key: cord-255936-hfa9w2dg
authors: Jin, Junyeong; Park, Changhoon; Cho, Sun-Hee; Chung, Junho
title: The level of decoy epitope in PCV2 vaccine affects the neutralizing activity of sera in the immunized animals
date: 2018-02-12
journal: Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications
DOI: 10.1016/j.bbrc.2018.01.141
sha: 
doc_id: 255936
cord_uid: hfa9w2dg

Abstract Viral pathogens have evolved a wide range of tactics to evade host immune responses and thus propagate effectively. One efficient tactic is to divert host immune responses toward an immunodominant decoy epitope and to induce non-neutralizing antibodies toward this epitope. Therefore, it is expected that the amount of decoy epitope in a subunit vaccine can affect the level of neutralizing antibody in an immunized animal. In this study, we tested this hypothesis by generating an antibody specific to the decoy epitope on the capsid protein of porcine circovirus type 2 (PCV2). Using this antibody, we found that two commercial vaccines contained statistically different amounts of the decoy epitope. The vaccine with lower levels of decoy epitope induced a significantly higher level of neutralizing antibody after immunization. This antibody can be used as an analytical tool to monitor the quality of a vaccine from batch to batch.

Viral pathogens have evolved a wide range of tactics to evade host immune responses and propagate effectively [1] . One such tactic is to divert the host immune response with a decoy. Decoy epitopes have been reported in a wide variety of viruses, including human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) [2] , feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) [3] , hepatitis C [4] , foot and mouth disease [5] , middleeast respiratory syndrome coronavirus [6] , severe fever with thrombocytopenia syndrome virus [7] , porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) [8] , murine gammaherpesvirus-68 (MHV-68) [9] , and porcine circovirus type 2 (PCV2) [10] . Because a recombinant mutant capsid protein (CP) with a deleted decoy epitope induced a higher level of virusneutralizing antibody than wild type proteins [11] , it was expected that higher levels of decoy epitope in a prepared batch of subunit vaccine would decrease its efficacy. However, it was not possible to test this hypothesis by measuring levels of decoy epitope in a vaccine because an antibody specific to the decoy epitope was not readily available.

PCV2 has a spherical structure with icosahedral symmetry [12] . The only structural protein of this virus is a 28-kD CP, which includes major antigenic determinants that can be used in subunit vaccines [13] . A previous study showed that an epitope composed of amino acid residues 169e180 (CP 169e180 ) is the most immunodominant among these antigenic determinants [11] . Because this epitope is buried inside the virus-like particle (VLP) structure (Fig. 1A) , antibodies to this epitope cannot react with the intact virus, and therefore are non-neutralizing [14] . As expected, PCV infection elicited a humoral response to the CP 169e180 epitope and drove the production of non-neutralizing antibodies [15] . Therefore, previous infection with PCV decreased the vaccines prevention of the future infections.

Since the first vaccine against PCV2 was introduced to the global market in 2006, nine PCV2 subunit vaccines have become available [16] . However, they were expected to contain differing amounts of incomplete VLPs, which are non-uniformly aggregated CPs with an exposed CP 169e180 epitope [17] . Incomplete VLPs can induce production of non-neutralizing antibodies and reduce vaccine efficacy [14, 18] . As there was no analytical tool to measure the amount of CP 169e180 epitope in a prepared batch of vaccine, it was not possible to correlate epitope levels with neutralizing activity after vaccination.

In this study, we developed an antibody specific to the CP 169e180 epitope, determined the relative amounts of CP 169e180 epitope in two commercially available vaccines, and analyzed the influence of the epitope level on the induction of neutralizing antibody.

2.1. Preparation of VLP, PCV2 recombinant proteins, and peptide conjugates PCV2 CP (amino acids [aa] 1e233) was expressed in baculovirusinfected Sf9 insect cells, as previously described [19] . The PCV2 ORF2 gene (GenBank no. EU747125) was cloned into the pFastBac expression vector (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) and transfected into Sf9 cells. The culture supernatant containing the recombinant baculovirus was harvested and used to infect a separate batch of Sf9 cells. After 3 days, VLPs were purified from culture supernatant by sucrose gradient ultracentrifugation.

