id sid tid token lemma pos 3278 1 1 This this DT 3278 1 2 article article NN 3278 1 3 discusses discuss VBZ 3278 1 4 structural structural JJ 3278 1 5 , , , 3278 1 6 systems system NNS 3278 1 7 , , , 3278 1 8 and and CC 3278 1 9 other other JJ 3278 1 10 types type NNS 3278 1 11 of of IN 3278 1 12 bias bias NN 3278 1 13 that that WDT 3278 1 14 arise arise VBP 3278 1 15 in in IN 3278 1 16 matching match VBG 3278 1 17 new new JJ 3278 1 18 records record NNS 3278 1 19 to to IN 3278 1 20 large large JJ 3278 1 21 data- data- JJ 3278 1 22 bases basis NNS 3278 1 23 . . . 3278 2 1 The the DT 3278 2 2 focus focus NN 3278 2 3 is be VBZ 3278 2 4 databases database NNS 3278 2 5 for for IN 3278 2 6 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 2 7 utilities utility NNS 3278 2 8 , , , 3278 2 9 but but CC 3278 2 10 other other JJ 3278 2 11 related related JJ 3278 2 12 database database NN 3278 2 13 concerns concern NNS 3278 2 14 will will MD 3278 2 15 be be VB 3278 2 16 discussed discuss VBN 3278 2 17 . . . 3278 3 1 Problems problem NNS 3278 3 2 of of IN 3278 3 3 satisfying satisfy VBG 3278 3 4 a a DT 3278 3 5 “ " `` 3278 3 6 match match NN 3278 3 7 ” " '' 3278 3 8 with with IN 3278 3 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 3278 3 10 flexibility flexibility NN 3278 3 11 and and CC 3278 3 12 rigor rigor VB 3278 3 13 in in IN 3278 3 14 an an DT 3278 3 15 environment environment NN 3278 3 16 of of IN 3278 3 17 imperfect imperfect JJ 3278 3 18 data datum NNS 3278 3 19 are be VBP 3278 3 20 presented present VBN 3278 3 21 , , , 3278 3 22 and and CC 3278 3 23 sources source NNS 3278 3 24 of of IN 3278 3 25 unintentional unintentional JJ 3278 3 26 variance variance NN 3278 3 27 are be VBP 3278 3 28 discussed discuss VBN 3278 3 29 . . . 3278 4 1 Editor editor NN 3278 4 2 ’s ’s POS 3278 4 3 note note NN 3278 4 4 : : : 3278 4 5 This this DT 3278 4 6 article article NN 3278 4 7 was be VBD 3278 4 8 submitted submit VBN 3278 4 9 in in IN 3278 4 10 honor honor NN 3278 4 11 of of IN 3278 4 12 the the DT 3278 4 13 fortieth fortieth JJ 3278 4 14 anniversaries anniversary NNS 3278 4 15 of of IN 3278 4 16 LITA LITA NNP 3278 4 17 and and CC 3278 4 18 ITAL ITAL NNP 3278 4 19 . . . 3278 5 1 S s JJ 3278 5 2 ameness ameness NN 3278 5 3 is be VBZ 3278 5 4 a a DT 3278 5 5 sometime sometime JJ 3278 5 6 thing thing NN 3278 5 7 . . . 3278 6 1 Libraries library NNS 3278 6 2 and and CC 3278 6 3 other other JJ 3278 6 4 information­intensive information­intensive JJ 3278 6 5 organizations organization NNS 3278 6 6 have have VBP 3278 6 7 long long RB 3278 6 8 faced face VBN 3278 6 9 the the DT 3278 6 10 problem problem NN 3278 6 11 of of IN 3278 6 12 large large JJ 3278 6 13 collections collection NNS 3278 6 14 of of IN 3278 6 15 records record NNS 3278 6 16 growing grow VBG 3278 6 17 incrementally incrementally RB 3278 6 18 . . . 3278 7 1 Computerized computerized JJ 3278 7 2 records record NNS 3278 7 3 in in IN 3278 7 4 a a DT 3278 7 5 net­ net­ NNP 3278 7 6 worked worked JJ 3278 7 7 environment environment NN 3278 7 8 have have VBP 3278 7 9 encouraged encourage VBN 3278 7 10 the the DT 3278 7 11 recognition recognition NN 3278 7 12 that that WDT 3278 7 13 duplicate duplicate VBP 3278 7 14 records record NNS 3278 7 15 pose pose VBP 3278 7 16 a a DT 3278 7 17 serious serious JJ 3278 7 18 threat threat NN 3278 7 19 to to IN 3278 7 20 efficient efficient JJ 3278 7 21 information information NN 3278 7 22 retrieval retrieval NN 3278 7 23 . . . 3278 8 1 Yet yet CC 3278 8 2 what what WP 3278 8 3 constitutes constitute VBZ 3278 8 4 a a DT 3278 8 5 duplicate duplicate JJ 3278 8 6 record record NN 3278 8 7 may may MD 3278 8 8 be be VB 3278 8 9 neither neither CC 3278 8 10 exact exact JJ 3278 8 11 nor nor CC 3278 8 12 completely completely RB 3278 8 13 predictable predictable JJ 3278 8 14 . . . 3278 9 1 Levels level NNS 3278 9 2 of of IN 3278 9 3 discernment discernment NN 3278 9 4 are be VBP 3278 9 5 required require VBN 3278 9 6 to to TO 3278 9 7 permit permit VB 3278 9 8 matches match NNS 3278 9 9 on on IN 3278 9 10 records record NNS 3278 9 11 that that WDT 3278 9 12 do do VBP 3278 9 13 not not RB 3278 9 14 dif­ dif­ VB 3278 9 15 fer fer VB 3278 9 16 significantly significantly RB 3278 9 17 and and CC 3278 9 18 records record NNS 3278 9 19 that that WDT 3278 9 20 do do VBP 3278 9 21 . . . 3278 10 1 n n DT 3278 10 2 Initial initial JJ 3278 10 3 definitions definition NNS 3278 10 4 Matching Matching NNP 3278 10 5 is be VBZ 3278 10 6 defined define VBN 3278 10 7 as as IN 3278 10 8 the the DT 3278 10 9 process process NN 3278 10 10 by by IN 3278 10 11 which which WDT 3278 10 12 additions addition NNS 3278 10 13 to to IN 3278 10 14 a a DT 3278 10 15 large large JJ 3278 10 16 database database NN 3278 10 17 are be VBP 3278 10 18 screened screen VBN 3278 10 19 and and CC 3278 10 20 compared compare VBN 3278 10 21 with with IN 3278 10 22 existing exist VBG 3278 10 23 database database NN 3278 10 24 records record NNS 3278 10 25 . . . 3278 11 1 Ideally ideally RB 3278 11 2 , , , 3278 11 3 this this DT 3278 11 4 process process NN 3278 11 5 of of IN 3278 11 6 matching match VBG 3278 11 7 ensures ensure NNS 3278 11 8 that that IN 3278 11 9 duplicates duplicate NNS 3278 11 10 are be VBP 3278 11 11 not not RB 3278 11 12 added add VBN 3278 11 13 , , , 3278 11 14 nor nor CC 3278 11 15 erroneous erroneous JJ 3278 11 16 replacements replacement NNS 3278 11 17 made make VBN 3278 11 18 of of IN 3278 11 19 record record NN 3278 11 20 pairs pair NNS 3278 11 21 that that WDT 3278 11 22 are be VBP 3278 11 23 not not RB 3278 11 24 really really RB 3278 11 25 equivalent equivalent JJ 3278 11 26 . . . 3278 12 1 OCLC OCLC NNP 3278 12 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 12 3 Online Online NNP 3278 12 4 Computer Computer NNP 3278 12 5 Library Library NNP 3278 12 6 Center Center NNP 3278 12 7 , , , 3278 12 8 Inc. Inc. NNP 3278 12 9 ) ) -RRB- 3278 12 10 is be VBZ 3278 12 11 a a DT 3278 12 12 non­ non­ NNP 3278 12 13 profit profit NN 3278 12 14 organization organization NN 3278 12 15 serving serve VBG 3278 12 16 member member NN 3278 12 17 libraries library NNS 3278 12 18 and and CC 3278 12 19 related related JJ 3278 12 20 institutions institution NNS 3278 12 21 throughout throughout IN 3278 12 22 the the DT 3278 12 23 world world NN 3278 12 24 . . . 3278 13 1 It -PRON- PRP 3278 13 2 is be VBZ 3278 13 3 the the DT 3278 13 4 chief chief JJ 3278 13 5 database database NN 3278 13 6 capital capital NN 3278 13 7 of of IN 3278 13 8 the the DT 3278 13 9 organization organization NN 3278 13 10 , , , 3278 13 11 and and CC 3278 13 12 it -PRON- PRP 3278 13 13 is be VBZ 3278 13 14 “ " `` 3278 13 15 owned own VBN 3278 13 16 ” " '' 3278 13 17 in in IN 3278 13 18 a a DT 3278 13 19 sense sense NN 3278 13 20 by by IN 3278 13 21 the the DT 3278 13 22 member member NN 3278 13 23 libraries library NNS 3278 13 24 worldwide worldwide RB 3278 13 25 that that IN 3278 13 26 use use VBP 3278 13 27 and and CC 3278 13 28 contribute contribute VBP 3278 13 29 to to IN 3278 13 30 it -PRON- PRP 3278 13 31 . . . 3278 14 1 At at IN 3278 14 2 this this DT 3278 14 3 writing writing NN 3278 14 4 , , , 3278 14 5 it -PRON- PRP 3278 14 6 contains contain VBZ 3278 14 7 over over IN 3278 14 8 seventy­three seventy­three CD 3278 14 9 mil­ mil­ NNP 3278 14 10 lion lion NN 3278 14 11 records record NNS 3278 14 12 . . . 3278 15 1 This this DT 3278 15 2 discussion discussion NN 3278 15 3 focuses focus VBZ 3278 15 4 chiefly chiefly RB 3278 15 5 on on IN 3278 15 6 OCLC oclc NN 3278 15 7 ’s ’s POS 3278 15 8 Extended extend VBN 3278 15 9 WorldCat WorldCat NNP 3278 15 10 ( ( -LRB- 3278 15 11 XWC XWC NNP 3278 15 12 ) ) -RRB- 3278 15 13 , , , 3278 15 14 though though IN 3278 15 15 many many JJ 3278 15 16 of of IN 3278 15 17 the the DT 3278 15 18 issues issue NNS 3278 15 19 are be VBP 3278 15 20 common common JJ 3278 15 21 to to IN 3278 15 22 other other JJ 3278 15 23 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 15 24 databases database NNS 3278 15 25 . . . 3278 16 1 Examples example NNS 3278 16 2 of of IN 3278 16 3 these these DT 3278 16 4 include include VBP 3278 16 5 the the DT 3278 16 6 Research Research NNP 3278 16 7 Libraries Libraries NNP 3278 16 8 Group Group NNP 3278 16 9 ’s ’s POS 3278 16 10 Research Research NNP 3278 16 11 Libraries Libraries NNP 3278 16 12 Information Information NNP 3278 16 13 Network Network NNP 3278 16 14 ( ( -LRB- 3278 16 15 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 16 16 ) ) -RRB- 3278 16 17 database database NN 3278 16 18 , , , 3278 16 19 PICA PICA NNP 3278 16 20 ( ( -LRB- 3278 16 21 a a DT 3278 16 22 European european JJ 3278 16 23 cooperative cooperative NN 3278 16 24 of of IN 3278 16 25 libraries library NNS 3278 16 26 headquartered headquarter VBN 3278 16 27 in in IN 3278 16 28 the the DT 3278 16 29 Netherlands Netherlands NNP 3278 16 30 ) ) -RRB- 3278 16 31 , , , 3278 16 32 and and CC 3278 16 33 other other JJ 3278 16 34 union union NN 3278 16 35 catalogs catalog NNS 3278 16 36 . . . 3278 17 1 The the DT 3278 17 2 literature literature NN 3278 17 3 will will MD 3278 17 4 demonstrate demonstrate VB 3278 17 5 that that IN 3278 17 6 the the DT 3278 17 7 problems problem NNS 3278 17 8 described describe VBN 3278 17 9 exist exist VBP 3278 17 10 in in IN 3278 17 11 many many JJ 3278 17 12 if if IN 3278 17 13 not not RB 3278 17 14 most most RBS 3278 17 15 large large JJ 3278 17 16 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 17 17 databases database NNS 3278 17 18 . . . 3278 17 19 The the DT 3278 17 20 database database NN 3278 17 21 contents content NNS 3278 17 22 are be VBP 3278 17 23 representations representation NNS 3278 17 24 or or CC 3278 17 25 surrogates surrogate NNS 3278 17 26 of of IN 3278 17 27 the the DT 3278 17 28 objects object NNS 3278 17 29 in in IN 3278 17 30 shared shared JJ 3278 17 31 collections collection NNS 3278 17 32 . . . 3278 18 1 Individual individual JJ 3278 18 2 records record NNS 3278 18 3 in in IN 3278 18 4 XWC XWC NNP 3278 18 5 are be VBP 3278 18 6 com­ com­ NNP 3278 18 7 plex plex NN 3278 18 8 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 18 9 representations representation NNS 3278 18 10 of of IN 3278 18 11 physical physical JJ 3278 18 12 or or CC 3278 18 13 virtual virtual JJ 3278 18 14 objects object NNS 3278 18 15 — — : 3278 18 16 books book NNS 3278 18 17 , , , 3278 18 18 films film NNS 3278 18 19 , , , 3278 18 20 URLs url NNS 3278 18 21 , , , 3278 18 22 maps map NNS 3278 18 23 , , , 3278 18 24 slides slide NNS 3278 18 25 , , , 3278 18 26 and and CC 3278 18 27 much much RB 3278 18 28 more more JJR 3278 18 29 . . . 3278 19 1 Each each DT 3278 19 2 of of IN 3278 19 3 these these DT 3278 19 4 records record NNS 3278 19 5 consists consist VBZ 3278 19 6 of of IN 3278 19 7 metadata metadata NN 3278 19 8 , , , 3278 19 9 i.e. i.e. FW 3278 19 10 , , , 3278 19 11 “ " `` 3278 19 12 structured structured JJ 3278 19 13 information information NN 3278 19 14 that that WDT 3278 19 15 describes describe VBZ 3278 19 16 , , , 3278 19 17 explains explain VBZ 3278 19 18 , , , 3278 19 19 locates locate NNS 3278 19 20 , , , 3278 19 21 or or CC 3278 19 22 otherwise otherwise RB 3278 19 23 makes make VBZ 3278 19 24 it -PRON- PRP 3278 19 25 easier easy JJR 3278 19 26 to to TO 3278 19 27 retrieve retrieve VB 3278 19 28 , , , 3278 19 29 use use VB 3278 19 30 , , , 3278 19 31 or or CC 3278 19 32 manage manage VB 3278 19 33 an an DT 3278 19 34 information information NN 3278 19 35 resource”1(appendix resource”1(appendix NN 3278 19 36 A a NN 3278 19 37 ) ) -RRB- 3278 19 38 . . . 3278 20 1 The the DT 3278 20 2 records record NNS 3278 20 3 use use VBP 3278 20 4 an an DT 3278 20 5 XML xml NN 3278 20 6 varia­ varia­ NN 3278 20 7 tion tion NN 3278 20 8 of of IN 3278 20 9 the the DT 3278 20 10 MARC MARC NNP 3278 20 11 communications communication NNS 3278 20 12 format.2 format.2 CD 3278 20 13 For for IN 3278 20 14 example example NN 3278 20 15 , , , 3278 20 16 a a DT 3278 20 17 record record NN 3278 20 18 for for IN 3278 20 19 a a DT 3278 20 20 book book NN 3278 20 21 might may MD 3278 20 22 typically typically RB 3278 20 23 contain contain VB 3278 20 24 such such JJ 3278 20 25 fields field NNS 3278 20 26 for for IN 3278 20 27 author author NN 3278 20 28 , , , 3278 20 29 title title NN 3278 20 30 , , , 3278 20 31 publisher publisher NN 3278 20 32 , , , 3278 20 33 and and CC 3278 20 34 date date NN 3278 20 35 , , , 3278 20 36 and and CC 3278 20 37 many many JJ 3278 20 38 more more JJR 3278 20 39 in in IN 3278 20 40 addi­ addi­ NN 3278 20 41 tion tion NN 3278 20 42 . . . 3278 21 1 The the DT 3278 21 2 representation representation NN 3278 21 3 of of IN 3278 21 4 any any DT 3278 21 5 one one CD 3278 21 6 object object NN 3278 21 7 can can MD 3278 21 8 be be VB 3278 21 9 quite quite RB 3278 21 10 com­ com­ NNP 3278 21 11 plex plex NN 3278 21 12 , , , 3278 21 13 containing contain VBG 3278 21 14 scores score NNS 3278 21 15 of of IN 3278 21 16 fields field NNS 3278 21 17 and and CC 3278 21 18 subfields subfield NNS 3278 21 19 . . . 3278 22 1 Such such PDT 3278 22 2 a a DT 3278 22 3 record record NN 3278 22 4 may may MD 3278 22 5 be be VB 3278 22 6 quite quite RB 3278 22 7 brief brief JJ 3278 22 8 , , , 3278 22 9 or or CC 3278 22 10 several several JJ 3278 22 11 thousand thousand CD 3278 22 12 characters character NNS 3278 22 13 long long RB 3278 22 14 . . . 3278 23 1 The the DT 3278 23 2 depth depth NN 3278 23 3 and and CC 3278 23 4 richness richness NN 3278 23 5 of of IN 3278 23 6 the the DT 3278 23 7 records record NNS 3278 23 8 varies vary VBZ 3278 23 9 enormously enormously RB 3278 23 10 . . . 3278 24 1 They -PRON- PRP 3278 24 2 may may MD 3278 24 3 describe describe VB 3278 24 4 materials material NNS 3278 24 5 in in IN 3278 24 6 more more JJR 3278 24 7 than than IN 3278 24 8 450 450 CD 3278 24 9 languages language NNS 3278 24 10 . . . 3278 25 1 This this DT 3278 25 2 is be VBZ 3278 25 3 a a DT 3278 25 4 database database NN 3278 25 5 against against IN 3278 25 6 which which WDT 3278 25 7 millions million NNS 3278 25 8 of of IN 3278 25 9 searches search NNS 3278 25 10 and and CC 3278 25 11 millions million NNS 3278 25 12 of of IN 3278 25 13 records record NNS 3278 25 14 are be VBP 3278 25 15 processed process VBN 3278 25 16 , , , 3278 25 17 each each DT 3278 25 18 month month NN 3278 25 19 . . . 3278 26 1 Why why WRB 3278 26 2 is be VBZ 3278 26 3 matching match VBG 3278 26 4 a a DT 3278 26 5 challenge challenge NN 3278 26 6 ? ? . 3278 27 1 Two two CD 3278 27 2 records record NNS 3278 27 3 describing describe VBG 3278 27 4 the the DT 3278 27 5 same same JJ 3278 27 6 intellectual intellectual JJ 3278 27 7 creation creation NN 3278 27 8 or or CC 3278 27 9 work work NN 3278 27 10 ( ( -LRB- 3278 27 11 e.g. e.g. RB 3278 27 12 , , , 3278 27 13 Shakespeare Shakespeare NNP 3278 27 14 ’s ’s NNP 3278 27 15 Othello Othello NNP 3278 27 16 ) ) -RRB- 3278 27 17 can can MD 3278 27 18 vary vary VB 3278 27 19 by by IN 3278 27 20 physical physical JJ 3278 27 21 form form NN 3278 27 22 and and CC 3278 27 23 other other JJ 3278 27 24 attributes attribute NNS 3278 27 25 . . . 3278 28 1 Two two CD 3278 28 2 records record NNS 3278 28 3 describing describe VBG 3278 28 4 both both CC 3278 28 5 the the DT 3278 28 6 same same JJ 3278 28 7 work work NN 3278 28 8 and and CC 3278 28 9 exactly exactly RB 3278 28 10 the the DT 3278 28 11 same same JJ 3278 28 12 form form NN 3278 28 13 can can MD 3278 28 14 differ differ VB 3278 28 15 from from IN 3278 28 16 each each DT 3278 28 17 other other JJ 3278 28 18 if if IN 3278 28 19 the the DT 3278 28 20 records record NNS 3278 28 21 were be VBD 3278 28 22 created create VBN 3278 28 23 under under IN 3278 28 24 different different JJ 3278 28 25 rules rule NNS 3278 28 26 of of IN 3278 28 27 record record JJ 3278 28 28 description description NN 3278 28 29 ( ( -LRB- 3278 28 30 catalog­ catalog­ NNP 3278 28 31 ing ing NN 3278 28 32 ) ) -RRB- 3278 28 33 . . . 3278 29 1 Two two CD 3278 29 2 records record NNS 3278 29 3 intended intend VBN 3278 29 4 to to TO 3278 29 5 describe describe VB 3278 29 6 the the DT 3278 29 7 same same JJ 3278 29 8 object object NN 3278 29 9 can can MD 3278 29 10 vary vary VB 3278 29 11 unintentionally unintentionally RB 3278 29 12 if if IN 3278 29 13 typographical typographical JJ 3278 29 14 or or CC 3278 29 15 other other JJ 3278 29 16 entry entry NN 3278 29 17 errors error NNS 3278 29 18 are be VBP 3278 29 19 present present JJ 3278 29 20 in in IN 3278 29 21 one one CD 3278 29 22 or or CC 3278 29 23 both both DT 3278 29 24 . . . 3278 30 1 Thus thus RB 3278 30 2 sorting sort VBG 3278 30 3 out out RP 3278 30 4 significant significant JJ 3278 30 5 from from IN 3278 30 6 insignificant insignificant JJ 3278 30 7 differences difference NNS 3278 30 8 is be VBZ 3278 30 9 critical critical JJ 3278 30 10 . . . 3278 31 1 An an DT 3278 31 2 example example NN 3278 31 3 of of IN 3278 31 4 the the DT 3278 31 5 challenges challenge NNS 3278 31 6 of of IN 3278 31 7 developing develop VBG 3278 31 8 matching match VBG 3278 31 9 software software NN 3278 31 10 in in IN 3278 31 11 the the DT 3278 31 12 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 31 13 Capture Capture NNP 3278 31 14 Project Project NNP 3278 31 15 is be VBZ 3278 31 16 described describe VBN 3278 31 17 elsewhere.3 elsewhere.3 IN 3278 31 18 The the DT 3278 31 19 scope scope NN 3278 31 20 of of IN 3278 31 21 misinformation misinformation NN 3278 31 22 is be VBZ 3278 31 23 limited limit VBN 3278 31 24 to to IN 3278 31 25 information information NN 3278 31 26 storage storage NN 3278 31 27 and and CC 3278 31 28 retrieval retrieval NN 3278 31 29 , , , 3278 31 30 and and CC 3278 31 31 specifically specifically RB 3278 31 32 to to IN 3278 31 33 comparison comparison NN 3278 31 34 of of IN 3278 31 35 incoming incoming JJ 3278 31 36 records record NNS 3278 31 37 to to TO 3278 31 38 candidate candidate VB 3278 31 39 matches match NNS 3278 31 40 in in IN 3278 31 41 the the DT 3278 31 42 database database NN 3278 31 43 . . . 3278 32 1 The the DT 3278 32 2 authors author NNS 3278 32 3 define define VBP 3278 32 4 misinformation misinformation NN 3278 32 5 as as IN 3278 32 6 follows follow VBZ 3278 32 7 : : : 3278 32 8 1 1 CD 3278 32 9 . . . 3278 33 1 Anything anything NN 3278 33 2 that that WDT 3278 33 3 can can MD 3278 33 4 cause cause VB 3278 33 5 two two CD 3278 33 6 database database NN 3278 33 7 records record NNS 3278 33 8 , , , 3278 33 9 i.e. i.e. FW 3278 33 10 , , , 3278 33 11 representations representation NNS 3278 33 12 of of IN 3278 33 13 different different JJ 3278 33 14 items item NNS 3278 33 15 to to TO 3278 33 16 be be VB 3278 33 17 mistaken mistake VBN 3278 33 18 as as IN 3278 33 19 representations representation NNS 3278 33 20 of of IN 3278 33 21 the the DT 3278 33 22 same same JJ 3278 33 23 item item NN 3278 33 24 . . . 3278 34 1 These these DT 3278 34 2 can can MD 3278 34 3 lead lead VB 3278 34 4 to to IN 3278 34 5 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 3278 34 6 merging merging NN 3278 34 7 or or CC 3278 34 8 updates update NNS 3278 34 9 . . . 3278 35 1 2 2 LS 3278 35 2 . . . 3278 36 1 The the DT 3278 36 2 effect effect NN 3278 36 3 of of IN 3278 36 4 techniques technique NNS 3278 36 5 or or CC 3278 36 6 processes process NNS 3278 36 7 of of IN 3278 36 8 search search NN 3278 36 9 that that WDT 3278 36 10 can can MD 3278 36 11 obscure obscure VB 3278 36 12 distinctions distinction NNS 3278 36 13 in in IN 3278 36 14 differing differ VBG 3278 36 15 items item NNS 3278 36 16 . . . 3278 37 1 3 3 LS 3278 37 2 . . . 3278 38 1 Any any DT 3278 38 2 case case NN 3278 38 3 where where WRB 3278 38 4 matching matching NN 3278 38 5 misses miss VBZ 3278 38 6 an an DT 3278 38 7 appropriate appropriate JJ 3278 38 8 match match NN 3278 38 9 due due IN 3278 38 10 to to IN 3278 38 11 nonsignificant nonsignificant JJ 3278 38 12 differences difference NNS 3278 38 13 in in IN 3278 38 14 two two CD 3278 38 15 records record NNS 3278 38 16 that that WDT 3278 38 17 really really RB 3278 38 18 represent represent VBP 3278 38 19 the the DT 3278 38 20 same same JJ 3278 38 21 item item NN 3278 38 22 . . . 3278 39 1 Note note VB 3278 39 2 that that DT 3278 39 3 disinformation disinformation NN 3278 39 4 ( ( -LRB- 3278 39 5 the the DT 3278 39 6 intentional intentional JJ 3278 39 7 effort effort NN 3278 39 8 to to IN 3278 39 9 mis­ mis­ XX 3278 39 10 represent represent VB 3278 39 11 ) ) -RRB- 3278 39 12 is be VBZ 3278 39 13 not not RB 3278 39 14 considered consider VBN 3278 39 15 in in IN 3278 39 16 scope scope NN 3278 39 17 for for IN 3278 39 18 this this DT 3278 39 19 discussion discussion NN 3278 39 20 . . . 3278 40 1 The the DT 3278 40 2 assumption assumption NN 3278 40 3 is be VBZ 3278 40 4 that that IN 3278 40 5 cooperation cooperation NN 3278 40 6 is be VBZ 3278 40 7 in in IN 3278 40 8 the the DT 3278 40 9 interests interest NNS 3278 40 10 of of IN 3278 40 11 all all DT 3278 40 12 parties party NNS 3278 40 13 contributing contribute VBG 3278 40 14 to to IN 3278 40 15 a a DT 3278 40 16 shared shared JJ 3278 40 17 database database NN 3278 40 18 . . . 3278 41 1 We -PRON- PRP 3278 41 2 do do VBP 3278 41 3 not not RB 3278 41 4 assume assume VB 3278 41 5 that that IN 3278 41 6 all all DT 3278 41 7 institutions institution NNS 3278 41 8 sharing share VBG 3278 41 9 the the DT 3278 41 10 database database NN 3278 41 11 have have VBP 3278 41 12 the the DT 3278 41 13 same same JJ 3278 41 14 goals goal NNS 3278 41 15 . . . 3278 42 1 MISINFORMATION MISINFORMATION NNP 3278 42 2 AND and CC 3278 42 3 BIAS bias NN 3278 42 4 IN in IN 3278 42 5 METADATA METADATA NNP 3278 42 6 PROCESSING PROCESSING NNP 3278 42 7 | | CD 3278 42 8 THORNBuRG THORNBuRG NNS 3278 42 9 AND and CC 3278 42 10 OSkINS OSkINS NNP 3278 42 11 15 15 CD 3278 42 12 Misinformation Misinformation NNP 3278 42 13 and and CC 3278 42 14 Bias Bias NNP 3278 42 15 in in IN 3278 42 16 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 42 17 Processing processing NN 3278 42 18 : : : 3278 42 19 Matching match VBG 3278 42 20 in in IN 3278 42 21 Large large JJ 3278 42 22 Databases database NNS 3278 42 23 Gail Gail NNP 3278 42 24 Thornburg Thornburg NNP 3278 42 25 and and CC 3278 42 26 W. W. NNP 3278 42 27 Michael Michael NNP 3278 42 28 Oskins Oskins NNP 3278 42 29 Gail Gail NNP 3278 42 30 Thornburg Thornburg NNP 3278 42 31 ( ( -LRB- 3278 42 32 thornbug@oclc.org thornbug@oclc.org NN 3278 42 33 ) ) -RRB- 3278 42 34 has have VBZ 3278 42 35 taught teach VBN 3278 42 36 at at IN 3278 42 37 the the DT 3278 42 38 University University NNP 3278 42 39 of of IN 3278 42 40 Maryland Maryland NNP 3278 42 41 and and CC 3278 42 42 the the DT 3278 42 43 University University NNP 3278 42 44 of of IN 3278 42 45 Illinois Illinois NNP 3278 42 46 , , , 3278 42 47 and and CC 3278 42 48 served serve VBD 3278 42 49 as as IN 3278 42 50 an an DT 3278 42 51 Adjunct adjunct JJ 3278 42 52 Professor professor NN 3278 42 53 at at IN 3278 42 54 Kent Kent NNP 3278 42 55 State State NNP 3278 42 56 University University NNP 3278 42 57 , , , 3278 42 58 and and CC 3278 42 59 as as IN 3278 42 60 a a DT 3278 42 61 senior senior JJ 3278 42 62 - - HYPH 3278 42 63 level level NN 3278 42 64 Software Software NNP 3278 42 65 Engineer engineer NN 3278 42 66 at at IN 3278 42 67 OCLC oclc NN 3278 42 68 . . . 3278 43 1 W. W. NNP 3278 43 2 Michael Michael NNP 3278 43 3 Oskins Oskins NNP 3278 43 4 ( ( -LRB- 3278 43 5 oskins@oclc.org oskins@oclc.org NNP 3278 43 6 ) ) -RRB- 3278 43 7 has have VBZ 3278 43 8 worked work VBN 3278 43 9 as as IN 3278 43 10 a a DT 3278 43 11 Developer Developer NNP 3278 43 12 and and CC 3278 43 13 Researcher researcher NN 3278 43 14 at at IN 3278 43 15 OCLC oclc NN 3278 43 16 for for IN 3278 43 17 twenty twenty CD 3278 43 18 years year NNS 3278 43 19 . . . 3278 44 1 16 16 CD 3278 44 2 INFORMATION information NN 3278 44 3 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3278 44 4 AND and CC 3278 44 5 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 44 6 | | NNP 3278 44 7 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 44 8 200716 200716 CD 3278 44 9 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3278 44 10 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3278 44 11 AND and CC 3278 44 12 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 44 13 | | NNP 3278 44 14 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 44 15 2007 2007 CD 3278 44 16 What what WP 3278 44 17 is be VBZ 3278 44 18 bias bias NN 3278 44 19 ? ? . 3278 45 1 Bias Bias NNP 3278 45 2 can can MD 3278 45 3 be be VB 3278 45 4 defined define VBN 3278 45 5 as as IN 3278 45 6 factors factor NNS 3278 45 7 in in IN 3278 45 8 the the DT 3278 45 9 creation creation NN 3278 45 10 or or CC 3278 45 11 processing processing NN 3278 45 12 of of IN 3278 45 13 database database NN 3278 45 14 records record NNS 3278 45 15 that that WDT 3278 45 16 feed feed VBP 3278 45 17 on on IN 3278 45 18 misinformation misinformation NN 3278 45 19 or or CC 3278 45 20 missing miss VBG 3278 45 21 information information NN 3278 45 22 , , , 3278 45 23 and and CC 3278 45 24 skew skew JJ 3278 45 25 charac­ charac­ NN 3278 45 26 terizations terization NNS 3278 45 27 of of IN 3278 45 28 the the DT 3278 45 29 database database NN 3278 45 30 records record NNS 3278 45 31 in in IN 3278 45 32 question question NN 3278 45 33 . . . 3278 46 1 Context context NN 3278 46 2 — — : 3278 46 3 Matching matching NN 3278 46 4 and and CC 3278 46 5 bias bias NN 3278 46 6 How how WRB 3278 46 7 are be VBP 3278 46 8 matching match VBG 3278 46 9 and and CC 3278 46 10 bias bias NN 3278 46 11 related relate VBN 3278 46 12 to to IN 3278 46 13 each each DT 3278 46 14 other other JJ 3278 46 15 ? ? . 3278 47 1 The the DT 3278 47 2 growth growth NN 3278 47 3 of of IN 3278 47 4 a a DT 3278 47 5 database database NN 3278 47 6 is be VBZ 3278 47 7 in in IN 3278 47 8 part part NN 3278 47 9 a a DT 3278 47 10 function function NN 3278 47 11 of of IN 3278 47 12 the the DT 3278 47 13 matching matching NN 3278 47 14 process process NN 3278 47 15 . . . 3278 48 1 If if IN 3278 48 2 matching matching NN 3278 48 3 is be VBZ 3278 48 4 not not RB 3278 48 5 tuned tune VBN 3278 48 6 correctly correctly RB 3278 48 7 , , , 3278 48 8 the the DT 3278 48 9 database database NN 3278 48 10 can can MD 3278 48 11 grow grow VB 3278 48 12 or or CC 3278 48 13 change change VB 3278 48 14 in in IN 3278 48 15 nonoptimal nonoptimal JJ 3278 48 16 ways way NNS 3278 48 17 . . . 3278 49 1 Another another DT 3278 49 2 way way NN 3278 49 3 to to TO 3278 49 4 look look VB 3278 49 5 at at IN 3278 49 6 the the DT 3278 49 7 problem problem NN 3278 49 8 is be VBZ 3278 49 9 to to TO 3278 49 10 consider consider VB 3278 49 11 the the DT 3278 49 12 goal goal NN 3278 49 13 of of IN 3278 49 14 success success NN 3278 49 15 in in IN 3278 49 16 searching search VBG 3278 49 17 , , , 3278 49 18 and and CC 3278 49 19 the the DT 3278 49 20 need need NN 3278 49 21 to to TO 3278 49 22 know know VB 3278 49 23 when when WRB 3278 49 24 to to TO 3278 49 25 stop stop VB 3278 49 26 . . . 3278 50 1 Human human JJ 3278 50 2 beings being NNS 3278 50 3 recognize recognize VBP 3278 50 4 that that IN 3278 50 5 failure failure NN 3278 50 6 to to TO 3278 50 7 find find VB 3278 50 8 the the DT 3278 50 9 best good JJS 3278 50 10 information information NN 3278 50 11 for for IN 3278 50 12 a a DT 3278 50 13 given give VBN 3278 50 14 problem problem NN 3278 50 15 may may MD 3278 50 16 be be VB 3278 50 17 costly costly JJ 3278 50 18 . . . 3278 51 1 Finding find VBG 3278 51 2 the the DT 3278 51 3 best good JJS 3278 51 4 information information NN 3278 51 5 when when WRB 3278 51 6 less less JJR 3278 51 7 would would MD 3278 51 8 suffice suffice VB 3278 51 9 may may MD 3278 51 10 also also RB 3278 51 11 be be VB 3278 51 12 costly costly JJ 3278 51 13 . . . 3278 52 1 Systems system NNS 3278 52 2 need need VBP 3278 52 3 to to TO 3278 52 4 know know VB 3278 52 5 this this DT 3278 52 6 . . . 3278 53 1 For for IN 3278 53 2 a a DT 3278 53 3 large large JJ 3278 53 4 shared share VBN 3278 53 5 data­ data­ NNP 3278 53 6 base base NN 3278 53 7 , , , 3278 53 8 hundreds hundred NNS 3278 53 9 of of IN 3278 53 10 thousands thousand NNS 3278 53 11 of of IN 3278 53 12 records record NNS 3278 53 13 may may MD 3278 53 14 be be VB 3278 53 15 processed process VBN 3278 53 16 in in IN 3278 53 17 a a DT 3278 53 18 day day NN 3278 53 19 ; ; : 3278 53 20 the the DT 3278 53 21 system system NN 3278 53 22 must must MD 3278 53 23 be be VB 3278 53 24 as as RB 3278 53 25 efficient efficient JJ 3278 53 26 as as IN 3278 53 27 possible possible JJ 3278 53 28 . . . 3278 54 1 What what WP 3278 54 2 are be VBP 3278 54 3 some some DT 3278 54 4 costs cost NNS 3278 54 5 ? ? . 3278 55 1 Fail fail VB 3278 55 2 to to TO 3278 55 3 match match VB 3278 55 4 when when WRB 3278 55 5 one one PRP 3278 55 6 should should MD 3278 55 7 , , , 3278 55 8 and and CC 3278 55 9 duplicates duplicate NNS 3278 55 10 may may MD 3278 55 11 proliferate proliferate VB 3278 55 12 in in IN 3278 55 13 the the DT 3278 55 14 database database NN 3278 55 15 . . . 3278 56 1 Match match VB 3278 56 2 badly badly RB 3278 56 3 , , , 3278 56 4 and and CC 3278 56 5 there there EX 3278 56 6 is be VBZ 3278 56 7 risk risk NN 3278 56 8 of of IN 3278 56 9 merging merge VBG 3278 56 10 multiple multiple JJ 3278 56 11 records record NNS 3278 56 12 that that WDT 3278 56 13 do do VBP 3278 56 14 not not RB 3278 56 15 represent represent VB 3278 56 16 the the DT 3278 56 17 same same JJ 3278 56 18 item item NN 3278 56 19 . . . 3278 57 1 A a DT 3278 57 2 system system NN 3278 57 3 of of IN 3278 57 4 matching matching NN 3278 57 5 can can MD 3278 57 6 fail fail VB 3278 57 7 in in IN 3278 57 8 more more JJR 3278 57 9 than than IN 3278 57 10 one one CD 3278 57 11 way way NN 3278 57 12 . . . 3278 58 1 Balance balance NN 3278 58 2 is be VBZ 3278 58 3 needed need VBN 3278 58 4 . . . 3278 59 1 1 1 LS 3278 59 2 . . . 3278 60 1 Searches search NNS 3278 60 2 , , , 3278 60 3 which which WDT 3278 60 4 are be VBP 3278 60 5 based base VBN 3278 60 6 on on IN 3278 60 7 data datum NNS 3278 60 8 in in IN 3278 60 9 the the DT 3278 60 10 incom­ incom­ NNP 3278 60 11 ing ing NN 3278 60 12 record record NN 3278 60 13 , , , 3278 60 14 may may MD 3278 60 15 be be VB 3278 60 16 too too RB 3278 60 17 precise precise JJ 3278 60 18 to to TO 3278 60 19 find find VB 3278 60 20 legitimate legitimate JJ 3278 60 21 matches match NNS 3278 60 22 . . . 3278 61 1 Loosen loosen VB 3278 61 2 the the DT 3278 61 3 criteria criterion NNS 3278 61 4 too too RB 3278 61 5 much much RB 3278 61 6 , , , 3278 61 7 and and CC 3278 61 8 the the DT 3278 61 9 search search NN 3278 61 10 may may MD 3278 61 11 return return VB 3278 61 12 too too RB 3278 61 13 many many JJ 3278 61 14 records record NNS 3278 61 15 to to TO 3278 61 16 compare compare VB 3278 61 17 . . . 3278 62 1 2 2 LS 3278 62 2 . . . 