id sid tid token lemma pos 3237 1 1 Author author NN 3237 1 2 ID ID NNP 3237 1 3 ? ? . 3237 2 1 mEtaPHor mEtaPHor NNP 3237 2 2 ’s ’s POS 3237 2 3 rolE rolE , 3237 2 4 in in IN 3237 2 5 tHE the DT 3237 2 6 inFormation information NN 3237 2 7 BEHavior behavior NN 3237 2 8 oF of IN 3237 2 9 Humans human NNS 3237 2 10 intEractinG interact VBZ 3237 2 11 witH with IN 3237 2 12 comPutErs computers CD 3237 2 13 | | CD 3237 2 14 sEasE sease CC 3237 2 15 9 9 CD 3237 2 16 Robin Robin NNP 3237 2 17 Sease Sease NNP 3237 2 18 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 2 19 ’s ’s POS 3237 2 20 Role Role NNP 3237 2 21 in in IN 3237 2 22 the the DT 3237 2 23 Information Information NNP 3237 2 24 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 2 25 of of IN 3237 2 26 Humans Humans NNPS 3237 2 27 Interacting interact VBG 3237 2 28 with with IN 3237 2 29 Computers Computers NNPS 3237 2 30 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 2 31 convey convey VBP 3237 2 32 information information NN 3237 2 33 , , , 3237 2 34 communicate communicate VBP 3237 2 35 abstrac- abstrac- JJ 3237 2 36 tions tion NNS 3237 2 37 , , , 3237 2 38 and and CC 3237 2 39 help help VB 3237 2 40 us -PRON- PRP 3237 2 41 understand understand VB 3237 2 42 new new JJ 3237 2 43 concepts concept NNS 3237 2 44 . . . 3237 3 1 While while IN 3237 3 2 the the DT 3237 3 3 nascent nascent JJ 3237 3 4 field field NN 3237 3 5 of of IN 3237 3 6 information information NN 3237 3 7 behavior behavior NN 3237 3 8 ( ( -LRB- 3237 3 9 IB IB NNP 3237 3 10 ) ) -RRB- 3237 3 11 has have VBZ 3237 3 12 adopted adopt VBN 3237 3 13 common common JJ 3237 3 14 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 3 15 like like IN 3237 3 16 “ " `` 3237 3 17 berry berry NN 3237 3 18 - - HYPH 3237 3 19 picking picking NN 3237 3 20 ” " '' 3237 3 21 and and CC 3237 3 22 “ " `` 3237 3 23 gap gap NN 3237 3 24 - - HYPH 3237 3 25 bridg- bridg- NN 3237 3 26 ing ing NN 3237 3 27 ” " '' 3237 3 28 for for IN 3237 3 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 3237 3 30 models model NNS 3237 3 31 , , , 3237 3 32 the the DT 3237 3 33 study study NN 3237 3 34 of of IN 3237 3 35 how how WRB 3237 3 36 people people NNS 3237 3 37 use use VBP 3237 3 38 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 3 39 is be VBZ 3237 3 40 only only RB 3237 3 41 now now RB 3237 3 42 emerging emerge VBG 3237 3 43 in in IN 3237 3 44 the the DT 3237 3 45 subfield subfield NN 3237 3 46 of of IN 3237 3 47 human human JJ 3237 3 48 informa- informa- NNP 3237 3 49 tion tion NN 3237 3 50 organizing organize VBG 3237 3 51 behavior behavior NN 3237 3 52 ( ( -LRB- 3237 3 53 HIOB HIOB NNP 3237 3 54 ) ) -RRB- 3237 3 55 . . . 3237 4 1 Metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 4 2 have have VBP 3237 4 3 been be VBN 3237 4 4 adopted adopt VBN 3237 4 5 in in IN 3237 4 6 human human JJ 3237 4 7 – – : 3237 4 8 computer computer NN 3237 4 9 interaction interaction NN 3237 4 10 ( ( -LRB- 3237 4 11 HCI HCI NNP 3237 4 12 ) ) -RRB- 3237 4 13 to to TO 3237 4 14 facili- facili- VB 3237 4 15 tate tate NNP 3237 4 16 the the DT 3237 4 17 dialogue dialogue NN 3237 4 18 between between IN 3237 4 19 user user NN 3237 4 20 and and CC 3237 4 21 system system NN 3237 4 22 . . . 3237 5 1 Exploration exploration NN 3237 5 2 of of IN 3237 5 3 the the DT 3237 5 4 literature literature NN 3237 5 5 on on IN 3237 5 6 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 5 7 in in IN 3237 5 8 the the DT 3237 5 9 fields field NNS 3237 5 10 of of IN 3237 5 11 linguistics linguistic NNS 3237 5 12 and and CC 3237 5 13 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 5 14 science science NN 3237 5 15 as as RB 3237 5 16 well well RB 3237 5 17 as as IN 3237 5 18 an an DT 3237 5 19 examination examination NN 3237 5 20 of of IN 3237 5 21 the the DT 3237 5 22 history history NN 3237 5 23 of of IN 3237 5 24 use use NN 3237 5 25 of of IN 3237 5 26 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 5 27 in in IN 3237 5 28 HCI HCI NNP 3237 5 29 as as IN 3237 5 30 a a DT 3237 5 31 case case NN 3237 5 32 study study NN 3237 5 33 of of IN 3237 5 34 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 5 35 usage usage NN 3237 5 36 offers offer VBZ 3237 5 37 insight insight NN 3237 5 38 into into IN 3237 5 39 the the DT 3237 5 40 role role NN 3237 5 41 of of IN 3237 5 42 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 5 43 in in IN 3237 5 44 human human JJ 3237 5 45 information information NN 3237 5 46 behavior behavior NN 3237 5 47 . . . 3237 6 1 Editor editor NN 3237 6 2 ’s ’s POS 3237 6 3 note note NN 3237 6 4 : : : 3237 6 5 This this DT 3237 6 6 article article NN 3237 6 7 is be VBZ 3237 6 8 the the DT 3237 6 9 winner winner NN 3237 6 10 of of IN 3237 6 11 the the DT 3237 6 12 LITA/ LITA/ NNP 3237 6 13 Ex Ex NNP 3237 6 14 Libris Libris NNP 3237 6 15 Writing Writing NNP 3237 6 16 Award Award NNP 3237 6 17 , , , 3237 6 18 2008 2008 CD 3237 6 19 . . . 3237 7 1 O o UH 3237 7 2 ur ur NNP 3237 7 3 world world NN 3237 7 4 is be VBZ 3237 7 5 growing grow VBG 3237 7 6 increasingly increasingly RB 3237 7 7 digital digital JJ 3237 7 8 ; ; : 3237 7 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 7 10 entire entire JJ 3237 7 11 lives life NNS 3237 7 12 — — : 3237 7 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 7 14 interactions interaction NNS 3237 7 15 , , , 3237 7 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 7 17 entertainment entertainment NN 3237 7 18 , , , 3237 7 19 even even RB 3237 7 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 7 21 personal personal JJ 3237 7 22 memories memory NNS 3237 7 23 — — : 3237 7 24 are be VBP 3237 7 25 mediated mediate VBN 3237 7 26 by by IN 3237 7 27 technol- technol- NN 3237 7 28 ogy ogy NN 3237 7 29 . . . 3237 8 1 Humans human NNS 3237 8 2 have have VBP 3237 8 3 had have VBN 3237 8 4 thousands thousand NNS 3237 8 5 of of IN 3237 8 6 years year NNS 3237 8 7 to to TO 3237 8 8 learn learn VB 3237 8 9 to to TO 3237 8 10 communicate communicate VB 3237 8 11 with with IN 3237 8 12 each each DT 3237 8 13 other other JJ 3237 8 14 , , , 3237 8 15 largely largely RB 3237 8 16 employing employ VBG 3237 8 17 meta- meta- JJ 3237 8 18 phors phor NNS 3237 8 19 and and CC 3237 8 20 analogies analogy NNS 3237 8 21 to to TO 3237 8 22 negotiate negotiate VB 3237 8 23 meaning meaning NN 3237 8 24 . . . 3237 9 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 9 2 experi- experi- JJ 3237 9 3 ence ence NN 3237 9 4 communicating communicate VBG 3237 9 5 with with IN 3237 9 6 computers computer NNS 3237 9 7 is be VBZ 3237 9 8 both both DT 3237 9 9 nascent nascent JJ 3237 9 10 yet yet RB 3237 9 11 broadening broaden VBG 3237 9 12 every every DT 3237 9 13 day day NN 3237 9 14 with with IN 3237 9 15 increasing increase VBG 3237 9 16 dependency dependency NN 3237 9 17 . . . 3237 10 1 We -PRON- PRP 3237 10 2 must must MD 3237 10 3 fully fully RB 3237 10 4 understand understand VB 3237 10 5 the the DT 3237 10 6 role role NN 3237 10 7 that that WDT 3237 10 8 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 10 9 play play VBP 3237 10 10 in in IN 3237 10 11 the the DT 3237 10 12 exchange exchange NN 3237 10 13 of of IN 3237 10 14 information information NN 3237 10 15 to to TO 3237 10 16 facilitate facilitate VB 3237 10 17 the the DT 3237 10 18 communication communication NN 3237 10 19 between between IN 3237 10 20 humans human NNS 3237 10 21 and and CC 3237 10 22 computers computer NNS 3237 10 23 . . . 3237 11 1 n n NNP 3237 11 2 Metaphors Metaphors NNP 3237 11 3 : : : 3237 11 4 a a DT 3237 11 5 definition definition NN 3237 11 6 Originally originally RB 3237 11 7 regarded regard VBN 3237 11 8 as as IN 3237 11 9 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 3237 11 10 devices device NNS 3237 11 11 , , , 3237 11 12 Plato Plato NNP 3237 11 13 abhorred abhor VBD 3237 11 14 the the DT 3237 11 15 use use NN 3237 11 16 of of IN 3237 11 17 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 11 18 , , , 3237 11 19 arguing argue VBG 3237 11 20 that that IN 3237 11 21 they -PRON- PRP 3237 11 22 could could MD 3237 11 23 convince convince VB 3237 11 24 a a DT 3237 11 25 man man NN 3237 11 26 to to TO 3237 11 27 do do VB 3237 11 28 the the DT 3237 11 29 illogical illogical NN 3237 11 30 . . . 3237 12 1 Schön Schön NNP 3237 12 2 explains explain VBZ 3237 12 3 that that IN 3237 12 4 at at IN 3237 12 5 that that DT 3237 12 6 time time NN 3237 12 7 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 12 8 were be VBD 3237 12 9 considered consider VBN 3237 12 10 a a DT 3237 12 11 “ " `` 3237 12 12 kind kind NN 3237 12 13 of of RB 3237 12 14 anomaly anomaly JJ 3237 12 15 of of IN 3237 12 16 language language NN 3237 12 17 , , , 3237 12 18 one one CD 3237 12 19 which which WDT 3237 12 20 must must MD 3237 12 21 be be VB 3237 12 22 dispelled dispel VBN 3237 12 23 in in IN 3237 12 24 order order NN 3237 12 25 to to TO 3237 12 26 clear clear VB 3237 12 27 the the DT 3237 12 28 path path NN 3237 12 29 for for IN 3237 12 30 a a DT 3237 12 31 general general JJ 3237 12 32 theory theory NN 3237 12 33 of of IN 3237 12 34 reference reference NN 3237 12 35 or or CC 3237 12 36 meaning meaning NN 3237 12 37 . . . 3237 12 38 ”1 ”1 '' 3237 12 39 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 3237 12 40 , , , 3237 12 41 on on IN 3237 12 42 the the DT 3237 12 43 other other JJ 3237 12 44 hand hand NN 3237 12 45 , , , 3237 12 46 saw see VBD 3237 12 47 that that IN 3237 12 48 they -PRON- PRP 3237 12 49 provided provide VBD 3237 12 50 insight insight NN 3237 12 51 into into IN 3237 12 52 the the DT 3237 12 53 items item NNS 3237 12 54 of of IN 3237 12 55 comparison comparison NN 3237 12 56 . . . 3237 13 1 “ " `` 3237 13 2 Ordinary ordinary JJ 3237 13 3 words word NNS 3237 13 4 convey convey VBP 3237 13 5 only only RB 3237 13 6 what what WP 3237 13 7 we -PRON- PRP 3237 13 8 know know VBP 3237 13 9 already already RB 3237 13 10 ; ; : 3237 13 11 it -PRON- PRP 3237 13 12 is be VBZ 3237 13 13 from from IN 3237 13 14 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 13 15 that that WDT 3237 13 16 we -PRON- PRP 3237 13 17 can can MD 3237 13 18 best best RB 3237 13 19 get get VB 3237 13 20 hold hold NN 3237 13 21 of of IN 3237 13 22 something something NN 3237 13 23 new new JJ 3237 13 24 . . . 3237 13 25 ”2 ”2 NNP 3237 13 26 Traditionally traditionally RB 3237 13 27 the the DT 3237 13 28 objects object NNS 3237 13 29 in in IN 3237 13 30 the the DT 3237 13 31 equation equation NN 3237 13 32 have have VBP 3237 13 33 been be VBN 3237 13 34 called call VBN 3237 13 35 the the DT 3237 13 36 tenor tenor NN 3237 13 37 and and CC 3237 13 38 the the DT 3237 13 39 vehicle vehicle NN 3237 13 40 , , , 3237 13 41 but but CC 3237 13 42 more more RBR 3237 13 43 recently recently RB 3237 13 44 they -PRON- PRP 3237 13 45 are be VBP 3237 13 46 referred refer VBN 3237 13 47 to to IN 3237 13 48 as as IN 3237 13 49 the the DT 3237 13 50 target target NN 3237 13 51 and and CC 3237 13 52 source source NN 3237 13 53 domains domain NNS 3237 13 54 . . . 3237 14 1 In in IN 3237 14 2 the the DT 3237 14 3 meta- meta- JJ 3237 14 4 phor phor NN 3237 14 5 , , , 3237 14 6 “ " `` 3237 14 7 Alex Alex NNP 3237 14 8 is be VBZ 3237 14 9 a a DT 3237 14 10 space space NN 3237 14 11 cadet cadet NN 3237 14 12 , , , 3237 14 13 ” " '' 3237 14 14 Alex Alex NNP 3237 14 15 is be VBZ 3237 14 16 the the DT 3237 14 17 tenor tenor NN 3237 14 18 or or CC 3237 14 19 target target VB 3237 14 20 domain domain NN 3237 14 21 ( ( -LRB- 3237 14 22 the the DT 3237 14 23 abstract abstract JJ 3237 14 24 or or CC 3237 14 25 undefined undefined JJ 3237 14 26 ) ) -RRB- 3237 14 27 , , , 3237 14 28 and and CC 3237 14 29 space space NN 3237 14 30 cadet cadet NN 3237 14 31 rep- rep- NN 3237 14 32 resents resent VBZ 3237 14 33 the the DT 3237 14 34 vehicle vehicle NN 3237 14 35 or or CC 3237 14 36 source source NN 3237 14 37 domain domain NN 3237 14 38 ( ( -LRB- 3237 14 39 the the DT 3237 14 40 known know VBN 3237 14 41 ) ) -RRB- 3237 14 42 . . . 3237 15 1 If if IN 3237 15 2 “ " `` 3237 15 3 the the DT 3237 15 4 essence essence NN 3237 15 5 of of IN 3237 15 6 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 15 7 is be VBZ 3237 15 8 understanding understand VBG 3237 15 9 and and CC 3237 15 10 experiencing experience VBG 3237 15 11 one one CD 3237 15 12 thing thing NN 3237 15 13 in in IN 3237 15 14 terms term NNS 3237 15 15 of of IN 3237 15 16 another another DT 3237 15 17 , , , 3237 15 18 ” " '' 3237 15 19 then then RB 3237 15 20 the the DT 3237 15 21 vehicle vehicle NN 3237 15 22 or or CC 3237 15 23 the the DT 3237 15 24 source source NN 3237 15 25 domain domain NN 3237 15 26 is be VBZ 3237 15 27 responsible responsible JJ 3237 15 28 for for IN 3237 15 29 elucidating elucidate VBG 3237 15 30 the the DT 3237 15 31 tenor tenor NN 3237 15 32 or or CC 3237 15 33 target target VB 3237 15 34 domain.3 domain.3 NNP 3237 15 35 One one CD 3237 15 36 measures measure VBZ 3237 15 37 the the DT 3237 15 38 relationship relationship NN 3237 15 39 between between IN 3237 15 40 these these DT 3237 15 41 domains domain NNS 3237 15 42 , , , 3237 15 43 the the DT 3237 15 44 tenor tenor NN 3237 15 45 and and CC 3237 15 46 the the DT 3237 15 47 vehicle vehicle NN 3237 15 48 , , , 3237 15 49 with with IN 3237 15 50 “ " `` 3237 15 51 ground ground NN 3237 15 52 ” " '' 3237 15 53 and and CC 3237 15 54 “ " `` 3237 15 55 tension tension NN 3237 15 56 . . . 3237 15 57 ” " '' 3237 15 58 Ground ground NN 3237 15 59 concerns concern VBZ 3237 15 60 the the DT 3237 15 61 similarities similarity NNS 3237 15 62 between between IN 3237 15 63 the the DT 3237 15 64 domains domain NNS 3237 15 65 and and CC 3237 15 66 tension tension NN 3237 15 67 represents represent VBZ 3237 15 68 the the DT 3237 15 69 dissimilarities.4 dissimilarities.4 NNP 3237 15 70 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 15 71 have have VBP 3237 15 72 been be VBN 3237 15 73 studied study VBN 3237 15 74 from from IN 3237 15 75 multiple multiple JJ 3237 15 76 perspec- perspec- NNP 3237 15 77 tives tive NNS 3237 15 78 : : : 3237 15 79 from from IN 3237 15 80 the the DT 3237 15 81 creative creative JJ 3237 15 82 use use NN 3237 15 83 of of IN 3237 15 84 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 15 85 in in IN 3237 15 86 literature literature NN 3237 15 87 to to IN 3237 15 88 the the DT 3237 15 89 comprehension comprehension NN 3237 15 90 or or CC 3237 15 91 appreciation appreciation NN 3237 15 92 of of IN 3237 15 93 metaphors.5 metaphors.5 NN 3237 15 94 The the DT 3237 15 95 research research NN 3237 15 96 from from IN 3237 15 97 other other JJ 3237 15 98 disciplines discipline NNS 3237 15 99 can can MD 3237 15 100 offer offer VB 3237 15 101 insight insight NN 3237 15 102 into into IN 3237 15 103 the the DT 3237 15 104 effect effect NN 3237 15 105 of of IN 3237 15 106 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 15 107 on on IN 3237 15 108 human human JJ 3237 15 109 information information NN 3237 15 110 behavior behavior NN 3237 15 111 . . . 3237 16 1 I -PRON- PRP 3237 16 2 will will MD 3237 16 3 first first RB 3237 16 4 discuss discuss VB 3237 16 5 the the DT 3237 16 6 use use NN 3237 16 7 of of IN 3237 16 8 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 16 9 in in IN 3237 16 10 language language NN 3237 16 11 and and CC 3237 16 12 then then RB 3237 16 13 review review VB 3237 16 14 some some DT 3237 16 15 of of IN 3237 16 16 the the DT 3237 16 17 theories theory NNS 3237 16 18 on on IN 3237 16 19 how how WRB 3237 16 20 they -PRON- PRP 3237 16 21 work work VBP 3237 16 22 . . . 3237 17 1 n n CC 3237 17 2 Metaphorically metaphorically RB 3237 17 3 speaking speak VBG 3237 17 4 : : : 3237 17 5 the the DT 3237 17 6 role role NN 3237 17 7 of of IN 3237 17 8 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 17 9 in in IN 3237 17 10 language language NN 3237 17 11 The the DT 3237 17 12 work work NN 3237 17 13 of of IN 3237 17 14 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 17 15 and and CC 3237 17 16 Johnson Johnson NNP 3237 17 17 has have VBZ 3237 17 18 been be VBN 3237 17 19 fundamental fundamental JJ 3237 17 20 to to IN 3237 17 21 understanding understand VBG 3237 17 22 the the DT 3237 17 23 pervasive pervasive JJ 3237 17 24 use use NN 3237 17 25 of of IN 3237 17 26 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 17 27 in in IN 3237 17 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 17 29 language language NN 3237 17 30 . . . 3237 18 1 They -PRON- PRP 3237 18 2 propose propose VBP 3237 18 3 that that IN 3237 18 4 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 18 5 are be VBP 3237 18 6 an an DT 3237 18 7 underly- underly- JJ 3237 18 8 ing ing NN 3237 18 9 structure structure NN 3237 18 10 forming form VBG 3237 18 11 and and CC 3237 18 12 shaping shape VBG 3237 18 13 the the DT 3237 18 14 way way NN 3237 18 15 we -PRON- PRP 3237 18 16 discuss discuss VBP 3237 18 17 and and CC 3237 18 18 even even RB 3237 18 19 think think VB 3237 18 20 about about IN 3237 18 21 the the DT 3237 18 22 world world NN 3237 18 23 . . . 3237 19 1 They -PRON- PRP 3237 19 2 argue argue VBP 3237 19 3 that that IN 3237 19 4 the the DT 3237 19 5 “ " `` 3237 19 6 human human JJ 3237 19 7 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 19 8 system system NN 3237 19 9 is be VBZ 3237 19 10 metaphorically metaphorically RB 3237 19 11 structured structure VBN 3237 19 12 and and CC 3237 19 13 defined define VBN 3237 19 14 . . . 3237 19 15 ”6 ”6 NN 3237 19 16 Mapping Mapping NNP 3237 19 17 from from IN 3237 19 18 a a DT 3237 19 19 source source NN 3237 19 20 domain domain NN 3237 19 21 to to IN 3237 19 22 a a DT 3237 19 23 target target NN 3237 19 24 domain domain NN 3237 19 25 is be VBZ 3237 19 26 central central JJ 3237 19 27 to to IN 3237 19 28 the the DT 3237 19 29 semantics semantic NNS 3237 19 30 of of IN 3237 19 31 language language NN 3237 19 32 and and CC 3237 19 33 com- com- NN 3237 19 34 munication munication NN 3237 19 35 . . . 3237 20 1 “ " `` 3237 20 2 Domains domain NNS 3237 20 3 need need VBP 3237 20 4 structure structure NN 3237 20 5 so so IN 3237 20 6 that that IN 3237 20 7 one one PRP 3237 20 8 can can MD 3237 20 9 reason reason VB 3237 20 10 about about IN 3237 20 11 them -PRON- PRP 3237 20 12 . . . 3237 21 1 The the DT 3237 21 2 major major JJ 3237 21 3 function function NN 3237 21 4 of of IN 3237 21 5 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 21 6 is be VBZ 3237 21 7 thus thus RB 3237 21 8 to to TO 3237 21 9 supply supply VB 3237 21 10 structure structure NN 3237 21 11 in in IN 3237 21 12 terms term NNS 3237 21 13 of of IN 3237 21 14 which which WDT 3237 21 15 reasoning reasoning NN 3237 21 16 can can MD 3237 21 17 be be VB 3237 21 18 done do VBN 3237 21 19 . . . 3237 21 20 ”7 ”7 '' 3237 21 21 In in IN 3237 21 22 Metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 21 23 We -PRON- PRP 3237 21 24 Live live VBP 3237 21 25 By by IN 3237 21 26 , , , 3237 21 27 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 21 28 and and CC 3237 21 29 Johnson Johnson NNP 3237 21 30 cata- cata- NN 3237 21 31 logue logue NN 3237 21 32 examples example NNS 3237 21 33 of of IN 3237 21 34 underlying underlie VBG 3237 21 35 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 21 36 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 21 37 . . . 3237 22 1 They -PRON- PRP 3237 22 2 identify identify VBP 3237 22 3 orientation orientation NN 3237 22 4 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 22 5 that that WDT 3237 22 6 underlie underlie VBP 3237 22 7 how how WRB 3237 22 8 we -PRON- PRP 3237 22 9 speak speak VBP 3237 22 10 about about IN 3237 22 11 abstract abstract JJ 3237 22 12 concepts concept NNS 3237 22 13 such such JJ 3237 22 14 as as IN 3237 22 15 health health NN 3237 22 16 , , , 3237 22 17 happi- happi- NN 3237 22 18 ness ness NN 3237 22 19 , , , 3237 22 20 and and CC 3237 22 21 success success NN 3237 22 22 . . . 3237 23 1 Each each DT 3237 23 2 of of IN 3237 23 3 these these DT 3237 23 4 states state NNS 3237 23 5 is be VBZ 3237 23 6 associated associate VBN 3237 23 7 with with IN 3237 23 8 the the DT 3237 23 9 direction direction NN 3237 23 10 up up RB 3237 23 11 . . . 3237 24 1 One one PRP 3237 24 2 can can MD 3237 24 3 be be VB 3237 24 4 “ " `` 3237 24 5 up up RB 3237 24 6 and and CC 3237 24 7 at at IN 3237 24 8 ‘ ' `` 3237 24 9 em -PRON- PRP 3237 24 10 ” " '' 3237 24 11 or or CC 3237 24 12 in in IN 3237 24 13 “ " `` 3237 24 14 high high JJ 3237 24 15 spirits spirit NNS 3237 24 16 ” " '' 3237 24 17 or or CC 3237 24 18 of of IN 3237 24 19 “ " `` 3237 24 20 high high JJ 3237 24 21 standing standing NN 3237 24 22 . . . 3237 24 23 ” " '' 3237 24 24 Counter counter NN 3237 24 25 examples example NNS 3237 24 26 include include VBP 3237 24 27 “ " `` 3237 24 28 being be VBG 3237 24 29 under under IN 3237 24 30 the the DT 3237 24 31 weather weather NN 3237 24 32 , , , 3237 24 33 ” " '' 3237 24 34 “ " `` 3237 24 35 feeling feel VBG 3237 24 36 down down RB 3237 24 37 , , , 3237 24 38 ” " '' 3237 24 39 and and CC 3237 24 40 “ " `` 3237 24 41 low low JJ 3237 24 42 comedy comedy NN 3237 24 43 . . . 3237 24 44 ” " '' 3237 24 45 Metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 24 46 shape shape VBP 3237 24 47 the the DT 3237 24 48 way way NN 3237 24 49 we -PRON- PRP 3237 24 50 think think VBP 3237 24 51 about about IN 3237 24 52 the the DT 3237 24 53 concepts concept NNS 3237 24 54 we -PRON- PRP 3237 24 55 are be VBP 3237 24 56 describing describe VBG 3237 24 57 . . . 3237 25 1 For for IN 3237 25 2 instance instance NN 3237 25 3 , , , 3237 25 4 the the DT 3237 25 5 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 25 6 “ " `` 3237 25 7 argument argument NN 3237 25 8 is be VBZ 3237 25 9 war war NN 3237 25 10 ” " '' 3237 25 11 ( ( -LRB- 3237 25 12 “ " `` 3237 25 13 defending defend VBG 3237 25 14 your -PRON- PRP$ 3237 25 15 point point NN 3237 25 16 of of IN 3237 25 17 view view NN 3237 25 18 , , , 3237 25 19 ” " '' 3237 25 20 “ " `` 3237 25 21 attacking attack VBG 3237 25 22 your -PRON- PRP$ 3237 25 23 opponent opponent NN 3237 25 24 ’s ’s POS 3237 25 25 stance stance NN 3237 25 26 , , , 3237 25 27 ” " '' 3237 25 28 and and CC 3237 25 29 “ " `` 3237 25 30 he -PRON- PRP 3237 25 31 shot shoot VBD 3237 25 32 me -PRON- PRP 3237 25 33 down down RP 3237 25 34 ” " '' 3237 25 35 ) ) -RRB- 3237 25 36 may may MD 3237 25 37 define define VB 3237 25 38 expectations expectation NNS 3237 25 39 for for IN 3237 25 40 “ " `` 3237 25 41 winning win VBG 3237 25 42 ” " '' 3237 25 43 and and CC 3237 25 44 “ " `` 3237 25 45 los- los- VBD 3237 25 46 ing ing NNP 3237 25 47 ” " '' 3237 25 48 and and CC 3237 25 49 detrimentally detrimentally RB 3237 25 50 shape shape VB 3237 25 51 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 25 52 ability ability NN 3237 25 53 to to TO 3237 25 54 negotiate negotiate VB 3237 25 55 and and CC 3237 25 56 compromise.8 compromise.8 VB 3237 25 57 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 25 58 and and CC 3237 25 59 Johnson Johnson NNP 3237 25 60 refer refer VBP 3237 25 61 also also RB 3237 25 62 to to IN 3237 25 63 Michael Michael NNP 3237 25 64 Reddy Reddy NNP 3237 25 65 ’s ’s POS 3237 25 66 1979 1979 CD 3237 25 67 piece piece NN 3237 25 68 , , , 3237 25 69 “ " `` 3237 25 70 The the DT 3237 25 71 Conduit Conduit NNP 3237 25 72 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 25 73 . . . 3237 25 74 ”9 ”9 NNP 3237 25 75 Reddy Reddy NNP 3237 25 76 hypoth- hypoth- VBZ 3237 25 77 esizes esize VBZ 3237 25 78 that that IN 3237 25 79 linguistically linguistically RB 3237 25 80 and and CC 3237 25 81 conceptually conceptually RB 3237 25 82 we -PRON- PRP 3237 25 83 see see VBP 3237 25 84 ideas idea NNS 3237 25 85 or or CC 3237 25 86 meanings meaning NNS 3237 25 87 as as IN 3237 25 88 objects object NNS 3237 25 89 , , , 3237 25 90 linguistic linguistic JJ 3237 25 91 expressions expression NNS 3237 25 92 as as IN 3237 25 93 contain- contain- NNP 3237 25 94 ers ers NNP 3237 25 95 , , , 3237 25 96 and and CC 3237 25 97 communication communication NN 3237 25 98 as as IN 3237 25 99 sending send VBG 3237 25 100 . . . 3237 26 1 The the DT 3237 26 2 “ " `` 3237 26 3 receivers receiver NNS 3237 26 4 ” " '' 3237 26 5 of of IN 3237 26 6 robin robin NNP 3237 26 7 sease sease NNP 3237 26 8 ( ( -LRB- 3237 26 9 seaser@u.washington.edu seaser@u.washington.edu ADD 3237 26 10 ) ) -RRB- 3237 26 11 is be VBZ 3237 26 12 an an DT 3237 26 13 MLIS MLIS NNP 3237 26 14 candidate candidate NN 3237 26 15 at at IN 3237 26 16 the the DT 3237 26 17 iSchool iSchool NNP 3237 26 18 , , , 3237 26 19 University University NNP 3237 26 20 of of IN 3237 26 21 Washington Washington NNP 3237 26 22 , , , 3237 26 23 Seattle Seattle NNP 3237 26 24 . . . 3237 27 1 10 10 CD 3237 27 2 inFormation information NN 3237 27 3 tEcHnoloGY technology NN 3237 27 4 anD and CC 3237 27 5 liBrariEs libraries NN 3237 27 6 | | NNP 3237 27 7 DEcEmBEr DEcEmBEr NNP 3237 27 8 2008 2008 CD 3237 27 9 the the DT 3237 27 10 communication communication NN 3237 27 11 are be VBP 3237 27 12 the the DT 3237 27 13 information information NN 3237 27 14 users user NNS 3237 27 15 or or CC 3237 27 16 seekers seeker NNS 3237 27 17 . . . 3237 28 1 The the DT 3237 28 2 designers designer NNS 3237 28 3 “ " `` 3237 28 4 package package VBP 3237 28 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 28 6 ideas idea NNS 3237 28 7 , , , 3237 28 8 ” " '' 3237 28 9 “ " `` 3237 28 10 put put VBD 3237 28 11 them -PRON- PRP 3237 28 12 down down RP 3237 28 13 on on IN 3237 28 14 paper paper NN 3237 28 15 , , , 3237 28 16 ” " '' 3237 28 17 and and CC 3237 28 18 “ " `` 3237 28 19 convey convey VB 3237 28 20 ” " '' 3237 28 21 them -PRON- PRP 3237 28 22 to to IN 3237 28 23 the the DT 3237 28 24 user user NN 3237 28 25 who who WP 3237 28 26 “ " `` 3237 28 27 gets get VBZ 3237 28 28 ” " '' 3237 28 29 them -PRON- PRP 3237 28 30 or or CC 3237 28 31 not not RB 3237 28 32 . . . 3237 29 1 Reddy Reddy NNP 3237 29 2 argues argue VBZ 3237 29 3 that that IN 3237 29 4 this this DT 3237 29 5 underlying underlying JJ 3237 29 6 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 29 7 influences influence VBZ 3237 29 8 the the DT 3237 29 9 way way NN 3237 29 10 we -PRON- PRP 3237 29 11 think think VBP 3237 29 12 about about IN 3237 29 13 the the DT 3237 29 14 communication communication NN 3237 29 15 process process NN 3237 29 16 , , , 3237 29 17 making make VBG 3237 29 18 information information NN 3237 29 19 and and CC 3237 29 20 meaning mean VBG 3237 29 21 an an DT 3237 29 22 object object NN 3237 29 23 rather rather RB 3237 29 24 than than IN 3237 29 25 a a DT 3237 29 26 process process NN 3237 29 27 , , , 3237 29 28 which which WDT 3237 29 29 trivializes trivialize VBZ 3237 29 30 the the DT 3237 29 31 function function NN 3237 29 32 of of IN 3237 29 33 the the DT 3237 29 34 reader reader NN 3237 29 35 or or CC 3237 29 36 listener.10 listener.10 NNP 3237 29 37 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 29 38 are be VBP 3237 29 39 undeniably undeniably RB 3237 29 40 central central JJ 3237 29 41 to to IN 3237 29 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 29 43 ability ability NN 3237 29 44 to to TO 3237 29 45 communicate communicate VB 3237 29 46 and and CC 3237 29 47 use use VB 3237 29 48 language language NN 3237 29 49 , , , 3237 29 50 and and CC 3237 29 51 perhaps perhaps RB 3237 29 52 more more JJR 3237 29 53 fun- fun- RB 3237 29 54 damentally damentally RB 3237 29 55 , , , 3237 29 56 to to TO 3237 29 57 convey convey VB 3237 29 58 meaning meaning NN 3237 29 59 or or CC 3237 29 60 to to TO 3237 29 61 infer infer VB 3237 29 62 meaning meaning NN 3237 29 63 — — : 3237 29 64 to to TO 3237 29 65 illustrate illustrate VB 3237 29 66 and and CC 3237 29 67 explain explain VB 3237 29 68 as as RB 3237 29 69 well well RB 3237 29 70 as as IN 3237 29 71 to to TO 3237 29 72 identify identify VB 3237 29 73 and and CC 3237 29 74 to to TO 3237 29 75 catalog catalog VB 3237 29 76 . . . 