Recombinant CP with a deletion of the N-terminal region of the protein (delN CP, aa 44e233) was expressed in Escherichia coli and purified, as described previously [12, 20, 21] . A synthetic CP 169e180 peptide (STIDYFQPNNKRC) was chemically synthesized using Fmoc solid-phase peptide synthesis (Peptron, Inc., Daejeon, South Korea) and conjugated to bovine serum albumin (BSA) or keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) [10] .

White leghorn chickens were immunized with KLH-conjugated CP 169e180 peptides. A phage-displayed chicken single-chain variable fragment (scFv) library was constructed using total RNA isolated from the bone marrow, spleen, and bursa of Fabricius of immunized chickens, as previously described [22] . A positive clone was enriched by biopanning and screened in a phage enzyme immunoassay, as described previously [23, 24] .

The gene encoding the selected scFv clone was subcloned into a modified mammalian expression vector encoding the C k domain of human IgG at the 3 0 region [25] . The scFv-C k fusion protein (anti-CP 169e180 antibody) was purified from the culture supernatants of transiently transfected HEK293F cells using KappaSelect resin (GE Fig. 1 . A novel PCV2 antibody is specific to the CP 169e180 epitope. (A) The three-dimensional structure of PCV2 (PDB: 3JCI) was visualized by PyMOL 1.3. One capsid protein (CP) and the immunodominant CP 169e180 decoy epitope are marked in green and red, respectively. (B) Enzyme immunoassay using the anti-CP 169e180 antibody. The amount of antibody bound to antigens coated on microtiter plate was detected by HRP-conjugated goat anti-human C k antibody. The results are the means ± standard deviations from experiments conducted in triplicate; **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001 by two-tailed unpaired Student's t-test. (C) Immunoblot analysis using the anti-CP 169e180 antibody. After the gel electrophoresis, antigens were transfected to nitrocellulose membrane. The membrane was probed with anti-CP 169e180 antibody.

Healthcare, London, UK), according to the manufacturer's instructions.

The wells of a 96-well microtiter plate (Corning) were coated with BSA-conjugated CP 169e180 peptides, delN CP, and purified VLP in coating buffer (0.1 M NaHCO 3 , pH 8.6) and then blocked with 3% (w/v) BSA in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS). After incubation with 1 mg/mL of anti-CP 169e180 antibody, horseradish peroxidase (HRP)conjugated goat anti-human C k antibodies (Chemicon-Millipore, Billerica, MA, USA) were added to each well. After washing with 0.05% (v/v) Tween 20 in PBS (PBST), 3,3 0 ,5,5 0 -tetramethyl benzidine (TMB) (GenDEPOT, Barker, TX, USA) substrate solution was added and the absorbance was measured at 650 nm with a Multiskan Ascent microplate reader (LabSystems, Helsinki, Finland) [26] .

Dissolved proteins and BSA-conjugated CP 169e180 peptides were boiled for 10 min in lithium dodecyl sulfate sample buffer with reducing agents (Invitrogen). The samples were then electrophoretically separated on a NuPage 4e12% Bis-Tris gel (Invitrogen) and transferred to a nitrocellulose membrane [27] . After blocking with 5% (w/v) skim milk in Tris-buffered saline, the membrane was incubated with 1 mg/mL of anti-CP 169e180 antibody and probed with HRP-conjugated goat anti-human C k antibodies (Chemicon-Millipore). The blot was visualized using SuperSignal West Pico chemiluminescent substrate (Thermo Fisher Scientific, IL, USA).

All animal experiments were performed under the approval of the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of the BioPOA (permit no. BP-2015-030-2). After the collection of sera from PCV2infected pigs and pigs with no infection history, the competition enzyme immunoassay was performed as described previously with the following appropriate modifications [25] . After pre-incubating non-infected and infected porcine sera (n ¼ 3/group) with serially diluted anti-CP 169e180 antibody, the mixtures were added to microtiter plate coated with BSA-conjugated CP 169e180 peptide. An irrelevant scFv fused with a C k domain was used as an isotypematched control. The amount of bound porcine IgG was determined by HRP-conjugated goat anti-porcine IgG antibodies (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, TX, USA) and TMB was used for the substrate of HRP.

