id sid tid token lemma pos 3344 1 1 Bailey Bailey NNP 3344 1 2 116 116 CD 3344 1 3 INFORMATION INFORMATION VBD 3344 1 4 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3344 1 5 AND and CC 3344 1 6 LIBRARIES library NNS 3344 1 7 | | CD 3344 1 8 SEPTEMBER september NN 3344 1 9 2006 2006 CD 3344 1 10 Three three CD 3344 1 11 critical critical JJ 3344 1 12 issues issue NNS 3344 1 13 — — : 3344 1 14 a a DT 3344 1 15 dramatic dramatic JJ 3344 1 16 expansion expansion NN 3344 1 17 of of IN 3344 1 18 the the DT 3344 1 19 scope scope NN 3344 1 20 , , , 3344 1 21 duration duration NN 3344 1 22 , , , 3344 1 23 and and CC 3344 1 24 punitive punitive JJ 3344 1 25 nature nature NN 3344 1 26 of of IN 3344 1 27 copyright copyright NN 3344 1 28 laws law NNS 3344 1 29 ; ; : 3344 1 30 the the DT 3344 1 31 abil- abil- JJ 3344 1 32 ity ity NN 3344 1 33 of of IN 3344 1 34 Digital Digital NNP 3344 1 35 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 1 36 Management Management NNP 3344 1 37 ( ( -LRB- 3344 1 38 DRM DRM NNP 3344 1 39 ) ) -RRB- 3344 1 40 systems system NNS 3344 1 41 to to TO 3344 1 42 lock lock VB 3344 1 43 - - HYPH 3344 1 44 down down RP 3344 1 45 digital digital JJ 3344 1 46 content content NN 3344 1 47 in in IN 3344 1 48 an an DT 3344 1 49 unprecedented unprecedented JJ 3344 1 50 fashion fashion NN 3344 1 51 ; ; : 3344 1 52 and and CC 3344 1 53 the the DT 3344 1 54 erosion erosion NN 3344 1 55 of of IN 3344 1 56 Net net JJ 3344 1 57 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 1 58 , , , 3344 1 59 which which WDT 3344 1 60 ensures ensure VBZ 3344 1 61 that that IN 3344 1 62 all all DT 3344 1 63 Internet internet NN 3344 1 64 traffic traffic NN 3344 1 65 is be VBZ 3344 1 66 treated treat VBN 3344 1 67 equally equally RB 3344 1 68 — — : 3344 1 69 are be VBP 3344 1 70 examined examine VBN 3344 1 71 in in IN 3344 1 72 detail detail NN 3344 1 73 and and CC 3344 1 74 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 1 75 potential potential JJ 3344 1 76 impact impact NN 3344 1 77 on on IN 3344 1 78 libraries library NNS 3344 1 79 is be VBZ 3344 1 80 assessed assess VBN 3344 1 81 . . . 3344 2 1 How how WRB 3344 2 2 legislatures legislature NNS 3344 2 3 , , , 3344 2 4 the the DT 3344 2 5 courts court NNS 3344 2 6 , , , 3344 2 7 and and CC 3344 2 8 the the DT 3344 2 9 commercial commercial JJ 3344 2 10 marketplace marketplace NN 3344 2 11 treat treat VBP 3344 2 12 these these DT 3344 2 13 issues issue NNS 3344 2 14 will will MD 3344 2 15 strongly strongly RB 3344 2 16 influence influence VB 3344 2 17 the the DT 3344 2 18 future future NN 3344 2 19 of of IN 3344 2 20 digital digital JJ 3344 2 21 information information NN 3344 2 22 for for IN 3344 2 23 good good JJ 3344 2 24 or or CC 3344 2 25 ill ill JJ 3344 2 26 . . . 3344 2 27 Editor Editor NNP 3344 2 28 's 's POS 3344 2 29 Note note NN 3344 2 30 : : : 3344 2 31 This this DT 3344 2 32 article article NN 3344 2 33 was be VBD 3344 2 34 submitted submit VBN 3344 2 35 in in IN 3344 2 36 honor honor NN 3344 2 37 of of IN 3344 2 38 the the DT 3344 2 39 fortieth fortieth JJ 3344 2 40 anniversaries anniversary NNS 3344 2 41 of of IN 3344 2 42 LITA LITA NNP 3344 2 43 and and CC 3344 2 44 ITAL ITAL NNP 3344 2 45 . . . 3344 3 1 B B NNP 3344 3 2 logs logs NNP 3344 3 3 . . . 3344 4 1 Digital digital JJ 3344 4 2 photo photo NN 3344 4 3 and and CC 3344 4 4 video video NN 3344 4 5 sharing sharing NN 3344 4 6 . . . 3344 5 1 Podcasts podcast NNS 3344 5 2 . . . 3344 6 1 Rip rip VB 3344 6 2 / / SYM 3344 6 3 Mix Mix NNP 3344 6 4 / / SYM 3344 6 5 Burn burn VB 3344 6 6 . . . 3344 7 1 Tagging tag VBG 3344 7 2 . . . 3344 8 1 Vlogs Vlogs NNP 3344 8 2 . . . 3344 9 1 Wikis wikis NN 3344 9 2 . . . 3344 10 1 These these DT 3344 10 2 buzz- buzz- JJ 3344 10 3 words word NNS 3344 10 4 point point VBP 3344 10 5 to to IN 3344 10 6 a a DT 3344 10 7 fundamental fundamental JJ 3344 10 8 social social JJ 3344 10 9 change change NN 3344 10 10 fueled fuel VBN 3344 10 11 by by IN 3344 10 12 cheap cheap JJ 3344 10 13 personal personal JJ 3344 10 14 computers computer NNS 3344 10 15 ( ( -LRB- 3344 10 16 PCs pc NNS 3344 10 17 ) ) -RRB- 3344 10 18 and and CC 3344 10 19 servers server NNS 3344 10 20 , , , 3344 10 21 the the DT 3344 10 22 Internet internet NN 3344 10 23 and and CC 3344 10 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 10 25 local local JJ 3344 10 26 wired wire VBN 3344 10 27 / / SYM 3344 10 28 wireless wireless NN 3344 10 29 feeder feeder NN 3344 10 30 networks network NNS 3344 10 31 , , , 3344 10 32 and and CC 3344 10 33 powerful powerful JJ 3344 10 34 , , , 3344 10 35 low low JJ 3344 10 36 - - HYPH 3344 10 37 cost cost NN 3344 10 38 software software NN 3344 10 39 . . . 3344 11 1 Citizens citizen NNS 3344 11 2 have have VBP 3344 11 3 morphed morph VBN 3344 11 4 from from IN 3344 11 5 passive passive JJ 3344 11 6 media medium NNS 3344 11 7 consumers consumer NNS 3344 11 8 to to IN 3344 11 9 digital digital JJ 3344 11 10 - - HYPH 3344 11 11 media medium NNS 3344 11 12 producers producer NNS 3344 11 13 and and CC 3344 11 14 publishers publisher NNS 3344 11 15 . . . 3344 12 1 Libraries library NNS 3344 12 2 and and CC 3344 12 3 scholars scholar NNS 3344 12 4 have have VBP 3344 12 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 12 6 own own JJ 3344 12 7 set set NN 3344 12 8 of of IN 3344 12 9 buzzwords buzzword NNS 3344 12 10 : : : 3344 12 11 digital digital JJ 3344 12 12 libraries library NNS 3344 12 13 , , , 3344 12 14 digital digital JJ 3344 12 15 presses press NNS 3344 12 16 , , , 3344 12 17 e e NN 3344 12 18 - - HYPH 3344 12 19 prints print NNS 3344 12 20 , , , 3344 12 21 institutional institutional JJ 3344 12 22 re- re- JJ 3344 12 23 positories positorie NNS 3344 12 24 , , , 3344 12 25 and and CC 3344 12 26 open open JJ 3344 12 27 - - HYPH 3344 12 28 access access NN 3344 12 29 ( ( -LRB- 3344 12 30 OA OA NNP 3344 12 31 ) ) -RRB- 3344 12 32 journals journal NNS 3344 12 33 , , , 3344 12 34 to to TO 3344 12 35 name name VB 3344 12 36 a a DT 3344 12 37 few few JJ 3344 12 38 . . . 3344 13 1 They -PRON- PRP 3344 13 2 connote connote VBP 3344 13 3 the the DT 3344 13 4 same same JJ 3344 13 5 kind kind NN 3344 13 6 of of IN 3344 13 7 change change NN 3344 13 8 : : : 3344 13 9 a a DT 3344 13 10 democratiza- democratiza- JJ 3344 13 11 tion tion NN 3344 13 12 of of IN 3344 13 13 publishing publishing NN 3344 13 14 and and CC 3344 13 15 media medium NNS 3344 13 16 production production NN 3344 13 17 using use VBG 3344 13 18 digital digital JJ 3344 13 19 technology technology NN 3344 13 20 . . . 3344 14 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 14 2 appears appear VBZ 3344 14 3 that that IN 3344 14 4 we -PRON- PRP 3344 14 5 are be VBP 3344 14 6 on on IN 3344 14 7 the the DT 3344 14 8 brink brink NN 3344 14 9 of of IN 3344 14 10 an an DT 3344 14 11 exciting exciting JJ 3344 14 12 new new JJ 3344 14 13 era era NN 3344 14 14 of of IN 3344 14 15 Internet internet NN 3344 14 16 innovation innovation NN 3344 14 17 : : : 3344 14 18 a a DT 3344 14 19 kind kind NN 3344 14 20 of of IN 3344 14 21 digital digital JJ 3344 14 22 utopia utopia NN 3344 14 23 . . . 3344 15 1 Gary Gary NNP 3344 15 2 Flake Flake NNP 3344 15 3 of of IN 3344 15 4 Microsoft Microsoft NNP 3344 15 5 has have VBZ 3344 15 6 provided provide VBN 3344 15 7 one one CD 3344 15 8 striking striking JJ 3344 15 9 vision vision NN 3344 15 10 of of IN 3344 15 11 what what WP 3344 15 12 could could MD 3344 15 13 be be VB 3344 15 14 ( ( -LRB- 3344 15 15 with with IN 3344 15 16 a a DT 3344 15 17 commercial commercial JJ 3344 15 18 twist twist NN 3344 15 19 ) ) -RRB- 3344 15 20 in in IN 3344 15 21 a a DT 3344 15 22 presentation presentation NN 3344 15 23 entitled entitle VBN 3344 15 24 “ " `` 3344 15 25 How how WRB 3344 15 26 I -PRON- PRP 3344 15 27 Learned learn VBD 3344 15 28 to to TO 3344 15 29 Stop stop VB 3344 15 30 Worrying Worrying NNP 3344 15 31 and and CC 3344 15 32 Love love VB 3344 15 33 the the DT 3344 15 34 Imminent imminent JJ 3344 15 35 Internet Internet NNP 3344 15 36 Singularity Singularity NNP 3344 15 37 , , , 3344 15 38 ” " '' 3344 15 39 and and CC 3344 15 40 there there EX 3344 15 41 are be VBP 3344 15 42 many many JJ 3344 15 43 other other JJ 3344 15 44 visions vision NNS 3344 15 45 of of IN 3344 15 46 possible possible JJ 3344 15 47 future future JJ 3344 15 48 Internet internet NN 3344 15 49 advances.1 advances.1 NN 3344 15 50 When when WRB 3344 15 51 did do VBD 3344 15 52 this this DT 3344 15 53 metamorphosis metamorphosis NN 3344 15 54 begin begin VB 3344 15 55 ? ? . 3344 16 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 16 2 depends depend VBZ 3344 16 3 on on IN 3344 16 4 who who WP 3344 16 5 you -PRON- PRP 3344 16 6 ask ask VBP 3344 16 7 . . . 3344 17 1 Let let VB 3344 17 2 ’s -PRON- PRP 3344 17 3 say say VB 3344 17 4 the the DT 3344 17 5 late late JJ 3344 17 6 1980s 1980 NNS 3344 17 7 , , , 3344 17 8 when when WRB 3344 17 9 the the DT 3344 17 10 Internet internet NN 3344 17 11 began begin VBD 3344 17 12 to to TO 3344 17 13 get get VB 3344 17 14 serious serious JJ 3344 17 15 traction traction NN 3344 17 16 and and CC 3344 17 17 an an DT 3344 17 18 early early JJ 3344 17 19 flowering flowering NN 3344 17 20 of of IN 3344 17 21 noncommercial noncommercial JJ 3344 17 22 digital digital JJ 3344 17 23 publishing publishing NN 3344 17 24 occurred occur VBD 3344 17 25 . . . 3344 18 1 In in IN 3344 18 2 the the DT 3344 18 3 subsequent subsequent JJ 3344 18 4 twenty twenty CD 3344 18 5 - - HYPH 3344 18 6 odd odd JJ 3344 18 7 years year NNS 3344 18 8 , , , 3344 18 9 publishing publishing NN 3344 18 10 and and CC 3344 18 11 media medium NNS 3344 18 12 production production NN 3344 18 13 went go VBD 3344 18 14 from from IN 3344 18 15 being be VBG 3344 18 16 highly highly RB 3344 18 17 centralized centralized JJ 3344 18 18 , , , 3344 18 19 capital capital NN 3344 18 20 - - HYPH 3344 18 21 intensive intensive JJ 3344 18 22 analog analog NN 3344 18 23 activities activity NNS 3344 18 24 with with IN 3344 18 25 limited limited JJ 3344 18 26 and and CC 3344 18 27 well- well- JJ 3344 18 28 defined define VBN 3344 18 29 distribution distribution NN 3344 18 30 channels channel NNS 3344 18 31 , , , 3344 18 32 to to IN 3344 18 33 being be VBG 3344 18 34 diffuse diffuse NN 3344 18 35 , , , 3344 18 36 relatively relatively RB 3344 18 37 low low JJ 3344 18 38 - - HYPH 3344 18 39 cost cost NN 3344 18 40 digital digital JJ 3344 18 41 activities activity NNS 3344 18 42 with with IN 3344 18 43 the the DT 3344 18 44 global global JJ 3344 18 45 Internet internet NN 3344 18 46 as as IN 3344 18 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 18 48 distribution distribution NN 3344 18 49 medium medium NN 3344 18 50 . . . 3344 19 1 Not not RB 3344 19 2 to to TO 3344 19 3 say say VB 3344 19 4 that that DT 3344 19 5 print print NN 3344 19 6 and and CC 3344 19 7 conven- conven- XX 3344 19 8 tional tional JJ 3344 19 9 media medium NNS 3344 19 10 are be VBP 3344 19 11 dead dead JJ 3344 19 12 , , , 3344 19 13 of of IN 3344 19 14 course course NN 3344 19 15 , , , 3344 19 16 but but CC 3344 19 17 it -PRON- PRP 3344 19 18 is be VBZ 3344 19 19 clear clear JJ 3344 19 20 that that IN 3344 19 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 19 22 era era NN 3344 19 23 of of IN 3344 19 24 dominance dominance NN 3344 19 25 is be VBZ 3344 19 26 waning wane VBG 3344 19 27 . . . 3344 20 1 The the DT 3344 20 2 future future NN 3344 20 3 is be VBZ 3344 20 4 digital digital JJ 3344 20 5 . . . 3344 21 1 Nor nor CC 3344 21 2 is be VBZ 3344 21 3 it -PRON- PRP 3344 21 4 to to TO 3344 21 5 say say VB 3344 21 6 that that IN 3344 21 7 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 21 8 companies company NNS 3344 21 9 ( ( -LRB- 3344 21 10 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 21 11 , , , 3344 21 12 film film NN 3344 21 13 , , , 3344 21 14 music music NN 3344 21 15 , , , 3344 21 16 radio radio NN 3344 21 17 , , , 3344 21 18 and and CC 3344 21 19 television television NN 3344 21 20 companies company NNS 3344 21 21 ) ) -RRB- 3344 21 22 and and CC 3344 21 23 information information NN 3344 21 24 companies company NNS 3344 21 25 ( ( -LRB- 3344 21 26 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 21 27 , , , 3344 21 28 book book NN 3344 21 29 , , , 3344 21 30 database database NN 3344 21 31 , , , 3344 21 32 and and CC 3344 21 33 serial serial JJ 3344 21 34 publishers publisher NNS 3344 21 35 ) ) -RRB- 3344 21 36 have have VBP 3344 21 37 ceded cede VBN 3344 21 38 the the DT 3344 21 39 digital digital JJ 3344 21 40 - - HYPH 3344 21 41 content content NN 3344 21 42 battlefield battlefield NN 3344 21 43 to to IN 3344 21 44 the the DT 3344 21 45 upstarts upstart NNS 3344 21 46 . . . 3344 22 1 Quite quite PDT 3344 22 2 the the DT 3344 22 3 contrary contrary NN 3344 22 4 . . . 3344 23 1 High high JJ 3344 23 2 - - HYPH 3344 23 3 quality quality NN 3344 23 4 , , , 3344 23 5 thousand thousand CD 3344 23 6 - - HYPH 3344 23 7 page page NN 3344 23 8 - - HYPH 3344 23 9 per per IN 3344 23 10 - - HYPH 3344 23 11 volume volume NN 3344 23 12 scientific scientific JJ 3344 23 13 jour- jour- NN 3344 23 14 nals nal NNS 3344 23 15 and and CC 3344 23 16 Hollywood Hollywood NNP 3344 23 17 blockbusters blockbuster NNS 3344 23 18 can can MD 3344 23 19 not not RB 3344 23 20 be be VB 3344 23 21 produced produce VBN 3344 23 22 for for IN 3344 23 23 pennies penny NNS 3344 23 24 , , , 3344 23 25 even even RB 3344 23 26 with with IN 3344 23 27 digital digital JJ 3344 23 28 wizardry wizardry NN 3344 23 29 . . . 3344 24 1 Information information NN 3344 24 2 and and CC 3344 24 3 enter- enter- XX 3344 24 4 tainment tainment NN 3344 24 5 companies company NNS 3344 24 6 still still RB 3344 24 7 have have VBP 3344 24 8 an an DT 3344 24 9 important important JJ 3344 24 10 role role NN 3344 24 11 to to TO 3344 24 12 play play VB 3344 24 13 , , , 3344 24 14 and and CC 3344 24 15 , , , 3344 24 16 even even RB 3344 24 17 if if IN 3344 24 18 they -PRON- PRP 3344 24 19 did do VBD 3344 24 20 n’t not RB 3344 24 21 , , , 3344 24 22 they -PRON- PRP 3344 24 23 hold hold VBP 3344 24 24 the the DT 3344 24 25 copyrights copyright NNS 3344 24 26 to to IN 3344 24 27 a a DT 3344 24 28 significant significant JJ 3344 24 29 chunk chunk NN 3344 24 30 of of IN 3344 24 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 3344 24 32 cultural cultural JJ 3344 24 33 heritage heritage NN 3344 24 34 . . . 3344 25 1 Entertainment entertainment NN 3344 25 2 and and CC 3344 25 3 information information NN 3344 25 4 companies company NNS 3344 25 5 have have VBP 3344 25 6 under- under- NNP 3344 25 7 stood stand VBD 3344 25 8 for for IN 3344 25 9 some some DT 3344 25 10 time time NN 3344 25 11 that that WDT 3344 25 12 they -PRON- PRP 3344 25 13 must must MD 3344 25 14 adapt adapt VB 3344 25 15 to to IN 3344 25 16 the the DT 3344 25 17 digital digital JJ 3344 25 18 environment environment NN 3344 25 19 or or CC 3344 25 20 die die VB 3344 25 21 , , , 3344 25 22 but but CC 3344 25 23 this this DT 3344 25 24 change change NN 3344 25 25 has have VBZ 3344 25 26 not not RB 3344 25 27 always always RB 3344 25 28 been be VBN 3344 25 29 easy easy JJ 3344 25 30 , , , 3344 25 31 especially especially RB 3344 25 32 when when WRB 3344 25 33 it -PRON- PRP 3344 25 34 involves involve VBZ 3344 25 35 concocting concoct VBG 3344 25 36 and and CC 3344 25 37 embracing embrace VBG 3344 25 38 new new JJ 3344 25 39 business business NN 3344 25 40 models model NNS 3344 25 41 . . . 3344 26 1 Nonetheless nonetheless RB 3344 26 2 , , , 3344 26 3 they -PRON- PRP 3344 26 4 intend intend VBP 3344 26 5 to to TO 3344 26 6 thrive thrive VB 3344 26 7 and and CC 3344 26 8 prosper prosper VB 3344 26 9 — — : 3344 26 10 and and CC 3344 26 11 to to TO 3344 26 12 do do VB 3344 26 13 whatever whatever WDT 3344 26 14 it -PRON- PRP 3344 26 15 takes take VBZ 3344 26 16 to to TO 3344 26 17 succeed succeed VB 3344 26 18 . . . 3344 27 1 As as IN 3344 27 2 they -PRON- PRP 3344 27 3 should should MD 3344 27 4 , , , 3344 27 5 since since IN 3344 27 6 they -PRON- PRP 3344 27 7 have have VBP 3344 27 8 an an DT 3344 27 9 obligation obligation NN 3344 27 10 to to IN 3344 27 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 27 12 share- share- JJ 3344 27 13 holders holder NNS 3344 27 14 to to TO 3344 27 15 do do VB 3344 27 16 so so RB 3344 27 17 . . . 3344 28 1 The the DT 3344 28 2 thing thing NN 3344 28 3 about about IN 3344 28 4 the the DT 3344 28 5 future future NN 3344 28 6 is be VBZ 3344 28 7 that that IN 3344 28 8 it -PRON- PRP 3344 28 9 is be VBZ 3344 28 10 rooted root VBN 3344 28 11 in in IN 3344 28 12 the the DT 3344 28 13 past past NN 3344 28 14 . . . 3344 29 1 Culture culture NN 3344 29 2 , , , 3344 29 3 even even RB 3344 29 4 digital digital JJ 3344 29 5 culture culture NN 3344 29 6 , , , 3344 29 7 builds build VBZ 3344 29 8 on on IN 3344 29 9 what what WP 3344 29 10 has have VBZ 3344 29 11 gone go VBN 3344 29 12 before before RB 3344 29 13 . . . 3344 30 1 Unconstrained unconstrained JJ 3344 30 2 access access NN 3344 30 3 to to IN 3344 30 4 past past JJ 3344 30 5 works work NNS 3344 30 6 helps help VBZ 3344 30 7 determine determine VB 3344 30 8 the the DT 3344 30 9 richness richness NN 3344 30 10 of of IN 3344 30 11 future future JJ 3344 30 12 works work NNS 3344 30 13 . . . 3344 31 1 Inversely inversely RB 3344 31 2 , , , 3344 31 3 when when WRB 3344 31 4 past past JJ 3344 31 5 works work NNS 3344 31 6 are be VBP 3344 31 7 inaccessible inaccessible JJ 3344 31 8 except except IN 3344 31 9 to to IN 3344 31 10 a a DT 3344 31 11 privileged privileged JJ 3344 31 12 minority minority NN 3344 31 13 , , , 3344 31 14 future future JJ 3344 31 15 works work NNS 3344 31 16 are be VBP 3344 31 17 impoverished impoverished JJ 3344 31 18 . . . 3344 32 1 This this DT 3344 32 2 brings bring VBZ 3344 32 3 us -PRON- PRP 3344 32 4 to to IN 3344 32 5 a a DT 3344 32 6 second second JJ 3344 32 7 trend trend NN 3344 32 8 that that WDT 3344 32 9 stands stand VBZ 3344 32 10 in in IN 3344 32 11 opposi- opposi- XX 3344 32 12 tion tion NN 3344 32 13 to to IN 3344 32 14 the the DT 3344 32 15 first first JJ 3344 32 16 . . . 3344 33 1 Put put VB 3344 33 2 simply simply RB 3344 33 3 , , , 3344 33 4 it -PRON- PRP 3344 33 5 is be VBZ 3344 33 6 the the DT 3344 33 7 view view NN 3344 33 8 that that IN 3344 33 9 intellectual intellectual JJ 3344 33 10 works work NNS 3344 33 11 are be VBP 3344 33 12 property property NN 3344 33 13 ; ; : 3344 33 14 that that IN 3344 33 15 this this DT 3344 33 16 property property NN 3344 33 17 should should MD 3344 33 18 be be VB 3344 33 19 protected protect VBN 3344 33 20 with with IN 3344 33 21 the the DT 3344 33 22 full full JJ 3344 33 23 force force NN 3344 33 24 of of IN 3344 33 25 civil civil JJ 3344 33 26 and and CC 3344 33 27 criminal criminal JJ 3344 33 28 law law NN 3344 33 29 ; ; : 3344 33 30 that that IN 3344 33 31 creators creator NNS 3344 33 32 have have VBP 3344 33 33 perpetual perpetual JJ 3344 33 34 , , , 3344 33 35 transferable transferable JJ 3344 33 36 property property NN 3344 33 37 rights right NNS 3344 33 38 ; ; : 3344 33 39 and and CC 3344 33 40 that that IN 3344 33 41 contracts contract NNS 3344 33 42 , , , 3344 33 43 rather rather RB 3344 33 44 than than IN 3344 33 45 copyright copyright NN 3344 33 46 law law NN 3344 33 47 , , , 3344 33 48 should should MD 3344 33 49 govern govern VB 3344 33 50 the the DT 3344 33 51 use use NN 3344 33 52 of of IN 3344 33 53 intellectual intellectual JJ 3344 33 54 works work NNS 3344 33 55 . . . 3344 34 1 A a DT 3344 34 2 third third JJ 3344 34 3 trend trend NN 3344 34 4 is be VBZ 3344 34 5 also also RB 3344 34 6 at at IN 3344 34 7 play play NN 3344 34 8 : : : 3344 34 9 the the DT 3344 34 10 growing grow VBG 3344 34 11 use use NN 3344 34 12 of of IN 3344 34 13 Digital Digital NNP 3344 34 14 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 34 15 Management Management NNP 3344 34 16 ( ( -LRB- 3344 34 17 DRM DRM NNP 3344 34 18 ) ) -RRB- 3344 34 19 technologies technology NNS 3344 34 20 . . . 3344 35 1 When when WRB 3344 35 2 intel- intel- NNP 3344 35 3 lectual lectual JJ 3344 35 4 works work NNS 3344 35 5 were be VBD 3344 35 6 in in IN 3344 35 7 paper paper NN 3344 35 8 ( ( -LRB- 3344 35 9 or or CC 3344 35 10 other other JJ 3344 35 11 tangible tangible JJ 3344 35 12 forms form NNS 3344 35 13 ) ) -RRB- 3344 35 14 , , , 3344 35 15 they -PRON- PRP 3344 35 16 could could MD 3344 35 17 only only RB 3344 35 18 be be VB 3344 35 19 controlled control VBN 3344 35 20 at at IN 3344 35 21 the the DT 3344 35 22 object object NN 3344 35 23 - - HYPH 3344 35 24 ownership ownership NN 3344 35 25 or or CC 3344 35 26 object object NN 3344 35 27 - - HYPH 3344 35 28 access access NN 3344 35 29 levels level NNS 3344 35 30 ( ( -LRB- 3344 35 31 a a DT 3344 35 32 library library NN 3344 35 33 controlling control VBG 3344 35 34 the the DT 3344 35 35 circulation circulation NN 3344 35 36 of of IN 3344 35 37 a a DT 3344 35 38 copy copy NN 3344 35 39 of of IN 3344 35 40 a a DT 3344 35 41 book book NN 3344 35 42 is be VBZ 3344 35 43 an an DT 3344 35 44 example example NN 3344 35 45 of of IN 3344 35 46 the the DT 3344 35 47 second second JJ 3344 35 48 case case NN 3344 35 49 ) ) -RRB- 3344 35 50 . . . 3344 36 1 Physical physical JJ 3344 36 2 possession possession NN 3344 36 3 of of IN 3344 36 4 a a DT 3344 36 5 work work NN 3344 36 6 , , , 3344 36 7 such such JJ 3344 36 8 as as IN 3344 36 9 a a DT 3344 36 10 book book NN 3344 36 11 , , , 3344 36 12 meant mean VBD 3344 36 13 that that IN 3344 36 14 the the DT 3344 36 15 user user NN 3344 36 16 had have VBD 3344 36 17 full full JJ 3344 36 18 use use NN 3344 36 19 of of IN 3344 36 20 it -PRON- PRP 3344 36 21 ( ( -LRB- 3344 36 22 i.e. i.e. FW 3344 36 23 , , , 3344 36 24 the the DT 3344 36 25 user user NN 3344 36 26 could could MD 3344 36 27 read read VB 3344 36 28 the the DT 3344 36 29 entire entire JJ 3344 36 30 book book NN 3344 36 31 and and CC 3344 36 32 photocopy photocopy VB 3344 36 33 pages page NNS 3344 36 34 from from IN 3344 36 35 it -PRON- PRP 3344 36 36 ) ) -RRB- 3344 36 37 . . . 3344 37 1 When when WRB 3344 37 2 works work NNS 3344 37 3 are be VBP 3344 37 4 in in IN 3344 37 5 digital digital JJ 3344 37 6 form form NN 3344 37 7 and and CC 3344 37 8 are be VBP 3344 37 9 protected protect VBN 3344 37 10 by by IN 3344 37 11 some some DT 3344 37 12 types type NNS 3344 37 13 of of IN 3344 37 14 DRM DRM NNP 3344 37 15 , , , 3344 37 16 this this DT 3344 37 17 may may MD 3344 37 18 no no RB 3344 37 19 longer longer RB 3344 37 20 be be VB 3344 37 21 true true JJ 3344 37 22 . . . 3344 38 1 For for IN 3344 38 2 example example NN 3344 38 3 , , , 3344 38 4 a a DT 3344 38 5 user user NN 3344 38 6 may may MD 3344 38 7 only only RB 3344 38 8 be be VB 3344 38 9 able able JJ 3344 38 10 to to TO 3344 38 11 view view VB 3344 38 12 a a DT 3344 38 13 single single JJ 3344 38 14 chapter chapter NN 3344 38 15 from from IN 3344 38 16 a a DT 3344 38 17 DRM DRM NNP 3344 38 18 - - HYPH 3344 38 19 protected protect VBN 3344 38 20 e e NN 3344 38 21 - - NN 3344 38 22 book book NN 3344 38 23 and and CC 3344 38 24 may may MD 3344 38 25 not not RB 3344 38 26 be be VB 3344 38 27 able able JJ 3344 38 28 to to TO 3344 38 29 print print VB 3344 38 30 it -PRON- PRP 3344 38 31 . . . 3344 39 1 The the DT 3344 39 2 fourth fourth JJ 3344 39 3 and and CC 3344 39 4 final final JJ 3344 39 5 trend trend NN 3344 39 6 deals deal NNS 3344 39 7 with with IN 3344 39 8 how how WRB 3344 39 9 the the DT 3344 39 10 Internet internet NN 3344 39 11 functions function NNS 3344 39 12 at at IN 3344 39 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 39 14 most most JJS 3344 39 15 fundamental fundamental JJ 3344 39 16 level level NN 3344 39 17 . . . 3344 40 1 The the DT 3344 40 2 Internet internet NN 3344 40 3 was be VBD 3344 40 4 designed design VBN 3344 40 5 to to TO 3344 40 6 be be VB 3344 40 7 content- content- JJ 3344 40 8 , , , 3344 40 9 application- application- NN 3344 40 10 , , , 3344 40 11 and and CC 3344 40 12 hardware hardware NN 3344 40 13 - - HYPH 3344 40 14 neu- neu- NN 3344 40 15 tral tral NN 3344 40 16 . . . 3344 41 1 As as RB 3344 41 2 long long RB 3344 41 3 as as IN 3344 41 4 certain certain JJ 3344 41 5 standards standard NNS 3344 41 6 were be VBD 3344 41 7 met meet VBN 3344 41 8 , , , 3344 41 9 the the DT 3344 41 10 network network NN 3344 41 11 did do VBD 3344 41 12 not not RB 3344 41 13 discriminate discriminate VB 3344 41 14 . . . 3344 42 1 One one CD 3344 42 2 type type NN 3344 42 3 of of IN 3344 42 4 content content NN 3344 42 5 was be VBD 3344 42 6 not not RB 3344 42 7 given give VBN 3344 42 8 preferential preferential JJ 3344 42 9 delivery delivery NN 3344 42 10 speed speed NN 3344 42 11 over over IN 3344 42 12 another another DT 3344 42 13 . . . 3344 43 1 One one CD 3344 43 2 type type NN 3344 43 3 of of IN 3344 43 4 Strong strong JJ 3344 43 5 Copyright copyright NN 3344 43 6 + + CC 3344 43 7 DRM DRM NNP 3344 43 8 + + SYM 3344 43 9 Weak weak JJ 3344 43 10 Net Net NNP 3344 43 11 Neutrality Neutrality NNP 3344 43 12 = = SYM 3344 43 13 Digital Digital NNP 3344 43 14 Dystopia Dystopia NNP 3344 43 15 ? ? . 3344 44 1 Charles Charles NNP 3344 44 2 W. W. NNP 3344 44 3 Bailey Bailey NNP 3344 44 4 Jr. Jr. NNP 3344 44 5 Charles Charles NNP 3344 44 6 W. W. NNP 3344 44 7 Bailey Bailey NNP 3344 44 8 Jr. Jr. NNP 3344 44 9 ( ( -LRB- 3344 44 10 cbailey@digital-scholarship.com cbailey@digital-scholarship.com ADD 3344 44 11 ) ) -RRB- 3344 44 12 is be VBZ 3344 44 13 Assistant Assistant NNP 3344 44 14 Dean Dean NNP 3344 44 15 for for IN 3344 44 16 Digital Digital NNP 3344 44 17 Library Library NNP 3344 44 18 Planning Planning NNP 3344 44 19 and and CC 3344 44 20 Development Development NNP 3344 44 21 at at IN 3344 44 22 University University NNP 3344 44 23 of of IN 3344 44 24 Houston Houston NNP 3344 44 25 Libraries Libraries NNP 3344 44 26 . . . 3344 45 1 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 3344 45 2 DYSTOPIA DYSTOPIA NNP 3344 45 3 | | NNP 3344 45 4 BAILEY BAILEY NNP 3344 45 5 117 117 CD 3344 45 6 content content NN 3344 45 7 was be VBD 3344 45 8 not not RB 3344 45 9 charged charge VBN 3344 45 10 for for IN 3344 45 11 delivery delivery NN 3344 45 12 while while IN 3344 45 13 another another DT 3344 45 14 was be VBD 3344 45 15 free free JJ 3344 45 16 . . . 3344 46 1 One one CD 3344 46 2 type type NN 3344 46 3 of of IN 3344 46 4 content content NN 3344 46 5 was be VBD 3344 46 6 not not RB 3344 46 7 blocked block VBN 3344 46 8 ( ( -LRB- 3344 46 9 at at IN 3344 46 10 least least JJS 3344 46 11 by by IN 3344 46 12 the the DT 3344 46 13 network network NN 3344 46 14 ) ) -RRB- 3344 46 15 while while IN 3344 46 16 another another DT 3344 46 17 was be VBD 3344 46 18 unhindered unhindered JJ 3344 46 19 . . . 3344 47 1 In in IN 3344 47 2 recent recent JJ 3344 47 3 years year NNS 3344 47 4 , , , 3344 47 5 network network NN 3344 47 6 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 47 7 has have VBZ 3344 47 8 come come VBN 3344 47 9 under under IN 3344 47 10 attack attack NN 3344 47 11 . . . 3344 48 1 The the DT 3344 48 2 collision collision NN 3344 48 3 of of IN 3344 48 4 these these DT 3344 48 5 trends trend NNS 3344 48 6 has have VBZ 3344 48 7 begun begin VBN 3344 48 8 in in IN 3344 48 9 courts court NNS 3344 48 10 , , , 3344 48 11 leg- leg- NN 3344 48 12 islatures islature NNS 3344 48 13 , , , 3344 48 14 and and CC 3344 48 15 the the DT 3344 48 16 marketplace marketplace NN 3344 48 17 . . . 3344 49 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 49 2 is be VBZ 3344 49 3 far far RB 3344 49 4 from from IN 3344 49 5 over over RB 3344 49 6 . . . 3344 50 1 As as IN 3344 50 2 we -PRON- PRP 3344 50 3 shall shall MD 3344 50 4 see see VB 3344 50 5 , , , 3344 50 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 50 7 outcome outcome NN 3344 50 8 will will MD 3344 50 9 determine determine VB 3344 50 10 what what WP 3344 50 11 the the DT 3344 50 12 future future NN 3344 50 13 of of IN 3344 50 14 digital digital JJ 3344 50 15 culture culture NN 3344 50 16 looks look VBZ 3344 50 17 like like IN 3344 50 18 . . . 3344 51 1 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 51 2 Stronger strong JJR 3344 51 3 copyright copyright NN 3344 51 4 : : : 3344 51 5 1790 1790 CD 3344 51 6 versus versus IN 3344 51 7 2006 2006 CD 3344 51 8 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 51 9 law law NN 3344 51 10 is be VBZ 3344 51 11 a a DT 3344 51 12 complex complex JJ 3344 51 13 topic topic NN 3344 51 14 . . . 3344 52 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 52 2 is be VBZ 3344 52 3 not not RB 3344 52 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 3344 52 5 intention intention NN 3344 52 6 to to TO 3344 52 7 provide provide VB 3344 52 8 a a DT 3344 52 9 full full JJ 3344 52 10 copyright copyright NN 3344 52 11 primer primer NN 3344 52 12 here here RB 3344 52 13 . . . 3344 53 1 ( ( -LRB- 3344 53 2 Indeed indeed RB 3344 53 3 , , , 3344 53 4 I -PRON- PRP 3344 53 5 will will MD 3344 53 6 assume assume VB 3344 53 7 that that IN 3344 53 8 the the DT 3344 53 9 reader reader NN 3344 53 10 understands understand VBZ 3344 53 11 some some DT 3344 53 12 copyright copyright NN 3344 53 13 basics basic NNS 3344 53 14 , , , 3344 53 15 such such JJ 3344 53 16 as as IN 3344 53 17 the the DT 3344 53 18 notion notion NN 3344 53 19 that that IN 3344 53 20 facts fact VBZ 3344 53 21 and and CC 3344 53 22 ideas idea NNS 3344 53 23 are be VBP 3344 53 24 not not RB 3344 53 25 cov- cov- RB 3344 53 26 ered ere VBN 3344 53 27 by by IN 3344 53 28 copyright copyright NN 3344 53 29 . . . 3344 53 30 ) ) -RRB- 3344 54 1 Rather rather RB 3344 54 2 , , , 3344 54 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 3344 54 4 aim aim NN 3344 54 5 is be VBZ 3344 54 6 to to TO 3344 54 7 highlight highlight VB 3344 54 8 some some DT 3344 54 9 key key JJ 3344 54 10 factors factor NNS 3344 54 11 about about IN 3344 54 12 how how WRB 3344 54 13 and and CC 3344 54 14 why why WRB 3344 54 15 United United NNP 3344 54 16 States States NNP 3344 54 17 copyright copyright NN 3344 54 18 law law NN 3344 54 19 has have VBZ 3344 54 20 evolved evolve VBN 3344 54 21 and and CC 3344 54 22 how how WRB 3344 54 23 it -PRON- PRP 3344 54 24 relates relate VBZ 3344 54 25 to to IN 3344 54 26 the the DT 3344 54 27 digital digital JJ 3344 54 28 problem problem NN 3344 54 29 at at IN 3344 54 30 hand hand NN 3344 54 31 . . . 3344 55 1 Three three CD 3344 55 2 authors author NNS 3344 55 3 ( ( -LRB- 3344 55 4 Lawrence Lawrence NNP 3344 55 5 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 55 6 , , , 3344 55 7 Professor Professor NNP 3344 55 8 of of IN 3344 55 9 Law Law NNP 3344 55 10 at at IN 3344 55 11 the the DT 3344 55 12 Stanford Stanford NNP 3344 55 13 Law Law NNP 3344 55 14 School School NNP 3344 55 15 ; ; : 3344 55 16 Jessica Jessica NNP 3344 55 17 Litman Litman NNP 3344 55 18 , , , 3344 55 19 Professor Professor NNP 3344 55 20 of of IN 3344 55 21 Law Law NNP 3344 55 22 at at IN 3344 55 23 the the DT 3344 55 24 Wayne Wayne NNP 3344 55 25 State State NNP 3344 55 26 University University NNP 3344 55 27 Law Law NNP 3344 55 28 School School NNP 3344 55 29 ; ; : 3344 55 30 and and CC 3344 55 31 Siva Siva NNP 3344 55 32 Vaidhyanathan Vaidhyanathan NNP 3344 55 33 , , , 3344 55 34 Assistant Assistant NNP 3344 55 35 Professor Professor NNP 3344 55 36 in in IN 3344 55 37 the the DT 3344 55 38 Department Department NNP 3344 55 39 of of IN 3344 55 40 Culture Culture NNP 3344 55 41 and and CC 3344 55 42 Communication Communication NNP 3344 55 43 at at IN 3344 55 44 New New NNP 3344 55 45 York York NNP 3344 55 46 University University NNP 3344 55 47 ) ) -RRB- 3344 55 48 have have VBP 3344 55 49 done do VBN 3344 55 50 brilliant brilliant JJ 3344 55 51 and and CC 3344 55 52 extensive extensive JJ 3344 55 53 work work NN 3344 55 54 in in IN 3344 55 55 this this DT 3344 55 56 area area NN 3344 55 57 , , , 3344 55 58 and and CC 3344 55 59 the the DT 3344 55 60 following follow VBG 3344 55 61 synopsis synopsis NN 3344 55 62 is be VBZ 3344 55 63 primarily primarily RB 3344 55 64 based base VBN 3344 55 65 on on IN 3344 55 66 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 55 67 con- con- NN 3344 55 68 tributions tribution NNS 3344 55 69 . . . 3344 56 1 I -PRON- PRP 3344 56 2 heartily heartily RB 3344 56 3 recommend recommend VBP 3344 56 4 that that IN 3344 56 5 you -PRON- PRP 3344 56 6 read read VBP 3344 56 7 the the DT 3344 56 8 cited cite VBN 3344 56 9 works work NNS 3344 56 10 in in IN 3344 56 11 full full JJ 3344 56 12 . . . 3344 57 1 The the DT 3344 57 2 purpose purpose NN 3344 57 3 of of IN 3344 57 4 copyright copyright NN 3344 57 5 Let let VB 3344 57 6 us -PRON- PRP 3344 57 7 start start VB 3344 57 8 with with IN 3344 57 9 the the DT 3344 57 10 basis basis NN 3344 57 11 of of IN 3344 57 12 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 57 13 copyright copyright NN 3344 57 14 law law NN 3344 57 15 , , , 3344 57 16 the the DT 3344 57 17 Constitution Constitution NNP 3344 57 18 ’s ’s , 3344 57 19 “ " `` 3344 57 20 Progress Progress NNP 3344 57 21 Clause Clause NNP 3344 57 22 ” " '' 3344 57 23 : : : 3344 57 24 “ " `` 3344 57 25 Congress Congress NNP 3344 57 26 has have VBZ 3344 57 27 the the DT 3344 57 28 power power NN 3344 57 29 to to TO 3344 57 30 promote promote VB 3344 57 31 the the DT 3344 57 32 Progress Progress NNP 3344 57 33 of of IN 3344 57 34 Science Science NNP 3344 57 35 and and CC 3344 57 36 useful useful JJ 3344 57 37 Arts art NNS 3344 57 38 , , , 3344 57 39 by by IN 3344 57 40 securing secure VBG 3344 57 41 for for IN 3344 57 42 limited limited JJ 3344 57 43 Times Times NNP 3344 57 44 to to IN 3344 57 45 Authors Authors NNPS 3344 57 46 and and CC 3344 57 47 Inventors inventor NNS 3344 57 48 the the DT 3344 57 49 exclusive exclusive JJ 3344 57 50 Right right NN 3344 57 51 to to IN 3344 57 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 57 53 respective respective JJ 3344 57 54 Writings Writings NNPS 3344 57 55 and and CC 3344 57 56 Discoveries Discoveries NNPS 3344 57 57 . . . 3344 57 58 ”2 ”2 NNP 3344 57 59 Copyright copyright NN 3344 57 60 was be VBD 3344 57 61 a a DT 3344 57 62 bargain bargain NN 3344 57 63 : : : 3344 57 64 society society NN 3344 57 65 would would MD 3344 57 66 grant grant VB 3344 57 67 creators creator NNS 3344 57 68 a a DT 3344 57 69 time time NN 3344 57 70 - - HYPH 3344 57 71 limited limit VBN 3344 57 72 ability ability NN 3344 57 73 to to TO 3344 57 74 control control VB 3344 57 75 and and CC 3344 57 76 profit profit VB 3344 57 77 from from IN 3344 57 78 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 57 79 works work NNS 3344 57 80 before before IN 3344 57 81 they -PRON- PRP 3344 57 82 fell fall VBD 3344 57 83 into into IN 3344 57 84 the the DT 3344 57 85 public public JJ 3344 57 86 domain domain NN 3344 57 87 ( ( -LRB- 3344 57 88 where where WRB 3344 57 89 works work NNS 3344 57 90 are be VBP 3344 57 91 unprotected unprotected JJ 3344 57 92 ) ) -RRB- 3344 57 93 because because IN 3344 57 94 doing do VBG 3344 57 95 so so RB 3344 57 96 resulted result VBD 3344 57 97 in in IN 3344 57 98 “ " `` 3344 57 99 Progress Progress NNP 3344 57 100 of of IN 3344 57 101 Science Science NNP 3344 57 102 and and CC 3344 57 103 useful useful JJ 3344 57 104 Arts art NNS 3344 57 105 ” " '' 3344 57 106 ( ( -LRB- 3344 57 107 a a DT 3344 57 108 social social JJ 3344 57 109 good good NN 3344 57 110 ) ) -RRB- 3344 57 111 . . . 3344 58 1 Regarding regard VBG 3344 58 2 the the DT 3344 58 3 Progress Progress NNP 3344 58 4 Clause Clause NNP 3344 58 5 , , , 3344 58 6 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 58 7 notes note VBZ 3344 58 8 : : : 3344 58 9 It -PRON- PRP 3344 58 10 does do VBZ 3344 58 11 not not RB 3344 58 12 say say VB 3344 58 13 Congress Congress NNP 3344 58 14 has have VBZ 3344 58 15 the the DT 3344 58 16 power power NN 3344 58 17 to to TO 3344 58 18 grant grant VB 3344 58 19 “ " `` 3344 58 20 creative creative JJ 3344 58 21 property property NN 3344 58 22 rights right NNS 3344 58 23 . . . 3344 58 24 ” " '' 3344 58 25 It -PRON- PRP 3344 58 26 says say VBZ 3344 58 27 that that IN 3344 58 28 Congress Congress NNP 3344 58 29 has have VBZ 3344 58 30 the the DT 3344 58 31 power power NN 3344 58 32 to to TO 3344 58 33 promote promote VB 3344 58 34 progress progress NN 3344 58 35 . . . 3344 59 1 The the DT 3344 59 2 grant grant NN 3344 59 3 of of IN 3344 59 4 power power NN 3344 59 5 is be VBZ 3344 59 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 59 7 purpose purpose NN 3344 59 8 , , , 3344 59 9 and and CC 3344 59 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 59 11 purpose purpose NN 3344 59 12 is be VBZ 3344 59 13 a a DT 3344 59 14 public public JJ 3344 59 15 one one NN 3344 59 16 , , , 3344 59 17 not not RB 3344 59 18 the the DT 3344 59 19 purpose purpose NN 3344 59 20 of of IN 3344 59 21 enriching enrich VBG 3344 59 22 publishers publisher NNS 3344 59 23 , , , 3344 59 24 nor nor CC 3344 59 25 even even RB 3344 59 26 primarily primarily RB 3344 59 27 the the DT 3344 59 28 purpose purpose NN 3344 59 29 of of IN 3344 59 30 reward- reward- NNP 3344 59 31 ing ing NNP 3344 59 32 authors.3 authors.3 XX 3344 59 33 However however RB 3344 59 34 , , , 3344 59 35 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 59 36 and and CC 3344 59 37 information information NN 3344 59 38 companies company NNS 3344 59 39 can can MD 3344 59 40 have have VB 3344 59 41 a a DT 3344 59 42 far far RB 3344 59 43 different different JJ 3344 59 44 view view NN 3344 59 45 , , , 3344 59 46 as as IN 3344 59 47 illustrated illustrate VBN 3344 59 48 by by IN 3344 59 49 this this DT 3344 59 50 quote quote NN 3344 59 51 from from IN 3344 59 52 Jack Jack NNP 3344 59 53 Valenti Valenti NNP 3344 59 54 , , , 3344 59 55 former former JJ 3344 59 56 president president NN 3344 59 57 of of IN 3344 59 58 the the DT 3344 59 59 Motion Motion NNP 3344 59 60 Picture Picture NNP 3344 59 61 Association Association NNP 3344 59 62 of of IN 3344 59 63 America America NNP 3344 59 64 : : : 3344 59 65 “ " `` 3344 59 66 Creative creative JJ 3344 59 67 property property NN 3344 59 68 owners owner NNS 3344 59 69 must must MD 3344 59 70 be be VB 3344 59 71 accorded accord VBN 3344 59 72 the the DT 3344 59 73 same same JJ 3344 59 74 rights right NNS 3344 59 75 and and CC 3344 59 76 protections protection NNS 3344 59 77 resident resident JJ 3344 59 78 in in IN 3344 59 79 all all DT 3344 59 80 other other JJ 3344 59 81 property property NN 3344 59 82 owners owner NNS 3344 59 83 in in IN 3344 59 84 the the DT 3344 59 85 nation nation NN 3344 59 86 . . . 3344 59 87 ”4 ”4 NNP 3344 59 88 Types type NNS 3344 59 89 of of IN 3344 59 90 works work NNS 3344 59 91 covered cover VBN 3344 59 92 When when WRB 3344 59 93 the the DT 3344 59 94 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 59 95 Act Act NNP 3344 59 96 of of IN 3344 59 97 1790 1790 CD 3344 59 98 was be VBD 3344 59 99 enacted enact VBN 3344 59 100 , , , 3344 59 101 it -PRON- PRP 3344 59 102 protected protect VBD 3344 59 103 published publish VBN 3344 59 104 books book NNS 3344 59 105 , , , 3344 59 106 maps map NNS 3344 59 107 , , , 3344 59 108 and and CC 3344 59 109 charts chart NNS 3344 59 110 written write VBN 3344 59 111 by by IN 3344 59 112 living live VBG 3344 59 113 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 59 114 authors author NNS 3344 59 115 as as RB 3344 59 116 well well RB 3344 59 117 as as IN 3344 59 118 unpublished unpublished JJ 3344 59 119 manuscripts manuscript NNS 3344 59 120 by by IN 3344 59 121 them.5 them.5 NNP 3344 59 122 The the DT 3344 59 123 act act NN 3344 59 124 gave give VBD 3344 59 125 the the DT 3344 59 126 author author NN 3344 59 127 the the DT 3344 59 128 exclusive exclusive JJ 3344 59 129 right right NN 3344 59 130 to to IN 3344 59 131 “ " `` 3344 59 132 print print NN 3344 59 133 , , , 3344 59 134 reprint reprint NN 3344 59 135 , , , 3344 59 136 publish publish NNS 3344 59 137 , , , 3344 59 138 or or CC 3344 59 139 vend vend VB 3344 59 140 ” " '' 3344 59 141 these these DT 3344 59 142 works work NNS 3344 59 143 . . . 3344 60 1 Now now RB 3344 60 2 , , , 3344 60 3 copyright copyright NN 3344 60 4 protects protect VBZ 3344 60 5 a a DT 3344 60 6 wide wide JJ 3344 60 7 range range NN 3344 60 8 of of IN 3344 60 9 published publish VBN 3344 60 10 and and CC 3344 60 11 unpublished unpublishe VBN 3344 60 12 “ " `` 3344 60 13 original original JJ 3344 60 14 works work NNS 3344 60 15 of of IN 3344 60 16 authorship authorship NN 3344 60 17 ” " '' 3344 60 18 that that WDT 3344 60 19 are be VBP 3344 60 20 “ " `` 3344 60 21 fixed fix VBN 3344 60 22 in in IN 3344 60 23 a a DT 3344 60 24 tangible tangible JJ 3344 60 25 medium medium NN 3344 60 26 of of IN 3344 60 27 expression expression NN 3344 60 28 ” " '' 3344 60 29 without without IN 3344 60 30 regard regard NN 3344 60 31 for for IN 3344 60 32 “ " `` 3344 60 33 the the DT 3344 60 34 nationality nationality NN 3344 60 35 or or CC 3344 60 36 domi- domi- NN 3344 60 37 cile cile NN 3344 60 38 of of IN 3344 60 39 the the DT 3344 60 40 author author NN 3344 60 41 , , , 3344 60 42 ” " '' 3344 60 43 including include VBG 3344 60 44 “ " `` 3344 60 45 1 1 CD 3344 60 46 . . . 3344 61 1 literary literary JJ 3344 61 2 works work NNS 3344 61 3 ; ; : 3344 61 4 2 2 LS 3344 61 5 . . . 3344 61 6 musical musical JJ 3344 61 7 works work NNS 3344 61 8 , , , 3344 61 9 including include VBG 3344 61 10 any any DT 3344 61 11 accompanying accompanying JJ 3344 61 12 words word NNS 3344 61 13 ; ; : 3344 61 14 3 3 LS 3344 61 15 . . . 3344 61 16 dramatic dramatic JJ 3344 61 17 works work NNS 3344 61 18 , , , 3344 61 19 including include VBG 3344 61 20 any any DT 3344 61 21 accompanying accompany VBG 3344 61 22 music music NN 3344 61 23 ; ; : 3344 61 24 4 4 LS 3344 61 25 . . . 3344 61 26 pantomimes pantomime NNS 3344 61 27 and and CC 3344 61 28 choreographic choreographic JJ 3344 61 29 works work NNS 3344 61 30 ; ; : 3344 61 31 5 5 LS 3344 61 32 . . . 3344 61 33 pictorial pictorial JJ 3344 61 34 , , , 3344 61 35 graphic graphic JJ 3344 61 36 , , , 3344 61 37 and and CC 3344 61 38 sculp- sculp- JJ 3344 61 39 tural tural JJ 3344 61 40 works work NNS 3344 61 41 ; ; : 3344 61 42 6 6 LS 3344 61 43 . . . 3344 61 44 motion motion NN 3344 61 45 pictures picture NNS 3344 61 46 and and CC 3344 61 47 other other JJ 3344 61 48 audiovisual audiovisual JJ 3344 61 49 works work NNS 3344 61 50 ; ; : 3344 61 51 7 7 LS 3344 61 52 . . . 