3237 30 1 The the DT 3237 30 2 role role NN 3237 30 3 of of IN 3237 30 4 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 30 5 in in IN 3237 30 6 human human JJ 3237 30 7 cognition cognition NN 3237 30 8 is be VBZ 3237 30 9 still still RB 3237 30 10 a a DT 3237 30 11 matter matter NN 3237 30 12 of of IN 3237 30 13 great great JJ 3237 30 14 debate debate NN 3237 30 15 . . . 3237 31 1 n n LS 3237 31 2 Thinking think VBG 3237 31 3 about about IN 3237 31 4 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 31 5 : : : 3237 31 6 the the DT 3237 31 7 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 31 8 role role NN 3237 31 9 of of IN 3237 31 10 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 31 11 Information Information NNP 3237 31 12 science science NN 3237 31 13 is be VBZ 3237 31 14 at at IN 3237 31 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 3237 31 16 heart heart NN 3237 31 17 the the DT 3237 31 18 study study NN 3237 31 19 of of IN 3237 31 20 informa- informa- JJ 3237 31 21 tion tion NN 3237 31 22 . . . 3237 32 1 If if IN 3237 32 2 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 32 3 exist exist VBP 3237 32 4 as as IN 3237 32 5 a a DT 3237 32 6 necessary necessary JJ 3237 32 7 component component NN 3237 32 8 of of IN 3237 32 9 language language NN 3237 32 10 — — : 3237 32 11 a a DT 3237 32 12 tool tool NN 3237 32 13 to to TO 3237 32 14 convey convey VB 3237 32 15 meaning meaning NN 3237 32 16 and and CC 3237 32 17 to to TO 3237 32 18 transfer transfer VB 3237 32 19 information information NN 3237 32 20 — — : 3237 32 21 then then RB 3237 32 22 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 32 23 are be VBP 3237 32 24 by by IN 3237 32 25 necessity necessity NN 3237 32 26 a a DT 3237 32 27 compo- compo- NN 3237 32 28 nent nent NN 3237 32 29 of of IN 3237 32 30 information information NN 3237 32 31 science science NN 3237 32 32 . . . 3237 33 1 Understanding understand VBG 3237 33 2 how how WRB 3237 33 3 meta- meta- JJ 3237 33 4 phors phor NNS 3237 33 5 work work VBP 3237 33 6 provides provide VBZ 3237 33 7 insight insight NN 3237 33 8 into into IN 3237 33 9 information information NN 3237 33 10 itself -PRON- PRP 3237 33 11 . . . 3237 34 1 Early early JJ 3237 34 2 propositions proposition NNS 3237 34 3 about about IN 3237 34 4 how how WRB 3237 34 5 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 34 6 were be VBD 3237 34 7 under- under- JJ 3237 34 8 stood stand VBD 3237 34 9 stemmed stem VBD 3237 34 10 from from IN 3237 34 11 poetic poetic JJ 3237 34 12 and and CC 3237 34 13 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 3237 34 14 research research NN 3237 34 15 . . . 3237 35 1 That that RB 3237 35 2 is is RB 3237 35 3 , , , 3237 35 4 if if IN 3237 35 5 a a DT 3237 35 6 sentence sentence NN 3237 35 7 can can MD 3237 35 8 not not RB 3237 35 9 be be VB 3237 35 10 interpreted interpret VBN 3237 35 11 literally literally RB 3237 35 12 , , , 3237 35 13 then then RB 3237 35 14 it -PRON- PRP 3237 35 15 must must MD 3237 35 16 be be VB 3237 35 17 interpreted interpret VBN 3237 35 18 figuratively figuratively RB 3237 35 19 . . . 3237 36 1 To to TO 3237 36 2 illustrate illustrate VB 3237 36 3 , , , 3237 36 4 the the DT 3237 36 5 asser- asser- JJ 3237 36 6 tion tion NN 3237 36 7 “ " `` 3237 36 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 3237 36 9 child child NN 3237 36 10 is be VBZ 3237 36 11 a a DT 3237 36 12 pig pig NN 3237 36 13 ” " '' 3237 36 14 is be VBZ 3237 36 15 initially initially RB 3237 36 16 illogical illogical JJ 3237 36 17 , , , 3237 36 18 so so RB 3237 36 19 the the DT 3237 36 20 receiver receiver NN 3237 36 21 would would MD 3237 36 22 then then RB 3237 36 23 move move VB 3237 36 24 on on RP 3237 36 25 to to IN 3237 36 26 figurative figurative JJ 3237 36 27 interpretation interpretation NN 3237 36 28 . . . 3237 37 1 Once once IN 3237 37 2 that that DT 3237 37 3 determination determination NN 3237 37 4 is be VBZ 3237 37 5 made make VBN 3237 37 6 , , , 3237 37 7 the the DT 3237 37 8 mind mind NN 3237 37 9 sets set VBZ 3237 37 10 about about IN 3237 37 11 find- find- NNP 3237 37 12 ing ing NNP 3237 37 13 meaning meaning NN 3237 37 14 from from IN 3237 37 15 the the DT 3237 37 16 expression expression NN 3237 37 17 . . . 3237 38 1 This this DT 3237 38 2 theory theory NN 3237 38 3 argues argue VBZ 3237 38 4 that that IN 3237 38 5 once once IN 3237 38 6 the the DT 3237 38 7 statement statement NN 3237 38 8 is be VBZ 3237 38 9 deemed deem VBN 3237 38 10 false false JJ 3237 38 11 , , , 3237 38 12 the the DT 3237 38 13 statement statement NN 3237 38 14 is be VBZ 3237 38 15 treated treat VBN 3237 38 16 like like IN 3237 38 17 a a DT 3237 38 18 simile simile NN 3237 38 19 , , , 3237 38 20 or or CC 3237 38 21 a a DT 3237 38 22 comparison comparison NN 3237 38 23 statement statement NN 3237 38 24 , , , 3237 38 25 by by IN 3237 38 26 identifying identify VBG 3237 38 27 traits trait NNS 3237 38 28 or or CC 3237 38 29 attributes attribute NNS 3237 38 30 in in IN 3237 38 31 the the DT 3237 38 32 source source NN 3237 38 33 domain domain NN 3237 38 34 ( ( -LRB- 3237 38 35 the the DT 3237 38 36 pig pig NN 3237 38 37 : : : 3237 38 38 sloppy sloppy JJ 3237 38 39 , , , 3237 38 40 slovenly slovenly RB 3237 38 41 , , , 3237 38 42 fascinated fascinate VBN 3237 38 43 with with IN 3237 38 44 mud mud NN 3237 38 45 ) ) -RRB- 3237 38 46 that that WDT 3237 38 47 would would MD 3237 38 48 be be VB 3237 38 49 applicable applicable JJ 3237 38 50 to to IN 3237 38 51 the the DT 3237 38 52 target target NN 3237 38 53 domain.11 domain.11 NNP 3237 38 54 One one CD 3237 38 55 group group NN 3237 38 56 of of IN 3237 38 57 theorists theorist NNS 3237 38 58 questions question NNS 3237 38 59 this this DT 3237 38 60 premise premise NN 3237 38 61 , , , 3237 38 62 point- point- NN 3237 38 63 ing ing NNP 3237 38 64 to to IN 3237 38 65 sentences sentence NNS 3237 38 66 that that WDT 3237 38 67 can can MD 3237 38 68 be be VB 3237 38 69 interpreted interpret VBN 3237 38 70 literally literally RB 3237 38 71 and and CC 3237 38 72 figu- figu- VB 3237 38 73 ratively ratively RB 3237 38 74 . . . 3237 39 1 One one CD 3237 39 2 useful useful JJ 3237 39 3 example example NN 3237 39 4 is be VBZ 3237 39 5 the the DT 3237 39 6 statement statement NN 3237 39 7 “ " `` 3237 39 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 3237 39 9 dog dog NN 3237 39 10 is be VBZ 3237 39 11 an an DT 3237 39 12 animal animal NN 3237 39 13 . . . 3237 39 14 ”12 ”12 '' 3237 39 15 While while IN 3237 39 16 this this DT 3237 39 17 expression expression NN 3237 39 18 is be VBZ 3237 39 19 true true JJ 3237 39 20 literally literally RB 3237 39 21 , , , 3237 39 22 most most JJS 3237 39 23 would would MD 3237 39 24 reject reject VB 3237 39 25 the the DT 3237 39 26 literal literal JJ 3237 39 27 interpretation interpretation NN 3237 39 28 in in IN 3237 39 29 favor favor NN 3237 39 30 of of IN 3237 39 31 one one NN 3237 39 32 that that WDT 3237 39 33 depicts depict VBZ 3237 39 34 the the DT 3237 39 35 dog dog NN 3237 39 36 as as IN 3237 39 37 a a DT 3237 39 38 ferocious ferocious JJ 3237 39 39 or or CC 3237 39 40 uncontrollable uncontrollable JJ 3237 39 41 beast beast NN 3237 39 42 . . . 3237 40 1 Glucksberg Glucksberg NNP 3237 40 2 and and CC 3237 40 3 Keysar Keysar NNP 3237 40 4 , , , 3237 40 5 among among IN 3237 40 6 others other NNS 3237 40 7 , , , 3237 40 8 seek seek VB 3237 40 9 a a DT 3237 40 10 model model NN 3237 40 11 that that WDT 3237 40 12 focuses focus VBZ 3237 40 13 on on IN 3237 40 14 the the DT 3237 40 15 associations association NNS 3237 40 16 between between IN 3237 40 17 the the DT 3237 40 18 domains domain NNS 3237 40 19 . . . 3237 41 1 They -PRON- PRP 3237 41 2 hypothesize hypothesize VBP 3237 41 3 that that IN 3237 41 4 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 41 5 are be VBP 3237 41 6 not not RB 3237 41 7 “ " `` 3237 41 8 implicit implicit JJ 3237 41 9 compari- compari- JJ 3237 41 10 sons son NNS 3237 41 11 ” " '' 3237 41 12 but but CC 3237 41 13 are be VBP 3237 41 14 class class NN 3237 41 15 - - HYPH 3237 41 16 inclusion inclusion NN 3237 41 17 statements statement NNS 3237 41 18 or or CC 3237 41 19 “ " `` 3237 41 20 assertions assertion NNS 3237 41 21 of of IN 3237 41 22 categorization categorization NN 3237 41 23 . . . 3237 41 24 ”13 ”13 NNP 3237 41 25 Research Research NNP 3237 41 26 in in IN 3237 41 27 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 41 28 processing processing NN 3237 41 29 of of IN 3237 41 30 analogies analogy NNS 3237 41 31 has have VBZ 3237 41 32 shifted shift VBN 3237 41 33 from from IN 3237 41 34 plain plain JJ 3237 41 35 association association NN 3237 41 36 of of IN 3237 41 37 A A NNP 3237 41 38 is be VBZ 3237 41 39 to to IN 3237 41 40 B b NN 3237 41 41 where where WRB 3237 41 42 A a DT 3237 41 43 traits trait NNS 3237 41 44 are be VBP 3237 41 45 matched match VBN 3237 41 46 to to IN 3237 41 47 B b NN 3237 41 48 traits trait NNS 3237 41 49 to to IN 3237 41 50 a a DT 3237 41 51 hypothesis hypothesis NN 3237 41 52 that that WDT 3237 41 53 maps map VBZ 3237 41 54 from from IN 3237 41 55 A a NN 3237 41 56 to to IN 3237 41 57 B b NN 3237 41 58 and and CC 3237 41 59 leads lead VBZ 3237 41 60 insight insight NN 3237 41 61 into into IN 3237 41 62 a a DT 3237 41 63 super super JJ 3237 41 64 - - JJ 3237 41 65 ordinate ordinate JJ 3237 41 66 category category NN 3237 41 67 that that WDT 3237 41 68 includes include VBZ 3237 41 69 both both CC 3237 41 70 A A NNP 3237 41 71 and and CC 3237 41 72 B. B. NNP 3237 41 73 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 41 74 ’s ’s POS 3237 41 75 work work NN 3237 41 76 studying study VBG 3237 41 77 science science NN 3237 41 78 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 41 79 in in IN 3237 41 80 the the DT 3237 41 81 1980s 1980s CD 3237 41 82 is be VBZ 3237 41 83 partially partially RB 3237 41 84 founded found VBN 3237 41 85 on on IN 3237 41 86 this this DT 3237 41 87 theory theory NN 3237 41 88 . . . 3237 42 1 She -PRON- PRP 3237 42 2 notes note VBZ 3237 42 3 that that IN 3237 42 4 through through IN 3237 42 5 “ " `` 3237 42 6 analogical analogical JJ 3237 42 7 reasoning reasoning NN 3237 42 8 , , , 3237 42 9 learning learning NN 3237 42 10 can can MD 3237 42 11 result result VB 3237 42 12 in in IN 3237 42 13 the the DT 3237 42 14 generation generation NN 3237 42 15 of of IN 3237 42 16 new new JJ 3237 42 17 categories category NNS 3237 42 18 and and CC 3237 42 19 schemas schema NNS 3237 42 20 . . . 3237 42 21 ”14 ”14 NNP 3237 42 22 She -PRON- PRP 3237 42 23 is be VBZ 3237 42 24 particularly particularly RB 3237 42 25 interested interested JJ 3237 42 26 in in IN 3237 42 27 creating create VBG 3237 42 28 ways way NNS 3237 42 29 for for IN 3237 42 30 computers computer NNS 3237 42 31 to to TO 3237 42 32 interpret interpret VB 3237 42 33 figurative figurative JJ 3237 42 34 expressions expression NNS 3237 42 35 . . . 3237 43 1 She -PRON- PRP 3237 43 2 proposes propose VBZ 3237 43 3 a a DT 3237 43 4 structure- structure- JJ 3237 43 5 mapping mapping NN 3237 43 6 theory theory NN 3237 43 7 : : : 3237 43 8 a a DT 3237 43 9 system system NN 3237 43 10 of of IN 3237 43 11 relations relation NNS 3237 43 12 ( ( -LRB- 3237 43 13 not not RB 3237 43 14 just just RB 3237 43 15 traits trait NNS 3237 43 16 ) ) -RRB- 3237 43 17 from from IN 3237 43 18 the the DT 3237 43 19 source source NN 3237 43 20 domain domain NN 3237 43 21 to to IN 3237 43 22 the the DT 3237 43 23 target target NN 3237 43 24 domain domain NN 3237 43 25 with with IN 3237 43 26 a a DT 3237 43 27 parallelism parallelism NN 3237 43 28 between between IN 3237 43 29 the the DT 3237 43 30 structures structure NNS 3237 43 31 that that WDT 3237 43 32 allows allow VBZ 3237 43 33 for for IN 3237 43 34 a a DT 3237 43 35 one one CD 3237 43 36 - - HYPH 3237 43 37 to to IN 3237 43 38 - - HYPH 3237 43 39 one one CD 3237 43 40 map- map- NN 3237 43 41 ping ping NN 3237 43 42 of of IN 3237 43 43 the the DT 3237 43 44 domains domain NNS 3237 43 45 and and CC 3237 43 46 relationships relationship NNS 3237 43 47 . . . 3237 44 1 Weiner Weiner NNP 3237 44 2 explores explore VBZ 3237 44 3 a a DT 3237 44 4 similar similar JJ 3237 44 5 tactic tactic NN 3237 44 6 with with IN 3237 44 7 human human JJ 3237 44 8 – – : 3237 44 9 computer computer NN 3237 44 10 interaction interaction NN 3237 44 11 language language NN 3237 44 12 processing processing NN 3237 44 13 by by IN 3237 44 14 prototyping prototype VBG 3237 44 15 the the DT 3237 44 16 shared shared JJ 3237 44 17 framework framework NN 3237 44 18 . . . 3237 45 1 The the DT 3237 45 2 prototype prototype NN 3237 45 3 theory theory NN 3237 45 4 allows allow VBZ 3237 45 5 for for IN 3237 45 6 a a DT 3237 45 7 range range NN 3237 45 8 of of IN 3237 45 9 possible possible JJ 3237 45 10 predicates predicate NNS 3237 45 11 and and CC 3237 45 12 would would MD 3237 45 13 accommodate accommodate VB 3237 45 14 greater great JJR 3237 45 15 tension tension NN 3237 45 16 ( ( -LRB- 3237 45 17 the the DT 3237 45 18 differences difference NNS 3237 45 19 in in IN 3237 45 20 a a DT 3237 45 21 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 45 22 ) ) -RRB- 3237 45 23 in in IN 3237 45 24 the the DT 3237 45 25 same same JJ 3237 45 26 way way NN 3237 45 27 that that WDT 3237 45 28 we -PRON- PRP 3237 45 29 can can MD 3237 45 30 categorize categorize VB 3237 45 31 penguins penguin NNS 3237 45 32 and and CC 3237 45 33 chickens chicken NNS 3237 45 34 under under IN 3237 45 35 the the DT 3237 45 36 prototype prototype NN 3237 45 37 of of IN 3237 45 38 bird.15 bird.15 NNP 3237 45 39 These these DT 3237 45 40 theories theory NNS 3237 45 41 of of IN 3237 45 42 categorization categorization NN 3237 45 43 remain remain VBP 3237 45 44 popular popular JJ 3237 45 45 today today NN 3237 45 46 , , , 3237 45 47 but but CC 3237 45 48 still still RB 3237 45 49 struggle struggle VB 3237 45 50 to to TO 3237 45 51 account account VB 3237 45 52 for for IN 3237 45 53 certain certain JJ 3237 45 54 things thing NNS 3237 45 55 about about IN 3237 45 56 the the DT 3237 45 57 way way NN 3237 45 58 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 45 59 are be VBP 3237 45 60 comprehended comprehend VBN 3237 45 61 . . . 3237 46 1 Specifically specifically RB 3237 46 2 , , , 3237 46 3 take take VB 3237 46 4 the the DT 3237 46 5 Shakespearean shakespearean JJ 3237 46 6 line line NN 3237 46 7 , , , 3237 46 8 “ " `` 3237 46 9 Juliet Juliet NNP 3237 46 10 is be VBZ 3237 46 11 the the DT 3237 46 12 sun sun NN 3237 46 13 . . . 3237 46 14 ” " '' 3237 46 15 Categorization categorization NN 3237 46 16 theory theory NN 3237 46 17 does do VBZ 3237 46 18 not not RB 3237 46 19 explain explain VB 3237 46 20 why why WRB 3237 46 21 some some DT 3237 46 22 attributes attribute NNS 3237 46 23 like like IN 3237 46 24 “ " `` 3237 46 25 glow- glow- NNP 3237 46 26 ing ing NNP 3237 46 27 ” " '' 3237 46 28 and and CC 3237 46 29 “ " `` 3237 46 30 center center NN 3237 46 31 of of IN 3237 46 32 the the DT 3237 46 33 solar solar JJ 3237 46 34 system system NN 3237 46 35 ” " '' 3237 46 36 are be VBP 3237 46 37 transferred transfer VBN 3237 46 38 from from IN 3237 46 39 the the DT 3237 46 40 source source NN 3237 46 41 while while IN 3237 46 42 others other NNS 3237 46 43 such such JJ 3237 46 44 as as IN 3237 46 45 “ " `` 3237 46 46 nuclear nuclear JJ 3237 46 47 ” " '' 3237 46 48 and and CC 3237 46 49 “ " `` 3237 46 50 huge huge JJ 3237 46 51 ” " '' 3237 46 52 are be VBP 3237 46 53 not.16 not.16 JJ 3237 46 54 This this DT 3237 46 55 theory theory NN 3237 46 56 also also RB 3237 46 57 stumbles stumble VBZ 3237 46 58 with with IN 3237 46 59 novel novel JJ 3237 46 60 poetic poetic JJ 3237 46 61 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 46 62 like like IN 3237 46 63 e e NNP 3237 46 64 e e NNP 3237 46 65 cummings cumming NNS 3237 46 66 ’ ' '' 3237 46 67 “ " `` 3237 46 68 the the DT 3237 46 69 voice voice NN 3237 46 70 of of IN 3237 46 71 your -PRON- PRP$ 3237 46 72 eyes eye NNS 3237 46 73 is be VBZ 3237 46 74 deeper deep JJR 3237 46 75 than than IN 3237 46 76 all all DT 3237 46 77 roses rose NNS 3237 46 78 . . . 3237 46 79 ”17 ”17 JJ 3237 46 80 Alternative alternative JJ 3237 46 81 theorists theorist NNS 3237 46 82 argue argue VBP 3237 46 83 that that IN 3237 46 84 while while IN 3237 46 85 the the DT 3237 46 86 categorization categorization NN 3237 46 87 - - HYPH 3237 46 88 based base VBN 3237 46 89 theories theory NNS 3237 46 90 accommodate accommodate VBP 3237 46 91 the the DT 3237 46 92 ground ground NN 3237 46 93 ( ( -LRB- 3237 46 94 commonality commonality NN 3237 46 95 ) ) -RRB- 3237 46 96 in in IN 3237 46 97 a a DT 3237 46 98 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 46 99 , , , 3237 46 100 they -PRON- PRP 3237 46 101 fail fail VBP 3237 46 102 to to TO 3237 46 103 fully fully RB 3237 46 104 explain explain VB 3237 46 105 the the DT 3237 46 106 effect effect NN 3237 46 107 and and CC 3237 46 108 purpose purpose NN 3237 46 109 of of IN 3237 46 110 the the DT 3237 46 111 tension tension NN 3237 46 112 ( ( -LRB- 3237 46 113 differences difference NNS 3237 46 114 ) ) -RRB- 3237 46 115 in in IN 3237 46 116 the the DT 3237 46 117 equation equation NN 3237 46 118 . . . 3237 47 1 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 47 2 fervently fervently RB 3237 47 3 contends contend VBZ 3237 47 4 that that IN 3237 47 5 simplifying simplify VBG 3237 47 6 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 47 7 models model NNS 3237 47 8 to to IN 3237 47 9 mere mere JJ 3237 47 10 categorization categorization NN 3237 47 11 ignores ignore VBZ 3237 47 12 the the DT 3237 47 13 unique unique JJ 3237 47 14 nature nature NN 3237 47 15 of of IN 3237 47 16 each each DT 3237 47 17 specific specific JJ 3237 47 18 mapping mapping NN 3237 47 19 : : : 3237 47 20 Each each DT 3237 47 21 mapping mapping NN 3237 47 22 defines define VBZ 3237 47 23 an an DT 3237 47 24 open open JJ 3237 47 25 - - HYPH 3237 47 26 ended ended JJ 3237 47 27 class class NN 3237 47 28 of of IN 3237 47 29 potential potential JJ 3237 47 30 correspondences correspondence NNS 3237 47 31 across across IN 3237 47 32 inference inference NN 3237 47 33 patterns pattern NNS 3237 47 34 . . . 3237 48 1 When when WRB 3237 48 2 acti- acti- NNP 3237 48 3 vated vated NNP 3237 48 4 , , , 3237 48 5 a a DT 3237 48 6 mapping mapping NN 3237 48 7 may may MD 3237 48 8 apply apply VB 3237 48 9 to to IN 3237 48 10 a a DT 3237 48 11 novel novel JJ 3237 48 12 source source NN 3237 48 13 domain domain NN 3237 48 14 knowledge knowledge NN 3237 48 15 structure structure NN 3237 48 16 and and CC 3237 48 17 characterize characterize VB 3237 48 18 a a DT 3237 48 19 corresponding corresponding JJ 3237 48 20 target target NN 3237 48 21 domain domain NN 3237 48 22 knowledge knowledge NN 3237 48 23 structure.18 structure.18 NNP 3237 48 24 In in IN 3237 48 25 other other JJ 3237 48 26 words word NNS 3237 48 27 , , , 3237 48 28 each each DT 3237 48 29 pairing pairing NN 3237 48 30 creates create VBZ 3237 48 31 new new JJ 3237 48 32 meaning meaning NN 3237 48 33 or or CC 3237 48 34 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 48 35 frameworks framework NNS 3237 48 36 from from IN 3237 48 37 which which WDT 3237 48 38 other other JJ 3237 48 39 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 48 40 and and CC 3237 48 41 meanings meaning NNS 3237 48 42 can can MD 3237 48 43 be be VB 3237 48 44 instantiated instantiate VBN 3237 48 45 . . . 3237 49 1 A a DT 3237 49 2 is be VBZ 3237 49 3 to to IN 3237 49 4 B b NN 3237 49 5 creates create VBZ 3237 49 6 meaning mean VBG 3237 49 7 C c NN 3237 49 8 , , , 3237 49 9 rather rather RB 3237 49 10 than than IN 3237 49 11 A a NN 3237 49 12 and and CC 3237 49 13 B b NN 3237 49 14 are be VBP 3237 49 15 part part NN 3237 49 16 of of IN 3237 49 17 C. C. NNP 3237 49 18 Looking look VBG 3237 49 19 at at IN 3237 49 20 it -PRON- PRP 3237 49 21 from from IN 3237 49 22 the the DT 3237 49 23 perspective perspective NN 3237 49 24 of of IN 3237 49 25 Lanier Lanier NNP 3237 49 26 , , , 3237 49 27 a a DT 3237 49 28 vocabulary vocabulary NN 3237 49 29 is be VBZ 3237 49 30 created create VBN 3237 49 31 upon upon IN 3237 49 32 which which WDT 3237 49 33 we -PRON- PRP 3237 49 34 can can MD 3237 49 35 define define VB 3237 49 36 even even RB 3237 49 37 more more JJR 3237 49 38 vocabulary.19 vocabulary.19 NNP 3237 49 39 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 49 40 maintains maintain VBZ 3237 49 41 that that IN 3237 49 42 the the DT 3237 49 43 theory theory NN 3237 49 44 of of IN 3237 49 45 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 49 46 domains domain NNS 3237 49 47 speaks speak VBZ 3237 49 48 to to IN 3237 49 49 both both CC 3237 49 50 the the DT 3237 49 51 uni uni JJ 3237 49 52 - - HYPH 3237 49 53 directional directional JJ 3237 49 54 nature nature NN 3237 49 55 of of IN 3237 49 56 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 49 57 as as RB 3237 49 58 well well RB 3237 49 59 as as IN 3237 49 60 the the DT 3237 49 61 “ " `` 3237 49 62 syste- syste- NNP 3237 49 63 maticity maticity NNP 3237 49 64 ” " '' 3237 49 65 that that WDT 3237 49 66 allows allow VBZ 3237 49 67 the the DT 3237 49 68 interpreter interpreter NN 3237 49 69 to to TO 3237 49 70 selectively selectively RB 3237 49 71 identify identify VB 3237 49 72 the the DT 3237 49 73 aspects aspect NNS 3237 49 74 that that WDT 3237 49 75 are be VBP 3237 49 76 consistent consistent JJ 3237 49 77 and and CC 3237 49 78 discard discard VB 3237 49 79 the the DT 3237 49 80 aspects aspect NNS 3237 49 81 that that WDT 3237 49 82 are be VBP 3237 49 83 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 3237 49 84 with with IN 3237 49 85 the the DT 3237 49 86 metaphor.20 metaphor.20 NNP 3237 49 87 More more RBR 3237 49 88 recent recent JJ 3237 49 89 work work NN 3237 49 90 approaches approach VBZ 3237 49 91 the the DT 3237 49 92 question question NN 3237 49 93 from from IN 3237 49 94 a a DT 3237 49 95 connectivist connectivist NN 3237 49 96 point point NN 3237 49 97 of of IN 3237 49 98 view view NN 3237 49 99 , , , 3237 49 100 seeking seek VBG 3237 49 101 ways way NNS 3237 49 102 to to TO 3237 49 103 identify identify VB 3237 49 104 an an DT 3237 49 105 overarching overarching JJ 3237 49 106 model model NN 3237 49 107 consistent consistent JJ 3237 49 108 with with IN 3237 49 109 and and CC 3237 49 110 encompassing encompass VBG 3237 49 111 of of IN 3237 49 112 other other JJ 3237 49 113 theories theory NNS 3237 49 114 . . . 3237 50 1 This this DT 3237 50 2 premise premise NN 3237 50 3 rests rest VBZ 3237 50 4 on on IN 3237 50 5 the the DT 3237 50 6 foundation foundation NN 3237 50 7 of of IN 3237 50 8 metaphor metaphor NNP 3237 50 9 as as IN 3237 50 10 communication communication NN 3237 50 11 and and CC 3237 50 12 examines examine VBZ 3237 50 13 the the DT 3237 50 14 use use NN 3237 50 15 of of IN 3237 50 16 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 50 17 in in IN 3237 50 18 conversational conversational JJ 3237 50 19 contexts contexts NN 3237 50 20 . . . 3237 51 1 The the DT 3237 51 2 necessary necessary JJ 3237 51 3 mutual mutual JJ 3237 51 4 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 51 5 environment environment NN 3237 51 6 of of IN 3237 51 7 the the DT 3237 51 8 communicators communicator NNS 3237 51 9 , , , 3237 51 10 the the DT 3237 51 11 mEtaPHor mEtaPHor NNPS 3237 51 12 ’s ’s POS 3237 51 13 rolE rolE , 3237 51 14 in in IN 3237 51 15 tHE the DT 3237 51 16 inFormation information NN 3237 51 17 BEHavior behavior NN 3237 51 18 oF of IN 3237 51 19 Humans human NNS 3237 51 20 intEractinG interact VBZ 3237 51 21 witH with IN 3237 51 22 comPutErs computers CD 3237 51 23 | | CD 3237 51 24 sEasE sease CC 3237 51 25 11 11 CD 3237 51 26 working work VBG 3237 51 27 memory memory NN 3237 51 28 , , , 3237 51 29 and and CC 3237 51 30 the the DT 3237 51 31 common common JJ 3237 51 32 ground ground NN 3237 51 33 that that IN 3237 51 34 they -PRON- PRP 3237 51 35 find find VBP 3237 51 36 are be VBP 3237 51 37 all all DT 3237 51 38 of of IN 3237 51 39 importance importance NN 3237 51 40 , , , 3237 51 41 but but CC 3237 51 42 so so RB 3237 51 43 are be VBP 3237 51 44 context context NN 3237 51 45 and and CC 3237 51 46 motivation motivation NN 3237 51 47 as as IN 3237 51 48 influencing influence VBG 3237 51 49 factors factor NNS 3237 51 50 . . . 3237 52 1 The the DT 3237 52 2 context context NN 3237 52 3 in in IN 3237 52 4 which which WDT 3237 52 5 the the DT 3237 52 6 statement statement NN 3237 52 7 is be VBZ 3237 52 8 made make VBN 3237 52 9 , , , 3237 52 10 the the DT 3237 52 11 place place NN 3237 52 12 in in IN 3237 52 13 which which WDT 3237 52 14 it -PRON- PRP 3237 52 15 is be VBZ 3237 52 16 interpreted interpret VBN 3237 52 17 , , , 3237 52 18 and and CC 3237 52 19 the the DT 3237 52 20 moti- moti- JJ 3237 52 21 vation vation NN 3237 52 22 of of IN 3237 52 23 the the DT 3237 52 24 user user NN 3237 52 25 to to TO 3237 52 26 understand understand VB 3237 52 27 the the DT 3237 52 28 statement statement NN 3237 52 29 combine combine VB 3237 52 30 to to TO 3237 52 31 affect affect VB 3237 52 32 the the DT 3237 52 33 meaning meaning NN 3237 52 34 that that WDT 3237 52 35 is be VBZ 3237 52 36 derived derive VBN 3237 52 37 . . . 3237 53 1 For for IN 3237 53 2 instance instance NN 3237 53 3 , , , 3237 53 4 the the DT 3237 53 5 phrase phrase NN 3237 53 6 , , , 3237 53 7 “ " `` 3237 53 8 I -PRON- PRP 3237 53 9 want want VBP 3237 53 10 you -PRON- PRP 3237 53 11 to to TO 3237 53 12 sheepdog sheepdog VB 3237 53 13 this this DT 3237 53 14 project project NN 3237 53 15 ” " '' 3237 53 16 could could MD 3237 53 17 mean mean VB 3237 53 18 something something NN 3237 53 19 different different JJ 3237 53 20 in in IN 3237 53 21 the the DT 3237 53 22 context context NN 3237 53 23 of of IN 3237 53 24 a a DT 3237 53 25 chaotic chaotic JJ 3237 53 26 group group NN 3237 53 27 of of IN 3237 53 28 workers worker NNS 3237 53 29 than than IN 3237 53 30 in in IN 3237 53 31 the the DT 3237 53 32 context context NN 3237 53 33 of of IN 3237 53 34 a a DT 3237 53 35 core core NN 3237 53 36 team team NN 3237 53 37 threatened threaten VBN 3237 53 38 by by IN 3237 53 39 competing compete VBG 3237 53 40 entities.21 entities.21 NNP 3237 53 41 Likewise likewise RB 3237 53 42 , , , 3237 53 43 the the DT 3237 53 44 relationship relationship NN 3237 53 45 of of IN 3237 53 46 the the DT 3237 53 47 receiver receiver NN 3237 53 48 to to IN 3237 53 49 the the DT 3237 53 50 sender sender NN 3237 53 51 could could MD 3237 53 52 modify modify VB 3237 53 53 the the DT 3237 53 54 motivation motivation NN 3237 53 55 of of IN 3237 53 56 the the DT 3237 53 57 receiver receiver NN 3237 53 58 to to TO 3237 53 59 seek seek VB 3237 53 60 meaning meaning NN 3237 53 61 beyond beyond IN 3237 53 62 the the DT 3237 53 63 first first JJ 3237 53 64 or or CC 3237 53 65 easiest easy JJS 3237 53 66 interpretation interpretation NN 3237 53 67 . . . 