ont n'ont NNP 40436 10846 36 jamais jamais NNP 40436 10846 37 touché touché NNP 40436 10846 38 à à NNP 40436 10846 39 ce ce NNP 40436 10846 40 point point NN 40436 10846 41 que que NNP 40436 10846 42 pour pour VBP 40436 10846 43 l'approuver l'approuver NN 40436 10846 44 . . . 40436 10847 1 D'où D'où NNP 40436 10847 2 il il NNP 40436 10847 3 suit suit NN 40436 10847 4 que que NNP 40436 10847 5 la la NNP 40436 10847 6 réalité réalité NNP 40436 10847 7 de de FW 40436 10847 8 la la NNP 40436 10847 9 Métempsychose Métempsychose NNP 40436 10847 10 est est NNP 40436 10847 11 indubitable indubitable JJ 40436 10847 12 ; ; : 40436 10847 13 c'est c'est VB 40436 10847 14 à à NNP 40436 10847 15 dire dire JJ 40436 10847 16 , , , 40436 10847 17 qu'il qu'il NNP 40436 10847 18 est est NNP 40436 10847 19 indubitable indubitable JJ 40436 10847 20 que que NNP 40436 10847 21 tous tous JJ 40436 10847 22 les les NNP 40436 10847 23 sectateurs sectateur NNS 40436 10847 24 de de NNP 40436 10847 25 Pythagore Pythagore NNP 40436 10847 26 et et FW 40436 10847 27 de de FW 40436 10847 28 Platon Platon NNP 40436 10847 29 l'ont l'ont NNP 40436 10847 30 soutenue soutenue NNP 40436 10847 31 dans dan VBZ 40436 10847 32 un un NNP 40436 10847 33 sens sens NNP 40436 10847 34 très très NNP 40436 10847 35 réel réel VBD 40436 10847 36 quant quant NNP 40436 10847 37 à à NNP 40436 10847 38 la la NNP 40436 10847 39 pluralité pluralité NNP 40436 10847 40 des des FW 40436 10847 41 vies vies NNP 40436 10847 42 et et FW 40436 10847 43 d'animations d'animations FW 40436 10847 44 " " '' 40436 10847 45 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10847 46 Tom Tom NNP 40436 10847 47 . . . 40436 10848 1 i. i. NNP 40436 10848 2 p. p. NN 40436 10848 3 525 525 CD 40436 10848 4 : : : 40436 10848 5 also also RB 40436 10848 6 Tom Tom NNP 40436 10848 7 . . . 40436 10849 1 ii ii LS 40436 10849 2 . . . 40436 10850 1 p. p. NN 40436 10850 2 432 432 CD 40436 10850 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10850 4 M. M. NNP 40436 10850 5 Cousin Cousin NNP 40436 10850 6 and and CC 40436 10850 7 M. M. NNP 40436 10850 8 Barthélemy Barthélemy NNP 40436 10850 9 St St NNP 40436 10850 10 Hilaire Hilaire NNP 40436 10850 11 are be VBP 40436 10850 12 of of IN 40436 10850 13 the the DT 40436 10850 14 same same JJ 40436 10850 15 opinion opinion NN 40436 10850 16 . . . 40436 10851 1 M. M. NNP 40436 10851 2 Barthélemy Barthélemy NNP 40436 10851 3 St. St. NNP 40436 10851 4 Hilaire Hilaire NNP 40436 10851 5 observes observe VBZ 40436 10851 6 in in IN 40436 10851 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10851 8 Premier Premier NNP 40436 10851 9 Mémoire Mémoire NNP 40436 10851 10 sur sur FW 40436 10851 11 le le NNP 40436 10851 12 Sankhyâ Sankhyâ NNP 40436 10851 13 p. p. NN 40436 10851 14 416 416 CD 40436 10851 15 , , , 40436 10851 16 Paris Paris NNP 40436 10851 17 , , , 40436 10851 18 1852 1852 CD 40436 10851 19 . . . 40436 10852 1 " " `` 40436 10852 2 Voilà Voilà NNP 40436 10852 3 donc donc VBZ 40436 10852 4 la la JJ 40436 10852 5 transmigration transmigration NN 40436 10852 6 dans dan NNS 40436 10852 7 les les VBP 40436 10852 8 plus plus CC 40436 10852 9 grands grand VBZ 40436 10852 10 dialogues dialogue NNS 40436 10852 11 de de IN 40436 10852 12 Platon Platon NNP 40436 10852 13 -- -- : 40436 10852 14 le le NNP 40436 10852 15 Timée Timée NNP 40436 10852 16 , , , 40436 10852 17 la la NNP 40436 10852 18 République République NNP 40436 10852 19 , , , 40436 10852 20 le le NNP 40436 10852 21 Phèdre Phèdre NNP 40436 10852 22 , , , 40436 10852 23 le le NNP 40436 10852 24 Phédon Phédon NNP 40436 10852 25 . . . 40436 10853 1 On on IN 40436 10853 2 peut peut NN 40436 10853 3 en en FW 40436 10853 4 retrouver retrouver NN 40436 10853 5 la la NNP 40436 10853 6 trace trace NN 40436 10853 7 manifeste manifeste NNP 40436 10853 8 dans dan VBZ 40436 10853 9 d'autres d'autres NNP 40436 10853 10 dialogues dialogue VBZ 40436 10853 11 moins moin NNS 40436 10853 12 considérables considérable NNS 40436 10853 13 , , , 40436 10853 14 le le NNP 40436 10853 15 Menon Menon NNP 40436 10853 16 et et NNP 40436 10853 17 le le NNP 40436 10853 18 Politique Politique NNP 40436 10853 19 , , , 40436 10853 20 par par NN 40436 10853 21 exemple exemple NN 40436 10853 22 . . . 40436 10854 1 La La NNP 40436 10854 2 transmigration transmigration NN 40436 10854 3 est est NNP 40436 10854 4 même même NNP 40436 10854 5 positivement positivement NNP 40436 10854 6 indiquée indiquée NNP 40436 10854 7 dans dan NNS 40436 10854 8 le le NNP 40436 10854 9 dixième dixième NNP 40436 10854 10 Livre Livre NNP 40436 10854 11 des des FW 40436 10854 12 Lois Lois NNP 40436 10854 13 , , , 40436 10854 14 où où IN 40436 10854 15 Platon Platon NNP 40436 10854 16 traite traite JJ 40436 10854 17 avec avec FW 40436 10854 18 tant tant NN 40436 10854 19 de de FW 40436 10854 20 force force NNP 40436 10854 21 et et NNP 40436 10854 22 de de NNP 40436 10854 23 solennité solennité NNP 40436 10854 24 de de NNP 40436 10854 25 la la NNP 40436 10854 26 providence providence NNP 40436 10854 27 et et NNP 40436 10854 28 de de FW 40436 10854 29 la la NNP 40436 10854 30 justice justice NNP 40436 10854 31 divines divine NNS 40436 10854 32 . . . 40436 10855 1 " " `` 40436 10855 2 En En NNP 40436 10855 3 présence présence NN 40436 10855 4 de de IN 40436 10855 5 témoignages témoignage NNS 40436 10855 6 si si VBP 40436 10855 7 sérieux sérieux JJ 40436 10855 8 , , , 40436 10855 9 et et NNP 40436 10855 10 de de NNP 40436 10855 11 tant tant NNP 40436 10855 12 de de NNP 40436 10855 13 persistance persistance NNP 40436 10855 14 à à NNP 40436 10855 15 revenir revenir NN 40436 10855 16 sur sur NNP 40436 10855 17 des des NNP 40436 10855 18 opinions opinion NNS 40436 10855 19 qui qui VBP 40436 10855 20 ne ne NNP 40436 10855 21 varient varient NN 40436 10855 22 pas pas NNP 40436 10855 23 , , , 40436 10855 24 je je NNP 40436 10855 25 crois crois NNP 40436 10855 26 que que NNP 40436 10855 27 tout tout NNP 40436 10855 28 esprit esprit FW 40436 10855 29 sensé sensé FW 40436 10855 30 ne ne NNP 40436 10855 31 peut peut VBP 40436 10855 32 que que NNP 40436 10855 33 partager partager NNP 40436 10855 34 l'avis l'avis NNP 40436 10855 35 de de NNP 40436 10855 36 M. M. NNP 40436 10855 37 Cousin Cousin NNP 40436 10855 38 . . . 40436 10856 1 Il il IN 40436 10856 2 est e JJS 40436 10856 3 impossible impossible JJ 40436 10856 4 que que NNP 40436 10856 5 Platon Platon NNP 40436 10856 6 ne ne NNP 40436 10856 7 se se NNP 40436 10856 8 fasse fasse NNP 40436 10856 9 de de FW 40436 10856 10 l'exposition l'exposition FW 40436 10856 11 de de NNP 40436 10856 12 ces ces NNP 40436 10856 13 opinions opinion NNS 40436 10856 14 qu'un qu'un NNP 40436 10856 15 pur pur NNP 40436 10856 16 badinage badinage NN 40436 10856 17 . . . 