id sid tid token lemma pos opencontent-org-7427 1 1 Open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 1 2 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 3 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 4 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 5 – – : opencontent-org-7427 1 6 iterating iterate VBG opencontent-org-7427 1 7 toward toward IN opencontent-org-7427 1 8 openness openness NN opencontent-org-7427 1 9 Skip Skip NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 10 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 1 11 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 1 12 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 1 13 iterating iterate VBG opencontent-org-7427 1 14 toward toward IN opencontent-org-7427 1 15 openness openness NN opencontent-org-7427 1 16 pragmatism pragmatism NN opencontent-org-7427 1 17 before before IN opencontent-org-7427 1 18 zeal zeal NN opencontent-org-7427 1 19 Menu Menu MD opencontent-org-7427 1 20 Close Close NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 21 Menu Menu NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 22 Categories Categories NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 23 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 1 24 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 1 25 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 26 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 27 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 28 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 29 Post Post NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 30 author author NN opencontent-org-7427 1 31 By by IN opencontent-org-7427 1 32 david david NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 33 Post Post NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 34 date date NN opencontent-org-7427 1 35 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 36 8 8 CD opencontent-org-7427 1 37 , , , opencontent-org-7427 1 38 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 1 39 19 19 CD opencontent-org-7427 1 40 Comments comment NNS opencontent-org-7427 1 41 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 1 42 Open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 1 43 Education education NN opencontent-org-7427 1 44 License license NN opencontent-org-7427 1 45 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 1 46 If if IN opencontent-org-7427 1 47 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 1 48 follow follow VBP opencontent-org-7427 1 49 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 1 50 blog blog NN opencontent-org-7427 1 51 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 1 52 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 1 53 regularity regularity NN opencontent-org-7427 1 54 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 1 55 ’ll will MD opencontent-org-7427 1 56 have have VB opencontent-org-7427 1 57 seen see VBN opencontent-org-7427 1 58 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 1 59 coming come VBG opencontent-org-7427 1 60 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 1 61 several several JJ opencontent-org-7427 1 62 weeks week NNS opencontent-org-7427 1 63 now now RB opencontent-org-7427 1 64 . . . opencontent-org-7427 2 1 When when WRB opencontent-org-7427 2 2 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 2 3 began begin VBD opencontent-org-7427 2 4 recommending recommend VBG opencontent-org-7427 2 5 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 2 6 people people NNS opencontent-org-7427 2 7 quit quit VBP opencontent-org-7427 2 8 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 2 9 OpenContent OpenContent NNP opencontent-org-7427 2 10 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 2 11 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 2 12 developed develop VBN opencontent-org-7427 2 13 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 2 14 98 98 CD opencontent-org-7427 2 15 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 2 16 99 99 CD opencontent-org-7427 2 17 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 2 18 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 2 19 begin begin VB opencontent-org-7427 2 20 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 2 21 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 2 22 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 2 23 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 2 24 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 2 25 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 2 26 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 2 27 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 2 28 2003 2003 CD opencontent-org-7427 2 29 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 2 30 , , , opencontent-org-7427 2 31 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 2 32 said say VBD opencontent-org-7427 2 33 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 2 34 was be VBD opencontent-org-7427 2 35 one one CD opencontent-org-7427 2 36 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 2 37 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 2 38 hardest hard JJS opencontent-org-7427 2 39 things thing NNS opencontent-org-7427 2 40 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 2 41 had have VBD opencontent-org-7427 2 42 ever ever RB opencontent-org-7427 2 43 done do VBN opencontent-org-7427 2 44 . . . opencontent-org-7427 3 1 And and CC opencontent-org-7427 3 2 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 3 3 was be VBD opencontent-org-7427 3 4 . . . opencontent-org-7427 4 1 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 4 2 More More JJR opencontent-org-7427 4 3 background background NN opencontent-org-7427 4 4 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 4 5 . . . opencontent-org-7427 5 1 Today today NN opencontent-org-7427 5 2 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 5 3 take take VBP opencontent-org-7427 5 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 5 5 lid lid NN opencontent-org-7427 5 6 off off IN opencontent-org-7427 5 7 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 5 8 next next JJ opencontent-org-7427 5 9 most most RBS opencontent-org-7427 5 10 difficult difficult JJ opencontent-org-7427 5 11 thing thing NN opencontent-org-7427 5 12 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 5 13 ’ve have VB opencontent-org-7427 5 14 done do VBN opencontent-org-7427 5 15 . . . opencontent-org-7427 6 1 As as IN opencontent-org-7427 6 2 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 6 3 describe describe VBP opencontent-org-7427 6 4 below below RB opencontent-org-7427 6 5 , , , opencontent-org-7427 6 6 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 6 7 hate hate VBP opencontent-org-7427 6 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 6 9 idea idea NN opencontent-org-7427 6 10 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 6 11 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 6 12 proliferation proliferation NN opencontent-org-7427 6 13 . . . opencontent-org-7427 7 1 However however RB opencontent-org-7427 7 2 , , , opencontent-org-7427 7 3 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 7 4 feel feel VBP opencontent-org-7427 7 5 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 7 6 there there EX opencontent-org-7427 7 7 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 7 8 several several JJ opencontent-org-7427 7 9 convincing convincing JJ opencontent-org-7427 7 10 arguments argument NNS opencontent-org-7427 7 11 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 7 12 we -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 7 13 need need VBP opencontent-org-7427 7 14 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 7 15 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 7 16 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 7 17 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 7 18 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 7 19 point point NN opencontent-org-7427 7 20 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 7 21 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 7 22 history history NN opencontent-org-7427 7 23 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 7 24 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 7 25 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 7 26 , , , opencontent-org-7427 7 27 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 7 28 specifically specifically RB opencontent-org-7427 7 29 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 7 30 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 7 31 history history NN opencontent-org-7427 7 32 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 7 33 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 7 34 education education NN opencontent-org-7427 7 35 . . . opencontent-org-7427 8 1 After after IN opencontent-org-7427 8 2 providing provide VBG opencontent-org-7427 8 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 8 4 arguments argument NNS opencontent-org-7427 8 5 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 8 6 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 8 7 thoughts thought NNS opencontent-org-7427 8 8 below below RB opencontent-org-7427 8 9 , , , opencontent-org-7427 8 10 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 8 11 ’ll will MD opencontent-org-7427 8 12 find find VB opencontent-org-7427 8 13 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 8 14 draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 8 15 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 8 16 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 8 17 first first JJ opencontent-org-7427 8 18 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 8 19 issued issue VBN opencontent-org-7427 8 20 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 8 21 OpenContent OpenContent NNP opencontent-org-7427 8 22 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 8 23 eight eight CD opencontent-org-7427 8 24 years year NNS opencontent-org-7427 8 25 – – : opencontent-org-7427 8 26 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 8 27 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 8 28 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 8 29 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 8 30 . . . opencontent-org-7427 9 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 9 2 Four four CD opencontent-org-7427 9 3 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 9 4 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 9 5 Open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 9 6 Content content NN opencontent-org-7427 9 7 When when WRB opencontent-org-7427 9 8 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 9 9 began begin VBD opencontent-org-7427 9 10 promoting promote VBG opencontent-org-7427 9 11 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 9 12 idea idea NN opencontent-org-7427 9 13 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 9 14 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 9 15 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 9 16 almost almost RB opencontent-org-7427 9 17 10 10 CD opencontent-org-7427 9 18 years year NNS opencontent-org-7427 9 19 ago ago RB opencontent-org-7427 9 20 , , , opencontent-org-7427 9 21 there there EX opencontent-org-7427 9 22 were be VBD opencontent-org-7427 9 23 four four CD opencontent-org-7427 9 24 main main JJ opencontent-org-7427 9 25 types type NNS opencontent-org-7427 9 26 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 9 27 activity activity NN opencontent-org-7427 9 28 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 9 29 was be VBD opencontent-org-7427 9 30 interested interested JJ opencontent-org-7427 9 31 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 9 32 promoting promote VBG opencontent-org-7427 9 33 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 9 34 although although IN opencontent-org-7427 9 35 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 9 36 took take VBD opencontent-org-7427 9 37 me -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 9 38 some some DT opencontent-org-7427 9 39 time time NN opencontent-org-7427 9 40 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 9 41 get get VB opencontent-org-7427 9 42 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 9 43 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 9 44 point point NN opencontent-org-7427 9 45 where where WRB opencontent-org-7427 9 46 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 9 47 could could MD opencontent-org-7427 9 48 articulate articulate VB opencontent-org-7427 9 49 them -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 9 50 clearly clearly RB opencontent-org-7427 9 51 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 9 52 . . . opencontent-org-7427 10 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 2 four four CD opencontent-org-7427 10 3 main main JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 4 types type NNS opencontent-org-7427 10 5 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 10 6 activity activity NN opencontent-org-7427 10 7 enabled enable VBN opencontent-org-7427 10 8 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 10 9 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 10 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 10 11 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 10 12 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 10 13 summarized summarize VBN opencontent-org-7427 10 14 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 10 15 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 10 16 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 17 four four CD opencontent-org-7427 10 18 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 10 19 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 10 20 : : : opencontent-org-7427 10 21 Reuse reuse VB opencontent-org-7427 10 22 – – : opencontent-org-7427 10 23 Use use VB opencontent-org-7427 10 24 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 25 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 10 26 verbatim verbatim NN opencontent-org-7427 10 27 , , , opencontent-org-7427 10 28 just just RB opencontent-org-7427 10 29 exactly exactly RB opencontent-org-7427 10 30 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 10 31 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 10 32 found find VBD opencontent-org-7427 10 33 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 10 34 Rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 10 35 – – : opencontent-org-7427 10 36 Alter alter VB opencontent-org-7427 10 37 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 10 38 transform transform VB opencontent-org-7427 10 39 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 40 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 10 41 so so IN opencontent-org-7427 10 42 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 10 43 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 10 44 better well RBR opencontent-org-7427 10 45 meets meet VBZ opencontent-org-7427 10 46 your -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 10 47 needs need NNS opencontent-org-7427 10 48 Remix Remix NNP opencontent-org-7427 10 49 – – : opencontent-org-7427 10 50 Combine combine VB opencontent-org-7427 10 51 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 52 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 10 53 verbatim verbatim JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 54 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 10 55 altered altered JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 56 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 10 57 work work VB opencontent-org-7427 10 58 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 10 59 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 60 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 10 61 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 10 62 better well RBR opencontent-org-7427 10 63 meet meet VB opencontent-org-7427 10 64 your -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 10 65 needs need NNS opencontent-org-7427 10 66 Redistribute Redistribute NNP opencontent-org-7427 10 67 – – : opencontent-org-7427 10 68 Share share VB opencontent-org-7427 10 69 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 70 verbatim verbatim JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 71 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 10 72 , , , opencontent-org-7427 10 73 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 74 reworked reworked JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 75 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 10 76 , , , opencontent-org-7427 10 77 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 10 78 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 79 remixed remixed JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 80 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 10 81 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 10 82 others other NNS opencontent-org-7427 10 83 Notice notice VB opencontent-org-7427 10 84 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 10 85 each each DT opencontent-org-7427 10 86 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 10 87 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 10 88 first first JJ opencontent-org-7427 10 89 three three CD opencontent-org-7427 10 90 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 10 91 encompasses encompass VBZ opencontent-org-7427 10 92 those those DT opencontent-org-7427 10 93 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 10 94 came come VBD opencontent-org-7427 10 95 before before IN opencontent-org-7427 10 96 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 10 97 . . . opencontent-org-7427 11 1 Reusing reusing NN opencontent-org-7427 11 2 involves involve VBZ opencontent-org-7427 11 3 copying copying NN opencontent-org-7427 11 4 , , , opencontent-org-7427 11 5 displaying display VBG opencontent-org-7427 11 6 , , , opencontent-org-7427 11 7 performing perform VBG opencontent-org-7427 11 8 , , , opencontent-org-7427 11 9 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 11 10 making make VBG opencontent-org-7427 11 11 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 11 12 uses use NNS opencontent-org-7427 11 13 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 11 14 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 11 15 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 11 16 just just RB opencontent-org-7427 11 17 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 11 18 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 11 19 found find VBD opencontent-org-7427 11 20 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 11 21 . . . opencontent-org-7427 12 1 Reworking rework VBG opencontent-org-7427 12 2 involves involve VBZ opencontent-org-7427 12 3 altering alter VBG opencontent-org-7427 12 4 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 12 5 transforming transform VBG opencontent-org-7427 12 6 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 12 7 , , , opencontent-org-7427 12 8 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 12 9 one one PRP opencontent-org-7427 12 10 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 12 11 only only RB opencontent-org-7427 12 12 do do VB opencontent-org-7427 12 13 if if IN opencontent-org-7427 12 14 afterward afterward RB opencontent-org-7427 12 15 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 12 16 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 12 17 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 12 18 able able JJ opencontent-org-7427 12 19 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 12 20 reuse reuse VB opencontent-org-7427 12 21 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 12 22 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 12 23 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 12 24 . . . opencontent-org-7427 13 1 Remixing remixing NN opencontent-org-7427 13 2 involves involve VBZ opencontent-org-7427 13 3 creating create VBG opencontent-org-7427 13 4 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 13 5 mashup mashup NN opencontent-org-7427 13 6 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 13 7 several several JJ opencontent-org-7427 13 8 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 13 9 – – : opencontent-org-7427 13 10 some some DT opencontent-org-7427 13 11 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 13 12 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 13 13 will will MD opencontent-org-7427 13 14 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 13 15 reworked rework VBN opencontent-org-7427 13 16 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 13 17 part part NN opencontent-org-7427 13 18 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 13 19 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 13 20 remixing remixing NN opencontent-org-7427 13 21 process process NN opencontent-org-7427 13 22 – – : opencontent-org-7427 13 23 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 13 24 one one PRP opencontent-org-7427 13 25 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 13 26 only only RB opencontent-org-7427 13 27 do do VB opencontent-org-7427 13 28 if if IN opencontent-org-7427 13 29 afterward afterward RB opencontent-org-7427 13 30 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 13 31 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 13 32 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 13 33 able able JJ opencontent-org-7427 13 34 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 13 35 reuse reuse VB opencontent-org-7427 13 36 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 13 37 remix remix NNS opencontent-org-7427 13 38 . . . opencontent-org-7427 14 1 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 14 2 A a DT opencontent-org-7427 14 3 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 14 4 remix remix NN opencontent-org-7427 14 5 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 14 6 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 14 7 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 14 8 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 14 9 reworking reworking NN opencontent-org-7427 14 10 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 14 11 done do VBN opencontent-org-7427 14 12 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 14 13 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 14 14 anthology anthology NN opencontent-org-7427 14 15 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 14 16 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 14 17 collection collection NN opencontent-org-7427 14 18 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 14 19 simple simple JJ opencontent-org-7427 14 20 reuses reuse NNS opencontent-org-7427 14 21 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 14 22 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 14 23 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 14 24 particularly particularly RB opencontent-org-7427 14 25 interesting interesting JJ opencontent-org-7427 14 26 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 14 27 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 14 28 purposes purpose NNS opencontent-org-7427 14 29 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 14 30 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 14 31 discussion discussion NN opencontent-org-7427 14 32 . . . opencontent-org-7427 14 33 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 15 1 In in IN opencontent-org-7427 15 2 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 15 3 learning learning NN opencontent-org-7427 15 4 objects object NNS opencontent-org-7427 15 5 literature literature NN opencontent-org-7427 15 6 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 15 7 elsewhere elsewhere RB opencontent-org-7427 15 8 , , , opencontent-org-7427 15 9 endless endless JJ opencontent-org-7427 15 10 problems problem NNS opencontent-org-7427 15 11 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 15 12 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 15 13 caused cause VBN opencontent-org-7427 15 14 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 15 15 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 15 16 fact fact NN opencontent-org-7427 15 17 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 15 18 people people NNS opencontent-org-7427 15 19 say say VBP opencontent-org-7427 15 20 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 15 21 reuse reuse VB opencontent-org-7427 15 22 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 15 23 when when WRB opencontent-org-7427 15 24 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 15 25 actually actually RB opencontent-org-7427 15 26 mean mean VBP opencontent-org-7427 15 27 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 15 28 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 15 29 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 15 30 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 15 31 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 15 32 remix remix NN opencontent-org-7427 15 33 , , , opencontent-org-7427 15 34 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 15 35 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 15 36 some some DT opencontent-org-7427 15 37 combination combination NN opencontent-org-7427 15 38 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 15 39 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 15 40 first first JJ opencontent-org-7427 15 41 three three CD opencontent-org-7427 15 42 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 15 43 . . . opencontent-org-7427 16 1 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 16 2 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 16 3 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 16 4 classic classic JJ opencontent-org-7427 16 5 problem problem NN opencontent-org-7427 16 6 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 16 7 imprecision imprecision NN opencontent-org-7427 16 8 ; ; : opencontent-org-7427 16 9 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 16 10 talking talk VBG opencontent-org-7427 16 11 fast fast RB opencontent-org-7427 16 12 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 16 13 loose loose JJ opencontent-org-7427 16 14 . . . opencontent-org-7427 17 1 Add add VB opencontent-org-7427 17 2 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 17 3 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 17 4 difficulty difficulty NN opencontent-org-7427 17 5 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 17 6 fact fact NN opencontent-org-7427 17 7 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 17 8 each each DT opencontent-org-7427 17 9 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 17 10 these these DT opencontent-org-7427 17 11 three three CD opencontent-org-7427 17 12 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 17 13 thrives thrive VBZ opencontent-org-7427 17 14 under under IN opencontent-org-7427 17 15 different different JJ opencontent-org-7427 17 16 conditions condition NNS opencontent-org-7427 17 17 , , , opencontent-org-7427 17 18 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 17 19 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 17 20 ’ve have VB opencontent-org-7427 17 21 got get VBN opencontent-org-7427 17 22 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 17 23 recipe recipe NN opencontent-org-7427 17 24 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 17 25 general general JJ opencontent-org-7427 17 26 confusion confusion NN opencontent-org-7427 17 27 . . . opencontent-org-7427 18 1 For for IN opencontent-org-7427 18 2 example example NN opencontent-org-7427 18 3 , , , opencontent-org-7427 18 4 take take VBP opencontent-org-7427 18 5 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 18 6 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 18 7 . . . opencontent-org-7427 18 8 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 18 9 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 18 10 R r NN opencontent-org-7427 18 11 deals deal VBZ opencontent-org-7427 18 12 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 18 13 creating create VBG opencontent-org-7427 18 14 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 18 15 derivative derivative NN opencontent-org-7427 18 16 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 18 17 altering alter VBG opencontent-org-7427 18 18 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 18 19 adapting adapt VBG opencontent-org-7427 18 20 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 18 21 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 18 22 . . . opencontent-org-7427 19 1 Traditionally traditionally RB opencontent-org-7427 19 2 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 19 3 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 19 4 tried try VBN opencontent-org-7427 19 5 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 19 6 strengthen strengthen VB opencontent-org-7427 19 7 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 19 8 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 