id sid tid token lemma pos 3242 1 1 EDitoRiaL EDitoRiaL NNP 3242 1 2 | | NNP 3242 1 3 tRuitt tRuitt NNP 3242 1 4 3 3 CD 3242 1 5 Marc Marc NNP 3242 1 6 TruittEditorial TruittEditorial NNP 3242 1 7 I -PRON- PRP 3242 1 8 doubt doubt VBP 3242 1 9 that that IN 3242 1 10 many many JJ 3242 1 11 of of IN 3242 1 12 the the DT 3242 1 13 Blog Blog NNP 3242 1 14 People People NNS 3242 1 15 are be VBP 3242 1 16 in in IN 3242 1 17 the the DT 3242 1 18 habit habit NN 3242 1 19 of of IN 3242 1 20 sustained sustained JJ 3242 1 21 reading reading NN 3242 1 22 of of IN 3242 1 23 complex complex JJ 3242 1 24 texts text NNS 3242 1 25 . . . 3242 2 1 — — : 3242 2 2 Michael Michael NNP 3242 2 3 Gorman Gorman NNP 3242 2 4 , , , 3242 2 5 2005 2005 CD 3242 2 6 S s NN 3242 2 7 o o NN 3242 2 8 , , , 3242 2 9 three three CD 3242 2 10 plus plus JJ 3242 2 11 years year NNS 3242 2 12 after after IN 3242 2 13 the the DT 3242 2 14 fact fact NN 3242 2 15 , , , 3242 2 16 why why WRB 3242 2 17 am be VBP 3242 2 18 I -PRON- PRP 3242 2 19 opening open VBG 3242 2 20 with with IN 3242 2 21 Michael Michael NNP 3242 2 22 Gorman Gorman NNP 3242 2 23 ’s ’s POS 3242 2 24 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 3242 2 25 characteriza- characteriza- JJ 3242 2 26 tion tion NN 3242 2 27 of of IN 3242 2 28 those those DT 3242 2 29 he -PRON- PRP 3242 2 30 labeled label VBD 3242 2 31 “ " `` 3242 2 32 Blog Blog NNP 3242 2 33 People People NNP 3242 2 34 ” " '' 3242 2 35 ? ? . 3242 3 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 3 2 have have VBP 3242 3 3 no no DT 3242 3 4 interest interest NN 3242 3 5 in in IN 3242 3 6 reopening reopen VBG 3242 3 7 this this DT 3242 3 8 debate debate NN 3242 3 9 , , , 3242 3 10 honestly honestly RB 3242 3 11 ! ! . 3242 4 1 But but CC 3242 4 2 the the DT 3242 4 3 problem problem NN 3242 4 4 with with IN 3242 4 5 generalizations generalization NNS 3242 4 6 , , , 3242 4 7 however however RB 3242 4 8 unfair unfair JJ 3242 4 9 , , , 3242 4 10 is be VBZ 3242 4 11 that that IN 3242 4 12 at at IN 3242 4 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 4 14 heart heart NN 3242 4 15 there there EX 3242 4 16 is be VBZ 3242 4 17 just just RB 3242 4 18 enough enough JJ 3242 4 19 substance substance NN 3242 4 20 to to TO 3242 4 21 make make VB 3242 4 22 them -PRON- PRP 3242 4 23 “ " `` 3242 4 24 stick”—to stick”—to NN 3242 4 25 give give VB 3242 4 26 them -PRON- PRP 3242 4 27 a a DT 3242 4 28 grain grain NN 3242 4 29 or or CC 3242 4 30 two two CD 3242 4 31 of of IN 3242 4 32 credibility credibility NN 3242 4 33 . . . 3242 5 1 Gorman Gorman NNP 3242 5 2 ’s ’s POS 3242 5 3 words word NNS 3242 5 4 struck strike VBD 3242 5 5 a a DT 3242 5 6 chord chord NN 3242 5 7 in in IN 3242 5 8 me -PRON- PRP 3242 5 9 that that WDT 3242 5 10 existed exist VBD 3242 5 11 before before IN 3242 5 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 3242 5 13 charge charge NN 3242 5 14 and and CC 3242 5 15 has have VBZ 3242 5 16 continued continue VBN 3242 5 17 to to TO 3242 5 18 exist exist VB 3242 5 19 to to IN 3242 5 20 this this DT 3242 5 21 day day NN 3242 5 22 . . . 3242 6 1 The the DT 3242 6 2 substance substance NN 3242 6 3 in in IN 3242 6 4 Gorman Gorman NNP 3242 6 5 ’s ’s POS 3242 6 6 words word NNS 3242 6 7 had have VBD 3242 6 8 little little JJ 3242 6 9 to to TO 3242 6 10 do do VB 3242 6 11 with with IN 3242 6 12 these these DT 3242 6 13 “ " `` 3242 6 14 Blog Blog NNP 3242 6 15 People People NNS 3242 6 16 ” " '' 3242 6 17 as as IN 3242 6 18 such such JJ 3242 6 19 ; ; : 3242 6 20 rather rather RB 3242 6 21 , , , 3242 6 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 3242 6 23 interest interest NN 3242 6 24 was be VBD 3242 6 25 piqued pique VBN 3242 6 26 by by IN 3242 6 27 the the DT 3242 6 28 implications implication NNS 3242 6 29 in in IN 3242 6 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 3242 6 31 remark remark NN 3242 6 32 about about IN 3242 6 33 how how WRB 3242 6 34 we -PRON- PRP 3242 6 35 all all DT 3242 6 36 deal deal VBP 3242 6 37 with with IN 3242 6 38 “ " `` 3242 6 39 complex complex JJ 3242 6 40 texts text NNS 3242 6 41 ” " '' 3242 6 42 and and CC 3242 6 43 the the DT 3242 6 44 “ " `` 3242 6 45 sustained sustained JJ 3242 6 46 reading reading NN 3242 6 47 ” " '' 3242 6 48 of of IN 3242 6 49 the the DT 3242 6 50 same same JJ 3242 6 51 . . . 3242 7 1 In in IN 3242 7 2 a a DT 3242 7 3 time time NN 3242 7 4 of of IN 3242 7 5 wide wide JJ 3242 7 6 availability availability NN 3242 7 7 of of IN 3242 7 8 full full JJ 3242 7 9 - - HYPH 3242 7 10 text text NN 3242 7 11 electronic electronic JJ 3242 7 12 articles article NNS 3242 7 13 , , , 3242 7 14 it -PRON- PRP 3242 7 15 has have VBZ 3242 7 16 become become VBN 3242 7 17 so so RB 3242 7 18 easy easy JJ 3242 7 19 and and CC 3242 7 20 tempting tempting JJ 3242 7 21 to to TO 3242 7 22 cherry cherry NN 3242 7 23 pick pick VB 3242 7 24 the the DT 3242 7 25 odd odd JJ 3242 7 26 phrase phrase NN 3242 7 27 here here RB 3242 7 28 or or CC 3242 7 29 there there RB 3242 7 30 , , , 3242 7 31 without without IN 3242 7 32 study study NN 3242 7 33 of of IN 3242 7 34 the the DT 3242 7 35 work work NN 3242 7 36 as as IN 3242 7 37 a a DT 3242 7 38 whole whole NN 3242 7 39 . . . 3242 8 1 How how WRB 3242 8 2 has have VBZ 3242 8 3 scholarship scholarship NN 3242 8 4 especially especially RB 3242 8 5 been be VBN 3242 8 6 changed change VBN 3242 8 7 by by IN 3242 8 8 the the DT 3242 8 9 ease ease NN 3242 8 10 with with IN 3242 8 11 which which WDT 3242 8 12 we -PRON- PRP 3242 8 13 can can MD 3242 8 14 reduce reduce VB 3242 8 15 works work NNS 3242 8 16 to to IN 3242 8 17 snippets snippet NNS 3242 8 18 with- with- NN 3242 8 19 out out RP 3242 8 20 having have VBG 3242 8 21 considered consider VBN 3242 8 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 8 23 overall overall JJ 3242 8 24 context context NN 3242 8 25 ? ? . 3242 9 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 9 2 ’m be VBP 3242 9 3 not not RB 3242 9 4 arguing argue VBG 3242 9 5 that that IN 3242 9 6 scholarly scholarly JJ 3242 9 7 research research NN 3242 9 8 and and CC 3242 9 9 writing writing NN 3242 9 10 has have VBZ 3242 9 11 n’t not RB 3242 9 12 always always RB 3242 9 13 been be VBN 3242 9 14 at at IN 3242 9 15 least least JJS 3242 9 16 in in IN 3242 9 17 part part NN 3242 9 18 about about IN 3242 9 19 finding find VBG 3242 9 20 the the DT 3242 9 21 perfect perfect JJ 3242 9 22 juicy juicy JJ 3242 9 23 quotation quotation NN 3242 9 24 around around IN 3242 9 25 which which WDT 3242 9 26 we -PRON- PRP 3242 9 27 then then RB 3242 9 28 weave weave VBP 3242 9 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 9 30 own own JJ 3242 9 31 these these DT 3242 9 32 s s NNS 3242 9 33 . . . 3242 10 1 Many many JJ 3242 10 2 of of IN 3242 10 3 us -PRON- PRP 3242 10 4 well well RB 3242 10 5 recall recall VBP 3242 10 6 the the DT 3242 10 7 boxes box NNS 3242 10 8 of of IN 3242 10 9 3x5 3x5 NNP 3242 10 10 ” " '' 3242 10 11 citation citation NN 3242 10 12 and and CC 3242 10 13 5x8 5x8 CD 3242 10 14 ” " '' 3242 10 15 quotation quotation NN 3242 10 16 files file NNS 3242 10 17 that that WDT 3242 10 18 we -PRON- PRP 3242 10 19 or or CC 3242 10 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 10 21 patrons patron NNS 3242 10 22 laboriously laboriously RB 3242 10 23 assembled assemble VBN 3242 10 24 through through IN 3242 10 25 weeks week NNS 3242 10 26 , , , 3242 10 27 months month NNS 3242 10 28 , , , 3242 10 29 and and CC 3242 10 30 years year NNS 3242 10 31 of of IN 3242 10 32 detailed detailed JJ 3242 10 33 research research NN 3242 10 34 . . . 