id author title date pages extension mime words sentences flesch summary cache txt work_eo5lzcdjwrcbfmdlfmolkjxac4 L. Nathan Oaklander Particulars, Positional Qualities, and Individuation 1977 13 .pdf application/pdf 5791 358 57 and Hausman against positional qualities and for bare particulars as individuators is unsound. Gustav Bergmann and Alan Hausman have argued that bare particulars are the only entities that can provide a dialectically adequate to it an ordinary thing consists of a bare particular joined to universals requires bare particulars and that nothing else can ground individuation particular be a constituent of more than one ordinary thing?" Bergmann a bare particular be "in" more than one ordinary thing?" Or, to a bare particular be "in" more than one ordinary thing?" Or, to a bare particular be "in" more than one ordinary thing?" Or, to a bare particular be "in" more than one ordinary thing?" Or, to a bare particular be "in" more than one ordinary thing?" Or, to individual constant sign refers to a different bare particular. things with bare particulars then it is categorially impossible for one bare particulars and positional qualities provide categorially different ./cache/work_eo5lzcdjwrcbfmdlfmolkjxac4.pdf ./txt/work_eo5lzcdjwrcbfmdlfmolkjxac4.txt