id sid tid token lemma pos cord-343877-jzkaee16 1 1 key key JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 1 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 2 cord-343877-jzkaee16 cord-343877-jzkaee16 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 3 authors author NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 4 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 5 Newdick Newdick NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 6 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 7 Chris Chris NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 8 ; ; : cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 9 Sheehan Sheehan NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 11 Mark Mark NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 12 ; ; : cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 13 Dunn Dunn NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 2 14 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 3 1 Michael Michael NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 3 2 title title NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 3 3 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 1 Tragic tragic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 2 choices choice NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 3 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 4 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 5 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 6 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 8 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 9 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 10 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 11 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 12 fairness fairness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 14 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 15 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 16 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 17 date date NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 18 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 19 2020 2020 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 20 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 21 08 08 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 22 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 23 07 07 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 24 journal journal NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 25 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 26 J J NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 27 Med Med NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 28 Ethics Ethics NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 29 DOI doi NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 4 30 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 5 1 10.1136 10.1136 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 5 2 / / SYM cord-343877-jzkaee16 5 3 medethics-2020 medethics-2020 NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 5 4 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 5 5 106487 106487 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 6 1 sha sha NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 6 2 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 6 3 bbc9aff34357404c237fd5c11b71ec2d7bf781c5 bbc9aff34357404c237fd5c11b71ec2d7bf781c5 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 6 4 doc_id doc_id NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 6 5 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 6 6 343877 343877 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 6 7 cord_uid cord_uid NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 6 8 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 7 1 jzkaee16 jzkaee16 NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 1 Tragic tragic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 2 choices choice NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 3 arise arise VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 4 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 6 COVID-19 covid-19 JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 7 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 8 when when WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 10 limited limited JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 11 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 12 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 13 available available JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 14 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 15 acute acute JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 16 medical medical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 17 settings setting NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 18 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 19 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 20 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 21 accessed access VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 22 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 23 all all DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 24 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 25 who who WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 26 need need VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 27 them -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 8 28 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 2 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 3 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 5 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 6 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 7 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 8 unavoidable unavoidable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 9 9 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 3 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 4 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 5 any any DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 6 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 7 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 8 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 9 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 11 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 12 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 14 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 15 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 16 recognised recognise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 19 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 20 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 21 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 22 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 23 upholds uphold VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 24 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 25 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 26 through through IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 27 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 28 fair fair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 29 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 30 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 31 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 32 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 33 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 34 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 35 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 10 36 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 1 Responding respond VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 2 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 3 recent recent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 4 calls call NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 5 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 6 1 1 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 7 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 8 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 9 safeguard safeguard VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 10 individuals individual NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 11 ’ ’ POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 12 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 13 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 14 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 15 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 16 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 17 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 18 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 19 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 20 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 21 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 23 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 24 2 2 LS cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 25 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 26 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 27 new new JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 28 authoritative authoritative JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 29 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 30 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 31 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 32 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 33 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 34 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 35 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 36 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 37 paper paper NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 38 seeks seek VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 39 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 40 clarify clarify VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 41 what what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 42 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 43 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 44 fairness fairness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 45 demand demand NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 46 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 47 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 48 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 49 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 50 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 51 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 52 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 53 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 54 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 55 both both CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 56 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 57 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 58 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 59 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 60 standpoint standpoint NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 11 61 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 2 paper paper NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 3 begins begin VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 4 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 5 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 6 brief brief JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 7 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 8 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 9 UK UK NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 10 law law NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 11 concerning concern VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 12 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 13 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 14 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 16 considering consider VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 17 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 18 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 19 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 20 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 21 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 22 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 23 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 24 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 25 marshalled marshal VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 26 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 27 judicial judicial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 28 deliberation deliberation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 29 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 30 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 31 use use NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 32 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 33 limited limited JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 34 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 35 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 36 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 37 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 38 National National NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 39 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 40 Service Service NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 41 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 42 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 43 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 12 44 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 3 then then RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 4 argued argue VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 5 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 6 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 7 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 8 distinction distinction NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 9 needs need VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 11 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 12 drawn draw VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 13 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 14 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 15 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 16 outcome outcome JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 17 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 18 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 19 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 20 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 21 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 22 procedurally procedurally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 23 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 24 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 25 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 26 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 27 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 28 ought ought MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 29 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 30 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 31 favoured favour VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 13 32 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 1 Congruent congruent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 2 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 4 position position NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 5 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 6 UK UK NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 7 courts court NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 8 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 9 adopted adopt VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 10 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 11 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 12 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 13 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 14 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 15 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 16 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 17 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 18 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 19 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 20 generally generally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 21 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 22 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 23 requirements requirement NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 24 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 25 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 26 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 27 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 28 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 29 substantive substantive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 30 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 31 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 32 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 33 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 34 applied apply VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 35 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 36 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 37 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 38 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 39 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 40 COVID-19 covid-19 JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 41 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 42 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 43 considered consider VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 44 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 45 detail detail NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 14 46 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 1 Tragic tragic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 2 choices choice NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 3 arise arise VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 4 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 6 COVID-19 covid-19 JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 7 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 8 when when WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 10 limited limited JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 11 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 12 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 13 available available JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 14 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 15 acute acute JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 16 medical medical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 17 settings setting NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 18 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 19 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 20 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 21 accessed access VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 22 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 23 all all DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 24 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 25 who who WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 26 need need VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 27 them -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 15 28 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 2 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 3 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 5 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 6 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 7 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 8 unavoidable unavoidable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 16 9 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 3 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 4 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 5 any any DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 6 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 7 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 8 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 9 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 11 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 12 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 14 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 15 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 16 recognised recognise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 19 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 20 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 21 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 22 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 23 upholds uphold VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 24 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 25 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 26 through through IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 27 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 28 fair fair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 29 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 30 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 31 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 32 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 33 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 34 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 35 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 17 36 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 1 Responding respond VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 2 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 3 recent recent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 4 calls call NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 5 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 6 1 1 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 7 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 8 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 9 safeguard safeguard VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 10 individuals individual NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 11 ' ' POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 12 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 13 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 14 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 15 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 16 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 17 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 18 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 19 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 20 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 21 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 23 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 24 2 2 LS cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 25 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 26 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 27 new new JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 28 authoritative authoritative JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 29 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 30 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 31 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 32 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 33 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 34 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 35 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 36 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 37 paper paper NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 38 seeks seek VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 39 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 40 clarify clarify VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 41 what what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 42 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 43 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 44 fairness fairness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 45 demand demand NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 46 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 47 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 48 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 49 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 50 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 51 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 52 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 53 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 54 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 55 both both CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 56 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 57 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 58 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 59 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 60 standpoint standpoint NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 18 61 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 2 paper paper NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 3 begins begin VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 4 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 5 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 6 brief brief JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 7 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 8 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 9 UK UK NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 10 law law NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 11 concerning concern VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 12 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 13 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 14 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 16 considering consider VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 17 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 18 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 19 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 20 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 21 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 22 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 23 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 24 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 25 marshalled marshal VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 26 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 27 judicial judicial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 28 deliberation deliberation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 29 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 30 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 31 use use NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 32 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 33 limited limited JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 34 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 35 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 36 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 37 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 38 National National NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 39 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 40 Service Service NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 41 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 42 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 43 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 19 44 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 3 then then RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 4 argued argue VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 5 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 6 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 7 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 8 distinction distinction NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 9 needs need VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 11 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 12 drawn draw VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 13 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 14 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 15 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 16 outcome outcome JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 17 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 18 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 19 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 20 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 21 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 22 procedurally procedurally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 23 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 24 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 25 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 26 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 27 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 28 ought ought MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 29 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 30 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 31 favoured favour VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 20 32 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 1 Congruent congruent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 2 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 4 position position NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 5 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 6 UK UK NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 7 courts court NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 8 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 9 adopted adopt VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 10 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 11 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 12 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 13 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 14 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 15 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 16 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 17 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 18 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 19 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 20 generally generally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 21 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 22 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 23 requirements requirement NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 24 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 25 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 26 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 27 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 28 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 29 substantive substantive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 30 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 31 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 32 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 33 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 34 applied apply VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 35 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 36 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 37 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 38 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 39 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 40 COVID-19 covid-19 JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 41 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 42 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 43 considered consider VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 44 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 45 detail detail NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 21 46 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 1 What what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 2 happens happen VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 3 if if IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 4 demand demand NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 5 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 6 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 7 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 8 exceeds exceed VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 10 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 11 facilities facility NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 12 available available JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 22 13 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 23 1 How how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 23 2 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 23 3 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 23 4 decide decide VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 23 5 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 23 6 us -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 23 7 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 2 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 3 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 4 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 5 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 6 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 7 questions question NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 8 pressing press VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 9 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 10 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 11 across across IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 12 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 13 world world NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 14 much much JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 15 attention attention NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 16 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 17 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 18 paid pay VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 19 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 20 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 21 actual actual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 22 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 23 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 24 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 25 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 26 expected expect VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 27 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 28 make make VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 24 29 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 2 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 3 May May NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 4 2020 2020 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 6 professional professional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 7 bodies body NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 8 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 9 invested invest VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 10 much much JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 11 effort effort NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 12 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 13 generating generate VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 14 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 15 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 16 various various JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 17 forms form NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 18 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 19 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 20 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 21 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 22 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 23 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 24 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 25 - - : cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 26 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 27 almost almost RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 28 all all DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 29 cases case NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 30 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 31 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 32 seems seem VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 33 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 34 permit permit VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 35 unpalatable unpalatable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 36 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 37 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 38 who who WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 39 gets get VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 40 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 25 41 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 26 1 1 1 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 26 2 2 2 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 3 write write VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 6 UK UK NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 7 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 8 coping cope VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 9 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 11 additional additional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 12 demands demand NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 13 placed place VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 14 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 15 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 16 without without IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 17 extensive extensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 18 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 19 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 20 ventilators ventilator NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 21 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 22 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 23 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 24 beds bed NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 27 25 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 1 However however RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 4 experience experience NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 5 clearly clearly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 6 highlights highlight VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 8 need need NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 9 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 10 more more JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 11 systematic systematic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 12 responses response NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 13 associated associate VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 14 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 15 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 16 need need NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 17 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 18 prioritise prioritise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 19 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 20 deprioritise deprioritise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 21 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 22 wide wide JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 23 range range NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 24 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 25 interventions intervention NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 26 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 27 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 28 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 28 29 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 1 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 2 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 3 provoked provoke VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 4 two two CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 5 main main JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 6 responses response NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 7 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 8 ethicists ethicist NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 9 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 10 lawyers lawyer NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 11 concerned concern VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 12 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 13 medical medical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 14 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 15 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 16 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 29 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 1 For for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 2 some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 4 emerging emerge VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 5 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 6 broad broad JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 7 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 8 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 9 produced produce VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 10 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 11 professional professional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 12 bodies body NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 13 does do VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 14 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 15 go go VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 16 far far RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 17 enough enough RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 30 18 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 1 What what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 3 needed need VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 