key: cord-301416-rfrbgnft
authors: Kashnitsky, Ilya; Aburto, José Manuel
title: COVID-19 in unequally ageing European regions
date: 2020-08-28
journal: World Dev
DOI: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2020.105170
sha: 
doc_id: 301416
cord_uid: rfrbgnft

The map presented in this brief note summarizes regional differences in population age structures between the NUTS-3 regions of Europe in the context of unequal age- and sex-specific death risks associated with the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic. Since older people are exposed to much higher death risks, older populations are expected to face much more difficult challenges coping with the pandemic. The urban/rural dimension turns out to be very important as the remote rural areas are also the oldest. In the map NUTS-3 regions of Europe are colored according to the deviation from European pooled estimate of the proportion of population at risk of death due to COVID-19. We assume that 5/6 of the populations get infected and experience age-specific infection-fatality ratios (IFRs) modelled by the Imperial College COVID-19 Response Team. We adjust IFRs by sex ratios of age-specific case-fatality ratios observed in the European countries that are included in the COVerAGE-DB. Thus, we effectively introduce a summary measure of population age structures focused on the most vulnerable to the pandemic. Such an estimate for the total European population is 1%. The map reflects the unequal population age structures rather than the precise figures on COVID-19 fatality. It is a case-if scenario that highlights the possible effect of the population age structures, a demographic perspective. This analysis clearly shows the contribution of regional differences in population age structures to the magnitude of the pandemic -- other things equal, we expect to see a four-fold variation in average regional infection-fatality ratios across Europe due only to differences in the population structures.

proportion of population at risk of death due to COVID-19. We assume that 5/6 of the populations get infected and experience age-specific infection-fatality ratios (IFRs) modelled by the Imperial College COVID-19 Response Team. We adjust IFRs by sex ratios of agespecific case-fatality ratios observed in the European countries that are included in the COVerAGE-DB. Thus, we effectively introduce a summary measure of population age structures focused on the most vulnerable to the pandemic. Such an estimate for the total European population is 1%. The map reflects the unequal population age structures rather than the precise figures on COVID-19 fatality. It is a case-if scenario that highlights the possible effect of the population age structures, a demographic perspective. This analysis clearly shows the contribution of regional differences in population age structures to the magnitude of the pandemic --other things equal, we expect to see a four-fold variation in average regional infection-fatality ratios across Europe due only to differences in the population structures.

The COVID-19 pandemic is unequally claiming lives across age groups. Since death risks increase sharply with age for people infected by SARS-CoV-2 (Ferguson et al., 2020) , the new coronavirus poses great challenges to populations with larger proportions of fragile people at older ages. Differences in population age compositions partly explain the spread and the crude fatality measures of the disease . Looking at population age structures is therefore critically important to assess the potential impact of COVID-19 on mortality in Europe, the oldest part of the world with considerable variations in the degree of ageing (Kashnitsky & Schöley, 2018) . We explore differences in population age structures across European NUTS-3 regions 1 (Eurostat, 2019) focusing on the crude estimate of the proportion of population expected to die due to COVID-19 (see Figure 1 ). We assume that 5/6 of the populations get infected and experience age-specific infection-fatality ratios (IFRs) modelled by the Imperial College COVID-19 Response Team (Ferguson et al., 2020) . We adjust IFRs by sex ratios of age-specific case-fatality ratios observed for the pooled population of all the European countries in the COVerAGE database (Riffe & Acosta, 2020) . Thus, we effectively introduce a summary measure of population age structures focused on the most vulnerable to the pandemic. The map in Figure 1 summarizes regional differences in population age structures between the NUTS-3 regions of Europe in the context of unequal age-and sexspecific death risks associated with the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic.

This approach requires careful consideration of the assumptions and limitations and the lack of high-quality data on the unfolding pandemic. The proportions of population at risk of death can predict the pandemic tolls only if (1) the age-specific profile of IFRs stays as modelled and (2) 5/6 of the population get infected (3) uniformly across regions. This is unlikely to hold true by the end of the pandemic as multiple non-pharmaceutical interventions have been put in place and others have been suggested . Estimates of IFRs move upwards as more outcomes of the infection are known and downwards as more mild cases are registered (Russell et al., 2020) . The final proportion of the population infected is difficult to predict and depends on the interventions taken that vary across countries and regions . Finally, other dimensions of structural differences in the populations may play an important role in the way the pandemic spreads. i.e. health inequalities (Nepomuceno et al., 2020) or the compositional structure of the households (Esteve et al., 2020) .

Despite the limitations, the regional differences in age structures shown here are relevant for the story of the unfolding pandemic and can inform potential scenarios in Europe, as long as the relative differences in fatality between age groups stay proportional.

Unlike the data on COVID-19, data on European population age structures are of great quality and shed light on the possible hotspots of the ongoing pandemic, which is highly relevant for planning public health interventions. The map reflects the unequal population age structures rather than the precise figures on COVID-19 fatality. Within Europe, population age structure differences alone can cause four-fold differences in the exposure to COVID19 death risks.

The map highlights that if the spread of the disease is not mitigated, the most affected regions are likely to be the remote periphery with relatively old populations, which in some countries are also less likely to have enough access to healthcare (Verhagen et al., 2020) . The first months of fighting the pandemic in Europe showed that the unprecedented interventions were mostly successful but we are nowhere close to herd immunity even in the most affected areas (Vollmer et al., 2020) , and the possibility of the second wave cannot be excluded. 

Highlights -European regions are ageing unequally -The COVID-19 pandemic is hardest in the elderly populations -Population age structures alone may account for four-fold variation in average regional infection-fatality ratios across Europe

Social network-based distancing strategies to flatten the COVID-19 curve in a post-lockdown world

Demographic science aids in understanding the spread and fatality rates of COVID-19

National age and coresidence patterns shape COVID-19 vulnerability

Population on 1 January by age, sex and NUTS 3 region

Impact of nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to reduce COVID19 mortality and healthcare demand

Estimating the number of infections and the impact of nonpharmaceutical interventions on COVID-19 in 11 European countries

Regional population structures at a glance. The Lancet

Besides population age structure, health and other demographic factors can contribute to understanding the COVID-19 burden

COVerAGE-DB: A database of COVID-19 cases and deaths by age

Estimating the infection and case fatality ratio for coronavirus disease (COVID-19) using age-adjusted data from the outbreak on the Diamond Princess cruise ship

Forecasting spatial, socioeconomic and demographic variation in COVID-19 health care demand in England and Wales

Report 20: A sub-national analysis of the rate of transmission of Covid-19 in Italy

The global impact of COVID-19 and strategies for mitigation and suppression