40436 10857 1 Il il IN 40436 10857 2 les les FW 40436 10857 3 a a DT 40436 10857 4 répetées répetées NN 40436 10857 5 , , , 40436 10857 6 sans san NNS 40436 10857 7 les les VBP 40436 10857 8 modifier modifier NNP 40436 10857 9 en en NNP 40436 10857 10 rien rien NNP 40436 10857 11 , , , 40436 10857 12 au au NNP 40436 10857 13 milieu milieu VB 40436 10857 14 des des NNP 40436 10857 15 discussions discussion NNS 40436 10857 16 les les NNP 40436 10857 17 plus plus CC 40436 10857 18 graves graves NNPS 40436 10857 19 et et FW 40436 10857 20 les les FW 40436 10857 21 plus plus NNP 40436 10857 22 étendues étendue NNS 40436 10857 23 . . . 40436 10858 1 Ajoutez ajoutez JJ 40436 10858 2 que que NNP 40436 10858 3 ces ces NN 40436 10858 4 doctrines doctrine NNS 40436 10858 5 tiennent tiennent NN 40436 10858 6 intimément intimément NN 40436 10858 7 à à NNP 40436 10858 8 toutes toute NNS 40436 10858 9 celles celle NNS 40436 10858 10 qui qui NNP 40436 10858 11 sont sont NNP 40436 10858 12 le le NNP 40436 10858 13 fond fond NNP 40436 10858 14 même même NNP 40436 10858 15 du du NNP 40436 10858 16 platonisme platonisme NN 40436 10858 17 , , , 40436 10858 18 et et NN 40436 10858 19 qu'elles qu'elle NNS 40436 10858 20 s'y s'y RB 40436 10858 21 entrelacent entrelacent NN 40436 10858 22 si si NN 40436 10858 23 étroitement étroitement NN 40436 10858 24 , , , 40436 10858 25 que que NNP 40436 10858 26 les les FW 40436 10858 27 en en FW 40436 10858 28 détacher détacher NN 40436 10858 29 , , , 40436 10858 30 c'est c'est NNP 40436 10858 31 le le NNP 40436 10858 32 mutiler mutiler NNP 40436 10858 33 et et NNP 40436 10858 34 l'amoindrir l'amoindrir NNP 40436 10858 35 . . . 40436 10859 1 Le Le NNP 40436 10859 2 système système NN 40436 10859 3 des des NNP 40436 10859 4 Idées Idées NNP 40436 10859 5 ne ne NNP 40436 10859 6 se se FW 40436 10859 7 comprend comprend NN 40436 10859 8 pas pas NNP 40436 10859 9 tout tout NNP 40436 10859 10 entier entier NNP 40436 10859 11 sans san NNS 40436 10859 12 la la NNP 40436 10859 13 réminiscence réminiscence NNP 40436 10859 14 : : : 40436 10859 15 et et NNP 40436 10859 16 la la NNP 40436 10859 17 réminiscence réminiscence NNP 40436 10859 18 elle elle NNP 40436 10859 19 même même NNP 40436 10859 20 implique implique NNP 40436 10859 21 necessairement necessairement NNP 40436 10859 22 l'existence l'existence NNP 40436 10859 23 antérieure antérieure NNP 40436 10859 24 de de NNP 40436 10859 25 l'âme l'âme NNP 40436 10859 26 . . . 40436 10859 27 " " '' 40436 10860 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 40436 10860 2 Henry Henry NNP 40436 10860 3 More More NNP 40436 10860 4 , , , 40436 10860 5 in in IN 40436 10860 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10860 7 ' ' `` 40436 10860 8 Treatise Treatise NNP 40436 10860 9 on on IN 40436 10860 10 the the DT 40436 10860 11 Immortality immortality NN 40436 10860 12 of of IN 40436 10860 13 the the DT 40436 10860 14 Soul Soul NNP 40436 10860 15 , , , 40436 10860 16 ' ' '' 40436 10860 17 argues argue VBZ 40436 10860 18 at at IN 40436 10860 19 considerable considerable JJ 40436 10860 20 length length NN 40436 10860 21 in in IN 40436 10860 22 defence defence NN 40436 10860 23 of of IN 40436 10860 24 pre pre NN 40436 10860 25 - - NN 40436 10860 26 existence existence NN 40436 10860 27 of of IN 40436 10860 28 each each DT 40436 10860 29 soul soul NN 40436 10860 30 , , , 40436 10860 31 as as IN 40436 10860 32 a a DT 40436 10860 33 part part NN 40436 10860 34 of of IN 40436 10860 35 the the DT 40436 10860 36 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10860 37 . . . 40436 10861 1 He -PRON- PRP 40436 10861 2 considers consider VBZ 40436 10861 3 himself -PRON- PRP 40436 10861 4 to to TO 40436 10861 5 have have VB 40436 10861 6 clearly clearly RB 40436 10861 7 proved--"That proved--"that IN 40436 10861 8 the the DT 40436 10861 9 pre pre NN 40436 10861 10 - - NN 40436 10861 11 existence existence NN 40436 10861 12 of of IN 40436 10861 13 the the DT 40436 10861 14 soul soul NN 40436 10861 15 is be VBZ 40436 10861 16 an an DT 40436 10861 17 opinion opinion NN 40436 10861 18 both both DT 40436 10861 19 in in IN 40436 10861 20 itself -PRON- PRP 40436 10861 21 the the DT 40436 10861 22 most most RBS 40436 10861 23 rational rational JJ 40436 10861 24 that that WDT 40436 10861 25 can can MD 40436 10861 26 be be VB 40436 10861 27 maintained maintain VBN 40436 10861 28 , , , 40436 10861 29 and and CC 40436 10861 30 has have VBZ 40436 10861 31 had have VBN 40436 10861 32 the the DT 40436 10861 33 suffrage suffrage NN 40436 10861 34 of of IN 40436 10861 35 the the DT 40436 10861 36 most most RBS 40436 10861 37 renowned renowned JJ 40436 10861 38 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10861 39 in in IN 40436 10861 40 all all DT 40436 10861 41 ages age NNS 40436 10861 42 of of IN 40436 10861 43 the the DT 40436 10861 44 world world NN 40436 10861 45 " " '' 40436 10861 46 . . . 40436 10862 1 Of of IN 40436 10862 2 these these DT 40436 10862 3 last last RB 40436 10862 4 - - HYPH 40436 10862 5 mentioned mention VBN 40436 10862 6 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10862 7 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10862 8 gives give VBZ 40436 10862 9 a a DT 40436 10862 10 list list NN 40436 10862 11 , , , 40436 10862 12 as as IN 40436 10862 13 follows follow VBZ 40436 10862 14 -- -- : 40436 10862 15 Moses Moses NNP 40436 10862 16 , , , 40436 10862 17 on on IN 40436 10862 18 the the DT 40436 10862 19 authority authority NN 40436 10862 20 of of IN 40436 10862 21 the the DT 40436 10862 22 Jewish jewish JJ 40436 10862 23 Cabbala Cabbala NNP 40436 10862 24 -- -- : 40436 10862 25 Zoroaster Zoroaster NNP 40436 10862 26 , , , 40436 10862 27 Pythagoras Pythagoras NNP 40436 10862 28 , , , 40436 10862 29 Epicharmus Epicharmus NNP 40436 10862 30 , , , 40436 10862 31 Empedocles Empedocles NNP 40436 10862 32 , , , 40436 10862 33 Cebês Cebês NNP 40436 10862 34 , , , 40436 10862 35 Euripides Euripides NNP 40436 10862 36 , , , 40436 10862 37 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10862 38 , , , 40436 10862 39 Euclid Euclid NNP 40436 10862 40 , , , 40436 10862 41 Philo Philo NNP 40436 10862 42 , , , 40436 10862 43 Virgil Virgil NNP 40436 10862 44 , , , 40436 10862 45 Marcus Marcus NNP 40436 10862 46 Cicero Cicero NNP 40436 10862 47 , , , 40436 10862 48 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 40436 10862 49 , , , 40436 10862 50 Jamblichus Jamblichus NNP 40436 10862 51 , , , 40436 10862 52 Proclus Proclus NNP 40436 10862 53 , , , 40436 10862 54 Boethius Boethius NNP 40436 10862 55 , , , 40436 10862 56 & & CC 40436 10862 57 c. c. NNP 40436 10862 58 See See NNP 40436 10862 59 chapters chapter NNS 40436 10862 60 xii xii NNP 40436 10862 61 . . . 