5 so so CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 7 claim claim NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 8 goes go VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 9 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 10 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 11 overarching overarching JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 13 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 14 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 15 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 16 government government NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 17 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 18 commands command VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 19 authority authority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 20 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 21 ensures ensure VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 22 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 23 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 24 fair fair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 25 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 26 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 27 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 31 28 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 1 3 3 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 2 4 4 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 3 For for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 4 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 7 response response NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 8 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 10 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 11 produced produce VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 12 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 13 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 15 assertion assertion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 16 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 17 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 18 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 19 against against IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 20 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 21 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 22 warning warn VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 23 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 24 any any DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 25 compromise compromise NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 26 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 27 normal normal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 28 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 29 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 30 vulnerable vulnerable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 31 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 32 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 33 challenge challenge NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 34 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 35 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 36 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 37 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 38 undertaken undertake VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 39 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 40 caution caution NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 41 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 42 fear fear NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 43 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 44 overlooking overlook VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 45 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 46 ' ' POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 47 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 32 48 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 33 1 5 5 LS cord-343877-jzkaee16 34 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 34 2 take take VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 34 3 issue issue NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 34 4 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 34 5 both both CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 34 6 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 34 7 views view NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 34 8 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 1 Rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 2 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 3 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 4 certainly certainly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 5 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 6 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 7 ad ad FW cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 8 hoc hoc FW cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 9 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 10 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 11 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 12 individual individual NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 13 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 14 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 15 right right NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 16 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 17 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 18 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 19 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 20 meaning mean VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 21 only only RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 22 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 23 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 24 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 25 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 26 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 27 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 28 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 29 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 30 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 31 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 32 valued value VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 35 33 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 1 Indeed indeed RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 3 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 4 overly overly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 5 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 6 individualistic individualistic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 7 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 8 approach approach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 9 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 10 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 11 damages damage NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 12 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 36 13 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 1 Healthcare Healthcare NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 2 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 3 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 4 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 5 imprecise imprecise JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 6 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 7 come come VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 8 into into IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 9 conflict conflict NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 11 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 12 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 13 never never RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 14 contradict contradict VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 15 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 16 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 37 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 3 because because IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 4 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 5 always always RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 6 belong belong VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 7 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 9 scope scope NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 10 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 11 things thing NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 12 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 13 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 14 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 15 value value NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 16 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 17 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 18 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 19 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 20 recognises recognise VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 21 them -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 38 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 2 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 3 sense sense NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 5 because because IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 7 protection protection NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 8 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 9 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 10 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 11 matters matter NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 12 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 14 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 16 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 17 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 18 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 19 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 20 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 21 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 22 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 23 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 24 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 25 safeguard safeguard VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 26 them -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 27 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 28 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 29 way way NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 30 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 31 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 32 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 33 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 34 other other JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 35 things thing NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 36 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 37 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 38 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 39 value value NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 39 40 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 40 1 6 6 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 40 2 7 7 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 2 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 3 provides provide VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 4 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 5 opportunity opportunity NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 6 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 7 rebalance rebalance VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 9 debate debate NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 10 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 11 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 12 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 13 generally generally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 14 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 15 as as RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 16 well well RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 17 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 18 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 19 notions notion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 20 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 21 authority authority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 23 fairness fairness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 24 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 25 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 26 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 27 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 28 concerning concern VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 29 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 30 use use NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 31 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 32 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 33 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 34 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 35 National National NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 36 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 37 Service Service NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 38 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 39 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 40 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 41 ought ought MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 42 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 43 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 44 configured configure VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 41 45 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 42 1 8 8 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 2 starting starting NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 3 point point NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 5 therefore therefore RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 6 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 7 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 8 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 9 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 10 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 11 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 12 properly properly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 13 understood understand VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 43 14 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 2 reject reject VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 4 notion notion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 5 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 6 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 7 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 8 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 9 some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 10 special special JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 11 status status NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 12 independent independent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 13 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 15 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 16 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 17 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 18 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 19 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 20 recognised recognise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 44 21 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 45 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 45 2 9 9 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 45 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 45 4 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 45 5 10 10 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 45 6 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 46 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 46 2 11 11 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 46 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 2 argue argue VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 3 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 4 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 5 law law NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 6 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 7 ethics ethic VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 9 fundamental fundamental JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 10 objective objective NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 12 any any DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 13 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 14 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 15 ration ration VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 16 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 17 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 18 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 19 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 20 serve serve VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 21 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 22 best good JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 23 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 24 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 25 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 26 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 27 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 28 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 29 whole whole NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 30 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 31 responding respond VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 32 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 33 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 34 fairly fairly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 35 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 36 equally equally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 37 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 38 consistently consistently RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 47 39 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 2 order order NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 3 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 4 do do VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 5 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 6 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 7 group group NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 8 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 9 need need VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 11 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 12 balanced balance VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 13 against against IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 15 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 16 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 17 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 18 individuals individual NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 48 19 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 1 Rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 2 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 3 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 4 overlooked overlook VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 5 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 6 balancing balance VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 8 needs need NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 9 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 10 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 11 already already RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 12 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 13 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 14 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 15 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 16 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 17 awaiting await VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 18 admission admission NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 19 because because IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 20 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 21 capacity capacity NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 22 constraints constraint NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 23 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 24 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 25 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 26 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 27 crucial crucial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 28 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 29 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 30 clear clear JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 31 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 32 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 33 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 34 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 35 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 36 balancing balancing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 37 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 38 achieved achieve VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 49 39 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 2 progress progress VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 3 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 4 follows follow VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 5 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 6 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 7 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 8 A a NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 9 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 10 Balancing balance VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 11 Individual Individual NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 12 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 13 Public Public NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 14 Interests Interests NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 15 section section NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 16 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 17 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 18 outline outline VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 19 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 20 series series NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 21 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 22 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 23 principles principle NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 24 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 25 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 26 balance balance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 27 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 28 individual individual NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 29 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 30 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 31 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 32 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 33 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 34 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 35 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 36 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 37 judicial judicial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 38 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 39 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 40 human human JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 41 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 42 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 43 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 44 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 45 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 46 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 47 UK UK NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 50 48 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 2 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 3 B b NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 4 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 5 Procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 6 versus versus IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 7 Outcome Outcome NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 8 Consistency Consistency NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 9 section section NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 11 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 12 distinguish distinguish VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 13 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 14 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 15 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 16 outcome outcome JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 17 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 51 18 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 2 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 3 C C NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 4 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 5 Procedural Procedural NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 6 Framework Framework NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 7 section section NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 9 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 10 describe describe VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 12 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 13 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 14 necessary necessary JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 15 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 16 promote promote VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 17 fairness fairness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 19 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 20 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 21 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 22 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 23 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 24 D D NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 25 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 26 Substantive Substantive NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 27 Triage Triage NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 28 Criteria Criteria NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 29 section section NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 30 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 31 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 32 consider consider VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 33 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 34 range range NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 35 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 36 substantive substantive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 37 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 38 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 39 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 40 give give VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 41 practical practical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 42 effect effect NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 43 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 44 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 45 balancing balancing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 46 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 47 individual individual NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 48 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 49 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 50 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 52 51 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 2 considering consider VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 3 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 4 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 5 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 6 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 7 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 8 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 9 conceived conceive VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 10 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 12 time time NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 13 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 14 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 15 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 16 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 17 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 18 UK UK NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 19 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 20 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 21 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 22 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 23 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 24 bear bear VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 25 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 26 mind mind NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 27 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 28 following follow VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 29 four four CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 30 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 31 principles principle NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 53 32 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 2 1 1 LS cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 3 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 4 Claims claim NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 5 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 6 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 7 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 8 single single JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 9 claimants claimant NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 10 must must MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 11 always always RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 12 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 13 balanced balance VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 14 against against IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 15 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 17 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 18 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 19 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 20 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 54 21 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 1 Healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 2 policy policy NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 3 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 4 benefit benefit VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 5 some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 6 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 7 harm harm VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 8 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 55 9 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 1 But but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 2 even even RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 3 here here RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 5 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 6 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 7 series series NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 8 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 9 cases case NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 12 European European NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 13 Court Court NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 14 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 15 Human Human NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 16 Rights Rights NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 17 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 18 refused refuse VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 19 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 20 guarantee guarantee VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 21 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 22 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 23 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 24 adversely adversely RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 25 affected affect VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 56 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 1 For for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 2 example example NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 4 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 5 Pentiacova Pentiacova NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 6 v v IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 7 Moldova Moldova NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 9 12 12 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 10 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 11 suffering suffer VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 12 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 13 chronic chronic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 14 renal renal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 15 failure failure NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 16 complained complain VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 17 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 18 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 19 haemodialysis haemodialysis NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 20 services service NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 21 were be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 22 being be VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 23 rationed ration VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 24 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 25 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 26 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 27 detriment detriment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 28 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 29 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 30 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 57 31 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 2 European European NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 3 Court Court NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 4 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 5 Human Human NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 6 Rights Rights NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 7 rejected reject VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 8 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 9 claim claim NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 58 10 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 2 said say VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 3 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 4 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 5 applicants applicant NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 6 ' ' POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 7 claim claim NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 8 amounts amount VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 9 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 10 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 11 call call NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 12 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 13 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 14 funds fund NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 15 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 16 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 17 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 18 view view NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 19 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 20 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 21 scarce scarce JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 22 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 23 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 24 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 25 have have VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 26 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 27 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 28 diverted divert VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 29 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 30 other other JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 31 worthy worthy JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 32 needs need NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 33 funded fund VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 34 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 35 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 36 taxpayer taxpayer NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 37 … … NFP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 38 While while IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 39 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 40 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 41 clearly clearly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 42 desirable desirable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 43 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 44 everyone everyone NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 45 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 46 have have VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 47 access access NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 48 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 49 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 50 full full JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 51 range range NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 52 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 53 medical medical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 54 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 55 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 56 including include VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 57 life life NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 58 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 59 saving save VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 60 medical medical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 61 procedures procedure NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 62 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 63 drugs drug NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 64 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 65 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 66 lack lack NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 67 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 68 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 69 means mean VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 70 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 71 there there EX cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 72 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 73 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 74 unfortunately unfortunately RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 75 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 76 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 77 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 78 Contracting Contracting NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 79 States state NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 80 many many JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 81 individuals individual NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 82 who who WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 83 do do VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 84 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 85 enjoy enjoy VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 86 them -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 87 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 88 especially especially RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 89 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 90 cases case NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 91 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 92 permanent permanent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 93 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 94 expensive expensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 95 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 96 … … NFP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 97 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 98 I i NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 99 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 100 t t NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 101 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 102 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 103 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 104 said say VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 105 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 106 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 107 respondent respondent NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 108 State State NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 109 failed fail VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 