3278 63 1 Once once IN 3278 63 2 retrieved retrieve VBN 3278 63 3 , , , 3278 63 4 candidate candidate NN 3278 63 5 matches match NNS 3278 63 6 are be VBP 3278 63 7 evaluated evaluate VBN 3278 63 8 . . . 3278 64 1 Compare compare VB 3278 64 2 candidates candidate NNS 3278 64 3 too too RB 3278 64 4 narrowly narrowly RB 3278 64 5 , , , 3278 64 6 and and CC 3278 64 7 records record NNS 3278 64 8 with with IN 3278 64 9 insignificant insignificant JJ 3278 64 10 differences difference NNS 3278 64 11 will will MD 3278 64 12 be be VB 3278 64 13 rejected reject VBN 3278 64 14 . . . 3278 65 1 Fail fail VB 3278 65 2 to to TO 3278 65 3 take take VB 3278 65 4 note note NN 3278 65 5 of of IN 3278 65 6 salient salient NN 3278 65 7 differences difference NNS 3278 65 8 between between IN 3278 65 9 incom­ incom­ NNP 3278 65 10 ing ing NN 3278 65 11 record record NN 3278 65 12 and and CC 3278 65 13 database database NN 3278 65 14 record record NN 3278 65 15 , , , 3278 65 16 and and CC 3278 65 17 the the DT 3278 65 18 match match NN 3278 65 19 will will MD 3278 65 20 be be VB 3278 65 21 wrong wrong JJ 3278 65 22 , , , 3278 65 23 undetected undetected JJ 3278 65 24 , , , 3278 65 25 and and CC 3278 65 26 potentially potentially RB 3278 65 27 hard hard JJ 3278 65 28 to to TO 3278 65 29 detect detect VB 3278 65 30 in in IN 3278 65 31 the the DT 3278 65 32 future future NN 3278 65 33 . . . 3278 66 1 The the DT 3278 66 2 goals goal NNS 3278 66 3 vary vary VBP 3278 66 4 in in IN 3278 66 5 different different JJ 3278 66 6 matching matching NN 3278 66 7 projects project NNS 3278 66 8 . . . 3278 67 1 For for IN 3278 67 2 some some DT 3278 67 3 projects project NNS 3278 67 4 , , , 3278 67 5 setting set VBG 3278 67 6 “ " `` 3278 67 7 holdings holding NNS 3278 67 8 , , , 3278 67 9 ” " '' 3278 67 10 the the DT 3278 67 11 indication indication NN 3278 67 12 that that IN 3278 67 13 a a DT 3278 67 14 member member NN 3278 67 15 library library NN 3278 67 16 owns own VBZ 3278 67 17 a a DT 3278 67 18 copy copy NN 3278 67 19 of of IN 3278 67 20 something something NN 3278 67 21 , , , 3278 67 22 is be VBZ 3278 67 23 the the DT 3278 67 24 main main JJ 3278 67 25 goal goal NN 3278 67 26 of of IN 3278 67 27 the the DT 3278 67 28 processing processing NN 3278 67 29 . . . 3278 68 1 This this DT 3278 68 2 does do VBZ 3278 68 3 not not RB 3278 68 4 involve involve VB 3278 68 5 adding add VBG 3278 68 6 , , , 3278 68 7 replacing replace VBG 3278 68 8 , , , 3278 68 9 or or CC 3278 68 10 merging merge VBG 3278 68 11 database database NN 3278 68 12 records record NNS 3278 68 13 . . . 3278 69 1 For for IN 3278 69 2 other other JJ 3278 69 3 projects project NNS 3278 69 4 , , , 3278 69 5 the the DT 3278 69 6 goal goal NN 3278 69 7 is be VBZ 3278 69 8 to to TO 3278 69 9 update update VB 3278 69 10 the the DT 3278 69 11 database database NN 3278 69 12 , , , 3278 69 13 either either CC 3278 69 14 by by IN 3278 69 15 replacing replace VBG 3278 69 16 matched match VBN 3278 69 17 records record NNS 3278 69 18 , , , 3278 69 19 merging merge VBG 3278 69 20 multiple multiple JJ 3278 69 21 duplicate duplicate VBP 3278 69 22 records record NNS 3278 69 23 into into IN 3278 69 24 one one CD 3278 69 25 , , , 3278 69 26 or or CC 3278 69 27 by by IN 3278 69 28 adding add VBG 3278 69 29 new new JJ 3278 69 30 records record NNS 3278 69 31 if if IN 3278 69 32 no no DT 3278 69 33 match match NN 3278 69 34 is be VBZ 3278 69 35 found find VBN 3278 69 36 in in IN 3278 69 37 the the DT 3278 69 38 database database NN 3278 69 39 . . . 3278 70 1 For for IN 3278 70 2 the the DT 3278 70 3 latter latter JJ 3278 70 4 , , , 3278 70 5 bad bad JJ 3278 70 6 matching matching NN 3278 70 7 could could MD 3278 70 8 compromise compromise VB 3278 70 9 database database NN 3278 70 10 contents content NNS 3278 70 11 . . . 3278 71 1 n n NNP 3278 71 2 Background Background NNP 3278 71 3 Hickey Hickey NNP 3278 71 4 and and CC 3278 71 5 Rypka Rypka NNP 3278 71 6 provide provide VBP 3278 71 7 a a DT 3278 71 8 good good JJ 3278 71 9 review review NN 3278 71 10 of of IN 3278 71 11 the the DT 3278 71 12 problems problem NNS 3278 71 13 of of IN 3278 71 14 identifying identify VBG 3278 71 15 duplicates duplicate NNS 3278 71 16 and and CC 3278 71 17 the the DT 3278 71 18 implications implication NNS 3278 71 19 for for IN 3278 71 20 match­ match­ NNP 3278 71 21 ing ing NN 3278 71 22 software.4 software.4 CD 3278 71 23 Their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 71 24 study study NN 3278 71 25 notes note VBZ 3278 71 26 concerns concern NNS 3278 71 27 from from IN 3278 71 28 a a DT 3278 71 29 variety variety NN 3278 71 30 of of IN 3278 71 31 library library NN 3278 71 32 networks network NNS 3278 71 33 including include VBG 3278 71 34 that that DT 3278 71 35 of of IN 3278 71 36 the the DT 3278 71 37 University University NNP 3278 71 38 of of IN 3278 71 39 Toronto Toronto NNP 3278 71 40 ( ( -LRB- 3278 71 41 UTLAS UTLAS NNP 3278 71 42 ) ) -RRB- 3278 71 43 , , , 3278 71 44 Washington Washington NNP 3278 71 45 Library Library NNP 3278 71 46 Network Network NNP 3278 71 47 ( ( -LRB- 3278 71 48 WLN WLN NNP 3278 71 49 ) ) -RRB- 3278 71 50 , , , 3278 71 51 and and CC 3278 71 52 Research Research NNP 3278 71 53 Libraries Libraries NNP 3278 71 54 Group Group NNP 3278 71 55 ( ( -LRB- 3278 71 56 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 71 57 ) ) -RRB- 3278 71 58 . . . 3278 72 1 They -PRON- PRP 3278 72 2 also also RB 3278 72 3 refer­ refer­ VBZ 3278 72 4 ence ence NN 3278 72 5 studies study NNS 3278 72 6 on on IN 3278 72 7 duplicate duplicate JJ 3278 72 8 detection detection NN 3278 72 9 in in IN 3278 72 10 the the DT 3278 72 11 Illinois Illinois NNP 3278 72 12 state­ state­ NNP 3278 72 13 wide wide JJ 3278 72 14 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 72 15 database database NN 3278 72 16 and and CC 3278 72 17 at at IN 3278 72 18 Oak Oak NNP 3278 72 19 Ridge Ridge NNP 3278 72 20 National National NNP 3278 72 21 Laboratories Laboratories NNPS 3278 72 22 . . . 3278 73 1 Background Background NNP 3278 73 2 discussion discussion NN 3278 73 3 of of IN 3278 73 4 broader broad JJR 3278 73 5 misinfor­ misinfor­ CD 3278 73 6 mation mation NN 3278 73 7 issues issue NNS 3278 73 8 in in IN 3278 73 9 shared shared JJ 3278 73 10 library library NN 3278 73 11 catalogs catalog NNS 3278 73 12 can can MD 3278 73 13 be be VB 3278 73 14 found find VBN 3278 73 15 in in IN 3278 73 16 Bade Bade NNP 3278 73 17 ’s ’s POS 3278 73 18 paper.5 paper.5 NN 3278 73 19 A a DT 3278 73 20 good good JJ 3278 73 21 , , , 3278 73 22 though though IN 3278 73 23 dated date VBN 3278 73 24 , , , 3278 73 25 review review NN 3278 73 26 of of IN 3278 73 27 duplicate duplicate JJ 3278 73 28 record record NN 3278 73 29 problems problem NNS 3278 73 30 can can MD 3278 73 31 be be VB 3278 73 32 found find VBN 3278 73 33 in in IN 3278 73 34 the the DT 3278 73 35 O’Neill O’Neill NNP 3278 73 36 , , , 3278 73 37 Rogers Rogers NNP 3278 73 38 , , , 3278 73 39 and and CC 3278 73 40 Oskins Oskins NNP 3278 73 41 article.6 article.6 NNP 3278 73 42 The the DT 3278 73 43 authors author NNS 3278 73 44 discuss discuss VBP 3278 73 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 73 46 analysis analysis NN 3278 73 47 of of IN 3278 73 48 differences difference NNS 3278 73 49 in in IN 3278 73 50 records record NNS 3278 73 51 that that WDT 3278 73 52 are be VBP 3278 73 53 similar similar JJ 3278 73 54 but but CC 3278 73 55 not not RB 3278 73 56 identical identical JJ 3278 73 57 , , , 3278 73 58 and and CC 3278 73 59 which which WDT 3278 73 60 elements element NNS 3278 73 61 caused cause VBD 3278 73 62 failure failure NN 3278 73 63 to to TO 3278 73 64 match match VB 3278 73 65 two two CD 3278 73 66 records record NNS 3278 73 67 for for IN 3278 73 68 the the DT 3278 73 69 same same JJ 3278 73 70 item item NN 3278 73 71 . . . 3278 74 1 For for IN 3278 74 2 example example NN 3278 74 3 , , , 3278 74 4 when when WRB 3278 74 5 there there EX 3278 74 6 was be VBD 3278 74 7 only only RB 3278 74 8 one one CD 3278 74 9 differing differ VBG 3278 74 10 element element NN 3278 74 11 in in IN 3278 74 12 a a DT 3278 74 13 pair pair NN 3278 74 14 , , , 3278 74 15 they -PRON- PRP 3278 74 16 found find VBD 3278 74 17 that that IN 3278 74 18 element element NN 3278 74 19 was be VBD 3278 74 20 most most RBS 3278 74 21 often often RB 3278 74 22 publication publication NN 3278 74 23 date date NN 3278 74 24 . . . 3278 75 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 75 2 study study NN 3278 75 3 shows show VBZ 3278 75 4 the the DT 3278 75 5 difficulties difficulty NNS 3278 75 6 for for IN 3278 75 7 experts expert NNS 3278 75 8 to to TO 3278 75 9 determine determine VB 3278 75 10 with with IN 3278 75 11 certainty certainty NN 3278 75 12 that that IN 3278 75 13 a a DT 3278 75 14 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 75 15 record record NN 3278 75 16 is be VBZ 3278 75 17 for for IN 3278 75 18 the the DT 3278 75 19 same same JJ 3278 75 20 item item NN 3278 75 21 . . . 3278 76 1 Problems problem NNS 3278 76 2 of of IN 3278 76 3 typographical typographical JJ 3278 76 4 errors error NNS 3278 76 5 in in IN 3278 76 6 shared shared JJ 3278 76 7 biblio­ biblio­ NNP 3278 76 8 graphic graphic JJ 3278 76 9 records record NNS 3278 76 10 come come VBN 3278 76 11 under under IN 3278 76 12 discussion discussion NN 3278 76 13 by by IN 3278 76 14 Beall Beall NNP 3278 76 15 and and CC 3278 76 16 Kafadar.7 kafadar.7 $ 3278 76 17 Their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 76 18 study study NN 3278 76 19 of of IN 3278 76 20 copy copy NN 3278 76 21 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 76 22 errors error NNS 3278 76 23 found find VBD 3278 76 24 only only RB 3278 76 25 35.8 35.8 CD 3278 76 26 percent percent NN 3278 76 27 were be VBD 3278 76 28 corrected correct VBN 3278 76 29 later later RB 3278 76 30 by by IN 3278 76 31 libraries library NNS 3278 76 32 , , , 3278 76 33 though though IN 3278 76 34 the the DT 3278 76 35 ordinary ordinary JJ 3278 76 36 assumption assumption NN 3278 76 37 is be VBZ 3278 76 38 that that DT 3278 76 39 copy copy NN 3278 76 40 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 76 41 will will MD 3278 76 42 be be VB 3278 76 43 updated update VBN 3278 76 44 when when WRB 3278 76 45 more more JJR 3278 76 46 information information NN 3278 76 47 is be VBZ 3278 76 48 available available JJ 3278 76 49 for for IN 3278 76 50 an an DT 3278 76 51 item item NN 3278 76 52 . . . 3278 77 1 Pollock Pollock NNP 3278 77 2 and and CC 3278 77 3 Zamora Zamora NNP 3278 77 4 report report NN 3278 77 5 on on IN 3278 77 6 a a DT 3278 77 7 spelling spelling NN 3278 77 8 error error NN 3278 77 9 detection detection NN 3278 77 10 project project NN 3278 77 11 at at IN 3278 77 12 Chemical Chemical NNP 3278 77 13 Abstracts Abstracts NNPS 3278 77 14 Service Service NNP 3278 77 15 ( ( -LRB- 3278 77 16 CAS CAS NNP 3278 77 17 ) ) -RRB- 3278 77 18 and and CC 3278 77 19 charac­ charac­ NNP 3278 77 20 terize terize VBP 3278 77 21 the the DT 3278 77 22 types type NNS 3278 77 23 of of IN 3278 77 24 errors error NNS 3278 77 25 they -PRON- PRP 3278 77 26 found.8 found.8 CD 3278 77 27 Chemical Chemical NNP 3278 77 28 Abstracts Abstracts NNPS 3278 77 29 databases database NNS 3278 77 30 are be VBP 3278 77 31 among among IN 3278 77 32 the the DT 3278 77 33 most most RBS 3278 77 34 searched search VBN 3278 77 35 databases database NNS 3278 77 36 in in IN 3278 77 37 the the DT 3278 77 38 world world NN 3278 77 39 . . . 3278 78 1 CAS CAS NNP 3278 78 2 is be VBZ 3278 78 3 usually usually RB 3278 78 4 characterized characterize VBN 3278 78 5 as as IN 3278 78 6 a a DT 3278 78 7 set set NN 3278 78 8 of of IN 3278 78 9 sources source NNS 3278 78 10 with with IN 3278 78 11 considerable considerable JJ 3278 78 12 depth depth NN 3278 78 13 and and CC 3278 78 14 breadth breadth NN 3278 78 15 . . . 3278 79 1 Of of IN 3278 79 2 the the DT 3278 79 3 four four CD 3278 79 4 most most RBS 3278 79 5 common common JJ 3278 79 6 typographical typographical JJ 3278 79 7 errors error NNS 3278 79 8 they -PRON- PRP 3278 79 9 describe describe VBP 3278 79 10 , , , 3278 79 11 errors error NNS 3278 79 12 of of IN 3278 79 13 omission omission NN 3278 79 14 are be VBP 3278 79 15 most most RBS 3278 79 16 common common JJ 3278 79 17 , , , 3278 79 18 with with IN 3278 79 19 insertion insertion NN 3278 79 20 second second JJ 3278 79 21 , , , 3278 79 22 substitution substitution NN 3278 79 23 third third NN 3278 79 24 , , , 3278 79 25 and and CC 3278 79 26 transposition transposition NN 3278 79 27 fourth fourth RB 3278 79 28 . . . 3278 80 1 Over over IN 3278 80 2 90 90 CD 3278 80 3 percent percent NN 3278 80 4 of of IN 3278 80 5 the the DT 3278 80 6 errors error NNS 3278 80 7 they -PRON- PRP 3278 80 8 found find VBD 3278 80 9 were be VBD 3278 80 10 single single JJ 3278 80 11 letter letter NN 3278 80 12 errors error NNS 3278 80 13 . . . 3278 81 1 This this DT 3278 81 2 is be VBZ 3278 81 3 in in IN 3278 81 4 agreement agreement NN 3278 81 5 with with IN 3278 81 6 the the DT 3278 81 7 findings finding NNS 3278 81 8 of of IN 3278 81 9 O’Neill O’Neill NNP 3278 81 10 and and CC 3278 81 11 Aluri Aluri NNP 3278 81 12 , , , 3278 81 13 though though IN 3278 81 14 the the DT 3278 81 15 databases database NNS 3278 81 16 were be VBD 3278 81 17 substantially substantially RB 3278 81 18 different.9 different.9 NNS 3278 81 19 Another another DT 3278 81 20 study study NN 3278 81 21 on on IN 3278 81 22 moving­ moving­ CD 3278 81 23 image image NN 3278 81 24 materials material NNS 3278 81 25 focuses focus VBZ 3278 81 26 on on IN 3278 81 27 problems problem NNS 3278 81 28 of of IN 3278 81 29 near­equivalents near­equivalents NNP 3278 81 30 in in IN 3278 81 31 cataloging.10 cataloging.10 NNP 3278 81 32 Yee Yee NNP 3278 81 33 suggests suggest VBZ 3278 81 34 that that IN 3278 81 35 cataloging catalog VBG 3278 81 36 practice practice NN 3278 81 37 tends tend VBZ 3278 81 38 to to TO 3278 81 39 lead lead VB 3278 81 40 to to IN 3278 81 41 making make VBG 3278 81 42 too too RB 3278 81 43 many many JJ 3278 81 44 separate separate JJ 3278 81 45 records record NNS 3278 81 46 for for IN 3278 81 47 near near JJ 3278 81 48 equivalents equivalent NNS 3278 81 49 . . . 3278 82 1 Owen Owen NNP 3278 82 2 Gingerich Gingerich NNP 3278 82 3 provides provide VBZ 3278 82 4 insight insight NN 3278 82 5 in in IN 3278 82 6 the the DT 3278 82 7 use use NN 3278 82 8 of of IN 3278 82 9 holdings holding NNS 3278 82 10 information information NN 3278 82 11 in in IN 3278 82 12 OCLC OCLC NNP 3278 82 13 and and CC 3278 82 14 other other JJ 3278 82 15 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 82 16 utilities utility NNS 3278 82 17 such such JJ 3278 82 18 as as IN 3278 82 19 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 82 20 for for IN 3278 82 21 scholarly scholarly JJ 3278 82 22 research research NN 3278 82 23 in in IN 3278 82 24 locating locate VBG 3278 82 25 early early JJ 3278 82 26 editions edition NNS 3278 82 27 of of IN 3278 82 28 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 3278 82 29 ’ ' '' 3278 82 30 De De NNP 3278 82 31 Revolutionibus.11 Revolutionibus.11 NNP 3278 82 32 Among among IN 3278 82 33 other other JJ 3278 82 34 sources source NNS 3278 82 35 , , , 3278 82 36 he -PRON- PRP 3278 82 37 used use VBD 3278 82 38 holdings holding NNS 3278 82 39 information information NN 3278 82 40 in in IN 3278 82 41 multiple multiple JJ 3278 82 42 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 82 43 utilities utility NNS 3278 82 44 to to TO 3278 82 45 help help VB 3278 82 46 in in IN 3278 82 47 collecting collect VBG 3278 82 48 a a DT 3278 82 49 census census NN 3278 82 50 of of IN 3278 82 51 copies copy NNS 3278 82 52 of of IN 3278 82 53 De De NNP 3278 82 54 Revolutionibus Revolutionibus NNP 3278 82 55 , , , 3278 82 56 and and CC 3278 82 57 plotting plot VBG 3278 82 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 82 59 movements movement NNS 3278 82 60 through through IN 3278 82 61 Europe Europe NNP 3278 82 62 in in IN 3278 82 63 the the DT 3278 82 64 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 3278 82 65 century century NN 3278 82 66 . . . 3278 83 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 3278 83 2 article article NN 3278 83 3 high­ high­ NNP 3278 83 4 lights light VBZ 3278 83 5 the the DT 3278 83 6 importance importance NN 3278 83 7 of of IN 3278 83 8 distinguishing distinguish VBG 3278 83 9 very very RB 3278 83 10 similar similar JJ 3278 83 11 items item NNS 3278 83 12 for for IN 3278 83 13 scholarly scholarly JJ 3278 83 14 research research NN 3278 83 15 . . . 3278 84 1 Shedenhelm Shedenhelm NNP 3278 84 2 and and CC 3278 84 3 Burk Burk NNP 3278 84 4 discuss discuss VBP 3278 84 5 the the DT 3278 84 6 introduction introduction NN 3278 84 7 of of IN 3278 84 8 vendor vendor NN 3278 84 9 records record NNS 3278 84 10 into into IN 3278 84 11 OCLC oclc NN 3278 84 12 ’s ’s NN 3278 84 13 WorldCat WorldCat NNP 3278 84 14 database.12 database.12 NNP 3278 84 15 Their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 84 16 results result NNS 3278 84 17 indicate indicate VBP 3278 84 18 that that IN 3278 84 19 these these DT 3278 84 20 minimal­level minimal­level NNP 3278 84 21 records record NNS 3278 84 22 increase increase VBP 3278 84 23 the the DT 3278 84 24 duplication duplication NN 3278 84 25 rate rate NN 3278 84 26 within within IN 3278 84 27 the the DT 3278 84 28 database database NN 3278 84 29 and and CC 3278 84 30 can can MD 3278 84 31 be be VB 3278 84 32 costly costly JJ 3278 84 33 to to TO 3278 84 34 upgrade upgrade VB 3278 84 35 . . . 3278 85 1 ( ( -LRB- 3278 85 2 See see VB 3278 85 3 further further JJ 3278 85 4 discussion discussion NN 3278 85 5 in in IN 3278 85 6 the the DT 3278 85 7 section section NN 3278 85 8 Change Change NNP 3278 85 9 in in IN 3278 85 10 Contributor Contributor NNP 3278 85 11 Characteristics Characteristics NNP 3278 85 12 below below RB 3278 85 13 . . . 3278 85 14 ) ) -RRB- 3278 86 1 One one CD 3278 86 2 problem problem NN 3278 86 3 in in IN 3278 86 4 analysis analysis NN 3278 86 5 of of IN 3278 86 6 sources source NNS 3278 86 7 of of IN 3278 86 8 mismatch mismatch NN 3278 86 9 in in IN 3278 86 10 previous previous JJ 3278 86 11 studies study NNS 3278 86 12 is be VBZ 3278 86 13 that that IN 3278 86 14 there there EX 3278 86 15 is be VBZ 3278 86 16 no no DT 3278 86 17 good good JJ 3278 86 18 way way NN 3278 86 19 to to TO 3278 86 20 detect detect VB 3278 86 21 and and CC 3278 86 22 charac­ charac­ NNP 3278 86 23 PuBLIC public JJ 3278 86 24 LIBRARIES library NNS 3278 86 25 AND and CC 3278 86 26 INTERNET INTERNET NNP 3278 86 27 ACCESS ACCESS NNP 3278 86 28 | | NNS 3278 86 29 JAEGER jaeger NN 3278 86 30 , , , 3278 86 31 BERTOT bertot NN 3278 86 32 , , , 3278 86 33 MCCLuRE mcclure UH 3278 86 34 , , , 3278 86 35 AND and CC 3278 86 36 RODRIGuEz rodriguez NN 3278 86 37 17MISINFORMATION 17misinformation CD 3278 86 38 AND and CC 3278 86 39 BIAS BIAS NNP 3278 86 40 IN in IN 3278 86 41 METADATA METADATA NNP 3278 86 42 PROCESSING PROCESSING NNP 3278 86 43 | | CD 3278 86 44 THORNBuRG THORNBuRG NNS 3278 86 45 AND and CC 3278 86 46 OSkINS OSkINS NNP 3278 86 47 17 17 CD 3278 86 48 terize terize NN 3278 86 49 typos typo NNS 3278 86 50 that that WDT 3278 86 51 form form VBP 3278 86 52 real real JJ 3278 86 53 words word NNS 3278 86 54 . . . 3278 87 1 Jasco Jasco NNP 3278 87 2 reviews review VBZ 3278 87 3 studies study NNS 3278 87 4 characterizing characterize VBG 3278 87 5 types type NNS 3278 87 6 and and CC 3278 87 7 sources source NNS 3278 87 8 of of IN 3278 87 9 errors.13 errors.13 NNP 3278 87 10 Sheila Sheila NNP 3278 87 11 Intner Intner NNP 3278 87 12 compares compare VBZ 3278 87 13 the the DT 3278 87 14 quality quality NN 3278 87 15 issues issue NNS 3278 87 16 in in IN 3278 87 17 the the DT 3278 87 18 databases database NNS 3278 87 19 of of IN 3278 87 20 OCLC oclc NN 3278 87 21 and and CC 3278 87 22 the the DT 3278 87 23 Research Research NNP 3278 87 24 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3278 87 25 Group Group NNP 3278 87 26 ( ( -LRB- 3278 87 27 RLG RLG NNP 3278 87 28 ) ) -RRB- 3278 87 29 and and CC 3278 87 30 finds find VBZ 3278 87 31 the the DT 3278 87 32 issues issue NNS 3278 87 33 similar.14 similar.14 NNP 3278 87 34 Intner Intner NNP 3278 87 35 used use VBD 3278 87 36 matched match VBN 3278 87 37 samples sample NNS 3278 87 38 of of IN 3278 87 39 records record NNS 3278 87 40 from from IN 3278 87 41 both both CC 3278 87 42 WorldCat WorldCat NNP 3278 87 43 and and CC 3278 87 44 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 87 45 to to TO 3278 87 46 list list VB 3278 87 47 and and CC 3278 87 48 compare compare VB 3278 87 49 types type NNS 3278 87 50 of of IN 3278 87 51 errors error NNS 3278 87 52 in in IN 3278 87 53 the the DT 3278 87 54 records record NNS 3278 87 55 . . . 3278 88 1 She -PRON- PRP 3278 88 2 noted note VBD 3278 88 3 that that IN 3278 88 4 while while IN 3278 88 5 the the DT 3278 88 6 perception perception NN 3278 88 7 at at IN 3278 88 8 that that DT 3278 88 9 time time NN 3278 88 10 was be VBD 3278 88 11 that that IN 3278 88 12 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 88 13 had have VBD 3278 88 14 higher­quality higher­quality CD 3278 88 15 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 88 16 , , , 3278 88 17 the the DT 3278 88 18 differences difference NNS 3278 88 19 found find VBN 3278 88 20 were be VBD 3278 88 21 not not RB 3278 88 22 statistically statistically RB 3278 88 23 significant significant JJ 3278 88 24 . . . 3278 89 1 Jeffrey Jeffrey NNP 3278 89 2 Beall Beall NNP 3278 89 3 , , , 3278 89 4 while while IN 3278 89 5 focusing focus VBG 3278 89 6 in in IN 3278 89 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 3278 89 8 study study NN 3278 89 9 on on IN 3278 89 10 the the DT 3278 89 11 full­ full­ NNP 3278 89 12 text text NN 3278 89 13 online online JJ 3278 89 14 database database NN 3278 89 15 JSTOR JSTOR NNP 3278 89 16 , , , 3278 89 17 notes note VBZ 3278 89 18 the the DT 3278 89 19 commonality commonality NN 3278 89 20 of of IN 3278 89 21 problems problem NNS 3278 89 22 in in IN 3278 89 23 metadata metadata NN 3278 89 24 quality.15 quality.15 NNP 3278 89 25 In in IN 3278 89 26 addition addition NN 3278 89 27 , , , 3278 89 28 he -PRON- PRP 3278 89 29 discusses discuss VBZ 3278 89 30 the the DT 3278 89 31 special special JJ 3278 89 32 quality quality NN 3278 89 33 problems problem NNS 3278 89 34 in in IN 3278 89 35 a a DT 3278 89 36 database database NN 3278 89 37 of of IN 3278 89 38 scanned scan VBN 3278 89 39 images image NNS 3278 89 40 . . . 3278 90 1 The the DT 3278 90 2 scanning scanning NN 3278 90 3 software software NN 3278 90 4 itself -PRON- PRP 3278 90 5 may may MD 3278 90 6 introduce introduce VB 3278 90 7 typo­ typo­ NNP 3278 90 8 graphical graphical JJ 3278 90 9 errors error NNS 3278 90 10 . . . 3278 91 1 Like like IN 3278 91 2 XWC XWC NNP 3278 91 3 , , , 3278 91 4 the the DT 3278 91 5 database database NN 3278 91 6 changes change VBZ 3278 91 7 rapidly rapidly RB 3278 91 8 . . . 3278 92 1 O’Neill O’Neill NNP 3278 92 2 and and CC 3278 92 3 Visine­Goetz Visine­Goetz NNP 3278 92 4 present present VB 3278 92 5 a a DT 3278 92 6 survey survey NN 3278 92 7 of of IN 3278 92 8 quality quality NN 3278 92 9 con­ con­ NNS 3278 92 10 trol trol VBP 3278 92 11 issues issue NNS 3278 92 12 in in IN 3278 92 13 online online JJ 3278 92 14 databases.16 databases.16 NNP 3278 92 15 Their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 92 16 sections section NNS 3278 92 17 on on IN 3278 92 18 dupli­ dupli­ NNP 3278 92 19 cate cate NN 3278 92 20 detection detection NN 3278 92 21 and and CC 3278 92 22 on on IN 3278 92 23 matching match VBG 3278 92 24 algorithms algorithm NNS 3278 92 25 illustrate illustrate VBP 3278 92 26 the the DT 3278 92 27 commonalities commonality NNS 3278 92 28 of of IN 3278 92 29 these these DT 3278 92 30 problems problem NNS 3278 92 31 in in IN 3278 92 32 a a DT 3278 92 33 variety variety NN 3278 92 34 of of IN 3278 92 35 shared share VBN 3278 92 36 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 92 37 databases database NNS 3278 92 38 . . . 3278 93 1 They -PRON- PRP 3278 93 2 cite cite VBP 3278 93 3 variation variation NN 3278 93 4 in in IN 3278 93 5 title title NN 3278 93 6 as as IN 3278 93 7 the the DT 3278 93 8 most most RBS 3278 93 9 common common JJ 3278 93 10 reason reason NN 3278 93 11 for for IN 3278 93 12 failure failure NN 3278 93 13 to to TO 3278 93 14 identify identify VB 3278 93 15 a a DT 3278 93 16 duplicate duplicate JJ 3278 93 17 record record NN 3278 93 18 that that WDT 3278 93 19 should should MD 3278 93 20 match match VB 3278 93 21 . . . 3278 94 1 Variations variation NNS 3278 94 2 in in IN 3278 94 3 publisher publisher NN 3278 94 4 , , , 3278 94 5 names name NNS 3278 94 6 , , , 3278 94 7 and and CC 3278 94 8 pagination pagination NN 3278 94 9 were be VBD 3278 94 10 noted note VBN 3278 94 11 as as IN 3278 94 12 common common JJ 3278 94 13 . . . 3278 95 1 Lei Lei NNP 3278 95 2 Zeng Zeng NNP 3278 95 3 pres­ pres­ NNP 3278 95 4 ents ent VBZ 3278 95 5 a a DT 3278 95 6 study study NN 3278 95 7 of of IN 3278 95 8 Chinese chinese JJ 3278 95 9 language language NN 3278 95 10 records record NNS 3278 95 11 in in IN 3278 95 12 the the DT 3278 95 13 OCLC oclc NN 3278 95 14 and and CC 3278 95 15 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 95 16 databases.17 databases.17 NNP 3278 95 17 Zeng Zeng NNP 3278 95 18 discusses discuss VBZ 3278 95 19 quality quality NN 3278 95 20 problems problem NNS 3278 95 21 including include VBG 3278 95 22 ( ( -LRB- 3278 95 23 1 1 LS 3278 95 24 ) ) -RRB- 3278 95 25 format format NN 3278 95 26 errors error NNS 3278 95 27 such such JJ 3278 95 28 as as IN 3278 95 29 field field NN 3278 95 30 and and CC 3278 95 31 subfield subfield NN 3278 95 32 tagging tagging NN 3278 95 33 and and CC 3278 95 34 incorrect incorrect JJ 3278 95 35 punctuation punctuation NN 3278 95 36 ; ; : 3278 95 37 ( ( -LRB- 3278 95 38 2 2 LS 3278 95 39 ) ) -RRB- 3278 95 40 content content NN 3278 95 41 errors error NNS 3278 95 42 such such JJ 3278 95 43 as as IN 3278 95 44 missing miss VBG 3278 95 45 fields field NNS 3278 95 46 and and CC 3278 95 47 internal internal JJ 3278 95 48 record record NN 3278 95 49 inconsisten­ inconsisten­ NNP 3278 95 50 cies cie NNS 3278 95 51 ; ; , 3278 95 52 and and CC 3278 95 53 ( ( -LRB- 3278 95 54 3 3 LS 3278 95 55 ) ) -RRB- 3278 95 56 editing editing NN 3278 95 57 and and CC 3278 95 58 inputting inputte VBG 3278 95 59 errors error NNS 3278 95 60 such such JJ 3278 95 61 as as IN 3278 95 62 spacing spacing NN 3278 95 63 and and CC 3278 95 64 misspelling misspelling NN 3278 95 65 . . . 3278 96 1 Part part NN 3278 96 2 2 2 CD 3278 96 3 of of IN 3278 96 4 her -PRON- PRP$ 3278 96 5 study study NN 3278 96 6 presents present VBZ 3278 96 7 the the DT 3278 96 8 results result NNS 3278 96 9 of of IN 3278 96 10 the the DT 3278 96 11 prototype prototype NN 3278 96 12 rule­based rule­based NNP 3278 96 13 system system NN 3278 96 14 developed develop VBD 3278 96 15 to to TO 3278 96 16 catch catch VB 3278 96 17 such such JJ 3278 96 18 errors.18 errors.18 NNP 3278 96 19 While while IN 3278 96 20 the the DT 3278 96 21 author author NN 3278 96 22 refrains refrain VBZ 3278 96 23 from from IN 3278 96 24 comparing compare VBG 3278 96 25 the the DT 3278 96 26 quality quality NN 3278 96 27 of of IN 3278 96 28 OCLC oclc NN 3278 96 29 and and CC 3278 96 30 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 96 31 Chinese chinese JJ 3278 96 32 language language NN 3278 96 33 catalog catalog NN 3278 96 34 records record NNS 3278 96 35 , , , 3278 96 36 the the DT 3278 96 37 discussion discussion NN 3278 96 38 makes make VBZ 3278 96 39 clear clear JJ 3278 96 40 that that IN 3278 96 41 the the DT 3278 96 42 quality quality NN 3278 96 43 issues issue NNS 3278 96 44 are be VBP 3278 96 45 common common JJ 3278 96 46 to to IN 3278 96 47 a a DT 3278 96 48 number number NN 3278 96 49 of of IN 3278 96 50 online online JJ 3278 96 51 databases database NNS 3278 96 52 . . . 3278 97 1 More More JJR 3278 97 2 work work NN 3278 97 3 is be VBZ 3278 97 4 needed need VBN 3278 97 5 on on IN 3278 97 6 quality quality NN 3278 97 7 and and CC 3278 97 8 accuracy accuracy NN 3278 97 9 of of IN 3278 97 10 shared shared JJ 3278 97 11 records record NNS 3278 97 12 in in IN 3278 97 13 non­Roman non­roman NN 3278 97 14 scripts script NNS 3278 97 15 , , , 3278 97 16 or or CC 3278 97 17 in in IN 3278 97 18 other other JJ 3278 97 19 lan­ lan­ NNP 3278 97 20 guages guage NNS 3278 97 21 transliterated transliterate VBN 3278 97 22 to to IN 3278 97 23 Roman roman JJ 3278 97 24 script script NN 3278 97 25 . . . 3278 98 1 n n DT 3278 98 2 Types Types NNP 3278 98 3 of of IN 3278 98 4 bias bias NN 3278 98 5 to to TO 3278 98 6 be be VB 3278 98 7 considered consider VBN 3278 98 8 Specific specific JJ 3278 98 9 factors factor NNS 3278 98 10 that that WDT 3278 98 11 may may MD 3278 98 12 tend tend VB 3278 98 13 to to TO 3278 98 14 bias bias VB 3278 98 15 an an DT 3278 98 16 attempt attempt NN 3278 98 17 to to TO 3278 98 18 match match VB 3278 98 19 one one CD 3278 98 20 record record NN 3278 98 21 to to IN 3278 98 22 another another DT 3278 98 23 include include NN 3278 98 24 : : : 3278 98 25 1 1 LS 3278 98 26 . . . 3278 99 1 Violated violated JJ 3278 99 2 expectations expectation NNS 3278 99 3 — — : 3278 99 4 system system NN 3278 99 5 software software NN 3278 99 6 expects expect VBZ 3278 99 7 data datum NNS 3278 99 8 it -PRON- PRP 3278 99 9 does do VBZ 3278 99 10 not not RB 3278 99 11 receive receive VB 3278 99 12 , , , 3278 99 13 or or CC 3278 99 14 data datum NNS 3278 99 15 received receive VBN 3278 99 16 is be VBZ 3278 99 17 not not RB 3278 99 18 well well RB 3278 99 19 formed form VBN 3278 99 20 . . . 3278 100 1 2 2 LS 3278 100 2 . . . 3278 101 1 Temporal temporal JJ 3278 101 2 bias bias NN 3278 101 3 — — : 3278 101 4 changes change NNS 3278 101 5 in in IN 3278 101 6 rules rule NNS 3278 101 7 and and CC 3278 101 8 philosophies philosophy NNS 3278 101 9 of of IN 3278 101 10 record record NN 3278 101 11 creation creation NN 3278 101 12 over over IN 3278 101 13 time time NN 3278 101 14 . . . 3278 102 1 3 3 LS 3278 102 2 . . . 3278 103 1 Design design NN 3278 103 2 bias bias NN 3278 103 3 — — : 3278 103 4 choices choice NNS 3278 103 5 in in IN 3278 103 6 layout layout NN 3278 103 7 of of IN 3278 103 8 the the DT 3278 103 9 records record NNS 3278 103 10 , , , 3278 103 11 which which WDT 3278 103 12 favor favor VBP 3278 103 13 one one CD 3278 103 14 type type NN 3278 103 15 of of IN 3278 103 16 record record NN 3278 103 17 representation representation NN 3278 103 18 at at IN 3278 103 19 the the DT 3278 103 20 expense expense NN 3278 103 21 of of IN 3278 103 22 another another DT 3278 103 23 . . . 3278 104 1 4 4 LS 3278 104 2 . . . 