key: cord-323898-054gv684
authors: Khan, Anas A.; AlRuthia, Yazed; Balkhi, Bander; Alghadeer, Sultan M.; Temsah, Mohamad-Hani; Althunayyan, Saqer M.; Alsofayan, Yousef M.
title: Survival and Estimation of Direct Medical Costs of Hospitalized COVID-19 Patients in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (Short Title: COVID-19 Survival and Cost in Saudi Arabia)
date: 2020-10-13
journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health
DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17207458
sha: 
doc_id: 323898
cord_uid: 054gv684

Objectives: Assess the survival of hospitalized coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) patients across age groups, sex, use of mechanical ventilators (MVs), nationality, and intensive care unit (ICU) admission in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Methods: Data were retrieved from the Saudi Ministry of Health (MoH) between 1 March and 29 May 2020. Kaplan–Meier (KM) analyses and multiple Cox proportional-hazards regression were conducted to assess the survival of hospitalized COVID-19 patients from hospital admission to discharge (censored) or death. Micro-costing was used to estimate the direct medical costs associated with hospitalization per patient. Results: The number of included patients with complete status (discharge or death) was 1422. The overall 14-day survival was 0.699 (95%CI: 0.652–0.741). Older adults (>70 years) (HR = 5.00, 95%CI = 2.83–8.91), patients on MVs (5.39, 3.83–7.64), non-Saudi patients (1.37, 1.01–1.89), and ICU admission (2.09, 1.49–2.93) were associated with a high risk of mortality. The mean cost per patient (in SAR) for those admitted to the general Medical Ward (GMW) and ICU was 42,704.49 ± 29,811.25 and 79,418.30 ± 55,647.69, respectively. Conclusion: The high hospitalization costs for COVID-19 patients represents is a significant public health challenge. Efficient allocation of healthcare resources cannot be emphasized enough.

Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID- 19) has affected every continent on Earth, and the number of confirmed cases has exceeded 9 million worldwide [1] . As more details about COVID-19 and its associated risk factors have surfaced, the diagnostic and clinical features, treatment, typical clinical course, and monitoring which distinguish the virus that causes COVID-19, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), have become clear. However, there remain inconsistencies in disease severity among patients and mortality among different countries that hamper the assessment and triage of patients [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] .

The overall case fatality rate (CFR) of COVID-19 has been estimated be~0.7% (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.4-1.0) and to range from 0.001% to 10.1% among those under 20 and over 80 years of age, respectively [7] . Moreover, it has been reported that the CFR can reach as high as 17% in the Northern regions of Italy [8] . In China, Yan-ni and colleagues estimated the CFR to be 6.1 ± 2.9% [9] . However, the CFR can be as high as 28% among hospitalized patients [10] .

Although the rate of hospitalization among patients confirmed to have COVID-19 is <5%,~19% of hospitalized patients in France are transferred to the intensive care unit (ICU) [7] . The median length of l stay (LOS) for COVID-19 patients has been reported to be ≤8 days based on a Chinese study; however, larger studies may be needed to better understand the course of COVID-19 after ICU admission [6, 11] . In addition, the LOS varied significantly between countries even before the pandemic [11] . In Saudi Arabia, the rate of hospitalization among all confirmed COVID-19 cases during March 2020 was 71.6% according to Alsofayan and colleagues, but the mortality rate was as low as 0.65% [12] . This high reported rate of hospitalization among COVID-19 cases may exacerbate the cost burden of viral respiratory infections in a country that was deeply affected by the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS) in 2012, and resulted in a huge financial burden with an estimated direct medical cost per patient of SAR 48,551.36 (United States dollars (USD) 12,947.03) [13] .

In light of the high rate of hospitalization among COVID-19 patients in Saudi Arabia, there is a need to identify different sociodemographic (e.g., age, sex) and medical (e.g., mechanical ventilator (MMV) use, ICU admission) status that might increase mortality risk. Moreover, the cost of hospitalization should be estimated. Providing government officials and clinicians with clear guidance on the risk factors, mortality rate, and how to prioritize screening, testing, isolation or quarantining of COVID-19 cases is imperative to manage this pandemic effectively and efficiently.

Here, we investigated the survival of hospitalized COVID-19 patients in Saudi Arabia across age groups, sex, nationality, MV use, and ICU admission. Furthermore, the average cost of hospitalization due to COVID-19 per patient was estimated.