3237 54 1 n n LS 3237 54 2 Classifying Classifying NNP 3237 54 3 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 54 4 : : : 3237 54 5 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 54 6 in in IN 3237 54 7 information information NN 3237 54 8 science science NN 3237 54 9 These these DT 3237 54 10 notions notion NNS 3237 54 11 of of IN 3237 54 12 context context NN 3237 54 13 and and CC 3237 54 14 user user NN 3237 54 15 - - HYPH 3237 54 16 motivation motivation NN 3237 54 17 are be VBP 3237 54 18 not not RB 3237 54 19 new new JJ 3237 54 20 to to IN 3237 54 21 the the DT 3237 54 22 field field NN 3237 54 23 of of IN 3237 54 24 information information NN 3237 54 25 science science NN 3237 54 26 . . . 3237 55 1 At at IN 3237 55 2 the the DT 3237 55 3 turn turn NN 3237 55 4 of of IN 3237 55 5 the the DT 3237 55 6 cen- cen- NN 3237 55 7 tury tury NN 3237 55 8 the the DT 3237 55 9 subfield subfield NN 3237 55 10 of of IN 3237 55 11 information information NN 3237 55 12 behavior behavior NN 3237 55 13 had have VBD 3237 55 14 begun begin VBN 3237 55 15 to to TO 3237 55 16 direct direct VB 3237 55 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 3237 55 18 attention attention NN 3237 55 19 to to IN 3237 55 20 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 55 21 psychology psychology NN 3237 55 22 , , , 3237 55 23 the the DT 3237 55 24 nature nature NN 3237 55 25 of of IN 3237 55 26 man man NN 3237 55 27 – – : 3237 55 28 machine machine NN 3237 55 29 dialogue dialogue NN 3237 55 30 , , , 3237 55 31 and and CC 3237 55 32 to to IN 3237 55 33 a a DT 3237 55 34 certain certain JJ 3237 55 35 extent extent NN 3237 55 36 the the DT 3237 55 37 role role NN 3237 55 38 of of IN 3237 55 39 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 55 40 in in IN 3237 55 41 deciphering deciphering NN 3237 55 42 and and CC 3237 55 43 creating create VBG 3237 55 44 meaning meaning NN 3237 55 45 . . . 3237 56 1 Spink spink NN 3237 56 2 investigates investigate VBZ 3237 56 3 human human JJ 3237 56 4 information information NN 3237 56 5 behavior behavior NN 3237 56 6 ( ( -LRB- 3237 56 7 HIB HIB NNP 3237 56 8 ) ) -RRB- 3237 56 9 from from IN 3237 56 10 an an DT 3237 56 11 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 3237 56 12 perspective.22 perspective.22 NNP 3237 56 13 After after IN 3237 56 14 exploring explore VBG 3237 56 15 a a DT 3237 56 16 wide wide JJ 3237 56 17 variety variety NN 3237 56 18 of of IN 3237 56 19 research research NN 3237 56 20 in in IN 3237 56 21 fields field NNS 3237 56 22 , , , 3237 56 23 Spink Spink NNP 3237 56 24 and and CC 3237 56 25 Currier Currier NNP 3237 56 26 per- per- RB 3237 56 27 formed form VBD 3237 56 28 a a DT 3237 56 29 qualitative qualitative JJ 3237 56 30 analysis analysis NN 3237 56 31 of of IN 3237 56 32 the the DT 3237 56 33 information information NN 3237 56 34 behavior behavior NN 3237 56 35 of of IN 3237 56 36 historical historical JJ 3237 56 37 figures figure NNS 3237 56 38 . . . 3237 57 1 They -PRON- PRP 3237 57 2 postulated postulate VBD 3237 57 3 that that IN 3237 57 4 modular modular JJ 3237 57 5 cogni- cogni- NN 3237 57 6 tive tive JJ 3237 57 7 architecture architecture NN 3237 57 8 makes make VBZ 3237 57 9 Homo Homo NNP 3237 57 10 sapiens sapiens VB 3237 57 11 rare rare JJ 3237 57 12 in in IN 3237 57 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 57 14 ability ability NN 3237 57 15 to to TO 3237 57 16 think think VB 3237 57 17 of of IN 3237 57 18 one one CD 3237 57 19 thing thing NN 3237 57 20 in in IN 3237 57 21 terms term NNS 3237 57 22 of of IN 3237 57 23 another.23 another.23 NNP 3237 57 24 The the DT 3237 57 25 resulting result VBG 3237 57 26 mapping mapping NN 3237 57 27 allows allow VBZ 3237 57 28 for for IN 3237 57 29 the the DT 3237 57 30 creation creation NN 3237 57 31 of of IN 3237 57 32 new new JJ 3237 57 33 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 57 34 struc- struc- JJ 3237 57 35 tures ture NNS 3237 57 36 in in IN 3237 57 37 a a DT 3237 57 38 similar similar JJ 3237 57 39 fashion fashion NN 3237 57 40 to to IN 3237 57 41 Lanier Lanier NNP 3237 57 42 ’s ’s POS 3237 57 43 vocabulary vocabulary NN 3237 57 44 develop- develop- VBZ 3237 57 45 ment ment JJ 3237 57 46 conjecture conjecture NN 3237 57 47 . . . 3237 58 1 Spink Spink NNP 3237 58 2 and and CC 3237 58 3 Currier Currier NNP 3237 58 4 ’s ’s POS 3237 58 5 work work NN 3237 58 6 launched launch VBD 3237 58 7 a a DT 3237 58 8 new new JJ 3237 58 9 theory theory NN 3237 58 10 of of IN 3237 58 11 information information NN 3237 58 12 use use NN 3237 58 13 , , , 3237 58 14 which which WDT 3237 58 15 has have VBZ 3237 58 16 led lead VBN 3237 58 17 to to IN 3237 58 18 recent recent JJ 3237 58 19 research research NN 3237 58 20 into into IN 3237 58 21 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 58 22 use use NN 3237 58 23 . . . 3237 59 1 In in IN 3237 59 2 an an DT 3237 59 3 attempt attempt NN 3237 59 4 to to TO 3237 59 5 model model VB 3237 59 6 an an DT 3237 59 7 integrative integrative JJ 3237 59 8 approach approach NN 3237 59 9 to to IN 3237 59 10 human human JJ 3237 59 11 information information NN 3237 59 12 behav- behav- NN 3237 59 13 ior ior NNP 3237 59 14 incorporating incorporate VBG 3237 59 15 the the DT 3237 59 16 everyday everyday JJ 3237 59 17 life life NN 3237 59 18 information information NN 3237 59 19 - - HYPH 3237 59 20 seeking seeking NN 3237 59 21 and and CC 3237 59 22 sense sense NN 3237 59 23 - - HYPH 3237 59 24 making make VBG 3237 59 25 approach approach NN 3237 59 26 , , , 3237 59 27 the the DT 3237 59 28 information information NN 3237 59 29 - - HYPH 3237 59 30 foraging forage VBG 3237 59 31 approach approach NN 3237 59 32 , , , 3237 59 33 and and CC 3237 59 34 the the DT 3237 59 35 problem problem NN 3237 59 36 - - HYPH 3237 59 37 solution solution NN 3237 59 38 view view NN 3237 59 39 of of IN 3237 59 40 information information NN 3237 59 41 seeking seek VBG 3237 59 42 , , , 3237 59 43 Spink Spink NNP 3237 59 44 and and CC 3237 59 45 Cole Cole NNP 3237 59 46 recognized recognize VBD 3237 59 47 a a DT 3237 59 48 gap gap NN 3237 59 49 in in IN 3237 59 50 the the DT 3237 59 51 research research NN 3237 59 52 covering cover VBG 3237 59 53 actual actual JJ 3237 59 54 information information NN 3237 59 55 use use NN 3237 59 56 and and CC 3237 59 57 proffered proffer VBD 3237 59 58 a a DT 3237 59 59 fourth fourth JJ 3237 59 60 information information NN 3237 59 61 approach approach NN 3237 59 62 to to TO 3237 59 63 account account VB 3237 59 64 for for IN 3237 59 65 it -PRON- PRP 3237 59 66 . . . 3237 60 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 60 2 informa- informa- JJ 3237 60 3 tion tion NN 3237 60 4 - - HYPH 3237 60 5 use use NN 3237 60 6 theory theory NN 3237 60 7 “ " '' 3237 60 8 starts start VBZ 3237 60 9 from from IN 3237 60 10 an an DT 3237 60 11 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 3237 60 12 psychology psychology NN 3237 60 13 notion notion NN 3237 60 14 that that IN 3237 60 15 humans human NNS 3237 60 16 are be VBP 3237 60 17 able able JJ 3237 60 18 to to TO 3237 60 19 adapt adapt VB 3237 60 20 to to IN 3237 60 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 60 22 environment environment NN 3237 60 23 and and CC 3237 60 24 survive survive VB 3237 60 25 because because IN 3237 60 26 of of IN 3237 60 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 60 28 modular modular JJ 3237 60 29 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 60 30 architec- architec- NN 3237 60 31 ture ture NN 3237 60 32 . . . 3237 60 33 ”24 ”24 NNP 3237 60 34 Development development NN 3237 60 35 of of IN 3237 60 36 this this DT 3237 60 37 theory theory NN 3237 60 38 has have VBZ 3237 60 39 birthed birth VBN 3237 60 40 a a DT 3237 60 41 sub sub NN 3237 60 42 - - HYPH 3237 60 43 area area NN 3237 60 44 within within IN 3237 60 45 the the DT 3237 60 46 field field NN 3237 60 47 of of IN 3237 60 48 human human JJ 3237 60 49 information information NN 3237 60 50 behavior behavior NN 3237 60 51 dubbed dub VBD 3237 60 52 human human JJ 3237 60 53 information information NN 3237 60 54 organizing organize VBG 3237 60 55 behavior behavior NN 3237 60 56 ( ( -LRB- 3237 60 57 HIOB HIOB NNP 3237 60 58 ) ) -RRB- 3237 60 59 of of IN 3237 60 60 which which WDT 3237 60 61 the the DT 3237 60 62 use use NN 3237 60 63 of of IN 3237 60 64 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 60 65 or or CC 3237 60 66 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 60 67 instantiation instantiation NN 3237 60 68 is be VBZ 3237 60 69 a a DT 3237 60 70 neces- neces- JJ 3237 60 71 sary sary JJ 3237 60 72 component component NN 3237 60 73 . . . 3237 61 1 Cole Cole NNP 3237 61 2 and and CC 3237 61 3 Leide Leide NNP 3237 61 4 explore explore VBP 3237 61 5 the the DT 3237 61 6 notion notion NN 3237 61 7 of of IN 3237 61 8 modular modular JJ 3237 61 9 cog- cog- JJ 3237 61 10 nitive nitive JJ 3237 61 11 architecture architecture NN 3237 61 12 in in IN 3237 61 13 an an DT 3237 61 14 attempt attempt NN 3237 61 15 to to TO 3237 61 16 model model VB 3237 61 17 a a DT 3237 61 18 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 61 19 framework framework NN 3237 61 20 for for IN 3237 61 21 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 61 22 use use NN 3237 61 23 in in IN 3237 61 24 HIOB HIOB NNP 3237 61 25 . . . 3237 62 1 Similar similar JJ 3237 62 2 to to IN 3237 62 3 the the DT 3237 62 4 categorization categorization NN 3237 62 5 theory theory NN 3237 62 6 of of IN 3237 62 7 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 62 8 use use NN 3237 62 9 , , , 3237 62 10 they -PRON- PRP 3237 62 11 claim claim VBP 3237 62 12 that that IN 3237 62 13 “ " `` 3237 62 14 metaphor metaphor NNP 3237 62 15 instantiation instantiation NN 3237 62 16 is be VBZ 3237 62 17 similar similar JJ 3237 62 18 to to IN 3237 62 19 a a DT 3237 62 20 form form NN 3237 62 21 of of IN 3237 62 22 super- super- NNP 3237 62 23 ordinate ordinate NNP 3237 62 24 category category NNP 3237 62 25 instantiation instantiation NN 3237 62 26 . . . 3237 63 1 . . . 3237 64 1 . . . 3237 65 1 along along IN 3237 65 2 with with IN 3237 65 3 the the DT 3237 65 4 meta- meta- JJ 3237 65 5 phor phor NN 3237 65 6 comes come VBZ 3237 65 7 the the DT 3237 65 8 structure structure NN 3237 65 9 of of IN 3237 65 10 the the DT 3237 65 11 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 65 12 . . . 3237 65 13 ”25 ”25 JJ 3237 65 14 Following follow VBG 3237 65 15 in in IN 3237 65 16 Belkin Belkin NNP 3237 65 17 ’s ’s POS 3237 65 18 footsteps footstep NNS 3237 65 19 , , , 3237 65 20 they -PRON- PRP 3237 65 21 address address VBP 3237 65 22 the the DT 3237 65 23 problem problem NN 3237 65 24 of of IN 3237 65 25 a a DT 3237 65 26 “ " `` 3237 65 27 domain domain NN 3237 65 28 novice novice NN 3237 65 29 attempting attempt VBG 3237 65 30 to to TO 3237 65 31 formulate formulate VB 3237 65 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 3237 65 33 information information NN 3237 65 34 need need VBP 3237 65 35 into into IN 3237 65 36 an an DT 3237 65 37 effective effective JJ 3237 65 38 query query NN 3237 65 39 to to IN 3237 65 40 an an DT 3237 65 41 information information NN 3237 65 42 retrieval retrieval NN 3237 65 43 system system NN 3237 65 44 . . . 3237 65 45 ”26 ”26 NNP 3237 65 46 They -PRON- PRP 3237 65 47 conducted conduct VBD 3237 65 48 three three CD 3237 65 49 case case NN 3237 65 50 studies study NNS 3237 65 51 with with IN 3237 65 52 the the DT 3237 65 53 purpose purpose NN 3237 65 54 of of IN 3237 65 55 developing develop VBG 3237 65 56 a a DT 3237 65 57 methodology methodology NN 3237 65 58 that that WDT 3237 65 59 researchers researcher NNS 3237 65 60 can can MD 3237 65 61 use use VB 3237 65 62 to to TO 3237 65 63 “ " `` 3237 65 64 ascertain ascertain VB 3237 65 65 the the DT 3237 65 66 efficacy efficacy NN 3237 65 67 of of IN 3237 65 68 metaphor metaphor NNP 3237 65 69 instantia- instantia- NNP 3237 65 70 tion tion NN 3237 65 71 as as IN 3237 65 72 an an DT 3237 65 73 information information NN 3237 65 74 need need VBP 3237 65 75 structuring structure VBG 3237 65 76 device device NN 3237 65 77 . . . 3237 65 78 ”27 ”27 UH 3237 65 79 They -PRON- PRP 3237 65 80 conclude conclude VBP 3237 65 81 that that DT 3237 65 82 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 65 83 instantiation instantiation NN 3237 65 84 might may MD 3237 65 85 help help VB 3237 65 86 us -PRON- PRP 3237 65 87 create create VB 3237 65 88 systems system NNS 3237 65 89 that that WDT 3237 65 90 more more RBR 3237 65 91 closely closely RB 3237 65 92 resemble resemble JJ 3237 65 93 the the DT 3237 65 94 way way NN 3237 65 95 that that WDT 3237 65 96 humans human NNS 3237 65 97 behave behave VBP 3237 65 98 with with IN 3237 65 99 information information NN 3237 65 100 : : : 3237 65 101 interaction interaction NN 3237 65 102 , , , 3237 65 103 organization organization NN 3237 65 104 , , , 3237 65 105 and and CC 3237 65 106 retrieval retrieval NN 3237 65 107 . . . 3237 66 1 n n NNP 3237 66 2 Metaphors Metaphors NNP 3237 66 3 in in IN 3237 66 4 human human NN 3237 66 5 – – : 3237 66 6 computer computer NN 3237 66 7 interaction interaction NN 3237 66 8 : : : 3237 66 9 a a DT 3237 66 10 case case NN 3237 66 11 study study NN 3237 66 12 reality reality NN 3237 66 13 bytes byte NNS 3237 66 14 While while IN 3237 66 15 theorists theorist NNS 3237 66 16 of of IN 3237 66 17 various various JJ 3237 66 18 fields field NNS 3237 66 19 explored explore VBD 3237 66 20 the the DT 3237 66 21 nature nature NN 3237 66 22 of of IN 3237 66 23 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 66 24 , , , 3237 66 25 the the DT 3237 66 26 field field NN 3237 66 27 of of IN 3237 66 28 human human NN 3237 66 29 – – : 3237 66 30 computer computer NN 3237 66 31 interaction interaction NN 3237 66 32 ( ( -LRB- 3237 66 33 HCI HCI NNP 3237 66 34 ) ) -RRB- 3237 66 35 found find VBD 3237 66 36 itself -PRON- PRP 3237 66 37 thrust thrust VBN 3237 66 38 into into IN 3237 66 39 the the DT 3237 66 40 thick thick JJ 3237 66 41 of of IN 3237 66 42 it -PRON- PRP 3237 66 43 . . . 3237 67 1 Rarely rarely RB 3237 67 2 does do VBZ 3237 67 3 one one NN 3237 67 4 intentionally intentionally RB 3237 67 5 adopt adopt VB 3237 67 6 new new JJ 3237 67 7 ideas idea NNS 3237 67 8 so so RB 3237 67 9 whole whole RB 3237 67 10 - - : 3237 67 11 heartedly heartedly RB 3237 67 12 without without IN 3237 67 13 first first RB 3237 67 14 considering consider VBG 3237 67 15 the the DT 3237 67 16 ramifications ramification NNS 3237 67 17 , , , 3237 67 18 but but CC 3237 67 19 the the DT 3237 67 20 history history NN 3237 67 21 of of IN 3237 67 22 HCI HCI NNP 3237 67 23 shows show VBZ 3237 67 24 that that IN 3237 67 25 that that DT 3237 67 26 is be VBZ 3237 67 27 exactly exactly RB 3237 67 28 what what WP 3237 67 29 happened happen VBD 3237 67 30 . . . 3237 68 1 It -PRON- PRP 3237 68 2 began begin VBD 3237 68 3 with with IN 3237 68 4 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 3237 68 5 adoption adoption NN 3237 68 6 to to TO 3237 68 7 improve improve VB 3237 68 8 communication communication NN 3237 68 9 , , , 3237 68 10 then then RB 3237 68 11 reeled reel VBN 3237 68 12 in in IN 3237 68 13 recognition recognition NN 3237 68 14 of of IN 3237 68 15 the the DT 3237 68 16 drawbacks drawback NNS 3237 68 17 of of IN 3237 68 18 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 68 19 mismatches mismatch NNS 3237 68 20 , , , 3237 68 21 and and CC 3237 68 22 finally finally RB 3237 68 23 has have VBZ 3237 68 24 lurched lurch VBN 3237 68 25 to to IN 3237 68 26 a a DT 3237 68 27 standstill standstill NN 3237 68 28 while while IN 3237 68 29 new new JJ 3237 68 30 approaches approach NNS 3237 68 31 to to TO 3237 68 32 metaphor metaphor VB 3237 68 33 use use NN 3237 68 34 are be VBP 3237 68 35 explored explore VBN 3237 68 36 . . . 3237 69 1 The the DT 3237 69 2 first first JJ 3237 69 3 instances instance NNS 3237 69 4 of of IN 3237 69 5 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 69 6 and and CC 3237 69 7 analogy analogy NN 3237 69 8 in in IN 3237 69 9 the the DT 3237 69 10 field field NN 3237 69 11 of of IN 3237 69 12 computer computer NN 3237 69 13 science science NN 3237 69 14 and and CC 3237 69 15 HCI HCI NNP 3237 69 16 preceded precede VBD 3237 69 17 images image NNS 3237 69 18 of of IN 3237 69 19 windows window NNS 3237 69 20 , , , 3237 69 21 desktops desktop NNS 3237 69 22 , , , 3237 69 23 mice mouse NNS 3237 69 24 , , , 3237 69 25 scrollbars scrollbar NNS 3237 69 26 , , , 3237 69 27 and and CC 3237 69 28 icons icon NNS 3237 69 29 . . . 3237 70 1 The the DT 3237 70 2 ini- ini- DT 3237 70 3 tial tial JJ 3237 70 4 focus focus NN 3237 70 5 was be VBD 3237 70 6 on on IN 3237 70 7 natural natural JJ 3237 70 8 language language NN 3237 70 9 processing processing NN 3237 70 10 to to TO 3237 70 11 improve improve VB 3237 70 12 the the DT 3237 70 13 communication communication NN 3237 70 14 between between IN 3237 70 15 the the DT 3237 70 16 user user NN 3237 70 17 and and CC 3237 70 18 the the DT 3237 70 19 system.28 system.28 NNP 3237 70 20 Although although IN 3237 70 21 the the DT 3237 70 22 field field NN 3237 70 23 of of IN 3237 70 24 information information NN 3237 70 25 science science NN 3237 70 26 was be VBD 3237 70 27 on on IN 3237 70 28 the the DT 3237 70 29 periphery periphery NN 3237 70 30 of of IN 3237 70 31 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 70 32 research research NN 3237 70 33 at at IN 3237 70 34 the the DT 3237 70 35 time time NN 3237 70 36 , , , 3237 70 37 it -PRON- PRP 3237 70 38 certainly certainly RB 3237 70 39 was be VBD 3237 70 40 interested interested JJ 3237 70 41 in in IN 3237 70 42 improving improve VBG 3237 70 43 the the DT 3237 70 44 dialogue dialogue NN 3237 70 45 between between IN 3237 70 46 users user NNS 3237 70 47 and and CC 3237 70 48 systems system NNS 3237 70 49 . . . 3237 71 1 Belkin Belkin NNP 3237 71 2 proposed propose VBD 3237 71 3 a a DT 3237 71 4 model model NN 3237 71 5 of of IN 3237 71 6 information information NN 3237 71 7 seeking seek VBG 3237 71 8 that that WDT 3237 71 9 highlighted highlight VBD 3237 71 10 the the DT 3237 71 11 user user NN 3237 71 12 ’s 's POS 3237 71 13 anomalous anomalous JJ 3237 71 14 state state NN 3237 71 15 of of IN 3237 71 16 knowledge knowledge NN 3237 71 17 . . . 3237 72 1 He -PRON- PRP 3237 72 2 argued argue VBD 3237 72 3 for for IN 3237 72 4 a a DT 3237 72 5 better well JJR 3237 72 6 understanding understanding NN 3237 72 7 of of IN 3237 72 8 user user NN 3237 72 9 ’s ’s POS 3237 72 10 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 72 11 models model NNS 3237 72 12 in in IN 3237 72 13 order order NN 3237 72 14 to to TO 3237 72 15 improve improve VB 3237 72 16 sys- sys- RB 3237 72 17 tem tem NN 3237 72 18 communications.29 communications.29 NNP 3237 72 19 Although although IN 3237 72 20 he -PRON- PRP 3237 72 21 did do VBD 3237 72 22 not not RB 3237 72 23 propose propose VB 3237 72 24 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 72 25 specifically specifically RB 3237 72 26 , , , 3237 72 27 the the DT 3237 72 28 advent advent NN 3237 72 29 of of IN 3237 72 30 the the DT 3237 72 31 graphical graphical JJ 3237 72 32 user user NN 3237 72 33 interface interface NN 3237 72 34 ( ( -LRB- 3237 72 35 GUI GUI NNP 3237 72 36 ) ) -RRB- 3237 72 37 placed place VBD 3237 72 38 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 72 39 in in IN 3237 72 40 a a DT 3237 72 41 position position NN 3237 72 42 to to TO 3237 72 43 tackle tackle VB 3237 72 44 Belkin Belkin NNP 3237 72 45 ’s ’s POS 3237 72 46 concerns concern NNS 3237 72 47 . . . 3237 73 1 Hci Hci NNP 3237 73 2 Gets get VBZ 3237 73 3 Gui Gui NNP 3237 73 4 Perhaps perhaps RB 3237 73 5 because because IN 3237 73 6 of of IN 3237 73 7 the the DT 3237 73 8 difficulty difficulty NN 3237 73 9 of of IN 3237 73 10 man man NN 3237 73 11 – – : 3237 73 12 machine machine NN 3237 73 13 dia- dia- NNP 3237 73 14 logue logue NNP 3237 73 15 , , , 3237 73 16 GUIs GUIs NNP 3237 73 17 emerged emerge VBD 3237 73 18 . . . 3237 74 1 By by IN 3237 74 2 simplifying simplify VBG 3237 74 3 the the DT 3237 74 4 “ " `` 3237 74 5 language language NN 3237 74 6 ” " '' 3237 74 7 to to TO 3237 74 8 “ " `` 3237 74 9 point point VB 3237 74 10 and and CC 3237 74 11 click click NN 3237 74 12 , , , 3237 74 13 ” " '' 3237 74 14 even even RB 3237 74 15 an an DT 3237 74 16 average average JJ 3237 74 17 user user NN 3237 74 18 could could MD 3237 74 19 make make VB 3237 74 20 the the DT 3237 74 21 system system NN 3237 74 22 do do VB 3237 74 23 what what WP 3237 74 24 it -PRON- PRP 3237 74 25 was be VBD 3237 74 26 supposed suppose VBN 3237 74 27 to to IN 3237 74 28 do.30 do.30 NNP 3237 74 29 With with IN 3237 74 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 3237 74 31 more more RBR 3237 74 32 intuitive intuitive JJ 3237 74 33 and and CC 3237 74 34 memorable memorable JJ 3237 74 35 interface interface NN 3237 74 36 , , , 3237 74 37 the the DT 3237 74 38 GUI GUI NNP 3237 74 39 was be VBD 3237 74 40 the the DT 3237 74 41 12 12 CD 3237 74 42 inFormation inFormation NNP 3237 74 43 tEcHnoloGY technology NN 3237 74 44 anD and CC 3237 74 45 liBrariEs libraries NN 3237 74 46 | | NNP 3237 74 47 DEcEmBEr DEcEmBEr NNP 3237 74 48 2008 2008 CD 3237 74 49 result result NN 3237 74 50 of of IN 3237 74 51 years year NNS 3237 74 52 of of IN 3237 74 53 frustration frustration NN 3237 74 54 trying try VBG 3237 74 55 to to TO 3237 74 56 remember remember VB 3237 74 57 system system NN 3237 74 58 functions function NNS 3237 74 59 and and CC 3237 74 60 commands command NNS 3237 74 61 . . . 3237 75 1 Because because IN 3237 75 2 illustrations illustration NNS 3237 75 3 of of IN 3237 75 4 the the DT 3237 75 5 abstract abstract JJ 3237 75 6 are be VBP 3237 75 7 necessarily necessarily RB 3237 75 8 grounded ground VBN 3237 75 9 in in IN 3237 75 10 something something NN 3237 75 11 concrete concrete NN 3237 75 12 , , , 3237 75 13 GUIs gui NNS 3237 75 14 and and CC 3237 75 15 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 75 16 were be VBD 3237 75 17 inexorably inexorably RB 3237 75 18 intertwined intertwine VBN 3237 75 19 ; ; : 3237 75 20 in in IN 3237 75 21 a a DT 3237 75 22 sense sense NN 3237 75 23 , , , 3237 75 24 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 75 25 were be VBD 3237 75 26 “ " `` 3237 75 27 inescapable inescapable JJ 3237 75 28 . . . 3237 75 29 ”31 ”31 '' 3237 75 30 Metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 75 31 enacted enact VBD 3237 75 32 through through IN 3237 75 33 the the DT 3237 75 34 user user NN 3237 75 35 interface interface NN 3237 75 36 would would MD 3237 75 37 become become VB 3237 75 38 the the DT 3237 75 39 primary primary JJ 3237 75 40 mechanism mechanism NN 3237 75 41 of of IN 3237 75 42 communication communication NN 3237 75 43 between between IN 3237 75 44 the the DT 3237 75 45 user user NN 3237 75 46 and and CC 3237 75 47 the the DT 3237 75 48 system system NN 3237 75 49 . . . 3237 76 1 GUI GUI NNP 3237 76 2 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 76 3 can can MD 3237 76 4 be be VB 3237 76 5 categorized categorize VBN 3237 76 6 several several JJ 3237 76 7 ways way NNS 3237 76 8 . . . 3237 77 1 A a DT 3237 77 2 typical typical JJ 3237 77 3 breakdown breakdown NN 3237 77 4 is be VBZ 3237 77 5 to to TO 3237 77 6 break break VB 3237 77 7 out out RP 3237 77 8 noun noun JJ 3237 77 9 and and CC 3237 77 10 verb verb JJ 3237 77 11 meta- meta- JJ 3237 77 12 phors phor NNS 3237 77 13 into into IN 3237 77 14 “ " `` 3237 77 15 organization organization NN 3237 77 16 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 77 17 ” " '' 3237 77 18 and and CC 3237 77 19 “ " `` 3237 77 20 operations operation NNS 3237 77 21 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 77 22 . . . 3237 77 23 ”32 ”32 NNP 3237 77 24 Alternatively alternatively RB 3237 77 25 , , , 3237 77 26 Fineman Fineman NNP 3237 77 27 further further RB 3237 77 28 divides divide VBZ 3237 77 29 the the DT 3237 77 30 nouns noun NNS 3237 77 31 and and CC 3237 77 32 classifies classify VBZ 3237 77 33 various various JJ 3237 77 34 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 77 35 into into IN 3237 77 36 three three CD 3237 77 37 basic basic JJ 3237 77 38 types type NNS 3237 77 39 : : : 3237 77 40 functionality functionality NN 3237 77 41 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 77 42 , , , 3237 77 43 interface interface NN 3237 77 44 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 77 45 , , , 3237 77 46 and and CC 3237 77 47 interaction interaction NN 3237 77 48 metaphors.33 metaphors.33 NNP 3237 77 49 Fineman Fineman NNP 3237 77 50 describes describe VBZ 3237 77 51 an an DT 3237 77 52 e e NN 3237 77 53 - - NN 3237 77 54 mail mail NN 3237 77 55 program program NN 3237 77 56 . . . 3237 78 1 Functionality functionality NN 3237 78 2 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 78 3 outline outline VBP 3237 78 4 the the DT 3237 78 5 expecta- expecta- JJ 3237 78 6 tions tion NNS 3237 78 7 that that IN 3237 78 8 a a DT 3237 78 9 user user NN 3237 78 10 should should MD 3237 78 11 have have VB 3237 78 12 for for IN 3237 78 13 an an DT 3237 78 14 application application NN 3237 78 15 and and CC 3237 78 16 gen- gen- NN 3237 78 17 erally erally RB 3237 78 18 guide guide VB 3237 78 19 the the DT 3237 78 20 overall overall JJ 3237 78 21 behavior behavior NN 3237 78 22 of of IN 3237 78 23 the the DT 3237 78 24 tool tool NN 3237 78 25 . . . 3237 79 1 In in IN 3237 79 2 the the DT 3237 79 3 e e NN 3237 79 4 - - NN 3237 79 5 mail mail NN 3237 79 6 program program NN 3237 79 7 the the DT 3237 79 8 functionality functionality NN 3237 79 9 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 79 10 would would MD 3237 79 11 be be VB 3237 79 12 “ " `` 3237 79 13 e e NN 3237 79 14 - - NN 3237 79 15 mail mail NN 3237 79 16 is be VBZ 3237 79 17 postal postal JJ 3237 79 18 mail mail NN 3237 79 19 . . . 3237 79 20 ” " '' 3237 79 21 Interface interface NN 3237 79 22 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 79 23 are be VBP 3237 79 24 the the DT 3237 79 25 mechanical mechanical JJ 3237 79 26 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 79 27 that that WDT 3237 79 28 allow allow VBP 3237 79 29 the the DT 3237 79 30 user user NN 3237 79 31 to to TO 3237 79 32 accomplish accomplish VB 3237 79 33 the the DT 3237 79 34 tasks task NNS 3237 79 35 within within IN 3237 79 36 the the DT 3237 79 37 functionality functionality NN 3237 79 38 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 79 39 . . . 