3278 105 1 Judgment judgment NN 3278 105 2 calls call VBZ 3278 105 3 — — : 3278 105 4 distinctions distinction NNS 3278 105 5 introduced introduce VBN 3278 105 6 in in IN 3278 105 7 record record NN 3278 105 8 representations representation NNS 3278 105 9 due due JJ 3278 105 10 to to IN 3278 105 11 differing differing JJ 3278 105 12 but but CC 3278 105 13 legitimate legitimate JJ 3278 105 14 variation variation NN 3278 105 15 in in IN 3278 105 16 expert expert JJ 3278 105 17 judgment judgment NN 3278 105 18 . . . 3278 106 1 OCLC oclc NN 3278 106 2 is be VBZ 3278 106 3 a a DT 3278 106 4 multina­ multina­ NNP 3278 106 5 tional tional JJ 3278 106 6 cooperative cooperative NN 3278 106 7 and and CC 3278 106 8 there there EX 3278 106 9 is be VBZ 3278 106 10 no no DT 3278 106 11 universal universal JJ 3278 106 12 set set NN 3278 106 13 of of IN 3278 106 14 standards standard NNS 3278 106 15 and and CC 3278 106 16 rules rule NNS 3278 106 17 for for IN 3278 106 18 creating create VBG 3278 106 19 database database NN 3278 106 20 records record NNS 3278 106 21 . . . 3278 107 1 Rules rule NNS 3278 107 2 of of IN 3278 107 3 cataloging catalog VBG 3278 107 4 most most RBS 3278 107 5 widely widely RB 3278 107 6 used use VBN 3278 107 7 are be VBP 3278 107 8 not not RB 3278 107 9 abso­ abso­ RB 3278 107 10 lutely lutely RB 3278 107 11 prescriptive prescriptive JJ 3278 107 12 and and CC 3278 107 13 are be VBP 3278 107 14 designed design VBN 3278 107 15 to to TO 3278 107 16 allow allow VB 3278 107 17 local local JJ 3278 107 18 deviation deviation NN 3278 107 19 to to TO 3278 107 20 meet meet VB 3278 107 21 local local JJ 3278 107 22 needs.19 needs.19 NNP 3278 107 23 5 5 CD 3278 107 24 . . . 3278 108 1 Structural structural JJ 3278 108 2 bias bias NN 3278 108 3 — — : 3278 108 4 process process NN 3278 108 5 and and CC 3278 108 6 systems system NNS 3278 108 7 bias bias NN 3278 108 8 . . . 3278 109 1 This this DT 3278 109 2 category category NN 3278 109 3 reflects reflect VBZ 3278 109 4 internal internal JJ 3278 109 5 influences influence NNS 3278 109 6 , , , 3278 109 7 inherent inherent JJ 3278 109 8 in in IN 3278 109 9 the the DT 3278 109 10 automatic automatic JJ 3278 109 11 processing processing NN 3278 109 12 , , , 3278 109 13 storage storage NN 3278 109 14 , , , 3278 109 15 and and CC 3278 109 16 retrieval retrieval NN 3278 109 17 of of IN 3278 109 18 large large JJ 3278 109 19 numbers number NNS 3278 109 20 of of IN 3278 109 21 records record NNS 3278 109 22 . . . 3278 110 1 6 6 CD 3278 110 2 . . . 3278 111 1 Growth growth NN 3278 111 2 of of IN 3278 111 3 the the DT 3278 111 4 database database NN 3278 111 5 environment environment NN 3278 111 6 — — : 3278 111 7 whether whether IN 3278 111 8 in in IN 3278 111 9 raw raw JJ 3278 111 10 numbers number NNS 3278 111 11 of of IN 3278 111 12 records record NNS 3278 111 13 , , , 3278 111 14 numbers number NNS 3278 111 15 of of IN 3278 111 16 specific specific JJ 3278 111 17 formats format NNS 3278 111 18 , , , 3278 111 19 numbers number NNS 3278 111 20 of of IN 3278 111 21 foreign foreign JJ 3278 111 22 languages language NNS 3278 111 23 , , , 3278 111 24 or or CC 3278 111 25 other other JJ 3278 111 26 characteristics characteristic NNS 3278 111 27 that that WDT 3278 111 28 may may MD 3278 111 29 affect affect VB 3278 111 30 efficient efficient JJ 3278 111 31 location location NN 3278 111 32 and and CC 3278 111 33 comparison comparison NN 3278 111 34 of of IN 3278 111 35 records record NNS 3278 111 36 . . . 3278 112 1 7 7 LS 3278 112 2 . . . 3278 113 1 Changes change NNS 3278 113 2 in in IN 3278 113 3 contributor contributor NN 3278 113 4 characteristics––in characteristics––in VBD 3278 113 5 the the DT 3278 113 6 goals goal NNS 3278 113 7 or or CC 3278 113 8 focus focus NN 3278 113 9 of of IN 3278 113 10 institutions institution NNS 3278 113 11 that that WDT 3278 113 12 contribute contribute VBP 3278 113 13 to to IN 3278 113 14 the the DT 3278 113 15 database database NN 3278 113 16 . . . 3278 114 1 Violated Violated NNP 3278 114 2 Expectations Expectations NNPS 3278 114 3 Data Data NNP 3278 114 4 may may MD 3278 114 5 not not RB 3278 114 6 conform conform VB 3278 114 7 to to IN 3278 114 8 expectations expectation NNS 3278 114 9 . . . 3278 115 1 Expectations expectation NNS 3278 115 2 about about IN 3278 115 3 the the DT 3278 115 4 nature nature NN 3278 115 5 of of IN 3278 115 6 records record NNS 3278 115 7 in in IN 3278 115 8 the the DT 3278 115 9 data­ data­ NNP 3278 115 10 bases basis NNS 3278 115 11 are be VBP 3278 115 12 frequently frequently RB 3278 115 13 violated violate VBN 3278 115 14 . . . 3278 116 1 What what WP 3278 116 2 seem seem VBP 3278 116 3 to to TO 3278 116 4 be be VB 3278 116 5 good good JJ 3278 116 6 rules rule NNS 3278 116 7 for for IN 3278 116 8 matching matching NN 3278 116 9 may may MD 3278 116 10 not not RB 3278 116 11 work work VB 3278 116 12 well well RB 3278 116 13 if if IN 3278 116 14 the the DT 3278 116 15 incoming incoming JJ 3278 116 16 data data NN 3278 116 17 is be VBZ 3278 116 18 not not RB 3278 116 19 well well RB 3278 116 20 formed form VBN 3278 116 21 , , , 3278 116 22 or or CC 3278 116 23 simply simply RB 3278 116 24 not not RB 3278 116 25 constructed construct VBN 3278 116 26 as as IN 3278 116 27 expected expect VBN 3278 116 28 . . . 3278 117 1 Biasing bias VBG 3278 117 2 sources source NNS 3278 117 3 in in IN 3278 117 4 the the DT 3278 117 5 incoming incoming JJ 3278 117 6 data datum NNS 3278 117 7 include include VBP 3278 117 8 the the DT 3278 117 9 fol­ fol­ XX 3278 117 10 lowing lowing NN 3278 117 11 : : : 3278 117 12 1 1 CD 3278 117 13 . . . 3278 118 1 Typographical typographical JJ 3278 118 2 errors error NNS 3278 118 3 occur occur VBP 3278 118 4 in in IN 3278 118 5 titles title NNS 3278 118 6 and and CC 3278 118 7 other other JJ 3278 118 8 parts part NNS 3278 118 9 of of IN 3278 118 10 the the DT 3278 118 11 record record NN 3278 118 12 . . . 3278 119 1 Anywhere anywhere RB 3278 119 2 the the DT 3278 119 3 software software NN 3278 119 4 has have VBZ 3278 119 5 to to TO 3278 119 6 parse parse VB 3278 119 7 text text NN 3278 119 8 , , , 3278 119 9 an an DT 3278 119 10 entry entry NN 3278 119 11 error error NN 3278 119 12 — — : 3278 119 13 or or CC 3278 119 14 even even RB 3278 119 15 correction correction NN 3278 119 16 of of IN 3278 119 17 an an DT 3278 119 18 entry entry NN 3278 119 19 error error NN 3278 119 20 by by IN 3278 119 21 a a DT 3278 119 22 later later JJ 3278 119 23 update update NN 3278 119 24 — — : 3278 119 25 could could MD 3278 119 26 con­ con­ ADD 3278 119 27 found find VBN 3278 119 28 matching matching NN 3278 119 29 . . . 3278 120 1 This this DT 3278 120 2 could could MD 3278 120 3 confound confound VB 3278 120 4 both both DT 3278 120 5 ( ( -LRB- 3278 120 6 a a DT 3278 120 7 ) ) -RRB- 3278 120 8 query query NN 3278 120 9 execution execution NN 3278 120 10 and and CC 3278 120 11 ( ( -LRB- 3278 120 12 b b NN 3278 120 13 ) ) -RRB- 3278 120 14 candidate candidate NN 3278 120 15 comparisons comparison NNS 3278 120 16 . . . 3278 121 1 Basically basically RB 3278 121 2 the the DT 3278 121 3 system system NN 3278 121 4 expects expect VBZ 3278 121 5 textual textual JJ 3278 121 6 data datum NNS 3278 121 7 such such JJ 3278 121 8 as as IN 3278 121 9 the the DT 3278 121 10 name name NN 3278 121 11 of of IN 3278 121 12 a a DT 3278 121 13 title title NN 3278 121 14 or or CC 3278 121 15 publisher publisher NN 3278 121 16 to to TO 3278 121 17 be be VB 3278 121 18 correct correct JJ 3278 121 19 , , , 3278 121 20 and and CC 3278 121 21 machine­based machine­based JJ 3278 121 22 efforts effort NNS 3278 121 23 to to TO 3278 121 24 detect detect VB 3278 121 25 errors error NNS 3278 121 26 in in IN 3278 121 27 data datum NNS 3278 121 28 are be VBP 3278 121 29 expensive expensive JJ 3278 121 30 to to TO 3278 121 31 run run VB 3278 121 32 . . . 3278 122 1 Spelling spell VBG 3278 122 2 detection detection NN 3278 122 3 techniques technique NNS 3278 122 4 can can MD 3278 122 5 compensate compensate VB 3278 122 6 in in IN 3278 122 7 some some DT 3278 122 8 ways way NNS 3278 122 9 for for IN 3278 122 10 data data NN 3278 122 11 problems problem NNS 3278 122 12 , , , 3278 122 13 but but CC 3278 122 14 will will MD 3278 122 15 not not RB 3278 122 16 identify identify VB 3278 122 17 cases case NNS 3278 122 18 of of IN 3278 122 19 real­word real­word NNP 3278 122 20 errors error NNS 3278 122 21 . . . 3278 123 1 See see VB 3278 123 2 Kukich Kukich NNP 3278 123 3 for for IN 3278 123 4 a a DT 3278 123 5 survey survey NN 3278 123 6 of of IN 3278 123 7 spelling spelling NN 3278 123 8 error error NN 3278 123 9 , , , 3278 123 10 real­word real­word NNP 3278 123 11 , , , 3278 123 12 and and CC 3278 123 13 context­dependent context­dependent NNP 3278 123 14 techniques.20 techniques.20 NNP 3278 123 15 2 2 CD 3278 123 16 . . . 3278 124 1 There there EX 3278 124 2 is be VBZ 3278 124 3 also also RB 3278 124 4 the the DT 3278 124 5 issue issue NN 3278 124 6 of of IN 3278 124 7 real real JJ 3278 124 8 word word NN 3278 124 9 differences difference NNS 3278 124 10 in in IN 3278 124 11 similar similar JJ 3278 124 12 text text NN 3278 124 13 strings string NNS 3278 124 14 . . . 3278 125 1 An an DT 3278 125 2 automated automated JJ 3278 125 3 system system NN 3278 125 4 with with IN 3278 125 5 programmed program VBN 3278 125 6 fault fault NN 3278 125 7 tolerance tolerance NN 3278 125 8 may may MD 3278 125 9 wrongly wrongly RB 3278 125 10 equate equate VB 3278 125 11 the the DT 3278 125 12 publisher publisher NN 3278 125 13 name name NN 3278 125 14 “ " `` 3278 125 15 Mila Mila NNP 3278 125 16 ” " '' 3278 125 17 with with IN 3278 125 18 “ " `` 3278 125 19 Mela Mela NNPS 3278 125 20 ” " '' 3278 125 21 when when WRB 3278 125 22 they -PRON- PRP 3278 125 23 are be VBP 3278 125 24 distinct distinct JJ 3278 125 25 publishers publisher NNS 3278 125 26 . . . 3278 126 1 Equivalence equivalence NN 3278 126 2 tables table NNS 3278 126 3 can can MD 3278 126 4 cross­reference cross­reference VB 3278 126 5 known know VBN 3278 126 6 variations variation NNS 3278 126 7 on on IN 3278 126 8 well­known well­known NNP 3278 126 9 publisher publisher NN 3278 126 10 names name NNS 3278 126 11 , , , 3278 126 12 but but CC 3278 126 13 can can MD 3278 126 14 not not RB 3278 126 15 predict predict VB 3278 126 16 merges merge NNS 3278 126 17 and and CC 3278 126 18 other other JJ 3278 126 19 organizational organizational JJ 3278 126 20 changes change NNS 3278 126 21 . . . 3278 127 1 Or or CC 3278 127 2 consider consider VB 3278 127 3 author author NN 3278 127 4 names name NNS 3278 127 5 : : : 3278 127 6 are be VBP 3278 127 7 “ " `` 3278 127 8 John John NNP 3278 127 9 Smith Smith NNP 3278 127 10 ” " '' 3278 127 11 and and CC 3278 127 12 “ " `` 3278 127 13 Jon Jon NNP 3278 127 14 Smith Smith NNP 3278 127 15 ” " '' 3278 127 16 the the DT 3278 127 17 1 1 CD 3278 127 18 � � JJ 3278 127 19 INFORMATION information JJ 3278 127 20 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3278 127 21 AND and CC 3278 127 22 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 127 23 | | NNP 3278 127 24 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 127 25 20071 20071 CD 3278 127 26 � � NN 3278 127 27 INFORMATION information JJ 3278 127 28 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3278 127 29 AND and CC 3278 127 30 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 127 31 | | NNP 3278 127 32 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 127 33 2007 2007 CD 3278 127 34 same same JJ 3278 127 35 ? ? . 3278 128 1 This this DT 3278 128 2 is be VBZ 3278 128 3 a a DT 3278 128 4 major major JJ 3278 128 5 problem problem NN 3278 128 6 with with IN 3278 128 7 automated automate VBN 3278 128 8 authority authority NN 3278 128 9 control control NN 3278 128 10 where where WRB 3278 128 11 context context NN 3278 128 12 clues clue NNS 3278 128 13 may may MD 3278 128 14 not not RB 3278 128 15 be be VB 3278 128 16 trustworthy trustworthy JJ 3278 128 17 . . . 3278 129 1 3 3 LS 3278 129 2 . . . 3278 130 1 Errors error NNS 3278 130 2 of of IN 3278 130 3 formatting formatting NN 3278 130 4 of of IN 3278 130 5 variable variable JJ 3278 130 6 fields field NNS 3278 130 7 in in IN 3278 130 8 the the DT 3278 130 9 meta­ meta­ NNP 3278 130 10 data datum NNS 3278 130 11 contribute contribute VBP 3278 130 12 to to IN 3278 130 13 false false JJ 3278 130 14 mismatch mismatch NN 3278 130 15 . . . 3278 131 1 The the DT 3278 131 2 rules rule NNS 3278 131 3 for for IN 3278 131 4 data datum NNS 3278 131 5 entry entry NN 3278 131 6 in in IN 3278 131 7 the the DT 3278 131 8 MARC MARC NNP 3278 131 9 record record NN 3278 131 10 are be VBP 3278 131 11 complex complex JJ 3278 131 12 and and CC 3278 131 13 have have VBP 3278 131 14 changed change VBN 3278 131 15 over over IN 3278 131 16 time time NN 3278 131 17 . . . 3278 132 1 Erroneous erroneous JJ 3278 132 2 placement placement NN 3278 132 3 or or CC 3278 132 4 coding coding NN 3278 132 5 of of IN 3278 132 6 subfields subfield NNS 3278 132 7 poses pose NNS 3278 132 8 challenges challenge NNS 3278 132 9 for for IN 3278 132 10 iden­ iden­ NNP 3278 132 11 tification tification NN 3278 132 12 of of IN 3278 132 13 relevant relevant JJ 3278 132 14 data datum NNS 3278 132 15 . . . 3278 133 1 The the DT 3278 133 2 software software NN 3278 133 3 must must MD 3278 133 4 be be VB 3278 133 5 fault fault NN 3278 133 6 tolerant tolerant JJ 3278 133 7 wherever wherever WRB 3278 133 8 possible possible JJ 3278 133 9 . . . 3278 134 1 Changes change NNS 3278 134 2 in in IN 3278 134 3 the the DT 3278 134 4 format format NN 3278 134 5 of of IN 3278 134 6 the the DT 3278 134 7 data datum NNS 3278 134 8 itself -PRON- PRP 3278 134 9 in in IN 3278 134 10 these these DT 3278 134 11 fields field NNS 3278 134 12 / / SYM 3278 134 13 sub­ sub­ NNP 3278 134 14 fields field NNS 3278 134 15 may may MD 3278 134 16 further far RBR 3278 134 17 complicate complicate VB 3278 134 18 record record NN 3278 134 19 comparisons comparison NNS 3278 134 20 . . . 3278 135 1 ISBNs ISBNs NNP 3278 135 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 135 3 International International NNP 3278 135 4 Standard Standard NNP 3278 135 5 Book Book NNP 3278 135 6 Numbers Numbers NNPS 3278 135 7 ) ) -RRB- 3278 135 8 and and CC 3278 135 9 LCCNs LCCNs NNP 3278 135 10 ( ( -LRB- 3278 135 11 Library Library NNP 3278 135 12 of of IN 3278 135 13 Congress Congress NNP 3278 135 14 Control Control NNP 3278 135 15 Numbers Numbers NNP 3278 135 16 ) ) -RRB- 3278 135 17 have have VBP 3278 135 18 both both CC 3278 135 19 changed change VBN 3278 135 20 format format NN 3278 135 21 in in IN 3278 135 22 the the DT 3278 135 23 recent recent JJ 3278 135 24 past past NN 3278 135 25 . . . 3278 136 1 4 4 LS 3278 136 2 . . . 3278 137 1 Errors error NNS 3278 137 2 occur occur VBP 3278 137 3 in in IN 3278 137 4 the the DT 3278 137 5 fields field NNS 3278 137 6 that that WDT 3278 137 7 indicate indicate VBP 3278 137 8 format format NN 3278 137 9 of of IN 3278 137 10 the the DT 3278 137 11 information information NN 3278 137 12 . . . 3278 138 1 In in IN 3278 138 2 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 138 3 records record NNS 3278 138 4 , , , 3278 138 5 format format NN 3278 138 6 information information NN 3278 138 7 is be VBZ 3278 138 8 used use VBN 3278 138 9 to to TO 3278 138 10 derive derive VB 3278 138 11 the the DT 3278 138 12 overall overall JJ 3278 138 13 type type NN 3278 138 14 of of IN 3278 138 15 material material NN 3278 138 16 being be VBG 3278 138 17 described describe VBN 3278 138 18 : : : 3278 138 19 book book NN 3278 138 20 , , , 3278 138 21 URL URL NNP 3278 138 22 , , , 3278 138 23 DVD dvd NN 3278 138 24 , , , 3278 138 25 and and CC 3278 138 26 so so RB 3278 138 27 on on RB 3278 138 28 . . . 3278 139 1 Errors error NNS 3278 139 2 in in IN 3278 139 3 the the DT 3278 139 4 data datum NNS 3278 139 5 in in IN 3278 139 6 combination combination NN 3278 139 7 can can MD 3278 139 8 generate generate VB 3278 139 9 an an DT 3278 139 10 incorrect incorrect JJ 3278 139 11 material material NN 3278 139 12 type type NN 3278 139 13 for for IN 3278 139 14 the the DT 3278 139 15 record record NN 3278 139 16 . . . 3278 140 1 5 5 CD 3278 140 2 . . . 3278 141 1 Language language NN 3278 141 2 of of IN 3278 141 3 cataloging catalog VBG 3278 141 4 : : : 3278 141 5 this this DT 3278 141 6 comparison comparison NN 3278 141 7 has have VBZ 3278 141 8 in in IN 3278 141 9 the the DT 3278 141 10 past past NN 3278 141 11 caused cause VBN 3278 141 12 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 3278 141 13 mismatches mismatch NNS 3278 141 14 . . . 3278 142 1 The the DT 3278 142 2 require­ require­ JJ 3278 142 3 ments ment NNS 3278 142 4 in in IN 3278 142 5 the the DT 3278 142 6 new new JJ 3278 142 7 matching matching NN 3278 142 8 aimed aim VBN 3278 142 9 to to TO 3278 142 10 address address VB 3278 142 11 this this DT 3278 142 12 . . . 3278 143 1 6 6 CD 3278 143 2 . . . 3278 144 1 Language language NN 3278 144 2 in in IN 3278 144 3 formation formation NN 3278 144 4 of of IN 3278 144 5 queries query NNS 3278 144 6 : : : 3278 144 7 MARC MARC JJR 3278 144 8 records record NNS 3278 144 9 frequently frequently RB 3278 144 10 are be VBP 3278 144 11 a a DT 3278 144 12 mixture mixture NN 3278 144 13 of of IN 3278 144 14 languages language NNS 3278 144 15 . . . 3278 145 1 As as IN 3278 145 2 has have VBZ 3278 145 3 been be VBN 3278 145 4 seen see VBN 3278 145 5 in in IN 3278 145 6 other other JJ 3278 145 7 projects project NNS 3278 145 8 with with IN 3278 145 9 intensive intensive JJ 3278 145 10 comparison comparison NN 3278 145 11 of of IN 3278 145 12 text text NN 3278 145 13 , , , 3278 145 14 overlap overlap VBP 3278 145 15 in in IN 3278 145 16 languages language NNS 3278 145 17 has have VBZ 3278 145 18 the the DT 3278 145 19 potential potential NN 3278 145 20 to to TO 3278 145 21 confuse confuse VB 3278 145 22 comparisons comparison NNS 3278 145 23 of of IN 3278 145 24 short short JJ 3278 145 25 strings string NNS 3278 145 26 of of IN 3278 145 27 text.21 text.21 NNP 3278 145 28 The the DT 3278 145 29 assumption assumption NN 3278 145 30 made make VBN 3278 145 31 here here RB 3278 145 32 is be VBZ 3278 145 33 that that IN 3278 145 34 the the DT 3278 145 35 use use NN 3278 145 36 of of IN 3278 145 37 all all DT 3278 145 38 pos­ pos­ NN 3278 145 39 sible sible JJ 3278 145 40 syllables syllable NNS 3278 145 41 contained contain VBN 3278 145 42 in in IN 3278 145 43 the the DT 3278 145 44 title title NN 3278 145 45 should should MD 3278 145 46 tend tend VB 3278 145 47 to to TO 3278 145 48 mitigate mitigate VB 3278 145 49 language language NN 3278 145 50 problems problem NNS 3278 145 51 . . . 3278 146 1 Nothing nothing NN 3278 146 2 short short JJ 3278 146 3 of of IN 3278 146 4 semantic semantic JJ 3278 146 5 analysis analysis NN 3278 146 6 by by IN 3278 146 7 the the DT 3278 146 8 software software NN 3278 146 9 is be VBZ 3278 146 10 likely likely JJ 3278 146 11 to to TO 3278 146 12 solve solve VB 3278 146 13 such such PDT 3278 146 14 a a DT 3278 146 15 problem problem NN 3278 146 16 , , , 3278 146 17 and and CC 3278 146 18 contextual contextual JJ 3278 146 19 approaches approach NNS 3278 146 20 to to TO 3278 146 21 detection detection VB 3278 146 22 have have VB 3278 146 23 had have VBN 3278 146 24 most most JJS 3278 146 25 success success NN 3278 146 26 ( ( -LRB- 3278 146 27 in in IN 3278 146 28 the the DT 3278 146 29 produc­ produc­ NNP 3278 146 30 tion tion NN 3278 146 31 environment environment NN 3278 146 32 ) ) -RRB- 3278 146 33 in in IN 3278 146 34 carefully carefully RB 3278 146 35 controlled control VBN 3278 146 36 cases case NNS 3278 146 37 . . . 3278 147 1 Matching match VBG 3278 147 2 overall overall RB 3278 147 3 must must MD 3278 147 4 be be VB 3278 147 5 generic generic JJ 3278 147 6 in in IN 3278 147 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 147 8 problem problem NN 3278 147 9 solving solve VBG 3278 147 10 techniques technique NNS 3278 147 11 . . . 3278 148 1 Temporal temporal JJ 3278 148 2 bias bias NN 3278 148 3 Large large JJ 3278 148 4 databases database NNS 3278 148 5 developed develop VBN 3278 148 6 over over IN 3278 148 7 time time NN 3278 148 8 have have VBP 3278 148 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 148 10 contents content NNS 3278 148 11 influenced influence VBN 3278 148 12 by by IN 3278 148 13 changes change NNS 3278 148 14 in in IN 3278 148 15 standards standard NNS 3278 148 16 for for IN 3278 148 17 record record NN 3278 148 18 creation creation NN 3278 148 19 , , , 3278 148 20 changes change NNS 3278 148 21 in in IN 3278 148 22 contributor contributor NN 3278 148 23 perception perception NN 3278 148 24 of of IN 3278 148 25 the the DT 3278 148 26 role role NN 3278 148 27 of of IN 3278 148 28 the the DT 3278 148 29 data­ data­ NNP 3278 148 30 base base NN 3278 148 31 , , , 3278 148 32 and and CC 3278 148 33 changes change NNS 3278 148 34 in in IN 3278 148 35 technology technology NN 3278 148 36 to to TO 3278 148 37 be be VB 3278 148 38 described describe VBN 3278 148 39 . . . 3278 149 1 Changes change NNS 3278 149 2 may may MD 3278 149 3 include include VB 3278 149 4 the the DT 3278 149 5 following follow VBG 3278 149 6 : : : 3278 149 7 1 1 CD 3278 149 8 . . . 3278 150 1 Description description NN 3278 150 2 level level NN 3278 150 3 : : : 3278 150 4 e.g. e.g. RB 3278 151 1 changes change NNS 3278 151 2 such such JJ 3278 151 3 as as IN 3278 151 4 book book NN 3278 151 5 or or CC 3278 151 6 elec­ elec­ NNP 3278 151 7 tronic tronic NN 3278 151 8 book book NN 3278 151 9 . . . 3278 152 1 These these DT 3278 152 2 have have VBP 3278 152 3 evolved evolve VBN 3278 152 4 from from IN 3278 152 5 format­ format­ NNP 3278 152 6 to to IN 3278 152 7 content­based content­based NNP 3278 152 8 descriptions description NNS 3278 152 9 that that WDT 3278 152 10 transcend transcend VBP 3278 152 11 format format NN 3278 152 12 . . . 3278 153 1 Over over IN 3278 153 2 time time NN 3278 153 3 , , , 3278 153 4 the the DT 3278 153 5 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 153 6 rules rule NNS 3278 153 7 for for IN 3278 153 8 describing describe VBG 3278 153 9 formats format NNS 3278 153 10 have have VBP 3278 153 11 changed change VBN 3278 153 12 . . . 3278 154 1 Thus thus RB 3278 154 2 a a DT 3278 154 3 format format NN 3278 154 4 description description NN 3278 154 5 created create VBN 3278 154 6 earlier early RBR 3278 154 7 might may MD 3278 154 8 inadvertently inadvertently RB 3278 154 9 “ " `` 3278 154 10 mismatch mismatch VB 3278 154 11 ” " '' 3278 154 12 the the DT 3278 154 13 newer new JJR 3278 154 14 description description NN 3278 154 15 of of IN 3278 154 16 exactly exactly RB 3278 154 17 the the DT 3278 154 18 same same JJ 3278 154 19 item item NN 3278 154 20 . . . 3278 155 1 For for IN 3278 155 2 example example NN 3278 155 3 , , , 3278 155 4 the the DT 3278 155 5 rules rule NNS 3278 155 6 for for IN 3278 155 7 describing describe VBG 3278 155 8 a a DT 3278 155 9 book book NN 3278 155 10 on on IN 3278 155 11 a a DT 3278 155 12 CD cd NN 3278 155 13 originally originally RB 3278 155 14 emphasized emphasize VBD 3278 155 15 the the DT 3278 155 16 CD cd NN 3278 155 17 format format NN 3278 155 18 , , , 3278 155 19 whereas whereas IN 3278 155 20 now now RB 3278 155 21 , , , 3278 155 22 the the DT 3278 155 23 emphasis emphasis NN 3278 155 24 might may MD 3278 155 25 be be VB 3278 155 26 shifted shift VBN 3278 155 27 to to TO 3278 155 28 focus focus VB 3278 155 29 on on IN 3278 155 30 the the DT 3278 155 31 intellectual intellectual JJ 3278 155 32 content content NN 3278 155 33 , , , 3278 155 34 the the DT 3278 155 35 fact fact NN 3278 155 36 that that IN 3278 155 37 it -PRON- PRP 3278 155 38 is be VBZ 3278 155 39 a a DT 3278 155 40 book book NN 3278 155 41 . . . 3278 156 1 2 2 LS 3278 156 2 . . . 3278 157 1 The the DT 3278 157 2 role role NN 3278 157 3 of of IN 3278 157 4 the the DT 3278 157 5 database database NN 3278 157 6 once once RB 3278 157 7 perceived perceive VBD 3278 157 8 as as IN 3278 157 9 chiefly chiefly RB 3278 157 10 repository repository JJ 3278 157 11 or or CC 3278 157 12 even even RB 3278 157 13 backup backup JJ 3278 157 14 source source NN 3278 157 15 for for IN 3278 157 16 a a DT 3278 157 17 given give VBN 3278 157 18 library library NN 3278 157 19 has have VBZ 3278 157 20 become become VBN 3278 157 21 a a DT 3278 157 22 shared share VBN 3278 157 23 resource resource NN 3278 157 24 with with IN 3278 157 25 responsibilities responsibility NNS 3278 157 26 to to IN 3278 157 27 a a DT 3278 157 28 community community NN 3278 157 29 larger large JJR 3278 157 30 than than IN 3278 157 31 any any DT 3278 157 32 one one CD 3278 157 33 library library NN 3278 157 34 . . . 3278 158 1 3 3 LS 3278 158 2 . . . 3278 159 1 Over over IN 3278 159 2 time time NN 3278 159 3 , , , 3278 159 4 the the DT 3278 159 5 use use NN 3278 159 6 of of IN 3278 159 7 the the DT 3278 159 8 database database NN 3278 159 9 may may MD 3278 159 10 change change VB 3278 159 11 . . . 3278 160 1 ( ( -LRB- 3278 160 2 This this DT 3278 160 3 is be VBZ 3278 160 4 further further RB 3278 160 5 discussed discuss VBN 3278 160 6 in in IN 3278 160 7 the the DT 3278 160 8 section section NN 3278 160 9 on on IN 3278 160 10 Growth Growth NNP 3278 160 11 of of IN 3278 160 12 the the DT 3278 160 13 Environment Environment NNP 3278 160 14 later later RB 3278 160 15 . . . 3278 160 16 ) ) -RRB- 3278 161 1 Searching Searching NNP 3278 161 2 has have VBZ 3278 161 3 to to TO 3278 161 4 satisfy satisfy VB 3278 161 5 the the DT 3278 161 6 reference reference NN 3278 161 7 function function NN 3278 161 8 of of IN 3278 161 9 the the DT 3278 161 10 database database NN 3278 161 11 , , , 3278 161 12 but but CC 3278 161 13 match­ match­ NNP 3278 161 14 ing e VBG 3278 161 15 as as IN 3278 161 16 a a DT 3278 161 17 process process NN 3278 161 18 also also RB 3278 161 19 relies rely VBZ 3278 161 20 on on IN 3278 161 21 searching search VBG 3278 161 22 , , , 3278 161 23 and and CC 3278 161 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 161 25 goals goal NNS 3278 161 26 are be VBP 3278 161 27 different different JJ 3278 161 28 . . . 3278 162 1 4 4 LS 3278 162 2 . . . 3278 163 1 Varied varied JJ 3278 163 2 standards standard NNS 3278 163 3 worldwide worldwide RB 3278 163 4 challenge challenge NN 3278 163 5 coopera­ coopera­ NNP 3278 163 6 tion tion NN 3278 163 7 . . . 3278 164 1 While while IN 3278 164 2 U.S. U.S. NNP 3278 164 3 libraries library NNS 3278 164 4 usually usually RB 3278 164 5 follow follow VBP 3278 164 6 AACR2 aacr2 ADD 3278 164 7 and and CC 3278 164 8 use use VB 3278 164 9 the the DT 3278 164 10 MARC21 MARC21 NNP 3278 164 11 communications communication NNS 3278 164 12 format format NN 3278 164 13 , , , 3278 164 14 other other JJ 3278 164 15 parts part NNS 3278 164 16 of of IN 3278 164 17 the the DT 3278 164 18 world world NN 3278 164 19 may may MD 3278 164 20 use use VB 3278 164 21 UNIMARC UNIMARC NNP 3278 164 22 and and CC 3278 164 23 country­specific country­specific NNP 3278 164 24 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 164 25 rules rule NNS 3278 164 26 . . . 3278 165 1 For for IN 3278 165 2 instance instance NN 3278 165 3 , , , 3278 165 4 the the DT 3278 165 5 PICA PICA NNP 3278 165 6 Bibliotekssystem Bibliotekssystem NNP 3278 165 7 , , , 3278 165 8 which which WDT 3278 165 9 hosts host VBZ 3278 165 10 the the DT 3278 165 11 Dutch Dutch NNP 3278 165 12 Union Union NNP 3278 165 13 Catalog Catalog NNP 3278 165 14 , , , 3278 165 15 used use VBD 3278 165 16 the the DT 3278 165 17 Prussian prussian JJ 3278 165 18 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 165 19 rules rule NNS 3278 165 20 , , , 3278 165 21 which which WDT 3278 165 22 tended tend VBD 3278 165 23 to to TO 3278 165 24 focus focus VB 3278 165 25 on on IN 3278 165 26 title title NN 3278 165 27 entries.22 entries.22 NNP 3278 165 28 The the DT 3278 165 29 switch switch NN 3278 165 30 to to IN 3278 165 31 the the DT 3278 165 32 RAK RAK NNP 3278 165 33 was be VBD 3278 165 34 made make VBN 3278 165 35 by by IN 3278 165 36 the the DT 3278 165 37 early early JJ 3278 165 38 nineties.23 nineties.23 NNP 3278 165 39 5 5 CD 3278 165 40 . . . 3278 166 1 Some some DT 3278 166 2 libraries library NNS 3278 166 3 may may MD 3278 166 4 not not RB 3278 166 5 use use VB 3278 166 6 any any DT 3278 166 7 form form NN 3278 166 8 of of IN 3278 166 9 MARC MARC NNP 3278 166 10 but but CC 3278 166 11 submit submit VB 3278 166 12 a a DT 3278 166 13 spreadsheet spreadsheet NN 3278 166 14 that that WDT 3278 166 15 is be VBZ 3278 166 16 then then RB 3278 166 17 converted convert VBN 3278 166 18 to to IN 3278 166 19 MARC MARC NNP 3278 166 20 . . . 3278 167 1 There there EX 3278 167 2 is be VBZ 3278 167 3 some some DT 3278 167 4 potential potential NN 3278 167 5 for for IN 3278 167 6 ambiguities ambiguity NNS 3278 167 7 in in IN 3278 167 8 those those DT 3278 167 9 conversions conversion NNS 3278 167 10 due due IN 3278 167 11 to to IN 3278 167 12 lack lack NN 3278 167 13 of of IN 3278 167 14 1:1 1:1 CD 3278 167 15 correspon­ correspon­ NN 3278 167 16 dence dence NN 3278 167 17 of of IN 3278 167 18 parts part NNS 3278 167 19 . . . 3278 168 1 6 6 CD 3278 168 2 . . . 3278 169 1 Even even RB 3278 169 2 within within IN 3278 169 3 a a DT 3278 169 4 country country NN 3278 169 5 , , , 3278 169 6 standards standard NNS 3278 169 7 change change VBP 3278 169 8 over over IN 3278 169 9 time time NN 3278 169 10 , , , 3278 169 11 so so IN 3278 169 12 that that IN 3278 169 13 “ " `` 3278 169 14 correct correct JJ 3278 169 15 ” " '' 3278 169 16 cataloging catalog VBG 3278 169 17 in in IN 3278 169 18 one one CD 3278 169 19 decade decade NN 3278 169 20 may may MD 3278 169 21 not not RB 3278 169 22 match match VB 3278 169 23 that that IN 3278 169 24 in in IN 3278 169 25 a a DT 3278 169 26 later later JJ 3278 169 27 period period NN 3278 169 28 . . . 3278 170 1 Neither neither DT 3278 170 2 is be VBZ 3278 170 3 wrong wrong JJ 3278 170 4 , , , 3278 170 5 in in IN 3278 170 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 170 7 own own JJ 3278 170 8 temporal temporal JJ 3278 170 9 context context NN 3278 170 10 , , , 3278 170 11 but but CC 3278 170 12 each each DT 3278 170 13 results result NNS 3278 170 14 in in IN 3278 170 15 different different JJ 3278 170 16 metadata metadata NN 3278 170 17 being be VBG 3278 170 18 created create VBN 3278 170 19 to to TO 3278 170 20 describe describe VB 3278 170 21 the the DT 3278 170 22 same same JJ 3278 170 23 item item NN 3278 170 24 . . . 