This study protocol was approved by the Ethics Review Board Committee of the Central Ministry of Health (20-75M) in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

The data of this study were retrieved from the Health Electronic Surveillance Network (HESN) database of the Saudi Ministry of Health (MoH) for COVID-19 patients. All symptomatic patients with confirmed COVID-19 after being tested in outpatient settings and confirmed in inpatient settings upon admission in Saudi hospitals from 1 March to 29 May 2020 were included. The retrieved variables were age, sex, nationality (Saudi vs. non-Saudi), city, hospital, date of hospital admission, date of discharge from hospital, MV use, inpatient environment (ICU vs. General Medical Ward (GMW)), and final status (discharge vs. death). Data on comorbidities were missing for most cases. No re-admissions for the COVID-19 patients were encountered in the retrieved data. All consecutive patients were assumed to receive standardized treatment protocols for COVID-19 as posted on the MoH website, and these protocols were (and are still being) updated on a regular basis.

The cost of hospitalization was estimated using the micro-costing method as stated in the protocols for COVID-19 management set by the MoH. The cost of hospitalization was based on the cost of: all medications (e.g., antivirals, antibiotics, anticoagulants, hydroxychloroquine); personal protective equipment (e.g., N95 masks, gowns, protective eyewear); oxygen; MVs; isolation-room fees (ICU vs. GMW); fees of physicians and other medical staff; laboratory and diagnostic tests (e.g., polymerase chain reaction, complete blood count, liver/cardiac enzymes, swabs, cultures, radiographs and computed tomography of the chest). Data on inpatient costs were retrieved from the MoH Cost Center. The cost is presented in Saudi riyals (SAR).

This was a retrospective cohort study upon which COVID-19 patients were followed up retrospectively between 1 March and 29 May 2020 from the date of hospital admission to discharge from hospital with final status which was either death or discharged alive (censored). Those without any update on their status were excluded.

Kaplan-Meier (KM) survival analyses were created to examine the survival probability overall as well as across age groups. Moreover, the survival probability was estimated across MV use and sex, nationality (Saudi vs. non-Saudi), and inpatient environment (ICU vs. GMW). Comparisons of different strata were adjusted using Tukey's method. The hazard ratio (HR) for death was generated using multiple Cox proportional-hazards regression that included the variables of: MV use (no vs. yes), age, sex (female vs. male), and inpatient environment (ICU vs. GMW). Significance was considered at α < 0.05, and the 95%CI is shown for different strata in all KM survival curves and reported for all HRs. Statistical analyses were conducted using SAS ® v9.4 (SAS, Cary, NC, USA).

The number of patients hospitalized due to COVID-19 between 1 March 2020 and 29 May 2020 was 6575. However, 5153 patients were not listed as having a final status (discharged alive or death) in the HESN database as of 29 May 2020. Therefore, only 1422 patients with final status (discharged alive or death) were eligible to be included in our analyses ( Figure 1 ). The majority of the patients were male (77.71%), and between 25 and 54 years of age (67.65%). Most patients were non-Saudi (68.78%), and from Medina (57.95%). Only 15% of patients were admitted to the ICU, and MV use was indicated in 13% (Table 1) . About 16% of patients (263 patients) died in hospital. The median LOS was 7.93 days, with a maximum LOS of 43 days. The overall mean survival time from admission to final status (discharged alive or death) for the study cohort was 21 days with differences across different variables (Table 2 ). Older COVID-19 patients had a significantly shorter mean duration of survival compared with their younger counterparts (p < 0.0001). Patients on MVs had a significantly shorter mean duration of survival compared with those not on MVs (8.87 vs. 18.93 days, p < 0.0001). Likewise, those admitted in ICUs had a significantly shorter mean duration of survival compared with those admitted to other inpatient environments (11.13 vs. 18.89 days, p < 0.0001). The survival probability (which was estimated using KM curves in all cases) of the overall study cohort from hospital admission up to the second day of hospitalization was estimated to be 0. Figure 6 ). For each 1-year increase in age, the death risk increased by an estimated 2.3% (HR = 1.023, p < 0.0001). The risk of death among patients on MVs was five-times higher compared with their counterparts who were not on MVs (HR = 5.15, p < 0.0001). The death risk for non-Saudi patients was 36% higher than that of their Saudi counterparts (HR = 1.36, p = 0.049). Furthermore, the death risk for patients admitted to the ICU was more than twice that of their counterparts admitted to the GMW (HR = 2.08, p < 0.0001). Being female was not associated with a lower risk of death (HR = 0.944, p = 0.725). The adjusted HRs with their 95%CIs are shown in Table 3 and Figure 7 . 

