id sid tid token lemma pos 9151 1 1 Editorial Editorial NNP 9151 1 2 Board Board NNP 9151 1 3 Thoughts Thoughts NNPS 9151 1 4 : : : 9151 1 5 Library Library NNP 9151 1 6 Analytics Analytics NNPS 9151 1 7 and and CC 9151 1 8 Patron Patron NNP 9151 1 9 Privacy Privacy NNP 9151 1 10 Ken Ken NNP 9151 1 11 Varnum Varnum NNP 9151 1 12 INFORMATION INFORMATION VBD 9151 1 13 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 9151 1 14 AND and CC 9151 1 15 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 9151 1 16 | | NNP 9151 1 17 DECEMBER DECEMBER NNS 9151 1 18 2015 2015 CD 9151 1 19 2 2 CD 9151 1 20 Two two CD 9151 1 21 significant significant JJ 9151 1 22 trends trend NNS 9151 1 23 are be VBP 9151 1 24 sweeping sweep VBG 9151 1 25 across across IN 9151 1 26 the the DT 9151 1 27 library library NN 9151 1 28 landscape landscape NN 9151 1 29 : : : 9151 1 30 assessment assessment NN 9151 1 31 ( ( -LRB- 9151 1 32 and and CC 9151 1 33 the the DT 9151 1 34 corresponding correspond VBG 9151 1 35 collection collection NN 9151 1 36 and and CC 9151 1 37 analysis analysis NN 9151 1 38 of of IN 9151 1 39 data datum NNS 9151 1 40 ) ) -RRB- 9151 1 41 and and CC 9151 1 42 privacy privacy NN 9151 1 43 ( ( -LRB- 9151 1 44 of of IN 9151 1 45 records record NNS 9151 1 46 of of IN 9151 1 47 user user NN 9151 1 48 interactions interaction NNS 9151 1 49 with with IN 9151 1 50 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 1 51 services service NNS 9151 1 52 ) ) -RRB- 9151 1 53 . . . 9151 2 1 Libraries library NNS 9151 2 2 , , , 9151 2 3 perhaps perhaps RB 9151 2 4 more more JJR 9151 2 5 than than IN 9151 2 6 any any DT 9151 2 7 other other JJ 9151 2 8 public public JJ 9151 2 9 service service NN 9151 2 10 organization organization NN 9151 2 11 , , , 9151 2 12 are be VBP 9151 2 13 strongly strongly RB 9151 2 14 motivated motivated JJ 9151 2 15 to to TO 9151 2 16 assess assess VB 9151 2 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 9151 2 18 offerings offering NNS 9151 2 19 with with IN 9151 2 20 dual dual JJ 9151 2 21 aims aim NNS 9151 2 22 . . . 9151 3 1 The the DT 9151 3 2 first first JJ 9151 3 3 might may MD 9151 3 4 be be VB 9151 3 5 thought think VBN 9151 3 6 of of IN 9151 3 7 as as IN 9151 3 8 an an DT 9151 3 9 altruistic altruistic JJ 9151 3 10 goal goal NN 9151 3 11 : : : 9151 3 12 understanding understand VBG 9151 3 13 the the DT 9151 3 14 needs need NNS 9151 3 15 of of IN 9151 3 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 9151 3 17 particular particular JJ 9151 3 18 clientele clientele NNS 9151 3 19 and and CC 9151 3 20 improving improve VBG 9151 3 21 library library NN 9151 3 22 services service NNS 9151 3 23 to to TO 9151 3 24 meet meet VB 9151 3 25 those those DT 9151 3 26 needs need NNS 9151 3 27 . . . 9151 4 1 The the DT 9151 4 2 second second JJ 9151 4 3 is be VBZ 9151 4 4 perhaps perhaps RB 9151 4 5 more more RBR 9151 4 6 existential existential JJ 9151 4 7 : : : 9151 4 8 helping help VBG 9151 4 9 justify justify VB 9151 4 10 the the DT 9151 4 11 value value NN 9151 4 12 libraries library NNS 9151 4 13 create create VBP 9151 4 14 to to IN 9151 4 15 whatever whatever WDT 9151 4 16 sources source NNS 9151 4 17 of of IN 9151 4 18 funding funding NN 9151 4 19 are be VBP 9151 4 20 necessary necessary JJ 9151 4 21 to to TO 9151 4 22 impress impress VB 9151 4 23 . . . 9151 5 1 Both both DT 9151 5 2 are be VBP 9151 5 3 valid valid JJ 9151 5 4 and and CC 9151 5 5 important important JJ 9151 5 6 . . . 9151 6 1 It -PRON- PRP 9151 6 2 is be VBZ 9151 6 3 hard hard JJ 9151 6 4 to to TO 9151 6 5 argue argue VB 9151 6 6 that that IN 9151 6 7 improving improve VBG 9151 6 8 services service NNS 9151 6 9 , , , 9151 6 10 focusing focus VBG 9151 6 11 on on IN 9151 6 12 actual actual JJ 9151 6 13 needs need NNS 9151 6 14 , , , 9151 6 15 and and CC 9151 6 16 maintaining maintain VBG 9151 6 17 funding funding NN 9151 6 18 are be VBP 9151 6 19 in in IN 9151 6 20 any any DT 9151 6 21 way way NN 9151 6 22 improper improper JJ 9151 6 23 goals goal NNS 9151 6 24 . . . 