110 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 111 strike strike VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 112 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 113 fair fair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 114 balance balance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 115 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 116 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 117 competing compete VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 118 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 119 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 120 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 121 applicants applicant NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 122 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 123 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 124 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 125 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 126 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 127 whole whole NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 59 128 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 1 For for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 2 example example NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 4 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 5 allocators allocator NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 6 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 7 consider consider VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 9 relative relative JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 10 need need NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 11 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 12 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 15 likely likely JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 16 benefit benefit NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 18 equality equality NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 19 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 20 access access NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 21 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 22 evidence evidence NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 23 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 24 efficacy efficacy NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 25 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 26 cost cost NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 60 27 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 2 respect respect NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 4 COVID-19 covid-19 JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 5 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 6 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 7 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 8 too too RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 9 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 10 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 12 disproportionate disproportionate JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 13 impact impact NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 14 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 15 black black JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 16 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 17 Asian asian JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 19 minority minority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 20 ethnic ethnic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 21 communities community NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 61 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 2 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 3 science science NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 4 develops develop VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 6 so so IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 8 response response NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 9 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 10 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 11 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 12 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 13 proportionate proportionate JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 62 14 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 1 Decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 2 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 3 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 4 gravity gravity NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 5 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 6 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 7 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 8 left leave VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 9 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 10 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 11 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 12 alone alone RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 13 ; ; : cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 14 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 15 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 16 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 17 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 18 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 19 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 20 required require VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 63 21 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 2 might may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 3 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 4 created create VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 5 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 6 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 7 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 8 hospital hospital NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 9 managers manager NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 10 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 11 patient patient JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 12 representatives representative NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 13 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 14 optimise optimise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 15 available available JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 16 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 18 perhaps perhaps RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 19 administered administer VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 20 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 21 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 22 coordinators coordinator NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 23 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 24 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 25 ideally ideally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 26 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 27 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 28 appeal appeal NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 29 mechanism mechanism NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 64 30 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 65 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 65 2 2 2 LS cord-343877-jzkaee16 65 3 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 1 Judicial judicial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 2 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 4 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 5 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 6 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 7 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 8 hard hard JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 9 choices choice NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 10 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 11 inevitable inevitable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 66 12 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 2 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 3 Court Court NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 4 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 5 Appeal Appeal NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 6 said say VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 7 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 8 R R NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 9 v v NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 10 Cambridge Cambridge NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 11 DHA DHA NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 13 13 13 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 14 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 15 Difficult difficult JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 16 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 17 agonizing agonizing JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 18 judgments judgment NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 19 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 20 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 21 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 22 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 23 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 24 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 25 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 26 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 27 limited limited JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 28 budget budget NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 29 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 30 best well RBS cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 31 allocated allocate VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 32 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 33 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 34 maximum maximum JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 35 advantage advantage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 36 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 37 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 38 maximum maximum JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 39 number number NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 40 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 41 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 67 42 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 1 That that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 3 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 5 judgment judgment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 7 court court NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 8 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 9 make make VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 10 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 68 11 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 2 court court NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 3 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 4 neither neither CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 6 authority authority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 7 nor nor CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 8 expertise expertise NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 9 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 10 do do VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 11 so so RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 13 even even RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 14 though though IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 15 judicial judicial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 16 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 17 subjects subject VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 18 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 19 rationality rationality NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 20 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 21 close close VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 22 scrutiny scrutiny NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 69 23 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 2 demands demand VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 3 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 4 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 5 authorities authority NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 6 consider consider VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 7 all all PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 9 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 10 factors factor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 11 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 12 including include VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 14 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 15 available available JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 70 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 2 explains explain VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 3 why why WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 5 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 6 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 7 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 8 so so RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 9 crucial crucial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 10 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 11 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 12 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 13 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 14 see see VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 15 ref ref NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 16 14 14 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 17 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 71 18 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 1 But but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 2 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 3 does do VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 4 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 5 undermine undermine VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 7 central central JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 8 principle principle NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 9 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 10 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 11 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 12 lawful lawful JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 13 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 14 provided provide VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 15 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 16 responds respond VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 17 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 18 everyone everyone NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 19 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 20 need need NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 21 fairly fairly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 23 consistently consistently RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 72 24 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 2 creates create VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 3 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 4 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 5 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 6 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 7 fair fair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 8 system system NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 9 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 10 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 11 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 12 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 14 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 15 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 16 substantive substantive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 17 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 18 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 19 access access NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 20 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 21 particular particular JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 22 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 73 23 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 1 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 2 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 3 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 4 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 5 yet yet RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 6 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 7 required require VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 8 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 9 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 10 ration ration VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 11 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 12 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 74 13 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 1 If if IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 2 limited limited JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 3 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 4 were be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 5 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 6 cause cause VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 7 conflict conflict NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 9 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 10 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 11 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 12 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 13 could could MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 14 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 15 claim claim VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 16 greater great JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 17 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 18 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 19 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 20 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 21 urgent urgent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 22 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 23 awaiting await VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 24 admission admission NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 75 25 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 2 such such PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 3 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 4 case case NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 6 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 7 could could MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 8 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 9 simply simply RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 10 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 11 withdrawn withdraw VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 76 12 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 1 However however RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 3 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 4 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 5 National National NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 6 Institute Institute NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 7 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 8 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 9 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 10 Care Care NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 11 Excellence Excellence NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 12 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 13 NICE NICE NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 14 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 15 says say VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 16 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 17 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 18 could could MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 19 lawfully lawfully RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 20 prioritise prioritise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 21 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 22 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 23 say say VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 24 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 25 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 26 moving move VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 27 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 28 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 29 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 30 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 31 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 32 ward ward NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 33 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 34 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 35 high high JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 36 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 37 dependency dependency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 38 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 39 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 40 step step NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 41 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 42 down down RP cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 43 unit unit NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 44 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 45 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 46 transfer transfer VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 47 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 48 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 49 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 50 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 51 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 52 elsewhere elsewhere RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 77 53 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 78 1 15 15 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 1 That that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 2 said say VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 4 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 5 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 6 involve involve VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 7 life life NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 8 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 9 death death NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 11 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 12 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 13 damage damage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 14 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 16 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 17 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 18 subject subject JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 19 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 20 careful careful JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 21 scrutiny scrutiny NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 22 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 23 ensure ensure VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 24 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 25 factors factor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 26 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 27 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 28 weighed weigh VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 29 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 30 balanced balance VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 31 properly properly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 79 32 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 2 On on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 3 9 9 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 4 April April NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 5 2020 2020 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 6 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 7 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 8 University University NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 9 College College NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 10 London London NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 11 Hospitals Hospitals NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 12 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 13 Foundation Foundation NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 14 Trust Trust NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 15 v v NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 16 MB MB NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 18 16 16 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 19 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 20 High High NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 21 Court Court NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 22 considered consider VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 23 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 24 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 25 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 26 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 27 Foundation Foundation NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 28 Trust Trust NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 29 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 30 withdraw withdraw VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 31 residential residential JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 32 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 33 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 34 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 35 mental mental JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 36 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 37 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 38 so so IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 39 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 40 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 41 make make VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 42 space space NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 43 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 44 accommodate accommodate VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 45 other other JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 46 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 47 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 48 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 80 49 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 81 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 81 2 court court NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 81 3 upheld uphold VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 81 4 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 81 5 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 81 6 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 2 said say VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 4 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 5 para para NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 6 55 55 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 7 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 8 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 9 some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 10 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 11 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 12 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 13 hospital hospital NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 14 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 15 have have VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 16 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 17 decide decide VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 18 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 19 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 20 two two CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 21 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 22 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 23 A a NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 24 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 25 B b NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 26 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 27 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 28 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 29 better well JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 30 claim claim NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 31 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 32 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 33 bed bed NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 34 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 35 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 36 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 37 better well JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 38 claim claim NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 39 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 40 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 41 bed bed NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 42 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 43 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 44 particular particular JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 45 unit unit NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 46 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 47 even even RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 48 ceasing cease VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 49 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 50 provide provide VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 51 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 52 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 53 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 54 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 55 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 56 one one CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 57 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 58 them -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 59 … … NFP cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 60 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 61 certainly certainly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 62 cause cause VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 63 extreme extreme JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 64 distress distress NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 65 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 66 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 67 give give VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 68 rise rise NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 69 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 70 significant significant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 71 risks risk NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 72 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 73 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 74 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 75 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 76 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 77 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 78 even even RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 79 life life NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 82 80 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 1 A a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 2 hospital hospital NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 3 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 4 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 5 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 6 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 7 determines determine VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 8 rationally rationally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 9 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 10 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 11 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 12 accordance accordance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 13 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 14 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 15 lawful lawful JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 16 policy policy NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 18 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 19 A a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 20 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 21 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 22 need need NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 23 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 24 greater great JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 25 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 26 B B NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 27 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 28 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 29 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 30 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 31 A a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 32 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 33 derive derive VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 34 greater great JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 35 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 36 benefit benefit NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 37 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 38 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 39 bed bed NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 40 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 41 B B NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 42 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 43 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 44 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 45 precluded preclude VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 46 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 47 Article article NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 48 3 3 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 49 ECHR ECHR NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 50 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 51 declining decline VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 52 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 53 offer offer VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 54 inpatient inpatient JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 55 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 56 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 83 57 B. B. NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 3 because because IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 4 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 5 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 6 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 7 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 8 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 9 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 10 scarce scarce JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 11 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 12 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 14 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 15 Auld Auld NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 16 LJ LJ NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 17 put put VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 18 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 19 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 20 R r NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 84 21 v v NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 85 1 North North NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 85 2 West West NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 85 3 Lancashire Lancashire NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 85 4 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 85 5 Authority Authority NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 85 6 ex ex NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 85 7 p. p. NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 85 8 A a NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 2 2000 2000 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 4 1 1 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 5 WLR WLR NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 6 977 977 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 7 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 8 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 9 996 996 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 86 11 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 2 i]t i]t `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 3 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 4 plain plain JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 5 … … NFP cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 6 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 7 article article NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 8 3 3 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 9 was be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 10 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 11 designed design VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 12 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 13 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 14 … … NFP cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 15 where where WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 17 challenge challenge NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 18 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 19 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 20 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 21 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 22 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 23 authority authority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 24 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 25 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 26 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 27 finite finite JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 28 funds fund NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 29 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 30 competing compete VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 31 demands demand NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 32 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 87 33 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 1 Decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 2 taken take VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 3 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 5 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 6 authority authority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 7 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 9 basis basis NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 10 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 11 finite finite JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 12 funds fund NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 13 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 14 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 15 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 16 my -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 17 judgment judgment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 18 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 19 no no RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 20 different different JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 21 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 22 principle principle NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 23 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 24 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 25 taken take VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 26 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 27 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 28 hospital hospital NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 29 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 30 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 31 basis basis NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 32 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 33 finite finite JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 34 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 35 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 36 other other JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 37 kinds kind NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 88 38 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 2 each each DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 3 case case NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 5 choice choice NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 6 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 7 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 8 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 9 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 10 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 11 