40436 10863 1 and and CC 40436 10863 2 xiii xiii NNP 40436 10863 3 . . . 40436 10864 1 pages page NNS 40436 10864 2 116 116 CD 40436 10864 3 , , , 40436 10864 4 117 117 CD 40436 10864 5 , , , 40436 10864 6 121 121 CD 40436 10864 7 of of IN 40436 10864 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10864 9 Treatise Treatise NNP 40436 10864 10 . . . 40436 10865 1 Compare compare VB 40436 10865 2 also also RB 40436 10865 3 what what WP 40436 10865 4 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10865 5 says say VBZ 40436 10865 6 in in IN 40436 10865 7 Sect Sect NNP 40436 10865 8 . . . 40436 10866 1 18 18 CD 40436 10866 2 of of IN 40436 10866 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10866 4 Preface Preface NNP 40436 10866 5 General General NNP 40436 10866 6 , , , 40436 10866 7 page page NN 40436 10866 8 xx.-xxiv xx.-xxiv NNP 40436 10866 9 . . . 40436 10866 10 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10867 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10867 2 Side side NN 40436 10867 3 - - HYPH 40436 10867 4 note note NN 40436 10867 5 : : : 40436 10867 6 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10867 7 's 's POS 40436 10867 8 demonstration demonstration NN 40436 10867 9 of of IN 40436 10867 10 the the DT 40436 10867 11 immortality immortality NN 40436 10867 12 of of IN 40436 10867 13 the the DT 40436 10867 14 soul soul NN 40436 10867 15 did do VBD 40436 10867 16 not not RB 40436 10867 17 appear appear VB 40436 10867 18 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 40436 10867 19 to to IN 40436 10867 20 subsequent subsequent JJ 40436 10867 21 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10867 22 . . . 40436 10868 1 The the DT 40436 10868 2 question question NN 40436 10868 3 remained remain VBD 40436 10868 4 debated debated JJ 40436 10868 5 and and CC 40436 10868 6 problematical problematical JJ 40436 10868 7 . . . 40436 10868 8 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10869 1 We -PRON- PRP 40436 10869 2 are be VBP 40436 10869 3 told tell VBN 40436 10869 4 that that IN 40436 10869 5 one one CD 40436 10869 6 vehement vehement NN 40436 10869 7 admirer admirer NN 40436 10869 8 of of IN 40436 10869 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10869 10 -- -- : 40436 10869 11 the the DT 40436 10869 12 Ambrakiot Ambrakiot NNP 40436 10869 13 Kleombrotus Kleombrotus NNP 40436 10869 14 -- -- : 40436 10869 15 was be VBD 40436 10869 16 so so RB 40436 10869 17 profoundly profoundly RB 40436 10869 18 affected affected JJ 40436 10869 19 and and CC 40436 10869 20 convinced convince VBN 40436 10869 21 by by IN 40436 10869 22 reading read VBG 40436 10869 23 the the DT 40436 10869 24 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10869 25 , , , 40436 10869 26 that that IN 40436 10869 27 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10869 28 immediately immediately RB 40436 10869 29 terminated terminate VBD 40436 10869 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10869 31 existence existence NN 40436 10869 32 by by IN 40436 10869 33 leaping leap VBG 40436 10869 34 from from IN 40436 10869 35 a a DT 40436 10869 36 high high JJ 40436 10869 37 wall wall NN 40436 10869 38 ; ; : 40436 10869 39 though though IN 40436 10869 40 in in IN 40436 10869 41 other other JJ 40436 10869 42 respects respect NNS 40436 10869 43 well well RB 40436 10869 44 satisfied satisfied JJ 40436 10869 45 with with IN 40436 10869 46 life life NN 40436 10869 47 . . . 40436 10870 1 But but CC 40436 10870 2 the the DT 40436 10870 3 number number NN 40436 10870 4 of of IN 40436 10870 5 persons person NNS 40436 10870 6 who who WP 40436 10870 7 derived derive VBD 40436 10870 8 from from IN 40436 10870 9 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10870 10 such such JJ 40436 10870 11 settled settled JJ 40436 10870 12 conviction conviction NN 40436 10870 13 , , , 40436 10870 14 was be VBD 40436 10870 15 certainly certainly RB 40436 10870 16 not not RB 40436 10870 17 considerable considerable JJ 40436 10870 18 . . . 40436 10871 1 Neither neither CC 40436 10871 2 the the DT 40436 10871 3 doctrine doctrine NN 40436 10871 4 nor nor CC 40436 10871 5 the the DT 40436 10871 6 reasonings reasoning NNS 40436 10871 7 of of IN 40436 10871 8 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10871 9 were be VBD 40436 10871 10 adopted adopt VBN 40436 10871 11 even even RB 40436 10871 12 by by IN 40436 10871 13 the the DT 40436 10871 14 immediate immediate JJ 40436 10871 15 successors successor NNS 40436 10871 16 in in IN 40436 10871 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10871 18 school school NN 40436 10871 19 : : : 40436 10871 20 still still RB 40436 10871 21 less less JJR 40436 10871 22 by by IN 40436 10871 23 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10871 24 and and CC 40436 10871 25 the the DT 40436 10871 26 Peripatetics Peripatetics NNPS 40436 10871 27 -- -- : 40436 10871 28 or or CC 40436 10871 29 by by IN 40436 10871 30 the the DT 40436 10871 31 Stoics Stoics NNPS 40436 10871 32 -- -- : 40436 10871 33 or or CC 40436 10871 34 by by IN 40436 10871 35 the the DT 40436 10871 36 Epikureans Epikureans NNPS 40436 10871 37 . . . 40436 10872 1 The the DT 40436 10872 2 Epikureans Epikureans NNPS 40436 10872 3 denied deny VBD 40436 10872 4 altogether altogether RB 40436 10872 5 the the DT 40436 10872 6 survivorship survivorship NN 40436 10872 7 of of IN 40436 10872 8 soul soul NN 40436 10872 9 over over IN 40436 10872 10 body body NN 40436 10872 11 : : : 40436 10872 12 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10872 13 gives give VBZ 40436 10872 14 a a DT 40436 10872 15 definition definition NN 40436 10872 16 of of IN 40436 10872 17 the the DT 40436 10872 18 soul soul NN 40436 10872 19 which which WDT 40436 10872 20 involves involve VBZ 40436 10872 21 this this DT 40436 10872 22 same same JJ 40436 10872 23 negation negation NN 40436 10872 24 , , , 40436 10872 25 though though IN 40436 10872 26 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10872 27 admits admit VBZ 40436 10872 28 as as IN 40436 10872 29 credible credible JJ 40436 10872 30 the the DT 40436 10872 31 separate separate JJ 40436 10872 32 existence existence NN 40436 10872 33 of of IN 40436 10872 34 the the DT 40436 10872 35 rational rational JJ 40436 10872 36 soul soul NN 40436 10872 37 , , , 40436 10872 38 without without IN 40436 10872 39 individuality individuality NN 40436 10872 40 or or CC 40436 10872 41 personality personality NN 40436 10872 42 . . . 