9151 7 1 However however RB 9151 7 2 , , , 9151 7 3 this this DT 9151 7 4 desire desire NN 9151 7 5 is be VBZ 9151 7 6 often often RB 9151 7 7 seen see VBN 9151 7 8 as as IN 9151 7 9 being be VBG 9151 7 10 in in IN 9151 7 11 conflict conflict NN 9151 7 12 with with IN 9151 7 13 exploring explore VBG 9151 7 14 too too RB 9151 7 15 deeply deeply RB 9151 7 16 the the DT 9151 7 17 actions action NNS 9151 7 18 or or CC 9151 7 19 needs need NNS 9151 7 20 of of IN 9151 7 21 individual individual JJ 9151 7 22 constituents constituent NNS 9151 7 23 , , , 9151 7 24 despite despite IN 9151 7 25 librarians librarian NNS 9151 7 26 ’ ' '' 9151 7 27 historical historical JJ 9151 7 28 and and CC 9151 7 29 deeply deeply RB 9151 7 30 - - HYPH 9151 7 31 held hold VBN 9151 7 32 belief belief NN 9151 7 33 that that IN 9151 7 34 each each DT 9151 7 35 constituent constituent NN 9151 7 36 ’s ’s POS 9151 7 37 precise precise JJ 9151 7 38 information information NN 9151 7 39 needs need NNS 9151 7 40 should should MD 9151 7 41 be be VB 9151 7 42 explored explore VBN 9151 7 43 and and CC 9151 7 44 provided provide VBN 9151 7 45 for for IN 9151 7 46 through through IN 9151 7 47 personalized personalize VBN 9151 7 48 , , , 9151 7 49 tailored tailored JJ 9151 7 50 services service NNS 9151 7 51 . . . 9151 8 1 Solid solid JJ 9151 8 2 assessment assessment NN 9151 8 3 can can MD 9151 8 4 not not RB 9151 8 5 happen happen VB 9151 8 6 without without IN 9151 8 7 solid solid JJ 9151 8 8 data datum NNS 9151 8 9 . . . 9151 9 1 Libraries library NNS 9151 9 2 have have VBP 9151 9 3 historically historically RB 9151 9 4 relied rely VBN 9151 9 5 on on IN 9151 9 6 qualitative qualitative JJ 9151 9 7 surveys survey NNS 9151 9 8 of of IN 9151 9 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 9151 9 10 users user NNS 9151 9 11 , , , 9151 9 12 asking ask VBG 9151 9 13 users user NNS 9151 9 14 to to TO 9151 9 15 evaluate evaluate VB 9151 9 16 the the DT 9151 9 17 quality quality NN 9151 9 18 of of IN 9151 9 19 the the DT 9151 9 20 services service NNS 9151 9 21 they -PRON- PRP 9151 9 22 receive receive VBP 9151 9 23 . . . 9151 10 1 Being be VBG 9151 10 2 able able JJ 9151 10 3 to to TO 9151 10 4 know know VB 9151 10 5 more more JJR 9151 10 6 details detail NNS 9151 10 7 and and CC 9151 10 8 ask ask VB 9151 10 9 directed directed JJ 9151 10 10 questions question NNS 9151 10 11 of of IN 9151 10 12 individuals individual NNS 9151 10 13 who who WP 9151 10 14 used use VBD 9151 10 15 services service NNS 9151 10 16 is be VBZ 9151 10 17 possible possible JJ 9151 10 18 in in IN 9151 10 19 the the DT 9151 10 20 traditional traditional JJ 9151 10 21 library library NN 9151 10 22 setting set VBG 9151 10 23 through through IN 9151 10 24 invitations invitation NNS 9151 10 25 to to TO 9151 10 26 complete complete VB 9151 10 27 surveys survey NNS 9151 10 28 after after IN 9151 10 29 individual individual JJ 9151 10 30 interactions interaction NNS 9151 10 31 such such JJ 9151 10 32 as as IN 9151 10 33 a a DT 9151 10 34 reference reference NN 9151 10 35 or or CC 9151 10 36 circulation circulation NN 9151 10 37 desk desk NN 9151 10 38 interaction interaction NN 9151 10 39 , , , 9151 10 40 library library NN 9151 10 41 program program NN 9151 10 42 , , , 9151 10 43 visit visit VB 9151 10 44 to to IN 9151 10 45 a a DT 9151 10 46 physical physical JJ 9151 10 47 location location NN 9151 10 48 , , , 9151 10 49 or or CC 9151 10 50 even even RB 9151 10 51 a a DT 9151 10 52 community community NN 9151 10 53 - - HYPH 9151 10 54 wide wide JJ 9151 10 55 survey survey NN 9151 10 56 invitation invitation NN 9151 10 57 . . . 