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 12 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 13 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 14 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 16 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 17 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 18 necessary necessary JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 19 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 20 consider consider VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 21 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 22 needs need NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 23 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 24 more more JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 25 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 26 one one CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 27 person person NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 89 28 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 2 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 3 Court Court NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 4 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 5 Appeal Appeal NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 6 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 7 confirmed confirm VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 9 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 10 right right NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 12 patient patient JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 13 choice choice NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 14 arises arise VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 15 only only RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 16 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 17 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 18 range range NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 19 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 20 treatments treatment NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 21 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 22 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 23 reasonably reasonably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 24 available available JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 25 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 26 us -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 27 although although IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 28 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 29 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 30 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 31 note note VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 32 above above RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 33 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 34 if if IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 35 such such PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 36 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 37 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 38 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 39 benefit benefit VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 40 one one CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 41 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 42 were be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 43 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 44 expose expose VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 45 another another DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 46 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 47 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 48 significant significant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 49 risk risk NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 50 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 51 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 52 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 53 could could MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 54 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 55 subject subject JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 56 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 57 close close JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 58 scrutiny scrutiny NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 59 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 60 judicial judicial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 61 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 90 62 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 91 1 17 17 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 91 2 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 91 3 4 4 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 91 4 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 2 statutory statutory JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 3 duty duty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 4 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 5 allocate allocate VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 6 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 7 belongs belong VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 8 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 10 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 11 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 12 authority authority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 14 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 15 judges judge NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 92 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 1 Public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 2 authorities authority NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 3 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 4 wide wide JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 5 discretion discretion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 6 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 7 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 8 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 9 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 10 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 93 11 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 2 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 3 Supreme Supreme NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 4 Court Court NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 5 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 6 said say VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 7 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 9 European European NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 10 Convention Convention NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 11 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 12 Human Human NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 13 Rights Rights NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 14 confers confer VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 15 broad broad JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 16 discretion discretion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 17 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 18 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 19 authorities authority NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 20 allocating allocate VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 21 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 22 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 23 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 24 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 25 competing compete VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 26 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 27 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 28 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 29 individual individual NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 30 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 31 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 32 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 33 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 34 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 35 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 36 whole whole NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 37 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 94 38 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 95 1 18 18 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 2 court court NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 3 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 4 powers power NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 5 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 6 no no RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 7 greater great JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 8 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 9 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 10 available available JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 11 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 12 applicants applicant NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 13 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 14 judicial judicial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 15 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 96 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 2 N n CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 3 v v IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 4 ACCG ACCG NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 6 19 19 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 8 applicant applicant NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 9 family family NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 10 sought seek VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 12 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 13 necessary necessary JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 14 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 15 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 16 trained train VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 17 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 18 carers carer NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 19 providing provide VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 20 round round JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 21 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 22 theclock theclock NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 23 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 24 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 25 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 26 disabled disabled JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 27 son son NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 28 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 29 home home NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 97 30 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 2 might may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 3 have have VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 4 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 5 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 6 his -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 7 best good JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 8 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 9 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 10 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 11 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 12 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 14 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 15 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 16 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 17 commissioning commissioning NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 18 group group NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 19 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 20 CCG CCG NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 21 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 22 could could MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 23 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 24 afford afford VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 25 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 26 adopt adopt VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 27 such such PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 28 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 29 policy policy NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 30 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 31 everyone everyone NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 32 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 33 refused refuse VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 34 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 35 request request NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 98 36 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 99 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 99 2 parents parent NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 99 3 ' ' POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 99 4 application application NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 99 5 was be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 99 6 refused refuse VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 99 7 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 1 Such such JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 2 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 3 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 4 involves involve VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 5 issues issue NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 6 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 7 affordability affordability NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 8 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 10 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 12 other other JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 13 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 14 unknown unknown JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 15 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 17 court court NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 100 18 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 1 For for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 2 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 3 reason reason NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 5 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 6 was be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 7 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 8 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 9 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 10 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 11 judges judge NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 101 12 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 102 1 Resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 102 2 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 102 3 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 102 4 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 102 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 102 6 CCG CCG NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 102 7 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 103 1 At at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 103 2 paras paras NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 103 3 35- 35- NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 1 These these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 2 principles principle NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 3 bear bear VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 4 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 6 crisis crisis NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 7 produced produce VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 8 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 9 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 10 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 12 UK UK NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 104 13 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 2 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 3 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 4 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 6 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 7 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 8 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 9 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 10 understood understand VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 11 only only RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 12 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 14 constraints constraint NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 15 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 16 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 17 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 105 18 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 2 extreme extreme JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 3 cases case NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 5 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 6 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 7 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 8 withdrawn withdraw VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 9 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 10 one one CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 11 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 12 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 13 divert divert VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 14 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 15 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 16 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 106 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 2 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 3 rests rest VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 4 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 6 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 7 authority authority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 9 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 11 court court NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 107 12 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 2 attraction attraction NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 4 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 5 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 6 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 7 encourage encourage VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 8 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 9 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 11 undervalue undervalue VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 12 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 13 say say VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 14 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 15 elderly elderly JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 16 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 17 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 18 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 19 group group NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 20 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 21 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 22 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 23 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 24 disabilities disability NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 108 25 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 2 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 3 needs need NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 4 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 5 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 6 must must MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 7 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 8 balanced balance VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 9 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 10 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 12 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 13 without without IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 14 prejudgement prejudgement NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 15 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 16 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 17 group group NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 18 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 19 stereotyping stereotyping NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 20 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 109 21 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 3 provided provide VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 4 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 5 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 6 balances balance VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 8 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 9 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 10 fairly fairly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 11 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 12 proportionately proportionately RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 13 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 14 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 15 proper proper JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 16 regard regard NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 17 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 18 equality equality NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 19 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 20 human human JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 21 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 22 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 23 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 24 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 25 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 26 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 27 upheld uphold VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 110 28 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 111 1 20 20 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 2 challenge challenge NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 4 therefore therefore RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 6 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 7 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 8 understand understand VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 9 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 11 guarantee guarantee VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 12 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 13 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 14 difficult difficult JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 15 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 16 unenviable unenviable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 17 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 18 respond respond VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 19 fairly fairly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 20 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 21 equally equally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 23 consistently consistently RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 24 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 25 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 112 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 4 purpose purpose NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 5 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 7 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 8 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 9 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 10 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 11 outline outline VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 12 below below RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 113 13 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 114 1 How how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 114 2 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 114 3 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 114 4 decide decide VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 114 5 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 114 6 us -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 114 7 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 1 Inevitably inevitably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 3 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 4 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 5 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 6 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 7 differ differ VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 8 - - : cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 9 even even RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 10 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 12 same same JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 13 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 115 14 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 1 Some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 2 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 3 insist insist VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 4 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 5 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 6 Hippocratic hippocratic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 7 duty duty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 8 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 9 promote promote VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 11 best good JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 12 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 13 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 14 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 15 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 16 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 116 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 1 Others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 2 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 3 promote promote VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 4 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 5 greatest great JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 6 benefit benefit NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 7 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 9 greatest great JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 10 number number NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 11 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 12 create create VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 13 space space NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 14 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 15 help help VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 16 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 17 most most RBS cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 18 likely likely JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 19 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 20 recover recover VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 21 quickly quickly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 117 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 1 Yet yet CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 2 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 3 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 4 favour favour VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 6 first first JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 7 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 9 queue queue NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 11 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 12 some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 13 over over IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 14 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 15 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 16 eg eg NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 18 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 19 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 20 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 21 workers worker NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 22 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 23 delivery delivery NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 24 drivers driver NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 25 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 26 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 27 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 28 disfavour disfavour JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 29 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 30 over over IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 31 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 32 certain certain JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 33 age age NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 118 34 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 1 Still still RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 2 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 3 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 4 adopt adopt VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 5 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 6 provisional provisional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 7 Hippocratic hippocratic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 8 approach approach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 9 unless unless IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 10 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 11 until until IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 12 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 13 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 14 given give VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 15 clear clear JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 16 instructions instruction NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 17 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 18 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 19 contrary contrary NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 20 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 21 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 22 hospital hospital NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 23 employer employer NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 119 24 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 120 1 Importantly importantly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 120 2 each each DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 120 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 120 4 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 120 5 variations variation NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 120 6 represents represent VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 120 7 distinctive distinctive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 120 8 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 1 nevertheless nevertheless RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 2 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 3 interpretations interpretation NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 4 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 5 what what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 6 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 7 means mean VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 8 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 9 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 10 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 11 clinician clinician NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 12 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 13 perform perform VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 15 professional professional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 16 role role NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 17 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 18 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 19 doctor doctor NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 121 20 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 1 These these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 2 different different JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 3 views view NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 4 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 5 represent represent VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 6 what what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 7 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 8 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 9 take take VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 11 lie lie VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 12 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 14 very very JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 15 heart heart NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 16 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 17 what what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 18 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 19 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 20 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 21 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 22 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 23 doctor doctor NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 122 24 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 1 Such such JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 2 variation variation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 4 even even RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 5 if if IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 6 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 7 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 8 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 9 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 11 product product NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 12 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 13 genuine genuine JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 14 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 15 deep deep JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 16 commitment commitment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 18 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 19 unsettling unsettling JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 20 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 21 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 22 clearly clearly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 23 leads lead VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 24 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 25 inconsistent inconsistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 26 responses response NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 27 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 28 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 29 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 30 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 31 presented present VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 32 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 33 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 34 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 35 look look VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 36 unfair unfair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 37 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 38 unattractive unattractive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 123 39 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 2 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 3 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 4 claimed claim VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 6 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 7 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 8 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 9 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 10 life life NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 11 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 12 death death NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 13 surely surely RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 14 requires require VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 15 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 124 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 125 1 3 3 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 125 2 4 4 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 2 value value NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 4 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 5 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 6 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 7 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 8 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 9 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 10 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 11 just just RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 12 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 13 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 14 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 15 ; ; : cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 16 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 17 too too RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 18 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 19 want want VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 20 reassurance reassurance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 21 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 22 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 23 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 24 acting act VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 25 ethically ethically RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 26 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 27 legally legally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 28 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 29 otherwise otherwise RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 30 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 31 absence absence NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 32 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 33 proper proper JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 34 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 35 exposes expose VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 36 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 37 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 38 complaint complaint VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 39 afterwards afterwards RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 126 40 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 1 However however RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 3 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 4 calling call VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 5 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 6 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 7 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 8 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 9 order order NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 11 provide provide VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 12 such such JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 13 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 14 need need VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 15 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 16 address address VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 17 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 18 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 19 question question NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 20 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 21 what what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 22 does do VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 23 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 24 demand demand NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 25 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 26 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 27 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 28 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 29 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 30 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 31 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 127 32 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 2 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 3 view view NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 5 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 6 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 7 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 8 encourage encourage VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 9 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 10 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 11 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 12 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 128 13 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 1 But but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 3 as as RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 