19 9 activity activity NN opencontent-org-7427 19 10 through through IN opencontent-org-7427 19 11 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 19 12 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 19 13 copyleft copyleft NN opencontent-org-7427 19 14 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 19 15 mechanism mechanism NN opencontent-org-7427 19 16 . . . opencontent-org-7427 20 1 Copyleft Copyleft NNP opencontent-org-7427 20 2 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 20 3 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 20 4 idea idea NN opencontent-org-7427 20 5 borrowed borrow VBN opencontent-org-7427 20 6 directly directly RB opencontent-org-7427 20 7 from from IN opencontent-org-7427 20 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 20 9 world world NN opencontent-org-7427 20 10 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 20 11 free free JJ opencontent-org-7427 20 12 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 20 13 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 20 14 source source NN opencontent-org-7427 20 15 software software NN opencontent-org-7427 20 16 , , , opencontent-org-7427 20 17 requiring require VBG opencontent-org-7427 20 18 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 20 19 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 20 20 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 20 21 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 20 22 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 20 23 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 20 24 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 20 25 exact exact JJ opencontent-org-7427 20 26 same same JJ opencontent-org-7427 20 27 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 20 28 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 20 29 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 20 30 original original NN opencontent-org-7427 20 31 . . . opencontent-org-7427 21 1 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 21 2 insures insure VBZ opencontent-org-7427 21 3 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 21 4 when when WRB opencontent-org-7427 21 5 derivatives derivative NNS opencontent-org-7427 21 6 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 21 7 created create VBN opencontent-org-7427 21 8 from from IN opencontent-org-7427 21 9 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 21 10 copylefted copylefte VBN opencontent-org-7427 21 11 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 21 12 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 21 13 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 21 14 , , , opencontent-org-7427 21 15 those those DT opencontent-org-7427 21 16 children child NNS opencontent-org-7427 21 17 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 21 18 grandchildren grandchild NNS opencontent-org-7427 21 19 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 21 20 remain remain VBP opencontent-org-7427 21 21 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 21 22 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 21 23 , , , opencontent-org-7427 21 24 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 21 25 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 21 26 exactly exactly RB opencontent-org-7427 21 27 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 21 28 same same JJ opencontent-org-7427 21 29 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 21 30 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 21 31 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 21 32 original original NN opencontent-org-7427 21 33 . . . opencontent-org-7427 22 1 However however RB opencontent-org-7427 22 2 , , , opencontent-org-7427 22 3 while while IN opencontent-org-7427 22 4 copyleft copyleft VBN opencontent-org-7427 22 5 strictly strictly RB opencontent-org-7427 22 6 requires require VBZ opencontent-org-7427 22 7 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 22 8 all all DT opencontent-org-7427 22 9 future future JJ opencontent-org-7427 22 10 generations generation NNS opencontent-org-7427 22 11 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 22 12 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 22 13 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 22 14 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 22 15 free free JJ opencontent-org-7427 22 16 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 22 17 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 22 18 , , , opencontent-org-7427 22 19 copyleft copyleft VBD opencontent-org-7427 22 20 significantly significantly RB opencontent-org-7427 22 21 hinders hinder VBZ opencontent-org-7427 22 22 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 22 23 remix remix NN opencontent-org-7427 22 24 activity activity NN opencontent-org-7427 22 25 . . . opencontent-org-7427 23 1 For for IN opencontent-org-7427 23 2 example example NN opencontent-org-7427 23 3 , , , opencontent-org-7427 23 4 conservative conservative JJ opencontent-org-7427 23 5 estimates estimate NNS opencontent-org-7427 23 6 say say VBP opencontent-org-7427 23 7 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 23 8 there there EX opencontent-org-7427 23 9 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 23 10 approximately approximately RB opencontent-org-7427 23 11 40 40 CD opencontent-org-7427 23 12 million million CD opencontent-org-7427 23 13 creative creative JJ opencontent-org-7427 23 14 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 23 15 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 23 16 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 23 17 currently currently RB opencontent-org-7427 23 18 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 23 19 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 23 20 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 23 21 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 23 22 Commons Commons NNP opencontent-org-7427 23 23 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 23 24 . . . opencontent-org-7427 24 1 About about IN opencontent-org-7427 24 2 half half NN opencontent-org-7427 24 3 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 24 4 these these DT opencontent-org-7427 24 5 use use VBP opencontent-org-7427 24 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 24 7 ShareAlike ShareAlike NNP opencontent-org-7427 24 8 clause clause NN opencontent-org-7427 24 9 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 24 10 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 24 11 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 24 12 ’ ’ POS opencontent-org-7427 24 13 copyleft copyleft NNP opencontent-org-7427 24 14 clause clause NN opencontent-org-7427 24 15 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 24 16 . . . opencontent-org-7427 25 1 Of of IN opencontent-org-7427 25 2 those those DT opencontent-org-7427 25 3 creative creative JJ opencontent-org-7427 25 4 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 25 5 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 25 6 use use VBP opencontent-org-7427 25 7 SA SA NNP opencontent-org-7427 25 8 , , , opencontent-org-7427 25 9 about about RB opencontent-org-7427 25 10 two two CD opencontent-org-7427 25 11 thirds third NNS opencontent-org-7427 25 12 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 25 13 ~13 ~13 : opencontent-org-7427 25 14 million million CD opencontent-org-7427 25 15 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 25 16 use use NN opencontent-org-7427 25 17 By By NNP opencontent-org-7427 25 18 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 25 19 NC NC NNP opencontent-org-7427 25 20 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 25 21 SA SA NNP opencontent-org-7427 25 22 , , , opencontent-org-7427 25 23 while while IN opencontent-org-7427 25 24 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 25 25 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 25 26 third third NN opencontent-org-7427 25 27 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 25 28 ~7 ~7 NFP opencontent-org-7427 25 29 million million CD opencontent-org-7427 25 30 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 25 31 uses use VBZ opencontent-org-7427 25 32 By By NNP opencontent-org-7427 25 33 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 25 34 SA SA NNP opencontent-org-7427 25 35 . . . opencontent-org-7427 26 1 While while IN opencontent-org-7427 26 2 statistics statistic NNS opencontent-org-7427 26 3 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 26 4 GFDL GFDL NNP opencontent-org-7427 26 5 adoption adoption NN opencontent-org-7427 26 6 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 26 7 harder hard JJR opencontent-org-7427 26 8 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 26 9 come come VB opencontent-org-7427 26 10 by by RB opencontent-org-7427 26 11 , , , opencontent-org-7427 26 12 because because IN opencontent-org-7427 26 13 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP opencontent-org-7427 26 14 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 26 15 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 26 16 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 26 17 Wikimedia Wikimedia NNP opencontent-org-7427 26 18 projects project NNS opencontent-org-7427 26 19 use use VBP opencontent-org-7427 26 20 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 26 21 GFDL GFDL NNS opencontent-org-7427 26 22 we -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 26 23 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 26 24 safely safely RB opencontent-org-7427 26 25 estimate estimate VB opencontent-org-7427 26 26 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 26 27 least least JJS opencontent-org-7427 26 28 7 7 CD opencontent-org-7427 26 29 million million CD opencontent-org-7427 26 30 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 26 31 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 26 32 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 26 33 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 26 34 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 26 35 GFDL GFDL NNP opencontent-org-7427 26 36 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 26 37 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 26 38 contains contain VBZ opencontent-org-7427 26 39 its -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 26 40 own own JJ opencontent-org-7427 26 41 copyleft copyleft NN opencontent-org-7427 26 42 clause clause NN opencontent-org-7427 26 43 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 26 44 . . . opencontent-org-7427 27 1 Since since IN opencontent-org-7427 27 2 half half NN opencontent-org-7427 27 3 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 27 4 all all DT opencontent-org-7427 27 5 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 27 6 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 27 7 materials material NNS opencontent-org-7427 27 8 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 27 9 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 27 10 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 27 11 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 27 12 copyleft copyleft JJ opencontent-org-7427 27 13 clause clause NN opencontent-org-7427 27 14 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 27 15 all all DT opencontent-org-7427 27 16 GFDL GFDL NNP opencontent-org-7427 27 17 licensed license VBD opencontent-org-7427 27 18 materials material NNS opencontent-org-7427 27 19 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 27 20 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 27 21 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 27 22 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 27 23 copyleft copyleft JJ opencontent-org-7427 27 24 clause clause NN opencontent-org-7427 27 25 , , , opencontent-org-7427 27 26 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 27 27 means mean VBZ opencontent-org-7427 27 28 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 27 29 over over IN opencontent-org-7427 27 30 half half NN opencontent-org-7427 27 31 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 27 32 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 27 33 world world NN opencontent-org-7427 27 34 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 27 35 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 27 36 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 27 37 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 27 38 copylefted copylefte VBN opencontent-org-7427 27 39 . . . opencontent-org-7427 28 1 And and CC opencontent-org-7427 28 2 while while IN opencontent-org-7427 28 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 28 4 CC CC NNP opencontent-org-7427 28 5 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 28 6 GFDL GFDL NNP opencontent-org-7427 28 7 copyleft copyleft VBD opencontent-org-7427 28 8 clauses clause NNS opencontent-org-7427 28 9 guarantee guarantee VBP opencontent-org-7427 28 10 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 28 11 all all DT opencontent-org-7427 28 12 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 28 13 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 28 14 will will MD opencontent-org-7427 28 15 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 28 16 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 28 17 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 28 18 , , , opencontent-org-7427 28 19 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 28 20 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 28 21 also also RB opencontent-org-7427 28 22 guarantee guarantee VBP opencontent-org-7427 28 23 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 28 24 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 28 25 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 28 26 never never RB opencontent-org-7427 28 27 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 28 28 used use VBN opencontent-org-7427 28 29 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 28 30 remixes remixe NNS opencontent-org-7427 28 31 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 28 32 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 28 33 majority majority NN opencontent-org-7427 28 34 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 28 35 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 28 36 copylefted copylefte VBN opencontent-org-7427 28 37 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 28 38 . . . opencontent-org-7427 29 1 You -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 29 2 ca can MD opencontent-org-7427 29 3 n’t not RB opencontent-org-7427 29 4 remix remix VB opencontent-org-7427 29 5 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 29 6 GFDL GFDL NNP opencontent-org-7427 29 7 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 29 8 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 29 9 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 29 10 By By NNP opencontent-org-7427 29 11 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 29 12 NC NC NNP opencontent-org-7427 29 13 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 29 14 SA SA NNP opencontent-org-7427 29 15 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 29 16 when when WRB opencontent-org-7427 29 17 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 29 18 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 29 19 require require VBP opencontent-org-7427 29 20 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 29 21 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 29 22 child child NN opencontent-org-7427 29 23 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 29 24 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 29 25 exactly exactly RB opencontent-org-7427 29 26 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 29 27 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 29 28 parent parent NN opencontent-org-7427 29 29 . . . opencontent-org-7427 30 1 Each each DT opencontent-org-7427 30 2 parent parent NN opencontent-org-7427 30 3 had have VBD opencontent-org-7427 30 4 one one CD opencontent-org-7427 30 5 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 30 6 only only RB opencontent-org-7427 30 7 one one CD opencontent-org-7427 30 8 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 30 9 – – : opencontent-org-7427 30 10 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 30 11 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 30 12 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 30 13 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 30 14 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 30 15 use use NN opencontent-org-7427 30 16 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 31 1 It -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 31 2 ’s ’ VBZ opencontent-org-7427 31 3 just just RB opencontent-org-7427 31 4 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 31 5 possible possible JJ opencontent-org-7427 31 6 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 31 7 legally legally RB opencontent-org-7427 31 8 remix remix VB opencontent-org-7427 31 9 these these DT opencontent-org-7427 31 10 materials material NNS opencontent-org-7427 31 11 ; ; , opencontent-org-7427 31 12 copyleft copyleft JJ opencontent-org-7427 31 13 prevents prevent VBZ opencontent-org-7427 31 14 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 31 15 remixing remixing NN opencontent-org-7427 31 16 . . . opencontent-org-7427 32 1 While while IN opencontent-org-7427 32 2 promoting promote VBG opencontent-org-7427 32 3 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 32 4 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 32 5 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 32 6 expense expense NN opencontent-org-7427 32 7 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 32 8 remix remix NNS opencontent-org-7427 32 9 – – : opencontent-org-7427 32 10 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 32 11 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 32 12 words word NNS opencontent-org-7427 32 13 , , , opencontent-org-7427 32 14 taking take VBG opencontent-org-7427 32 15 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 32 16 copyleft copyleft JJ opencontent-org-7427 32 17 approach approach NN opencontent-org-7427 32 18 – – : opencontent-org-7427 32 19 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 32 20 fine fine JJ opencontent-org-7427 32 21 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 32 22 software software NN opencontent-org-7427 32 23 , , , opencontent-org-7427 32 24 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 32 25 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 32 26 problematic problematic JJ opencontent-org-7427 32 27 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 32 28 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 32 29 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 32 30 extremely extremely RB opencontent-org-7427 32 31 problematic problematic JJ opencontent-org-7427 32 32 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 32 33 education education NN opencontent-org-7427 32 34 . . . opencontent-org-7427 33 1 As as IN opencontent-org-7427 33 2 educators educator NNS opencontent-org-7427 33 3 , , , opencontent-org-7427 33 4 we -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 33 5 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 33 6 always always RB opencontent-org-7427 33 7 remixing remixe VBG opencontent-org-7427 33 8 materials material NNS opencontent-org-7427 33 9 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 33 10 use use NN opencontent-org-7427 33 11 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 33 12 our -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 33 13 classrooms classroom NNS opencontent-org-7427 33 14 both both DT opencontent-org-7427 33 15 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 33 16 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 33 17 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 33 18 real real JJ opencontent-org-7427 33 19 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 33 20 world world NN opencontent-org-7427 33 21 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 33 22 online online NN opencontent-org-7427 33 23 . . . opencontent-org-7427 34 1 Your -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 34 2 mileage mileage NN opencontent-org-7427 34 3 may may MD opencontent-org-7427 34 4 vary vary VB opencontent-org-7427 34 5 , , , opencontent-org-7427 34 6 but but CC opencontent-org-7427 34 7 over over IN opencontent-org-7427 34 8 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 34 9 last last JJ opencontent-org-7427 34 10 15 15 CD opencontent-org-7427 34 11 years year NNS opencontent-org-7427 34 12 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 34 13 teaching teaching NN opencontent-org-7427 34 14 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 34 15 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 34 16 estimate estimate VB opencontent-org-7427 34 17 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 34 18 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 34 19 remixing remixing NN opencontent-org-7427 34 20 activities activity NNS opencontent-org-7427 34 21 outnumber outnumber VBP opencontent-org-7427 34 22 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 34 23 reworking rework VBG opencontent-org-7427 34 24 activities activity NNS opencontent-org-7427 34 25 10:1 10:1 CD opencontent-org-7427 34 26 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 34 27 more more JJR opencontent-org-7427 34 28 . . . opencontent-org-7427 35 1 If if IN opencontent-org-7427 35 2 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 35 3 teachers teacher NNS opencontent-org-7427 35 4 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 35 5 like like IN opencontent-org-7427 35 6 me -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 35 7 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 35 8 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 35 9 regard regard NN opencontent-org-7427 35 10 , , , opencontent-org-7427 35 11 then then RB opencontent-org-7427 35 12 , , , opencontent-org-7427 35 13 copyleft copyleft NNP opencontent-org-7427 35 14 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 35 15 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 35 16 huge huge JJ opencontent-org-7427 35 17 problem problem NN opencontent-org-7427 35 18 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 35 19 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 35 20 education education NN opencontent-org-7427 35 21 . . . opencontent-org-7427 36 1 Like like IN opencontent-org-7427 36 2 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 36 3 American american JJ opencontent-org-7427 36 4 football football NN opencontent-org-7427 36 5 coach coach NN opencontent-org-7427 36 6 who who WP opencontent-org-7427 36 7 tries try VBZ opencontent-org-7427 36 8 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 36 9 use use VB opencontent-org-7427 36 10 his -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 36 11 successful successful JJ opencontent-org-7427 36 12 offensive offensive JJ opencontent-org-7427 36 13 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 36 14 defensive defensive JJ opencontent-org-7427 36 15 strategies strategy NNS opencontent-org-7427 36 16 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 36 17 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 36 18 European european JJ opencontent-org-7427 36 19 football football NN opencontent-org-7427 36 20 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 36 21 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 36 22 soccer soccer NN opencontent-org-7427 36 23 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 36 24 team team NN opencontent-org-7427 36 25 , , , opencontent-org-7427 36 26 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 36 27 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 36 28 source source NN opencontent-org-7427 36 29 advocate advocate NN opencontent-org-7427 36 30 who who WP opencontent-org-7427 36 31 brings bring VBZ opencontent-org-7427 36 32 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 36 33 successful successful JJ opencontent-org-7427 36 34 idea idea NN opencontent-org-7427 36 35 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 36 36 copyleft copyleft VBN opencontent-org-7427 36 37 into into IN opencontent-org-7427 36 38 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 36 39 world world NN opencontent-org-7427 36 40 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 36 41 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 36 42 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 36 43 will will MD opencontent-org-7427 36 44 eventually eventually RB opencontent-org-7427 36 45 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 36 46 disappointed disappoint VBN opencontent-org-7427 36 47 . . . opencontent-org-7427 37 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 37 2 primary primary JJ opencontent-org-7427 37 3 activity activity NN opencontent-org-7427 37 4 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 37 5 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 37 6 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 37 7 source source NN opencontent-org-7427 37 8 software software NN opencontent-org-7427 37 9 developer developer NN opencontent-org-7427 37 10 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 37 11 reworking rework VBG opencontent-org-7427 37 12 ; ; : opencontent-org-7427 37 13 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 37 14 primary primary JJ opencontent-org-7427 37 15 activity activity NN opencontent-org-7427 37 16 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 37 17 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 37 18 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 37 19 educator educator NN opencontent-org-7427 37 20 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 37 21 remixing remixe VBG opencontent-org-7427 37 22 . . . opencontent-org-7427 38 1 Different different JJ opencontent-org-7427 38 2 activities activity NNS opencontent-org-7427 38 3 require require VBP opencontent-org-7427 38 4 different different JJ opencontent-org-7427 38 5 supporting support VBG opencontent-org-7427 38 6 strategies strategy NNS opencontent-org-7427 38 7 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 38 8 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 38 9 successful successful JJ opencontent-org-7427 38 10 . . . opencontent-org-7427 39 1 If if IN opencontent-org-7427 39 2 we -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 39 3 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 39 4 serious serious JJ opencontent-org-7427 39 5 about about IN opencontent-org-7427 39 6 wanting want VBG opencontent-org-7427 39 7 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 39 8 freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 39 9 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 39 10 legally legally RB opencontent-org-7427 39 11 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 39 12 frictionlessly frictionlessly RB opencontent-org-7427 39 13 remix remix VBZ opencontent-org-7427 39 14 educational educational JJ opencontent-org-7427 39 15 materials material NNS opencontent-org-7427 39 16 , , , opencontent-org-7427 39 17 we -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 39 18 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 39 19 one one CD opencontent-org-7427 39 20 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 39 21 two two CD opencontent-org-7427 39 22 choices choice NNS opencontent-org-7427 39 23 : : : opencontent-org-7427 39 24 either either CC opencontent-org-7427 39 25 ignore ignore VB opencontent-org-7427 39 26 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 39 27 OpenCourseWares opencoursewares CD opencontent-org-7427 39 28 , , , opencontent-org-7427 39 29 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP opencontent-org-7427 39 30 , , , opencontent-org-7427 39 31 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 39 32 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 39 33 copylefted copylefte VBD opencontent-org-7427 39 34 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 39 35 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 39 36 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 39 37 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 39 38 world world NN opencontent-org-7427 39 39 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 39 40 i.e. i.e. FW opencontent-org-7427 39 41 , , , opencontent-org-7427 39 42 work work VB opencontent-org-7427 39 43 only only RB opencontent-org-7427 39 44 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 39 45 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 39 46 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 39 47 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 39 48 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 39 49 n’t not RB opencontent-org-7427 39 50 copylefted copylefte VBN opencontent-org-7427 39 51 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 39 52 , , , opencontent-org-7427 39 53 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 