40436 10873 1 The the DT 40436 10873 2 Stoics Stoics NNPS 40436 10873 3 , , , 40436 10873 4 while while IN 40436 10873 5 affirming affirm VBG 40436 10873 6 the the DT 40436 10873 7 soul soul NN 40436 10873 8 to to TO 40436 10873 9 be be VB 40436 10873 10 material material JJ 40436 10873 11 as as RB 40436 10873 12 well well RB 40436 10873 13 as as IN 40436 10873 14 the the DT 40436 10873 15 body body NN 40436 10873 16 , , , 40436 10873 17 considered consider VBD 40436 10873 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10873 19 as as IN 40436 10873 20 a a DT 40436 10873 21 detached detach VBN 40436 10873 22 fragment fragment NN 40436 10873 23 of of IN 40436 10873 24 the the DT 40436 10873 25 all all RB 40436 10873 26 - - HYPH 40436 10873 27 pervading pervade VBG 40436 10873 28 cosmical cosmical JJ 40436 10873 29 or or CC 40436 10873 30 mundane mundane JJ 40436 10873 31 soul soul NN 40436 10873 32 , , , 40436 10873 33 which which WDT 40436 10873 34 was be VBD 40436 10873 35 re re VBN 40436 10873 36 - - VBN 40436 10873 37 absorbed absorb VBN 40436 10873 38 after after IN 40436 10873 39 the the DT 40436 10873 40 death death NN 40436 10873 41 of of IN 40436 10873 42 the the DT 40436 10873 43 individual individual NN 40436 10873 44 into into IN 40436 10873 45 the the DT 40436 10873 46 great great JJ 40436 10873 47 whole whole NN 40436 10873 48 to to TO 40436 10873 49 which which WDT 40436 10873 50 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10873 51 belonged belong VBD 40436 10873 52 . . . 40436 10874 1 None none NN 40436 10874 2 of of IN 40436 10874 3 these these DT 40436 10874 4 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10874 5 were be VBD 40436 10874 6 persuaded persuade VBN 40436 10874 7 by by IN 40436 10874 8 the the DT 40436 10874 9 arguments argument NNS 40436 10874 10 of of IN 40436 10874 11 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10874 12 . . . 40436 10875 1 The the DT 40436 10875 2 popular popular JJ 40436 10875 3 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 40436 10875 4 , , , 40436 10875 5 which which WDT 40436 10875 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10875 7 often often RB 40436 10875 8 censures censure VBZ 40436 10875 9 harshly harshly RB 40436 10875 10 , , , 40436 10875 11 recognised recognise VBD 40436 10875 12 some some DT 40436 10875 13 sort sort NN 40436 10875 14 of of IN 40436 10875 15 posthumous posthumous JJ 40436 10875 16 existence existence NN 40436 10875 17 as as IN 40436 10875 18 a a DT 40436 10875 19 part part NN 40436 10875 20 of of IN 40436 10875 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10875 22 creed creed NN 40436 10875 23 ; ; : 40436 10875 24 and and CC 40436 10875 25 the the DT 40436 10875 26 uninquiring uninquiring JJ 40436 10875 27 multitude multitude NN 40436 10875 28 continued continue VBD 40436 10875 29 in in IN 40436 10875 30 the the DT 40436 10875 31 teaching teaching NN 40436 10875 32 and and CC 40436 10875 33 traditions tradition NNS 40436 10875 34 of of IN 40436 10875 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10875 36 youth youth NN 40436 10875 37 . . . 40436 10876 1 But but CC 40436 10876 2 literary literary JJ 40436 10876 3 and and CC 40436 10876 4 philosophical philosophical JJ 40436 10876 5 men man NNS 40436 10876 6 , , , 40436 10876 7 who who WP 40436 10876 8 sought seek VBD 40436 10876 9 to to TO 40436 10876 10 form form VB 40436 10876 11 some some DT 40436 10876 12 opinion opinion NN 40436 10876 13 for for IN 40436 10876 14 themselves -PRON- PRP 40436 10876 15 without without IN 40436 10876 16 altogether altogether RB 40436 10876 17 rejecting reject VBG 40436 10876 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10876 19 as as IN 40436 10876 20 the the DT 40436 10876 21 Epikureans Epikureans NNPS 40436 10876 22 rejected reject VBD 40436 10876 23 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10876 24 the the DT 40436 10876 25 basis basis NN 40436 10876 26 of of IN 40436 10876 27 the the DT 40436 10876 28 current current JJ 40436 10876 29 traditions tradition NNS 40436 10876 30 -- -- : 40436 10876 31 were be VBD 40436 10876 32 in in IN 40436 10876 33 no no DT 40436 10876 34 better well JJR 40436 10876 35 condition condition NN 40436 10876 36 for for IN 40436 10876 37 deciding decide VBG 40436 10876 38 the the DT 40436 10876 39 question question NN 40436 10876 40 with with IN 40436 10876 41 the the DT 40436 10876 42 assistance assistance NN 40436 10876 43 of of IN 40436 10876 44 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10876 45 , , , 40436 10876 46 than than IN 40436 10876 47 they -PRON- PRP 40436 10876 48 would would MD 40436 10876 49 have have VB 40436 10876 50 been be VBN 40436 10876 51 without without IN 40436 10876 52 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10876 53 . . . 40436 10877 1 While while IN 40436 10877 2 the the DT 40436 10877 3 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10877 4 of of IN 40436 10877 5 the the DT 40436 10877 6 bodily bodily JJ 40436 10877 7 organism organism NN 40436 10877 8 , , , 40436 10877 9 and and CC 40436 10877 10 of of IN 40436 10877 11 mind mind NN 40436 10877 12 or or CC 40436 10877 13 soul soul NN 40436 10877 14 as as IN 40436 10877 15 embodied embody VBN 40436 10877 16 therein therein RB 40436 10877 17 , , , 40436 10877 18 received receive VBD 40436 10877 19 important important JJ 40436 10877 20 additions addition NNS 40436 10877 21 , , , 40436 10877 22 from from IN 40436 10877 23 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 40436 10877 24 down down RP 40436 10877 25 to to IN 40436 10877 26 Galen Galen NNP 40436 10877 27 -- -- : 40436 10877 28 no no DT 40436 10877 29 new new JJ 40436 10877 30 facts fact NNS 40436 10877 31 either either CC 40436 10877 32 were be VBD 40436 10877 33 known know VBN 40436 10877 34 or or CC 40436 10877 35 could could MD 40436 10877 36 become become VB 40436 10877 37 known known JJ 40436 10877 38 , , , 40436 10877 39 respecting respect VBG 40436 10877 40 soul soul NN 40436 10877 41 _ _ NNP 40436 10877 42 per per FW 40436 10877 43 se se FW 40436 10877 44 _ _ NNP 40436 10877 45 , , , 40436 10877 46 considered consider VBN 40436 10877 47 as as IN 40436 10877 48 pre pre JJ 40436 10877 49 - - JJ 40436 10877 50 existent existent JJ 40436 10877 51 or or CC 40436 10877 52 post post NN 40436 10877 53 - - JJ 40436 10877 54 existent existent NN 40436 10877 55 to to IN 40436 10877 56 body body NN 40436 10877 57 . . . 