The COVID-19 pandemic has had a detrimental effect on global healthcare systems, and affected every aspect of human and economic life [14] . As of 22 June 2020, the number of COVID-19 cases in Saudi Arabia has exceeded 161,000, with an estimated case fatality rate (CFR) of 0.81% [15] . The reported CFR is far below that of France, Belgium, Spain, Italy, and the UK, which have reported a CFR between 11.5% (Spain) to 16% (Belgium) [1, 5, 16] . However, the CFR among hospitalized COVID-19 patients is far higher than the population-level CFR. Our study (which is the first to report the survival probability across age groups, sex, nationality, MV use, and ICU admission among a sample of hospitalized COVID-19 patients in Saudi Arabia) revealed the CFR to be 16.6%. This CFR is far below the reported CFR among hospitalized patients in the UK (33%) [17] (Docherty et al., 2020), Italy (27%) [18] , and the USA (21%) [19] . In addition, the percentage of hospitalized patients treated in the ICU or who received invasive ventilation was similar to the one reported in the USA [19] .

The overall 30-day mortality among our cohort was 16.6%, but the 14-day mortality (15.81%) represented >91% of deaths. This finding suggests that the first 14 days of hospitalization are critical for COVID-19 patients, which has also been reported among a sample of hospitalized Italian patients with COVID-19 [18] . The overall 14-day and 30-day survival probability (using KM curves) was 0.699 and 0.459, respectively. This observation is consistent with a study conducted in Sichuan Province in China, which found that the LOS was associated with higher risk of death [20] . Older adults were at a significantly higher risk of death compared with those in other age groups, a finding that is in accordance with the work of other scholars [21, 22] . This higher risk of mortality among ICU patients aligns with the findings of research studies among hospitalized COVID-19 patients [23] . Although most hospitalized patients were male, the risk of mortality was not higher among male patients in comparison with their female counterparts. This finding contradicts the observations of other scholars who showed a higher risk of mortality among hospitalized male patients with COVID-19 [24, 25] . Patients on MVs had a more than five-times higher risk of death compared with their counterparts not on MVs, a finding that is similar to data from Auld and colleagues [26] . Pareek and collaborators reported that ethnicity may have a role in the survival of COVID-19 patients [27] . We found that hospitalized non-Saudi patients were at a slightly higher risk of mortality. This could be attributable to the fact that many non-Saudi patients who were hospitalized for COVID-19 did not have legal residence status, and lack health insurance coverage prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. However, this could change if other diseases (e.g., diabetes mellitus, asthma, hypertension, cardiovascular diseases, or chronic renal failure) were controlled for in the analysis.

A major concern about the COVID-19 pandemic is the high cost burden to healthcare systems. We calculated the direct medical cost associated with treatment of COVID-19 patients in Saudi Arabia. The cost of COVID-19 treatment was calculated based on MoH treatment protocols and accounted for all health resources used to deliver care to COVID-19 patients. Our cost data highlighted differences in resource utilization between patients presenting with moderate-to-severe symptoms versus critical cases who required ICU admission. Our cost analyses illustrated that the mean direct medical cost of patients with moderate-to-severe COVID-19 symptoms admitted to the GMW was SAR 5303.21per patient per day, which was much lower compared with the mean cost per patient per day for patients admitted to the ICU (e.g., SAR 9727.41). However, the difference in the mean cost per patient per day between patients who needed MVs and those who did not need them was SAR 2244.42 and SAR 3405.42 among patients admitted in GMW and ICU, respectively.

The total direct medical cost per patient was calculated based on the level of care and LOS. The total direct medical cost per patient for those with moderate-to-severe symptoms admitted to the GMW was SAR 42,704.49. However, there was an approximate twofold increase in the cost for ICU patients (e.g., SAR 79,418.30). Interestingly, the total cost for patients on MVs was slightly lower in comparison with their counterparts admitted to the GMW but who were not on MVs. This finding was largely attributable to a significantly shorter duration of survival and higher rate of mortality among patients on MVs, which translated to a shorter LOS and, eventually, lower total cost per patient. However, this finding is not consistent with data from a study by Rae and colleagues, who reported that patients on MVs often required a longer hospital stay with a higher cost of healthcare-resource utilization [28] .

