id sid tid token lemma pos cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 1 key key JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 2 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 3 cord-023118-dwh70u29 cord-023118-dwh70u29 JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 4 authors author NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 5 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 6 Devereaux Devereaux NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 8 Mary Mary NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 9 title title NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 10 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 11 Moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 12 Judgments Judgments NNPS cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 13 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 14 Works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 16 Art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 17 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 18 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 19 Case Case NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 21 Narrative Narrative NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 22 Literature Literature NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 23 date date NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 24 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 25 2004 2004 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 26 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 27 01 01 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 28 - - SYM cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 29 30 30 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 30 journal journal NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 31 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 32 nan nan NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 33 DOI DOI NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 34 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 35 10.1111 10.1111 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 36 / / SYM cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 37 j.1540 j.1540 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 38 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 39 594x.2004.00130.x 594x.2004.00130.x CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 40 sha sha NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 1 41 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 2 1 5ceafe2f2da64728c31d1abede17a1b6ca64360b 5ceafe2f2da64728c31d1abede17a1b6ca64360b NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 2 2 doc_id doc_id CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 2 3 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 2 4 23118 23118 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 3 1 cord_uid cord_uid NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 3 2 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 4 1 dwh70u29 dwh70u29 NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 4 2 nan nan NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 1 Since since IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 2 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 3 least least JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 5 late late JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 6 1990s 1990 NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 8 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 9 wide wide JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 10 range range NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 12 contemporary contemporary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 13 philosophers philosopher NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 15 aestheticians aesthetician NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 17 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 18 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 19 theorists theorist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 22 arts art NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 23 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 24 embraced embrace VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 25 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 26 once once RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 27 heretical heretical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 28 practice practice NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 29 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 30 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 31 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 5 32 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 6 1 1 1 LS cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 3 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 4 uncommon uncommon JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 5 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 6 find find VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 7 one one PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 8 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 9 colleagues colleague NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 10 unabashedly unabashedly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 11 discussing discuss VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 13 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 14 content content NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 16 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 17 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 19 arguing argue VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 20 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 22 edifying edifying JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 23 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 24 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 25 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 26 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 27 general general JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 28 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 29 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 30 attempting attempt VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 31 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 32 find find VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 33 room room NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 34 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 35 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 36 content content NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 37 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 38 consequences consequence NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 39 under under IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 40 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 41 rubric rubric NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 42 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 43 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 44 aesthetic aesthetic NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 7 45 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 1 Not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 2 everyone everyone NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 3 thinks think VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 4 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 5 turn turn NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 6 toward toward IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 8 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 9 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 10 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 11 thing thing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 8 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 1 Academic academic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 2 journals journal NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 3 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 4 conference conference NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 5 programs program NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 6 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 7 alive alive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 8 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 9 disputes dispute NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 10 over over IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 11 whether whether IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 12 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 13 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 14 really really RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 15 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 16 make make VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 17 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 18 better well JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 19 citizens citizen NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 20 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 21 kinder kind JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 22 people people NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 23 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 24 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 25 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 26 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 28 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 29 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 30 whether whether IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 31 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 32 expression expression NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 33 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 34 morally morally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 35 objectionable objectionable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 36 views view NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 37 should should MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 38 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 39 regarded regard VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 40 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 41 marring mar VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 42 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 43 artistic artistic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 44 value value NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 45 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 46 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 47 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 48 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 49 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 50 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 51 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 52 what what WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 53 extent extent NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 54 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 55 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 56 any any DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 57 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 58 artists artist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 59 should should MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 60 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 61 held hold VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 62 responsible responsible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 63 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 64 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 65 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 66 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 67 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 68 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 69 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 70 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 71 on on RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 9 72 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 2 very very JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 3 existence existence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 5 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 6 debates debate NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 7 attests attest VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 8 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 10 status status NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 12 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 13 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 14 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 15 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 16 sanctioned sanction VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 17 topic topic NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 18 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 19 contemporary contemporary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 20 aesthetics aesthetic NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 10 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 1 These these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 2 debates debate NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 3 form form VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 5 background background NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 6 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 7 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 8 concerns concern NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 9 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 11 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 2 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 3 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 4 wish wish VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 5 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 6 pursue pursue VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 7 often often RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 8 goes go VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 9 unnoticed unnoticed JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 10 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 11 yet yet CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 12 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 13 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 14 fundamental fundamental JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 12 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 2 concerns concern VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 4 enterprise enterprise NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 6 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 7 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 8 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 9 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 13 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 1 My -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 2 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 4 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 5 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 6 What what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 7 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 8 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 9 doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 10 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 11 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 12 assign assign VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 13 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 14 values value NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 15 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 16 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 17 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 18 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 19 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 14 20 ? ? . cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 2 somewhat somewhat RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 3 different different JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 4 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 6 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 7 does do VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 8 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 9 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 10 come come VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 11 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 12 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 14 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 16 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 17 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 18 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 19 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 21 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 15 22 ? ? . cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 2 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 3 broad broad JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 4 sense sense NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 6 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 7 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 8 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 9 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 10 mean mean VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 16 11 ? ? . cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 2 exploring explore VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 3 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 4 general general JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 5 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 7 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 8 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 9 focus focus VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 10 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 11 written write VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 12 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 17 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 1 Literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 2 forms form NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 3 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 4 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 6 novel novel JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 7 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 8 short short JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 9 story story NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 10 provide provide VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 11 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 12 obvious obvious JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 13 starting starting NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 14 place place NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 15 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 16 inquiring inquire VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 17 into into IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 18 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 19 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 20 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 21 doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 22 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 23 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 24 bring bring VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 25 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 26 categories category NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 27 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 28 bear bear VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 29 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 30 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 31 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 32 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 33 more more RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 34 generally generally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 18 35 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 19 1 2 2 LS cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 1 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 2 Narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 3 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 6 after after RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 7 all all RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 9 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 10 fancy fancy JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 11 word word NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 12 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 20 13 story story NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 1 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 2 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 3 take take VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 4 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 5 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 6 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 7 datum datum NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 8 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 9 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 10 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 11 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 12 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 13 bad bad JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 15 right right JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 16 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 17 wrong wrong JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 19 harm harm NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 20 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 21 benefit benefit NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 22 tend tend VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 23 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 24 arise arise VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 25 naturally naturally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 26 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 28 context context NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 29 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 30 storytelling storytelling NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 21 31 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 1 Some some DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 2 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 3 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 4 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 5 say say VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 6 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 7 apply apply VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 8 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 9 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 10 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 11 forms form NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 12 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 13 fictional fictional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 14 film film NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 16 drama drama NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 18 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 19 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 20 painting painting NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 22 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 2 urge urge NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 4 make make VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 5 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 6 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 7 arises arise VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 8 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 9 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 10 response response NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 11 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 12 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 13 kinds kind NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 15 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 16 as as RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 17 well well RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 23 18 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 1 However however RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 4 feature feature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 6 visual visual JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 7 representation representation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 8 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 9 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 10 painting painting NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 11 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 12 film film NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 13 complicates complicate VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 14 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 15 cases case NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 16 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 17 ways way NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 18 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 19 require require VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 20 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 21 separate separate JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 22 analysis analysis NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 24 23 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 1 Similarly similarly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 3 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 5 element element NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 7 live live JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 8 performance performance NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 9 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 11 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 13 staged stage VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 14 drama drama NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 25 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 1 Hence hence RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 2 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 3 focal focal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 4 point point NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 5 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 6 remains remain VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 7 exclusively exclusively RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 8 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 10 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 11 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 13 works work VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 14 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 15 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 16 engage engage VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 17 through through IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 18 reading reading NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 26 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 2 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 4 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 5 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 6 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 7 doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 8 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 9 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 10 bring bring VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 11 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 12 categories category NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 13 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 14 bear bear VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 15 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 16 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 17 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 18 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 19 works work VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 20 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 21 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 22 should should MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 23 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 24 distinguished distinguish VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 25 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 26 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 27 number number NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 28 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 29 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 30 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 31 central central JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 32 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 33 discussion discussion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 34 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 35 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 36 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 27 37 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 1 These these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 2 include include VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 3 empirical empirical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 4 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 5 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 7 impact impact NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 9 reading reading NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 10 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 12 role role NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 15 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 16 imagination imagination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 17 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 18 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 19 behavior behavior NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 20 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 21 values value NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 22 ; ; , cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 23 normative normative JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 24 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 25 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 26 artistic artistic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 27 responsibility responsibility NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 28 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 29 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 30 kind kind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 31 noted note VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 32 above above RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 33 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 34 3 3 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 35 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 36 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 37 broader broad JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 38 relationship relationship NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 39 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 40 aesthetic aesthetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 41 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 42 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 43 values value NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 44 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 45 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 28 46 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 29 1 4 4 LS cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 1 Unlike unlike IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 2 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 3 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 6 issue issue NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 8 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 9 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 10 understand understand VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 12 content content NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 15 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 16 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 17 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 18 make make VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 20 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 21 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 22 short short JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 23 stories story NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 24 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 25 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 26 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 27 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 28 doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 29 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 30 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 31 make make VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 32 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 33 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 34 remains remain VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 35 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 36 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 37 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 38 most most JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 39 part part NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 40 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 41 unasked unasked JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 30 42 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 1 Perhaps perhaps RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 2 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 4 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 5 because because IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 6 defenders defender NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 7 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 8 critics critic NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 10 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 11 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 12 alike alike RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 13 tend tend VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 14 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 15 assume assume VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 16 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 17 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 18 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 19 functions function NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 20 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 21 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 22 contexts context NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 23 much much JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 24 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 25 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 26 same same JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 27 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 28 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 29 does do VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 30 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 31 ordinary ordinary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 32 life life NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 31 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 1 If if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 2 deeming deem VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 3 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 4 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 5 immoral immoral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 6 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 7 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 8 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 9 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 10 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 11 nothing nothing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 12 special special JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 14 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 15 requires require VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 16 no no DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 17 special special JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 18 analysis analysis NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 32 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 3 part part NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 5 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 6 contention contention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 8 however however RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 9 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 10 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 11 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 12 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 13 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 14 doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 15 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 16 making make VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 17 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 18 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 19 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 20 special special JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 21 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 22 requires require VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 23 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 24 separate separate JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 25 account account NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 33 26 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 2 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 3 follows follow VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 5 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 6 begin begin VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 7 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 8 clarifying clarify VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 9 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 10 motivating motivate VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 12 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 14 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 15 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 16 means mean VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 17 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 18 say say VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 20 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 21 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 22 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 23 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 24 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 25 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 26 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 27 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 28 immoral immoral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 29 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 30 edifying edifying JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 31 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 32 unedifying unedifying JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 33 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 34 ethically ethically RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 35 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 36 ir)responsible ir)responsible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 37 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 38 evil evil JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 39 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 40 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 41 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 42 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 43 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 44 on on RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 34 45 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 35 1 5 5 LS cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 2 then then RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 3 turn turn VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 4 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 6 task task NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 8 providing provide VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 9 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 10 framework framework NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 11 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 12 answering answer VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 13 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 14 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 36 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 1 To to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 2 anticipate anticipate VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 4 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 5 leading leading JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 6 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 8 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 9 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 10 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 11 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 12 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 13 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 14 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 15 best best RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 16 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 17 understood understand VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 18 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 20 context context NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 21 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 22 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 23 particular particular JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 24 conception conception NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 25 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 26 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 27 nature nature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 28 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 29 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 30 fiction fiction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 37 31 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 2 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 3 argue argue VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 4 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 5 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 6 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 7 short short JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 8 stories story NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 9 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 10 specific specific JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 11 features feature NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 12 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 13 elicit elicit VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 14 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 15 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 16 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 17 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 18 make make VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 20 activity activity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 21 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 22 making make VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 23 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 24 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 25 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 26 them -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 27 intelligible intelligible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 38 28 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 