id sid tid token lemma pos doi-org-9532 1 1 Project project NN doi-org-9532 1 2 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 1 3 - - : doi-org-9532 1 4 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 1 5 and and CC doi-org-9532 1 6 Its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 1 7 Discontents discontent NNS doi-org-9532 1 8 : : : doi-org-9532 1 9 An an DT doi-org-9532 1 10 Essay Essay NNP doi-org-9532 1 11 on on IN doi-org-9532 1 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 1 13 Ethics ethic NNS doi-org-9532 1 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 1 15 Librarianship Librarianship NNP doi-org-9532 1 16 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 1 17 Skip Skip NNP doi-org-9532 1 18 to to IN doi-org-9532 1 19 Content Content NNP doi-org-9532 1 20 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 1 21 Institutional Institutional NNP doi-org-9532 1 22 Login Login NNP doi-org-9532 1 23 LOG LOG NNP doi-org-9532 1 24 IN in IN doi-org-9532 1 25 browse browse NN doi-org-9532 1 26 or or CC doi-org-9532 1 27 Search search NN doi-org-9532 1 28 : : : doi-org-9532 1 29 menu menu NN doi-org-9532 1 30 Advanced Advanced NNP doi-org-9532 1 31 Search Search NNP doi-org-9532 1 32 Browse Browse NNP doi-org-9532 1 33 MyMUSE MyMUSE NNP doi-org-9532 1 34 Account Account NNP doi-org-9532 1 35 Log Log NNP doi-org-9532 1 36 In in IN doi-org-9532 1 37 / / SYM doi-org-9532 1 38 Sign sign VB doi-org-9532 1 39 Up up RP doi-org-9532 1 40 Change change NN doi-org-9532 1 41 My -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 1 42 Account account NN doi-org-9532 1 43 User User NNP doi-org-9532 1 44 Settings Settings NNP doi-org-9532 1 45 Access Access NNP doi-org-9532 1 46 via via IN doi-org-9532 1 47 Institution Institution NNP doi-org-9532 1 48 MyMUSE MyMUSE NNP doi-org-9532 1 49 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 1 50 Search Search NNP doi-org-9532 1 51 History history NN doi-org-9532 1 52 View view VBP doi-org-9532 1 53 History history NN doi-org-9532 1 54 Purchase purchase NN doi-org-9532 1 55 History history NN doi-org-9532 1 56 MyMUSE mymuse NN doi-org-9532 1 57 Alerts Alerts NNPS doi-org-9532 1 58 Contact Contact NNP doi-org-9532 1 59 Support support NN doi-org-9532 1 60 portal portal NN doi-org-9532 1 61 : : : doi-org-9532 1 62 Libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 1 63 and and CC doi-org-9532 1 64 the the DT doi-org-9532 1 65 Academy Academy NNP doi-org-9532 1 66 portal portal NN doi-org-9532 1 67 : : : doi-org-9532 1 68 Libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 1 69 and and CC doi-org-9532 1 70 the the DT doi-org-9532 1 71 Academy Academy NNP doi-org-9532 1 72 Volume Volume NNP doi-org-9532 1 73 19 19 CD doi-org-9532 1 74 , , , doi-org-9532 1 75 Number number NN doi-org-9532 1 76 1 1 CD doi-org-9532 1 77 , , , doi-org-9532 1 78 January January NNP doi-org-9532 1 79 2019 2019 CD doi-org-9532 1 80 Johns Johns NNP doi-org-9532 1 81 Hopkins Hopkins NNP doi-org-9532 1 82 University University NNP doi-org-9532 1 83 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 1 84 Article Article NNP doi-org-9532 1 85 View view VBP doi-org-9532 1 86 Download Download NNP doi-org-9532 1 87 Save Save NNP doi-org-9532 1 88 View View NNP doi-org-9532 1 89 Citation Citation NNP doi-org-9532 1 90 contents content VBZ doi-org-9532 1 91 Additional Additional NNP doi-org-9532 1 92 Information Information NNP doi-org-9532 1 93 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 1 94 and and CC doi-org-9532 1 95 Its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 1 96 Discontents discontent NNS doi-org-9532 1 97 : : : doi-org-9532 1 98 An an DT doi-org-9532 1 99 Essay Essay NNP doi-org-9532 1 100 on on IN doi-org-9532 1 101 the the DT doi-org-9532 1 102 Ethics Ethics NNP doi-org-9532 1 103 of of IN doi-org-9532 1 104 Librarianship Librarianship NNP doi-org-9532 1 105 John John NNP doi-org-9532 1 106 Wenzler Wenzler NNP doi-org-9532 1 107 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 1 108 bio bio NNP doi-org-9532 1 109 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 1 110 abstract abstract JJ doi-org-9532 1 111 This this DT doi-org-9532 1 112 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 1 113 analyzes analyze VBZ doi-org-9532 1 114 the the DT doi-org-9532 1 115 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 1 116 about about IN doi-org-9532 1 117 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 1 118 in in IN doi-org-9532 1 119 the the DT doi-org-9532 1 120 library library NN doi-org-9532 1 121 literature literature NN doi-org-9532 1 122 and and CC doi-org-9532 1 123 identifies identify VBZ doi-org-9532 1 124 a a DT doi-org-9532 1 125 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 1 126 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 1 127 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 1 128 that that WDT doi-org-9532 1 129 generates generate VBZ doi-org-9532 1 130 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 1 131 . . . doi-org-9532 2 1 It -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 2 2 then then RB doi-org-9532 2 3 advances advance VBZ doi-org-9532 2 4 an an DT doi-org-9532 2 5 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 2 6 in in IN doi-org-9532 2 7 favor favor NN doi-org-9532 2 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 2 9 library library JJ doi-org-9532 2 10 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 2 11 based base VBN doi-org-9532 2 12 on on IN doi-org-9532 2 13 Wayne Wayne NNP doi-org-9532 2 14 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 2 15 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 2 16 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 2 17 's 's POS doi-org-9532 2 18 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 2 19 history history NN doi-org-9532 2 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 2 21 library library JJ doi-org-9532 2 22 values value NNS doi-org-9532 2 23 in in IN doi-org-9532 2 24 Libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 2 25 and and CC doi-org-9532 2 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 2 27 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 2 28 and and CC doi-org-9532 2 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 2 30 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 2 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 2 32 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 2 33 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 2 34 developed develop VBN doi-org-9532 2 35 by by IN doi-org-9532 2 36 such such JJ doi-org-9532 2 37 political political JJ doi-org-9532 2 38 philosophers philosopher NNS doi-org-9532 2 39 as as IN doi-org-9532 2 40 Ronald Ronald NNP doi-org-9532 2 41 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 2 42 , , , doi-org-9532 2 43 John John NNP doi-org-9532 2 44 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 2 45 , , , doi-org-9532 2 46 and and CC doi-org-9532 2 47 Martha Martha NNP doi-org-9532 2 48 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 2 49 . . . doi-org-9532 3 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 3 2 conclusion conclusion NN doi-org-9532 3 3 , , , doi-org-9532 3 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 3 5 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 3 6 responds respond VBZ doi-org-9532 3 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 3 8 potential potential JJ doi-org-9532 3 9 objections objection NNS doi-org-9532 3 10 to to IN doi-org-9532 3 11 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 3 12 pro pro JJ doi-org-9532 3 13 - - JJ doi-org-9532 3 14 neutrality neutrality JJ doi-org-9532 3 15 thesis thesis NN doi-org-9532 3 16 by by IN doi-org-9532 3 17 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 3 18 and and CC doi-org-9532 3 19 radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 3 20 authors author NNS doi-org-9532 3 21 . . . doi-org-9532 4 1 Questioning question VBG doi-org-9532 4 2 Library library NN doi-org-9532 4 3 Neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 4 4 The the DT doi-org-9532 4 5 ordinary ordinary JJ doi-org-9532 4 6 individual individual NN doi-org-9532 4 7 , , , doi-org-9532 4 8 by by IN doi-org-9532 4 9 exercising exercise VBG doi-org-9532 4 10 critical critical JJ doi-org-9532 4 11 judgment judgment NN doi-org-9532 4 12 , , , doi-org-9532 4 13 will will MD doi-org-9532 4 14 select select VB doi-org-9532 4 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 4 16 good good JJ doi-org-9532 4 17 and and CC doi-org-9532 4 18 reject reject VB doi-org-9532 4 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 4 20 bad bad JJ doi-org-9532 4 21 . . . doi-org-9532 5 1 We -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 5 2 trust trust VBP doi-org-9532 5 3 Americans Americans NNPS doi-org-9532 5 4 to to TO doi-org-9532 5 5 recognize recognize VB doi-org-9532 5 6 propaganda propaganda NN doi-org-9532 5 7 and and CC doi-org-9532 5 8 misinformation misinformation NN doi-org-9532 5 9 , , , doi-org-9532 5 10 and and CC doi-org-9532 5 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 5 12 make make VB doi-org-9532 5 13 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 5 14 own own JJ doi-org-9532 5 15 decisions decision NNS doi-org-9532 5 16 about about IN doi-org-9532 5 17 what what WP doi-org-9532 5 18 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 5 19 read read VBP doi-org-9532 5 20 and and CC doi-org-9532 5 21 believe.1 believe.1 NNP doi-org-9532 5 22 American American NNP doi-org-9532 5 23 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 5 24 Association Association NNP doi-org-9532 5 25 In in IN doi-org-9532 5 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 5 27 last last JJ doi-org-9532 5 28 10 10 CD doi-org-9532 5 29 years year NNS doi-org-9532 5 30 or or CC doi-org-9532 5 31 so so RB doi-org-9532 5 32 , , , doi-org-9532 5 33 and and CC doi-org-9532 5 34 especially especially RB doi-org-9532 5 35 since since IN doi-org-9532 5 36 the the DT doi-org-9532 5 37 election election NN doi-org-9532 5 38 of of IN doi-org-9532 5 39 President President NNP doi-org-9532 5 40 Donald Donald NNP doi-org-9532 5 41 Trump Trump NNP doi-org-9532 5 42 in in IN doi-org-9532 5 43 2016 2016 CD doi-org-9532 5 44 , , , doi-org-9532 5 45 " " `` doi-org-9532 5 46 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 5 47 " " '' doi-org-9532 5 48 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 5 49 become become VBN doi-org-9532 5 50 a a DT doi-org-9532 5 51 dirty dirty JJ doi-org-9532 5 52 word word NN doi-org-9532 5 53 for for IN doi-org-9532 5 54 many many JJ doi-org-9532 5 55 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 5 56 committed commit VBN doi-org-9532 5 57 to to IN doi-org-9532 5 58 social social JJ doi-org-9532 5 59 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 5 60 . . . doi-org-9532 6 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 6 2 2008 2008 CD doi-org-9532 6 3 , , , doi-org-9532 6 4 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 6 5 Juice Juice NNP doi-org-9532 6 6 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 6 7 published publish VBD doi-org-9532 6 8 Questioning Questioning NNP doi-org-9532 6 9 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 6 10 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 6 11 , , , doi-org-9532 6 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 6 13 collection collection NN doi-org-9532 6 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 6 15 articles article NNS doi-org-9532 6 16 from from IN doi-org-9532 6 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 6 18 Progressive Progressive NNP doi-org-9532 6 19 Librarian Librarian NNP doi-org-9532 6 20 that that WDT doi-org-9532 6 21 critiqued critique VBD doi-org-9532 6 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 6 23 idea idea NN doi-org-9532 6 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 6 25 library library JJ doi-org-9532 6 26 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 6 27 from from IN doi-org-9532 6 28 various various JJ doi-org-9532 6 29 perspectives.2 perspectives.2 NNP doi-org-9532 6 30 Since since IN doi-org-9532 6 31 then then RB doi-org-9532 6 32 , , , doi-org-9532 6 33 articles article NNS doi-org-9532 6 34 and and CC doi-org-9532 6 35 presentations presentation NNS doi-org-9532 6 36 rejecting reject VBG doi-org-9532 6 37 the the DT doi-org-9532 6 38 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 6 39 End end NN doi-org-9532 6 40 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 6 41 55 55 CD doi-org-9532 6 42 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 6 43 concept concept NN doi-org-9532 6 44 of of IN doi-org-9532 6 45 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 6 46 as as IN doi-org-9532 6 47 a a DT doi-org-9532 6 48 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 6 49 flaw flaw NN doi-org-9532 6 50 in in IN doi-org-9532 6 51 the the DT doi-org-9532 6 52 traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 6 53 ethos ethos NN doi-org-9532 6 54 of of IN doi-org-9532 6 55 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 6 56 have have VBP doi-org-9532 6 57 become become VBN doi-org-9532 6 58 increasingly increasingly RB doi-org-9532 6 59 common common JJ doi-org-9532 6 60 in in IN doi-org-9532 6 61 the the DT doi-org-9532 6 62 mainstream mainstream JJ doi-org-9532 6 63 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 6 64 of of IN doi-org-9532 6 65 the the DT doi-org-9532 6 66 profession profession NN doi-org-9532 6 67 . . . doi-org-9532 7 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 7 2 few few JJ doi-org-9532 7 3 examples example NNS doi-org-9532 7 4 illustrate illustrate VBP doi-org-9532 7 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 7 6 trend trend NN doi-org-9532 7 7 : : : doi-org-9532 7 8 • • VB doi-org-9532 7 9 The the DT doi-org-9532 7 10 American American NNP doi-org-9532 7 11 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 7 12 Association Association NNP doi-org-9532 7 13 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 7 14 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 7 15 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 7 16 Annual Annual NNP doi-org-9532 7 17 Conference Conference NNP doi-org-9532 7 18 in in IN doi-org-9532 7 19 2015 2015 CD doi-org-9532 7 20 included include VBD doi-org-9532 7 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 7 22 presentation presentation NN doi-org-9532 7 23 " " `` doi-org-9532 7 24 ' ' `` doi-org-9532 7 25 But but CC doi-org-9532 7 26 We -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 7 27 're be VBP doi-org-9532 7 28 Neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 7 29 ! ! . doi-org-9532 7 30 ' ' '' doi-org-9532 8 1 and and CC doi-org-9532 8 2 Other other JJ doi-org-9532 8 3 Librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 8 4 Fictions fiction NNS doi-org-9532 8 5 Confronted confront VBN doi-org-9532 8 6 by by IN doi-org-9532 8 7 # # , doi-org-9532 8 8 critlib critlib NNS doi-org-9532 8 9 . . . doi-org-9532 9 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 9 2 3 3 CD doi-org-9532 9 3 • • NN doi-org-9532 9 4 In in IN doi-org-9532 9 5 2017 2017 CD doi-org-9532 9 6 , , , doi-org-9532 9 7 American American NNP doi-org-9532 9 8 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 9 9 published publish VBD doi-org-9532 9 10 an an DT doi-org-9532 9 11 editorial editorial NN doi-org-9532 9 12 titled title VBN doi-org-9532 9 13 " " `` doi-org-9532 9 14 Never Never NNP doi-org-9532 9 15 Neutral Neutral NNP doi-org-9532 9 16 : : : doi-org-9532 9 17 Critical critical JJ doi-org-9532 9 18 Librarianship Librarianship NNP doi-org-9532 9 19 and and CC doi-org-9532 9 20 Technology Technology NNP doi-org-9532 9 21 . . . doi-org-9532 10 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 10 2 4 4 CD doi-org-9532 10 3 • • NNPS doi-org-9532 10 4 In in IN doi-org-9532 10 5 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 10 6 , , , doi-org-9532 10 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 10 8 president president NN doi-org-9532 10 9 's 's POS doi-org-9532 10 10 program program NN doi-org-9532 10 11 at at IN doi-org-9532 10 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 10 13 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 10 14 Midwinter Midwinter NNP doi-org-9532 10 15 Meeting Meeting NNP doi-org-9532 10 16 asked ask VBD doi-org-9532 10 17 : : : doi-org-9532 10 18 " " `` doi-org-9532 10 19 Are be VBP doi-org-9532 10 20 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 10 21 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 10 22 ? ? . doi-org-9532 11 1 Have have VBP doi-org-9532 11 2 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 11 3 ever ever RB doi-org-9532 11 4 been be VBN doi-org-9532 11 5 ? ? . doi-org-9532 12 1 Should Should MD doi-org-9532 12 2 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 12 3 be be VB doi-org-9532 12 4 ? ? . doi-org-9532 13 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 13 2 5 5 CD doi-org-9532 13 3 The the DT doi-org-9532 13 4 critique critique NN doi-org-9532 13 5 of of IN doi-org-9532 13 6 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 13 7 includes include VBZ doi-org-9532 13 8 three three CD doi-org-9532 13 9 strands strand NNS doi-org-9532 13 10 . . . doi-org-9532 14 1 First first RB doi-org-9532 14 2 , , , doi-org-9532 14 3 critics critic NNS doi-org-9532 14 4 argue argue VBP doi-org-9532 14 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 14 6 maintaining maintain VBG doi-org-9532 14 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 14 8 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 14 9 stance stance NN doi-org-9532 14 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 14 11 impartiality impartiality NN doi-org-9532 14 12 undermines undermine VBZ doi-org-9532 14 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 14 14 ability ability NN doi-org-9532 14 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 14 16 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 14 17 to to TO doi-org-9532 14 18 advocate advocate VB doi-org-9532 14 19 for for IN doi-org-9532 14 20 social social JJ doi-org-9532 14 21 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 14 22 through through IN doi-org-9532 14 23 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 14 24 work work NN doi-org-9532 14 25 . . . doi-org-9532 15 1 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 15 2 encourages encourage VBZ doi-org-9532 15 3 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 15 4 cowardliness cowardliness NN doi-org-9532 15 5 — — : doi-org-9532 15 6 conscious conscious JJ doi-org-9532 15 7 or or CC doi-org-9532 15 8 not not RB doi-org-9532 15 9 — — : doi-org-9532 15 10 by by IN doi-org-9532 15 11 allowing allow VBG doi-org-9532 15 12 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 15 13 to to TO doi-org-9532 15 14 hide hide VB doi-org-9532 15 15 behind behind IN doi-org-9532 15 16 false false JJ doi-org-9532 15 17 claims claim NNS doi-org-9532 15 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 15 19 evenhandedness evenhandedness NN doi-org-9532 15 20 as as IN doi-org-9532 15 21 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 15 22 capitulate capitulate VBP doi-org-9532 15 23 to to IN doi-org-9532 15 24 an an DT doi-org-9532 15 25 unjust unjust JJ doi-org-9532 15 26 status status NN doi-org-9532 15 27 quo quo FW doi-org-9532 15 28 . . . doi-org-9532 16 1 South south JJ doi-org-9532 16 2 African african JJ doi-org-9532 16 3 Archbishop Archbishop NNP doi-org-9532 16 4 Desmond Desmond NNP doi-org-9532 16 5 Tutu Tutu NNP doi-org-9532 16 6 summarized summarize VBD doi-org-9532 16 7 this this DT doi-org-9532 16 8 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 16 9 when when WRB doi-org-9532 16 10 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 16 11 observed observe VBD doi-org-9532 16 12 : : : doi-org-9532 16 13 " " `` doi-org-9532 16 14 If if IN doi-org-9532 16 15 you -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 16 16 are be VBP doi-org-9532 16 17 in in IN doi-org-9532 16 18 a a DT doi-org-9532 16 19 situation situation NN doi-org-9532 16 20 where where WRB doi-org-9532 16 21 an an DT doi-org-9532 16 22 elephant elephant NN doi-org-9532 16 23 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 16 24 sitting sit VBG doi-org-9532 16 25 on on IN doi-org-9532 16 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 16 27 tail tail NN doi-org-9532 16 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 16 29 a a DT doi-org-9532 16 30 mouse mouse NN doi-org-9532 16 31 and and CC doi-org-9532 16 32 you -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 16 33 say say VBP doi-org-9532 16 34 , , , doi-org-9532 16 35 ' ' '' doi-org-9532 16 36 Oh oh UH doi-org-9532 16 37 no no UH doi-org-9532 16 38 , , , doi-org-9532 16 39 no no UH doi-org-9532 16 40 , , , doi-org-9532 16 41 no no UH doi-org-9532 16 42 , , , doi-org-9532 16 43 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 16 44 am be VBP doi-org-9532 16 45 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 16 46 , , , doi-org-9532 16 47 ' ' '' doi-org-9532 16 48 the the DT doi-org-9532 16 49 mouse mouse NN doi-org-9532 16 50 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 16 51 not not RB doi-org-9532 16 52 going go VBG doi-org-9532 16 53 to to TO doi-org-9532 16 54 appreciate appreciate VB doi-org-9532 16 55 your -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 16 56 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 16 57 . . . doi-org-9532 17 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 17 2 6 6 CD doi-org-9532 17 3 For for IN doi-org-9532 17 4 critics critic NNS doi-org-9532 17 5 , , , doi-org-9532 17 6 library library JJ doi-org-9532 17 7 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 17 8 means mean VBZ doi-org-9532 17 9 supporting support VBG doi-org-9532 17 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 17 11 strong strong JJ doi-org-9532 17 12 against against IN doi-org-9532 17 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 17 14 weak weak JJ doi-org-9532 17 15 , , , doi-org-9532 17 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 17 17 oppressors oppressor NNS doi-org-9532 17 18 against against IN doi-org-9532 17 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 17 20 oppressed oppressed JJ doi-org-9532 17 21 , , , doi-org-9532 17 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 17 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 17 24 majority majority NN doi-org-9532 17 25 against against IN doi-org-9532 17 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 17 27 marginalized marginalize VBN doi-org-9532 17 28 . . . doi-org-9532 18 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 18 2 second second JJ doi-org-9532 18 3 strand strand NN doi-org-9532 18 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 18 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 18 6 critique critique NN doi-org-9532 18 7 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 18 8 that that IN doi-org-9532 18 9 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 18 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 18 11 a a DT doi-org-9532 18 12 myth myth NN doi-org-9532 18 13 . . . doi-org-9532 19 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 19 2 Social Social NNP doi-org-9532 19 3 Justice Justice NNP doi-org-9532 19 4 and and CC doi-org-9532 19 5 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 19 6 Work Work NNP doi-org-9532 19 7 , , , doi-org-9532 19 8 Stephen Stephen NNP doi-org-9532 19 9 Bales Bales NNP doi-org-9532 19 10 asserts assert VBZ doi-org-9532 19 11 that that IN doi-org-9532 19 12 " " `` doi-org-9532 19 13 library library JJ doi-org-9532 19 14 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 19 15 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 19 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 19 17 myth myth NN doi-org-9532 19 18 hiding hide VBG doi-org-9532 19 19 a a DT doi-org-9532 19 20 bias bias NN doi-org-9532 19 21 … … NFP doi-org-9532 19 22 all all DT doi-org-9532 19 23 positions position NNS doi-org-9532 19 24 are be VBP doi-org-9532 19 25 political political JJ doi-org-9532 19 26 positions position NNS doi-org-9532 19 27 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 19 28 some some DT doi-org-9532 19 29 practitioners practitioner NNS doi-org-9532 19 30 are be VBP doi-org-9532 19 31 just just RB doi-org-9532 19 32 more more RBR doi-org-9532 19 33 honest honest JJ doi-org-9532 19 34 in in IN doi-org-9532 19 35 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 19 36 admission admission NN doi-org-9532 19 37 of of IN doi-org-9532 19 38 this this DT doi-org-9532 19 39 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 19 40 . . . doi-org-9532 20 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 20 2 7 7 CD doi-org-9532 20 3 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 20 4 to to IN doi-org-9532 20 5 this this DT doi-org-9532 20 6 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 20 7 , , , doi-org-9532 20 8 those those DT doi-org-9532 20 9 who who WP doi-org-9532 20 10 assert assert VBP doi-org-9532 20 11 that that IN doi-org-9532 20 12 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 20 13 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 20 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 20 15 be be VB doi-org-9532 20 16 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 20 17 ignore ignore NN doi-org-9532 20 18 deeper deep JJR doi-org-9532 20 19 structural structural JJ doi-org-9532 20 20 forces force NNS doi-org-9532 20 21 that that WDT doi-org-9532 20 22 shape shape VBP doi-org-9532 20 23 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 20 24 social social JJ doi-org-9532 20 25 world world NN doi-org-9532 20 26 . . . doi-org-9532 21 1 False false JJ doi-org-9532 21 2 claims claim NNS doi-org-9532 21 3 of of IN doi-org-9532 21 4 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 21 5 legitimize legitimize VBP doi-org-9532 21 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 21 7 prerogatives prerogative NNS doi-org-9532 21 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 21 9 privileged privileged JJ doi-org-9532 21 10 social social JJ doi-org-9532 21 11 groups group NNS doi-org-9532 21 12 by by IN doi-org-9532 21 13 making make VBG doi-org-9532 21 14 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 21 15 advantages advantage NNS doi-org-9532 21 16 appear appear VBP doi-org-9532 21 17 natural natural JJ doi-org-9532 21 18 and and CC doi-org-9532 21 19 inevitable inevitable JJ doi-org-9532 21 20 . . . doi-org-9532 22 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 22 2 concept concept NN doi-org-9532 22 3 of of IN doi-org-9532 22 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 22 5 white white JJ doi-org-9532 22 6 privilege privilege NN doi-org-9532 22 7 " " '' doi-org-9532 22 8 illustrates illustrate VBZ doi-org-9532 22 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 22 10 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 22 11 . . . doi-org-9532 23 1 It -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 23 2 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 23 3 hard hard JJ doi-org-9532 23 4 for for IN doi-org-9532 23 5 white white JJ doi-org-9532 23 6 people people NNS doi-org-9532 23 7 to to TO doi-org-9532 23 8 acknowledge acknowledge VB doi-org-9532 23 9 that that IN doi-org-9532 23 10 biased biased JJ doi-org-9532 23 11 social social JJ doi-org-9532 23 12 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 23 13 tend tend VBP doi-org-9532 23 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 23 15 give give VB doi-org-9532 23 16 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 23 17 more more JJR doi-org-9532 23 18 wealth wealth NN doi-org-9532 23 19 and and CC doi-org-9532 23 20 power power NN doi-org-9532 23 21 because because IN doi-org-9532 23 22 such such PDT doi-org-9532 23 23 an an DT doi-org-9532 23 24 admission admission NN doi-org-9532 23 25 undermines undermine VBZ doi-org-9532 23 26 meritocratic meritocratic JJ doi-org-9532 23 27 justifications justification NNS doi-org-9532 23 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 23 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 23 30 existing exist VBG doi-org-9532 23 31 distribution distribution NN doi-org-9532 23 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 23 33 social social JJ doi-org-9532 23 34 advantage advantage NN doi-org-9532 23 35 based base VBN doi-org-9532 23 36 on on IN doi-org-9532 23 37 the the DT doi-org-9532 23 38 assumption assumption NN doi-org-9532 23 39 that that IN doi-org-9532 23 40 people people NNS doi-org-9532 23 41 basically basically RB doi-org-9532 23 42 get get VBP doi-org-9532 23 43 what what WP doi-org-9532 23 44 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 23 45 deserve deserve VBP doi-org-9532 23 46 through through IN doi-org-9532 23 47 hard hard JJ doi-org-9532 23 48 work.8 work.8 . doi-org-9532 23 49 For for IN doi-org-9532 23 50 critics critic NNS doi-org-9532 23 51 , , , doi-org-9532 23 52 anyone anyone NN doi-org-9532 23 53 who who WP doi-org-9532 23 54 believes believe VBZ doi-org-9532 23 55 in in IN doi-org-9532 23 56 the the DT doi-org-9532 23 57 myth myth NN doi-org-9532 23 58 of of IN doi-org-9532 23 59 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 23 60 fails fail VBZ doi-org-9532 23 61 to to TO doi-org-9532 23 62 see see VB doi-org-9532 23 63 how how WRB doi-org-9532 23 64 current current JJ doi-org-9532 23 65 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 23 66 might may MD doi-org-9532 23 67 be be VB doi-org-9532 23 68 changed change VBN doi-org-9532 23 69 to to TO doi-org-9532 23 70 improve improve VB doi-org-9532 23 71 social social JJ doi-org-9532 23 72 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 23 73 . . . doi-org-9532 24 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 24 2 third third JJ doi-org-9532 24 3 strand strand NN doi-org-9532 24 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 24 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 24 6 critique critique NN doi-org-9532 24 7 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 24 8 that that IN doi-org-9532 24 9 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 24 10 diminishes diminish VBZ doi-org-9532 24 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 24 12 importance importance NN doi-org-9532 24 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 24 14 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 24 15 by by IN doi-org-9532 24 16 reducing reduce VBG doi-org-9532 24 17 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 24 18 to to IN doi-org-9532 24 19 mere mere JJ doi-org-9532 24 20 technicians technician NNS doi-org-9532 24 21 . . . doi-org-9532 25 1 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 25 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 25 3 librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 25 4 Joseph Joseph NNP doi-org-9532 25 5 Good Good NNP doi-org-9532 25 6 : : : doi-org-9532 25 7 Neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 25 8 responses response NNS doi-org-9532 25 9 to to IN doi-org-9532 25 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 25 11 vital vital JJ doi-org-9532 25 12 issues issue NNS doi-org-9532 25 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 25 14 gay gay JJ doi-org-9532 25 15 marriage marriage NN doi-org-9532 25 16 , , , doi-org-9532 25 17 African african JJ doi-org-9532 25 18 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 25 19 American american JJ doi-org-9532 25 20 reparations reparation NNS doi-org-9532 25 21 , , , doi-org-9532 25 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 25 23 affirmative affirmative JJ doi-org-9532 25 24 action action NN doi-org-9532 25 25 continually continually RB doi-org-9532 25 26 jeopardize jeopardize VBP doi-org-9532 25 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 25 28 library library NN doi-org-9532 25 29 's 's POS doi-org-9532 25 30 relevance relevance NN doi-org-9532 25 31 in in IN doi-org-9532 25 32 contemporary contemporary JJ doi-org-9532 25 33 society society NN doi-org-9532 25 34 . . . doi-org-9532 26 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 26 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 26 3 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 26 4 can can MD doi-org-9532 26 5 not not RB doi-org-9532 26 6 be be VB doi-org-9532 26 7 motivated motivate VBN doi-org-9532 26 8 to to TO doi-org-9532 26 9 take take VB doi-org-9532 26 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 26 11 stand stand NN doi-org-9532 26 12 on on IN doi-org-9532 26 13 pressing press VBG doi-org-9532 26 14 social social JJ doi-org-9532 26 15 issues issue NNS doi-org-9532 26 16 out out IN doi-org-9532 26 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 26 18 a a DT doi-org-9532 26 19 sense sense NN doi-org-9532 26 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 26 21 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 26 22 duty duty NN doi-org-9532 26 23 , , , doi-org-9532 26 24 certainly certainly RB doi-org-9532 26 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 26 26 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 26 27 should should MD doi-org-9532 26 28 break break VB doi-org-9532 26 29 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 26 30 or or CC doi-org-9532 26 31 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 26 32 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 26 33 in in IN doi-org-9532 26 34 the the DT doi-org-9532 26 35 name name NN doi-org-9532 26 36 of of IN doi-org-9532 26 37 self self NN doi-org-9532 26 38 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 26 39 interest.9 interest.9 NNS doi-org-9532 26 40 If if IN doi-org-9532 26 41 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 26 42 merely merely RB doi-org-9532 26 43 process process VBP doi-org-9532 26 44 , , , doi-org-9532 26 45 manage manage VBP doi-org-9532 26 46 , , , doi-org-9532 26 47 and and CC doi-org-9532 26 48 distribute distribute VB doi-org-9532 26 49 information information NN doi-org-9532 26 50 without without IN doi-org-9532 26 51 evaluating evaluate VBG doi-org-9532 26 52 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 26 53 , , , doi-org-9532 26 54 Good good JJ doi-org-9532 26 55 believes believe VBZ doi-org-9532 26 56 that that IN doi-org-9532 26 57 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 26 58 have have VBP doi-org-9532 26 59 minimal minimal JJ doi-org-9532 26 60 social social JJ doi-org-9532 26 61 importance importance NN doi-org-9532 26 62 . . . doi-org-9532 27 1 Good Good NNP doi-org-9532 27 2 's 's POS doi-org-9532 27 3 anxiety anxiety NN doi-org-9532 27 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 27 5 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 27 6 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 27 7 End end NN doi-org-9532 27 8 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 27 9 56 56 CD doi-org-9532 27 10 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 27 11 neuters neuter NNS doi-org-9532 27 12 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 27 13 resonates resonate VBZ doi-org-9532 27 14 with with IN doi-org-9532 27 15 broader broad JJR doi-org-9532 27 16 anxieties anxiety NNS doi-org-9532 27 17 about about IN doi-org-9532 27 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 27 19 value value NN doi-org-9532 27 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 27 21 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 27 22 in in IN doi-org-9532 27 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 27 24 digital digital JJ doi-org-9532 27 25 age age NN doi-org-9532 27 26 . . . doi-org-9532 28 1 At at IN doi-org-9532 28 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 28 3 time time NN doi-org-9532 28 4 when when WRB doi-org-9532 28 5 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 28 6 wonder wonder VBP doi-org-9532 28 7 if if IN doi-org-9532 28 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 28 9 Internet internet NN doi-org-9532 28 10 will will MD doi-org-9532 28 11 render render VB doi-org-9532 28 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 28 13 profession profession NN doi-org-9532 28 14 superfluous superfluous JJ doi-org-9532 28 15 , , , doi-org-9532 28 16 machines machine NNS doi-org-9532 28 17 seem seem VBP doi-org-9532 28 18 more more RBR doi-org-9532 28 19 likely likely JJ doi-org-9532 28 20 to to TO doi-org-9532 28 21 replace replace VB doi-org-9532 28 22 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 28 23 who who WP doi-org-9532 28 24 simply simply RB doi-org-9532 28 25 process process VBP doi-org-9532 28 26 data datum NNS doi-org-9532 28 27 than than IN doi-org-9532 28 28 those those DT doi-org-9532 28 29 who who WP doi-org-9532 28 30 are be VBP doi-org-9532 28 31 politically politically RB doi-org-9532 28 32 engaged engaged JJ doi-org-9532 28 33 . . . doi-org-9532 29 1 Defending defend VBG doi-org-9532 29 2 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 29 3 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 29 4 Somewhat somewhat RB doi-org-9532 29 5 surprisingly surprisingly RB doi-org-9532 29 6 , , , doi-org-9532 29 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 29 8 critique critique NN doi-org-9532 29 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 29 10 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 29 11 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 29 12 encountered encounter VBN doi-org-9532 29 13 little little JJ doi-org-9532 29 14 resistance resistance NN doi-org-9532 29 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 29 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 29 17 literature literature NN doi-org-9532 29 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 29 19 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 29 20 so so RB doi-org-9532 29 21 far far RB doi-org-9532 29 22 . . . doi-org-9532 30 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 30 2 2014 2014 CD doi-org-9532 30 3 , , , doi-org-9532 30 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 30 5 library library NN doi-org-9532 30 6 director director NN doi-org-9532 30 7 blogging blogge VBG doi-org-9532 30 8 about about IN doi-org-9532 30 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 30 10 " " `` doi-org-9532 30 11 Myth Myth NNP doi-org-9532 30 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 30 13 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 30 14 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 30 15 " " '' doi-org-9532 30 16 observed observe VBD doi-org-9532 30 17 : : : doi-org-9532 30 18 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 30 19 recently recently RB doi-org-9532 30 20 attempted attempt VBD doi-org-9532 30 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 30 22 find find VB doi-org-9532 30 23 information information NN doi-org-9532 30 24 supporting support VBG doi-org-9532 30 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 30 26 idea idea NN doi-org-9532 30 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 30 28 library library JJ doi-org-9532 30 29 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 30 30 , , , doi-org-9532 30 31 but but CC doi-org-9532 30 32 had have VBD doi-org-9532 30 33 a a DT doi-org-9532 30 34 hard hard JJ doi-org-9532 30 35 time time NN doi-org-9532 30 36 finding find VBG doi-org-9532 30 37 anything anything NN doi-org-9532 30 38 other other JJ doi-org-9532 30 39 than than IN doi-org-9532 30 40 opinion opinion NN doi-org-9532 30 41 pieces piece NNS doi-org-9532 30 42 by by IN doi-org-9532 30 43 those those DT doi-org-9532 30 44 questioning question VBG doi-org-9532 30 45 the the DT doi-org-9532 30 46 concept concept NN doi-org-9532 30 47 . . . doi-org-9532 31 1 It -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 31 2 looks look VBZ doi-org-9532 31 3 like like IN doi-org-9532 31 4 what what WP doi-org-9532 31 5 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 31 6 have have VBP doi-org-9532 31 7 ended end VBN doi-org-9532 31 8 up up RP doi-org-9532 31 9 with with IN doi-org-9532 31 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 31 11 outdated outdate VBN doi-org-9532 31 12 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 31 13 that that WDT doi-org-9532 31 14 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 31 15 not not RB doi-org-9532 31 16 reflect reflect VB doi-org-9532 31 17 what what WP doi-org-9532 31 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 31 19 library library NN doi-org-9532 31 20 profession profession NN doi-org-9532 31 21 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 31 22 doing do VBG doi-org-9532 31 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 31 24 how how WRB doi-org-9532 31 25 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 31 26 actually actually RB doi-org-9532 31 27 feel feel VBP doi-org-9532 31 28 about about IN doi-org-9532 31 29 it.10 it.10 NNP doi-org-9532 31 30 In in IN doi-org-9532 31 31 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 31 32 2015 2015 CD doi-org-9532 31 33 book book NN doi-org-9532 31 34 , , , doi-org-9532 31 35 The the DT doi-org-9532 31 36 Dialectic Dialectic NNP doi-org-9532 31 37 of of IN doi-org-9532 31 38 Academic Academic NNP doi-org-9532 31 39 Librarianship Librarianship NNP doi-org-9532 31 40 , , , doi-org-9532 31 41 Stephen Stephen NNP doi-org-9532 31 42 Bales Bales NNP doi-org-9532 31 43 points point VBZ doi-org-9532 31 44 to to IN doi-org-9532 31 45 what what WP doi-org-9532 31 46 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 31 47 sees see VBZ doi-org-9532 31 48 as as IN doi-org-9532 31 49 a a DT doi-org-9532 31 50 dearth dearth NN doi-org-9532 31 51 of of IN doi-org-9532 31 52 recent recent JJ doi-org-9532 31 53 scholarly scholarly JJ doi-org-9532 31 54 publications publication NNS doi-org-9532 31 55 in in IN doi-org-9532 31 56 favor favor NN doi-org-9532 31 57 of of IN doi-org-9532 31 58 nonpartisan nonpartisan JJ doi-org-9532 31 59 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 31 60 . . . doi-org-9532 32 1 Other other JJ doi-org-9532 32 2 than than IN doi-org-9532 32 3 opinion opinion NN doi-org-9532 32 4 pieces piece NNS doi-org-9532 32 5 and and CC doi-org-9532 32 6 listserv listserv JJ doi-org-9532 32 7 disputes dispute NNS doi-org-9532 32 8 , , , doi-org-9532 32 9 calls call VBZ doi-org-9532 32 10 for for IN doi-org-9532 32 11 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 32 12 , , , doi-org-9532 32 13 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 32 14 seems seem VBZ doi-org-9532 32 15 , , , doi-org-9532 32 16 are be VBP doi-org-9532 32 17 beginning begin VBG doi-org-9532 32 18 to to TO doi-org-9532 32 19 be be VB doi-org-9532 32 20 relegated relegate VBN doi-org-9532 32 21 to to IN doi-org-9532 32 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 32 23 official official JJ doi-org-9532 32 24 statements statement NNS doi-org-9532 32 25 of of IN doi-org-9532 32 26 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 32 27 associations association NNS doi-org-9532 32 28 , , , doi-org-9532 32 29 boilerplate boilerplate NN doi-org-9532 32 30 lectures lecture NNS doi-org-9532 32 31 in in IN doi-org-9532 32 32 college college NN doi-org-9532 32 33 classrooms classroom NNS doi-org-9532 32 34 , , , doi-org-9532 32 35 and and CC doi-org-9532 32 36 textbooks textbook NNS doi-org-9532 32 37 , , , doi-org-9532 32 38 all all DT doi-org-9532 32 39 of of IN doi-org-9532 32 40 which which WDT doi-org-9532 32 41 often often RB doi-org-9532 32 42 benefit benefit VBP doi-org-9532 32 43 by by IN doi-org-9532 32 44 avoiding avoid VBG doi-org-9532 32 45 openly openly RB doi-org-9532 32 46 stated state VBN doi-org-9532 32 47 political political JJ doi-org-9532 32 48 positions.11 positions.11 NNP doi-org-9532 32 49 If if IN doi-org-9532 32 50 belief belief NN doi-org-9532 32 51 in in IN doi-org-9532 32 52 library library JJ doi-org-9532 32 53 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 32 54 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 32 55 as as RB doi-org-9532 32 56 pervasive pervasive JJ doi-org-9532 32 57 as as IN doi-org-9532 32 58 the the DT doi-org-9532 32 59 critique critique NNP doi-org-9532 32 60 supposes suppose VBZ doi-org-9532 32 61 , , , doi-org-9532 32 62 one one NN doi-org-9532 32 63 wonders wonder VBZ doi-org-9532 32 64 why why WRB doi-org-9532 32 65 persistent persistent JJ doi-org-9532 32 66 criticism criticism NN doi-org-9532 32 67 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 32 68 not not RB doi-org-9532 32 69 met meet VBN doi-org-9532 32 70 with with IN doi-org-9532 32 71 more more JJR doi-org-9532 32 72 opposition opposition NN doi-org-9532 32 73 in in IN doi-org-9532 32 74 the the DT doi-org-9532 32 75 literature literature NN doi-org-9532 32 76 . . . doi-org-9532 33 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 33 2 , , , doi-org-9532 33 3 as as IN doi-org-9532 33 4 Bales Bales NNP doi-org-9532 33 5 suggests suggest VBZ doi-org-9532 33 6 , , , doi-org-9532 33 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 33 8 critique critique NN doi-org-9532 33 9 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 33 10 been be VBN doi-org-9532 33 11 so so RB doi-org-9532 33 12 successful successful JJ doi-org-9532 33 13 that that IN doi-org-9532 33 14 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 33 15 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 33 16 no no RB doi-org-9532 33 17 longer long RBR doi-org-9532 33 18 possible possible JJ doi-org-9532 33 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 33 20 offer offer VB doi-org-9532 33 21 a a DT doi-org-9532 33 22 rational rational JJ doi-org-9532 33 23 defense defense NN doi-org-9532 33 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 33 25 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 33 26 . . . doi-org-9532 34 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 34 2 , , , doi-org-9532 34 3 in in IN doi-org-9532 34 4 contrast contrast NN doi-org-9532 34 5 , , , doi-org-9532 34 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 34 7 virtues virtue NNS doi-org-9532 34 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 34 9 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 34 10 are be VBP doi-org-9532 34 11 so so RB doi-org-9532 34 12 obvious obvious JJ doi-org-9532 34 13 to to IN doi-org-9532 34 14 most most JJS doi-org-9532 34 15 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 34 16 that that IN doi-org-9532 34 17 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 34 18 see see VBP doi-org-9532 34 19 no no DT doi-org-9532 34 20 need need NN doi-org-9532 34 21 for for IN doi-org-9532 34 22 theoretical theoretical JJ doi-org-9532 34 23 justification justification NN doi-org-9532 34 24 . . . doi-org-9532 35 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 35 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 35 3 pro pro NN doi-org-9532 35 4 and and CC doi-org-9532 35 5 con con JJ doi-org-9532 35 6 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 35 7 about about IN doi-org-9532 35 8 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 35 9 at at IN doi-org-9532 35 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 35 11 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 35 12 Midwinter Midwinter NNP doi-org-9532 35 13 Meeting Meeting NNP doi-org-9532 35 14 in in IN doi-org-9532 35 15 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 35 16 reflects reflect VBZ doi-org-9532 35 17 a a DT doi-org-9532 35 18 growing grow VBG doi-org-9532 35 19 awareness awareness NN doi-org-9532 35 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 35 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 35 22 critique critique NN doi-org-9532 35 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 35 24 will will MD doi-org-9532 35 25 lead lead VB doi-org-9532 35 26 to to IN doi-org-9532 35 27 increasing increase VBG doi-org-9532 35 28 scholarly scholarly JJ doi-org-9532 35 29 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 35 30 . . . doi-org-9532 36 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 36 2 now now RB doi-org-9532 36 3 , , , doi-org-9532 36 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 5 most most RBS doi-org-9532 36 6 vigorous vigorous JJ doi-org-9532 36 7 defense defense NN doi-org-9532 36 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 36 9 library library JJ doi-org-9532 36 10 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 36 11 can can MD doi-org-9532 36 12 still still RB doi-org-9532 36 13 be be VB doi-org-9532 36 14 found find VBN doi-org-9532 36 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 36 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 36 17 1975 1975 CD doi-org-9532 36 18 book book NN doi-org-9532 36 19 by by IN doi-org-9532 36 20 David David NNP doi-org-9532 36 21 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 36 22 , , , doi-org-9532 36 23 The the DT doi-org-9532 36 24 Flight Flight NNP doi-org-9532 36 25 from from IN doi-org-9532 36 26 Reason reason NN doi-org-9532 36 27 : : : doi-org-9532 36 28 Essays essay NNS doi-org-9532 36 29 on on IN doi-org-9532 36 30 Intellectual Intellectual NNP doi-org-9532 36 31 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 36 32 in in IN doi-org-9532 36 33 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 34 Academy Academy NNP doi-org-9532 36 35 , , , doi-org-9532 36 36 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 37 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 36 38 , , , doi-org-9532 36 39 and and CC doi-org-9532 36 40 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 41 Library.12 library.12 NN doi-org-9532 36 42 The the DT doi-org-9532 36 43 central central JJ doi-org-9532 36 44 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 36 45 of of IN doi-org-9532 36 46 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 47 book book NN doi-org-9532 36 48 , , , doi-org-9532 36 49 " " `` doi-org-9532 36 50 Social Social NNP doi-org-9532 36 51 Responsibility Responsibility NNP doi-org-9532 36 52 vs. vs. CC doi-org-9532 36 53 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 54 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 36 55 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 36 56 of of IN doi-org-9532 36 57 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 36 58 , , , doi-org-9532 36 59 " " '' doi-org-9532 36 60 was be VBD doi-org-9532 36 61 published publish VBN doi-org-9532 36 62 in in IN doi-org-9532 36 63 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 36 64 Journal Journal NNP doi-org-9532 36 65 in in IN doi-org-9532 36 66 1972 1972 CD doi-org-9532 36 67 as as IN doi-org-9532 36 68 part part NN doi-org-9532 36 69 of of IN doi-org-9532 36 70 an an DT doi-org-9532 36 71 intense intense JJ doi-org-9532 36 72 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 36 73 about about IN doi-org-9532 36 74 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 75 ethics ethic NNS doi-org-9532 36 76 of of IN doi-org-9532 36 77 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 36 78 that that WDT doi-org-9532 36 79 developed develop VBD doi-org-9532 36 80 in in IN doi-org-9532 36 81 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 82 late late JJ doi-org-9532 36 83 1960s 1960 NNS doi-org-9532 36 84 and and CC doi-org-9532 36 85 early early JJ doi-org-9532 36 86 1970s 1970 NNS doi-org-9532 36 87 in in IN doi-org-9532 36 88 response response NN doi-org-9532 36 89 to to IN doi-org-9532 36 90 the the DT doi-org-9532 36 91 widespread widespread JJ doi-org-9532 36 92 social social JJ doi-org-9532 36 93 protests protest NNS doi-org-9532 36 94 of of IN doi-org-9532 36 95 that that DT doi-org-9532 36 96 era era NN doi-org-9532 36 97 . . . doi-org-9532 37 1 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 37 2 was be VBD doi-org-9532 37 3 director director NN doi-org-9532 37 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 37 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 37 6 School School NNP doi-org-9532 37 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 37 8 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 37 9 Science Science NNP doi-org-9532 37 10 at at IN doi-org-9532 37 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 37 12 University University NNP doi-org-9532 37 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 37 14 Minnesota Minnesota NNP doi-org-9532 37 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 37 16 Minneapolis Minneapolis NNP doi-org-9532 37 17 and and CC doi-org-9532 37 18 had have VBD doi-org-9532 37 19 been be VBN doi-org-9532 37 20 a a DT doi-org-9532 37 21 strong strong JJ doi-org-9532 37 22 advocate advocate NN doi-org-9532 37 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 37 24 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 37 25 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 37 26 throughout throughout IN doi-org-9532 37 27 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 37 28 career career NN doi-org-9532 37 29 . . . doi-org-9532 38 1 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 38 2 chaired chair VBD doi-org-9532 38 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 38 4 Intellectual Intellectual NNP doi-org-9532 38 5 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 38 6 Committee Committee NNP doi-org-9532 38 7 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 38 8 IFC IFC NNP doi-org-9532 38 9 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 38 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 38 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 38 12 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 38 13 for for IN doi-org-9532 38 14 several several JJ doi-org-9532 38 15 years year NNS doi-org-9532 38 16 and and CC doi-org-9532 38 17 supported support VBD doi-org-9532 38 18 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 38 19 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 38 20 as as IN doi-org-9532 38 21 a a DT doi-org-9532 38 22 member member NN doi-org-9532 38 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 38 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 38 25 American American NNP doi-org-9532 38 26 Association Association NNP doi-org-9532 38 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 38 28 University University NNP doi-org-9532 38 29 Professors Professors NNPS doi-org-9532 38 30 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 38 31 AAUP AAUP NNP doi-org-9532 38 32 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 38 33 . . . doi-org-9532 39 1 Throughout throughout IN doi-org-9532 39 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 39 3 1950s 1950 NNS doi-org-9532 39 4 and and CC doi-org-9532 39 5 1960s 1960 NNS doi-org-9532 39 6 , , , doi-org-9532 39 7 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 39 8 sought seek VBD doi-org-9532 39 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 39 10 make make VB doi-org-9532 39 11 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 39 12 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 39 13 a a DT doi-org-9532 39 14 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 39 15 ethical ethical JJ doi-org-9532 39 16 mandate mandate NN doi-org-9532 39 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 39 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 39 19 library library NN doi-org-9532 39 20 profession profession NN doi-org-9532 39 21 . . . doi-org-9532 40 1 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 40 2 fought fight VBD doi-org-9532 40 3 against against IN doi-org-9532 40 4 efforts effort NNS doi-org-9532 40 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 40 6 force force VB doi-org-9532 40 7 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 40 8 to to TO doi-org-9532 40 9 sign sign VB doi-org-9532 40 10 loyalty loyalty NN doi-org-9532 40 11 oaths oath NNS doi-org-9532 40 12 during during IN doi-org-9532 40 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 40 14 McCarthy McCarthy NNP doi-org-9532 40 15 era era NN doi-org-9532 40 16 , , , doi-org-9532 40 17 when when WRB doi-org-9532 40 18 there there EX doi-org-9532 40 19 were be VBD doi-org-9532 40 20 widespread widespread JJ doi-org-9532 40 21 accusations accusation NNS doi-org-9532 40 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 40 23 suspected suspect VBN doi-org-9532 40 24 Communist communist JJ doi-org-9532 40 25 activities activity NNS doi-org-9532 40 26 , , , doi-org-9532 40 27 often often RB doi-org-9532 40 28 with with IN doi-org-9532 40 29 little little JJ doi-org-9532 40 30 evidence.13 evidence.13 NNP doi-org-9532 40 31 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 40 32 also also RB doi-org-9532 40 33 strove strove VBP doi-org-9532 40 34 to to TO doi-org-9532 40 35 make make VB doi-org-9532 40 36 the the DT doi-org-9532 40 37 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 40 38 more more RBR doi-org-9532 40 39 effective effective JJ doi-org-9532 40 40 in in IN doi-org-9532 40 41 supporting support VBG doi-org-9532 40 42 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 40 43 who who WP doi-org-9532 40 44 had have VBD doi-org-9532 40 45 been be VBN doi-org-9532 40 46 disciplined discipline VBN doi-org-9532 40 47 for for IN doi-org-9532 40 48 resisting resist VBG doi-org-9532 40 49 attempts attempt NNS doi-org-9532 40 50 to to TO doi-org-9532 40 51 censor censor VB doi-org-9532 40 52 library library NN doi-org-9532 40 53 collections.14 collections.14 NNP doi-org-9532 40 54 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 40 55 End end NN doi-org-9532 40 56 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 40 57 57 57 CD doi-org-9532 40 58 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 40 59 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 40 60 's 's POS doi-org-9532 40 61 1972 1972 CD doi-org-9532 40 62 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 40 63 was be VBD doi-org-9532 40 64 prompted prompt VBN doi-org-9532 40 65 by by IN doi-org-9532 40 66 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 40 67 within within IN doi-org-9532 40 68 the the DT doi-org-9532 40 69 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 40 70 about about IN doi-org-9532 40 71 whether whether IN doi-org-9532 40 72 the the DT doi-org-9532 40 73 social social JJ doi-org-9532 40 74 responsibilities responsibility NNS doi-org-9532 40 75 of of IN doi-org-9532 40 76 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 40 77 should should MD doi-org-9532 40 78 go go VB doi-org-9532 40 79 beyond beyond IN doi-org-9532 40 80 protecting protect VBG doi-org-9532 40 81 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 40 82 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 40 83 as as IN doi-org-9532 40 84 defined define VBN doi-org-9532 40 85 by by IN doi-org-9532 40 86 the the DT doi-org-9532 40 87 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 40 88 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 40 89 of of IN doi-org-9532 40 90 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 40 91 . . . doi-org-9532 41 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 41 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 41 3 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 41 4 , , , doi-org-9532 41 5 as as IN doi-org-9532 41 6 in in IN doi-org-9532 41 7 many many JJ doi-org-9532 41 8 other other JJ doi-org-9532 41 9 organizations organization NNS doi-org-9532 41 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 41 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 41 12 1970s 1970 NNS doi-org-9532 41 13 , , , doi-org-9532 41 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 41 15 consensus consensus NN doi-org-9532 41 16 New New NNP doi-org-9532 41 17 Deal Deal NNP doi-org-9532 41 18 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 41 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 41 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 41 21 post post JJ doi-org-9532 41 22 - - JJ doi-org-9532 41 23 World world JJ doi-org-9532 41 24 War War NNP doi-org-9532 41 25 II II NNP doi-org-9532 41 26 era era NN doi-org-9532 41 27 was be VBD doi-org-9532 41 28 being be VBG doi-org-9532 41 29 challenged challenge VBN doi-org-9532 41 30 by by IN doi-org-9532 41 31 radicals radical NNS doi-org-9532 41 32 opposed oppose VBN doi-org-9532 41 33 to to IN doi-org-9532 41 34 racial racial JJ doi-org-9532 41 35 segregation segregation NN doi-org-9532 41 36 and and CC doi-org-9532 41 37 the the DT doi-org-9532 41 38 Vietnam Vietnam NNP doi-org-9532 41 39 War War NNP doi-org-9532 41 40 . . . doi-org-9532 42 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 42 2 growing grow VBG doi-org-9532 42 3 number number NN doi-org-9532 42 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 42 5 Americans Americans NNPS doi-org-9532 42 6 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 42 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 42 8 there there EX doi-org-9532 42 9 were be VBD doi-org-9532 42 10 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 42 11 flaws flaw NNS doi-org-9532 42 12 in in IN doi-org-9532 42 13 American american JJ doi-org-9532 42 14 society society NN doi-org-9532 42 15 that that WDT doi-org-9532 42 16 could could MD doi-org-9532 42 17 be be VB doi-org-9532 42 18 resolved resolve VBN doi-org-9532 42 19 only only RB doi-org-9532 42 20 by by IN doi-org-9532 42 21 radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 42 22 change change NN doi-org-9532 42 23 . . . doi-org-9532 43 1 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 43 2 members member NNS doi-org-9532 43 3 committed commit VBD doi-org-9532 43 4 to to IN doi-org-9532 43 5 these these DT doi-org-9532 43 6 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 43 7 formed form VBD doi-org-9532 43 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 43 9 Social Social NNP doi-org-9532 43 10 Responsibilities Responsibilities NNPS doi-org-9532 43 11 Round Round NNP doi-org-9532 43 12 Table table NN doi-org-9532 43 13 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 43 14 SRRT SRRT NNP doi-org-9532 43 15 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 43 16 and and CC doi-org-9532 43 17 argued argue VBD doi-org-9532 43 18 that that IN doi-org-9532 43 19 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 43 20 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 43 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 43 22 take take VB doi-org-9532 43 23 a a DT doi-org-9532 43 24 clear clear JJ doi-org-9532 43 25 stand stand NN doi-org-9532 43 26 in in IN doi-org-9532 43 27 favor favor NN doi-org-9532 43 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 43 29 progressive progressive JJ doi-org-9532 43 30 social social JJ doi-org-9532 43 31 movements movement NNS doi-org-9532 43 32 . . . doi-org-9532 44 1 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 44 2 proposed propose VBD doi-org-9532 44 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 44 4 broader broad JJR doi-org-9532 44 5 definition definition NN doi-org-9532 44 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 44 7 " " `` doi-org-9532 44 8 social social JJ doi-org-9532 44 9 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 44 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 44 11 that that WDT doi-org-9532 44 12 contrasted contrast VBD doi-org-9532 44 13 with with IN doi-org-9532 44 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 44 15 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 44 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 44 17 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 44 18 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 44 19 that that IN doi-org-9532 44 20 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 44 21 had have VBD doi-org-9532 44 22 championed champion VBN doi-org-9532 44 23 throughout throughout IN doi-org-9532 44 24 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 44 25 career career NN doi-org-9532 44 26 . . . doi-org-9532 45 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 45 2 1970 1970 CD doi-org-9532 45 3 , , , doi-org-9532 45 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 45 5 SRRT SRRT NNP doi-org-9532 45 6 issued issue VBD doi-org-9532 45 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 45 8 report report NN doi-org-9532 45 9 that that WDT doi-org-9532 45 10 framed frame VBD doi-org-9532 45 11 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 45 12 understanding understanding NN doi-org-9532 45 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 45 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 45 15 social social JJ doi-org-9532 45 16 role role NN doi-org-9532 45 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 45 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 45 19 library library NN doi-org-9532 45 20 as as IN doi-org-9532 45 21 an an DT doi-org-9532 45 22 alternative alternative NN doi-org-9532 45 23 to to IN doi-org-9532 45 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 45 25 more more RBR doi-org-9532 45 26 limited limited JJ doi-org-9532 45 27 political political JJ doi-org-9532 45 28 agenda agenda NN doi-org-9532 45 29 that that IN doi-org-9532 45 30 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 45 31 had have VBD doi-org-9532 45 32 defended defend VBN doi-org-9532 45 33 as as IN doi-org-9532 45 34 chair chair NN doi-org-9532 45 35 of of IN doi-org-9532 45 36 the the DT doi-org-9532 45 37 IFC IFC NNP doi-org-9532 45 38 : : : doi-org-9532 45 39 There there EX doi-org-9532 45 40 are be VBP doi-org-9532 45 41 two two CD doi-org-9532 45 42 conflicting conflict VBG doi-org-9532 45 43 definitions definition NNS doi-org-9532 45 44 of of IN doi-org-9532 45 45 Social Social NNP doi-org-9532 45 46 Responsibility Responsibility NNP doi-org-9532 45 47 held hold VBN doi-org-9532 45 48 by by IN doi-org-9532 45 49 members member NNS doi-org-9532 45 50 of of IN doi-org-9532 45 51 the the DT doi-org-9532 45 52 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 45 53 at at IN doi-org-9532 45 54 present present NN doi-org-9532 45 55 . . . doi-org-9532 46 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 46 2 first first JJ doi-org-9532 46 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 46 4 traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 46 5 , , , doi-org-9532 46 6 conservative conservative JJ doi-org-9532 46 7 and and CC doi-org-9532 46 8 variously variously RB doi-org-9532 46 9 phrased phrase VBN doi-org-9532 46 10 : : : doi-org-9532 46 11 " " `` doi-org-9532 46 12 The the DT doi-org-9532 46 13 function function NN doi-org-9532 46 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 46 15 a a DT doi-org-9532 46 16 library library NN doi-org-9532 46 17 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 46 18 to to TO doi-org-9532 46 19 have have VB doi-org-9532 46 20 factual factual JJ doi-org-9532 46 21 material material NN doi-org-9532 46 22 on on IN doi-org-9532 46 23 both both DT doi-org-9532 46 24 sides side NNS doi-org-9532 46 25 of of IN doi-org-9532 46 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 46 27 question question NN doi-org-9532 46 28 . . . doi-org-9532 47 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 47 2 library library NN doi-org-9532 47 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 47 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 47 5 reservoir reservoir NN doi-org-9532 47 6 for for IN doi-org-9532 47 7 information information NN doi-org-9532 47 8 and and CC doi-org-9532 47 9 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 47 10 business business NN doi-org-9532 47 11 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 47 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 47 13 conserve conserve VB doi-org-9532 47 14 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 47 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 47 16 wait wait VB doi-org-9532 47 17 till till IN doi-org-9532 47 18 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 47 19 users user NNS doi-org-9532 47 20 require require VBP doi-org-9532 47 21 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 47 22 contents content NNS doi-org-9532 47 23 . . . doi-org-9532 48 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 48 2 library library NN doi-org-9532 48 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 48 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 48 5 source source NN doi-org-9532 48 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 48 7 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 48 8 , , , doi-org-9532 48 9 not not RB doi-org-9532 48 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 48 11 promoter promoter NN doi-org-9532 48 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 48 13 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 48 14 . . . doi-org-9532 48 15 " " '' doi-org-9532 49 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 49 2 second second JJ doi-org-9532 49 3 definition definition NN doi-org-9532 49 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 49 5 " " `` doi-org-9532 49 6 social social JJ doi-org-9532 49 7 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 49 8 " " '' doi-org-9532 49 9 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 49 10 considered consider VBN doi-org-9532 49 11 radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 49 12 , , , doi-org-9532 49 13 new new JJ doi-org-9532 49 14 , , , doi-org-9532 49 15 activist activist NN doi-org-9532 49 16 . . . doi-org-9532 50 1 It -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 50 2 can can MD doi-org-9532 50 3 best well RBS doi-org-9532 50 4 be be VB doi-org-9532 50 5 summed sum VBN doi-org-9532 50 6 up up RP doi-org-9532 50 7 by by IN doi-org-9532 50 8 a a DT doi-org-9532 50 9 definition definition NN doi-org-9532 50 10 put put VBN doi-org-9532 50 11 forth forth RP doi-org-9532 50 12 by by IN doi-org-9532 50 13 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 50 14 's 's POS doi-org-9532 50 15 Committee Committee NNP doi-org-9532 50 16 on on IN doi-org-9532 50 17 Organization Organization NNP doi-org-9532 50 18 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 50 19 COO COO NNP doi-org-9532 50 20 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 50 21 : : : doi-org-9532 50 22 " " `` doi-org-9532 50 23 Social social JJ doi-org-9532 50 24 responsibilities responsibility NNS doi-org-9532 50 25 can can MD doi-org-9532 50 26 be be VB doi-org-9532 50 27 defined define VBN doi-org-9532 50 28 as as IN doi-org-9532 50 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 50 30 relationships relationship NNS doi-org-9532 50 31 that that WDT doi-org-9532 50 32 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 50 33 and and CC doi-org-9532 50 34 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 50 35 have have VBP doi-org-9532 50 36 to to IN doi-org-9532 50 37 non non JJ doi-org-9532 50 38 - - JJ doi-org-9532 50 39 library library JJ doi-org-9532 50 40 problems problem NNS doi-org-9532 50 41 that that WDT doi-org-9532 50 42 relate relate VBP doi-org-9532 50 43 to to IN doi-org-9532 