There is a dearth of data about the direct medical cost of COVID-19 in the Middle East. Very few scholars have assessed the financial impact on healthcare systems worldwide. The mean direct medical cost per patient (in USD) has been reported to be 2395 in China [29] , 10,000 in Canada [30] and 4633.43 in India [31] . A study published recently in the USA reported the mean cost of treatment of patients with mild COVID-19 who were not hospitalized ranged from USD 32 for consultation over the telephone to USD 96 for a clinic visit [32] . Those data are in accordance with our observations because mild cases are often not hospitalized and used medications mainly for relief from fever or pain only. Moreover, that USA study estimated the median direct medical cost of caring for patients with moderate COVID-19 symptoms who did not require hospitalization but had to be seen at Emergency Department was USD 3045, and was USD 14,366 for those with more severe symptoms that necessitated hospitalization. Based on those estimates, the total direct medical cost in the USA has been projected to range from USD 163.4 billion to USD 654.0 billion [32] . In Sweden, the total direct medical cost has been projected to reach USD 2 billion [33] . The mean direct medical cost per patient we estimated was SAR 48,436.18 (USD 12,916.31), which was not significantly different from the one reported for the management of a MERS-CoV patient in Saudi Arabia (USD 12,947.03) [13] . However, the total direct medical cost of COVID-19 far exceeds the one reported for MERS-CoV due to the high number of COVID-19 infections that are being reported on a daily basis. These variations in cost estimates across countries highlight the challenges in estimating and comparing the direct medical costs globally given the vast differences in the cost of treatment protocols, personnel cost, and utilization rates of healthcare resources and their prices between countries.

Our study had four main limitations. First, we did not include all hospitalized patients in Saudi Arabia, which limits the generalizability of our findings. Second, variables such as comorbidities (e.g., diabetes mellitus, asthma, cancer, hypertension, chronic kidney disease), smoking status, and occupation were not investigated, which may have changed our findings if they had been controlled for in our analyses. Additionally, the study did not control for the changes in the treatment protocols and their potential impact on mortality rates. Third, this study was conducted from the perspective of healthcare payers, and did not take into consideration other important costs, such as productivity losses and "lockdown" costs. Therefore, the economic impact of COVID-19 would have been much greater. Fourth, the outcomes for patients who were discharged alive (censored) cannot be ascertained as some discharged patients may have died or readmitted afterwards.

Future research should examine the: (i) survival probability for hospitalized COVID-19 patients controlling for comorbidities and other potential confounders; (ii) cost of COVID-19 on other important sectors of the economy; (iii) total direct medical costs of COVID-19 to the Saudi Arabia healthcare system.

An interactive web-based dashboard to track COVID-19 in real time

Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in

Systematic review of COVID-19 in children shows milder cases and a better prognosis than adults

The Novel Coronavirus Pneumonia Emergency Response Epidemiology Team The Epidemiological Characteristics of an Outbreak of 2019 Novel Coronavirus Diseases (COVID-19)-China, 2020

Case-Fatality Rate and Characteristics of Patients Dying in Relation to COVID-19 in Italy

Clinical course and risk factors for mortality of adult inpatients with COVID-19 in Wuhan, China: A retrospective cohort study

Case fatality rate analysis of Italian COVID-19 outbreak

Estimating the instant case fatality rate of COVID-19 in China

Estimates of the severity of coronavirus disease 2019: A model-based analysis

Intensive care management of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): Challenges and recommendations

Clinical characteristics of COVID-19 in Saudi Arabia: A national retrospective study

Estimation of Direct Medical Costs of Middle East Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus Infection: A Single-Center Retrospective Chart Review Study

The socio-economic implications of the coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19): A review

Saudi Ministry of Health (MOH) COVID-19 Media Center

Cross-country comparison of case fatality rates of COVID-19/ SARS-COV-2. Osong Public Health Res

Features of 16,749 hospitalised UK patients with COVID-19 using the ISARIC WHO Clinical Characterisation Protocol

Survival of hospitalized COVID-19 patients in Northern Italy: A population-based cohort study by the ITA-COVID19 Network

The Northwell COVID-19 Research Consortium. Presenting Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes among 5700 Patients Hospitalized with COVID-19 in the

Survival analysis of hospital length of stay of novel coronavirus (COVID-19) pneumonia patients in Sichuan, China

Predictors of mortality for patients with COVID-19 pneumonia caused by SARS-CoV-2: A prospective cohort study

Predictors of mortality in hospitalized COVID-19 patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Prevalence and risk factors of mortality among hospitalized patients with COVID-19: A systematic review and Meta-analysis

Gender Differences in Patients with COVID-19: Focus on Severity and Mortality. Front

COVID-19: The gendered impacts of the outbreak

ICU and Ventilator Mortality among Critically Ill Adults with Coronavirus Disease

Ethnicity and COVID-19: An urgent public health research priority

Potential Costs of Coronavirus Treatment for People with Employer Coverage. Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker Website

China Spends $2395 on Average for each COVID-19 Patient

Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of public health measures to control COVID-19: A modelling study

Rs 3.5 Lakh Spent on Each Covid-19 Patient in Victoria Hospital: Karnataka Minister

The Potential Health Care Costs and Resource Use Associated with COVID-19 in The United States. Health Aff

Covid-19 health care demand and mortality in Sweden in response to non-pharmaceutical (NPIs) mitigation and suppression scenarios

This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license