2 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 3 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 4 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 5 interest interest VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 6 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 7 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 8 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 9 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 10 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 11 take take VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 13 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 14 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 15 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 16 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 17 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 18 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 39 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 2 existence existence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 4 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 5 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 6 might may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 7 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 8 questioned question VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 40 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 41 1 6 6 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 1 One one PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 2 might may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 3 argue argue VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 4 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 5 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 6 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 7 appear appear VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 8 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 9 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 10 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 12 morality morality NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 14 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 15 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 16 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 18 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 19 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 20 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 21 Heart Heart NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 22 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 23 Darkness Darkness NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 24 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 25 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 26 Portrait Portrait NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 27 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 28 Dorian Dorian NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 29 Gray Gray NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 30 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 31 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 32 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 33 fact fact NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 34 really really RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 35 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 36 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 37 else else RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 42 38 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 43 1 Appearances appearance NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 43 2 deceive deceive VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 43 3 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 1 On on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 2 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 3 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 6 real real JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 7 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 9 evaluation evaluation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 10 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 11 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 12 engage engage VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 13 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 14 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 15 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 16 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 17 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 18 else else RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 20 typically typically RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 21 either either CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 22 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 23 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 24 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 25 characters character NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 26 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 27 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 28 motivations motivation NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 29 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 44 30 actions action NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 2 Kurtz Kurtz NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 4 Dorian Dorian NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 5 Gray Gray NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 6 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 8 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 10 implied implied JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 11 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 12 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 13 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 14 implied imply VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 15 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 16 attitude attitude NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 17 toward toward IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 19 characters character NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 20 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 22 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 23 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 24 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 25 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 26 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 27 real real JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 28 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 29 world world NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 30 beliefs belief NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 31 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 32 actions action NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 45 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 1 Another another DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 2 possibility possibility NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 4 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 6 real real JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 7 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 9 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 10 appraisal appraisal NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 11 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 13 actual actual JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 14 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 15 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 46 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 1 That that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 2 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 4 Conrad Conrad NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 5 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 6 actions action NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 7 qua qua VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 8 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 9 being being NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 10 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 11 either either CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 12 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 13 writing write VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 14 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 15 particular particular JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 16 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 17 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 18 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 19 doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 20 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 21 else else RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 22 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 23 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 24 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 25 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 26 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 27 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 28 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 29 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 30 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 31 mean mean VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 32 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 33 condemn condemn VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 47 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 2 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 3 of of RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 4 course course RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 5 often often RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 6 make make VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 7 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 8 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 9 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 10 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 11 they -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 12 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 14 course course RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 15 important important JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 48 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 1 My -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 2 claim claim NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 4 however however RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 6 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 7 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 8 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 10 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 11 kind kind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 12 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 13 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 14 exhaust exhaust VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 15 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 16 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 49 17 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 1 Ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 2 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 3 also also RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 4 involves involve VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 5 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 6 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 7 class class NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 9 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 10 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 11 nar nar NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 12 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 13 ratives rative VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 14 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 16 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 17 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 18 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 19 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 20 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 21 reduced reduce VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 22 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 23 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 24 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 25 authors author NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 26 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 27 characters character NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 28 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 29 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 30 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 50 31 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 3 also also RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 4 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 5 contention contention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 6 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 7 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 8 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 9 play play VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 10 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 11 crucial crucial JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 12 role role NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 13 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 14 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 15 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 51 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 2 support support NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 4 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 5 latter latter JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 6 claim claim NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 8 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 9 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 10 help help VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 11 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 12 examine examine VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 14 nature nature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 16 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 17 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 52 18 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 53 1 Consider consider VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 53 2 three three CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 53 3 examples example NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 53 4 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 54 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 54 2 1 1 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 54 3 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 55 1 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 1 And and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 2 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 3 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 4 poet poet NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 5 writes write VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 8 sufferings suffering NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 10 Niobe Niobe NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 56 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 1 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 2 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 4 Trojan Trojan NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 5 war war NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 6 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 7 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 8 any any DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 9 similar similar JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 10 theme theme NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 57 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 2 that that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 4 they -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 5 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 7 God God NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 8 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 58 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 1 such such PDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 2 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 3 fiction fiction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 5 suicidal suicidal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 7 ruinous ruinous JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 9 impious impious JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 59 11 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 60 1 7 7 LS cord-023118-dwh70u29 60 2 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 60 3 2 2 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 60 4 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 1 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 2 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 3 's be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 4 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 5 just just RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 7 word word NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 8 ' ' `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 9 nigger nigger NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 10 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 11 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 12 'm be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 13 objecting object VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 14 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 16 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 17 's be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 19 whole whole JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 20 range range NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 21 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 22 assumptions assumption NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 23 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 24 slavery slavery NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 25 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 26 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 27 consequences consequence NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 28 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 29 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 30 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 31 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 32 whites white NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 33 should should MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 34 deal deal VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 35 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 36 liberated liberated JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 37 slaves slave NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 38 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 39 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 40 liberated liberated JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 41 slaves slave NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 42 should should MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 43 behave behave VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 44 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 45 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 46 behave behave VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 47 toward toward IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 48 whites white NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 49 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 50 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 61 51 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 1 That that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 2 book book NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 3 [ [ -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 4 Huckleberry Huckleberry NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 5 Finn Finn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 6 ] ] -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 8 just just RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 9 bad bad JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 10 education education NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 12 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 14 fact fact NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 15 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 16 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 17 's be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 18 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 19 cleverly cleverly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 20 written write VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 21 makes make VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 22 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 23 even even RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 24 more more RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 25 troublesome troublesome JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 62 26 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 63 1 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 64 1 8 8 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 64 2 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 64 3 3 3 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 64 4 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 1 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 2 Nabokov Nabokov NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 3 has have VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 5 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 7 person person NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 9 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 10 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 12 completely completely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 13 bamboozled bamboozle VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 14 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 15 habitual habitual JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 16 reactions reaction NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 17 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 18 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 19 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 20 evil evil NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 21 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 22 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 23 ugly ugly JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 24 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 25 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 26 beautiful beautiful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 65 27 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 1 Lolita Lolita NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 3 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 4 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 6 aesthetic aesthetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 7 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 8 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 9 trespasses trespass NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 66 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 67 1 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 68 1 9 9 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 2 first first JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 3 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 5 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 6 most most JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 7 readers reader NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 8 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 9 recognize recognize VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 10 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 11 comes come VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 12 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 13 Socrates Socrates NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 14 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 15 Book Book NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 16 II II NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 18 Plato Plato NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 19 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 20 Republic Republic NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 69 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 2 second second JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 4 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 5 instance instance NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 7 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 8 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 9 cited cite VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 10 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 11 Wayne Wayne NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 12 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 13 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 14 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 15 discussion discussion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 16 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 17 Huckleberry Huckleberry NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 18 Finn Finn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 70 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 2 third third JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 3 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 4 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 5 take take VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 6 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 7 Colin Colin NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 8 McGinn McGinn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 9 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 10 discussion discussion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 12 Lolita Lolita NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 13 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 14 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 15 Ethics Ethics NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 17 Evil Evil NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 19 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 20 Fiction Fiction NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 71 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 2 want want VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 4 bracket bracket VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 6 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 9 truth truth NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 10 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 11 falsity falsity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 13 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 14 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 15 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 16 look look VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 17 instead instead RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 18 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 19 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 20 structure structure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 72 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 73 1 What what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 73 2 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 73 3 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 73 4 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 73 5 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 73 6 ? ? . cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 3 first first JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 4 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 6 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 7 find find VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 8 Socrates Socrates NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 9 laying lay VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 10 out out RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 11 rules rule NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 12 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 13 precepts precept NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 14 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 15 which which WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 17 poets poet NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 18 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 20 just just JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 21 city city NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 22 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 23 meant mean VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 24 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 25 conform conform VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 74 26 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 2 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 4 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 5 disapprobation disapprobation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 6 appears appear VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 7 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 8 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 9 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 10 certain certain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 11 group group NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 13 poets poet NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 75 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 1 Those those DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 2 who who WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 3 write write VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 4 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 5 misrepresenting misrepresent VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 7 gods god NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 8 deserve deserve VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 9 condemnation condemnation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 10 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 11 even even RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 12 banishment banishment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 76 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 3 second second JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 4 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 6 talk talk NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 9 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 10 bad bad JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 11 education education NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 12 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 13 likely likely JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 14 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 15 result result VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 16 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 17 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 18 assigned assigned JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 19 reading reading NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 21 Huckleberry Huckleberry NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 22 Finn Finn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 23 leads lead VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 24 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 25 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 26 see see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 28 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 29 involved involve VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 30 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 31 directed direct VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 32 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 33 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 34 book book NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 35 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 36 consequences consequence NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 77 37 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 1 Here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 2 Twain Twain NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 3 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 4 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 5 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 6 treated treat VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 7 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 8 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 9 causal causal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 10 agent agent NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 11 much much RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 12 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 13 one one PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 14 might may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 15 regard regard VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 16 HIV HIV NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 17 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 19 SARS SARS NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 20 virus virus NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 21 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 22 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 23 causal causal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 24 agent agent NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 78 25 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 79 1 10 10 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 3 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 4 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 5 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 7 undergraduate undergraduate JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 8 reader reader NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 9 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 10 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 11 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 12 colleague colleague NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 13 finds find VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 14 unsupportable unsupportable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 80 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 3 final final JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 4 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 6 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 7 see see VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 8 McGinn McGinn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 9 making make VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 10 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 11 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 12 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 13 easily easily RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 14 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 15 read read VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 16 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 17 directed direct VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 18 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 19 Nabokov Nabokov NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 20 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 22 real real JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 23 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 24 life life NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 25 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 26 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 27 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 28 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 29 fictional fictional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 30 creation creation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 31 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 32 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 33 character character NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 34 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 35 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 81 36 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 4 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 5 Nabokov Nabokov NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 6 who who WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 7 has have VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 8 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 9 bamboozled bamboozle VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 10 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 11 habitual habitual JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 12 reactions reaction NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 13 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 14 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 15 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 16 evil evil NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 18 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 19 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 20 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 21 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 22 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 23 character character NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 24 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 25 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 26 who who WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 27 brings bring VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 28 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 29 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 30 bamboozlement bamboozlement NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 31 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 32 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 33 life life NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 82 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 83 1 11 11 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 1 One one PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 2 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 3 see see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 4 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 5 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 6 each each DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 8 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 9 instances instance NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 10 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 12 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 13 involved involve VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 14 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 15 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 16 read read VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 17 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 18 being be VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 19 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 20 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 21 being be VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 22 reducible reducible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 23 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 24 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 25 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 26 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 27 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 28 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 29 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 30 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 31 than than IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 32 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 33 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 34 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 35 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 84 36 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 1 Let let VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 2 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 3 look look VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 4 again again RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 5 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 7 three three CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 8 examples example NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 9 before before IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 10 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 85 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 3 first first JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 4 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 6 notice notice VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 7 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 9 while while IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 10 Socrates Socrates NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 11 addresses address VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 13 actions action NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 16 poets poet NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 18 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 19 he -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 20 deems deem VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 21 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 22 ruinous ruinous JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 23 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 24 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 25 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 26 impious impious JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 27 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 28 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 29 any any DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 30 poetry poetry NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 31 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 32 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 33 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 34 fiction fiction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 35 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 36 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 37 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 38 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 39 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 40 Homer Homer NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 41 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 42 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 43 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 44 attributes attribute VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 45 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 46 fall fall NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 47 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 48 Troy Troy NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 49 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 50 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 51 sufferings suffering NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 52 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 53 men man NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 54 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 55 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 56 gods god NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 86 57 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 1 His -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 2 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 4 aimed aim VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 5 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 6 merely merely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 7 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 9 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 10 character character NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 13 poets poet NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 15 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 16 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 17 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 