9151 11 1 Focus focus JJ 9151 11 2 groups group NNS 9151 11 3 can can MD 9151 11 4 be be VB 9151 11 5 assembled assemble VBN 9151 11 6 as as RB 9151 11 7 well well RB 9151 11 8 , , , 9151 11 9 of of IN 9151 11 10 course course NN 9151 11 11 , , , 9151 11 12 once once RB 9151 11 13 a a DT 9151 11 14 library library NN 9151 11 15 has have VBZ 9151 11 16 identified identify VBN 9151 11 17 a a DT 9151 11 18 real real JJ 9151 11 19 - - HYPH 9151 11 20 world world NN 9151 11 21 group group NN 9151 11 22 to to TO 9151 11 23 study study VB 9151 11 24 . . . 9151 12 1 However however RB 9151 12 2 , , , 9151 12 3 those those DT 9151 12 4 samples sample NNS 9151 12 5 are be VBP 9151 12 6 more more RBR 9151 12 7 often often RB 9151 12 8 convenience convenience NN 9151 12 9 samples sample NNS 9151 12 10 or or CC 9151 12 11 — — : 9151 12 12 unless unless IN 9151 12 13 a a DT 9151 12 14 library library NN 9151 12 15 is be VBZ 9151 12 16 able able JJ 9151 12 17 to to TO 9151 12 18 successfully successfully RB 9151 12 19 contact contact VB 9151 12 20 and and CC 9151 12 21 receive receive VB 9151 12 22 responses response NNS 9151 12 23 from from IN 9151 12 24 across across IN 9151 12 25 the the DT 9151 12 26 entire entire JJ 9151 12 27 community community NN 9151 12 28 — — : 9151 12 29 somewhat somewhat RB 9151 12 30 self self NN 9151 12 31 - - HYPH 9151 12 32 selected select VBN 9151 12 33 . . . 9151 13 1 Assessment assessment NN 9151 13 2 that that WDT 9151 13 3 leads lead VBZ 9151 13 4 to to IN 9151 13 5 new new JJ 9151 13 6 or or CC 9151 13 7 improved improved JJ 9151 13 8 services service NNS 9151 13 9 relies rely VBZ 9151 13 10 much much RB 9151 13 11 more more RBR 9151 13 12 heavily heavily RB 9151 13 13 on on IN 9151 13 14 broad broad RB 9151 13 15 - - HYPH 9151 13 16 based base VBN 9151 13 17 understanding understanding NN 9151 13 18 of of IN 9151 13 19 the the DT 9151 13 20 users user NNS 9151 13 21 of of IN 9151 13 22 a a DT 9151 13 23 system system NN 9151 13 24 . . . 9151 14 1 Libraries library NNS 9151 14 2 have have VBP 9151 14 3 been be VBN 9151 14 4 able able JJ 9151 14 5 to to TO 9151 14 6 do do VB 9151 14 7 limited limited JJ 9151 14 8 quantitative quantitative JJ 9151 14 9 studies study NNS 9151 14 10 of of IN 9151 14 11 library library JJ 9151 14 12 usage usage NN 9151 14 13 — — : 9151 14 14 at at IN 9151 14 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 9151 14 16 simplest simple JJS 9151 14 17 , , , 9151 14 18 counting count VBG 9151 14 19 how how WRB 9151 14 20 many many JJ 9151 14 21 of of IN 9151 14 22 this this DT 9151 14 23 were be VBD 9151 14 24 checked check VBN 9151 14 25 out out RP 9151 14 26 , , , 9151 14 27 how how WRB 9151 14 28 many many JJ 9151 14 29 of of IN 9151 14 30 that that DT 9151 14 31 was be VBD 9151 14 32 accessed access VBN 9151 14 33 , , , 9151 14 34 and and CC 9151 14 35 how how WRB 9151 14 36 many many JJ 9151 14 37 users user NNS 9151 14 38 were be VBD 9151 14 39 involved involve VBN 9151 14 40 . . . 9151 15 1 These these DT 9151 15 2 metrics metric NNS 9151 15 3 are be VBP 9151 15 4 useful useful JJ 9151 15 5 , , , 9151 15 6 but but CC 9151 15 7 also also RB 9151 15 8 limited limited JJ 9151 15 9 , , , 9151 15 10 particularly particularly RB 9151 15 11 at at IN 9151 15 12 the the DT 9151 15 13 scale scale NN 9151 15 14 of of IN 9151 15 15 a a DT 9151 15 16 single single JJ 9151 15 17 library library NN 9151 15 18 . . . 9151 16 1 Knowing know VBG 9151 16 2 that that IN 9151 16 3 a a DT 9151 16 4 pool pool NN 9151 16 5 of of IN 9151 16 6 resources resource NNS 9151 16 7 is be VBZ 9151 16 8 heavily heavily RB 9151 16 9 used use VBN 9151 16 10 is be VBZ 9151 16 11 helpful helpful JJ 9151 16 12 ; ; : 9151 16 13 even even RB 9151 16 14 knowing know VBG 9151 16 15 that that IN 9151 16 16 a a DT 9151 16 17 suite suite NN 9151 16 18 of of IN 9151 16 19 resources resource NNS 9151 16 20 is be VBZ 9151 16 21 frequently frequently RB 9151 16 22 used use VBN 9151 16 23 collectively collectively RB 9151 16 24 is be VBZ 9151 16 25 beneficial beneficial JJ 9151 16 26 . . . 