key: cord-341806-7hatbzra
authors: Bone, Anna E; Finucane, Anne M; Leniz, Javiera; Higginson, Irene J; Sleeman, Katherine E
title: Changing patterns of mortality during the COVID-19 pandemic: Population-based modelling to understand palliative care implications
date: 2020-07-24
journal: Palliat Med
DOI: 10.1177/0269216320944810
sha: 
doc_id: 341806
cord_uid: 7hatbzra

BACKGROUND: COVID-19 has directly and indirectly caused high mortality worldwide. AIM: To explore patterns of mortality during the COVID-19 pandemic and implications for palliative care, service planning and research. DESIGN: Descriptive analysis and population-based modelling of routine data. PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: All deaths registered in England and Wales between 7 March and 15 May 2020. We described the following mortality categories by age, gender and place of death: (1) baseline deaths (deaths that would typically occur in a given period); (2) COVID-19 deaths and (3) additional deaths not directly attributed to COVID-19. We estimated the proportion of people who died from COVID-19 who might have been in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic using simple modelling with explicit assumptions. RESULTS: During the first 10 weeks of the pandemic, there were 101,614 baseline deaths, 41,105 COVID-19 deaths and 14,520 additional deaths. Deaths in care homes increased by 220%, while home and hospital deaths increased by 77% and 90%, respectively. Hospice deaths fell by 20%. Additional deaths were among older people (86% aged ⩾ 75 years), and most occurred in care homes (56%) and at home (43%). We estimate that 22% (13%–31%) of COVID-19 deaths occurred among people who might have been in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic. CONCLUSION: The COVID-19 pandemic has led to a surge in palliative care needs. Health and social care systems must ensure availability of palliative care to support people with severe COVID-19, particularly in care homes.

• • We estimate that just over one in five of all COVID-19 deaths occurred among people who might have been in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic.

• • Health and social care systems must ensure availability of palliative care to support people with severe COVID- 19, particularly in care home settings. • • The need for integrated models of palliative care in care home settings is key, and research to underpin these models is needed.

Approaches to death and dying reveal much of the attitude of society as a whole to the individuals who compose it (Cicely Saunders, 1984) . 1 The COVID-19 pandemic has led to an unprecedented surge in mortality around the world, with some countries such as United Kingdom, the United States and Italy particularly affected. In the United Kingdom and elsewhere, the government response has been focused on prevention and curative treatments. There has been very little emphasis internationally on care needs, including palliative care needs, for people dying during the COVID-19 pandemic. 2 Clinical research and observation has found that people dying with COVID-19 are symptomatic, frequently experiencing breathlessness and agitation near the end of life. 3 Clinical uncertainty around the illness trajectories of those infected increases the complexity of clinical decision-making and communication with patients and family. 4 Deaths occurring during the COVID-19 pandemic are likely to be associated with poorer bereavement outcomes for family and friends and higher distress and support needs among frontline health and social care staff. 5 There is an important role for palliative care, but the palliative care needs of the population have not been described.

Large-scale population-based studies exploring patterns of mortality are important for anticipating numbers of people in need of care and for informing governments about the need to plan and reorganise services. 6, 7 Previous research suggests that up to 82% of people dying in a typical year have palliative care needs. 8 However, the emergence of COVID-19 has changed patterns of mortality. We currently lack an understanding of the palliative care needs for people dying during the COVID-19 pandemic at a population level.

In England and Wales, official mortality data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) reveal that during the first 10 weeks of the pandemic (7 March to 15 May 2020), there were over 41,000 COVID-19 deaths, most occurring in hospitals (65%), with 28% in care homes and few elsewhere (7%). 9 The ONS estimated that there were also over 14,000 'additional' deaths, which were deaths over and above the number of deaths expected based on the 5-year average and which were not certified as caused by Most people dying with COVID-19 are older with underlying health conditions. The extent to which people dying with COVID-19 may have been in their last year of life in the absence of the COVID-19 pandemic has stimulated considerable debate. 10 Estimating this could help inform resource allocation and service planning, since the goals of care for those with a pre-existing advanced progressive or terminal illness may differ from those with no serious health concerns prior to a COVID-19 infection.