18 impiety impiety NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 20 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 21 poetry poetry NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 22 they -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 23 produce produce VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 87 24 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 3 second second JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 4 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 6 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 7 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 8 outraged outraged JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 9 colleague colleague NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 10 directs direct VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 11 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 12 remarks remark NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 13 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 14 merely merely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 15 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 17 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 18 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 19 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 20 Huckleberry Huckleberry NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 21 Finn Finn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 22 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 23 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 24 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 25 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 26 that that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 27 book book NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 28 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 29 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 31 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 32 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 33 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 34 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 35 cleverly cleverly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 36 written write VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 37 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 38 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 39 Mark Mark NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 40 Twain Twain NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 88 41 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 3 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 4 book book NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 5 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 6 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 7 held hold VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 8 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 9 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 10 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 11 bad bad JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 89 13 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 3 last last JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 4 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 6 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 7 careful careful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 8 reading reading NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 10 McGinn McGinn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 11 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 12 remarks remark NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 13 reveals reveal VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 14 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 15 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 16 discussion discussion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 18 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 19 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 20 character character NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 21 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 22 meant mean VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 23 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 24 support support VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 25 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 26 conclusion conclusion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 27 directed direct VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 28 fundamentally fundamentally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 29 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 31 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 32 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 33 Lolita Lolita NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 90 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 4 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 5 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 6 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 7 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 8 aesthetic aesthetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 9 trespass trespass NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 10 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 11 occupies occupy VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 12 McGinn McGinn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 13 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 91 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 92 1 12 12 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 1 To to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 2 suggest suggest VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 3 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 4 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 5 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 6 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 7 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 8 nothing nothing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 9 more more JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 10 than than IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 11 authors author NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 13 characters character NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 15 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 16 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 17 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 18 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 20 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 21 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 22 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 23 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 24 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 25 miss miss VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 26 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 27 plain plain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 28 meaning meaning NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 29 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 31 sentences sentence NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 32 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 33 express express VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 34 them -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 93 35 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 1 One one CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 2 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 4 begin begin VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 5 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 6 get get VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 7 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 8 handle handle NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 9 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 11 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 13 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 14 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 16 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 17 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 18 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 19 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 20 analogy analogy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 94 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 1 Moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 2 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 3 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 4 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 5 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 6 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 7 like like IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 8 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 9 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 10 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 11 actions action NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 12 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 95 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 2 analogy analogy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 3 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 5 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 6 two two CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 7 different different JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 8 kinds kind NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 10 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 96 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 1 Just just RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 2 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 3 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 4 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 5 evaluate evaluate VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 7 act act NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 9 breaking break VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 10 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 11 confidence confidence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 13 independent independent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 15 whether whether IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 16 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 17 perfidy perfidy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 18 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 19 discovered discover VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 20 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 21 independent independent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 22 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 23 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 24 harmful harmful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 25 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 26 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 27 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 28 too too RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 29 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 30 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 31 evaluate evaluate VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 32 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 33 morality morality NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 34 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 35 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 36 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 37 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 38 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 39 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 40 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 41 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 97 42 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 98 1 Moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 98 2 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 98 3 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 98 4 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 98 5 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 1 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 2 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 4 one one PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 5 might may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 6 say say VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 8 deontological deontological JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 99 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 1 Still still RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 4 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 5 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 6 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 7 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 8 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 9 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 11 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 12 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 13 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 14 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 15 remain remain VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 16 puzzling puzzling JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 100 17 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 1 Let let VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 2 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 3 try try VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 4 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 5 illustrate illustrate VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 6 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 7 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 8 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 9 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 101 10 mind mind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 1 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 2 why why WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 3 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 4 think think VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 5 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 6 important important JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 7 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 8 considering consider VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 9 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 10 fourth fourth JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 11 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 14 German german JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 15 writer writer NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 16 Bernard Bernard NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 17 Schlink Schlink NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 18 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 19 highly highly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 20 acclaimed acclaim VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 21 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 22 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 23 problematic problematic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 102 24 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 103 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 103 2 Reader Reader NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 103 3 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 104 1 13 13 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 1 Apart apart RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 2 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 3 any any DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 4 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 5 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 6 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 7 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 8 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 10 whom whom WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 11 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 12 know know VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 13 very very RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 14 little little JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 15 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 16 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 17 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 18 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 19 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 20 bad bad JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 21 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 22 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 23 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 24 German german JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 25 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 26 non non JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 27 - - JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 28 German german JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 29 readers reader NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 30 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 31 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 32 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 33 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 34 deeply deeply RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 35 offensive offensive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 105 36 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 1 Central central JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 2 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 4 story story NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 5 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 6 Hannah Hannah NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 8 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 9 rather rather RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 10 unlikable unlikable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 11 woman woman NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 12 who who WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 13 seduces seduce VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 15 then then RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 16 deceives deceive VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 17 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 18 abandons abandon VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 20 fifteen fifteen CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 21 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 22 year year NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 23 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 24 old old JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 25 narrator narrator NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 26 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 28 story story NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 106 29 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 1 Hannah Hannah NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 2 reappears reappear VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 3 years year NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 4 later later RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 6 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 7 trial trial NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 8 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 9 war war NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 10 crimes crime NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 11 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 12 e.g. e.g. RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 14 serving serve VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 15 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 16 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 17 guard guard NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 18 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 19 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 20 German german JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 21 concentration concentration NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 22 camp camp NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 23 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 24 refusing refuse VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 25 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 26 intervene intervene VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 27 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 28 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 29 church church NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 30 full full JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 31 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 32 women woman NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 33 prisoners prisoner NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 34 under under IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 35 her -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 36 care care NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 37 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 38 set set VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 39 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 40 fire fire NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 41 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 107 42 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 108 1 Hannah Hannah NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 108 2 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 108 3 crimes crime NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 108 4 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 108 5 horrible horrible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 108 6 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 109 1 But but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 109 2 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 109 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 109 4 full full JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 109 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 109 6 villains villain NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 109 7 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 1 Hannah Hannah NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 2 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 3 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 4 somewhat somewhat RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 5 worse bad JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 6 than than IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 7 some some DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 9 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 10 surely surely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 11 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 12 alone alone JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 13 among among IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 14 fictional fictional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 15 characters character NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 110 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 1 What what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 2 makes make VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 4 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 5 repugnant repugnant JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 6 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 7 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 9 among among IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 10 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 11 things thing NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 13 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 14 uses use VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 15 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 16 heroine heroine NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 17 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 18 illiteracy illiteracy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 19 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 20 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 21 fear fear NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 22 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 23 exposure exposure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 24 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 25 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 26 illiterate illiterate JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 27 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 28 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 29 only only RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 30 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 31 explain explain VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 32 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 33 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 34 also also RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 35 partially partially RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 36 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 37 excuse excuse VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 38 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 39 Hannah Hannah NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 40 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 41 crimes crime NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 111 42 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 2 personal personal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 3 shame shame NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 5 her -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 6 illiteracy illiteracy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 8 allowed allow VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 9 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 10 overshadow overshadow VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 11 larger large JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 12 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 13 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 14 political political JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 15 issues issue NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 16 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 17 ways way NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 18 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 19 seem seem VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 20 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 21 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 22 morally morally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 23 problematic problematic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 112 24 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 2 point point NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 3 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 5 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 6 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 8 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 9 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 10 characters character NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 11 behave behave VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 12 badly badly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 14 nor nor CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 15 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 16 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 17 narrator narrator NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 18 evidences evidence VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 19 considerable considerable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 20 complacency complacency NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 21 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 22 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 23 evil evil NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 113 24 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 1 Clearly clearly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 3 novelist novelist NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 4 might may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 5 have have VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 6 written write VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 7 such such PDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 8 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 9 story story NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 10 precisely precisely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 11 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 12 expose expose VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 14 immorality immorality NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 16 behavior behavior NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 17 like like IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 18 Hannah Hannah NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 19 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 20 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 22 self self NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 23 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 24 absorption absorption NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 25 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 26 her -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 27 heedless heedless JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 28 lover lover NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 114 29 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 1 This this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 3 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 5 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 6 think think VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 9 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 10 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 11 Schlink Schlink NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 12 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 13 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 115 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 1 As as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 2 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 3 read read VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 4 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 7 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 8 allows allow VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 10 individual individual JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 11 tragedy tragedy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 13 illiteracy illiteracy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 14 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 15 distort distort VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 17 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 18 terrain terrain NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 19 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 20 surveys survey VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 116 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 1 Let let VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 2 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 3 forget forget VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 4 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 5 ethics ethic NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 6 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 7 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 8 moment moment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 117 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 2 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 3 approach approach VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 5 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 6 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 7 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 8 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 9 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 10 doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 11 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 12 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 13 direct direct VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 14 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 15 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 16 attention attention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 17 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 19 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 20 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 21 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 22 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 23 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 24 asking ask VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 25 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 26 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 27 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 28 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 29 read read VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 30 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 31 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 118 32 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 1 This this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 3 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 4 complicated complicated JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 5 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 7 one one NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 8 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 9 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 10 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 11 address address VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 12 fully fully RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 13 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 119 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 1 But but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 2 even even RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 3 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 4 limited limited JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 5 discussion discussion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 8 nature nature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 11 activity activity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 13 reading reading NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 14 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 15 shed shed VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 16 light light NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 17 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 19 activity activity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 21 making make VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 22 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 23 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 24 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 25 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 120 26 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 1 When when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 3 read read VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 4 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 5 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 7 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 8 read read VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 9 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 10 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 11 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 12 particular particular JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 13 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 121 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 2 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 3 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 4 just just RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 5 take take VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 6 in in RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 8 words word NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 9 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 10 individual individual JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 11 incidents incident NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 122 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 2 typically typically RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 3 find find VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 4 ourselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 5 asking ask VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 6 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 7 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 8 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 9 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 10 going go VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 11 on on RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 12 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 13 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 14 why why WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 16 characters character NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 17 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 18 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 19 motives motive NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 20 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 21 presented present VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 22 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 23 they -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 24 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 25 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 26 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 28 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 29 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 30 point point NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 31 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 32 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 123 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 1 Thus thus RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 3 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 4 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 6 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 7 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 8 ask ask VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 9 what what WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 10 attitude attitude NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 11 Lolita Lolita NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 12 takes take VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 13 toward toward IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 14 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 15 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 16 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 17 pedophilia pedophilia NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 18 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 19 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 20 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 21 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 22 readers reader NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 23 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 24 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 25 make make VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 26 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 27 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 28 predilection predilection NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 29 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 30 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 31 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 32 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 33 meaning meaning NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 34 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 35 point point NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 36 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 37 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 38 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 124 39 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 1 This this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 3 part part NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 5 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 6 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 8 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 9 read read VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 10 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 11 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 12 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 13 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 14 story story NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 125 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 1 When when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 3 read read VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 4 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 6 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 7 read read VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 8 them -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 9 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 10 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 12 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 13 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 14 organized organize VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 15 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 16 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 17 certain certain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 18 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 126 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 2 read read VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 3 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 4 as as RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 5 organized organize VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 6 so so IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 7 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 8 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 9 allow allow VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 10 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 11 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 12 ask ask VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 13 certain certain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 14 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 127 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 1 And and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 2 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 3 see see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 4 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 5 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 6 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 7 organized organize VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 8 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 9 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 10 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 11 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 12 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 13 see see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 14 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 15 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 16 purposive purposive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 128 17 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 2 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 3 allows allow VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 4 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 5 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 6 ask ask VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 7 certain certain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 8 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 129 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 1 That that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 3 come come VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 4 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 5 ask ask VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 6 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 7 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 8 appears appear VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 9 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 10 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 11 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 12 least least JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 13 part part NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 16 purpose purpose NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 19 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 130 20 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 2 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 4 purposiveness purposiveness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 5 brings bring VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 6 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 7 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 9 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 11 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 12 agent agent NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 131 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 2 read read VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 4 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 5 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 6 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 7 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 8 has have VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 9 been be VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 10 designed design VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 11 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 12 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 13 interests interest NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 14 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 15 cognitive cognitive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 17 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 19 political political JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 20 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 21 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 22 mind mind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 132 23 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 1 Kant Kant NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 2 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 3 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 5 purposiveness purposiveness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 6 without without IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 7 purpose purpose NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 8 provides provide VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 9 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 10 model model NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 11 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 13 conception conception NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 15 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 16 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 17 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 18 developing develop VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 133 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 1 Kant Kant NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 2 speaks speak VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 4 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 5 seeing see VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 6 order order NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 7 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 8 arrangement arrangement NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 9 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 10 nature nature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 11 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 12 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 13 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 14 flower flower NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 15 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 16 bird bird NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 17 plumage plumage NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 18 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 134 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 2 sort sort NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 4 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 5 he -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 6 has have VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 7 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 8 mind mind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 9 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 10 one one CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 11 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 12 which which WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 13 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 14 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 15 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 16 able able JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 17 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 18 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 19 locate locate VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 20 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 21 causes cause NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 22 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 23 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 24 form form NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 25 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 26 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 27 will will NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 28 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 29 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 30 since since IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 31 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 32 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 33 no no DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 34 epistemological epistemological JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 35 access access NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 36 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 37 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 38 existence existence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 39 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 40 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 41 deity deity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 135 42 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 2 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 3 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 4 able able JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 5 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 6 render render VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 8 explanation explanation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 10 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 11 possibility possibility NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 12 intelligible intelligible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 13 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 14 ourselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 15 only only RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 16 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 17 deriving derive VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 18 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 19 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 20 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 21 will will NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 22 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 136 23 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 137 1 14 14 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 1 One one PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 2 also also RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 3 finds find VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 5 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 7 purposiveness purposiveness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 8 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 9 Hume Hume NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 138 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 2 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 3 Dialogues dialogue NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 4 Concerning concern VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 5 Natural Natural NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 6 Religion Religion NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 8 Cleanthes Cleanthes NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 9 elaborates elaborate VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 10 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 11 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 12 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 13 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 14 advancing advance VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 15 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 16 version version NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 19 argument argument NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 20 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 21 design design NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 22 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 139 23 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 1 Consider consider VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 3 anatomize anatomize VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 5 eye eye NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 7 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 8 he -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 9 directs direct VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 140 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 1 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 2 Survey survey VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 3 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 4 structure structure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 5 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 6 contrivance contrivance NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 7 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 8 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 9 tell tell VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 10 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 12 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 13 your -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 14 own own JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 15 feeling feeling NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 17 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 19 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 21 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 22 contriver contriver NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 23 does do VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 24 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 25 immediately immediately RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 26 flow flow VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 27 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 28 upon upon IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 29 you -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 30 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 31 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 32 force force NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 33 like like IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 34 that that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 35 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 36 sensation sensation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 37 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 141 38 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 142 1 15 15 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 1 Cleanthes Cleanthes NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 2 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 3 claim claim NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 4 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 5 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 6 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 8 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 9 Jerry Jerry NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 10 Sobel Sobel NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 11 points point VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 12 out out RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 14 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 16 intelligibility intelligibility NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 19 world world NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 20 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 21 expressible expressible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 22 only only RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 23 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 24 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 25 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 26 design design NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 28 that that RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 29 is is RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 30 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 31 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 32 intentional intentional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 33 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 143 35 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 144 1 16 16 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 145 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 145 2 same same JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 145 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 145 4 true true JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 145 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 145 6 written write VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 145 7 narratives narrative NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 145 8 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 146 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 146 2 read read VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 146 3 them -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 146 4 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 146 5 intentional intentional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 146 6 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 146 7 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 1 Indeed indeed RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 3 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 4 intelligibility intelligibility NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 5 rests rest VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 6 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 7 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 8 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 10 intentionality intentionality NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 147 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 1 As as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 2 Stanley Stanley NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 3 Cavell Cavell NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 4 maintains maintain VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 7 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 9 intentionality intentionality NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 10 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 11 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 12 inescapable inescapable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 13 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 14 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 15 speaking speaking NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 16 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 17 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 19 as as RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 20 inescapable inescapable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 21 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 22 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 23 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 24 talk talk NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 25 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 26 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 27 what what WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 28 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 29 beings being NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 30 say say VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 31 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 32 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 148 34 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 1 Absent absent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 3 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 5 intention intention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 7 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 8 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 9 would would MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 10 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 11 understand understand VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 12 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 13 they -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 14 [ [ -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 15 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 16 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 17 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 18 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 19 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 20 beings being NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 21 ] ] -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 22 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 23 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 149 24 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 150 1 17 17 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 2 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 4 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 5 creator creator NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 8 fact fact NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 10 having have VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 11 been be VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 12 created create VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 14 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 15 flows flow VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 16 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 17 upon upon IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 18 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 19 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 20 because because IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 21 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 22 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 23 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 24 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 25 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 26 speak speak VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 28 built build VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 29 into into IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 31 experience experience NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 32 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 33 looking look VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 34 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 35 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 36 understanding understanding NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 37 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 38 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 39 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 151 40 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 152 1 18 18 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 2 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 4 that that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 6 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 7 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 8 creator creator NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 9 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 10 intelligence intelligence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 11 presupposed presuppose VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 12 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 14 activity activity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 16 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 17 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 153 18 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 2 read read VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 3 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 4 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 5 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 6 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 7 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 8 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 9 were be VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 10 written write VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 11 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 12 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 13 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 14 who who WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 15 has have VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 16 produced produce VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 17 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 18 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 19 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 20 such such PDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 21 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 22 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 23 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 24 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 25 prompt prompt VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 26 certain certain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 27 questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 28 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 29 provide provide VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 31 resources resource NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 32 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 33 begin begin VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 34 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 35 answer answer VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 36 them -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 154 37 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 155 1 19 19 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 2 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 3 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 4 useful useful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 5 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 6 have have VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 7 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 8 term term NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 9 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 11 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 13 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 14 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 15 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 16 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 17 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 18 find find VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 20 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 21 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 22 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 23 creator creator NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 24 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 25 flowing flow VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 26 in in RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 27 upon upon IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 28 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 156 29 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 157 1 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 1 Let let VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 2 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 3 say say VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 4 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 5 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 6 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 7 posit posit VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 8 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 9 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 158 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 1 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 2 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 3 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 4 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 5 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 6 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 9 analogue analogue NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 11 Hume Hume NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 12 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 13 imagined imagine VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 14 contriver contriver NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 159 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 2 act act NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 4 positing posit VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 5 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 8 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 9 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 10 understand understand VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 11 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 13 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 14 best best RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 15 understood understand VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 16 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 17 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 18 kind kind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 20 logical logical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 21 act act NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 160 22 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 3 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 4 separate separate JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 5 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 6 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 7 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 9 act act NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 11 making make VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 12 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 13 presuppositions presupposition NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 14 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 15 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 16 under under IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 17 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 18 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 20 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 21 purposiveness purposiveness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 161 22 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 162 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 162 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 162 3 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 162 4 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 162 5 datable datable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 162 6 psychological psychological JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 162 7 event event NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 162 8 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 2 point point NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 4 that that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 5 simply simply RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 6 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 7 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 8 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 9 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 10 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 12 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 13 posit posit VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 14 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 15 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 163 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 1 Doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 2 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 4 intrinsic intrinsic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 5 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 7 structure structure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 9 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 10 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 164 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 165 1 20 20 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 2 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 5 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 8 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 9 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 10 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 11 number number NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 13 similar similar JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 14 concepts concept NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 15 standardly standardly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 16 employed employ VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 17 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 19 critical critical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 20 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 166 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 1 First first RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 4 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 7 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 8 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 9 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 10 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 11 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 13 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 16 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 17 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 167 18 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 2 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 3 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 6 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 8 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 9 Grass Grass NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 10 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 11 Singing singing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 13 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 15 real real JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 16 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 17 life life NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 18 person person NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 20 Doris Doris NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 21 Lessing Lessing NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 22 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 23 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 24 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 25 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 26 calling call VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 28 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 29 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 30 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 31 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 32 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 33 contrast contrast NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 34 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 35 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 36 interpretive interpretive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 37 construct construct NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 38 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 39 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 40 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 41 fiction fiction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 168 42 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 1 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 2 Its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 3 function function NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 5 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 6 allow allow VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 7 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 8 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 9 read read VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 11 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 12 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 13 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 14 certain certain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 15 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 17 that that RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 18 is is RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 20 under under IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 22 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 23 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 24 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 25 purposiveness purposiveness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 169 26 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 1 Access access NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 2 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 4 particular particular JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 5 features feature NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 8 given give VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 9 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 10 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 11 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 12 secured secure VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 13 through through IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 15 imagination imagination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 170 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 2 fact fact NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 3 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 4 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 5 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 6 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 7 thinking think VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 8 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 10 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 11 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 12 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 13 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 14 posit posit VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 15 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 16 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 17 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 18 marked mark VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 19 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 20 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 21 fact fact NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 22 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 23 claims claim VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 24 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 25 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 26 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 27 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 28 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 29 cast cast VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 30 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 31 claims claim NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 32 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 33 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 34 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 171 35 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 2 point point NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 3 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 4 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 5 put put VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 7 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 8 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 9 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 10 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 11 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 12 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 14 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 15 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 16 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 17 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 18 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 19 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 20 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 22 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 23 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 172 24 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 2 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 5 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 8 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 9 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 10 alternative alternative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 11 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 13 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 16 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 17 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 19 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 20 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 21 explication explication NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 22 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 23 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 24 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 25 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 26 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 173 27 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 1 Second second RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 4 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 7 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 8 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 9 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 10 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 11 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 13 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 16 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 17 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 18 fictional fictional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 19 narrator narrator NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 174 20 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 175 1 Narrators narrator NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 175 2 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 175 3 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 175 4 unreliable unreliable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 175 5 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 175 6 cf cf NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 175 7 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 1 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 2 purblind purblind NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 3 butler butler NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 4 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 5 Kazuo Kazuo NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 6 Ishiguro Ishiguro NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 7 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 8 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 9 Remains remain NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 12 Day day NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 13 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 176 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 1 They -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 2 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 3 espouse espouse VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 4 points point NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 6 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 8 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 9 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 10 rejects reject VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 11 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 12 criticizes criticize VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 177 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 2 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 3 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 5 narrator narrator NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 7 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 8 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 9 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 10 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 11 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 12 principle principle JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 13 share share VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 14 any any DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 15 number number NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 16 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 17 properties property NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 18 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 20 presumably presumably RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 21 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 22 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 24 normal normal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 25 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 26 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 27 there there EX cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 28 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 29 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 30 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 31 fair fair JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 32 amount amount NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 33 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 34 extensional extensional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 35 overlap overlap NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 178 36 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 179 1 But but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 179 2 overlap overlap VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 179 3 does do VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 179 4 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 179 5 identity identity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 179 6 yield yield VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 179 7 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 1 Even even RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 2 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 3 cases case NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 4 like like IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 5 Toni Toni NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 6 Morrison Morrison NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 7 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 8 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 9 Bluest Bluest NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 10 Eye Eye NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 12 where where WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 13 Claudia Claudia NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 14 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 15 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 16 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 17 reliable reliable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 18 narrator narrator NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 20 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 22 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 23 offers offer VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 24 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 25 broader broad JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 26 point point NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 27 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 28 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 29 than than IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 30 that that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 31 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 32 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 33 one one CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 34 character character NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 180 35 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 2 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 5 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 9 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 12 highest high JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 13 controlling control VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 14 intelligence intelligence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 17 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 181 18 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 2 think think VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 5 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 7 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 8 presenting present VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 9 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 10 character character NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 12 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 13 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 15 Claudia Claudia NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 17 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 19 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 22 reader reader NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 182 23 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 1 Lastly lastly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 3 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 4 most most RBS cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 5 importantly importantly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 8 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 11 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 12 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 13 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 14 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 15 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 17 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 18 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 19 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 20 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 21 implied imply VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 22 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 23 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 24 introduced introduce VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 25 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 26 Wayne Wayne NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 27 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 183 28 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 184 1 21 21 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 185 1 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 185 2 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 185 3 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 185 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 185 5 murky murky JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 185 6 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 2 places place NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 5 implied imply VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 7 appears appear VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 8 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 9 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 10 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 11 version version NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 14 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 15 himself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 16 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 17 herself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 19 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 20 self self NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 21 created create VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 22 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 24 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 25 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 26 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 27 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 28 persona persona NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 186 29 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 2 implied implied JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 3 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 6 self self NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 8 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 9 becomes become VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 10 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 11 become become VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 13 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 187 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 2 implied implied JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 3 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 6 wiser wise JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 8 wittier witty JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 9 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 10 more more RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 11 generous generous JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 12 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 13 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 14 perhaps perhaps RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 15 crueler cruel JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 17 more more RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 18 ambitious ambitious JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 20 unfaltering unfaltering JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 21 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 22 self self NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 24 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 25 imagines imagine VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 26 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 28 creation creation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 29 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 31 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 188 32 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 189 1 22 22 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 1 On on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 2 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 3 strand strand NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 5 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 6 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 7 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 10 implied imply VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 11 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 12 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 14 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 15 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 16 fictionalized fictionalized JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 17 rendition rendition NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 18 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 20 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 190 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 1 But but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 2 just just RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 3 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 5 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 8 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 9 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 11 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 14 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 15 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 17 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 18 too too RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 19 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 20 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 21 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 22 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 24 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 25 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 26 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 27 fictionalized fictionalized JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 28 version version NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 29 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 31 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 32 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 191 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 2 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 3 places place NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 5 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 6 implied imply VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 7 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 8 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 9 appears appear VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 10 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 11 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 12 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 13 name name NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 14 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 16 imagined imagine VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 17 personification personification NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 18 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 20 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 21 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 22 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 23 organizing organizing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 24 intelligence intelligence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 25 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 26 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 27 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 192 28 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 3 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 4 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 5 implied imply VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 7 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 8 who who WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 9 offers offer VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 10 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 11 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 12 friendship friendship NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 14 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 15 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 16 use use VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 17 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 18 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 19 metaphor metaphor NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 193 20 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 2 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 3 invites invite VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 5 promises promise NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 7 advises advise VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 9 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 10 gives give VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 11 pleasure pleasure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 194 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 1 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 2 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 3 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 4 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 5 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 6 very very RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 7 similar similar JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 8 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 9 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 10 own own JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 195 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 2 features feature NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 5 implied implied JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 7 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 9 features feature NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 12 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 13 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 14 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 15 bound bind VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 16 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 17 overlap overlap VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 18 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 19 places place NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 196 20 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 1 Still still RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 3 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 4 seems seem VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 5 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 6 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 7 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 9 two two CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 10 notions notion NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 11 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 12 distinct distinct JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 197 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 2 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 5 implied implied JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 7 brings bring VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 8 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 9 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 10 aspects aspect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 12 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 13 real real JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 14 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 15 life life NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 16 authors author NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 17 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 18 that that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 19 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 20 simply simply RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 21 absent absent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 22 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 24 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 25 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 26 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 27 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 28 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 198 29 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 2 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 5 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 8 more more RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 9 abstract abstract JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 199 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 2 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 5 implied imply VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 8 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 9 optional optional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 10 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 11 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 12 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 13 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 14 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 15 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 16 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 17 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 18 there there RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 20 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 21 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 22 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 23 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 24 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 25 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 26 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 27 found find VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 200 28 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 2 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 5 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 8 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 9 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 10 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 11 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 12 presupposition presupposition NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 14 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 15 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 16 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 201 17 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 1 To to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 2 read read VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 3 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 4 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 5 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 6 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 7 posit posit VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 8 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 9 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 202 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 2 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 5 implied imply VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 8 constructed construct VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 9 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 11 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 12 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 203 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 2 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 5 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 8 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 9 construct construct NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 12 reader reader NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 204 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 1 Thus thus RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 3 although although IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 4 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 5 think think VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 6 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 7 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 8 probably probably RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 9 does do VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 10 have have VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 12 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 15 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 16 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 19 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 20 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 21 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 22 captured capture VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 23 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 24 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 25 conception conception NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 26 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 28 implied implied JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 29 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 205 30 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 1 Though though IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 2 abstract abstract JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 5 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 8 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 9 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 10 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 11 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 12 empty empty JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 206 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 1 Questions question NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 2 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 4 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 5 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 6 allow allow VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 8 real real JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 9 discussion discussion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 207 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 2 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 3 ask ask VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 4 whether whether IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 6 proposals proposal NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 7 advanced advance VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 8 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 9 Swift Swift NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 10 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 11 A a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 12 Modest Modest NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 13 Proposal Proposal NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 14 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 15 ironic ironic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 16 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 17 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 18 meant mean VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 19 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 20 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 21 taken take VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 22 seriously seriously RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 208 23 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 1 23 23 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 2 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 3 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 4 dispute dispute VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 5 whether whether IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 6 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 7 Merchant Merchant NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 9 Venice Venice NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 10 criticizes criticize VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 12 endorses endorse VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 14 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 15 merely merely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 16 investigates investigate VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 17 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 18 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 20 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 21 payment payment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 22 embodied embody VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 23 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 24 Shylock Shylock NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 25 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 26 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 27 pound pound NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 28 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 29 flesh flesh NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 209 30 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 1 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 2 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 3 evidence evidence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 4 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 5 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 6 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 7 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 9 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 10 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 11 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 12 consist consist VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 13 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 14 texts text NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 15 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 17 reading reading NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 18 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 19 texts text NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 210 20 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 2 access access NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 3 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 5 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 6 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 8 secured secure VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 9 through through IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 11 act act NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 13 interpretation interpretation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 211 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 1 With with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 2 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 3 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 4 mind mind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 6 let let VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 7 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 8 reexamine reexamine VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 10 mindset mindset NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 11 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 12 which which WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 14 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 16 making make VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 17 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 18 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 20 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 21 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 22 appears appear VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 23 outlandish outlandish JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 212 24 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 1 When when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 3 raised raise VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 4 skeptical skeptical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 5 doubts doubt NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 6 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 8 meaningfulness meaningfulness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 10 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 11 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 12 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 13 texts text NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 14 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 16 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 17 were be VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 18 thinking think VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 20 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 21 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 22 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 23 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 24 book book NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 25 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 26 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 27 constituted constitute VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 28 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 29 ink ink NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 30 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 31 paper paper NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 32 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 33 glue glue NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 213 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 1 As as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 2 readers reader NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 4 however however RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 7 primary primary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 8 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 10 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 11 attention attention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 12 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 13 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 15 pages page NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 16 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 17 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 18 ink ink NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 19 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 20 paper paper NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 21 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 22 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 24 story story NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 214 25 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 1 To to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 2 make make VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 3 sense sense NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 5 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 6 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 7 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 8 must must MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 9 consider consider VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 11 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 12 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 14 standpoint standpoint NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 17 reader reader NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 215 18 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 1 Seen see VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 2 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 3 that that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 4 standpoint standpoint NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 7 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 8 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 9 becomes become VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 10 intelligible intelligible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 216 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 2 read read VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 3 under under IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 5 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 7 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 8 purposiveness purposiveness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 217 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 1 Positing posit VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 2 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 3 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 4 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 5 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 6 presupposition presupposition NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 8 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 9 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 218 10 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 1 Now now RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 2 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 3 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 4 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 5 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 6 basic basic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 7 grip grip NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 8 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 10 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 13 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 14 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 16 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 17 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 18 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 19 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 20 position position NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 21 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 22 look look VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 23 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 24 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 25 conception conception NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 26 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 28 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 29 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 30 goes go VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 31 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 32 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 219 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 2 conception conception NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 3 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 4 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 5 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 6 mind mind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 8 familiar familiar JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 9 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 10 traditional traditional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 220 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 1 Lionel Lionel NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 2 Trilling Trilling NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 3 draws draw VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 4 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 5 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 6 when when WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 7 he -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 8 observes observe VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 9 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 11 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 12 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 13 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 14 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 15 especially especially RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 16 useful useful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 17 agent agent NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 18 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 20 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 21 imagination imagination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 221 22 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 222 1 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 223 1 24 24 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 1 This this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 2 characterization characterization NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 5 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 6 sees see VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 8 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 9 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 10 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 11 kind kind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 13 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 14 tool tool NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 224 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 2 accentuates accentuate VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 4 capacity capacity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 7 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 8 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 9 reveal reveal VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 11 wide wide JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 12 range range NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 13 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 14 complexity complexity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 16 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 17 types type NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 18 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 19 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 20 development development NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 21 over over IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 22 time time NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 23 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 24 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 25 less less RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 26 easily easily RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 27 achieved achieve VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 28 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 29 less less RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 30 capacious capacious JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 31 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 32 forms form NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 33 like like IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 34 poetry poetry NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 35 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 36 short short JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 37 stories story NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 225 38 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 1 Iris Iris NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 2 Murdoch Murdoch NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 3 notably notably RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 4 develops develop VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 5 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 6 idea idea NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 8 describing describe VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 10 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 11 calm calm JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 12 merciful merciful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 13 vision vision NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 14 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 17 novelist novelist NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 19 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 20 vision vision NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 21 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 22 allows allow VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 24 reader reader NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 25 imaginative imaginative JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 26 access access NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 27 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 28 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 29 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 30 different different JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 31 people people NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 32 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 33 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 34 why why WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 35 they -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 36 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 37 different different JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 38 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 226 39 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 227 1 25 25 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 2 result result NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 4 Murdoch Murdoch NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 5 observes observe VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 8 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 10 breath breath NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 12 tolerance tolerance NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 13 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 14 generosity generosity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 15 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 16 intelligent intelligent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 17 kindness kindness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 18 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 19 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 20 great great JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 21 novelists novelist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 22 achieve achieve VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 228 23 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 1 On on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 2 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 3 traditional traditional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 4 conception conception NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 7 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 8 provides provide VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 10 possibility possibility NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 12 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 13 like like IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 14 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 15 education education NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 229 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 1 This this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 2 education education NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 3 takes take VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 4 place place NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 5 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 6 schooling school VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 8 imagination imagination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 9 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 10 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 11 Hume Hume NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 12 calls call VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 14 sentiments sentiment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 15 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 16 providing provide VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 17 means mean NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 18 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 19 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 20 reader reader NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 21 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 22 emotional emotional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 23 engagement engagement NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 24 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 