id sid tid token lemma pos cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 1 key key JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 2 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 3 cord-027756-w44t68tj cord-027756-w44t68tj NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 4 authors author NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 5 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 6 Coggon Coggon NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 7 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 8 John John NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 9 ; ; : cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 10 Gostin Gostin NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 11 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 12 Lawrence Lawrence NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 1 13 O O NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 1 title title NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 2 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 3 Postscript postscript NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 4 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 5 COVID-19 covid-19 VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 6 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 7 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 8 Legal Legal NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 9 Determinants Determinants NNPS cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 10 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 11 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 12 date date NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 13 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 14 2020 2020 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 15 - - HYPH cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 16 05 05 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 17 - - SYM cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 18 25 25 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 19 journal journal NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 20 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 21 Public Public NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 22 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 2 23 Ethics Ethics NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 1 DOI DOI NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 2 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 3 10.1093 10.1093 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 4 / / SYM cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 5 phe phe NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 6 / / SYM cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 7 phaa015 phaa015 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 8 sha sha NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 9 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 10 bb78e1c5808263b492bdca90f7482889c7661952 bb78e1c5808263b492bdca90f7482889c7661952 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 11 doc_id doc_id CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 12 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 13 27756 27756 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 14 cord_uid cord_uid NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 3 15 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 4 1 w44t68tj w44t68tj NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 1 This this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 2 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 3 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 4 short short JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 5 postscript postscript NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 6 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 7 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 8 Public Public NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 9 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 10 Ethics Ethics NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 11 special special JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 12 issue issue NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 13 on on IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 14 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 15 legal legal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 16 determinants determinant NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 17 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 18 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 5 19 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 2 reflect reflect VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 3 briefly briefly RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 4 on on IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 5 emerging emerge VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 6 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 7 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 8 COVID-19 covid-19 VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 9 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 10 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 11 raise raise VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 12 important important JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 13 questions question NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 14 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 15 ethics ethic NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 16 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 17 law law NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 18 that that WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 19 must must MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 20 be be VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 21 addressed address VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 22 ; ; : cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 23 including include VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 24 through through IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 25 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 26 lens lens NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 27 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 28 legal legal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 29 determinants determinant NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 30 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 31 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 32 with with IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 33 critical critical JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 34 attention attention NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 35 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 36 what what WP cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 37 it -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 38 means mean VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 39 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 40 protect protect VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 41 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 42 with with IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 43 justice justice NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 6 44 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 1 Since since IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 2 this this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 3 special special JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 4 issue issue NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 5 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 6 Public Public NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 7 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 8 Ethics Ethics NNPS cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 9 went go VBD cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 10 into into IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 11 production production NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 12 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 13 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 14 global global JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 15 pandemic pandemic NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 16 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 17 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 18 has have VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 19 led lead VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 20 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 21 extraordinary extraordinary JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 22 measures measure NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 23 being be VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 24 taken take VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 25 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 26 many many JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 27 countries country NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 28 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 29 including include VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 30 those those DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 31 where where WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 32 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 33 each each DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 34 live live VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 35 ( ( -LRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 36 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 37 UK UK NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 38 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 39 USA USA NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 40 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 41 respectively respectively RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 42 ) ) -RRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 7 43 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 1 As as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 3 draft draft VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 4 this this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 5 short short JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 6 postscript postscript NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 7 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 8 President President NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 9 Trump Trump NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 10 has have VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 11 declared declare VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 12 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 13 national national JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 14 emergency emergency NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 15 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 16 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 17 USA USA NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 18 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 19 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 20 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 21 fifty fifty CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 22 state state NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 23 governors governor NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 24 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 25 declared declare VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 26 state state NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 27 emergencies emergency NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 8 28 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 1 President President NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 2 Trump Trump NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 3 has have VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 4 also also RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 5 now now RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 6 taken take VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 7 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 8 extraordinary extraordinary JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 9 move move NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 10 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 11 announcing announce VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 12 that that IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 13 he -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 14 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 15 stopping stop VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 16 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 17 USA USA NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 18 's 's POS cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 19 funding funding NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 20 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 21 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 22 World World NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 