50 44 the the DT doi-org-9532 50 45 social social JJ doi-org-9532 50 46 welfare welfare NN doi-org-9532 50 47 of of IN doi-org-9532 50 48 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 50 49 society society NN doi-org-9532 50 50 . . . doi-org-9532 51 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 51 2 15 15 CD doi-org-9532 51 3 Although although IN doi-org-9532 51 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 51 5 report report NN doi-org-9532 51 6 embraces embrace VBZ doi-org-9532 51 7 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 51 8 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 51 9 , , , doi-org-9532 51 10 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 51 11 asserts assert VBZ doi-org-9532 51 12 that that IN doi-org-9532 51 13 defending defend VBG doi-org-9532 51 14 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 51 15 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 51 16 represents represent VBZ doi-org-9532 51 17 an an DT doi-org-9532 51 18 overly overly RB doi-org-9532 51 19 narrow narrow JJ doi-org-9532 51 20 political political JJ doi-org-9532 51 21 agenda agenda NN doi-org-9532 51 22 . . . doi-org-9532 52 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 52 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 52 3 period period NN doi-org-9532 52 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 52 5 intense intense JJ doi-org-9532 52 6 social social JJ doi-org-9532 52 7 conflict conflict NN doi-org-9532 52 8 , , , doi-org-9532 52 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 52 10 SRRT SRRT NNP doi-org-9532 52 11 wanted want VBD doi-org-9532 52 12 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 52 13 to to TO doi-org-9532 52 14 take take VB doi-org-9532 52 15 a a DT doi-org-9532 52 16 stand stand NN doi-org-9532 52 17 on on IN doi-org-9532 52 18 broader broad JJR doi-org-9532 52 19 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 52 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 52 21 social social JJ doi-org-9532 52 22 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 52 23 . . . doi-org-9532 53 1 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 53 2 maintained maintain VBD doi-org-9532 53 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 53 4 adopting adopt VBG doi-org-9532 53 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 53 6 SRRT SRRT NNP doi-org-9532 53 7 's 's POS doi-org-9532 53 8 radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 53 9 definition definition NN doi-org-9532 53 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 53 11 social social JJ doi-org-9532 53 12 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 53 13 would would MD doi-org-9532 53 14 destroy destroy VB doi-org-9532 53 15 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 53 16 than than IN doi-org-9532 53 17 expand expand VB doi-org-9532 53 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 53 19 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 53 20 's 's POS doi-org-9532 53 21 political political JJ doi-org-9532 53 22 effectiveness effectiveness NN doi-org-9532 53 23 . . . doi-org-9532 54 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 54 2 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 54 3 eyes eye NNS doi-org-9532 54 4 , , , doi-org-9532 54 5 taking take VBG doi-org-9532 54 6 an an DT doi-org-9532 54 7 activist activist JJ doi-org-9532 54 8 position position NN doi-org-9532 54 9 on on IN doi-org-9532 54 10 " " `` doi-org-9532 54 11 non non JJ doi-org-9532 54 12 - - JJ doi-org-9532 54 13 library library JJ doi-org-9532 54 14 problems problem NNS doi-org-9532 54 15 " " '' doi-org-9532 54 16 meant mean VBD doi-org-9532 54 17 abandoning abandon VBG doi-org-9532 54 18 effective effective JJ doi-org-9532 54 19 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 54 20 to to IN doi-org-9532 54 21 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 54 22 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 54 23 . . . doi-org-9532 55 1 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 55 2 argued argue VBD doi-org-9532 55 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 55 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 55 5 library library NN doi-org-9532 55 6 could could MD doi-org-9532 55 7 be be VB doi-org-9532 55 8 an an DT doi-org-9532 55 9 " " `` doi-org-9532 55 10 advocacy advocacy NN doi-org-9532 55 11 " " '' doi-org-9532 55 12 library library NN doi-org-9532 55 13 or or CC doi-org-9532 55 14 a a DT doi-org-9532 55 15 " " `` doi-org-9532 55 16 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 55 17 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 55 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 55 19 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 55 20 " " '' doi-org-9532 55 21 library library NN doi-org-9532 55 22 , , , doi-org-9532 55 23 but but CC doi-org-9532 55 24 not not RB doi-org-9532 55 25 both both DT doi-org-9532 55 26 . . . doi-org-9532 56 1 By by IN doi-org-9532 56 2 promoting promote VBG doi-org-9532 56 3 specific specific JJ doi-org-9532 56 4 positions position NNS doi-org-9532 56 5 on on IN doi-org-9532 56 6 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 56 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 56 8 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 56 9 social social JJ doi-org-9532 56 10 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 56 11 , , , doi-org-9532 56 12 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 56 13 undermined undermine VBD doi-org-9532 56 14 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 56 15 role role NN doi-org-9532 56 16 as as IN doi-org-9532 56 17 impartial impartial JJ doi-org-9532 56 18 advocates advocate NNS doi-org-9532 56 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 56 20 favor favor NN doi-org-9532 56 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 56 22 open open JJ doi-org-9532 56 23 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 56 24 minded minded JJ doi-org-9532 56 25 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 56 26 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 56 27 : : : doi-org-9532 56 28 " " `` doi-org-9532 56 29 America America NNP doi-org-9532 56 30 's 's POS doi-org-9532 56 31 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 56 32 can can MD doi-org-9532 56 33 not not RB doi-org-9532 56 34 afford afford VB doi-org-9532 56 35 to to TO doi-org-9532 56 36 be be VB doi-org-9532 56 37 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 56 38 about about IN doi-org-9532 56 39 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 56 40 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 56 41 to to TO doi-org-9532 56 42 preserve preserve VB doi-org-9532 56 43 the the DT doi-org-9532 56 44 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 56 45 to to TO doi-org-9532 56 46 read read VB doi-org-9532 56 47 for for IN doi-org-9532 56 48 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 56 49 . . . doi-org-9532 57 1 At at IN doi-org-9532 57 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 57 3 same same JJ doi-org-9532 57 4 time time NN doi-org-9532 57 5 , , , doi-org-9532 57 6 as as IN doi-org-9532 57 7 professionals professional NNS doi-org-9532 57 8 , , , doi-org-9532 57 9 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 57 10 must must MD doi-org-9532 57 11 remain remain VB doi-org-9532 57 12 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 57 13 about about IN doi-org-9532 57 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 57 15 issues issue NNS doi-org-9532 57 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 57 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 57 18 day day NN doi-org-9532 57 19 regardless regardless RB doi-org-9532 57 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 57 21 what what WP doi-org-9532 57 22 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 57 23 may may MD doi-org-9532 57 24 do do VB doi-org-9532 57 25 as as IN doi-org-9532 57 26 private private JJ doi-org-9532 57 27 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 57 28 . . . doi-org-9532 58 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 58 2 16 16 CD doi-org-9532 58 3 Although although IN doi-org-9532 58 4 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 58 5 acknowledged acknowledge VBD doi-org-9532 58 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 58 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 58 8 country country NN doi-org-9532 58 9 faced face VBD doi-org-9532 58 10 many many JJ doi-org-9532 58 11 social social JJ doi-org-9532 58 12 problems problem NNS doi-org-9532 58 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 58 14 that that IN doi-org-9532 58 15 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 58 16 had have VBD doi-org-9532 58 17 an an DT doi-org-9532 58 18 obligation obligation NN doi-org-9532 58 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 58 20 contribute contribute VB doi-org-9532 58 21 to to IN doi-org-9532 58 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 58 23 solution solution NN doi-org-9532 58 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 58 25 these these DT doi-org-9532 58 26 problems problem NNS doi-org-9532 58 27 as as IN doi-org-9532 58 28 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 58 29 , , , doi-org-9532 58 30 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 58 31 argued argue VBD doi-org-9532 58 32 that that IN doi-org-9532 58 33 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 58 34 ' ' POS doi-org-9532 58 35 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 58 36 to to IN doi-org-9532 58 37 the the DT doi-org-9532 58 38 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 58 39 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 58 40 of of IN doi-org-9532 58 41 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 58 42 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 58 43 had have VBD doi-org-9532 58 44 to to TO doi-org-9532 58 45 take take VB doi-org-9532 58 46 priority priority NN doi-org-9532 58 47 over over IN doi-org-9532 58 48 personal personal JJ doi-org-9532 58 49 political political JJ doi-org-9532 58 50 commitments commitment NNS doi-org-9532 58 51 while while IN doi-org-9532 58 52 working work VBG doi-org-9532 58 53 in in IN doi-org-9532 58 54 the the DT doi-org-9532 58 55 library library NN doi-org-9532 58 56 . . . doi-org-9532 59 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 59 2 question question NN doi-org-9532 59 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 59 4 why why WRB doi-org-9532 59 5 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 59 6 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 59 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 59 8 advocacy advocacy NN doi-org-9532 59 9 was be VBD doi-org-9532 59 10 incompatible incompatible JJ doi-org-9532 59 11 with with IN doi-org-9532 59 12 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 59 13 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 59 14 . . . doi-org-9532 60 1 Why why WRB doi-org-9532 60 2 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 60 3 fighting fight VBG doi-org-9532 60 4 racism racism NN doi-org-9532 60 5 , , , doi-org-9532 60 6 economic economic JJ doi-org-9532 60 7 inequality inequality NN doi-org-9532 60 8 , , , doi-org-9532 60 9 or or CC doi-org-9532 60 10 nuclear nuclear JJ doi-org-9532 60 11 proliferation proliferation NN doi-org-9532 60 12 incompatible incompatible JJ doi-org-9532 60 13 with with IN doi-org-9532 60 14 defending defend VBG doi-org-9532 60 15 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 60 16 ' ' POS doi-org-9532 60 17 right right NN doi-org-9532 60 18 to to TO doi-org-9532 60 19 read read VB doi-org-9532 60 20 whatever whatever WDT doi-org-9532 60 21 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 60 22 want want VBP doi-org-9532 60 23 ? ? . doi-org-9532 61 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 61 2 conflict conflict NN doi-org-9532 61 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 61 4 not not RB doi-org-9532 61 5 immediately immediately RB doi-org-9532 61 6 obvious obvious JJ doi-org-9532 61 7 . . . doi-org-9532 62 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 62 2 fact fact NN doi-org-9532 62 3 , , , doi-org-9532 62 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 62 5 AAUP AAUP NNP doi-org-9532 62 6 takes take VBZ doi-org-9532 62 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 62 8 opposite opposite JJ doi-org-9532 62 9 position position NN doi-org-9532 62 10 for for IN doi-org-9532 62 11 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 62 12 members member NNS doi-org-9532 62 13 . . . doi-org-9532 63 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 63 2 university university NN doi-org-9532 63 3 professors professor NNS doi-org-9532 63 4 , , , doi-org-9532 63 5 having have VBG doi-org-9532 63 6 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 63 7 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 63 8 means mean VBZ doi-org-9532 63 9 having have VBG doi-org-9532 63 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 63 11 right right NN doi-org-9532 63 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 63 13 express express VB doi-org-9532 63 14 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 63 15 End end NN doi-org-9532 63 16 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 63 17 58 58 CD doi-org-9532 63 18 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 63 19 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 63 20 political political JJ doi-org-9532 63 21 opinions opinion NNS doi-org-9532 63 22 without without IN doi-org-9532 63 23 fear fear NN doi-org-9532 63 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 63 25 institutional institutional JJ doi-org-9532 63 26 retribution retribution NN doi-org-9532 63 27 . . . doi-org-9532 64 1 All all DT doi-org-9532 64 2 that that WDT doi-org-9532 64 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 64 4 AAUP AAUP NNP doi-org-9532 64 5 requires require VBZ doi-org-9532 64 6 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 64 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 64 8 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 64 9 to to IN doi-org-9532 64 10 scholarly scholarly JJ doi-org-9532 64 11 accuracy accuracy NN doi-org-9532 64 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 64 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 64 14 willingness willingness NN doi-org-9532 64 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 64 16 " " `` doi-org-9532 64 17 show show VB doi-org-9532 64 18 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 64 19 to to IN doi-org-9532 64 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 64 21 opinions opinion NNS doi-org-9532 64 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 64 23 others other NNS doi-org-9532 64 24 " " '' doi-org-9532 64 25 in in IN doi-org-9532 64 26 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 64 27 debate.17 debate.17 NNP doi-org-9532 64 28 In in IN doi-org-9532 64 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 64 30 academy academy NN doi-org-9532 64 31 , , , doi-org-9532 64 32 defending defend VBG doi-org-9532 64 33 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 64 34 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 64 35 means mean VBZ doi-org-9532 64 36 creating create VBG doi-org-9532 64 37 an an DT doi-org-9532 64 38 environment environment NN doi-org-9532 64 39 that that WDT doi-org-9532 64 40 promotes promote VBZ doi-org-9532 64 41 open open JJ doi-org-9532 64 42 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 64 43 minded minded JJ doi-org-9532 64 44 discussion discussion NN doi-org-9532 64 45 of of IN doi-org-9532 64 46 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 64 47 where where WRB doi-org-9532 64 48 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 64 49 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 64 50 encouraged encourage VBN doi-org-9532 64 51 to to TO doi-org-9532 64 52 articulate articulate VB doi-org-9532 64 53 , , , doi-org-9532 64 54 defend defend VB doi-org-9532 64 55 , , , doi-org-9532 64 56 and and CC doi-org-9532 64 57 justify justify VB doi-org-9532 64 58 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 64 59 values value NNS doi-org-9532 64 60 . . . doi-org-9532 65 1 So so CC doi-org-9532 65 2 , , , doi-org-9532 65 3 why why WRB doi-org-9532 65 4 would would MD doi-org-9532 65 5 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 65 6 believe believe VB doi-org-9532 65 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 65 8 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 65 9 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 65 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 65 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 65 12 library library NN doi-org-9532 65 13 requires require VBZ doi-org-9532 65 14 that that IN doi-org-9532 65 15 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 65 16 suppress suppress VBP doi-org-9532 65 17 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 65 18 opinions opinion NNS doi-org-9532 65 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 65 20 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 65 21 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 65 22 activities activity NNS doi-org-9532 65 23 ? ? . doi-org-9532 66 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 66 2 hindsight hindsight NN doi-org-9532 66 3 , , , doi-org-9532 66 4 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 66 5 think think VBP doi-org-9532 66 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 66 7 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 66 8 's 's POS doi-org-9532 66 9 attempt attempt NN doi-org-9532 66 10 to to TO doi-org-9532 66 11 answer answer VB doi-org-9532 66 12 this this DT doi-org-9532 66 13 question question NN doi-org-9532 66 14 was be VBD doi-org-9532 66 15 marred mar VBN doi-org-9532 66 16 by by IN doi-org-9532 66 17 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 66 18 intense intense JJ doi-org-9532 66 19 engagement engagement NN doi-org-9532 66 20 with with IN doi-org-9532 66 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 66 22 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 66 23 political political JJ doi-org-9532 66 24 struggles struggle NNS doi-org-9532 66 25 within within IN doi-org-9532 66 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 66 27 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 66 28 . . . doi-org-9532 66 29 As as IN doi-org-9532 66 30 the the DT doi-org-9532 66 31 chair chair NN doi-org-9532 66 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 66 33 the the DT doi-org-9532 66 34 IFC IFC NNP doi-org-9532 66 35 , , , doi-org-9532 66 36 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 66 37 saw see VBD doi-org-9532 66 38 the the DT doi-org-9532 66 39 SRRT SRRT NNP doi-org-9532 66 40 's 's POS doi-org-9532 66 41 rejection rejection NN doi-org-9532 66 42 of of IN doi-org-9532 66 43 the the DT doi-org-9532 66 44 " " `` doi-org-9532 66 45 traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 66 46 , , , doi-org-9532 66 47 conservative conservative JJ doi-org-9532 66 48 " " '' doi-org-9532 66 49 interpretation interpretation NN doi-org-9532 66 50 of of IN doi-org-9532 66 51 social social JJ doi-org-9532 66 52 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 66 53 as as IN doi-org-9532 66 54 a a DT doi-org-9532 66 55 direct direct JJ doi-org-9532 66 56 attack attack NN doi-org-9532 66 57 against against IN doi-org-9532 66 58 himself -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 66 59 , , , doi-org-9532 66 60 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 66 61 committee committee NN doi-org-9532 66 62 , , , doi-org-9532 66 63 and and CC doi-org-9532 66 64 the the DT doi-org-9532 66 65 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 66 66 that that WDT doi-org-9532 66 67 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 66 68 had have VBD doi-org-9532 66 69 championed champion VBN doi-org-9532 66 70 throughout throughout IN doi-org-9532 66 71 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 66 72 career career NN doi-org-9532 66 73 . . . doi-org-9532 67 1 Moreover moreover RB doi-org-9532 67 2 , , , doi-org-9532 67 3 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 67 4 was be VBD doi-org-9532 67 5 dismayed dismay VBN doi-org-9532 67 6 by by IN doi-org-9532 67 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 67 8 apparent apparent JJ doi-org-9532 67 9 embrace embrace NN doi-org-9532 67 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 67 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 67 12 SRRT SRRT NNP doi-org-9532 67 13 's 's POS doi-org-9532 67 14 position position NN doi-org-9532 67 15 by by IN doi-org-9532 67 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 67 17 library library NN doi-org-9532 67 18 press press NN doi-org-9532 67 19 . . . doi-org-9532 68 1 His -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 68 2 book book NN doi-org-9532 68 3 includes include VBZ doi-org-9532 68 4 extensive extensive JJ doi-org-9532 68 5 complaints complaint NNS doi-org-9532 68 6 about about IN doi-org-9532 68 7 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 68 8 Journal Journal NNP doi-org-9532 68 9 's 's POS doi-org-9532 68 10 abandonment abandonment NN doi-org-9532 68 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 68 12 objective objective JJ doi-org-9532 68 13 journalism journalism NN doi-org-9532 68 14 , , , doi-org-9532 68 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 68 16 part part NN doi-org-9532 68 17 stemming stem VBG doi-org-9532 68 18 from from IN doi-org-9532 68 19 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 68 20 belief belief NN doi-org-9532 68 21 that that IN doi-org-9532 68 22 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 68 23 had have VBD doi-org-9532 68 24 been be VBN doi-org-9532 68 25 unfairly unfairly RB doi-org-9532 68 26 criticized criticize VBN doi-org-9532 68 27 by by IN doi-org-9532 68 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 68 29 magazine magazine NN doi-org-9532 68 30 . . . doi-org-9532 69 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 69 2 inflammatory inflammatory JJ doi-org-9532 69 3 title title NN doi-org-9532 69 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 69 5 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 69 6 's 's POS doi-org-9532 69 7 book book NN doi-org-9532 69 8 reflects reflect VBZ doi-org-9532 69 9 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 69 10 unwillingness unwillingness NN doi-org-9532 69 11 — — : doi-org-9532 69 12 in in IN doi-org-9532 69 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 69 14 heat heat NN doi-org-9532 69 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 69 16 an an DT doi-org-9532 69 17 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 69 18 political political JJ doi-org-9532 69 19 fight fight NN doi-org-9532 69 20 — — : doi-org-9532 69 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 69 22 grant grant VB doi-org-9532 69 23 a a DT doi-org-9532 69 24 fair fair JJ doi-org-9532 69 25 hearing hearing NN doi-org-9532 69 26 to to IN doi-org-9532 69 27 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 69 28 opponents opponent NNS doi-org-9532 69 29 . . . doi-org-9532 70 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 70 2 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 70 3 , , , doi-org-9532 70 4 advocacy advocacy NN doi-org-9532 70 5 was be VBD doi-org-9532 70 6 incompatible incompatible JJ doi-org-9532 70 7 with with IN doi-org-9532 70 8 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 70 9 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 70 10 because because IN doi-org-9532 70 11 activist activist JJ doi-org-9532 70 12 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 70 13 had have VBD doi-org-9532 70 14 taken take VBN doi-org-9532 70 15 a a DT doi-org-9532 70 16 " " `` doi-org-9532 70 17 flight flight NN doi-org-9532 70 18 from from IN doi-org-9532 70 19 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 70 20 " " `` doi-org-9532 70 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 70 22 embrace embrace VB doi-org-9532 70 23 irrational irrational JJ doi-org-9532 70 24 dogmatism dogmatism NN doi-org-9532 70 25 . . . doi-org-9532 71 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 71 2 example example NN doi-org-9532 71 3 , , , doi-org-9532 71 4 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 71 5 argued argue VBD doi-org-9532 71 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 71 7 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 71 8 who who WP doi-org-9532 71 9 thought think VBD doi-org-9532 71 10 that that IN doi-org-9532 71 11 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 71 12 should should MD doi-org-9532 71 13 endorse endorse VB doi-org-9532 71 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 71 15 environmental environmental JJ doi-org-9532 71 16 politics politic NNS doi-org-9532 71 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 71 18 Rachel Rachel NNP doi-org-9532 71 19 Carson Carson NNP doi-org-9532 71 20 's 's POS doi-org-9532 71 21 Silent Silent NNP doi-org-9532 71 22 Spring Spring NNP doi-org-9532 71 23 prioritized prioritize VBD doi-org-9532 71 24 " " `` doi-org-9532 71 25 gut gut NN doi-org-9532 71 26 feelings feeling NNS doi-org-9532 71 27 " " '' doi-org-9532 71 28 over over IN doi-org-9532 71 29 rational rational JJ doi-org-9532 71 30 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 71 31 . . . doi-org-9532 72 1 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 72 2 " " `` doi-org-9532 72 3 feel feel VBP doi-org-9532 72 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 72 5 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 72 6 are be VBP doi-org-9532 72 7 right right JJ doi-org-9532 72 8 because because IN doi-org-9532 72 9 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 72 10 are be VBP doi-org-9532 72 11 sincere sincere JJ doi-org-9532 72 12 in in IN doi-org-9532 72 13 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 72 14 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 72 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 72 16 because because IN doi-org-9532 72 17 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 72 18 hold hold VBP doi-org-9532 72 19 strong strong JJ doi-org-9532 72 20 convictions conviction NNS doi-org-9532 72 21 . . . doi-org-9532 73 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 73 2 18 18 CD doi-org-9532 73 3 There there EX doi-org-9532 73 4 was be VBD doi-org-9532 73 5 no no DT doi-org-9532 73 6 middle middle JJ doi-org-9532 73 7 ground ground NN doi-org-9532 73 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 73 9 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 73 10 's 's POS doi-org-9532 73 11 analysis analysis NN doi-org-9532 73 12 that that WDT doi-org-9532 73 13 would would MD doi-org-9532 73 14 allow allow VB doi-org-9532 73 15 a a DT doi-org-9532 73 16 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 73 17 to to TO doi-org-9532 73 18 endorse endorse VB doi-org-9532 73 19 a a DT doi-org-9532 73 20 radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 73 21 political political JJ doi-org-9532 73 22 position position NN doi-org-9532 73 23 without without IN doi-org-9532 73 24 becoming become VBG doi-org-9532 73 25 a a DT doi-org-9532 73 26 " " `` doi-org-9532 73 27 rigid rigid JJ doi-org-9532 73 28 , , , doi-org-9532 73 29 " " '' doi-org-9532 73 30 " " `` doi-org-9532 73 31 intransigent intransigent JJ doi-org-9532 73 32 " " '' doi-org-9532 73 33 extremist extremist NN doi-org-9532 73 34 who who WP doi-org-9532 73 35 sincerely sincerely RB doi-org-9532 73 36 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 73 37 " " '' doi-org-9532 73 38 that that IN doi-org-9532 73 39 anyone anyone NN doi-org-9532 73 40 who who WP doi-org-9532 73 41 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 73 42 not not RB doi-org-9532 73 43 view view VB doi-org-9532 73 44 the the DT doi-org-9532 73 45 world world NN doi-org-9532 73 46 precisely precisely RB doi-org-9532 73 47 as as IN doi-org-9532 73 48 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 73 49 do do VBP doi-org-9532 73 50 should should MD doi-org-9532 73 51 be be VB doi-org-9532 73 52 forced force VBN doi-org-9532 73 53 to to TO doi-org-9532 73 54 conform conform VB doi-org-9532 73 55 or or CC doi-org-9532 73 56 cease cease VB doi-org-9532 73 57 to to TO doi-org-9532 73 58 exist exist VB doi-org-9532 73 59 . . . doi-org-9532 74 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 74 2 19 19 CD doi-org-9532 74 3 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 74 4 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 74 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 74 6 adopting adopt VBG doi-org-9532 74 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 74 8 SRRT SRRT NNP doi-org-9532 74 9 's 's POS doi-org-9532 74 10 vision vision NN doi-org-9532 74 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 74 12 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 74 13 was be VBD doi-org-9532 74 14 equivalent equivalent JJ doi-org-9532 74 15 to to IN doi-org-9532 74 16 adopting adopt VBG doi-org-9532 74 17 left left JJ doi-org-9532 74 18 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 74 19 wing wing NN doi-org-9532 74 20 political political JJ doi-org-9532 74 21 dogmatism dogmatism NN doi-org-9532 74 22 just just RB doi-org-9532 74 23 as as IN doi-org-9532 74 24 damaging damage VBG doi-org-9532 74 25 to to IN doi-org-9532 74 26 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 74 27 values value NNS doi-org-9532 74 28 as as IN doi-org-9532 74 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 74 30 right right JJ doi-org-9532 74 31 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 74 32 wing wing NN doi-org-9532 74 33 McCarthyism McCarthyism NNP doi-org-9532 74 34 that that IN doi-org-9532 74 35 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 74 36 had have VBD doi-org-9532 74 37 fought fight VBN doi-org-9532 74 38 against against IN doi-org-9532 74 39 in in IN doi-org-9532 74 40 the the DT doi-org-9532 74 41 1950s 1950 NNS doi-org-9532 74 42 and and CC doi-org-9532 74 43 1960s 1960 NNS doi-org-9532 74 44 . . . doi-org-9532 75 1 Furthermore furthermore RB doi-org-9532 75 2 , , , doi-org-9532 75 3 due due IN doi-org-9532 75 4 to to IN doi-org-9532 75 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 75 6 inherent inherent JJ doi-org-9532 75 7 right right RB doi-org-9532 75 8 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 75 9 leaning lean VBG doi-org-9532 75 10 political political JJ doi-org-9532 75 11 tendencies tendency NNS doi-org-9532 75 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 75 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 75 14 nation nation NN doi-org-9532 75 15 , , , doi-org-9532 75 16 Bern Bern NNP doi-org-9532 75 17 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 75 18 inghausen inghausen NNP doi-org-9532 75 19 argued argue VBD doi-org-9532 75 20 that that IN doi-org-9532 75 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 75 22 activism activism NN doi-org-9532 75 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 75 24 left left JJ doi-org-9532 75 25 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 75 26 wing wing NN doi-org-9532 75 27 extremists extremist NNS doi-org-9532 75 28 almost almost RB doi-org-9532 75 29 always always RB doi-org-9532 75 30 contributed contribute VBD doi-org-9532 75 31 to to IN doi-org-9532 75 32 the the DT doi-org-9532 75 33 ultimate ultimate JJ doi-org-9532 75 34 triumph triumph NN doi-org-9532 75 35 of of IN doi-org-9532 75 36 right right JJ doi-org-9532 75 37 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 75 38 wing wing NN doi-org-9532 75 39 extremism extremism NN doi-org-9532 75 40 in in IN doi-org-9532 75 41 American american JJ doi-org-9532 75 42 politics politic NNS doi-org-9532 75 43 by by IN doi-org-9532 75 44 undermining undermine VBG doi-org-9532 75 45 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 75 46 traditions tradition NNS doi-org-9532 75 47 that that WDT doi-org-9532 75 48 hold hold VBP doi-org-9532 75 49 all all DT doi-org-9532 75 50 forms form NNS doi-org-9532 75 51 of of IN doi-org-9532 75 52 authoritarianism authoritarianism NN doi-org-9532 75 53 at at IN doi-org-9532 75 54 bay bay NNP doi-org-9532 75 55 . . . doi-org-9532 76 1 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 76 2 's 's POS doi-org-9532 76 3 intransigence intransigence NN doi-org-9532 76 4 prevented prevent VBD doi-org-9532 76 5 him -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 76 6 from from IN doi-org-9532 76 7 acknowledging acknowledge VBG doi-org-9532 76 8 that that IN doi-org-9532 76 9 political political JJ doi-org-9532 76 10 activism activism NN doi-org-9532 76 11 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 76 12 not not RB doi-org-9532 76 13 inherently inherently RB doi-org-9532 76 14 inconsistent inconsistent JJ doi-org-9532 76 15 with with IN doi-org-9532 76 16 fair fair JJ doi-org-9532 76 17 and and CC doi-org-9532 76 18 open open JJ doi-org-9532 76 19 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 76 20 minded minded JJ doi-org-9532 76 21 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 76 22 . . . doi-org-9532 77 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 77 2 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 77 3 can can MD doi-org-9532 77 4 be be VB doi-org-9532 77 5 completely completely RB doi-org-9532 77 6 committed commit VBN doi-org-9532 77 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 77 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 77 9 arguments argument NNS doi-org-9532 77 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 77 11 Silent Silent NNP doi-org-9532 77 12 Spring Spring NNP doi-org-9532 77 13 without without IN doi-org-9532 77 14 closing close VBG doi-org-9532 77 15 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 77 16 mind mind NN doi-org-9532 77 17 to to TO doi-org-9532 77 18 alternative alternative JJ doi-org-9532 77 19 perspectives perspective NNS doi-org-9532 77 20 . . . doi-org-9532 78 1 Antinuclear antinuclear JJ doi-org-9532 78 2 activists activist NNS doi-org-9532 78 3 can can MD doi-org-9532 78 4 try try VB doi-org-9532 78 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 78 6 convince convince VB doi-org-9532 78 7 other other JJ doi-org-9532 78 8 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 78 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 78 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 78 11 accuracy accuracy NN doi-org-9532 78 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 78 13 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 78 14 views view NNS doi-org-9532 78 15 without without IN doi-org-9532 78 16 seeking seek VBG doi-org-9532 78 17 to to TO doi-org-9532 78 18 impose impose VB doi-org-9532 78 19 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 78 20 conclusions conclusion NNS doi-org-9532 78 21 on on IN doi-org-9532 78 22 others other NNS doi-org-9532 78 23 through through IN doi-org-9532 78 24 force force NN doi-org-9532 78 25 or or CC doi-org-9532 78 26 censorship censorship NN doi-org-9532 78 27 . . . doi-org-9532 79 1 Most Most JJS doi-org-9532 79 2 of of IN doi-org-9532 79 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 79 4 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 79 5 who who WP doi-org-9532 79 6 responded respond VBD doi-org-9532 79 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 79 8 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 79 9 's 's POS doi-org-9532 79 10 original original JJ doi-org-9532 79 11 article article NN doi-org-9532 79 12 in in IN doi-org-9532 79 13 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 79 14 Journal Journal NNP doi-org-9532 79 15 disagreed disagree VBD doi-org-9532 79 16 with with IN doi-org-9532 79 17 him -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 79 18 on on IN doi-org-9532 79 19 these these DT doi-org-9532 79 20 grounds.20 grounds.20 NNP doi-org-9532 79 21 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 79 22 argued argue VBD doi-org-9532 79 23 that that IN doi-org-9532 79 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 79 25 irrational irrational JJ doi-org-9532 79 26 library library NN doi-org-9532 79 27 ideologues ideologue NNS doi-org-9532 79 28 that that IN doi-org-9532 79 29 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 79 30 admonished admonish VBD doi-org-9532 79 31 in in IN doi-org-9532 79 32 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 79 33 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 79 34 existed exist VBD doi-org-9532 79 35 only only RB doi-org-9532 79 36 in in IN doi-org-9532 79 37 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 79 38 imagination imagination NN doi-org-9532 79 39 . . . doi-org-9532 80 1 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 80 2 failed fail VBD doi-org-9532 80 3 to to TO doi-org-9532 80 4 see see VB doi-org-9532 80 5 themselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 80 6 in in IN doi-org-9532 80 7 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 80 8 End end NN doi-org-9532 80 9 Page page NN doi-org-9532 80 10 59 59 CD doi-org-9532 80 11 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 80 12 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 80 13 's 's POS doi-org-9532 80 14 account account NN doi-org-9532 80 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 80 16 did do VBD doi-org-9532 80 17 not not RB doi-org-9532 80 18 agree agree VB doi-org-9532 80 19 that that IN doi-org-9532 80 20 advocating advocate VBG doi-org-9532 80 21 for for IN doi-org-9532 80 22 a a DT doi-org-9532 80 23 broader broad JJR doi-org-9532 80 24 interpretation interpretation NN doi-org-9532 80 25 of of IN doi-org-9532 80 26 a a DT doi-org-9532 80 27 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 80 28 's 's POS doi-org-9532 80 29 social social JJ doi-org-9532 80 30 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 80 31 meant mean VBD doi-org-9532 80 32 abandoning abandon VBG doi-org-9532 80 33 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 80 34 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 80 35 to to IN doi-org-9532 80 36 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 80 37 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 80 38 . . . doi-org-9532 81 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 81 2 Deeper deep JJR doi-org-9532 81 3 Moral Moral NNP doi-org-9532 81 4 Dilemma Dilemma NNP doi-org-9532 81 5 Although although IN doi-org-9532 81 6 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 81 7 's 's POS doi-org-9532 81 8 attacks attack NNS doi-org-9532 81 9 against against IN doi-org-9532 81 10 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 81 11 critics critic NNS doi-org-9532 81 12 weakened weaken VBD doi-org-9532 81 13 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 81 14 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 81 15 , , , doi-org-9532 81 16 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 81 17 still still RB doi-org-9532 81 18 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 81 19 that that IN doi-org-9532 81 20 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 81 21 description description NN doi-org-9532 81 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 81 23 a a DT doi-org-9532 81 24 stark stark JJ doi-org-9532 81 25 contrast contrast NN doi-org-9532 81 26 between between IN doi-org-9532 81 27 " " `` doi-org-9532 81 28 social social JJ doi-org-9532 81 29 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 81 30 " " '' doi-org-9532 81 31 and and CC doi-org-9532 81 32 " " `` doi-org-9532 81 33 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 81 34 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 81 35 " " '' doi-org-9532 81 36 points point VBZ doi-org-9532 81 37 to to IN doi-org-9532 81 38 a a DT doi-org-9532 81 39 troubling troubling JJ doi-org-9532 81 40 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 81 41 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 81 42 at at IN doi-org-9532 81 43 the the DT doi-org-9532 81 44 heart heart NN doi-org-9532 81 45 of of IN doi-org-9532 81 46 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 81 47 in in IN doi-org-9532 81 48 a a DT doi-org-9532 81 49 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 81 50 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 81 51 society society NN doi-org-9532 81 52 . . . doi-org-9532 82 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 82 2 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 82 3 results result VBZ doi-org-9532 82 4 from from IN doi-org-9532 82 5 two two CD doi-org-9532 82 6 powerful powerful JJ doi-org-9532 82 7 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 82 8 intuitions intuition NNS doi-org-9532 82 9 that that WDT doi-org-9532 82 10 pull pull VBP doi-org-9532 82 11 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 82 12 in in IN doi-org-9532 82 13 opposite opposite JJ doi-org-9532 82 14 directions direction NNS doi-org-9532 82 15 whenever whenever WRB doi-org-9532 82 16 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 82 17 own own JJ doi-org-9532 82 18 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 82 19 values value NNS doi-org-9532 82 20 differ differ VBP doi-org-9532 82 21 significantly significantly RB doi-org-9532 82 22 from from IN doi-org-9532 82 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 82 24 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 82 25 values value NNS doi-org-9532 82 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 82 27 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 82 28 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 82 29 . . . doi-org-9532 83 1 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 83 2 will will MD doi-org-9532 83 3 call call VB doi-org-9532 83 4 these these DT doi-org-9532 83 5 intuitions intuition NNS doi-org-9532 83 6 Proposition Proposition NNP doi-org-9532 83 7 A a NN doi-org-9532 83 8 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 83 9 activist activist NN doi-org-9532 83 10 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 83 11 and and CC doi-org-9532 83 12 Proposition Proposition NNP doi-org-9532 83 13 N N NNP doi-org-9532 83 14 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 83 15 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 83 16 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 83 17 . . . doi-org-9532 84 1 Proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 84 2 A a DT doi-org-9532 84 3 asserts assert VBZ doi-org-9532 84 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 84 5 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 84 6 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 84 7 to to TO doi-org-9532 84 8 do do VB doi-org-9532 84 9 everything everything NN doi-org-9532 84 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 84 11 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 84 12 power power NN doi-org-9532 84 13 to to TO doi-org-9532 84 14 prevent prevent VB doi-org-9532 84 15 injustice injustice NN doi-org-9532 84 16 regardless regardless RB doi-org-9532 84 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 84 18 whether whether IN doi-org-9532 84 19 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 84 20 started start VBD doi-org-9532 84 21 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 84 22 . . . doi-org-9532 85 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 85 2 witness witness NN doi-org-9532 85 3 who who WP doi-org-9532 85 4 fails fail VBZ doi-org-9532 85 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 85 6 prevent prevent VB doi-org-9532 85 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 85 8 crime crime NN doi-org-9532 85 9 when when WRB doi-org-9532 85 10 she -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 85 11 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 85 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 85 13 power power NN doi-org-9532 85 14 do do VBP doi-org-9532 85 15 so so RB doi-org-9532 85 16 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 85 17 almost almost RB doi-org-9532 85 18 as as RB doi-org-9532 85 19 culpable culpable JJ doi-org-9532 85 20 as as IN doi-org-9532 85 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 85 22 person person NN doi-org-9532 85 23 who who WP doi-org-9532 85 24 commits commit VBZ doi-org-9532 85 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 85 26 crime crime NN doi-org-9532 85 27 , , , doi-org-9532 85 28 in in IN doi-org-9532 85 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 85 30 eyes eye NNS doi-org-9532 85 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 85 32 most most JJS doi-org-9532 85 33 . . . doi-org-9532 86 1 And and CC doi-org-9532 86 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 86 3 more more JJR doi-org-9532 86 4 power power NN doi-org-9532 86 5 someone someone NN doi-org-9532 86 6 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 86 7 , , , doi-org-9532 86 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 86 9 more more JJR doi-org-9532 86 10 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 86 11 she -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 86 12 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 86 13 . . . doi-org-9532 87 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 87 2 trained trained JJ doi-org-9532 87 3 , , , doi-org-9532 87 4 gun gun NN doi-org-9532 87 5 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 87 6 carrying carry VBG doi-org-9532 87 7 policeman policeman NN doi-org-9532 87 8 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 87 9 greater great JJR doi-org-9532 87 10 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 87 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 87 12 stop stop VB doi-org-9532 87 13 a a DT doi-org-9532 87 14 mugging mugging NN doi-org-9532 87 15 than than IN doi-org-9532 87 16 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 87 17 a a DT doi-org-9532 87 18 frail frail NN doi-org-9532 87 19 , , , doi-org-9532 87 20 elderly elderly JJ doi-org-9532 87 21 citizen citizen NN doi-org-9532 87 22 . . . doi-org-9532 88 1 Bosses boss NNS doi-org-9532 88 2 have have VBP doi-org-9532 88 3 more more JJR doi-org-9532 88 4 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 88 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 88 6 limit limit VB doi-org-9532 88 7 injustice injustice NN doi-org-9532 88 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 88 9 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 88 10 organizations organization NNS doi-org-9532 88 11 than than IN doi-org-9532 88 12 do do VBP doi-org-9532 88 13 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 88 14 subordinates subordinate NNS doi-org-9532 88 15 . . . doi-org-9532 89 1 This this DT doi-org-9532 89 2 intuitive intuitive JJ doi-org-9532 89 3 sense sense NN doi-org-9532 89 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 89 5 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 89 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 89 7 fight fight VB doi-org-9532 89 8 injustice injustice NN doi-org-9532 89 9 initiated initiate VBN doi-org-9532 89 10 by by IN doi-org-9532 89 11 others other NNS doi-org-9532 89 12 — — : doi-org-9532 89 13 or or CC doi-org-9532 89 14 by by IN doi-org-9532 89 15 society society NN doi-org-9532 89 16 at at IN doi-org-9532 89 17 large large JJ doi-org-9532 89 18 — — : doi-org-9532 89 19 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 89 20 at at IN doi-org-9532 89 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 89 22 heart heart NN doi-org-9532 89 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 89 24 discontent discontent NN doi-org-9532 89 25 with with IN doi-org-9532 89 26 library library JJ doi-org-9532 89 27 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 89 28 . . . doi-org-9532 90 1 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 90 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 90 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 90 4 critics critic NNS doi-org-9532 90 5 , , , doi-org-9532 90 6 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 90 7 who who WP doi-org-9532 90 8 fail fail VBP doi-org-9532 90 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 90 10 use use VB doi-org-9532 90 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 90 12 influence influence NN doi-org-9532 90 13 conferred confer VBN doi-org-9532 90 14 on on IN doi-org-9532 90 15 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 90 16 by by IN doi-org-9532 90 17 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 90 18 education education NN doi-org-9532 90 19 and and CC doi-org-9532 90 20 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 90 21 social social JJ doi-org-9532 90 22 status status NN doi-org-9532 90 23 to to TO doi-org-9532 90 24 reduce reduce VB doi-org-9532 90 25 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 90 26 social social JJ doi-org-9532 90 27 injustice injustice NN doi-org-9532 90 28 are be VBP doi-org-9532 90 29 as as RB doi-org-9532 90 30 culpable culpable JJ doi-org-9532 90 31 as as IN doi-org-9532 90 32 witnesses witness NNS doi-org-9532 90 33 who who WP doi-org-9532 90 34 do do VBP doi-org-9532 90 35 nothing nothing NN doi-org-9532 90 36 to to TO doi-org-9532 90 37 stop stop VB doi-org-9532 90 38 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 90 39 crimes crime NNS doi-org-9532 90 40 . . . doi-org-9532 91 1 Proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 91 2 N N NNP doi-org-9532 91 3 asserts assert VBZ doi-org-9532 91 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 91 5 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 91 6 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 91 7 wrong wrong JJ doi-org-9532 91 8 for for IN doi-org-9532 91 9 someone someone NN doi-org-9532 91 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 91 11 a a DT doi-org-9532 91 12 position position NN doi-org-9532 91 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 91 14 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 91 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 91 16 impose impose VB doi-org-9532 91 17 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 91 18 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 91 19 values value NNS doi-org-9532 91 20 on on IN doi-org-9532 91 21 others other NNS doi-org-9532 91 22 . . . doi-org-9532 92 1 Most Most JJS doi-org-9532 92 2 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 92 3 in in IN doi-org-9532 92 4 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 92 5 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 92 6 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 92 7 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 92 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 92 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 92 10 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 92 11 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 92 12 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 92 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 92 14 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 92 15 fellow fellow JJ doi-org-9532 92 16 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 92 17 . . . doi-org-9532 93 1 Government government NN doi-org-9532 93 2 officials official NNS doi-org-9532 93 3 should should MD doi-org-9532 93 4 not not RB doi-org-9532 93 5 censor censor VB doi-org-9532 93 6 political political JJ doi-org-9532 93 7 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 93 8 that that WDT doi-org-9532 93 9 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 93 10 disagree disagree VBP doi-org-9532 93 11 with with IN doi-org-9532 93 12 . . . doi-org-9532 94 1 Bosses boss NNS doi-org-9532 94 2 should should MD doi-org-9532 94 3 not not RB doi-org-9532 94 4 impose impose VB doi-org-9532 94 5 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 94 6 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 94 7 on on IN doi-org-9532 94 8 employees employee NNS doi-org-9532 94 9 . . . doi-org-9532 95 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 95 2 desire desire NN doi-org-9532 95 3 to to TO doi-org-9532 95 4 respect respect VB doi-org-9532 95 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 95 6 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 95 7 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 95 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 95 9 all all DT doi-org-9532 95 10 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 95 11 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 95 12 at at IN doi-org-9532 95 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 95 14 heart heart NN doi-org-9532 95 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 95 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 95 17 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 95 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 95 19 library library JJ doi-org-9532 95 20 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 95 21 . . . doi-org-9532 96 1 When when WRB doi-org-9532 96 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 96 3 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 96 4 to to TO doi-org-9532 96 5 Read read VB doi-org-9532 96 6 Statement Statement NNP doi-org-9532 96 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 96 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 96 9 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 96 10 says say VBZ doi-org-9532 96 11 that that IN doi-org-9532 96 12 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 96 13 " " `` doi-org-9532 96 14 do do VBP doi-org-9532 96 15 not not RB doi-org-9532 96 16 foster foster VB doi-org-9532 96 17 education education NN doi-org-9532 96 18 by by IN doi-org-9532 96 19 imposing impose VBG doi-org-9532 96 20 as as IN doi-org-9532 96 21 mentors mentor NNS doi-org-9532 96 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 96 23 patterns pattern NNS doi-org-9532 96 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 96 25 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 96 26 own own JJ doi-org-9532 96 27 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 96 28 , , , doi-org-9532 96 29 " " '' doi-org-9532 96 30 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 96 31 asks ask VBZ doi-org-9532 96 32 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 96 33 to to TO doi-org-9532 96 34 respect respect VB doi-org-9532 96 35 the the DT doi-org-9532 96 36 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 96 37 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 96 38 of of IN doi-org-9532 96 39 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 96 40 patrons.21 patrons.21 NNP doi-org-9532 96 41 Instead instead RB doi-org-9532 96 42 of of IN doi-org-9532 96 43 serving serve VBG doi-org-9532 96 44 as as IN doi-org-9532 96 45 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 96 46 educators educator NNS doi-org-9532 96 47 , , , doi-org-9532 96 48 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 96 49 provide provide VBP doi-org-9532 96 50 information information NN doi-org-9532 96 51 that that WDT doi-org-9532 96 52 allows allow VBZ doi-org-9532 96 53 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 96 54 to to TO doi-org-9532 96 55 make make VB doi-org-9532 96 56 up up RP doi-org-9532 96 57 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 96 58 own own JJ doi-org-9532 96 59 minds mind NNS doi-org-9532 96 60 . . . doi-org-9532 97 1 When when WRB doi-org-9532 97 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 97 3 overall overall JJ doi-org-9532 97 4 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 97 5 worldview worldview NN doi-org-9532 97 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 97 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 97 8 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 97 9 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 97 10 largely largely RB doi-org-9532 97 11 in in IN doi-org-9532 97 12 harmony harmony NN doi-org-9532 97 13 with with IN doi-org-9532 97 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 97 15 worldview worldview NN doi-org-9532 97 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 97 17 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 97 18 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 97 19 , , , doi-org-9532 97 20 propositions proposition VBZ doi-org-9532 97 21 A a NN doi-org-9532 97 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 97 23 N n NN doi-org-9532 97 24 usually usually RB doi-org-9532 97 25 are be VBP doi-org-9532 97 26 compatible compatible JJ doi-org-9532 97 27 with with IN doi-org-9532 97 28 each each DT doi-org-9532 97 29 other other JJ doi-org-9532 97 30 . . . doi-org-9532 98 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 98 2 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 98 3 comes come VBZ doi-org-9532 98 4 when when WRB doi-org-9532 98 5 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 98 6 encounter encounter VBP doi-org-9532 98 7 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 98 8 whose whose WP$ doi-org-9532 98 9 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 98 10 ends end NNS doi-org-9532 98 11 are be VBP doi-org-9532 98 12 fundamentally fundamentally RB doi-org-9532 98 13 at at IN doi-org-9532 98 14 odds odd NNS doi-org-9532 98 15 with with IN doi-org-9532 98 16 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 98 17 own own JJ doi-org-9532 98 18 . . . doi-org-9532 99 1 Then then RB doi-org-9532 99 2 , , , doi-org-9532 99 3 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 99 4 often often RB doi-org-9532 99 5 seems seem VBZ doi-org-9532 99 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 99 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 99 8 best good JJS doi-org-9532 99 9 way way NN doi-org-9532 99 10 for for IN doi-org-9532 99 11 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 99 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 99 13 use use VB doi-org-9532 99 14 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 99 15 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 99 16 to to TO doi-org-9532 99 17 prevent prevent VB doi-org-9532 99 18 injustice injustice NN doi-org-9532 99 19 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 99 20 to to TO doi-org-9532 99 21 use use VB doi-org-9532 99 22 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 99 23 influence influence NN doi-org-9532 99 24 to to TO doi-org-9532 99 25 impose impose VB doi-org-9532 99 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 99 27 " " `` doi-org-9532 99 28 patterns pattern NNS doi-org-9532 99 29 of of IN doi-org-9532 99 30 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 99 31 own own JJ doi-org-9532 99 32 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 99 33 " " '' doi-org-9532 99 34 on on IN doi-org-9532 99 35 the the DT doi-org-9532 99 36 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 99 37 . . . doi-org-9532 100 1 Thus thus RB doi-org-9532 100 2 , , , doi-org-9532 100 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 100 4 only only JJ doi-org-9532 100 5 way way NN doi-org-9532 100 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 100 7 accomplish accomplish VB doi-org-9532 100 8 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 100 9 A A NNP doi-org-9532 100 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 100 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 100 12 violate violate VB doi-org-9532 100 13 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 100 14 N n NN doi-org-9532 100 15 , , , doi-org-9532 100 16 or or CC doi-org-9532 100 17 vice vice NN doi-org-9532 100 18 versa versa RB doi-org-9532 100 19 . . . doi-org-9532 101 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 101 2 few few JJ doi-org-9532 101 3 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 101 4 experiments experiment NNS doi-org-9532 101 5 illustrate illustrate VBP doi-org-9532 101 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 101 7 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 101 8 . . . doi-org-9532 102 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 102 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 102 3 Page page NN doi-org-9532 102 4 60 60 CD doi-org-9532 102 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 102 6 Scenario Scenario NNP doi-org-9532 102 7 A A NNP doi-org-9532 102 8 As as IN doi-org-9532 102 9 a a DT doi-org-9532 102 10 history history NN doi-org-9532 102 11 major major NN doi-org-9532 102 12 in in IN doi-org-9532 102 13 college college NN doi-org-9532 102 14 , , , doi-org-9532 102 15 librarian librarian NNP doi-org-9532 102 16 A a DT doi-org-9532 102 17 developed develop VBD doi-org-9532 102 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 102 19 conviction conviction NN doi-org-9532 102 20 that that IN doi-org-9532 102 21 socialism socialism NN doi-org-9532 102 22 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 102 23 a a DT doi-org-9532 102 24 delusionary delusionary JJ doi-org-9532 102 25 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 102 26 that that WDT doi-org-9532 102 27 leads lead VBZ doi-org-9532 102 28 to to IN doi-org-9532 102 29 social social JJ doi-org-9532 102 30 evil evil NN doi-org-9532 102 31 . . . doi-org-9532 103 1 After after IN doi-org-9532 103 2 studying study VBG doi-org-9532 103 3 several several JJ doi-org-9532 103 4 socialist socialist JJ doi-org-9532 103 5 revolutions revolution NNS doi-org-9532 103 6 that that WDT doi-org-9532 103 7 resulted result VBD doi-org-9532 103 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 103 9 authoritarian authoritarian JJ doi-org-9532 103 10 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 103 11 , , , doi-org-9532 103 12 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 103 13 became become VBD doi-org-9532 103 14 convinced convinced JJ doi-org-9532 103 15 that that IN doi-org-9532 103 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 103 17 quixotic quixotic JJ doi-org-9532 103 18 dreams dream NNS doi-org-9532 103 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 103 20 socialism socialism NN doi-org-9532 103 21 are be VBP doi-org-9532 103 22 based base VBN doi-org-9532 103 23 on on IN doi-org-9532 103 24 a a DT doi-org-9532 103 25 false false JJ doi-org-9532 103 26 understanding understanding NN doi-org-9532 103 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 103 28 human human JJ doi-org-9532 103 29 nature nature NN doi-org-9532 103 30 that that WDT doi-org-9532 103 31 always always RB doi-org-9532 103 32 leads lead VBZ doi-org-9532 103 33 to to IN doi-org-9532 103 34 tragedy tragedy NN doi-org-9532 103 35 . . . doi-org-9532 104 1 Patron Patron NNP doi-org-9532 104 2 A A NNP doi-org-9532 104 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 104 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 104 5 doorman doorman NN doi-org-9532 104 6 at at IN doi-org-9532 104 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 104 8 luxury luxury NN doi-org-9532 104 9 hotel hotel NN doi-org-9532 104 10 who who WP doi-org-9532 104 11 comes come VBZ doi-org-9532 104 12 to to IN doi-org-9532 104 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 104 14 library library NN doi-org-9532 104 15 with with IN doi-org-9532 104 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 104 17 conviction conviction NN doi-org-9532 104 18 — — : doi-org-9532 104 19 based base VBN doi-org-9532 104 20 on on IN doi-org-9532 104 21 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 104 22 experience experience NN doi-org-9532 104 23 with with IN doi-org-9532 104 24 employers employer NNS doi-org-9532 104 25 who who WP doi-org-9532 104 26 have have VBP doi-org-9532 104 27 exploited exploit VBN doi-org-9532 104 28 him -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 104 29 and and CC doi-org-9532 104 30 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 104 31 daily daily JJ doi-org-9532 104 32 observation observation NN doi-org-9532 104 33 of of IN doi-org-9532 104 34 the the DT doi-org-9532 104 35 extremes extreme NNS doi-org-9532 104 36 of of IN doi-org-9532 104 37 wealth wealth NN doi-org-9532 104 38 and and CC doi-org-9532 104 39 poverty poverty NN doi-org-9532 104 40 in in IN doi-org-9532 104 41 front front NN doi-org-9532 104 42 of of IN doi-org-9532 104 43 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 104 44 hotel hotel NN doi-org-9532 104 45 — — : doi-org-9532 104 46 that that IN doi-org-9532 104 47 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 104 48 social social JJ doi-org-9532 104 49 order order NN doi-org-9532 104 50 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 104 51 deeply deeply RB doi-org-9532 104 52 immoral immoral JJ doi-org-9532 104 53 . . . doi-org-9532 105 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 105 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 105 3 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 105 4 interview interview NN doi-org-9532 105 5 , , , doi-org-9532 105 6 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 105 7 A a DT doi-org-9532 105 8 expresses express VBZ doi-org-9532 105 9 a a DT doi-org-9532 105 10 desire desire NN doi-org-9532 105 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 105 12 read read VB doi-org-9532 105 13 Das Das NNP doi-org-9532 105 14 Kapital Kapital NNP doi-org-9532 105 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 105 16 similar similar JJ doi-org-9532 105 17 types type NNS doi-org-9532 105 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 105 19 socialist socialist JJ doi-org-9532 105 20 literature literature NN doi-org-9532 105 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 105 22 better well RBR doi-org-9532 105 23 understand understand VB doi-org-9532 105 24 what what WP doi-org-9532 105 25 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 105 26 wrong wrong JJ doi-org-9532 105 27 with with IN doi-org-9532 105 28 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 105 29 society society NN doi-org-9532 105 30 . . . doi-org-9532 106 1 During during IN doi-org-9532 106 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 106 3 interview interview NN doi-org-9532 106 4 , , , doi-org-9532 106 5 librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 106 6 A a DT doi-org-9532 106 7 struggles struggle NNS doi-org-9532 106 8 with with IN doi-org-9532 106 9 a a DT doi-org-9532 106 10 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 106 11 . . . doi-org-9532 107 1 By by IN doi-org-9532 107 2 helping help VBG doi-org-9532 107 3 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 107 4 A a DT doi-org-9532 107 5 access access NN doi-org-9532 107 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 107 7 writings writing NNS doi-org-9532 107 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 107 9 Marxist marxist JJ doi-org-9532 107 10 theorists theorist NNS doi-org-9532 107 11 , , , doi-org-9532 107 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 107 13 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 107 14 would would MD doi-org-9532 107 15 contribute contribute VB doi-org-9532 107 16 to to IN doi-org-9532 107 17 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 107 18 miseducation miseducation NN doi-org-9532 107 19 . . . doi-org-9532 108 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 108 2 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 108 3 knows know VBZ doi-org-9532 108 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 108 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 108 6 material material NN doi-org-9532 108 7 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 108 8 flawed flawed JJ doi-org-9532 108 9 but but CC doi-org-9532 108 10 will will MD doi-org-9532 108 11 be be VB doi-org-9532 108 12 seductive seductive JJ doi-org-9532 108 13 to to IN doi-org-9532 108 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 108 15 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 108 16 in in IN doi-org-9532 108 17 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 108 18 current current JJ doi-org-9532 108 19 frame frame NN doi-org-9532 108 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 108 21 mind mind NN doi-org-9532 108 22 . . . doi-org-9532 109 1 What what WP doi-org-9532 109 2 if if IN doi-org-9532 109 3 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 109 4 A a NN doi-org-9532 109 5 — — : doi-org-9532 109 6 enticed entice VBN doi-org-9532 109 7 by by IN doi-org-9532 109 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 109 9 fantasies fantasy NNS doi-org-9532 109 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 109 11 socialism socialism NN doi-org-9532 109 12 — — : doi-org-9532 109 13 inspires inspire VBZ doi-org-9532 109 14 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 109 15 friends friend NNS doi-org-9532 109 16 to to TO doi-org-9532 109 17 engage engage VB doi-org-9532 109 18 in in IN doi-org-9532 109 19 protests protest NNS doi-org-9532 109 20 that that WDT doi-org-9532 109 21 lead lead VBP doi-org-9532 109 22 to to IN doi-org-9532 109 23 unnecessary unnecessary JJ doi-org-9532 109 24 pain pain NN doi-org-9532 109 25 and and CC doi-org-9532 109 26 suffering suffering NN doi-org-9532 109 27 ? ? . doi-org-9532 110 1 But but CC doi-org-9532 110 2 if if IN doi-org-9532 110 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 110 4 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 110 5 nudges nudge VBZ doi-org-9532 110 6 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 110 7 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 110 8 toward toward IN doi-org-9532 110 9 sound sound JJ doi-org-9532 110 10 political political JJ doi-org-9532 110 11 conclusions conclusion NNS doi-org-9532 110 12 by by IN doi-org-9532 110 13 warning warn VBG doi-org-9532 110 14 him -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 110 15 about about IN doi-org-9532 110 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 110 17 errors error NNS doi-org-9532 110 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 110 19 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 110 20 chosen choose VBN doi-org-9532 110 21 authors author NNS doi-org-9532 110 22 or or CC doi-org-9532 110 23 by by IN doi-org-9532 110 24 directing direct VBG doi-org-9532 110 25 him -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 110 26 toward toward IN doi-org-9532 110 27 more more RBR doi-org-9532 110 28 accurate accurate JJ doi-org-9532 110 29 social social JJ doi-org-9532 110 30 theorists theorist NNS doi-org-9532 110 31 , , , doi-org-9532 110 32 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 110 33 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 110 34 violate violate VB doi-org-9532 110 35 the the DT doi-org-9532 110 36 