25 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 26 centers center NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 27 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 28 reality reality NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 29 which which WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 30 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 31 remote remote JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 32 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 33 oneself oneself PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 230 35 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 231 1 26 26 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 1 So so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 2 understood understand VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 5 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 6 offers offer VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 8 possibility possibility NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 10 understanding understanding NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 12 empathy empathy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 14 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 15 tolerance tolerance NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 232 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 2 claim claim NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 3 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 5 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 6 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 8 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 9 least least JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 10 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 11 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 12 hands hand NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 14 allow allow VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 16 development development NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 18 imagination imagination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 20 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 21 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 22 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 23 well well RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 24 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 25 exercised exercise VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 26 imagination imagination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 27 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 28 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 29 turn turn VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 30 foster foster JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 31 virtues virtue NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 32 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 33 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 34 compassion compassion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 35 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 36 generosity generosity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 37 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 38 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 39 one one CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 40 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 41 many many JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 42 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 43 contemporary contemporary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 44 aestheticians aesthetician NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 45 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 46 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 47 theorists theorist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 48 wish wish VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 49 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 50 make make VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 233 51 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 234 1 27 27 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 1 On on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 2 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 3 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 6 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 8 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 9 inherently inherently RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 10 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 11 enterprise enterprise NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 235 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 2 adopting adopt VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 3 Trilling Trilling NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 4 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 5 conception conception NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 8 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 9 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 10 however however RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 12 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 13 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 14 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 15 assuming assume VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 16 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 17 all all DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 18 authors author NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 19 set set VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 20 out out RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 21 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 22 create create VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 23 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 24 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 25 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 26 engage engage VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 27 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 28 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 29 explicitly explicitly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 30 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 31 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 32 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 33 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 34 those those DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 35 who who WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 36 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 37 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 38 necessarily necessarily RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 39 succeed succeed VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 236 40 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 1 Still still RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 2 less less JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 3 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 4 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 5 suggesting suggest VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 6 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 7 novelists novelist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 8 ought ought MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 9 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 10 write write VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 11 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 13 purpose purpose NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 15 engaging engage VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 16 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 17 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 18 instruction instruction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 19 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 20 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 21 works work VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 22 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 23 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 24 must must MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 25 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 26 judged judge VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 28 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 29 whole whole JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 30 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 31 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 32 part part NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 33 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 34 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 35 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 36 success success NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 37 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 38 inculcating inculcate VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 39 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 40 virtue virtue NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 237 41 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 238 1 28 28 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 1 My -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 2 claim claim NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 4 rather rather RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 5 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 6 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 7 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 8 make make VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 9 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 10 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 11 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 12 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 13 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 14 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 15 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 16 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 17 activity activity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 18 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 19 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 20 shown show VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 21 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 22 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 23 intelligible intelligible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 239 24 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 1 As as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 3 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 4 seen see VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 7 approach approach NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 8 advocated advocate VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 9 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 10 allows allow VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 11 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 12 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 13 explain explain VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 14 claims claim NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 15 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 16 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 17 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 18 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 19 goodness goodness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 20 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 21 badness badness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 22 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 23 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 24 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 25 ordinary ordinary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 26 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 27 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 240 28 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 2 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 3 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 4 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 5 make make VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 8 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 9 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 10 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 11 posited posit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 12 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 13 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 14 parallel parallel VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 15 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 16 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 17 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 18 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 19 real real JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 20 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 21 agents agent NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 241 22 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 1 Seeing see VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 2 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 3 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 4 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 5 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 6 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 8 that that RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 9 is is RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 10 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 11 under under IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 13 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 15 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 16 purposiveness purposiveness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 18 turns turn VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 19 out out RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 20 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 21 have have VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 22 implications implication NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 23 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 24 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 25 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 26 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 27 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 28 do do VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 29 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 30 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 31 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 32 indeed indeed RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 33 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 34 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 35 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 36 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 37 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 38 do do VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 39 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 40 generally generally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 242 41 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 1 Let let VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 2 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 3 conclude conclude VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 4 then then RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 5 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 6 saying say VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 7 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 8 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 10 ramifications ramification NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 12 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 13 approach approach NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 243 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 2 too too RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 3 long long RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 5 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 6 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 7 faced face VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 8 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 9 interminable interminable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 10 debate debate NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 11 over over IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 13 legitimacy legitimacy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 15 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 16 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 244 17 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 1 Typically typically RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 2 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 3 dispute dispute NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 4 gets get VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 5 cast cast VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 6 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 7 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 9 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 10 opposition opposition NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 11 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 13 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 14 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 15 aesthetic aesthetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 16 dimensions dimension NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 18 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 245 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 1 Even even RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 2 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 4 best good JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 5 hands hand NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 7 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 8 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 9 exchanges exchange NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 10 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 11 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 12 topic topic NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 13 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 14 Martha Martha NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 15 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 16 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 17 Richard Richard NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 18 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 20 29 29 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 21 setting set VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 22 up up RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 24 problem problem NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 25 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 26 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 27 way way NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 28 does do VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 29 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 30 get get VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 31 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 32 very very RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 33 far far RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 246 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 2 opposition opposition NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 3 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 4 begins begin VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 5 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 6 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 7 false false JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 9 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 10 Murdoch Murdoch NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 11 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 12 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 13 number number NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 15 contemporary contemporary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 16 thinkers thinker NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 17 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 18 noted note VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 247 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 1 30 30 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 2 Let let VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 3 me -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 4 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 5 least least JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 6 briefly briefly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 7 indicate indicate VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 8 why why WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 9 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 10 point point VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 11 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 12 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 13 direction direction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 14 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 15 moving move VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 16 beyond beyond IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 17 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 18 framework framework NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 248 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 1 Take take VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 3 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 4 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 7 dispute dispute NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 8 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 9 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 10 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 11 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 249 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 1 31 31 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 2 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 3 rejects reject VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 5 legitimacy legitimacy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 7 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 8 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 250 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 251 1 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 251 2 endorses endorse VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 251 3 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 251 4 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 1 Despite despite IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 2 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 3 disagreement disagreement NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 5 both both DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 6 miss miss VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 7 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 8 crucial crucial JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 9 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 10 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 12 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 13 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 14 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 15 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 16 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 252 17 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 1 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 2 fails fail VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 4 understand understand VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 6 centrality centrality NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 9 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 10 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 11 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 13 particularly particularly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 14 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 16 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 19 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 20 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 21 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 22 form form NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 23 inescapably inescapably RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 24 concerned concerned JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 25 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 26 imagining imagine VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 27 lives life NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 28 better well RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 29 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 30 worse bad JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 31 than than IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 32 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 33 own own JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 34 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 35 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 36 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 37 focus focus NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 38 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 39 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 40 debate debate NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 41 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 42 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 43 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 253 44 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 2 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 5 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 6 dimension dimension NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 8 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 9 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 10 optional optional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 11 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 12 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 13 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 14 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 15 attend attend VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 16 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 17 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 18 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 254 19 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 1 Like like IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 2 most most JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 3 aestheticists aestheticist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 5 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 6 recommends recommend VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 8 latter latter JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 255 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 1 Ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 2 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 4 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 5 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 6 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 8 merely merely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 9 directs direct VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 10 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 11 attention attention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 12 away away RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 13 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 14 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 15 makes make VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 16 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 17 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 256 18 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 257 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 257 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 257 3 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 257 4 distraction distraction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 257 5 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 258 1 Why why WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 258 2 ? ? . cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 1 Because because IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 2 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 3 reduces reduce VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 4 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 5 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 6 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 7 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 8 pep pep NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 9 pills pill NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 10 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 11 32 32 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 12 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 13 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 14 call call NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 15 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 16 action action NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 259 17 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 1 Now now RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 2 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 4 surely surely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 5 right right JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 6 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 7 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 8 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 9 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 10 take take VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 11 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 12 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 13 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 15 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 16 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 17 realworld realworld JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 18 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 19 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 20 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 21 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 22 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 23 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 24 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 25 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 26 some some DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 27 cases case NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 28 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 29 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 30 turn turn VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 31 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 32 attention attention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 33 away away RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 34 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 35 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 36 stylistic stylistic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 37 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 38 structural structural JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 39 matters matter NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 40 central central JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 41 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 42 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 43 value value NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 44 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 45 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 260 46 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 261 1 Then then RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 261 2 again again RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 261 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 261 4 they -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 261 5 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 261 6 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 261 7 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 1 Moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 2 concern concern NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 3 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 5 fact fact NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 6 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 7 Nabokov Nabokov NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 8 manages manage VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 9 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 10 make make VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 12 pedophile pedophile NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 14 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 15 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 17 sympathetic sympathetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 18 need need NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 19 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 20 exclude exclude VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 21 attention attention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 22 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 23 Lolita Lolita NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 24 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 25 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 26 strategies strategy NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 27 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 28 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 29 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 30 contrary contrary NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 262 31 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 1 More more RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 2 importantly importantly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 4 however however RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 6 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 7 fails fail VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 8 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 9 recognize recognize VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 10 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 11 some some DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 12 kinds kind NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 14 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 15 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 17 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 18 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 19 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 20 argued argue VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 21 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 22 take take VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 23 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 24 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 25 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 26 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 27 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 28 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 29 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 263 30 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 2 More More JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 3 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 5 consequences consequence NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 7 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 8 oversight oversight NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 9 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 10 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 11 moment moment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 264 13 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 265 1 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 265 2 makes make VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 265 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 265 4 same same JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 265 5 mistake mistake NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 265 6 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 1 She -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 2 fails fail VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 4 recognize recognize VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 6 centrality centrality NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 9 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 10 standing standing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 13 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 14 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 16 locating locate VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 17 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 18 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 19 dimension dimension NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 21 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 22 too too RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 23 narrowly narrowly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 24 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 25 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 26 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 266 27 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 2 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 4 she -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 5 leaves leave VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 6 herself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 7 wide wide JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 8 open open JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 9 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 10 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 11 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 12 objection objection NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 13 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 15 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 16 her -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 17 hands hand NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 18 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 19 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 20 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 21 diminished diminish VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 22 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 23 reduced reduce VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 24 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 25 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 26 causal causal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 27 lever lever NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 28 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 29 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 30 world world NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 31 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 32 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 33 call call NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 34 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 35 action action NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 36 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 37 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 38 given give VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 39 political political JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 40 agenda agenda NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 267 41 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 268 1 33 33 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 1 Despite despite IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 2 nuanced nuanced JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 3 attention attention NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 4 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 5 language language NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 6 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 7 style style NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 9 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 10 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 11 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 12 interpretations interpretation NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 13 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 14 Poetic Poetic NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 15 Justice Justice NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 17 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 18 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 20 leave leave VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 21 little little JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 22 doubt doubt NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 23 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 24 she -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 25 employs employ VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 26 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 27 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 28 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 29 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 30 criticismprimarily criticismprimarily NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 31 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 32 instrumental instrumental JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 33 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 269 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 1 Native native JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 2 Son Son NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 3 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 5 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 6 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 7 she -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 8 discusses discuss VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 9 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 10 intended intend VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 11 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 12 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 13 means means NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 14 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 15 improve improve VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 17 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 18 sympathies sympathy NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 20 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 21 judiciary judiciary NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 270 22 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 271 1 34 34 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 1 This this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 2 effort effort NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 4 restore restore VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 5 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 6 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 7 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 8 ancient ancient JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 9 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 10 honorable honorable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 11 position position NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 12 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 13 public public JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 14 life life NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 16 commendable commendable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 17 though though IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 18 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 19 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 20 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 21 leads lead VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 22 too too RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 23 readily readily RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 24 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 25 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 