3278 171 1 Intner Intner NNP 3278 171 2 points point VBZ 3278 171 3 out out RP 3278 171 4 that that IN 3278 171 5 OCLC OCLC NNP 3278 171 6 ’s ’s POS 3278 171 7 database database NN 3278 171 8 was be VBD 3278 171 9 initi­ initi­ NNP 3278 171 10 ated ate VBD 3278 171 11 a a DT 3278 171 12 full full JJ 3278 171 13 decade decade NN 3278 171 14 before before IN 3278 171 15 RLG RLG NNP 3278 171 16 implemented implement VBN 3278 171 17 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 171 18 , , , 3278 171 19 and and CC 3278 171 20 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 171 21 started start VBD 3278 171 22 almost almost RB 3278 171 23 the the DT 3278 171 24 same same JJ 3278 171 25 time time NN 3278 171 26 as as IN 3278 171 27 the the DT 3278 171 28 AACR2 aacr2 JJ 3278 171 29 publication.24 publication.24 NNP 3278 171 30 Thus thus RB 3278 171 31 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 171 32 had have VBD 3278 171 33 many many JJ 3278 171 34 fewer few JJR 3278 171 35 pre­AACR2 pre­aacr2 NN 3278 171 36 records record NNS 3278 171 37 in in IN 3278 171 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 171 39 database database NN 3278 171 40 , , , 3278 171 41 while while IN 3278 171 42 Worldcat Worldcat NNP 3278 171 43 had have VBD 3278 171 44 many many JJ 3278 171 45 more more JJR 3278 171 46 preexisting preexisting NN 3278 171 47 records record NNS 3278 171 48 to to TO 3278 171 49 try try VB 3278 171 50 to to TO 3278 171 51 match match VB 3278 171 52 with with IN 3278 171 53 the the DT 3278 171 54 newer new JJR 3278 171 55 AACR2 aacr2 JJ 3278 171 56 forms form NNS 3278 171 57 . . . 3278 172 1 7 7 LS 3278 172 2 . . . 3278 173 1 Objects object NNS 3278 173 2 referenced reference VBN 3278 173 3 in in IN 3278 173 4 the the DT 3278 173 5 database database NN 3278 173 6 may may MD 3278 173 7 change change VB 3278 173 8 over over IN 3278 173 9 time time NN 3278 173 10 . . . 3278 174 1 For for IN 3278 174 2 instance instance NN 3278 174 3 , , , 3278 174 4 a a DT 3278 174 5 record record NN 3278 174 6 describing describe VBG 3278 174 7 an an DT 3278 174 8 elec­ elec­ NNP 3278 174 9 tronic tronic NN 3278 174 10 resource resource NN 3278 174 11 may may MD 3278 174 12 point point VB 3278 174 13 to to IN 3278 174 14 a a DT 3278 174 15 location location NN 3278 174 16 no no RB 3278 174 17 longer long RBR 3278 174 18 valid valid JJ 3278 174 19 for for IN 3278 174 20 that that DT 3278 174 21 resource resource NN 3278 174 22 . . . 3278 175 1 8 8 LS 3278 175 2 . . . 3278 176 1 Vendor vendor NN 3278 176 2 records record NNS 3278 176 3 are be VBP 3278 176 4 created create VBN 3278 176 5 as as IN 3278 176 6 advance advance NN 3278 176 7 advertis­ advertis­ WRB 3278 176 8 ing ing NN 3278 176 9 , , , 3278 176 10 but but CC 3278 176 11 there there EX 3278 176 12 is be VBZ 3278 176 13 no no DT 3278 176 14 guarantee guarantee NN 3278 176 15 the the DT 3278 176 16 records record NNS 3278 176 17 will will MD 3278 176 18 be be VB 3278 176 19 updated update VBN 3278 176 20 later later RB 3278 176 21 . . . 3278 177 1 Estimating estimate VBG 3278 177 2 the the DT 3278 177 3 time time NN 3278 177 4 before before IN 3278 177 5 updates update NNS 3278 177 6 occur occur VBP 3278 177 7 is be VBZ 3278 177 8 impossible impossible JJ 3278 177 9 . . . 3278 178 1 9 9 CD 3278 178 2 . . . 3278 179 1 Records record NNS 3278 179 2 themselves -PRON- PRP 3278 179 3 change change VBP 3278 179 4 over over IN 3278 179 5 time time NN 3278 179 6 as as IN 3278 179 7 they -PRON- PRP 3278 179 8 are be VBP 3278 179 9 copied copy VBN 3278 179 10 , , , 3278 179 11 derived derive VBN 3278 179 12 , , , 3278 179 13 and and CC 3278 179 14 migrated migrate VBN 3278 179 15 into into IN 3278 179 16 other other JJ 3278 179 17 systems system NNS 3278 179 18 . . . 3278 180 1 They -PRON- PRP 3278 180 2 may may MD 3278 180 3 be be VB 3278 180 4 enhanced enhance VBN 3278 180 5 or or CC 3278 180 6 corrected correct VBN 3278 180 7 in in IN 3278 180 8 any any DT 3278 180 9 system system NN 3278 180 10 where where WRB 3278 180 11 they -PRON- PRP 3278 180 12 reside reside VBP 3278 180 13 . . . 3278 181 1 So so RB 3278 181 2 when when WRB 3278 181 3 they -PRON- PRP 3278 181 4 return return VBP 3278 181 5 to to IN 3278 181 6 the the DT 3278 181 7 origi­ origi­ NNP 3278 181 8 nating nate VBG 3278 181 9 database database NN 3278 181 10 , , , 3278 181 11 they -PRON- PRP 3278 181 12 may may MD 3278 181 13 have have VB 3278 181 14 been be VBN 3278 181 15 transformed transform VBN 3278 181 16 so so RB 3278 181 17 far far RB 3278 181 18 as as IN 3278 181 19 to to TO 3278 181 20 be be VB 3278 181 21 unrecognizable unrecognizable JJ 3278 181 22 as as IN 3278 181 23 representations representation NNS 3278 181 24 of of IN 3278 181 25 the the DT 3278 181 26 same same JJ 3278 181 27 item item NN 3278 181 28 . . . 3278 182 1 This this DT 3278 182 2 problem problem NN 3278 182 3 is be VBZ 3278 182 4 not not RB 3278 182 5 unique unique JJ 3278 182 6 to to IN 3278 182 7 XWC XWC NNP 3278 182 8 ; ; : 3278 182 9 PuBLIC public JJ 3278 182 10 LIBRARIES library NNS 3278 182 11 AND and CC 3278 182 12 INTERNET INTERNET NNP 3278 182 13 ACCESS ACCESS NNP 3278 182 14 | | NNS 3278 182 15 JAEGER jaeger NN 3278 182 16 , , , 3278 182 17 BERTOT bertot NN 3278 182 18 , , , 3278 182 19 MCCLuRE mcclure UH 3278 182 20 , , , 3278 182 21 AND and CC 3278 182 22 RODRIGuEz rodriguez NN 3278 182 23 1 1 CD 3278 182 24 � � JJ 3278 182 25 MISINFORMATION misinformation NN 3278 182 26 AND and CC 3278 182 27 BIAS bias NN 3278 182 28 IN in IN 3278 182 29 METADATA METADATA NNP 3278 182 30 PROCESSING PROCESSING NNP 3278 182 31 | | CD 3278 182 32 THORNBuRG THORNBuRG NNS 3278 182 33 AND and CC 3278 182 34 OSkINS OSkINS NNP 3278 182 35 1 1 CD 3278 182 36 � � NNS 3278 182 37 it -PRON- PRP 3278 182 38 is be VBZ 3278 182 39 a a DT 3278 182 40 challenge challenge NN 3278 182 41 for for IN 3278 182 42 any any DT 3278 182 43 shared share VBN 3278 182 44 database database NN 3278 182 45 where where WRB 3278 182 46 export export NN 3278 182 47 of of IN 3278 182 48 records record NNS 3278 182 49 and and CC 3278 182 50 reentry reentry NN 3278 182 51 is be VBZ 3278 182 52 likely likely JJ 3278 182 53 . . . 3278 183 1 Design design NN 3278 183 2 bias bias NN 3278 183 3 The the DT 3278 183 4 title title NN 3278 183 5 , , , 3278 183 6 author author NN 3278 183 7 , , , 3278 183 8 publisher publisher NN 3278 183 9 , , , 3278 183 10 place place NN 3278 183 11 of of IN 3278 183 12 publication publication NN 3278 183 13 , , , 3278 183 14 and and CC 3278 183 15 other other JJ 3278 183 16 elements element NNS 3278 183 17 of of IN 3278 183 18 a a DT 3278 183 19 record record NN 3278 183 20 , , , 3278 183 21 designed design VBN 3278 183 22 in in IN 3278 183 23 a a DT 3278 183 24 time time NN 3278 183 25 when when WRB 3278 183 26 most most JJS 3278 183 27 of of IN 3278 183 28 the the DT 3278 183 29 contents content NNS 3278 183 30 of of IN 3278 183 31 a a DT 3278 183 32 library library NN 3278 183 33 were be VBD 3278 183 34 books book NNS 3278 183 35 , , , 3278 183 36 may may MD 3278 183 37 not not RB 3278 183 38 appear appear VB 3278 183 39 as as RB 3278 183 40 clear clear JJ 3278 183 41 or or CC 3278 183 42 usable usable JJ 3278 183 43 for for IN 3278 183 44 other other JJ 3278 183 45 forms form NNS 3278 183 46 of of IN 3278 183 47 informa­ informa­ NNP 3278 183 48 tion tion NN 3278 183 49 , , , 3278 183 50 such such JJ 3278 183 51 as as IN 3278 183 52 Web web NN 3278 183 53 sites site NNS 3278 183 54 or or CC 3278 183 55 software software NN 3278 183 56 . . . 3278 184 1 There there EX 3278 184 2 is be VBZ 3278 184 3 a a DT 3278 184 4 risk risk NN 3278 184 5 to to IN 3278 184 6 any any DT 3278 184 7 design design NN 3278 184 8 of of IN 3278 184 9 a a DT 3278 184 10 representation representation NN 3278 184 11 for for IN 3278 184 12 an an DT 3278 184 13 object object NN 3278 184 14 , , , 3278 184 15 that that IN 3278 184 16 it -PRON- PRP 3278 184 17 may may MD 3278 184 18 favor favor VB 3278 184 19 distinctions distinction NNS 3278 184 20 in in IN 3278 184 21 one one CD 3278 184 22 format format NN 3278 184 23 over over IN 3278 184 24 another another DT 3278 184 25 . . . 3278 185 1 Or or CC 3278 185 2 representations representation NNS 3278 185 3 imported import VBN 3278 185 4 from from IN 3278 185 5 other other JJ 3278 185 6 schemes scheme NNS 3278 185 7 may may MD 3278 185 8 lose lose VB 3278 185 9 distinctions distinction NNS 3278 185 10 in in IN 3278 185 11 the the DT 3278 185 12 crosswalk crosswalk NN 3278 185 13 from from IN 3278 185 14 one one CD 3278 185 15 scheme scheme NN 3278 185 16 to to IN 3278 185 17 another another DT 3278 185 18 . . . 3278 186 1 A a DT 3278 186 2 crosswalk crosswalk NN 3278 186 3 is be VBZ 3278 186 4 a a DT 3278 186 5 mechanism mechanism NN 3278 186 6 for for IN 3278 186 7 the the DT 3278 186 8 mapping mapping NN 3278 186 9 of of IN 3278 186 10 data datum NNS 3278 186 11 elements element NNS 3278 186 12 / / SYM 3278 186 13 content content NN 3278 186 14 from from IN 3278 186 15 one one CD 3278 186 16 metadata metadata NN 3278 186 17 scheme scheme NN 3278 186 18 to to IN 3278 186 19 another another DT 3278 186 20 . . . 3278 187 1 Dublin Dublin NNP 3278 187 2 Core Core NNP 3278 187 3 and and CC 3278 187 4 MARC MARC NNP 3278 187 5 are be VBP 3278 187 6 just just RB 3278 187 7 two two CD 3278 187 8 examples example NNS 3278 187 9 of of IN 3278 187 10 schemes scheme NNS 3278 187 11 used use VBN 3278 187 12 by by IN 3278 187 13 library library NN 3278 187 14 professionals professional NNS 3278 187 15 . . . 3278 188 1 Software software NN 3278 188 2 exists exist VBZ 3278 188 3 to to TO 3278 188 4 convert convert VB 3278 188 5 Dublin Dublin NNP 3278 188 6 Core Core NNP 3278 188 7 metadata metadata NN 3278 188 8 to to IN 3278 188 9 MARC MARC NNP 3278 188 10 for­ for­ NNP 3278 188 11 mat mat NN 3278 188 12 , , , 3278 188 13 but but CC 3278 188 14 the the DT 3278 188 15 process process NN 3278 188 16 of of IN 3278 188 17 converting convert VBG 3278 188 18 less less RBR 3278 188 19 complex complex JJ 3278 188 20 data datum NNS 3278 188 21 to to IN 3278 188 22 a a DT 3278 188 23 scheme scheme NN 3278 188 24 of of IN 3278 188 25 more more JJR 3278 188 26 structured structured JJ 3278 188 27 data datum NNS 3278 188 28 has have VBZ 3278 188 29 inevitable inevitable JJ 3278 188 30 limita­ limita­ NNP 3278 188 31 tions tion NNS 3278 188 32 . . . 3278 189 1 For for IN 3278 189 2 instance instance NN 3278 189 3 , , , 3278 189 4 Dublin Dublin NNP 3278 189 5 Core Core NNP 3278 189 6 has have VBZ 3278 189 7 “ " `` 3278 189 8 SUBJECT subject NN 3278 189 9 ” " '' 3278 189 10 while while IN 3278 189 11 MARC MARC NNP 3278 189 12 has have VBZ 3278 189 13 dozens dozen NNS 3278 189 14 of of IN 3278 189 15 ways way NNS 3278 189 16 to to TO 3278 189 17 indicate indicate VB 3278 189 18 subject subject JJ 3278 189 19 , , , 3278 189 20 each each DT 3278 189 21 with with IN 3278 189 22 a a DT 3278 189 23 different different JJ 3278 189 24 kind kind NN 3278 189 25 of of IN 3278 189 26 designation designation NN 3278 189 27 for for IN 3278 189 28 subject subject JJ 3278 189 29 aspects aspect NNS 3278 189 30 of of IN 3278 189 31 an an DT 3278 189 32 item.25 item.25 NNP 3278 189 33 See see VB 3278 189 34 discussion discussion NN 3278 189 35 in in IN 3278 189 36 Beall.26 beall.26 PRP$ 3278 189 37 Libraries library NNS 3278 189 38 commonly commonly RB 3278 189 39 exchange exchange VBP 3278 189 40 or or CC 3278 189 41 purchase purchase NN 3278 189 42 records record NNS 3278 189 43 from from IN 3278 189 44 external external JJ 3278 189 45 sources source NNS 3278 189 46 to to TO 3278 189 47 reduce reduce VB 3278 189 48 the the DT 3278 189 49 volume volume NN 3278 189 50 or or CC 3278 189 51 costs cost NNS 3278 189 52 of of IN 3278 189 53 in­house in­house NNP 3278 189 54 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 189 55 . . . 3278 190 1 If if IN 3278 190 2 an an DT 3278 190 3 institution institution NN 3278 190 4 harvests harvest VBZ 3278 190 5 metadata metadata NN 3278 190 6 from from IN 3278 190 7 multiple multiple JJ 3278 190 8 sources source NNS 3278 190 9 , , , 3278 190 10 there there EX 3278 190 11 can can MD 3278 190 12 be be VB 3278 190 13 varying varying NN 3278 190 14 structures structure NNS 3278 190 15 , , , 3278 190 16 content content NN 3278 190 17 standards standard NNS 3278 190 18 , , , 3278 190 19 and and CC 3278 190 20 overall overall JJ 3278 190 21 quality quality NN 3278 190 22 , , , 3278 190 23 all all DT 3278 190 24 of of IN 3278 190 25 which which WDT 3278 190 26 can can MD 3278 190 27 make make VB 3278 190 28 record record JJ 3278 190 29 compari­ compari­ JJ 3278 190 30 sons son NNS 3278 190 31 error error VB 3278 190 32 prone prone JJ 3278 190 33 . . . 3278 191 1 While while IN 3278 191 2 library library NN 3278 191 3 and and CC 3278 191 4 information information NN 3278 191 5 science science NN 3278 191 6 professionals professional NNS 3278 191 7 have have VBP 3278 191 8 been be VBN 3278 191 9 creating create VBG 3278 191 10 metadata metadata NN 3278 191 11 in in IN 3278 191 12 the the DT 3278 191 13 form form NN 3278 191 14 of of IN 3278 191 15 catalog catalog NN 3278 191 16 records record NNS 3278 191 17 for for IN 3278 191 18 a a DT 3278 191 19 long long JJ 3278 191 20 time time NN 3278 191 21 , , , 3278 191 22 the the DT 3278 191 23 wider wide JJR 3278 191 24 community community NN 3278 191 25 of of IN 3278 191 26 digital digital JJ 3278 191 27 repositories repository NNS 3278 191 28 may may MD 3278 191 29 be be VB 3278 191 30 outside outside IN 3278 191 31 the the DT 3278 191 32 LIS LIS NNP 3278 191 33 commu­ commu­ NN 3278 191 34 nity nity NN 3278 191 35 , , , 3278 191 36 and and CC 3278 191 37 have have VBP 3278 191 38 varied varied JJ 3278 191 39 understanding understanding NN 3278 191 40 of of IN 3278 191 41 the the DT 3278 191 42 need need NN 3278 191 43 for for IN 3278 191 44 consistent consistent JJ 3278 191 45 representations representation NNS 3278 191 46 of of IN 3278 191 47 data datum NNS 3278 191 48 . . . 3278 192 1 Robertson Robertson NNP 3278 192 2 discusses discuss VBZ 3278 192 3 the the DT 3278 192 4 challenges challenge NNS 3278 192 5 of of IN 3278 192 6 metadata metadata NN 3278 192 7 creation creation NN 3278 192 8 outside outside IN 3278 192 9 the the DT 3278 192 10 library library NN 3278 192 11 community.27 community.27 NNP 3278 192 12 Museums Museums NNPS 3278 192 13 and and CC 3278 192 14 archives archive NNS 3278 192 15 may may MD 3278 192 16 take take VB 3278 192 17 a a DT 3278 192 18 dif­ dif­ RB 3278 192 19 ferent ferent JJ 3278 192 20 view view NN 3278 192 21 of of IN 3278 192 22 what what WDT 3278 192 23 quality quality NN 3278 192 24 standards standard NNS 3278 192 25 in in IN 3278 192 26 metadata metadata NN 3278 192 27 are be VBP 3278 192 28 . . . 3278 193 1 For for IN 3278 193 2 example example NN 3278 193 3 , , , 3278 193 4 for for IN 3278 193 5 a a DT 3278 193 6 museum museum NN 3278 193 7 , , , 3278 193 8 extensive extensive JJ 3278 193 9 detail detail NN 3278 193 10 about about IN 3278 193 11 the the DT 3278 193 12 provenance provenance NN 3278 193 13 of of IN 3278 193 14 an an DT 3278 193 15 object object NN 3278 193 16 is be VBZ 3278 193 17 necessary necessary JJ 3278 193 18 . . . 3278 194 1 Archives archive NNS 3278 194 2 often often RB 3278 194 3 record record VBP 3278 194 4 information information NN 3278 194 5 at at IN 3278 194 6 the the DT 3278 194 7 collection collection NN 3278 194 8 level level NN 3278 194 9 rather rather RB 3278 194 10 than than IN 3278 194 11 the the DT 3278 194 12 object object NN 3278 194 13 level level NN 3278 194 14 ; ; : 3278 194 15 for for IN 3278 194 16 example example NN 3278 194 17 , , , 3278 194 18 a a DT 3278 194 19 box box NN 3278 194 20 of of IN 3278 194 21 miscellaneous miscellaneous JJ 3278 194 22 papers paper NNS 3278 194 23 , , , 3278 194 24 as as IN 3278 194 25 opposed oppose VBN 3278 194 26 to to IN 3278 194 27 a a DT 3278 194 28 record record NN 3278 194 29 for for IN 3278 194 30 each each DT 3278 194 31 of of IN 3278 194 32 the the DT 3278 194 33 papers paper NNS 3278 194 34 within within IN 3278 194 35 the the DT 3278 194 36 box box NN 3278 194 37 . . . 3278 195 1 Educators educator NNS 3278 195 2 need need VBP 3278 195 3 to to TO 3278 195 4 describe describe VB 3278 195 5 resources resource NNS 3278 195 6 such such JJ 3278 195 7 as as IN 3278 195 8 learning learning NN 3278 195 9 objects object NNS 3278 195 10 . . . 3278 196 1 A a DT 3278 196 2 learning learning JJ 3278 196 3 object object NN 3278 196 4 is be VBZ 3278 196 5 any any DT 3278 196 6 entity entity NN 3278 196 7 , , , 3278 196 8 digital digital JJ 3278 196 9 or or CC 3278 196 10 nondigital nondigital JJ 3278 196 11 , , , 3278 196 12 which which WDT 3278 196 13 can can MD 3278 196 14 be be VB 3278 196 15 used use VBN 3278 196 16 , , , 3278 196 17 reused reuse VBN 3278 196 18 , , , 3278 196 19 or or CC 3278 196 20 referenced reference VBN 3278 196 21 during during IN 3278 196 22 technology­supported technology­supported NNP 3278 196 23 learning learn VBG 3278 196 24 28 28 CD 3278 196 25 For for IN 3278 196 26 these these DT 3278 196 27 objects object NNS 3278 196 28 a a DT 3278 196 29 metadata metadata NN 3278 196 30 record record NN 3278 196 31 using use VBG 3278 196 32 the the DT 3278 196 33 IEEE IEEE NNP 3278 196 34 LOM LOM NNP 3278 196 35 standard standard NN 3278 196 36 may may MD 3278 196 37 be be VB 3278 196 38 used.29 used.29 NNP 3278 196 39 While while IN 3278 196 40 this this DT 3278 196 41 is be VBZ 3278 196 42 as as RB 3278 196 43 complex complex JJ 3278 196 44 as as IN 3278 196 45 a a DT 3278 196 46 MARC MARC NNP 3278 196 47 record record NN 3278 196 48 , , , 3278 196 49 it -PRON- PRP 3278 196 50 has have VBZ 3278 196 51 less less JJR 3278 196 52 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 196 53 description description NN 3278 196 54 and and CC 3278 196 55 more more JJR 3278 196 56 focus focus NN 3278 196 57 on on IN 3278 196 58 description description NN 3278 196 59 of of IN 3278 196 60 the the DT 3278 196 61 nature nature NN 3278 196 62 and and CC 3278 196 63 use use NN 3278 196 64 of of IN 3278 196 65 the the DT 3278 196 66 learning learning NN 3278 196 67 object object NN 3278 196 68 . . . 3278 197 1 In in IN 3278 197 2 short short JJ 3278 197 3 , , , 3278 197 4 for for IN 3278 197 5 one one CD 3278 197 6 type type NN 3278 197 7 of of IN 3278 197 8 institution institution NN 3278 197 9 the the DT 3278 197 10 notion notion NN 3278 197 11 of of IN 3278 197 12 appropriate appropriate JJ 3278 197 13 granularity granularity NN 3278 197 14 of of IN 3278 197 15 description description NN 3278 197 16 may may MD 3278 197 17 be be VB 3278 197 18 too too RB 3278 197 19 detailed detailed JJ 3278 197 20 or or CC 3278 197 21 too too RB 3278 197 22 vague vague JJ 3278 197 23 for for IN 3278 197 24 the the DT 3278 197 25 needs need NNS 3278 197 26 of of IN 3278 197 27 another another DT 3278 197 28 type type NN 3278 197 29 of of IN 3278 197 30 institution institution NN 3278 197 31 . . . 3278 198 1 Judgment judgment NN 3278 198 2 calls call VBZ 3278 198 3 Two two CD 3278 198 4 persons person NNS 3278 198 5 creating create VBG 3278 198 6 independent independent JJ 3278 198 7 records record NNS 3278 198 8 for for IN 3278 198 9 the the DT 3278 198 10 same same JJ 3278 198 11 item item NN 3278 198 12 exercise exercise NN 3278 198 13 judgment judgment NN 3278 198 14 in in IN 3278 198 15 describing describe VBG 3278 198 16 what what WP 3278 198 17 is be VBZ 3278 198 18 most most JJS 3278 198 19 impor­ impor­ NNP 3278 198 20 tant tant NN 3278 198 21 about about IN 3278 198 22 the the DT 3278 198 23 object object NN 3278 198 24 . . . 3278 199 1 One one PRP 3278 199 2 may may MD 3278 199 3 say say VB 3278 199 4 it -PRON- PRP 3278 199 5 is be VBZ 3278 199 6 a a DT 3278 199 7 book book NN 3278 199 8 with with IN 3278 199 9 an an DT 3278 199 10 accompanying accompany VBG 3278 199 11 CD cd NN 3278 199 12 , , , 3278 199 13 another another DT 3278 199 14 may may MD 3278 199 15 say say VB 3278 199 16 it -PRON- PRP 3278 199 17 is be VBZ 3278 199 18 software software NN 3278 199 19 on on IN 3278 199 20 a a DT 3278 199 21 CD CD NNP 3278 199 22 , , , 3278 199 23 accompanied accompany VBN 3278 199 24 by by IN 3278 199 25 a a DT 3278 199 26 book book NN 3278 199 27 of of IN 3278 199 28 documentation documentation NN 3278 199 29 . . . 3278 200 1 Another another DT 3278 200 2 example example NN 3278 200 3 of of IN 3278 200 4 legitimate legitimate JJ 3278 200 5 variation variation NN 3278 200 6 is be VBZ 3278 200 7 the the DT 3278 200 8 choice choice NN 3278 200 9 of of IN 3278 200 10 use use NN 3278 200 11 of of IN 3278 200 12 ellipses ellipsis NNS 3278 200 13 [ [ -LRB- 3278 200 14 … … NFP 3278 200 15 ] ] -RRB- 3278 200 16 to to TO 3278 200 17 leave leave VB 3278 200 18 out out RP 3278 200 19 parts part NNS 3278 200 20 of of IN 3278 200 21 long long JJ 3278 200 22 titles title NNS 3278 200 23 in in IN 3278 200 24 a a DT 3278 200 25 metadata metadata NN 3278 200 26 description description NN 3278 200 27 . . . 3278 201 1 One one CD 3278 201 2 record record NN 3278 201 3 creator creator NN 3278 201 4 may may MD 3278 201 5 list list VB 3278 201 6 the the DT 3278 201 7 whole whole JJ 3278 201 8 title title NN 3278 201 9 , , , 3278 201 10 another another DT 3278 201 11 may may MD 3278 201 12 list list VB 3278 201 13 only only RB 3278 201 14 the the DT 3278 201 15 first first JJ 3278 201 16 part part NN 3278 201 17 followed follow VBN 3278 201 18 by by IN 3278 201 19 the the DT 3278 201 20 mark mark NN 3278 201 21 of of IN 3278 201 22 ellipsis ellipsis NN 3278 201 23 to to TO 3278 201 24 indicate indicate VB 3278 201 25 abbreviation abbreviation NN 3278 201 26 of of IN 3278 201 27 the the DT 3278 201 28 lengthy lengthy JJ 3278 201 29 title title NN 3278 201 30 . . . 3278 202 1 Either either CC 3278 202 2 is be VBZ 3278 202 3 correct correct JJ 3278 202 4 , , , 3278 202 5 but but CC 3278 202 6 may may MD 3278 202 7 not not RB 3278 202 8 match match VB 3278 202 9 each each DT 3278 202 10 other other JJ 3278 202 11 without without IN 3278 202 12 special special JJ 3278 202 13 techniques technique NNS 3278 202 14 . . . 3278 203 1 See see VB 3278 203 2 appendix appendix NNP 3278 203 3 B B NNP 3278 203 4 for for IN 3278 203 5 the the DT 3278 203 6 perils peril NNS 3278 203 7 of of IN 3278 203 8 ellipsis ellipsis NN 3278 203 9 handling handling NN 3278 203 10 . . . 3278 204 1 The the DT 3278 204 2 form form NN 3278 204 3 of of IN 3278 204 4 name name NN 3278 204 5 of of IN 3278 204 6 a a DT 3278 204 7 publisher publisher NN 3278 204 8 , , , 3278 204 9 given give VBN 3278 204 10 other other JJ 3278 204 11 occur­ occur­ NNP 3278 204 12 rences rence NNS 3278 204 13 of of IN 3278 204 14 a a DT 3278 204 15 publisher publisher NN 3278 204 16 name name NN 3278 204 17 in in IN 3278 204 18 a a DT 3278 204 19 record record NN 3278 204 20 , , , 3278 204 21 may may MD 3278 204 22 be be VB 3278 204 23 abbrevi­ abbrevi­ NNP 3278 204 24 ated ate VBN 3278 204 25 . . . 3278 205 1 For for IN 3278 205 2 instance instance NN 3278 205 3 , , , 3278 205 4 in in IN 3278 205 5 one one CD 3278 205 6 place place NN 3278 205 7 the the DT 3278 205 8 corporate corporate JJ 3278 205 9 author author NN 3278 205 10 who who WP 3278 205 11 is be VBZ 3278 205 12 also also RB 3278 205 13 the the DT 3278 205 14 publisher publisher NN 3278 205 15 might may MD 3278 205 16 be be VB 3278 205 17 listed list VBN 3278 205 18 in in IN 3278 205 19 the the DT 3278 205 20 author author NN 3278 205 21 field field NN 3278 205 22 as as IN 3278 205 23 “ " `` 3278 205 24 Department Department NNP 3278 205 25 of of IN 3278 205 26 Health Health NNP 3278 205 27 and and CC 3278 205 28 Human Human NNP 3278 205 29 Services Services NNPS 3278 205 30 ” " '' 3278 205 31 and and CC 3278 205 32 then then RB 3278 205 33 abbreviated abbreviate VBN 3278 205 34 — — : 3278 205 35 or or CC 3278 205 36 not not RB 3278 205 37 — — : 3278 205 38 in in IN 3278 205 39 the the DT 3278 205 40 publisher publisher NN 3278 205 41 area area NN 3278 205 42 as as IN 3278 205 43 “ " `` 3278 205 44 The the DT 3278 205 45 Department Department NNP 3278 205 46 . . . 3278 205 47 ” " '' 3278 205 48 Note note VB 3278 205 49 that that IN 3278 205 50 there there EX 3278 205 51 are be VBP 3278 205 52 limitations limitation NNS 3278 205 53 inherent inherent JJ 3278 205 54 to to IN 3278 205 55 the the DT 3278 205 56 valida­ valida­ NNP 3278 205 57 tion tion NN 3278 205 58 of of IN 3278 205 59 any any DT 3278 205 60 system system NN 3278 205 61 of of IN 3278 205 62 matching matching NN 3278 205 63 , , , 3278 205 64 in in IN 3278 205 65 that that DT 3278 205 66 human human JJ 3278 205 67 reviewers reviewer NNS 3278 205 68 may may MD 3278 205 69 not not RB 3278 205 70 be be VB 3278 205 71 able able JJ 3278 205 72 to to TO 3278 205 73 determine determine VB 3278 205 74 whether whether IN 3278 205 75 two two CD 3278 205 76 representa­ representa­ JJ 3278 205 77 tions tion NNS 3278 205 78 in in IN 3278 205 79 fact fact NN 3278 205 80 describe describe VB 3278 205 81 the the DT 3278 205 82 same same JJ 3278 205 83 item item NN 3278 205 84 . . . 3278 206 1 Structural structural JJ 3278 206 2 bias bias NN 3278 206 3 1 1 CD 3278 206 4 . . . 3278 207 1 Process process NN 3278 207 2 bias bias NN 3278 207 3 refers refer VBZ 3278 207 4 to to IN 3278 207 5 any any DT 3278 207 6 features feature NNS 3278 207 7 of of IN 3278 207 8 the the DT 3278 207 9 software software NN 3278 207 10 which which WDT 3278 207 11 at at IN 3278 207 12 run­time run­time NN 3278 207 13 may may MD 3278 207 14 change change VB 3278 207 15 the the DT 3278 207 16 way way NN 3278 207 17 matching matching NN 3278 207 18 is be VBZ 3278 207 19 carried carry VBN 3278 207 20 out out RP 3278 207 21 , , , 3278 207 22 whether whether IN 3278 207 23 by by IN 3278 207 24 shortening shorten VBG 3278 207 25 or or CC 3278 207 26 lengthen­ lengthen­ NNP 3278 207 27 ing e VBG 3278 207 28 the the DT 3278 207 29 analysis analysis NN 3278 207 30 , , , 3278 207 31 or or CC 3278 207 32 otherwise otherwise RB 3278 207 33 branching branch VBG 3278 207 34 the the DT 3278 207 35 logical logical JJ 3278 207 36 flow flow NN 3278 207 37 . . . 3278 208 1 This this DT 3278 208 2 can can MD 3278 208 3 arise arise VB 3278 208 4 from from IN 3278 208 5 many many JJ 3278 208 6 sources source NNS 3278 208 7 , , , 3278 208 8 including include VBG 3278 208 9 but but CC 3278 208 10 not not RB 3278 208 11 limited limited JJ 3278 208 12 to to IN 3278 208 13 the the DT 3278 208 14 following follow VBG 3278 208 15 factors factor NNS 3278 208 16 . . . 3278 209 1 a. a. NN 3278 210 1 There there EX 3278 210 2 is be VBZ 3278 210 3 need need NN 3278 210 4 for for IN 3278 210 5 efficient efficient JJ 3278 210 6 processing processing NN 3278 210 7 of of IN 3278 210 8 large large JJ 3278 210 9 num­ num­ JJ 3278 210 10 bers ber NNS 3278 210 11 of of IN 3278 210 12 incoming incoming JJ 3278 210 13 records record NNS 3278 210 14 . . . 3278 211 1 This this DT 3278 211 2 can can MD 3278 211 3 force force VB 3278 211 4 an an DT 3278 211 5 empha­ empha­ NN 3278 211 6 sis sis NN 3278 211 7 on on IN 3278 211 8 speedy speedy JJ 3278 211 9 matching matching NN 3278 211 10 . . . 3278 212 1 That that RB 3278 212 2 is is RB 3278 212 3 , , , 3278 212 4 matching match VBG 3278 212 5 not not RB 3278 212 6 required require VBN 3278 212 7 to to TO 3278 212 8 replace replace VB 3278 212 9 records record NNS 3278 212 10 tends tend VBZ 3278 212 11 to to TO 3278 212 12 be be VB 3278 212 13 optimized optimize VBN 3278 212 14 to to TO 3278 212 15 stop stop VB 3278 212 16 searching search VBG 3278 212 17 / / SYM 3278 212 18 matching match VBG 3278 212 19 as as RB 3278 212 20 early early RB 3278 212 21 as as IN 3278 212 22 is be VBZ 3278 212 23 reason­ reason­ NN 3278 212 24 able able JJ 3278 212 25 . . . 3278 213 1 In in IN 3278 213 2 the the DT 3278 213 3 case case NN 3278 213 4 where where WRB 3278 213 5 unique unique JJ 3278 213 6 key key JJ 3278 213 7 searching searching NN 3278 213 8 finds find VBZ 3278 213 9 a a DT 3278 213 10 single single JJ 3278 213 11 match match NN 3278 213 12 to to IN 3278 213 13 an an DT 3278 213 14 incoming incoming JJ 3278 213 15 record record NN 3278 213 16 , , , 3278 213 17 it -PRON- PRP 3278 213 18 is be VBZ 3278 213 19 fairly fairly RB 3278 213 20 easy easy JJ 3278 213 21 for for IN 3278 213 22 the the DT 3278 213 23 software software NN 3278 213 24 to to TO 3278 213 25 “ " `` 3278 213 26 justify justify VB 3278 213 27 ” " '' 3278 213 28 stopping stopping NN 3278 213 29 . . . 3278 214 1 If if IN 3278 214 2 there there EX 3278 214 3 are be VBP 3278 214 4 multiple multiple JJ 3278 214 5 matches match NNS 3278 214 6 found find VBN 3278 214 7 , , , 3278 214 8 more more JJR 3278 214 9 analysis analysis NN 3278 214 10 may may MD 3278 214 11 be be VB 3278 214 12 needed need VBN 3278 214 13 before before IN 3278 214 14 the the DT 3278 214 15 decision decision NN 3278 214 16 to to TO 3278 214 17 stop stop VB 3278 214 18 matching match VBG 3278 214 19 can can MD 3278 214 20 be be VB 3278 214 21 made make VBN 3278 214 22 . . . 3278 215 1 Over over IN 3278 215 2 time time NN 3278 215 3 the the DT 3278 215 4 numbers number NNS 3278 215 5 of of IN 3278 215 6 records record NNS 3278 215 7 processed process VBN 3278 215 8 has have VBZ 3278 215 9 increased increase VBN 3278 215 10 enormously enormously RB 3278 215 11 . . . 3278 216 1 b. b. NNP 3278 217 1 Matching match VBG 3278 217 2 needs need VBZ 3278 217 3 to to TO 3278 217 4 exploit exploit VB 3278 217 5 “ " `` 3278 217 6 unique unique JJ 3278 217 7 ” " '' 3278 217 8 keys key NNS 3278 217 9 to to TO 3278 217 10 speed speed NN 3278 217 11 searching searching NN 3278 217 12 , , , 3278 217 13 yet yet CC 3278 217 14 these these DT 3278 217 15 may may MD 3278 217 16 not not RB 3278 217 17 prove prove VB 3278 217 18 to to TO 3278 217 19 be be VB 3278 217 20 unique unique JJ 3278 217 21 . . . 3278 218 1 Though though IN 3278 218 2 agreements agreement NNS 3278 218 3 are be VBP 3278 218 4 in in IN 3278 218 5 place place NN 3278 218 6 for for IN 3278 218 7 use use NN 3278 218 8 of of IN 3278 218 9 numeric numeric JJ 3278 218 10 keys key NNS 3278 218 11 such such JJ 3278 218 12 as as IN 3278 218 13 ISBNs ISBNs NNPS 3278 218 14 , , , 3278 218 15 creation creation NN 3278 218 16 of of IN 3278 218 17 these these DT 3278 218 18 keys key NNS 3278 218 19 is be VBZ 3278 218 20 not not RB 3278 218 21 under under IN 3278 218 22 the the DT 3278 218 23 control control NN 3278 218 24 of of IN 3278 218 25 any any DT 3278 218 26 one one CD 3278 218 27 organization organization NN 3278 218 28 . . . 