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 110 37 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 110 38 of of IN doi-org-9532 110 39 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 110 40 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 110 41 ? ? . doi-org-9532 111 1 Scenario Scenario NNP doi-org-9532 111 2 B b NN doi-org-9532 111 3 Librarian Librarian NNP doi-org-9532 111 4 B B NNP doi-org-9532 111 5 recently recently RB doi-org-9532 111 6 graduated graduate VBD doi-org-9532 111 7 with with IN doi-org-9532 111 8 a a DT doi-org-9532 111 9 degree degree NN doi-org-9532 111 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 111 11 psychology psychology NN doi-org-9532 111 12 from from IN doi-org-9532 111 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 111 14 University University NNP doi-org-9532 111 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 111 16 California California NNP doi-org-9532 111 17 , , , doi-org-9532 111 18 Berkeley Berkeley NNP doi-org-9532 111 19 , , , doi-org-9532 111 20 where where WRB doi-org-9532 111 21 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 111 22 learned learn VBD doi-org-9532 111 23 that that IN doi-org-9532 111 24 homosexuality homosexuality NN doi-org-9532 111 25 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 111 26 a a DT doi-org-9532 111 27 natural natural JJ doi-org-9532 111 28 and and CC doi-org-9532 111 29 morally morally RB doi-org-9532 111 30 blameless blameless JJ doi-org-9532 111 31 form form NN doi-org-9532 111 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 111 33 human human JJ doi-org-9532 111 34 desire desire NN doi-org-9532 111 35 . . . doi-org-9532 112 1 Prompted prompt VBN doi-org-9532 112 2 by by IN doi-org-9532 112 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 112 4 experience experience NN doi-org-9532 112 5 of of IN doi-org-9532 112 6 a a DT doi-org-9532 112 7 close close JJ doi-org-9532 112 8 friend friend NN doi-org-9532 112 9 who who WP doi-org-9532 112 10 was be VBD doi-org-9532 112 11 forced force VBN doi-org-9532 112 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 112 13 go go VB doi-org-9532 112 14 through through IN doi-org-9532 112 15 conversion conversion NN doi-org-9532 112 16 therapy therapy NN doi-org-9532 112 17 as as IN doi-org-9532 112 18 a a DT doi-org-9532 112 19 teenager teenager NN doi-org-9532 112 20 , , , doi-org-9532 112 21 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 112 22 wrote write VBD doi-org-9532 112 23 a a DT doi-org-9532 112 24 paper paper NN doi-org-9532 112 25 on on IN doi-org-9532 112 26 conversion conversion NN doi-org-9532 112 27 therapy therapy NN doi-org-9532 112 28 demonstrating demonstrate VBG doi-org-9532 112 29 that that IN doi-org-9532 112 30 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 112 31 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 112 32 pseudoscientific pseudoscientific JJ doi-org-9532 112 33 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 112 34 that that WDT doi-org-9532 112 35 causes cause VBZ doi-org-9532 112 36 unnecessary unnecessary JJ doi-org-9532 112 37 suffering suffering NN doi-org-9532 112 38 for for IN doi-org-9532 112 39 those those DT doi-org-9532 112 40 forced force VBN doi-org-9532 112 41 to to TO doi-org-9532 112 42 endure endure VB doi-org-9532 112 43 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 112 44 . . . doi-org-9532 113 1 Patron Patron NNP doi-org-9532 113 2 B B NNP doi-org-9532 113 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 113 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 113 5 middle middle JJ doi-org-9532 113 6 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 113 7 aged aged JJ doi-org-9532 113 8 father father NN doi-org-9532 113 9 troubled trouble VBN doi-org-9532 113 10 by by IN doi-org-9532 113 11 homosexual homosexual JJ doi-org-9532 113 12 tendencies tendency NNS doi-org-9532 113 13 that that WDT doi-org-9532 113 14 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 113 15 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 113 16 observed observe VBN doi-org-9532 113 17 in in IN doi-org-9532 113 18 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 113 19 son son NN doi-org-9532 113 20 . . . doi-org-9532 114 1 His -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 114 2 son son NN doi-org-9532 114 3 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 114 4 not not RB doi-org-9532 114 5 yet yet RB doi-org-9532 114 6 come come VBN doi-org-9532 114 7 out out RP doi-org-9532 114 8 as as RB doi-org-9532 114 9 gay gay RB doi-org-9532 114 10 , , , doi-org-9532 114 11 but but CC doi-org-9532 114 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 114 13 father father NN doi-org-9532 114 14 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 114 15 worried worry VBN doi-org-9532 114 16 that that IN doi-org-9532 114 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 114 18 boy boy NN doi-org-9532 114 19 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 114 20 headed head VBN doi-org-9532 114 21 toward toward IN doi-org-9532 114 22 an an DT doi-org-9532 114 23 unhappy unhappy JJ doi-org-9532 114 24 life life NN doi-org-9532 114 25 of of IN doi-org-9532 114 26 social social JJ doi-org-9532 114 27 exclusion exclusion NN doi-org-9532 114 28 . . . doi-org-9532 115 1 Patron Patron NNP doi-org-9532 115 2 B B NNP doi-org-9532 115 3 recently recently RB doi-org-9532 115 4 heard hear VBD doi-org-9532 115 5 a a DT doi-org-9532 115 6 radio radio NN doi-org-9532 115 7 interview interview NN doi-org-9532 115 8 about about IN doi-org-9532 115 9 a a DT doi-org-9532 115 10 book book NN doi-org-9532 115 11 called call VBN doi-org-9532 115 12 A a DT doi-org-9532 115 13 Parent Parent NNP doi-org-9532 115 14 's 's POS doi-org-9532 115 15 Guide Guide NNP doi-org-9532 115 16 to to IN doi-org-9532 115 17 Preventing prevent VBG doi-org-9532 115 18 Homosexuality Homosexuality NNP doi-org-9532 115 19 by by IN doi-org-9532 115 20 Joseph Joseph NNP doi-org-9532 115 21 Nicolosi Nicolosi NNP doi-org-9532 115 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 115 23 wants want VBZ doi-org-9532 115 24 to to TO doi-org-9532 115 25 learn learn VB doi-org-9532 115 26 more more JJR doi-org-9532 115 27 about about IN doi-org-9532 115 28 reparative reparative JJ doi-org-9532 115 29 therapy therapy NN doi-org-9532 115 30 . . . doi-org-9532 116 1 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 116 2 asks ask VBZ doi-org-9532 116 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 116 4 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 116 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 116 6 help help VB doi-org-9532 116 7 him -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 116 8 find find VB doi-org-9532 116 9 Nicolosi Nicolosi NNP doi-org-9532 116 10 's 's POS doi-org-9532 116 11 book book NN doi-org-9532 116 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 116 13 others other NNS doi-org-9532 116 14 like like IN doi-org-9532 116 15 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 116 16 . . . doi-org-9532 117 1 During during IN doi-org-9532 117 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 117 3 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 117 4 interview interview NN doi-org-9532 117 5 , , , doi-org-9532 117 6 librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 117 7 B B NNP doi-org-9532 117 8 struggles struggle VBZ doi-org-9532 117 9 with with IN doi-org-9532 117 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 117 11 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 117 12 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 117 13 . . . doi-org-9532 118 1 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 118 2 knows know VBZ doi-org-9532 118 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 118 4 reparative reparative JJ doi-org-9532 118 5 therapy therapy NN doi-org-9532 118 6 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 118 7 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 118 8 , , , doi-org-9532 118 9 but but CC doi-org-9532 118 10 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 118 11 fears fear VBZ doi-org-9532 118 12 that that IN doi-org-9532 118 13 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 118 14 will will MD doi-org-9532 118 15 be be VB doi-org-9532 118 16 attractive attractive JJ doi-org-9532 118 17 to to IN doi-org-9532 118 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 118 19 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 118 20 in in IN doi-org-9532 118 21 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 118 22 current current JJ doi-org-9532 118 23 frame frame NN doi-org-9532 118 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 118 25 mind mind NN doi-org-9532 118 26 . . . doi-org-9532 119 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 119 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 119 3 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 119 4 simply simply RB doi-org-9532 119 5 helps help VBZ doi-org-9532 119 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 119 7 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 119 8 find find VB doi-org-9532 119 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 119 10 books book NNS doi-org-9532 119 11 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 119 12 wants want VBZ doi-org-9532 119 13 , , , doi-org-9532 119 14 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 119 15 may may MD doi-org-9532 119 16 encourage encourage VB doi-org-9532 119 17 a a DT doi-org-9532 119 18 course course NN doi-org-9532 119 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 119 20 action action NN doi-org-9532 119 21 that that WDT doi-org-9532 119 22 will will MD doi-org-9532 119 23 cause cause VB doi-org-9532 119 24 much much JJ doi-org-9532 119 25 suffering suffering NN doi-org-9532 119 26 for for IN doi-org-9532 119 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 119 28 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 119 29 's 's POS doi-org-9532 119 30 family family NN doi-org-9532 119 31 . . . doi-org-9532 120 1 However however RB doi-org-9532 120 2 , , , doi-org-9532 120 3 if if IN doi-org-9532 120 4 librarian librarian NNP doi-org-9532 120 5 B B NNP doi-org-9532 120 6 warns warn VBZ doi-org-9532 120 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 120 8 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 120 9 about about IN doi-org-9532 120 10 Nicolosi Nicolosi NNP doi-org-9532 120 11 's 's POS doi-org-9532 120 12 errors error NNS doi-org-9532 120 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 120 14 directs direct VBZ doi-org-9532 120 15 him -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 120 16 toward toward IN doi-org-9532 120 17 authors author NNS doi-org-9532 120 18 who who WP doi-org-9532 120 19 will will MD doi-org-9532 120 20 give give VB doi-org-9532 120 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 120 22 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 120 23 a a DT doi-org-9532 120 24 better well JJR doi-org-9532 120 25 understanding understanding NN doi-org-9532 120 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 120 27 what what WP doi-org-9532 120 28 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 120 29 son son NN doi-org-9532 120 30 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 120 31 experiencing experience VBG doi-org-9532 120 32 , , , doi-org-9532 120 33 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 120 34 librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 120 35 B B NNP doi-org-9532 120 36 using use VBG doi-org-9532 120 37 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 120 38 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 120 39 to to TO doi-org-9532 120 40 undermine undermine VB doi-org-9532 120 41 the the DT doi-org-9532 120 42 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 120 43 's 's POS doi-org-9532 120 44 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 120 45 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 120 46 and and CC doi-org-9532 120 47 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 120 48 ability ability NN doi-org-9532 120 49 to to TO doi-org-9532 120 50 develop develop VB doi-org-9532 120 51 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 120 52 own own JJ doi-org-9532 120 53 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 120 54 opinions opinion NNS doi-org-9532 120 55 ? ? . doi-org-9532 121 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 121 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 121 3 Page page NN doi-org-9532 121 4 61 61 CD doi-org-9532 121 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 121 6 Scenario Scenario NNP doi-org-9532 121 7 C c NN doi-org-9532 121 8 Librarian Librarian NNP doi-org-9532 121 9 C C NNP doi-org-9532 121 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 121 11 a a DT doi-org-9532 121 12 born bear VBN doi-org-9532 121 13 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 121 14 again again RB doi-org-9532 121 15 Christian Christian NNP doi-org-9532 121 16 who who WP doi-org-9532 121 17 suffered suffer VBD doi-org-9532 121 18 from from IN doi-org-9532 121 19 sexual sexual JJ doi-org-9532 121 20 confusion confusion NN doi-org-9532 121 21 until until IN doi-org-9532 121 22 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 121 23 had have VBD doi-org-9532 121 24 a a DT doi-org-9532 121 25 conversion conversion NN doi-org-9532 121 26 experience experience NN doi-org-9532 121 27 when when WRB doi-org-9532 121 28 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 121 29 was be VBD doi-org-9532 121 30 21 21 CD doi-org-9532 121 31 . . . doi-org-9532 122 1 His -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 122 2 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 122 3 values value NNS doi-org-9532 122 4 are be VBP doi-org-9532 122 5 based base VBN doi-org-9532 122 6 on on IN doi-org-9532 122 7 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 122 8 study study NN doi-org-9532 122 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 122 10 scripture scripture NN doi-org-9532 122 11 , , , doi-org-9532 122 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 122 13 guidance guidance NN doi-org-9532 122 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 122 15 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 122 16 pastor pastor NN doi-org-9532 122 17 , , , doi-org-9532 122 18 and and CC doi-org-9532 122 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 122 20 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 122 21 intuitions intuition NNS doi-org-9532 122 22 derived derive VBN doi-org-9532 122 23 from from IN doi-org-9532 122 24 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 122 25 close close JJ doi-org-9532 122 26 relationship relationship NN doi-org-9532 122 27 to to IN doi-org-9532 122 28 God God NNP doi-org-9532 122 29 . . . doi-org-9532 123 1 Librarian Librarian NNP doi-org-9532 123 2 C C NNP doi-org-9532 123 3 knows know VBZ doi-org-9532 123 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 123 5 giving give VBG doi-org-9532 123 6 in in RP doi-org-9532 123 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 123 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 123 9 type type NN doi-org-9532 123 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 123 11 homosexual homosexual JJ doi-org-9532 123 12 desires desire NNS doi-org-9532 123 13 that that WDT doi-org-9532 123 14 tormented torment VBD doi-org-9532 123 15 him -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 123 16 as as IN doi-org-9532 123 17 a a DT doi-org-9532 123 18 teenager teenager NN doi-org-9532 123 19 alienates alienate VBZ doi-org-9532 123 20 sinners sinner NNS doi-org-9532 123 21 from from IN doi-org-9532 123 22 God God NNP doi-org-9532 123 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 123 24 leads lead VBZ doi-org-9532 123 25 to to IN doi-org-9532 123 26 unnecessary unnecessary JJ doi-org-9532 123 27 suffering suffering NN doi-org-9532 123 28 both both CC doi-org-9532 123 29 in in IN doi-org-9532 123 30 this this DT doi-org-9532 123 31 life life NN doi-org-9532 123 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 123 33 the the DT doi-org-9532 123 34 next next JJ doi-org-9532 123 35 . . . doi-org-9532 124 1 Patron Patron NNP doi-org-9532 124 2 C C NNP doi-org-9532 124 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 124 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 124 5 15-year 15-year CD doi-org-9532 124 6 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 124 7 old old JJ doi-org-9532 124 8 boy boy NN doi-org-9532 124 9 who who WP doi-org-9532 124 10 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 124 11 been be VBN doi-org-9532 124 12 troubled trouble VBN doi-org-9532 124 13 by by IN doi-org-9532 124 14 increasingly increasingly RB doi-org-9532 124 15 strong strong JJ doi-org-9532 124 16 homosexual homosexual JJ doi-org-9532 124 17 fantasies fantasy NNS doi-org-9532 124 18 . . . doi-org-9532 125 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 125 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 125 3 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 125 4 interview interview NN doi-org-9532 125 5 , , , doi-org-9532 125 6 patron patron NNP doi-org-9532 125 7 C C NNP doi-org-9532 125 8 expresses express VBZ doi-org-9532 125 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 125 10 desire desire NN doi-org-9532 125 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 125 12 learn learn VB doi-org-9532 125 13 more more JJR doi-org-9532 125 14 about about IN doi-org-9532 125 15 where where WRB doi-org-9532 125 16 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 125 17 desires desire NNS doi-org-9532 125 18 come come VBP doi-org-9532 125 19 from from IN doi-org-9532 125 20 and and CC doi-org-9532 125 21 what what WP doi-org-9532 125 22 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 125 23 should should MD doi-org-9532 125 24 do do VB doi-org-9532 125 25 about about IN doi-org-9532 125 26 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 125 27 . . . doi-org-9532 126 1 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 126 2 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 126 3 been be VBN doi-org-9532 126 4 afraid afraid JJ doi-org-9532 126 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 126 6 talk talk VB doi-org-9532 126 7 with with IN doi-org-9532 126 8 anyone anyone NN doi-org-9532 126 9 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 126 10 knows know VBZ doi-org-9532 126 11 because because IN doi-org-9532 126 12 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 126 13 family family NN doi-org-9532 126 14 and and CC doi-org-9532 126 15 friends friend NNS doi-org-9532 126 16 disapprove disapprove NN doi-org-9532 126 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 126 18 homosexuality homosexuality NN doi-org-9532 126 19 . . . doi-org-9532 127 1 Somewhere somewhere RB doi-org-9532 127 2 , , , doi-org-9532 127 3 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 127 4 heard hear VBD doi-org-9532 127 5 about about IN doi-org-9532 127 6 book book NN doi-org-9532 127 7 called call VBN doi-org-9532 127 8 The the DT doi-org-9532 127 9 Survival Survival NNP doi-org-9532 127 10 Guide Guide NNP doi-org-9532 127 11 for for IN doi-org-9532 127 12 Queer Queer NNP doi-org-9532 127 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 127 14 Questioning Questioning NNP doi-org-9532 127 15 Teens Teens NNPS doi-org-9532 127 16 . . . doi-org-9532 128 1 Does do VBZ doi-org-9532 128 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 128 3 library library NN doi-org-9532 128 4 have have VB doi-org-9532 128 5 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 128 6 or or CC doi-org-9532 128 7 books book NNS doi-org-9532 128 8 like like IN doi-org-9532 128 9 that that DT doi-org-9532 128 10 ? ? . doi-org-9532 129 1 Librarian Librarian NNP doi-org-9532 129 2 C C NNP doi-org-9532 129 3 's 's POS doi-org-9532 129 4 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 129 5 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 129 6 like like IN doi-org-9532 129 7 that that DT doi-org-9532 129 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 129 9 librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 129 10 A A NNP doi-org-9532 129 11 or or CC doi-org-9532 129 12 B. B. NNP doi-org-9532 130 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 130 2 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 130 3 simply simply RB doi-org-9532 130 4 directs direct VBZ doi-org-9532 130 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 130 6 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 130 7 — — : doi-org-9532 130 8 without without IN doi-org-9532 130 9 warning warning NN doi-org-9532 130 10 — — : doi-org-9532 130 11 toward toward IN doi-org-9532 130 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 130 13 literature literature NN doi-org-9532 130 14 that that WDT doi-org-9532 130 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 130 16 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 130 17 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 130 18 requested request VBN doi-org-9532 130 19 , , , doi-org-9532 130 20 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 130 21 may may MD doi-org-9532 130 22 doom doom VB doi-org-9532 130 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 130 24 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 130 25 to to IN doi-org-9532 130 26 a a DT doi-org-9532 130 27 life life NN doi-org-9532 130 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 130 29 sin sin NN doi-org-9532 130 30 . . . doi-org-9532 131 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 131 2 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 131 3 knows know VBZ doi-org-9532 131 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 131 5 those those DT doi-org-9532 131 6 books book NNS doi-org-9532 131 7 are be VBP doi-org-9532 131 8 misleading misleading JJ doi-org-9532 131 9 , , , doi-org-9532 131 10 but but CC doi-org-9532 131 11 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 131 12 are be VBP doi-org-9532 131 13 likely likely JJ doi-org-9532 131 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 131 15 seduce seduce VB doi-org-9532 131 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 131 17 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 131 18 in in IN doi-org-9532 131 19 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 131 20 current current JJ doi-org-9532 131 21 frame frame NN doi-org-9532 131 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 131 23 mind mind NN doi-org-9532 131 24 . . . doi-org-9532 132 1 Does do VBZ doi-org-9532 132 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 132 3 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 132 4 's 's POS doi-org-9532 132 5 obligation obligation NN doi-org-9532 132 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 132 7 respect respect VB doi-org-9532 132 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 132 9 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 132 10 's 's POS doi-org-9532 132 11 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 132 12 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 132 13 take take VBP doi-org-9532 132 14 precedence precedence NN doi-org-9532 132 15 over over IN doi-org-9532 132 16 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 132 17 obligation obligation NN doi-org-9532 132 18 to to TO doi-org-9532 132 19 protect protect VB doi-org-9532 132 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 132 21 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 132 22 from from IN doi-org-9532 132 23 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 132 24 corruption corruption NN doi-org-9532 132 25 ? ? . doi-org-9532 133 1 Separation separation NN doi-org-9532 133 2 of of IN doi-org-9532 133 3 Spheres sphere NNS doi-org-9532 133 4 In in IN doi-org-9532 133 5 these these DT doi-org-9532 133 6 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 133 7 experiments experiment NNS doi-org-9532 133 8 , , , doi-org-9532 133 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 133 10 tension tension NN doi-org-9532 133 11 between between IN doi-org-9532 133 12 advocacy advocacy NN doi-org-9532 133 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 133 14 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 133 15 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 133 16 not not RB doi-org-9532 133 17 necessarily necessarily RB doi-org-9532 133 18 derive derive VB doi-org-9532 133 19 from from IN doi-org-9532 133 20 irrationality irrationality NN doi-org-9532 133 21 , , , doi-org-9532 133 22 dogmatism dogmatism NN doi-org-9532 133 23 , , , doi-org-9532 133 24 or or CC doi-org-9532 133 25 an an DT doi-org-9532 133 26 unwillingness unwillingness NN doi-org-9532 133 27 to to TO doi-org-9532 133 28 consider consider VB doi-org-9532 133 29 alternative alternative JJ doi-org-9532 133 30 points point NNS doi-org-9532 133 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 133 32 view view NN doi-org-9532 133 33 . . . doi-org-9532 134 1 It -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 134 2 comes come VBZ doi-org-9532 134 3 from from IN doi-org-9532 134 4 something something NN doi-org-9532 134 5 deeper deep JJR doi-org-9532 134 6 and and CC doi-org-9532 134 7 more more RBR doi-org-9532 134 8 profound profound JJ doi-org-9532 134 9 — — : doi-org-9532 134 10 from from IN doi-org-9532 134 11 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 134 12 society society NN doi-org-9532 134 13 's 's POS doi-org-9532 134 14 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 134 15 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 134 16 about about IN doi-org-9532 134 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 134 18 legitimacy legitimacy NN doi-org-9532 134 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 134 20 conflicting conflicting JJ doi-org-9532 134 21 systems system NNS doi-org-9532 134 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 134 23 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 134 24 value value NN doi-org-9532 134 25 in in IN doi-org-9532 134 26 which which WDT doi-org-9532 134 27 reasonable reasonable JJ doi-org-9532 134 28 people people NNS doi-org-9532 134 29 may may MD doi-org-9532 134 30 disagree disagree VB doi-org-9532 134 31 . . . doi-org-9532 135 1 Three three CD doi-org-9532 135 2 factors factor NNS doi-org-9532 135 3 lead lead VBP doi-org-9532 135 4 to to IN doi-org-9532 135 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 135 6 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 135 7 ' ' POS doi-org-9532 135 8 dilemmas dilemma NNS doi-org-9532 135 9 : : : doi-org-9532 135 10 1 1 CD doi-org-9532 135 11 . . . doi-org-9532 136 1 Moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 136 2 and and CC doi-org-9532 136 3 political political JJ doi-org-9532 136 4 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 136 5 matter matter NN doi-org-9532 136 6 . . . doi-org-9532 137 1 Is be VBZ doi-org-9532 137 2 socialism socialism NN doi-org-9532 137 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 137 4 utopian utopian JJ doi-org-9532 137 5 fantasy fantasy NN doi-org-9532 137 6 or or CC doi-org-9532 137 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 137 8 viable viable JJ doi-org-9532 137 9 political political JJ doi-org-9532 137 10 option option NN doi-org-9532 137 11 ? ? . doi-org-9532 138 1 Is be VBZ doi-org-9532 138 2 homosexuality homosexuality NN doi-org-9532 138 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 138 4 natural natural JJ doi-org-9532 138 5 form form NN doi-org-9532 138 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 138 7 sexual sexual JJ doi-org-9532 138 8 desire desire NN doi-org-9532 138 9 or or CC doi-org-9532 138 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 138 11 dangerous dangerous JJ doi-org-9532 138 12 perversion perversion NN doi-org-9532 138 13 ? ? . doi-org-9532 139 1 Actions action NNS doi-org-9532 139 2 based base VBN doi-org-9532 139 3 on on IN doi-org-9532 139 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 139 5 wrong wrong JJ doi-org-9532 139 6 answers answer NNS doi-org-9532 139 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 139 8 these these DT doi-org-9532 139 9 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 139 10 lead lead VB doi-org-9532 139 11 to to IN doi-org-9532 139 12 injustice injustice NN doi-org-9532 139 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 139 14 suffering suffering NN doi-org-9532 139 15 . . . doi-org-9532 140 1 2 2 LS doi-org-9532 140 2 . . . doi-org-9532 141 1 There there EX doi-org-9532 141 2 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 141 3 no no DT doi-org-9532 141 4 universal universal JJ doi-org-9532 141 5 agreement agreement NN doi-org-9532 141 6 about about IN doi-org-9532 141 7 what what WP doi-org-9532 141 8 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 141 9 morally morally RB doi-org-9532 141 10 good good JJ doi-org-9532 141 11 , , , doi-org-9532 141 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 141 13 there there EX doi-org-9532 141 14 probably probably RB doi-org-9532 141 15 never never RB doi-org-9532 141 16 will will MD doi-org-9532 141 17 be be VB doi-org-9532 141 18 . . . doi-org-9532 142 1 As as IN doi-org-9532 142 2 one one CD doi-org-9532 142 3 social social JJ doi-org-9532 142 4 theorist theorist NN doi-org-9532 142 5 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 142 6 argued argue VBN doi-org-9532 142 7 : : : doi-org-9532 142 8 " " `` doi-org-9532 142 9 Many many JJ doi-org-9532 142 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 142 11 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 142 12 deepest deep JJS doi-org-9532 142 13 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 142 14 and and CC doi-org-9532 142 15 metaphysical metaphysical JJ doi-org-9532 142 16 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 142 17 , , , doi-org-9532 142 18 like like IN doi-org-9532 142 19 how how WRB doi-org-9532 142 20 to to TO doi-org-9532 142 21 live live VB doi-org-9532 142 22 a a DT doi-org-9532 142 23 good good JJ doi-org-9532 142 24 life life NN doi-org-9532 142 25 or or CC doi-org-9532 142 26 which which WDT doi-org-9532 142 27 God God NNP doi-org-9532 142 28 to to TO doi-org-9532 142 29 worship worship VB doi-org-9532 142 30 , , , doi-org-9532 142 31 are be VBP doi-org-9532 142 32 inherently inherently RB doi-org-9532 142 33 contestable contestable JJ doi-org-9532 142 34 — — : doi-org-9532 142 35 reasonable reasonable JJ doi-org-9532 142 36 people people NNS doi-org-9532 142 37 can can MD doi-org-9532 142 38 and and CC doi-org-9532 142 39 will will MD doi-org-9532 142 40 disagree disagree VB doi-org-9532 142 41 . . . doi-org-9532 143 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 143 2 22 22 CD doi-org-9532 143 3 3 3 CD doi-org-9532 143 4 . . . doi-org-9532 144 1 Librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 144 2 serve serve VBP doi-org-9532 144 3 as as IN doi-org-9532 144 4 an an DT doi-org-9532 144 5 interface interface NN doi-org-9532 144 6 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 144 7 gatekeeper gatekeeper NN doi-org-9532 144 8 ? ? . doi-org-9532 144 9 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 145 1 between between IN doi-org-9532 145 2 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 145 3 and and CC doi-org-9532 145 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 145 5 information information NN doi-org-9532 145 6 that that WDT doi-org-9532 145 7 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 145 8 seek seek VBP doi-org-9532 145 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 145 10 develop develop VB doi-org-9532 145 11 and and CC doi-org-9532 145 12 defend defend VB doi-org-9532 145 13 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 145 14 values value NNS doi-org-9532 145 15 . . . doi-org-9532 146 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 146 2 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 146 3 comes come VBZ doi-org-9532 146 4 from from IN doi-org-9532 146 5 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 146 6 official official JJ doi-org-9532 146 7 role role NN doi-org-9532 146 8 as as IN doi-org-9532 146 9 mediators mediator NNS doi-org-9532 146 10 between between IN doi-org-9532 146 11 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 146 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 146 13 organized organized JJ doi-org-9532 146 14 collections collection NNS doi-org-9532 146 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 146 16 evidence evidence NN doi-org-9532 146 17 that that WDT doi-org-9532 146 18 support support VBP doi-org-9532 146 19 different different JJ doi-org-9532 146 20 points point NNS doi-org-9532 146 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 146 22 view view NN doi-org-9532 146 23 . . . doi-org-9532 147 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 147 2 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 147 3 choose choose VBP doi-org-9532 147 4 , , , doi-org-9532 147 5 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 147 6 can can MD doi-org-9532 147 7 use use VB doi-org-9532 147 8 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 147 9 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 147 10 to to TO doi-org-9532 147 11 favor favor VB doi-org-9532 147 12 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 147 13 own own JJ doi-org-9532 147 14 views view NNS doi-org-9532 147 15 at at IN doi-org-9532 147 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 147 17 expense expense NN doi-org-9532 147 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 147 19 alternatives alternative NNS doi-org-9532 147 20 . . . doi-org-9532 148 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 148 2 influence influence NN doi-org-9532 148 3 derives derive VBZ doi-org-9532 148 4 from from IN doi-org-9532 148 5 several several JJ doi-org-9532 148 6 aspects aspect NNS doi-org-9532 148 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 148 8 library library NN doi-org-9532 148 9 work work NN doi-org-9532 148 10 : : : doi-org-9532 148 11 a. a. NN doi-org-9532 149 1 As as IN doi-org-9532 149 2 in in IN doi-org-9532 149 3 my -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 149 4 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 149 5 experiments experiment NNS doi-org-9532 149 6 , , , doi-org-9532 149 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 149 8 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 149 9 interview interview NN doi-org-9532 149 10 gives give VBZ doi-org-9532 149 11 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 149 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 149 13 chance chance NN doi-org-9532 149 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 149 15 guide guide VB doi-org-9532 149 16 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 149 17 to to IN doi-org-9532 149 18 data datum NNS doi-org-9532 149 19 and and CC doi-org-9532 149 20 arguments argument NNS doi-org-9532 149 21 consistent consistent JJ doi-org-9532 149 22 with with IN doi-org-9532 149 23 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 149 24 own own JJ doi-org-9532 149 25 views view NNS doi-org-9532 149 26 . . . doi-org-9532 150 1 b. b. NNP doi-org-9532 151 1 Collection collection NN doi-org-9532 151 2 and and CC doi-org-9532 151 3 preservation preservation NN doi-org-9532 151 4 decisions decision NNS doi-org-9532 151 5 can can MD doi-org-9532 151 6 favor favor VB doi-org-9532 151 7 information information NN doi-org-9532 151 8 consistent consistent JJ doi-org-9532 151 9 with with IN doi-org-9532 151 10 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 151 11 own own JJ doi-org-9532 151 12 values value NNS doi-org-9532 151 13 . . . doi-org-9532 152 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 152 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 152 3 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 152 4 62 62 CD doi-org-9532 152 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 152 6 c. c. NN doi-org-9532 152 7 Metadata Metadata NNP doi-org-9532 152 8 created create VBN doi-org-9532 152 9 by by IN doi-org-9532 152 10 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 152 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 152 12 organize organize VB doi-org-9532 152 13 collections collection NNS doi-org-9532 152 14 can can MD doi-org-9532 152 15 impose impose VB doi-org-9532 152 16 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 152 17 judgment judgment NN doi-org-9532 152 18 through through IN doi-org-9532 152 19 categorization categorization NN doi-org-9532 152 20 by by IN doi-org-9532 152 21 , , , doi-org-9532 152 22 for for IN doi-org-9532 152 23 example example NN doi-org-9532 152 24 , , , doi-org-9532 152 25 labeling label VBG doi-org-9532 152 26 some some DT doi-org-9532 152 27 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 152 28 communities community NNS doi-org-9532 152 29 as as IN doi-org-9532 152 30 cults cult NNS doi-org-9532 152 31 or or CC doi-org-9532 152 32 some some DT doi-org-9532 152 33 forms form NNS doi-org-9532 152 34 of of IN doi-org-9532 152 35 sexual sexual JJ doi-org-9532 152 36 desire desire NN doi-org-9532 152 37 as as IN doi-org-9532 152 38 psychological psychological JJ doi-org-9532 152 39 disorders.23 disorders.23 NNP doi-org-9532 152 40 d. d. NNP doi-org-9532 152 41 Search Search NNP doi-org-9532 152 42 algorithms algorithm NNS doi-org-9532 152 43 created create VBD doi-org-9532 152 44 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 152 45 or or CC doi-org-9532 152 46 adopted adopt VBN doi-org-9532 152 47 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 152 48 by by IN doi-org-9532 152 49 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 152 50 can can MD doi-org-9532 152 51 make make VB doi-org-9532 152 52 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 152 53 easier easy JJR doi-org-9532 152 54 to to TO doi-org-9532 152 55 find find VB doi-org-9532 152 56 information information NN doi-org-9532 152 57 consistent consistent JJ doi-org-9532 152 58 with with IN doi-org-9532 152 59 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 152 60 own own JJ doi-org-9532 152 61 values value NNS doi-org-9532 152 62 and and CC doi-org-9532 152 63 harder hard JJR doi-org-9532 152 64 to to TO doi-org-9532 152 65 find find VB doi-org-9532 152 66 evidence evidence NN doi-org-9532 152 67 that that WDT doi-org-9532 152 68 challenges challenge VBZ doi-org-9532 152 69 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 152 70 biases.24 biases.24 NNP doi-org-9532 152 71 So so RB doi-org-9532 152 72 , , , doi-org-9532 152 73 when when WRB doi-org-9532 152 74 and and CC doi-org-9532 152 75 how how WRB doi-org-9532 152 76 should should MD doi-org-9532 152 77 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 152 78 use use VB doi-org-9532 152 79 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 152 80 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 152 81 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 152 82 to to TO doi-org-9532 152 83 direct direct VB doi-org-9532 152 84 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 152 85 to to IN doi-org-9532 152 86 the the DT doi-org-9532 152 87 correct correct JJ doi-org-9532 152 88 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 152 89 views view NNS doi-org-9532 152 90 as as IN doi-org-9532 152 91 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 152 92 see see VBP doi-org-9532 152 93 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 152 94 ? ? . doi-org-9532 153 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 153 2 there there EX doi-org-9532 153 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 153 4 no no DT doi-org-9532 153 5 systematic systematic JJ doi-org-9532 153 6 theoretical theoretical JJ doi-org-9532 153 7 resolution resolution NN doi-org-9532 153 8 to to IN doi-org-9532 153 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 153 10 conflict conflict NN doi-org-9532 153 11 between between IN doi-org-9532 153 12 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 153 13 A a NN doi-org-9532 153 14 and and CC doi-org-9532 153 15 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 153 16 N. n. NN doi-org-9532 153 17 In in IN doi-org-9532 153 18 practice practice NN doi-org-9532 153 19 , , , doi-org-9532 153 20 most most JJS doi-org-9532 153 21 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 153 22 will will MD doi-org-9532 153 23 be be VB doi-org-9532 153 24 guided guide VBN doi-org-9532 153 25 by by IN doi-org-9532 153 26 intuition intuition NN doi-org-9532 153 27 and and CC doi-org-9532 153 28 experience experience NN doi-org-9532 153 29 when when WRB doi-org-9532 153 30 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 153 31 encounter encounter VBP doi-org-9532 153 32 these these DT doi-org-9532 153 33 dilemmas dilemma NNS doi-org-9532 153 34 in in IN doi-org-9532 153 35 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 153 36 work work NN doi-org-9532 153 37 . . . doi-org-9532 154 1 Can Can MD doi-org-9532 154 2 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 154 3 go go VB doi-org-9532 154 4 beyond beyond IN doi-org-9532 154 5 that that DT doi-org-9532 154 6 ? ? . doi-org-9532 155 1 Can Can MD doi-org-9532 155 2 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 155 3 determine determine VB doi-org-9532 155 4 if if IN doi-org-9532 155 5 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 155 6 A a NN doi-org-9532 155 7 or or CC doi-org-9532 155 8 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 155 9 N n CC doi-org-9532 155 10 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 155 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 155 12 have have VB doi-org-9532 155 13 priority priority NN doi-org-9532 155 14 when when WRB doi-org-9532 155 15 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 155 16 come come VBP doi-org-9532 155 17 into into IN doi-org-9532 155 18 conflict conflict NN doi-org-9532 155 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 155 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 155 21 work work NN doi-org-9532 155 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 155 23 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 155 24 ? ? . doi-org-9532 156 1 That that IN doi-org-9532 156 2 , , , doi-org-9532 156 3 to to IN doi-org-9532 156 4 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 156 5 , , , doi-org-9532 156 6 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 156 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 156 8 deep deep JJ doi-org-9532 156 9 question question NN doi-org-9532 156 10 at at IN doi-org-9532 156 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 156 12 heart heart NN doi-org-9532 156 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 156 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 156 15 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 156 16 about about IN doi-org-9532 156 17 library library JJ doi-org-9532 156 18 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 156 19 . . . doi-org-9532 157 1 Despite despite IN doi-org-9532 157 2 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 157 3 's 's POS doi-org-9532 157 4 hyperbole hyperbole NN doi-org-9532 157 5 , , , doi-org-9532 157 6 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 157 7 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 157 8 offers offer VBZ doi-org-9532 157 9 a a DT doi-org-9532 157 10 powerful powerful JJ doi-org-9532 157 11 means mean NNS doi-org-9532 157 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 157 13 addressing address VBG doi-org-9532 157 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 157 15 dilemma dilemma NN doi-org-9532 157 16 through through IN doi-org-9532 157 17 a a DT doi-org-9532 157 18 strict strict JJ doi-org-9532 157 19 segregation segregation NN doi-org-9532 157 20 between between IN doi-org-9532 157 21 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 157 22 private private JJ doi-org-9532 157 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 157 24 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 157 25 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 157 26 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 157 27 . . . doi-org-9532 158 1 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 158 2 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 158 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 158 4 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 158 5 can can MD doi-org-9532 158 6 meet meet VB doi-org-9532 158 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 158 8 demands demand NNS doi-org-9532 158 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 158 10 both both DT doi-org-9532 158 11 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 158 12 A a NN doi-org-9532 158 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 158 14 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 158 15 N n NN doi-org-9532 158 16 by by IN doi-org-9532 158 17 applying apply VBG doi-org-9532 158 18 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 158 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 158 20 different different JJ doi-org-9532 158 21 spheres sphere NNS doi-org-9532 158 22 . . . doi-org-9532 159 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 159 2 In in IN doi-org-9532 159 3 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 159 4 private private JJ doi-org-9532 159 5 , , , doi-org-9532 159 6 personal personal JJ doi-org-9532 159 7 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 159 8 , , , doi-org-9532 159 9 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 159 10 exercise exercise VBP doi-org-9532 159 11 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 159 12 rights right NNS doi-org-9532 159 13 as as IN doi-org-9532 159 14 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 159 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 159 16 play play VB doi-org-9532 159 17 active active JJ doi-org-9532 159 18 roles role NNS doi-org-9532 159 19 as as IN doi-org-9532 159 20 partisan partisan JJ doi-org-9532 159 21 proponents proponent NNS doi-org-9532 159 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 159 23 supporters supporter NNS doi-org-9532 159 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 159 25 social social JJ doi-org-9532 159 26 , , , doi-org-9532 159 27 political political JJ doi-org-9532 159 28 , , , doi-org-9532 159 29 or or CC doi-org-9532 159 30 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 159 31 causes cause NNS doi-org-9532 159 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 159 33 organizations organization NNS doi-org-9532 159 34 . . . doi-org-9532 160 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 160 2 25 25 CD doi-org-9532 160 3 As as IN doi-org-9532 160 4 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 160 5 , , , doi-org-9532 160 6 family family NN doi-org-9532 160 7 members member NNS doi-org-9532 160 8 , , , doi-org-9532 160 9 and and CC doi-org-9532 160 10 friends friend NNS doi-org-9532 160 11 , , , doi-org-9532 160 12 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 160 13 A a DT doi-org-9532 160 14 takes take VBZ doi-org-9532 160 15 precedence precedence NN doi-org-9532 160 16 , , , doi-org-9532 160 17 and and CC doi-org-9532 160 18 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 160 19 should should MD doi-org-9532 160 20 use use VB doi-org-9532 160 21 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 160 22 influence influence NN doi-org-9532 160 23 to to TO doi-org-9532 160 24 fight fight VB doi-org-9532 160 25 for for IN doi-org-9532 160 26 social social JJ doi-org-9532 160 27 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 160 28 as as IN doi-org-9532 160 29 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 160 30 understand understand VBP doi-org-9532 160 31 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 160 32 . . . doi-org-9532 161 1 However however RB doi-org-9532 161 2 , , , doi-org-9532 161 3 as as IN doi-org-9532 161 4 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 161 5 , , , doi-org-9532 161 6 proposition proposition NN doi-org-9532 161 7 N n NN doi-org-9532 161 8 takes take VBZ doi-org-9532 161 9 precedence precedence NN doi-org-9532 161 10 : : : doi-org-9532 161 11 " " `` doi-org-9532 161 12 In in IN doi-org-9532 161 13 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 161 14 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 161 15 work work NN doi-org-9532 161 16 , , , doi-org-9532 161 17 which which WDT doi-org-9532 161 18 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 161 19 consider consider VBP doi-org-9532 161 20 a a DT doi-org-9532 161 21 part part NN doi-org-9532 161 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 161 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 161 24 communication communication NN doi-org-9532 161 25 system system NN doi-org-9532 161 26 by by IN doi-org-9532 161 27 which which WDT doi-org-9532 161 28 human human JJ doi-org-9532 161 29 beings being NNS doi-org-9532 161 30 maintain maintain VBP doi-org-9532 161 31 contact contact NN doi-org-9532 161 32 with with IN doi-org-9532 161 33 the the DT doi-org-9532 161 34 world world NN doi-org-9532 161 35 around around IN doi-org-9532 161 36 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 161 37 , , , doi-org-9532 161 38 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 161 39 maintain maintain VBP doi-org-9532 161 40 as as IN doi-org-9532 161 41 high high JJ doi-org-9532 161 42 a a DT doi-org-9532 161 43 degree degree NN doi-org-9532 161 44 of of IN doi-org-9532 161 45 impartiality impartiality NN doi-org-9532 161 46 and and CC doi-org-9532 161 47 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 161 48 as as IN doi-org-9532 161 49 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 161 50 humanly humanly RB doi-org-9532 161 51 possible possible JJ doi-org-9532 161 52 . . . doi-org-9532 162 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 162 2 26 26 CD doi-org-9532 162 3 For for IN doi-org-9532 162 4 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 162 5 , , , doi-org-9532 162 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 162 7 library library NN doi-org-9532 162 8 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 162 9 an an DT doi-org-9532 162 10 institution institution NN doi-org-9532 162 11 devoted devote VBN doi-org-9532 162 12 to to IN doi-org-9532 162 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 162 14 support support NN doi-org-9532 162 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 162 16 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 162 17 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 162 18 for for IN doi-org-9532 162 19 all all DT doi-org-9532 162 20 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 162 21 , , , doi-org-9532 162 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 162 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 162 24 goals goal NNS doi-org-9532 162 25 of of IN doi-org-9532 162 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 162 27 institution institution NN doi-org-9532 162 28 take take VBP doi-org-9532 162 29 precedence precedence NN doi-org-9532 162 30 over over IN doi-org-9532 162 31 the the DT doi-org-9532 162 32 private private JJ doi-org-9532 162 33 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 162 34 convictions conviction NNS doi-org-9532 162 35 of of IN doi-org-9532 162 36 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 162 37 in in IN doi-org-9532 162 38 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 162 39 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 162 40 work work NN doi-org-9532 162 41 . . . doi-org-9532 163 1 At at IN doi-org-9532 163 2 times time NNS doi-org-9532 163 3 , , , doi-org-9532 163 4 this this DT doi-org-9532 163 5 priority priority NN doi-org-9532 163 6 leads lead VBZ doi-org-9532 163 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 163 8 internal internal JJ doi-org-9532 163 9 conflict conflict NN doi-org-9532 163 10 because because IN doi-org-9532 163 11 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 163 12 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 163 13 commitments commitment NNS doi-org-9532 163 14 prevent prevent VBP doi-org-9532 163 15 us -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 163 16 from from IN doi-org-9532 163 17 performing perform VBG doi-org-9532 163 18 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 163 19 acts act NNS doi-org-9532 163 20 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 163 21 would would MD doi-org-9532 163 22 be be VB doi-org-9532 163 23 obligated obligate VBN doi-org-9532 163 24 to to TO doi-org-9532 163 25 perform perform VB doi-org-9532 163 26 in in IN doi-org-9532 163 27 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 163 28 private private JJ doi-org-9532 163 29 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 163 30 . . . doi-org-9532 164 1 However however RB doi-org-9532 164 2 , , , doi-org-9532 164 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 164 4 importance importance NN doi-org-9532 164 5 of of IN doi-org-9532 164 6 preserving preserve VBG doi-org-9532 164 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 164 8 long long JJ doi-org-9532 164 9 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 164 10 term term NN doi-org-9532 164 11 value value NN doi-org-9532 164 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 164 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 164 14 library library NN doi-org-9532 164 15 as as IN doi-org-9532 164 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 164 17 source source NN doi-org-9532 164 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 164 19 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 164 20 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 164 21 for for IN doi-org-9532 164 22 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 164 23 makes make VBZ doi-org-9532 164 24 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 164 25 restraint restraint NN doi-org-9532 164 26 worthwhile worthwhile NN doi-org-9532 164 27 . . . doi-org-9532 165 1 Although although IN doi-org-9532 165 2 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 165 3 strives strive VBZ doi-org-9532 165 4 to to TO doi-org-9532 165 5 provide provide VB doi-org-9532 165 6 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 165 7 clarity clarity NN doi-org-9532 165 8 , , , doi-org-9532 165 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 165 10 blunt blunt JJ doi-org-9532 165 11 alternative alternative NN doi-org-9532 165 12 that that IN doi-org-9532 165 13 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 165 14 offers offer VBZ doi-org-9532 165 15 between between IN doi-org-9532 165 16 social social JJ doi-org-9532 165 17 activism activism NN doi-org-9532 165 18 and and CC doi-org-9532 165 19 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 165 20 may may MD doi-org-9532 165 21 have have VB doi-org-9532 165 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 165 23 opposite opposite JJ doi-org-9532 165 24 effect effect NN doi-org-9532 165 25 for for IN doi-org-9532 165 26 many many JJ doi-org-9532 165 27 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 165 28 . . . doi-org-9532 166 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 166 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 166 3 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 166 4 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 166 5 of of IN doi-org-9532 166 6 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 166 7 requires require VBZ doi-org-9532 166 8 parking park VBG doi-org-9532 166 9 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 166 10 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 166 11 values value NNS doi-org-9532 166 12 outside outside IN doi-org-9532 166 13 every every DT doi-org-9532 166 14 time time NN doi-org-9532 166 15 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 166 16 go go VBP doi-org-9532 166 17 to to IN doi-org-9532 166 18 work work NN doi-org-9532 166 19 , , , doi-org-9532 166 20 maybe maybe RB doi-org-9532 166 21 something something NN doi-org-9532 166 22 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 166 23 wrong wrong JJ doi-org-9532 166 24 with with IN doi-org-9532 166 25 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 166 26 . . . doi-org-9532 167 1 Why why WRB doi-org-9532 167 2 should should MD doi-org-9532 167 3 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 167 4 restrict restrict VB doi-org-9532 167 5 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 167 6 social social JJ doi-org-9532 167 7 advocacy advocacy NN doi-org-9532 167 8 precisely precisely RB doi-org-9532 167 9 in in IN doi-org-9532 167 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 167 11 arena arena NN doi-org-9532 167 12 where where WRB doi-org-9532 167 13 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 167 14 training training NN doi-org-9532 167 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 167 16 expertise expertise NN doi-org-9532 167 17 give give VBP doi-org-9532 167 18 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 167 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 167 20 greatest great JJS doi-org-9532 167 21 social social JJ doi-org-9532 167 22 influence influence NN doi-org-9532 167 23 ? ? . doi-org-9532 168 1 Why why WRB doi-org-9532 168 2 exactly exactly RB doi-org-9532 168 3 are be VBP doi-org-9532 168 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 168 5 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 168 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 168 7 Read read VB doi-org-9532 168 8 Statement Statement NNP doi-org-9532 168 9 and and CC doi-org-9532 168 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 168 11 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 168 12 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 168 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 168 14 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 168 15 so so RB doi-org-9532 168 16 important important JJ doi-org-9532 168 17 to to IN doi-org-9532 168 18 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 168 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 168 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 168 21 first first JJ doi-org-9532 168 22 place place NN doi-org-9532 168 23 ? ? . doi-org-9532 169 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 169 2 Library library JJ doi-org-9532 169 3 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 169 4 Syllogism Syllogism NNP doi-org-9532 169 5 Answering answer VBG doi-org-9532 169 6 these these DT doi-org-9532 169 7 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 169 8 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 169 9 been be VBN doi-org-9532 169 10 difficult difficult JJ doi-org-9532 169 11 for for IN doi-org-9532 169 12 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 169 13 because because IN doi-org-9532 169 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 169 15 values value NNS doi-org-9532 169 16 expressed express VBN doi-org-9532 169 17 in in IN doi-org-9532 169 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 169 19 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 169 20 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 169 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 169 22 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 169 23 seem seem VBP doi-org-9532 169 24 so so RB doi-org-9532 169 25 obvious obvious JJ doi-org-9532 169 26 that that IN doi-org-9532 169 27 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 169 28 hardly hardly RB doi-org-9532 169 29 need need VBP doi-org-9532 169 30 justification justification NN doi-org-9532 169 31 . . . doi-org-9532 170 1 Who who WP doi-org-9532 170 2 could could MD doi-org-9532 170 3 disagree disagree VB doi-org-9532 170 4 when when WRB doi-org-9532 170 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 170 6 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 170 7 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 170 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 170 9 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 170 10 asserts assert VBZ doi-org-9532 170 11 that that IN doi-org-9532 170 12 " " `` doi-org-9532 170 13 materials material NNS doi-org-9532 170 14 should should MD doi-org-9532 170 15 not not RB doi-org-9532 170 16 be be VB doi-org-9532 170 17 excluded exclude VBN doi-org-9532 170 18 because because IN doi-org-9532 170 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 170 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 170 21 origin origin NN doi-org-9532 170 22 , , , doi-org-9532 170 23 background background NN doi-org-9532 170 24 , , , doi-org-9532 170 25 or or CC doi-org-9532 170 26 views view NNS doi-org-9532 170 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 170 28 those those DT doi-org-9532 170 29 contributing contribute VBG doi-org-9532 170 30 to to IN doi-org-9532 170 31 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 170 32 creation creation NN doi-org-9532 170 33 " " '' doi-org-9532 170 34 ? ? . doi-org-9532 171 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 171 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 171 3 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 171 4 63 63 CD doi-org-9532 171 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 171 6 Who who WP doi-org-9532 171 7 could could MD doi-org-9532 171 8 argue argue VB doi-org-9532 171 9 when when WRB doi-org-9532 171 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 171 11 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 171 12 's 's POS doi-org-9532 171 13 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 171 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 171 15 Read read VB doi-org-9532 171 16 Statement Statement NNP doi-org-9532 171 17 says say VBZ doi-org-9532 171 18 that that IN doi-org-9532 171 19 " " `` doi-org-9532 171 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 171 21 ordinary ordinary JJ doi-org-9532 171 22 individual individual NN doi-org-9532 171 23 , , , doi-org-9532 171 24 by by IN doi-org-9532 171 25 exercising exercise VBG doi-org-9532 171 26 critical critical JJ doi-org-9532 171 27 judgment judgment NN doi-org-9532 171 28 , , , doi-org-9532 171 29 will will MD doi-org-9532 171 30 select select VB doi-org-9532 171 31 the the DT doi-org-9532 171 32 good good JJ doi-org-9532 171 33 and and CC doi-org-9532 171 34 reject reject VBP doi-org-9532 171 35 the the DT doi-org-9532 171 36 bad bad JJ doi-org-9532 171 37 " " '' doi-org-9532 171 38 ? ? . doi-org-9532 172 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 172 2 most most JJS doi-org-9532 172 3 of of IN doi-org-9532 172 4 my -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 172 5 career career NN doi-org-9532 172 6 , , , doi-org-9532 172 7 such such JJ doi-org-9532 172 8 sentiments sentiment NNS doi-org-9532 172 9 have have VBP doi-org-9532 172 10 been be VBN doi-org-9532 172 11 easy easy JJ doi-org-9532 172 12 platitudes platitude NNS doi-org-9532 172 13 , , , doi-org-9532 172 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 172 15 inevitable inevitable JJ doi-org-9532 172 16 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 172 17 landscape landscape NN doi-org-9532 172 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 172 19 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 172 20 , , , doi-org-9532 172 21 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 172 22 than than IN doi-org-9532 172 23 controversial controversial JJ doi-org-9532 172 24 political political JJ doi-org-9532 172 25 commitments commitment NNS doi-org-9532 172 26 that that WDT doi-org-9532 172 27 could could MD doi-org-9532 172 28 be be VB doi-org-9532 172 29 challenged challenge VBN doi-org-9532 172 30 . . . doi-org-9532 173 1 But but CC doi-org-9532 173 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 173 3 critique critique NN doi-org-9532 173 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 173 5 library library JJ doi-org-9532 173 6 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 173 7 interrupts interrupt VBZ doi-org-9532 173 8 my -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 173 9 dogmatic dogmatic JJ doi-org-9532 173 10 slumbers slumber NNS doi-org-9532 173 11 . . . doi-org-9532 174 1 Recent recent JJ doi-org-9532 174 2 United United NNP doi-org-9532 174 3 States States NNP doi-org-9532 174 4 elections election NNS doi-org-9532 174 5 make make VBP doi-org-9532 174 6 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 174 7 wonder wonder VB doi-org-9532 174 8 if if IN doi-org-9532 174 9 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 174 10 really really RB doi-org-9532 174 11 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 174 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 174 13 " " `` doi-org-9532 174 14 trust trust VB doi-org-9532 174 15 Americans Americans NNPS doi-org-9532 174 16 to to TO doi-org-9532 174 17 recognize recognize VB doi-org-9532 174 18 propaganda propaganda NN doi-org-9532 174 19 and and CC doi-org-9532 174 20 misinformation misinformation NN doi-org-9532 174 21 , , , doi-org-9532 174 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 174 23 to to TO doi-org-9532 174 24 make make VB doi-org-9532 174 25 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 174 26 own own JJ doi-org-9532 174 27 decisions decision NNS doi-org-9532 174 28 about about IN doi-org-9532 174 29 what what WP doi-org-9532 174 30 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 174 31 read read VBP doi-org-9532 174 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 174 33 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 174 34 , , , doi-org-9532 174 35 " " '' doi-org-9532 174 36 as as IN doi-org-9532 174 37 the the DT doi-org-9532 174 38 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 174 39 to to TO doi-org-9532 174 40 Read read VB doi-org-9532 174 41 Statement Statement NNP doi-org-9532 174 42 asserts assert VBZ doi-org-9532 174 43 . . . doi-org-9532 175 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 175 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 175 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 175 4 post post NN doi-org-9532 175 5 truth truth NN doi-org-9532 175 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 175 7 era era NN doi-org-9532 175 8 , , , doi-org-9532 175 9 faith faith NN doi-org-9532 175 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 175 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 175 12 critical critical JJ doi-org-9532 175 13 judgment judgment NN doi-org-9532 175 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 175 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 175 16 ordinary ordinary JJ doi-org-9532 175 17 individuals individual NNS doi-org-9532 175 18 may may MD doi-org-9532 175 19 be be VB doi-org-9532 175 20 disastrous disastrous JJ doi-org-9532 175 21 . . . doi-org-9532 176 1 Can Can MD doi-org-9532 176 2 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 176 3 really really RB doi-org-9532 176 4 assume assume VB doi-org-9532 176 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 176 6 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 176 7 will will MD doi-org-9532 176 8 recognize recognize VB doi-org-9532 176 9 fake fake JJ doi-org-9532 176 10 news news NN doi-org-9532 176 11 for for IN doi-org-9532 176 12 what what WP doi-org-9532 176 13 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 176 14 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 176 15 if if IN doi-org-9532 176 16 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 176 17 do do VBP doi-org-9532 176 18 not not RB doi-org-9532 176 19 " " `` doi-org-9532 176 20 protect protect VB doi-org-9532 176 21 " " '' doi-org-9532 176 22 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 176 23 from from IN doi-org-9532 176 24 propaganda propaganda NN doi-org-9532 176 25 or or CC doi-org-9532 176 26 if if IN doi-org-9532 176 27 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 176 28 refuse refuse VBP doi-org-9532 176 29 to to TO doi-org-9532 176 30 " " `` doi-org-9532 176 31 foster foster JJ doi-org-9532 176 32 education education NN doi-org-9532 176 33 by by IN doi-org-9532 176 34 imposing impose VBG doi-org-9532 176 35 as as IN doi-org-9532 176 36 mentors mentor NNS doi-org-9532 176 37 the the DT doi-org-9532 176 38 patterns pattern NNS doi-org-9532 176 39 of of IN doi-org-9532 176 40 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 176 41 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 176 42 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 176 43 own own JJ doi-org-9532 176 44 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 176 45 " " '' doi-org-9532 176 46 ? ? . doi-org-9532 177 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 177 2 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 177 3 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 177 4 forces force VBZ doi-org-9532 177 5 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 177 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 177 7 interrogate interrogate VB doi-org-9532 177 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 177 9 deeper deep JJR doi-org-9532 177 10 political political JJ doi-org-9532 177 11 assumptions assumption NNS doi-org-9532 177 12 implicit implicit JJ doi-org-9532 177 13 in in IN doi-org-9532 177 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 177 15 platitudes platitude NNS doi-org-9532 177 16 so so RB doi-org-9532 177 17 confidently confidently RB doi-org-9532 177 18 expressed express VBN doi-org-9532 177 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 177 20 mid mid JJ doi-org-9532 177 21 - - JJ doi-org-9532 177 22 twentieth twentieth JJ doi-org-9532 177 23 century century NN doi-org-9532 177 24 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 177 25 documents document NNS doi-org-9532 177 26 . . . doi-org-9532 178 1 Are be VBP doi-org-9532 178 2 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 178 3 still still RB doi-org-9532 178 4 viable viable JJ doi-org-9532 178 5 for for IN doi-org-9532 178 6 twenty twenty CD doi-org-9532 178 7 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 178 8 first first JJ doi-org-9532 178 9 century century NN doi-org-9532 178 10 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 178 11 ? ? . doi-org-9532 179 1 My -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 179 2 attempt attempt NN doi-org-9532 179 3 to to TO doi-org-9532 179 4 think think VB doi-org-9532 179 5 through through IN doi-org-9532 179 6 these these DT doi-org-9532 179 7 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 179 8 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 179 9 led lead VBN doi-org-9532 179 10 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 179 11 to to IN doi-org-9532 179 