39 54 forcibly forcibly RB opencontent-org-7427 39 55 constrain constrain VB opencontent-org-7427 39 56 ourselves -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 39 57 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 39 58 one one CD opencontent-org-7427 39 59 subset subset NN opencontent-org-7427 39 60 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 39 61 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 39 62 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 39 63 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 39 64 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 39 65 content content JJ opencontent-org-7427 39 66 universe universe NN opencontent-org-7427 39 67 . . . opencontent-org-7427 40 1 Do do VBP opencontent-org-7427 40 2 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 40 3 see see VB opencontent-org-7427 40 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 40 5 irony irony NN opencontent-org-7427 40 6 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 41 1 About about IN opencontent-org-7427 41 2 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 41 3 Copyleft Copyleft NNP opencontent-org-7427 41 4 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 41 5 Attribution Attribution NNP opencontent-org-7427 41 6 Restrictions Restrictions NNPS opencontent-org-7427 41 7 Some some DT opencontent-org-7427 41 8 supporters supporter NNS opencontent-org-7427 41 9 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 41 10 copyleft copyleft JJ opencontent-org-7427 41 11 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 41 12 like like IN opencontent-org-7427 41 13 CC CC NNP opencontent-org-7427 41 14 By By NNP opencontent-org-7427 41 15 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 41 16 SA SA NNP opencontent-org-7427 41 17 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 41 18 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 41 19 GFDL GFDL NNP opencontent-org-7427 41 20 claim claim VBP opencontent-org-7427 41 21 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 41 22 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 41 23 give give VBP opencontent-org-7427 41 24 users user NNS opencontent-org-7427 41 25 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 41 26 ability ability NN opencontent-org-7427 41 27 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 41 28 use use VB opencontent-org-7427 41 29 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 41 30 reuse reuse VB opencontent-org-7427 41 31 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 41 32 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 41 33 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 41 34 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 41 35 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 41 36 restrictions restriction NNS opencontent-org-7427 41 37 . . . opencontent-org-7427 41 38 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 41 39 Obviously obviously RB opencontent-org-7427 41 40 , , , opencontent-org-7427 41 41 requirements requirement NNS opencontent-org-7427 41 42 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 41 43 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 41 44 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 41 45 copylefting copylefting NN opencontent-org-7427 41 46 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 41 47 derivatives derivative NNS opencontent-org-7427 41 48 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 41 49 very very RB opencontent-org-7427 41 50 real real JJ opencontent-org-7427 41 51 restrictions restriction NNS opencontent-org-7427 41 52 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 41 53 should should MD opencontent-org-7427 41 54 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 41 55 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 41 56 overlooked overlook VBN opencontent-org-7427 41 57 . . . opencontent-org-7427 42 1 While while IN opencontent-org-7427 42 2 supporters supporter NNS opencontent-org-7427 42 3 claim claim VBP opencontent-org-7427 42 4 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 42 5 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 42 6 some some DT opencontent-org-7427 42 7 restrictions restriction NNS opencontent-org-7427 42 8 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 42 9 necessary necessary JJ opencontent-org-7427 42 10 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 42 11 protect protect VB opencontent-org-7427 42 12 freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 42 13 , , , opencontent-org-7427 42 14 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 42 15 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 42 16 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 42 17 requirements requirement NNS opencontent-org-7427 42 18 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 42 19 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 42 20 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 42 21 copylefting copylefting NN opencontent-org-7427 42 22 fall fall NN opencontent-org-7427 42 23 into into IN opencontent-org-7427 42 24 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 42 25 category category NN opencontent-org-7427 42 26 , , , opencontent-org-7427 42 27 both both CC opencontent-org-7427 42 28 these these DT opencontent-org-7427 42 29 restrictions restriction NNS opencontent-org-7427 42 30 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 42 31 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 42 32 problematic problematic JJ opencontent-org-7427 42 33 both both DT opencontent-org-7427 42 34 practically practically RB opencontent-org-7427 42 35 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 42 36 philosophically philosophically RB opencontent-org-7427 42 37 . . . opencontent-org-7427 43 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 43 2 ’ve have VB opencontent-org-7427 43 3 spent spend VBN opencontent-org-7427 43 4 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 43 5 significant significant JJ opencontent-org-7427 43 6 amount amount NN opencontent-org-7427 43 7 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 43 8 time time NN opencontent-org-7427 43 9 above above IN opencontent-org-7427 43 10 describing describe VBG opencontent-org-7427 43 11 why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 43 12 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 43 13 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 43 14 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 43 15 case case NN opencontent-org-7427 43 16 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 43 17 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 43 18 copyleft copyleft JJ opencontent-org-7427 43 19 restriction restriction NN opencontent-org-7427 43 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 44 1 When when WRB opencontent-org-7427 44 2 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 44 3 contemplate contemplate VBP opencontent-org-7427 44 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 44 5 different different JJ opencontent-org-7427 44 6 cultures culture NNS opencontent-org-7427 44 7 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 44 8 cultural cultural JJ opencontent-org-7427 44 9 values value NNS opencontent-org-7427 44 10 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 44 11 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 44 12 world world NN opencontent-org-7427 44 13 , , , opencontent-org-7427 44 14 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 44 15 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 44 16 n’t not RB opencontent-org-7427 44 17 hard hard JJ opencontent-org-7427 44 18 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 44 19 imagine imagine VB opencontent-org-7427 44 20 scenarios scenario NNS opencontent-org-7427 44 21 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 44 22 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 44 23 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 44 24 requirement requirement NN opencontent-org-7427 44 25 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 44 26 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 44 27 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 44 28 prevent prevent VB opencontent-org-7427 44 29 appropriate appropriate JJ opencontent-org-7427 44 30 uses use NNS opencontent-org-7427 44 31 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 44 32 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 44 33 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 44 34 . . . opencontent-org-7427 45 1 One one CD opencontent-org-7427 45 2 need nee MD opencontent-org-7427 45 3 only only RB opencontent-org-7427 45 4 contemplate contemplate VB opencontent-org-7427 45 5 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 45 6 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 45 7 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 45 8 areas area NNS opencontent-org-7427 45 9 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 45 10 enduring endure VBG opencontent-org-7427 45 11 unrest unrest NN opencontent-org-7427 45 12 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 45 13 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 45 14 world world NN opencontent-org-7427 45 15 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 45 16 understand understand VB opencontent-org-7427 45 17 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 45 18 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 45 19 requirement requirement NN opencontent-org-7427 45 20 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 45 21 attribute attribute VB opencontent-org-7427 45 22 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 45 23 reuse reuse NN opencontent-org-7427 45 24 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 45 25 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 45 26 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 45 27 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 45 28 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 45 29 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 45 30 Sunni Sunni NNP opencontent-org-7427 45 31 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 45 32 Shia Shia NNP opencontent-org-7427 45 33 author author NN opencontent-org-7427 45 34 , , , opencontent-org-7427 45 35 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 45 36 example example NN opencontent-org-7427 45 37 , , , opencontent-org-7427 45 38 will will MD opencontent-org-7427 45 39 prevent prevent VB opencontent-org-7427 45 40 members member NNS opencontent-org-7427 45 41 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 45 42 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 45 43 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 45 44 group group NN opencontent-org-7427 45 45 from from IN opencontent-org-7427 45 46 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 45 47 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 45 48 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 45 49 . . . opencontent-org-7427 46 1 Sadly sadly RB opencontent-org-7427 46 2 , , , opencontent-org-7427 46 3 over over IN opencontent-org-7427 46 4 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 46 5 dozen dozen NN opencontent-org-7427 46 6 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 46 7 examples example NNS opencontent-org-7427 46 8 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 46 9 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 46 10 kind kind NN opencontent-org-7427 46 11 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 46 12 Israeli israeli JJ opencontent-org-7427 46 13 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 46 14 Palestinian palestinian JJ opencontent-org-7427 46 15 , , , opencontent-org-7427 46 16 etc etc FW opencontent-org-7427 46 17 . . . opencontent-org-7427 46 18 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 47 1 could could MD opencontent-org-7427 47 2 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 47 3 given give VBN opencontent-org-7427 47 4 . . . opencontent-org-7427 48 1 It -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 48 2 quickly quickly RB opencontent-org-7427 48 3 becomes become VBZ opencontent-org-7427 48 4 clear clear JJ opencontent-org-7427 48 5 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 48 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 48 7 requirement requirement NN opencontent-org-7427 48 8 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 48 9 attribute attribute VB opencontent-org-7427 48 10 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 48 11 original original JJ opencontent-org-7427 48 12 author author NN opencontent-org-7427 48 13 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 48 14 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 48 15 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 48 16 subtle subtle JJ opencontent-org-7427 48 17 but but CC opencontent-org-7427 48 18 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 48 19 less less RBR opencontent-org-7427 48 20 real real JJ opencontent-org-7427 48 21 way way NN opencontent-org-7427 48 22 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 48 23 discriminating discriminate VBG opencontent-org-7427 48 24 against against IN opencontent-org-7427 48 25 persons person NNS opencontent-org-7427 48 26 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 48 27 groups group NNS opencontent-org-7427 48 28 . . . opencontent-org-7427 49 1 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 49 2 If if IN opencontent-org-7427 49 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 49 4 accusation accusation NN opencontent-org-7427 49 5 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 49 6 being be VBG opencontent-org-7427 49 7 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 49 8 instrument instrument NN opencontent-org-7427 49 9 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 49 10 discrimination discrimination NN opencontent-org-7427 49 11 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 49 12 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 49 13 convincing convince VBG opencontent-org-7427 49 14 enough enough RB opencontent-org-7427 49 15 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 49 16 some some DT opencontent-org-7427 49 17 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 49 18 source source NN opencontent-org-7427 49 19 advocates advocate NNS opencontent-org-7427 49 20 , , , opencontent-org-7427 49 21 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 49 22 situation situation NN opencontent-org-7427 49 23 also also RB opencontent-org-7427 49 24 puts put VBZ opencontent-org-7427 49 25 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 49 26 seemingly seemingly RB opencontent-org-7427 49 27 innocuous innocuous JJ opencontent-org-7427 49 28 requirement requirement NN opencontent-org-7427 49 29 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 49 30 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 49 31 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 49 32 odds odd NNS opencontent-org-7427 49 33 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 49 34 one one CD opencontent-org-7427 49 35 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 49 36 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 49 37 basic basic JJ opencontent-org-7427 49 38 premises premise NNS opencontent-org-7427 49 39 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 49 40 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 49 41 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 49 42 source source NN opencontent-org-7427 49 43 definition definition NN opencontent-org-7427 49 44 . . . opencontent-org-7427 49 45 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 50 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 50 2 believe believe VBP opencontent-org-7427 50 3 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 50 4 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 50 5 absolutely absolutely RB opencontent-org-7427 50 6 crucial crucial JJ opencontent-org-7427 50 7 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 50 8 we -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 50 9 do do VBP opencontent-org-7427 50 10 everything everything NN opencontent-org-7427 50 11 we -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 50 12 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 50 13 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 50 14 live live VB opencontent-org-7427 50 15 up up RP opencontent-org-7427 50 16 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 50 17 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 50 18 ideals ideal NNS opencontent-org-7427 50 19 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 50 20 nondiscrimination nondiscrimination NN opencontent-org-7427 50 21 expressed express VBN opencontent-org-7427 50 22 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 50 23 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 50 24 definition definition NN opencontent-org-7427 50 25 , , , opencontent-org-7427 50 26 our -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 50 27 institutions institution NNS opencontent-org-7427 50 28 , , , opencontent-org-7427 50 29 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 50 30 civilization civilization NN opencontent-org-7427 50 31 generally generally RB opencontent-org-7427 50 32 . . . opencontent-org-7427 51 1 Why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 51 2 Not not RB opencontent-org-7427 51 3 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 51 4 Public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 51 5 Domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 51 6 Dedication dedication NN opencontent-org-7427 51 7 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 52 1 If if IN opencontent-org-7427 52 2 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 52 3 appropriate appropriate JJ opencontent-org-7427 52 4 goal goal NN opencontent-org-7427 52 5 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 52 6 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 52 7 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 52 8 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 52 9 , , , opencontent-org-7427 52 10 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 52 11 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 52 12 appears appear VBZ opencontent-org-7427 52 13 , , , opencontent-org-7427 52 14 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 52 15 make make VB opencontent-org-7427 52 16 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 52 17 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 52 18 available available JJ opencontent-org-7427 52 19 without without IN opencontent-org-7427 52 20 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 52 21 restrictions restriction NNS opencontent-org-7427 52 22 , , , opencontent-org-7427 52 23 why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 52 24 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 52 25 simply simply RB opencontent-org-7427 52 26 dedicate dedicate VB opencontent-org-7427 52 27 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 52 28 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 52 29 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 52 30 question question NN opencontent-org-7427 52 31 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 52 32 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 52 33 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 52 34 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 52 35 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 53 1 There there EX opencontent-org-7427 53 2 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 53 3 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 53 4 number number NN opencontent-org-7427 53 5 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 53 6 problems problem NNS opencontent-org-7427 53 7 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 53 8 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 53 9 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 53 10 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 53 11 dedication dedication NN opencontent-org-7427 53 12 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 53 13 like like IN opencontent-org-7427 53 14 that that DT opencontent-org-7427 53 15 offered offer VBN opencontent-org-7427 53 16 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 53 17 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 53 18 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 53 19 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 53 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 54 1 First first RB opencontent-org-7427 54 2 , , , opencontent-org-7427 54 3 dedicating dedicate VBG opencontent-org-7427 54 4 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 54 5 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 54 6 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 54 7 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 54 8 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 54 9 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 54 10 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 54 11 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 54 12 significantly significantly RB opencontent-org-7427 54 13 more more RBR opencontent-org-7427 54 14 involved involved JJ opencontent-org-7427 54 15 process process NN opencontent-org-7427 54 16 than than IN opencontent-org-7427 54 17 licensing license VBG opencontent-org-7427 54 18 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 54 19 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 54 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 55 1 While while IN opencontent-org-7427 55 2 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 55 3 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 55 4 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 55 5 rightly rightly RB opencontent-org-7427 55 6 famous famous JJ opencontent-org-7427 55 7 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 55 8 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 55 9 easy easy JJ opencontent-org-7427 55 10 their -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 55 11 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 55 12 selection selection NN opencontent-org-7427 55 13 technology technology NN opencontent-org-7427 55 14 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 55 15 little little JJ opencontent-org-7427 55 16 green green JJ opencontent-org-7427 55 17 buttons button NNS opencontent-org-7427 55 18 make make VBP opencontent-org-7427 55 19 licensing license VBG opencontent-org-7427 55 20 your -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 55 21 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 55 22 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 55 23 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 55 24 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 55 25 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 55 26 , , , opencontent-org-7427 55 27 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 55 28 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 55 29 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 55 30 dedication dedication NN opencontent-org-7427 55 31 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 55 32 much much RB opencontent-org-7427 55 33 more more RBR opencontent-org-7427 55 34 complicated complicated JJ opencontent-org-7427 55 35 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 55 36 includes include VBZ opencontent-org-7427 55 37 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 55 38 number number NN opencontent-org-7427 55 39 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 55 40 steps step NNS opencontent-org-7427 55 41 , , , opencontent-org-7427 55 42 including include VBG opencontent-org-7427 55 43 making make VBG opencontent-org-7427 55 44 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 55 45 request request NN opencontent-org-7427 55 46 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 55 47 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 55 48 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 55 49 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 55 50 send send VB opencontent-org-7427 55 51 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 55 52 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 55 53 email email NN opencontent-org-7427 55 54 regarding regard VBG opencontent-org-7427 55 55 your -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 55 56 intent intent NN opencontent-org-7427 55 57 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 55 58 place place VB opencontent-org-7427 55 59 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 55 60 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 55 61 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 55 62 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 55 63 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 55 64 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 55 65 . . . opencontent-org-7427 56 1 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 56 2 rigamarole rigamarole NN opencontent-org-7427 56 3 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 56 4 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 56 5 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 56 6 fault fault NN opencontent-org-7427 56 7 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 56 8 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 56 9 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 56 10 ; ; : opencontent-org-7427 56 11 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 56 12 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 56 13 simplified simplify VBN opencontent-org-7427 56 14 as as RB opencontent-org-7427 56 15 much much RB opencontent-org-7427 56 16 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 56 17 possible possible JJ opencontent-org-7427 56 18 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 56 19 process process NN opencontent-org-7427 56 20 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 56 21 putting put VBG opencontent-org-7427 56 22 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 56 23 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 56 24 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 56 25 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 56 26 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 56 27 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 56 28 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 56 29 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 56 30 US US NNP opencontent-org-7427 56 31 . . . opencontent-org-7427 57 1 But but CC opencontent-org-7427 57 2 secondly secondly RB opencontent-org-7427 57 3 , , , opencontent-org-7427 57 4 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 57 5 more more RBR opencontent-org-7427 57 6 importantly importantly RB opencontent-org-7427 57 7 , , , opencontent-org-7427 57 8 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 57 9 may may MD opencontent-org-7427 57 10 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 57 11 impossible impossible JJ opencontent-org-7427 57 12 under under IN opencontent-org-7427 57 13 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 57 14 law law NN opencontent-org-7427 57 15 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 57 16 some some DT opencontent-org-7427 57 17 jurisdictions jurisdiction NNS opencontent-org-7427 57 18 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 57 19 place place VB opencontent-org-7427 57 20 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 57 21 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 57 22 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 57 23 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 57 24 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 57 25 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 57 26 . . . opencontent-org-7427 58 1 For for IN opencontent-org-7427 58 2 example example NN opencontent-org-7427 58 3 , , , opencontent-org-7427 58 4 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 58 5 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 58 6 EU EU NNP opencontent-org-7427 58 7 authors author NNS opencontent-org-7427 58 8 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 58 9 certain certain JJ opencontent-org-7427 58 10 rights right NNS opencontent-org-7427 58 11 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 58 12 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 58 13 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 58 14 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 58 15 contracted contract VBN opencontent-org-7427 58 16 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 58 17 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 58 18 away away RB opencontent-org-7427 58 19 , , , opencontent-org-7427 58 20 making make VBG opencontent-org-7427 58 21 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 58 22 impossible impossible JJ opencontent-org-7427 58 23 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 