40436 10878 1 Galen Galen NNP 40436 10878 2 expressly expressly RB 40436 10878 3 records record VBZ 40436 10878 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10878 5 dissatisfaction dissatisfaction NN 40436 10878 6 with with IN 40436 10878 7 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10878 8 on on IN 40436 10878 9 this this DT 40436 10878 10 point point NN 40436 10878 11 , , , 40436 10878 12 though though IN 40436 10878 13 generally generally RB 40436 10878 14 among among IN 40436 10878 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10878 16 warmest warm JJS 40436 10878 17 admirers admirer NNS 40436 10878 18 . . . 40436 10879 1 Questions question NNS 40436 10879 2 of of IN 40436 10879 3 this this DT 40436 10879 4 kind kind NN 40436 10879 5 remained remain VBD 40436 10879 6 always always RB 40436 10879 7 problematical problematical JJ 40436 10879 8 , , , 40436 10879 9 standing stand VBG 40436 10879 10 themes theme NNS 40436 10879 11 for for IN 40436 10879 12 rhetoric rhetoric NN 40436 10879 13 or or CC 40436 10879 14 dialectic dialectic NN 40436 10879 15 . . . 40436 10880 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10880 2 114 114 CD 40436 10880 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10880 4 Every every DT 40436 10880 5 man man NN 40436 10880 6 could could MD 40436 10880 7 do do VB 40436 10880 8 , , , 40436 10880 9 though though IN 40436 10880 10 not not RB 40436 10880 11 with with IN 40436 10880 12 the the DT 40436 10880 13 same same JJ 40436 10880 14 exuberant exuberant JJ 40436 10880 15 eloquence eloquence NN 40436 10880 16 , , , 40436 10880 17 what what WP 40436 10880 18 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10880 19 had have VBD 40436 10880 20 done do VBN 40436 10880 21 -- -- : 40436 10880 22 and and CC 40436 10880 23 no no DT 40436 10880 24 man man NN 40436 10880 25 could could MD 40436 10880 26 do do VB 40436 10880 27 more more JJR 40436 10880 28 . . . 40436 10881 1 Every every DT 40436 10881 2 man man NN 40436 10881 3 could could MD 40436 10881 4 coin coin VB 40436 10881 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10881 6 own own JJ 40436 10881 7 hopes hope NNS 40436 10881 8 and and CC 40436 10881 9 fears fear NNS 40436 10881 10 , , , 40436 10881 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10881 12 own own JJ 40436 10881 13 æsthetical æsthetical JJ 40436 10881 14 preferences preference NNS 40436 10881 15 and and CC 40436 10881 16 repugnances repugnance NNS 40436 10881 17 , , , 40436 10881 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10881 19 own own JJ 40436 10881 20 ethical ethical JJ 40436 10881 21 aspiration aspiration NN 40436 10881 22 to to TO 40436 10881 23 distribute distribute VB 40436 10881 24 rewards reward NNS 40436 10881 25 and and CC 40436 10881 26 punishments punishment NNS 40436 10881 27 among among IN 40436 10881 28 the the DT 40436 10881 29 characters character NNS 40436 10881 30 around around IN 40436 10881 31 him -PRON- PRP 40436 10881 32 -- -- : 40436 10881 33 into into IN 40436 10881 34 affirmative affirmative JJ 40436 10881 35 prophecies prophecy NNS 40436 10881 36 respecting respect VBG 40436 10881 37 an an DT 40436 10881 38 unknowable unknowable JJ 40436 10881 39 future future NN 40436 10881 40 , , , 40436 10881 41 where where WRB 40436 10881 42 neither neither CC 40436 10881 43 verification verification NN 40436 10881 44 nor nor CC 40436 10881 45 Elenchus Elenchus NNP 40436 10881 46 were be VBD 40436 10881 47 accessible accessible JJ 40436 10881 48 . . . 40436 10882 1 The the DT 40436 10882 2 state state NN 40436 10882 3 of of IN 40436 10882 4 this this DT 40436 10882 5 discussion discussion NN 40436 10882 6 throughout throughout IN 40436 10882 7 the the DT 40436 10882 8 Pagan pagan JJ 40436 10882 9 world world NN 40436 10882 10 bears bear VBZ 40436 10882 11 out out RP 40436 10882 12 the the DT 40436 10882 13 following follow VBG 40436 10882 14 remark remark NN 40436 10882 15 of of IN 40436 10882 16 Lord Lord NNP 40436 10882 17 Macaulay Macaulay NNP 40436 10882 18 , , , 40436 10882 19 with with IN 40436 10882 20 which which WDT 40436 10882 21 I -PRON- PRP 40436 10882 22 conclude conclude VBP 40436 10882 23 the the DT 40436 10882 24 present present NN 40436 10882 25 chapter:--"There chapter:--"There . 40436 10882 26 are be VBP 40436 10882 27 branches branch NNS 40436 10882 28 of of IN 40436 10882 29 knowledge knowledge NN 40436 10882 30 with with IN 40436 10882 31 respect respect NN 40436 10882 32 to to TO 40436 10882 33 which which WDT 40436 10882 34 the the DT 40436 10882 35 law law NN 40436 10882 36 of of IN 40436 10882 37 the the DT 40436 10882 38 human human JJ 40436 10882 39 mind mind NN 40436 10882 40 is be VBZ 40436 10882 41 progress progress NN 40436 10882 42 . . . 40436 10883 1 . . . 40436 10884 1 . . . 40436 10885 1 . . . 40436 10886 1 But but CC 40436 10886 2 with with IN 40436 10886 3 theology theology NN 40436 10886 4 , , , 40436 10886 5 the the DT 40436 10886 6 case case NN 40436 10886 7 is be VBZ 40436 10886 8 very very RB 40436 10886 9 different different JJ 40436 10886 10 . . . 40436 10887 1 As as IN 40436 10887 2 respects respect VBZ 40436 10887 3 natural natural JJ 40436 10887 4 religion religion NN 40436 10887 5 -- -- : 40436 10887 6 revelation revelation NN 40436 10887 7 being be VBG 40436 10887 8 for for IN 40436 10887 9 the the DT 40436 10887 10 present present NN 40436 10887 11 altogether altogether RB 40436 10887 12 left leave VBN 40436 10887 13 out out IN 40436 10887 14 of of IN 40436 10887 15 the the DT 40436 10887 16 question question NN 40436 10887 17 -- -- : 40436 10887 18 it -PRON- PRP 40436 10887 19 is be VBZ 40436 10887 20 not not RB 40436 10887 21 easy easy JJ 40436 10887 22 to to TO 40436 10887 23 see see VB 40436 10887 24 that that IN 40436 10887 25 a a DT 40436 10887 26 philosopher philosopher NN 40436 10887 27 of of IN 40436 10887 28 the the DT 40436 10887 29 present present JJ 40436 10887 30 day day NN 40436 10887 31 is be VBZ 40436 10887 32 more more RBR 40436 10887 33 favourably favourably RB 40436 10887 34 situated situated JJ 40436 10887 35 than than IN 40436 10887 36 Thales Thales NNPS 40436 10887 37 or or CC 40436 10887 38 Simonides Simonides NNPS 40436 10887 39 . . . 40436 10888 1 . . . 40436 10889 1 . . . 40436 10890 1 . . . 