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 179 13 library library JJ doi-org-9532 179 14 neutrality neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 179 15 syllogism syllogism NN doi-org-9532 179 16 summarized summarize VBN doi-org-9532 179 17 here here RB doi-org-9532 179 18 . . . doi-org-9532 180 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 180 2 following follow VBG doi-org-9532 180 3 sections section NNS doi-org-9532 180 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 180 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 180 6 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 180 7 will will MD doi-org-9532 180 8 flesh flesh VB doi-org-9532 180 9 out out RP doi-org-9532 180 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 180 11 steps step NNS doi-org-9532 180 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 180 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 180 14 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 180 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 180 16 then then RB doi-org-9532 180 17 respond respond VB doi-org-9532 180 18 to to IN doi-org-9532 180 19 potential potential JJ doi-org-9532 180 20 objections objection NNS doi-org-9532 180 21 . . . doi-org-9532 181 1 Major Major NNP doi-org-9532 181 2 Premise premise NN doi-org-9532 181 3 : : : doi-org-9532 181 4 Libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 181 5 and and CC doi-org-9532 181 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 181 7 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 181 8 In in IN doi-org-9532 181 9 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 181 10 and and CC doi-org-9532 181 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 181 12 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 181 13 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 181 14 2012 2012 CD doi-org-9532 181 15 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 181 16 , , , doi-org-9532 181 17 Wayne Wayne NNP doi-org-9532 181 18 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 181 19 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 181 20 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 181 21 , , , doi-org-9532 181 22 author author NN doi-org-9532 181 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 181 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 181 25 Academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 181 26 Librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 181 27 blog blog NN doi-org-9532 181 28 , , , doi-org-9532 181 29 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 181 30 that that IN doi-org-9532 181 31 " " `` doi-org-9532 181 32 the the DT doi-org-9532 181 33 philosophical philosophical JJ doi-org-9532 181 34 and and CC doi-org-9532 181 35 political political JJ doi-org-9532 181 36 principles principle NNS doi-org-9532 181 37 of of IN doi-org-9532 181 38 the the DT doi-org-9532 181 39 European European NNP doi-org-9532 181 40 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 181 41 provide provide VBP doi-org-9532 181 42 the the DT doi-org-9532 181 43 philosophical philosophical JJ doi-org-9532 181 44 foundation foundation NN doi-org-9532 181 45 of of IN doi-org-9532 181 46 American american JJ doi-org-9532 181 47 academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 181 48 and and CC doi-org-9532 181 49 public public JJ doi-org-9532 181 50 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 181 51 . . . doi-org-9532 182 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 182 2 27 27 CD doi-org-9532 182 3 These these DT doi-org-9532 182 4 principles principle NNS doi-org-9532 182 5 include include VBP doi-org-9532 182 6 a a DT doi-org-9532 182 7 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 182 8 to to IN doi-org-9532 182 9 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 182 10 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 182 11 . . . doi-org-9532 183 1 Minor minor JJ doi-org-9532 183 2 Premise premise NN doi-org-9532 183 3 : : : doi-org-9532 183 4 Liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 183 5 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 183 6 Several several JJ doi-org-9532 183 7 twentieth twentieth JJ doi-org-9532 183 8 century century NN doi-org-9532 183 9 American american JJ doi-org-9532 183 10 political political JJ doi-org-9532 183 11 philosophers philosopher NNS doi-org-9532 183 12 , , , doi-org-9532 183 13 including include VBG doi-org-9532 183 14 Ronald Ronald NNP doi-org-9532 183 15 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 183 16 , , , doi-org-9532 183 17 John John NNP doi-org-9532 183 18 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 183 19 , , , doi-org-9532 183 20 and and CC doi-org-9532 183 21 Martha Martha NNP doi-org-9532 183 22 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 183 23 , , , doi-org-9532 183 24 argue argue VBP doi-org-9532 183 25 that that IN doi-org-9532 183 26 " " `` doi-org-9532 183 27 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 183 28 between between IN doi-org-9532 183 29 different different JJ doi-org-9532 183 30 conceptions conception NNS doi-org-9532 183 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 183 32 the the DT doi-org-9532 183 33 good good JJ doi-org-9532 183 34 " " '' doi-org-9532 183 35 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 183 36 essential essential JJ doi-org-9532 183 37 to to IN doi-org-9532 183 38 a a DT doi-org-9532 183 39 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 183 40 political political JJ doi-org-9532 183 41 state state NN doi-org-9532 183 42 . . . doi-org-9532 184 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 184 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 184 3 state state NN doi-org-9532 184 4 fails fail VBZ doi-org-9532 184 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 184 6 maintain maintain VB doi-org-9532 184 7 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 184 8 between between IN doi-org-9532 184 9 different different JJ doi-org-9532 184 10 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 184 11 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 184 12 , , , doi-org-9532 184 13 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 184 14 fails fail VBZ doi-org-9532 184 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 184 16 treat treat VB doi-org-9532 184 17 every every DT doi-org-9532 184 18 citizen citizen NN doi-org-9532 184 19 with with IN doi-org-9532 184 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 184 21 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 184 22 care care NN doi-org-9532 184 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 184 24 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 184 25 she -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 184 26 deserves deserve VBZ doi-org-9532 184 27 as as IN doi-org-9532 184 28 a a DT doi-org-9532 184 29 member member NN doi-org-9532 184 30 of of IN doi-org-9532 184 31 a a DT doi-org-9532 184 32 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 184 33 society society NN doi-org-9532 184 34 . . . doi-org-9532 185 1 Conclusion conclusion NN doi-org-9532 185 2 : : : doi-org-9532 185 3 Librarians Librarians NNPS doi-org-9532 185 4 Should Should MD doi-org-9532 185 5 Be be VB doi-org-9532 185 6 Neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 185 7 between between IN doi-org-9532 185 8 Different Different NNP doi-org-9532 185 9 Conceptions Conceptions NNPS doi-org-9532 185 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 185 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 185 12 Good Good NNP doi-org-9532 185 13 If if IN doi-org-9532 185 14 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 185 15 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 185 16 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 185 17 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 185 18 right right JJ doi-org-9532 185 19 about about IN doi-org-9532 185 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 185 21 political political JJ doi-org-9532 185 22 principles principle NNS doi-org-9532 185 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 185 24 American american JJ doi-org-9532 185 25 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 185 26 and and CC doi-org-9532 185 27 if if IN doi-org-9532 185 28 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 185 29 , , , doi-org-9532 185 30 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 185 31 , , , doi-org-9532 185 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 185 33 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 185 34 are be VBP doi-org-9532 185 35 right right JJ doi-org-9532 185 36 about about IN doi-org-9532 185 37 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 185 38 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 185 39 , , , doi-org-9532 185 40 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 185 41 should should MD doi-org-9532 185 42 do do VB doi-org-9532 185 43 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 185 44 best good JJS doi-org-9532 185 45 to to TO doi-org-9532 185 46 maintain maintain VB doi-org-9532 185 47 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 185 48 between between IN doi-org-9532 185 49 differing differ VBG doi-org-9532 185 50 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 185 51 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 185 52 to to TO doi-org-9532 185 53 provide provide VB doi-org-9532 185 54 an an DT doi-org-9532 185 55 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 185 56 environment environment NN doi-org-9532 185 57 in in IN doi-org-9532 185 58 which which WDT doi-org-9532 185 59 every every DT doi-org-9532 185 60 citizen citizen NN doi-org-9532 185 61 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 185 62 an an DT doi-org-9532 185 63 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 185 64 opportunity opportunity NN doi-org-9532 185 65 to to TO doi-org-9532 185 66 discover discover VB doi-org-9532 185 67 , , , doi-org-9532 185 68 develop develop VB doi-org-9532 185 69 , , , doi-org-9532 185 70 and and CC doi-org-9532 185 71 defend defend VB doi-org-9532 185 72 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 185 73 own own JJ doi-org-9532 185 74 conceptions conception NNS doi-org-9532 185 75 of of IN doi-org-9532 185 76 the the DT doi-org-9532 185 77 good good NN doi-org-9532 185 78 . . . doi-org-9532 186 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 186 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 186 3 Page page NN doi-org-9532 186 4 64 64 CD doi-org-9532 186 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 186 6 Libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 186 7 and and CC doi-org-9532 186 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 186 9 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 186 10 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 186 11 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 186 12 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 186 13 traces trace VBZ doi-org-9532 186 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 186 15 historical historical JJ doi-org-9532 186 16 origins origin NNS doi-org-9532 186 17 and and CC doi-org-9532 186 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 186 19 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 186 20 " " `` doi-org-9532 186 21 telos telo NNS doi-org-9532 186 22 " " '' doi-org-9532 186 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 186 24 American american JJ doi-org-9532 186 25 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 186 26 to to IN doi-org-9532 186 27 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 186 28 developed develop VBN doi-org-9532 186 29 by by IN doi-org-9532 186 30 European European NNP doi-org-9532 186 31 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 186 32 thinkers thinker NNS doi-org-9532 186 33 in in IN doi-org-9532 186 34 the the DT doi-org-9532 186 35 seventeenth seventeenth JJ doi-org-9532 186 36 century century NN doi-org-9532 186 37 , , , doi-org-9532 186 38 who who WP doi-org-9532 186 39 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 186 40 in in IN doi-org-9532 186 41 the the DT doi-org-9532 186 42 power power NN doi-org-9532 186 43 of of IN doi-org-9532 186 44 human human JJ doi-org-9532 186 45 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 186 46 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 186 47 than than IN doi-org-9532 186 48 traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 186 49 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 186 50 . . . doi-org-9532 187 1 Although although IN doi-org-9532 187 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 187 3 scholarship scholarship NN doi-org-9532 187 4 about about IN doi-org-9532 187 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 187 6 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 187 7 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 187 8 vast vast JJ doi-org-9532 187 9 , , , doi-org-9532 187 10 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 187 11 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 187 12 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 187 13 relies rely VBZ doi-org-9532 187 14 on on IN doi-org-9532 187 15 a a DT doi-org-9532 187 16 recent recent JJ doi-org-9532 187 17 analysis analysis NN doi-org-9532 187 18 by by IN doi-org-9532 187 19 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 187 20 historian historian NN doi-org-9532 187 21 Jonathan Jonathan NNP doi-org-9532 187 22 Israel Israel NNP doi-org-9532 187 23 to to TO doi-org-9532 187 24 summarize summarize VB doi-org-9532 187 25 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 187 26 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 187 27 . . . doi-org-9532 188 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 188 2 A a DT doi-org-9532 188 3 Revolution Revolution NNP doi-org-9532 188 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 188 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 188 6 Mind mind NN doi-org-9532 188 7 : : : doi-org-9532 188 8 Radical Radical NNP doi-org-9532 188 9 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 188 10 and and CC doi-org-9532 188 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 188 12 Intellectual Intellectual NNP doi-org-9532 188 13 Origins Origins NNP doi-org-9532 188 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 188 15 Modern Modern NNP doi-org-9532 188 16 Democracy Democracy NNP doi-org-9532 188 17 , , , doi-org-9532 188 18 Israel Israel NNP doi-org-9532 188 19 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 188 20 : : : doi-org-9532 188 21 Radical Radical NNP doi-org-9532 188 22 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 188 23 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 188 24 a a DT doi-org-9532 188 25 set set NN doi-org-9532 188 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 188 27 basic basic JJ doi-org-9532 188 28 principles principle NNS doi-org-9532 188 29 that that WDT doi-org-9532 188 30 can can MD doi-org-9532 188 31 be be VB doi-org-9532 188 32 summed sum VBN doi-org-9532 188 33 up up RP doi-org-9532 188 34 concisely concisely RB doi-org-9532 188 35 as as IN doi-org-9532 188 36 : : : doi-org-9532 188 37 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 188 38 ; ; , doi-org-9532 188 39 racial racial JJ doi-org-9532 188 40 and and CC doi-org-9532 188 41 sexual sexual JJ doi-org-9532 188 42 equality equality NN doi-org-9532 188 43 ; ; , doi-org-9532 188 44 individual individual JJ doi-org-9532 188 45 liberty liberty NN doi-org-9532 188 46 of of IN doi-org-9532 188 47 lifestyle lifestyle NN doi-org-9532 188 48 ; ; , doi-org-9532 188 49 full full JJ doi-org-9532 188 50 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 188 51 of of IN doi-org-9532 188 52 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 188 53 , , , doi-org-9532 188 54 expression expression NN doi-org-9532 188 55 , , , doi-org-9532 188 56 and and CC doi-org-9532 188 57 the the DT doi-org-9532 188 58 press press NN doi-org-9532 188 59 … … NFP doi-org-9532 188 60 Its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 188 61 chief chief JJ doi-org-9532 188 62 maxim maxim NN doi-org-9532 188 63 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 188 64 that that IN doi-org-9532 188 65 all all DT doi-org-9532 188 66 men man NNS doi-org-9532 188 67 have have VBP doi-org-9532 188 68 the the DT doi-org-9532 188 69 same same JJ doi-org-9532 188 70 basic basic JJ doi-org-9532 188 71 needs need NNS doi-org-9532 188 72 , , , doi-org-9532 188 73 rights right NNS doi-org-9532 188 74 , , , doi-org-9532 188 75 and and CC doi-org-9532 188 76 status status NN doi-org-9532 188 77 irrespective irrespective RB doi-org-9532 188 78 of of IN doi-org-9532 188 79 what what WP doi-org-9532 188 80 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 188 81 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 188 82 or or CC doi-org-9532 188 83 what what WP doi-org-9532 188 84 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 188 85 , , , doi-org-9532 188 86 economic economic JJ doi-org-9532 188 87 , , , doi-org-9532 188 88 or or CC doi-org-9532 188 89 ethnic ethnic JJ doi-org-9532 188 90 group group NN doi-org-9532 188 91 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 188 92 belong belong VBP doi-org-9532 188 93 to to IN doi-org-9532 188 94 , , , doi-org-9532 188 95 and and CC doi-org-9532 188 96 that that IN doi-org-9532 188 97 consequently consequently RB doi-org-9532 188 98 all all DT doi-org-9532 188 99 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 188 100 to to TO doi-org-9532 188 101 be be VB doi-org-9532 188 102 treated treat VBN doi-org-9532 188 103 alike alike RB doi-org-9532 188 104 , , , doi-org-9532 188 105 on on IN doi-org-9532 188 106 the the DT doi-org-9532 188 107 basis basis NN doi-org-9532 188 108 of of IN doi-org-9532 188 109 equity equity NN doi-org-9532 188 110 , , , doi-org-9532 188 111 whether whether IN doi-org-9532 188 112 black black JJ doi-org-9532 188 113 or or CC doi-org-9532 188 114 white white JJ doi-org-9532 188 115 , , , doi-org-9532 188 116 male male JJ doi-org-9532 188 117 or or CC doi-org-9532 188 118 female female JJ doi-org-9532 188 119 , , , doi-org-9532 188 120 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 188 121 or or CC doi-org-9532 188 122 nonreligious.28 nonreligious.28 NNP doi-org-9532 188 123 Israel Israel NNP doi-org-9532 188 124 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 188 125 not not RB doi-org-9532 188 126 argue argue VB doi-org-9532 188 127 that that IN doi-org-9532 188 128 all all DT doi-org-9532 188 129 seventeenth seventeenth JJ doi-org-9532 188 130 century century NN doi-org-9532 188 131 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 188 132 thinkers thinker NNS doi-org-9532 188 133 were be VBD doi-org-9532 188 134 ready ready JJ doi-org-9532 188 135 to to TO doi-org-9532 188 136 grant grant VB doi-org-9532 188 137 " " `` doi-org-9532 188 138 full full JJ doi-org-9532 188 139 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 188 140 of of IN doi-org-9532 188 141 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 188 142 " " '' doi-org-9532 188 143 to to IN doi-org-9532 188 144 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 188 145 immediately immediately RB doi-org-9532 188 146 . . . doi-org-9532 189 1 Many many JJ doi-org-9532 189 2 famous famous JJ doi-org-9532 189 3 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 189 4 philosophers philosopher NNS doi-org-9532 189 5 denied deny VBD doi-org-9532 189 6 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 189 7 rights right NNS doi-org-9532 189 8 to to IN doi-org-9532 189 9 women woman NNS doi-org-9532 189 10 , , , doi-org-9532 189 11 non non NNS doi-org-9532 189 12 - - NNS doi-org-9532 189 13 Christians Christians NNPS doi-org-9532 189 14 , , , doi-org-9532 189 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 189 16 poor poor JJ doi-org-9532 189 17 , , , doi-org-9532 189 18 or or CC doi-org-9532 189 19 non non NNS doi-org-9532 189 20 - - NNS doi-org-9532 189 21 Europeans Europeans NNPS doi-org-9532 189 22 . . . doi-org-9532 190 1 Many many JJ doi-org-9532 190 2 American american JJ doi-org-9532 190 3 revolutionaries revolutionary NNS doi-org-9532 190 4 steeped steep VBD doi-org-9532 190 5 in in IN doi-org-9532 190 6 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 190 7 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 190 8 proclaimed proclaim VBD doi-org-9532 190 9 that that IN doi-org-9532 190 10 " " `` doi-org-9532 190 11 all all DT doi-org-9532 190 12 men man NNS doi-org-9532 190 13 are be VBP doi-org-9532 190 14 created create VBN doi-org-9532 190 15 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 190 16 " " '' doi-org-9532 190 17 in in IN doi-org-9532 190 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 190 19 Declaration Declaration NNP doi-org-9532 190 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 190 21 Independence Independence NNP doi-org-9532 190 22 while while IN doi-org-9532 190 23 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 190 24 continued continue VBD doi-org-9532 190 25 to to TO doi-org-9532 190 26 own own VB doi-org-9532 190 27 slaves.29 slaves.29 NNP doi-org-9532 190 28 Nevertheless nevertheless RB doi-org-9532 190 29 , , , doi-org-9532 190 30 Israel Israel NNP doi-org-9532 190 31 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 190 32 that that IN doi-org-9532 190 33 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 190 34 thinkers thinker NNS doi-org-9532 190 35 developed develop VBD doi-org-9532 190 36 a a DT doi-org-9532 190 37 new new JJ doi-org-9532 190 38 understanding understanding NN doi-org-9532 190 39 of of IN doi-org-9532 190 40 the the DT doi-org-9532 190 41 relationship relationship NN doi-org-9532 190 42 between between IN doi-org-9532 190 43 the the DT doi-org-9532 190 44 individual individual NN doi-org-9532 190 45 and and CC doi-org-9532 190 46 society society NN doi-org-9532 190 47 that that WDT doi-org-9532 190 48 encouraged encourage VBD doi-org-9532 190 49 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 190 50 equality equality NN doi-org-9532 190 51 . . . doi-org-9532 191 1 As as IN doi-org-9532 191 2 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 191 3 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 191 4 became become VBD doi-org-9532 191 5 more more RBR doi-org-9532 191 6 successful successful JJ doi-org-9532 191 7 , , , doi-org-9532 191 8 that that DT doi-org-9532 191 9 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 191 10 was be VBD doi-org-9532 191 11 applied apply VBN doi-org-9532 191 12 to to IN doi-org-9532 191 13 broader broad JJR doi-org-9532 191 14 and and CC doi-org-9532 191 15 more more RBR doi-org-9532 191 16 inclusive inclusive JJ doi-org-9532 191 17 groups group NNS doi-org-9532 191 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 191 19 human human JJ doi-org-9532 191 20 beings being NNS doi-org-9532 191 21 . . . doi-org-9532 192 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 192 2 belief belief NN doi-org-9532 192 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 192 4 all all DT doi-org-9532 192 5 people people NNS doi-org-9532 192 6 are be VBP doi-org-9532 192 7 capable capable JJ doi-org-9532 192 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 192 9 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 192 10 and and CC doi-org-9532 192 11 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 192 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 192 13 have have VB doi-org-9532 192 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 192 15 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 192 16 to to TO doi-org-9532 192 17 develop develop VB doi-org-9532 192 18 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 192 19 own own JJ doi-org-9532 192 20 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 192 21 and and CC doi-org-9532 192 22 political political JJ doi-org-9532 192 23 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 192 24 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 192 25 central central JJ doi-org-9532 192 26 to to IN doi-org-9532 192 27 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 192 28 values value NNS doi-org-9532 192 29 . . . doi-org-9532 193 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 193 2 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 193 3 famous famous JJ doi-org-9532 193 4 1784 1784 CD doi-org-9532 193 5 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 193 6 " " `` doi-org-9532 193 7 What what WP doi-org-9532 193 8 Is be VBZ doi-org-9532 193 9 Enlightenment enlightenment NN doi-org-9532 193 10 ? ? . doi-org-9532 193 11 " " '' doi-org-9532 194 1 Immanuel Immanuel NNP doi-org-9532 194 2 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 194 3 stated state VBD doi-org-9532 194 4 , , , doi-org-9532 194 5 " " `` doi-org-9532 194 6 Enlightenment enlightenment NN doi-org-9532 194 7 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 194 8 man man NN doi-org-9532 194 9 's 's POS doi-org-9532 194 10 emergence emergence NN doi-org-9532 194 11 from from IN doi-org-9532 194 12 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 194 13 self self NN doi-org-9532 194 14 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 194 15 imposed impose VBN doi-org-9532 194 16 immaturity immaturity NN doi-org-9532 194 17 . . . doi-org-9532 195 1 Immaturity immaturity NN doi-org-9532 195 2 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 195 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 195 4 inability inability NN doi-org-9532 195 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 195 6 use use VB doi-org-9532 195 7 one one PRP doi-org-9532 195 8 's 's POS doi-org-9532 195 9 understanding understanding NN doi-org-9532 195 10 without without IN doi-org-9532 195 11 guidance guidance NN doi-org-9532 195 12 from from IN doi-org-9532 195 13 another another DT doi-org-9532 195 14 . . . doi-org-9532 196 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 196 2 30 30 CD doi-org-9532 196 3 The the DT doi-org-9532 196 4 idea idea NN doi-org-9532 196 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 196 6 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 196 7 can can MD doi-org-9532 196 8 reason reason VB doi-org-9532 196 9 for for IN doi-org-9532 196 10 themselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 196 11 undermines undermine VBZ doi-org-9532 196 12 paternalistic paternalistic JJ doi-org-9532 196 13 forms form NNS doi-org-9532 196 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 196 15 religion religion NN doi-org-9532 196 16 and and CC doi-org-9532 196 17 society society NN doi-org-9532 196 18 , , , doi-org-9532 196 19 which which WDT doi-org-9532 196 20 assume assume VBP doi-org-9532 196 21 that that IN doi-org-9532 196 22 most most JJS doi-org-9532 196 23 people people NNS doi-org-9532 196 24 are be VBP doi-org-9532 196 25 not not RB doi-org-9532 196 26 capable capable JJ doi-org-9532 196 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 196 28 finding find VBG doi-org-9532 196 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 196 30 truth truth NN doi-org-9532 196 31 on on IN doi-org-9532 196 32 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 196 33 own own JJ doi-org-9532 196 34 . . . doi-org-9532 197 1 Traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 197 2 pre pre JJ doi-org-9532 197 3 - - JJ doi-org-9532 197 4 Enlightenment enlightenment JJ doi-org-9532 197 5 rulers ruler NNS doi-org-9532 197 6 in in IN doi-org-9532 197 7 Europe Europe NNP doi-org-9532 197 8 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 197 9 that that IN doi-org-9532 197 10 access access NN doi-org-9532 197 11 to to IN doi-org-9532 197 12 truth truth NN doi-org-9532 197 13 was be VBD doi-org-9532 197 14 limited limit VBN doi-org-9532 197 15 to to IN doi-org-9532 197 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 197 17 small small JJ doi-org-9532 197 18 , , , doi-org-9532 197 19 educated educated JJ doi-org-9532 197 20 elite elite NNS doi-org-9532 197 21 and and CC doi-org-9532 197 22 that that IN doi-org-9532 197 23 political political JJ doi-org-9532 197 24 power power NN doi-org-9532 197 25 should should MD doi-org-9532 197 26 be be VB doi-org-9532 197 27 restricted restrict VBN doi-org-9532 197 28 to to IN doi-org-9532 197 29 a a DT doi-org-9532 197 30 small small JJ doi-org-9532 197 31 class class NN doi-org-9532 197 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 197 33 aristocrats aristocrat NNS doi-org-9532 197 34 . . . doi-org-9532 198 1 Most Most JJS doi-org-9532 198 2 people people NNS doi-org-9532 198 3 were be VBD doi-org-9532 198 4 destined destine VBN doi-org-9532 198 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 198 6 serve serve VB doi-org-9532 198 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 198 8 will will NN doi-org-9532 198 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 198 10 God God NNP doi-org-9532 198 11 or or CC doi-org-9532 198 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 198 13 needs need NNS doi-org-9532 198 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 198 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 198 16 state state NN doi-org-9532 198 17 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 198 18 than than IN doi-org-9532 198 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 198 20 pursue pursue VB doi-org-9532 198 21 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 198 22 own own JJ doi-org-9532 198 23 ends end NNS doi-org-9532 198 24 . . . doi-org-9532 199 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 199 2 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 199 3 conception conception NN doi-org-9532 199 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 199 5 society society NN doi-org-9532 199 6 as as IN doi-org-9532 199 7 an an DT doi-org-9532 199 8 institution institution NN doi-org-9532 199 9 that that WDT doi-org-9532 199 10 can can MD doi-org-9532 199 11 only only RB doi-org-9532 199 12 be be VB doi-org-9532 199 13 justified justify VBN doi-org-9532 199 14 by by IN doi-org-9532 199 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 199 16 benefits benefit NNS doi-org-9532 199 17 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 199 18 brings bring VBZ doi-org-9532 199 19 to to IN doi-org-9532 199 20 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 199 21 individual individual JJ doi-org-9532 199 22 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 199 23 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 199 24 built build VBN doi-org-9532 199 25 on on IN doi-org-9532 199 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 199 27 Enlighten Enlighten NNP doi-org-9532 199 28 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 199 29 ment ment NNP doi-org-9532 199 30 's 's POS doi-org-9532 199 31 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 199 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 199 33 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 199 34 . . . doi-org-9532 200 1 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 200 2 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 200 3 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 200 4 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 200 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 200 6 American american JJ doi-org-9532 200 7 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 200 8 have have VBP doi-org-9532 200 9 earned earn VBN doi-org-9532 200 10 social social JJ doi-org-9532 200 11 legitimacy legitimacy NN doi-org-9532 200 12 based base VBN doi-org-9532 200 13 on on IN doi-org-9532 200 14 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 200 15 promise promise NN doi-org-9532 200 16 to to TO doi-org-9532 200 17 promote promote VB doi-org-9532 200 18 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 200 19 values value NNS doi-org-9532 200 20 . . . doi-org-9532 201 1 Academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 201 2 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 201 3 primarily primarily RB doi-org-9532 201 4 serve serve VBP doi-org-9532 201 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 201 6 modern modern JJ doi-org-9532 201 7 university university NN doi-org-9532 201 8 's 's POS doi-org-9532 201 9 quest quest NN doi-org-9532 201 10 for for IN doi-org-9532 201 11 knowledge knowledge NN doi-org-9532 201 12 as as IN doi-org-9532 201 13 an an DT doi-org-9532 201 14 end end NN doi-org-9532 201 15 unto unto IN doi-org-9532 201 16 itself -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 201 17 . . . doi-org-9532 202 1 Before before IN doi-org-9532 202 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 202 3 Civil Civil NNP doi-org-9532 202 4 War War NNP doi-org-9532 202 5 , , , doi-org-9532 202 6 most most JJS doi-org-9532 202 7 American american JJ doi-org-9532 202 8 universities university NNS doi-org-9532 202 9 focused focus VBD doi-org-9532 202 10 on on IN doi-org-9532 202 11 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 202 12 training training NN doi-org-9532 202 13 for for IN doi-org-9532 202 14 ministers minister NNS doi-org-9532 202 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 202 16 political political JJ doi-org-9532 202 17 elites elite NNS doi-org-9532 202 18 in in IN doi-org-9532 202 19 specific specific JJ doi-org-9532 202 20 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 202 21 traditions tradition NNS doi-org-9532 202 22 . . . doi-org-9532 203 1 Because because IN doi-org-9532 203 2 " " `` doi-org-9532 203 3 instruction instruction NN doi-org-9532 203 4 was be VBD doi-org-9532 203 5 dependent dependent JJ doi-org-9532 203 6 on on IN doi-org-9532 203 7 studying study VBG doi-org-9532 203 8 a a DT doi-org-9532 203 9 few few JJ doi-org-9532 203 10 classical classical JJ doi-org-9532 203 11 texts text NNS doi-org-9532 203 12 closely closely RB doi-org-9532 203 13 , , , doi-org-9532 203 14 or or CC doi-org-9532 203 15 through through IN doi-org-9532 203 16 recitation recitation NN doi-org-9532 203 17 from from IN doi-org-9532 203 18 textbooks textbook NNS doi-org-9532 203 19 , , , doi-org-9532 203 20 there there EX doi-org-9532 203 21 was be VBD doi-org-9532 203 22 hardly hardly RB doi-org-9532 203 23 any any DT doi-org-9532 203 24 need need NN doi-org-9532 203 25 for for IN doi-org-9532 203 26 academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 203 27 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 203 28 to to TO doi-org-9532 203 29 support support VB doi-org-9532 203 30 the the DT doi-org-9532 203 31 curricula curriculum NNS doi-org-9532 203 32 . . . doi-org-9532 203 33 " " '' doi-org-9532 204 1 College college NN doi-org-9532 204 2 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 204 3 were be VBD doi-org-9532 204 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 204 5 just just RB doi-org-9532 204 6 not not RB doi-org-9532 204 7 that that RB doi-org-9532 204 8 important important JJ doi-org-9532 204 9 " " '' doi-org-9532 204 10 because because IN doi-org-9532 204 11 there there EX doi-org-9532 204 12 was be VBD doi-org-9532 204 13 little little JJ doi-org-9532 204 14 need need NN doi-org-9532 204 15 for for IN doi-org-9532 204 16 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 204 17 exploration exploration NN doi-org-9532 204 18 beyond beyond IN doi-org-9532 204 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 204 20 approved approve VBN doi-org-9532 204 21 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 204 22 End end NN doi-org-9532 204 23 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 204 24 65 65 CD doi-org-9532 204 25 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 204 26 texts.31 texts.31 NNP doi-org-9532 204 27 Only only RB doi-org-9532 204 28 when when WRB doi-org-9532 204 29 American american JJ doi-org-9532 204 30 universities university NNS doi-org-9532 204 31 began begin VBD doi-org-9532 204 32 to to TO doi-org-9532 204 33 adopt adopt VB doi-org-9532 204 34 the the DT doi-org-9532 204 35 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 204 36 model model NN doi-org-9532 204 37 of of IN doi-org-9532 204 38 German german JJ doi-org-9532 204 39 universities university NNS doi-org-9532 204 40 at at IN doi-org-9532 204 41 the the DT doi-org-9532 204 42 end end NN doi-org-9532 204 43 of of IN doi-org-9532 204 44 the the DT doi-org-9532 204 45 nineteenth nineteenth JJ doi-org-9532 204 46 century century NN doi-org-9532 204 47 did do VBD doi-org-9532 204 48 American american JJ doi-org-9532 204 49 academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 204 50 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 204 51 became become VBD doi-org-9532 204 52 important important JJ doi-org-9532 204 53 . . . doi-org-9532 205 1 As as IN doi-org-9532 205 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 205 3 search search NN doi-org-9532 205 4 for for IN doi-org-9532 205 5 new new JJ doi-org-9532 205 6 knowledge knowledge NN doi-org-9532 205 7 became become VBD doi-org-9532 205 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 205 9 primary primary JJ doi-org-9532 205 10 purpose purpose NN doi-org-9532 205 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 205 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 205 13 university university NN doi-org-9532 205 14 , , , doi-org-9532 205 15 large large JJ doi-org-9532 205 16 and and CC doi-org-9532 205 17 well well RB doi-org-9532 205 18 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 205 19 organized organize VBN doi-org-9532 205 20 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 205 21 were be VBD doi-org-9532 205 22 needed need VBN doi-org-9532 205 23 to to TO doi-org-9532 205 24 store store VB doi-org-9532 205 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 205 26 endless endless JJ doi-org-9532 205 27 accumulation accumulation NN doi-org-9532 205 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 205 29 learning learning NN doi-org-9532 205 30 and and CC doi-org-9532 205 31 to to TO doi-org-9532 205 32 support support VB doi-org-9532 205 33 the the DT doi-org-9532 205 34 independent independent JJ doi-org-9532 205 35 exploration exploration NN doi-org-9532 205 36 of of IN doi-org-9532 205 37 scholars scholar NNS doi-org-9532 205 38 . . . doi-org-9532 206 1 American american JJ doi-org-9532 206 2 public public JJ doi-org-9532 206 3 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 206 4 gained gain VBD doi-org-9532 206 5 popular popular JJ doi-org-9532 206 6 support support NN doi-org-9532 206 7 as as IN doi-org-9532 206 8 a a DT doi-org-9532 206 9 means means NN doi-org-9532 206 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 206 11 promoting promote VBG doi-org-9532 206 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 206 13 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 206 14 self self NN doi-org-9532 206 15 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 206 16 development development NN doi-org-9532 206 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 206 18 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 206 19 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 206 20 . . . doi-org-9532 207 1 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 207 2 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 207 3 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 207 4 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ doi-org-9532 207 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 207 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 207 7 earliest early JJS doi-org-9532 207 8 publicly publicly RB doi-org-9532 207 9 funded fund VBN doi-org-9532 207 10 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 207 11 — — : doi-org-9532 207 12 also also RB doi-org-9532 207 13 built build VBN doi-org-9532 207 14 in in IN doi-org-9532 207 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 207 16 middle middle NN doi-org-9532 207 17 to to IN doi-org-9532 207 18 late late JJ doi-org-9532 207 19 nineteenth nineteenth JJ doi-org-9532 207 20 century century NN doi-org-9532 207 21 — — : doi-org-9532 207 22 were be VBD doi-org-9532 207 23 justified justify VBN doi-org-9532 207 24 as as IN doi-org-9532 207 25 a a DT doi-org-9532 207 26 supplement supplement NN doi-org-9532 207 27 to to IN doi-org-9532 207 28 public public JJ doi-org-9532 207 29 schools school NNS doi-org-9532 207 30 because because IN doi-org-9532 207 31 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 207 32 allowed allow VBD doi-org-9532 207 33 adults adult NNS doi-org-9532 207 34 to to TO doi-org-9532 207 35 continue continue VB doi-org-9532 207 36 the the DT doi-org-9532 207 37 education education NN doi-org-9532 207 38 that that IN doi-org-9532 207 39 the the DT doi-org-9532 207 40 schools school NNS doi-org-9532 207 41 had have VBD doi-org-9532 207 42 started start VBN doi-org-9532 207 43 . . . doi-org-9532 208 1 Access access NN doi-org-9532 208 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 208 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 208 4 library library NN doi-org-9532 208 5 was be VBD doi-org-9532 208 6 valuable valuable JJ doi-org-9532 208 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 208 8 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 208 9 society society NN doi-org-9532 208 10 because because IN doi-org-9532 208 11 " " `` doi-org-9532 208 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 208 13 largest large JJS doi-org-9532 208 14 possible possible JJ doi-org-9532 208 15 number number NN doi-org-9532 208 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 208 17 persons person NNS doi-org-9532 208 18 should should MD doi-org-9532 208 19 be be VB doi-org-9532 208 20 induced induce VBN doi-org-9532 208 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 208 22 read read VB doi-org-9532 208 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 208 24 understand understand VB doi-org-9532 208 25 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 208 26 going go VBG doi-org-9532 208 27 down down RP doi-org-9532 208 28 to to IN doi-org-9532 208 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 208 30 very very JJ doi-org-9532 208 31 foundations foundation NNS doi-org-9532 208 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 208 33 social social JJ doi-org-9532 208 34 order order NN doi-org-9532 208 35 , , , doi-org-9532 208 36 which which WDT doi-org-9532 208 37 are be VBP doi-org-9532 208 38 constantly constantly RB doi-org-9532 208 39 presenting present VBG doi-org-9532 208 40 themselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 208 41 , , , doi-org-9532 208 42 and and CC doi-org-9532 208 43 which which WDT doi-org-9532 208 44 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 208 45 , , , doi-org-9532 208 46 as as IN doi-org-9532 208 47 a a DT doi-org-9532 208 48 people people NNS doi-org-9532 208 49 , , , doi-org-9532 208 50 are be VBP doi-org-9532 208 51 constantly constantly RB doi-org-9532 208 52 required require VBN doi-org-9532 208 53 to to TO doi-org-9532 208 54 decide decide VB doi-org-9532 208 55 . . . doi-org-9532 209 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 209 2 32 32 CD doi-org-9532 209 3 Although although IN doi-org-9532 209 4 there there EX doi-org-9532 209 5 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 209 6 been be VBN doi-org-9532 209 7 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 209 8 about about IN doi-org-9532 209 9 whether whether IN doi-org-9532 209 10 public public JJ doi-org-9532 209 11 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 209 12 actually actually RB doi-org-9532 209 13 do do VBP doi-org-9532 209 14 enlighten enlighten VB doi-org-9532 209 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 209 16 public public NN doi-org-9532 209 17 instead instead RB doi-org-9532 209 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 209 19 merely merely RB doi-org-9532 209 20 entertaining entertain VBG doi-org-9532 209 21 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 209 22 , , , doi-org-9532 209 23 justifications justification NNS doi-org-9532 209 24 for for IN doi-org-9532 209 25 using use VBG doi-org-9532 209 26 tax tax NN doi-org-9532 209 27 dollars dollar NNS doi-org-9532 209 28 to to TO doi-org-9532 209 29 pay pay VB doi-org-9532 209 30 for for IN doi-org-9532 209 31 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 209 32 continue continue VBP doi-org-9532 209 33 to to TO doi-org-9532 209 34 focus focus VB doi-org-9532 209 35 on on IN doi-org-9532 209 36 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 209 37 role role NN doi-org-9532 209 38 in in IN doi-org-9532 209 39 promoting promote VBG doi-org-9532 209 40 the the DT doi-org-9532 209 41 free free JJ doi-org-9532 209 42 inquiry inquiry NN doi-org-9532 209 43 necessary necessary JJ doi-org-9532 209 44 for for IN doi-org-9532 209 45 a a DT doi-org-9532 209 46 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 209 47 democracy.33 democracy.33 NNP doi-org-9532 209 48 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 209 49 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 209 50 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 209 51 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 209 52 not not RB doi-org-9532 209 53 address address VB doi-org-9532 209 54 the the DT doi-org-9532 209 55 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 209 56 to to TO doi-org-9532 209 57 Read read VB doi-org-9532 209 58 Statement Statement NNP doi-org-9532 209 59 directly directly RB doi-org-9532 209 60 , , , doi-org-9532 209 61 but but CC doi-org-9532 209 62 the the DT doi-org-9532 209 63 document document NN doi-org-9532 209 64 buttresses buttress VBZ doi-org-9532 209 65 the the DT doi-org-9532 209 66 connection connection NN doi-org-9532 209 67 that that WDT doi-org-9532 209 68 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 209 69 makes make VBZ doi-org-9532 209 70 between between IN doi-org-9532 209 71 the the DT doi-org-9532 209 72 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 209 73 and and CC doi-org-9532 209 74 the the DT doi-org-9532 209 75 ethos ethos NN doi-org-9532 209 76 of of IN doi-org-9532 209 77 American american JJ doi-org-9532 209 78 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 209 79 . . . doi-org-9532 210 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 210 2 language language NN doi-org-9532 210 3 used use VBN doi-org-9532 210 4 by by IN doi-org-9532 210 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 210 6 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 210 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 210 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 210 9 1953 1953 CD doi-org-9532 210 10 statement statement NN doi-org-9532 210 11 closely closely RB doi-org-9532 210 12 resembles resemble VBZ doi-org-9532 210 13 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 210 14 's 's POS doi-org-9532 210 15 1784 1784 CD doi-org-9532 210 16 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 210 17 on on IN doi-org-9532 210 18 enlightenment enlightenment NN doi-org-9532 210 19 . . . doi-org-9532 211 1 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 211 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 211 3 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 211 4 , , , doi-org-9532 211 5 " " `` doi-org-9532 211 6 Nothing nothing NN doi-org-9532 211 7 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 211 8 required require VBN doi-org-9532 211 9 for for IN doi-org-9532 211 10 this this DT doi-org-9532 211 11 enlightenment enlightenment NN doi-org-9532 211 12 , , , doi-org-9532 211 13 however however RB doi-org-9532 211 14 , , , doi-org-9532 211 15 except except IN doi-org-9532 211 16 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 211 17 ; ; : doi-org-9532 211 18 and and CC doi-org-9532 211 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 211 20 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 211 21 in in IN doi-org-9532 211 22 question question NN doi-org-9532 211 23 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 211 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 211 25 least least RBS doi-org-9532 211 26 harmful harmful JJ doi-org-9532 211 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 211 28 all all DT doi-org-9532 211 29 , , , doi-org-9532 211 30 namely namely RB doi-org-9532 211 31 , , , doi-org-9532 211 32 the the DT doi-org-9532 211 33 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 211 34 to to TO doi-org-9532 211 35 use use VB doi-org-9532 211 36 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 211 37 publicly publicly RB doi-org-9532 211 38 in in IN doi-org-9532 211 39 all all DT doi-org-9532 211 40 matters matter NNS doi-org-9532 211 41 … … NFP doi-org-9532 211 42 The the DT doi-org-9532 211 43 public public JJ doi-org-9532 211 44 use use NN doi-org-9532 211 45 of of IN doi-org-9532 211 46 one one NN doi-org-9532 211 47 's 's POS doi-org-9532 211 48 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 211 49 must must MD doi-org-9532 211 50 always always RB doi-org-9532 211 51 be be VB doi-org-9532 211 52 free free JJ doi-org-9532 211 53 , , , doi-org-9532 211 54 and and CC doi-org-9532 211 55 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 211 56 alone alone RB doi-org-9532 211 57 can can MD doi-org-9532 211 58 bring bring VB doi-org-9532 211 59 about about RP doi-org-9532 211 60 enlightenment enlightenment NN doi-org-9532 211 61 among among IN doi-org-9532 211 62 mankind mankind NN doi-org-9532 211 63 . . . doi-org-9532 212 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 212 2 34 34 CD doi-org-9532 212 3 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 212 4 's 's POS doi-org-9532 212 5 emphasis emphasis NN doi-org-9532 212 6 on on IN doi-org-9532 212 7 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 212 8 independence independence NN doi-org-9532 212 9 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 212 10 mirrored mirror VBN doi-org-9532 212 11 in in IN doi-org-9532 212 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 212 13 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 212 14 's 's POS doi-org-9532 212 15 credo credo NN doi-org-9532 212 16 : : : doi-org-9532 212 17 " " `` doi-org-9532 212 18 We -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 212 19 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 212 20 that that IN doi-org-9532 212 21 free free JJ doi-org-9532 212 22 communication communication NN doi-org-9532 212 23 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 212 24 essential essential JJ doi-org-9532 212 25 to to IN doi-org-9532 212 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 212 27 preservation preservation NN doi-org-9532 212 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 212 29 a a DT doi-org-9532 212 30 free free JJ doi-org-9532 212 31 society society NN doi-org-9532 212 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 212 33 a a DT doi-org-9532 212 34 creative creative JJ doi-org-9532 212 35 culture culture NN doi-org-9532 212 36 . . . doi-org-9532 213 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 213 2 35 35 CD doi-org-9532 213 3 The the DT doi-org-9532 213 4 public public JJ doi-org-9532 213 5 library library NN doi-org-9532 213 6 embodies embody VBZ doi-org-9532 213 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 213 8 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 213 9 self self NN doi-org-9532 213 10 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 213 11 reliance reliance NN doi-org-9532 213 12 prized prize VBN doi-org-9532 213 13 by by IN doi-org-9532 213 14 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 213 15 . . . doi-org-9532 214 1 Unlike unlike IN doi-org-9532 214 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 214 3 school school NN doi-org-9532 214 4 or or CC doi-org-9532 214 5 a a DT doi-org-9532 214 6 church church NN doi-org-9532 214 7 where where WRB doi-org-9532 214 8 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 214 9 development development NN doi-org-9532 214 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 214 11 directed direct VBN doi-org-9532 214 12 by by IN doi-org-9532 214 13 a a DT doi-org-9532 214 14 master master NN doi-org-9532 214 15 , , , doi-org-9532 214 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 214 17 library library NN doi-org-9532 214 18 creates create VBZ doi-org-9532 214 19 an an DT doi-org-9532 214 20 open open JJ doi-org-9532 214 21 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 214 22 environment environment NN doi-org-9532 214 23 where where WRB doi-org-9532 214 24 individuals individual NNS doi-org-9532 214 25 are be VBP doi-org-9532 214 26 guided guide VBN doi-org-9532 214 27 by by IN doi-org-9532 214 28 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 214 29 own own JJ doi-org-9532 214 30 curiosity curiosity NN doi-org-9532 214 31 . . . doi-org-9532 215 1 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 215 2 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 215 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 215 4 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 215 5 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 215 6 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 215 7 succeeds succeed VBZ doi-org-9532 215 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 215 9 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 215 10 effort effort NN doi-org-9532 215 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 215 12 trace trace VB doi-org-9532 215 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 215 14 origins origin NNS doi-org-9532 215 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 215 16 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 215 17 purpose purpose NN doi-org-9532 215 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 215 19 library library JJ doi-org-9532 215 20 values value NNS doi-org-9532 215 21 to to IN doi-org-9532 215 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 215 23 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 215 24 . . . doi-org-9532 216 1 His -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 216 2 historical historical JJ doi-org-9532 216 3 account account NN doi-org-9532 216 4 shows show VBZ doi-org-9532 216 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 216 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 216 7 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 216 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 216 9 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 216 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 216 11 a a DT doi-org-9532 216 12 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 216 13 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 216 14 are be VBP doi-org-9532 216 15 not not RB doi-org-9532 216 16 eternal eternal JJ doi-org-9532 216 17 truths truth NNS doi-org-9532 216 18 inherent inherent JJ doi-org-9532 216 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 216 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 216 21 universe universe NN doi-org-9532 216 22 but but CC doi-org-9532 216 23 are be VBP doi-org-9532 216 24 embedded embed VBN doi-org-9532 216 25 in in IN doi-org-9532 216 26 specific specific JJ doi-org-9532 216 27 social social JJ doi-org-9532 216 28 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 216 29 designed design VBN doi-org-9532 216 30 to to TO doi-org-9532 216 31 achieve achieve VB doi-org-9532 216 32 specific specific JJ doi-org-9532 216 33 political political JJ doi-org-9532 216 34 ends end NNS doi-org-9532 216 35 . . . doi-org-9532 217 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 217 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 217 3 Page page NN doi-org-9532 217 4 66 66 CD doi-org-9532 217 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 217 6 Liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 217 7 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 217 8 The the DT doi-org-9532 217 9 thesis thesis NN doi-org-9532 217 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 217 11 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 217 12 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 217 13 was be VBD doi-org-9532 217 14 developed develop VBN doi-org-9532 217 15 by by IN doi-org-9532 217 16 several several JJ doi-org-9532 217 17 American american JJ doi-org-9532 217 18 political political JJ doi-org-9532 217 19 philosophers philosopher NNS doi-org-9532 217 20 in in IN doi-org-9532 217 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 217 22 late late JJ doi-org-9532 217 23 twentieth twentieth JJ doi-org-9532 217 24 century century NN doi-org-9532 217 25 in in IN doi-org-9532 217 26 response response NN doi-org-9532 217 27 to to IN doi-org-9532 217 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 217 29 same same JJ doi-org-9532 217 30 political political JJ doi-org-9532 217 31 conflicts conflict NNS doi-org-9532 217 32 that that WDT doi-org-9532 217 33 led lead VBD doi-org-9532 217 34 to to IN doi-org-9532 217 35 the the DT doi-org-9532 217 36 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 217 37 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 217 38 about about IN doi-org-9532 217 39 library library JJ doi-org-9532 217 40 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 217 41 during during IN doi-org-9532 217 42 the the DT doi-org-9532 217 43 1970s 1970s CD doi-org-9532 217 44 . . . doi-org-9532 218 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 218 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 218 3 famous famous JJ doi-org-9532 218 4 1978 1978 CD doi-org-9532 218 5 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 218 6 on on IN doi-org-9532 218 7 " " `` doi-org-9532 218 8 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 218 9 , , , doi-org-9532 218 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 218 11 Ronald Ronald NNP doi-org-9532 218 12 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 218 13 asked ask VBD doi-org-9532 218 14 if if IN doi-org-9532 218 15 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 218 16 still still RB doi-org-9532 218 17 was be VBD doi-org-9532 218 18 a a DT doi-org-9532 218 19 viable viable JJ doi-org-9532 218 20 political political JJ doi-org-9532 218 21 philosophy philosophy NN doi-org-9532 218 22 after after IN doi-org-9532 218 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 218 24 disaster disaster NN doi-org-9532 218 25 of of IN doi-org-9532 218 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 218 27 Vietnam Vietnam NNP doi-org-9532 218 28 War War NNP doi-org-9532 218 29 — — : doi-org-9532 218 30 conducted conduct VBN doi-org-9532 218 31 by by IN doi-org-9532 218 32 Americans Americans NNPS doi-org-9532 218 33 who who WP doi-org-9532 218 34 called call VBD doi-org-9532 218 35 themselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 218 36 liberals liberal NNS doi-org-9532 218 37 — — : doi-org-9532 218 38 and and CC doi-org-9532 218 39 the the DT doi-org-9532 218 40 dissolution dissolution NN doi-org-9532 218 41 of of IN doi-org-9532 218 42 the the DT doi-org-9532 218 43 New New NNP doi-org-9532 218 44 Deal Deal NNP doi-org-9532 218 45 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 218 46 consensus consensus NN doi-org-9532 218 47 . . . doi-org-9532 219 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 219 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 219 3 1970s 1970 NNS doi-org-9532 219 4 , , , doi-org-9532 219 5 many many JJ doi-org-9532 219 6 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 219 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 219 8 Vietnam Vietnam NNP doi-org-9532 219 9 " " `` doi-org-9532 219 10 exposed expose VBD doi-org-9532 219 11 hidden hidden JJ doi-org-9532 219 12 connections connection NNS doi-org-9532 219 13 between between IN doi-org-9532 219 14 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 219 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 219 16 exploitation exploitation NN doi-org-9532 219 17 " " '' doi-org-9532 219 18 and and CC doi-org-9532 219 19 decided decide VBD doi-org-9532 219 20 that that IN doi-org-9532 219 21 " " `` doi-org-9532 219 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 219 23 line line NN doi-org-9532 219 24 between between IN doi-org-9532 219 25 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 219 26 and and CC doi-org-9532 219 27 conservatism conservatism NN doi-org-9532 219 28 was be VBD doi-org-9532 219 29 … … NFP doi-org-9532 219 30 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 219 31 a a DT doi-org-9532 219 32 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 219 33 sham sham NN doi-org-9532 219 34 . . . doi-org-9532 220 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 220 2 36 36 CD doi-org-9532 220 3 To to TO doi-org-9532 220 4 continue continue VB doi-org-9532 220 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 220 6 believe believe VB doi-org-9532 220 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 220 8 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 220 9 as as IN doi-org-9532 220 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 220 11 morally morally RB doi-org-9532 220 12 coherent coherent JJ doi-org-9532 220 13 political political JJ doi-org-9532 220 14 philosophy philosophy NN doi-org-9532 220 15 , , , doi-org-9532 220 16 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 220 17 sought seek VBD doi-org-9532 220 18 to to TO doi-org-9532 220 19 find find VB doi-org-9532 220 20 a a DT doi-org-9532 220 21 deeper deep JJR doi-org-9532 220 22 principle principle NN doi-org-9532 220 23 beneath beneath IN doi-org-9532 220 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 220 25 flawed flawed JJ doi-org-9532 220 26 policies policy NNS doi-org-9532 220 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 220 28 Cold Cold NNP doi-org-9532 220 29 War War NNP doi-org-9532 220 30 politicians politician NNS doi-org-9532 220 31 . . . doi-org-9532 221 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 221 2 principle principle NN doi-org-9532 221 3 that that WDT doi-org-9532 221 4 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 221 5 proposed propose VBD doi-org-9532 221 6 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 221 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 221 8 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 221 9 " " `` doi-org-9532 221 10 government government NN doi-org-9532 221 11 must must MD doi-org-9532 221 12 be be VB doi-org-9532 221 13 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 221 14 on on IN doi-org-9532 221 15 what what WP doi-org-9532 221 16 might may MD doi-org-9532 221 17 be be VB doi-org-9532 221 18 called call VBN doi-org-9532 221 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 221 20 question question NN doi-org-9532 221 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 221 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 221 23 good good JJ doi-org-9532 221 24 life life NN doi-org-9532 221 25 . . . doi-org-9532 222 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 222 2 37 37 CD doi-org-9532 222 3 Because because IN doi-org-9532 222 4 people people NNS doi-org-9532 222 5 have have VBP doi-org-9532 222 6 differing differ VBG doi-org-9532 222 7 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 222 8 about about IN doi-org-9532 222 9 " " `` doi-org-9532 222 10 what what WP doi-org-9532 222 11 gives give VBZ doi-org-9532 222 12 value value NN doi-org-9532 222 13 to to IN doi-org-9532 222 14 life life NN doi-org-9532 222 15 , , , doi-org-9532 222 16 " " '' doi-org-9532 222 17 liberals liberal NNS doi-org-9532 222 18 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 222 19 that that IN doi-org-9532 222 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 222 21 only only JJ doi-org-9532 222 22 way way NN doi-org-9532 222 23 " " '' doi-org-9532 222 24 for for IN doi-org-9532 222 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 222 26 government government NN doi-org-9532 222 27 to to TO doi-org-9532 222 28 treat treat VB doi-org-9532 222 29 all all PDT doi-org-9532 222 30 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 222 31 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 222 32 as as IN doi-org-9532 222 33 free free JJ doi-org-9532 222 34 , , , doi-org-9532 222 35 or or CC doi-org-9532 222 36 as as RB doi-org-9532 222 37 independent independent JJ doi-org-9532 222 38 , , , doi-org-9532 222 39 or or CC doi-org-9532 222 40 with with IN doi-org-9532 222 41 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 222 42 dignity dignity NN doi-org-9532 222 43 " " '' doi-org-9532 222 44 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 222 45 to to TO doi-org-9532 222 46 allow allow VB doi-org-9532 222 47 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 222 48 to to TO doi-org-9532 222 49 live live VB doi-org-9532 222 50 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 222 51 to to IN doi-org-9532 222 52 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 222 53 own own JJ doi-org-9532 222 54 standards standard NNS doi-org-9532 222 55 of of IN doi-org-9532 222 56 virtue virtue NN doi-org-9532 222 57 as as RB doi-org-9532 222 58 much much JJ doi-org-9532 222 59 as as IN doi-org-9532 222 60 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 222 61 practically practically RB doi-org-9532 222 62 possible possible JJ doi-org-9532 222 63 . . . doi-org-9532 223 1 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 223 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 223 3 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 223 4 , , , doi-org-9532 223 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 223 6 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 223 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 223 8 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 223 9 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 223 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 223 11 compatible compatible JJ doi-org-9532 223 12 with with IN doi-org-9532 223 13 differing differ VBG doi-org-9532 223 14 political political JJ doi-org-9532 223 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 223 16 economic economic JJ doi-org-9532 223 17 policies policy NNS doi-org-9532 223 18 . . . doi-org-9532 224 1 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 224 2 himself -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 224 3 supported support VBD doi-org-9532 224 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 224 5 market market NN doi-org-9532 224 6 economy economy NN doi-org-9532 224 7 modified modify VBN doi-org-9532 224 8 by by IN doi-org-9532 224 9 income income NN doi-org-9532 224 10 redistribution redistribution NN doi-org-9532 224 11 and and CC doi-org-9532 224 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 224 13 social social JJ doi-org-9532 224 14 safety safety NN doi-org-9532 224 15 net net NN doi-org-9532 224 16 but but CC doi-org-9532 224 17 thought think VBD doi-org-9532 224 18 that that IN doi-org-9532 224 19 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 224 20 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 224 21 also also RB doi-org-9532 224 22 was be VBD doi-org-9532 224 23 compatible compatible JJ doi-org-9532 224 24 with with IN doi-org-9532 224 25 more more JJR doi-org-9532 224 26 extreme extreme JJ doi-org-9532 224 27 versions version NNS doi-org-9532 224 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 224 29 laissez laissez NN doi-org-9532 224 30 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 224 31 faire faire NN doi-org-9532 224 32 or or CC doi-org-9532 224 33 with with IN doi-org-9532 224 34 socialism socialism NN doi-org-9532 224 35 . . . doi-org-9532 225 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 225 2 key key JJ doi-org-9532 225 3 difference difference NN doi-org-9532 225 4 between between IN doi-org-9532 225 5 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 225 6 and and CC doi-org-9532 225 7 competing compete VBG doi-org-9532 225 8 political political JJ doi-org-9532 225 9 philosophies philosophy NNS doi-org-9532 225 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 225 11 not not RB doi-org-9532 225 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 225 13 matter matter NN doi-org-9532 225 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 225 15 specific specific JJ doi-org-9532 225 16 economic economic JJ doi-org-9532 225 17 policies policy NNS doi-org-9532 225 18 but but CC doi-org-9532 225 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 225 20 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 225 21 belief belief NN doi-org-9532 225 22 that that IN doi-org-9532 225 23 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 225 24 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 225 25 to to TO doi-org-9532 225 26 decide decide VB doi-org-9532 225 27 for for IN doi-org-9532 225 28 themselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 225 29 how how WRB doi-org-9532 225 30 to to TO doi-org-9532 225 31 live live VB doi-org-9532 225 32 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 225 33 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 225 34 . . . doi-org-9532 226 1 Non non JJ doi-org-9532 226 2 - - JJ doi-org-9532 226 3 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 226 4 political political JJ doi-org-9532 226 5 philosophies philosophy NNS doi-org-9532 226 6 assume assume VBP doi-org-9532 226 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 226 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 226 9 government government NN doi-org-9532 226 10 must must MD doi-org-9532 226 11 have have VB doi-org-9532 226 12 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 226 13 own own JJ doi-org-9532 226 14 " " '' doi-org-9532 226 15 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 226 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 226 17 what what WP doi-org-9532 226 18 human human JJ doi-org-9532 226 19 beings being NNS doi-org-9532 226 20 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 226 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 226 22 be be VB doi-org-9532 226 23 " " `` doi-org-9532 226 24 and and CC doi-org-9532 226 25 then then RB doi-org-9532 226 26 develop develop VB doi-org-9532 226 27 policies policy NNS doi-org-9532 226 28 that that WDT doi-org-9532 226 29 encourage encourage VBP doi-org-9532 226 30 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 226 31 to to TO doi-org-9532 226 32 live live VB doi-org-9532 226 33 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 226 34 to to IN doi-org-9532 226 35 appropriate appropriate JJ doi-org-9532 226 36 standards standard NNS doi-org-9532 226 37 of of IN doi-org-9532 226 38 virtue.38 virtue.38 NNP doi-org-9532 226 39 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 226 40 focuses focus VBZ doi-org-9532 226 41 on on IN doi-org-9532 226 42 increasing increase VBG doi-org-9532 226 43 the the DT doi-org-9532 226 44 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 