3278 219 1 20 20 CD 3278 219 2 INFORMATION information NN 3278 219 3 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3278 219 4 AND and CC 3278 219 5 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 219 6 | | NNP 3278 219 7 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 219 8 200720 200720 CD 3278 219 9 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3278 219 10 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3278 219 11 AND and CC 3278 219 12 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 219 13 | | NNP 3278 219 14 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 219 15 2007 2007 CD 3278 219 16 c. c. NN 3278 219 17 Problems Problems NNPS 3278 219 18 arise arise VBP 3278 219 19 when when WRB 3278 219 20 brief brief JJ 3278 219 21 records record NNS 3278 219 22 are be VBP 3278 219 23 com­ com­ NNP 3278 219 24 pared pare VBN 3278 219 25 with with IN 3278 219 26 fuller full JJR 3278 219 27 records record NNS 3278 219 28 . . . 3278 220 1 Comparisons comparison NNS 3278 220 2 may may MD 3278 220 3 be be VB 3278 220 4 biased bias VBN 3278 220 5 inadvertently inadvertently RB 3278 220 6 towards towards IN 3278 220 7 false false JJ 3278 220 8 matches match NNS 3278 220 9 . . . 3278 221 1 Such such JJ 3278 221 2 sparseness sparseness NN 3278 221 3 of of IN 3278 221 4 data datum NNS 3278 221 5 has have VBZ 3278 221 6 been be VBN 3278 221 7 identified identify VBN 3278 221 8 as as IN 3278 221 9 a a DT 3278 221 10 problem problem NN 3278 221 11 in in IN 3278 221 12 RLIN RLIN NNP 3278 221 13 matching match VBG 3278 221 14 as as RB 3278 221 15 well well RB 3278 221 16 as as IN 3278 221 17 in in IN 3278 221 18 XWC XWC NNP 3278 221 19 . . . 3278 222 1 d. d. NNP 3278 222 2 At at IN 3278 222 3 the the DT 3278 222 4 same same JJ 3278 222 5 time time NN 3278 222 6 there there EX 3278 222 7 is be VBZ 3278 222 8 bias bias NN 3278 222 9 toward toward IN 3278 222 10 less less JJR 3278 222 11 generic generic JJ 3278 222 12 titles title NNS 3278 222 13 in in IN 3278 222 14 matching matching NN 3278 222 15 . . . 3278 223 1 Requirements requirement NNS 3278 223 2 of of IN 3278 223 3 sys­ sys­ CD 3278 223 4 tem tem NN 3278 223 5 throughput throughput NN 3278 223 6 mandate mandate VBP 3278 223 7 an an DT 3278 223 8 upper upper JJ 3278 223 9 limit limit NN 3278 223 10 on on IN 3278 223 11 the the DT 3278 223 12 size size NN 3278 223 13 of of IN 3278 223 14 result result NN 3278 223 15 set set VBD 3278 223 16 that that IN 3278 223 17 the the DT 3278 223 18 matching match VBG 3278 223 19 software software NN 3278 223 20 will will MD 3278 223 21 even even RB 3278 223 22 attempt attempt VB 3278 223 23 to to TO 3278 223 24 analyze analyze VB 3278 223 25 . . . 3278 224 1 This this DT 3278 224 2 upper upper JJ 3278 224 3 limit limit NN 3278 224 4 could could MD 3278 224 5 tend tend VB 3278 224 6 to to TO 3278 224 7 discriminate discriminate VB 3278 224 8 against against IN 3278 224 9 effective effective JJ 3278 224 10 retrieval retrieval NN 3278 224 11 of of IN 3278 224 12 generic generic JJ 3278 224 13 titles title NNS 3278 224 14 . . . 3278 225 1 Matching Matching NNP 3278 225 2 will will MD 3278 225 3 reject reject VB 3278 225 4 very very RB 3278 225 5 large large JJ 3278 225 6 results result NNS 3278 225 7 sets set NNS 3278 225 8 of of IN 3278 225 9 searches search NNS 3278 225 10 . . . 3278 226 1 So so RB 3278 226 2 the the DT 3278 226 3 query query NN 3278 226 4 that that WDT 3278 226 5 has have VBZ 3278 226 6 fewer few JJR 3278 226 7 title title NN 3278 226 8 terms term NNS 3278 226 9 may may MD 3278 226 10 tend tend VB 3278 226 11 to to TO 3278 226 12 retrieve retrieve VB 3278 226 13 too too RB 3278 226 14 much much RB 3278 226 15 . . . 3278 227 1 Titles title NNS 3278 227 2 such such JJ 3278 227 3 as as IN 3278 227 4 “ " `` 3278 227 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNPS 3278 227 6 ” " '' 3278 227 7 or or CC 3278 227 8 “ " `` 3278 227 9 Bulletin Bulletin NNP 3278 227 10 ” " '' 3278 227 11 may may MD 3278 227 12 be be VB 3278 227 13 difficult difficult JJ 3278 227 14 to to TO 3278 227 15 match match VB 3278 227 16 if if IN 3278 227 17 insufficient insufficient JJ 3278 227 18 other other JJ 3278 227 19 informa­ informa­ NNP 3278 227 20 tion tion NN 3278 227 21 is be VBZ 3278 227 22 present present JJ 3278 227 23 in in IN 3278 227 24 the the DT 3278 227 25 record record NN 3278 227 26 for for IN 3278 227 27 the the DT 3278 227 28 query query NN 3278 227 29 to to TO 3278 227 30 use use VB 3278 227 31 . . . 3278 228 1 Ironically ironically RB 3278 228 2 this this DT 3278 228 3 can can MD 3278 228 4 mean mean VB 3278 228 5 addition addition NN 3278 228 6 of of IN 3278 228 7 more more JJR 3278 228 8 generic generic JJ 3278 228 9 titles title NNS 3278 228 10 to to IN 3278 228 11 the the DT 3278 228 12 database database NN 3278 228 13 , , , 3278 228 14 since since IN 3278 228 15 what what WP 3278 228 16 is be VBZ 3278 228 17 there there EX 3278 228 18 is be VBZ 3278 228 19 in in IN 3278 228 20 effect effect NN 3278 228 21 less less RBR 3278 228 22 findable findable JJ 3278 228 23 . . . 3278 229 1 e. e. NNP 3278 229 2 Transparency Transparency NNP 3278 229 3 can can MD 3278 229 4 contribute contribute VB 3278 229 5 to to IN 3278 229 6 bias bias NN 3278 229 7 in in IN 3278 229 8 that that DT 3278 229 9 , , , 3278 229 10 for for IN 3278 229 11 each each DT 3278 229 12 layer layer NN 3278 229 13 of of IN 3278 229 14 transparency transparency NN 3278 229 15 a a DT 3278 229 16 layer layer NN 3278 229 17 of of IN 3278 229 18 opacity opacity NN 3278 229 19 may may MD 3278 229 20 be be VB 3278 229 21 added add VBN 3278 229 22 , , , 3278 229 23 when when WRB 3278 229 24 information information NN 3278 229 25 is be VBZ 3278 229 26 filtered filter VBN 3278 229 27 out out RP 3278 229 28 from from IN 3278 229 29 a a DT 3278 229 30 user user NN 3278 229 31 ’s ’s POS 3278 229 32 view view NN 3278 229 33 . . . 3278 230 1 That that DT 3278 230 2 user user NN 3278 230 3 may may MD 3278 230 4 be be VB 3278 230 5 a a DT 3278 230 6 human human NN 3278 230 7 or or CC 3278 230 8 an an DT 3278 230 9 application application NN 3278 230 10 . . . 3278 231 1 OpenURL OpenURL `` 3278 231 2 access access NN 3278 231 3 to to IN 3278 231 4 “ " `` 3278 231 5 appropriate appropriate JJ 3278 231 6 copy copy NN 3278 231 7 ” " '' 3278 231 8 is be VBZ 3278 231 9 an an DT 3278 231 10 example example NN 3278 231 11 from from IN 3278 231 12 the the DT 3278 231 13 standards standard NNS 3278 231 14 world world NN 3278 231 15 . . . 3278 232 1 The the DT 3278 232 2 complexity complexity NN 3278 232 3 of of IN 3278 232 4 choosing choose VBG 3278 232 5 among among IN 3278 232 6 multiple multiple JJ 3278 232 7 online online JJ 3278 232 8 copies copy NNS 3278 232 9 has have VBZ 3278 232 10 become become VBN 3278 232 11 known know VBN 3278 232 12 as as IN 3278 232 13 the the DT 3278 232 14 “ " `` 3278 232 15 appro­ appro­ NNP 3278 232 16 priate priate NNP 3278 232 17 copy copy NN 3278 232 18 ” " '' 3278 232 19 problem problem NN 3278 232 20 . . . 3278 233 1 There there EX 3278 233 2 are be VBP 3278 233 3 a a DT 3278 233 4 number number NN 3278 233 5 of of IN 3278 233 6 instances instance NNS 3278 233 7 where where WRB 3278 233 8 more more JJR 3278 233 9 than than IN 3278 233 10 one one CD 3278 233 11 legitimate legitimate JJ 3278 233 12 copy copy NN 3278 233 13 of of IN 3278 233 14 an an DT 3278 233 15 electronic electronic JJ 3278 233 16 article article NN 3278 233 17 may may MD 3278 233 18 exist exist VB 3278 233 19 , , , 3278 233 20 such such JJ 3278 233 21 as as IN 3278 233 22 mir­ mir­ XX 3278 233 23 roring rore VBG 3278 233 24 or or CC 3278 233 25 aggregator aggregator NN 3278 233 26 databases database NNS 3278 233 27 . . . 3278 234 1 It -PRON- PRP 3278 234 2 is be VBZ 3278 234 3 essentially essentially RB 3278 234 4 a a DT 3278 234 5 problem problem NN 3278 234 6 of of IN 3278 234 7 where where WRB 3278 234 8 and and CC 3278 234 9 how how WRB 3278 234 10 to to TO 3278 234 11 introduce introduce VB 3278 234 12 localiza­ localiza­ CD 3278 234 13 tion tion NN 3278 234 14 into into IN 3278 234 15 the the DT 3278 234 16 linking link VBG 3278 234 17 process.30 process.30 NNP 3278 234 18 Appropriateness Appropriateness NNP 3278 234 19 reflects reflect VBZ 3278 234 20 the the DT 3278 234 21 user user NN 3278 234 22 ’s ’s POS 3278 234 23 context context NN 3278 234 24 , , , 3278 234 25 e.g. e.g. RB 3278 234 26 , , , 3278 234 27 location location NN 3278 234 28 , , , 3278 234 29 license license NN 3278 234 30 agreements agreement NNS 3278 234 31 in in IN 3278 234 32 place place NN 3278 234 33 , , , 3278 234 34 cost cost NN 3278 234 35 , , , 3278 234 36 and and CC 3278 234 37 other other JJ 3278 234 38 factors factor NNS 3278 234 39 . . . 3278 235 1 2 2 LS 3278 235 2 . . . 3278 236 1 Systems system NNS 3278 236 2 bias bias NN 3278 236 3 . . . 3278 237 1 What what WP 3278 237 2 is be VBZ 3278 237 3 this this DT 3278 237 4 , , , 3278 237 5 really really RB 3278 237 6 ? ? . 3278 238 1 The the DT 3278 238 2 database database NN 3278 238 3 can can MD 3278 238 4 be be VB 3278 238 5 seen see VBN 3278 238 6 as as IN 3278 238 7 “ " `` 3278 238 8 agent agent NN 3278 238 9 . . . 3278 238 10 ” " '' 3278 238 11 The the DT 3278 238 12 weight weight NN 3278 238 13 of of IN 3278 238 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 238 15 own own JJ 3278 238 16 mass mass NN 3278 238 17 may may MD 3278 238 18 affect affect VB 3278 238 19 efforts effort NNS 3278 238 20 to to TO 3278 238 21 use use VB 3278 238 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 238 23 contents content NNS 3278 238 24 . . . 3278 239 1 a. a. NN 3278 240 1 For for IN 3278 240 2 maintainers maintainer NNS 3278 240 3 of of IN 3278 240 4 large large JJ 3278 240 5 database database NN 3278 240 6 systems system NNS 3278 240 7 , , , 3278 240 8 the the DT 3278 240 9 goals goal NNS 3278 240 10 of of IN 3278 240 11 database database NN 3278 240 12 repository repository NN 3278 240 13 and and CC 3278 240 14 search search NN 3278 240 15 engine engine NN 3278 240 16 may may MD 3278 240 17 be be VB 3278 240 18 somewhat somewhat RB 3278 240 19 at at IN 3278 240 20 odds odd NNS 3278 240 21 . . . 3278 241 1 Yet yet CC 3278 241 2 librarians librarian NNS 3278 241 3 do do VBP 3278 241 4 make make VB 3278 241 5 use use NN 3278 241 6 of of IN 3278 241 7 the the DT 3278 241 8 database database NN 3278 241 9 as as IN 3278 241 10 reference reference NN 3278 241 11 source source NN 3278 241 12 . . . 3278 242 1 b. b. NNP 3278 243 1 Search search NN 3278 243 2 strategies strategy NNS 3278 243 3 for for IN 3278 243 4 the the DT 3278 243 5 software software NN 3278 243 6 that that WDT 3278 243 7 acts act VBZ 3278 243 8 as as IN 3278 243 9 a a DT 3278 243 10 user user NN 3278 243 11 of of IN 3278 243 12 the the DT 3278 243 13 database database NN 3278 243 14 is be VBZ 3278 243 15 necessarily necessarily RB 3278 243 16 developed develop VBN 3278 243 17 and and CC 3278 243 18 optimized optimize VBN 3278 243 19 at at IN 3278 243 20 a a DT 3278 243 21 certain certain JJ 3278 243 22 point point NN 3278 243 23 in in IN 3278 243 24 time time NN 3278 243 25 . . . 3278 244 1 Yet yet RB 3278 244 2 a a DT 3278 244 3 river river NN 3278 244 4 of of IN 3278 244 5 new new JJ 3278 244 6 information information NN 3278 244 7 flows flow VBZ 3278 244 8 into into IN 3278 244 9 this this DT 3278 244 10 data­ data­ NNP 3278 244 11 base base NN 3278 244 12 . . . 3278 245 1 1 1 LS 3278 245 2 . . . 3278 246 1 If if IN 3278 246 2 the the DT 3278 246 3 numbers number NNS 3278 246 4 of of IN 3278 246 5 types type NNS 3278 246 6 of of IN 3278 246 7 entries entry NNS 3278 246 8 in in IN 3278 246 9 various various JJ 3278 246 10 database database NN 3278 246 11 indexes index NNS 3278 246 12 grows grow VBZ 3278 246 13 nonproportion­ nonproportion­ CD 3278 246 14 ally ally NN 3278 246 15 , , , 3278 246 16 search search NN 3278 246 17 strategies strategy NNS 3278 246 18 that that WDT 3278 246 19 worked work VBD 3278 246 20 well well RB 3278 246 21 in in IN 3278 246 22 the the DT 3278 246 23 past past NN 3278 246 24 could could MD 3278 246 25 potentially potentially RB 3278 246 26 fall fall VB 3278 246 27 “ " `` 3278 246 28 out out IN 3278 246 29 of of IN 3278 246 30 tune tune NN 3278 246 31 ” " '' 3278 246 32 with with IN 3278 246 33 the the DT 3278 246 34 database database NN 3278 246 35 contents content NNS 3278 246 36 . . . 3278 247 1 See see VB 3278 247 2 Growth growth NN 3278 247 3 of of IN 3278 247 4 the the DT 3278 247 5 Environment Environment NNP 3278 247 6 section section NN 3278 247 7 below below RB 3278 247 8 . . . 3278 248 1 2 2 LS 3278 248 2 . . . 3278 249 1 Change change NN 3278 249 2 in in IN 3278 249 3 proportions proportion NNS 3278 249 4 of of IN 3278 249 5 languages language NNS 3278 249 6 in in IN 3278 249 7 the the DT 3278 249 8 database database NN 3278 249 9 may may MD 3278 249 10 render render VB 3278 249 11 an an DT 3278 249 12 application application NN 3278 249 13 ’s ’s POS 3278 249 14 use use NN 3278 249 15 of of IN 3278 249 16 stopword stopword NN 3278 249 17 lists list NNS 3278 249 18 less less RBR 3278 249 19 effective effective JJ 3278 249 20 . . . 3278 250 1 3 3 LS 3278 250 2 . . . 3278 251 1 If if IN 3278 251 2 changes change NNS 3278 251 3 in in IN 3278 251 4 technology technology NN 3278 251 5 or or CC 3278 251 6 practice practice NN 3278 251 7 result result NN 3278 251 8 in in IN 3278 251 9 new new JJ 3278 251 10 forms form NNS 3278 251 11 of of IN 3278 251 12 material material NN 3278 251 13 being be VBG 3278 251 14 described describe VBN 3278 251 15 in in IN 3278 251 16 the the DT 3278 251 17 database database NN 3278 251 18 , , , 3278 251 19 the the DT 3278 251 20 software software NN 3278 251 21 searches search NNS 3278 251 22 using use VBG 3278 251 23 material material NN 3278 251 24 type type NN 3278 251 25 as as IN 3278 251 26 a a DT 3278 251 27 limiter limiter NN 3278 251 28 may may MD 3278 251 29 not not RB 3278 251 30 work work VB 3278 251 31 properly properly RB 3278 251 32 . . . 3278 252 1 The the DT 3278 252 2 software software NN 3278 252 3 is be VBZ 3278 252 4 using use VBG 3278 252 5 abstractions abstraction NNS 3278 252 6 provided provide VBN 3278 252 7 by by IN 3278 252 8 the the DT 3278 252 9 database database NN 3278 252 10 , , , 3278 252 11 and and CC 3278 252 12 they -PRON- PRP 3278 252 13 need need VBP 3278 252 14 to to TO 3278 252 15 be be VB 3278 252 16 kept keep VBN 3278 252 17 synchronized synchronize VBN 3278 252 18 . . . 3278 253 1 c. c. NNP 3278 253 2 Automated Automated NNP 3278 253 3 query query NN 3278 253 4 construction construction NN 3278 253 5 presents present VBZ 3278 253 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 253 7 own own JJ 3278 253 8 problems problem NNS 3278 253 9 . . . 3278 254 1 The the DT 3278 254 2 use use NN 3278 254 3 of of IN 3278 254 4 Boolean Boolean NNP 3278 254 5 searching search VBG 3278 254 6 [ [ -LRB- 3278 254 7 term term NN 3278 254 8 A a NN 3278 254 9 and and CC 3278 254 10 term term NN 3278 254 11 B b NN 3278 254 12 and and CC 3278 254 13 term term NN 3278 254 14 C c NN 3278 254 15 ] ] -RRB- 3278 254 16 is be VBZ 3278 254 17 quite quite RB 3278 254 18 restrictive restrictive JJ 3278 254 19 in in IN 3278 254 20 the the DT 3278 254 21 sense sense NN 3278 254 22 that that IN 3278 254 23 there there EX 3278 254 24 is be VBZ 3278 254 25 no no DT 3278 254 26 “ " `` 3278 254 27 halfway halfway NN 3278 254 28 ” " '' 3278 254 29 or or CC 3278 254 30 flex flex NN 3278 254 31 for for IN 3278 254 32 a a DT 3278 254 33 record record NN 3278 254 34 being be VBG 3278 254 35 included include VBN 3278 254 36 in in IN 3278 254 37 a a DT 3278 254 38 set set NN 3278 254 39 of of IN 3278 254 40 candidates candidate NNS 3278 254 41 . . . 3278 255 1 Matching matching NN 3278 255 2 starts start VBZ 3278 255 3 with with IN 3278 255 4 the the DT 3278 255 5 most most RBS 3278 255 6 specific specific JJ 3278 255 7 search search NN 3278 255 8 to to TO 3278 255 9 avoid avoid VB 3278 255 10 too­high too­high JJ 3278 255 11 numbers number NNS 3278 255 12 of of IN 3278 255 13 records record NNS 3278 255 14 retrieved retrieve VBN 3278 255 15 , , , 3278 255 16 and and CC 3278 255 17 all all DT 3278 255 18 it -PRON- PRP 3278 255 19 can can MD 3278 255 20 do do VB 3278 255 21 is be VBZ 3278 255 22 drop drop VB 3278 255 23 or or CC 3278 255 24 rearrange rearrange VB 3278 255 25 terms term NNS 3278 255 26 from from IN 3278 255 27 a a DT 3278 255 28 query query NN 3278 255 29 in in IN 3278 255 30 the the DT 3278 255 31 effort effort NN 3278 255 32 to to TO 3278 255 33 broaden broaden VB 3278 255 34 the the DT 3278 255 35 results result NNS 3278 255 36 . . . 3278 256 1 d. d. NNP 3278 256 2 Disconnects Disconnects NNP 3278 256 3 in in IN 3278 256 4 metadata metadata NN 3278 256 5 object object VBP 3278 256 6 creation creation NN 3278 256 7 / / SYM 3278 256 8 revision revision NN 3278 256 9 are be VBP 3278 256 10 another another DT 3278 256 11 problem problem NN 3278 256 12 . . . 3278 257 1 Links link NNS 3278 257 2 can can MD 3278 257 3 point point VB 3278 257 4 to to IN 3278 257 5 broken broken JJ 3278 257 6 URIs URIs NNP 3278 257 7 ( ( -LRB- 3278 257 8 uniform uniform JJ 3278 257 9 resource resource NN 3278 257 10 identifiers identifier NNS 3278 257 11 ) ) -RRB- 3278 257 12 . . . 3278 258 1 Controlled control VBN 3278 258 2 vocabularies vocabulary NNS 3278 258 3 can can MD 3278 258 4 drift drift VB 3278 258 5 or or CC 3278 258 6 expand expand VB 3278 258 7 . . . 3278 259 1 Even even RB 3278 259 2 more more RBR 3278 259 3 confusing confusing JJ 3278 259 4 , , , 3278 259 5 a a DT 3278 259 6 URI uri NN 3278 259 7 that that WDT 3278 259 8 is be VBZ 3278 259 9 not not RB 3278 259 10 broken break VBN 3278 259 11 may may MD 3278 259 12 point point VB 3278 259 13 to to IN 3278 259 14 content content NN 3278 259 15 which which WDT 3278 259 16 has have VBZ 3278 259 17 changed change VBN 3278 259 18 to to IN 3278 259 19 the the DT 3278 259 20 point point NN 3278 259 21 where where WRB 3278 259 22 the the DT 3278 259 23 metadata metadata NN 3278 259 24 no no RB 3278 259 25 longer long RBR 3278 259 26 describes describe VBZ 3278 259 27 the the DT 3278 259 28 item item NN 3278 259 29 it -PRON- PRP 3278 259 30 once once RB 3278 259 31 did do VBD 3278 259 32 . . . 3278 260 1 At at IN 3278 260 2 one one CD 3278 260 3 extreme extreme NN 3278 260 4 , , , 3278 260 5 Bruce Bruce NNP 3278 260 6 and and CC 3278 260 7 Hillmann Hillmann NNP 3278 260 8 describe describe VBP 3278 260 9 the the DT 3278 260 10 curious curious JJ 3278 260 11 case case NN 3278 260 12 of of IN 3278 260 13 citation citation NN 3278 260 14 of of IN 3278 260 15 judicial judicial JJ 3278 260 16 opinions opinion NNS 3278 260 17 , , , 3278 260 18 for for IN 3278 260 19 which which WDT 3278 260 20 a a DT 3278 260 21 record record NN 3278 260 22 of of IN 3278 260 23 the the DT 3278 260 24 opinion opinion NN 3278 260 25 may may MD 3278 260 26 be be VB 3278 260 27 created create VBN 3278 260 28 as as RB 3278 260 29 much much JJ 3278 260 30 as as IN 3278 260 31 eighteen eighteen CD 3278 260 32 months month NNS 3278 260 33 before before IN 3278 260 34 the the DT 3278 260 35 volume volume NN 3278 260 36 with with IN 3278 260 37 the the DT 3278 260 38 official official JJ 3278 260 39 citation citation NN 3278 260 40 is be VBZ 3278 260 41 printed print VBN 3278 260 42 , , , 3278 260 43 and and CC 3278 260 44 thus thus RB 3278 260 45 the the DT 3278 260 46 official official JJ 3278 260 47 citation citation NN 3278 260 48 can can MD 3278 260 49 not not RB 3278 260 50 be be VB 3278 260 51 created.31 created.31 NNP 3278 260 52 e. e. NNP 3278 260 53 Expectations expectation NNS 3278 260 54 for for IN 3278 260 55 creation creation NN 3278 260 56 of of IN 3278 260 57 metadata metadata NN 3278 260 58 play play VBP 3278 260 59 a a DT 3278 260 60 role role NN 3278 260 61 as as RB 3278 260 62 well well RB 3278 260 63 . . . 3278 261 1 Traditional traditional JJ 3278 261 2 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 261 3 has have VBZ 3278 261 4 generally generally RB 3278 261 5 had have VBN 3278 261 6 an an DT 3278 261 7 expectation expectation NN 3278 261 8 that that IN 3278 261 9 most most JJS 3278 261 10 metadata metadata NN 3278 261 11 is be VBZ 3278 261 12 being be VBG 3278 261 13 cre­ cre­ NNP 3278 261 14 ated ate VBN 3278 261 15 once once RB 3278 261 16 and and CC 3278 261 17 reused reuse VBD 3278 261 18 . . . 3278 262 1 Yet yet CC 3278 262 2 current current JJ 3278 262 3 practice practice NN 3278 262 4 may may MD 3278 262 5 be be VB 3278 262 6 more more RBR 3278 262 7 iterative iterative JJ 3278 262 8 , , , 3278 262 9 and and CC 3278 262 10 must must MD 3278 262 11 be be VB 3278 262 12 , , , 3278 262 13 if if IN 3278 262 14 such such JJ 3278 262 15 problems problem NNS 3278 262 16 as as IN 3278 262 17 records record NNS 3278 262 18 with with IN 3278 262 19 broken broken JJ 3278 262 20 Internet internet NN 3278 262 21 URIs uri NNS 3278 262 22 are be VBP 3278 262 23 to to TO 3278 262 24 be be VB 3278 262 25 avoided avoid VBN 3278 262 26 . . . 3278 263 1 f. f. NNP 3278 263 2 Loss Loss NNP 3278 263 3 of of IN 3278 263 4 synchronization synchronization NN 3278 263 5 can can MD 3278 263 6 subvert subvert VB 3278 263 7 process­ process­ NNP 3278 263 8 ing ing NN 3278 263 9 . . . 3278 264 1 Note note VB 3278 264 2 that that IN 3278 264 3 other other JJ 3278 264 4 elements element NNS 3278 264 5 of of IN 3278 264 6 metadata metadata NN 3278 264 7 may may MD 3278 264 8 become become VB 3278 264 9 divorced divorced JJ 3278 264 10 or or CC 3278 264 11 out out IN 3278 264 12 of of IN 3278 264 13 synch synch NN 3278 264 14 with with IN 3278 264 15 the the DT 3278 264 16 origi­ origi­ NNP 3278 264 17 nal nal NNP 3278 264 18 target target NN 3278 264 19 /purpose /purpose , 3278 264 20 . . . 3278 265 1 The the DT 3278 265 2 prefix prefix NN 3278 265 3 to to IN 3278 265 4 an an DT 3278 265 5 ISBN ISBN NNP 3278 265 6 was be VBD 3278 265 7 originally originally RB 3278 265 8 intended intend VBN 3278 265 9 to to TO 3278 265 10 describe describe VB 3278 265 11 the the DT 3278 265 12 publisher publisher NN 3278 265 13 , , , 3278 265 14 but but CC 3278 265 15 is be VBZ 3278 265 16 now now RB 3278 265 17 an an DT 3278 265 18 unreliable unreliable JJ 3278 265 19 discriminator discriminator NN 3278 265 20 . . . 3278 266 1 Numeric numeric JJ 3278 266 2 keys key NNS 3278 266 3 intended intend VBD 3278 266 4 to to TO 3278 266 5 identify identify VB 3278 266 6 items item NNS 3278 266 7 uniquely uniquely RB 3278 266 8 can can MD 3278 266 9 retrieve retrieve VB 3278 266 10 multiple multiple JJ 3278 266 11 items item NNS 3278 266 12 , , , 3278 266 13 if if IN 3278 266 14 the the DT 3278 266 15 scheme scheme NN 3278 266 16 for for IN 3278 266 17 assign­ assign­ NNP 3278 266 18 ing e VBG 3278 266 19 them -PRON- PRP 3278 266 20 is be VBZ 3278 266 21 not not RB 3278 266 22 applied apply VBN 3278 266 23 consistently consistently RB 3278 266 24 . . . 3278 267 1 In in IN 3278 267 2 the the DT 3278 267 3 worst bad JJS 3278 267 4 case case NN 3278 267 5 , , , 3278 267 6 meaningful meaningful JJ 3278 267 7 data data NN 3278 267 8 elements element NNS 3278 267 9 may may MD 3278 267 10 become become VB 3278 267 11 so so RB 3278 267 12 corrupted corrupted JJ 3278 267 13 as as IN 3278 267 14 to to TO 3278 267 15 be be VB 3278 267 16 useless useless JJ 3278 267 17 for for IN 3278 267 18 record record JJ 3278 267 19 retrieval retrieval NN 3278 267 20 or or CC 3278 267 21 even even RB 3278 267 22 comparison comparison NN 3278 267 23 of of IN 3278 267 24 two two CD 3278 267 25 records record NNS 3278 267 26 . . . 3278 268 1 g. g. NNP 3278 268 2 Ownership Ownership NNP 3278 268 3 issues issue NNS 3278 268 4 can can MD 3278 268 5 detract detract VB 3278 268 6 from from IN 3278 268 7 optimal optimal JJ 3278 268 8 data­ data­ NNP 3278 268 9 base base NN 3278 268 10 management management NN 3278 268 11 . . . 3278 269 1 Member member NN 3278 269 2 institutions institution NNS 3278 269 3 ’ ’ POS 3278 269 4 percep­ percep­ JJ 3278 269 5 tions tion NNS 3278 269 6 of of IN 3278 269 7 ownership ownership NN 3278 269 8 of of IN 3278 269 9 individual individual JJ 3278 269 10 records record NNS 3278 269 11 can can MD 3278 269 12 conflict conflict VB 3278 269 13 with with IN 3278 269 14 the the DT 3278 269 15 goals goal NNS 3278 269 16 of of IN 3278 269 17 efficient efficient JJ 3278 269 18 search search NN 3278 269 19 and and CC 3278 269 20 retrieval retrieval NN 3278 269 21 . . . 3278 270 1 Members member NNS 3278 270 2 may may MD 3278 270 3 resist resist VB 3278 270 4 the the DT 3278 270 5 idea idea NN 3278 270 6 of of IN 3278 270 7 a a DT 3278 270 8 “ " `` 3278 270 9 bet­ bet­ NNP 3278 270 10 PuBLIC public JJ 3278 270 11 LIBRARIES library NNS 3278 270 12 AND and CC 3278 270 13 INTERNET INTERNET NNP 3278 270 14 ACCESS ACCESS NNP 3278 270 15 | | NNS 3278 270 16 JAEGER jaeger NN 3278 270 17 , , , 3278 270 18 BERTOT bertot NN 3278 270 19 , , , 3278 270 20 MCCLuRE mcclure UH 3278 270 21 , , , 3278 270 22 AND and CC 3278 270 23 RODRIGuEz rodriguez NN 3278 270 24 21MISINFORMATION 21misinformation CD 3278 270 25 AND and CC 3278 270 26 BIAS BIAS NNP 3278 270 27 IN in IN 3278 270 28 METADATA METADATA NNP 3278 270 29 PROCESSING PROCESSING NNP 3278 270 30 | | CD 3278 270 31 THORNBuRG THORNBuRG NNS 3278 270 32 AND and CC 3278 270 33 OSkINS oskins RB 3278 270 34 21 21 CD 3278 270 35 ter ter NN 3278 270 36 ” " '' 3278 270 37 record record NN 3278 270 38 being be VBG 3278 270 39 merged merge VBN 3278 270 40 with with IN 3278 270 41 a a DT 3278 270 42 “ " `` 3278 270 43 lesser less JJR 3278 270 44 ” " '' 3278 270 45 one one CD 3278 270 46 . . . 3278 271 1 So so RB 3278 271 2 systems system NNS 3278 271 3 have have VBP 3278 271 4 ways way NNS 3278 271 5 of of IN 3278 271 6 ranking rank VBG 3278 271 7 records record NNS 3278 271 8 by by IN 3278 271 9 source source NN 3278 271 10 or or CC 3278 271 11 contents content NNS 3278 271 12 with with IN 3278 271 13 the the DT 3278 271 14 general general JJ 3278 271 15 goal goal NN 3278 271 16 of of IN 3278 271 17 trying try VBG 3278 271 18 to to TO 3278 271 19 avoid avoid VB 3278 271 20 losing lose VBG 3278 271 21 information information NN 3278 271 22 , , , 3278 271 23 but but CC 3278 271 24 with with IN 3278 271 25 the the DT 3278 271 26 specific specific JJ 3278 271 27 effect effect NN 3278 271 28 of of IN 3278 271 29 refraining refrain VBG 3278 271 30 from from IN 3278 271 31 actions action NNS 3278 271 32 that that WDT 3278 271 33 might may MD 3278 271 34 be be VB 3278 271 35 enriching enrich VBG 3278 271 36 in in IN 3278 271 37 a a DT 3278 271 38 given give VBN 3278 271 39 case case NN 3278 271 40 . . . 3278 272 1 Growth growth NN 3278 272 2 of of IN 3278 272 3 the the DT 3278 272 4 database database NN 3278 272 5 environment environment NN 3278 272 6 A a DT 3278 272 7 shared share VBN 3278 272 8 database database NN 3278 272 9 can can MD 3278 272 10 grow grow VB 3278 272 11 in in IN 3278 272 12 unpredictable unpredictable JJ 3278 272 13 ways way NNS 3278 272 14 . . . 3278 273 1 A a DT 3278 273 2 change change NN 3278 273 3 in in IN 3278 273 4 the the DT 3278 273 5 relative relative JJ 3278 273 6 proportions proportion NNS 3278 273 7 of of IN 3278 273 8 different different JJ 3278 273 9 types type NNS 3278 273 10 of of IN 3278 273 11 materials material NNS 3278 273 12 or or CC 3278 273 13 topical topical JJ 3278 273 14 coverage coverage NN 3278 273 15 can can MD 3278 273 16 render render VB 3278 273 17 once­effective once­effective NNP 3278 273 18 searches search NNS 3278 273 19 ineffective ineffective JJ 3278 273 20 due due IN 3278 273 21 to to IN 3278 273 22 large large JJ 3278 273 23 result result NN 3278 273 24 sets set NNS 3278 273 25 . . . 3278 274 1 An an DT 3278 274 2 example example NN 3278 274 3 of of IN 3278 274 4 this this DT 3278 274 5 is be VBZ 3278 274 6 the the DT 3278 274 7 number number NN 3278 274 8 of of IN 3278 274 9 Internet­related internet­related JJ 3278 274 10 entries entry NNS 3278 274 11 in in IN 3278 274 12 XWC XWC NNP 3278 274 13 . . . 3278 275 1 A a DT 3278 275 2 search search NN 3278 275 3 such such JJ 3278 275 4 as as IN 3278 275 5 “ " `` 3278 275 6 dog dog NN 3278 275 7 ” " '' 3278 275 8 restricted restrict VBN 3278 275 9 to to IN 3278 275 10 “ " `` 3278 275 11 Internet­related internet­related JJ 3278 275 12 ” " '' 3278 275 13 entries entry NNS 3278 275 14 in in IN 3278 275 15 1995 1995 CD 3278 275 16 retrieved retrieve VBD 3278 275 17 thirty­four thirty­four NNP 3278 275 18 hits hit NNS 3278 275 19 . . . 3278 276 1 This this DT 3278 276 2 might may MD 3278 276 3 be be VB 3278 276 4 a a DT 3278 276 5 manageable manageable JJ 3278 276 6 number number NN 3278 276 7 . . . 3278 277 1 But but CC 3278 277 2 in in IN 3278 277 3 2005 2005 CD 3278 277 4 , , , 3278 277 5 225 225 CD 3278 277 6 entries entry NNS 3278 277 7 were be VBD 3278 277 8 in in IN 3278 277 9 the the DT 3278 277 10 result result NN 3278 277 11 set set NN 3278 277 12 . . . 3278 278 1 Similarly similarly RB 3278 278 2 with with IN 3278 278 3 subject subject JJ 3278 278 4 headings heading NNS 3278 278 5 , , , 3278 278 6 one one CD 3278 278 7 search search NN 3278 278 8 on on IN 3278 278 9 “ " `` 3278 278 10 computer computer NN 3278 278 11 animation animation NN 3278 278 12 ” " '' 3278 278 13 retrieved retrieve VBD 3278 278 14 fourteen fourteen CD 3278 278 15 hits hit NNS 3278 278 16 in in IN 3278 278 17 1980 1980 CD 3278 278 18 , , , 3278 278 19 and and CC 3278 278 20 342 342 CD 3278 278 21 in in IN 3278 278 22 2005 2005 CD 3278 278 23 . . . 3278 279 1 In in IN 3278 279 2 both both DT 3278 279 3 cases case NNS 3278 279 4 the the DT 3278 279 5 result result NN 3278 279 6 sets set NNS 3278 279 7 grew grow VBD 3278 279 8 from from IN 3278 279 9 manageable manageable JJ 3278 279 10 to to IN 3278 279 11 “ " `` 3278 279 12 too too RB 3278 279 13 large large JJ 3278 279 14 ” " '' 3278 279 15 over over IN 3278 279 16 time time NN 3278 279 17 . . . 3278 280 1 The the DT 3278 280 2 increase increase NN 3278 280 3 in in IN 3278 280 4 the the DT 3278 280 5 number number NN 3278 280 6 of of IN 3278 280 7 foreign foreign JJ 3278 280 8 language language NN 3278 280 9 entries entry NNS 3278 280 10 in in IN 3278 280 11 a a DT 3278 280 12 database database NN 3278 280 13 can can MD 3278 280 14 cause cause VB 3278 280 15 problems problem NNS 3278 280 16 . . . 3278 281 1 Just just RB 3278 281 2 determining determine VBG 3278 281 3 what what WDT 3278 281 4 language language NN 3278 281 5 an an DT 3278 281 6 entry entry NN 3278 281 7 is be VBZ 3278 281 8 in in IN 3278 281 9 can can MD 3278 281 10 be be VB 3278 281 11 difficult difficult JJ 3278 281 12 , , , 3278 281 13 and and CC 3278 281 14 records record NNS 3278 281 15 may may MD 3278 281 16 contain contain VB 3278 281 17 multiple multiple JJ 3278 281 18 languages language NNS 3278 281 19 . . . 3278 282 1 Also also RB 3278 282 2 , , , 3278 282 3 such such JJ 3278 282 4 languages language NNS 3278 282 5 as as IN 3278 282 6 Chinese chinese JJ 3278 282 7 , , , 3278 282 8 Japanese japanese JJ 3278 282 9 , , , 3278 282 10 and and CC 3278 282 11 Korean korean JJ 3278 282 12 can can MD 3278 282 13 overlap overlap VB 3278 282 14 . . . 