We randomly designated two of out nine commercial vaccines ( The level of total PCV2 antigen in prepared VLP, delN CP, and the two commercial vaccines was measured by enzyme immunoassay using an anti-PCV2 polyclonal antibody (Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory, Iowa State University, Iowa, USA) [28] and HRP-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG antibodies (Bethyl Laboratories, Montgomery, TX, USA), as described previously.

To monitor the CP 169e180 epitope levels, we performed the enzyme immunoassay using the anti-CP 169e180 antibody and HRPconjugated goat anti-human C k antibodies (Chemicon-Millipore), as previously described.

Twenty guinea pigs were randomly divided into four groups (n ¼ 5/group). Each guinea pig was immunized intradermally with 200 mL of VLP, delN CP, or commercial vaccine. Four weeks after immunization, whole blood was collected and sera were prepared.

An indirect fluorescence assay (IFA) was performed using the sera and PCV2-infected PK-15 cells, as previously described [18, 29] . To monitor the reactivity of sera to the CP 169e180 epitope, enzyme immunoassays, using BSA-conjugated CP 169e180 peptides and HRPconjugated anti-guinea pig IgG antibodies (Bethyl Laboratories), were performed as described previously. We performed serum virus neutralization assays using PK-15 cells, as described previously [30, 31] .

Statistical analysis was conducted using GraphPad Prism (v5.0; GraphPad Software Inc., San Diego, CA, USA). Results are expressed as means and standard deviations of the indicated number of independent measurements. Statistical significance was determined using two-tailed unpaired Student's t tests and non-parametric Mann-Whitney's u test. Two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to analyze the relationship between the two independent factors. For all statistical analyses, p values of <0.05 were considered statistically significant.

A phage display library of combinatorial scFv was prepared using chickens immunized with KLH-conjugated CP 169e180 peptides. The complexity of the library exceeded 1.2 Â 10 9 . To enrich for scFv clones with specific reactivity to the CP 169e180 epitope, six total rounds of biopanning were performed. For each round of biopanning, monomeric delN CP and CP 169e180 peptides were alternately used as antigens. The N terminus of CP plays a key role in the assembly of the VLP structure. Thus, deletion of the N-terminal region exposes the CP 169e180 epitope (del CP).

After biopanning, the reactivity of individual clones to CP 169e180 peptide, delN CP, and PCV2 VLPs was tested by phage enzyme immunoassay. A clone was selected, and its recombinant scFv-C k fusion protein prepared using a mammalian expression system. The recombinant scFv-C k fusion protein reacted to CP 169e180 peptide and delN CP, but not to VLPs (Fig. 1B) . In immunoblot analysis, the recombinant scFv-C k fusion protein was reactive not only to the CP 169e180 peptide and delN CP, but also to VLPs, because the CP 169e180 epitope on VLP was exposed by the denaturation that occurs during sample preparation (Fig. 1C) .

Although the CP 169e180 segment is too short to harbor more than one antigenic determinant, we further confirmed a number of antigenic determinants using the polyclonal sera of pigs infected with PCV2. In a competition enzyme immunoassay employing a microtiter plate coated with BSA-conjugated CP 169e180 peptide and HRP-conjugated anti-porcine IgG antibody, the recombinant anti-CP 169e180 antibody almost completely inhibited the binding of naturally occurring anti-CP 169e180 antibody to the peptide in a PCV2-infected pig's sera (Fig. 2) . From these results, we concluded that there is only one antigenic determinant in CP 169e180 residues.

The relative amount of PCV2 antigen in two commercially available vaccines was determined in an enzyme immunoassay, using purified VLP and the recombinant delN CP protein. The amount of coated antigen was then determined by anti-PCV2 polyclonal antibody. Because the quantity of bound antibody was not statistically different between the vaccines, we concluded that they contained similar amounts of the recombinant CP (Fig. 3A) . We then determined the relative amount of CP 169e180 epitope in these two vaccines with an enzyme immunoassay employing anti-CP 169e180 antibody (Fig. 3B) . Because we found a higher amount of anti-CP 169e180 antibody bound to vaccine A-coated wells than in vaccine B-coated wells, we concluded that vaccine A contained a higher amount of CP 169e180 epitope.