226 45 of of IN doi-org-9532 226 46 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 226 47 to to TO doi-org-9532 226 48 choose choose VB doi-org-9532 226 49 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 226 50 own own JJ doi-org-9532 226 51 version version NN doi-org-9532 226 52 of of IN doi-org-9532 226 53 the the DT doi-org-9532 226 54 good good JJ doi-org-9532 226 55 life life NN doi-org-9532 226 56 , , , doi-org-9532 226 57 whereas whereas IN doi-org-9532 226 58 other other JJ doi-org-9532 226 59 forms form NNS doi-org-9532 226 60 of of IN doi-org-9532 226 61 government government NN doi-org-9532 226 62 encourage encourage NN doi-org-9532 226 63 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 226 64 with with IN doi-org-9532 226 65 more more RBR doi-org-9532 226 66 or or CC doi-org-9532 226 67 less less JJR doi-org-9532 226 68 force force NN doi-org-9532 226 69 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 226 70 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 226 71 to to TO doi-org-9532 226 72 live live VB doi-org-9532 226 73 a a DT doi-org-9532 226 74 good good JJ doi-org-9532 226 75 life life NN doi-org-9532 226 76 as as IN doi-org-9532 226 77 the the DT doi-org-9532 226 78 government government NN doi-org-9532 226 79 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 226 80 defined define VBN doi-org-9532 226 81 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 226 82 . . . doi-org-9532 227 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 227 2 Political Political NNP doi-org-9532 227 3 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 227 4 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 227 5 1993 1993 CD doi-org-9532 227 6 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 227 7 , , , doi-org-9532 227 8 John John NNP doi-org-9532 227 9 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 227 10 , , , doi-org-9532 227 11 perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 227 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 227 13 most most RBS doi-org-9532 227 14 influential influential JJ doi-org-9532 227 15 American american JJ doi-org-9532 227 16 political political JJ doi-org-9532 227 17 philosopher philosopher NN doi-org-9532 227 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 227 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 227 20 twentieth twentieth JJ doi-org-9532 227 21 century century NN doi-org-9532 227 22 , , , doi-org-9532 227 23 built build VBD doi-org-9532 227 24 a a DT doi-org-9532 227 25 complete complete JJ doi-org-9532 227 26 system system NN doi-org-9532 227 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 227 28 political political JJ doi-org-9532 227 29 morality morality NN doi-org-9532 227 30 out out IN doi-org-9532 227 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 227 32 the the DT doi-org-9532 227 33 insights insight NNS doi-org-9532 227 34 in in IN doi-org-9532 227 35 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 227 36 's 's POS doi-org-9532 227 37 essay.39 essay.39 NNP doi-org-9532 227 38 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 227 39 to to IN doi-org-9532 227 40 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 227 41 , , , doi-org-9532 227 42 pluralistic pluralistic JJ doi-org-9532 227 43 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 227 44 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 227 45 are be VBP doi-org-9532 227 46 composed compose VBN doi-org-9532 227 47 of of IN doi-org-9532 227 48 groups group NNS doi-org-9532 227 49 of of IN doi-org-9532 227 50 people people NNS doi-org-9532 227 51 who who WP doi-org-9532 227 52 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 227 53 in in IN doi-org-9532 227 54 a a DT doi-org-9532 227 55 wide wide JJ doi-org-9532 227 56 variety variety NN doi-org-9532 227 57 of of IN doi-org-9532 227 58 " " `` doi-org-9532 227 59 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 227 60 " " '' doi-org-9532 227 61 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 227 62 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 227 63 , , , doi-org-9532 227 64 including include VBG doi-org-9532 227 65 Catholicism Catholicism NNP doi-org-9532 227 66 , , , doi-org-9532 227 67 Lutheranism Lutheranism NNP doi-org-9532 227 68 , , , doi-org-9532 227 69 Islam Islam NNP doi-org-9532 227 70 , , , doi-org-9532 227 71 Utilitarianism Utilitarianism NNP doi-org-9532 227 72 , , , doi-org-9532 227 73 Kantianism Kantianism NNP doi-org-9532 227 74 , , , doi-org-9532 227 75 Marxism Marxism NNP doi-org-9532 227 76 , , , doi-org-9532 227 77 and and CC doi-org-9532 227 78 many many JJ doi-org-9532 227 79 others other NNS doi-org-9532 227 80 . . . doi-org-9532 228 1 Comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 228 2 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 228 3 philosophies philosophy NNS doi-org-9532 228 4 offer offer VBP doi-org-9532 228 5 a a DT doi-org-9532 228 6 thoroughgoing thoroughgoe VBG doi-org-9532 228 7 account account NN doi-org-9532 228 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 228 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 228 10 universe universe NN doi-org-9532 228 11 and and CC doi-org-9532 228 12 human human JJ doi-org-9532 228 13 nature nature NN doi-org-9532 228 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 228 15 explain explain VB doi-org-9532 228 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 228 17 standards standard NNS doi-org-9532 228 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 228 19 virtue virtue NN doi-org-9532 228 20 that that WDT doi-org-9532 228 21 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 228 22 to to TO doi-org-9532 228 23 govern govern VB doi-org-9532 228 24 human human JJ doi-org-9532 228 25 behavior behavior NN doi-org-9532 228 26 . . . doi-org-9532 229 1 Differing differ VBG doi-org-9532 229 2 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 229 3 philosophies philosophy NNS doi-org-9532 229 4 offer offer VBP doi-org-9532 229 5 conflicting conflicting NN doi-org-9532 229 6 accounts account NNS doi-org-9532 229 7 . . . doi-org-9532 230 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 230 2 example example NN doi-org-9532 230 3 , , , doi-org-9532 230 4 Muslims Muslims NNPS doi-org-9532 230 5 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 230 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 230 7 human human JJ doi-org-9532 230 8 behavior behavior NN doi-org-9532 230 9 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 230 10 to to TO doi-org-9532 230 11 be be VB doi-org-9532 230 12 consistent consistent JJ doi-org-9532 230 13 with with IN doi-org-9532 230 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 230 15 word word NN doi-org-9532 230 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 230 17 God God NNP doi-org-9532 230 18 as as IN doi-org-9532 230 19 transcribed transcribe VBN doi-org-9532 230 20 by by IN doi-org-9532 230 21 Muhammad Muhammad NNP doi-org-9532 230 22 in in IN doi-org-9532 230 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 230 24 Quran Quran NNP doi-org-9532 230 25 , , , doi-org-9532 230 26 whereas whereas IN doi-org-9532 230 27 Utilitarians utilitarian NNS doi-org-9532 230 28 dismiss dismiss VBP doi-org-9532 230 29 all all DT doi-org-9532 230 30 forms form NNS doi-org-9532 230 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 230 32 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 230 33 belief belief NN doi-org-9532 230 34 and and CC doi-org-9532 230 35 argue argue VBP doi-org-9532 230 36 that that IN doi-org-9532 230 37 human human JJ doi-org-9532 230 38 behavior behavior NN doi-org-9532 230 39 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 230 40 to to TO doi-org-9532 230 41 be be VB doi-org-9532 230 42 governed govern VBN doi-org-9532 230 43 by by IN doi-org-9532 230 44 the the DT doi-org-9532 230 45 desire desire NN doi-org-9532 230 46 to to TO doi-org-9532 230 47 produce produce VB doi-org-9532 230 48 the the DT doi-org-9532 230 49 greatest great JJS doi-org-9532 230 50 amount amount NN doi-org-9532 230 51 of of IN doi-org-9532 230 52 collective collective JJ doi-org-9532 230 53 happiness happiness NN doi-org-9532 230 54 for for IN doi-org-9532 230 55 humanity humanity NN doi-org-9532 230 56 . . . doi-org-9532 231 1 Other other JJ doi-org-9532 231 2 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 231 3 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 231 4 philosophies philosophy NNS doi-org-9532 231 5 offer offer VBP doi-org-9532 231 6 many many JJ doi-org-9532 231 7 other other JJ doi-org-9532 231 8 incompatible incompatible JJ doi-org-9532 231 9 theories theory NNS doi-org-9532 231 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 231 11 virtue virtue NN doi-org-9532 231 12 . . . doi-org-9532 232 1 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 232 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 232 3 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 232 4 , , , doi-org-9532 232 5 most most JJS doi-org-9532 232 6 political political JJ doi-org-9532 232 7 philosophers philosopher NNS doi-org-9532 232 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 232 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 232 10 past past NN doi-org-9532 232 11 assumed assume VBD doi-org-9532 232 12 that that IN doi-org-9532 232 13 political political JJ doi-org-9532 232 14 virtue virtue NN doi-org-9532 232 15 must must MD doi-org-9532 232 16 be be VB doi-org-9532 232 17 embedded embed VBN doi-org-9532 232 18 in in IN doi-org-9532 232 19 a a DT doi-org-9532 232 20 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 232 21 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 232 22 doctrine doctrine NN doi-org-9532 232 23 . . . doi-org-9532 233 1 To to TO doi-org-9532 233 2 build build VB doi-org-9532 233 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 233 4 just just JJ doi-org-9532 233 5 society society NN doi-org-9532 233 6 , , , doi-org-9532 233 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 233 8 philosopher philosopher NN doi-org-9532 233 9 assumes assume VBZ doi-org-9532 233 10 that that IN doi-org-9532 233 11 leaders leader NNS doi-org-9532 233 12 must must MD doi-org-9532 233 13 first first RB doi-org-9532 233 14 evaluate evaluate VB doi-org-9532 233 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 233 16 various various JJ doi-org-9532 233 17 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 233 18 systems system NNS doi-org-9532 233 19 available available JJ doi-org-9532 233 20 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 233 21 End end NN doi-org-9532 233 22 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 233 23 67 67 CD doi-org-9532 233 24 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 233 25 to to IN doi-org-9532 233 26 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 233 27 . . . doi-org-9532 234 1 Then then RB doi-org-9532 234 2 , , , doi-org-9532 234 3 after after IN doi-org-9532 234 4 choosing choose VBG doi-org-9532 234 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 234 6 right right JJ doi-org-9532 234 7 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 234 8 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 234 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 234 10 value value NN doi-org-9532 234 11 , , , doi-org-9532 234 12 leaders leader NNS doi-org-9532 234 13 can can MD doi-org-9532 234 14 evaluate evaluate VB doi-org-9532 234 15 specific specific JJ doi-org-9532 234 16 political political JJ doi-org-9532 234 17 policies policy NNS doi-org-9532 234 18 based base VBN doi-org-9532 234 19 on on IN doi-org-9532 234 20 how how WRB doi-org-9532 234 21 well well RB doi-org-9532 234 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 234 23 policies policy NNS doi-org-9532 234 24 promote promote VBP doi-org-9532 234 25 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 234 26 chosen choose VBN doi-org-9532 234 27 standards standard NNS doi-org-9532 234 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 234 29 virtue virtue NN doi-org-9532 234 30 . . . doi-org-9532 235 1 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 235 2 considers consider VBZ doi-org-9532 235 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 235 4 political political JJ doi-org-9532 235 5 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 235 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 235 7 an an DT doi-org-9532 235 8 alternative alternative NN doi-org-9532 235 9 to to IN doi-org-9532 235 10 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 235 11 political political JJ doi-org-9532 235 12 philosophies philosophy NNS doi-org-9532 235 13 because because IN doi-org-9532 235 14 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 235 15 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 235 16 based base VBN doi-org-9532 235 17 on on IN doi-org-9532 235 18 limited limited JJ doi-org-9532 235 19 standards standard NNS doi-org-9532 235 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 235 21 political political JJ doi-org-9532 235 22 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 235 23 that that WDT doi-org-9532 235 24 need nee MD doi-org-9532 235 25 not not RB doi-org-9532 235 26 choose choose VB doi-org-9532 235 27 between between IN doi-org-9532 235 28 competing compete VBG doi-org-9532 235 29 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 235 30 theories theory NNS doi-org-9532 235 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 235 32 morality morality NN doi-org-9532 235 33 . . . doi-org-9532 236 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 236 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 236 3 pluralistic pluralistic JJ doi-org-9532 236 4 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 236 5 society society NN doi-org-9532 236 6 , , , doi-org-9532 236 7 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 236 8 believes believe VBZ doi-org-9532 236 9 that that IN doi-org-9532 236 10 almost almost RB doi-org-9532 236 11 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 236 12 can can MD doi-org-9532 236 13 agree agree VB doi-org-9532 236 14 on on IN doi-org-9532 236 15 shared shared JJ doi-org-9532 236 16 standards standard NNS doi-org-9532 236 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 236 18 social social JJ doi-org-9532 236 19 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 236 20 even even RB doi-org-9532 236 21 if if IN doi-org-9532 236 22 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 236 23 never never RB doi-org-9532 236 24 will will MD doi-org-9532 236 25 agree agree VB doi-org-9532 236 26 about about IN doi-org-9532 236 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 236 28 existence existence NN doi-org-9532 236 29 of of IN doi-org-9532 236 30 God God NNP doi-org-9532 236 31 or or CC doi-org-9532 236 32 other other JJ doi-org-9532 236 33 contested contest VBN doi-org-9532 236 34 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 236 35 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 236 36 . . . doi-org-9532 237 1 Social social JJ doi-org-9532 237 2 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 237 3 in in IN doi-org-9532 237 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 237 5 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 237 6 society society NN doi-org-9532 237 7 focuses focus VBZ doi-org-9532 237 8 on on IN doi-org-9532 237 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 237 10 virtues virtue NNS doi-org-9532 237 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 237 12 shared share VBN doi-org-9532 237 13 civic civic JJ doi-org-9532 237 14 life life NN doi-org-9532 237 15 , , , doi-org-9532 237 16 in in IN doi-org-9532 237 17 which which WDT doi-org-9532 237 18 diverse diverse JJ doi-org-9532 237 19 communities community NNS doi-org-9532 237 20 with with IN doi-org-9532 237 21 differing differ VBG doi-org-9532 237 22 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 237 23 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 237 24 must must MD doi-org-9532 237 25 cooperate cooperate VB doi-org-9532 237 26 to to TO doi-org-9532 237 27 achieve achieve VB doi-org-9532 237 28 social social JJ doi-org-9532 237 29 ends end NNS doi-org-9532 237 30 , , , doi-org-9532 237 31 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 237 32 than than IN doi-org-9532 237 33 on on IN doi-org-9532 237 34 the the DT doi-org-9532 237 35 virtues virtue NNS doi-org-9532 237 36 of of IN doi-org-9532 237 37 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 237 38 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 237 39 systems system NNS doi-org-9532 237 40 . . . doi-org-9532 238 1 Governmental governmental JJ doi-org-9532 238 2 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 238 3 between between IN doi-org-9532 238 4 differing differ VBG doi-org-9532 238 5 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 238 6 systems system NNS doi-org-9532 238 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 238 8 value value NN doi-org-9532 238 9 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 238 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 238 11 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 238 12 feature feature NN doi-org-9532 238 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 238 14 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 238 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 238 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 238 17 politically politically RB doi-org-9532 238 18 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 238 19 state state NN doi-org-9532 238 20 , , , doi-org-9532 238 21 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 238 22 to to IN doi-org-9532 238 23 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 238 24 . . . doi-org-9532 239 1 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 239 2 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 239 3 necessary necessary JJ doi-org-9532 239 4 to to TO doi-org-9532 239 5 achieve achieve VB doi-org-9532 239 6 a a DT doi-org-9532 239 7 state state NN doi-org-9532 239 8 that that WDT doi-org-9532 239 9 can can MD doi-org-9532 239 10 be be VB doi-org-9532 239 11 legitimate legitimate JJ doi-org-9532 239 12 for for IN doi-org-9532 239 13 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 239 14 regardless regardless RB doi-org-9532 239 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 239 16 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 239 17 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 239 18 system system NN doi-org-9532 239 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 239 20 values value NNS doi-org-9532 239 21 . . . doi-org-9532 240 1 Because because IN doi-org-9532 240 2 no no DT doi-org-9532 240 3 one one PRP doi-org-9532 240 4 would would MD doi-org-9532 240 5 agree agree VB doi-org-9532 240 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 240 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 240 8 society society NN doi-org-9532 240 9 that that WDT doi-org-9532 240 10 systematically systematically RB doi-org-9532 240 11 suppresses suppress VBZ doi-org-9532 240 12 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 240 13 own own JJ doi-org-9532 240 14 values value NNS doi-org-9532 240 15 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 240 16 just just RB doi-org-9532 240 17 , , , doi-org-9532 240 18 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 240 19 must must MD doi-org-9532 240 20 agree agree VB doi-org-9532 240 21 not not RB doi-org-9532 240 22 to to TO doi-org-9532 240 23 use use VB doi-org-9532 240 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 240 25 power power NN doi-org-9532 240 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 240 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 240 28 state state NN doi-org-9532 240 29 to to TO doi-org-9532 240 30 impose impose VB doi-org-9532 240 31 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 240 32 views view NNS doi-org-9532 240 33 on on IN doi-org-9532 240 34 others other NNS doi-org-9532 240 35 . . . doi-org-9532 241 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 241 2 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 241 3 who who WP doi-org-9532 241 4 agrees agree VBZ doi-org-9532 241 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 241 6 play play VB doi-org-9532 241 7 by by IN doi-org-9532 241 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 241 9 rules rule NNS doi-org-9532 241 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 241 11 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 241 12 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 241 13 — — : doi-org-9532 241 14 and and CC doi-org-9532 241 15 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 241 16 not not RB doi-org-9532 241 17 use use VB doi-org-9532 241 18 force force NN doi-org-9532 241 19 or or CC doi-org-9532 241 20 intimidation intimidation NN doi-org-9532 241 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 241 22 impose impose VB doi-org-9532 241 23 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 241 24 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 241 25 on on IN doi-org-9532 241 26 others other NNS doi-org-9532 241 27 — — : doi-org-9532 241 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 241 29 state state NN doi-org-9532 241 30 should should MD doi-org-9532 241 31 not not RB doi-org-9532 241 32 privilege privilege VB doi-org-9532 241 33 any any DT doi-org-9532 241 34 one one CD doi-org-9532 241 35 view view NN doi-org-9532 241 36 above above IN doi-org-9532 241 37 others other NNS doi-org-9532 241 38 . . . doi-org-9532 242 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 242 2 University University NNP doi-org-9532 242 3 of of IN doi-org-9532 242 4 Chicago Chicago NNP doi-org-9532 242 5 philosopher philosopher NN doi-org-9532 242 6 Martha Martha NNP doi-org-9532 242 7 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 242 8 , , , doi-org-9532 242 9 who who WP doi-org-9532 242 10 adopted adopt VBD doi-org-9532 242 11 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 242 12 's 's POS doi-org-9532 242 13 political political JJ doi-org-9532 242 14 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 242 15 , , , doi-org-9532 242 16 offers offer VBZ doi-org-9532 242 17 a a DT doi-org-9532 242 18 powerful powerful JJ doi-org-9532 242 19 explanation explanation NN doi-org-9532 242 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 242 21 how how WRB doi-org-9532 242 22 governmental governmental JJ doi-org-9532 242 23 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 242 24 promotes promote VBZ doi-org-9532 242 25 a a DT doi-org-9532 242 26 society society NN doi-org-9532 242 27 in in IN doi-org-9532 242 28 which which WDT doi-org-9532 242 29 all all DT doi-org-9532 242 30 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 242 31 are be VBP doi-org-9532 242 32 treated treat VBN doi-org-9532 242 33 with with IN doi-org-9532 242 34 dignity dignity NN doi-org-9532 242 35 : : : doi-org-9532 242 36 Respect respect NN doi-org-9532 242 37 in in IN doi-org-9532 242 38 political political JJ doi-org-9532 242 39 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 242 40 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 242 41 , , , doi-org-9532 242 42 first first RB doi-org-9532 242 43 and and CC doi-org-9532 242 44 foremost foremost RB doi-org-9532 242 45 , , , doi-org-9532 242 46 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 242 47 for for IN doi-org-9532 242 48 persons person NNS doi-org-9532 242 49 , , , doi-org-9532 242 50 not not RB doi-org-9532 242 51 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 242 52 for for IN doi-org-9532 242 53 the the DT doi-org-9532 242 54 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 242 55 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 242 56 hold hold VBP doi-org-9532 242 57 , , , doi-org-9532 242 58 for for IN doi-org-9532 242 59 the the DT doi-org-9532 242 60 grounding grounding NN doi-org-9532 242 61 of of IN doi-org-9532 242 62 those those DT doi-org-9532 242 63 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 242 64 , , , doi-org-9532 242 65 or or CC doi-org-9532 242 66 for for IN doi-org-9532 242 67 anything anything NN doi-org-9532 242 68 else else RB doi-org-9532 242 69 about about IN doi-org-9532 242 70 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 242 71 . . . doi-org-9532 243 1 It -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 243 2 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 243 3 because because IN doi-org-9532 243 4 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 243 5 respect respect VBP doi-org-9532 243 6 persons person NNS doi-org-9532 243 7 that that WDT doi-org-9532 243 8 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 243 9 think think VBP doi-org-9532 243 10 that that IN doi-org-9532 243 11 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 243 12 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 243 13 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 243 14 deserve deserve VBP doi-org-9532 243 15 space space NN doi-org-9532 243 16 to to TO doi-org-9532 243 17 unfold unfold VB doi-org-9532 243 18 themselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 243 19 , , , doi-org-9532 243 20 and and CC doi-org-9532 243 21 deserve deserve VBP doi-org-9532 243 22 respectful respectful JJ doi-org-9532 243 23 , , , doi-org-9532 243 24 nonderogatory nonderogatory JJ doi-org-9532 243 25 treatment treatment NN doi-org-9532 243 26 from from IN doi-org-9532 243 27 government government NN doi-org-9532 243 28 … … . doi-org-9532 243 29 For for IN doi-org-9532 243 30 a a DT doi-org-9532 243 31 public public JJ doi-org-9532 243 32 official official NN doi-org-9532 243 33 in in IN doi-org-9532 243 34 a a DT doi-org-9532 243 35 leading leading JJ doi-org-9532 243 36 role role NN doi-org-9532 243 37 to to TO doi-org-9532 243 38 say say VB doi-org-9532 243 39 " " `` doi-org-9532 243 40 X X NNP doi-org-9532 243 41 's 's POS doi-org-9532 243 42 doctrine doctrine NN doi-org-9532 243 43 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 243 44 not not RB doi-org-9532 243 45 as as RB doi-org-9532 243 46 well well RB doi-org-9532 243 47 grounded ground VBN doi-org-9532 243 48 as as IN doi-org-9532 243 49 Y Y NNP doi-org-9532 243 50 's 's POS doi-org-9532 243 51 " " `` doi-org-9532 243 52 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 243 53 , , , doi-org-9532 243 54 inevitably inevitably RB doi-org-9532 243 55 , , , doi-org-9532 243 56 to to TO doi-org-9532 243 57 denigrate denigrate VB doi-org-9532 243 58 X x NN doi-org-9532 243 59 , , , doi-org-9532 243 60 and and CC doi-org-9532 243 61 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 243 62 want want VBP doi-org-9532 243 63 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 243 64 political political JJ doi-org-9532 243 65 principles principle NNS doi-org-9532 243 66 to to TO doi-org-9532 243 67 show show VB doi-org-9532 243 68 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 243 69 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 243 70 to to IN doi-org-9532 243 71 X x NN doi-org-9532 243 72 and and CC doi-org-9532 243 73 Y.40 y.40 NN doi-org-9532 243 74 Although although IN doi-org-9532 243 75 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 243 76 supports support VBZ doi-org-9532 243 77 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 243 78 's 's POS doi-org-9532 243 79 overall overall JJ doi-org-9532 243 80 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 243 81 , , , doi-org-9532 243 82 she -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 243 83 develops develop VBZ doi-org-9532 243 84 an an DT doi-org-9532 243 85 important important JJ doi-org-9532 243 86 critique critique NN doi-org-9532 243 87 of of IN doi-org-9532 243 88 one one CD doi-org-9532 243 89 aspect aspect NN doi-org-9532 243 90 of of IN doi-org-9532 243 91 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 243 92 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 243 93 . . . doi-org-9532 244 1 Rawls rawl NNS doi-org-9532 244 2 thought think VBD doi-org-9532 244 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 244 4 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 244 5 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 244 6 should should MD doi-org-9532 244 7 be be VB doi-org-9532 244 8 open open JJ doi-org-9532 244 9 to to IN doi-org-9532 244 10 all all DT doi-org-9532 244 11 " " `` doi-org-9532 244 12 reasonable reasonable JJ doi-org-9532 244 13 " " '' doi-org-9532 244 14 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 244 15 . . . doi-org-9532 245 1 So so RB doi-org-9532 245 2 , , , doi-org-9532 245 3 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 245 4 asks ask VBZ doi-org-9532 245 5 , , , doi-org-9532 245 6 what what WP doi-org-9532 245 7 makes make VBZ doi-org-9532 245 8 a a DT doi-org-9532 245 9 doctrine doctrine NN doi-org-9532 245 10 unreasonable unreasonable JJ doi-org-9532 245 11 ? ? . doi-org-9532 246 1 How how WRB doi-org-9532 246 2 do do VBP doi-org-9532 246 3 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 246 4 determine determine VB doi-org-9532 246 5 what what WDT doi-org-9532 246 6 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 246 7 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 246 8 not not RB doi-org-9532 246 9 be be VB doi-org-9532 246 10 tolerated tolerate VBN doi-org-9532 246 11 in in IN doi-org-9532 246 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 246 13 pluralistic pluralistic JJ doi-org-9532 246 14 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 246 15 ? ? . doi-org-9532 247 1 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 247 2 , , , doi-org-9532 247 3 at at IN doi-org-9532 247 4 times time NNS doi-org-9532 247 5 , , , doi-org-9532 247 6 tried try VBD doi-org-9532 247 7 to to TO doi-org-9532 247 8 define define VB doi-org-9532 247 9 unreasonable unreasonable JJ doi-org-9532 247 10 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 247 11 as as IN doi-org-9532 247 12 those those DT doi-org-9532 247 13 that that WDT doi-org-9532 247 14 are be VBP doi-org-9532 247 15 obviously obviously RB doi-org-9532 247 16 inaccurate inaccurate JJ doi-org-9532 247 17 or or CC doi-org-9532 247 18 are be VBP doi-org-9532 247 19 based base VBN doi-org-9532 247 20 on on IN doi-org-9532 247 21 faulty faulty JJ doi-org-9532 247 22 logic logic NN doi-org-9532 247 23 . . . doi-org-9532 248 1 But but CC doi-org-9532 248 2 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 248 3 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 248 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 248 5 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 248 6 's 's POS doi-org-9532 248 7 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 248 8 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 248 9 a a DT doi-org-9532 248 10 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 248 11 and and CC doi-org-9532 248 12 political political JJ doi-org-9532 248 13 account account NN doi-org-9532 248 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 248 15 society society NN doi-org-9532 248 16 , , , doi-org-9532 248 17 and and CC doi-org-9532 248 18 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 248 19 definition definition NN doi-org-9532 248 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 248 21 " " `` doi-org-9532 248 22 unreasonable unreasonable JJ doi-org-9532 248 23 " " '' doi-org-9532 248 24 also also RB doi-org-9532 248 25 should should MD doi-org-9532 248 26 be be VB doi-org-9532 248 27 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 248 28 and and CC doi-org-9532 248 29 political political JJ doi-org-9532 248 30 . . . doi-org-9532 249 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 249 2 her -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 249 3 , , , doi-org-9532 249 4 an an DT doi-org-9532 249 5 unreasonable unreasonable JJ doi-org-9532 249 6 doctrine doctrine NN doi-org-9532 249 7 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 249 8 one one CD doi-org-9532 249 9 that that WDT doi-org-9532 249 10 rejects reject VBZ doi-org-9532 249 11 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 249 12 's 's POS doi-org-9532 249 13 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 249 14 premise premise NN doi-org-9532 249 15 that that IN doi-org-9532 249 16 every every DT doi-org-9532 249 17 citizen citizen NN doi-org-9532 249 18 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 249 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 249 20 be be VB doi-org-9532 249 21 treated treat VBN doi-org-9532 249 22 with with IN doi-org-9532 249 23 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 249 24 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 249 25 . . . doi-org-9532 250 1 Thus thus RB doi-org-9532 250 2 , , , doi-org-9532 250 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 250 4 state state NN doi-org-9532 250 5 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 250 6 not not RB doi-org-9532 250 7 condone condone VB doi-org-9532 250 8 " " `` doi-org-9532 250 9 hate hate NN doi-org-9532 250 10 speech speech NN doi-org-9532 250 11 " " '' doi-org-9532 250 12 that that WDT doi-org-9532 250 13 attacks attack VBZ doi-org-9532 250 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 250 15 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 250 16 political political JJ doi-org-9532 250 17 rights right NNS doi-org-9532 250 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 250 19 other other JJ doi-org-9532 250 20 groups group NNS doi-org-9532 250 21 in in IN doi-org-9532 250 22 society society NN doi-org-9532 250 23 , , , doi-org-9532 250 24 but but CC doi-org-9532 250 25 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 250 26 who who WP doi-org-9532 250 27 respects respect VBZ doi-org-9532 250 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 250 29 dignity dignity NN doi-org-9532 250 30 of of IN doi-org-9532 250 31 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 250 32 fellow fellow JJ doi-org-9532 250 33 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 250 34 should should MD doi-org-9532 250 35 be be VB doi-org-9532 250 36 free free JJ doi-org-9532 250 37 to to TO doi-org-9532 250 38 develop develop VB doi-org-9532 250 39 , , , doi-org-9532 250 40 follow follow VB doi-org-9532 250 41 , , , doi-org-9532 250 42 and and CC doi-org-9532 250 43 promote promote VB doi-org-9532 250 44 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 250 45 own own JJ doi-org-9532 250 46 values value NNS doi-org-9532 250 47 — — : doi-org-9532 250 48 regardless regardless RB doi-org-9532 250 49 of of IN doi-org-9532 250 50 content content NN doi-org-9532 250 51 — — : doi-org-9532 250 52 without without IN doi-org-9532 250 53 discrimination discrimination NN doi-org-9532 250 54 or or CC doi-org-9532 250 55 bias bias NN doi-org-9532 250 56 from from IN doi-org-9532 250 57 the the DT doi-org-9532 250 58 state.41 state.41 NNP doi-org-9532 250 59 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 250 60 End end NN doi-org-9532 250 61 Page page NN doi-org-9532 250 62 68 68 CD doi-org-9532 250 63 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 250 64 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 250 65 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 250 66 and and CC doi-org-9532 250 67 Political Political NNP doi-org-9532 250 68 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 250 69 Political Political NNP doi-org-9532 250 70 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 250 71 grounds ground VBZ doi-org-9532 250 72 the the DT doi-org-9532 250 73 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 250 74 assumed assume VBN doi-org-9532 250 75 in in IN doi-org-9532 250 76 the the DT doi-org-9532 250 77 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 250 78 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 250 79 of of IN doi-org-9532 250 80 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 250 81 in in IN doi-org-9532 250 82 a a DT doi-org-9532 250 83 broader broad JJR doi-org-9532 250 84 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 250 85 of of IN doi-org-9532 250 86 social social JJ doi-org-9532 250 87 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 250 88 . . . doi-org-9532 251 1 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 251 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 251 3 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 251 4 and and CC doi-org-9532 251 5 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 251 6 , , , doi-org-9532 251 7 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 251 8 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 251 9 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 251 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 251 11 best good JJS doi-org-9532 251 12 means mean NNS doi-org-9532 251 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 251 14 achieving achieve VBG doi-org-9532 251 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 251 16 enlightened enlighten VBN doi-org-9532 251 17 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 251 18 society society NN doi-org-9532 251 19 that that WDT doi-org-9532 251 20 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 251 21 are be VBP doi-org-9532 251 22 designed design VBN doi-org-9532 251 23 to to TO doi-org-9532 251 24 support support VB doi-org-9532 251 25 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 251 26 to to IN doi-org-9532 251 27 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 251 28 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 251 29 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 251 30 . . . doi-org-9532 252 1 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 252 2 's 's POS doi-org-9532 252 3 distinction distinction NN doi-org-9532 252 4 between between IN doi-org-9532 252 5 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 252 6 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 252 7 systems system NNS doi-org-9532 252 8 and and CC doi-org-9532 252 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 252 10 more more RBR doi-org-9532 252 11 limited limited JJ doi-org-9532 252 12 system system NN doi-org-9532 252 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 252 14 political political JJ doi-org-9532 252 15 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 252 16 provides provide VBZ doi-org-9532 252 17 deeper deep JJR doi-org-9532 252 18 theoretical theoretical JJ doi-org-9532 252 19 justification justification NN doi-org-9532 252 20 for for IN doi-org-9532 252 21 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 252 22 's 's POS doi-org-9532 252 23 distinction distinction NN doi-org-9532 252 24 between between IN doi-org-9532 252 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 252 26 private private JJ doi-org-9532 252 27 and and CC doi-org-9532 252 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 252 29 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 252 30 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 252 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 252 32 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 252 33 . . . doi-org-9532 253 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 253 2 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 253 3 private private JJ doi-org-9532 253 4 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 253 5 , , , doi-org-9532 253 6 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 253 7 have have VBP doi-org-9532 253 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 253 9 same same JJ doi-org-9532 253 10 rights right NNS doi-org-9532 253 11 as as IN doi-org-9532 253 12 any any DT doi-org-9532 253 13 other other JJ doi-org-9532 253 14 citizen citizen NN doi-org-9532 253 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 253 16 develop develop VB doi-org-9532 253 17 , , , doi-org-9532 253 18 support support VB doi-org-9532 253 19 , , , doi-org-9532 253 20 and and CC doi-org-9532 253 21 promote promote VB doi-org-9532 253 22 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 253 23 own own JJ doi-org-9532 253 24 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 253 25 conceptions conception NNS doi-org-9532 253 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 253 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 253 28 good good NN doi-org-9532 253 29 . . . doi-org-9532 254 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 254 2 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 254 3 professional professional JJ doi-org-9532 254 4 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 254 5 , , , doi-org-9532 254 6 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 254 7 who who WP doi-org-9532 254 8 work work VBP doi-org-9532 254 9 as as IN doi-org-9532 254 10 public public JJ doi-org-9532 254 11 officials official NNS doi-org-9532 254 12 have have VBP doi-org-9532 254 13 an an DT doi-org-9532 254 14 obligation obligation NN doi-org-9532 254 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 254 16 treat treat VB doi-org-9532 254 17 all all DT doi-org-9532 254 18 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 254 19 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 254 20 with with IN doi-org-9532 254 21 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 254 22 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 254 23 , , , doi-org-9532 254 24 including include VBG doi-org-9532 254 25 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 254 26 that that IN doi-org-9532 254 27 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 254 28 vigorously vigorously RB doi-org-9532 254 29 oppose oppose VBP doi-org-9532 254 30 in in IN doi-org-9532 254 31 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 254 32 private private JJ doi-org-9532 254 33 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 254 34 . . . doi-org-9532 255 1 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 255 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 255 3 this this DT doi-org-9532 255 4 view view NN doi-org-9532 255 5 , , , doi-org-9532 255 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 255 7 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 255 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 255 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 255 10 public public JJ doi-org-9532 255 11 library library NN doi-org-9532 255 12 makes make VBZ doi-org-9532 255 13 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 255 14 especially especially RB doi-org-9532 255 15 valuable valuable JJ doi-org-9532 255 16 as as IN doi-org-9532 255 17 a a DT doi-org-9532 255 18 means means NN doi-org-9532 255 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 255 20 promoting promote VBG doi-org-9532 255 21 self self NN doi-org-9532 255 22 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 255 23 development development NN doi-org-9532 255 24 in in IN doi-org-9532 255 25 politically politically RB doi-org-9532 255 26 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 255 27 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 255 28 . . . doi-org-9532 256 1 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 256 2 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 256 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 256 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 256 5 real real JJ doi-org-9532 256 6 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 256 7 to to TO doi-org-9532 256 8 live live VB doi-org-9532 256 9 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 256 10 to to IN doi-org-9532 256 11 one one PRP doi-org-9532 256 12 's 's POS doi-org-9532 256 13 own own JJ doi-org-9532 256 14 view view NN doi-org-9532 256 15 also also RB doi-org-9532 256 16 requires require VBZ doi-org-9532 256 17 protecting protect VBG doi-org-9532 256 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 256 19 spaces space NNS doi-org-9532 256 20 in in IN doi-org-9532 256 21 which which WDT doi-org-9532 256 22 people people NNS doi-org-9532 256 23 may may MD doi-org-9532 256 24 leave leave VB doi-org-9532 256 25 one one CD doi-org-9532 256 26 view view NN doi-org-9532 256 27 and and CC doi-org-9532 256 28 opt opt NNP doi-org-9532 256 29 for for IN doi-org-9532 256 30 another another DT doi-org-9532 256 31 , , , doi-org-9532 256 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 256 33 also also RB doi-org-9532 256 34 the the DT doi-org-9532 256 35 spaces space NNS doi-org-9532 256 36 in in IN doi-org-9532 256 37 which which WDT doi-org-9532 256 38 children child NNS doi-org-9532 256 39 learn learn VBP doi-org-9532 256 40 about about IN doi-org-9532 256 41 options option NNS doi-org-9532 256 42 so so IN doi-org-9532 256 43 that that IN doi-org-9532 256 44 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 256 45 can can MD doi-org-9532 256 46 really really RB doi-org-9532 256 47 live live VB doi-org-9532 256 48 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 256 49 own own JJ doi-org-9532 256 50 lives life NNS doi-org-9532 256 51 . . . doi-org-9532 257 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 257 2 42 42 CD doi-org-9532 257 3 It -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 257 4 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 257 5 hard hard JJ doi-org-9532 257 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 257 7 imagine imagine VB doi-org-9532 257 8 spaces space NNS doi-org-9532 257 9 better well RBR doi-org-9532 257 10 suited suit VBN doi-org-9532 257 11 to to IN doi-org-9532 257 12 encouraging encourage VBG doi-org-9532 257 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 257 14 exploration exploration NN doi-org-9532 257 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 257 16 options option NNS doi-org-9532 257 17 than than IN doi-org-9532 257 18 public public JJ doi-org-9532 257 19 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 257 20 . . . doi-org-9532 258 1 And and CC doi-org-9532 258 2 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 258 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 258 4 hard hard JJ doi-org-9532 258 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 258 6 imagine imagine VB doi-org-9532 258 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 258 8 more more RBR doi-org-9532 258 9 important important JJ doi-org-9532 258 10 political political JJ doi-org-9532 258 11 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 258 12 for for IN doi-org-9532 258 13 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 258 14 than than IN doi-org-9532 258 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 258 16 " " `` doi-org-9532 258 17 protect protect VB doi-org-9532 258 18 " " '' doi-org-9532 258 19 those those DT doi-org-9532 258 20 spaces space NNS doi-org-9532 258 21 by by IN doi-org-9532 258 22 making make VBG doi-org-9532 258 23 sure sure RB doi-org-9532 258 24 that that IN doi-org-9532 258 25 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 258 26 continue continue VBP doi-org-9532 258 27 to to TO doi-org-9532 258 28 provide provide VB doi-org-9532 258 29 a a DT doi-org-9532 258 30 wide wide JJ doi-org-9532 258 31 diversity diversity NN doi-org-9532 258 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 258 33 views view NNS doi-org-9532 258 34 for for IN doi-org-9532 258 35 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 258 36 to to TO doi-org-9532 258 37 explore explore VB doi-org-9532 258 38 . . . doi-org-9532 259 1 This this DT doi-org-9532 259 2 account account NN doi-org-9532 259 3 addresses address VBZ doi-org-9532 259 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 259 5 primary primary JJ doi-org-9532 259 6 criticisms criticism NNS doi-org-9532 259 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 259 8 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 259 9 articulated articulate VBN doi-org-9532 259 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 259 11 recent recent JJ doi-org-9532 259 12 library library NN doi-org-9532 259 13 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 259 14 . . . doi-org-9532 260 1 Against against IN doi-org-9532 260 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 3 charge charge NN doi-org-9532 260 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 260 5 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 260 6 protects protect VBZ doi-org-9532 260 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 8 strong strong JJ doi-org-9532 260 9 against against IN doi-org-9532 260 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 11 weak weak JJ doi-org-9532 260 12 , , , doi-org-9532 260 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 14 political political JJ doi-org-9532 260 15 liberal liberal NN doi-org-9532 260 16 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 260 17 that that IN doi-org-9532 260 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 19 purpose purpose NN doi-org-9532 260 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 260 21 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 260 22 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 260 23 precisely precisely RB doi-org-9532 260 24 to to TO doi-org-9532 260 25 protect protect VB doi-org-9532 260 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 27 opinions opinion NNS doi-org-9532 260 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 260 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 30 minority minority NN doi-org-9532 260 31 against against IN doi-org-9532 260 32 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 33 tyranny tyranny NN doi-org-9532 260 34 of of IN doi-org-9532 260 35 the the DT doi-org-9532 260 36 majority majority NN doi-org-9532 260 37 . . . doi-org-9532 261 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 261 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 261 3 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 261 4 society society NN doi-org-9532 261 5 , , , doi-org-9532 261 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 261 7 danger danger NN doi-org-9532 261 8 often often RB doi-org-9532 261 9 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 261 10 that that IN doi-org-9532 261 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 261 12 majority majority NN doi-org-9532 261 13 will will MD doi-org-9532 261 14 use use VB doi-org-9532 261 15 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 261 16 influence influence NN doi-org-9532 261 17 to to TO doi-org-9532 261 18 impose impose VB doi-org-9532 261 19 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 261 20 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 261 21 system system NN doi-org-9532 261 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 261 23 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 261 24 values value NNS doi-org-9532 261 25 on on IN doi-org-9532 261 26 a a DT doi-org-9532 261 27 minority minority NN doi-org-9532 261 28 . . . doi-org-9532 262 1 By by IN doi-org-9532 262 2 protecting protect VBG doi-org-9532 262 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 262 4 space space NN doi-org-9532 262 5 where where WRB doi-org-9532 262 6 all all DT doi-org-9532 262 7 views view NNS doi-org-9532 262 8 receive receive VBP doi-org-9532 262 9 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 262 10 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 262 11 — — : doi-org-9532 262 12 including include VBG doi-org-9532 262 13 those those DT doi-org-9532 262 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 262 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 262 16 majority majority NN doi-org-9532 262 17 , , , doi-org-9532 262 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 262 19 minority minority NN doi-org-9532 262 20 , , , doi-org-9532 262 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 262 22 powerful powerful JJ doi-org-9532 262 23 , , , doi-org-9532 262 24 and and CC doi-org-9532 262 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 262 26 poor poor JJ doi-org-9532 262 27 — — : doi-org-9532 262 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 262 29 library library NN doi-org-9532 262 30 can can MD doi-org-9532 262 31 counterbalance counterbalance VB doi-org-9532 262 32 the the DT doi-org-9532 262 33 tendency tendency NN doi-org-9532 262 34 to to TO doi-org-9532 262 35 enforce enforce VB doi-org-9532 262 36 conformity conformity NN doi-org-9532 262 37 of of IN doi-org-9532 262 38 opinion opinion NN doi-org-9532 262 39 in in IN doi-org-9532 262 40 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 262 41 communities community NNS doi-org-9532 262 42 . . . doi-org-9532 263 1 Of of RB doi-org-9532 263 2 course course RB doi-org-9532 263 3 , , , doi-org-9532 263 4 no no DT doi-org-9532 263 5 library library NN doi-org-9532 263 6 exists exist VBZ doi-org-9532 263 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 263 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 263 9 perfectly perfectly RB doi-org-9532 263 10 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 263 11 society society NN doi-org-9532 263 12 imagined imagine VBN doi-org-9532 263 13 by by IN doi-org-9532 263 14 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 263 15 . . . doi-org-9532 264 1 Marred mar VBN doi-org-9532 264 2 by by IN doi-org-9532 264 3 persistent persistent JJ doi-org-9532 264 4 racism racism NN doi-org-9532 264 5 , , , doi-org-9532 264 6 sexism sexism NN doi-org-9532 264 7 , , , doi-org-9532 264 8 and and CC doi-org-9532 264 9 increasing increase VBG doi-org-9532 264 10 economic economic JJ doi-org-9532 264 11 inequality inequality NN doi-org-9532 264 12 , , , doi-org-9532 264 13 twenty twenty CD doi-org-9532 264 14 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 264 15 first first JJ doi-org-9532 264 16 century century NN doi-org-9532 264 17 America America NNP doi-org-9532 264 18 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 264 19 not not RB doi-org-9532 264 20 come come VBN doi-org-9532 264 21 close close RB doi-org-9532 264 22 to to IN doi-org-9532 264 23 achieving achieve VBG doi-org-9532 264 24 a a DT doi-org-9532 264 25 political political JJ doi-org-9532 264 26 order order NN doi-org-9532 264 27 in in IN doi-org-9532 264 28 which which WDT doi-org-9532 264 29 every every DT doi-org-9532 264 30 citizen citizen NN doi-org-9532 264 31 receives receive VBZ doi-org-9532 264 32 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 264 33 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 264 34 . . . doi-org-9532 265 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 265 2 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 265 3 ignore ignore VBP doi-org-9532 265 4 these these DT doi-org-9532 265 5 distressing distress VBG doi-org-9532 265 6 realities reality NNS doi-org-9532 265 7 and and CC doi-org-9532 265 8 act act VB doi-org-9532 265 9 as as IN doi-org-9532 265 10 if if IN doi-org-9532 265 11 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 265 12 society society NN doi-org-9532 265 13 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 265 14 already already RB doi-org-9532 265 15 achieved achieve VBN doi-org-9532 265 16 social social JJ doi-org-9532 265 17 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 265 18 , , , doi-org-9532 265 19 many many JJ doi-org-9532 265 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 265 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 265 22 inequities inequity NNS doi-org-9532 265 23 in in IN doi-org-9532 265 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 265 25 surrounding surround VBG doi-org-9532 265 26 environment environment NN doi-org-9532 265 27 will will MD doi-org-9532 265 28 be be VB doi-org-9532 265 29 replicated replicate VBN doi-org-9532 265 30 within within IN doi-org-9532 265 31 the the DT doi-org-9532 265 32 library library NN doi-org-9532 265 33 walls wall NNS doi-org-9532 265 34 . . . doi-org-9532 266 1 Affirmative affirmative JJ doi-org-9532 266 2 action action NN doi-org-9532 266 3 within within IN doi-org-9532 266 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 266 5 library library NN doi-org-9532 266 6 can can MD doi-org-9532 266 7 mitigate mitigate VB doi-org-9532 266 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 266 9 consequences consequence NNS doi-org-9532 266 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 266 11 injustice injustice NN doi-org-9532 266 12 outside outside IN doi-org-9532 266 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 266 14 library library NN doi-org-9532 266 15 while while IN doi-org-9532 266 16 maintaining maintain VBG doi-org-9532 266 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 266 18 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 266 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 266 20 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 266 21 between between IN doi-org-9532 266 22 different different JJ doi-org-9532 266 23 conceptions conception NNS doi-org-9532 266 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 266 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 266 26 good.43 good.43 NNP doi-org-9532 266 27 Librarians Librarians NNPS doi-org-9532 266 28 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 266 29 to to TO doi-org-9532 266 30 seek seek VB doi-org-9532 266 31 out out RP doi-org-9532 266 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 266 33 collect collect VB doi-org-9532 266 34 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 266 35 End end NN doi-org-9532 266 36 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 266 37 69 69 CD doi-org-9532 266 38 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 266 39 viewpoints viewpoint NNS doi-org-9532 266 40 infrequently infrequently RB doi-org-9532 266 41 expressed express VBN doi-org-9532 266 42 in in IN doi-org-9532 266 43 the the DT doi-org-9532 266 44 mass mass NN doi-org-9532 266 45 media media NN doi-org-9532 266 46 because because IN doi-org-9532 266 47 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 266 48 are be VBP doi-org-9532 266 49 inconsistent inconsistent JJ doi-org-9532 266 50 with with IN doi-org-9532 266 51 the the DT doi-org-9532 266 52 interests interest NNS doi-org-9532 266 53 of of IN doi-org-9532 266 54 those those DT doi-org-9532 266 55 who who WP doi-org-9532 266 56 have have VBP doi-org-9532 266 57 money money NN doi-org-9532 266 58 and and CC doi-org-9532 266 59 power power NN doi-org-9532 266 60 . . . doi-org-9532 267 1 Making make VBG doi-org-9532 267 2 sure sure JJ doi-org-9532 267 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 267 4 unpopular unpopular JJ doi-org-9532 267 5 and and CC doi-org-9532 267 6 unconventional unconventional JJ doi-org-9532 267 7 opinions opinion NNS doi-org-9532 267 8 are be VBP doi-org-9532 267 9 available available JJ doi-org-9532 267 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 267 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 267 12 library library NN doi-org-9532 267 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 267 14 increasing increase VBG doi-org-9532 267 15 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 267 16 visibility visibility NN doi-org-9532 267 17 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 267 18 a a DT doi-org-9532 267 19 useful useful JJ doi-org-9532 267 20 means mean NNS doi-org-9532 267 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 267 22 countering counter VBG doi-org-9532 267 23 biases bias NNS doi-org-9532 267 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 267 25 conventional conventional JJ doi-org-9532 267 26 wisdom wisdom NN doi-org-9532 267 27 . . . doi-org-9532 268 1 However however RB doi-org-9532 268 2 , , , doi-org-9532 268 3 from from IN doi-org-9532 268 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 268 5 perspective perspective NN doi-org-9532 268 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 268 7 political political JJ doi-org-9532 268 8 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 268 9 , , , doi-org-9532 268 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 268 11 goal goal NN doi-org-9532 268 12 always always RB doi-org-9532 268 13 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 268 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 268 15 expand expand VB doi-org-9532 268 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 268 17 diversity diversity NN doi-org-9532 268 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 268 19 options option NNS doi-org-9532 268 20 available available JJ doi-org-9532 268 21 to to IN doi-org-9532 268 22 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 268 23 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 268 24 than than IN doi-org-9532 268 25 to to TO doi-org-9532 268 26 direct direct VB doi-org-9532 268 27 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 268 28 to to IN doi-org-9532 268 29 conclusions conclusion NNS doi-org-9532 268 30 that that IN doi-org-9532 268 31 the the DT doi-org-9532 268 32 librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 268 33 considers consider NNS doi-org-9532 268 34 correct correct JJ doi-org-9532 268 35 . . . doi-org-9532 269 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 269 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 269 3 library library NN doi-org-9532 269 4 to to TO doi-org-9532 269 5 emphasize emphasize VB doi-org-9532 269 6 specific specific JJ doi-org-9532 269 7 doctrines doctrine NNS doi-org-9532 269 8 — — : doi-org-9532 269 9 either either CC doi-org-9532 269 10 minority minority NN doi-org-9532 269 11 or or CC doi-org-9532 269 12 majority majority NN doi-org-9532 269 13 — — : doi-org-9532 269 14 because because IN doi-org-9532 269 15 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 269 16 are be VBP doi-org-9532 269 17 " " `` doi-org-9532 269 18 right right JJ doi-org-9532 269 19 " " '' doi-org-9532 269 20 would would MD doi-org-9532 269 21 undermine undermine VB doi-org-9532 269 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 269 23 library library NN doi-org-9532 269 24 's 's POS doi-org-9532 269 25 role role NN doi-org-9532 269 26 as as IN doi-org-9532 269 27 a a DT doi-org-9532 269 28 space space NN doi-org-9532 269 29 that that WDT doi-org-9532 269 30 treats treat VBZ doi-org-9532 269 31 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 269 32 with with IN doi-org-9532 269 33 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 269 34 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 269 35 and and CC doi-org-9532 269 36 gives give VBZ doi-org-9532 269 37 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 269 38 the the DT doi-org-9532 269 39 opportunity opportunity NN doi-org-9532 269 40 to to TO doi-org-9532 269 41 explore explore VB doi-org-9532 269 42 differing differing JJ doi-org-9532 269 43 options option NNS doi-org-9532 269 44 of of IN doi-org-9532 269 45 the the DT doi-org-9532 269 46 good good NN doi-org-9532 269 47 . . . doi-org-9532 270 1 Political political JJ doi-org-9532 270 2 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 270 3 also also RB doi-org-9532 270 4 answers answer VBZ doi-org-9532 270 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 270 6 charge charge NN doi-org-9532 270 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 270 8 library library JJ doi-org-9532 270 9 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 270 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 270 11 an an DT doi-org-9532 270 12 ahistorical ahistorical JJ doi-org-9532 270 13 , , , doi-org-9532 270 14 apolitical apolitical JJ doi-org-9532 270 15 myth myth NN doi-org-9532 270 16 . . . doi-org-9532 271 1 Because because IN doi-org-9532 271 2 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 271 3 grounds ground VBZ doi-org-9532 271 4 library library JJ doi-org-9532 271 5 values value NNS doi-org-9532 271 6 in in IN doi-org-9532 271 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 271 8 philosophical philosophical JJ doi-org-9532 271 9 vision vision NN doi-org-9532 271 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 271 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 271 12 European European NNP doi-org-9532 271 13 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 271 14 and and CC doi-org-9532 271 15 commits commit VBZ doi-org-9532 271 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 271 17 library library NN doi-org-9532 271 18 to to IN doi-org-9532 271 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 271 20 support support NN doi-org-9532 271 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 271 22 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 271 23 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 271 24 , , , doi-org-9532 271 25 this this DT doi-org-9532 271 26 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 271 27 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 271 28 not not RB doi-org-9532 271 29 pretend pretend VB doi-org-9532 271 30 that that IN doi-org-9532 271 31 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 271 32 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 271 33 a a DT doi-org-9532 271 34 natural natural JJ doi-org-9532 271 35 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 271 36 that that WDT doi-org-9532 271 37 transcends transcend VBZ doi-org-9532 271 38 politics politic NNS doi-org-9532 271 39 . . . doi-org-9532 272 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 272 2 library library NN doi-org-9532 272 3 's 's POS doi-org-9532 272 4 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 272 5 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 272 6 embedded embed VBN doi-org-9532 272 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 272 8 and and CC doi-org-9532 272 9 limited limit VBN doi-org-9532 272 10 by by IN doi-org-9532 272 11 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 272 12 political political JJ doi-org-9532 272 13 commitments commitment NNS doi-org-9532 272 14 . . . doi-org-9532 273 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 273 2 library library NN doi-org-9532 273 3 should should MD doi-org-9532 273 4 not not RB doi-org-9532 273 5 remain remain VB doi-org-9532 273 6 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 273 7 when when WRB doi-org-9532 273 8 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 273 9 , , , doi-org-9532 273 10 especially especially RB doi-org-9532 273 11 those those DT doi-org-9532 273 12 who who WP doi-org-9532 273 13 have have VBP doi-org-9532 273 14 power power NN doi-org-9532 273 15 , , , doi-org-9532 273 16 refuse refuse VBP doi-org-9532 273 17 to to TO doi-org-9532 273 18 play play VB doi-org-9532 273 19 by by IN doi-org-9532 273 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 273 21 rules rule NNS doi-org-9532 273 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 273 23 political political JJ doi-org-9532 273 24 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 273 25 by by IN doi-org-9532 273 26 using use VBG doi-org-9532 273 27 violence violence NN doi-org-9532 273 28 , , , doi-org-9532 273 29 threats threat NNS doi-org-9532 273 30 , , , doi-org-9532 273 31 or or CC doi-org-9532 273 32 intimidation intimidation NN doi-org-9532 273 33 to to TO doi-org-9532 273 34 suppress suppress VB doi-org-9532 273 35 the the DT doi-org-9532 273 36 free free JJ doi-org-9532 273 37 expression expression NN doi-org-9532 273 38 of of IN doi-org-9532 273 39 others other NNS doi-org-9532 273 40 . . . doi-org-9532 274 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 274 2 library library NN doi-org-9532 274 3 should should MD doi-org-9532 274 4 , , , doi-org-9532 274 5 however however RB doi-org-9532 274 6 , , , doi-org-9532 274 7 remain remain VBP doi-org-9532 274 8 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 274 9 between between IN doi-org-9532 274 10 different different JJ doi-org-9532 274 11 conceptions conception NNS doi-org-9532 274 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 274 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 274 14 good good JJ doi-org-9532 274 15 adopted adopt VBN doi-org-9532 274 16 by by IN doi-org-9532 274 17 groups group NNS doi-org-9532 274 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 274 19 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 274 20 who who WP doi-org-9532 274 21 are be VBP doi-org-9532 274 22 competing compete VBG doi-org-9532 274 23 for for IN doi-org-9532 274 24 political political JJ doi-org-9532 274 25 influence influence NN doi-org-9532 274 26 in in IN doi-org-9532 274 27 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 274 28 ways way NNS doi-org-9532 274 29 . . . doi-org-9532 275 1 Liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 275 2 and and CC doi-org-9532 275 3 Radical Radical NNP doi-org-9532 275 4 Critiques Critiques NNPS doi-org-9532 275 5 Critics Critics NNPS doi-org-9532 275 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 275 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 275 8 library library JJ doi-org-9532 275 9 neutrality neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 275 10 syllogism syllogism NN doi-org-9532 275 11 fall fall VBP doi-org-9532 275 12 into into IN doi-org-9532 275 13 two two CD doi-org-9532 275 14 camps camp NNS doi-org-9532 275 15 , , , doi-org-9532 275 16 depending depend VBG doi-org-9532 275 17 on on IN doi-org-9532 275 18 which which WDT doi-org-9532 275 19 premise premise NN doi-org-9532 275 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 275 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 275 22 syllogism syllogism NN doi-org-9532 275 23 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 275 24 challenge challenge VBP doi-org-9532 275 25 . . . doi-org-9532 276 1 Liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 276 2 critics critic NNS doi-org-9532 276 3 accept accept VBP doi-org-9532 276 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 276 5 major major JJ doi-org-9532 276 6 premise premise NN doi-org-9532 276 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 276 8 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 276 9 are be VBP doi-org-9532 276 10 founded found VBN doi-org-9532 276 11 on on IN doi-org-9532 276 12 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 276 13 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 276 14 but but CC doi-org-9532 276 15 reject reject VB doi-org-9532 276 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 276 17 minor minor JJ doi-org-9532 276 18 premise premise NN doi-org-9532 276 19 that that IN doi-org-9532 276 20 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 276 21 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 276 22 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 276 23 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 276 24 to to TO doi-org-9532 276 25 be be VB doi-org-9532 276 26 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 276 27 . . . doi-org-9532 277 1 Radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 277 2 critics critic NNS doi-org-9532 277 3 reject reject VBP doi-org-9532 277 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 