40436 10891 1 As as IN 40436 10891 2 to to IN 40436 10891 3 the the DT 40436 10891 4 other other JJ 40436 10891 5 great great JJ 40436 10891 6 question question NN 40436 10891 7 -- -- : 40436 10891 8 the the DT 40436 10891 9 question question NN 40436 10891 10 , , , 40436 10891 11 what what WP 40436 10891 12 becomes become VBZ 40436 10891 13 of of IN 40436 10891 14 man man NN 40436 10891 15 after after IN 40436 10891 16 death death NN 40436 10891 17 -- -- : 40436 10891 18 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10891 19 do do VBP 40436 10891 20 not not RB 40436 10891 21 see see VB 40436 10891 22 that that IN 40436 10891 23 a a DT 40436 10891 24 highly highly RB 40436 10891 25 educated educate VBN 40436 10891 26 European european JJ 40436 10891 27 , , , 40436 10891 28 left leave VBD 40436 10891 29 to to IN 40436 10891 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10891 31 unassisted unassisted JJ 40436 10891 32 reason reason NN 40436 10891 33 , , , 40436 10891 34 is be VBZ 40436 10891 35 more more RBR 40436 10891 36 likely likely JJ 40436 10891 37 to to TO 40436 10891 38 be be VB 40436 10891 39 in in IN 40436 10891 40 the the DT 40436 10891 41 right right NN 40436 10891 42 than than IN 40436 10891 43 a a DT 40436 10891 44 Blackfoot Blackfoot NNP 40436 10891 45 Indian Indian NNP 40436 10891 46 . . . 40436 10892 1 Not not RB 40436 10892 2 a a DT 40436 10892 3 single single JJ 40436 10892 4 one one CD 40436 10892 5 of of IN 40436 10892 6 the the DT 40436 10892 7 many many JJ 40436 10892 8 sciences science NNS 40436 10892 9 in in IN 40436 10892 10 which which WDT 40436 10892 11 we -PRON- PRP 40436 10892 12 surpass surpass VBP 40436 10892 13 the the DT 40436 10892 14 Blackfoot Blackfoot NNP 40436 10892 15 Indians Indians NNPS 40436 10892 16 , , , 40436 10892 17 throws throw VBZ 40436 10892 18 the the DT 40436 10892 19 smallest small JJS 40436 10892 20 light light NN 40436 10892 21 on on IN 40436 10892 22 the the DT 40436 10892 23 state state NN 40436 10892 24 of of IN 40436 10892 25 the the DT 40436 10892 26 soul soul NN 40436 10892 27 after after IN 40436 10892 28 the the DT 40436 10892 29 animal animal NN 40436 10892 30 life life NN 40436 10892 31 is be VBZ 40436 10892 32 extinct extinct JJ 40436 10892 33 . . . 40436 10893 1 In in IN 40436 10893 2 truth truth NN 40436 10893 3 , , , 40436 10893 4 all all PDT 40436 10893 5 the the DT 40436 10893 6 philosophers philosopher NNS 40436 10893 7 , , , 40436 10893 8 ancient ancient JJ 40436 10893 9 and and CC 40436 10893 10 modern modern JJ 40436 10893 11 , , , 40436 10893 12 who who WP 40436 10893 13 have have VBP 40436 10893 14 attempted attempt VBN 40436 10893 15 , , , 40436 10893 16 without without IN 40436 10893 17 the the DT 40436 10893 18 help help NN 40436 10893 19 of of IN 40436 10893 20 revelation revelation NN 40436 10893 21 , , , 40436 10893 22 to to TO 40436 10893 23 prove prove VB 40436 10893 24 the the DT 40436 10893 25 immortality immortality NN 40436 10893 26 of of IN 40436 10893 27 man man NN 40436 10893 28 -- -- : 40436 10893 29 from from IN 40436 10893 30 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10893 31 down down IN 40436 10893 32 to to IN 40436 10893 33 Franklin Franklin NNP 40436 10893 34 -- -- : 40436 10893 35 appear appear VB 40436 10893 36 to to IN 40436 10893 37 us -PRON- PRP 40436 10893 38 to to TO 40436 10893 39 have have VB 40436 10893 40 failed fail VBN 40436 10893 41 deplorably deplorably RB 40436 10893 42 . . . 40436 10894 1 Then then RB 40436 10894 2 again again RB 40436 10894 3 , , , 40436 10894 4 all all PDT 40436 10894 5 the the DT 40436 10894 6 great great JJ 40436 10894 7 enigmas enigmas NN 40436 10894 8 which which WDT 40436 10894 9 perplex perplex VBP 40436 10894 10 the the DT 40436 10894 11 natural natural JJ 40436 10894 12 theologian theologian NN 40436 10894 13 are be VBP 40436 10894 14 the the DT 40436 10894 15 same same JJ 40436 10894 16 in in IN 40436 10894 17 all all DT 40436 10894 18 ages age NNS 40436 10894 19 . . . 40436 10895 1 The the DT 40436 10895 2 ingenuity ingenuity NN 40436 10895 3 of of IN 40436 10895 4 a a DT 40436 10895 5 people people NNS 40436 10895 6 just just RB 40436 10895 7 emerging emerge VBG 40436 10895 8 from from IN 40436 10895 9 barbarism barbarism NN 40436 10895 10 , , , 40436 10895 11 is be VBZ 40436 10895 12 quite quite RB 40436 10895 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 40436 10895 14 to to TO 40436 10895 15 propound propound VB 40436 10895 16 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10895 17 . . . 40436 10896 1 The the DT 40436 10896 2 genius genius NN 40436 10896 3 of of IN 40436 10896 4 Locke Locke NNP 40436 10896 5 or or CC 40436 10896 6 Clarke Clarke NNP 40436 10896 7 is be VBZ 40436 10896 8 quite quite RB 40436 10896 9 unable unable JJ 40436 10896 10 to to TO 40436 10896 11 solve solve VB 40436 10896 12 them -PRON- PRP 40436 10896 13 . . . 40436 10897 1 . . . 40436 10898 1 . . . 40436 10899 1 . . . 40436 10900 1 Natural Natural NNP 40436 10900 2 Theology Theology NNP 40436 10900 3 , , , 40436 10900 4 then then RB 40436 10900 5 , , , 40436 10900 6 is be VBZ 40436 10900 7 not not RB 40436 10900 8 a a DT 40436 10900 9 progressive progressive JJ 40436 10900 10 science science NN 40436 10900 11 . . . 40436 10901 1 " " `` 40436 10901 2 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10901 3 115 115 CD 40436 10901 4 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10901 5 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10901 6 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10901 7 114 114 CD 40436 10901 8 : : : 40436 10901 9 Seneca Seneca NNP 40436 10901 10 says say VBZ 40436 10901 11 , , , 40436 10901 12 Epist epist NN 40436 10901 13 . . . 40436 10902 1 88 88 CD 40436 10902 2 . . . 40436 10903 1 " " `` 40436 10903 2 Innumerabiles innumerabile NNS 40436 10903 3 sunt sunt NN 40436 10903 4 quæstiones quæstione NNS 40436 10903 5 de de FW 40436 10903 6 animo animo NNP 40436 10903 7 : : : 40436 10903 8 unde unde NNP 40436 10903 9 sit sit NNP 40436 10903 10 , , , 40436 10903 11 qualis qualis NNP 40436 10903 12 sit sit VBP 40436 10903 13 , , , 40436 10903 14 quando quando NNP 40436 10903 15 esse esse NNP 40436 10903 16 incipiat incipiat NNP 40436 10903 17 , , , 40436 10903 18 quamdiu quamdiu NNP 40436 10903 19 sit sit VBP 40436 10903 20 ; ; : 40436 10903 21 an an DT 40436 10903 22 aliunde aliunde NNP 40436 10903 23 aliò aliò NNP 40436 10903 24 transeat transeat VBP 40436 10903 25 , , , 40436 10903 26 et et NN 40436 10903 27 domicilium domicilium NN 40436 10903 28 mutet mutet NN 40436 10903 29 , , , 40436 10903 30 ad ad NN 40436 10903 31 alias alias NNP 40436 10903 32 animalium animalium NNP 40436 10903 33 formas formas NNP 40436 10903 34 aliasque aliasque NNP 40436 10903 35 conjectus conjectus NNP 40436 10903 36 , , , 40436 10903 37 an an DT 40436 10903 38 non non AFX 40436 10903 39 amplius amplius NN 40436 10903 40 quam quam NNP 40436 10903 41 semel semel NNP 40436 10903 42 serviat serviat NNP 40436 10903 43 , , , 40436 10903 44 et et NN 40436 10903 