Inconsistent triad - Wikipedia





	
	

	
	

	Inconsistent triad

	
		From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

		

		

		
		

		Jump to navigation
		Jump to search
			
	This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.
Find sources: "Inconsistent triad" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR  (May 2008) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)



An inconsistent triad consists of three propositions of which at most two can be true. For example:


	Alice loves me.
	If Alice loves me, then she would have sent flowers.
	Alice has not sent flowers.


If one finds oneself believing all three propositions of an inconsistent triad, then (in order to be rational) one must give up or modify at least one of those beliefs. Maybe Alice doesn't love me, or maybe she wouldn't send flowers to me if she did, or maybe she actually has sent flowers.

Any inconsistent triad {A, B, C} gives rise to a trilemma {{A, B}, {B, C}, {C, A}}.


Contents


	1 Perception and objects
	2 The problem of evil
	3 See also
	4 References





Perception and objects[edit]

The dialectical framework for the whole discussion of the problem in the philosophy of perception and the theoretical conception of perceptual experience is set out as an inconsistent triad.[1]


	Physical objects are mind-independent.
	Physical objects are the direct objects of perception.
	The direct objects of perception are mind-dependent.


The first proposition is defended by realist, while is rejected by anti-realist or idealist.


The problem of evil[edit]

Main article: Problem of evil

The problem of evil is often given in the form of an inconsistent triad. For example, J. L. Mackie gave the following three propositions:


	God is omnipotent
	God is omnibenevolent
	Evil exists


Mackie argued that these propositions were inconsistent, and thus, that at least one of these propositions must be false. Either:


	God is omnipotent and omnibenevolent, and evil does not exist.
	God is omnipotent, but not omnibenevolent; thus, evil exists by God's will.
	God is omnibenevolent, but not omnipotent; thus, evil exists, but it is not within God's power to stop it (at least not instantaneously).


Many responses have been made to the problem of evil, including the proposition that evil exists as a consequence of a greater good, such as free will; that evil is an illusion; and that evil is necessary for spiritual growth.


See also[edit]

	Reductio ad absurdum
	Trilemma


References[edit]


	^ Brewer, Bill (2011-03-01). Perception and its Objects. Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199260256.001.0001/acprof-9780199260256. ISBN 9780191725470.





	Howard-Snyder, F., Howard-Snyder, D., & Wasserman, R. (2009). The Power of Logic (4th Edition). New York: McGraw-Hill. (p. 336)  
ISBN 978-0-07-340737-1









Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Inconsistent_triad&oldid=921026055"


		Categories: 	Syllogistic fallacies
	Problem of evil


Hidden categories: 	Articles needing additional references from May 2008
	All articles needing additional references




	




	





	Navigation menu

	
		

	
		Personal tools
	

	
			Not logged in
	Talk
	Contributions
	Create account
	Log in


		
	



		
			

	
		Namespaces
	

	
			Article
	Talk


		
	



			

	
	
		Variants
	

	
		

		
	



		

		
			

	
		Views
	

	
			Read
	Edit
	View history


		
	



			

	
	
		More
	

	
		

		
	



			
	
		Search
	

	
		
			
			
			
			
		

	




		

	

	

	
		
	

	

	
		Navigation
	

	
			Main page
	Contents
	Current events
	Random article
	About Wikipedia
	Contact us
	Donate


		
	



	

	
		Contribute
	

	
			Help
	Learn to edit
	Community portal
	Recent changes
	Upload file


		
	




	
		Tools
	

	
			What links here
	Related changes
	Upload file
	Special pages
	Permanent link
	Page information
	Cite this page
	Wikidata item


		
	




	
		Print/export
	

	
			Download as PDF
	Printable version


		
	



	

	
		Languages
	

	
		

		Add links

	









		 This page was last edited on 13 October 2019, at 11:46 (UTC).
	Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License;
additional terms may apply.  By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization.



		Privacy policy
	About Wikipedia
	Disclaimers
	Contact Wikipedia
	Mobile view
	Developers
	Statistics
	Cookie statement