3278 283 1 Chinese chinese JJ 3278 283 2 syllables syllable NNS 3278 283 3 such such JJ 3278 283 4 as as IN 3278 283 5 : : : 3278 283 6 “ " `` 3278 283 7 a a LS 3278 283 8 , , , 3278 283 9 an an DT 3278 283 10 , , , 3278 283 11 to to IN 3278 283 12 , , , 3278 283 13 no no UH 3278 283 14 , , , 3278 283 15 Jan Jan NNP 3278 283 16 , , , 3278 283 17 Ka Ka NNP 3278 283 18 , , , 3278 283 19 Jun Jun NNP 3278 283 20 , , , 3278 283 21 lung lung NN 3278 283 22 , , , 3278 283 23 sung sung NNP 3278 283 24 , , , 3278 283 25 I -PRON- PRP 3278 283 26 , , , 3278 283 27 lo lo NNP 3278 283 28 , , , 3278 283 29 la la NNP 3278 283 30 , , , 3278 283 31 le le NNP 3278 283 32 , , , 3278 283 33 so so RB 3278 283 34 , , , 3278 283 35 sun sun NN 3278 283 36 , , , 3278 283 37 Juan Juan NNP 3278 283 38 , , , 3278 283 39 ” " '' 3278 283 40 seen see VBN 3278 283 41 out out IN 3278 283 42 of of IN 3278 283 43 context context NN 3278 283 44 might may MD 3278 283 45 be be VB 3278 283 46 Chinese chinese JJ 3278 283 47 or or CC 3278 283 48 any any DT 3278 283 49 one one CD 3278 283 50 of of IN 3278 283 51 several several JJ 3278 283 52 other other JJ 3278 283 53 languages language NNS 3278 283 54 . . . 3278 284 1 Determining determine VBG 3278 284 2 appropriate appropriate JJ 3278 284 3 handling handling NN 3278 284 4 of of IN 3278 284 5 stopwords stopword NNS 3278 284 6 and and CC 3278 284 7 other other JJ 3278 284 8 rules rule NNS 3278 284 9 for for IN 3278 284 10 effective effective JJ 3278 284 11 title title NN 3278 284 12 matching matching NN 3278 284 13 becomes become VBZ 3278 284 14 more more RBR 3278 284 15 complex complex JJ 3278 284 16 as as IN 3278 284 17 more more JJR 3278 284 18 languages language NNS 3278 284 19 populate populate VBP 3278 284 20 the the DT 3278 284 21 database database NN 3278 284 22 . . . 3278 285 1 Changes change NNS 3278 285 2 in in IN 3278 285 3 contributor contributor NN 3278 285 4 characteristics characteristic NNS 3278 285 5 Copy Copy NNP 3278 285 6 cataloging catalog VBG 3278 285 7 practices practice NNS 3278 285 8 in in IN 3278 285 9 an an DT 3278 285 10 institution institution NN 3278 285 11 can can MD 3278 285 12 affect affect VB 3278 285 13 XWC XWC NNP 3278 285 14 indirectly indirectly RB 3278 285 15 . . . 3278 286 1 An an DT 3278 286 2 institution institution NN 3278 286 3 previously previously RB 3278 286 4 oriented orient VBN 3278 286 5 to to IN 3278 286 6 fixing fix VBG 3278 286 7 downloaded download VBN 3278 286 8 records record NNS 3278 286 9 may may MD 3278 286 10 adopt adopt VB 3278 286 11 a a DT 3278 286 12 policy policy NN 3278 286 13 of of IN 3278 286 14 refrain­ refrain­ NNP 3278 286 15 ing ing NNP 3278 286 16 from from IN 3278 286 17 changing change VBG 3278 286 18 downloaded downloaded JJ 3278 286 19 records record NNS 3278 286 20 . . . 3278 287 1 Historical historical JJ 3278 287 2 inde­ inde­ CD 3278 287 3 pendence pendence NN 3278 287 4 of of IN 3278 287 5 libraries library NNS 3278 287 6 is be VBZ 3278 287 7 one one CD 3278 287 8 illustration illustration NN 3278 287 9 . . . 3278 288 1 Prior prior RB 3278 288 2 to to IN 3278 288 3 the the DT 3278 288 4 1970s 1970 NNS 3278 288 5 , , , 3278 288 6 most most JJS 3278 288 7 libraries library NNS 3278 288 8 did do VBD 3278 288 9 not not RB 3278 288 10 share share VB 3278 288 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 288 12 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 288 13 with with IN 3278 288 14 other other JJ 3278 288 15 libraries library NNS 3278 288 16 . . . 3278 289 1 Many many JJ 3278 289 2 institutions institution NNS 3278 289 3 , , , 3278 289 4 especially especially RB 3278 289 5 smaller small JJR 3278 289 6 ones one NNS 3278 289 7 , , , 3278 289 8 were be VBD 3278 289 9 outside outside IN 3278 289 10 the the DT 3278 289 11 loop loop NN 3278 289 12 and and CC 3278 289 13 did do VBD 3278 289 14 things thing NNS 3278 289 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 289 16 own own JJ 3278 289 17 way way NN 3278 289 18 . . . 3278 290 1 They -PRON- PRP 3278 290 2 used use VBD 3278 290 3 what what WP 3278 290 4 rules rule NNS 3278 290 5 they -PRON- PRP 3278 290 6 felt feel VBD 3278 290 7 were be VBD 3278 290 8 useful useful JJ 3278 290 9 , , , 3278 290 10 if if IN 3278 290 11 they -PRON- PRP 3278 290 12 used use VBD 3278 290 13 any any DT 3278 290 14 rules rule NNS 3278 290 15 at at RB 3278 290 16 all all RB 3278 290 17 . . . 3278 291 1 Later later RB 3278 291 2 they -PRON- PRP 3278 291 3 converted convert VBD 3278 291 4 sparse sparse RB 3278 291 5 and and CC 3278 291 6 poorly poorly RB 3278 291 7 formed form VBN 3278 291 8 data datum NNS 3278 291 9 into into IN 3278 291 10 MARC MARC NNP 3278 291 11 records record NNS 3278 291 12 and and CC 3278 291 13 sent send VBD 3278 291 14 them -PRON- PRP 3278 291 15 to to IN 3278 291 16 OCLC oclc NN 3278 291 17 for for IN 3278 291 18 matching matching NN 3278 291 19 , , , 3278 291 20 perhaps perhaps RB 3278 291 21 in in IN 3278 291 22 an an DT 3278 291 23 effort effort NN 3278 291 24 to to TO 3278 291 25 get get VB 3278 291 26 back back RB 3278 291 27 a a DT 3278 291 28 more more RBR 3278 291 29 complete complete JJ 3278 291 30 and and CC 3278 291 31 useful useful JJ 3278 291 32 record record NN 3278 291 33 . . . 3278 292 1 Yet yet CC 3278 292 2 the the DT 3278 292 3 matching matching NN 3278 292 4 process process NN 3278 292 5 is be VBZ 3278 292 6 not not RB 3278 292 7 always always RB 3278 292 8 able able JJ 3278 292 9 to to TO 3278 292 10 distinguish distinguish VB 3278 292 11 or or CC 3278 292 12 interpret interpret VB 3278 292 13 these these DT 3278 292 14 local local JJ 3278 292 15 dialects dialect NNS 3278 292 16 . . . 3278 293 1 Changes change NNS 3278 293 2 in in IN 3278 293 3 specialization specialization NN 3278 293 4 of of IN 3278 293 5 cata­ cata­ NN 3278 293 6 loging log VBG 3278 293 7 staff staff NN 3278 293 8 at at IN 3278 293 9 an an DT 3278 293 10 institution institution NN 3278 293 11 , , , 3278 293 12 or or CC 3278 293 13 cutbacks cutback NNS 3278 293 14 in in IN 3278 293 15 staff staff NN 3278 293 16 can can MD 3278 293 17 lead lead VB 3278 293 18 to to IN 3278 293 19 reduced reduced JJ 3278 293 20 facility facility NN 3278 293 21 in in IN 3278 293 22 providing provide VBG 3278 293 23 original original JJ 3278 293 24 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 293 25 . . . 3278 294 1 Outsourcing outsourcing NN 3278 294 2 of of IN 3278 294 3 cataloging catalog VBG 3278 294 4 work work NN 3278 294 5 can can MD 3278 294 6 affect affect VB 3278 294 7 handling handling NN 3278 294 8 of of IN 3278 294 9 specialized specialized JJ 3278 294 10 materials material NNS 3278 294 11 as as RB 3278 294 12 well well RB 3278 294 13 . . . 3278 295 1 The the DT 3278 295 2 introduction introduction NN 3278 295 3 of of IN 3278 295 4 Vendor Vendor NNP 3278 295 5 Records Records NNPS 3278 295 6 and and CC 3278 295 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 295 8 characteristics characteristic NNS 3278 295 9 has have VBZ 3278 295 10 been be VBN 3278 295 11 noted note VBN 3278 295 12 by by IN 3278 295 13 Shedenhelm Shedenhelm NNP 3278 295 14 and and CC 3278 295 15 Burk.32 Burk.32 NNP 3278 295 16 As as IN 3278 295 17 they -PRON- PRP 3278 295 18 note note VBP 3278 295 19 , , , 3278 295 20 these these DT 3278 295 21 records record NNS 3278 295 22 are be VBP 3278 295 23 very very RB 3278 295 24 brief brief JJ 3278 295 25 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 295 26 records record NNS 3278 295 27 originally originally RB 3278 295 28 designed design VBN 3278 295 29 to to TO 3278 295 30 advertise advertise VB 3278 295 31 an an DT 3278 295 32 item item NN 3278 295 33 for for IN 3278 295 34 sale sale NN 3278 295 35 by by IN 3278 295 36 the the DT 3278 295 37 vendor vendor NN 3278 295 38 . . . 3278 296 1 These these DT 3278 296 2 mini­ mini­ NNP 3278 296 3 mal mal JJ 3278 296 4 level level NN 3278 296 5 records record NNS 3278 296 6 have have VBP 3278 296 7 a a DT 3278 296 8 relatively relatively RB 3278 296 9 high high JJ 3278 296 10 degree degree NN 3278 296 11 of of IN 3278 296 12 dupli­ dupli­ NNP 3278 296 13 cation cation NN 3278 296 14 with with IN 3278 296 15 existing exist VBG 3278 296 16 records record NNS 3278 296 17 ( ( -LRB- 3278 296 18 37.5 37.5 CD 3278 296 19 percent percent NN 3278 296 20 in in IN 3278 296 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 296 22 study study NN 3278 296 23 ) ) -RRB- 3278 296 24 and and CC 3278 296 25 because because IN 3278 296 26 of of IN 3278 296 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 3278 296 28 sparseness sparseness NN 3278 296 29 can can MD 3278 296 30 increase increase VB 3278 296 31 the the DT 3278 296 32 cost cost NN 3278 296 33 of of IN 3278 296 34 cataloging catalog VBG 3278 296 35 . . . 3278 297 1 Changes change NNS 3278 297 2 in in IN 3278 297 3 the the DT 3278 297 4 proportion proportion NN 3278 297 5 of of IN 3278 297 6 contribu­ contribu­ NN 3278 297 7 tors tor NNS 3278 297 8 who who WP 3278 297 9 create create VBP 3278 297 10 records record NNS 3278 297 11 in in IN 3278 297 12 non­MARC non­MARC NNP 3278 297 13 formats format NNS 3278 297 14 such such JJ 3278 297 15 as as IN 3278 297 16 Dublin Dublin NNP 3278 297 17 Core Core NNP 3278 297 18 can can MD 3278 297 19 affect affect VB 3278 297 20 the the DT 3278 297 21 completeness completeness NN 3278 297 22 of of IN 3278 297 23 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 297 24 entries entry NNS 3278 297 25 . . . 3278 298 1 The the DT 3278 298 2 use use NN 3278 298 3 of of IN 3278 298 4 such such JJ 3278 298 5 formats format NNS 3278 298 6 , , , 3278 298 7 meant mean VBD 3278 298 8 to to TO 3278 298 9 facilitate facilitate VB 3278 298 10 the the DT 3278 298 11 entry entry NN 3278 298 12 of of IN 3278 298 13 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 298 14 materials material NNS 3278 298 15 , , , 3278 298 16 does do VBZ 3278 298 17 come come VB 3278 298 18 with with IN 3278 298 19 a a DT 3278 298 20 cost cost NN 3278 298 21 . . . 3278 299 1 Group group NN 3278 299 2 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 299 3 is be VBZ 3278 299 4 a a DT 3278 299 5 process process NN 3278 299 6 whereby whereby WRB 3278 299 7 smaller small JJR 3278 299 8 libraries library NNS 3278 299 9 can can MD 3278 299 10 join join VB 3278 299 11 a a DT 3278 299 12 larger large JJR 3278 299 13 set set NN 3278 299 14 of of IN 3278 299 15 institutions institution NNS 3278 299 16 in in IN 3278 299 17 order order NN 3278 299 18 to to TO 3278 299 19 reduce reduce VB 3278 299 20 costs cost NNS 3278 299 21 and and CC 3278 299 22 facilitate facilitate VB 3278 299 23 cataloging catalog VBG 3278 299 24 . . . 3278 300 1 This this DT 3278 300 2 larger large JJR 3278 300 3 group group NN 3278 300 4 then then RB 3278 300 5 contributes contribute VBZ 3278 300 6 to to IN 3278 300 7 OCLC oclc NN 3278 300 8 ’s ’s POS 3278 300 9 database database NN 3278 300 10 as as IN 3278 300 11 an an DT 3278 300 12 entity entity NN 3278 300 13 . . . 3278 301 1 The the DT 3278 301 2 growth growth NN 3278 301 3 of of IN 3278 301 4 group group NN 3278 301 5 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 301 6 has have VBZ 3278 301 7 resulted result VBN 3278 301 8 in in IN 3278 301 9 the the DT 3278 301 10 addition addition NN 3278 301 11 of of IN 3278 301 12 more more JJR 3278 301 13 records record NNS 3278 301 14 from from IN 3278 301 15 smaller small JJR 3278 301 16 libraries library NNS 3278 301 17 , , , 3278 301 18 which which WDT 3278 301 19 may may MD 3278 301 20 in in IN 3278 301 21 the the DT 3278 301 22 future future NN 3278 301 23 have have VB 3278 301 24 an an DT 3278 301 25 effect effect NN 3278 301 26 on on IN 3278 301 27 searching search VBG 3278 301 28 / / SYM 3278 301 29 matching matching NN 3278 301 30 in in IN 3278 301 31 XWC XWC NNP 3278 301 32 WorldCat WorldCat NNP 3278 301 33 overall overall RB 3278 301 34 . . . 3278 302 1 Internationalization internationalization NN 3278 302 2 may may MD 3278 302 3 be be VB 3278 302 4 a a DT 3278 302 5 factor factor NN 3278 302 6 as as RB 3278 302 7 well well RB 3278 302 8 . . . 3278 303 1 The the DT 3278 303 2 MARC MARC NNP 3278 303 3 format format NN 3278 303 4 is be VBZ 3278 303 5 an an DT 3278 303 6 Anglo­based anglo­based JJ 3278 303 7 format format NN 3278 303 8 with with IN 3278 303 9 English­language­based English­language­based NNP 3278 303 10 documentation documentation NN 3278 303 11 . . . 3278 304 1 Rapid rapid JJ 3278 304 2 inter­ inter­ NNP 3278 304 3 national national JJ 3278 304 4 growth growth NN 3278 304 5 thrusts thrust NNS 3278 304 6 a a DT 3278 304 7 broader broad JJR 3278 304 8 range range NN 3278 304 9 of of IN 3278 304 10 traditions tradition NNS 3278 304 11 into into IN 3278 304 12 a a DT 3278 304 13 MARC MARC NNP 3278 304 14 / / SYM 3278 304 15 OCLC oclc NN 3278 304 16 world world NN 3278 304 17 . . . 3278 305 1 The the DT 3278 305 2 role role NN 3278 305 3 of of IN 3278 305 4 character character NN 3278 305 5 sets set NNS 3278 305 6 is be VBZ 3278 305 7 heightened heighten VBN 3278 305 8 as as IN 3278 305 9 the the DT 3278 305 10 database database NN 3278 305 11 grows grow VBZ 3278 305 12 . . . 3278 306 1 A a DT 3278 306 2 Cyrillic cyrillic JJ 3278 306 3 record record NN 3278 306 4 may may MD 3278 306 5 not not RB 3278 306 6 be be VB 3278 306 7 confidently confidently RB 3278 306 8 matched match VBN 3278 306 9 to to IN 3278 306 10 a a DT 3278 306 11 transliterated transliterate VBN 3278 306 12 record record NN 3278 306 13 for for IN 3278 306 14 the the DT 3278 306 15 same same JJ 3278 306 16 item item NN 3278 306 17 . . . 3278 307 1 Although although IN 3278 307 2 WorldCat WorldCat NNP 3278 307 3 has have VBZ 3278 307 4 a a DT 3278 307 5 long long JJ 3278 307 6 his­ his­ CD 3278 307 7 tory tory NN 3278 307 8 with with IN 3278 307 9 CJK CJK NNP 3278 307 10 records record NNS 3278 307 11 , , , 3278 307 12 MARC MARC NNP 3278 307 13 and and CC 3278 307 14 WorldCat WorldCat NNP 3278 307 15 are be VBP 3278 307 16 not not RB 3278 307 17 yet yet RB 3278 307 18 accustomed accustom VBN 3278 307 19 to to IN 3278 307 20 a a DT 3278 307 21 wide wide JJ 3278 307 22 repertoire repertoire NN 3278 307 23 of of IN 3278 307 24 character character NN 3278 307 25 sets set NNS 3278 307 26 . . . 3278 308 1 Now now RB 3278 308 2 , , , 3278 308 3 however however RB 3278 308 4 , , , 3278 308 5 XWC XWC NNP 3278 308 6 is be VBZ 3278 308 7 an an DT 3278 308 8 environment environment NN 3278 308 9 in in IN 3278 308 10 which which WDT 3278 308 11 expanding expand VBG 3278 308 12 character character NN 3278 308 13 coverage coverage NN 3278 308 14 is be VBZ 3278 308 15 possible possible JJ 3278 308 16 , , , 3278 308 17 and and CC 3278 308 18 likely likely JJ 3278 308 19 . . . 3278 309 1 Future future JJ 3278 309 2 research research NN 3278 309 3 n n CC 3278 309 4 We -PRON- PRP 3278 309 5 need need VBP 3278 309 6 more more JJR 3278 309 7 systematic systematic JJ 3278 309 8 study study NN 3278 309 9 of of IN 3278 309 10 the the DT 3278 309 11 types type NNS 3278 309 12 of of IN 3278 309 13 errors error NNS 3278 309 14 / / SYM 3278 309 15 omissions omission NNS 3278 309 16 encountered encounter VBN 3278 309 17 in in IN 3278 309 18 MARC MARC NNP 3278 309 19 record record NN 3278 309 20 cre­ cre­ NNP 3278 309 21 ation ation NN 3278 309 22 . . . 3278 310 1 n n LS 3278 310 2 How how WRB 3278 310 3 can can MD 3278 310 4 the the DT 3278 310 5 process process NN 3278 310 6 of of IN 3278 310 7 matching match VBG 3278 310 8 accomodate accomodate NN 3278 310 9 objects object NNS 3278 310 10 that that WDT 3278 310 11 change change VBP 3278 310 12 over over IN 3278 310 13 time time NN 3278 310 14 ? ? . 3278 311 1 n n LS 3278 311 2 How how WRB 3278 311 3 does do VBZ 3278 311 4 the the DT 3278 311 5 conversion conversion NN 3278 311 6 from from IN 3278 311 7 new new JJ 3278 311 8 metadata metadata NN 3278 311 9 schemes scheme NNS 3278 311 10 affect affect VBP 3278 311 11 matching match VBG 3278 311 12 to to IN 3278 311 13 MARC MARC NNP 3278 311 14 records record NNS 3278 311 15 ? ? . 3278 312 1 Does do VBZ 3278 312 2 it -PRON- PRP 3278 312 3 help help VB 3278 312 4 to to TO 3278 312 5 know know VB 3278 312 6 in in IN 3278 312 7 what what WDT 3278 312 8 format format NN 3278 312 9 a a DT 3278 312 10 record record NN 3278 312 11 arrived arrive VBD 3278 312 12 , , , 3278 312 13 or or CC 3278 312 14 under under IN 3278 312 15 what what WP 3278 312 16 rules rule NNS 3278 312 17 it -PRON- PRP 3278 312 18 was be VBD 3278 312 19 created create VBN 3278 312 20 ? ? . 3278 313 1 n n LS 3278 313 2 How how WRB 3278 313 3 can can MD 3278 313 4 we -PRON- PRP 3278 313 5 address address VB 3278 313 6 sparseness sparseness NN 3278 313 7 in in IN 3278 313 8 vendor vendor NN 3278 313 9 records record NNS 3278 313 10 or or CC 3278 313 11 legal legal JJ 3278 313 12 citations citation NNS 3278 313 13 ? ? . 3278 314 1 How how WRB 3278 314 2 can can MD 3278 314 3 we -PRON- PRP 3278 314 4 deal deal VB 3278 314 5 with with IN 3278 314 6 other other JJ 3278 314 7 advance advance NN 3278 314 8 publication publication NN 3278 314 9 issues issue NNS 3278 314 10 ? ? . 3278 315 1 n n LS 3278 315 2 How how WRB 3278 315 3 do do VBP 3278 315 4 changes change NNS 3278 315 5 in in IN 3278 315 6 philosophy philosophy NN 3278 315 7 of of IN 3278 315 8 the the DT 3278 315 9 database database NN 3278 315 10 affect affect VB 3278 315 11 the the DT 3278 315 12 integrity integrity NN 3278 315 13 of of IN 3278 315 14 the the DT 3278 315 15 matching matching NN 3278 315 16 process process NN 3278 315 17 ? ? . 3278 316 1 n n LS 3278 316 2 Conclusions Conclusions NNPS 3278 316 3 In in IN 3278 316 4 this this DT 3278 316 5 review review NN 3278 316 6 we -PRON- PRP 3278 316 7 have have VBP 3278 316 8 seen see VBN 3278 316 9 that that IN 3278 316 10 characterizing characterize VBG 3278 316 11 metadata metadata NN 3278 316 12 at at IN 3278 316 13 a a DT 3278 316 14 high high JJ 3278 316 15 level level NN 3278 316 16 is be VBZ 3278 316 17 difficult difficult JJ 3278 316 18 . . . 3278 317 1 Challenges challenge NNS 3278 317 2 for for IN 3278 317 3 adding add VBG 3278 317 4 to to IN 3278 317 5 a a DT 3278 317 6 large large JJ 3278 317 7 , , , 3278 317 8 complex complex JJ 3278 317 9 database database NN 3278 317 10 include include VBP 3278 317 11 some some DT 3278 317 12 of of IN 3278 317 13 the the DT 3278 317 14 following follow VBG 3278 317 15 : : : 3278 317 16 22 22 CD 3278 317 17 INFORMATION information NN 3278 317 18 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3278 317 19 AND and CC 3278 317 20 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 317 21 | | NNP 3278 317 22 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 317 23 200722 200722 CD 3278 317 24 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3278 317 25 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3278 317 26 AND and CC 3278 317 27 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 317 28 | | NNP 3278 317 29 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 317 30 2007 2007 CD 3278 317 31 n n NN 3278 317 32 Rules Rules NNPS 3278 317 33 for for IN 3278 317 34 expert expert JJ 3278 317 35 creation creation NN 3278 317 36 of of IN 3278 317 37 metadata metadata NN 3278 317 38 inevitably inevitably RB 3278 317 39 change change VBP 3278 317 40 over over IN 3278 317 41 time time NN 3278 317 42 . . . 3278 318 1 n n CC 3278 318 2 The the DT 3278 318 3 object object NN 3278 318 4 of of IN 3278 318 5 the the DT 3278 318 6 metadata metadata NN 3278 318 7 itself -PRON- PRP 3278 318 8 may may MD 3278 318 9 change change VB 3278 318 10 , , , 3278 318 11 more more RBR 3278 318 12 often often RB 3278 318 13 than than IN 3278 318 14 may may MD 3278 318 15 be be VB 3278 318 16 convenient convenient JJ 3278 318 17 . . . 3278 319 1 n n DT 3278 319 2 Comparisons Comparisons NNP 3278 319 3 of of IN 3278 319 4 briefer briefer NN 3278 319 5 records record NNS 3278 319 6 to to IN 3278 319 7 records record NNS 3278 319 8 that that WDT 3278 319 9 are be VBP 3278 319 10 more more RBR 3278 319 11 elaborate elaborate JJ 3278 319 12 descriptions description NNS 3278 319 13 can can MD 3278 319 14 have have VB 3278 319 15 pitfalls pitfall NNS 3278 319 16 . . . 3278 320 1 Search search NN 3278 320 2 and and CC 3278 320 3 comparison comparison NN 3278 320 4 strategies strategy NNS 3278 320 5 for for IN 3278 320 6 such such JJ 3278 320 7 record record NN 3278 320 8 pairs pair NNS 3278 320 9 are be VBP 3278 320 10 challenged challenge VBN 3278 320 11 by by IN 3278 320 12 the the DT 3278 320 13 need need NN 3278 320 14 to to TO 3278 320 15 have have VB 3278 320 16 matching match VBG 3278 320 17 algorithms algorithm NNS 3278 320 18 that that WDT 3278 320 19 work work VBP 3278 320 20 for for IN 3278 320 21 every every DT 3278 320 22 scenario scenario NN 3278 320 23 . . . 3278 321 1 n n LS 3278 321 2 Changes change NNS 3278 321 3 within within IN 3278 321 4 the the DT 3278 321 5 database database NN 3278 321 6 may may MD 3278 321 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 3278 321 8 con­ con­ XX 3278 321 9 tribute tribute NN 3278 321 10 to to IN 3278 321 11 exacerbation exacerbation NN 3278 321 12 of of IN 3278 321 13 matching match VBG 3278 321 14 problems problem NNS 3278 321 15 if if IN 3278 321 16 duplicates duplicate NNS 3278 321 17 are be VBP 3278 321 18 added add VBN 3278 321 19 too too RB 3278 321 20 often often RB 3278 321 21 , , , 3278 321 22 or or CC 3278 321 23 records record NNS 3278 321 24 are be VBP 3278 321 25 merged merge VBN 3278 321 26 that that DT 3278 321 27 actually actually RB 3278 321 28 represent represent VBP 3278 321 29 different different JJ 3278 321 30 contents content NNS 3278 321 31 . . . 3278 322 1 Because because IN 3278 322 2 of of IN 3278 322 3 the the DT 3278 322 4 risk risk NN 3278 322 5 , , , 3278 322 6 policies policy NNS 3278 322 7 for for IN 3278 322 8 merging merge VBG 3278 322 9 and and CC 3278 322 10 replacing replace VBG 3278 322 11 records record NNS 3278 322 12 tend tend VBP 3278 322 13 to to TO 3278 322 14 be be VB 3278 322 15 conservative conservative JJ 3278 322 16 , , , 3278 322 17 but but CC 3278 322 18 this this DT 3278 322 19 does do VBZ 3278 322 20 not not RB 3278 322 21 always always RB 3278 322 22 favor favor VB 3278 322 23 the the DT 3278 322 24 greatest great JJS 3278 322 25 efficiency efficiency NN 3278 322 26 in in IN 3278 322 27 database database NN 3278 322 28 processing processing NN 3278 322 29 . . . 3278 323 1 n n LS 3278 323 2 Changes Changes NNPS 3278 323 3 in in IN 3278 323 4 the the DT 3278 323 5 membership membership NN 3278 323 6 sharing share VBG 3278 323 7 a a DT 3278 323 8 database database NN 3278 323 9 are be VBP 3278 323 10 likely likely JJ 3278 323 11 to to TO 3278 323 12 affect affect VB 3278 323 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 3278 323 14 shape shape NN 3278 323 15 and and CC 3278 323 16 searchability searchability NN 3278 323 17 . . . 3278 324 1 n n LS 3278 324 2 Newer new JJR 3278 324 3 schemes scheme NNS 3278 324 4 of of IN 3278 324 5 metadata metadata NN 3278 324 6 representation representation NN 3278 324 7 are be VBP 3278 324 8 likely likely JJ 3278 324 9 to to TO 3278 324 10 challenge challenge VB 3278 324 11 existing exist VBG 3278 324 12 algorithms algorithm NNS 3278 324 13 for for IN 3278 324 14 determining determine VBG 3278 324 15 matches match NNS 3278 324 16 . . . 3278 325 1 References reference NNS 3278 325 2 1 1 CD 3278 325 3 . . . 3278 326 1 National National NNP 3278 326 2 Information Information NNP 3278 326 3 Standards Standards NNP 3278 326 4 Organization Organization NNP 3278 326 5 , , , 3278 326 6 Under- Under- NNP 3278 326 7 standing stand VBG 3278 326 8 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 326 9 ( ( -LRB- 3278 326 10 Bethesda Bethesda NNP 3278 326 11 , , , 3278 326 12 Md. Md. NNP 3278 327 1 : : : 3278 327 2 NISO NISO NNP 3278 327 3 Pr Pr NNP 3278 327 4 . . NNP 3278 327 5 , , , 3278 327 6 2004 2004 CD 3278 327 7 ) ) -RRB- 3278 327 8 , , , 3278 327 9 1 1 CD 3278 327 10 . . . 3278 327 11 http:// http:// RB 3278 327 12 www.niso.org/standards/resources/Understanding www.niso.org/standards/resources/understande VBG 3278 327 13 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 327 14 . . . 3278 328 1 pdf pdf NNP 3278 328 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 328 3 accessed access VBN 3278 328 4 Feb. February NNP 3278 328 5 26 26 CD 3278 328 6 , , , 3278 328 7 2006 2006 CD 3278 328 8 ) ) -RRB- 3278 328 9 . . . 3278 329 1 2 2 LS 3278 329 2 . . . 3278 330 1 Library Library NNP 3278 330 2 of of IN 3278 330 3 Congress Congress NNP 3278 330 4 , , , 3278 330 5 “ " `` 3278 330 6 MARC MARC NNP 3278 330 7 21 21 CD 3278 330 8 Concise Concise NNP 3278 330 9 Format Format NNP 3278 330 10 for for IN 3278 330 11 Bibliographic Bibliographic NNP 3278 330 12 Data Data NNP 3278 330 13 ( ( -LRB- 3278 330 14 2002 2002 CD 3278 330 15 ) ) -RRB- 3278 330 16 . . . 3278 330 17 ” " '' 3278 330 18 http://www.loc.gov/marc/ http://www.loc.gov/marc/ RB 3278 330 19 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3278 330 20 / / SYM 3278 330 21 ecbdhome.html ecbdhome.html NNS 3278 330 22 ( ( -LRB- 3278 330 23 accessed access VBN 3278 330 24 Nov. November NNP 3278 330 25 20 20 CD 3278 330 26 , , , 3278 330 27 2004 2004 CD 3278 330 28 ) ) -RRB- 3278 330 29 . . . 3278 331 1 3 3 LS 3278 331 2 . . . 3278 332 1 Gail Gail NNP 3278 332 2 Thornburg Thornburg NNP 3278 332 3 , , , 3278 332 4 “ " `` 3278 332 5 Matching match VBG 3278 332 6 : : : 3278 332 7 Discrimination discrimination NN 3278 332 8 , , , 3278 332 9 Misinforma­ Misinforma­ NNP 3278 332 10 tion tion NN 3278 332 11 , , , 3278 332 12 and and CC 3278 332 13 Sudden sudden JJ 3278 332 14 Death death NN 3278 332 15 , , , 3278 332 16 ” " '' 3278 332 17 Informing Informing NNP 3278 332 18 Science Science NNP 3278 332 19 Conference Conference NNP 3278 332 20 , , , 3278 332 21 Flag­ flag­ CD 3278 332 22 staff staff NN 3278 332 23 , , , 3278 332 24 Ariz. Arizona NNP 3278 332 25 , , , 3278 332 26 June June NNP 3278 332 27 2005 2005 CD 3278 332 28 . . . 3278 333 1 4 4 LS 3278 333 2 . . . 3278 334 1 Thomas Thomas NNP 3278 334 2 B. B. NNP 3278 334 3 Hickey Hickey NNP 3278 334 4 and and CC 3278 334 5 David David NNP 3278 334 6 J. J. NNP 3278 334 7 Rypka Rypka NNP 3278 334 8 , , , 3278 334 9 “ " `` 3278 334 10 Automatic automatic JJ 3278 334 11 Detec­ Detec­ NNP 3278 334 12 tion tion NN 3278 334 13 of of IN 3278 334 14 Duplicate Duplicate NNP 3278 334 15 Monographic Monographic NNP 3278 334 16 Records Records NNPS 3278 334 17 , , , 3278 334 18 ” " '' 3278 334 19 Journal Journal NNP 3278 334 20 of of IN 3278 334 21 Library Library NNP 3278 334 22 Auto- Auto- NNPS 3278 334 23 mation mation NN 3278 334 24 12 12 CD 3278 334 25 , , , 3278 334 26 no no UH 3278 334 27 . . . 3278 335 1 2 2 LS 3278 335 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 335 3 June June NNP 3278 335 4 1979 1979 CD 3278 335 5 ) ) -RRB- 3278 335 6 : : : 3278 335 7 125–42 125–42 CD 3278 335 8 . . . 3278 336 1 5 5 CD 3278 336 2 . . . 3278 337 1 David David NNP 3278 337 2 Bade Bade NNP 3278 337 3 , , , 3278 337 4 “ " `` 3278 337 5 The the DT 3278 337 6 Creation Creation NNP 3278 337 7 and and CC 3278 337 8 Persistence Persistence NNP 3278 337 9 of of IN 3278 337 10 Misinfor­ Misinfor­ NNP 3278 337 11 mation mation NN 3278 337 12 in in IN 3278 337 13 Shared Shared NNP 3278 337 14 Library Library NNP 3278 337 15 Catalogs Catalogs NNP 3278 337 16 , , , 3278 337 17 ” " '' 3278 337 18 Occasional Occasional NNP 3278 337 19 Paper Paper NNP 3278 337 20 No no NN 3278 337 21 . . . 3278 338 1 211 211 CD 3278 338 2 , , , 3278 338 3 ( ( -LRB- 3278 338 4 Graduate Graduate NNP 3278 338 5 School School NNP 3278 338 6 of of IN 3278 338 7 Library Library NNP 3278 338 8 and and CC 3278 338 9 Information Information NNP 3278 338 10 Science Science NNP 3278 338 11 , , , 3278 338 12 Univer­ Univer­ NNP 3278 338 13 sity sity NN 3278 338 14 of of IN 3278 338 15 Illinois Illinois NNP 3278 338 16 at at IN 3278 338 17 Urbana Urbana NNP 3278 338 18 – – : 3278 338 19 Champaign Champaign NNP 3278 338 20 , , , 3278 338 21 Apr. April NNP 3278 339 1 2002 2002 CD 3278 339 2 ) ) -RRB- 3278 339 3 . . . 3278 340 1 6 6 CD 3278 340 2 . . . 3278 341 1 Edward Edward NNP 3278 341 2 T. T. NNP 3278 341 3 O’Neill O’Neill NNP 3278 341 4 , , , 3278 341 5 Sally Sally NNP 3278 341 6 A. A. NNP 3278 341 7 Rogers Rogers NNP 3278 341 8 , , , 3278 341 9 and and CC 3278 341 10 W. W. NNP 3278 341 11 Michael Michael NNP 3278 341 12 Oskins Oskins NNP 3278 341 13 , , , 3278 341 14 “ " `` 3278 341 15 Characteristics Characteristics NNP 3278 341 16 of of IN 3278 341 17 Duplicate Duplicate NNP 3278 341 18 Records Records NNPS 3278 341 19 in in IN 3278 341 20 OCLC oclc NN 3278 341 21 ’s ’s POS 3278 341 22 Online Online NNP 3278 341 23 Union Union NNP 3278 341 24 Catalog Catalog NNP 3278 341 25 , , , 3278 341 26 ” " '' 3278 341 27 Library Library NNP 3278 341 28 Resources Resources NNPS 3278 341 29 and and CC 3278 341 30 Technical Technical NNP 3278 341 31 Services Services NNP 3278 341 32 37 37 CD 3278 341 33 , , , 3278 341 34 no.1 no.1 NNP 3278 341 35 ( ( -LRB- 3278 341 36 1993 1993 CD 3278 341 37 ) ) -RRB- 3278 341 38 : : : 3278 341 39 59–71 59–71 CD 3278 341 40 . . . 3278 342 1 7 7 LS 3278 342 2 . . . 3278 343 1 Jeffrey Jeffrey NNP 3278 343 2 Beal Beal NNP 3278 343 3 and and CC 3278 343 4 Karen Karen NNP 3278 343 5 Kafadar Kafadar NNP 3278 343 6 , , , 3278 343 7 “ " `` 3278 343 8 The the DT 3278 343 9 Effectiveness Effectiveness NNP 3278 343 10 of of IN 3278 343 11 Copy Copy NNP 3278 343 12 Cataloging Cataloging NNP 3278 343 13 at at IN 3278 343 14 Eliminating eliminate VBG 3278 343 15 Typographical Typographical NNP 3278 343 16 Errors Errors NNPS 3278 343 17 in in IN 3278 343 18 Shared Shared NNP 3278 343 19 Bibliographic Bibliographic NNP 3278 343 20 Records Records NNP 3278 343 21 , , , 3278 343 22 ” " '' 3278 343 23 Library Library NNP 3278 343 24 Resources Resources NNP 3278 343 25 & & CC 3278 343 26 Technical Technical NNP 3278 343 27 Services Services NNP 3278 343 28 48 48 CD 3278 343 29 , , , 3278 343 30 no no UH 3278 343 31 . . . 3278 344 1 2 2 LS 3278 344 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 344 3 Apr. April NNP 3278 345 1 2004 2004 CD 3278 345 2 ) ) -RRB- 3278 345 3 : : : 3278 345 4 92–101 92–101 CD 3278 345 5 . . . 3278 346 1 8 8 LS 3278 346 2 . . . 