3237 80 1 The the DT 3237 80 2 interface interface NN 3237 80 3 meta- meta- NN 3237 80 4 phors phor NNS 3237 80 5 should should MD 3237 80 6 be be VB 3237 80 7 guided guide VBN 3237 80 8 by by IN 3237 80 9 the the DT 3237 80 10 functionality functionality NN 3237 80 11 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 80 12 , , , 3237 80 13 but but CC 3237 80 14 not not RB 3237 80 15 constrained constrain VBN 3237 80 16 by by IN 3237 80 17 them -PRON- PRP 3237 80 18 . . . 3237 81 1 Examples example NNS 3237 81 2 would would MD 3237 81 3 include include VB 3237 81 4 the the DT 3237 81 5 address address NN 3237 81 6 book book NN 3237 81 7 and and CC 3237 81 8 printer printer NN 3237 81 9 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 81 10 . . . 3237 82 1 Interaction interaction NN 3237 82 2 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 82 3 , , , 3237 82 4 or or CC 3237 82 5 the the DT 3237 82 6 verbs verb NNS 3237 82 7 , , , 3237 82 8 are be VBP 3237 82 9 the the DT 3237 82 10 underlying underlie VBG 3237 82 11 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 82 12 that that WDT 3237 82 13 define define VBP 3237 82 14 the the DT 3237 82 15 form form NN 3237 82 16 of of IN 3237 82 17 the the DT 3237 82 18 action action NN 3237 82 19 , , , 3237 82 20 how how WRB 3237 82 21 things thing NNS 3237 82 22 are be VBP 3237 82 23 per- per- RB 3237 82 24 formed form VBN 3237 82 25 ; ; : 3237 82 26 these these DT 3237 82 27 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 82 28 span span VBP 3237 82 29 beyond beyond IN 3237 82 30 a a DT 3237 82 31 particular particular JJ 3237 82 32 tool tool NN 3237 82 33 , , , 3237 82 34 but but CC 3237 82 35 greatly greatly RB 3237 82 36 affect affect VB 3237 82 37 the the DT 3237 82 38 functionality functionality NN 3237 82 39 metaphor.34 metaphor.34 NNP 3237 82 40 The the DT 3237 82 41 effect effect NN 3237 82 42 of of IN 3237 82 43 the the DT 3237 82 44 selected select VBN 3237 82 45 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 82 46 can can MD 3237 82 47 not not RB 3237 82 48 be be VB 3237 82 49 under- under- RB 3237 82 50 estimated estimate VBN 3237 82 51 . . . 3237 83 1 For for IN 3237 83 2 instance instance NN 3237 83 3 , , , 3237 83 4 many many JJ 3237 83 5 feel feel VBP 3237 83 6 that that IN 3237 83 7 the the DT 3237 83 8 direct direct JJ 3237 83 9 manipu- manipu- NNP 3237 83 10 lation lation NN 3237 83 11 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 83 12 ( ( -LRB- 3237 83 13 data datum NNS 3237 83 14 is be VBZ 3237 83 15 an an DT 3237 83 16 object object NN 3237 83 17 that that WDT 3237 83 18 can can MD 3237 83 19 be be VB 3237 83 20 manipulated manipulate VBN 3237 83 21 ) ) -RRB- 3237 83 22 and and CC 3237 83 23 GUI GUI NNP 3237 83 24 are be VBP 3237 83 25 synonymous.35 synonymous.35 NNP 3237 83 26 And and CC 3237 83 27 within within IN 3237 83 28 the the DT 3237 83 29 graphical graphical JJ 3237 83 30 user user NN 3237 83 31 interface interface NN 3237 83 32 , , , 3237 83 33 the the DT 3237 83 34 choice choice NN 3237 83 35 of of IN 3237 83 36 desktop desktop NN 3237 83 37 has have VBZ 3237 83 38 affected affect VBN 3237 83 39 all all DT 3237 83 40 aspects aspect NNS 3237 83 41 of of IN 3237 83 42 the the DT 3237 83 43 interface interface NN 3237 83 44 with with IN 3237 83 45 the the DT 3237 83 46 user user NN 3237 83 47 . . . 3237 84 1 One one CD 3237 84 2 need nee MD 3237 84 3 only only RB 3237 84 4 reflect reflect VB 3237 84 5 upon upon IN 3237 84 6 the the DT 3237 84 7 famous famous JJ 3237 84 8 Englebart Englebart NNP 3237 84 9 demonstration demonstration NN 3237 84 10 of of IN 3237 84 11 the the DT 3237 84 12 “ " `` 3237 84 13 mouse mouse NN 3237 84 14 ” " '' 3237 84 15 most most RBS 3237 84 16 often often RB 3237 84 17 viewed view VBN 3237 84 18 in in IN 3237 84 19 Alan Alan NNP 3237 84 20 Kay Kay NNP 3237 84 21 ’s ’s POS 3237 84 22 video video NN 3237 84 23 presentation.36 presentation.36 NNP 3237 84 24 Englebart Englebart NNP 3237 84 25 ’s ’s POS 3237 84 26 mouse mouse NN 3237 84 27 preceded precede VBD 3237 84 28 the the DT 3237 84 29 notion notion NN 3237 84 30 of of IN 3237 84 31 a a DT 3237 84 32 desktop desktop NN 3237 84 33 and and CC 3237 84 34 more more RBR 3237 84 35 closely closely RB 3237 84 36 resembled resemble VBN 3237 84 37 a a DT 3237 84 38 pilot pilot NN 3237 84 39 ’s ’s POS 3237 84 40 controls control NNS 3237 84 41 than than IN 3237 84 42 an an DT 3237 84 43 office office NN 3237 84 44 worker worker NN 3237 84 45 sitting sit VBG 3237 84 46 at at IN 3237 84 47 a a DT 3237 84 48 typewriter typewriter NN 3237 84 49 keyboard keyboard NN 3237 84 50 . . . 3237 85 1 Imagine imagine VB 3237 85 2 how how WRB 3237 85 3 different different JJ 3237 85 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 85 5 computers computer NNS 3237 85 6 would would MD 3237 85 7 be be VB 3237 85 8 today today NN 3237 85 9 had have VBD 3237 85 10 the the DT 3237 85 11 pilot pilot NN 3237 85 12 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 85 13 ever ever RB 3237 85 14 got get VBD 3237 85 15 off off RP 3237 85 16 the the DT 3237 85 17 ground.37 ground.37 NNP 3237 85 18 the the DT 3237 85 19 ground ground NN 3237 85 20 we -PRON- PRP 3237 85 21 walk walk VBP 3237 85 22 on on IN 3237 85 23 Having have VBG 3237 85 24 adopted adopt VBN 3237 85 25 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 85 26 , , , 3237 85 27 the the DT 3237 85 28 field field NN 3237 85 29 of of IN 3237 85 30 HCI HCI NNP 3237 85 31 wanted want VBD 3237 85 32 a a DT 3237 85 33 better well JJR 3237 85 34 understanding understanding NN 3237 85 35 of of IN 3237 85 36 why why WRB 3237 85 37 and and CC 3237 85 38 how how WRB 3237 85 39 they -PRON- PRP 3237 85 40 worked work VBD 3237 85 41 . . . 3237 86 1 Carroll Carroll NNP 3237 86 2 and and CC 3237 86 3 Thomas Thomas NNP 3237 86 4 stressed stress VBD 3237 86 5 the the DT 3237 86 6 importance importance NN 3237 86 7 of of IN 3237 86 8 psychol- psychol- NN 3237 86 9 ogy ogy NN 3237 86 10 research research NN 3237 86 11 and and CC 3237 86 12 rallied rally VBD 3237 86 13 for for IN 3237 86 14 the the DT 3237 86 15 use use NN 3237 86 16 of of IN 3237 86 17 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 86 18 for for IN 3237 86 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 3237 86 20 grounding ground VBG 3237 86 21 purposes purpose NNS 3237 86 22 , , , 3237 86 23 that that RB 3237 86 24 is is RB 3237 86 25 , , , 3237 86 26 bridging bridge VBG 3237 86 27 abstract abstract JJ 3237 86 28 concepts concept NNS 3237 86 29 to to IN 3237 86 30 concrete concrete JJ 3237 86 31 attributes attribute NNS 3237 86 32 . . . 3237 87 1 In in IN 3237 87 2 a a DT 3237 87 3 manner manner NN 3237 87 4 similar similar JJ 3237 87 5 to to IN 3237 87 6 Belkin Belkin NNP 3237 87 7 , , , 3237 87 8 they -PRON- PRP 3237 87 9 brought bring VBD 3237 87 10 forth forth RB 3237 87 11 the the DT 3237 87 12 notion notion NN 3237 87 13 that that IN 3237 87 14 the the DT 3237 87 15 designer designer NN 3237 87 16 of of IN 3237 87 17 the the DT 3237 87 18 system system NN 3237 87 19 creates create VBZ 3237 87 20 a a DT 3237 87 21 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 87 22 model model NN 3237 87 23 of of IN 3237 87 24 how how WRB 3237 87 25 it -PRON- PRP 3237 87 26 works work VBZ 3237 87 27 . . . 3237 88 1 The the DT 3237 88 2 meta- meta- JJ 3237 88 3 phors phor NNS 3237 88 4 used use VBN 3237 88 5 within within IN 3237 88 6 the the DT 3237 88 7 user user NN 3237 88 8 interface interface NN 3237 88 9 serve serve VBP 3237 88 10 as as IN 3237 88 11 bridges bridge NNS 3237 88 12 to to IN 3237 88 13 the the DT 3237 88 14 user user NN 3237 88 15 ’s ’s POS 3237 88 16 mental mental JJ 3237 88 17 model model NN 3237 88 18 of of IN 3237 88 19 the the DT 3237 88 20 system system NN 3237 88 21 . . . 3237 89 1 “ " `` 3237 89 2 People People NNS 3237 89 3 employ employ VBP 3237 89 4 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 89 5 in in IN 3237 89 6 learning learn VBG 3237 89 7 about about IN 3237 89 8 computing compute VBG 3237 89 9 systems system NNS 3237 89 10 , , , 3237 89 11 the the DT 3237 89 12 designers designer NNS 3237 89 13 of of IN 3237 89 14 those those DT 3237 89 15 systems system NNS 3237 89 16 should should MD 3237 89 17 anticipate anticipate VB 3237 89 18 and and CC 3237 89 19 support support VB 3237 89 20 likely likely JJ 3237 89 21 metaphorical metaphorical JJ 3237 89 22 constructions construction NNS 3237 89 23 to to TO 3237 89 24 increase increase VB 3237 89 25 the the DT 3237 89 26 ease ease NN 3237 89 27 of of IN 3237 89 28 learning learn VBG 3237 89 29 and and CC 3237 89 30 using use VBG 3237 89 31 the the DT 3237 89 32 system system NN 3237 89 33 . . . 3237 89 34 ”38 ”38 RB 3237 89 35 They -PRON- PRP 3237 89 36 encouraged encourage VBD 3237 89 37 designers designer NNS 3237 89 38 to to TO 3237 89 39 consider consider VB 3237 89 40 the the DT 3237 89 41 limitations limitation NNS 3237 89 42 and and CC 3237 89 43 consequences consequence NNS 3237 89 44 of of IN 3237 89 45 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 89 46 ; ; : 3237 89 47 ideally ideally RB 3237 89 48 , , , 3237 89 49 the the DT 3237 89 50 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 89 51 should should MD 3237 89 52 convey convey VB 3237 89 53 its -PRON- PRP$ 3237 89 54 limitations limitation NNS 3237 89 55 to to IN 3237 89 56 the the DT 3237 89 57 user user NN 3237 89 58 . . . 3237 90 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 90 2 eagerness eagerness NN 3237 90 3 to to TO 3237 90 4 adopt adopt VB 3237 90 5 meta- meta- JJ 3237 90 6 phors phor NNS 3237 90 7 , , , 3237 90 8 which which WDT 3237 90 9 they -PRON- PRP 3237 90 10 considered consider VBD 3237 90 11 “ " `` 3237 90 12 crucial crucial JJ 3237 90 13 ” " '' 3237 90 14 for for IN 3237 90 15 motivating motivating NN 3237 90 16 and and CC 3237 90 17 facilitating facilitate VBG 3237 90 18 understanding understanding NN 3237 90 19 , , , 3237 90 20 was be VBD 3237 90 21 countered counter VBN 3237 90 22 only only RB 3237 90 23 by by IN 3237 90 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 90 25 warning warning NN 3237 90 26 that that IN 3237 90 27 “ " `` 3237 90 28 for for IN 3237 90 29 most most JJS 3237 90 30 computer computer NN 3237 90 31 systems system NNS 3237 90 32 there there EX 3237 90 33 will will MD 3237 90 34 come come VB 3237 90 35 a a DT 3237 90 36 point point NN 3237 90 37 at at IN 3237 90 38 which which WDT 3237 90 39 the the DT 3237 90 40 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 90 41 or or CC 3237 90 42 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 90 43 that that WDT 3237 90 44 initially initially RB 3237 90 45 helped help VBD 3237 90 46 the the DT 3237 90 47 user user NN 3237 90 48 understand understand VB 3237 90 49 the the DT 3237 90 50 system system NN 3237 90 51 will will MD 3237 90 52 begin begin VB 3237 90 53 to to TO 3237 90 54 hinder hinder VB 3237 90 55 further further JJ 3237 90 56 learning learning NN 3237 90 57 . . . 3237 90 58 ”39 ”39 NNP 3237 90 59 Case Case NNP 3237 90 60 recognized recognize VBD 3237 90 61 the the DT 3237 90 62 importance importance NN 3237 90 63 of of IN 3237 90 64 assessing assess VBG 3237 90 65 users user NNS 3237 90 66 ’ ’ POS 3237 90 67 needs need NNS 3237 90 68 and and CC 3237 90 69 expectations expectation NNS 3237 90 70 when when WRB 3237 90 71 designing design VBG 3237 90 72 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 90 73 for for IN 3237 90 74 systems system NNS 3237 90 75 . . . 3237 91 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 3237 91 2 study study NN 3237 91 3 of of IN 3237 91 4 historians historian NNS 3237 91 5 found find VBD 3237 91 6 that that IN 3237 91 7 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 91 8 and and CC 3237 91 9 analogies analogy NNS 3237 91 10 are be VBP 3237 91 11 commonly commonly RB 3237 91 12 used use VBN 3237 91 13 in in IN 3237 91 14 the the DT 3237 91 15 information information NN 3237 91 16 behavior behavior NN 3237 91 17 of of IN 3237 91 18 historians historian NNS 3237 91 19 . . . 3237 92 1 He -PRON- PRP 3237 92 2 endorsed endorse VBD 3237 92 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 92 4 use use NN 3237 92 5 in in IN 3237 92 6 inter- inter- NN 3237 92 7 face face NN 3237 92 8 development development NN 3237 92 9 despite despite IN 3237 92 10 potential potential JJ 3237 92 11 pitfalls pitfall NNS 3237 92 12 . . . 3237 93 1 Concerned concern VBN 3237 93 2 mostly mostly RB 3237 93 3 with with IN 3237 93 4 transitioning transition VBG 3237 93 5 historians historian NNS 3237 93 6 from from IN 3237 93 7 physical physical JJ 3237 93 8 to to IN 3237 93 9 electronic electronic JJ 3237 93 10 format format NN 3237 93 11 , , , 3237 93 12 Case Case NNP 3237 93 13 argued argue VBD 3237 93 14 that that IN 3237 93 15 digital digital JJ 3237 93 16 documents document NNS 3237 93 17 and and CC 3237 93 18 files file NNS 3237 93 19 should should MD 3237 93 20 more more RBR 3237 93 21 closely closely RB 3237 93 22 resemble resemble JJ 3237 93 23 physical physical JJ 3237 93 24 files file NNS 3237 93 25 — — : 3237 93 26 not not RB 3237 93 27 necessarily necessarily RB 3237 93 28 physically physically RB 3237 93 29 but but CC 3237 93 30 in in IN 3237 93 31 the the DT 3237 93 32 manner manner NN 3237 93 33 of of IN 3237 93 34 retrieval retrieval NNP 3237 93 35 and and CC 3237 93 36 storage.40 storage.40 NNP 3237 93 37 Espousing Espousing NNP 3237 93 38 a a DT 3237 93 39 slightly slightly RB 3237 93 40 more more RBR 3237 93 41 conservative conservative JJ 3237 93 42 opinion opinion NN 3237 93 43 , , , 3237 93 44 Marcus Marcus NNP 3237 93 45 indicated indicate VBD 3237 93 46 that that IN 3237 93 47 an an DT 3237 93 48 “ " `` 3237 93 49 appropriate appropriate JJ 3237 93 50 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 93 51 bal- bal- NN 3237 93 52 ances ance NNS 3237 93 53 delicately delicately RB 3237 93 54 expectation expectation NN 3237 93 55 and and CC 3237 93 56 surprise surprise NN 3237 93 57 on on IN 3237 93 58 part part NN 3237 93 59 of of IN 3237 93 60 the the DT 3237 93 61 user user NN 3237 93 62 / / SYM 3237 93 63 viewer viewer NN 3237 93 64 . . . 3237 93 65 ”41 ”41 NNP 3237 93 66 Marcus Marcus NNP 3237 93 67 repeated repeat VBD 3237 93 68 that that IN 3237 93 69 the the DT 3237 93 70 objective objective NN 3237 93 71 of of IN 3237 93 72 the the DT 3237 93 73 designer designer NN 3237 93 74 is be VBZ 3237 93 75 to to TO 3237 93 76 design design VB 3237 93 77 a a DT 3237 93 78 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 93 79 model model NN 3237 93 80 that that WDT 3237 93 81 clearly clearly RB 3237 93 82 indicates indicate VBZ 3237 93 83 to to IN 3237 93 84 users user NNS 3237 93 85 what what WP 3237 93 86 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 93 87 expectations expectation NNS 3237 93 88 of of IN 3237 93 89 the the DT 3237 93 90 system system NN 3237 93 91 should should MD 3237 93 92 be be VB 3237 93 93 , , , 3237 93 94 the the DT 3237 93 95 goal goal NN 3237 93 96 being be VBG 3237 93 97 that that IN 3237 93 98 the the DT 3237 93 99 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 93 100 model model NN 3237 93 101 cre- cre- NN 3237 93 102 ated ate VBN 3237 93 103 by by IN 3237 93 104 the the DT 3237 93 105 designers designer NNS 3237 93 106 will will MD 3237 93 107 map map VB 3237 93 108 as as RB 3237 93 109 much much RB 3237 93 110 as as IN 3237 93 111 possible possible JJ 3237 93 112 to to IN 3237 93 113 an an DT 3237 93 114 existing exist VBG 3237 93 115 mental mental JJ 3237 93 116 model model NN 3237 93 117 that that IN 3237 93 118 the the DT 3237 93 119 user user NN 3237 93 120 can can MD 3237 93 121 bring bring VB 3237 93 122 to to IN 3237 93 123 refer- refer- JJ 3237 93 124 ence.42 ence.42 NNP 3237 93 125 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 93 126 are be VBP 3237 93 127 not not RB 3237 93 128 only only RB 3237 93 129 useful useful JJ 3237 93 130 for for IN 3237 93 131 familiarizing familiarize VBG 3237 93 132 users user NNS 3237 93 133 with with IN 3237 93 134 the the DT 3237 93 135 system system NN 3237 93 136 , , , 3237 93 137 but but CC 3237 93 138 also also RB 3237 93 139 affect affect VB 3237 93 140 the the DT 3237 93 141 system system NN 3237 93 142 design design NN 3237 93 143 as as IN 3237 93 144 part part NN 3237 93 145 of of IN 3237 93 146 the the DT 3237 93 147 design design NN 3237 93 148 rationale rationale NN 3237 93 149 . . . 3237 94 1 MacLean MacLean NNP 3237 94 2 , , , 3237 94 3 Bellotti Bellotti NNP 3237 94 4 , , , 3237 94 5 Young Young NNP 3237 94 6 , , , 3237 94 7 and and CC 3237 94 8 Moran Moran NNP 3237 94 9 noted note VBD 3237 94 10 the the DT 3237 94 11 usefulness usefulness NN 3237 94 12 of of IN 3237 94 13 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 94 14 in in IN 3237 94 15 the the DT 3237 94 16 creative creative JJ 3237 94 17 process process NN 3237 94 18 , , , 3237 94 19 but but CC 3237 94 20 expressed express VBD 3237 94 21 concern concern NN 3237 94 22 that that IN 3237 94 23 designers designer NNS 3237 94 24 should should MD 3237 94 25 consider consider VB 3237 94 26 the the DT 3237 94 27 effect effect NN 3237 94 28 of of IN 3237 94 29 even even RB 3237 94 30 implicit implicit JJ 3237 94 31 metaphors.43 metaphors.43 NNP 3237 94 32 Some some DT 3237 94 33 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 94 34 are be VBP 3237 94 35 inevitable inevitable JJ 3237 94 36 because because IN 3237 94 37 “ " `` 3237 94 38 new new JJ 3237 94 39 concepts concept NNS 3237 94 40 and and CC 3237 94 41 processes process NNS 3237 94 42 require require VBP 3237 94 43 new new JJ 3237 94 44 terminology terminology NN 3237 94 45 . . . 3237 95 1 We -PRON- PRP 3237 95 2 can can MD 3237 95 3 either either CC 3237 95 4 coin coin VB 3237 95 5 new new JJ 3237 95 6 terms term NNS 3237 95 7 , , , 3237 95 8 borrow borrow VB 3237 95 9 them -PRON- PRP 3237 95 10 from from IN 3237 95 11 Greek Greek NNP 3237 95 12 , , , 3237 95 13 Latin Latin NNP 3237 95 14 , , , 3237 95 15 or or CC 3237 95 16 other other JJ 3237 95 17 languages language NNS 3237 95 18 , , , 3237 95 19 create create VBP 3237 95 20 terms term NNS 3237 95 21 by by IN 3237 95 22 adding add VBG 3237 95 23 prefixes prefix NNS 3237 95 24 or or CC 3237 95 25 suffixes suffix NNS 3237 95 26 — — : 3237 95 27 or or CC 3237 95 28 use use VBP 3237 95 29 metaphoric metaphoric JJ 3237 95 30 terms term NNS 3237 95 31 . . . 3237 95 32 ”44 ”44 NN 3237 95 33 Many many JJ 3237 95 34 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 95 35 used use VBN 3237 95 36 by by IN 3237 95 37 designers designer NNS 3237 95 38 in in IN 3237 95 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 95 40 communications communication NNS 3237 95 41 are be VBP 3237 95 42 simply simply RB 3237 95 43 embedded embed VBN 3237 95 44 in in IN 3237 95 45 the the DT 3237 95 46 language language NN 3237 95 47 of of IN 3237 95 48 computer computer NN 3237 95 49 science science NN 3237 95 50 . . . 3237 96 1 What what WP 3237 96 2 makes make VBZ 3237 96 3 computer computer NN 3237 96 4 science science NN 3237 96 5 so so RB 3237 96 6 unique unique JJ 3237 96 7 among among IN 3237 96 8 the the DT 3237 96 9 sciences science NNS 3237 96 10 , , , 3237 96 11 especially especially RB 3237 96 12 when when WRB 3237 96 13 using use VBG 3237 96 14 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 96 15 , , , 3237 96 16 is be VBZ 3237 96 17 that that IN 3237 96 18 they -PRON- PRP 3237 96 19 not not RB 3237 96 20 only only RB 3237 96 21 talk talk VBP 3237 96 22 about about IN 3237 96 23 something something NN 3237 96 24 in in IN 3237 96 25 terms term NNS 3237 96 26 of of IN 3237 96 27 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 96 28 , , , 3237 96 29 they -PRON- PRP 3237 96 30 imple- imple- VBP 3237 96 31 ment ment VB 3237 96 32 them -PRON- PRP 3237 96 33 too too RB 3237 96 34 . . . 3237 97 1 “ " `` 3237 97 2 We -PRON- PRP 3237 97 3 live live VBP 3237 97 4 with with IN 3237 97 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 97 6 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 97 7 . . . 3237 97 8 ”45 ”45 '' 3237 97 9 This this DT 3237 97 10 discourse discourse NN 3237 97 11 may may MD 3237 97 12 carry carry VB 3237 97 13 loads load NNS 3237 97 14 of of IN 3237 97 15 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 3237 97 16 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 97 17 for for IN 3237 97 18 common common JJ 3237 97 19 users user NNS 3237 97 20 , , , 3237 97 21 “ " `` 3237 97 22 heaps heap VBZ 3237 97 23 ” " '' 3237 97 24 and and CC 3237 97 25 “ " `` 3237 97 26 stacks stack NNS 3237 97 27 ” " '' 3237 97 28 and and CC 3237 97 29 “ " `` 3237 97 30 parents parent NNS 3237 97 31 ” " '' 3237 97 32 and and CC 3237 97 33 “ " `` 3237 97 34 children child NNS 3237 97 35 , , , 3237 97 36 ” " '' 3237 97 37 for for IN 3237 97 38 instance instance NN 3237 97 39 , , , 3237 97 40 come come VB 3237 97 41 readily readily RB 3237 97 42 to to TO 3237 97 43 mind mind VB 3237 97 44 for for IN 3237 97 45 anyone anyone NN 3237 97 46 with with IN 3237 97 47 computer computer NN 3237 97 48 science science NN 3237 97 49 experience experience NN 3237 97 50 , , , 3237 97 51 but but CC 3237 97 52 do do VBP 3237 97 53 mEtaPHor mEtaPHor NNP 3237 97 54 ’s ’s POS 3237 97 55 rolE rolE , 3237 97 56 in in IN 3237 97 57 tHE the DT 3237 97 58 inFormation information NN 3237 97 59 BEHavior behavior NN 3237 97 60 oF of IN 3237 97 61 Humans human NNS 3237 97 62 intEractinG interact VBZ 3237 97 63 witH with IN 3237 97 64 comPutErs computers CD 3237 97 65 | | CD 3237 97 66 sEasE sease CC 3237 97 67 13 13 CD 3237 97 68 not not RB 3237 97 69 necessarily necessarily RB 3237 97 70 convey convey VBP 3237 97 71 meaning meaning NN 3237 97 72 to to IN 3237 97 73 users user NNS 3237 97 74 . . . 3237 98 1 We -PRON- PRP 3237 98 2 should should MD 3237 98 3 stay stay VB 3237 98 4 aware aware JJ 3237 98 5 of of IN 3237 98 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 98 7 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 98 8 so so IN 3237 98 9 that that IN 3237 98 10 we -PRON- PRP 3237 98 11 avoid avoid VBP 3237 98 12 seeing see VBG 3237 98 13 “ " `` 3237 98 14 platforms platform NNS 3237 98 15 , , , 3237 98 16 engines engine NNS 3237 98 17 and and CC 3237 98 18 objects object NNS 3237 98 19 rather rather RB 3237 98 20 than than IN 3237 98 21 ‘ ' `` 3237 98 22 platforms platform NNS 3237 98 23 ’ ' '' 3237 98 24 , , , 3237 98 25 ‘ ' `` 3237 98 26 engines engine NNS 3237 98 27 ’ ' '' 3237 98 28 and and CC 3237 98 29 ‘ ' `` 3237 98 30 objects object NNS 3237 98 31 . . . 3237 98 32 ’”46 ’”46 '' 3237 98 33 the the DT 3237 98 34 tension tension NN 3237 98 35 builds build VBZ 3237 98 36 These these DT 3237 98 37 caveats caveat NNS 3237 98 38 that that IN 3237 98 39 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 98 40 must must MD 3237 98 41 be be VB 3237 98 42 constantly constantly RB 3237 98 43 moni- moni- JJ 3237 98 44 tored tore VBN 3237 98 45 and and CC 3237 98 46 selected select VBN 3237 98 47 with with IN 3237 98 48 care care NN 3237 98 49 , , , 3237 98 50 coupled couple VBN 3237 98 51 with with IN 3237 98 52 a a DT 3237 98 53 growing grow VBG 3237 98 54 collection collection NN 3237 98 55 of of IN 3237 98 56 mismatched mismatched JJ 3237 98 57 and and CC 3237 98 58 ill ill RB 3237 98 59 - - HYPH 3237 98 60 fitting fitting JJ 3237 98 61 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 98 62 , , , 3237 98 63 began begin VBD 3237 98 64 the the DT 3237 98 65 initial initial JJ 3237 98 66 protestations protestation NNS 3237 98 67 over over IN 3237 98 68 the the DT 3237 98 69 use use NN 3237 98 70 of of IN 3237 98 71 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 98 72 in in IN 3237 98 73 HCI HCI NNP 3237 98 74 . . . 3237 99 1 The the DT 3237 99 2 field field NN 3237 99 3 of of IN 3237 99 4 HCI HCI NNP 3237 99 5 started start VBD 3237 99 6 experiencing experience VBG 3237 99 7 the the DT 3237 99 8 effect effect NN 3237 99 9 of of IN 3237 99 10 the the DT 3237 99 11 tension tension NN 3237 99 12 in in IN 3237 99 13 the the DT 3237 99 14 metaphorical metaphorical JJ 3237 99 15 equation equation NN 3237 99 16 — — : 3237 99 17 those those DT 3237 99 18 attributes attribute NNS 3237 99 19 that that WDT 3237 99 20 fail fail VBP 3237 99 21 to to TO 3237 99 22 match match VB 3237 99 23 . . . 3237 100 1 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 100 2 and and CC 3237 100 3 Nielson Nielson NNP 3237 100 4 summarize summarize VB 3237 100 5 three three CD 3237 100 6 “ " `` 3237 100 7 classic classic JJ 3237 100 8 drawbacks drawback NNS 3237 100 9 ” " '' 3237 100 10 of of IN 3237 100 11 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 100 12 : : : 3237 100 13 n n CC 3237 100 14 The the DT 3237 100 15 target target NN 3237 100 16 domain domain NN 3237 100 17 has have VBZ 3237 100 18 features feature NNS 3237 100 19 not not RB 3237 100 20 in in IN 3237 100 21 the the DT 3237 100 22 source source NN 3237 100 23 domain domain NN 3237 100 24 ( ( -LRB- 3237 100 25 magic magic NNP 3237 100 26 attributes attribute NNS 3237 100 27 ) ) -RRB- 3237 100 28 . . . 3237 101 1 n n LS 3237 101 2 The the DT 3237 101 3 source source NN 3237 101 4 domain domain NN 3237 101 5 has have VBZ 3237 101 6 features feature NNS 3237 101 7 not not RB 3237 101 8 in in IN 3237 101 9 the the DT 3237 101 10 target target NN 3237 101 11 domain domain NN 3237 101 12 ( ( -LRB- 3237 101 13 misleading misleading JJ 3237 101 14 attributes attribute NNS 3237 101 15 ) ) -RRB- 3237 101 16 . . . 3237 102 1 n n LS 3237 102 2 Some some DT 3237 102 3 features feature NNS 3237 102 4 exist exist VBP 3237 102 5 in in IN 3237 102 6 both both DT 3237 102 7 domains domain NNS 3237 102 8 but but CC 3237 102 9 act act NN 3237 102 10 differ- differ- NNP 3237 102 11 ently ently RB 3237 102 12 ( ( -LRB- 3237 102 13 violation violation NN 3237 102 14 of of IN 3237 102 15 expectations).47 expectations).47 NN 3237 102 16 Even even RB 3237 102 17 proponents proponent NNS 3237 102 18 of of IN 3237 102 19 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 102 20 readily readily RB 3237 102 21 admitted admit VBD 3237 102 22 the the DT 3237 102 23 limits limit NNS 3237 102 24 of of IN 3237 102 25 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 102 26 , , , 3237 102 27 specifically specifically RB 3237 102 28 that that IN 3237 102 29 they -PRON- PRP 3237 102 30 never never RB 3237 102 31 match match VBP 3237 102 32 perfectly perfectly RB 3237 102 33 and and CC 3237 102 34 that that IN 3237 102 35 they -PRON- PRP 3237 102 36 can can MD 3237 102 37 “ " `` 3237 102 38 limit limit VB 3237 102 39 meaning meaning NN 3237 102 40 . . . 