26 mistaken mistaken JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 27 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 28 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 29 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 30 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 31 involves involve VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 32 nothing nothing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 33 but but IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 34 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 35 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 36 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 37 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 38 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 39 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 40 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 41 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 42 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 43 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 44 indirectly indirectly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 45 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 46 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 47 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 48 authors author NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 49 responsible responsible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 50 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 51 those those DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 52 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 53 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 272 54 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 1 What what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 2 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 3 hope hope VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 4 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 5 have have VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 6 established establish VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 7 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 8 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 9 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 10 such such PDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 11 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 12 view view NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 14 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 15 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 16 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 17 incomplete incomplete JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 18 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 19 misguided misguided JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 273 20 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 1 That that DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 2 said say VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 4 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 5 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 6 worth worth JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 7 stating state VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 8 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 9 both both DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 10 sides side NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 13 traditional traditional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 14 debate debate NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 15 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 16 aestheticists aestheticist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 17 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 18 ethicists ethicist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 19 get get VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 20 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 21 right right JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 274 22 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 1 Defenders defender NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 2 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 3 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 4 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 5 correctly correctly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 6 stress stress VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 8 importance importance NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 10 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 11 engagement engagement NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 12 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 13 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 14 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 15 has have VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 16 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 17 offer offer VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 18 us -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 19 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 20 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 21 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 22 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 23 context context NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 24 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 25 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 26 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 27 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 28 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 29 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 30 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 31 natural natural JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 32 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 33 appropriate appropriate JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 34 part part NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 35 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 36 appreciation appreciation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 37 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 38 evaluation evaluation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 275 39 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 1 Opponents opponent NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 2 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 3 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 4 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 5 rightly rightly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 6 insist insist VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 7 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 8 without without IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 9 considerable considerable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 10 sensitivity sensitivity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 11 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 12 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 13 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 14 aesthetic aesthetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 15 features feature NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 17 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 18 lose lose VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 19 much much JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 22 pleasure pleasure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 23 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 24 instruction instruction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 25 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 26 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 27 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 28 best good JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 29 provides provide NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 276 30 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 1 And and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 2 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 3 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 4 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 5 right right JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 7 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 8 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 9 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 10 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 11 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 12 developing develop VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 13 just just RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 14 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 15 aesthetic aesthetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 16 sensitivity sensitivity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 277 17 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 1 Ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 2 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 3 demands demand VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 4 awareness awareness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 6 features feature NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 7 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 8 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 10 irony irony NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 11 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 12 ambiguity ambiguity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 14 stylistic stylistic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 15 complexity complexity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 17 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 19 rhythm rhythm NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 21 language language NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 22 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 23 precisely precisely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 24 those those DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 25 features feature NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 26 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 27 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 28 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 29 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 30 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 31 calls call VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 32 literary literary NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 278 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 1 So so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 3 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 4 least least JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 5 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 6 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 7 certain certain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 8 subclass subclass NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 10 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 11 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 12 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 13 those those DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 14 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 15 take take VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 17 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 18 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 19 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 20 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 21 object object NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 22 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 23 made make VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 24 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 25 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 26 certain certain JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 27 subclass subclass NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 28 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 29 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 30 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 31 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 32 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 33 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 34 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 35 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 36 narrative narrative NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 37 fictions fiction NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 38 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 39 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 40 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 41 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 42 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 43 aesthetic aesthetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 44 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 45 come come VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 46 together together RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 279 47 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 2 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 3 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 4 make make VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 5 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 6 competent competent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 7 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 8 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 9 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 11 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 12 without without IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 13 engaging engage VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 14 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 16 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 17 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 18 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 19 form form NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 20 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 21 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 22 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 23 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 24 content content NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 25 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 26 presented present VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 27 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 28 structured structure VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 280 29 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 281 1 Why why WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 281 2 ? ? . cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 1 Because because IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 2 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 3 order order NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 4 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 5 form form VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 6 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 7 principled principled JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 8 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 9 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 10 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 12 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 13 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 14 whether whether IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 15 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 16 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 17 morally morally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 18 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 19 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 20 bad bad JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 21 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 22 enlightening enlightening JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 23 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 24 demeaning demeaning JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 25 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 26 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 27 need need VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 28 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 29 determine determine VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 30 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 31 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 32 values value NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 33 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 34 commitments commitment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 35 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 36 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 37 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 38 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 39 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 282 40 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 283 1 This this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 283 2 process process NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 283 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 283 4 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 283 5 simple simple JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 283 6 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 2 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 3 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 5 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 6 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 8 merely merely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 9 count count VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 10 up up RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 12 number number NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 284 14 times time NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 1 Twain Twain NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 2 uses use VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 4 n n NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 5 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 6 word word NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 7 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 8 Lawrence Lawrence NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 10 f f NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 11 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 12 word word NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 13 ; ; : cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 14 nor nor CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 15 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 16 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 17 simply simply RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 18 look look VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 19 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 20 what what WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 22 characters character NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 23 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 24 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 25 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 26 say say VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 27 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 28 do do VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 285 29 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 1 Nor nor CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 3 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 4 enough enough JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 5 merely merely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 6 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 7 examine examine VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 8 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 9 competent competent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 10 readers reader NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 11 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 12 likely likely JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 13 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 14 respond respond VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 286 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 2 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 4 engage engage VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 6 whole whole JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 7 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 8 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 9 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 10 all all PDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 11 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 12 overarching overarching JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 13 detail detail NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 14 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 15 subtlety subtlety NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 17 contradiction contradiction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 18 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 19 confusion confusion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 20 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 21 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 22 task task NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 23 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 24 requires require VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 25 careful careful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 26 reading reading NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 28 imagination imagination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 29 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 30 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 31 hard hard JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 32 interpretive interpretive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 33 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 287 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 288 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 288 2 5 5 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 288 3 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 1 A a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 2 note note NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 3 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 4 terminology terminology NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 5 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 6 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 8 context context NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 10 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 11 paper paper NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 13 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 14 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 15 using use VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 16 ' ' `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 17 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 18 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 19 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 20 ' ' `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 21 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 22 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 23 interchangeably interchangeably RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 289 24 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 2 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 3 also also RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 4 using use VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 5 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 6 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 7 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 8 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 9 very very RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 10 broad broad JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 11 sense sense NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 13 including include VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 14 more more JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 15 than than IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 16 might may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 17 ordinarily ordinarily RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 18 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 19 counted count VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 20 under under IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 22 label label NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 23 ' ' `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 24 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 25 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 290 26 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 2 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 3 purposes purpose NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 6 label label NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 7 ' ' `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 9 moral moral NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 10 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 11 includes include VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 13 political political JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 16 ideological ideological JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 19 religious religious JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 20 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 21 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 22 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 23 on on RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 291 24 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 1 Lastly lastly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 3 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 4 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 5 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 6 committed commit VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 7 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 9 claim claim NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 10 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 12 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 13 ' ' POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 14 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 15 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 16 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 17 ' ' `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 18 immoral immoral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 19 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 20 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 22 fundamental fundamental JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 23 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 24 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 25 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 26 evaluation evaluation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 292 27 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 1 Here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 2 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 3 use use VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 4 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 5 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 6 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 7 stand stand NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 8 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 9 ins in NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 10 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 11 all all DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 12 kinds kind NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 14 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 15 language language NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 16 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 17 ordinary ordinary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 18 talk talk NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 20 justice justice NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 21 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 22 happiness happiness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 23 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 24 virtue virtue NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 25 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 26 vice vice NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 28 terms term NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 29 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 30 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 31 ' ' `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 32 duty duty NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 33 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 34 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 35 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 36 obligation obligation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 37 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 38 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 39 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 40 ' ' `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 41 right right UH cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 42 ' ' '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 43 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 44 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 45 theory theory NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 46 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 293 47 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 294 1 6 6 LS cord-023118-dwh70u29 294 2 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 2 owe owe VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 3 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 4 line line NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 6 objection objection NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 7 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 8 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 9 anonymous anonymous JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 10 reviewer reviewer NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 12 12 12 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 295 13 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 2 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 3 actual actual JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 4 practice practice NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 6 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 7 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 9 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 10 different different JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 11 kinds kind NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 12 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 13 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 14 judgment judgment NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 15 frequently frequently RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 16 run run VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 17 together together RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 296 18 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 1 Unwary unwary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 2 critics critic NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 3 easily easily RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 4 fall fall VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 5 prey prey NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 6 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 8 common common JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 9 error error NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 11 confusing confuse VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 12 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 13 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 14 with with IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 15 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 16 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 17 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 18 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 19 fictional fictional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 20 creations creation NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 297 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 2 latter latter JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 3 occurs occur VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 4 particularly particularly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 5 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 6 cases case NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 7 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 8 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 9 Lolita Lolita NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 10 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 11 where where WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 13 character character NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 15 Humbert Humbert NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 16 exercises exercise VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 17 such such PDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 18 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 19 powerful powerful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 20 presence presence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 298 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 1 This this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 2 proclivity proclivity NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 4 erode erode VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 6 distinction distinction NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 7 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 9 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 10 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 11 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 12 else else RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 13 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 14 be be VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 15 even even RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 16 stronger strong JJR cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 17 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 18 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 19 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 21 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 22 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 23 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 24 presumed presume VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 25 effects effect NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 26 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 27 where where WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 28 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 29 reservations reservation NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 30 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 31 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 32 given give VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 33 outcome outcome NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 34 get get VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 35 freely freely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 36 transferred transfer VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 37 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 38 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 39 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 40 presumed presume VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 41 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 42 bring bring VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 43 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 44 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 299 45 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 2 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 3 instances instance NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 5 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 6 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 7 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 8 confused confused JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 300 9 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 2 mean mean VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 3 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 4 use use VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 5 talk talk NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 7 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 8 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 9 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 10 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 11 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 12 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 13 kind kind NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 15 shorthand shorthand NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 301 16 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 1 Claims claim NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 2 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 3 Huckleberry Huckleberry NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 4 Finn Finn NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 5 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 6 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 7 racist racist JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 8 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 9 stand stand NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 10 proxy proxy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 11 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 12 condemnation condemnation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 15 assumed assume VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 16 attitudes attitude NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 17 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 18 beliefs belief NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 19 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 20 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 21 historical historical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 22 person person NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 23 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 24 Samuel Samuel NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 25 Clemens Clemens NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 302 26 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 3 Clemens Clemens NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 4 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 5 actions action NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 6 qua qua VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 7 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 8 being being NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 9 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 10 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 11 mean mean VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 12 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 13 criticize criticize VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 303 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 304 1 30 30 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 304 2 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 1 See see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 3 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 4 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 6 Kendall Kendall NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 7 L. L. NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 8 Walton Walton NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 9 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 10 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 11 Morals Morals NNPS cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 12 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 13 Fiction Fiction NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 14 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 15 Fictional Fictional NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 16 Morality Morality NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 18 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 19 Proceedings proceeding NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 21 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 22 Aristotelian Aristotelian NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 23 Society Society NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 24 Supplementary Supplementary NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 25 68 68 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 26 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 27 1994 1994 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 28 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 29 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 30 27 27 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 31 - - SYM cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 32 50 50 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 305 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 2 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 3 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 4 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 5 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 6 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 7 aesthetic aesthetic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 8 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 9 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 10 come come VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 11 together together RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 12 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 13 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 14 analysis analysis NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 16 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 17 given give VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 18 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 20 see see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 21 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 22 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 23 Beauty Beauty NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 24 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 25 Evil Evil NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 26 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 27 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 28 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 29 Levinson Levinson NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 30 volume volume NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 31 cited cite VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 32 above above IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 33 31 31 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 306 34 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 3 worth worth JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 4 noting note VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 6 considerable considerable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 7 recent recent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 8 literature literature NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 9 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 10 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 11 ethicist ethicist NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 12 - - HYPH cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 13 aestheticist aestheticist NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 14 debate debate NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 307 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 1 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 2 focus focus VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 3 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 5 debate debate NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 6 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 7 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 