23 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 24 Organization Organization NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 25 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 26 which which WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 27 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 28 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 29 highly highly RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 30 damaging damaging JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 31 action action NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 32 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 33 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 34 midst midst NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 35 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 36 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 37 pandemic pandemic NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 9 38 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 1 Prime Prime NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 2 Minister Minister NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 3 Boris Boris NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 4 Johnson Johnson NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 5 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 6 who who WP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 7 has have VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 8 since since IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 9 been be VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 10 heavily heavily RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 11 impacted impact VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 12 through through IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 13 contracting contracting NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 14 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 15 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 16 declared declare VBD cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 17 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 18 national national JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 19 emergency emergency NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 20 on on IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 21 23rd 23rd JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 22 March March NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 23 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 24 2020 2020 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 25 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 26 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 27 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 28 UK UK NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 29 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 30 following follow VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 31 which which WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 32 time time NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 33 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 34 UK UK NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 35 Parliament Parliament NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 36 has have VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 37 granted grant VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 38 extensive extensive JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 39 emergency emergency NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 40 powers power NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 41 through through IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 42 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 43 Coronavirus Coronavirus NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 44 Act Act NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 45 2020 2020 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 10 46 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 1 The the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 2 resultant resultant JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 3 position position NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 4 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 5 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 6 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 7 write write VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 8 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 9 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 10 that that IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 11 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 12 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 13 USA USA NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 14 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 15 most most JJS cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 16 governors governor NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 17 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 18 ordered order VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 19 residents resident NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 20 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 21 stay stay VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 22 at at IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 23 home home NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 24 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 25 all all DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 26 non non JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 27 - - JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 28 essential essential JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 29 businesses business NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 30 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 31 close close VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 32 ( ( -LRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 33 Gostin Gostin NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 34 et et FW cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 35 al al NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 36 . . NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 37 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 38 2020a 2020a CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 39 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 40 b b LS cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 41 ) ) -RRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 11 42 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 1 In in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 2 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 3 UK UK NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 4 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 5 following follow VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 6 early early RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 7 highly highly RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 8 permissive permissive JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 9 governance governance NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 10 approaches approach NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 11 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 12 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 13 government government NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 14 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 15 devolved devolved JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 16 administrations administration NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 17 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 18 now now RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 19 using use VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 20 emergency emergency NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 21 laws law NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 22 significantly significantly RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 23 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 24 curtail curtail VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 25 general general JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 26 freedoms freedom NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 27 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 28 efforts effort NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 29 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 30 contain contain VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 31 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 32 spread spread NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 33 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 34 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 35 ( ( -LRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 36 Coggon Coggon NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 37 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 38 2020 2020 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 39 ) ) -RRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 12 40 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 1 In in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 2 both both DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 3 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 4 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 5 countries country NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 6 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 7 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 8 elsewhere elsewhere RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 9 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 10 an an DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 11 overbearing overbearing JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 12 concern concern NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 13 has have VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 14 been be VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 15 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 16 functioning functioning NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 17 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 18 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 19 healthcare healthcare NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 20 systems system NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 13 21 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 1 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 2 could could MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 3 overrun overrun VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 4 doctors doctor NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 5 ' ' POS cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 6 offices office NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 7 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 8 hospitals hospital NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 9 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 10 which which WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 11 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 12 also also RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 13 short short JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 14 on on IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 15 critical critical JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 16 supplies supply NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 17 such such JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 18 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 19 personal personal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 20 protective protective JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 21 equipment equipment NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 22 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 23 ventilators ventilator NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 14 24 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 1 Scrutiny scrutiny NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 2 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 3 evaluation evaluation NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 4 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 5 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 6 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 7 response response NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 8 nationally nationally RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 9 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 10 globally globally RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 11 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 12 ongoing ongoing JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 15 13 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 1 When when WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 3 come come VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 4 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 5 look look VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 6 back back RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 7 on on IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 8 this this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 9 crisis crisis NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 10 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 11 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 12 will will MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 13 see see VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 14 social social JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 15 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 16 legal legal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 17 determinants determinant NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 18 having have VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 19 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 20 marked marked JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 21 impact impact NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 22 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 23 both both CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 24 at at IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 25 national national JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 26 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 27 global global JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 28 levels level NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 16 29 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 1 How how WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 2 effective effective JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 3 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 4 governments government NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 5 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 6 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 7 World World NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 8 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 9 Organization Organization NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 10 been be VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 11 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 12 curtailing curtail VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 13 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 14 spread spread NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 15 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 16 SARS SARS NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 17 - - HYPH cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 18 CoV-2 CoV-2 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 17 19 ? ? . cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 1 How how WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 2 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 3 they -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 4 balanced balance VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 5 public public JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 6 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 7 with with IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 8 human human JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 9 rights right NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 18 10 ? ? . cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 1 What what WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 2 lessons lesson NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 3 can can MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 4 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 5 learn learn VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 6 about about IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 7 national national JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 8 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 9 global global JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 10 preparedness preparedness NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 19 11 ? ? . cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 1 As as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 2 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 3 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 4 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 5 pandemic pandemic NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 6 run run NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 7 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 8 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 9 after after RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 10 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 11 it -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 12 will will MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 13 be be VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 14 crucial crucial JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 15 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 16 explore explore VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 17 how how WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 18 law law NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 19 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 20 governance governance NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 21 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 22 been be VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 23 used use VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 24 ( ( -LRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 25 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 26 not not RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 27 used use VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 28 ) ) -RRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 29 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 30 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 31 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 32 question question VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 33 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 34 effectiveness effectiveness NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 35 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 36 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 37 compliance compliance NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 38 with with IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 39 human human JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 40 rights right NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 41 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 42 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 43 how how WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 44 equitable equitable JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 45 they -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 46 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 47 been be VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 20 48 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 1 Across across IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 2 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 3 world world NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 4 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 5 there there EX cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 6 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 7 been be VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 8 notable notable JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 9 distinctions distinction NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 10 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 11 different different JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 12 national national JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 13 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 21 14 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 1 Governments government NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 2 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 3 experts expert NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 4 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 5 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 6 citizens citizen NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 7 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 8 watching watch VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 9 closely closely RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 10 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 11 see see VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 12 how how WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 13 different different JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 14 methods method NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 15 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 16 governance governance NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 17 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 18 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 19 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 20 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 21 not not RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 22 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 23 working work VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 24 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 25 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 26 crisis crisis NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 27 unfolds unfold VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 28 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 29 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 30 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 31 understanding understanding NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 32 improves improve VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 22 33 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 1 Problems problem NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 2 abound abound VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 3 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 4 relation relation NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 5 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 6 scientific scientific JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 7 uncertainty uncertainty NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 8 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 9 paucity paucity NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 10 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 11 data datum NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 12 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 13 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 14 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 15 extreme extreme JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 16 challenges challenge NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 17 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 18 achieving achieve VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 19 equitable equitable JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 20 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 21 proportionate proportionate JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 22 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 23 23 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 1 At at IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 2 one one CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 3 point point NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 4 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 5 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 6 may may MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 7 have have VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 8 considered consider VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 9 it -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 10 unimaginable unimaginable JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 11 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 12 have have VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 13 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 14 largescale largescale JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 15 ' ' `` cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 16 lockdown lockdown NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 17 ' ' '' cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 18 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 19 liberal liberal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 20 Western western JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 21 democracies democracy NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 22 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 23 but but CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 24 that that DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 25 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 26 exactly exactly RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 27 what what WP cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 28 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 29 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 