3237 102 41 ”48 ”48 NNP 3237 102 42 Halasz Halasz NNP 3237 102 43 and and CC 3237 102 44 Moran Moran NNP 3237 102 45 cautioned caution VBD 3237 102 46 that that IN 3237 102 47 teaching teach VBG 3237 102 48 new new JJ 3237 102 49 users user NNS 3237 102 50 through through IN 3237 102 51 analogical analogical JJ 3237 102 52 models model NNS 3237 102 53 may may MD 3237 102 54 be be VB 3237 102 55 an an DT 3237 102 56 easy easy JJ 3237 102 57 way way NN 3237 102 58 to to TO 3237 102 59 introduce introduce VB 3237 102 60 a a DT 3237 102 61 user user NN 3237 102 62 to to IN 3237 102 63 a a DT 3237 102 64 new new JJ 3237 102 65 system system NN 3237 102 66 but but CC 3237 102 67 that that IN 3237 102 68 “ " `` 3237 102 69 analogical analogical JJ 3237 102 70 models model NNS 3237 102 71 can can MD 3237 102 72 act act VB 3237 102 73 as as IN 3237 102 74 barriers barrier NNS 3237 102 75 preventing prevent VBG 3237 102 76 new new JJ 3237 102 77 users user NNS 3237 102 78 from from IN 3237 102 79 developing develop VBG 3237 102 80 an an DT 3237 102 81 effective effective JJ 3237 102 82 understanding understanding NN 3237 102 83 of of IN 3237 102 84 systems system NNS 3237 102 85 . . . 3237 102 86 ”49 ”49 NNP 3237 102 87 Halasz Halasz NNP 3237 102 88 and and CC 3237 102 89 Moran Moran NNP 3237 102 90 argued argue VBD 3237 102 91 that that IN 3237 102 92 computers computer NNS 3237 102 93 are be VBP 3237 102 94 unique unique JJ 3237 102 95 ; ; : 3237 102 96 we -PRON- PRP 3237 102 97 should should MD 3237 102 98 abandon abandon VB 3237 102 99 analogical analogical JJ 3237 102 100 models model NNS 3237 102 101 and and CC 3237 102 102 rather rather RB 3237 102 103 seek seek VB 3237 102 104 to to TO 3237 102 105 create create VB 3237 102 106 a a DT 3237 102 107 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 102 108 model model NN 3237 102 109 of of IN 3237 102 110 the the DT 3237 102 111 system system NN 3237 102 112 that that WDT 3237 102 113 would would MD 3237 102 114 more more RBR 3237 102 115 accurately accurately RB 3237 102 116 reflect reflect VB 3237 102 117 the the DT 3237 102 118 actual actual JJ 3237 102 119 system system NN 3237 102 120 . . . 3237 103 1 A a DT 3237 103 2 system system NN 3237 103 3 designer designer NN 3237 103 4 ’s ’s POS 3237 103 5 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 103 6 model model NN 3237 103 7 would would MD 3237 103 8 represent represent VB 3237 103 9 the the DT 3237 103 10 system system NN 3237 103 11 to to TO 3237 103 12 improve improve VB 3237 103 13 the the DT 3237 103 14 user user NN 3237 103 15 ’s ’s POS 3237 103 16 ability ability NN 3237 103 17 to to TO 3237 103 18 solve solve VB 3237 103 19 problems problem NNS 3237 103 20 and and CC 3237 103 21 apply apply VB 3237 103 22 reason reason NN 3237 103 23 within within IN 3237 103 24 the the DT 3237 103 25 system system NN 3237 103 26 . . . 3237 104 1 They -PRON- PRP 3237 104 2 confess confess VBP 3237 104 3 that that IN 3237 104 4 moving move VBG 3237 104 5 away away RB 3237 104 6 from from IN 3237 104 7 analogical analogical JJ 3237 104 8 models model NNS 3237 104 9 leaves leave VBZ 3237 104 10 the the DT 3237 104 11 user user NN 3237 104 12 without without IN 3237 104 13 the the DT 3237 104 14 tool tool NN 3237 104 15 of of IN 3237 104 16 “ " `` 3237 104 17 prior prior JJ 3237 104 18 knowledge knowledge NN 3237 104 19 , , , 3237 104 20 ” " '' 3237 104 21 so so CC 3237 104 22 for for IN 3237 104 23 teaching teach VBG 3237 104 24 purposes purpose NNS 3237 104 25 ( ( -LRB- 3237 104 26 though though IN 3237 104 27 not not RB 3237 104 28 long long JJ 3237 104 29 - - HYPH 3237 104 30 term term NN 3237 104 31 reasoning reasoning NN 3237 104 32 purposes purpose NNS 3237 104 33 ) ) -RRB- 3237 104 34 they -PRON- PRP 3237 104 35 offer offer VBP 3237 104 36 the the DT 3237 104 37 use use NN 3237 104 38 of of IN 3237 104 39 smaller small JJR 3237 104 40 , , , 3237 104 41 simpler simple JJR 3237 104 42 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 104 43 — — : 3237 104 44 those those DT 3237 104 45 that that WDT 3237 104 46 they -PRON- PRP 3237 104 47 liken liken VBD 3237 104 48 to to IN 3237 104 49 liter- liter- NNP 3237 104 50 ary ary JJ 3237 104 51 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 104 52 used use VBN 3237 104 53 to to TO 3237 104 54 “ " `` 3237 104 55 make make VB 3237 104 56 a a DT 3237 104 57 point point NN 3237 104 58 in in IN 3237 104 59 passing pass VBG 3237 104 60 . . . 3237 105 1 Once once IN 3237 105 2 the the DT 3237 105 3 point point NN 3237 105 4 is be VBZ 3237 105 5 made make VBN 3237 105 6 , , , 3237 105 7 the the DT 3237 105 8 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 105 9 can can MD 3237 105 10 be be VB 3237 105 11 discarded discard VBN 3237 105 12 . . . 3237 105 13 ”50 ”50 '' 3237 105 14 Noting note VBG 3237 105 15 that that IN 3237 105 16 there there EX 3237 105 17 was be VBD 3237 105 18 room room NN 3237 105 19 for for IN 3237 105 20 error error NN 3237 105 21 and and CC 3237 105 22 rejection rejection NN 3237 105 23 on on IN 3237 105 24 behalf behalf NN 3237 105 25 of of IN 3237 105 26 the the DT 3237 105 27 user user NN 3237 105 28 , , , 3237 105 29 Marcus Marcus NNP 3237 105 30 explained explain VBD 3237 105 31 that that IN 3237 105 32 some some DT 3237 105 33 inappro- inappro- JJ 3237 105 34 priate priate NN 3237 105 35 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 105 36 simply simply RB 3237 105 37 become become VBP 3237 105 38 assimilated assimilate VBN 3237 105 39 or or CC 3237 105 40 evolve evolve NN 3237 105 41 . . . 3237 106 1 For for IN 3237 106 2 example example NN 3237 106 3 , , , 3237 106 4 the the DT 3237 106 5 original original JJ 3237 106 6 Apple Apple NNP 3237 106 7 trashcan trashcan NN 3237 106 8 icon icon NN 3237 106 9 more more RBR 3237 106 10 closely closely RB 3237 106 11 resembled resemble VBN 3237 106 12 a a DT 3237 106 13 “ " `` 3237 106 14 kitchen kitchen NN 3237 106 15 garbage garbage NN 3237 106 16 can can MD 3237 106 17 ” " '' 3237 106 18 for for IN 3237 106 19 scraps scrap NNS 3237 106 20 and and CC 3237 106 21 rotting rot VBG 3237 106 22 things thing NNS 3237 106 23 than than IN 3237 106 24 an an DT 3237 106 25 office office NN 3237 106 26 wastebasket wastebasket NN 3237 106 27 for for IN 3237 106 28 paper paper NN 3237 106 29 , , , 3237 106 30 but but CC 3237 106 31 over over IN 3237 106 32 the the DT 3237 106 33 years year NNS 3237 106 34 it -PRON- PRP 3237 106 35 has have VBZ 3237 106 36 evolved evolve VBN 3237 106 37 to to IN 3237 106 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 3237 106 39 current current JJ 3237 106 40 office office NN 3237 106 41 basket basket NN 3237 106 42 icon.51 icon.51 NNP 3237 106 43 Also also RB 3237 106 44 , , , 3237 106 45 as as IN 3237 106 46 technology technology NN 3237 106 47 changes change NNS 3237 106 48 , , , 3237 106 49 the the DT 3237 106 50 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 106 51 will will MD 3237 106 52 change change VB 3237 106 53 . . . 3237 107 1 “ " `` 3237 107 2 The the DT 3237 107 3 paradigm paradigm NN 3237 107 4 shift shift NN 3237 107 5 , , , 3237 107 6 or or CC 3237 107 7 change change NN 3237 107 8 in in IN 3237 107 9 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 107 10 , , , 3237 107 11 will will MD 3237 107 12 be be VB 3237 107 13 constant constant JJ 3237 107 14 and and CC 3237 107 15 swift swift JJ 3237 107 16 as as IN 3237 107 17 paradigms paradigm NNS 3237 107 18 evolve evolve VBP 3237 107 19 from from IN 3237 107 20 prototypes prototype NNS 3237 107 21 , , , 3237 107 22 become become VB 3237 107 23 typed typed JJ 3237 107 24 , , , 3237 107 25 evolve evolve VB 3237 107 26 to to IN 3237 107 27 archetypes archetype NNS 3237 107 28 , , , 3237 107 29 and and CC 3237 107 30 eventually eventually RB 3237 107 31 become become VBN 3237 107 32 stereotyped stereotyped JJ 3237 107 33 or or CC 3237 107 34 obsolete obsolete JJ 3237 107 35 . . . 3237 107 36 ”52 ”52 NN 3237 107 37 Without without IN 3237 107 38 stating state VBG 3237 107 39 it -PRON- PRP 3237 107 40 explicitly explicitly RB 3237 107 41 , , , 3237 107 42 he -PRON- PRP 3237 107 43 spoke speak VBD 3237 107 44 of of IN 3237 107 45 dead dead JJ 3237 107 46 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 107 47 : : : 3237 107 48 meta- meta- JJ 3237 107 49 phors phor NNS 3237 107 50 that that WDT 3237 107 51 no no RB 3237 107 52 longer long RBR 3237 107 53 bring bring VBP 3237 107 54 new new JJ 3237 107 55 meaning meaning NN 3237 107 56 to to IN 3237 107 57 light light NN 3237 107 58 , , , 3237 107 59 the the DT 3237 107 60 “ " `` 3237 107 61 arm arm NN 3237 107 62 ” " '' 3237 107 63 of of IN 3237 107 64 a a DT 3237 107 65 chair chair NN 3237 107 66 or or CC 3237 107 67 the the DT 3237 107 68 “ " `` 3237 107 69 leg leg NN 3237 107 70 ” " '' 3237 107 71 of of IN 3237 107 72 a a DT 3237 107 73 table table NN 3237 107 74 , , , 3237 107 75 for for IN 3237 107 76 instance instance NN 3237 107 77 . . . 3237 108 1 These these DT 3237 108 2 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 108 3 are be VBP 3237 108 4 accepted accept VBN 3237 108 5 idiomatically idiomatically RB 3237 108 6 with with IN 3237 108 7 no no DT 3237 108 8 need need NN 3237 108 9 for for IN 3237 108 10 explanation explanation NN 3237 108 11 and and CC 3237 108 12 exploration exploration NN 3237 108 13 . . . 3237 109 1 Aware aware JJ 3237 109 2 of of IN 3237 109 3 the the DT 3237 109 4 ease ease NN 3237 109 5 with with IN 3237 109 6 which which WDT 3237 109 7 users user NNS 3237 109 8 employ employ VBP 3237 109 9 idi- idi- NNP 3237 109 10 omatic omatic JJ 3237 109 11 icons icon NNS 3237 109 12 in in IN 3237 109 13 computing computing NN 3237 109 14 , , , 3237 109 15 Cooper Cooper NNP 3237 109 16 adduced adduce VBD 3237 109 17 that that IN 3237 109 18 idi- idi- NNP 3237 109 19 oms oms JJ 3237 109 20 and and CC 3237 109 21 meaningless meaningless JJ 3237 109 22 symbols symbol NNS 3237 109 23 are be VBP 3237 109 24 preferable preferable JJ 3237 109 25 to to IN 3237 109 26 new new JJ 3237 109 27 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 109 28 , , , 3237 109 29 claiming claim VBG 3237 109 30 “ " `` 3237 109 31 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 109 32 offer offer VBP 3237 109 33 a a DT 3237 109 34 tiny tiny JJ 3237 109 35 boost boost NN 3237 109 36 in in IN 3237 109 37 learnability learnability NN 3237 109 38 to to IN 3237 109 39 first first JJ 3237 109 40 time time NN 3237 109 41 users user NNS 3237 109 42 at at IN 3237 109 43 tremendous tremendous JJ 3237 109 44 cost cost NN 3237 109 45 . . . 3237 110 1 The the DT 3237 110 2 biggest big JJS 3237 110 3 problem problem NN 3237 110 4 is be VBZ 3237 110 5 that that IN 3237 110 6 by by IN 3237 110 7 representing represent VBG 3237 110 8 old old JJ 3237 110 9 technology technology NN 3237 110 10 , , , 3237 110 11 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 110 12 firmly firmly RB 3237 110 13 nail nail VBP 3237 110 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 110 15 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 110 16 feet foot NNS 3237 110 17 to to IN 3237 110 18 the the DT 3237 110 19 ground ground NN 3237 110 20 , , , 3237 110 21 forever forever RB 3237 110 22 limiting limit VBG 3237 110 23 the the DT 3237 110 24 power power NN 3237 110 25 of of IN 3237 110 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 110 27 software software NN 3237 110 28 . . . 3237 110 29 ”53 ”53 NNP 3237 110 30 He -PRON- PRP 3237 110 31 pro- pro- NN 3237 110 32 posed pose VBD 3237 110 33 that that IN 3237 110 34 we -PRON- PRP 3237 110 35 move move VBP 3237 110 36 away away RB 3237 110 37 from from IN 3237 110 38 a a DT 3237 110 39 metaphoric metaphoric JJ 3237 110 40 paradigm paradigm NN 3237 110 41 to to IN 3237 110 42 an an DT 3237 110 43 idiomatic idiomatic JJ 3237 110 44 paradigm paradigm NN 3237 110 45 where where WRB 3237 110 46 a a DT 3237 110 47 word word NN 3237 110 48 or or CC 3237 110 49 symbol symbol NN 3237 110 50 sim- sim- NNS 3237 110 51 ply ply UH 3237 110 52 stands stand VBZ 3237 110 53 for for IN 3237 110 54 something something NN 3237 110 55 else else RB 3237 110 56 and and CC 3237 110 57 does do VBZ 3237 110 58 not not RB 3237 110 59 carry carry VB 3237 110 60 with with IN 3237 110 61 it -PRON- PRP 3237 110 62 the the DT 3237 110 63 weight weight NN 3237 110 64 of of IN 3237 110 65 analogy analogy NN 3237 110 66 . . . 3237 111 1 Many many JJ 3237 111 2 of of IN 3237 111 3 the the DT 3237 111 4 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 111 5 originally originally RB 3237 111 6 created create VBN 3237 111 7 in in IN 3237 111 8 computing computing NN 3237 111 9 have have VBP 3237 111 10 become become VBN 3237 111 11 dead dead JJ 3237 111 12 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 111 13 or or CC 3237 111 14 idioms idiom NNS 3237 111 15 already already RB 3237 111 16 . . . 3237 112 1 People People NNS 3237 112 2 do do VBP 3237 112 3 not not RB 3237 112 4 think think VB 3237 112 5 of of IN 3237 112 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 112 7 memory memory NN 3237 112 8 buffer buffer NN 3237 112 9 where where WRB 3237 112 10 they -PRON- PRP 3237 112 11 store store VBP 3237 112 12 copied copy VBD 3237 112 13 or or CC 3237 112 14 cut cut VBN 3237 112 15 items item NNS 3237 112 16 as as IN 3237 112 17 an an DT 3237 112 18 actual actual JJ 3237 112 19 clipboard clipboard NN 3237 112 20 . . . 3237 113 1 The the DT 3237 113 2 Macintosh Macintosh NNP 3237 113 3 trashcan trashcan NNP 3237 113 4 is be VBZ 3237 113 5 ubiquitously ubiquitously RB 3237 113 6 cited cite VBN 3237 113 7 as as IN 3237 113 8 a a DT 3237 113 9 per- per- NN 3237 113 10 fect fect JJ 3237 113 11 example example NN 3237 113 12 of of IN 3237 113 13 a a DT 3237 113 14 mismatched mismatch VBN 3237 113 15 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 113 16 and and CC 3237 113 17 illustrates illustrate VBZ 3237 113 18 what what WP 3237 113 19 may may MD 3237 113 20 happen happen VB 3237 113 21 when when WRB 3237 113 22 a a DT 3237 113 23 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 113 24 becomes become VBZ 3237 113 25 idiomatic idiomatic JJ 3237 113 26 . . . 3237 114 1 For for IN 3237 114 2 many many JJ 3237 114 3 years year NNS 3237 114 4 to to IN 3237 114 5 the the DT 3237 114 6 horror horror NN 3237 114 7 and and CC 3237 114 8 confusion confusion NN 3237 114 9 of of IN 3237 114 10 many many JJ 3237 114 11 users user NNS 3237 114 12 , , , 3237 114 13 the the DT 3237 114 14 trashcan trashcan NNP 3237 114 15 both both DT 3237 114 16 deleted delete VBD 3237 114 17 files file NNS 3237 114 18 and and CC 3237 114 19 was be VBD 3237 114 20 used use VBN 3237 114 21 to to TO 3237 114 22 eject eject VB 3237 114 23 a a DT 3237 114 24 diskette diskette NN 3237 114 25 . . . 3237 115 1 A a DT 3237 115 2 user user NN 3237 115 3 would would MD 3237 115 4 drag drag VB 3237 115 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 115 6 diskette diskette NNP 3237 115 7 icon icon NN 3237 115 8 to to IN 3237 115 9 the the DT 3237 115 10 trashcan trashcan NNP 3237 115 11 to to TO 3237 115 12 eject eject VB 3237 115 13 it -PRON- PRP 3237 115 14 . . . 3237 116 1 Although although IN 3237 116 2 this this DT 3237 116 3 may may MD 3237 116 4 seem seem VB 3237 116 5 like like IN 3237 116 6 just just RB 3237 116 7 a a DT 3237 116 8 poor poor JJ 3237 116 9 choice choice NN 3237 116 10 of of IN 3237 116 11 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 116 12 , , , 3237 116 13 it -PRON- PRP 3237 116 14 does do VBZ 3237 116 15 have have VB 3237 116 16 a a DT 3237 116 17 sensible sensible JJ 3237 116 18 origin origin NN 3237 116 19 . . . 3237 117 1 Historically historically RB 3237 117 2 , , , 3237 117 3 computers computer NNS 3237 117 4 had have VBD 3237 117 5 no no DT 3237 117 6 hard hard JJ 3237 117 7 drive drive NN 3237 117 8 , , , 3237 117 9 but but CC 3237 117 10 rather rather RB 3237 117 11 ran run VBD 3237 117 12 applications application NNS 3237 117 13 from from IN 3237 117 14 diskettes diskette NNS 3237 117 15 . . . 3237 118 1 When when WRB 3237 118 2 you -PRON- PRP 3237 118 3 were be VBD 3237 118 4 entirely entirely RB 3237 118 5 done do VBN 3237 118 6 with with IN 3237 118 7 the the DT 3237 118 8 application application NN 3237 118 9 you -PRON- PRP 3237 118 10 would would MD 3237 118 11 remove remove VB 3237 118 12 the the DT 3237 118 13 application application NN 3237 118 14 icon icon NN 3237 118 15 from from IN 3237 118 16 the the DT 3237 118 17 desktop desktop NN 3237 118 18 by by IN 3237 118 19 placing place VBG 3237 118 20 it -PRON- PRP 3237 118 21 in in IN 3237 118 22 the the DT 3237 118 23 trash trash NN 3237 118 24 . . . 3237 119 1 You -PRON- PRP 3237 119 2 would would MD 3237 119 3 also also RB 3237 119 4 need need VB 3237 119 5 to to TO 3237 119 6 eject eject VB 3237 119 7 the the DT 3237 119 8 diskette diskette NNP 3237 119 9 . . . 3237 120 1 For for IN 3237 120 2 expediency expediency NN 3237 120 3 , , , 3237 120 4 Apple Apple NNP 3237 120 5 engineers engineer NNS 3237 120 6 incorporated incorporate VBD 3237 120 7 ejection ejection NN 3237 120 8 and and CC 3237 120 9 desktop desktop NN 3237 120 10 removal removal NN 3237 120 11 into into IN 3237 120 12 one one CD 3237 120 13 quick quick JJ 3237 120 14 task task NN 3237 120 15 . . . 3237 121 1 It -PRON- PRP 3237 121 2 was be VBD 3237 121 3 user user NN 3237 121 4 tested test VBN 3237 121 5 and and CC 3237 121 6 readily readily RB 3237 121 7 adopted.54 adopted.54 NNP 3237 121 8 The the DT 3237 121 9 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 121 10 was be VBD 3237 121 11 a a DT 3237 121 12 natural natural JJ 3237 121 13 extension extension NN 3237 121 14 until until IN 3237 121 15 the the DT 3237 121 16 function- function- NNP 3237 121 17 ality ality NN 3237 121 18 changed change VBD 3237 121 19 . . . 3237 122 1 The the DT 3237 122 2 user user NN 3237 122 3 is be VBZ 3237 122 4 not not RB 3237 122 5 the the DT 3237 122 6 only only JJ 3237 122 7 potential potential JJ 3237 122 8 victim victim NN 3237 122 9 of of IN 3237 122 10 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 122 11 ; ; : 3237 122 12 the the DT 3237 122 13 blinders blinder NNS 3237 122 14 of of IN 3237 122 15 an an DT 3237 122 16 adopted adopt VBN 3237 122 17 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 122 18 can can MD 3237 122 19 curtail curtail VB 3237 122 20 a a DT 3237 122 21 sys- sys- NN 3237 122 22 tem tem NN 3237 122 23 designers designer NNS 3237 122 24 ’ ' '' 3237 122 25 vision.55 vision.55 NNP 3237 122 26 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 122 27 and and CC 3237 122 28 Nielson Nielson NNP 3237 122 29 take take VB 3237 122 30 great great JJ 3237 122 31 offense offense NN 3237 122 32 at at IN 3237 122 33 the the DT 3237 122 34 direct direct JJ 3237 122 35 manipulation manipulation NN 3237 122 36 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 122 37 because because IN 3237 122 38 it -PRON- PRP 3237 122 39 reduces reduce VBZ 3237 122 40 us -PRON- PRP 3237 122 41 to to TO 3237 122 42 “ " `` 3237 122 43 pointing pointing NN 3237 122 44 ” " '' 3237 122 45 and and CC 3237 122 46 “ " `` 3237 122 47 grunting grunt VBG 3237 122 48 ” " '' 3237 122 49 as as IN 3237 122 50 if if IN 3237 122 51 we -PRON- PRP 3237 122 52 were be VBD 3237 122 53 children child NNS 3237 122 54 barely barely RB 3237 122 55 able able JJ 3237 122 56 to to TO 3237 122 57 communicate communicate VB 3237 122 58 or or CC 3237 122 59 patrons patron NNS 3237 122 60 at at IN 3237 122 61 a a DT 3237 122 62 res- res- NNS 3237 122 63 taurant taurant NN 3237 122 64 where where WRB 3237 122 65 we -PRON- PRP 3237 122 66 do do VBP 3237 122 67 n’t not RB 3237 122 68 speak speak VB 3237 122 69 the the DT 3237 122 70 language language NN 3237 122 71 . . . 3237 123 1 When when WRB 3237 123 2 they -PRON- PRP 3237 123 3 state state VBP 3237 123 4 “ " `` 3237 123 5 computer computer NN 3237 123 6 interfaces interface NNS 3237 123 7 must must MD 3237 123 8 evolve evolve VB 3237 123 9 to to TO 3237 123 10 utilize utilize VB 3237 123 11 more more JJR 3237 123 12 of of IN 3237 123 13 the the DT 3237 123 14 power power NN 3237 123 15 of of IN 3237 123 16 language,”56 language,”56 NNP 3237 123 17 they -PRON- PRP 3237 123 18 are be VBP 3237 123 19 not not RB 3237 123 20 speaking speak VBG 3237 123 21 of of IN 3237 123 22 voice voice NN 3237 123 23 control control NN 3237 123 24 and and CC 3237 123 25 natural natural JJ 3237 123 26 language language NN 3237 123 27 processing processing NN 3237 123 28 , , , 3237 123 29 but but CC 3237 123 30 to to TO 3237 123 31 creat- creat- VB 3237 123 32 ing ing NNP 3237 123 33 a a DT 3237 123 34 shared shared JJ 3237 123 35 language language NN 3237 123 36 understandable understandable JJ 3237 123 37 by by IN 3237 123 38 both both DT 3237 123 39 the the DT 3237 123 40 user user NN 3237 123 41 and and CC 3237 123 42 the the DT 3237 123 43 system system NN 3237 123 44 . . . 3237 124 1 Only only RB 3237 124 2 “ " `` 3237 124 3 power power NN 3237 124 4 users user NNS 3237 124 5 ” " '' 3237 124 6 of of IN 3237 124 7 a a DT 3237 124 8 machine machine NN 3237 124 9 have have VBP 3237 124 10 breached breach VBN 3237 124 11 the the DT 3237 124 12 walls wall NNS 3237 124 13 of of IN 3237 124 14 the the DT 3237 124 15 interface interface NN 3237 124 16 and and CC 3237 124 17 have have VBP 3237 124 18 attempted attempt VBN 3237 124 19 to to TO 3237 124 20 learn learn VB 3237 124 21 the the DT 3237 124 22 language language NN 3237 124 23 of of IN 3237 124 24 the the DT 3237 124 25 machine machine NN 3237 124 26 itself -PRON- PRP 3237 124 27 , , , 3237 124 28 but but CC 3237 124 29 even even RB 3237 124 30 they -PRON- PRP 3237 124 31 are be VBP 3237 124 32 inevitably inevitably RB 3237 124 33 dragged drag VBN 3237 124 34 down down RP 3237 124 35 by by IN 3237 124 36 the the DT 3237 124 37 restrictions restriction NNS 3237 124 38 of of IN 3237 124 39 direct direct JJ 3237 124 40 manipulation.57 manipulation.57 NNP 3237 124 41 14 14 CD 3237 124 42 inFormation inFormation NNP 3237 124 43 tEcHnoloGY technology NN 3237 124 44 anD and CC 3237 124 45 liBrariEs libraries NN 3237 124 46 | | NNP 3237 124 47 DEcEmBEr DEcEmBEr NNP 3237 124 48 2008 2008 CD 3237 124 49 Near near IN 3237 124 50 the the DT 3237 124 51 end end NN 3237 124 52 of of IN 3237 124 53 the the DT 3237 124 54 millennium millennium NN 3237 124 55 , , , 3237 124 56 user user NN 3237 124 57 interface interface NN 3237 124 58 guide- guide- NN 3237 124 59 lines line NNS 3237 124 60 and and CC 3237 124 61 handbooks handbook NNS 3237 124 62 backed back VBD 3237 124 63 off off RP 3237 124 64 — — : 3237 124 65 afraid afraid JJ 3237 124 66 to to TO 3237 124 67 support support VB 3237 124 68 or or CC 3237 124 69 spurn spurn NN 3237 124 70 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 124 71 use use NN 3237 124 72 in in IN 3237 124 73 HCI HCI NNP 3237 124 74 . . . 3237 125 1 Blackwell Blackwell NNP 3237 125 2 ’s ’s POS 3237 125 3 chronicle chronicle NN 3237 125 4 of of IN 3237 125 5 the the DT 3237 125 6 history history NN 3237 125 7 of of IN 3237 125 8 the the DT 3237 125 9 desktop desktop NN 3237 125 10 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 125 11 notes note NNS 3237 125 12 that that IN 3237 125 13 1990 1990 CD 3237 125 14 “ " `` 3237 125 15 marked mark VBD 3237 125 16 the the DT 3237 125 17 middle middle NN 3237 125 18 of of IN 3237 125 19 a a DT 3237 125 20 decade decade NN 3237 125 21 ( ( -LRB- 3237 125 22 1985 1985 CD 3237 125 23 to to IN 3237 125 24 1995 1995 CD 3237 125 25 ) ) -RRB- 3237 125 26 in in IN 3237 125 27 which which WDT 3237 125 28 research- research- JJ 3237 125 29 ers ers NNP 3237 125 30 anticipated anticipate VBD 3237 125 31 problems problem NNS 3237 125 32 with with IN 3237 125 33 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 125 34 at at IN 3237 125 35 the the DT 3237 125 36 start start NN 3237 125 37 and and CC 3237 125 38 had have VBD 3237 125 39 experienced experience VBN 3237 125 40 failure failure NN 3237 125 41 by by IN 3237 125 42 the the DT 3237 125 43 end end NN 3237 125 44 . . . 3237 125 45 ”58 ”58 VB 3237 125 46 The the DT 3237 125 47 silence silence NN 3237 125 48 is be VBZ 3237 125 49 most most RBS 3237 125 50 stunning stunning JJ 3237 125 51 in in IN 3237 125 52 the the DT 3237 125 53 Handbook Handbook NNP 3237 125 54 of of IN 3237 125 55 Human Human NNP 3237 125 56 Computer Computer NNP 3237 125 57 Interaction Interaction NNP 3237 125 58 , , , 3237 125 59 a a DT 3237 125 60 1,582 1,582 CD 3237 125 61 page page NN 3237 125 62 volume volume NN 3237 125 63 in in IN 3237 125 64 which which WDT 3237 125 65 only only RB 3237 125 66 two two CD 3237 125 67 of of IN 3237 125 68 the the DT 3237 125 69 sixty sixty CD 3237 125 70 - - HYPH 3237 125 71 two two CD 3237 125 72 chapters chapter NNS 3237 125 73 even even RB 3237 125 74 mention mention VBP 3237 125 75 metaphors.59 metaphors.59 NNP 3237 125 76 Hollan Hollan NNP 3237 125 77 , , , 3237 125 78 Bederson Bederson NNP 3237 125 79 , , , 3237 125 80 and and CC 3237 125 81 Helfman Helfman NNP 3237 125 82 caution caution VBP 3237 125 83 against against IN 3237 125 84 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 125 85 in in IN 3237 125 86 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 125 87 chapter chapter NN 3237 125 88 on on IN 3237 125 89 information information NN 3237 125 90 visualization,60 visualization,60 NN 3237 125 91 while while IN 3237 125 92 Neale Neale NNP 3237 125 93 and and CC 3237 125 94 Carroll Carroll NNP 3237 125 95 cautiously cautiously RB 3237 125 96 return return VBP 3237 125 97 to to IN 3237 125 98 Carroll Carroll NNP 3237 125 99 ’s ’s POS 3237 125 100 original original JJ 3237 125 101 thesis thesis NN 3237 125 102 , , , 3237 125 103 stress- stress- VBD 3237 125 104 ing e VBG 3237 125 105 the the DT 3237 125 106 importance importance NN 3237 125 107 of of IN 3237 125 108 creating create VBG 3237 125 109 a a DT 3237 125 110 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 125 111 model model NN 3237 125 112 ( ( -LRB- 3237 125 113 the the DT 3237 125 114 designer designer NN 3237 125 115 ’s ’s POS 3237 125 116 model model NN 3237 125 117 of of IN 3237 125 118 the the DT 3237 125 119 system system NN 3237 125 120 ’s ’s POS 3237 125 121 functions function NNS 3237 125 122 ) ) -RRB- 3237 125 123 that that IN 3237 125 124 “ " `` 3237 125 125 should should MD 3237 125 126 incorporate incorporate VB 3237 125 127 an an DT 3237 125 128 accurate accurate JJ 3237 125 129 understanding understanding NN 3237 125 130 of of IN 3237 125 131 the the DT 3237 125 132 user user NN 3237 125 133 ’s ’s POS 3237 125 134 task task NN 3237 125 135 , , , 3237 125 136 requirements requirement NNS 3237 125 137 , , , 3237 125 138 experience experience NN 3237 125 139 , , , 3237 125 140 capabilities capability NNS 3237 125 141 , , , 3237 125 142 and and CC 3237 125 143 limitations limitation NNS 3237 125 144 . . . 