This study aims to explore patterns of mortality during the first 10 weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic in England and Wales (7 March to 15 May 2020) to understand implications for palliative care, service planning and research. The objectives are (1) to explore trends in place of death; (2) to explore the age and gender distribution of baseline deaths, COVID-19 deaths and additional deaths; (3) to estimate the proportion of people who died from COVID-19 who would have been in their last year of life, and differences by age; and (4) to use this information to discuss implications for palliative care provision, service planning and research.

Descriptive analysis and population-based modelling using routinely collected mortality data for England and Wales.

We used publicly available data from the ONS including the following: Death registration data have been used in previous studies examining national trends in place of death. 6 In response to the pandemic, the ONS has released weekly death registration data, including deaths involving COVID-19 and place of occurrence for all deaths. Guidance for professionals completing death certificates states that COVID-19 should be included as a contributing or underlying cause of death, when this is suspected even in the absence of laboratory confirmation. 12 

We first defined the following mortality categories: baseline deaths, COVID-19 deaths and additional deaths, as detailed in Box 1. The numbers of people in each mortality category were calculated for England and Wales between 7 March (week 11) and 15 May 2020 (week 20) as follows:

1. Baseline deaths. We estimated the baseline deaths according to the average deaths in the 10-week period of interest (weeks 11 to 20) over the years 2015 to 2019, by age and gender.

2. COVID-19 deaths. Data on COVID-19 deaths were obtained from the ONS weekly registered deaths, which include deaths by age, gender and place of occurrence. 9 The ONS produces figures for deaths involving COVID-19 based on any mention of COVID-19 on the death certificate, including when the physician suspects COVID-19 based on symptoms but where no test was available. 9 These figures include deaths outside of hospital. a) People who died from COVID-19 who might have been in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic. First, we derived an estimate of the proportion of the population infected in each age group by re-arranging the following equation:

COVID-19 deaths = total population x proportion infected x infection fatality ratio. The information we used in this equation included the number of registered COVID-19 deaths reported by ONS; 9 the total population from the ONS principal projections 11 and infection fatality ratios by 10-year age groupings obtained from the work by Ferguson et al. 13, 14 (supplementary Table 1 ).

Second, we hypothesised that someone who is in their last year of life will have an increased risk of dying from COVID-19 compared to someone in the same age group who is not in their last year of life. To account for this, we applied a risk of dying multiplier to this group based on evidence of increased risk of death among people with serious conditions (supplementary Table 2 ). We applied a range of multipliers, with our primary estimate based on the median risk of death across different conditions. 15 Therefore, the number of people who die with COVID-19 who would be expected to die within a year was calculated using the following equation:

COVID-19 deaths among those in their last year of life = baseline deaths x proportion infected x infection fatality ratio x risk of dying multiplier 3. Additional deaths. We calculated additional deaths by subtracting the estimated baseline deaths and COVID-19 deaths from all registered deaths on a per week basis over the 10-week period of interest (weeks [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] . This was calculated for each age and gender group separately to identify additional deaths within different demographic categories. Where this resulted in a negative value, the estimated baseline figure was reduced by this amount and the value for additional deaths was zero. 1

Age, gender and place of death. To understand the age and gender distribution of the COVID-19 and additional deaths, we grouped data into four age groups (<45, 45-64, 65-74 and ⩾ 85 years) and compared them with baseline deaths over the period of interest (weeks [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] . We described trends in place of occurrence of deaths using the ONS defined categories of 'hospital' (acute and community, not psychiatric), 'care home' (nursing and residential), 'home', 'hospice' and combined 'other communal' and 'elsewhere'. To estimate additional deaths by place of death over the period, we used place of death data for week 11 to estimate baseline place of death, as weekly place of death information was unavailable for previous years.

We sought the views and experiences of members of our patient and public network regarding their concerns around COVID-19 pandemic. These consultations informed the focus and design of this study. Patient and public involvement (PPI) representatives provided feedback on the article.