3242 11 1 But but CC 3242 11 2 if if IN 3242 11 3 the the DT 3242 11 4 style style NN 3242 11 5 of of IN 3242 11 6 compil- compil- NN 3242 11 7 ing e VBG 3242 11 8 these these DT 3242 11 9 files file NNS 3242 11 10 that that WDT 3242 11 11 I -PRON- PRP 3242 11 12 witnessed witness VBD 3242 11 13 ( ( -LRB- 3242 11 14 and and CC 3242 11 15 indeed indeed RB 3242 11 16 did do VBD 3242 11 17 ) ) -RRB- 3242 11 18 is be VBZ 3242 11 19 any any DT 3242 11 20 guide guide NN 3242 11 21 , , , 3242 11 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 11 23 existence existence NN 3242 11 24 was be VBD 3242 11 25 the the DT 3242 11 26 product product NN 3242 11 27 of of IN 3242 11 28 precisely precisely RB 3242 11 29 that that IN 3242 11 30 “ " `` 3242 11 31 sustained sustained JJ 3242 11 32 reading reading NN 3242 11 33 of of IN 3242 11 34 complex complex JJ 3242 11 35 texts text NNS 3242 11 36 ” " '' 3242 11 37 of of IN 3242 11 38 which which WDT 3242 11 39 Gorman Gorman NNP 3242 11 40 spoke speak VBD 3242 11 41 . . . 3242 12 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 3242 12 2 vague vague JJ 3242 12 3 , , , 3242 12 4 nagging nagging JJ 3242 12 5 sense sense NN 3242 12 6 is be VBZ 3242 12 7 that that DT 3242 12 8 what what WP 3242 12 9 is be VBZ 3242 12 10 changing change VBG 3242 12 11 is be VBZ 3242 12 12 this this DT 3242 12 13 style style NN 3242 12 14 of of IN 3242 12 15 approaching approach VBG 3242 12 16 whole whole JJ 3242 12 17 texts text NNS 3242 12 18 . . . 3242 13 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 13 2 wondered wonder VBD 3242 13 3 then then RB 3242 13 4 about about IN 3242 13 5 how how WRB 3242 13 6 much much JJ 3242 13 7 scholarly scholarly JJ 3242 13 8 research research NN 3242 13 9 today today NN 3242 13 10 is be VBZ 3242 13 11 driven drive VBN 3242 13 12 by by IN 3242 13 13 keyword keyword NNP 3242 13 14 searches search NNS 3242 13 15 of of IN 3242 13 16 digitized digitize VBN 3242 13 17 texts text NNS 3242 13 18 that that WDT 3242 13 19 then then RB 3242 13 20 essentially essentially RB 3242 13 21 produce produce VBP 3242 13 22 “ " `` 3242 13 23 virtual virtual JJ 3242 13 24 quotation quotation NN 3242 13 25 files file NNS 3242 13 26 ” " '' 3242 13 27 without without IN 3242 13 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 13 29 having have VBG 3242 13 30 had have VBD 3242 13 31 to to TO 3242 13 32 struggle struggle VB 3242 13 33 with with IN 3242 13 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 13 35 context context NN 3242 13 36 in in IN 3242 13 37 the the DT 3242 13 38 whole whole NN 3242 13 39 of of IN 3242 13 40 the the DT 3242 13 41 original original JJ 3242 13 42 source source NN 3242 13 43 text text NN 3242 13 44 ? ? . 3242 14 1 Fast fast VB 3242 14 2 forward forward RB 3242 14 3 three three CD 3242 14 4 years year NNS 3242 14 5 . . . 3242 15 1 Lately lately RB 3242 15 2 , , , 3242 15 3 several several JJ 3242 15 4 articles article NNS 3242 15 5 touch- touch- VBP 3242 15 6 ing e VBG 3242 15 7 on on IN 3242 15 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 15 9 changing change VBG 3242 15 10 ways way NNS 3242 15 11 of of IN 3242 15 12 interacting interact VBG 3242 15 13 with with IN 3242 15 14 resources resource NNS 3242 15 15 have have VBP 3242 15 16 appeared appear VBN 3242 15 17 in in IN 3242 15 18 both both DT 3242 15 19 scholarly scholarly JJ 3242 15 20 and and CC 3242 15 21 popular popular JJ 3242 15 22 venues venue NNS 3242 15 23 , , , 3242 15 24 and and CC 3242 15 25 these these DT 3242 15 26 have have VBP 3242 15 27 served serve VBN 3242 15 28 to to TO 3242 15 29 underline underline VB 3242 15 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 3242 15 31 sense sense NN 3242 15 32 that that IN 3242 15 33 we -PRON- PRP 3242 15 34 are be VBP 3242 15 35 miss- miss- JJ 3242 15 36 ing e VBG 3242 15 37 something something NN 3242 15 38 because because IN 3242 15 39 of of IN 3242 15 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 15 41 growing grow VBG 3242 15 42 lack lack NN 3242 15 43 of of IN 3242 15 44 engage- engage- NN 3242 15 45 ment ment JJ 3242 15 46 with with IN 3242 15 47 whole whole JJ 3242 15 48 texts text NNS 3242 15 49 . . . 3242 16 1 Writing write VBG 3242 16 2 in in IN 3242 16 3 the the DT 3242 16 4 July July NNP 3242 16 5 / / SYM 3242 16 6 August August NNP 3242 16 7 issue issue NN 3242 16 8 of of IN 3242 16 9 The the DT 3242 16 10 Atlantic Atlantic NNP 3242 16 11 Monthly Monthly NNP 3242 16 12 , , , 3242 16 13 Nicholas Nicholas NNP 3242 16 14 Carr Carr NNP 3242 16 15 asks ask VBZ 3242 16 16 “ " `` 3242 16 17 Is be VBZ 3242 16 18 Google Google NNP 3242 16 19 Making make VBG 3242 16 20 Us -PRON- PRP 3242 16 21 Stupid stupid JJ 3242 16 22 ? ? . 3242 16 23 ” " '' 3242 16 24 Drawing draw VBG 3242 16 25 an an DT 3242 16 26 analogy analogy NN 3242 16 27 to to IN 3242 16 28 the the DT 3242 16 29 scene scene NN 3242 16 30 in in IN 3242 16 31 the the DT 3242 16 32 film film NN 3242 16 33 2001 2001 CD 3242 16 34 : : : 3242 16 35 A a DT 3242 16 36 Space Space NNP 3242 16 37 Odyssey Odyssey NNP 3242 16 38 , , , 3242 16 39 in in IN 3242 16 40 which which WDT 3242 16 41 astronaut astronaut NN 3242 16 42 Dave Dave NNP 3242 16 43 Bowman Bowman NNP 3242 16 44 disables disable VBZ 3242 16 45 supercomputer supercomputer NN 3242 16 46 HAL HAL NNP 3242 16 47 ’s ’s , 3242 16 48 memory memory NN 3242 16 49 circuits circuit NNS 3242 16 50 , , , 3242 16 51 Carr Carr NNP 3242 16 52 says say VBZ 3242 16 53 I -PRON- PRP 3242 16 54 can can MD 3242 16 55 feel feel VB 3242 16 56 it -PRON- PRP 3242 16 57 , , , 3242 16 58 too too RB 3242 16 59 . . . 3242 17 1 Over over IN 3242 17 2 the the DT 3242 17 3 past past JJ 3242 17 4 few few JJ 3242 17 5 years year NNS 3242 17 6 I -PRON- PRP 3242 17 7 ’ve have VB 3242 17 8 had have VBD 3242 17 9 an an DT 3242 17 10 uncomfortable uncomfortable JJ 3242 17 11 sense sense NN 3242 17 12 that that IN 3242 17 13 someone someone NN 3242 17 14 , , , 3242 17 15 or or CC 3242 17 16 something something NN 3242 17 17 , , , 3242 17 18 has have VBZ 3242 17 19 been be VBN 3242 17 20 tinkering tinker VBG 3242 17 21 with with IN 3242 17 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 3242 17 23 brain brain NN 3242 17 24 , , , 3242 17 25 remapping remappe VBG 3242 17 26 the the DT 3242 17 27 neural neural JJ 3242 17 28 circuitry circuitry NN 3242 17 29 , , , 3242 17 30 reprogramming reprogramme VBG 3242 17 31 the the DT 3242 17 32 memory memory NN 3242 17 33 . . . 3242 18 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 3242 18 2 mind mind NN 3242 18 3 is be VBZ 3242 18 4 n’t not RB 3242 18 5 going go VBG 3242 18 6 — — : 3242 18 7 so so RB 3242 18 8 far far RB 3242 18 9 as as IN 3242 18 10 I -PRON- PRP 3242 18 11 can can MD 3242 18 12 tell tell VB 3242 18 13 — — : 3242 18 14 but but CC 3242 18 15 it -PRON- PRP 3242 18 16 ’s ’ VBZ 3242 18 17 changing change VBG 3242 18 18 . . . 