9151 17 1 However however RB 9151 17 2 , , , 9151 17 3 tying tie VBG 9151 17 4 use use NN 9151 17 5 of of IN 9151 17 6 resources resource NNS 9151 17 7 to to IN 9151 17 8 specific specific JJ 9151 17 9 information information NN 9151 17 10 needs need NNS 9151 17 11 or or CC 9151 17 12 information information NN 9151 17 13 seekers seeker NNS 9151 17 14 , , , 9151 17 15 whether whether IN 9151 17 16 this this DT 9151 17 17 is be VBZ 9151 17 18 defined define VBN 9151 17 19 as as IN 9151 17 20 Ken Ken NNP 9151 17 21 Varnum Varnum NNP 9151 17 22 ( ( -LRB- 9151 17 23 varnum@umich.edu varnum@umich.edu NNP 9151 17 24 ) ) -RRB- 9151 17 25 , , , 9151 17 26 a a DT 9151 17 27 member member NN 9151 17 28 of of IN 9151 17 29 the the DT 9151 17 30 ITAL ITAL NNP 9151 17 31 Editorial Editorial NNP 9151 17 32 Board Board NNP 9151 17 33 , , , 9151 17 34 is be VBZ 9151 17 35 Senior Senior NNP 9151 17 36 Program Program NNP 9151 17 37 Manager Manager NNP 9151 17 38 for for IN 9151 17 39 Discovery Discovery NNP 9151 17 40 , , , 9151 17 41 Delivery Delivery NNP 9151 17 42 , , , 9151 17 43 and and CC 9151 17 44 Learning Learning NNP 9151 17 45 Analytics Analytics NNP 9151 17 46 at at IN 9151 17 47 the the DT 9151 17 48 University University NNP 9151 17 49 of of IN 9151 17 50 Michigan Michigan NNP 9151 17 51 Library Library NNP 9151 17 52 , , , 9151 17 53 Ann Ann NNP 9151 17 54 Arbor Arbor NNP 9151 17 55 , , , 9151 17 56 Michigan Michigan NNP 9151 17 57 . . . 9151 18 1 mailto:varnum@umich.edu mailto:varnum@umich.edu NNP 9151 18 2 EDITORIAL EDITORIAL NNP 9151 18 3 BOARD BOARD NNP 9151 18 4 THOUGHTS THOUGHTS NNP 9151 18 5 : : : 9151 18 6 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9151 18 7 ANALYTICS ANALYTICS NNP 9151 18 8 AND and CC 9151 18 9 PATRON PATRON NNP 9151 18 10 PRIVACY PRIVACY NNP 9151 18 11 | | NNP 9151 18 12 VARNUM VARNUM NNP 9151 18 13 doi doi NN 9151 18 14 : : : 9151 18 15 10.6017 10.6017 CD 9151 18 16 / / SYM 9151 18 17 ital.v34i4.9151 ital.v34i4.9151 CD 9151 18 18 3 3 CD 9151 18 19 individuals individual NNS 9151 18 20 or or CC 9151 18 21 ad ad FW 9151 18 22 hoc hoc FW 9151 18 23 collections collection NNS 9151 18 24 of of IN 9151 18 25 users user NNS 9151 18 26 based base VBN 9151 18 27 on on IN 9151 18 28 situational situational JJ 9151 18 29 factors factor NNS 9151 18 30 such such JJ 9151 18 31 as as IN 9151 18 32 academic academic JJ 9151 18 33 level level NN 9151 18 34 , , , 9151 18 35 course course NN 9151 18 36 enrollments enrollment NNS 9151 18 37 , , , 9151 18 38 etc etc FW 9151 18 39 . . . 9151 19 1 These these DT 9151 19 2 more more RBR 9151 19 3 specific specific JJ 9151 19 4 grouping grouping NN 9151 19 5 rely rely NN 9151 19 6 on on IN 9151 19 7 granular granular JJ 9151 19 8 data datum NNS 9151 19 9 that that WDT 9151 19 10 for for IN 9151 19 11 many many JJ 9151 19 12 libraries library NNS 9151 19 13 — — : 9151 19 14 especially especially RB 9151 19 15 academic academic JJ 9151 19 16 ones one NNS 9151 19 17 — — : 9151 19 18 are be VBP 9151 19 19 increasingly increasingly RB 9151 19 20 electronic electronic JJ 9151 19 21 . . . 9151 20 1 We -PRON- PRP 9151 20 2 are be VBP 9151 20 3 at at IN 9151 20 4 a a DT 9151 20 5 point point NN 9151 20 6 in in IN 9151 20 7 time time NN 9151 20 8 when when WRB 9151 20 9 we -PRON- PRP 9151 20 10 have have VBP 9151 20 11 the the DT 9151 20 12 potential potential NN 9151 20 13 to to TO 9151 20 14 leverage leverage VB 9151 20 15 wide wide JJ 9151 20 16 swathes swathe NNS 9151 20 17 of of IN 9151 20 18 user user NN 9151 20 19 data datum NNS 9151 20 20 . . . 9151 21 1 And and CC 9151 21 2 this this DT 9151 21 3 is be VBZ 9151 21 4 where where WRB 9151 21 5 the the DT 9151 21 6 second second JJ 9151 21 7 trend trend NN 9151 21 8 , , , 9151 21 9 privacy privacy NN 9151 21 10 , , , 9151 21 11 comes come VBZ 9151 21 12 to to TO 9151 21 13 bear bear VB 9151 21 14 . . . 9151 22 1 Protecting protect VBG 9151 22 2 user user NN 9151 22 3 privacy privacy NN 9151 22 4 has have VBZ 9151 22 5 been be VBN 9151 22 6 a a DT 9151 22 7 guiding guide VBG 9151 22 8 principle principle NN 9151 22 9 of of IN 9151 22 10 librarianship librarianship NN 9151 22 11 in in IN 9151 22 12 the the DT 9151 22 13 United United NNP 9151 22 14 States States NNP 9151 22 15 ( ( -LRB- 9151 22 16 in in IN 9151 22 17 particular particular JJ 9151 22 18 ) ) -RRB- 9151 22 19 since since IN 9151 22 20 the the DT 9151 22 21 1970s 1970 NNS 9151 22 22 , , , 9151 22 23 as as IN 9151 22 24 a a DT 9151 22 25 strong strong JJ 9151 22 26 reaction reaction NN 9151 22 27 to to IN 9151 22 28 U.S. U.S. NNP 9151 22 29 government government NN 9151 22 30 ( ( -LRB- 9151 22 31 through through IN 9151 22 32 the the DT 9151 22 33 FBI FBI NNP 9151 22 34 ) ) -RRB- 9151 22 35 requests request VBZ 9151 22 36 to to TO 9151 22 37 provide provide VB 9151 22 38 access access NN 9151 22 39 to to IN 9151 22 40 circulation circulation NN 9151 22 41 logs log NNS 9151 22 42 for for IN 9151 22 43 individuals individual NNS 9151 22 44 under under IN 9151 22 45 suspicion suspicion NN 9151 22 46 of of IN 9151 22 47 espionage espionage NN 9151 22 48 . . . 9151 23 1 This this DT 9151 23 2 was be VBD 9151 23 3 in in IN 9151 23 4 the the DT 9151 23 5 early early JJ 9151 23 6 days day NNS 9151 23 7 of of IN 9151 23 8 library library JJ 9151 23 9 automation automation NN 9151 23 10 , , , 9151 23 11 when when WRB 9151 23 12 large large JJ 9151 23 13 libraries library NNS 9151 23 14 with with IN 9151 23 15 automated automate VBN 9151 23 16 ILS ILS NNP 9151 23 17 systems system NNS 9151 23 18 could could MD 9151 23 19 prevent prevent VB 9151 23 20 future future JJ 9151 23 21 disclosure disclosure NN 9151 23 22 through through IN 9151 23 23 the the DT 9151 23 24 straightforward straightforward JJ 9151 23 25 strategy strategy NN 9151 23 26 of of IN 9151 23 27 purging purge VBG 9151 23 28 transaction transaction NN 9151 23 29 records record NNS 9151 23 30 as as RB 9151 23 31 soon soon RB 9151 23 32 as as IN 9151 23 33 the the DT 9151 23 34 item item NN 9151 23 35 was be VBD 9151 23 36 returned return VBN 9151 23 37 . . . 9151 24 1 This this DT 9151 24 2 practice practice NN 9151 24 3 became become VBD 9151 24 4 standard standard JJ 9151 24 5 operating operate VBG 9151 24 6 procedure procedure NN 9151 24 7 in in IN 9151 24 8 libraries library NNS 9151 24 9 , , , 9151 24 10 and and CC 9151 24 11 expanded expand VBN 9151 24 12 into into IN 9151 24 13 new new JJ 9151 24 14 information information NN 9151 24 15 service service NN 9151 24 16 domains domain NNS 9151 24 17 as as IN 9151 24 18 they -PRON- PRP 9151 24 19 evolved evolve VBD 9151 24 20 over over IN 9151 24 21 the the DT 9151 24 22 following follow VBG 9151 24 23 forty forty CD 9151 24 24 years year NNS 9151 24 25 . . . 9151 25 1 With with IN 9151 25 2 good good JJ 9151 25 3 intentions intention NNS 9151 25 4 , , , 9151 25 5 libraries library NNS 9151 25 6 have have VBP 9151 25 7 ensured ensure VBN 9151 25 8 that that IN 9151 25 9 they -PRON- PRP 9151 25 10 maintain maintain VBP 9151 25 11 no no DT 9151 25 12 long long JJ 9151 25 13 - - HYPH 9151 25 14 term term NN 9151 25 15 history history NN 9151 25 16 for for IN 9151 25 17 most most JJS 9151 25 18 online online JJ 9151 25 19 services service NNS 9151 25 20 . . . 9151 26 1 As as IN 9151 26 2 a a DT 9151 26 3 profession profession NN 9151 26 4 , , , 9151 26 5 we -PRON- PRP 9151 26 6 have have VBP 9151 26 7 begun begin VBN 9151 26 8 to to TO 9151 26 9 realize realize VB 9151 26 10 that that IN 9151 26 11 the the DT 9151 26 12 straightforward straightforward NN 9151 26 13 ( ( -LRB- 9151 26 14 and and CC 9151 26 15 arguably arguably RB 9151 26 16 simplistic simplistic JJ 9151 26 17 ) ) -RRB- 9151 26 18 approaches approach NNS 9151 26 19 we -PRON- PRP 9151 26 20 have have VBP 9151 26 21 relied rely VBN 9151 26 22 on on RP 9151 26 23 for for IN 9151 26 24 so so RB 9151 26 25 long long RB 9151 26 26 may may MD 9151 26 27 no no RB 9151 26 28 longer longer RB 9151 26 29 be be VB 9151 26 30 appropriate appropriate JJ 9151 26 31 or or CC 9151 26 32 helpful helpful JJ 9151 26 33 . . . 