45 emissus emissus NN 40436 10903 46 evagetur evagetur NNP 40436 10903 47 in in IN 40436 10903 48 toto toto NN 40436 10903 49 ; ; : 40436 10903 50 utrum utrum NNP 40436 10903 51 corpus corpus NNP 40436 10903 52 sit sit NNP 40436 10903 53 , , , 40436 10903 54 an an DT 40436 10903 55 non non AFX 40436 10903 56 sit sit NN 40436 10903 57 : : : 40436 10903 58 quid quid NNP 40436 10903 59 sit sit NNP 40436 10903 60 facturus facturus NN 40436 10903 61 , , , 40436 10903 62 quum quum NN 40436 10903 63 per per IN 40436 10903 64 nos nos NNP 40436 10903 65 aliquid aliquid NNP 40436 10903 66 facere facere JJ 40436 10903 67 desierit desierit NN 40436 10903 68 : : : 40436 10903 69 quomodo quomodo VB 40436 10903 70 libertate libertate JJ 40436 10903 71 usurus usurus NNP 40436 10903 72 , , , 40436 10903 73 cum cum NNP 40436 10903 74 ex ex NNP 40436 10903 75 hâc hâc NNP 40436 10903 76 exierit exierit NNP 40436 10903 77 caveâ caveâ NN 40436 10903 78 : : : 40436 10903 79 an an DT 40436 10903 80 obliviscatur obliviscatur JJ 40436 10903 81 priorum priorum NNP 40436 10903 82 et et NNP 40436 10903 83 illic illic NNP 40436 10903 84 nosse nosse NNP 40436 10903 85 incipiat incipiat NNP 40436 10903 86 , , , 40436 10903 87 postquam postquam NNP 40436 10903 88 de de NNP 40436 10903 89 corpore corpore NNP 40436 10903 90 abductus abductus NNP 40436 10903 91 in in IN 40436 10903 92 sublime sublime JJ 40436 10903 93 secessit secessit NN 40436 10903 94 . . . 40436 10903 95 " " '' 40436 10904 1 Compare Compare NNP 40436 10904 2 Lucretius Lucretius NNP 40436 10904 3 , , , 40436 10904 4 i. i. NNP 40436 10905 1 113 113 CD 40436 10905 2 . . . 40436 10905 3 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10906 1 [ [ -LRB- 40436 10906 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 40436 10906 3 115 115 CD 40436 10906 4 : : : 40436 10906 5 Macaulay Macaulay NNP 40436 10906 6 , , , 40436 10906 7 Ranke Ranke NNP 40436 10906 8 's 's POS 40436 10906 9 History history NN 40436 10906 10 of of IN 40436 10906 11 the the DT 40436 10906 12 Popes Popes NNPS 40436 10906 13 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10906 14 Crit Crit NNP 40436 10906 15 . . . 40436 10907 1 and and CC 40436 10907 2 Hist Hist NNP 40436 10907 3 . . . 40436 10908 1 Essays Essays NNP 40436 10908 2 , , , 40436 10908 3 vol vol NNP 40436 10908 4 . . . 40436 10909 1 iii iii NNP 40436 10909 2 . . . 40436 10910 1 p. p. NN 40436 10910 2 210 210 CD 40436 10910 3 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10910 4 . . . 40436 10911 1 Sir Sir NNP 40436 10911 2 Wm Wm NNP 40436 10911 3 . . . 40436 10912 1 Hamilton Hamilton NNP 40436 10912 2 observes observe VBZ 40436 10912 3 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10912 4 Lectures Lectures NNP 40436 10912 5 on on IN 40436 10912 6 Logic Logic NNP 40436 10912 7 , , , 40436 10912 8 Lect Lect NNP 40436 10912 9 . . . 40436 10913 1 26 26 CD 40436 10913 2 , , , 40436 10913 3 p. p. NN 40436 10913 4 55 55 CD 40436 10913 5 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10913 6 : : : 40436 10913 7 " " `` 40436 10913 8 Thus thus RB 40436 10913 9 Plato Plato NNP 40436 10913 10 , , , 40436 10913 11 in in IN 40436 10913 12 the the DT 40436 10913 13 Phædon Phædon NNP 40436 10913 14 , , , 40436 10913 15 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 40436 10913 16 the the DT 40436 10913 17 immortality immortality NN 40436 10913 18 of of IN 40436 10913 19 the the DT 40436 10913 20 soul soul NN 40436 10913 21 from from IN 40436 10913 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10913 23 simplicity simplicity NN 40436 10913 24 : : : 40436 10913 25 in in IN 40436 10913 26 the the DT 40436 10913 27 Republic Republic NNP 40436 10913 28 , , , 40436 10913 29 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10913 30 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 40436 10913 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10913 32 simplicity simplicity NN 40436 10913 33 from from IN 40436 10913 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 40436 10913 35 immortality immortality NN 40436 10913 36 . . . 40436 10913 37 " " '' 40436 10913 38 ] ] -RRB- 40436 10914 1 END END NNP 40436 10914 2 OF of IN 40436 10914 3 VOL VOL NNP 40436 10914 4 . . . 40436 10915 1 II ii CD 40436 10915 2 . . . 40436 10916 1 * * NFP 40436 10916 2 * * NFP 40436 10916 3 * * NFP 40436 10916 4 * * NFP 40436 10916 5 * * NFP 40436 10916 6 * * NFP 40436 10916 7 * * NFP 40436 10916 8 * * NFP 40436 10916 9 * * NFP 40436 10916 10 * * NFP 40436 10916 11 * * NFP 40436 10916 12 * * NFP 40436 10916 13 * * NFP 40436 10916 14 * * NFP 40436 10916 15 * * NFP 40436 10916 16 * * NFP 40436 10916 17 * * NFP 40436 10916 18 * * NFP 40436 10916 19 * * NFP 40436 10916 20 * * NFP 40436 10916 21 * * NFP 40436 10916 22 * * NFP 40436 10916 23 * * NFP 40436 10916 24 * * NFP 40436 10916 25 * * NFP 40436 10916 26 * * NFP 40436 10916 27 * * NFP 40436 10916 28 * * NFP 40436 10916 29 * * NFP 40436 10916 30 * * NFP 40436 10916 31 * * NFP 40436 10916 32 * * NFP 40436 10916 33 * * NFP 40436 10916 34 * * NFP 40436 10916 35 * * NFP 40436 10916 36 * * NFP 40436 10916 37 * * NFP 40436 10916 38 Transcriber Transcriber NNP 40436 10916 39 's 's POS 40436 10916 40 Note Note NNP 40436 10916 41 The the DT 40436 10916 42 text text NN 40436 10916 43 is be VBZ 40436 10916 44 based base VBN 40436 10916 45 on on IN 40436 10916 46 versions version NNS 40436 10916 47 made make VBN 40436 10916 48 available available JJ 40436 10916 49 by by IN 40436 10916 50 the the DT 40436 10916 51 Internet Internet NNP 40436 10916 52 Archive Archive NNP 40436 10916 53 . . . 40436 10917 1 For for IN 40436 10917 2 the the DT 40436 10917 3 Greek greek JJ 40436 10917 4 transcriptions transcription NNS 40436 10917 5 the the DT 40436 10917 6 following follow VBG 40436 10917 7 conventions convention NNS 40436 10917 8 have have VBP 40436 10917 9 been be VBN 40436 10917 10 used use VBN 40436 10917 11 : : : 40436 10917 12 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10917 13 is be VBZ 40436 10917 14 for for IN 40436 10917 15 smooth smooth JJ 40436 10917 16 breathing breathing NN 40436 10917 17 ; ; : 40436 10917 18 ( ( -LRB- 40436 10917 19 for for IN 40436 10917 20 hard hard RB 40436 10917 21 ; ; : 40436 10917 22 + + CC 40436 10917 23 for for IN 40436 10917 24 diaeresis diaeresis NN 40436 10917 25 ; ; , 40436 10917 26 / / , 40436 10917 27 for for IN 40436 10917 28 acute acute JJ 40436 10917 29 accent accent NN 40436 10917 30 ; ; : 40436 10917 31 \ \ VB 40436 10917 32 for for IN 40436 10917 33 grave grave NN 40436 10917 34 ; ; : 40436 10917 35 = = NFP 40436 10917 36 for for IN 40436 10917 37 circumflex circumflex NN 40436 10917 38 ; ; : 40436 10917 39 | | NNP 40436 10917 40 for for IN 40436 10917 41 iota iota NNP 40436 10917 42 subscript subscript NNP 40436 10917 43 . . . 