3242 19 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 19 2 ’m be VBP 3242 19 3 not not RB 3242 19 4 thinking think VBG 3242 19 5 the the DT 3242 19 6 way way NN 3242 19 7 I -PRON- PRP 3242 19 8 used use VBD 3242 19 9 to to TO 3242 19 10 think think VB 3242 19 11 . . . 3242 20 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 20 2 can can MD 3242 20 3 feel feel VB 3242 20 4 it -PRON- PRP 3242 20 5 most most RBS 3242 20 6 strongly strongly RB 3242 20 7 when when WRB 3242 20 8 I -PRON- PRP 3242 20 9 ’m be VBP 3242 20 10 reading read VBG 3242 20 11 . . . 3242 21 1 Immersing immerse VBG 3242 21 2 myself -PRON- PRP 3242 21 3 in in IN 3242 21 4 a a DT 3242 21 5 book book NN 3242 21 6 or or CC 3242 21 7 a a DT 3242 21 8 lengthy lengthy JJ 3242 21 9 article article NN 3242 21 10 used use VBN 3242 21 11 to to TO 3242 21 12 be be VB 3242 21 13 easy easy JJ 3242 21 14 . . . 3242 22 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 3242 22 2 mind mind NN 3242 22 3 would would MD 3242 22 4 get get VB 3242 22 5 caught catch VBN 3242 22 6 up up RP 3242 22 7 in in IN 3242 22 8 the the DT 3242 22 9 narrative narrative NN 3242 22 10 or or CC 3242 22 11 the the DT 3242 22 12 turns turn NNS 3242 22 13 of of IN 3242 22 14 the the DT 3242 22 15 argument argument NN 3242 22 16 , , , 3242 22 17 and and CC 3242 22 18 I -PRON- PRP 3242 22 19 ’d ’d MD 3242 22 20 spend spend VB 3242 22 21 hours hour NNS 3242 22 22 strolling stroll VBG 3242 22 23 through through IN 3242 22 24 long long JJ 3242 22 25 stretches stretch NNS 3242 22 26 of of IN 3242 22 27 prose prose NN 3242 22 28 . . . 3242 23 1 That that DT 3242 23 2 ’s ’ VBZ 3242 23 3 rarely rarely RB 3242 23 4 the the DT 3242 23 5 case case NN 3242 23 6 anymore anymore RB 3242 23 7 . . . 3242 24 1 Now now RB 3242 24 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 3242 24 3 concen- concen- NN 3242 24 4 tration tration NN 3242 24 5 often often RB 3242 24 6 starts start VBZ 3242 24 7 to to TO 3242 24 8 drift drift VB 3242 24 9 after after IN 3242 24 10 two two CD 3242 24 11 or or CC 3242 24 12 three three CD 3242 24 13 pages page NNS 3242 24 14 . . . 3242 25 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 25 2 get get VBP 3242 25 3 fidgety fidgety JJ 3242 25 4 , , , 3242 25 5 lose lose VB 3242 25 6 the the DT 3242 25 7 thread thread NN 3242 25 8 , , , 3242 25 9 begin begin VB 3242 25 10 looking look VBG 3242 25 11 for for IN 3242 25 12 something something NN 3242 25 13 else else RB 3242 25 14 to to TO 3242 25 15 do do VB 3242 25 16 . . . 3242 26 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 26 2 feel feel VBP 3242 26 3 as as IN 3242 26 4 if if IN 3242 26 5 I -PRON- PRP 3242 26 6 ’m be VBP 3242 26 7 always always RB 3242 26 8 dragging drag VBG 3242 26 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 3242 26 10 wayward wayward JJ 3242 26 11 brain brain NN 3242 26 12 back back RB 3242 26 13 to to IN 3242 26 14 the the DT 3242 26 15 text text NN 3242 26 16 . . . 3242 27 1 The the DT 3242 27 2 deep deep JJ 3242 27 3 reading reading NN 3242 27 4 that that WDT 3242 27 5 used use VBD 3242 27 6 to to TO 3242 27 7 come come VB 3242 27 8 naturally naturally RB 3242 27 9 has have VBZ 3242 27 10 become become VBN 3242 27 11 a a DT 3242 27 12 struggle.1 struggle.1 NNP 3242 27 13 Carr Carr NNP 3242 27 14 goes go VBZ 3242 27 15 on on RP 3242 27 16 to to TO 3242 27 17 explain explain VB 3242 27 18 that that IN 3242 27 19 “ " `` 3242 27 20 what what WP 3242 27 21 the the DT 3242 27 22 Net net NN 3242 27 23 seems seem VBZ 3242 27 24 to to TO 3242 27 25 be be VB 3242 27 26 doing do VBG 3242 27 27 is be VBZ 3242 27 28 chipping chip VBG 3242 27 29 away away RP 3242 27 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 3242 27 31 capacity capacity NN 3242 27 32 for for IN 3242 27 33 concentra- concentra- NNP 3242 27 34 tion tion NN 3242 27 35 and and CC 3242 27 36 contemplation contemplation NN 3242 27 37 . . . 3242 28 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 3242 28 2 mind mind NN 3242 28 3 now now RB 3242 28 4 expects expect VBZ 3242 28 5 to to TO 3242 28 6 take take VB 3242 28 7 in in IN 3242 28 8 information information NN 3242 28 9 the the DT 3242 28 10 way way NN 3242 28 11 the the DT 3242 28 12 Net net NN 3242 28 13 distributes distribute VBZ 3242 28 14 it -PRON- PRP 3242 28 15 : : : 3242 28 16 in in IN 3242 28 17 a a DT 3242 28 18 swiftly swiftly RB 3242 28 19 moving move VBG 3242 28 20 stream stream NN 3242 28 21 of of IN 3242 28 22 particles particle NNS 3242 28 23 . . . 3242 29 1 Once once IN 3242 29 2 I -PRON- PRP 3242 29 3 was be VBD 3242 29 4 a a DT 3242 29 5 scuba scuba NN 3242 29 6 diver diver NN 3242 29 7 in in IN 3242 29 8 the the DT 3242 29 9 sea sea NN 3242 29 10 of of IN 3242 29 11 words word NNS 3242 29 12 . . . 3242 30 1 Now now RB 3242 30 2 I -PRON- PRP 3242 30 3 zip zip VBP 3242 30 4 along along IN 3242 30 5 the the DT 3242 30 6 surface surface NN 3242 30 7 like like IN 3242 30 8 a a DT 3242 30 9 guy guy NN 3242 30 10 on on IN 3242 30 11 a a DT 3242 30 12 Jet Jet NNP 3242 30 13 Ski Ski NNP 3242 30 14 . . . 3242 30 15 ”2 ”2 NNP 3242 30 16 Carr Carr NNP 3242 30 17 ’s ’s POS 3242 30 18 nagging nagging JJ 3242 30 19 fear fear NN 3242 30 20 found find VBD 3242 30 21 similar similar JJ 3242 30 22 expression expression NN 3242 30 23 among among IN 3242 30 24 some some DT 3242 30 25 tech tech NN 3242 30 26 - - HYPH 3242 30 27 savvy savvy JJ 3242 30 28 participants participant NNS 3242 30 29 of of IN 3242 30 30 library library JJ 3242 30 31 online online JJ 3242 30 32 forums forum NNS 3242 30 33 ; ; : 3242 30 34 one one CD 3242 30 35 of of IN 3242 30 36 the the DT 3242 30 37 more more RBR 3242 30 38 interesting interesting JJ 3242 30 39 comments comment NNS 3242 30 40 appeared appear VBD 3242 30 41 on on IN 3242 30 42 the the DT 3242 30 43 Web4Lib Web4Lib NNP 3242 30 44 electronic electronic JJ 3242 30 45 discussion discussion NN 3242 30 46 list list NN 3242 30 47 . . . 3242 31 1 In in IN 3242 31 2 a a DT 3242 31 3 discussion discussion NN 3242 31 4 of of IN 3242 31 5 the the DT 3242 31 6 article article NN 3242 31 7 , , , 3242 31 8 Tim Tim NNP 3242 31 9 Spalding Spalding NNP 3242 31 10 of of IN 3242 31 11 LibraryThing LibraryThing NNP 3242 31 12 observed observe VBD 3242 31 13 that that IN 3242 31 14 he -PRON- PRP 3242 31 15 himself -PRON- PRP 3242 31 16 had have VBD 3242 31 17 experienced experience VBN 3242 31 18 what what WP 3242 31 19 he -PRON- PRP 3242 31 20 dubbed dub VBD 3242 31 21 “ " `` 3242 31 22 the the DT 3242 31 23 Google Google NNP 3242 31 24 effect effect NN 3242 31 25 ” " '' 3242 31 26 and and CC 3242 31 27 noted note VBD 3242 31 28 Something something NN 3242 31 29 is be VBZ 3242 31 30 lost lose VBN 3242 31 31 . . . 3242 32 1 . . . 3242 33 1 . . . 3242 34 1 . . . 