30 seen see VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 31 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 32 many many JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 33 nations nation NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 34 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 35 including include VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 36 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 37 own own JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 24 38 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 1 At at IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 2 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 3 same same JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 4 time time NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 5 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 6 concerns concern NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 7 proliferate proliferate VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 8 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 9 nations nation NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 10 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 11 communities community NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 12 who who WP cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 13 stand stand VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 14 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 15 be be VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 16 harder hard RBR cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 17 hit hit VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 18 still still RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 19 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 20 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 21 ill ill RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 22 - - HYPH cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 23 resourced resourced JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 24 or or CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 25 otherwise otherwise RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 26 lacking lack VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 27 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 28 infrastructural infrastructural JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 29 capacity capacity NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 30 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 31 respond respond VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 32 effectively effectively RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 25 33 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 1 The the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 2 virus virus NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 3 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 4 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 5 example example NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 6 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 7 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 8 poised poise VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 9 now now RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 10 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 11 spread spread VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 12 through through IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 13 Africa Africa NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 14 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 15 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 16 Indian indian JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 17 sub sub NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 18 - - JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 19 continent continent NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 26 20 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 27 1 This this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 27 2 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 1 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 2 global global JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 3 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 4 doi:10.1093 doi:10.1093 NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 5 / / SYM cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 6 phe phe NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 7 / / SYM cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 8 phaa015 phaa015 NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 9 V v NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 10 C C NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 11 The the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 12 Author(s Author(s NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 13 ) ) -RRB- cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 14 2020 2020 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 28 15 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 29 1 Published publish VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 29 2 by by IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 29 3 Oxford Oxford NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 29 4 University University NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 29 5 Press Press NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 29 6 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 30 1 Available available JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 30 2 online online RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 30 3 at at IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 30 4 www.phe.oxfordjournals.org www.phe.oxfordjournals.org NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 30 5 PUBLIC public JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 30 6 HEALTH health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 30 7 ETHICS ethic NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 30 8 2020 2020 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 1 • • NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 2 1 1 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 3 - - SYM cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 4 2 2 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 5 emergency emergency NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 6 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 7 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 8 it -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 9 demands demand VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 10 coordinated coordinated JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 11 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 12 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 13 political political JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 14 leadership leadership NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 15 that that WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 16 take take VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 17 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 18 global global JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 19 outlook outlook NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 31 20 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 1 Within within IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 2 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 3 among among IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 4 nations nation NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 5 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 6 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 7 already already RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 8 see see VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 9 gross gross JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 10 inequities inequity NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 32 11 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 1 These these DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 2 will will MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 3 become become VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 4 starker stark JJR cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 5 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 6 time time NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 7 progresses progress VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 8 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 9 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 10 must must MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 11 be be VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 12 given give VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 13 careful careful JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 14 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 15 collaborative collaborative JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 16 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 17 cross cross JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 18 - - JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 19 disciplinary disciplinary JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 20 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 21 cross cross JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 22 - - JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 23 sector sector JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 24 scrutiny scrutiny NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 33 25 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 1 Colleagues colleague NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 2 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 3 global global JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 4 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 5 public public JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 6 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 7 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 8 including include VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 9 scholars scholar NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 10 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 11 ethics ethic NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 12 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 13 law law NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 14 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 15 will will MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 16 therefore therefore RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 17 rightly rightly RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 18 be be VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 19 attentive attentive JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 20 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 21 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 22 implications implication NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 23 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 24 this this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 25 crisis crisis NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 26 at at IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 27 subnational subnational JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 28 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 29 national national JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 30 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 31 international international JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 32 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 33 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 34 global global JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 35 levels level NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 34 36 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 1 The the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 2 challenges challenge NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 3 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 4 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 5 acute acute JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 6 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 7 sustained sustained JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 8 events event NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 9 consequent consequent NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 10 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 11 COVID-19 covid-19 VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 12 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 13 across across IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 14 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 15 globe globe NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 16 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 17 have have VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 18 already already RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 19 laid lay VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 20 bare bare JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 21 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 