3344 61 53 sound sound JJ 3344 61 54 recordings recording NNS 3344 61 55 ; ; : 3344 61 56 8 8 CD 3344 61 57 . . . 3344 61 58 architectural architectural JJ 3344 61 59 works work NNS 3344 61 60 . . . 3344 61 61 ”6 ”6 NN 3344 61 62 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 61 63 In in IN 3344 61 64 contrast contrast NN 3344 61 65 to to IN 3344 61 66 the the DT 3344 61 67 limited limited JJ 3344 61 68 print print NN 3344 61 69 publishing publish VBG 3344 61 70 rights right NNS 3344 61 71 inherent inherent JJ 3344 61 72 in in IN 3344 61 73 the the DT 3344 61 74 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 61 75 Act Act NNP 3344 61 76 of of IN 3344 61 77 1790 1790 CD 3344 61 78 , , , 3344 61 79 current current JJ 3344 61 80 law law NN 3344 61 81 grants grant NNS 3344 61 82 copyright copyright NN 3344 61 83 owners owner NNS 3344 61 84 the the DT 3344 61 85 following follow VBG 3344 61 86 rights right NNS 3344 61 87 ( ( -LRB- 3344 61 88 especially especially RB 3344 61 89 notable notable JJ 3344 61 90 is be VBZ 3344 61 91 the the DT 3344 61 92 addi- addi- JJ 3344 61 93 tion tion NN 3344 61 94 of of IN 3344 61 95 control control NN 3344 61 96 over over IN 3344 61 97 derivative derivative JJ 3344 61 98 works work NNS 3344 61 99 , , , 3344 61 100 such such JJ 3344 61 101 as as IN 3344 61 102 a a DT 3344 61 103 play play NN 3344 61 104 based base VBN 3344 61 105 on on IN 3344 61 106 a a DT 3344 61 107 novel novel NN 3344 61 108 or or CC 3344 61 109 a a DT 3344 61 110 translation translation NN 3344 61 111 ) ) -RRB- 3344 61 112 : : : 3344 61 113 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 61 114 to to TO 3344 61 115 reproduce reproduce VB 3344 61 116 the the DT 3344 61 117 work work NN 3344 61 118 in in IN 3344 61 119 copies copy NNS 3344 61 120 or or CC 3344 61 121 phonograph phonograph NN 3344 61 122 records record NNS 3344 61 123 ; ; : 3344 61 124 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 61 125 to to TO 3344 61 126 prepare prepare VB 3344 61 127 derivative derivative JJ 3344 61 128 works work NNS 3344 61 129 based base VBN 3344 61 130 upon upon IN 3344 61 131 the the DT 3344 61 132 work work NN 3344 61 133 ; ; : 3344 61 134 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 61 135 to to TO 3344 61 136 distribute distribute VB 3344 61 137 copies copy NNS 3344 61 138 or or CC 3344 61 139 phonograph phonograph VB 3344 61 140 records record NNS 3344 61 141 of of IN 3344 61 142 the the DT 3344 61 143 work work NN 3344 61 144 to to IN 3344 61 145 the the DT 3344 61 146 public public NN 3344 61 147 by by IN 3344 61 148 sale sale NN 3344 61 149 or or CC 3344 61 150 other other JJ 3344 61 151 transfer transfer NN 3344 61 152 of of IN 3344 61 153 ownership ownership NN 3344 61 154 , , , 3344 61 155 or or CC 3344 61 156 by by IN 3344 61 157 rental rental NN 3344 61 158 , , , 3344 61 159 lease lease NN 3344 61 160 , , , 3344 61 161 or or CC 3344 61 162 lending lending NN 3344 61 163 ; ; : 3344 61 164 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 61 165 to to TO 3344 61 166 perform perform VB 3344 61 167 the the DT 3344 61 168 work work NN 3344 61 169 publicly publicly RB 3344 61 170 , , , 3344 61 171 in in IN 3344 61 172 the the DT 3344 61 173 case case NN 3344 61 174 of of IN 3344 61 175 literary literary JJ 3344 61 176 , , , 3344 61 177 musi- musi- XX 3344 61 178 cal cal JJ 3344 61 179 , , , 3344 61 180 dramatic dramatic JJ 3344 61 181 , , , 3344 61 182 and and CC 3344 61 183 choreographic choreographic JJ 3344 61 184 works work NNS 3344 61 185 , , , 3344 61 186 pantomimes pantomime NNS 3344 61 187 , , , 3344 61 188 and and CC 3344 61 189 motion motion NN 3344 61 190 pictures picture NNS 3344 61 191 and and CC 3344 61 192 other other JJ 3344 61 193 audiovisual audiovisual JJ 3344 61 194 works work NNS 3344 61 195 ; ; : 3344 61 196 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 61 197 to to TO 3344 61 198 display display VB 3344 61 199 the the DT 3344 61 200 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 61 201 work work NN 3344 61 202 publicly publicly RB 3344 61 203 , , , 3344 61 204 in in IN 3344 61 205 the the DT 3344 61 206 case case NN 3344 61 207 of of IN 3344 61 208 literary literary JJ 3344 61 209 , , , 3344 61 210 musical musical JJ 3344 61 211 , , , 3344 61 212 dramatic dramatic JJ 3344 61 213 , , , 3344 61 214 and and CC 3344 61 215 choreographic choreographic JJ 3344 61 216 works work NNS 3344 61 217 , , , 3344 61 218 pantomimes pantomime NNS 3344 61 219 , , , 3344 61 220 and and CC 3344 61 221 pictorial pictorial JJ 3344 61 222 , , , 3344 61 223 graphic graphic JJ 3344 61 224 , , , 3344 61 225 or or CC 3344 61 226 sculptural sculptural JJ 3344 61 227 works work NNS 3344 61 228 , , , 3344 61 229 including include VBG 3344 61 230 the the DT 3344 61 231 individual individual JJ 3344 61 232 images image NNS 3344 61 233 of of IN 3344 61 234 a a DT 3344 61 235 motion motion NN 3344 61 236 picture picture NN 3344 61 237 or or CC 3344 61 238 other other JJ 3344 61 239 audiovisual audiovisual JJ 3344 61 240 work work NN 3344 61 241 ; ; : 3344 61 242 and and CC 3344 61 243 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 61 244 in in IN 3344 61 245 the the DT 3344 61 246 case case NN 3344 61 247 of of IN 3344 61 248 sound sound JJ 3344 61 249 recordings recording NNS 3344 61 250 , , , 3344 61 251 to to TO 3344 61 252 perform perform VB 3344 61 253 the the DT 3344 61 254 work work NN 3344 61 255 pub- pub- NN 3344 61 256 licly licly NN 3344 61 257 by by IN 3344 61 258 means mean NNS 3344 61 259 of of IN 3344 61 260 a a DT 3344 61 261 digital digital JJ 3344 61 262 audio audio JJ 3344 61 263 transmission.7 transmission.7 CD 3344 61 264 Duration Duration NNP 3344 61 265 The The NNP 3344 61 266 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 61 267 Act Act NNP 3344 61 268 of of IN 3344 61 269 1790 1790 CD 3344 61 270 granted grant VBN 3344 61 271 authors author NNS 3344 61 272 a a DT 3344 61 273 term term NN 3344 61 274 of of IN 3344 61 275 four- four- NN 3344 61 276 teen teen NN 3344 61 277 years year NNS 3344 61 278 , , , 3344 61 279 with with IN 3344 61 280 one one CD 3344 61 281 renewal renewal NN 3344 61 282 if if IN 3344 61 283 the the DT 3344 61 284 author author NN 3344 61 285 was be VBD 3344 61 286 still still RB 3344 61 287 living live VBG 3344 61 288 ( ( -LRB- 3344 61 289 twenty twenty CD 3344 61 290 - - HYPH 3344 61 291 eight eight CD 3344 61 292 years year NNS 3344 61 293 total).8 total).8 VBN 3344 61 294 Now now RB 3344 61 295 the the DT 3344 61 296 situation situation NN 3344 61 297 is be VBZ 3344 61 298 much much RB 3344 61 299 more more RBR 3344 61 300 complex complex JJ 3344 61 301 , , , 3344 61 302 and and CC 3344 61 303 , , , 3344 61 304 rather rather RB 3344 61 305 than than IN 3344 61 306 trying try VBG 3344 61 307 to to TO 3344 61 308 review review VB 3344 61 309 the the DT 3344 61 310 details detail NNS 3344 61 311 , , , 3344 61 312 I -PRON- PRP 3344 61 313 ’ll will MD 3344 61 314 provide provide VB 3344 61 315 the the DT 3344 61 316 following follow VBG 3344 61 317 example example NN 3344 61 318 . . . 3344 62 1 For for IN 3344 62 2 a a DT 3344 62 3 personal personal JJ 3344 62 4 author author NN 3344 62 5 who who WP 3344 62 6 produced produce VBD 3344 62 7 a a DT 3344 62 8 work work NN 3344 62 9 on on IN 3344 62 10 or or CC 3344 62 11 after after IN 3344 62 12 January January NNP 3344 62 13 1 1 CD 3344 62 14 , , , 3344 62 15 1978 1978 CD 3344 62 16 , , , 3344 62 17 it -PRON- PRP 3344 62 18 is be VBZ 3344 62 19 covered cover VBN 3344 62 20 for for IN 3344 62 21 the the DT 3344 62 22 life life NN 3344 62 23 of of IN 3344 62 24 the the DT 3344 62 25 author author NN 3344 62 26 plus plus CC 3344 62 27 seventy seventy CD 3344 62 28 years.9 years.9 UH 3344 62 29 So so RB 3344 62 30 , , , 3344 62 31 assuming assume VBG 3344 62 32 118 118 CD 3344 62 33 INFORMATION information NN 3344 62 34 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3344 62 35 AND and CC 3344 62 36 LIBRARIES library NNS 3344 62 37 | | NNP 3344 62 38 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3344 62 39 2006 2006 CD 3344 62 40 an an DT 3344 62 41 author author NN 3344 62 42 lives live VBZ 3344 62 43 an an DT 3344 62 44 average average JJ 3344 62 45 seventy seventy CD 3344 62 46 - - HYPH 3344 62 47 five five CD 3344 62 48 years year NNS 3344 62 49 , , , 3344 62 50 the the DT 3344 62 51 work work NN 3344 62 52 would would MD 3344 62 53 be be VB 3344 62 54 covered cover VBN 3344 62 55 for for IN 3344 62 56 144 144 CD 3344 62 57 years year NNS 3344 62 58 , , , 3344 62 59 which which WDT 3344 62 60 is be VBZ 3344 62 61 approximately approximately RB 3344 62 62 116 116 CD 3344 62 63 years year NNS 3344 62 64 longer long RBR 3344 62 65 than than IN 3344 62 66 in in IN 3344 62 67 1790 1790 CD 3344 62 68 . . . 3344 63 1 Registration registration NN 3344 63 2 Registration registration NN 3344 63 3 was be VBD 3344 63 4 required require VBN 3344 63 5 by by IN 3344 63 6 the the DT 3344 63 7 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 63 8 Act Act NNP 3344 63 9 of of IN 3344 63 10 1790 1790 CD 3344 63 11 , , , 3344 63 12 but but CC 3344 63 13 very very RB 3344 63 14 few few JJ 3344 63 15 eligible eligible JJ 3344 63 16 works work NNS 3344 63 17 were be VBD 3344 63 18 registered register VBN 3344 63 19 from from IN 3344 63 20 1790 1790 CD 3344 63 21 to to IN 3344 63 22 1800 1800 CD 3344 63 23 , , , 3344 63 24 which which WDT 3344 63 25 enriched enrich VBD 3344 63 26 the the DT 3344 63 27 public public JJ 3344 63 28 domain.10 domain.10 NNP 3344 63 29 Now now RB 3344 63 30 registra- registra- JJ 3344 63 31 tion tion NN 3344 63 32 is be VBZ 3344 63 33 not not RB 3344 63 34 required require VBN 3344 63 35 , , , 3344 63 36 and and CC 3344 63 37 no no DT 3344 63 38 work work NN 3344 63 39 enriches enrich VBZ 3344 63 40 the the DT 3344 63 41 public public JJ 3344 63 42 domain domain NN 3344 63 43 until until IN 3344 63 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 63 45 term term NN 3344 63 46 is be VBZ 3344 63 47 over over RB 3344 63 48 , , , 3344 63 49 even even RB 3344 63 50 if if IN 3344 63 51 the the DT 3344 63 52 author author NN 3344 63 53 ( ( -LRB- 3344 63 54 or or CC 3344 63 55 the the DT 3344 63 56 author author NN 3344 63 57 ’s ’s . 3344 63 58 descendants descendant NNS 3344 63 59 ) ) -RRB- 3344 63 60 have have VBP 3344 63 61 no no DT 3344 63 62 interest interest NN 3344 63 63 in in IN 3344 63 64 the the DT 3344 63 65 work work NN 3344 63 66 being be VBG 3344 63 67 under under IN 3344 63 68 copyright copyright NN 3344 63 69 , , , 3344 63 70 or or CC 3344 63 71 it -PRON- PRP 3344 63 72 is be VBZ 3344 63 73 impossible impossible JJ 3344 63 74 to to TO 3344 63 75 locate locate VB 3344 63 76 the the DT 3344 63 77 copyright copyright NN 3344 63 78 holder holder NN 3344 63 79 to to TO 3344 63 80 gain gain VB 3344 63 81 permission permission NN 3344 63 82 to to TO 3344 63 83 use use VB 3344 63 84 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 63 85 or or CC 3344 63 86 her -PRON- PRP$ 3344 63 87 works work NNS 3344 63 88 ( ( -LRB- 3344 63 89 creating create VBG 3344 63 90 so so RB 3344 63 91 - - HYPH 3344 63 92 called call VBN 3344 63 93 “ " `` 3344 63 94 orphan orphan NNP 3344 63 95 works works NNP 3344 63 96 ” " '' 3344 63 97 ) ) -RRB- 3344 63 98 . . . 3344 64 1 Drafting draft VBG 3344 64 2 of of IN 3344 64 3 legislation legislation NN 3344 64 4 By by IN 3344 64 5 1901 1901 CD 3344 64 6 , , , 3344 64 7 copyright copyright NN 3344 64 8 law law NN 3344 64 9 had have VBD 3344 64 10 become become VBN 3344 64 11 fairly fairly RB 3344 64 12 esoteric esoteric JJ 3344 64 13 and and CC 3344 64 14 com- com- NN 3344 64 15 plex plex NN 3344 64 16 , , , 3344 64 17 and and CC 3344 64 18 drafting draft VBG 3344 64 19 new new JJ 3344 64 20 copyright copyright NN 3344 64 21 legislation legislation NN 3344 64 22 had have VBD 3344 64 23 become become VBN 3344 64 24 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 64 25 difficult difficult JJ 3344 64 26 . . . 3344 65 1 Consequently consequently RB 3344 65 2 , , , 3344 65 3 Congress Congress NNP 3344 65 4 adopted adopt VBD 3344 65 5 a a DT 3344 65 6 new new JJ 3344 65 7 strategy strategy NN 3344 65 8 : : : 3344 65 9 let let VB 3344 65 10 those those DT 3344 65 11 whose whose WP$ 3344 65 12 commercial commercial JJ 3344 65 13 interests interest NNS 3344 65 14 were be VBD 3344 65 15 directly directly RB 3344 65 16 affected affect VBN 3344 65 17 by by IN 3344 65 18 copyright copyright NN 3344 65 19 law law NN 3344 65 20 deliberate deliberate JJ 3344 65 21 and and CC 3344 65 22 negoti- negoti- NNP 3344 65 23 ate eat VBD 3344 65 24 with with IN 3344 65 25 each each DT 3344 65 26 other other JJ 3344 65 27 about about IN 3344 65 28 copyright copyright NN 3344 65 29 law law NN 3344 65 30 changes change NNS 3344 65 31 , , , 3344 65 32 and and CC 3344 65 33 use use VB 3344 65 34 the the DT 3344 65 35 results result NNS 3344 65 36 of of IN 3344 65 37 this this DT 3344 65 38 process process NN 3344 65 39 as as IN 3344 65 40 the the DT 3344 65 41 basis basis NN 3344 65 42 of of IN 3344 65 43 new new JJ 3344 65 44 legislation.11 legislation.11 NNP 3344 65 45 Over Over NNP 3344 65 46 time time NN 3344 65 47 , , , 3344 65 48 this this DT 3344 65 49 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 65 50 became become VBD 3344 65 51 a a DT 3344 65 52 dialogue dialogue NN 3344 65 53 among among IN 3344 65 54 representatives representative NNS 3344 65 55 of of IN 3344 65 56 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 65 57 , , , 3344 65 58 high high JJ 3344 65 59 - - HYPH 3344 65 60 tech tech NN 3344 65 61 , , , 3344 65 62 information information NN 3344 65 63 , , , 3344 65 64 and and CC 3344 65 65 telecommunications telecommunications NN 3344 65 66 companies company NNS 3344 65 67 ; ; : 3344 65 68 other other JJ 3344 65 69 parties party NNS 3344 65 70 , , , 3344 65 71 such such JJ 3344 65 72 as as IN 3344 65 73 library library NN 3344 65 74 associations association NNS 3344 65 75 ; ; , 3344 65 76 and and CC 3344 65 77 rights right NNS 3344 65 78 - - HYPH 3344 65 79 holder holder NN 3344 65 80 groups group NNS 3344 65 81 ( ( -LRB- 3344 65 82 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 65 83 , , , 3344 65 84 ASCAP ASCAP NNP 3344 65 85 ) ) -RRB- 3344 65 86 . . . 3344 66 1 Since since IN 3344 66 2 these these DT 3344 66 3 parties party NNS 3344 66 4 often often RB 3344 66 5 had have VBD 3344 66 6 competing compete VBG 3344 66 7 interests interest NNS 3344 66 8 , , , 3344 66 9 the the DT 3344 66 10 negotiations negotiation NNS 3344 66 11 were be VBD 3344 66 12 frequently frequently RB 3344 66 13 contentious contentious JJ 3344 66 14 and and CC 3344 66 15 lengthy lengthy JJ 3344 66 16 . . . 3344 67 1 The the DT 3344 67 2 resulting result VBG 3344 67 3 laws law NNS 3344 67 4 created create VBD 3344 67 5 a a DT 3344 67 6 kind kind NN 3344 67 7 of of IN 3344 67 8 crazy crazy JJ 3344 67 9 quilt quilt NN 3344 67 10 of of IN 3344 67 11 specific specific JJ 3344 67 12 exceptions exception NNS 3344 67 13 for for IN 3344 67 14 the the DT 3344 67 15 deals deal NNS 3344 67 16 made make VBN 3344 67 17 during during IN 3344 67 18 these these DT 3344 67 19 sessions session NNS 3344 67 20 to to IN 3344 67 21 the the DT 3344 67 22 ever ever RB 3344 67 23 - - HYPH 3344 67 24 expanding expand VBG 3344 67 25 control control NN 3344 67 26 over over IN 3344 67 27 intellectual intellectual JJ 3344 67 28 works work NNS 3344 67 29 that that WDT 3344 67 30 copyright copyright NN 3344 67 31 reform reform NN 3344 67 32 generally generally RB 3344 67 33 engendered engender VBD 3344 67 34 . . . 3344 68 1 Since since IN 3344 68 2 the the DT 3344 68 3 public public NN 3344 68 4 was be VBD 3344 68 5 not not RB 3344 68 6 at at IN 3344 68 7 the the DT 3344 68 8 table table NN 3344 68 9 , , , 3344 68 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 68 11 highly highly RB 3344 68 12 diverse diverse JJ 3344 68 13 interests interest NNS 3344 68 14 were be VBD 3344 68 15 not not RB 3344 68 16 directly directly RB 3344 68 17 represented represent VBN 3344 68 18 , , , 3344 68 19 and and CC 3344 68 20 , , , 3344 68 21 since since IN 3344 68 22 stakeholder stakeholder NN 3344 68 23 industries industry NNS 3344 68 24 lobby lobby NN 3344 68 25 Congress Congress NNP 3344 68 26 and and CC 3344 68 27 the the DT 3344 68 28 public public NN 3344 68 29 does do VBZ 3344 68 30 not not RB 3344 68 31 , , , 3344 68 32 the the DT 3344 68 33 public public NN 3344 68 34 ’s ’s POS 3344 68 35 interests interest NNS 3344 68 36 were be VBD 3344 68 37 often often RB 3344 68 38 not not RB 3344 68 39 well well RB 3344 68 40 served serve VBN 3344 68 41 . . . 3344 69 1 ( ( -LRB- 3344 69 2 There there EX 3344 69 3 were be VBD 3344 69 4 some some DT 3344 69 5 efforts effort NNS 3344 69 6 by by IN 3344 69 7 special special JJ 3344 69 8 interest interest NN 3344 69 9 groups group NNS 3344 69 10 to to TO 3344 69 11 represent represent VB 3344 69 12 the the DT 3344 69 13 public public NN 3344 69 14 on on IN 3344 69 15 narrowly narrowly RB 3344 69 16 focused focused JJ 3344 69 17 issues issue NNS 3344 69 18 . . . 3344 69 19 ) ) -RRB- 3344 70 1 Frequency frequency NN 3344 70 2 of of IN 3344 70 3 copyright copyright NN 3344 70 4 term term NN 3344 70 5 legislation legislation NN 3344 70 6 With with IN 3344 70 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 3344 70 8 restraint restraint NN 3344 70 9 , , , 3344 70 10 Congress Congress NNP 3344 70 11 , , , 3344 70 12 in in IN 3344 70 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 70 14 first first JJ 3344 70 15 hundred hundred CD 3344 70 16 years year NNS 3344 70 17 , , , 3344 70 18 enacted enact VBD 3344 70 19 one one CD 3344 70 20 copyright copyright NN 3344 70 21 bill bill NN 3344 70 22 that that WDT 3344 70 23 extended extend VBD 3344 70 24 the the DT 3344 70 25 copy- copy- RB 3344 70 26 right right JJ 3344 70 27 term term NN 3344 70 28 and and CC 3344 70 29 one one CD 3344 70 30 in in IN 3344 70 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 70 32 next next JJ 3344 70 33 fifty fifty CD 3344 70 34 ; ; : 3344 70 35 however however RB 3344 70 36 , , , 3344 70 37 starting start VBG 3344 70 38 in in IN 3344 70 39 1962 1962 CD 3344 70 40 , , , 3344 70 41 it -PRON- PRP 3344 70 42 passed pass VBD 3344 70 43 eleven eleven CD 3344 70 44 bills bill NNS 3344 70 45 in in IN 3344 70 46 the the DT 3344 70 47 next next JJ 3344 70 48 forty forty NN 3344 70 49 years.12 years.12 NNP 3344 70 50 Famously famously RB 3344 70 51 , , , 3344 70 52 Jack Jack NNP 3344 70 53 Valenti Valenti NNP 3344 70 54 once once RB 3344 70 55 proposed propose VBD 3344 70 56 that that DT 3344 70 57 copyright copyright NN 3344 70 58 “ " `` 3344 70 59 last last JJ 3344 70 60 forever forever RB 3344 70 61 less less JJR 3344 70 62 one one CD 3344 70 63 day day NN 3344 70 64 . . . 3344 70 65 ”13 ”13 FW 3344 70 66 By by IN 3344 70 67 continually continually RB 3344 70 68 extending extend VBG 3344 70 69 copyright copyright NN 3344 70 70 terms term NNS 3344 70 71 in in IN 3344 70 72 a a DT 3344 70 73 serial serial JJ 3344 70 74 fashion fashion NN 3344 70 75 , , , 3344 70 76 Congress Congress NNP 3344 70 77 may may MD 3344 70 78 grant grant VB 3344 70 79 him -PRON- PRP 3344 70 80 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 70 81 wish wish NN 3344 70 82 . . . 3344 71 1 Licenses license NNS 3344 71 2 In in IN 3344 71 3 1790 1790 CD 3344 71 4 , , , 3344 71 5 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 71 6 works work NNS 3344 71 7 were be VBD 3344 71 8 sold sell VBN 3344 71 9 and and CC 3344 71 10 owned own VBN 3344 71 11 . . . 3344 72 1 Today today NN 3344 72 2 , , , 3344 72 3 many many JJ 3344 72 4 digital digital JJ 3344 72 5 works work NNS 3344 72 6 are be VBP 3344 72 7 licensed license VBN 3344 72 8 . . . 3344 73 1 Licenses license NNS 3344 73 2 usually usually RB 3344 73 3 fall fall VBP 3344 73 4 under under IN 3344 73 5 state state NN 3344 73 6 contract contract NN 3344 73 7 law law NN 3344 73 8 rather rather RB 3344 73 9 than than IN 3344 73 10 federal federal JJ 3344 73 11 copyright copyright NN 3344 73 12 law.14 law.14 NNS 3344 73 13 Licensed license VBN 3344 73 14 works work NNS 3344 73 15 are be VBP 3344 73 16 not not RB 3344 73 17 owned own VBN 3344 73 18 , , , 3344 73 19 and and CC 3344 73 20 the the DT 3344 73 21 first first JJ 3344 73 22 - - HYPH 3344 73 23 sale sale NN 3344 73 24 doctrine doctrine NN 3344 73 25 is be VBZ 3344 73 26 not not RB 3344 73 27 in in IN 3344 73 28 effect.15 effect.15 NNP 3344 73 29 While while IN 3344 73 30 copyright copyright NN 3344 73 31 is be VBZ 3344 73 32 the the DT 3344 73 33 legal legal JJ 3344 73 34 foundation foundation NN 3344 73 35 of of IN 3344 73 36 licenses license NNS 3344 73 37 ( ( -LRB- 3344 73 38 i.e. i.e. FW 3344 73 39 , , , 3344 73 40 works work NNS 3344 73 41 can can MD 3344 73 42 be be VB 3344 73 43 licensed license VBN 3344 73 44 because because IN 3344 73 45 licensors licensor NNS 3344 73 46 own own VBP 3344 73 47 the the DT 3344 73 48 copyright copyright NN 3344 73 49 to to IN 3344 73 50 those those DT 3344 73 51 works work NNS 3344 73 52 ) ) -RRB- 3344 73 53 , , , 3344 73 54 licenses license NNS 3344 73 55 are be VBP 3344 73 56 contracts contract NNS 3344 73 57 , , , 3344 73 58 and and CC 3344 73 59 contract contract NN 3344 73 60 provisions provision NNS 3344 73 61 trump trump VBP 3344 73 62 user user NN 3344 73 63 - - HYPH 3344 73 64 favorable favorable JJ 3344 73 65 copyright copyright NN 3344 73 66 provisions provision NNS 3344 73 67 , , , 3344 73 68 such such JJ 3344 73 69 as as IN 3344 73 70 fair fair JJ 3344 73 71 use use NN 3344 73 72 , , , 3344 73 73 if if IN 3344 73 74 the the DT 3344 73 75 licensor licensor NN 3344 73 76 chooses choose VBZ 3344 73 77 to to TO 3344 73 78 negate negate VB 3344 73 79 them -PRON- PRP 3344 73 80 in in IN 3344 73 81 a a DT 3344 73 82 license license NN 3344 73 83 . . . 3344 74 1 Criminal criminal JJ 3344 74 2 and and CC 3344 74 3 civil civil JJ 3344 74 4 penalties penalty NNS 3344 74 5 In in IN 3344 74 6 1790 1790 CD 3344 74 7 there there EX 3344 74 8 were be VBD 3344 74 9 civil civil JJ 3344 74 10 penalties penalty NNS 3344 74 11 for for IN 3344 74 12 copyright copyright NN 3344 74 13 infringe- infringe- NNP 3344 74 14 ment ment NNP 3344 74 15 ( ( -LRB- 3344 74 16 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 74 17 , , , 3344 74 18 statutory statutory JJ 3344 74 19 fines fine NNS 3344 74 20 of of IN 3344 74 21 “ " `` 3344 74 22 50 50 CD 3344 74 23 cents cent NNS 3344 74 24 per per IN 3344 74 25 sheet sheet NN 3344 74 26 found find VBN 3344 74 27 in in IN 3344 74 28 the the DT 3344 74 29 infringer infringer NN 3344 74 30 ’s 's NNP 3344 74 31 possession”).16 possession”).16 NNP 3344 74 32 Now now RB 3344 74 33 there there EX 3344 74 34 are be VBP 3344 74 35 criminal criminal JJ 3344 74 36 copyright copyright NN 3344 74 37 penalties penalty NNS 3344 74 38 , , , 3344 74 39 including include VBG 3344 74 40 felony felony NN 3344 74 41 violations violation NNS 3344 74 42 that that WDT 3344 74 43 can can MD 3344 74 44 result result VB 3344 74 45 in in IN 3344 74 46 a a DT 3344 74 47 maximum maximum NN 3344 74 48 of of IN 3344 74 49 five five CD 3344 74 50 years year NNS 3344 74 51 of of IN 3344 74 52 imprisonment imprisonment NN 3344 74 53 and and CC 3344 74 54 fines fine NNS 3344 74 55 as as RB 3344 74 56 high high JJ 3344 74 57 as as IN 3344 74 58 $ $ $ 3344 74 59 250,000 250,000 CD 3344 74 60 for for IN 3344 74 61 first first JJ 3344 74 62 - - HYPH 3344 74 63 time time NN 3344 74 64 offenders offender NNS 3344 74 65 ; ; , 3344 74 66 civil civil JJ 3344 74 67 statutory statutory JJ 3344 74 68 fines fine NNS 3344 74 69 that that WDT 3344 74 70 can can MD 3344 74 71 range range VB 3344 74 72 as as RB 3344 74 73 high high JJ 3344 74 74 as as IN 3344 74 75 $ $ $ 3344 74 76 150,000 150,000 CD 3344 74 77 per per IN 3344 74 78 infringement infringement NN 3344 74 79 ( ( -LRB- 3344 74 80 if if IN 3344 74 81 infringement infringement NN 3344 74 82 is be VBZ 3344 74 83 “ " `` 3344 74 84 willful willful JJ 3344 74 85 ” " '' 3344 74 86 ) ) -RRB- 3344 74 87 , , , 3344 74 88 and and CC 3344 74 89 other other JJ 3344 74 90 penalties.17 penalties.17 NNP 3344 74 91 Once once IN 3344 74 92 the the DT 3344 74 93 copyright copyright NN 3344 74 94 implications implication NNS 3344 74 95 of of IN 3344 74 96 digital digital JJ 3344 74 97 media medium NNS 3344 74 98 and and CC 3344 74 99 the the DT 3344 74 100 Internet internet NN 3344 74 101 sunk sink VBN 3344 74 102 in in IN 3344 74 103 , , , 3344 74 104 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 74 105 and and CC 3344 74 106 information information NN 3344 74 107 companies company NNS 3344 74 108 were be VBD 3344 74 109 deeply deeply RB 3344 74 110 concerned concerned JJ 3344 74 111 : : : 3344 74 112 digital digital JJ 3344 74 113 technologies technology NNS 3344 74 114 made make VBD 3344 74 115 creating create VBG 3344 74 116 perfect perfect JJ 3344 74 117 copies copy NNS 3344 74 118 effortless effortless NN 3344 74 119 , , , 3344 74 120 and and CC 3344 74 121 the the DT 3344 74 122 Internet internet NN 3344 74 123 provided provide VBD 3344 74 124 a a DT 3344 74 125 free free JJ 3344 74 126 ( ( -LRB- 3344 74 127 or or CC 3344 74 128 low low JJ 3344 74 129 - - HYPH 3344 74 130 cost cost NN 3344 74 131 ) ) -RRB- 3344 74 132 way way NN 3344 74 133 to to TO 3344 74 134 distribute distribute VB 3344 74 135 content content NN 3344 74 136 globally globally RB 3344 74 137 . . . 3344 75 1 Congress Congress NNP 3344 75 2 , , , 3344 75 3 primarily primarily RB 3344 75 4 spurred spur VBD 3344 75 5 on on RP 3344 75 6 by by IN 3344 75 7 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 75 8 companies company NNS 3344 75 9 , , , 3344 75 10 passed pass VBD 3344 75 11 several several JJ 3344 75 12 laws law NNS 3344 75 13 aimed aim VBN 3344 75 14 at at IN 3344 75 15 curtailing curtailing NN 3344 75 16 perceived perceive VBN 3344 75 17 digital digital NNP 3344 75 18 “ " `` 3344 75 19 theft theft NNP 3344 75 20 ” " '' 3344 75 21 through through IN 3344 75 22 criminal criminal JJ 3344 75 23 penalties penalty NNS 3344 75 24 . . . 3344 76 1 Under under IN 3344 76 2 the the DT 3344 76 3 1997 1997 CD 3344 76 4 No No NNP 3344 76 5 Electronic Electronic NNP 3344 76 6 Theft Theft NNP 3344 76 7 ( ( -LRB- 3344 76 8 NET NET NNP 3344 76 9 ) ) -RRB- 3344 76 10 Act Act NNP 3344 76 11 , , , 3344 76 12 copyright copyright NN 3344 76 13 infringers infringer NNS 3344 76 14 face face VBP 3344 76 15 “ " `` 3344 76 16 up up IN 3344 76 17 to to TO 3344 76 18 3 3 CD 3344 76 19 years year NNS 3344 76 20 in in IN 3344 76 21 prison prison NN 3344 76 22 and/or and/or CC 3344 76 23 $ $ $ 3344 76 24 250,000 250,000 CD 3344 76 25 fines fine NNS 3344 76 26 , , , 3344 76 27 ” " '' 3344 76 28 even even RB 3344 76 29 for for IN 3344 76 30 noncommercial noncommercial JJ 3344 76 31 infringement.18 infringement.18 NNP 3344 76 32 Under under IN 3344 76 33 the the DT 3344 76 34 1998 1998 CD 3344 76 35 Digital Digital NNP 3344 76 36 Millennium Millennium NNP 3344 76 37 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 76 38 Act Act NNP 3344 76 39 ( ( -LRB- 3344 76 40 DMCA DMCA NNP 3344 76 41 ) ) -RRB- 3344 76 42 , , , 3344 76 43 those those DT 3344 76 44 who who WP 3344 76 45 defeat defeat VBP 3344 76 46 technological technological JJ 3344 76 47 mechanisms mechanism NNS 3344 76 48 that that WDT 3344 76 49 control control VBP 3344 76 50 access access NN 3344 76 51 to to IN 3344 76 52 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 76 53 works work NNS 3344 76 54 ( ( -LRB- 3344 76 55 a a DT 3344 76 56 process process NN 3344 76 57 called call VBN 3344 76 58 “ " `` 3344 76 59 circum- circum- NNP 3344 76 60 vention vention NNP 3344 76 61 ” " '' 3344 76 62 ) ) -RRB- 3344 76 63 face face VB 3344 76 64 a a DT 3344 76 65 maximum maximum NN 3344 76 66 of of IN 3344 76 67 five five CD 3344 76 68 years year NNS 3344 76 69 in in IN 3344 76 70 prison prison NN 3344 76 71 and and CC 3344 76 72 $ $ $ 3344 76 73 500,000 500,000 CD 3344 76 74 in in IN 3344 76 75 fines.19 fines.19 NNP 3344 76 76 Effect Effect NNP 3344 76 77 of of IN 3344 76 78 copyright copyright NN 3344 76 79 on on IN 3344 76 80 average average JJ 3344 76 81 citizens citizen NNS 3344 76 82 In in IN 3344 76 83 1790 1790 CD 3344 76 84 , , , 3344 76 85 copyright copyright NN 3344 76 86 law law NN 3344 76 87 had have VBD 3344 76 88 little little JJ 3344 76 89 effect effect NN 3344 76 90 on on IN 3344 76 91 citizens citizen NNS 3344 76 92 . . . 3344 77 1 The the DT 3344 77 2 average average JJ 3344 77 3 person person NN 3344 77 4 was be VBD 3344 77 5 not not RB 3344 77 6 an an DT 3344 77 7 author author NN 3344 77 8 or or CC 3344 77 9 publisher publisher NN 3344 77 10 , , , 3344 77 11 private private JJ 3344 77 12 use use NN 3344 77 13 of of IN 3344 77 14 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 77 15 materials material NNS 3344 77 16 was be VBD 3344 77 17 basically basically RB 3344 77 18 unregulated unregulated JJ 3344 77 19 , , , 3344 77 20 the the DT 3344 77 21 public public JJ 3344 77 22 domain domain NN 3344 77 23 was be VBD 3344 77 24 healthy healthy JJ 3344 77 25 , , , 3344 77 26 and and CC 3344 77 27 many many JJ 3344 77 28 types type NNS 3344 77 29 of of IN 3344 77 30 works work NNS 3344 77 31 were be VBD 3344 77 32 not not RB 3344 77 33 covered cover VBN 3344 77 34 by by IN 3344 77 35 copyright copyright NN 3344 77 36 at at RB 3344 77 37 all all RB 3344 77 38 . . . 3344 78 1 In in IN 3344 78 2 2006 2006 CD 3344 78 3 , , , 3344 78 4 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 78 5 virtually virtually RB 3344 78 6 every every DT 3344 78 7 type type NN 3344 78 8 of of IN 3344 78 9 work work NN 3344 78 10 imaginable imaginable NN 3344 78 11 is be VBZ 3344 78 12 under under IN 3344 78 13 automatic automatic JJ 3344 78 14 copyright copyright NN 3344 78 15 protection protection NN 3344 78 16 for for IN 3344 78 17 extended extended JJ 3344 78 18 periods period NNS 3344 78 19 of of IN 3344 78 20 time time NN 3344 78 21 ; ; : 3344 78 22 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 78 23 private private JJ 3344 78 24 use use NN 3344 78 25 of of IN 3344 78 26 digital digital JJ 3344 78 27 works work NNS 3344 78 28 is be VBZ 3344 78 29 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 78 30 visible visible JJ 3344 78 31 and and CC 3344 78 32 of of IN 3344 78 33 concern concern NN 3344 78 34 to to IN 3344 78 35 copyright copyright NN 3344 78 36 holders holder NNS 3344 78 37 ; ; : 3344 78 38 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 78 39 the the DT 3344 78 40 public public JJ 3344 78 41 domain domain NN 3344 78 42 is be VBZ 3344 78 43 endangered endanger VBN 3344 78 44 ; ; : 3344 78 45 and and CC 3344 78 46 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 78 47 ordinary ordinary JJ 3344 78 48 citizens citizen NNS 3344 78 49 are be VBP 3344 78 50 being be VBG 3344 78 51 prosecuted prosecute VBN 3344 78 52 as as IN 3344 78 53 “ " `` 3344 78 54 pirates pirate NNS 3344 78 55 ” " '' 3344 78 56 under under IN 3344 78 57 draconian draconian NNP 3344 78 58 statutory statutory JJ 3344 78 59 and and CC 3344 78 60 criminal criminal JJ 3344 78 61 penalties penalty NNS 3344 78 62 . . . 3344 79 1 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 3344 79 2 DYSTOPIA DYSTOPIA NNP 3344 79 3 | | NNP 3344 79 4 BAILEY BAILEY NNP 3344 79 5 119 119 CD 3344 79 6 Regarding regard VBG 3344 79 7 this this DT 3344 79 8 development development NN 3344 79 9 , , , 3344 79 10 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 79 11 says say VBZ 3344 79 12 : : : 3344 79 13 For for IN 3344 79 14 the the DT 3344 79 15 first first JJ 3344 79 16 time time NN 3344 79 17 in in IN 3344 79 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 3344 79 19 tradition tradition NN 3344 79 20 , , , 3344 79 21 the the DT 3344 79 22 ordinary ordinary JJ 3344 79 23 ways way NNS 3344 79 24 in in IN 3344 79 25 which which WDT 3344 79 26 individuals individual NNS 3344 79 27 create create VBP 3344 79 28 and and CC 3344 79 29 share share VBP 3344 79 30 culture culture NN 3344 79 31 fall fall NN 3344 79 32 within within IN 3344 79 33 the the DT 3344 79 34 reach reach NN 3344 79 35 of of IN 3344 79 36 the the DT 3344 79 37 regulation regulation NN 3344 79 38 of of IN 3344 79 39 the the DT 3344 79 40 law law NN 3344 79 41 , , , 3344 79 42 which which WDT 3344 79 43 has have VBZ 3344 79 44 expanded expand VBN 3344 79 45 to to TO 3344 79 46 draw draw VB 3344 79 47 within within IN 3344 79 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 79 49 control control NN 3344 79 50 a a DT 3344 79 51 vast vast JJ 3344 79 52 amount amount NN 3344 79 53 of of IN 3344 79 54 culture culture NN 3344 79 55 and and CC 3344 79 56 creativity creativity NN 3344 79 57 that that WDT 3344 79 58 it -PRON- PRP 3344 79 59 never never RB 3344 79 60 reached reach VBD 3344 79 61 before before RB 3344 79 62 . . . 3344 80 1 The the DT 3344 80 2 technology technology NN 3344 80 3 that that WDT 3344 80 4 preserved preserve VBD 3344 80 5 the the DT 3344 80 6 balance balance NN 3344 80 7 of of IN 3344 80 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 3344 80 9 history history NN 3344 80 10 — — : 3344 80 11 between between IN 3344 80 12 uses use NNS 3344 80 13 of of IN 3344 80 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 3344 80 15 culture culture NN 3344 80 16 that that WDT 3344 80 17 were be VBD 3344 80 18 free free JJ 3344 80 19 and and CC 3344 80 20 uses use NNS 3344 80 21 of of IN 3344 80 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 3344 80 23 culture culture NN 3344 80 24 that that WDT 3344 80 25 were be VBD 3344 80 26 only only RB 3344 80 27 upon upon IN 3344 80 28 permission permission NN 3344 80 29 — — : 3344 80 30 has have VBZ 3344 80 31 been be VBN 3344 80 32 undone undo VBN 3344 80 33 . . . 3344 81 1 The the DT 3344 81 2 consequence consequence NN 3344 81 3 is be VBZ 3344 81 4 that that IN 3344 81 5 we -PRON- PRP 3344 81 6 are be VBP 3344 81 7 less less JJR 3344 81 8 and and CC 3344 81 9 less less RBR 3344 81 10 a a DT 3344 81 11 free free JJ 3344 81 12 culture culture NN 3344 81 13 , , , 3344 81 14 more more JJR 3344 81 15 and and CC 3344 81 16 more more RBR 3344 81 17 a a DT 3344 81 18 permission permission NN 3344 81 19 culture.20 culture.20 NNP 3344 81 20 How how WRB 3344 81 21 has have VBZ 3344 81 22 copyright copyright NN 3344 81 23 changed change VBN 3344 81 24 since since IN 3344 81 25 the the DT 3344 81 26 days day NNS 3344 81 27 of of IN 3344 81 28 the the DT 3344 81 29 founding found VBG 3344 81 30 fathers father NNS 3344 81 31 ? ? . 3344 82 1 As as IN 3344 82 2 we -PRON- PRP 3344 82 3 have have VBP 3344 82 4 seen see VBN 3344 82 5 , , , 3344 82 6 there there EX 3344 82 7 has have VBZ 3344 82 8 been be VBN 3344 82 9 a a DT 3344 82 10 shift shift NN 3344 82 11 in in IN 3344 82 12 copyright copyright NN 3344 82 13 law law NN 3344 82 14 ( ( -LRB- 3344 82 15 and and CC 3344 82 16 social social JJ 3344 82 17 perceptions perception NNS 3344 82 18 of of IN 3344 82 19 it -PRON- PRP 3344 82 20 ) ) -RRB- 3344 82 21 from from IN 3344 82 22 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 82 23 promoting promote VBG 3344 82 24 progress progress NN 3344 82 25 to to IN 3344 82 26 protecting protect VBG 3344 82 27 intellectual intellectual JJ 3344 82 28 prop- prop- NNS 3344 82 29 erty erty NN 3344 82 30 owners owner NNS 3344 82 31 ’ ’ POS 3344 82 32 “ " `` 3344 82 33 rights right NNS 3344 82 34 ” " '' 3344 82 35 ; ; : 3344 82 36 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 82 37 from from IN 3344 82 38 covering cover VBG 3344 82 39 limited limited JJ 3344 82 40 types type NNS 3344 82 41 of of IN 3344 82 42 works work NNS 3344 82 43 to to IN 3344 82 44 covering cover VBG 3344 82 45 virtually virtually RB 3344 82 46 all all DT 3344 82 47 types type NNS 3344 82 48 of of IN 3344 82 49 works work NNS 3344 82 50 ; ; : 3344 82 51 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 82 52 from from IN 3344 82 53 granting grant VBG 3344 82 54 only only JJ 3344 82 55 basic basic JJ 3344 82 56 reproduction reproduction NN 3344 82 57 and and CC 3344 82 58 distribu- distribu- JJ 3344 82 59 tion tion NN 3344 82 60 rights right NNS 3344 82 61 to to IN 3344 82 62 granting grant VBG 3344 82 63 a a DT 3344 82 64 much much RB 3344 82 65 wider wide JJR 3344 82 66 range range NN 3344 82 67 of of IN 3344 82 68 rights right NNS 3344 82 69 ; ; : 3344 82 70 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 82 71 from from IN 3344 82 72 offering offer VBG 3344 82 73 a a DT 3344 82 74 relatively relatively RB 3344 82 75 short short JJ 3344 82 76 duration duration NN 3344 82 77 of of IN 3344 82 78 protection protection NN 3344 82 79 to to IN 3344 82 80 offering offer VBG 3344 82 81 a a DT 3344 82 82 relatively relatively RB 3344 82 83 long long JJ 3344 82 84 ( ( -LRB- 3344 82 85 potentially potentially RB 3344 82 86 perpetual perpetual JJ 3344 82 87 ) ) -RRB- 3344 82 88 one one CD 3344 82 89 ; ; : 3344 82 90 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 82 91 from from IN 3344 82 92 requiring require VBG 3344 82 93 registration registration NN 3344 82 94 to to IN 3344 82 95 providing provide VBG 3344 82 96 automatic automatic JJ 3344 82 97 copyright copyright NN 3344 82 98 ; ; : 3344 82 99 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 82 100 from from IN 3344 82 101 drafting draft VBG 3344 82 102 laws law NNS 3344 82 103 in in IN 3344 82 104 Congress Congress NNP 3344 82 105 to to IN 3344 82 106 drafting draft VBG 3344 82 107 laws law NNS 3344 82 108 in in IN 3344 82 109 work work NN 3344 82 110 groups group NNS 3344 82 111 of of IN 3344 82 112 interested interested JJ 3344 82 113 parties party NNS 3344 82 114 dominated dominate VBN 3344 82 115 by by IN 3344 82 116 com- com- NN 3344 82 117 mercial mercial JJ 3344 82 118 representatives representative NNS 3344 82 119 ; ; : 3344 82 120 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 82 121 from from IN 3344 82 122 making make VBG 3344 82 123 infrequent infrequent JJ 3344 82 124 extensions extension NNS 3344 82 125 of of IN 3344 82 126 copyright copyright NN 3344 82 127 duration duration NN 3344 82 128 to to IN 3344 82 129 making make VBG 3344 82 130 frequent frequent JJ 3344 82 131 ones one NNS 3344 82 132 ; ; : 3344 82 133 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 82 134 from from IN 3344 82 135 selling sell VBG 3344 82 136 works work NNS 3344 82 137 to to IN 3344 82 138 licensing license VBG 3344 82 139 them -PRON- PRP 3344 82 140 ; ; : 3344 82 141 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 82 142 from from IN 3344 82 143 relatively relatively RB 3344 82 144 modest modest JJ 3344 82 145 civil civil JJ 3344 82 146 penalties penalty NNS 3344 82 147 to to IN 3344 82 148 severe severe JJ 3344 82 149 civil civil JJ 3344 82 150 and and CC 3344 82 151 criminal criminal JJ 3344 82 152 penalties penalty NNS 3344 82 153 ; ; : 3344 82 154 and and CC 3344 82 155 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 82 156 from from IN 3344 82 157 ignoring ignore VBG 3344 82 158 ordinary ordinary JJ 3344 82 159 citizens citizen NNS 3344 82 160 ’ ’ POS 3344 82 161 typical typical JJ 3344 82 162 use use NN 3344 82 163 of of IN 3344 82 164 copy- copy- RB 3344 82 165 righted right VBN 3344 82 166 works work NNS 3344 82 167 to to IN 3344 82 168 branding brand VBG 3344 82 169 them -PRON- PRP 3344 82 170 as as IN 3344 82 171 pirates pirate NNS 3344 82 172 and and CC 3344 82 173 prosecut- prosecut- VBZ 3344 82 174 ing e VBG 3344 82 175 them -PRON- PRP 3344 82 176 with with IN 3344 82 177 lawsuits lawsuit NNS 3344 82 178 . . . 3344 83 1 ( ( -LRB- 3344 83 2 Regarding regard VBG 3344 83 3 lawsuits lawsuit NNS 3344 83 4 filed file VBN 3344 83 5 by by IN 3344 83 6 the the DT 3344 83 7 Recording Recording NNP 3344 83 8 Industry Industry NNP 3344 83 9 Association Association NNP 3344 83 10 of of IN 3344 83 11 America America NNP 3344 83 12 against against IN 3344 83 13 four four CD 3344 83 14 students student NNS 3344 83 15 , , , 3344 83 16 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 83 17 notes note VBZ 3344 83 18 : : : 3344 83 19 “ " `` 3344 83 20 If if IN 3344 83 21 you -PRON- PRP 3344 83 22 added add VBD 3344 83 23 up up RP 3344 83 24 the the DT 3344 83 25 claims claim NNS 3344 83 26 , , , 3344 83 27 these these DT 3344 83 28 four four CD 3344 83 29 lawsuits lawsuit NNS 3344 83 30 were be VBD 3344 83 31 asking ask VBG 3344 83 32 courts court NNS 3344 83 33 in in IN 3344 83 34 the the DT 3344 83 35 United United NNP 3344 83 36 States States NNP 3344 83 37 to to TO 3344 83 38 award award VB 3344 83 39 the the DT 3344 83 40 plaintiffs plaintiff NNS 3344 83 41 close close JJ 3344 83 42 to to IN 3344 83 43 $ $ $ 3344 83 44 100 100 CD 3344 83 45 billion billion CD 3344 83 46 — — : 3344 83 47 six six CD 3344 83 48 times time NNS 3344 83 49 the the DT 3344 83 50 total total JJ 3344 83 51 profit profit NN 3344 83 52 of of IN 3344 83 53 the the DT 3344 83 54 film film NN 3344 83 55 industry industry NN 3344 83 56 in in IN 3344 83 57 2001.”)21 2001.”)21 CD 3344 83 58 Complicating complicate VBG 3344 83 59 this this DT 3344 83 60 situation situation NN 3344 83 61 further far RBR 3344 83 62 is be VBZ 3344 83 63 intense intense JJ 3344 83 64 consolida- consolida- NN 3344 83 65 tion tion NN 3344 83 66 and and CC 3344 83 67 increased increase VBN 3344 83 68 vertical vertical JJ 3344 83 69 integration integration NN 3344 83 70 in in IN 3344 83 71 the the DT 3344 83 72 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 83 73 , , , 3344 83 74 information information NN 3344 83 75 , , , 3344 83 76 telecommunications telecommunication NNS 3344 83 77 , , , 3344 83 78 and and CC 3344 83 79 other other JJ 3344 83 80 high high JJ 3344 83 81 - - HYPH 3344 83 82 tech tech NN 3344 83 83 industries industry NNS 3344 83 84 involved involve VBN 3344 83 85 in in IN 3344 83 86 the the DT 3344 83 87 Internet.22 internet.22 XX 3344 83 88 This this DT 3344 83 89 vertical vertical JJ 3344 83 90 integra- integra- NN 3344 83 91 tion tion NN 3344 83 92 has have VBZ 3344 83 93 implications implication NNS 3344 83 94 for for IN 3344 83 95 what what WP 3344 83 96 can can MD 3344 83 97 be be VB 3344 83 98 published publish VBN 3344 83 99 and and CC 3344 83 100 the the DT 3344 83 101 free free JJ 3344 83 102 flow flow NN 3344 83 103 of of IN 3344 83 104 information information NN 3344 83 105 . . . 