3242 35 1 Human human JJ 3242 35 2 culture culture NN 3242 35 3 often often RB 3242 35 4 advances advance VBZ 3242 35 5 by by IN 3242 35 6 externalizing externalize VBG 3242 35 7 pieces piece NNS 3242 35 8 of of IN 3242 35 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 35 10 mental mental JJ 3242 35 11 life life NN 3242 35 12 — — : 3242 35 13 writing write VBG 3242 35 14 externalizes externalize NNS 3242 35 15 memory memory NN 3242 35 16 , , , 3242 35 17 calculators calculator NNS 3242 35 18 externalize externalize VBP 3242 35 19 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 3242 35 20 , , , 3242 35 21 maps map NNS 3242 35 22 , , , 3242 35 23 and and CC 3242 35 24 now now RB 3242 35 25 GPS gps ADD 3242 35 26 , , , 3242 35 27 externalize externalize VB 3242 35 28 way way NN 3242 35 29 - - HYPH 3242 35 30 finding finding NN 3242 35 31 , , , 3242 35 32 etc etc FW 3242 35 33 . . . 3242 36 1 Each each DT 3242 36 2 shift shift NN 3242 36 3 changes change VBZ 3242 36 4 the the DT 3242 36 5 culture culture NN 3242 36 6 . . . 3242 37 1 And and CC 3242 37 2 each each DT 3242 37 3 shift shift NN 3242 37 4 comes come VBZ 3242 37 5 with with IN 3242 37 6 a a DT 3242 37 7 cost cost NN 3242 37 8 . . . 3242 38 1 Nobody nobody NN 3242 38 2 memorizes memorize VBZ 3242 38 3 texts text NNS 3242 38 4 anymore anymore RB 3242 38 5 , , , 3242 38 6 nobody nobody NN 3242 38 7 knows know VBZ 3242 38 8 the the DT 3242 38 9 times time NNS 3242 38 10 tables table NNS 3242 38 11 past past IN 3242 38 12 ten ten CD 3242 38 13 or or CC 3242 38 14 twelve twelve CD 3242 38 15 and and CC 3242 38 16 nobody nobody NN 3242 38 17 can can MD 3242 38 18 find find VB 3242 38 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 38 20 way way NN 3242 38 21 home home RB 3242 38 22 from from IN 3242 38 23 the the DT 3242 38 24 stars star NNS 3242 38 25 and and CC 3242 38 26 the the DT 3242 38 27 side side NN 3242 38 28 of of IN 3242 38 29 the the DT 3242 38 30 tree tree NN 3242 38 31 the the DT 3242 38 32 moss moss NN 3242 38 33 grows grow VBZ 3242 38 34 on.3 on.3 VBP 3242 38 35 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 3242 38 36 , , , 3242 38 37 another another DT 3242 38 38 article article NN 3242 38 39 appeared appear VBD 3242 38 40 on on IN 3242 38 41 a a DT 3242 38 42 closely closely RB 3242 38 43 related relate VBN 3242 38 44 topic topic NN 3242 38 45 , , , 3242 38 46 this this DT 3242 38 47 time time NN 3242 38 48 in in IN 3242 38 49 the the DT 3242 38 50 journal journal NN 3242 38 51 Science Science NNP 3242 38 52 . . . 3242 39 1 James James NNP 3242 39 2 A. A. NNP 3242 39 3 Evans Evans NNP 3242 39 4 observed observe VBD 3242 39 5 that that IN 3242 39 6 , , , 3242 39 7 because because IN 3242 39 8 “ " `` 3242 39 9 scientists scientist NNS 3242 39 10 and and CC 3242 39 11 scholars scholar NNS 3242 39 12 tend tend VBP 3242 39 13 to to TO 3242 39 14 search search VB 3242 39 15 electronically electronically RB 3242 39 16 and and CC 3242 39 17 follow follow VB 3242 39 18 hyperlinks hyperlink NNS 3242 39 19 rather rather RB 3242 39 20 than than IN 3242 39 21 browse browse NN 3242 39 22 or or CC 3242 39 23 peruse peruse VB 3242 39 24 , , , 3242 39 25 ” " '' 3242 39 26 the the DT 3242 39 27 easy easy JJ 3242 39 28 availability availability NN 3242 39 29 of of IN 3242 39 30 electronic electronic JJ 3242 39 31 resources resource NNS 3242 39 32 was be VBD 3242 39 33 resulting result VBG 3242 39 34 in in IN 3242 39 35 an an DT 3242 39 36 “ " `` 3242 39 37 ironic ironic JJ 3242 39 38 change change NN 3242 39 39 ” " '' 3242 39 40 for for IN 3242 39 41 scientific scientific JJ 3242 39 42 marc marc NN 3242 39 43 truitt truitt NNP 3242 39 44 ( ( -LRB- 3242 39 45 marc.truitt@ualberta.ca marc.truitt@ualberta.ca NNP 3242 39 46 ) ) -RRB- 3242 39 47 is be VBZ 3242 39 48 Associate Associate NNP 3242 39 49 Director Director NNP 3242 39 50 , , , 3242 39 51 Bibliographic Bibliographic NNP 3242 39 52 and and CC 3242 39 53 Information Information NNP 3242 39 54 Technology Technology NNP 3242 39 55 Services Services NNP 3242 39 56 , , , 3242 39 57 University University NNP 3242 39 58 of of IN 3242 39 59 Alberta Alberta NNP 3242 39 60 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3242 39 61 , , , 3242 39 62 Edmonton Edmonton NNP 3242 39 63 , , , 3242 39 64 Alberta Alberta NNP 3242 39 65 , , , 3242 39 66 Canada Canada NNP 3242 39 67 , , , 3242 39 68 and and CC 3242 39 69 Editor Editor NNP 3242 39 70 of of IN 3242 39 71 ITAL ITAL NNP 3242 39 72 . . . 3242 40 1 4 4 CD 3242 40 2 inFoRmation information NN 3242 40 3 tEcHnoLoGY technology NN 3242 40 4 anD and CC 3242 40 5 LiBRaRiEs LiBRaRiEs NNP 3242 40 6 | | NNP 3242 40 7 sEptEmBER september CD 3242 40 8 2008 2008 CD 3242 40 9 scholarship scholarship NN 3242 40 10 , , , 3242 40 11 in in IN 3242 40 12 that that DT 3242 40 13 as as IN 3242 40 14 more more JJR 3242 40 15 journal journal NN 3242 40 16 issues issue NNS 3242 40 17 came come VBD 3242 40 18 online online RB 3242 40 19 , , , 3242 40 20 the the DT 3242 40 21 articles article NNS 3242 40 22 referenced reference VBD 3242 40 23 tended tend VBD 3242 40 24 to to TO 3242 40 25 be be VB 3242 40 26 more more RBR 3242 40 27 recent recent JJ 3242 40 28 , , , 3242 40 29 fewer few JJR 3242 40 30 journals journal NNS 3242 40 31 and and CC 3242 40 32 articles article NNS 3242 40 33 were be VBD 3242 40 34 cited cite VBN 3242 40 35 , , , 3242 40 36 and and CC 3242 40 37 more more JJR 3242 40 38 of of IN 3242 40 39 those those DT 3242 40 40 citations citation NNS 3242 40 41 were be VBD 3242 40 42 to to IN 3242 40 43 fewer few JJR 3242 40 44 journals journal NNS 3242 40 45 and and CC 3242 40 46 articles article NNS 3242 40 47 . . . 3242 41 1 The the DT 3242 41 2 forced forced JJ 3242 41 3 browsing browsing NN 3242 41 4 of of IN 3242 41 5 print print NN 3242 41 6 archives archive NNS 3242 41 7 may may MD 3242 41 8 have have VB 3242 41 9 stretched stretch VBN 3242 41 10 scientists scientist NNS 3242 41 11 and and CC 3242 41 12 scholars scholar NNS 3242 41 13 to to TO 3242 41 14 anchor anchor VB 3242 41 15 findings finding NNS 3242 41 16 deeply deeply RB 3242 41 17 into into IN 3242 41 18 past past JJ 3242 41 19 and and CC 3242 41 20 present present JJ 3242 41 21 scholarship scholarship NN 3242 41 22 . . . 3242 42 1 Searching search VBG 3242 42 2 online online RB 3242 42 3 is be VBZ 3242 42 4 more more RBR 3242 42 5 efficient efficient JJ 3242 42 6 and and CC 3242 42 7 following follow VBG 3242 42 8 hyper- hyper- JJ 3242 42 9 links link NNS 3242 42 10 quickly quickly RB 3242 42 11 puts put VBZ 3242 42 12 researchers researcher NNS 3242 42 13 in in IN 3242 42 14 touch touch NN 3242 42 15 with with IN 3242 42 16 prevailing prevail VBG 3242 42 17 opinion opinion NN 3242 42 18 , , , 3242 42 19 but but CC 3242 42 20 this this DT 3242 42 21 may may MD 3242 42 22 accelerate accelerate VB 3242 42 23 consensus consensus NN 3242 42 24 and and CC 3242 42 25 narrow narrow VB 3242 42 26 the the DT 3242 42 27 range range NN 3242 42 28 of of IN 3242 42 29 findings finding NNS 3242 42 30 and and CC 3242 42 31 ideas idea NNS 3242 42 32 built build VBD 3242 42 33 upon.4 upon.4 CD 3242 42 34 Evans Evans NNP 3242 42 35 ’s ’s POS 3242 42 36 research research NN 3242 42 37 highlights highlight VBZ 3242 42 38 an an DT 3242 42 39 additional additional JJ 3242 42 40 irony irony NN 3242 42 41 : : : 3242 42 42 an an DT 3242 42 43 unintended unintended JJ 3242 42 44 benefit benefit NN 3242 42 45 to to IN 3242 42 46 the the DT 3242 42 47 scholarly scholarly JJ 3242 42 48 process process NN 3242 42 49 in in IN 3242 42 50 the the DT 3242 42 51 paper- paper- NN 3242 42 52 based base VBN 3242 42 53 world world NN 3242 42 54 was be VBD 3242 42 55 “ " `` 3242 42 56 poor poor JJ 3242 42 57 indexing indexing NN 3242 42 58 , , , 3242 42 59 ” " '' 3242 42 60 since since IN 3242 42 61 it -PRON- PRP 3242 42 62 encouraged encourage VBD 3242 42 63 browsing browse VBG 3242 42 64 through through IN 3242 42 65 less less RBR 3242 42 66 relevant relevant JJ 3242 42 67 , , , 3242 42 68 older old JJR 3242 42 69 , , , 3242 42 70 or or CC 3242 42 71 more more RBR 3242 42 72 marginal marginal JJ 3242 42 73 literature literature NN 3242 42 74 . . . 