9151 27 1 Over over IN 9151 27 2 the the DT 9151 27 3 past past JJ 9151 27 4 year year NN 9151 27 5 , , , 9151 27 6 these these DT 9151 27 7 conversations conversation NNS 9151 27 8 found find VBD 9151 27 9 focus focus NN 9151 27 10 through through IN 9151 27 11 a a DT 9151 27 12 project project NN 9151 27 13 coordinated coordinate VBN 9151 27 14 by by IN 9151 27 15 the the DT 9151 27 16 National National NNP 9151 27 17 Information Information NNP 9151 27 18 Standards Standards NNP 9151 27 19 Organization Organization NNP 9151 27 20 thanks thank NNS 9151 27 21 to to IN 9151 27 22 a a DT 9151 27 23 grant grant NN 9151 27 24 from from IN 9151 27 25 the the DT 9151 27 26 Andrew Andrew NNP 9151 27 27 W. W. NNP 9151 27 28 Mellon Mellon NNP 9151 27 29 Foundation.1 Foundation.1 NNP 9151 27 30 The the DT 9151 27 31 range range NN 9151 27 32 of of IN 9151 27 33 issues issue NNS 9151 27 34 discussed discuss VBN 9151 27 35 here here RB 9151 27 36 was be VBD 9151 27 37 far far RB 9151 27 38 - - HYPH 9151 27 39 reaching reach VBG 9151 27 40 and and CC 9151 27 41 touched touch VBN 9151 27 42 on on IN 9151 27 43 virtually virtually RB 9151 27 44 every every DT 9151 27 45 aspect aspect NN 9151 27 46 of of IN 9151 27 47 privacy privacy NN 9151 27 48 and and CC 9151 27 49 assessment assessment NN 9151 27 50 imaginable imaginable NN 9151 27 51 . . . 9151 28 1 The the DT 9151 28 2 resulting result VBG 9151 28 3 draft draft NN 9151 28 4 document document NN 9151 28 5 , , , 9151 28 6 Consensus Consensus NNP 9151 28 7 Framework Framework NNP 9151 28 8 to to TO 9151 28 9 Support support VB 9151 28 10 Patron Patron NNP 9151 28 11 Privacy Privacy NNP 9151 28 12 in in IN 9151 28 13 Digital Digital NNP 9151 28 14 Library Library NNP 9151 28 15 and and CC 9151 28 16 Information Information NNP 9151 28 17 Systems,2 Systems,2 NNP 9151 28 18 outlines outline VBZ 9151 28 19 12 12 CD 9151 28 20 principles principle NNS 9151 28 21 that that WDT 9151 28 22 libraries librarie VBZ 9151 28 23 ( ( -LRB- 9151 28 24 and and CC 9151 28 25 the the DT 9151 28 26 information information NN 9151 28 27 service service NN 9151 28 28 vendors vendor NNS 9151 28 29 they -PRON- PRP 9151 28 30 partner partner VBP 9151 28 31 with with IN 9151 28 32 ) ) -RRB- 9151 28 33 should should MD 9151 28 34 follow follow VB 9151 28 35 as as IN 9151 28 36 they -PRON- PRP 9151 28 37 establish establish VBP 9151 28 38 “ " `` 9151 28 39 practices practice NNS 9151 28 40 and and CC 9151 28 41 procedures procedure NNS 9151 28 42 to to TO 9151 28 43 protect protect VB 9151 28 44 the the DT 9151 28 45 digital digital JJ 9151 28 46 privacy privacy NN 9151 28 47 of of IN 9151 28 48 the the DT 9151 28 49 library library NN 9151 28 50 user user NN 9151 28 51 . . . 9151 28 52 ” " '' 9151 28 53 This this DT 9151 28 54 new new JJ 9151 28 55 consensus consensus NN 9151 28 56 framework framework NN 9151 28 57 sets set VBZ 9151 28 58 a a DT 9151 28 59 series series NN 9151 28 60 of of IN 9151 28 61 guidelines guideline NNS 9151 28 62 for for IN 9151 28 63 us -PRON- PRP 9151 28 64 to to TO 9151 28 65 consider consider VB 9151 28 66 as as IN 9151 28 67 we -PRON- PRP 9151 28 68 begin begin VBP 9151 28 69 to to TO 9151 28 70 move move VB 9151 28 71 into into IN 9151 28 72 this this DT 9151 28 73 uncharted uncharted JJ 9151 28 74 ( ( -LRB- 9151 28 75 for for IN 9151 28 76 libraries library NNS 9151 28 77 ) ) -RRB- 9151 28 78 territory territory NN 9151 28 79 . . . 