4 desirable desirable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 5 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 6 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 7 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 8 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 9 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 11 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 12 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 13 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 14 strictly strictly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 15 necessary necessary JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 129 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 3 true true JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 4 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 6 government government NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 7 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 8 have have VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 9 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 10 obligation obligation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 11 under under IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 12 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 13 European European NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 14 Convention Convention NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 15 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 16 Human Human NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 17 Rights Rights NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 18 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 19 establish establish VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 20 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 21 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 22 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 23 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 24 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 25 if if IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 26 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 27 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 28 authority authority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 29 exposes expose VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 30 people people NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 31 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 32 systematic systematic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 33 danger danger NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 34 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 35 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 36 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 37 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 38 managed manage VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 39 locally locally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 130 40 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 1 Until until IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 2 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 3 time time NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 5 however however RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 6 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 7 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 8 note note VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 9 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 10 priority priority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 11 setting set VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 12 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 13 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 14 CCGs ccg NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 15 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 16 never never RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 17 had have VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 18 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 19 benefit benefit NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 20 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 21 overarching overarching JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 22 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 23 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 24 because because IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 25 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 26 government government NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 27 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 28 taken take VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 29 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 30 view view NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 31 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 32 local local JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 33 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 34 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 35 makers maker NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 36 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 37 best best RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 38 able able JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 39 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 40 respond respond VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 41 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 42 local local JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 43 needs need NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 131 44 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 1 Instead instead RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 3 judicial judicial JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 4 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 5 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 6 clarified clarify VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 7 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 8 local local JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 9 decisionmakers decisionmaker NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 10 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 11 introduce introduce VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 12 fair fair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 13 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 14 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 15 procedures procedure NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 16 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 17 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 18 legally legally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 19 defensible defensible JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 132 20 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 1 What what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 3 essential essential JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 4 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 5 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 6 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 7 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 8 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 9 spell spell VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 10 out out RP cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 11 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 12 values value NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 13 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 14 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 15 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 16 considered consider VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 17 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 18 funding fund VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 19 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 20 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 21 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 22 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 23 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 24 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 25 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 26 considered consider VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 27 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 28 ways way NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 29 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 30 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 31 fair fair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 32 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 33 rational rational JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 34 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 35 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 133 36 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 2 21 21 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 4 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 5 22 22 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 6 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 7 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 8 23 23 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 134 9 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 135 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 135 2 24 24 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 135 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 135 4 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 135 5 25 25 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 135 6 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 3 helpful helpful JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 5 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 6 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 7 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 9 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 10 distinguish distinguish VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 11 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 12 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 13 outcome outcome JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 14 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 136 15 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 137 1 26 26 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 1 Understandably understandably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 3 both both DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 4 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 5 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 6 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 7 find find VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 8 appeal appeal NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 9 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 11 idea idea NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 12 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 13 outcome outcome NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 14 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 15 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 16 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 17 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 18 operated operate VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 19 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 20 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 21 way way NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 22 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 23 enable enable VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 24 people people NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 25 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 26 know know VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 27 where where WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 28 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 29 stand stand VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 30 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 31 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 32 advance advance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 33 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 34 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 35 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 36 being be VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 37 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 138 38 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 1 An an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 2 algorithmic algorithmic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 3 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 4 formula formula NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 5 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 6 based base VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 7 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 8 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 9 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 10 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 11 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 12 sought seek VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 13 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 14 crunch crunch VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 15 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 16 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 17 values value NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 19 facts fact NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 20 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 21 likely likely RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 22 lie lie VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 23 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 24 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 25 heart heart NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 26 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 27 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 28 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 29 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 30 kind kind NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 139 31 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 1 One one CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 2 reason reason NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 3 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 4 people people NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 5 find find VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 6 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 7 appealing appeal VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 8 might may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 9 lie lie VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 10 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 12 fact fact NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 13 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 14 providing provide VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 15 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 16 kind kind NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 17 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 18 metric metric JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 19 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 20 formula formula NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 21 makes make VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 22 hugely hugely RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 23 difficult difficult JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 24 problems problem NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 25 seem seem VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 26 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 27 manageable manageable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 140 28 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 1 But but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 2 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 3 course course NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 5 such such PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 6 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 7 approach approach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 8 disguises disguise VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 10 difficulty difficulty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 11 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 12 hides hide VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 13 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 14 behind behind IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 15 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 16 algorithm algorithm NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 17 so so IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 18 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 19 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 20 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 21 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 22 encouraged encourage VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 23 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 24 expect expect VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 25 outcome outcome NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 26 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 27 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 28 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 29 where where WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 30 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 31 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 32 impossible impossible JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 33 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 34 achieve achieve VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 141 35 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 2 contrast contrast NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 4 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 5 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 6 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 7 embraced embrace VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 8 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 9 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 10 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 11 require require VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 12 us -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 13 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 14 accept accept VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 15 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 16 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 17 difficult difficult JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 18 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 19 depend depend VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 20 irreducibly irreducibly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 21 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 22 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 23 details detail NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 24 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 25 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 26 case case NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 27 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 28 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 29 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 30 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 31 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 32 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 142 33 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 3 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 4 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 5 accept accept VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 6 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 7 anything anything NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 8 goes go VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 9 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 10 however however RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 143 11 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 2 need need VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 3 assurance assurance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 4 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 6 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 7 facts fact NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 8 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 9 values value NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 10 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 11 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 12 given give VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 13 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 14 consideration consideration NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 15 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 16 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 17 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 18 openended openended JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 19 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 20 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 21 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 22 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 23 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 144 24 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 1 Crucially crucially RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 3 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 4 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 5 means mean VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 6 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 8 set set NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 9 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 10 things thing NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 11 considered consider VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 13 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 15 way way NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 16 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 17 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 18 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 19 considered consider VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 20 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 21 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 22 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 23 same same JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 24 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 25 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 26 very very RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 27 similar similar JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 28 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 29 across across IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 30 cases case NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 31 without without IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 32 prejudging prejudge VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 33 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 34 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 35 elements element NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 36 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 37 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 38 case case NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 145 39 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 1 Procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 2 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 3 means mean VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 4 accepting accept VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 5 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 6 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 7 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 8 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 9 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 10 give give VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 11 rise rise NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 12 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 13 different different JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 14 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 15 so so RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 16 seemingly seemingly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 17 inconsistent inconsistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 18 outcomes outcome NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 19 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 20 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 21 might may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 22 reasonably reasonably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 23 differ differ VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 24 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 25 whether whether IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 26 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 27 person person NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 28 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 29 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 30 allocated allocate VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 31 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 32 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 33 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 34 bed bed NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 35 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 36 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 37 ventilator ventilator NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 38 when when WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 39 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 40 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 41 balanced balance VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 42 all all PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 43 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 44 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 45 factors factor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 46 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 47 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 48 judgement judgement NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 146 49 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 1 Inevitably inevitably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 3 therefore therefore RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 5 although although IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 7 procedures procedure NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 8 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 9 different different JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 10 decisionmakers decisionmaker NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 11 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 12 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 13 analogous analogous JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 14 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 15 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 16 outcomes outcome NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 17 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 18 them -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 19 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 20 legitimately legitimately RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 21 differ differ VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 22 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 23 according accord VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 24 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 25 local local JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 26 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 27 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 28 need need NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 29 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 30 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 31 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 32 availability availability NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 33 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 34 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 147 35 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 2 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 3 view view NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 5 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 6 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 7 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 8 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 9 promote promote VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 10 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 11 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 13 rather rather RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 14 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 15 outcome outcome NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 16 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 148 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 3 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 4 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 5 say say VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 6 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 7 outcome outcome NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 8 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 9 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 10 irrelevant irrelevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 149 11 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 1 Instead instead RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 3 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 4 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 5 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 7 latter latter JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 8 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 9 unachievable unachievable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 10 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 11 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 12 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 13 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 14 kind kind NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 15 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 17 reasons reason NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 18 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 19 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 20 discussed discuss VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 21 above above RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 150 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 1 A a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 2 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 3 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 4 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 5 consider consider VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 6 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 7 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 8 governing govern VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 9 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 10 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 11 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 12 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 14 sensitive sensitive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 15 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 17 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 18 requirements requirement NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 19 discussed discuss VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 20 above above RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 21 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 22 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 23 Balancing balance VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 24 Individual Individual NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 25 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 26 Public Public NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 27 Interests Interests NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 28 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 151 29 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 1 Importantly importantly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 3 such such PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 5 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 6 sits sit VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 7 above above RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 9 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 10 functions function NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 11 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 12 structure structure NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 14 local local JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 15 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 16 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 17 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 18 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 19 ensuring ensure VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 20 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 21 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 22 interests interest NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 23 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 24 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 25 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 26 as as RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 27 well well RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 28 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 29 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 30 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 31 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 32 accorded accord VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 33 proper proper JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 34 respect respect NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 152 35 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 1 A a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 2 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 4 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 5 procedures procedure NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 6 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 7 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 8 essential essential JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 9 means mean NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 10 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 11 expressing express VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 12 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 13 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 14 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 15 interest interest NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 16 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 17 responding respond VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 18 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 19 everyone everyone NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 20 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 21 needs need NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 22 fairly fairly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 23 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 24 consistently consistently RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 153 25 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 1 There there EX cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 2 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 3 two two CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 4 main main JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 5 reasons reason NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 6 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 7 adopting adopt VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 8 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 9 approach approach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 10 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 11 apply apply VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 12 equally equally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 13 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 14 triaging triage VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 15 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 16 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 17 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 18 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 19 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 20 as as RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 21 well well RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 22 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 23 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 24 other other JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 25 prioritisation prioritisation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 26 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 27 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 28 need need VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 29 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 30 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 31 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 154 32 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 1 First first RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 4 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 5 values value NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 6 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 7 underpin underpin VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 8 fairness fairness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 9 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 10 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 11 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 12 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 13 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 14 reasonably reasonably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 15 contested contest VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 16 ; ; : cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 17 there there EX cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 18 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 19 no no DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 20 single single JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 21 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 22 position position NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 23 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 24 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 25 nature nature NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 26 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 27 extent extent NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 28 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 29 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 30 people people NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 31 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 32 entitled entitle VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 33 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 34 receive receive VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 155 35 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 2 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 3 reasonably reasonably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 4 disagree disagree VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 5 whether whether IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 6 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 7 maximise maximise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 8 utility utility NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 9 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 10 equity equity NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 11 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 12 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 13 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 14 freedom freedom NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 15 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 156 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 2 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 3 reasonably reasonably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 4 disagree disagree VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 5 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 6 whether whether IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 7 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 8 professionals professional NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 9 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 10 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 11 prioritised prioritise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 13 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 14 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 15 who who WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 16 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 17 lived live VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 18 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 19 social social JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 