3237 125 145 ”61 ”61 NNP 3237 125 146 n n CC 3237 125 147 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 125 148 ever ever RB 3237 125 149 after after IN 3237 125 150 By by IN 3237 125 151 the the DT 3237 125 152 year year NN 3237 125 153 2000 2000 CD 3237 125 154 , , , 3237 125 155 system system NN 3237 125 156 designers designer NNS 3237 125 157 found find VBD 3237 125 158 themselves -PRON- PRP 3237 125 159 stuck stick VBN 3237 125 160 between between IN 3237 125 161 a a DT 3237 125 162 rock rock NN 3237 125 163 and and CC 3237 125 164 hard hard JJ 3237 125 165 drive drive NN 3237 125 166 . . . 3237 126 1 Investigations investigation NNS 3237 126 2 into into IN 3237 126 3 the the DT 3237 126 4 efficacy efficacy NN 3237 126 5 of of IN 3237 126 6 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 126 7 find find VBP 3237 126 8 that that IN 3237 126 9 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 126 10 are be VBP 3237 126 11 a a DT 3237 126 12 mixed mixed JJ 3237 126 13 bag bag NN 3237 126 14 , , , 3237 126 15 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 3237 126 16 , , , 3237 126 17 useful useful JJ 3237 126 18 , , , 3237 126 19 yet yet CC 3237 126 20 problematic.62 problematic.62 NNP 3237 126 21 While while IN 3237 126 22 creating create VBG 3237 126 23 a a DT 3237 126 24 taxonomy taxonomy NN 3237 126 25 of of IN 3237 126 26 HCI HCI NNP 3237 126 27 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 126 28 , , , 3237 126 29 Barr Barr NNP 3237 126 30 , , , 3237 126 31 Biddle Biddle NNP 3237 126 32 , , , 3237 126 33 and and CC 3237 126 34 Noble noble JJ 3237 126 35 conclude conclude NN 3237 126 36 that that IN 3237 126 37 “ " `` 3237 126 38 the the DT 3237 126 39 analysis analysis NN 3237 126 40 present present JJ 3237 126 41 in in IN 3237 126 42 the the DT 3237 126 43 taxonomy taxonomy NN 3237 126 44 should should MD 3237 126 45 indicate indicate VB 3237 126 46 that that IN 3237 126 47 there there EX 3237 126 48 are be VBP 3237 126 49 many many JJ 3237 126 50 benefits benefit NNS 3237 126 51 to to TO 3237 126 52 user user NN 3237 126 53 - - HYPH 3237 126 54 interface interface NN 3237 126 55 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 126 56 if if IN 3237 126 57 we -PRON- PRP 3237 126 58 choose choose VBP 3237 126 59 them -PRON- PRP 3237 126 60 correctly correctly RB 3237 126 61 and and CC 3237 126 62 harness harness VB 3237 126 63 them -PRON- PRP 3237 126 64 properly properly RB 3237 126 65 . . . 3237 126 66 ”63 ”63 NNP 3237 126 67 Yet yet RB 3237 126 68 Blackwell Blackwell NNP 3237 126 69 ’s ’s POS 3237 126 70 dissertation dissertation NN 3237 126 71 research research NN 3237 126 72 finds find VBZ 3237 126 73 that that IN 3237 126 74 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 126 75 afford afford VBP 3237 126 76 “ " `` 3237 126 77 surprisingly surprisingly RB 3237 126 78 little little JJ 3237 126 79 benefit benefit NN 3237 126 80 for for IN 3237 126 81 cognitive cognitive JJ 3237 126 82 tasks task NNS 3237 126 83 ” " '' 3237 126 84 and and CC 3237 126 85 that that IN 3237 126 86 the the DT 3237 126 87 benefit benefit NN 3237 126 88 is be VBZ 3237 126 89 “ " `` 3237 126 90 largely largely RB 3237 126 91 restricted restrict VBN 3237 126 92 to to IN 3237 126 93 mnemonic mnemonic JJ 3237 126 94 assistance assistance NN 3237 126 95 . . . 3237 126 96 ”64 ”64 NNP 3237 126 97 Blackwell Blackwell NNP 3237 126 98 notes note VBZ 3237 126 99 that that IN 3237 126 100 the the DT 3237 126 101 benefits benefit NNS 3237 126 102 were be VBD 3237 126 103 greatest great JJS 3237 126 104 when when WRB 3237 126 105 the the DT 3237 126 106 user user NN 3237 126 107 constructed construct VBD 3237 126 108 his -PRON- PRP$ 3237 126 109 or or CC 3237 126 110 her -PRON- PRP$ 3237 126 111 own own JJ 3237 126 112 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 126 113 rather rather RB 3237 126 114 than than IN 3237 126 115 using use VBG 3237 126 116 the the DT 3237 126 117 system- system- NN 3237 126 118 supplied supply VBN 3237 126 119 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 126 120 . . . 3237 127 1 Interestingly interestingly RB 3237 127 2 , , , 3237 127 3 while while IN 3237 127 4 studying study VBG 3237 127 5 stu- stu- NN 3237 127 6 dents dent NNS 3237 127 7 ’ ’ POS 3237 127 8 understanding understanding NN 3237 127 9 of of IN 3237 127 10 search search NN 3237 127 11 engines engine NNS 3237 127 12 , , , 3237 127 13 Hendry Hendry NNP 3237 127 14 identi- identi- NN 3237 127 15 fied fie VBD 3237 127 16 a a DT 3237 127 17 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 127 18 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 127 19 ( ( -LRB- 3237 127 20 not not RB 3237 127 21 provided provide VBN 3237 127 22 by by IN 3237 127 23 the the DT 3237 127 24 system system NN 3237 127 25 ) ) -RRB- 3237 127 26 common common JJ 3237 127 27 to to IN 3237 127 28 many many JJ 3237 127 29 of of IN 3237 127 30 the the DT 3237 127 31 students student NNS 3237 127 32 ’ ’ POS 3237 127 33 visions vision NNS 3237 127 34 of of IN 3237 127 35 an an DT 3237 127 36 informa- informa- JJ 3237 127 37 tion tion NN 3237 127 38 retrieval retrieval NN 3237 127 39 system system NN 3237 127 40 . . . 3237 128 1 Although although IN 3237 128 2 Hendry Hendry NNP 3237 128 3 does do VBZ 3237 128 4 not not RB 3237 128 5 suggest suggest VB 3237 128 6 that that IN 3237 128 7 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 128 8 should should MD 3237 128 9 be be VB 3237 128 10 used use VBN 3237 128 11 when when WRB 3237 128 12 creating create VBG 3237 128 13 systems system NNS 3237 128 14 , , , 3237 128 15 he -PRON- PRP 3237 128 16 does do VBZ 3237 128 17 question question VB 3237 128 18 how how WRB 3237 128 19 existing exist VBG 3237 128 20 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 128 21 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 128 22 might may MD 3237 128 23 be be VB 3237 128 24 identified identify VBN 3237 128 25 through through IN 3237 128 26 sketching sketching NN 3237 128 27 and and CC 3237 128 28 then then RB 3237 128 29 incorporated incorporate VBD 3237 128 30 to to TO 3237 128 31 create create VB 3237 128 32 mappings mapping NNS 3237 128 33 “ " `` 3237 128 34 between between IN 3237 128 35 problem problem NN 3237 128 36 domains domain NNS 3237 128 37 and and CC 3237 128 38 pro- pro- NN 3237 128 39 gramming gramming NN 3237 128 40 notations notation NNS 3237 128 41 . . . 3237 128 42 ”65 ”65 NNP 3237 128 43 Endeavoring endeavor VBG 3237 128 44 to to TO 3237 128 45 incorporate incorporate VB 3237 128 46 the the DT 3237 128 47 benefits benefit NNS 3237 128 48 of of IN 3237 128 49 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 128 50 while while IN 3237 128 51 dodging dodge VBG 3237 128 52 the the DT 3237 128 53 drawbacks drawback NNS 3237 128 54 , , , 3237 128 55 recent recent JJ 3237 128 56 variations variation NNS 3237 128 57 on on IN 3237 128 58 the the DT 3237 128 59 use use NN 3237 128 60 of of IN 3237 128 61 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 128 62 have have VBP 3237 128 63 been be VBN 3237 128 64 tendered tender VBN 3237 128 65 . . . 3237 129 1 Neale neale JJ 3237 129 2 and and CC 3237 129 3 Carroll Carroll NNP 3237 129 4 lobby lobby NN 3237 129 5 for for IN 3237 129 6 composite composite JJ 3237 129 7 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 129 8 — — : 3237 129 9 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 129 10 made make VBD 3237 129 11 up up RP 3237 129 12 of of IN 3237 129 13 multiple multiple JJ 3237 129 14 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 129 15 — — : 3237 129 16 to to TO 3237 129 17 alleviate alleviate VB 3237 129 18 the the DT 3237 129 19 tension tension NN 3237 129 20 between between IN 3237 129 21 source source NN 3237 129 22 and and CC 3237 129 23 target target VB 3237 129 24 domains.66 domains.66 NNP 3237 129 25 Powell Powell NNP 3237 129 26 found find VBD 3237 129 27 composite composite JJ 3237 129 28 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 129 29 useful useful JJ 3237 129 30 for for IN 3237 129 31 facilitating facilitate VBG 3237 129 32 computer computer NN 3237 129 33 game game NN 3237 129 34 play play NN 3237 129 35 without without IN 3237 129 36 unduly unduly RB 3237 129 37 upsetting upsetting JJ 3237 129 38 users user NNS 3237 129 39 . . . 3237 130 1 She -PRON- PRP 3237 130 2 explains explain VBZ 3237 130 3 that that IN 3237 130 4 gamers gamer NNS 3237 130 5 have have VBP 3237 130 6 readily readily RB 3237 130 7 adopted adopt VBN 3237 130 8 the the DT 3237 130 9 tool tool NN 3237 130 10 or or CC 3237 130 11 inventory inventory NN 3237 130 12 bag bag NN 3237 130 13 from from IN 3237 130 14 which which WDT 3237 130 15 the the DT 3237 130 16 user user NN 3237 130 17 may may MD 3237 130 18 equip equip VB 3237 130 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 130 20 character character NN 3237 130 21 with with IN 3237 130 22 a a DT 3237 130 23 man- man- JJ 3237 130 24 nequin nequin NN 3237 130 25 style style NN 3237 130 26 “ " `` 3237 130 27 dress dress NN 3237 130 28 - - HYPH 3237 130 29 up up RP 3237 130 30 ” " '' 3237 130 31 panel panel NN 3237 130 32 . . . 3237 131 1 The the DT 3237 131 2 bag bag NN 3237 131 3 and and CC 3237 131 4 mannequin mannequin NN 3237 131 5 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 131 6 have have VBP 3237 131 7 no no DT 3237 131 8 real real JJ 3237 131 9 - - HYPH 3237 131 10 world world NN 3237 131 11 association association NN 3237 131 12 but but CC 3237 131 13 work work NN 3237 131 14 effectively.67 effectively.67 NNP 3237 131 15 Hsu Hsu NNP 3237 131 16 , , , 3237 131 17 investigating investigate VBG 3237 131 18 composite composite JJ 3237 131 19 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 131 20 , , , 3237 131 21 confirmed confirm VBD 3237 131 22 Neale Neale NNP 3237 131 23 and and CC 3237 131 24 Carroll Carroll NNP 3237 131 25 ’s ’s POS 3237 131 26 assertions assertion NNS 3237 131 27 and and CC 3237 131 28 found find VBD 3237 131 29 that that IN 3237 131 30 the the DT 3237 131 31 “ " `` 3237 131 32 closer close JJR 3237 131 33 the the DT 3237 131 34 mapping mapping NN 3237 131 35 between between IN 3237 131 36 designers designer NNS 3237 131 37 ’ ’ POS 3237 131 38 conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 131 39 models model NNS 3237 131 40 and and CC 3237 131 41 users user NNS 3237 131 42 ’ ’ POS 3237 131 43 mental mental JJ 3237 131 44 models model NNS 3237 131 45 , , , 3237 131 46 the the DT 3237 131 47 greater great JJR 3237 131 48 the the DT 3237 131 49 effect effect NN 3237 131 50 of of IN 3237 131 51 interface interface NN 3237 131 52 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 131 53 . . . 3237 131 54 ”68 ”68 NNP 3237 131 55 As as IN 3237 131 56 an an DT 3237 131 57 alternative alternative NN 3237 131 58 to to IN 3237 131 59 composite composite JJ 3237 131 60 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 131 61 , , , 3237 131 62 Khoury Khoury NNP 3237 131 63 and and CC 3237 131 64 Simoff Simoff NNP 3237 131 65 propose propose VBP 3237 131 66 a a DT 3237 131 67 new new JJ 3237 131 68 class class NN 3237 131 69 of of IN 3237 131 70 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 131 71 that that WDT 3237 131 72 they -PRON- PRP 3237 131 73 call call VBP 3237 131 74 “ " `` 3237 131 75 elastic elastic JJ 3237 131 76 . . . 3237 131 77 ” " '' 3237 131 78 They -PRON- PRP 3237 131 79 explain explain VBP 3237 131 80 that that IN 3237 131 81 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 131 82 in in IN 3237 131 83 language language NN 3237 131 84 are be VBP 3237 131 85 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 3237 131 86 , , , 3237 131 87 and and CC 3237 131 88 we -PRON- PRP 3237 131 89 must must MD 3237 131 90 deal deal VB 3237 131 91 with with IN 3237 131 92 them -PRON- PRP 3237 131 93 in in IN 3237 131 94 informa- informa- JJ 3237 131 95 tion tion NN 3237 131 96 technology technology NN 3237 131 97 . . . 3237 132 1 Rather rather RB 3237 132 2 than than IN 3237 132 3 focusing focus VBG 3237 132 4 on on IN 3237 132 5 concrete concrete JJ 3237 132 6 objects object NNS 3237 132 7 , , , 3237 132 8 however however RB 3237 132 9 , , , 3237 132 10 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 132 11 should should MD 3237 132 12 focus focus VB 3237 132 13 on on IN 3237 132 14 social social JJ 3237 132 15 structures structure NNS 3237 132 16 , , , 3237 132 17 such such JJ 3237 132 18 as as IN 3237 132 19 relationships relationship NNS 3237 132 20 in in IN 3237 132 21 game game NN 3237 132 22 play play NN 3237 132 23 . . . 3237 133 1 They -PRON- PRP 3237 133 2 conclude conclude VBP 3237 133 3 that that IN 3237 133 4 “ " `` 3237 133 5 elastic elastic JJ 3237 133 6 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 133 7 can can MD 3237 133 8 provide provide VB 3237 133 9 an an DT 3237 133 10 optimal optimal JJ 3237 133 11 mapping mapping NN 3237 133 12 from from IN 3237 133 13 source source NN 3237 133 14 to to TO 3237 133 15 target target VB 3237 133 16 domains domain NNS 3237 133 17 . . . 3237 133 18 ”69 ”69 NNP 3237 133 19 n n CC 3237 133 20 Conclusion Conclusion NNP 3237 133 21 Historically historically RB 3237 133 22 , , , 3237 133 23 in in IN 3237 133 24 HCI HCI NNP 3237 133 25 the the DT 3237 133 26 designer designer NN 3237 133 27 of of IN 3237 133 28 the the DT 3237 133 29 system system NN 3237 133 30 supplies supply VBZ 3237 133 31 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 133 32 to to TO 3237 133 33 help help VB 3237 133 34 the the DT 3237 133 35 user user NN 3237 133 36 understand understand VB 3237 133 37 the the DT 3237 133 38 system system NN 3237 133 39 better well RBR 3237 133 40 . . . 3237 134 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 3237 134 2 , , , 3237 134 3 this this DT 3237 134 4 format format NN 3237 134 5 falls fall VBZ 3237 134 6 prey prey NN 3237 134 7 to to IN 3237 134 8 Reddy Reddy NNP 3237 134 9 ’s ’s POS 3237 134 10 conduit conduit NN 3237 134 11 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 134 12 : : : 3237 134 13 the the DT 3237 134 14 receiver receiver NN 3237 134 15 of of IN 3237 134 16 the the DT 3237 134 17 information information NN 3237 134 18 is be VBZ 3237 134 19 left leave VBN 3237 134 20 out out IN 3237 134 21 of of IN 3237 134 22 the the DT 3237 134 23 communication communication NN 3237 134 24 process process NN 3237 134 25 . . . 3237 135 1 If if IN 3237 135 2 HCI HCI NNP 3237 135 3 is be VBZ 3237 135 4 to to TO 3237 135 5 learn learn VB 3237 135 6 from from IN 3237 135 7 human- human- NN 3237 135 8 to to IN 3237 135 9 - - HYPH 3237 135 10 human human JJ 3237 135 11 interaction interaction NN 3237 135 12 , , , 3237 135 13 then then RB 3237 135 14 the the DT 3237 135 15 user user NN 3237 135 16 of of IN 3237 135 17 the the DT 3237 135 18 system system NN 3237 135 19 should should MD 3237 135 20 be be VB 3237 135 21 able able JJ 3237 135 22 to to TO 3237 135 23 communicate communicate VB 3237 135 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 3237 135 25 or or CC 3237 135 26 her -PRON- PRP$ 3237 135 27 needs need NNS 3237 135 28 to to IN 3237 135 29 the the DT 3237 135 30 system system NN 3237 135 31 . . . 3237 136 1 If if IN 3237 136 2 the the DT 3237 136 3 system system NN 3237 136 4 does do VBZ 3237 136 5 not not RB 3237 136 6 have have VB 3237 136 7 the the DT 3237 136 8 capacity capacity NN 3237 136 9 to to TO 3237 136 10 understand understand VB 3237 136 11 the the DT 3237 136 12 request request NN 3237 136 13 , , , 3237 136 14 then then RB 3237 136 15 the the DT 3237 136 16 user user NN 3237 136 17 and and CC 3237 136 18 the the DT 3237 136 19 system system NN 3237 136 20 should should MD 3237 136 21 be be VB 3237 136 22 empow- empow- JJ 3237 136 23 ered ere VBN 3237 136 24 to to TO 3237 136 25 select select VB 3237 136 26 mutually mutually RB 3237 136 27 agreeable agreeable JJ 3237 136 28 simple simple JJ 3237 136 29 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 136 30 for for IN 3237 136 31 communicating communicate VBG 3237 136 32 . . . 3237 137 1 The the DT 3237 137 2 user user NN 3237 137 3 should should MD 3237 137 4 be be VB 3237 137 5 given give VBN 3237 137 6 the the DT 3237 137 7 option option NN 3237 137 8 to to TO 3237 137 9 choose choose VB 3237 137 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 3237 137 11 or or CC 3237 137 12 her -PRON- PRP$ 3237 137 13 own own JJ 3237 137 14 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 137 15 , , , 3237 137 16 and and CC 3237 137 17 the the DT 3237 137 18 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 137 19 , , , 3237 137 20 vocabulary vocabulary NN 3237 137 21 , , , 3237 137 22 and and CC 3237 137 23 “ " `` 3237 137 24 language language NN 3237 137 25 ” " '' 3237 137 26 created create VBN 3237 137 27 should should MD 3237 137 28 be be VB 3237 137 29 able able JJ 3237 137 30 to to TO 3237 137 31 evolve evolve VB 3237 137 32 as as IN 3237 137 33 the the DT 3237 137 34 boundaries boundary NNS 3237 137 35 of of IN 3237 137 36 the the DT 3237 137 37 comparison comparison NN 3237 137 38 are be VBP 3237 137 39 reached reach VBN 3237 137 40 . . . 3237 138 1 A a DT 3237 138 2 common common JJ 3237 138 3 complaint complaint NN 3237 138 4 from from IN 3237 138 5 users user NNS 3237 138 6 is be VBZ 3237 138 7 , , , 3237 138 8 “ " `` 3237 138 9 The the DT 3237 138 10 computer computer NN 3237 138 11 just just RB 3237 138 12 is be VBZ 3237 138 13 n’t not RB 3237 138 14 listening listen VBG 3237 138 15 to to IN 3237 138 16 me -PRON- PRP 3237 138 17 . . . 3237 138 18 ” " '' 3237 138 19 And and CC 3237 138 20 they -PRON- PRP 3237 138 21 are be VBP 3237 138 22 , , , 3237 138 23 of of IN 3237 138 24 course course NN 3237 138 25 , , , 3237 138 26 right right UH 3237 138 27 . . . 3237 139 1 The the DT 3237 139 2 field field NN 3237 139 3 of of IN 3237 139 4 information information NN 3237 139 5 science science NN 3237 139 6 , , , 3237 139 7 and and CC 3237 139 8 particularly particularly RB 3237 139 9 the the DT 3237 139 10 subfield subfield NN 3237 139 11 of of IN 3237 139 12 human human JJ 3237 139 13 information information NN 3237 139 14 behavior behavior NN 3237 139 15 , , , 3237 139 16 are be VBP 3237 139 17 in in IN 3237 139 18 a a DT 3237 139 19 unique unique JJ 3237 139 20 position position NN 3237 139 21 to to TO 3237 139 22 help help VB 3237 139 23 resolve resolve VB 3237 139 24 the the DT 3237 139 25 long long RB 3237 139 26 - - HYPH 3237 139 27 standing stand VBG 3237 139 28 debate debate NN 3237 139 29 over over IN 3237 139 30 the the DT 3237 139 31 use use NN 3237 139 32 of of IN 3237 139 33 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 139 34 in in IN 3237 139 35 HCI HCI NNP 3237 139 36 . . . 3237 140 1 From from IN 3237 140 2 Belkin Belkin NNP 3237 140 3 ’s ’s POS 3237 140 4 early early RB 3237 140 5 stated state VBN 3237 140 6 objec- objec- NN 3237 140 7 tives tive NNS 3237 140 8 to to TO 3237 140 9 improve improve VB 3237 140 10 information information NN 3237 140 11 systems system NNS 3237 140 12 to to IN 3237 140 13 Cole Cole NNP 3237 140 14 and and CC 3237 140 15 Leide Leide NNP 3237 140 16 ’s ’s POS 3237 140 17 pursuit pursuit NN 3237 140 18 of of IN 3237 140 19 metaphor metaphor NNP 3237 140 20 instantiation instantiation NN 3237 140 21 in in IN 3237 140 22 human human JJ 3237 140 23 information information NN 3237 140 24 organizing organize VBG 3237 140 25 behavior behavior NN 3237 140 26 , , , 3237 140 27 the the DT 3237 140 28 study study NN 3237 140 29 of of IN 3237 140 30 information information NN 3237 140 31 behavior behavior NN 3237 140 32 attempts attempt VBZ 3237 140 33 to to TO 3237 140 34 better well RBR 3237 140 35 understand understand VB 3237 140 36 and and CC 3237 140 37 ideally ideally RB 3237 140 38 facilitate facilitate VBP 3237 140 39 the the DT 3237 140 40 user user NN 3237 140 41 — — : 3237 140 42 assisting assist VBG 3237 140 43 them -PRON- PRP 3237 140 44 in in IN 3237 140 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 3237 140 46 acquisition acquisition NN 3237 140 47 and and CC 3237 140 48 application application NN 3237 140 49 of of IN 3237 140 50 information information NN 3237 140 51 . . . 3237 141 1 Metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 141 2 are be VBP 3237 141 3 clearly clearly RB 3237 141 4 utilized utilize VBN 3237 141 5 by by IN 3237 141 6 humans human NNS 3237 141 7 as as IN 3237 141 8 they -PRON- PRP 3237 141 9 communicate communicate VBP 3237 141 10 with with IN 3237 141 11 each each DT 3237 141 12 other other JJ 3237 141 13 , , , 3237 141 14 seek seek VB 3237 141 15 and and CC 3237 141 16 concep- concep- XX 3237 141 17 tualize tualize VB 3237 141 18 information information NN 3237 141 19 , , , 3237 141 20 and and CC 3237 141 21 solve solve VB 3237 141 22 problems problem NNS 3237 141 23 . . . 3237 142 1 To to TO 3237 142 2 improve improve VB 3237 142 3 the the DT 3237 142 4 interaction interaction NN 3237 142 5 between between IN 3237 142 6 human human NN 3237 142 7 and and CC 3237 142 8 computer computer NN 3237 142 9 , , , 3237 142 10 we -PRON- PRP 3237 142 11 must must MD 3237 142 12 first first RB 3237 142 13 gain gain VB 3237 142 14 better well JJR 3237 142 15 insight insight NN 3237 142 16 into into IN 3237 142 17 the the DT 3237 142 18 role role NN 3237 142 19 that that WDT 3237 142 20 metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 142 21 play play VBP 3237 142 22 in in IN 3237 142 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 3237 142 24 own own JJ 3237 142 25 interaction interaction NN 3237 142 26 with with IN 3237 142 27 information information NN 3237 142 28 . . . 3237 143 1 mEtaPHor mEtaPHor NNP 3237 143 2 ’s ’s POS 3237 143 3 rolE rolE , 3237 143 4 in in IN 3237 143 5 tHE the DT 3237 143 6 inFormation information NN 3237 143 7 BEHavior behavior NN 3237 143 8 oF of IN 3237 143 9 Humans human NNS 3237 143 10 intEractinG interact VBZ 3237 143 11 witH with IN 3237 143 12 comPutErs computers CD 3237 143 13 | | CD 3237 143 14 sEasE sease $ 3237 143 15 15 15 CD 3237 143 16 References reference NNS 3237 143 17 1 1 CD 3237 143 18 . . . 3237 144 1 Donald Donald NNP 3237 144 2 A. A. NNP 3237 144 3 Schön Schön NNP 3237 144 4 , , , 3237 144 5 “ " `` 3237 144 6 Generative Generative NNP 3237 144 7 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 144 8 , , , 3237 144 9 ” " '' 3237 144 10 in in IN 3237 144 11 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 144 12 and and CC 3237 144 13 Thought Thought NNP 3237 144 14 , , , 3237 144 15 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 144 16 ed ed NNP 3237 144 17 . . NNP 3237 144 18 , , , 3237 144 19 ed ed NNP 3237 144 20 . . . 3237 145 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3237 145 2 Ortony Ortony NNP 3237 145 3 ( ( -LRB- 3237 145 4 New New NNP 3237 145 5 York York NNP 3237 145 6 : : : 3237 145 7 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3237 145 8 Univ Univ NNP 3237 145 9 . . . 3237 146 1 Pr Pr NNP 3237 146 2 . . NNP 3237 146 3 , , , 3237 146 4 1993 1993 CD 3237 146 5 ) ) -RRB- 3237 146 6 : : : 3237 146 7 138 138 CD 3237 146 8 . . . 3237 147 1 2 2 LS 3237 147 2 . . . 3237 148 1 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 3237 148 2 , , , 3237 148 3 Rhetoric Rhetoric NNP 3237 148 4 , , , 3237 148 5 Book Book NNP 3237 148 6 III III NNP 3237 148 7 , , , 3237 148 8 Chapter chapter NN 3237 148 9 10 10 CD 3237 148 10 , , , 3237 148 11 ed ed NNP 3237 148 12 . . . 3237 149 1 Lee Lee NNP 3237 149 2 Honeycutt Honeycutt NNP 3237 149 3 , , , 3237 149 4 trans tran NNS 3237 149 5 . . . 3237 150 1 William William NNP 3237 150 2 R. R. NNP 3237 150 3 Roberts Roberts NNP 3237 150 4 , , , 3237 150 5 www.public.iastate.edu/~honeyl/ www.public.iastate.edu/~honeyl/ JJS 3237 150 6 Rhetoric rhetoric NN 3237 150 7 / / SYM 3237 150 8 rhet3 rhet3 NN 3237 150 9 - - HYPH 3237 150 10 10.html 10.html CD 3237 150 11 ( ( -LRB- 3237 150 12 accessed access VBN 3237 150 13 June June NNP 3237 150 14 25 25 CD 3237 150 15 , , , 3237 150 16 2008 2008 CD 3237 150 17 ) ) -RRB- 3237 150 18 . . . 3237 151 1 3 3 LS 3237 151 2 . . . 3237 152 1 George George NNP 3237 152 2 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 152 3 and and CC 3237 152 4 Mark Mark NNP 3237 152 5 Johnson Johnson NNP 3237 152 6 , , , 3237 152 7 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 152 8 We -PRON- PRP 3237 152 9 Live live VBP 3237 152 10 By by IN 3237 152 11 ( ( -LRB- 3237 152 12 Chicago Chicago NNP 3237 152 13 : : : 3237 152 14 Univ Univ NNP 3237 152 15 . . . 3237 153 1 of of IN 3237 153 2 Chicago Chicago NNP 3237 153 3 Pr Pr NNP 3237 153 4 . . NNP 3237 153 5 , , , 3237 153 6 1980 1980 CD 3237 153 7 ) ) -RRB- 3237 153 8 : : : 3237 153 9 5 5 CD 3237 153 10 . . . 3237 154 1 4 4 LS 3237 154 2 . . . 3237 155 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3237 155 2 Ortony Ortony NNP 3237 155 3 , , , 3237 155 4 “ " `` 3237 155 5 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 155 6 , , , 3237 155 7 Language Language NNP 3237 155 8 , , , 3237 155 9 and and CC 3237 155 10 Thought Thought NNP 3237 155 11 , , , 3237 155 12 ” " '' 3237 155 13 in in IN 3237 155 14 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 155 15 and and CC 3237 155 16 Thought Thought NNP 3237 155 17 , , , 3237 155 18 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 155 19 ed ed NNP 3237 155 20 . . NNP 3237 155 21 , , , 3237 155 22 ed ed NNP 3237 155 23 . . . 3237 156 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3237 156 2 Ortony Ortony NNP 3237 156 3 ( ( -LRB- 3237 156 4 New New NNP 3237 156 5 York York NNP 3237 156 6 : : : 3237 156 7 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3237 156 8 Univ Univ NNP 3237 156 9 . . . 3237 157 1 Pr Pr NNP 3237 157 2 . . NNP 3237 157 3 , , , 3237 157 4 1979/1993 1979/1993 CD 3237 157 5 ) ) -RRB- 3237 157 6 : : : 3237 157 7 1–18 1–18 CD 3237 157 8 . . . 3237 158 1 5 5 CD 3237 158 2 . . . 3237 159 1 Robert Robert NNP 3237 159 2 Sternberg Sternberg NNP 3237 159 3 , , , 3237 159 4 Roger Roger NNP 3237 159 5 Tourangeau Tourangeau NNP 3237 159 6 , , , 3237 159 7 and and CC 3237 159 8 Georgia Georgia NNP 3237 159 9 Nigro Nigro NNP 3237 159 10 , , , 3237 159 11 “ " `` 3237 159 12 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 159 13 , , , 3237 159 14 Induction Induction NNP 3237 159 15 , , , 3237 159 16 and and CC 3237 159 17 Social Social NNP 3237 159 18 Policy Policy NNP 3237 159 19 : : : 3237 159 20 The the DT 3237 159 21 Convergence Convergence NNP 3237 159 22 of of IN 3237 159 23 Macroscopic Macroscopic NNP 3237 159 24 and and CC 3237 159 25 Microscopic Microscopic NNP 3237 159 26 Views Views NNPS 3237 159 27 , , , 3237 159 28 ” " '' 3237 159 29 in in IN 3237 159 30 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 159 31 and and CC 3237 159 32 Thought Thought NNP 3237 159 33 , , , 3237 159 34 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 159 35 ed ed NNP 3237 159 36 . . NNP 3237 159 37 , , , 3237 159 38 ed ed NNP 3237 159 39 . . . 