9151 29 1 If if IN 9151 29 2 we -PRON- PRP 9151 29 3 are be VBP 9151 29 4 to to TO 9151 29 5 record record VB 9151 29 6 and and CC 9151 29 7 make make VB 9151 29 8 use use NN 9151 29 9 of of IN 9151 29 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 29 11 users user NNS 9151 29 12 ’ ' '' 9151 29 13 online online RB 9151 29 14 ( ( -LRB- 9151 29 15 and and CC 9151 29 16 offline offline NNP 9151 29 17 , , , 9151 29 18 for for IN 9151 29 19 that that DT 9151 29 20 matter matter NN 9151 29 21 ) ) -RRB- 9151 29 22 footprints footprint VBZ 9151 29 23 to to TO 9151 29 24 improve improve VB 9151 29 25 services service NNS 9151 29 26 , , , 9151 29 27 improve improve VB 9151 29 28 the the DT 9151 29 29 user user NN 9151 29 30 experience experience NN 9151 29 31 , , , 9151 29 32 and and CC 9151 29 33 justify justify VB 9151 29 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 29 35 value value NN 9151 29 36 , , , 9151 29 37 this this DT 9151 29 38 document document NN 9151 29 39 gives give VBZ 9151 29 40 us -PRON- PRP 9151 29 41 an an DT 9151 29 42 outline outline NN 9151 29 43 of of IN 9151 29 44 the the DT 9151 29 45 issues issue NNS 9151 29 46 to to TO 9151 29 47 consider consider VB 9151 29 48 . . . 9151 30 1 It -PRON- PRP 9151 30 2 is be VBZ 9151 30 3 time time NN 9151 30 4 ( ( -LRB- 9151 30 5 and and CC 9151 30 6 probably probably RB 9151 30 7 long long RB 9151 30 8 past past JJ 9151 30 9 time time NN 9151 30 10 ) ) -RRB- 9151 30 11 that that WDT 9151 30 12 we -PRON- PRP 9151 30 13 make make VBP 9151 30 14 conscious conscious JJ 9151 30 15 decisions decision NNS 9151 30 16 about about IN 9151 30 17 how how WRB 9151 30 18 we -PRON- PRP 9151 30 19 assess assess VBP 9151 30 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 30 21 online online JJ 9151 30 22 resources resource NNS 9151 30 23 , , , 9151 30 24 in in IN 9151 30 25 particular particular JJ 9151 30 26 , , , 9151 30 27 and and CC 9151 30 28 do do VB 9151 30 29 so so RB 9151 30 30 with with IN 9151 30 31 a a DT 9151 30 32 deeper deep JJR 9151 30 33 knowledge knowledge NN 9151 30 34 of of IN 9151 30 35 both both PDT 9151 30 36 the the DT 9151 30 37 resources resource NNS 9151 30 38 used use VBN 9151 30 39 and and CC 9151 30 40 the the DT 9151 30 41 people people NNS 9151 30 42 using use VBG 9151 30 43 them -PRON- PRP 9151 30 44 . . . 9151 31 1 At at IN 9151 31 2 the the DT 9151 31 3 exact exact JJ 9151 31 4 moment moment NN 9151 31 5 in in IN 9151 31 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 31 7 technological technological JJ 9151 31 8 history history NN 9151 31 9 when when WRB 9151 31 10 we -PRON- PRP 9151 31 11 find find VBP 9151 31 12 ourselves -PRON- PRP 9151 31 13 able able JJ 9151 31 14 to to TO 9151 31 15 provide provide VB 9151 31 16 automated automate VBN 9151 31 17 services service NNS 9151 31 18 at at IN 9151 31 19 scale scale NN 9151 31 20 to to IN 9151 31 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 31 22 users user NNS 9151 31 23 through through IN 9151 31 24 the the DT 9151 31 25 Internet internet NN 9151 31 26 and and CC 9151 31 27 simultaneously simultaneously RB 9151 31 28 record record VB 9151 31 29 and and CC 9151 31 30 analyze analyze VB 9151 31 31 the the DT 9151 31 32 intricate intricate JJ 9151 31 33 details detail NNS 9151 31 34 of of IN 9151 31 35 those those DT 9151 31 36 transactions transaction NNS 9151 31 37 , , , 9151 31 38 we -PRON- PRP 9151 31 39 need need VBP 9151 31 40 to to TO 9151 31 41 come come VB 9151 31 42 to to TO 9151 31 43 think think VB 9151 31 44 clearly clearly RB 9151 31 45 about about IN 9151 31 46 what what WP 9151 31 47 questions question NNS 9151 31 48 we -PRON- PRP 9151 31 49 have have VBP 9151 31 50 , , , 9151 31 51 what what WDT 9151 31 52 data datum NNS 9151 31 53 we -PRON- PRP 9151 31 54 need need VBP 9151 31 55 to to TO 9151 31 56 answer answer VB 9151 31 57 them -PRON- PRP 9151 31 58 , , , 9151 31 59 and and CC 9151 31 60 be be VB 9151 31 61 explicit explicit JJ 9151 31 62 about about IN 9151 31 63 how how WRB 9151 31 64 those those DT 9151 31 65 data datum NNS 9151 31 66 points point NNS 9151 31 67 are be VBP 9151 31 68 treated treat VBN 9151 31 69 . . . 