277 5 major major JJ doi-org-9532 277 6 premise premise NN doi-org-9532 277 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 277 8 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 277 9 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 277 10 to to TO doi-org-9532 277 11 support support VB doi-org-9532 277 12 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 277 13 values value NNS doi-org-9532 277 14 . . . doi-org-9532 278 1 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 278 2 may may MD doi-org-9532 278 3 agree agree VB doi-org-9532 278 4 with with IN doi-org-9532 278 5 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 278 6 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 278 7 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 278 8 's 's POS doi-org-9532 278 9 historical historical JJ doi-org-9532 278 10 account account NN doi-org-9532 278 11 , , , doi-org-9532 278 12 but but CC doi-org-9532 278 13 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 278 14 disagree disagree VBP doi-org-9532 278 15 with with IN doi-org-9532 278 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 278 17 claim claim NN doi-org-9532 278 18 that that IN doi-org-9532 278 19 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 278 20 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 278 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 278 22 guide guide VB doi-org-9532 278 23 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 278 24 in in IN doi-org-9532 278 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 278 26 future future NN doi-org-9532 278 27 . . . doi-org-9532 279 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 279 2 Liberal Liberal NNP doi-org-9532 279 3 Critique Critique NNP doi-org-9532 279 4 In in IN doi-org-9532 279 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 279 6 philosophical philosophical JJ doi-org-9532 279 7 literature literature NN doi-org-9532 279 8 , , , doi-org-9532 279 9 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 279 10 political political JJ doi-org-9532 279 11 theorists theorist NNS doi-org-9532 279 12 who who WP doi-org-9532 279 13 reject reject VBP doi-org-9532 279 14 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 279 15 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 279 16 have have VBP doi-org-9532 279 17 been be VBN doi-org-9532 279 18 called call VBN doi-org-9532 279 19 perfectionists perfectionist NNS doi-org-9532 279 20 . . . doi-org-9532 280 1 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 280 2 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 280 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 280 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 280 5 successful successful JJ doi-org-9532 280 6 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 280 7 society society NN doi-org-9532 280 8 depends depend VBZ doi-org-9532 280 9 on on IN doi-org-9532 280 10 specific specific JJ doi-org-9532 280 11 types type NNS doi-org-9532 280 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 280 13 virtue virtue NN doi-org-9532 280 14 that that IN doi-org-9532 280 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 280 16 government government NN doi-org-9532 280 17 must must MD doi-org-9532 280 18 promote promote VB doi-org-9532 280 19 . . . doi-org-9532 281 1 From from IN doi-org-9532 281 2 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 281 3 perspective perspective NN doi-org-9532 281 4 , , , doi-org-9532 281 5 simply simply RB doi-org-9532 281 6 taking take VBG doi-org-9532 281 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 281 8 hands hand NNS doi-org-9532 281 9 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 281 10 off off RP doi-org-9532 281 11 approach approach NN doi-org-9532 281 12 to to IN doi-org-9532 281 13 political political JJ doi-org-9532 281 14 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 281 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 281 16 allowing allow VBG doi-org-9532 281 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 281 18 marketplace marketplace NN doi-org-9532 281 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 281 20 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 281 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 281 22 determine determine VB doi-org-9532 281 23 what what WP doi-org-9532 281 24 people people NNS doi-org-9532 281 25 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 281 26 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 281 27 not not RB doi-org-9532 281 28 offer offer VB doi-org-9532 281 29 adequate adequate JJ doi-org-9532 281 30 protection protection NN doi-org-9532 281 31 against against IN doi-org-9532 281 32 irrational irrational JJ doi-org-9532 281 33 forces force NNS doi-org-9532 281 34 that that WDT doi-org-9532 281 35 threaten threaten VBP doi-org-9532 281 36 to to TO doi-org-9532 281 37 overwhelm overwhelm VB doi-org-9532 281 38 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 281 39 societies.44 societies.44 NNP doi-org-9532 281 40 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 281 41 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 281 42 that that IN doi-org-9532 281 43 most most JJS doi-org-9532 281 44 pre pre JJ doi-org-9532 281 45 - - JJ doi-org-9532 281 46 twentieth twentieth JJ doi-org-9532 281 47 century century NN doi-org-9532 281 48 liberals liberal NNS doi-org-9532 281 49 , , , doi-org-9532 281 50 such such JJ doi-org-9532 281 51 as as IN doi-org-9532 281 52 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 281 53 and and CC doi-org-9532 281 54 John John NNP doi-org-9532 281 55 Stuart Stuart NNP doi-org-9532 281 56 Mill Mill NNP doi-org-9532 281 57 , , , doi-org-9532 281 58 were be VBD doi-org-9532 281 59 perfectionists perfectionist NNS doi-org-9532 281 60 who who WP doi-org-9532 281 61 did do VBD doi-org-9532 281 62 not not RB doi-org-9532 281 63 make make VB doi-org-9532 281 64 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 281 65 distinction distinction NN doi-org-9532 281 66 between between IN doi-org-9532 281 67 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 281 68 theories theory NNS doi-org-9532 281 69 of of IN doi-org-9532 281 70 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 281 71 and and CC doi-org-9532 281 72 the the DT doi-org-9532 281 73 more more RBR doi-org-9532 281 74 limited limited JJ doi-org-9532 281 75 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 281 76 of of IN doi-org-9532 281 77 political political JJ doi-org-9532 281 78 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 281 79 . . . doi-org-9532 282 1 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 282 2 were be VBD doi-org-9532 282 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 282 4 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 282 5 liberals liberal NNS doi-org-9532 282 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 282 7 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 282 8 than than IN doi-org-9532 282 9 " " `` doi-org-9532 282 10 political political JJ doi-org-9532 282 11 liberals liberal NNS doi-org-9532 282 12 . . . doi-org-9532 282 13 " " '' doi-org-9532 283 1 Both both DT doi-org-9532 283 2 Mill Mill NNP doi-org-9532 283 3 and and CC doi-org-9532 283 4 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 283 5 developed develop VBD doi-org-9532 283 6 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 283 7 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 283 8 theories theory NNS doi-org-9532 283 9 that that WDT doi-org-9532 283 10 emphasized emphasize VBD doi-org-9532 283 11 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 283 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 283 13 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 283 14 that that IN doi-org-9532 283 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 283 16 government government NN doi-org-9532 283 17 should should MD doi-org-9532 283 18 discourage discourage VB doi-org-9532 283 19 traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 283 20 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 283 21 dogmatism dogmatism NN doi-org-9532 283 22 . . . doi-org-9532 284 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 284 2 contrast contrast NN doi-org-9532 284 3 to to IN doi-org-9532 284 4 political political JJ doi-org-9532 284 5 liberals liberal NNS doi-org-9532 284 6 like like IN doi-org-9532 284 7 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 284 8 , , , doi-org-9532 284 9 who who WP doi-org-9532 284 10 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 284 11 that that IN doi-org-9532 284 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 284 13 government government NN doi-org-9532 284 14 must must MD doi-org-9532 284 15 maintain maintain VB doi-org-9532 284 16 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 284 17 between between IN doi-org-9532 284 18 scientific scientific JJ doi-org-9532 284 19 and and CC doi-org-9532 284 20 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 284 21 accounts account NNS doi-org-9532 284 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 284 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 284 24 good good JJ doi-org-9532 284 25 life life NN doi-org-9532 284 26 , , , doi-org-9532 284 27 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 284 28 perfectionists perfectionist NNS doi-org-9532 284 29 agree agree VBP doi-org-9532 284 30 with with IN doi-org-9532 284 31 Mill Mill NNP doi-org-9532 284 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 284 33 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 284 34 that that IN doi-org-9532 284 35 the the DT doi-org-9532 284 36 government government NN doi-org-9532 284 37 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 284 38 End end NN doi-org-9532 284 39 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 284 40 70 70 CD doi-org-9532 284 41 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 284 42 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 284 43 a a DT doi-org-9532 284 44 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 284 45 to to TO doi-org-9532 284 46 actively actively RB doi-org-9532 284 47 defend defend VB doi-org-9532 284 48 society society NN doi-org-9532 284 49 against against IN doi-org-9532 284 50 dogmatic dogmatic JJ doi-org-9532 284 51 ways way NNS doi-org-9532 284 52 of of IN doi-org-9532 284 53 thinking thinking NN doi-org-9532 284 54 that that WDT doi-org-9532 284 55 undermine undermine JJ doi-org-9532 284 56 rational rational JJ doi-org-9532 284 57 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 284 58 . . . doi-org-9532 285 1 At at IN doi-org-9532 285 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 285 3 end end NN doi-org-9532 285 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 285 5 Libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 285 6 and and CC doi-org-9532 285 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 285 8 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 285 9 , , , doi-org-9532 285 10 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 285 11 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 285 12 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 285 13 rejects reject VBZ doi-org-9532 285 14 library library JJ doi-org-9532 285 15 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 285 16 in in IN doi-org-9532 285 17 favor favor NN doi-org-9532 285 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 285 19 a a DT doi-org-9532 285 20 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 285 21 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 285 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 285 23 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 285 24 rationalism rationalism NN doi-org-9532 285 25 . . . doi-org-9532 286 1 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 286 2 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 286 3 : : : doi-org-9532 286 4 Librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 286 5 can can MD doi-org-9532 286 6 not not RB doi-org-9532 286 7 be be VB doi-org-9532 286 8 , , , doi-org-9532 286 9 and and CC doi-org-9532 286 10 should should MD doi-org-9532 286 11 not not RB doi-org-9532 286 12 be be VB doi-org-9532 286 13 , , , doi-org-9532 286 14 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 286 15 at at RB doi-org-9532 286 16 all all RB doi-org-9532 286 17 . . . doi-org-9532 287 1 Intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 287 2 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 287 3 should should MD doi-org-9532 287 4 not not RB doi-org-9532 287 5 mean mean VB doi-org-9532 287 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 287 7 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 287 8 to to TO doi-org-9532 287 9 believe believe VB doi-org-9532 287 10 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 287 11 , , , doi-org-9532 287 12 but but CC doi-org-9532 287 13 only only RB doi-org-9532 287 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 287 15 read read VB doi-org-9532 287 16 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 287 17 . . . doi-org-9532 288 1 And and CC doi-org-9532 288 2 as as IN doi-org-9532 288 3 proponents proponent NNS doi-org-9532 288 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 288 5 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 288 6 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 288 7 , , , doi-org-9532 288 8 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 288 9 are be VBP doi-org-9532 288 10 by by IN doi-org-9532 288 11 default default NN doi-org-9532 288 12 implicated implicate VBN doi-org-9532 288 13 in in IN doi-org-9532 288 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 288 15 entire entire JJ doi-org-9532 288 16 scheme scheme NN doi-org-9532 288 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 288 18 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 288 19 values value NNS doi-org-9532 288 20 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 288 21 have have VBP doi-org-9532 288 22 elaborated elaborate VBN doi-org-9532 288 23 … … NFP doi-org-9532 288 24 Intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 288 25 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 288 26 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 288 27 mean mean VB doi-org-9532 288 28 that that IN doi-org-9532 288 29 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 288 30 should should MD doi-org-9532 288 31 provide provide VB doi-org-9532 288 32 all all DT doi-org-9532 288 33 information information NN doi-org-9532 288 34 to to IN doi-org-9532 288 35 all all DT doi-org-9532 288 36 people people NNS doi-org-9532 288 37 , , , doi-org-9532 288 38 but but CC doi-org-9532 288 39 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 288 40 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 288 41 not not RB doi-org-9532 288 42 mean mean VB doi-org-9532 288 43 that that IN doi-org-9532 288 44 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 288 45 have have VBP doi-org-9532 288 46 to to TO doi-org-9532 288 47 remain remain VB doi-org-9532 288 48 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 288 49 towards towards IN doi-org-9532 288 50 that that DT doi-org-9532 288 51 information.45 information.45 NNP doi-org-9532 288 52 Here here RB doi-org-9532 288 53 , , , doi-org-9532 288 54 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 288 55 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 288 56 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 288 57 embeds embed NNS doi-org-9532 288 58 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 288 59 in in IN doi-org-9532 288 60 a a DT doi-org-9532 288 61 thoroughgoing thoroughgoe VBG doi-org-9532 288 62 scheme scheme NN doi-org-9532 288 63 of of IN doi-org-9532 288 64 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 288 65 rationalism rationalism NN doi-org-9532 288 66 . . . doi-org-9532 289 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 289 2 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 289 3 obligation obligation NN doi-org-9532 289 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 289 5 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 289 6 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 289 7 not not RB doi-org-9532 289 8 simply simply RB doi-org-9532 289 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 289 10 preserve preserve VB doi-org-9532 289 11 a a DT doi-org-9532 289 12 place place NN doi-org-9532 289 13 where where WRB doi-org-9532 289 14 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 289 15 can can MD doi-org-9532 289 16 explore explore VB doi-org-9532 289 17 different different JJ doi-org-9532 289 18 points point NNS doi-org-9532 289 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 289 20 view view NN doi-org-9532 289 21 but but CC doi-org-9532 289 22 also also RB doi-org-9532 289 23 to to TO doi-org-9532 289 24 promote promote VB doi-org-9532 289 25 scientific scientific JJ doi-org-9532 289 26 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 289 27 against against IN doi-org-9532 289 28 " " `` doi-org-9532 289 29 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 289 30 . . . doi-org-9532 289 31 " " '' doi-org-9532 290 1 Because because IN doi-org-9532 290 2 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 290 3 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 290 4 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 290 5 believes believe VBZ doi-org-9532 290 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 290 7 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 290 8 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 290 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 290 10 collect collect VB doi-org-9532 290 11 and and CC doi-org-9532 290 12 provide provide VB doi-org-9532 290 13 access access NN doi-org-9532 290 14 to to IN doi-org-9532 290 15 all all DT doi-org-9532 290 16 points point NNS doi-org-9532 290 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 290 18 view view NN doi-org-9532 290 19 regardless regardless RB doi-org-9532 290 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 290 21 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 290 22 validity validity NN doi-org-9532 290 23 , , , doi-org-9532 290 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 290 25 implications implication NNS doi-org-9532 290 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 290 27 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 290 28 non non JJ doi-org-9532 290 29 - - JJ doi-org-9532 290 30 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 290 31 are be VBP doi-org-9532 290 32 subtle subtle JJ doi-org-9532 290 33 . . . doi-org-9532 291 1 However however RB doi-org-9532 291 2 , , , doi-org-9532 291 3 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 291 4 stance stance NN doi-org-9532 291 5 suggests suggest VBZ doi-org-9532 291 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 291 7 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 291 8 have have VBP doi-org-9532 291 9 a a DT doi-org-9532 291 10 responsibility responsibility NN doi-org-9532 291 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 291 12 advise advise VB doi-org-9532 291 13 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 291 14 on on IN doi-org-9532 291 15 which which WDT doi-org-9532 291 16 views view NNS doi-org-9532 291 17 are be VBP doi-org-9532 291 18 more more RBR doi-org-9532 291 19 enlightened enlightened JJ doi-org-9532 291 20 . . . doi-org-9532 292 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 292 2 my -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 292 3 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 292 4 desk desk NN doi-org-9532 292 5 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 292 6 experiments experiment NNS doi-org-9532 292 7 , , , doi-org-9532 292 8 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 292 9 would would MD doi-org-9532 292 10 presumably presumably RB doi-org-9532 292 11 expect expect VB doi-org-9532 292 12 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 292 13 to to TO doi-org-9532 292 14 warn warn VB doi-org-9532 292 15 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 292 16 about about IN doi-org-9532 292 17 any any DT doi-org-9532 292 18 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 292 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 292 20 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 292 21 chosen choose VBN doi-org-9532 292 22 texts text NNS doi-org-9532 292 23 while while IN doi-org-9532 292 24 directing direct VBG doi-org-9532 292 25 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 292 26 toward toward IN doi-org-9532 292 27 more more RBR doi-org-9532 292 28 enlightened enlighten VBN doi-org-9532 292 29 authors author NNS doi-org-9532 292 30 . . . doi-org-9532 293 1 At at IN doi-org-9532 293 2 one one CD doi-org-9532 293 3 point point NN doi-org-9532 293 4 , , , doi-org-9532 293 5 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 293 6 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 293 7 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 293 8 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 293 9 that that IN doi-org-9532 293 10 " " `` doi-org-9532 293 11 sectarian sectarian JJ doi-org-9532 293 12 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 293 13 views view NNS doi-org-9532 293 14 on on IN doi-org-9532 293 15 homosexuality homosexuality NN doi-org-9532 293 16 " " `` doi-org-9532 293 17 contradict contradict VB doi-org-9532 293 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 293 19 enlightened enlightened JJ doi-org-9532 293 20 views view NNS doi-org-9532 293 21 that that IN doi-org-9532 293 22 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 293 23 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 293 24 to to IN doi-org-9532 293 25 promote.46 promote.46 NNP doi-org-9532 293 26 He -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 293 27 also also RB doi-org-9532 293 28 expresses express VBZ doi-org-9532 293 29 cautious cautious JJ doi-org-9532 293 30 support support NN doi-org-9532 293 31 for for IN doi-org-9532 293 32 efforts effort NNS doi-org-9532 293 33 of of IN doi-org-9532 293 34 early early JJ doi-org-9532 293 35 twentieth twentieth JJ doi-org-9532 293 36 century century NN doi-org-9532 293 37 public public JJ doi-org-9532 293 38 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 293 39 to to IN doi-org-9532 293 40 Americanize Americanize NNP doi-org-9532 293 41 " " `` doi-org-9532 293 42 immigrants immigrant NNS doi-org-9532 293 43 from from IN doi-org-9532 293 44 countries country NNS doi-org-9532 293 45 without without IN doi-org-9532 293 46 democracies democracy NNS doi-org-9532 293 47 . . . doi-org-9532 294 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 294 2 47 47 CD doi-org-9532 294 3 While while IN doi-org-9532 294 4 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 294 5 advocates advocate VBZ doi-org-9532 294 6 respect respect NN doi-org-9532 294 7 for for IN doi-org-9532 294 8 all all DT doi-org-9532 294 9 cultures culture NNS doi-org-9532 294 10 , , , doi-org-9532 294 11 BivensTatum BivensTatum NNP doi-org-9532 294 12 suggests suggest VBZ doi-org-9532 294 13 that that IN doi-org-9532 294 14 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 294 15 have have VBP doi-org-9532 294 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 294 17 positive positive JJ doi-org-9532 294 18 role role NN doi-org-9532 294 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 294 20 play play VB doi-org-9532 294 21 in in IN doi-org-9532 294 22 educating educate VBG doi-org-9532 294 23 immigrants immigrant NNS doi-org-9532 294 24 in in IN doi-org-9532 294 25 habits habit NNS doi-org-9532 294 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 294 27 mind mind NN doi-org-9532 294 28 required require VBN doi-org-9532 294 29 for for IN doi-org-9532 294 30 successful successful JJ doi-org-9532 294 31 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 294 32 . . . doi-org-9532 295 1 His -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 295 2 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 295 3 suggests suggest VBZ doi-org-9532 295 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 295 5 not not RB doi-org-9532 295 6 all all DT doi-org-9532 295 7 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 295 8 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 295 9 cultures culture NNS doi-org-9532 295 10 are be VBP doi-org-9532 295 11 compatible compatible JJ doi-org-9532 295 12 with with IN doi-org-9532 295 13 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 295 14 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 295 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 295 16 that that IN doi-org-9532 295 17 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 295 18 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 295 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 295 20 promote promote VB doi-org-9532 295 21 and and CC doi-org-9532 295 22 encourage encourage VB doi-org-9532 295 23 cultures culture NNS doi-org-9532 295 24 consistent consistent JJ doi-org-9532 295 25 with with IN doi-org-9532 295 26 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 295 27 . . . doi-org-9532 296 1 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 296 2 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 296 3 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 296 4 's 's POS doi-org-9532 296 5 belief belief NN doi-org-9532 296 6 that that IN doi-org-9532 296 7 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 296 8 have have VBP doi-org-9532 296 9 an an DT doi-org-9532 296 10 active active JJ doi-org-9532 296 11 role role NN doi-org-9532 296 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 296 13 play play VB doi-org-9532 296 14 in in IN doi-org-9532 296 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 296 16 fight fight NN doi-org-9532 296 17 against against IN doi-org-9532 296 18 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 296 19 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 296 20 particularly particularly RB doi-org-9532 296 21 attractive attractive JJ doi-org-9532 296 22 at at IN doi-org-9532 296 23 a a DT doi-org-9532 296 24 time time NN doi-org-9532 296 25 when when WRB doi-org-9532 296 26 many many JJ doi-org-9532 296 27 liberals liberal NNS doi-org-9532 296 28 worry worry VBP doi-org-9532 296 29 that that IN doi-org-9532 296 30 fake fake JJ doi-org-9532 296 31 news news NN doi-org-9532 296 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 296 33 anti anti NN doi-org-9532 296 34 - - NN doi-org-9532 296 35 intellectualism intellectualism NN doi-org-9532 296 36 are be VBP doi-org-9532 296 37 undermining undermine VBG doi-org-9532 296 38 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 296 39 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 296 40 in in IN doi-org-9532 296 41 Western western JJ doi-org-9532 296 42 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 296 43 . . . doi-org-9532 297 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 297 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 297 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 297 4 post post NN doi-org-9532 297 5 truth truth NN doi-org-9532 297 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 297 7 world world NN doi-org-9532 297 8 where where WRB doi-org-9532 297 9 many many JJ doi-org-9532 297 10 Americans Americans NNPS doi-org-9532 297 11 refuse refuse VBP doi-org-9532 297 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 297 13 believe believe VB doi-org-9532 297 14 in in IN doi-org-9532 297 15 global global JJ doi-org-9532 297 16 warming warming NN doi-org-9532 297 17 , , , doi-org-9532 297 18 want want VBP doi-org-9532 297 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 297 20 teach teach VB doi-org-9532 297 21 creationism creationism NN doi-org-9532 297 22 in in IN doi-org-9532 297 23 public public JJ doi-org-9532 297 24 schools school NNS doi-org-9532 297 25 , , , doi-org-9532 297 26 or or CC doi-org-9532 297 27 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 297 28 that that IN doi-org-9532 297 29 vaccinations vaccination NNS doi-org-9532 297 30 cause cause VBP doi-org-9532 297 31 autism autism NN doi-org-9532 297 32 , , , doi-org-9532 297 33 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 297 34 seems seem VBZ doi-org-9532 297 35 important important JJ doi-org-9532 297 36 for for IN doi-org-9532 297 37 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 297 38 to to TO doi-org-9532 297 39 stand stand VB doi-org-9532 297 40 up up RP doi-org-9532 297 41 for for IN doi-org-9532 297 42 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 297 43 . . . doi-org-9532 298 1 Recently recently RB doi-org-9532 298 2 , , , doi-org-9532 298 3 science science NN doi-org-9532 298 4 itself -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 298 5 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 298 6 indicated indicate VBN doi-org-9532 298 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 298 8 scientific scientific JJ doi-org-9532 298 9 reasoning reasoning NN doi-org-9532 298 10 needs need VBZ doi-org-9532 298 11 help help NN doi-org-9532 298 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 298 13 get get VB doi-org-9532 298 14 traction traction NN doi-org-9532 298 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 298 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 298 17 popular popular JJ doi-org-9532 298 18 mind mind NN doi-org-9532 298 19 . . . doi-org-9532 299 1 Social social JJ doi-org-9532 299 2 psychologists psychologist NNS doi-org-9532 299 3 and and CC doi-org-9532 299 4 behavioral behavioral JJ doi-org-9532 299 5 economists economist NNS doi-org-9532 299 6 argue argue VBP doi-org-9532 299 7 that that IN doi-org-9532 299 8 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 299 9 minds mind NNS doi-org-9532 299 10 are be VBP doi-org-9532 299 11 governed govern VBN doi-org-9532 299 12 by by IN doi-org-9532 299 13 motivated motivated JJ doi-org-9532 299 14 reasoning reasoning NN doi-org-9532 299 15 and and CC doi-org-9532 299 16 naturally naturally RB doi-org-9532 299 17 gravitate gravitate VB doi-org-9532 299 18 toward toward IN doi-org-9532 299 19 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 299 20 that that WDT doi-org-9532 299 21 are be VBP doi-org-9532 299 22 emotionally emotionally RB doi-org-9532 299 23 satisfying satisfying JJ doi-org-9532 299 24 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 299 25 than than IN doi-org-9532 299 26 toward toward IN doi-org-9532 299 27 reasoned reason VBN doi-org-9532 299 28 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 299 29 and and CC doi-org-9532 299 30 objective objective JJ doi-org-9532 299 31 evidence.48 evidence.48 NNP doi-org-9532 299 32 Fake Fake NNP doi-org-9532 299 33 news news NN doi-org-9532 299 34 spreads spread VBZ doi-org-9532 299 35 faster fast RBR doi-org-9532 299 36 than than IN doi-org-9532 299 37 objective objective JJ doi-org-9532 299 38 reporting reporting NN doi-org-9532 299 39 on on IN doi-org-9532 299 40 social social JJ doi-org-9532 299 41 networks network NNS doi-org-9532 299 42 because because IN doi-org-9532 299 43 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 299 44 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 299 45 designed design VBN doi-org-9532 299 46 to to TO doi-org-9532 299 47 trigger trigger VB doi-org-9532 299 48 powerful powerful JJ doi-org-9532 299 49 emotional emotional JJ doi-org-9532 299 50 instincts instinct NNS doi-org-9532 299 51 that that WDT doi-org-9532 299 52 go go VBP doi-org-9532 299 53 deeper deeply RBR doi-org-9532 299 54 than than IN doi-org-9532 299 55 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 299 56 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 299 57 to to IN doi-org-9532 299 58 reason.49 reason.49 NNP doi-org-9532 299 59 If if IN doi-org-9532 299 60 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 299 61 fail fail VBP doi-org-9532 299 62 to to TO doi-org-9532 299 63 take take VB doi-org-9532 299 64 the the DT doi-org-9532 299 65 side side NN doi-org-9532 299 66 of of IN doi-org-9532 299 67 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 299 68 in in IN doi-org-9532 299 69 such such PDT doi-org-9532 299 70 an an DT doi-org-9532 299 71 irrational irrational JJ doi-org-9532 299 72 world world NN doi-org-9532 299 73 , , , doi-org-9532 299 74 how how WRB doi-org-9532 299 75 can can MD doi-org-9532 299 76 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 299 77 expect expect VB doi-org-9532 299 78 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 299 79 dedication dedication NN doi-org-9532 299 80 to to IN doi-org-9532 299 81 rational rational JJ doi-org-9532 299 82 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 299 83 and and CC doi-org-9532 299 84 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 299 85 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 299 86 to to TO doi-org-9532 299 87 be be VB doi-org-9532 299 88 effective effective JJ doi-org-9532 299 89 ? ? . doi-org-9532 300 1 As as RB doi-org-9532 300 2 attractive attractive JJ doi-org-9532 300 3 as as IN doi-org-9532 300 4 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 300 5 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 300 6 , , , doi-org-9532 300 7 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 300 8 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 300 9 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 300 10 's 's POS doi-org-9532 300 11 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 300 12 , , , doi-org-9532 300 13 non non JJ doi-org-9532 300 14 - - JJ doi-org-9532 300 15 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 300 16 embrace embrace NN doi-org-9532 300 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 300 18 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 300 19 rationalism rationalism NN doi-org-9532 300 20 leads lead VBZ doi-org-9532 300 21 to to IN doi-org-9532 300 22 difficult difficult JJ doi-org-9532 300 23 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 300 24 about about IN doi-org-9532 300 25 who who WP doi-org-9532 300 26 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 300 27 qualified qualified JJ doi-org-9532 300 28 to to TO doi-org-9532 300 29 be be VB doi-org-9532 300 30 a a DT doi-org-9532 300 31 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 300 32 . . . doi-org-9532 301 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 301 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 301 3 Page page NN doi-org-9532 301 4 71 71 CD doi-org-9532 301 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 301 6 Should Should MD doi-org-9532 301 7 people people NNS doi-org-9532 301 8 who who WP doi-org-9532 301 9 disagree disagree VBP doi-org-9532 301 10 with with IN doi-org-9532 301 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 301 12 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 301 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 301 14 global global JJ doi-org-9532 301 15 warming warming NN doi-org-9532 301 16 or or CC doi-org-9532 301 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 301 18 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 301 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 301 20 evolution evolution NN doi-org-9532 301 21 be be VB doi-org-9532 301 22 allowed allow VBN doi-org-9532 301 23 to to TO doi-org-9532 301 24 serve serve VB doi-org-9532 301 25 on on IN doi-org-9532 301 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 301 27 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 301 28 desk desk NN doi-org-9532 301 29 , , , doi-org-9532 301 30 where where WRB doi-org-9532 301 31 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 301 32 might may MD doi-org-9532 301 33 mislead mislead VB doi-org-9532 301 34 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 301 35 ? ? . doi-org-9532 302 1 What what WP doi-org-9532 302 2 about about IN doi-org-9532 302 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 302 4 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 302 5 who who WP doi-org-9532 302 6 believes believe VBZ doi-org-9532 302 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 302 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 302 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS doi-org-9532 302 10 , , , doi-org-9532 302 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 302 12 Torah Torah NNP doi-org-9532 302 13 , , , doi-org-9532 302 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 302 15 Book Book NNP doi-org-9532 302 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 302 17 Mormon Mormon NNP doi-org-9532 302 18 , , , doi-org-9532 302 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 302 20 Quran Quran NNP doi-org-9532 302 21 , , , doi-org-9532 302 22 or or CC doi-org-9532 302 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 302 24 Apache Apache NNP doi-org-9532 302 25 Creation Creation NNP doi-org-9532 302 26 Story Story NNP doi-org-9532 302 27 ? ? . doi-org-9532 303 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 303 2 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 303 3 , , , doi-org-9532 303 4 none none NN doi-org-9532 303 5 of of IN doi-org-9532 303 6 these these DT doi-org-9532 303 7 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 303 8 myths myth NNS doi-org-9532 303 9 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 303 10 any any DT doi-org-9532 303 11 more more RBR doi-org-9532 303 12 rational rational JJ doi-org-9532 303 13 warrant warrant NN doi-org-9532 303 14 than than IN doi-org-9532 303 15 arguments argument NNS doi-org-9532 303 16 against against IN doi-org-9532 303 17 global global JJ doi-org-9532 303 18 warming warming NN doi-org-9532 303 19 . . . doi-org-9532 304 1 As as IN doi-org-9532 304 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 304 3 library library NN doi-org-9532 304 4 director director NN doi-org-9532 304 5 , , , doi-org-9532 304 6 should should MD doi-org-9532 304 7 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 304 8 refuse refuse VB doi-org-9532 304 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 304 10 hire hire VB doi-org-9532 304 11 anyone anyone NN doi-org-9532 304 12 who who WP doi-org-9532 304 13 maintains maintain VBZ doi-org-9532 304 14 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 304 15 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 304 16 at at IN doi-org-9532 304 17 odds odd NNS doi-org-9532 304 18 with with IN doi-org-9532 304 19 my -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 304 20 scientific scientific JJ doi-org-9532 304 21 understanding understanding NN doi-org-9532 304 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 304 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 304 24 universe universe NN doi-org-9532 304 25 or or CC doi-org-9532 304 26 at at IN doi-org-9532 304 27 least least JJS doi-org-9532 304 28 force force VB doi-org-9532 304 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 304 30 employee employee NN doi-org-9532 304 31 to to TO doi-org-9532 304 32 toe toe VB doi-org-9532 304 33 the the DT doi-org-9532 304 34 line line NN doi-org-9532 304 35 of of IN doi-org-9532 304 36 science science NN doi-org-9532 304 37 on on IN doi-org-9532 304 38 the the DT doi-org-9532 304 39 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 304 40 desk desk NN doi-org-9532 304 41 ? ? . doi-org-9532 305 1 What what WP doi-org-9532 305 2 about about IN doi-org-9532 305 3 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 305 4 who who WP doi-org-9532 305 5 voted vote VBD doi-org-9532 305 6 for for IN doi-org-9532 305 7 Donald Donald NNP doi-org-9532 305 8 Trump Trump NNP doi-org-9532 305 9 in in IN doi-org-9532 305 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 305 11 2016 2016 CD doi-org-9532 305 12 election election NN doi-org-9532 305 13 , , , doi-org-9532 305 14 perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 305 15 because because IN doi-org-9532 305 16 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 305 17 believed believe VBD doi-org-9532 305 18 some some DT doi-org-9532 305 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 305 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 305 21 news news NN doi-org-9532 305 22 about about IN doi-org-9532 305 23 Trump Trump NNP doi-org-9532 305 24 and and CC doi-org-9532 305 25 Hillary Hillary NNP doi-org-9532 305 26 Clinton Clinton NNP doi-org-9532 305 27 that that WDT doi-org-9532 305 28 was be VBD doi-org-9532 305 29 distributed distribute VBN doi-org-9532 305 30 by by IN doi-org-9532 305 31 Russian russian JJ doi-org-9532 305 32 trolls troll NNS doi-org-9532 305 33 ? ? . doi-org-9532 306 1 Can Can MD doi-org-9532 306 2 someone someone NN doi-org-9532 306 3 who who WP doi-org-9532 306 4 was be VBD doi-org-9532 306 5 irrational irrational JJ doi-org-9532 306 6 enough enough RB doi-org-9532 306 7 to to TO doi-org-9532 306 8 vote vote VB doi-org-9532 306 9 for for IN doi-org-9532 306 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 306 11 politician politician NN doi-org-9532 306 12 based base VBN doi-org-9532 306 13 on on IN doi-org-9532 306 14 false false JJ doi-org-9532 306 15 information information NN doi-org-9532 306 16 distributed distribute VBN doi-org-9532 306 17 by by IN doi-org-9532 306 18 foreign foreign JJ doi-org-9532 306 19 agents agent NNS doi-org-9532 306 20 be be VB doi-org-9532 306 21 trusted trust VBN doi-org-9532 306 22 to to TO doi-org-9532 306 23 distinguish distinguish VB doi-org-9532 306 24 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 306 25 from from IN doi-org-9532 306 26 reason reason NN doi-org-9532 306 27 working work VBG doi-org-9532 306 28 at at IN doi-org-9532 306 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 306 30 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 306 31 desk desk NN doi-org-9532 306 32 ? ? . doi-org-9532 307 1 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 307 2 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 307 3 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 307 4 's 's POS doi-org-9532 307 5 rejection rejection NN doi-org-9532 307 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 307 7 library library JJ doi-org-9532 307 8 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 307 9 on on IN doi-org-9532 307 10 perfectionist perfectionist JJ doi-org-9532 307 11 grounds ground NNS doi-org-9532 307 12 harkens harkens NNP doi-org-9532 307 13 back back RB doi-org-9532 307 14 to to IN doi-org-9532 307 15 an an DT doi-org-9532 307 16 earlier early JJR doi-org-9532 307 17 version version NN doi-org-9532 307 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 307 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 307 20 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 307 21 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 307 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 307 23 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 307 24 . . . doi-org-9532 308 1 According accord VBG doi-org-9532 308 2 to to IN doi-org-9532 308 3 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 308 4 , , , doi-org-9532 308 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 308 6 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 308 7 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 308 8 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 308 9 used use VBD doi-org-9532 308 10 to to TO doi-org-9532 308 11 include include VB doi-org-9532 308 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 308 13 clause clause NN doi-org-9532 308 14 saying say VBG doi-org-9532 308 15 that that IN doi-org-9532 308 16 " " `` doi-org-9532 308 17 books book NNS doi-org-9532 308 18 ' ' '' doi-org-9532 308 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 308 20 sound sound JJ doi-org-9532 308 21 factual factual JJ doi-org-9532 308 22 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 308 23 ' ' '' doi-org-9532 308 24 should should MD doi-org-9532 308 25 not not RB doi-org-9532 308 26 be be VB doi-org-9532 308 27 proscribed proscribe VBN doi-org-9532 308 28 or or CC doi-org-9532 308 29 removed remove VBN doi-org-9532 308 30 from from IN doi-org-9532 308 31 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 308 32 . . . doi-org-9532 309 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 309 2 50 50 CD doi-org-9532 309 3 Including include VBG doi-org-9532 309 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 309 5 qualifier qualifier NN doi-org-9532 309 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 309 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 309 8 sound sound JJ doi-org-9532 309 9 factual factual JJ doi-org-9532 309 10 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 309 11 " " '' doi-org-9532 309 12 gave give VBD doi-org-9532 309 13 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 309 14 leeway leeway NN doi-org-9532 309 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 309 16 keep keep VB doi-org-9532 309 17 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 309 18 out out IN doi-org-9532 309 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 309 20 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 309 21 collections collection NNS doi-org-9532 309 22 . . . doi-org-9532 310 1 However however RB doi-org-9532 310 2 , , , doi-org-9532 310 3 after after IN doi-org-9532 310 4 a a DT doi-org-9532 310 5 public public JJ doi-org-9532 310 6 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 310 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 310 8 Illinois Illinois NNP doi-org-9532 310 9 rejected reject VBD doi-org-9532 310 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 310 11 Protestant protestant JJ doi-org-9532 310 12 journal journal NN doi-org-9532 310 13 that that WDT doi-org-9532 310 14 criticized criticize VBD doi-org-9532 310 15 Catholicism Catholicism NNP doi-org-9532 310 16 because because IN doi-org-9532 310 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 310 18 journal journal NN doi-org-9532 310 19 lacked lack VBD doi-org-9532 310 20 " " `` doi-org-9532 310 21 sound sound JJ doi-org-9532 310 22 factual factual JJ doi-org-9532 310 23 authority authority NN doi-org-9532 310 24 , , , doi-org-9532 310 25 " " '' doi-org-9532 310 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 310 27 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 310 28 decided decide VBD doi-org-9532 310 29 to to TO doi-org-9532 310 30 remove remove VB doi-org-9532 310 31 the the DT doi-org-9532 310 32 phrase phrase NN doi-org-9532 310 33 from from IN doi-org-9532 310 34 the the DT doi-org-9532 310 35 1967 1967 CD doi-org-9532 310 36 version version NN doi-org-9532 310 37 of of IN doi-org-9532 310 38 the the DT doi-org-9532 310 39 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 310 40 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 310 41 of of IN doi-org-9532 310 42 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 310 43 instead instead RB doi-org-9532 310 44 of of IN doi-org-9532 310 45 trying try VBG doi-org-9532 310 46 to to TO doi-org-9532 310 47 determine determine VB doi-org-9532 310 48 whether whether IN doi-org-9532 310 49 Catholicism Catholicism NNP doi-org-9532 310 50 was be VBD doi-org-9532 310 51 more more RBR doi-org-9532 310 52 factual factual JJ doi-org-9532 310 53 than than IN doi-org-9532 310 54 Protestantism Protestantism NNP doi-org-9532 310 55 . . . doi-org-9532 311 1 This this DT doi-org-9532 311 2 change change NN doi-org-9532 311 3 made make VBD doi-org-9532 311 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 311 5 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 311 6 Bill Bill NNP doi-org-9532 311 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 311 8 Rights Rights NNPS doi-org-9532 311 9 more more RBR doi-org-9532 311 10 consistent consistent JJ doi-org-9532 311 11 with with IN doi-org-9532 311 12 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 311 13 's 's POS doi-org-9532 311 14 interpretation interpretation NN doi-org-9532 311 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 311 16 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 311 17 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 311 18 , , , doi-org-9532 311 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 311 20 which which WDT doi-org-9532 311 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 311 22 state state NN doi-org-9532 311 23 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 311 24 not not RB doi-org-9532 311 25 take take VB doi-org-9532 311 26 an an DT doi-org-9532 311 27 official official JJ doi-org-9532 311 28 stance stance NN doi-org-9532 311 29 on on IN doi-org-9532 311 30 the the DT doi-org-9532 311 31 scientific scientific JJ doi-org-9532 311 32 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 311 33 held hold VBN doi-org-9532 311 34 by by IN doi-org-9532 311 35 different different JJ doi-org-9532 311 36 groups group NNS doi-org-9532 311 37 in in IN doi-org-9532 311 38 society society NN doi-org-9532 311 39 . . . doi-org-9532 312 1 As as IN doi-org-9532 312 2 indicated indicate VBN doi-org-9532 312 3 in in IN doi-org-9532 312 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 312 5 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 312 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 312 7 Read read VB doi-org-9532 312 8 Statement Statement NNP doi-org-9532 312 9 , , , doi-org-9532 312 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 312 11 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 312 12 approach approach NN doi-org-9532 312 13 requires require VBZ doi-org-9532 312 14 faith faith NN doi-org-9532 312 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 312 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 312 17 critical critical JJ doi-org-9532 312 18 judgment judgment NN doi-org-9532 312 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 312 20 ordinary ordinary JJ doi-org-9532 312 21 individuals individual NNS doi-org-9532 312 22 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 312 23 than than IN doi-org-9532 312 24 in in IN doi-org-9532 312 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 312 26 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 312 27 guidance guidance NN doi-org-9532 312 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 312 29 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 312 30 to to TO doi-org-9532 312 31 protect protect VB doi-org-9532 312 32 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 312 33 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 312 34 from from IN doi-org-9532 312 35 authoritarian authoritarian JJ doi-org-9532 312 36 demagogues demagogue NNS doi-org-9532 312 37 . . . doi-org-9532 313 1 It -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 313 2 may may MD doi-org-9532 313 3 be be VB doi-org-9532 313 4 impossible impossible JJ doi-org-9532 313 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 313 6 give give VB doi-org-9532 313 7 any any DT doi-org-9532 313 8 definitive definitive JJ doi-org-9532 313 9 proof proof NN doi-org-9532 313 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 313 11 advance advance NN doi-org-9532 313 12 that that IN doi-org-9532 313 13 such such JJ doi-org-9532 313 14 faith faith NN doi-org-9532 313 15 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 313 16 justified justify VBN doi-org-9532 313 17 , , , doi-org-9532 313 18 especially especially RB doi-org-9532 313 19 with with IN doi-org-9532 313 20 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 313 21 growing grow VBG doi-org-9532 313 22 understanding understanding NN doi-org-9532 313 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 313 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 313 25 power power NN doi-org-9532 313 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 313 27 irrational irrational JJ doi-org-9532 313 28 ideas idea NNS doi-org-9532 313 29 and and CC doi-org-9532 313 30 undemocratic undemocratic JJ doi-org-9532 313 31 impulses impulse NNS doi-org-9532 313 32 in in IN doi-org-9532 313 33 human human JJ doi-org-9532 313 34 nature nature NN doi-org-9532 313 35 . . . doi-org-9532 314 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB doi-org-9532 314 2 , , , doi-org-9532 314 3 if if IN doi-org-9532 314 4 faith faith NN doi-org-9532 314 5 in in IN doi-org-9532 314 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 314 7 judgment judgment NN doi-org-9532 314 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 314 9 ordinary ordinary JJ doi-org-9532 314 10 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 314 11 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 314 12 not not RB doi-org-9532 314 13 justified justify VBN doi-org-9532 314 14 , , , doi-org-9532 314 15 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 314 16 doubt doubt VBP doi-org-9532 314 17 that that IN doi-org-9532 314 18 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 314 19 can can MD doi-org-9532 314 20 fix fix VB doi-org-9532 314 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 314 22 problem problem NN doi-org-9532 314 23 by by IN doi-org-9532 314 24 " " `` doi-org-9532 314 25 imposing impose VBG doi-org-9532 314 26 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 314 27 own own JJ doi-org-9532 314 28 patterns pattern NNS doi-org-9532 314 29 " " '' doi-org-9532 314 30 of of IN doi-org-9532 314 31 thought thought NN doi-org-9532 314 32 on on IN doi-org-9532 314 33 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 314 34 — — : doi-org-9532 314 35 at at IN doi-org-9532 314 36 least least JJS doi-org-9532 314 37 , , , doi-org-9532 314 38 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 314 39 do do VBP doi-org-9532 314 40 not not RB doi-org-9532 314 41 think think VB doi-org-9532 314 42 that that IN doi-org-9532 314 43 library library JJ doi-org-9532 314 44 paternalism paternalism NN doi-org-9532 314 45 could could MD doi-org-9532 314 46 fix fix VB doi-org-9532 314 47 the the DT doi-org-9532 314 48 problem problem NN doi-org-9532 314 49 in in IN doi-org-9532 314 50 any any DT doi-org-9532 314 51 way way NN doi-org-9532 314 52 that that WDT doi-org-9532 314 53 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 314 54 consistent consistent JJ doi-org-9532 314 55 with with IN doi-org-9532 314 56 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 314 57 . . . doi-org-9532 315 1 Thus thus RB doi-org-9532 315 2 , , , doi-org-9532 315 3 my -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 315 4 ultimate ultimate JJ doi-org-9532 315 5 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 315 6 against against IN doi-org-9532 315 7 perfectionism perfectionism NN doi-org-9532 315 8 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 315 9 less less RBR doi-org-9532 315 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 315 11 matter matter NN doi-org-9532 315 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 315 13 evidence evidence NN doi-org-9532 315 14 and and CC doi-org-9532 315 15 proof proof NN doi-org-9532 315 16 and and CC doi-org-9532 315 17 more more RBR doi-org-9532 315 18 a a DT doi-org-9532 315 19 matter matter NN doi-org-9532 315 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 315 21 hope hope NN doi-org-9532 315 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 315 23 faith faith NN doi-org-9532 315 24 . . . doi-org-9532 316 1 Librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 316 2 should should MD doi-org-9532 316 3 build build VB doi-org-9532 316 4 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 316 5 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 316 6 with with IN doi-org-9532 316 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 316 8 expectation expectation NN doi-org-9532 316 9 that that IN doi-org-9532 316 10 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 316 11 will will MD doi-org-9532 316 12 use use VB doi-org-9532 316 13 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 316 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 316 15 expand expand VB doi-org-9532 316 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 316 17 scope scope NN doi-org-9532 316 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 316 19 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 316 20 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 316 21 and and CC doi-org-9532 316 22 hope hope VB doi-org-9532 316 23 that that IN doi-org-9532 316 24 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 316 25 faith faith NN doi-org-9532 316 26 in in IN doi-org-9532 316 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 316 28 critical critical JJ doi-org-9532 316 29 judgment judgment NN doi-org-9532 316 30 of of IN doi-org-9532 316 31 ordinary ordinary JJ doi-org-9532 316 32 people people NNS doi-org-9532 316 33 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 316 34 justified justified JJ doi-org-9532 316 35 . . . doi-org-9532 317 1 We -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 317 2 will will MD doi-org-9532 317 3 see see VB doi-org-9532 317 4 what what WP doi-org-9532 317 5 happens happen VBZ doi-org-9532 317 6 . . . doi-org-9532 318 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 318 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 318 3 Page page NN doi-org-9532 318 4 72 72 CD doi-org-9532 318 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 318 6 The the DT doi-org-9532 318 7 Radical Radical NNP doi-org-9532 318 8 Critique Critique NNP doi-org-9532 318 9 Radical Radical NNP doi-org-9532 318 10 critics critic NNS doi-org-9532 318 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 318 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 318 13 library library JJ doi-org-9532 318 14 neutrality neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 318 15 syllogism syllogism NN doi-org-9532 318 16 do do VBP doi-org-9532 318 17 not not RB doi-org-9532 318 18 care care VB doi-org-9532 318 19 if if IN doi-org-9532 318 20 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 318 21 requires require VBZ doi-org-9532 318 22 a a DT doi-org-9532 318 23 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 318 24 state state NN doi-org-9532 318 25 because because IN doi-org-9532 318 26 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 318 27 reject reject VBP doi-org-9532 318 28 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 318 29 itself -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 318 30 . . . doi-org-9532 319 1 Conservative conservative JJ doi-org-9532 319 2 radicals radical NNS doi-org-9532 319 3 reject reject VBP doi-org-9532 319 4 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 319 5 on on IN doi-org-9532 319 6 behalf behalf NN doi-org-9532 319 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 319 8 traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 319 9 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 319 10 values value NNS doi-org-9532 319 11 that that WDT doi-org-9532 319 12 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 319 13 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 319 14 have have VBP doi-org-9532 319 15 been be VBN doi-org-9532 319 16 abandoned abandon VBN doi-org-9532 319 17 by by IN doi-org-9532 319 18 modern modern JJ doi-org-9532 319 19 society society NN doi-org-9532 319 20 . . . doi-org-9532 320 1 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 320 2 want want VBP doi-org-9532 320 3 to to TO doi-org-9532 320 4 ground ground VB doi-org-9532 320 5 morality morality NN doi-org-9532 320 6 in in IN doi-org-9532 320 7 traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 320 8 cultural cultural JJ doi-org-9532 320 9 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 320 10 because because IN doi-org-9532 320 11 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 320 12 believe believe VBP doi-org-9532 320 13 that that IN doi-org-9532 320 14 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 320 15 , , , doi-org-9532 320 16 individualistic individualistic JJ doi-org-9532 320 17 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 320 18 render render VBP doi-org-9532 320 19 people people NNS doi-org-9532 320 20 rootless rootless VBP doi-org-9532 320 21 and and CC doi-org-9532 320 22 alienated.51 alienated.51 NNP doi-org-9532 320 23 Revolutionary Revolutionary NNP doi-org-9532 320 24 radicals radical NNS doi-org-9532 320 25 reject reject VBP doi-org-9532 320 26 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 320 27 individualism individualism NN doi-org-9532 320 28 not not RB doi-org-9532 320 29 on on IN doi-org-9532 320 30 behalf behalf NN doi-org-9532 320 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 320 32 abandoned abandon VBN doi-org-9532 320 33 social social JJ doi-org-9532 320 34 orders order NNS doi-org-9532 320 35 of of IN doi-org-9532 320 36 the the DT doi-org-9532 320 37 past past NN doi-org-9532 320 38 but but CC doi-org-9532 320 39 on on IN doi-org-9532 320 40 possible possible JJ doi-org-9532 320 41 social social JJ doi-org-9532 320 42 orders order NNS doi-org-9532 320 43 of of IN doi-org-9532 320 44 the the DT doi-org-9532 320 45 future future NN doi-org-9532 320 46 . . . doi-org-9532 321 1 They -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 321 2 argue argue VBP doi-org-9532 321 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 321 4 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 321 5 prevents prevent VBZ doi-org-9532 321 6 people people NNS doi-org-9532 321 7 from from IN doi-org-9532 321 8 achieving achieve VBG doi-org-9532 321 9 alternative alternative JJ doi-org-9532 321 10 social social JJ doi-org-9532 321 11 arrangements arrangement NNS doi-org-9532 321 12 more more RBR doi-org-9532 321 13 consistent consistent JJ doi-org-9532 321 14 with with IN doi-org-9532 321 15 human human JJ doi-org-9532 321 16 aspirations aspiration NNS doi-org-9532 321 17 because because IN doi-org-9532 321 18 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 321 19 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 321 20 makes make VBZ doi-org-9532 321 21 oppressive oppressive JJ doi-org-9532 321 22 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 321 23 seem seem VB doi-org-9532 321 24 inevitable inevitable JJ doi-org-9532 321 25 by by IN doi-org-9532 321 26 embedding embed VBG doi-org-9532 321 27 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 321 28 in in IN doi-org-9532 321 29 false false JJ doi-org-9532 321 30 beliefs belief NNS doi-org-9532 321 31 about about IN doi-org-9532 321 32 human human JJ doi-org-9532 321 33 nature nature NN doi-org-9532 321 34 that that WDT doi-org-9532 321 35 are be VBP doi-org-9532 321 36 impervious impervious JJ doi-org-9532 321 37 to to IN doi-org-9532 321 38 political political JJ doi-org-9532 321 39 change change NN doi-org-9532 321 40 . . . doi-org-9532 322 1 Although although IN doi-org-9532 322 2 conservative conservative JJ doi-org-9532 322 3 radicals radical NNS doi-org-9532 322 4 appear appear VBP doi-org-9532 322 5 to to TO doi-org-9532 322 6 have have VB doi-org-9532 322 7 more more JJR doi-org-9532 322 8 influence influence NN doi-org-9532 322 9 in in IN doi-org-9532 322 10 contemporary contemporary JJ doi-org-9532 322 11 American american JJ doi-org-9532 322 12 politics politic NNS doi-org-9532 322 13 , , , doi-org-9532 322 14 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 322 15 will will MD doi-org-9532 322 16 focus focus VB doi-org-9532 322 17 on on IN doi-org-9532 322 18 revolutionary revolutionary JJ doi-org-9532 322 19 radicals radical NNS doi-org-9532 322 20 here here RB doi-org-9532 322 21 because because IN doi-org-9532 322 22 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 322 23 are be VBP doi-org-9532 322 24 more more RBR doi-org-9532 322 25 influential influential JJ doi-org-9532 322 26 in in IN doi-org-9532 322 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 322 28 current current JJ doi-org-9532 322 29 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 322 30 of of IN doi-org-9532 322 31 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 322 32 . . . doi-org-9532 323 1 Whereas whereas IN doi-org-9532 323 2 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 323 3 have have VBP doi-org-9532 323 4 argued argue VBN doi-org-9532 323 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 323 6 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 323 7 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 323 8 means mean VBZ doi-org-9532 323 9 that that IN doi-org-9532 323 10 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 323 11 in in IN doi-org-9532 323 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 323 13 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 323 14 society society NN doi-org-9532 323 15 should should MD doi-org-9532 323 16 have have VB doi-org-9532 323 17 equal equal JJ doi-org-9532 323 18 opportunity opportunity NN doi-org-9532 323 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 323 20 promote promote VB doi-org-9532 323 21 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 323 22 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 323 23 views view NNS doi-org-9532 323 24 if if IN doi-org-9532 323 25 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 323 26 play play VBP doi-org-9532 323 27 by by IN doi-org-9532 323 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 323 29 rules rule NNS doi-org-9532 323 30 of of IN doi-org-9532 323 31 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 323 32 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 323 33 , , , doi-org-9532 323 34 radicals radical NNS doi-org-9532 323 35 argue argue VBP doi-org-9532 323 36 that that IN doi-org-9532 323 37 the the DT doi-org-9532 323 38 rules rule NNS doi-org-9532 323 39 are be VBP doi-org-9532 323 40 rigged rig VBN doi-org-9532 323 41 . . . doi-org-9532 324 1 Playing play VBG doi-org-9532 324 2 by by IN doi-org-9532 324 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 324 4 rules rule NNS doi-org-9532 324 5 necessarily necessarily RB doi-org-9532 324 6 leads lead VBZ doi-org-9532 324 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 324 8 inequities inequity NNS doi-org-9532 324 9 that that WDT doi-org-9532 324 10 undermine undermine VBP doi-org-9532 324 11 efforts effort NNS doi-org-9532 324 12 to to TO doi-org-9532 324 13 achieve achieve VB doi-org-9532 324 14 social social JJ doi-org-9532 324 15 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 324 16 because because IN doi-org-9532 324 17 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 324 18 encourages encourage VBZ doi-org-9532 324 19 people people NNS doi-org-9532 324 20 to to TO doi-org-9532 324 21 seek seek VB doi-org-9532 324 22 individualistic individualistic JJ doi-org-9532 324 23 solutions solution NNS doi-org-9532 324 24 to to IN doi-org-9532 324 25 systematic systematic JJ doi-org-9532 324 26 problems problem NNS doi-org-9532 324 27 that that WDT doi-org-9532 324 28 can can MD doi-org-9532 324 29 be be VB doi-org-9532 324 30 resolved resolve VBN doi-org-9532 324 31 only only RB doi-org-9532 324 32 through through IN doi-org-9532 324 33 collective collective JJ doi-org-9532 324 34 action action NN doi-org-9532 324 35 . . . doi-org-9532 325 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 325 2 example example NN doi-org-9532 325 3 , , , doi-org-9532 325 4 Andrew Andrew NNP doi-org-9532 325 5 Carnegie Carnegie NNP doi-org-9532 325 6 contributed contribute VBD doi-org-9532 325 7 generously generously RB doi-org-9532 325 8 to to IN doi-org-9532 325 9 public public JJ doi-org-9532 325 10 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 325 11 because because IN doi-org-9532 325 12 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 325 13 wanted want VBD doi-org-9532 325 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 325 15 give give VB doi-org-9532 325 16 everyone everyone NN doi-org-9532 325 17 in in IN doi-org-9532 325 18 America America NNP doi-org-9532 325 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 325 20 opportunity opportunity NN doi-org-9532 325 21 to to TO doi-org-9532 325 22 become become VB doi-org-9532 325 23 self self NN doi-org-9532 325 24 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 325 25 made make VBN doi-org-9532 325 26 entrepreneurs entrepreneur NNS doi-org-9532 325 27 like like IN doi-org-9532 325 28 himself -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 325 29 . . . doi-org-9532 326 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 326 2 resulting result VBG doi-org-9532 326 3 ubiquity ubiquity NN doi-org-9532 326 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 326 5 public public JJ doi-org-9532 326 6 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 326 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 326 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 326 9 United United NNP doi-org-9532 326 10 States States NNP doi-org-9532 326 11 as as IN doi-org-9532 326 12 arenas arena NNS doi-org-9532 326 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 326 14 self self NN doi-org-9532 326 15 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 326 16 improvement improvement NN doi-org-9532 326 17 encourages encourage VBZ doi-org-9532 326 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 326 19 poor poor JJ doi-org-9532 326 20 and and CC doi-org-9532 326 21 ambitious ambitious JJ doi-org-9532 326 22 to to TO doi-org-9532 326 23 improve improve VB doi-org-9532 326 24 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 326 25 social social JJ doi-org-9532 326 26 condition condition NN doi-org-9532 326 27 by by IN doi-org-9532 326 28 increasing increase VBG doi-org-9532 326 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 326 30 " " `` doi-org-9532 326 31 human human JJ doi-org-9532 326 32 capital capital NN doi-org-9532 326 33 " " '' doi-org-9532 326 34 that that IN doi-org-9532 326 35 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 326 36 can can MD doi-org-9532 326 37 sell sell VB doi-org-9532 326 38 in in IN doi-org-9532 326 39 the the DT doi-org-9532 326 40 marketplace marketplace NN doi-org-9532 326 41 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 326 42 than than IN doi-org-9532 326 43 by by IN doi-org-9532 326 44 joining join VBG doi-org-9532 326 45 together together RB doi-org-9532 326 46 with with IN doi-org-9532 326 47 others other NNS doi-org-9532 326 48 to to TO doi-org-9532 326 49 seek seek VB doi-org-9532 326 50 political political JJ doi-org-9532 326 51 solutions solution NNS doi-org-9532 326 52 to to IN doi-org-9532 326 53 inequality inequality NN doi-org-9532 326 54 . . . doi-org-9532 327 1 Public public JJ doi-org-9532 327 2 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 327 3 may may MD doi-org-9532 327 4 allow allow VB doi-org-9532 327 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 327 6 lucky lucky JJ doi-org-9532 327 7 few few JJ doi-org-9532 327 8 to to TO doi-org-9532 327 9 emulate emulate VB doi-org-9532 327 10 Carnegie Carnegie NNP doi-org-9532 327 11 , , , doi-org-9532 327 12 but but CC doi-org-9532 327 13 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 