3278 347 1 J. J. NNP 3278 347 2 J. J. NNP 3278 347 3 Pollock Pollock NNP 3278 347 4 and and CC 3278 347 5 A. A. NNP 3278 347 6 Zamora Zamora NNP 3278 347 7 , , , 3278 347 8 “ " `` 3278 347 9 Collection Collection NNP 3278 347 10 and and CC 3278 347 11 Characteriza­ Characteriza­ NNP 3278 347 12 tion tion NN 3278 347 13 of of IN 3278 347 14 Spelling Spelling NNP 3278 347 15 Errors Errors NNPS 3278 347 16 in in IN 3278 347 17 Scientific Scientific NNP 3278 347 18 and and CC 3278 347 19 Scholarly Scholarly NNP 3278 347 20 Text Text NNP 3278 347 21 , , , 3278 347 22 ” " '' 3278 347 23 Journal Journal NNP 3278 347 24 of of IN 3278 347 25 the the DT 3278 347 26 American American NNP 3278 347 27 Society Society NNP 3278 347 28 for for IN 3278 347 29 Information Information NNP 3278 347 30 Science Science NNP 3278 347 31 34 34 CD 3278 347 32 , , , 3278 347 33 no no UH 3278 347 34 . . . 3278 348 1 1 1 CD 3278 348 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 348 3 1983 1983 CD 3278 348 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 348 5 : : : 3278 348 6 51–58 51–58 CD 3278 348 7 . . . 3278 349 1 9 9 CD 3278 349 2 . . . 3278 350 1 Edward Edward NNP 3278 350 2 T. T. NNP 3278 350 3 O’Neill O’Neill NNP 3278 350 4 and and CC 3278 350 5 Rao Rao NNP 3278 350 6 Aluri Aluri NNP 3278 350 7 , , , 3278 350 8 “ " `` 3278 350 9 A a DT 3278 350 10 Method Method NNP 3278 350 11 for for IN 3278 350 12 Cor­ Cor­ NNS 3278 350 13 recting recte VBG 3278 350 14 Typographical typographical JJ 3278 350 15 Errors Errors NNPS 3278 350 16 in in IN 3278 350 17 Subject subject JJ 3278 350 18 Headings Headings NNPS 3278 350 19 in in IN 3278 350 20 OCLC OCLC NNP 3278 350 21 Records Records NNPS 3278 350 22 , , , 3278 350 23 ” " '' 3278 350 24 Research Research NNP 3278 350 25 Report Report NNP 3278 350 26 # # NNP 3278 350 27 OCLC OCLC NNP 3278 350 28 / / SYM 3278 350 29 OPR OPR NNP 3278 350 30 / / SYM 3278 350 31 RR­80/3 RR­80/3 NNP 3278 350 32 ( ( -LRB- 3278 350 33 1980 1980 CD 3278 350 34 ) ) -RRB- 3278 350 35 . . . 3278 351 1 10 10 CD 3278 351 2 . . . 3278 352 1 Martha Martha NNP 3278 352 2 M. M. NNP 3278 352 3 Yee Yee NNP 3278 352 4 , , , 3278 352 5 “ " `` 3278 352 6 Manifestations manifestation NNS 3278 352 7 and and CC 3278 352 8 Year­Equivalents year­equivalent NNS 3278 352 9 : : : 3278 352 10 Theory theory NN 3278 352 11 , , , 3278 352 12 with with IN 3278 352 13 Special special JJ 3278 352 14 Attention attention NN 3278 352 15 to to IN 3278 352 16 Moving­Image moving­image NN 3278 352 17 Materials material NNS 3278 352 18 , , , 3278 352 19 ” " '' 3278 352 20 Library Library NNP 3278 352 21 Resources Resources NNPS 3278 352 22 and and CC 3278 352 23 Technical Technical NNP 3278 352 24 Services Services NNP 3278 352 25 38 38 CD 3278 352 26 , , , 3278 352 27 no no UH 3278 352 28 . . . 3278 353 1 3 3 CD 3278 353 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 353 3 1995 1995 CD 3278 353 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 353 5 : : : 3278 353 6 227–55 227–55 CD 3278 353 7 . . . 3278 354 1 11 11 CD 3278 354 2 . . . 3278 355 1 Owen Owen NNP 3278 355 2 Gingerich Gingerich NNP 3278 355 3 , , , 3278 355 4 “ " `` 3278 355 5 Researching research VBG 3278 355 6 the the DT 3278 355 7 Book Book NNP 3278 355 8 Nobody Nobody NNP 3278 355 9 Read read VB 3278 355 10 : : : 3278 355 11 The the DT 3278 355 12 De De NNP 3278 355 13 Revolutionibus Revolutionibus NNP 3278 355 14 of of IN 3278 355 15 Nicolaus Nicolaus NNP 3278 355 16 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 3278 355 17 , , , 3278 355 18 ” " '' 3278 355 19 The the DT 3278 355 20 Papers Papers NNPS 3278 355 21 of of IN 3278 355 22 the the DT 3278 355 23 Bibliographical Bibliographical NNP 3278 355 24 Society Society NNP 3278 355 25 of of IN 3278 355 26 America America NNP 3278 355 27 99 99 CD 3278 355 28 , , , 3278 355 29 no no UH 3278 355 30 . . . 3278 356 1 4 4 CD 3278 356 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 356 3 2005 2005 CD 3278 356 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 356 5 : : : 3278 356 6 484–504 484–504 CD 3278 356 7 . . . 3278 357 1 12 12 CD 3278 357 2 . . . 3278 358 1 Laura Laura NNP 3278 358 2 D. D. NNP 3278 358 3 Shedenhelm Shedenhelm NNP 3278 358 4 and and CC 3278 358 5 Bartley Bartley NNP 3278 358 6 A. A. NNP 3278 358 7 Burk Burk NNP 3278 358 8 , , , 3278 358 9 “ " `` 3278 358 10 Book Book NNP 3278 358 11 Vendor Vendor NNP 3278 358 12 Records Records NNPS 3278 358 13 in in IN 3278 358 14 the the DT 3278 358 15 OCLC oclc NN 3278 358 16 Database database NN 3278 358 17 : : : 3278 358 18 Boon Boon NNP 3278 358 19 or or CC 3278 358 20 Bane Bane NNP 3278 358 21 ? ? . 3278 358 22 ” " '' 3278 358 23 Library Library NNP 3278 358 24 Resources Resources NNPS 3278 358 25 and and CC 3278 358 26 Technical Technical NNP 3278 358 27 Services Services NNP 3278 358 28 45 45 CD 3278 358 29 , , , 3278 358 30 no no UH 3278 358 31 . . . 3278 359 1 1 1 CD 3278 359 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 359 3 2001 2001 CD 3278 359 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 359 5 : : : 3278 359 6 10–19 10–19 CD 3278 359 7 . . . 3278 360 1 13 13 CD 3278 360 2 . . . 3278 361 1 Peter Peter NNP 3278 361 2 Jasco Jasco NNP 3278 361 3 , , , 3278 361 4 “ " `` 3278 361 5 Content content JJ 3278 361 6 Evaluation evaluation NN 3278 361 7 of of IN 3278 361 8 Databases database NNS 3278 361 9 , , , 3278 361 10 ” " '' 3278 361 11 in in IN 3278 361 12 Annual Annual NNP 3278 361 13 Review Review NNP 3278 361 14 of of IN 3278 361 15 Information Information NNP 3278 361 16 Science Science NNP 3278 361 17 and and CC 3278 361 18 Technology Technology NNP 3278 361 19 , , , 3278 361 20 vol vol NNP 3278 361 21 . . . 3278 362 1 32 32 CD 3278 362 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 362 3 Medford Medford NNP 3278 362 4 , , , 3278 362 5 N.J. New Jersey NNP 3278 362 6 : : : 3278 362 7 Information Information NNP 3278 362 8 Today Today NNP 3278 362 9 , , , 3278 362 10 Inc. Inc. NNP 3278 362 11 , , , 3278 362 12 for for IN 3278 362 13 the the DT 3278 362 14 American American NNP 3278 362 15 Society Society NNP 3278 362 16 for for IN 3278 362 17 Infor­ Infor­ NNP 3278 362 18 mation mation NN 3278 362 19 Science Science NNP 3278 362 20 , , , 3278 362 21 1997 1997 CD 3278 362 22 ) ) -RRB- 3278 362 23 , , , 3278 362 24 231–67 231–67 CD 3278 362 25 . . . 3278 363 1 14 14 CD 3278 363 2 . . . 3278 364 1 Sheila Sheila NNP 3278 364 2 Intner Intner NNP 3278 364 3 , , , 3278 364 4 “ " `` 3278 364 5 Quality quality NN 3278 364 6 in in IN 3278 364 7 Bibliographic Bibliographic NNP 3278 364 8 Databases Databases NNP 3278 364 9 : : : 3278 364 10 An an DT 3278 364 11 Analysis Analysis NNP 3278 364 12 of of IN 3278 364 13 Member­Controlled Member­Controlled NNP 3278 364 14 Cataloging Cataloging NNP 3278 364 15 of of IN 3278 364 16 OCLC OCLC NNP 3278 364 17 and and CC 3278 364 18 RLIN RLIN NNS 3278 364 19 , , , 3278 364 20 ” " '' 3278 364 21 Advances advance NNS 3278 364 22 in in IN 3278 364 23 Library Library NNP 3278 364 24 Administration Administration NNP 3278 364 25 and and CC 3278 364 26 Organization Organization NNP 3278 364 27 8 8 CD 3278 364 28 ( ( -LRB- 3278 364 29 1989 1989 CD 3278 364 30 ) ) -RRB- 3278 364 31 : : : 3278 364 32 1–24 1–24 CD 3278 364 33 . . . 3278 365 1 15 15 CD 3278 365 2 . . . 3278 366 1 Jeffrey Jeffrey NNP 3278 366 2 Beall Beall NNP 3278 366 3 , , , 3278 366 4 “ " `` 3278 366 5 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 366 6 and and CC 3278 366 7 Data Data NNP 3278 366 8 Quality Quality NNP 3278 366 9 Problems Problems NNPS 3278 366 10 in in IN 3278 366 11 the the DT 3278 366 12 Digital Digital NNP 3278 366 13 Library Library NNP 3278 366 14 , , , 3278 366 15 ” " '' 3278 366 16 Journal Journal NNP 3278 366 17 of of IN 3278 366 18 Digital Digital NNP 3278 366 19 Information Information NNP 3278 366 20 6 6 CD 3278 366 21 , , , 3278 366 22 no no UH 3278 366 23 . . . 3278 367 1 3 3 CD 3278 367 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 367 3 2005 2005 CD 3278 367 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 367 5 : : : 3278 367 6 10–11 10–11 CD 3278 367 7 . . . 3278 368 1 16 16 CD 3278 368 2 . . . 3278 369 1 Edward Edward NNP 3278 369 2 T. T. NNP 3278 369 3 O’Neill O’Neill NNP 3278 369 4 and and CC 3278 369 5 Diane Diane NNP 3278 369 6 Vizine­Goetz Vizine­Goetz NNP 3278 369 7 , , , 3278 369 8 “ " `` 3278 369 9 Quality quality JJ 3278 369 10 Control Control NNP 3278 369 11 in in IN 3278 369 12 Online Online NNP 3278 369 13 Databases database NNS 3278 369 14 , , , 3278 369 15 ” " '' 3278 369 16 Annual Annual NNP 3278 369 17 Review Review NNP 3278 369 18 of of IN 3278 369 19 Information Information NNP 3278 369 20 Sci- Sci- NNP 3278 369 21 ence ence NN 3278 369 22 and and CC 3278 369 23 Technology technology NN 3278 369 24 23 23 CD 3278 369 25 ( ( -LRB- 3278 369 26 Washington Washington NNP 3278 369 27 , , , 3278 369 28 D.C. D.C. NNP 3278 369 29 : : : 3278 369 30 American American NNP 3278 369 31 Society Society NNP 3278 369 32 for for IN 3278 369 33 Information Information NNP 3278 369 34 Science Science NNP 3278 369 35 , , , 3278 369 36 1988 1988 CD 3278 369 37 ) ) -RRB- 3278 369 38 . . . 3278 370 1 17 17 CD 3278 370 2 . . . 3278 371 1 Lei Lei NNP 3278 371 2 Zeng Zeng NNP 3278 371 3 , , , 3278 371 4 “ " `` 3278 371 5 Quality Quality NNP 3278 371 6 Control Control NNP 3278 371 7 of of IN 3278 371 8 Chinese­Language Chinese­Language NNP 3278 371 9 Records Records NNPS 3278 371 10 Using use VBG 3278 371 11 a a DT 3278 371 12 Rule­Based rule­base VBN 3278 371 13 Data Data NNP 3278 371 14 Validation Validation NNP 3278 371 15 System System NNP 3278 371 16 . . . 3278 372 1 Part part NN 3278 372 2 1 1 CD 3278 372 3 : : : 3278 372 4 An an DT 3278 372 5 Evalua­ Evalua­ NNP 3278 372 6 tion tion NN 3278 372 7 of of IN 3278 372 8 the the DT 3278 372 9 Quality Quality NNP 3278 372 10 of of IN 3278 372 11 Chinese­Language Chinese­Language NNP 3278 372 12 Records Records NNPS 3278 372 13 in in IN 3278 372 14 the the DT 3278 372 15 OCLC OCLC NNP 3278 372 16 OLUC OLUC NNP 3278 372 17 Database Database NNP 3278 372 18 , , , 3278 372 19 ” " '' 3278 372 20 Cataloging catalog VBG 3278 372 21 and and CC 3278 372 22 Classification Classification NNP 3278 372 23 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 3278 372 24 16 16 CD 3278 372 25 , , , 3278 372 26 no no UH 3278 372 27 . . . 3278 373 1 4 4 CD 3278 373 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 373 3 1993 1993 CD 3278 373 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 373 5 : : : 3278 373 6 25–66 25–66 CD 3278 373 7 18 18 CD 3278 373 8 . . . 3278 374 1 Lei Lei NNP 3278 374 2 Zeng Zeng NNP 3278 374 3 , , , 3278 374 4 “ " `` 3278 374 5 Quality Quality NNP 3278 374 6 Control Control NNP 3278 374 7 of of IN 3278 374 8 Chinese­Language Chinese­Language NNP 3278 374 9 Records Records NNPS 3278 374 10 Using use VBG 3278 374 11 a a DT 3278 374 12 Rule­Based rule­base VBN 3278 374 13 Data Data NNP 3278 374 14 Validation Validation NNP 3278 374 15 System System NNP 3278 374 16 . . . 3278 375 1 Part part NN 3278 375 2 2 2 CD 3278 375 3 : : : 3278 375 4 A a DT 3278 375 5 Study Study NNP 3278 375 6 of of IN 3278 375 7 a a DT 3278 375 8 Rule­Based rule­base VBN 3278 375 9 Data Data NNP 3278 375 10 Validation Validation NNP 3278 375 11 System System NNP 3278 375 12 for for IN 3278 375 13 Online Online NNP 3278 375 14 Chinese Chinese NNP 3278 375 15 Cata­ cata­ NN 3278 375 16 loging log VBG 3278 375 17 , , , 3278 375 18 ” " '' 3278 375 19 Cataloging Cataloging NNP 3278 375 20 and and CC 3278 375 21 Classification Classification NNP 3278 375 22 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 3278 375 23 18 18 CD 3278 375 24 , , , 3278 375 25 no no UH 3278 375 26 . . . 3278 376 1 1 1 CD 3278 376 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 376 3 1993 1993 CD 3278 376 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 376 5 : : : 3278 376 6 3–26 3–26 CD 3278 376 7 . . . 3278 377 1 19 19 CD 3278 377 2 . . . 3278 378 1 Anglo anglo JJ 3278 378 2 - - HYPH 3278 378 3 American american JJ 3278 378 4 Cataloguing Cataloguing NNP 3278 378 5 Rules Rules NNPS 3278 378 6 , , , 3278 378 7 2nd 2nd NNP 3278 378 8 ed ed NNP 3278 378 9 . . NNP 3278 378 10 , , , 3278 378 11 2002 2002 CD 3278 378 12 rev rev NNP 3278 378 13 . . . 3278 379 1 ( ( -LRB- 3278 379 2 Chi­ chi­ JJ 3278 379 3 cago cago NN 3278 379 4 : : : 3278 379 5 ALA ALA NNP 3278 379 6 , , , 3278 379 7 2002 2002 CD 3278 379 8 ) ) -RRB- 3278 379 9 . . . 3278 380 1 20 20 CD 3278 380 2 . . . 3278 381 1 Karen Karen NNP 3278 381 2 Kukich Kukich NNP 3278 381 3 , , , 3278 381 4 “ " `` 3278 381 5 Techniques technique NNS 3278 381 6 for for IN 3278 381 7 Automatically automatically RB 3278 381 8 Correct­ Correct­ NNP 3278 381 9 ing ing NNP 3278 381 10 Words Words NNPS 3278 381 11 in in IN 3278 381 12 Text Text NNP 3278 381 13 , , , 3278 381 14 ” " '' 3278 381 15 ACM ACM NNP 3278 381 16 Computing Computing NNP 3278 381 17 Surveys Surveys NNP 3278 381 18 24 24 CD 3278 381 19 , , , 3278 381 20 no no UH 3278 381 21 . . . 3278 382 1 4 4 CD 3278 382 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 382 3 1992 1992 CD 3278 382 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 382 5 : : : 3278 382 6 377–439 377–439 CD 3278 382 7 . . . 3278 383 1 21 21 CD 3278 383 2 . . . 3278 384 1 Gail Gail NNP 3278 384 2 Thornburg Thornburg NNP 3278 384 3 , , , 3278 384 4 “ " `` 3278 384 5 The the DT 3278 384 6 Syllables Syllables NNPS 3278 384 7 in in IN 3278 384 8 the the DT 3278 384 9 Haystack Haystack NNP 3278 384 10 : : : 3278 384 11 Techni­ Techni­ NNP 3278 384 12 cal cal JJ 3278 384 13 Challenges Challenges NNPS 3278 384 14 of of IN 3278 384 15 Non­Chinese Non­Chinese NNP 3278 384 16 in in IN 3278 384 17 a a DT 3278 384 18 Wade­Giles wade­giles NN 3278 384 19 to to IN 3278 384 20 Pinyin Pinyin NNP 3278 384 21 Con­ Con­ NNP 3278 384 22 version version NN 3278 384 23 , , , 3278 384 24 ” " '' 3278 384 25 Information Information NNP 3278 384 26 Technology Technology NNP 3278 384 27 and and CC 3278 384 28 Libraries Libraries NNP 3278 384 29 21 21 CD 3278 384 30 , , , 3278 384 31 no no UH 3278 384 32 . . . 3278 385 1 3 3 CD 3278 385 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 385 3 2002 2002 CD 3278 385 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 385 5 : : : 3278 385 6 120–26 120–26 CD 3278 385 7 . . . 3278 386 1 22 22 CD 3278 386 2 . . . 3278 387 1 Hartmut Hartmut NNP 3278 387 2 Walravens Walravens NNP 3278 387 3 , , , 3278 387 4 “ " `` 3278 387 5 Serials Serials NNPS 3278 387 6 Cataloguing Cataloguing NNP 3278 387 7 in in IN 3278 387 8 Germany Germany NNP 3278 387 9 : : : 3278 387 10 The the DT 3278 387 11 Historical Historical NNP 3278 387 12 Development Development NNP 3278 387 13 , , , 3278 387 14 ” " '' 3278 387 15 Cataloging Cataloging NNP 3278 387 16 and and CC 3278 387 17 Classification Classification NNP 3278 387 18 Quar- Quar- NNP 3278 387 19 terly terly RB 3278 387 20 35 35 CD 3278 387 21 , , , 3278 387 22 no no UH 3278 387 23 . . . 3278 388 1 3/4 3/4 CD 3278 388 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 388 3 2003 2003 CD 3278 388 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 388 5 : : : 3278 388 6 541–51 541–51 CD 3278 388 7 ; ; : 3278 388 8 Instruktionen Instruktionen NNP 3278 388 9 für für NNS 3278 388 10 die die VBP 3278 388 11 alphabetischen alphabetischen NNP 3278 388 12 kataloge kataloge NNP 3278 388 13 der der NNP 3278 388 14 preuszischen preuszischen NNP 3278 388 15 bibliotheken bibliotheken NNP 3278 388 16 vom vom NNS 3278 388 17 10 10 CD 3278 388 18 . . . 3278 388 19 mai mai NNP 3278 388 20 1899 1899 CD 3278 388 21 . . . 3278 389 1 2 2 CD 3278 389 2 ausg ausg NNP 3278 389 3 . . . 3278 390 1 in in IN 3278 390 2 der der NNP 3278 390 3 fassung fassung NNP 3278 390 4 vom vom NNP 3278 390 5 10 10 CD 3278 390 6 . . . 3278 390 7 august august NNP 3278 390 8 1908 1908 CD 3278 390 9 ( ( -LRB- 3278 390 10 Berlin Berlin NNP 3278 390 11 : : : 3278 390 12 Behrend Behrend NNP 3278 390 13 & & CC 3278 390 14 Co. Co. NNP 3278 390 15 , , , 3278 390 16 1909 1909 CD 3278 390 17 ) ) -RRB- 3278 390 18 . . . 3278 391 1 23 23 CD 3278 391 2 . . . 3278 392 1 Richard Richard NNP 3278 392 2 Greene Greene NNP 3278 392 3 , , , 3278 392 4 e­mail e­mail NN 3278 392 5 message message NN 3278 392 6 to to IN 3278 392 7 author author NN 3278 392 8 , , , 3278 392 9 Nov. November NNP 3278 392 10 13 13 CD 3278 392 11 , , , 3278 392 12 2006 2006 CD 3278 392 13 ; ; : 3278 392 14 Regeln Regeln NNP 3278 392 15 für für NNS 3278 392 16 die die VBP 3278 392 17 alphabetische alphabetische NN 3278 392 18 Katalogisierung Katalogisierung NNP 3278 392 19 : : : 3278 392 20 RAK RAK NNP 3278 392 21 / / SYM 3278 392 22 Irmgard Irmgard NNP 3278 392 23 Bou­ Bou­ NNP 3278 392 24 vier vier NN 3278 392 25 ( ( -LRB- 3278 392 26 Wiesbaden Wiesbaden NNP 3278 392 27 , , , 3278 392 28 Germany Germany NNP 3278 392 29 : : : 3278 392 30 L. L. NNP 3278 392 31 Reichert Reichert NNP 3278 392 32 , , , 3278 392 33 1980 1980 CD 3278 392 34 , , , 3278 392 35 c1977 c1977 NNP 3278 392 36 ) ) -RRB- 3278 392 37 . . . 3278 393 1 24 24 CD 3278 393 2 . . . 3278 394 1 Intner Intner NNP 3278 394 2 , , , 3278 394 3 “ " `` 3278 394 4 Quality quality NN 3278 394 5 in in IN 3278 394 6 Bibliographic Bibliographic NNP 3278 394 7 Databases Databases NNP 3278 394 8 . . . 3278 394 9 ” " '' 3278 394 10 25 25 CD 3278 394 11 . . . 3278 395 1 Richard Richard NNP 3278 395 2 Greene Greene NNP 3278 395 3 , , , 3278 395 4 e­mail e­mail NN 3278 395 5 message message NN 3278 395 6 to to IN 3278 395 7 author author NN 3278 395 8 , , , 3278 395 9 Feb. February NNP 3278 395 10 27 27 CD 3278 395 11 , , , 3278 395 12 2006 2006 CD 3278 395 13 . . . 3278 396 1 26 26 CD 3278 396 2 . . . 3278 397 1 Beall Beall NNP 3278 397 2 , , , 3278 397 3 “ " `` 3278 397 4 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 397 5 and and CC 3278 397 6 Data Data NNP 3278 397 7 Quality Quality NNP 3278 397 8 Problems Problems NNPS 3278 397 9 in in IN 3278 397 10 the the DT 3278 397 11 Digital Digital NNP 3278 397 12 Library Library NNP 3278 397 13 . . . 3278 397 14 ” " '' 3278 397 15 27 27 CD 3278 397 16 . . . 3278 398 1 R. R. NNP 3278 398 2 John John NNP 3278 398 3 Robertson Robertson NNP 3278 398 4 , , , 3278 398 5 “ " `` 3278 398 6 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 398 7 Quality Quality NNP 3278 398 8 : : : 3278 398 9 Implications implication NNS 3278 398 10 for for IN 3278 398 11 Library Library NNP 3278 398 12 and and CC 3278 398 13 Information Information NNP 3278 398 14 Science Science NNP 3278 398 15 Professionals Professionals NNPS 3278 398 16 , , , 3278 398 17 ” " '' 3278 398 18 Library Library NNP 3278 398 19 Review Review NNP 3278 398 20 54 54 CD 3278 398 21 , , , 3278 398 22 no no UH 3278 398 23 . . . 3278 399 1 5 5 CD 3278 399 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 399 3 2005 2005 CD 3278 399 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 399 5 : : : 3278 399 6 295–300 295–300 CD 3278 399 7 . . . 3278 400 1 PuBLIC public JJ 3278 400 2 LIBRARIES library NNS 3278 400 3 AND and CC 3278 400 4 INTERNET INTERNET NNP 3278 400 5 ACCESS ACCESS NNP 3278 400 6 | | NNS 3278 400 7 JAEGER jaeger NN 3278 400 8 , , , 3278 400 9 BERTOT bertot NN 3278 400 10 , , , 3278 400 11 MCCLuRE mcclure UH 3278 400 12 , , , 3278 400 13 AND and CC 3278 400 14 RODRIGuEz rodriguez NN 3278 400 15 23MISINFORMATION 23misinformation CD 3278 400 16 AND and CC 3278 400 17 BIAS bia NNS 3278 400 18 IN in IN 3278 400 19 METADATA METADATA NNP 3278 400 20 PROCESSING PROCESSING NNP 3278 400 21 | | CD 3278 400 22 THORNBuRG THORNBuRG NNS 3278 400 23 AND and CC 3278 400 24 OSkINS oskins RB 3278 400 25 23 23 CD 3278 400 26 28 28 CD 3278 400 27 . . . 3278 401 1 IEEE IEEE NNP 3278 401 2 . . . 3278 402 1 Learning Learning NNP 3278 402 2 Technology Technology NNP 3278 402 3 Standards Standards NNP 3278 402 4 Committee Committee NNP 3278 402 5 , , , 3278 402 6 “ " `` 3278 402 7 WG12 wg12 NN 3278 402 8 : : : 3278 402 9 Learning learning NN 3278 402 10 Objects object NNS 3278 402 11 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 402 12 . . . 3278 402 13 ” " '' 3278 402 14 http://ltsc.ieee.org/wg12 http://ltsc.ieee.org/wg12 NNP 3278 402 15 ( ( -LRB- 3278 402 16 accessed access VBN 3278 402 17 Feb. February NNP 3278 402 18 26 26 CD 3278 402 19 , , , 3278 402 20 2006 2006 CD 3278 402 21 ) ) -RRB- 3278 402 22 . . . 3278 403 1 29 29 CD 3278 403 2 . . . 3278 404 1 Ibid ibid RB 3278 404 2 . . . 3278 405 1 30 30 CD 3278 405 2 . . . 3278 406 1 Orien Orien NNP 3278 406 2 Beit­Arie Beit­Arie NNP 3278 406 3 et et FW 3278 406 4 al al NNP 3278 406 5 . . NNP 3278 406 6 , , , 3278 406 7 “ " `` 3278 406 8 Linking link VBG 3278 406 9 to to IN 3278 406 10 the the DT 3278 406 11 Appropriate Appropriate NNP 3278 406 12 Copy Copy NNP 3278 406 13 : : : 3278 406 14 Report report NN 3278 406 15 of of IN 3278 406 16 a a DT 3278 406 17 DOI­Based DOI­Based NNP 3278 406 18 Prototype Prototype NNP 3278 406 19 , , , 3278 406 20 ” " '' 3278 406 21 D D NNP 3278 406 22 - - HYPH 3278 406 23 Lib Lib NNP 3278 406 24 7 7 CD 3278 406 25 , , , 3278 406 26 no no UH 3278 406 27 . . . 3278 407 1 9 9 CD 3278 407 2 ( ( -LRB- 3278 407 3 Sept. September NNP 3278 407 4 2001 2001 CD 3278 407 5 ) ) -RRB- 3278 407 6 . . . 3278 408 1 31 31 CD 3278 408 2 . . . 3278 409 1 Thomas Thomas NNP 3278 409 2 R. R. NNP 3278 409 3 Bruce Bruce NNP 3278 409 4 and and CC 3278 409 5 Diane Diane NNP 3278 409 6 I. I. NNP 3278 409 7 Hillmann,“The Hillmann,“The NNP 3278 409 8 Continuum Continuum NNP 3278 409 9 of of IN 3278 409 10 Metadata Metadata NNP 3278 409 11 Quality Quality NNP 3278 409 12 : : : 3278 409 13 Defining define VBG 3278 409 14 , , , 3278 409 15 Expressing express VBG 3278 409 16 , , , 3278 409 17 Exploiting exploit VBG 3278 409 18 , , , 3278 409 19 ” " '' 3278 409 20 in in IN 3278 409 21 Meta- Meta- NNP 3278 409 22 data datum NNS 3278 409 23 in in IN 3278 409 24 Practice Practice NNP 3278 409 25 ( ( -LRB- 3278 409 26 Chicago Chicago NNP 3278 409 27 : : : 3278 409 28 ALA ALA NNP 3278 409 29 , , , 3278 409 30 2004 2004 CD 3278 409 31 ) ) -RRB- 3278 409 32 , , , 3278 409 33 238–56 238–56 CD 3278 409 34 . . . 3278 410 1 32 32 CD 3278 410 2 . . . 3278 411 1 Shedenhelm Shedenhelm NNP 3278 411 2 and and CC 3278 411 3 Burk Burk NNP 3278 411 4 , , , 3278 411 5 “ " `` 3278 411 6 Book Book NNP 3278 411 7 Vendor Vendor NNP 3278 411 8 Records Records NNPS 3278 411 9 in in IN 3278 411 10 the the DT 3278 411 11 OCLC OCLC NNP 3278 411 12 Database database NN 3278 411 13 . . . 3278 411 14 ” " '' 3278 411 15 24 24 CD 3278 411 16 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNS 3278 411 17 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3278 411 18 AND and CC 3278 411 19 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 411 20 | | NNP 3278 411 21 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 411 22 200724 200724 CD 3278 411 23 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3278 411 24 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3278 411 25 AND and CC 3278 411 26 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 411 27 | | NNP 3278 411 28 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 411 29 2007 2007 CD 3278 411 30 Appendix Appendix NNP 3278 411 31 A. a. NN 3278 412 1 Sample Sample NNP 3278 412 2 CDFRecord CDFRecord NNP 3278 412 3 Record Record NNP 3278 412 4 from from IN 3278 412 5 the the DT 3278 412 6 XWC XWC NNP 3278 412 7 Database Database NNP 3278 412 8 < < XX 3278 412 9 CDFRec CDFRec NNP 3278 412 10 db=”fs­xwc”> > XX 3278 412 12 cgm cgm XX 3278 412 13 7a 7a NN 3278 412 14 < < XX 3278 412 15 /a /a . 3278 412 16 > > XX 3278 412 17 < < XX 3278 412 18 c001>2768129027681290 > XX 3278 412 20 < < XX 3278 412 21 c007 c007 VBP 3278 412 22 > > XX 3278 412 23 vf vf XX 3278 412 24 bcahru > XX 3278 412 26 < < XX 3278 412 27 c007 c007 VBP 3278 412 28 > > XX 3278 412 29 mr mr NNP 3278 412 30 baaafu > XX 3278 412 32 < < XX 3278 412 33 c008>920714r19551952fr c008>920714r19551952fr NNP 3278 412 34 092 092 CD 3278 412 35 mleng mleng NN 3278 412 36 < < XX 3278 412 37 /c008 /c008 NNP 3278 412 38 > > XX 3278 412 39 < < XX 3278 412 40 v010 v010 NNP 3278 412 41 i1= i1= NNP 3278 412 42 ” " '' 3278 412 43 “ " `` 3278 412 44 i2= i2= FW 3278 412 45 ” " '' 3278 412 46 “ " `` 3278 412 47 > > XX 3278 412 48 < < XX 3278 412 49 sa> > XX 3278 412 51 92513007 92513007 CD 3278 412 52 < < XX 3278 412 53 /d> > XX 3278 412 56 < < XX 3278 412 57 v040 v040 JJ 3278 412 58 i1= i1= NNP 3278 412 59 ” " '' 3278 412 60 “ " `` 3278 412 61 i2= i2= FW 3278 412 62 ” " '' 3278 412 63 “ " `` 3278 412 64 > > XX 3278 412 65 < < XX 3278 412 66 sa> > JJ 3278 412 68 DLC > XX 3278 412 71 amim > XX 3278 412 73 < < XX 3278 412 74 sc> > XX 3278 412 76 DLC > XX 3278 412 78 < < XX 3278 412 79 v017 v017 NNP 3278 412 80 i1= i1= NNP 3278 412 81 ” " '' 3278 412 82 “ " `` 3278 412 83 i2= i2= FW 3278 412 84 ” " '' 3278 412 85 “ " `` 3278 412 86 > > XX 3278 412 87 < < XX 3278 412 88 sa> > XX 3278 412 90 LP5921 > NFP 3278 412 93 U.S. U.S. NNP 3278 413 1 Copyright Copyright NNP 3278 413 2 Office > XX 3278 413 5 < < XX 3278 413 6 v044 v044 NNP 3278 413 7 i1= i1= NNP 3278 413 8 ” " '' 3278 413 9 “ " `` 3278 413 10 i2= i2= FW 3278 413 11 ” " '' 3278 413 12 “ " `` 3278 413 13 > > XX 3278 413 14 < < XX 3278 413 15 sa> > NN 3278 413 17 xxu > XX 3278 413 19 < < XX 3278 413 20 sa> > VBN 3278 413 22 mr > XX 3278 413 24 < < XX 3278 413 25 v050 v050 NNP 3278 413 26 i1=”0 i1=”0 POS 3278 413 27 ” " '' 3278 413 28 i2=”0”> > XX 3278 413 30 VBE VBE NNP 3278 413 31 6360­6361 6360­6361 CD 3278 413 32 ( ( -LRB- 3278 413 33 viewing view VBG 3278 413 34 copy) > XX 3278 413 36 < < XX 3278 413 37 v050 v050 NNP 3278 413 38 i1=”0 i1=”0 POS 3278 413 39 ” " '' 3278 413 40 i2=”0”> > XX 3278 413 42 FGB FGB NNP 3278 413 43 5643­5647 5643­5647 CD 3278 413 44 ( ( -LRB- 3278 413 45 ref ref NNP 3278 413 46 print) > XX 3278 413 48 < < XX 3278 413 49 v050 v050 NNP 3278 413 50 i1=”0 i1=”0 POS 3278 413 51 ” " '' 3278 413 52 i2=”0”> > XX 3278 413 54 FPA fpa NN 3278 413 55 0621­0625 0621­0625 CD 3278 413 56 ( ( -LRB- 3278 413 57 master­ master­ NN 3278 413 58 pos) > XX 3278 413 60 < < XX 3278 413 61 v130 v130 IN 3278 413 62 i1=”0 i1=”0 CD 3278 413 63 ” " '' 3278 413 64 i2= i2= FW 3278 413 65 ” " '' 3278 413 66 “ " `` 3278 413 67 > > XX 3278 413 68 < < XX 3278 413 69 sa> > FW 3278 413 71 Othello Othello NNP 3278 413 72 ( ( -LRB- 3278 413 73 Motion Motion NNP 3278 413 74 picture picture NN 3278 413 75 : : : 3278 413 76 Welles) > XX 3278 413 78 < < XX 3278 413 79 v245 v245 NNP 3278 413 80 i1=”1 i1=”1 XX 3278 413 81 ” " '' 3278 413 82 i2=”4”> > XX 3278 413 84 The the DT 3278 413 85 Tragedy Tragedy NNP 3278 413 86 of of IN 3278 413 87 Othello­­ Othello­­ NNP 3278 413 88 the the DT 3278 413 89 Moor Moor NNP 3278 413 90 of of IN 3278 413 91 Venice Venice NNP 3278 413 92 / > XX 3278 413 94 < < XX 3278 413 95 sc> > FW 3278 413 97 a a DT 3278 413 98 Mercury Mercury NNP 3278 413 99 Production Production NNP 3278 413 100 , , , 3278 413 101 [ [ -LRB- 3278 413 102 Films film NNS 3278 413 103 Marceau Marceau NNP 3278 413 104 ? ? . 3278 413 105 ] ] -RRB- 3278 414 1 ; ; : 3278 414 2 directed direct VBN 3278 414 3 , , , 3278 414 4 produced produce VBN 3278 414 5 , , , 3278 414 6 and and CC 3278 414 7 written write VBN 3278 414 8 by by IN 3278 414 9 Orson Orson NNP 3278 414 10 Welles. > XX 3278 414 13 < < XX 3278 414 14 v257 v257 NNP 3278 414 15 i1= i1= NNP 3278 414 16 ” " '' 3278 414 17 “ " `` 3278 414 18 i2= i2= FW 3278 414 19 ” " '' 3278 414 20 “ " `` 3278 414 21 > > XX 3278 414 22 < < XX 3278 414 23 sa> > NN 3278 414 25 U.S. U.S. NNP 3278 415 1 ; ; : 3278 415 2 [ [ -LRB- 3278 415 3 Morocco Morocco NNP 3278 415 4 ? ? . 3278 416 1 ] ] -RRB- 3278 416 2 < < XX 3278 416 3 /d> > XX 3278 416 6 < < XX 3278 416 7 v260 v260 NN 3278 416 8 i1= i1= NNS 3278 416 9 ” " '' 3278 416 10 “ " `` 3278 416 11 i2= i2= FW 3278 416 12 ” " '' 3278 416 13 “ " `` 3278 416 14 > > XX 3278 416 15 < < XX 3278 416 16 sa> > NN 3278 416 18 France France NNP 3278 416 19 : : : 3278 416 20 < < XX 3278 416 21 /d> > XX 3278 416 24 Films Films NNPS 3278 416 25 Marceau,1952 Marceau,1952 NNP 3278 416 26 ; ; : 3278 416 27 < < XX 3278 416 28 /d /d . 3278 416 29 > > XX 3278 416 30 < < XX 3278 416 31 /sc>[Morocco /sc>[Morocco NFP 3278 416 32 ? ? . 3278 417 1 : : : 3278 417 2 : : : 3278 417 3 < < XX 3278 417 4 /d> > NNP 3278 417 6 s.n s.n NNP 3278 417 7 . . NNP 3278 417 8 , > XX 3278 417 11 < < XX 3278 417 12 sc>1952 sc>1952 NNP 3278 417 13 ? ? . 3278 417 14 ] ] -RRB- 3278 418 1 ; ; : 3278 418 2 < < XX 3278 418 3 /d> > NFP 3278 418 5 United United NNP 3278 418 6 States States NNP 3278 418 7 : : : 3278 418 8 < < XX 3278 418 9 / / SYM 3278 418 10 d> > XX 3278 418 12 < < XX 3278 418 13 sb> > XX 3278 418 15 United United NNP 3278 418 16 Artists,1955.1955. > XX 3278 418 19 < < XX 3278 418 20 v300 v300 NNP 3278 418 21 i1= i1= NNP 3278 418 22 ” " '' 3278 418 23 “ " `` 3278 418 24 i2= i2= FW 3278 418 25 ” " '' 3278 418 26 “ " `` 3278 418 27 > > XX 3278 418 28 < < XX 3278 418 29 sa>2 sa>2 NNP 3278 418 30 videocassettes videocassette NNS 3278 418 31 of of IN 3278 418 32 2 2 CD 3278 418 33 ( ( -LRB- 3278 418 34 ca ca NN 3278 418 35 . . . 3278 419 1 92 92 CD 3278 419 2 min min NN 3278 419 3 . . . 3278 419 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 420 1 : : : 3278 420 2 < < XX 3278 420 3 /d> > XX 3278 420 5 sd sd NN 3278 420 6 . . NNP 3278 420 7 , , , 3278 420 8 b&w b&w NNPS 3278 420 9 ; ; : 3278 420 10 < < XX 3278 420 11 /d> > XX 3278 420 14 < < XX 3278 420 15 sc>3/4 sc>3/4 NNP 3278 420 16 in in IN 3278 420 17 . . . 3278 421 1 viewing view VBG 3278 421 2 copy. > NNP 3278 421 4 < < XX 3278 421 5 v300 v300 NNP 3278 421 6 i1= i1= NNP 3278 421 7 ” " '' 3278 421 8 “ " `` 3278 421 9 i2= i2= FW 3278 421 10 ” " '' 3278 421 11 “ " `` 3278 421 12 > > XX 3278 421 13 < < XX 3278 421 14 sa>10 sa>10 NNP 3278 421 15 reels reel NNS 3278 421 16 of of IN 3278 421 17 10 10 CD 3278 421 18 on on IN 3278 421 19 5 5 CD 3278 421 20 ( ( -LRB- 3278 421 21 ca ca NN 3278 421 22 . . . 3278 422 1 8280 8280 CD 3278 422 2 ft ft NNP 3278 422 3 . . NNP 3278 422 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 422 5 : : : 3278 422 6 < < XX 3278 422 7 /d> > XX 3278 422 9 sd sd NN 3278 422 10 . . NNP 3278 422 11 , , , 3278 422 12 b&w b&w ADD 3278 422 13 ; ; : 3278 422 14 < < XX 3278 422 15 /d> > XX 3278 422 17 < < XX 3278 422 18 sc>35 sc>35 NNP 3278 422 19 mm mm NNP 3278 422 20 . . . 3278 423 1 ref ref NNP 3278 423 2 print. > XX 3278 423 4 < < XX 3278 423 5 v300 v300 NNP 3278 423 6 i1= i1= NNP 3278 423 7 ” " '' 3278 423 8 “ " `` 3278 423 9 i2= i2= FW 3278 423 10 ” " '' 3278 423 11 “ " `` 3278 423 12 > > XX 3278 423 13 < < XX 3278 423 14 sa>10 sa>10 NNP 3278 423 15 reels reel NNS 3278 423 16 of of IN 3278 423 17 10 10 CD 3278 423 18 on on IN 3278 423 19 5 5 CD 3278 423 20 ( ( -LRB- 3278 423 21 ca ca NN 3278 423 22 . . . 3278 424 1 8280 8280 CD 3278 424 2 ft ft NNP 3278 424 3 . . NNP 3278 424 4 ) ) -RRB- 3278 424 5 : : : 3278 424 6 < < XX 3278 424 7 /d> > XX 3278 424 9 sd sd NN 3278 424 10 . . NNP 3278 424 11 , , , 3278 424 12 b&w b&w ADD 3278 424 13 ; ; : 3278 424 14 < < XX 3278 424 15 /d> > XX 3278 424 17 < < XX 3278 424 18 sc>35 sc>35 NNP 3278 424 19 mm mm NNP 3278 424 20 . . . 