58 24 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 58 25 author author NN opencontent-org-7427 58 26 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 58 27 legally legally RB opencontent-org-7427 58 28 relinquish relinquish VB opencontent-org-7427 58 29 all all DT opencontent-org-7427 58 30 rights right NNS opencontent-org-7427 58 31 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 58 32 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 58 33 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 58 34 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 58 35 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 58 36 put put VBD opencontent-org-7427 58 37 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 58 38 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 58 39 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 58 40 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 58 41 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 58 42 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 58 43 . . . opencontent-org-7427 59 1 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 59 2 Commons Commons NNP opencontent-org-7427 59 3 also also RB opencontent-org-7427 59 4 recognizes recognize VBZ opencontent-org-7427 59 5 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 59 6 problem problem NN opencontent-org-7427 59 7 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 59 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 59 9 statement statement NN opencontent-org-7427 59 10 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 59 11 their -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 59 12 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 59 13 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 59 14 dedication dedication NN opencontent-org-7427 59 15 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 59 16 may may MD opencontent-org-7427 59 17 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 59 18 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 59 19 valid valid JJ opencontent-org-7427 59 20 outside outside IN opencontent-org-7427 59 21 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 59 22 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 59 23 United United NNP opencontent-org-7427 59 24 States States NNP opencontent-org-7427 59 25 . . . opencontent-org-7427 59 26 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 59 27 Hence hence RB opencontent-org-7427 59 28 , , , opencontent-org-7427 59 29 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 59 30 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 59 31 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 59 32 dedication dedication NN opencontent-org-7427 59 33 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 59 34 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 59 35 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 59 36 internationally internationally RB opencontent-org-7427 59 37 viable viable JJ opencontent-org-7427 59 38 mechanism mechanism NN opencontent-org-7427 59 39 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 59 40 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 59 41 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 59 42 . . . opencontent-org-7427 60 1 About about RB opencontent-org-7427 60 2 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 60 3 Four Four NNP opencontent-org-7427 60 4 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 60 5 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 60 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 60 7 Four four CD opencontent-org-7427 60 8 Freedoms Freedoms NNPS opencontent-org-7427 60 9 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 60 10 hate hate VBP opencontent-org-7427 60 11 definitions definition NNS opencontent-org-7427 60 12 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 60 13 taxonomies taxonomy NNS opencontent-org-7427 60 14 outside outside IN opencontent-org-7427 60 15 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 60 16 hard hard JJ opencontent-org-7427 60 17 sciences science NNS opencontent-org-7427 60 18 . . . opencontent-org-7427 61 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 61 2 hate hate VBP opencontent-org-7427 61 3 them -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 61 4 particularly particularly RB opencontent-org-7427 61 5 because because IN opencontent-org-7427 61 6 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 61 7 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 61 8 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 61 9 involved involve VBN opencontent-org-7427 61 10 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 61 11 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 61 12 political political JJ opencontent-org-7427 61 13 contests contest NNS opencontent-org-7427 61 14 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 61 15 creating create VBG opencontent-org-7427 61 16 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 61 17 perpetuating perpetuate VBG opencontent-org-7427 61 18 them -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 61 19 – – : opencontent-org-7427 61 20 specifically specifically RB opencontent-org-7427 61 21 , , , opencontent-org-7427 61 22 definitions definition NNS opencontent-org-7427 61 23 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 61 24 taxonomies taxonomy NNS opencontent-org-7427 61 25 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 61 26 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 61 27 learning learn VBG opencontent-org-7427 61 28 objects object NNS opencontent-org-7427 61 29 . . . opencontent-org-7427 61 30 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 61 31 Whose whose WP$ opencontent-org-7427 61 32 definition definition NN opencontent-org-7427 61 33 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 61 34 learning learn VBG opencontent-org-7427 61 35 object object NN opencontent-org-7427 61 36 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 61 37 best good JJS opencontent-org-7427 61 38 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 62 1 Whose whose WP$ opencontent-org-7427 62 2 taxonomy taxonomy NN opencontent-org-7427 62 3 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 62 4 best good JJS opencontent-org-7427 62 5 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 63 1 These these DT opencontent-org-7427 63 2 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 63 3 largely largely RB opencontent-org-7427 63 4 meaningless meaningless JJ opencontent-org-7427 63 5 political political JJ opencontent-org-7427 63 6 battles battle NNS opencontent-org-7427 63 7 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 63 8 left leave VBD opencontent-org-7427 63 9 behind behind RB opencontent-org-7427 63 10 many many JJ opencontent-org-7427 63 11 years year NNS opencontent-org-7427 63 12 ago ago RB opencontent-org-7427 63 13 . . . opencontent-org-7427 64 1 It -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 64 2 therefore therefore RB opencontent-org-7427 64 3 surprises surprise VBZ opencontent-org-7427 64 4 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 64 5 one one NN opencontent-org-7427 64 6 more more JJR opencontent-org-7427 64 7 than than IN opencontent-org-7427 64 8 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 64 9 surprised surprise VBD opencontent-org-7427 64 10 me -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 64 11 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 64 12 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 64 13 felt feel VBD opencontent-org-7427 64 14 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 64 15 need need NN opencontent-org-7427 64 16 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 64 17 list list VB opencontent-org-7427 64 18 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 64 19 explicate explicate VB opencontent-org-7427 64 20 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 64 21 Four four CD opencontent-org-7427 64 22 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 64 23 , , , opencontent-org-7427 64 24 especially especially RB opencontent-org-7427 64 25 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 64 26 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 64 27 context context NN opencontent-org-7427 64 28 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 64 29 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 64 30 existing exist VBG opencontent-org-7427 64 31 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 64 32 Four Four NNP opencontent-org-7427 64 33 Freedoms Freedoms NNPS opencontent-org-7427 64 34 . . . opencontent-org-7427 64 35 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 64 36 While while IN opencontent-org-7427 64 37 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 64 38 Four four CD opencontent-org-7427 64 39 Freedoms Freedoms NNPS opencontent-org-7427 64 40 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 64 41 their -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 64 42 roots root NNS opencontent-org-7427 64 43 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 64 44 free free JJ opencontent-org-7427 64 45 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 64 46 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 64 47 source source NN opencontent-org-7427 64 48 software software NN opencontent-org-7427 64 49 , , , opencontent-org-7427 64 50 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 64 51 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 64 52 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 64 53 discussed discuss VBN opencontent-org-7427 64 54 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 64 55 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 64 56 context context NN opencontent-org-7427 64 57 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 64 58 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 64 59 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 64 60 as as RB opencontent-org-7427 64 61 well well RB opencontent-org-7427 64 62 . . . opencontent-org-7427 65 1 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 2 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 65 3 Terry Terry NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 4 Foote Foote NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 5 summarized summarize VBD opencontent-org-7427 65 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 65 7 freedoms freedom NNS opencontent-org-7427 65 8 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 65 9 our -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 65 10 2005 2005 CD opencontent-org-7427 65 11 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 12 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 13 Conference Conference NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 14 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 65 15 : : : opencontent-org-7427 65 16 Freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 65 17 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 65 18 copy copy VB opencontent-org-7427 65 19 Freedom Freedom NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 20 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 65 21 modify modify VB opencontent-org-7427 65 22 Freedom Freedom NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 23 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 65 24 redistribute redistribute VB opencontent-org-7427 65 25 Freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 65 26 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 65 27 redistribute redistribute VB opencontent-org-7427 65 28 modified modify VBN opencontent-org-7427 65 29 versions version NNS opencontent-org-7427 65 30 Freedom Freedom NNP opencontent-org-7427 65 31 1 1 CD opencontent-org-7427 65 32 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 65 33 analogous analogous JJ opencontent-org-7427 65 34 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 65 35 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 65 36 first first JJ opencontent-org-7427 65 37 R r NN opencontent-org-7427 65 38 , , , opencontent-org-7427 65 39 reuse reuse NN opencontent-org-7427 65 40 . . . opencontent-org-7427 66 1 Freedoms freedom NNS opencontent-org-7427 66 2 3 3 CD opencontent-org-7427 66 3 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 66 4 4 4 CD opencontent-org-7427 66 5 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 66 6 analogous analogous JJ opencontent-org-7427 66 7 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 66 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 66 9 final final JJ opencontent-org-7427 66 10 R r NN opencontent-org-7427 66 11 , , , opencontent-org-7427 66 12 redistribute redistribute NN opencontent-org-7427 66 13 . . . opencontent-org-7427 67 1 Freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 67 2 2 2 CD opencontent-org-7427 67 3 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 67 4 either either CC opencontent-org-7427 67 5 analogous analogous JJ opencontent-org-7427 67 6 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 67 7 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 67 8 second second JJ opencontent-org-7427 67 9 R r NN opencontent-org-7427 67 10 , , , opencontent-org-7427 67 11 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 67 12 , , , opencontent-org-7427 67 13 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 67 14 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 67 15 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 67 16 amalgamation amalgamation NN opencontent-org-7427 67 17 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 67 18 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 67 19 second second JJ opencontent-org-7427 67 20 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 67 21 third third JJ opencontent-org-7427 67 22 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 67 23 , , , opencontent-org-7427 67 24 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 67 25 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 67 26 remix remix NN opencontent-org-7427 67 27 . . . opencontent-org-7427 68 1 In in IN opencontent-org-7427 68 2 either either DT opencontent-org-7427 68 3 case case NN opencontent-org-7427 68 4 , , , opencontent-org-7427 68 5 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 68 6 Four Four NNP opencontent-org-7427 68 7 Freedoms Freedoms NNPS opencontent-org-7427 68 8 do do VBP opencontent-org-7427 68 9 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 68 10 distinguish distinguish VB opencontent-org-7427 68 11 sufficiently sufficiently RB opencontent-org-7427 68 12 between between IN opencontent-org-7427 68 13 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 68 14 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 68 15 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 68 16 remix remix NN opencontent-org-7427 68 17 activities activity NNS opencontent-org-7427 68 18 . . . opencontent-org-7427 69 1 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 69 2 leads lead VBZ opencontent-org-7427 69 3 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 69 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 69 5 problems problem NNS opencontent-org-7427 69 6 described describe VBN opencontent-org-7427 69 7 above above RB opencontent-org-7427 69 8 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 69 9 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 69 10 rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 69 11 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 69 12 considered consider VBN opencontent-org-7427 69 13 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 69 14 supported support VBN opencontent-org-7427 69 15 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 69 16 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 69 17 cost cost NN opencontent-org-7427 69 18 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 69 19 remix remix NNS opencontent-org-7427 69 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 70 1 These these DT opencontent-org-7427 70 2 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 70 3 distinct distinct JJ opencontent-org-7427 70 4 activities activity NNS opencontent-org-7427 70 5 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 70 6 require require VBP opencontent-org-7427 70 7 different different JJ opencontent-org-7427 70 8 environmental environmental JJ opencontent-org-7427 70 9 conditions condition NNS opencontent-org-7427 70 10 . . . opencontent-org-7427 71 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 2 Four Four NNP opencontent-org-7427 71 3 Freedoms Freedoms NNPS opencontent-org-7427 71 4 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 71 5 listed list VBN opencontent-org-7427 71 6 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 71 7 Freedom Freedom NNP opencontent-org-7427 71 8 Defined Defined NNP opencontent-org-7427 71 9 also also RB opencontent-org-7427 71 10 fail fail VBP opencontent-org-7427 71 11 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 12 make make VB opencontent-org-7427 71 13 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 71 14 distinction distinction NN opencontent-org-7427 71 15 : : : opencontent-org-7427 71 16 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 17 freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 71 18 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 19 use use VB opencontent-org-7427 71 20 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 21 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 71 22 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 71 23 enjoy enjoy VB opencontent-org-7427 71 24 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 25 benefits benefit NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 26 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 71 27 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 71 28 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 71 29 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 30 freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 71 31 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 32 study study VB opencontent-org-7427 71 33 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 34 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 71 35 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 71 36 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 37 apply apply VB opencontent-org-7427 71 38 knowledge knowledge NN opencontent-org-7427 71 39 acquired acquire VBN opencontent-org-7427 71 40 from from IN opencontent-org-7427 71 41 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 71 42 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 43 freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 71 44 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 45 make make VB opencontent-org-7427 71 46 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 71 47 redistribute redistribute VB opencontent-org-7427 71 48 copies copy NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 49 , , , opencontent-org-7427 71 50 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 71 51 whole whole NN opencontent-org-7427 71 52 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 71 53 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 71 54 part part NN opencontent-org-7427 71 55 , , , opencontent-org-7427 71 56 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 71 57 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 58 information information NN opencontent-org-7427 71 59 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 71 60 expression expression NN opencontent-org-7427 71 61 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 62 freedom freedom NN opencontent-org-7427 71 63 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 64 make make VB opencontent-org-7427 71 65 changes change NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 66 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 71 67 improvements improvement NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 68 , , , opencontent-org-7427 71 69 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 71 70 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 71 distribute distribute VB opencontent-org-7427 71 72 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 71 73 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 74 While while IN opencontent-org-7427 71 75 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 76 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 71 77 father father NN opencontent-org-7427 71 78 knows know VBZ opencontent-org-7427 71 79 best good JJS opencontent-org-7427 71 80 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 71 81 approach approach NN opencontent-org-7427 71 82 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 71 83 copyleft copyleft JJ opencontent-org-7427 71 84 places place NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 85 only only RB opencontent-org-7427 71 86 incentive incentive NN opencontent-org-7427 71 87 obstacles obstacle NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 88 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 71 89 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 90 path path NN opencontent-org-7427 71 91 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 71 92 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 71 93 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 71 94 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 71 95 creators creator NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 96 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 71 97 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 71 98 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 99 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 71 100 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 71 101 stripping strip VBG opencontent-org-7427 71 102 them -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 71 103 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 71 104 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 105 ability ability NN opencontent-org-7427 71 106 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 107 choose choose VB opencontent-org-7427 71 108 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 71 109 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 71 110 license license VB opencontent-org-7427 71 111 their -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 71 112 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 71 113 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 114 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 71 115 , , , opencontent-org-7427 71 116 copyleft copyleft VBD opencontent-org-7427 71 117 places place NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 118 legal legal JJ opencontent-org-7427 71 119 obstacles obstacle NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 120 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 71 121 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 71 122 path path NN opencontent-org-7427 71 123 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 71 124 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 71 125 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 71 126 remixers remixer NNS opencontent-org-7427 71 127 . . . opencontent-org-7427 72 1 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 72 2 problem problem NN opencontent-org-7427 72 3 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 72 4 difficult difficult JJ opencontent-org-7427 72 5 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 72 6 see see VB opencontent-org-7427 72 7 through through IN opencontent-org-7427 72 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 72 9 imprecision imprecision NN opencontent-org-7427 72 10 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 72 11 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 72 12 way way NN opencontent-org-7427 72 13 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 72 14 Four Four NNP opencontent-org-7427 72 15 Freedoms Freedoms NNP opencontent-org-7427 72 16 deals deal NNS opencontent-org-7427 72 17 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 72 18 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 72 19 modify modify NNP opencontent-org-7427 72 20 , , , opencontent-org-7427 72 21 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 72 22 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 72 23 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 72 24 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 72 25 one one CD opencontent-org-7427 72 26 reason reason NN opencontent-org-7427 72 27 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 72 28 felt feel VBD opencontent-org-7427 72 29 justified justified JJ opencontent-org-7427 72 30 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 72 31 listing list VBG opencontent-org-7427 72 32 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 72 33 explaining explain VBG opencontent-org-7427 72 34 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 72 35 Four four CD opencontent-org-7427 72 36 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 72 37 . . . opencontent-org-7427 73 1 Purpose purpose NN opencontent-org-7427 73 2 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 73 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 4 New New NNP opencontent-org-7427 73 5 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 73 6 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 7 purpose purpose NN opencontent-org-7427 73 8 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 73 9 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 10 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 73 11 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 73 12 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 73 13 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 73 14 create create VB opencontent-org-7427 73 15 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 73 16 way way NN opencontent-org-7427 73 17 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 73 18 people people NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 19 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 73 20 license license VB opencontent-org-7427 73 21 their -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 73 22 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 23 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 73 24 such such PDT opencontent-org-7427 73 25 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 73 26 way way NN opencontent-org-7427 73 27 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 73 28 : : : opencontent-org-7427 73 29 applying apply VBG opencontent-org-7427 73 30 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 31 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 73 32 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 73 33 easy easy JJ opencontent-org-7427 73 34 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 73 35 authors author NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 36 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 73 37 understanding understand VBG opencontent-org-7427 73 38 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 39 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 73 40 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 73 41 easy easy JJ opencontent-org-7427 73 42 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 73 43 users user NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 44 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 45 engaging engage VBG opencontent-org-7427 73 46 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 73 47 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 73 48 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 73 49 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 50 four four CD opencontent-org-7427 73 51 Rs r NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 52 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 73 53 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 73 54 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 73 55 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 73 56 occur occur VB opencontent-org-7427 73 57 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 73 58 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 73 59 completely completely RB opencontent-org-7427 73 60 frictionless frictionless JJ opencontent-org-7427 73 61 manner manner NN opencontent-org-7427 73 62 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 63 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 64 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 73 65 imposes impose VBZ opencontent-org-7427 73 66 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 73 67 restrictions restriction NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 68 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 73 69 licensees licensee NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 70 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 71 decreasing decrease VBG opencontent-org-7427 73 72 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 73 chances chance NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 