22 sheer sheer JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 23 vulnerability vulnerability NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 24 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 25 human human JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 26 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 27 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 28 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 29 fragility fragility NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 30 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 31 social social JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 32 institutions institution NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 33 that that IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 34 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 35 may may MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 36 take take VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 37 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 38 granted grant VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 39 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 40 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 41 astounding astounding JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 42 interconnectedness interconnectedness NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 43 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 44 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 45 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 46 need need NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 47 that that IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 48 these these DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 49 bring bring VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 50 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 51 equitable equitable JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 52 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 53 transparent transparent JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 54 methods method NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 55 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 56 coordination coordination NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 57 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 58 regulation regulation NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 59 ; ; : cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 60 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 61 good good JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 62 governance governance NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 63 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 64 including include VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 65 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 66 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 67 public public NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 68 's 's POS cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 69 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 35 70 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 1 The the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 2 need need NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 3 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 4 brave brave JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 5 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 6 contemplated contemplate VBD cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 7 political political JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 8 leadership leadership NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 9 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 10 clear clear JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 11 ; ; : cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 12 leadership leadership NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 13 that that WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 14 looks look VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 15 globally globally RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 16 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 17 not not RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 18 just just RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 19 nationally nationally RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 36 20 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 1 And and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 2 however however RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 3 different different JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 4 countries country NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 5 ' ' POS cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 6 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 7 come come VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 8 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 9 be be VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 10 judged judge VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 11 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 12 hindsight hindsight NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 13 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 14 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 15 power power NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 16 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 17 law law NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 18 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 19 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 20 limits limit NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 21 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 22 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 23 risks risk NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 24 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 25 its -PRON- PRP$ cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 26 relationships relationship NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 27 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 28 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 29 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 30 other other JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 31 vital vital JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 32 values value NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 33 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 34 could could MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 35 not not RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 36 be be VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 37 made make VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 38 starker stark JJR cord-027756-w44t68tj 37 39 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 1 In in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 2 using use VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 3 law law NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 4 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 5 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 6 tool tool NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 7 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 8 serve serve VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 9 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 10 public public NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 11 's 's POS cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 12 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 13 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 14 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 15 need need NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 16 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 17 scientific scientific JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 18 evidence evidence NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 19 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 20 clear clear JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 21 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 22 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 23 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 24 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 25 challenges challenge NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 26 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 27 seeking seek VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 28 societal societal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 29 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 30 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 31 threats threat NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 32 that that WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 33 are be VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 34 not not RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 35 immediately immediately RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 36 visible visible JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 38 37 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 1 A a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 2 key key JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 3 lesson lesson NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 4 already already RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 5 learned learn VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 6 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 7 that that IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 8 we -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 9 must must MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 10 invest invest VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 11 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 12 public public JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 13 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 14 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 15 prepare prepare VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 16 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 17 rapid rapid JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 18 identification identification NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 19 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 20 response response NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 21 when when WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 22 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 23 situation situation NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 24 such such JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 25 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 26 this this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 27 arises arise VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 39 28 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 1 Beyond beyond IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 2 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 3 sound sound JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 4 scientific scientific JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 5 evidence evidence NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 6 base base NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 7 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 8 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 9 legal legal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 10 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 11 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 12 enjoy enjoy VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 13 legitimacy legitimacy NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 14 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 15 they -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 16 must must MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 17 accord accord VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 18 with with IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 19 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 20 rule rule NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 21 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 22 law law NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 23 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 24 including include VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 25 by by IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 26 exhibiting exhibit VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 27 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 28 clear clear JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 29 commitment commitment NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 30 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 31 fair fair JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 32 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 33 equal equal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 34 treatment treatment NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 35 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 36 proportionality proportionality NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 37 