8 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 9 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 10 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 11 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 12 couple couple NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 14 reasons reason NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 308 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 2 one one CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 3 thing thing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 5 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 6 exchange exchange NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 7 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 9 pages page NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 10 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 11 Philosophy Philosophy NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 12 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 13 Literature Literature NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 14 avoids avoid VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 15 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 16 regrettable regrettable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 17 tendency tendency NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 18 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 19 direct direct VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 20 arguments argument NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 21 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 22 nameless nameless JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 23 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 24 generic generic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 25 opponents opponent NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 26 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 27 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 28 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 29 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 30 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 31 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 32 ethicists ethicist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 33 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 34 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 35 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 36 traditional traditional JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 37 aestheticians aesthetician NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 38 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 39 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 309 40 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 1 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 2 another another DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 3 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 4 both both DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 5 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 6 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 7 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 8 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 9 articulated articulate VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 10 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 11 defended defend VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 12 positions position NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 13 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 14 have have VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 15 had have VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 16 considerable considerable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 17 influence influence NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 18 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 19 only only RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 20 within within IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 21 philosophy philosophy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 22 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 23 also also RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 24 within within IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 25 legal legal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 26 studies study NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 310 27 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 311 1 32 32 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 311 2 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 1 While while IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 2 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 3 relevant relevant JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 4 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 5 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 6 interests interest NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 7 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 9 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 10 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 11 worth worth JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 12 noting note VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 13 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 14 much much JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 17 argument argument NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 18 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 19 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 20 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 21 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 22 involves involve VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 23 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 24 substantive substantive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 25 dispute dispute NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 26 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 27 political political JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 28 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 29 judicial judicial JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 30 matters matter NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 312 31 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 1 See see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 3 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 4 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 6 Posner Posner NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 7 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 8 discussion discussion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 9 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 10 market market NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 11 relations relation NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 13 race race NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 15 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 17 legal legal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 18 controversy controversy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 19 over over IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 20 gay gay JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 21 rights right NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 22 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 23 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 24 Against against IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 25 Ethical Ethical NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 26 Criticism Criticism NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 28 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 29 pp pp NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 30 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 313 31 _SP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 1 Contemporary contemporary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 2 advocates advocate NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 4 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 5 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 6 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 7 among among IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 8 whom whom WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 9 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 10 count count VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 11 myself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 13 include include VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 14 Wayne Wayne NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 15 Booth Booth NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 16 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 17 Martha Martha NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 18 Nussbaum Nussbaum NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 20 Berys Berys NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 21 Gaut Gaut NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 22 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 23 Matt Matt NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 24 Kieran Kieran NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 25 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 26 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 27 many many JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 28 others other NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 29 provides provide VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 30 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 31 good good JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 32 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 33 albeit albeit IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 34 negative negative JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 35 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 36 account account NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 37 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 38 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 39 debates debate NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 40 2 2 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 314 41 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 1 Here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 2 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 3 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 4 using use VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 6 concept concept NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 8 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 9 broadly broadly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 10 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 11 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 12 distinguishing distinguish VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 13 between between IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 14 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 16 established establish VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 17 artistic artistic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 18 merit merit NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 19 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 20 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 21 Nabokov Nabokov NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 22 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 23 Lolita Lolita NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 24 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 25 ordinary ordinary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 26 popular popular JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 27 arts art NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 28 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 29 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 31 novels novel NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 32 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 33 Stephen Stephen NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 34 King King NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 35 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 36 movies movie NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 37 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 38 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 39 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 40 Silence Silence NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 41 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 42 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 43 Lambs Lambs NNPS cord-023118-dwh70u29 315 44 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 316 1 3 3 LS cord-023118-dwh70u29 316 2 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 2 position position NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 3 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 4 take take VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 5 on on RP cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 6 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 7 normative normative JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 8 issue issue NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 9 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 10 separate separate JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 11 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 12 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 13 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 14 likely likely JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 15 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 16 reflect reflect VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 17 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 18 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 19 least least JJS cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 20 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 21 part part NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 22 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 23 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 24 views view NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 25 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 26 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 27 empirical empirical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 28 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 29 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 31 impact impact NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 32 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 33 reading read VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 34 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 35 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 317 36 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 1 Skeptics skeptic NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 2 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 3 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 4 power power NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 5 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 6 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 7 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 8 affect affect VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 9 human human JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 10 character character NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 11 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 12 conduct conduct NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 13 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 14 unlikely unlikely JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 15 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 16 worry worry VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 17 much much RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 18 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 19 holding hold VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 20 artists artist NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 21 accountable accountable JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 22 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 23 ethically ethically RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 24 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 25 otherwise otherwise RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 26 - - : cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 27 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 28 any any DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 29 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 30 minimal minimal JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 31 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 318 32 effect effect NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 319 1 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 319 2 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 319 3 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 319 4 produce produce VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 319 5 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 320 1 4 4 LS cord-023118-dwh70u29 320 2 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 1 Proponents proponent NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 2 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 3 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 4 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 5 adopt adopt VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 6 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 7 variety variety NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 9 conflicting conflict VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 10 positions position NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 11 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 12 these these DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 13 issues issue NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 321 14 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 1 See see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 2 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 3 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 4 example example NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 5 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 6 Amy Amy NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 7 Mullin Mullin NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 8 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 9 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 10 Evaluating evaluate VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 11 Art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 12 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 13 Morally morally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 14 Significant significant JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 15 Imagining imagining NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 16 Versus versus IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 17 Moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 322 18 Soundness soundness NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 1 Noël Noël NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 2 Carroll Carroll NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 3 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 4 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 5 Art Art NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 6 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 7 Ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 8 Criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 323 9 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 1 An an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 2 Overview Overview NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 4 Recent Recent NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 5 Directions direction NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 6 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 7 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 8 Reader Reader NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 9 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 10 trans trans NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 324 11 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 325 1 Carol Carol NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 325 2 Brown Brown NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 325 3 Janeway Janeway NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 2 Critique Critique NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 4 Judgment Judgment NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 5 For for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 6 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 7 reading reading NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 9 Kant Kant NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 10 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 11 Hume Hume NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 12 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 13 authorial authorial JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 14 design design NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 16 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 17 am be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 18 indebted indebted JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 19 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 20 Jerry Jerry NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 21 E. E. NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 22 Sobel Sobel NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 23 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 24 illuminating illuminate VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 25 discussion discussion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 26 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 27 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 28 Arguing argue VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 29 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 30 Accepting accept VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 31 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 32 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 33 Preserving preserve VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 34 Design Design NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 35 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 36 Heidegger Heidegger NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 37 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 38 Hume Hume NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 39 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 40 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 41 Kant Kant NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 42 Although although IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 43 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 44 discovered discover VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 45 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 46 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 47 subsequent subsequent JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 48 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 49 developing develop VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 50 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 51 account account NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 52 presented present VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 326 53 here here RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 1 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 2 there there EX cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 3 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 4 similarities similarity NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 5 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 6 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 7 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 8 understand understand VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 9 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 10 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 11 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 13 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 14 figure figure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 327 15 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 2 agree agree VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 3 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 5 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 6 at at IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 7 issue issue NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 8 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 9 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 10 interpretive interpretive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 11 construct construct NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 328 12 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 1 One one CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 2 main main JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 3 difference difference NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 4 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 5 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 6 accounts account NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 8 however however RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 9 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 10 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 11 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 12 Nehamas Nehamas NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 13 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 14 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 15 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 16 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 17 author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 18 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 19 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 20 figure figure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 21 who who WP cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 22 emerges emerge VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 23 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 24 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 25 whole whole JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 26 oeuvre oeuvre NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 28 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 29 from from IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 30 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 31 particular particular JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 32 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 329 33 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 1 A a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 2 second second JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 3 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 4 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 5 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 6 wish wish VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 7 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 8 employ employ VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 9 this this DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 10 notion notion NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 11 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 12 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 13 service service NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 14 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 15 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 16 analysis analysis NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 18 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 19 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 20 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 21 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 22 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 23 art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 24 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 25 whereas whereas IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 26 Nehamas Nehamas NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 27 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 28 project project NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 29 concerns concern VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 30 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 31 process process NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 32 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 33 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 34 interpretation interpretation NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 35 more more RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 36 generally generally RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 330 37 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 331 1 See see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 331 2 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 2 Postulated Postulated NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 3 Author author NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 4 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 5 Critical critical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 6 Monism monism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 7 as as IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 8 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 9 Regulative Regulative NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 332 10 Ideal ideal NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 3 true true JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 4 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 5 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 6 irony irony NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 7 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 8 very very RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 9 subtle subtle JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 10 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 11 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 12 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 13 think think VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 14 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 15 case case NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 16 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 17 Swift Swift NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 18 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 19 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 20 many many JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 21 readers reader NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 22 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 23 miss miss VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 24 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 333 25 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 2 possibility possibility NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 4 misinterpreting misinterpret VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 5 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 6 work work NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 7 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 8 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 9 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 10 getting get VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 11 it -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 12 wrong wrong JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 13 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 14 " " '' cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 15 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 16 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 17 restricted restrict VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 18 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 19 ironic ironic JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 20 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 334 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 335 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 335 2 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 335 3 something something NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 335 4 readers reader NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 335 5 always always RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 335 6 risk risk VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 335 7 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 1 A a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 2 more more RBR cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 3 sustained sustained JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 4 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 5 careful careful JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 6 examination examination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 7 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 8 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 9 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 10 may may MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 11 reveal reveal VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 12 such such JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 13 errors error NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 14 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 15 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 16 complex complex JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 17 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 18 will will MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 19 likely likely RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 20 give give VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 21 rise rise NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 22 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 23 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 24 variety variety NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 25 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 26 competing compete VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 27 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 28 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 29 plausible plausible JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 30 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 31 interpretations interpretation NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 336 32 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 1 The the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 2 point point NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 3 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 4 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 5 account account NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 6 is be VBZ cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 7 not not RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 8 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 9 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 10 making make VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 11 moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 12 judgments judgment NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 13 about about IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 14 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 15 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 16 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 17 can can MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 18 never never RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 19 go go VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 20 wrong wrong JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 21 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 22 but but CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 23 that that IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 24 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 25 doing do VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 26 so so RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 27 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 28 are be VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 29 necessarily necessarily RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 30 engaged engage VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 31 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 32 an an DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 33 interpretive interpretive JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 34 enterprise enterprise NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 35 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 36 one one CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 37 that that WDT cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 38 we -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 39 appeal appeal VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 40 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 41 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 42 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 43 text text NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 44 itself -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 45 to to TO cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 46 sustain sustain VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 337 47 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 338 1 24 24 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 338 2 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 1 Lionel Lionel NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 2 Trilling Trilling NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 3 Matt Matt NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 4 Kieran Kieran NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 5 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 6 " " `` cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 7 Art art NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 8 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 9 Imagination imagination NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 10 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 11 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 12 Cultivation Cultivation NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 13 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 14 Morals Morals NNPS cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 15 Frank Frank NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 16 Palmer Palmer NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 17 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 18 Literature Literature NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 19 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 20 Moral moral JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 21 Understanding understanding NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 22 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 23 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 24 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 25 essay essay NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 26 by by IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 27 Mullin Mullin NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 28 noted note VBD cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 29 above above IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 30 I -PRON- PRP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 31 leave leave VBP cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 32 aside aside RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 33 for for IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 34 now now RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 35 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 36 much much RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 37 discussed discuss VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 38 question question NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 39 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 40 how how WRB cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 41 much much JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 42 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 43 if if IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 44 at at RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 45 all all RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 339 46 , , . cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 1 a a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 2 novel novel NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 3 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 4 success success NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 5 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 6 failure failure NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 7 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 8 cultivating cultivate VBG cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 9 tolerance tolerance NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 10 or or CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 11 other other JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 12 virtues virtue NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 13 should should MD cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 14 count count VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 15 in in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 16 evaluations evaluation NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 17 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 18 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 19 literary literary JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 20 standing standing NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 340 21 . . . cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 1 In in IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 2 addition addition NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 3 to to IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 4 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 5 works work NNS cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 6 cited cite VBN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 7 above above RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 8 ( ( -LRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 9 nn nn UH cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 10 . . NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 11 4 4 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 12 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 13 27 27 CD cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 14 ) ) -RRB- cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 15 , , , cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 16 see see VB cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 17 Berys Berys NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 18 Gaut Gaut NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 19 's 's POS cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 20 argument argument NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 21 on on IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 22 behalf behalf NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 23 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 24 the the DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 25 legitimacy legitimacy NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 26 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 27 ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 28 criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 29 Against against IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 30 Ethical Ethical NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 31 Criticism Criticism NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 32 Exactly exactly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 33 and and CC cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 34 Responsibly responsibly RB cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 35 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 36 A a DT cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 37 Defense Defense NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 38 of of IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 39 Ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 40 Criticism Criticism NNP cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 41 Against against IN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 42 Ethical ethical JJ cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 43 Criticism criticism NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 341 44 : : : cord-023118-dwh70u29 342 1 Part part NN cord-023118-dwh70u29 342 2 Two two CD