74 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 73 75 accidental accidental JJ opencontent-org-7427 73 76 discrimination discrimination NN opencontent-org-7427 73 77 against against IN opencontent-org-7427 73 78 persons person NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 79 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 73 80 groups group NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 81 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 82 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 73 83 remixing remixing NN opencontent-org-7427 73 84 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 73 85 well well RB opencontent-org-7427 73 86 supported support VBN opencontent-org-7427 73 87 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 88 so so IN opencontent-org-7427 73 89 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 73 90 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 73 91 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 73 92 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 73 93 legally legally RB opencontent-org-7427 73 94 remixable remixable JJ opencontent-org-7427 73 95 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 73 96 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 73 97 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 73 98 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 73 99 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 73 100 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 73 101 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 73 102 remixer remixer NNP opencontent-org-7427 73 103 has have VBZ opencontent-org-7427 73 104 rights right NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 105 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 106 whether whether IN opencontent-org-7427 73 107 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 73 108 c c NNP opencontent-org-7427 73 109 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 73 110 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 111 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 73 112 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 113 GFDL GFDL NNP opencontent-org-7427 73 114 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 115 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 73 116 differently differently RB opencontent-org-7427 73 117 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 73 118 , , , opencontent-org-7427 73 119 decreasing decrease VBG opencontent-org-7427 73 120 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 73 121 incompatibility incompatibility NN opencontent-org-7427 73 122 problems problem NNS opencontent-org-7427 73 123 . . . opencontent-org-7427 74 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 74 2 Approach Approach NNP opencontent-org-7427 74 3 In in IN opencontent-org-7427 74 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 74 5 context context NN opencontent-org-7427 74 6 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 74 7 historical historical JJ opencontent-org-7427 74 8 approaches approach NNS opencontent-org-7427 74 9 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 74 10 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 74 11 copyright copyright NN opencontent-org-7427 74 12 law law NN opencontent-org-7427 74 13 against against IN opencontent-org-7427 74 14 itself -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 74 15 , , , opencontent-org-7427 74 16 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 74 17 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 74 18 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 74 19 takes take VBZ opencontent-org-7427 74 20 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 74 21 approach approach NN opencontent-org-7427 74 22 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 74 23 granting grant VBG opencontent-org-7427 74 24 licensees licensee NNS opencontent-org-7427 74 25 all all PDT opencontent-org-7427 74 26 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 74 27 rights right NNS opencontent-org-7427 74 28 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 74 29 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 74 30 they -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 74 31 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 74 32 need need VB opencontent-org-7427 74 33 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 74 34 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 74 35 under under IN opencontent-org-7427 74 36 current current JJ opencontent-org-7427 74 37 , , , opencontent-org-7427 74 38 applicable applicable JJ opencontent-org-7427 74 39 law law NN opencontent-org-7427 74 40 . . . opencontent-org-7427 75 1 Credit credit NN opencontent-org-7427 75 2 Where where WRB opencontent-org-7427 75 3 Credit Credit NNP opencontent-org-7427 75 4 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 75 5 Due Due NNP opencontent-org-7427 75 6 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 75 7 language language NN opencontent-org-7427 75 8 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 75 9 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 75 10 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 75 11 draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 75 12 borrows borrow VBZ opencontent-org-7427 75 13 heavily heavily RB opencontent-org-7427 75 14 from from IN opencontent-org-7427 75 15 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 75 16 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 75 17 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 75 18 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 75 19 , , , opencontent-org-7427 75 20 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 75 21 only only RB opencontent-org-7427 75 22 seems seem VBZ opencontent-org-7427 75 23 appropriate appropriate JJ opencontent-org-7427 75 24 . . . opencontent-org-7427 76 1 Adopters adopter NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 2 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 76 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 76 4 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 76 5 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 76 6 will will MD opencontent-org-7427 76 7 also also RB opencontent-org-7427 76 8 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 76 9 able able JJ opencontent-org-7427 76 10 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 76 11 use use VB opencontent-org-7427 76 12 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 13 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 76 14 ’ ’ POS opencontent-org-7427 76 15 RDF RDF NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 16 metadata metadata VBP opencontent-org-7427 76 17 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 76 18 their -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 76 19 documents document NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 20 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 76 21 describe describe VB opencontent-org-7427 76 22 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 76 23 Google Google NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 24 , , , opencontent-org-7427 76 25 Yahoo Yahoo NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 26 ! ! . opencontent-org-7427 76 27 , , , opencontent-org-7427 76 28 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 76 29 others other NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 30 what what WDT opencontent-org-7427 76 31 rights right NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 32 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 76 33 associated associate VBN opencontent-org-7427 76 34 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 76 35 their -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 76 36 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 37 , , , opencontent-org-7427 76 38 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 76 39 follows follow VBZ opencontent-org-7427 76 40 : : : opencontent-org-7427 76 41 < < XX opencontent-org-7427 76 42 rdf rdf VB opencontent-org-7427 76 43 : : : opencontent-org-7427 76 44 RDF RDF NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 45 xmlns=”http://creativecommons.org xmlns=”http://creativecommons.org NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 46 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 47 ns ns IN opencontent-org-7427 76 48 # # NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 49 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 76 50 xmlns xmln NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 51 : : : opencontent-org-7427 76 52 dc=”http://purl.org dc=”http://purl.org NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 53 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 54 dc dc NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 55 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 56 elements/1.1/ elements/1.1/ NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 57 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 76 58 xmlns xmln NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 59 : : : opencontent-org-7427 76 60 rdf=”http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf rdf=”http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf NN opencontent-org-7427 76 61 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 76 62 syntax syntax NN opencontent-org-7427 76 63 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 76 64 ns ns NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 65 # # $ opencontent-org-7427 76 66 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 76 67 > > XX opencontent-org-7427 76 68 < < XX opencontent-org-7427 76 69 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 76 70 rdf rdf NN opencontent-org-7427 76 71 : : : opencontent-org-7427 76 72 about=”http://opencontent.org about=”http://opencontent.org NN opencontent-org-7427 76 73 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 74 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 75 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 76 oel/1.0/ oel/1.0/ NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 77 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 76 78 > > XX opencontent-org-7427 76 79     _SP opencontent-org-7427 76 80 < < XX opencontent-org-7427 76 81 permits permit VBZ opencontent-org-7427 76 82 rdf rdf NN opencontent-org-7427 76 83 : : : opencontent-org-7427 76 84 resource=”http://creativecommons.org resource=”http://creativecommons.org NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 85 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 86 ns#Reproduction ns#Reproduction NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 87 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 76 88 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 89 > > XX opencontent-org-7427 76 90     _SP opencontent-org-7427 76 91 < < XX opencontent-org-7427 76 92 permits permit VBZ opencontent-org-7427 76 93 rdf rdf NN opencontent-org-7427 76 94 : : : opencontent-org-7427 76 95 resource=”http://creativecommons.org resource=”http://creativecommons.org NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 96 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 97 ns#Distribution ns#Distribution NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 98 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 76 99 / / , opencontent-org-7427 76 100 > > XX opencontent-org-7427 76 101     _SP opencontent-org-7427 76 102 < < XX opencontent-org-7427 76 103 permits permit VBZ opencontent-org-7427 76 104 rdf rdf NN opencontent-org-7427 76 105 : : : opencontent-org-7427 76 106 resource=”http://creativecommons.org resource=”http://creativecommons.org NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 107 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 76 108 ns#DerivativeWorks ns#DerivativeWorks NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 109 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 76 110 / / , opencontent-org-7427 76 111 > > XX opencontent-org-7427 76 112 < < XX opencontent-org-7427 76 113 /license /license , opencontent-org-7427 76 114 > > XX opencontent-org-7427 76 115 < < XX opencontent-org-7427 76 116 /rdf /rdf NFP opencontent-org-7427 76 117 > > XX opencontent-org-7427 76 118 Finally finally RB opencontent-org-7427 76 119 , , , opencontent-org-7427 76 120 Raquel Raquel NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 121 Xalabarder Xalabarder NNP opencontent-org-7427 76 122 has have VBZ opencontent-org-7427 76 123 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 76 124 extremely extremely RB opencontent-org-7427 76 125 helpful helpful JJ opencontent-org-7427 76 126 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 76 127 clarifying clarify VBG opencontent-org-7427 76 128 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 76 129 international international JJ opencontent-org-7427 76 130 issues issue NNS opencontent-org-7427 76 131 around around IN opencontent-org-7427 76 132 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 76 133 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 76 134 . . . opencontent-org-7427 77 1 And and CC opencontent-org-7427 77 2 now now RB opencontent-org-7427 77 3 , , , opencontent-org-7427 77 4 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 77 5 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 77 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 77 7 draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 77 8 . . . opencontent-org-7427 78 1 Open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 78 2 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 78 3 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 78 4 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 78 5 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 78 6 0.9 0.9 CD opencontent-org-7427 78 7 , , , opencontent-org-7427 78 8 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 78 9 8 8 CD opencontent-org-7427 78 10 , , , opencontent-org-7427 78 11 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 78 12 . . . opencontent-org-7427 79 1 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 79 2 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 79 3 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 79 4 draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 79 5 document document NN opencontent-org-7427 79 6 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 79 7 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 79 8 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 79 9 yet yet RB opencontent-org-7427 79 10 intended intend VBN opencontent-org-7427 79 11 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 79 12 use use NN opencontent-org-7427 79 13 . . . opencontent-org-7427 80 1 Disclaimer Disclaimer NNP opencontent-org-7427 80 2 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 80 3 OpenContent OpenContent NNP opencontent-org-7427 80 4 Foundation Foundation NNP opencontent-org-7427 80 5 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 80 6 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 80 7 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 80 8 law law NN opencontent-org-7427 80 9 firm firm NN opencontent-org-7427 80 10 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 80 11 does do VBZ opencontent-org-7427 80 12 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 80 13 provide provide VB opencontent-org-7427 80 14 legal legal JJ opencontent-org-7427 80 15 services service NNS opencontent-org-7427 80 16 . . . opencontent-org-7427 81 1 Distribution distribution NN opencontent-org-7427 81 2 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 81 3 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 81 4 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 81 5 does do VBZ opencontent-org-7427 81 6 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 81 7 create create VB opencontent-org-7427 81 8 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 81 9 attorney attorney NN opencontent-org-7427 81 10 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 81 11 client client NN opencontent-org-7427 81 12 relationship relationship NN opencontent-org-7427 81 13 . . . opencontent-org-7427 82 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 82 2 OpenContent OpenContent NNP opencontent-org-7427 82 3 Foundation Foundation NNP opencontent-org-7427 82 4 provides provide VBZ opencontent-org-7427 82 5 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 82 6 information information NN opencontent-org-7427 82 7 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 82 8 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 82 9 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 82 10 as as RB opencontent-org-7427 82 11 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 82 12 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 82 13 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 82 14 basis basis NN opencontent-org-7427 82 15 . . . opencontent-org-7427 83 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 83 2 OpenContent OpenContent NNP opencontent-org-7427 83 3 Foundation Foundation NNP opencontent-org-7427 83 4 makes make VBZ opencontent-org-7427 83 5 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 83 6 warranties warranty NNS opencontent-org-7427 83 7 regarding regard VBG opencontent-org-7427 83 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 83 9 information information NN opencontent-org-7427 83 10 provided provide VBN opencontent-org-7427 83 11 , , , opencontent-org-7427 83 12 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 83 13 disclaims disclaim VBZ opencontent-org-7427 83 14 liability liability NN opencontent-org-7427 83 15 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 83 16 damages damage NNS opencontent-org-7427 83 17 resulting result VBG opencontent-org-7427 83 18 from from IN opencontent-org-7427 83 19 its -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 83 20 use use NN opencontent-org-7427 83 21 . . . opencontent-org-7427 84 1 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 84 2 Licensor Licensor NNP opencontent-org-7427 84 3 hereby hereby NN opencontent-org-7427 84 4 grants grant VBZ opencontent-org-7427 84 5 You -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 84 6 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 84 7 worldwide worldwide RB opencontent-org-7427 84 8 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 9 royalty royalty NN opencontent-org-7427 84 10 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 84 11 free free JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 12 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 13 non non JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 14 - - JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 15 exclusive exclusive JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 16 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 84 17 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 84 18 exercise exercise VB opencontent-org-7427 84 19 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 84 20 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 84 21 all all DT opencontent-org-7427 84 22 rights right NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 23 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 84 24 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 25 Work work NN opencontent-org-7427 84 26 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 84 27 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 84 28 You -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 84 29 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 84 30 require require VB opencontent-org-7427 84 31 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 84 32 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 84 33 under under IN opencontent-org-7427 84 34 current current JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 35 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 36 applicable applicable JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 37 law law NN opencontent-org-7427 84 38 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 39 including include VBG opencontent-org-7427 84 40 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 84 41 but but CC opencontent-org-7427 84 42 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 84 43 limited limit VBN opencontent-org-7427 84 44 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 84 45 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 84 46 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 47 rights right NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 48 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 84 49 : : : opencontent-org-7427 84 50 Reuse reuse VB opencontent-org-7427 84 51 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 52 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 84 53 verbatim verbatim NN opencontent-org-7427 84 54 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 55 just just RB opencontent-org-7427 84 56 exactly exactly RB opencontent-org-7427 84 57 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 84 58 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 84 59 found find VBD opencontent-org-7427 84 60 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 84 61 Rework rework NN opencontent-org-7427 84 62 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 63 alter alter VB opencontent-org-7427 84 64 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 65 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 66 transform transform VB opencontent-org-7427 84 67 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 68 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 84 69 so so IN opencontent-org-7427 84 70 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 84 71 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 84 72 better well RBR opencontent-org-7427 84 73 meets meet VBZ opencontent-org-7427 84 74 your -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 84 75 needs need NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 76 Remix Remix NNP opencontent-org-7427 84 77 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 84 78 combine combine VB opencontent-org-7427 84 79 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 80 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 84 81 verbatim verbatim JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 82 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 83 altered altered JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 84 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 84 85 work work VB opencontent-org-7427 84 86 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 84 87 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 88 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 89 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 84 90 better well RBR opencontent-org-7427 84 91 meet meet VB opencontent-org-7427 84 92 your -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 84 93 needs need NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 94 Redistribute redistribute NN opencontent-org-7427 84 95 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 96 verbatim verbatim JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 97 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 84 98 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 99 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 100 altered altered JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 101 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 84 102 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 103 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 104 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 105 remixed remixed JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 106 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 84 107 Representations Representations NNPS opencontent-org-7427 84 108 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 109 Warranties Warranties NNPS opencontent-org-7427 84 110 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 84 111 Disclaimer Disclaimer NNP opencontent-org-7427 84 112 Unless unless IN opencontent-org-7427 84 113 otherwise otherwise RB opencontent-org-7427 84 114 mutually mutually RB opencontent-org-7427 84 115 agreed agree VBD opencontent-org-7427 84 116 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 84 117 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 84 118 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 119 parties party NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 120 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 84 121 writing writing NN opencontent-org-7427 84 122 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 123 licensor licensor NN opencontent-org-7427 84 124 offers offer VBZ opencontent-org-7427 84 125 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 126 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 84 127 as as RB opencontent-org-7427 84 128 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 84 129 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 84 130 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 84 131 makes make VBZ opencontent-org-7427 84 132 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 84 133 representations representation NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 134 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 135 warranties warranty NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 136 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 84 137 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 84 138 kind kind NN opencontent-org-7427 84 139 concerning concern VBG opencontent-org-7427 84 140 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 141 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 84 142 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 143 express express VB opencontent-org-7427 84 144 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 145 implied implied JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 146 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 147 statutory statutory JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 148 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 149 otherwise otherwise RB opencontent-org-7427 84 150 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 151 including include VBG opencontent-org-7427 84 152 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 153 without without IN opencontent-org-7427 84 154 limitation limitation NN opencontent-org-7427 84 155 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 156 warranties warranty NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 157 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 84 158 title title NN opencontent-org-7427 84 159 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 160 merchantibility merchantibility NN opencontent-org-7427 84 161 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 162 fitness fitness NN opencontent-org-7427 84 163 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 84 164 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 84 165 particular particular JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 166 purpose purpose NN opencontent-org-7427 84 167 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 168 noninfringement noninfringement NN opencontent-org-7427 84 169 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 170 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 171 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 172 absence absence NN opencontent-org-7427 84 173 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 84 174 latent latent NN opencontent-org-7427 84 175 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 176 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 177 defects defect NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 178 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 179 accuracy accuracy NN opencontent-org-7427 84 180 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 181 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 182 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 84 183 presence presence NN opencontent-org-7427 84 184 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 84 185 absence absence NN opencontent-org-7427 84 186 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 84 187 errors error NNS opencontent-org-7427 84 188 , , , opencontent-org-7427 84 189 whether whether IN opencontent-org-7427 84 190 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 84 191 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 84 192 discoverable discoverable JJ opencontent-org-7427 84 193 . . . opencontent-org-7427 85 1 Some some DT opencontent-org-7427 85 2 jurisdictions jurisdiction NNS opencontent-org-7427 85 3 do do VBP opencontent-org-7427 85 4 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 85 5 allow allow VB opencontent-org-7427 85 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 85 7 exclusion exclusion NN opencontent-org-7427 85 8 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 85 9 implied implied