40436 10918 1 ch ch NNP 40436 10918 2 is be VBZ 40436 10918 3 used use VBN 40436 10918 4 for for IN 40436 10918 5 chi chi NNP 40436 10918 6 , , , 40436 10918 7 ph ph NNP 40436 10918 8 for for IN 40436 10918 9 phi phi NNP 40436 10918 10 , , , 40436 10918 11 ps ps NNP 40436 10918 12 for for IN 40436 10918 13 psi psi NNP 40436 10918 14 , , , 40436 10918 15 th th XX 40436 10918 16 for for IN 40436 10918 17 theta theta NN 40436 10918 18 ; ; : 40436 10918 19 ê ê NNP 40436 10918 20 for for IN 40436 10918 21 eta eta NNP 40436 10918 22 and and CC 40436 10918 23 ô ô NNP 40436 10918 24 for for IN 40436 10918 25 omega omega NN 40436 10918 26 ; ; : 40436 10918 27 u u NNP 40436 10918 28 is be VBZ 40436 10918 29 used use VBN 40436 10918 30 for for IN 40436 10918 31 upsilon upsilon NN 40436 10918 32 in in IN 40436 10918 33 all all DT 40436 10918 34 cases case NNS 40436 10918 35 . . . 40436 10919 1 Corrections correction NNS 40436 10919 2 to to IN 40436 10919 3 the the DT 40436 10919 4 text text NN 40436 10919 5 , , , 40436 10919 6 indicated indicate VBN 40436 10919 7 in in IN 40436 10919 8 text text NN 40436 10919 9 with with IN 40436 10919 10 * * NFP 40436 10919 11 * * NFP 40436 10919 12 : : : 40436 10919 13 Location Location NNP 40436 10919 14 Text Text NNP 40436 10919 15 of of IN 40436 10919 16 scan scan NNP 40436 10919 17 of of IN 40436 10919 18 3rd 3rd NNP 40436 10919 19 edition edition NNP 40436 10919 20 Correction Correction NNP 40436 10919 21 ToC toc NN 40436 10919 22 , , , 40436 10919 23 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10919 24 . . . 40436 10920 1 13 13 CD 40436 10920 2 s s NNPS 40436 10920 3 - - SYM 40436 10920 4 n n JJ 40436 10920 5 3 3 CD 40436 10920 6 Minor Minor NNP 40436 10920 7 Major Major NNP 40436 10920 8 ToC toc NN 40436 10920 9 , , , 40436 10920 10 Ch ch NN 40436 10920 11 . . . 40436 10921 1 14 14 CD 40436 10921 2 s s NNP 40436 10921 3 - - HYPH 40436 10921 4 n n NNP 40436 10921 5 24 24 CD 40436 10921 6 _ _ NNP 40436 10921 7 pain pain NN 40436 10921 8 _ _ NNP 40436 10921 9 _ _ NNP 40436 10921 10 gain gain NN 40436 10921 11 _ _ NNP 40436 10921 12 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10921 13 . . . 40436 10922 1 13 13 CD 40436 10922 2 fn fn CD 40436 10922 3 . . . 40436 10923 1 40 40 CD 40436 10923 2 iv iv CD 40436 10923 3 . . . 40436 10924 1 4 4 CD 40436 10924 2 , , , 40436 10924 3 5 5 CD 40436 10924 4 ; ; : 40436 10924 5 iv iv LS 40436 10924 6 . . . 40436 10925 1 4 4 CD 40436 10925 2 , , , 40436 10925 3 5 5 CD 40436 10925 4 , , , 40436 10925 5 p. p. NN 40436 10925 6 220 220 CD 40436 10925 7 seq seq NN 40436 10925 8 . . . 40436 10926 1 ) ) -RRB- 40436 10926 2 ; ; : 40436 10926 3 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10926 4 . . . 40436 10927 1 13 13 CD 40436 10927 2 near near IN 40436 10927 3 fn fn NNP 40436 10927 4 . . . 40436 10928 1 46 46 CD 40436 10928 2 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10928 3 was be VBD 40436 10928 4 even even RB 40436 10928 5 fit fit JJ 40436 10928 6 he -PRON- PRP 40436 10928 7 was be VBD 40436 10928 8 not not RB 40436 10928 9 even even RB 40436 10928 10 fit fit JJ 40436 10928 11 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10928 12 . . . 40436 10929 1 17 17 CD 40436 10929 2 near near JJ 40436 10929 3 fn fn NNP 40436 10929 4 . . . 40436 10930 1 3 3 CD 40436 10930 2 fulfiling fulfil VBG 40436 10930 3 fulfilling fulfil VBG 40436 10930 4 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10930 5 . . . 40436 10931 1 19 19 CD 40436 10931 2 after after IN 40436 10931 3 fn fn CD 40436 10931 4 . . . 40436 10932 1 32 32 CD 40436 10932 2 sixth sixth JJ 40436 10932 3 eighth eighth JJ 40436 10932 4 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10932 5 . . . 40436 10933 1 19 19 CD 40436 10933 2 fn fn CD 40436 10933 3 . . . 40436 10934 1 44 44 CD 40436 10934 2 p. p. NN 40436 10934 3 . . . 40436 10935 1 p. p. NN 40436 10935 2 31 31 CD 40436 10935 3 . . . 40436 10936 1 Ch ch NN 40436 10936 2 . . . 40436 10937 1 20 20 CD 40436 10937 2 after after IN 40436 10937 3 fn fn CD 40436 10937 4 . . . 40436 10938 1 13 13 CD 40436 10938 2 aud aud NNP 40436 10938 3 and and CC 40436 10938 4 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10938 5 . . . 40436 10939 1 22 22 CD 40436 10939 2 after after IN 40436 10939 3 fn fn CD 40436 10939 4 . . . 40436 10940 1 47 47 CD 40436 10940 2 sixth sixth JJ 40436 10940 3 eighth eighth JJ 40436 10940 4 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10940 5 . . . 40436 10941 1 23 23 CD 40436 10941 2 fn fn CD 40436 10941 3 . . . 40436 10942 1 134 134 CD 40436 10942 2 p. p. NN 40436 10942 3 240 240 CD 40436 10942 4 p. p. NN 40436 10942 5 242 242 CD 40436 10942 6 Ch ch NN 40436 10942 7 . . . 40436 10943 1 23 23 CD 40436 10943 2 fn fn CD 40436 10943 3 . . . 40436 10944 1 135 135 CD 40436 10944 2 ch ch NN 40436 10944 3 . . . 40436 10945 1 xviii xviii NNP 40436 10945 2 ch ch NNP 40436 10945 3 . . . 40436 10946 1 xvii xvii NNP 40436 10946 2 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10946 3 . . . 40436 10947 1 24 24 CD 40436 10947 2 fn fn CD 40436 10947 3 . . . 40436 10948 1 75 75 CD 40436 10948 2 Pratagoras pratagora NNS 40436 10948 3 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 40436 10948 4 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10948 5 . . . 40436 10949 1 24 24 CD 40436 10949 2 fn fn CD 40436 10949 3 . . . 40436 10950 1 77 77 CD 40436 10950 2 a)nro a)nro NNS 40436 10950 3 / / SYM 40436 10950 4 s s NNP 40436 10950 5 a)ndro a)ndro NNP 40436 10950 6 / / SYM 40436 10950 7 s s NNP 40436 10950 8 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10950 9 . . . 40436 10951 1 24 24 CD 40436 10951 2 fn fn CD 40436 10951 3 . . . 40436 10952 1 86 86 CD 40436 10952 2 Die die VBP 40436 10952 3 _ _ NNP 40436 10952 4 Dialoge Dialoge NNP 40436 10952 5 ... ... : 40436 10952 6 _ _ NNP 40436 10952 7 _ _ NNP 40436 10952 8 Die Die NNP 40436 10952 9 Dialoge Dialoge NNP 40436 10952 10 ... ... . 40436 10952 11 _ _ NNP 40436 10952 12 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10952 13 . . . 40436 10953 1 25 25 CD 40436 10953 2 after after IN 40436 10953 3 fn fn CD 40436 10953 4 . . . 40436 10954 1 58 58 CD 40436 10954 2 intellegible intellegible JJ 40436 10954 3 intelligible intelligible JJ 40436 10954 4 Ch Ch NNP 40436 10954 5 . . . 40436 10955 1 25 25 CD 40436 10955 2 after after IN 40436 10955 3 fn fn CD 40436 10955 4 . . . 40436 10956 1 110 110 CD 40436 10956 2 alloted allot VBN 40436 10956 3 allotted allot VBD