3237 160 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3237 160 2 Ortony Ortony NNP 3237 160 3 ( ( -LRB- 3237 160 4 New New NNP 3237 160 5 York York NNP 3237 160 6 : : : 3237 160 7 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3237 160 8 Univ Univ NNP 3237 160 9 . . . 3237 161 1 Pr Pr NNP 3237 161 2 . . NNP 3237 161 3 , , , 3237 161 4 1979/1993 1979/1993 CD 3237 161 5 ) ) -RRB- 3237 161 6 : : : 3237 161 7 277–303 277–303 CD 3237 161 8 . . . 3237 162 1 6 6 CD 3237 162 2 . . . 3237 163 1 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 163 2 and and CC 3237 163 3 Johnson Johnson NNP 3237 163 4 , , , 3237 163 5 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 163 6 We -PRON- PRP 3237 163 7 Live live VBP 3237 163 8 By by IN 3237 163 9 , , , 3237 163 10 9 9 CD 3237 163 11 . . . 3237 164 1 7 7 LS 3237 164 2 . . . 3237 165 1 George George NNP 3237 165 2 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 165 3 , , , 3237 165 4 “ " `` 3237 165 5 The the DT 3237 165 6 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 3237 165 7 Theory Theory NNP 3237 165 8 of of IN 3237 165 9 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 165 10 , , , 3237 165 11 ” " '' 3237 165 12 in in IN 3237 165 13 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 165 14 and and CC 3237 165 15 Thought Thought NNP 3237 165 16 , , , 3237 165 17 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 165 18 ed ed NNP 3237 165 19 . . NNP 3237 165 20 , , , 3237 165 21 ed ed NNP 3237 165 22 . . . 3237 166 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3237 166 2 Ortony Ortony NNP 3237 166 3 ( ( -LRB- 3237 166 4 New New NNP 3237 166 5 York York NNP 3237 166 6 : : : 3237 166 7 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3237 166 8 Univ Univ NNP 3237 166 9 . . . 3237 167 1 Pr Pr NNP 3237 167 2 . . NNP 3237 167 3 , , , 3237 167 4 1979/1993 1979/1993 CD 3237 167 5 ) ) -RRB- 3237 167 6 : : : 3237 167 7 194 194 CD 3237 167 8 . . . 3237 168 1 8 8 LS 3237 168 2 . . . 3237 169 1 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 169 2 and and CC 3237 169 3 Johnson Johnson NNP 3237 169 4 , , , 3237 169 5 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 169 6 We -PRON- PRP 3237 169 7 Live live VBP 3237 169 8 By by IN 3237 169 9 . . . 3237 170 1 9 9 CD 3237 170 2 . . . 3237 171 1 Michael Michael NNP 3237 171 2 J. J. NNP 3237 171 3 Reddy Reddy NNP 3237 171 4 , , , 3237 171 5 “ " `` 3237 171 6 The the DT 3237 171 7 Conduit Conduit NNP 3237 171 8 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 171 9 , , , 3237 171 10 ” " '' 3237 171 11 in in IN 3237 171 12 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 171 13 and and CC 3237 171 14 Thought Thought NNP 3237 171 15 , , , 3237 171 16 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 171 17 ed ed NNP 3237 171 18 . . NNP 3237 171 19 , , , 3237 171 20 ed ed NNP 3237 171 21 . . . 3237 172 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3237 172 2 Ortony Ortony NNP 3237 172 3 ( ( -LRB- 3237 172 4 New New NNP 3237 172 5 York York NNP 3237 172 6 : : : 3237 172 7 Cam- Cam- NNP 3237 172 8 bridge bridge NN 3237 172 9 Univ Univ NNP 3237 172 10 . . . 3237 173 1 Pr Pr NNP 3237 173 2 . . NNP 3237 173 3 , , , 3237 173 4 1993 1993 CD 3237 173 5 ) ) -RRB- 3237 173 6 : : : 3237 173 7 174–201 174–201 CD 3237 173 8 . . . 3237 174 1 10 10 CD 3237 174 2 . . . 3237 175 1 Ibid ibid RB 3237 175 2 . . . 3237 176 1 11 11 CD 3237 176 2 . . . 3237 177 1 Alan Alan NNP 3237 177 2 Paivio Paivio NNP 3237 177 3 and and CC 3237 177 4 Mary Mary NNP 3237 177 5 Walsh Walsh NNP 3237 177 6 , , , 3237 177 7 “ " `` 3237 177 8 Psychological psychological JJ 3237 177 9 Processes Processes NNPS 3237 177 10 in in IN 3237 177 11 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 177 12 Comprehension Comprehension NNP 3237 177 13 and and CC 3237 177 14 Memory memory NN 3237 177 15 , , , 3237 177 16 ” " '' 3237 177 17 in in IN 3237 177 18 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 177 19 and and CC 3237 177 20 Thought Thought NNP 3237 177 21 , , , 3237 177 22 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 177 23 ed ed NNP 3237 177 24 . . NNP 3237 177 25 , , , 3237 177 26 ed ed NNP 3237 177 27 . . . 3237 178 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3237 178 2 Ortony Ortony NNP 3237 178 3 ( ( -LRB- 3237 178 4 New New NNP 3237 178 5 York York NNP 3237 178 6 : : : 3237 178 7 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3237 178 8 Univ Univ NNP 3237 178 9 . . . 3237 179 1 Pr Pr NNP 3237 179 2 . . NNP 3237 179 3 , , , 3237 179 4 1979/1993 1979/1993 CD 3237 179 5 ) ) -RRB- 3237 179 6 : : : 3237 179 7 307–28 307–28 CD 3237 179 8 . . . 3237 180 1 12 12 CD 3237 180 2 . . . 3237 181 1 Sam Sam NNP 3237 181 2 Glucksberg Glucksberg NNP 3237 181 3 and and CC 3237 181 4 Boaz Boaz NNP 3237 181 5 Keysar Keysar NNP 3237 181 6 , , , 3237 181 7 “ " `` 3237 181 8 How how WRB 3237 181 9 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 181 10 Work work VBP 3237 181 11 , , , 3237 181 12 ” " '' 3237 181 13 in in IN 3237 181 14 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 181 15 and and CC 3237 181 16 Thought Thought NNP 3237 181 17 , , , 3237 181 18 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 181 19 ed ed NNP 3237 181 20 . . NNP 3237 181 21 , , , 3237 181 22 ed ed NNP 3237 181 23 . . . 3237 182 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3237 182 2 Ortony Ortony NNP 3237 182 3 ( ( -LRB- 3237 182 4 New New NNP 3237 182 5 York York NNP 3237 182 6 : : : 3237 182 7 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3237 182 8 Univ Univ NNP 3237 182 9 . . . 3237 183 1 Pr Pr NNP 3237 183 2 . . NNP 3237 183 3 , , , 3237 183 4 1993 1993 CD 3237 183 5 ) ) -RRB- 3237 183 6 : : : 3237 183 7 408 408 CD 3237 183 8 . . . 3237 184 1 13 13 CD 3237 184 2 . . . 3237 185 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3237 185 2 . . . 3237 185 3 , , , 3237 185 4 401 401 CD 3237 185 5 . . . 3237 186 1 14 14 CD 3237 186 2 . . . 3237 187 1 Dedre Dedre NNP 3237 187 2 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 187 3 , , , 3237 187 4 “ " `` 3237 187 5 Reasoning reason VBG 3237 187 6 and and CC 3237 187 7 Learning Learning NNP 3237 187 8 by by IN 3237 187 9 Analogy Analogy NNP 3237 187 10 , , , 3237 187 11 ” " '' 3237 187 12 American American NNP 3237 187 13 Psychologist Psychologist NNP 3237 187 14 52 52 CD 3237 187 15 , , , 3237 187 16 no no UH 3237 187 17 . . . 3237 188 1 1 1 CD 3237 188 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 188 3 1997 1997 CD 3237 188 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 188 5 : : : 3237 188 6 33 33 CD 3237 188 7 . . . 3237 189 1 15 15 CD 3237 189 2 . . . 3237 190 1 Judith Judith NNP 3237 190 2 E. E. NNP 3237 190 3 Weiner Weiner NNP 3237 190 4 , , , 3237 190 5 “ " `` 3237 190 6 A a DT 3237 190 7 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3237 190 8 Representation Representation NNP 3237 190 9 Approach Approach NNP 3237 190 10 to to IN 3237 190 11 Understanding Understanding NNP 3237 190 12 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 190 13 , , , 3237 190 14 ” " '' 3237 190 15 Computational Computational NNP 3237 190 16 Linguistics Linguistics NNP 3237 190 17 10 10 CD 3237 190 18 , , , 3237 190 19 no no UH 3237 190 20 . . . 3237 191 1 1 1 CD 3237 191 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 191 3 1984 1984 CD 3237 191 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 191 5 : : : 3237 191 6 1–14 1–14 CD 3237 191 7 . . . 3237 192 1 16 16 CD 3237 192 2 . . . 3237 193 1 George George NNP 3237 193 2 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 193 3 , , , 3237 193 4 “ " `` 3237 193 5 Position Position NNP 3237 193 6 Paper Paper NNP 3237 193 7 on on IN 3237 193 8 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 193 9 , , , 3237 193 10 ” " '' 3237 193 11 Proceed- Proceed- NNP 3237 193 12 ings ing NNS 3237 193 13 of of IN 3237 193 14 the the DT 3237 193 15 1987 1987 CD 3237 193 16 Workshop Workshop NNP 3237 193 17 on on IN 3237 193 18 Theoretical Theoretical NNP 3237 193 19 Issues Issues NNPS 3237 193 20 in in IN 3237 193 21 Natural Natural NNP 3237 193 22 Language Language NNP 3237 193 23 Processing Processing NNP 3237 193 24 ( ( -LRB- 3237 193 25 Morristown Morristown NNP 3237 193 26 , , , 3237 193 27 N.J. New Jersey NNP 3237 193 28 : : : 3237 193 29 Association Association NNP 3237 193 30 for for IN 3237 193 31 Computational Computational NNP 3237 193 32 Linguistics Linguistics NNP 3237 193 33 , , , 3237 193 34 1987 1987 CD 3237 193 35 ) ) -RRB- 3237 193 36 : : : 3237 193 37 94–197 94–197 CD 3237 193 38 . . . 3237 194 1 17 17 CD 3237 194 2 . . . 3237 195 1 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 195 2 , , , 3237 195 3 “ " `` 3237 195 4 Reasoning reasoning NN 3237 195 5 , , , 3237 195 6 ” " '' 3237 195 7 106 106 CD 3237 195 8 . . . 3237 196 1 18 18 CD 3237 196 2 . . . 3237 197 1 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 197 2 , , , 3237 197 3 “ " `` 3237 197 4 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 3237 197 5 Theory Theory NNP 3237 197 6 , , , 3237 197 7 ” " '' 3237 197 8 210 210 CD 3237 197 9 . . . 3237 198 1 19 19 CD 3237 198 2 . . . 3237 199 1 Jaron Jaron NNP 3237 199 2 Lanier Lanier NNP 3237 199 3 , , , 3237 199 4 “ " `` 3237 199 5 Jaron Jaron NNP 3237 199 6 ’s ’s POS 3237 199 7 World World NNP 3237 199 8 : : : 3237 199 9 The the DT 3237 199 10 Meaning Meaning NNP 3237 199 11 of of IN 3237 199 12 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 199 13 , , , 3237 199 14 ” " '' 3237 199 15 Discover Discover NNP 3237 199 16 ( ( -LRB- 3237 199 17 Mind Mind NNP 3237 199 18 and and CC 3237 199 19 Brain Brain NNP 3237 199 20 ) ) -RRB- 3237 199 21 28 28 CD 3237 199 22 , , , 3237 199 23 no no UH 3237 199 24 . . . 3237 200 1 2 2 CD 3237 200 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 200 3 2007 2007 CD 3237 200 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 200 5 , , , 3237 200 6 http://discover http://discover NNP 3237 200 7 magazine.com/2007/feb/jarons-world-metaphors-vocabulary magazine.com/2007/feb/jarons-world-metaphors-vocabulary NNP 3237 200 8 ( ( -LRB- 3237 200 9 accessed access VBN 3237 200 10 June June NNP 3237 200 11 25 25 CD 3237 200 12 , , , 3237 200 13 2008 2008 CD 3237 200 14 ) ) -RRB- 3237 200 15 . . . 3237 201 1 20 20 CD 3237 201 2 . . . 3237 202 1 Lakoff Lakoff NNP 3237 202 2 and and CC 3237 202 3 Johnson Johnson NNP 3237 202 4 , , , 3237 202 5 “ " `` 3237 202 6 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 202 7 . . . 3237 202 8 ” " '' 3237 202 9 21 21 CD 3237 202 10 . . . 3237 203 1 David David NNP 3237 203 2 Ritchie Ritchie NNP 3237 203 3 , , , 3237 203 4 “ " `` 3237 203 5 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 203 6 in in IN 3237 203 7 Conversational Conversational NNP 3237 203 8 Context Context NNP 3237 203 9 : : : 3237 203 10 Toward toward IN 3237 203 11 a a DT 3237 203 12 Connectivity Connectivity NNP 3237 203 13 Theory Theory NNP 3237 203 14 of of IN 3237 203 15 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 203 16 Interpretation Interpretation NNP 3237 203 17 , , , 3237 203 18 ” " '' 3237 203 19 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 203 20 and and CC 3237 203 21 Symbol Symbol NNP 3237 203 22 19 19 CD 3237 203 23 , , , 3237 203 24 no no UH 3237 203 25 . . . 3237 204 1 4 4 CD 3237 204 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 204 3 2004 2004 CD 3237 204 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 204 5 : : : 3237 204 6 265–87 265–87 CD 3237 204 7 . . . 3237 205 1 22 22 CD 3237 205 2 . . . 3237 206 1 Amanda Amanda NNP 3237 206 2 Spink Spink NNP 3237 206 3 and and CC 3237 206 4 Charles Charles NNP 3237 206 5 Cole Cole NNP 3237 206 6 , , , 3237 206 7 “ " `` 3237 206 8 A a DT 3237 206 9 Human Human NNP 3237 206 10 Information Information NNP 3237 206 11 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 206 12 Approach Approach NNP 3237 206 13 to to IN 3237 206 14 a a DT 3237 206 15 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 3237 206 16 of of IN 3237 206 17 Information information NN 3237 206 18 , , , 3237 206 19 ” " '' 3237 206 20 Library Library NNP 3237 206 21 Trends Trends NNP 3237 206 22 52 52 CD 3237 206 23 , , , 3237 206 24 no no UH 3237 206 25 . . . 3237 207 1 3 3 CD 3237 207 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 207 3 2004 2004 CD 3237 207 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 207 5 : : : 3237 207 6 617–28 617–28 LS 3237 207 7 ; ; : 3237 207 8 Amanda Amanda NNP 3237 207 9 Spink Spink NNP 3237 207 10 and and CC 3237 207 11 James James NNP 3237 207 12 Currier Currier NNP 3237 207 13 , , , 3237 207 14 “ " `` 3237 207 15 Towards towards IN 3237 207 16 an an DT 3237 207 17 Evolutionary Evolutionary NNP 3237 207 18 Perspective Perspective NNP 3237 207 19 for for IN 3237 207 20 Human Human NNP 3237 207 21 Information Information NNP 3237 207 22 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 207 23 : : : 3237 207 24 An An NNP 3237 207 25 Exploratory Exploratory NNP 3237 207 26 Study Study NNP 3237 207 27 , , , 3237 207 28 ” " '' 3237 207 29 Journal Journal NNP 3237 207 30 of of IN 3237 207 31 Documentation Documentation NNP 3237 207 32 62 62 CD 3237 207 33 , , , 3237 207 34 no no UH 3237 207 35 . . . 3237 208 1 2 2 CD 3237 208 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 208 3 2006 2006 CD 3237 208 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 208 5 : : : 3237 208 6 171–93 171–93 CD 3237 208 7 ; ; : 3237 208 8 Amanda Amanda NNP 3237 208 9 Spink Spink NNP 3237 208 10 and and CC 3237 208 11 James James NNP 3237 208 12 Currier Currier NNP 3237 208 13 , , , 3237 208 14 “ " `` 3237 208 15 Emerg- Emerg- NNP 3237 208 16 ing ing NNP 3237 208 17 Evolutionary Evolutionary NNP 3237 208 18 Approach Approach NNP 3237 208 19 to to IN 3237 208 20 Human Human NNP 3237 208 21 Information Information NNP 3237 208 22 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 208 23 , , , 3237 208 24 ” " '' 3237 208 25 in in IN 3237 208 26 New New NNP 3237 208 27 Directions Directions NNPS 3237 208 28 in in IN 3237 208 29 Human Human NNP 3237 208 30 Information Information NNP 3237 208 31 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 208 32 , , , 3237 208 33 ed ed NN 3237 208 34 . . . 3237 209 1 Amanda Amanda NNP 3237 209 2 Spink Spink NNP 3237 209 3 and and CC 3237 209 4 Charles Charles NNP 3237 209 5 Cole Cole NNP 3237 209 6 , , , 3237 209 7 ol old JJ 3237 209 8 . . . 3237 210 1 8 8 CD 3237 210 2 of of IN 3237 210 3 Information Information NNP 3237 210 4 Science Science NNP 3237 210 5 and and CC 3237 210 6 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3237 210 7 Management Management NNP 3237 210 8 ( ( -LRB- 3237 210 9 Netherlands Netherlands NNP 3237 210 10 : : : 3237 210 11 Springer Springer NNP 3237 210 12 , , , 3237 210 13 2006 2006 CD 3237 210 14 ) ) -RRB- 3237 210 15 : : : 3237 210 16 170–202 170–202 CD 3237 210 17 . . . 3237 211 1 23 23 CD 3237 211 2 . . . 3237 212 1 Spink Spink NNP 3237 212 2 and and CC 3237 212 3 Currier Currier NNP 3237 212 4 , , , 3237 212 5 “ " `` 3237 212 6 Towards towards IN 3237 212 7 an an DT 3237 212 8 Evolutionary Evolutionary NNP 3237 212 9 Perspec- Perspec- NNP 3237 212 10 tive tive JJ 3237 212 11 . . . 3237 212 12 ” " '' 3237 212 13 24 24 CD 3237 212 14 . . . 3237 213 1 Amanda Amanda NNP 3237 213 2 Spink Spink NNP 3237 213 3 and and CC 3237 213 4 Charles Charles NNP 3237 213 5 Cole Cole NNP 3237 213 6 , , , 3237 213 7 “ " `` 3237 213 8 Human Human NNP 3237 213 9 Information Information NNP 3237 213 10 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 213 11 : : : 3237 213 12 Integrating integrate VBG 3237 213 13 Diverse diverse JJ 3237 213 14 Approaches approach NNS 3237 213 15 and and CC 3237 213 16 Information Information NNP 3237 213 17 Use Use NNP 3237 213 18 , , , 3237 213 19 ” " '' 3237 213 20 Journal Journal NNP 3237 213 21 of of IN 3237 213 22 the the DT 3237 213 23 American American NNP 3237 213 24 Society Society NNP 3237 213 25 for for IN 3237 213 26 Science Science NNP 3237 213 27 and and CC 3237 213 28 Technology Technology NNP 3237 213 29 57 57 CD 3237 213 30 , , , 3237 213 31 no no UH 3237 213 32 . . . 3237 214 1 1 1 CD 3237 214 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 214 3 2005 2005 CD 3237 214 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 214 5 : : : 3237 214 6 25 25 CD 3237 214 7 . . . 3237 215 1 25 25 CD 3237 215 2 . . . 3237 216 1 Charles Charles NNP 3237 216 2 Cole Cole NNP 3237 216 3 and and CC 3237 216 4 John John NNP 3237 216 5 E. E. NNP 3237 216 6 Leide Leide NNP 3237 216 7 , , , 3237 216 8 “ " `` 3237 216 9 A a DT 3237 216 10 Cognitive Cognitive NNP 3237 216 11 Framework Framework NNP 3237 216 12 for for IN 3237 216 13 Human Human NNP 3237 216 14 Information Information NNP 3237 216 15 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 216 16 : : : 3237 216 17 The the DT 3237 216 18 Place Place NNP 3237 216 19 of of IN 3237 216 20 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 216 21 in in IN 3237 216 22 Human Human NNP 3237 216 23 Information Information NNP 3237 216 24 Organizing Organizing NNP 3237 216 25 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 216 26 ” " '' 3237 216 27 in in IN 3237 216 28 New New NNP 3237 216 29 Directions Directions NNPS 3237 216 30 in in IN 3237 216 31 Human Human NNP 3237 216 32 Information Information NNP 3237 216 33 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 216 34 ed ed NNP 3237 216 35 . . . 3237 217 1 Amanda Amanda NNP 3237 217 2 Spink Spink NNP 3237 217 3 and and CC 3237 217 4 Charles Charles NNP 3237 217 5 Cole Cole NNP 3237 217 6 , , , 3237 217 7 vol vol NNP 3237 217 8 . . . 3237 218 1 8 8 CD 3237 218 2 of of IN 3237 218 3 Information Information NNP 3237 218 4 Science Science NNP 3237 218 5 and and CC 3237 218 6 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3237 218 7 Management Management NNP 3237 218 8 ( ( -LRB- 3237 218 9 Nether- Nether- NNP 3237 218 10 lands land NNS 3237 218 11 : : : 3237 218 12 Springer Springer NNP 3237 218 13 , , , 3237 218 14 2006 2006 CD 3237 218 15 ) ) -RRB- 3237 218 16 : : : 3237 218 17 174 174 CD 3237 218 18 . . . 3237 219 1 26 26 CD 3237 219 2 . . . 3237 220 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3237 220 2 . . . 3237 220 3 , , , 3237 220 4 173 173 CD 3237 220 5 . . . 3237 221 1 27 27 CD 3237 221 2 . . . 3237 222 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3237 222 2 . . . 3237 222 3 , , , 3237 222 4 198 198 CD 3237 222 5 . . . 3237 223 1 28 28 CD 3237 223 2 . . . 3237 224 1 Weiner Weiner NNP 3237 224 2 , , , 3237 224 3 “ " `` 3237 224 4 A a DT 3237 224 5 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3237 224 6 Representation Representation NNP 3237 224 7 Approach Approach NNP 3237 224 8 ” " '' 3237 224 9 ; ; : 3237 224 10 Gent- Gent- NNP 3237 224 11 ner ner NNP 3237 224 12 , , , 3237 224 13 “ " `` 3237 224 14 Reasoning Reasoning NNP 3237 224 15 and and CC 3237 224 16 Learning Learning NNP 3237 224 17 . . . 3237 224 18 ” " '' 3237 224 19 29 29 CD 3237 224 20 . . . 3237 225 1 Nicholas Nicholas NNP 3237 225 2 J. J. NNP 3237 225 3 Belkin Belkin NNP 3237 225 4 , , , 3237 225 5 “ " `` 3237 225 6 Anomalous Anomalous NNP 3237 225 7 State State NNP 3237 225 8 of of IN 3237 225 9 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3237 225 10 for for IN 3237 225 11 Information Information NNP 3237 225 12 Retrieval Retrieval NNP 3237 225 13 , , , 3237 225 14 ” " '' 3237 225 15 Canadian canadian JJ 3237 225 16 Journal Journal NNP 3237 225 17 of of IN 3237 225 18 Information Information NNP 3237 225 19 Science Science NNP 3237 225 20 5 5 CD 3237 225 21 ( ( -LRB- 3237 225 22 1980 1980 CD 3237 225 23 ) ) -RRB- 3237 225 24 : : : 3237 225 25 133–43 133–43 CD 3237 225 26 . . . 3237 226 1 30 30 CD 3237 226 2 . . . 3237 227 1 Donald Donald NNP 3237 227 2 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 227 3 and and CC 3237 227 4 Jacob Jacob NNP 3237 227 5 Nielson Nielson NNP 3237 227 6 , , , 3237 227 7 “ " `` 3237 227 8 The the DT 3237 227 9 Anti Anti NNP 3237 227 10 - - NNP 3237 227 11 Mac Mac NNP 3237 227 12 Inter- Inter- NNP 3237 227 13 face face NN 3237 227 14 , , , 3237 227 15 ” " '' 3237 227 16 Communications communication NNS 3237 227 17 of of IN 3237 227 18 the the DT 3237 227 19 ACM ACM NNP 3237 227 20 39 39 CD 3237 227 21 , , , 3237 227 22 no no UH 3237 227 23 . . . 3237 228 1 8 8 CD 3237 228 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 228 3 1996 1996 CD 3237 228 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 228 5 : : : 3237 228 6 70–82 70–82 CD 3237 228 7 . . . 3237 229 1 31 31 CD 3237 229 2 . . . 3237 230 1 Richard Richard NNP 3237 230 2 M. M. NNP 3237 230 3 Chisholm Chisholm NNP 3237 230 4 , , , 3237 230 5 “ " `` 3237 230 6 New New NNP 3237 230 7 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 230 8 for for IN 3237 230 9 Understand- Understand- NNP 3237 230 10 ing e VBG 3237 230 11 the the DT 3237 230 12 New New NNP 3237 230 13 Machines Machines NNPS 3237 230 14 ” " '' 3237 230 15 Proceedings proceeding NNS 3237 230 16 of of IN 3237 230 17 the the DT 3237 230 18 4th 4th JJ 3237 230 19 Annual Annual NNP 3237 230 20 International International NNP 3237 230 21 Conference Conference NNP 3237 230 22 on on IN 3237 230 23 Systems Systems NNPS 3237 230 24 Documentation Documentation NNP 3237 230 25 ( ( -LRB- 3237 230 26 New New NNP 3237 230 27 York York NNP 3237 230 28 : : : 3237 230 29 ACM ACM NNP 3237 230 30 , , , 3237 230 31 1986 1986 CD 3237 230 32 ) ) -RRB- 3237 230 33 : : : 3237 230 34 91 91 CD 3237 230 35 . . . 3237 231 1 32 32 CD 3237 231 2 . . . 3237 232 1 Aaron Aaron NNP 3237 232 2 Marcus Marcus NNP 3237 232 3 , , , 3237 232 4 “ " `` 3237 232 5 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 232 6 Design Design NNP 3237 232 7 in in IN 3237 232 8 User User NNP 3237 232 9 Interfaces Interfaces NNPS 3237 232 10 : : : 3237 232 11 How how WRB 3237 232 12 to to TO 3237 232 13 Effectively effectively RB 3237 232 14 Manage manage VB 3237 232 15 Expectation Expectation NNP 3237 232 16 , , , 3237 232 17 Surprise Surprise NNP 3237 232 18 , , , 3237 232 19 Comprehen- Comprehen- NNP 3237 232 20 sion sion NN 3237 232 21 , , , 3237 232 22 and and CC 3237 232 23 Delight Delight NNP 3237 232 24 ” " '' 3237 232 25 in in IN 3237 232 26 Conference Conference NNP 3237 232 27 Companion Companion NNP 3237 232 28 on on IN 3237 232 29 Human Human NNP 3237 232 30 Factors Factors NNPS 3237 232 31 in in IN 3237 232 32 Computing Computing NNP 3237 232 33 Systems Systems NNPS 3237 232 34 CHI CHI NNP 3237 232 35 ‘ ' `` 3237 232 36 95 95 CD 3237 232 37 , , , 3237 232 38 ed ed NN 3237 232 39 . . . 3237 233 1 Irivin Irivin NNP 3237 233 2 Katz Katz NNP 3237 233 3 , , , 3237 233 4 Robert Robert NNP 3237 233 5 Mack Mack NNP 3237 233 6 , , , 3237 233 7 and and CC 3237 233 8 Linn Linn NNP 3237 233 9 Marks Marks NNP 3237 233 10 ( ( -LRB- 3237 233 11 New New NNP 3237 233 12 York York NNP 3237 233 13 : : : 3237 233 14 ACM ACM NNP 3237 233 15 , , , 3237 233 16 1995 1995 CD 3237 233 17 ) ) -RRB- 3237 233 18 : : : 3237 233 19 373–74 373–74 CD 3237 233 20 . . . 3237 234 1 33 33 CD 3237 234 2 . . . 3237 235 1 Benjamin Benjamin NNP 3237 235 2 Fineman Fineman NNP 3237 235 3 , , , 3237 235 4 “ " `` 3237 235 5 Computers computer NNS 3237 235 6 as as IN 3237 235 7 People People NNS 3237 235 8 : : : 3237 235 9 Human Human NNP 3237 235 10 Inter- Inter- NNP 3237 235 11 action action NN 3237 235 12 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 235 13 in in IN 3237 235 14 Human Human NNP 3237 235 15 - - HYPH 3237 235 16 Computer Computer NNP 3237 235 17 Interaction Interaction NNP 3237 235 18 ( ( -LRB- 3237 235 19 master master NNP 3237 235 20 ’s ’s POS 3237 235 21 thesis thesis NN 3237 235 22 , , , 3237 235 23 Carnegie Carnegie NNP 3237 235 24 - - HYPH 3237 235 25 Mellon Mellon NNP 3237 235 26 University University NNP 3237 235 27 , , , 3237 235 28 2004 2004 CD 3237 235 29 ) ) -RRB- 3237 235 30 , , , 3237 235 31 www.mildabandon www.mildabandon NNP 3237 235 32 .com .com . 3237 235 33 / / SYM 3237 235 34 paper paper NN 3237 235 35 / / SYM 3237 235 36 paper.pdf paper.pdf NNP 3237 235 37 ( ( -LRB- 3237 235 38 accessed access VBN 3237 235 39 June June NNP 3237 235 40 25 25 CD 3237 235 41 , , , 3237 235 42 2008 2008 CD 3237 235 43 ) ) -RRB- 3237 235 44 . . . 3237 236 1 34 34 CD 3237 236 2 . . . 3237 237 1 Ibid ibid RB 3237 237 2 . . . 3237 238 1 35 35 CD 3237 238 2 . . . 3237 239 1 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 239 2 and and CC 3237 239 3 Nielson Nielson NNP 3237 239 4 , , , 3237 239 5 “ " `` 3237 239 6 The the DT 3237 239 7 Anti Anti NNP 3237 239 8 - - NNP 3237 239 9 Mac Mac NNP 3237 239 10 Interface Interface NNP 3237 239 11 . . . 3237 239 12 ” " '' 3237 239 13 36 36 CD 3237 239 14 . . . 3237 240 1 Alan Alan NNP 3237 240 2 Kay Kay NNP 3237 240 3 , , , 3237 240 4 Doing do VBG 3237 240 5 with with IN 3237 240 6 Images image NNS 3237 240 7 Makes make VBZ 3237 240 8 Symbols Symbols NNPS 3237 240 9 ( ( -LRB- 3237 240 10 University University NNP 3237 240 11 Video Video NNP 3237 240 12 Communications Communications NNPS 3237 240 13 , , , 3237 240 14 1987 1987 CD 3237 240 15 ) ) -RRB- 3237 240 16 , , , 3237 240 17 Flash Flash NNP 3237 240 18 Video Video NNP 3237 240 19 File File NNP 3237 240 20 , , , 3237 240 21 http://video http://video ADD 3237 240 22 .google.com .google.com . 3237 240 23 / / SYM 3237 240 24 videoplay?docid=-533537336174204822 videoplay?docid=-533537336174204822 NN 3237 240 25 ( ( -LRB- 3237 240 26 accessed access VBN 3237 240 27 June June NNP 3237 240 28 25 25 CD 3237 240 29 , , , 3237 240 30 2008 2008 CD 3237 240 31 ) ) -RRB- 3237 240 32 . . . 3237 241 1 37 37 CD 3237 241 2 . . . 3237 242 1 Alan Alan NNP 3237 242 2 F. F. NNP 3237 242 3 Blackwell Blackwell NNP 3237 242 4 , , , 3237 242 5 “ " `` 3237 242 6 The the DT 3237 242 7 Reification Reification NNP 3237 242 8 of of IN 3237 242 9 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 242 10 as as IN 3237 242 11 a a DT 3237 242 12 Design Design NNP 3237 242 13 Tool Tool NNP 3237 242 14 , , , 3237 242 15 ” " '' 3237 242 16 ACM ACM NNP 3237 242 17 Transactions Transactions NNPS 3237 242 18 on on IN 3237 242 19 Computer Computer NNP 3237 242 20 - - HYPH 3237 242 21 Human Human NNP 3237 242 22 Interaction Interaction NNP 3237 242 23 13 13 CD 3237 242 24 , , , 3237 242 25 no no UH 3237 242 26 . . . 3237 243 1 4 4 CD 3237 243 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 243 3 2006 2006 CD 3237 243 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 243 5 : : : 3237 243 6 490–530 490–530 CD 3237 243 7 . . . 3237 244 1 38 38 CD 3237 244 2 . . . 3237 245 1 John John NNP 3237 245 2 M. M. NNP 3237 245 3 Carroll Carroll NNP 3237 245 4 and and CC 3237 245 5 John John NNP 3237 245 6 C. C. NNP 3237 245 7 Thomas Thomas NNP 3237 245 8 , , , 3237 245 9 “ " `` 3237 245 10 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 245 11 and and CC 3237 245 12 the the DT 3237 245 13 Cognitive Cognitive NNP 3237 245 14 Representation Representation NNP 3237 245 15 of of IN 3237 245 16 Computing Computing NNP 3237 245 17 Systems Systems NNPS 3237 245 18 , , , 3237 245 19 ” " '' 3237 245 20 IEEE IEEE NNP 3237 245 21 Transac- Transac- NNP 3237 245 22 tions tion NNS 3237 245 23 on on IN 3237 245 24 Systems Systems NNPS 3237 245 25 , , , 3237 245 26 Man Man NNP 3237 245 27 and and CC 3237 245 28 Cybernetics Cybernetics NNP 3237 245 29 12 12 CD 3237 245 30 , , , 3237 245 31 no no UH 3237 245 32 . . . 