3344 84 1 For for IN 3344 84 2 example example NN 3344 84 3 , , , 3344 84 4 a a DT 3344 84 5 company company NN 3344 84 6 that that WDT 3344 84 7 publishes publish VBZ 3344 84 8 books book NNS 3344 84 9 and and CC 3344 84 10 magazines magazine NNS 3344 84 11 , , , 3344 84 12 produces produce VBZ 3344 84 13 films film NNS 3344 84 14 and and CC 3344 84 15 television television NN 3344 84 16 pro- pro- NN 3344 84 17 grams gram NNS 3344 84 18 , , , 3344 84 19 provides provide VBZ 3344 84 20 Internet internet NN 3344 84 21 access access NN 3344 84 22 and and CC 3344 84 23 digital digital JJ 3344 84 24 content content NN 3344 84 25 , , , 3344 84 26 and and CC 3344 84 27 provides provide VBZ 3344 84 28 cable cable NN 3344 84 29 television television NN 3344 84 30 services service NNS 3344 84 31 ( ( -LRB- 3344 84 32 including include VBG 3344 84 33 broadband broadband NN 3344 84 34 Internet internet NN 3344 84 35 access access NN 3344 84 36 ) ) -RRB- 3344 84 37 has have VBZ 3344 84 38 different different JJ 3344 84 39 corporate corporate JJ 3344 84 40 interests interest NNS 3344 84 41 than than IN 3344 84 42 a a DT 3344 84 43 company company NN 3344 84 44 that that WDT 3344 84 45 performs perform VBZ 3344 84 46 a a DT 3344 84 47 single single JJ 3344 84 48 function function NN 3344 84 49 . . . 3344 85 1 These these DT 3344 85 2 interrelated interrelated JJ 3344 85 3 interests interest NNS 3344 85 4 may may MD 3344 85 5 affect affect VB 3344 85 6 not not RB 3344 85 7 only only RB 3344 85 8 what what WDT 3344 85 9 information information NN 3344 85 10 is be VBZ 3344 85 11 produced produce VBN 3344 85 12 and and CC 3344 85 13 whether whether IN 3344 85 14 competing compete VBG 3344 85 15 information information NN 3344 85 16 and and CC 3344 85 17 services service NNS 3344 85 18 are be VBP 3344 85 19 freely freely RB 3344 85 20 available available JJ 3344 85 21 through through IN 3344 85 22 controlled control VBN 3344 85 23 digital digital JJ 3344 85 24 distribution distribution NN 3344 85 25 channels channel NNS 3344 85 26 , , , 3344 85 27 but but CC 3344 85 28 corporate corporate JJ 3344 85 29 perceptions perception NNS 3344 85 30 of of IN 3344 85 31 copyright copyright NN 3344 85 32 issues issue NNS 3344 85 33 as as RB 3344 85 34 well well RB 3344 85 35 . . . 3344 86 1 One one CD 3344 86 2 of of IN 3344 86 3 the the DT 3344 86 4 ironies irony NNS 3344 86 5 of of IN 3344 86 6 the the DT 3344 86 7 current current JJ 3344 86 8 copyright copyright NN 3344 86 9 situation situation NN 3344 86 10 is be VBZ 3344 86 11 this this DT 3344 86 12 : : : 3344 86 13 if if IN 3344 86 14 creative creative JJ 3344 86 15 works work NNS 3344 86 16 are be VBP 3344 86 17 by by IN 3344 86 18 nature nature NN 3344 86 19 property property NN 3344 86 20 , , , 3344 86 21 and and CC 3344 86 22 stealing steal VBG 3344 86 23 property property NN 3344 86 24 is be VBZ 3344 86 25 ( ( -LRB- 3344 86 26 and and CC 3344 86 27 has have VBZ 3344 86 28 always always RB 3344 86 29 been be VBN 3344 86 30 ) ) -RRB- 3344 86 31 wrong wrong JJ 3344 86 32 , , , 3344 86 33 then then RB 3344 86 34 some some DT 3344 86 35 of of IN 3344 86 36 the the DT 3344 86 37 very very JJ 3344 86 38 industries industry NNS 3344 86 39 that that WDT 3344 86 40 are be VBP 3344 86 41 demanding demand VBG 3344 86 42 that that IN 3344 86 43 this this DT 3344 86 44 truth truth NN 3344 86 45 be be VB 3344 86 46 embodied embody VBN 3344 86 47 in in IN 3344 86 48 copyright copyright NN 3344 86 49 law law NN 3344 86 50 have have VBP 3344 86 51 , , , 3344 86 52 in in IN 3344 86 53 the the DT 3344 86 54 past past NN 3344 86 55 , , , 3344 86 56 been be VBN 3344 86 57 pirates pirate NNS 3344 86 58 themselves -PRON- PRP 3344 86 59 , , , 3344 86 60 even even RB 3344 86 61 though though IN 3344 86 62 certain certain JJ 3344 86 63 acts act NNS 3344 86 64 of of IN 3344 86 65 piracy piracy NN 3344 86 66 may may MD 3344 86 67 have have VB 3344 86 68 been be VBN 3344 86 69 legal legal JJ 3344 86 70 ( ( -LRB- 3344 86 71 or or CC 3344 86 72 appeared appear VBD 3344 86 73 to to TO 3344 86 74 be be VB 3344 86 75 legal legal JJ 3344 86 76 ) ) -RRB- 3344 86 77 under under IN 3344 86 78 then then RB 3344 86 79 - - HYPH 3344 86 80 existing exist VBG 3344 86 81 copyright copyright NN 3344 86 82 laws.23 laws.23 NNP 3344 86 83 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 86 84 states state VBZ 3344 86 85 : : : 3344 86 86 If if IN 3344 86 87 “ " `` 3344 86 88 piracy piracy NN 3344 86 89 ” " '' 3344 86 90 means mean VBZ 3344 86 91 using use VBG 3344 86 92 the the DT 3344 86 93 creative creative JJ 3344 86 94 property property NN 3344 86 95 of of IN 3344 86 96 others other NNS 3344 86 97 without without IN 3344 86 98 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 86 99 permission permission NN 3344 86 100 — — : 3344 86 101 if if IN 3344 86 102 “ " `` 3344 86 103 if if IN 3344 86 104 value value NN 3344 86 105 , , , 3344 86 106 then then RB 3344 86 107 right right UH 3344 86 108 ” " '' 3344 86 109 is be VBZ 3344 86 110 true true JJ 3344 86 111 — — : 3344 86 112 then then RB 3344 86 113 the the DT 3344 86 114 history history NN 3344 86 115 of of IN 3344 86 116 the the DT 3344 86 117 content content NN 3344 86 118 industry industry NN 3344 86 119 is be VBZ 3344 86 120 a a DT 3344 86 121 his- his- NN 3344 86 122 tory tory NN 3344 86 123 of of IN 3344 86 124 piracy piracy NN 3344 86 125 . . . 3344 87 1 Every every DT 3344 87 2 important important JJ 3344 87 3 sector sector NN 3344 87 4 of of IN 3344 87 5 “ " `` 3344 87 6 big big JJ 3344 87 7 media medium NNS 3344 87 8 ” " '' 3344 87 9 today today NN 3344 87 10 — — : 3344 87 11 film film NN 3344 87 12 , , , 3344 87 13 records record NNS 3344 87 14 , , , 3344 87 15 radio radio NN 3344 87 16 , , , 3344 87 17 and and CC 3344 87 18 cable cable NN 3344 87 19 TV tv NN 3344 87 20 — — : 3344 87 21 was be VBD 3344 87 22 born bear VBN 3344 87 23 of of IN 3344 87 24 a a DT 3344 87 25 kind kind NN 3344 87 26 of of IN 3344 87 27 piracy piracy NN 3344 87 28 so so RB 3344 87 29 defined define VBN 3344 87 30 . . . 3344 88 1 The the DT 3344 88 2 consistent consistent JJ 3344 88 3 story story NN 3344 88 4 is be VBZ 3344 88 5 how how WRB 3344 88 6 last last JJ 3344 88 7 generation generation NN 3344 88 8 ’s ’s , 3344 88 9 pirates pirate NNS 3344 88 10 join join VBP 3344 88 11 this this DT 3344 88 12 generation generation NN 3344 88 13 ’s ’s , 3344 88 14 country country NN 3344 88 15 club club NN 3344 88 16 — — : 3344 88 17 until until IN 3344 88 18 now.24 now.24 NNP 3344 88 19 Let let VB 3344 88 20 ’s -PRON- PRP 3344 88 21 take take VB 3344 88 22 a a DT 3344 88 23 simple simple JJ 3344 88 24 case case NN 3344 88 25 : : : 3344 88 26 cable cable NN 3344 88 27 television television NN 3344 88 28 . . . 3344 89 1 Early early JJ 3344 89 2 cable cable NN 3344 89 3 television television NN 3344 89 4 companies company NNS 3344 89 5 used use VBN 3344 89 6 broadcast broadcast NN 3344 89 7 television television NN 3344 89 8 programs program NNS 3344 89 9 without without IN 3344 89 10 compensating compensate VBG 3344 89 11 copyright copyright NN 3344 89 12 owners owner NNS 3344 89 13 , , , 3344 89 14 who who WP 3344 89 15 branded brand VBD 3344 89 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 89 17 actions action NNS 3344 89 18 as as IN 3344 89 19 piracy piracy NN 3344 89 20 and and CC 3344 89 21 filed file VBD 3344 89 22 lawsuits lawsuit NNS 3344 89 23 . . . 3344 90 1 After after IN 3344 90 2 two two CD 3344 90 3 defeats defeat NNS 3344 90 4 in in IN 3344 90 5 the the DT 3344 90 6 Supreme Supreme NNP 3344 90 7 Court Court NNP 3344 90 8 , , , 3344 90 9 broadcast broadcast VBD 3344 90 10 television television NN 3344 90 11 companies company NNS 3344 90 12 won win VBD 3344 90 13 a a DT 3344 90 14 victory victory NN 3344 90 15 ( ( -LRB- 3344 90 16 of of IN 3344 90 17 sorts sort NNS 3344 90 18 ) ) -RRB- 3344 90 19 in in IN 3344 90 20 Congress Congress NNP 3344 90 21 , , , 3344 90 22 which which WDT 3344 90 23 took take VBD 3344 90 24 nearly nearly RB 3344 90 25 thirty thirty CD 3344 90 26 years year NNS 3344 90 27 to to TO 3344 90 28 resolve resolve VB 3344 90 29 the the DT 3344 90 30 matter matter NN 3344 90 31 : : : 3344 90 32 cable cable NN 3344 90 33 television television NN 3344 90 34 companies company NNS 3344 90 35 would would MD 3344 90 36 pay pay VB 3344 90 37 , , , 3344 90 38 but but CC 3344 90 39 not not RB 3344 90 40 what what WP 3344 90 41 broadcast broadcast VBD 3344 90 42 television television NN 3344 90 43 companies company NNS 3344 90 44 wanted want VBD 3344 90 45 ; ; : 3344 90 46 rather rather RB 3344 90 47 they -PRON- PRP 3344 90 48 would would MD 3344 90 49 pay pay VB 3344 90 50 fees fee NNS 3344 90 51 determined determine VBN 3344 90 52 by by IN 3344 90 53 law.25 law.25 NNS 3344 90 54 Of of RB 3344 90 55 course course RB 3344 90 56 , , , 3344 90 57 this this DT 3344 90 58 view view NN 3344 90 59 of of IN 3344 90 60 history history NN 3344 90 61 ( ( -LRB- 3344 90 62 big big JJ 3344 90 63 media medium NNS 3344 90 64 companies company NNS 3344 90 65 as as IN 3344 90 66 pirates pirate NNS 3344 90 67 in in IN 3344 90 68 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 90 69 infancy infancy NN 3344 90 70 ) ) -RRB- 3344 90 71 is be VBZ 3344 90 72 open open JJ 3344 90 73 to to TO 3344 90 74 dispute dispute VB 3344 90 75 . . . 3344 91 1 For for IN 3344 91 2 the the DT 3344 91 3 moment moment NN 3344 91 4 , , , 3344 91 5 let let VB 3344 91 6 ’s -PRON- PRP 3344 91 7 assume assume VB 3344 91 8 that that IN 3344 91 9 it -PRON- PRP 3344 91 10 is be VBZ 3344 91 11 true true JJ 3344 91 12 . . . 3344 92 1 Put put VB 3344 92 2 more more RBR 3344 92 3 gently gently RB 3344 92 4 , , , 3344 92 5 some some DT 3344 92 6 of of IN 3344 92 7 the the DT 3344 92 8 most most RBS 3344 92 9 important important JJ 3344 92 10 media medium NNS 3344 92 11 companies company NNS 3344 92 12 of of IN 3344 92 13 modern modern JJ 3344 92 14 times time NNS 3344 92 15 flourished flourish VBD 3344 92 16 because because RB 3344 92 17 of of IN 3344 92 18 relatively relatively RB 3344 92 19 lax lax JJ 3344 92 20 copyright copyright NN 3344 92 21 control control NN 3344 92 22 , , , 3344 92 23 a a DT 3344 92 24 relatively relatively RB 3344 92 25 rich rich JJ 3344 92 26 public public JJ 3344 92 27 domain domain NN 3344 92 28 , , , 3344 92 29 and and CC 3344 92 30 , , , 3344 92 31 in in IN 3344 92 32 some some DT 3344 92 33 cases case NNS 3344 92 34 , , , 3344 92 35 a a DT 3344 92 36 societal societal JJ 3344 92 37 boon boon NN 3344 92 38 that that WDT 3344 92 39 allowed allow VBD 3344 92 40 them -PRON- PRP 3344 92 41 to to TO 3344 92 42 pay pay VB 3344 92 43 statutory statutory JJ 3344 92 44 license license NN 3344 92 45 fees fee NNS 3344 92 46 — — : 3344 92 47 which which WDT 3344 92 48 are be VBP 3344 92 49 compulsory compulsory JJ 3344 92 50 for for IN 3344 92 51 copyright copyright NN 3344 92 52 owners owner NNS 3344 92 53 — — : 3344 92 54 instead instead RB 3344 92 55 of of IN 3344 92 56 potentially potentially RB 3344 92 57 paying pay VBG 3344 92 58 much much RB 3344 92 59 higher high JJR 3344 92 60 fees fee NNS 3344 92 61 set set VBN 3344 92 62 by by IN 3344 92 63 copyright copyright NN 3344 92 64 owners owner NNS 3344 92 65 or or CC 3344 92 66 being be VBG 3344 92 67 denied deny VBN 3344 92 68 use use NN 3344 92 69 at at RB 3344 92 70 all all RB 3344 92 71 . . . 3344 93 1 Today today NN 3344 93 2 , , , 3344 93 3 the the DT 3344 93 4 very very JJ 3344 93 5 things thing NNS 3344 93 6 that that WDT 3344 93 7 fostered foster VBD 3344 93 8 media medium NNS 3344 93 9 companies company NNS 3344 93 10 ’ ’ POS 3344 93 11 growth growth NN 3344 93 12 are be VBP 3344 93 13 under under IN 3344 93 14 attack attack NN 3344 93 15 by by IN 3344 93 16 them -PRON- PRP 3344 93 17 . . . 3344 94 1 The the DT 3344 94 2 success success NN 3344 94 3 of of IN 3344 94 4 those those DT 3344 94 5 attacks attack NNS 3344 94 6 is be VBZ 3344 94 7 diminishing diminish VBG 3344 94 8 the the DT 3344 94 9 ability ability NN 3344 94 10 of of IN 3344 94 11 new new JJ 3344 94 12 digital digital JJ 3344 94 13 content content NN 3344 94 14 and and CC 3344 94 15 service service NN 3344 94 16 companies company NNS 3344 94 17 to to TO 3344 94 18 flourish flourish VB 3344 94 19 and and CC 3344 94 20 , , , 3344 94 21 in in IN 3344 94 22 the the DT 3344 94 23 long long JJ 3344 94 24 run run NN 3344 94 25 , , , 3344 94 26 may may MD 3344 94 27 diminish diminish VB 3344 94 28 even even RB 3344 94 29 big big JJ 3344 94 30 media medium NNS 3344 94 31 ’s ’s '' 3344 94 32 ability ability NN 3344 94 33 to to TO 3344 94 34 continue continue VB 3344 94 35 to to TO 3344 94 36 thrive thrive VB 3344 94 37 as as IN 3344 94 38 a a DT 3344 94 39 permission permission NN 3344 94 40 culture culture NN 3344 94 41 replaces replace VBZ 3344 94 42 a a DT 3344 94 43 permissive permissive JJ 3344 94 44 culture culture NN 3344 94 45 . . . 3344 95 1 Several several JJ 3344 95 2 prominent prominent JJ 3344 95 3 copyright copyright NN 3344 95 4 scholars scholar NNS 3344 95 5 have have VBP 3344 95 6 suggested suggest VBN 3344 95 7 copyright copyright NN 3344 95 8 reforms reform NNS 3344 95 9 to to TO 3344 95 10 help help VB 3344 95 11 restore restore VB 3344 95 12 balance balance NN 3344 95 13 to to IN 3344 95 14 the the DT 3344 95 15 copyright copyright NN 3344 95 16 system system NN 3344 95 17 . . . 3344 96 1 James James NNP 3344 96 2 Boyle Boyle NNP 3344 96 3 , , , 3344 96 4 professor professor NN 3344 96 5 of of IN 3344 96 6 law law NN 3344 96 7 at at IN 3344 96 8 the the DT 3344 96 9 Duke Duke NNP 3344 96 10 University University NNP 3344 96 11 Law Law NNP 3344 96 12 School School NNP 3344 96 13 , , , 3344 96 14 recommends recommend VBZ 3344 96 15 a a DT 3344 96 16 twenty twenty CD 3344 96 17 - - HYPH 3344 96 18 year year NN 3344 96 19 copyright copyright NN 3344 96 20 term term NN 3344 96 21 with with IN 3344 96 22 “ " `` 3344 96 23 a a DT 3344 96 24 broadly broadly RB 3344 96 25 defined define VBN 3344 96 26 fair fair JJ 3344 96 27 use use NN 3344 96 28 protection protection NN 3344 96 29 for for IN 3344 96 30 journalis- journalis- NNP 3344 96 31 tic tic NNP 3344 96 32 , , , 3344 96 33 teaching teaching NN 3344 96 34 , , , 3344 96 35 and and CC 3344 96 36 parodic parodic JJ 3344 96 37 uses use NNS 3344 96 38 — — : 3344 96 39 provided provide VBN 3344 96 40 that that IN 3344 96 41 those those DT 3344 96 42 uses use NNS 3344 96 43 were be VBD 3344 96 44 not not RB 3344 96 45 judged judge VBN 3344 96 46 to to TO 3344 96 47 be be VB 3344 96 48 in in IN 3344 96 49 bad bad JJ 3344 96 50 faith faith NN 3344 96 51 by by IN 3344 96 52 a a DT 3344 96 53 jury jury NN 3344 96 54 applying apply VBG 3344 96 55 the the DT 3344 96 56 ‘ ' `` 3344 96 57 beyond beyond IN 3344 96 58 a a DT 3344 96 59 reasonable reasonable JJ 3344 96 60 doubt doubt NN 3344 96 61 ’ ' '' 3344 96 62 standard standard NN 3344 96 63 . . . 3344 96 64 ”26 ”26 NNP 3344 96 65 120 120 CD 3344 96 66 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3344 96 67 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3344 96 68 AND and CC 3344 96 69 LIBRARIES library NNS 3344 96 70 | | NNP 3344 96 71 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3344 96 72 2006 2006 CD 3344 96 73 William William NNP 3344 96 74 W. W. NNP 3344 96 75 Fisher Fisher NNP 3344 96 76 III III NNP 3344 96 77 , , , 3344 96 78 Hale Hale NNP 3344 96 79 and and CC 3344 96 80 Dorr Dorr NNP 3344 96 81 Professor Professor NNP 3344 96 82 of of IN 3344 96 83 Intellectual Intellectual NNP 3344 96 84 Property Property NNP 3344 96 85 Law Law NNP 3344 96 86 at at IN 3344 96 87 Harvard Harvard NNP 3344 96 88 University University NNP 3344 96 89 Law Law NNP 3344 96 90 School School NNP 3344 96 91 , , , 3344 96 92 suggests suggest VBZ 3344 96 93 that that IN 3344 96 94 “ " `` 3344 96 95 we -PRON- PRP 3344 96 96 replace replace VBP 3344 96 97 major major JJ 3344 96 98 portions portion NNS 3344 96 99 of of IN 3344 96 100 the the DT 3344 96 101 copyright copyright NN 3344 96 102 and and CC 3344 96 103 encryption encryption NN 3344 96 104 - - HYPH 3344 96 105 reinforcement reinforcement NN 3344 96 106 models model NNS 3344 96 107 with with IN 3344 96 108 . . . 3344 97 1 . . . 3344 98 1 . . . 3344 99 1 a a DT 3344 99 2 governmentally governmentally RB 3344 99 3 administered administer VBN 3344 99 4 reward reward NN 3344 99 5 system system NN 3344 99 6 ” " '' 3344 99 7 that that WDT 3344 99 8 would would MD 3344 99 9 put put VB 3344 99 10 in in IN 3344 99 11 place place NN 3344 99 12 new new JJ 3344 99 13 taxes taxis NNS 3344 99 14 and and CC 3344 99 15 compensate compensate NN 3344 99 16 registered register VBN 3344 99 17 copyright copyright NN 3344 99 18 owners owner NNS 3344 99 19 of of IN 3344 99 20 music music NN 3344 99 21 or or CC 3344 99 22 films film NNS 3344 99 23 with with IN 3344 99 24 “ " `` 3344 99 25 a a DT 3344 99 26 share share NN 3344 99 27 of of IN 3344 99 28 the the DT 3344 99 29 tax tax NN 3344 99 30 revenues revenue NNS 3344 99 31 proportional proportional JJ 3344 99 32 to to IN 3344 99 33 the the DT 3344 99 34 relative relative JJ 3344 99 35 popularity popularity NN 3344 99 36 of of IN 3344 99 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 99 38 or or CC 3344 99 39 her -PRON- PRP$ 3344 99 40 creation creation NN 3344 99 41 , , , 3344 99 42 ” " '' 3344 99 43 and and CC 3344 99 44 would would MD 3344 99 45 “ " `` 3344 99 46 eliminate eliminate VB 3344 99 47 most most JJS 3344 99 48 of of IN 3344 99 49 the the DT 3344 99 50 current current JJ 3344 99 51 prohibitions prohibition NNS 3344 99 52 on on IN 3344 99 53 unauthorized unauthorized JJ 3344 99 54 reproduction reproduction NN 3344 99 55 , , , 3344 99 56 distribution distribution NN 3344 99 57 , , , 3344 99 58 adaptation adaptation NN 3344 99 59 , , , 3344 99 60 and and CC 3344 99 61 performance performance NN 3344 99 62 of of IN 3344 99 63 audio audio NN 3344 99 64 and and CC 3344 99 65 video video NN 3344 99 66 recordings recording NNS 3344 99 67 . . . 3344 99 68 ”27 ”27 NNP 3344 99 69 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 99 70 recommends recommend VBZ 3344 99 71 that that IN 3344 99 72 copyright copyright NN 3344 99 73 law law NN 3344 99 74 be be VB 3344 99 75 guided guide VBN 3344 99 76 by by IN 3344 99 77 the the DT 3344 99 78 following follow VBG 3344 99 79 general general JJ 3344 99 80 principles principle NNS 3344 99 81 : : : 3344 99 82 ( ( -LRB- 3344 99 83 1 1 LS 3344 99 84 ) ) -RRB- 3344 99 85 short short JJ 3344 99 86 copyright copyright NN 3344 99 87 terms term NNS 3344 99 88 , , , 3344 99 89 ( ( -LRB- 3344 99 90 2 2 LS 3344 99 91 ) ) -RRB- 3344 99 92 a a DT 3344 99 93 simple simple JJ 3344 99 94 binary binary JJ 3344 99 95 system system NN 3344 99 96 of of IN 3344 99 97 protected protect VBN 3344 99 98 / / SYM 3344 99 99 not not RB 3344 99 100 pro- pro- NN 3344 99 101 tected tecte VBN 3344 99 102 works work NNS 3344 99 103 without without IN 3344 99 104 complex complex JJ 3344 99 105 exceptions exception NNS 3344 99 106 , , , 3344 99 107 ( ( -LRB- 3344 99 108 3 3 LS 3344 99 109 ) ) -RRB- 3344 99 110 mandatory mandatory JJ 3344 99 111 renewal renewal NN 3344 99 112 , , , 3344 99 113 and and CC 3344 99 114 ( ( -LRB- 3344 99 115 4 4 LS 3344 99 116 ) ) -RRB- 3344 99 117 a a DT 3344 99 118 “ " `` 3344 99 119 prospective prospective JJ 3344 99 120 ” " '' 3344 99 121 orientation orientation NN 3344 99 122 that that WDT 3344 99 123 forbids forbid VBZ 3344 99 124 retrospective retrospective VBP 3344 99 125 term term NN 3344 99 126 extensions.28 extensions.28 NNP 3344 99 127 ( ( -LRB- 3344 99 128 Previously previously RB 3344 99 129 , , , 3344 99 130 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 99 131 had have VBD 3344 99 132 proposed propose VBN 3344 99 133 a a DT 3344 99 134 seventy seventy CD 3344 99 135 - - HYPH 3344 99 136 five five CD 3344 99 137 - - HYPH 3344 99 138 year year NN 3344 99 139 term term NN 3344 99 140 contingent contingent NN 3344 99 141 on on IN 3344 99 142 five five CD 3344 99 143 - - HYPH 3344 99 144 year year NN 3344 99 145 renewals renewal NNS 3344 99 146 ) ) -RRB- 3344 99 147 . . . 3344 100 1 He -PRON- PRP 3344 100 2 suggests suggest VBZ 3344 100 3 reinstating reinstate VBG 3344 100 4 the the DT 3344 100 5 copyright copyright NN 3344 100 6 registra- registra- JJ 3344 100 7 tion tion NN 3344 100 8 requirement requirement NN 3344 100 9 using use VBG 3344 100 10 a a DT 3344 100 11 flexible flexible JJ 3344 100 12 system system NN 3344 100 13 similar similar JJ 3344 100 14 to to IN 3344 100 15 that that DT 3344 100 16 used use VBN 3344 100 17 for for IN 3344 100 18 domain domain NN 3344 100 19 name name NN 3344 100 20 registrations registration NNS 3344 100 21 . . . 3344 101 1 He -PRON- PRP 3344 101 2 favors favor VBZ 3344 101 3 works work VBZ 3344 101 4 having have VBG 3344 101 5 copyright copyright NN 3344 101 6 marks mark NNS 3344 101 7 , , , 3344 101 8 and and CC 3344 101 9 , , , 3344 101 10 if if IN 3344 101 11 they -PRON- PRP 3344 101 12 are be VBP 3344 101 13 not not RB 3344 101 14 present present JJ 3344 101 15 , , , 3344 101 16 he -PRON- PRP 3344 101 17 would would MD 3344 101 18 permit permit VB 3344 101 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 101 20 free free JJ 3344 101 21 use use NN 3344 101 22 until until IN 3344 101 23 copyright copyright NN 3344 101 24 owners owner NNS 3344 101 25 voice voice VBP 3344 101 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 101 27 opposition opposition NN 3344 101 28 to to IN 3344 101 29 this this DT 3344 101 30 use use NN 3344 101 31 ( ( -LRB- 3344 101 32 uses use NNS 3344 101 33 of of IN 3344 101 34 the the DT 3344 101 35 work work NN 3344 101 36 made make VBN 3344 101 37 prior prior RB 3344 101 38 to to IN 3344 101 39 this this DT 3344 101 40 point point NN 3344 101 41 would would MD 3344 101 42 still still RB 3344 101 43 be be VB 3344 101 44 permitted permit VBN 3344 101 45 ) ) -RRB- 3344 101 46 . . . 3344 102 1 Litman Litman NNP 3344 102 2 wants want VBZ 3344 102 3 a a DT 3344 102 4 copyright copyright NN 3344 102 5 law law NN 3344 102 6 “ " `` 3344 102 7 that that WDT 3344 102 8 is be VBZ 3344 102 9 short short JJ 3344 102 10 , , , 3344 102 11 simple simple JJ 3344 102 12 , , , 3344 102 13 and and CC 3344 102 14 fair fair JJ 3344 102 15 , , , 3344 102 16 ” " '' 3344 102 17 in in IN 3344 102 18 which which WDT 3344 102 19 we -PRON- PRP 3344 102 20 “ " `` 3344 102 21 stop stop VB 3344 102 22 defining define VBG 3344 102 23 copyright copyright NN 3344 102 24 in in IN 3344 102 25 terms term NNS 3344 102 26 of of IN 3344 102 27 reproduction reproduction NN 3344 102 28 ” " '' 3344 102 29 and and CC 3344 102 30 recast recast VB 3344 102 31 copyright copyright NN 3344 102 32 as as IN 3344 102 33 “ " `` 3344 102 34 an an DT 3344 102 35 exclusive exclusive JJ 3344 102 36 right right NN 3344 102 37 of of IN 3344 102 38 commercial commercial JJ 3344 102 39 exploitation exploitation NN 3344 102 40 . . . 3344 102 41 ”29 ”29 NNP 3344 102 42 Litman Litman NNP 3344 102 43 would would MD 3344 102 44 eliminate eliminate VB 3344 102 45 indus- indus- NN 3344 102 46 try try VB 3344 102 47 - - HYPH 3344 102 48 specific specific JJ 3344 102 49 copyright copyright NN 3344 102 50 law law NN 3344 102 51 exceptions exception NNS 3344 102 52 , , , 3344 102 53 but but CC 3344 102 54 grant grant VB 3344 102 55 the the DT 3344 102 56 public public NN 3344 102 57 “ " `` 3344 102 58 a a DT 3344 102 59 right right NN 3344 102 60 to to TO 3344 102 61 engage engage VB 3344 102 62 in in IN 3344 102 63 copying copying NN 3344 102 64 or or CC 3344 102 65 other other JJ 3344 102 66 uses use VBZ 3344 102 67 incidental incidental JJ 3344 102 68 to to IN 3344 102 69 a a DT 3344 102 70 licensed licensed JJ 3344 102 71 or or CC 3344 102 72 legally legally RB 3344 102 73 privileged privileged JJ 3344 102 74 use use NN 3344 102 75 ” " '' 3344 102 76 ; ; : 3344 102 77 the the DT 3344 102 78 “ " `` 3344 102 79 right right NN 3344 102 80 to to TO 3344 102 81 cite cite VB 3344 102 82 ” " '' 3344 102 83 ( ( -LRB- 3344 102 84 even even RB 3344 102 85 infringing infringe VBG 3344 102 86 works work NNS 3344 102 87 ) ) -RRB- 3344 102 88 ; ; : 3344 102 89 and and CC 3344 102 90 “ " `` 3344 102 91 an an DT 3344 102 92 affirmative affirmative JJ 3344 102 93 right right NN 3344 102 94 to to TO 3344 102 95 gain gain VB 3344 102 96 access access NN 3344 102 97 to to IN 3344 102 98 , , , 3344 102 99 extract extract VB 3344 102 100 , , , 3344 102 101 use use NN 3344 102 102 , , , 3344 102 103 and and CC 3344 102 104 reuse reuse VB 3344 102 105 the the DT 3344 102 106 ideas idea NNS 3344 102 107 , , , 3344 102 108 facts fact NNS 3344 102 109 , , , 3344 102 110 information information NN 3344 102 111 , , , 3344 102 112 and and CC 3344 102 113 other other JJ 3344 102 114 public public JJ 3344 102 115 - - HYPH 3344 102 116 domain domain NN 3344 102 117 material material NN 3344 102 118 embodied embody VBN 3344 102 119 in in IN 3344 102 120 protected protect VBN 3344 102 121 works work NNS 3344 102 122 ” " '' 3344 102 123 ( ( -LRB- 3344 102 124 including include VBG 3344 102 125 a a DT 3344 102 126 restricted restricted JJ 3344 102 127 circumvention circumvention NN 3344 102 128 right).30 right).30 NN 3344 102 129 Things thing NNS 3344 102 130 change change VBP 3344 102 131 in in IN 3344 102 132 two two CD 3344 102 133 hundred hundred CD 3344 102 134 - - HYPH 3344 102 135 plus plus CC 3344 102 136 years year NNS 3344 102 137 , , , 3344 102 138 and and CC 3344 102 139 the the DT 3344 102 140 law law NN 3344 102 141 must must MD 3344 102 142 change change VB 3344 102 143 with with IN 3344 102 144 them -PRON- PRP 3344 102 145 . . . 3344 103 1 Since since IN 3344 103 2 the the DT 3344 103 3 late late JJ 3344 103 4 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 3344 103 5 century century NN 3344 103 6 , , , 3344 103 7 copyright copyright NN 3344 103 8 law law NN 3344 103 9 has have VBZ 3344 103 10 been be VBN 3344 103 11 especially especially RB 3344 103 12 impacted impact VBN 3344 103 13 by by IN 3344 103 14 new new JJ 3344 103 15 tech- tech- JJ 3344 103 16 nologies nologie NNS 3344 103 17 . . . 3344 104 1 The the DT 3344 104 2 question question NN 3344 104 3 is be VBZ 3344 104 4 this this DT 3344 104 5 : : : 3344 104 6 has have VBZ 3344 104 7 copyright copyright NN 3344 104 8 law law NN 3344 104 9 struck strike VBD 3344 104 10 the the DT 3344 104 11 right right JJ 3344 104 12 balance balance NN 3344 104 13 between between IN 3344 104 14 encouraging encourage VBG 3344 104 15 progress progress NN 3344 104 16 through through IN 3344 104 17 granting grant VBG 3344 104 18 creators creator NNS 3344 104 19 specific specific JJ 3344 104 20 rights right NNS 3344 104 21 and and CC 3344 104 22 fostering foster VBG 3344 104 23 a a DT 3344 104 24 strong strong JJ 3344 104 25 public public JJ 3344 104 26 domain domain NN 3344 104 27 that that WDT 3344 104 28 also also RB 3344 104 29 nourishes nourish VBZ 3344 104 30 creative creative JJ 3344 104 31 endeavor endeavor NN 3344 104 32 ? ? . 3344 105 1 If if IN 3344 105 2 that that DT 3344 105 3 balance balance NN 3344 105 4 has have VBZ 3344 105 5 been be VBN 3344 105 6 lost lose VBN 3344 105 7 , , , 3344 105 8 how how WRB 3344 105 9 can can MD 3344 105 10 it -PRON- PRP 3344 105 11 be be VB 3344 105 12 restored restore VBN 3344 105 13 ? ? . 3344 106 1 Or or CC 3344 106 2 is be VBZ 3344 106 3 society society NN 3344 106 4 simply simply RB 3344 106 5 no no RB 3344 106 6 longer long RBR 3344 106 7 striving strive VBG 3344 106 8 to to TO 3344 106 9 maintain maintain VB 3344 106 10 that that DT 3344 106 11 balance balance NN 3344 106 12 because because IN 3344 106 13 intellectual intellectual JJ 3344 106 14 works work NNS 3344 106 15 are be VBP 3344 106 16 indeed indeed RB 3344 106 17 property property NN 3344 106 18 , , , 3344 106 19 property property NN 3344 106 20 must must MD 3344 106 21 be be VB 3344 106 22 protected protect VBN 3344 106 23 for for IN 3344 106 24 commerce commerce NN 3344 106 25 to to TO 3344 106 26 prosper prosper VB 3344 106 27 , , , 3344 106 28 and and CC 3344 106 29 the the DT 3344 106 30 concept concept NN 3344 106 31 of of IN 3344 106 32 bal- bal- NN 3344 106 33 ance ance NN 3344 106 34 is be VBZ 3344 106 35 outmoded outmoded JJ 3344 106 36 and and CC 3344 106 37 no no RB 3344 106 38 longer longer RB 3344 106 39 reflects reflect VBZ 3344 106 40 societal societal JJ 3344 106 41 values value NNS 3344 106 42 ? ? . 3344 107 1 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 107 2 DRM DRM NNP 3344 107 3 : : : 3344 107 4 Locked lock VBN 3344 107 5 - - HYPH 3344 107 6 up up RP 3344 107 7 content content NN 3344 107 8 and and CC 3344 107 9 fine fine RB 3344 107 10 - - HYPH 3344 107 11 grained grain VBN 3344 107 12 control control NN 3344 107 13 Noted note VBN 3344 107 14 attorney attorney NN 3344 107 15 Michael Michael NNP 3344 107 16 Godwin Godwin NNP 3344 107 17 defines define VBZ 3344 107 18 DRM DRM NNP 3344 107 19 as as IN 3344 107 20 “ " `` 3344 107 21 a a DT 3344 107 22 collec- collec- NN 3344 107 23 tive tive JJ 3344 107 24 name name NN 3344 107 25 for for IN 3344 107 26 technologies technology NNS 3344 107 27 that that WDT 3344 107 28 prevent prevent VBP 3344 107 29 you -PRON- PRP 3344 107 30 from from IN 3344 107 31 using use VBG 3344 107 32 a a DT 3344 107 33 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 107 34 digital digital JJ 3344 107 35 work work NN 3344 107 36 beyond beyond IN 3344 107 37 the the DT 3344 107 38 degree degree NN 3344 107 39 to to TO 3344 107 40 which which WDT 3344 107 41 the the DT 3344 107 42 copyright copyright NN 3344 107 43 owner owner NN 3344 107 44 ( ( -LRB- 3344 107 45 or or CC 3344 107 46 a a DT 3344 107 47 publisher publisher NN 3344 107 48 who who WP 3344 107 49 may may MD 3344 107 50 not not RB 3344 107 51 actually actually RB 3344 107 52 hold hold VB 3344 107 53 a a DT 3344 107 54 copyright copyright NN 3344 107 55 ) ) -RRB- 3344 107 56 wishes wish VBZ 3344 107 57 to to TO 3344 107 58 allow allow VB 3344 107 59 you -PRON- PRP 3344 107 60 to to TO 3344 107 61 use use VB 3344 107 62 it -PRON- PRP 3344 107 63 . . . 3344 107 64 ”31 ”31 VB 3344 107 65 Like like IN 3344 107 66 copyright copyright NN 3344 107 67 , , , 3344 107 68 DRM DRM NNP 3344 107 69 systems system NNS 3344 107 70 are be VBP 3344 107 71 complex complex JJ 3344 107 72 , , , 3344 107 73 with with IN 3344 107 74 many many JJ 3344 107 75 variations variation NNS 3344 107 76 . . . 3344 108 1 There there EX 3344 108 2 are be VBP 3344 108 3 two two CD 3344 108 4 key key JJ 3344 108 5 technologies technology NNS 3344 108 6 : : : 3344 108 7 ( ( -LRB- 3344 108 8 1 1 LS 3344 108 9 ) ) -RRB- 3344 108 10 digital digital NNP 3344 108 11 mark- mark- NNP 3344 108 12 ing ing NNP 3344 108 13 ( ( -LRB- 3344 108 14 i.e. i.e. FW 3344 108 15 , , , 3344 108 16 digital digital JJ 3344 108 17 fingerprints fingerprint NNS 3344 108 18 that that WDT 3344 108 19 uniquely uniquely RB 3344 108 20 identify identify VBP 3344 108 21 a a DT 3344 108 22 work work NN 3344 108 23 based base VBN 3344 108 24 on on IN 3344 108 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 108 26 characteristics characteristic NNS 3344 108 27 , , , 3344 108 28 simple simple JJ 3344 108 29 labels label NNS 3344 108 30 that that WDT 3344 108 31 attach attach VBP 3344 108 32 rights right NNS 3344 108 33 information information NN 3344 108 34 to to IN 3344 108 35 content content NN 3344 108 36 , , , 3344 108 37 and and CC 3344 108 38 watermarks watermark VBZ 3344 108 39 that that IN 3344 108 40 typically typically RB 3344 108 41 hide hide VBP 3344 108 42 information information NN 3344 108 43 that that WDT 3344 108 44 can can MD 3344 108 45 be be VB 3344 108 46 used use VBN 3344 108 47 to to TO 3344 108 48 identify identify VB 3344 108 49 a a DT 3344 108 50 work work NN 3344 108 51 ) ) -RRB- 3344 108 52 , , , 3344 108 53 and and CC 3344 108 54 ( ( -LRB- 3344 108 55 2 2 LS 3344 108 56 ) ) -RRB- 3344 108 57 encryption encryption NN 3344 108 58 ( ( -LRB- 3344 108 59 i.e. i.e. FW 3344 108 60 , , , 3344 108 61 scrambled scramble VBN 3344 108 62 digital digital JJ 3344 108 63 content content NN 3344 108 64 that that WDT 3344 108 65 requires require VBZ 3344 108 66 a a DT 3344 108 67 digital digital JJ 3344 108 68 key key NN 3344 108 69 to to IN 3344 108 70 decipher decipher NNP 3344 108 71 it).32 it).32 NNP 3344 108 72 Specialized Specialized NNP 3344 108 73 hardware hardware NN 3344 108 74 can can MD 3344 108 75 be be VB 3344 108 76 used use VBN 3344 108 77 to to TO 3344 108 78 restrict restrict VB 3344 108 79 access access NN 3344 108 80 as as RB 3344 108 81 well well RB 3344 108 82 , , , 3344 108 83 often often RB 3344 108 84 in in IN 3344 108 85 conjunction conjunction NN 3344 108 86 with with IN 3344 108 87 digital digital JJ 3344 108 88 marking marking NN 3344 108 89 and and CC 3344 108 90 encryption encryption NN 3344 108 91 . . . 3344 109 1 The the DT 3344 109 2 intent intent NN 3344 109 3 of of IN 3344 109 4 this this DT 3344 109 5 article article NN 3344 109 6 is be VBZ 3344 109 7 not not RB 3344 109 8 to to TO 3344 109 9 provide provide VB 3344 109 10 a a DT 3344 109 11 technical technical JJ 3344 109 12 tutorial tutorial NN 3344 109 13 , , , 3344 109 14 but but CC 3344 109 15 to to TO 3344 109 16 set set VB 3344 109 17 forth forth RP 3344 109 18 an an DT 3344 109 19 overview overview NN 3344 109 20 of of IN 3344 109 21 the the DT 3344 109 22 basic basic JJ 3344 109 23 DRM DRM NNP 3344 109 24 concept concept NN 3344 109 25 and and CC 3344 109 26 discuss discuss VB 3344 109 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 109 28 implications implication NNS 3344 109 29 . . . 3344 110 1 What what WP 3344 110 2 is be VBZ 3344 110 3 of of IN 3344 110 4 interest interest NN 3344 110 5 here here RB 3344 110 6 is be VBZ 3344 110 7 not not RB 3344 110 8 how how WRB 3344 110 9 system system NN 3344 110 10 A a NN 3344 110 11 - - HYPH 3344 110 12 B B NNP 3344 110 13 - - HYPH 3344 110 14 C C NNP 3344 110 15 works work VBZ 3344 110 16 in in IN 3344 110 17 contrast contrast NN 3344 110 18 to to TO 3344 110 19 system system NN 3344 110 20 X X NNP 3344 110 21 - - NN 3344 110 22 Y y JJ 3344 110 23 - - HYPH 3344 110 24 Z Z NNP 3344 110 25 , , , 3344 110 26 but but CC 3344 110 27 what what WP 3344 110 28 DRM DRM NNP 3344 110 29 allows allow VBZ 3344 110 30 copyright copyright NN 3344 110 31 owners owner NNS 3344 110 32 to to TO 3344 110 33 do do VB 3344 110 34 and and CC 3344 110 35 the the DT 3344 110 36 issues issue NNS 3344 110 37 related relate VBN 3344 110 38 to to IN 3344 110 39 DRM DRM NNP 3344 110 40 . . . 3344 111 1 To to TO 3344 111 2 do do VB 3344 111 3 so so RB 3344 111 4 , , , 3344 111 5 let let VB 3344 111 6 ’s -PRON- PRP 3344 111 7 use use VB 3344 111 8 an an DT 3344 111 9 analogy analogy NN 3344 111 10 , , , 3344 111 11 understanding understanding NN 3344 111 12 that that IN 3344 111 13 real real JJ 3344 111 14 DRM DRM NNP 3344 111 15 systems system NNS 3344 111 16 can can MD 3344 111 17 work work VB 3344 111 18 in in IN 3344 111 19 other other JJ 3344 111 20 ways way NNS 3344 111 21 as as RB 3344 111 22 well well RB 3344 111 23 ( ( -LRB- 3344 111 24 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 111 25 , , , 3344 111 26 digi- digi- NNP 3344 111 27 tal tal NNP 3344 111 28 watermarks watermark NNS 3344 111 29 can can MD 3344 111 30 be be VB 3344 111 31 used use VBN 3344 111 32 to to TO 3344 111 33 track track VB 3344 111 34 illegal illegal JJ 3344 111 35 use use NN 3344 111 36 of of IN 3344 111 37 images image NNS 3344 111 38 on on IN 3344 111 39 the the DT 3344 111 40 Internet internet NN 3344 111 41 without without IN 3344 111 42 those those DT 3344 111 43 images image NNS 3344 111 44 being be VBG 3344 111 45 otherwise otherwise RB 3344 111 46 protected protect VBN 3344 111 47 ) ) -RRB- 3344 111 48 . . . 3344 112 1 For for IN 3344 112 2 the the DT 3344 112 3 moment moment NN 3344 112 4 , , , 3344 112 5 let let VB 3344 112 6 ’s -PRON- PRP 3344 112 7 imagine imagine VB 3344 112 8 that that IN 3344 112 9 the the DT 3344 112 10 content content NN 3344 112 11 a a DT 3344 112 12 user user NN 3344 112 13 wishes wish VBZ 3344 112 14 to to TO 3344 112 15 access access VB 3344 112 16 is be VBZ 3344 112 17 in in IN 3344 112 18 an an DT 3344 112 19 unbreakable unbreakable JJ 3344 112 20 , , , 3344 112 21 encrypted encrypt VBN 3344 112 22 digital digital JJ 3344 112 23 safe safe JJ 3344 112 24 . . . 3344 113 1 The the DT 3344 113 2 user user NN 3344 113 3 can can MD 3344 113 4 not not RB 3344 113 5 see see VB 3344 113 6 inside inside IN 3344 113 7 the the DT 3344 113 8 safe safe JJ 3344 113 9 . . . 3344 114 1 By by IN 3344 114 2 entering enter VBG 3344 114 3 the the DT 3344 114 4 correct correct JJ 3344 114 5 digital digital JJ 3344 114 6 combination combination NN 3344 114 7 , , , 3344 114 8 certain certain JJ 3344 114 9 content content NN 3344 114 10 becomes become VBZ 3344 114 11 visible visible JJ 3344 114 12 ( ( -LRB- 3344 114 13 or or CC 3344 114 14 audible audible JJ 3344 114 15 or or CC 3344 114 16 both both DT 3344 114 17 ) ) -RRB- 3344 114 18 in in IN 3344 114 19 the the DT 3344 114 20 safe safe NN 3344 114 21 . . . 3344 115 1 That that DT 3344 115 2 content content NN 3344 115 3 can can MD 3344 115 4 then then RB 3344 115 5 be be VB 3344 115 6 utilized utilize VBN 3344 115 7 in in IN 3344 115 8 specific specific JJ 3344 115 9 ways way NNS 3344 115 10 ( ( -LRB- 3344 115 11 and and CC 3344 115 12 only only RB 3344 115 13 those those DT 3344 115 14 ways way NNS 3344 115 15 ) ) -RRB- 3344 115 16 , , , 3344 115 17 including include VBG 3344 115 18 , , , 3344 115 19 if if IN 3344 115 20 permitted permit VBN 3344 115 21 , , , 3344 115 22 leaving leave VBG 3344 115 23 the the DT 3344 115 24 safe safe JJ 3344 115 25 . . . 3344 116 1 If if IN 3344 116 2 a a DT 3344 116 3 public public JJ 3344 116 4 domain domain NN 3344 116 5 work work NN 3344 116 6 is be VBZ 3344 116 7 put put VBN 3344 116 8 in in IN 3344 116 9 the the DT 3344 116 10 safe safe JJ 3344 116 11 , , , 3344 116 12 access access NN 3344 116 13 to to IN 3344 116 14 it -PRON- PRP 3344 116 15 is be VBZ 3344 116 16 restricted restrict VBN 3344 116 17 regardless regardless RB 3344 116 18 of of IN 3344 116 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 116 20 copyright copyright NN 3344 116 21 status status NN 3344 116 22 . . . 3344 117 1 Bill Bill NNP 3344 117 2 Rosenblatt Rosenblatt NNP 3344 117 3 , , , 3344 117 4 Bill Bill NNP 3344 117 5 Trippe Trippe NNP 3344 117 6 , , , 3344 117 7 and and CC 3344 117 8 Stephen Stephen NNP 3344 117 9 Mooney Mooney NNP 3344 117 10 pro- pro- NN 3344 117 11 vide vide VBP 3344 117 12 a a DT 3344 117 13 very very RB 3344 117 14 useful useful JJ 3344 117 15 conceptual conceptual JJ 3344 117 16 model model NN 3344 117 17 of of IN 3344 117 18 DRM DRM NNP 3344 117 19 rights right NNS 3344 117 20 in in IN 3344 117 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 117 22 landmark landmark NN 3344 117 23 DRM DRM NNP 3344 117 24 book book NN 3344 117 25 , , , 3344 117 26 Digital Digital NNP 3344 117 27 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 117 28 Management Management NNP 3344 117 29 : : : 3344 117 30 Business Business NNP 3344 117 31 and and CC 3344 117 32 Technology Technology NNP 3344 117 33 , , , 3344 117 34 summarized summarize VBD 3344 117 35 here.33 here.33 NNP 3344 117 36 There there EX 3344 117 37 are be VBP 3344 117 38 three three CD 3344 117 39 types type NNS 3344 117 40 of of IN 3344 117 41 content content NN 3344 117 42 rights right NNS 3344 117 43 : : : 3344 117 44 ( ( -LRB- 3344 117 45 1 1 LS 3344 117 46 ) ) -RRB- 3344 117 47 render render NN 3344 117 48 rights right NNS 3344 117 49 , , , 3344 117 50 ( ( -LRB- 3344 117 51 2 2 LS 3344 117 52 ) ) -RRB- 3344 117 53 transport transport NN 3344 117 54 rights right NNS 3344 117 55 , , , 3344 117 56 and and CC 3344 117 57 ( ( -LRB- 3344 117 58 3 3 LS 3344 117 59 ) ) -RRB- 3344 117 60 derivative derivative JJ 3344 117 61 - - HYPH 3344 117 62 works work NNS 3344 117 63 rights right NNS 3344 117 64 . . . 3344 118 1 Render render NN 3344 118 2 rights right NNS 3344 118 3 allow allow VBP 3344 118 4 authorized authorize VBN 3344 118 5 users user NNS 3344 118 6 to to TO 3344 118 7 view view VB 3344 118 8 , , , 3344 118 9 play play VB 3344 118 10 , , , 3344 118 11 and and CC 3344 118 12 print print NN 3344 118 13 protected protect VBD 3344 118 14 content content NN 3344 118 15 . . . 3344 119 1 Transport transport NN 3344 119 2 rights right NNS 3344 119 3 allow allow VBP 3344 119 4 authorized authorize VBN 3344 119 5 users user NNS 3344 119 6 to to TO 3344 119 7 copy copy VB 3344 119 8 , , , 3344 119 9 move move VBP 3344 119 10 , , , 3344 119 11 and and CC 3344 119 12 loan loan NN 3344 119 13 content content NN 3344 119 14 ( ( -LRB- 3344 119 15 the the DT 3344 119 16 user user NN 3344 119 17 retains retain VBZ 3344 119 18 the the DT 3344 119 19 content content NN 3344 119 20 if if IN 3344 119 21 it -PRON- PRP 3344 119 22 is be VBZ 3344 119 23 copied copy VBN 3344 119 24 and and CC 3344 119 25 gets get VBZ 3344 119 26 it -PRON- PRP 3344 119 27 back back RB 3344 119 28 when when WRB 3344 119 29 a a DT 3344 119 30 loan loan NN 3344 119 31 is be VBZ 3344 119 32 over over RB 3344 119 33 , , , 3344 119 34 but but CC 3344 119 35 does do VBZ 3344 119 36 not not RB 3344 119 37 keep keep VB 3344 119 38 a a DT 3344 119 39 copy copy NN 3344 119 40 if if IN 3344 119 41 it -PRON- PRP 3344 119 42 is be VBZ 3344 119 43 moved move VBN 3344 119 44 ) ) -RRB- 3344 119 45 . . . 3344 120 1 Derivative derivative JJ 3344 120 2 - - HYPH 3344 120 3 works work NNS 3344 120 4 rights right NNS 3344 120 5 allow allow VBP 3344 120 6 authorized authorize VBN 3344 120 7 users user NNS 3344 120 8 to to TO 3344 120 9 extract extract VB 3344 120 10 pieces piece NNS 3344 120 11 of of IN 3344 120 12 content content NN 3344 120 13 , , , 3344 120 14 edit edit VB 3344 120 15 the the DT 3344 120 16 content content NN 3344 120 17 in in IN 3344 120 18 place place NN 3344 120 19 , , , 3344 120 20 and and CC 3344 120 21 embed embe VBN 3344 120 22 content content NN 3344 120 23 by by IN 3344 120 24 extracting extract VBG 3344 120 25 some some DT 3344 120 26 of of IN 3344 120 27 it -PRON- PRP 3344 120 28 and and CC 3344 120 29 using use VBG 3344 120 30 it -PRON- PRP 3344 120 31 in in IN 3344 120 32 other other JJ 3344 120 33 works work NNS 3344 120 34 . . . 