This study uses routinely collected anonymised and publicly available data. No ethical approvals were necessary.

Between 7 March and 15 May 2020 (weeks [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] in England and Wales, there were 157,239 deaths registered, of which 41,105 were from COVID-19. We estimate that this included 101,614 baseline deaths (as estimated by average weekly deaths over the same period during 2015-2019) and 14,520 additional deaths ( Figure 1 ). The lower number of deaths observed in week 19 is likely due to a public holiday in that week which delayed the registration of deaths. 9

Where people die in England and Wales has changed ( Figure 2 ). Taking all deaths together, weekly hospital deaths increased by 90% from week 11 (n = 4975) to a peak in week 16 (n = 9434). We observe a 77% increase in home deaths between weeks 11 (n = 2725) and 17 (n = 4834), while care home deaths increased by 220% during the same period (week 11 n = 2471 and week 17 n = 7911). In week 18, care homes temporarily became the most common place to die. Hospice deaths fell by 20% between week 11 (n = 553) and week 19 (n = 441), representing 3% of deaths during the 10-week period.

Most COVID-19 deaths occurred in hospitals (65%) and care homes (28%), with few occurring at home and hospice (5% and 1%, respectively). The location of the additional deaths has not been described. Comparing place of death for additional deaths occurring in weeks 12-20 with week 11, we found the majority of additional deaths occurred in care homes (56%) and at home (43%) (Figure 3 ). During weeks 12-20, there were fewer additional deaths in hospitals and hospices compared to week 11, indicating that there were fewer non-COVID-19 deaths in these settings than usual.

We found the age distribution of COVID-19 deaths to be overall older compared to baseline deaths, with 74% of COVID-19 deaths aged ⩾ 75 years compared to 68% of baseline deaths (Figure 4 ). Additional deaths are older still, with 83% aged ⩾ 75 years and 56% aged ⩾ 85 years. A greater proportion of COVID-19 deaths are male (56%), compared to 49% of baseline deaths and 50% of additional deaths.

Among the people who are registered as dying with COVID-19, we have estimated a group who would be in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic. Using our primary (and lower and upper) estimates for the risk of dying multiplier, we found that 22% (13%-31%) of people who died with COVID-19 over the period of interest were likely to be in their last year of life (Table 1 and supplementary Figure 1 ). This increases with age, such that by ≥ 80 years, 33% (19%-47%) of people who die with COVID are likely in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic.

Using routine data and modelling scenarios to understand mortality patterns during the COVID-19 pandemic, we highlight that care homes temporarily became the most common place to die in England and Wales, and that hospital and home deaths increased by over 50%, while deaths in hospices fell by 20%. We show that people in the additional deaths category are proportionately more likely to be older, and to die in care homes and at home, than those who are certified as dying with COVID-19. Finally, we estimate for the first time that just over one in five COVID-19 deaths occur among people who might be in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic, and that this increases to a third of those aged over 85 years.

Deaths in hospitals and care homes and at home increased during the first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic. Rapid adaptation of models of palliative care is needed at the first sign of subsequent waves of the COVID-19 pandemic or future pandemics to support the increased number of people dying in these settings. Guidance on remote consultations in primary care 16 and on managing distressing symptoms in the community 17 is available to help support care for people with suspected COVID-19, but challenges remain in terms of workforce and equipment. A pilot study of palliative care delivered in care homes via teleconference supported the feasibility of this approach where required. 18 Specialist palliative care provision in care homes is currently variable, [19] [20] [21] and guidance to support palliative care for people with COVID-19 in nursing homes has been found to be lacking and limited in focus. 22 In contrast, deaths in hospices fell during the time period. A similar phenomenon was found during the 2003 SARS pandemic and highlighted the need for seamless continuity of care between settings. 23 Systems that enable hospice resources to rapidly shift from inpatient to community settings are likely to be important in future pandemic peaks. 24 Little has been described about the characteristics of the additional deaths that have occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic. The aetiology of these deaths is not known, in particular whether they are undiagnosed COVID-19 deaths or deaths associated with the pandemic without being a result of the disease (e.g. due to avoidance of urgent healthcare). 25 There is emerging evidence that older people with COVID-19 may present with non-specific and atypical symptoms such as delirium or low-grade fever. 26 We found that the additional deaths group comprises predominantly older people in care homes, suggesting that these may be undiagnosed COVID-19 deaths. Irrespective of aetiology, this group are likely to have significant palliative care needs. The characteristics of the additional deaths population is likely to change as the pandemic progresses, and deferred harm from missed routine check-ups or screening becomes more likely. 27 At a population level, we estimate that 22% of COVID-19 deaths occur among people who might have been in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic, and that among those aged > 85 years, 33% might be in their last year of life. For those with advanced conditions living at home and in care homes, guidelines recommend that general practitioners (GPs), community healthcare staff and community geriatricians urgently review advance care plans with patients and their families and discuss their care preferences in the case of contracting COVID-19. 17, 28 These discussions are challenging, particularly when conducted over the telephone. Specialist palliative care services may play a role in offering advice and support for conducting difficult conversations in difficult situations.