327 14 encourage encourage VBP doi-org-9532 327 15 neglect neglect NN doi-org-9532 327 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 327 17 collective collective JJ doi-org-9532 327 18 responses response NNS doi-org-9532 327 19 to to IN doi-org-9532 327 20 inequality inequality NN doi-org-9532 327 21 that that WDT doi-org-9532 327 22 have have VBP doi-org-9532 327 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 327 24 potential potential NN doi-org-9532 327 25 to to TO doi-org-9532 327 26 increase increase VB doi-org-9532 327 27 social social JJ doi-org-9532 327 28 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 327 29 in in IN doi-org-9532 327 30 a a DT doi-org-9532 327 31 more more RBR doi-org-9532 327 32 comprehensive comprehensive JJ doi-org-9532 327 33 way way NN doi-org-9532 327 34 . . . doi-org-9532 328 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 328 2 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 328 3 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 328 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 328 5 Locating locate VBG doi-org-9532 328 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 328 7 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 328 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 328 9 Institutional Institutional NNP doi-org-9532 328 10 Oppression Oppression NNP doi-org-9532 328 11 , , , doi-org-9532 328 12 " " '' doi-org-9532 328 13 nina nina NNP doi-org-9532 328 14 de de NNP doi-org-9532 328 15 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 328 16 articulates articulate VBZ doi-org-9532 328 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 328 18 radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 328 19 rejection rejection NN doi-org-9532 328 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 328 21 library library JJ doi-org-9532 328 22 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 328 23 with with IN doi-org-9532 328 24 explicit explicit JJ doi-org-9532 328 25 directness directness NN doi-org-9532 328 26 . . . doi-org-9532 329 1 Her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 329 2 analysis analysis NN doi-org-9532 329 3 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 329 4 based base VBN doi-org-9532 329 5 on on IN doi-org-9532 329 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 329 7 social social JJ doi-org-9532 329 8 theory theory NN doi-org-9532 329 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 329 10 Andrea Andrea NNP doi-org-9532 329 11 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 329 12 , , , doi-org-9532 329 13 a a DT doi-org-9532 329 14 professor professor NN doi-org-9532 329 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 329 16 media medium NNS doi-org-9532 329 17 and and CC doi-org-9532 329 18 cultural cultural JJ doi-org-9532 329 19 studies study NNS doi-org-9532 329 20 at at IN doi-org-9532 329 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 329 22 University University NNP doi-org-9532 329 23 of of IN doi-org-9532 329 24 California California NNP doi-org-9532 329 25 , , , doi-org-9532 329 26 Riverside Riverside NNP doi-org-9532 329 27 . . . doi-org-9532 330 1 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 330 2 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 330 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 330 4 white white JJ doi-org-9532 330 5 supremacy supremacy NN doi-org-9532 330 6 , , , doi-org-9532 330 7 slavery slavery NN doi-org-9532 330 8 , , , doi-org-9532 330 9 and and CC doi-org-9532 330 10 genocide genocide NN doi-org-9532 330 11 are be VBP doi-org-9532 330 12 inherent inherent JJ doi-org-9532 330 13 in in IN doi-org-9532 330 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 330 15 social social JJ doi-org-9532 330 16 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 330 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 330 18 modern modern JJ doi-org-9532 330 19 capitalist capitalist NN doi-org-9532 330 20 societies.52 societies.52 NNP doi-org-9532 330 21 For for IN doi-org-9532 330 22 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 330 23 , , , doi-org-9532 330 24 the the DT doi-org-9532 330 25 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 330 26 claim claim NN doi-org-9532 330 27 in in IN doi-org-9532 330 28 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 330 29 analysis analysis NN doi-org-9532 330 30 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 330 31 that that DT doi-org-9532 330 32 white white JJ doi-org-9532 330 33 supremacy supremacy NN doi-org-9532 330 34 and and CC doi-org-9532 330 35 genocide genocide NN doi-org-9532 330 36 are be VBP doi-org-9532 330 37 essential essential JJ doi-org-9532 330 38 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 330 39 than than IN doi-org-9532 330 40 accidental accidental JJ doi-org-9532 330 41 features feature NNS doi-org-9532 330 42 of of IN doi-org-9532 330 43 modern modern JJ doi-org-9532 330 44 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 330 45 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 330 46 . . . doi-org-9532 331 1 Almost almost RB doi-org-9532 331 2 no no DT doi-org-9532 331 3 one one NN doi-org-9532 331 4 today today NN doi-org-9532 331 5 — — : doi-org-9532 331 6 certainly certainly RB doi-org-9532 331 7 no no DT doi-org-9532 331 8 one one NN doi-org-9532 331 9 whom whom WP doi-org-9532 331 10 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 331 11 would would MD doi-org-9532 331 12 call call VB doi-org-9532 331 13 " " `` doi-org-9532 331 14 liberal"—would liberal"—would NNP doi-org-9532 331 15 defend defend VB doi-org-9532 331 16 white white JJ doi-org-9532 331 17 supremacy supremacy NN doi-org-9532 331 18 as as IN doi-org-9532 331 19 a a DT doi-org-9532 331 20 good good JJ doi-org-9532 331 21 thing thing NN doi-org-9532 331 22 . . . doi-org-9532 332 1 And and CC doi-org-9532 332 2 few few JJ doi-org-9532 332 3 people people NNS doi-org-9532 332 4 — — : doi-org-9532 332 5 certainly certainly RB doi-org-9532 332 6 no no DT doi-org-9532 332 7 one one NN doi-org-9532 332 8 whom whom WP doi-org-9532 332 9 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 332 10 would would MD doi-org-9532 332 11 consider consider VB doi-org-9532 332 12 honest honest JJ doi-org-9532 332 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 332 14 well well RB doi-org-9532 332 15 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 332 16 informed inform VBN doi-org-9532 332 17 — — : doi-org-9532 332 18 would would MD doi-org-9532 332 19 deny deny VB doi-org-9532 332 20 that that IN doi-org-9532 332 21 white white JJ doi-org-9532 332 22 supremacy supremacy NN doi-org-9532 332 23 continues continue VBZ doi-org-9532 332 24 to to TO doi-org-9532 332 25 exist exist VB doi-org-9532 332 26 in in IN doi-org-9532 332 27 modern modern JJ doi-org-9532 332 28 American american JJ doi-org-9532 332 29 society society NN doi-org-9532 332 30 . . . doi-org-9532 333 1 Where where WRB doi-org-9532 333 2 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 333 3 and and CC doi-org-9532 333 4 de de NNP doi-org-9532 333 5 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 333 6 disagree disagree VBP doi-org-9532 333 7 with with IN doi-org-9532 333 8 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 333 9 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 333 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 333 11 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 333 12 assertion assertion NN doi-org-9532 333 13 that that IN doi-org-9532 333 14 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 333 15 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 333 16 impossible impossible JJ doi-org-9532 333 17 to to TO doi-org-9532 333 18 get get VB doi-org-9532 333 19 rid rid VBN doi-org-9532 333 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 333 21 white white JJ doi-org-9532 333 22 supremacy supremacy NN doi-org-9532 333 23 , , , doi-org-9532 333 24 slavery slavery NN doi-org-9532 333 25 , , , doi-org-9532 333 26 and and CC doi-org-9532 333 27 genocide genocide NN doi-org-9532 333 28 without without IN doi-org-9532 333 29 doing do VBG doi-org-9532 333 30 away away RB doi-org-9532 333 31 with with IN doi-org-9532 333 32 capitalism capitalism NN doi-org-9532 333 33 and and CC doi-org-9532 333 34 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 333 35 . . . doi-org-9532 334 1 From from IN doi-org-9532 334 2 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 334 3 perspective perspective NN doi-org-9532 334 4 , , , doi-org-9532 334 5 trying try VBG doi-org-9532 334 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 334 7 eliminate eliminate VB doi-org-9532 334 8 white white JJ doi-org-9532 334 9 supremacy supremacy NN doi-org-9532 334 10 while while IN doi-org-9532 334 11 playing play VBG doi-org-9532 334 12 by by IN doi-org-9532 334 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 334 14 rules rule NNS doi-org-9532 334 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 334 16 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 334 17 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 334 18 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 334 19 like like IN doi-org-9532 334 20 using use VBG doi-org-9532 334 21 a a DT doi-org-9532 334 22 little little JJ doi-org-9532 334 23 bucket bucket NN doi-org-9532 334 24 to to TO doi-org-9532 334 25 remove remove VB doi-org-9532 334 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 334 27 water water NN doi-org-9532 334 28 from from IN doi-org-9532 334 29 a a DT doi-org-9532 334 30 boat boat NN doi-org-9532 334 31 full full JJ doi-org-9532 334 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 334 33 holes hole NNS doi-org-9532 334 34 . . . doi-org-9532 335 1 Faster fast RBR doi-org-9532 335 2 than than IN doi-org-9532 335 3 reformers reformer NNS doi-org-9532 335 4 can can MD doi-org-9532 335 5 remedy remedy VB doi-org-9532 335 6 social social JJ doi-org-9532 335 7 injustices injustice NNS doi-org-9532 335 8 generated generate VBN doi-org-9532 335 9 by by IN doi-org-9532 335 10 capitalism capitalism NN doi-org-9532 335 11 , , , doi-org-9532 335 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 335 13 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 335 14 flaws flaw NNS doi-org-9532 335 15 at at IN doi-org-9532 335 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 335 17 heart heart NN doi-org-9532 335 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 335 19 system system NN doi-org-9532 335 20 create create VBP doi-org-9532 335 21 more more JJR doi-org-9532 335 22 violence violence NN doi-org-9532 335 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 335 24 exploitation exploitation NN doi-org-9532 335 25 . . . doi-org-9532 336 1 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 336 2 End end NN doi-org-9532 336 3 Page page NN doi-org-9532 336 4 73 73 CD doi-org-9532 336 5 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 336 6 Because because IN doi-org-9532 336 7 de de NNP doi-org-9532 336 8 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 336 9 considers consider VBZ doi-org-9532 336 10 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 336 11 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 336 12 rotten rotten JJ doi-org-9532 336 13 to to IN doi-org-9532 336 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 336 15 core core NN doi-org-9532 336 16 , , , doi-org-9532 336 17 she -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 336 18 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 336 19 that that IN doi-org-9532 336 20 any any DT doi-org-9532 336 21 institution institution NN doi-org-9532 336 22 — — : doi-org-9532 336 23 including include VBG doi-org-9532 336 24 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 336 25 — — : doi-org-9532 336 26 that that DT doi-org-9532 336 27 supports support VBZ doi-org-9532 336 28 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 336 29 contributes contribute VBZ doi-org-9532 336 30 to to IN doi-org-9532 336 31 the the DT doi-org-9532 336 32 ongoing ongoing JJ doi-org-9532 336 33 oppression oppression NN doi-org-9532 336 34 of of IN doi-org-9532 336 35 nonwhite nonwhite JJ doi-org-9532 336 36 people people NNS doi-org-9532 336 37 around around IN doi-org-9532 336 38 the the DT doi-org-9532 336 39 world world NN doi-org-9532 336 40 : : : doi-org-9532 336 41 " " `` doi-org-9532 336 42 The the DT doi-org-9532 336 43 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 336 44 of of IN doi-org-9532 336 45 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 336 46 as as IN doi-org-9532 336 47 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 336 48 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 336 49 existing exist VBG doi-org-9532 336 50 to to TO doi-org-9532 336 51 make make VB doi-org-9532 336 52 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 336 53 ' ' '' doi-org-9532 336 54 better well JJR doi-org-9532 336 55 , , , doi-org-9532 336 56 ' ' '' doi-org-9532 336 57 thus thus RB doi-org-9532 336 58 stronger strong JJR doi-org-9532 336 59 , , , doi-org-9532 336 60 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 336 61 no no DT doi-org-9532 336 62 less less JJR doi-org-9532 336 63 than than IN doi-org-9532 336 64 an an DT doi-org-9532 336 65 ideal ideal NN doi-org-9532 336 66 wherein wherein WRB doi-org-9532 336 67 the the DT doi-org-9532 336 68 genocide genocide NN doi-org-9532 336 69 of of IN doi-org-9532 336 70 Indigenous indigenous JJ doi-org-9532 336 71 peoples people NNS doi-org-9532 336 72 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 336 73 finally finally RB doi-org-9532 336 74 completed complete VBN doi-org-9532 336 75 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 336 76 putting put VBG doi-org-9532 336 77 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 336 78 in in IN doi-org-9532 336 79 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 336 80 strongest strong JJS doi-org-9532 336 81 position position NN doi-org-9532 336 82 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 336 83 . . . doi-org-9532 337 1 " " `` doi-org-9532 337 2 53 53 CD doi-org-9532 337 3 By by IN doi-org-9532 337 4 " " '' doi-org-9532 337 5 creating create VBG doi-org-9532 337 6 better well JJR doi-org-9532 337 7 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 337 8 , , , doi-org-9532 337 9 " " '' doi-org-9532 337 10 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 337 11 contribute contribute VBP doi-org-9532 337 12 to to IN doi-org-9532 337 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 337 14 reproduction reproduction NN doi-org-9532 337 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 337 16 an an DT doi-org-9532 337 17 unjust unjust JJ doi-org-9532 337 18 social social JJ doi-org-9532 337 19 order order NN doi-org-9532 337 20 based base VBN doi-org-9532 337 21 on on IN doi-org-9532 337 22 violence violence NN doi-org-9532 337 23 . . . doi-org-9532 338 1 Librarians Librarians NNPS doi-org-9532 338 2 who who WP doi-org-9532 338 3 assert assert VBP doi-org-9532 338 4 that that IN doi-org-9532 338 5 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 338 6 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 338 7 are be VBP doi-org-9532 338 8 politically politically RB doi-org-9532 338 9 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 338 10 thus thus RB doi-org-9532 338 11 legitimize legitimize VBP doi-org-9532 338 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 338 13 violent violent JJ doi-org-9532 338 14 oppression oppression NN doi-org-9532 338 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 338 16 indigenous indigenous JJ doi-org-9532 338 17 people people NNS doi-org-9532 338 18 perpetuated perpetuate VBN doi-org-9532 338 19 by by IN doi-org-9532 338 20 capitalism capitalism NN doi-org-9532 338 21 . . . doi-org-9532 339 1 Specifically specifically RB doi-org-9532 339 2 , , , doi-org-9532 339 3 as as IN doi-org-9532 339 4 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 339 5 that that WDT doi-org-9532 339 6 collect collect VBP doi-org-9532 339 7 and and CC doi-org-9532 339 8 organize organize VB doi-org-9532 339 9 knowledge knowledge NN doi-org-9532 339 10 , , , doi-org-9532 339 11 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 339 12 support support VBP doi-org-9532 339 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 339 14 commodification commodification NN doi-org-9532 339 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 339 16 information information NN doi-org-9532 339 17 through through IN doi-org-9532 339 18 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 339 19 property property NN doi-org-9532 339 20 rights right NNS doi-org-9532 339 21 . . . doi-org-9532 340 1 Although although IN doi-org-9532 340 2 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 340 3 try try VBP doi-org-9532 340 4 to to TO doi-org-9532 340 5 share share VB doi-org-9532 340 6 information information NN doi-org-9532 340 7 with with IN doi-org-9532 340 8 a a DT doi-org-9532 340 9 broader broad JJR doi-org-9532 340 10 audience audience NN doi-org-9532 340 11 , , , doi-org-9532 340 12 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 340 13 participate participate VBP doi-org-9532 340 14 in in IN doi-org-9532 340 15 a a DT doi-org-9532 340 16 system system NN doi-org-9532 340 17 in in IN doi-org-9532 340 18 which which WDT doi-org-9532 340 19 information information NN doi-org-9532 340 20 becomes become VBZ doi-org-9532 340 21 property property NN doi-org-9532 340 22 by by IN doi-org-9532 340 23 restricting restrict VBG doi-org-9532 340 24 access access NN doi-org-9532 340 25 to to IN doi-org-9532 340 26 information information NN doi-org-9532 340 27 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 340 28 to to IN doi-org-9532 340 29 copyright copyright NN doi-org-9532 340 30 rules rule NNS doi-org-9532 340 31 . . . doi-org-9532 341 1 Only only RB doi-org-9532 341 2 by by IN doi-org-9532 341 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 341 4 breaking break VBG doi-org-9532 341 5 and and CC doi-org-9532 341 6 disrupting disrupt VBG doi-org-9532 341 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 341 8 system system NN doi-org-9532 341 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 341 10 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 341 11 property property NN doi-org-9532 341 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 341 13 other other JJ doi-org-9532 341 14 aspects aspect NNS doi-org-9532 341 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 341 16 capitalism capitalism NN doi-org-9532 341 17 , , , doi-org-9532 341 18 especially especially RB doi-org-9532 341 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 341 20 publishing publishing NN doi-org-9532 341 21 industry industry NN doi-org-9532 341 22 " " '' doi-org-9532 341 23 can can MD doi-org-9532 341 24 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 341 25 hope hope VB doi-org-9532 341 26 to to TO doi-org-9532 341 27 make make VB doi-org-9532 341 28 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 341 29 work work NN doi-org-9532 341 30 contribute contribute VB doi-org-9532 341 31 to to IN doi-org-9532 341 32 social social JJ doi-org-9532 341 33 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 341 34 instead instead RB doi-org-9532 341 35 of of IN doi-org-9532 341 36 racial racial JJ doi-org-9532 341 37 oppression oppression NN doi-org-9532 341 38 , , , doi-org-9532 341 39 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 341 40 to to IN doi-org-9532 341 41 de de NNP doi-org-9532 341 42 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 341 43 . . . doi-org-9532 342 1 As as IN doi-org-9532 342 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 342 3 citizen citizen NN doi-org-9532 342 4 , , , doi-org-9532 342 5 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 342 6 disagree disagree VBP doi-org-9532 342 7 with with IN doi-org-9532 342 8 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 342 9 's 's POS doi-org-9532 342 10 and and CC doi-org-9532 342 11 de de NNP doi-org-9532 342 12 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 342 13 's 's POS doi-org-9532 342 14 political political JJ doi-org-9532 342 15 analysis analysis NN doi-org-9532 342 16 because because IN doi-org-9532 342 17 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 342 18 am be VBP doi-org-9532 342 19 convinced convince VBN doi-org-9532 342 20 by by IN doi-org-9532 342 21 Israel Israel NNP doi-org-9532 342 22 's 's POS doi-org-9532 342 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 342 24 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 342 25 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 342 26 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 342 27 's 's POS doi-org-9532 342 28 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 342 29 that that IN doi-org-9532 342 30 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 342 31 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 342 32 and and CC doi-org-9532 342 33 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 342 34 values value NNS doi-org-9532 342 35 genuinely genuinely RB doi-org-9532 342 36 promote promote VBP doi-org-9532 342 37 human human JJ doi-org-9532 342 38 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 342 39 despite despite IN doi-org-9532 342 40 the the DT doi-org-9532 342 41 obvious obvious JJ doi-org-9532 342 42 flaws flaw NNS doi-org-9532 342 43 of of IN doi-org-9532 342 44 modern modern JJ doi-org-9532 342 45 capitalist capitalist JJ doi-org-9532 342 46 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 342 47 . . . doi-org-9532 343 1 Even even RB doi-org-9532 343 2 if if IN doi-org-9532 343 3 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 343 4 agreed agree VBD doi-org-9532 343 5 with with IN doi-org-9532 343 6 de de NNP doi-org-9532 343 7 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 343 8 , , , doi-org-9532 343 9 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 343 10 doubt doubt VBP doi-org-9532 343 11 that that IN doi-org-9532 343 12 rejecting reject VBG doi-org-9532 343 13 library library JJ doi-org-9532 343 14 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 343 15 would would MD doi-org-9532 343 16 be be VB doi-org-9532 343 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 343 18 best good JJS doi-org-9532 343 19 strategy strategy NN doi-org-9532 343 20 for for IN doi-org-9532 343 21 disseminating disseminate VBG doi-org-9532 343 22 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 343 23 views view NNS doi-org-9532 343 24 . . . doi-org-9532 344 1 Librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 344 2 who who WP doi-org-9532 344 3 seek seek VBP doi-org-9532 344 4 to to TO doi-org-9532 344 5 maintain maintain VB doi-org-9532 344 6 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 344 7 between between IN doi-org-9532 344 8 different different JJ doi-org-9532 344 9 conceptions conception NNS doi-org-9532 344 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 344 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 344 12 good good JJ doi-org-9532 344 13 have have VBP doi-org-9532 344 14 an an DT doi-org-9532 344 15 obligation obligation NN doi-org-9532 344 16 to to TO doi-org-9532 344 17 make make VB doi-org-9532 344 18 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 344 19 's 's POS doi-org-9532 344 20 analysis analysis NN doi-org-9532 344 21 available available JJ doi-org-9532 344 22 to to IN doi-org-9532 344 23 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 344 24 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 344 25 regardless regardless RB doi-org-9532 344 26 of of IN doi-org-9532 344 27 whether whether IN doi-org-9532 344 28 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 344 29 agree agree VBP doi-org-9532 344 30 with with IN doi-org-9532 344 31 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 344 32 so so IN doi-org-9532 344 33 that that IN doi-org-9532 344 34 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 344 35 can can MD doi-org-9532 344 36 decide decide VB doi-org-9532 344 37 for for IN doi-org-9532 344 38 themselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 344 39 . . . doi-org-9532 345 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 345 2 library library NN doi-org-9532 345 3 committed commit VBD doi-org-9532 345 4 to to IN doi-org-9532 345 5 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 345 6 that that WDT doi-org-9532 345 7 hired hire VBD doi-org-9532 345 8 de de NNP doi-org-9532 345 9 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 345 10 would would MD doi-org-9532 345 11 ask ask VB doi-org-9532 345 12 her -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 345 13 not not RB doi-org-9532 345 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 345 15 give give VB doi-org-9532 345 16 preference preference NN doi-org-9532 345 17 to to IN doi-org-9532 345 18 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 345 19 's 's POS doi-org-9532 345 20 social social JJ doi-org-9532 345 21 analysis analysis NN doi-org-9532 345 22 over over IN doi-org-9532 345 23 alternative alternative JJ doi-org-9532 345 24 theories theory NNS doi-org-9532 345 25 while while IN doi-org-9532 345 26 she -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 345 27 was be VBD doi-org-9532 345 28 at at IN doi-org-9532 345 29 work work NN doi-org-9532 345 30 , , , doi-org-9532 345 31 but but CC doi-org-9532 345 32 de de NNP doi-org-9532 345 33 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 345 34 would would MD doi-org-9532 345 35 be be VB doi-org-9532 345 36 free free JJ doi-org-9532 345 37 to to TO doi-org-9532 345 38 write write VB doi-org-9532 345 39 articles article NNS doi-org-9532 345 40 defending defend VBG doi-org-9532 345 41 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 345 42 or or CC doi-org-9532 345 43 to to TO doi-org-9532 345 44 engage engage VB doi-org-9532 345 45 in in IN doi-org-9532 345 46 social social JJ doi-org-9532 345 47 activism activism NN doi-org-9532 345 48 to to TO doi-org-9532 345 49 " " `` doi-org-9532 345 50 unsettle unsettle VB doi-org-9532 345 51 America America NNP doi-org-9532 345 52 " " '' doi-org-9532 345 53 on on IN doi-org-9532 345 54 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 345 55 own own JJ doi-org-9532 345 56 time time NN doi-org-9532 345 57 without without IN doi-org-9532 345 58 worrying worry VBG doi-org-9532 345 59 about about IN doi-org-9532 345 60 losing lose VBG doi-org-9532 345 61 her -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 345 62 job.54 job.54 NNP doi-org-9532 345 63 Thus thus RB doi-org-9532 345 64 , , , doi-org-9532 345 65 de de NNP doi-org-9532 345 66 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 345 67 's 's POS doi-org-9532 345 68 conception conception NN doi-org-9532 345 69 of of IN doi-org-9532 345 70 the the DT doi-org-9532 345 71 good good NN doi-org-9532 345 72 would would MD doi-org-9532 345 73 get get VB doi-org-9532 345 74 a a DT doi-org-9532 345 75 hearing hearing NN doi-org-9532 345 76 and and CC doi-org-9532 345 77 a a DT doi-org-9532 345 78 chance chance NN doi-org-9532 345 79 to to TO doi-org-9532 345 80 prove prove VB doi-org-9532 345 81 to to IN doi-org-9532 345 82 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 345 83 that that IN doi-org-9532 345 84 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 345 85 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 345 86 preferable preferable JJ doi-org-9532 345 87 to to IN doi-org-9532 345 88 the the DT doi-org-9532 345 89 alternatives alternative NNS doi-org-9532 345 90 . . . doi-org-9532 346 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 346 2 , , , doi-org-9532 346 3 in in IN doi-org-9532 346 4 contrast contrast NN doi-org-9532 346 5 , , , doi-org-9532 346 6 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 346 7 were be VBD doi-org-9532 346 8 expected expect VBN doi-org-9532 346 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 346 10 actively actively RB doi-org-9532 346 11 engage engage VB doi-org-9532 346 12 in in IN doi-org-9532 346 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 346 14 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 346 15 education education NN doi-org-9532 346 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 346 17 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 346 18 , , , doi-org-9532 346 19 de de NNP doi-org-9532 346 20 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 346 21 would would MD doi-org-9532 346 22 have have VB doi-org-9532 346 23 more more JJR doi-org-9532 346 24 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 346 25 to to TO doi-org-9532 346 26 fight fight VB doi-org-9532 346 27 against against IN doi-org-9532 346 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 346 29 oppressive oppressive JJ doi-org-9532 346 30 preconceptions preconception NNS doi-org-9532 346 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 346 32 liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 346 33 at at IN doi-org-9532 346 34 work work NN doi-org-9532 346 35 , , , doi-org-9532 346 36 but but CC doi-org-9532 346 37 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 346 38 who who WP doi-org-9532 346 39 disagree disagree VBP doi-org-9532 346 40 with with IN doi-org-9532 346 41 her -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 346 42 would would MD doi-org-9532 346 43 also also RB doi-org-9532 346 44 have have VB doi-org-9532 346 45 more more JJR doi-org-9532 346 46 liberty liberty NN doi-org-9532 346 47 to to TO doi-org-9532 346 48 dismiss dismiss VB doi-org-9532 346 49 her -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 346 50 views view NNS doi-org-9532 346 51 . . . doi-org-9532 347 1 While while IN doi-org-9532 347 2 de de NNP doi-org-9532 347 3 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 347 4 thinks think VBZ doi-org-9532 347 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 347 6 " " `` doi-org-9532 347 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 347 8 enlightenment enlightenment NN doi-org-9532 347 9 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 347 10 and and CC doi-org-9532 347 11 was be VBD doi-org-9532 347 12 evil evil JJ doi-org-9532 347 13 because because IN doi-org-9532 347 14 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 347 15 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 347 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 347 17 ideology ideology NN doi-org-9532 347 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 347 19 colonialism colonialism NN doi-org-9532 347 20 , , , doi-org-9532 347 21 " " `` doi-org-9532 347 22 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 347 23 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 347 24 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 347 25 considers consider VBZ doi-org-9532 347 26 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 347 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 347 28 ultimate ultimate JJ doi-org-9532 347 29 source source NN doi-org-9532 347 30 of of IN doi-org-9532 347 31 beneficial beneficial JJ doi-org-9532 347 32 modern modern JJ doi-org-9532 347 33 social social JJ doi-org-9532 347 34 values.55 values.55 NNP doi-org-9532 347 35 Presumably presumably RB doi-org-9532 347 36 , , , doi-org-9532 347 37 BivensTatum BivensTatum NNP doi-org-9532 347 38 would would MD doi-org-9532 347 39 dismiss dismiss VB doi-org-9532 347 40 de de NNP doi-org-9532 347 41 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 347 42 's 's POS doi-org-9532 347 43 article article NN doi-org-9532 347 44 as as IN doi-org-9532 347 45 an an DT doi-org-9532 347 46 expression expression NN doi-org-9532 347 47 of of IN doi-org-9532 347 48 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 347 49 nonsense nonsense NN doi-org-9532 347 50 that that WDT doi-org-9532 347 51 library library NN doi-org-9532 347 52 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 347 53 should should MD doi-org-9532 347 54 be be VB doi-org-9532 347 55 free free JJ doi-org-9532 347 56 to to TO doi-org-9532 347 57 read read VB doi-org-9532 347 58 but but CC doi-org-9532 347 59 not not RB doi-org-9532 347 60 to to TO doi-org-9532 347 61 believe believe VB doi-org-9532 347 62 . . . doi-org-9532 348 1 Consequently consequently RB doi-org-9532 348 2 , , , doi-org-9532 348 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 348 4 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 348 5 who who WP doi-org-9532 348 6 visited visit VBD doi-org-9532 348 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 348 8 library library NN doi-org-9532 348 9 while while IN doi-org-9532 348 10 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 348 11 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 348 12 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 348 13 was be VBD doi-org-9532 348 14 at at IN doi-org-9532 348 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 348 16 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 348 17 desk desk NN doi-org-9532 348 18 would would MD doi-org-9532 348 19 receive receive VB doi-org-9532 348 20 a a DT doi-org-9532 348 21 radically radically RB doi-org-9532 348 22 different different JJ doi-org-9532 348 23 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 348 24 education education NN doi-org-9532 348 25 than than IN doi-org-9532 348 26 a a DT doi-org-9532 348 27 patron patron NN doi-org-9532 348 28 who who WP doi-org-9532 348 29 came come VBD doi-org-9532 348 30 while while IN doi-org-9532 348 31 de de NNP doi-org-9532 348 32 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 348 33 was be VBD doi-org-9532 348 34 on on IN doi-org-9532 348 35 duty duty NN doi-org-9532 348 36 . . . doi-org-9532 349 1 And and CC doi-org-9532 349 2 , , , doi-org-9532 349 3 if if IN doi-org-9532 349 4 government government NN doi-org-9532 349 5 agencies agency NNS doi-org-9532 349 6 that that WDT doi-org-9532 349 7 hire hire VBP doi-org-9532 349 8 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 349 9 expected expect VBD doi-org-9532 349 10 them -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 349 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 349 12 be be VB doi-org-9532 349 13 morally morally RB doi-org-9532 349 14 engaged engage VBN doi-org-9532 349 15 rather rather RB doi-org-9532 349 16 than than IN doi-org-9532 349 17 morally morally RB doi-org-9532 349 18 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 349 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 349 20 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 349 21 work work NN doi-org-9532 349 22 , , , doi-org-9532 349 23 many many JJ doi-org-9532 349 24 agencies agency NNS doi-org-9532 349 25 would would MD doi-org-9532 349 26 [ [ -LRB- doi-org-9532 349 27 End end NN doi-org-9532 349 28 Page Page NNP doi-org-9532 349 29 74 74 CD doi-org-9532 349 30 ] ] -RRB- doi-org-9532 349 31 likely likely RB doi-org-9532 349 32 prefer prefer VBP doi-org-9532 349 33 to to TO doi-org-9532 349 34 hire hire VB doi-org-9532 349 35 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 349 36 who who WP doi-org-9532 349 37 agree agree VBP doi-org-9532 349 38 with with IN doi-org-9532 349 39 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 349 40 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 349 41 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 349 42 or or CC doi-org-9532 349 43 me -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 349 44 over over IN doi-org-9532 349 45 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 349 46 who who WP doi-org-9532 349 47 agree agree VBP doi-org-9532 349 48 with with IN doi-org-9532 349 49 de de NNP doi-org-9532 349 50 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 349 51 or or CC doi-org-9532 349 52 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 349 53 . . . doi-org-9532 350 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 350 2 conservative conservative JJ doi-org-9532 350 3 districts district NNS doi-org-9532 350 4 where where WRB doi-org-9532 350 5 traditional traditional JJ doi-org-9532 350 6 religious religious JJ doi-org-9532 350 7 views view NNS doi-org-9532 350 8 hold hold VBP doi-org-9532 350 9 sway sway NN doi-org-9532 350 10 , , , doi-org-9532 350 11 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 350 12 would would MD doi-org-9532 350 13 be be VB doi-org-9532 350 14 difficult difficult JJ doi-org-9532 350 15 for for IN doi-org-9532 350 16 any any DT doi-org-9532 350 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 350 18 us -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 350 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 350 20 get get VB doi-org-9532 350 21 work work NN doi-org-9532 350 22 . . . doi-org-9532 351 1 Ultimately ultimately RB doi-org-9532 351 2 , , , doi-org-9532 351 3 radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 351 4 views view NNS doi-org-9532 351 5 that that WDT doi-org-9532 351 6 currently currently RB doi-org-9532 351 7 reflect reflect VBP doi-org-9532 351 8 minority minority NN doi-org-9532 351 9 opinions opinion NNS doi-org-9532 351 10 will will MD doi-org-9532 351 11 more more RBR doi-org-9532 351 12 likely likely JJ doi-org-9532 351 13 get get VB doi-org-9532 351 14 heard hear VBN doi-org-9532 351 15 if if IN doi-org-9532 351 16 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 351 17 are be VBP doi-org-9532 351 18 committed commit VBN doi-org-9532 351 19 to to IN doi-org-9532 351 20 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 351 21 than than IN doi-org-9532 351 22 if if IN doi-org-9532 351 23 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 351 24 are be VBP doi-org-9532 351 25 committed commit VBN doi-org-9532 351 26 to to IN doi-org-9532 351 27 radicalism radicalism NN doi-org-9532 351 28 . . . doi-org-9532 352 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 352 2 one one PRP doi-org-9532 352 3 could could MD doi-org-9532 352 4 argue argue VB doi-org-9532 352 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 352 6 a a DT doi-org-9532 352 7 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 352 8 to to IN doi-org-9532 352 9 library library JJ doi-org-9532 352 10 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 352 11 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 352 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 352 13 huge huge JJ doi-org-9532 352 14 missed miss VBN doi-org-9532 352 15 opportunity opportunity NN doi-org-9532 352 16 because because IN doi-org-9532 352 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 352 18 practice practice NN doi-org-9532 352 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 352 20 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 352 21 confers confer NNS doi-org-9532 352 22 superior superior JJ doi-org-9532 352 23 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 352 24 insight insight NN doi-org-9532 352 25 on on IN doi-org-9532 352 26 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 352 27 . . . doi-org-9532 353 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 353 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 353 3 psychological psychological JJ doi-org-9532 353 4 tendencies tendency NNS doi-org-9532 353 5 that that WDT doi-org-9532 353 6 entice entice VBP doi-org-9532 353 7 someone someone NN doi-org-9532 353 8 into into IN doi-org-9532 353 9 a a DT doi-org-9532 353 10 career career NN doi-org-9532 353 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 353 12 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 353 13 are be VBP doi-org-9532 353 14 more more RBR doi-org-9532 353 15 conducive conducive JJ doi-org-9532 353 16 to to IN doi-org-9532 353 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 353 18 discovery discovery NN doi-org-9532 353 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 353 20 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 353 21 truth truth NN doi-org-9532 353 22 than than IN doi-org-9532 353 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 353 24 tendencies tendency NNS doi-org-9532 353 25 that that WDT doi-org-9532 353 26 lead lead VBP doi-org-9532 353 27 to to IN doi-org-9532 353 28 a a DT doi-org-9532 353 29 career career NN doi-org-9532 353 30 as as IN doi-org-9532 353 31 a a DT doi-org-9532 353 32 banker banker NN doi-org-9532 353 33 or or CC doi-org-9532 353 34 a a DT doi-org-9532 353 35 dentist dentist NN doi-org-9532 353 36 . . . doi-org-9532 354 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 354 2 daily daily JJ doi-org-9532 354 3 exposure exposure NN doi-org-9532 354 4 to to IN doi-org-9532 354 5 a a DT doi-org-9532 354 6 wide wide JJ doi-org-9532 354 7 variety variety NN doi-org-9532 354 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 354 9 literature literature NN doi-org-9532 354 10 , , , doi-org-9532 354 11 diverse diverse JJ doi-org-9532 354 12 systems system NNS doi-org-9532 354 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 354 14 information information NN doi-org-9532 354 15 retrieval retrieval NN doi-org-9532 354 16 , , , doi-org-9532 354 17 and and CC doi-org-9532 354 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 354 19 social social JJ doi-org-9532 354 20 needs need NNS doi-org-9532 354 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 354 22 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 354 23 makes make VBZ doi-org-9532 354 24 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 354 25 more more RBR doi-org-9532 354 26 sensitive sensitive JJ doi-org-9532 354 27 to to IN doi-org-9532 354 28 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 354 29 reality reality NN doi-org-9532 354 30 than than IN doi-org-9532 354 31 the the DT doi-org-9532 354 32 average average JJ doi-org-9532 354 33 citizen citizen NN doi-org-9532 354 34 . . . doi-org-9532 355 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 355 2 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 355 3 are be VBP doi-org-9532 355 4 like like IN doi-org-9532 355 5 the the DT doi-org-9532 355 6 philosophers philosopher NNS doi-org-9532 355 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 355 8 Plato Plato NNP doi-org-9532 355 9 's 's POS doi-org-9532 355 10 allegory allegory NN doi-org-9532 355 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 355 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 355 13 cave cave NN doi-org-9532 355 14 who who WP doi-org-9532 355 15 have have VBP doi-org-9532 355 16 escaped escape VBN doi-org-9532 355 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 355 18 distortions distortion NNS doi-org-9532 355 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 355 20 vulgar vulgar JJ doi-org-9532 355 21 opinion opinion NN doi-org-9532 355 22 to to TO doi-org-9532 355 23 see see VB doi-org-9532 355 24 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 355 25 truth truth NN doi-org-9532 355 26 in in IN doi-org-9532 355 27 the the DT doi-org-9532 355 28 full full JJ doi-org-9532 355 29 light light NN doi-org-9532 355 30 of of IN doi-org-9532 355 31 day day NN doi-org-9532 355 32 . . . doi-org-9532 356 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 356 2 becoming become VBG doi-org-9532 356 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 356 4 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 356 5 imbues imbue VBZ doi-org-9532 356 6 us -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 356 7 with with IN doi-org-9532 356 8 a a DT doi-org-9532 356 9 deeper deep JJR doi-org-9532 356 10 understanding understanding NN doi-org-9532 356 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 356 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 356 13 evils evil NNS doi-org-9532 356 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 356 15 capitalism capitalism NN doi-org-9532 356 16 that that WDT doi-org-9532 356 17 remain remain VBP doi-org-9532 356 18 obscure obscure JJ doi-org-9532 356 19 to to IN doi-org-9532 356 20 most most JJS doi-org-9532 356 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 356 22 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 356 23 fellow fellow JJ doi-org-9532 356 24 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 356 25 , , , doi-org-9532 356 26 perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 356 27 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 356 28 have have VBP doi-org-9532 356 29 a a DT doi-org-9532 356 30 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 356 31 obligation obligation NN doi-org-9532 356 32 to to TO doi-org-9532 356 33 lead lead VB doi-org-9532 356 34 the the DT doi-org-9532 356 35 way way NN doi-org-9532 356 36 to to IN doi-org-9532 356 37 a a DT doi-org-9532 356 38 better well JJR doi-org-9532 356 39 society society NN doi-org-9532 356 40 instead instead RB doi-org-9532 356 41 of of IN doi-org-9532 356 42 passively passively RB doi-org-9532 356 43 hiding hide VBG doi-org-9532 356 44 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 356 45 insight insight NN doi-org-9532 356 46 behind behind IN doi-org-9532 356 47 false false JJ doi-org-9532 356 48 claims claim NNS doi-org-9532 356 49 of of IN doi-org-9532 356 50 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 356 51 . . . doi-org-9532 357 1 Perhaps perhaps RB doi-org-9532 357 2 the the DT doi-org-9532 357 3 profession profession NN doi-org-9532 357 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 357 5 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 357 6 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 357 7 particularly particularly RB doi-org-9532 357 8 well well RB doi-org-9532 357 9 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 357 10 suited suit VBN doi-org-9532 357 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 357 12 produce produce VB doi-org-9532 357 13 an an DT doi-org-9532 357 14 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 357 15 vanguard vanguard NN doi-org-9532 357 16 committed commit VBN doi-org-9532 357 17 to to IN doi-org-9532 357 18 social social JJ doi-org-9532 357 19 justice.56 justice.56 NNP doi-org-9532 357 20 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 357 21 doubt doubt VBP doi-org-9532 357 22 that that IN doi-org-9532 357 23 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 357 24 can can MD doi-org-9532 357 25 provide provide VB doi-org-9532 357 26 a a DT doi-org-9532 357 27 definitive definitive JJ doi-org-9532 357 28 deductive deductive JJ doi-org-9532 357 29 argument argument NN doi-org-9532 357 30 against against IN doi-org-9532 357 31 this this DT doi-org-9532 357 32 view view NN doi-org-9532 357 33 any any DT doi-org-9532 357 34 more more RBR doi-org-9532 357 35 than than IN doi-org-9532 357 36 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 357 37 can can MD doi-org-9532 357 38 prove prove VB doi-org-9532 357 39 that that IN doi-org-9532 357 40 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 357 41 will will MD doi-org-9532 357 42 not not RB doi-org-9532 357 43 be be VB doi-org-9532 357 44 destroyed destroy VBN doi-org-9532 357 45 by by IN doi-org-9532 357 46 the the DT doi-org-9532 357 47 inherent inherent JJ doi-org-9532 357 48 irrationality irrationality NN doi-org-9532 357 49 of of IN doi-org-9532 357 50 human human JJ doi-org-9532 357 51 nature nature NN doi-org-9532 357 52 . . . doi-org-9532 358 1 So so RB doi-org-9532 358 2 far far RB doi-org-9532 358 3 , , , doi-org-9532 358 4 however however RB doi-org-9532 358 5 , , , doi-org-9532 358 6 political political JJ doi-org-9532 358 7 movements movement NNS doi-org-9532 358 8 led lead VBN doi-org-9532 358 9 by by IN doi-org-9532 358 10 vanguards vanguard NNS doi-org-9532 358 11 with with IN doi-org-9532 358 12 superior superior JJ doi-org-9532 358 13 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 358 14 insight insight NN doi-org-9532 358 15 have have VBP doi-org-9532 358 16 not not RB doi-org-9532 358 17 gone go VBN doi-org-9532 358 18 well well RB doi-org-9532 358 19 . . . doi-org-9532 359 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 359 2 China China NNP doi-org-9532 359 3 , , , doi-org-9532 359 4 Eastern Eastern NNP doi-org-9532 359 5 Europe Europe NNP doi-org-9532 359 6 , , , doi-org-9532 359 7 and and CC doi-org-9532 359 8 Cuba Cuba NNP doi-org-9532 359 9 , , , doi-org-9532 359 10 they -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 359 11 produced produce VBD doi-org-9532 359 12 totalitarian totalitarian JJ doi-org-9532 359 13 societies society NNS doi-org-9532 359 14 in in IN doi-org-9532 359 15 which which WDT doi-org-9532 359 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 359 17 government government NN doi-org-9532 359 18 tried try VBD doi-org-9532 359 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 359 20 mold mold VB doi-org-9532 359 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 359 22 thoughts thought NNS doi-org-9532 359 23 and and CC doi-org-9532 359 24 actions action NNS doi-org-9532 359 25 of of IN doi-org-9532 359 26 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 359 27 in in IN doi-org-9532 359 28 a a DT doi-org-9532 359 29 particularly particularly RB doi-org-9532 359 30 pervasive pervasive JJ doi-org-9532 359 31 way way NN doi-org-9532 359 32 . . . doi-org-9532 360 1 My -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 360 2 hope hope NN doi-org-9532 360 3 still still RB doi-org-9532 360 4 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 360 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 360 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 360 7 best good JJS doi-org-9532 360 8 political political JJ doi-org-9532 360 9 responses response NNS doi-org-9532 360 10 to to IN doi-org-9532 360 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 360 12 challenges challenge NNS doi-org-9532 360 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 360 14 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 360 15 collective collective JJ doi-org-9532 360 16 life life NN doi-org-9532 360 17 will will MD doi-org-9532 360 18 emerge emerge VB doi-org-9532 360 19 from from IN doi-org-9532 360 20 open open JJ doi-org-9532 360 21 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 360 22 in in IN doi-org-9532 360 23 a a DT doi-org-9532 360 24 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 360 25 society society NN doi-org-9532 360 26 that that WDT doi-org-9532 360 27 respects respect VBZ doi-org-9532 360 28 the the DT doi-org-9532 360 29 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 360 30 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 360 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 360 32 all all PDT doi-org-9532 360 33 its -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 360 34 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 360 35 . . . doi-org-9532 361 1 Even even RB doi-org-9532 361 2 if if IN doi-org-9532 361 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 361 4 economic economic JJ doi-org-9532 361 5 individualism individualism NN doi-org-9532 361 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 361 7 a a DT doi-org-9532 361 8 market market NN doi-org-9532 361 9 society society NN doi-org-9532 361 10 generates generate VBZ doi-org-9532 361 11 economic economic JJ doi-org-9532 361 12 injustice injustice NN doi-org-9532 361 13 , , , doi-org-9532 361 14 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 361 15 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 361 16 not not RB doi-org-9532 361 17 necessarily necessarily RB doi-org-9532 361 18 follow follow VB doi-org-9532 361 19 that that IN doi-org-9532 361 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 361 21 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 361 22 independence independence NN doi-org-9532 361 23 encouraged encourage VBN doi-org-9532 361 24 by by IN doi-org-9532 361 25 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 361 26 morality morality NN doi-org-9532 361 27 and and CC doi-org-9532 361 28 by by IN doi-org-9532 361 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 361 30 ethos ethos NN doi-org-9532 361 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 361 32 American american JJ doi-org-9532 361 33 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 361 34 also also RB doi-org-9532 361 35 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 361 36 unjust unjust JJ doi-org-9532 361 37 . . . doi-org-9532 362 1 Individuals individual NNS doi-org-9532 362 2 can can MD doi-org-9532 362 3 agree agree VB doi-org-9532 362 4 to to TO doi-org-9532 362 5 participate participate VB doi-org-9532 362 6 in in IN doi-org-9532 362 7 collective collective JJ doi-org-9532 362 8 action action NN doi-org-9532 362 9 through through IN doi-org-9532 362 10 unions union NNS doi-org-9532 362 11 and and CC doi-org-9532 362 12 radical radical JJ doi-org-9532 362 13 politics politic NNS doi-org-9532 362 14 without without IN doi-org-9532 362 15 abandoning abandon VBG doi-org-9532 362 16 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 362 17 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 362 18 autonomy autonomy NN doi-org-9532 362 19 to to TO doi-org-9532 362 20 decide decide VB doi-org-9532 362 21 for for IN doi-org-9532 362 22 themselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 362 23 what what WP doi-org-9532 362 24 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 362 25 right right JJ doi-org-9532 362 26 and and CC doi-org-9532 362 27 wrong.57 wrong.57 NNP doi-org-9532 362 28 Faith Faith NNP doi-org-9532 362 29 in in IN doi-org-9532 362 30 the the DT doi-org-9532 362 31 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 362 32 independence independence NN doi-org-9532 362 33 of of IN doi-org-9532 362 34 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 362 35 citizens citizen NNS doi-org-9532 362 36 may may MD doi-org-9532 362 37 be be VB doi-org-9532 362 38 disastrous disastrous JJ doi-org-9532 362 39 in in IN doi-org-9532 362 40 a a DT doi-org-9532 362 41 society society NN doi-org-9532 362 42 distorted distort VBN doi-org-9532 362 43 either either CC doi-org-9532 362 44 by by IN doi-org-9532 362 45 the the DT doi-org-9532 362 46 fundamental fundamental JJ doi-org-9532 362 47 irrationality irrationality NN doi-org-9532 362 48 of of IN doi-org-9532 362 49 human human JJ doi-org-9532 362 50 nature nature NN doi-org-9532 362 51 or or CC doi-org-9532 362 52 by by IN doi-org-9532 362 53 systematic systematic JJ doi-org-9532 362 54 violence violence NN doi-org-9532 362 55 embedded embed VBN doi-org-9532 362 56 in in IN doi-org-9532 362 57 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 362 58 institutions institution NNS doi-org-9532 362 59 , , , doi-org-9532 362 60 but but CC doi-org-9532 362 61 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 362 62 still still RB doi-org-9532 362 63 seems seem VBZ doi-org-9532 362 64 the the DT doi-org-9532 362 65 best good JJS doi-org-9532 362 66 bet bet NN doi-org-9532 362 67 that that IN doi-org-9532 362 68 we -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 362 69 can can MD doi-org-9532 362 70 make make VB doi-org-9532 362 71 in in IN doi-org-9532 362 72 an an DT doi-org-9532 362 73 uncertain uncertain JJ doi-org-9532 362 74 world world NN doi-org-9532 362 75 . . . doi-org-9532 363 1 John John NNP doi-org-9532 363 2 WenzlerJohn WenzlerJohn NNP doi-org-9532 363 3 Wenzler Wenzler NNP doi-org-9532 363 4 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 363 5 dean dean NN doi-org-9532 363 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 363 7 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 363 8 at at IN doi-org-9532 363 9 California California NNP doi-org-9532 363 10 State State NNP doi-org-9532 363 11 University University NNP doi-org-9532 363 12 East East NNP doi-org-9532 363 13 Bay Bay NNP doi-org-9532 363 14 ; ; : doi-org-9532 363 15 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 363 16 may may MD doi-org-9532 363 17 be be VB doi-org-9532 363 18 reached reach VBN doi-org-9532 363 19 by by IN doi-org-9532 363 20 e e NN doi-org-9532 363 21 - - NN doi-org-9532 363 22 mail mail NN doi-org-9532 363 23 at at IN doi-org-9532 363 24 : : : doi-org-9532 363 25 John.wenzler@csueastbay.edu John.wenzler@csueastbay.edu NNS doi-org-9532 363 26 . . . doi-org-9532 364 1 Notes note NNS doi-org-9532 364 2 1 1 CD doi-org-9532 364 3 . . . doi-org-9532 365 1 American American NNP doi-org-9532 365 2 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 365 3 Association Association NNP doi-org-9532 365 4 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 365 5 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 365 6 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 365 7 , , , doi-org-9532 365 8 " " `` doi-org-9532 365 9 The the DT doi-org-9532 365 10 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 365 11 to to TO doi-org-9532 365 12 Read read VB doi-org-9532 365 13 Statement statement NN doi-org-9532 365 14 , , , doi-org-9532 365 15 " " '' doi-org-9532 365 16 June June NNP doi-org-9532 365 17 30 30 CD doi-org-9532 365 18 , , , doi-org-9532 365 19 2004 2004 CD doi-org-9532 365 20 , , , doi-org-9532 365 21 http://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/freedomreadstatement http://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/freedomreadstatement NNP doi-org-9532 365 22 . . . doi-org-9532 366 1 2 2 LS doi-org-9532 366 2 . . . doi-org-9532 367 1 Alison Alison NNP doi-org-9532 367 2 Lewis Lewis NNP doi-org-9532 367 3 , , , doi-org-9532 367 4 ed ed NNP doi-org-9532 367 5 . . NNP doi-org-9532 367 6 , , , doi-org-9532 367 7 Questioning Questioning NNP doi-org-9532 367 8 Library library JJ doi-org-9532 367 9 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 367 10 : : : doi-org-9532 367 11 Essays essay NNS doi-org-9532 367 12 from from IN doi-org-9532 367 13 Progressive progressive JJ doi-org-9532 367 14 Librarian Librarian NNP doi-org-9532 367 15 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 367 16 Duluth Duluth NNP doi-org-9532 367 17 , , , doi-org-9532 367 18 MN MN NNP doi-org-9532 367 19 : : : doi-org-9532 367 20 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 367 21 Juice Juice NNP doi-org-9532 367 22 , , , doi-org-9532 367 23 2008 2008 CD doi-org-9532 367 24 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 367 25 . . . doi-org-9532 368 1 3 3 LS doi-org-9532 368 2 . . . doi-org-9532 369 1 Annie Annie NNP doi-org-9532 369 2 Pho Pho NNP doi-org-9532 369 3 , , , doi-org-9532 369 4 Emily Emily NNP doi-org-9532 369 5 Drabinski Drabinski NNP doi-org-9532 369 6 , , , doi-org-9532 369 7 Fobazi Fobazi NNP doi-org-9532 369 8 Ettarh Ettarh NNP doi-org-9532 369 9 , , , doi-org-9532 369 10 Kelly Kelly NNP doi-org-9532 369 11 McElroy McElroy NNP doi-org-9532 369 12 , , , doi-org-9532 369 13 and and CC doi-org-9532 369 14 Nicole Nicole NNP doi-org-9532 369 15 Pagowsky Pagowsky NNP doi-org-9532 369 16 , , , doi-org-9532 369 17 " " `` doi-org-9532 369 18 ' ' `` doi-org-9532 369 19 But but CC doi-org-9532 369 20 We -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 369 21 're be VBP doi-org-9532 369 22 Neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 369 23 ! ! . doi-org-9532 369 24 ' ' '' doi-org-9532 370 1 And and CC doi-org-9532 370 2 Other other JJ doi-org-9532 370 3 Librarian librarian JJ doi-org-9532 370 4 Fictions fiction NNS doi-org-9532 370 5 Confronted confront VBN doi-org-9532 370 6 by by IN doi-org-9532 370 7 # # , doi-org-9532 370 8 critlib critlib NNS doi-org-9532 370 9 , , , doi-org-9532 370 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 370 11 presentation presentation NN doi-org-9532 370 12 at at IN doi-org-9532 370 13 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 370 14 Annual Annual NNP doi-org-9532 370 15 Conference Conference NNP doi-org-9532 370 16 , , , doi-org-9532 370 17 San San NNP doi-org-9532 370 18 Francisco Francisco NNP doi-org-9532 370 19 , , , doi-org-9532 370 20 June June NNP doi-org-9532 370 21 28 28 CD doi-org-9532 370 22 , , , doi-org-9532 370 23 2015 2015 CD doi-org-9532 370 24 . . . doi-org-9532 371 1 4 4 LS doi-org-9532 371 2 . . . doi-org-9532 372 1 Meredith Meredith NNP doi-org-9532 372 2 Farkas Farkas NNP doi-org-9532 372 3 , , , doi-org-9532 372 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 372 5 Never never RB doi-org-9532 372 6 Neutral Neutral NNP doi-org-9532 372 7 : : : doi-org-9532 372 8 Critical Critical NNP doi-org-9532 372 9 Librarianship Librarianship NNP doi-org-9532 372 10 & & CC doi-org-9532 372 11 Technology Technology NNP doi-org-9532 372 12 , , , doi-org-9532 372 13 " " `` doi-org-9532 372 14 American American NNP doi-org-9532 372 15 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 372 16 , , , doi-org-9532 372 17 January January NNP doi-org-9532 372 18 3 3 CD doi-org-9532 372 19 , , , doi-org-9532 372 20 2017 2017 CD doi-org-9532 372 21 , , , doi-org-9532 372 22 https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/2017/01/03/never-neutral-critlib-technology/. https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/2017/01/03/never-neutral-critlib-technology/. ADD doi-org-9532 373 1 5 5 CD doi-org-9532 373 2 . . . doi-org-9532 374 1 Amy Amy NNP doi-org-9532 374 2 Carlton Carlton NNP doi-org-9532 374 3 , , , doi-org-9532 374 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 374 5 Are be VBP doi-org-9532 374 6 Libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 374 7 Neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 374 8 ? ? . doi-org-9532 375 1 Highlights highlight NNS doi-org-9532 375 2 from from IN doi-org-9532 375 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 375 4 Midwinter Midwinter NNP doi-org-9532 375 5 President President NNP doi-org-9532 375 6 's 's POS doi-org-9532 375 7 Program Program NNP doi-org-9532 375 8 , , , doi-org-9532 375 9 " " `` doi-org-9532 375 10 American American NNP doi-org-9532 375 11 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 375 12 , , , doi-org-9532 375 13 June June NNP doi-org-9532 375 14 1 1 CD doi-org-9532 375 15 , , , doi-org-9532 375 16 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 375 17 , , , doi-org-9532 375 18 https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/blogs/the-scoop/are-libraries-neutral/. https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/blogs/the-scoop/are-libraries-neutral/. ADD doi-org-9532 376 1 6 6 CD doi-org-9532 376 2 . . . doi-org-9532 377 1 Reuters Reuters NNP doi-org-9532 377 2 , , , doi-org-9532 377 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 377 4 Tutu Tutu NNP doi-org-9532 377 5 Chides chide VBZ doi-org-9532 377 6 Bush Bush NNP doi-org-9532 377 7 on on IN doi-org-9532 377 8 Oversimplifying Oversimplifying NNP doi-org-9532 377 9 U.S. U.S. NNP doi-org-9532 377 10 Terror Terror NNP doi-org-9532 377 11 War War NNP doi-org-9532 377 12 , , , doi-org-9532 377 13 " " '' doi-org-9532 377 14 March March NNP doi-org-9532 377 15 17 17 CD doi-org-9532 377 16 , , , doi-org-9532 377 17 2004 2004 CD doi-org-9532 377 18 . . . doi-org-9532 378 1 Cited cite VBN doi-org-9532 378 2 by by IN doi-org-9532 378 3 Robert Robert NNP doi-org-9532 378 4 Jensen Jensen NNP doi-org-9532 378 5 , , , doi-org-9532 378 6 " " `` doi-org-9532 378 7 The the DT doi-org-9532 378 8 Myth Myth NNP doi-org-9532 378 9 of of IN doi-org-9532 378 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 378 11 Neutral Neutral NNP doi-org-9532 378 12 Professional Professional NNP doi-org-9532 378 13 , , , doi-org-9532 378 14 " " '' doi-org-9532 378 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 378 16 Lewis Lewis NNP doi-org-9532 378 17 , , , doi-org-9532 378 18 Questioning Questioning NNP doi-org-9532 378 19 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 378 20 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 378 21 , , , doi-org-9532 378 22 91 91 CD doi-org-9532 378 23 . . . doi-org-9532 379 1 7 7 LS doi-org-9532 379 2 . . . doi-org-9532 380 1 Stephen Stephen NNP doi-org-9532 380 2 Bales Bales NNP doi-org-9532 380 3 , , , doi-org-9532 380 4 Social Social NNP doi-org-9532 380 5 Justice Justice NNP doi-org-9532 380 6 and and CC doi-org-9532 380 7 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 380 8 Work Work NNP doi-org-9532 380 9 : : : doi-org-9532 380 10 A a DT doi-org-9532 380 11 Guide Guide NNP doi-org-9532 380 12 to to IN doi-org-9532 380 13 Theory Theory NNP doi-org-9532 380 14 and and CC doi-org-9532 380 15 Practice Practice NNP doi-org-9532 380 16 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 380 17 Cambridge Cambridge NNP doi-org-9532 380 18 , , , doi-org-9532 380 19 MA MA NNP doi-org-9532 380 20 : : : doi-org-9532 380 21 Chandos chandos NN doi-org-9532 380 22 , , , doi-org-9532 380 23 2017 2017 CD doi-org-9532 380 24 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 380 25 , , , doi-org-9532 380 26 14 14 CD doi-org-9532 380 27 . . . doi-org-9532 381 1 8 8 LS doi-org-9532 381 2 . . . doi-org-9532 382 1 Francis Francis NNP doi-org-9532 382 2 E. E. NNP doi-org-9532 382 3 Kendall Kendall NNP doi-org-9532 382 4 , , , doi-org-9532 382 5 " " `` doi-org-9532 382 6 Understanding understand VBG doi-org-9532 382 7 White White NNP doi-org-9532 382 8 Privilege Privilege NNP doi-org-9532 382 9 , , , doi-org-9532 382 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 382 11 2002 2002 CD doi-org-9532 382 12 , , , doi-org-9532 382 13 https://www.cpt.org/files/Undoing%20Racism%20-%20Understanding%20White%20Privilege%20-%20Kendall.pdf https://www.cpt.org/files/Undoing%20Racism%20-%20Understanding%20White%20Privilege%20-%20Kendall.pdf NNP doi-org-9532 382 14 . . . doi-org-9532 383 1 9 9 CD doi-org-9532 383 2 . . . doi-org-9532 384 1 Joseph Joseph NNP doi-org-9532 384 2 Good Good NNP doi-org-9532 384 3 , , , doi-org-9532 384 4 " " '' doi-org-9532 384 5 The the DT doi-org-9532 384 6 Hottest Hottest NNP doi-org-9532 384 7 Place Place NNP doi-org-9532 384 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 384 9 Hell Hell NNP doi-org-9532 384 10 : : : doi-org-9532 384 11 The the DT doi-org-9532 384 12 Crisis Crisis NNP doi-org-9532 384 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 384 14 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 384 15 in in IN doi-org-9532 384 16 Contemporary Contemporary NNP doi-org-9532 384 17 Librarianship Librarianship NNP doi-org-9532 384 18 , , , doi-org-9532 384 19 " " '' doi-org-9532 384 20 in in IN doi-org-9532 384 21 Lewis Lewis NNP doi-org-9532 384 22 , , , doi-org-9532 384 23 Questioning Questioning NNP doi-org-9532 384 24 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 384 25 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 384 26 , , , doi-org-9532 384 27 144 144 CD doi-org-9532 384 28 . . . doi-org-9532 385 1 10 10 CD doi-org-9532 385 2 . . . doi-org-9532 386 1 Candise Candise NNP doi-org-9532 386 2 Branum Branum NNP doi-org-9532 386 3 , , , doi-org-9532 386 4 " " '' doi-org-9532 386 5 The the DT doi-org-9532 386 6 Myth Myth NNP doi-org-9532 386 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 386 8 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 386 9 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 386 10 , , , doi-org-9532 386 11 " " '' doi-org-9532 386 12 blog blog NN doi-org-9532 386 13 , , , doi-org-9532 386 14 May May NNP doi-org-9532 386 15 15 15 CD doi-org-9532 386 16 , , , doi-org-9532 386 17 2014 2014 CD doi-org-9532 386 18 , , , doi-org-9532 386 19 https://candisebranum.wordpress.com/2014/05/15/the-myth-of-library-neutrality/. https://candisebranum.wordpress.com/2014/05/15/the-myth-of-library-neutrality/. NNP doi-org-9532 387 1 11 11 CD doi-org-9532 387 2 . . . doi-org-9532 388 1 Stephen Stephen NNP doi-org-9532 388 2 Bales Bales NNP doi-org-9532 388 3 , , , doi-org-9532 388 4 The the DT doi-org-9532 388 5 Dialectic Dialectic NNP doi-org-9532 388 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 388 7 Academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 388 8 Librarianship Librarianship NNP doi-org-9532 388 9 : : : doi-org-9532 388 10 A a DT doi-org-9532 388 11 Critical Critical NNP doi-org-9532 388 12 Approach Approach NNP doi-org-9532 388 13 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 388 14 Sacramento Sacramento NNP doi-org-9532 388 15 , , , doi-org-9532 388 16 CA CA NNP doi-org-9532 388 17 : : : doi-org-9532 388 18 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 388 19 Juice Juice NNP doi-org-9532 388 20 , , , doi-org-9532 388 21 2015 2015 CD doi-org-9532 388 22 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 388 23 , , , doi-org-9532 388 24 132 132 CD doi-org-9532 388 25 . . . doi-org-9532 389 1 12 12 CD doi-org-9532 389 2 . . . doi-org-9532 390 1 David David NNP doi-org-9532 390 2 K. K. NNP doi-org-9532 390 3 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 390 4 , , , doi-org-9532 390 5 The the DT doi-org-9532 390 6 Flight Flight NNP doi-org-9532 390 7 from from IN doi-org-9532 390 8 Reason reason NN doi-org-9532 390 9 : : : doi-org-9532 390 10 Essays essay NNS doi-org-9532 390 11 on on IN doi-org-9532 390 12 Intellectual Intellectual NNP doi-org-9532 390 13 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 390 14 in in IN doi-org-9532 390 15 the the DT doi-org-9532 390 16 Academy Academy NNP doi-org-9532 390 17 , , , doi-org-9532 390 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 390 19 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 390 20 , , , doi-org-9532 390 21 and and CC doi-org-9532 390 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 390 23 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 390 24 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 390 25 Chicago Chicago NNP doi-org-9532 390 26 : : : doi-org-9532 390 27 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 390 28 , , , doi-org-9532 390 29 1975 1975 CD doi-org-9532 390 30 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 390 31 . . . doi-org-9532 391 1 13 13 CD doi-org-9532 391 2 . . . doi-org-9532 392 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 392 2 an an DT doi-org-9532 392 3 overview overview NN doi-org-9532 392 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 392 5 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 392 6 's 's POS doi-org-9532 392 7 work work NN doi-org-9532 392 8 on on IN doi-org-9532 392 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 392 10 Intellectual Intellectual NNP doi-org-9532 392 11 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 392 12 Committee Committee NNP doi-org-9532 392 13 , , , doi-org-9532 392 14 see see VB doi-org-9532 392 15 Louise Louise NNP doi-org-9532 392 16 S. S. NNP doi-org-9532 392 17 Robbins Robbins NNP doi-org-9532 392 18 , , , doi-org-9532 392 19 Censorship Censorship NNP doi-org-9532 392 20 and and CC doi-org-9532 392 21 the the DT doi-org-9532 392 22 American American NNP doi-org-9532 392 23 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 392 24 : : : doi-org-9532 392 25 The the DT doi-org-9532 392 26 American American NNP doi-org-9532 392 27 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 392 28 Association Association NNP doi-org-9532 392 29 's 's POS doi-org-9532 392 30 Response response NN doi-org-9532 392 31 to to IN doi-org-9532 392 32 Threats Threats NNP doi-org-9532 392 33 to to IN doi-org-9532 392 34 Intellectual Intellectual NNP doi-org-9532 392 35 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 392 36 , , , doi-org-9532 392 37 1939–1969 1939–1969 CD doi-org-9532 392 38 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 392 39 Westport westport NN doi-org-9532 392 40 , , , doi-org-9532 392 41 CT CT NNP doi-org-9532 392 42 : : : doi-org-9532 392 43 Greenwood greenwood NN doi-org-9532 392 44 , , , doi-org-9532 392 45 1996 1996 CD doi-org-9532 392 46 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 392 47 , , , doi-org-9532 392 48 especially especially RB doi-org-9532 392 49 , , , doi-org-9532 392 50 29–105 29–105 CD doi-org-9532 392 51 . . . doi-org-9532 393 1 14 14 CD doi-org-9532 393 2 . . . doi-org-9532 394 1 In in IN doi-org-9532 394 2 chapter chapter NN doi-org-9532 394 3 8 8 CD doi-org-9532 394 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 394 5 The the DT doi-org-9532 394 6 Flight Flight NNP doi-org-9532 394 7 from from IN doi-org-9532 394 8 Reason Reason NNP doi-org-9532 394 9 , , , doi-org-9532 394 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 394 11 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 394 12 's 's POS doi-org-9532 394 13 Program program NN doi-org-9532 394 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 394 15 Defend defend VB doi-org-9532 394 16 Defenders defender NNS doi-org-9532 394 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 394 18 Intellectual Intellectual NNP doi-org-9532 394 19 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 394 20 , , , doi-org-9532 394 21 " " `` doi-org-9532 394 22 128–56 128–56 CD doi-org-9532 394 23 , , , doi-org-9532 394 24 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 394 25 describes describe VBZ doi-org-9532 394 26 efforts effort NNS doi-org-9532 394 27 to to TO doi-org-9532 394 28 increase increase VB doi-org-9532 394 29 support support NN doi-org-9532 394 30 for for IN doi-org-9532 394 31 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 394 32 fired fire VBD doi-org-9532 394 33 or or CC doi-org-9532 394 34 disciplined discipline VBN doi-org-9532 394 35 for for IN doi-org-9532 394 36 resisting resist VBG doi-org-9532 394 37 censorship censorship NN doi-org-9532 394 38 . . . doi-org-9532 395 1 15 15 CD doi-org-9532 395 2 . . . doi-org-9532 396 1 Cited cite VBN doi-org-9532 396 2 by by IN doi-org-9532 396 3 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 396 4 , , , doi-org-9532 396 5 The the DT doi-org-9532 396 6 Flight Flight NNP doi-org-9532 396 7 from from IN doi-org-9532 396 8 Reason Reason NNP doi-org-9532 396 9 , , , doi-org-9532 396 10 110 110 CD doi-org-9532 396 11 . . . doi-org-9532 397 1 16 16 CD doi-org-9532 397 2 . . . doi-org-9532 398 1 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 398 2 , , , doi-org-9532 398 3 The the DT doi-org-9532 398 4 Flight Flight NNP doi-org-9532 398 5 from from IN doi-org-9532 398 6 Reason Reason NNP doi-org-9532 398 7 , , , doi-org-9532 398 8 108 108 CD doi-org-9532 398 9 . . . doi-org-9532 399 1 17 17 CD doi-org-9532 399 2 . . . doi-org-9532 400 1 American American NNP doi-org-9532 400 2 Association Association NNP doi-org-9532 400 3 of of IN doi-org-9532 400 4 University University NNP doi-org-9532 400 5 Professors Professors NNPS doi-org-9532 400 6 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 400 7 AAUP AAUP NNP doi-org-9532 400 8 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 400 9 , , , doi-org-9532 400 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 400 11 1940 1940 CD doi-org-9532 400 12 Statement Statement NNP doi-org-9532 400 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 400 14 Principles Principles NNPS doi-org-9532 400 15 on on IN doi-org-9532 400 16 Academic Academic NNP doi-org-9532 400 17 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 400 18 and and CC doi-org-9532 400 19 Tenure Tenure NNP doi-org-9532 400 20 , , , doi-org-9532 400 21 " " '' doi-org-9532 400 22 https://www.aaup.org/report/1940-statement-principles-academic-freedom-and-tenure https://www.aaup.org/report/1940-statement-principles-academic-freedom-and-tenure ADD doi-org-9532 400 23 . . . doi-org-9532 401 1 18 18 CD doi-org-9532 401 2 . . . doi-org-9532 402 1 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 402 2 , , , doi-org-9532 402 3 The the DT doi-org-9532 402 4 Flight Flight NNP doi-org-9532 402 5 from from IN doi-org-9532 402 6 Reason Reason NNP doi-org-9532 402 7 , , , doi-org-9532 402 8 119 119 CD doi-org-9532 402 9 . . . doi-org-9532 403 1 19 19 CD doi-org-9532 403 2 . . . doi-org-9532 404 1 Ibid Ibid NNP doi-org-9532 404 2 . . . doi-org-9532 404 3 , , , doi-org-9532 404 4 108 108 CD doi-org-9532 404 5 . . . doi-org-9532 405 1 20 20 CD doi-org-9532 405 2 . . . doi-org-9532 406 1 Several several JJ doi-org-9532 406 2 responses response NNS doi-org-9532 406 3 to to IN doi-org-9532 406 4 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 406 5 's 's POS doi-org-9532 406 6 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 406 7 were be VBD doi-org-9532 406 8 included include VBN doi-org-9532 406 9 in in IN doi-org-9532 406 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 406 11 January January NNP doi-org-9532 406 12 1 1 CD doi-org-9532 406 13 , , , doi-org-9532 406 14 1973 1973 CD doi-org-9532 406 15 , , , doi-org-9532 406 16 issue issue NN doi-org-9532 406 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 406 18 the the DT doi-org-9532 406 19 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 406 20 Journal Journal NNP doi-org-9532 406 21 . . . doi-org-9532 407 1 See see VB doi-org-9532 407 2 Robert Robert NNP doi-org-9532 407 3 F. F. NNP doi-org-9532 407 4 Wedgeworth Wedgeworth NNP doi-org-9532 407 5 , , , doi-org-9532 407 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 407 7 The the DT doi-org-9532 407 8 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 407 9 Debate Debate NNP doi-org-9532 407 10 , , , doi-org-9532 407 11 " " '' doi-org-9532 407 12 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 407 13 Journal Journal NNP doi-org-9532 407 14 98 98 CD doi-org-9532 407 15 , , , doi-org-9532 407 16 1 1 CD doi-org-9532 407 17 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 407 18 1973 1973 CD doi-org-9532 407 19 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 407 20 : : : doi-org-9532 407 21 25–41 25–41 CD doi-org-9532 407 22 . . . doi-org-9532 408 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 408 2 article article NN doi-org-9532 408 3 includes include VBZ doi-org-9532 408 4 22 22 CD doi-org-9532 408 5 responses response NNS doi-org-9532 408 6 to to IN doi-org-9532 408 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 408 8 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 408 9 . . . doi-org-9532 409 1 Four four CD doi-org-9532 409 2 of of IN doi-org-9532 409 3 responses response NNS doi-org-9532 409 4 agreed agree VBD doi-org-9532 409 5 with with IN doi-org-9532 409 6 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 409 7 ; ; : doi-org-9532 409 8 18 18 CD doi-org-9532 409 9 were be VBD doi-org-9532 409 10 critical critical JJ doi-org-9532 409 11 to to IN doi-org-9532 409 12 a a DT doi-org-9532 409 13 greater great JJR doi-org-9532 409 14 or or CC doi-org-9532 409 15 lesser less JJR doi-org-9532 409 16 extent extent NN doi-org-9532 409 17 . . . doi-org-9532 410 1 21 21 CD doi-org-9532 410 2 . . . doi-org-9532 411 1 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 411 2 , , , doi-org-9532 411 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 411 4 The the DT doi-org-9532 411 5 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 411 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 411 7 Read read VB doi-org-9532 411 8 Statement statement NN doi-org-9532 411 9 . . . doi-org-9532 411 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 412 1 22 22 CD doi-org-9532 412 2 . . . doi-org-9532 413 1 Samuel Samuel NNP doi-org-9532 413 2 Hammond Hammond NNP doi-org-9532 413 3 , , , doi-org-9532 413 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 413 5 The the DT doi-org-9532 413 6 Future future NN doi-org-9532 413 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 413 8 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 413 9 and and CC doi-org-9532 413 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 413 11 Politicization Politicization NNP doi-org-9532 413 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 413 13 Everything Everything NNP doi-org-9532 413 14 , , , doi-org-9532 413 15 " " '' doi-org-9532 413 16 January January NNP doi-org-9532 413 17 25 25 CD doi-org-9532 413 18 , , , doi-org-9532 413 19 2017 2017 CD doi-org-9532 413 20 , , , doi-org-9532 413 21 https://niskanencenter.org/blog/future-liberalism-politicization-everything/. https://niskanencenter.org/blog/future-liberalism-politicization-everything/. XX doi-org-9532 414 1 23 23 CD doi-org-9532 414 2 . . . doi-org-9532 415 1 See see VB doi-org-9532 415 2 K. K. NNP doi-org-9532 415 3 R. R. NNP doi-org-9532 415 4 Roberto Roberto NNP doi-org-9532 415 5 , , , doi-org-9532 415 6 ed ed NNP doi-org-9532 415 7 . . NNP doi-org-9532 415 8 , , , doi-org-9532 415 9 Radical Radical NNP doi-org-9532 415 10 Cataloging Cataloging NNP doi-org-9532 415 11 : : : doi-org-9532 415 12 Essays essay NNS doi-org-9532 415 13 at at IN doi-org-9532 415 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 415 15 Front Front NNP doi-org-9532 415 16 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 415 17 Jefferson Jefferson NNP doi-org-9532 415 18 , , , doi-org-9532 415 19 NC NC NNP doi-org-9532 415 20 : : : doi-org-9532 415 21 McFarland McFarland NNP doi-org-9532 415 22 , , , doi-org-9532 415 23 2008 2008 CD doi-org-9532 415 24 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 415 25 for for IN doi-org-9532 415 26 discussion discussion NN doi-org-9532 415 27 of of IN doi-org-9532 415 28 how how WRB doi-org-9532 415 29 cataloging catalog VBG doi-org-9532 415 30 and and CC doi-org-9532 415 31 metadata metadata NN doi-org-9532 415 32 can can MD doi-org-9532 415 33 reinforce reinforce VB doi-org-9532 415 34 bias bias NN doi-org-9532 415 35 . . . doi-org-9532 416 1 24 24 CD doi-org-9532 416 2 . . . doi-org-9532 417 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 417 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 417 3 recent recent JJ doi-org-9532 417 4 account account NN doi-org-9532 417 5 of of IN doi-org-9532 417 6 how how WRB doi-org-9532 417 7 search search NN doi-org-9532 417 8 algorithms algorithm NNS doi-org-9532 417 9 can can MD doi-org-9532 417 10 reinforce reinforce VB doi-org-9532 417 11 biased biased JJ doi-org-9532 417 12 perspectives perspective NNS doi-org-9532 417 13 , , , doi-org-9532 417 14 see see VB doi-org-9532 417 15 Safiya Safiya NNP doi-org-9532 417 16 Umoja Umoja NNP doi-org-9532 417 17 Noble Noble NNP doi-org-9532 417 18 , , , doi-org-9532 417 19 Algorithms Algorithms NNP doi-org-9532 417 20 of of IN doi-org-9532 417 21 Oppression Oppression NNP doi-org-9532 417 22 : : : doi-org-9532 417 23 How how WRB doi-org-9532 417 24 Search Search NNP doi-org-9532 417 25 Engines engine NNS doi-org-9532 417 26 Reinforce Reinforce NNP doi-org-9532 417 27 Racism Racism NNP doi-org-9532 417 28 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 417 29 New New NNP doi-org-9532 417 30 York York NNP doi-org-9532 417 31 : : : doi-org-9532 417 32 NYU NYU NNP doi-org-9532 417 33 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 417 34 , , , doi-org-9532 417 35 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 417 36 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 417 37 . . . doi-org-9532 418 1 25 25 CD doi-org-9532 418 2 . . . doi-org-9532 419 1 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 419 2 , , , doi-org-9532 419 3 The the DT doi-org-9532 419 4 Flight Flight NNP doi-org-9532 419 5 from from IN doi-org-9532 419 6 Reason Reason NNP doi-org-9532 419 7 , , , doi-org-9532 419 8 123 123 CD doi-org-9532 419 9 . . . doi-org-9532 420 1 26 26 CD doi-org-9532 420 2 . . . doi-org-9532 421 1 Ibid Ibid NNP doi-org-9532 421 2 . . . doi-org-9532 421 3 , , , doi-org-9532 421 4 122 122 CD doi-org-9532 421 5 . . . doi-org-9532 422 1 27 27 CD doi-org-9532 422 2 . . . doi-org-9532 423 1 Wayne Wayne NNP doi-org-9532 423 2 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 423 3 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 423 4 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 423 5 , , , doi-org-9532 423 6 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 423 7 and and CC doi-org-9532 423 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 423 9 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 423 10 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 423 11 Los Los NNP doi-org-9532 423 12 Angeles Angeles NNP doi-org-9532 423 13 : : : doi-org-9532 423 14 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 423 15 Juice Juice NNP doi-org-9532 423 16 , , , doi-org-9532 423 17 2012 2012 CD doi-org-9532 423 18 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 423 19 , , , doi-org-9532 423 20 185 185 CD doi-org-9532 423 21 . . . doi-org-9532 424 1 28 28 CD doi-org-9532 424 2 . . . doi-org-9532 425 1 Jonathan Jonathan NNP doi-org-9532 425 2 I. I. NNP doi-org-9532 425 3 Israel Israel NNP doi-org-9532 425 4 , , , doi-org-9532 425 5 Radical Radical NNP doi-org-9532 425 6 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 425 7 : : : doi-org-9532 425 8 Philosophy Philosophy NNP doi-org-9532 425 9 and and CC doi-org-9532 425 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 425 11 Making making NN doi-org-9532 425 12 of of IN doi-org-9532 425 13 Modernity Modernity NNP doi-org-9532 425 14 , , , doi-org-9532 425 15 1650–1750 1650–1750 CD doi-org-9532 425 16 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 425 17 Oxford Oxford NNP doi-org-9532 425 18 , , , doi-org-9532 425 19 U.K. U.K. NNP doi-org-9532 425 20 : : : doi-org-9532 425 21 Oxford Oxford NNP doi-org-9532 425 22 University University NNP doi-org-9532 425 23 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 425 24 , , , doi-org-9532 425 25 2001 2001 CD doi-org-9532 425 26 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 425 27 , , , doi-org-9532 425 28 41 41 CD doi-org-9532 425 29 . . . doi-org-9532 426 1 29 29 CD doi-org-9532 426 2 . . . doi-org-9532 427 1 See see VB doi-org-9532 427 2 Jill Jill NNP doi-org-9532 427 3 Lepore Lepore NNP doi-org-9532 427 4 , , , doi-org-9532 427 5 These these DT doi-org-9532 427 6 Truths truth NNS doi-org-9532 427 7 : : : doi-org-9532 427 8 A a DT doi-org-9532 427 9 History history NN doi-org-9532 427 10 of of IN doi-org-9532 427 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 427 12 United United NNP doi-org-9532 427 13 States States NNP doi-org-9532 427 14 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 427 15 New New NNP doi-org-9532 427 16 York York NNP doi-org-9532 427 17 : : : doi-org-9532 427 18 Norton Norton NNP doi-org-9532 427 19 , , , doi-org-9532 427 20 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 427 21 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 427 22 , , , doi-org-9532 427 23 109–52 109–52 CD doi-org-9532 427 24 for for IN doi-org-9532 427 25 a a DT doi-org-9532 427 26 good good JJ doi-org-9532 427 27 account account NN doi-org-9532 427 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 427 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 427 30 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 427 31 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 427 32 of of IN doi-org-9532 427 33 the the DT doi-org-9532 427 34 founders founder NNS doi-org-9532 427 35 of of IN doi-org-9532 427 36 the the DT doi-org-9532 427 37 United United NNP doi-org-9532 427 38 States States NNP doi-org-9532 427 39 and and CC doi-org-9532 427 40 how how WRB doi-org-9532 427 41 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 427 42 ideals ideal NNS doi-org-9532 427 43 were be VBD doi-org-9532 427 44 compromised compromise VBN doi-org-9532 427 45 by by IN doi-org-9532 427 46 slavery slavery NN doi-org-9532 427 47 . . . doi-org-9532 428 1 30 30 CD doi-org-9532 428 2 . . . doi-org-9532 429 1 Immanuel Immanuel NNP doi-org-9532 429 2 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 429 3 , , , doi-org-9532 429 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 429 5 An an DT doi-org-9532 429 6 Answer answer NN doi-org-9532 429 7 to to IN doi-org-9532 429 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 429 9 Question question NN doi-org-9532 429 10 : : : doi-org-9532 429 11 What what WP doi-org-9532 429 12 Is be VBZ doi-org-9532 429 13 Enlightenment enlightenment NN doi-org-9532 429 14 ? ? . doi-org-9532 429 15 " " '' doi-org-9532 430 1 trans trans NNPS doi-org-9532 430 2 . . . doi-org-9532 431 1 Mary Mary NNP doi-org-9532 431 2 C. C. NNP doi-org-9532 431 3 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 431 4 , , , doi-org-9532 431 5 1784 1784 CD doi-org-9532 431 6 , , , doi-org-9532 431 7 http://www.columbia.edu/acis/ets/CCREAD/etscc/kant.html http://www.columbia.edu/acis/ets/ccread/etscc/kant.html CD doi-org-9532 431 8 . . . doi-org-9532 432 1 31 31 CD doi-org-9532 432 2 . . . doi-org-9532 433 1 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 433 2 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 433 3 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 433 4 , , , doi-org-9532 433 5 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 433 6 and and CC doi-org-9532 433 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 433 8 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 433 9 , , , doi-org-9532 433 10 83 83 CD doi-org-9532 433 11 . . . doi-org-9532 434 1 32 32 CD doi-org-9532 434 2 . . . doi-org-9532 435 1 Boston Boston NNP doi-org-9532 435 2 Public Public NNP doi-org-9532 435 3 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 435 4 , , , doi-org-9532 435 5 " " `` doi-org-9532 435 6 Upon upon IN doi-org-9532 435 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 435 8 Objects object NNS doi-org-9532 435 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 435 10 Be be VB doi-org-9532 435 11 Attained attain VBN doi-org-9532 435 12 by by IN doi-org-9532 435 13 the the DT doi-org-9532 435 14 Establishment Establishment NNP doi-org-9532 435 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 435 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 435 17 Public Public NNP doi-org-9532 435 18 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 435 19 : : : doi-org-9532 435 20 Report report NN doi-org-9532 435 21 of of IN doi-org-9532 435 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 435 23 Trustees Trustees NNPS doi-org-9532 435 24 of of IN doi-org-9532 435 25 the the DT doi-org-9532 435 26 Public Public NNP doi-org-9532 435 27 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 435 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 435 29 the the DT doi-org-9532 435 30 City City NNP doi-org-9532 435 31 of of IN doi-org-9532 435 32 Boston Boston NNP doi-org-9532 435 33 , , , doi-org-9532 435 34 1852 1852 CD doi-org-9532 435 35 , , , doi-org-9532 435 36 " " '' doi-org-9532 435 37 cited cite VBN doi-org-9532 435 38 by by IN doi-org-9532 435 39 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 435 40 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 435 41 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 435 42 in in IN doi-org-9532 435 43 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 435 44 and and CC doi-org-9532 435 45 the the DT doi-org-9532 435 46 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 435 47 , , , doi-org-9532 435 48 107 107 CD doi-org-9532 435 49 . . . doi-org-9532 436 1 33 33 CD doi-org-9532 436 2 . . . doi-org-9532 437 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 437 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 437 3 recent recent JJ doi-org-9532 437 4 discussion discussion NN doi-org-9532 437 5 of of IN doi-org-9532 437 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 437 7 entertainment entertainment NN doi-org-9532 437 8 versus versus IN doi-org-9532 437 9 education education NN doi-org-9532 437 10 debate debate NN doi-org-9532 437 11 , , , doi-org-9532 437 12 see see VB doi-org-9532 437 13 John John NNP doi-org-9532 437 14 Buschman Buschman NNP doi-org-9532 437 15 , , , doi-org-9532 437 16 " " `` doi-org-9532 437 17 On on IN doi-org-9532 437 18 Democracy Democracy NNP doi-org-9532 437 19 and and CC doi-org-9532 437 20 Libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 437 21 , , , doi-org-9532 437 22 " " '' doi-org-9532 437 23 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 437 24 Quarterly Quarterly NNP doi-org-9532 437 25 88 88 CD doi-org-9532 437 26 , , , doi-org-9532 437 27 1 1 CD doi-org-9532 437 28 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 437 29 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 437 30 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 437 31 : : : doi-org-9532 437 32 23–40 23–40 LS doi-org-9532 437 33 . . . doi-org-9532 438 1 Buschman Buschman NNP doi-org-9532 438 2 analyzes analyze VBZ doi-org-9532 438 3 Wayne Wayne NNP doi-org-9532 438 4 A. A. NNP doi-org-9532 438 5 Wiegand Wiegand NNP doi-org-9532 438 6 's 's POS doi-org-9532 438 7 Part part NN doi-org-9532 438 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 438 9 Our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 438 10 Lives life NNS doi-org-9532 438 11 : : : doi-org-9532 438 12 A a DT doi-org-9532 438 13 People People NNPS doi-org-9532 438 14 's 's POS doi-org-9532 438 15 History history NN doi-org-9532 438 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 438 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 438 18 American American NNP doi-org-9532 438 19 Public Public NNP doi-org-9532 438 20 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 438 21 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 438 22 Oxford Oxford NNP doi-org-9532 438 23 , , , doi-org-9532 438 24 U.K. U.K. NNP doi-org-9532 438 25 : : : doi-org-9532 438 26 Oxford Oxford NNP doi-org-9532 438 27 University University NNP doi-org-9532 438 28 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 438 29 , , , doi-org-9532 438 30 2015 2015 CD doi-org-9532 438 31 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 438 32 . . . doi-org-9532 439 1 Interestingly interestingly RB doi-org-9532 439 2 , , , doi-org-9532 439 3 Wiegand Wiegand NNP doi-org-9532 439 4 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 439 5 that that IN doi-org-9532 439 6 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 439 7 social social JJ doi-org-9532 439 8 history history NN doi-org-9532 439 9 undermines undermine VBZ doi-org-9532 439 10 the the DT doi-org-9532 439 11 thesis thesis NN doi-org-9532 439 12 that that IN doi-org-9532 439 13 public public JJ doi-org-9532 439 14 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 439 15 support support VBP doi-org-9532 439 16 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 439 17 . . . doi-org-9532 440 1 Buschman Buschman NNP doi-org-9532 440 2 argues argue VBZ doi-org-9532 440 3 that that IN doi-org-9532 440 4 Wiegand Wiegand NNP doi-org-9532 440 5 misinterprets misinterpret VBZ doi-org-9532 440 6 the the DT doi-org-9532 440 7 evidence evidence NN doi-org-9532 440 8 discovered discover VBN doi-org-9532 440 9 in in IN doi-org-9532 440 10 his -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 440 11 own own JJ doi-org-9532 440 12 research research NN doi-org-9532 440 13 because because IN doi-org-9532 440 14 he -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 440 15 understands understand VBZ doi-org-9532 440 16 " " `` doi-org-9532 440 17 supporting support VBG doi-org-9532 440 18 democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 440 19 " " '' doi-org-9532 440 20 in in IN doi-org-9532 440 21 an an DT doi-org-9532 440 22 overly overly RB doi-org-9532 440 23 narrow narrow JJ doi-org-9532 440 24 way way NN doi-org-9532 440 25 . . . doi-org-9532 441 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 441 2 Buschman Buschman NNP doi-org-9532 441 3 , , , doi-org-9532 441 4 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 441 5 education education NN doi-org-9532 441 6 goes go VBZ doi-org-9532 441 7 beyond beyond IN doi-org-9532 441 8 wonkish wonkish NN doi-org-9532 441 9 interest interest NN doi-org-9532 441 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 441 11 public public JJ doi-org-9532 441 12 policy policy NN doi-org-9532 441 13 such such JJ doi-org-9532 441 14 as as IN doi-org-9532 441 15 reading read VBG doi-org-9532 441 16 the the DT doi-org-9532 441 17 ballot ballot NN doi-org-9532 441 18 propositions proposition NNS doi-org-9532 441 19 or or CC doi-org-9532 441 20 knowing know VBG doi-org-9532 441 21 who who WP doi-org-9532 441 22 your -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 441 23 congressman congressman NN doi-org-9532 441 24 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 441 25 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 441 26 for for IN doi-org-9532 441 27 which which WDT doi-org-9532 441 28 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 441 29 provide provide VBP doi-org-9532 441 30 little little JJ doi-org-9532 441 31 help help NN doi-org-9532 441 32 , , , doi-org-9532 441 33 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 441 34 to to IN doi-org-9532 441 35 Wiegand Wiegand NNP doi-org-9532 441 36 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 441 37 . . . doi-org-9532 442 1 Training training NN doi-org-9532 442 2 for for IN doi-org-9532 442 3 democratic democratic JJ doi-org-9532 442 4 citizenship citizenship NN doi-org-9532 442 5 includes include VBZ doi-org-9532 442 6 broader broad JJR doi-org-9532 442 7 forms form NNS doi-org-9532 442 8 of of IN doi-org-9532 442 9 self self NN doi-org-9532 442 10 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 442 11 development development NN doi-org-9532 442 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 442 13 community community NN doi-org-9532 442 14 engagement engagement NN doi-org-9532 442 15 , , , doi-org-9532 442 16 which which WDT doi-org-9532 442 17 are be VBP doi-org-9532 442 18 widely widely RB doi-org-9532 442 19 supported support VBN doi-org-9532 442 20 by by IN doi-org-9532 442 21 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 442 22 , , , doi-org-9532 442 23 according accord VBG doi-org-9532 442 24 to to IN doi-org-9532 442 25 Wiegand Wiegand NNP doi-org-9532 442 26 's 's POS doi-org-9532 442 27 history history NN doi-org-9532 442 28 . . . doi-org-9532 443 1 34 34 CD doi-org-9532 443 2 . . . doi-org-9532 444 1 Kant Kant NNP doi-org-9532 444 2 , , , doi-org-9532 444 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 444 4 An an DT doi-org-9532 444 5 Answer answer NN doi-org-9532 444 6 to to IN doi-org-9532 444 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 444 8 Question question NN doi-org-9532 444 9 : : : doi-org-9532 444 10 What what WP doi-org-9532 444 11 Is be VBZ doi-org-9532 444 12 Enlightenment enlightenment NN doi-org-9532 444 13 ? ? . doi-org-9532 444 14 " " '' doi-org-9532 445 1 35 35 CD doi-org-9532 445 2 . . . doi-org-9532 446 1 ALA ALA NNP doi-org-9532 446 2 , , , doi-org-9532 446 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 446 4 The the DT doi-org-9532 446 5 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 446 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 446 7 Read read VB doi-org-9532 446 8 Statement statement NN doi-org-9532 446 9 . . . doi-org-9532 446 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 447 1 36 36 CD doi-org-9532 447 2 . . . doi-org-9532 448 1 Ronald Ronald NNP doi-org-9532 448 2 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 448 3 , , , doi-org-9532 448 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 448 5 Liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 448 6 , , , doi-org-9532 448 7 " " '' doi-org-9532 448 8 chap chap NNP doi-org-9532 448 9 . . . doi-org-9532 449 1 6 6 CD doi-org-9532 449 2 in in IN doi-org-9532 449 3 Stuart Stuart NNP doi-org-9532 449 4 Hampshire Hampshire NNP doi-org-9532 449 5 , , , doi-org-9532 449 6 T. T. NNP doi-org-9532 449 7 M. M. NNP doi-org-9532 449 8 Scanlon Scanlon NNP doi-org-9532 449 9 , , , doi-org-9532 449 10 Bernard Bernard NNP doi-org-9532 449 11 Williams Williams NNP doi-org-9532 449 12 , , , doi-org-9532 449 13 Thomas Thomas NNP doi-org-9532 449 14 Nagel Nagel NNP doi-org-9532 449 15 , , , doi-org-9532 449 16 and and CC doi-org-9532 449 17 Ronald Ronald NNP doi-org-9532 449 18 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 449 19 , , , doi-org-9532 449 20 Public public JJ doi-org-9532 449 21 and and CC doi-org-9532 449 22 Private private JJ doi-org-9532 449 23 Morality Morality NNP doi-org-9532 449 24 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 449 25 Cambridge Cambridge NNP doi-org-9532 449 26 , , , doi-org-9532 449 27 U.K. U.K. NNP doi-org-9532 449 28 : : : doi-org-9532 449 29 Cambridge Cambridge NNP doi-org-9532 449 30 University University NNP doi-org-9532 449 31 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 449 32 , , , doi-org-9532 449 33 1978 1978 CD doi-org-9532 449 34 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 449 35 , , , doi-org-9532 449 36 113–14 113–14 CD doi-org-9532 449 37 . . . doi-org-9532 450 1 37 37 CD doi-org-9532 450 2 . . . doi-org-9532 451 1 Dworkin Dworkin NNP doi-org-9532 451 2 , , , doi-org-9532 451 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 451 4 Liberalism liberalism NN doi-org-9532 451 5 , , , doi-org-9532 451 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 451 7 127 127 CD doi-org-9532 451 8 . . . doi-org-9532 452 1 38 38 CD doi-org-9532 452 2 . . . doi-org-9532 453 1 Ibid ibid RB doi-org-9532 453 2 . . . doi-org-9532 454 1 39 39 CD doi-org-9532 454 2 . . . doi-org-9532 455 1 John John NNP doi-org-9532 455 2 Rawls Rawls NNP doi-org-9532 455 3 , , , doi-org-9532 455 4 Political Political NNP doi-org-9532 455 5 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 455 6 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 455 7 New New NNP doi-org-9532 455 8 York York NNP doi-org-9532 455 9 : : : doi-org-9532 455 10 Columbia Columbia NNP doi-org-9532 455 11 University University NNP doi-org-9532 455 12 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 455 13 , , , doi-org-9532 455 14 1993 1993 CD doi-org-9532 455 15 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 455 16 . . . doi-org-9532 456 1 40 40 CD doi-org-9532 456 2 . . . doi-org-9532 457 1 Martha Martha NNP doi-org-9532 457 2 C. C. NNP doi-org-9532 457 3 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP doi-org-9532 457 4 , , , doi-org-9532 457 5 " " `` doi-org-9532 457 6 Perfectionist Perfectionist NNP doi-org-9532 457 7 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 457 8 and and CC doi-org-9532 457 9 Political Political NNP doi-org-9532 457 10 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 457 11 , , , doi-org-9532 457 12 " " '' doi-org-9532 457 13 Philosophy Philosophy NNP doi-org-9532 457 14 & & CC doi-org-9532 457 15 Public Public NNP doi-org-9532 457 16 Affairs Affairs NNPS doi-org-9532 457 17 39 39 CD doi-org-9532 457 18 , , , doi-org-9532 457 19 1 1 CD doi-org-9532 457 20 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 457 21 2011 2011 CD doi-org-9532 457 22 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 457 23 : : : doi-org-9532 457 24 33 33 CD doi-org-9532 457 25 . . . doi-org-9532 458 1 41 41 CD doi-org-9532 458 2 . . . doi-org-9532 459 1 The the DT doi-org-9532 459 2 question question NN doi-org-9532 459 3 of of IN doi-org-9532 459 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 459 5 hate hate NN doi-org-9532 459 6 speech speech NN doi-org-9532 459 7 " " '' doi-org-9532 459 8 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 459 9 challenging challenge VBG doi-org-9532 459 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 459 11 this this DT doi-org-9532 459 12 context context NN doi-org-9532 459 13 . . . doi-org-9532 460 1 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 460 2 define define VBP doi-org-9532 460 3 " " '' doi-org-9532 460 4 hate hate NN doi-org-9532 460 5 speech speech NN doi-org-9532 460 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 460 7 as as IN doi-org-9532 460 8 speech speech NN doi-org-9532 460 9 that that WDT doi-org-9532 460 10 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 460 11 not not RB doi-org-9532 460 12 play play VB doi-org-9532 460 13 by by IN doi-org-9532 460 14 the the DT doi-org-9532 460 15 rules rule NNS doi-org-9532 460 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 460 17 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 460 18 discourse discourse NN doi-org-9532 460 19 because because IN doi-org-9532 460 20 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 460 21 deliberately deliberately RB doi-org-9532 460 22 creates create VBZ doi-org-9532 460 23 prejudice prejudice NN doi-org-9532 460 24 that that IN doi-org-9532 460 25 hinders hinder NNS doi-org-9532 460 26 targeted target VBD doi-org-9532 460 27 groups group NNS doi-org-9532 460 28 from from IN doi-org-9532 460 29 participating participate VBG doi-org-9532 460 30 in in IN doi-org-9532 460 31 civic civic JJ doi-org-9532 460 32 life life NN doi-org-9532 460 33 . . . doi-org-9532 461 1 Thus thus RB doi-org-9532 461 2 , , , doi-org-9532 461 3 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 461 4 ought ought MD doi-org-9532 461 5 not not RB doi-org-9532 461 6 be be VB doi-org-9532 461 7 neutral neutral JJ doi-org-9532 461 8 about about IN doi-org-9532 461 9 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 461 10 . . . doi-org-9532 462 1 Of of RB doi-org-9532 462 2 course course RB doi-org-9532 462 3 , , , doi-org-9532 462 4 one one PRP doi-org-9532 462 5 must must MD doi-org-9532 462 6 be be VB doi-org-9532 462 7 careful careful JJ doi-org-9532 462 8 about about IN doi-org-9532 462 9 using use VBG doi-org-9532 462 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 462 11 loose loose JJ doi-org-9532 462 12 definition definition NN doi-org-9532 462 13 of of IN doi-org-9532 462 14 " " `` doi-org-9532 462 15 hate hate NN doi-org-9532 462 16 speech speech NN doi-org-9532 462 17 " " '' doi-org-9532 462 18 as as IN doi-org-9532 462 19 a a DT doi-org-9532 462 20 backdoor backdoor JJ doi-org-9532 462 21 escape escape NN doi-org-9532 462 22 from from IN doi-org-9532 462 23 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 462 24 in in IN doi-org-9532 462 25 general general JJ doi-org-9532 462 26 by by IN doi-org-9532 462 27 defining define VBG doi-org-9532 462 28 any any DT doi-org-9532 462 29 idea idea NN doi-org-9532 462 30 that that IN doi-org-9532 462 31 one one PRP doi-org-9532 462 32 does do VBZ doi-org-9532 462 33 not not RB doi-org-9532 462 34 like like VB doi-org-9532 462 35 as as IN doi-org-9532 462 36 hate hate NN doi-org-9532 462 37 speech speech NN doi-org-9532 462 38 . . . doi-org-9532 463 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB doi-org-9532 463 2 , , , doi-org-9532 463 3 the the DT doi-org-9532 463 4 challenge challenge NN doi-org-9532 463 5 of of IN doi-org-9532 463 6 applying apply VBG doi-org-9532 463 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 463 8 distinction distinction NN doi-org-9532 463 9 in in IN doi-org-9532 463 10 practice practice NN doi-org-9532 463 11 should should MD doi-org-9532 463 12 not not RB doi-org-9532 463 13 lead lead VB doi-org-9532 463 14 us -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 463 15 to to TO doi-org-9532 463 16 throw throw VB doi-org-9532 463 17 up up RP doi-org-9532 463 18 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 463 19 hands hand NNS doi-org-9532 463 20 and and CC doi-org-9532 463 21 not not RB doi-org-9532 463 22 even even RB doi-org-9532 463 23 try try VB doi-org-9532 463 24 , , , doi-org-9532 463 25 as as IN doi-org-9532 463 26 " " `` doi-org-9532 463 27 free free JJ doi-org-9532 463 28 speech speech NN doi-org-9532 463 29 absolutists absolutist NNS doi-org-9532 463 30 " " `` doi-org-9532 463 31 tend tend VBP doi-org-9532 463 32 to to TO doi-org-9532 463 33 do do VB doi-org-9532 463 34 . . . doi-org-9532 464 1 This this DT doi-org-9532 464 2 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 464 3 an an DT doi-org-9532 464 4 important important JJ doi-org-9532 464 5 question question NN doi-org-9532 464 6 that that WDT doi-org-9532 464 7 goes go VBZ doi-org-9532 464 8 beyond beyond IN doi-org-9532 464 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 464 10 scope scope NN doi-org-9532 464 11 of of IN doi-org-9532 464 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 464 13 current current JJ doi-org-9532 464 14 essay essay NN doi-org-9532 464 15 . . . doi-org-9532 465 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 465 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 465 3 good good JJ doi-org-9532 465 4 discussion discussion NN doi-org-9532 465 5 , , , doi-org-9532 465 6 see see VB doi-org-9532 465 7 Jeremy Jeremy NNP doi-org-9532 465 8 Waldron Waldron NNP doi-org-9532 465 9 , , , doi-org-9532 465 10 " " `` doi-org-9532 465 11 Dignity Dignity NNP doi-org-9532 465 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 465 13 Defamation Defamation NNP doi-org-9532 465 14 : : : doi-org-9532 465 15 The the DT doi-org-9532 465 16 Visibility Visibility NNP doi-org-9532 465 17 of of IN doi-org-9532 465 18 Hate Hate NNP doi-org-9532 465 19 , , , doi-org-9532 465 20 " " '' doi-org-9532 465 21 Harvard Harvard NNP doi-org-9532 465 22 Law Law NNP doi-org-9532 465 23 Review Review NNP doi-org-9532 465 24 123 123 CD doi-org-9532 465 25 , , , doi-org-9532 465 26 7 7 CD doi-org-9532 465 27 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 465 28 2010 2010 CD doi-org-9532 465 29 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 465 30 : : : doi-org-9532 465 31 1596–657 1596–657 CD doi-org-9532 465 32 . . . doi-org-9532 466 1 42 42 CD doi-org-9532 466 2 . . . doi-org-9532 467 1 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNS doi-org-9532 467 2 , , , doi-org-9532 467 3 " " `` doi-org-9532 467 4 Perfectionist Perfectionist NNP doi-org-9532 467 5 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 467 6 and and CC doi-org-9532 467 7 Political Political NNP doi-org-9532 467 8 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 467 9 , , , doi-org-9532 467 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 467 11 36 36 CD doi-org-9532 467 12 . . . doi-org-9532 468 1 43 43 CD doi-org-9532 468 2 . . . doi-org-9532 469 1 Deciding decide VBG doi-org-9532 469 2 exactly exactly RB doi-org-9532 469 3 how how WRB doi-org-9532 469 4 and and CC doi-org-9532 469 5 when when WRB doi-org-9532 469 6 to to TO doi-org-9532 469 7 use use VB doi-org-9532 469 8 affirmative affirmative JJ doi-org-9532 469 9 action action NN doi-org-9532 469 10 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 469 11 a a DT doi-org-9532 469 12 challenging challenging JJ doi-org-9532 469 13 question question NN doi-org-9532 469 14 to to TO doi-org-9532 469 15 which which WDT doi-org-9532 469 16 I -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 469 17 can can MD doi-org-9532 469 18 not not RB doi-org-9532 469 19 do do VB doi-org-9532 469 20 justice justice NN doi-org-9532 469 21 here here RB doi-org-9532 469 22 . . . doi-org-9532 470 1 Thomas Thomas NNP doi-org-9532 470 2 Nagel Nagel NNP doi-org-9532 470 3 , , , doi-org-9532 470 4 " " `` doi-org-9532 470 5 The the DT doi-org-9532 470 6 Policy policy NN doi-org-9532 470 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 470 8 Preference preference NN doi-org-9532 470 9 , , , doi-org-9532 470 10 " " '' doi-org-9532 470 11 Philosophy Philosophy NNP doi-org-9532 470 12 & & CC doi-org-9532 470 13 Public Public NNP doi-org-9532 470 14 Affairs Affairs NNPS doi-org-9532 470 15 2 2 CD doi-org-9532 470 16 , , , doi-org-9532 470 17 4 4 CD doi-org-9532 470 18 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 470 19 1973 1973 CD doi-org-9532 470 20 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 470 21 : : : doi-org-9532 470 22 348–63 348–63 CD doi-org-9532 470 23 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 470 24 a a DT doi-org-9532 470 25 good good JJ doi-org-9532 470 26 introduction introduction NN doi-org-9532 470 27 to to IN doi-org-9532 470 28 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 470 29 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 470 30 about about IN doi-org-9532 470 31 affirmative affirmative JJ doi-org-9532 470 32 action action NN doi-org-9532 470 33 from from IN doi-org-9532 470 34 a a DT doi-org-9532 470 35 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 470 36 perspective perspective NN doi-org-9532 470 37 . . . doi-org-9532 471 1 44 44 CD doi-org-9532 471 2 . . . doi-org-9532 472 1 Two two CD doi-org-9532 472 2 political political JJ doi-org-9532 472 3 philosophers philosopher NNS doi-org-9532 472 4 who who WP doi-org-9532 472 5 have have VBP doi-org-9532 472 6 argued argue VBN doi-org-9532 472 7 against against IN doi-org-9532 472 8 liberal liberal JJ doi-org-9532 472 9 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 472 10 are be VBP doi-org-9532 472 11 Joseph Joseph NNP doi-org-9532 472 12 Raz Raz NNP doi-org-9532 472 13 , , , doi-org-9532 472 14 The the DT doi-org-9532 472 15 Morality Morality NNP doi-org-9532 472 16 of of IN doi-org-9532 472 17 Freedom Freedom NNP doi-org-9532 472 18 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 472 19 Oxford Oxford NNP doi-org-9532 472 20 , , , doi-org-9532 472 21 U.K. U.K. NNP doi-org-9532 472 22 : : : doi-org-9532 472 23 Oxford Oxford NNP doi-org-9532 472 24 University University NNP doi-org-9532 472 25 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 472 26 , , , doi-org-9532 472 27 1986 1986 CD doi-org-9532 472 28 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 472 29 and and CC doi-org-9532 472 30 George George NNP doi-org-9532 472 31 Sher Sher NNP doi-org-9532 472 32 , , , doi-org-9532 472 33 Beyond Beyond NNP doi-org-9532 472 34 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 472 35 : : : doi-org-9532 472 36 Perfectionism perfectionism NN doi-org-9532 472 37 and and CC doi-org-9532 472 38 Politics Politics NNP doi-org-9532 472 39 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 472 40 Cambridge Cambridge NNP doi-org-9532 472 41 , , , doi-org-9532 472 42 U.K. U.K. NNP doi-org-9532 472 43 : : : doi-org-9532 472 44 Cambridge Cambridge NNP doi-org-9532 472 45 University University NNP doi-org-9532 472 46 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 472 47 , , , doi-org-9532 472 48 1997 1997 CD doi-org-9532 472 49 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 472 50 . . . doi-org-9532 473 1 45 45 CD doi-org-9532 473 2 . . . doi-org-9532 474 1 Bivens Bivens NNP doi-org-9532 474 2 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 474 3 Tatum Tatum NNP doi-org-9532 474 4 , , , doi-org-9532 474 5 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 474 6 and and CC doi-org-9532 474 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 474 8 Enlightenment Enlightenment NNP doi-org-9532 474 9 , , , doi-org-9532 474 10 187 187 CD doi-org-9532 474 11 . . . doi-org-9532 475 1 46 46 CD doi-org-9532 475 2 . . . doi-org-9532 476 1 Ibid Ibid NNP doi-org-9532 476 2 . . . doi-org-9532 476 3 , , , doi-org-9532 476 4 133 133 CD doi-org-9532 476 5 . . . doi-org-9532 477 1 47 47 CD doi-org-9532 477 2 . . . doi-org-9532 478 1 Ibid Ibid NNP doi-org-9532 478 2 . . . doi-org-9532 478 3 , , , doi-org-9532 478 4 112 112 CD doi-org-9532 478 5 . . . doi-org-9532 479 1 48 48 CD doi-org-9532 479 2 . . . doi-org-9532 480 1 A a DT doi-org-9532 480 2 great great JJ doi-org-9532 480 3 deal deal NN doi-org-9532 480 4 has have VBZ doi-org-9532 480 5 been be VBN doi-org-9532 480 6 written write VBN doi-org-9532 480 7 on on IN doi-org-9532 480 8 these these DT doi-org-9532 480 9 topics topic NNS doi-org-9532 480 10 . . . doi-org-9532 481 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 481 2 an an DT doi-org-9532 481 3 overview overview NN doi-org-9532 481 4 of of IN doi-org-9532 481 5 some some DT doi-org-9532 481 6 of of IN doi-org-9532 481 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 481 8 recent recent JJ doi-org-9532 481 9 research research NN doi-org-9532 481 10 , , , doi-org-9532 481 11 see see VB doi-org-9532 481 12 Daniel Daniel NNP doi-org-9532 481 13 Kahneman Kahneman NNP doi-org-9532 481 14 , , , doi-org-9532 481 15 Thinking Thinking NNP doi-org-9532 481 16 , , , doi-org-9532 481 17 Fast fast JJ doi-org-9532 481 18 and and CC doi-org-9532 481 19 Slow slow JJ doi-org-9532 481 20 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 481 21 New New NNP doi-org-9532 481 22 York York NNP doi-org-9532 481 23 : : : doi-org-9532 481 24 Farrar Farrar NNP doi-org-9532 481 25 , , , doi-org-9532 481 26 Straus Straus NNP doi-org-9532 481 27 and and CC doi-org-9532 481 28 Giroux Giroux NNP doi-org-9532 481 29 , , , doi-org-9532 481 30 2011 2011 CD doi-org-9532 481 31 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 481 32 . . . doi-org-9532 482 1 49 49 CD doi-org-9532 482 2 . . . doi-org-9532 483 1 Soroush soroush JJ doi-org-9532 483 2 Vosoughi Vosoughi NNP doi-org-9532 483 3 , , , doi-org-9532 483 4 Deb Deb NNP doi-org-9532 483 5 Roy Roy NNP doi-org-9532 483 6 , , , doi-org-9532 483 7 and and CC doi-org-9532 483 8 Sinan Sinan NNP doi-org-9532 483 9 Aral Aral NNP doi-org-9532 483 10 , , , doi-org-9532 483 11 " " '' doi-org-9532 483 12 The the DT doi-org-9532 483 13 Spread spread NN doi-org-9532 483 14 of of IN doi-org-9532 483 15 True true JJ doi-org-9532 483 16 and and CC doi-org-9532 483 17 False False NNP doi-org-9532 483 18 News News NNP doi-org-9532 483 19 Online Online NNP doi-org-9532 483 20 , , , doi-org-9532 483 21 " " `` doi-org-9532 483 22 Science Science NNP doi-org-9532 483 23 359 359 CD doi-org-9532 483 24 , , , doi-org-9532 483 25 6308 6308 CD doi-org-9532 483 26 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 483 27 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 483 28 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 483 29 : : : doi-org-9532 483 30 1146–51 1146–51 LS doi-org-9532 483 31 . . . doi-org-9532 484 1 50 50 CD doi-org-9532 484 2 . . . doi-org-9532 485 1 Berninghausen Berninghausen NNP doi-org-9532 485 2 , , , doi-org-9532 485 3 The the DT doi-org-9532 485 4 Flight Flight NNP doi-org-9532 485 5 from from IN doi-org-9532 485 6 Reason Reason NNP doi-org-9532 485 7 , , , doi-org-9532 485 8 9 9 CD doi-org-9532 485 9 . . . doi-org-9532 486 1 51 51 CD doi-org-9532 486 2 . . . doi-org-9532 487 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 487 2 a a DT doi-org-9532 487 3 relatively relatively RB doi-org-9532 487 4 recent recent JJ doi-org-9532 487 5 philosophical philosophical JJ doi-org-9532 487 6 defense defense NN doi-org-9532 487 7 of of IN doi-org-9532 487 8 conservatism conservatism NN doi-org-9532 487 9 , , , doi-org-9532 487 10 see see VB doi-org-9532 487 11 Alasdair Alasdair NNP doi-org-9532 487 12 MacIntyre MacIntyre NNP doi-org-9532 487 13 , , , doi-org-9532 487 14 After after IN doi-org-9532 487 15 Virtue Virtue NNP doi-org-9532 487 16 : : : doi-org-9532 487 17 A a DT doi-org-9532 487 18 Study Study NNP doi-org-9532 487 19 in in IN doi-org-9532 487 20 Moral Moral NNP doi-org-9532 487 21 Theory Theory NNP doi-org-9532 487 22 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 487 23 Notre Notre NNP doi-org-9532 487 24 Dame Dame NNP doi-org-9532 487 25 , , , doi-org-9532 487 26 IN in IN doi-org-9532 487 27 : : : doi-org-9532 487 28 University University NNP doi-org-9532 487 29 of of IN doi-org-9532 487 30 Notre Notre NNP doi-org-9532 487 31 Dame Dame NNP doi-org-9532 487 32 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 487 33 , , , doi-org-9532 487 34 1984 1984 CD doi-org-9532 487 35 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 487 36 . . . doi-org-9532 488 1 52 52 CD doi-org-9532 488 2 . . . doi-org-9532 488 3 nina nina NNP doi-org-9532 488 4 de de NNP doi-org-9532 488 5 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 488 6 , , , doi-org-9532 488 7 " " `` doi-org-9532 488 8 Locating locate VBG doi-org-9532 488 9 the the DT doi-org-9532 488 10 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 488 11 in in IN doi-org-9532 488 12 Institutional Institutional NNP doi-org-9532 488 13 Oppression Oppression NNP doi-org-9532 488 14 , , , doi-org-9532 488 15 " " `` doi-org-9532 488 16 In in IN doi-org-9532 488 17 the the DT doi-org-9532 488 18 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 488 19 with with IN doi-org-9532 488 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 488 21 Lead Lead NNP doi-org-9532 488 22 Pipe Pipe NNP doi-org-9532 488 23 , , , doi-org-9532 488 24 September September NNP doi-org-9532 488 25 24 24 CD doi-org-9532 488 26 , , , doi-org-9532 488 27 2014 2014 CD doi-org-9532 488 28 , , , doi-org-9532 488 29 http://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2014/locating-the-library-in-institutional-oppression http://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2014/locating-the-library-in-institutional-oppression NN doi-org-9532 488 30 . . . doi-org-9532 489 1 de de NNP doi-org-9532 489 2 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 489 3 cites cite VBZ doi-org-9532 489 4 Andrea Andrea NNP doi-org-9532 489 5 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 489 6 , , , doi-org-9532 489 7 " " `` doi-org-9532 489 8 Indigeneity Indigeneity NNP doi-org-9532 489 9 , , , doi-org-9532 489 10 Settler Settler NNP doi-org-9532 489 11 Colonialism Colonialism NNP doi-org-9532 489 12 , , , doi-org-9532 489 13 White White NNP doi-org-9532 489 14 Supremacy Supremacy NNP doi-org-9532 489 15 — — : doi-org-9532 489 16 Centre Centre NNP doi-org-9532 489 17 for for IN doi-org-9532 489 18 World World NNP doi-org-9532 489 19 Dialogue Dialogue NNP doi-org-9532 489 20 , , , doi-org-9532 489 21 " " `` doi-org-9532 489 22 Global Global NNP doi-org-9532 489 23 Dialogue Dialogue NNP doi-org-9532 489 24 12 12 CD doi-org-9532 489 25 , , , doi-org-9532 489 26 2 2 CD doi-org-9532 489 27 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 489 28 2010 2010 CD doi-org-9532 489 29 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 489 30 : : : doi-org-9532 489 31 1–13 1–13 CD doi-org-9532 489 32 . . . doi-org-9532 490 1 53 53 CD doi-org-9532 490 2 . . . doi-org-9532 490 3 de de NNP doi-org-9532 490 4 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 490 5 , , , doi-org-9532 490 6 " " `` doi-org-9532 490 7 Locating locate VBG doi-org-9532 490 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 490 9 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 490 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 490 11 Institutional Institutional NNP doi-org-9532 490 12 Oppression Oppression NNP doi-org-9532 490 13 . . . doi-org-9532 490 14 " " '' doi-org-9532 491 1 54 54 CD doi-org-9532 491 2 . . . doi-org-9532 492 1 On on IN doi-org-9532 492 2 " " `` doi-org-9532 492 3 Unsettling Unsettling NNP doi-org-9532 492 4 America America NNP doi-org-9532 492 5 , , , doi-org-9532 492 6 " " '' doi-org-9532 492 7 de de NNP doi-org-9532 492 8 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 492 9 refers refer VBZ doi-org-9532 492 10 to to IN doi-org-9532 492 11 the the DT doi-org-9532 492 12 website website NN doi-org-9532 492 13 " " `` doi-org-9532 492 14 Unsettling Unsettling NNP doi-org-9532 492 15 America America NNP doi-org-9532 492 16 : : : doi-org-9532 492 17 Decolonization decolonization NN doi-org-9532 492 18 in in IN doi-org-9532 492 19 Theory Theory NNP doi-org-9532 492 20 & & CC doi-org-9532 492 21 Practice Practice NNP doi-org-9532 492 22 , , , doi-org-9532 492 23 " " '' doi-org-9532 492 24 https://unsettlingamerica.wordpress.com/about/. https://unsettlingamerica.wordpress.com/about/. NNP doi-org-9532 493 1 If if IN doi-org-9532 493 2 de de NNP doi-org-9532 493 3 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 493 4 were be VBD doi-org-9532 493 5 an an DT doi-org-9532 493 6 academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 493 7 librarian librarian NN doi-org-9532 493 8 , , , doi-org-9532 493 9 she -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 493 10 might may MD doi-org-9532 493 11 write write VB doi-org-9532 493 12 articles article NNS doi-org-9532 493 13 in in IN doi-org-9532 493 14 support support NN doi-org-9532 493 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 493 16 Andrea Andrea NNP doi-org-9532 493 17 Smith Smith NNP doi-org-9532 493 18 on on IN doi-org-9532 493 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 493 20 university university NN doi-org-9532 493 21 's 's POS doi-org-9532 493 22 time time NN doi-org-9532 493 23 . . . doi-org-9532 494 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 494 2 academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 494 3 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 494 4 , , , doi-org-9532 494 5 who who WP doi-org-9532 494 6 often often RB doi-org-9532 494 7 are be VBP doi-org-9532 494 8 expected expect VBN doi-org-9532 494 9 to to TO doi-org-9532 494 10 engage engage VB doi-org-9532 494 11 in in IN doi-org-9532 494 12 scholarship scholarship NN doi-org-9532 494 13 as as IN doi-org-9532 494 14 part part NN doi-org-9532 494 15 of of IN doi-org-9532 494 16 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 494 17 work work NN doi-org-9532 494 18 , , , doi-org-9532 494 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 494 20 commitment commitment NN doi-org-9532 494 21 to to IN doi-org-9532 494 22 neutrality neutrality NN doi-org-9532 494 23 applies apply VBZ doi-org-9532 494 24 to to IN doi-org-9532 494 25 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 494 26 work work NN doi-org-9532 494 27 with with IN doi-org-9532 494 28 collections collection NNS doi-org-9532 494 29 and and CC doi-org-9532 494 30 patrons patron NNS doi-org-9532 494 31 , , , doi-org-9532 494 32 not not RB doi-org-9532 494 33 to to IN doi-org-9532 494 34 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 494 35 work work NN doi-org-9532 494 36 as as IN doi-org-9532 494 37 scholars scholar NNS doi-org-9532 494 38 . . . doi-org-9532 495 1 As as IN doi-org-9532 495 2 scholars scholar NNS doi-org-9532 495 3 , , , doi-org-9532 495 4 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 495 5 should should MD doi-org-9532 495 6 have have VB doi-org-9532 495 7 the the DT doi-org-9532 495 8 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 495 9 freedom freedom NN doi-org-9532 495 10 to to TO doi-org-9532 495 11 articulate articulate VB doi-org-9532 495 12 controversial controversial JJ doi-org-9532 495 13 opinions opinion NNS doi-org-9532 495 14 related relate VBN doi-org-9532 495 15 to to IN doi-org-9532 495 16 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 495 17 areas area NNS doi-org-9532 495 18 of of IN doi-org-9532 495 19 expertise expertise NN doi-org-9532 495 20 without without IN doi-org-9532 495 21 fear fear NN doi-org-9532 495 22 of of IN doi-org-9532 495 23 losing lose VBG doi-org-9532 495 24 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 495 25 position position NN doi-org-9532 495 26 . . . doi-org-9532 496 1 Neutrality Neutrality NNP doi-org-9532 496 2 applies apply VBZ doi-org-9532 496 3 at at IN doi-org-9532 496 4 the the DT doi-org-9532 496 5 reference reference NN doi-org-9532 496 6 desk desk NN doi-org-9532 496 7 or or CC doi-org-9532 496 8 in in IN doi-org-9532 496 9 collection collection NN doi-org-9532 496 10 development development NN doi-org-9532 496 11 , , , doi-org-9532 496 12 where where WRB doi-org-9532 496 13 librarians librarian NNS doi-org-9532 496 14 should should MD doi-org-9532 496 15 not not RB doi-org-9532 496 16 give give VB doi-org-9532 496 17 preference preference NN doi-org-9532 496 18 even even RB doi-org-9532 496 19 to to IN doi-org-9532 496 20 their -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 496 21 own own JJ doi-org-9532 496 22 scholarship scholarship NN doi-org-9532 496 23 in in IN doi-org-9532 496 24 relation relation NN doi-org-9532 496 25 to to IN doi-org-9532 496 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 496 27 work work NN doi-org-9532 496 28 of of IN doi-org-9532 496 29 intellectual intellectual JJ doi-org-9532 496 30 opponents opponent NNS doi-org-9532 496 31 . . . doi-org-9532 497 1 55 55 CD doi-org-9532 497 2 . . . doi-org-9532 497 3 de de NNP doi-org-9532 497 4 jesus jesus NNP doi-org-9532 497 5 , , , doi-org-9532 497 6 " " `` doi-org-9532 497 7 Locating locate VBG doi-org-9532 497 8 the the DT doi-org-9532 497 9 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 497 10 in in IN doi-org-9532 497 11 Institutional Institutional NNP doi-org-9532 497 12 Oppression Oppression NNP doi-org-9532 497 13 . . . doi-org-9532 497 14 " " '' doi-org-9532 498 1 56 56 CD doi-org-9532 498 2 . . . doi-org-9532 499 1 See see VB doi-org-9532 499 2 Fobazi Fobazi NNP doi-org-9532 499 3 Ettarh Ettarh NNP doi-org-9532 499 4 , , , doi-org-9532 499 5 " " `` doi-org-9532 499 6 Vocational Vocational NNP doi-org-9532 499 7 Awe Awe NNP doi-org-9532 499 8 and and CC doi-org-9532 499 9 Librarianship Librarianship NNP doi-org-9532 499 10 : : : doi-org-9532 499 11 The the DT doi-org-9532 499 12 Lies lie NNS doi-org-9532 499 13 We -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 499 14 Tell tell VBP doi-org-9532 499 15 Ourselves -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 499 16 , , , doi-org-9532 499 17 " " `` doi-org-9532 499 18 In in IN doi-org-9532 499 19 the the DT doi-org-9532 499 20 Library Library NNP doi-org-9532 499 21 with with IN doi-org-9532 499 22 the the DT doi-org-9532 499 23 Lead Lead NNP doi-org-9532 499 24 Pipe Pipe NNP doi-org-9532 499 25 , , , doi-org-9532 499 26 January January NNP doi-org-9532 499 27 10 10 CD doi-org-9532 499 28 , , , doi-org-9532 499 29 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 499 30 , , , doi-org-9532 499 31 http://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2018/vocational-awe/ http://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2018/vocational-awe/ UH doi-org-9532 499 32 , , , doi-org-9532 499 33 for for IN doi-org-9532 499 34 an an DT doi-org-9532 499 35 interesting interesting JJ doi-org-9532 499 36 discussion discussion NN doi-org-9532 499 37 of of IN doi-org-9532 499 38 the the DT doi-org-9532 499 39 idea idea NN doi-org-9532 499 40 that that IN doi-org-9532 499 41 " " `` doi-org-9532 499 42 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 499 43 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 499 44 a a DT doi-org-9532 499 45 sacred sacred JJ doi-org-9532 499 46 calling calling NN doi-org-9532 499 47 " " '' doi-org-9532 499 48 and and CC doi-org-9532 499 49 the the DT doi-org-9532 499 50 sense sense NN doi-org-9532 499 51 of of IN doi-org-9532 499 52 moral moral JJ doi-org-9532 499 53 superiority superiority NN doi-org-9532 499 54 sometimes sometimes RB doi-org-9532 499 55 associated associate VBN doi-org-9532 499 56 with with IN doi-org-9532 499 57 the the DT doi-org-9532 499 58 profession profession NN doi-org-9532 499 59 of of IN doi-org-9532 499 60 librarianship librarianship NN doi-org-9532 499 61 . . . doi-org-9532 500 1 57 57 CD doi-org-9532 500 2 . . . doi-org-9532 501 1 For for IN doi-org-9532 501 2 an an DT doi-org-9532 501 3 economic economic JJ doi-org-9532 501 4 / / SYM doi-org-9532 501 5 political political JJ doi-org-9532 501 6 analysis analysis NN doi-org-9532 501 7 that that WDT doi-org-9532 501 8 comes come VBZ doi-org-9532 501 9 closest close JJS doi-org-9532 501 10 to to IN doi-org-9532 501 11 my -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 501 12 current current JJ doi-org-9532 501 13 views view NNS doi-org-9532 501 14 on on IN doi-org-9532 501 15 these these DT doi-org-9532 501 16 questions question NNS doi-org-9532 501 17 , , , doi-org-9532 501 18 see see VB doi-org-9532 501 19 Robert Robert NNP doi-org-9532 501 20 Kuttner Kuttner NNP doi-org-9532 501 21 , , , doi-org-9532 501 22 Can Can MD doi-org-9532 501 23 Democracy democracy NN doi-org-9532 501 24 Survive survive VB doi-org-9532 501 25 Global global JJ doi-org-9532 501 26 Capitalism capitalism NN doi-org-9532 501 27 ? ? . doi-org-9532 502 1 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 502 2 New New NNP doi-org-9532 502 3 York York NNP doi-org-9532 502 4 : : : doi-org-9532 502 5 Norton Norton NNP doi-org-9532 502 6 , , , doi-org-9532 502 7 2018 2018 CD doi-org-9532 502 8 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 502 9 , , , doi-org-9532 502 10 especially especially RB doi-org-9532 502 11 chapter chapter NN doi-org-9532 502 12 11 11 CD doi-org-9532 502 13 , , , doi-org-9532 502 14 " " `` doi-org-9532 502 15 Liberalism Liberalism NNP doi-org-9532 502 16 , , , doi-org-9532 502 17 Populism Populism NNP doi-org-9532 502 18 , , , doi-org-9532 502 19 Fascism Fascism NNP doi-org-9532 502 20 . . . doi-org-9532 502 21 " " '' doi-org-9532 503 1 Copyright copyright NN doi-org-9532 503 2 © © NNP doi-org-9532 503 3 2019 2019 CD doi-org-9532 503 4 Johns Johns NNP doi-org-9532 503 5 Hopkins Hopkins NNP doi-org-9532 503 6 University University NNP doi-org-9532 503 7 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 503 8 Previous Previous NNP doi-org-9532 503 9 Article Article NNP doi-org-9532 503 10 Crafting Crafting NNP doi-org-9532 503 11 Competencies Competencies NNPS doi-org-9532 503 12 , , , doi-org-9532 503 13 Creating create VBG doi-org-9532 503 14 Culture culture NN doi-org-9532 503 15 : : : doi-org-9532 503 16 Using use VBG doi-org-9532 503 17 Core core NN doi-org-9532 503 18 Competencies competency NNS doi-org-9532 503 19 to to IN doi-org-9532 503 20 Navigate navigate VB doi-org-9532 503 21 Departmental Departmental NNP doi-org-9532 503 22 Mergers merger NNS doi-org-9532 503 23 Next next IN doi-org-9532 503 24 Article Article NNP doi-org-9532 503 25 Addressing address VBG doi-org-9532 503 26 the the DT doi-org-9532 503 27 Technical technical JJ doi-org-9532 503 28 Challenges Challenges NNPS doi-org-9532 503 29 of of IN doi-org-9532 503 30 Open open JJ doi-org-9532 503 31 Educational educational JJ doi-org-9532 503 32 Resources resource NNS doi-org-9532 503 33 Recommend recommend VBP doi-org-9532 503 34 Additional Additional NNP doi-org-9532 503 35 Information Information NNP doi-org-9532 503 36 ISSN ISSN NNP doi-org-9532 503 37 1530 1530 CD doi-org-9532 503 38 - - SYM doi-org-9532 503 39 7131 7131 CD doi-org-9532 503 40 Print Print NNP doi-org-9532 503 41 ISSN ISSN NNP doi-org-9532 503 42 1531 1531 CD doi-org-9532 503 43 - - SYM doi-org-9532 503 44 2542 2542 CD doi-org-9532 503 45 Pages Pages NNP doi-org-9532 503 46 55 55 CD doi-org-9532 503 47 - - SYM doi-org-9532 503 48 78 78 CD doi-org-9532 503 49 Launched launch VBN doi-org-9532 503 50 on on IN doi-org-9532 503 51 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 503 52 2019 2019 CD doi-org-9532 503 53 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 503 54 01 01 CD doi-org-9532 503 55 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 503 56 29 29 CD doi-org-9532 503 57 Open open JJ doi-org-9532 503 58 Access access NN doi-org-9532 503 59 No No NNP doi-org-9532 503 60 Project Project NNP doi-org-9532 503 61 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 503 62 Mission Mission NNP doi-org-9532 503 63 Project Project NNP doi-org-9532 503 64 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 503 65 promotes promote VBZ doi-org-9532 503 66 the the DT doi-org-9532 503 67 creation creation NN doi-org-9532 503 68 and and CC doi-org-9532 503 69 dissemination dissemination NN doi-org-9532 503 70 of of IN doi-org-9532 503 71 essential essential JJ doi-org-9532 503 72 humanities humanity NNS doi-org-9532 503 73 and and CC doi-org-9532 503 74 social social JJ doi-org-9532 503 75 science science NN doi-org-9532 503 76 resources resource NNS doi-org-9532 503 77 through through IN doi-org-9532 503 78 collaboration collaboration NN doi-org-9532 503 79 with with IN doi-org-9532 503 80 libraries library NNS doi-org-9532 503 81 , , , doi-org-9532 503 82 publishers publisher NNS doi-org-9532 503 83 , , , doi-org-9532 503 84 and and CC doi-org-9532 503 85 scholars scholar NNS doi-org-9532 503 86 worldwide worldwide RB doi-org-9532 503 87 . . . doi-org-9532 504 1 Forged forge VBN doi-org-9532 504 2 from from IN doi-org-9532 504 3 a a DT doi-org-9532 504 4 partnership partnership NN doi-org-9532 504 5 between between IN doi-org-9532 504 6 a a DT doi-org-9532 504 7 university university NN doi-org-9532 504 8 press press NN doi-org-9532 504 9 and and CC doi-org-9532 504 10 a a DT doi-org-9532 504 11 library library NN doi-org-9532 504 12 , , , doi-org-9532 504 13 Project Project NNP doi-org-9532 504 14 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 504 15 is be VBZ doi-org-9532 504 16 a a DT doi-org-9532 504 17 trusted trusted JJ doi-org-9532 504 18 part part NN doi-org-9532 504 19 of of IN doi-org-9532 504 20 the the DT doi-org-9532 504 21 academic academic JJ doi-org-9532 504 22 and and CC doi-org-9532 504 23 scholarly scholarly JJ doi-org-9532 504 24 community community NN doi-org-9532 504 25 it -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 504 26 serves serve VBZ doi-org-9532 504 27 . . . doi-org-9532 505 1 about about IN doi-org-9532 505 2 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 505 3 Story Story NNP doi-org-9532 505 4 Publishers Publishers NNPS doi-org-9532 505 5 Discovery Discovery NNP doi-org-9532 505 6 Partners Partners NNPS doi-org-9532 505 7 Advisory Advisory NNP doi-org-9532 505 8 Board Board NNP doi-org-9532 505 9 Journal Journal NNP doi-org-9532 505 10 Subscribers Subscribers NNP doi-org-9532 505 11 Book Book NNP doi-org-9532 505 12 Customers Customers NNPS doi-org-9532 505 13 Conferences conference VBZ doi-org-9532 505 14 what what WP doi-org-9532 505 15 's be VBZ doi-org-9532 505 16 on on IN doi-org-9532 505 17 muse muse NN doi-org-9532 505 18 Open Open NNP doi-org-9532 505 19 Access Access NNP doi-org-9532 505 20 Journals Journals NNPS doi-org-9532 505 21 Books Books NNPS doi-org-9532 505 22 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 505 23 in in IN doi-org-9532 505 24 Focus Focus NNP doi-org-9532 505 25 T.S. T.S. NNP doi-org-9532 506 1 Eliot Eliot NNP doi-org-9532 506 2 Prose Prose NNP doi-org-9532 506 3 resources resources NNPS doi-org-9532 506 4 News News NNP doi-org-9532 506 5 & & CC doi-org-9532 506 6 Announcements Announcements NNP doi-org-9532 506 7 Promotional Promotional NNP doi-org-9532 506 8 Material Material NNP doi-org-9532 506 9 Get get VBP doi-org-9532 506 10 Alerts alert NNS doi-org-9532 506 11 Presentations Presentations NNPS doi-org-9532 506 12 information information NN doi-org-9532 506 13 for for IN doi-org-9532 506 14 Publishers Publishers NNPS doi-org-9532 506 15 Librarians Librarians NNPS doi-org-9532 506 16 Individuals Individuals NNPS doi-org-9532 506 17 Instructors Instructors NNPS doi-org-9532 506 18 Contact contact NN doi-org-9532 506 19 Contact contact NN doi-org-9532 506 20 Us -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 506 21 Help Help NNP doi-org-9532 506 22 Policy policy NN doi-org-9532 506 23 & & CC doi-org-9532 506 24 Terms term NNS doi-org-9532 506 25 Accessibility Accessibility NNP doi-org-9532 506 26 Privacy Privacy NNP doi-org-9532 506 27 Policy Policy NNP doi-org-9532 506 28 Terms term NNS doi-org-9532 506 29 of of IN doi-org-9532 506 30 Use Use NNP doi-org-9532 506 31 2715 2715 CD doi-org-9532 506 32 North North NNP doi-org-9532 506 33 Charles Charles NNP doi-org-9532 506 34 Street Street NNP doi-org-9532 506 35 Baltimore Baltimore NNP doi-org-9532 506 36 , , , doi-org-9532 506 37 Maryland Maryland NNP doi-org-9532 506 38 , , , doi-org-9532 506 39 USA USA NNP doi-org-9532 506 40 21218 21218 CD doi-org-9532 506 41 +1 +1 SYM doi-org-9532 506 42 ( ( -LRB- doi-org-9532 506 43 410 410 CD doi-org-9532 506 44 ) ) -RRB- doi-org-9532 506 45 516 516 CD doi-org-9532 506 46 - - HYPH doi-org-9532 506 47 6989 6989 CD doi-org-9532 506 48 muse@press.jhu.edu muse@press.jhu.edu NN doi-org-9532 506 49 © © NNP doi-org-9532 506 50 2020 2020 CD doi-org-9532 506 51 Project Project NNP doi-org-9532 506 52 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 506 53 . . . doi-org-9532 507 1 Produced produce VBN doi-org-9532 507 2 by by IN doi-org-9532 507 3 Johns Johns NNP doi-org-9532 507 4 Hopkins Hopkins NNP doi-org-9532 507 5 University University NNP doi-org-9532 507 6 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 507 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 507 8 collaboration collaboration NN doi-org-9532 507 9 with with IN doi-org-9532 507 10 The the DT doi-org-9532 507 11 Sheridan Sheridan NNP doi-org-9532 507 12 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 507 13 . . . doi-org-9532 508 1 Now now RB doi-org-9532 508 2 and and CC doi-org-9532 508 3 Always always RB doi-org-9532 508 4 , , , doi-org-9532 508 5 The the DT doi-org-9532 508 6 Trusted Trusted NNP doi-org-9532 508 7 Content Content NNP doi-org-9532 508 8 Your -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 508 9 Research research NN doi-org-9532 508 10 Requires require VBZ doi-org-9532 508 11 Now now RB doi-org-9532 508 12 and and CC doi-org-9532 508 13 Always always RB doi-org-9532 508 14 , , , doi-org-9532 508 15 The the DT doi-org-9532 508 16 Trusted Trusted NNP doi-org-9532 508 17 Content Content NNP doi-org-9532 508 18 Your -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 508 19 Research research NN doi-org-9532 508 20 Requires require VBZ doi-org-9532 508 21 Built build VBN doi-org-9532 508 22 on on IN doi-org-9532 508 23 the the DT doi-org-9532 508 24 Johns Johns NNP doi-org-9532 508 25 Hopkins Hopkins NNP doi-org-9532 508 26 University University NNP doi-org-9532 508 27 Campus Campus NNP doi-org-9532 508 28 Built build VBN doi-org-9532 508 29 on on IN doi-org-9532 508 30 the the DT doi-org-9532 508 31 Johns Johns NNP doi-org-9532 508 32 Hopkins Hopkins NNP doi-org-9532 508 33 University University NNP doi-org-9532 508 34 Campus Campus NNP doi-org-9532 508 35 © © NNP doi-org-9532 508 36 2020 2020 CD doi-org-9532 508 37 Project Project NNP doi-org-9532 508 38 MUSE MUSE NNP doi-org-9532 508 39 . . . doi-org-9532 509 1 Produced produce VBN doi-org-9532 509 2 by by IN doi-org-9532 509 3 Johns Johns NNP doi-org-9532 509 4 Hopkins Hopkins NNP doi-org-9532 509 5 University University NNP doi-org-9532 509 6 Press Press NNP doi-org-9532 509 7 in in IN doi-org-9532 509 8 collaboration collaboration NN doi-org-9532 509 9 with with IN doi-org-9532 509 10 The the DT doi-org-9532 509 11 Sheridan Sheridan NNP doi-org-9532 509 12 Libraries Libraries NNPS doi-org-9532 509 13 . . . doi-org-9532 510 1 Back back RB doi-org-9532 510 2 To to IN doi-org-9532 510 3 Top Top NNP doi-org-9532 510 4 This this DT doi-org-9532 510 5 website website NN doi-org-9532 510 6 uses use VBZ doi-org-9532 510 7 cookies cookie NNS doi-org-9532 510 8 to to TO doi-org-9532 510 9 ensure ensure VB doi-org-9532 510 10 you -PRON- PRP doi-org-9532 510 11 get get VB doi-org-9532 510 12 the the DT doi-org-9532 510 13 best good JJS doi-org-9532 510 14 experience experience NN doi-org-9532 510 15 on on IN doi-org-9532 510 16 our -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 510 17 website website NN doi-org-9532 510 18 . . . doi-org-9532 511 1 Without without IN doi-org-9532 511 2 cookies cookie NNS doi-org-9532 511 3 your -PRON- PRP$ doi-org-9532 511 4 experience experience NN doi-org-9532 511 5 may may MD doi-org-9532 511 6 not not RB doi-org-9532 511 7 be be VB doi-org-9532 511 8 seamless seamless JJ doi-org-9532 511 9 . . .