3344 121 1 Each each DT 3344 121 2 one one NN 3344 121 3 of of IN 3344 121 4 these these DT 3344 121 5 individual individual JJ 3344 121 6 rights right NNS 3344 121 7 has have VBZ 3344 121 8 three three CD 3344 121 9 attributes attribute NNS 3344 121 10 : : : 3344 121 11 ( ( -LRB- 3344 121 12 1 1 LS 3344 121 13 ) ) -RRB- 3344 121 14 consideration consideration NN 3344 121 15 , , , 3344 121 16 ( ( -LRB- 3344 121 17 2 2 LS 3344 121 18 ) ) -RRB- 3344 121 19 extents extent NNS 3344 121 20 , , , 3344 121 21 and and CC 3344 121 22 ( ( -LRB- 3344 121 23 3 3 LS 3344 121 24 ) ) -RRB- 3344 121 25 types type NNS 3344 121 26 of of IN 3344 121 27 users user NNS 3344 121 28 . . . 3344 122 1 In in IN 3344 122 2 the the DT 3344 122 3 first first JJ 3344 122 4 attribute attribute NN 3344 122 5 , , , 3344 122 6 consideration consideration NN 3344 122 7 , , , 3344 122 8 access access NN 3344 122 9 to to IN 3344 122 10 content content NN 3344 122 11 is be VBZ 3344 122 12 provided provide VBN 3344 122 13 for for IN 3344 122 14 something something NN 3344 122 15 of of IN 3344 122 16 value value NN 3344 122 17 to to IN 3344 122 18 the the DT 3344 122 19 publisher publisher NN 3344 122 20 ( ( -LRB- 3344 122 21 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 122 22 , , , 3344 122 23 money money NN 3344 122 24 or or CC 3344 122 25 personal personal JJ 3344 122 26 information information NN 3344 122 27 ) ) -RRB- 3344 122 28 . . . 3344 123 1 Content content NN 3344 123 2 can can MD 3344 123 3 then then RB 3344 123 4 be be VB 3344 123 5 used use VBN 3344 123 6 to to IN 3344 123 7 some some DT 3344 123 8 extent extent NN 3344 123 9 ( ( -LRB- 3344 123 10 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 123 11 , , , 3344 123 12 for for IN 3344 123 13 a a DT 3344 123 14 certain certain JJ 3344 123 15 amount amount NN 3344 123 16 of of IN 3344 123 17 time time NN 3344 123 18 or or CC 3344 123 19 a a DT 3344 123 20 certain certain JJ 3344 123 21 number number NN 3344 123 22 of of IN 3344 123 23 times time NNS 3344 123 24 ) ) -RRB- 3344 123 25 . . . 3344 124 1 The the DT 3344 124 2 rights right NNS 3344 124 3 and and CC 3344 124 4 attributes attribute VBZ 3344 124 5 users user NNS 3344 124 6 have have VBP 3344 124 7 are be VBP 3344 124 8 determined determine VBN 3344 124 9 by by IN 3344 124 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 124 11 user user NN 3344 124 12 types type NNS 3344 124 13 . . . 3344 125 1 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 3344 125 2 DYSTOPIA DYSTOPIA NNP 3344 125 3 | | NNP 3344 125 4 BAILEY BAILEY NNP 3344 125 5 121 121 CD 3344 125 6 For for IN 3344 125 7 example example NN 3344 125 8 , , , 3344 125 9 an an DT 3344 125 10 academic academic JJ 3344 125 11 user user NN 3344 125 12 , , , 3344 125 13 in in IN 3344 125 14 consideration consideration NN 3344 125 15 of of IN 3344 125 16 a a DT 3344 125 17 specified specified JJ 3344 125 18 license license NN 3344 125 19 payment payment NN 3344 125 20 by by IN 3344 125 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 125 22 or or CC 3344 125 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 3344 125 24 library library NN 3344 125 25 , , , 3344 125 26 can can MD 3344 125 27 view view VB 3344 125 28 a a DT 3344 125 29 DRM drm NN 3344 125 30 - - HYPH 3344 125 31 protected protect VBN 3344 125 32 scholarly scholarly NNP 3344 125 33 article article NN 3344 125 34 — — : 3344 125 35 but but CC 3344 125 36 not not RB 3344 125 37 copy copy VB 3344 125 38 , , , 3344 125 39 move move VBP 3344 125 40 , , , 3344 125 41 loan loan NN 3344 125 42 , , , 3344 125 43 extract extract NN 3344 125 44 , , , 3344 125 45 edit edit NN 3344 125 46 , , , 3344 125 47 or or CC 3344 125 48 embed embe VBN 3344 125 49 it -PRON- PRP 3344 125 50 — — : 3344 125 51 for for IN 3344 125 52 a a DT 3344 125 53 week week NN 3344 125 54 , , , 3344 125 55 after after IN 3344 125 56 which which WDT 3344 125 57 it -PRON- PRP 3344 125 58 is be VBZ 3344 125 59 inaccessible inaccessible JJ 3344 125 60 . . . 3344 126 1 We -PRON- PRP 3344 126 2 can can MD 3344 126 3 extend extend VB 3344 126 4 this this DT 3344 126 5 hypothetical hypothetical JJ 3344 126 6 example example NN 3344 126 7 by by IN 3344 126 8 imagining imagine VBG 3344 126 9 that that IN 3344 126 10 the the DT 3344 126 11 library library NN 3344 126 12 could could MD 3344 126 13 pay pay VB 3344 126 14 higher high JJR 3344 126 15 license license NN 3344 126 16 fees fee NNS 3344 126 17 to to TO 3344 126 18 gain gain VB 3344 126 19 more more JJR 3344 126 20 rights right NNS 3344 126 21 to to IN 3344 126 22 the the DT 3344 126 23 journal journal NN 3344 126 24 in in IN 3344 126 25 question question NN 3344 126 26 , , , 3344 126 27 and and CC 3344 126 28 the the DT 3344 126 29 library library NN 3344 126 30 ( ( -LRB- 3344 126 31 or or CC 3344 126 32 the the DT 3344 126 33 user user NN 3344 126 34 ) ) -RRB- 3344 126 35 could could MD 3344 126 36 dynamically dynamically RB 3344 126 37 purchase purchase VB 3344 126 38 additional additional JJ 3344 126 39 article article NN 3344 126 40 - - HYPH 3344 126 41 specific specific JJ 3344 126 42 rights right NNS 3344 126 43 enhancements enhancement NNS 3344 126 44 as as IN 3344 126 45 needed need VBN 3344 126 46 through through IN 3344 126 47 micropayments micropayment NNS 3344 126 48 . . . 3344 127 1 This this DT 3344 127 2 example example NN 3344 127 3 is be VBZ 3344 127 4 extreme extreme JJ 3344 127 5 ; ; : 3344 127 6 however however RB 3344 127 7 , , , 3344 127 8 it -PRON- PRP 3344 127 9 illustrates illustrate VBZ 3344 127 10 the the DT 3344 127 11 fine fine RB 3344 127 12 - - HYPH 3344 127 13 grained grained JJ 3344 127 14 , , , 3344 127 15 high high JJ 3344 127 16 level level NN 3344 127 17 of of IN 3344 127 18 control control NN 3344 127 19 that that IN 3344 127 20 publishers publisher NNS 3344 127 21 could could MD 3344 127 22 potentially potentially RB 3344 127 23 have have VB 3344 127 24 over over IN 3344 127 25 content content NN 3344 127 26 by by IN 3344 127 27 using use VBG 3344 127 28 DRM DRM NNP 3344 127 29 technology technology NN 3344 127 30 . . . 3344 128 1 Godwin Godwin NNP 3344 128 2 suggests suggest VBZ 3344 128 3 that that IN 3344 128 4 DRM DRM NNP 3344 128 5 may may MD 3344 128 6 inhibit inhibit VB 3344 128 7 a a DT 3344 128 8 variety variety NN 3344 128 9 of of IN 3344 128 10 legitimate legitimate JJ 3344 128 11 uses use NNS 3344 128 12 of of IN 3344 128 13 DRM DRM NNP 3344 128 14 - - HYPH 3344 128 15 protected protect VBN 3344 128 16 information information NN 3344 128 17 , , , 3344 128 18 such such JJ 3344 128 19 as as IN 3344 128 20 access access NN 3344 128 21 to to IN 3344 128 22 public public JJ 3344 128 23 - - HYPH 3344 128 24 domain domain NN 3344 128 25 works work NNS 3344 128 26 ( ( -LRB- 3344 128 27 or or CC 3344 128 28 other other JJ 3344 128 29 works work NNS 3344 128 30 that that WDT 3344 128 31 would would MD 3344 128 32 allow allow VB 3344 128 33 liberal liberal JJ 3344 128 34 use use NN 3344 128 35 ) ) -RRB- 3344 128 36 , , , 3344 128 37 preservation preservation NN 3344 128 38 of of IN 3344 128 39 works work NNS 3344 128 40 by by IN 3344 128 41 librar- librar- NNP 3344 128 42 ies ie NNS 3344 128 43 , , , 3344 128 44 creation creation NN 3344 128 45 of of IN 3344 128 46 new new JJ 3344 128 47 derivative derivative JJ 3344 128 48 works work NNS 3344 128 49 , , , 3344 128 50 conduct conduct NN 3344 128 51 of of IN 3344 128 52 histori- histori- FW 3344 128 53 cal cal NN 3344 128 54 research research NN 3344 128 55 , , , 3344 128 56 exercise exercise NN 3344 128 57 of of IN 3344 128 58 fair fair JJ 3344 128 59 - - HYPH 3344 128 60 use use NN 3344 128 61 rights right NNS 3344 128 62 , , , 3344 128 63 and and CC 3344 128 64 instructional instructional JJ 3344 128 65 use.34 use.34 RB 3344 128 66 The the DT 3344 128 67 ability ability NN 3344 128 68 of of IN 3344 128 69 blind blind JJ 3344 128 70 ( ( -LRB- 3344 128 71 or or CC 3344 128 72 otherwise otherwise RB 3344 128 73 disabled disabled JJ 3344 128 74 ) ) -RRB- 3344 128 75 users user NNS 3344 128 76 to to TO 3344 128 77 employ employ VB 3344 128 78 assistive assistive JJ 3344 128 79 technologies technology NNS 3344 128 80 may may MD 3344 128 81 also also RB 3344 128 82 be be VB 3344 128 83 prevented prevent VBN 3344 128 84 by by IN 3344 128 85 DRM DRM NNP 3344 128 86 technology.35 technology.35 NNP 3344 128 87 DRM DRM NNP 3344 128 88 also also RB 3344 128 89 raises raise VBZ 3344 128 90 a a DT 3344 128 91 variety variety NN 3344 128 92 of of IN 3344 128 93 privacy privacy NN 3344 128 94 concerns.36 concerns.36 NNP 3344 128 95 Fair Fair NNP 3344 128 96 use use NN 3344 128 97 is be VBZ 3344 128 98 an an DT 3344 128 99 especially especially RB 3344 128 100 thorny thorny JJ 3344 128 101 problem problem NN 3344 128 102 . . . 3344 129 1 Rosenblatt rosenblatt VB 3344 129 2 , , , 3344 129 3 Trippe Trippe NNP 3344 129 4 , , , 3344 129 5 and and CC 3344 129 6 Mooney mooney JJ 3344 129 7 state state NN 3344 129 8 : : : 3344 129 9 Fair fair JJ 3344 129 10 use use NN 3344 129 11 is be VBZ 3344 129 12 an an DT 3344 129 13 “ " `` 3344 129 14 I -PRON- PRP 3344 129 15 ’ll will MD 3344 129 16 know know VB 3344 129 17 it -PRON- PRP 3344 129 18 when when WRB 3344 129 19 I -PRON- PRP 3344 129 20 see see VBP 3344 129 21 it -PRON- PRP 3344 129 22 ” " '' 3344 129 23 proposition proposition NN 3344 129 24 , , , 3344 129 25 meaning mean VBG 3344 129 26 that that IN 3344 129 27 it -PRON- PRP 3344 129 28 ca can MD 3344 129 29 n’t not RB 3344 129 30 be be VB 3344 129 31 proscriptively proscriptively RB 3344 129 32 defined define VBN 3344 129 33 . . . 3344 130 1 . . . 3344 131 1 . . . 3344 132 1 . . . 3344 133 1 Just just RB 3344 133 2 as as IN 3344 133 3 there there EX 3344 133 4 is be VBZ 3344 133 5 no no DT 3344 133 6 such such JJ 3344 133 7 thing thing NN 3344 133 8 as as IN 3344 133 9 a a DT 3344 133 10 “ " `` 3344 133 11 black black JJ 3344 133 12 box box NN 3344 133 13 ” " '' 3344 133 14 that that WDT 3344 133 15 determines determine VBZ 3344 133 16 whether whether IN 3344 133 17 broadcast broadcast NN 3344 133 18 material material NN 3344 133 19 is be VBZ 3344 133 20 or or CC 3344 133 21 is be VBZ 3344 133 22 n’t not RB 3344 133 23 indecent indecent JJ 3344 133 24 , , , 3344 133 25 there there EX 3344 133 26 is be VBZ 3344 133 27 no no DT 3344 133 28 such such JJ 3344 133 29 thing thing NN 3344 133 30 as as IN 3344 133 31 a a DT 3344 133 32 “ " `` 3344 133 33 black black JJ 3344 133 34 box box NN 3344 133 35 ” " '' 3344 133 36 that that WDT 3344 133 37 can can MD 3344 133 38 determine determine VB 3344 133 39 whether whether IN 3344 133 40 a a DT 3344 133 41 given give VBN 3344 133 42 use use NN 3344 133 43 of of IN 3344 133 44 content content JJ 3344 133 45 qualifies qualifie NNS 3344 133 46 as as IN 3344 133 47 fair fair JJ 3344 133 48 use use NN 3344 133 49 or or CC 3344 133 50 not not RB 3344 133 51 . . . 3344 134 1 Anything anything NN 3344 134 2 that that WDT 3344 134 3 ca can MD 3344 134 4 n’t not RB 3344 134 5 be be VB 3344 134 6 proscriptively proscriptively RB 3344 134 7 defined define VBN 3344 134 8 ca can MD 3344 134 9 n’t not RB 3344 134 10 be be VB 3344 134 11 represented represent VBN 3344 134 12 in in IN 3344 134 13 a a DT 3344 134 14 computer computer NN 3344 134 15 system.37 system.37 NNP 3344 134 16 No no DT 3344 134 17 need need NN 3344 134 18 to to TO 3344 134 19 panic panic VB 3344 134 20 about about IN 3344 134 21 scholarly scholarly JJ 3344 134 22 journals journal NNS 3344 134 23 — — : 3344 134 24 yet yet RB 3344 134 25 . . . 3344 135 1 Your -PRON- PRP$ 3344 135 2 scholarly scholarly JJ 3344 135 3 journal journal NN 3344 135 4 publisher publisher NN 3344 135 5 or or CC 3344 135 6 other other JJ 3344 135 7 third third JJ 3344 135 8 - - HYPH 3344 135 9 party party NN 3344 135 10 supplier supplier NN 3344 135 11 is be VBZ 3344 135 12 unlikely unlikely JJ 3344 135 13 to to TO 3344 135 14 present present VB 3344 135 15 you -PRON- PRP 3344 135 16 with with IN 3344 135 17 such such JJ 3344 135 18 detailed detailed JJ 3344 135 19 options option NNS 3344 135 20 tomor- tomor- XX 3344 135 21 row row NN 3344 135 22 . . . 3344 136 1 But but CC 3344 136 2 you -PRON- PRP 3344 136 3 may may MD 3344 136 4 already already RB 3344 136 5 be be VB 3344 136 6 licensing license VBG 3344 136 7 other other JJ 3344 136 8 digital digital JJ 3344 136 9 content content NN 3344 136 10 that that WDT 3344 136 11 is be VBZ 3344 136 12 DRM DRM NNP 3344 136 13 - - HYPH 3344 136 14 protected protect VBN 3344 136 15 , , , 3344 136 16 such such JJ 3344 136 17 as as IN 3344 136 18 digital digital JJ 3344 136 19 music music NN 3344 136 20 or or CC 3344 136 21 e e NN 3344 136 22 - - HYPH 3344 136 23 books book NNS 3344 136 24 that that WDT 3344 136 25 require require VBP 3344 136 26 a a DT 3344 136 27 hardware hardware NN 3344 136 28 e e NN 3344 136 29 - - NN 3344 136 30 book book NN 3344 136 31 reader reader NN 3344 136 32 . . . 3344 137 1 As as IN 3344 137 2 the the DT 3344 137 3 recent recent JJ 3344 137 4 Sony Sony NNP 3344 137 5 BMG BMG NNP 3344 137 6 “ " `` 3344 137 7 rootkit rootkit NNS 3344 137 8 ” " '' 3344 137 9 episode episode NN 3344 137 10 illustrated illustrate VBD 3344 137 11 , , , 3344 137 12 creating create VBG 3344 137 13 effective effective JJ 3344 137 14 , , , 3344 137 15 secure secure JJ 3344 137 16 DRM DRM NNP 3344 137 17 systems system NNS 3344 137 18 can can MD 3344 137 19 be be VB 3344 137 20 challeng- challeng- NNP 3344 137 21 ing ing NNP 3344 137 22 , , , 3344 137 23 even even RB 3344 137 24 for for IN 3344 137 25 large large JJ 3344 137 26 corporations.38 corporations.38 NNP 3344 137 27 Again Again NNP 3344 137 28 , , , 3344 137 29 the the DT 3344 137 30 reasons reason NNS 3344 137 31 for for IN 3344 137 32 this this DT 3344 137 33 are be VBP 3344 137 34 complex complex JJ 3344 137 35 . . . 3344 138 1 In in IN 3344 138 2 very very RB 3344 138 3 simple simple JJ 3344 138 4 terms term NNS 3344 138 5 , , , 3344 138 6 it -PRON- PRP 3344 138 7 boils boil VBZ 3344 138 8 down down RP 3344 138 9 to to IN 3344 138 10 this this DT 3344 138 11 : : : 3344 138 12 assuming assume VBG 3344 138 13 that that IN 3344 138 14 the the DT 3344 138 15 content content NN 3344 138 16 can can MD 3344 138 17 be be VB 3344 138 18 protected protect VBN 3344 138 19 up up RP 3344 138 20 to to IN 3344 138 21 the the DT 3344 138 22 point point NN 3344 138 23 it -PRON- PRP 3344 138 24 is be VBZ 3344 138 25 placed place VBN 3344 138 26 in in IN 3344 138 27 a a DT 3344 138 28 DRM DRM NNP 3344 138 29 system system NN 3344 138 30 , , , 3344 138 31 the the DT 3344 138 32 DRM DRM NNP 3344 138 33 system system NN 3344 138 34 has have VBZ 3344 138 35 the the DT 3344 138 36 best good JJS 3344 138 37 chance chance NN 3344 138 38 of of IN 3344 138 39 working work VBG 3344 138 40 if if IN 3344 138 41 all all DT 3344 138 42 possible possible JJ 3344 138 43 devices device NNS 3344 138 44 that that WDT 3344 138 45 can can MD 3344 138 46 process process VB 3344 138 47 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 138 48 protected protect VBN 3344 138 49 content content NN 3344 138 50 either either CC 3344 138 51 directly directly RB 3344 138 52 support support VB 3344 138 53 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 138 54 protection protection NN 3344 138 55 technology technology NN 3344 138 56 , , , 3344 138 57 recognize recognize VB 3344 138 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 138 59 restrictions restriction NNS 3344 138 60 and and CC 3344 138 61 enforce enforce VB 3344 138 62 them -PRON- PRP 3344 138 63 through through IN 3344 138 64 another another DT 3344 138 65 means mean NNS 3344 138 66 , , , 3344 138 67 or or CC 3344 138 68 refuse refuse VB 3344 138 69 access.39 access.39 NNP 3344 138 70 Anything Anything NNP 3344 138 71 less less JJR 3344 138 72 creates create VBZ 3344 138 73 “ " `` 3344 138 74 holes hole NNS 3344 138 75 ” " '' 3344 138 76 in in IN 3344 138 77 the the DT 3344 138 78 protective protective JJ 3344 138 79 DRM DRM NNP 3344 138 80 shell shell NN 3344 138 81 , , , 3344 138 82 such such JJ 3344 138 83 as as IN 3344 138 84 the the DT 3344 138 85 well well RB 3344 138 86 - - HYPH 3344 138 87 known know VBN 3344 138 88 “ " `` 3344 138 89 analog analog NN 3344 138 90 hole hole NN 3344 138 91 ” " '' 3344 138 92 ( ( -LRB- 3344 138 93 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 138 94 , , , 3344 138 95 when when WRB 3344 138 96 DRM DRM NNP 3344 138 97 - - HYPH 3344 138 98 protected protect VBN 3344 138 99 digital digital JJ 3344 138 100 content content NN 3344 138 101 is be VBZ 3344 138 102 converted convert VBN 3344 138 103 to to IN 3344 138 104 analog analog VB 3344 138 105 form form NN 3344 138 106 to to TO 3344 138 107 be be VB 3344 138 108 played play VBN 3344 138 109 , , , 3344 138 110 it -PRON- PRP 3344 138 111 can can MD 3344 138 112 then then RB 3344 138 113 be be VB 3344 138 114 rerecorded rerecorde VBN 3344 138 115 using use VBG 3344 138 116 digital digital JJ 3344 138 117 equipment equipment NN 3344 138 118 without without IN 3344 138 119 DRM DRM NNP 3344 138 120 protection).40 protection).40 NN 3344 138 121 Ideally ideally RB 3344 138 122 , , , 3344 138 123 in in IN 3344 138 124 other other JJ 3344 138 125 words word NNS 3344 138 126 , , , 3344 138 127 every every DT 3344 138 128 server server NN 3344 138 129 , , , 3344 138 130 network network NN 3344 138 131 router router NN 3344 138 132 , , , 3344 138 133 PC pc NN 3344 138 134 and and CC 3344 138 135 PC pc NN 3344 138 136 component component NN 3344 138 137 , , , 3344 138 138 operating operating NN 3344 138 139 system system NN 3344 138 140 , , , 3344 138 141 and and CC 3344 138 142 relevant relevant JJ 3344 138 143 electronic electronic JJ 3344 138 144 device device NN 3344 138 145 ( ( -LRB- 3344 138 146 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 138 147 , , , 3344 138 148 CD cd NN 3344 138 149 player player NN 3344 138 150 , , , 3344 138 151 DVD dvd NN 3344 138 152 player player NN 3344 138 153 , , , 3344 138 154 audio- audio- JJ 3344 138 155 recording record VBG 3344 138 156 device device NN 3344 138 157 , , , 3344 138 158 and and CC 3344 138 159 video video NN 3344 138 160 - - HYPH 3344 138 161 recording record VBG 3344 138 162 device device NN 3344 138 163 ) ) -RRB- 3344 138 164 would would MD 3344 138 165 work work VB 3344 138 166 with with IN 3344 138 167 the the DT 3344 138 168 DRM DRM NNP 3344 138 169 system system NN 3344 138 170 as as IN 3344 138 171 outlined outline VBN 3344 138 172 previously previously RB 3344 138 173 or or CC 3344 138 174 would would MD 3344 138 175 not not RB 3344 138 176 allow allow VB 3344 138 177 access access NN 3344 138 178 to to IN 3344 138 179 the the DT 3344 138 180 content content NN 3344 138 181 at at RB 3344 138 182 all all RB 3344 138 183 . . . 3344 139 1 Clearly clearly RB 3344 139 2 , , , 3344 139 3 this this DT 3344 139 4 ideal ideal JJ 3344 139 5 end end NN 3344 139 6 - - HYPH 3344 139 7 state state NN 3344 139 8 for for IN 3344 139 9 DRM DRM NNP 3344 139 10 may may MD 3344 139 11 well well RB 3344 139 12 never never RB 3344 139 13 be be VB 3344 139 14 realized realize VBN 3344 139 15 , , , 3344 139 16 especially especially RB 3344 139 17 given give VBN 3344 139 18 the the DT 3344 139 19 troublesome troublesome JJ 3344 139 20 backward- backward- NN 3344 139 21 compatibility compatibility NN 3344 139 22 equipment equipment NN 3344 139 23 problem.41 problem.41 NNP 3344 139 24 However however RB 3344 139 25 , , , 3344 139 26 this this DT 3344 139 27 does do VBZ 3344 139 28 not not RB 3344 139 29 mean mean VB 3344 139 30 that that IN 3344 139 31 the the DT 3344 139 32 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 139 33 , , , 3344 139 34 information information NN 3344 139 35 , , , 3344 139 36 and and CC 3344 139 37 high- high- JJ 3344 139 38 technology technology NN 3344 139 39 companies company NNS 3344 139 40 will will MD 3344 139 41 not not RB 3344 139 42 try try VB 3344 139 43 to to TO 3344 139 44 make make VB 3344 139 45 whatever whatever WDT 3344 139 46 piecemeal piecemeal JJ 3344 139 47 progress progress NN 3344 139 48 that that WDT 3344 139 49 they -PRON- PRP 3344 139 50 can can MD 3344 139 51 in in IN 3344 139 52 this this DT 3344 139 53 area.42 area.42 NNP 3344 139 54 The the DT 3344 139 55 Trusted Trusted NNP 3344 139 56 Computing Computing NNP 3344 139 57 Group Group NNP 3344 139 58 is be VBZ 3344 139 59 an an DT 3344 139 60 important important JJ 3344 139 61 mul- mul- NN 3344 139 62 tiple tiple JJ 3344 139 63 - - HYPH 3344 139 64 industry industry NN 3344 139 65 security security NN 3344 139 66 organization organization NN 3344 139 67 , , , 3344 139 68 whose whose WP$ 3344 139 69 standards standard NNS 3344 139 70 work work NN 3344 139 71 could could MD 3344 139 72 have have VB 3344 139 73 a a DT 3344 139 74 strong strong JJ 3344 139 75 impact impact NN 3344 139 76 on on IN 3344 139 77 the the DT 3344 139 78 future future NN 3344 139 79 of of IN 3344 139 80 DRM DRM NNP 3344 139 81 . . . 3344 140 1 Robert Robert NNP 3344 140 2 A. A. NNP 3344 140 3 Gehring Gehring NNP 3344 140 4 notes note VBZ 3344 140 5 : : : 3344 140 6 But but CC 3344 140 7 a a DT 3344 140 8 DRM DRM NNP 3344 140 9 system system NN 3344 140 10 is be VBZ 3344 140 11 almost almost RB 3344 140 12 useless useless JJ 3344 140 13 , , , 3344 140 14 that that RB 3344 140 15 is is RB 3344 140 16 from from IN 3344 140 17 a a DT 3344 140 18 con- con- NN 3344 140 19 tent tent NN 3344 140 20 owner owner NN 3344 140 21 ’s ’s NNP 3344 140 22 perspective perspective NN 3344 140 23 , , , 3344 140 24 until until IN 3344 140 25 it -PRON- PRP 3344 140 26 is be VBZ 3344 140 27 deployed deploy VBN 3344 140 28 broadly broadly RB 3344 140 29 . . . 3344 141 1 Putting put VBG 3344 141 2 together together RB 3344 141 3 cheap cheap JJ 3344 141 4 TC TC NNP 3344 141 5 components component NNS 3344 141 6 with with IN 3344 141 7 a a DT 3344 141 8 market- market- NN 3344 141 9 dominating dominate VBG 3344 141 10 operating operating NN 3344 141 11 system system NN 3344 141 12 “ " `` 3344 141 13 enriched enrich VBN 3344 141 14 ” " '' 3344 141 15 with with IN 3344 141 16 DRM DRM NNP 3344 141 17 functionality functionality NN 3344 141 18 is be VBZ 3344 141 19 the the DT 3344 141 20 most most RBS 3344 141 21 economic economic JJ 3344 141 22 way way NN 3344 141 23 to to TO 3344 141 24 provide provide VB 3344 141 25 the the DT 3344 141 26 majority majority NN 3344 141 27 of of IN 3344 141 28 users user NNS 3344 141 29 with with IN 3344 141 30 “ " `` 3344 141 31 copyright copyright NN 3344 141 32 boxes box NNS 3344 141 33 . . . 3344 141 34 ”43 ”43 '' 3344 141 35 Seth Seth NNP 3344 141 36 Schoen Schoen NNP 3344 141 37 argues argue VBZ 3344 141 38 computer computer NN 3344 141 39 owners owner NNS 3344 141 40 should should MD 3344 141 41 be be VB 3344 141 42 empowered empower VBN 3344 141 43 to to TO 3344 141 44 override override VB 3344 141 45 certain certain JJ 3344 141 46 features feature NNS 3344 141 47 of of IN 3344 141 48 “ " `` 3344 141 49 trusted trust VBN 3344 141 50 com- com- NN 3344 141 51 puting puting NN 3344 141 52 architecture architecture NN 3344 141 53 ” " '' 3344 141 54 to to TO 3344 141 55 address address VB 3344 141 56 issues issue NNS 3344 141 57 with with IN 3344 141 58 “ " `` 3344 141 59 anti anti JJ 3344 141 60 - - JJ 3344 141 61 competi- competi- JJ 3344 141 62 tive tive JJ 3344 141 63 and and CC 3344 141 64 anti anti JJ 3344 141 65 - - JJ 3344 141 66 consumer consumer JJ 3344 141 67 behavior behavior NN 3344 141 68 ” " '' 3344 141 69 and and CC 3344 141 70 other other JJ 3344 141 71 problems.44 problems.44 NNP 3344 141 72 DRM DRM NNP 3344 141 73 could could MD 3344 141 74 potentially potentially RB 3344 141 75 be be VB 3344 141 76 legislatively legislatively RB 3344 141 77 mandated mandate VBN 3344 141 78 . . . 3344 142 1 There there EX 3344 142 2 is be VBZ 3344 142 3 a a DT 3344 142 4 closely closely RB 3344 142 5 related related JJ 3344 142 6 legal legal JJ 3344 142 7 precedent precedent NN 3344 142 8 , , , 3344 142 9 the the DT 3344 142 10 Audio Audio NNP 3344 142 11 Home Home NNP 3344 142 12 Recording Recording NNP 3344 142 13 Act Act NNP 3344 142 14 , , , 3344 142 15 which which WDT 3344 142 16 requires require VBZ 3344 142 17 that that IN 3344 142 18 digital digital JJ 3344 142 19 audiotape audiotape NN 3344 142 20 equip- equip- NNP 3344 142 21 ment ment NNP 3344 142 22 include include VBP 3344 142 23 special special JJ 3344 142 24 hardware hardware NN 3344 142 25 to to TO 3344 142 26 prevent prevent VB 3344 142 27 serial serial NN 3344 142 28 copying.45 copying.45 NNP 3344 142 29 There there EX 3344 142 30 is be VBZ 3344 142 31 currently currently RB 3344 142 32 a a DT 3344 142 33 bill bill NN 3344 142 34 before before IN 3344 142 35 Congress Congress NNP 3344 142 36 that that WDT 3344 142 37 would would MD 3344 142 38 require require VB 3344 142 39 use use NN 3344 142 40 of of IN 3344 142 41 a a DT 3344 142 42 “ " `` 3344 142 43 broadcast broadcast NN 3344 142 44 flag flag NN 3344 142 45 ” " '' 3344 142 46 ( ( -LRB- 3344 142 47 a a DT 3344 142 48 digital digital JJ 3344 142 49 marker marker NN 3344 142 50 ) ) -RRB- 3344 142 51 for for IN 3344 142 52 digital digital JJ 3344 142 53 broadcast broadcast NN 3344 142 54 and and CC 3344 142 55 satellite satellite NN 3344 142 56 radio radio NN 3344 142 57 receivers.46 receivers.46 NNP 3344 142 58 Last last JJ 3344 142 59 year year NN 3344 142 60 , , , 3344 142 61 a a DT 3344 142 62 similar similar JJ 3344 142 63 FCC FCC NNP 3344 142 64 regulation regulation NN 3344 142 65 for for IN 3344 142 66 broadcast broadcast VBN 3344 142 67 digital digital JJ 3344 142 68 television television NN 3344 142 69 was be VBD 3344 142 70 struck strike VBN 3344 142 71 down down RP 3344 142 72 by by IN 3344 142 73 a a DT 3344 142 74 federal federal JJ 3344 142 75 appeals appeal NNS 3344 142 76 court court NN 3344 142 77 ; ; : 3344 142 78 consequently consequently RB 3344 142 79 , , , 3344 142 80 the the DT 3344 142 81 current current JJ 3344 142 82 bill bill NN 3344 142 83 explicitly explicitly RB 3344 142 84 empowers empower VBZ 3344 142 85 the the DT 3344 142 86 FCC FCC NNP 3344 142 87 to to TO 3344 142 88 “ " `` 3344 142 89 enforce enforce VB 3344 142 90 ‘ ' '' 3344 142 91 prohibi- prohibi- JJ 3344 142 92 tions tion NNS 3344 142 93 against against IN 3344 142 94 unauthorized unauthorized JJ 3344 142 95 copying copying NN 3344 142 96 and and CC 3344 142 97 redistribution redistribution NN 3344 142 98 . . . 3344 142 99 ’”47 ’”47 '' 3344 142 100 Another another DT 3344 142 101 bill bill NN 3344 142 102 would would MD 3344 142 103 plug plug VB 3344 142 104 the the DT 3344 142 105 analog analog NN 3344 142 106 - - HYPH 3344 142 107 to to IN 3344 142 108 - - HYPH 3344 142 109 digital digital JJ 3344 142 110 video video NN 3344 142 111 analog analog NN 3344 142 112 hole hole NN 3344 142 113 by by IN 3344 142 114 putting put VBG 3344 142 115 “ " `` 3344 142 116 strict strict JJ 3344 142 117 legal legal JJ 3344 142 118 controls control NNS 3344 142 119 on on IN 3344 142 120 any any DT 3344 142 121 video video NN 3344 142 122 analog analog NN 3344 142 123 to to TO 3344 142 124 digital digital VB 3344 142 125 ( ( -LRB- 3344 142 126 A a NN 3344 142 127 / / SYM 3344 142 128 D d NN 3344 142 129 ) ) -RRB- 3344 142 130 convertors convertor NNS 3344 142 131 . . . 3344 142 132 ”48 ”48 NNP 3344 142 133 Whether whether IN 3344 142 134 these these DT 3344 142 135 bills bill NNS 3344 142 136 become become VBP 3344 142 137 law law NN 3344 142 138 or or CC 3344 142 139 not not RB 3344 142 140 , , , 3344 142 141 efforts effort NNS 3344 142 142 to to TO 3344 142 143 mandate mandate VB 3344 142 144 DRM DRM NNP 3344 142 145 are be VBP 3344 142 146 unlikely unlikely JJ 3344 142 147 to to TO 3344 142 148 end end VB 3344 142 149 . . . 3344 143 1 DMCA DMCA NNP 3344 143 2 strongly strongly RB 3344 143 3 supports support VBZ 3344 143 4 DRM DRM NNP 3344 143 5 by by IN 3344 143 6 prohibiting prohibit VBG 3344 143 7 both both CC 3344 143 8 the the DT 3344 143 9 circumvention circumvention NN 3344 143 10 of of IN 3344 143 11 technological technological JJ 3344 143 12 mechanisms mechanism NNS 3344 143 13 that that WDT 3344 143 14 control control VBP 3344 143 15 access access NN 3344 143 16 to to IN 3344 143 17 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 143 18 works work NNS 3344 143 19 ( ( -LRB- 3344 143 20 with with IN 3344 143 21 some some DT 3344 143 22 minor minor JJ 3344 143 23 exceptions exception NNS 3344 143 24 ) ) -RRB- 3344 143 25 and and CC 3344 143 26 the the DT 3344 143 27 “ " `` 3344 143 28 manufacture manufacture NN 3344 143 29 of of IN 3344 143 30 any any DT 3344 143 31 device device NN 3344 143 32 , , , 3344 143 33 composition composition NN 3344 143 34 of of IN 3344 143 35 any any DT 3344 143 36 program program NN 3344 143 37 , , , 3344 143 38 or or CC 3344 143 39 offering offering NN 3344 143 40 of of IN 3344 143 41 any any DT 3344 143 42 service service NN 3344 143 43 ” " '' 3344 143 44 to to TO 3344 143 45 do do VB 3344 143 46 so.49 so.49 NNP 3344 143 47 What what WP 3344 143 48 would would MD 3344 143 49 the the DT 3344 143 50 world world NN 3344 143 51 be be VB 3344 143 52 like like IN 3344 143 53 if if IN 3344 143 54 all all DT 3344 143 55 newly newly RB 3344 143 56 published publish VBN 3344 143 57 ( ( -LRB- 3344 143 58 or or CC 3344 143 59 released release VBN 3344 143 60 ) ) -RRB- 3344 143 61 commercially commercially RB 3344 143 62 created create VBN 3344 143 63 information information NN 3344 143 64 was be VBD 3344 143 65 in in IN 3344 143 66 digital digital JJ 3344 143 67 form form NN 3344 143 68 , , , 3344 143 69 protected protect VBN 3344 143 70 by by IN 3344 143 71 DRM DRM NNP 3344 143 72 ? ? . 3344 144 1 What what WP 3344 144 2 would would MD 3344 144 3 it -PRON- PRP 3344 144 4 be be VB 3344 144 5 like like IN 3344 144 6 if if IN 3344 144 7 all all DT 3344 144 8 old old JJ 3344 144 9 works work NNS 3344 144 10 in in IN 3344 144 11 print print NN 3344 144 12 and and CC 3344 144 13 analog analog NN 3344 144 14 formats format NNS 3344 144 15 were be VBD 3344 144 16 only only RB 3344 144 17 reissued reissue VBN 3344 144 18 in in IN 3344 144 19 digital digital JJ 3344 144 20 form form NN 3344 144 21 , , , 3344 144 22 protected protect VBN 3344 144 23 by by IN 3344 144 24 DRM DRM NNP 3344 144 25 ? ? . 3344 145 1 What what WP 3344 145 2 would would MD 3344 145 3 it -PRON- PRP 3344 145 4 be be VB 3344 145 5 like like IN 3344 145 6 if if IN 3344 145 7 all all DT 3344 145 8 hardware hardware NN 3344 145 9 that that WDT 3344 145 10 could could MD 3344 145 11 process process VB 3344 145 12 that that DT 3344 145 13 digital digital JJ 3344 145 14 information information NN 3344 145 15 had have VBD 3344 145 16 to to TO 3344 145 17 support support VB 3344 145 18 the the DT 3344 145 19 information information NN 3344 145 20 ’s ’s . 3344 145 21 DRM DRM NNP 3344 145 22 scheme scheme NN 3344 145 23 or or CC 3344 145 24 block block VB 3344 145 25 any any DT 3344 145 26 access access NN 3344 145 27 to to IN 3344 145 28 it -PRON- PRP 3344 145 29 because because IN 3344 145 30 this this DT 3344 145 31 was be VBD 3344 145 32 mandated mandate VBN 3344 145 33 by by IN 3344 145 34 law law NN 3344 145 35 ? ? . 3344 146 1 What what WP 3344 146 2 would would MD 3344 146 3 it -PRON- PRP 3344 146 4 be be VB 3344 146 5 122 122 CD 3344 146 6 INFORMATION information NN 3344 146 7 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3344 146 8 AND and CC 3344 146 9 LIBRARIES library NNS 3344 146 10 | | CD 3344 146 11 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3344 146 12 2006 2006 CD 3344 146 13 like like IN 3344 146 14 if if IN 3344 146 15 all all DT 3344 146 16 operating operate VBG 3344 146 17 systems system NNS 3344 146 18 had have VBD 3344 146 19 direct direct JJ 3344 146 20 or or CC 3344 146 21 indirect indirect JJ 3344 146 22 built build VBN 3344 146 23 - - HYPH 3344 146 24 in in RP 3344 146 25 support support NN 3344 146 26 for for IN 3344 146 27 DRM DRM NNP 3344 146 28 ? ? . 3344 147 1 Would Would MD 3344 147 2 “ " `` 3344 147 3 Progress Progress NNP 3344 147 4 of of IN 3344 147 5 Science Science NNP 3344 147 6 and and CC 3344 147 7 useful useful JJ 3344 147 8 Arts art NNS 3344 147 9 ” " '' 3344 147 10 be be VB 3344 147 11 promoted promote VBN 3344 147 12 or or CC 3344 147 13 squashed squash VBN 3344 147 14 ? ? . 3344 148 1 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 148 2 Weaker Weaker NNP 3344 148 3 Net net JJ 3344 148 4 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 148 5 Lessig Lessig NNPS 3344 148 6 identifies identify VBZ 3344 148 7 three three CD 3344 148 8 important important JJ 3344 148 9 characteristics characteristic NNS 3344 148 10 of of IN 3344 148 11 the the DT 3344 148 12 Internet internet NN 3344 148 13 that that WDT 3344 148 14 have have VBP 3344 148 15 fostered foster VBN 3344 148 16 innovation innovation NN 3344 148 17 : : : 3344 148 18 ( ( -LRB- 3344 148 19 1 1 LS 3344 148 20 ) ) -RRB- 3344 148 21 edge edge NN 3344 148 22 architec- architec- NNP 3344 148 23 ture ture NN 3344 148 24 : : : 3344 148 25 software software NN 3344 148 26 applications application NNS 3344 148 27 run run VBP 3344 148 28 on on IN 3344 148 29 servers server NNS 3344 148 30 connected connect VBN 3344 148 31 to to IN 3344 148 32 the the DT 3344 148 33 network network NN 3344 148 34 , , , 3344 148 35 rather rather RB 3344 148 36 than than IN 3344 148 37 on on IN 3344 148 38 the the DT 3344 148 39 network network NN 3344 148 40 itself -PRON- PRP 3344 148 41 , , , 3344 148 42 ensuring ensure VBG 3344 148 43 that that IN 3344 148 44 the the DT 3344 148 45 network network NN 3344 148 46 itself -PRON- PRP 3344 148 47 does do VBZ 3344 148 48 not not RB 3344 148 49 have have VB 3344 148 50 to to TO 3344 148 51 be be VB 3344 148 52 modified modify VBN 3344 148 53 for for IN 3344 148 54 new new JJ 3344 148 55 or or CC 3344 148 56 updated update VBN 3344 148 57 applications application NNS 3344 148 58 to to TO 3344 148 59 run run VB 3344 148 60 ; ; : 3344 148 61 ( ( -LRB- 3344 148 62 2 2 LS 3344 148 63 ) ) -RRB- 3344 148 64 no no DT 3344 148 65 application application NN 3344 148 66 optimization optimization NN 3344 148 67 : : : 3344 148 68 a a DT 3344 148 69 relatively relatively RB 3344 148 70 simple simple JJ 3344 148 71 , , , 3344 148 72 but but CC 3344 148 73 effective effective JJ 3344 148 74 , , , 3344 148 75 protocol protocol NNP 3344 148 76 is be VBZ 3344 148 77 utilized utilize VBN 3344 148 78 ( ( -LRB- 3344 148 79 Internet Internet NNP 3344 148 80 Protocol Protocol NNP 3344 148 81 ) ) -RRB- 3344 148 82 that that DT 3344 148 83 is be VBZ 3344 148 84 indifferent indifferent JJ 3344 148 85 to to IN 3344 148 86 what what WDT 3344 148 87 software software NN 3344 148 88 applications application NNS 3344 148 89 run run VBP 3344 148 90 on on IN 3344 148 91 top top NN 3344 148 92 of of IN 3344 148 93 it -PRON- PRP 3344 148 94 , , , 3344 148 95 again again RB 3344 148 96 insulating insulate VBG 3344 148 97 the the DT 3344 148 98 network network NN 3344 148 99 from from IN 3344 148 100 application application NN 3344 148 101 changes change NNS 3344 148 102 ; ; : 3344 148 103 and and CC 3344 148 104 ( ( -LRB- 3344 148 105 3 3 LS 3344 148 106 ) ) -RRB- 3344 148 107 neutral neutral JJ 3344 148 108 platform platform NN 3344 148 109 : : : 3344 148 110 the the DT 3344 148 111 network network NN 3344 148 112 does do VBZ 3344 148 113 not not RB 3344 148 114 prefer prefer VB 3344 148 115 certain certain JJ 3344 148 116 data data NN 3344 148 117 packets packet NNS 3344 148 118 or or CC 3344 148 119 deny deny VB 3344 148 120 certain certain JJ 3344 148 121 packets packet NNS 3344 148 122 access.50 access.50 NNP 3344 148 123 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 148 124 ’s ’s POS 3344 148 125 conceptual conceptual JJ 3344 148 126 model model NN 3344 148 127 is be VBZ 3344 148 128 very very RB 3344 148 129 useful useful JJ 3344 148 130 when when WRB 3344 148 131 thinking think VBG 3344 148 132 about about IN 3344 148 133 Net net JJ 3344 148 134 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 148 135 , , , 3344 148 136 a a DT 3344 148 137 topic topic NN 3344 148 138 of of IN 3344 148 139 growing grow VBG 3344 148 140 concern concern NN 3344 148 141 . . . 3344 149 1 EDUCAUSE EDUCAUSE NNP 3344 149 2 ’s ’s , 3344 149 3 definition definition NN 3344 149 4 of of IN 3344 149 5 Net net JJ 3344 149 6 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 149 7 aptly aptly RB 3344 149 8 cap- cap- JJ 3344 149 9 tures ture NNS 3344 149 10 these these DT 3344 149 11 concerns concern NNS 3344 149 12 : : : 3344 149 13 “ " `` 3344 149 14 Net net JJ 3344 149 15 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 149 16 ” " '' 3344 149 17 is be VBZ 3344 149 18 the the DT 3344 149 19 term term NN 3344 149 20 used use VBN 3344 149 21 to to TO 3344 149 22 describe describe VB 3344 149 23 the the DT 3344 149 24 concept concept NN 3344 149 25 of of IN 3344 149 26 keeping keep VBG 3344 149 27 the the DT 3344 149 28 Internet internet NN 3344 149 29 open open JJ 3344 149 30 to to IN 3344 149 31 all all DT 3344 149 32 lawful lawful JJ 3344 149 33 content content NN 3344 149 34 , , , 3344 149 35 infor- infor- NNP 3344 149 36 mation mation NN 3344 149 37 , , , 3344 149 38 applications application NNS 3344 149 39 , , , 3344 149 40 and and CC 3344 149 41 equipment equipment NN 3344 149 42 . . . 3344 150 1 There there EX 3344 150 2 is be VBZ 3344 150 3 increasing increase VBG 3344 150 4 concern concern NN 3344 150 5 that that IN 3344 150 6 the the DT 3344 150 7 owners owner NNS 3344 150 8 of of IN 3344 150 9 the the DT 3344 150 10 local local JJ 3344 150 11 broadband broadband NN 3344 150 12 connec- connec- NN 3344 150 13 tions tion NNS 3344 150 14 ( ( -LRB- 3344 150 15 usually usually RB 3344 150 16 either either CC 3344 150 17 the the DT 3344 150 18 cable cable NN 3344 150 19 or or CC 3344 150 20 telephone telephone NN 3344 150 21 company company NN 3344 150 22 ) ) -RRB- 3344 150 23 may may MD 3344 150 24 block block VB 3344 150 25 or or CC 3344 150 26 discriminate discriminate VB 3344 150 27 against against IN 3344 150 28 certain certain JJ 3344 150 29 Internet internet NN 3344 150 30 users user NNS 3344 150 31 or or CC 3344 150 32 applications application NNS 3344 150 33 in in IN 3344 150 34 order order NN 3344 150 35 to to TO 3344 150 36 give give VB 3344 150 37 an an DT 3344 150 38 advantage advantage NN 3344 150 39 to to IN 3344 150 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 150 41 own own JJ 3344 150 42 services service NNS 3344 150 43 . . . 3344 151 1 While while IN 3344 151 2 the the DT 3344 151 3 owners owner NNS 3344 151 4 of of IN 3344 151 5 the the DT 3344 151 6 local local JJ 3344 151 7 network network NN 3344 151 8 have have VBP 3344 151 9 a a DT 3344 151 10 legitimate legitimate JJ 3344 151 11 right right NN 3344 151 12 to to TO 3344 151 13 manage manage VB 3344 151 14 traffic traffic NN 3344 151 15 on on IN 3344 151 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 151 17 network network NN 3344 151 18 to to TO 3344 151 19 pre- pre- VB 3344 151 20 vent vent NN 3344 151 21 congestion congestion NN 3344 151 22 , , , 3344 151 23 viruses virus NNS 3344 151 24 , , , 3344 151 25 and and CC 3344 151 26 so so RB 3344 151 27 forth forth RB 3344 151 28 , , , 3344 151 29 network network NN 3344 151 30 owners owner NNS 3344 151 31 should should MD 3344 151 32 not not RB 3344 151 33 be be VB 3344 151 34 able able JJ 3344 151 35 to to TO 3344 151 36 block block VB 3344 151 37 or or CC 3344 151 38 degrade degrade VB 3344 151 39 traffic traffic NN 3344 151 40 based base VBN 3344 151 41 on on IN 3344 151 42 the the DT 3344 151 43 identity identity NN 3344 151 44 of of IN 3344 151 45 the the DT 3344 151 46 user user NN 3344 151 47 or or CC 3344 151 48 the the DT 3344 151 49 type type NN 3344 151 50 of of IN 3344 151 51 application application NN 3344 151 52 solely solely RB 3344 151 53 to to TO 3344 151 54 favor favor VB 3344 151 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 151 56 interests.51 interests.51 NNP 3344 151 57 For for IN 3344 151 58 some some DT 3344 151 59 time time NN 3344 151 60 , , , 3344 151 61 there there EX 3344 151 62 have have VBP 3344 151 63 been be VBN 3344 151 64 fears fear NNS 3344 151 65 that that IN 3344 151 66 Net net JJ 3344 151 67 neutral- neutral- NN 3344 151 68 ity ity NN 3344 151 69 was be VBD 3344 151 70 endangered endanger VBN 3344 151 71 as as IN 3344 151 72 the the DT 3344 151 73 Internet internet NN 3344 151 74 became become VBD 3344 151 75 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 151 76 commercialized commercialize VBN 3344 151 77 , , , 3344 151 78 a a DT 3344 151 79 greater great JJR 3344 151 80 percentage percentage NN 3344 151 81 of of IN 3344 151 82 home home NN 3344 151 83 Internet internet NN 3344 151 84 users user NNS 3344 151 85 migrated migrate VBN 3344 151 86 to to IN 3344 151 87 broadband broadband NN 3344 151 88 connections connection NNS 3344 151 89 not not RB 3344 151 90 regulated regulate VBN 3344 151 91 by by IN 3344 151 92 common common JJ 3344 151 93 carrier carrier NN 3344 151 94 laws law NNS 3344 151 95 , , , 3344 151 96 and and CC 3344 151 97 telecommunications telecommunications NN 3344 151 98 mergers merger NNS 3344 151 99 ( ( -LRB- 3344 151 100 and and CC 3344 151 101 vertical vertical JJ 3344 151 102 integration integration NN 3344 151 103 ) ) -RRB- 3344 151 104 accelerated accelerate VBD 3344 151 105 . . . 3344 152 1 Some some DT 3344 152 2 of of IN 3344 152 3 these these DT 3344 152 4 fears fear NNS 3344 152 5 are be VBP 3344 152 6 now now RB 3344 152 7 appearing appear VBG 3344 152 8 to to TO 3344 152 9 be be VB 3344 152 10 realized realize VBN 3344 152 11 , , , 3344 152 12 albeit albeit IN 3344 152 13 with with IN 3344 152 14 resistance resistance NN 3344 152 15 by by IN 3344 152 16 the the DT 3344 152 17 Internet internet NN 3344 152 18 community community NN 3344 152 19 . . . 