9151 32 1 It -PRON- PRP 9151 32 2 is be VBZ 9151 32 3 important important JJ 9151 32 4 that that IN 9151 32 5 we -PRON- PRP 9151 32 6 start start VBP 9151 32 7 this this DT 9151 32 8 process process NN 9151 32 9 now now RB 9151 32 10 and and CC 9151 32 11 change change VB 9151 32 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 32 13 blunt blunt JJ 9151 32 14 practices practice NNS 9151 32 15 into into IN 9151 32 16 more more JJR 9151 32 17 strategic strategic JJ 9151 32 18 data datum NNS 9151 32 19 collection collection NN 9151 32 20 and and CC 9151 32 21 analysis analysis NN 9151 32 22 . . . 9151 33 1 Where where WRB 9151 33 2 40 40 CD 9151 33 3 years year NNS 9151 33 4 ago ago RB 9151 33 5 we -PRON- PRP 9151 33 6 opted opt VBD 9151 33 7 to to IN 9151 33 8 INFORMATION information NN 9151 33 9 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 9151 33 10 AND and CC 9151 33 11 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 9151 33 12 | | NNP 9151 33 13 DECEMBER DECEMBER NNP 9151 33 14 2015 2015 CD 9151 33 15 4 4 CD 9151 33 16 bluntly bluntly RB 9151 33 17 enforce enforce VB 9151 33 18 user user NN 9151 33 19 privacy privacy NN 9151 33 20 by by IN 9151 33 21 deleting delete VBG 9151 33 22 the the DT 9151 33 23 data datum NNS 9151 33 24 , , , 9151 33 25 we -PRON- PRP 9151 33 26 should should MD 9151 33 27 now now RB 9151 33 28 take take VB 9151 33 29 a a DT 9151 33 30 more more RBR 9151 33 31 nuanced nuanced JJ 9151 33 32 approach approach NN 9151 33 33 and and CC 9151 33 34 store store NN 9151 33 35 and and CC 9151 33 36 analyze analyze VB 9151 33 37 data datum NNS 9151 33 38 in in IN 9151 33 39 the the DT 9151 33 40 service service NN 9151 33 41 of of IN 9151 33 42 improved improve VBN 9151 33 43 services service NNS 9151 33 44 and and CC 9151 33 45 tools tool NNS 9151 33 46 for for IN 9151 33 47 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 33 48 user user NN 9151 33 49 communities community NNS 9151 33 50 . . . 9151 34 1 We -PRON- PRP 9151 34 2 have have VBP 9151 34 3 the the DT 9151 34 4 opportunity opportunity NN 9151 34 5 , , , 9151 34 6 through through IN 9151 34 7 technology technology NN 9151 34 8 and and CC 9151 34 9 a a DT 9151 34 10 more more RBR 9151 34 11 nuanced nuanced JJ 9151 34 12 understanding understanding NN 9151 34 13 of of IN 9151 34 14 privacy privacy NN 9151 34 15 , , , 9151 34 16 to to TO 9151 34 17 conduct conduct VB 9151 34 18 a a DT 9151 34 19 protracted protract VBN 9151 34 20 reference reference NN 9151 34 21 interview interview NN 9151 34 22 with with IN 9151 34 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 34 24 virtual virtual JJ 9151 34 25 users user NNS 9151 34 26 over over IN 9151 34 27 multiple multiple JJ 9151 34 28 interactions interaction NNS 9151 34 29 … … NFP 9151 34 30 and and CC 9151 34 31 thereby thereby RB 9151 34 32 improve improve VB 9151 34 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 9151 34 34 services service NNS 9151 34 35 . . . 9151 35 1 REFERENCES reference NNS 9151 35 2 1 1 CD 9151 35 3 . . . 9151 35 4 http://www.niso.org/topics/tl/patron_privacy/ http://www.niso.org/topics/tl/patron_privacy/ DT 9151 35 5 2 2 CD 9151 35 6 . . . 9151 35 7 http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/NISO%20Consensus http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/NISO%20Consensus NNP 9151 35 8 % % NN 9151 35 9 20Principles%20Users%20Digital%20Privacy.pdf 20principles%20users%20digital%20privacy.pdf CD 9151 35 10 http://www.niso.org/topics/tl/patron_privacy/ http://www.niso.org/topics/tl/patron_privacy/ NN 9151 35 11 http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/NISO%20Consensus%20Principles%20Users%20Digital%20Privacy.pdf http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/NISO%20Consensus%20Principles%20Users%20Digital%20Privacy.pdf NNP 9151 35 12 http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/NISO%20Consensus%20Principles%20Users%20Digital%20Privacy.pdf http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/NISO%20Consensus%20Principles%20Users%20Digital%20Privacy.pdf .