3242 43 1 This this DT 3242 43 2 browsing browsing NN 3242 43 3 had have VBD 3242 43 4 the the DT 3242 43 5 effect effect NN 3242 43 6 of of IN 3242 43 7 “ " `` 3242 43 8 facilitat[ing facilitat[ing NN 3242 43 9 ] ] -RRB- 3242 43 10 broader broad JJR 3242 43 11 comparisons comparison NNS 3242 43 12 and and CC 3242 43 13 led lead VBN 3242 43 14 researchers researcher NNS 3242 43 15 into into IN 3242 43 16 the the DT 3242 43 17 past past NN 3242 43 18 . . . 3242 44 1 Modern modern JJ 3242 44 2 graduate graduate NN 3242 44 3 education education NN 3242 44 4 parallels parallel NNS 3242 44 5 this this DT 3242 44 6 shift shift NN 3242 44 7 in in IN 3242 44 8 pub- pub- JJ 3242 44 9 lication lication NN 3242 44 10 — — : 3242 44 11 shorter short JJR 3242 44 12 in in IN 3242 44 13 years year NNS 3242 44 14 , , , 3242 44 15 more more RBR 3242 44 16 specialized specialized JJ 3242 44 17 in in IN 3242 44 18 scope scope NN 3242 44 19 , , , 3242 44 20 culminating culminate VBG 3242 44 21 less less RBR 3242 44 22 frequently frequently RB 3242 44 23 in in IN 3242 44 24 a a DT 3242 44 25 true true JJ 3242 44 26 dissertation dissertation NN 3242 44 27 than than IN 3242 44 28 an an DT 3242 44 29 album album NN 3242 44 30 of of IN 3242 44 31 articles article NNS 3242 44 32 . . . 3242 44 33 ”5 ”5 , 3242 44 34 What what WP 3242 44 35 is be VBZ 3242 44 36 one one CD 3242 44 37 to to TO 3242 44 38 make make VB 3242 44 39 of of IN 3242 44 40 all all DT 3242 44 41 of of IN 3242 44 42 this this DT 3242 44 43 ? ? . 3242 45 1 At at IN 3242 45 2 the the DT 3242 45 3 outset outset NN 3242 45 4 , , , 3242 45 5 I -PRON- PRP 3242 45 6 wish wish VBP 3242 45 7 to to TO 3242 45 8 state state VB 3242 45 9 clearly clearly RB 3242 45 10 that that IN 3242 45 11 I -PRON- PRP 3242 45 12 am be VBP 3242 45 13 not not RB 3242 45 14 some some DT 3242 45 15 sort sort NN 3242 45 16 of of IN 3242 45 17 anti anti JJ 3242 45 18 e e JJ 3242 45 19 - - NN 3242 45 20 text text NN 3242 45 21 Luddite Luddite NNP 3242 45 22 . . . 3242 46 1 Electronic electronic JJ 3242 46 2 texts text NNS 3242 46 3 are be VBP 3242 46 4 a a DT 3242 46 5 fact fact NN 3242 46 6 of of IN 3242 46 7 life life NN 3242 46 8 , , , 3242 46 9 and and CC 3242 46 10 are be VBP 3242 46 11 becoming become VBG 3242 46 12 moreso moreso NN 3242 46 13 every every DT 3242 46 14 day day NN 3242 46 15 . . . 3242 47 1 Even even RB 3242 47 2 though though IN 3242 47 3 they -PRON- PRP 3242 47 4 are be VBP 3242 47 5 in in IN 3242 47 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 47 7 infancy infancy NN 3242 47 8 as as IN 3242 47 9 a a DT 3242 47 10 medium medium NN 3242 47 11 , , , 3242 47 12 they -PRON- PRP 3242 47 13 ’ve have VB 3242 47 14 already already RB 3242 47 15 transformed transform VBN 3242 47 16 the the DT 3242 47 17 landscape landscape NN 3242 47 18 of of IN 3242 47 19 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3242 47 20 access access NN 3242 47 21 . . . 3242 48 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 3242 48 2 interest interest NN 3242 48 3 is be VBZ 3242 48 4 not not RB 3242 48 5 with with IN 3242 48 6 the the DT 3242 48 7 tool tool NN 3242 48 8 , , , 3242 48 9 but but CC 3242 48 10 with with IN 3242 48 11 the the DT 3242 48 12 manner manner NN 3242 48 13 in in IN 3242 48 14 which which WDT 3242 48 15 we -PRON- PRP 3242 48 16 are be VBP 3242 48 17 using use VBG 3242 48 18 it -PRON- PRP 3242 48 19 . . . 3242 49 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 49 2 began begin VBD 3242 49 3 by by IN 3242 49 4 suggesting suggest VBG 3242 49 5 that that IN 3242 49 6 I -PRON- PRP 3242 49 7 share share VBP 3242 49 8 with with IN 3242 49 9 Gorman Gorman NNP 3242 49 10 a a DT 3242 49 11 concern concern NN 3242 49 12 about about IN 3242 49 13 how how WRB 3242 49 14 we -PRON- PRP 3242 49 15 increasingly increasingly RB 3242 49 16 engage engage VBP 3242 49 17 with with IN 3242 49 18 “ " `` 3242 49 19 com- com- NN 3242 49 20 plex plex NN 3242 49 21 texts text NNS 3242 49 22 ” " '' 3242 49 23 today today NN 3242 49 24 . . . 3242 50 1 Unlike unlike IN 3242 50 2 him -PRON- PRP 3242 50 3 , , , 3242 50 4 though though RB 3242 50 5 , , , 3242 50 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 3242 50 7 concern concern NN 3242 50 8 is be VBZ 3242 50 9 not not RB 3242 50 10 limited limit VBN 3242 50 11 only only RB 3242 50 12 to to IN 3242 50 13 the the DT 3242 50 14 so so RB 3242 50 15 - - HYPH 3242 50 16 called call VBN 3242 50 17 Blog Blog NNP 3242 50 18 People People NNP 3242 50 19 ( ( -LRB- 3242 50 20 whomever whomever VBP 3242 50 21 they -PRON- PRP 3242 50 22 may may MD 3242 50 23 be be VB 3242 50 24 ) ) -RRB- 3242 50 25 , , , 3242 50 26 but but CC 3242 50 27 indeed indeed RB 3242 50 28 , , , 3242 50 29 it -PRON- PRP 3242 50 30 includes include VBZ 3242 50 31 all all DT 3242 50 32 of of IN 3242 50 33 us -PRON- PRP 3242 50 34 . . . 3242 51 1 With with IN 3242 51 2 the the DT 3242 51 3 explosion explosion NN 3242 51 4 in in IN 3242 51 5 easily easily RB 3242 51 6 accessible accessible JJ 3242 51 7 electronic electronic JJ 3242 51 8 texts text NNS 3242 51 9 , , , 3242 51 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 51 11 ideas idea NNS 3242 51 12 and and CC 3242 51 13 habits habit NNS 3242 51 14 concerning concern VBG 3242 51 15 interaction interaction NN 3242 51 16 with with IN 3242 51 17 these these DT 3242 51 18 texts text NNS 3242 51 19 are be VBP 3242 51 20 changing change VBG 3242 51 21 , , , 3242 51 22 sometimes sometimes RB 3242 51 23 in in IN 3242 51 24 unintended unintended JJ 3242 51 25 ways way NNS 3242 51 26 . . . 3242 52 1 In in IN 3242 52 2 a a DT 3242 52 3 recent recent JJ 3242 52 4 informal informal JJ 3242 52 5 survey survey NN 3242 52 6 I -PRON- PRP 3242 52 7 conducted conduct VBD 3242 52 8 of of IN 3242 52 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 3242 52 10 colleagues colleague NNS 3242 52 11 at at IN 3242 52 12 work work NN 3242 52 13 , , , 3242 52 14 I -PRON- PRP 3242 52 15 asked ask VBD 3242 52 16 , , , 3242 52 17 “ " `` 3242 52 18 Have have VBP 3242 52 19 you -PRON- PRP 3242 52 20 ever ever RB 3242 52 21 read read VBN 3242 52 22 an an DT 3242 52 23 e e NN 3242 52 24 - - NN 3242 52 25 book book NN 3242 52 26 ( ( -LRB- 3242 52 27 not not RB 3242 52 28 just just RB 3242 52 29 a a DT 3242 52 30 journal journal NN 3242 52 31 article article NN 3242 52 32 ) ) -RRB- 3242 52 33 from from IN 3242 52 34 ( ( -LRB- 3242 52 35 virtual virtual JJ 3242 52 36 ) ) -RRB- 3242 52 37 cover cover NN 3242 52 38 to to IN 3242 52 39 ( ( -LRB- 3242 52 40 virtual virtual JJ 3242 52 41 ) ) -RRB- 3242 52 42 cover cover VB 3242 52 43 ? ? . 