20 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 21 economic economic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 22 disadvantage disadvantage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 157 23 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 1 Second second RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 4 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 5 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 6 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 7 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 9 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 10 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 11 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 12 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 13 morally morally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 14 significant significant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 158 15 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 1 Precisely precisely RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 2 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 3 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 4 interpret interpret VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 5 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 6 considerations consideration NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 7 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 8 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 9 accord accord VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 10 them -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 11 weight weight NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 13 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 14 depend depend VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 15 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 17 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 18 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 19 each each DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 20 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 21 setting setting NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 23 each each DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 24 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 25 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 159 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 1 How how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 3 then then RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 5 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 6 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 7 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 8 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 9 realised realise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 10 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 11 any any DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 12 local local JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 13 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 14 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 15 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 16 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 17 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 18 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 19 endorsed endorse VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 20 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 21 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 22 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 160 23 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 2 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 3 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 4 argued argue VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 6 27 27 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 7 28 28 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 8 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 9 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 10 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 12 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 13 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 14 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 15 requirements requirement NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 16 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 17 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 18 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 19 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 20 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 21 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 22 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 23 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 24 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 25 generally generally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 26 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 27 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 28 encourage encourage VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 29 hospitals hospital NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 30 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 31 appoint appoint VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 32 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 33 team team NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 34 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 35 senior senior JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 36 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 37 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 38 perhaps perhaps RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 39 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 40 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 41 independent independent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 42 member member NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 43 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 44 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 45 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 46 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 47 team team NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 48 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 49 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 50 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 51 oversee oversee VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 52 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 53 support support VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 54 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 55 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 56 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 57 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 58 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 59 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 60 if if IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 61 needs need NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 62 be be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 63 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 64 make make VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 65 final final JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 66 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 67 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 68 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 69 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 161 70 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 2 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 3 promote promote VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 4 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 5 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 6 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 8 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 9 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 10 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 11 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 162 12 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 1 Further further RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 3 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 4 hospitals hospital NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 5 seek seek VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 6 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 7 coordinate coordinate VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 8 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 9 activities activity NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 10 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 11 one one CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 12 another another DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 13 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 14 regional regional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 15 level level NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 16 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 17 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 18 internal internal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 19 hospital hospital NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 20 system system NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 21 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 22 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 23 reviewed review VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 24 regionally regionally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 25 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 26 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 27 ensure ensure VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 28 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 29 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 30 requirements requirement NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 31 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 32 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 33 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 34 met meet VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 163 35 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 1 Admittedly admittedly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 3 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 4 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 5 diverts divert VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 6 senior senior JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 7 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 8 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 9 treating treat VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 10 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 164 11 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 2 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 3 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 4 time time NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 5 consuming consume VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 6 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 7 emotionally emotionally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 8 draining drain VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 165 9 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 1 There there EX cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 3 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 4 difficult difficult JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 5 balance balance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 6 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 7 providing provide VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 8 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 9 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 10 overview overview NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 11 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 12 letting let VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 13 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 14 do do VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 15 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 16 job job NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 166 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 1 However however RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 3 when when WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 4 searching search VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 5 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 6 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 7 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 8 questions question NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 9 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 10 asked ask VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 11 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 12 future future NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 15 risk risk NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 16 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 17 inconsistency inconsistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 18 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 19 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 20 having have VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 21 such such PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 22 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 23 system system NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 24 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 25 obvious obvious JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 26 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 27 both both DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 28 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 29 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 30 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 167 31 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 2 addition addition NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 3 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 4 notions notion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 5 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 6 fairness fairness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 7 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 8 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 9 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 10 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 11 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 12 part part NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 13 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 14 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 15 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 16 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 17 concerns concern VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 18 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 19 duty duty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 20 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 21 transparency transparency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 23 candour candour NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 24 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 25 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 168 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 3 now now RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 4 well well RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 5 established establish VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 6 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 8 principles principle NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 9 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 10 informed informed JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 11 consent consent NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 12 require require VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 13 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 14 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 15 explain explain VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 16 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 17 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 19 relatives relative NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 20 both both CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 21 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 22 uncertainties uncertainty NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 23 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 24 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 25 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 26 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 27 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 28 processes process NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 29 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 30 place place NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 31 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 32 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 33 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 34 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 35 including include VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 36 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 37 extreme extreme JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 38 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 39 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 40 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 41 difficult difficult JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 42 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 43 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 44 withdraw withdraw VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 45 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 46 withhold withhold VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 47 treatment treatment NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 169 48 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 170 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 170 2 29 29 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 170 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 170 4 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 170 5 30 30 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 170 6 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 171 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 171 2 31 31 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 171 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 171 4 _SP cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 1 As as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 3 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 4 seen see VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 6 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 7 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 8 does do VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 9 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 10 abrogate abrogate VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 11 responsibility responsibility NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 12 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 13 determine determine VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 15 substantive substantive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 16 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 17 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 18 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 19 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 20 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 21 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 22 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 23 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 24 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 25 agreed agree VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 26 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 172 27 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 1 Understandably understandably RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 3 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 4 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 5 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 6 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 7 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 8 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 9 requires require VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 10 content content NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 11 - - : cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 12 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 13 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 14 values value NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 15 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 16 shape shape VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 17 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 18 inform inform VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 19 all all DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 20 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 21 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 173 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 1 What what WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 2 substantive substantive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 3 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 4 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 5 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 6 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 7 used use VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 8 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 9 distinguish distinguish VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 10 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 11 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 12 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 13 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 14 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 15 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 16 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 17 incorporated incorporate VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 18 into into IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 19 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 20 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 21 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 22 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 23 fair fair JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 24 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 25 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 26 making making NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 174 27 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 1 Clearly clearly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 3 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 4 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 5 where where WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 6 much much JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 7 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 9 debate debate NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 10 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 11 taken take VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 12 place place NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 175 13 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 1 On on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 2 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 3 account account NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 5 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 6 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 7 also also RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 9 place place NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 10 where where WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 11 all all DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 12 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 13 concerns concern NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 14 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 15 heard hear VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 16 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 17 balanced balance VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 18 together together RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 176 19 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 1 Once once IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 3 give give VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 4 up up RP cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 5 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 7 quest quest NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 8 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 9 outcome outcome NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 10 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 11 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 12 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 13 task task NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 14 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 15 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 16 ensure ensure VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 17 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 18 all all PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 19 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 20 individual individual NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 21 features feature VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 22 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 23 matter matter VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 24 morally morally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 25 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 26 included include VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 27 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 28 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 29 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 30 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 31 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 32 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 33 discriminatory discriminatory JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 34 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 35 irrelevant irrelevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 36 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 37 non non JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 38 - - JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 39 applicable applicable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 40 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 41 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 42 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 43 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 177 44 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 1 Put put VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 2 another another DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 3 way way NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 6 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 7 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 8 capture capture VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 9 all all DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 10 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 11 only only RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 12 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 13 ethically ethically RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 14 relevant relevant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 15 features feature NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 16 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 17 go go VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 18 into into IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 19 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 20 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 178 21 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 1 Striking strike VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 2 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 3 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 4 balance balance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 5 here here RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 6 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 7 specifying specify VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 8 broad broad JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 9 values value NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 10 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 11 considerations consideration NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 13 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 14 determining determine VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 15 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 16 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 17 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 18 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 19 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 20 challenge challenge NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 179 21 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 1 How how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 2 generic generic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 3 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 4 patient patient JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 5 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 6 then then RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 7 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 9 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 10 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 180 11 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 2 Belgian Belgian NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 3 Society Society NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 4 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 5 Intensive Intensive NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 6 Care Care NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 7 recommended recommend VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 8 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 9 elderly elderly JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 10 residents resident NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 11 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 12 retirement retirement NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 13 homes home NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 14 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 15 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 16 normally normally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 17 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 18 admitted admit VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 19 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 20 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 21 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 22 because because IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 23 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 24 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 25 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 26 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 27 disproportionate disproportionate JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 28 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 181 29 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 182 1 32 32 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 183 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 183 2 seems seem VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 183 3 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 183 4 very very RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 183 5 broad broad JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 183 6 criterion criterion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 183 7 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 1 Many many JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 2 dependent dependent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 3 residents resident NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 4 retain retain VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 5 significant significant JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 6 independence independence NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 7 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 8 require require VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 9 limited limited JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 10 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 184 11 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 2 might may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 3 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 4 criticised criticise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 5 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 6 failing fail VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 7 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 8 consider consider VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 10 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 12 individuals individual NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 185 13 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 1 An an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 2 analogous analogous JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 3 concern concern NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 4 was be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 5 raised raise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 6 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 7 March March NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 8 2020 2020 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 9 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 10 when when WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 11 NICE nice JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 12 recommended recommend VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 13 use use NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 14 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 15 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 16 Clinical Clinical NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 17 Frailty Frailty NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 18 Score Score NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 19 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 20 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 21 1 1 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 22 - - SYM cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 23 9 9 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 24 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 186 25 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 2 recommendation recommendation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 3 was be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 4 criticised criticise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 5 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 6 MENCAP MENCAP NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 7 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 8 other other JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 9 non non JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 10 - - JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 11 governmental governmental JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 12 bodies body NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 13 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 14 being be VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 15 too too RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 16 generic generic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 187 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 1 Shortly shortly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 2 afterwards afterwards RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 4 NICE NICE NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 5 acknowledged acknowledge VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 6 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 7 had have VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 8 failed fail VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 9 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 10 indicate indicate VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 11 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 12 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 13 all all DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 14 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 15 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 17 same same JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 18 point point NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 19 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 20 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 21 frailty frailty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 22 scale scale NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 23 were be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 24 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 25 same same JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 188 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 1 For for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 2 example example NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 4 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 5 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 6 stable stable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 7 mental mental JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 8 illness illness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 9 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 10 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 11 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 12 considered consider VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 14 same same JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 15 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 16 dependent dependent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 17 adults adult NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 18 whose whose WP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 19 conditions condition NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 20 were be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 21 deteriorating deteriorate VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 189 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 190 1 33 33 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 1 So so RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 3 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 4 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 5 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 6 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 7 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 8 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 9 patient patient JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 10 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 191 11 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 2 Pittsburgh Pittsburgh NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 3 Sequential Sequential NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 4 Organ Organ NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 5 Failure Failure NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 6 Assessment Assessment NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 7 scoring scoring NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 8 system system NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 9 attempts attempt VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 11 achieve achieve VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 12 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 13 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 14 putting put VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 15 numbers number NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 16 against against IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 17 particular particular JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 18 conditions condition NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 19 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 20 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 21 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 22 scale scale NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 23 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 24 1 1 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 25 - - SYM cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 26 8 8 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 27 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 28 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 29 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 30 most most RBS cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 31 severely severely RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 32 ill ill JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 33 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 34 scoring score VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 35 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 36 highest high JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 37 number number NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 38 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 192 39 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 193 1 34 34 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 2 express express JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 3 aim aim NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 4 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 5 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 6 exclude exclude VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 7 some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 8 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 9 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 10 order order NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 11 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 12 admit admit VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 13 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 14 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 15 promote promote VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 17 survival survival NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 18 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 19 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 20 greatest great JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 21 number number NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 194 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 1 Those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 2 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 3 comorbidity comorbidity NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 4 likely likely JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 5 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 6 end end VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 7 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 8 lives life NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 9 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 10 1 1 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 11 year year NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 12 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 13 scored score VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 14 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 15 highly highly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 16 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 17 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 18 likely likely JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 19 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 20 live live VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 21 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 22 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 23 further further JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 24 10 10 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 25 years year NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 195 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 2 scoring scoring NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 3 system system NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 4 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 5 helpful helpful JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 6 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 7 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 8 general general JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 9 guide guide NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 11 distinguish distinguish VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 12 classes class NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 13 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 14 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 16 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 17 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 18 far far RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 19 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 20 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 21 take take VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 22 us -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 23 towards towards IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 24 distinguishing distinguish VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 25 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 26 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 27 level level NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 28 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 29 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 30 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 196 31 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 1 Bear bear VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 2 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 3 mind mind NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 5 number number NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 6 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 7 variables variable NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 9 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 10 example example NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 11 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 12 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 13 often often RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 14 present present VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 15 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 16 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 17 mixture mixture NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 18 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 19 comorbidities comorbiditie NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 20 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 21 some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 22 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 23 severe severe JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 24 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 25 others other NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 26 less less RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 197 27 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 1 Say say VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 3 suffer suffer VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 5 combination combination NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 6 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 7 diabetes diabetes NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 9 hypertension hypertension NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 11 obesity obesity NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 12 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 13 heart heart NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 14 disease disease NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 198 15 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 1 Comparing compare VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 2 one one CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 3 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 4 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 5 another another DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 6 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 7 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 8 standard standard JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 9 scale scale NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 10 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 11 unlikely unlikely JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 12 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 13 capture capture VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 15 subtle subtle JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 16 differences difference NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 17 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 18 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 19 condition condition NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 20 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 21 us -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 199 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 1 Second second JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 3 different different JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 4 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 5 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 6 assess assess VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 8 prognosis prognosis NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 9 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 10 diagnosis diagnosis NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 12 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 13 same same JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 14 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 15 differently differently RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 200 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 1 Third third RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 4 availability availability NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 5 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 6 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 7 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 8 beds bed NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 9 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 10 vary vary VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 11 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 12 time time NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 13 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 14 time time NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 15 so so IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 16 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 17 even even RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 18 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 19 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 20 identical identical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 21 scores score NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 22 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 23 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 24 receive receive VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 25 identical identical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 26 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 27 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 28 different different JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 29 points point NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 30 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 31 time time NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 201 32 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 1 Finally finally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 3 getting get VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 4 clear clear JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 5 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 6 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 7 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 8 themselves -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 9 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 10 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 11 own own JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 12 wishes wish NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 13 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 14 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 15 extremely extremely RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 16 difficult difficult JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 202 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 1 Thus thus RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 4 unique unique JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 5 nature nature NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 6 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 7 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 8 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 9 limits limit VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 11 reach reach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 12 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 13 scoring score VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 14 systems system NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 15 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 16 any any DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 17 defensible defensible JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 18 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 19 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 203 20 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 1 Indeed indeed RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 3 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 4 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 5 misleading mislead VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 6 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 7 suggest suggest VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 8 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 9 provide provide VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 10 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 11 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 12 objective objective JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 13 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 14 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 15 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 16 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 17 tool tool NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 18 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 19 algorithm algorithm NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 20 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 21 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 22 level level NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 23 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 24 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 25 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 204 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 1 Uncertainty uncertainty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 2 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 3 disagreement disagreement NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 4 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 5 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 6 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 7 inevitable inevitable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 8 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 9 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 10 discretion discretion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 11 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 12 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 13 familiar familiar JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 14 Bolam Bolam NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 15 35 35 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 16 test test NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 17 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 18 always always RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 19 likely likely JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 20 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 21 play play VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 22 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 23 role role NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 205 24 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 206 1 i i PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 1 Where where WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 3 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 4 balance balance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 5 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 6 systems system NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 7 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 8 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 9 too too RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 10 generic generic JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 11 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 12 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 13 so so RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 14 precise precise JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 15 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 16 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 17 camouflage camouflage VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 18 reality reality NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 207 19 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 1 There there EX cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 2 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 3 compromises compromise NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 4 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 5 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 6 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 7 all all RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 8 along along IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 10 spectrum spectrum NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 208 11 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 209 1 An an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 209 2 alternative alternative JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 209 3 approach approach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 209 4 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 209 5 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 209 6 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 209 7 use use VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 209 8 numbers number NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 1 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 3 instead instead RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 5 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 6 place place VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 7 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 8 into into IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 9 broad broad JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 10 categories category NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 11 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 12 perhaps perhaps RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 13 based base VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 14 around around IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 15 high high JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 16 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 17 medium medium JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 19 low low JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 20 priority priority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 210 21 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 211 1 ii ii LS cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 1 At at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 2 highest high JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 3 priority priority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 4 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 5 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 6 those those DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 7 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 9 highest high JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 10 probability probability NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 12 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 13 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 14 rapid rapid JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 15 recovery recovery NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 212 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 1 Low low JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 2 priority priority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 3 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 4 given give VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 5 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 6 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 7 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 9 lowest low JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 10 probability probability NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 12 doing do VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 13 so so RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 213 14 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 1 Priority priority NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 3 given give VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 4 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 5 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 6 according accord VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 7 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 8 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 9 capacity capacity NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 10 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 11 recover recover VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 12 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 14 speed speed NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 15 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 16 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 17 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 18 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 19 likely likely JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 20 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 21 do do VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 22 so so RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 214 23 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 1 On on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 2 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 3 view view NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 5 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 6 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 7 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 8 assigned assign VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 9 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 10 ' ' `` cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 11 score'-this score'-this NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 12 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 13 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 14 an an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 15 algorithm algorithm NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 215 16 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 1 Instead instead RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 3 doctors doctor NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 4 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 5 responsible responsible JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 6 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 7 applying apply VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 8 flexible flexible JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 9 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 10 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 11 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 12 own own JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 13 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 14 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 15 discretion discretion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 16 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 17 together together RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 18 with with IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 19 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 20 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 21 teams team NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 23 coordinators coordinator NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 24 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 25 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 26 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 27 light light NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 28 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 29 each each DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 30 patient patient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 31 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 32 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 33 circumstances circumstance NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 34 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 35 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 36 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 37 available available JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 216 38 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 2 advantage advantage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 4 such such PDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 5 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 6 system system NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 7 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 8 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 9 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 10 does do VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 11 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 12 promise promise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 13 more more JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 14 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 15 objectivity objectivity NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 16 ' ' '' cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 17 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 18 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 19 selection selection NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 20 criteria criterion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 21 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 22 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 23 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 24 delivered deliver VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 25 ; ; : cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 26 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 27 does do VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 28 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 29 promise promise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 30 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 31 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 32 advance advance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 33 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 34 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 35 actual actual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 36 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 37 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 38 more more JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 39 determination determination NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 40 than than IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 41 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 42 possible possible JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 43 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 44 ethically ethically RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 45 justifiable justifiable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 217 46 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 2 goes go VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 3 without without IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 4 saying say VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 5 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 6 proper proper JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 7 records record NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 8 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 9 every every DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 10 such such JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 11 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 12 must must MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 13 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 14 maintained maintain VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 15 so so IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 16 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 17 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 18 can can MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 19 understand understand VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 20 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 21 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 22 why why WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 23 each each DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 24 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 25 was be VBD cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 26 made make VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 218 27 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 1 36 36 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 2 Opinions opinion NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 3 will will MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 4 differ differ VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 5 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 6 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 7 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 8 model model NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 9 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 10 most most RBS cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 11 helpful helpful JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 219 12 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 1 On on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 2 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 3 one one CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 4 hand hand NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 6 too too RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 7 much much JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 8 flexibility flexibility NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 9 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 10 compromise compromise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 11 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 12 possibility possibility NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 13 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 14 invoking invoke VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 15 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 16 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 17 process process NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 18 ; ; : cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 19 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 20 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 21 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 22 other other JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 23 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 24 highly highly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 25 detailed detailed JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 26 scoring score VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 27 systems system NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 28 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 29 disguise disguise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 30 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 31 reality reality NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 32 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 33 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 34 need need NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 35 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 36 make make VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 37 judgements judgement NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 38 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 39 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 40 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 41 interweave interweave VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 42 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 43 value value NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 44 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 45 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 46 experience experience NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 220 47 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 1 Whichever whichever WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 3 preferred prefer VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 5 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 6 must must MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 7 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 8 based base VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 9 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 10 candour candour NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 11 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 12 trust trust NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 13 between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 14 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 15 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 16 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 17 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 19 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 20 merits merit NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 21 further further JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 22 discussion discussion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 221 23 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 2 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 3 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 4 given give VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 5 rise rise NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 6 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 7 much much JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 8 discomfort discomfort NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 9 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 11 kinds kind NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 12 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 13 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 14 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 15 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 16 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 17 front front JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 18 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 19 line line NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 20 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 21 workers worker NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 22 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 23 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 24 required require VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 25 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 26 make make VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 27 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 28 allocating allocate VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 29 limited limited JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 30 healthcare healthcare NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 31 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 222 32 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 1 These these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 2 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 3 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 4 forced force VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 5 us -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 6 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 7 confront confront VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 8 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 9 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 10 interventions intervention NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 11 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 12 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 13 scale scale NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 14 never never RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 15 before before IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 16 required require VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 223 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 2 addition addition NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 3 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 4 being be VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 5 deeply deeply RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 6 morally morally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 7 disturbing disturbing JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 9 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 10 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 11 given give VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 12 rise rise NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 13 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 14 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 15 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 16 objections objection NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 224 17 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 1 Decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 2 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 3 makers maker NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 4 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 5 have have VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 6 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 7 traumatised traumatise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 8 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 10 nature nature NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 12 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 13 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 14 challenge challenge NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 15 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 16 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 17 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 18 risk risk NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 19 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 20 being be VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 21 called call VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 22 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 23 account account VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 24 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 25 law law NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 225 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 1 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 2 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 3 sought seek VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 4 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 5 clarify clarify VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 6 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 7 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 8 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 9 front front JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 10 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 11 line line NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 12 workers worker NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 13 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 14 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 15 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 16 echoes echo VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 17 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 18 many many JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 19 respects respect NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 20 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 21 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 22 frameworks framework NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 23 developed develop VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 24 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 25 CCG CCG NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 26 resource resource NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 27 allocation allocation NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 28 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 29 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 30 broadly broadly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 31 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 32 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 33 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 34 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 35 subject subject JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 36 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 37 certain certain JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 38 constraints constraint NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 39 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 40 formalised formalise VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 41 processes process NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 42 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 43 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 44 law law NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 45 has have VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 46 accommodated accommodate VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 226 47 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 1 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 2 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 3 takes take VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 5 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 6 approach approach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 7 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 8 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 9 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 11 recognising recognise VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 12 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 13 intractable intractable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 14 difficulty difficulty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 16 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 17 importance importance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 18 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 19 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 20 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 21 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 22 respect respect NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 23 that that WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 24 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 25 owed owe VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 26 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 27 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 28 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 29 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 30 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 31 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 32 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 33 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 34 whole whole NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 227 35 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 2 calls call NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 3 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 4 national national JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 5 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 6 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 7 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 8 warranted warrant VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 228 9 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 1 Such such JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 2 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 3 would would MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 4 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 5 help help VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 6 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 7 settle settle VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 9 collective collective JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 10 nerves nerve NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 11 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 12 even even RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 13 if if IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 14 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 15 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 16 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 17 strictly strictly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 18 necessary necessary JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 19 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 20 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 21 procedural procedural JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 22 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 23 we -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 24 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 25 articulated articulate VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 229 26 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 1 But but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 2 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 3 calls call NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 4 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 5 largely largely RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 6 failed fail VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 7 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 8 capture capture VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 10 central central JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 11 issue issue NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 12 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 13 what what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 14 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 15 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 16 should should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 17 look look VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 18 like like IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 19 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 20 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 21 what what WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 22 consistency consistency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 23 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 24 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 25 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 26 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 27 demands demand NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 230 28 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 231 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 231 2 account account NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 231 3 above above RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 231 4 provides provide VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 231 5 that that DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 231 6 content content NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 231 7 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 1 More more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 2 broadly broadly RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 4 outside outside IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 6 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 7 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 8 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 9 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 10 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 11 features feature NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 12 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 13 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 14 current current JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 15 debate debate NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 16 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 17 revealed reveal VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 18 how how WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 19 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 20 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 21 too too RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 22 long long RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 23 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 24 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 25 traditions tradition NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 26 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 27 bioethics bioethic NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 28 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 29 law law NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 30 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 31 focused focus VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 32 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 33 attention attention NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 34 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 35 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 36 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 37 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 38 obligations obligation NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 39 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 40 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 41 patients patient NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 42 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 43 clinicians clinician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 232 44 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 1 37 37 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 2 38 38 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 3 This this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 5 given give VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 7 history history NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 8 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 9 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 10 respective respective JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 11 fields field NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 13 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 14 understandable understandable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 16 but but CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 17 times time NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 18 such such JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 19 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 20 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 21 illustrate illustrate VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 22 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 23 myopia myopia NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 24 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 25 this this DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 26 approach approach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 233 27 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 2 bioethics bioethic NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 3 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 4 as as IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 5 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 6 medical medical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 7 law law NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 8 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 9 there there EX cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 10 have have VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 11 been be VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 12 some some DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 13 notable notable JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 14 recent recent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 15 movements movement NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 16 towards towards IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 17 thinking think VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 18 about about IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 19 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 20 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 21 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 22 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 23 policy policy NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 24 obligations obligation NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 25 at at IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 26 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 27 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 28 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 29 social social JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 30 level level NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 234 31 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 1 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 2 39 39 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 3 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 4 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 5 40 40 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 6 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 7 [ [ -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 8 41 41 CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 235 9 ] ] -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 1 In in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 2 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 3 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 4 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 5 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 6 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 7 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 8 these these DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 9 kinds kind NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 10 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 11 public public NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 12 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 13 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 14 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 15 wider wide JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 16 social social JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 17 considerations consideration NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 18 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 19 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 20 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 21 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 236 22 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 1 To to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 2 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 3 clear clear JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 4 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 5 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 6 think think VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 7 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 8 broader broad JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 9 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 10 terms term NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 11 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 12 not not RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 13 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 14 abandon abandon VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 15 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 16 individual individual NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 17 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 18 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 19 moral moral JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 20 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 21 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 22 specialness specialness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 23 - - : cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 24 far far RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 25 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 26 it -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 237 27 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 2 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 3 simply simply RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 4 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 5 recognise recognise VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 6 that that IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 7 individual individual JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 8 - - HYPH cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 9 specific specific JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 10 values value NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 11 emerge emerge VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 12 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 13 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 14 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 15 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 16 embedded embed VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 17 within within IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 18 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 19 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 20 context context NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 21 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 22 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 23 wider wide JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 24 community community NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 25 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 26 which which WDT cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 27 all all DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 28 individuals individual NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 29 are be VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 30 located locate VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 238 31 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 239 1 Twitter Twitter NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 239 2 Mark Mark NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 239 3 Sheehan Sheehan NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 240 1 @mark_sheehan_ox @mark_sheehan_ox NFP cord-343877-jzkaee16 241 1 Ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 241 2 dimensions dimension NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 241 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 241 4 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 241 5 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 241 6 frontline frontline JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 241 7 staff staff NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 241 8 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 242 1 London London NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 242 2 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 242 3 Royal Royal NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 242 4 College College NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 242 5 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 1 Physicians physician NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 2 Covid-19 covid-19 VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 3 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 4 government government NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 5 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 6 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 7 emergency emergency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 8 rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 9 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 10 critical critical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 11 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 12 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 13 needed need VBN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 14 to to TO cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 15 support support VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 16 professional professional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 17 decision decision NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 18 making make VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 19 COVID-19 covid-19 VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 20 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 21 where where WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 22 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 23 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 24 National National NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 25 ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 26 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 27 Who who WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 28 gets get VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 29 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 30 ventilator ventilator NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 243 31 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 1 important important JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 2 legal legal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 3 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 4 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 5 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 6 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 7 Autonomy autonomy NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 8 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 9 trust trust VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 10 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 11 bioethics bioethics NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 12 British british JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 13 idealism idealism NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 244 14 -a -a . cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 1 history history NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 2 Re re NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 3 - - VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 4 balancing balance VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 5 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 6 Rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 7 Debate debate NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 8 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 9 Tackling tackle VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 11 Tensions tension NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 12 Between between IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 13 Individual Individual NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 14 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 15 Community Community NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 245 16 rights right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 2 future future NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 4 bioethics bioethic NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 5 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 6 three three CD cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 7 dogmas dogma NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 8 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 9 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 10 cup cup NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 11 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 12 hemlock hemlock NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 13 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 14 equality equality NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 15 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 16 social social JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 17 justice justice NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 18 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 19 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 20 poverty poverty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 21 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 22 autonomy autonomy NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 23 Preserving preserve VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 24 social social JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 25 citizenship citizenship NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 26 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 27 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 28 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 246 29 markets market NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 1 -there -there : cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 2 may may MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 3 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 4 trouble trouble NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 5 ahead ahead RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 6 National National NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 7 Institute Institute NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 8 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 9 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 10 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 11 Care Care NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 12 Excellence Excellence NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 13 ( ( -LRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 14 NICE nice JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 247 15 ) ) -RRB- cord-343877-jzkaee16 248 1 University University NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 248 2 College College NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 1 London London NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 2 Hospitals Hospitals NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 3 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 4 Foundation Foundation NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 5 Trust Trust NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 6 v v NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 7 MB MB NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 8 Burke Burke NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 9 v v IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 10 General General NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 11 Medical Medical NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 12 Council Council NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 13 Royal Royal NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 14 Borough Borough NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 15 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 16 Kensington Kensington NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 17 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 249 18 Chelsea Chelsea NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 250 1 Who who WP cord-343877-jzkaee16 250 2 Should Should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 250 3 We -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 250 4 Treat treat VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 250 5 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 251 1 -Rights -right NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 251 2 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 251 3 Rationing rationing NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 251 4 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 251 5 Resources Resources NNPS cord-343877-jzkaee16 251 6 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 251 7 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 251 8 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 1 From from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 2 wednesbury wednesbury NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 3 unreasonableness unreasonableness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 4 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 5 accountability accountability NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 6 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 7 reasonableness reasonableness NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 8 Medicine Medicine NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 9 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 10 social social JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 11 justice justice NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 12 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 13 essays essay NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 14 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 15 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 16 distribution distribution NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 17 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 18 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 19 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 252 20 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 253 1 2 2 LS cord-343877-jzkaee16 253 2 nd nd NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 253 3 ed ed NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 253 4 Commissioning commission VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 253 5 ethically ethically RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 253 6 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 253 7 legally legally RB cord-343877-jzkaee16 253 8 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 1 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 2 more more JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 3 things thing NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 4 change change VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 5 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 7 more more RBR cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 8 they -PRON- PRP cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 9 stay stay VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 10 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 254 11 same same JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 1 Should Should MD cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 2 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 3 decisions decision NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 4 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 5 institutional institutional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 6 review review NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 7 boards board NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 8 be be VB cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 9 consistent consistent JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 255 10 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 256 1 Considerations consideration NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 256 2 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 256 3 ventilator ventilator NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 256 4 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 256 5 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 256 6 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 256 7 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 256 8 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 257 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 257 2 Toughest tough JJS cord-343877-jzkaee16 257 3 Triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 1 -Allocating -allocate VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 2 Ventilators ventilator NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 3 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 4 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 5 Pandemic Pandemic NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 6 Cambridge Cambridge NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 7 University University NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 8 Hospital Hospital NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 9 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 10 Foundation Foundation NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 11 Trust Trust NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 12 Aintree Aintree NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 13 University University NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 14 Hospital Hospital NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 15 NHS NHS NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 16 Foundation Foundation NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 17 Trust Trust NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 18 v v IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 19 James James NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 20 Ethical ethical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 21 principles principle NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 22 concerning concern VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 23 proportionality proportionality NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 24 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 25 critical critical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 26 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 27 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 28 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 29 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 30 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 31 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 32 advice advice NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 33 by by IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 34 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 35 Belgian Belgian NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 36 Society Society NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 37 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 38 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 39 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 40 medicine medicine NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 258 41 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 1 Belgian Belgian NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 2 Society Society NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 4 intensive intensive JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 5 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 6 medicine medicine NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 7 Nice Nice NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 8 updates update NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 259 9 rapid rapid JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 1 COVID-19 covid-19 JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 2 guidance guidance NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 3 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 4 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 5 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 6 Allocation Allocation NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 7 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 8 scarce scarce JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 9 critical critical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 10 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 11 resources resource NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 12 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 13 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 14 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 15 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 260 16 emergency emergency NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 1 Bolam Bolam NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 2 v v IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 3 Friern Friern NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 4 Hospital Hospital NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 5 Management Management NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 6 Committee Committee NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 7 Transplant Transplant NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 8 recipient recipient NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 9 selection selection NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 10 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 11 peacetime peacetime NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 12 vs. vs. FW cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 13 wartime wartime JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 14 triage triage NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 15 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 16 Inequality Inequality NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 17 or or CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 18 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 19 Why why WRB cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 20 Justice justice NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 21 is be VBZ cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 22 Good good JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 23 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 24 Our -PRON- PRP$ cord-343877-jzkaee16 261 25 Health Health NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 2 Perversion perversion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 4 autonomy autonomy NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 5 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 6 coercion coercion NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 7 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 8 constraints constraint NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 9 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 10 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 11 liberal liberal JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 12 Society Society NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 13 A a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 14 broader broad JJR cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 15 liberty liberty NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 16 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 17 J.S. J.S. NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 18 Mill Mill NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 19 , , , cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 20 paternalism paternalism NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 21 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 22 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 23 public public NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 24 's 's POS cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 25 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 26 Adjusting adjust VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 27 the the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 28 focus focus NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 29 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 30 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 31 public public JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 32 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 33 ethics ethic NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 34 approach approach NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 35 to to IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 36 data datum NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 262 37 research research NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 1 An an DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 2 ethics ethic NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 3 framework framework NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 4 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 5 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 6 learning learn VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 7 health health NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 8 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 9 system system NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 10 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 11 a a DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 12 departure departure NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 13 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 14 traditional traditional JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 15 research research NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 16 ethics ethic NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 17 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 18 clinical clinical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 263 19 ethics ethic NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 264 1 The the DT cord-343877-jzkaee16 264 2 standard standard NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 264 3 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 264 4 care care NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 264 5 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 264 6 medical medical JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 264 7 negligence negligence NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 264 8 -moving -move VBG cord-343877-jzkaee16 265 1 on on IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 265 2 from from IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 265 3 Bolam Bolam NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 266 1 > > XX cord-343877-jzkaee16 266 2 ? ? . cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 1 Ethics ethic NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 2 framework framework VBP cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 3 for for IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 4 use use NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 5 in in IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 6 acute acute JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 7 paediatric paediatric JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 8 settings setting NNS cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 9 during during IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 10 COVID-19 covid-19 JJ cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 11 pandemic pandemic NN cord-343877-jzkaee16 267 12 . . . cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 1 London London NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 2 : : : cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 3 Royal Royal NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 4 College College NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 5 of of IN cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 6 Paediatrics Paediatrics NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 7 and and CC cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 8 Child Child NNP cord-343877-jzkaee16 268 9 Health Health NNP