While the focus of this article is COVID-19, it should be noted that baseline deaths outnumber COVID-19 and additional deaths. Previous modelling has shown that around 69%-82% of the baseline group are likely to have palliative care needs. 8 COVID-19 will impact this group, for example, through fewer face-to-face contacts and potentially less availability of specialist palliative care support, as services are suddenly stretched beyond their usual bounds. Informal caregivers are likely to play an important role in caring for those in home settings and may need additional support. 29 Across all mortality categories, there is the need for bereavement support as a result of higher prevalence of complicated grief. 30 There will be the typical grief associated with death and dying, but on a much larger scale. In addition, there will also be novel grief processes, linked to social isolation and distancing, self-blame around infection and not being able to attend funerals. 31 Palliative care specialists with particular expertise in bereavement support have a role in supporting families in coping with bereavement and supporting colleagues to deliver this care alongside other relevant organisations.

Internationally, the COVID-19 pandemic has affected countries at different times and to varying degrees. The United Kingdom has experienced particularly high mortality during the COVID-19 pandemic. 32 A common feature across nations affected by COVID-19 is the high proportion of COVID-19 deaths among care home residents, for example, 34% in South Korea and 51% in France. 33 All countries severely affected by COVID-19 will have a surge in need for palliative care, though country-level factors, such as socio-demographic characteristics, will influence the magnitude of this. National guidance on providing palliative care during pandemics, taking into account the structure of the health and social care system and level of integration of palliative care, is essential. 34

This is the first article to estimate and characterise population-level patterns of mortality during the COVID-19 pandemic in relation to palliative care. We have produced simple models with explicit assumptions to raise questions and stimulate discussion. We calculated additional 15 This study focused on mortality only. Other aspects of palliative care are important to be considered, for example, symptom control, support with difficult conversations, advance care planning, and complex clinical decision-making. 35 There are also longer-term needs among those surviving COVID-19, such as rehabilitation and palliative care, which are likely to be significant and important for service planning but were not modelled here. We have produced population-based models that are useful for strategic health service planning but are not directly applicable to clinical decision-making at an individual level. For example, while we have estimated the number of people dying from COVID-19 who might have been in their last year of life in the absence of the pandemic at the population level, we acknowledge the challenges of prognostication at the individual level. 36 Our estimates used the currently available data on the risk of death from COVID-19 across different conditions, and this multiplier should be revised as more data become available.

A population-level understanding of the palliative care needs of people with severe COVID-19 is essential to guide efficient health service planning, but has been missing from political rhetoric around the world, much of which has been focused on intensive care capacity. Greater support for care homes through closer collaboration with primary care, specialist palliative care services and community geriatricians is needed for now and for future pandemics. 37 Investment in palliative care training and education for social care staff so that they have the skills, competence and confidence to provide care to those approaching the end of life. Given the steep rise in deaths that have occurred in challenging circumstances, ensuring provision of bereavement support should be a priority.