3344 153 1 For for IN 3344 153 2 example example NN 3344 153 3 , , , 3344 153 4 AOL AOL NNP 3344 153 5 has have VBZ 3344 153 6 indicated indicate VBN 3344 153 7 that that IN 3344 153 8 it -PRON- PRP 3344 153 9 will will MD 3344 153 10 implement implement VB 3344 153 11 a a DT 3344 153 12 two two CD 3344 153 13 - - HYPH 3344 153 14 tier tier NN 3344 153 15 e e NN 3344 153 16 - - NN 3344 153 17 mail mail NN 3344 153 18 system system NN 3344 153 19 for for IN 3344 153 20 companies company NNS 3344 153 21 , , , 3344 153 22 nonprofits nonprofit NNS 3344 153 23 , , , 3344 153 24 and and CC 3344 153 25 others other NNS 3344 153 26 who who WP 3344 153 27 send send VBP 3344 153 28 mass mass NN 3344 153 29 mailings mailing NNS 3344 153 30 : : : 3344 153 31 those those DT 3344 153 32 who who WP 3344 153 33 pay pay VBP 3344 153 34 bypass bypass NN 3344 153 35 spam spam NN 3344 153 36 filters filter NNS 3344 153 37 , , , 3344 153 38 those those DT 3344 153 39 who who WP 3344 153 40 do do VBP 3344 153 41 n’t not RB 3344 153 42 pay pay VB 3344 153 43 do do VBP 3344 153 44 n’t not RB 3344 153 45 bypass bypass VB 3344 153 46 spam spam NN 3344 153 47 filters.52 filters.52 NNP 3344 153 48 Critics Critics NNP 3344 153 49 fear fear VBP 3344 153 50 that that IN 3344 153 51 free free JJ 3344 153 52 e e NN 3344 153 53 - - NN 3344 153 54 mail mail NN 3344 153 55 services service NNS 3344 153 56 will will MD 3344 153 57 deterio- deterio- XX 3344 153 58 rate rate NN 3344 153 59 under under IN 3344 153 60 a a DT 3344 153 61 two two CD 3344 153 62 - - HYPH 3344 153 63 tier tier NN 3344 153 64 system system NN 3344 153 65 . . . 3344 154 1 Facing face VBG 3344 154 2 fierce fierce JJ 3344 154 3 criticism criticism NN 3344 154 4 from from IN 3344 154 5 the the DT 3344 154 6 DearAOL.com DearAOL.com NNP 3344 154 7 Coalition Coalition NNP 3344 154 8 and and CC 3344 154 9 many many JJ 3344 154 10 others other NNS 3344 154 11 , , , 3344 154 12 AOL AOL NNP 3344 154 13 has have VBZ 3344 154 14 relented relent VBN 3344 154 15 somewhat somewhat RB 3344 154 16 on on IN 3344 154 17 the the DT 3344 154 18 nonprofit nonprofit JJ 3344 154 19 issue issue NN 3344 154 20 by by IN 3344 154 21 offering offer VBG 3344 154 22 special special JJ 3344 154 23 treatment treatment NN 3344 154 24 for for IN 3344 154 25 “ " `` 3344 154 26 qualified qualified JJ 3344 154 27 ” " '' 3344 154 28 nonprofits nonprofit NNS 3344 154 29 . . . 3344 155 1 A a DT 3344 155 2 second second JJ 3344 155 3 example example NN 3344 155 4 is be VBZ 3344 155 5 that that IN 3344 155 6 an an DT 3344 155 7 analysis analysis NN 3344 155 8 of of IN 3344 155 9 Verizon Verizon NNP 3344 155 10 ’s ’s NNP 3344 155 11 FCC FCC NNP 3344 155 12 filings filing NNS 3344 155 13 reveals reveal VBZ 3344 155 14 that that IN 3344 155 15 “ " `` 3344 155 16 more more JJR 3344 155 17 than than IN 3344 155 18 80 80 CD 3344 155 19 % % NN 3344 155 20 of of IN 3344 155 21 Verizon Verizon NNP 3344 155 22 ’s ’s NNP 3344 155 23 current current JJ 3344 155 24 capacity capacity NN 3344 155 25 is be VBZ 3344 155 26 earmarked earmark VBN 3344 155 27 for for IN 3344 155 28 carrying carry VBG 3344 155 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 155 30 service service NN 3344 155 31 , , , 3344 155 32 while while IN 3344 155 33 all all DT 3344 155 34 other other JJ 3344 155 35 traffic traffic NN 3344 155 36 jostles jostle NNS 3344 155 37 in in IN 3344 155 38 the the DT 3344 155 39 remainder remainder NN 3344 155 40 . . . 3344 155 41 ”53 ”53 NNP 3344 155 42 Content content NN 3344 155 43 - - HYPH 3344 155 44 oriented orient VBN 3344 155 45 Net net JJ 3344 155 46 companies company NNS 3344 155 47 are be VBP 3344 155 48 worried worried JJ 3344 155 49 : : : 3344 155 50 Leading lead VBG 3344 155 51 Net net JJ 3344 155 52 companies company NNS 3344 155 53 say say VBP 3344 155 54 that that IN 3344 155 55 Verizon Verizon NNP 3344 155 56 ’s ’s NNP 3344 155 57 actions action NNS 3344 155 58 could could MD 3344 155 59 keep keep VB 3344 155 60 some some DT 3344 155 61 rivals rival NNS 3344 155 62 off off IN 3344 155 63 the the DT 3344 155 64 road road NN 3344 155 65 . . . 3344 156 1 As as IN 3344 156 2 consumers consumer NNS 3344 156 3 try try VBP 3344 156 4 to to TO 3344 156 5 search search VB 3344 156 6 Google Google NNP 3344 156 7 , , , 3344 156 8 buy buy VB 3344 156 9 books book NNS 3344 156 10 on on IN 3344 156 11 Amazon.com Amazon.com NNP 3344 156 12 , , , 3344 156 13 or or CC 3344 156 14 watch watch VB 3344 156 15 videos video NNS 3344 156 16 on on IN 3344 156 17 Yahoo Yahoo NNP 3344 156 18 ! ! . 3344 156 19 , , , 3344 156 20 they -PRON- PRP 3344 156 21 ’ll will MD 3344 156 22 all all DT 3344 156 23 be be VB 3344 156 24 trying try VBG 3344 156 25 to to TO 3344 156 26 squeeze squeeze VB 3344 156 27 into into IN 3344 156 28 the the DT 3344 156 29 leftover leftover NN 3344 156 30 lanes lane NNS 3344 156 31 on on IN 3344 156 32 Verizon Verizon NNP 3344 156 33 ’s ’s NNP 3344 156 34 network network NN 3344 156 35 . . . 3344 157 1 . . . 3344 158 1 . . . 3344 159 1 . . . 3344 160 1 “ " `` 3344 160 2 The the DT 3344 160 3 Bells Bells NNPS 3344 160 4 have have VBP 3344 160 5 designed design VBN 3344 160 6 a a DT 3344 160 7 broadband broadband NN 3344 160 8 system system NN 3344 160 9 that that WDT 3344 160 10 squeezes squeeze VBZ 3344 160 11 out out RP 3344 160 12 the the DT 3344 160 13 public public JJ 3344 160 14 Internet internet NN 3344 160 15 in in IN 3344 160 16 favor favor NN 3344 160 17 of of IN 3344 160 18 services service NNS 3344 160 19 or or CC 3344 160 20 content content NN 3344 160 21 they -PRON- PRP 3344 160 22 want want VBP 3344 160 23 to to TO 3344 160 24 provide provide VB 3344 160 25 , , , 3344 160 26 ” " '' 3344 160 27 says say VBZ 3344 160 28 Paul Paul NNP 3344 160 29 Misener Misener NNP 3344 160 30 , , , 3344 160 31 vice vice NN 3344 160 32 - - HYPH 3344 160 33 president president NN 3344 160 34 for for IN 3344 160 35 global global JJ 3344 160 36 policy policy NN 3344 160 37 at at IN 3344 160 38 Amazon.com.54 Amazon.com.54 NNP 3344 160 39 A a DT 3344 160 40 third third JJ 3344 160 41 example example NN 3344 160 42 is be VBZ 3344 160 43 a a DT 3344 160 44 comment comment NN 3344 160 45 by by IN 3344 160 46 William William NNP 3344 160 47 L. L. NNP 3344 160 48 Smith Smith NNP 3344 160 49 , , , 3344 160 50 BellSouth BellSouth NNP 3344 160 51 ‘s 's NNP 3344 160 52 chief chief JJ 3344 160 53 technology technology NN 3344 160 54 officer officer NN 3344 160 55 , , , 3344 160 56 who who WP 3344 160 57 “ " `` 3344 160 58 told tell VBD 3344 160 59 reporters reporter NNS 3344 160 60 and and CC 3344 160 61 analysts analyst NNS 3344 160 62 that that IN 3344 160 63 an an DT 3344 160 64 Internet internet NN 3344 160 65 service service NN 3344 160 66 provider provider NN 3344 160 67 such such JJ 3344 160 68 as as IN 3344 160 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 160 70 firm firm NN 3344 160 71 should should MD 3344 160 72 be be VB 3344 160 73 able able JJ 3344 160 74 , , , 3344 160 75 for for IN 3344 160 76 example example NN 3344 160 77 , , , 3344 160 78 to to TO 3344 160 79 charge charge VB 3344 160 80 Yahoo Yahoo NNP 3344 160 81 Inc. Inc. NNP 3344 160 82 for for IN 3344 160 83 the the DT 3344 160 84 opportunity opportunity NN 3344 160 85 to to TO 3344 160 86 have have VB 3344 160 87 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 160 88 search search NN 3344 160 89 site site NN 3344 160 90 load load NN 3344 160 91 faster fast RBR 3344 160 92 than than IN 3344 160 93 that that DT 3344 160 94 of of IN 3344 160 95 Google Google NNP 3344 160 96 Inc. Inc. NNP 3344 160 97 , , , 3344 160 98 ” " '' 3344 160 99 but but CC 3344 160 100 qualified qualify VBD 3344 160 101 this this DT 3344 160 102 assertion assertion NN 3344 160 103 by by IN 3344 160 104 indicat- indicat- NN 3344 160 105 ing ing NNP 3344 160 106 that that IN 3344 160 107 “ " `` 3344 160 108 a a DT 3344 160 109 pay pay VB 3344 160 110 - - HYPH 3344 160 111 for for IN 3344 160 112 - - HYPH 3344 160 113 performance performance NN 3344 160 114 marketplace marketplace NN 3344 160 115 should should MD 3344 160 116 be be VB 3344 160 117 allowed allow VBN 3344 160 118 to to TO 3344 160 119 develop develop VB 3344 160 120 on on IN 3344 160 121 top top NN 3344 160 122 of of IN 3344 160 123 a a DT 3344 160 124 baseline baseline NN 3344 160 125 service service NN 3344 160 126 level level NN 3344 160 127 that that WDT 3344 160 128 all all DT 3344 160 129 content content NN 3344 160 130 providers provider NNS 3344 160 131 would would MD 3344 160 132 enjoy enjoy VB 3344 160 133 . . . 3344 160 134 ”55 ”55 '' 3344 160 135 About about RB 3344 160 136 four four CD 3344 160 137 months month NNS 3344 160 138 later later RB 3344 160 139 , , , 3344 160 140 AT&T AT&T NNP 3344 160 141 announced announce VBD 3344 160 142 that that IN 3344 160 143 it -PRON- PRP 3344 160 144 would would MD 3344 160 145 acquire acquire VB 3344 160 146 BellSouth BellSouth NNP 3344 160 147 , , , 3344 160 148 after after IN 3344 160 149 which which WDT 3344 160 150 it -PRON- PRP 3344 160 151 “ " `` 3344 160 152 will will MD 3344 160 153 be be VB 3344 160 154 the the DT 3344 160 155 local local JJ 3344 160 156 carrier carrier NN 3344 160 157 in in IN 3344 160 158 22 22 CD 3344 160 159 states state NNS 3344 160 160 covering cover VBG 3344 160 161 more more JJR 3344 160 162 than than IN 3344 160 163 half half NN 3344 160 164 of of IN 3344 160 165 the the DT 3344 160 166 American american JJ 3344 160 167 population population NN 3344 160 168 . . . 3344 160 169 ”56 ”56 NNP 3344 160 170 Finally finally RB 3344 160 171 , , , 3344 160 172 in in IN 3344 160 173 a a DT 3344 160 174 white white JJ 3344 160 175 paper paper NN 3344 160 176 for for IN 3344 160 177 Public Public NNP 3344 160 178 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3344 160 179 , , , 3344 160 180 John John NNP 3344 160 181 Windhausen Windhausen NNP 3344 160 182 Jr. Jr. NNP 3344 160 183 states state VBZ 3344 160 184 : : : 3344 160 185 This this DT 3344 160 186 concern concern NN 3344 160 187 is be VBZ 3344 160 188 not not RB 3344 160 189 just just RB 3344 160 190 theoretical theoretical JJ 3344 160 191 — — : 3344 160 192 broadband broadband NN 3344 160 193 network network NN 3344 160 194 providers provider NNS 3344 160 195 are be VBP 3344 160 196 taking take VBG 3344 160 197 advantage advantage NN 3344 160 198 of of IN 3344 160 199 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 160 200 unregulated unregulated JJ 3344 160 201 status status NN 3344 160 202 . . . 3344 161 1 Cable cable NN 3344 161 2 operators operator NNS 3344 161 3 have have VBP 3344 161 4 barred bar VBN 3344 161 5 consumers consumer NNS 3344 161 6 from from IN 3344 161 7 using use VBG 3344 161 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 161 9 cable cable NN 3344 161 10 modems modem NNS 3344 161 11 for for IN 3344 161 12 virtual virtual JJ 3344 161 13 private private JJ 3344 161 14 networks network NNS 3344 161 15 and and CC 3344 161 16 home home NN 3344 161 17 networking networking NN 3344 161 18 and and CC 3344 161 19 blocked block VBD 3344 161 20 streaming stream VBG 3344 161 21 video video NN 3344 161 22 applications application NNS 3344 161 23 . . . 3344 162 1 Telephone telephone NN 3344 162 2 and and CC 3344 162 3 wireless wireless NN 3344 162 4 companies company NNS 3344 162 5 have have VBP 3344 162 6 blocked block VBN 3344 162 7 Internet internet NN 3344 162 8 telephone telephone NN 3344 162 9 ( ( -LRB- 3344 162 10 VoIP voip NN 3344 162 11 — — : 3344 162 12 Voice Voice NNP 3344 162 13 over over IN 3344 162 14 the the DT 3344 162 15 Internet Internet NNP 3344 162 16 Protocol Protocol NNP 3344 162 17 ) ) -RRB- 3344 162 18 traffic traffic NN 3344 162 19 outright outright RB 3344 162 20 in in IN 3344 162 21 order order NN 3344 162 22 to to TO 3344 162 23 protect protect VB 3344 162 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 162 25 own own JJ 3344 162 26 telephone telephone NN 3344 162 27 service service NN 3344 162 28 revenues.57 revenues.57 NNP 3344 162 29 These these DT 3344 162 30 and and CC 3344 162 31 similar similar JJ 3344 162 32 examples example NNS 3344 162 33 are be VBP 3344 162 34 harbingers harbinger NNS 3344 162 35 of of IN 3344 162 36 troubled troubled JJ 3344 162 37 days day NNS 3344 162 38 ahead ahead RB 3344 162 39 for for IN 3344 162 40 Net net JJ 3344 162 41 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 162 42 . . . 3344 163 1 The the DT 3344 163 2 canary canary NN 3344 163 3 in in IN 3344 163 4 the the DT 3344 163 5 Net net JJ 3344 163 6 neu- neu- NN 3344 163 7 trality trality NN 3344 163 8 mine mine NN 3344 163 9 is be VBZ 3344 163 10 n’t not RB 3344 163 11 dead dead JJ 3344 163 12 yet yet RB 3344 163 13 , , , 3344 163 14 but but CC 3344 163 15 it -PRON- PRP 3344 163 16 ’s ’ VBZ 3344 163 17 getting get VBG 3344 163 18 very very RB 3344 163 19 nervous nervous JJ 3344 163 20 . . . 3344 164 1 The the DT 3344 164 2 bottom bottom JJ 3344 164 3 line line NN 3344 164 4 ? ? . 3344 165 1 Noted note VBN 3344 165 2 OA OA NNP 3344 165 3 advocate advocate NN 3344 165 4 Peter Peter NNP 3344 165 5 Suber Suber NNP 3344 165 6 analyzes analyze VBZ 3344 165 7 the the DT 3344 165 8 situation situation NN 3344 165 9 as as IN 3344 165 10 follows follow VBZ 3344 165 11 : : : 3344 165 12 But but CC 3344 165 13 now now RB 3344 165 14 cable cable NN 3344 165 15 and and CC 3344 165 16 telecom telecom NN 3344 165 17 companies company NNS 3344 165 18 want want VBP 3344 165 19 to to TO 3344 165 20 discrimi- discrimi- VB 3344 165 21 nate nate NNP 3344 165 22 , , , 3344 165 23 charge charge VB 3344 165 24 premium premium NN 3344 165 25 prices price NNS 3344 165 26 for for IN 3344 165 27 premium premium NN 3344 165 28 service service NN 3344 165 29 , , , 3344 165 30 and and CC 3344 165 31 give give VB 3344 165 32 second second JJ 3344 165 33 - - HYPH 3344 165 34 rate rate NN 3344 165 35 service service NN 3344 165 36 to to IN 3344 165 37 everyone everyone NN 3344 165 38 else else RB 3344 165 39 . . . 3344 166 1 If if IN 3344 166 2 we -PRON- PRP 3344 166 3 relax relax VBP 3344 166 4 the the DT 3344 166 5 principle principle NN 3344 166 6 of of IN 3344 166 7 net net JJ 3344 166 8 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 166 9 , , , 3344 166 10 then then RB 3344 166 11 ISPs isp NNS 3344 166 12 could could MD 3344 166 13 , , , 3344 166 14 if if IN 3344 166 15 they -PRON- PRP 3344 166 16 wanted want VBD 3344 166 17 , , , 3344 166 18 limit limit VB 3344 166 19 the the DT 3344 166 20 software software NN 3344 166 21 and and CC 3344 166 22 hardware hardware NN 3344 166 23 you -PRON- PRP 3344 166 24 could could MD 3344 166 25 con- con- VB 3344 166 26 nect nect VB 3344 166 27 to to IN 3344 166 28 the the DT 3344 166 29 net net NN 3344 166 30 . . . 3344 167 1 They -PRON- PRP 3344 167 2 could could MD 3344 167 3 charge charge VB 3344 167 4 you -PRON- PRP 3344 167 5 more more RBR 3344 167 6 if if IN 3344 167 7 you -PRON- PRP 3344 167 8 send send VBP 3344 167 9 or or CC 3344 167 10 receive receive VBP 3344 167 11 more more JJR 3344 167 12 than than IN 3344 167 13 a a DT 3344 167 14 set set VBN 3344 167 15 number number NN 3344 167 16 of of IN 3344 167 17 emails email NNS 3344 167 18 . . . 3344 168 1 They -PRON- PRP 3344 168 2 could could MD 3344 168 3 block block VB 3344 168 4 emails email NNS 3344 168 5 containing contain VBG 3344 168 6 certain certain JJ 3344 168 7 keywords keyword NNS 3344 168 8 or or CC 3344 168 9 emails email NNS 3344 168 10 from from IN 3344 168 11 people people NNS 3344 168 12 or or CC 3344 168 13 organizations organization NNS 3344 168 14 they -PRON- PRP 3344 168 15 disliked dislike VBD 3344 168 16 , , , 3344 168 17 and and CC 3344 168 18 block block VB 3344 168 19 traffic traffic NN 3344 168 20 to to IN 3344 168 21 or or CC 3344 168 22 from from IN 3344 168 23 competitor competitor NN 3344 168 24 web web NN 3344 168 25 sites site NNS 3344 168 26 . . . 3344 169 1 They -PRON- PRP 3344 169 2 could could MD 3344 169 3 make make VB 3344 169 4 filtered filtered JJ 3344 169 5 service service NN 3344 169 6 the the DT 3344 169 7 default default NN 3344 169 8 and and CC 3344 169 9 force force NN 3344 169 10 users user NNS 3344 169 11 to to TO 3344 169 12 pay pay VB 3344 169 13 extra extra JJ 3344 169 14 for for IN 3344 169 15 the the DT 3344 169 16 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 3344 169 17 DYSTOPIA DYSTOPIA NNP 3344 169 18 | | NNP 3344 169 19 BAILEY BAILEY NNP 3344 169 20 123 123 CD 3344 169 21 wide wide JJ 3344 169 22 open open JJ 3344 169 23 internet internet NN 3344 169 24 . . . 3344 170 1 If if IN 3344 170 2 you -PRON- PRP 3344 170 3 tried try VBD 3344 170 4 to to TO 3344 170 5 shop shop VB 3344 170 6 at at IN 3344 170 7 a a DT 3344 170 8 store store NN 3344 170 9 that that WDT 3344 170 10 has have VBZ 3344 170 11 n’t not RB 3344 170 12 paid pay VBN 3344 170 13 them -PRON- PRP 3344 170 14 a a DT 3344 170 15 kickback kickback NN 3344 170 16 , , , 3344 170 17 they -PRON- PRP 3344 170 18 could could MD 3344 170 19 steer steer VB 3344 170 20 you -PRON- PRP 3344 170 21 to to IN 3344 170 22 a a DT 3344 170 23 store store NN 3344 170 24 that that WDT 3344 170 25 has have VBZ 3344 170 26 . . . 3344 171 1 . . . 3344 172 1 . . . 3344 173 1 . . . 3344 174 1 If if IN 3344 174 2 companies company NNS 3344 174 3 like like IN 3344 174 4 AT&T AT&T NNP 3344 174 5 and and CC 3344 174 6 Verizon Verizon NNP 3344 174 7 have have VBP 3344 174 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 174 9 way way NN 3344 174 10 , , , 3344 174 11 there there EX 3344 174 12 will will MD 3344 174 13 be be VB 3344 174 14 two two CD 3344 174 15 tiers tier NNS 3344 174 16 of of IN 3344 174 17 internet internet NN 3344 174 18 service service NN 3344 174 19 : : : 3344 174 20 fast fast JJ 3344 174 21 and and CC 3344 174 22 expensive expensive JJ 3344 174 23 and and CC 3344 174 24 slow slow JJ 3344 174 25 and and CC 3344 174 26 cheap cheap JJ 3344 174 27 ( ( -LRB- 3344 174 28 or or CC 3344 174 29 cheaper cheap JJR 3344 174 30 ) ) -RRB- 3344 174 31 . . . 3344 175 1 We -PRON- PRP 3344 175 2 unwealthy unwealthy JJ 3344 175 3 users user NNS 3344 175 4 — — : 3344 175 5 students student NNS 3344 175 6 , , , 3344 175 7 scholars scholar NNS 3344 175 8 , , , 3344 175 9 universities university NNS 3344 175 10 , , , 3344 175 11 and and CC 3344 175 12 small small JJ 3344 175 13 publishers publisher NNS 3344 175 14 — — : 3344 175 15 wouldn't wouldn't CC 3344 175 16 be be VB 3344 175 17 forced force VBN 3344 175 18 offline offline JJ 3344 175 19 , , , 3344 175 20 just just RB 3344 175 21 forced force VBN 3344 175 22 into into IN 3344 175 23 the the DT 3344 175 24 slow slow JJ 3344 175 25 lane lane NN 3344 175 26 . . . 3344 176 1 Because because IN 3344 176 2 the the DT 3344 176 3 fast fast JJ 3344 176 4 lane lane NN 3344 176 5 would would MD 3344 176 6 reserve reserve VB 3344 176 7 a a DT 3344 176 8 chunk chunk NN 3344 176 9 of of IN 3344 176 10 bandwidth bandwidth NN 3344 176 11 for for IN 3344 176 12 the the DT 3344 176 13 wealthy wealthy JJ 3344 176 14 , , , 3344 176 15 the the DT 3344 176 16 peons peon NNS 3344 176 17 would would MD 3344 176 18 crowd crowd VB 3344 176 19 together together RB 3344 176 20 in in IN 3344 176 21 what what WP 3344 176 22 remained remain VBD 3344 176 23 , , , 3344 176 24 reducing reduce VBG 3344 176 25 service service NN 3344 176 26 below below IN 3344 176 27 current current JJ 3344 176 28 levels level NNS 3344 176 29 . . . 3344 177 1 New new JJ 3344 177 2 services service NNS 3344 177 3 starting start VBG 3344 177 4 in in IN 3344 177 5 the the DT 3344 177 6 slow slow JJ 3344 177 7 lane lane NN 3344 177 8 would would MD 3344 177 9 n't not RB 3344 177 10 have have VB 3344 177 11 a a DT 3344 177 12 fighting fight VBG 3344 177 13 chance chance NN 3344 177 14 against against IN 3344 177 15 entrenched entrenched JJ 3344 177 16 players player NNS 3344 177 17 in in IN 3344 177 18 the the DT 3344 177 19 fast fast JJ 3344 177 20 lane lane NN 3344 177 21 . . . 3344 178 1 Think think VB 3344 178 2 about about IN 3344 178 3 eBay eBay NNP 3344 178 4 in in IN 3344 178 5 1995 1995 CD 3344 178 6 , , , 3344 178 7 Google Google NNP 3344 178 8 in in IN 3344 178 9 1999 1999 CD 3344 178 10 , , , 3344 178 11 or or CC 3344 178 12 Skype Skype NNP 3344 178 13 in in IN 3344 178 14 2002 2002 CD 3344 178 15 without without IN 3344 178 16 the the DT 3344 178 17 level level JJ 3344 178 18 playing playing NN 3344 178 19 field field NN 3344 178 20 provided provide VBN 3344 178 21 by by IN 3344 178 22 network network NN 3344 178 23 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 178 24 . . . 3344 179 1 Or or CC 3344 179 2 think think VB 3344 179 3 about about IN 3344 179 4 any any DT 3344 179 5 OA OA NNP 3344 179 6 journal journal NN 3344 179 7 or or CC 3344 179 8 repository repository NN 3344 179 9 today.58 today.58 NNP 3344 179 10 Is be VBZ 3344 179 11 Net net JJ 3344 179 12 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 179 13 a a DT 3344 179 14 quaint quaint NN 3344 179 15 anachronism anachronism NN 3344 179 16 of of IN 3344 179 17 the the DT 3344 179 18 Internet internet NN 3344 179 19 ’s ’s , 3344 179 20 distant distant JJ 3344 179 21 academic academic JJ 3344 179 22 / / SYM 3344 179 23 research research NN 3344 179 24 roots root NNS 3344 179 25 that that IN 3344 179 26 we -PRON- PRP 3344 179 27 would would MD 3344 179 28 be be VB 3344 179 29 better well JJR 3344 179 30 off off RP 3344 179 31 without without IN 3344 179 32 ? ? . 3344 180 1 Would Would MD 3344 180 2 new new JJ 3344 180 3 Internet internet NN 3344 180 4 companies company NNS 3344 180 5 and and CC 3344 180 6 noncom- noncom- JJ 3344 180 7 mercial mercial JJ 3344 180 8 services service NNS 3344 180 9 prosper prosper VB 3344 180 10 better well RBR 3344 180 11 if if IN 3344 180 12 it -PRON- PRP 3344 180 13 was be VBD 3344 180 14 gone go VBN 3344 180 15 , , , 3344 180 16 spurring spur VBG 3344 180 17 on on IN 3344 180 18 new new JJ 3344 180 19 waves wave NNS 3344 180 20 of of IN 3344 180 21 innovation innovation NN 3344 180 22 ? ? . 3344 181 1 Would Would MD 3344 181 2 telecommunications telecommunications VB 3344 181 3 companies company NNS 3344 181 4 ( ( -LRB- 3344 181 5 who who WP 3344 181 6 may may MD 3344 181 7 be be VB 3344 181 8 part part NN 3344 181 9 of of IN 3344 181 10 larger large JJR 3344 181 11 conglomerates conglomerate NNS 3344 181 12 ) ) -RRB- 3344 181 13 , , , 3344 181 14 free free JJ 3344 181 15 to to TO 3344 181 16 charge charge VB 3344 181 17 for for IN 3344 181 18 tiered tiere VBN 3344 181 19 - - HYPH 3344 181 20 services service NNS 3344 181 21 , , , 3344 181 22 offer offer VBP 3344 181 23 us -PRON- PRP 3344 181 24 exciting exciting JJ 3344 181 25 new new JJ 3344 181 26 service service NN 3344 181 27 offerings offering NNS 3344 181 28 and and CC 3344 181 29 better well JJR 3344 181 30 , , , 3344 181 31 more more RBR 3344 181 32 reliable reliable JJ 3344 181 33 service service NN 3344 181 34 ? ? . 3344 182 1 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 182 2 Defending defend VBG 3344 182 3 the the DT 3344 182 4 Internet internet NN 3344 182 5 revolution revolution NN 3344 182 6 Sixties sixty NNS 3344 182 7 icon icon NN 3344 182 8 Bob Bob NNP 3344 182 9 Dylan Dylan NNP 3344 182 10 ’s ’s NNP 3344 182 11 line line NN 3344 182 12 in in IN 3344 182 13 “ " `` 3344 182 14 The the DT 3344 182 15 Times time NNS 3344 182 16 They -PRON- PRP 3344 182 17 Are be VBP 3344 182 18 A- a- RB 3344 182 19 Changin’”—“Then changin’”—“then RB 3344 182 20 you -PRON- PRP 3344 182 21 better well RBR 3344 182 22 start start VBP 3344 182 23 swimmin swimmin NN 3344 182 24 ’ ' '' 3344 182 25 or or CC 3344 182 26 you -PRON- PRP 3344 182 27 ’ll will MD 3344 182 28 sink sink VB 3344 182 29 like like IN 3344 182 30 a a DT 3344 182 31 stone”—couldn’t stone”—couldn’t NNP 3344 182 32 be be VB 3344 182 33 more more RBR 3344 182 34 apt apt JJ 3344 182 35 for for IN 3344 182 36 those those DT 3344 182 37 concerned concerned JJ 3344 182 38 with with IN 3344 182 39 the the DT 3344 182 40 issues issue NNS 3344 182 41 outlined outline VBN 3344 182 42 in in IN 3344 182 43 this this DT 3344 182 44 paper paper NN 3344 182 45 . . . 3344 183 1 Here here RB 3344 183 2 ’s ’s , 3344 183 3 a a DT 3344 183 4 brief brief JJ 3344 183 5 over- over- JJ 3344 183 6 view view NN 3344 183 7 of of IN 3344 183 8 some some DT 3344 183 9 of of IN 3344 183 10 the the DT 3344 183 11 strategies strategy NNS 3344 183 12 being be VBG 3344 183 13 used use VBN 3344 183 14 to to TO 3344 183 15 defend defend VB 3344 183 16 the the DT 3344 183 17 freewheeling freewheel VBG 3344 183 18 Internet internet NN 3344 183 19 revolution revolution NN 3344 183 20 . . . 3344 184 1 1 1 LS 3344 184 2 . . . 3344 185 1 Darknet darknet NN 3344 185 2 : : : 3344 185 3 J. J. NNP 3344 185 4 D. D. NNP 3344 185 5 Lasica Lasica NNP 3344 185 6 says say VBZ 3344 185 7 : : : 3344 185 8 “ " `` 3344 185 9 For for IN 3344 185 10 the the DT 3344 185 11 most most JJS 3344 185 12 part part NN 3344 185 13 , , , 3344 185 14 the the DT 3344 185 15 Darknet Darknet NNP 3344 185 16 is be VBZ 3344 185 17 simply simply RB 3344 185 18 the the DT 3344 185 19 underground underground JJ 3344 185 20 Internet internet NN 3344 185 21 . . . 3344 186 1 But but CC 3344 186 2 there there EX 3344 186 3 are be VBP 3344 186 4 many many JJ 3344 186 5 darknets darknet NNS 3344 186 6 : : : 3344 186 7 the the DT 3344 186 8 millions million NNS 3344 186 9 of of IN 3344 186 10 users user NNS 3344 186 11 trading trade VBG 3344 186 12 files file NNS 3344 186 13 in in IN 3344 186 14 the the DT 3344 186 15 shady shady JJ 3344 186 16 regions region NNS 3344 186 17 of of IN 3344 186 18 Usenet Usenet NNP 3344 186 19 and and CC 3344 186 20 Internet internet NN 3344 186 21 Relay Relay NNP 3344 186 22 Chat chat NN 3344 186 23 ; ; : 3344 186 24 students student NNS 3344 186 25 who who WP 3344 186 26 send send VBP 3344 186 27 songs song NNS 3344 186 28 and and CC 3344 186 29 TV tv NN 3344 186 30 shows show VBZ 3344 186 31 to to IN 3344 186 32 each each DT 3344 186 33 other other JJ 3344 186 34 using use VBG 3344 186 35 instant instant JJ 3344 186 36 messaging messaging NN 3344 186 37 services service NNS 3344 186 38 from from IN 3344 186 39 AOL AOL NNP 3344 186 40 , , , 3344 186 41 Yahoo Yahoo NNP 3344 186 42 , , , 3344 186 43 and and CC 3344 186 44 Microsoft Microsoft NNP 3344 186 45 ; ; : 3344 186 46 city city NN 3344 186 47 streets street NNS 3344 186 48 and and CC 3344 186 49 college college NN 3344 186 50 campuses campus NNS 3344 186 51 where where WRB 3344 186 52 people people NNS 3344 186 53 copy copy VBP 3344 186 54 , , , 3344 186 55 burn burn VBP 3344 186 56 , , , 3344 186 57 and and CC 3344 186 58 share share VB 3344 186 59 physical physical JJ 3344 186 60 media medium NNS 3344 186 61 like like IN 3344 186 62 CDs cd NNS 3344 186 63 ; ; : 3344 186 64 and and CC 3344 186 65 the the DT 3344 186 66 new new JJ 3344 186 67 breed breed NN 3344 186 68 of of IN 3344 186 69 encrypted encrypt VBN 3344 186 70 dark dark JJ 3344 186 71 networks network NNS 3344 186 72 like like IN 3344 186 73 Freenet Freenet NNP 3344 186 74 . . . 3344 187 1 . . . 3344 188 1 .”59 .”59 NNP 3344 188 2 We -PRON- PRP 3344 188 3 may may MD 3344 188 4 think think VB 3344 188 5 of of IN 3344 188 6 the the DT 3344 188 7 Darknet Darknet NNP 3344 188 8 as as RB 3344 188 9 simply simply RB 3344 188 10 fostering foster VBG 3344 188 11 illegal illegal JJ 3344 188 12 file file NN 3344 188 13 swapping swap VBG 3344 188 14 by by IN 3344 188 15 ordinary ordinary JJ 3344 188 16 citizens citizen NNS 3344 188 17 , , , 3344 188 18 but but CC 3344 188 19 the the DT 3344 188 20 Darknet Darknet NNP 3344 188 21 strategy strategy NN 3344 188 22 can can MD 3344 188 23 also also RB 3344 188 24 be be VB 3344 188 25 used use VBN 3344 188 26 to to TO 3344 188 27 escape escape VB 3344 188 28 government government NN 3344 188 29 Internet internet NN 3344 188 30 censorship censorship NN 3344 188 31 , , , 3344 188 32 as as IN 3344 188 33 is be VBZ 3344 188 34 the the DT 3344 188 35 case case NN 3344 188 36 with with IN 3344 188 37 Freenet Freenet NNP 3344 188 38 use use NN 3344 188 39 in in IN 3344 188 40 China.60 china.60 $ 3344 188 41 2 2 CD 3344 188 42 . . . 3344 189 1 Legislative legislative JJ 3344 189 2 and and CC 3344 189 3 Legal legal JJ 3344 189 4 Action Action NNP 3344 189 5 : : : 3344 189 6 There there EX 3344 189 7 have have VBP 3344 189 8 been be VBN 3344 189 9 attempts attempt NNS 3344 189 10 to to TO 3344 189 11 pass pass VB 3344 189 12 laws law NNS 3344 189 13 to to TO 3344 189 14 amend amend VB 3344 189 15 or or CC 3344 189 16 reverse reverse VB 3344 189 17 copyright copyright NN 3344 189 18 and and CC 3344 189 19 other other JJ 3344 189 20 laws law NNS 3344 189 21 resulting result VBG 3344 189 22 from from IN 3344 189 23 the the DT 3344 189 24 counter counter JJ 3344 189 25 - - JJ 3344 189 26 Internet internet NN 3344 189 27 - - HYPH 3344 189 28 revolution revolution NN 3344 189 29 , , , 3344 189 30 which which WDT 3344 189 31 have have VBP 3344 189 32 been be VBN 3344 189 33 met meet VBN 3344 189 34 by by IN 3344 189 35 swift swift JJ 3344 189 36 , , , 3344 189 37 powerful powerful JJ 3344 189 38 , , , 3344 189 39 and and CC 3344 189 40 generally generally RB 3344 189 41 effective effective JJ 3344 189 42 opposition opposition NN 3344 189 43 from from IN 3344 189 44 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 189 45 companies company NNS 3344 189 46 and and CC 3344 189 47 other other JJ 3344 189 48 parties party NNS 3344 189 49 affected affect VBN 3344 189 50 by by IN 3344 189 51 these these DT 3344 189 52 proposed propose VBN 3344 189 53 measures measure NNS 3344 189 54 . . . 3344 190 1 The the DT 3344 190 2 moral moral NN 3344 190 3 of of IN 3344 190 4 this this DT 3344 190 5 story story NN 3344 190 6 is be VBZ 3344 190 7 that that IN 3344 190 8 these these DT 3344 190 9 large large JJ 3344 190 10 corporations corporation NNS 3344 190 11 can can MD 3344 190 12 afford afford VB 3344 190 13 to to TO 3344 190 14 pay pay VB 3344 190 15 lobbyists lobbyist NNS 3344 190 16 , , , 3344 190 17 make make VB 3344 190 18 campaign campaign NN 3344 190 19 contributions contribution NNS 3344 190 20 , , , 3344 190 21 and and CC 3344 190 22 otherwise otherwise RB 3344 190 23 exert exert VB 3344 190 24 significant significant JJ 3344 190 25 influence influence NN 3344 190 26 over over IN 3344 190 27 lawmakers lawmaker NNS 3344 190 28 , , , 3344 190 29 while while IN 3344 190 30 , , , 3344 190 31 by by RB 3344 190 32 and and CC 3344 190 33 large large JJ 3344 190 34 , , , 3344 190 35 advocates advocate NNS 3344 190 36 for for IN 3344 190 37 the the DT 3344 190 38 other other JJ 3344 190 39 side side NN 3344 190 40 do do VBP 3344 190 41 not not RB 3344 190 42 have have VB 3344 190 43 the the DT 3344 190 44 same same JJ 3344 190 45 clout clout NN 3344 190 46 . . . 3344 191 1 The the DT 3344 191 2 battle battle NN 3344 191 3 in in IN 3344 191 4 the the DT 3344 191 5 courts court NNS 3344 191 6 has have VBZ 3344 191 7 been be VBN 3344 191 8 more more JJR 3344 191 9 of of IN 3344 191 10 a a DT 3344 191 11 mixed mixed JJ 3344 191 12 bag bag NN 3344 191 13 ; ; : 3344 191 14 however however RB 3344 191 15 , , , 3344 191 16 there there EX 3344 191 17 have have VBP 3344 191 18 been be VBN 3344 191 19 some some DT 3344 191 20 notable notable JJ 3344 191 21 defeats defeat NNS 3344 191 22 for for IN 3344 191 23 reform reform NN 3344 191 24 advocates advocate NNS 3344 191 25 , , , 3344 191 26 especially especially RB 3344 191 27 in in IN 3344 191 28 the the DT 3344 191 29 copyright copyright NN 3344 191 30 arena arena NN 3344 191 31 ( ( -LRB- 3344 191 32 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 191 33 , , , 3344 191 34 Eldred Eldred NNP 3344 191 35 v. v. IN 3344 191 36 Ashcroft Ashcroft NNP 3344 191 37 ) ) -RRB- 3344 191 38 , , , 3344 191 39 where where WRB 3344 191 40 most most JJS 3344 191 41 of of IN 3344 191 42 the the DT 3344 191 43 action action NN 3344 191 44 has have VBZ 3344 191 45 been be VBN 3344 191 46 . . . 3344 192 1 3 3 LS 3344 192 2 . . . 3344 193 1 Market market NN 3344 193 2 Forces force NNS 3344 193 3 : : : 3344 193 4 When when WRB 3344 193 5 commercial commercial JJ 3344 193 6 choices choice NNS 3344 193 7 can can MD 3344 193 8 be be VB 3344 193 9 made make VBN 3344 193 10 , , , 3344 193 11 users user NNS 3344 193 12 can can MD 3344 193 13 vote vote VB 3344 193 14 with with IN 3344 193 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 193 16 pocketbooks pocketbook NNS 3344 193 17 about about IN 3344 193 18 some some DT 3344 193 19 Internet internet NN 3344 193 20 changes change NNS 3344 193 21 . . . 3344 194 1 But but CC 3344 194 2 , , , 3344 194 3 if if IN 3344 194 4 monopoly monopoly NN 3344 194 5 forces force NNS 3344 194 6 are be VBP 3344 194 7 in in IN 3344 194 8 play play NN 3344 194 9 , , , 3344 194 10 such such JJ 3344 194 11 as as IN 3344 194 12 having have VBG 3344 194 13 a a DT 3344 194 14 single single JJ 3344 194 15 option option NN 3344 194 16 for for IN 3344 194 17 broadband broadband NN 3344 194 18 access access NN 3344 194 19 , , , 3344 194 20 the the DT 3344 194 21 only only JJ 3344 194 22 other other JJ 3344 194 23 choice choice NN 3344 194 24 may may MD 3344 194 25 be be VB 3344 194 26 no no DT 3344 194 27 service service NN 3344 194 28 . . . 3344 195 1 However however RB 3344 195 2 , , , 3344 195 3 as as IN 3344 195 4 the the DT 3344 195 5 OA OA NNP 3344 195 6 move- move- NN 3344 195 7 ment ment NN 3344 195 8 ( ( -LRB- 3344 195 9 described describe VBN 3344 195 10 later later RB 3344 195 11 ) ) -RRB- 3344 195 12 has have VBZ 3344 195 13 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 3344 195 14 , , , 3344 195 15 a a DT 3344 195 16 concerted concerted JJ 3344 195 17 effort effort NN 3344 195 18 by by IN 3344 195 19 highly highly RB 3344 195 20 motivated motivated JJ 3344 195 21 individuals individual NNS 3344 195 22 and and CC 3344 195 23 nonprofit nonprofit JJ 3344 195 24 organiza- organiza- JJ 3344 195 25 tions tion NNS 3344 195 26 can can MD 3344 195 27 establish establish VB 3344 195 28 viable viable JJ 3344 195 29 new new JJ 3344 195 30 alternatives alternative NNS 3344 195 31 to to IN 3344 195 32 commercial commercial JJ 3344 195 33 services service NNS 3344 195 34 that that WDT 3344 195 35 can can MD 3344 195 36 change change VB 3344 195 37 the the DT 3344 195 38 rules rule NNS 3344 195 39 of of IN 3344 195 40 the the DT 3344 195 41 game game NN 3344 195 42 in in IN 3344 195 43 some some DT 3344 195 44 cases case NNS 3344 195 45 . . . 3344 196 1 Companies company NNS 3344 196 2 can can MD 3344 196 3 also also RB 3344 196 4 explore explore VB 3344 196 5 radical radical JJ 3344 196 6 new new JJ 3344 196 7 business business NN 3344 196 8 models model NNS 3344 196 9 that that WDT 3344 196 10 may may MD 3344 196 11 appear appear VB 3344 196 12 paradoxical paradoxical JJ 3344 196 13 to to TO 3344 196 14 pre pre VB 3344 196 15 - - JJ 3344 196 16 Internet internet JJ 3344 196 17 - - HYPH 3344 196 18 era era NN 3344 196 19 thinking thinking NN 3344 196 20 , , , 3344 196 21 but but CC 3344 196 22 make make VB 3344 196 23 perfect perfect JJ 3344 196 24 sense sense NN 3344 196 25 in in IN 3344 196 26 the the DT 3344 196 27 new new JJ 3344 196 28 digital digital NNP 3344 196 29 real- real- NNP 3344 196 30 ity ity NNP 3344 196 31 . . . 3344 197 1 In in IN 3344 197 2 the the DT 3344 197 3 long long JJ 3344 197 4 run run NN 3344 197 5 , , , 3344 197 6 the the DT 3344 197 7 winners winner NNS 3344 197 8 of of IN 3344 197 9 the the DT 3344 197 10 digital digital JJ 3344 197 11 - - HYPH 3344 197 12 content content NN 3344 197 13 wars war NNS 3344 197 14 may may MD 3344 197 15 be be VB 3344 197 16 those those DT 3344 197 17 who who WP 3344 197 18 are be VBP 3344 197 19 not not RB 3344 197 20 afraid afraid JJ 3344 197 21 of of IN 3344 197 22 going go VBG 3344 197 23 down down IN 3344 197 24 the the DT 3344 197 25 Internet internet NN 3344 197 26 rabbit rabbit NN 3344 197 27 hole hole NN 3344 197 28 . . . 3344 198 1 4 4 LS 3344 198 2 . . . 3344 199 1 Creative creative JJ 3344 199 2 Commons Commons NNPS 3344 199 3 : : : 3344 199 4 Copyright copyright NN 3344 199 5 is be VBZ 3344 199 6 a a DT 3344 199 7 two two CD 3344 199 8 - - HYPH 3344 199 9 edged edged JJ 3344 199 10 sword sword NN 3344 199 11 : : : 3344 199 12 it -PRON- PRP 3344 199 13 can can MD 3344 199 14 be be VB 3344 199 15 used use VBN 3344 199 16 as as IN 3344 199 17 the the DT 3344 199 18 legal legal JJ 3344 199 19 basis basis NN 3344 199 20 of of IN 3344 199 21 licenses license NNS 3344 199 22 ( ( -LRB- 3344 199 23 and and CC 3344 199 24 DRM DRM NNP 3344 199 25 ) ) -RRB- 3344 199 26 to to TO 3344 199 27 restrict restrict VB 3344 199 28 and and CC 3344 199 29 control control VB 3344 199 30 digital digital JJ 3344 199 31 information information NN 3344 199 32 , , , 3344 199 33 or or CC 3344 199 34 it -PRON- PRP 3344 199 35 can can MD 3344 199 36 be be VB 3344 199 37 used use VBN 3344 199 38 as as IN 3344 199 39 the the DT 3344 199 40 legal legal JJ 3344 199 41 basis basis NN 3344 199 42 of of IN 3344 199 43 licenses license NNS 3344 199 44 to to TO 3344 199 45 permit permit VB 3344 199 46 liberal liberal JJ 3344 199 47 use use NN 3344 199 48 of of IN 3344 199 49 digital digital JJ 3344 199 50 information information NN 3344 199 51 . . . 3344 200 1 By by IN 3344 200 2 using use VBG 3344 200 3 one one CD 3344 200 4 of of IN 3344 200 5 the the DT 3344 200 6 six six CD 3344 200 7 major major JJ 3344 200 8 Creative Creative NNP 3344 200 9 Common Common NNP 3344 200 10 Licenses Licenses NNPS 3344 200 11 ( ( -LRB- 3344 200 12 CCL CCL NNP 3344 200 13 ) ) -RRB- 3344 200 14 , , , 3344 200 15 authors author NNS 3344 200 16 can can MD 3344 200 17 retain retain VB 3344 200 18 copyright copyright NN 3344 200 19 , , , 3344 200 20 but but CC 3344 200 21 significantly significantly RB 3344 200 22 enrich enrich VBP 3344 200 23 society society NN 3344 200 24 ’s ’s , 3344 200 25 collective collective JJ 3344 200 26 cultural cultural JJ 3344 200 27 repository repository NN 3344 200 28 with with IN 3344 200 29 works work NNS 3344 200 30 that that WDT 3344 200 31 can can MD 3344 200 32 be be VB 3344 200 33 freely freely RB 3344 200 34 shared share VBN 3344 200 35 for for IN 3344 200 36 noncommercial noncommercial JJ 3344 200 37 purposes purpose NNS 3344 200 38 , , , 3344 200 39 used use VBN 3344 200 40 , , , 3344 200 41 in in IN 3344 200 42 some some DT 3344 200 43 cases case NNS 3344 200 44 , , , 3344 200 45 for for IN 3344 200 46 commercial commercial JJ 3344 200 47 purposes purpose NNS 3344 200 48 , , , 3344 200 49 and and CC 3344 200 50 used use VBD 3344 200 51 to to TO 3344 200 52 easily easily RB 3344 200 53 build build VB 3344 200 54 new new JJ 3344 200 55 derivative derivative JJ 3344 200 56 creative creative JJ 3344 200 57 works work NNS 3344 200 58 . . . 3344 201 1 For for IN 3344 201 2 example example NN 3344 201 3 , , , 3344 201 4 the the DT 3344 201 5 Creative Creative NNP 3344 201 6 Commons Commons NNP 3344 201 7 Attribution Attribution NNP 3344 201 8 License License NNP 3344 201 9 requires require VBZ 3344 201 10 that that IN 3344 201 11 a a DT 3344 201 12 work work NN 3344 201 13 is be VBZ 3344 201 14 attributed attribute VBN 3344 201 15 to to IN 3344 201 16 the the DT 3344 201 17 author author NN 3344 201 18 ; ; : 3344 201 19 however however RB 3344 201 20 , , , 3344 201 21 a a DT 3344 201 22 work work NN 3344 201 23 can can MD 3344 201 24 be be VB 3344 201 25 used use VBN 3344 201 26 for for IN 3344 201 27 any any DT 3344 201 28 commercial commercial JJ 3344 201 29 or or CC 3344 201 30 noncommercial noncommercial JJ 3344 201 31 purpose purpose NN 3344 201 32 without without IN 3344 201 33 permission permission NN 3344 201 34 , , , 3344 201 35 including include VBG 3344 201 36 creating create VBG 3344 201 37 derivative derivative JJ 3344 201 38 works.61 works.61 NNP 3344 201 39 There there EX 3344 201 40 are be VBP 3344 201 41 a a DT 3344 201 42 variety variety NN 3344 201 43 of of IN 3344 201 44 other other JJ 3344 201 45 licenses license NNS 3344 201 46 , , , 3344 201 47 such such JJ 3344 201 48 as as IN 3344 201 49 the the DT 3344 201 50 GNU GNU NNP 3344 201 51 Free Free NNP 3344 201 52 Documentation Documentation NNP 3344 201 53 License License NNP 3344 201 54 , , , 3344 201 55 that that WDT 3344 201 56 can can MD 3344 201 57 be be VB 3344 201 58 used use VBN 3344 201 59 for for IN 3344 201 60 similar similar JJ 3344 201 61 purposes.62 purposes.62 NNP 3344 201 62 5 5 CD 3344 201 63 . . . 3344 202 1 OA OA NNP 3344 202 2 : : : 3344 202 3 Scholars scholar NNS 3344 202 4 create create VBP 3344 202 5 certain certain JJ 3344 202 6 types type NNS 3344 202 7 of of IN 3344 202 8 information information NN 3344 202 9 , , , 3344 202 10 such such JJ 3344 202 11 as as IN 3344 202 12 journal journal NN 3344 202 13 articles article NNS 3344 202 14 , , , 3344 202 15 without without IN 3344 202 16 expecting expect VBG 3344 202 17 to to TO 3344 202 18 be be VB 3344 202 19 paid pay VBN 3344 202 20 to to TO 3344 202 21 do do VB 3344 202 22 so so RB 3344 202 23 , , , 3344 202 24 and and CC 3344 202 25 it -PRON- PRP 3344 202 26 is be VBZ 3344 202 27 in in IN 3344 202 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 202 29 best good JJS 3344 202 30 interests interest NNS 3344 202 31 for for IN 3344 202 32 these these DT 3344 202 33 works work NNS 3344 202 34 to to TO 3344 202 35 be be VB 3344 202 36 widely widely RB 3344 202 37 read read VBN 3344 202 38 , , , 3344 202 39 especially especially RB 3344 202 40 by by IN 3344 202 41 specialists specialist NNS 3344 202 42 in in IN 3344 202 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 202 44 fields.63 fields.63 NNP 3344 202 45 By by IN 3344 202 46 putting put VBG 3344 202 47 e e NN 3344 202 48 - - HYPH 3344 202 49 prints print NNS 3344 202 50 ( ( -LRB- 3344 202 51 electronic electronic JJ 3344 202 52 preprints preprint NNS 3344 202 53 or or CC 3344 202 54 post post NN 3344 202 55 - - JJ 3344 202 56 prints print NNS 3344 202 57 ) ) -RRB- 3344 202 58 of of IN 3344 202 59 articles article NNS 3344 202 60 on on IN 3344 202 61 personal personal JJ 3344 202 62 home home NN 3344 202 63 pages page NNS 3344 202 64 or or CC 3344 202 65 in in IN 3344 202 66 various various JJ 3344 202 67 types type NNS 3344 202 68 of of IN 3344 202 69 digital digital JJ 3344 202 70 archives archive NNS 3344 202 71 ( ( -LRB- 3344 202 72 e.g. e.g. RB 3344 202 73 , , , 3344 202 74 institutional institutional JJ 3344 202 75 repositories repository NNS 3344 202 76 ) ) -RRB- 3344 202 77 in in IN 3344 202 78 full full JJ 3344 202 79 compliance compliance NN 3344 202 80 with with IN 3344 202 81 copyright copyright NN 3344 202 82 law law NN 3344 202 83 and and CC 3344 202 84 , , , 3344 202 85 if if IN 3344 202 86 needed need VBN 3344 202 87 , , , 3344 202 88 in in IN 3344 202 89 compli- compli- JJ 3344 202 90 ance ance NN 3344 202 91 with with IN 3344 202 92 publisher publisher NN 3344 202 93 policies policy NNS 3344 202 94 , , , 3344 202 95 scholars scholar NNS 3344 202 96 can can MD 3344 202 97 provide provide VB 3344 202 98 free free JJ 3344 202 99 global global JJ 3344 202 100 access access NN 3344 202 101 to to IN 3344 202 102 these these DT 3344 202 103 works work NNS 3344 202 104 with with IN 3344 202 105 minimal minimal JJ 3344 202 106 effort effort NN 3344 202 107 and and CC 3344 202 108 at at IN 3344 202 109 no no UH 3344 202 110 ( ( -LRB- 3344 202 111 or or CC 3344 202 112 little little JJ 3344 202 113 ) ) -RRB- 3344 202 114 cost cost NN 3344 202 115 to to IN 3344 202 116 themselves -PRON- PRP 3344 202 117 . . . 