JJ opencontent-org-7427 85 10 warranties warranty NNS opencontent-org-7427 85 11 , , , opencontent-org-7427 85 12 so so IN opencontent-org-7427 85 13 such such JJ opencontent-org-7427 85 14 exclusion exclusion NN opencontent-org-7427 85 15 may may MD opencontent-org-7427 85 16 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 85 17 apply apply VB opencontent-org-7427 85 18 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 85 19 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 85 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 86 1 Limitation limitation NN opencontent-org-7427 86 2 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 86 3 Liability Liability NNP opencontent-org-7427 86 4 Except except IN opencontent-org-7427 86 5 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 86 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 86 7 extent extent NN opencontent-org-7427 86 8 required require VBN opencontent-org-7427 86 9 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 86 10 applicable applicable JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 11 law law NN opencontent-org-7427 86 12 , , , opencontent-org-7427 86 13 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 86 14 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 86 15 event event NN opencontent-org-7427 86 16 will will MD opencontent-org-7427 86 17 licensor licensor VB opencontent-org-7427 86 18 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 86 19 liable liable JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 20 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 86 21 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 86 22 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 86 23 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 86 24 legal legal JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 25 theory theory NN opencontent-org-7427 86 26 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 86 27 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 86 28 special special JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 29 , , , opencontent-org-7427 86 30 incidental incidental JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 31 , , , opencontent-org-7427 86 32 consequential consequential JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 33 , , , opencontent-org-7427 86 34 punitive punitive JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 35 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 86 36 exemplary exemplary JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 37 damages damage NNS opencontent-org-7427 86 38 arising arise VBG opencontent-org-7427 86 39 out out IN opencontent-org-7427 86 40 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 86 41 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 86 42 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 86 43 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 86 44 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 86 45 use use NN opencontent-org-7427 86 46 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 86 47 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 86 48 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 86 49 , , , opencontent-org-7427 86 50 even even RB opencontent-org-7427 86 51 if if IN opencontent-org-7427 86 52 licensor licensor NN opencontent-org-7427 86 53 has have VBZ opencontent-org-7427 86 54 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 86 55 advised advise VBN opencontent-org-7427 86 56 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 86 57 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 86 58 possibility possibility NN opencontent-org-7427 86 59 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 86 60 such such JJ opencontent-org-7427 86 61 damages damage NNS opencontent-org-7427 86 62 . . . opencontent-org-7427 87 1 Termination Termination NNP opencontent-org-7427 87 2 Subject subject JJ opencontent-org-7427 87 3 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 87 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 87 5 above above JJ opencontent-org-7427 87 6 terms term NNS opencontent-org-7427 87 7 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 87 8 conditions condition NNS opencontent-org-7427 87 9 , , , opencontent-org-7427 87 10 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 87 11 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 87 12 granted grant VBN opencontent-org-7427 87 13 here here RB opencontent-org-7427 87 14 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 87 15 perpetual perpetual JJ opencontent-org-7427 87 16 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 87 17 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 87 18 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 87 19 duration duration NN opencontent-org-7427 87 20 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 87 21 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 87 22 applicable applicable JJ opencontent-org-7427 87 23 copyright copyright NN opencontent-org-7427 87 24 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 87 25 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 87 26 Work work NN opencontent-org-7427 87 27 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 87 28 . . . opencontent-org-7427 88 1 So so CC opencontent-org-7427 88 2 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 88 3 what what WP opencontent-org-7427 88 4 do do VBP opencontent-org-7427 88 5 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 88 6 think think VB opencontent-org-7427 88 7 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 89 1 Related related JJ opencontent-org-7427 89 2 Tags Tags NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 3 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 89 4 , , , opencontent-org-7427 89 5 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 89 6 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 89 7 ← ← NNS opencontent-org-7427 89 8 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 89 9 Design Design NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 10 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 89 11 Use Use NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 12 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 89 13 Simulation Simulation NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 14 Computer Computer NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 15 Games Games NNPS opencontent-org-7427 89 16 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 89 17 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 18 → → SYM opencontent-org-7427 89 19 Assymetry Assymetry NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 20 , , , opencontent-org-7427 89 21 Hypocrisy Hypocrisy NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 22 , , , opencontent-org-7427 89 23 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 89 24 Public Public NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 25 Domain Domain NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 26 19 19 CD opencontent-org-7427 89 27 replies reply NNS opencontent-org-7427 89 28 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 89 29 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 89 30 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 31 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 32 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 33 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 34 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 89 35 iterating iterate VBG opencontent-org-7427 89 36 toward toward IN opencontent-org-7427 89 37 openness openness NN opencontent-org-7427 89 38 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 89 39 david david NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 40 : : : opencontent-org-7427 89 41 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 42 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 43 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 44 Draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 89 45 « « NN opencontent-org-7427 89 46 Identity Identity NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 47 Unknownsays unknownsay NNS opencontent-org-7427 89 48 : : : opencontent-org-7427 89 49 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 50 8 8 CD opencontent-org-7427 89 51 , , , opencontent-org-7427 89 52 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 89 53 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 89 54 8:05 8:05 CD opencontent-org-7427 89 55 am am NN opencontent-org-7427 89 56 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 89 57 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 89 58 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 89 59 Aug Aug NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 60 8th 8th NN opencontent-org-7427 89 61 , , , opencontent-org-7427 89 62 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 89 63 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 89 64 Ryan Ryan NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 65 Lanham Lanham NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 66 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 67 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 68 License license NN opencontent-org-7427 89 69 Draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 89 70 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 89 71 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 89 72 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 89 73 Cem Cem NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 74 Kanersays Kanersays NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 75 : : : opencontent-org-7427 89 76 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 77 9 9 CD opencontent-org-7427 89 78 , , , opencontent-org-7427 89 79 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 89 80 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 89 81 10:48 10:48 CD opencontent-org-7427 89 82 am be VBP opencontent-org-7427 89 83 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 89 84 ’ve have VB opencontent-org-7427 89 85 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 89 86 struggling struggle VBG opencontent-org-7427 89 87 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 89 88 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 89 89 idea idea NN opencontent-org-7427 89 90 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 89 91 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 89 92 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 89 93 Education education NN opencontent-org-7427 89 94 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 89 95 as as RB opencontent-org-7427 89 96 well well RB opencontent-org-7427 89 97 . . . opencontent-org-7427 90 1 There there EX opencontent-org-7427 90 2 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 90 3 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 90 4 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 90 5 least least JJS opencontent-org-7427 90 6 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 90 7 two two CD opencontent-org-7427 90 8 types type NNS opencontent-org-7427 90 9 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 90 10 material material NN opencontent-org-7427 90 11 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 90 12 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 90 13 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 90 14 least least JJS opencontent-org-7427 90 15 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 90 16 two two CD opencontent-org-7427 90 17 types type NNS opencontent-org-7427 90 18 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 90 19 users user NNS opencontent-org-7427 90 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 91 1 Materials material NNS opencontent-org-7427 91 2 : : : opencontent-org-7427 91 3 – – : opencontent-org-7427 91 4 generated generate VBN opencontent-org-7427 91 5 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 91 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 91 7 instructor instructor NN opencontent-org-7427 91 8 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 91 9 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 91 10 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 91 11 instructors instructor NNS opencontent-org-7427 91 12 who who WP opencontent-org-7427 91 13 share share VBP opencontent-org-7427 91 14 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 91 15 under under IN opencontent-org-7427 91 16 some some DT opencontent-org-7427 91 17 sort sort NN opencontent-org-7427 91 18 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 91 19 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 91 20 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 91 21 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 91 22 – – : opencontent-org-7427 91 23 generated generate VBN opencontent-org-7427 91 24 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 91 25 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 91 26 students student NNS opencontent-org-7427 91 27 Users user NNS opencontent-org-7427 91 28 : : : opencontent-org-7427 91 29 – – : opencontent-org-7427 91 30 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 91 31 instructor instructor NN opencontent-org-7427 91 32 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 91 33 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 91 34 future future JJ opencontent-org-7427 91 35 instructors instructor NNS opencontent-org-7427 91 36 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 91 37 – – : opencontent-org-7427 91 38 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 91 39 student student NN opencontent-org-7427 91 40 who who WP opencontent-org-7427 91 41 wants want VBZ opencontent-org-7427 91 42 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 91 43 reuse reuse VB opencontent-org-7427 91 44 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 91 45 quote quote VB opencontent-org-7427 91 46 another another DT opencontent-org-7427 91 47 student student NN opencontent-org-7427 91 48 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 91 49 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 91 50 . . . opencontent-org-7427 92 1 There there EX opencontent-org-7427 92 2 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 92 3 legal legal JJ opencontent-org-7427 92 4 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 92 5 ethical ethical JJ opencontent-org-7427 92 6 reasons reason NNS opencontent-org-7427 92 7 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 92 8 restricting restrict VBG opencontent-org-7427 92 9 reuse reuse NN opencontent-org-7427 92 10 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 92 11 student student NN opencontent-org-7427 92 12 material material NN opencontent-org-7427 92 13 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 92 14 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 92 15 absence absence NN opencontent-org-7427 92 16 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 92 17 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 92 18 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 92 19 . . . opencontent-org-7427 93 1 There there EX opencontent-org-7427 93 2 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 93 3 confidentiality confidentiality NN opencontent-org-7427 93 4 issues issue NNS opencontent-org-7427 93 5 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 93 6 restricting restrict VBG opencontent-org-7427 93 7 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 93 8 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 93 9 student student NN opencontent-org-7427 93 10 material material NN opencontent-org-7427 93 11 , , , opencontent-org-7427 93 12 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 93 13 least least JJS opencontent-org-7427 93 14 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 93 15 which which WDT opencontent-org-7427 93 16 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 93 17 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 93 18 need need NN opencontent-org-7427 93 19 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 93 20 allow allow VB opencontent-org-7427 93 21 space space NN opencontent-org-7427 93 22 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 93 23 students student NNS opencontent-org-7427 93 24 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 93 25 try try VB opencontent-org-7427 93 26 out out RP opencontent-org-7427 93 27 really really RB opencontent-org-7427 93 28 dumb dumb JJ opencontent-org-7427 93 29 arguments argument NNS opencontent-org-7427 93 30 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 93 31 order order NN opencontent-org-7427 93 32 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 93 33 get get VB opencontent-org-7427 93 34 feedback feedback NN opencontent-org-7427 93 35 . . . opencontent-org-7427 94 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 94 2 risk risk NN opencontent-org-7427 94 3 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 94 4 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 94 5 permanent permanent JJ opencontent-org-7427 94 6 record record NN opencontent-org-7427 94 7 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 94 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 94 9 form form NN opencontent-org-7427 94 10 , , , opencontent-org-7427 94 11 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 94 12 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 94 13 person person NN opencontent-org-7427 94 14 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 94 15 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 94 16 idiot idiot NN opencontent-org-7427 94 17 , , , opencontent-org-7427 94 18 read read VB opencontent-org-7427 94 19 what what WP opencontent-org-7427 94 20 s s VBZ opencontent-org-7427 94 21 / / SYM opencontent-org-7427 94 22 he -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 94 23 wrote write VBD opencontent-org-7427 94 24 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 94 25 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 94 26 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 94 27 too too RB opencontent-org-7427 94 28 serious serious JJ opencontent-org-7427 94 29 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 94 30 ignore ignore VB opencontent-org-7427 94 31 . . . opencontent-org-7427 95 1 Some some DT opencontent-org-7427 95 2 colleagues colleague NNS opencontent-org-7427 95 3 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 95 4 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 95 5 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 95 6 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 95 7 wrestling wrestle VBG opencontent-org-7427 95 8 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 95 9 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 95 10 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 95 11 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 95 12 while while NN opencontent-org-7427 95 13 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 95 14 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 95 15 currently currently RB opencontent-org-7427 95 16 using use VBG opencontent-org-7427 95 17 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 95 18 following follow VBG opencontent-org-7427 95 19 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 95 20 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 95 21 our -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 95 22 online online JJ opencontent-org-7427 95 23 courses course NNS opencontent-org-7427 95 24 . . . opencontent-org-7427 96 1 You -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 96 2 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 96 3 welcome welcome JJ opencontent-org-7427 96 4 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 96 5 mine -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 96 6 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 96 7 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 96 8 ideas idea NNS opencontent-org-7427 96 9 . . . opencontent-org-7427 97 1 http://www.associationforsoftwaretesting.org/BBST/ASTBBSTIntellectualProperty.htm http://www.associationforsoftwaretesting.org/bbst/astbbstintellectualproperty.htm LS opencontent-org-7427 97 2 — — : opencontent-org-7427 97 3 Cem Cem NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 4 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 5 Knowledge knowledge NN opencontent-org-7427 97 6 Foundation Foundation NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 7 Weblog Weblog NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 8 » » '' opencontent-org-7427 97 9 Blog Blog NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 10 Archive Archive NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 11 » » . opencontent-org-7427 97 12 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 97 13 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 14 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 15 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 16 Draftsays draftsay NNS opencontent-org-7427 97 17 : : : opencontent-org-7427 97 18 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 19 9 9 CD opencontent-org-7427 97 20 , , , opencontent-org-7427 97 21 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 97 22 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 97 23 5:15 5:15 CD opencontent-org-7427 97 24 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 97 25 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 97 26 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 97 27 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 97 28 Dr. Dr. NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 29 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 30 Wiley Wiley NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 31 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 97 32 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 33 Content Content NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 34 published publish VBD opencontent-org-7427 97 35 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 97 36 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 37 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 38 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 39 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 97 40 . . . opencontent-org-7427 98 1 Before before IN opencontent-org-7427 98 2 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 98 3 text text NN opencontent-org-7427 98 4 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 98 5 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 98 6 draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 98 7 itself -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 98 8 he -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 98 9 relates relate VBZ opencontent-org-7427 98 10 some some DT opencontent-org-7427 98 11 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 98 12 his -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 98 13 thoughts thought NNS opencontent-org-7427 98 14 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 98 15 experiences experience NNS opencontent-org-7427 98 16 relating relate VBG opencontent-org-7427 98 17 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 98 18 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 98 19 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 98 20 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 98 21 Wide wide JJ opencontent-org-7427 98 22 Open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 98 23 Education education NN opencontent-org-7427 98 24 » » NNS opencontent-org-7427 98 25 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 98 26 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 98 27 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 98 28 punchsays punchsay NNS opencontent-org-7427 98 29 : : : opencontent-org-7427 98 30 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 98 31 9 9 CD opencontent-org-7427 98 32 , , , opencontent-org-7427 98 33 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 98 34 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 98 35 5:47 5:47 CD opencontent-org-7427 98 36 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 98 37 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 98 38 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 98 39 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 98 40 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 98 41 Wiley Wiley NNP opencontent-org-7427 98 42 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 98 43 windup windup NN opencontent-org-7427 98 44 : : : opencontent-org-7427 98 45 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 98 46 release release NN opencontent-org-7427 98 47 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 98 48 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 98 49 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 98 50 OpenContent OpenContent NNP opencontent-org-7427 98 51 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 98 52 draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 98 53 . . . opencontent-org-7427 99 1 While while IN opencontent-org-7427 99 2 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 99 3 first first RB opencontent-org-7427 99 4 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 99 5 might may MD opencontent-org-7427 99 6 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 99 7 thinking think VBG opencontent-org-7427 99 8 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 99 9 Why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 99 10 another another DT opencontent-org-7427 99 11 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 99 12 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 99 13 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 99 14 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 99 15 but but CC opencontent-org-7427 99 16 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 99 17 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 99 18 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 99 19 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 99 20 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 99 21 D'Arcy D'Arcy NNP opencontent-org-7427 99 22 Normansays Normansays NNPS opencontent-org-7427 99 23 : : : opencontent-org-7427 99 24 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 99 25 10 10 CD opencontent-org-7427 99 26 , , , opencontent-org-7427 99 27 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 99 28 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 99 29 7:55 7:55 CD opencontent-org-7427 99 30 am be VBP opencontent-org-7427 99 31 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 99 32 , , , opencontent-org-7427 99 33 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 99 34 ’ve have VB opencontent-org-7427 99 35 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 99 36 struggling struggle VBG opencontent-org-7427 99 37 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 99 38 understand understand VB opencontent-org-7427 99 39 why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 99 40 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 99 41 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 99 42 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 99 43 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 99 44 warranted warrant VBN opencontent-org-7427 99 45 . . . opencontent-org-7427 100 1 How how WRB opencontent-org-7427 100 2 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 100 3 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 100 4 benefit benefit VB opencontent-org-7427 100 5 either either CC opencontent-org-7427 100 6 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 100 7 original original JJ opencontent-org-7427 100 8 creator creator NN opencontent-org-7427 100 9 , , , opencontent-org-7427 100 10 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 100 11 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 100 12 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 100 13 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 100 14 repurposer repurposer NN opencontent-org-7427 100 15 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 100 16 beyond beyond IN opencontent-org-7427 100 17 what what WP opencontent-org-7427 100 18 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 100 19 plain plain JJ opencontent-org-7427 100 20 vanilla vanilla NN opencontent-org-7427 100 21 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 100 22 Commons Commons NNP opencontent-org-7427 100 23 Attribution Attribution NNP opencontent-org-7427 100 24 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 100 25 provides provide VBZ opencontent-org-7427 100 26 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 101 1 That that DT opencontent-org-7427 101 2 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 101 3 allows allow VBZ opencontent-org-7427 101 4 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 101 5 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 101 6 , , , opencontent-org-7427 101 7 does do VBZ opencontent-org-7427 101 8 n’t not RB