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 38 administration administration NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 39 according accord VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 40 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 41 principles principle NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 42 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 43 good good JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 44 governance governance NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 40 45 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 1 There there EX cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 2 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 3 inevitable inevitable JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 4 urgency urgency NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 5 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 6 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 7 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 8 COVID-19 covid-19 VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 9 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 10 but but CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 11 they -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 12 form form VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 13 parts part NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 14 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 15 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 16 long long JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 17 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 18 complex complex JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 19 process process NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 41 20 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 1 A a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 2 measure measure NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 3 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 4 this this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 5 moment moment NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 6 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 7 which which WDT cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 8 will will MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 9 demand demand VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 10 continued continued JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 11 analysis analysis NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 12 as as IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 13 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 14 after after IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 15 it -PRON- PRP cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 16 unfolds unfold VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 17 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 18 will will MD cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 19 be be VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 20 how how WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 21 well well JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 22 governments government NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 23 fare fare VBP cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 24 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 25 protecting protect VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 26 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 27 with with IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 28 justice justice NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 42 29 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 1 There there EX cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 2 is be VBZ cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 3 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 4 vital vital JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 5 role role NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 6 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 7 continued continue VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 8 efforts effort NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 9 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 10 scholars scholar NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 11 interested interest VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 12 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 13 public public JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 14 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 15 ethics ethic NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 16 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 17 law law NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 18 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 19 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 20 legal legal JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 21 determinants determinant NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 22 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 23 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 43 24 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 1 Beyond beyond IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 2 liberty liberty NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 3 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 4 social social JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 5 values value NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 6 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 7 public public JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 8 health health NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 9 ethics ethic NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 10 in in IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 11 responses response NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 12 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 13 COVID-19 covid-19 VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 14 Presidential presidential JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 15 powers power NNS cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 16 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 17 response response NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 18 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 19 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 20 Responding respond VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 21 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 22 COVID-19 covid-19 VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 23 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 24 How how WRB cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 25 to to TO cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 26 Navigate navigate VB cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 27 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 28 Public Public NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 29 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 30 Emergency Emergency NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 31 Legally legally RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 32 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 33 Ethically ethically RB cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 34 This this DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 35 special special JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 36 issue issue NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 37 was be VBD cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 38 produced produce VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 39 following follow VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 40 a a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 41 launch launch NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 42 event event NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 43 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 44 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 45 Lancet Lancet NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 46 - - HYPH cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 47 O'Neill O'Neill NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 48 Commission Commission NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 49 's 's POS cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 50 report report NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 51 on on IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 52 The the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 53 Legal Legal NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 54 Determinants Determinants NNPS cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 55 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 56 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 57 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 58 hosted host VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 59 by by IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 60 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 61 Centre Centre NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 62 for for IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 63 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 64 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 65 Law Law NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 66 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 67 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 68 Society Society NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 69 at at IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 70 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 71 University University NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 72 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 73 Bristol Bristol NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 74 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 75 UK UK NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 76 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 77 on on IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 78 29 29 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 79 October October NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 80 2019 2019 CD cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 81 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 82 ' ' '' cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 83 Mapping map VBG cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 84 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 85 Path Path NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 86 to to IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 87 Global Global NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 88 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 89 with with IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 90 Justice justice NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 44 91 : : : cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 1 A a DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 2 Critical critical JJ cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 3 Discussion discussion NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 4 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 5 Social Social NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 6 Structures Structures NNPS cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 7 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 8 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 9 Inequities Inequities NNPS cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 10 , , , cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 11 and and CC cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 12 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 13 Legal Legal NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 14 Determinants Determinants NNPS cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 15 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 16 Health Health NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 17 ' ' '' cord-027756-w44t68tj 45 18 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 1 The the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 2 event event NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 3 was be VBD cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 4 supported support VBN cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 5 by by IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 6 the the DT cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 7 University University NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 8 of of IN cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 9 Bristol Bristol NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 10 Law Law NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 11 School School NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 12 's 's POS cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 13 Centre Centre NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 14 Fund Fund NNP cord-027756-w44t68tj 46 15 . . . cord-027756-w44t68tj 47 1 None none NN cord-027756-w44t68tj 47 2 declared declare VBD cord-027756-w44t68tj 47 3 . . .