3344 203 1 Further further RB 3344 203 2 , , , 3344 203 3 a a DT 3344 203 4 new new JJ 3344 203 5 generation generation NN 3344 203 6 of of IN 3344 203 7 free free JJ 3344 203 8 e e NNS 3344 203 9 - - NNS 3344 203 10 journals journal NNS 3344 203 11 are be VBP 3344 203 12 being be VBG 3344 203 13 published publish VBN 3344 203 14 on on IN 3344 203 15 the the DT 3344 203 16 Internet internet NN 3344 203 17 that that WDT 3344 203 18 are be VBP 3344 203 19 being be VBG 3344 203 20 funded fund VBN 3344 203 21 by by IN 3344 203 22 a a DT 3344 203 23 variety variety NN 3344 203 24 of of IN 3344 203 25 business business NN 3344 203 26 models model NNS 3344 203 27 , , , 3344 203 28 such such JJ 3344 203 29 as as IN 3344 203 30 advertising advertising NN 3344 203 31 , , , 3344 203 32 author author NN 3344 203 33 fees fee NNS 3344 203 34 , , , 3344 203 35 library library JJ 3344 203 36 membership membership NN 3344 203 37 fees fee NNS 3344 203 38 , , , 3344 203 39 and and CC 3344 203 40 supplemental supplemental JJ 3344 203 41 products product NNS 3344 203 42 . . . 3344 204 1 These these DT 3344 204 2 OA OA NNP 3344 204 3 strategies strategy NNS 3344 204 4 make make VBP 3344 204 5 digital digital JJ 3344 204 6 124 124 CD 3344 204 7 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNS 3344 204 8 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3344 204 9 AND and CC 3344 204 10 LIBRARIES library NNS 3344 204 11 | | NNP 3344 204 12 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3344 204 13 2006 2006 CD 3344 204 14 scholarly scholarly JJ 3344 204 15 information information NN 3344 204 16 freely freely RB 3344 204 17 available available JJ 3344 204 18 to to IN 3344 204 19 users user NNS 3344 204 20 across across IN 3344 204 21 the the DT 3344 204 22 globe globe NN 3344 204 23 , , , 3344 204 24 regardless regardless RB 3344 204 25 of of IN 3344 204 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 204 27 personal personal JJ 3344 204 28 affluence affluence NN 3344 204 29 or or CC 3344 204 30 the the DT 3344 204 31 affluence affluence NN 3344 204 32 of of IN 3344 204 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 204 34 affiliated affiliated JJ 3344 204 35 institutions institution NNS 3344 204 36 . . . 3344 205 1 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 205 2 Impact Impact NNP 3344 205 3 on on IN 3344 205 4 libraries library NNS 3344 205 5 This this DT 3344 205 6 paper paper NN 3344 205 7 ’s ’s : 3344 205 8 analysis analysis NN 3344 205 9 of of IN 3344 205 10 copyright copyright NN 3344 205 11 , , , 3344 205 12 DRM DRM NNP 3344 205 13 , , , 3344 205 14 and and CC 3344 205 15 network network NN 3344 205 16 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 205 17 trends trend NNS 3344 205 18 holds hold VBZ 3344 205 19 no no DT 3344 205 20 good good JJ 3344 205 21 news news NN 3344 205 22 for for IN 3344 205 23 libraries library NNS 3344 205 24 . . . 3344 206 1 Copyright copyright NN 3344 206 2 The the DT 3344 206 3 reach reach NN 3344 206 4 of of IN 3344 206 5 copyright copyright NN 3344 206 6 law law NN 3344 206 7 constantly constantly RB 3344 206 8 encompasses encompass VBZ 3344 206 9 new new JJ 3344 206 10 types type NNS 3344 206 11 of of IN 3344 206 12 materials material NNS 3344 206 13 and and CC 3344 206 14 for for IN 3344 206 15 an an DT 3344 206 16 ever ever RB 3344 206 17 - - HYPH 3344 206 18 lengthening lengthen VBG 3344 206 19 duration duration NN 3344 206 20 . . . 3344 207 1 As as IN 3344 207 2 a a DT 3344 207 3 result result NN 3344 207 4 , , , 3344 207 5 copyright copyright NN 3344 207 6 holders holder NNS 3344 207 7 must must MD 3344 207 8 explicitly explicitly RB 3344 207 9 place place VB 3344 207 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 207 11 works work NNS 3344 207 12 in in IN 3344 207 13 the the DT 3344 207 14 public public JJ 3344 207 15 domain domain NN 3344 207 16 if if IN 3344 207 17 the the DT 3344 207 18 public public JJ 3344 207 19 domain domain NN 3344 207 20 is be VBZ 3344 207 21 to to TO 3344 207 22 continue continue VB 3344 207 23 to to TO 3344 207 24 grow grow VB 3344 207 25 . . . 3344 208 1 Needless needless JJ 3344 208 2 to to TO 3344 208 3 say say VB 3344 208 4 , , , 3344 208 5 the the DT 3344 208 6 public public JJ 3344 208 7 domain domain NN 3344 208 8 is be VBZ 3344 208 9 a a DT 3344 208 10 primary primary JJ 3344 208 11 source source NN 3344 208 12 of of IN 3344 208 13 materials material NNS 3344 208 14 that that WDT 3344 208 15 can can MD 3344 208 16 be be VB 3344 208 17 digitized digitize VBN 3344 208 18 without without IN 3344 208 19 having have VBG 3344 208 20 to to TO 3344 208 21 face face VB 3344 208 22 a a DT 3344 208 23 complex complex NN 3344 208 24 , , , 3344 208 25 potentially potentially RB 3344 208 26 expensive expensive JJ 3344 208 27 , , , 3344 208 28 and and CC 3344 208 29 sometimes sometimes RB 3344 208 30 hope- hope- JJ 3344 208 31 less less JJR 3344 208 32 permission permission NN 3344 208 33 clearance clearance NN 3344 208 34 process process NN 3344 208 35 . . . 3344 209 1 This this DT 3344 209 2 process process NN 3344 209 3 can can MD 3344 209 4 be be VB 3344 209 5 especially especially RB 3344 209 6 daunting daunt VBG 3344 209 7 for for IN 3344 209 8 media medium NNS 3344 209 9 works work NNS 3344 209 10 ( ( -LRB- 3344 209 11 such such JJ 3344 209 12 as as IN 3344 209 13 films film NNS 3344 209 14 and and CC 3344 209 15 video video NN 3344 209 16 ) ) -RRB- 3344 209 17 , , , 3344 209 18 even even RB 3344 209 19 for for IN 3344 209 20 the the DT 3344 209 21 use use NN 3344 209 22 of of IN 3344 209 23 very very RB 3344 209 24 short short JJ 3344 209 25 segments segment NNS 3344 209 26 of of IN 3344 209 27 these these DT 3344 209 28 works work NNS 3344 209 29 . . . 3344 210 1 J. J. NNP 3344 210 2 D. D. NNP 3344 210 3 Lasica Lasica NNP 3344 210 4 recounts recount VBZ 3344 210 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 210 6 effort effort NN 3344 210 7 to to TO 3344 210 8 get get VB 3344 210 9 permission permission NN 3344 210 10 to to TO 3344 210 11 use use VB 3344 210 12 short short JJ 3344 210 13 music music NN 3344 210 14 and and CC 3344 210 15 film film NN 3344 210 16 segments segment NNS 3344 210 17 in in IN 3344 210 18 a a DT 3344 210 19 personal personal JJ 3344 210 20 video video NN 3344 210 21 : : : 3344 210 22 five five CD 3344 210 23 out out IN 3344 210 24 of of IN 3344 210 25 seven seven CD 3344 210 26 music music NN 3344 210 27 companies company NNS 3344 210 28 declined decline VBD 3344 210 29 ; ; : 3344 210 30 six six CD 3344 210 31 out out IN 3344 210 32 of of IN 3344 210 33 seven seven CD 3344 210 34 movie movie NN 3344 210 35 studios studio NNS 3344 210 36 declined decline VBD 3344 210 37 , , , 3344 210 38 and and CC 3344 210 39 the the DT 3344 210 40 one one NN 3344 210 41 that that WDT 3344 210 42 agreed agree VBD 3344 210 43 had have VBD 3344 210 44 serious serious JJ 3344 210 45 reservations.64 reservations.64 NNP 3344 210 46 The the DT 3344 210 47 replies reply NNS 3344 210 48 to to IN 3344 210 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 210 50 inquiry inquiry NN 3344 210 51 , , , 3344 210 52 for for IN 3344 210 53 those those DT 3344 210 54 companies company NNS 3344 210 55 that that WDT 3344 210 56 bothered bother VBD 3344 210 57 to to TO 3344 210 58 reply reply VB 3344 210 59 at at RB 3344 210 60 all all RB 3344 210 61 , , , 3344 210 62 are be VBP 3344 210 63 well well RB 3344 210 64 worth worth JJ 3344 210 65 reading read VBG 3344 210 66 . . . 3344 211 1 For for IN 3344 211 2 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 211 3 libraries library NNS 3344 211 4 without without IN 3344 211 5 the the DT 3344 211 6 resources resource NNS 3344 211 7 to to TO 3344 211 8 deal deal VB 3344 211 9 with with IN 3344 211 10 complicated complicated JJ 3344 211 11 copyright copyright NN 3344 211 12 - - HYPH 3344 211 13 related relate VBN 3344 211 14 issues issue NNS 3344 211 15 , , , 3344 211 16 the the DT 3344 211 17 digitization digitization NN 3344 211 18 clock clock NN 3344 211 19 stops stop VBZ 3344 211 20 at at IN 3344 211 21 1922 1922 CD 3344 211 22 , , , 3344 211 23 the the DT 3344 211 24 last last JJ 3344 211 25 year year NN 3344 211 26 we -PRON- PRP 3344 211 27 can can MD 3344 211 28 be be VB 3344 211 29 sure sure JJ 3344 211 30 that that IN 3344 211 31 a a DT 3344 211 32 work work NN 3344 211 33 is be VBZ 3344 211 34 in in IN 3344 211 35 the the DT 3344 211 36 public public JJ 3344 211 37 domain domain NN 3344 211 38 without without IN 3344 211 39 checking check VBG 3344 211 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 211 41 copyright copyright NN 3344 211 42 status status NN 3344 211 43 and and CC 3344 211 44 getting get VBG 3344 211 45 permission permission NN 3344 211 46 if if IN 3344 211 47 it -PRON- PRP 3344 211 48 is be VBZ 3344 211 49 under under IN 3344 211 50 copyright.65 copyright.65 NNP 3344 211 51 What what WP 3344 211 52 can can MD 3344 211 53 we -PRON- PRP 3344 211 54 look look VB 3344 211 55 forward forward RB 3344 211 56 to to IN 3344 211 57 ? ? . 3344 212 1 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 212 2 says say VBZ 3344 212 3 : : : 3344 212 4 “ " `` 3344 212 5 Thus thus RB 3344 212 6 , , , 3344 212 7 in in IN 3344 212 8 the the DT 3344 212 9 twenty twenty CD 3344 212 10 years year NNS 3344 212 11 after after IN 3344 212 12 the the DT 3344 212 13 Sonny Sonny NNP 3344 212 14 Bono Bono NNP 3344 212 15 Act Act NNP 3344 212 16 , , , 3344 212 17 while while IN 3344 212 18 one one CD 3344 212 19 million million CD 3344 212 20 patents patent NNS 3344 212 21 will will MD 3344 212 22 pass pass VB 3344 212 23 into into IN 3344 212 24 the the DT 3344 212 25 public public JJ 3344 212 26 domain domain NN 3344 212 27 , , , 3344 212 28 zero zero CD 3344 212 29 copyrights copyright NNS 3344 212 30 will will MD 3344 212 31 pass pass VB 3344 212 32 into into IN 3344 212 33 the the DT 3344 212 34 public public JJ 3344 212 35 domain domain NN 3344 212 36 by by IN 3344 212 37 virtue virtue NN 3344 212 38 of of IN 3344 212 39 the the DT 3344 212 40 expiration expiration NN 3344 212 41 of of IN 3344 212 42 a a DT 3344 212 43 copyright copyright NN 3344 212 44 term term NN 3344 212 45 . . . 3344 212 46 ”66 ”66 NNP 3344 212 47 ( ( -LRB- 3344 212 48 The the DT 3344 212 49 Sonny Sonny NNP 3344 212 50 Bono Bono NNP 3344 212 51 Term Term NNP 3344 212 52 Extension Extension NNP 3344 212 53 Act Act NNP 3344 212 54 was be VBD 3344 212 55 passed pass VBN 3344 212 56 in in IN 3344 212 57 1998 1998 CD 3344 212 58 . . . 3344 212 59 ) ) -RRB- 3344 213 1 Digital digital JJ 3344 213 2 preservation preservation NN 3344 213 3 is be VBZ 3344 213 4 another another DT 3344 213 5 area area NN 3344 213 6 of of IN 3344 213 7 concern concern NN 3344 213 8 in in IN 3344 213 9 a a DT 3344 213 10 legal legal JJ 3344 213 11 environment environment NN 3344 213 12 where where WRB 3344 213 13 most most JJS 3344 213 14 information information NN 3344 213 15 is be VBZ 3344 213 16 automati- automati- JJ 3344 213 17 cally cally RB 3344 213 18 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 213 19 , , , 3344 213 20 copyright copyright NN 3344 213 21 terms term NNS 3344 213 22 are be VBP 3344 213 23 lengthy lengthy JJ 3344 213 24 ( ( -LRB- 3344 213 25 or or CC 3344 213 26 end- end- NNP 3344 213 27 less less RBR 3344 213 28 ) ) -RRB- 3344 213 29 , , , 3344 213 30 and and CC 3344 213 31 information information NN 3344 213 32 is be VBZ 3344 213 33 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 213 34 licensed license VBN 3344 213 35 . . . 3344 214 1 Simply simply RB 3344 214 2 put put VBN 3344 214 3 , , , 3344 214 4 a a DT 3344 214 5 library library NN 3344 214 6 can can MD 3344 214 7 not not RB 3344 214 8 digitally digitally RB 3344 214 9 preserve preserve VB 3344 214 10 what what WP 3344 214 11 it -PRON- PRP 3344 214 12 does do VBZ 3344 214 13 not not RB 3344 214 14 own own VB 3344 214 15 unless unless IN 3344 214 16 the the DT 3344 214 17 work work NN 3344 214 18 is be VBZ 3344 214 19 in in IN 3344 214 20 the the DT 3344 214 21 public public JJ 3344 214 22 domain domain NN 3344 214 23 , , , 3344 214 24 the the DT 3344 214 25 work work NN 3344 214 26 ’s ’s , 3344 214 27 license license NN 3344 214 28 permits permit VBZ 3344 214 29 it -PRON- PRP 3344 214 30 , , , 3344 214 31 or or CC 3344 214 32 the the DT 3344 214 33 work work NN 3344 214 34 ’s ’s , 3344 214 35 copyright copyright NN 3344 214 36 owner owner NN 3344 214 37 grants grant NNS 3344 214 38 permission permission NN 3344 214 39 to to TO 3344 214 40 do do VB 3344 214 41 so so RB 3344 214 42 . . . 3344 215 1 Or or CC 3344 215 2 can can MD 3344 215 3 it -PRON- PRP 3344 215 4 ? ? . 3344 216 1 After after RB 3344 216 2 all all RB 3344 216 3 , , , 3344 216 4 the the DT 3344 216 5 Internet internet NN 3344 216 6 Archive Archive NNP 3344 216 7 does do VBZ 3344 216 8 not not RB 3344 216 9 ask ask VB 3344 216 10 permission permission NN 3344 216 11 ahead ahead RB 3344 216 12 of of IN 3344 216 13 time time NN 3344 216 14 before before IN 3344 216 15 preserving preserve VBG 3344 216 16 the the DT 3344 216 17 entire entire JJ 3344 216 18 Internet internet NN 3344 216 19 , , , 3344 216 20 although although IN 3344 216 21 it -PRON- PRP 3344 216 22 responds respond VBZ 3344 216 23 to to IN 3344 216 24 requests request NNS 3344 216 25 to to TO 3344 216 26 restrict restrict VB 3344 216 27 infor- infor- JJ 3344 216 28 mation mation NN 3344 216 29 . . . 3344 217 1 And and CC 3344 217 2 that that DT 3344 217 3 is be VBZ 3344 217 4 why why WRB 3344 217 5 the the DT 3344 217 6 Internet Internet NNP 3344 217 7 Archive Archive NNP 3344 217 8 is be VBZ 3344 217 9 currently currently RB 3344 217 10 being be VBG 3344 217 11 sued sue VBN 3344 217 12 by by IN 3344 217 13 Healthcare Healthcare NNP 3344 217 14 Advocates Advocates NNPS 3344 217 15 , , , 3344 217 16 which which WDT 3344 217 17 says say VBZ 3344 217 18 that that IN 3344 217 19 it -PRON- PRP 3344 217 20 : : : 3344 217 21 “ " `` 3344 217 22 is be VBZ 3344 217 23 just just RB 3344 217 24 like like IN 3344 217 25 a a DT 3344 217 26 big big JJ 3344 217 27 vacuum vacuum NN 3344 217 28 cleaner cleaner NN 3344 217 29 , , , 3344 217 30 sucking suck VBG 3344 217 31 up up RP 3344 217 32 information information NN 3344 217 33 and and CC 3344 217 34 making make VBG 3344 217 35 it -PRON- PRP 3344 217 36 available available JJ 3344 217 37 . . . 3344 217 38 ”67 ”67 UH 3344 217 39 If if IN 3344 217 40 it -PRON- PRP 3344 217 41 is be VBZ 3344 217 42 not not RB 3344 217 43 settled settle VBN 3344 217 44 out out IN 3344 217 45 of of IN 3344 217 46 court court NN 3344 217 47 , , , 3344 217 48 this this DT 3344 217 49 will will MD 3344 217 50 be be VB 3344 217 51 an an DT 3344 217 52 interesting interesting JJ 3344 217 53 case case NN 3344 217 54 for for IN 3344 217 55 more more JJR 3344 217 56 digitally digitally RB 3344 217 57 adventurous adventurous JJ 3344 217 58 libraries library NNS 3344 217 59 to to TO 3344 217 60 watch watch VB 3344 217 61 . . . 3344 218 1 As as IN 3344 218 2 the the DT 3344 218 3 cost cost NN 3344 218 4 of of IN 3344 218 5 the the DT 3344 218 6 hardware hardware NN 3344 218 7 and and CC 3344 218 8 software software NN 3344 218 9 needed need VBD 3344 218 10 to to TO 3344 218 11 effectively effectively RB 3344 218 12 do do VB 3344 218 13 so so RB 3344 218 14 continues continue VBZ 3344 218 15 to to TO 3344 218 16 drop drop VB 3344 218 17 , , , 3344 218 18 faculty faculty NN 3344 218 19 , , , 3344 218 20 students student NNS 3344 218 21 , , , 3344 218 22 and and CC 3344 218 23 other other JJ 3344 218 24 library library NN 3344 218 25 users user NNS 3344 218 26 will will MD 3344 218 27 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 218 28 want want VB 3344 218 29 to to TO 3344 218 30 repurpose repurpose VB 3344 218 31 content content NN 3344 218 32 , , , 3344 218 33 digitizing digitize VBG 3344 218 34 conventional conventional JJ 3344 218 35 print print NN 3344 218 36 and and CC 3344 218 37 media medium NNS 3344 218 38 materials material NNS 3344 218 39 , , , 3344 218 40 remixing remixe VBG 3344 218 41 digital digital JJ 3344 218 42 ones one NNS 3344 218 43 , , , 3344 218 44 and/or and/or CC 3344 218 45 creating create VBG 3344 218 46 new new JJ 3344 218 47 digital digital JJ 3344 218 48 materi- materi- JJ 3344 218 49 als als NNP 3344 218 50 from from IN 3344 218 51 both both DT 3344 218 52 . . . 3344 219 1 With with IN 3344 219 2 the the DT 3344 219 3 “ " `` 3344 219 4 information information NN 3344 219 5 commons commons NNPS 3344 219 6 ” " '' 3344 219 7 movement movement NN 3344 219 8 , , , 3344 219 9 academic academic JJ 3344 219 10 libraries library NNS 3344 219 11 are be VBP 3344 219 12 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 219 13 providing provide VBG 3344 219 14 users user NNS 3344 219 15 with with IN 3344 219 16 the the DT 3344 219 17 hard- hard- NNP 3344 219 18 ware ware NN 3344 219 19 and and CC 3344 219 20 software software NN 3344 219 21 tools tool NNS 3344 219 22 to to TO 3344 219 23 repurpose repurpose VB 3344 219 24 content content NN 3344 219 25 . . . 3344 220 1 Given give VBN 3344 220 2 that that IN 3344 220 3 the the DT 3344 220 4 wording wording NN 3344 220 5 of of IN 3344 220 6 the the DT 3344 220 7 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 221 1 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 221 2 Act Act NNP 3344 221 3 section section NN 3344 221 4 108 108 CD 3344 221 5 ( ( -LRB- 3344 221 6 f f NN 3344 221 7 ) ) -RRB- 3344 221 8 ( ( -LRB- 3344 221 9 1 1 LS 3344 221 10 ) ) -RRB- 3344 221 11 is be VBZ 3344 221 12 vague vague JJ 3344 221 13 enough enough RB 3344 221 14 that that IN 3344 221 15 it -PRON- PRP 3344 221 16 could could MD 3344 221 17 be be VB 3344 221 18 interpreted interpret VBN 3344 221 19 to to TO 3344 221 20 include include VB 3344 221 21 these these DT 3344 221 22 tools tool NNS 3344 221 23 when when WRB 3344 221 24 they -PRON- PRP 3344 221 25 are be VBP 3344 221 26 used use VBN 3344 221 27 for for IN 3344 221 28 information information NN 3344 221 29 reproduction reproduction NN 3344 221 30 , , , 3344 221 31 is be VBZ 3344 221 32 the the DT 3344 221 33 old old JJ 3344 221 34 “ " `` 3344 221 35 copyright copyright NN 3344 221 36 disclaimer disclaimer NN 3344 221 37 on on IN 3344 221 38 the the DT 3344 221 39 photocopier photocopier NN 3344 221 40 ” " '' 3344 221 41 solution solution NN 3344 221 42 enough enough RB 3344 221 43 in in IN 3344 221 44 the the DT 3344 221 45 new new JJ 3344 221 46 digital digital JJ 3344 221 47 environment environment NN 3344 221 48 ? ? . 3344 222 1 Or or CC 3344 222 2 — — : 3344 222 3 in in IN 3344 222 4 light light NN 3344 222 5 of of IN 3344 222 6 the the DT 3344 222 7 unprecedented unprecedented JJ 3344 222 8 transformational transformational JJ 3344 222 9 power power NN 3344 222 10 of of IN 3344 222 11 these these DT 3344 222 12 tools tool NNS 3344 222 13 to to TO 3344 222 14 create create VB 3344 222 15 new new JJ 3344 222 16 digital digital JJ 3344 222 17 works work NNS 3344 222 18 , , , 3344 222 19 and and CC 3344 222 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 222 21 widespread widespread JJ 3344 222 22 use use NN 3344 222 23 both both DT 3344 222 24 within within IN 3344 222 25 libraries library NNS 3344 222 26 and and CC 3344 222 27 on on IN 3344 222 28 campus campus NN 3344 222 29 — — : 3344 222 30 do do VBP 3344 222 31 academic academic JJ 3344 222 32 libraries library NNS 3344 222 33 bear bear VB 3344 222 34 heavier heavy JJR 3344 222 35 responsibilities responsibility NNS 3344 222 36 regarding regard VBG 3344 222 37 copyright copyright NN 3344 222 38 compli- compli- JJ 3344 222 39 ance ance NN 3344 222 40 , , , 3344 222 41 permission permission NN 3344 222 42 - - HYPH 3344 222 43 seeking seeking NN 3344 222 44 , , , 3344 222 45 and and CC 3344 222 46 education education NN 3344 222 47 ? ? . 3344 223 1 Similar similar JJ 3344 223 2 issues issue NNS 3344 223 3 arise arise VBP 3344 223 4 when when WRB 3344 223 5 faculty faculty NN 3344 223 6 want want VBP 3344 223 7 to to TO 3344 223 8 place place VB 3344 223 9 self self NN 3344 223 10 - - HYPH 3344 223 11 cre- cre- NN 3344 223 12 ated ate VBD 3344 223 13 digital digital JJ 3344 223 14 works work NNS 3344 223 15 that that WDT 3344 223 16 incorporate incorporate VBP 3344 223 17 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 223 18 materials material NNS 3344 223 19 in in IN 3344 223 20 electronic electronic JJ 3344 223 21 reserves reserve NNS 3344 223 22 systems system NNS 3344 223 23 or or CC 3344 223 24 institutional institutional JJ 3344 223 25 repositories repository NNS 3344 223 26 . . . 3344 224 1 End- End- NNP 3344 224 2 user user NN 3344 224 3 contributions contribution NNS 3344 224 4 to to IN 3344 224 5 “ " `` 3344 224 6 Library library JJ 3344 224 7 2.0 2.0 CD 3344 224 8 ” " '' 3344 224 9 systems system NNS 3344 224 10 that that WDT 3344 224 11 incorporate incorporate VBP 3344 224 12 copyrighted copyright VBN 3344 224 13 materials material NNS 3344 224 14 may may MD 3344 224 15 also also RB 3344 224 16 raise raise VB 3344 224 17 copyright copyright NN 3344 224 18 concerns concern NNS 3344 224 19 . . . 3344 225 1 DRM DRM NNP 3344 225 2 As as IN 3344 225 3 libraries library NNS 3344 225 4 realize realize VBP 3344 225 5 that that IN 3344 225 6 they -PRON- PRP 3344 225 7 can can MD 3344 225 8 not not RB 3344 225 9 afford afford VB 3344 225 10 dual dual JJ 3344 225 11 formats format NNS 3344 225 12 , , , 3344 225 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 225 14 new new JJ 3344 225 15 journal journal NN 3344 225 16 and and CC 3344 225 17 index index NN 3344 225 18 holdings holding NNS 3344 225 19 are be VBP 3344 225 20 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 225 21 solely solely RB 3344 225 22 digital digital JJ 3344 225 23 . . . 3344 226 1 Libraries library NNS 3344 226 2 are be VBP 3344 226 3 also also RB 3344 226 4 licensing license VBG 3344 226 5 a a DT 3344 226 6 growing grow VBG 3344 226 7 variety variety NN 3344 226 8 of of IN 3344 226 9 “ " `` 3344 226 10 born bear VBN 3344 226 11 digital digital JJ 3344 226 12 ” " '' 3344 226 13 information information NN 3344 226 14 . . . 3344 227 1 The the DT 3344 227 2 complexities complexity NNS 3344 227 3 of of IN 3344 227 4 dealing deal VBG 3344 227 5 with with IN 3344 227 6 license license NN 3344 227 7 restrictions restriction NNS 3344 227 8 for for IN 3344 227 9 these these DT 3344 227 10 commercial commercial JJ 3344 227 11 digital digital JJ 3344 227 12 prod- prod- NN 3344 227 13 ucts uct NNS 3344 227 14 are be VBP 3344 227 15 well well RB 3344 227 16 understood understand VBN 3344 227 17 , , , 3344 227 18 but but CC 3344 227 19 imagine imagine VB 3344 227 20 if if IN 3344 227 21 DRM DRM NNP 3344 227 22 was be VBD 3344 227 23 layered layer VBN 3344 227 24 on on IN 3344 227 25 top top NN 3344 227 26 of of IN 3344 227 27 license license NN 3344 227 28 restrictions restriction NNS 3344 227 29 . . . 3344 228 1 As as IN 3344 228 2 we -PRON- PRP 3344 228 3 have have VBP 3344 228 4 discussed discuss VBN 3344 228 5 , , , 3344 228 6 DRM DRM NNP 3344 228 7 will will MD 3344 228 8 allow allow VB 3344 228 9 content content JJ 3344 228 10 producers producer NNS 3344 228 11 and and CC 3344 228 12 distributors distributor NNS 3344 228 13 to to TO 3344 228 14 slice slice VB 3344 228 15 , , , 3344 228 16 dice dice NN 3344 228 17 , , , 3344 228 18 and and CC 3344 228 19 monetize monetize VB 3344 228 20 access access NN 3344 228 21 to to IN 3344 228 22 digital digital JJ 3344 228 23 information information NN 3344 228 24 in in IN 3344 228 25 ways way NNS 3344 228 26 that that WDT 3344 228 27 were be VBD 3344 228 28 previously previously RB 3344 228 29 impossible impossible JJ 3344 228 30 . . . 3344 229 1 What what WP 3344 229 2 may may MD 3344 229 3 be be VB 3344 229 4 every every DT 3344 229 5 publisher publisher NN 3344 229 6 / / SYM 3344 229 7 vendor vendor NN 3344 229 8 ’s ’s , 3344 229 9 dream dream NN 3344 229 10 could could MD 3344 229 11 be be VB 3344 229 12 every every DT 3344 229 13 library library NN 3344 229 14 ’s ’s '' 3344 229 15 nightmare nightmare NN 3344 229 16 . . . 3344 230 1 Aside aside RB 3344 230 2 from from IN 3344 230 3 a a DT 3344 230 4 potential potential JJ 3344 230 5 surge surge NN 3344 230 6 of of IN 3344 230 7 publisher publisher NN 3344 230 8 / / SYM 3344 230 9 vendor vendor NN 3344 230 10 - - HYPH 3344 230 11 specific specific JJ 3344 230 12 access access NN 3344 230 13 licensing licensing NN 3344 230 14 options option NNS 3344 230 15 and and CC 3344 230 16 fees fee NNS 3344 230 17 , , , 3344 230 18 libraries library NNS 3344 230 19 may may MD 3344 230 20 also also RB 3344 230 21 have have VB 3344 230 22 to to TO 3344 230 23 contend contend VB 3344 230 24 with with IN 3344 230 25 publisher/ publisher/ NNP 3344 230 26 vendor vendor NN 3344 230 27 - - HYPH 3344 230 28 specific specific JJ 3344 230 29 DRM DRM NNP 3344 230 30 technical technical JJ 3344 230 31 solutions solution NNS 3344 230 32 , , , 3344 230 33 which which WDT 3344 230 34 may may MD 3344 230 35 : : : 3344 230 36 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 230 37 depend depend VB 3344 230 38 on on IN 3344 230 39 particular particular JJ 3344 230 40 hardware hardware NN 3344 230 41 / / SYM 3344 230 42 software software NN 3344 230 43 platforms platform NNS 3344 230 44 , , , 3344 230 45 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 230 46 be be VB 3344 230 47 incompatible incompatible JJ 3344 230 48 with with IN 3344 230 49 each each DT 3344 230 50 other other JJ 3344 230 51 , , , 3344 230 52 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 230 53 decrease decrease NNP 3344 230 54 computer computer NN 3344 230 55 reliability reliability NN 3344 230 56 and and CC 3344 230 57 security security NN 3344 230 58 , , , 3344 230 59 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 230 60 eliminate eliminate NNP 3344 230 61 fair fair JJ 3344 230 62 or or CC 3344 230 63 otherwise otherwise RB 3344 230 64 legal legal JJ 3344 230 65 use use NN 3344 230 66 of of IN 3344 230 67 DRM drm NN 3344 230 68 - - HYPH 3344 230 69 pro- pro- NN 3344 230 70 tected tecte VBN 3344 230 71 information information NN 3344 230 72 , , , 3344 230 73 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 230 74 raise raise VBP 3344 230 75 user user NN 3344 230 76 privacy privacy NN 3344 230 77 issues issue NNS 3344 230 78 , , , 3344 230 79 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 230 80 restrict restrict VBP 3344 230 81 digital digital JJ 3344 230 82 preservation preservation NN 3344 230 83 to to TO 3344 230 84 bitstream bitstream VB 3344 230 85 preservation preservation NN 3344 230 86 ( ( -LRB- 3344 230 87 if if IN 3344 230 88 allowed allow VBN 3344 230 89 by by IN 3344 230 90 license license NN 3344 230 91 ) ) -RRB- 3344 230 92 , , , 3344 230 93 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 3344 230 94 DYSTOPIA DYSTOPIA NNP 3344 230 95 | | NNP 3344 230 96 BAILEY BAILEY NNP 3344 230 97 125 125 CD 3344 230 98 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 230 99 make make VBP 3344 230 100 it -PRON- PRP 3344 230 101 difficult difficult JJ 3344 230 102 to to TO 3344 230 103 assess assess VB 3344 230 104 whether whether IN 3344 230 105 to to TO 3344 230 106 license license VB 3344 230 107 DRM- drm- NN 3344 230 108 protected protect VBD 3344 230 109 materials material NNS 3344 230 110 , , , 3344 230 111 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 230 112 increase increase VBP 3344 230 113 the the DT 3344 230 114 difficulty difficulty NN 3344 230 115 of of IN 3344 230 116 providing provide VBG 3344 230 117 unified unified JJ 3344 230 118 access access NN 3344 230 119 to to IN 3344 230 120 information information NN 3344 230 121 from from IN 3344 230 122 different different JJ 3344 230 123 publishers publisher NNS 3344 230 124 and and CC 3344 230 125 vendors vendor NNS 3344 230 126 , , , 3344 230 127 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 230 128 multiply multiply NNP 3344 230 129 user user NN 3344 230 130 support support NN 3344 230 131 headaches headache NNS 3344 230 132 , , , 3344 230 133 and and CC 3344 230 134 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 230 135 necessitate necessitate NNP 3344 230 136 increased increase VBN 3344 230 137 staffing staffing NN 3344 230 138 . . . 3344 231 1 DRM DRM NNP 3344 231 2 makes make VBZ 3344 231 3 solving solve VBG 3344 231 4 many many JJ 3344 231 5 of of IN 3344 231 6 these these DT 3344 231 7 problems problem NNS 3344 231 8 both both DT 3344 231 9 legally legally RB 3344 231 10 and and CC 3344 231 11 technically technically RB 3344 231 12 impossible impossible JJ 3344 231 13 . . . 3344 232 1 For for IN 3344 232 2 example example NN 3344 232 3 , , , 3344 232 4 under under IN 3344 232 5 DMCA DMCA NNP 3344 232 6 , , , 3344 232 7 libraries library NNS 3344 232 8 have have VBP 3344 232 9 the the DT 3344 232 10 right right NN 3344 232 11 to to TO 3344 232 12 circumvent circumvent VB 3344 232 13 DRM DRM NNP 3344 232 14 for for IN 3344 232 15 a a DT 3344 232 16 work work NN 3344 232 17 in in IN 3344 232 18 order order NN 3344 232 19 to to TO 3344 232 20 evaluate evaluate VB 3344 232 21 whether whether IN 3344 232 22 they -PRON- PRP 3344 232 23 want want VBP 3344 232 24 to to TO 3344 232 25 purchase purchase VB 3344 232 26 it -PRON- PRP 3344 232 27 . . . 3344 233 1 However however RB 3344 233 2 , , , 3344 233 3 they -PRON- PRP 3344 233 4 can can MD 3344 233 5 not not RB 3344 233 6 do do VB 3344 233 7 so so RB 3344 233 8 without without IN 3344 233 9 the the DT 3344 233 10 software software NN 3344 233 11 tools tool NNS 3344 233 12 to to TO 3344 233 13 crack crack VB 3344 233 14 the the DT 3344 233 15 work work NN 3344 233 16 ’s ’s . 3344 233 17 DRM DRM NNP 3344 233 18 protection protection NN 3344 233 19 . . . 3344 234 1 But but CC 3344 234 2 the the DT 3344 234 3 distribution distribution NN 3344 234 4 of of IN 3344 234 5 those those DT 3344 234 6 tools tool NNS 3344 234 7 is be VBZ 3344 234 8 illegal illegal JJ 3344 234 9 under under IN 3344 234 10 DMCA DMCA NNP 3344 234 11 , , , 3344 234 12 and and CC 3344 234 13 local local JJ 3344 234 14 develop- develop- NNS 3344 234 15 ment ment NN 3344 234 16 of of IN 3344 234 17 such such JJ 3344 234 18 tools tool NNS 3344 234 19 is be VBZ 3344 234 20 likely likely JJ 3344 234 21 to to TO 3344 234 22 be be VB 3344 234 23 prohibitively prohibitively RB 3344 234 24 complex complex JJ 3344 234 25 and and CC 3344 234 26 expensive.68 expensive.68 NNP 3344 234 27 Fostering foster VBG 3344 234 28 alternatives alternative NNS 3344 234 29 to to IN 3344 234 30 restrictive restrictive JJ 3344 234 31 copyright copyright NN 3344 234 32 and and CC 3344 234 33 DRM DRM NNP 3344 234 34 Given give VBN 3344 234 35 the the DT 3344 234 36 uphill uphill JJ 3344 234 37 battle battle NN 3344 234 38 in in IN 3344 234 39 the the DT 3344 234 40 courts court NNS 3344 234 41 and and CC 3344 234 42 legislatures legislature NNS 3344 234 43 , , , 3344 234 44 CCLs CCLs NNPS 3344 234 45 ( ( -LRB- 3344 234 46 or or CC 3344 234 47 similar similar JJ 3344 234 48 licenses license NNS 3344 234 49 ) ) -RRB- 3344 234 50 and and CC 3344 234 51 OA OA NNP 3344 234 52 are be VBP 3344 234 53 particularly particularly RB 3344 234 54 prom- prom- JJ 3344 234 55 ising ise VBG 3344 234 56 strategies strategy NNS 3344 234 57 to to TO 3344 234 58 deal deal VB 3344 234 59 with with IN 3344 234 60 copyright copyright NN 3344 234 61 and and CC 3344 234 62 DRM DRM NNP 3344 234 63 issues issue NNS 3344 234 64 . . . 3344 235 1 Copyright copyright NN 3344 235 2 laws law NNS 3344 235 3 do do VBP 3344 235 4 not not RB 3344 235 5 need need VB 3344 235 6 to to TO 3344 235 7 change change VB 3344 235 8 for for IN 3344 235 9 these these DT 3344 235 10 strategies strategy NNS 3344 235 11 to to TO 3344 235 12 be be VB 3344 235 13 effective effective JJ 3344 235 14 . . . 3344 236 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 236 2 is be VBZ 3344 236 3 not not RB 3344 236 4 just just RB 3344 236 5 a a DT 3344 236 6 question question NN 3344 236 7 of of IN 3344 236 8 libraries library NNS 3344 236 9 helping help VBG 3344 236 10 to to TO 3344 236 11 support support VB 3344 236 12 OA OA NNP 3344 236 13 by by IN 3344 236 14 paying pay VBG 3344 236 15 for for IN 3344 236 16 institutional institutional JJ 3344 236 17 memberships membership NNS 3344 236 18 to to IN 3344 236 19 OA OA NNP 3344 236 20 jour- jour- NN 3344 236 21 nals nal NNS 3344 236 22 , , , 3344 236 23 building build VBG 3344 236 24 and and CC 3344 236 25 maintaining maintain VBG 3344 236 26 institutional institutional JJ 3344 236 27 repositories repository NNS 3344 236 28 , , , 3344 236 29 supporting support VBG 3344 236 30 OA OA NNP 3344 236 31 mandates mandate NNS 3344 236 32 , , , 3344 236 33 encouraging encourage VBG 3344 236 34 faculty faculty NN 3344 236 35 to to TO 3344 236 36 edit edit VB 3344 236 37 and and CC 3344 236 38 publish publish VB 3344 236 39 OA OA NNP 3344 236 40 journals journal NNS 3344 236 41 , , , 3344 236 42 educating educate VBG 3344 236 43 faculty faculty NN 3344 236 44 about about IN 3344 236 45 copyright copyright NN 3344 236 46 and and CC 3344 236 47 OA OA NNP 3344 236 48 issues issue NNS 3344 236 49 , , , 3344 236 50 and and CC 3344 236 51 encouraging encourage VBG 3344 236 52 them -PRON- PRP 3344 236 53 to to TO 3344 236 54 utilize utilize VB 3344 236 55 CCLs ccl NNS 3344 236 56 ( ( -LRB- 3344 236 57 or or CC 3344 236 58 similar similar JJ 3344 236 59 licenses license NNS 3344 236 60 ) ) -RRB- 3344 236 61 . . . 3344 237 1 To to TO 3344 237 2 truly truly RB 3344 237 3 create create VB 3344 237 4 change change NN 3344 237 5 , , , 3344 237 6 libraries library NNS 3344 237 7 need need VBP 3344 237 8 to to TO 3344 237 9 “ " `` 3344 237 10 walk walk VB 3344 237 11 the the DT 3344 237 12 talk talk NN 3344 237 13 ” " '' 3344 237 14 and and CC 3344 237 15 either either CC 3344 237 16 let let VB 3344 237 17 the the DT 3344 237 18 public public JJ 3344 237 19 - - HYPH 3344 237 20 domain domain NN 3344 237 21 materials material NNS 3344 237 22 they -PRON- PRP 3344 237 23 digitize digitize VBP 3344 237 24 remain remain VBP 3344 237 25 in in IN 3344 237 26 the the DT 3344 237 27 public public JJ 3344 237 28 domain domain NN 3344 237 29 , , , 3344 237 30 or or CC 3344 237 31 put put VBD 3344 237 32 them -PRON- PRP 3344 237 33 under under IN 3344 237 34 CCLs ccl NNS 3344 237 35 ( ( -LRB- 3344 237 36 or or CC 3344 237 37 similar similar JJ 3344 237 38 licenses license NNS 3344 237 39 ) ) -RRB- 3344 237 40 , , , 3344 237 41 and and CC 3344 237 42 , , , 3344 237 43 when when WRB 3344 237 44 they -PRON- PRP 3344 237 45 create create VBP 3344 237 46 original original JJ 3344 237 47 digital digital JJ 3344 237 48 content content NN 3344 237 49 , , , 3344 237 50 put put VBD 3344 237 51 it -PRON- PRP 3344 237 52 under under IN 3344 237 53 CCLs ccl NNS 3344 237 54 ( ( -LRB- 3344 237 55 or or CC 3344 237 56 similar similar JJ 3344 237 57 ) ) -RRB- 3344 237 58 licenses license NNS 3344 237 59 as as RB 3344 237 60 well well RB 3344 237 61 . . . 3344 238 1 As as IN 3344 238 2 the the DT 3344 238 3 OA OA NNP 3344 238 4 movement movement NN 3344 238 5 has have VBZ 3344 238 6 shown show VBN 3344 238 7 , , , 3344 238 8 using use VBG 3344 238 9 CCLs ccl NNS 3344 238 10 does do VBZ 3344 238 11 not not RB 3344 238 12 rule rule VB 3344 238 13 out out RP 3344 238 14 revenue revenue NN 3344 238 15 generation generation NN 3344 238 16 ( ( -LRB- 3344 238 17 if if IN 3344 238 18 that that DT 3344 238 19 is be VBZ 3344 238 20 an an DT 3344 238 21 appropriate appropriate JJ 3344 238 22 goal goal NN 3344 238 23 ) ) -RRB- 3344 238 24 , , , 3344 238 25 but but CC 3344 238 26 it -PRON- PRP 3344 238 27 does do VBZ 3344 238 28 require require VB 3344 238 29 facilitating facilitate VBG 3344 238 30 strategies strategy NNS 3344 238 31 , , , 3344 238 32 such such JJ 3344 238 33 as as IN 3344 238 34 advertis- advertis- NNP 3344 238 35 ing ing NNP 3344 238 36 and and CC 3344 238 37 offering offer VBG 3344 238 38 fee fee NN 3344 238 39 - - HYPH 3344 238 40 based base VBN 3344 238 41 add add VB 3344 238 42 - - HYPH 3344 238 43 on on RP 3344 238 44 products product NNS 3344 238 45 and and CC 3344 238 46 services service NNS 3344 238 47 . . . 3344 239 1 Net net JJ 3344 239 2 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 239 3 There there EX 3344 239 4 are be VBP 3344 239 5 many many JJ 3344 239 6 unknowns unknown NNS 3344 239 7 surrounding surround VBG 3344 239 8 the the DT 3344 239 9 issue issue NN 3344 239 10 of of IN 3344 239 11 Net net JJ 3344 239 12 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 239 13 , , , 3344 239 14 but but CC 3344 239 15 what what WP 3344 239 16 is be VBZ 3344 239 17 clear clear JJ 3344 239 18 is be VBZ 3344 239 19 that that IN 3344 239 20 it -PRON- PRP 3344 239 21 is be VBZ 3344 239 22 under under IN 3344 239 23 assault assault NN 3344 239 24 . . . 3344 240 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 240 2 is be VBZ 3344 240 3 also also RB 3344 240 4 clear clear JJ 3344 240 5 that that IN 3344 240 6 Internet internet NN 3344 240 7 services service NNS 3344 240 8 are be VBP 3344 240 9 more more RBR 3344 240 10 likely likely JJ 3344 240 11 to to TO 3344 240 12 require require VB 3344 240 13 more more JJR 3344 240 14 , , , 3344 240 15 not not RB 3344 240 16 less less JJR 3344 240 17 , , , 3344 240 18 bandwidth bandwidth JJ 3344 240 19 in in IN 3344 240 20 the the DT 3344 240 21 future future NN 3344 240 22 as as IN 3344 240 23 digital digital JJ 3344 240 24 media medium NNS 3344 240 25 and and CC 3344 240 26 other other JJ 3344 240 27 high high JJ 3344 240 28 - - HYPH 3344 240 29 bandwidth bandwidth NN 3344 240 30 applications application NNS 3344 240 31 become become VBP 3344 240 32 more more RBR 3344 240 33 com- com- NN 3344 240 34 monplace monplace NN 3344 240 35 , , , 3344 240 36 complex complex NN 3344 240 37 , , , 3344 240 38 and and CC 3344 240 39 interwoven interwoven RB 3344 240 40 into into IN 3344 240 41 a a DT 3344 240 42 larger large JJR 3344 240 43 number number NN 3344 240 44 of of IN 3344 240 45 Internet internet NN 3344 240 46 systems system NNS 3344 240 47 . . . 3344 241 1 One one PRP 3344 241 2 would would MD 3344 241 3 imagine imagine VB 3344 241 4 that that IN 3344 241 5 if if IN 3344 241 6 a a DT 3344 241 7 corporation corporation NN 3344 241 8 such such JJ 3344 241 9 as as IN 3344 241 10 Google Google NNP 3344 241 11 had have VBD 3344 241 12 to to TO 3344 241 13 pay pay VB 3344 241 14 for for IN 3344 241 15 a a DT 3344 241 16 high high JJ 3344 241 17 - - HYPH 3344 241 18 speed speed NN 3344 241 19 digital digital JJ 3344 241 20 lane lane NN 3344 241 21 , , , 3344 241 22 it -PRON- PRP 3344 241 23 would would MD 3344 241 24 want want VB 3344 241 25 it -PRON- PRP 3344 241 26 to to TO 3344 241 27 reach reach VB 3344 241 28 as as RB 3344 241 29 many many JJ 3344 241 30 consumers consumer NNS 3344 241 31 as as IN 3344 241 32 possible possible JJ 3344 241 33 . . . 3344 242 1 So so RB 3344 242 2 , , , 3344 242 3 it -PRON- PRP 3344 242 4 may may MD 3344 242 5 well well RB 3344 242 6 be be VB 3344 242 7 that that IN 3344 242 8 libraries library NNS 3344 242 9 ’ ' '' 3344 242 10 Google Google NNP 3344 242 11 access access NN 3344 242 12 would would MD 3344 242 13 be be VB 3344 242 14 unaffected unaffected JJ 3344 242 15 or or CC 3344 242 16 possibly possibly RB 3344 242 17 improved improve VBN 3344 242 18 by by IN 3344 242 19 a a DT 3344 242 20 two two CD 3344 242 21 - - HYPH 3344 242 22 tier tier NN 3344 242 23 ( ( -LRB- 3344 242 24 or or CC 3344 242 25 multi multi JJ 3344 242 26 - - JJ 3344 242 27 tier tier JJ 3344 242 28 ) ) -RRB- 3344 242 29 Internet internet NN 3344 242 30 “ " `` 3344 242 31 speed speed NN 3344 242 32 - - HYPH 3344 242 33 lane lane NN 3344 242 34 ” " '' 3344 242 35 service service NN 3344 242 36 model model NN 3344 242 37 . . . 3344 243 1 Would Would MD 3344 243 2 the the DT 3344 243 3 same same JJ 3344 243 4 be be VB 3344 243 5 true true JJ 3344 243 6 for for IN 3344 243 7 library library NN 3344 243 8 - - HYPH 3344 243 9 oriented orient VBN 3344 243 10 publishers publisher NNS 3344 243 11 and and CC 3344 243 12 vendors vendor NNS 3344 243 13 ? ? . 3344 244 1 That that DT 3344 244 2 may may MD 3344 244 3 depend depend VB 3344 244 4 on on IN 3344 244 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 244 6 size size NN 3344 244 7 and and CC 3344 244 8 relative relative JJ 3344 244 9 affluence affluence NN 3344 244 10 . . . 3344 245 1 If if IN 3344 245 2 so so RB 3344 245 3 , , , 3344 245 4 the the DT 3344 245 5 ability ability NN 3344 245 6 of of IN 3344 245 7 smaller small JJR 3344 245 8 publishers publisher NNS 3344 245 9 and and CC 3344 245 10 vendors vendor NNS 3344 245 11 to to TO 3344 245 12 offer offer VB 3344 245 13 innovative innovative JJ 3344 245 14 bandwidth bandwidth NN 3344 245 15 - - HYPH 3344 245 16 intensive intensive JJ 3344 245 17 products product NNS 3344 245 18 and and CC 3344 245 19 services service NNS 3344 245 20 may may MD 3344 245 21 be be VB 3344 245 22 curtailed curtail VBN 3344 245 23 . . . 