3242 52 44 ” " '' 3242 52 45 For for IN 3242 52 46 those those DT 3242 52 47 whose whose WP$ 3242 52 48 answer answer NN 3242 52 49 was be VBD 3242 52 50 affirmative affirmative JJ 3242 52 51 , , , 3242 52 52 I -PRON- PRP 3242 52 53 also also RB 3242 52 54 asked ask VBD 3242 52 55 , , , 3242 52 56 “ " `` 3242 52 57 How how WRB 3242 52 58 many many JJ 3242 52 59 such such JJ 3242 52 60 books book NNS 3242 52 61 have have VBP 3242 52 62 you -PRON- PRP 3242 52 63 read read VB 3242 52 64 in in IN 3242 52 65 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 52 66 entirety entirety NN 3242 52 67 ? ? . 3242 52 68 ” " '' 3242 52 69 Out out IN 3242 52 70 of of IN 3242 52 71 twenty twenty CD 3242 52 72 - - HYPH 3242 52 73 odd odd JJ 3242 52 74 responses response NNS 3242 52 75 , , , 3242 52 76 three three CD 3242 52 77 individuals individual NNS 3242 52 78 answered answer VBD 3242 52 79 that that DT 3242 52 80 yes yes UH 3242 52 81 , , , 3242 52 82 they -PRON- PRP 3242 52 83 had have VBD 3242 52 84 had have VBN 3242 52 85 occasion occasion NN 3242 52 86 to to TO 3242 52 87 read read VB 3242 52 88 an an DT 3242 52 89 entire entire JJ 3242 52 90 e e NN 3242 52 91 - - NN 3242 52 92 book book NN 3242 52 93 ( ( -LRB- 3242 52 94 for for IN 3242 52 95 a a DT 3242 52 96 total total NN 3242 52 97 of of IN 3242 52 98 six six CD 3242 52 99 books book NNS 3242 52 100 among among IN 3242 52 101 the the DT 3242 52 102 three three CD 3242 52 103 “ " `` 3242 52 104 yes yes UH 3242 52 105 ” " '' 3242 52 106 respondents respondent NNS 3242 52 107 , , , 3242 52 108 which which WDT 3242 52 109 seemed seem VBD 3242 52 110 surprisingly surprisingly RB 3242 52 111 high high JJ 3242 52 112 to to IN 3242 52 113 me -PRON- PRP 3242 52 114 ) ) -RRB- 3242 52 115 . . . 3242 53 1 Of of IN 3242 53 2 greater great JJR 3242 53 3 interest interest NN 3242 53 4 , , , 3242 53 5 though though RB 3242 53 6 , , , 3242 53 7 were be VBD 3242 53 8 those those DT 3242 53 9 who who WP 3242 53 10 chose choose VBD 3242 53 11 to to TO 3242 53 12 question question VB 3242 53 13 the the DT 3242 53 14 premise premise NN 3242 53 15 of of IN 3242 53 16 the the DT 3242 53 17 survey survey NN 3242 53 18 , , , 3242 53 19 arguing argue VBG 3242 53 20 that that IN 3242 53 21 people people NNS 3242 53 22 do do VBP 3242 53 23 n’t not RB 3242 53 24 “ " `` 3242 53 25 read read VB 3242 53 26 ” " '' 3242 53 27 e e NN 3242 53 28 - - NNS 3242 53 29 books book NNS 3242 53 30 the the DT 3242 53 31 way way NN 3242 53 32 that that WDT 3242 53 33 they -PRON- PRP 3242 53 34 read read VBP 3242 53 35 paper paper NN 3242 53 36 ones one NNS 3242 53 37 . . . 3242 54 1 It -PRON- PRP 3242 54 2 does do VBZ 3242 54 3 make make VB 3242 54 4 one one CD 3242 54 5 wonder wonder NN 3242 54 6 , , , 3242 54 7 then then RB 3242 54 8 , , , 3242 54 9 how how WRB 3242 54 10 Amazon Amazon NNP 3242 54 11 thinks think VBZ 3242 54 12 it -PRON- PRP 3242 54 13 possesses possess VBZ 3242 54 14 a a DT 3242 54 15 viable viable JJ 3242 54 16 business business NN 3242 54 17 model model NN 3242 54 18 in in IN 3242 54 19 the the DT 3242 54 20 Kindle Kindle NNP 3242 54 21 e e NN 3242 54 22 - - HYPH 3242 54 23 book book NN 3242 54 24 reader reader NN 3242 54 25 , , , 3242 54 26 for for IN 3242 54 27 which which WDT 3242 54 28 it -PRON- PRP 3242 54 29 currently currently RB 3242 54 30 lists list VBZ 3242 54 31 an an DT 3242 54 32 astounding astounding JJ 3242 54 33 140,000 140,000 CD 3242 54 34 + + CC 3242 54 35 available available JJ 3242 54 36 e e NN 3242 54 37 - - HYPH 3242 54 38 books book NNS 3242 54 39 . . . 3242 55 1 Clearly clearly RB 3242 55 2 , , , 3242 55 3 some some DT 3242 55 4 e e NNS 3242 55 5 - - HYPH 3242 55 6 books book NNS 3242 55 7 are be VBP 3242 55 8 being be VBG 3242 55 9 read read VBN 3242 55 10 as as IN 3242 55 11 whole whole JJ 3242 55 12 texts text NNS 3242 55 13 , , , 3242 55 14 by by IN 3242 55 15 some some DT 3242 55 16 people people NNS 3242 55 17 , , , 3242 55 18 for for IN 3242 55 19 some some DT 3242 55 20 purposes purpose NNS 3242 55 21 . . . 3242 56 1 But but CC 3242 56 2 I -PRON- PRP 3242 56 3 suspect suspect VBP 3242 56 4 that that DT 3242 56 5 ’s ’s NN 3242 56 6 another another DT 3242 56 7 story.6 story.6 NNP 3242 56 8 Carr Carr NNP 3242 56 9 and and CC 3242 56 10 Evans Evans NNP 3242 56 11 use use VBP 3242 56 12 slightly slightly RB 3242 56 13 differing differ VBG 3242 56 14 imagery imagery NN 3242 56 15 to to TO 3242 56 16 describe describe VB 3242 56 17 a a DT 3242 56 18 similar similar JJ 3242 56 19 phenomenon phenomenon NN 3242 56 20 . . . 3242 57 1 Carr Carr NNP 3242 57 2 closes close VBZ 3242 57 3 with with IN 3242 57 4 a a DT 3242 57 5 refer- refer- JJ 3242 57 6 ence ence NN 3242 57 7 back back RB 3242 57 8 to to IN 3242 57 9 the the DT 3242 57 10 death death NN 3242 57 11 of of IN 3242 57 12 2001 2001 CD 3242 57 13 ’s ’s NN 3242 57 14 HAL HAL NNP 3242 57 15 , , , 3242 57 16 saying say VBG 3242 57 17 , , , 3242 57 18 “ " `` 3242 57 19 As as IN 3242 57 20 we -PRON- PRP 3242 57 21 come come VBP 3242 57 22 to to TO 3242 57 23 rely rely VB 3242 57 24 on on IN 3242 57 25 computers computer NNS 3242 57 26 to to TO 3242 57 27 mediate mediate VB 3242 57 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 57 29 understanding understanding NN 3242 57 30 of of IN 3242 57 31 the the DT 3242 57 32 world world NN 3242 57 33 , , , 3242 57 34 it -PRON- PRP 3242 57 35 is be VBZ 3242 57 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 57 37 own own JJ 3242 57 38 intelligence intelligence NN 3242 57 39 that that WDT 3242 57 40 flattens flatten VBZ 3242 57 41 into into IN 3242 57 42 artificial artificial JJ 3242 57 43 intelligence intelligence NN 3242 57 44 . . . 3242 57 45 ”7 ”7 NNP 3242 57 46 Evans Evans NNP 3242 57 47 , , , 3242 57 48 on on IN 3242 57 49 the the DT 3242 57 50 other other JJ 3242 57 51 hand hand NN 3242 57 52 , , , 3242 57 53 com- com- NN 3242 57 54 pares pare VBZ 3242 57 55 contemporary contemporary JJ 3242 57 56 scientific scientific JJ 3242 57 57 researchers researcher NNS 3242 57 58 to to IN 3242 57 59 Newton Newton NNP 3242 57 60 and and CC 3242 57 61 Darwin Darwin NNP 3242 57 62 , , , 3242 57 63 each each DT 3242 57 64 of of IN 3242 57 65 whom whom WP 3242 57 66 produced produce VBD 3242 57 67 works work NNS 3242 57 68 that that IN 3242 57 69 “ " `` 3242 57 70 not not RB 3242 57 71 only only RB 3242 57 72 were be VBD 3242 57 73 engaged engage VBN 3242 57 74 in in IN 3242 57 75 current current JJ 3242 57 76 debates debate NNS 3242 57 77 , , , 3242 57 78 but but CC 3242 57 79 wove wove VB 3242 57 80 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 57 81 proposi- proposi- JJ 3242 57 82 tions tion NNS 3242 57 83 into into IN 3242 57 84 conversation conversation NN 3242 57 85 with with IN 3242 57 86 astronomers astronomer NNS 3242 57 87 , , , 3242 57 88 geometers geometer NNS 3242 57 89 , , , 3242 57 90 and and CC 3242 57 91 naturalists naturalist NNS 3242 57 92 from from IN 3242 57 93 centuries century NNS 3242 57 94 past past JJ 3242 57 95 . . . 