3237 246 1 2 2 CD 3237 246 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 246 3 1982 1982 CD 3237 246 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 246 5 : : : 3237 246 6 108 108 CD 3237 246 7 . . . 3237 247 1 39 39 CD 3237 247 2 . . . 3237 248 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3237 248 2 . . . 3237 248 3 , , , 3237 248 4 113 113 CD 3237 248 5 . . . 3237 249 1 40 40 CD 3237 249 2 . . . 3237 250 1 Donald Donald NNP 3237 250 2 Case Case NNP 3237 250 3 , , , 3237 250 4 “ " `` 3237 250 5 Conceptual Conceptual NNP 3237 250 6 Organization Organization NNP 3237 250 7 and and CC 3237 250 8 Retrieval Retrieval NNP 3237 250 9 of of IN 3237 250 10 Text Text NNP 3237 250 11 by by IN 3237 250 12 Historians Historians NNPS 3237 250 13 : : : 3237 250 14 The the DT 3237 250 15 Role Role NNP 3237 250 16 of of IN 3237 250 17 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 250 18 and and CC 3237 250 19 Memory Memory NNP 3237 250 20 , , , 3237 250 21 ” " '' 3237 250 22 Journal Journal NNP 3237 250 23 of of IN 3237 250 24 the the DT 3237 250 25 American American NNP 3237 250 26 Society Society NNP 3237 250 27 for for IN 3237 250 28 Information Information NNP 3237 250 29 Science Science NNP 3237 250 30 42 42 CD 3237 250 31 , , , 3237 250 32 no no UH 3237 250 33 . . . 3237 251 1 9 9 CD 3237 251 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 251 3 1991 1991 CD 3237 251 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 251 5 : : : 3237 251 6 657–68 657–68 CD 3237 251 7 . . . 3237 252 1 41 41 CD 3237 252 2 . . . 3237 253 1 Aaron Aaron NNP 3237 253 2 Marcus Marcus NNP 3237 253 3 , , , 3237 253 4 “ " `` 3237 253 5 Managing manage VBG 3237 253 6 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 253 7 for for IN 3237 253 8 Advanced Advanced NNP 3237 253 9 User User NNP 3237 253 10 Interface Interface NNP 3237 253 11 , , , 3237 253 12 ” " '' 3237 253 13 Proceedings proceeding NNS 3237 253 14 of of IN 3237 253 15 International International NNP 3237 253 16 Workshop Workshop NNP 3237 253 17 AVI AVI NNP 3237 253 18 ’ ' '' 3237 253 19 94 94 CD 3237 253 20 ( ( -LRB- 3237 253 21 New New NNP 3237 253 22 York York NNP 3237 253 23 : : : 3237 253 24 ACM ACM NNP 3237 253 25 , , , 3237 253 26 1994 1994 CD 3237 253 27 ) ) -RRB- 3237 253 28 : : : 3237 253 29 14 14 CD 3237 253 30 . . . 3237 254 1 16 16 CD 3237 254 2 inFormation information NN 3237 254 3 tEcHnoloGY technology NN 3237 254 4 anD and CC 3237 254 5 liBrariEs libraries NN 3237 254 6 | | NNP 3237 254 7 DEcEmBEr DEcEmBEr NNP 3237 254 8 2008 2008 CD 3237 254 9 42 42 CD 3237 254 10 . . . 3237 255 1 Ibid ibid RB 3237 255 2 . . . 3237 256 1 43 43 CD 3237 256 2 . . . 3237 257 1 Allan Allan NNP 3237 257 2 MacLean MacLean NNP 3237 257 3 , , , 3237 257 4 Victoria Victoria NNP 3237 257 5 Bellotti Bellotti NNP 3237 257 6 , , , 3237 257 7 Richard Richard NNP 3237 257 8 Young Young NNP 3237 257 9 , , , 3237 257 10 and and CC 3237 257 11 Thomas Thomas NNP 3237 257 12 Moran Moran NNP 3237 257 13 , , , 3237 257 14 “ " `` 3237 257 15 Reaching reach VBG 3237 257 16 Through through IN 3237 257 17 Analogy analogy NN 3237 257 18 : : : 3237 257 19 A a DT 3237 257 20 Design Design NNP 3237 257 21 Ratio- Ratio- NNP 3237 257 22 nale nale NN 3237 257 23 Perspective Perspective NNP 3237 257 24 on on IN 3237 257 25 Roles Roles NNPS 3237 257 26 of of IN 3237 257 27 Analogy Analogy NNP 3237 257 28 ” " '' 3237 257 29 in in IN 3237 257 30 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 3237 257 31 of of IN 3237 257 32 CHI CHI NNP 3237 257 33 ‘ ' `` 3237 257 34 91 91 CD 3237 257 35 Conference Conference NNP 3237 257 36 on on IN 3237 257 37 Human Human NNP 3237 257 38 Factors Factors NNPS 3237 257 39 in in IN 3237 257 40 Computer Computer NNP 3237 257 41 Systems Systems NNPS 3237 257 42 ( ( -LRB- 3237 257 43 New New NNP 3237 257 44 York York NNP 3237 257 45 : : : 3237 257 46 ACM ACM NNP 3237 257 47 Press Press NNP 3237 257 48 , , , 3237 257 49 1991 1991 CD 3237 257 50 ) ) -RRB- 3237 257 51 , , , 3237 257 52 167–72 167–72 CD 3237 257 53 . . . 3237 258 1 44 44 CD 3237 258 2 . . . 3237 259 1 Chilsolm Chilsolm NNP 3237 259 2 , , , 3237 259 3 “ " `` 3237 259 4 New New NNP 3237 259 5 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 259 6 , , , 3237 259 7 ” " '' 3237 259 8 90 90 CD 3237 259 9 . . . 3237 260 1 45 45 CD 3237 260 2 . . . 3237 261 1 Gerald Gerald NNP 3237 261 2 J. J. NNP 3237 261 3 Johnson Johnson NNP 3237 261 4 , , , 3237 261 5 “ " `` 3237 261 6 Of of IN 3237 261 7 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 261 8 and and CC 3237 261 9 the the DT 3237 261 10 Difficulty Difficulty NNP 3237 261 11 of of IN 3237 261 12 Computer Computer NNP 3237 261 13 Discourse Discourse NNP 3237 261 14 , , , 3237 261 15 ” " '' 3237 261 16 Communications communication NNS 3237 261 17 of of IN 3237 261 18 the the DT 3237 261 19 ACM ACM NNP 3237 261 20 37 37 CD 3237 261 21 , , , 3237 261 22 no no UH 3237 261 23 . . . 3237 262 1 12 12 CD 3237 262 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 262 3 1994 1994 CD 3237 262 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 262 5 : : : 3237 262 6 97–102 97–102 CD 3237 262 7 . . . 3237 263 1 46 46 CD 3237 263 2 . . . 3237 264 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3237 264 2 . . . 3237 264 3 , , , 3237 264 4 101 101 CD 3237 264 5 . . . 3237 265 1 47 47 CD 3237 265 2 . . . 3237 266 1 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 266 2 and and CC 3237 266 3 Nielson Nielson NNP 3237 266 4 , , , 3237 266 5 “ " `` 3237 266 6 The the DT 3237 266 7 Anti Anti NNP 3237 266 8 - - NNP 3237 266 9 Mac Mac NNP 3237 266 10 Interface Interface NNP 3237 266 11 . . . 3237 266 12 ” " '' 3237 266 13 48 48 CD 3237 266 14 . . . 3237 267 1 Chisolm Chisolm NNP 3237 267 2 , , , 3237 267 3 “ " `` 3237 267 4 New New NNP 3237 267 5 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 267 6 , , , 3237 267 7 ” " '' 3237 267 8 90 90 CD 3237 267 9 . . . 3237 268 1 49 49 CD 3237 268 2 . . . 3237 269 1 Frank Frank NNP 3237 269 2 Halasz Halasz NNP 3237 269 3 and and CC 3237 269 4 Thomas Thomas NNP 3237 269 5 P. P. NNP 3237 269 6 Moran Moran NNP 3237 269 7 , , , 3237 269 8 “ " `` 3237 269 9 Analogy Analogy NNP 3237 269 10 Consid- Consid- NNP 3237 269 11 ered ere VBD 3237 269 12 Harmful harmful JJ 3237 269 13 , , , 3237 269 14 ” " '' 3237 269 15 International International NNP 3237 269 16 Journal Journal NNP 3237 269 17 of of IN 3237 269 18 Man Man NNP 3237 269 19 - - HYPH 3237 269 20 Machine Machine NNP 3237 269 21 Studies Studies NNPS 3237 269 22 14 14 CD 3237 269 23 ( ( -LRB- 3237 269 24 1981 1981 CD 3237 269 25 ) ) -RRB- 3237 269 26 : : : 3237 269 27 383 383 CD 3237 269 28 . . . 3237 270 1 50 50 CD 3237 270 2 . . . 3237 271 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3237 271 2 . . . 3237 271 3 , , , 3237 271 4 185 185 CD 3237 271 5 . . . 3237 272 1 51 51 CD 3237 272 2 . . . 3237 273 1 Marcus Marcus NNP 3237 273 2 , , , 3237 273 3 “ " `` 3237 273 4 Managing manage VBG 3237 273 5 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 273 6 , , , 3237 273 7 ” " '' 3237 273 8 14 14 CD 3237 273 9 . . . 3237 274 1 52 52 CD 3237 274 2 . . . 3237 275 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3237 275 2 . . . 3237 275 3 , , , 3237 275 4 16 16 CD 3237 275 5 . . . 3237 276 1 53 53 CD 3237 276 2 . . . 3237 277 1 Alan Alan NNP 3237 277 2 Cooper Cooper NNP 3237 277 3 , , , 3237 277 4 “ " `` 3237 277 5 The the DT 3237 277 6 Myth Myth NNP 3237 277 7 of of IN 3237 277 8 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 277 9 ” " '' 3237 277 10 originally originally RB 3237 277 11 pub- pub- RB 3237 277 12 lished lishe VBN 3237 277 13 in in IN 3237 277 14 Visual Visual NNP 3237 277 15 Basic Basic NNP 3237 277 16 Programmer Programmer NNP 3237 277 17 ’s ’s POS 3237 277 18 Journal Journal NNP 3237 277 19 ( ( -LRB- 3237 277 20 July July NNP 3237 277 21 1995 1995 CD 3237 277 22 ) ) -RRB- 3237 277 23 , , , 3237 277 24 www www NNP 3237 277 25 .cooper.com .cooper.com NNP 3237 277 26 / / SYM 3237 277 27 articles article NNS 3237 277 28 / / SYM 3237 277 29 art_myth_of_metaphor.htm art_myth_of_metaphor.htm JJ 3237 277 30 ( ( -LRB- 3237 277 31 accessed access VBN 3237 277 32 June June NNP 3237 277 33 25 25 CD 3237 277 34 , , , 3237 277 35 2008 2008 CD 3237 277 36 ) ) -RRB- 3237 277 37 . . . 3237 278 1 54 54 CD 3237 278 2 . . . 3237 279 1 Tim Tim NNP 3237 279 2 Rohrer Rohrer NNP 3237 279 3 , , , 3237 279 4 “ " `` 3237 279 5 Metaphors metaphor NNS 3237 279 6 We -PRON- PRP 3237 279 7 Compute compute VBP 3237 279 8 By by IN 3237 279 9 : : : 3237 279 10 Bringing bring VBG 3237 279 11 Magic Magic NNP 3237 279 12 into into IN 3237 279 13 Interface Interface NNP 3237 279 14 Design Design NNP 3237 279 15 , , , 3237 279 16 ” " '' 3237 279 17 ( ( -LRB- 3237 279 18 1995 1995 CD 3237 279 19 ) ) -RRB- 3237 279 20 , , , 3237 279 21 http://zakros.ucsd.edu/~trohrer/ http://zakros.ucsd.edu/~trohrer/ NNP 3237 279 22 metaphor metaphor NN 3237 279 23 / / SYM 3237 279 24 gui4web.htm gui4web.htm NN 3237 279 25 ( ( -LRB- 3237 279 26 accessed access VBN 3237 279 27 June June NNP 3237 279 28 25 25 CD 3237 279 29 , , , 3237 279 30 2008 2008 CD 3237 279 31 ) ) -RRB- 3237 279 32 . . . 3237 280 1 55 55 CD 3237 280 2 . . . 3237 281 1 Gentner Gentner NNP 3237 281 2 and and CC 3237 281 3 Nielson Nielson NNP 3237 281 4 , , , 3237 281 5 “ " `` 3237 281 6 The the DT 3237 281 7 Anti Anti NNP 3237 281 8 - - NNP 3237 281 9 Mac Mac NNP 3237 281 10 Interface Interface NNP 3237 281 11 . . . 3237 281 12 ” " '' 3237 281 13 56 56 CD 3237 281 14 . . . 3237 282 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3237 282 2 . . . 3237 282 3 , , , 3237 282 4 74 74 CD 3237 282 5 57 57 CD 3237 282 6 . . . 3237 283 1 Ibid ibid RB 3237 283 2 . . . 3237 284 1 58 58 CD 3237 284 2 . . . 3237 285 1 Blackwell Blackwell NNP 3237 285 2 , , , 3237 285 3 “ " `` 3237 285 4 The the DT 3237 285 5 Reification Reification NNP 3237 285 6 of of IN 3237 285 7 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 285 8 , , , 3237 285 9 ” " '' 3237 285 10 493 493 CD 3237 285 11 . . . 3237 286 1 59 59 CD 3237 286 2 . . . 3237 287 1 Handbook Handbook NNP 3237 287 2 of of IN 3237 287 3 Human Human NNP 3237 287 4 Computer Computer NNP 3237 287 5 Interaction Interaction NNP 3237 287 6 , , , 3237 287 7 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 287 8 rev rev NNP 3237 287 9 . . . 3237 288 1 ed ed NNP 3237 288 2 . . NNP 3237 288 3 , , , 3237 288 4 ed ed NNP 3237 288 5 . . . 3237 289 1 Martin Martin NNP 3237 289 2 Helander Helander NNP 3237 289 3 , , , 3237 289 4 Thomas Thomas NNP 3237 289 5 Landauer Landauer NNP 3237 289 6 , , , 3237 289 7 and and CC 3237 289 8 P. P. NNP 3237 289 9 Prabhu Prabhu NNP 3237 289 10 ( ( -LRB- 3237 289 11 Amster- Amster- NNP 3237 289 12 dam dam NN 3237 289 13 : : : 3237 289 14 Elsevier Elsevier NNP 3237 289 15 Science Science NNP 3237 289 16 Pub Pub NNP 3237 289 17 . . . 3237 290 1 B.V. B.V. NNP 3237 290 2 , , , 3237 290 3 1998 1998 CD 3237 290 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 290 5 . . . 3237 291 1 60 60 CD 3237 291 2 . . . 3237 292 1 James James NNP 3237 292 2 Hollan Hollan NNP 3237 292 3 , , , 3237 292 4 Benjamin Benjamin NNP 3237 292 5 Bederson Bederson NNP 3237 292 6 , , , 3237 292 7 and and CC 3237 292 8 Jonathan Jonathan NNP 3237 292 9 Helfman Helfman NNP 3237 292 10 , , , 3237 292 11 “ " `` 3237 292 12 Information Information NNP 3237 292 13 Visualization Visualization NNP 3237 292 14 ” " '' 3237 292 15 in in IN 3237 292 16 Handbook Handbook NNP 3237 292 17 of of IN 3237 292 18 Human Human NNP 3237 292 19 Computer Computer NNP 3237 292 20 Interaction Interaction NNP 3237 292 21 , , , 3237 292 22 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 292 23 rev rev NNP 3237 292 24 . . . 3237 293 1 ed ed NNP 3237 293 2 . . NNP 3237 293 3 , , , 3237 293 4 ed ed NNP 3237 293 5 . . . 3237 294 1 Martin Martin NNP 3237 294 2 Helander Helander NNP 3237 294 3 , , , 3237 294 4 Thomas Thomas NNP 3237 294 5 Landauer Landauer NNP 3237 294 6 , , , 3237 294 7 and and CC 3237 294 8 P. P. NNP 3237 294 9 Prabhu Prabhu NNP 3237 294 10 ( ( -LRB- 3237 294 11 Amsterdam Amsterdam NNP 3237 294 12 : : : 3237 294 13 Elsevier Elsevier NNP 3237 294 14 Science Science NNP 3237 294 15 Pub Pub NNP 3237 294 16 . . . 3237 295 1 B.V. B.V. NNP 3237 295 2 , , , 3237 295 3 1998 1998 CD 3237 295 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 295 5 , , , 3237 295 6 441–62 441–62 CD 3237 295 7 . . . 3237 296 1 61 61 CD 3237 296 2 . . . 3237 297 1 Dennis Dennis NNP 3237 297 2 C. C. NNP 3237 297 3 Neale Neale NNP 3237 297 4 and and CC 3237 297 5 John John NNP 3237 297 6 M. M. NNP 3237 297 7 Carroll Carroll NNP 3237 297 8 , , , 3237 297 9 “ " `` 3237 297 10 The the DT 3237 297 11 Role role NN 3237 297 12 of of IN 3237 297 13 Meta- meta- NN 3237 297 14 phors phor NNS 3237 297 15 in in IN 3237 297 16 User User NNP 3237 297 17 Interface Interface NNP 3237 297 18 Design Design NNP 3237 297 19 ” " '' 3237 297 20 in in IN 3237 297 21 Handbook Handbook NNP 3237 297 22 of of IN 3237 297 23 Human Human NNP 3237 297 24 Computer Computer NNP 3237 297 25 Interaction Interaction NNP 3237 297 26 , , , 3237 297 27 2nd 2nd NNP 3237 297 28 rev rev NNP 3237 297 29 . . . 3237 298 1 ed ed NNP 3237 298 2 . . NNP 3237 298 3 , , , 3237 298 4 ed ed NNP 3237 298 5 . . . 3237 299 1 Martin Martin NNP 3237 299 2 Helander Helander NNP 3237 299 3 , , , 3237 299 4 Thomas Thomas NNP 3237 299 5 Landauer Landauer NNP 3237 299 6 and and CC 3237 299 7 P. P. NNP 3237 299 8 Prabhu Prabhu NNP 3237 299 9 ( ( -LRB- 3237 299 10 Amsterdam Amsterdam NNP 3237 299 11 : : : 3237 299 12 Elsevier Elsevier NNP 3237 299 13 Science Science NNP 3237 299 14 Pub Pub NNP 3237 299 15 . . . 3237 300 1 B.V. B.V. NNP 3237 300 2 , , , 3237 300 3 1998 1998 CD 3237 300 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 300 5 : : : 3237 300 6 447 447 CD 3237 300 7 . . . 3237 301 1 62 62 CD 3237 301 2 . . . 3237 302 1 A. A. NNP 3237 302 2 F. F. NNP 3237 302 3 Blackwell Blackwell NNP 3237 302 4 and and CC 3237 302 5 T. T. NNP 3237 302 6 R. R. NNP 3237 302 7 G. G. NNP 3237 302 8 Green Green NNP 3237 302 9 , , , 3237 302 10 “ " `` 3237 302 11 Does do VBZ 3237 302 12 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 302 13 Increase increase VB 3237 302 14 Visual visual JJ 3237 302 15 Language language NN 3237 302 16 Usability usability NN 3237 302 17 ? ? . 3237 302 18 ” " '' 3237 302 19 in in IN 3237 302 20 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 3237 302 21 1999 1999 CD 3237 302 22 IEEE IEEE NNP 3237 302 23 Symposium Symposium NNP 3237 302 24 on on IN 3237 302 25 Visual Visual NNP 3237 302 26 Languages language NNS 3237 302 27 ( ( -LRB- 3237 302 28 1999 1999 CD 3237 302 29 ) ) -RRB- 3237 302 30 : : : 3237 302 31 246–53 246–53 CD 3237 302 32 . . . 3237 303 1 ; ; : 3237 303 2 Lee Lee NNP 3237 303 3 Ratzan Ratzan NNP 3237 303 4 , , , 3237 303 5 “ " `` 3237 303 6 Making make VBG 3237 303 7 Sense Sense NNP 3237 303 8 of of IN 3237 303 9 the the DT 3237 303 10 Web web NN 3237 303 11 : : : 3237 303 12 A a DT 3237 303 13 Metaphorical Metaphorical NNP 3237 303 14 Approach Approach NNP 3237 303 15 , , , 3237 303 16 ” " '' 3237 303 17 Informa- Informa- NNP 3237 303 18 tion tion NN 3237 303 19 Research Research NNP 3237 303 20 6 6 CD 3237 303 21 , , , 3237 303 22 no no UH 3237 303 23 . . . 3237 304 1 1 1 CD 3237 304 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 304 3 2000 2000 CD 3237 304 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 304 5 , , , 3237 304 6 http://informationr.net/ir/6-1/ http://informationr.net/ir/6-1/ NNP 3237 304 7 paper85.html paper85.html NNP 3237 304 8 ( ( -LRB- 3237 304 9 accessed access VBD 3237 304 10 June June NNP 3237 304 11 25 25 CD 3237 304 12 , , , 3237 304 13 2008 2008 CD 3237 304 14 ) ) -RRB- 3237 304 15 ; ; : 3237 304 16 Christopher Christopher NNP 3237 304 17 R. R. NNP 3237 304 18 Wolfe Wolfe NNP 3237 304 19 , , , 3237 304 20 “ " `` 3237 304 21 Plant Plant NNP 3237 304 22 a a NNP 3237 304 23 Tree Tree NNP 3237 304 24 in in IN 3237 304 25 Cyberspace Cyberspace NNP 3237 304 26 : : : 3237 304 27 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 304 28 and and CC 3237 304 29 Analogy Analogy NNP 3237 304 30 as as IN 3237 304 31 Design Design NNP 3237 304 32 Elements Elements NNPS 3237 304 33 in in IN 3237 304 34 Web web NN 3237 304 35 - - HYPH 3237 304 36 Based base VBN 3237 304 37 Learning Learning NNP 3237 304 38 Environments Environments NNPS 3237 304 39 , , , 3237 304 40 ” " '' 3237 304 41 CyberPsychol- cyberpsychol- NN 3237 304 42 ogy ogy NN 3237 304 43 & & CC 3237 304 44 Behavior Behavior NNP 3237 304 45 4 4 CD 3237 304 46 , , , 3237 304 47 no no UH 3237 304 48 . . . 3237 305 1 1 1 CD 3237 305 2 ( ( -LRB- 3237 305 3 2001 2001 CD 3237 305 4 ) ) -RRB- 3237 305 5 : : : 3237 305 6 67–76 67–76 LS 3237 305 7 ; ; : 3237 305 8 Muna Muna NNP 3237 305 9 K. K. NNP 3237 305 10 Yousef Yousef NNP 3237 305 11 , , , 3237 305 12 “ " `` 3237 305 13 Legal legal JJ 3237 305 14 , , , 3237 305 15 Social Social NNP 3237 305 16 , , , 3237 305 17 Theoretical theoretical JJ 3237 305 18 and and CC 3237 305 19 Fundamental fundamental JJ 3237 305 20 Aspects Aspects NNPS 3237 305 21 : : : 3237 305 22 Assessment Assessment NNP 3237 305 23 of of IN 3237 305 24 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 305 25 Efficacy Efficacy NNP 3237 305 26 in in IN 3237 305 27 User User NNP 3237 305 28 Interfaces Interfaces NNP 3237 305 29 for for IN 3237 305 30 the the DT 3237 305 31 Elderly elderly JJ 3237 305 32 : : : 3237 305 33 A a DT 3237 305 34 Tentative Tentative NNP 3237 305 35 Model Model NNP 3237 305 36 for for IN 3237 305 37 Enhancing enhance VBG 3237 305 38 Accessibility accessibility NN 3237 305 39 , , , 3237 305 40 ” " '' 3237 305 41 Proceedings proceeding NNS 3237 305 42 of of IN 3237 305 43 the the DT 3237 305 44 2001 2001 CD 3237 305 45 EC/ ec/ CD 3237 305 46 NSF NSF NNP 3237 305 47 Workshop Workshop NNP 3237 305 48 on on IN 3237 305 49 Universal Universal NNP 3237 305 50 Accessibility Accessibility NNP 3237 305 51 of of IN 3237 305 52 Ubiquitous ubiquitous JJ 3237 305 53 Computing computing NN 3237 305 54 : : : 3237 305 55 Providing provide VBG 3237 305 56 For for IN 3237 305 57 the the DT 3237 305 58 Elderly elderly JJ 3237 305 59 ( ( -LRB- 3237 305 60 New New NNP 3237 305 61 York York NNP 3237 305 62 : : : 3237 305 63 ACM ACM NNP 3237 305 64 , , , 3237 305 65 2001 2001 CD 3237 305 66 ) ) -RRB- 3237 305 67 : : : 3237 305 68 120–24 120–24 CD 3237 305 69 . . . 3237 306 1 63 63 CD 3237 306 2 . . . 3237 307 1 Pippin Pippin NNP 3237 307 2 Barr Barr NNP 3237 307 3 , , , 3237 307 4 Robert Robert NNP 3237 307 5 Biddle Biddle NNP 3237 307 6 , , , 3237 307 7 and and CC 3237 307 8 James James NNP 3237 307 9 Noble Noble NNP 3237 307 10 , , , 3237 307 11 “ " `` 3237 307 12 A a DT 3237 307 13 Tax- Tax- NNP 3237 307 14 onomy onomy NN 3237 307 15 of of IN 3237 307 16 User User NNP 3237 307 17 Interface Interface NNP 3237 307 18 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 307 19 ” " '' 3237 307 20 Proceedings Proceedings NNPS 3237 307 21 of of IN 3237 307 22 SIGCHI SIGCHI NNP 3237 307 23 - - HYPH 3237 307 24 NZ NZ NNP 3237 307 25 Symposium Symposium NNP 3237 307 26 On on IN 3237 307 27 Computer Computer NNP 3237 307 28 - - HYPH 3237 307 29 Human Human NNP 3237 307 30 Interaction Interaction NNP 3237 307 31 ( ( -LRB- 3237 307 32 CHINZ CHINZ NNP 3237 307 33 2002 2002 CD 3237 307 34 ) ) -RRB- 3237 307 35 ( ( -LRB- 3237 307 36 Ham- Ham- NNP 3237 307 37 ilton ilton NN 3237 307 38 , , , 3237 307 39 New New NNP 3237 307 40 Zealand Zealand NNP 3237 307 41 : : : 3237 307 42 Australian Australian NNP 3237 307 43 Computer Computer NNP 3237 307 44 Society Society NNP 3237 307 45 , , , 3237 307 46 2002 2002 CD 3237 307 47 ) ) -RRB- 3237 307 48 : : : 3237 307 49 6 6 CD 3237 307 50 . . . 3237 308 1 64 64 CD 3237 308 2 . . . 3237 309 1 Alan Alan NNP 3237 309 2 F. F. NNP 3237 309 3 Blackwell Blackwell NNP 3237 309 4 , , , 3237 309 5 “ " `` 3237 309 6 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 309 7 in in IN 3237 309 8 Diagrams Diagrams NNP 3237 309 9 ” " '' 3237 309 10 ( ( -LRB- 3237 309 11 PhD PhD NNP 3237 309 12 diss diss NNP 3237 309 13 . . NNP 3237 309 14 , , , 3237 309 15 Darwin Darwin NNP 3237 309 16 College College NNP 3237 309 17 , , , 3237 309 18 Univ Univ NNP 3237 309 19 . . . 3237 310 1 of of IN 3237 310 2 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3237 310 3 , , , 3237 310 4 1998 1998 CD 3237 310 5 ) ) -RRB- 3237 310 6 , , , 3237 310 7 www.cl.cam www.cl.cam NNP 3237 310 8 .ac.uk/~afb21 .ac.uk/~afb21 . 3237 310 9 / / SYM 3237 310 10 publications publication NNS 3237 310 11 / / SYM 3237 310 12 thesis thesis NN 3237 310 13 / / SYM 3237 310 14 blackwell blackwell NNP 3237 310 15 - - HYPH 3237 310 16 thesis.pdf thesis.pdf NNP 3237 310 17 ( ( -LRB- 3237 310 18 accessed access VBN 3237 310 19 June June NNP 3237 310 20 25 25 CD 3237 310 21 , , , 3237 310 22 2008 2008 CD 3237 310 23 ) ) -RRB- 3237 310 24 : : : 3237 310 25 1 1 LS 3237 310 26 . . . 3237 311 1 65 65 CD 3237 311 2 . . . 3237 312 1 David David NNP 3237 312 2 G. G. NNP 3237 312 3 Hendry Hendry NNP 3237 312 4 , , , 3237 312 5 “ " `` 3237 312 6 Sketching sketch VBG 3237 312 7 with with IN 3237 312 8 Conceptual conceptual JJ 3237 312 9 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 312 10 to to TO 3237 312 11 Explain explain VB 3237 312 12 Computational computational JJ 3237 312 13 Processes Processes NNPS 3237 312 14 ” " '' 3237 312 15 Visutal Visutal NNP 3237 312 16 Languages Languages NNPS 3237 312 17 and and CC 3237 312 18 Human Human NNP 3237 312 19 - - HYPH 3237 312 20 Centric Centric NNP 3237 312 21 Computing Computing NNP 3237 312 22 ( ( -LRB- 3237 312 23 VL VL NNP 3237 312 24 - - HYPH 3237 312 25 HCC HCC NNP 3237 312 26 ‘ ' `` 3237 312 27 06 06 CD 3237 312 28 ) ) -RRB- 3237 312 29 , , , 3237 312 30 ( ( -LRB- 3237 312 31 Piscataway Piscataway NNP 3237 312 32 , , , 3237 312 33 N.J. New Jersey NNP 3237 312 34 : : : 3237 312 35 IEEE IEEE NNP 3237 312 36 , , , 3237 312 37 2006 2006 CD 3237 312 38 ) ) -RRB- 3237 312 39 : : : 3237 312 40 7 7 LS 3237 312 41 . . . 3237 313 1 66 66 CD 3237 313 2 . . . 3237 314 1 Neale Neale NNP 3237 314 2 and and CC 3237 314 3 Carroll Carroll NNP 3237 314 4 , , , 3237 314 5 “ " `` 3237 314 6 The the DT 3237 314 7 Role Role NNP 3237 314 8 of of IN 3237 314 9 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 314 10 in in IN 3237 314 11 User User NNP 3237 314 12 Inter- Inter- NNP 3237 314 13 face face NN 3237 314 14 Design Design NNP 3237 314 15 . . . 3237 314 16 ” " '' 3237 314 17 67 67 CD 3237 314 18 . . . 3237 315 1 Amy Amy NNP 3237 315 2 Powell Powell NNP 3237 315 3 , , , 3237 315 4 “ " `` 3237 315 5 Composite Composite NNP 3237 315 6 Metaphor Metaphor NNP 3237 315 7 , , , 3237 315 8 Games Games NNPS 3237 315 9 and and CC 3237 315 10 Inter- Inter- NNP 3237 315 11 face face NN 3237 315 12 ” " '' 3237 315 13 Proceedings proceeding NNS 3237 315 14 of of IN 3237 315 15 the the DT 3237 315 16 Second Second NNP 3237 315 17 Australasian Australasian NNP 3237 315 18 Conference Conference NNP 3237 315 19 on on IN 3237 315 20 inter- inter- XX 3237 315 21 active active JJ 3237 315 22 Entertainment entertainment NN 3237 315 23 : : : 3237 315 24 vol vol NNP 3237 315 25 . . . 3237 316 1 123 123 CD 3237 316 2 , , , 3237 316 3 ACM ACM NNP 3237 316 4 International International NNP 3237 316 5 Conference Conference NNP 3237 316 6 Proceeding Proceeding NNP 3237 316 7 Series Series NNP 3237 316 8 ( ( -LRB- 3237 316 9 Sydney Sydney NNP 3237 316 10 , , , 3237 316 11 Australia Australia NNP 3237 316 12 : : : 3237 316 13 Creativity Creativity NNP 3237 316 14 & & CC 3237 316 15 Cognition Cognition NNP 3237 316 16 Studios Studios NNP 3237 316 17 Pr Pr NNP 3237 316 18 . . NNP 3237 316 19 , , , 3237 316 20 2005 2005 CD 3237 316 21 ) ) -RRB- 3237 316 22 : : : 3237 316 23 159–62 159–62 CD 3237 316 24 . . . 3237 317 1 68 68 CD 3237 317 2 . . . 3237 318 1 Yu Yu NNP 3237 318 2 - - HYPH 3237 318 3 chen chen NNP 3237 318 4 Hsu Hsu NNP 3237 318 5 , , , 3237 318 6 “ " `` 3237 318 7 The the DT 3237 318 8 Long Long NNP 3237 318 9 - - HYPH 3237 318 10 Term Term NNP 3237 318 11 Effects Effects NNPS 3237 318 12 of of IN 3237 318 13 Integral Integral NNP 3237 318 14 Versus Versus NNP 3237 318 15 Composite Composite NNP 3237 318 16 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 318 17 on on IN 3237 318 18 Experts expert NNS 3237 318 19 ’ ' '' 3237 318 20 and and CC 3237 318 21 Novices Novices NNPS 3237 318 22 ’ ’ POS 3237 318 23 Search Search NNP 3237 318 24 Behav- Behav- NNP 3237 318 25 iors ior NNS 3237 318 26 , , , 3237 318 27 ” " '' 3237 318 28 Interacting interact VBG 3237 318 29 with with IN 3237 318 30 Computers computer NNS 3237 318 31 17 17 CD 3237 318 32 ( ( -LRB- 3237 318 33 2005 2005 CD 3237 318 34 ) ) -RRB- 3237 318 35 : : : 3237 318 36 391 391 CD 3237 318 37 . . . 3237 319 1 69 69 CD 3237 319 2 . . . 3237 320 1 Gerald Gerald NNP 3237 320 2 Khoury Khoury NNP 3237 320 3 and and CC 3237 320 4 Simeon Simeon NNP 3237 320 5 Simoff Simoff NNP 3237 320 6 , , , 3237 320 7 “ " `` 3237 320 8 Elastic elastic JJ 3237 320 9 Metaphors Metaphors NNPS 3237 320 10 : : : 3237 320 11 Expanding expand VBG 3237 320 12 the the DT 3237 320 13 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 3237 320 14 of of IN 3237 320 15 Interface Interface NNP 3237 320 16 Design Design NNP 3237 320 17 ” " '' 3237 320 18 in in IN 3237 320 19 Selected Selected NNP 3237 320 20 Papers Papers NNP 3237 320 21 from from IN 3237 320 22 Conference Conference NNP 3237 320 23 on on IN 3237 320 24 Computers Computers NNPS 3237 320 25 and and CC 3237 320 26 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 3237 320 27 , , , 3237 320 28 ed ed NN 3237 320 29 . . . 3237 321 1 John John NNP 3237 321 2 Weckert Weckert NNP 3237 321 3 and and CC 3237 321 4 Yeslam Yeslam NNP 3237 321 5 Al Al NNP 3237 321 6 - - HYPH 3237 321 7 Saggaf Saggaf NNP 3237 321 8 , , , 3237 321 9 vol vol NNP 3237 321 10 . . . 3237 322 1 37 37 CD 3237 322 2 of of IN 3237 322 3 ACM ACM NNP 3237 322 4 International International NNP 3237 322 5 Conference Conference NNP 3237 322 6 Proceeding Proceeding NNP 3237 322 7 Series Series NNP 3237 322 8 Volume volume NN 3237 322 9 101 101 CD 3237 322 10 ( ( -LRB- 3237 322 11 Darlinghurst Darlinghurst NNP 3237 322 12 , , , 3237 322 13 Australia Australia NNP 3237 322 14 : : : 3237 322 15 Austra- Austra- NNP 3237 322 16 lian lian NNP 3237 322 17 Computer Computer NNP 3237 322 18 Society Society NNP 3237 322 19 , , , 3237 322 20 2003 2003 CD 3237 322 21 ) ) -RRB- 3237 322 22 : : : 3237 322 23 70 70 CD 3237 322 24 . . .