3344 246 1 Unless unless IN 3344 246 2 they -PRON- PRP 3344 246 3 are be VBP 3344 246 4 affluent affluent JJ 3344 246 5 , , , 3344 246 6 libraries library NNS 3344 246 7 may may MD 3344 246 8 also also RB 3344 246 9 find find VB 3344 246 10 that that IN 3344 246 11 they -PRON- PRP 3344 246 12 are be VBP 3344 246 13 confined confine VBN 3344 246 14 to to IN 3344 246 15 slower slow JJR 3344 246 16 Internet internet NN 3344 246 17 speed speed NN 3344 246 18 lanes lane NNS 3344 246 19 when when WRB 3344 246 20 they -PRON- PRP 3344 246 21 act act VBP 3344 246 22 as as IN 3344 246 23 information information NN 3344 246 24 providers provider NNS 3344 246 25 . . . 3344 247 1 For for IN 3344 247 2 libraries library NNS 3344 247 3 engaged engage VBN 3344 247 4 in in IN 3344 247 5 digital digital JJ 3344 247 6 library library NN 3344 247 7 , , , 3344 247 8 electronic electronic JJ 3344 247 9 publishing publishing NN 3344 247 10 , , , 3344 247 11 and and CC 3344 247 12 institutional institutional JJ 3344 247 13 repository repository JJ 3344 247 14 projects project NNS 3344 247 15 , , , 3344 247 16 this this DT 3344 247 17 may may MD 3344 247 18 be be VB 3344 247 19 problematic problematic JJ 3344 247 20 , , , 3344 247 21 especially especially RB 3344 247 22 as as IN 3344 247 23 they -PRON- PRP 3344 247 24 increasingly increasingly RB 3344 247 25 add add VBP 3344 247 26 more more JJR 3344 247 27 digital digital JJ 3344 247 28 media medium NNS 3344 247 29 , , , 3344 247 30 large large JJ 3344 247 31 - - HYPH 3344 247 32 data data NN 3344 247 33 - - HYPH 3344 247 34 set set NN 3344 247 35 , , , 3344 247 36 or or CC 3344 247 37 other other JJ 3344 247 38 bandwidth bandwidth NN 3344 247 39 - - HYPH 3344 247 40 intensive intensive JJ 3344 247 41 applications application NNS 3344 247 42 . . . 3344 248 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 248 2 ’s ’ VBZ 3344 248 3 important important JJ 3344 248 4 to to TO 3344 248 5 keep keep VB 3344 248 6 in in IN 3344 248 7 mind mind NN 3344 248 8 that that IN 3344 248 9 Net net JJ 3344 248 10 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 248 11 impacts impact NNS 3344 248 12 are be VBP 3344 248 13 tied tie VBN 3344 248 14 to to IN 3344 248 15 where where WRB 3344 248 16 the the DT 3344 248 17 chokepoints chokepoint NNS 3344 248 18 are be VBP 3344 248 19 , , , 3344 248 20 with with IN 3344 248 21 the the DT 3344 248 22 most most RBS 3344 248 23 serious serious JJ 3344 248 24 potential potential JJ 3344 248 25 impacts impact NNS 3344 248 26 being be VBG 3344 248 27 at at IN 3344 248 28 chokepoints chokepoint NNS 3344 248 29 that that WDT 3344 248 30 affect affect VBP 3344 248 31 large large JJ 3344 248 32 numbers number NNS 3344 248 33 of of IN 3344 248 34 users user NNS 3344 248 35 , , , 3344 248 36 such such JJ 3344 248 37 as as IN 3344 248 38 local local JJ 3344 248 39 ISPs isp NNS 3344 248 40 that that WDT 3344 248 41 are be VBP 3344 248 42 part part NN 3344 248 43 of of IN 3344 248 44 large large JJ 3344 248 45 corporations corporation NNS 3344 248 46 , , , 3344 248 47 national national NNP 3344 248 48 / / SYM 3344 248 49 international international JJ 3344 248 50 back- back- NNP 3344 248 51 bone bone NN 3344 248 52 networks network NNS 3344 248 53 , , , 3344 248 54 and and CC 3344 248 55 major major JJ 3344 248 56 Internet internet NN 3344 248 57 information information NN 3344 248 58 services service NNS 3344 248 59 ( ( -LRB- 3344 248 60 e.g e.g NNP 3344 248 61 . . NNP 3344 248 62 ,Yahoo ,Yahoo NNP 3344 248 63 ! ! . 3344 248 64 ) ) -RRB- 3344 248 65 . . . 3344 249 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 249 2 is be VBZ 3344 249 3 also also RB 3344 249 4 important important JJ 3344 249 5 to to TO 3344 249 6 realize realize VB 3344 249 7 that that IN 3344 249 8 the the DT 3344 249 9 problem problem NN 3344 249 10 may may MD 3344 249 11 be be VB 3344 249 12 partitioned partition VBN 3344 249 13 to to IN 3344 249 14 particular particular JJ 3344 249 15 network network NN 3344 249 16 segments segment NNS 3344 249 17 . . . 3344 250 1 For for IN 3344 250 2 example example NN 3344 250 3 , , , 3344 250 4 on on IN 3344 250 5 - - HYPH 3344 250 6 campus campus NN 3344 250 7 network network NN 3344 250 8 users user NNS 3344 250 9 may may MD 3344 250 10 not not RB 3344 250 11 experience experience VB 3344 250 12 any any DT 3344 250 13 speed speed NN 3344 250 14 issues issue NNS 3344 250 15 associated associate VBN 3344 250 16 with with IN 3344 250 17 the the DT 3344 250 18 delivery delivery NN 3344 250 19 of of IN 3344 250 20 bandwidth bandwidth NN 3344 250 21 - - HYPH 3344 250 22 intensive intensive JJ 3344 250 23 information information NN 3344 250 24 from from IN 3344 250 25 local local JJ 3344 250 26 library library NN 3344 250 27 servers server NNS 3344 250 28 because because IN 3344 250 29 that that DT 3344 250 30 net- net- IN 3344 250 31 work work NN 3344 250 32 segment segment NN 3344 250 33 is be VBZ 3344 250 34 under under IN 3344 250 35 university university NN 3344 250 36 control control NN 3344 250 37 . . . 3344 251 1 Remote remote JJ 3344 251 2 users user NNS 3344 251 3 , , , 3344 251 4 however however RB 3344 251 5 , , , 3344 251 6 including include VBG 3344 251 7 affiliated affiliate VBN 3344 251 8 home home NN 3344 251 9 users user NNS 3344 251 10 , , , 3344 251 11 may may MD 3344 251 12 experience experience VB 3344 251 13 throttled throttle VBN 3344 251 14 - - HYPH 3344 251 15 down down RP 3344 251 16 performance performance NN 3344 251 17 beyond beyond IN 3344 251 18 what what WP 3344 251 19 would would MD 3344 251 20 normally normally RB 3344 251 21 be be VB 3344 251 22 expected expect VBN 3344 251 23 due due IN 3344 251 24 to to IN 3344 251 25 speed speed NN 3344 251 26 - - HYPH 3344 251 27 lane lane NN 3344 251 28 enforcement enforcement NN 3344 251 29 by by IN 3344 251 30 backbone backbone NN 3344 251 31 providers provider NNS 3344 251 32 or or CC 3344 251 33 local local JJ 3344 251 34 ISPs isp NNS 3344 251 35 controlled control VBN 3344 251 36 by by IN 3344 251 37 large large JJ 3344 251 38 corporations corporation NNS 3344 251 39 . . . 3344 252 1 Likewise likewise RB 3344 252 2 , , , 3344 252 3 users user NNS 3344 252 4 at at IN 3344 252 5 two two CD 3344 252 6 universities university NNS 3344 252 7 connected connect VBN 3344 252 8 by by IN 3344 252 9 a a DT 3344 252 10 spe- spe- NN 3344 252 11 cial cial JJ 3344 252 12 research research NN 3344 252 13 network network NN 3344 252 14 may may MD 3344 252 15 experience experience VB 3344 252 16 no no DT 3344 252 17 issues issue NNS 3344 252 18 related relate VBN 3344 252 19 to to IN 3344 252 20 accessing access VBG 3344 252 21 the the DT 3344 252 22 other other JJ 3344 252 23 university university NN 3344 252 24 ’s ’s , 3344 252 25 bandwidth bandwidth NN 3344 252 26 - - HYPH 3344 252 27 intensive intensive JJ 3344 252 28 library library NN 3344 252 29 applications application NNS 3344 252 30 from from IN 3344 252 31 on on IN 3344 252 32 - - HYPH 3344 252 33 campus campus NN 3344 252 34 computers computer NNS 3344 252 35 because because IN 3344 252 36 the the DT 3344 252 37 backbone backbone NN 3344 252 38 provider provider NN 3344 252 39 is be VBZ 3344 252 40 under under IN 3344 252 41 a a DT 3344 252 42 contractual contractual JJ 3344 252 43 obligation obligation NN 3344 252 44 to to TO 3344 252 45 deliver deliver VB 3344 252 46 specific specific JJ 3344 252 47 network network NN 3344 252 48 performance performance NN 3344 252 49 levels level NNS 3344 252 50 . . . 3344 253 1 Although although IN 3344 253 2 the the DT 3344 253 3 example example NN 3344 253 4 of of IN 3344 253 5 speed speed NN 3344 253 6 lanes lane NNS 3344 253 7 has have VBZ 3344 253 8 been be VBN 3344 253 9 used use VBN 3344 253 10 in in IN 3344 253 11 this this DT 3344 253 12 examination examination NN 3344 253 13 of of IN 3344 253 14 potential potential JJ 3344 253 15 Net net JJ 3344 253 16 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 253 17 impacts impact NNS 3344 253 18 on on IN 3344 253 19 libraries library NNS 3344 253 20 , , , 3344 253 21 the the DT 3344 253 22 problem problem NN 3344 253 23 is be VBZ 3344 253 24 more more RBR 3344 253 25 complex complex JJ 3344 253 26 than than IN 3344 253 27 this this DT 3344 253 28 , , , 3344 253 29 because because IN 3344 253 30 network network NN 3344 253 31 services service NNS 3344 253 32 , , , 3344 253 33 such such JJ 3344 253 34 as as IN 3344 253 35 peer peer NN 3344 253 36 - - HYPH 3344 253 37 to to IN 3344 253 38 - - HYPH 3344 253 39 peer peer NN 3344 253 40 networking networking NN 3344 253 41 proto- proto- NN 3344 253 42 cols col NNS 3344 253 43 , , , 3344 253 44 can can MD 3344 253 45 be be VB 3344 253 46 completely completely RB 3344 253 47 blocked block VBN 3344 253 48 , , , 3344 253 49 digital digital JJ 3344 253 50 information information NN 3344 253 51 can can MD 3344 253 52 be be VB 3344 253 53 blocked block VBN 3344 253 54 or or CC 3344 253 55 filtered filter VBN 3344 253 56 , , , 3344 253 57 and and CC 3344 253 58 other other JJ 3344 253 59 types type NNS 3344 253 60 of of IN 3344 253 61 fine fine RB 3344 253 62 - - HYPH 3344 253 63 grained grain VBN 3344 253 64 network network NN 3344 253 65 control control NN 3344 253 66 can can MD 3344 253 67 be be VB 3344 253 68 exerted exert VBN 3344 253 69 . . . 3344 254 1 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 254 2 Conclusion Conclusion NNP 3344 254 3 This this DT 3344 254 4 paper paper NN 3344 254 5 has have VBZ 3344 254 6 deliberately deliberately RB 3344 254 7 presented present VBN 3344 254 8 one one CD 3344 254 9 side side NN 3344 254 10 of of IN 3344 254 11 the the DT 3344 254 12 story story NN 3344 254 13 . . . 3344 255 1 It -PRON- PRP 3344 255 2 should should MD 3344 255 3 not not RB 3344 255 4 be be VB 3344 255 5 construed construe VBN 3344 255 6 as as IN 3344 255 7 saying say VBG 3344 255 8 that that IN 3344 255 9 copyright copyright NN 3344 255 10 law law NN 3344 255 11 should should MD 3344 255 12 be be VB 3344 255 13 abolished abolish VBN 3344 255 14 or or CC 3344 255 15 violated violate VBN 3344 255 16 , , , 3344 255 17 that that IN 3344 255 18 DRM DRM NNP 3344 255 19 can can MD 3344 255 20 serve serve VB 3344 255 21 no no DT 3344 255 22 useful useful JJ 3344 255 23 purpose purpose NN 3344 255 24 ( ( -LRB- 3344 255 25 if if IN 3344 255 26 it -PRON- PRP 3344 255 27 is be VBZ 3344 255 28 possible possible JJ 3344 255 29 to to TO 3344 255 30 fix fix VB 3344 255 31 certain certain JJ 3344 255 32 critical critical JJ 3344 255 33 defi- defi- JJ 3344 255 34 ciencies ciencie NNS 3344 255 35 and and CC 3344 255 36 if if IN 3344 255 37 it -PRON- PRP 3344 255 38 is be VBZ 3344 255 39 properly properly RB 3344 255 40 employed employ VBN 3344 255 41 ) ) -RRB- 3344 255 42 , , , 3344 255 43 or or CC 3344 255 44 that that IN 3344 255 45 no no DT 3344 255 46 one one NN 3344 255 47 has have VBZ 3344 255 48 to to TO 3344 255 49 foot foot VB 3344 255 50 the the DT 3344 255 51 bill bill NN 3344 255 52 for for IN 3344 255 53 content content NN 3344 255 54 creation creation NN 3344 255 55 / / SYM 3344 255 56 marketing marketing NN 3344 255 57 / / SYM 3344 255 58 distribution distribution NN 3344 255 59 and and CC 3344 255 60 ever ever RB 3344 255 61 - - HYPH 3344 255 62 more more JJR 3344 255 63 - - HYPH 3344 255 64 bandwidth bandwidth NN 3344 255 65 - - HYPH 3344 255 66 hungry hungry JJ 3344 255 67 Internet internet NN 3344 255 68 applications application NNS 3344 255 69 . . . 3344 256 1 126 126 CD 3344 256 2 INFORMATION information NN 3344 256 3 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3344 256 4 AND and CC 3344 256 5 LIBRARIES library NNS 3344 256 6 | | CD 3344 256 7 SEPTEMBER september NN 3344 256 8 2006 2006 CD 3344 256 9 Nor nor CC 3344 256 10 is be VBZ 3344 256 11 it -PRON- PRP 3344 256 12 to to TO 3344 256 13 say say VB 3344 256 14 that that IN 3344 256 15 the the DT 3344 256 16 other other JJ 3344 256 17 side side NN 3344 256 18 of of IN 3344 256 19 the the DT 3344 256 20 story story NN 3344 256 21 , , , 3344 256 22 the the DT 3344 256 23 side side NN 3344 256 24 most most RBS 3344 256 25 likely likely JJ 3344 256 26 to to TO 3344 256 27 be be VB 3344 256 28 told tell VBN 3344 256 29 by by IN 3344 256 30 spokespersons spokesperson NNS 3344 256 31 of of IN 3344 256 32 the the DT 3344 256 33 entertain- entertain- JJ 3344 256 34 ment ment JJ 3344 256 35 , , , 3344 256 36 information information NN 3344 256 37 , , , 3344 256 38 and and CC 3344 256 39 telecommunications telecommunications NN 3344 256 40 industries industry NNS 3344 256 41 , , , 3344 256 42 has have VBZ 3344 256 43 no no DT 3344 256 44 validity validity NN 3344 256 45 and and CC 3344 256 46 does do VBZ 3344 256 47 not not RB 3344 256 48 deserve deserve VB 3344 256 49 to to TO 3344 256 50 be be VB 3344 256 51 heard hear VBN 3344 256 52 . . . 3344 257 1 However however RB 3344 257 2 , , , 3344 257 3 that that DT 3344 257 4 side side NN 3344 257 5 of of IN 3344 257 6 the the DT 3344 257 7 story story NN 3344 257 8 is be VBZ 3344 257 9 having have VBG 3344 257 10 no no DT 3344 257 11 problem problem NN 3344 257 12 being be VBG 3344 257 13 heard hear VBN 3344 257 14 , , , 3344 257 15 especially especially RB 3344 257 16 in in IN 3344 257 17 the the DT 3344 257 18 halls hall NNS 3344 257 19 of of IN 3344 257 20 Congress Congress NNP 3344 257 21 . . . 3344 258 1 The the DT 3344 258 2 side side NN 3344 258 3 of of IN 3344 258 4 the the DT 3344 258 5 story story NN 3344 258 6 presented present VBN 3344 258 7 in in IN 3344 258 8 this this DT 3344 258 9 paper paper NN 3344 258 10 is be VBZ 3344 258 11 not not RB 3344 258 12 as as RB 3344 258 13 widely widely RB 3344 258 14 heard hear VBN 3344 258 15 — — : 3344 258 16 at at IN 3344 258 17 least least JJS 3344 258 18 , , , 3344 258 19 not not RB 3344 258 20 yet yet RB 3344 258 21 . . . 3344 259 1 Nor nor CC 3344 259 2 does do VBZ 3344 259 3 it -PRON- PRP 3344 259 4 intend intend VB 3344 259 5 to to TO 3344 259 6 imply imply VB 3344 259 7 that that IN 3344 259 8 executives executive NNS 3344 259 9 from from IN 3344 259 10 the the DT 3344 259 11 entertainment entertainment NN 3344 259 12 , , , 3344 259 13 information information NN 3344 259 14 , , , 3344 259 15 telecommunications telecommunication NNS 3344 259 16 , , , 3344 259 17 and and CC 3344 259 18 other other JJ 3344 259 19 corporate corporate JJ 3344 259 20 venues venue NNS 3344 259 21 lack lack VBP 3344 259 22 a a DT 3344 259 23 social social JJ 3344 259 24 conscience conscience NN 3344 259 25 , , , 3344 259 26 are be VBP 3344 259 27 fully fully RB 3344 259 28 unified unify VBN 3344 259 29 in in IN 3344 259 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 259 31 views view NNS 3344 259 32 , , , 3344 259 33 or or CC 3344 259 34 are be VBP 3344 259 35 unconcerned unconcerned JJ 3344 259 36 with with IN 3344 259 37 the the DT 3344 259 38 societal societal JJ 3344 259 39 implications implication NNS 3344 259 40 of of IN 3344 259 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 259 42 positions position NNS 3344 259 43 . . . 3344 260 1 However however RB 3344 260 2 , , , 3344 260 3 by by IN 3344 260 4 focusing focus VBG 3344 260 5 on on IN 3344 260 6 short short JJ 3344 260 7 - - HYPH 3344 260 8 term term NN 3344 260 9 issues issue NNS 3344 260 10 , , , 3344 260 11 they -PRON- PRP 3344 260 12 may may MD 3344 260 13 not not RB 3344 260 14 fully fully RB 3344 260 15 realize realize VB 3344 260 16 the the DT 3344 260 17 potentially potentially RB 3344 260 18 negative negative JJ 3344 260 19 , , , 3344 260 20 long long JJ 3344 260 21 - - HYPH 3344 260 22 term term NN 3344 260 23 impact impact NN 3344 260 24 that that WDT 3344 260 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 260 26 positions position NNS 3344 260 27 may may MD 3344 260 28 have have VB 3344 260 29 on on IN 3344 260 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 260 31 own own JJ 3344 260 32 enterprises enterprise NNS 3344 260 33 . . . 3344 261 1 Nor nor CC 3344 261 2 has have VBZ 3344 261 3 this this DT 3344 261 4 paper paper NN 3344 261 5 presented present VBN 3344 261 6 all all DT 3344 261 7 of of IN 3344 261 8 the the DT 3344 261 9 issues issue NNS 3344 261 10 that that WDT 3344 261 11 threaten threaten VBP 3344 261 12 the the DT 3344 261 13 Internet internet NN 3344 261 14 , , , 3344 261 15 such such JJ 3344 261 16 as as IN 3344 261 17 assaults assault NNS 3344 261 18 on on IN 3344 261 19 privacy privacy NN 3344 261 20 , , , 3344 261 21 increas- increas- NNP 3344 261 22 ingly ingly RB 3344 261 23 determined determine VBN 3344 261 24 ( ( -LRB- 3344 261 25 and and CC 3344 261 26 malicious malicious JJ 3344 261 27 ) ) -RRB- 3344 261 28 hacking hacking NN 3344 261 29 , , , 3344 261 30 state state NN 3344 261 31 and and CC 3344 261 32 other other JJ 3344 261 33 censorship censorship NN 3344 261 34 , , , 3344 261 35 and and CC 3344 261 36 the the DT 3344 261 37 seemingly seemingly RB 3344 261 38 insolvable insolvable JJ 3344 261 39 problem problem NN 3344 261 40 of of IN 3344 261 41 over- over- NN 3344 261 42 laying lay VBG 3344 261 43 national national JJ 3344 261 44 laws law NNS 3344 261 45 on on IN 3344 261 46 a a DT 3344 261 47 global global JJ 3344 261 48 digital digital JJ 3344 261 49 medium medium NN 3344 261 50 . . . 3344 262 1 What what WP 3344 262 2 this this DT 3344 262 3 paper paper NN 3344 262 4 has have VBZ 3344 262 5 said say VBN 3344 262 6 is be VBZ 3344 262 7 simply simply RB 3344 262 8 this this DT 3344 262 9 : : : 3344 262 10 three three CD 3344 262 11 issues issue NNS 3344 262 12 — — : 3344 262 13 a a DT 3344 262 14 dramatic dramatic JJ 3344 262 15 expansion expansion NN 3344 262 16 of of IN 3344 262 17 the the DT 3344 262 18 scope scope NN 3344 262 19 , , , 3344 262 20 duration duration NN 3344 262 21 , , , 3344 262 22 and and CC 3344 262 23 punitive punitive JJ 3344 262 24 nature nature NN 3344 262 25 of of IN 3344 262 26 copyright copyright NN 3344 262 27 laws law NNS 3344 262 28 ; ; : 3344 262 29 the the DT 3344 262 30 ability ability NN 3344 262 31 of of IN 3344 262 32 DRM DRM NNP 3344 262 33 to to TO 3344 262 34 lock lock VB 3344 262 35 - - HYPH 3344 262 36 down down RP 3344 262 37 content content NN 3344 262 38 in in IN 3344 262 39 an an DT 3344 262 40 unprecedented unprecedented JJ 3344 262 41 fashion fashion NN 3344 262 42 ; ; : 3344 262 43 and and CC 3344 262 44 the the DT 3344 262 45 erosion erosion NN 3344 262 46 of of IN 3344 262 47 Net net JJ 3344 262 48 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 262 49 — — : 3344 262 50 bear bear VB 3344 262 51 careful careful JJ 3344 262 52 scrutiny scrutiny NN 3344 262 53 by by IN 3344 262 54 those those DT 3344 262 55 who who WP 3344 262 56 believe believe VBP 3344 262 57 that that IN 3344 262 58 the the DT 3344 262 59 Internet internet NN 3344 262 60 has have VBZ 3344 262 61 fostered foster VBN 3344 262 62 ( ( -LRB- 3344 262 63 and and CC 3344 262 64 will will MD 3344 262 65 continue continue VB 3344 262 66 to to TO 3344 262 67 foster foster VB 3344 262 68 ) ) -RRB- 3344 262 69 a a DT 3344 262 70 digital digital JJ 3344 262 71 revolution revolution NN 3344 262 72 that that WDT 3344 262 73 has have VBZ 3344 262 74 resulted result VBN 3344 262 75 in in IN 3344 262 76 an an DT 3344 262 77 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 3344 262 78 explosion explosion NN 3344 262 79 of of IN 3344 262 80 innovation innovation NN 3344 262 81 , , , 3344 262 82 creativity creativity NN 3344 262 83 , , , 3344 262 84 and and CC 3344 262 85 information information NN 3344 262 86 dis- dis- IN 3344 262 87 semination semination NN 3344 262 88 . . . 3344 263 1 These these DT 3344 263 2 issues issue NNS 3344 263 3 may may MD 3344 263 4 well well RB 3344 263 5 determine determine VB 3344 263 6 whether whether IN 3344 263 7 the the DT 3344 263 8 much much RB 3344 263 9 - - HYPH 3344 263 10 touted tout VBN 3344 263 11 information information NN 3344 263 12 superhighway superhighway NN 3344 263 13 lives live VBZ 3344 263 14 up up RP 3344 263 15 to to IN 3344 263 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 3344 263 17 promise promise NN 3344 263 18 or or CC 3344 263 19 simply simply RB 3344 263 20 becomes become VBZ 3344 263 21 the the DT 3344 263 22 “ " `` 3344 263 23 information information NN 3344 263 24 toll toll NN 3344 263 25 road road NN 3344 263 26 ” " '' 3344 263 27 of of IN 3344 263 28 the the DT 3344 263 29 future future NN 3344 263 30 , , , 3344 263 31 ironically ironically RB 3344 263 32 resembling resemble VBG 3344 263 33 the the DT 3344 263 34 pre pre JJ 3344 263 35 - - JJ 3344 263 36 Internet internet JJ 3344 263 37 online online JJ 3344 263 38 services service NNS 3344 263 39 of of IN 3344 263 40 the the DT 3344 263 41 past past NN 3344 263 42 . . . 3344 264 1 References reference NNS 3344 264 2 and and CC 3344 264 3 notes note VBZ 3344 264 4 1 1 CD 3344 264 5 . . . 3344 265 1 Gary Gary NNP 3344 265 2 Flake Flake NNP 3344 265 3 , , , 3344 265 4 “ " `` 3344 265 5 How how WRB 3344 265 6 I -PRON- PRP 3344 265 7 Learned learn VBD 3344 265 8 to to TO 3344 265 9 Stop stop VB 3344 265 10 Worrying Worrying NNP 3344 265 11 and and CC 3344 265 12 Love love VB 3344 265 13 the the DT 3344 265 14 Imminent imminent JJ 3344 265 15 Internet Internet NNP 3344 265 16 Singularity Singularity NNP 3344 265 17 , , , 3344 265 18 ” " '' 3344 265 19 http://castingwords.com/ http://castingwords.com/ NNP 3344 265 20 transcripts transcript NNS 3344 265 21 / / SYM 3344 265 22 O3/5073.html O3/5073.html NNP 3344 265 23 ( ( -LRB- 3344 265 24 accessed access VBN 3344 265 25 May May NNP 3344 265 26 2 2 CD 3344 265 27 , , , 3344 265 28 2006 2006 CD 3344 265 29 ) ) -RRB- 3344 265 30 . . . 3344 266 1 2 2 LS 3344 266 2 . . . 3344 267 1 Lawrence Lawrence NNP 3344 267 2 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 267 3 , , , 3344 267 4 Free Free NNP 3344 267 5 Culture Culture NNP 3344 267 6 : : : 3344 267 7 The the DT 3344 267 8 Nature Nature NNP 3344 267 9 and and CC 3344 267 10 Future future NN 3344 267 11 of of IN 3344 267 12 Creativity Creativity NNP 3344 267 13 ( ( -LRB- 3344 267 14 New New NNP 3344 267 15 York York NNP 3344 267 16 : : : 3344 267 17 Penguin Penguin NNP 3344 267 18 , , , 3344 267 19 2005 2005 CD 3344 267 20 ) ) -RRB- 3344 267 21 , , , 3344 267 22 130 130 CD 3344 267 23 , , , 3344 267 24 www.free-culture.cc/ www.free-culture.cc/ NNP 3344 267 25 ( ( -LRB- 3344 267 26 accessed access VBN 3344 267 27 May May NNP 3344 267 28 2 2 CD 3344 267 29 , , , 3344 267 30 2006 2006 CD 3344 267 31 ) ) -RRB- 3344 267 32 . . . 3344 268 1 3 3 LS 3344 268 2 . . . 3344 269 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 269 2 . . . 3344 269 3 , , , 3344 269 4 131 131 CD 3344 269 5 . . . 3344 270 1 4 4 LS 3344 270 2 . . . 3344 271 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 271 2 . . . 3344 271 3 , , , 3344 271 4 117–18 117–18 CD 3344 271 5 . . . 3344 272 1 5 5 CD 3344 272 2 . . . 3344 273 1 William William NNP 3344 273 2 F. F. NNP 3344 273 3 Patry Patry NNP 3344 273 4 , , , 3344 273 5 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 273 6 Law Law NNP 3344 273 7 and and CC 3344 273 8 Practice Practice NNP 3344 273 9 ( ( -LRB- 3344 273 10 Washing- Washing- NNP 3344 273 11 ton ton NN 3344 273 12 , , , 3344 273 13 D.C. D.C. NNP 3344 273 14 : : : 3344 273 15 Bureau Bureau NNP 3344 273 16 of of IN 3344 273 17 National National NNP 3344 273 18 Affairs Affairs NNPS 3344 273 19 , , , 3344 273 20 2000 2000 CD 3344 273 21 ) ) -RRB- 3344 273 22 , , , 3344 273 23 http://digital http://digital NNP 3344 273 24 - - HYPH 3344 273 25 law law NN 3344 273 26 -online.info -online.info NN 3344 273 27 / / SYM 3344 273 28 patry patry NN 3344 273 29 ( ( -LRB- 3344 273 30 accessed access VBN 3344 273 31 May May NNP 3344 273 32 2 2 CD 3344 273 33 , , , 3344 273 34 2006 2006 CD 3344 273 35 ) ) -RRB- 3344 273 36 . . . 3344 274 1 6 6 CD 3344 274 2 . . . 3344 275 1 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 276 1 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 276 2 Office Office NNP 3344 276 3 , , , 3344 276 4 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 276 5 Basics Basics NNP 3344 276 6 ( ( -LRB- 3344 276 7 Washington Washington NNP 3344 276 8 , , , 3344 276 9 D.C. D.C. NNP 3344 276 10 : : : 3344 276 11 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 277 1 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 277 2 Office Office NNP 3344 277 3 , , , 3344 277 4 2000 2000 CD 3344 277 5 ) ) -RRB- 3344 277 6 , , , 3344 277 7 www.copyright.gov/circs/circl/ www.copyright.gov/circs/circl/ NNP 3344 277 8 html html NN 3344 277 9 ( ( -LRB- 3344 277 10 accessed access VBN 3344 277 11 May May NNP 3344 277 12 2 2 CD 3344 277 13 , , , 3344 277 14 2006 2006 CD 3344 277 15 ) ) -RRB- 3344 277 16 . . . 3344 278 1 7 7 LS 3344 278 2 . . . 3344 279 1 Ibid ibid RB 3344 279 2 . . . 3344 280 1 8 8 LS 3344 280 2 . . . 3344 281 1 Lessig Lessig NNS 3344 281 2 , , , 3344 281 3 Free Free NNP 3344 281 4 Culture Culture NNP 3344 281 5 , , , 3344 281 6 133 133 CD 3344 281 7 . . . 3344 282 1 9 9 CD 3344 282 2 . . . 3344 283 1 Barbara Barbara NNP 3344 283 2 M. M. NNP 3344 283 3 Waxer Waxer NNP 3344 283 4 and and CC 3344 283 5 Marsha Marsha NNP 3344 283 6 Baum Baum NNP 3344 283 7 , , , 3344 283 8 Internet Internet NNP 3344 283 9 Surf Surf NNP 3344 283 10 and and CC 3344 283 11 Turf Turf NNP 3344 283 12 Revealed reveal VBD 3344 283 13 : : : 3344 283 14 The the DT 3344 283 15 Essential Essential NNP 3344 283 16 Guide Guide NNP 3344 283 17 to to IN 3344 283 18 Copyright copyright NN 3344 283 19 , , , 3344 283 20 Fair Fair NNP 3344 283 21 Use Use NNP 3344 283 22 , , , 3344 283 23 and and CC 3344 283 24 Find- Find- NNP 3344 283 25 ing ing NNP 3344 283 26 Media Media NNP 3344 283 27 ( ( -LRB- 3344 283 28 Boston Boston NNP 3344 283 29 : : : 3344 283 30 Thompson Thompson NNP 3344 283 31 Course Course NNP 3344 283 32 Technology Technology NNP 3344 283 33 , , , 3344 283 34 2006 2006 CD 3344 283 35 ) ) -RRB- 3344 283 36 , , , 3344 283 37 17 17 CD 3344 283 38 . . . 3344 284 1 10 10 CD 3344 284 2 . . . 3344 285 1 Patry patry NN 3344 285 2 , , , 3344 285 3 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 285 4 Law Law NNP 3344 285 5 and and CC 3344 285 6 Practice Practice NNP 3344 285 7 ; ; : 3344 285 8 Lessig Lessig NNS 3344 285 9 , , , 3344 285 10 Free Free NNP 3344 285 11 Culture Culture NNP 3344 285 12 , , , 3344 285 13 133 133 CD 3344 285 14 . . . 3344 286 1 11 11 CD 3344 286 2 . . . 3344 287 1 Jessica Jessica NNP 3344 287 2 Litman Litman NNP 3344 287 3 , , , 3344 287 4 Digital Digital NNP 3344 287 5 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 287 6 ( ( -LRB- 3344 287 7 Amherst Amherst NNP 3344 287 8 : : : 3344 287 9 Prometheus Prometheus NNP 3344 287 10 Books Books NNP 3344 287 11 , , , 3344 287 12 2001 2001 CD 3344 287 13 ) ) -RRB- 3344 287 14 , , , 3344 287 15 35–63 35–63 CD 3344 287 16 . . . 3344 288 1 12 12 CD 3344 288 2 . . . 3344 289 1 Lessig Lessig NNS 3344 289 2 , , , 3344 289 3 Free Free NNP 3344 289 4 Culture Culture NNP 3344 289 5 , , , 3344 289 6 134 134 CD 3344 289 7 . . . 3344 290 1 13 13 CD 3344 290 2 . . . 3344 291 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 291 2 . . . 3344 291 3 , , , 3344 291 4 326 326 CD 3344 291 5 . . . 3344 292 1 14 14 CD 3344 292 2 . . . 3344 293 1 Association Association NNP 3344 293 2 of of IN 3344 293 3 American American NNP 3344 293 4 Universities Universities NNPS 3344 293 5 , , , 3344 293 6 the the DT 3344 293 7 Association Association NNP 3344 293 8 of of IN 3344 293 9 Research Research NNP 3344 293 10 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3344 293 11 , , , 3344 293 12 the the DT 3344 293 13 Association Association NNP 3344 293 14 of of IN 3344 293 15 American American NNP 3344 293 16 University University NNP 3344 293 17 Presses Presses NNPS 3344 293 18 , , , 3344 293 19 and and CC 3344 293 20 the the DT 3344 293 21 Association Association NNP 3344 293 22 of of IN 3344 293 23 American American NNP 3344 293 24 Publishers Publishers NNPS 3344 293 25 , , , 3344 293 26 Campus Campus NNP 3344 293 27 Copy- copy- RB 3344 293 28 right right JJ 3344 293 29 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 293 30 & & CC 3344 293 31 Responsibilities Responsibilities NNPS 3344 293 32 : : : 3344 293 33 A a DT 3344 293 34 Basic Basic NNP 3344 293 35 Guide Guide NNP 3344 293 36 to to IN 3344 293 37 Policy Policy NNP 3344 293 38 Considerations Considerations NNP 3344 293 39 ( ( -LRB- 3344 293 40 Association Association NNP 3344 293 41 of of IN 3344 293 42 American American NNP 3344 293 43 Universities Universities NNPS 3344 293 44 , , , 3344 293 45 the the DT 3344 293 46 Association Association NNP 3344 293 47 of of IN 3344 293 48 Research Research NNP 3344 293 49 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3344 293 50 , , , 3344 293 51 the the DT 3344 293 52 Association Association NNP 3344 293 53 of of IN 3344 293 54 American American NNP 3344 293 55 University University NNP 3344 293 56 Presses Presses NNPS 3344 293 57 , , , 3344 293 58 and and CC 3344 293 59 the the DT 3344 293 60 Association Association NNP 3344 293 61 of of IN 3344 293 62 American American NNP 3344 293 63 Publishers Publishers NNPS 3344 293 64 , , , 3344 293 65 2006 2006 CD 3344 293 66 ) ) -RRB- 3344 293 67 , , , 3344 293 68 8 8 CD 3344 293 69 , , , 3344 293 70 www.arl.org/info/ www.arl.org/info/ NNP 3344 293 71 frn frn NNP 3344 293 72 / / SYM 3344 293 73 copy copy NNP 3344 293 74 / / SYM 3344 293 75 CampusCopyright05.pdf CampusCopyright05.pdf NFP 3344 293 76 ( ( -LRB- 3344 293 77 accessed access VBN 3344 293 78 May May NNP 3344 293 79 2 2 CD 3344 293 80 , , , 3344 293 81 2006 2006 CD 3344 293 82 ) ) -RRB- 3344 293 83 . . . 3344 294 1 15 15 CD 3344 294 2 . . . 3344 295 1 George George NNP 3344 295 2 H. H. NNP 3344 295 3 Pike Pike NNP 3344 295 4 , , , 3344 295 5 “ " `` 3344 295 6 The the DT 3344 295 7 Delicate delicate JJ 3344 295 8 Dance Dance NNP 3344 295 9 of of IN 3344 295 10 Database Database NNP 3344 295 11 Li- Li- NNP 3344 295 12 censes cense NNS 3344 295 13 , , , 3344 295 14 Copyright copyright NN 3344 295 15 , , , 3344 295 16 and and CC 3344 295 17 Fair Fair NNP 3344 295 18 Use Use NNP 3344 295 19 , , , 3344 295 20 ” " '' 3344 295 21 Computers computer NNS 3344 295 22 in in IN 3344 295 23 Libraries Libraries NNP 3344 295 24 22 22 CD 3344 295 25 , , , 3344 295 26 no no UH 3344 295 27 . . . 3344 296 1 5 5 CD 3344 296 2 ( ( -LRB- 3344 296 3 2002 2002 CD 3344 296 4 ) ) -RRB- 3344 296 5 : : : 3344 296 6 14 14 CD 3344 296 7 , , , 3344 296 8 http://infotoday.com/cilmag/may02/pike http://infotoday.com/cilmag/may02/pike ADD 3344 296 9 .htm .htm . 3344 296 10 ( ( -LRB- 3344 296 11 accessed access VBN 3344 296 12 May May NNP 3344 296 13 2 2 CD 3344 296 14 , , , 3344 296 15 2006 2006 CD 3344 296 16 ) ) -RRB- 3344 296 17 . . . 3344 297 1 16 16 CD 3344 297 2 . . . 3344 298 1 Patry patry NN 3344 298 2 , , , 3344 298 3 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 298 4 Law Law NNP 3344 298 5 and and CC 3344 298 6 Practice Practice NNP 3344 298 7 . . . 3344 299 1 17 17 CD 3344 299 2 . . . 3344 300 1 Computer Computer NNP 3344 300 2 Crime Crime NNP 3344 300 3 and and CC 3344 300 4 Intellectual Intellectual NNP 3344 300 5 Property Property NNP 3344 300 6 Section Section NNP 3344 300 7 Crimi- Crimi- NNP 3344 300 8 nal nal NNP 3344 300 9 Division Division NNP 3344 300 10 , , , 3344 300 11 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 300 12 Department Department NNP 3344 300 13 of of IN 3344 300 14 Justice Justice NNP 3344 300 15 , , , 3344 300 16 “ " `` 3344 300 17 Prosecuting prosecute VBG 3344 300 18 Intellec- Intellec- NNP 3344 300 19 tual tual JJ 3344 300 20 Property Property NNP 3344 300 21 Crimes Crimes NNPS 3344 300 22 Manual Manual NNP 3344 300 23 , , , 3344 300 24 ” " '' 3344 300 25 www.cybercrime.gov/ipmanual www.cybercrime.gov/ipmanual JJ 3344 300 26 .htm .htm NFP 3344 300 27 ( ( -LRB- 3344 300 28 accessed access VBN 3344 300 29 May May NNP 3344 300 30 2 2 CD 3344 300 31 , , , 3344 300 32 2006 2006 CD 3344 300 33 ) ) -RRB- 3344 300 34 ; ; : 3344 300 35 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 301 1 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 301 2 Office Office NNP 3344 301 3 , , , 3344 301 4 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 301 5 Law Law NNP 3344 301 6 of of IN 3344 301 7 the the DT 3344 301 8 United United NNP 3344 301 9 States States NNP 3344 301 10 of of IN 3344 301 11 America America NNP 3344 301 12 and and CC 3344 301 13 Related Related NNP 3344 301 14 Laws Laws NNPS 3344 301 15 Contained contain VBN 3344 301 16 in in IN 3344 301 17 Title Title NNP 3344 301 18 17 17 CD 3344 301 19 of of IN 3344 301 20 the the DT 3344 301 21 United United NNP 3344 301 22 States States NNP 3344 301 23 Code Code NNP 3344 301 24 ( ( -LRB- 3344 301 25 Washington Washington NNP 3344 301 26 , , , 3344 301 27 D.C. D.C. NNP 3344 301 28 : : : 3344 301 29 U.S. U.S. NNP 3344 302 1 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 302 2 Office Office NNP 3344 302 3 , , , 3344 302 4 2003 2003 CD 3344 302 5 ) ) -RRB- 3344 302 6 , , , 3344 302 7 www.copyright.gov/title17/circ92.pdf www.copyright.gov/title17/circ92.pdf NNP 3344 302 8 ( ( -LRB- 3344 302 9 accessed access VBN 3344 302 10 May May NNP 3344 302 11 2 2 CD 3344 302 12 , , , 3344 302 13 2006 2006 CD 3344 302 14 ) ) -RRB- 3344 302 15 . . . 3344 303 1 18 18 CD 3344 303 2 . . . 3344 304 1 Recording record VBG 3344 304 2 Industry Industry NNP 3344 304 3 Association Association NNP 3344 304 4 of of IN 3344 304 5 America America NNP 3344 304 6 , , , 3344 304 7 “ " `` 3344 304 8 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 304 9 Laws Laws NNPS 3344 304 10 , , , 3344 304 11 ” " '' 3344 304 12 www.riaa.com/issues/copyright/laws.asp www.riaa.com/issues/copyright/laws.asp NNP 3344 304 13 ( ( -LRB- 3344 304 14 accessed access VBN 3344 304 15 May May NNP 3344 304 16 2 2 CD 3344 304 17 , , , 3344 304 18 2006 2006 CD 3344 304 19 ) ) -RRB- 3344 304 20 . . . 3344 305 1 19 19 CD 3344 305 2 . . . 3344 306 1 Kenneth Kenneth NNP 3344 306 2 D. D. NNP 3344 306 3 Crews Crews NNP 3344 306 4 , , , 3344 306 5 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 306 6 Law Law NNP 3344 306 7 for for IN 3344 306 8 Librarians Librarians NNPS 3344 306 9 and and CC 3344 306 10 Educa- Educa- NNP 3344 306 11 tors tor NNS 3344 306 12 : : : 3344 306 13 Creative creative JJ 3344 306 14 Strategies Strategies NNPS 3344 306 15 and and CC 3344 306 16 Practical Practical NNP 3344 306 17 Solutions Solutions NNPS 3344 306 18 , , , 3344 306 19 2nd 2nd JJ 3344 306 20 ed ed NN 3344 306 21 . . . 3344 307 1 ( ( -LRB- 3344 307 2 Chicago Chicago NNP 3344 307 3 : : : 3344 307 4 ALA ALA NNP 3344 307 5 , , , 3344 307 6 2006 2006 CD 3344 307 7 ) ) -RRB- 3344 307 8 , , , 3344 307 9 94 94 CD 3344 307 10 . . . 3344 308 1 20 20 CD 3344 308 2 . . . 3344 309 1 Lessig Lessig NNS 3344 309 2 , , , 3344 309 3 Free Free NNP 3344 309 4 Culture Culture NNP 3344 309 5 , , , 3344 309 6 8 8 CD 3344 309 7 . . . 3344 310 1 21 21 CD 3344 310 2 . . . 3344 311 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 311 2 . . . 3344 311 3 , , , 3344 311 4 51 51 CD 3344 311 5 . . . 3344 312 1 22 22 CD 3344 312 2 . . . 3344 313 1 Lawrence Lawrence NNP 3344 313 2 Lessig Lessig NNP 3344 313 3 , , , 3344 313 4 The the DT 3344 313 5 Future future NN 3344 313 6 of of IN 3344 313 7 Ideas idea NNS 3344 313 8 : : : 3344 313 9 The the DT 3344 313 10 Fate Fate NNP 3344 313 11 of of IN 3344 313 12 the the DT 3344 313 13 Com- Com- NNP 3344 313 14 mons mon NNS 3344 313 15 in in IN 3344 313 16 a a DT 3344 313 17 Connected Connected NNP 3344 313 18 World World NNP 3344 313 19 ( ( -LRB- 3344 313 20 New New NNP 3344 313 21 York York NNP 3344 313 22 : : : 3344 313 23 Vintage Vintage NNP 3344 313 24 Bks Bks NNP 3344 313 25 . . NNP 3344 313 26 , , , 3344 313 27 2002 2002 CD 3344 313 28 ) ) -RRB- 3344 313 29 , , , 3344 313 30 165–66 165–66 CD 3344 313 31 , , , 3344 313 32 176 176 CD 3344 313 33 . . . 3344 314 1 23 23 CD 3344 314 2 . . . 3344 315 1 Lessig Lessig NNS 3344 315 2 , , , 3344 315 3 Free Free NNP 3344 315 4 Culture Culture NNP 3344 315 5 , , , 3344 315 6 53–61 53–61 CD 3344 315 7 . . . 3344 316 1 24 24 CD 3344 316 2 . . . 3344 317 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 317 2 . . . 3344 317 3 , , , 3344 317 4 53 53 CD 3344 317 5 . . . 3344 318 1 25 25 CD 3344 318 2 . . . 3344 319 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 319 2 . . . 3344 319 3 , , , 3344 319 4 59–61 59–61 CD 3344 319 5 . . . 3344 320 1 26 26 CD 3344 320 2 . . . 3344 321 1 James James NNP 3344 321 2 Boyle Boyle NNP 3344 321 3 , , , 3344 321 4 Shamans Shamans NNPS 3344 321 5 , , , 3344 321 6 Software Software NNP 3344 321 7 , , , 3344 321 8 and and CC 3344 321 9 Spleens Spleens NNPS 3344 321 10 : : : 3344 321 11 Law Law NNP 3344 321 12 and and CC 3344 321 13 the the DT 3344 321 14 Construction construction NN 3344 321 15 of of IN 3344 321 16 the the DT 3344 321 17 Information Information NNP 3344 321 18 Society Society NNP 3344 321 19 ( ( -LRB- 3344 321 20 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3344 321 21 : : : 3344 321 22 Harvard Harvard NNP 3344 321 23 Univ Univ NNP 3344 321 24 . . . 3344 322 1 Pr pr NN 3344 322 2 . . NNP 3344 322 3 , , , 3344 322 4 1996 1996 CD 3344 322 5 ) ) -RRB- 3344 322 6 , , , 3344 322 7 172 172 CD 3344 322 8 . . . 3344 323 1 27 27 CD 3344 323 2 . . . 3344 324 1 William William NNP 3344 324 2 W. W. NNP 3344 324 3 Fisher Fisher NNP 3344 324 4 III III NNP 3344 324 5 , , , 3344 324 6 Promises promise VBZ 3344 324 7 to to TO 3344 324 8 Keep keep VB 3344 324 9 : : : 3344 324 10 Technology technology NN 3344 324 11 , , , 3344 324 12 Law Law NNP 3344 324 13 , , , 3344 324 14 and and CC 3344 324 15 the the DT 3344 324 16 Future Future NNP 3344 324 17 of of IN 3344 324 18 Entertainment Entertainment NNP 3344 324 19 ( ( -LRB- 3344 324 20 Stanford Stanford NNP 3344 324 21 , , , 3344 324 22 Calif. California NNP 3344 324 23 : : : 3344 324 24 Stanford Stanford NNP 3344 324 25 Univ Univ NNP 3344 324 26 . . . 3344 325 1 Pr Pr NNP 3344 325 2 . . NNP 3344 325 3 , , , 3344 325 4 2004 2004 CD 3344 325 5 ) ) -RRB- 3344 325 6 , , , 3344 325 7 202 202 CD 3344 325 8 . . . 3344 326 1 28 28 CD 3344 326 2 . . . 3344 327 1 Lessig Lessig NNS 3344 327 2 , , , 3344 327 3 Free Free NNP 3344 327 4 Culture Culture NNP 3344 327 5 , , , 3344 327 6 289–93 289–93 CD 3344 327 7 . . . 3344 328 1 29 29 CD 3344 328 2 . . . 3344 329 1 Litman Litman NNP 3344 329 2 , , , 3344 329 3 Digital Digital NNP 3344 329 4 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 329 5 , , , 3344 329 6 179–80 179–80 CD 3344 329 7 . . . 3344 330 1 30 30 CD 3344 330 2 . . . 3344 331 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 331 2 . . . 3344 331 3 , , , 3344 331 4 181–84 181–84 CD 3344 331 5 . . . 3344 332 1 31 31 CD 3344 332 2 . . . 3344 333 1 Michael Michael NNP 3344 333 2 Godwin Godwin NNP 3344 333 3 , , , 3344 333 4 Digital Digital NNP 3344 333 5 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 333 6 Management Management NNP 3344 333 7 : : : 3344 333 8 A a DT 3344 333 9 Guide Guide NNP 3344 333 10 for for IN 3344 333 11 Librarians Librarians NNPS 3344 333 12 ( ( -LRB- 3344 333 13 Washington Washington NNP 3344 333 14 , , , 3344 333 15 D.C. D.C. NNP 3344 333 16 : : : 3344 333 17 Office office NN 3344 333 18 for for IN 3344 333 19 Information Information NNP 3344 333 20 Technology Technology NNP 3344 333 21 Policy Policy NNP 3344 333 22 , , , 3344 333 23 ALA ALA NNP 3344 333 24 , , , 3344 333 25 2006 2006 CD 3344 333 26 ) ) -RRB- 3344 333 27 , , , 3344 333 28 1 1 CD 3344 333 29 , , , 3344 333 30 www.ala.org/ala/washoff/WOissues/ www.ala.org/ala/washoff/WOissues/ NNP 3344 333 31 copyrightb copyrightb NN 3344 333 32 / / SYM 3344 333 33 digitalrights digitalright NNS 3344 333 34 / / SYM 3344 333 35 DRMfinal.pdf DRMfinal.pdf NNP 3344 333 36 ( ( -LRB- 3344 333 37 accessed access VBN 3344 333 38 May May NNP 3344 333 39 2 2 CD 3344 333 40 , , , 3344 333 41 2006 2006 CD 3344 333 42 ) ) -RRB- 3344 333 43 . . . 3344 334 1 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 3344 334 2 DYSTOPIA DYSTOPIA NNP 3344 334 3 | | NNP 3344 334 4 BAILEY BAILEY NNP 3344 334 5 127 127 CD 3344 334 6 32 32 CD 3344 334 7 . . . 3344 335 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 335 2 . . . 3344 335 3 , , , 3344 335 4 10–18 10–18 CD 3344 335 5 . . . 3344 336 1 33 33 CD 3344 336 2 . . . 3344 337 1 Bill Bill NNP 3344 337 2 Rosenblatt Rosenblatt NNP 3344 337 3 , , , 3344 337 4 Bill Bill NNP 3344 337 5 Trippe Trippe NNP 3344 337 6 , , , 3344 337 7 and and CC 3344 337 8 Stephen Stephen NNP 3344 337 9 Mooney Mooney NNP 3344 337 10 , , , 3344 337 11 Digital Digital NNP 3344 337 12 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 337 13 Management Management NNP 3344 337 14 : : : 3344 337 15 Business Business NNP 3344 337 16 and and CC 3344 337 17 Technology Technology NNP 3344 337 18 ( ( -LRB- 3344 337 19 New New NNP 3344 337 20 York York NNP 3344 337 21 : : : 3344 337 22 M&T M&T NNP 3344 337 23 Bks Bks NNP 3344 337 24 . . NNP 3344 337 25 , , , 3344 337 26 2002 2002 CD 3344 337 27 ) ) -RRB- 3344 337 28 , , , 3344 337 29 61–64 61–64 CD 3344 337 30 . . . 3344 338 1 34 34 CD 3344 338 2 . . . 3344 339 1 Godwin Godwin NNP 3344 339 2 , , , 3344 339 3 Digital Digital NNP 3344 339 4 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 339 5 Management Management NNP 3344 339 6 : : : 3344 339 7 A a DT 3344 339 8 Guide Guide NNP 3344 339 9 for for IN 3344 339 10 Librar- Librar- NNP 3344 339 11 ians ians NNPS 3344 339 12 , , , 3344 339 13 2 2 CD 3344 339 14 . . . 3344 340 1 35 35 CD 3344 340 2 . . . 3344 341 1 David David NNP 3344 341 2 Mann Mann NNP 3344 341 3 , , , 3344 341 4 “ " `` 3344 341 5 Digital Digital NNP 3344 341 6 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 341 7 Management Management NNP 3344 341 8 and and CC 3344 341 9 People People NNPS 3344 341 10 with with IN 3344 341 11 Sight Sight NNP 3344 341 12 Loss Loss NNP 3344 341 13 , , , 3344 341 14 ” " '' 3344 341 15 INDICARE INDICARE NNP 3344 341 16 Monitor Monitor NNP 3344 341 17 2 2 CD 3344 341 18 , , , 3344 341 19 no no UH 3344 341 20 . . . 