3242 57 96 ” " '' 3242 57 97 Twenty twenty CD 3242 57 98 - - HYPH 3242 57 99 first first JJ 3242 57 100 - - HYPH 3242 57 101 century century NN 3242 57 102 scientists scientist NNS 3242 57 103 and and CC 3242 57 104 scholars scholar NNS 3242 57 105 , , , 3242 57 106 by by IN 3242 57 107 contrast contrast NN 3242 57 108 , , , 3242 57 109 are be VBP 3242 57 110 able able JJ 3242 57 111 because because IN 3242 57 112 of of IN 3242 57 113 readily readily RB 3242 57 114 available available JJ 3242 57 115 electronic electronic JJ 3242 57 116 resources resource NNS 3242 57 117 “ " `` 3242 57 118 to to TO 3242 57 119 frame frame NN 3242 57 120 and and CC 3242 57 121 pub- pub- NN 3242 57 122 lish lish VB 3242 57 123 their -PRON- PRP$ 3242 57 124 arguments argument NNS 3242 57 125 more more RBR 3242 57 126 efficiently efficiently RB 3242 57 127 , , , 3242 57 128 [ [ -LRB- 3242 57 129 but but CC 3242 57 130 ] ] -RRB- 3242 57 131 they -PRON- PRP 3242 57 132 weave weave VBP 3242 57 133 them -PRON- PRP 3242 57 134 into into IN 3242 57 135 a a DT 3242 57 136 more more RBR 3242 57 137 focused focused JJ 3242 57 138 — — : 3242 57 139 and and CC 3242 57 140 more more RBR 3242 57 141 narrow narrow JJ 3242 57 142 — — : 3242 57 143 past past JJ 3242 57 144 and and CC 3242 57 145 present present JJ 3242 57 146 . . . 3242 57 147 ” " '' 3242 57 148 8 8 CD 3242 57 149 Perhaps perhaps RB 3242 57 150 the the DT 3242 57 151 most most RBS 3242 57 152 succinct succinct JJ 3242 57 153 statement statement NN 3242 57 154 , , , 3242 57 155 though though RB 3242 57 156 , , , 3242 57 157 comes come VBZ 3242 57 158 from from IN 3242 57 159 LibraryThing LibraryThing NNP 3242 57 160 ’s ’s POS 3242 57 161 Tim Tim NNP 3242 57 162 Spalding Spalding NNP 3242 57 163 , , , 3242 57 164 who who WP 3242 57 165 summa- summa- VBD 3242 57 166 rized rize VBD 3242 57 167 the the DT 3242 57 168 problem problem NN 3242 57 169 thusly thusly RB 3242 57 170 : : : 3242 57 171 “ " `` 3242 57 172 We -PRON- PRP 3242 57 173 advance advance VBP 3242 57 174 by by IN 3242 57 175 becoming become VBG 3242 57 176 dumber dumb JJR 3242 57 177 . . . 3242 57 178 ”9 ”9 VB 3242 57 179 An an DT 3242 57 180 ITAL ITAL NNP 3242 57 181 research research NN 3242 57 182 and and CC 3242 57 183 publishing publishing NN 3242 57 184 opportunity opportunity NN 3242 57 185 for for IN 3242 57 186 an an DT 3242 57 187 inquisitive inquisitive JJ 3242 57 188 and and CC 3242 57 189 enterprising enterprising JJ 3242 57 190 scholar scholar NN 3242 57 191 , , , 3242 57 192 perhaps perhaps RB 3242 57 193 ? ? . 3242 58 1 I -PRON- PRP 3242 58 2 ’d ’d , 3242 58 3 wel- wel- RB 3242 58 4 come come VB 3242 58 5 the the DT 3242 58 6 manuscript manuscript NN 3242 58 7 ! ! . 3242 59 1 Shameless Shameless NNP 3242 59 2 Plugs Plugs NNP 3242 59 3 Department Department NNP 3242 59 4 . . . 3242 60 1 By by IN 3242 60 2 the the DT 3242 60 3 time time NN 3242 60 4 you -PRON- PRP 3242 60 5 read read VBP 3242 60 6 this this DT 3242 60 7 , , , 3242 60 8 we -PRON- PRP 3242 60 9 at at IN 3242 60 10 ITAL ITAL NNP 3242 60 11 will will MD 3242 60 12 have have VB 3242 60 13 launched launch VBN 3242 60 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 60 15 new new JJ 3242 60 16 blog blog NN 3242 60 17 , , , 3242 60 18 ITALica ITALica NNP 3242 60 19 ( ( -LRB- 3242 60 20 http://ital-ica.blogspot.com http://ital-ica.blogspot.com NNP 3242 60 21 ) ) -RRB- 3242 60 22 . . . 3242 61 1 ITALica ITALica NNP 3242 61 2 addresses address VBZ 3242 61 3 a a DT 3242 61 4 need need NN 3242 61 5 we -PRON- PRP 3242 61 6 on on IN 3242 61 7 the the DT 3242 61 8 ITAL ITAL NNP 3242 61 9 editorial editorial NN 3242 61 10 board board NN 3242 61 11 have have VBP 3242 61 12 long long RB 3242 61 13 sensed sense VBN 3242 61 14 ; ; : 3242 61 15 that that RB 3242 61 16 is is RB 3242 61 17 , , , 3242 61 18 an an DT 3242 61 19 area area NN 3242 61 20 for for IN 3242 61 21 “ " `` 3242 61 22 letters letter NNS 3242 61 23 to to IN 3242 61 24 the the DT 3242 61 25 editor editor NN 3242 61 26 , , , 3242 61 27 ” " '' 3242 61 28 updates update VBZ 3242 61 29 to to IN 3242 61 30 articles article NNS 3242 61 31 , , , 3242 61 32 supplementary supplementary JJ 3242 61 33 materials material NNS 3242 61 34 we -PRON- PRP 3242 61 35 ca can MD 3242 61 36 n’t not RB 3242 61 37 work work VB 3242 61 38 into into IN 3242 61 39 the the DT 3242 61 40 jour- jour- NN 3242 61 41 nal nal NNP 3242 61 42 — — : 3242 61 43 you -PRON- PRP 3242 61 44 name name VBP 3242 61 45 it -PRON- PRP 3242 61 46 . . . 3242 62 1 One one CD 3242 62 2 of of IN 3242 62 3 the the DT 3242 62 4 most most RBS 3242 62 5 important important JJ 3242 62 6 features feature NNS 3242 62 7 of of IN 3242 62 8 ITALica ITALica NNP 3242 62 9 will will MD 3242 62 10 be be VB 3242 62 11 a a DT 3242 62 12 forum forum NN 3242 62 13 for for IN 3242 62 14 readers reader NNS 3242 62 15 ’ ’ POS 3242 62 16 conversations conversation NNS 3242 62 17 with with IN 3242 62 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 62 19 authors author NNS 3242 62 20 : : : 3242 62 21 We -PRON- PRP 3242 62 22 ’ll will MD 3242 62 23 ask ask VB 3242 62 24 authors author NNS 3242 62 25 to to IN 3242 62 26 host host VB 3242 62 27 and and CC 3242 62 28 monitor monitor VB 3242 62 29 dis- dis- IN 3242 62 30 cussion cussion NN 3242 62 31 for for IN 3242 62 32 a a DT 3242 62 33 period period NN 3242 62 34 of of IN 3242 62 35 time time NN 3242 62 36 after after IN 3242 62 37 publication publication NN 3242 62 38 so so IN 3242 62 39 that that IN 3242 62 40 you -PRON- PRP 3242 62 41 ’ll will MD 3242 62 42 then then RB 3242 62 43 have have VB 3242 62 44 a a DT 3242 62 45 chance chance NN 3242 62 46 to to TO 3242 62 47 interact interact VB 3242 62 48 with with IN 3242 62 49 them -PRON- PRP 3242 62 50 . . . 3242 63 1 ITALica ITALica NNP 3242 63 2 is be VBZ 3242 63 3 currently currently RB 3242 63 4 a a DT 3242 63 5 pilot pilot NN 3242 63 6 project project NN 3242 63 7 . . . 3242 64 1 For for IN 3242 64 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 64 3 first first JJ 3242 64 4 issue issue NN 3242 64 5 we -PRON- PRP 3242 64 6 will will MD 3242 64 7 have have VB 3242 64 8 begun begin VBN 3242 64 9 with with IN 3242 64 10 a a DT 3242 64 11 discussion discussion NN 3242 64 12 hosted host VBN 3242 64 13 by by IN 3242 64 14 Jennifer Jennifer NNP 3242 64 15 Bowen Bowen NNP 3242 64 16 , , , 3242 64 17 whose whose WP$ 3242 64 18 article article NN 3242 64 19 “ " `` 3242 64 20 Metadata Metadata NNP 3242 64 21 to to TO 3242 64 22 Support support VB 3242 64 23 Next Next NNP 3242 64 24 - - HYPH 3242 64 25 Generation Generation NNP 3242 64 26 Library Library NNP 3242 64 27 Resource Resource NNP 3242 64 28 Discovery Discovery NNP 3242 64 29 : : : 3242 64 30 Lessons lesson NNS 3242 64 31 from from IN 3242 64 32 the the DT 3242 64 33 eXtensible eXtensible NNP 3242 64 34 Catalog Catalog NNP 3242 64 35 , , , 3242 64 36 Phase Phase NNP 3242 64 37 I -PRON- PRP 3242 64 38 ” " '' 3242 64 39 was be VBD 3242 64 40 published publish VBN 3242 64 41 in in IN 3242 64 42 the the DT 3242 64 43 June June NNP 3242 64 44 2008 2008 CD 3242 64 45 issue issue NN 3242 64 46 of of IN 3242 64 47 ITAL ITAL NNP 3242 64 48 . . . 