To monitor the humoral response, we collected sera from guinea pigs (n ¼ 5/group) that were immunized with vaccines. For control sera, we also immunized with VLPs and the recombinant delN CP in parallel. To confirm successful vaccination, we performed IFA as described previously using PCV2-infected PK-15 cells [18, 29] . There was no statistical difference between the antibody titer of sera obtained from animals immunized with the two vaccines. As expected, the sera of animals immunized with delN CP showed a statistically lower antibody titer compared to other groups (p < 0.05) (Fig. 3C) . In an enzyme immunoassay employing a microtiter plate coated with BSA-conjugated CP 169e180 peptide, sera from animals immunized with vaccine A had a significantly higher antibody titer than vaccine B-vaccinated animals (p < 0.01) (Fig. 3D) . Additionally, the sera of delN CP-immunized animals had a significantly higher antibody titer than those of VLP-immunized animals (p < 0.01). Then we measured and compared the neutralizing activity of sera in an in vitro infection experiment employing PCV2 virus and PK-15 cells. The sera from vaccine B-immunized animals had a significantly higher neutralizing antibody titer than sera from vaccine A-immunized animals (p < 0.001) (Fig. 3E) . Also, the sera of VLP-immunized animals showed significantly higher neutralizing activity than sera of VLP-immunized animals (p < 0.01).

Since the emergence of PCV2, there has been considerable effort to produce an effective vaccine [32] . For some time, the main hurdle was efficient overexpression of CP [19, 33] . Later, it was found that the immunodominant CP 169e180 epitope of PCV2 is buried during viral capsid assembly and that the antibodies targeting this epitope are non-neutralizing, which is a common viral immune-evasion mechanism [14] . PCV2 infection inevitably provokes exposure to the decoy epitope and therefore is less effective at generating a protective humoral response than immunization of the subunit vaccine with a minimal amount of exposed decoy epitope [18] .

Researchers had predicted that incomplete VLPs with an exposed immunodominant CP 169e180 epitope can be contaminated during the preparation of subunit vaccine and drive the humoral response to produce non-neutralizing antibodies, but could not quantify the exposed immunodominant CP 169e180 epitope in the subunit vaccines because of the lack of proper analytical tools [33e36]. To rectify this, we generated a monoclonal antibody specific to the immunodominant CP 169e180 epitope from an antibody library generated using chickens immunized with CP 169e180 peptide. This recombinant anti-CP 169e180 antibody preferentially reacted to delN CP with an exposed CP 169e180 epitope compared to VLP in an enzyme immunoassay (Fig. 1B) . Because the length of linear B-cell epitopes can vary widely from 3 to 38 amino acids [37] , we confirmed that CP 169e180 peptides behave as a single epitope in a competition enzyme immunoassay. The recombinant CP 169e180 antibody almost completely inhibited the binding of PCV2-infected pig sera to CP 169e180 peptide.

We then used this antibody to quantify the relative amount of CP 169e180 epitope in two commercially available vaccines and found that vaccine A contained significantly more decoy epitope than vaccine B. After immunization, vaccine A induced a significantly higher antibody response to decoy epitope than vaccine B, which supported the finding that vaccine B induced a higher amount of neutralizing antibody.

In summary, our research demonstrated that the amount of immunodominant decoy epitope present in PCV2 vaccine can be measured by an epitope-specific antibody. From the measured level of decoy epitope, we could predict the efficacy of a vaccine for the induction of neutralizing antibody titer. We believe that anti-CP 169e180 antibody can be used to monitor the varying quality of the subunit vaccine from batch to batch. Fig. 2 . Recombinant anti-CP 169e180 antibody inhibited the binding of naturally occurring antibody. After pre-incubation with sera from the non-infected (A) and infected pigs (B) with anti-CP 169e180 antibody (n ¼ 3/group), the mixtures were added to a CP 169e180 peptide-coated microtiter plate. The amount of bound porcine antibody was measured by HRP-conjugated anti-porcine IgG antibody. Absorbance was measured at 650 nm. The results are the means ± standard deviations from the experiments, which were conducted in triplicate using the sera from three pigs (P1, P2, and P3 in each group).

The authors have declared that there is no conflict of interest.

Anti-immunology: evasion of the host immune system by bacterial and viral pathogens

Neutralizing antibodies generated during natural HIV-1 infection: good news for an HIV-1 vaccine?

Feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) neutralization: a review

Immune control and failure in HCV infectionetipping the balance

Xenoepitope substitution avoids deceptive imprinting and broadens the immune response to foot-and-mouth disease virus

Introduction of neutralizing immunogenicity index to the rational design of MERS coronavirus subunit vaccines

Critical epitopes in the nucleocapsid protein of SFTS virus recognized by a panel of SFTS patients derived human monoclonal antibodies

Signal peptide cleavage from GP5 of PRRSV: a minor fraction of molecules retains the decoy epitope, a presumed molecular cause for viral persistence

The murine gammaherpesvirus-68 gp150 acts as an immunogenic decoy to limit virion neutralization

Antibody recognition of porcine circovirus type 2 capsid protein epitopes after vaccination, infection, and disease

Replacing the decoy epitope of PCV2b capsid protein with a protective epitope enhances efficacy of PCV2b vaccine

Structural insights into the assembly and regulation of distinct viral capsid complexes

Interaction of the replication proteins and the capsid protein of porcine circovirus type 1 and 2 with host proteins

Recognition of the different structural forms of the capsid protein determines the outcome following infection with porcine circovirus type 2

Genetic variation of porcine circovirus type 2 (PCV2) and its relevance to vaccination, pathogenesis and diagnosis

Commercial porcine circovirus type 2 vaccines: efficacy and clinical

CP 169e180 epitope level was measured in an enzyme immunoassay using the anti-CP 169e180 antibody. (C) Anti-PCV2 antibody in the immunized sera was determined by an indirect fluorescence assay using PCV2-infected PK-15 cells (n ¼ 5/group). (D) The amount of anti-CP 169e180 antibody in the immunized sera was measured in an enzyme immunoassay using a CP 169e180 peptide-coated microtiter plate. (E) Neutralizing activity of the immunized sera was measured with a virus neutralization assay. Results are the means ± standard deviations

Virus-like particles in vaccine development

Antibody responses following vaccination versus infection in a porcine circovirus-type 2 (PCV2) disease model show distinct differences in virus neutralization and epitope recognition

Efficient production of type 2 porcine circovirus-like particles by a recombinant baculovirus

Characterization of porcine circovirus type 2 (PCV2) capsid particle assembly and its application to virus-like particle vaccine development

Expression of porcine circovirus 2 ORF2 gene requires codon optimized E. coli cells

Barbas 3rd, Methods for the generation of chicken monoclonal antibody fragments by phage display

Phage Display: a Laboratory Manual

A point mutation in the heavy chain complementarity-determining region 3 (HCDR3) significantly enhances the specificity of an anti-ROS1 antibody

An antibody reactive to the Gly63-Lys68 epitope of NT-proBNP exhibits O-glycosylation-independent binding

Chicken scFvs with an artificial cysteine for site-directed conjugation

Western blotting": electrophoretic transfer of proteins from sodium dodecyl sulfateepolyacrylamide gels to unmodified nitrocellulose and radiographic detection with antibody and radioiodinated protein A

Evaluation of commercial polyclonal-and monoclonal-antibody-based immunohistochemical tests for 2 genotypes of Porcine circovirus type 2 and comparison with in-situ hybridization assays

Comparative efficacy of experimental inactivated and live-attenuated chimeric porcine circovirus (PCV) 1-2b vaccines derived from PCV1 and PCV2b isolates originated in China

Production, preliminary characterisation and applications of monoclonal antibodies to porcine circovirus

Characterization of immune response of young pigs to porcine circovirus type 2 infection

Global status of porcine circovirus type 2 and its associated diseases in sub-saharan africa

Enhanced production of porcine circovirus type 2 (PCV2) virus-like particles in Sf9 cells by translational enhancers

Protection of swine against post-weaning multisystemic wasting syndrome (PMWS) by porcine circovirus type 2 (PCV2) proteins

Immunogenicity of empty capsids of porcine circovius type 2 produced in insect cells

Immunity conferred by an experimental vaccine based on the recombinant PCV2 Cap protein expressed in Trichoplusia ni-larvae

Predicting flexible length linear B-cell epitopes

We would like to thank Tae-Eun Kim for the technical assistance and Taeyeub Lee for structural modeling of PCV2 using PyMOL1.3. 

Transparency document related to this article can be found online at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbrc.2018.01.141.