3344 342 1 11 11 CD 3344 342 2 ( ( -LRB- 3344 342 3 2006 2006 CD 3344 342 4 ) ) -RRB- 3344 342 5 , , , 3344 342 6 www www NNP 3344 342 7 .indicare.org .indicare.org NN 3344 342 8 / / SYM 3344 342 9 tiki tiki NNP 3344 342 10 - - HYPH 3344 342 11 print_article.php?articleId=170 print_article.php?articleId=170 NNP 3344 342 12 ( ( -LRB- 3344 342 13 accessed access VBN 3344 342 14 May May NNP 3344 342 15 2 2 CD 3344 342 16 , , , 3344 342 17 2006 2006 CD 3344 342 18 ) ) -RRB- 3344 342 19 . . . 3344 343 1 36 36 CD 3344 343 2 . . . 3344 344 1 Julie Julie NNP 3344 344 2 E. E. NNP 3344 344 3 Cohen Cohen NNP 3344 344 4 , , , 3344 344 5 “ " `` 3344 344 6 DRM DRM NNP 3344 344 7 and and CC 3344 344 8 Privacy Privacy NNP 3344 344 9 , , , 3344 344 10 ” " '' 3344 344 11 Communications communication NNS 3344 344 12 of of IN 3344 344 13 the the DT 3344 344 14 ACM ACM NNP 3344 344 15 46 46 CD 3344 344 16 , , , 3344 344 17 no no UH 3344 344 18 . . . 3344 345 1 4 4 CD 3344 345 2 ( ( -LRB- 3344 345 3 2003 2003 CD 3344 345 4 ) ) -RRB- 3344 345 5 : : : 3344 345 6 46–49 46–49 CD 3344 345 7 . . . 3344 346 1 37 37 CD 3344 346 2 . . . 3344 347 1 Rosenblatt rosenblatt VB 3344 347 2 , , , 3344 347 3 Trippe Trippe NNP 3344 347 4 , , , 3344 347 5 and and CC 3344 347 6 Mooney Mooney NNP 3344 347 7 , , , 3344 347 8 Digital Digital NNP 3344 347 9 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 347 10 Manage- Manage- NNP 3344 347 11 ment ment JJ 3344 347 12 : : : 3344 347 13 Business business NN 3344 347 14 and and CC 3344 347 15 Technology Technology NNP 3344 347 16 , , , 3344 347 17 45 45 CD 3344 347 18 . . . 3344 348 1 38 38 CD 3344 348 2 . . . 3344 349 1 J. J. NNP 3344 349 2 Alex Alex NNP 3344 349 3 Halderman Halderman NNP 3344 349 4 and and CC 3344 349 5 Edward Edward NNP 3344 349 6 W. W. NNP 3344 349 7 Felten Felten NNP 3344 349 8 , , , 3344 349 9 “ " `` 3344 349 10 Lessons lesson NNS 3344 349 11 from from IN 3344 349 12 the the DT 3344 349 13 Sony Sony NNP 3344 349 14 CD CD NNP 3344 349 15 DRM DRM NNP 3344 349 16 Episode Episode NNP 3344 349 17 , , , 3344 349 18 ” " '' 3344 349 19 Feb. February NNP 3344 349 20 14 14 CD 3344 349 21 , , , 3344 349 22 2006 2006 CD 3344 349 23 , , , 3344 349 24 http://itpolicy.princeton http://itpolicy.princeton NNP 3344 349 25 .edu .edu . 3344 349 26 / / SYM 3344 349 27 pub pub NNP 3344 349 28 / / SYM 3344 349 29 sonydrm sonydrm NNP 3344 349 30 - - HYPH 3344 349 31 ext.pdf ext.pdf NNP 3344 349 32 ( ( -LRB- 3344 349 33 accessed access VBN 3344 349 34 May May NNP 3344 349 35 2 2 CD 3344 349 36 , , , 3344 349 37 2006 2006 CD 3344 349 38 ) ) -RRB- 3344 349 39 . . . 3344 350 1 39 39 CD 3344 350 2 . . . 3344 351 1 Godwin Godwin NNP 3344 351 2 , , , 3344 351 3 Digital Digital NNP 3344 351 4 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 351 5 Management Management NNP 3344 351 6 : : : 3344 351 7 A a DT 3344 351 8 Guide Guide NNP 3344 351 9 for for IN 3344 351 10 Librarians Librarians NNPS 3344 351 11 , , , 3344 351 12 18–36 18–36 CD 3344 351 13 . . . 3344 352 1 40 40 CD 3344 352 2 . . . 3344 353 1 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP 3344 353 2 , , , 3344 353 3 “ " `` 3344 353 4 Analog Analog NNP 3344 353 5 Hole Hole NNP 3344 353 6 , , , 3344 353 7 ” " '' 3344 353 8 http://en.wikipedia.org/ http://en.wikipedia.org/ NNP 3344 353 9 wiki wiki NNP 3344 353 10 / / SYM 3344 353 11 Analog_hole Analog_hole NNP 3344 353 12 ( ( -LRB- 3344 353 13 accessed access VBN 3344 353 14 May May NNP 3344 353 15 2 2 CD 3344 353 16 , , , 3344 353 17 2006 2006 CD 3344 353 18 ) ) -RRB- 3344 353 19 . . . 3344 354 1 41 41 CD 3344 354 2 . . . 3344 355 1 Godwin Godwin NNP 3344 355 2 , , , 3344 355 3 Digital Digital NNP 3344 355 4 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 355 5 Management Management NNP 3344 355 6 : : : 3344 355 7 A a DT 3344 355 8 Guide Guide NNP 3344 355 9 for for IN 3344 355 10 Librarians Librarians NNPS 3344 355 11 , , , 3344 355 12 18–20 18–20 CD 3344 355 13 . . . 3344 356 1 42 42 CD 3344 356 2 . . . 3344 357 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3344 357 2 . . . 3344 357 3 , , , 3344 357 4 36 36 CD 3344 357 5 . . . 3344 358 1 43 43 CD 3344 358 2 . . . 3344 359 1 Robert Robert NNP 3344 359 2 A. A. NNP 3344 359 3 Gehring Gehring NNP 3344 359 4 , , , 3344 359 5 “ " `` 3344 359 6 Trusted trust VBD 3344 359 7 Computing Computing NNP 3344 359 8 for for IN 3344 359 9 Digital Digital NNP 3344 359 10 Rights Rights NNPS 3344 359 11 Management Management NNP 3344 359 12 , , , 3344 359 13 ” " '' 3344 359 14 INDICARE INDICARE NNP 3344 359 15 Monitor Monitor NNP 3344 359 16 2 2 CD 3344 359 17 , , , 3344 359 18 no no UH 3344 359 19 . . . 3344 360 1 12 12 CD 3344 360 2 ( ( -LRB- 3344 360 3 2006 2006 CD 3344 360 4 ) ) -RRB- 3344 360 5 , , , 3344 360 6 www.indicare www.indicare NNP 3344 360 7 .org .org . 3344 360 8 / / SYM 3344 360 9 tiki tiki FW 3344 360 10 - - HYPH 3344 360 11 read_article.php?articleId=179 read_article.php?articleId=179 NNS 3344 360 12 ( ( -LRB- 3344 360 13 accessed access VBN 3344 360 14 May May NNP 3344 360 15 2 2 CD 3344 360 16 , , , 3344 360 17 2006 2006 CD 3344 360 18 ) ) -RRB- 3344 360 19 . . . 3344 361 1 44 44 CD 3344 361 2 . . . 3344 362 1 Seth Seth NNP 3344 362 2 Schoen Schoen NNP 3344 362 3 , , , 3344 362 4 “ " `` 3344 362 5 Trusted Trusted NNP 3344 362 6 Computing Computing NNP 3344 362 7 : : : 3344 362 8 Promise Promise NNP 3344 362 9 and and CC 3344 362 10 Risk Risk NNP 3344 362 11 , , , 3344 362 12 ” " '' 3344 362 13 www.eff.org/Infrastructure/trusted_computing/20031001 www.eff.org/Infrastructure/trusted_computing/20031001 : 3344 362 14 _ _ NNP 3344 362 15 tc.php tc.php '' 3344 362 16 ( ( -LRB- 3344 362 17 accessed access VBN 3344 362 18 May May NNP 3344 362 19 2 2 CD 3344 362 20 , , , 3344 362 21 2006 2006 CD 3344 362 22 ) ) -RRB- 3344 362 23 . . . 3344 363 1 45 45 CD 3344 363 2 . . . 3344 364 1 Pamela Pamela NNP 3344 364 2 Samuelson Samuelson NNP 3344 364 3 , , , 3344 364 4 “ " `` 3344 364 5 DRM DRM NNP 3344 364 6 { { -LRB- 3344 364 7 and and CC 3344 364 8 , , , 3344 364 9 or or CC 3344 364 10 , , , 3344 364 11 vs. vs. IN 3344 364 12 } } -RRB- 3344 364 13 the the DT 3344 364 14 Law Law NNP 3344 364 15 , , , 3344 364 16 ” " '' 3344 364 17 Com- com- CD 3344 364 18 munications munication NNS 3344 364 19 of of IN 3344 364 20 the the DT 3344 364 21 ACM ACM NNP 3344 364 22 46 46 CD 3344 364 23 , , , 3344 364 24 no no UH 3344 364 25 . . . 3344 365 1 4 4 CD 3344 365 2 ( ( -LRB- 3344 365 3 2003 2003 CD 3344 365 4 ) ) -RRB- 3344 365 5 : : : 3344 365 6 43–44 43–44 CD 3344 365 7 . . . 3344 366 1 46 46 CD 3344 366 2 . . . 3344 367 1 Declan Declan NNP 3344 367 2 McCullagh McCullagh NNP 3344 367 3 , , , 3344 367 4 “ " `` 3344 367 5 Congress Congress NNP 3344 367 6 Raises raise VBZ 3344 367 7 Broadcast Broadcast NNP 3344 367 8 Flag Flag NNP 3344 367 9 for for IN 3344 367 10 Audio Audio NNP 3344 367 11 , , , 3344 367 12 ” " '' 3344 367 13 CNET cnet NN 3344 367 14 News.com News.com NNS 3344 367 15 , , , 3344 367 16 Mar. March NNP 3344 368 1 2 2 CD 3344 368 2 , , , 3344 368 3 2006 2006 CD 3344 368 4 , , , 3344 368 5 http://news.com http://news.com ADD 3344 368 6 .com .com . 3344 368 7 / / SYM 3344 368 8 Congress+raises+broadcast+flag+for+audio/2100 Congress+raises+broadcast+flag+for+audio/2100 NNP 3344 368 9 - - HYPH 3344 368 10 1028 1028 CD 3344 368 11 _ _ NNP 3344 368 12 3-6045225.html 3-6045225.html CD 3344 368 13 ( ( -LRB- 3344 368 14 accessed access VBN 3344 368 15 May May NNP 3344 368 16 2 2 CD 3344 368 17 , , , 3344 368 18 2006 2006 CD 3344 368 19 ) ) -RRB- 3344 368 20 . . . 3344 369 1 47 47 CD 3344 369 2 . . . 3344 370 1 Ibid ibid RB 3344 370 2 . . . 3344 371 1 48 48 CD 3344 371 2 . . . 3344 372 1 Danny Danny NNP 3344 372 2 O’Brien O’Brien NNP 3344 372 3 , , , 3344 372 4 “ " `` 3344 372 5 A a DT 3344 372 6 Lump lump NN 3344 372 7 of of IN 3344 372 8 Coal Coal NNP 3344 372 9 for for IN 3344 372 10 Consumers consumer NNS 3344 372 11 : : : 3344 372 12 Analog Analog NNP 3344 372 13 Hole Hole NNP 3344 372 14 Bill Bill NNP 3344 372 15 Introduced Introduced NNP 3344 372 16 , , , 3344 372 17 ” " '' 3344 372 18 EFF EFF NNP 3344 372 19 DeepLinks DeepLinks NNP 3344 372 20 , , , 3344 372 21 Dec. December NNP 3344 372 22 16 16 CD 3344 372 23 , , , 3344 372 24 2005 2005 CD 3344 372 25 , , , 3344 372 26 www.eff www.eff NNP 3344 372 27 .org .org . 3344 372 28 / / SYM 3344 372 29 deeplinks deeplink NNS 3344 372 30 / / SYM 3344 372 31 archives/004261.php archives/004261.php IN 3344 372 32 ( ( -LRB- 3344 372 33 accessed access VBN 3344 372 34 May May NNP 3344 372 35 2 2 CD 3344 372 36 , , , 3344 372 37 2006 2006 CD 3344 372 38 ) ) -RRB- 3344 372 39 . . . 3344 373 1 49 49 CD 3344 373 2 . . . 3344 374 1 Siva Siva NNP 3344 374 2 Vaidhyanathan Vaidhyanathan NNP 3344 374 3 , , , 3344 374 4 Copyrights Copyrights NNPS 3344 374 5 and and CC 3344 374 6 Copywrongs Copywrongs NNPS 3344 374 7 : : : 3344 374 8 The the DT 3344 374 9 Rise rise NN 3344 374 10 of of IN 3344 374 11 Intellectual intellectual JJ 3344 374 12 Property Property NNP 3344 374 13 and and CC 3344 374 14 How how WRB 3344 374 15 it -PRON- PRP 3344 374 16 Threatens threaten VBZ 3344 374 17 Creativity creativity NN 3344 374 18 ( ( -LRB- 3344 374 19 New New NNP 3344 374 20 York York NNP 3344 374 21 : : : 3344 374 22 New New NNP 3344 374 23 York York NNP 3344 374 24 Univ Univ NNP 3344 374 25 . . . 3344 375 1 Pr Pr NNP 3344 375 2 . . NNP 3344 375 3 , , , 3344 375 4 2001 2001 CD 3344 375 5 ) ) -RRB- 3344 375 6 , , , 3344 375 7 174–75 174–75 CD 3344 375 8 . . . 3344 376 1 50 50 CD 3344 376 2 . . . 3344 377 1 Lessig Lessig NNS 3344 377 2 , , , 3344 377 3 The the DT 3344 377 4 Future Future NNP 3344 377 5 of of IN 3344 377 6 Ideas Ideas NNP 3344 377 7 , , , 3344 377 8 36–37 36–37 CD 3344 377 9 . . . 3344 378 1 51 51 CD 3344 378 2 . . . 3344 379 1 EDUCAUSE EDUCAUSE NNP 3344 379 2 , , , 3344 379 3 “ " `` 3344 379 4 Net net JJ 3344 379 5 Neutrality Neutrality NNP 3344 379 6 , , , 3344 379 7 ” " '' 3344 379 8 www.educause.edu/ www.educause.edu/ VBN 3344 379 9 c c NNP 3344 379 10 o o NN 3344 379 11 n n NN 3344 379 12 t t NNP 3344 379 13 e e NN 3344 379 14 n n NNP 3344 379 15 t t NN 3344 379 16 . . . 3344 380 1 a a DT 3344 380 2 s s NNP 3344 380 3 p p NN 3344 380 4 ? ? . 3344 381 1 PA pa NN 3344 381 2 G g NN 3344 381 3 E e NN 3344 381 4 _ _ NN 3344 381 5 I i NN 3344 381 6 D d NN 3344 381 7 = = SYM 3344 381 8 6 6 CD 3344 381 9 4 4 CD 3344 381 10 5 5 CD 3344 381 11 & & CC 3344 381 12 PA PA NNP 3344 381 13 R r NN 3344 381 14 E e NN 3344 381 15 N n NN 3344 381 16 T t NN 3344 381 17 _ _ NN 3344 381 18 I i NN 3344 381 19 D d NN 3344 381 20 = = SYM 3344 381 21 8 8 CD 3344 381 22 0 0 CD 3344 381 23 7 7 CD 3344 381 24 & & CC 3344 381 25 b b NNP 3344 381 26 h h NNP 3344 381 27 c c NNP 3344 381 28 p p NN 3344 381 29 = = SYM 3344 381 30 1 1 CD 3344 381 31 ( ( -LRB- 3344 381 32 accessed access VBN 3344 381 33 May May NNP 3344 381 34 2 2 CD 3344 381 35 , , , 3344 381 36 2006 2006 CD 3344 381 37 ) ) -RRB- 3344 381 38 . . . 3344 382 1 52 52 CD 3344 382 2 . . . 3344 383 1 Electronic Electronic NNP 3344 383 2 Frontier Frontier NNP 3344 383 3 Foundation Foundation NNP 3344 383 4 , , , 3344 383 5 “ " `` 3344 383 6 DearAOL.com DearAOL.com NNP 3344 383 7 Coalition Coalition NNP 3344 383 8 Grows grow VBZ 3344 383 9 from from IN 3344 383 10 50 50 CD 3344 383 11 Organizations organization NNS 3344 383 12 to to IN 3344 383 13 500 500 CD 3344 383 14 In in IN 3344 383 15 One one CD 3344 383 16 Week Week NNP 3344 383 17 , , , 3344 383 18 ” " '' 3344 383 19 Mar. March NNP 3344 384 1 7 7 CD 3344 384 2 , , , 3344 384 3 2006 2006 CD 3344 384 4 , , , 3344 384 5 www.eff.org/news/archives/2006_03.php#004461 www.eff.org/news/archives/2006_03.php#004461 NNP 3344 384 6 ( ( -LRB- 3344 384 7 accessed access VBN 3344 384 8 May May NNP 3344 384 9 2 2 CD 3344 384 10 , , , 3344 384 11 2006 2006 CD 3344 384 12 ) ) -RRB- 3344 384 13 . . . 3344 385 1 53 53 CD 3344 385 2 . . . 3344 386 1 Catherine Catherine NNP 3344 386 2 Yang Yang NNP 3344 386 3 , , , 3344 386 4 “ " `` 3344 386 5 Is be VBZ 3344 386 6 Verizon Verizon NNP 3344 386 7 a a DT 3344 386 8 Network Network NNP 3344 386 9 Hog Hog NNP 3344 386 10 ? ? . 3344 386 11 ” " '' 3344 386 12 Business- Business- NNP 3344 386 13 Week Week NNP 3344 386 14 , , , 3344 386 15 Feb. February NNP 3344 386 16 13 13 CD 3344 386 17 , , , 3344 386 18 2006 2006 CD 3344 386 19 , , , 3344 386 20 58 58 CD 3344 386 21 , , , 3344 386 22 www.businessweek.com/technology/ www.businessweek.com/technology/ NNP 3344 386 23 content content NN 3344 386 24 / / SYM 3344 386 25 feb2006 feb2006 NN 3344 386 26 / / SYM 3344 386 27 tc20060202_061809.htm tc20060202_061809.htm NNP 3344 386 28 ( ( -LRB- 3344 386 29 accessed access VBN 3344 386 30 May May NNP 3344 386 31 2 2 CD 3344 386 32 , , , 3344 386 33 2006 2006 CD 3344 386 34 ) ) -RRB- 3344 386 35 . . . 3344 387 1 54 54 CD 3344 387 2 . . . 3344 388 1 Ibid ibid RB 3344 388 2 . . . 3344 389 1 55 55 CD 3344 389 2 . . . 3344 390 1 Jonathan Jonathan NNP 3344 390 2 Krim Krim NNP 3344 390 3 , , , 3344 390 4 “ " `` 3344 390 5 Executive Executive NNP 3344 390 6 Wants want VBZ 3344 390 7 to to TO 3344 390 8 Charge charge VB 3344 390 9 for for IN 3344 390 10 Web web NN 3344 390 11 Speed speed NN 3344 390 12 , , , 3344 390 13 ” " '' 3344 390 14 Washington Washington NNP 3344 390 15 Post Post NNP 3344 390 16 , , , 3344 390 17 Dec. December NNP 3344 390 18 1 1 CD 3344 390 19 , , , 3344 390 20 2005 2005 CD 3344 390 21 , , , 3344 390 22 D05 D05 NNP 3344 390 23 , , , 3344 390 24 www.washingtonpost www.washingtonpost NNP 3344 390 25 .com .com . 3344 390 26 / / SYM 3344 390 27 wp wp NNP 3344 390 28 - - HYPH 3344 390 29 dyn dyn NNP 3344 390 30 / / SYM 3344 390 31 content content NN 3344 390 32 / / SYM 3344 390 33 article/2005/11/30 article/2005/11/30 CD 3344 390 34 / / SYM 3344 390 35 AR2005113002109 ar2005113002109 NN 3344 390 36 .html .html . 3344 390 37 ( ( -LRB- 3344 390 38 accessed access VBN 3344 390 39 May May NNP 3344 390 40 2 2 CD 3344 390 41 , , , 3344 390 42 2006 2006 CD 3344 390 43 ) ) -RRB- 3344 390 44 . . . 3344 391 1 56 56 CD 3344 391 2 . . . 3344 392 1 Harold Harold NNP 3344 392 2 Furchtgott Furchtgott NNP 3344 392 3 - - HYPH 3344 392 4 Roth Roth NNP 3344 392 5 , , , 3344 392 6 “ " `` 3344 392 7 AT&T AT&T NNP 3344 392 8 , , , 3344 392 9 or or CC 3344 392 10 Another another DT 3344 392 11 Telecom Telecom NNP 3344 392 12 Takeover Takeover NNP 3344 392 13 , , , 3344 392 14 ” " '' 3344 392 15 The the DT 3344 392 16 New New NNP 3344 392 17 York York NNP 3344 392 18 Sun Sun NNP 3344 392 19 , , , 3344 392 20 Mar. March NNP 3344 393 1 7 7 CD 3344 393 2 , , , 3344 393 3 2006 2006 CD 3344 393 4 . . . 3344 393 5 www.nysun.com/ www.nysun.com/ NNP 3344 393 6 article/28695 article/28695 NNS 3344 393 7 ( ( -LRB- 3344 393 8 accessed access VBN 3344 393 9 May May NNP 3344 393 10 2 2 CD 3344 393 11 , , , 3344 393 12 2006 2006 CD 3344 393 13 ) ) -RRB- 3344 393 14 . . . 3344 394 1 ( ( -LRB- 3344 394 2 See see VB 3344 394 3 also also RB 3344 394 4 : : : 3344 394 5 www.furchtgott www.furchtgott NNP 3344 394 6 -roth.com -roth.com . 3344 394 7 / / NFP 3344 394 8 news.php?id=87 news.php?id=87 NNP 3344 394 9 ( ( -LRB- 3344 394 10 accessed access VBN 3344 394 11 May May NNP 3344 394 12 2 2 CD 3344 394 13 , , , 3344 394 14 2006 2006 CD 3344 394 15 ) ) -RRB- 3344 394 16 . . . 3344 395 1 57 57 CD 3344 395 2 . . . 3344 396 1 John John NNP 3344 396 2 Windhausen Windhausen NNP 3344 396 3 Jr. Jr. NNP 3344 396 4 , , , 3344 396 5 Good good JJ 3344 396 6 Fences fence NNS 3344 396 7 Make make VBP 3344 396 8 Bad bad JJ 3344 396 9 Broadband broadband NN 3344 396 10 : : : 3344 396 11 Preserving preserve VBG 3344 396 12 an an DT 3344 396 13 Open open JJ 3344 396 14 Internet internet NN 3344 396 15 through through IN 3344 396 16 Net net JJ 3344 396 17 Neutrality Neutrality NNP 3344 396 18 ( ( -LRB- 3344 396 19 Washington Washington NNP 3344 396 20 , , , 3344 396 21 D.C. D.C. NNP 3344 396 22 : : : 3344 396 23 Public Public NNP 3344 396 24 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3344 396 25 , , , 3344 396 26 2006 2006 CD 3344 396 27 ) ) -RRB- 3344 396 28 , , , 3344 396 29 www.publicknowledge.org/ www.publicknowledge.org/ NNP 3344 396 30 content content NN 3344 396 31 / / SYM 3344 396 32 papers paper NNS 3344 396 33 / / SYM 3344 396 34 pk pk JJ 3344 396 35 - - HYPH 3344 396 36 net net JJ 3344 396 37 - - HYPH 3344 396 38 neutrality neutrality NN 3344 396 39 - - HYPH 3344 396 40 whitep-20060206 whitep-20060206 NNP 3344 396 41 ( ( -LRB- 3344 396 42 accessed access VBN 3344 396 43 May May NNP 3344 396 44 2 2 CD 3344 396 45 , , , 3344 396 46 2006 2006 CD 3344 396 47 ) ) -RRB- 3344 396 48 . . . 3344 397 1 58 58 CD 3344 397 2 . . . 3344 398 1 Peter Peter NNP 3344 398 2 Suber Suber NNP 3344 398 3 , , , 3344 398 4 “ " `` 3344 398 5 Three three CD 3344 398 6 Gathering Gathering NNP 3344 398 7 Storms Storms NNPS 3344 398 8 That that WDT 3344 398 9 Could Could MD 3344 398 10 Cause cause VB 3344 398 11 Collateral collateral JJ 3344 398 12 Damage damage NN 3344 398 13 for for IN 3344 398 14 Open open JJ 3344 398 15 Access access NN 3344 398 16 , , , 3344 398 17 ” " '' 3344 398 18 SPARC SPARC NNP 3344 398 19 Open Open NNP 3344 398 20 Access Access NNP 3344 398 21 News- News- NNP 3344 398 22 letter letter NN 3344 398 23 , , , 3344 398 24 no no UH 3344 398 25 . . . 3344 399 1 95 95 CD 3344 399 2 ( ( -LRB- 3344 399 3 2006 2006 CD 3344 399 4 ) ) -RRB- 3344 399 5 , , , 3344 399 6 www.earlham.edu/~peters/ www.earlham.edu/~peters/ NNP 3344 399 7 fos fos NNP 3344 399 8 / / SYM 3344 399 9 newsletter/ newsletter/ NNS 3344 399 10 03-02-06.htm#collateral 03-02-06.htm#collateral CD 3344 399 11 ( ( -LRB- 3344 399 12 accessed access VBN 3344 399 13 May May NNP 3344 399 14 2 2 CD 3344 399 15 , , , 3344 399 16 2006 2006 CD 3344 399 17 ) ) -RRB- 3344 399 18 . . . 3344 400 1 59 59 CD 3344 400 2 . . . 3344 401 1 J. J. NNP 3344 401 2 D. D. NNP 3344 401 3 Lasica Lasica NNP 3344 401 4 , , , 3344 401 5 Darknet Darknet NNP 3344 401 6 : : : 3344 401 7 Hollywood Hollywood NNP 3344 401 8 ’s ’s , 3344 401 9 War War NNP 3344 401 10 against against IN 3344 401 11 the the DT 3344 401 12 Digital Digital NNP 3344 401 13 Generation Generation NNP 3344 401 14 ( ( -LRB- 3344 401 15 New New NNP 3344 401 16 York York NNP 3344 401 17 : : : 3344 401 18 Wiley Wiley NNP 3344 401 19 , , , 3344 401 20 2005 2005 CD 3344 401 21 ) ) -RRB- 3344 401 22 , , , 3344 401 23 45 45 CD 3344 401 24 . . . 3344 402 1 60 60 CD 3344 402 2 . . . 3344 403 1 John John NNP 3344 403 2 Borland Borland NNP 3344 403 3 , , , 3344 403 4 “ " `` 3344 403 5 Freenet Freenet NNP 3344 403 6 Keeps Keeps NNP 3344 403 7 File file NN 3344 403 8 - - HYPH 3344 403 9 Trading trading NN 3344 403 10 Flame Flame NNP 3344 403 11 Burn- Burn- NNP 3344 403 12 ing ing JJ 3344 403 13 , , , 3344 403 14 ” " '' 3344 403 15 CNET cnet NN 3344 403 16 News.com News.com NNS 3344 403 17 , , , 3344 403 18 Oct. October NNP 3344 403 19 28 28 CD 3344 403 20 , , , 3344 403 21 2002 2002 CD 3344 403 22 , , , 3344 403 23 http://news.com.com/2100 http://news.com.com/2100 VBZ 3344 403 24 -1023 -1023 NNP 3344 403 25 - - : 3344 403 26 963459.html 963459.html NNP 3344 403 27 ( ( -LRB- 3344 403 28 accessed access VBN 3344 403 29 May May NNP 3344 403 30 2 2 CD 3344 403 31 , , , 3344 403 32 2006 2006 CD 3344 403 33 ) ) -RRB- 3344 403 34 . . . 3344 404 1 61 61 CD 3344 404 2 . . . 3344 405 1 Creative Creative NNP 3344 405 2 Commons Commons NNPS 3344 405 3 , , , 3344 405 4 “ " `` 3344 405 5 Attribution attribution NN 3344 405 6 2.5 2.5 CD 3344 405 7 , , , 3344 405 8 ” " '' 3344 405 9 http://creative http://creative ADD 3344 405 10 commons.org/licenses/by/2.5/ commons.org/licenses/by/2.5/ NNP 3344 405 11 ( ( -LRB- 3344 405 12 accessed access VBN 3344 405 13 May May NNP 3344 405 14 2 2 CD 3344 405 15 , , , 3344 405 16 2006 2006 CD 3344 405 17 ) ) -RRB- 3344 405 18 . . . 3344 406 1 62 62 CD 3344 406 2 . . . 3344 407 1 Lawrence Lawrence NNP 3344 407 2 Liang Liang NNP 3344 407 3 , , , 3344 407 4 “ " `` 3344 407 5 A a DT 3344 407 6 Guide guide NN 3344 407 7 To to TO 3344 407 8 Open open VB 3344 407 9 Content content NN 3344 407 10 Licenses Licenses NNPS 3344 407 11 . . . 3344 407 12 ” " '' 3344 407 13 http://pzwart.wdka.hro.nl/mdr/research/lliang/open http://pzwart.wdka.hro.nl/mdr/research/lliang/open ADD 3344 407 14 _ _ NNP 3344 407 15 content_guide content_guide NNP 3344 407 16 ( ( -LRB- 3344 407 17 accessed access VBN 3344 407 18 May May NNP 3344 407 19 2 2 CD 3344 407 20 , , , 3344 407 21 2006 2006 CD 3344 407 22 ) ) -RRB- 3344 407 23 . . . 3344 408 1 63 63 CD 3344 408 2 . . . 3344 409 1 Peter Peter NNP 3344 409 2 Suber Suber NNP 3344 409 3 , , , 3344 409 4 “ " `` 3344 409 5 Open open JJ 3344 409 6 Access access NN 3344 409 7 Overview overview NN 3344 409 8 : : : 3344 409 9 Focusing focus VBG 3344 409 10 on on IN 3344 409 11 Open open JJ 3344 409 12 Access access NN 3344 409 13 to to IN 3344 409 14 Peer Peer NNP 3344 409 15 - - HYPH 3344 409 16 Reviewed Reviewed NNP 3344 409 17 Research Research NNP 3344 409 18 Articles Articles NNPS 3344 409 19 and and CC 3344 409 20 Their -PRON- PRP$ 3344 409 21 Preprints preprint NNS 3344 409 22 . . . 3344 409 23 ” " '' 3344 409 24 www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm NN 3344 409 25 ( ( -LRB- 3344 409 26 accessed access VBN 3344 409 27 May May NNP 3344 409 28 2 2 CD 3344 409 29 , , , 3344 409 30 2006 2006 CD 3344 409 31 ) ) -RRB- 3344 409 32 ; ; : 3344 409 33 Charles Charles NNP 3344 409 34 W. W. NNP 3344 409 35 Bailey Bailey NNP 3344 409 36 Jr. Jr. NNP 3344 409 37 , , , 3344 409 38 “ " `` 3344 409 39 Open open JJ 3344 409 40 Access access NN 3344 409 41 and and CC 3344 409 42 Libraries library NNS 3344 409 43 , , , 3344 409 44 ” " '' 3344 409 45 in in IN 3344 409 46 Mark Mark NNP 3344 409 47 Jacobs Jacobs NNP 3344 409 48 , , , 3344 409 49 ed ed NNP 3344 409 50 . . NNP 3344 409 51 , , , 3344 409 52 Electronic Electronic NNP 3344 409 53 Resources Resources NNPS 3344 409 54 Librarians Librarians NNPS 3344 409 55 : : : 3344 409 56 The The NNP 3344 409 57 Human Human NNP 3344 409 58 Ele- Ele- NNP 3344 409 59 ment ment NN 3344 409 60 of of IN 3344 409 61 the the DT 3344 409 62 Digital Digital NNP 3344 409 63 Information Information NNP 3344 409 64 Age Age NNP 3344 409 65 ( ( -LRB- 3344 409 66 Binghamton Binghamton NNP 3344 409 67 , , , 3344 409 68 N.Y. New York NNP 3344 409 69 : : : 3344 409 70 Haworth Haworth NNP 3344 409 71 , , , 3344 409 72 2006 2006 CD 3344 409 73 ) ) -RRB- 3344 409 74 , , , 3344 409 75 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 3344 409 76 , , , 3344 409 77 www.digital-scholarship.com/cwb/OA www.digital-scholarship.com/cwb/OA VBD 3344 409 78 Libraries.pdf Libraries.pdf NNP 3344 409 79 ( ( -LRB- 3344 409 80 accessed access VBN 3344 409 81 May May NNP 3344 409 82 2 2 CD 3344 409 83 , , , 3344 409 84 2006 2006 CD 3344 409 85 ) ) -RRB- 3344 409 86 . . . 3344 410 1 64 64 CD 3344 410 2 . . . 3344 411 1 Lasica Lasica NNP 3344 411 2 , , , 3344 411 3 Darknet Darknet NNP 3344 411 4 , , , 3344 411 5 72–73 72–73 NN 3344 411 6 . . . 3344 412 1 65 65 CD 3344 412 2 . . . 3344 413 1 Waxer Waxer NNP 3344 413 2 and and CC 3344 413 3 Baum Baum NNP 3344 413 4 , , , 3344 413 5 Internet internet NN 3344 413 6 Surf Surf NNP 3344 413 7 and and CC 3344 413 8 Turf Turf NNP 3344 413 9 Revealed Revealed NNP 3344 413 10 , , , 3344 413 11 17 17 CD 3344 413 12 . . . 3344 414 1 66 66 CD 3344 414 2 . . . 3344 415 1 Lessig Lessig NNS 3344 415 2 , , , 3344 415 3 Free Free NNP 3344 415 4 Culture Culture NNP 3344 415 5 , , , 3344 415 6 134–35 134–35 CD 3344 415 7 . . . 3344 416 1 67 67 CD 3344 416 2 . . . 3344 417 1 Joe Joe NNP 3344 417 2 Mandak Mandak NNP 3344 417 3 , , , 3344 417 4 “ " `` 3344 417 5 Internet internet NN 3344 417 6 Archive Archive NNP 3344 417 7 ’s ’s NNP 3344 417 8 Value Value NNP 3344 417 9 , , , 3344 417 10 Legality legality NN 3344 417 11 Debated debate VBN 3344 417 12 in in IN 3344 417 13 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 417 14 Suit Suit NNP 3344 417 15 , , , 3344 417 16 ” " '' 3344 417 17 Mercury Mercury NNP 3344 417 18 News News NNP 3344 417 19 , , , 3344 417 20 Mar. March NNP 3344 418 1 31 31 CD 3344 418 2 , , , 3344 418 3 2006 2006 CD 3344 418 4 , , , 3344 418 5 www www NNP 3344 418 6 .mercurynews.com .mercurynews.com NN 3344 418 7 / / SYM 3344 418 8 mld mld NNP 3344 418 9 / / SYM 3344 418 10 mercurynews mercurynews NNP 3344 418 11 / / SYM 3344 418 12 news news NN 3344 418 13 / / SYM 3344 418 14 local local JJ 3344 418 15 / / SYM 3344 418 16 states/ states/ NNP 3344 418 17 california california NNP 3344 418 18 / / , 3344 418 19 northern_california/14234638.htm northern_california/14234638.htm UH 3344 418 20 ( ( -LRB- 3344 418 21 accessed access VBN 3344 418 22 May May NNP 3344 418 23 2 2 CD 3344 418 24 , , , 3344 418 25 2006 2006 CD 3344 418 26 ) ) -RRB- 3344 418 27 . . . 3344 419 1 68 68 CD 3344 419 2 . . . 3344 420 1 Arnold Arnold NNP 3344 420 2 P. P. NNP 3344 420 3 Lutzker Lutzker NNP 3344 420 4 , , , 3344 420 5 Primer Primer NNP 3344 420 6 on on IN 3344 420 7 the the DT 3344 420 8 Digital Digital NNP 3344 420 9 Millennium Millennium NNP 3344 420 10 : : : 3344 420 11 What what WP 3344 420 12 the the DT 3344 420 13 Digital Digital NNP 3344 420 14 Millennium Millennium NNP 3344 420 15 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 420 16 Act Act NNP 3344 420 17 and and CC 3344 420 18 the the DT 3344 420 19 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 420 20 Term Term NNP 3344 420 21 Exten- Exten- NNP 3344 420 22 sion sion NN 3344 420 23 Act Act NNP 3344 420 24 Mean Mean NNP 3344 420 25 for for IN 3344 420 26 the the DT 3344 420 27 Library Library NNP 3344 420 28 Community Community NNP 3344 420 29 ( ( -LRB- 3344 420 30 Washington Washington NNP 3344 420 31 , , , 3344 420 32 D.C. D.C. NNP 3344 420 33 : : : 3344 420 34 ALA ALA NNP 3344 420 35 Washington Washington NNP 3344 420 36 Office Office NNP 3344 420 37 , , , 3344 420 38 1999 1999 CD 3344 420 39 ) ) -RRB- 3344 420 40 , , , 3344 420 41 www.ala.org/ala/washoff/WOis www.ala.org/ala/washoff/WOis . 3344 420 42 sues sues NNP 3344 420 43 / / SYM 3344 420 44 copyrightb copyrightb NNP 3344 420 45 / / SYM 3344 420 46 dmca dmca NNS 3344 420 47 / / SYM 3344 420 48 dmcaprimer.pdf dmcaprimer.pdf NN 3344 420 49 ( ( -LRB- 3344 420 50 accessed access VBN 3344 420 51 May May NNP 3344 420 52 2 2 CD 3344 420 53 , , , 3344 420 54 2006 2006 CD 3344 420 55 ) ) -RRB- 3344 420 56 . . . 3344 421 1 The the DT 3344 421 2 Chamberlain Chamberlain NNP 3344 421 3 Group Group NNP 3344 421 4 Inc. Inc. NNP 3344 421 5 v. v. CC 3344 421 6 Skylink Skylink NNP 3344 421 7 Technologies Technologies NNPS 3344 421 8 Inc. Inc. NNP 3344 421 9 deci- deci- NN 3344 421 10 sion sion NN 3344 421 11 offers offer VBZ 3344 421 12 some some DT 3344 421 13 hope hope NN 3344 421 14 that that IN 3344 421 15 authorized authorize VBD 3344 421 16 users user NNS 3344 421 17 of of IN 3344 421 18 DRM DRM NNP 3344 421 19 - - HYPH 3344 421 20 protected protect VBN 3344 421 21 works work NNS 3344 421 22 could could MD 3344 421 23 legally legally RB 3344 421 24 circumvent circumvent VB 3344 421 25 DRM DRM NNP 3344 421 26 for for IN 3344 421 27 lawful lawful JJ 3344 421 28 purposes purpose NNS 3344 421 29 if if IN 3344 421 30 they -PRON- PRP 3344 421 31 had have VBD 3344 421 32 the the DT 3344 421 33 means mean NNS 3344 421 34 to to TO 3344 421 35 do do VB 3344 421 36 so so RB 3344 421 37 ( ( -LRB- 3344 421 38 see see VB 3344 421 39 : : : 3344 421 40 Crews crew NNS 3344 421 41 , , , 3344 421 42 Copyright Copyright NNP 3344 421 43 Law Law NNP 3344 421 44 for for IN 3344 421 45 Librarians Librarians NNPS 3344 421 46 and and CC 3344 421 47 Educators Educators NNPS 3344 421 48 : : : 3344 421 49 Creative Creative NNP 3344 421 50 Strategies Strategies NNPS 3344 421 51 and and CC 3344 421 52 Practical Practical NNP 3344 421 53 Solutions Solutions NNPS 3344 421 54 , , , 3344 421 55 96–97 96–97 CD 3344 421 56 ) ) -RRB- 3344 421 57 . . . 3344 422 1 continued continue VBN 3344 422 2 on on IN 3344 422 3 page page NN 3344 422 4 139 139 CD 3344 422 5 TOWARD toward NN 3344 422 6 A a DT 3344 422 7 TWENTY TWENTY NNP 3344 422 8 - - HYPH 3344 422 9 FIRST FIRST NNP 3344 422 10 - - HYPH 3344 422 11 CENTURY century NN 3344 422 12 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 3344 422 13 CATALOG CATALOG NNP 3344 422 14 | | NNP 3344 422 15 ANTELMAN ANTELMAN NNP 3344 422 16 , , , 3344 422 17 LYNEMA LYNEMA NNP 3344 422 18 , , , 3344 422 19 AND and CC 3344 422 20 PACE PACE NNP 3344 422 21 139 139 CD 3344 422 22 Copyright copyright NN 3344 422 23 © © NN 3344 422 24 2006 2006 CD 3344 422 25 by by IN 3344 422 26 Charles Charles NNP 3344 422 27 W. W. NNP 3344 422 28 Bailey Bailey NNP 3344 422 29 Jr. Jr. NNP 3344 423 1 This this DT 3344 423 2 work work NN 3344 423 3 is be VBZ 3344 423 4 licensed license VBN 3344 423 5 under under IN 3344 423 6 the the DT 3344 423 7 Creative Creative NNP 3344 423 8 Commons Commons NNP 3344 423 9 Attribution- Attribution- NNP 3344 423 10 NonCommercial NonCommercial NNP 3344 423 11 2.5 2.5 CD 3344 423 12 License License NNP 3344 423 13 . . . 3344 424 1 To to TO 3344 424 2 view view VB 3344 424 3 a a DT 3344 424 4 copy copy NN 3344 424 5 of of IN 3344 424 6 this this DT 3344 424 7 license license NN 3344 424 8 , , , 3344 424 9 visit visit VBP 3344 424 10 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.5/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.5/ NNP 3344 424 11 or or CC 3344 424 12 send send VB 3344 424 13 a a DT 3344 424 14 letter letter NN 3344 424 15 to to IN 3344 424 16 Creative Creative NNP 3344 424 17 Commons Commons NNPS 3344 424 18 , , , 3344 424 19 543 543 CD 3344 424 20 Howard Howard NNP 3344 424 21 St. St. NNP 3344 424 22 , , , 3344 424 23 5th 5th JJ 3344 424 24 Floor Floor NNP 3344 424 25 , , , 3344 424 26 San San NNP 3344 424 27 Francisco Francisco NNP 3344 424 28 , , , 3344 424 29 CA CA NNP 3344 424 30 , , , 3344 424 31 94105 94105 CD 3344 424 32 , , , 3344 424 33 USA USA NNP 3344 424 34 . . . 3344 425 1 Bailey Bailey NNP 3344 425 2 continued continue VBD 3344 425 3 from from IN 3344 425 4 127 127 CD 3344 425 5 ฀ ฀ NN 3344 425 6 Known know VBN 3344 425 7 - - HYPH 3344 425 8 Item Item NNP 3344 425 9 Questions Questions NNP 3344 425 10 1 1 CD 3344 425 11 . . . 3344 426 1 “ " `` 3344 426 2 Your -PRON- PRP$ 3344 426 3 history history NN 3344 426 4 professor professor NN 3344 426 5 has have VBZ 3344 426 6 requested request VBN 3344 426 7 you -PRON- PRP 3344 426 8 to to TO 3344 426 9 start start VB 3344 426 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 3344 426 11 research research NN 3344 426 12 project project NN 3344 426 13 by by IN 3344 426 14 looking look VBG 3344 426 15 up up RP 3344 426 16 background background NN 3344 426 17 information information NN 3344 426 18 in in IN 3344 426 19 a a DT 3344 426 20 book book NN 3344 426 21 titled title VBN 3344 426 22 Civilizations civilization NNS 3344 426 23 of of IN 3344 426 24 the the DT 3344 426 25 Ancient Ancient NNP 3344 426 26 Near Near NNP 3344 426 27 East East NNP 3344 426 28 . . . 3344 426 29 ” " '' 3344 426 30 a. a. NN 3344 427 1 “ " `` 3344 427 2 Please please UH 3344 427 3 find find VB 3344 427 4 this this DT 3344 427 5 title title NN 3344 427 6 in in IN 3344 427 7 the the DT 3344 427 8 library library NN 3344 427 9 catalog catalog NN 3344 427 10 . . . 3344 427 11 ” " '' 3344 427 12 b. b. NNP 3344 428 1 “ " `` 3344 428 2 Where where WRB 3344 428 3 would would MD 3344 428 4 you -PRON- PRP 3344 428 5 go go VB 3344 428 6 to to TO 3344 428 7 find find VB 3344 428 8 this this DT 3344 428 9 book book NN 3344 428 10 physically physically RB 3344 428 11 ? ? . 3344 428 12 ” " '' 3344 428 13 2 2 CD 3344 428 14 . . . 3344 429 1 “ " `` 3344 429 2 For for IN 3344 429 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 3344 429 4 literature literature NN 3344 429 5 class class NN 3344 429 6 , , , 3344 429 7 you -PRON- PRP 3344 429 8 need need VBP 3344 429 9 to to TO 3344 429 10 read read VB 3344 429 11 the the DT 3344 429 12 book book NN 3344 429 13 titled title VBN 3344 429 14 Gulliver Gulliver NNP 3344 429 15 ’s ’s , 3344 429 16 Travels travel NNS 3344 429 17 written write VBN 3344 429 18 by by IN 3344 429 19 Jonathan Jonathan NNP 3344 429 20 Swift Swift NNP 3344 429 21 . . . 3344 430 1 Find find VB 3344 430 2 the the DT 3344 430 3 call call NN 3344 430 4 number number NN 3344 430 5 for for IN 3344 430 6 one one CD 3344 430 7 copy copy NN 3344 430 8 of of IN 3344 430 9 this this DT 3344 430 10 book book NN 3344 430 11 . . . 3344 430 12 ” " '' 3344 430 13 3 3 CD 3344 430 14 . . . 3344 431 1 “ " `` 3344 431 2 You -PRON- PRP 3344 431 3 ’ve have VB 3344 431 4 been be VBN 3344 431 5 hearing hear VBG 3344 431 6 a a DT 3344 431 7 lot lot NN 3344 431 8 about about IN 3344 431 9 the the DT 3344 431 10 physicist physicist JJ 3344 431 11 Richard Richard NNP 3344 431 12 Feynman Feynman NNP 3344 431 13 , , , 3344 431 14 and and CC 3344 431 15 you -PRON- PRP 3344 431 16 ’d ’d , 3344 431 17 like like VB 3344 431 18 to to TO 3344 431 19 find find VB 3344 431 20 out out RP 3344 431 21 whether whether IN 3344 431 22 the the DT 3344 431 23 library library NN 3344 431 24 has have VBZ 3344 431 25 any any DT 3344 431 26 of of IN 3344 431 27 the the DT 3344 431 28 books book NNS 3344 431 29 that that WDT 3344 431 30 he -PRON- PRP 3344 431 31 has have VBZ 3344 431 32 written write VBN 3344 431 33 . . . 3344 431 34 ” " '' 3344 431 35 a. a. NN 3344 432 1 “ " `` 3344 432 2 What what WP 3344 432 3 is be VBZ 3344 432 4 the the DT 3344 432 5 title title NN 3344 432 6 of of IN 3344 432 7 one one CD 3344 432 8 of of IN 3344 432 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 432 10 books book NNS 3344 432 11 ? ? . 3344 432 12 ” " '' 3344 432 13 b. b. NNP 3344 433 1 “ " `` 3344 433 2 Is be VBZ 3344 433 3 there there EX 3344 433 4 a a DT 3344 433 5 copy copy NN 3344 433 6 of of IN 3344 433 7 this this DT 3344 433 8 book book NN 3344 433 9 you -PRON- PRP 3344 433 10 could could MD 3344 433 11 check check VB 3344 433 12 out out RP 3344 433 13 from from IN 3344 433 14 D. D. NNP 3344 433 15 H. H. NNP 3344 433 16 Hill Hill NNP 3344 433 17 Library Library NNP 3344 433 18 ? ? . 3344 433 19 ” " '' 3344 433 20 4 4 CD 3344 433 21 . . . 3344 434 1 “ " `` 3344 434 2 You -PRON- PRP 3344 434 3 have have VBP 3344 434 4 the the DT 3344 434 5 citation citation NN 3344 434 6 for for IN 3344 434 7 a a DT 3344 434 8 journal journal NN 3344 434 9 article article NN 3344 434 10 about about IN 3344 434 11 photosynthesis photosynthesis NN 3344 434 12 , , , 3344 434 13 light light NN 3344 434 14 , , , 3344 434 15 and and CC 3344 434 16 plant plant NN 3344 434 17 growth growth NN 3344 434 18 . . . 3344 435 1 You -PRON- PRP 3344 435 2 can can MD 3344 435 3 read read VB 3344 435 4 the the DT 3344 435 5 actual actual JJ 3344 435 6 citation citation NN 3344 435 7 for for IN 3344 435 8 the the DT 3344 435 9 journal journal NNP 3344 435 10 article article NN 3344 435 11 on on IN 3344 435 12 this this DT 3344 435 13 sheet sheet NN 3344 435 14 of of IN 3344 435 15 paper paper NN 3344 435 16 . . . 3344 435 17 ” " '' 3344 435 18 Alley Alley NNP 3344 435 19 , , , 3344 435 20 H. H. NNP 3344 435 21 , , , 3344 435 22 M. M. NNP 3344 435 23 Rieger Rieger NNP 3344 435 24 , , , 3344 435 25 and and CC 3344 435 26 J.M. J.M. NNP 3344 436 1 Affolter Affolter NNP 3344 436 2 . . . 3344 437 1 “ " `` 3344 437 2 Effects effect NNS 3344 437 3 of of IN 3344 437 4 Developmental Developmental NNP 3344 437 5 Light Light NNP 3344 437 6 Level Level NNP 3344 437 7 on on IN 3344 437 8 Photosynthesis Photosynthesis NNP 3344 437 9 and and CC 3344 437 10 Biomass Biomass NNP 3344 437 11 Production Production NNP 3344 437 12 in in IN 3344 437 13 Echinacea Echinacea NNP 3344 437 14 Laevigata Laevigata NNP 3344 437 15 , , , 3344 437 16 a a DT 3344 437 17 Federally Federally NNP 3344 437 18 Listed Listed NNP 3344 437 19 Endan- Endan- NNP 3344 437 20 gered gere VBD 3344 437 21 Species Species NNPS 3344 437 22 . . . 3344 437 23 ” " '' 3344 437 24 Natural Natural NNP 3344 437 25 Areas Areas NNPS 3344 437 26 Journal Journal NNP 3344 437 27 25.2 25.2 CD 3344 437 28 ( ( -LRB- 3344 437 29 2005 2005 CD 3344 437 30 ) ) -RRB- 3344 437 31 : : : 3344 437 32 117–22 117–22 CD 3344 437 33 . . . 3344 438 1 a. a. NN 3344 439 1 “ " `` 3344 439 2 Using use VBG 3344 439 3 the the DT 3344 439 4 library library NN 3344 439 5 catalog catalog NN 3344 439 6 , , , 3344 439 7 can can MD 3344 439 8 you -PRON- PRP 3344 439 9 determine determine VB 3344 439 10 if if IN 3344 439 11 the the DT 3344 439 12 library library NN 3344 439 13 owns own VBZ 3344 439 14 this this DT 3344 439 15 journal journal NN 3344 439 16 ? ? . 3344 439 17 ” " '' 3344 439 18 b. b. NNP 3344 440 1 “ " `` 3344 440 2 Do do VB 3344 440 3 library library NN 3344 440 4 users user NNS 3344 440 5 have have VBP 3344 440 6 access access NN 3344 440 7 to to IN 3344 440 8 the the DT 3344 440 9 volume volume NN 3344 440 10 that that WDT 3344 440 11 actually actually RB 3344 440 12 contains contain VBZ 3344 440 13 this this DT 3344 440 14 article article NN 3344 440 15 ( ( -LRB- 3344 440 16 either either CC 3344 440 17 electronically electronically RB 3344 440 18 or or CC 3344 440 19 in in IN 3344 440 20 print print NN 3344 440 21 ) ) -RRB- 3344 440 22 ? ? . 3344 440 23 ” " '' 3344 440 24 ฀ ฀ NNP 3344 440 25 Topical Topical NNP 3344 440 26 Questions Questions NNPS 3344 440 27 5 5 CD 3344 440 28 . . . 3344 441 1 “ " `` 3344 441 2 Please please UH 3344 441 3 find find VB 3344 441 4 the the DT 3344 441 5 titles title NNS 3344 441 6 of of IN 3344 441 7 two two CD 3344 441 8 books book NNS 3344 441 9 that that WDT 3344 441 10 have have VBP 3344 441 11 been be VBN 3344 441 12 written write VBN 3344 441 13 about about IN 3344 441 14 Bill Bill NNP 3344 441 15 Gates Gates NNP 3344 441 16 ( ( -LRB- 3344 441 17 not not RB 3344 441 18 books book NNS 3344 441 19 written write VBN 3344 441 20 by by IN 3344 441 21 Bill Bill NNP 3344 441 22 Gates Gates NNP 3344 441 23 ) ) -RRB- 3344 441 24 . . . 3344 441 25 ” " '' 3344 441 26 6 6 CD 3344 441 27 . . . 3344 442 1 “ " `` 3344 442 2 Your -PRON- PRP$ 3344 442 3 cat cat NN 3344 442 4 is be VBZ 3344 442 5 acting act VBG 3344 442 6 like like IN 3344 442 7 he -PRON- PRP 3344 442 8 does do VBZ 3344 442 9 n’t not RB 3344 442 10 feel feel VB 3344 442 11 well well RB 3344 442 12 , , , 3344 442 13 and and CC 3344 442 14 you -PRON- PRP 3344 442 15 are be VBP 3344 442 16 worried worried JJ 3344 442 17 about about IN 3344 442 18 him -PRON- PRP 3344 442 19 . . . 3344 443 1 Please please UH 3344 443 2 find find VB 3344 443 3 two two CD 3344 443 4 books book NNS 3344 443 5 that that WDT 3344 443 6 provide provide VBP 3344 443 7 information information NN 3344 443 8 specifically specifically RB 3344 443 9 on on IN 3344 443 10 cat cat NN 3344 443 11 health health NN 3344 443 12 or or CC 3344 443 13 caring care VBG 3344 443 14 for for IN 3344 443 15 cats cat NNS 3344 443 16 . . . 3344 443 17 ” " '' 3344 443 18 7 7 CD 3344 443 19 . . . 3344 444 1 “ " `` 3344 444 2 You -PRON- PRP 3344 444 3 have have VBP 3344 444 4 family family NN 3344 444 5 who who WP 3344 444 6 are be VBP 3344 444 7 considering consider VBG 3344 444 8 a a DT 3344 444 9 solar solar JJ 3344 444 10 house house NN 3344 444 11 . . . 3344 445 1 Does do VBZ 3344 445 2 the the DT 3344 445 3 library library NN 3344 445 4 have have VB 3344 445 5 any any DT 3344 445 6 materials material NNS 3344 445 7 about about IN 3344 445 8 building build VBG 3344 445 9 passive passive JJ 3344 445 10 solar solar JJ 3344 445 11 homes home NNS 3344 445 12 ? ? . 3344 445 13 ” " '' 3344 445 14 8 8 CD 3344 445 15 . . . 3344 446 1 “ " `` 3344 446 2 Can Can MD 3344 446 3 you -PRON- PRP 3344 446 4 show show VB 3344 446 5 me -PRON- PRP 3344 446 6 how how WRB 3344 446 7 would would MD 3344 446 8 you -PRON- PRP 3344 446 9 find find VB 3344 446 10 the the DT 3344 446 11 most most RBS 3344 446 12 recently recently RB 3344 446 13 published publish VBN 3344 446 14 book book NN 3344 446 15 about about IN 3344 446 16 nuclear nuclear JJ 3344 446 17 energy energy NN 3344 446 18 policy policy NN 3344 446 19 in in IN 3344 446 20 the the DT 3344 446 21 United United NNP 3344 446 22 States States NNP 3344 446 23 ? ? . 3344 446 24 ” " '' 3344 446 25 9 9 CD 3344 446 26 . . . 3344 447 1 “ " `` 3344 447 2 Imagine imagine VB 3344 447 3 you -PRON- PRP 3344 447 4 teach teach VBP 3344 447 5 introductory introductory JJ 3344 447 6 Spanish Spanish NNP 3344 447 7 and and CC 3344 447 8 you -PRON- PRP 3344 447 9 want want VBP 3344 447 10 to to TO 3344 447 11 broaden broaden VB 3344 447 12 your -PRON- PRP$ 3344 447 13 students student NNS 3344 447 14 ’ ’ POS 3344 447 15 horizons horizon NNS 3344 447 16 by by IN 3344 447 17 expos- expos- NNP 3344 447 18 ing ing NNP 3344 447 19 them -PRON- PRP 3344 447 20 to to IN 3344 447 21 poetry poetry NN 3344 447 22 in in IN 3344 447 23 Spanish Spanish NNP 3344 447 24 . . . 3344 448 1 Find find VB 3344 448 2 at at RB 3344 448 3 least least RBS 3344 448 4 one one CD 3344 448 5 audio audio NN 3344 448 6 recording recording NN 3344 448 7 of of IN 3344 448 8 a a DT 3344 448 9 poet poet NN 3344 448 10 reading read VBG 3344 448 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 3344 448 12 or or CC 3344 448 13 her -PRON- PRP$ 3344 448 14 work work NN 3344 448 15 aloud aloud RB 3344 448 16 in in IN 3344 448 17 Spanish Spanish NNP 3344 448 18 . . . 3344 448 19 ” " '' 3344 448 20 10 10 CD 3344 448 21 . . . 3344 449 1 “ " `` 3344 449 2 You -PRON- PRP 3344 449 3 would would MD 3344 449 4 like like VB 3344 449 5 to to TO 3344 449 6 browse browse VB 3344 449 7 the the DT 3344 449 8 recent recent JJ 3344 449 9 journal journal NN 3344 449 10 litera- litera- XX 3344 449 11 ture ture NN 3344 449 12 in in IN 3344 449 13 the the DT 3344 449 14 field field NN 3344 449 15 of of IN 3344 449 16 landscape landscape NN 3344 449 17 architecture architecture NN 3344 449 18 . . . 3344 450 1 Does do VBZ 3344 450 2 the the DT 3344 450 3 Design Design NNP 3344 450 4 Library Library NNP 3344 450 5 have have VBP 3344 450 6 any any DT 3344 450 7 journals journal NNS 3344 450 8 about about IN 3344 450 9 landscape landscape NN 3344 450 10 architecture architecture NN 3344 450 11 ? ? . 3344 450 12 ” " '' 3344 450 13 Appendix Appendix NNP 3344 450 14 A A NNP 3344 450 15 : : : 3344 450 16 NCSU NCSU NNP 3344 450 17 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3344 450 18 Catalog Catalog NNP 3344 450 19 Usability usability NN 3344 450 20 Test test NN 3344 450 21 Tasks task NNS