COVID-19 is now the focus of much research, but very few studies are focused on palliative and end of life care. 38, 39 Data and research are urgently required to answer the following questions:

What are the best integrated models of palliative care in care homes that can be adapted for use during the COVID-19 pandemic?

What is the impact of COVID-19 on the hospice sector and how might hospice services best use their available resources?

What is the impact of COVID-19 on complex grief, and what resources are needed to support those experiencing this?

What is the impact of COVID-19 on carers supporting people with palliative care needs in community settings?

Our study has highlighted the high level of need for palliative care during the COVID-19 pandemic. Healthcare systems responding to COVID-19 must consider the need for palliative care surge capacity, including the workforce and equipment, to enable people to be cared for appropriately in all settings. The need for integrated models of palliative care in care home settings is imperative. The rapid changes to practice during the pandemic provide important opportunities for research, evaluation and learning, and it is essential that new models are underpinned by evidence. draft of the manuscript. All authors critically revised the manuscript for intellectual content and approved the final version of the submitted manuscript. The corresponding author attests that all listed authors meet authorship criteria and that no one meeting the criteria have been omitted.

All data are publicly available

The author(s) declared the following potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: All authors have completed the ICMJE uniform disclosure form at www.icmje.org/coi_disclosure.pdf and declare: no support from any organisation for the submitted work; no financial relationships with any organisations that might have an interest in the submitted work in the previous 3 years; no other relationships or activities that could appear to have influenced the submitted work.

World Health Organisation. Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) Pandemic

Characteristics, symptom management and outcomes of 101 patients with COVID-19 referred for hospital palliative care

The importance of addressing advance care planning and decisions about do-not-resuscitate orders during novel coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19)

Bereavement support on the frontline of COVID-19: recommendations for hospital clinicians

What is the impact of population ageing on the future provision of end-oflife care? Population-based projections of place of death

How many people will need palliative care in 2040? Past trends, future projections and implications for services

How many people need palliative care? A study developing and comparing methods for population-based estimates

How much 'normal' risk does Covid represent

Principal projection -England and Wales population in age groups

Guidance for doctors completing medical certificates of cause of death in England and Wales for use during the emergency period only

Impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to reduce COVID-19 mortality and healthcare demand

Global Covid-19 Case Fatality Rates

Risk factors for mortality in patients with Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies

Covid-19: a remote assessment in primary care

COVID-19 rapid guideline: managing symptoms (including at the end of life) in the community

Early integration of palliative care in a long-term care home: a telemedicine feasibility pilot study

A survey of end-of-life care in care homes: issues of definition and practice

Palliative care provision in long-term care facilities differs across Europe: results of a cross-sectional study in six European countries (PACE)

Strategies for the implementation of palliative care education and organizational interventions in long-term care facilities: a scoping review

International COVID-19 palliative care guidance for nursing homes leaves key themes unaddressed

Hospice utilization during the SARS outbreak in Taiwan

The role and response of palliative care and hospice services in epidemics and pandemics: a rapid review to inform practice during the COVID-19 pandemic

What is happening to non-covid deaths?

Atypical presentation of COVID-19 in a frail older person

Collateral damage: the impact on cancer outcomes of the COVID-19 pandemic. Medrxiv. Epub ahead of print 28

COVID-19: managing the COVID-19 pandemic in care homes for older people

Administration of endof-life drugs by family caregivers during covid-19 pandemic

Complicated grief after death of a relative in the intensive care unit

Grief during the COVID-19 pandemic: considerations for palliative care providers

Coronavirus pandemic -country comparisons

Mortality associated with COVID-19 outbreaks in care homes: early international evidence. International Long Term Care Policy Network

Global Atlas of Palliative Care at the End of Life

Crisis symptom management and patient communication protocols are important tools for all clinicians responding to COVID-19

Prognostication in palliative care

Commentary: COVID in care homes -challenges and dilemmas in healthcare delivery

Urgent Public Health COVID-19 Studies

UK Research Innovation. COVID-19 research and innovation supported by UKRI

We are grateful for the critical review from Janice Tausig, Richard Meade, Scott Murray and Helen Findlay. 

Supplemental material for this article is available online.