3278 425 1 masterpos. > XX 3278 425 3 < < XX 3278 425 4 v500 v500 NNP 3278 425 5 i1= i1= NNP 3278 425 6 ” " '' 3278 425 7 “ " `` 3278 425 8 i2= i2= FW 3278 425 9 ” " '' 3278 425 10 “ " `` 3278 425 11 > > XX 3278 425 12 < < XX 3278 425 13 sa> > JJ 3278 425 15 Copyright copyright NN 3278 425 16 : : : 3278 425 17 Orson Orson NNP 3278 425 18 Welles Welles NNP 3278 425 19 ; ; : 3278 425 20 19Sep52 19sep52 ADD 3278 425 21 ; ; : 3278 425 22 LP5921. > XX 3278 425 24 < < XX 3278 425 25 v500 v500 NNP 3278 425 26 i1= i1= NNP 3278 425 27 ” " '' 3278 425 28 “ " `` 3278 425 29 i2= i2= FW 3278 425 30 ” " '' 3278 425 31 “ " `` 3278 425 32 > > XX 3278 425 33 < < XX 3278 425 34 sa> > NN 3278 425 36 Reference reference NN 3278 425 37 sources source NNS 3278 425 38 cited cite VBD 3278 425 39 below below RB 3278 425 40 and and CC 3278 425 41 M M NNP 3278 425 42 / / SYM 3278 425 43 B B NNP 3278 425 44 / / SYM 3278 425 45 RS RS NNP 3278 425 46 preliminary preliminary JJ 3278 425 47 cataloging cataloging NN 3278 425 48 card card NN 3278 425 49 list list NN 3278 425 50 title title NN 3278 425 51 as as IN 3278 425 52 Othello. > XX 3278 425 54 < < XX 3278 425 55 v508 v508 JJ 3278 425 56 i1= i1= NNP 3278 425 57 ” " '' 3278 425 58 “ " `` 3278 425 59 i2= i2= FW 3278 425 60 ” " '' 3278 425 61 “ " `` 3278 425 62 > > XX 3278 425 63 < < XX 3278 425 64 sa> > XX 3278 425 66 Photography Photography NNP 3278 425 67 , , , 3278 425 68 Anchisi Anchisi NNP 3278 425 69 Brizzi Brizzi NNP 3278 425 70 , , , 3278 425 71 G.R. G.R. NNP 3278 426 1 Aldo Aldo NNP 3278 426 2 , , , 3278 426 3 George George NNP 3278 426 4 Fanto Fanto NNP 3278 426 5 ; ; : 3278 426 6 film film NN 3278 426 7 editors editor NNS 3278 426 8 , , , 3278 426 9 John John NNP 3278 426 10 Shepridge Shepridge NNP 3278 426 11 , , , 3278 426 12 Jean Jean NNP 3278 426 13 Sacha Sacha NNP 3278 426 14 , , , 3278 426 15 Renzo Renzo NNP 3278 426 16 Lucidi Lucidi NNP 3278 426 17 , , , 3278 426 18 William William NNP 3278 426 19 Morton Morton NNP 3278 426 20 ; ; : 3278 426 21 music music NN 3278 426 22 , , , 3278 426 23 Francesco Francesco NNP 3278 426 24 Lavagnino Lavagnino NNP 3278 426 25 , , , 3278 426 26 Alberto Alberto NNP 3278 426 27 Barberis. > XX 3278 426 29 < < XX 3278 426 30 v511 v511 NNP 3278 426 31 i1=”1 i1=”1 UH 3278 426 32 ” " '' 3278 426 33 i2= i2= NNP 3278 426 34 ” " '' 3278 426 35 “ " `` 3278 426 36 > > XX 3278 426 37 < < XX 3278 426 38 sa> > NN 3278 426 40 Orson Orson NNP 3278 426 41 Welles Welles NNP 3278 426 42 , , , 3278 426 43 Suzanne Suzanne NNP 3278 426 44 Cloutier Cloutier NNP 3278 426 45 , , , 3278 426 46 MicheaÌ MicheaÌ NNP 3278 426 47 l l NNP 3278 426 48 MacLiamoÌ MacLiamoÌ NNP 3278 426 49 ir ir NNP 3278 426 50 , , , 3278 426 51 Robert Robert NNP 3278 426 52 Coote. > XX 3278 426 55 < < XX 3278 426 56 v500 v500 NNP 3278 426 57 i1= i1= NNP 3278 426 58 ” " '' 3278 426 59 “ " `` 3278 426 60 i2= i2= FW 3278 426 61 ” " '' 3278 426 62 “ " `` 3278 426 63 > > XX 3278 426 64 < < XX 3278 426 65 sa> > XX 3278 426 67 Director director NN 3278 426 68 , , , 3278 426 69 producer producer NN 3278 426 70 , , , 3278 426 71 and and CC 3278 426 72 writer writer NN 3278 426 73 credits credit NNS 3278 426 74 taken take VBN 3278 426 75 from from IN 3278 426 76 Focus Focus NNP 3278 426 77 on on IN 3278 426 78 Orson Orson NNP 3278 426 79 Welles Welles NNP 3278 426 80 , , , 3278 426 81 p. p. NN 3278 426 82 205. > XX 3278 426 84 < < XX 3278 426 85 v500 v500 NNP 3278 426 86 i1= i1= NNP 3278 426 87 ” " '' 3278 426 88 “ " `` 3278 426 89 i2= i2= FW 3278 426 90 ” " '' 3278 426 91 “ " `` 3278 426 92 > > XX 3278 426 93 < < XX 3278 426 94 sa> > XX 3278 426 96 LC LC NNP 3278 426 97 has have VBZ 3278 426 98 U.S. U.S. NNP 3278 426 99 reissue reissue NN 3278 426 100 copy. > NFP 3278 426 102 DLC > XX 3278 426 104 < < XX 3278 426 105 v510 v510 NNP 3278 426 106 i1=”4 i1=”4 NNP 3278 426 107 ” " '' 3278 426 108 i2= i2= FW 3278 426 109 ” " '' 3278 426 110 “ " `` 3278 426 111 > > XX 3278 426 112 < < XX 3278 426 113 sa> > JJ 3278 426 115 New New NNP 3278 426 116 York York NNP 3278 426 117 times,9/15/55.9/15/55. > FW 3278 426 120 < < XX 3278 426 121 v500 v500 NNP 3278 426 122 i1= i1= NNP 3278 426 123 ” " '' 3278 426 124 “ " `` 3278 426 125 i2= i2= FW 3278 426 126 ” " '' 3278 426 127 “ " `` 3278 426 128 > > XX 3278 426 129 < < XX 3278 426 130 sa> > . 3278 426 132 An an DT 3278 426 133 adaptation adaptation NN 3278 426 134 of of IN 3278 426 135 the the DT 3278 426 136 play play NN 3278 426 137 by by IN 3278 426 138 William William NNP 3278 426 139 Shakespeare. > XX 3278 426 141 < < XX 3278 426 142 v500 v500 NNP 3278 426 143 i1= i1= NNP 3278 426 144 ” " '' 3278 426 145 “ " `` 3278 426 146 i2= i2= FW 3278 426 147 ” " '' 3278 426 148 “ " `` 3278 426 149 > > XX 3278 426 150 < < XX 3278 426 151 sa> > NN 3278 426 153 Reference reference NN 3278 426 154 sources source NNS 3278 426 155 used use VBD 3278 426 156 : : : 3278 426 157 New New NNP 3278 426 158 York York NNP 3278 426 159 times time NNS 3278 426 160 , , , 3278 426 161 9/15/55 9/15/55 CD 3278 426 162 ; ; : 3278 426 163 International international JJ 3278 426 164 motion motion NN 3278 426 165 pic­ pic­ NNP 3278 426 166 ture ture NNP 3278 426 167 almanac almanac NNP 3278 426 168 , , , 3278 426 169 1956 1956 CD 3278 426 170 , , , 3278 426 171 p. p. NN 3278 426 172 329 329 CD 3278 426 173 ; ; : 3278 426 174 Focus Focus NNP 3278 426 175 on on IN 3278 426 176 Orson Orson NNP 3278 426 177 Welles Welles NNP 3278 426 178 , , , 3278 426 179 p. p. NN 3278 426 180 205­206 205­206 NNS 3278 426 181 ; ; : 3278 426 182 Monthly monthly JJ 3278 426 183 film film NN 3278 426 184 bulletin bulletin NN 3278 426 185 , , , 3278 426 186 v. v. CC 3278 426 187 23 23 CD 3278 426 188 , , , 3278 426 189 no no UH 3278 426 190 . . . 3278 427 1 267 267 CD 3278 427 2 , , , 3278 427 3 p. p. NN 3278 427 4 44 44 CD 3278 427 5 ; ; : 3278 427 6 Index Index NNP 3278 427 7 de de NNP 3278 427 8 la la NNP 3278 427 9 cineÌ cineÌ NNP 3278 427 10 matog­ matog­ NNP 3278 427 11 raphie raphie NNP 3278 427 12 française francì§aise CD 3278 427 13 , , , 3278 427 14 1952 1952 CD 3278 427 15 , , , 3278 427 16 p. p. NN 3278 427 17 496. > XX 3278 427 19 < < XX 3278 427 20 v541 v541 NNP 3278 427 21 i1= i1= NNP 3278 427 22 ” " '' 3278 427 23 “ " `` 3278 427 24 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 25 ” " '' 3278 427 26 “ " `` 3278 427 27 > > XX 3278 427 28 < < XX 3278 427 29 sd> > XX 3278 427 31 Received receive VBN 3278 427 32 : : : 3278 427 33 5/26/87 5/26/87 CD 3278 427 34 from from IN 3278 427 35 LC LC NNP 3278 427 36 video video NN 3278 427 37 lab; > XX 3278 427 39 viewing view VBG 3278 427 40 copy; > XX 3278 427 43 < < XX 3278 427 44 sc> > XX 3278 427 46 preservation preservation NN 3278 427 47 , , , 3278 427 48 made make VBN 3278 427 49 from from IN 3278 427 50 ref ref NN 3278 427 51 print print NN 3278 427 52 , , , 3278 427 53 paperwork paperwork NN 3278 427 54 in in IN 3278 427 55 ACQ ACQ NNP 3278 427 56 : : : 3278 427 57 Copyright­­Material Copyright­­Material NNP 3278 427 58 Movement Movement NNP 3278 427 59 Form Form NNP 3278 427 60 file file NN 3278 427 61 , , , 3278 427 62 LWO LWO NNP 3278 427 63 21635; > XX 3278 427 65 < < XX 3278 427 66 sa> > JJ 3278 427 68 Copyright copyright NN 3278 427 69 Collection. > XX 3278 427 71 < < XX 3278 427 72 v541 v541 NNP 3278 427 73 i1= i1= NNP 3278 427 74 ” " '' 3278 427 75 “ " `` 3278 427 76 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 77 ” " '' 3278 427 78 “ " `` 3278 427 79 > > XX 3278 427 80 < < XX 3278 427 81 sd> > XX 3278 427 83 Received receive VBN 3278 427 84 : : : 3278 427 85 12/2/64; > XX 3278 427 88 < < XX 3278 427 89 s3> > XX 3278 427 91 ref ref NN 3278 427 92 print; > NN 3278 427 94 copyright copyright NN 3278 427 95 deposit; > XX 3278 427 97 < < XX 3278 427 98 sa> > JJ 3278 427 100 Copyright copyright NN 3278 427 101 Collection. > XX 3278 427 103 < < XX 3278 427 104 v541 v541 NNP 3278 427 105 i1= i1= NNP 3278 427 106 ” " '' 3278 427 107 “ " `` 3278 427 108 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 109 ” " '' 3278 427 110 “ " `` 3278 427 111 > > XX 3278 427 112 < < XX 3278 427 113 sd> > XX 3278 427 115 Received receive VBD 3278 427 116 : : : 3278 427 117 5/70; > XX 3278 427 120 < < XX 3278 427 121 s3> > XX 3278 427 123 masterpos; > XX 3278 427 125 gift; > XX 3278 427 127 < < XX 3278 427 128 sa> > JJ 3278 427 130 AFI AFI NNP 3278 427 131 Theatre Theatre NNP 3278 427 132 Collection. > XX 3278 427 134 < < XX 3278 427 135 v650 v650 NNP 3278 427 136 i1= i1= NNP 3278 427 137 ” " '' 3278 427 138 “ " `` 3278 427 139 i2=”0”> > XX 3278 427 141 Othello Othello NNP 3278 427 142 ( ( -LRB- 3278 427 143 Fictitious Fictitious NNP 3278 427 144 charac­ charac­ NNP 3278 427 145 ter) > XX 3278 427 147 Drama. > XX 3278 427 149 PuBLIC public JJ 3278 427 150 LIBRARIES library NNS 3278 427 151 AND and CC 3278 427 152 INTERNET INTERNET NNP 3278 427 153 ACCESS ACCESS NNP 3278 427 154 | | NNS 3278 427 155 JAEGER jaeger NN 3278 427 156 , , , 3278 427 157 BERTOT bertot NN 3278 427 158 , , , 3278 427 159 MCCLuRE mcclure UH 3278 427 160 , , , 3278 427 161 AND and CC 3278 427 162 RODRIGuEz rodriguez NN 3278 427 163 25MISINFORMATION 25misinformation LS 3278 427 164 AND and CC 3278 427 165 BIAS bia NNS 3278 427 166 IN in IN 3278 427 167 METADATA METADATA NNP 3278 427 168 PROCESSING PROCESSING NNP 3278 427 169 | | CD 3278 427 170 THORNBuRG THORNBuRG NNS 3278 427 171 AND and CC 3278 427 172 OSkINS OSkINS NNP 3278 427 173 25 25 CD 3278 427 174 < < XX 3278 427 175 v655 v655 VBD 3278 427 176 i1= i1= NNP 3278 427 177 ” " '' 3278 427 178 “ " `` 3278 427 179 i2=”7”> > XX 3278 427 181 Plays. > XX 3278 427 183 < < XX 3278 427 184 s2> > XX 3278 427 186 mim > XX 3278 427 188 < < XX 3278 427 189 v655 v655 VBD 3278 427 190 i1= i1= NNP 3278 427 191 ” " '' 3278 427 192 “ " `` 3278 427 193 i2=”7”> > XX 3278 427 195 Features. > XX 3278 427 197 < < XX 3278 427 198 s2> > XX 3278 427 200 mim > XX 3278 427 202 < < XX 3278 427 203 v700 v700 NNP 3278 427 204 i1=”1 i1=”1 FW 3278 427 205 ” " '' 3278 427 206 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 207 ” " '' 3278 427 208 “ " `` 3278 427 209 > > XX 3278 427 210 < < XX 3278 427 211 sa> > FW 3278 427 213 Welles Welles NNP 3278 427 214 , , , 3278 427 215 Orson, > XX 3278 427 217 < < XX 3278 427 218 sd>1915­1915­ > XX 3278 427 220 direction, > XX 3278 427 222 < < XX 3278 427 223 se> > XX 3278 427 225 production, > NN 3278 427 227 writing, > XX 3278 427 230 < < XX 3278 427 231 se> > XX 3278 427 233 cast. > XX 3278 427 235 < < XX 3278 427 236 v700 v700 NNP 3278 427 237 i1=”1 i1=”1 FW 3278 427 238 ” " '' 3278 427 239 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 240 ” " '' 3278 427 241 “ " `` 3278 427 242 > > XX 3278 427 243 < < XX 3278 427 244 sa> > JJ 3278 427 246 Cloutier Cloutier NNP 3278 427 247 , , , 3278 427 248 Suzanne,1927­1927­ > XX 3278 427 251 cast. > XX 3278 427 254 < < XX 3278 427 255 v700 v700 FW 3278 427 256 i1=”1 i1=”1 FW 3278 427 257 ” " '' 3278 427 258 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 259 ” " '' 3278 427 260 “ " `` 3278 427 261 > > XX 3278 427 262 < < XX 3278 427 263 sa> > XX 3278 427 265 Mac Mac NNP 3278 427 266 LiammoÌ LiammoÌ NNP 3278 427 267 ir ir NNP 3278 427 268 , , , 3278 427 269 MicheaÌ MicheaÌ NNP 3278 427 270 l, > XX 3278 427 272 < < XX 3278 427 273 sd>1899­1978,1899­1978, > XX 3278 427 275 cast. > XX 3278 427 278 < < XX 3278 427 279 v700 v700 FW 3278 427 280 i1=”1 i1=”1 FW 3278 427 281 ” " '' 3278 427 282 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 283 ” " '' 3278 427 284 “ " `` 3278 427 285 > > XX 3278 427 286 < < XX 3278 427 287 sa> > NN 3278 427 289 Coote Coote NNP 3278 427 290 , , , 3278 427 291 Robert,1909­1982,1909­1982, > XX 3278 427 294 cast. > XX 3278 427 297 < < XX 3278 427 298 v710 v710 NNP 3278 427 299 i1=”2 i1=”2 NNP 3278 427 300 ” " '' 3278 427 301 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 302 ” " '' 3278 427 303 “ " `` 3278 427 304 > > XX 3278 427 305 < < XX 3278 427 306 sa> > JJ 3278 427 308 Copyright Copyright NNP 3278 427 309 Collection Collection NNP 3278 427 310 ( ( -LRB- 3278 427 311 Library Library NNP 3278 427 312 of of IN 3278 427 313 Congress) > XX 3278 427 315 DLC > XX 3278 427 318 < < XX 3278 427 319 v710 v710 NNP 3278 427 320 i1=”2 i1=”2 NNP 3278 427 321 ” " '' 3278 427 322 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 323 ” " '' 3278 427 324 “ " `` 3278 427 325 > > XX 3278 427 326 < < XX 3278 427 327 sa> > JJ 3278 427 329 AFI AFI NNP 3278 427 330 Theatre Theatre NNP 3278 427 331 Collection Collection NNP 3278 427 332 ( ( -LRB- 3278 427 333 Library Library NNP 3278 427 334 of of IN 3278 427 335 Congress) > XX 3278 427 337 DLC > XX 3278 427 340 < < XX 3278 427 341 v740 v740 NNP 3278 427 342 i1=”0 i1=”0 NNP 3278 427 343 ” " '' 3278 427 344 i2= i2= FW 3278 427 345 ” " '' 3278 427 346 “ " `` 3278 427 347 > > XX 3278 427 348 < < XX 3278 427 349 sa> > NFP 3278 427 351 Othello. > XX 3278 427 354 < < XX 3278 427 355 /CDFRec /CDFRec NNP 3278 427 356 > > NFP 3278 427 357 Appendix Appendix NNP 3278 427 358 B. B. NNP 3278 428 1 The the DT 3278 428 2 Perils Perils NNP 3278 428 3 of of IN 3278 428 4 Judging Judging NNP 3278 428 5 Near Near NNP 3278 428 6 Matches Matches NNP 3278 428 7 A. a. NN 3278 429 1 Challenges challenge NNS 3278 429 2 of of IN 3278 429 3 Handling handle VBG 3278 429 4 Ellipses Ellipses NNPS 3278 429 5 in in IN 3278 429 6 Titles Titles NNPS 3278 429 7 Thought think VBN 3278 429 8 to to TO 3278 429 9 be be VB 3278 429 10 Similar Similar NNP 3278 429 11 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 429 12 title title NN 3278 429 13 : : : 3278 429 14 General general JJ 3278 429 15 explanation explanation NN 3278 429 16 of of IN 3278 429 17 tax tax NN 3278 429 18 legislation legislation NN 3278 429 19 enacted enact VBN 3278 429 20 in in IN 3278 429 21 ... ... : 3278 429 22 / / SYM 3278 429 23 prepared prepare VBN 3278 429 24 by by IN 3278 429 25 the the DT 3278 429 26 staff staff NN 3278 429 27 of of IN 3278 429 28 the the DT 3278 429 29 Joint Joint NNP 3278 429 30 Committee Committee NNP 3278 429 31 on on IN 3278 429 32 Taxation Taxation NNP 3278 429 33 Match Match NNP 3278 429 34 : : : 3278 429 35 General general JJ 3278 429 36 explanation explanation NN 3278 429 37 of of IN 3278 429 38 tax tax NN 3278 429 39 legislation legislation NN 3278 429 40 enacted enact VBN 3278 429 41 in in IN 3278 429 42 the the DT 3278 429 43 104th 104th JJ 3278 429 44 Congress Congress NNP 3278 429 45 prepared prepare VBN 3278 429 46 by by IN 3278 429 47 the the DT 3278 429 48 staff staff NN 3278 429 49 of of IN 3278 429 50 the the DT 3278 429 51 Joint Joint NNP 3278 429 52 Committee Committee NNP 3278 429 53 on on IN 3278 429 54 Taxation Taxation NNP 3278 429 55 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 429 56 title title NN 3278 429 57 : : : 3278 429 58 General general JJ 3278 429 59 explanation explanation NN 3278 429 60 of of IN 3278 429 61 tax tax NN 3278 429 62 legislation legislation NN 3278 429 63 enacted enact VBN 3278 429 64 in in IN 3278 429 65 ... ... : 3278 429 66 / / SYM 3278 429 67 prepared prepare VBN 3278 429 68 by by IN 3278 429 69 the the DT 3278 429 70 staff staff NN 3278 429 71 of of IN 3278 429 72 the the DT 3278 429 73 Joint Joint NNP 3278 429 74 Committee Committee NNP 3278 429 75 on on IN 3278 429 76 Taxation Taxation NNP 3278 429 77 Match Match NNP 3278 429 78 : : : 3278 429 79 General general JJ 3278 429 80 explanation explanation NN 3278 429 81 of of IN 3278 429 82 tax tax NN 3278 429 83 legislation legislation NN 3278 429 84 enacted enact VBN 3278 429 85 in in IN 3278 429 86 the the DT 3278 429 87 106th 106th JJ 3278 429 88 Congress Congress NNP 3278 429 89 prepared prepare VBN 3278 429 90 by by IN 3278 429 91 the the DT 3278 429 92 staff staff NN 3278 429 93 of of IN 3278 429 94 the the DT 3278 429 95 Joint Joint NNP 3278 429 96 Committee Committee NNP 3278 429 97 on on IN 3278 429 98 Taxation Taxation NNP 3278 429 99 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 429 100 title title NN 3278 429 101 : : : 3278 429 102 General general JJ 3278 429 103 explanation explanation NN 3278 429 104 of of IN 3278 429 105 tax tax NN 3278 429 106 legislation legislation NN 3278 429 107 enacted enact VBN 3278 429 108 in in IN 3278 429 109 ... ... : 3278 429 110 / / SYM 3278 429 111 prepared prepare VBN 3278 429 112 by by IN 3278 429 113 the the DT 3278 429 114 staff staff NN 3278 429 115 of of IN 3278 429 116 the the DT 3278 429 117 Joint Joint NNP 3278 429 118 Committee Committee NNP 3278 429 119 on on IN 3278 429 120 Taxation Taxation NNP 3278 429 121 Match Match NNP 3278 429 122 : : : 3278 429 123 General general JJ 3278 429 124 explanation explanation NN 3278 429 125 of of IN 3278 429 126 tax tax NN 3278 429 127 legislation legislation NN 3278 429 128 enacted enact VBN 3278 429 129 in in IN 3278 429 130 the the DT 3278 429 131 107th 107th JJ 3278 429 132 Congress Congress NNP 3278 429 133 prepared prepare VBN 3278 429 134 by by IN 3278 429 135 the the DT 3278 429 136 staff staff NN 3278 429 137 of of IN 3278 429 138 the the DT 3278 429 139 Joint Joint NNP 3278 429 140 Committee Committee NNP 3278 429 141 on on IN 3278 429 142 Taxation Taxation NNP 3278 429 143 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 429 144 title title NN 3278 429 145 : : : 3278 429 146 General general JJ 3278 429 147 explanation explanation NN 3278 429 148 of of IN 3278 429 149 tax tax NN 3278 429 150 legislation legislation NN 3278 429 151 enacted enact VBN 3278 429 152 in in IN 3278 429 153 ... ... : 3278 429 154 / / SYM 3278 429 155 prepared prepare VBN 3278 429 156 by by IN 3278 429 157 the the DT 3278 429 158 staff staff NN 3278 429 159 of of IN 3278 429 160 the the DT 3278 429 161 Joint Joint NNP 3278 429 162 Committee Committee NNP 3278 429 163 on on IN 3278 429 164 Taxation Taxation NNP 3278 429 165 Match Match NNP 3278 429 166 : : : 3278 429 167 General general JJ 3278 429 168 explanation explanation NN 3278 429 169 of of IN 3278 429 170 tax tax NN 3278 429 171 legislation legislation NN 3278 429 172 enacted enact VBN 3278 429 173 in in IN 3278 429 174 the the DT 3278 429 175 108th 108th JJ 3278 429 176 Congress Congress NNP 3278 429 177 prepared prepare VBN 3278 429 178 by by IN 3278 429 179 the the DT 3278 429 180 staff staff NN 3278 429 181 of of IN 3278 429 182 the the DT 3278 429 183 Joint Joint NNP 3278 429 184 Committee Committee NNP 3278 429 185 on on IN 3278 429 186 Taxation Taxation NNP 3278 429 187 B. B. NNP 3278 430 1 Partial Partial NNP 3278 430 2 Matches Matches NNPS 3278 430 3 in in IN 3278 430 4 Names Names NNPS 3278 430 5 Which which WDT 3278 430 6 Might may MD 3278 430 7 Represent represent VB 3278 430 8 the the DT 3278 430 9 Same Same NNP 3278 430 10 Publisher Publisher NNP 3278 430 11 Publisher Publisher NNP 3278 430 12 comparison comparison NN 3278 430 13 is be VBZ 3278 430 14 challenging challenge VBG 3278 430 15 in in IN 3278 430 16 an an DT 3278 430 17 environment environment NN 3278 430 18 where where WRB 3278 430 19 organziations organziation NNS 3278 430 20 are be VBP 3278 430 21 regularly regularly RB 3278 430 22 merged merge VBN 3278 430 23 or or CC 3278 430 24 acquired acquire VBN 3278 430 25 by by IN 3278 430 26 other other JJ 3278 430 27 organziations organziation NNS 3278 430 28 . . . 3278 431 1 There there EX 3278 431 2 is be VBZ 3278 431 3 no no DT 3278 431 4 real real JJ 3278 431 5 authority authority NN 3278 431 6 control control NN 3278 431 7 for for IN 3278 431 8 publishers publisher NNS 3278 431 9 that that WDT 3278 431 10 would would MD 3278 431 11 help help VB 3278 431 12 cataloguers cataloguer NNS 3278 431 13 decide decide VB 3278 431 14 on on IN 3278 431 15 a a DT 3278 431 16 preferred preferred JJ 3278 431 17 form form NN 3278 431 18 . . . 3278 432 1 When when WRB 3278 432 2 governmental governmental JJ 3278 432 3 organizations organization NNS 3278 432 4 are be VBP 3278 432 5 added add VBN 3278 432 6 to to IN 3278 432 7 the the DT 3278 432 8 mix mix NN 3278 432 9 , , , 3278 432 10 the the DT 3278 432 11 challenges challenge NNS 3278 432 12 increase increase VBP 3278 432 13 . . . 3278 433 1 Below below IN 3278 433 2 are be VBP 3278 433 3 some some DT 3278 433 4 examples example NNS 3278 433 5 of of IN 3278 433 6 non­match­ non­match­ NNP 3278 433 7 ing ing NNP 3278 433 8 text text NN 3278 433 9 of of IN 3278 433 10 publisher publisher NN 3278 433 11 names name NNS 3278 433 12 in in IN 3278 433 13 records record NNS 3278 433 14 , , , 3278 433 15 which which WDT 3278 433 16 might may MD 3278 433 17 or or CC 3278 433 18 might may MD 3278 433 19 not not RB 3278 433 20 considered considered VB 3278 433 21 the the DT 3278 433 22 same same JJ 3278 433 23 by by IN 3278 433 24 a a DT 3278 433 25 human human JJ 3278 433 26 expert expert NN 3278 433 27 . . . 3278 434 1 ( ( -LRB- 3278 434 2 The the DT 3278 434 3 publisher publisher NN 3278 434 4 names name NNS 3278 434 5 have have VBP 3278 434 6 been be VBN 3278 434 7 normalized normalize VBN 3278 434 8 . . . 3278 434 9 ) ) -RRB- 3278 435 1 26 26 CD 3278 435 2 INFORMATION information NN 3278 435 3 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3278 435 4 AND and CC 3278 435 5 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 435 6 | | NNP 3278 435 7 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 435 8 200726 200726 CD 3278 435 9 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3278 435 10 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3278 435 11 AND and CC 3278 435 12 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3278 435 13 | | NNP 3278 435 14 JuNE JuNE NNP 3278 435 15 2007 2007 CD 3278 435 16 1 1 CD 3278 435 17 . . . 3278 436 1 Publisher publisher NN 3278 436 2 name name NN 3278 436 3 may may MD 3278 436 4 be be VB 3278 436 5 partially partially RB 3278 436 6 or or CC 3278 436 7 differently differently RB 3278 436 8 recorded record VBN 3278 436 9 in in IN 3278 436 10 two two CD 3278 436 11 records record NNS 3278 436 12 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 436 13 publisher publisher NN 3278 436 14 : : : 3278 436 15 konzeptstudien konzeptstudien NNP 3278 436 16 kantonale kantonale NNP 3278 436 17 planungsgruppe planungsgruppe NNP 3278 436 18 Match Match NNP 3278 436 19 : : : 3278 436 20 kantonale kantonale NNP 3278 436 21 planungsgruppe planungsgruppe NNP 3278 436 22 konzeptstudien konzeptstudien NNP 3278 436 23 ( ( -LRB- 3278 436 24 word word NN 3278 436 25 order order NN 3278 436 26 different different JJ 3278 436 27 ) ) -RRB- 3278 436 28 Incoming incoming JJ 3278 436 29 publisher publisher NN 3278 436 30 : : : 3278 436 31 institut institut NNP 3278 436 32 francais francais NNP 3278 436 33 proche proche NNP 3278 436 34 orient orient NNP 3278 436 35 Match Match NNP 3278 436 36 : : : 3278 436 37 institut institut NNP 3278 436 38 francais francais NNP 3278 436 39 darcheologie darcheologie NNP 3278 436 40 proche proche NNP 3278 436 41 orient orient NNP 3278 436 42 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 436 43 publisher publisher NN 3278 436 44 : : : 3278 436 45 u u NNP 3278 436 46 s s NNP 3278 436 47 dept dept NNP 3278 436 48 of of IN 3278 436 49 commerce commerce NNP 3278 436 50 national national NNP 3278 436 51 oceanic oceanic NNP 3278 436 52 and and CC 3278 436 53 atmospheric atmospheric NNP 3278 436 54 administration administration NNP 3278 436 55 national national NNP 3278 436 56 environ­ environ­ NNP 3278 436 57 mental mental JJ 3278 436 58 satellite satellite NN 3278 436 59 data datum NNS 3278 436 60 and and CC 3278 436 61 information information NN 3278 436 62 service service NN 3278 436 63 Match match NN 3278 436 64 : : : 3278 436 65 national national JJ 3278 436 66 oceanic oceanic NNP 3278 436 67 and and CC 3278 436 68 atmospheric atmospheric JJ 3278 436 69 administration administration NN 3278 436 70 2 2 CD 3278 436 71 . . . 3278 437 1 Publisher publisher NN 3278 437 2 name name NN 3278 437 3 may may MD 3278 437 4 have have VB 3278 437 5 changed change VBN 3278 437 6 due due IN 3278 437 7 to to IN 3278 437 8 acquisition acquisition NN 3278 437 9 by by IN 3278 437 10 another another DT 3278 437 11 organization organization NN 3278 437 12 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 437 13 publisher publisher NN 3278 437 14 : : : 3278 437 15 pearson pearson NNP 3278 437 16 prentice prentice NNP 3278 437 17 hall hall NNP 3278 437 18 Match Match NNP 3278 437 19 : : : 3278 437 20 prentice prentice NN 3278 437 21 hall hall NN 3278 437 22 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 437 23 publisher publisher NN 3278 437 24 : : : 3278 437 25 uxl uxl NNP 3278 437 26 Match Match NNP 3278 437 27 : : : 3278 437 28 uxl uxl NNP 3278 437 29 thomson thomson NNP 3278 437 30 gale gale NN 3278 437 31 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 437 32 publisher publisher NN 3278 437 33 : : : 3278 437 34 thomson thomson NNP 3278 437 35 arco arco NNP 3278 437 36 Match Match NNP 3278 437 37 : : : 3278 437 38 arco arco NNP 3278 437 39 thomson thomson NNP 3278 437 40 learning learn VBG 3278 437 41 3 3 CD 3278 437 42 . . . 3278 438 1 One one CD 3278 438 2 record record NN 3278 438 3 may may MD 3278 438 4 show show VB 3278 438 5 “ " `` 3278 438 6 publisher publisher NN 3278 438 7 ” " '' 3278 438 8 which which WDT 3278 438 9 is be VBZ 3278 438 10 actually actually RB 3278 438 11 government government NN 3278 438 12 distributing distribute VBG 3278 438 13 agency agency NN 3278 438 14 or or CC 3278 438 15 clearinghouse clearinghouse NN 3278 438 16 such such JJ 3278 438 17 as as IN 3278 438 18 the the DT 3278 438 19 U.S. U.S. NNP 3278 438 20 Government Government NNP 3278 438 21 Printing Printing NNP 3278 438 22 Office Office NNP 3278 438 23 or or CC 3278 438 24 National National NNP 3278 438 25 Technical Technical NNP 3278 438 26 Information Information NNP 3278 438 27 Service Service NNP 3278 438 28 ( ( -LRB- 3278 438 29 NTIS NTIS NNP 3278 438 30 ) ) -RRB- 3278 438 31 , , , 3278 438 32 while while IN 3278 438 33 the the DT 3278 438 34 candidate candidate NN 3278 438 35 match match NN 3278 438 36 shows show VBZ 3278 438 37 the the DT 3278 438 38 actual actual JJ 3278 438 39 government government NN 3278 438 40 agency agency NN 3278 438 41 . . . 3278 439 1 These these DT 3278 439 2 can can MD 3278 439 3 be be VB 3278 439 4 almost almost RB 3278 439 5 impossible impossible JJ 3278 439 6 to to TO 3278 439 7 evaluate evaluate VB 3278 439 8 . . . 3278 440 1 Incoming incoming JJ 3278 440 2 publisher publisher NN 3278 440 3 : : : 3278 440 4 u u NNP 3278 440 5 s s NNP 3278 440 6 congressional congressional JJ 3278 440 7 service service NN 3278 440 8 Match match NN 3278 440 9 : : : 3278 440 10 supt supt NNP 3278 440 11 g g NN 3278 440 12 p p NN 3278 440 13 o o XX 3278 440 14 ( ( -LRB- 3278 440 15 Here here RB 3278 440 16 the the DT 3278 440 17 distributor distributor NN 3278 440 18 is be VBZ 3278 440 19 the the DT 3278 440 20 Government Government NNP 3278 440 21 Printing Printing NNP 3278 440 22 Office Office NNP 3278 440 23 , , , 3278 440 24 listed list VBN 3278 440 25 as as IN 3278 440 26 the the DT 3278 440 27 publisher publisher NN 3278 440 28 ) ) -RRB- 3278 440 29 Incoming incoming JJ 3278 440 30 publisher publisher NN 3278 440 31 : : : 3278 440 32 u u NNP 3278 440 33 s s NNP 3278 440 34 dept dept NNP 3278 440 35 of of IN 3278 440 36 commerce commerce NNP 3278 440 37 national national NNP 3278 440 38 oceanic oceanic NNP 3278 440 39 and and CC 3278 440 40 atmospheric atmospheric NNP 3278 440 41 administration administration NNP 3278 440 42 national national NNP 3278 440 43 environmental environmental NNP 3278 440 44 satellite satellite NNP 3278 440 45 data datum NNS 3278 440 46 and and CC 3278 440 47 information information NN 3278 440 48 service service NN 3278 440 49 Match match NN 3278 440 50 : : : 3278 440 51 national national JJ 3278 440 52 oceanic oceanic NNP 3278 440 53 and and CC 3278 440 54 atmospheric atmospheric JJ 3278 440 55 administration administration NN 3278 440 56 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 440 57 publisher publisher NN 3278 440 58 : : : 3278 440 59 u u NNP 3278 440 60 s s NNP 3278 440 61 gpo gpo NN 3278 440 62 Match match NN 3278 440 63 : : : 3278 440 64 u u NNP 3278 440 65 s s NNP 3278 440 66 fish fish NN 3278 440 67 and and CC 3278 440 68 wildlife wildlife NN 3278 440 69 service service NNP 3278 440 70 4 4 CD 3278 440 71 . . . 3278 441 1 The the DT 3278 441 2 publisher publisher NN 3278 441 3 in in IN 3278 441 4 a a DT 3278 441 5 record record NN 3278 441 6 may may MD 3278 441 7 start start VB 3278 441 8 with with IN 3278 441 9 or or CC 3278 441 10 end end VB 3278 441 11 with with IN 3278 441 12 the the DT 3278 441 13 publisher publisher NN 3278 441 14 in in IN 3278 441 15 the the DT 3278 441 16 second second JJ 3278 441 17 record record NN 3278 441 18 . . . 3278 442 1 Should Should MD 3278 442 2 it -PRON- PRP 3278 442 3 be be VB 3278 442 4 called call VBN 3278 442 5 a a DT 3278 442 6 match match NN 3278 442 7 ? ? . 3278 443 1 Good good JJ 3278 443 2 : : : 3278 443 3 Incoming incoming JJ 3278 443 4 publisher publisher NN 3278 443 5 trotta trotta NN 3278 443 6 Match match NN 3278 443 7 : : : 3278 443 8 editorial editorial JJ 3278 443 9 trotta trotta NN 3278 443 10 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 443 11 publisher publisher NN 3278 443 12 wiley wiley NNP 3278 443 13 Match match NN 3278 443 14 : : : 3278 443 15 john john NNP 3278 443 16 wiley wiley NNP 3278 443 17 Questionable Questionable NNP 3278 443 18 ? ? . 3278 444 1 Incoming incoming JJ 3278 444 2 publisher publisher NN 3278 444 3 prentice prentice NN 3278 444 4 hall hall NN 3278 444 5 Match Match NNP 3278 444 6 : : : 3278 444 7 prentice prentice NNP 3278 444 8 hall hall NNP 3278 444 9 regents regent VBZ 3278 444 10 canada canada NNP 3278 444 11 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 444 12 publisher publisher NN 3278 444 13 geuthner geuthner NN 3278 444 14 Match match NN 3278 444 15 : : : 3278 444 16 orientaliste orientaliste NN 3278 444 17 geuthner geuthner NN 3278 444 18 Incoming Incoming NNP 3278 444 19 publisher publisher NN 3278 444 20 oxford oxford IN 3278 444 21 Match Match NNP 3278 444 22 : : : 3278 444 23 distributed distribute VBN 3278 444 24 royal royal JJ 3278 444 25 affairs affair NNS 3278 444 26 oxford oxford IN 3278 444 27 Incoming incoming JJ 3278 444 28 publisher publisher NN 3278 444 29 : : : 3278 444 30 pan pan NNP 3278 444 31 union union NNP 3278 444 32 general general NNP 3278 444 33 secretariat secretariat NNP 3278 444 34 organization organization NN 3278 444 35 states state VBZ 3278 444 36 Match Match NNP 3278 444 37 : : : 3278 444 38 social social JJ 3278 444 39 science science NN 3278 444 40 section section NN 3278 444 41 cultural cultural NNP 3278 444 42 affairs affairs NNPS 3278 444 43 pan pan NNP 3278 444 44 union union NNP