3242 65 1 For for IN 3242 65 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 65 3 second second JJ 3242 65 4 ITALica italica NN 3242 65 5 , , , 3242 65 6 we -PRON- PRP 3242 65 7 plan plan VBP 3242 65 8 to to TO 3242 65 9 expand expand VB 3242 65 10 coverage coverage NN 3242 65 11 and and CC 3242 65 12 discussion discussion NN 3242 65 13 to to TO 3242 65 14 include include VB 3242 65 15 all all DT 3242 65 16 articles article NNS 3242 65 17 and and CC 3242 65 18 other other JJ 3242 65 19 features feature NNS 3242 65 20 in in IN 3242 65 21 the the DT 3242 65 22 September September NNP 3242 65 23 issue issue NN 3242 65 24 you -PRON- PRP 3242 65 25 now now RB 3242 65 26 have have VBP 3242 65 27 in in IN 3242 65 28 hand hand NN 3242 65 29 . . . 3242 66 1 ITALica ITALica NNP 3242 66 2 is be VBZ 3242 66 3 sure sure JJ 3242 66 4 to to TO 3242 66 5 become become VB 3242 66 6 a a DT 3242 66 7 stimulat- stimulat- NN 3242 66 8 ing ing NN 3242 66 9 supplement supplement NN 3242 66 10 to to IN 3242 66 11 and and CC 3242 66 12 forum forum NN 3242 66 13 for for IN 3242 66 14 topics topic NNS 3242 66 15 originating originate VBG 3242 66 16 in in IN 3242 66 17 ITAL ITAL NNP 3242 66 18 . . . 3242 67 1 We -PRON- PRP 3242 67 2 look look VBP 3242 67 3 forward forward RB 3242 67 4 to to IN 3242 67 5 seeing see VBG 3242 67 6 you -PRON- PRP 3242 67 7 there there RB 3242 67 8 ! ! . 3242 68 1 References reference NNS 3242 68 2 and and CC 3242 68 3 Notes Notes NNPS 3242 68 4 Extract Extract NNP 3242 68 5 . . . 3242 69 1 Michael Michael NNP 3242 69 2 Gorman Gorman NNP 3242 69 3 , , , 3242 69 4 “ " `` 3242 69 5 Revenge revenge NN 3242 69 6 of of IN 3242 69 7 the the DT 3242 69 8 Blog Blog NNP 3242 69 9 People People NNS 3242 69 10 ! ! . 3242 69 11 ” " '' 3242 69 12 Library Library NNP 3242 69 13 Journal Journal NNP 3242 69 14 ( ( -LRB- 3242 69 15 Feb. February NNP 3242 69 16 15 15 CD 3242 69 17 , , , 3242 69 18 2005 2005 CD 3242 69 19 ) ) -RRB- 3242 69 20 www.libraryjournal.com/article/ www.libraryjournal.com/article/ NNP 3242 69 21 CA502009.html CA502009.html NNP 3242 69 22 ( ( -LRB- 3242 69 23 accessed access VBN 3242 69 24 July July NNP 3242 69 25 21 21 CD 3242 69 26 , , , 3242 69 27 2008 2008 CD 3242 69 28 ) ) -RRB- 3242 69 29 . . . 3242 70 1 1 1 LS 3242 70 2 . . . 3242 71 1 Nicholas Nicholas NNP 3242 71 2 Carr Carr NNP 3242 71 3 , , , 3242 71 4 “ " `` 3242 71 5 Is be VBZ 3242 71 6 Google Google NNP 3242 71 7 Making make VBG 3242 71 8 Us -PRON- PRP 3242 71 9 Stupid stupid JJ 3242 71 10 ? ? . 3242 71 11 ” " '' 3242 71 12 The the DT 3242 71 13 Atlantic Atlantic NNP 3242 71 14 Monthly Monthly NNP 3242 71 15 301 301 CD 3242 71 16 ( ( -LRB- 3242 71 17 July July NNP 3242 71 18 / / SYM 3242 71 19 Aug Aug NNP 3242 71 20 . . . 3242 72 1 2008 2008 LS 3242 72 2 ) ) -RRB- 3242 72 3 www.theatlantic.com/ www.theatlantic.com/ NNP 3242 72 4 doc/200807 doc/200807 CD 3242 72 5 / / SYM 3242 72 6 google google NNP 3242 72 7 ( ( -LRB- 3242 72 8 accessed access VBN 3242 72 9 July July NNP 3242 72 10 23 23 CD 3242 72 11 , , , 3242 72 12 2008 2008 CD 3242 72 13 ) ) -RRB- 3242 72 14 . . . 3242 73 1 EDitoR EDitoR NNP 3242 73 2 ’s ’s POS 3242 73 3 coLumn coLumn NNP 3242 73 4 | | NNP 3242 73 5 tRuitt tRuitt NNP 3242 73 6 5 5 CD 3242 73 7 2 2 CD 3242 73 8 . . . 3242 74 1 Ibid ibid RB 3242 74 2 . . . 3242 75 1 3 3 LS 3242 75 2 . . . 3242 76 1 Tim Tim NNP 3242 76 2 Spalding Spalding NNP 3242 76 3 , , , 3242 76 4 “ " `` 3242 76 5 Re re IN 3242 76 6 : : : 3242 76 7 ‘ ' `` 3242 76 8 Is be VBZ 3242 76 9 Google Google NNP 3242 76 10 Making make VBG 3242 76 11 Us -PRON- PRP 3242 76 12 Stupid Stupid NNP 3242 76 13 ? ? . 3242 77 1 What what WP 3242 77 2 the the DT 3242 77 3 Internet internet NN 3242 77 4 is be VBZ 3242 77 5 Doing do VBG 3242 77 6 to to IN 3242 77 7 Our -PRON- PRP$ 3242 77 8 Brains brain NNS 3242 77 9 , , , 3242 77 10 ’ ' '' 3242 77 11 ” " '' 3242 77 12 Web4Lib Web4Lib NNP 3242 77 13 discussion discussion NN 3242 77 14 list list NN 3242 77 15 post post NNP 3242 77 16 , , , 3242 77 17 June June NNP 3242 77 18 19 19 CD 3242 77 19 , , , 3242 77 20 2008 2008 CD 3242 77 21 , , , 3242 77 22 http://article.gmane.org/gmane.education http://article.gmane.org/gmane.education NNP 3242 77 23 .web4lib/12349 .web4lib/12349 . 3242 77 24 ( ( -LRB- 3242 77 25 accessed access VBN 3242 77 26 July July NNP 3242 77 27 24 24 CD 3242 77 28 , , , 3242 77 29 2008 2008 CD 3242 77 30 ) ) -RRB- 3242 77 31 . . . 3242 78 1 4 4 LS 3242 78 2 . . . 3242 79 1 James James NNP 3242 79 2 A. A. NNP 3242 79 3 Evans Evans NNP 3242 79 4 , , , 3242 79 5 “ " `` 3242 79 6 Electronic Electronic NNP 3242 79 7 Publication Publication NNP 3242 79 8 and and CC 3242 79 9 the the DT 3242 79 10 Narrow- Narrow- NNP 3242 79 11 ing ing NNP 3242 79 12 of of IN 3242 79 13 Science Science NNP 3242 79 14 and and CC 3242 79 15 Scholarship Scholarship NNP 3242 79 16 , , , 3242 79 17 ” " '' 3242 79 18 Science science NN 3242 79 19 ( ( -LRB- 3242 79 20 July July NNP 3242 79 21 18 18 CD 3242 79 22 , , , 3242 79 23 2008 2008 CD 3242 79 24 ) ) -RRB- 3242 79 25 www www NNP 3242 79 26 .sciencemag.org .sciencemag.org NN 3242 79 27 / / SYM 3242 79 28 cgi cgi NN 3242 79 29 / / SYM 3242 79 30 content content NN 3242 79 31 / / SYM 3242 79 32 full/321/5887/395 full/321/5887/395 NNP 3242 79 33 ( ( -LRB- 3242 79 34 accessed access VBN 3242 79 35 July July NNP 3242 79 36 24 24 CD 3242 79 37 , , , 3242 79 38 2008 2008 CD 3242 79 39 ) ) -RRB- 3242 79 40 . . . 3242 80 1 Emphasis emphasis NN 3242 80 2 added add VBD 3242 80 3 . . . 3242 81 1 5 5 CD 3242 81 2 . . . 3242 82 1 Ibid ibid RB 3242 82 2 . . . 3242 83 1 6 6 CD 3242 83 2 . . . 3242 84 1 As as IN 3242 84 2 of of IN 3242 84 3 5:30PM 5:30PM NNP 3242 84 4 ( ( -LRB- 3242 84 5 EST EST NNP 3242 84 6 ) ) -RRB- 3242 84 7 , , , 3242 84 8 July July NNP 3242 84 9 24 24 CD 3242 84 10 , , , 3242 84 11 2008 2008 CD 3242 84 12 , , , 3242 84 13 Amazon Amazon NNP 3242 84 14 ’s ’s POS 3242 84 15 website website NN 3242 84 16 listed list VBD 3242 84 17 145,591 145,591 CD 3242 84 18 “ " `` 3242 84 19 Kindle Kindle NNP 3242 84 20 books book NNS 3242 84 21 . . . 3242 84 22 ” " '' 3242 84 23 www.amazon.com/s/qid=1216934603/ www.amazon.com/s/qid=1216934603/ NNP 3242 84 24 ref ref NNP 3242 84 25 = = SYM 3242 84 26 sr_hi?ie sr_hi?ie NNP 3242 84 27 = = SYM 3242 84 28 UTF8&rs=154606011&bbn=154606011&rh utf8&rs=154606011&bbn=154606011&rh NN 3242 84 29 = = SYM 3242 84 30 n%3A1 n%3a1 NN 3242 84 31 54606011&page=1 54606011&page=1 CD 3242 84 32 . . . 3242 85 1 7 7 LS 3242 85 2 . . . 3242 86 1 Carr Carr NNP 3242 86 2 , , , 3242 86 3 “ " `` 3242 86 4 Is be VBZ 3242 86 5 Google Google NNP 3242 86 6 Making make VBG 3242 86 7 Us -PRON- PRP 3242 86 8 Stupid stupid JJ 3242 86 9 ? ? . 3242 86 10 ” " '' 3242 86 11 8 8 CD 3242 86 12 . . . 3242 87 1 Evans Evans NNP 3242 87 2 , , , 3242 87 3 “ " `` 3242 87 4 Electronic Electronic NNP 3242 87 5 Publication Publication NNP 3242 87 6 and and CC 3242 87 7 the the DT 3242 87 8 Narrowing narrowing NN 3242 87 9 of of IN 3242 87 10 Sci- Sci- NNP 3242 87 11 ence ence NN 3242 87 12 of of IN 3242 87 13 Scholarship scholarship NN 3242 87 14 . . . 3242 87 15 ” " '' 3242 87 16 9 9 CD 3242 87 17 . . . 3242 88 1 Spalding spalding NN 3242 88 2 , , , 3242 88 3 “ " `` 3242 88 4 Re re IN 3242 88 5 : : : 3242 88 6 ‘ ' `` 3242 88 7 Is be VBZ 3242 88 8 Google Google NNP 3242 88 9 Making make VBG 3242 88 10 Us -PRON- PRP 3242 88 11 Stupid stupid JJ 3242 88 12 ? ? . 3242 88 13 ’ ' '' 3242 88 14 ” " ''