opencontent-org-7427 101 9 require require VB opencontent-org-7427 101 10 share share NN opencontent-org-7427 101 11 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 101 12 alike alike RB opencontent-org-7427 101 13 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 101 14 although although IN opencontent-org-7427 101 15 that that DT opencontent-org-7427 101 16 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 101 17 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 101 18 added add VBN opencontent-org-7427 101 19 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 101 20 , , , opencontent-org-7427 101 21 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 101 22 requires require VBZ opencontent-org-7427 101 23 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 101 24 . . . opencontent-org-7427 102 1 It -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 102 2 also also RB opencontent-org-7427 102 3 allows allow VBZ opencontent-org-7427 102 4 commercial commercial JJ opencontent-org-7427 102 5 use use NN opencontent-org-7427 102 6 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 102 7 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 102 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 102 9 original original JJ opencontent-org-7427 102 10 and/or and/or CC opencontent-org-7427 102 11 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 102 12 works work NNS opencontent-org-7427 102 13 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 102 14 – – : opencontent-org-7427 102 15 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 102 16 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 102 17 , , , opencontent-org-7427 102 18 if if IN opencontent-org-7427 102 19 desired desire VBN opencontent-org-7427 102 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 103 1 Would Would MD opencontent-org-7427 103 2 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 103 3 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 103 4 as as RB opencontent-org-7427 103 5 effective effective JJ opencontent-org-7427 103 6 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 103 7 just just RB opencontent-org-7427 103 8 recommend recommend VB opencontent-org-7427 103 9 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 103 10 particular particular JJ opencontent-org-7427 103 11 combination combination NN opencontent-org-7427 103 12 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 103 13 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 103 14 bit bit NN opencontent-org-7427 103 15 flags flag NNS opencontent-org-7427 103 16 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 104 1 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 2 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 3 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 4 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 104 5 Attribution Attribution NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 6 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 104 7 important important JJ opencontent-org-7427 104 8 - - : opencontent-org-7427 104 9 D'Arcy D'Arcy NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 10 Norman Norman NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 11 dot dot NN opencontent-org-7427 104 12 netsays netsay VBZ opencontent-org-7427 104 13 : : : opencontent-org-7427 104 14 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 15 10 10 CD opencontent-org-7427 104 16 , , , opencontent-org-7427 104 17 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 104 18 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 104 19 10:16 10:16 CD opencontent-org-7427 104 20 am am NN opencontent-org-7427 104 21 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 104 22 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 104 23 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 104 24 read read VBD opencontent-org-7427 104 25 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 26 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 104 27 post post NN opencontent-org-7427 104 28 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 104 29 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 104 30 proposed propose VBN opencontent-org-7427 104 31 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 104 32 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 33 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 34 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 104 35 , , , opencontent-org-7427 104 36 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 104 37 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 104 38 ’ve have VB opencontent-org-7427 104 39 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 104 40 struggling struggle VBG opencontent-org-7427 104 41 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 104 42 understand understand VB opencontent-org-7427 104 43 why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 104 44 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 104 45 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 104 46 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 104 47 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 104 48 needed need VBN opencontent-org-7427 104 49 . . . opencontent-org-7427 105 1 Here here RB opencontent-org-7427 105 2 ’s ’ VBZ opencontent-org-7427 105 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 105 4 comment comment NN opencontent-org-7427 105 5 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 105 6 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 105 7 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 105 8 leighblackallsays leighblackallsay NNS opencontent-org-7427 105 9 : : : opencontent-org-7427 105 10 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 105 11 10 10 CD opencontent-org-7427 105 12 , , , opencontent-org-7427 105 13 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 105 14 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 105 15 4:17 4:17 CD opencontent-org-7427 105 16 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 105 17 Hi hi UH opencontent-org-7427 105 18 Dave Dave NNP opencontent-org-7427 105 19 , , , opencontent-org-7427 105 20 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 105 21 ’m be VBP opencontent-org-7427 105 22 going go VBG opencontent-org-7427 105 23 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 105 24 second second JJ opencontent-org-7427 105 25 D’Arcy d’arcy NN opencontent-org-7427 105 26 here here RB opencontent-org-7427 105 27 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 105 28 needing need VBG opencontent-org-7427 105 29 more more JJR opencontent-org-7427 105 30 clarification clarification NN opencontent-org-7427 105 31 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 105 32 why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 105 33 CC CC NNP opencontent-org-7427 105 34 BY BY NNP opencontent-org-7427 105 35 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 105 36 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 105 37 usable usable JJ opencontent-org-7427 105 38 . . . opencontent-org-7427 106 1 In in IN opencontent-org-7427 106 2 education education NN opencontent-org-7427 106 3 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 106 4 academia academia NN opencontent-org-7427 106 5 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 106 6 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 106 7 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 106 8 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 106 9 should should MD opencontent-org-7427 106 10 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 106 11 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 106 12 normal normal JJ opencontent-org-7427 106 13 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 106 14 attribute attribute VB opencontent-org-7427 106 15 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 106 16 sources source NNS opencontent-org-7427 106 17 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 106 18 original original JJ opencontent-org-7427 106 19 creator creator NN opencontent-org-7427 106 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 107 1 It -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 107 2 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 107 3 common common JJ opencontent-org-7427 107 4 practice practice NN opencontent-org-7427 107 5 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 107 6 text text NN opencontent-org-7427 107 7 , , , opencontent-org-7427 107 8 very very RB opencontent-org-7427 107 9 uncommon uncommon JJ opencontent-org-7427 107 10 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 107 11 images image NNS opencontent-org-7427 107 12 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 107 13 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 107 14 media medium NNS opencontent-org-7427 107 15 . . . opencontent-org-7427 108 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 108 2 see see VBP opencontent-org-7427 108 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 108 4 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 108 5 BY by RB opencontent-org-7427 108 6 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 108 7 complimentary complimentary NN opencontent-org-7427 108 8 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 108 9 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 108 10 academic academic JJ opencontent-org-7427 108 11 effort effort NN opencontent-org-7427 108 12 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 108 13 sustain sustain VB opencontent-org-7427 108 14 links link NNS opencontent-org-7427 108 15 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 108 16 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 108 17 past past NN opencontent-org-7427 108 18 . . . opencontent-org-7427 109 1 Public Public NNP opencontent-org-7427 109 2 Domain Domain NNP opencontent-org-7427 109 3 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 109 4 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 109 5 derivative derivative JJ opencontent-org-7427 109 6 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 109 7 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 109 8 similar similar JJ opencontent-org-7427 109 9 intent intent NN opencontent-org-7427 109 10 , , , opencontent-org-7427 109 11 makes make VBZ opencontent-org-7427 109 12 allowances allowance NNS opencontent-org-7427 109 13 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 109 14 that that DT opencontent-org-7427 109 15 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 109 16 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 109 17 slacken slacken VB opencontent-org-7427 109 18 off off RP opencontent-org-7427 109 19 , , , opencontent-org-7427 109 20 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 109 21 so so RB opencontent-org-7427 109 22 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 109 23 links link NNS opencontent-org-7427 109 24 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 109 25 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 109 26 past past NN opencontent-org-7427 109 27 may may MD opencontent-org-7427 109 28 fray fray VB opencontent-org-7427 109 29 . . . opencontent-org-7427 110 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 110 2 struggle struggle VBP opencontent-org-7427 110 3 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 110 4 see see VB opencontent-org-7427 110 5 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 110 6 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 110 7 can can MD opencontent-org-7427 110 8 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 110 9 seen see VBN opencontent-org-7427 110 10 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 110 11 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 110 12 restriction restriction NN opencontent-org-7427 110 13 . . . opencontent-org-7427 111 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 111 2 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 111 3 no no DT opencontent-org-7427 111 4 trouble trouble NN opencontent-org-7427 111 5 seeing see VBG opencontent-org-7427 111 6 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 111 7 copyleft copyleft VBN opencontent-org-7427 111 8 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 111 9 restrictive restrictive JJ opencontent-org-7427 111 10 . . . opencontent-org-7427 112 1 Attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 112 2 seems seem VBZ opencontent-org-7427 112 3 almost almost RB opencontent-org-7427 112 4 more more JJR opencontent-org-7427 112 5 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 112 6 moral moral JJ opencontent-org-7427 112 7 obligation obligation NN opencontent-org-7427 112 8 , , , opencontent-org-7427 112 9 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 112 10 certainly certainly RB opencontent-org-7427 112 11 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 112 12 academic academic JJ opencontent-org-7427 112 13 best good JJS opencontent-org-7427 112 14 practice practice NN opencontent-org-7427 112 15 . . . opencontent-org-7427 113 1 So so RB opencontent-org-7427 113 2 why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 113 3 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 113 4 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 113 5 plain plain JJ opencontent-org-7427 113 6 old old JJ opencontent-org-7427 113 7 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 113 8 BY by RB opencontent-org-7427 113 9 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 114 1 Steve Steve NNP opencontent-org-7427 114 2 Foerstersays Foerstersays NNP opencontent-org-7427 114 3 : : : opencontent-org-7427 114 4 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 114 5 11 11 CD opencontent-org-7427 114 6 , , , opencontent-org-7427 114 7 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 114 8 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 114 9 5:52 5:52 CD opencontent-org-7427 114 10 am am NN opencontent-org-7427 114 11 Public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 114 12 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 114 13 dedications dedication NNS opencontent-org-7427 114 14 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 114 15 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 114 16 difficult difficult JJ opencontent-org-7427 114 17 . . . opencontent-org-7427 115 1 Most Most JJS opencontent-org-7427 115 2 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 115 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 115 4 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 115 5 Commons Commons NNPS opencontent-org-7427 115 6 process process NN opencontent-org-7427 115 7 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 115 8 legally legally RB opencontent-org-7427 115 9 unnecessary unnecessary JJ opencontent-org-7427 115 10 . . . opencontent-org-7427 116 1 Simply simply RB opencontent-org-7427 116 2 appending append VBG opencontent-org-7427 116 3 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 116 4 notice notice NN opencontent-org-7427 116 5 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 116 6 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 116 7 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 116 8 dedicating dedicate VBG opencontent-org-7427 116 9 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 116 10 material material NN opencontent-org-7427 116 11 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 116 12 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 116 13 public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 116 14 domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 116 15 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 116 16 sufficient sufficient JJ opencontent-org-7427 116 17 . . . opencontent-org-7427 117 1 For for IN opencontent-org-7427 117 2 those those DT opencontent-org-7427 117 3 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 117 4 whom whom WP opencontent-org-7427 117 5 that that DT opencontent-org-7427 117 6 ’s ’ VBZ opencontent-org-7427 117 7 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 117 8 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 117 9 good good JJ opencontent-org-7427 117 10 solution solution NN opencontent-org-7427 117 11 , , , opencontent-org-7427 117 12 then then RB opencontent-org-7427 117 13 like like IN opencontent-org-7427 117 14 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 117 15 others other NNS opencontent-org-7427 117 16 , , , opencontent-org-7427 117 17 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 117 18 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 117 19 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 117 20 ask ask VB opencontent-org-7427 117 21 what what WP opencontent-org-7427 117 22 ’s ’ VBZ opencontent-org-7427 117 23 so so RB opencontent-org-7427 117 24 wrong wrong JJ opencontent-org-7427 117 25 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 117 26 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 117 27 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 117 28 BY BY NNP opencontent-org-7427 117 29 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 117 30 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 117 31 new new JJ opencontent-org-7427 117 32 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 117 33 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 117 34 warranted warrant VBN opencontent-org-7427 117 35 . . . opencontent-org-7427 118 1 Unilever Unilever NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 2 Centre Centre NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 3 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 118 4 Molecular Molecular NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 5 Informatics Informatics NNPS opencontent-org-7427 118 6 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 7 Cambridge Cambridge NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 8 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 118 9 petermr petermr NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 10 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 118 11 blog blog NN opencontent-org-7427 118 12 » » `` opencontent-org-7427 118 13 Blog Blog NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 14 Archive Archive NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 15 » » '' opencontent-org-7427 118 16 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 118 17 data datum NNS opencontent-org-7427 118 18 : : : opencontent-org-7427 118 19 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 118 20 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 118 21 needed?says needed?says . opencontent-org-7427 118 22 : : : opencontent-org-7427 118 23 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 24 11 11 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 25 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 26 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 27 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 118 28 7:49 7:49 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 29 am am NN opencontent-org-7427 118 30 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 31 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 118 32 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 33 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 34 Education education NN opencontent-org-7427 118 35 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 36 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 37 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 118 38 Assymetry Assymetry NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 39 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 40 Hypocrisy Hypocrisy NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 41 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 42 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 118 43 Public Public NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 44 Domain Domain NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 45 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 46 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 118 47 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 48 Unilever Unilever NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 49 Centre Centre NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 50 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 118 51 Molecular Molecular NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 52 Informatics Informatics NNPS opencontent-org-7427 118 53 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 54 Cambridge Cambridge NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 55 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 118 56 petermr petermr NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 57 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 118 58 blog blog NN opencontent-org-7427 118 59 » » `` opencontent-org-7427 118 60 Blog Blog NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 61 Archive Archive NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 62 » » '' opencontent-org-7427 118 63 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 118 64 data datum NNS opencontent-org-7427 118 65 : : : opencontent-org-7427 118 66 concepts concept NNS opencontent-org-7427 118 67 from from IN opencontent-org-7427 118 68 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 69 Wileysays Wileysays NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 70 : : : opencontent-org-7427 118 71 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 72 11 11 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 73 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 74 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 75 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 118 76 8:18 8:18 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 77 am am NN opencontent-org-7427 118 78 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 79 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 118 80 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 81 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 82 Education education NN opencontent-org-7427 118 83 License license NN opencontent-org-7427 118 84 Draft Draft NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 85 Published publish VBN opencontent-org-7427 118 86 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 118 87 david david NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 88 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 89 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 118 90 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 91 » » ADD opencontent-org-7427 118 92 Open open VB opencontent-org-7427 118 93 science science NN opencontent-org-7427 118 94 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 118 95 licensing licensing NN opencontent-org-7427 118 96 » » '' opencontent-org-7427 118 97 business|bytes|genes|moleculessays business|bytes|genes|moleculessay NNS opencontent-org-7427 118 98 : : : opencontent-org-7427 118 99 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 100 11 11 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 101 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 102 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 103 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 118 104 10:14 10:14 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 105 am be VBP opencontent-org-7427 118 106 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 107 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 118 108 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 109 reading read VBG opencontent-org-7427 118 110 Open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 118 111 education education NN opencontent-org-7427 118 112 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 118 113 draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 118 114 Assymetry Assymetry NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 115 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 116 Hypcrisy Hypcrisy NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 117 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 118 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 118 119 Public public JJ opencontent-org-7427 118 120 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 121 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 118 122 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 118 123 Peter Peter NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 124 Rawsthornesays Rawsthornesays NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 125 : : : opencontent-org-7427 118 126 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 118 127 11 11 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 128 , , , opencontent-org-7427 118 129 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 130 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 118 131 12:36 12:36 CD opencontent-org-7427 118 132 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 118 133 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 118 134 ’m be VBP opencontent-org-7427 118 135 going go VBG opencontent-org-7427 118 136 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 118 137 stray stray VB opencontent-org-7427 118 138 from from IN opencontent-org-7427 118 139 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 118 140 questioning questioning NN opencontent-org-7427 118 141 theme theme NN opencontent-org-7427 118 142 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 118 143 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 118 144 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 118 145 comments comment NNS opencontent-org-7427 118 146 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 118 147 state state NN opencontent-org-7427 118 148 that that WDT opencontent-org-7427 118 149 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 118 150 like like VBP opencontent-org-7427 118 151 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 118 152 description description NN opencontent-org-7427 118 153 . . . opencontent-org-7427 119 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 119 2 ’m be VBP opencontent-org-7427 119 3 still still RB opencontent-org-7427 119 4 fence fence VBP opencontent-org-7427 119 5 sitting sit VBG opencontent-org-7427 119 6 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 119 7 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 119 8 actual actual JJ opencontent-org-7427 119 9 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 119 10 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 119 11 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 119 12 like like VBP opencontent-org-7427 119 13 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 119 14 description description NN opencontent-org-7427 119 15 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 119 16 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 119 17 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 119 18 articulates articulate NNS opencontent-org-7427 119 19 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 119 20 issues issue NNS opencontent-org-7427 119 21 around around IN opencontent-org-7427 119 22 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 119 23 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 119 24 educational educational JJ opencontent-org-7427 119 25 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 119 26 . . . opencontent-org-7427 120 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 120 2 may may MD opencontent-org-7427 120 3 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 120 4 so so RB opencontent-org-7427 120 5 bold bold JJ opencontent-org-7427 120 6 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 120 7 say say VB opencontent-org-7427 120 8 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 120 9 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 120 10 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 120 11 best good JJS opencontent-org-7427 120 12 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 120 13 have have VBP opencontent-org-7427 120 14 read read VBN opencontent-org-7427 120 15 . . . opencontent-org-7427 121 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 121 2 been be VBN opencontent-org-7427 121 3 hard hard JJ opencontent-org-7427 121 4 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 121 5 find find VB opencontent-org-7427 121 6 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 121 7 good good JJ opencontent-org-7427 121 8 written written JJ opencontent-org-7427 121 9 description description NN opencontent-org-7427 121 10 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 121 11 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 121 12 issues issue NNS opencontent-org-7427 121 13 within within IN opencontent-org-7427 121 14 such such PDT opencontent-org-7427 121 15 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 121 16 OER OER NNP opencontent-org-7427 121 17 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 121 18 . . . opencontent-org-7427 122 1 And and CC opencontent-org-7427 122 2 finding find VBG opencontent-org-7427 122 3 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 122 4 right right JJ opencontent-org-7427 122 5 balance balance NN opencontent-org-7427 122 6 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 122 7 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 122 8 educational educational JJ opencontent-org-7427 122 9 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 122 10 licensing licensing NN opencontent-org-7427 122 11 does do VBZ opencontent-org-7427 122 12 seem seem VB opencontent-org-7427 122 13 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 122 14 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 122 15 hard hard JJ opencontent-org-7427 122 16 . . . opencontent-org-7427 123 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 123 2 agree agree VBP opencontent-org-7427 123 3 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 123 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 123 5 statements statement NNS opencontent-org-7427 123 6 about about IN opencontent-org-7427 123 7 Remix Remix NNP opencontent-org-7427 123 8 vs. vs. IN opencontent-org-7427 123 9 Reuse Reuse NNP opencontent-org-7427 123 10 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 123 11 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 123 12 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 123 13 educator educator NN opencontent-org-7427 123 14 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 123 15 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 123 16 say say VB opencontent-org-7427 123 17 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 123 18 10:1 10:1 CD opencontent-org-7427 123 19 ratio ratio NN opencontent-org-7427 123 20 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 123 21 remix remix NN opencontent-org-7427 123 22 over over IN opencontent-org-7427 123 23 reuse reuse NN opencontent-org-7427 123 24 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 123 25 correct correct JJ opencontent-org-7427 123 26 . . . opencontent-org-7427 124 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 124 2 also also RB opencontent-org-7427 124 3 like like VBP opencontent-org-7427 124 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 124 5 comments comment NNS opencontent-org-7427 124 6 about about IN opencontent-org-7427 124 7 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 124 8 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 124 9 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 124 10 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 124 11 could could MD opencontent-org-7427 124 12 limit limit VB opencontent-org-7427 124 13 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 124 14 use use NN opencontent-org-7427 124 15 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 124 16 materials material NNS opencontent-org-7427 124 17 , , , opencontent-org-7427 124 18 particularly particularly RB opencontent-org-7427 124 19 cross cross VB opencontent-org-7427 124 20 - - JJ opencontent-org-7427 124 21 culturally culturally RB opencontent-org-7427 124 22 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 124 23 In in IN opencontent-org-7427 124 24 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 124 25 end end NN opencontent-org-7427 124 26 , , , opencontent-org-7427 124 27 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 124 28 like like VBP opencontent-org-7427 124 29 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 124 30 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 124 31 has have VBZ opencontent-org-7427 124 32 put put VBN opencontent-org-7427 124 33 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 124 34 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 124 35 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 124 36 table table NN opencontent-org-7427 124 37 . . . opencontent-org-7427 125 1 At at IN opencontent-org-7427 125 2 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 125 3 time time NN opencontent-org-7427 125 4 where where WRB opencontent-org-7427 125 5 ccLearn ccLearn NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 6 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 125 7 being be VBG opencontent-org-7427 125 8 developed develop VBN opencontent-org-7427 125 9 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 125 10 may may MD opencontent-org-7427 125 11 bring bring VB opencontent-org-7427 125 12 more more JJR opencontent-org-7427 125 13 views view NNS opencontent-org-7427 125 14 into into IN opencontent-org-7427 125 15 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 125 16 fold fold NN opencontent-org-7427 125 17 as as IN opencontent-org-7427 125 18 ccLearn ccLearn NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 19 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 125 20 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 125 21 others other NNS opencontent-org-7427 125 22 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 125 23 mature mature VBP opencontent-org-7427 125 24 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 125 25 Dr. Dr. NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 26 Klaus Klaus NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 27 Grafsays Grafsays NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 28 : : : opencontent-org-7427 125 29 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 30 11 11 CD opencontent-org-7427 125 31 , , , opencontent-org-7427 125 32 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 125 33 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 125 34 5:15 5:15 CD opencontent-org-7427 125 35 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 125 36 German german JJ opencontent-org-7427 125 37 declaration declaration NN opencontent-org-7427 125 38 according accord VBG opencontent-org-7427 125 39 § § NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 40 32 32 CD opencontent-org-7427 125 41 III iii CD opencontent-org-7427 125 42 German german JJ opencontent-org-7427 125 43 Copyright copyright NN opencontent-org-7427 125 44 Law Law NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 45 making make VBG opencontent-org-7427 125 46 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 125 47 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 125 48 nearly nearly RB opencontent-org-7427 125 49 Public Public NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 50 Domain domain NN opencontent-org-7427 125 51 : : : opencontent-org-7427 125 52 http://archiv.twoday.net/stories/4157270/ http://archiv.twoday.net/stories/4157270/ NN opencontent-org-7427 125 53 Steve Steve NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 54 Foerstersays Foerstersays NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 55 : : : opencontent-org-7427 125 56 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 125 57 12 12 CD opencontent-org-7427 125 58 , , , opencontent-org-7427 125 59 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 125 60 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 125 61 7:53 7:53 CD opencontent-org-7427 125 62 am be VBP opencontent-org-7427 125 63 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 125 64 should should MD opencontent-org-7427 125 65 add add VB opencontent-org-7427 125 66 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 125 67 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 125 68 had have VBD opencontent-org-7427 125 69 n’t not RB opencontent-org-7427 125 70 heard hear VBN opencontent-org-7427 125 71 that that DT opencontent-org-7427 125 72 insightful insightful JJ opencontent-org-7427 125 73 cross cross JJ opencontent-org-7427 125 74 - - JJ opencontent-org-7427 125 75 cultural cultural JJ opencontent-org-7427 125 76 argument argument NN opencontent-org-7427 125 77 against against IN opencontent-org-7427 125 78 requiring require VBG opencontent-org-7427 125 79 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 125 80 before before RB opencontent-org-7427 125 81 . . . opencontent-org-7427 126 1 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 126 2 had have VBD opencontent-org-7427 126 3 always always RB opencontent-org-7427 126 4 assumed assume VBN opencontent-org-7427 126 5 that that IN opencontent-org-7427 126 6 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 126 7 was be VBD opencontent-org-7427 126 8 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 126 9 harmless harmless JJ opencontent-org-7427 126 10 requirement requirement NN opencontent-org-7427 126 11 but but CC opencontent-org-7427 126 12 no no UH opencontent-org-7427 126 13 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 126 14 see see VBP opencontent-org-7427 126 15 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 126 16 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 126 17 could could MD opencontent-org-7427 126 18 be be VB opencontent-org-7427 126 19 otherwise otherwise RB opencontent-org-7427 126 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 127 1 Can Can MD opencontent-org-7427 127 2 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 127 3 personal personal JJ opencontent-org-7427 127 4 genome genome JJ opencontent-org-7427 127 5 sequence sequence NN opencontent-org-7427 127 6 get get VBP opencontent-org-7427 127 7 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 127 8 creative creative JJ opencontent-org-7427 127 9 commons common NNS opencontent-org-7427 127 10 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 127 11 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 128 1 : : : opencontent-org-7427 128 2 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 128 3 Personal Personal NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 4 Genomesays Genomesays NNPS opencontent-org-7427 128 5 : : : opencontent-org-7427 128 6 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 7 12 12 CD opencontent-org-7427 128 8 , , , opencontent-org-7427 128 9 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 128 10 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 128 11 10:09 10:09 CD opencontent-org-7427 128 12 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 128 13 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 128 14 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 128 15 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 128 16 more more JJR opencontent-org-7427 128 17 discussion discussion NN opencontent-org-7427 128 18 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 128 19 data datum NNS opencontent-org-7427 128 20 licenses license NNS opencontent-org-7427 128 21 , , , opencontent-org-7427 128 22 there there EX opencontent-org-7427 128 23 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 128 24 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 128 25 good good JJ opencontent-org-7427 128 26 discussion discussion NN opencontent-org-7427 128 27 happening happen VBG opencontent-org-7427 128 28 elsewhere elsewhere RB opencontent-org-7427 128 29 via via IN opencontent-org-7427 128 30 Deepak Deepak NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 31 Singh Singh NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 32 , , , opencontent-org-7427 128 33 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 34 Wiley Wiley NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 35 , , , opencontent-org-7427 128 36 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 128 37 Peter Peter NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 38 Murray Murray NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 39 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 128 40 Rust Rust NNP opencontent-org-7427 128 41 . . . opencontent-org-7427 129 1 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 2 13 13 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 3 , , , opencontent-org-7427 129 4 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 5 | | NN opencontent-org-7427 129 6 Filed file VBN opencontent-org-7427 129 7 Under under IN opencontent-org-7427 129 8 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 9 Access Access NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 10 , , , opencontent-org-7427 129 11 Privacy Privacy NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 12 , , , opencontent-org-7427 129 13 Genomic Genomic NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 14 Data Data NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 15 , , , opencontent-org-7427 129 16 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 129 17 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 129 18 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 129 19 Unilever Unilever NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 20 Centre Centre NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 21 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 129 22 Molecular Molecular NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 23 Informatics Informatics NNPS opencontent-org-7427 129 24 , , , opencontent-org-7427 129 25 Cambridge Cambridge NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 26 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 129 27 petermr petermr NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 28 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 129 29 blog blog NN opencontent-org-7427 129 30 » » `` opencontent-org-7427 129 31 Blog Blog NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 32 Archive Archive NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 33 » » '' opencontent-org-7427 129 34 What what WP opencontent-org-7427 129 35 do do VBP opencontent-org-7427 129 36 we -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 129 37 mean mean VB opencontent-org-7427 129 38 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 129 39 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 129 40 science?says science?say NNS opencontent-org-7427 129 41 : : : opencontent-org-7427 129 42 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 43 24 24 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 44 , , , opencontent-org-7427 129 45 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 46 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 129 47 2:52 2:52 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 48 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 129 49 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 129 50 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 129 51 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 129 52 Wiley Wiley NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 53 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 129 54 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 55 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 56 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 57 , , , opencontent-org-7427 129 58 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 129 59 attempt attempt NN opencontent-org-7427 129 60 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 129 61 put put VB opencontent-org-7427 129 62 legal legal JJ opencontent-org-7427 129 63 muscle muscle NN opencontent-org-7427 129 64 into into IN opencontent-org-7427 129 65 a a DT opencontent-org-7427 129 66 Public Public NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 67 Domain Domain NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 68 dedication dedication NN opencontent-org-7427 129 69 ; ; : opencontent-org-7427 129 70 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 129 71 linked link VBN opencontent-org-7427 129 72 post post NN opencontent-org-7427 129 73 contains contain VBZ opencontent-org-7427 129 74 an an DT opencontent-org-7427 129 75 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 129 76 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 129 77 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 129 78 Andrew Andrew NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 79 Renssays Renssays NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 80 : : : opencontent-org-7427 129 81 August August NNP opencontent-org-7427 129 82 19 19 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 83 , , , opencontent-org-7427 129 84 2008 2008 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 85 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 129 86 2:41 2:41 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 87 am be VBP opencontent-org-7427 129 88 Why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 129 89 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 129 90 wait wait VB opencontent-org-7427 129 91 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 129 92 see see VB opencontent-org-7427 129 93 how how WRB opencontent-org-7427 129 94 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 129 95 0 0 CD opencontent-org-7427 129 96 develops develop VBZ opencontent-org-7427 129 97 before before IN opencontent-org-7427 129 98 licence licence NN opencontent-org-7427 129 99 proliferation proliferation NN opencontent-org-7427 129 100 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 130 1 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 130 2 0 0 CD opencontent-org-7427 130 3 seems seem VBZ opencontent-org-7427 130 4 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 130 5 meet meet VB opencontent-org-7427 130 6 your -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 130 7 criteria criterion NNS opencontent-org-7427 130 8 . . . opencontent-org-7427 131 1 If if IN opencontent-org-7427 131 2 it -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 131 3 does do VBZ opencontent-org-7427 131 4 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 131 5 , , , opencontent-org-7427 131 6 then then RB opencontent-org-7427 131 7 why why WRB opencontent-org-7427 131 8 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 131 9 ? ? . opencontent-org-7427 132 1 Giorgos Giorgos NNP opencontent-org-7427 132 2 Cheliotissays Cheliotissays NNPS opencontent-org-7427 132 3 : : : opencontent-org-7427 132 4 October October NNP opencontent-org-7427 132 5 13 13 CD opencontent-org-7427 132 6 , , , opencontent-org-7427 132 7 2008 2008 CD opencontent-org-7427 132 8 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 132 9 8:27 8:27 CD opencontent-org-7427 132 10 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 132 11 Hi hi UH opencontent-org-7427 132 12 , , , opencontent-org-7427 132 13 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 132 14 saw see VBD opencontent-org-7427 132 15 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 132 16 quoted quote VBD opencontent-org-7427 132 17 one one CD opencontent-org-7427 132 18 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 132 19 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 132 20 old old JJ opencontent-org-7427 132 21 blog blog NN opencontent-org-7427 132 22 posts post NNS opencontent-org-7427 132 23 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 132 24 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 132 25 usage usage NN opencontent-org-7427 132 26 . . . opencontent-org-7427 133 1 It -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 133 2 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 133 3 very very RB opencontent-org-7427 133 4 outdated outdated JJ opencontent-org-7427 133 5 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 133 6 now now RB opencontent-org-7427 133 7 ! ! . opencontent-org-7427 134 1 Current current JJ opencontent-org-7427 134 2 estimates estimate NNS opencontent-org-7427 134 3 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 134 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 134 5 number number NN opencontent-org-7427 134 6 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 134 7 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 134 8 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 134 9 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 134 10 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 134 11 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 134 12 about about IN opencontent-org-7427 134 13 100 100 CD opencontent-org-7427 134 14 million million CD opencontent-org-7427 134 15 , , , opencontent-org-7427 134 16 not not RB opencontent-org-7427 134 17 40 40 CD opencontent-org-7427 134 18 . . . opencontent-org-7427 134 19 iterating iterate VBG opencontent-org-7427 134 20 toward toward IN opencontent-org-7427 134 21 openness openness NN opencontent-org-7427 134 22 » » '' opencontent-org-7427 134 23 Blog Blog NNP opencontent-org-7427 134 24 Archive Archive NNP opencontent-org-7427 134 25 » » '' opencontent-org-7427 134 26 Contra Contra NNP opencontent-org-7427 134 27 NC NC NNP opencontent-org-7427 134 28 - - HYPH opencontent-org-7427 134 29 Mostlysays Mostlysays NNP opencontent-org-7427 134 30 : : : opencontent-org-7427 134 31 April April NNP opencontent-org-7427 134 32 1 1 CD opencontent-org-7427 134 33 , , , opencontent-org-7427 134 34 2009 2009 CD opencontent-org-7427 134 35 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 134 36 3:37 3:37 CD opencontent-org-7427 134 37 pm pm NN opencontent-org-7427 134 38 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 134 39 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 134 40 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 134 41 I -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 134 42 began begin VBD opencontent-org-7427 134 43 developing develop VBG opencontent-org-7427 134 44 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 134 45 notion notion NN opencontent-org-7427 134 46 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 134 47 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 134 48 4Rs 4rs CD opencontent-org-7427 134 49 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 134 50 open open JJ opencontent-org-7427 134 51 content content NN opencontent-org-7427 134 52 . . . opencontent-org-7427 135 1 ( ( -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 135 2 These these DT opencontent-org-7427 135 3 were be VBD opencontent-org-7427 135 4 first first RB opencontent-org-7427 135 5 presented present VBN opencontent-org-7427 135 6 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 135 7 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 135 8 “ " `` opencontent-org-7427 135 9 Open Open NNP opencontent-org-7427 135 10 Education Education NNP opencontent-org-7427 135 11 License License NNP opencontent-org-7427 135 12 ” " '' opencontent-org-7427 135 13 draft draft NN opencontent-org-7427 135 14 back back RB opencontent-org-7427 135 15 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 135 16 2007 2007 CD opencontent-org-7427 135 17 . . . opencontent-org-7427 135 18 ) ) -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 136 1 The the DT opencontent-org-7427 136 2 4Rs 4rs CD opencontent-org-7427 136 3 include include VBP opencontent-org-7427 136 4 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 136 5 rights right NNS opencontent-org-7427 136 6 [ [ -LRB- opencontent-org-7427 136 7 … … NFP opencontent-org-7427 136 8 ] ] -RRB- opencontent-org-7427 136 9 Comments comment NNS opencontent-org-7427 136 10 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 136 11 closed closed JJ opencontent-org-7427 136 12 . . . opencontent-org-7427 137 1 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 137 2 blog blog NN opencontent-org-7427 137 3 is be VBZ opencontent-org-7427 137 4 written write VBN opencontent-org-7427 137 5 and and CC opencontent-org-7427 137 6 maintained maintain VBN opencontent-org-7427 137 7 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 137 8 David David NNP opencontent-org-7427 137 9 Wiley Wiley NNP opencontent-org-7427 137 10 . . . opencontent-org-7427 138 1 Opinions opinion NNS opencontent-org-7427 138 2 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 138 3 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 138 4 own own JJ opencontent-org-7427 138 5 . . . opencontent-org-7427 139 1 This this DT opencontent-org-7427 139 2 blog blog NN opencontent-org-7427 139 3 focuses focus VBZ opencontent-org-7427 139 4 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 139 5 issues issue NNS opencontent-org-7427 139 6 relating relate VBG opencontent-org-7427 139 7 to to IN opencontent-org-7427 139 8 openness openness NN opencontent-org-7427 139 9 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 139 10 education education NN opencontent-org-7427 139 11 . . . opencontent-org-7427 140 1 For for IN opencontent-org-7427 140 2 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 140 3 thoughts thought NNS opencontent-org-7427 140 4 on on IN opencontent-org-7427 140 5 improving improve VBG opencontent-org-7427 140 6 success success NN opencontent-org-7427 140 7 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 140 8 US US NNP opencontent-org-7427 140 9 postsecondary postsecondary JJ opencontent-org-7427 140 10 students student NNS opencontent-org-7427 140 11 , , , opencontent-org-7427 140 12 see see VB opencontent-org-7427 140 13 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 140 14 other other JJ opencontent-org-7427 140 15 blog blog NN opencontent-org-7427 140 16 improving improve VBG opencontent-org-7427 140 17 student student NN opencontent-org-7427 140 18 success success NN opencontent-org-7427 140 19 . . . opencontent-org-7427 141 1 Unless unless IN opencontent-org-7427 141 2 otherwise otherwise RB opencontent-org-7427 141 3 noted note VBN opencontent-org-7427 141 4 , , , opencontent-org-7427 141 5 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 141 6 contents content NNS opencontent-org-7427 141 7 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 141 8 this this DT opencontent-org-7427 141 9 site site NN opencontent-org-7427 141 10 are be VBP opencontent-org-7427 141 11 licensed license VBN opencontent-org-7427 141 12 under under IN opencontent-org-7427 141 13 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 141 14 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 141 15 Commons Commons NNP opencontent-org-7427 141 16 Attribution Attribution NNP opencontent-org-7427 141 17 4.0 4.0 CD opencontent-org-7427 141 18 International international JJ opencontent-org-7427 141 19 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 141 20 . . . opencontent-org-7427 142 1 Should Should MD opencontent-org-7427 142 2 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 142 3 choose choose VB opencontent-org-7427 142 4 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 142 5 exercise exercise VB opencontent-org-7427 142 6 any any DT opencontent-org-7427 142 7 of of IN opencontent-org-7427 142 8 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 142 9 5R 5r JJ opencontent-org-7427 142 10 permissions permission NNS opencontent-org-7427 142 11 granted grant VBD opencontent-org-7427 142 12 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 142 13 under under IN opencontent-org-7427 142 14 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 142 15 Creative Creative NNP opencontent-org-7427 142 16 Commons Commons NNP opencontent-org-7427 142 17 Attribution Attribution NNP opencontent-org-7427 142 18 4.0 4.0 CD opencontent-org-7427 142 19 license license NN opencontent-org-7427 142 20 , , , opencontent-org-7427 142 21 please please UH opencontent-org-7427 142 22 attribute attribute VB opencontent-org-7427 142 23 me -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 142 24 in in IN opencontent-org-7427 142 25 accordance accordance NN opencontent-org-7427 142 26 with with IN opencontent-org-7427 142 27 CC cc NN opencontent-org-7427 142 28 ’s ’s POS opencontent-org-7427 142 29 best good JJS opencontent-org-7427 142 30 practices practice NNS opencontent-org-7427 142 31 for for IN opencontent-org-7427 142 32 attribution attribution NN opencontent-org-7427 142 33 . . . opencontent-org-7427 143 1 If if IN opencontent-org-7427 143 2 you -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 143 3 would would MD opencontent-org-7427 143 4 like like VB opencontent-org-7427 143 5 to to TO opencontent-org-7427 143 6 attribute attribute VB opencontent-org-7427 143 7 me -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 143 8 differently differently RB opencontent-org-7427 143 9 or or CC opencontent-org-7427 143 10 use use VB opencontent-org-7427 143 11 my -PRON- PRP$ opencontent-org-7427 143 12 work work NN opencontent-org-7427 143 13 under under IN opencontent-org-7427 143 14 different different JJ opencontent-org-7427 143 15 terms term NNS opencontent-org-7427 143 16 , , , opencontent-org-7427 143 17 contact contact VB opencontent-org-7427 143 18 me -PRON- PRP opencontent-org-7427 143 19 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 143 20 david david NNP opencontent-org-7427 143 21   _SP opencontent-org-7427 143 22 dot dot NNP opencontent-org-7427 143 23 wiley wiley NNP opencontent-org-7427 143 24 at at IN opencontent-org-7427 143 25 gmail gmail NN opencontent-org-7427 143 26   _SP opencontent-org-7427 143 27 dot dot NN opencontent-org-7427 143 28 com com NN opencontent-org-7427 143 29 . . . opencontent-org-7427 144 1 © © LS opencontent-org-7427 144 2 2020 2020 CD opencontent-org-7427 144 3 iterating iterate VBG opencontent-org-7427 144 4 toward toward IN opencontent-org-7427 144 5 openness openness NN opencontent-org-7427 144 6 Powered power VBN opencontent-org-7427 144 7 by by IN opencontent-org-7427 144 8 WordPress WordPress NNP opencontent-org-7427 144 9 To to IN opencontent-org-7427 144 10 the the DT opencontent-org-7427 144 11 top top JJ opencontent-org-7427 144 12 ↑ ↑ NN opencontent-org-7427 144 13 Up up RP opencontent-org-7427 144 14 ↑ ↑ NN